04. Other Books Authored or permitted by Çréla Prabhupäda Reviews

KÅÑËA BOOK-Introduction
[From undated, typed documents]

Preface

Nibåtta-tarñair upagiya mänäd

Bhavouñadhi satramano’ bhirämät

Kauttama sloka gunänuvädät

Pumän virajyeta vina pasughnät

When someone sees our cover of the book like Kåñëa in these countries, they ask immediately, “WHO IS KÅÑËA? Who is the girl with Kåñëa?” etc.

The immediate answer is that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. How is that? Because He confirms to the exact details of the Supreme Being Godhead. In other words, Kåñëa is Godhead because He is all-attractive, and without being all-attractive there is no meaning of Godhead. How one becomes all-attractive? First of all because of one's great riches. If one is very wealthy, he becomes attractive to the people in general. Similarly if someone is very powerful, he also becomes attractive. If someone is very famous, he also becomes attractive. So if someone is very beautiful, or wise, or unattached to all kinds of possessions, he also becomes attractive. So, by our practical experience, we can know that one is attractive only by his 1. wealth, 2. power, 3. reputation, 4. beauty, 5. wisdom, and 6. renunciation. These are called six opulences, and one who is in possession of all these six opulences at once and unlimitedly, He is understood to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This understanding of the quality of Godhead is vedic version given by Paräsär Muni, a great authority.

We have seen many rich persons, many powerful persons, many famous persons, many beautiful persons, many learned and scholarly persons, and persons in the renounced order of life unattached to material possessions; but we have never seen any one person who is unlimitedly wealthy, powerful, famous, beautiful, wise, and unattached at the same time, like Kåñëa, in the history of the human kind. Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is an historical person because He appeared on this earth 5,000 years ago. He stayed on this earth for full 125 years and played exactly like a human being, but without any parallel. From the very moment of His appearance up to the last point of His disappearance, everything of His activities is unparalleled in the history of the world, and therefore anyone who knows what we mean by Godhead, will accept Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Godhead means that nobody is equal to Him and nobody is greater than Him. That is the import of “God is Great.”

There are various classes of men in the world who speak of God in different ways, but according to Vedic literatures, and according to the great Acaryas, the authorized persons in the knowledge of God, of all ages, like Acarya Samkara, Ramanuja, Madhya, Visnusvami, Lord Caitanya, and all their followers by disciplic succession, unanimously agree to accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So far we, the followers of Vedic civilization, are concerned, we accept the history of the whole universe consisting of different planetary systems called by the names Svargalokas or the higher planetary systems, Martyalokas or the intermediary planetary system, and Pätälalokas or the lower planetary system. Modern historians of the world cannot supply historical evidences beyond three thousand of years, and the anthropologists says that ten thousand years ago there was no human being as the result of gradual process of evolution. The Vedic historical evidences are the Puranas and Mahabarata, and from these books we get history of the human society extending over millions and billions of years.

For example we get the history of Kåñëa’s appearances and disappearances for millions and billions of years ago. In the fourth chapter of the Bhagavad Gita Kåñëa says to Arjuna that both Kåñëa and Arjuna had many births before, and all of them Kåñëa remembered but Arjuna did not. Here is the difference of knowledge of Kåñëa and that of Arjuna. Arjuna may be a great warrior, very cultured, and belonging to the Royal family of the Kuru dynasty, but after all he was an ordinary human being while Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead because of his vast extensive knowledge. As such there is the difference of memory which is part of knowledge.

Kåñëa's knowledge is so perfect that He remembers all incidences of His past appearances some millions and billions of years ago, but Arjuna being an ordinary human being his memory and knowledge is limited by the time and space. Kåñëa remembers His activities in His previous appearance when He instructed the lessons of the Bhagavad Gita some millions of years ago.

It is nowadays, a fasion of the atheistic class of men that they want to become God by following some mystic process. Generally the atheist claims to have become God by meditation of their own imagination. But Kåñëa is not that class of God by manufacturing of such mystic meditational process. He is Godhead without undergoing the severe processes of mystic yogic exercises, He is Godhead in any circumstances.

Just after his appearance within the prison bars of His maternal uncle Kamsa, where His father and mother were interned, He appeared as four-handed Viñëu Narayana without' his mother's body, and then He turned Himself like a baby and dictated His father to carry Him to the house of Nanda Maharaj Yasoda. When He was just a small baby, He was attempted to be killed by the giant Putana, but Kåñëa sucked her breast along with her life. That is the difference between real Godhead and make up God in the mystic factory.

Kåñëa had no chance to practice the mystic process and still He manifested Himself as the Supreme Personality of Godhead in every step of his growth, from being a baby to childhood, from childhood to boyhood, from boyhood to youthhood, and so on. In this book KÅÑËA, all His activities as a human being are described, but at the same time He has maintained His stability as the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

As we have explained above that Kåñëa being all-attractive, one should concentrate one's propensity of being attracted by Kåñëa. In the Bhagavad Gita it is said that the individual person is the proprietor or master of his bodyly construction. But Krsna being the Super-soul present in everyone's heart, He is the Super-proprietor and Super-master of every individual body.

As such, if we concentrate our loving propensities upon Kåñëa only, then immediately the problems of universal love, unity, and tranquillity will be automatically performed as much as watering the root of the tree means watering the branches, twigs, leaves, and flowers of the tree., or supplying foodstuff to the stomach through the proper hole of the body, namely the mouth, satisfies all the different limbs and parts of the body.

To know this art means to become Kåñëa consciousness. We have inaugerated the Kåñëa consciousness movement for this purpose that every one can satisfy his propensity of love for others simply by reposing his love upon Kåñëa. The whole world is very much anxious to satisfy the dormant propensity of love for others, but invention of various methods like socialism, communism, altruism, humanitarianism, nationalism, and everything that we may manufacture for the peace and prosperity of the world, will all become useless and complete frustration because of our gross ignorance of the art of loving Kåñëa.

Generally people think that advancing the cause of moral principles and religious rites, the people will be happy. Another thinks that happiness may be achieved by economic development, and still another thinks that simply by sense gratification people will be happy. But the real fact is that people can only be happy by loving Kåñëa.

Kåñëa can reciprocate perfectly one’s loving propensities saturated in different mellows. There are twelve different Rasas or mellows for reciprocating are porpensity of love for others. You can love Kåñëa as the Supreme unknown, you can love Kåñëa as the Supreme Master, the Supreme Friend, the Supreme child, or the Supreme Lover, primarily. You can love Kåñëa indirectly in seven different mellows which are apparently opposite to the five primary loving principles as above mentioned, but on the whole, if you can simply repose your dormant loving propensity upon Kåñëa, then your life becomes successful.

It is not a fiction, but it is a fact which we can realize by practical application in life and see the result by direct perception.

In the Bhagavad Gita, ninth chapter, this science of Kåñëa Consciousness is explained as the king of all knowledge, the king of all confidential things, the supreme science of transcendental realisation, but at the same time we can directly perceive the result of this Kåñëa consciousness science although it is very easy to practice and it is simply pleasure to act in Kåñëa consciousness. And at last whatever percentage of Kåñëa consciousness you can perform, it becomes an eternal asset of your life, imperishable in all circumstances.

It is now practically experimented how the modern confused and frustrated younger generation of the Western countries practically feeling the result of reposing one's loving propensity upon Krishna only.

It is said that you might have executed severe type of austerities, penances and sacrifices in your life, but if you have failed to awaken your dormant loving propensity for Kåñëa, then all such activities are calculated to have no value. On the other hand, if you have awakened your dormant loving propensity for Kåñëa, then all such activities are calculated to have no value. On the other hand, if you have awakened your dormant loving propensity for Kåñëa, then what is the use of such execution of austerities and penances unnecessary as labor of love.

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is the unique gift of Lord Caitanya to the fallen souls of this age in a very simple method which has practically been experimented during the last four years in the western countries and there is no doubt about it how this movement can satisfy the dormant loving propensities of human kind.

This book Kåñëa is another presentation to help the Kåñëa Consciousness Movement in the western world. This transcendental literature is published in two parts with profuse illustrations in colorful pictures. People love to read various kinds of stories and fictions to enjoy the waste of time and energy. The propensity for reading different kinds of literature can be utilized by reposing it upon Kåñëa, but the result is imperishable satisfaction of the souls both individually and collectively.

It is said in the Bhagavad Gita that a little execution of this Kåñëa Consciousness service can save all from the greatest danger. We can cite hundreds of thousands of such incidences as to how we have escaped from the greatest danger of life even by slight advancement of Kåñëa consciousness life.

We therefore request everyone to take advantage of this great transcendental literature and all will find it practically how even by reading one page to another, one accumulates immense treasure of knowledge in art, science, literature, philosophy and religion and ultimately love of Godhead simply by reading this one book, 'Kåñëa'.

[The following is handwritten:]

My thankful acknowledgement is due to Sriman George Harrison of the Beatles fame for his liberal contribution of $19,000 (nineteen thousand) to meet the entire cost of printing the book KÅÑËA Part one. May Kåñëa enrich this nice boy by more advancement in KÅÑËA consciousness.

And at last my ever willing blessings are bestowed upon Sriman Syamasunder Dasadhikary for strenuous endeavour for publishing the book and upon Sriman Hayagriva Dasadhikary, Sriman Satsvarupa Das Adhikary, Srimati Devahuti Devi, Srimati Jadurani Dasi, Sriman Muralidhar Brahmachary, Sriman Bharadvaj Das Adhikary & Sriman Pradyumna Das Adhikary for their hard labor in different ways to see the publication a great success.

Hare Krsna.

A.C.B.

Advent Day of

Srila Bhakti Siddhanta Sarasvati

L.A. ISKCON H.Q

3764 Watseka Avenue

February 26th, 1970


(Insert following verse to head Preface, page 1)

Nibåtta tarñai rupagéya mänäd

Bhavouñadhi sotramanobhirämät

Kauuttama slokagunänuvädät

Pumän virajjeta vina pasughnät. (pp )



Preface

********************************

(addend the following acknowledgements to conclude the preface on page four)

My thankful acknowledgement is due to Sriman George Harrison of the Beatles fame for his liberal contribution of $19,000 (nineteen thousand) to meet the entire cost of printing the book KÅÑËA Part one. May KÅÑËA enrich this nice boy more advanced in KÅÑËA consciousness.

And at last my ever-willing blessings are bestowed upon Sriman Syamasunder Das Adhikary, Brahmananda Brahmachary, Sriman Hayagriva Das Adhikary, Sriman Satsvarupa Das Adhikary, Srimati Devahuti Devi, Srimati Jadurani Dasi, Sriman Muralidhar Das Brahmachary, Sriman Bharadraj Das Adhikary, and Pradyumna Das Adhikary etc for their hard labor in different ways to see the publication a great success.

Hare Krsna.

A.C.B.

Advent Day of Srila

Bhakti Siddhanta Saresvati

L.A. ISKCON H.Q.

3764 Watseka Avenue

February 26th, 1970

KÅÑËA, The Supreme Personality of Godhead - Volume 1, 1970 Edition

Kb 1970 /Flap intro

Flap:

$8.00 U.S.A.
£3 U.K.

The most comprehensive and authoritative Vedic scriptural literature is the Çrémad-Bhägavatam ("The Beautiful Story of the Personality of Godhead"), the mature contribution of Çréla Vyäsadeva, the compiler of the Vedas. Of the twelve cantos of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the tenth canto is considered the most confidential, since it describes all the transcendental pastimes of Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa is a summary study of the tenth canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

The activities of Kåñëa, which appear to be like those of an ordinary human being, can only be properly understood with the help of a bona fide spiritual master fully realized in the knowledge of this transcendental nature. A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada is authorized by an unbreakable disciplic succession of spiritual masters going back thousands of years to the time when Kåñëa appeared. Because he is the representative of the disciplic succession for this age and because of his complete immersion in love of Kåñëa Prabhupäda is uniquely qualified to present Kåñëa as He is.

Çukadeva Gosvämé, the original speaker of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, has declared that there are three classes of men and that the pastimes of Kåñëa will be relished by each of them. The liberated soul who is no longer interested in mundane topics most certainly hears about Kåñëa with the highest pleasure. The person who is trying to become liberated will also enjoy these topics of the Personality of Godhead, which purify anyone who hears them.

And even the gross materialist will enjoy hearing about Kåñëa because of the resemblance between His affairs with the gopis and the loving affairs of ordinary boys and girls.

Forseeing the publication of this book, with its fifty-eight full-color illustrations, Prabhupäda commented, "No other religion has such a full concept of God. I think our Kåñëa book will convince them. Whoever reads it will become a devotee of Kåñëa."

With Introductory note by George Harrison


Not for sale in India


OTHER BOOKS by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam
(12 volumes)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
The Nectar of Devotion
Çré Éçopaniñad
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
The First Step in God Realization
Back to Godhead Magazine
(Editor)


A Summary Study of Çréla Vyäsadeva's Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto.


ISKCON PRESS
38 North Beacon Street
Boston, Massachusetts 02134


Copyright© 1970 A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
Library of Congress Catalogue Card Number: 74-118081
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Printed by Dai Nippon Printing Co., Ltd. in Japan

Kb 1970 / To My Father, Gour Mohon De (1849-1930)

To My Father, Gour Mohon De (1849-1930)

a pure devotee of Kåñëa, who raised me as a Kåñëa conscious child from the beginning of my life. In my boyhood ages he instructed me how to play the mådanga. He gave me Rädhä-Kåñëa Vigraha to worship, and he gave me Jagannätha-Ratha to duly observe the festival as my childhood play. He was kind to me, and I imbibed from him the ideas later on solidified by my spiritual master, the eternal father.

Kb 1970 / Words from Apple

Words From Apple

Everybody is looking for KÅÑËA.

Some don't realize that they are, but they are.

KÅÑËA is GOD, the Source of all that exists, the Cause of all that is, was, or ever will be.

As GOD is unlimited, HE has many Names.

Allah-Buddha-Jehova-Rama: All are KÅÑËA, all are ONE.

God is not abstract; He has both the impersonal and the personal aspects to His personality which is SUPREME, ETERNAL, BLISSFUL, and full of KNOWLEDGE. As a single drop of water has the same qualities as an ocean of water, so has our consciousness the qualities of GOD'S consciousness ... but through our identification and attachment with material energy (physical body, sense pleasures, material possessions, ego, etc.) our true TRANSCENDENTAL CONSCIOUSNESS has been polluted, and like a dirty mirror it is unable to reflect a pure image.

With many lives our association with the TEMPORARY has grown. This impermanent body, a bag of bones and flesh, is mistaken for our true self, and we have accepted this temporary condition to be final.

Through all ages, great SAINTS have remained as living proof that this non-temporary, permanent state of GOD CONSCIOUSNESS can be revived in all living Souls. Each soul is potentially divine.

Kåñëa says in Bhagavad Gita: "Steady in the Self, being freed from all material contamination, the yogi achieves the highest perfectional stage of happiness in touch with the Supreme Consciousness." (VI, 28)

YOGA (a scientific method for GOD (SELF) realization) is the process by which we purify our consciousness, stop further pollution, and arrive at the state of Perfection, full KNOWLEDGE, full BLISS.

If there's a God, I want to see Him. It's pointless to believe in something without proof, and Kåñëa Consciousness and meditation are methods where you can actually obtain GOD perception. You can actually see God, and hear Him, play with Him. It might sound crazy, but He is actually there, actually with you.

There are many yogic Paths—Raja, Jnana, Hatha, Kriya, Karma, Bhakti—which are all acclaimed by the MASTERS of each method.

SWAMI BHAKTIVEDANTA is as his title says, a BHAKTI Yogi following the path of DEVOTION. By serving GOD through each thought, word, and DEED, and by chanting of HIS Holy Names, the devotee quickly develops God-consciousness. By chanting

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa
Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare
Hare Räma, Hare Räma
Räma Räma, Hare Hare

one inevitably arrives at KÅÑËA Consciousness. (The proof of the pudding is in the eating!)

I request that you take advantage of this book KÅÑËA, and enter into its understanding. I also request that you make an appointment to meet your God now, through the self liberating process of YOGA (UNION) and GIVE PEACE A CHANCE.


(hand written)

All you need is Love (Krishna) Hari Bol.

George Harrison 31/3/70


Apple Corps Ltd 3 Savile Row London W1 Gerrard 2771/3993 Telex Apcore London


Kb 1970 / Preface

Preface

nivåtta-tarñair upagéyamänäd
bhavauñadhäc chrotramano’ bhirämät
ka uttama-çloka-guëänuvädät
pumän virajyeta vinä paçughnät
(Çrémad-Bhägavatam 10.1.4)

In these Western countries, when someone sees the cover of a book like Kåñëa, he immediately asks, “Who is Kåñëa? Who is the girl with Kåñëa?” etc.

The immediate answer is that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. How is that? Because He conforms in exact detail to descriptions of the Supreme Being, the Godhead. In other words, Kåñëa is the Godhead because He is all-attractive. Outside the principle of all-attraction, there is no meaning to the word Godhead. How is it one can be all-attractive? First of all, if one is very wealthy, if he has great riches, he becomes attractive to the people in general. Similarly, if someone is very powerful, he also becomes attractive, and if someone is very famous, he also becomes attractive, and if someone is very beautiful or wise or unattached to all kinds of possessions, he also becomes attractive. So from practical experience we can observe that one is attractive due to 1) wealth, 2) power, 3) fame, 4) beauty, 5) wisdom, and 6) renunciation. One who is in possession of all six of these opulences at the same time, who possesses them to an unlimited degree, is understood to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead. These opulences of the Godhead are delineated by Paräçara Muni, a great Vedic authority.

We have seen many rich persons, many powerful persons, many famous persons, many beautiful persons, many learned and scholarly persons, and persons in the renounced order of life unattached to material possessions. But we have never seen any one person who is unlimitedly and simultaneously wealthy, powerful, famous, beautiful, wise and unattached, like Kåñëa, in the history of humanity. Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is an historical person who appeared on this earth 5,000 years ago. He stayed on this earth for 125 years and played exactly like a human being, but His activities were unparalleled. From the very moment of His appearance to the moment of His disappearance, every one of His activities is unparalleled in the history of the world, and therefore anyone who knows what we mean by Godhead will accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. No one is equal to the Godhead, and no one is greater than Him. That is the import of the familiar saying, “God is great.”

There are various classes of men in the world who speak of God in different ways, but according to Vedic literatures and according to the great äcäryas, the authorized persons versed in the knowledge of God, in all ages, like äcäryas Çaìkara, Rämänuja, Madhva, Viñëusvämé, Lord Caitanya and all their followers by disciplic succession, all unanimously agree that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As far as we, the followers of Vedic civilization, are concerned, we accept the Vedic history of the whole universe, which consists of different planetary systems called Svargalokas, or the higher planetary system, Martyalokas, or the intermediary planetary system, and Pätälalokas, or the lower planetary system. The modern historians of this earth cannot supply historical evidences of events that occurred before 5,000 years ago, and the anthropologists say that 40,000 years ago Homo sapiens had not appeared on this planet because evolution had not reached that point. But the Vedic histories, the Puräëas and Mahäbhärata, relate human histories which extend millions and billions of years into the past.

For example, from these literatures we are given the histories of Kåñëa’s appearances and disappearances millions and billions of years ago. In the Fourth Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä [4.5] Kåñëa tells Arjuna that both He and Arjuna had had many births before and that He (Kåñëa) could remember all of them and that Arjuna could not. This illustrates the difference between the knowledge of Kåñëa and that of Arjuna. Arjuna might have been a very great warrior, a well-cultured member of the Kuru dynasty, but after all, he was an ordinary human being, whereas Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is the possessor of unlimited knowledge. Because He possesses unlimited knowledge, Kåñëa has a memory that is boundless.

Kåñëa's knowledge is so perfect that He remembers all the incidences of His appearances some millions and billions of years in the past, but Arjuna’s memory and knowledge are limited by time and space, for he is an ordinary human being. In the Fourth Chapter Kåñëa states that He can remember instructing the lessons of the Bhagavad-gétä [4.1] some millions of years ago to the sun-god, Vivasvän.

Nowadays it is the fashion of the atheistic class of men to try to become God by following some mystic process. Generally the atheists claim to be God by dint of their imagination or their meditational prowess. Kåñëa is not that kind of God. He does not become God by manufacturing some mystic process of meditation, nor does He become God by undergoing the severe austerities of the mystic yogic exercises. Properly speaking, He never becomes God because He is the Godhead in all circumstances.

Within the prison of His maternal uncle Kaàsa, where His father and mother were confined, Kåñëa appeared outside His mother’s body as the four-handed Viñëu-Näräyaëa. Then He turned Himself into a baby and told His father to carry Him to the house of Nanda Mahäräja and his wife Yaçodä. When Kåñëa was just a small baby the gigantic demoness Pütanä attempted to kill Him, but when He sucked her breast He pulled out her life. That is the difference between the real Godhead and a God manufactured in the mystic factory. Kåñëa had no chance to practice the mystic yoga process, yet He manifested Himself as the Supreme Personality of Godhead at every step, from infancy to childhood, from childhood to boyhood, and from boyhood to young manhood. In this book Kåñëa, all of His activities as a human being are described. Although Kåñëa plays like a human being, He always maintains His identity as the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Since Kåñëa is all-attractive, one should know that all his desires should be focused on Kåñëa. In the Bhagavad-gétä [13.1-3] it is said that the individual person is the proprietor or master of the body, but Krsna, who is the Supersoul present in everyone's heart, is the supreme proprietor and supreme master of each and every individual body. As such, if we concentrate our loving propensities upon Kåñëa only, then immediately universal love, unity and tranquility will be automatically realized. When one waters the root of a tree, he automatically waters the branches, twigs, leaves and flowers; when one supplies food to the stomach through the mouth, he satisfies all the various parts of the body.

The art of focusing one’s attention on the Supreme and giving one’s love to Him is called Kåñëa consciousness. We have inaugerated the Kåñëa consciousness movement so that everyone can satisfy his propensity for loving others simply by directing his love towards Kåñëa. The whole world is very much anxious to satisfy the dormant propensity of love for others, but the inventions of various methods like socialism, communism, altruism, humanitarianism, nationalism, and whatever else may be manufactured for the peace and prosperity of the world, are all useless and frustrating because of our gross ignorance of the art of loving Kåñëa. Generally people think that by advancing the cause of moral principles and religious rites, they will be happy. Others may think that happiness can be achieved by economic development, and yet others think that simply by sense gratification they will be happy. But the real fact is that people can only be happy by loving Kåñëa.

Kåñëa can perfectly reciprocate one’s loving propensities in different relationships called mellows or rasas. Basically there are twelve loving relationships. One can love Kåñëa as the supreme unknown, as the supreme master, the supreme friend, the supreme child, the supreme lover. These are the five basic love rasas. One can also love Kåñëa indirectly in seven different relationships, which are apparently different from the five primary relationships. All in all, however, if one simply reposes his dormant loving propensity in Kåñëa, then his life becomes successful. This is not a fiction but is a fact that can be realized by practical application. One can directly perceive the effects that love for Kåñëa has on his life.

In the Ninth Chapter [9.2] of the Bhagavad-gétä this science of Kåñëa consciousness is called the king of all knowledge, the king of all confidential things, and the supreme science of transcendental realization. Yet we can directly experience the results of this science of Kåñëa consciousness because it is very easy to practice and is very pleasurable. Whatever percentage of Kåñëa consciousness we can perform will become an eternal asset to our life, for it is imperishable in all circumstances. It has now been actually proved that today’s confused and frustrated younger generation in the Western countries can directly perceive the results of chanelling the loving propensity toward Kåñëa alone.

It is said that although one executes severe austerities, penances and sacrifices in his life, if he fails to awaken his dormant love for Kåñëa, then all his penances are to be considered useless. On the other hand, if one has awakened his dormant love for Kåñëa, then what is the use in executing austerities and penances unnecessarily?

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is the unique gift of Lord Caitanya to the fallen souls of this age. It is a very simple method which has actually been carried out during the last four years in the Western countries, and there is no doubt that this movement can satisfy the dormant loving propensities of humanity. This book Kåñëa is another presentation to help the Kåñëa consciousness movement in the Western world. This transcendental literature is published in two parts with profuse illustrations. People love to read various kinds of fiction to spend their time and energy. Now this tendency can be directed to Kåñëa. The result will be the imperishable satisfaction of the soul, both individually and collectively.

It is said in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.40] that even a little effort expended on the path of Kåñëa consciousness can save one from the greatest danger. Hundreds of thousands of examples can be cited of people who have escaped the greatest dangers of life due to a slight advancement in Kåñëa consciousness. We therefore request everyone to take advantage of this great transcendental literature. One will find that by reading one page after another, an immense treasure of knowledge in art, science, literature, philosophy and religion will be revealed, and ultimately, by reading this one book, Kåñëa, love of Godhead will fructify.

My grateful acknowledgement is due to Çrémän George Harrison, now chanting Hare Kåñëa, for his liberal contribution of $19,000 to meet the entire cost of printing this volume. May Kåñëa bestow upon this nice boy further advancement in Kåñëa consciousness.

And at last my ever-willing blessings are bestowed upon Çrémän Çyämasundaradäsa Adhikäré, Çrémän Brahmänandadäsa Brahmacäré, Çrémän Hayagrévadäsa Adhikäré, Çrémän Satsvarüpadäsa Adhikäré, Çrématé Devahüti Devé, Çrématé Jaduräëé Däsé, Çrémän Muralédharadäsa Brahmacäré, Çrémän Bhäradväjadäsa Adhikäré, and Çrémän Pradyumnadäsa Adhikäré, etc., for their hard labor in different ways to make this publication a great success.

Hare Kåñëa.

Advent Day of
Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté


February 26th, 1970
ISKCON Headquarters
3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California

Kb 1970 / Introduction by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Introduction

Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! he!
Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! he!
Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! rakña mäm!
Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! Kåñëa! pähi mäm!
Räma! Räghava! Räma! Räghava! Räma! Räghava! rakña mäm!
Kåñëa! Keçava! Kåñëa! Keçava! Kåñëa! Keçava! pähi mäm!

Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 7.96)

While attempting to write this book, Kåñëa, let me first offer my respectful obeisances unto my spiritual master, Om Viñëupäda 108 Çré Çrémad Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Mahäräja Prabhupäda. Then let me offer my respectful obeisances to the ocean of mercy, Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya Mahäprabhu. He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa Himself, appearing in the role of a devotee just to distribute the highest principles of devotional service. Lord Caitanya began His preaching from the country known as Gauòadeça (West Bengal). And as I belong to the Mädhva-Gauòéya-sampradäya, I must therefore offer my respectful obeisances to our disciplic succession. This Mädhva-Gauòéya-sampradäya is also known as Brahma-sampradäya because the disciplic succession originally began from Brahmä. Brahmä instructed the sage Närada, Närada instructed Vyäsadeva, and Vyäsadeva instructed Madhva Muni or Madhväcärya. Mädhavendra Puré, the originator of Mädhva-Gauòéya-sampradäya, belonged to the Madhväcärya disciplic succession; he had many renowned disciples both in the sannyäsa (renounced) and household orders of life, disciples such as Nityänanda Prabhu, Advaita Prabhu and Éçvara Puré. Éçvara Puré happened to be the spiritual master of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. So let us offer our respectful obeisances to Éçvara Puré, Nityänanda Prabhu, Çré Advaita Äcärya Prabhu, Çréväsa Paëòit and Çré Gadädhara Paëòit. Next, let us offer our respectful obeisances to Svarüpa-Dämodara, who acted as the private secretary to Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu; and let us offer our respectful obeisances to Çré Väsudeva Datta and the constant attendant of Lord Caitanya, Çré Govinda, and the constant friend of Lord Caitanya, Mukunda, and also to Muräri Gupta. And let us offer our respectful obeisances to the six Gosvämés of Våndävana, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé and Çré Raghunätha Däsa Gosvämé.

Kåñëa Himself has explained in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.7] that He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Whenever there are discrepancies in the regulative principles of man's religious life and a prominence of irreligious activities, He appears on this earthly planet. In other words, when Lord Çré Kåñëa appeared, there was a necessity of minimizing the load of sinful activities accumulated on this planet, or in this universe. For affairs of the material creation, Lord Mahä-Viñëu, the plenary portion of Kåñëa, is in charge.

When the Lord descends, the incarnation emanates from Viñëu. Mahä-Viñëu is the original cause of material creation, and from Him Garbhodakaçäyi-Viñëu expands, and then Kñérodakaçäyé-Viñëu. Generally, all the incarnations appearing within this material universe are plenary expansions from Kñérodakaçäyi-Viñëu. Therefore, the business of minimizing the overload of sinful activities on this earth does not belong to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa Himself. But when Kåñëa appears, all the Viñëu expansions also join with Him. Kåñëa's different expansions, namely Näräyaëa, the quadrupal expansion of Väsudeva, Saìkarñaëa, Pradyumna and Aniruddha, as well as the partial plenary expansion of Matsya or the incarnation of fish, and other yuga-avatäras (incarnations for the millennium), and the manvantara-avatäras, the incarnations of Manus—all combine together and appear with the body of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa is the complete whole, and all plenary expansions and incarnations always live with Him.

When Kåñëa appeared, Lord Viñëu was also with Him. Kåñëa actually appears to demonstrate His Våndävana pastimes and to attract the fortunate conditioned souls and invite them back home, back to Godhead. The killing of the demons was simultaneous to His Våndävana activities and was carried out only by the Viñëu portion of Kåñëa.

In the Bhagavad-gétä, Eighth Chapter, 20th verse, it is stated that there is another eternal nature, the spiritual sky, which is transcendental to this manifested and nonmanifested matter. The manifested world can be seen in the form of many stars and planetary systems, such as the sun, moon, etc., but beyond this there is a nonmanifested portion which is not approachable to anyone in this body. And beyond that nonmanifested matter there is the spiritual kingdom. That kingdom is described in the Bhagavad-gétä as supreme and eternal. It is never annihilated. This material nature is subjected to repeated creation and annihilation. But that part, the spiritual nature, remains as it is, eternally.

The supreme abode of the Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is also described in the Brahmä-saàhitä as the abode of cintämaëi. That abode of Lord Kåñëa known as Goloka Våndävana is full of palaces made of touchstone. There the trees are called desire trees, and the cows are called surabhi. The Lord is served there by hundreds and thousands of goddesses of fortune. His name is Govinda, the Primeval Lord, and He is the cause of all causes. There the Lord plays His flute, His eyes are like lotus petals, and the color of His body is like that of a beautiful cloud. On His head is a peacock feather. He is so attractive that He excels thousands of cupids. Lord Kåñëa gives only a little hint in the Gétä of His personal abode which is the supermost planet in the spiritual kingdom. But in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Kåñëa actually appears with all His paraphernalia and demonstrates His activities in Våndävana, then at Mathurä, and then at Dvärakä. The subject matter of this book will gradually reveal all these activities.

The family in which Kåñëa appeared is called the Yadu dynasty. This Yadu dynasty belongs to the family descending from Soma, the god in the moon planet. There are two different kñatriya families of the royal order, one descending from the king of the moon planet and the other descending from the king of the sun planet. Whenever the Supreme Personality of Godhead appears, He generally appears in a kñatriya family because He has to establish religious principles or the life of righteousness. The kñatriya family is the protector of the human race, according to the Vedic system. When the Supreme Personality of Godhead appeared as Lord Rämacandra, He appeared in the family descending from the sun-god, known as Raghu-vaàça; and when He appeared as Lord Kåñëa, He did so in the family of Yadu-vaàça. There is a long list of the kings of the Yadu-vaàça in the Ninth Canto, 24th chapter of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. All of them were great powerful kings. Kåñëa's father's name was Vasudeva, son of Çürasena, descending from the Yadu dynasty. Actually, the Supreme Personality of Godhead does not belong to any dynasty of this material world, but the family in which the Supreme Personality of Godhead appears becomes famous, by His grace. For example, sandalwood is produced in the states of Malaya. Sandalwood has its own qualifications apart from Malaya, but because, accidently, this wood is mainly produced in the states of Malaya, it is known as Malayan sandalwood. Similarly, Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead belongs to everyone, but just as the sun rises from the east, although there are other directions from which it could rise, so, by His own choice, the Lord appears in a particular family, and that family becomes famous.

When Kåñëa appears, all His plenary expansions also appear with Him. Kåñëa appeared along with Balaräma (Baladeva), who is known as His elder brother. Balaräma is the origin of Saìkarñaëa, of the quadrupal expansion. Balaräma is also the plenary expansion of Kåñëa. In this book, the attempt will be made to show how Kåñëa appeared in the family of the Yadu dynasty and how He displayed His transcendental characteristics. This is very vividly described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam—specifically, the Tenth Canto—and the basis of this book will be Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

The pastimes of the Lord are generally heard and relished by liberated souls. Those who are conditioned souls are interested in reading fictional stories of the material activities of some common man. Narrations describing the transcendental activities of the Lord are found in Çrémad-Bhägavatam and other Puräëas. But, the conditioned souls still prefer to study ordinary narrations. They are not so interested in studying the narrations of the pastimes of the Lord, Kåñëa. And yet, the descriptions of the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa are so attractive that they are relishable for all classes of men. There are three classes of men in this world. One class consists of liberated souls, another consists of those who are trying to be liberated, and the third consists of materialistic men. Whether one is liberated or is trying to be liberated, or is even grossly materialistic, the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa are worth studying.

Liberated souls have no interest in materialistic activities. The impersonalist theory that after liberation one becomes inactive and needs hear nothing does not prove that a liberated person is actually inactive. A living soul cannot be inactive. He is either active in the conditioned state or in the liberated state. A diseased person, for example, is also active, but his activities are all painful. The same person, when freed from the diseased condition, is still active, but in the healthy condition the activities are full of pleasure. Similarly, the impersonalists manage to get freed from the diseased conditional activities, but they have no information of activities in the healthy condition. Those who are actually liberated and in full knowledge take to hearing the activities of Kåñëa; such engagement is pure spiritual activity.

It is essential for persons who are actually liberated to hear about the pastimes of Kåñëa. That is the supreme relishable subject matter for one in the liberated state. Also, if persons who are trying to be liberated hear such narrations as Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, then their path of liberation becomes very clear. Bhagavad-gétä is the preliminary study of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. By studying the Gétä, one becomes fully conscious of the position of Lord Kåñëa; and when he is situated at the lotus feet of Kåñëa, he understands the narrations of Kåñëa as described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Lord Caitanya has therefore advised His followers that their business is to propagate Kåñëa-kathä.

Kåñëa-kathä means narrations about Kåñëa. There are two Kåñëa-kathäs: narrations spoken by Kåñëa and narrations spoken about Kåñëa. Bhagavad-gétä is the narration or the philosophy or the science of God, spoken by Kåñëa Himself. Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the narration about the activities and transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa. Both are Kåñëa-kathä. It is the order of Lord Caitanya that Kåñëa-kathä should be spread all over the world, because if the conditioned souls, suffering under the pangs of material existence, take to Kåñëa-kathä, then their path of liberation will be open and clear. The purpose of presenting this book is primarily to induce people to understand Kåñëa or Kåñëa-kathä, because thereby they can become freed from material bondage.

This Kåñëa-kathä will also be very much appealing to the most materialistic persons because Kåñëa's pastimes with the gopés (cowherd girls) are exactly like the loving affairs between young girls and boys within this material world. Actually, the sex feeling found in human society is not unnatural because this same sex feeling is there in the original Personality of Godhead. The pleasure potency is called Çrématé Rädhäräëé. The attraction of loving affairs on the basis of sex feeling is the original feature of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and we, the conditioned souls, being part and parcel of the Supreme, have such feelings also, but they are experienced within a perverted, minute condition. Therefore, when those who are after sex life in this material world hear about Kåñëa's pastimes with the gopés, they will relish transcendental pleasure, although it appears to be materialistic. The advantage will be that they will gradually be elevated to the spiritual platform. In the Bhägavatam it is stated that if one hears the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa with the gopés from authorities with submission, then he will be promoted to the platform of transcendental loving service to the Lord, and the material disease of lust within his heart will be completely vanquished. In other words, it will counteract the material sex life.

Kåñëa will be appealing to the liberated souls and to persons who are trying to be liberated, as well as to the gross, conditioned materialist. According to the statement of Mahäräja Parékñit, who heard about Kåñëa from Çukadeva Gosvämé, Kåñëa-kathä is equally applicable to every human being, in whatever condition of life he is in. Everyone will appreciate it to the highest magnitude. But Mahäräja Parékñit also warned that persons who are simply engaged in killing animals and in killing themselves may not be very much attracted to Kåñëa-kathä. In other words, ordinary persons who are following the regulative moral principles of scriptures, no matter in what condition they are found, will certainly be attracted, but not persons who are killing themselves. The exact word used in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.1.4] is paçughna, which means killing animals or killing oneself. Persons who are not self-realized and who are not interested in spiritual realization are killing themselves; they are committing suicide. Because this human form of life is especially meant for self-realization, by neglecting this important part of his activities, one simply wastes his time like the animals. So he is paçughna. The other meaning of the word refers to those who are actually killing animals. This means persons who are animal eaters (even dog eaters), and they are all engaged in killing animals in so many ways, such as hunting, opening slaughterhouses, etc. Such persons cannot be interested in Kåñëa-kathä.

King Parékñit was especially interested in hearing Kåñëa-kathä because he knew that his forefathers and particularly his grandfather, Arjuna, were victorious in the great battle of Kurukñetra only because of Kåñëa. We may also take this material world as a battlefield of Kurukñetra. Everyone is struggling hard for existence in this battlefield, and at every step there is danger. According to Mahäräja Parékñit, the battlefield of Kurukñetra was just like a vast ocean full of dangerous animals. His grandfather Arjuna had to fight with such great heroes as Bhéñma, Droëa, Karëa, and many others who were not ordinary fighters. Such warriors have been compared to the timiìgila fish in the ocean. The timiìgila fish can very easily swallow up big whales. The great fighters on the battlefield of Kurukñetra could swallow many, many Arjunas very easily, but simply due to Kåñëa's mercy, Arjuna was able to kill all of them. Just as one can cross with no exertion over the little pit of water contained in the hoofprint of a calf, so Arjuna, by the grace of Kåñëa, was able to very easily jump over the ocean of the battle of Kurukñetra.

Mahäräja Parékñit very much appreciated Kåñëa's activities for many other reasons. Not only was his grandfather saved by Kåñëa, but he himself also was saved by Kåñëa. At the end of the battle of Kurukñetra, all the members of the Kuru dynasty, both the sons and grandsons on the side of Dhåtaräñöra, as well as those on the side of the Päëòavas, died in the fighting. Except the five Päëòava brothers, everyone died on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. Mahäräja Parékñit was at that time within the embryo of his mother. His father, Abhimanyu, the son of Arjuna, also died on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, and so Mahäräja Parékñit was a posthumous child. When he was in the womb of his mother, a brahmästra weapon was released by Açvatthämä to kill the child. When Parékñit Mahäräja's mother, Uttarä, approached Kåñëa, Kåñëa, seeing the danger of abortion, entered her womb as the Supersoul and saved Mahäräja Parékñit. Mahäräja Parékñit's other name is Viñëuräta because he was saved by Lord Viñëu Himself while still within the womb.

Thus everyone, in any condition of life, should be interested in hearing about Kåñëa and His activities because He is the Supreme Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead. He is all-pervading; He is living within everyone's heart, and He is living as His universal form. And yet, as described in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.6], He appears as He is in the human society just to invite everyone to His transcendental abode, back to home, back to Godhead. Everyone should be interested in knowing about Kåñëa, and this book is presented with this purpose: that people may know about Kåñëa and be perfectly benefitted in this human form of life.

In the Ninth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çré Baladeva is described as the son of Rohiëé, a wife of Vasudeva. Vasudeva, the father of Kåñëa, had sixteen wives, and one of them was Rohiëé, the mother of Balaräma. But Balaräma is also described as the son of Devaké, so how could He be the son of both Devaké and Rohiëé? This was one of the questions put by Mahäräja Parékñit to Çukadeva Gosvämé, and it will be answered in due course. Mahäräja Parékñit also asked Çukadeva Gosvämé why Çré Kåñëa, just after His appearance as the son of Vasudeva, was immediately carried to the house of Nanda Mahäräja in Våndävana, Gokula. He also wanted to know what the activities of Lord Kåñëa were while He was in Våndävana and while He was in Mathurä. Besides that, he was especially inquisitive to know why Kåñëa killed His maternal uncle, Kaàsa. Kaàsa, being the brother of His mother, was a very intimate superior to Kåñëa, so how was it that He killed Kaàsa? Also, he asked how many years Lord Kåñëa remained in human society, how many years He reigned over the kingdom of Dvärakä, and how many wives He accepted there. A kñatriya king is generally accustomed to accept more than one wife; therefore Mahäräja Parékñit also inquired about His number of wives. The subject matter of this book is Çukadeva Gosvämé's answering of these and other questions asked by Mahäräja Parékñit.

The position of Mahäräja Parékñit and Çukadeva Gosvämé is unique. Mahäräja Parékñit is the right person to hear about the transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa, and Çukadeva Gosvämé is the right person to describe them. If such a fortunate combination is made possible, then Kåñëa-kathä immediately becomes revealed, and people may benefit to the highest possible degree from such a conversation.

This narration was presented by Çukadeva Gosvämé when Mahäräja Parékñit was prepared to give up his body, fasting on the bank of the Ganges. In order to assure Çukadeva Gosvämé that by hearing Kåñëa-kathä he would not feel tired, Mahäräja Parékñit expressed himself very frankly: "Hunger and thirst may give trouble to ordinary persons or to me, but the topics of Kåñëa are so nice that one can continue to hear about them without feeling tired because such hearing situates one in the transcendental position." It is understood that one must be very fortunate to hear about Kåñëa-kathä seriously, like Mahäräja Parékñit. He was especially intent on the subject matter because he was expecting death at any moment. Every one of us should be conscious of death at every moment. This life is not at all assured; at any time one can die. It does not matter whether one is a young man or an old man. So before death takes place, we must be fully Kåñëa conscious.

At the point of his death, King Parékñit was hearing Çrémad-Bhägavatam from Çukadeva Gosvämé. When King Parékñit expressed his untiring desire to hear about Kåñëa, Çukadeva Gosvämé was very pleased. Çukadeva was the greatest of all Bhägavata reciters, and thus he began to speak about Kåñëa's pastimes, which destroy all inauspiciousness in this age of Kali. Çukadeva Gosvämé thanked the King for his eagerness to hear about Kåñëa, and he encouraged him by saying, "My dear King, your intelligence is very keen because you are so eager to hear about the pastimes of Kåñëa." He informed Mahäräja Parékñit that hearing and chanting of the pastimes of Kåñëa are so auspicious that the process purifies the three varieties of men involved: he who recites the transcendental topics of Kåñëa, he who hears such topics, and he who inquires about Him. These pastimes are just like the Ganges water which flows from the toe of Lord Viñëu: they purify the three worlds, the upper, middle and lower planetary systems.

KB 1970-1-1 / Advent of Lord Kåñëa

1 /Advent of Lord Kåñëa

Once the world was overburdened by the unnecessary defense force of different kings, who were actually demons, but were posing themselves as the royal order. At that time, the whole world became perturbed, and the predominating deity of this earth, known as Bhümi, went to see Lord Brahmä to tell of her calamaties due to the demoniac kings. Bhümi assumed the shape of a cow and presented herself before Lord Brahmä with tears in her eyes. She was bereaved and was weeping just to invoke the Lord's compassion. She related the calamitous position of the earth, and after hearing this, Lord Brahmä became much aggrieved, and he at once started for the ocean of milk, where Lord Viñëu resides. Lord Brahmä was accompanied by all the demigods headed by Lord Çiva, and Bhümi also followed. Arriving on the shore of the milk ocean, Lord Brahmä began to pacify the Lord Viñëu who formerly saved the earthly planet by assuming the transcendental form of a boar.

In the Vedic mantras, there is a particular type of prayer called Puruña-sükta. Generally, the demigods offer their obeisances unto Viñëu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, by chanting the Puruña-sükta. It is understood herein that the predominating deity of every planet can see the supreme lord of this universe, Brahmä, whenever there is some disturbance in his planet. And Brahmä can approach the Supreme Lord Viñëu, not by seeing Him directly, but by standing on the shore of the ocean of milk. There is a planet within this universe called Çvetadvépa, and on that planet there is an ocean of milk. It is understood from various Vedic literatures that just as there is the ocean of salt water within this planet, there are various kinds of oceans in other planets. Somewhere there is an ocean of milk, somewhere there is an ocean of oil, and somewhere there is an ocean of liquor and many other types of oceans. Puruña-sükta is the standard prayer which the demigods recite to appease the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kñérodakaçäyé-Viñëu. Because He is lying on the ocean of milk, He is called Kñérodakaçäyé-Viñëu. He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, through whom all the incarnations within this universe appear.

After all the demigods offered the Puruña-sükta prayer to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, they apparently heard no response. Then Lord Brahmä personally sat in meditation, and there was a message-transmission from Lord Viñëu to Brahmä. Brahmä then broadcast the message to the demigods. That is the system of receiving Vedic knowledge. The Vedic knowledge is received first by Brahmä from the Supreme Personality of Godhead, through the medium of the heart. As stated in the beginning of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, tene brahma hådä: the transcendental knowledge of the Vedas was transmitted to Lord Brahmä through the heart. Here also, in the same way, only Brahmä could understand the message transmitted by Lord Viñëu, and he broadcast it to the demigods for their immediate action. The message was: the Supreme Personality of Godhead will appear on the earth very soon along with His supreme powerful potencies, and as long as He remains on the earth planet to execute His mission of annihilating the demons and establishing the devotees, the demigods should also remain there to assist Him. They should all immediately take birth in the family of the Yadu dynasty, wherein the Lord will also appear in due course of time.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself, Kåñëa, personally appeared as the son of Vasudeva. Before He appeared, all the demigods, along with their wives, appeared in different pious families in the world just to assist the Lord in executing His mission. The exact word used here is tatpriyärtham, which means the demigods should appear on the earth in order to please the Lord. In other words, any living entity who lives only to satisfy the Lord is a demigod. The demigods were further informed that the plenary portion of Lord Kåñëa, Ananta, who is maintaining the universal planets by extending his millions of hoods, would also appear on earth before Lord Kåñëa's appearance. They were also informed that the external potency of Viñëu (mäyä), with whom all the conditioned souls are enamoured, would also appear just to execute the purpose of the Supreme Lord.

After instructing and pacifying all the demigods, as well as Bhümi, with sweet words, Lord Brahmä, the father of all prajäpatis, or progenitors of universal population, departed for his own abode, the highest material planet, called Brahmaloka.

The leader of the Yadu dynasty, King Çürasena, was ruling over the country known as Mathurä (the district of Mathurä) as well as the district known as Çürasena. On account of the rule of King Çürasena, Mathurä became the capital city of all the kings of the Yadus. Mathurä was also made the capital of the kings of the Yadu dynasty because the Yadus were a very pious family and knew that Mathurä is the place where Lord Çré Kåñëa lives eternally, just as He also lives in Dvärakä.

Once upon a time, Vasudeva, the son of Çürasena, just after marrying Devaké, was going home on his chariot with his newly wedded wife. The father of Devaké, known as Devaka, had contributed a sufficient dowery because he was very affectionate toward his daughter. He had contributed hundreds of chariots completely decorated with gold equipment. At that time, Kaàsa, the son of Ugrasena, in order to please his sister, Devaké, had voluntarily taken the reins of the horses of Vasudeva's chariot and was driving. According to the custom of the Vedic civilization, when a girl is married, the brother takes the sister and brother-in-law to their home. Because the newly married girl may feel too much separation from her father's family, the brother goes with her until she reaches her father-in-law's house. The full dowery contributed by Devaka was as follows: 400 elephants fully decorated with golden garlands, 15,000 decorated horses, and 1800 chariots. He also arranged for two hundred beautiful girls to follow his daughter. The kñatriya system of marriage, still current in India, dictates that when a kñatriya is married, a few dozen of the bride's young girl friends (in addition to the bride) go to the house of the king. The followers of the queen are called maidservants, but actually they act as friends of the queen. This practice is prevalent from time immemorial, traceable at least to the time before the advent of Lord Kåñëa 5,000 years ago. So Vasudeva brought home another two hundred beautiful girls along with his wife.

While the bride and bridegroom were passing along on the chariot, there were different kinds of musical instruments playing to indicate the auspicious moment. There were conchshells, bugles, drums and kettledrums; combined together, they were vibrating a nice concert. The procession was passing very pleasingly, and Kaàsa was driving the chariot, when suddenly there was a miraculous sound vibrated from the sky which especially announced to Kaàsa: "Kaàsa: you are such a fool. You are driving the chariot of your sister and your brother-in-law, but you do not know that the eighth child of this sister will kill you."

Kaàsa was the son of Ugrasena, of the Bhoja dynasty. It is said that Kaàsa was the most demonic of all the Bhoja dynasty kings. Immediately after hearing the prophecy from the sky, he caught hold of Devaké's hair and was just about to kill her with his sword. Vasudeva was astonished at Kaàsa's behavior, and in order to pacify the cruel, shameless brother-in-law, he began to speak as follows, with great reason and evidence. He said, "My dear brother-in-law Kaàsa, you are the most famous king of the Bhoja dynasty, and people know that you are the greatest warrior and a valiant king. How is it that you are so infuriated that you are prepared to kill a woman who is your own sister at this auspicious time of her marriage? Why should you be so much afraid of death? Death is already born along with your birth. From the very day you took your birth, you began to die. Suppose you are twenty-five years old; that means you have already died twenty-five years. Every moment, every second, you are dying. Why then should you be so much afraid of death? Final death is inevitable. You may die either today or in a hundred years; you cannot avoid death. Why should you be so much afraid? Actually, death means annihilation of the present body. As soon as the present body stops functioning and mixes with the five elements of material nature, the living entity within the body accepts another body, according to his present action and reaction. It is just as when a man walks on the street; he puts forward his foot, and when he is confident that his foot is situated on sound ground, he lifts the other foot. In this way, one after another, the body changes and the soul transmigrates. See how the plantworms change from one twig to another so carefully! Similarly, the living entity changes his body as soon as the higher authorities decide on his next body. As long as a living entity is conditioned within this material world, he must take material bodies one after another. His next particular body is offered by the laws of nature, according to the actions and reactions of this life.

"This body is exactly like one of the bodies which we always see in dreams. During our dream of sleep, we create so many bodies according to mental creation. We have seen gold and we have also seen a mountain, so in a dream we can see a golden mountain by combining the two ideas. Sometimes in dreams, we see that we have a body which is flying in the sky, and at that time we completely forget our present body. Similarly, these bodies are changing. When you have one body, you forget the past body. During a dream, we may make contact with so many new kinds of bodies, but when we are awake we forget them all. And actually these material bodies are the creations of our mental activities. But at the present moment we do not recollect our past bodies.

"The nature of the mind is flickering. Sometimes it accepts something, and immediately it rejects the same thing. Accepting and rejecting is the process of the mind in contact with the five objects of sense gratification: form, taste, smell, sound, and touch. In its speculative way, the mind comes in touch with the objects of sense gratification, and when the living entity desires a particular type of body, he gets it. Therefore, the body is an offering by the laws of material nature. The living entity accepts a body and comes out again into the material world to enjoy or suffer according to the construction of the body. Unless we have a particular type of body, we cannot enjoy or suffer according to our mental proclivities inherited from the previous life. The particular type of body is actually offered to us according to our mental condition at the time of death.

"The luminous planets like the sun, moon or the stars reflect themselves in different types of reservoirs, like water, oil or ghee. The reflection moves according to the movement of the reservoir. The reflection of the moon is on the water, and the moving water makes the moon also appear to be moving, but actually the moon is not moving. Similarly, by mental concoction, the living entity attains different kinds of bodies, although actually he has no connection with such bodies. But on account of illusion, being enchanted by the influence of mäyä, the living entity thinks that he belongs to a particular type of body. That is the way of conditioned life. Suppose a living entity is now in a human form of body. He thinks that he belongs to the human community, or a particular country or particular place. He identifies himself in that way and unnecessarily prepares for another body which is not required by him. Such desires and mental concoctions are the cause of different types of body. The covering influence of material nature is so strong that the living entity is satisfied in whatever body he gets, and he identifies with that body with great pleasure. Therefore, I beg to request you not to be overwhelmed by the dictation of your mind and body."

Vasudeva thus requested Kaàsa not to be envious of his newly married sister. One should not be envious of anyone because envy is the cause of fear both in this world and in the next when one is before Yamaräja (the lord of punishment after death). Vasudeva appealed to Kaàsa on behalf of Devaké, stating that she was his younger sister. He also appealed at an auspicious moment, at the time of marriage. A younger sister or brother are supposed to be protected as one's children. "The position is overall so delicate," Vasudeva reasoned, "that if you kill her, it will go against your high reputation."

Vasudeva tried to pacify Kaàsa by good instruction as well as by philosophical discrimination, but Kaàsa was not to be pacified because his association was demoniac. Because of his demoniac associations, he was always a demon, although born in a very high royal family. A demon never cares for any good instruction. He is just like a determined thief: one can give him moral instruction, but it will not be effective. Similarly, those who are demoniac or atheistic by nature can hardly assimilate any good instruction, however authorized it may be. That is the difference between demigod and demon. Those who can accept good instruction and try to live their lives in that way are called demigods, and those who are unable to take such good instruction are called demons. Failing in his attempt to pacify Kaàsa, Vasudeva wondered how he would protect his wife Devaké. When there is imminent danger, an intelligent person should try to avoid the dangerous position as far as possible. But if, in spite of endeavoring by all intelligence, one fails to avoid the dangerous position, there is no fault on his part. One should try his best to execute his duties, but if the attempt fails, he is not at fault.

Vasudeva thought of his wife as follows: "For the present let me save the life of Devaké, then later on, if there are children, I shall see how to save them." He further thought, "If in the future I get a child who can kill Kaàsa—just as Kaàsa is thinking—then both Devaké and the child will be saved because the law of Providence is inconceivable. But now, some way or other, let me save the life of Devaké."

There is no certainty how a living entity contacts a certain type of body, just as there is no certainty how the blazing fire comes in contact with a certain type of wood in the forest. When there is a forest fire, it is experienced that the blazing fire sometimes leaps over one tree and catches another by the influence of the wind. Similarly, a living entity may be very careful and fearful in the matter of executing his duties, but it is still very difficult for him to know what type of body he is going to get in the next life. Mahäräja Bharata was very faithfully executing the duties of self-realization, but by chance he contacted temporary affection for a deer, and he had to accept his next life in the body of a deer.

Vasudeva, after deliberating on how to save his wife, began to speak to Kaàsa with great respect, although Kaàsa was the most sinful man. Sometimes it happens that a most virtuous person like Vasudeva has to flatter a person like Kaàsa, a most vicious person. That is the way of all diplomatic transactions. Although Vasudeva was deeply aggrieved, he presented himself outwardly as cheerful. He addressed the shameless Kaàsa in that way because he was so atrocious. Vasudeva said to Kaàsa, "My dear brother-in-law, please consider that you have no danger from your sister. You are awaiting some danger because you have heard a prophetic voice in the sky. But the danger is to come from the sons of your sister, who are not present now. And who knows? There may or may not be sons in the future. Considering all this, you are safe for the present. Nor is there cause of fear from your sister. If there are any sons born of her, I promise that I shall present all of them to you for necessary action."

Kaàsa knew the value of Vasudeva's word of honor, and he was convinced by his argument. For the time being, he desisted from the heinous killing of his sister. Thus Vasudeva was pleased and praised the decision of Kaàsa. In this way, he returned to his home.

After due course of time, Vasudeva and Devaké gave birth to eight male children, as well as one daughter. When the first son was born, Vasudeva kept his word of honor and immediately brought the child before Kaàsa. It is said that Vasudeva was very much elevated and famous for his word of honor, and he wanted to maintain this fame. Although it was very painful for Vasudeva to hand over the newly born child, Kaàsa was very glad to receive him. But he became a little compassionate with the behavior of Vasudeva. This event is very exemplary. For a great soul like Vasudeva, there is nothing considered to be painful in the course of discharging one's duty. A learned person like Vasudeva carries out his duties without hesitation. On the other hand, a demon like Kaàsa never hesitates in committing any abominable action. It is said, therefore, that a saintly person can tolerate all kinds of miserable conditions of life, a learned man can discharge his duties without awaiting favorable circumstances, a heinous person like Kaàsa can act in any sinful way, and a devotee can sacrifice everything to satisfy the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Kaàsa became satisfied by the action of Vasudeva. He was surprised to see Vasudeva keeping his promise, and being compassionate upon him and pleased, he began to speak as follows: "My dear Vasudeva, you need not present this child to me. I am not in danger from this child. I have heard that the eighth child born of you and Devaké will kill me. Why should I accept this child unnecessarily? You can take him back."

When Vasudeva was returning home with his first-born child, although he was pleased by the behavior of Kaàsa, he could not believe in him because he knew that Kaàsa was uncontrolled. An atheistic person cannot be firm in his word of honor. One who cannot control the senses cannot be steady in his determination. The great politician, Cäëakya Paëòit, said, "Never put your trust in a diplomat or in a woman." Those who are addicted to unrestricted sense gratification can never be truthful, nor can they be trusted with any faith.

At that time the great sage Närada came to Kaàsa. He was informed of Kaàsa's becoming compassionate to Vasudeva and returning his first-born child. Närada was very anxious to accelerate the descent of Lord Kåñëa as soon as possible. He therefore informed Kaàsa that personalities like Nanda Mahäräja and all the cowherd men and girls and the wives of the cowherd men in Våndävana, and, on the other side, Vasudeva, his father Çürasena and all his relatives born in the family of Våñëi of the Yadu Dynasty, were preparing for the appearance of the Lord. Närada warned Kaàsa to be careful of the friends and well-wishers and all the demigods taking birth in those families. Kaàsa and his friends and advisors were all demons. Demons are always afraid of demigods. After being thus informed by Närada about the appearance of the demigods in different families, Kaàsa at once became alert. He understood that since the demigods had already appeared, Lord Viñëu must be coming soon. He at once arrested both his brother-in-law Vasudeva and Devaké and put them behind prison bars.

Within the prison, shackled in iron chains, Vasudeva and Devaké gave birth to a male child year after year, and Kaàsa, thinking each of the babies to be the incarnation of Viñëu, killed them one after another. He was particularly afraid of the eighth child, but after the visit of Närada, he came to the conclusion that any child might be Kåñëa. Therefore it was better to kill all the babies who took birth of Devaké and Vasudeva.

This action of Kaàsa is not very difficult to understand. There are many instances in the history of the world of persons in the royal order who have killed father, brother, or a whole family and friends for the satisfaction of their ambitions. There is nothing astonishing about this, for the demoniac can kill anyone for their nefarious ambitions.

Kaàsa was made aware of his previous birth by the grace of Närada. He learned that in his previous birth he was a demon of the name Kälanemi and that he was killed by Viñëu. Having taken his birth in the Bhoja family, he decided to become the deadly enemy of the Yadu dynasty; Kåñëa was going to take birth in that family, and Kaàsa was very much afraid that he would be killed by Kåñëa, just as he was killed in his last birth.

He first of all imprisoned his father Ugrasena because he was the chief king among the Yadu, Bhoja, and Andhaka dynasties, and he also occupied the kingdom of Çürasena, Vasudeva's father. He declared himself the king of all such places.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the First Chapter of Kåñëa, "Advent of Lord Kåñëa."

KB 1970-1-2 / Prayers by the Demigods for Lord Kåñëa in the Womb

2 /Prayers by the Demigods for Lord Kåñëa in the Womb

King Kaàsa not only occupied the kingdoms of the Yadu, Bhoja, and Andhaka dynasties and the kingdom of Çürasena, but he also made alliances with all the other demoniac kings, as follows: the demon Pralamba, demon Baka, demon Cäëüra, demon Tåëävarta, demon Aghäsura, demon Muñöika, demon Ariñöa, demon Dvivida, demon Pütanä, demon Keçé and demon Dhenuka. At that time, Jaräsandha was the king of Magadha province (known at present as Behar state). Thus by his diplomatic policy, Kaàsa consolidated the most powerful kingdom of his time, under the protection of Jaräsandha. He made further alliances with such kings as Bäëäsura and Bhaumäsura, until he was the strongest. Then he began to behave most inimically towards the Yadu dynasty into which Kåñëa was to take His birth.

Being harassed by Kaàsa, the kings of the Yadu, Bhoja and Andhaka dynasties began to take shelter in different states such as the state of the Kurus, the state of the Païcälas and the states known as Kekaya, Çälva, Vidarbha, Niñadha, Videha and Koçala. Kaàsa broke the solidarity of the Yadu Kingdom, as well as the Bhoja and Andhaka. He made his position the most solid within the vast tract of land known at that time as Bhäratavarña.

When Kaàsa killed the six babies of Devaké and Vasudeva one after another, many friends and relatives of Kaàsa approached him and requested him to discontinue these heinous activities. But all of them became worshipers of Kaàsa.

When Devaké became pregnant for the seventh time, a plenary expansion of Kåñëa known as Ananta appeared within her womb. Devaké was overwhelmed both with jubilation and lamentation. She was joyful, for she could understand that Lord Viñëu had taken shelter within her womb, but at the same time she was sorry that as soon as her child would come out, Kaàsa would kill Him. At that time, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, being compassionate upon the fearful condition of the Yadus, due to atrocities committed by Kaàsa, ordered the appearance of His Yogamäyä, or His internal potency. Kåñëa is the Lord of the universe, but He is especially the Lord of the Yadu dynasty.

This Yogamäyä is the principal potency of the Personality of Godhead. In the Vedas it is stated that the Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, has multipotencies. Paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate. All the different potencies are acting externally and internally, and Yogamäyä is the chief of all potencies. He ordered the appearance of Yogamäyä in the land of Vrajabhümi, in Våndävana, which is always decorated and full with beautiful cows. In Våndävana, Rohiëé, one of the wives of Vasudeva, was residing at the house of King Nanda and Queen Yaçodä. Not only Rohiëé, but many others in the Yadu dynasty were scattered all over the country due to their fear of the atrocities of Kaàsa. Some of them were even living in the caves of the mountains.

The Lord thus informed Yogamäyä: "Under the imprisonment of Kaàsa are Devaké and Vasudeva, and at the present moment, My plenary expansion, Çeña, is within the womb of Devaké. You can arrange the transfer of Çeña from the womb of Devaké to the womb of Rohiëé. After this arrangement, I am personally going to appear in the womb of Devaké with My full potencies. Then I shall appear as the son of Devaké and Vasudeva. And you shall appear as the daughter of Nanda and Yaçodä in Våndävana.

"Since you will appear as My contemporary sister, people within the world will worship you with all kinds of valuable presentations: incense, candles, flowers and offerings of sacrifice. You shall quickly satisfy their desires for sense gratification. People who are after materialistic affection will worship you under the different forms of your expansions, which will be named Durgä, Bhadrakälé, Vijayä, Vaiñëavé, Kumudä, Caëòikä, Kåñëä, Mädhavé, Kanyakä, Mäyä, Näräyaëé, Éçäné, Çäradä and Ambikä."

Kåñëa and Yogamäyä appeared as brother and sister—the Supreme Powerful and the supreme power. Although there is no clear distinction between the Powerful and the power, power is always subordinate to the Powerful. Those who are materialistic are worshippers of the power, but those who are transcendentalists are worshippers of the Powerful. Kåñëa is the Supreme Powerful, and Durgä is the supreme power within the material world. Actually people in the Vedic culture worship both the Powerful and the power. There are many hundreds of thousands of temples of Viñëu and Devé, and sometimes they are worshipped simultaneously. The worshipper of the power, Durgä, or the external energy of Kåñëa, may achieve all kinds of material success very easily, but anyone who wants to be elevated transcendentally must engage in worshipping the Powerful in Kåñëa consciousness.

The Lord also declared to Yogamäyä that His plenary expansion, Ananta Çeña, was within the womb of Devaké. On account of being forcibly attracted to the womb of Rohiëé, He would be known as Saìkarñaëa and would be the source of all spiritual power or bala, by which one could be able to attain the highest bliss of life which is called ramaëa. Therefore the plenary portion Ananta would be known after His appearance either as Saìkarñaëa or Balaräma.

In the Upaniñads it is stated, Näyam ätmä bala hénena labhya [Muë. Up. 3.2.4]. The purport is that one cannot attain the Supreme or any form of self-realization without being sufficiently favored by Balaräma. Bala does not mean physical strength. No one can attain spiritual perfection by physical strength. One must have the spiritual strength which is infused by Balaräma or Saìkarñaëa. Ananta or Çeña is the power which sustains all the planets in their different positions. Materially this sustaining power is known as the law of gravitation, but actually it is the display of the potency of Saìkarñaëa. Balaräma or Saìkarñaëa is spiritual power, or the original spiritual master. Therefore Lord Nityänanda Prabhu, who is also the incarnation of Balaräma, is the original spiritual master. And the spiritual master is the representative of Balaräma, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who supplies spiritual strength. In the Caitanya-caritämåta it is confirmed that the spiritual master is the manifestation of the mercy of Kåñëa.

When Yogamäyä was thus ordered by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, she circumambulated the Lord and then appeared within this material world according to His order. When the Supreme Powerful Personality of Godhead transferred Lord Çeña from the womb of Devaké to the womb of Rohiëé, both of them were under the spell of Yogamäyä, which is also called yoga-nidrä. When this was done, people understood that Devaké's seventh pregnancy was a miscarriage. Thus although Balaräma appeared as the son of Devaké, He was transferred to the womb of Rohiëé to appear as her son. After this arrangement, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, who is always ready to place His full potencies in His unalloyed devotees, entered as the Lord of the whole creation within the mind of Vasudeva. It is understood in this connection that Lord Kåñëa first of all situated Himself in the unalloyed heart of Devaké. He was not put into the womb of Devaké by seminal discharge. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, by His inconceivable potency, can appear in any way. It is not necessary for Him to appear in the ordinary way by seminal injection within the womb of a woman.

When Vasudeva was sustaining the form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead within his heart, he appeared just like the glowing sun whose shining rays are always unbearable and scorching to the common man. The form of the Lord situated in the pure unalloyed heart of Vasudeva is not different from the original form of Kåñëa. The appearance of the form of Kåñëa anywhere, and specifically within the heart, is called dhäma. Dhäma does not only refer to Kåñëa's form, but His name, His form, His quality and His paraphernalia. Everything becomes manifest simultaneously.

Thus the eternal form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead with full potencies was transferred from the mind of Vasudeva to the mind of Devaké, exactly as the setting sun's rays are transferred to the full moon rising in the east.

Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, entered the body of Devaké from the body of Vasudeva. He was beyond the conditions of the ordinary living entity. When Kåñëa is there, it is to be understood that all His plenary expansions, such as Näräyaëa, and incarnations like Lord Nåsiàha, Varäha, etc., are with Him, and they are not subject to the conditions of material existence. In this way, Devaké became the residence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead who is one without a second and the cause of all creation. Devaké became the residence of the Absolute Truth, but because she was within the house of Kaàsa, she looked just like a supressed fire, or like misused education. When fire is covered by the walls of a pot or is kept in a jug, the illuminating rays of the fire cannot be very much appreciated. Similarly, misused knowledge, which does not benefit the people in general, is not very much appreciated. So Devaké was kept within the prison walls of Kaàsa's palace, and no one could see her transcendental beauty which resulted from her conceiving the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Kaàsa, however, saw the transcendental beauty of his sister Devaké, and he at once concluded that the Supreme Personality of Godhead had taken shelter in her womb. She had never before looked so wonderfully beautiful. He could distinctly understand that there was something wonderful within the womb of Devaké. In this way, Kaàsa became perturbed. He was sure that the Supreme Personality of Godhead would kill him in the future and that He had now come. Kaàsa began to think: "What is to be done with Devaké? Surely she has Viñëu or Kåñëa within her womb, so it is certain that Kåñëa has come to execute the mission of the demigods. And even if I immediately kill Devaké, His mission cannot be frustrated." Kaàsa knew very well that no one can frustrate the purpose of Viñëu. Any intelligent man can understand that the laws of God cannot be violated. His purpose will be served in spite of all impediments offered by the demons. Kaàsa thought: "If I kill Devaké at the present moment, Viñëu will enforce His supreme will more vehemently. To kill Devaké just now would be a most abominable act. No one desires to kill his reputation, even in an awkward situation; if I kill Devaké now, my reputation will be spoiled. Devaké is a woman, and she is under my shelter; she is pregnant, and if I kill her, immediately all my reputation, the result of pious activities and duration of life, will be finished."

He also further deliberated: "A person who is too cruel, even in this lifetime is as good as dead. No one likes a cruel person during his lifetime, and after his death, people curse him. On account of his self-identification with the body, he must be degraded and pushed into the darkest region of hell." Kaàsa thus meditated on all the pros and cons of killing Devaké at that time.

Kaàsa finally decided not to kill Devaké right away but to wait for the inevitable future. But his mind became absorbed in animosity against the Personality of Godhead. He patiently waited for the deliverance of the child, expecting to kill Him, as he had done previously with the other babies of Devaké. Thus being merged in the ocean of animosity against the Personality of Godhead, he began to think of Kåñëa and Viñëu while sitting, while sleeping, while walking, while eating, while working—in all the situations of his life. His mind became so much absorbed with the thought of the Supreme Personality of Godhead that indirectly he could see only Kåñëa or Viñëu around him. Unfortunately, although his mind was so absorbed in the thought of Viñëu, he is not recognized as a devotee because he was thinking of Kåñëa as an enemy. The state of mind of a great devotee is also to be always absorbed in Kåñëa, but a devotee thinks of Him favorably, not unfavorably. To think of Kåñëa favorably is Kåñëa consciousness, but to think of Kåñëa unfavorably is not Kåñëa consciousness.

At this time Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva, accompanied by great sages like Närada and followed by many other demigods, invisibly appeared in the house of Kaàsa. They began to pray for the Supreme Personality of Godhead in select prayers which are very pleasing to the devotees and which award fulfillment of their desires. The first words they spoke acclaimed that the Lord is true to His vow. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa descends in this material world just to protect the pious and destroy the impious. That is His vow. The demigods could understand that the Lord had taken His residence within the womb of Devaké in order to fulfill this vow. The demigods were very glad that the Lord was appearing to fulfill His mission, and they addressed Him as satyam param, or the Supreme Absolute Truth.

Everyone is searching after the truth. That is the philosophical way of life. The demigods give information that the Supreme Absolute Truth is Kåñëa. One who becomes fully Kåñëa conscious can attain the Absolute Truth. Kåñëa is the Absolute Truth. Relative truth is not truth in all the three phases of eternal time. Time is divided into past, present and future. Kåñëa is Truth always, past, present and future. In the material world everything is being controlled by supreme time, in the course of past, present and future. But before the creation, Kåñëa was existing, and when there is creation, everything is resting in Kåñëa, and when this creation is finished, Kåñëa will remain. Therefore, He is Absolute Truth in all circumstances. If there is any truth within this material world, it emanates from the Supreme Truth, Kåñëa. If there is any opulence within this material world, the cause of the opulence is Kåñëa. If there is any reputation within this material world, the cause of the reputation is Kåñëa. If there is any strength within this material world, the cause of such strength is Kåñëa. If there is any wisdom and education within this material world, the cause of such wisdom and education is Kåñëa. Therefore Kåñëa is the source of all relative truths.

This material world is composed of five principal elements: earth, water, fire, air and ether, and all such elements are emanations from Kåñëa. The material scientists accept these primary five elements as the cause of material manifestation, but the elements in their gross and subtle states are produced by Kåñëa. The living entities who are working within this material world are also products of His marginal potency. In the Seventh Chapter [7.5] of the Bhagavad-gétä, it is clearly stated that the whole manifestation is a combination of two kinds of energies of Kåñëa, the superior energy and the inferior energy. The living entities are the superior energy, and the dead material elements are His inferior energy. In its dormant stage, everything remains in Kåñëa.

The demigods continued to offer their respectful prayers unto the supreme form of the Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, by analytical study of the material manifestation. What is this material manifestation? It is just like a tree. A tree stands on the ground. Similarly, the tree of the material manifestation is standing on the ground of material nature. This material manifestation is compared with a tree because a tree is ultimately cut off in due course of time. A tree is called våkña. Våkña means that thing which will be ultimately cut off. Therefore, this tree of the material manifestation cannot be accepted as the Ultimate Truth. The influence of time is on the material manifestation, but Kåñëa's body is eternal. He existed before the material manifestation, He is existing while the material manifestation is continuing, and when it will be dissolved, He will continue to exist.

The Kaöha Upaniñad also cites this example of the tree of material manifestation standing on the ground of material nature. This tree has two kinds of fruits, distress and happiness. Those who are living on the tree of the body are just like two birds. One bird is the localized aspect of Kåñëa known as the Paramätmä, and the other bird is the living entity. The living entity is eating the fruits of this material manifestation. Sometimes he eats the fruit of happiness, and sometimes he eats the fruit of distress. But the other bird is not interested in eating the fruit of distress or happiness because he is self-satisfied. The Kaöha Upaniñad states that one bird on the tree of the body is eating the fruits, and the other bird is simply witnessing. The roots of this tree extend in three directions. That means the root of the tree is the three modes of material nature: goodness, passion and ignorance. Just as the tree's root expands, so, by association of the modes of material nature (goodness, passion and ignorance), one expands his duration of material existence. The taste of the fruits are of four kinds: religiosity, economic development, sense gratification and ultimately, liberation. According to the different associations in the three modes of material nature, the living entities are tasting different kinds of religiosity, different kinds of economic development, different kinds of sense gratification and different kinds of liberation. Practically all material work is performed in ignorance, but because there are three qualities, sometimes the quality of ignorance is covered with goodness or passion. The taste of these material fruits is accepted through five senses. The five sense organs through which knowledge is acquired are subjected to six kinds of whips: lamentation, illusion, infirmity, death, hunger and thirst. This material body, or the material manifestation, is covered by seven layers: skin, muscle, flesh, marrow, bone, fat and semina. The branches of the tree are eight: earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and ego. There are nine gates in this body: the two eyes, two nostrils, two ears, one mouth, one genital, one rectum. And there are ten kinds of internal air passing within the body: präëa, apäna, udäna, vyäna, samäna, etc. The two birds seated in this tree, as explained above, are the living entity and the localized Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The root cause of the material manifestation described here is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Supreme Personality of Godhead expands Himself and takes charge of the three qualities of the material world. Viñëu takes charge of the modes of goodness, Brahmä takes charge of the modes of passion, and Lord Çiva takes charge of the modes of ignorance. Brahmä, by the modes of passion, creates this manifestation, Lord Viñëu maintains this manifestation by the modes of goodness, and Lord Çiva annihilates it by the modes of ignorance. The whole creation ultimately rests in the Supreme Lord. He is the cause of creation, maintenance and dissolution. And when the whole manifestation is dissolved, in its subtle form as the energy of the Lord, it rests within the body of the Supreme Lord.

"At the present," the demigods prayed, "the Supreme Lord Kåñëa is appearing just for the maintenance of this manifestation." Actually the Supreme Cause is one, but, being deluded by the three modes of material nature, less intelligent persons see that the material world is manifested through different causes. Those who are intelligent can see that the cause is one, Kåñëa. As it is stated in the Brahma-saàhitä: sarva-käraëa-käraëam. Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is the cause of all causes. Brahmä is the deputed agent for creation, Viñëu is the expansion of Kåñëa for maintenance, and Lord Çiva is the expansion of Kåñëa for dissolution.

"Our dear Lord," the demigods prayed, "it is very difficult to understand Your eternal form of personality. People in general are unable to understand Your actual form; therefore You are personally descending to exhibit Your original eternal form. Somehow people can understand the different incarnations of Your Lordship, but they are puzzled to understand the eternal form of Kåñëa with two hands, moving among human beings exactly like one of them. This eternal form of Your Lordship is ever increasing in transcendental pleasure for the devotees. But for the nondevotees, this form is very dangerous." As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa is very pleasing to the sädhu. It is said, pariträëäya sädhünäà. But this form is very dangerous for the demons because Kåñëa also descends to kill the demons. He is, therefore, simultaneously pleasing to the devotees and dangerous to the demons.

"Our dear lotus-eyed Lord, You are the source of pure goodness. There are many great sages who simply by samädhi, or transcendentally meditating upon Your lotus feet and thus being absorbed in Your thought, have easily transformed the great ocean of nescience created by the material nature to no more than water in a calf's hoofprint." The purpose of meditation is to focus the mind upon the Personality of Godhead, beginning from His lotus feet. Simply by meditation on the lotus feet of the Lord, great sages cross over this vast ocean of material existence without difficulty.

"O self-illuminated one, the great saintly persons who have crossed over the ocean of nescience, by the help of the transcendental boat of Your lotus feet, have not taken away that boat. It is still lying on this side." The demigods are using a nice simile. If one takes a boat to cross over a river, the boat also goes with one to the other side of the river. And so when one reaches the destination, how can the same boat be available to those who are still on the other side? To answer this difficulty, the demigods say in their prayer that the boat is not taken away. The devotees still remaining on the other side are able to pass over the ocean of material nature because the pure devotees do not take the boat with them when they cross over. When one simply approaches the boat, the whole ocean of material nescience is reduced to the size of water in a calf's hoofprint. Therefore, the devotees do not need to take a boat to the other side; they simply cross the ocean immediately. Because the great saintly persons are compassionate toward all conditioned souls, the boat is still lying at the lotus feet of the Lord. One can meditate upon His feet at any time, and by so doing, one can cross over the great ocean of material existence.

Meditation means concentration upon the lotus feet of the Lord. Lotus feet indicate the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Those who are impersonalists do not recognize the lotus feet of the Lord, and therefore their object of meditation is something impersonal. The demigods express their mature verdict that persons who are interested in meditating on something void or impersonal cannot cross over the ocean of nescience. Such persons are simply imagining that they have become liberated. "O lotus-eyed Lord! Their intelligence is contaminated because they fail to meditate upon the lotus feet of Your Lordship." As a result of this neglectful activity, the impersonalists fall down again into the material way of conditioned life, although they may temporarily rise up to the point of impersonal realization. Impersonalists, after undergoing severe austerities and penances, merge themselves into the Brahman effulgence or impersonal Brahman existence. But their minds are not free from material contamination; they have simply tried to negate the material ways of thinking. That does not mean that they have become liberated. Thus they fall down. In the Bhagavad-gétä it is stated that the impersonalist has to undergo great tribulation in realizing the ultimate goal. At the beginning of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, it is also stated that without devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one cannot achieve liberation from the bondage of fruitive activities. The statement of Lord Kåñëa is there in the Bhagavad-gétä, and in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam the statement of the great sage Närada is there, and here also the demigods confirm it. "Persons who have not taken to devotional service are understood to have come short of the ultimate purpose of knowledge and are not favored by Your grace." The impersonalists simply think that they are liberated, but actually they have no feeling for the Personality of Godhead. They think that when Kåñëa comes into the material world, he accepts a material body. They therefore overlook the transcendental body of Kåñëa. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä. Avajänanti mäà müòhäù. In spite of conquering material lust and rising up to the point of liberation, the impersonalists fall down. If they are engaged just in knowing things for the sake of knowledge and do not take to the devotional service of the Lord, they cannot achieve the desired result. Their achievement is the trouble they take, and that is all. It is clearly stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that to realize Brahman identification is not all. Brahman identification may help one become joyful without material attachment or detachment and to achieve the platform of equanimity, but after this stage, one has to take to devotional service. When one takes to devotional service after being elevated to the platform of Brahman realization, he is then admitted into the spiritual kingdom for permanent residence in association with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. That is the result of devotional service. Those who are devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead never fall down like the impersonalists. Even if the devotees fall down, they remain affectionately attached to their Lordship. They can meet all kinds of obstacles on the path of devotional service, and freely, without any fear, they can surmount such obstacles. Because of their surrender, they are certain that Kåñëa will always protect them. As it is promised by Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä: "My devotees are never vanquished."

"Our dear Lord, You have appeared in Your original unalloyed form, the eternal form of goodness, for the welfare of all living entities within this material world. Taking advantage of Your appearance, all of them can now very easily understand the nature and form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Persons who belong to the four divisions of the social order (the brahmacärés, the gåhasthas, the vänaprasthas and the sannyäsés) can all take advantage of Your appearance.

"Dear Lord, husband of the goddess of fortune, devotees who are dovetailed in Your service do not fall down from their high position like the impersonalists. Being protected by You, the devotees are able to traverse over the heads of many of mäyä's commanders-in-chief, who can always put stumbling blocks on the path of liberation. My dear Lord, You appear in Your transcendental form for the benefit of the living entities so that they can see You face to face and offer their worshipful sacrifices by ritualistic performance of the Vedas, mystic meditation and devotional service as recommended in the scriptures. Dear Lord, if You did not appear in Your eternal transcendental form, full of bliss and knowledge—which can eradicate all kinds of speculative ignorance about Your position—then all people would simply speculate about You according to their respective modes of material nature."

The appearance of Kåñëa is the answer to all imaginative iconography of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Everyone imagines the form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead according to his mode of material nature. In the Brahmä-saàhitä [5.33] it is said that the Lord is the oldest person. Therefore a section of religionists imagine that God must be very old, and therefore they depict a form of the Lord like a very old man. But in the same Brahmä-saàhitä, that is contradicted; although He is the oldest of all living entities, He has His eternal form as a fresh youth. The exact words used in this connection in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.2.35] are vijïänam ajïänabhid äpamärjanam. Vijïänam means transcendental knowledge of the Supreme Personality. Vijïänam is also experienced knowledge. Transcendental knowledge has to be accepted by the descending process of disciplic succession as Brahmä presents the knowledge of Kåñëa in the Brahma-saàhitä. Brahma-saàhitä is vijïänam as realized by Brahmä's transcendental experience, and in that way he presented the form and the pastimes of Kåñëa in the transcendental abode. Ajïänabhid means that which can match all kinds of speculation. In ignorance, people are imagining the form of the Lord; sometimes He has no form and sometimes He has form, according to their different imaginations. But the presentation of Kåñëa in the Brahma-saàhitä is vijïänam—scientific, experienced knowledge given by Lord Brahmä and accepted by Lord Caitanya. There is no doubt about it. Çré Kåñëa's form, Çré Kåñëa's flute, Kåñëa's color—everything is reality. Here it is said that this vijïänam is always defeating all kinds of speculative knowledge. "Therefore, without Your appearing as Kåñëa, as You are, neither ajïänabhid (nescience of speculative knowledge) nor vijïänam would be realized. Ajïänabhid äpamärjanam—by Your appearance the speculative knowledge of ignorance will be vanquished and the real experienced knowledge of authorities like Lord Brahmä will be established. Men influenced by the three modes of material nature imagine their own God according to the modes of material nature. In this way God is presented in various ways, but Your appearance will establish what the real form of God is."

The highest blunder committed by the impersonalist is to think that when the incarnation of God comes, He accepts the form of matter in the modes of goodness. Actually the form of Kåñëa or Näräyaëa is transcendental to any material idea. Even the greatest impersonalist, Çaìkaräcärya, has admitted that näräyaëaù paro 'vyaktät: the material creation is caused by the avyakta impersonal manifestation of matter or the nonphenomenal total reservation of matter, and Kåñëa is transcendental to that material conception. That is expressed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [4.3.23] as çuddha-sattva, or transcendental. He does not belong to the material mode of goodness, and He is above the position of material goodness. He belongs to the transcendental eternal status of bliss and knowledge.

"Dear Lord, when You appear in Your different incarnations, You take different names and forms according to different situations. Lord Kåñëa is Your name because You are all attractive; You are called Çyämasundara because of Your transcendental beauty. Çyäma means blackish, yet they say that You are more beautiful than thousands of cupids. Kandarpa-koöi-kamanéya [Bs 5.30]. Although You appear in a color which is compared to the blackish cloud, because You are transcendental Absolute, Your beauty is many many times more attractive than the delicate body of Cupid. Sometimes You are called Giridhäré because You lifted the hill known as Govardhana. You are sometimes called Nandanandana or Väsudeva or Devakénandana because You appear as the son of Mahäräja Nanda or Devaké or Vasudeva. Impersonalists think that Your many names or forms are according to a particular type of work and quality because they accept You from the position of a material observer.

"Our dear Lord, the way of understanding is not to study Your absolute nature, form and activities by mental speculation. One must engage himself in devotional service; then one can understand Your absolute nature, transcendental form, name and quality. Actually only a person who has a little taste for the service of Your lotus feet can understand Your transcendental nature or form and quality. Others may go on speculating for millions of years, but it is not possible for them to understand even a single part of Your actual position." In other words, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, cannot be understood by the nondevotees because there is a curtain of Yogamäyä which covers Kåñëa's actual features. As confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä, nähaà prakäçaù sarvasya. The Lord says, "I am not exposed to anyone and everyone." When Kåñëa came, He was actually present on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, and everyone saw Him. But not everyone could understand that He was the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Still, everyone who died in His presence attained complete liberation from material bondage and was transferred to the spiritual world.

"O Lord, the impersonalists or nondevotees cannot understand that Your name is identical with Your form." Since the Lord is Absolute, there is no difference between His name and His actual form. In the material world there is a difference between form and name. The mango fruit is different from the name of the mango. One cannot taste the mango fruit simply by chanting, "Mango, mango, mango." But the devotee who knows that there is no difference between the name and the form of the Lord chants Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare, Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, and realizes that he is always in Kåñëa's company.

For persons who are not very advanced in absolute knowledge of the Supreme, Lord Kåñëa exhibits His transcendental pastimes. They can simply think of the pastimes of the Lord and get the full benefit. Since there is no difference between the transcendental name and form of the Lord, there is no difference between the transcendental pastimes and the form of the Lord. For those who are less intelligent (like women, laborers or the mercantile class), the great sage Vyäsadeva wrote Mahäbhärata. In the Mahäbhärata, Kåñëa is present in His different activities. Mahäbhärata is history, and simply by studying, hearing and memorizing the transcendental activities of Kåñëa, the less intelligent can also gradually rise to the standard of pure devotees.

The pure devotees, who are always absorbed in the thought of the transcendental lotus feet of Kåñëa and who are always engaged in devotional service in full Kåñëa consciousness, are never to be considered to be in the material world. Çré Rüpa Gosvämé has explained that those who are always engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, by body, mind and activities, are to be considered liberated even within this body. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä: those who are engaged in the devotional service of the Lord have already transcended the material position.

Kåñëa appears to give a chance both to the devotees and nondevotees for realization of the ultimate goal of life. The devotees get the direct chance to see Him and worship Him. Those who are not on that platform get the chance to become acquainted with His activities and thus become elevated to the same position.

"O dear Lord," the demigods continued, "You are unborn; therefore we do not find any reason for Your appearance other than for Your pleasurable pastimes." Although the reason for the appearance of the Lord is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä (He descends just to give protection to the devotee and vanquish the nondevotee), actually He descends for His pleasure-meeting with the devotees, not really to vanquish the nondevotees. The nondevotees can be vanquished simply by material nature. "The action and reaction of the external energy of material nature (creation, maintenance and annihilation) are being carried on automatically. But simply by taking shelter of Your holy name—because Your holy name and Your personality are nondifferent—the devotees are sufficiently protected." The protection of the devotees and the annihilation of the nondevotees are actually not the business of the Supreme Personality of Godhead when He descends. They are just for His transcendental pleasure. There cannot be any other reason for His appearance.

"Our dear Lord, You are appearing as the best of the Yadu dynasty, and we are offering our respectful humble obeisance unto Your lotus feet. Before this appearance, You also appeared as the fish incarnation, the horse incarnation, the tortoise incarnation, the swan incarnation, as King Rämacandra, as Paraçuräma, and as many other incarnations. You appeared just to protect the devotees, and we request You in Your present appearance as the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself to give us similar protection all over the three worlds and remove all obstacles for the peaceful execution of our lives.

"Dear mother Devaké, within your womb is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, appearing along with all His plenary extensions. He is the original Personality of Godhead appearing for our welfare. Therefore you should not be afraid of your brother, the King of Bhoja. Your son Lord Kåñëa, who is the original Personality of Godhead, will appear for the protection of the pious Yadu dynasty. The Lord is appearing not only alone but accompanied by His immediate plenary portion, Balaräma."

Devaké was very much afraid of her brother Kaàsa because he had already killed so many of her children. She used to remain very anxious about Kåñëa. In the Viñëu Puräëa it is stated that in order to pacify Devaké, all the demigods, along with their wives, used to always visit her to encourage her not to be afraid that her son would be killed by Kaàsa. Kåñëa, who was within her womb, was to appear not only to diminish the burden of the world but specifically to protect the interest of the Yadu dynasty, and certainly to protect Devaké and Vasudeva.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Chapter of Kåñëa, "Prayers by the Demigods for Lord Kåñëa in the Womb."

KB 1970-1-3 / Birth of Lord Kåñëa

3 /Birth of Lord Kåñëa

As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.8-9], the Lord says that His appearance, birth, and activities are all transcendental, and one who understands them factually becomes immediately eligible to be transferred to the spiritual world. The Lord's appearance or birth is not like that of an ordinary man who is forced to accept a material body according to his past deeds. The Lord's appearance is explained in the Second Chapter: He appears out of His own sweet pleasure. When the time was mature for the appearance of the Lord, the constellations became very auspicious. The astrological influence of the star known as Rohiëé was also predominant because this star is considered to be very auspicious. Rohiëé is under the direct supervision of Brahmä. According to the astrological conclusion, besides the proper situation of the stars, there are auspicious and inauspicious moments due to the different situations of the different planetary systems. At the time of Kåñëa's birth, the planetary systems were automatically adjusted so that everything became auspicious.

At that time, in all directions, east, west, south, north, everywhere, there was an atmosphere of peace and prosperity. There were auspicious stars visible in the sky, and on the surface in all towns and villages or pasturing grounds and within the minds of everyone there were signs of good fortune. The rivers were flowing full of waters, and lakes were beautifully decorated with lotus flowers. The forests were full with beautiful birds and peacocks. All the birds within the forests began to sing with sweet voices, and the peacocks began to dance along with their consorts. The wind blew very pleasantly, carrying the aroma of different flowers, and the sensation of bodily touch was very pleasing. At home, the brähmaëas, who were accustomed to offer sacrifices in the fire, found their homes very pleasant for offerings. Due to disturbances created by the demoniac kings, the sacrificial fire altar had been almost stopped in the houses of brähmaëas, but now they could find the opportunity to start the fire peacefully. Being forbidden to offer sacrifices, the brähmaëas were very distressed in mind, intelligence and activities, but just on the point of Kåñëa's appearance, automatically their minds became full of joy because they could hear loud vibrations in the sky of transcendental sounds proclaiming the appearance of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The denizens of the Gandharva and Kinnara planets began to sing, and the denizens of Siddhaloka and the planets of the Cäraëas began to offer prayers in the service of the Personality of Godhead. In the heavenly planets, the angels along with their wives, accompanied by the Apsaras, began to dance.

The great sages and the demigods, being pleased, began to shower flowers. At the seashore, there was the sound of mild waves, and above the sea there were clouds in the sky which began to thunder very pleasingly.

When things were adjusted like this, Lord Viñëu, who is residing within the heart of every living entity, appeared in the darkness of night as the Supreme Personality of Godhead before Devaké, who also appeared as one of the demigoddesses. The appearance of Lord Viñëu at that time could be compared with the full moon in the sky as it rises on the eastern horizon. The objection may be raised that, since Lord Kåñëa appeared on the eighth day of the waning moon, there could be no rising of the full moon. In answer to this it may be said that Lord Kåñëa appeared in the dynasty which is in the hierarchy of the moon; therefore, although the moon was incomplete on that night, because of the Lord's appearance in the dynasty wherein the moon is himself the original person, the moon was in an overjoyous condition, so by the grace of Kåñëa he could appear just as a full moon.

In an astronomical treatise by the name Khamäëikya, the constellations at the time of the appearance of Lord Kåñëa are very nicely described. It is confirmed that the child born at that auspicious moment was the Supreme Brahman or the Absolute Truth.

Vasudeva saw that wonderful child born as a baby with four hands, holding conchshell, club, disc, and lotus flower, decorated with the mark of Çrévatsa, wearing the jeweled necklace of kaustubha stone, dressed in yellow silk, appearing dazzling like a bright blackish cloud, wearing a helmet bedecked with the vaidürya stone, valuable bracelets, earrings and similar other ornaments all over His body and an abundance of hair on His head. Due to the extraordinary features of the child, Vasudeva was struck with wonder. How could a newly born child be so decorated? He could therefore understand that Lord Kåñëa had now appeared, and he became overpowered by the occasion. Vasudeva very humbly wondered that although he was an ordinary living entity conditioned by material nature and was externally imprisoned by Kaàsa, the all-pervading Personality of Godhead, Viñëu or Kåñëa, was appearing as a child in his home, exactly in His original position. No earthly child is born with four hands decorated with ornaments and nice clothing, fully equipped with all the signs of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Over and over again, Vasudeva glanced at his child, and he considered how to celebrate this auspicious moment: "Generally, when a male child is born," he thought, "people observe the occasion with jubilant celebrations, and in my home, although I am imprisoned, the Supreme Personality of Godhead has taken birth. How many millions of millions of times should I be prepared to observe this auspicious ceremony!"

When Vasudeva, who is also called Änakadundubhi, was looking at his newborn baby, he was so happy that he wanted to give many thousands of cows in charity to the brähmaëas. According to the Vedic system, whenever there is an auspicious ceremony in the kñatriya king's palace, the king gives many things in charity. Cows decorated with golden ornaments are delivered to the brähmaëas and sages. Vasudeva wanted to perform a charitable ceremony to celebrate Kåñëa's appearance, but because he was shackled within the walls of Kaàsa's prison, this was not possible. Instead, within his mind he gave thousands of cows to the brähmaëas.

When Vasudeva was convinced that the newborn child was the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself, he bowed down with folded hands and began to offer Him prayers. At that time Vasudeva was in the transcendental position, and he became completely free from all fear of Kaàsa. The newborn baby was also flashing His effulgence within the room in which He appeared.

Vasudeva then began to offer his prayers. "My dear Lord, I can understand who You are. You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Supersoul of all living entities and the Absolute Truth. You have appeared in Your own eternal form which is directly perceived by us. I understand that because I am afraid of Kaàsa, You have appeared just to deliver me from that fear. You do not belong to this material world; You are the same person who brings about the cosmic manifestation simply by glancing over material nature."

One may argue that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who creates the whole cosmic manifestation simply by His glance, cannot come within the womb of Devaké, the wife of Vasudeva. To eradicate this argument, Vasudeva said, "My dear Lord, it is not a very wonderful thing that You appear within the womb of Devaké because the creation was also made in that way. You were lying in the Causal Ocean as Mahä-Viñëu, and by Your breathing process, innumerable universes came into existence. Then You entered into each of the universes as Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu. Then again You expanded Yourself as Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu and entered into the hearts of all living entities and entered even within the atoms. Therefore Your entrance in the womb of Devaké is understandable in the same way. You appear to have entered, but You are simultaneously all-pervading. We can understand Your entrance and nonentrance from material examples. The total material energy remains intact even after being divided into sixteen elements. The material body is nothing but the combination of the five gross elements—namely earth, water, fire, air and ether. Whenever there is a material body, it appears that such elements are newly created, but actually the elements are always existing outside of the body. Similarly, although You appear as a child in the womb of Devaké, You are also existing outside. You are always in Your abode, but still You can simultaneously expand Yourself into millions of forms.

"One has to understand Your appearance with great intelligence because the material energy is also emanating from You. You are the original source of the material energy, just as the sun is the source of the sunshine. The sunshine cannot cover the sun globe, nor can the material energy—being an emanation from You—cover You. You appear to be in the three modes of material energy, but actually the three modes of material energy cannot cover You. This is understood by the highly intellectual philosophers. In other words, although You appear to be within the material energy, You are never covered by it."

We hear from the Vedic version that the Supreme Brahman exhibits His effulgence, and therefore everything becomes illuminated. We can understand from Brahma-saàhitä [5.40] that the brahmajyoti, or the Brahman effulgence, emanates from the body of the Supreme Lord. And from the Brahman effulgence, all creation takes place. It is further stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [14.27] that the Lord is also the support of the Brahman effulgence. Originally He is the root cause of everything. But persons who are less intelligent think that when the Supreme Personality of Godhead comes within this material world, He accepts the material qualities. Such conclusions are not very mature, but are made by the less intelligent.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead is directly and indirectly existing everywhere; He is outside this material creation, and He is also within it. He is within this material creation not only as Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu; He is also within the atom. Existence is due to His presence. Nothing can be separated from His existence. In the Vedic injunction we find that the Supreme Soul or the root cause of everything has to be searched out because nothing exists independent of the Supreme Soul. Therefore the material manifestation is also a transformation of His potency. Both inert matter and the living force—soul—are emanations from Him. Only the foolish conclude that when the Supreme Lord appears He accepts the conditions of matter. Even if He appears to have accepted the material body, He is still not subjected to any material condition. Kåñëa has therefore appeared and defeated all imperfect conclusions about the appearance and disappearance of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

"My Lord, Your appearance, existence and disappearance are beyond the influence of the material qualities. Because Your Lordship is the controller of everything and the resting place of the Supreme Brahman, there is nothing inconceivable or contradictory in You. As You have said, material nature works under Your superintendence. It is just like government officers working under the orders of the chief executive. The influence of subordinate activities cannot affect You. The Supreme Brahman and all phenomena are existing within You, and all the activities of material nature are controlled by Your Lordship.

"You are called çuklam. Çuklam or 'whiteness' is the symbolic representation of the Absolute Truth because it is unaffected by the material qualities. Lord Brahmä is called rakta, or red, because Brahmä represents the qualities of passion for creation. Darkness is entrusted to Lord Çiva because he annihilates the cosmos. The creation, annihilation and maintenance of this cosmic manifestation is conducted by Your potencies, yet You are always unaffected by those qualities. As confirmed in the Vedas, Harir hi nirguëaù säkñät: the Supreme Personality of Godhead is always free from all material qualities. It is also said that the qualities of passion and ignorance are nonexistent in the person of the Supreme Lord.

"My Lord, You are the supreme controller, the Personality of Godhead, the supreme great, maintaining the order of this cosmic manifestation. And in spite of Your being the supreme controller, You have so kindly appeared in my home. The purpose of Your appearance is to kill the followers of the demonic rulers of the world who are in the dress of royal princes but are actually demons. I am sure that You will kill all of them and their followers and soldiers.

"I understand that You have appeared to kill the uncivilized Kaàsa and his followers. But knowing that You were to appear to kill him and his followers, he has already killed so many of Your predecessors, elder brothers. Now he is simply awaiting the news of Your birth. As soon as he hears about it, he will immediately appear with all kinds of weapons to kill You."

After this prayer of Vasudeva, Devaké, the mother of Kåñëa, offered her prayers. She was very frightened because of her brother's atrocities. Devaké said "My dear Lord, Your eternal forms, like Näräyaëa, Lord Räma, Çeña, Varäha, Nåsiàha, Vämana, Baladeva, and millions of similar incarnations emanating from Viñëu, are described in the Vedic literature as original. You are original because all Your forms as incarnations are outside of this material creation. Your form was existing before this cosmic manifestation was created. Your forms are eternal and all-pervading. They are self-effulgent, changeless and uncontaminated by the material qualities. Such eternal forms are ever-cognizant and full of bliss; they are situated in transcendental goodness and are always engaged in different pastimes. You are not limited to a particular form only; all such transcendental eternal forms are self-sufficient. I can understand that You are the Supreme Lord Viñëu.

"After many millions of years, when Lord Brahmä comes to the end of his life, the annihilation of the cosmic manifestation takes place. At that time the five elements—namely earth, water, fire, air and ether—enter into the mahat-tattva. The mahat-tattva again enters, by the force of time, into the nonmanifested total material energy; the total material energy enters into the energetic pradhäna, and the pradhäna enters into You. Therefore after the annihilation of the whole cosmic manifestation, You alone remain with Your transcendental name, form, quality and paraphernalia.

"My Lord, I offer my respectful obeisances unto You because You are the director of the unmanifested total energy, and the ultimate reservoir of the material nature. My Lord, the whole cosmic manifestation is under the influence of time, beginning from the moment up to the duration of the year. All act under Your direction. You are the original director of everything and the reservoir of all potent energies.

"Therefore my Lord, I request You to save me from the cruel hands of the son of Ugrasena, Kaàsa. I am praying to Your Lordship to please rescue me from this fearful condition because You are always ready to give protection to Your servitors." The Lord has confirmed this statement in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.31] by assuring Arjuna, "You may declare to the world, My devotee shall never be vanquished."

While thus praying to the Lord for rescue, mother Devaké expressed her motherly affection: "I understand that this transcendental form is generally perceived in meditation by the great sages, but I am still afraid because as soon as Kaàsa understands that You have appeared, he might harm You. So I request that for the time being You become invisible to our material eyes." In other words, she requested the Lord to assume the form of an ordinary child. "My only cause of fear from my brother Kaàsa is due to Your appearance. My Lord Madhusüdana, Kaàsa may know that You are already born. Therefore I request You to conceal this four-armed form of Your Lordship which holds the four symbols of Viñëu—namely the conchshell, the disc, the club and the lotus flower. My dear Lord, at the end of the annihilation of the cosmic manifestation, You put the whole universe within Your abdomen; still by Your unalloyed mercy You have appeared in my womb. I am surprised that You imitate the activities of ordinary human beings just to please Your devotee."

On hearing the prayers of Devaké, the Lord replied, "My dear mother, in the millennium of Sväyambhuva Manu, My father Vasudeva was living as one of the Prajäpatis, and his name at that time was Sutapä, and you were his wife named Påçni. At that time, when Lord Brahmä was desiring to increase the population, he requested you to generate offspring. You controlled your senses and performed severe austerities. By practicing the breathing exercise of the yoga system, both you and your husband could tolerate all the influences of the material laws: the rainy season, the onslaught of the wind, and the scorching heat of the sunshine. You also executed all religious principles. In this way you were able to cleanse your heart and control the influence of material law. In executing your austerity, you used to eat only the leaves of the trees which fell to the ground. Then with steady mind and controlled sex drive, you worshiped Me, desiring some wonderful benediction from Me. Both of you practiced severe austerities for 12,000 years, by the calculation of the demigods. During that time, your mind was always absorbed in Me. When you were executing devotional service and always thinking of Me within your heart, I was very much pleased with you. O sinless mother, your heart is therefore always pure. At that time also I appeared before you in this form just to fulfill your desire, and I asked you to ask whatever you desired. At that time you wished to have Me born as your son. Although you saw Me personally, instead of asking for your complete liberation from the material bondage, under the influence of My energy, you asked Me to become your son."

In other words, the Lord selected His mother and father—namely Påçni and Sutapä—specifically to appear in the material world. Whenever the Lord comes as a human being, He must have someone as a mother and father, so He selected Påçni and Sutapä perpetually as His mother and father. And on account of this, both Påçni and Sutapä could not ask the Lord for liberation. Liberation is not so important as the transcendental loving service of the Lord. The Lord could have awarded Påçni and Sutapä immediate liberation, but He preferred to keep them within this material world for His different appearances, as will be explained in the following verses. On receiving the benediction from the Lord to become His father and mother, both Påçni and Sutapä returned from the activities of austerity and lived as husband and wife in order to beget a child who was the Supreme Lord Himself.

In due course of time Påçni became pregnant and gave birth to the child. The Lord spoke to Devaké and Vasudeva: "At that time My name was Påçnigarbha. In the next millennium also you took birth as Aditi and Kaçyapa, and I became your child of the name Upendra. At that time My form was just like a dwarf, and for this reason I was known as Vämanadeva. I gave you the benediction that I would take birth as your son three times. The first time I was known as Påçnigarbha, born of Påçni and Sutapä, the next birth I was Upendra born of Aditi and Kaçyapa, and now for the third time I am born as Kåñëa from you, Devaké and Vasudeva. I appeared in this Viñëu form just to convince you that I am the same Supreme Personality of Godhead again taken birth. I could have appeared just like an ordinary child, but in that way you would not believe that I, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, have taken birth in your womb. My dear father and mother, you have therefore raised Me many times as your child, with great affection and love, and I am therefore very pleased and obliged to you. And I assure you that this time you shall go back to home, back to Godhead, on account of your perfection in your mission. I know you are very concerned about Me and afraid of Kaàsa. Therefore I order you to take me immediately to Gokula and replace Me with the daughter who has just been born to Yaçodä."

Having spoken thus in the presence of His father and mother, the Lord turned Himself into an ordinary child and remained silent.

Being ordered by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Vasudeva attempted to take his son from the delivery room, and exactly at that time, a daughter was born of Nanda and Yaçodä. She was Yogamäyä, the internal potency of the Lord. By the influence of this internal potency, Yogamäyä, all the residents of Kaàsa's palace, especially the doorkeepers, were overwhelmed with deep sleep, and all the palace doors opened, although they were barred and shackled with iron chains. The night was very dark, but as soon as Vasudeva took Kåñëa on his lap and went out, he could see everything just as in the sunlight.

In the Caitanya-caritämåta [Madhya 22.31] it is said that Kåñëa is just like sunlight, and wherever there is Kåñëa, the illusory energy, which is compared to darkness, cannot remain. When Vasudeva was carrying Kåñëa, the darkness of the night disappeared. All the prison doors automatically opened. At the same time there was a thunder in the sky and severe rainfall. While Vasudeva was carrying his son Kåñëa in the falling rain, Lord Çeña in the shape of a serpent spread his hood over the head of Vasudeva so that he would not be hampered by the rainfall. Vasudeva came onto the bank of the Yamunä and saw that the water of the Yamunä was roaring with waves and that the whole span was full of foam. Still, in that furious feature, the river gave passage to Vasudeva to cross, just as the great Indian Ocean gave a path to Lord Räma when He was bridging over the gulf. In this way Vasudeva crossed the River Yamunä. On the other side, he went to the place of Nanda Mahäräja situated in Gokula, where he saw that all the cowherd men were fast asleep. He took the opportunity of silently entering into the house of Yaçodä, and without difficulty he replaced his son, taking away the baby girl newly born in the house of Yaçodä. Then, after entering the house very silently and exchanging the boy with the girl, he again returned to the prison of Kaàsa and silently put the girl on the lap of Devaké. He again clamped the shackles on himself so that Kaàsa could not recognize that so many things had happened.

Mother Yaçodä understood that a child was born of her, but because she was very tired from the labor of childbirth, she was fast asleep. When she awoke, she could not remember whether she had given birth to a male or female child.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Third Chapter of Kåñëa, "Birth of Lord Kåñëa."

KB 1970-1-4 / Kaàsa Begins His Persecutions

4 /Kaàsa Begins His Persecutions

After Vasudeva adjusted all the doors and gates, the gatekeepers awoke and heard the newborn child crying. Kaàsa was waiting to hear the news of the child's birth, and the gatekeepers immediately approached him and informed him that the child was born. At that time, Kaàsa got up from his bed very quickly and exclaimed, "Now the cruel death of my life is born!" Kaàsa became perplexed now that his death was approaching, and his hair stood on end. Immediately he proceeded toward the place where the child was born.

Devaké, on seeing her brother approaching, prayed in a very meek attitude to Kaàsa: "My dear brother, please do not kill this female child. I promise that this child will be the wife of your son; therefore don't kill her. You are not to be killed by any female child. That was the omen. You are to be killed by a male child, so please do not kill her. My dear brother, you have killed so many of my children who were just born, shining as the sun. That is not your fault. You have been advised by demoniac friends to kill my children. But now I beg you to excuse this girl. Let her live as my daughter."

Kaàsa was so cruel that he did not listen to the beautiful prayers of his sister Devaké. He forcibly grabbed the newborn child to rebuke his sister and attempted to dash her on the stone mercilessly. This is a graphic example of a cruel brother who could sacrifice all relationships for the sake of personal gratification. But immediately the child slipped out of his hands, went up in the sky and appeared with eight arms as the younger sister of Viñëu. She was decorated with a nice dress and flower garlands and ornaments; in her eight hands she held a bow, lancet, arrows, bell, conchshell, disc, club and shield.

Seeing the appearance of the child (who was actually the goddess Durgä), all the demigods from different planets like Siddhaloka, Cäraëaloka, Gandharvaloka, Apsaraloka, Kinnaraloka, and Uragaloka presented her articles and began to offer their respective prayers. From above, the goddess addressed Kaàsa: "You rascal, how can you kill me? The child who will kill you is already born before me somewhere within this world. Don't be so cruel to your poor sister." After this appearance, the goddess Durgä became known by various names in various parts of the world.

After hearing these words, Kaàsa became very much overwhelmed with fear. Out of pity, he immediately released Vasudeva and Devaké from the bondage of their shackles and very politely began to address them. He said, "My dear sister and brother-in-law, I have acted just like a demon in killing my own nephews. I have given up all consideration of our intimate relationship. I do not know what will be the result of these acts of mine. Probably I shall be sent to the hell where killers of the brähmaëas go. I am surprised, however, that the celestial prophecy has not come true. False propaganda is not found only in the human society. Now it appears that even the celestial denizens speak lies. Because I believed in the words of the celestial denizens, I have committed so many sins by killing the children of my sister. My dear Vasudeva and Devaké, you are both very great souls. I have nothing to instruct you, but still I request that you not be sorry for the death of your children. Every one of us is under the control of superior power, and that superior power does not allow us to remain together. We are bound to be separated from our friends and relatives in due course of time. But we must know for certain that even after the disappearance of the different material bodies, the soul remains intact eternally. For example, there are many pots made of earthly clay, and they are prepared and also broken. But in spite of this, the earth remains as it is perpetually. Similarly, the bodies of the soul under different conditions are made and destroyed, but the spirit soul remains eternally. So there is nothing to lament over. Everyone should understand that this material body is different from the spirit soul, and so long as one does not come to that understanding, he is sure to accept the processes of transmigration from one body to another. My dear sister Devaké, you are so gentle and kind. Please excuse me—don't be aggrieved by the death of your children, which I have caused. Actually this was not done by me because all these are predestined activities. One has to act according to the predestined plan, even unwillingly. People misunderstand that with the end of the body, the self dies, or they think that one can kill another living entity. All these misconceptions oblige one to accept the conditions of material existence. In other words, as long as one is not firmly convinced of the eternality of the soul, one is subjected to the tribulation of being killer and killed. My dear sister Devaké and brother-in-law Vasudeva, kindly excuse the atrocities I have committed against you. I am very poor-hearted, and you are so great-hearted, so take compassion upon me and excuse me."

While Kaàsa was speaking to his brother-in-law and sister, tears flowed from his eyes and he fell down at their feet. Believing the words of Durgä-devé, whom he had tried to kill, Kaàsa immediately released his brother-in-law and sister. He personally unlocked the iron shackles and very sympathetically showed his friendship, just like a family member.

When Devaké saw her brother so repentent, she also became pacified and forgot all his atrocious activities against her children. Vasudeva also, forgetting all past incidents, spoke smilingly with his brother-in-law. Vasudeva told Kaàsa, "My dear fortunate brother-in-law, what you are saying about the material body and the soul is correct. Every living entity is born ignorant, understanding this material body to be his self. This conception of life is due to ignorance, and on the basis of this ignorance we create enmity or friendship. Lamentation, jubilation, fearfulness, envy, greed, illusion and madness are different features of our material concept of life. A person influenced like this engages in enmity due only to the material body. Being engaged in such activities, we forget our eternal relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

Vasudeva took the opportunity of Kaàsa's benevolence and informed him that his atheistic activities were also due to this misconception of life—namely taking the material body to be the self. When Vasudeva talked with Kaàsa in such an illuminating way, Kaàsa became very pleased, and his guilt for killing his nephews subdued. With the permission of his sister Devaké and brother-in-law Vasudeva, he returned to his home with a relieved mind.

But the next day Kaàsa called all his counsellors together and narrated to them all the incidents that had happened the night before. All the counsellors of Kaàsa were demons and eternal enemies of the demigods, so they became depressed upon hearing their master speak of the night's events. And although they were not very much experienced or learned, they began to give instructions to Kaàsa as follows: "Dear sir, let us now make arrangements to kill all children who were born within the last ten days in all towns, countries, villages and pasturing grounds. Let us execute this plan indiscriminately. We think that the demigods cannot do anything against us if we perform these atrocities. They are always afraid of fighting with us, and even if they wish to check our activities, they will not dare to do so. Because of the immeasurable strength of your bow, they fear you. Indeed, we have practical experience that whenever you stood to fight with them and began to shower your arrows on them, they immediately began to flee in all directions just to save their lives. Many of the demigods were unable to fight with you, and they immediately surrendered themselves unto you by opening their turbans and the flag on their heads. With folded hands they begged you to spare them and said, 'My lord, we are all afraid of your strength. Please release us from this dangerous fight.' We have also seen many times that you would never kill such surrendered fighters when they were all fearful, their bows, arrows and chariots broken, forgetful of their military activities and unable to fight with you. So actually we have nothing to fear from these demigods. They are very proud of being great fighters in peacetime outside of the warfield, but actually they cannot show any talent or military power on the warfield. Although Lord Viñëu, Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä are always ready to help the demigods headed by Indra, we have no reason to be afraid of them. As far as Lord Viñëu is concerned, He has already hidden Himself within the hearts of all living entities, and He cannot come out. As far as Lord Çiva is concerned, he has renounced all activities; he has already entered into the forest. And Lord Brahmä is always engaged in different types of austerities and meditation. And what to speak of Indra—he is a straw in comparison to your strength. Therefore we have nothing to fear from all these demigods. But we must not neglect them because the demigods are our determined enemies. We must be careful to protect ourselves. To root them out from their very existence, we should just engage ourselves in your service and be always ready for your command."

The demons continued to say: "If there is some disease in the body which is neglected, it becomes incurable. Similarly, when one is not careful about restraining the senses and lets them loose, it is very difficult to control them at all. Therefore, we must always be very careful of the demigods before they get too strong to be subdued. The foundation of strength of the demigods is Lord Viñëu, because the ultimate goal of all religious principles is to satisfy Him. The Vedic injunctions, the brähmaëas, the cows, austerities, sacrifices, performances of charity and distribution of wealth are all for the satisfaction of Lord Viñëu. So let us immediately begin by killing all the brähmaëas who are in charge of the Vedic knowledge and the great sages who are in charge of sacrificial ritualistic performances. Let us kill all the cows which are the source of butter which is so necessary for performing sacrifices. Please give us your permission to kill all these creatures."

Actually the limbs of the transcendental body of Lord Viñëu are the brähmaëas, the cows, Vedic knowledge, austerity, truthfulness, sense and mind control, faithfulness, charity, tolerance and performance of sacrifices. Lord Viñëu is situated in everyone's heart and is the leader of all demigods, including Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä. "We think that to kill Lord Viñëu is to persecute the great sages and brähmaëas," said the ministers.

Thus being advised by the demonic ministers, Kaàsa, who was from the very beginning the greatest rascal, decided to persecute the brähmaëas and Vaiñëavas, being entrapped by the shackles of all-devouring, eternal time. He ordered the demons to harass all kinds of saintly persons, and then he entered his house. The adherents of Kaàsa were all influenced by the modes of passion as well as illusioned by the modes of ignorance, and their only business was to create enmity with saintly persons. Such activities can only reduce the duration of life. The demons accelerated the process and invited their deaths as soon as possible. The result of persecuting saintly persons is not only untimely death. The act is so offensive that the actor also gradually loses his beauty, his fame and his religious principles, and his promotion to higher planets is also checked. Driven by various kinds of mental concoctions, the demons diminish all kinds of welfare. An offense at the lotus feet of the devotees and brähmaëas is a greater offense than that committed at the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Thus a godless civilization becomes the source of all calamities.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fourth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kaàsa Begins His Persecutions."

KB 1970-1-5 / Meeting of Nanda and Vasudeva

5 /Meeting of Nanda and Vasudeva

Although Kåñëa was the real son of Vasudeva and Devaké, because of Kaàsa's atrocious activities Vasudeva could not enjoy the birth ceremony of his son. But Nanda Mahäräja, the foster father, celebrated the birth ceremony of Kåñëa very joyfully. The next day, it was declared that a male child was born of Yaçodä. According to Vedic custom, Nanda Mahäräja called for learned astrologers and brähmaëas to perform the birth ceremony. After the birth of a child, the astrologers calculate the moment of the birth and make a horoscope of the child's future life. Another ceremony takes place after the birth of the child: the family members take baths, cleanse themselves and decorate themselves with ornaments and garlands; then they come before the child and the astrologer to hear of the future life of the child. Nanda Mahäräja and other members of the family dressed and sat down in front of the birth place. All the brähmaëas who were assembled there on this occasion chanted auspicious mantras, according to the rituals, while the astrologers performed the birth ceremony. All the demigods are also worshiped on this occasion, as well as the forefathers of the family. Nanda Mahäräja distributed 200,000 well decorated, dressed and ornamented cows to the brähmaëas. He not only gave cows in charity, but hills of grains, decorated with golden-bordered garments and many ornaments.

In the material world we possess riches and wealth in many ways, but sometimes not in very honest and pious ways, because that is the nature of accumulating wealth. According to Vedic injunction, therefore, such wealth should be purified by giving cows and gold in charity to the brähmaëas. A newborn child is also purified by giving grains in charity to the brähmaëas. In this material world it is to be understood that we are always living in a contaminated state. We therefore have to purify the duration of our lives, our possession of wealth and ourselves. The duration of life is purified by taking daily bath and cleansing the body inside and outside and accepting the ten kinds of purificatory processes. By austerities, by worship of the Lord, and by distribution of charity, we can purify the possession of wealth. We can purify ourselves by studying the Vedas, by striving for self-realization and by understanding the Supreme Absolute Truth. It is therefore stated in the Vedic literature that by birth everyone is born a çüdra, and by accepting the purificatory process one becomes twice-born. By studies of the Vedas one can become vipra, which is the preliminary qualification for becoming a brähmaëa. When one understands the Absolute Truth in perfection, he is called a brähmaëa. And when the brähmaëa reaches further perfection, he becomes a Vaiñëava or a devotee.

In that ceremony, all the brähmaëas assembled began to chant different kinds of Vedic mantras to invoke all good fortune for the child. There are different kinds of chanting known as süta, mägadha, vandé, and virudävalé. Along with this chanting of mantras and songs, bugles and kettledrums sounded outside the house. On this occasion, the joyous vibrations could be heard in all the pasturing grounds and all the houses. Within and outside of the houses there were varieties of artistic paintings, done with rice pulp, and scented water was sprinkled everywhere, even on the roads and streets. Ceilings and roofs were decorated with different kinds of flags, festoons and green leaves. The gates were made of green leaves and flowers. All the cows, bulls and calves were smeared with a mixture of oil and turmeric and painted with minerals like red oxide, yellow clay and manganese. They wore garlands of peacock feathers, and were covered with nice colored dresses and gold necklaces.

When all the ecstatic cowherd men heard that Nanda Mahäräja, father of Kåñëa, was celebrating the birth ceremony of his son, they became spontaneously joyful. They dressed themselves with very costly garments and ornamented their bodies with different kinds of earrings and necklaces and wore great turbans on their heads. After dressing themselves in this gorgeous way, they took various kinds of presentations and thus approached the house of Nanda Mahäräja.

As soon as they heard that mother Yaçodä had given birth to a child, all the cowherd women became overwhelmed with joy, and they also dressed themselves with various kinds of costly garments and ornaments and smeared scented cosmetics on their bodies.

As the dust on the lotus flower exhibits the exquisite beauty of the flower, all the gopés (cowherd girls) applied the dust of kuìkuma on their lotus-like faces. These beautiful gopés took their different presentations and very soon reached the house of Mahäräja Nanda. Overburdened with their heavy hips and swollen breasts, the gopés could not proceed very quickly towards the house of Nanda Mahäräja, but out of ecstatic love for Kåñëa they began to proceed as quickly as possible. Their ears were decorated with pearl rings, their necks were decorated with jewel padlocks, their lips and eyes were decorated with different kinds of lipstick and ointment, and their hands were decorated with nice golden bangles. As they were very hastily passing over the stone road, the flower garlands which were decorating their bodies fell to the ground, and it appeared that a shower of flowers was falling from the sky. From the movement of the different kinds of ornaments on their bodies, they were looking still more beautiful. In this way, they all reached the house of Nanda-Yaçodä and blessed the child: "Dear child, You live long just to protect us." While they were blessing child Kåñëa in this way, they offered a mixture of turmeric powder with oil, yogurt, milk and water. They not only sprinkled this mixture on the body of child Kåñëa but on all other persons who were present there. Also on that auspicious occasion, there were different bands of expert musicians playing.

When the cowherd men saw the pastimes of the cowherd women, they became very joyful, and in response they also began to throw yogurt, milk, clarified butter and water upon the bodies of the gopés. Then both parties began to throw butter on each other's bodies. Nanda Mahäräja was also very happy to see the pastimes of the cowherd men and women, and he became very liberal in giving charity to the different singers who were assembled there. Some singers were reciting great verses from the Upaniñads and Puräëas, some were glorifying the family ancestors, and some were singing very sweet songs. There were also many learned brähmaëas present, and Nanda Mahäräja, being very satisfied on this occasion, began to give them different kinds of garments, ornaments, and cows in charity.

It is very important to note in this connection how wealthy the inhabitants of Våndävana were simply by raising cows. All the cowherd men belonged to the vaiçya community, and their business was to protect the cows and cultivate crops. By their dress and ornaments and by their behavior, it appears that although they were in a small village, they still were rich in material possessions. They possessed such an abundance of various kinds of milk products that they were throwing butter lavishly on each other's bodies without restriction. Their wealth was in milk, yogurt, clarified butter and many other milk products, and by trading their agricultural products, they were rich in various kinds of jewelry, ornaments and costly dresses. Not only did they possess all these things, but they could give them away in charity, as did Nanda Mahäräja.

Thus Nanda Mahäräja, the foster father of Lord Kåñëa, began to satisfy the desires of all the men assembled there. He respectively received them and gave them in charity whatever they desired. The learned brähmaëas, who had no other source of income, were completely dependent of the vaiçya and kñatriya communities for their maintenance, and they received gifts on such festive occasions as birthdays, marriages, etc. While Nanda Mahäräja was worshiping Lord Viñëu on this occasion and was trying to satisfy all the people there, his only desire was that the newborn child Kåñëa would be happy. Nanda Mahäräja had no knowledge that this child was the origin of Viñëu, but he was praying to Lord Viñëu to protect Him.

Rohiëédevé, mother of Balaräma, was the most fortunate wife of Vasudeva. She was away from her husband, yet just to congratulate Mahäräja Nanda on the occasion of the birth ceremony of his son, Kåñëa, she dressed herself very nicely. Wearing a garland, a necklace and other bodily ornaments, she appeared on the scene and moved hither and thither. According to the Vedic system, a woman whose husband is not at home does not dress herself very nicely. But although Rohiëé's husband was away, she still dressed herself on this occasion.

From the opulence of the birth ceremony of Kåñëa, it is very clear that at that time Våndävana was rich in every respect. Because Lord Kåñëa took birth in the house of King Nanda and mother Yaçodä, the goddess of fortune was obliged to manifest her opulences in Våndävana. It appeared that Våndävana had already become a site for the pastimes of the goddess of fortune.

After the birth ceremony, Nanda Mahäräja decided to go to Mathurä to pay the annual tax to the government of Kaàsa. Before leaving, he called for the able cowherd men of the village and asked them to take care of Våndävana in his absence. When Nanda Mahäräja arrived in Mathurä, Vasudeva got the news and was very eager to congratulate his friend. He immediately went to the place where Nanda Mahäräja was staying. When Vasudeva saw Nanda, he felt that he had regained his life. Nanda, overwhelmed with joy, immediately stood up and embraced Vasudeva. Vasudeva was received very warmly and offered a nice place to sit. At that time Vasudeva was anxious about his two sons who had been put under the protection of Nanda without Nanda's knowledge. With great anxiety, Vasudeva inquired about them. Both Balaräma and Kåñëa were the sons of Vasudeva. Balaräma was transferred to the womb of Rohiëé, Vasudeva's own wife, but Rohiëé was kept under the protection of Nanda Mahäräja. Kåñëa was personally delivered to Yaçodä and exchanged with her daughter. Nanda Mahäräja knew that Balaräma was the son of Vasudeva, although he did not know that Kåñëa was also Vasudeva's son. But Vasudeva was aware of this fact and inquired very eagerly about Kåñëa and Balaräma.

Vasudeva then addressed him, "My dear brother, you were old enough and very anxious to beget a son, and yet you had none. Now by the grace of the Lord you are fortunate to have a very nice son. I think that this incident is very auspicious for you. Dear friend, I was imprisoned by Kaàsa, and now I am released; therefore this is another birth for me. I had no hope of seeing you again, but by God's grace I can see you." Vasudeva then expressed his anxiety about Kåñëa. Kåñëa was sent incognito to the bed of mother Yaçodä, and after very pompously celebrating His birth ceremony, Nanda went to Mathurä. So Vasudeva was very pleased and said, "This is a new birth for me." He never expected that Kåñëa would live because all his other sons were killed by Kaàsa.

Vasudeva continued, "My dear friend, it is very difficult for us to live together. Although we have our family and relatives, sons and daughters, by nature's way we are generally separated from one another. The reason for this is that every living entity appears on this earth under different pressures of fruitive activities; although they assemble together, there is no certainty of their remaining together for a long time. According to one's fruitive activities, one has to act differently and thereby be separated. For example, many plants and creepers are floating on the waves of the ocean. Sometimes they come together and sometimes they separate forever: one plant goes one way and another plant goes another. Similarly, our family assembly may be very nice while we are living together, but after some time, in the course of the waves of time, we are separated."

The purport of this expression by Vasudeva is this: although he had eight sons born in the womb of Devaké, unfortunately they were all gone. He could not even keep his one son Kåñëa with him. Vasudeva was feeling His separation, but he could not express the real fact. "Please tell me about the welfare of Våndävana," he said. "You have many animals—are they happy? Are they getting sufficient grass and water? Please also let me know whether the place where you are now living is undisturbed and peaceful." This inquiry was made by Vasudeva because he was very anxious about Kåñëa's safety. He knew that Kaàsa and his followers were trying to kill Kåñëa by sending various kinds of demons. They had already resolved that all children born within ten days of the birthday of Kåñëa should be killed. Because Vasudeva was so anxious about Kåñëa, he inquired about the safety of His residence. He also inquired about Balaräma and His mother Rohiëé, who were entrusted to the care of Nanda Mahäräja. Vasudeva also reminded Nanda Mahäräja that Balaräma did not know His real father. "He knows you as His father. And now you have another child, Kåñëa, and I think you are taking very nice care for both of Them." It is also significant that Vasudeva inquired about the welfare of Nanda Mahäräja's animals. The animals, and especially the cows, were protected exactly in the manner of one's children. Vasudeva was a kñatriya, and Nanda Mahäräja was a vaiçya. It is the duty of the kñatriya to give protection to the citizens of mankind, and it is the duty of the vaiçyas to give protection to the cows. The cows are as important as the citizens. Just as the human citizens should be given all kinds of protection, so the cows also should be given full protection.

Vasudeva continued to say that the maintenance of religious principles, economic development and the satisfactory execution of meeting the demands of the senses depend on cooperation among relatives, nations and all humanity. Therefore, it is everyone's duty to see that his fellow citizens and the cows are not put into difficulty. One should see to the peace and comfort of his fellow man and the animals. The development of religious principles, economic development and sense gratification can then be achieved without difficulty. Vasudeva expressed his sorrow due to not being able to give protection to his own sons born of Devaké. He was thinking that religious principles, economic development and the satisfaction of his senses were therefore all lost.

On hearing this, Nanda Mahäräja replied, "My dear Vasudeva, I know that you are very much aggrieved because the cruel king Kaàsa has killed all your sons born of Devaké. Although the last child was a daughter, Kaàsa could not kill her, and she has entered into the celestial planets. My dear friend, do not be aggrieved; we are all being controlled by our past unseen activities. Everyone is subjected to his past deeds, and one who is conversant with the philosophy of karma and its reaction is a man in knowledge. Such a person will not be aggrieved at any incident, happy or miserable."

Vasudeva then replied, "My dear Nanda, if you have already paid the government taxes, then return soon to your place, because I think that there may be some disturbances in Gokula."

After the friendly conversation between Nanda Mahäräja and Vasudeva, Vasudeva returned to his home. The cowherd men headed by Nanda Mahäräja, who had come to Mathurä to pay their taxes, also returned.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fifth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Meeting of Nanda and Vasudeva."

KB 1970-1-6 / Pütanä Killed

6 / Pütanä Killed

While Nanda Mahäräja was returning home, he considered Vasudeva's warning that there might be some disturbance in Gokula. Certainly the advice was friendly and not false. So Nanda thought, "There is some truth in it." Therefore, out of fear, he began to take shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is quite natural for a devotee in danger to think of Kåñëa because he has no other shelter. When a child is in danger, he takes shelter of his mother or father. Similarly, a devotee is always under the shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but when he specifically sees some danger, he remembers the Lord very rapidly.

After consulting with his demonic ministers, Kaàsa instructed a witch named Pütanä, who knew the black art of killing small children by ghastly sinful methods, to kill all kinds of children in the cities, villages and pasturing grounds. Such witches can play their black art only where there is no chanting or hearing of the holy name of Kåñëa. It is said that wherever the chanting of the holy name of Kåñëa is done, even negligently, all bad elements—witches, ghosts, and dangerous calamaties—immediately disappear. And this is certainly true of the place where the chanting of the holy name of Kåñëa is done seriously—especially in Våndävana when the Supreme Lord was personally present. Therefore, the doubts of Nanda Mahäräja were certainly based on affection for Kåñëa. Actually there was no danger from the activities of Pütanä, despite her powers. Such witches are called khecaré, which means they can fly in the sky. This black art of witchcraft is still practiced by some women in the remote northwestern side of India. They can transfer themselves from one place to another on the branch of an uprooted tree. Pütanä knew this witchcraft, and therefore she is described in the Bhägavatam as khecaré.

Pütanä entered the county of Gokula, the residential quarter of Nanda Mahäräja, without permission. Dressing herself just like a beautiful woman, she entered the house of mother Yaçodä. She appeared very beautiful with raised hips, nicely swollen breasts, earrings, and flowers in her hair. She looked especially beautiful on account of her thin waist. She was glancing at everyone with very attractive looks and smiling face, and all the residents of Våndävana were captivated. The innocent cowherd women thought that she was a goddess of fortune appearing in Våndävana with a lotus flower in her hand. It seemed to them that she had personally come to see Kåñëa, who is her husband. Because of her exquisite beauty, no one checked her movement, and therefore she freely entered the house of Nanda Mahäräja. Pütanä, the killer of many, many children, found baby Kåñëa lying on a small bed, and she could at once perceive that the baby was hiding His unparalleled potencies. Pütanä thought, "This child is so powerful that He can destroy the whole universe immediately."

Pütanä's understanding is very significant. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is situated in everyone's heart. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [10.10] that He gives one necessary intelligence, and He also causes one to forget. Pütanä was immediately aware that the child whom she was observing in the house of Nanda Mahäräja was the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself. He was lying there as a small baby, but that does not mean that He was less powerful. The materialistic theory that God-worship is anthropomorphic is not correct. No living being can become God by undergoing meditation or austerities. God is always God. Kåñëa as the child-baby is as complete as He is as a full-fledged youth. The Mäyävädé theory holds that the living entity was formerly God but has now become overwhelmed by the influence of mäyä. Therefore they say that presently he is not God, but when the influence of mäyä is taken away, then he again becomes God. This theory cannot be applied to the minute living entities. The living entities are minute parts and parcels of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; they are minute particles or sparks of the supreme fire, but are not the original fire, or Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, even from the beginning of His appearance in the house of Vasudeva and Devaké.

Kåñëa showed the nature of a small baby and closed His eyes, as if to avoid the face of Pütanä. This closing of the eyes is interpreted and studied in different ways by the devotees. Some say that Kåñëa closed His eyes because He did not like to see the face of Pütanä, who had killed so many children and who had now come to kill Him. Others say that something extraordinary was being dictated to her, and in order to give her assurance, Kåñëa closed His eyes so that she would not be frightened. And yet others interpret in this way: Kåñëa appeared to kill the demons and give protection to the devotees, as it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä: pariträëäya sädhünäà véëäçäya ca duñkåtäm. The first demon to be killed was a woman. According to Vedic rules, the killing of a woman, a brähmaëa, cows, or of a child, is forbidden. Kåñëa was obliged to kill the demon Pütanä, and because the killing of a woman is forbidden according to Vedic Çästra, He could not help but close His eyes. Another interpretation is that Kåñëa closed His eyes because He simply took Pütanä to be His nurse. Pütanä came to Kåñëa just to offer her breast for the Lord to suck. Kåñëa is so merciful that even though He knew Pütanä was there to kill Him, He took her as His nurse or mother.

There are seven kinds of mothers according to Vedic injunction: the real mother, the wife of a teacher or spiritual master, the wife of a king, the wife of a brähmaëa, the cow, the nurse, and the mother earth. Because Pütanä came to take Kåñëa on her lap and offer her breast's milk to be sucked by Him, she was accepted by Kåñëa as one of His mothers. That is considered to be another reason He closed His eyes: He had to kill a nurse or mother. But His killing of His mother or nurse was no different from His love for His real mother or foster mother Yaçodä. We further understand from Vedic information that Pütanä was also treated as a mother and given the same facility as Yaçodä. As Yaçodä was given liberation from the material world, so Pütanä was also given liberation. When the baby Kåñëa closed His eyes, Pütanä took Him on her lap. She did not know that she was holding death personified. If a person mistakes a snake for a rope, he dies. Similarly, Pütanä killed so many babies before meeting Kåñëa, but now she was accepting the snake that would kill her immediately.

When Pütanä was taking baby Kåñëa on her lap, both Yaçodä and Rohiëé were present, but they did not forbid her because she was so beautifully dressed and because she showed motherly affection towards Kåñëa. They could not understand that she was a sword within a decorated case. Pütanä had smeared a very powerful poison on her breasts, and immediately after taking the baby on her lap, she pushed her breastly nipple within His mouth. She was hoping that as soon as He would suck her breast, He would die. But baby Kåñëa very quickly took the nipple in anger. He sucked the milk-poison along with the life air of the demon. In other words, Kåñëa simultaneously sucked the milk from her breast and killed her by sucking out her life. Kåñëa is so merciful that because the demon Pütanä came to offer her breast-milk to Him, He fulfilled her desire and accepted her activity as motherly. But to stop her from further nefarious activities, He immediately killed her. And because the demon was killed by Kåñëa, she got liberation. When Kåñëa sucked out her very breath, Pütanä fell down on the ground, spread her arms and legs and began to cry, "Oh child, leave me, leave me!" She was crying loudly and perspiring, and her whole body became wet.

As she died, screaming, there was a tremendous vibration both on the earth and in the sky, in all directions, and people thought that thunderbolts were falling. Thus the nightmare of the Pütanä witch was over, and she assumed her real feature as a great demon. She opened her fierce mouth and spread her arms and legs all over. She fell exactly as Våträsura when struck by the thunderbolt of Indra. The long hair on her head was scattered all over her body. Her fallen body extended up to twelve miles and smashed all the trees to pieces, and everyone was struck with wonder upon seeing this gigantic body. Her teeth appeared just like ploughed roads, and her nostrils appeared just like mountain caves. Her breasts appeared like small hills, and her hair was a vast reddish bush. Her eye sockets appeared like blind wells, and her two thighs appeared like two banks of a river; her two hands appeared like two strongly constructed bridges, and her abdomen seemed like a dried-up lake. All the cowherd men and women became struck with awe and wonder upon seeing this. And the tumultuous sound of her falling shocked their brains and ears and made their hearts beat strongly.

When the gopés saw little Kåñëa fearlessly playing on Pütanä's lap, they very quickly came and picked Him up. Mother Yaçodä, Rohiëé, and other elderly gopés immediately performed the auspicious rituals by taking the tail of a cow and circumambulating His body. The child was completely washed with the urine of a cow, and the dust created by the hooves of the cows was thrown all over His body. This was all just to save little Kåñëa from future inauspicious accidents. This incident gives us a clear indication of how important the cow is to the family, society and to living beings in general. The transcendental body of Kåñëa did not require any protection, but to instruct us on the importance of the cow, the Lord was smeared over with cow dung, washed with the urine of a cow, and sprinkled with the dust upraised by the walking of the cows.

After this purificatory process, the gopés, headed by mother Yaçodä and Rohiëé, chanted twelve names of Viñëu to give Kåñëa's body full protection from all evil influences. They washed their hands and feet and sipped water three times, as is the custom before chanting mantra. They chanted as follows: "My dear Kåñëa, may the Lord who is known as Maëimän protect Your thighs; may Lord Viñëu who is known as Yajïa protect Your legs; may Lord Acyuta protect Your arms; may Lord Hayagréva protect Your abdomen; may Lord Keçava protect Your heart; may Lord Viñëu protect Your arms; may Lord Urukrama protect Your face; may Lord Éçvara protect Your head; may Lord Cakradhara protect Your front; may Lord Gadädhara protect Your back; may Lord Madhusüdana who carries a bow in His hand protect Your eyesight; may Lord Viñëu with His conchshell protect Your left side; may the Personality of Godhead Upendra protect You from above, and may Lord Tärkñya protect You from below the earth; may Lord Haladhara protect You from all sides; may the Personality of Godhead known as Håñékeça protect all Your senses; may Lord Näräyaëa protect Your breath; and may the Lord of Çvetadvépa, Näräyaëa, protect Your heart; may Lord Yogeçvara protect Your mind; may Lord Påçnigarbha protect Your intelligence, and may the Supreme Personality of Godhead protect Your soul. While You are playing, may Lord Govinda protect You from all sides, and when You are sleeping, may Lord Mädhava protect You from all danger; when You are working may the Lord of Vaikuëöha protect You from falling down; when You are sitting, may the Lord of Vaikuëöha give You all protection; and while You are eating, may the Lord of all sacrifices give You all protection."

Thus mother Yaçodä began to chant different names of Viñëu to protect the child Kåñëa's different bodily parts. Mother Yaçodä was firmly convinced that she should protect her child from different kinds of evil spirits and ghosts—namely Òäkinés, Yätudhänés, Küñmäëòäs, Yakñas, Räkñasas, Véëäyakas, Koöarä, Revaté, Jyeñöhä, Pütanä, Mätåkäs, Unmädas and similar other evil spirits who cause persons to forget their own existence and give trouble to the life-air and the senses. Sometimes they appear in dreams and cause much perturbation; sometimes they appear as old women and suck the blood of small children. But all such ghosts and evil spirits cannot remain where there is chanting of the holy name of God. Mother Yaçodä was firmly convinced of the Vedic injunctions about the importance of cows and the holy name of Viñëu; therefore she took all shelter in the cows and the name of Viñëu just to protect her child Kåñëa. She recited all the holy names of Viñëu so that He might save the child. Vedic culture has taken advantage of keeping cows and chanting the holy name of Viñëu since the beginning of history, and persons who are still following the Vedic ways, especially the householders, keep at least one dozen cows and worship the Deity of Lord Viñëu, who is installed in their house.

The elderly gopés of Våndävana were so absorbed in affection for Kåñëa that they wanted to save Him, although there was no need to, for He had already protected Himself. They could not understand that Kåñëa was the Supreme Personality of Godhead playing as a child. After performing the formalities to protect the child, mother Yaçodä took Kåñëa and let Him suck her own breast. When the child was protected by Viñëu mantra, mother Yaçodä felt that He was safe. In the meantime, all the cowherd men who went to Mathurä to pay tax returned home and were struck with wonder at seeing the gigantic dead body of Pütanä.

Nanda Mahäräja recalled the prophecy of Vasudeva and considered him a great sage and mystic yogi; otherwise, how could he have foretold an incident that happened during his absence from Våndävana. After this, all the residents of Vraja cut the gigantic body of Pütanä into pieces and piled it up with wood for burning. When all the limbs of Pütanä's body were burning, the smoke emanating from the fire created a good aroma. This aroma was due to her being killed by Kåñëa. This means that the demon Pütanä was washed of all her sinful activities and attained a celestial body. Here is an example of how the Supreme Personality of Godhead is all good: Pütanä came to kill Kåñëa, but because He sucked her milk, she was immediately purified, and her dead body attained a transcendental quality. Her only business was to kill small children; she was only fond of blood. But in spite of being envious of Kåñëa, she attained salvation because she gave her milk to Him to drink. So what can be said of others who are affectionate to Kåñëa in the relationship of mother or father?

The pure devotees always serve Kåñëa with great love and affection, for He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Supersoul of every living entity. It is concluded therefore that even a little energy expended in the service of the Lord gives one immense transcendental profit. This is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä: svalpam apy asya dharmasya. Devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness is so sublime that even a little service to Kåñëa, knowingly or unknowingly, gives one the greatest benefit. The system of worshiping Kåñëa by offering flowers from a tree is also beneficial for the living entity who is confined to the bodily existence of that tree. When flowers and fruits are offered to Kåñëa, the tree that bore them also receives much benefit, indirectly. The arcanä process, or worshiping procedure, is therefore beneficial for everyone. Kåñëa is worshipable by great demigods like Brahmä and Lord Çiva, and Pütanä was so fortunate that the same Kåñëa played in her lap as a little child. The lotus feet of Kåñëa, which are worshiped by great sages and devotees, were placed on the body of Pütanä. People worship Kåñëa and offer food, but automatically He sucked the milk from the body of Pütanä. Devotees therefore pray that if simply by offering something as an enemy, Pütanä got so much benefit, then who can measure the benefit of worshiping Kåñëa in love and affection?

One should only worship Kåñëa if for no other reason than so much benefit awaits the worshiper. Although Pütanä was an evil spirit, she gained elevation just like the mother of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is clear that the cows and the elderly gopés who offered milk to Kåñëa were also elevated to the transcendental position. Kåñëa can offer anyone anything, from liberation to anything materially conceivable. Therefore, there cannot be any doubt of the salvation of Pütanä, whose bodily milk was sucked by Kåñëa for such a long time. And how can there be any doubt about the salvation of the gopés who were so fond of Kåñëa? Undoubtedly all the gopés and cowherd boys and cows who served Kåñëa in Våndävana with love and affection were liberated from the miserable condition of material existence.

When all the inhabitants of Våndävana smelled the good aroma from the smoke of the burning Pütanä, they inquired from each other, "Where is this good flavor coming from?" And while conversing, they came to understand that it was the fumes of the burning Pütanä. They were very fond of Kåñëa, and as soon as they heard that the demon Pütanä was killed by Kåñëa, they offered blessings to the little child out of affection. After the burning of Pütanä, Nanda Mahäräja came home and immediately took up the child on his lap and began to smell His head. In this way, he was quite satisfied that his little child was saved from this great calamity. Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé has blessed all persons who hear the narration of the killing of Pütanä by Kåñëa. They will surely attain the favor of Govinda.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Sixth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Pütanä Killed."

KB 1970-1-7 / Salvation of Tåëävarta

7 / Salvation of Tåëävarta

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is always full of six opulences—namely complete wealth, complete strength, complete fame, complete knowledge, complete beauty and complete renunciation. The Lord appears in different complete, eternal forms of incarnation. The conditioned soul has immense opportunity to hear about the transcendental activities of the Lord in these different incarnations. In the Bhagavad-gétä it is said, janma karma ca me divyam. The pastimes and activities of the Lord are not material; they are beyond the material conception. But the conditioned soul can benefit by hearing such uncommon activities. Hearing is an opportunity to associate with the Lord; to hear His activities is to evolve to the transcendental nature—simply by hearing. The conditioned soul has a natural aptitude to hear something about other conditioned souls in the form of fiction, drama and novel. That inclination to hear something about others may be utilized in hearing the pastimes of the Lord. Then one can immediately evolve to his transcendental nature. Kåñëa's pastimes are not only beautiful; they are also very pleasing to the mind.

If someone takes advantage of hearing the pastimes of the Lord, the material contamination of dust, accumulated in the heart due to long association with material nature, can be immediately cleansed. Lord Caitanya also instructed that simply by hearing the transcendental name of Lord Kåñëa, one can cleanse the heart of all material contamination. There are different processes for self-realization, but this process of devotional service—of which hearing is the most important function—when adopted by any conditioned soul, will automatically cleanse him of the material contamination and enable him to realize his real constitutional position. Conditional life is due to this contamination only, and as soon as it is cleared off, then naturally the dormant function of the living entity—rendering service to the Lord—awakens. By developing his eternal relationship with the Supreme Lord, one becomes eligible to create friendship with the devotees. Mahäräja Parékñit recommended, from practical experience, that everyone try to hear about the transcendental pastimes of the Lord. This Kåñëa treatise is meant for that purpose, and the reader may take advantage in order to attain the ultimate goal of human life.

The Lord, out of His causeless mercy, descends on this material world and displays His activities just like an ordinary man. Unfortunately the impious entities or the atheistic class of men consider Kåñëa to be an ordinary man like themselves, and so they deride Him. This is condemned in the Bhagavad-gétä by the Lord Himself when He says, "Avajänanti mäà müòhäù." The müòhas, or the rascals, take Kåñëa to be an ordinary man or a slightly more powerful man; out of their great misfortune, they cannot accept Him as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Sometimes such unfortunate persons misrepresent themselves as incarnations of Kåñëa without referring to the authorized scriptures.

When Kåñëa grew up a little more, He began to turn Himself backside up; He did not merely lie down on His back. And another function was observed by Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja: Kåñëa's first birthday. They arranged for Kåñëa's birthday ceremony, which is still observed by all followers of the Vedic principles. (Kåñëa's birthday ceremony is observed in India by all Hindus, irrespective of different sectarian views.) All the cowherd men and women were invited to participate, and they arrived in jubilation. A nice band played, and the people assembled enjoyed it. All the learned brähmaëas were invited, and they chanted Vedic hymns for the good fortune of Kåñëa. During the chanting of the Vedic hymns and playing of the bands, Kåñëa was bathed by mother Yaçodä. This bathing ceremony is technically called abhiñeka, and even today this is observed in all the temples of Våndävana as Janmäñöamé Day or the birthday anniversary of Lord Kåñëa.

On this occasion, mother Yaçodä arranged to distribute a large quantity of grains, and first-class cows decorated with golden ornaments were made ready to be given in charity to the learned, respectable brähmaëas. Yaçodä took her bath and dressed herself nicely, and taking child Kåñëa, duly dressed and bathed, on her lap, she sat down to hear the Vedic hymns chanted by the brähmaëas. While listening to the chanting of the Vedic hymns, the child appeared to be falling asleep, and therefore mother Yaçodä very silently laid Him down on the bed. Being engaged in receiving all the friends, relatives and residents of Våndävana on that holy occasion, she forgot to feed the child milk. He was crying, being hungry, but mother Yaçodä could not hear Him cry because of the various noises. The child, however, became angry because He was hungry and His mother was not paying attention to Him. So He lifted His legs and began to kick His lotus feet just like an ordinary child. Baby Kåñëa had been placed underneath a hand-driven cart, and while He was kicking His legs, He accidently touched the wheel of the cart, and it collapsed. Various kinds of utensils and brass and metal dishes had been piled up in the hand cart, and they all fell down with a great noise. The wheel of the cart separated from the axle, and the spokes of the wheel were all broken and scattered hither and thither. Mother Yaçodä and all the gopés, as well as Mahäräja Nanda and the cowherd men, were astonished as to how the cart could have collapsed by itself. All the men and women who were assembled for the holy function crowded around and began to suggest how the cart might have collapsed. No one could ascertain the cause, but some small children who were entrusted to play with baby Kåñëa informed the crowd that it was due to Kåñëa's striking His feet against the wheel. They assured the crowd that they had seen how it happened with their own eyes, and they strongly asserted the point. Some were listening to the statement of the small children, but others said, "How can you believe the statements of these children?" The cowherd men and women could not understand that the all-powerful Personality of Godhead was lying there as a baby, and He could do anything. Both the possible and impossible were in His power. While the discussion was going on, baby Kåñëa cried. Without remonstration, mother Yaçodä picked the child up on her lap and called the learned brähmaëas to chant holy Vedic hymns to counteract the evil spirits. At the same time she allowed the baby to suck her breast. If a child sucks the mother's breast nicely, it is to be understood that he is out of all danger. After this, all the stronger cowherd men put the broken cart in order, and all the scattered things were set up nicely as before. The brähmaëas thereafter began to offer oblations to the sacrificial fire with yogurt, butter, kuça grass, and water. They worshiped the Supreme Personality of Godhead for the good fortune of the child.

The brähmaëas who were present at that time were all qualified because they were not envious; they never indulged in untruthfulness, they were never proud, they were nonviolent, and they never claimed any false prestige. They were all bona fide brähmaëas, and there was no reason to think that their blessing would be useless. With firm faith in the qualified brähmaëas, Nanda Mahäräja took his child on his lap and bathed Him with water mixed with various herbs while the brähmaëas chanted hymns from the Åk, Yajus and Säma Vedas.

It is said that without being a qualified brähmaëa, one should not read the mantras of the Vedas. Here is the proof that the brähmaëas were qualified with all the brahminical symptoms. Mahäräja Nanda also had full faith in them. Therefore they were allowed to perform the ritualistic ceremonies by chanting the Vedic mantras. There are many different varieties of sacrifices recommended for different purposes, but the mantras are all to be chanted by qualified brähmaëas. And because in this age of Kali such qualified brähmaëas are not available, all Vedic ritualistic sacrifices are forbidden. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has therefore recommended only one kind of sacrifice in this age—namely saìkértana yajïa, or simply chanting the mahämantra, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare, Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

As the brähmaëas chanted the Vedic hymns and performed the ritualistic ceremonies for the second time, Nanda Mahäräja again gave huge quantities of grains and many cows to them. All the cows which were given in charity were covered with nice gold-embroidered garments, and their horns were bedecked with golden rings; their hooves were covered with silver plate, and they wore garlands of flowers. He gave so many cows just for the welfare of his wonderful child, and the brähmaëas in return bestowed their heart-felt blessing. And the blessings offered by the able brähmaëas were never to be baffled.

One day, shortly after this ceremony, when mother Yaçodä was patting her baby on her lap, the baby felt too heavy, and being unable to carry Him, she unwillingly placed Him on the ground. After a while, she became engaged in household affairs. At that time, one of the servants of Kaàsa, known as Tåëävarta, as instructed by Kaàsa, appeared there in the shape of a whirlwind. He picked the child up on his shoulders and raised a great dust storm all over Våndävana. Because of this, everyone's eyes became covered within a few moments, and the whole area of Våndävana became densely dark so that no one could see himself or anyone else. During this great catastrophe, mother Yaçodä could not see her baby, who was taken away by the whirlwind, and she began to cry very piteously. She fell down on the ground exactly like a cow who has just lost her calf. When mother Yaçodä was so piteously crying, all the cowherd women immediately came and began to look for the baby, but they were disappointed and could not find Him. The Tåëävarta demon who took baby Kåñëa on his shoulder went high in the sky, but the baby assumed such a weight that suddenly he could not go any further, and he had to stop his whirlwind activities. Baby Kåñëa made Himself heavy and began to weigh down the demon. The Lord caught hold of his neck. Tåëävarta felt the baby to be as heavy as a big mountain, and he tried to get out of His clutches, but he was unable to do so, and his eyes popped out from their sockets. Crying very fiercely, he fell down to the ground of Våndävana and died. The demon fell exactly like Tripuräsura, who was pierced by the arrow of Lord Çiva. He hit the stone ground, and His limbs were smashed. His body became visible to all the inhabitants of Våndävana.

When the gopés saw the demon killed and child Kåñëa very happily playing on his body, they immediately picked Kåñëa up with great affection. The cowherd men and women became very happy to get back their beloved child Kåñëa. At that time they began to talk about how wonderful it was that the demon took away the child to devour Him but could not do so; instead he fell down dead. Some of them supported the situation: "This is proper because those who are too sinful die from their sinful reactions, and child Kåñëa is pious; therefore He is saved from all kinds of fearful situations. And we too must have performed great sacrifices in our previous lives, worshiping the Supreme Personality of Godhead, giving great wealth in charity and acting philanthropically for the general welfare of men. Because of such pious activities, the child is saved from all danger."

The gopés assembled there spoke among themselves: "What sort of austerities and penances we must have undergone in our previous lives! We must have worshiped the Supreme Personality of Godhead, offered different kinds of sacrifices, made charities and performed many welfare activities for the public such as growing banyan trees and excavating wells. As a result of these pious activities, we have got back our child, even though He was supposed to be dead. Now He has come back to enliven His relatives." After observing such wonderful happenings, Nanda Mahäräja began to think of the words of Vasudeva again and again.

After this incident, when Yaçodä once was nursing her child and patting Him with great affection, there streamed a profuse supply of milk from her breast, and when she opened the mouth of the child with her fingers, she suddenly saw the universal manifestation within His mouth. She saw within the mouth of Kåñëa the whole sky, including the luminaries, stars in all directions, the sun, moon, fire, air, seas, islands, mountains, rivers, forests, and all other movable and immovable entities. Upon seeing this, mother Yaçodä's heart began to throb, and she murmured within herself, "How wonderful this is!" She could not express anything, but simply closed her eyes. She was absorbed in wonderful thoughts. Kåñëa's showing the universal form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, even when lying down on the lap of His mother, proves that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is always the Supreme Personality of Godhead, whether He is manifested as a child on the lap of His mother or as a charioteer on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. The concoction of the impersonalist, that one can become God by meditation or by some artificial material activities, is herewith declared false. God is always God in any condition or status, and the living entities are always the parts and parcels of the Supreme Lord. They can never be equal to the inconceivable supernatural power of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Seventh Chapter of Kåñëa, "Salvation of Tåëävarta."

KB 1970-1-8 / Vision of the Universal Form

8 / Vision of the Universal Form

After this incident, Vasudeva asked his family priest Gargamuni to visit the place of Nanda Mahäräja in order to astrologically calculate the future life of Kåñëa. Gargamuni was a great saintly sage who underwent many austerities and penances and was appointed priest of the Yadu dynasty. When Gargamuni arrived at the home of Nanda Mahäräja, Nanda Mahäräja was very pleased to see him and immediately stood up with folded hands and offered his respectful obeisances. He received Gargamuni with the feeling of one who is worshiping God or the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He offered him a nice sitting place, and when he sat down, Nanda Mahäräja offered him a warm reception. Addressing him very politely, he said: "My dear brähmaëa, your appearance in a householder's place is only to enlighten. We are always engaged in household duties and are forgetting our real duty of self-realization. Your coming to our house is to give us some enlightenment about spiritual life. You have no other purpose to visit householders." Actually a saintly person or a brähmaëa has no business visiting householders who are always busy in the matter of dollars and cents. If it is asked, "Why don't the householders go to a saintly person or a brähmaëa for enlightenment?" the answer is that householders are very poor-hearted. Generally householders think that their engagement in family affairs is their prime duty and that self-realization or enlightenment in spiritual knowledge is secondary. Out of compassion only, saintly persons and brähmaëas go to householders' homes.

Nanda Mahäräja addressed Gargamuni as one of the great authorities in astrological science. The foretellings of astrological science, such as the occurrence of solar or lunar eclipses, are wonderful calculations, and by this particular science, a person can understand the future very clearly. Gargamuni was proficient in this knowledge. By this knowledge one can understand what his previous activities were, and by the result of such activities one may enjoy or suffer in this life.

Nanda Mahäräja also addressed Gargamuni as the "best of the brähmaëas." A brähmaëa is one who is expert in the knowledge of the Supreme. Without knowledge of the Supreme Absolute, one cannot be recognized as a brähmaëa. The exact word used in this connection is brahmavidäm, which means those who know the Supreme very well. An expert brähmaëa is able to give reformatory facilities to the sub-castes—namely the kñatriyas and vaiçyas. The çüdras observe no reformatory performances. The brähmaëa is considered to be the spiritual master or priest for the kñatriya and vaiçya. Nanda Mahäräja happened to be a vaiçya, and he accepted Gargamuni as a first class brähmaëa. He therefore offered his two foster sons—namely Kåñëa and Balaräma—to Him to purify. He agreed that not only these boys, but all human beings just after birth should accept a qualified brähmaëa as spiritual master.

Upon this request, Gargamuni replied, "Vasudeva has sent me to see to the reformatory performances of these boys, especially Kåñëa's. I am their family priest, and incidentally, it appears to me that Kåñëa is the son of Devaké." By his astrological calculation, Gargamuni could understand that Kåñëa was the son of Devaké but that He was being kept under the care of Nanda Mahäräja, which Nanda did not know. Indirectly he said that Kåñëa, as well as Balaräma, were both sons of Vasudeva. Balaräma was known as the son of Vasudeva because His mother Rohiëé was present there, but Nanda Mahäräja did not know about Kåñëa. Gargamuni indirectly disclosed the fact that Kåñëa was the son of Devaké. Gargamuni also warned Nanda Mahäräja that if he would perform the reformatory ceremony, then Kaàsa, who was naturally very sinful, would understand that Kåñëa was the son of Devaké and Vasudeva. According to astrological calculation, Devaké could not have a female child, although everyone thought that the eighth child of Devaké was female. In this way Gargamuni intimated to Nanda Mahäräja that the female child was born of Yaçodä and that Kåñëa was born of Devaké, and they were exchanged. The female child, or Durgä, also informed Kaàsa that the child who would kill him was already born somewhere else. Gargamuni stated, "If I give your child a name and if He fulfills the prophecy of the female child to Kaàsa, then it may be that the sinful demon will come and kill this child also after the name-giving ceremony. But I do not want to become responsible for all these future calamities."

On hearing the words of Gargamuni, Nanda Mahäräja said, "If there is such danger, then it is better not to plan any gorgeous name-giving ceremony. It would be better for you to simply chant the Vedic hymns and perform the purificatory process. We belong to the twice-born caste, and I am taking this opportunity of your presence. So please perform the name-giving ceremony without external pomp." Nanda Mahäräja wanted to keep the name-giving ceremony a secret and yet take advantage of Gargamuni's performing the ceremony.

When Gargamuni was so eagerly requested by Nanda Mahäräja, he performed the name-giving ceremony as secretly as possible in the cowshed of Nanda Mahäräja. He informed Nanda Mahäräja that Balaräma, the son of Rohiëé, would be very pleasing to his family members and relatives and therefore would be called Räma. In the future He would be extraordinarily strong and therefore would be called Balaräma. Gargamuni said further, "Because your family and the family of the Yadus are so intimately connected and attracted, therefore His name will also be Saìkarñaëa." This means that Gargamuni awarded three names to the son of Rohiëé—namely Balaräma, Saìkarñaëa, and Baladeva. But he carefully did not disclose the fact that Balaräma also appeared in the womb of Devaké and was subsequently transferred to the womb of Rohiëé. Kåñëa and Balaräma are real brothers, being originally sons of Devaké.

Gargamuni then informed Nanda Mahäräja, "As far as the other boy is concerned, this child has taken different bodily complexions in different yugas (millennia). First of all He assumed the color white, then He assumed the color red, then the color yellow and now He has assumed the color black. Besides that, He was formerly the son of Vasudeva; therefore His name should be Väsudeva as well as Kåñëa. Some people will call Him Kåñëa, and some will call Him Väsudeva. But one thing you must know: This son has had many, many other names and activities due to His different pastimes."

Gargamuni gave Nanda Mahäräja a further hint that his son will also be called Giridharé because of His uncommon pastimes of lifting Goverdhana Hill. Since he could understand everything past and future, he said, "I know everything about His activities and name, but others do not know. This child will be very pleasing to all the cowherd men and cows. Being very popular in Våndävana, He will be the cause of all good fortune for you. Because of His presence, you will overcome all kinds of material calamities, despite opposing elements."

Gargamuni continued to say, "My dear King of Vraja, in His previous births, this child many times protected righteous persons from the hands of rogues and thieves whenever there was political disruption. Your child is so powerful that anyone who will become a devotee of your boy will never be troubled by enemies. Just as demigods are always protected by Lord Viñëu, so the devotees of your child will always be protected by Näräyaëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This child will grow in power, beauty, opulence—in everything—on the level of Näräyaëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore I would advise that you protect Him very carefully so that He may grow without disturbance."

Gargamuni further informed Nanda Mahäräja that because he was a great devotee of Näräyaëa, Lord Näräyaëa gave a son who is equal to Him. At the same time he indicated, “Your son will be disturbed by so many demons, so be careful and protect Him.” In this way, Gargamuni convinced Nanda Mahäräja that Näräyaëa Himself had become his son. In various ways he described the transcendental qualities of his son. After giving this information, Gargamuni returned to his home. Nanda Mahäräja began to think of himself as the most fortunate person, and he was very satisfied to be benedicted in this way.

A short time after this incident, both Balaräma and Kåñëa began to crawl on Their hands and knees. When They were crawling like that, They pleased Their mothers. The bells tied to Their waist and ankles sounded fascinating, and They would move around very pleasingly. Sometimes, just like ordinary children, They would be frightened by others and would immediately hurry to Their mothers for protection. Sometimes They would fall into the clay and mud of Våndävana and would approach Their mothers smeared with clay and saffron. They were actually smeared with saffron and sandalwood pulp by Their mothers, but due to crawling over muddy clay, They would simultaneously smear Their bodies with clay. As soon as They would come crawling to their mothers, Yaçodä and Rohiëé would take Them on their laps and, covering the lower portion of their saris, allow Them to suck their breasts. When the babies were sucking their breasts, the mothers would see small teeth coming in. Thus their joy would be intensified to see their children grow. Sometimes the naughty babies would crawl up to the cowshed, catch the tail of a calf and stand up. The calves, being disturbed, would immediately begin running here and there, and the children would be dragged over clay and cow dung. To see this fun, Yaçodä and Rohiëé would call all their neighboring friends, the gopés. Upon seeing these childhood pastimes of Lord Kåñëa, the gopés would be merged in transcendental bliss. In their enjoyment they would laugh very loudly.

Both Kåñëa and Balaräma were so restless that Their mothers Yaçodä and Rohiëé would try to protect Them from cows, bulls, monkeys, water, fire and birds while they were executing their household duties. Always being anxious to protect the children and to execute their duties, they were not very tranquil. In a very short time, both Kåñëa and Balaräma began to stand up and slightly move on Their legs. When Kåñëa and Balaräma began to walk, other friends of the same age joined Them, and together they began to give the highest transcendental pleasure to the gopés, specifically to mother Yaçodä and Rohiëé.

All the gopé friends of Yaçodä and Rohiëé enjoyed the naughty childish activities of Kåñëa and Balaräma in Våndävana. In order to enjoy further transcendental bliss, they all assembled and went to mother Yaçodä to lodge complaints against the restless boys. When Kåñëa was sitting before mother Yaçodä, all the elderly gopés began to lodge complaints against Him so that Kåñëa could hear. They said, "Dear Yaçodä, why don't you restrict your naughty Kåñëa. He comes to our houses along with Balaräma every morning and evening, and before the milking of the cows They let loose the calves, and the calves drink all the milk of the cows. So when we go to milk the cows, we find no milk, and we have to return with empty pots. If we warn Kåñëa and Balaräma about doing this, They simply smile charmingly. We cannot do anything. Also, your Kåñëa and Balaräma find great pleasure in stealing our stock of yogurt and butter from wherever we keep it. When Kåñëa and Balaräma are caught stealing the yogurt and butter, They say, 'Why do you charge us with stealing? Do you think that butter and yogurt are in scarcity in our house?' Sometimes They steal butter, yogurt and milk and distribute them to the monkeys. When the monkeys are well fed and do not take any more, then your boys chide, 'This milk and butter and yogurt are useless—even the monkeys won't take it.' And They break the pots and throw them hither and thither. If we keep our stock of yogurt, butter and milk in a solitary dark place, your Kåñëa and Balaräma find it in the darkness by the glaring effulgence of the ornaments and jewels on Their bodies. If by chance they cannot find the hidden butter and yogurt, They go to our little babies and pinch their bodies so that they cry, and then They go away. If we keep our stock of butter and yogurt high on the ceiling, hanging on a swing, although it is beyond Their reach, They arrange to reach it by piling all kinds of wooden crates over the grinding machine. And if They cannot reach, They make a hole in the pot. We think therefore that you better take all the jeweled ornaments from the bodies of your children."

On hearing this, Yaçodä would say, "All right, I will take all the jewels from Kåñëa so that He can not see the butter hidden in the darkness." Then the gopés would say, "No, no, don't do this. What good will you do by taking away the jewels? We do not know what kind of boys these are, but even without ornaments They spread some kind of effulgence so that even in darkness They can see everything." Then mother Yaçodä would inform them, "All right, keep your butter and yogurt carefully so that They may not reach it." In reply to this, the gopés said, "Yes, actually we do so, but because we are sometimes engaged in our household duties, these naughty boys enter our house somehow or other and spoil everything. Sometimes being unable to steal our butter and yogurt, out of anger They pass urine on the clean floor and sometimes spit on it. Just see your boy now—He is hearing this complaint. All day They simply make arrangements to steal our butter and yogurt, and now They are sitting just like very silent good boys. Just see His face." When mother Yaçodä thought to chastise her boy after hearing all the complaints, she saw His pitiable face, and smiling, she did not chastise Him.

Another day, when Kåñëa and Balaräma were playing with Their friends, all the boys joined Balaräma and told mother Yaçodä that Kåñëa had eaten clay. On hearing this, mother Yaçodä caught hold of Kåñëa's hand and said, "My dear Kåñëa, why have You eaten earth in a solitary place? Just see, all Your friends including Balaräma are complaining about You." Being afraid of His mother, Kåñëa replied, "My dear mother, all these boys, including My elder brother Balaräma, are speaking lies against Me. I have never eaten clay. My elder brother Balaräma, while playing with Me today, became angry, and therefore He has joined with the other boys to complain against Me. They have all combined together to complain so you will be angry and chastise Me. If you think they are truthful, then you can look within My mouth to see whether I have taken clay or not." His mother replied, "All right, if You have actually not taken any clay, then just open Your mouth. I shall see."

When the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa was so ordered by His mother, He immediately opened His mouth just like an ordinary boy. Then mother Yaçodä saw within that mouth the complete opulence of creation. She saw the entire outer space in all directions, mountains, islands, oceans, seas, planets, air, fire, moon and stars. Along with the moon and the stars she also saw the entire elements, water, sky, the extensive ethereal existence along with the total ego and the products of the senses and the controller of the senses, all the demigods, the objects of the senses like sound, smell, etc., and the three qualities of material nature. She also could perceive that within His mouth were all living entities, eternal time, material nature, spiritual nature, activity, consciousness and different forms of the whole creation. Yaçodä could find within the mouth of her child everything necessary for cosmic manifestation. She also saw, within His mouth, herself taking Kåñëa on her lap and having Him sucking her breast. Upon seeing all this, she became struck with awe and began to wonder whether she were dreaming or actually seeing something extraordinary. She concluded that she was either dreaming or seeing the play of the illusory energy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. She thought that she had become mad, mentally deranged, to see all those wonderful things. Then she thought, "It may be cosmic mystic power attained by my child, and therefore I am perplexed by such visions within His mouth. Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead under whose energy bodily self and bodily possessions are conceived." She then said, "Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto Him, under whose illusory energy I am thinking that Nanda Mahäräja is my husband and Kåñëa is my son, that all the properties of Nanda Mahäräja belong to me and that all the cowherd men and women are my subjects. All this misconception is due to the illusory energy of the Supreme Lord. So let me pray to Him that He may protect me always."

While mother Yaçodä was thinking in this high philosophical way, Lord Kåñëa again expanded His internal energy just to bewilder her with maternal affection. Immediately mother Yaçodä forgot all philosophical speculation and accepted Kåñëa as her own child. She took Him on her lap and became overwhelmed with maternal affection. She thus began to think, "Kåñëa is not understandable to the masses through the gross process of knowledge, but He can be received through the Upaniñads and the Vedänta or mystic Yoga system and Saìkhya philosophy." Then she began to think of the Supreme Personality of Godhead as her own begotten child.

Certainly mother Yaçodä had executed many, many pious activities as a result of which she got the Absolute Truth, Supreme Personality of Godhead, as her son who sucked milk from her breast. Similarly, Nanda Mahäräja also must have performed many great sacrifices and pious activities for Lord Kåñëa to become his son and address him as father. But it is surprising that Vasudeva and Devaké did not enjoy the transcendental bliss of Kåñëa's childhood pastimes, although Kåñëa was their real son. The childhood pastimes of Kåñëa are glorified even today by many sages and saintly persons, but Vasudeva and Devaké could not enjoy such childhood pastimes personally. The reason for this was explained by Çukadeva Gosvämé to Mahäräja Parékñit as follows.

When the best of the Vasus of the name Droëa along with his wife Dharä were ordered to increase progeny by Lord Brahmä, they said unto him, "Dear father, we are seeking your benediction." Droëa and Dharä then took benediction from Brahmä that in the future—when they would take birth again within the universe—the Supreme Lord Kåñëa in His most attractive feature of childhood would absorb their whole attention. Their dealings with Kåñëa would be so powerful that simply by hearing of Kåñëa's childhood activities with them, anyone could very easily cross over the nescience of birth and death. Lord Brahmä agreed to give them the benediction, and as a result the same Droëa appeared as Nanda Mahäräja in Våndävana, and the same Dharä appeared as mother Yaçodä, the wife of Nanda Mahäräja.

In this way, Nanda Mahäräja and his wife, mother Yaçodä, developed their unalloyed devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, having gotten Him as their son. And all the gopés and cowherd men who were associates of Kåñëa naturally developed their own different feelings of love for Kåñëa.

Therefore, just to fulfill the benediction of Lord Brahmä, Lord Kåñëa appeared along with His plenary expansion, Balaräma, and performed all kinds of childhood pastimes in order to increase the transcendental pleasure of all residents of Våndävana.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Eighth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Vision of the Universal Form."

KB 1970-1-9 / Mother Yaçodä Binding Lord Kåñëa

9 / Mother Yaçodä Binding Lord Kåñëa

Once upon a time, seeing that her maidservant was engaged in different household duties, mother Yaçodä personally took charge of churning butter. And while she churned butter, she sang the childhood pastimes of Kåñëa and enjoyed thinking of her son.

The end of her sari was tightly wrapped while she churned, and on account of her intense love for her son, milk automatically dripped from her breasts which moved as she labored very hard, churning with two hands. The bangles and bracelets on her hands tinkled as they touched each other, and her earrings and breasts shook. There were drops of perspiration on her face, and the flower garland which was on her head scattered here and there. Before this picturesque sight, Lord Kåñëa appeared as a child. He felt hungry, and out of love for His mother, He wanted her to stop churning. He indicated that her first business was to let Him suck her breast and then churn butter later.

Mother Yaçodä took her son on her lap and pushed the nipples of her breasts into His mouth. And while Kåñëa was sucking the milk, she was smiling, enjoying the beauty of her child's face. Suddenly, the milk which was on the oven began to boil over. Just to stop the milk from spilling, mother Yaçodä at once put Kåñëa aside and went to the oven. Left in that state by His mother, Kåñëa became very angry, and His lips and eyes became red in rage. He pressed His teeth and lips, and taking up a piece of stone, He immediately broke the butter pot. He took butter out of it, and with false tears in His eyes, He began to eat the butter in a secluded place.

In the meantime, mother Yaçodä returned to the churning place after setting the overflowing milk pan in order. She saw the broken pot in which the churning yogurt was kept. Since she could not find her boy, she concluded that the broken pot was His work. She began to smile as she thought, "The child is very clever. After breaking the pot He has left this place, fearing punishment." After she sought all over, she found a big wooden grinding mortar which was kept upside down, and she found her son sitting on it. He was taking butter which was hanging from the ceiling on a swing, and He was feeding it to the monkeys. She saw Kåñëa looking this way and that way in fear of her because He was conscious of His naughty behavior. After seeing her son so engaged, she very silently approached Him from behind. Kåñëa, however, quickly saw her coming at Him with a stick in her hand, and immediately He got down from the grinding mortar and began to flee in fear.

Mother Yaçodä chased Him to all corners, trying to capture the Supreme Personality of Godhead who is never approached even by the meditations of great yogés. In other words, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, who is never caught by the yogés and speculators, was playing just like a little child for a great devotee like mother Yaçodä. Mother Yaçodä, however, could not easily catch the fast-running child because of her thin waist and heavy body. Still she tried to follow Him as fast as possible. Her hair loosened, and the flower in her hair fell to the ground. Although she was tired, she somehow reached her naughty child and captured Him. When He was caught, Kåñëa was almost on the point of crying. He smeared His hands over His eyes, which were anointed with black eye cosmetics. The child saw His mother’s face while she stood over Him, and His eyes became restless from fear. Mother Yaçodä could understand that Kåñëa was unnecessarily afraid, and for His benefit she wanted to allay His fears.

Being the topmost well-wisher of her child, mother Yaçodä began to think, "If the child is too fearful of me, I don't know what will happen to Him." Mother Yaçodä then threw away her stick. In order to punish Him, she thought to bind His hands with some ropes. She did not know it, but it was actually impossible for her to bind the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Mother Yaçodä was thinking that Kåñëa was her tiny child; she did not know that the child had no limitation. There is no inside or outside of Him, nor beginning or end. He is unlimited and all-pervading. Indeed, He is Himself the whole cosmic manifestation. Still, mother Yaçodä was thinking of Kåñëa as her child. Although He is beyond the reach of all senses, she endeavored to bind Him up to a wooden grinding mortar. But when she tried to bind Him, she found that the rope she was using was too short—by two inches. She gathered more ropes from the house and added to it, but at the end she found the same shortage. In this way, she connected all the ropes available at home, but when the final knot was added, she saw that it was still two inches too short. Mother Yaçodä was smiling, but she was astonished. How was it happening?

In attempting to bind her son, she became tired. She was perspiring, and the garland on her head fell down. Then Lord Kåñëa appreciated the hard labor of His mother, and being compassionate upon her, He agreed to be bound up by the ropes. Kåñëa, playing as a human child in the house of mother Yaçodä, was performing His own selected pastimes. Of course no one can control the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The pure devotee surrenders himself unto the lotus feet of the Lord, who may either protect or vanquish the devotee. But for his part, the devotee never forgets his own position of surrender. Similarly, the Lord also feels transcendental pleasure by submitting Himself to the protection of the devotee. This was exemplified by Kåñëa's surrender unto His mother, Yaçodä.

Kåñëa is the supreme bestower of all kinds of liberation to His devotees, but the benediction which was bestowed upon mother Yaçodä was never experienced even by Lord Brahmä or Lord Çiva or the goddess of fortune.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is known as the son of Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja, is never so completely known to the yogés and speculators. But He is easily available to His devotees. Nor is He appreciated as the supreme reservoir of all pleasure by the yogés and speculators.

After binding her son, mother Yaçodä engaged herself in household affairs. At that time, bound up to the wooden mortar, Kåñëa could see a pair of trees before Him which were known as arjuna trees. The great reservoir of pleasure, Lord Çré Kåñëa, thus thought to Himself, "Mother Yaçodä first of all left without feeding Me sufficient milk, and therefore I broke the pot of yogurt and distributed the stock butter in charity to the monkeys. Now she has bound Me up to a wooden mortar. So I shall do something more mischievous than before." And thus He thought of pulling down the two very tall arjuna trees.

There is a history behind the pair of arjuna trees. In their previous lives, the trees were born as the human sons of Kuvera, and their names were Nalaküvara and Maëigréva. Fortunately, they came within the vision of the Lord. In their previous lives they were cursed by the great sage Närada in order to receive the highest benediction of seeing Lord Kåñëa. This benediction-curse was bestowed upon them because of their forgetfulness due to intoxication. This story will be narrated in the next chapter.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Ninth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Mother Yaçodä Binding Lord Kåñëa."

KB 1970-1-10 / Deliverance of Nalaküvara and Maëigréva

10 /Deliverance of Nalaküvara and Maëigréva

The story of the cursing of Nalaküvara and Maëigréva and their deliverance by Kåñëa, under the all-blissful desire of the great sage Närada, is here described.

The two great demigods, Nalaküvara and Maëigréva, were sons of the treasurer of the demigods, Kuvera, who was a great devotee of Lord Çiva. By the grace of Lord Çiva, Kuvera's material opulences had no limit. As a rich man's sons often become addicted to wine and women, so these two sons of Kuvera were also addicted to wine and sex. Once, these two demigods, desiring to enjoy, entered the garden of Lord Çiva in the province of Kailäsa on the bank of Mandäkiné Ganges. There they drank much and engaged in hearing the sweet singing of beautiful women who accompanied them in that garden of fragrant flowers. In an intoxicated condition, they both entered the water of the Ganges, which was full with lotus flowers, and there they began to enjoy the company of the young girls exactly as the male elephant enjoys the female elephants within the water.

While they were thus enjoying themselves in the water, all of a sudden Närada, the great sage, happened to pass that way. He could understand that the demigods Nalaküvara and Maëigréva were too intoxicated and could not even see that he was passing. The young girls, however, were not so intoxicated as the demigods, and they at once became ashamed at being naked before the great sage Närada. They began to cover themselves with all haste. The two demigod-sons of Kuvera were so intoxicated that they could not appreciate the presence of the sage Närada and therefore did not cover their bodies. On seeing the two demigods so degraded by intoxication, Närada desired their welfare, and therefore he exhibited his causeless mercy upon them by cursing them.

Because the great sage was compassionate upon them, he wanted to finish their false enjoyment of intoxication and association with young girls and wanted them to see Lord Kåñëa eye to eye. He conceived of cursing them as follows. He said that the attraction for material enjoyment is due to an increase of the mode of passion. A person in the material world, when favored by the material opulence of riches, generally becomes addicted to three things—intoxication, sex and gambling. Materially opulent men, being puffed up with the accumulation of wealth, also become so merciless that they indulge in killing animals by opening slaughterhouses. And they think that they themselves will never die. Such foolish persons, forgetting the laws of nature, become overly infatuated with the body. They forget that the material body, even though very much advanced in civilization, up to the position of the demigods, will finally be burned to ashes. And while one is living, whatever the external condition of the body may be, within there is only stool, urine and various kinds of worms. Thus being engaged in jealousy and violence to other bodies, materialists cannot understand the ultimate goal of life, and without knowing this goal of life, they generally glide down to a hellish condition. In their next birth, such foolish persons commit all kinds of sinful activities on account of this temporary body, and they are even unable to consider whether this body actually belongs to them. Generally it is said that the body belongs to the persons who feed the body. One might therefore consider whether this body belongs to one personally or to the master to whom one renders service. The master of slaves claims full right to the bodies of the slaves because the master feeds the slaves. It may be questioned then whether the body belongs to the father, who is the seed-giving master of this body, or to the mother, who develops the child's body in her womb.

Foolish persons are engaged in committing all sorts of sins due to the misconception of identifying the material body with the self. But one should be intelligent enough to understand to whom this body belongs. A foolish person indulges in killing other animals to maintain the body, but he does not consider whether this body belongs to him or to his father or mother or grandfather. Sometimes a grandfather or a father gives his daughter in charity to a person with a view of getting back the daughter's child as a son. The body may also belong to a stronger man who forces it to work for him. Sometimes the slave's body is sold to the master on the basis that the body will belong to the master. And at the end of life, the body belongs to the fire, because the body is given to the fire and burned to ashes. Or the body is thrown into the street to be eaten by the dogs and vultures.

Before committing all kinds of sins to maintain the body, one should understand to whom the body belongs. Ultimately it is concluded that the body is a product of material nature, and at the end it merges into material nature; therefore, the conclusion should be that the body belongs to material nature. One should not wrongly think that the body belongs to him. To maintain a false possession, why should one indulge in killing? Why should one kill innocent animals to maintain the body?

When a man is infatuated with the false prestige of opulence, he does not care for any moral instruction but indulges in wine, women and animal killing. In such circumstances, a poverty-stricken man is often better situated because a poor man thinks of himself in relation to other bodies. A poor man often does not wish to inflict injuries to other bodies because he can understand more readily that when he himself is injured he feels pain. As such, the great sage Närada considered that because the demigods Nalaküvara and Maëigréva were so infatuated by false prestige, they should be put into a condition of life devoid of opulence.

A person who has a pinprick in his body does not wish others to be pricked by pins; a considerate man in the life of poverty does not wish others to be also put into that condition. Generally it is seen that one who has risen from a poverty-stricken life and becomes wealthy creates some charitable institution at the end of his life so that other poverty-stricken men might be benefitted. In short, a compassionate poor man may consider others' pains and pleasures with empathy. A poor man may be seldom puffed with false pride, and he may be freed from all kinds of infatuation. He may remain satisfied by whatever he gets for his maintenance by the grace of the Lord.

To remain in the poverty-stricken condition is a kind of austerity. According to Vedic culture, therefore, the brähmaëas, as a matter of routine, keep themselves in a poverty-stricken condition to save themselves from the false prestige of material opulence. False prestige due to advancement of material prosperity is a great impediment for spiritual emancipation. A poverty-stricken man cannot become unnaturally fat by eating more and more. And on account of not being able to eat more than he requires, his senses are not very turbulent. When the senses are not very turbulent, he cannot become violent.

Another advantage of poverty is that a saintly person can easily enter a poor man's house, and thus the poor man can take advantage of the saintly person's association. A very opulent man does not allow anyone to enter his house; therefore, the saintly person cannot enter. According to the Vedic system, a saintly person takes the position of a mendicant so that on the plea of begging something from the householder, he can enter any house. The householder, who has usually forgotten everything about spiritual advancement because he is busy maintaining family affairs, can be benefitted by the association of a saintly person. There is a great chance for the poor man to become liberated through association with a saint. Of what use are persons who are puffed up with material opulence and prestige if they are bereft of the association of saintly persons and devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead?

The great sage Närada thereafter thought that it was his duty to put those demigods into a condition where they could not be falsely proud of their material opulence and prestige. Närada was compassionate and wanted to save them from their fallen life. They were in the mode of darkness, and being therefore unable to control their senses, they were addicted to sex life. It was the duty of a saintly person like Närada to save them from their abominable condition. In animal life, the animal has no sense to understand that he is naked. But Kuvera was the treasurer of the demigods, a very responsible man, and Nalaküvara and Maëigréva were two of his sons. And yet they became so animalistic and irresponsible that they could not understand, due to intoxication, that they were naked. To cover the lower part of the body is a principle of human civilization, and when a man or woman forgets this principle, they become degraded. Närada therefore thought that the best punishment for them was to make them immovable living entities, or trees. Trees are, by nature's laws, immovable. Although trees are covered by the mode of ignorance, they cannot do harm. The great sage Närada thought it fitting that, although the brothers, by his mercy, would be punished to become trees, they continue to keep their memory to be able to know why they were being punished. After changing the body, a living entity generally forgets his previous life, but in special cases, by the grace of the Lord, as with Nalaküvara and Maëigréva, one can remember.

Sage Närada therefore contemplated that the two demigods should remain for one hundred years, in the time of the demigods, in the form of trees, and after that they would be fortunate enough to see the Supreme Personality of Godhead, face to face, by His causeless mercy. And thus they would be again promoted to the life of the demigods and great devotees of the Lord.

After this, the great sage Närada returned to his abode known as Näräyaëa Äçrama, and the two demigods turned into trees, known as twin arjuna trees. The two demigods were favored by the causeless mercy of Närada and given a chance to grow in Nanda's courtyard and see Lord Kåñëa face to face.

Although the child Kåñëa was bound up to the wooden mortar, He began to proceed towards the growing trees in order to fulfill the prophecy of His great devotee Närada. Lord Kåñëa knew that Närada was His great devotee and that the trees standing before Him as twin arjuna trees were actually the sons of Kuvera. "I must now fulfill the words of My great devotee Närada," He thought. Then He began to proceed through the passage between the two trees. Although He was able to pass through the passage, the large wooden mortar stuck horizontally between the trees. Taking advantage of this, Lord Kåñëa began to pull the rope which was tied to the mortar. As soon as He pulled, with great strength, the two trees, with all branches and limbs, fell down immediately with a great sound. Out of the broken, fallen trees came two great personalities, shining like blazing fire. All sides became illuminated and beautiful by their presence. The two purified bodies immediately came before child Kåñëa and bowed down to offer their respects and prayers in the following words.

"Dear Lord Kåñëa, You are the original Personality of Godhead, master of all mystic powers. Learned brähmaëas know very well that this cosmic manifestation is an expansion of Your potencies which are sometimes manifest and sometimes unmanifest. You are the original provider of the life, body and senses of all living entities. You are the eternal God, Lord Viñëu, who is all-pervading, the principal controller of everything. You are the original source of the cosmic manifestation which is acting under the spell of the three modes of material nature—goodness, passion and ignorance. You are living as the Supersoul in all the multi-forms of living entities, and You know very well what is going on within their bodies and minds. Therefore You are the supreme director of all activities of all living entities. But although You are in the midst of everything which is under the spell of the material modes of nature, You are not affected by such contaminated qualities. No one under the jurisdiction of the material modes can understand Your transcendental qualities, which existed before the creation; therefore You are called the Supreme Brahman who is always glorified by His personal internal potencies. In this material world You can be known only by Your different incarnations. Although You assume different types of bodies, these bodies are not part of the material creation. They are always full of transcendental potencies of unlimited opulence, strength, beauty, fame, wisdom and renunciation. In the material existence, there is a difference between the body and the owner of the body, but because You appear in Your original spiritual body, there is no such difference for You. When You appear, Your uncommon activities indicate that You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Such uncommon activities are not possible for anyone in material existence. You are that Supreme Personality of Godhead, now appearing to cause the birth and death as well as liberation of the living entities, and You are full with all Your plenary expansions. You can bestow on everyone all kinds of benediction. O Lord! O source of all fortune and goodness, we offer our respectful obeisances unto You. You are the all-pervading Supreme Personality of Godhead, the source of peace and the supreme person in the dynasty of King Yadu. O Lord, our father known as Kuvera, the demigod, is Your servant. Similarly, the great sage Närada is also Your servitor, and by their grace only we have been able to see You personally. We therefore pray that we may always be engaged in Your transcendental loving service by speaking only about Your glories and hearing about Your transcendental activities. May our hands and other limbs be engaged in Your service and our minds always be concentrated at Your lotus feet and our heads always bowed down before the all-pervading universal form of Your Lordship."

When the demigods Nalaküvara and Maëigréva finished their prayers, the child, Lord Kåñëa, the master and proprietor of Gokula, bound to the wooden grinding mortar by the ropes of Yaçodä, began to smile and said, "It was already known to Me that My great devotee-sage Närada had shown his causeless mercy by saving you from the abominable condition of pride due to possessing extraordinary beauty and opulence in the family of the demigods. He has saved you from gliding down into the lowest condition of hellish life. All these facts are already known to Me. You are very fortunate because you were not only cursed by him, but you had the great opportunity to see him. If someone is able, by chance, to see a great saintly person like Närada face to face, who is always serene and merciful to everyone, then immediately that conditioned soul becomes liberated. This is exactly like being situated in the full light of the sun: there cannot be any visionary impediment. Therefore, O Nalaküvara and Maëigréva, your lives have now become successful because you have developed ecstatic love for Me. This is your last birth within material existence. Now you can go back to your father's residence in the heavenly planet, and by remaining in the attitude of devotional service, you will be liberated in this very life."

After this, the demigods circumambulated the Lord many times and bowed down before Him again and again, and thus they left. The Lord remained bound up with ropes to the grinding mortar.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Tenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Deliverance of Nalaküvara and Maëigréva."

KB 1970-1-11 / Killing the Demons Vatsäsura and Bakäsura

11 / Killing the Demons Vatsäsura and Bakäsura

When the twin arjuna trees fell to the ground, making a sound like the falling of thunderbolts, all the inhabitants of Gokula, including Nanda Mahäräja, immediately came to the spot. They were very much astonished to see how the two great trees had suddenly fallen. Because they could find no reason for their falling down, they were puzzled. When they saw child Kåñëa bound up to the wooden mortar by the ropes of Yaçodä, they began to think that it must have been caused by some demon. Otherwise, how was it possible? At the same time, they were very much perturbed because such uncommon incidences were always happening to the child Kåñëa. While the elderly cowherd men were thus contemplating, the small children who were playing there informed the men that the trees fell due to Kåñëa's pulling the wooden mortar with the ropes to which He was bound. "Kåñëa came in between the two trees," they explained, "and the wooden mortar was topsy-turvied and stuck in between the trees. Kåñëa began to pull the rope, and the trees fell down. When the trees fell down, two very dazzling men came out of the trees, and they began to talk to Kåñëa."

Most of the cowherd men did not believe the statement of the children. They could not believe that such things were at all possible. Some of them, however, believed them and told Nanda Mahäräja, "Your child is different from all other children. He just might have done it." Nanda Mahäräja began to smile, hearing about the extraordinary abilities of his son. He came forward and untied the knot just to free his wonderful child. After being freed by Nanda Mahäräja, Kåñëa was taken onto the laps of the elderly gopés. They took Him away to the courtyard of the house and began to clap, praising His wonderful activities. Kåñëa began to clap along with them, just like an ordinary child. The Supreme Lord Kåñëa, being completely controlled by the gopés, began to sing and dance, just like a puppet in their hands.

Sometimes mother Yaçodä used to ask Kåñëa to bring her a wooden plank for sitting. Although the wooden plank was too heavy to be carried by a child, still somehow or other Kåñëa would bring it to His mother. Sometimes while worshiping Näräyaëa, His father would ask Him to bring his wooden slippers, and Kåñëa, with great difficulty, would put the slippers on His head and bring them to His father. When He was asked to lift some heavy article and was unable to lift it, He would simply move His arms. In this way, daily, at every moment, He was the reservoir of all pleasure to His parents. The Lord was exhibiting such childish activities before the inhabitants of Våndävana because He wanted to show the great philosophers and sages searching after the Absolute Truth how the Supreme Absolute Truth Personality of Godhead is controlled by and subject to the desires of His pure devotees.

One day, a fruit vendor came before the house of Nanda Mahäräja. Upon hearing the vendor call, "If anyone wants fruits please come and take them from me!" child Kåñëa immediately took some grains in His palm and went to get fruits in exchange. In those days exchange was by barter; therefore Kåñëa might have seen His parents exchange fruits and other things by bartering grains, and so He imitated. But His palms were very small, and He was not very careful to hold them tight, so He was dropping the grains. The vendor who came to sell fruits saw this and was very much captivated by the beauty of the Lord, so he immediately accepted whatever few grains were left in His palm and filled His hands with fruits. In this meantime, the vendor saw that his whole basket of fruit had become filled with jewels. The Lord is the bestower of all benediction. If someone gives something to the Lord, he is not the loser; he is the gainer by a million times.

One day Lord Kåñëa, the liberator of the twin arjuna trees, was playing with Balaräma and the other children on the bank of the Yamunä, and because it was already late in the morning, Rohiëé, the mother of Balaräma, went to call them back home. But Balaräma and Kåñëa were so engrossed in playing with Their friends that They did not wish to come back; They just engaged Themselves in playing more and more. When Rohiëé was unable to take Them back home, she went home and sent mother Yaçodä to call Them again. Mother Yaçodä was so affectionate toward her son that as soon as she came out to call Him back home, her breast filled up with milk. She loudly cried, "My dear child, please come back home. Your time for lunch is already past." She then said, "My dear Kåñëa, O my dear lotus-eyed child, please come and suck my breast. You have played enough. You must be very hungry, my dear little child. You must be tired from playing for so long." She also addressed Balaräma thus: "My dear, the glory of Your family, please come back with Your younger brother Kåñëa immediately. You have been engaged in playing since morning, and You must be very tired. Please come back and take Your lunch at home. Your father Nandaraja is waiting for You. He has to eat, so You must come back so that he can eat."

As soon as Kåñëa and Balaräma heard that Nanda Mahäräja was waiting for Them and could not take his food in Their absence, They started to return. Their other playmates complained, "Kåñëa is leaving us just at the point when our playing is at the summit. Next time we shall not allow Him to leave."

His playmates then threatened not to allow Him to play with them again. Kåñëa became afraid, and instead of going back home, He went back again to play with the boys. At that time, mother Yaçodä scolded the children and told Kåñëa, "My dear Kåñëa, do You think that You are a street boy? You have no home? Please come back to Your home! I see that Your body has become very dirty from playing since early morning. Now come home and take Your bath. Besides, today is Your birthday ceremony; therefore You should come back home and give cows in charity to the brähmaëas. Don't You see how Your playmates are decorated with ornaments by their mothers? You should also be cleansed and decorated with nice dress and ornaments. Please, therefore, come back, take Your bath, dress Yourself nicely, and then again You may go on playing."

In this way mother Yaçodä called back Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma who are worshipable by great demigods like Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva. She was thinking of Them as her children.

When mother Yaçodä's children, Kåñëa and Balaräma, came home, she bathed Them very nicely and dressed Them with ornaments. She then called for the brähmaëas, and through her children she gave many cows in charity for the occasion of Kåñëa's birthday. In this way she performed the birthday ceremony of Kåñëa at home.

After this incident, all the elderly members of the cowherd men assembled together, and Nanda Mahäräja presided. They began to consult amongst themselves how to stop great disturbances in the Mahävana on account of the demons. In this meeting, Upananda, brother of Nanda Mahäräja, was present. He was considered to be learned and experienced, and he was a well-wisher of Kåñëa and Balaräma. He was a leader, and he began to address the meeting as follows: "My dear friends! Now we should leave here for another place because we are continually finding that great demons are coming here to disturb the peaceful situation, and they are especially attempting to kill the small children. Just consider Pütanä and Kåñëa. It was simply by the grace of Lord Hari that Kåñëa was saved from the hands of such a great demon. Next the whirlwind demon took Kåñëa away in the sky, but by the grace of Lord Hari He was saved, and the demon fell down on a stone slab and died. Very recently, this child was playing between two trees, and the trees fell down violently, and yet there was no injury to the child. So Lord Hari saved Him again. Just imagine the calamity if this child or any other child playing with Him were crushed by the falling trees! Considering all these incidences, we must conclude that this place is no longer safe. Let us leave. We have all been saved from different calamities by the grace of Lord Hari. Now we should be cautious and leave this place and reside somewhere where we can live peacefully. I think that we should all go to the forest known as Våndävana, where just now there are newly grown plants and herbs. It is very suitable for pasturing ground for our cows, and we and our families, the gopés with their children, can very peacefully live there. Near Våndävana there is Govardhana Hill, which is very beautiful, and there is newly grown grass and fodder for the animals, so there will be no difficulty in living there. I therefore suggest that we start immediately for that beautiful place, as there is no need to waste any more time. Let us prepare all our carts immediately, and, if you like, let us go, keeping all the cows in front."

On hearing the statement of Upananda, all the cowherd men immediately agreed. "Let us immediately go there." Everyone then loaded all their household furniture and utensils on the carts and prepared to go to Våndävana. All the old men of the village, the children and women were arranged on seats, and the cowherd men equipped themselves with bows and arrows to follow the carts. All the cows and bulls along with their calves were placed in the front, and the men surrounded the flocks with their bows and arrows and began to blow on their horns and bugles. In this way, with tumultuous sound, they started for Våndävana.

And who can describe the damsels of Vraja? They were all seated on the carts and were very beautifully dressed with ornaments and costly saris. They began to chant the pastimes of child Kåñëa as usual. Mother Yaçodä and mother Rohiëé were seated on a separate cart, and Kåñëa and Balaräma were seated on their laps. While mother Rohiëé and Yaçodä were riding on the cart, they talked to Kåñëa and Balaräma, and feeling the pleasure of such talks, they looked very, very beautiful.

In this way, after reaching Våndävana, where everyone lives eternally, very peacefully and happily, they encircled Våndävana and kept the carts all together. After seeing the beautiful appearance of Govardhana on the bank of the River Yamunä, they began to construct their places of residence. While those of the same age were walking together and children were talking with their parents, the inhabitants of Våndävana felt very happy.

At this time Kåñëa and Balaräma were given charge of the calves. The first responsibility of the cowherd boys was to take care of the little calves. The boys are trained in this from the very beginning of their childhood. So along with other little cowherd boys, Kåñëa and Balaräma went into the pasturing ground and took charge of the calves and played with Their playmates. While taking charge of the calves, sometimes the two brothers played on Their flutes. And sometimes They played with ämalaké fruits and bael fruits, just like small children play with balls. Sometimes They danced and made tinkling sounds with Their ankle bells. Sometimes They made Themselves into bulls and cows by covering Themselves with blankets. Thus Kåñëa and Balaräma played. The two brothers also used to imitate the sounds of bulls and cows and play at bullfighting. Sometimes They used to imitate the sounds of various animals and birds. In this way, They enjoyed Their childhood pastimes apparently like ordinary, mundane children.

Once, when Kåñëa and Balaräma were playing on the bank of the Yamunä, a demon of the name Vatsäsura assumed the shape of a calf and came there intending to kill the brothers. By taking the shape of a calf, the demon could mingle with other calves. Kåñëa, however, specifically noticed this, and He immediately told Balaräma about the entrance of the demon. Both brothers then followed him and sneaked up upon him. Kåñëa caught hold of the demon-calf by the two hind legs and tail, whipped him around very forcibly and threw him up into a tree. The demon lost his life and fell down from the top of the tree to the ground. When the demon lay dead on the ground, all the playmates of Kåñëa congratulated Him, "Well done, well done," and the demigods in the sky began to shower flowers with great satisfaction. In this way, the maintainers of the complete creation, Kåñëa and Balaräma, used to take care of the calves in the morning every day, and thus They enjoyed Their childhood pastimes as cowherd boys in Våndävana.

All the cowherd boys would daily go to the bank of the River Yamunä to water their calves. Usually, when the calves drank water from the Yamunä, the boys also drank. One day, after drinking, when they were sitting on the bank of the river, they saw a huge animal which looked something like a duck and was as big as a hill. Its top was as strong as a thunderbolt. When they saw that unusual animal, they became afraid of it. The name of this beast was Bakäsura, and he was a friend of Kaàsa's. He appeared on the scene suddenly and immediately attacked Kåñëa with his pointed, sharp beaks and quickly swallowed Him up. When Kåñëa was thus swallowed, all the boys, headed by Balaräma, became almost breathless, as if they had died. But when the Bakäsura demon was swallowing up Kåñëa, he felt a burning fiery sensation in his throat. This was due to the glowing effulgence of Kåñëa. The demon quickly threw Kåñëa up and tried to kill Him by pinching Him in his beaks. Bakäsura did not know that although Kåñëa was playing the part of a child of Nanda Mahäräja, He was still the original father of Lord Brahmä, the creator of the universe. The child of mother Yaçodä, who is the reservoir of pleasure for the demigods and who is the maintainer of saintly persons, caught hold of the beaks of the great gigantic duck and, before His cowherd boy friends, bifurcated his mouth, just as a child very easily splits a blade of grass. From the sky, the denizens of the heavenly planets showered flowers like the cämeli, the most fragrant of all flowers, as a token of their congratulations. Accompanying the showers of flowers was a vibration of bugles, drums and conchshells.

When the boys saw the showering of flowers and heard the celestial sounds, they became struck with wonder. When they saw Kåñëa, they all, including Balaräma, were so pleased that it seemed as if they had regained their very source of life. As soon as they saw Kåñëa coming towards them, they one after another embraced the son of Nanda and held Him to their chests. After this, they assembled all the calves under their charge and began to return home.

When they arrived home, they began to speak of the wonderful activities of the son of Nanda. When the gopés and cowherd men all heard the story from the boys, they felt great happiness because naturally they loved Kåñëa, and hearing about His glories and victorious activities, they became still more affectionate toward Him. Thinking that the child Kåñëa was saved from the mouth of death, they began to see His face with great love and affection. They were full of anxieties, but they could not turn their faces from the vision of Kåñëa. The gopés and the men began to converse amongst themselves about how the child Kåñëa was attacked in so many ways and so many times by so many demons, and yet the demons were killed and Kåñëa was uninjured. They continued to converse amongst themselves about how so many great demons in such fierce bodies attacked Kåñëa to kill Him, but by the grace of Hari, they could not cause even a slight injury. Rather, they died like small flies in a fire. Thus they remembered the words of Gargamuni who foretold, by dint of his vast knowledge of the Vedas and astrology, that this boy would be attacked by many demons. Now they actually saw that this was coming true, word for word.

All the elderly cowherd men, including Nanda Mahäräja, used to talk of the wonderful activities of Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, and they were always so much absorbed in those talks that they forgot the threefold miseries of this material existence. This is the effect of Kåñëa consciousness. What was enjoyed 5,000 years ago by Nanda Mahäräja can still be enjoyed by persons who are in Kåñëa consciousness simply by talking about the transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa and His associates.

Thus both Balaräma and Kåñëa enjoyed Their childhood pastimes, imitating the monkeys of Lord Rämacandra who constructed the bridge over the ocean and Hanumän, who jumped over the water to Ceylon. And They used to imitate such pastimes among Their friends and so happily passed Their childhood life.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Eleventh Chapter of Kåñëa, "Killing the Demons Vatsäsura and Bakäsura."

KB 1970-1-12 / The Killing of the Aghäsura Demon

12 / The Killing of the Aghäsura Demon

Once the Lord desired to go early in the morning with all His cowherd boy friends to the forest, where they were to assemble together and take lunch. As soon as He got up from bed, He blew a buffalo horn and called all His friends together. Keeping the calves before them, they started for the forest. In this way, Lord Kåñëa assembled thousands of His boy friends. They were each equipped with a stick, flute and horn as well as lunch bag, and each of them was taking care of thousands of calves. All the boys appeared very jolly and happy in that excursion. Each and every one of them was attentive for his personal calves. The boys were fully decorated with various kinds of golden ornaments, and out of sporting propensities they began to pick up flowers, leaves, twigs, peacock feathers and red clay from different places in the forest, and they began to dress themselves in different ways. While passing through the forest, one boy stole another boy's lunch package and passed it to a third. And when the boy whose lunch package was stolen came to know of it, he tried to take it back. But one threw it to another boy. This sportive playing went on amongst the boys as childhood pastimes.

When Lord Kåñëa went ahead to a distant place in order to see some specific scenery, the boys behind Him tried to run to catch up and be the first to touch Him. So there was a great competition. One would say, "I will go there and touch Kåñëa," and another would say, "Oh you cannot go. I'll touch Kåñëa first." Some of them played on their flutes or vibrated bugles made of buffalo horn. Some of them gladly followed the peacocks and imitated the onomatopoetic sounds of the cuckoo. While the birds were flying in the sky, the boys ran after the birds' shadows along the ground and tried to follow their exact courses. Some of them went to the monkeys and silently sat down by them, and some of them imitated the dancing of the peacocks. Some of them caught the tails of the monkeys and played with them, and when the monkeys jumped in a tree, the boys also followed. When a monkey showed its face and teeth, a boy imitated and showed his teeth to the monkey. Some of the boys played with the frogs on the bank of the Yamunä, and when, out of fear, the frogs jumped in the water, the boys immediately dove in after them, and they would come out of the water when they saw their own shadows and stand imitating, making caricatures and laughing. They would also go to an empty well and make loud sounds, and when the echo came back, they would call it ill names and laugh.

As stated personally by the Supreme Personality of Godhead in the Bhagavad-gétä, He is realized proportionately by transcendentalists as Brahman, Paramätmä and the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Here, in confirmation of the same statement, Lord Kåñëa, who awards the impersonalist Brahman realization by His bodily effulgence, also gives pleasure to the devotees as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Those who are under the spell of external energy, mäyä, take Him only as a beautiful child. Yet He gave full transcendental pleasure to the cowherd boys who played with Him. Only after accumulating heaps of pious activities, those boys were promoted to personally associate with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Who can estimate the transcendental fortune of the residents of Våndävana? They were personally visualizing the Supreme Personality of Godhead face to face, He whom many yogés cannot find even after undergoing severe austerities, although He is sitting within the heart. This is also confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.38]. One may search for Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead through the pages of the Vedas and Upaniñads, but if one is fortunate enough to associate with a devotee, he can see the Supreme Personality of Godhead face to face. After accumulating pious activities in many, many previous lives, the cowherd boys were seeing Kåñëa face to face and playing with Him as friends. They could not understand that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but they were playing as intimate friends with intense love for Him.

When Lord Kåñëa was enjoying His childhood pastimes with His boy friends, one Aghäsura demon became very impatient. He was unable to see Kåñëa playing, so he appeared before the boys intending to kill them all. This Aghäsura was so dangerous that even the denizens of heaven were afraid of him. Although the denizens of heaven drank nectar daily to prolong their lives, they were afraid of this Aghäsura and were wondering, "When will the demon be killed?" The denizens used to drink nectar to become immortal, but actually they were not confident of their immortality. On the other hand, the boys who were playing with Kåñëa had no fear of the demons. They were free of fear. Any material arrangement for protecting oneself from death is always unsure, but if one is in Kåñëa consciousness, then immortality is confidently assured.

The demon Aghäsura appeared before Kåñëa and His friends. Aghäsura happened to be the younger brother of Pütanä and Bakäsura, and he thought, "Kåñëa has killed my brother and sister. Now I shall kill Him along with all His friends and calves." Aghäsura was instigated by Kaàsa, so he had come with determination. Aghäsura also began to think that when he would offer grains and water in memory of his brother and kill Kåñëa and all the cowherd boys, then automatically all the inhabitants of Våndävana would die. Generally, for the householders, the children are the life and breath force. When all the children die, then naturally the parents also die on account of strong affection for them.

Aghäsura, thus deciding to kill all the inhabitants of Våndävana, expanded himself by the yogic siddhi called mahimä. The demons are generally expert in achieving almost all kinds of mystic powers. In the yoga system, by the perfection called mahima-siddhi, one can expand himself as he desires. The demon Aghäsura expanded himself up to eight miles and assumed the shape of a very fat serpent. Having attained this wonderful body, he stretched his mouth open just like a mountain cave. Desiring to swallow all the boys at once, including Kåñëa and Balaräma, he sat on the path.

The demon in the shape of a big fat serpent expanded his lips from land to sky; his lower lip was touching the ground and his upper lip was touching the clouds. His jaws appeared like a big mountain cave, without limitation, and his teeth appeared just like mountain summits. His tongue appeared to be a broad traffic way, and he was breathing just like a hurricane. The fire of his eyes was blazing. At first the boys thought that the demon was a statue, but after examining it, they saw that it was more like a big serpent lying down in the road and widening his mouth. The boys began to talk among themselves: "This figure appears to be a great animal, and he is sitting in such a posture just to swallow us all. Just see—is it not a big snake that has widened his mouth to eat all of us?"

One of them said, "Yes, what you say is true. This animal's upper lip appears to be just like the sunshine, and its lower lip is just like the reflection of red sunshine on the ground. Dear friends, just look to the right and left hand side of the mouth of the animal. Its mouth appears to be like a big mountain cave, and its height cannot be estimated. The chin is also raised just like a mountain summit. That long highway appears to be its tongue, and inside the mouth it is as dark as in a mountain cave. The hot wind that is blowing like a hurricane is his breathing, and the fishy bad smell coming out from his mouth is the smell of his intestines."

Then they further consulted among themselves: "If we all at one time entered into the mouth of this great serpent, how could it possibly swallow all of us? And even if it were to swallow all of us at once, it could not swallow Kåñëa. Kåñëa will immediately kill him, as He did Bakäsura." Talking in this way, all the boys looked at the beautiful lotus-like face of Kåñëa, and they began to clap and smile. And so they marched forward and entered the mouth of the gigantic serpent.

Meanwhile, Kåñëa, who is the Supersoul within everyone's heart, could understand that the big statuesque figure was a demon. While He was planning how to stop the destruction of His intimate friends, all the boys along with their cows and calves entered the mouth of the serpent. But Kåñëa did not enter. The demon was awaiting Kåñëa's entrance, and he was thinking, "Everyone has entered except Kåñëa, who has killed my brothers and sisters."

Kåñëa is the assurance of safety to everyone. But when He saw that His friends were already out of His hands and were lying within the belly of a great serpent. He became, momentarily, aggrieved. He was also struck with wonder how the external energy works so wonderfully. He then began to consider how the demon should be killed and how he could save the boys and calves. Although there was no factual concern on Kåñëa's part, He was thinking like that. Finally, after some deliberation, He also entered the mouth of the demon. When Kåñëa entered, all the demigods, who had gathered to see the fun and who were hiding within the clouds, began to express their feelings with the words, "Alas! alas!" At the same time, all the friends of Aghäsura, especially Kaàsa, who were all accustomed to eating flesh and blood, began to express their jubilation, understanding that Kåñëa had also entered the mouth of the demon.

While the demon was trying to smash Kåñëa and His companions, Kåñëa heard the demigods crying, "Alas, alas," and He immediately began to expand Himself within the throat of the demon. Although he had a gigantic body, the demon choked by the expanding of Kåñëa. His big eyes moved violently, and he quickly suffocated. His life-air could not come out from any source, and ultimately it burst out of a hole in the upper part of his skull. Thus his life-air passed off. After the demon dropped dead, Kåñëa, with His transcendental glance alone, brought all the boys and calves back to consciousness and came with them out of the mouth of the demon. While Kåñëa was within the mouth of Aghäsura, the demon's spirit soul came out like a dazzling light, illuminating all directions, and waited in the sky. As soon as Kåñëa with His calves and friends came out of the mouth of the demon, that glittering effulgent light immediately merged into the body of Kåñëa within the vision of all the demigods.

The demigods became overwhelmed with joy and began to shower flowers on the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, and thus they worshiped Him. The denizens of heaven began to dance in jubilation, and the denizens in Gandharvaloka began to offer various kinds of prayers. Drummers began to beat drums in jubilation, the brähmaëas began to recite Vedic hymns, and all the devotees of the Lord began to chant the words, "Jaya! Jaya! All glories to the Supreme Personality of Godhead!"

When Lord Brahmä heard those auspicious vibrations which sounded throughout the higher planetary system, he immediately came down to see what had happened. He saw that the demon was killed, and he was struck with wonder at the uncommon glorious pastimes of the Personality of Godhead. The gigantic mouth of the demon remained in an open position for many days and gradually dried up; it remained a spot of pleasure pastimes for all the cowherd boys.

The killing of Aghäsura took place when Kåñëa and all His boy friends were under five years old. Children under five years old are called kaumära. After five years up to the tenth year they are called paugaëòa, and after the tenth year up to the fifteenth year they are called kaiçora. After the fifteenth year, boys are called youths. So for one year there was no discussion of the incident of the Aghäsura demon in the village of Vraja. But when they attained their sixth year, they informed their parents of the incident with great wonder. The reason for this will be clear in the next chapter.

For Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is far greater than such demigods as Lord Brahmä, it is not at all difficult to award one the opportunity of merging with His eternal body. This He awarded to Aghäsura. Aghäsura was certainly the most sinful living entity, and it is not possible for the sinful to merge into the existence of the Absolute Truth. But in this particular case, because Kåñëa entered into Aghäsura's body, the demon became fully cleansed of all sinful reaction. Persons constantly thinking of the eternal form of the Lord in the shape of the Deity or in the shape of a mental form are awarded the transcendental goal of entering into the kingdom of God and associating with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So we can just imagine the elevated position of someone like Aghäsura into whose body the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, personally entered. Great sages, meditators and devotees constantly keep the form of the Lord within the heart, or they see the Deity form of the Lord in the temples; in that way, they become liberated from all material contamination and at the end of the body enter into the kingdom of God. This perfection is possible simply by keeping the form of the Lord within the mind. But in the case of Aghäsura, the Supreme Personality of Godhead personally entered. Aghäsura's position was therefore greater than the ordinary devotee's or the greatest yogi's.

Mahäräja Parékñit, who was engaged in hearing the transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa (who saved the life of Mahäräja Parékñit while he was in the womb of his mother), became more and more interested to hear about Him. And thus he questioned the sage Çukadeva Gosvämé, who was reciting Çrémad-Bhägavatam before the King.

King Parékñit was a bit astonished to understand that the killing of the Aghäsura demon was not discussed for one year, until after the boys attained the paugaëòa age. Mahäräja Parékñit was very inquisitive to learn this, for he was sure that such an incident was due to the working of Kåñëa's different energies.

Generally, the kñatriyas or the administrative class are always busy with their political affairs, and they have very little chance to hear about the transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa. But while Parékñit Mahäräja was hearing these transcendental pastimes, he considered himself to be very fortunate because he was hearing from Çukadeva Gosvämé, the greatest authority on the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Thus being requested by Mahäräja Parékñit, Çukadeva Gosvämé continued to speak about the transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa in the matter of His form, quality, fame and paraphernalia.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twelfth Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Killing of the Aghäsura Demon."

KB 1970-1-13 / The Stealing of the Boys and Calves by Brahmä

13 / The Stealing of the Boys and Calves by Brahmä

Çukadeva Gosvämé was very much encouraged when Mahäräja Parékñit asked him why the cowherd boys did not discuss the death of Aghäsura until after one year had passed. He explained thus: "My dear King, you are making the subject matter of the transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa fresher by your inquisitiveness."

It is said that it is the nature of a devotee to constantly apply his mind, energy, words, ears, etc., in hearing and chanting about Kåñëa. This is called Kåñëa consciousness, and for one who is rapt in hearing and chanting Kåñëa, the subject matter never becomes hackneyed or old. That is the significance of transcendental subject matter in contrast to material subject matter. Material subject matter becomes stale, and one cannot hear a certain subject for a long time; he wants change. But as far as transcendental subject matter is concerned, it is called nityanavanaväyamäna. This means that one can go on chanting and hearing about the Lord and never feel tired but will remain fresh and eager to hear more and more.

It is the duty of the spiritual master to disclose all confidential subject matter to the inquisitive and sincere disciple. Thus Çukadeva Gosvämé began to explain why the killing of Aghäsura was not discussed until one year had passed. Çukadeva Gosvämé told the King, "Now hear of this secret with attention. After saving His friends from the mouth of Aghäsura and after killing the demon, Lord Kåñëa brought His friends to the bank of Yamunä and addressed them as follows: 'My dear friends, just see how this spot is very nice for taking lunch and playing on the soft sandy Yamunä bank. You can see how the lotus flowers in the water are beautifully blown and how they distribute their flavor all around. The chirping of the birds along with cooing of the peacocks, surrounded by the whispering of the leaves in the trees, combine and present sound-vibrations that echo one another. And this just enriches the beautiful scenery created by the trees here. Let us have our lunch in this spot because it is already late and we are feeling hungry. Let the calves remain near us, and let them drink water from the Yamunä. While we engage in our lunch-taking, the calves may engage in eating the soft grasses that are in this spot.' "

On hearing this proposal from Kåñëa, all the boys became very glad and said, "Certainly, let us all sit down here to take our lunch." They then let loose the calves to eat the soft grass. Sitting down on the ground and keeping Kåñëa in the center, they began to open their different boxes brought from home. Lord Çré Kåñëa was seated in the center of the circle, and all the boys kept their faces toward Him. They ate and constantly enjoyed seeing the Lord face to face. Kåñëa appeared to be the whorl of a lotus flower, and the boys surrounding Him appeared to be its different petals. The boys collected flowers, leaves of flowers and the barks of trees and placed them under their different boxes, and thus they began to eat their lunch, keeping company with Kåñëa. While taking lunch, each boy began to manifest different kinds of relations with Kåñëa, and they enjoyed each other's company with joking words. While thus enjoying lunch with His friends, Lord Kåñëa's flute was pushed within the belt of His cloth, and His bugle and cane were pushed in on the left-hand side of His cloth. He was holding a lump of foodstuff prepared with yogurt, butter, rice and pieces of fruit salad in His left palm, which could be seen through His petal-like finger joints. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, who accepts the results of all great sacrifices, was laughing and joking, enjoying lunch with His friends in Våndävana. And thus the scene was being observed by the demigods from heaven. As for the boys, they were simply enjoying transcendental bliss in the company of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

At that time, the calves that were pasturing nearby entered into the deep forest, allured by new grasses, and gradually went out of sight. When the boys saw that the calves were not nearby, they became afraid for their safety, and they immediately cried out, "Kåñëa!" Kåñëa is the killer of fear personified. Everyone is afraid of fear personified, but fear personified is afraid of Kåñëa. By crying out the word "Kåñëa," the boys at once transcended the fearful situation. Out of His great affection, Kåñëa did not want His friends to give up their pleasing lunch engagement and go searching for the calves. He therefore said, "My dear friends, you need not interrupt your lunch. Go on enjoying. I am going personally where the calves are." Thus Lord Kåñëa immediately started to search out the calves in the caves and bushes. He searched in the mountain holes and in the forests, but nowhere could He find them.

At the time when Aghäsura was killed and the demigods were looking on the incident with great surprise, Brahmä, who was born out of the lotus flower growing out of the navel of Viñëu, also came to see. He was surprised how a little boy like Kåñëa could act so wonderfully. Although he was informed that the little cowherd boy was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he wanted to see more glorified pastimes of the Lord, and thus he stole all the calves and cowherd boys and took them to a different place. Lord Kåñëa, therefore, in spite of searching for the calves, could not find them, and He even lost His boy friends on the bank of the Yamunä where they had been taking their lunch. In the form of a cowherd boy, Lord Kåñëa was very little in comparison to Brahmä, but because He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, He could immediately understand that all the calves and boys had been stolen by Brahmä. Kåñëa thought, "Brahmä has taken away all the boys and calves. How can I alone return to Våndävana? The mothers will be aggrieved!"

Therefore in order to satisfy the mothers of His friends as well as to convince Brahmä of the supremacy of the Personality of Godhead, He immediately expanded Himself as the cowherd boys and calves. In the Vedas it is said that the Supreme Personality of Godhead expands Himself in so many living entities by His energy. Therefore it was not very difficult for Him to expand Himself again into so many boys and calves. He expanded Himself to become exactly like the boys, who were of all different features, facial and bodily construction, and who were different in their clothing and ornaments and in their behavior and personal activities. In other words, everyone has different tastes; being individual soul, each person has entirely different activities and behavior. Yet Kåñëa exactly expanded Himself into all the different positions of the individual boys. He also became the calves, who were also of different sizes, colors, activities, etc. This was possible because everything is an expansion of Kåñëa's energy. In the Viñëu Puräëa it is said, parasya brahmaëaù çakti. Whatever we actually see in the cosmic manifestation—be it matter or the activities of the living entities—is simply an expansion of the energies of the Lord, as heat and light are the different expansions of fire.

Thus expanding Himself as the boys and calves in their individual capacities, and surrounded by such expansions of Himself, Kåñëa entered the village of Våndävana. The residents had no knowledge of what had happened. After entering the village, Våndävana, all the calves entered their respective cowsheds, and the boys also went to their respective mothers and homes.

The mothers of the boys heard the vibration of their flutes before their entrance, and to receive them, they came out of their homes and embraced them. And out of maternal affection, milk was flowing from their breasts, and they allowed the boys to drink it. However, their offering was not exactly to their boys but to the Supreme Personality of Godhead who had expanded Himself into such boys. This was another chance for all the mothers of Våndävana to feed the Supreme Personality of Godhead with their own milk. Therefore Lord Kåñëa gave not only Yaçodä the chance of feeding Him, but this time He gave the chance to all the elderly gopés.

All the boys began to deal with their mothers as usual, and the mothers also, on the approach of evening, began to bathe their respective children, decorate them with tilaka and ornaments and give them necessary food after the day's labor. The cows also, who were away in the pasturing ground, returned in the evening and began to call their respective calves. The calves immediately came to their mothers, and the mothers began to lick the bodies of the calves. These relations between the cows and the gopés with their calves and boys remained unchanged, although actually the original calves and boys were not there. Actually the cows' affection for their calves and the elderly gopés' affection for the boys causelessly increased. Their affection increased naturally, even though the calves and boys were not their offspring. Although the cows and elderly gopés of Våndävana had greater affection for Kåñëa than for their own offspring, after this incident, their affection for their offspring increased exactly as it did for Kåñëa. For one year continually, Kåñëa Himself expanded as the calves and cowherd boys and was present in the pasturing ground.

As it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.61], Kåñëa's expansion is situated in everyone's heart as the Supersoul. Similarly, instead of expanding Himself as the Supersoul, He expanded Himself as a portion of calves and cowherd boys for one continuous year.

One day, when Kåñëa, along with Balaräma, was maintaining the calves in the forest, They saw some cows grazing on the top of Govardhana Hill. The cows could see down into the valley where the calves were being taken care of by the boys. Suddenly, on sighting their calves, the cows began to run towards them. They leaped downhill with joined front and rear legs. The cows were so melted with affection for their calves that they did not care about the rough path from the top of Govardhana Hill down to the pasturing ground. They began to approach the calves with their milk bags full of milk, and they raised their tails upwards. When they were coming down the hill, their milk bags were pouring milk on the ground out of intense maternal affection for the calves, although they were not their own calves. These cows had their own calves, and the calves that were grazing beneath Govardhana Hill were larger; they were not expected to drink milk directly from the milk bag but were satisfied with the grass. Yet all the cows came immediately and began to lick their bodies, and the calves also began to suck milk from the milk bags. There appeared to be a great bondage of affection between the cows and calves.

When the cows were running down from the top of Govardhana Hill, the men who were taking care of them tried to stop them. Elderly cows are taken care of by the men, and the calves are taken care of by the boys; and as far as possible, the calves are kept separate from the cows, so that the calves do not drink all the available milk. Therefore the men who were taking care of the cows on the top of Govardhana Hill tried to stop them, but they failed. Baffled by their failure, they were feeling ashamed and angry. They were very unhappy, but when they came down and saw their children taking care of the calves, they all of a sudden became very affectionate toward the children. It was very astonishing. Although the men came down disappointed, baffled and angry, as soon as they saw their own children, their hearts melted with great affection. At once their anger, dissatisfaction and unhappiness disappeared. They began to show paternal love for the children, and with great affection they lifted them in their arms and embraced them. They began to smell their children's heads and enjoy their company with great happiness. After embracing their children, the men again took the cows back to the top of Govardhana Hill. Along the way they began to think of their children, and affectionate tears fell from their eyes.

When Balaräma saw this extraordinary exchange of affection between the cows and their calves and between the fathers and their children—when neither the calves nor the children needed so much care—He began to wonder why this extraordinary thing happened. He was astonished to see all the residents of Våndävana so affectionate for their own children, exactly as they had been for Kåñëa. Similarly, the cows had grown affectionate for their calves—as much as for Kåñëa. Balaräma therefore concluded that the extraordinary show of affection was something mystical, either performed by the demigods or by some powerful man. Otherwise, how could this wonderful change take place? He concluded that this mystical change must have been caused by Kåñëa, whom Balaräma considered His worshipable Personality of Godhead. He thought, "It was arranged by Kåñëa, and even I could not check its mystic power." Thus Balaräma understood that all those boys and calves were only expansions of Kåñëa.

Balaräma inquired from Kåñëa about the actual situation. He said, "My dear Kåñëa, in the beginning I thought that all these cows, calves and cowherd boys were either great sages and saintly persons or demigods, but at the present it appears that they are actually Your expansions. They are all You; You Yourself are playing as the calves and cows and boys. What is the mystery of this situation? Where have those other calves and cows and boys gone? And why are You expanding Yourself as the cows, calves, and boys? Will You kindly tell Me what is the cause?" At the request of Balaräma, Kåñëa briefly explained the whole situation: how the calves and boys were stolen by Brahmä and how He was concealing the incident by expanding Himself so people would not know that the original cows, calves, and boys were missing.

While Kåñëa and Balaräma were talking, Brahmä returned after a moment's interval (according to the duration of his life). We have information of Lord Brahmä's duration of life from the Bhagavad-gétä [8.17]: 1,000 times the duration of the four ages, or 4,300,000 x 1,000, comprise Brahmä's twelve hours. Similarly, one moment of Brahmä is equal to one year of our solar calculation. After one moment of Brahmä's calculation, Brahmä came back to see the fun caused by his stealing the boys and calves. But he was also afraid that he was playing with fire. Kåñëa was his master, and he had played mischief for fun by taking away His calves and boys. He was really anxious, so he did not stay away very long; he came back after a moment (of his calculation). He saw that all the boys, calves and cows were playing with Kåñëa in the same way as when he had come upon them, although he was confident that he had taken them and made them lie down asleep under the spell of his mystic power. Brahmä began to think, "All the boys, calves and cows were taken away by me, and I know they are still sleeping. How is it that a similar batch of cows, boys and calves are playing with Kåñëa? Is it that they are not influenced by my mystic power? Have they been playing continually for one year with Kåñëa?" Brahmä tried to understand who they were and how they were uninfluenced by his mystic power, but he could not ascertain it. In other words, he himself came under the spell of his own mystic power. The influence of his mystic power appeared like snow in darkness or the glow worm in daytime. During the night's darkness, the glow worm can show some glittering power, and the snow piled up on the top of a hill or on the ground can shine during the daytime. But at night the snow has no silver glitter; nor does the glow worm have any illuminating power during the daytime. Similarly, when the small mystic power exhibited by Brahmä was before the mystic power of Kåñëa, it was just like snow or the glow worm. When a man of small mystic power wants to show potency in the presence of greater mystic power, he diminishes his own influence; he does not increase it. Even a great personality like Brahmä, when he wanted to show his mystic power before Kåñëa, became ludicrous. Brahmä was thus confused about his own mystic power.

In order to convince Brahmä that all those cows, calves and boys were not the original ones, the cows, calves, and boys who were playing with Kåñëa transformed into Viñëu forms. Actually, the original ones were sleeping under the spell of Brahmä's mystic power, but the present ones, seen by Brahmä, were all immediate expansions of Kåñëa, or Viñëu. Viñëu is the expansion of Kåñëa, so the Viñëu forms appeared before Brahmä. All the Viñëu forms were of bluish color and dressed in yellow garments; all of Them had four hands decorated with club, disc, lotus flower and conchshell. On Their heads were glittering golden jeweled helmets; They were bedecked with pearls and earrings, and garlanded with beautiful flowers. On Their chests was the mark of çrévatsa; Their arms were decorated with armlets and other jewelry. Their necks were smooth just like the conchshell, Their legs were decorated with bells, Their waists decorated with golden bells, and Their fingers decorated with jeweled rings. Brahmä also saw that upon the whole body of Lord Viñëu, fresh tulasé buds were thrown, beginning from His lotus feet up to the top of the head. Another significant feature of the Viñëu forms was that all of Them were looking transcendentally beautiful. Their smiling resembled the moonshine, and Their glancing resembled the early rising of the sun. Just by Their glancing They appeared as the creators and maintainers of the modes of ignorance and passion. Viñëu represents the mode of goodness, Brahmä represents the mode of passion, and Lord Çiva represents the mode of ignorance. Therefore as maintainer of everything in the cosmic manifestation, Viñëu is also creator and maintainer of Brahmä and Lord Çiva.

After this manifestation of Lord Viñëu, Brahmä saw that many other Brahmäs and Çivas and demigods and even insignificant living entities down to the ants and very small straws—movable and immovable living entities—were dancing, surrounding Lord Viñëu. Their dancing was accompanied by various kinds of music, and all of Them were worshiping Lord Viñëu. Brahmä realized that all those Viñëu forms were complete, beginning from the aëimä perfection of becoming small like an atom, up to becoming infinite like the cosmic manifestation. All the mystic powers of Brahmä, Çiva, all the demigods and the twenty-four elements of cosmic manifestation were fully represented in the person of Viñëu. By the influence of Lord Viñëu, all subordinate mystic powers were engaged in His worship. He was being worshiped by time, space, cosmic manifestation, reformation, desire, activity and the three qualities of material nature. Lord Viñëu, Brahmä also realized, is the reservoir of all truth, knowledge and bliss. He is the combination of three transcendental features, namely eternity, knowledge, and bliss, and He is the object of worship by the followers of the Upaniñads. Brahmä realized that all the different forms of cows, boys and calves transformed into Viñëu forms were not transformed by a mysticism of the type that a yogé or a demigod can display by specific powers invested in him. The cows, calves and boys transformed into Viñëu mürtis or Viñëu forms were not displays of Viñëu mäyä or Viñëu energy, but were Viñëu Himself. The respective qualifications of Viñëu and Viñëu mäyä are just like fire and heat. In the heat there is the qualification of fire, namely warmth; and yet heat is not fire. The manifestation of the Viñëu forms of the boys, cows and calves was not like the heat, but rather the fire—they were all actually Viñëu. Factually, the qualification of Viñëu is full truth, full knowledge and full bliss. Another example can be given with material objects, which are reflected in many, many forms. For example, the sun is reflected in many water pots, but the reflections of the sun in many pots are not actually the sun. There is no actual heat and light from the sun in the pot, although it appears as the sun. But the forms which Kåñëa assumed were each and every one full Viñëu. Satyam means truth, jïänam, full knowledge, and änanda, full bliss.

Transcendental forms of the Supreme Personality of Godhead in His person are so great that the impersonal followers of the Upaniñads cannot reach the platform of knowledge to understand them. Particularly, the transcendental forms of the Lord are beyond the reach of the impersonalists who can only understand, through the studies of Upaniñads, that the Absolute Truth is not matter and that the Absolute Truth is not materially restricted by limited potency. Lord Brahmä understood Kåñëa and His expansion into Viñëu forms and could understand that, due to the expansion of energy of the Supreme Lord, everything movable and immovable within the cosmic manifestation is existing.

When Brahmä was thus standing baffled in his limited power and conscious of his limited activities within the eleven senses, he could at least realize that he was also a creation of the material energy, just like a puppet. As a puppet has no independent power to dance but dances according to the direction of the puppet master, so the demigods and living entities are all subordinate to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As it is stated in the Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 5.142], the only master is Kåñëa, and all others are servants. The whole world is under the waves of the material spell, and beings are floating like straws in water. So their struggle for existence is continuing. But as soon as one becomes conscious that he is the eternal servant of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, this mäyä or illusory struggle for existence is immediately stopped.

Lord Brahmä, who has full control over the goddess of learning and who is considered to be the best authority in Vedic knowledge, was thus perplexed, being unable to understand the extraordinary power manifested in the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the mundane world, even a personality like Brahmä is unable to understand the potential mystic power of the Supreme Lord. Not only did Brahmä fail to understand, but he was perplexed even to see the display which was being manifested by Kåñëa before him.

Kåñëa took compassion upon Brahmä's inability to see even how He was displaying the force of Viñëu in transferring Himself into cows and cowherd boys, and thus, while fully manifesting the Viñëu expansion, He suddenly pulled His curtain of yogamäyä over the scene. In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.25] it is said that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is not visible due to the curtain spread by yogamäyä. That which covers the reality is mahämäyä, or the external energy, which does not allow a conditioned soul to understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead beyond the cosmic manifestation. But the energy which partially manifests the Supreme Personality of Godhead and partially does not allow one to see, is called yogamäyä. Brahmä is not an ordinary conditioned soul. He is far, far superior to all the demigods, and yet he could not comprehend the display of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; therefore Kåñëa willingly stopped manifesting any further potency. The conditioned soul not only becomes bewildered, but he is completely unable to understand. The curtain of yogamäyä was drawn so that Brahmä would not become more and more perplexed.

When Brahmä was relieved from his perplexity, he appeared to be awakened from an almost dead state, and he began to open his eyes with great difficulty. Thus he could see the eternal cosmic manifestation with common eyes. He saw all around him the super-excellent view of Våndävana—full with trees—which is the source of life for all living entities. He could appreciate the transcendental land of Våndävana where all the living entities are transcendental to ordinary nature. In the forest of Våndävana, even ferocious animals like tigers and others live peacefully along with the deer and human being. He could understand that, because of the presence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead in Våndävana, that place is transcendental to all other places and that there is no lust and greed there.

Brahmä thus found Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, playing the part of a small cowherd boy; he saw that little child with a lump of food in His left hand, searching out His friends, cows and calves, just as He was actually doing one year before, after their disappearance.

Immediately Brahmä descended from his great swan carrier and fell down before the Lord just like a golden stick. The word used among the Vaiñëavas for offering respect is daëòavat. This word means falling down like a stick; one should offer respect to the superior Vaiñëava by falling down straight, with his body just like a stick. So Brahmä fell down before the Lord just like a stick to offer respect; and because the complexion of Brahmä is golden, he appeared to be like a golden stick lying down before Lord Kåñëa. All the four helmets on the heads of Brahmä touched the lotus feet of Kåñëa. Brahmä, being very joyful, began to shed tears, and he washed the lotus feet of Kåñëa with his tears. Repeatedly he fell and rose as he recalled the wonderful activities of the Lord. After repeating obeisances for a long time, Brahmä stood up and smeared his hands over his eyes. Seeing the Lord before him, he, trembling, began to offer prayers with great respect, humility and attention.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirteenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Stealing of the Boys and Calves by Brahmä."

KB 1970-1-14 / Prayers Offered by Lord Brahmä to Lord Kåñëa

14 / Prayers Offered by Lord Brahmä to Lord Kåñëa

Brahmä said, "My dear Lord, You are the only worshipful Supreme Lord, Personality of Godhead; therefore I am offering my humble obeisances and prayers just to please You. Your bodily features are of the color of clouds filled with water. You are glittering with a silver electric aura emanating from Your yellow garments.

"Let me offer my respectful repeated obeisances unto the son of Mahäräja Nanda who is standing before me with conchshell, earrings and peacock feather on His head. His face is beautiful; He is wearing a helmet, garlanded by forest flowers, and He stands with a morsel of food in His hand. He is decorated with cane and bugle, and He carries a buffalo horn and flute. He stands before me with small lotus feet.

"My dear Lord, people may say that I am the master of all Vedic knowledge, and I am supposed to be the creator of this universe, but it has been proved now that I cannot understand Your personality, even though You are present before me just like a child. You are playing with Your boy friends, calves and cows, which might imply that You do not even have sufficient education. You are appearing just like a village boy, carrying Your food in Your hand and searching for Your calves. And yet there is so much difference between Your body and mine that I cannot estimate the potency of Your body. As I have already stated in the Brahma-saàhitä, Your body is not material."

In the Brahma-saàhitä [5.1] it is stated that the body of the Lord is all spiritual; there is no difference between the Lord's body and His self. Each limb of His body can perform the actions of all the others. The Lord can see with His hands, He can hear with His eyes, He can accept offerings with His legs and He can create with His mouth.

Brahmä continued: "Your appearance as a cowherd child is for the benefit of the devotees, and although I have committed offenses at Your lotus feet by stealing away Your cows, boys and calves, I can understand that You have mercy upon me. That is Your transcendental quality; You are very affectionate toward Your devotees. In spite of Your affection for me, I cannot estimate the potency of Your bodily activities. It is to be understood that when I, Lord Brahmä, the supreme personality of this universe, cannot estimate the child-like body of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, then what to speak of others? And if I cannot estimate the spiritual potency of Your child-like body, then what can I understand about Your transcendental pastimes? Therefore, as it is said in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.9], anyone who can understand a little of the transcendental pastimes, appearance and disappearance of the Lord becomes immediately eligible to enter into the kingdom of God after quitting the material body. This statement is also confirmed in the Vedas, and it is stated simply: by understanding the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one can overcome the chain of repeated birth and death. I therefore recommend that people should not try to understand You by their speculative knowledge.

"The best process of understanding You is to submissively give up the speculative process and try to hear about You, either from Yourself as You have given statements in the Bhagavad-gétä and many similar Vedic literatures, or from a realized devotee who has taken shelter at Your lotus feet. One has to hear from a devotee without speculation. One does not even need to change his worldly position; he simply has to hear Your message. Although You are not understandable by the material senses, simply by hearing about You, one can gradually conquer the nescience of misunderstanding. By Your own grace only, You become revealed to a devotee. You are unconquerable by any other means. Speculative knowledge without any trace of devotional service is simply a useless waste of time in the search for You. Devotional service is so important that even a little attempt can raise one to the highest perfectional platform. One should not, therefore, neglect this auspicious process of devotional service and take to the speculative method. By the speculative method one may gain partial knowledge of Your cosmic manifestation, but it is not possible to understand You, the origin of everything. The attempt of persons who are interested only in speculative knowledge is simply wasted labor, like the labor of a person who attempts to gain something by beating the empty husk of a rice paddy. A little quantity of paddy can be husked by the grinding wheel, and one can gain some grains of rice, but if the skin of the paddy is already beaten by the grinding wheel, there is no further gain in beating the husk. It is simply useless labor.

"My dear Lord, there are many instances in the history of human society where a person, after failing to achieve the transcendental platform, engaged himself in devotional service with his body, mind and words and thus attained the highest perfectional state of entering into Your abode. The processes of understanding You by speculation or mystic meditation are all useless without devotional service. One should therefore engage himself in Your devotional service even in his worldly activities, and one should always keep himself near You by the process of hearing and chanting Your transcendental glories. Simply by being attached to hearing and chanting Your glories, one can attain the highest perfectional stage and enter into Your kingdom. If a person, therefore, always keeps in touch with You by hearing and chanting Your glories and offers the results of his work for Your satisfaction only, he very easily and happily attains entrance into Your supreme abode. You are realizable by persons who have cleansed their hearts of all contamination. This cleansing of the heart is made possible by chanting and hearing the glories of Your Lordship."

The Lord is all-pervading. As it is stated by Lord Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.4], "Everything is sustained by Me, but at the same time I am not in everything." Since the Lord is all-pervading, there is nothing existing without His knowledge. The all-pervasive nature of the Supreme Personality of Godhead can never be within the limited knowledge of a living entity; therefore, a person who has attained steadiness of the mind by fixing the mind on the lotus feet of the Lord is able to understand the Supreme Lord to some extent. It is the business of the mind to wander over varied subject matter for sense gratification. Therefore only a person who engages the senses always in the service of the Lord can control the mind and be fixed at the lotus feet of the Lord. This concentration of the mind upon the lotus feet of the Lord is called samädhi. Until one reaches the stage of samädhi, or trance, he cannot understand the nature of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. There may be some philosophers or scientists who can study the cosmic nature from atom to atom; they may be so advanced that they can count the atomic composition of the cosmic atmosphere or all the planets and stars in the sky, or even the shining molecular parts of the sun or other stars and luminaries in the sky. But it is not possible to count the qualities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

As described in the beginning of Vedänta-sütra, the Supreme Person is the origin of all qualities. He is generally called nirguëa. Nirguëa means without qualities. Guëa means quality, and nir means without. But impersonalists interpret this word nirguëa as "having no quality." Because they are unable to estimate the qualities of the Lord in transcendental realization, they conclude that the Supreme Lord has no qualities. But that is actually not the position. The real position is that He is the original source of all qualities. All qualities are emanating constantly from Him. How, therefore, can a limited person count the qualities of the Lord? One may estimate the qualities of the Lord for one moment, but the next moment the qualities are increased; so it is not possible to make an estimation of the transcendental qualities of the Lord. He is therefore called nirguëa. His qualities cannot be estimated.

One should not uselessly labor in mental speculation to estimate the Lord's qualities. There is no need of adopting the speculative method or exercising the body to attain mystic yoga perfection. One should simply understand that the distress and happiness of this body are predestined; there is no need to try to avoid the distress of this bodily existence or to attempt to achieve happiness by different types of exercises. The best course is to surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead with body, mind and words and always be engaged in His service. This transcendental labor is fruitful, but other attempts to understand the Absolute Truth are never successful. Therefore an intelligent man does not try to understand the Supreme Person, Absolute Truth, by speculative or mystic power. Rather, he engages in devotional service and depends on the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He knows that whatever may happen to the body is due to his past fruitive activities. If one lives such a simple life in devotional service, then automatically he can inherit the transcendental abode of the Lord. Actually, every living entity is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord and a son of the Godhead. Each has the natural right to inherit and share the transcendental pleasures of the Lord, but due to the contact of matter, conditioned living entities have been practically disinherited. If one adopts the simple method of engaging himself in devotional service, automatically he becomes eligible to become freed from the material contamination and elevated to the transcendental position of associating with the Supreme Lord.

Lord Brahmä presented himself to Lord Kåñëa as the most presumptuous living creature because he wanted to examine the wonder of His personal power. He stole the boys and calves of the Lord in order to see how the Lord would recover them. After his maneuver, Lord Brahmä admitted that his attempt was most presumptuous, for he was attempting to test his energy before the person of original energy. Coming to his senses, Lord Brahmä saw that although he was a very powerful living creature in the estimation of all other living creatures within this material world, in comparison to the power and energy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, his power was nothing. The scientists of the material world have discovered wonders such as atomic weapons, and when tested in a city or insignificant place on this planet, such powerful weapons create so-called havoc, but if the atomic weapons are tested on the sun, what is their significance? They are insignificant there. Similarly, Brahmä's stealing the calves and boys from Çré Kåñëa may be a wonderful display of mystic power, but when Çré Kåñëa exhibited His expansive power in so many calves and boys and maintained them without effort, Brahmä could understand that his own power was insignificant.

Brahmä addressed Lord Kåñëa as Acyuta because the Lord is never forgetful of a little service rendered by His devotee. He is so kind and affectionate towards His devotees that a little service by them is accepted by Him as a great deal. Brahmä has certainly rendered much service to the Lord. As the supreme personality in charge of this particular universe, he is, without a doubt, a faithful servant of Kåñëa; therefore he could appease Kåñëa. He asked that the Lord understand him as a subordinate servant whose little mistake and impudence might be excused. He admitted that he was puffed up by his powerful position as Lord Brahmä. Because he is the qualitative incarnation of the mode of passion within this material world, this was natural for him, and therefore he committed the mistake. But after all, Lord Kåñëa would kindly take compassion upon His subordinate and excuse him for his gross mistake.

Lord Brahmä realized his actual position. He is certainly the supreme teacher of this universe, in charge of the production of material nature consisting of complete material elements, false ego, sky, air, fire, water and earth. Such a universe may be gigantic, but it can be measured, just as we measure our body as seven cubits. Generally everyone's personal bodily measurement is calculated to be seven cubits of his hand. This particular universe may appear as a very gigantic body, but it is nothing but the measurement of seven cubits for Lord Brahmä. Aside from this universe, there are unlimited other universes which are outside the jurisdiction of this particular Lord Brahmä. Just as innumerable atomic infinitesimal fragments pass through the holes of a screened window, so millions and trillions of universes in their seedling form are coming out from the bodily pores of Mahä-Viñëu, and that Mahä-Viñëu is but a part of the plenary expansion of Kåñëa. Under these circumstances, although Lord Brahmä is the supreme creature within this universe, what is his importance in the presence of Lord Kåñëa?

Lord Brahmä therefore compared himself to a little child within the womb of his mother. If the child within the womb plays with his hands and legs, and while playing touches the body of the mother, is the mother offended with the child? Of course she isn't. Similarly, Lord Brahmä may be a very great personality, and yet not only Brahmä but everything that be is existing within the womb of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Lord's energy is all-pervading; there is no place in the creation where it is not acting. Everything is existing within the energy of the Lord, so the Brahmä of this universe or the Brahmäs of the many other millions and trillions of universes are existing within the energy of the Lord; therefore the Lord is considered to be the mother, and everything existing within the womb of the mother is considered to be the child. And the good mother is never offended with the child, even if he touches the body of the mother by kicking his legs.

Lord Brahmä then admitted that his birth was from the lotus flower which blossomed from the navel of Näräyaëa after the dissolution of the three worlds, or three planetary systems, known as Bhurloka, Bhuvarloka and Svarloka. The universe is divided into three divisions, namely Svarga, Martya and Pätäla. These three planetary systems are merged into water at the time of dissolution. At that time Näräyaëa, the plenary portion of Kåñëa, lies down on the water and gradually a lotus stem grows from His navel, and from that lotus flower, Brahmä is born. It is naturally concluded that the mother of Brahmä is Näräyaëa. Because the Lord is the resting place of all the living entities after the dissolution of the universe, He is called Näräyaëa. The word nära means the aggregate total of all living entities, and ayana means the resting place. The form of Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu is called Näräyaëa because He rests Himself on that water. In addition, He is the resting place of all living creatures. Besides that, Näräyaëa is also present in everyone's heart, as it is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.61]. In that sense, also, He is Näräyaëa, as ayana means the source of knowledge as well as the resting place. It is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.15] that remembrance of the living entity is due to the presence of the Supersoul within the heart. After changing the body, a living creature forgets everything of his past life, but because Näräyaëa the Supersoul is present within his heart, he is reminded by Him to act according to his past desire. Lord Brahmä wanted to prove that Kåñëa is the original Näräyaëa, that He is the source of Näräyaëa, and that Näräyaëa is not an exhibition of the external energy, mäyä, but is an expansion of spiritual energy. The activities of the external energy or mäyä are exhibited after the creation of this cosmic world, and the original spiritual energy of Näräyaëa was acting before the creation. So the expansions of Näräyaëa, from Kåñëa to Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu, from Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu to Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu, and from Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu to everyone's heart, are manifestations of His spiritual energy. They are not conducted by the material energy; therefore they are not temporary. Anything conducted by the material energy is temporary, but everything executed by the spiritual energy is eternal.

Lord Brahmä reconfirmed his statement establishing Kåñëa as the original Näräyaëa. He said that the gigantic universal body is still resting on the water known as Garbhodaka. He spoke as follows: "This gigantic body of the universe is another manifestation of Your energy. On account of His resting on the water, this universal form is also Näräyaëa, and we are all within the womb of this Näräyaëa form. I see Your different Näräyaëa forms everywhere. I can see You on the water, I can feel You within my heart, and I can also see You before me now. You are the original Näräyaëa.

"My dear Lord, in this incarnation You have proved that You are the supreme controller of mäyä. You remain within the cosmic manifestation, and yet the whole creation is within You. This fact has already been proved by You when You exhibited the whole universal creation within Your mouth before Your mother Yaçodä. By Your inconceivable potency of yogamäyä, You can make such things effective without external help.

"My dear Lord Kåñëa, the whole cosmic manifestation that we are visualizing at present is all within Your body. Yet I am seeing You outside, and You are also seeing me outside. How can such things happen without being influenced by Your inconceivable energy?"

Lord Brahmä stressed herein that without accepting the inconceivable energy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one cannot explain things as they are. He continued: "My dear Lord, leaving aside all other things and just considering today's happenings—what I have seen—are they not all due to Your inconceivable energies? First of all I saw You alone; thereafter You expanded Yourself as Your friends, the calves and all the existence of Våndävana; then I saw You and all the boys as four-handed Viñëus, and They were being worshiped by all elements and all demigods, including myself. Again They all became cowherd boys, and You remained alone as You were before. Does this not mean that You are the Supreme Lord Näräyaëa, the origin of everything, and from You everything emanates, and again everything enters unto You, and You remain the same as before?"

"Persons who are unaware of Your inconceivable energy cannot understand that You alone expand Yourself as the creator Brahmä, maintainer Viñëu, and annihilator Çiva. Persons who are not in awareness of things as they are contemplate that I, Brahmä, am the creator, Viñëu is the maintainer, and Lord Çiva is the annihilator. Actually, You are alone everything—creator, maintainer, and annihilator. Similarly, You expand Yourself in different incarnations; among the demigods You incarnate as Vämanadeva, among the great sages You incarnate as Paraçuräma, among the human beings You appear as Yourself, as Lord Kåñëa, or Lord Räma, among the animals You appear as the boar incarnation, and among the aquatics You appear as the incarnation of fish. And yet You have no appearance; You are always eternal. Your appearance and disappearance are made possible by Your inconceivable energy just to give protection to the faithful devotees and to annihilate the demons. O my Lord, O all-pervading Supreme Personality of Godhead, O Supersoul, controller of all mystic powers, no one can appreciate Your transcendental pastimes as they are exhibited within these three worlds. No one can estimate how You have expanded Your yogamäyä and Your incarnation and how You act by Your transcendental energy. My dear Lord, this whole cosmic manifestation is just like a flashing dream, and its temporary existence simply disturbs the mind. As a result, we are full of anxiety in this existence; to live within this material world means simply to suffer and to be full of all miseries. And yet this temporary existence of the material world appears to be pleasing and dear on account of its having evolved from Your body, which is eternal and full of bliss and knowledge.

"My conclusion is, therefore, that You are the Supreme Soul, Absolute Truth, and the supreme original person; and although You have expanded Yourself in so many Viñëu forms, or in living entities and energies, by Your inconceivable transcendental potencies, You are the supreme one without a second, You are the supreme Supersoul. The innumerable living entities are simply like sparks of the original fire. Your Lordship, the conception of the Supersoul as impersonal is wrongly accepted because I see that You are the original person. A person with a poor fund of knowledge may think that, because You are the son of Mahäräja Nanda, You are not the original person, that You are born just like a human being. They are mistaken. You are the actual original person; that is my conclusion. In spite of Your being the son of Nanda, You are the original person, and there is no doubt about it. You are the Absolute Truth, and You are not of this material darkness. You are the source of the original brahmajyoti as well as the material luminaries. Your transcendental effulgence is identical with brahmajyoti. As it is described in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.40], the brahmajyoti is nothing but Your personal bodily effulgence. There are many Viñëu incarnations and incarnations of Your different qualities, but all those incarnations are not on the same level. You are the original lamp. Other incarnations may possess the same candle power as the original lamp, but the original lamp is the beginning of all light. And because You are not one of the creations of this material world, even after the annihilation of this world, Your existence as You are will continue.

"Because You are the original person, You are therefore described in the Gopäla-täpané (the Vedic Upaniñad), as well as in the Brahma-saàhitä, as govindam ädi-puruñam. Govinda is the original person, the cause of all causes. In the Bhagavad-gétä [14.27] also it is stated that You are the source of the Brahman effulgence. No one should conclude that Your body is like an ordinary material body. Your body is akñara, indestructible. The material body is always full of threefold miseries, but Your body is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha: full of being, bliss, knowledge and eternality. You are also niraïjana because Your pastimes, as the little son of mother Yaçodä or the Lord of the gopés, are never contaminated by the material qualities. And although You exhibited Yourself in so many cowherd boys, calves and cows, Your transcendental potency is not reduced. You are always complete. As it is described in the Vedic literature, even if the complete is taken away from the complete—Supreme Absolute Truth—it yet remains the complete, Supreme Absolute Truth. And although many expansions from the complete are visible, the complete is one without a second. Since all Your pastimes are spiritual, there is no possibility of their being contaminated by the material modes of nature. When You place Yourself subordinate to Your father and mother, Nanda and Yaçodä, You are not reduced in Your potency; this is an expression of Your loving attitude for Your devotees. There is no other competitor or second identity than Yourself. A person with a poor fund of knowledge concludes that Your pastimes and appearance are simply material designations. You are transcendental to both nescience and knowledge, as it is confirmed in the Gopäla-täpané. You are the original amåta (nectar of immortality), indestructible. As it is confirmed in the Vedas, amåtaà çäçvataà brahme. Brahman is the eternal, the supreme origin of everything, who has no birth or death.

"In the Upaniñads it is stated that the Supreme Brahman is as effulgent as the sun and is the origin of everything, and anyone who can understand that original person becomes liberated from the material conditional life. Anyone who can simply be attached to You by devotional service can know Your actual position, Your birth, appearance, disappearance and activities. As confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [8.5], simply by understanding Your constitutional position, appearance and disappearance, one can be immediately elevated to the spiritual kingdom after quitting this present body. Therefore to cross over the ocean of material nescience, an intelligent person takes shelter of Your lotus feet and is easily transferred to the spiritual world. There are many so-called meditators who do not know that You are the Supreme Soul. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.61], You are the Supreme Soul present in everyone's heart. Therefore there is no necessity of one's meditating on something beyond You. One who is always absorbed in meditation on Your original form of Kåñëa easily crosses over the ocean of material nescience. But persons who do not know that You are the Supreme Soul remain within this material world in spite of their so-called meditation. If, by the association of Your devotees, a person comes to the knowledge that Lord Kåñëa is the original Supersoul, then it is possible for him to cross over the ocean of material ignorance. For instance, a person becomes transcendental to the mistake of thinking a rope is a snake; as soon as one understands that the rope is not a snake, he is liberated from fear. For one who understands You, therefore, through Your personal teachings, as stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.29], or through Your pure devotees, as stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.14.58] and all Vedic literatures—that You are the ultimate goal of understanding—he need no more fear this material existence.

"So-called liberation and bondage has no meaning for a person who is already engaged in Your devotional service, just as a person who knows that the rope is not a snake is unafraid. A devotee knows that this material world belongs to You, and he therefore engages everything in Your transcendental loving service. Thus there is no bondage for him. For a person who is already situated in the sun planet, there is no question of the appearance or disappearance of the sun in the name of day or night. It is also said that You, Kåñëa, are just like the sun, and mäyä is like darkness. When the sun is present, there is no question of darkness; so, for those who are always in Your presence, there is no question of bondage or liberation. They are already liberated. On the other hand, persons who falsely think themselves to be liberated without taking shelter of Your lotus feet, fall down because their intelligence is not pure.

"If one therefore thinks that the Supersoul is something different from Your personality and thus searches out the Supersoul somewhere else, in the forest or in the caves of the Himälayas, his condition is very lamentable.

“Your teachings in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66] are that one should give up all other processes of self-realization and simply surrender unto You, for that is complete. Because You are supreme in everything, those who are searching after the Brahman effulgence are also searching after You. And those who are searching after Supersoul realization are also searching after You. You have stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that You Yourself, by Your partial representation as the Supersoul, have entered into this material cosmic manifestation. You are present in everyone’s heart, and there is no need to search out the Supersoul anywhere else. If someone does so, he is simply in ignorance. One who is transcendental to such a position understands that You are unlimited; You are both within and without. Your presence is everywhere. Instead of searching for the Supersoul anywhere else, a devotee only concentrates his mind on You within. Actually one who is liberated from the material concept of life can search for You; others cannot. The simile of thinking the rope to be a snake is applicable only to those who are still in ignorance of You. Actually the existence of a snake besides the rope is only within the mind. The existence of mäyä, similarly, is only within the mind. Mäyä is nothing but ignorance of Your personality. When one forgets Your personality, that is the conditional state of mäyä. Therefore one who is fixed upon You both internally and externally is not illusioned.

"One who has attained a little devotional service can understand Your glories. Even one striving for Brahman realization or Paramätmä realization cannot understand the different features of Your personality unless he treads the devotional path. One may be the spiritual master of many impersonalists, or he may go to the forest or to a cave or mountain and meditate as a hermit for many, many years, but he cannot understand Your glories without being favored by a slight degree of devotional service. Brahman realization or Paramätmä realization are also not possible even after one searches for many, many years unless one is touched by the wonderful effect of devotional service.

"My dear Lord, I pray that I may be so fortunate that, in this life or in another life, wherever I may take my birth, I may be counted as one of Your devotees. Wherever I may be, I pray that I may be engaged in Your devotional service. I do not even care what form of life I get in the future, because I can see that even in the form of cows and calves or cowherd boys, the devotees are so fortunate to be always engaged in Your transcendental loving service and association. Therefore I wish to be one of them instead of such an exalted person as I am now, for I am full of ignorance. The gopés and cows of Våndävana are so fortunate that they have been able to supply their breast milk to You. Persons who are engaged in performing great sacrifices and offering many valuable goats in the sacrifice cannot attain the perfection of understanding You, but simply by devotional service these innocent village women and cows are all able to satisfy You with their milk. You have drunk their milk to satisfaction, yet You are never satisfied by those engaged in performing sacrifices. I am simply surprised, therefore, with the fortunate position of Mahäräja Nanda, mother Yaçodä and the cowherd men and gopés, because You, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Absolute Truth, are existing here as their most intimate lovable object. My dear Lord, no one can actually appreciate the good fortune of these residents of Våndävana. We are all demigods, controlling deities of the various senses of the living entities, and we are proud of enjoying such privileges, but actually there is no comparison between our position and the position of these fortunate residents of Våndävana because they are actually relishing Your presence and enjoying Your association by dint of their activities. We may be proud of being controllers of the senses, but here the residents of Våndävana are so transcendental that they are not under our control. Actually they are enjoying the senses through service to You. I shall therefore consider myself fortunate to be given a chance to take birth in this land of Våndävana in any of my future lives.

"My dear Lord, I am therefore not interested in either material opulences or liberation. I am most humbly praying at Your lotus feet for You to please give me any sort of birth within this Våndävana forest so that I may be able to be favored by the dust of the feet of some of the devotees of Våndävana. Even if I am given the chance to grow just as the humble grass in this land, that will be a glorious birth for me. But if I am not so fortunate to take birth within the forest of Våndävana, I beg to be allowed to take birth outside the immediate area of Våndävana so that when the devotees go out they will walk over me. Even that would be a great fortune for me. I am just aspiring for a birth in which I will be smeared by the dust of the devotees' feet.

"I can see that everyone here is simply full of Kåñëa consciousness; they do not know anything but Mukunda. All the Vedas are indeed searching after the lotus feet of Kåñëa."

It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.15] that the purpose of Vedic knowledge is to find Kåñëa. And it is said in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.33] that it is very difficult to find Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, by systematic reading of the Vedic literature. But He is very easily available through the mercy of a pure devotee. The pure devotees of Våndävana are fortunate because they can see Mukunda (Lord Kåñëa) all the time. This word "mukunda" can be understood in two ways. Muk means liberation. Lord Kåñëa can give liberation and therefore transcendental bliss. The word also refers to His smiling face, which is just like the kunda flower. Mukha also means face. The kunda flower is very beautiful, and it appears to be smiling. Thus the comparison is made.

The difference between the pure devotees of Våndävana and other devotees is that the residents of Våndävana have no other desire but to be associated with Kåñëa. Kåñëa, being very kind to His devotees, fulfills their desire; because they always want Kåñëa's association, the Lord is always prepared to give it to them. The devotees of Våndävana are also spontaneous lovers. They do not follow the regulative principles. They are not required to strictly follow regulative principles because they are already naturally developed in transcendental love for Kåñëa. Regulative principles are required for persons who have not achieved the position of transcendental love. Brahmä is also a devotee of the Lord, but he is subject to follow the regulative principles. He prays to Kåñëa to give him the chance to take birth in Våndävana so that he might be elevated to the platform of spontaneous love.

Lord Brahmä continued: "My Lord, sometimes I am puzzled as to how Your Lordship will be able to repay, in gratitude, the devotional service of these residents of Våndävana. Although I know that You are the supreme source of all benediction, I am puzzled to know how You will be able to repay all the service that You are receiving from these residents of Våndävana. I think of how You are so kind, so magnanimous, that even Pütanä, who came to cheat You by dressing herself as a very affectionate mother, was awarded liberation and the actual post of a mother. And other demons belonging to the same family, such as Aghäsura and Bakäsura, were also favored with liberation. Under the circumstances, I am puzzled. These residents of Våndävana have given You everything—their bodies, their minds, their love, their homes. Everything is being utilized for Your purpose. So how will You be able to repay their debt? You have already given Yourself to Pütanä! I surmise that You shall ever remain a debtor to the residents of Våndävana, being unable to repay their loving service. My Lord, I can understand that the superexcellent service of the residents of Våndävana is due to their spontaneously engaging all natural instincts in Your service. It is said that attachment for material objects and home is due to illusion, which makes a living entity conditioned in the material world. But this is only the case for persons who are not in Kåñëa consciousness. In the case of the residents of Våndävana, such obstructions, as attachment to hearth and home, are nonexistent. Because their attachment has been converted unto You, and their home has been converted into a temple because You are always there, and because they have forgotten everything for Your sake, there is no impediment. For a Kåñëa conscious person, there is no such thing as impediments in hearth and home. Nor is there illusion.

"I can also understand that Your appearance as a small cowherd boy, a child of the cowherd men, is not at all a material activity. You are so much obliged by their affection that You are here to enthuse them with more loving service by Your transcendental presence. In Våndävana there is no distinction between material and spiritual because everything is dedicated to Your loving service. My dear Lord, Your Våndävana pastimes are simply to enthuse Your devotees. If someone takes Your Våndävana pastimes to be material, he will be misled.

"My dear Lord Kåñëa, those who deride You, claiming that You have a material body like an ordinary man, are described in the Bhagavad-gétä as demonic and less intelligent. You are always transcendental. The nondevotees are cheated because they consider You to be a material creation. Actually, You have assumed this body, which resembles that of an ordinary cowherd boy, simply to increase the devotion and transcendental bliss of Your devotees.

"My dear Lord, I have nothing to say about people who advertise that they have already realized God or that by their realization they have themselves become God. But as far as I am concerned, I admit frankly that for me it is not possible to realize You by my body, mind or speech. What can I say about You, or how can I realize You by my senses? I cannot even think of You perfectly with my mind, which is the master of the senses. Your qualities, Your activities and Your body cannot be conceived by any person within this material world. Only by Your mercy can one understand, to some extent, what You are. My dear Lord, You are the Supreme Lord of all creation, although I sometimes falsely think that I am the master of this universe. I may be master of this universe, but there are innumerable universes, and there are innumerable Brahmäs also who preside over these universes. But actually You are the master of them all. As the Supersoul in everyone's heart, You know everything. Please, therefore accept me as Your surrendered servant. I hope that You will excuse me for disturbing You in Your pastimes with Your friends and calves. Now if You will kindly allow me, I will immediately leave so You can enjoy Your friends and calves without my presence.

"My dear Lord Kåñëa, Your very name suggests that You are all-attractive. The attraction of the sun and the moon are all due to You. By the attraction of the sun, You are beautifying the very existence of the Yadu dynasty. With the attraction of the moon, You are enhancing the potency of the land, the demigods, the brähmaëas, the cows and the oceans. Because of Your supreme attraction, demons like Kaàsa and others are annihilated. Therefore it is my deliberate conclusion that You are the only worshipable Deity within the creation. Accept my humble obeisances until the annihilation of this material world. As long as there is sunshine within this material world, kindly accept my humble obeisances."

In this way, Brahmä, the master of this universe, after offering humble and respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead and circumambulating Him three times, was ready to return to his abode known as Brahmaloka. By His gesture, the Supreme Personality of Godhead gave him permission to return. As soon as Brahmä left, Lord Çré Kåñëa immediately appeared as He had on the very day the cows and cowherd boys had vanished.

Kåñëa had left His friends on the bank of the Yamunä while they were engaged in lunch, and although He returned exactly one year later, the cowherd boys thought that He had returned within a second. That is the way of Kåñëa’s different energies and activities. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.61] that Kåñëa Himself is residing in everyone’s heart, and He causes both remembrance and forgetfulness. All living entities are controlled by the supreme energy of the Lord, and sometimes they remember and sometimes they forget their constitutional position. His friends, being controlled in such a way, could not understand that for one whole year they were absent from the Yamunä bank and were under the spell of Brahmä’s illusion. When Kåñëa appeared before the boys, they thought, “Kåñëa has returned within a minute.” They began to laugh, thinking that Kåñëa was not willing to leave their lunchtime company. They were very jubilant and invited Him, “Dear friend Kåñëa, You have come back so quickly! All right, we have not as yet begun our lunch, not even taken one morsel of food. So please come and join us and let us eat together.” Kåñëa smiled and accepted their invitation, and He began to enjoy the lunchtime company of His friends. While eating, Kåñëa was thinking, “These boys believe that I have come back within a second, but they do not know that for the last year I have been involved with the mystic activities of Lord Brahmä.”

After finishing their lunch, Kåñëa and His friends and calves began to return to their Vrajabhümi homes. While passing, they enjoyed seeing the dead carcass of Aghäsura in the shape of a gigantic serpent. When Kåñëa returned home to Vrajabhümi, He was seen by all the inhabitants of Våndävana. He was wearing a peacock feather in His helmet, which was also decorated with forest flowers. Kåñëa was also garlanded with flowers and painted with different colored minerals collected from the caves of Govardhana Hill. Govardhana Hill is always famous for supplying natural red dyes, and Kåñëa and His friends painted their bodies with them. Each of them had a bugle made of buffalo horn and a stick and a flute, and each called his respective calves by their particular names. They were so proud of Kåñëa's wonderful activities that, while entering the village, they all sang His glories. All the gopés in Våndävana saw beautiful Kåñëa entering the village. The boys composed nice songs describing how they were saved from being swallowed by the great serpent and how the serpent was killed. Some described Kåñëa as the son of Yaçodä, and others as the son of Nanda Mahäräja. "He is so wonderful that He saved us from the clutches of the great serpent and killed him," they said. But little did they know that one year had passed since the killing of Aghäsura.

In this regard, Mahäräja Parékñit asked Çukadeva Gosvämé how the inhabitants of Våndävana suddenly developed so much love for Kåñëa, although Kåñëa was not a member of any of their families. Mahäräja Parékñit enquired, "During the absence of the original cowherd boys, when Kåñëa expanded Himself, why is it that the boys' parents became more loving toward Him than toward their own sons? Also, why did the cows become so loving toward the calves, more than toward their own calves?"

Çukadeva Gosvämé told Mahäräja Parékñit that every living entity is actually most attached to his own self. Outward paraphernalia such as home, family, friends, country, society, wealth, opulence, reputation, etc., are all only secondary in pleasing the living entity. They please only because they bring pleasure to the self. For this reason, one is self-centered and is attached to his body and self more than he is to relatives like wife, children, and friends. If there is some immediate danger to one's own person, he first of all takes care of himself, then others. That is natural. That means, more than anything else, he loves his own self. The next important object of affection, after his own self, is his material body. A person who has no information of the spirit soul is very much attached to his material body, so much so that even in old age he wants to preserve the body in so many artificial ways, thinking that his old and broken body can be saved. Everyone is working hard day and night just to give pleasure to his own self, under either the bodily or spiritual concept of life. We are attached to material possessions because they give pleasure to the senses or to the body. The attachment to the body is there only because the "I," the spirit soul, is within the body. Similarly, when one is further advanced, he knows that the spirit soul is pleasing because it is part and parcel of Kåñëa. Ultimately, it is Kåñëa who is pleasing and all-attractive. He is the Supersoul of everything. And in order to give us this information, Kåñëa descends and tells us that the all-attractive center is He Himself. Without being an expansion of Kåñëa, nothing can be attractive.

Whatever is attractive within the cosmic manifestation is due to Kåñëa. Kåñëa is therefore the reservoir of all pleasure. The active principle of everything is Kåñëa, and highly elevated transcendentalists see everything in connection with Him. In the Caitanya-caritämåta it is stated that a mahäbhagavata, or highly advanced devotee, sees Kåñëa as the active principle in all movable and immovable living entities. Therefore he sees everything within this cosmic manifestation in relation to Kåñëa. For the fortunate person who has taken shelter of Kåñëa as everything, liberation is already there. He is no longer in the material world. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä. Whoever is engaged in the devotional service of Kåñëa is already on the brahma-bhüta or spiritual platform. The very name Kåñëa suggests piety and liberation. Anyone who takes shelter of the lotus feet of Kåñëa enters the boat for crossing over the ocean of nescience. For him, this vast expansion of the material manifestation becomes as insignificant as a hoofprint. Kåñëa is the center of all great souls, and He is the shelter of the material worlds.

For one who is on the platform of Kåñëa consciousness, Vaikuëöha, or the spiritual world, is not far away. He does not live within the material world where there is danger at every step. In this way, Kåñëa consciousness was fully explained by Çukadeva Gosvämé to Mahäräja Parékñit. Çukadeva Gosvämé even recited to the king the statements and prayers of Lord Brahmä. These descriptions of Lord Kåñëa's pastimes with His cowherd boys, His eating with them on the bank of the Yamunä and Lord Brahmä's prayers unto Him, are all transcendental subject matters. Anyone who hears, recites or chants them surely gets all his spiritual desires fulfilled. Thus Kåñëa's childhood appearance, His sporting with Balaräma in Våndävana, was described.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fourteenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Prayers Offered by Lord Brahmä to Lord Kåñëa."

KB 1970-1-15 / Killing of Dhenukäsura

15 / Killing of Dhenukäsura

In this way, Çré Kåñëa, along with His elder brother Balaräma, passed the childhood age known as kaumära and stepped into the age of paugaëòa, from the sixth year up to the tenth. At that time, all the cowherd men conferred and agreed to give those boys who had passed their fifth year charge of the cows in the pasturing ground. Given charge of the cows, Kåñëa and Balaräma traversed Våndävana, purifying the land with Their footprints.

Accompanied by the cowherd boys and Balaräma, Kåñëa brought forward the cows and played on His flute through the forest of Våndävana, which was full of flowers, vegetables, and pasturing grass. The Våndävana forest was as sanctified as the clear mind of a devotee and was full of bees, flowers and fruits. There were chirping birds and clear water lakes with waters that could relieve one of all fatigues. Sweet flavored breezes blew always, refreshing the mind and body. Kåñëa, with His friends and Balaräma, entered the forest and, seeing the favorable situation, enjoyed the atmosphere to the fullest extent. Kåñëa saw all the trees, overloaded with fruits and fresh twigs, coming down to touch the ground as if welcoming Him by touching His lotus feet. He was very pleased by the behavior of the trees, fruits and flowers, and He began to smile realizing their desires.

Kåñëa then spoke to His elder brother Balaräma as follows: "My dear brother, You are superior to all of us, and Your lotus feet are worshiped by the demigods. Just see how these trees, full with fruits, have bent down to worship Your lotus feet. It appears that they are trying to get out of the darkness of being obliged to accept the form of trees. Actually, the trees born in the land of Våndävana are not ordinary living entities. Having held the impersonal point of view in their past lives, they are now put into this stationary condition of life, but now they have the opportunity of seeing You in Våndävana, and they are praying for further advancement in spiritual life through Your personal association. Generally the trees are living entities in the modes of darkness. The impersonalist philosophers are in that darkness, but they eradicate it by taking full advantage of Your presence. I think the drones that are buzzing all around You must have been Your devotees in their past lives. They cannot leave Your company because no one can be a better, more affectionate master than You. You are the supreme and original Personality of Godhead, and the drones are just trying to spread Your glories by chanting every moment. I think some of them must be great sages, devotees of Your Lordship, and they are disguising themselves in the form of drones because they are unable to give up Your company even for a moment. My dear brother, You are the supreme worshipable Godhead. Just see how the peacocks in great ecstasy are dancing before You. The deer, whose behavior is just like the gopés, are welcoming You with the same affection. And the cuckoos who are residing in this forest are receiving You with great joy because they consider that Your appearance is so auspicious in their home. Even though they are trees and animals, these residents of Våndävana are glorifying You. They are prepared to welcome You to their best capacity, as is the practice of great souls in receiving another great soul at home. As for the land, it is so pious and fortunate that the footprints of Your lotus feet are marking its body.

"It is quite natural for these Våndävana inhabitants to thus receive a great personality like You. The herbs, creepers and plants are also so fortunate to touch Your lotus feet. And by Your touching the twigs with Your hands, these small plants are also made glorious. As for the hills and the rivers, they too are now glorious because You are glancing at them. Above all, the damsels of Vraja, the gopés, attracted by Your beauty, are the most glorious, because You embrace them with Your strong arms."

In this way, both Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma began to enjoy the residents of Våndävana to their full satisfaction, along with the calves and cows on the bank of the Yamunä. In some places both Kåñëa and Balaräma were accompanied by Their friends. The boys were singing, imitating the humming sound of the drones and accompanying Kåñëa and Balaräma, who were garlanded with forest flowers. While walking, the boys sometimes imitated the quacking sound of the swans in the lakes, or when they saw the peacocks dancing, they imitated them before Kåñëa. Kåñëa also moved His neck, imitating the dancing and making His friends laugh.

The cows taken care of by Kåñëa had different names, and Kåñëa would call them with love. After hearing Kåñëa calling, the cows would immediately respond by mooing, and the boys would enjoy this exchange to their hearts' content. They would all imitate the sound vibrations made by the different kinds of birds, especially the cakoras, peacocks, cuckoo and bhäradväjas. Sometimes, when they would see the weaker animals fleeing out of fear of the sounds of tigers and lions, the boys, along with Kåñëa and Balaräma, would imitate the animals and run away with them. When they felt some fatigue, they would sit down, and Balaräma would put His head on the lap of one of the boys just to take rest, and Kåñëa would immediately come and begin massaging the legs of Balaräma. And sometimes He would take a palm fan and fan the body of Balaräma, causing a pleasing breeze to relieve Him of His fatigue. Other boys would sometimes dance or sing while Balaräma took rest, and sometimes they would wrestle amongst themselves or jump. When the boys were thus engaged, Kåñëa would immediately join them, and catching their hands, He would enjoy their company and laugh and praise their activities. When Kåñëa would feel tired and fatigued, He would sometimes take shelter of the root of a big tree, or the lap of a cowherd boy, and lie down. When He would lie down with a boy or a root as His pillow, some of the boys would come and massage His legs, and some would fan His body with a fan made from leaves. Some of the more talented boys would sing in very sweet voices to please Him. Thus very soon His fatigue would go away. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, whose legs are tended by the goddess of fortune, shared Himself with the cowherd boys as one of them, expanding His internal potency to appear exactly like a village boy. But despite His appearing just like a village boy, there were occasions when He proved Himself to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Sometimes men pose themselves as the Supreme Personality of Godhead and cheat innocent people, but they can only cheat; they cannot exhibit the potency of God.

While Kåñëa was thus engaged in exhibiting His internal potency along with the supermost fortunate friends, there occurred another chance for Him to exhibit the superhuman powers of Godhead. His most intimate friends Çrédämä, Subala and Stokakåñëa began to address Kåñëa and Balaräma with great love and affection thus: "Dear Balaräma, You are very powerful; Your arms are very strong. Dear Kåñëa, You are very expert in killing all kinds of disturbing demons. Will You kindly note that just near this place there is a big forest of the name Tälavana. This forest is full of palm trees, and all the trees are filled with fruits. Some are falling down, and some of them are very ripe even in the trees. It is a very nice place, but because of a great demon, Dhenukäsura, it is very difficult to go there. No one can reach the trees to collect the fruits. Dear Kåñëa and Balaräma, this demon is present there in the form of an ass, and he is surrounded by similar demon friends who assume the same shape. All of them are very strong, so it is very difficult to approach this place. Dear brothers, You are the only persons who can kill such demons. Other than You, no one can go there for fear of being killed. Not even animals go there, and no birds are sleeping there; they have all left. One can only appreciate the sweet aroma that is coming from that place. It appears that up until now, no one has tasted the sweet fruits there, either on the tree or on the ground. Dear Kåñëa, to tell You frankly, we are very attracted by this sweet aroma. Dear Balaräma, let us all go there and enjoy these fruits. The aroma of the fruits is now spread everywhere. Don't You smell it from here?"

When Balaräma and Kåñëa were thus petitioned by Their smiling, intimate friends, They were inclined to please them, and They began to proceed towards the forest, surrounded by all Their friends. Immediately upon entering the Tälavana, Balaräma began to yank the trees with His arms, exhibiting the strength of an elephant. Because of this jerking, all the ripe fruits fell down on the ground. Upon hearing the sound of the falling fruits, the demon Dhenukäsura, who was living there in the form of an ass, began to approach with great force, shaking the whole field so that all the trees began to move as if there were an earthquake. The demon appeared first before Balaräma and began to kick His chest with his hind legs. At first, Balaräma did not say anything, but the demon with great anger began to kick Him again more vehemently. This time Balaräma immediately caught hold of the legs of the ass with one hand and, wheeling him around, threw him into the treetops. While he was being wheeled around by Balaräma, the demon lost his life. Balaräma threw the demon into the biggest palm tree about, and the demon's body was so heavy that the palm tree fell upon other trees, and several fell down. It appeared as if a great hurricane had passed through the forest, and all the trees were falling down, one after another. This exhibition of extraordinary strength is not astonishing because Balaräma is the Personality of Godhead known as Ananta Çeñanäga, who is holding all the planets on the hoods of His millions of heads. The whole cosmic manifestation is maintained by Him exactly as two threads hold the weaving of a cloth.

After the demon was thrown into the trees, all the friends and associates of Dhenukäsura immediately assembled and attacked Balaräma and Kåñëa with great force. They were determined to retaliate and avenge the death of their friend. But Kåñëa and Balaräma began to catch each of the asses by the hind legs and, exactly in the same way, wheel them around. Thus They killed all of them by throwing them into the palm trees. Because of the dead bodies of the asses, there was a panoramic scene. It appeared as if clouds of various colors were assembled in the trees. Hearing of this great incident, the demigods from the higher planets began to shower flowers on Kåñëa and Balaräma and began to beat their drums and offer devotional prayers.

A few days after the killing of Dhenukäsura, people began to come into the Tälavana forest to collect the fruits, and animals began to return without fear to feed on the nice grasses grown there. Just by chanting or hearing these transcendental activities and pastimes of the brothers Kåñëa and Balaräma, one can amass pious activities.

When Kåñëa, Balaräma and Their friends entered the village of Våndävana, They played Their flutes, and the boys praised Their uncommon activities in the forest. Their faces were decorated with tilaka and smeared with the dust raised by the cows, and Kåñëa's head was decorated with a peacock feather. Both He and Balaräma played Their flutes, and the young gopés were joyous to see Kåñëa returning home. All the gopés in Våndävana remained very morose on account of Kåñëa's absence. All day they were thinking of Kåñëa in the forest or of Him herding cows in the pasture. When they saw Kåñëa returning, all their anxieties were immediately relieved, and they began to look at His face the way drones hover over the honey of the lotus flower. When Kåñëa entered the village, the young gopés smiled and laughed. Kåñëa, while playing the flute, enjoyed the beautiful smiling faces of the gopés.

Then Kåñëa and Balaräma were immediately received by Their affectionate mothers, Yaçodä and Rohiëé, and, according to the time's demands, they began to fulfill the desires of their affectionate sons. Simultaneously, the mothers rendered service and bestowed benediction upon their transcendental sons. They very nicely took care of their children by bathing and dressing Them. Kåñëa was dressed in bluish garments, and Balaräma was dressed in yellowish garments, and They were given all sorts of ornaments and flower garlands. Being relieved of the fatigue of Their day's work in the pasturing ground, They looked refreshed and very beautiful.

They were given palatable dishes by Their mothers, and They pleasantly ate everything. After eating, They were seated nicely on clean bedding, and the mothers began to sing various songs of Their activities. As soon as They sat down on the bedding, They very quickly fell fast asleep. In this way, Kåñëa and Balaräma used to enjoy Våndävana life as cowherd boys.

Sometimes Kåñëa used to go with His boy friends and with Balaräma, and sometimes He used to go alone with His friends to the bank of the Yamunä and tend the cows. Gradually, the summer season arrived, and one day, while in the field, the boys and cows became very thirsty and began to drink the water of the Yamunä. The river, however, was made poisonous by the venom of the great serpent known as Käliya.

Because the water was so poisonous, the boys and cows became visibly affected immediately after drinking. They suddenly fell down on the ground, apparently dead. Then Kåñëa, who is the life of all lives, simply cast His merciful glance over them, and all the boys and cows regained consciousness and began to look at one another with great astonishment. They could understand that by drinking the water of Yamunä they had died and that the merciful glance of Kåñëa restored their life. Thus they appreciated the mystic power of Kåñëa, who is known as Yogeçvara, the master of all mystic yogés.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fifteenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Killing of Dhenukäsura."

KB 1970-1-16 / Subduing Käliya

16 / Subduing Käliya

When He understood that the water of the Yamunä was being polluted by the black serpent Käliya, Lord Kåñëa took action against him and made him leave the Yamunä and go elsewhere, and thus the water became purified.

When this story was being narrated by Çukadeva Gosvämé, Mahäräja Parékñit became eager to hear more about Kåñëa's childhood pastimes. He inquired from Çukadeva Gosvämé how Kåñëa chastised Käliya, who was living in the water for many years. Actually, Mahäräja Parékñit was becoming more and more enthusiastic to hear the transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa, and his inquiry was made with great interest.

Çukadeva Gosvämé narrated the story as follows. Within the River Yamunä there was a great lake, and in that lake the black serpent Käliya used to live. Because of his poison, the whole area was so contaminated that it emanated a poisonous vapor twenty-four hours a day. If a bird happened to even pass over the spot, he would immediately fall down in the water and die.

Due to the poisonous effect of the Yamunä's vapors, the trees and grass near the bank of the Yamunä had all dried up. Lord Kåñëa saw the effect of the great serpent's poison: the whole river that ran before Våndävana was now deadly.

Kåñëa, who advented Himself just to kill all undesirable elements in the world, immediately climbed up in a big kadamba tree on the bank of the Yamunä. The kadamba is a round yellow flower, generally seen only in the Våndävana area. After climbing to the top of the tree, He tightened His belt cloth, and, flapping His arms just like a wrestler, jumped in the midst of the poisonous lake. The kadamba tree from which Kåñëa had jumped was the only tree there which was not dead. Some commentators say that due to touching the lotus feet of Kåñëa, the tree became immediately alive. In some other Puräëas it is stated that Garuòa, the eternal carrier of Viñëu, knew that Kåñëa would take this action in the future, so he put some nectar on this tree to preserve it. When Lord Kåñëa jumped into the water, the river overflooded its banks, as if something very large had fallen into it. This exhibition of Kåñëa's strength is not at all uncommon because He is the reservoir of all strength.

When Kåñëa was swimming about, just like a great strong elephant, He made a tumultuous sound which the great black serpent Käliya could hear. The tumult was intolerable for him, and he could understand that this was an attempt to attack his home. Therefore he immediately came before Kåñëa. Käliya saw that Kåñëa was indeed worth seeing because His body was so beautiful and delicate; its color resembled that of a cloud, and His legs resembled a lotus flower. He was decorated with Çrévatsa, jewels and yellow garments. He was smiling with a beautiful face and was playing in the River Yamunä with great strength. But in spite of Kåñëa's beautiful features, Käliya felt great anger within his heart, and thus he grabbed Kåñëa with his mighty coils. Seeing the incredible way in which Kåñëa was enveloped in the coils of the serpent, the affectionate cowherd boys and inhabitants of Våndävana immediately became stunned out of fear. They had dedicated everything to Kåñëa, their lives, property, affection, activities—everything was for Kåñëa—and when they saw Him in that condition, they became overwhelmed with fear and fell down on the ground. All the cows, bulls and small calves became overwhelmed with grief, and they began to look at Him with great anxiety. Out of fear they could only cry in agony and stand erect on the bank, unable to help their beloved Kåñëa.

While this scene was taking place on the bank of the Yamunä, there were ill omens manifest. The earth trembled, meteors fell from the sky, and the bodies of men shivered. All these are indications of great immediate danger. Observing the inauspicious signs, the cowherd men, including Mahäräja Nanda, became very anxious out of fear. At the same time they were informed that Kåñëa had gone to the pasturing ground without His elder brother, Balaräma. As soon as Nanda and Yaçodä and the cowherd men heard this news, they became even more anxious. Out of their great affection for Kåñëa, unaware of the extent of Kåñëa's potencies, they became overwhelmed with grief and anxiety because they had nothing dearer than Kåñëa and because they dedicated their everything—life, property, affection, mind and activities—to Kåñëa. Because of their great attachment for Kåñëa, they thought, "Today Kåñëa is surely going to be vanquished!"

All the inhabitants of Våndävana came out of the village to see Kåñëa. The assembly consisted of children, young and old men, women, animals and all living entities; they knew that Kåñëa was their only means of sustenance. While this was happening, Balaräma, who is the master of all knowledge, stood there simply smiling. He knew how powerful His younger brother Kåñëa was and that there was no cause for anxiety when Kåñëa was fighting with an ordinary serpent of the material world. He did not, therefore, personally take any part in their concern. On the other hand, all the inhabitants of Våndävana, being disturbed, began to search out Kåñëa by following the impression of His footprints on the ground, and thus they moved towards the bank of the Yamunä. Finally, by following the footprints marked with flag, bow and conchshell, the inhabitants of Våndävana arrived at the river bank and saw that all the cows and boys were weeping to behold Kåñëa enwrapped in the coils of the black serpent. Then they became still more overwhelmed with grief. While Balaräma was smiling to see their lamentation, all the inhabitants of Vrajabhümi merged into the ocean of grief because they thought that Kåñëa was finished. Although the residents of Våndävana did not know much about Kåñëa, their love for Him was beyond comparison. As soon as they saw that Kåñëa was in the River Yamunä enveloped by the serpent Käliya and that all the boys and cows were lamenting, they simply began to think of Kåñëa's friendship, His smiling face, His sweet words and His dealings with them. Thinking of all these and believing that their Kåñëa was now within the clutches of Käliya, they at once felt that the three worlds had become vacant. Lord Caitanya also said that He was seeing the three worlds as vacant for want of Kåñëa. This is the highest stage of Kåñëa consciousness. Almost all of the inhabitants of Våndävana had the highest ecstasy, love for Kåñëa.

When mother Yaçodä arrived, she wanted to enter the River Yamunä, and being checked, she fainted. Other friends who were equally aggrieved were shedding tears like torrents of rain or waves of the river, but in order to bring mother Yaçodä to consciousness, they began to speak loudly about the transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa. Mother Yaçodä remained still, as if dead, because her consciousness was concentrated on the face of Kåñëa. Nanda and all others who dedicated everything, including their lives, to Kåñëa were ready to enter the waters of the Yamunä, but Lord Balaräma checked them because He was in perfect knowledge that there was no danger.

For two hours Kåñëa remained like an ordinary child gripped in the coils of Käliya, but when He saw that all the inhabitants of Gokula—including His mother and father, the gopés, the boys and the cows—were just on the point of death and that they had no shelter for salvation from imminent death, Kåñëa immediately freed Himself. He began to expand His body, and when the serpent tried to hold Him, he felt a great strain. On account of the strain, his coils slackened, and he had no other alternative but to let loose the Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, from his grasp. Käliya then became very angry, and his great hoods expanded. He exhaled poisonous fumes from his nostrils, his eyes blazed like fire, and flames issued from his mouth. The great serpent remained still for some time, looking at Kåñëa. Licking his lips with bifurcated tongues, the serpent looked at Kåñëa with double hoods, and his eyesight was full of poison. Kåñëa immediately pounced upon him, just as Garuòa swoops upon a snake. Thus attacked, Käliya looked for an opportunity to bite Him, but Kåñëa moved around him. As Kåñëa and Käliya moved in a circle, the serpent gradually became fatigued, and his strength seemed to diminish considerably. Kåñëa immediately pressed down the serpent's hoods and jumped up on them. The Lord's lotus feet became tinged with red from the rays of the jewels on the snake's hoods. Then He who is the original artist of all fine arts, such as dancing, began to dance upon the hoods of the serpent, although they were moving to and fro. Upon seeing this, denizens from the upper planets began to shower flowers, beat drums, play different types of flutes and sing various prayers and songs. In this way, all the denizens of heaven, such as the Gandharvas, Siddhas and demigods, became very pleased.

While Kåñëa was dancing on his hoods, Käliya tried to push Him down with some of his other hoods. Käliya had about a hundred hoods, but Kåñëa took control of them. He began to dash Käliya with His lotus feet, and this was more than the serpent could bear. Gradually, Käliya was reduced to struggling for his very life. He vomited all kinds of refuse and exhaled fire. While throwing up poisonous material from within, Käliya became reduced in his sinful situation. Out of great anger, he began to struggle for existence and tried to raise one of his hoods to kill the Lord. The Lord immediately captured that hood and subdued it by kicking it and dancing on it. It actually appeared as if the Supreme Personality of Godhead Viñëu was being worshiped; the poisons emanating from the mouth of the serpent appeared to be like flower offerings. Käliya then began to vomit blood instead of poison; he was completely fatigued. His whole body appeared to be broken by the kicks of the Lord. Within his mind, however, he finally began to understand that Kåñëa was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and he began to surrender unto Him. He realized that Kåñëa was the Supreme Lord, the master of everything.

The wives of the serpent, known as the Nägapatnés, saw that their husband was being subdued by the kicking of the Lord, within whose womb the whole universe remains. Käliya's wives prepared to worship the Lord, although, in their haste, their dress, hair and ornaments became disarrayed. They also surrendered unto the Supreme Lord and began to pray. They appeared before Him, put forward their offspring and anxiously offered respectful obeisances, falling down on the bank of the Yamunä. The Nägapatnés knew that Kåñëa is the shelter of all surrendered souls, and they desired to release their husband from the impending danger by pleasing the Lord with their prayers.

The Nägapatnés began to offer their prayers as follows: "O dear Lord, You are equal to everyone. For You there is no distinction between Your sons, friends or enemies. Therefore the punishment which You have so kindly offered to Käliya is exactly befitting. O Lord, You have descended especially for the purpose of annihilating all kinds of disturbing elements within the world, and because You are the Absolute Truth, there is no difference between Your mercy and punishment. We think, therefore, that this apparent punishment to Käliya is actually some benediction. We consider that Your punishment is Your great mercy upon us because when You punish someone it is to be understood that the reactions of his sinful activities are eradicated. It is already clear that this creature appearing in the body of a serpent must have been overburdened with all kinds of sin; otherwise, how could he have the body of a serpent? Your dancing on his hoods reduces all the sinful results of actions caused by his having this body of a serpent. It is, therefore, very auspicious that You have become angry and have punished him in this way. We are very astonished to see how You have become so pleased with this serpent who evidently performed various religious activities in his past lives. Everyone must have been pleased by his undergoing all kinds of penances and austerities, and he must have executed universal welfare activities for all living creatures."

The Nägapatnés confirm that one cannot come in contact with Kåñëa without having executed pious activities in devotional service in his previous lives. As Lord Caitanya advised in His Çikñäñöaka [3], one has to execute devotional service by humbly chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra, thinking oneself lower than the straw in the street and not expecting honor for himself but offering all kinds of honor to others. The Nägapatnés were astonished that, although Käliya had the body of a serpent as the result of grievous sinful activities, at the same time he was in contact with the Lord to the extent that the Lord's lotus feet were touching his hoods. Certainly this was not the ordinary result of pious activities. These two contradictory facts astonished them. Thus they continued to pray: "O dear Lord, we are simply astonished to see that he is so fortunate as to have the the dust of Your lotus feet on his head. This is a fortune sought after by great saintly persons. Even the goddess of fortune underwent severe austerities just to have the blessing of the dust of Your lotus feet, so how is it that Käliya is so easily getting this dust on his head? We have heard from authoritative sources that those who are blessed with the dust of Your lotus feet do not care even for the highest post within the universe, namely the post of Lord Brahmä, or the kingship of heavenly planets, or the sovereignty of this planet. Nor do such persons desire to rule the planets above this earth, such as Siddhaloka; nor do they aspire for the mystic powers achieved by the yoga process. Nor do the pure devotees aspire for liberation by becoming one with You. My Lord, although he is born in a species of life which is fostered by the most abominable modes of material nature, accompanied with the quality of anger, this King of the serpents has achieved something very, very rare. Living entities who are wandering within this universe and getting different species of life can very easily achieve the greatest benediction only by Your mercy."

It is also confirmed in the Caitanya-caritämåta that the living entities are wandering within the universe in various species of life, but by the mercy of Kåñëa and the spiritual master, they can get the seed of devotional service, and thus their path of liberation can be cleared.

"We therefore offer our respectful obeisances unto You," the Nägapatnés continued, "our dear Lord, because You are the Supreme Person, You are living as the Supersoul within every living entity; although You are transcendental to the cosmic manifestation, everything is resting in You. You are the personified indefatigable eternal time. The entire time force is existing in You, and You are therefore the seer and the embodiment of total time in the shape of past, present and future, month, day, hour, moment—everything. In other words, O Lord, You can see perfectly all the activities happening in every moment, in every hour, in every day, every year, past, present and future. You are Yourself the universal form, and yet You are different from this universe. You are simultaneously one and different from the universe. We therefore offer our respectful obeisances unto You. You are Yourself the whole universe, and yet You are the creator of the whole universe. You are the superintendent and maintainer of this whole universe, and You are its original cause. Although You are present within this universe by Your three qualitative incarnations, Brahmä, Viñëu, and Maheçvara, You are transcendental to the material creation. Although You are the cause of the appearance of all kinds of living entities—their senses, their lives, their minds, their intelligence—You are to be realized by Your internal energy. Let us therefore offer our respectful obeisances unto You, who are unlimited, finer than the finest, the center of all creation and knower of everything. Different varieties of philosophical speculators try to reach You. You are the ultimate goal of all philosophical efforts, and You are actually described by all philosophies and by different kinds of doctrines. Let us offer our respectful obeisances unto You, because You are the origin of all scripture and the source of knowledge. You are the root of all evidences, and You are the Supreme Person who can bestow upon us the supreme knowledge. You are the cause of all kinds of desires, and You are the cause of all kinds of satisfaction. You are the Vedas personified. Therefore we offer You our respectful obeisances.

"Our dear Lord, You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, and You are also the supreme enjoyer now appeared as the son of Vasudeva, who is a manifestation of the pure state of goodness. You are the predominating Deity of mind and intelligence, Pradyumna and Aniruddha, and You are the Lord of all Vaiñëavas. By Your expansion as caturvyüha—namely Väsudeva, Saìkarñaëa, Aniruddha and Pradyumna—You are the cause of the development of mind and intelligence. By Your activities only, the living entities become covered by forgetfulness or discover their real identity. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä (Fifteenth Chapter): the Lord is sitting as the Supersoul in everyone's heart, and due to His presence the living entity either forgets himself or revives his original identity. We can partially understand that You are within our hearts as the witness of all our activities, but it is very difficult to appreciate Your presence, although every one of us can do so to some extent. You are the supreme controller of both the material and spiritual energies; therefore You are the supreme leader, although You are different from this cosmic manifestation. You are the witness and creator and the very ingredient of this cosmic manifestation. We therefore offer our respectful obeisances unto You. Our dear Lord, in the matter of creating this cosmic manifestation, personally You have nothing to exert; by expending Your different kinds of energy—namely the mode of goodness, the mode of passion and the mode of ignorance—You can create, maintain and annihilate this cosmic manifestation. As the controller of the entire time force, You can simply glance over the material energy, create this universe and energize the different forces of material nature which are acting differently in different creatures. No one can estimate, therefore, how Your activities are going on within this world. Our dear Lord, although You have expanded into the three principal Deities of this universe—namely Lord Brahmä, Lord Viñëu and Lord Çiva—for creation, maintenance and destruction, Your appearance as Lord Viñëu is actually for the benediction of living creatures. Therefore, for those who are actually peaceful and who are aspiring after the supreme peace, worship of Your peaceful appearance as Lord Viñëu is recommended. O Lord, we are submitting our prayers unto You. You can appreciate that this poor serpent is going to give up his life. You know that for us women our lives and everything are our husband's; therefore, we are praying unto You that You kindly excuse Käliya, our husband, because if this serpent dies, then we shall be in great difficulty. Looking upon us only, please excuse this great offender. Our dear Lord, every living creature is Your offspring, and You maintain everyone. This serpent is also Your offspring, and You can excuse him although he has offended You, undoubtedly without knowing Your potency. We are praying that he may be excused for this time. Our dear Lord, we are offering our loving service unto You because we are all eternal servitors of Your Lordship. You can order us and ask us to do whatever You please. Every living being can be relieved from all kinds of despair if he agrees to abide by Your orders."

After the Nägapatnés submitted their prayers, Lord Kåñëa released Käliya from his punishment. Käliya was already unconscious from being struck by the Lord. Upon regaining consciousness and being released from the punishment, Käliya got back his life force and the working power of his senses. With folded hands, he humbly began to pray to the Supreme Lord Kåñëa: "My dear Lord, I have been born in such a species that by nature I am angry and envious, being in the darkest region of the mode of ignorance. Your Lordship knows well that it is very difficult to give up one's natural instincts, although by such instincts the living creature transmigrates from one body to another." It is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.14] that it is very difficult to get out of the clutches of material nature, but if anyone surrenders unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, the modes of material nature can no longer act on him. "My dear Lord," Käliya continued, "You are therefore the original creator of all kinds of modes of material nature by which the universe is created. You are the cause of the different kinds of mentality possessed by living creatures by which they have obtained different varieties of bodies. My dear Lord, I am born as a serpent; therefore, by natural instinct, I am very angry. How is it then possible to give up my acquired nature without Your mercy? It is very difficult to get out of the clutches of Your mäyä. By Your mäyä we remain enslaved. My dear Lord, kindly excuse me for my inevitable material tendencies. Now You can punish me or save me as You desire."

After hearing this, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who was acting as a small human child, ordered the serpent thus: "You must immediately leave this place and go to the ocean. Leave without delay. You can take with you all your offspring, wives and everything that you possess. Don't pollute the waters of the Yamunä. Let it be drunk by My cows and cowherd boys without hindrance." The Lord then declared that the order given to the Käliya snake be recited and heard by everyone so that no one need fear Käliya any longer.

Anyone who hears the narration of the Käliya serpent and his punishment will need fear no more the envious activities of snakes. The Lord also declared: "If one takes a bath in the Käliya lake where My cowherd boy friends and I have bathed, or if one, fasting for a day, offers oblations to the forefathers from the water of this lake, he will be relieved from all kinds of sinful reaction." The Lord also assured Käliya: "You came here out of fear of Garuòa, who wanted to eat you in the beautiful land by the ocean. Now, after seeing the marks where I have touched your head with My lotus feet, Garuòa will not disturb you."

The Lord was pleased with Käliya and his wives. Immediately after hearing His order, the wives began to worship Him with great offerings of nice garments, flowers, garlands, jewels, ornaments, sandal pulp, lotus flowers, and nice eatable fruits. In this way they pleased the master of Garuòa, of whom they were very much afraid. Then, obeying the orders of Lord Kåñëa, all of them left the lake within the Yamunä.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Sixteenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Subduing Käliya."

KB 1970-1-17 / Extinguishing the Forest Fire

17 / Extinguishing the Forest Fire

King Parékñit, after hearing of the chastisement of Käliya, inquired from Çukadeva Gosvämé as to why Käliya left his beautiful land and why Garuòa was so antagonistic to him. Çukadeva Gosvämé informed the King that the island known as Nägälaya was inhabited by serpents and that Käliya was one of the chief serpents there. Being accustomed to eating snakes, Garuòa used to come to this island and kill many serpents at his will. Some of them he actually ate, but some were unnecessarily killed. The reptile society became so disturbed that their leader, Väsuki, appealed to Lord Brahmä for protection. Lord Brahmä made an arrangement by which Garuòa would not create a disturbance: on each half-moon day, the reptile community would offer a serpent to Garuòa. The serpent was to be kept underneath a tree as a sacrificial offering to Garuòa. Garuòa was satisfied with this offering, and therefore he did not disturb any other serpents.

But gradually, Käliya took advantage of this situation. He was unnecessarily puffed up by the volume of his accumulated poison, as well as by his material power, and he thought, "Why should Garuòa be offered this sacrifice?" He then ceased offering any sacrifice; instead, he himself ate the offering intended for Garuòa. When Garuòa, the great devotee-carrier of Viñëu, understood that Käliya was eating the offered sacrifices, he became very angry and quickly rushed to the island to kill the offensive serpent. Käliya tried to fight Garuòa and faced him with his many hoods and poisonous sharp teeth. Käliya attempted to bite him, and Garuòa, the son of Tärkñya, in great anger and with the great force deserving the carrier of Lord Viñëu, struck the body of Käliya with his effulgent golden wings. Käliya, who is also known as Kadrüsuta, son of Kadrü, immediately fled to the lake known as Käliyadaha, underneath the Yamunä River, which Garuòa could not approach.

Käliya took shelter within the water of the Yamunä for the following reason. Just as Garuòa went to the island of the Käliya snake, so he also used to go to the Yamunä to catch fish to eat. There was, however, a great yogé known as Saubhari Muni, who used to meditate within the water there and who was sympathetic with the fish. He asked Garuòa not to come there and disturb the fish. Although Garuòa was not under anyone's order, being the carrier of Lord Viñëu, he did not disobey the order of the great yogé. Instead of staying and eating many fish, he carried off one big fish, who was their leader. Saubhari Muni was sorry that one of the leaders of the fish was taken away by Garuòa, and thinking of their protection, he cursed Garuòa in the following words: "Henceforward from this day, if Garuòa comes here to catch fish, then—I say this with all my strength—he will be immediately killed."

This curse was known only to Käliya. Käliya was, therefore, confident that Garuòa would not be able to come there, and so he thought it wise to take shelter of the lake within the Yamunä. But Käliya's taking shelter of Saubhari Muni was not successful; he was driven away from the Yamunä by Kåñëa, the master of Garuòa. It may be noted that Garuòa is directly related to the Supreme Personality of Godhead and is so powerful that he is never subjected to anyone's order or curse. Actually the cursing of Garuòa—who is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [6.8.29] to be of the stature of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Bhagavän—was an offense on the part of Saubhari Muni. Although Garuòa did not try to retaliate, the Muni was not saved from his offensive act against a great Vaiñëava personality. Due to this offence, Saubhari fell down from his yogic position and afterwards became a householder, a sense enjoyer in the material world. The falldown of Saubhari Muni, who was supposed to be absorbed in spiritual bliss by meditation, is an instruction to the offender of Vaiñëavas.

When Kåñëa finally came out of Käliya's lake, He was seen by all His friends and relatives on the bank of Yamunä. He appeared before them nicely decorated, smeared all over with candana pulp, bedecked with valuable jewels and stones, and almost completely covered with gold. The inhabitants of Våndävana, cowherd boys and men, mother Yaçodä, Mahäräja Nanda and all the cows and calves, saw Kåñëa coming from the Yamunä, and it was as though they had recovered their very life. When a person regains his life, naturally he becomes absorbed in pleasure and joyfulness. They each in turn pressed Kåñëa to their chests, and thus they felt a great relief. Mother Yaçodä, Rohiëé, Mahäräja Nanda and the cowherd men became so happy that they embraced Kåñëa and thought they had achieved their ultimate goal of life.

Balaräma also embraced Kåñëa, but He was laughing because He had known what would happen to Kåñëa when everyone else was so overwhelmed with anxiety. All the trees on the bank of the Yamunä, all the cows, bulls and calves were full of pleasure because of Kåñëa's appearance there. The brähmaëa inhabitants of Våndävana, along with their wives, immediately came to congratulate Kåñëa and His family members. Brähmaëas are considered to be the spiritual masters of society. They offered their blessings to Kåñëa and the family on account of Kåñëa's release. They also asked Mahäräja Nanda to give them some charity on that occasion. Being so pleased by Kåñëa's return, Mahäräja Nanda began to give many cows and much gold in charity to the brähmaëas. While Nanda Mahäräja was thus engaged, mother Yaçodä simply embraced Kåñëa and made Him sit on her lap while she shed tears continually.

Since it was almost night, and all the inhabitants of Våndävana, including the cows and calves, were very tired, they decided to take their rest on the river bank. In the middle of the night, while they were taking rest, there was suddenly a great forest fire, and it quickly appeared that the fire would soon devour all the inhabitants of Våndävana. As soon as they felt the warmth of the fire, they immediately took shelter of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, although He was playing just like their child. They began to say, "Our dear Kåñëa! O Supreme Personality of Godhead! Our dear Balaräma, the reservoir of all strength! Please try to save us from this all devouring and devastating fire. We have no other shelter than You. This devastating fire will swallow us all!" Thus they prayed to Kåñëa, saying that they could not take any shelter other than His lotus feet. Lord Kåñëa, being compassionate upon His own townspeople, immediately swallowed up the whole forest fire and saved them. This was not impossible for Kåñëa because He is unlimited. He has unlimited power to do anything He desires.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Seventeenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Extinguishing the Forest Fire."

KB 1970-1-18 / Killing the Demon Pralambäsura

18 / Killing the Demon Pralambäsura

After extinguishing the devastating fire, Kåñëa, surrounded by His relatives, friends, cows, calves and bulls and glorified by their singing, again entered Våndävana, which is always full of cows. While Kåñëa and Balaräma were enjoying life in Våndävana, in the midst of the cowherd boys and girls, the season gradually changed to summer. The summer season in India is not very much welcomed because of the excessive heat, but in Våndävana everyone was pleased because summer there appeared just like spring. This was possible only because Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, who are the controllers even of Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva, were residing there. In Våndävana there are many falls which are always pouring water, and the sound is so sweet that it covers the sound of the crickets. And because water flows all over, the forest always looks very green and beautiful.

The inhabitants of Våndävana were never disturbed by the scorching heat of the sun or the high summer temperatures. The lakes of Våndävana are surrounded by green grasses, and various kinds of lotus flowers bloom there, such as the kalhära-kaïjotpala, and the air blowing in Våndävana carries the aromatic pollen of those lotus flowers. When the particles of water from the waves of the Yamunä, the lakes and the waterfalls, touched the bodies of the inhabitants of Våndävana, they automatically felt a cooling effect. Therefore they were practically undisturbed by the summer season.

Våndävana is such a nice place. Flowers are always blooming, and there are even various kinds of decorated deer. Birds are chirping, peacocks are crowing and dancing, and bees are humming. The cuckoos there sing nicely in five kinds of tunes.

Kåñëa, the reservoir of pleasure, blowing His flute, accompanied by His elder brother Balaräma and other cowherd boys and cows, entered the beautiful forest of Våndävana to enjoy the atmosphere. They walked into the midst of newly grown leaves of trees whose flowers resembled peacock feathers. They were garlanded by those flowers and decorated with saffron chalk. Sometimes they were dancing and singing and sometimes wrestling with one another. While Kåñëa danced, some of the cowherd boys sang, and others played on flutes; some bugled on buffalo horns or clapped their hands, praising Kåñëa, "Dear brother, You are dancing very nicely." Actually, all these boys were demigods descended from higher planets to assist Kåñëa in His pastimes. The demigods garbed in the dress of the cowherd boys were encouraging Kåñëa in His dancing, just as one artist encourages another with praise. Up to that time, neither Balaräma nor Kåñëa had undergone the haircutting ceremony; therefore Their hair was clustered like crows' feathers. They were always playing hide-and-seek with Their boy friends or jumping or fighting with one another. Sometimes, while His friends were chanting and dancing, Kåñëa would praise them, "My dear friends, you are dancing and singing very nicely." The boys played at catching ball with bell shaped fruits and round ämalaké. They played blindman's buff, challenging and touching one another. Sometimes they imitated the forest deer and various kinds of birds. They joked with one another by imitating croaking frogs, and they enjoyed swinging underneath the trees. Sometimes they would play like a king and his subjects amongst themselves. In this way, Balaräma and Kåñëa, along with all Their friends, played all kinds of sports and enjoyed the soothing atmosphere of Våndävana, full of rivers, lakes, rivulets, fine trees and excellent fruits and flowers.

Once while they were engaged in their transcendental pastimes, a great demon of the name Pralambäsura entered their company, desiring to kidnap both Balaräma and Kåñëa. Although Kåñëa was playing the part of a cowherd boy, as the Supreme Personality of Godhead He could understand everything—past, present and future. So when Pralambäsura entered their company, Kåñëa began to think how to kill the demon, but externally He received him as a friend. "O My dear friend," He said. "It is very good that you have come to take part in our pastimes." Kåñëa then called all His friends and ordered them: "Now we shall play in pairs. We shall challenge one another in pairs." With this proposal, all the boys assembled together. Some of them took the side of Kåñëa, and some of them took the side of Balaräma, and they arranged to play in duel. The defeated members in duel fighting had to carry the victorious members on their backs. They began playing, and at the same time tended the cows as they proceeded through the Bhäëòéravana forest. The party of Balaräma, accompanied by Çrédämä and Våñabha, came out victorious, and Kåñëa's party had to carry them on their backs through the Bhäëòéravana forest. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, being defeated, had to carry Çrédämä on His back, and Bhadrasena carried Våñabha. Imitating their play, Pralambäsura, who appeared there as a cowherd boy, carried Balaräma on his back. Pralambäsura was the greatest of the demons, and he had calculated that Kåñëa was the most powerful of the cowherd boys.

In order to avoid the company of Kåñëa, Pralambäsura carried Balaräma far away. The demon was undoubtedly very strong and powerful, but he was carrying Balaräma, who is compared with a mountain; therefore he began to feel the burden, and thus he assumed his real form. When he appeared in his real feature, he was decorated with a golden helmet and earrings and looked just like a cloud with lightning carrying the moon. Balaräma observed the demon's body expanding up to the limits of the clouds, his eyes dazzling like blazing fire and his mouth flashing with sharpened teeth. At first, Balaräma was surprised by the demon's appearance, and He began to wonder, "How is it that all of a sudden this carrier has changed in every way?" But with a clear mind He could quickly understand that He was being carried away from His friends by a demon who intended to kill Him. Immediately He struck the head of the demon with His strong fist, just as the king of the heavenly planets strikes a mountain with his thunderbolt. Being stricken by the fist of Balaräma, the demon fell down dead, just like a snake with a smashed head, and blood poured from his mouth. When the demon fell, he made a tremendous sound, and it sounded as if a great hill were falling upon being struck by the thunderbolt of King Indra. All the boys then rushed to the spot. Being astonished by the ghastly scene, they began to praise Balaräma with the words, "Well done, well done." All of them then began to embrace Balaräma with great affection, thinking that He had returned from death, and they offered their blessings and congratulations. All the demigods in the heavenly planets became very satisfied and showered flowers on the transcendental body of Balaräma, and they also offered their blessings and congratulations for His having killed the great demon Pralambäsura.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Eighteenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Killing the Demon Pralambäsura."

KB 1970-1-19 / Devouring the Forest Fire

19 / Devouring the Forest Fire

While Kåñëa and Balaräma and Their friends were engaged in the pastimes described above, the cows, being unobserved, began to wander off on their own, entering farther and farther into the deepest part of the forest, allured by fresh grasses. The goats, cows and buffalo travelled from one forest to another and entered the forest known as Iñikäöavi. This forest was full of green grass, and therefore they were allured; but when they entered, they saw that there was a forest fire, and they began to cry. On the other side, Balaräma and Kåñëa, along with Their friends, could not find their animals, and they became very aggrieved. They began to trace the cows by following their footprints, as well as the path of eaten grass. All of the boys were fearing that their very means of livelihood, the cows, were now lost. Soon, however, they heard the crying of their cows. Kåñëa began to call the cows by their respective names, with great noise. Upon hearing Kåñëa calling, the cows immediately replied with joy. But by this time the forest fire surrounded all of them, and the situation appeared to be very fearful. The flames increased as the wind blew very quickly, and it appeared that everything movable and immovable would be devoured. All the cows and the boys became very frightened, and they looked towards Balaräma the way a dying man looks at the picture of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They said, "Dear Kåñëa and Balaräma, we are now burning from the heat of this blazing fire. Let us take shelter of Your lotus feet. We know You can protect us from this great danger. Our dear friend Kåñëa, we are Your intimate friends. It is not right that we should suffer in this way. We are all completely dependent on You, and You are the knower of all religious life. We do not know anyone except You."

The Personality of Godhead heard the appealing voices of His friends, and casting a pleasing glance over them, He began to answer. By speaking through His eyes, He impressed His friends that there was no cause for fear. Then Kåñëa, the supreme mystic, the powerful Personality of Godhead, immediately swallowed up all the flames of the fire. The cows and boys were thus saved from imminent danger. Out of fear, the boys were almost unconscious, but when they regained their consciousness and opened their eyes, they saw that they were again in the forest with Kåñëa, Balaräma and the cows. They were astonished to see that they were completely free from the attack of the blazing fire and that the cows were saved. They secretly thought that Kåñëa must not be an ordinary boy, but some demigod.

In the evening, Kåñëa and Balaräma, along with the boys and cows, returned to Våndävana, playing Their flutes. As they approached the village, all the gopés became very joyous. Throughout the day the gopés used to think of Kåñëa while He was in the forest, and in His absence they were considering one moment to be like twelve years.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Nineteenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Devouring the Forest Fire."

KB 1970-1-20 / Description of Autumn

20 / Description of Autumn

The killing of Pralambäsura and the devouring of the devastating forest fire by Kåñëa and Balaräma became household topics in Våndävana. The cowherd men described these wonderful activities to their wives and to everyone else, and all were struck with wonder. They concluded that Kåñëa and Balaräma were demigods who had kindly come to Våndävana to become their children. In this way, the rainy season ensued. In India, after the scorching heat of the summer, the rainy season is very welcome. The clouds accumulating in the sky, covering the sun and the moon, become very pleasing to the people, and they expect rainfall at every moment. After summer, the advent of the rainy season is considered to be a life-giving source for everyone. The thunder and occasional lightning are also pleasurable to the people.

The symptoms of the rainy season may be compared to the symptoms of the living entities who are covered by the three modes of material nature. The unlimited sky is like the Supreme Brahman, and the tiny living entities are like the covered sky, or Brahman covered by the three modes of material nature. Originally, everyone is part and parcel of Brahman. The Supreme Brahman, or the unlimited sky, can never be covered by a cloud, but a portion of it can be covered. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.7], the living entities are part and parcel of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. But they are only an insignificant portion of the Supreme Lord. This portion is covered by the modes of material nature, and therefore the living entities are residing within this material world. The brahmajyoti—spiritual effulgence—is just like the sunshine; as the sunshine is full of molecular shining particles, so the brahmajyoti is full of minute portions of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Out of that unlimited expansion of minute portions of the Supreme Lord, some are covered by the influence of material nature, whereas others are free.

Clouds are accumulated water drawn from the land by the sunshine. Continually for eight months the sun evaporates all kinds of water from the surface of the globe, and this water is accumulated in the shape of clouds, which are distributed as water when there is need. Similarly, a government exacts various taxes from the citizens which the citizens are able to pay by their different material activities: agriculture, trade and industry; thus the government can also exact taxes in the form of income tax and sales tax. This is compared to the sun drawing water from the earth. When there is again need of water on the surface of the globe, the same sunshine converts the water into clouds and distributes it all over the globe. Similarly, the taxes collected by the government must be distributed to the people again, as educational work, public work, sanitary work, etc. This is very essential for a good government. The government should not simply exact tax for useless squandering; the tax collection should be utilized for the public welfare of the state.

During the rainy season, there are strong winds blustering all over the country and carrying clouds from one place to another to distribute water. When water is urgently needed after the summer season, the clouds are just like a rich man who, in times of need, distributes his money even by exhausting his whole treasury. So the clouds exhaust themselves by distributing water all over the surface of the globe.

When Mahäräja Daçaratha, the father of Lord Rämacandra, used to fight with his enemies, it was said that he approached them just like a farmer uprooting unnecessary plants and trees. And when there was need of giving charity, he used to distribute money exactly as the cloud distributes rain. The distribution of rain by clouds is so sumptuous that it is compared to the distribution of wealth by a great, munificent person. The clouds' downpour is so sufficient that the rains even fall on rocks and hills and on the oceans and seas where there is no need for water. It is like a charitable person who opens his treasury for distribution and who does not discriminate whether the charity is needed or not. He gives in charity openhanded.

Before the rainfall, the whole surface of the globe becomes almost depleted of all kinds of energies and appears very lean. After the rainfall, the whole surface of the earth becomes green with vegetation and appears to be very healthy and strong. Here, a comparison is made with the person undergoing austerities for fulfillment of a material desire. The flourishing condition of the earth after a rainy season is compared with the fulfillment of material desires. Sometimes, when a country is subjected by an undesirable government, persons and parties undergo severe penances and austerities to get control of the government, and when they attain control, they flourish by giving themselves generous salaries. This also is like the flourishing of the earth in the rainy season. Actually, one should undergo severe austerities and penances only to achieve spiritual happiness. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is recommended that tapasa or penance should be accepted for realizing the Supreme Lord. By accepting austerity in devotional service, one regains his spiritual life, and as soon as one regains his spiritual life, he enjoys unlimited spiritual bliss. But if someone undertakes austerities and penances for some material gain, it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20] that the results are temporary and that they are desired by persons of less intelligence.

During the rainy season, in the evening, there are many glowworms visible about the tops of trees, hither and thither, and they glitter just like lights. But the luminaries of the sky, the stars and the moons, are not visible. Similarly, in the age of Kali, persons who are atheists or miscreants become very prominently visible, whereas persons who are actually following the Vedic principles for spiritual emancipation are practically obscured. This age, Kaliyuga, is compared to the cloudy season of the living entities. In this age, real knowledge is covered by the influence of material advancement of civilization. The cheap mental speculators, atheists and manufacturers of so-called religious principles become prominent like the glowworms, whereas persons strictly following the Vedic principles or scriptural injunctions become covered by the clouds of this age. People should learn to take advantage of the actual luminaries of the sky, the sun, moon, and stars, instead of the glowworm's light. Actually, the glowworm cannot give any light in the darkness of night. As clouds sometimes clear, even in the rainy season, and sometimes the moon, stars and sun become visible, so even in this Kaliyuga there are sometimes advantages. The Vedic movement of Lord Caitanya's—the distribution of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra—is heard in this way. People seriously anxious to find real life should take advantage of this movement instead of looking toward the light of mental speculators and atheists.

After the first rainfall, when there is a thundering sound in the clouds, all the frogs begin to croak, like students suddenly engaged in reading their studies. Students are generally supposed to rise early in the morning. They do not usually arise of their own accord, however, but only when there is a bell sounded in the temple or in the cultural institution. By the order of the spiritual master they immediately rise, and after finishing their morning duties, they sit down to study the Vedas or chant Vedic mantras. Everyone is sleeping in the darkness of Kaliyuga, but when there is a great äcärya, by his calling only, everyone takes to the study of the Vedas to acquire actual knowledge. During the rainy season, many small ponds, lakes and rivulets become filled with water; otherwise the rest of the year they remain dry. Similarly, materialistic persons are dry, but sometimes, when they are in a so-called opulent position, with a home or children or a little bank balance, they appear to be flourishing, but immediately afterwards they become dry again, like the small rivulets and ponds. The poet Vidyäpati said that in the society of friends, family, children, wife, etc., there is certainly some pleasure, but that pleasure is compared to a drop of water in the desert. Everyone is hankering after happiness, just as in the desert everyone is hankering after water. If, in the desert, there is a drop of water, the water is there of course, but the benefit from that drop of water is very insignificant. In our materialistic way of life, we are hankering after an ocean of happiness, but in the form of society, friends and mundane love, we are getting no more than a drop of water. Our satisfaction is never achieved, as the small rivulets, lakes and ponds are never filled with water in the dry season.

Due to rainfall, the grass, trees and vegetation look very green. Sometimes the grass is covered by a certain kind of red insect, and when the green and red combine with umbrella-like mushrooms, the entire scene changes, just like a person who has suddenly become rich. The farmer then becomes very happy to see his field full of grains, but the capitalists—who are always unaware of the activities of a supernatural power—become unhappy because they are afraid of a competitive price. In some places certain capitalists in government restrict the farmer from producing too much grains, not knowing the actual fact that all food grains are supplied by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. According to the Vedic injunction, eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead maintains this creation; therefore, He arranges for a supply of whatever is required for all living entities. When there is population increase, it is the business of the Supreme Lord to feed them. But persons who are atheists or miscreants do not like abundant production of food grains, especially if their business might be hampered.

During the rainy season, all living entities, in the land, sky and water, become very refreshed, exactly like one who engages in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. We have practical experience of this with our students in the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. Before becoming students, they were dirty looking, although they had naturally beautiful personal features; but due to having no information of Kåñëa consciousness they appeared very dirty and wretched. Since they have taken to Kåñëa consciousness, their health has improved, and by following the rules and regulations, their bodily luster has increased. When they are dressed with saffron colored cloth, with tilaka on their foreheads and beads in their hands and on their necks, they look exactly as if they come directly from Vaikuëöha.

In the rainy season, when the rivers swell and rush to the oceans and seas, they appear to agitate the ocean. Similarly, if a person who is engaged in the yoga-mystic process is not very advanced in spiritual life, he can become agitated by the sex impulse. High mountains, however, although splashed by torrents of rain, do not change; so a person who is advanced in Kåñëa consciousness, even if put into difficulties, is not embarrassed because a person who is spiritually advanced accepts any adverse condition of life as the mercy of the Lord, and thus he is completely eligible to enter into the spiritual kingdom.

In the rainy season some of the roads are not frequently used, and they become covered with long grasses. This is exactly like a brähmaëa who is not accustomed to studying and practicing the reformatory methods of Vedic injunctions—he becomes covered with the long grasses of mäyä. In that condition, forgetful of his constitutional nature, he forgets his position of eternal servitorship to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. By being deviated by the seasonal overgrowth of long grasses created by mäyä, a person identifies himself with mayic production and succumbs to illusion, forgetting his spiritual life.

During the rainy season, lightning appears in one group of clouds and then immediately in another group of clouds. This phenomena is compared to a lusty woman who does not fix her mind on one man. A cloud is compared to a qualified person because it pours rain and gives sustenance to many people; a man who is qualified similarly gives sustenance to many living creatures, such as family members or many workers in business. Unfortunately, his whole life can be disturbed by a wife who divorces him; when the husband is disturbed, the whole family is ruined, the children are dispersed or the business is closed, and everything is effected. It is therefore recommended that a woman desiring to advance in Kåñëa consciousness peacefully live with a husband and that the couple not separate under any condition. The husband and wife should control sex indulgence and concentrate their minds on Kåñëa consciousness so their life may be successful. After all, in the material world a man requires a woman, and a woman requires a man. When they are combined, they should live peacefully in Kåñëa consciousness and should not be restless like the lightning, flashing from one group of clouds to another.

Sometimes, in addition to the roaring thunder of the clouds, there is an appearance of a rainbow, which stands as a bow without a string. Actually, a bow is in the curved position, being tied at its two ends by the bowstring; but in the rainbow there is no such string, and yet it rests in the sky so beautifully. Similarly, when the Supreme Personality of Godhead descends to this material world, He appears just like an ordinary human being, but He is not resting on any material condition. In the Bhagavad-gétä [4.6], the Lord says that He appears by His internal potency, which is free from the bondage of the external potency. What is bondage for the ordinary creature is freedom for the Personality of Godhead. In the rainy season, the moonlight is covered by clouds but is visible at intervals. It sometimes appears that the moon is moving with the movement of the clouds, but actually the moon is still; due to the clouds it also appears to move. Similarly, for one who has identified himself with the moving material world, his actual spiritual luster is covered by illusion, and with the movement of material activities, he thinks that he is moving through different spheres of life. This is due to false ego, which is the demarcation between spiritual and material existence, just as the moving cloud is the demarcation between moonlight and darkness. In the rainy season, when the clouds appear for the first time, after seeing their appearance, the peacocks begin to dance with joy. This can be compared to persons who are very harassed in the materialistic way of life. If they can find the association of a person engaged in the loving devotional service of the Lord, they become enlightened, just like the peacocks when they dance. We have practical experience of this, because many of our students were dry and morose previous to their coming to Kåñëa consciousness, but having come into contact with devotees, they are now dancing like jubilant peacocks.

Plants and creepers grow by drinking water from the ground. Similarly, a person practicing austerities becomes dry; after the austere performances are completed and he gets the result, he begins to enjoy life in sense gratification, with family, society, love, home and other paraphernalia. Sometimes it is seen that cranes and ducks meander continually on the banks of the lakes and rivers, although the banks are filled with muddy garbage and thorny creepers. Similarly, persons who are householders without Kåñëa consciousness are constantly tarrying in material life, in spite of all kinds of inconveniences. In family life, or any life, one cannot be perfectly happy without being Kåñëa conscious. Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkur prays that he will have the association of a person—either a householder or a man in the renounced order of life—who is engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord and is always crying the holy name of Lord Caitanya. For the materialistic person, worldly affairs become too aggressive, whereas to a person who is in Kåñëa consciousness, everything appears to be happily situated.

The barriers around the agricultural field sometimes break due to heavy torrents of rain. Similarly, the unauthorized atheistic propaganda in the age of Kali breaks the boundary of the Vedic injunctions. Thus people gradually degenerate to godlessness. In the rainy season, the clouds, tossed by the wind, deliver water which is welcomed like nectar. When the Vedic followers, the brähmaëas, inspire rich men like kings and the wealthy mercantile community to give charity in the performance of great sacrifices, the distribution of such wealth is also nectarean. The four sections of human society, namely the brähmaëas, the kñatriyas, the vaiçyas and the çüdras, are meant to live peacefully in a cooperative mood; this is possible when they are guided by the expert Vedic brähmaëas who perform sacrifices and distribute wealth equally.

Våndävana forest improved from the rains and was replete with ripened dates, mangoes, blackberries and other fruits. Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and His boy friends and Lord Balaräma, entered the forest to enjoy the new seasonal atmosphere. The cows, being fed by new grasses, became very healthy, and their milk bags were all very full. When Lord Kåñëa called them by name, they immediately came to Him out of affection, and in their joyful condition the milk flowed from their bags. Lord Kåñëa was very pleased when passing through the Våndävana forest by the side of Govardhana Hill. On the bank of the Yamunä He saw all the trees decorated with bee hives pouring honey. There were many waterfalls on Govardhana Hill, and their flowing made a nice sound. Kåñëa heard them as He looked into the caves of the hill. When the rainy season was not ended completely but was gradually turning to autumn, sometimes, especially when there was rainfall within the forest, Kåñëa and His companions would sit under a tree or within the caves of Govardhana Hill and enjoy eating the ripened fruits and talking with great pleasure. When Kåñëa and Balaräma were in the forest all day, mother Yaçodä used to send Them some rice mixed with yogurt, fruits and sweetmeat. Kåñëa would take them and sit on a slab of stone on the bank of the Yamunä. While Kåñëa and Balaräma and Their friends were eating, they watched the cows, calves and bulls. The cows appeared to be tired from standing with their heavy milk bags. By sitting and chewing grass, they became happy, and Kåñëa was pleased to see them. He was proud to see the beauty of the forest, which was nothing but the manifestation of His own energy.

At such times Kåñëa would praise nature’s special activities during the rainy season. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.10] that the material energy, or nature, is not independent in its actions. Nature is acting under the superintendence of Kåñëa. It is also stated in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.44] that material nature, known as Durgä, is acting as the shadow of Kåñëa. Whatever order is sent from Kåñëa, material nature obeys. Therefore the natural beauty created by the rainy season was acted out according to the indications of Kåñëa. Soon all the water reservoirs became very clean and pleasing, and refreshing air was blowing everywhere because of the appearance of autumn. The sky was completely cleared of all clouds, and it recovered its natural blue color. The blooming lotus flower in the clear water in the forest appeared like a person who has fallen down from yoga practice but again has become beautiful by resuming his spiritual life.

Everything becomes naturally beautiful with the appearance of the autumn season. Similarly, when a materialistic person takes to Kåñëa consciousness and spiritual life, he also becomes as clear as the sky and water in autumn. The autumn season takes away the rolling of dark clouds in the sky as well as the polluted water. Filthy conditions on the ground also become cleansed. Similarly, a person who takes to Kåñëa consciousness immediately becomes cleansed of all dirty things within and without. Kåñëa is therefore known as Hari. "Hari" means "he who takes away." Kåñëa immediately takes away all unclean habits from anyone who takes to Kåñëa consciousness. The clouds of autumn are white, for they do not carry any water. Similarly, a retired man, being freed from all responsibility of family affairs (namely, maintaining the home, wife and children) and taking completely to Kåñëa consciousness, becomes freed from all anxieties and looks as white as clouds in autumn. Sometimes in autumn the falls come down from the top of the hill to supply clean water, and sometimes they stop. Similarly, sometimes great saintly persons distribute clear knowledge, and sometimes they are silent. The small ponds which were filled with water because of the rainy season, gradually dry up in autumn. As for the tiny aquatics living in the reservoirs, they cannot understand that their numbers are diminishing day by day, as the materially engrossed persons cannot understand that their duration of life is being reduced day by day. Such persons are engaged in maintaining cows, property, children, wife, society and friendship. Due to the reduced water and scorching heat from the sun in the autumn season, the small creatures living in small reservoirs of water are much disturbed; they are exactly like uncontrolled persons who are always unhappy from being unable to enjoy life or maintain their family members. The muddy earth gradually dries up, and newly grown fresh vegetables begin to wither. Similarly, for one who has taken to Kåñëa consciousness, desire for family enjoyment gradually dries up.

Because of the appearance of the autumn season, the water of the ocean becomes calm and quiet, just as a person developed in self-realization is no longer disturbed by the three modes of material nature. In autumn, farmers save the water within the fields by building strong walls so that the water contained within the field cannot run out. There is hardly any hope for new rainfalls; therefore they want to save whatever is in the field. Similarly, a person who is actually advanced in self-realization protects his energy by controlling the senses. It is advised that after the age of fifty, one should retire from family life and should conserve the energy of the body for utilization in the advancement of Kåñëa consciousness. Unless one is able to control the senses and engage them in the transcendental loving service of Mukunda, there is no possibility of salvation.

During the daytime in autumn, the sun is very scorching, but at night, due to the clear moonshine, people get relief from the day's fatigue. If a person takes shelter of Mukunda, or Kåñëa, he can be saved from the fatigue of misidentifying the body with the self. Mukunda, or Kåñëa, is also the source of solace to the damsels of Våndävana. The damsels of Vrajabhümi are always suffering because of separation from Kåñëa. When they meet Kåñëa during the moonlit autumn night, their fatigue of separation is also satiated. When the sky is clear of all clouds, the stars at night shine very beautifully; similarly, when a person is actually situated in Kåñëa consciousness, he is cleared of all dirty things, and he becomes as beautiful as the stars in the autumn sky. Although the Vedas prescribe karma in the form of offering sacrifices, their ultimate purpose is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.42-44]: one has to accept Kåñëa consciousness after thoroughly understanding the purpose of the Vedas. Therefore the clean heart exhibited by a devotee in Kåñëa consciousness can be compared to the clean sky of the autumn season. During autumn, the moon looks very bright along with the stars in the clear sky. Lord Kåñëa Himself appeared in the sky of the Yadu dynasty, and He was exactly like the moon surrounded by the stars, or the members of the Yadu dynasty. When there are ample blooming flowers in the gardens in the forest, the fresh, aromatic breeze gives a great relief to the person who has suffered during the summer and rainy seasons. Unfortunately, such breezes could not give any relief to the gopés because of their hearts' dedication to Kåñëa. People in general might have taken pleasure in that nice autumn breeze, but the gopés, not being embraced by Kåñëa, were not very satisfied.

On arrival of the autumn season, all the cows, deer, birds and females in general become pregnant, because in that season generally all the husbands become impelled by sex desire. This is exactly like the transcendentalists who, by the grace of the Supreme Lord, are bestowed with the benediction of their destinations in life. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has instructed in his Upadeçamåtä that one should follow devotional service with great enthusiasm, patience and conviction and should follow the rules and regulations, keep oneself clean from material contamination and stay in the association of devotees. By following these principles, one is sure to achieve the desired result of devotional service. For he who patiently follows the regulative principles of devotional service, the time will come when he will achieve the result, as the wives who reap results by becoming pregnant.

During the autumn, the lotus flowers in the lakes grow in large numbers because of the absence of lilies; both the lilies and the lotus flowers grow by sunshine, but during the autumn season, the scorching sunshine helps only the lotus. This example is given in the case of a country where the king or the government is strong; the rise of unwanted elements like thieves and robbers cannot prosper. When the citizens become confident that they will not be attacked by robbers, they develop very satisfactorily. A strong government is compared to the scorching sunshine in the autumn season; the lilies are compared to unwanted persons like robbers, and the lotus flowers are compared to the satisfied citizens of the government. During autumn, the fields become filled with ripened grains. At that time, the people become happy over the harvest and observe various ceremonies, such as Navänna—the offering of new grains to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The new grains are first offered to the Deities in various temples, and all are invited to take sweet rice made of these new grains. There are other religious ceremonies and methods of worship, particularly in Bengal, where the greatest of all such ceremonies is held, called Durgä Püjä.

In Våndävana the autumn season was very beautiful then because of the presence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa and Balaräma. The mercantile community, the royal order and great sages were free to move to achieve their desired benedictions. Similarly, the transcendentalists, when freed from the encagement of the material body, also achieved their desired goal. During the rainy season, the mercantile community cannot move from one place to another and so do not get their desired profit. Nor can the royal order go from one place to another to collect taxes from the people. As for saintly persons who must travel to preach transcendental knowledge, they also are restrained by the rainy season. But during the autumn, all of them leave their confines. In the case of the transcendentalist, be he a jïäné, a yogé, or a devotee, because of the material body he cannot actually enjoy spiritual achievement. But as soon as he gives up the body, or after death, the jïäné merges into the spiritual effulgence of the Supreme Lord; the yogé transfers himself to the various higher planets, and the devotee goes to the planet of the Supreme Lord, Goloka Våndävana, or the Vaikuëöhas, and thus enjoys his eternal spiritual life.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twentieth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Description of Autumn."

KB 1970-1-21 / The Gopés Attracted by the Flute

21 / The Gopés Attracted by the Flute

Kåñëa was very pleased with the atmosphere of the forest where flowers bloomed and bees and drones hummed very jubilantly. While the birds, trees and branches were all looking very happy, Kåñëa, tending the cows, accompanied by Çré Balaräma and the cowherd boys, began to vibrate His transcendental flute. After hearing the vibration of the flute of Kåñëa, the gopés in Våndävana remembered Him and began to talk amongst themselves about how nicely Kåñëa was playing His flute. When the gopés were describing the sweet vibration of Kåñëa's flute, they also remembered their pastimes with Him; thus their minds became disturbed, and they were unable to describe completely the beautiful vibrations. While discussing the transcendental vibration, they remembered also how Kåñëa dressed, decorated with a peacock feather on His head, just like a dancing actor, and with blue flowers pushed over His ear. His garment glowed yellow-gold, and He was garlanded with a vaijayanté necklace. Dressed in such an attractive way, Kåñëa filled up the holes of His flute with the nectar emanating from His lips. So they remembered Him, entering the forest of Våndävana, which is always glorified by the footprints of Kåñëa and His companions.

Kåñëa was very expert in playing the flute, and the gopés were captivated by the sound vibration, which was not only attractive to them, but to all living creatures who heard it. One of the gopés told her friends, "The highest perfection of the eyes is to see Kåñëa and Balaräma entering the forest and playing Their flutes and tending the cows with Their friends."

Persons who are constantly engaged in the transcendental meditation of seeing Kåñëa, internally and externally, by thinking of Him playing the flute and entering the Våndävana forest, have really attained the perfection of samädhi. Samädhi (trance) means absorption of all the activities of the senses on a particular object, and the gopés indicate that the pastimes of Kåñëa are the perfection of all meditation and samädhi. It is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä that anyone who is always absorbed in the thought of Kåñëa is the topmost of all yogés.

Another gopé expressed her opinion that Kåñëa and Balaräma, while tending the cows, appeared just like actors going to play on a dramatic stage. Kåñëa was dressed in glowing garments of yellow, Balaräma in blue, and They held new twigs of mango tree, peacock feathers, and bunches of flowers in Their hands. Dressed with garlands of lotus flowers, They were sometimes singing very sweetly among Their friends. One gopé told her friend, "How is it Kåñëa and Balaräma are looking so beautiful?" Another gopé said, "My dear friend, we cannot even think of His bamboo flute—what sort of pious activities did it execute so that it is now enjoying the nectar of the lips of Kåñëa?" Kåñëa sometimes kisses the gopés; therefore the transcendental nectar of His lips is available only to them, and His lips are considered their property. Therefore the gopés asked: "How is it possible that the flute, which is nothing but a bamboo rod, is always engaged in enjoying the nectar from Kåñëa's lips? Because the flute is engaged in the service of the Supreme Lord, the mother and the father of the flute must be happy."

The lakes and the rivers are considered to be the mothers of the trees because the trees live simply by drinking water. So the waters of the lakes and rivers of Våndävana were full of happy lotus flowers because the waters were thinking, "How is it our son, the bamboo rod, is enjoying the nectar of Kåñëa's lips?" The bamboo trees standing by the banks of the rivers and the lakes were also happy to see their descendant so engaged in the service of the Lord, just as persons who are advanced in knowledge take pleasure to see their descendants engage in the service of the Lord. The trees were overwhelmed with joy and were incessantly yielding honey, which flowed from the beehives hanging on the branches.

Sometimes the gopés spoke thus to their friends about Kåñëa: "Dear friends, our Våndävana is proclaiming the glories of this entire earth because this planet is glorified by the lotus footprints of the son of Devaké. Besides that, when Govinda plays His flute, the peacocks immediately become mad. When all the animals and trees and plants, either on the top of Govardhana Hill or in the valley, see the dancing of the peacock, they all stand still and listen to the transcendental sound of the flute with great attention. We think that this boon is not possible or available on any other planet." Although the gopés were village cowherd women and girls, they had knowledge of Kåñëa. Similarly, one can learn the highest truths simply by hearing the Vedas from authoritative sources.

Another gopé said, "My dear friends, just see the deer! Although they are dumb animals, they have approached the son of Mahäräja Nanda, Kåñëa. Not only are they attracted by the dress of Kåñëa and Balaräma, but as soon as they hear the playing of the flute, the deer, along with their husbands, offer respectful obeisances unto the Lord by looking at Him with great affection." The gopés were envious of the deer because the deer were able to offer their service to Kåñëa along with their husbands. The gopés thought themselves not so fortunate because whenever they wanted to go to Kåñëa, their husbands were not very happy.

Another gopé said, "My dear friends, Kåñëa is so nicely dressed that He appears to be the impetus to various kinds of ceremonies held by the womenfolk. Even the wives of the denizens of heaven become attracted after hearing the transcendental sound of His flute. Although they are travelling in the air in their airplanes, enjoying the company of their husbands, on hearing the sound of Kåñëa's flute, they immediately become perturbed. Their hair is loosened and their tight dresses are slackened." This means that the transcendental sound of the flute of Kåñëa extended to all corners of the universe. Also, it is significant that the gopés knew about the different kinds of airplanes flying in the sky.

Another gopé said to her friends, "My dear friends, the cows are also charmed as soon as they hear the transcendental sound of the flute of Kåñëa. It sounds to them like the pouring of nectar, and they immediately spread their long ears just to catch the liquid nectar of the flute. As for the calves, they are seen with the nipples of their mothers pressed in their mouths, but they cannot suck the milk. They remain struck with devotion, and tears glide down their eyes, illustrating vividly how they are embracing Kåñëa heart to heart." These phenomena indicate that even the cows and calves in Våndävana knew how to cry for Kåñëa and embrace Him heart to heart. Actually, Kåñëa conscious affection can be culminated in shedding tears from the eyes.

A younger gopé told her mother, "My dear mother, the birds, who are all looking at Kåñëa playing on His flute, are sitting very attentively on the branches and twigs of different trees. From their features it appears that they have forgotten everything and are engaged only in hearing Kåñëa's flute. This proves that they are not ordinary birds; they are great sages and devotees, and just to hear Kåñëa's flute they have appeared in Våndävana forest as birds." Great sages and scholars are interested in Vedic knowledge, but the essence of Vedic knowledge is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä: vedaiç ca sarvair aham eva vedyaù. Through the knowledge of the Vedas, Kåñëa has to be understood. From the behavior of these birds, it appeared that they were great scholars in Vedic knowledge and that they took to Kåñëa's transcendental vibration and rejected all branches of Vedic knowledge. Even the River Yamunä, being desirous to embrace the lotus feet of Kåñëa after hearing the transcendental vibration of His flute, broke her fierce waves to flow very nicely with lotus flowers in her hands, just to present flowers to Mukunda with deep feeling.

The scorching heat of the autumn sunshine was sometimes intolerable, and therefore the clouds in the sky appeared in sympathy above Kåñëa and Balaräma and Their boy friends while They engaged in blowing Their flutes. The clouds served as a soothing umbrella over Their heads just to make friendship with Kåñëa. The wanton aborigine girls also became fully satisfied when they smeared their faces and breasts with the dust of Våndävana, which was reddish from the touch of Kåñëa's lotus feet. The aborigine girls had very full breasts, and they were also very lusty, but when their lovers felt their breasts, they were not very satisfied. When they came out into the midst of the forest, they saw that while Kåñëa was walking, some of the leaves and creepers of Våndävana turned reddish from the kuìkuma powder which fell from His lotus feet. His lotus feet were held by the gopés on their breasts, which were also smeared with kuìkuma powder, but when Kåñëa travelled in the Våndävana forest with Balaräma and His boy friends, the reddish powder fell on the ground of the Våndävana forest. So the lusty aborigine girls, while looking toward Kåñëa playing His flute, saw the reddish kuìkuma on the ground and immediately took it and smeared it over their faces and breasts. In this way they became fully satisfied, although they were not satisfied when their lovers touched their breasts. All material lusty desires can be immediately satisfied if one comes in contact with Kåñëa consciousness.

Another gopé began to praise the unique position of Govardhana Hill in this way: "How fortunate is this Govardhana Hill, for it is enjoying the association of Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma who are accustomed to walk on it. Thus Govardhana is always in touch with the lotus feet of the Lord. And because Govardhana Hill is so obliged to Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, it is supplying different kinds of fruits, roots and herbs, as well as very pleasing crystal water from its lakes, in presentation to the Lord." The best presentation offered by Govardhana Hill, however, was newly grown grass for the cows and calves. Govardhana Hill knew how to please the Lord by pleasing His most beloved associates, the cows and the cowherd boys.

Another gopé said that everything appeared wonderful when Kåñëa and Balaräma travelled in the forest of Våndävana playing Their flutes and making intimate friendship with all kinds of moving and nonmoving living creatures. When Kåñëa and Balaräma played on Their transcendental flutes, the moving creatures became stunned and stopped their activities, and the nonmoving living creatures, like trees and plants, began to shiver with ecstasy.

Kåñëa and Balaräma carried binding ropes on Their shoulders and in Their hands, just like ordinary cowherd boys. While milking the cows, the boys bound the hind legs with a small rope. This rope almost always hung from the shoulders of the boys, and it was not absent on the shoulders of Kåñëa and Balaräma. In spite of Their being the Supreme Personality of Godhead, They played exactly like cowherd boys, and therefore everything became wonderful and attractive.

While Kåñëa was engaged in tending the cows in the forest of Våndävana or on Govardhana Hill, the gopés in the village were always absorbed in thinking of Him and discussing His different pastimes. This is the perfect example of Kåñëa consciousness: to somehow or other remain always engrossed in thoughts of Kåñëa. The vivid example is always present in the behavior of the gopés; therefore Lord Caitanya declared that no one can worship the Supreme Lord by any method which is better than the method of the gopés. The gopés were not born in very high brähmaëa or kñatriya families; they were born in the families of vaiçyas, and not in big mercantile communities but in the families of cowherd men. They were not very well educated, although they heard all sorts of knowledge from the brähmaëas, the authorities of Vedic knowledge. The gopés' only purpose was to remain always absorbed in thoughts of Kåñëa.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-first Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Gopés Attracted by the Flute."

KB 1970-1-22 / Stealing the Garments of the Unmarried Gopé Girls

22 / Stealing the Garments of the Unmarried Gopé Girls

According to Vedic civilization, unmarried girls from ten to fourteen years of age are supposed to worship either Lord Çiva or the goddess Durgä in order to get a nice husband. But the unmarried girls of Våndävana were already attracted by the beauty of Kåñëa. They were, however, engaged in the worship of the goddess Durgä in the beginning of the hemanta season (just prior to the winter season). The first month of hemanta is called Agrahäyana (October-November), and at that time all the unmarried gopés of Våndävana began to worship goddess Durgä with a vow. They first ate haviñyänna, a kind of foodstuff prepared by boiling together mung dahl and rice without any spices or turmeric. According to Vedic injunction, this kind of foodstuff is recommended to purify the body before one enacts a ritualistic ceremony. All the unmarried gopés in Våndävana used to daily worship goddess Kätyäyané early in the morning after taking bath in the River Yamunä. Kätyäyané is another name for goddess Durgä. The goddess is worshiped by preparing a doll made out of sand mixed with earth from the bank of the Yamunä. It is recommended in the Vedic scriptures that a deity may be made from different kinds of material elements; it can be painted, made of metal, made of jewels, made of wood, earth or stone or can be conceived within the heart of the worshiper. The Mäyävädé philosopher takes all these forms of the deity to be imaginary, but actually they are accepted in the Vedic literatures to be identical with either the Supreme Lord or a respective demigod.

The unmarried gopés used to prepare the deity of goddess Durgä and worship it with candana pulp, garlands, incense lamps and all kinds of presentations—fruits, grains and twigs of plants. After worshiping, it is the custom to pray for some benediction. The unmarried girls used to pray with great devotion to goddess Kätyäyané, addressing her as follows: "O supreme eternal energy of the Personality of Godhead, O supreme mystic power, O supreme controller of this material world, O goddess, please be kind to us and arrange for our marriage with the son of Nanda Mahäräja, Kåñëa." The Vaiñëavas generally do not worship any demigods. Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkur has strictly forbidden all worship of the demigods for anyone who wants to advance in pure devotional service. Yet the gopés, who are beyond compare in their affection for Kåñëa, were seen to worship Durgä. The worshipers of demigods also sometimes mention that the gopés also worshiped goddess Durgä, but we must understand the purpose of the gopés. Generally, people worship goddess Durgä for some material benediction. Here, the gopés prayed to the goddess to become wives of Lord Kåñëa. The purport is that if Kåñëa is the center of activity, a devotee can adopt any means to achieve that goal. The gopés could adopt any means to satisfy or serve Kåñëa. That was the superexcellent characteristic of the gopés. They worshiped goddess Durgä completely for one month in order to have Kåñëa as their husband. Every day they prayed for Kåñëa, the son of Nanda Mahäräja, to become their husband.

Early in the morning, the gopés used to go to the bank of the Yamunä to take bath. They would assemble together, capturing each other's hands, and loudly sing of the wonderful pastimes of Kåñëa. It is an old system among Indian girls and women that when they take bath in the river they place their garments on the bank and dip into the water completely naked. The portion of the river where the girls and women take bath was strictly prohibited to any male member, and this is still the system. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, knowing the minds of the unmarried young gopés, benedicted them with their desired objective. They had prayed for Kåñëa to become their husband, and Kåñëa wanted to fulfill their desires.

At the end of the month, Kåñëa, along with His friends, appeared on the scene. Another name of Kåñëa is Yogeçvara, or master of all mystic powers. By practicing meditation, the yogi can study the psychic movement of other men, and certainly Kåñëa could understand the desire of the gopés. Appearing on the scene, Kåñëa immediately collected all the garments of the gopés, climbed up in a nearby tree, and with smiling face began to speak to them.

"My dear girls," He said. "Please come here one after another and pray for your garments and then take them away. I'm not joking with you. I'm just telling the truth. I have no desire to play any joke with you, for you have observed the regulative principles for one month by worshiping goddess Kätyäyané. Please do not come here all at once. Come alone; I want to see each of you in your complete beauty, for you all have thin waists. I have requested you to come alone. Now please comply."

When the girls in the water heard such joking words from Kåñëa, they began to look at one another and smile. They were very joyous to hear such a request from Kåñëa because they were already in love with Him. Out of shyness, they looked at one another, but they could not come out of the water because they were naked. Due to remaining in the water for a long time, they felt cold and were shivering, yet upon hearing the pleasing and joking words of Govinda, their minds were perturbed with great joy. They began to tell Kåñëa, "Dear son of Nanda Mahäräja, please do not joke with us in that way. It is completely unjust to us. You are a very respectable boy because You are the son of Nanda Mahäräja, and You are very dear to us, but You should not play this joke on us because now we are all shivering from the cold water. Kindly deliver our garments immediately, otherwise we shall suffer." They then began to appeal to Kåñëa with great submission. "Dear Çyämasundara," they said, "we are all Your eternal servitors. Whatever You order us to do, we are obliged to perform without hesitation because we consider it our religious duty. But if You insist on putting this proposal to us, which is impossible to perform, then certainly we will have to go to Nanda Mahäräja and lodge a complaint against You. If Nanda Mahäräja does not take action, then we shall tell King Kaàsa about Your misbehavior."

Upon hearing this appeal by the unmarried gopés, Kåñëa answered, "My dear girls, if you think that you are My eternal servitors and you are always ready to execute My order, then My request is that, with your smiling faces, you please come here alone, one after another, and take away your garments. If you do not come here, however, and if you lodge complaints to My father, I shall not care anyway, for I know My father is old and cannot take any action against Me."

When the gopés saw that Kåñëa was strong and determined, they had no alternative but to abide by His order. One after another they came out of the water, but because they were completely naked, they tried to cover their nakedness by placing their left hand over their pubic area. In that posture they were all shivering. Their simple presentation was so pure that Lord Kåñëa immediately became pleased with them. All the unmarried gopés who prayed to Kätyäyané to have Kåñëa as their husband were thus satisfied. A woman cannot be naked before any male except her husband. The unmarried gopés desired Kåñëa as their husband, and He fulfilled their desire in this way. Being pleased with them, He took their garments on His shoulder and began to speak as follows. "My dear girls, you have committed a great offense by going naked in the River Yamunä. Because of this, the predominating deity of the Yamunä, Varuëadeva, has become displeased with you. Please, therefore, just touch your foreheads with folded palms and bow down before the demigod Varuëa in order to be excused from this offensive act." The gopés were all simple souls, and whatever Kåñëa said they took to be true. In order to be freed from the wrath of Varuëadeva, as well as to fulfill the desired end of their vows and ultimately to please their worshipable Lord, Kåñëa, they immediately abided by His order. Thus they became the greatest lovers of Kåñëa, and His most obedient servitors.

Nothing can compare to the Kåñëa consciousness of the gopés. Actually, the gopés did not care for Varuëa or any other demigod; they only wanted to satisfy Kåñëa. Kåñëa became very ingratiated and satisfied by the simple dealings of the gopés, and He immediately delivered their respective garments, one after another. Although Kåñëa cheated the young unmarried gopés and made them stand naked before Him and enjoyed joking words with them, and although He treated them just like dolls and stole their garments, they were still pleased with Him and never lodged complaints against Him. This attitude of the gopés is described by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu when He prays, "My dear Lord Kåñëa, You may embrace me or trample me under Your feet, or You may make me brokenhearted by never being present before me. Whatever You like, You can do, because You have complete freedom to act. But in spite of all Your dealings, You are my Lord eternally, and I have no other worshipable object." This is the attitude of the gopés toward Kåñëa.

Lord Kåñëa was pleased with them, and since they all desired to have Him as their husband, He told them, "My dear well-behaved girls, I know of your desire for Me and why you worship goddess Kätyäyané, and I completely approve of your action. Anyone whose full consciousness is always absorbed in Me, even if in lust, is elevated. As a fried seed cannot fructify, so any desire in connection with My loving service cannot produce any fruitive result, as in ordinary karma."

There is a statement in the Brahma-saàhitä: karmäëi nirdahati kintu ca bhakti-bhäjäm. Everyone is bound by his fruitive activities, but the devotees, because they work completely for the satisfaction of the Lord, suffer no reactions. Similarly, the gopés' attitude toward Kåñëa, although seemingly lusty, should not be considered to be like the lusty desires of ordinary women. The reason is explained by Kåñëa Himself. Activities in devotional service to Kåñëa are transcendental to any fruitive result.

"My dear gopés," Kåñëa continued, "your desire to have Me as your husband will be fulfilled because with this desire you have worshiped goddess Kätyäyané. I promise you that during the next autumn season you shall be able to meet with Me, and you shall enjoy Me as your husband."

Taking shelter of the shade of the trees, Kåñëa became very happy. While walking He began to address the inhabitants of Våndävana. "My dear Stokakåñëa, My dear Varüthapa, My dear Bhadrasena, My dear Sudämä, My dear Subala, My dear Arjuna, My dear Viçäla, My dear Åñabha—just look at these most fortunate trees of Våndävana. They have dedicated their lives to the welfare of others. Individually they are tolerating all kinds of natural disturbances, such as hurricanes, torrents of rain, scorching heat and piercing cold, but they are very careful to relieve our fatigues and give us shelter. My dear friends, I think they are glorified in this birth as trees. They are so careful to give shelter to others that they are like noble, highly elevated charitable men who never deny charity to one who approaches them. No one is denied shelter by these trees. They supply various kinds of facilities to human society, such as leaves, flowers, fruit, shade, roots, bark, flavor extracts and fuel. They are the perfect example of noble life. They are like a noble person who has sacrificed everything possible—his body, mind, activities, intelligence and words—in engaging in the welfare of all living entities."

Thus the Supreme Personality of Godhead walked on the bank of the Yamunä, touching the leaves of the trees and their fruits, flowers and twigs, and praising their glorious welfare activities. Different people may accept certain welfare activities to be beneficial for human society, according to their own views, but the welfare activity that can be rendered to people in general, for eternal benefit, is the spreading of the Kåñëa consciousness movement. Everyone should be prepared to propagate this movement. As instructed by Lord Caitanya, one should be humbler than the grass on the ground and more tolerant than the tree. The toleration of the trees is explained by Lord Kåñëa Himself, and those who are engaged in the preaching of Kåñëa consciousness should learn lessons from the teachings of Lord Kåñëa and Lord Caitanya through Their direct disciplic succession.

While passing through the forest of Våndävana on the bank of the Yamunä, Kåñëa sat down at a beautiful spot and allowed the cows to drink the cold and transparent water of the Yamunä. Being fatigued, the cowherd boys, Kåñëa and Balaräma also drank. After seeing the young gopés taking bath in the Yamunä, Kåñëa passed the rest of the morning with the boys.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-second Chapter of Kåñëa, "Stealing the Garments of the Unmarried Gopé Girls."

KB 1970-1-23 / Delivering the Wives of the Brähmaëas Who Performed Sacrifices

23 / Delivering the Wives of the Brähmaëas Who Performed Sacrifices

The morning passed, and the cowherd boys were very hungry because they had not eaten breakfast. They immediately approached Kåñëa and Balaräma and said, "Dear Kåñëa and Balaräma, You are both all-powerful; You can kill many, many demons, but today we are much afflicted with hunger, and this is disturbing us. Please arrange for something that will mitigate our hunger."

Requested in this way by Their friends, Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma immediately showed compassion on certain wives of brähmaëas who were performing sacrifices. These wives were great devotees of the Lord, and Kåñëa took this opportunity to bless them. He said, "My dear friends, please go to the house of the brähmaëas nearby. They are now engaged in performing Vedic sacrifices known as äìgirasa, for they desire elevation to heavenly planets. All of you please go to them." Then Lord Kåñëa warned His friends, "These brähmaëas are not Vaiñëavas. They cannot even chant Our names, Kåñëa and Balaräma. They are very busy in chanting the Vedic hymns, although the purpose of Vedic knowledge is to find Me. But because they are not attracted by the names of Kåñëa and Balaräma, you had better not ask them for anything in My name. Better ask for some charity in the name of Balaräma."

Charity is generally given to high class brähmaëas, but Kåñëa and Balaräma did not appear in a brähmaëa family. Balaräma was known as the son of Vasudeva, a kñatriya, and Kåñëa was known in Våndävana as the son of Nanda Mahäräja, who was a vaiçya. Neither belonged to the brähmaëa community. Therefore, Kåñëa considered that the brähmaëas engaged in performing sacrifices might not be induced to give charity to a kñatriya and vaiçya. "But at least if you utter the name of Balaräma, they may prefer to give in charity to a kñatriya, rather than to Me, because I am only a vaiçya."

Being thus ordered by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, all the boys went to the brähmaëas and began to ask for some charity. They approached them with folded hands and fell down on the ground to offer respect. "O earthly gods, kindly hear us who are ordered by Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma. We hope you know Them both very well, and we wish you all good fortune. Kåñëa and Balaräma are tending cows nearby, and we have accompanied Them. We have come to ask for some food from you. You are all brähmaëas and knowers of religious principles, and if you think that you should give us charity, then give us some food and we shall all eat along with Kåñëa and Balaräma. You are the most respectable brähmaëas within the human society, and you are expected to know all the principles of religious procedure."

Although the boys were village boys and were not expected to be learned in all the Vedic principles of religious ritual, they hinted that because of their association with Kåñëa and Balaräma, they knew all those principles. When the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa and Balaräma, asked for food, the boys would immediately deliver it without hesitation because it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that one should perform yajïa (sacrifices) only for the satisfaction of Viñëu.

The boys continued, "Lord Viñëu as Kåñëa and Balaräma is standing waiting, and you should immediately deliver whatever food you have in your stock." They also explained to the brähmaëas how foodstuffs are to be accepted. Generally, the Vaiñëavas, or pure devotees of the Lord, do not take part in ordinary sacrificial performances. But they know very well the ceremonials called dékñä paçusamtha sauträmnya. One is permitted to take food after the procedure of dékñä and before the animal sacrificial ceremony and the Sauträmaëé, or ceremony in which liquors are also offered. The boys said, "We can take your food at the present stage of your ceremony, for now it will not be prohibitory. So you can deliver us the foodstuff."

Although the companions of Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma were simple cowherd boys, they were in a position to dictate even to the high class brähmaëas engaged in the Vedic rituals of sacrifices. But the smärta brähmaëas, who were simply sacrificial-minded, could not understand the dictation of the transcendental devotees of the Lord. They could not even appreciate the begging of the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa and Balaräma. Although they heard all the arguments on behalf of Kåñëa and Balaräma, they did not care for them, and they refused to speak to the boys. Despite being highly elevated in the knowledge of Vedic sacrificial rites, all such nondevotee brähmaëas, although they think of themselves as very highly elevated, are ignorant, foolish persons. All their activities are useless because they do not know the purpose of the Vedas, as it is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.15]: to understand Kåñëa. In spite of their advancement in Vedic knowledge and rituals, they do not understand Kåñëa; therefore their knowledge of the Vedas is superficial. Lord Caitanya, therefore, gave His valuable opinion that a person does not have to be born in a brähmaëa family; if he knows Kåñëa or the science of Kåñëa consciousness, he is more than a brähmaëa, and he is quite fit to become spiritual master.

There are various details to be observed in the performance of sacrifices, and they are known collectively as deça. They are as follows: käla means the time, påthak dravya, the different detailed paraphernalia, mantra, hymns, tantra, scriptural evidences, agni, fire, åtvij, learned performers of sacrifices, devatä, the demigods, vajamäna, the performer of the sacrifices, kratu, the sacrifice itself, and dharma, the procedures. All these are for satisfying Kåñëa. It is confirmed that He is the actual enjoyer of all sacrifices [Bg. 9.24] because He is directly the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the Supreme Absolute Truth, beyond the conception or speculation of material senses. He is present just like an ordinary human boy. But for persons who identify themselves with this body, it is very difficult to understand Him. The brähmaëas were very interested in the comforts of this material body and in elevation to the higher planetary residences called svarga-väsa. They were therefore completely unable to understand the position of Kåñëa.

When the boys saw that the brähmaëas would not speak to them, they became very disappointed. They then returned to Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma and explained everything that had happened. After hearing their statements, the Supreme Personality began to smile. He told them that they should not be sorry for being refused by the brähmaëas because that is the way of begging. He convinced them that while one is engaged in collecting or begging, one should not think that he will be successful everywhere. He may be unsuccessful in some places, but that should not be cause for disappointment. Lord Kåñëa then asked all the boys to go again, but this time to the wives of those brähmaëas engaged in sacrifices. He also informed them that these wives were great devotees. "They are always absorbed in thinking of Us. Go there and ask for some food in My name and the name of Balaräma, and I am sure that they will deliver you as much food as you desire."

Carrying out Kåñëa's order, the boys immediately went to the wives of the brähmaëas. They found the wives sitting inside their house. They were very beautifully decorated with ornaments. After offering them all respectful obeisances, the boys said, "Dear mothers, please accept our humble obeisances and hear our statement. May we inform you that Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma are nearby. They have come here with the cows, and you may know also that we have come here under Their instructions. All of us are very hungry; therefore, we have come to you for some food. Please give us something to eat for Kåñëa, Balaräma and ourselves."

Immediately upon hearing this, the wives of the brähmaëas became anxious for Kåñëa and Balaräma. These reactions were spontaneous. They did not have to be convinced of the importance of Kåñëa and Balaräma; immediately upon hearing Their names, they became very anxious to see Them. Being advanced by thinking of Kåñëa constantly, they were performing the greatest form of mystic meditation. All the wives then became very busily engaged in filling up different pots with nice foodstuff. Due to the performance of the sacrifice, the various food was all very palatable. After collecting a feast, they prepared to go to Kåñëa, their most lovable object, exactly in the way rivers flow to the sea.

For a long time the wives had been anxious to see Kåñëa. However, when they were preparing to leave home to go see Him, their husbands, fathers, sons and relatives asked them not to go. But the wives did not comply. When a devotee is called by the attraction of Kåñëa, he does not care for bodily ties. The women entered the forest of Våndävana on the bank of the Yamunä, which was verdant with vegetation and newly grown vines and flowers. Within that forest, they saw Kåñëa and Balaräma engaged in tending the cows, along with Their very affectionate boy friends.

The brähmaëas' wives saw Kåñëa putting on a garment glittering like gold. He wore a nice garland of forest flowers and a peacock feather on His head. He was also painted with the minerals found in Våndävana, and He looked exactly like a dancing actor on a theatrical stage. They saw Him keeping one hand on the shoulder of His friend, and in His other hand, He was holding a lotus flower. His ears were decorated with lilies, He wore marks of tilaka, and He was smiling charmingly. With their very eyes, the wives of the brähmaëas saw the Supreme Personality of Godhead, of whom they had heard so much, who was so dear to them, and in whom their minds were always absorbed. Now they saw Him eye to eye and face to face, and Kåñëa entered within their hearts through their eyes.

They began to embrace Kåñëa to their hearts' content, and the distress of separation was mitigated immediately. They were just like great sages who, by their advancement of knowledge, merge into the existence of the Supreme. As the Supersoul living in everyone's heart, Lord Kåñëa could understand their minds; they had come to Him despite all the protests of their relatives, fathers, husbands, brothers, and all the duties of household affairs. They came just to see Him who was their life and soul. They were actually following Kåñëa's instruction in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66]: one should surrender to Him, giving up all varieties of occupational and religious duties. The wives of the brähmaëas actually carried out the instruction of the Bhagavad-gétä in total. He therefore began to speak to them, smiling very magnificently. It should be noted in this connection that when Kåñëa entered into the wives' hearts and when they embraced Him and felt the transcendental bliss of being merged with Him, the Supreme Lord Kåñëa did not lose His identity, nor did the individual wives lose theirs. The individuality of both the Lord and the wives remained, yet they felt oneness in existence. When a lover submits to his lover without any pinch of personal consideration, that is called oneness. Lord Caitanya has taught us this feeling of oneness in His Çikñäñöaka [8]: Kåñëa may act freely, doing whatever He likes, but the devotee should always be in oneness or in agreement with His desires. That oneness was exhibited by the wives of the brähmaëas in their love for Kåñëa.

Kåñëa welcomed them with the following words: "My dear wives of the brähmaëas, you are all very fortunate and welcomed here. Please let Me know what I can do for you. Your coming here, neglecting all the restrictions and hindrances of relatives, fathers, brothers and husbands, in order to see Me, is completely befitting. One who does this actually knows his self interest, because rendering transcendental loving service unto Me, without motive or restriction, is actually auspicious for the living entities."

Lord Kåñëa here confirms that the highest perfectional stage of the conditional soul is surrender to Him. One must give up all other responsibilities. This complete surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the most auspicious path for the conditioned soul because the Supreme Lord is the supreme objective of love. Everyone is loving Kåñëa ultimately, but realization is according to the advancement of his knowledge. One comes to understand that his self is the spirit soul, and the spirit soul is nothing but a part and parcel of the Supreme Lord; therefore the Supreme Lord is the ultimate goal of love, and thus one should surrender unto Him. This surrender is considered auspicious for the conditioned soul. Our life, property, home, wife, children, house, country, society and all paraphernalia which are very dear to us are expansions of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is the central object of love because He gives us all bliss, expanding Himself in so many ways according to our different situations, namely bodily, mental or spiritual.

"My dear wives of the brähmaëas," Kåñëa said. "You can now return to your homes. Engage yourselves in sacrificial activities and be engaged in the service of your husbands and household affairs so that your husbands will be pleased with you, and the sacrifice which they have begun will be properly executed. After all, your husbands are householders, and without your help how can they execute their prescribed duties?"

The wives of the brähmaëas replied, "Dear Lord, this sort of instruction does not befit You. Your eternal promise is that You will always protect Your devotees, and now You must fulfill this promise. Anyone who comes and surrenders unto You never goes back to the conditioned life of material existence. We expect that You will now fulfill Your promise. We have surrendered unto Your lotus feet, which are covered by the tulasé leaves, so we have no more desire to return to the company of our so-called relatives, friends, and society and give up the shelter of Your lotus feet. And what shall we do, returning home? Our husbands, brothers, fathers, sons, mothers and our friends do not expect to see us because we have already left them all. Therefore we have no shelter to return to. Please, therefore, do not ask us to return home, but arrange for our stay under Your lotus feet so that we can eternally live under Your protection."

The Supreme Personality of Godhead replied, "My dear wives, rest assured that your husbands will not neglect you on your return, nor will your brothers, sons, or fathers refuse to accept you. Because you are My pure devotees, not only your relatives but also people in general, as well as the demigods, will be satisfied with you." Kåñëa is situated as the Supersoul in everyone's heart. So if someone becomes a pure devotee of Lord Kåñëa, he immediately becomes pleasing to everyone. The pure devotee of Lord Kåñëa is never inimical to anyone. A sane person cannot be an enemy of a pure devotee. "Transcendental love for Me does not depend upon bodily connection," Kåñëa said further, "but anyone whose mind is always absorbed in Me will surely, very soon, come to Me for My eternal association."

After being instructed by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, all the wives again returned home to their respective husbands. Pleased to see their wives back home, the brähmaëas executed the performances of sacrifices by sitting together, as it is enjoined in the çästras. According to Vedic principle, religious rituals must be executed by the husband and wife together. When the brähmaëas' wives returned, the sacrifice was duly and nicely executed. One of the brähmaëas' wives, however, who was forcibly checked from going to see Kåñëa, began to remember Him as she heard of His bodily features. Being completely absorbed in His thought, she gave up her material body conditioned by the laws of nature.

Çré Govinda, the ever-joyful Personality of Godhead, revealed His transcendental pastimes, appearing just like an ordinary human being, and enjoyed the food offered by the wives of the brähmaëas. In this way, He attracted common persons to Kåñëa consciousness. He attracted to His words and beauty all the cows, cowherd boys and damsels in Våndävana.

After the return of their wives from Kåñëa, the brähmaëas engaged in the performance of sacrifices began to regret their sinful activities in refusing food to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They could finally understand their mistake; engaged in the performance of Vedic rituals, they had neglected the Supreme Personality of Godhead who had appeared just like an ordinary human being and asked for some food. They began to condemn themselves after seeing the faith and devotion of their wives. They regretted very much that, although their wives were elevated to the platform of pure devotional service, they themselves could not understand even a little bit of how to love and offer transcendental loving service to the Supreme Soul. They began to talk among themselves. "To hell with our being born brähmaëas! To hell with our learning all Vedic literatures! To hell with our performing great sacrifices and observing all the rules and regulations! To hell with our family! To hell with our expert service in performing the rituals exactly to the description of scriptures! To hell with it all, for we have not developed transcendental loving service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is beyond the speculation of the mind, body and senses."

The learned brähmaëas, expert in Vedic ritualistic performances, were properly regretful, because without developing Kåñëa consciousness, all discharge of religious duties is simply a waste of time and energy. They continued to talk among themselves; "The external energy of Kåñëa is so strong that it can create illusion to overcome even the greatest mystic yogé. Although we expert brähmaëas are considered to be the teachers of all other sections of human society, we also have been illusioned by the external energy. Just see how fortunate these women are who have so devotedly dedicated their lives to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. They could easily give up their family connection, which is so difficult to do. Family life is just like a dark well for the continuation of material miseries."

Women in general, being very simple in heart, can very easily take to Kåñëa consciousness, and when they develop love of Kåñëa they can easily get liberation from the clutches of mäyä, which is very difficult for even so-called intelligent and learned men to surpass. According to Vedic injunction, women are not allowed to undergo the purificatory process of initiation by the sacred thread, nor are they allowed to live as brahmacäriëé in the äçrama of the spiritual master; nor are they advised to undergo the strict disciplinary procedure; nor are they very much expert in discussing philosophy or self-realization. And by nature they are not very pure; nor are they very much attached to auspicious activities. "But how wonderful it is that they have developed transcendental love for Kåñëa, the Lord of all mystic yogés!" the brähmaëas exclaimed. "They have surpassed all of us in firm faith and devotion unto Kåñëa. Being too attached to the materialistic way of life, although we are considered to be masters in all purificatory processes, we did not actually know what the goal is. Even though we were reminded of Kåñëa and Balaräma by the cowherd boys, we disregarded Them. We think now that it was simply a trick of mercy upon us by the Supreme Personality of Godhead that He sent His friends to beg foodstuff from us. Otherwise, He had no need to send them. He could have satisfied their hunger then and there just by willing to do so."

If someone denies Kåñëa's self-sufficiency on hearing that He was tending the cows for livelihood, or if someone doubts His not being in need of the foodstuff, thinking that He was actually hungry, then one should understand that the goddess of fortune is always engaged in His service. In this way the goddess can break her faulty habit of restlessness. In Vedic literatures like Brahma-saàhitä [5.29] it is stated that Kåñëa is served in His abode with great respect by not only one goddess of fortune but many thousands. Therefore it is simply illusion for one to think that Kåñëa begged food from the brähmaëas. It was actually a trick to show them the mercy of accepting Him in pure devotional service. The Vedic ceremonial paraphernalia, the suitable place, suitable time, different grades of articles for performing ritualistic ceremonies, the Vedic hymns, the priest who is able to perform such sacrifice, the fire and the demigods, the performer of the sacrifice and the religious principles are all meant for understanding Kåñëa, for Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is the Supreme Lord Viñëu, and the Lord of all mystic yogés.

"Because He has appeared as a child in the dynasty of the Yadus, we were so foolish that we could not understand that He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead," the brähmaëas said. "But on the other hand, we are very proud because we have such exalted wives who have developed pure transcendental service of the Lord without being shackled by our rigid position. Let us therefore offer our respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa, under whose illusory energy, called mäyä, we are absorbed in fruitive activities. We therefore pray to the Lord to be kind enough to excuse us because we are simply captivated by His external energy. We transgressed His order without knowing His transcendental glories."

The brähmaëas repented for their sinful activities. They wanted to go personally to offer their obeisances unto Him, but being afraid of Kaàsa, they could not go. In other words, it is very difficult for one to surrender fully unto the Personality of Godhead without being purified by devotional service. The example of the learned brähmaëas and their wives is vivid. The wives of the brähmaëas, because they were infused by pure devotional service, did not care for any kind of opposition. They immediately went to Kåñëa. But although the brähmaëas had come to know the supremacy of the Lord and were repenting, they were still afraid of King Kaàsa because they were too addicted to fruitive activities.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-third Chapter of Kåñëa, "Delivering the Wives of the Brähmaëas Who Performed Sacrifices."

KB 1970-1-24 / Worshiping Govardhana Hill

24 / Worshiping Govardhana Hill

While engaged with the brähmaëas who were too involved in the performance of Vedic sacrifices, Kåñëa and Balaräma also saw that the cowherd men were preparing a similar sacrifice in order to pacify Indra, the King of heaven, who is responsible for supplying water. As stated in the Caitanya-caritämåta [M. 22.142], a devotee of Kåñëa has strong and firm faith in the understanding that if he is simply engaged in Kåñëa consciousness and Kåñëa's transcendental loving service, then he is freed from all other obligations. A pure devotee of Lord Kåñëa doesn't have to perform any of the ritualistic functions enjoined in the Vedas; nor is he required to worship any demigods. Being a devotee of Lord Kåñëa, one is understood to have performed all kinds of Vedic rituals and all kinds of worship to the demigods. Just by performing the Vedic ritualistic ceremonies or worshiping the demigods, one does not develop devotional service for Kåñëa. But one who is engaged fully in the service of the Lord has already finished all Vedic injunctions.

Kåñëa ordered a stop to all such activities by His devotees, for He wanted to firmly establish exclusive devotional service during His presence in Våndävana. Kåñëa knew that the cowherd men were preparing for the Indra sacrifice because He is the omniscient Personality of Godhead, but as a matter of etiquette, he began to inquire with great honor and submission from elder personalities like Mahäräja Nanda and others.

Kåñëa asked His father, "My dear father, what is this arrangement going on for a great sacrifice? What is the result of such sacrifice, and for whom is it meant? How is it performed? Will you kindly let Me know? I am very anxious to know this procedure, so please explain to Me the purpose of this sacrifice." Upon this inquiry, His father, Nanda Mahäräja, remained silent, thinking that his young boy would not be able to understand the intricacies of performing the yajïa. Kåñëa, however, persisted: "My dear father, for those who are liberal and saintly, there is no secrecy. They do not think anyone to be a friend or enemy because they are always open to everyone. And even for those who are not so liberal, nothing should be secret for the family members and friends, although secrecy may be maintained for persons who are inimical. Therefore you cannot keep any secrets from Me. All persons are engaged in fruitive activities. Some know what these activities are, and they know the result, and some execute activities without knowing the purpose or the result. A person who acts with full knowledge gets the full result; one who acts without knowledge does not get such a perfect result. Therefore, please let Me know the purpose of the sacrifice which you are going to perform. Is it according to Vedic injunction? Or is it simply a popular ceremony? Kindly let Me know in detail about the sacrifice."

On hearing this inquiry from Kåñëa, Mahäräja Nanda replied, "My dear boy, this ceremonial performance is more or less traditional. Because rainfall is due to the mercy of King Indra and the clouds are his representatives, and because water is so important for our living, we must show some gratitude to the controller of this rainfall, Mahäräja Indra. We are arranging, therefore, to pacify King Indra, because he has very kindly sent us clouds to pour down sufficient quantity of rain for successful agricultural activities. Water is very important; without rainfall we cannot farm or produce grains. We cannot live if there is no rainfall. It is necessary for successful religious ceremonies, economic development, and, ultimately, liberation. Therefore we should not give up the traditional ceremonial function; if one gives it up, being influenced by lust, or greed or fear, then it does not look very good for him."

After hearing this, Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, in the presence of His father and all the cowherd men of Våndävana, spoke in such a way as to make heavenly King Indra very angry. He suggested that they forego the sacrifice. His reasons for discouraging the sacrifice performed to please Indra were twofold. First, as stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20], there is no need to worship the demigods for any material advancement; all results derived from worshiping the demigods are simply temporary, and only those who are less intelligent are interested with temporary results. Secondly, whatever temporary result one derives from worshiping the demigods is actually granted by the permission of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is clearly stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, mayaiva vihitän hi tän. Whatever benefit is supposed to be derived from the demigods is actually bestowed by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Without the permission of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one cannot bestow any benefit upon others. But sometimes the demigods become puffed up by the influence of material nature; thinking themselves as all in all, they try to forget the supremacy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.25.1], it is clearly stated that in this instance Kåñëa wanted to make King Indra angry. Kåñëa's advent was especially meant for the annihilation of the demons and protection of the devotees. King Indra was certainly a devotee, not a demon, but because he was puffed up, Kåñëa wanted to teach him a lesson. He first tried to make Indra angry by stopping the Indra Püjä which was arranged by the cowherd men in Våndävana.

With this purpose in mind, Kåñëa began to talk as if He were an atheist supporting the philosophy of karma-mémäàsä. Advocates of this type of philosophy do not accept the supreme authority of the Personality of Godhead. They put forward the argument that if anyone works nicely, the result is sure to come. Their opinion is that even if there is a God who gives man the result of his fruitive activities, there is no need to worship Him because unless man works He cannot bestow any good result. They say that instead of worshiping a demigod or God, people should give attention to their own duties, and thus the good result will surely come. Lord Kåñëa began to speak to His father according to these principles of the karma-mémäàsä philosophy. "My dear father," He said, "I don't think you need to worship any demigod for the successful performance of your agricultural activities. Every living being is born according to his past karma and leaves this life simply taking the result of his present karma. Everyone is born in different types or species of life according to his past activities, and he gets his next birth according to the activities of this life. Different grades of material happiness and distress, comforts and disadvantages of life, are different results of different kinds of activities, either from the past or present life."

Mahäräja Nanda and other elderly members argued that without satisfying the predominating god, one cannot derive any good result simply by material activities. This is actually the fact. For example, it is sometimes found that, in spite of first-class medical help and treatment by a first-class physician, a diseased person dies. It is concluded, therefore, that first-class medical treatment or the attempts of a first-class physician are not in themselves the cause for curing a patient; there must be the hand of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Similarly, a father's and mother's taking care of their children is not the cause of the children's comfort. Sometimes it is found that in spite of all care by the parents, the children go bad or succumb to death. Therefore material causes are not sufficient for results. There must be the sanction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Nanda Mahäräja therefore advocated that, in order to get good results for agricultural activities, they must satisfy Indra, the superintending deity of the rain supply. Lord Kåñëa nullified this argument, saying that the demigods give results only to persons who have executed their prescribed duties. The demigods cannot give any good results to the person who has not executed the prescribed duties; therefore demigods are dependent on the execution of duties and are not absolute in awarding good results to anyone.

"My dear father, there is no need to worship the demigod Indra," Lord Kåñëa said. "Everyone has to achieve the result of his own work. We can actually see that one becomes busy according to the natural tendency of his work; and according to that natural tendency, all living entities—either human beings or demigods—achieve their respective results. All living entities achieve higher or lower bodies and create enemies, friends or neutral parties only because of their different kinds of work. One should be careful to discharge duties according to his natural instinct and not divert attention to the worship of various demigods. The demigods will be satisfied by proper execution of all duties, so there is no need to worship them. Let us, rather, perform our prescribed duties very nicely. Actually one cannot be happy without executing his proper prescribed duty. One who does not, therefore, properly discharge his prescribed duties, is compared with an unchaste woman. The proper prescribed duty of the brähmaëas is the study of the Vedas; the proper duty of the royal order, the kñatriyas, is engagement in protecting the citizens; the proper duty of the vaiçya community is agriculture, trade and protection of the cows; and the proper duty of the çüdras is service to the higher classes, namely the brähmaëas, kñatriyas, and vaiçyas. We belong to the vaiçya community, and our proper duty is to farm, or to trade with the agricultural produce, to protect cows, or take to banking."

Kåñëa identified Himself with the vaiçya community because Nanda Mahäräja was protecting many cows, and Kåñëa was taking care of them. He enumerated four kinds of business engagements for the vaiçya community, namely agriculture, trade, protection of cows and banking. Although the vaiçyas can take to any of these occupations, the men of Våndävana were engaged primarily in the protection of cows.

Kåñëa further explained to His father: "This cosmic manifestation is going on under the influence of three modes of material nature—goodness, passion, and ignorance. These three modes are the causes of creation, maintenance, and destruction. The cloud is caused by the action of the mode of passion; therefore it is the mode of passion which causes the rainfall. And after the rainfall, the living entities derive the result—success in agricultural work. What, then, has Indra to do in this affair? Even if you do not please Indra, what can he do? We do not derive any special benefit from Indra. Even if he is there, he pours water on the ocean also, where there is no need of water. So he is pouring water on the ocean or on the land; it does not depend on our worshiping him. As far as we are concerned, we do not need to go to another city or village or foreign country. There are palatial buildings in the cities, but we are satisfied living in this forest of Våndävana. Our specific relationship is with Govardhana Hill and Våndävana forest and nothing more. I therefore request you, My dear father, to begin a sacrifice which will satisfy the local brähmaëas and Govardhana Hill, and let us have nothing to do with Indra."

After hearing this statement by Kåñëa, Nanda Mahäräja replied, "My dear boy, since You are asking, I shall arrange for a separate sacrifice for the local brähmaëas and Govardhana Hill. But for the present let me execute this sacrifice known as Indra-yajïa."

But Kåñëa replied, "My dear father, don't delay. The sacrifice you propose for Govardhana and the local brähmaëas will take much time. Better take the arrangement and paraphernalia you have already made for sacrificing Indra-yajïa and immediately engage it to satisfy Govardhana Hill and the local brähmaëas."

Mahäräja Nanda finally relented. The cowherd men then inquired from Kåñëa how He wanted the yajïa performed, and Kåñëa gave them the following directions. "Prepare very nice foodstuffs of all descriptions from the grains and ghee collected for the yajïa. Prepare rice, dahl, then halavah, päkorä, puri and all kinds of milk preparations like sweet rice, sweetballs, sandeça, rasagullä and läòòu and invite the learned brähmaëas who can chant the Vedic hymns and offer oblations to the fire. The brähmaëas should be given all kinds of grains in charity. Then decorate all the cows and feed them well. After performing this, give money in charity to the brähmaëas. As far as the lower animals are concerned, such as the dogs, and the lower grades of people, such as the cäëòälas, or the fifth class of men who are considered untouchable, they also may be given sumptuous prasädam. After giving nice grasses to the cows, the sacrifice known as Govardhana Püjä may immediately begin. This sacrifice will very much satisfy Me."

In this statement, Lord Kåñëa practically described the whole economy of the vaiçya community. In all communities of human society, and in the animal kingdom, among the cows, dogs, goats, etc., everyone has his part to play. Each is to work in cooperation for the total benefit of all society, which includes not only animate objects but also inanimate objects like hills and land. The vaiçya community is specifically responsible for the economic improvement of the society by producing grains, by giving protection to the cows, by transporting food when needed, and by banking and finance.

From this statement we learn also that the cats and dogs, although not so important, are not to be neglected. Cow protection is actually more important than protection of cats and dogs. Another hint we get from this statement is that the cäëòälas or the untouchables are also not to be neglected by the higher classes. Everyone is important, but some are directly responsible for the advancement of human society, and some are only indirectly responsible. However, when Kåñëa consciousness is there, then everyone's total benefit is taken care of.

The sacrifice known as Govardhana Püjä is observed in the Kåñëa consciousness movement. Lord Caitanya has recommended that since Kåñëa is worshipable, so His land, Våndävana and Govardhana Hill, are also worshipable. To confirm this statement, Lord Kåñëa said that Govardhana Püjä is as good as worship of Him. From that day, the Govardhana Püjä has been still going on and is known as Annaküöa. In all the temples of Våndävana or outside of Våndävana, huge quantities of food are prepared in this ceremony and are very sumptuously distributed to the general population. Sometimes the food is thrown to the crowds, and they enjoy collecting it off the ground. From these instances, we can understand that prasädam offered to Kåñëa never becomes polluted or contaminated, even if it is thrown on the ground. The people, therefore, collect it and eat with great satisfaction.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, therefore advised the cowherd men to stop the Indra-yajïa and begin the Govardhana Püjä in order to chastise Indra who was very much puffed up at being the supreme controller of the heavenly planets. The honest and simple cowherd men headed by Nanda Mahäräja accepted Kåñëa's proposal and executed in detail everything He advised. They performed Govardhana worship and circumambulation of the hill. (Following the inauguration of Govardhana Püjä, people in Våndävana still dress nicely and assemble near Govardhana Hill to offer worship and circumambulate the hill, leading their cows all around.) According to the instruction of Lord Kåñëa, Nanda Mahäräja and the cowherd men called in learned brähmaëas and began to worship Govardhana Hill by chanting Vedic hymns and offering prasädam. The inhabitants of Våndävana assembled together, decorated their cows and gave them grass. Keeping the cows in front, they began to circumambulate Govardhana Hill. The gopés also dressed themselves very luxuriantly and sat in bull-driven carts, chanting the glories of Kåñëa's pastimes. Assembled there to act as priests for Govardhana Püjä, the brähmaëas offered their blessings to the cowherd men and their wives, the gopés.

When everything was complete, Kåñëa assumed a great transcendental form and declared to the inhabitants of Våndävana that He was Himself Govardhana Hill in order to convince the devotees that Govardhana Hill and Kåñëa Himself are identical. Then Kåñëa began to eat all the food offered there. The identity of Kåñëa and Govardhana Hill is still honored, and great devotees take rocks from Govardhana Hill and worship them exactly as they worship the Deity of Kåñëa in the temples. Devotees therefore collect small rocks or pebbles from Govardhana Hill and worship them at home, because this worship is as good as Deity worship. The form of Kåñëa who began to eat the offerings was separately constituted, and Kåñëa Himself along with other inhabitants of Våndävana began to offer obeisances to the Deity as well as Govardhana Hill. In offering obeisances to the huge form of Kåñëa Himself and Govardhana Hill, Kåñëa declared, "Just see how Govardhana Hill has assumed this huge form and is favoring us by accepting all the offerings." Kåñëa also declared at that meeting, "One who neglects the worship of Govardhana Püjä, as I am personally conducting it, will not be happy. There are many snakes on Govardhana Hill, and persons neglecting the prescribed duty of Govardhana Püjä will be bitten by these snakes and killed. In order to assure the good fortune of the cows and themselves, all people of Våndävana near Govardhana must worship the hill, as prescribed by Me."

Thus performing the Govardhana Püjä sacrifice, all the inhabitants of Våndävana followed the instructions of Kåñëa, the son of Vasudeva, and afterwards they returned to their respective homes.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-fourth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Worshiping Govardhana Hill."

KB 1970-1-25 / Devastating Rainfall in Våndävana

25 / Devastating Rainfall in Våndävana

When Indra understood that the sacrifice offered by the cowherd men in Våndävana was stopped by Kåñëa, he became angry, and he vented his anger upon the inhabitants of Våndävana, who were headed by Nanda Mahäräja, although Indra knew perfectly well that Kåñëa was personally protecting them. As the director of different kinds of clouds, Indra called for the säàvartaka. This cloud is invited when there is a need to devastate the whole cosmic manifestation. The säàvartaka was ordered by Indra to go over Våndävana and inundate the whole area with an extensive flood. Demonically, Indra thought himself to be the all-powerful supreme personality. When demons become very powerful, they defy the supreme controller, Personality of Godhead. Indra, though not a demon, was puffed up by his material position, and he wanted to challenge the supreme controller. He thought himself, at least for the time being, as powerful as Kåñëa. Indra said, "Just see the impudence of the inhabitants of Våndävana! They are simply inhabitants of the forest, but being infatuated with their friend Kåñëa, who is nothing but an ordinary human being, they have dared to defy the demigods."

Kåñëa has declared in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.23] that the worshipers of the demigods are not very intelligent. He has also declared that one has to give up all kinds of worship and simply concentrate on Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa's invoking the anger of Indra and later on chastising him is a clear indication to His devotee that those who are engaged in Kåñëa consciousness have no need to worship any demigod, even if it is found that the demigod has become angry. Kåñëa gives His devotees all protection, and they should completely depend on His mercy.

Indra cursed the action of the inhabitants of Våndävana and said, "By defying the authority of the demigods, the inhabitants of Våndävana will suffer in material existence. Having neglected the sacrifice to the demigods, they cannot cross over the impediments of the ocean of material misery." Indra further declared, "These cowherd men in Våndävana have neglected my authority on the advice of this talkative boy who is known as Kåñëa. He is nothing but a child, and by believing this child, they have enraged me." Thus he ordered the säàvartaka cloud to go and destroy the prosperity of Våndävana. "The men of Våndävana," said Indra, "have become too puffed up over their material opulence and their confidence in the presence of their tiny friend, Kåñëa. He is simply talkative, childish, and unaware of the complete cosmic situation, although He is thinking Himself very advanced in knowledge. Because they have taken Kåñëa so seriously, they must be punished, and so I have ordered the säàvartaka cloud to go there and inundate the place. They should be destroyed with their cows."

It is indicated here that in the villages or outside the towns, the inhabitants must depend on the cows for their prosperity. When the cows are destroyed, the people are destitute of all kinds of opulences. When King Indra ordered the säàvartaka and companion clouds to go to Våndävana, the clouds were afraid of the assignment. But King Indra assured them, "You go ahead, and I will also go, riding on my elephant, accompanied by great storms. And I shall apply all my strength to punish the inhabitants of Våndävana."

Ordered by King Indra, all the dangerous clouds appeared above Våndävana and began to pour water incessantly, with all their strength and power. There was constant lightning and thunder, blowing of severe wind and incessant falling of rain. The rainfall seemed to fall like piercing sharp arrows. By pouring water as thick as pillars, without cessation, the clouds gradually filled all the lands in Våndävana with water, and there was no visible distinction between higher and lower land. The situation was very dangerous, especially for the animals. The rainfall was accompanied by great winds, and every living creature in Våndävana began to tremble from the severe cold. Unable to find any other source of deliverance, they all approached Govinda to take shelter at His lotus feet. The cows especially, being much aggrieved from the heavy rain, bowed down their heads, and taking their calves underneath their bodies, they approached the Supreme Personality of Godhead to take shelter of His lotus feet. At that time all the inhabitants of Våndävana began to pray to Lord Kåñëa. "Dear Kåñëa," they prayed, "You are all-powerful, and You are very affectionate to Your devotees. Now please protect us who have been much harrassed by angry Indra."

Upon hearing their prayer, Kåñëa could also understand that Indra, being bereft of his sacrificial honor, was pouring down rain that was accompanied by heavy pieces of ice and strong winds, although all this was out of season. Kåñëa understood that this was a deliberate exhibition of anger by Indra. He therefore concluded, "This demigod who thinks himself supreme has shown his great power, but I shall answer him according to My position, and I shall teach him that he is not autonomous in managing universal affairs. I am the Supreme Lord over all, and I shall thus take away his false prestige which has risen from his power. The demigods are My devotees, and therefore it is not possible for them to forget My supremacy, but somehow or other he has become puffed up with material power and thus is now maddened. I shall act in such a way to relieve him of this false prestige. I shall give protection to My pure devotees in Våndävana, who are at present completely at My mercy and whom I have taken completely under My protection. I will save them by My mystic power."

Thinking in this way, Lord Kåñëa immediately picked up Govardhana Hill with one hand, exactly as a child picks up a mushroom from the ground. Thus He exhibited His transcendental pastime of lifting Govardhana Hill. Lord Kåñëa then began to address His devotees, "My dear brothers, My dear father, My dear inhabitants of Våndävana, you can now safely enter under the umbrella of Govardhana Hill, which I have just lifted. Do not be afraid of the hill and think that it will fall from My hand. You have been too much afflicted from the heavy rain and strong wind; therefore I have lifted this hill, which will protect you exactly like a huge umbrella. I think this is a proper arrangement to relieve you from your immediate distress. Be happy along with your animals underneath this great umbrella." Being assured by Lord Kåñëa, all the inhabitants of Våndävana entered beneath the great hill and appeared to be safe along with their property and animals.

The inhabitants of Våndävana and their animals remained there for one week without being disturbed by hunger, thirst or any other discomforts. They were simply astonished to see how Kåñëa was holding up the mountain with the little finger of His left hand. Seeing the extraordinary mystic power of Kåñëa, Indra, the King of heaven, was thunderstruck and baffled in his determination. He immediately called for all the clouds and asked them to desist. When the sky became completely cleared of all clouds and there was sunrise again, the strong winds stopped. At that time Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, known now as the lifter of Govardhana Hill, said, "My dear cowherd men, now you can leave and take your wives, children, cows and valuables, because everything is ended. The inundation has gone down, along with the swelling waters of the river."

All the men loaded their valuables on carts and slowly left with their cows and other paraphernalia. After they had cleared out everything, Lord Kåñëa very slowly replaced Govardhana Hill exactly in the same position as it had been before. When everything was done, all the inhabitants of Våndävana approached Kåñëa and embraced Him with great ecstacy. The gopés, being naturally very affectionate to Kåñëa, began to offer Him curd mixed with their tears, and they poured incessant blessings upon Him. Mother Yaçodä, mother Rohiëé, Nanda, and Balaräma, who is the strongest of the strong, embraced Kåñëa one after another and, from spontaneous feelings of affection, blessed Him over and over again. In the heavens, different demigods from different planetary systems, such as Siddhaloka, Gandharvaloka and Cäraëaloka, also began to show their complete satisfaction. They poured showers of flowers on the surface of the earth and sounded different conchshells. There was beating of drums, and being inspired by godly feelings, residents of Gandharvaloka began to play on their tampouras to please the Lord. After this incident, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, surrounded by His dear friends and animals, returned to His home. As usual, the gopés began to chant the glorious pastimes of Lord Kåñëa with great feeling, for they were chanting from the heart.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-fifth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Devastating Rainfall in Våndävana."

KB 1970-1-26 / Wonderful Kåñëa

26 / Wonderful Kåñëa

Without understanding the intricacies of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and without knowing His uncommon spiritual opulences, the innocent cowherd boys and men of Våndävana began to discuss the wonderful activities of Kåñëa which surpass the activities of all men.

One of them said, "My dear friends, considering His wonderful activities, how is it possible that such an uncommon boy would come and live with us in Våndävana? It is really not possible. Just imagine! He is now only seven years old! How was it possible for Him to lift Govardhana Hill in one hand and hold it up just like the king of elephants holds a lotus flower? To lift a lotus flower is a most insignificant thing for an elephant, and similarly Kåñëa lifted Govardhana Hill without exertion. When He was simply a small baby and could not even see properly, He killed a great demon, Pütanä. While sucking her breast, He also sucked out her life-air. Kåñëa killed the Pütanä demon exactly as eternal time kills a living creature in due course. When He was only three months old, He was sleeping underneath a hand-driven cart. Being hungry for His mother's breast, He began to cry and throw His legs upwards. And from the kicking of his small feet the cart immediately broke apart and fell to pieces. When He was only one year old, He was carried away by the Tåëävarta demon disguised as a whirlwind, and although He was taken very high in the sky, He simply hung on the neck of the demon and forced him to fall from the sky and immediately die. Once His mother, being disturbed by His stealing butter, tied Him to a wooden mortar, and the child pushed it towards a pair of trees known as yamala arjuna and caused them to fall. Once, when He was engaged in tending the calves in the forest along with His elder brother, Balaräma, a demon named Bakäsura appeared, and Kåñëa at once bifurcated the demon's beaks. When the demon known as Vatsäsura entered among the calves tended by Kåñëa with a desire to kill Him, He immediately detected the demon, killed him, and threw him into a tree. When Kåñëa, along with His brother, Balaräma, entered the Tälavana forest, the demon known as Dhenukäsura, in the shape of an ass, attacked Them and was immediately killed by Balaräma, who caught his hind legs and threw him in a palm tree. Although the Dhenukäsura demon was assisted by his cohorts, also in the shape of asses, all were killed, and the Tälavana forest was then open for the use of the animals and inhabitants of Våndävana. When Pralambäsura entered amongst His cowherd boy friends, He caused his death by Balaräma. Thereafter, Kåñëa saved His friends and cows from the severe forest fire, and He chastised the Käliya serpent in the lake of Yamunä and forced him to leave the vicinity of the Yamunä River; He thereby made the water of the Yamunä poisonless."

Another one of the friends of Nanda Mahäräja said, "My dear Nanda, we do not know why we are so attracted by your son Kåñëa. We want to forget Him, but this is impossible. Why are we so naturally affectionate toward Him? Just imagine how wonderful it is! On one hand He is only a boy of seven years old, and on the other hand there is a huge hill like Govardhana Hill, and He lifted it so easily! O Nanda Mahäräja, we are now in great doubt—your son Kåñëa must be one of the demigods. He is not at all an ordinary boy. Maybe He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

On hearing the praises of the cowherd men in Våndävana, King Nanda said, "My dear friends, in reply to you I can simply present the statement of Gargamuni so that your doubts may be cleared. When he came to perform the name-giving ceremony, he said that this boy descends in different periods of time in different colors and that this time He has appeared in Våndävana in a dark color and is known as Kåñëa. Previously, He has white color, then red color, then yellow color. He also said that this boy was once the son of Vasudeva, and everyone who knows of His previous birth calls Him Väsudeva. Actually he said that my son has many varieties of names, according to His different qualities and activities. Gargäcärya assured me that this boy will be all-auspicious for my family and that He will be able to give transcendental blissful pleasure to all the cowherd men and cows in Våndävana. Even though we will be put into various kinds of difficulties, by the grace of this boy we will be very easily freed from them. He also said that formerly this boy saved the world from an unregulated condition, and He saved all honest men from the hands of the dishonest. He also said that any fortunate man who becomes attached to this boy, Kåñëa, is never vanquished or defeated by his enemy. On the whole, He is exactly like Lord Viñëu, who always takes the side of the demigods, who are consequently never defeated by the demons. Gargäcärya thus concluded that my child will grow to be exactly like Viñëu in transcendental beauty, qualification, activities, influence and opulence, and so we should not be very astonished by His wonderful activities. After telling me this, Gargäcärya returned home, and since then we have been continually seeing the wonderful activities of this child. According to the version of Gargäcärya, I consider that He must be Näräyaëa Himself, or maybe a plenary portion of Näräyaëa."

When all the cowherd men very attentively heard the statements of Gargäcärya through Nanda Mahäräja, they better appreciated the wonderful activities of Kåñëa and became very jubilant and satisfied. They began to praise Nanda Mahäräja, because by consulting him their doubts about Kåñëa were cleared. They said, "Let Kåñëa, who is so kind, beautiful and merciful, protect us. When angry Indra sent torrents of rain, accompanied by showers of ice blocks and high wind, He immediately took compassion upon us and saved us and our families, cows and valuable possessions by picking up the Govardhana Hill, just as a child picks up a mushroom. He saved us so wonderfully. May He continue to mercifully glance over us and our cows. May we live peacefully under the protection of wonderful Kåñëa."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-sixth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Wonderful Kåñëa."

KB 1970-1-27 / Prayers by Indra, the King of Heaven

27 / Prayers by Indra, the King of Heaven

When Kåñëa saved the inhabitants of Våndävana from the wrath of Indra by lifting Govardhana Hill, a surabhi cow from Goloka Våndävana, as well as King Indra from the heavenly planet, appeared before Him. Indra, the King of heaven, was conscious of his offence before Kåñëa; therefore he stealthily appeared before Him from a secluded place. He immediately fell down at the lotus feet of Kåñëa, although his own crown was dazzling like sunshine. Indra knew about the exalted position of Kåñëa because Kåñëa is the master of Indra, but he could not believe that Kåñëa could come down and live in Våndävana among the cowherd men. When Kåñëa defied the authority of Indra, Indra became angry because he thought that he was all in all within this universe and that no one was as powerful as he. But after this incident, his false puffed up prestige was destroyed. Being conscious of his subordinate position, he appeared before Kåñëa with folded hands and began to offer the following prayers.

"My dear Lord," Indra said, "being puffed up by my false prestige, I thought that You had offended me by not allowing the cowherd men to perform the Indra-yajïa, and I thought that You wanted to enjoy the offerings that were arranged for the sacrifice. I thought that in the name of a Govardhana sacrifice, You were taking my share of profit, and therefore I mistook Your position. Now by Your grace I can understand that You are the Supreme Lord, Personality of Godhead, and that You are transcendental to all the material qualities. Your transcendental position is viçuddha-sattvam, which is above the platform of the material mode of goodness, and Your transcendental abode is beyond the disturbance of the material qualities. Your name, fame, form, quality and pastimes are all beyond this material nature, and they are never disturbed by the three material modes. Your abode is accessible only for one who undergoes severe austerities and penances and who is completely freed from the onslaught of material qualities like passion and ignorance. If someone thinks that when You come within this material world You accept the modes of material nature, he is mistaken. The webs of the material qualities are never able to touch You, and You certainly do not accept them when You are present within this world. Your Lordship is never conditioned by the laws of material nature.

"My dear Lord, You are the original father of this cosmic manifestation. You are the supreme spiritual master of this cosmic world, and You are the original proprietor of everything. As eternal time, You are competent to chastise offenders. Within this material world there are many fools like myself who consider themselves to be the Supreme Lord or the all in all within the universe. You are so merciful that without punishing their offenses, You devise means so that their false prestige is subdued and they can know that You, and none else, are the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

"My dear Lord, You are the supreme father, the supreme spiritual master and supreme king. Therefore, You have the right to chastise all living entities whenever there is any discrepancy in their behavior. The father, the spiritual master, and the supreme executive officer of the state are always well-wishers of their sons, their students and their citizens respectively. As such, the well-wishers have the right to chastise their dependents. By Your own desire You appear auspiciously on the earth in Your eternal varieties of forms; You come to glorify the earthly planet and specifically to chastise persons who are falsely claiming to be God. In the material world there is regular competition between different types of living entities to become supreme leaders of society, and after being frustrated in achieving the supreme positions of leadership, foolish persons claim to be God, the Supreme Personality. There are many such foolish personalities in this world, like me, but in due course of time, when they come to their senses, they surrender unto You and again engage themselves properly by rendering service unto You. And that is the purpose of Your chastising persons envious of You.

"My dear Lord, I committed a great offense unto Your lotus feet, being falsely proud of my material opulences, not knowing Your unlimited power. Therefore, my Lord, kindly excuse me, because I am fool number one. Kindly give me Your blessings so that I may not act so foolishly again. If You think, my Lord, that the offence is very great and cannot be excused, then I appeal to You that I am Your eternal servant; Your appearance in this world is to give protection to Your eternal servants and to destroy the demons who maintain great military strength just to burden the very existence of the earth. As I am Your eternal servant, kindly excuse me.

"My dear Lord, You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead. I offer my respectful obeisances unto You because You are the Supreme Person and the Supreme Soul. You are the son of Vasudeva, and You are the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, the master of all pure devotees. Please accept my prostrated obeisances. You are the personification of supreme knowledge. You can appear anywhere according to Your desire in any one of Your eternal forms. You are the root of all creation and the Supreme Soul of all living entities. Due to my gross ignorance, I created great disturbance in Våndävana by sending torrents of rain and heavy hailstorm. I acted out of severe anger caused by Your stopping the sacrifice which was to be held to satisfy me. But my dear Lord, You are so kind to me that You have bestowed Your mercy upon me by destroying all my false pride. I therefore take shelter unto Your lotus feet. My dear Lord, You are not only the supreme controller, but also the spiritual master of all living entities."

Thus praised by Indra, Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, smiling beautifully, said, "My dear Indra, I have stopped your sacrifice just to show My causeless mercy and to revive your memory that I am your eternal master. I am not only your master, but I am the master of all the other demigods as well. You should always remember that all your material opulences are due to My mercy. Everyone should always remember that I am the Supreme Lord. I can show anyone My favor, and I can chastise anyone, because no one is superior to Me. If I find someone overpowered by false pride, in order to show him My causeless mercy, I withdraw all his opulences."

It is noteworthy that Kåñëa sometimes removes all opulences in order to facilitate a rich man's becoming a surrendered soul to Him. This is a special favor of the Lord's. Sometimes it is seen that a person is very opulent materially, but due to his devotional service to the Lord, he may be reduced to poverty. One should not think, however, that because he worshiped the Supreme Lord he became poverty-stricken. The real purport is that when a person is a pure devotee, but at the same time, by miscalculation, he wants to lord it over material nature, the Lord shows His special mercy by taking away all material opulences until at last he surrenders unto the Supreme Lord.

After instructing Indra, Lord Kåñëa asked him to return to his kingdom in the heavenly planet and to remember always that he is never the supreme but is always subordinate to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He also advised him to remain as King of heaven, but to be careful of false pride.

After this, the transcendental surabhi cow, who also came with Indra to see Kåñëa, offered her respectful obeisances unto Him and worshiped Him. The surabhi offered her prayer as follows. "My dear Lord Kåñëa, You are the most powerful of all mystic yogés because You are the soul of the complete universe, and from You only all this cosmic manifestation has taken place. Therefore, although Indra tried his best to kill my descendant cows in Våndävana, they remained under Your shelter, and You have protected them all so well. We do not know anyone else as the Supreme, nor do we go to any other god or demigods for protection. Therefore, You are our Indra, You are the Supreme Father of the whole cosmic manifestation, and You are the protector and elevator of all the cows, brähmaëas, demigods and others who are pure devotees of Your Lordship. O Supersoul of the universe, let us bathe You with our milk because You are our Indra. O Lord, You appear just to diminish the burden of impure activities on the earth."

In this way, Kåñëa was bathed by the milk of the surabhi cows, and Indra was bathed by the water of the celestial Ganges through the trunk of his carrier elephant. After this, the heavenly King Indra, along with surabhi cows and all other demigods and their mothers, worshiped Lord Kåñëa by bathing Him with Ganges water and the milk of the surabhis. Thus Govinda, Lord Kåñëa, was pleased with all of them. The residents of all higher planetary systems, such as Gandharvaloka, Pitåloka, Siddhaloka, and Cäraëaloka, all combined and began to glorify the Lord by chanting His holy name. Their wives and damsels began to dance with great joy. They very much satisfied the Lord by incessantly pouring flowers from the sky. When everything was very nicely and joyfully settled, the cows overflooded the surface of the earth with their milk. The water of the rivers began to flow and give nourishment to the trees, producing fruits and flowers of different colors and taste. The trees began to pour drops of honey. The hills and mountains began to produce potent medicinal plants and valuable stones. Because of Kåñëa's presence, all these things happened very nicely, and the lower animals, who were generally envious, were envious no longer.

After satisfying Kåñëa, who is the Lord of all the cows in Våndävana, who is known as Govinda, King Indra took His permission to return to his heavenly kingdom. He was surrounded by all kinds of demigods who passed with him through cosmic space. This great incident is a powerful example of how Kåñëa consciousness can benefit the world. Even the lower animals forget their envious nature and become elevated to the qualities of the demigods.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-seventh Chapter of Kåñëa, "Prayers by Indra, the King of Heaven."

KB 1970-1-28 / Releasing Nanda Mahäräja from the Clutches of Varuëa

28 / Releasing Nanda Mahäräja from the Clutches of Varuëa

The Govardhana Ceremony took place on the new moon day. After this, there were torrents of rain and hailstorms imposed by King Indra for seven days. Nine days of the waxing moon having passed, on the tenth day King Indra worshiped Lord Kåñëa, and thus the matter was satisfactorily settled. After this, on the eleventh day of the full moon, there was Ekädaçé. Mahäräja Nanda observed fasting for the whole day, and just early in the morning of the Dvädaçé, the day after Ekädaçé, he went to take bath in the River Yamunä. He entered deep into the water of the river, but he was arrested immediately by one of the servants of Varuëadeva. These servants brought Nanda Mahäräja before the demigod Varuëa and accused him of taking a bath in the river at the wrong time. According to astronomical calculations, the time in which he took bath was considered demoniac. The fact was, Nanda Mahäräja wanted to take a bath in the River Yamunä early in the morning before the sunrise, but somehow or other he was a little too early, and he bathed at an inauspicious time. Consequently he was arrested.

When Nanda Mahäräja was taken away by Varuëa's servants, his companions began to call loudly for Kåñëa and Balaräma. Immediately Kåñëa and Balaräma could understand that Nanda Mahäräja was taken by Varuëa, and thus They went to the abode of Varuëa, for They were pledged to give protection. The inhabitants of Våndävana, the unalloyed devotees of the Lord, having no shelter other than the Supreme Personality of Godhead, naturally cried to Him for help, exactly like children who do not know anything but the protection of their parents. Demigod Varuëa received Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma with great respect and said, "My dear Lord, actually at this very moment, because of Your presence, I am materially defeated. Although I am the proprietor of all the treasures in the water, I know that such possessions do not make for a successful life. But this moment, as I look at You, my life is made completely successful because by seeing You I no longer have to accept a material body. Therefore, O Lord, Supreme Personality of Godhead, Supreme Brahman and Supersoul of everything, let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You. You are the supreme transcendental personality; there is no possibility of imposing the influence of material nature upon You. I am very sorry that by being foolish, by not knowing what to do or what not to do, I have mistakenly arrested Your father, Nanda Mahäräja. So I beg Your pardon for the offence of my servants. I think that it was Your plan to show me Your mercy by Your personal presence here. My dear Lord Kåñëa, Govinda, be merciful upon me—here is Your father. You can take him back immediately."

In this way Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, rescued His father and presented him before his friends with great jubilation. Nanda Mahäräja was surprised that, although the demigod was so opulent, he offered such respect to Kåñëa. That was very astonishing to Nanda, and he began to describe the incident to his friends and relatives with great wonder.

Actually, although Kåñëa was acting so wonderfully, Mahäräja Nanda and mother Yaçodä could not think of Him as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Instead, they always accepted Him as their beloved child. Thus Nanda Mahäräja did not accept the fact that Varuëa worshiped Kåñëa because Kåñëa was the Supreme Personality of Godhead; rather he took it that because Kåñëa was such a wonderful child He was respected even by Varuëa. The friends of Nanda Mahäräja, all the cowherd men, became eager to know if Kåñëa were actually the Supreme Personality and if He were going to give them all salvation. When they were all thus consulting among themselves, Kåñëa understood their minds, and in order to assure them of their destiny in the spiritual kingdom, He showed them the spiritual sky. Generally, ordinary persons are engaged simply in working hard in the material world, and they have no information that there is another kingdom or another sky, which is known as the spiritual sky, where life is eternal, blissful, and full of knowledge. As it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.6], a person returning to that spiritual sky never returns to this material world of death and suffering.

Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is always anxious to give information to the conditioned soul that there is a spiritual sky far, far beyond this material sky, transcendental to the innumerable universes created within the total material energy. Kåñëa is, of course, always very kind to every conditioned soul, but, as stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.29], He is especially inclined to the devotees. Hearing their inquiries, Kåñëa immediately thought that His devotees in Våndävana should be informed of the spiritual sky and the Vaikuëöha planets therein. Within the material world, every conditioned soul is in the darkness of ignorance. This means that all conditioned souls are under the concept of this bodily existence.

Everyone is under the impression that he is of this material world, and with this concept of life, everyone is working in ignorance in different forms of life. The activities of the particular type of body are called karma, or fruitive action. All conditioned souls under the impression of the bodily concept are working according to their particular types of body. These activities are creating their future conditional life. Because they have very little information of the spiritual world, they do not generally take to spiritual activities, which are called bhakti-yoga. Those who successfully practice bhakti-yoga, after giving up this present body, go directly to the spiritual world and become situated in one of the Vaikuëöha planets. The inhabitants of Våndävana are all pure devotees. Their destination after quitting the body is Kåñëaloka. They even surpass the Vaikuëöhalokas. The fact is, those who are always engaged in Kåñëa consciousness and mature, pure devotional service are given the chance, after death, to gain Kåñëa's association in the universes within the material world. Kåñëa's pastimes are continually going on, either in this universe or in another universe. Just as the sun globe is passing through many places across this earthly planet, so Kåñëa-lélä, or the transcendental advent and pastimes of Kåñëa, are also going on continually, either in this or another universe. The mature devotees, who have completely executed Kåñëa consciousness, are immediately transferred to the universe where Kåñëa is appearing. In that universe the devotees get their first opportunity to associate with Kåñëa personally and directly. The training goes on, as we see in the Våndävana lélä of Kåñëa within this planet. Kåñëa therefore revealed the actual feature of the Vaikuëöha planets so that the inhabitants of Våndävana could know their destination.

Thus Kåñëa showed them the eternal ever-existing spiritual sky which is unlimited and full of knowledge. Within this material world there are different gradations of forms, and according to the gradations, knowledge is proportionately manifested. For example, the knowledge in the body of a child is not as perfect as the knowledge in the body of an adult man. Everywhere there are different gradations of living entities, in aquatic animals, in the plants and trees, in the reptiles and insects, in birds and beasts and in the civilized and uncivilized human forms of life. Above the human form of life there are demigods, Cäraëas and Siddhas on up to Brahmaloka where Lord Brahmä lives, and among these demigods there are always different gradations of knowledge. But past this material world, in the Vaikuëöha sky, everyone is in full knowledge. All the living entities there are engaged in devotional service to the Lord, either in the Vaikuëöha planets or in Kåñëaloka.

As it is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.55], full knowledge means knowing Kåñëa to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Vedas and Bhagavad-gétä [15.6] it is also stated that in the brahmajyoti or spiritual sky there is no need of sunlight, moonlight, or electricity. All those planets are self-illuminating, and all of them are eternally situated. There is no question of creation and annihilation in the brahmajyoti, spiritual sky. Bhagavad-gétä [8.20] also confirms that beyond the material sky there is another eternal spiritual sky where everything is eternally existing. Information of the spiritual sky can be had only from great sages and saintly persons who have already surpassed the influence of the three material modes of nature. Unless one is constantly situated on that transcendental platform, it is not possible to understand the spiritual nature.

Therefore it is recommended that one should take to bhakti-yoga and keep himself engaged twenty-four hours in Kåñëa consciousness, which places one beyond the reach of the modes of material nature. One in Kåñëa consciousness can easily understand the nature of the spiritual sky and Vaikuëöhaloka. The inhabitants of Våndävana, being always engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, could therefore very easily understand the transcendental nature of the Vaikuëöhalokas.

Thus Kåñëa led all the cowherd men, headed by Nanda Mahäräja, to the lake where Akrüra was later shown the Vaikuëöha planetary system. They took their bath immediately and saw the real nature of the Vaikuëöhalokas. After seeing the spiritual sky and the Vaikuëöhalokas, all the men, headed by Nanda Mahäräja, felt wonderfully blissful, and coming out of the river, they saw Kåñëa, who was being worshiped with excellent prayers.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-eighth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Releasing Nanda Mahäräja from the Clutches of Varuëa."

KB 1970-1-29 / The Räsa Dance: Introduction

29 / The Räsa Dance: Introduction

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated the räsa dance took place on the full moon night of the çarat season. From the statement of previous chapters, it appears that the festival of Govardhana Püjä was performed just after the dark moon night of the month of Kärttika, and thereafter the ceremony of Bhrätådvitéya was performed; then the wrath of Indra was exhibited in the shape of torrents of rain and hailstorm, and Lord Kåñëa held up Govardhana Hill for seven days, up until the ninth day of the moon. Thereafter, on the tenth day, the inhabitants of Våndävana were talking amongst themselves about the wonderful activities of Kåñëa, and the next day, Ekädaçé was observed by Nanda Mahäräja. On the next day, Dvädaçé, Nanda Mahäräja went to take a bath in the Ganges and was arrested by the men of Varuëa; then he was released by Lord Kåñëa. Then Nanda Mahäräja, along with the cowherd men, was shown the spiritual sky.

In this way, the full moon night of çarat season came to an end. The full moon night of Äçvina is called çärad-pürëimä. It appears from the statement of Çrémad-Bhägavatam that Kåñëa had to wait another year for such a moon before enjoying the räsa dance with the gopés. At the age of seven years, He lifted Govardhana Hill. Therefore, the räsa dance took place during His eighth year.

From Vedic literature it appears that when a theatrical actor dances among many dancing girls, the group-dance is called a räsa dance. When Kåñëa saw the full moon night of the çarat season, He decorated Himself with various seasonal flowers, especially the mallikä flowers, which are very fragrant. He remembered the gopés' prayers to goddess Kätyäyané, wherein they prayed for Kåñëa to be their husband. He thought that the full night of the çarat season was just suitable for a nice dance. So their desire to have Kåñëa as their husband would then be fulfilled.

The words used in this connection in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.29.1] are bhagavän api. This means that although Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, He has no desire that needs to be fulfilled because He is always full with six opulences. Yet He wanted to enjoy the company of the gopés. Bhagavän api signifies that this is not like the ordinary dancing of young boys and young girls. The specific word used in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam is yogamäyäm upäçritaù, which means that this dancing with the gopés is on the platform of yogamäyä, not mahämäyä. The dancing of young boys and girls within this material world is in the kingdom of mahämäyä, or the external energy. The räsa dance of Kåñëa with the gopés is on the platform of yogamäyä. The difference between the platform of yogamäyä and mahämäyä is compared in the Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 4.164] to the difference between gold and iron. From the viewpoint of metallurgy, gold and iron are both metals, but the quality is completely different. Similarly, although the räsa dance and Lord Kåñëa's association with the gopés appear like the ordinary mixing of young boys and girls, the quality is completely different. The difference is appreciated by great Vaiñëavas because they can understand the difference between love of Kåñëa and lust.

On the mahämäyä platform, dances take place on the basis of sense gratification. But when Kåñëa called the gopés by sounding His flute, the gopés very hurriedly rushed towards the spot of räsa dance with the transcendental desire of satisfying Kåñëa. The author of Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 4.165], Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämé, has explained that lust means sense gratification, and love also means sense gratification—but for Kåñëa. In other words, when activities are enacted on the platform of personal sense gratification, they are called material activities, but when they are enacted for the satisfaction of Kåñëa, then they are spiritual activities. On any platform of activities, the principle of sense gratification is there. But on the spiritual platform, sense gratification is for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, whereas on the material platform it is for the performer. For example, on the material platform, when a servant serves a master, he is not trying to satisfy the senses of the master, but rather his own senses. The servant would not serve the master if the payment stopped. That means that the servant engages himself in the service of the master just to satisfy his senses. On the spiritual platform, the servitor of the Supreme Personality of Godhead serves Kåñëa without payment, and he continues his service in all conditions. That is the difference between Kåñëa consciousness and material consciousness.

It appears that Kåñëa enjoyed the räsa dance with the gopés when He was eight years old. At that time, many of the gopés were married, because in India, especially in those days, girls were married at a very early age. There are even many instances of a girl giving birth to a child at the age of twelve. Under the circumstances, all the gopés who wanted to have Kåñëa as their husband were already married. At the same time, they continued to hope that Kåñëa would be their husband. Their attitude toward Kåñëa was that of paramour love. Therefore, the loving affairs of Kåñëa with the gopés is called parakéya-rasa. A married man or a wife who desires another wife or husband is called parakéya-rasa.

Actually, Kåñëa is the husband of everyone because He is the supreme enjoyer. The gopés wanted Kåñëa to be their husband, but factually there was no possibility of His marrying all the gopés. But because they had that natural tendency to accept Kåñëa as their supreme husband, the relationship between the gopés and Kåñëa is called parakéya-rasa. This parakéya-rasa is ever-existent in Goloka Våndävana in the spiritual sky where there is no possibility of the inebriety which characterizes parakéya-rasa in the material world. In the material world, parakéya-rasa is abominable, whereas in the spiritual world it is present in the superexcellent relationship of Kåñëa and the gopés. There are many other relationships with Kåñëa: master and servant, friends and friend, parent and son, and lover and beloved. Out of all these rasas, the parakéya-rasa is considered to be the topmost.

This material world is the perverted reflection of the spiritual world; it is just like the reflection of a tree on the bank of a reservoir of water: the topmost part of the tree is seen as the lowest part. Similarly, parakéya-rasa, when pervertedly reflected in this material world, is abominable. When people, therefore, imitate the räsa dance of Kåñëa with the gopés, they simply enjoy the perverted, abominable reflection of the transcendental parakéya-rasa. There is no possibility of enjoying this transcendental parakéya-rasa within the material world. It is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.33.30] that one should not imitate this parakéya-rasa even in dream or imagination. Those who do so drink the most deadly poison.

When Kåñëa, the supreme enjoyer, desired to enjoy the company of the gopés on that full moon night of the çarat season, exactly at that very moment, the moon, the lord of the stars, appeared in the sky, displaying its most beautiful features. The full moon night of the çarat season is the most beautiful night in the year. In India there is a great monument called Taj Mahal in Agra, a city in the Uttar Pradesh province, and the tomb is made of first-class marble stone. During the night of the full moon of the çarat season, many foreigners go to see the beautiful reflections of the moon on the tomb. Thus this full moon night is celebrated even today for its beauty.

When the full moon rose in the east, it tinged everything with a reddish color. With the rising of the moon, the whole sky appeared smeared by red kuìkuma. When a husband long separated from his wife returns home, he decorates the face of his wife with red kuìkuma. This long-expected moonrise of the çarat season was thus smearing the eastern sky.

The appearance of the moon increased Kåñëa's desire to dance with the gopés. The forests were filled with fragrant flowers. The atmosphere was cooling and festive. When Lord Kåñëa began to blow His flute, the gopés all over Våndävana became enchanted. Their attraction to the vibration of the flute increased a thousand times due to the rising full moon, the red horizon, the calm and cool atmosphere, and the blossoming flowers. All these gopés were by nature very much attracted to Kåñëa's beauty, and when they heard the vibration of His flute, they became apparently lustful to satisfy the senses of Kåñëa.

Immediately upon hearing the vibration of the flute, they all left their respective engagements and proceeded to the spot where Kåñëa was standing. While they ran very swiftly, all their earrings swung back and forth. They all rushed toward the place known as Vaàçévaöa. Some of them were engaged in milking cows, but they left their milking business half finished and immediately went to Kåñëa. One of them had just collected milk and put it in a milk pan on the oven to boil, but she did not care whether the milk overboiled and spilled—she immediately left to go see Kåñëa. Some of them were breast feeding their small babies, and some were engaged in distributing food to the members of their families, but they left all such engagements and immediately rushed towards the spot where Kåñëa was playing His flute. Some were engaged in serving their husbands, and some were themselves engaged in eating, but neither caring to serve their husbands nor eat, they immediately left. Some of them wanted to decorate their faces with cosmetic ointments and to dress themselves very nicely before going to Kåñëa, but unfortunately they could not finish their cosmetic decorations nor put on their dresses in the right way because of their anxiety to meet Kåñëa immediately. Their faces were decorated hurriedly and were haphazardly finished; some even put the lower part of their dresses on the upper part of their bodies and the upper part on the lower part.

While all the gopés were hurriedly leaving their respective places, their husbands, brothers and fathers were all struck with wonder to know where they were going. Being young girls, they were protected either by husbands, elderly brothers or fathers. All their guardians forbade them to go to Kåñëa, but they disregarded them. When a person becomes attracted by Kåñëa and is in full Kåñëa consciousness, he does not care for any worldly duties, even though very urgent. Kåñëa consciousness is so powerful that it gives everyone relief from all material activities. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé [Brs. 1.2.239] has written a very nice verse wherein one gopé advises another, "My dear friend, if you desire to enjoy the company of material society, friendship and love, then please do not go to see this smiling boy Govinda, who is standing on the bank of the Yamunä and playing His flute, His lips brightened by the beams of the full moonlight." Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé indirectly instructs that one who has been captivated by the beautiful smiling face of Kåñëa has lost all attraction for material enjoyments. This is the test of advancement in Kåñëa consciousness: a person advancing in Kåñëa consciousness must lose interest in material activities and personal sense gratification.

Some of the gopés were factually detained from going to Kåñëa by their husbands and were locked up by force within their rooms. Being unable to go to Kåñëa, they began to meditate upon His transcendental form by closing their eyes. They already had the form of Kåñëa within their minds. They proved to be the greatest yogés; as is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, a person who is constantly thinking of Kåñëa within his heart with faith and love is considered to be the topmost of all yogés. Actually, a yogé concentrates his mind on the form of Lord Viñëu. That is real yoga. Kåñëa is the original form of all Viñëu tattvas. The gopés could not go to Kåñëa personally, so they began to meditate on Him as perfect yogés.

In the conditioned stage of the living entities, there are two kinds of results of fruitive activities: the conditioned living entity who is constantly engaged in sinful activities has suffering as his result, and he who is engaged in pious activities has material enjoyment as a result. In either case—material suffering or material enjoyment—the enjoyer or sufferer is conditioned by material nature.

The gopé associates of Kåñëa, who assemble in the place where Kåñëa is appearing, are from different groups. Most of the gopés are eternal companions of Kåñëa. As stated in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.37], änanda-cin-maya-rasa-pratibhävitäbhiù: in the spiritual world the associates of Kåñëa, especially the gopés, are the manifestation of the pleasure potency of Lord Kåñëa. They are expansions of Çrématé Rädhäräëé. But when Kåñëa exhibits His transcendental pastimes within the material world in some of the universes, not only the eternal associates of Kåñëa come, but also those who are being promoted to that status from this material world. The gopés who joined Kåñëa's pastimes within this material world were coming from the status of ordinary human beings. If they had been bound by fruitive action, they were fully freed from the reaction of karma by constant meditation on Kåñëa. Their severe painful yearnings caused by their not being able to see Kåñëa freed them from all sinful reactions, and their ecstacy of transcendental love for Kåñëa in His absence was transcendental to all their reactions of material pious activities. The conditioned soul is subjected to birth and death, either by pious or sinful activities, but the gopés who began to meditate on Kåñëa transcended both positions and became purified and thus elevated to the status of the gopés already expanded by His pleasure potency. All the gopés who concentrated their minds on Kåñëa in the spirit of paramour love became fully uncontaminated from all the fruitive reactions of material nature, and some of them immediately gave up their material bodies developed under the three modes of material nature.

Mahäräja Parékñit heard Çukadeva Gosvämé explain the situation of the gopés who assembled with Kåñëa in the räsa dance. When he heard that some of the gopés, simply by concentrating on Kåñëa as their paramour, became freed from all contamination of material birth and death, he said, "The gopés did not know that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They accepted Him as a beautiful boy and considered Him to be their paramour. So how was it possible for them to get freed from the material condition just by thinking of a paramour?" One should consider here that Kåñëa and ordinary living beings are qualitatively one. The ordinary living beings, being part and parcel of Kåñëa, are also Brahman, but Kåñëa is the Supreme—Parabrahman. The question is, if it is possible for the devotee to get free from the material, contaminated stage simply by thinking of Kåñëa, then why not others who are also thinking of someone? If one is thinking of a husband or son, or if anyone at all is thinking of another living entity, since all living entities are also Brahman, then why are they not all freed from the contaminated stage of material nature? This is a very intelligent question, because the atheists are always imitating Kåñëa. In these days of Kaliyuga, there are many rascals who think themselves to be as great as Kåñëa and who cheat people into believing that thinking of them is as good as thinking of Lord Kåñëa. Parékñit Mahäräja, apprehending the dangerous condition of blind followers of demonic imitators, therefore asked this question, and fortunately it is recorded in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam to warn innocent people that thinking of an ordinary man and thinking of Kåñëa are not the same.

Actually, even thinking of the demigods cannot compare with thinking of Kåñëa. It is also warned in Vaiñëava Tantra that one who puts Viñëu, Näräyaëa, or Kåñëa on the same level of the demigods is called päsaëòa, or a rascal. On hearing this question of Mahäräja Parékñit, Çukadeva Gosvämé replied, "My dear King, your question is already answered, even before this incident."

Because Parékñit Mahäräja wanted to clear up the situation, his spiritual master answered him very intelligently, “Why are you again asking the same subject matter which has already been explained to you? Why are you so forgetful?” A spiritual master is always in the superior position, so he has the right to chastise his disciple in this way. Çukadeva Gosvämé knew that Mahäräja Parékñit asked the question not for his own understanding, but as a warning to the future innocent people who might think others to be equal to Kåñëa.

Çukadeva Gosvämé then reminded Parékñit Mahäräja about the salvation of Çiçupäla. Çiçupäla was always envious of Kåñëa, and because of his envy Kåñëa killed him. Since Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çiçupäla gained salvation simply by seeing Him. If an envious person can get salvation simply by concentrating his mind on Kåñëa, then what to speak of the gopés who are so dear to Kåñëa and always thinking of Him in love? There must be some difference between the enemies and the friends. If Kåñëa's enemies could get freed from material contamination and become one with the Supreme, then certainly His dear friends like the gopés are freed and with Him.

Besides that, in the Bhagavad-gétä [1.15] Kåñëa is called Håñékeça. Çukadeva Gosvämé also said that Kåñëa is Håñékeça, the Supersoul, whereas an ordinary man is a conditioned soul covered by the material body. Kåñëa and Kåñëa's body are the same because He is Håñékeça. Any person making a distinction between Kåñëa and Kåñëa's body is fool number one. Kåñëa is Håñékeça and Adhokñaja. These two particular words have been used by Parékñit Mahäräja in this instance. Håñékeça is the Supersoul, and Adhokñaja is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, transcendental to the material nature. Just to show favor to the ordinary living entities, out of His causeless mercy, He appears as He is. Unfortunately, foolish persons mistake Him to be another ordinary person, and so they become eligible to go to hell. Çukadeva Gosvämé reconfirmed that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, imperishable, immeasurable, and free from all material contamination.

Çukadeva Gosvämé continued to inform Mahäräja Parékñit that Kåñëa is not an ordinary person. He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, full of all spiritual qualities. He appears in this material world out of His causeless mercy, and whenever He appears, He appears as He is without change. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä. There the Lord says that He appears in His spiritual potency. He does not appear under the control of this material potency. The material potency is under His control. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.10] it is stated that the material potency is working under His superintendence. It is also confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.44] that the material potency known as Durgä is acting just as a shadow which moves with the movement of the substance. The conclusion is that if one somehow or other becomes attached to Kåñëa or attracted to Him, either because of His beauty, quality, opulence, fame, strength, renunciation or knowledge, or even through lust, anger or fear, or affection or friendship, then one's salvation and freedom from material contamination is assured.

In the Bhagavad-gétä, Eighteenth Chapter, the Lord also states that one who is engaged in preaching Kåñëa consciousness is very dear to Him. A preacher has to face many difficulties in his struggle to preach pure Kåñëa consciousness. Sometimes he has to suffer bodily injuries, and sometimes he has to meet death also. All this is taken as a great austerity on behalf of Kåñëa. Kåñëa therefore has said that such a preacher is very, very dear to Him. If Kåñëa's enemies can expect salvation simply by concentrating their minds on Him, then what to speak of persons who are so dear to Kåñëa? The conclusion should be that the salvation of those who are engaged in preaching Kåñëa consciousness in the world is guaranteed in all circumstances. But such preachers never care for salvation, because factually one who is engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, devotional service, has already achieved salvation. Çukadeva Gosvämé therefore assured King Parékñit that he should always rest assured that one attracted by Kåñëa attains liberation from material bondage because Kåñëa is the transcendental master of all mystic power.

When all the gopés assembled, as described, before Kåñëa, He began to speak to them, welcoming them as well as discouraging them by word jugglery. Kåñëa is the supreme speaker; He is the speaker of the Bhagavad-gétä. He can speak on the highest elevated subjects of philosophy, politics, economics—everything. And He also spoke before the gopés who were so dear to Him. He wanted to enchant them by word jugglery, and thus He began to speak as follows.

"O ladies of Våndävana," Kåñëa said. "You are very fortunate, and you are very dear to Me. I am very pleased that you have come here, and I hope everything is well in Våndävana. Now please order Me. What can I do for you? What is the purpose of coming here in this dead of night. Kindly take your seats and let Me know what I can do for you."

The gopés had come to Kåñëa to enjoy His company, to dance with Him, embrace Him and kiss Him, and when Kåñëa began to receive them very officially, showing all kinds of etiquette, they were surprised. He was treating them as ordinary society women. Therefore they began to smile among themselves, and they very eagerly listened to Kåñëa talk in that way. When He saw that they were smiling at Him, He said, "My dear friends, you must know now that it is the dead of night, and the forest is very dangerous. At this time all the ferocious jungle animals, the tigers, bears, jackals and wolves, are prowling in the forest. Therefore it is very dangerous for you. You cannot select a secure place now. Everywhere you go you will find that all these animals are loitering to find their prey. I think, therefore, that you are taking a great risk in coming here in the dead of night. Please turn back immediately, without delay."

When He saw that they continued to smile, He said, "I very much appreciate your bodily features. All of you have nice, very thin waists." All of the gopés there were exquisitely beautiful. They are described by the word sumadhyamä; the standard of beauty of a woman is said to be sumadhyamä when the middle portion of the body is slender.

Kåñëa wanted to impress on them that they were not old enough to take care of themselves. Actually, they required protection. It was not very wise for them to come in the dead of night to Kåñëa. Kåñëa also indicated that He was young and that they were young girls. "It does not look very well for young girls and boys to remain together in the dead of night." After hearing this advice, the gopés did not seem very happy; therefore Kåñëa began to stress the point in a different way.

"My dear friends, I can understand that you have left your homes without the permission of your guardians; therefore I think your mothers, your fathers, your elderly brothers or even your sons, and what to speak of your husbands, must be very anxious to find you. As long as you are here, they must be searching in different places, and their minds must be very agitated. So don't tarry. Please go back and make them peaceful."

When the gopés appeared to be a little bit disturbed and angry from the free advice of Kåñëa, they diverted their attention to looking at the beauty of the forest. At that time the whole forest was illuminated by the bright shining of the moon, and the air was blowing very silently over the blooming flowers, and the green leaves of the trees were moving in the breeze. Kåñëa took the opportunity of their looking at the forest to advise them. "I think you have come out to see the beautiful Våndävana forest on this night," He said, "but you must now be satisfied. So return to your homes without delay. I understand that you are all very chaste women, so now that you have seen the beautiful atmosphere of the Våndävana forests, please return home and engage in the faithful service of your respective husbands. Some of you must have babies by this time, although you are very young. You must have left your small babies at home, and they must be crying. Please immediately go back home and just feed them with your breast milk. I can also understand that you have very great affection for Me, and out of that transcendental affection you have come here, hearing My playing on the flute. Your feelings of love and affection for Me are very appropriate because I am the Supreme Personality of Godhead. All living creatures are My parts and parcels, and naturally they are affectionate to Me. So this affection for Me is very much welcome, and I congratulate you for this. Now you can go back to your homes. Another thing I must explain to you is that for a chaste woman, service to the husband without duplicity is the best religious principle. A woman should be not only faithful and chaste to the husband, but affectionate to the friends of her husband, obedient to the father and mother of the husband, and affectionate to the younger brothers of the husband. And most importantly, the woman must take care of the children."

In this way, Kåñëa explained the duty of a woman. He also stressed the point of serving the husband: "Even if he is not of very good character, or even if he is not very rich or fortunate, or even if he is old or invalid on account of continued diseases, whatever her husband's condition, a woman should not divorce her husband if she actually desires to be elevated to the higher planetary systems after leaving this body. Besides that, it is considered abominable in society if a woman is unfaithful and goes searching for another man. Such habits will deter a woman from being elevated to the heavenly planets, and the results of such habits are very degrading. A married woman should not search for a paramour, for this is not sanctioned by the Vedic principles of life. If you think that you are very much attached to Me and you want My association, I advise you not to personally try to enjoy Me. It is better for you to go home, simply talk about Me, think of Me, and by this process of constantly remembering Me and chanting My names, you will surely be elevated to the spiritual platform. There is no need to stand near Me. Please go back home."

The instruction given herein by the Supreme Personality of Godhead to the gopés was not at all sarcastic. Such instructions should be taken very seriously by all honest women. The chastity of women is specifically stressed herein by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore this principle should be followed by any serious woman who wants to be elevated to a higher status of life. Kåñëa is the center of all affection for all living creatures. When this affection is developed for Kåñëa, then one surpasses and transcends all Vedic injunctions. This was possible for the gopés because they saw Kåñëa face to face. This is not possible for any women in the conditioned state. Unfortunately, by imitating the behavior of Kåñëa with the gopés, sometimes a rascal takes the position of Kåñëa, following the philosophy of monism or oneness, and he very irresponsibly takes advantage of this räsa-lélä to entice many innocent women and mislead them in the name of spiritual realization. As a warning, Lord Kåñëa has herein hinted that what was possible for the gopés is not possible for ordinary women. Although a woman can actually be elevated by advanced Kåñëa consciousness, she should not be enticed by an imposter who says that he is Kåñëa. She should concentrate her devotional activities in chanting and meditating upon Kåñëa, as is advised herein. One should not follow the men called sahajiyä, the so-called devotees who take everything very lightly.

When Kåñëa spoke in such a discouraging way to the gopés, they became very sad, for they thought that their desire to enjoy räsa dance with Kåñëa would be frustrated. Thus they became full of anxiety. Out of great sadness, the gopés began to breathe very heavily. Instead of looking at Kåñëa face to face, they bowed their heads and looked to the ground, and they began to draw various types of curved lines on the ground with their toes. They were shedding heavy tears, and their cosmetic decorations were being washed from their faces. The water from their eyes mixed with the kuìkuma of their breasts and fell to the ground. They could not say anything to Kåñëa, but simply stood there silently. By their silence they expressed that their hearts were grieviously wounded.

The gopés were not ordinary women. In essence they were on an equal level with Kåñëa. They are His eternal associates. As it is confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä, they are expansions of the pleasure potency of Kåñëa, and as His potency they are nondifferent from Him. Although they were depressed by the words of Kåñëa, they did not like to use harsh words against Him. Yet they wanted to rebuke Kåñëa for His unkind words, and therefore they began to speak in faltering voices. They did not like to use harsh words against Kåñëa because He was their dearmost, their heart and soul. The gopés had only Kåñëa within their hearts. They were completely surrendered and dedicated souls. Naturally, when they heard such unkind words, they tried to reply, but in the attempt torrents of tears fell from their eyes. Finally they managed to speak.

"Kåñëa," they said, "You are very cruel! You should not talk like that. We are full-fledged surrendered souls. Please accept us, and don't talk in that cruel way. Of course, You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and You can do whatever You like, but it is not worthy of Your position to treat us in such a cruel way. We have come to You, leaving everything behind, just to take shelter of Your lotus feet. We know that You are completely independent and can do whatever You like, but we request You, don't reject us. We are Your devotees. You should accept us as Lord Näräyaëa accepts His devotees. There are many devotees of Lord Näräyaëa who worship Him for salvation, and He awards them salvation. Similarly, how can You reject us when we have no other shelter than Your lotus feet?

"O dear Kåñëa," they continued, "You are the supreme instructor. There is no doubt about it. Your instructions to the women to be faithful to their husbands and to be merciful to their children, to take care of homely affairs and to be obedient to the elderly members of the family, are surely just according to the tenets of çästras. But we know also that all these instructions of the çästras may be observed perfectly by keeping oneself under the protection of Your lotus feet. Our husbands, friends, family members and children are all dear and pleasing to us only because of Your presence, for You are the Supersoul of all living creatures. Without Your presence, one is worthless. When You leave the body, the body immediately dies, and according to the injunction of the çästra, a dead body must immediately be thrown in a river or burned. Therefore, ultimately You are the dearmost personality in this world. By placing our faith and love in Your personality, there is no chance of our being bereft of husband, friends, sons or daughters. If a woman accepts You as the supreme husband, then she will never be bereft of her husband, as in the bodily concept of life. If we accept You as our ultimate husband, then there is no question of being separated, divorced or widowed. You are the eternal husband, eternal son, eternal friend, and eternal master, and one who enters into a relationship with You is eternally happy. Since You are the teacher of all religious principles, Your lotus feet first have to be worshiped. Accordingly, the çästras state, äcärya-upäsanä: the worship of Your lotus feet is the first principle. Besides that, as stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.29], You are the only enjoyer, You are the only proprietor, and You are the only friend. As such, we have come to You, leaving aside all so-called friends, society and love, and now You have become our enjoyer. Let us be everlastingly enjoyed by You. Be our proprietor, for that is Your natural claim, and be our supreme friend, for You are naturally so. Let us thus embrace You as the supreme beloved."

Then the gopés told the lotus-eyed Kåñëa, "Please do not discourage our long-cherished desires to have You as our husband. Any intelligent man who cares for his own self-interest reposes all his loving spirit in You. Persons who are simply misled by the external energy, who want to be satisfied by false concepts, try to enjoy themselves apart from You. The so-called husband, friend, son, daughter, or father and mother are all simply sources of material misery. No one is made happy in this material world by having a so-called father, mother, husband, son, daughter and friend. Although the father and mother are expected to protect the children, there are many children who are suffering for want of food and shelter. There are many good physicians, but when a patient dies, no physician can revive him. There are many means of protection, but when one is doomed, none of the protective measures can help, and without Your protection the so-called sources of protection simply become sources of continued distress. We therefore appeal to You, dear Lord of all lords, please do not kill our long-cherished desires to have You as our supreme husband.

"Dear Kåñëa, as women, we are certainly satisfied when our hearts are engaged in the activities of family affairs, but our hearts have already been stolen by You. We can no longer engage them in family affairs. Besides that, You are asking us repeatedly to return home, and that is a very appropriate instruction, but unfortunately we have been stunned here. Our legs have no power to move a step from Your lotus feet. Therefore, if even at Your request we return home, what shall we do there? We have lost all our capacity to act without You. Instead of engaging our hearts in family affairs as women, we have now developed a different type of lust which is continually blazing in our hearts. Now we request You, dear Kåñëa, to extinguish that fire with Your beautiful smile and the transcendental vibration emanating from Your lips. If You do not agree to do us this favor, we shall certainly be burned in the fire of separation. In that condition, we shall simply think of You and Your beautiful features and give up our bodies immediately. In that way we think it will be possible for us to reside at Your lotus feet in the next life. Dear Kåñëa, if You say that if we go home our respective husbands will satisfy the lusty flame of our desire, we can only say that that is no longer possible. You have given us a chance to be enjoyed by You in the forest and have touched our breasts once in the past, which we accepted as a blessing, as did the goddesses of fortune, who are enjoyed in the Vaikuëöhalokas by You. Since we have tasted this transcendental enjoyment, we are no longer interested in going to anyone but You for the satisfaction of our lust. Dear Kåñëa, the lotus feet of the goddess of fortune are always worshiped by the demigods, although she is always resting on Your chest in the Vaikuëöha planets. She underwent great austerity and penance to have some shelter at Your lotus feet, which are always covered by tulasé leaves. Your lotus feet are the proper shelter of Your servitors, and the goddess of fortune, instead of abiding on Your chest, comes down and worships Your lotus feet. We have now placed ourselves under the dust of Your feet. Please do not reject us, for we are fully surrendered souls.

"Dear Kåñëa, You are known as Hari. You destroy all the miseries of all living entities, specifically of those who have left their homes and family attachment and have completely taken to You. We have left our homes with the hope that we shall completely devote and dedicate our lives to Your service. We are simply begging to be engaged as Your servants. We do not wish to ask You to accept us as Your wives. Simply accept us as Your maidservants. Since You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead and like to enjoy the parakéya-rasa and are famous as a transcendental woman hunter, we have come to satisfy Your transcendental desires. We are also after our own satisfaction, for simply by looking at Your smiling face we have become very lusty. We have come before You decorated with all ornaments and dress, but until You embrace us, all our dresses and beautiful features remain incomplete. You are the Supreme Person, and if You complete our dressing attempt as the puruña-bhüñaëa, or the male ornament, then all our desires and bodily decorations are complete.

"Dear Kåñëa, we have simply been captivated by seeing You with tilaka and with earrings and by seeing Your beautiful face covered with scattered hair and Your extraordinary smile. Not only that, but we are also attracted by Your arms, which always give assurance to the surrendered souls. And although we are also attracted by Your chest, which is always embraced by the goddess of fortune, we do not wish to take her position. We shall simply be satisfied by being Your maidservants. If You, however, accuse us of encouraging prostitution, then we can only ask where is that woman within these three worlds who is not captivated by Your beauty and the rhythmic songs vibrated by Your transcendental flute? Within these three worlds there is no distinction between men and women in relation to You because both men and women belong to the marginal potency or prakåti. No one is actually the enjoyer or the male; everyone is meant to be enjoyed by You. There is no woman within these three worlds who cannot but deviate from her path of chastity once she is attracted to You because Your beauty is so sublime that not only men and women, but cows, birds, beasts and even trees, fruits and flowers—everyone and everything—become enchanted, and what to speak of ourselves? It is, however, definitely decided that as Lord Viñëu is always protecting the demigods from the onslaught of demons, so You have also advented in Våndävana just to give the residents protection from all kinds of distress. O dear friend of the distressed, kindly place Your hand on our burning breasts as well as on our heads, because we have surrendered unto You as Your eternal maidservants. If You think, however, that Your lotus-like palms might be burned to ashes if placed on our burning breasts, let us assure You that Your palms will feel pleasure instead of pain, as the lotus flower, although very delicate and soft, enjoys the scorching heat of the sun."

Upon hearing the anxious plea of the gopés, the Supreme Personality of Godhead began to smile, and being very kind to the gopés, the Lord, although self-sufficient, began to embrace them and kiss them as they desired. When Kåñëa, smiling, looked at the faces of the gopés, the beauty of their faces became a hundred times enhanced. When He was enjoying them in their midst, He appeared just like the full moon surrounded by millions of shining stars. Thus the Supreme Personality of Godhead, surrounded by hundreds of gopés and decorated with a flower garland of many colors, began to wander within the Våndävana forest, sometimes singing to Himself and sometimes singing with the gopés. In this way, both the Lord and the gopés reached the cool sandy bank of the Yamunä where there were lilies and lotus flowers. In such a transcendental atmosphere, both the gopés and Kåñëa began to enjoy one another. While they were walking on the bank of the Yamunä, Kåñëa would sometimes put His arms around a gopé's head, breast or waist. Pinching one another and joking and looking at one another, they enjoyed. When Kåñëa touched the bodies of the gopés, their lust to embrace Him increased. They all enjoyed these pastimes. Thus the gopés were blessed with all mercy by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, for they enjoyed His company without a tinge of mundane sex life.

The gopés, however, soon began to feel very proud, thinking themselves to be the most fortunate women in the universe by being favored by the company of Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa, who is known as Keçava, could immediately understand their pride caused by their great fortune of enjoying Him personally, and in order to show them His causeless mercy and to curb their false pride, He immediately disappeared from the scene, exhibiting His opulence of renunciation. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is always full with six kinds of opulences, and this is an instance of the opulence of renunciation. This renunciation confirms Kåñëa's total nonattachment. He is always self-sufficient and is not dependent on anything. This is the platform on which the transcendental pastimes are enacted.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Twenty-ninth Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Räsa Dance: Introduction."

KB 1970-1-30 / Kåñëa's Hiding from the Gopés

30 / Kåñëa's Hiding from the Gopés

When Kåñëa suddenly disappeared from the company of the gopés, they began to search for Him in every place. After not finding Him anywhere, they became afraid and almost mad after Him. They were simply thinking of the pastimes of Kåñëa in great love and affection. Being absorbed in thought, they experienced loss of memory, and with dampened eyes they began to see the very pastimes of Kåñëa, His beautiful talks with them, His embracing, kissing, and other activities. Being so attracted to Kåñëa, they began to imitate His dancing, His walking and smiling, as if they themselves were Kåñëa. Due to Kåñëa's absence, they all became crazy; each one of them began to tell the others that she was Kåñëa Himself. Soon they all began to assemble together and chant Kåñëa's name very loudly, and they moved from one part of the forest to another searching for Him. Actually, Kåñëa is all-pervasive; He is in the sky, and He is in the forest; He is within the heart, and He is always everywhere.

The gopés therefore began to question the trees and plants about Kåñëa. There were various types of big trees and small plants in the forest, and the gopés began to address them. "Dear banyan tree, have you seen the son of Mahäräja Nanda passing this way, laughing and playing on His flute? He has stolen our hearts and has gone away. If you have seen Him, kindly inform us which way He has gone. Dear açoka tree, dear näga flower tree and campaka flower tree, have you seen the younger brother of Balaräma pass this way? He has disappeared because of our pride." The gopés were aware of the reason for Kåñëa's sudden disappearance. They could understand that when they were enjoying Kåñëa, they thought themselves to be the most fortunate women within the universe, and since they were feeling proud, Kåñëa disappeared immediately just to curb their pride. Kåñëa does not like His devotees to be proud of their service to Him. He accepts everyone's service, but He does not like one devotee to be prouder than others. If sometimes there are such feelings, Kåñëa ends them by changing His attitude toward the devotee.

The gopés then began to address the tulasé plants: "Dear tulasé, you are much beloved by Lord Kåñëa because your leaves are always at His lotus feet. Dear mälaté flower, dear mallikä flower, dear jasmine flower, all of you must have been touched by Kåñëa while He was passing this way after giving us transcendental enjoyment. Have you seen Mädhava passing this way? O mango trees, O trees of jack fruit, O pear trees and äsana trees! O blackberries and bael trees and trees of kadamba flower—you are all very pious trees to be living on the bank of Yamunä. Kåñëa must have passed through this way. Will you kindly let us know which way He has gone?

The gopés then looked upon the ground they were traversing and began to address the earth, "Dear earthly planet, we do not know how many penances and austerities you have undergone to be now living with the footprints of Lord Kåñëa upon you. You are very jolly; the hairs on your body are these jubilant trees and plants. Lord Kåñëa must have been very much pleased with you, otherwise how could He have embraced you in the form of Varäha the boar? When you were submerged in water, He delivered you, taking the whole weight of your existence on His tusks."

After addressing the innumerable trees and plants, they turned their faces toward the beautiful deer who were looking on them very pleasingly. "It appears," they addressed the deer, "that Kåñëa, who is the Supreme Näräyaëa Himself, must have passed through this way along with His companion, Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune. Otherwise, how is it possible that the aroma of His garland, which is smeared with the red kuìkuma from the breast of the goddess of fortune, can be perceived in the breeze blowing here? It appears that they must have passed through here and touched your bodies, and thus you are feeling so pleasant and are looking toward us with sympathy. Will you kindly, therefore, inform us which way Kåñëa has gone? Kåñëa is the well-wisher of Våndävana. He is as kind to you as to us; therefore after leaving us, He must have been present in your company. O fortunate trees, we are thinking of Kåñëa, the younger brother of Balaräma. While passing through here, with one hand resting on the shoulder of the goddess of fortune and the other hand whirling a lotus flower, He must have been very pleased to accept your obeisances, and He must have glanced at you with great pleasure.

Some of the gopés then began to address their other gopé friends, "Dear friends, why don't you question these creepers who are so jubilantly embracing the big trees as if the trees were their husbands? It appears that the flowers of the creepers must have been touched by the nails of Kåñëa. Otherwise, how could they feel so jubilant?"

After searching for Kåñëa here and there, when the gopés became fatigued, they began to talk like madwomen. They could only satisfy themselves by imitating the different pastimes of Kåñëa. One of them imitated the demon, Pütanä, and one of them imitated Kåñëa and sucked her breast. One gopé imitated a hand-driven cart, and another gopé lay down beneath the cart and began to throw up her legs, touching the wheels of the cart, as Kåñëa did to kill the demon Çakaöäsura. They imitated child Kåñëa, lying down on the ground, and one gopé became the demon Tåëävarta and carried the small child Kåñëa by force into the sky; and one of the gopés began to imitate Kåñëa while He was attempting to walk, ringing His ankle bells. Two gopés imitated Kåñëa and Balaräma, and many others imitated Their cowherd boy friends. One gopé assumed the form of Bakäsura, and another forced her to fall down as the demon Bakäsura did when he was killed; similarly, another gopé defeated Vatsäsura. Just as Kåñëa used to call His cows by their different names, so the gopés imitated Him, calling the cows by their respective names. One of the gopés began to play on a flute, and another praised her the way Kåñëa's boy friends praised Him while He played on His flute. One of the gopés took another gopé on her shoulders, just as Kåñëa used to take His boy friends. Absorbed in thoughts of Kåñëa, the gopé who was carrying her friend began to boast that she was Kåñëa herself: "All of you just see my movement!" One of the gopés raised her hand with her covering garments and said, "Now don't be afraid of torrents of rain and severe hurricanes. I'll save you!" In this way she imitated the lifting of Govardhana Hill. One gopé forcibly put her feet on the head of another gopé and said, "You rascal Käliya! I shall punish you severely. You must leave this place. I have descended on this earth to punish all kinds of miscreants!" Another gopé told her friends, "Just see! The flames of the forest fire are coming to devour us. Please close your eyes, and I shall immediately save you from this imminent danger."

In this way all the gopés were madly feeling the absence of Kåñëa. They enquired for Him from the trees and plants. In some places they found the imprints of the marks on the sole of His feet—namely the flag, the lotus flower, the trident, the thunderbolt, etc. After seeing those footprints, they exclaimed, "O here is the impression of the marks on the sole of Kåñëa. All the marks, such as the flag, the lotus flower, the trident and the thunderbolt, are distinctly visible here." They began to follow the footprints, and shortly they saw another set of footprints beside them, and immediately they became very sorry. "Dear friends, just see! Whose are these other footprints? They are beside the footprints of the son of Mahäräja Nanda. It is certainly Kåñëa passing through, resting His hand on some other gopé, exactly as an elephant goes side by side with his beloved mate. We must, therefore, understand that this particular gopé served Kåñëa with greater affectionate love than ourselves. Because of this, although He has left us, He could not leave Her company. He has taken Her along with Him. Dear friends, just imagine how the dust of this place is transcendentally glorious. The dust of the lotus feet of Kåñëa is worshiped even by Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva, and the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé. But at the same time, we are very sorry that this particular gopé has gone along with Kåñëa, for She is sharing the nectar of Kåñëa's kisses and leaving us aside to lament. O friends, just see! At this particular spot we do not see the footprints of that gopé. It appears that because there were some pin-pricks from the dried grass, Kåñëa took Rädhäräëé on His shoulder. O, She is so dear to Him! Kåñëa must have picked some flowers in this spot to satisfy Rädhäräëé, because here, where He stood erect to get the flowers from the high branches of the tree, we find only half the impression of His feet. Dear friends, just see how Kåñëa must have sat down here with Rädhäräëé and tried to set flowers in Her hair. You can be certain that both of Them sat together here. Kåñëa is self-sufficient; He has nothing to enjoy from any other source, yet just to satisfy His devotee He has treated Rädhäräëé exactly as a lusty boy treats his girl friend. Kåñëa is so kind that He always tolerates the disturbances created by His girl friends."

In this way, all the gopés began to point out the faults of the particular gopé who had been taken alone by Kåñëa. They began to say that the chief gopé, Rädhäräëé, who was taken alone by Kåñëa, must be very proud of Her position, thinking Herself the greatest of the gopés. "Yet how could Kåñëa take Her away alone, leaving all of us aside, unless She be extraordinarily qualified and beautiful? She must have taken Kåñëa in the deep forest and told Him, 'My dear Kåñëa, I am now very tired. I cannot go any further. Please carry Me wherever You like.' When Kåñëa was spoken to in this way, He might have told Rädhäräëé, 'All right, better get on My shoulder.' But immediately Kåñëa must have disappeared, and now Rädhäräëé must be lamenting for Him, 'My dear lover, My dearest, You are so fine and so powerful. Where have You gone? I am nothing but Your most obedient maidservant. I am very much aggrieved. Please come and be with Me again.' Kåñëa, however, is not coming to Her. He must be watching Her from a distant place and enjoying Her sorrow."

All the gopés then went further and further into the forest, searching out Kåñëa, but when they learned that actually Rädhäräëé was left alone by Kåñëa, they became very sorry. This is the test of Kåñëa consciousness. In the beginning they were a little envious that Kåñëa had taken Rädhäräëé alone, leaving aside all other gopés, but as soon as they knew that Kåñëa had also left Rädhäräëé and that She was alone lamenting for Him, they became more sympathetic to Her. The gopés found Rädhäräëé and heard everything from Her, about how She misbehaved with Kåñëa and how She was proud and was insulted for Her pride. After hearing all this, they became actually very sympathetic. Then all the gopés, including Rädhäräëé, began to proceed further into the forest until they could no longer see the moonlight.

When they saw that it was getting gradually darker, they stopped. Their mind and intelligence became absorbed in the thoughts of Kåñëa; they all imitated the activities of Kåñëa and His speeches. Due to their heart and soul being completely given to Kåñëa, they began to chant His glories, completely forgetting their family interests. In this way, all the gopés assembled together on the bank of Yamunä, and expecting that Kåñëa must return to them, they simply engaged in the chanting of the glories of Çré Kåñëa—Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare, Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirtieth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kåñëa's Hiding from the Gopés."

KB 1970-1-31 / Songs by the Gopés

31 / Songs by the Gopés

One gopé said, "My dear Kåñëa, ever since You took Your birth in this land of Vrajabhümi, everything appears to be glorious. The land of Våndävana has become glorious, and it is as if the goddess of fortune is personally always existing here. But it is only we who are very unhappy, because we are searching for You, but cannot see You with our greatest effort. Our life is completely dependent upon You; therefore we request that You again come to us."

Another gopé said, "My dear Kåñëa, You are the life and soul even of the lotus flower that grows on the water of lakes made transparent by the clear rains of autumn. Although the lotus flowers are so beautiful, without Your glance they fade away. Similarly, without You, we are also dying. Actually, we are neither Your wives nor slaves. You never spent any money for us, yet we are simply attracted by Your glance. Now, if we die without receiving Your glance, You'll be responsible for our deaths. Certainly the killing of women is a great sin, and if You do not come to see us and we die, You will suffer the reactions of sin. So please come see us. Do not think that one can be killed only by certain weapons. We are being killed by Your absence. You should consider how You are responsible for killing women. We are always grateful to You because You have protected us many times: from the poisonous water of Yamunä, from the serpent Käliya, from Bakäsura, from the anger of Indra and his torrents of rain, from forest fire and so many other incidents. You are the greatest and most powerful of all. It is wonderful for You to protect us from so many dangers, but we are surprised that You are neglecting us at this moment. Dear Kåñëa, dear friend, we know very well that You are not actually the son of mother Yaçodä or the cowherd man Nanda Mahäräja. You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the Supersoul of all living entities. You have, out of Your own causeless mercy, appeared in this world, requested by Lord Brahmä for the protection of the world. It is by Your kindness only that You have appeared in the dynasty of Yadu. O best in the dynasty of Yadu, if anyone afraid of this materialistic way of life takes shelter at Your lotus feet, You never deny him protection. Your movements are sweet, and You are independent, touching the goddess of fortune with one hand and in the other bearing a lotus flower. That is Your extraordinary feature. Please, therefore, come before us and bless us with the lotus flower in Your hand.

"Dear Kåñëa, You are the killer of all the fears of the inhabitants of Våndävana. You are the supremely powerful hero, and we know that You can kill the unnecessary pride of Your devotee as well as the pride of women like us simply by Your beautiful smile. We are simply Your maidservants and slaves; please, therefore, accept us by showing us Your lotus-like beautiful face.

"Dear Kåñëa, actually we have become very lusty, having been touched by Your lotus feet. Your lotus feet certainly kill all kinds of sinful activities of devotees who have taken shelter there. You are so kind that even the ordinary animals take shelter under Your lotus feet. Your lotus feet are also the residence of the goddess of fortune, yet You dance on the head of the Käliya serpent with them. Now we are requesting You to kindly place Your lotus feet on our breasts and pacify our lusty desires to touch You.

"O Lord, Your attractive eyes, like the lotus, are so nice and pleasing. Your sweet words are so fascinating that they please even the greatest scholars, who also become attracted to You. We are also attracted by Your speaking and by the beauty of Your face and eyes. Please, therefore, satisfy us by Your nectarean kisses. Dear Lord, words spoken by You or words describing Your activities are full of nectar, and simply by speaking or hearing Your words one can be saved from the blazing fire of material existence. Great demigods like Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva are always engaged in chanting the glories of Your words. They do so to eradicate the sinful activities of all living entities in the material world. If one simply tries to hear Your transcendental words, he can very quickly be elevated to the platform of pious activities. For the Vaiñëavas, Your words give transcendental pleasure, and saintly persons who are engaged in distributing Your transcendental message all over the world are first-class charitable persons." (This is confirmed by Rüpa Gosvämé also when he addressed Lord Caitanya as the most munificent incarnation because Lord Caitanya distributed the words of Kåñëa and love of Kåñëa free of charge all over the world.)

"Dear Kåñëa," the gopés continued, "You are very cunning. You can imagine how much we are distressed simply by remembering Your cunning smile, Your pleasing glance, Your walking with us in the forest of Våndävana, and Your auspicious meditations. Your talks with us in lonely places were heart-warming. Now we are all aggrieved to remember Your behavior. Please save us. Dear Kåñëa, certainly You know how much we are saddened when You go out of Våndävana village to tend the cows in the forest. How we are afflicted simply to think that Your soft lotus feet are being pricked by the dry grass and the tiny stones in the forest! We are so attached to You that we always think simply of Your lotus feet.

"O Kåñëa, when You return from the pasturing ground with the animals, we see Your face covered by Your curly hair and dusted by the hoof-dust of the cows. We see Your mildly smiling face, and our desire to enjoy You increases. O dear Kåñëa, You are the supreme lover, and You always give shelter to surrendered souls. You fulfill everyone's desire; Your lotus feet are even worshiped by Lord Brahmä, the creator of the universe. To whomever worships Your lotus feet, You without a doubt always bestow Your benedictions. So kindly be pleased with us and keep Your lotus feet on our breasts and thus relieve our present distresses. Dear Kåñëa, we are seeking Your kisses which You offer even to Your flute. The vibration of Your flute enchants the whole world and our hearts also. Kindly, therefore, return and kiss us with Your mouth of nectar."

When Lord Kåñëa finally reappeared and assembled with the gopés, He looked very beautiful, just befitting a person with all kinds of opulences. In the Brahma-saàhitä [5.37], it is stated, änanda-cin-maya-rasa-pratibhävitäbhiù: Kåñëa alone is not particularly beautiful, but when His energy—especially His pleasure energy, represented by Rädhäräëé—expands, He looks very magnificent. The Mäyävada conception of the perfection of the Absolute Truth without potency is due to insufficient knowledge. Actually, outside the exhibition of His different potencies, the Absolute Truth is not complete. Änanda-cin-maya-rasa means that His body is a transcendental form of eternal bliss and knowledge. Kåñëa is always surrounded by different potencies, and therefore He is perfect and beautiful. We understand from Brahma-saàhitä and Skanda Puräëa that Kåñëa is always surrounded by many thousands of goddesses of fortune. The gopés are all goddesses of fortune, and Kåñëa took them hand in hand on the bank of the Yamunä.

It is said in the Skanda Puräëa that out of many thousands of gopés, 16,000 are predominant; out of those 16,000 gopés, 108 gopés are especially prominent; and out of 108 gopés, eight gopés are still more prominent; out of eight gopés, Rädhäräëé and Candrävalé are prominent; and out of these two gopés, Rädhäräëé is the most prominent.

When Kåñëa entered the forest on the bank of the Yamunä, the moonlight dissipated the surrounding darkness. Due to the season, flowers like the kunda and kadamba were blooming, and a gentle breeze was carrying their aroma. Due to the aroma, the bees were also flying in the breeze, thinking that the aroma was honey. The gopés made a seat for Kåñëa by leveling the soft sand and placing cloths over it.

The gopés who were gathered there were mostly all followers of the Vedas. In their previous births, during Lord Rämacandra's advent, they were Vedic scholars who desired the association of Lord Rämacandra in conjugal love. Rämacandra gave them the benediction that they would be present for the advent of Lord Kåñëa, and He would fulfill their desires. During Kåñëa's advent, the Vedic scholars took birth in the shape of the gopés in Våndävana; as young gopés, they got the association of Kåñëa in fulfillment of their previous births' desire. The ultimate goal of their perfect desire was attained, and they were so joyous that they had nothing further to desire. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [8.15]: if one attains the Supreme Personality of Godhead, then he has no desire for anything. When the gopés had Kåñëa in their company, not only all their grief, but their lamenting in the absence of Kåñëa was relieved. They felt they had no desire to be fulfilled. Fully satisfied in the company of Kåñëa, they spread their cloths on the ground. These garments were made of fine linen and smeared with the red kuìkuma which decorated their breasts. With great care they spread a sitting place for Kåñëa. Kåñëa was their life and soul, and they created a very comfortable seat for Him.

Sitting on the seat amongst the gopés, Kåñëa became more beautiful. Great yogés like Lord Çiva, Lord Brahmä or even Lord Çeña and others always try to fix their attention upon Kåñëa in their heart, but here the gopés actually saw Kåñëa seated before them on their cloths. In the society of the gopés, Kåñëa looked very beautiful. They were the most beautiful damsels within the three worlds, and they assembled together around Kåñëa.

It may be asked herein how Kåñëa seated Himself beside so many gopés and yet sat alone. There is a significant word in this verse: éçvara. As it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, éçvaraù sarva-bhütänam. Éçvara refers to the Supreme Lord as the Supersoul seated in everyone's heart. Kåñëa also manifested this potency of expansion as Paramätmä in this gathering with the gopés. Kåñëa was sitting by the side of each gopé, unseen by the others. Kåñëa was so kind to the gopés that instead of sitting in their hearts to be appreciated in yogic meditation, He seated Himself by their sides. By seating Himself outside, He showed special favor to the gopés, who were the selected beauties of all creation. Having gotten their most beloved Lord, the gopés began to please Him by moving their eyebrows and smiling and also by suppressing their anger. Some of them took His lotus feet in their laps and began to massage Him. And while smiling, they confidentially expressed their suppressed anger and said, "Dear Kåñëa, we are ordinary women of Våndävana, and we do not know much about Vedic knowledge—what is right and what is wrong. We therefore put a question to You, and, since You are very learned, You can answer it properly. In dealing between lovers, we find that there are three classes of men. One class simply receives, another class reciprocates favorably, even if the lover is very contrary, and the third class neither acts contrary nor answers favorably in dealings of love. So out of these three classes, which do You prefer, or which do You call honest?"

In answer, Kåñëa said, "My dear friends, persons who simply reciprocate the loving dealings of the other party are just like merchants. They give in loving affairs as much as they get from the other party. Practically there is no question of love. It is simply business dealing, and it is self-interested or self-centered. Better the second class of men, who love in spite of the opposite party's contrariness; even those without a tinge of loving affairs are better than the merchants. Sincere love can be seen when the father and mother love their children in spite of their children's neglect. The third class neither reciprocates nor neglects. They can be further divided into two classes. One is the self-satisfied, who do not require anyone's love. They are called ätmäräma, which means they are absorbed in the thought of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and so do not care whether one loves them or not. But another class are ungrateful men. They are called callous. The men in this group revolt against superior persons. For instance, a son, in spite of receiving all kinds of things from loving parents, may be callous and not reciprocate. Those in this class are generally known as gurudruha, which means they receive favors from the parents or the spiritual master and yet neglect them."

Kåñëa indirectly answered the questions of the gopés, even those questions which implied that Kåñëa did not properly receive their dealings. In answer, Kåñëa said that He, as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is self-satisfied. He does not require anyone's love, but at the same time He said that He is not ungrateful.

"My dear friends," Kåñëa continued, "you might be aggrieved by My words and acts, but you must know that sometimes I do not reciprocate my devotees' dealings with Me. It appears that my devotees are very much attached to Me, but sometimes I do not reciprocate their feelings properly in order to increase their love for Me more and more. If I can very easily be approached by them, they might think, 'Kåñëa is so easily available.' So sometimes I do not respond. If a person has no money but after some time accumulates some wealth and then loses it, he will think of the lost property twenty-four hours a day. Similarly, in order to increase the love of My devotees, sometimes I appear to be lost to them, and instead of forgetting Me, they feel their loving sentiments for Me increase. My dear friends, do not think for a moment that I have been dealing with You just like ordinary devotees. I know what you are. You have forsaken all kinds of social and religious obligations; you have given up all connection with your parents. Without caring for social convention and religious obligations, you have come to Me and loved Me, and I am so much obliged to you that I cannot treat you as ordinary devotees. Do not think that I was away from you. I was near to you. I was simply seeing how much you were anxious for Me in My absence. So please do not try to find fault in Me. Because you consider Me so dear to you, kindly excuse Me if I have done anything wrong. I cannot repay your continual love for Me, even throughout the lifetimes of the demigods in the heavenly planets. It is impossible to repay you or show gratitude for your love; therefore please be satisfied by your own pious activities. You have displayed exemplary attraction for Me, overcoming the greatest difficulties arising from family connections. Please be satisfied with your highly exemplary character, for it is not possible for Me to repay your debt."

The exemplary character of devotional service manifested by the devotees of Våndävana is the purest type of devotion. It is enjoined in authoritative çästra that devotional service must be ahaituka and apratihata. This means that devotional service to Kåñëa cannot be checked by political or religious convention. The stage of devotional service is always transcendental. The gopés particularly showed pure devotional service towards Kåñëa, so much so that Kåñëa Himself remained indebted to them. Lord Caitanya thus said that the devotional service manifested by the gopés in Våndävana excelled all other methods of approaching the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-first Chapter of Kåñëa, "Songs by the Gopés."

KB 1970-1-32 / Description of the Räsa Dance

32 / Description of the Räsa Dance

Thus hearing the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, speaking to pacify them, the gopés became very much pleased. And not only by hearing His words, but also by touching the hands and legs of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, they became completely relieved from the great suffering of separation. After this, the Supreme Personality of Godhead began His räsa dance. When one dances in the midst of many girls, it is called a räsa dance. So Kåñëa began to dance among the most beautiful and fortunate girls within the three worlds. The gopés of Våndävana, who were so attracted to Him, danced with Kåñëa, hand in hand.

Kåñëa's räsa dance should never be compared with any kind of material dance, such as a ball dance or a society dance. The räsa dance is a completely spiritual performance. In order to establish this fact, Kåñëa, the supreme mystic, expanded Himself in many forms and stood beside each gopé. Placing His hands on the shoulders of the gopés on both sides of Him, He began to dance in their midst. The mystic expansions of Kåñëa were not perceived by the gopés because Kåñëa appeared alone to each of them. Each gopé thought that Kåñëa was dancing with her alone. Above that wonderful dance flew many airplanes carrying the denizens of the heavenly planets, who were very anxious to see the wonderful dance of Kåñëa with the gopés. The Gandharvas and Kinnaras began to sing, and, accompanied by their respective wives, all the Gandharvas began to shower flowers on the dancers.

As the gopés and Kåñëa danced together, a very blissful musical sound was produced from the tinkling of their bells, ornaments and bangles. It appeared that Kåñëa was a greenish sapphire locket in the midst of a golden necklace decorated with valuable stones. While Kåñëa and the gopés danced they displayed extraordinary bodily features. The movements of their legs, their placing their hands on one another, the movements of their eyebrows, their smiling, the movements of the breasts of the gopés and their clothes, their earrings, their cheeks, their hair with flowers—as they sang and danced these combined together to appear like clouds, thunder, snow and lightning. Kåñëa's bodily features appeared just like a group of clouds, their songs were like thunder, the beauty of the gopés appeared to be just like lightning in the sky, and the drops of perspiration visible on their faces appeared like falling snow. In this way, both the gopés and Kåñëa fully engaged in dancing.

The necks of the gopés became tinted with red due to their desire to enjoy Kåñëa more and more. To satisfy them, Kåñëa began to clap His hands in time with their singing. Actually the whole world is full of Kåñëa's singing, but it is appreciated in different ways by different kinds of living entities. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä: ye yathä mäà prapadyante. Kåñëa is dancing, and every living entity is also dancing, but there is a difference in the dancing in the spiritual world and in the material world. This is expressed by the author of Caitanya-caritämåta, who says that the master dancer is Kåñëa and everyone is His servant. Everyone is trying to imitate Kåñëa's dancing. Those who are actually in Kåñëa consciousness respond rightly to the dancing of Kåñëa: they do not try to dance independently. But those in the material world try to imitate Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The living entities are dancing under the direction of Kåñëa's mäyä and are thinking that they are equal to Kåñëa. But this is not a fact. In Kåñëa consciousness, this misconception is absent, for a person in Kåñëa consciousness knows that Kåñëa is the supreme master and everyone is His servant. One has to dance to please Kåñëa, not to imitate or to become equal to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The gopés wanted to please Kåñëa, and therefore as Kåñëa sang, they responded and encouraged Him by saying, "Well done, well done." Sometimes they presented beautiful music for His pleasure, and He responded by praising their singing.

When some of the gopés became very tired from dancing and moving their bodies, they placed their hands on the shoulders of Çré Kåñëa. Then their hair loosened and flowers fell to the ground. When they placed their hands on Kåñëa's shoulder, they became overwhelmed by the fragrance of His body which emanated from the lotus, other aromatic flowers, and the pulp of sandalwood. They became filled with attraction for Him, and they began to kiss one another. Some gopés touched Kåñëa cheek to cheek, and Kåñëa began to offer them chewed betel nuts from His mouth, which they exchanged with great pleasure by kissing. And by accepting those betel nuts, the gopés spiritually advanced.

The gopés became tired after long singing and dancing. Kåñëa was dancing beside them, and to alleviate their fatigue they took Çré Kåñëa's hand and placed it on their raised breasts. Kåñëa's hand, as well as the breasts of the gopés, are eternally auspicious; therefore when they combined, both of them became spiritually enhanced. The gopés so enjoyed the company of Kåñëa, the husband of the goddess of fortune, that they forgot that they had any other husband in the world, and upon being embraced by the arms of Kåñëa and dancing and singing with Him, they forgot everything. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam thus describes the beauty of the gopés while they were räsa dancing with Kåñëa. There were lotus flowers over both their ears, and their faces were decorated with sandalwood pulp. They wore tilaka, and there were drops of sweat on their smiling mouths. From their feet came the tinkling sound of ankle bells as well as bangles. The flowers within their hair were falling to the lotus feet of Kåñëa, and He was very satisfied.

As stated in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.37], all these gopés are expansions of Kåñëa's pleasure potency. Touching their bodies with His hands and looking at their pleasing eyes, Kåñëa enjoyed the gopés exactly as a child enjoys playing with the reflection of his body in a mirror. When Kåñëa touched the different parts of their bodies, the gopés felt surcharged with spiritual energy. They could not adjust their loosened clothes, although they tried to keep them properly. Their hair and garments became scattered, and their ornaments loosened as they forgot themselves in company with Kåñëa.

While Kåñëa was enjoying the company of the gopés in the räsa dance, the astonished demigods and their wives gathered in the sky. The moon, being afflicted with a sort of lust, began to watch the dance and became stunned with wonder. The gopés had prayed to the goddess Kätyäyané to have Kåñëa as their husband. Now Kåñëa was fulfilling their desire by expanding Himself in as many forms as there were gopés and enjoying them exactly as a husband.

Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé has remarked that Kåñëa is self-sufficient—He is ätmäräma. He doesn't need anyone else for His satisfaction. Because the gopés wanted Kåñëa as their husband, He fulfilled their desire. When Kåñëa saw that the gopés were tired from dancing with Him, He immediately began to smear His hands over their faces so that their fatigue would be satiated. In order to reciprocate the kind hospitality of Kåñëa, the gopés began to look at Him lovingly. They were overjoyed by the auspicious touch of the hand of Kåñëa. Their smiling cheeks shone with beauty, and they began to sing the glories of Kåñëa with transcendental pleasure. As pure devotees, the more the gopés enjoyed Kåñëa's company, the more they became enlightened with His glories, and thus they reciprocated with Him. They wanted to satisfy Kåñëa by glorifying His transcendental pastimes. Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the master of all masters, and the gopés wanted to worship Him for His unusual exhibition of mercy upon them.

Both the gopés and Kåñëa entered the water of the Yamunä just to relieve their fatigue from the räsa dance. The lily flower garlands around the necks of the gopés were strewn to pieces due to their embracing the body of Kåñëa, and the flowers were reddish from being smeared with the kuìkuma on their breasts. The bumblebees were humming about in order to get honey from the flowers. Kåñëa and the gopés entered the water of Yamunä just as an elephant enters a water tank with his many female companions. Both the gopés and Kåñëa forgot their real identity, playing in the water, enjoying each others' company and relieving the fatigue of räsa dancing. The gopés began to splash water on the body of Kåñëa, all the while smiling, and Kåñëa enjoyed this. As Kåñëa was taking pleasure in the joking words and splashing water, the demigods in the heavenly planets began to shower flowers. The demigods thus praised the super-excellent räsa dance of Kåñëa, the supreme enjoyer, and His pastimes with the gopés in the water of Yamunä.

After this, Lord Kåñëa and the gopés came out of the water and began to stroll along the bank of the Yamunä, where a nice breeze was blowing, carrying the aroma of different kinds of flowers over the water and land. While strolling on the bank of the Yamunä, Kåñëa recited various kinds of poetry. He thus enjoyed the company of the gopés in the soothing moonlight of autumn.

Sex desire is especially excited in the autumn season, but the wonderful thing about Kåñëa's association with the gopés is that there was no question of sex desire. It was, as clearly stated in the Bhägavata description by Çukadeva Gosvämé, avaruddha-saurataù, namely the sex impulse was completely controlled. There is a distinction between Lord Kåñëa's dancing with the gopés and the ordinary dancing of living entities within the material world. In order to clear up further misconceptions about the räsa dance and the affairs of Kåñëa and the gopés, Mahäräja Parékñit, the hearer of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, told Çukadeva Gosvämé, "Kåñëa appeared on the earth to establish the regulative principles of religion and to curb the predominance of irreligion. But the behavior of Kåñëa and the gopés might encourage irreligious principles in the material world. I am simply surprised that He would act in such a way, enjoying the company of others' wives in the dead of night." This statement of Mahäräja Parékñit's was very much appreciated by Çukadeva Gosvämé. The answer anticipates the abominable acts of the Mäyävädé impersonalists who place themselves in the position of Kåñëa and enjoy the company of young girls and women.

The basic Vedic injunctions never allow a person to enjoy sex with any woman except one's own wife. Kåñëa's appreciation of the gopés appeared to be distinctly in violation of these rules. Mahäräja Parékñit understood the total situation from Çukadeva Gosvämé, yet to further clear the transcendental nature of Kåñëa and the gopés in räsa dance, he expressed his surprise. This is very important in order to check the unrestricted association with women by the prakåta-sahajiyä.

In his statement, Mahäräja Parékñit has used several important words which require clarification. The first word, jugupsitam, means abominable. The first doubt of Mahäräja Parékñit was as follows: Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead who has advented Himself to establish religious principles. Why then did He mix with others' wives in the dead of night and enjoy dancing, embracing and kissing? According to the Vedic injunctions, this is not allowed. Also, when the gopés first came to Him, He gave instructions to them to return to their homes. To call the wives of other persons or young girls and enjoy dancing with them is certainly abominable according to the Vedas. Why should Kåñëa have done this?

Another word used here is äptakäma. Some may take it for granted that Kåñëa was very lusty among young girls, but Parékñit Mahäräja said that this was not possible. He could not be lusty. First of all, from the material calculation He was only eight years old. At that age a boy cannot be lusty. Äptakäma means that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is self-satisfied. Even if He were lusty, He doesn't need to take help from others to satisfy His lusty desires. The next point is that, although not lusty Himself, He might have been induced by the lusty desires of the gopés. But Mahäräja Parékñit then used another word, yadu-pati, which indicates that Kåñëa is the most exalted personality in the dynasty of the Yadus. The kings in the dynasty of Yadu were considered to be the most pious, and their descendants were also like that. Having taken birth in that family, how could Kåñëa have been induced, even by the gopés? It is concluded, therefore, that it was not possible for Kåñëa to do anything abominable. But Mahäräja Parékñit was in doubt as to why Kåñëa acted in that way. What was the real purpose?

Another word Mahäräja Parékñit used when he addressed Çukadeva Gosvämé is suvrata, which means to take a vow to enact pious activities. Çukadeva Gosvämé was an educated brahmacäré, and under the circumstances, it was not possible for him to indulge in sex. This is strictly prohibited for brahmacärés, and what to speak of a brahmacäré like Çukadeva Gosvämé. But because the circumstances of the räsa dance were very suspect, Mahäräja Parékñit inquired for clarification from Çukadeva Gosvämé. Çukadeva Gosvämé immediately replied that transgressions of religious principles by the supreme controller testify to His great power. For example, fire can consume any abominable thing; that is the manifestation of the supremacy of fire. Similarly, the sun can absorb water from a urinal or from stool, and the sun is not polluted; rather, due to the influence of sunshine, the polluted, contaminated place becomes disinfected and sterilized.

One may also argue that since Kåñëa is the supreme authority, His activities should be followed. In answer to this question, Çukadeva Gosvämé has very clearly said that éçvaraëam, or the supreme controller, may sometimes violate His instructions, but this is only possible for the controller Himself, not for the followers. Unusual and uncommon activities by the controller can never by imitated. Çukadeva Gosvämé warned that the conditioned followers, who are not actually in control, should never even imagine imitating the uncommon activities of the controller. A Mäyävädé philosopher may falsely claim to be God or Kåñëa, but he cannot actually act like Kåñëa. He can persuade his followers to falsely imitate räsa dance, but he is unable to lift Govardhana Hill. We have many experiences in the past of Mäyävädé rascals deluding their followers by posing themselves as Kåñëa in order to enjoy räsa-lélä. In many instances they were checked by the government, arrested and punished. In Orissa, Öhäkur Bhaktivinode also punished a so-called incarnation of Viñëu, who was imitating räsa-lélä with young girls. There were many complaints against him. At that time, Bhaktivinode Öhäkur was magistrate, and the government deputed him to deal with that rascal, and he punished him very severely. The räsa-lélä dance cannot be imitated by anyone. Çukadeva Gosvämé warns that one should not even think of imitating it. He specifically mentions that if, out of foolishness, one tries to imitate Kåñëa's räsa dance, he will be killed, just like a person who wants to imitate Lord Çiva's drinking of an ocean of poison. Lord Çiva drank an ocean of poison and kept it within his throat. The poison made his throat turn blue; and therefore Lord Çiva is called Nélakaëöa. But if any ordinary person tries to imitate Lord Çiva by drinking poison or smoking gaïja, he is sure to be vanquished and will die within a very short time. Lord Çré Kåñëa's dealing with the gopés was under special circumstances.

Most of the gopés in their previous lives were great sages, expert in the studies of the Vedas, and when Lord Kåñëa appeared as Lord Rämacandra, they wanted to enjoy with Him. Lord Rämacandra gave them the benediction that their desires would be fulfilled when He would appear as Kåñëa. Therefore the desire of the gopés to enjoy the appearance of Lord Kåñëa was long cherished. So they approached goddess Kätyäyané to have Kåñëa as their husband. There are many other circumstances also which testify to the supreme authority of Kåñëa and show that He is not bound to the rules and regulations of the material world. In special cases, He acts as He likes to favor His devotees. This is only possible for Him, because He is the supreme controller. People in general should follow the instructions of Lord Kåñëa as given in the Bhagavad-gétä and should not even imagine imitating Lord Kåñëa in the räsa dance.

Kåñëa's lifting of Govardhana Hill, His killing great demons like Pütanä and others are all obviously extraordinary activities. Similarly, the räsa dance is also an uncommon activity and cannot be imitated by any ordinary man. An ordinary person engaged in his occupational duty, like Arjuna, should execute his duty for the satisfaction of Kåñëa; that is within his power. Arjuna was a fighter, and Kåñëa wanted him to fight for His satisfaction. Arjuna agreed, although at first he was not willing to fight. Duties are required for ordinary persons. They should not jump up and try to imitate Kåñëa and indulge in räsa-lélä and thus bring about their ruin. One should know with certainty that Kåñëa had no personal interest in whatever He did for the benediction of the gopés. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, na mäà karmäëi limpanti: Kåñëa never enjoys or suffers the result of His activities. Therefore it is not possible for Him to act irreligiously. He is transcendental to all activities and religious principles. He is untouched by the modes of material nature. He is the supreme controller of all living entities, either in human society, in the demigod society in heavenly planets, or in lower forms of life. He is the supreme controller of all living entities and of material nature; therefore, He has nothing to do with religious or irreligious principles.

Çukadeva Gosvämé further concludes that the great sages and devotees, who are washed clean of all conditional life, can move freely even within the contamination of material nature by keeping Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead within their hearts. In this way also they do not become subject to the laws of pleasure and pain in the modes of material nature. How, then, is it possible for Kåñëa, who appears in His own internal potency, to be subjected to the laws of karma?

In the Bhagavad-gétä the Lord clearly says that whenever He appears He does so by His internal potency; He is not forced to accept a body by the laws of karma like an ordinary living entity. Every other living entity is forced to accept a certain type of body by his previous actions. But when Kåñëa appears, He always appears in a body; it is not forced upon Him by the action of His past deeds. His body is a vehicle for His transcendental pleasure which is enacted by His internal potency. He has no obligation to the laws of karma. The Mäyävädé monist must accept a certain type of body, being forced by the laws of nature; therefore, his claim to be one with Kåñëa or God is only theoretical. Such persons who claim to be equal with Kåñëa and indulge in räsa-lélä create a dangerous situation for the people in general. Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is already present as Supersoul within the bodies of the gopés and their husbands. He is the guide of all living entities, as is confirmed in the Kaöha Upaniñad, nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm. The Supersoul directs the individual soul to act, and the Supersoul is the actor and witness of all action.

It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä that Kåñëa is present in everyone's heart, and from Him come all action, remembrance and forgetfulness. He is the original person to be known by Vedic knowledge. He is the author of Vedänta philosophy, and He knows the Vedänta philosophy perfectly well. The so-called Vedäntists and Mäyävädés cannot understand Kåñëa as He is; they simply mislead followers by imitating the actions of Kåñëa in an unauthorized way. Kåñëa, the Supersoul of everyone, is already within the body of everyone; therefore if He sees someone or embraces someone there is no question of propriety.

Some ask that if Kåñëa is self-sufficient, why should He at all manifest pastimes with the gopés which are disturbing to the so-called moralists of the world? The answer is that such activities show special mercy to the fallen, conditioned souls. The gopés are also expansions of His internal energy, but because Kåñëa wanted to exhibit the räsa-lélä, they also appeared as ordinary human beings. In the material world, pleasure is ultimately manifested in the sex attraction between man and woman. The man lives simply to be attracted by women, and the woman lives simply to be attracted by men. That is the basic principle of material life. As soon as these attractions are combined, people become more and more implicated in material existence. In order to show them special favor, Kåñëa exhibited this räsa-lélä dance. It is just to captivate the conditioned soul. Since they are very much attracted by sexology, they can enjoy the same life with Kåñëa and thus become liberated from the material condition. In the Second Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Mahäräja Parékñit also explains that the pastimes and activities of Lord Kåñëa are medicine for the conditioned souls. If they simply hear about Kåñëa they become relieved from the material disease. They are addicted to material enjoyment and are accustomed to reading sex literature, but by hearing these transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa with the gopés, they will be relieved from material contamination.

How they should hear and from whom is also explained by Çukadeva Gosvämé. The difficulty is that the whole world is full of Mäyävädés, and when they become professional reciters of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and when people, without knowing the effect of the Mäyäväda philosophy, hear from such persons, they become confused. Discussion of räsa-lélä among people in general is not recommended because they are affected by the Mäyäväda philosophy, but if one who is advanced explains, and people hear from him, certainly the hearers will be gradually elevated to the position of Kåñëa consciousness and liberated from materially contaminated life.

Another important point is that all the gopés who danced with Kåñëa were not in their material bodies. They danced with Kåñëa in their spiritual bodies. All their husbands thought that their wives were sleeping by their sides. The so-called husbands of the gopés were already enamored by the influence of the external energy of Kåñëa; so by dint of this very energy they could not understand that their wives had gone to dance with Kåñëa. What then is the basis of accusing Kåñëa of dancing with others' wives? The bodies of the gopés, which were their husbands', were lying in bed, but the spiritual parts and parcels of Kåñëa were dancing with Him. Kåñëa is the supreme person, the whole spirit, and He danced with the spiritual bodies of the gopés. There is therefore no reason to accuse Kåñëa in any way.

After the räsa dance was over, the night turned into the brähma-muhürta (the night of Brahmä, a very, very long period, as mentioned in the Bhagavad-gétä [8.17]). The brähma-muhürta takes place about one and a half hours before sunrise. It is recommended that one should rise from bed at that time and, after finishing daily ablutions, take to spiritual activities by performing Maìgala-ärätrika and chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra. This period is very convenient for the execution of spiritual activities. When that auspicious moment arrived, Kåñëa asked the gopés to leave. Although they were not willing to quit His company, they were very obedient and dear to Him. As soon as Kåñëa asked them to go home, they immediately left and returned home. Çukadeva Gosvämé concludes this episode of räsa-lélä by pointing out that if a person hears from the right source of the pastimes of Kåñëa, who is Viñëu Himself, and the gopés, who are expansions of His energy, then he will be relieved from the most dangerous type of disease, namely lust. If one actually hears räsa-lélä, he will become completely freed from the lusty desire of sex life and elevated to the highest level of spiritual understanding. Generally, because they hear from Mäyävädés and they themselves are Mäyävädés, people become more and more implicated in sex life. The conditioned soul should hear the räsa-lélä dance from an authorized spiritual master and be trained by him so that he can understand the whole situation; thus one can be elevated to the highest standard of spiritual life, otherwise one will be implicated. Material lust is a kind of heart disease, and to cure the material heart disease of the conditioned soul, it is recommended that one should hear, but not from the impersonalist rascals. If one hears from the right sources with right understanding, then his situation will be different.

Çukadeva Gosvämé has used the word çraddhänvita for one who is trained in the spiritual life. Çraddhä, or faith, is the beginning. One who has developed his faith in Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Supreme Spirit Soul, can both describe and hear. Çukadeva also uses the word anuçåëuyät. One must hear from disciplic succession. Anu means following, and anu means always. So one must always follow the disciplic succession and not hear from any stray professional reciter, Mäyävädé or ordinary man. Anuçåëuyät means that one must hear from an authorized person who is in the disciplic succession and is always engaged in Kåñëa consciousness. When a person wants to hear in this way, then the effect will be sure. By hearing räsa-lélä, one will be elevated to the highest position of spiritual life.

Çukadeva Gosvämé uses two specific words, bhaktim and paräm. Bhaktim paräm means execution of devotional service above the neophyte stage. Those who are simply attracted to temple worship but do not know the philosophy of bhakti are in the neophyte stage. That sort of bhakti is not the perfectional stage. The perfectional stage of bhakti, or devotional service, is completely free from material contamination. The most dangerous aspect of contamination is lust or sex life. Bhaktim paräm devotional service is so potent that the more one advances in this line, the more he loses his attraction for material life. One who is actually deriving benefit from hearing räsa-lélä dance surely achieves the transcendental position. He surely loses all traces of lust in his heart.

Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur points out that according to Bhagavad-gétä [8.17], the Brahmä day and Brahmä night are periods of solar years expanding to 4,300,000 multiplied by 1,000. According to Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur, the räsa dance was performed during the long period of Brahmä's night, but the gopés could not understand that. In order to fulfill their desire, Kåñëa extended the night to cover such a great period of time. One may ask how this was possible, and Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur reminds us that Kåñëa, although bound by a small rope, could show His mother the whole universe within His mouth. How was this possible? The answer is that He can do anything for the pleasure of His devotees. Similarly, because the gopés wanted to enjoy Kåñëa, they were given the opportunity to associate with Him for a long period. This was done according to His promise. When Kåñëa stole the garments of the gopés while they were taking bath at Cirghat on Yamunä, Kåñëa promised to fulfill their desire in some future night. In one night, therefore, they enjoyed the company of Kåñëa as their beloved husband, but that night was not an ordinary night. It was a night of Brahmä, and lasted millions and millions of years. Everything is possible for Kåñëa, for He is the supreme controller.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-second Chapter of Kåñëa, "Description of the Räsa Dance."

KB 1970-1-33 / Vidyädhara Liberated and the Demon Çaìkhäsura Killed

33 / Vidyädhara Liberated and the Demon Çaìkhäsura Killed

Once upon a time, the cowherd men of Våndävana, headed by Nanda Mahäräja, desired to go to Ambikävana to perform the Çivarätri performance. The räsa-lélä was performed during the autumn, and after that the next big ceremony is Holi or the Dolayäträ ceremony. Between the Dolayäträ ceremony and the räsa-lélä ceremony there is one important ceremony which is called Çivarätri, which is especially observed by the Çaivites, or devotees of Lord Çiva. But sometimes the Vaiñëavas also observe this ceremony because they accept Lord Çiva as the foremost Vaiñëava. But the function of Çivarätri is not observed very regularly by the bhaktas, or devotees of Kåñëa. Under the circumstances, it is stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam that the cowherd men headed by Nanda Mahäräja "once upon a time desired." That means that they were not regularly observing the Çivarätri function, but that once upon a time they wanted to go to Ambikävana out of curiosity. Ambikävana is situated somewhere in the Gujarat province. Ambikävana is said to be situated on the river Sarasvaté, yet we do not find any Sarasvaté River in the Gujarat province; the only river there is Savarmati. In India, all the big places of pilgrimage are situated on nice rivers like the Ganges, Yamunä, Sarasvaté, Narmadä, Godävaré, Käveré, etc. Ambikävana was situated on the bank of Sarasvaté, and all the cowherd men and Nanda Mahäräja went there.

They very devotedly began to worship the deity of Lord Çiva and Ambikä. It is the general practice that wherever there is a temple of Lord Çiva, there must be another temple of Ambikä (or Durgä) because Ambikä is the wife of Lord Çiva and is the most exalted of chaste women. She doesn't live outside the association of her husband. After reaching Ambikävana, the cowherd men of Våndävana first bathed themselves in the River Sarasvaté. If one goes to any place of pilgrimage, his first duty is to take a bath and sometimes to shave his head. That is the first business. After taking bath, they worshiped the Deities and then distributed charity in the holy places.

According to the Vedic system, charity is given to the brähmaëas. It is stated in the Vedic çästras that only the brähmaëas and the sannyäsés can accept charity. The cowherd men from Våndävana gave cows decorated with golden ornaments and beautiful garlands. The brähmaëas are given charity because they are not engaged in any business profession. They are supposed to be engaged in brahminical occupations, as described in the Bhagavad-gétä—namely, they must be very learned and must perform austerity and penances. They must not only themselves be learned, but they must also teach others. Brähmaëas are not meant to be brähmaëas alone; they should create other brähmaëas also. If a man is found who agrees to become a brähmaëa's disciple, he is also given the chance to become a brähmaëa. The brähmaëa is always engaged in the worship of Lord Viñëu. Therefore the brähmaëas are eligible to accept all kinds of charity. But if the brähmaëas receive excess charity, they are to distribute it for the service of Viñëu. In the Vedic scripture, therefore, one is recommended to give in charity to the brähmaëas, and by so doing one pleases Lord Viñëu and all the demigods.

The pilgrims take bath, worship the Deity, and give in charity; they are also recommended to fast one day. They should go to a place of pilgrimage and stay there at least for three days. The first day is spent fasting, and at night they can drink a little water because water does not break the fast.

The cowherd men, headed by Nanda Mahäräja, spent that night on the bank of the Sarasvaté. They fasted all day and drank a little water at night. But while they were taking their rest, a great serpent from the nearby forest appeared before them and hungrily began to swallow up Nanda Mahäräja. Nanda began to cry helplessly, "My dear son, Kåñëa, please come and save me from this danger! This serpent is swallowing me!" When Nanda Mahäräja cried for help, all the cowherd men got up and saw what was happening. They immediately took up burning logs and began to beat the snake to kill it. But in spite of being beaten with burning logs, the serpent was not about to give up swallowing Nanda Mahäräja.

At that time Kåñëa appeared on the scene and touched the serpent with His lotus feet. Immediately upon being touched by the lotus feet of Kåñëa, the serpent shed its reptilian body and appeared as a very beautiful demigod named Vidyädhara. His bodily features were so beautiful that he appeared to be worshipable. There was a luster and effulgence emanating from his body, and he was garlanded with a gold necklace. He offered obeisances to Lord Kåñëa and stood before Him with great humility. Kåñëa then asked the demigod, "You appear to be a very nice demigod and to be favored by the goddess of fortune. How is it that you performed such abominable activities, and how did you get the body of a serpent?" The demigod then began to narrate the story of his previous life.

"My dear Lord," he said, "in my previous life I was named Vidyädhara and was known all over the world for my beauty. Because I was a celebrated personality, I used to travel all over in my airplane. While traveling, I saw a great sage named Äìgirä. He was very ugly, and because I was very proud of my beauty, I laughed at him. Due to this sinful action, I was condemned by the great sage to assume the form of a serpent."

One should note here that before being favored by Kåñëa, a person is always under the modes of material nature, however elevated he may be materially. Vidyädhara was a materially elevated demigod, and he was very beautiful. He also held a great material position and was able to travel all over by airplane. Yet he was condemned to become a serpent in his next life. Any materially elevated person can be condemned to an abominable species of life if he is not careful. It is a misconception that after reaching the human body one is never degraded. Vidyädhara himself states that even though he was a demigod, he was condemned to become a serpent. But because he was touched by the lotus feet of Kåñëa, he immediately came to Kåñëa consciousness. He admitted, however, that in his previous life he was actually sinful. A Kåñëa conscious person knows that he is always the servant of the servant of Kåñëa; he is most insignificant, and whatever good he does is by the grace of Kåñëa and the spiritual master. [Padyävalé 74]

The demigod Vidyädhara continued to speak to Çré Kåñëa. "Because I was very proud of the exquisite beauty of my body," he said, "I derided the ugly features of the great sage Äìgirä. He cursed me for my sin, and I became a snake. Now I consider that this curse by the sage was not at all a curse; it was a great benediction for me. Had he not cursed me, I would not have assumed the body of a serpent and would not have been kicked by Your lotus feet and thus freed from all material contamination."

In material existence, four things are very valuable: to be born in a decent family, to be very rich, to be very learned, and to be very beautiful. These are considered to be material assets. Unfortunately, without Kåñëa consciousness, these material assets sometimes become sources of sin and degradation. Despite Vidyädhara's being a demigod and having a beautiful body, he was condemned to the body of a snake due to pride. A snake is considered to be the most cruel and envious living entity, but those who are human beings and are envious of others are considered to be even more vicious than snakes. The snake can be subdued or controlled by charming mantras and herbs, but a person who is envious cannot be controlled by anyone.

"My dear Lord," Vidyädhara continued, "Now since I think I have become freed from all kinds of sinful activities, I am asking Your permission to return to my abode, the heavenly planet." This request indicates that persons who are attached to fruitive activities, desiring promotion to the comforts of higher planetary systems, cannot achieve their ultimate goal of life without the sanction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is also stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.23] that the less intelligent want to achieve material benefits and therefore worship different kinds of demigods, but they actually get the benediction from the demigods through the permission of Lord Viñëu, or Kåñëa. Demigods have no power to bestow material profit. Even if one is attached to material benediction, he can worship Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead and ask Him. Kåñëa is completely able to give even material benediction. There is a difference, however, in asking material benediction from the demigods and from Kåñëa. Dhruva Mahäräja worshiped the Supreme Personality of Godhead for material benediction, but when he actually achieved the favor of the Supreme Lord and saw Him, he was so satisfied that he refused to accept any material benediction. The intelligent person does not ask favors from or worship the demigods; he directly becomes Kåñëa conscious, and if he has any desire for material benefit, he asks Kåñëa, not the demigods.

Vidyädhara, awaiting permission of Kåñëa to return to the heavenly planets, said, "Now because I am touched by Your lotus feet, I am relieved from all kinds of material pangs. You are the most powerful of all mystics. You are the original Supreme Personality of Godhead. You are the master of all the devotees. You are the provider of the planetary systems, and therefore I am asking Your permission. You may accept me as fully surrendered unto You. I know very well that persons who are constantly engaged in chanting Your holy name attain release from all sinful reactions, and certainly persons who are fortunate enough to be personally touched by Your lotus feet are freed. Therefore I am sure that I am now relieved from the curse of the brähmaëa simply by being touched by Your lotus feet."

In this way, Vidyädhara got permission from Lord Kåñëa to return to his home in the higher planetary system. After receiving this honor, he began to circumambulate the Lord. And after offering his respectful obeisances unto Him, he returned to his heavenly planet. Thus Nanda Mahäräja also became relieved from the imminent danger of being devoured by the snake.

The cowherd men who had come to execute the ritualistic function of worshiping Lord Çiva and Ambikä finished their business and prepared to return to Våndävana. While returning, they recalled the wonderful activities of Kåñëa. By relating the incident of Vidyädhara's deliverance, they became more attached to Kåñëa. They had come to worship Lord Çiva and Ambikä, but they became more and more attached to Kåñëa. Similarly, the gopés also worshiped goddess Kätyäyané to become more and more attached to Kåñëa. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.23] that persons who are attached to worshiping demigods like Lord Brahmä, Çiva, Indra and Candra, for some personal benefit, are less intelligent and have forgotten the real purpose of life. But the cowherd men, inhabitants of Våndävana, were no ordinary men. Whatever they did, they did for Kåñëa. If one worships demigods like Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä to become more attached to Kåñëa, that is approved. But if one goes to the demigods for some personal benefit, that is condemned.

After this incident, on a very pleasant night, both Kåñëa and His elder brother Balaräma, who are inconceivably powerful, went into the forest of Våndävana. They were accompanied by the damsels of Vrajabhümi, and they began to enjoy each other's company. The young damsels of Vraja were very nicely dressed and anointed with pulp of sandalwood and decorated with flowers. The moon was shining in the sky, surrounded by glittering stars, and the breeze was blowing, bearing the aroma of mallikä flowers, and the bumblebees were mad after the aroma. Taking advantage of the pleasing atmosphere, both Kåñëa and Balaräma began to sing very melodiously. The damsels became so absorbed in their rhythmical song that they almost forgot themselves; their hair loosened, their dresses slackened, and their garlands began to fall to the ground.

At that time, while they were so much absorbed, almost in madness, a demon associate of Kuvera (the treasurer of the heavenly planets) appeared on the scene. The demon's name was Çaìkhäsura because on his head there was a valuable jewel resembling a conchshell. Just as the two sons of Kuvera were puffed up over their wealth and opulence and did not care for Närada Muni's presence, this Çaìkhäsura was also puffed up over material opulence. He thought that Kåñëa and Balaräma were two ordinary cowherd boys enjoying the company of many beautiful girls. Generally, in the material world, a person with riches thinks that all beautiful women should be enjoyed by him. Çaìkhäsura also thought that, since he belonged to the rich community of Kuvera, he, not Kåñëa and Balaräma, should enjoy the company of so many beautiful girls. He therefore decided to take charge of them. He appeared before Kåñëa and Balaräma and the damsels of Vraja and began to lead the girls away to the north. He commanded them as if he were their proprietor and husband, despite the presence of Kåñëa and Balaräma. Being forcibly taken away by Çaìkhäsura, the damsels of Vraja began to call the names of Kåñëa and Balaräma for protection. The two brothers immediately began to follow them, taking up big logs in Their hands. "Don't be afraid, don't be afraid," They called to the gopés. "We are coming at once to chastise this demon." Very quickly They reached Çaìkhäsura. Thinking the brothers too powerful, Çaìkhäsura left the company of the gopés and ran for fear of his life. But Kåñëa would not let him go. He entrusted the gopés to the care of Balaräma and followed Çaìkhäsura wherever he fled. Kåñëa wanted to take the valuable jewel resembling a conchshell from the head of the demon. After following him a very short distance, Kåñëa caught him, struck his head with His fist and killed him. He then took the valuable jewel and returned. In the presence of all the damsels of Vraja, He presented the valuable jewel to His elder brother Balaräma.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-third Chapter of Kåñëa, "Vidyädhara Liberated and the Demon Çaìkhäsura Killed."

KB 1970-1-34 / The Gopés' Feelings of Separation

34 / The Gopés' Feelings of Separation

The gopés of Våndävana were so attached to Kåñëa that they were not satisfied simply with the räsa dance at night. They wanted to associate with Him and enjoy His company during the daytime also. When Kåñëa went to the forest with His cowherd boy friends and cows, the gopés did not physically take part, but their hearts went with Him. And because their hearts went, they were able to enjoy His company through strong feelings of separation. To acquire this strong feeling of separation is the teaching of Lord Caitanya and His direct disciplic succession of Gosvämés. When we are not in physical contact with Kåñëa, we can associate with Him like the gopés, through feelings of separation. Kåñëa's transcendental form, qualities, pastimes, and entourage are all identical with Him. There are nine different kinds of devotional service. Devotional service to Kåñëa in feelings of separation elevates the devotee to the highest perfectional level, to the level of the gopés.

It is stated in Çréniväsäcärya's prayer to the six Gosvämés that they left the material opulences of government service and the princely status of life and went to Våndävana, where they lived just like ordinary mendicants, begging from door to door. But they were so much enriched with the gopés' feelings of separation that they enjoyed transcendental pleasure at every moment. Similarly, when Lord Caitanya was at Jagannätha Puré, He was in the role of Rädhäräëé, feeling the separation of Kåñëa. Those who are in the disciplic succession of the Mädhva-Gauòéya-sampradäya should also feel the separation of Kåñëa, worship His transcendental form, and discuss His transcendental teachings, His pastimes, His qualities, His entourage and His associations. The spiritual masters should enrich the devotees to the highest devotional perfection. Feeling constant separation while engaged in the service of the Lord is the perfection of Kåñëa consciousness.

The gopés used to discuss Kåñëa amongst themselves, and their talks were as follows. "My dear friends," one gopé said, "do you know that when Kåñëa lies on the ground He rests on His left elbow, and His head rests on His left hand. He moves His attractive eyebrows while playing His flute with His delicate fingers, and the sound He produces creates such a nice atmosphere that the denizens of the heavenly planets, who travel in space with their wives and beloved, stop their airplanes, for they are stunned by the vibration of the flute. The wives of the demigods who are seated in the planes then become very much ashamed of their singing and musical qualifications. Not only that, but they become afflicted with conjugal love, and their hair and tightened dresses immediately loosen."

Another gopé said, "My dear friends, Kåñëa is so beautiful that the goddess of fortune always remains on His chest, and He is always adorned with a golden necklace. Beautiful Kåñëa plays His flute in order to enliven the hearts of many devotees. He is the only friend of the suffering living entities. When He plays His flute, all the cows and other animals of Våndävana, although engaged in eating, simply take a morsel of food in their mouths and stop chewing. Their ears raise up and they become stunned. They do not appear alive but like painted animals. Kåñëa's flute playing is so attractive that even the animals become enchanted, and what to speak of ourselves."

Another gopé said, "My dear friends, not only living animals, but even inanimate objects like the rivers and lakes of Våndävana also become stunned when Kåñëa passes with peacock feathers on His head and His body smeared with the minerals of Våndävana. With leaves and flowers decorating His body, He looks like some hero. When He plays on His flute and calls the cows with Balaräma, the River Yamunä stops flowing and waits for the air to carry dust from His lotus feet. The River Yamunä is unfortunate like us; it does not get Kåñëa's mercy. The river simply remains stunned, stopping its waves just as we also stop crying out of frustration for Kåñëa."

In the absence of Kåñëa the gopés were constantly shedding tears, but sometimes, when they expected that Kåñëa was coming, they would stop crying. But when they saw that Kåñëa was not coming, then again they would become frustrated and begin to cry. Kåñëa is the original Personality of Godhead, the origin of all Viñëu forms, and the cowherd boys are all demigods. Lord Viñëu is always worshiped and surrounded by different demigods like Lord Çiva, Lord Brahmä, Indra, Candra, and others. When Kåñëa traveled through the Våndävana forest or walked on the Govardhana Hill, He was accompanied by the cowherd boys. While walking, He played His flute, just to call His cows. Just by His association, the trees, plants and other vegetation in the forest immediately became Kåñëa conscious. A Kåñëa conscious person sacrifices everything for Kåñëa. Although trees and plants are not very advanced in consciousness, by the association of Kåñëa and His friends they also become Kåñëa conscious. They then want to deliver everything—whatever they have—their fruits, flowers, and the honey incessantly falling from their branches.

When Kåñëa walked on the bank of the Yamunä, He was seen nicely decorated with tilaka on His head. He was garlanded with different kinds of forest flowers, and His body was smeared by the pulp of sandalwood and tulasé leaves. The bumblebees became mad after the treasure and sweet nectar of the atmosphere. Being pleased by the humming sound of the bees, Kåñëa would play His flute, and together the sounds became so sweet to hear that the aquatics, the cranes, swans and ducks and other birds were charmed. Instead of swimming or flying, they became stunned. They closed their eyes and entered a trance of meditation in worship of Kåñëa.

One gopé said, "My dear friend, Kåñëa and Balaräma are nicely dressed with earrings and pearl necklaces. They enjoy Themselves on the top of Govardhana Hill, and everything becomes absorbed in transcendental pleasure when Kåñëa plays on His flute, charming the whole created manifestation. When He plays, the clouds stop their loud thundering, out of fear of Him. Rather than disturb the vibration of His flute, they respond with mild thunder and so congratulate Kåñëa, their friend."

Kåñëa is accepted as the friend of the cloud because both the cloud and Kåñëa satisfy the people when they are disturbed. When the people are burning due to excessive heat, the cloud satisfies them with rain. Similarly, when people in materialistic life become disturbed by the blazing fire of material pangs, Kåñëa gives them relief. The cloud and Kåñëa, having the same bodily color also, are considered to be friends. Desiring to congratulate its superior friend, the cloud poured not water, but small flowers and covered the head of Kåñëa to protect Him from the scorching sunshine.

One of the gopés told mother Yaçodä, "My dear mother, your son is very expert among the cowherd boys. He knows all the different arts, how to tend the cows and how to play the flute. He composes His own songs, and to sing them He puts His flute to His mouth. When He plays, either in the morning or in the evening, all the demigods, like Lord Çiva, Brahmä, Indra and Candra, bow their heads and listen with great attention. Although they are very learned and expert, they cannot understand the musical arrangements of Kåñëa's flute. They simply listen attentively and try to understand, but become bewildered and nothing more."

Another gopé said, "My dear friend, when Kåñëa returns home with His cows, the footprint of the soles of His feet—with flag, thunderbolt, trident, and lotus flower—relieves the pain the earth feels when the cows traverse it. He walks in a stride which is so attractive, and He carries His flute. Just by looking at Him we become lusty to enjoy His company. At that time, our movements cease. We become just like trees and stand perfectly still. We even forget what we look like."

Kåñëa had many thousands of cows, and they were divided into groups according to their colors. They were also differently named according to color. When He would return from the pasturing ground, He would find all the cows gathered. As Vaiñëavas count 108 beads, which represent the 108 individual gopés, so Kåñëa would also chant 108 different groups of cows.

"When Kåñëa returns, He is garlanded with tulasé leaves," a gopé describes Him to a friend. "He puts His hand on the shoulder of a cowherd boy friend, and begins to blow His transcendental flute. The wives of the black deer become enchanted upon hearing the vibration of His flute, which resembles the vibration of the véëä. The deer come to Kåñëa and become so charmed that they stand still, forgetting their homes and husbands. Like us, who are enchanted by the ocean of the transcendental qualities of Kåñëa, the she-deer become enchanted by the vibration of His flute."

Another gopé told mother Yaçodä, "My dear mother, when your son returns home, He decorates Himself with the buds of the kunda flower, and just to enlighten and gladden His friends, He blows His flute. The breeze blowing from the south pleases the atmosphere because it is fragrant and very cool. Demigods like the Gandharvas and Siddhas take advantage of this atmosphere and offer prayers to Kåñëa by sounding their bugles and drums. Kåñëa is very kind to the inhabitants of Vrajabhümi, Våndävana, and when He returns with His cows and friends, He is remembered as the lifter of Govardhana Hill. Taking advantage of this opportunity, the most exalted demigods like Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva come down to offer their evening prayers, and they accompany the cowherd boys in glorifying the qualities of Kåñëa.

"Kåñëa is compared with the moon, born in the ocean of the womb of Devaké. When He returns in the evening, it appears that He is fatigued, but He still tries to gladden the inhabitants of Våndävana by His auspicious presence. When Kåñëa returns, garlanded with flowers, His face looks beautiful. He walks into Våndävana with a stride just like the elephant and slowly enters His home. Upon His return, the men, women, and cows of Våndävana immediately forget the scorching heat of the day."

Such descriptions of Kåñëa's transcendental pastimes and activities were remembered by the gopés during His absence from Våndävana. They give us some idea of Kåñëa's attraction. Everyone and everything is attracted to Kåñëa—that is the perfect description of Kåñëa's attraction. The example of the gopés is very instructive to persons who are trying to be absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness. One can very easily associate with Kåñëa simply by remembering His transcendental pastimes. Everyone has a tendency to love someone. That Kåñëa should be the object of love is the central point of Kåñëa consciousness. By constantly chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra and remembering the transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa, one can be fully in Kåñëa consciousness and thus make his life sublime and fruitful.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-fourth Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Gopés' Feelings of Separation."

KB 1970-1-35 / Kaàsa Sends Akrüra for Kåñëa

35 / Kaàsa Sends Akrüra for Kåñëa

Våndävana was always absorbed in the thought of Kåñëa. Everyone remembered His pastimes and was constantly merged in the ocean of transcendental bliss. But the material world is so contaminated that even in Våndävana the asuras or demons tried to disturb the peaceful situation.

One demon named Ariñöäsura entered the village like a great bull with a gigantic body and horns, digging up the earth with his hoofs. When the demon entered Våndävana, it appeared that the whole land trembled, as if there were an earthquake. He roared fiercely, and after digging up the earth on the riverside, he entered the village proper. The fearful roaring of the bull was so piercing that some of the pregnant cows and women had miscarriages. Its body was so big, stout and strong that a cloud hovered over its body just as clouds hover over mountains. Ariñöäsura entered Våndävana with such a fearful appearance that just on seeing this great demon, all the men and women were afflicted with great fear, and the cows and other animals fled the village.

The situation became very terrible, and all the inhabitants of Våndävana began to cry, "Kåñëa! Kåñëa, please save us!" Kåñëa also saw that the cows were running away, and He immediately replied, "Don't be afraid. Don't be afraid." He then appeared before Ariñöäsura and said, "You are the lowest of living entities. Why are you frightening the inhabitants of Gokula? What will you gain by this action? If you have come to challenge My authority, then I am prepared to fight you." In this way, Kåñëa challenged the demon, and the demon became very angry by the words of Kåñëa. Kåñëa stood before the bull, resting His hand on the shoulder of a friend. The bull began to proceed towards Kåñëa in anger. Digging the earth with his hoofs, Ariñöäsura lifted his tail, and it appeared that clouds were hovering about the tail. His eyes were reddish and moving in anger. Pointing his horns at Kåñëa, he began to charge Him, just like the thunderbolt of Indra. But Kåñëa immediately caught his horns and tossed him away, just as a gigantic elephant repels a small inimical elephant. Although the demon appeared to be very tired and although he was perspiring, he took courage and got up. Again he charged Kåñëa with great force and anger. While rushing towards Kåñëa, he breathed very heavily. Kåñëa again caught his horns and immediately threw him on the ground, breaking his horns. Kåñëa then began to kick his body, just as one squeezes a wet cloth on the ground. Being thus kicked by Kåñëa, Ariñöäsura rolled over and began to move his legs violently. Bleeding and passing stool and urine, his eyes starting from their sockets, he passed to the kingdom of death.

The demigods in the celestial planets began to shower flowers on Kåñëa for His wonderful achievements. Kåñëa was already the life and soul of the inhabitants of Våndävana, and after killing this demon in the shape of a bull, He became the cynosure of all eyes. With Balaräma, He triumphantly entered Våndävana village, and the inhabitants glorified Him and Balaräma with great jubilation. When a person performs some wonderful feat, his kinsmen and relatives and friends naturally become jubilant.

It was after this incident that the great sage Närada disclosed the secret of Kåñëa. Närada Muni is generally known as devadarçana, which means that he can be seen only by demigods or persons on the same level with the demigods. But Närada visited Kaàsa, who was not at all on the level of the demigods, and yet Kaàsa saw him. Of course Kaàsa also saw Kåñëa, what to speak of Närada Muni, but generally one must have purified eyes to see the Lord and His devotees. Of course, by association with a pure devotee, one can derive an imperceptible benefit, which is called ajïatasukåti. He cannot understand how he is making progress, yet he makes progress by seeing the devotee of the Lord. Närada Muni's mission was to finish things quickly. Kåñëa appeared to kill the demons, and Kaàsa was the chief among them. Närada wanted to expedite things; therefore, he immediately approached Kaàsa with all the real information. "You are to be killed by the eighth son of Vasudeva," Närada told Kaàsa. "That eighth son is Kåñëa. You were misled by Vasudeva into believing that the eighth issue of Vasudeva was a daughter. Actually, the daughter was born of Yaçodä, the wife of Nanda Mahäräja, and Vasudeva exchanged the daughter, so you were misled. Kåñëa is the son of Vasudeva, as is Balaräma. Being afraid of your atrocious nature, Vasudeva has tactfully hidden Them in Våndävana, out of your sight." Närada further informed Kaàsa, "Kåñëa and Balaräma have been living incognito in the care of Nanda Mahäräja. All the asuras, your companions who were sent to Våndävana to kill different children, were all killed by Kåñëa and Balaräma."

As soon as Kaàsa got this information from Närada Muni, he took out his sharpened sword and prepared to kill Vasudeva for his duplicity. But Närada pacified him. "You are not to be killed by Vasudeva," he said. "Why are you so anxious to kill him? Better try to kill Kåñëa and Balaräma." But in order to satisfy his wrath, Kaàsa arrested Vasudeva and his wife and shackled them in iron chains. Acting on the new information, Kaàsa immediately called for the Keçé demon and asked him to go to Våndävana immediately to fetch Balaräma and Kåñëa. In actuality, Kaàsa asked Keçé to go to Våndävana to be killed by Kåñëa and Balaräma and thus get salvation. Then Kaàsa called for the expert elephant trainers, Cäëüra, Muñöika, Çala, Toçala, etc., and he told them, "My dear friends, try to hear me attentively. At Nanda Mahäräja's place in Våndävana there are two brothers, Kåñëa and Balaräma. They are actually two sons of Vasudeva. As you know, I have been destined to be killed by Kåñëa; there is a prophecy to this effect. Now I am requesting you to arrange for a wrestling match. People from different parts of the country will come to see the festival. I will arrange to get those two boys here, and you will try to kill Them in the wrestling arena."

Wrestling matches are still enjoyed by the indigenous people in the northern part of India, and it appears from the statements of Çrémad-Bhägavatam that 5,000 years ago wrestling was popular. Kaàsa planned to arrange such a wrestling competition and to invite people to visit. He also told the trainers of the elephants, "Be sure to bring the elephant named Kuvalayäpéòa and keep him at the gate of the wrestling camp. Try to capture Kåñëa and Balaräma on Their arrival and kill Them."

Kaàsa also advised his friends to arrange to worship Lord Çiva by offering animal sacrifices and performing the sacrifice called Dhanur-yajïa and the sacrifice performed on the fourteenth day of the moon known as Caturdaçé. This date falls three days after Ekädaçé, and it is set aside for the worship of Lord Çiva. One of the plenary portions of Lord Çiva is called Kälabhairava. This form of Lord Çiva is worshiped by the demons who offer skinned animals before him. The process is still current in India in a place called Vaidyanätha-dhäma where the demons offer animal sacrifices to the deity of Kälabhairava. Kaàsa belonged to this demonic group. He was also an expert diplomat, and so he quickly arranged for his demon friends to kill Kåñëa and Balaräma.

He then called for Akrüra, one of the descendants in the family of Yadu in which Kåñëa was born as the son of Vasudeva. When Akrüra came to see Kaàsa, Kaàsa very politely shook hands with him and said, "My dear Akrüra, actually I've no better friend than you in the Bhoja and Yadu dynasties. You are the most munificent person, so as a friend I am begging charity from you. Actually I have taken shelter of you exactly as King Indra takes shelter of Lord Viñëu. I request you to go immediately to Våndävana and find the two boys named Kåñëa and Balaräma. They are sons of Nanda Mahäräja. Take this nice chariot, especially prepared for the boys, and bring Them here immediately. That is my request to you. Now, my plan is to kill these two boys. As soon as They come in the gate, there will be a giant elephant named Kuvalayäpéòa awaiting, and possibly he will be able to kill Them. But if somehow or other They escape, They will next meet the wrestlers and will be killed by them. That is my plan. And after killing these two boys, I shall kill Vasudeva and Nanda, who are supporters of the Våñëi and Bhoja dynasties. I shall also kill my father Ugrasena and his brother Devaka, because they are actually my enemies and are hindrances to my diplomacy and politics. Thus I shall get rid of all my enemies. Jaräsandha is my father-in-law, and I have a great monkey friend named Dvivida. With their help it will be easy to kill all the kings on the surface of the world who support the demigods. This is my plan. In this way I shall be free from all opposition, and it will be very pleasant to rule the world without obstruction. You may know also that Çambara, Narakäsura and Bäëäsura are my intimate friends, and when I begin this war against the kings who support the demigods, they will help me considerably. Surely I shall be rid of all my enemies. Please go immediately to Våndävana and encourage the boys to come here to see the beauty of Mathurä and take pleasure in the wrestling competition."

After hearing this plan of Kaàsa's, Akrüra replied, "My dear King, your plan is very excellently made to counteract the hindrances to your diplomatic activities. But you should maintain some discretion, or your plans will not be fruitful. After all, man proposes, God disposes. We may make very great plans, but unless they are sanctioned by the supreme authority, they will fail. Everyone in this material world knows that the supernatural power is the ultimate disposer of everything. One may make a very great plan with his fertile brain, but he must know that he will become subjected to the fruits, misery and happiness. But I have nothing to say against your proposal. As a friend, I shall carry out your order and bring Kåñëa and Balaräma here, as you desire."

After instructing his friends in various ways, Kaàsa retired, and Akrüra went to Våndävana.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-fifth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kaàsa Sends Akrüra for Kåñëa."

KB 1970-1-36 / Killing the Keçé Demon and Vyomäsura

36 / Killing the Keçé Demon and Vyomäsura

After being instructed by Kaàsa, the demon Keçé assumed the form of a terrible horse. He entered the area of Våndävana, his great mane flying and his hooves digging up the earth. He began to whinny and terrify the whole world. Kåñëa saw that the demon was terrifying all the residents of Våndävana with his whinnying and his tail wheeling in the sky like a big cloud. Kåñëa could understand that the horse was challenging Him to fight. The Lord accepted his challenge and stood before the Keçé demon. As He called him to fight, the horse began to proceed towards Kåñëa, making a horrible sound like a roaring lion. Keçé rushed toward the Lord with great speed and tried to trample Him with his legs, which were strong, forceful, and as hard as stone. Kåñëa, however, immediately caught hold of his legs and thus baffled him. Being somewhat angry, Kåñëa began to move around the horse dextrously. After a few rounds, He threw him a hundred yards away, just as Garuòa throws a big snake. Thrown by Kåñëa, the horse immediately passed out, but after a little while he regained consciousness and with great anger and force rushed toward Kåñëa again, this time with his mouth open. As soon as Keçé reached Him, Kåñëa pushed His left hand within the horse's mouth. The horse felt great pain because the hand of Kåñëa felt to him like a hot iron rod. Immediately his teeth fell out. Kåñëa's hand within the mouth of the horse at once began to inflate, and Keçé's throat choked up. As the great horse began to suffocate, perspiration appeared on his body, and he began to throw his legs hither and thither. As his last breath came, his eyeballs bulged in their sockets, and he passed stool and urine simultaneously. Thus the vital force of his life expired. When the horse was dead, his mouth became loose and Kåñëa could extract His hand without difficulty. He did not feel any surprise that the Keçé demon was killed so easily, but the demigods were amazed, and out of their great appreciation they offered Kåñëa greetings by showering flowers.

After this incident, Närada Muni, the greatest of all devotees, came to see Kåñëa in a solitary place and began to talk with Him. "My dear Lord Kåñëa," he said, "You are the unlimited Supersoul, the supreme controller of all mystic powers, the Lord of the whole universe, the all-pervading Personality of Godhead. You are the resting place of the cosmic manifestation, the master of all the devotees and the Lord of everyone. My dear Lord, as the Supersoul of all living entities, You remain concealed within their hearts exactly as fire remains concealed in every piece of fuel. You are the witness of all the activities of the living entities, and You are the supreme controller within their hearts. You are self-sufficient; before the creation, you existed, and by Your energy You have created the whole material universe. According to Your perfect plan, this material world is created by the interaction of the modes of nature, and by You they are maintained and annihilated. Although You are unaffected by all these activities, You are the supreme controller eternally. My dear Lord, You have advented Yourself on the surface of this world just to kill all the so-called kings who are actually demons. These hobgoblins are cheating people in the dress of the princely order. You have advented Yourself to fulfill Your own statement that You come within this material world just to protect the principles of religion and annihilate unwanted miscreants. My dear Lord, I am therefore sure that the day after tomorrow I shall see demons like Cäëüra, Muñöika and the other wrestlers and elephants, as well as Kaàsa himself, killed by You. And I shall see this with my own eyes. After this, I hope I shall be able to see the killing of other demons like Çaìkha, Yavana, Mura, and Narakäsura. I shall also see how You take away the pärijäta flower from the kingdom of heaven, and how You defeat the king of heaven himself.

"My dear Lord," Närada Muni continued, "I shall then be able to see how You marry princesses, the daughters of chivalrous kings, by paying the price of kñatriya strength." (Whenever a kñatriya wants to marry a very beautiful and qualified princess of a great king, he must fight his competitors and emerge victorious. Then he is given the hand of the princess in charity.)

"I shall also see how You save King Någa from a hellish condition," said Närada Muni. "This You shall enact in Dvärakä. I shall also be able to see how You get Your wife and the Syamantaka jewel and how You save the son of a brähmaëa from death after he has already been transferred to another planet. After this, I will be able to see You kill the Pauëòraka demon and burn to ashes the kingdom of Käçé. I will see how You kill the King of Cedi and Dantavakra in great fights, on behalf of Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira. Besides all this, it will be possible for me to see many other chivalrous activities while You remain in Dvärakä. And all these activities performed by Your grace will be sung by great poets for all time. And at the battle of Kurukñetra You will take part as the chariot driver of Your friend Arjuna, and as the invincible death incarnation, eternal time, You will vanquish all belligerents assembled there. I shall see a large number of military forces killed in that battlefield. My Lord, let me offer my respectful obeisances unto Your lotus feet. You are situated completely in the transcendental position in perfect knowledge and bliss. You are complete in Yourself and are beyond all desires. By exhibiting Your internal potency, You have set up the influence of mäyä. Your unlimited potency cannot even be measured by anyone. My dear Lord, You are the supreme controller. You are under Your own internal potency, and it is simply vain to think that You are dependent on any of Your creations.

"You have taken birth in the Yadu dynasty, or the Våñëi dynasty. Your advent on the surface of the earth in Your original form of eternal blissful knowledge is Your own pastime. You are not dependent on anything but Yourself; therefore I offer my respectful obeisances unto Your lotus feet."

Närada Muni wanted to impress upon people in general that Kåñëa is fully independent. His activities, such as His appearance in the family of Yadu or His friendship with Arjuna, do not necessarily oblige Him to act to enjoy their results. They are all pastimes, and for Him they are all play. But for us they are actual, tangible facts.

After offering his respectful obeisances to Lord Kåñëa, Närada Muni took permission and left. After He had killed the Keçé demon, Kåñëa returned to tending the cows with His friends in the forest as though nothing had happened. Thus Kåñëa is eternally engaged in His transcendental activities in Våndävana with His friends, the cowherd boys and gopés, but sometimes He exhibits the extraordinary prowess of the Supreme Personality of Godhead by killing different types of demons.

Later that morning Kåñëa went to play with His cowherd boy friends on the top of the Govardhana Hill. They were imitating the play of thieves and police. Some of the boys became police constables, and some became thieves, and some took the role of lambs. While they were thus enjoying their childhood pastimes, a demon known by the name of Vyomäsura, "the demon who flies in the sky," appeared on the scene. He was the son of another great demon named Maya. These demons can perform wonderful magic. Vyomäsura took the part of a cowherd boy playing as thief and stole many boys who were playing the parts of lambs. One after another he took away almost all the boys and put them in the caves of the mountain and sealed the mouths of the caves with stones. Kåñëa could understand the trick the demon was playing; therefore He caught hold of him exactly as a lion catches hold of a lamb. The demon tried to expand himself like a hill to escape arrest, but Kåñëa did not allow him to get out of His clutches. He was immediately thrown on the ground with great force and killed, just as an animal is killed in the slaughterhouse. After killing the Vyoma demon, Lord Kåñëa released all His friends from the caves of the mountain. He was then praised by His friends and by the demigods for these wonderful acts. He again returned to Våndävana with His cows and friends.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-sixth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Killing the Keçé Demon and Vyomäsura."

KB 1970-1-37 / Akrüra's Arrival in Våndävana

37 / Akrüra's Arrival in Våndävana

Närada Muni did not mention Kåñëa's killing Vyomäsura, which means that he was killed on the same day as the Keçé demon. The Keçé demon was killed in the early morning, and after that the boys went to tend the cows on Govardhana Hill, and it was there that Vyomäsura was killed. Both demons were killed in the morning. Akrüra was requested by Kaàsa to arrive in Våndävana by evening. After receiving instruction from Kaàsa, Akrüra started the next morning via chariot for Våndävana. Because Akrüra himself was a great devotee of the Lord, while going to Våndävana he began to praise the Lord. Devotees are always absorbed in thoughts of Kåñëa, and Akrüra was constantly thinking of Lord Kåñëa's lotus eyes.

He did not know what sort of pious activities he must have done to gain an opportunity to go see Lord Kåñëa. Akrüra thought that if Kåñëa willed, he would be able to see Him. Akrüra considered himself most fortunate that he was going to see Kåñëa, whom great mystic yogés desire to see. He was confident that on that day all the sinful reactions of his past life would be finished and his fortunate human form of life would be successful. Akrüra also considered that he was very much favored by Kaàsa, who was sending him to bring back Kåñëa and Balaräma and thus enabling him to see the Lord. Akrüra continued to consider that formerly great sages and saintly persons were liberated from the material world simply by seeing the shining nails of the lotus feet of Kåñëa.

"That Supreme Personality of Godhead has now come just like an ordinary human being, and it is my great fortune to be able to see Him face to face," Akrüra thought. He was thrilled with expectations of seeing the very lotus feet which are worshiped by great demigods like Brahmä, Närada, and Lord Çiva, which traverse the ground of Våndävana and which touch the breasts of the gopés covered with tinges of kuìkuma. He thought, "I am so fortunate that I will be able to see those very lotus feet on this day, and certainly I shall be able to see the beautiful face of Kåñëa, which is marked on the forehead and the nose with tilaka. And I shall also see His smile and His curling black hair. I can be sure of this opportunity because I see that today the deer are passing on my right side. Today it will be possible for me to actually see the beauty of the spiritual kingdom of Viñëuloka because Kåñëa is the Supreme Viñëu, and He has advented Himself out of His own good will. He is the reservoir of all beauty; therefore my eyes will be filled today."

Akrüra knew beyond doubt that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Viñëu. Lord Viñëu glances over the material energy, and thus the cosmic manifestation comes into being. And although Lord Viñëu is the creator of this material world, He is free, by His own energy, from the influence of material energy. By His internal potency He can pierce the darkness of material energy. Similarly, Kåñëa the original Viñëu, by expansion of His internal potency, created the inhabitants of Våndävana. In the Brahma-saàhitä [5.37] it is also confirmed that the paraphernalia and the abode of Kåñëa are expansions of His internal potency. The same internal potency is exhibited on earth as Våndävana, where Kåñëa enjoys Himself with His parents and in the company of His friends, the cowherd boys and gopés. By the statement of Akrüra, it is clear that, since Kåñëa is transcendental to the modes of material nature, the inhabitants of Våndävana, who are engaged in loving service of the Lord, are also transcendental.

Akrüra also considered the necessity of the transcendental pastimes of the Lord. He thought that the transcendental activities, instructions, qualities and pastimes of Kåñëa are all for the good fortune of people in general. The people can remain constantly in Kåñëa consciousness by discussing the Lord's transcendental form, qualities, pastimes, and paraphernalia. By doing so, the whole universe can actually live auspiciously and advance peacefully. But without Kåñëa consciousness, civilization is but a decoration for a dead body. A dead body may be decorated very nicely, but without consciousness such decorations are useless. Human society without Kåñëa consciousness is useless and lifeless.

Akrüra thought, "That Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, has now appeared as one of the descendants of the Yadu dynasty. The principles of religion are His enacted laws. Those who are abiding by such laws are the demigods, and those who are not abiding are demons. He has advented Himself to give protection to the demigods, who are very obedient to the laws of the Supreme Lord. The demigods and the devotees of the Lord take pleasure in abiding by the laws of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa takes pleasure in giving them all sorts of protection. These activities of Kåñëa, His protection of the devotees and killing the demons, as confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.8], are always good for men to hear and narrate. The glorious activities of the Lord will ever increasingly be chanted by the devotees and demigods.

"Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is the spiritual master of all spiritual masters; He is the deliverer of all fallen souls and the proprietor of the three worlds. Anyone is able to see Him by eyes smeared with love of Godhead. Today I shall be able to see the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who by His transcendental beauty has attracted the goddess of fortune to live with Him perpetually. As soon as I arrive in Våndävana, I will get down from this chariot and fall prostrate to offer my obeisances to the Supreme Lord, the master of material nature and all living entities. The lotus feet of Kåñëa are always worshiped by great mystic yogés, so I shall also worship His lotus feet and become one of His friends in Våndävana like the cowherd boys. When I bow down before Lord Kåñëa in that way, certainly He will place His fearless lotus hand on my head. His hand is offered to all conditioned souls who take shelter under His lotus feet. Kåñëa is the ultimate goal of life for all people who fear material existence, and certainly when I see Him He will give me the shelter of His lotus feet. I am aspiring for the touch of His lotus-like hands on my head."

In this way Akrüra expected blessings from the hand of Kåñëa. He knew that Indra, who is the king of heaven and the master of the three worlds—the upper, middle, and lower planetary systems—was blessed by the Lord simply for his offering a little water which Kåñëa accepted. Similarly, Bali Mahäräja gave only three feet of land in charity to Vämanadeva, and he also offered a little water which Lord Vämanadeva accepted, and thereby Bali Mahäräja attained the position of Indra. When the gopés were dancing with Kåñëa in the räsa dance, they became fatigued, and Kåñëa smeared His hand, which is as fragrant as a lotus flower, over the pearl-like drops of perspiration on the faces of the gopés, and immediately they became refreshed. Thus Akrüra was expecting benediction from that supreme hand of Kåñëa. Kåñëa's hand is capable of bestowing benediction to all kinds of men if they take to Kåñëa consciousness. If one wants material happiness like the king of heaven, he can derive that benediction from the hand of Kåñëa; if one wants liberation from the pangs of material existence, he can also get benediction from the hand of Kåñëa; and if one in pure transcendental love for Kåñëa wants personal association and the touch of His transcendental body, he can also gain benediction from His hand.

Akrüra was afraid, however, of being deputed by Kaàsa, the enemy of Kåñëa. He thought, "I am going to see Kåñëa as a messenger of the enemy." And at the same time, he thought, "Kåñëa is in each and everyone's heart as the Supersoul, so He must know my heart." Although Akrüra was trusted by the enemy of Kåñëa, his heart was clear. He was a pure devotee of Kåñëa. He risked Kaàsa's wrath just to meet Kåñëa. He was certain that although he was going as a representative of Kaàsa, Kåñëa would not accept him as an enemy. "Even though I am on a sinful mission, being deputed by Kaàsa, when I approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead, I shall stand before Him with all humility and folded hands. Surely, He will be pleased with my devotional attitude, and maybe He will smile lovingly and look upon me and thereby free me from all kinds of sinful reaction. I shall then be on the platform of transcendental bliss and knowledge. Since Kåñëa knows my heart, certainly when I approach Him, He will embrace me. I am not only one of the members of the Yadu dynasty, but I am an unalloyed pure devotee. By His merciful embrace, my body, my heart and soul will be completely cleansed of the actions and reactions of my past life. When our bodies touch, I will immediately stand up with folded hands, with all humility. Certainly Kåñëa and Balaräma will call me, 'Akrüra, uncle,' and at that time my whole life will be glorious. Unless one is recognized by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, his life cannot be successful."

It is clearly stated here that one should try to be recognized by the Supreme Personality of Godhead by one's service and devotion, without which the human form of life is condemned. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.29], the Supreme Lord, Personality of Godhead, is equal to everyone. He has no friends and no enemies. But He is inclined to a devotee who renders Him service with devotional love. The Bhagavad-gétä [18.55] also declares that the Supreme Lord is responsive to the devotional service rendered by the devotee. Akrüra thought that Kåñëa was like the desire tree in the heavenly planets which gives fruit according to the desire of the worshiper. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is also the source of everything. A devotee must know how to render service unto Him and thus be recognized by Him. In the Caitanya-caritämåta it is therefore explained that one should serve both the spiritual master and Kåñëa simultaneously and in that way make progress in Kåñëa consciousness. Service rendered to Kåñëa under the direction of the spiritual master is bona fide service because the spiritual master is the manifested representative of Kåñëa. Çré Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur says that when one satisfies the spiritual master, he satisfies the Supreme Lord. It is exactly like service in a government office. One has to work under the supervision of the departmental head. If the supervisor of the department is satisfied with the service of a particular person, a promotion and increase in pay will automatically come.

Akrüra then thought, "When Kåñëa and Balaräma are pleased with my prayers, certainly They will take my hand, receive me within Their homes and offer me all kinds of respectable hospitalities, and They will surely ask me of the activities of Kaàsa and his friends."

In this way, Akrüra, who was the son of Çvaphalka, meditated on Çré Kåñëa on his journey from Mathurä. He reached Våndävana by the end of the day. Akrüra passed the whole journey without knowing how long it took. When he reached Våndävana, the sun was setting. As soon as he entered the boundary of Våndävana, he saw the footprints of the cows and Lord Kåñëa's footprints, impressed with the signs of His sole, the flag, trident, thunderbolt and lotus flower. Upon seeing the footprints of Kåñëa, Akrüra immediately jumped down from the chariot, out of respect. He became overwhelmed with all the symptoms of ecstasy; he wept, and his body trembled. Out of extreme jubilation upon seeing the dust touched by the lotus feet of Kåñëa, Akrüra fell flat on his face and began to roll on the ground.

Akrüra's journey to Våndävana is exemplary. One who intends to visit Våndävana should follow the ideal footsteps of Akrüra and always think of the pastimes and activities of the Lord. As soon as one reaches the boundary of Våndävana, he should immediately smear the dust of Våndävana over his body without thinking of his material position and prestige. Narottamadäsa Öhäkur has sung in his celebrated song, Viñaya-chäriyä kave çuddha have mana: "When my mind will be purified after leaving the contamination of material sense enjoyment, I shall be able to visit Våndävana." Actually, one cannot go to Våndävana by purchasing a ticket. The process of going to Våndävana is shown by Akrüra.

When Akrüra entered Våndävana, he saw Kåñëa and Balaräma engaged in supervising the milking of the cows. Kåñëa was dressed in yellow garments and Balaräma in bluish. Akrüra also saw that Kåñëa's eyes were exactly like the beautifully grown lotus flower of the autumn season. He saw both Kåñëa and Balaräma in the spring of Their youth. Although both were similar in bodily features, Kåñëa was blackish in complexion, whereas Balaräma was whitish. Both were the shelter of the goddess of fortune. They had well-constructed bodies, beautiful hands and pleasing faces, and They were as strong as elephants. Now, after seeing Their footprints, Akrüra actually saw Kåñëa and Balaräma, face to face. Although They were the most influential personalities, They were glancing at him with smiling faces. Akrüra could understand that both Kåñëa and Balaräma had returned from tending cows in the forest; They had taken Their baths and were dressed with fresh clothing and garlanded with flowers and necklaces made of valuable jewels. Their bodies were smeared with the pulp of sandalwood. Akrüra greatly appreciated the aroma of flowers and sandalwood and Their bodily presence. He considered himself very fortunate to see Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and His plenary expansion, Balaräma, face to face, for he knew that They were the original personalities of the creation.

As stated in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.1], Kåñëa is the original Personality of Godhead and the cause of all causes. Akrüra could understand that the Supreme Personality of Godhead appeared personally for the welfare of His creation, to reestablish the principles of religion and to annihilate the demons. With Their bodily effulgence, the brothers were dissipating all the darkness of the world, as if They were mountains of sapphire and silver. Without hesitating, Akrüra immediately got down from his chariot and fell flat, just like a rod, before Kåñëa and Balaräma. Upon touching the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he became overwhelmed with transcendental bliss; his voice choked up and he could not speak. Due to Kåñëa's transcendental presence, incessant torrents of tears fell from his eyes. He remained stunned in ecstasy, as if devoid of all powers to see and speak. Lord Kåñëa, who is very kind to His devotees, raised Akrüra with His hand and embraced him. It appeared that Lord Kåñëa was very pleased with Akrüra. Balaräma also embraced Akrüra. Taking him by the hand, Kåñëa and Balaräma brought him to Their sitting room where They offered him a very nice sitting place and water for washing his feet. They also worshiped him with suitable presentations of honey and other ingredients. When Akrüra was thus comfortably seated, both Kåñëa and Balaräma offered Him a cow in charity and then brought very palatable dishes of eatables, and Akrüra accepted them. When Akrüra finished eating, Balaräma gave him betel nut and spices, as well as pulp of sandalwood, just to make him more pleased and comfortable. The Vedic system of receiving a guest was completely observed by Lord Kåñëa Himself to teach all others how to receive a guest at home. It is a Vedic injunction that even if a guest is an enemy, he should be received so well that he does not apprehend any danger from the host. If the host is a poor man, he should at least offer a straw mat as a sitting place and a glass of water to drink. Kåñëa and Balaräma welcomed Akrüra just befitting his exalted position.

After Akrüra was thus properly received and seated, Nanda Mahäräja, the foster father of Kåñëa, said, "My dear Akrüra, what shall I inquire from you? I know that you are being protected by Kaàsa, who is most cruel and demoniac. His protection is just like the slaughterhouse keeper's protection of animals he will kill in the future. Kaàsa is so selfish that he has killed the sons of his own sister, so how can I honestly believe that he is protecting the citizens of Mathurä?" This statement is most significant. If the political or executive heads of the state are simply interested in themselves, they can never look after the welfare of the citizens.

As Nanda Mahäräja spoke to Akrüra with pleasing words, Akrüra forgot all the fatigue of his day's journey from Mathurä to Våndävana.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-seventh Chapter of Kåñëa, "Akrüra's Arrival in Våndävana."

KB 1970-1-38 / Akrüra's Return Journey and His Visiting of Viñëuloka Within the Yamunä River

38 / Akrüra's Return Journey and His Visiting of Viñëuloka Within the Yamunä River

Akrüra was warmly received by Lord Kåñëa and Nanda Mahäräja and offered a resting place for the night. In the meantime, the two brothers Balaräma and Kåñëa went to take Their supper. Akrüra sat on his bed and began to reflect that all the desires which he had anticipated while coming from Mathurä to Våndävana had been fulfilled. Lord Kåñëa is the husband of the goddess of fortune; being pleased with His pure devotee, He can offer whatever the devotee desires. But the pure devotee does not ask anything from the Lord for his personal benefit.

After taking Their supper, Kåñëa and Balaräma came to bid goodnight to Akrüra. Kåñëa asked about His maternal uncle, Kaàsa, "How is he dealing with his friends?" And He asked, "How are my relatives?" He also inquired into Kaàsa's plans. The Supreme Personality of Godhead then informed Akrüra that his presence was very much welcome. He inquired from him whether all his relatives and friends were well and free from all kinds of ailments. Kåñëa stated that He was very sorry that His maternal uncle Kaàsa was the head of the kingdom; He said that Kaàsa was the greatest anachronism in the whole system of government and that they could not expect any welfare for the citizens while he ruled. Then Kåñëa said, "My father has undergone much tribulation simply from My being his son. For this reason also he has lost many other sons. I think Myself so fortunate that you have come as My friend and relative. My good friend Akrüra, please tell me the purpose of your coming to Våndävana."

After this inquiry, Akrüra, who belonged to the dynasty of Yadu, explained the recent events in Mathurä, including Kaàsa's attempt to kill Vasudeva, the father of Kåñëa. He related the things which happened after the disclosure by Närada that Kåñëa was the son of Vasudeva. Sitting by Him in the house of Nanda Mahäräja, Akrüra narrated all the stories regarding Kaàsa. He told how Närada met Kaàsa and how he himself was deputed by Kaàsa to come to Våndävana. Akrüra explained to Kåñëa that Närada had told Kaàsa all about Kåñëa's being transferred from Mathurä to Våndävana just after His birth and about His killing all the demons sent by Kaàsa. Akrüra then explained to Kåñëa the purpose of his coming to Våndävana: to take him back to Mathurä. After hearing of these arrangements, Balaräma and Kåñëa, who are very expert in killing opponents, mildly laughed at the plans of Kaàsa.

They asked Nanda Mahäräja to invite all the cowherd boys to go to Mathurä to participate in the ceremony known as Dhanur-yajïa. Kaàsa wanted them all to go there to participate in the function. On Kåñëa's word, Nanda Mahäräja at once called for the cowherd boys and asked them to collect all kinds of milk preparations and milk to present in the ceremony. He also sent instructions to the police chief of Våndävana to tell all the inhabitants about Kaàsa's great Dhanur-yajïa function and invite them to join. Nanda Mahäräja informed the cowherd boys that they would start the next morning. They therefore arranged for the cows and bulls to carry them all to Mathurä.

When the gopés saw that Akrüra had come to take Kåñëa and Balaräma away to Mathurä, they became overwhelmed with anxiety. Some of them became so aggrieved that their faces turned black, and they began to breathe warmly and had palpitations of the heart. They discovered that their hair and dress immediately loosened. Hearing the news that Kåñëa and Balaräma were leaving for Mathurä, others who were engaged in household duties stopped working as if they had forgotten everything, like a person who is called forth to die and leave this world at once. Others immediately fainted due to separation from Kåñëa. Remembering His attractive smile and His talks with them, the gopés became overwhelmed with grief. They all remembered the characteristics of the Personality of Godhead, how He moved within the area of Våndävana and how, with joking words, He attracted all their hearts. Thinking of Kåñëa and of their imminent separation from Him, the gopés assembled together with heavy beating hearts. Completely absorbed in thought of Kåñëa, tears fell from their eyes. They began to converse as follows.

"O Providence, you are so cruel! It appears that you do not know how to show mercy to others. By your arrangement, friends contact one another, but without fulfilling their desires you separate them. This is exactly like children's play that has no meaning. It is very abominable that you arrange to show us beautiful Kåñëa, whose bluish curling hair beautifies His broad forehead and sharp nose, who is always smiling to minimize all contention in this material world, and then arrange to separate Him from us. O Providence, You are so cruel! But most astonishingly You appear now as 'Akrüra,' which means 'not cruel.' In the beginning we appreciated Your workmanship in giving us these eyes to see the beautiful face of Kåñëa, but now, just like a foolish creature, You are trying to take out our eyes so we may not see Kåñëa here again. Kåñëa, the son of Nanda Mahäräja, is also very cruel! He must always have new friends; He does not like to keep friendship for a long time with anyone. We gopés of Våndävana, having left our homes, friends, and relatives, have become Kåñëa's maidservants, but He is neglecting us and going away. He does not even look upon us, although we are completely surrendered unto Him. Now all the young girls in Mathurä will have the opportunity. They are expecting Kåñëa's arrival, and they will enjoy His sweet smiling face and will drink its honey. Although we know that Kåñëa is very steady and determined, we are threatened that as soon as He sees the beautiful faces of the young girls in Mathurä, He will forget Himself. We fear He will become controlled by them and will forget us, for we are simple village girls. He will no longer be kind to us. We therefore do not expect Kåñëa to return to Våndävana. He will not leave the company of the girls in Mathurä."

The gopés began to imagine the great functions in the city of Mathurä. Kåñëa would pass through the streets, and the ladies and young girls of the city would see Him from the balconies of their respective houses. Mathurä City contained different communities, known then as Daçärha, Bhoja, Andhaka and Sätvata. All these communities were different branches of the same family in which Kåñëa appeared, namely the Yadu dynasty. They were also expecting the arrival of Kåñëa. It had already been ascertained that Kåñëa, who is the rest of the goddess of fortune and reservoir of all pleasure and transcendental qualities, was going to visit Mathurä City.

The gopés then began to condemn the activities of Akrüra. They stated that he was taking Kåñëa, who was more dear than the dearest to them and who was the pleasure of their eyes. He was being taken from their sight without their being informed or solaced by Akrüra. Akrüra should not have been so merciless but should have taken compassion on them. The gopés went on to say: "The most astonishing feature is that Kåñëa, the son of Nanda, without consideration, has already seated Himself on the chariot. From this it appears that Kåñëa is not very intelligent. Yet He may be very intelligent—but He is not very civilized. Not only Kåñëa, but all the cowherd men are so callous that they are already yoking the bulls and calves for the journey to Mathurä. The elderly persons in Våndävana are also merciless; they do not take our plight into consideration and stop Kåñëa's journey to Mathurä. Even the demigods are very unkind to us; they are not impeding His going to Mathurä."

The gopés prayed to the demigods to create some natural disturbance, such as a hurricane, storm or heavy rainfall, so that Kåñëa could not go to Mathurä. They then began to consider: "Despite our elderly parents and guardians, we shall personally stop Kåñëa from going to Mathurä. We have no other alternative than to take this direct action. Everyone has gone against us to take away Kåñëa from our sight. Without Him we cannot live for a moment." The gopés thus decided to obstruct the passage through which the chariot of Kåñëa was supposed to pass. They began to talk among themselves: "We have passed a very long night—which seemed only a moment—engaged in the räsa dance with Kåñëa. We were looking at His sweet smile and were embracing and talking. Now, how shall we live even for a moment if He goes away from us? At the end of the day, in the evening, along with His elder brother Balaräma, Kåñëa would return home with His friends. His face would be smeared with the dust raised by the hooves of the cows, and He would smile and play on His flute and look upon us so kindly. How shall we be able to forget Him? How shall we be able to forget Kåñëa, who is our life and soul? He has already taken away our hearts in so many ways throughout our days and nights, and if He goes away, there is no possibility of our continuing to live." Thinking like this, the gopés became more and more griefstricken at Kåñëa's leaving Våndävana. They could not check their minds, and they began to cry loudly, calling the different names of Kåñëa, "O dear Dämodara! Dear Mädhava!"

The gopés cried all night before the departure of Kåñëa. As soon as the sun rose, Akrüra finished his morning bath, got on the chariot and began to start for Mathurä with Kåñëa and Balaräma. Nanda Mahäräja and the cowherd men got up on bullock carts, after loading them with milk preparations, such as yogurt, milk, and ghee, filled in big earthen pots, and began to follow the chariot of Kåñëa and Balaräma. In spite of Kåñëa's asking them not to obstruct their way, all the gopés surrounded the chariot and stood up to see Kåñëa with pitiable eyes. Kåñëa was very much affected upon seeing the plight of the gopés, but His duty was to start for Mathurä, for this was foretold by Närada. Kåñëa, therefore, consoled the gopés. He told them that they should not be aggrieved; He was coming back very soon after finishing His business. But they could not be persuaded to disperse. The chariot, however, began to head west, and as it proceeded, the minds of the gopés followed it as far as possible. They watched the flag on the chariot as long as it was visible; finally they could only see the dust of the chariot in the distance. The gopés did not move from their places but stood until the chariot could not be seen at all. They remained standing still, as if they were painted pictures. All the gopés decided that Kåñëa was not returning immediately, and with greatly disappointed hearts, they returned to their respective homes. Being greatly disturbed by the absence of Kåñëa, they simply thought all day and night about His pastimes and thus derived some consolation.

The Lord, accompanied by Akrüra and Balaräma, drove the chariot with great speed towards the bank of the Yamunä. Simply by taking a bath in the Yamunä, anyone can diminish the reaction of his sinful activities. Both Kåñëa and Balaräma took Their baths in the river and washed Their faces. After drinking the transparent crystal clear water of the Yamunä, They took Their seats again on the chariot. The chariot was standing underneath the shade of big trees, and both brothers sat down there. Akrüra then took Their permission to also take bath in the Yamunä. According to Vedic ritual, after taking bath in the river, one should stand at least half submerged and murmur the Gäyatré mantra. While he was standing in the river, Akrüra suddenly saw both Balaräma and Kåñëa within the water. He was surprised to see Them there because he was confident that They were sitting on the chariot. Confused, he immediately came out of the water and went to see where the boys were, and he was very surprised to see that They were sitting on the chariot as before. When he saw Them on the chariot, he began to wonder whether he saw Them in the water. He therefore went back to the river. This time he saw not only Balaräma and Kåñëa there, but many of the demigods and all the Siddhas, Cäraëas, and Gandharvas. They were all standing before the Lord, who was lying down. He also saw the Çeña Näga with thousands of hoods. Lord Çeña Näga was covered with bluish garments, and His necks were all white. The white necks of Çeña Näga appeared exactly like snowcapped mountains. On the curved lap of Çeña Näga, Akrüra saw Kåñëa sitting very soberly, with four hands. His eyes were like the reddish petals of the lotus flower.

In other words, after returning, Akrüra saw Balaräma turned into Çeña Näga and Kåñëa turned into Mahä-Viñëu. He saw the fourhanded Supreme Personality of Godhead, smiling very beautifully. He was very pleasing to all and was looking towards everyone. He appeared beautiful with His raised nose, broad forehead, spread-up ears and reddish lips. His arms, reaching to the knees, were very strongly built. His shoulders were high, His chest very broad and shaped like the conchshell. His navel was very deep, and His abdomen was marked with three lines. His waist was broad and big, resembling the hips of a woman, and His thighs resembled the trunks of elephants. The other parts of His legs, the joints and lower extremities, were all very beautiful, the nails of His feet were dazzling, and His toes were as beautiful as the petals of the lotus flower. His helmet was decorated with very valuable jewels. There was a nice belt around the waist, and He wore a sacred thread across His broad chest. Bangles were on His hands and armlets on the upper portion of His arms. He wore bells on His ankles. He possessed dazzling beauty, and His palms were like the lotus flower. He was still more beautiful with different emblems of the Viñëu-mürti, the conchshell, club, disc and lotus flower, which He held in His four hands. His chest was marked with the particular signs of Viñëu, and He wore fresh flower garlands. All in all, He was very beautiful to look at. Akrüra also saw His Lordship surrounded by intimate associates like the four Kumäras, Sanaka, Sanätana, Sananda and Sanatkumära, and other associates like Sunanda and Nanda, as well as demigods like Brahmä and Lord Çiva. The nine great learned sages were there, and devotees like Prahläda and Närada were engaged in offering prayers to the Lord with clean hearts and pure words. After seeing the transcendental Personality of Godhead, Akrüra immediately became overwhelmed with great devotion, and all over his body there was transcendental shivering. Although for the moment he was bewildered, he retained his clear consciousness and bowed down his head before the Lord. With folded hands and faltering voice, he began to offer prayers to the Lord.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-eighth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Akrüra's Return Journey and His Visiting of Viñëuloka Within the Yamunä River."

KB 1970-1-39 / Prayers by Akrüra

39 / Prayers by Akrüra

Akrüra offered his prayers as follows: "My dear Lord, I here pay my respectful obeisances unto You because You are the supreme cause of all causes and the original inexhaustible Personality, Näräyaëa. From Your navel a lotus flower grows, and from that lotus, Brahmä, the creator of this universe, is born. Since Brahmä is the cause of this universe, You are the cause of all causes. All the elements of this cosmic manifestation—earth, water, fire, air, ether, ego and the total material energy, as well as nature, the marginal energy, the living entities, mind, senses, the sense objects and the demigods who control the affairs of the cosmos—are all produced from Your body. You are the Supersoul of everything, but no one knows Your transcendental form. Everyone within this material world is influenced by the modes of material nature. Demigods like Lord Brahmä, being covered by the influence of material nature, do not exactly know Your transcendental existence beyond the cosmic manifestation of the three modes of material nature. Great sages and mystics worship You as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the original cause of all living entities, all cosmic manifestation and all demigods. They worship You as all-inclusive. Some of the learned brähmaëas also worship You by observing the ritualistic ceremony of the Åg-veda. They offer different kinds of sacrifices in the names of different gods. And there are others also who are fond of worshiping transcendental knowledge. They are very peaceful and wish to give up all kinds of material activities. They engage themselves in the philosophical search for You, known as jïäna-yoga.

"There are devotees also known as Bhägavatas who worship You as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. After being properly initiated in the method of Päïcarätra, they decorate their bodies with tilaka and engage in worshiping Your different forms of Viñëu mürti. There are others also, known as Çaivites, followers of the different äcäryas, who worship You in the form of Lord Çiva."

It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.23] that worship of demigods is also indirectly worship of the Supreme Lord. But such worship is not orthodox, because the worshipable Lord is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa. Demigods such as Brahmä and Çiva are incarnations of the material qualities, which are also emanations from the body of Näräyaëa. Actually, there was no one existing before the creation except Näräyaëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The worship of a demigod is not on the level with worship of Näräyaëa.

Akrüra said, "Although the minds of those who are devotees of the demigods are fixed on a particular demigod, because You are the Supersoul of all living entities, including the demigods, worship of demigods indirectly goes to You. Sometimes, after flowing down from the mountains during the rainy season, small rivers fail to reach the sea; some reach the sea and some do not. Similarly, the worshipers of the demigods may or may not reach You. There is no guarantee. Their success depends on the strength of their worship."

According to Vedic principle, when a worshiper worships a particular demigod, he also conducts some ritual for Näräyaëa, Yajïeçvara, for it is mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä [7.21] that demigods cannot fulfill the desires of their worshipers without the sanction of Näräyaëa, or Kåñëa. The exact words used in the Bhagavad-gétä are mayaiva vihitän hi tän, which means that the demigods can award some benediction after being authorized by the Supreme Lord. When the demigod worshiper comes to his senses, he can reason as follows: "The demigod can offer benediction only after being empowered by the Supreme Lord, so why not worship the Supreme Lord directly?" Worshipers of the demigods may come to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but others, who take the demigod as all in all, cannot reach the ultimate goal.

Akrüra continued to pray: "My dear Lord, the whole world is filled with the three material modes of nature, namely, goodness, passion and ignorance. Everyone within this material world is covered by these modes, from Lord Brahmä down to the immovable plants and trees. My dear Lord, I offer my respectful obeisances unto You, because You are beyond the influence of the three modes. Except for You, everyone is being carried away by the waves of these modes. My dear Lord, fire is Your mouth, the earth is Your feet, the sun is Your eye, the sky is Your navel, and the directions are Your ears. Space is Your head, the demigods are Your arms, the oceans and seas are Your abdomen, and the winds and air are Your strength and vitality. All the plants and herbs are the hair on Your body; the clouds are Your hair, the mountains are Your bones and nails, the days and nights are the twinkling of Your eyelids; Prajäpati (the progenitor) is Your genitals, and the rains are Your semina.

"My dear Lord, all living entities, including different grades of demigods, different grades of overlords, kings and other living entities, are supposed to be resting in You. As part and parcel of the big unit, one cannot know You by experimental knowledge. One can simply understand Your transcendental existence as the great ocean in which different grades of living entities are included, or as the fruit kadamba out of which small mosquitoes come. My dear Lord, whatever eternal forms and incarnations You accept and which appear in this world are meant for relieving the living entities from their ignorance, illusion and lamentation. All people, therefore, can appreciate the incarnations and pastimes of Your Lordship and eternally glorify Your activities. No one can estimate how many forms and incarnations You have, nor can anyone estimate the number of universes that are existing within You.

"Let me therefore offer my respectful obeisances unto the incarnation of fish, who appeared in devastation, although Your Lordship is the cause of all causes. Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the Hayagréva incarnation who killed the two demons, Madhu and Kaiöabha; let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You who appeared as the gigantic tortoise and held up the great mountain Mandara, and who appeared as the boar who rescued the earth planet which had fallen into the water of Garbhodaka. Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto Your Lordship, who appeared as Nåsiàhadeva, who delivered all kinds of devotees from the fearful condition of atheistic atrocities. Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You who appeared as Vämanadeva and covered the three worlds simply by expanding Your lotus feet. Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You who appeared as the Lord of the Bhågus in order to kill all the infidel administrators of the world. And let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You who appeared as Lord Räma to kill demons like Rävaëa. You are worshiped by all devotees as the chief of the Raghu dynasty, Lord Rämacandra. Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You who appeared as Lord Väsudeva, Lord Saìkarñaëa, Lord Pradyumna and Lord Aniruddha. Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You, who appeared as Lord Buddha in order to bewilder the atheistic and demoniac. And let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You, who appeared as Kalki in order to chastise the so-called royal order degraded to the abominable condition of the mlecchas, who are below the jurisdiction of Vedic regulative principles.

"My dear Lord, everyone within this material world is conditioned by Your illusory energy. Under the impression of false identification and false possession, everyone is transmigrating from one body to another in the path of fruitive activities and their reactions. My dear Lord, I am also no exception to these conditioned souls. I am falsely thinking myself happy in possessing my home, wife, children, state, property and effects. In this way I am acting as if in a dreamland because none of these are permanent. I am a fool to be always absorbed in such thoughts, accepting them as permanent and true. My dear Lord, due to my false identification, I have accepted everything which is nonpermanent, such as this material body, which is not spiritual and is the source of all kinds of miserable conditions. Being bewildered by such concepts of life, I am always absorbed in thoughts of duality, and I have forgotten You who are the reservoir of all transcendental pleasure. I am bereft of Your transcendental association and am just like a foolish creature who goes in search of water in the desert, leaving the water spot which is covered by water-nourished vegetables. The conditioned souls want to quench their thirst, but they do not know where to find water. They give up the spot where there is actually a reservoir of water and run into the desert where there is no water. My dear Lord, I am completely incapable of controlling my mind, which is now driven by the unbridled senses and is attracted by fruitive activities and their results. My dear Lord, Your lotus feet cannot be appreciated by any person in the conditional stage of material existence, but somehow or other I have come near Your lotus feet, and I consider this to be Your causeless mercy upon me. You can act in any way because You are the supreme controller. I can thus understand that when a person becomes eligible to be delivered from the path of repeated birth and death, it is only by Your causeless mercy that he further progresses to become attached to Your causeless devotional service."

Akrüra fell down before the Lord and said, "My dear Lord, Your transcendental eternal form is full of knowledge. Simply by concentrating one's mind upon Your form, one can understand in full knowledge everything that be, because You are the original source of all knowledge. You are the supreme powerful, possessing all kinds of energies. You are the Supreme Brahman and the Supreme Person, supreme controller and master of the material energies. I offer my respectful obeisances unto You because You are Väsudeva, the resting place of all creation. You are the all-pervading Supreme Personality of Godhead, and You are also the Supreme Soul residing in everyone's heart and giving direction to act. Now, my Lord, I am completely surrendered unto You. Please give me Your protection."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Thirty-ninth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Prayers by Akrüra."

KB 1970-1-40 / Kåñëa Enters Mathurä

40 / Kåñëa Enters Mathurä

While Akrüra was offering his prayers to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Lord disappeared from the water, exactly as an expert dramatic actor changes his dress and assumes his original feature. After the Viñëu-mürti disappeared, Akrüra got out of the water. Finishing the rest of his ritualistic performance, he went near the chariot of Balaräma and Kåñëa and was struck with wonder. Kåñëa asked whether he had seen something wonderful within the water or in space. Akrüra said, "My dear Lord, all wonderful things that are happening within this world, either in the sky or in the water or on the land, are factually appearing in Your universal form. So when I have seen You, what wonderful things have I not seen?" This statement confirms the Vedic version that one who knows Kåñëa knows everything, and one who has seen Kåñëa has seen everything, regardless of how wonderful a thing may be. "My dear Lord," Akrüra continued, "there cannot be anything more wonderful than Your transcendental form. When I have seen Your transcendental form, what is there left to see?"

After saying this, Akrüra immediately started the chariot. By the end of the day, they had almost reached the precincts of Mathurä. When passing from Våndävana to Mathurä, all passersby along the way who saw Kåñëa and Balaräma could not help but look at Them again and again. In the meantime, the other inhabitants of Våndävana, headed by Nanda and Upananda, had already reached Mathurä by going through forests and rivers, and they were awaiting the arrival of Kåñëa and Balaräma. Upon reaching the entrance to Mathurä, Kåñëa and Balaräma got down from the chariot and shook hands with Akrüra. Kåñëa informed Akrüra, "You may go home now because We shall enter Mathurä along with Our associates." Akrüra replied, "My dear Lord, I cannot go to Mathurä alone, leaving You aside. I am Your surrendered servant. Please do not try to avoid me. Please, come along with me, with Your elder brother and cowherd boy friends, and sanctify my house. My dear Lord, if You come, my home will be sanctified by the dust of Your lotus feet. The water emanating from the perspiration of Your lotus feet, namely the Ganges, purifies everyone, including the forefathers, the fire-god and all other demigods. King Bali Mahäräja has become famous simply by washing Your lotus feet, and all his relatives have achieved the heavenly planet due to his contact with the Ganges water. Bali Mahäräja himself enjoyed all material opulences and later on was elevated to the highest exalted position of liberation. The Ganges water not only sanctifies the three worlds but is carried on the head of Lord Çiva. O Supreme Lord of all lords! O master of the universe! I offer my respectful obeisances unto You."

On hearing this, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, replied, "Akrüra, I shall surely come to your home with My elder brother Balaräma, but only after killing all the demons who are envious of the Yadu dynasty. In this way I shall please all My relatives." Akrüra became a little disappointed by these words of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but he could not disregard the order. He therefore entered Mathurä and informed Kaàsa about the arrival of Kåñëa, and then he entered his own home.

After the departure of Akrüra, Lord Kåñëa, Balaräma and the cowherd boys entered Mathurä to see the city. They observed that the gate of Mathurä was made of first-class marble, very well constructed, and the doors were made of pure gold. There were gorgeous gardens all around, and the whole city was encircled by cannons so that no enemy could enter very easily. They saw that all the crossings of the roads were decorated with gold. And there were many rich men's houses, all appearing symmetrical, as if constructed by one engineer. The houses were decorated with costly jewels, and each and every house had nice compounds of trees, fruits and flowers. The gardens, corridors and verandas of the houses were decorated with silk cloth and embroidery work in jewels and pearls. In front of the balcony windows were pigeons and peacocks walking and cooing. All the grain dealers' shops within the city were decorated with different kinds of flowers and garlands, newly grown grass and blossoming roses. The central doors of the houses were decorated with water pots filled with water, and a mixture of water and yogurt was sprinkled all around. There were flowers decorated with burning lamps of different sizes over the doors, and there were also decorations of fresh mango leaves and silk festoons on all the doors of the houses.

When the news spread that Kåñëa, Balaräma and the cowherd boys were within Mathurä City, all the inhabitants gathered, and the ladies and girls immediately went up to the roofs of the houses to see Them. They had been awaiting the arrival of Kåñëa and Balaräma with great anxiety, and in their extreme eagerness to see Kåñëa and Balaräma, the ladies did not dress themselves very properly. Some of them placed their dress in the wrong place. Some annointed their eyes on one side only, and some wore ankle bells only on one leg or only one earring. Thus in great haste, not even decorated properly, they came to see Kåñëa from the roofs. Some of them had been taking their lunch, but as soon as they heard that Kåñëa and Balaräma were in the city, they left their eating and ran to the roof. Some of them were in the bathroom, taking their baths, but without properly finishing their baths, they came to see Kåñëa and Balaräma. Passing by very slowly and smiling, Lord Kåñëa immediately stole their hearts. He who is the husband of the goddess of fortune passed through the street like an elephant. For a very long time the women of Mathurä had heard about Kåñëa and Balaräma and Their uncommon characteristics, and they were very much attracted and eager to see Them. Now when they actually saw Kåñëa and Balaräma passing on the street and saw Them sweetly smiling, the ladies' joy reached the point of ecstasy. When they actually saw Them with their eyes, they took Kåñëa and Balaräma within their hearts and began to embrace Them to their fullest desire. Their hairs stood up in ecstasy. They had heard of Kåñëa, but they had never seen Him, and now their longing was relieved. After going up on the roofs of the palaces of Mathurä, the ladies began to shower flowers upon Kåñëa and Balaräma. When the brothers were passing through the streets, all the brähmaëas in the neighborhood also went out with sandalwood and flowers and respectfully welcomed Them to the city. All the residents of Mathurä began to talk among themselves about the elevated and pious activities of the people of Våndävana. The residents of Mathurä were surprised at the pious activities the cowherd men in Våndävana must have performed in their previous lives to be able to see Kåñëa and Balaräma daily as cowherd boys.

While Kåñëa and Balaräma were passing in this way, They saw a washerman and dyer of clothing. Kåñëa was pleased to ask him for some nice clothing. He also promised that if the washerman would deliver the nicest dyed cloth to Him, he would be very happy, and all good fortune would be his. Kåñëa was neither beggar nor was He in need of clothing, but by this request He indicated that everyone should be ready to offer to Kåñëa whatever He wants. That is the purpose of Kåñëa consciousness.

Unfortunately, this washerman was a servant of Kaàsa and therefore could not appreciate the demand of Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is the effect of bad association. He could have immediately delivered the clothing to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who promised him all good fortune, but being a servant of Kaàsa, the sinful demon could not accept the offer. Instead of being pleased, he was very angry and refused the Lord's request saying, "How is it that You are asking clothing which is meant for the king?" The washerman then began to instruct Kåñëa and Balaräma: "My dear boys, in the future don't be so impudent as to ask for things which belong to the king. Otherwise, You will be punished by the government men. They will arrest You and punish You, and You will be in difficulty. I have practical experience of this fact. Anyone who unlawfully wants to use the king's property is very severely punished."

On hearing this, Lord Kåñëa, the son of Devaké, became very angry at the washerman, and striking him with the upper portion of His hand, He separated the man's head from his body. The washerman fell down dead on the ground. In this way Lord Kåñëa confirmed the statement [Bs. 5.32] that every limb of His body is capable of doing everything He likes. Without a sword, but simply with His hand, he cut off the head of the washerman. This is proof that the Supreme Lord is omnipotent. If He wants to do something, He can do it without extraneous help.

After this ghastly incident, the employees of the washerman immediately dispersed, leaving the clothing. Kåñëa and Balaräma took possession of it and dressed according to Their choice; the rest of the clothes were offered to the cowherd boys, who also used them as they desired. What they did not use remained there. They then continued to proceed. In the meantime, a devotee-tailor took the opportunity of service and prepared some nice clothes from the cloth for Kåñëa and Balaräma. Thus being very nicely attired, Kåñëa and Balaräma looked like elephants dressed with colored clothings on the full moon day of the dark moon. Kåñëa was very much pleased with the tailor and gave him the benediction of särüpya-mukti, which means that after leaving his body, he would be liberated and would attain a body exactly like fourhanded Näräyaëa's in the Vaikuëöha planets. He also granted him that as long as he would live he would earn sufficient opulence to be able to enjoy sense gratification. By this incident Kåñëa proved that those who are Kåñëa conscious devotees will not be lacking material enjoyment or sense gratification. They will have sufficient opportunity for such things, but after leaving this life they will be allowed to enter the spiritual planets of Vaikuëöhaloka or Kåñëaloka, Goloka Våndävana.

After dressing nicely, Kåñëa and Balaräma went to a florist of the name Sudämä. As soon as they reached the precinct of his house, the florist immediately came out and with great devotion fell down on his face to offer his respectful obeisances. He offered a nice seat to Kåñëa and Balaräma and asked his assistant to bring out flowers and betel nuts smeared with pulp of candana. The florist's welcome greatly satisfied the Lord.

The florist very humbly and submissively offered his prayers to the Lord, saying, "My dear Lord, because You have come to my place, I think all my forefathers and all my worshipable superiors are pleased and delivered. My dear Lord, You are the supreme cause of all causes of this cosmic manifestation, but for the benefit of the residents of this earthly planet, You have appeared with Your plenary portion to give protection to Your devotees and annihilate the demons. You are equally disposed as the friend of all living entities; You are the Supersoul, and You do not discriminate between friend and enemy. Yet You are pleased to give Your devotees the special result of their devotional activities. My Lord, I am praying that You please tell me whatever You wish me to do, because I am Your eternal servant. If You will allow me to do something, it will be a great favor to me." The florist, Sudämä, was greatly pleased within his heart by seeing Kåñëa and Balaräma in his place, and thus, as his choicest desire, he made two exquisite garlands of various flowers and presented them to the Lord. Both Kåñëa and Balaräma were very pleased with his sincere service, and Kåñëa offered the florist His salutation and benediction, which He is always prepared to bestow upon the surrendered souls. When the florist was offered benediction, he begged from the Lord that he might remain His eternal servant in devotional service and by such service do good to all living creatures. By this, it is clear that a devotee of the Lord in Kåñëa consciousness should not be simply satisfied by his own advancement in devotional service; he must be willing to work for the welfare of all others. This example was followed by the six Gosvämés of Våndävana. It is therefore stated in their prayer [2], lokänäà hitakäriëau: Vaiñëavas, or devotees of the Lord, are not selfish. Whatever benefit they derive from the Supreme Personality of Godhead as benediction they want to distribute to all other persons. That is the greatest of all humanitarian activities. Being satisfied with the florist, Lord Kåñëa not only gave him benediction for whatever he wanted, but over and above that, He offered him all material opulences, family prosperity, long duration of life, and whatever else his heart desired within the material world.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fortieth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kåñëa Enters Mathurä."

KB 1970-1-41 / The Breaking of the Bow in the Sacrificial Arena

41 / The Breaking of the Bow in the Sacrificial Arena

After leaving the florist's place, Kåñëa and Balaräma saw a hunchbacked young woman carrying a dish of sandalwood pulp through the streets. Since Kåñëa is the reservoir of all pleasure, He wanted to make all His companions joyous by cutting a joke with the hunchbacked woman. Kåñëa addressed her, "O tall young woman, who are you? Tell Me, for whom are you carrying this sandalwood pulp in your hand? I think you should offer this sandalwood to Me, and if you do so I am sure you will be fortunate." Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and He knew everything about the hunchback. By His inquiry He indicated that there was no use in serving a demon; one had better serve Kåñëa and Balaräma and get rid of the result of sins.

The woman replied to Kåñëa, "My dear Çyämasundara, dear beautiful dark boy, You may know that I am engaged as maidservant of Kaàsa. I am supplying him pulp of sandalwood daily. The king is very pleased with me for supplying this nice thing, but now I see that there is no one who can better be served by this pulp of sandalwood than You two brothers." Being captivated by the beautiful features of Kåñëa and Balaräma, Their talking, Their smiling, Their glancing and other activities, the hunchbacked woman began to smear the pulp of sandalwood over Their bodies with great satisfaction and devotion. The two transcendental beggars, Kåñëa and Balaräma, were naturally beautiful and had beautiful complexions, and They were nicely dressed in colorful garments. The upper portions of Their bodies were already very attractive, and when the hunchbacked woman smeared Their bodies with sandalwood pulp, They looked even more beautiful. Kåñëa was very pleased by this service, and He began to consider how to reward her. In other words, in order to draw the attention of the Lord, the Kåñëa conscious devotee has to serve Him in great love and devotion. Kåñëa cannot be pleased by any action other than transcendental loving service unto Him. Thinking like this, Lord Kåñëa pressed the feet of the hunchbacked woman with His toes and, capturing her cheeks with His fingers, gave her a jerk in order to make her straight. At once the hunchbacked woman looked like a beautiful straight girl, with broad hips, thin waist and very nice, well shaped breasts. Since Kåñëa was pleased with the service of the hunchbacked woman, and since she was touched by Kåñëa's hands, she became the most beautiful girl among women. This incident shows that by serving Kåñëa the devotee immediately becomes elevated to the most exalted position. In all respects, devotional service is so potent that anyone who takes to it becomes qualified with all godly qualities. Kåñëa was attracted to the hunchbacked woman not for her beauty but for her service; as soon as she rendered service, she immediately became the most beautiful woman. A Kåñëa conscious person does not have to be qualified or beautiful; after becoming Kåñëa conscious and rendering service unto Kåñëa, he becomes very qualified and beautiful.

When the woman was turned by Kåñëa's favor into an exquisitely beautiful young girl, she naturally felt very much obliged to Kåñëa, and she was also attracted by His beauty. Without hesitation, she caught the rear part of His cloth and began to snatch it. She smiled flirtatiously and admitted that she was agitated by lusty desires. She forgot that she was on the street and before the elder brother of Kåñëa and His friends.

She frankly proposed to Kåñëa: "My dear hero, I cannot leave You in this way. You must come to my place. I am already very much attracted to Your beauty, so I must receive You well, for You are the best among males. You must also be very kind upon me." In plain words she proposed that Kåñëa come to her home and satisfy her lusty desires. Kåñëa, of course, felt a little bit embarassed in front of His elder brother, Balaräma, but He knew that the girl was simple and attracted; therefore He simply smiled at her words. Looking towards His cowherd boy friends, he replied to the girl, "My dear beautiful girl, I am very much pleased by your invitation, and I must come to your home after finishing My other business here. Such a beautiful girl like you is the only means of solace for a person like Me, for I am away from home and not married. Certainly, as a suitable girl friend, you can give us relief from all kinds of mental agitation." Kåñëa satisfied the girl in this way with sweet words. Leaving her there, He began to proceed down the street of the marketplace where the citizens were prepared to receive Him with various kinds of presentations, especially betel nuts, flowers and sandalwood.

The mercantile men in the market worshiped Kåñëa and Balaräma with great respect. When Kåñëa was passing through the street, all the women in the surrounding houses came to see Him, and some of the younger ones almost fainted, being captivated by His beauty. Their hair and tight dresses loosened, and they forgot where they were standing.

Kåñëa next inquired from the citizens as to the location of the place of sacrifice. Kaàsa had arranged for the sacrifice called Dhanur-yajïa, and to designate this particular sacrifice he had placed a big bow near the sacrificial altar. The bow was very big and wonderful and resembled the rainbow in the sky. Within the sacrificial arena, this bow was protected by many constables and watchmen engaged by King Kaàsa. As Kåñëa and Balaräma approached the bow, they were warned not to go nearer, but Kåñëa ignored this warning. He forcibly went up and immediately took the big bow in His left hand. After stringing the bow in the presence of the crowd, He drew it and broke it at the middle into two parts, exactly as an elephant breaks sugar cane in the field. Everyone present appreciated Kåñëa's power. The sound of the bow cracking filled both sky and land and was heard by Kaàsa. When Kaàsa heard what had happened, he began to fear for his life. The caretaker of the bow, who was standing by watching, became very angry. He ordered his men to take up weapons, and he began to rush towards Kåñëa, shouting, "Arrest Him! Kill Him! Kill Him!" Kåñëa and Balaräma were surrounded. When They saw the threatening motions of the guards, they became angry, and taking up the two pieces of the broken bow, They began to beat off all the caretaker's men. While this turmoil was going on, Kaàsa sent a small group of troops to assist the caretakers, but both Kåñëa and Balaräma fought with them also and killed them.

After this, Kåñëa did not proceed further into the sacrificial arena but went out the gate and proceeded towards Their resting camp. Along the way, He visited various places in Mathurä City with great delight. Seeing the activities and wonderful prowess of Kåñëa, all the citizens of Mathurä began to consider the two brothers to be demigods who had come down to Mathurä, and they all looked upon Them with great astonishment. The two brothers strolled carefree in the street, not caring for the law and order of Kaàsa.

When evening came, Kåñëa and Balaräma, with Their cowherd boy friends, went to the outskirts of the city where all their cars were assembled. Thus Kåñëa and Balaräma gave some preliminary hints of Their arrival to Kaàsa, and he could understand what severe type of danger was awaiting him the next day in the sacrificial arena.

When Kåñëa and Balaräma were going from Våndävana to Mathurä, the inhabitants of Våndävana had imagined the great fortune of the citizens of Mathurä in being able to see the wonderful beauty of Kåñëa, who is worshiped by His pure devotees as well as the goddess of fortune. The fantasies of the residents of Våndävana were actually realized, for the citizens of Mathurä became fully satisfied by seeing Kåñëa.

When Kåñëa returned to His camp, He was taken care of by servants who washed His lotus feet, gave Him a nice seat and offered Him milk and palatable dishes of foodstuffs. After taking supper and thinking of the next day's program, He very peacefully began to take rest. Thus He passed the night there.

On the other side, when Kaàsa came to understand about the breaking of his wonderful bow and the killing of the caretaker and soldiers by Kåñëa, he could partially realize the power of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He could realize that the eighth son of Devaké had appeared and that now his death was imminent. Thinking of his imminent death, he could not rest the entire night. He began to have many inauspicious visions, and he could understand that both Kåñëa and Balaräma, who had approached the precincts of the city, were his messengers of death. Kaàsa began to see various kinds of inauspicious signs, both awake and dreaming. When he looked in the mirror he could not see his head, although the head was actually present. He could see the luminaries in the sky in double, although there was only one set factually. He began to see holes in his shadow, and he could hear high buzzing sound within his ears. All the trees before him appeared to be made of gold, and he could not see his own footprints in dust or muddy clay. In dream he saw various kinds of ghosts being carried in a carriage drawn by donkeys. He also dreamed that someone gave him poison, and he was drinking it. He dreamed also that he was going naked with a garland of flowers and was smearing oil all over his body. Thus, as Kaàsa saw various signs of death both awake and sleeping, he could understand that death was certain, and thus in great anxiety he could not rest that night. Just after the night expired, he busily arranged for the wrestling match.

The wrestling arena was nicely cleansed and decorated with flags, festoons and flowers, and the match was announced by the beating of kettledrums. The platform appeared very beautiful due to streamers and flags. Different types of galleries were arranged for respectable persons—kings, brähmaëas and kñatriyas. The various kings had reserved thrones, and others had arranged seats also. Kaàsa finally arrived, accompanied by various ministers and secretaries, and he sat on the raised platform especially meant for him. Unfortunately, although he was sitting in the center of all governing executive heads, his heart was palpitating in fear of death. Cruel death evidentally does not care even for a person as powerful as Kaàsa. When death comes, it does not care for anyone's exalted position.

When everything was complete, the wrestlers, who were to exhibit their skills before the assembly, walked into the arena. They were decorated with bright ornaments and dress. Some of the famous wrestlers were Cäëüra, Muñöika, Çala, Küöa and Toçala. Being enlivened by the musical concert, they passed through with great alacrity. All the respectable cowherd men who came from Våndävana, headed by Nanda, were also welcomed by Kaàsa. After presenting Kaàsa with the milk products they had brought with them, the cowherd men also took their respective seats by the side of the king, on a platform especially meant for them.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-first Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Breaking of the Bow in the Sacrificial Arena."

KB 1970-1-42 / The Killing of the Elephant Kuvalayäpéòa

42 / The Killing of the Elephant Kuvalayäpéòa

After taking their baths and finishing all other morning duties, Kåñëa and Balaräma could hear the beating of the kettledrums in the wrestling camp. They immediately prepared Themselves to proceed to the spot to see the fun. When Kåñëa and Balaräma reached the gate of the wrestling camp, They saw a big elephant of the name Kuvalayäpéòa being tended by a caretaker. The caretaker was deliberately blocking Their entrance by keeping the elephant in front of the gateway. Kåñëa could understand the purpose of the caretaker, and He prepared Himself by tightening His dress before combatting the elephant. He began to address the caretaker in a very grave voice, as resounding as a cloud: "You miscreant caretaker, give way and let Me pass through the gate. If you block My way, I shall send you and your elephant to the house of death personified."

The caretaker, being thus insulted by Kåñëa, became very angry, and in order to challenge Kåñëa, as was previously planned, he provoked the elephant to attack. The elephant then moved before Kåñëa like inevitable death. It rushed towards Him and tried to catch Him with its trunk, but Kåñëa very dexterously moved behind the elephant. Being able to see only to the end of its nose, the elephant could not see Kåñëa hiding behind its legs, but it tried to capture Him with its trunk. Kåñëa again very quickly escaped capture, and He again ran behind the elephant and caught its tail. Holding the elephant by its tail, Kåñëa began to pull it, and with very great strength He dragged it for at least twenty-five yards, just as Garuòa drags an insignificant snake. Kåñëa pulled the elephant from this side to that, from right to left, just as He used to pull the tail of a calf in His childhood. After this, Kåñëa went in front of the elephant and gave it a strong slap. He then slipped away from the elephant's view and ran to its back. Then, falling down on the ground, Kåñëa placed Himself in front of the elephant's two legs and caused it to trip and fall. Kåñëa immediately got up, but the elephant, thinking that He was still lying down, tried to push an ivory tusk through the body of Kåñëa by forcibly stabbing it into the ground. Although the elephant was harassed and angry, the caretaker riding on its head tried to provoke it further. The elephant then rushed madly towards Kåñëa. As soon as it came within reach, Kåñëa caught hold of the trunk and pulled the elephant down. When the elephant and caretaker fell, Kåñëa jumped up on the elephant's back and broke it and killed the caretaker also. After killing the elephant, Kåñëa took an ivory tusk on His shoulder. Decorated with drops of perspiration and sprinkled with the blood of the elephant, He felt very blissful, and thus He began to proceed towards the wrestling camp. Lord Balaräma took the other tusk of the elephant on His shoulder. Accompanied by Their cowherd boy friends, They entered the arena.

When Kåñëa entered the wrestling arena with Balaräma and Their friends, He appeared differently to different people according to their different relationships (rasas) with Him. Kåñëa is the reservoir of all pleasure and all kinds of rasas, both favorable and unfavorable. He appeared to the wrestlers exactly like a thunderbolt. To the people in general He appeared as the most beautiful personality. To the females He appeared to be the most attractive male, Cupid personified, and thus increased their lust. The cowherd men who were present there looked upon Kåñëa as their own kinsman, coming from the same village of Våndävana. The kñatriya kings who were present saw Him as the strongest ruler. To the parents of Kåñëa, Nanda and Yaçodä, He appeared to be the most loving child. To Kaàsa, the king of the Bhoja dynasty, He appeared to be death personified. To the unintelligent, He appeared to be an incapable personality. To the yogés present, He appeared to be the Supersoul. To the members of the Våñëi dynasty He appeared to be the most celebrated descendant. Thus appreciated differently by different kinds of men present, Kåñëa entered the wrestling arena with Balaräma and His cowherd boy friends. Having heard that Kåñëa had already killed the elephant, Kuvalayäpéòa, Kaàsa knew beyond doubt that Kåñëa was formidable. He thus became very much afraid of Him. Kåñëa and Balaräma had long hands. They were beautifully dressed, and They were attractive to all the people assembled there. They were dressed as if They were going to act on a dramatic stage, and They drew the attention of all people.

The citizens of Mathurä City who saw Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, became very pleased and began to look on His face with insatiable glances, as if they were drinking the nectar of heaven. Seeing Kåñëa gave them so much pleasure that it appeared that they were not only drinking the nectar of seeing His face, but were smelling the aroma and licking up the taste of His body and were embracing Him and Balaräma with their arms. They began to talk among themselves about the two transcendental brothers. For a long time they had heard of the beauty and activities of Kåñëa and Balaräma, but now they were personally seeing Them face to face. They thought that Kåñëa and Balaräma were two plenary incarnations of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, who had appeared in Våndävana.

The citizens of Mathurä began to recite Kåñëa's pastimes, His birth as the son of Vasudeva, His being taken into the care of Nanda Mahäräja and his wife in Gokula, and all those events leading to His coming to Mathurä. They spoke of the killing of the demon Pütanä, as well as the killing of Tåëävarta, who came as a whirlwind. They also recalled the deliverance of the twin brothers from within the yamala arjuna trees. The citizens of Mathurä spoke among themselves: Çaìkhäsura, Keçé, Dhenukäsura and many other demons were killed by Kåñëa and Balaräma in Våndävana. Kåñëa also saved all the cowherd men of Våndävana from devastating fire. He chastised the Käliya snake in the water of Yamunä, and He curbed the false pride of the heavenly king, Indra. Kåñëa held up the great Govardhana Hill in one hand for seven continuous days and saved all the people of Gokula from incessant rain, hurricane and windstorm." They also began to remember other enlivening activities: "The damsels of Våndävana were so pleased by seeing Kåñëa's beauty and participating in His activities that they forgot the purpose of material existence. By seeing and thinking of Kåñëa, they forgot all sorts of material fatigue." The Mathurä citizens discussed the dynasty of Yadu, saying that because of Kåñëa's appearance in this dynasty, the Yadus would remain the most celebrated family in the whole universe. While they were thus talking about the activities of Kåñëa and Balaräma, they heard the vibrations of different bands announcing the wrestling match.

The famous wrestler Cäëüra then began to talk with Kåñëa and Balaräma. "My dear Kåñëa and Balaräma," he said, "we have heard about Your past activities. You are great heroes, and therefore the king has called you. We have heard that Your arms are very strong. The king and all the people present here desire to see a display of Your wrestling abilities. A citizen should be obedient and please the mind of the ruling king; acting in that way, the citizen attains all kinds of good fortune. One who does not care to act obediently is made unhappy because of the king's anger. You are cowherd boys, and we have heard that while tending Your cows in the forest, You enjoy wrestling with each other. We wish, therefore, for You to join with us in wrestling so that all the people present here, along with the king, will be pleased."

Kåñëa immediately understood the purpose of Cäëüra's statements, and He prepared to wrestle with him. But according to the time and circumstances, He spoke as follows: "You are the subject of the King of Bhoja, and you live in the jungle. We are also indirectly his subjects, and we try to please him as far as possible. This offer of wrestling is a great favor of his, but the fact is that We are simply boys. We sometimes play in the forest of Våndävana with our friends who are our own age. We think that to combat persons of equal age and strength is good for us, but to fight great wrestlers like you would not be good for the audience. It would contradict their religious principles." Kåñëa thus indicated that the celebrated, strong wrestlers should not challenge Kåñëa and Balaräma to fight.

In reply to this, Cäëüra said, "My dear Kåñëa, we can understand that You are neither a child nor a young man. You are transcendental to everyone, as is Your big brother, Balaräma. You have already killed the elephant Kuvalayäpéòa, who was capable of fighting and defeating other elephants. You have killed him in a wonderful way. Because of Your strength, it behooves You to compete with the stronger wrestlers amongst us. I therefore wish to wrestle with You, and Your elder brother, Balaräma, will wrestle with Muñöika."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-second Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Killing of the Elephant Kuvalayäpéòa."

KB 1970-1-43 / The Killing of Kaàsa

43 / The Killing of Kaàsa

After Kaàsa's wrestlers expressed their determination, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the killer of Madhu, confronted Cäëüra, and Lord Balaräma, the son of Rohiëé, confronted Muñöika. Kåñëa and Cäëüra and then Balaräma and Muñöika locked themselves hand to hand, leg to leg, and each began to press against the other with a view to come out victorious. They joined palm to palm, calf to calf, head to head, chest to chest and began to strike each other. The fighting increased as they pushed one another from one place to another. One captured another and threw him down on the ground, and another rushed from the back to the front of another and tried to overcome him with a hold. The fighting increased step by step. There was picking up, the dragging and pushing, and then the legs and hands were locked together. All the arts of wrestling were perfectly exhibited by the parties, as each tried his best to defeat his opponent.

But the audience in the wrestling arena was not very satisfied because the combatants did not appear to be equally matched. They considered Kåñëa and Balaräma to be mere boys before the wrestlers Cäëüra and Muñöika, who were huge men as solid as stone. Being compassionate and favoring Kåñëa and Balaräma, many members of the audience began to talk as follows. "Dear friends, there is danger here." Another said, "Even in front of the king this wrestling is going on between incompatable sides." The audience had lost their sense of enjoyment. They could not encourage the fighting between the strong and the weak. "Muñöika and Cäëüra are just like thunderbolts, as strong as great mountains, and Kåñëa and Balaräma are two delicate boys of very tender age. The principle of justice has already left this assembly. Persons who are aware of the civilized principles of justice will not remain to watch this unfair match. Those taking part in this wrestling match are not very much enlightened; therefore whether they speak or remain silent, they are being subjected to the reactions of sinful activities." "But my dear friends," another in the assembly spoke out, "just look at the face of Kåñëa. There are drops of perspiration on His face from chasing His enemy, and His face appears like the lotus flower with drops of water. And do you see how the face of Lord Balaräma has turned especially beautiful? There is a reddish hue on His white face because He is engaged in a strong wrestling match with Muñöika."

Ladies in the assembly also addressed one another. "Dear friends, just imagine how fortunate the land of Våndävana is where the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself is present, always decorated with flower garlands and engaged in tending cows along with His brother, Lord Balaräma. He is always accompanied by His cowherd boy friends, and He plays His transcendental flute. The residents of Våndävana are fortunate to be able to constantly see the lotus feet of Kåñëa and Balaräma, which are worshiped by great demigods like Lord Çiva and Brahmä and the goddess of fortune. We cannot estimate how many pious activities were executed by the damsels of Vrajabhümi so that they were able to enjoy the Supreme Personality of Godhead and look on the unparalleled beauty of His transcendental body. The beauty of the Lord is beyond compare. No one is higher or equal to Him in beauty of complexion or bodily luster. Kåñëa and Balaräma are the reservoir of all kinds of opulence—namely wealth, strength, beauty, fame, knowledge and renunciation. The gopés are so fortunate that they can see and think of Kåñëa twenty-four hours a day, beginning from their milking the cows or husking the paddy or churning the butter in the morning. While engaged in cleaning their houses and washing their floors, they are always absorbed in the thought of Kåñëa."

The gopés give a perfect example of how one can execute Kåñëa consciousness even if he is in different types of material engagement. By constantly being absorbed in the thought of Kåñëa, one cannot be affected by the contamination of material activities. The gopés are, therefore, perfectly in trance, samädhi, the highest perfectional stage of mystic power. In the Bhagavad-gétä [6.47], it is confirmed that one who is constantly thinking of Kåñëa is a first-class yogé among all kinds of yogés. "My dear friends," one lady told another, "we must accept the gopés' activities to be the highest form of piety; otherwise, how could they have achieved the opportunity of seeing Kåñëa both morning and evening when He goes to the pasturing ground with His cows and cowherd boy friends and returns in the evening? They frequently see Him playing on His flute and smiling very brilliantly."

When Lord Kåñëa, the Supersoul of every living being, understood that the ladies in the assembly were anxious for Him, He decided not to continue wrestling but to kill the wrestlers immediately. The parents of Kåñëa and Balaräma, namely Nanda Mahäräja, Yaçodä, Vasudeva and Devaké, were also very anxious because they did not know the unlimited strength of their children. Lord Balaräma was fighting with the wrestler Muñöika in the same way that Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, was fighting and wrestling with Cäëüra. Lord Kåñëa appeared to be cruel to Cäëüra, and He immediately struck him thrice with His fist. The great wrestler was jolted, to the astonishment of the audience. Cäëüra then took his last chance and attacked Kåñëa, just as one hawk swoops upon another. Folding his two hands, he began to strike the chest of Kåñëa, but Lord Kåñëa was not even slightly disturbed, no more than an elephant that is hit by a flower garland. Kåñëa quickly caught the two hands of Cäëüra and began to wheel him around, and simply by this centrifugal action, Cäëüra lost his life. Kåñëa then threw him to the ground. Cäëüra fell just like the flag of Indra, and all his nicely decorated ornaments were scattered hither and thither.

Muñöika also struck Balaräma, and Balaräma returned the stroke with great force. Muñöika began to tremble, and blood and vomit flowed from his mouth. Distressed, he gave up his vital force and fell down just as a tree falls down in a hurricane. After the two wrestlers were killed, a wrestler named Küöa came forward. Lord Balaräma immediately caught him in His left hand and killed him nonchalantly. Another wrestler of the name Çala came forward, and Kåñëa immediately kicked him and cracked his head. Another wrestler named Toçala came forward and was killed in the same way. Thus all the great wrestlers were killed by Kåñëa and Balaräma, and the remaining wrestlers began to flee from the assembly out of fear for their lives. All the cowherd boy friends of Kåñëa and Balaräma approached Them and congratulated Them with great pleasure. While drums beat and they talked of the victory, the leg bells on the feet of Kåñëa and Balaräma tinkled.

All people gathered there began to clap in great ecstasy, and no one could estimate the bounds of their pleasure. The brähmaëas present began to praise Kåñëa and Balaräma ecstatically. Only Kaàsa was morose; he neither clapped nor offered benediction to Kåñëa. Kaàsa resented the drums' being beaten for Kåñëa's victory, and he was very sorry that the wrestlers had been killed and had fled the assembly. He therefore immediately ordered the drum playing to stop and began to address his friends as follows: "I order that these two sons of Vasudeva be immediately driven out of Mathurä. The cowherd boys who have come with Them should be plundered and all their riches taken away. Nanda Mahäräja should immediately be arrested and killed for his cunning behavior, and the rascal Vasudeva should also be killed without delay. Also my father, Ugrasena, who has always supported my enemies against my will, should be killed."

When Kaàsa spoke in this way, Lord Kåñëa became very angry with him, and within a second He jumped over the high guards of King Kaàsa. Kaàsa was prepared for Kåñëa's attack, for he knew from the beginning that He was to be the cause of his death. He immediately unsheathed his sword and prepared to answer the challenge of Kåñëa with sword and shield. As Kaàsa wielded his sword up and down, hither and thither, Lord Kåñëa, the supreme powerful Lord, caught hold of him with great force. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is the shelter of the complete creation and from whose lotus navel the whole creation is manifested, immediately knocked the crown from the head of Kaàsa and grabbed his long hair in His hand. He then dragged Kaàsa from his seat to the wrestling dias and threw him down. Then Kåñëa at once straddled his chest and began to strike him over and over again. Simply from the strokes of His fist, Kaàsa lost his vital force.

In order to assure His parents that Kaàsa was dead, Lord Kåñëa dragged him just as a lion drags an elephant after killing it. On sight of this, there was a great roaring sound from all sides, as some spectators expressed their jubilation and others cried in lamentation. From the day Kaàsa heard that he would be killed by the eighth son of Devaké, he was always thinking of Kåñëa twenty-four hours a day without any stoppage—even while he was eating, while he was walking, while he was breathing—and naturally he got the blessing of liberation. In the Bhagavad-gétä [8.6] it is stated, sadä tad-bhäva-bhävitaù: a person gets his next life according to the thoughts in which he is always absorbed. Kaàsa was thinking of Kåñëa with His wheel, which means Näräyaëa who holds a wheel, conchshell, lotus flower and club.

According to the opinion of authorities, Kaàsa attained särüpya-mukti after death, that is to say he attained the same form as Näräyaëa (Viñëu). On the Vaikuëöha planets all the inhabitants have the same bodily features as Näräyaëa. After his death, Kaàsa attained liberation and was promoted to Vaikuëöhaloka. From this instance we can understand that even a person who thinks of the Supreme Personality of Godhead as an enemy gets liberation and a place in a Vaikuëöha planet, so what to speak of the pure devotees who are always absorbed in favorable thoughts of Kåñëa? Even an enemy who is killed by Kåñëa gets liberation and is placed in the impersonal brahmajyoti. Since the Supreme Personality of Godhead is all good, anyone thinking of Him, either as enemy or as friend, gets liberation. But the liberation of the devotee and the liberation of the enemy are not the same. The enemy generally gets the liberation of säyujya, and sometimes he gets särüpya liberation.

Kaàsa had eight brothers, headed by Kaìka. All of them were younger than he, and when they learned that their elder brother had been killed, they combined together and rushed towards Kåñëa in great anger to kill Him. Kaàsa and his brothers were all Kåñëa's maternal uncles. They were all brothers of Kåñëa's mother, Devaké. When Kåñëa killed Kaàsa He killed His maternal uncle, which is against the regulation of Vedic injunction. Although Kåñëa is independent of all Vedic injunction, He violates the Vedic injunction only in inevitable cases. Kaàsa could not be killed by anyone but Kåñëa; therefore Kåñëa was obliged to kill him. As far as Kaàsa's eight brothers were concerned, Balaräma took charge of killing them. Balaräma's mother, Rohiëé, although the wife of Vasudeva, was not the sister of Kaàsa; therefore Balaräma took charge of killing all of Kaàsa's eight brothers. He immediately took up an available weapon (most probably the elephant's tusk which He carried) and killed the eight brothers one after another, just as a lion kills a flock of deer. Kåñëa and Balaräma thus verified the statement that the Supreme Personality of Godhead appears to give protection to the pious and to kill the impious demons who are always enemies of the demigods.

The demigods from the higher planetary systems began to shower flowers, congratulating Kåñëa and Balaräma. Among the demigods were powerful personalities like Lord Brahmä and Çiva, and all joined together in showing their jubilation over Kaàsa's death. There was beating of drums and showering of flowers from the heavenly planets, and the wives of the demigods began to dance in ecstasy.

The wives of Kaàsa and his eight brothers became aggrieved on account of their husbands' sudden deaths, and all of them were striking their foreheads and shedding torrents of tears. They were crying very loudly and embracing the bodies of their husbands. The wives of Kaàsa and his brothers began to lament, addressing the dead bodies: "Our dear husbands, you are so kind and are the protectors of your dependents. Now, after your death, we are also dead, along with your homes and children. We are no longer looking very auspicious. On account of your death, the auspicious functions which were to take place, such as the sacrifice of the bow, have all been spoiled. Our dear husbands, you treated persons ill who were faultless, and as a result you have been killed. This is inevitable because a person who torments an innocent person must be punished by the laws of nature. We know that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is the supreme master of everything and the supreme enjoyer of everything, and therefore anyone who neglects His authority can never be happy, and ultimately, as you have, he meets death."

Since Kåñëa was kind and affectionate to His aunts, He began to give them solace as far as was possible. The ritualistic ceremonies after death were then conducted under the personal supervision of Kåñëa because He happened to be the nephew of all the dead princes. After finishing this business, Kåñëa and Balaräma immediately released Their father and mother, Vasudeva and Devaké who had been imprisoned by Kaàsa. Kåñëa and Balaräma fell at Their parents' feet and offered them prayers. Vasudeva and Devaké had suffered so much trouble because Kåñëa was their son; it was because of Kåñëa that Kaàsa was always giving them trouble. Devaké and Vasudeva were fully conscious of Kåñëa's exalted position as the Supreme Personality of Godhead; therefore, although Kåñëa touched their feet and offered obeisances and prayers to them, they did not embrace Him, but simply stood up to hear the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Although Kåñëa was born as their son, Vasudeva and Devaké were always conscious of His position.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-third Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Killing of Kaàsa."

KB 1970-1-44 / Kåñëa Recovers the Son of His Teacher

44 / Kåñëa Recovers the Son of His Teacher

When Lord Kåñëa saw that Vasudeva and Devaké were remaining standing in a reverential attitude, He immediately expanded His influence of yogamäyä so that they could treat Him and Balaräma as children. As in the material world the relationship existing between father and mother and children can be established amongst different living entities by the influence of the illusory energy, so, by the influence of yogamäyä, the devotee can establish a relationship in which the Supreme Personality of Godhead is his child. After creating this situation by His yogamäyä, Kåñëa, appearing with His elder brother Balaräma as the most illustrious sons in the dynasty of the Sätvatas, very submissively and respectfully addressed Vasudeva and Devaké: "My dear father and mother, although you have always been very anxious for the protection of Our lives, you could not enjoy the pleasure of having Us as your babies, as your growing boys and as your adolescent youths." Kåñëa indirectly praised the fatherhood of Nanda Mahäräja and motherhood of Yaçodä as most glorious because although He and Balaräma were not their born sons, Nanda and Yaçodä actually enjoyed Their childhood pastimes. By nature's own arrangement, the childhood of the embodied living being is enjoyed by the parents. Even in the animal kingdom the parents are found to be affectionate to the cubs. Being captivated by the activities of their children, they take much care for their well-being. As for Vasudeva and Devaké, they were always very anxious for the protection of their sons, Kåñëa and Balaräma. That is why Kåñëa, after His appearance, was immediately transferred to another's house. Balaräma was also transferred from Devaké's womb to Rohiëé's womb.

Vasudeva and Devaké were full of anxieties for Kåñëa's and Balaräma's protection, and they could not enjoy Their childhood pastimes. Kåñëa said, "Unfortunately, being ordered by Our fate, We could not be raised by Our own parents to enjoy childhood pleasures at home. My dear father and mother, a man has a debt to pay to his parents, from whom he gets this body which can bestow upon him all the benefits of material existence. According to the Vedic injunction, this human form of life enables one to perform all kinds of religious activities, fulfill all kinds of desires and acquire all kinds of wealth. And only in this human form is there every possibility that one can get liberation from material existence. This body is produced by the combined efforts of the father and mother. Every human being should be obliged to his parents and understand that he cannot repay his debt to them. If, after growing up, a son does not try to satisfy his parents by his actions or by an endowment of riches, he is surely punished after death by the superintendent of death and made to eat his own flesh. If a person is able to care for or give protection to old parents, children, the spiritual master, brähmaëas and other dependents, but does not do so, he is considered to be already dead, although he is supposedly breathing. My dear father and mother, you have always been very anxious for Our protection, but unfortunately We could not render any service unto you. Up to date We have simply wasted Our time; We could not serve you for reasons beyond Our control. Mother and father, please excuse Us for Our sinful action."

When the Supreme Personality of Godhead was speaking as an innocent boy in very sweet words, both Vasudeva and Devaké became captivated by parental affection and embraced Them with great pleasure. They were amazed and could not speak or answer the words of Kåñëa, but simply embraced Him and Balaräma in great affection and remained silent, shedding incessant tears.

Thus consoling His father and mother, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, appearing as the beloved son of Devaké, approached His grandfather Ugrasena and announced that Ugrasena would now be the King of the Yadu kingdom. Kaàsa had been forcibly ruling over the kingdom of Yadu, in spite of the presence of his father, whom he had arrested. But after the death of Kaàsa, Kaàsa's father was released and announced to be the King of the Yadu kingdom. It appears that in those days, in the western part of India, there were many small kingdoms, and they were ruled by the Yadu dynasty, Andhaka dynasty, Våñëi dynasty and Bhoja dynasty. Mahäräja Ugrasena belonged to the Bhoja dynasty; therefore Kåñëa indirectly declared that the king of the Bhoja dynasty would be emperor of the other small kingdoms. He willingly asked Mahäräja Ugrasena to rule over Them because They were his subjects. The word prajä is used both for the progeny and for the citizens, so Kåñëa belonged to the prajä, both as a grandson to Mahäräja Ugrasena and as a member of the Yadu dynasty. He voluntarily accepted the rule of Mahäräja Ugrasena. He informed Ugrasena: "Being cursed by the Yayäti, the kings of the Yadu dynasty will not rise against the throne. It will be Our pleasure to serve you as your servants. Our full cooperation with you will make your position more exalted and secure so that the kings of other dynasties will not hesitate to pay their respective revenues. Protected by Us, you will be honored even by the demigods from the heavenly planets. My dear grandfather, out of fear of My late uncle Kaàsa, all the kings belonging to the Yadu dynasty, Våñëi dynasty, Andhaka dynasty, Madhu dynasty, Daçärha dynasty and Kukura dynasty were very anxious and disturbed. Now you can pacify them all and give them assurance of security. The whole kingdom will be peaceful."

All the kings in the neighboring area had left their homes in fear of Kaàsa and were living in distant parts of the country. Now, after the death of Kaàsa and the reinstatement of Ugrasena as king, the neighboring kings were given all kinds of presentations and comforts. Then they returned to their respective homes. After this nice political arrangement, the citizens of Mathurä were pleased to live in Mathurä, being protected by the strong arms of Kåñëa and Balaräma. On account of good government in the presence of Kåñëa and Balaräma, the inhabitants of Mathurä felt complete satisfaction in the fulfillment of all their material desires and necessities, and because they saw Kåñëa and Balaräma daily, eye to eye, they soon forgot all material miseries completely. As soon as they saw Kåñëa and Balaräma coming out on the street, very nicely dressed and smiling and looking here and there, the citizens were immediately filled with loving ecstasies, simply by seeing the personal presence of Mukunda. Mukunda refers to one who can award liberation and transcendental bliss. Kåñëa's presence acted as such a vitalizing tonic that not only the younger generation, but even the old men of Mathurä became fully invigorated with youthful energy and strength by regularly seeing Him.

Nanda Mahäräja and Yaçodä were also living in Mathurä because Kåñëa and Balaräma were there, but after some time they wanted to go back to Våndävana. Kåñëa and Balaräma went before them and very feelingly and affectionately embraced Nanda and Yaçodä, and Kåñëa began to speak as follows: "My dear father and mother, although I was born of Vasudeva and Devaké, you have been Our real father and mother, because from Our very birth and childhood, you raised Us with great affection and love. Your affectionate love for Us was more than anyone can offer one's own children. You are actually Our father and mother, because you raised Us as your own children at a time when We were just like orphans. For certain reasons We were rejected by Our father and mother, and you protected Us. My dear father and mother, I know you will be feeling separation by returning to Våndävana and leaving Us here, but please rest assured that I shall be coming back to Våndävana just after giving some satisfaction to My real father and mother, Vasudeva and Devaké, My grandfather, and other relatives and family members." Kåñëa and Balaräma satisfied Nanda and Yaçodä by sweet words and by presentation of various clothing, ornaments and properly made utensils. They satisfied them, along with their friends and neighbors who had come with them from Våndävana to Mathurä, as fully as possible. On account of his excessive parental affection for Balaräma and Kåñëa, Nanda Mahäräja felt tears in his eyes, and he embraced Them and started with the cowherd men for Våndävana.

After this, Vasudeva had his son initiated by sacred thread as the token of second birth, which is essential for the higher castes of human society. Vasudeva called for his family priest and learned brähmaëas, and the sacred thread ceremony of Kåñëa and Balaräma was duly performed. During this ceremony, Vasudeva gave various ornaments in charity to the brähmaëas and endowed them with cows decorated with silken cloths and golden ornaments. Previously, during the birth of Kåñëa and Balaräma, Vasudeva had wanted to give cows in charity to the brähmaëas, but being imprisoned by Kaàsa, he was able to do so only within his mind. With the death of Kaàsa the actual cows were given to the brähmaëas. Then Balaräma and Kåñëa were duly initiated with the sacred thread ceremony, and They repeated the chanting of the Gäyatré mantra. The Gäyatré mantra is offered to the disciples after the sacred thread ceremony, and Balaräma and Kåñëa properly discharged the duties of chanting this mantra. Anyone who executes the chanting of this mantra has to abide by certain principles and vows. Although Balaräma and Kåñëa were both transcendental personalities, They strictly followed the regulative principles. Both were initiated by Their family priest Gargäcärya, usually known as Gargamuni, the äcärya of the Yadu dynasty. According to Vedic culture, every respectable person has an äcärya, or spiritual master. One is not considered to be a perfectly cultured man without being initiated and trained by an äcärya. It is said, therefore, that one who has approached an äcärya is actually in perfect knowledge. Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma were the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the master of all education and knowledge. There was no need for Them to accept a spiritual master or äcärya, yet for the instruction of ordinary men, They also accepted a spiritual master for advancement in spiritual knowledge.

It is customary, after being initiated in the Gäyatré mantra, for one to live away from home for some time under the care of the äcärya in order to be trained in spiritual life. During this period one has to work under the spiritual master as an ordinary menial servant. There are many rules and regulations for a brahmacäré living under the care of an äcärya, and both Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma strictly followed those regulative principles while living under the instruction of their spiritual master, Sändépani Muni, in his place in northern India. According to scriptural injunctions, a spiritual master should be respected and be regarded on an equal level with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Both Kåñëa and Balaräma exactly followed those principles with great devotion and underwent the regulations of brahmacarya, and thus They satisfied Their spiritual master, who instructed Them in Vedic knowledge. Being very satisfied, Sändépani Muni instructed Them in all the intricacies of Vedic wisdom as well as in supplementary literatures such as the Upaniñads. Because Kåñëa and Balaräma happened to be kñatriyas, They were specifically trained in military science, politics and mathematics. In politics there are six departments of knowledge—how to make peace, how to fight, how to pacify, how to divide and rule, how to give shelter, etc. All these items were fully explained and instructed to Kåñëa and Balaräma.

The ocean is the source of water in a river. The cloud is created by the evaporation of ocean water, and the same water is distributed as rain all over the surface of the earth and then returns toward the ocean in rivers. So Kåñëa and Balaräma, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, are the source of all kinds of knowledge, but because They were playing like ordinary human boys, They set the example so that everyone would receive knowledge from the right source. Thus They agreed to take knowledge from a spiritual master.

After hearing only once from the teacher, Kåñëa and Balaräma learned all the arts and sciences. In sixty-four days and sixty-four nights They learned all the necessary arts and sciences that are required in human society. During daytime They took lessons on a subject from the teacher, and by nightfall, after having heard from the teacher, They were expert in that department of knowledge.

First of all They learned how to sing, how to compose songs and how to recognize the different tunes; They learned the favorable and unfavorable accents and meters, how to sing different kinds of rhythms and melodies, and how to follow them by beating different kinds of drums. They learned how to dance with rhythm, melody and different songs. They learned how to write dramas, and They learned the various types of paintings, beginning from different village arts up to the highest perfectional stage. They also learned how to paint tilaka on the face and make different kinds of dots on the forehead and cheeks. Then They learned the art of painting on the floor with liquid paste of rice and flour; such paintings are very popular at auspicious ceremonies performed at household affairs or in the temple. They learned how to make a resting place with flowers and how to decorate clothing and leaves with colorful paintings. They also learned how to set different valuable jewels in ornaments. They learned the art of ringing water pots. Water pots are filled with water to a certain measurement so that when one beats on the pots, different tunes are produced, and when the pots are beaten together they produce a melodious sound. They also learned how to throw water in the rivers or the lakes while taking a bath among friends. They also learned how to decorate with flowers. This art of decorating can still be seen in various temples of Våndävana during the summer season. It is called phulabäòi. The dais, the throne, the walls and the ceiling are all fully decorated, and a small, aromatic fountain of flowers is fixed in the center. Because of these floral decorations, the people, fatigued from the heat of the summer season, become refreshed.

Kåñëa and Balaräma learned the art of dressing hair in various styles and fixing a helmet in different positions on the head. They also learned how to perform on the theatrical stage, how to decorate dramatic actors with flower ornaments over the ear, and how to sprinkle sandalwood pulp and water to produce a nice fragrance. They also learned the art of performing magical feats. Within the magical field there is an art called bahurüpé by which a person dresses himself in such a way that when he approaches a friend he cannot be recognized. They also learned how to make beverages which are required at various times, and They studied syrups and tastes and the effects of intoxication. They learned how to manipulate thin threads for dancing puppets, and They learned how to string wires on musical instruments, such as the véëä, sitar and tampura, to produce melodious sound. Then They learned puzzles and how to set and solve them. They learned the art of reading books from which even a foolish student can very quickly learn to read the alphabet and comprehend writing. Then They learned how to rehearse and act out a drama. They also studied the art of solving crossword puzzles, filling up the missing space and making complete words.

They also learned how to draw pictographic literature. In some countries in the world, pictographic literature is still current. A story is represented by pictures; for instance, a man and a house are pictured to represent a man going home. Kåñëa and Balaräma also learned the art of architecture—how to construct residential buildings. They learned to recognize valuable jewels by studying the luster and the quality of their colors. Then They learned the art of setting jewels with gold and silver. They also learned how to study soil to find minerals. This study of soil is now a greatly specialized science, but formerly it was common knowledge even for the ordinary man. They learned to study herbs and plants and to extract medicine from the elements. By studying the different species of plants, They learned how to crossbreed plants and get different types of fruits. They learned how to train and engage lambs and cocks in fighting for sporting purposes. They then learned how to teach parrots to speak and answer the questions of human beings.

They learned practical psychology—how to influence another's mind and thus induce another to act according to one's own desire. Sometimes this is called hypnotism. They learned how to wash hair, dye it in different colors and curl it in different ways. They learned the art of telling what is written in someone's book without actually seeing it. They learned to tell what is contained in another's fist. Sometimes children imitate this art, although not very accurately. One child keeps something within his fist and asks his friend, "Can you tell what is within?" and the friend gives some suggestion, although He actually cannot tell. But there is an art by which one can understand and actually tell what is held within the fist.

Kåñëa and Balaräma learned how to speak and understand the languages of various countries. They learned not only the languages of human beings. Kåñëa could also speak even with animals and birds. Evidence of this is found in Vaiñëava literature compiled by the Gosvämés. Then They learned how to make carriages and airplanes from flowers. It is said in the Ramäyäëa that after defeating Rävaëa, Rämacandra was carried from Laìkä to Bhäratavarña on a plane of flowers called puñpa-ratha. Kåñëa then learned the art of foretelling events by seeing signs. In a book called Khanär vacana, the various types of signs and omens are described. If, when one is going out, one sees someone with a bucket full of water, that is a very good sign. But if one sees someone with an empty bucket, it is not a very good sign. Similarly, if one sees cow's milk along with her calf, it is a good sign. The result of understanding these signs is that one can foretell events, and Kåñëa learned the science. Kåñëa also learned the art of composing mätåkä. A mätåkä is a crossword section with three letters in a line; counting any three from any side, it will count nine. The mätåkäs are of different kinds and are for different purposes.

Kåñëa learned the art of cutting valuable stones such as diamonds, and He learned the art of questioning and answering by immediately composing poetry within His mind. He learned the science of the action and reaction of physical combinations and permutations. He learned the art of a psychiatrist, who can understand the psychic movements of another person. He learned how to satisfy one's desires. Desires are very difficult to fulfill; but if one desires something which is unreasonable and can never be fulfilled, the desire can be subdued and satisfied, and that is an art. By this art one can also subdue sex impulses when they are aroused, as they are even in brahmacäré life. By this art one can make even an enemy his friend or transfer the direct action of a physical element to other things.

Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, the reservoir of all knowledge of arts and sciences, exhibited Their perfect understanding when They offered to serve Their teacher by awarding him anything he desired. This offering by the student to the teacher or spiritual master is called guru-dakñiëä. It is essential that a student satisfy the teacher in return for any learning received, either material or spiritual. When Kåñëa and Balaräma offered Their service in this way, the teacher, Sändépani Muni, thought it wise to ask Them for something extraordinary, something which no common student could offer. He therefore consulted with his wife about what to ask from Them. They had already seen the extraordinary potencies of Kåñëa and Balaräma and could understand that the two boys were the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They decided to ask for the return of their son, who had drowned in the ocean on the bank of Prabhäsakñetra.

When Kåñëa and Balaräma heard from Their teacher about the death of his son on the bank of Prabhäsakñetra, They immediately started for the ocean on Their chariot. Reaching the beach, They asked the controlling deity of the ocean to return the son of Their teacher. The ocean deity immediately appeared before the Lord and offered Him all respectful obeisances with great humility.

The Lord said, "Some time back you caused the drowning of the son of Our teacher. I order you to return him."

The ocean deity replied, "The boy was not actually taken by me, but was captured by a demon named Païcajana. This great demon generally remains deep in the water in the shape of a conchshell. The son of Your teacher might be within the belly of the demon, having been devoured by him."

On hearing this, Kåñëa dove deep into the water and caught hold of the demon Païcajana. He killed him on the spot, but could not find the son of His teacher within his belly. Therefore He took the demon's dead body (in the shape of a conchshell) and returned to His chariot on the beach of Prabhäsakñetra. From there He started for Saàyamané, the residence of Yamaräja, the superintendent of death. Accompanied by His elder brother Balaräma, who is also known as Haläyudha, Kåñëa arrived there and blew on His conchshell.

Hearing the vibration, Yamaräja appeared and received Çré Kåñëa with all respectful obeisances. Yamaräja could understand who Kåñëa and Balaräma were, and therefore he immediately offered his humble service to the Lord. Kåñëa had appeared on the surface of the earth as an ordinary human being, but actually Kåñëa and Balaräma are the Supersoul living within the heart of every living entity. They are Viñëu Himself, but were playing just like ordinary human boys. As Yamaräja offered his services to the Lord, Çré Kåñëa asked him to return His teacher's son, who had come to him as a result of his work. "Considering My ruling as supreme," said Kåñëa, "you should immediately return the son of My teacher."

Yamaräja returned the boy to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and Kåñëa and Balaräma brought him to his father. The brothers asked if Their teacher had anything more to ask from Them, but he replied, "My dear sons, You have done enough for me. I am now completely satisfied. What further want can there be for a man who has disciples like You? My dear boys, You can go home now. These glorious acts of Yours will always be renowned all over the world. You are above all blessing, yet it is my duty to bless You. I give You the benediction that whatever You speak will remain as eternally fresh as the instruction of the Vedas. Your teachings will not only be honored within this universe or in this millennium, but in all places and ages and will remain increasingly new and important." Due to this benediction from His teacher, Lord Kåñëa's Bhagavad-gétä is ever increasingly fresh and is not only renowned within this universe, but in other planets and in other universes also.

Being ordered by Their teacher, Kåñëa and Balaräma immediately returned home on Their chariots. They traveled at great speeds like the wind and made sounds like the crashing of clouds. All the residents of Mathurä, who had not seen Kåñëa and Balaräma for a long time, were very pleased to see Them again. They felt joyful, like a person who has regained his lost property.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-fourth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kåñëa Recovers the Son of His Teacher."

KB 1970-1-45 / Uddhava Visits Våndävana

45 / Uddhava Visits Våndävana

Nanda Mahäräja returned to Våndävana without Kåñëa and Balaräma. He was accompanied only by the cowherd boys and men. It was certainly a very pathetic scene for the gopés, mother Yaçodä, Çrématé Rädhäräëé and all the inhabitants and residents of Våndävana. Many devotees have tried to make adjustments to Kåñëa's being away from Våndävana because according to expert opinion, Kåñëa, the original Supreme Personality of Godhead, never goes even a step out of Våndävana. He always remains there. The explanation of expert devotees is that Kåñëa was actually not absent from Våndävana; He came back with Nanda Mahäräja as promised.

When He was going to Mathurä on the chariot driven by Akrüra and the gopés were practically blocking the way, Kåñëa assured them that He was coming back just after finishing His business in Mathurä. He told them not to be overwhelmed, and in this way He pacified them. But when He did not come back with Nanda Mahäräja, it appeared that He either cheated them or could not keep His promise. Expert devotees, however, have decided that Kåñëa was neither a cheater nor a breaker of promises. Kåñëa, in His original identity, returned with Nanda Mahäräja and stayed with the gopés and mother Yaçodä in His bhava expansion. Kåñëa and Balaräma remained in Mathurä, not in Their original forms, but in Their expansions as Väsudeva and Saìkarñaëa. The real Kåñëa and Balaräma were in Våndävana in Their bhava manifestation, whereas in Mathurä They appeared in the prabhava and vaibhava expansions. This is the expert opinion of advanced devotees of Kåñëa. But when Nanda Mahäräja was preparing to return to Våndävana, there was discussion among him, Kåñëa and Balaräma as to how the boys could live in separation from Nanda. The conclusion to separate was reached by mutual agreement.

Vasudeva and Devaké happened to be Kåñëa and Balaräma's real parents. They wanted to keep Them now because of the death of Kaàsa. While Kaàsa was alive, They were kept under the protection of Nanda Mahäräja in Våndävana. Now, naturally, the father and mother of Kåñëa and Balaräma wanted Them to remain with them, specifically for the reformatory function of purification, the sacred thread ceremony. They also wanted to give Them a proper education, for this is the duty of the father. Another consideration was that all the friends of Kaàsa outside Mathurä were planning to attack Mathurä. For that reason also Kåñëa's presence was required. Kåñëa did not want Våndävana to be disturbed by enemies like Dantavakra and Jaräsandha. If Kåñëa were to go to Våndävana, these enemies would not only attack Mathurä, but would go on to Våndävana, and the peaceful inhabitants of Våndävana would be disturbed. Kåñëa therefore decided to remain in Mathurä, and Nanda Mahäräja went back to Våndävana. Although the inhabitants of Våndävana were feeling separation from Kåñëa, Kåñëa was always present with them by His lélä, or pastimes, and this made them ecstatic.

Since Kåñëa had departed from Våndävana to Mathurä, the inhabitants of Våndävana, especially mother Yaçodä, Nanda Mahäräja, Çrématé Rädhäräëé, the gopés and the cowherd boys, were simply thinking of Kåñëa at every step. They were thinking, "Kåñëa was playing in this way. Kåñëa was blowing His flute. Kåñëa was joking with us, and Kåñëa was embracing us." This is called lélä-smaraëa, and it is the process of association with Kåñëa most recommended by great devotees; even Lord Caitanya enjoyed lélä-smaraëa association of Kåñëa when He was at Puré. Those who are in the most exalted position of devotional service and ecstasy can live with Kåñëa always by remembering His pastimes. Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur has given us a transcendental literature entitled Kåñëa-bhävanamåtä, which is full with Kåñëa's pastimes. Devotees can remain absorbed in Kåñëa-thought by reading such books. Any book of Kåñëa-lélä, even this book, Kåñëa, and our Teachings of Lord Caitanya, is actually solace for devotees who are feeling the separation of Kåñëa.

That Kåñëa and Balaräma did not come to Våndävana can be adjusted as follows: They did not break Their promise to return to Våndävana, nor were They absent, but Their presence was necessary in Mathurä.

In the meantime, Uddhava, a cousin-brother of Kåñëa, came to see Kåñëa from Dvärakä. He was the son of Vasudeva's brother and was almost the same age as Kåñëa. His bodily features resembled Kåñëa's almost exactly. After returning from His teacher's home, Kåñëa was pleased to see Uddhava, who happened to be His dearmost friend. He wanted to send him to Våndävana with a message to the residents to pacify their deep feeling of separation.

As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, ye yathä mäà prapadyante: Kåñëa is very responsive. He responds in proportion to the devotee's advancement in devotional service. The gopés were thinking of Kåñëa in separation twenty-four hours a day. Kåñëa was also always thinking of the gopés, mother Yaçodä, Nanda Mahäräja and the residents of Våndävana, although He appeared to be away from them. He could understand how they were transcendentally aggrieved, and so He immediately wanted to send Uddhava to give them a message of solace.

Uddhava is described as the most exalted personality in the Våñëi dynasty, almost equal to Kåñëa. He was a great friend, and on account of being the direct student of Båhaspati, the teacher and priest of the heavenly planets, he was very intelligent and sharp in decision. From the intellectual standpoint, he was highly qualified. Kåñëa, being a very loving friend of Uddhava, wanted to send him to Våndävana just to study the highly elevated ecstatic devotional service practiced there. Even if one is highly elevated in material education and is even the disciple of Båhaspati, he still has to learn from the gopés and the residents of Våndävana how to love Kåñëa to the highest degree. Sending Uddhava to Våndävana with a message to the residents of Våndävana to pacify them was Kåñëa's special favor to Uddhava.

Lord Kåñëa's name is Hari, which means one who takes away all the distress from the surrendered souls. Lord Caitanya states that there cannot be, at any time, a worship as exalted as that realized by the gopés. Being very anxious about the gopés' grief, Kåñëa talked with Uddhava and politely requested him to go to Våndävana. Shaking Uddhava's hand with His own hands, He said, "My dear gentle friend Uddhava, please go immediately to Våndävana and try to pacify My father and mother, Nanda Mahäräja and Yaçodädevi, and the gopés. They are very much griefstricken, as if suffering from great ailments. Go and give them a message. I hope their ailments will be partially relieved. The gopés are always absorbed in thoughts of Me. They have dedicated body, desire, life and soul to Me. I am anxious not only for the gopés, but for anyone who sacrifices society, friendship, love and personal comforts for Me. It is My duty to protect such exalted devotees. The gopés are the most dear. They are always thinking of Me in such a way that they remain overwhelmed and almost dead in anxiety due to separation from Me. They are keeping alive simply by thinking that I am returning to them very soon."

Requested by Lord Kåñëa, Uddhava immediately left on His chariot and carried the message to Gokula. He approached Våndävana at sunset, when the cows were returning home from the pasturing ground. Uddhava and his chariot were covered by the dust raised by the hooves of the cows. He saw bulls running after cows for mating; other cows, with overladened milkbags, were running after the calves to fill them with milk. Uddhava saw that the entire land of Våndävana was filled with white cows and their calves. Cows were running here and there all over Gokula, and he could hear the sound of milking. Every residential house in Våndävana was decorated for the worship of the sun-god and the fire-god and for the reception of guests, cows, brähmaëas and demigods. Every home was illuminated with light and incense arranged for sanctification. All over Våndävana there were nice flower garlands, flying birds and the humming sound of the bees. The lakes were filled with lotus flowers and with ducks and swans.

Uddhava entered the house of Nanda Mahäräja and was received as a representative of Väsudeva. Nanda Mahäräja offered him a place and sat down with him to ask about messages from Kåñëa, Balaräma and other family members in Mathurä. He could understand that Uddhava was a very confidential friend of Kåñëa and therefore must have come with good messages. "My dear Uddhava, how is my friend Vasudeva enjoying life? He is now released from the prison of Kaàsa, and he is now with his friends and his children, Kåñëa and Balaräma. So he must be very happy. Tell me about him and his welfare. We are also very happy that Kaàsa, the most sinful demon, is now killed. He was always envious of the family of the Yadus, his friends and relatives. Now because of his sinful activities, he is dead and gone, along with all his brothers.

"Please let us now know whether Kåñëa is remembering His father and mother and His friends and companions in Våndävana. Does He like to remember His cows, His gopés, His Govardhana Hill, His pasturing ground in Våndävana? Or has He forgotten all these now? Is there any possibility of His coming back to His friends and relatives so that we can again see His beautiful face with its raised nose and lotus-like eyes? We remember how He saved us from the forest fire, how He saved us from the great snake Käliya in the Yamunä, how He saved us from so many other demons, and we simply think how much we are obliged to Him for giving us protection in so many dangerous situations. My dear Uddhava, when we think of Kåñëa's beautiful face and eyes and His different activities here in Våndävana, we become so overwhelmed that all our activities cease. We simply think of Kåñëa, how He used to smile and how He looked upon us. When we go to the banks of the Yamunä and other lakes of Våndävana or near Govardhana Hill or the pasturing field, we see that the impressions of Kåñëa's footprints are still on the surface of the earth. We remember Him playing in those places, because He was constantly visiting them. When His appearance within our minds becomes manifest, we immediately become absorbed in thought of Him.

"We think, therefore, that Kåñëa and Balaräma may be chief demigods in heaven who have appeared before us like ordinary boys in order to execute particular duties on earth. This was also foretold by Gargamuni when making Kåñëa's horoscope. If Kåñëa were not a great personality, how could He have killed Kaàsa, who possessed the strength of 10,000 elephants? Besides Kaàsa, there were very strong wrestlers, as well as the giant elephant, Kuvalayäpéòa. All these animals and demons were killed by Him just as a lion kills an ordinary animal. How wonderful it is that Kåñëa took in one hand the big, heavy bow made of three joined palm trees and broke it very quickly. How wonderful it is that continually for seven days He held up Govardhana Hill in one hand. How wonderful it is that He has killed all the demons, like Pralambäsura, Dhenukäsura, Ariñöäsura, Tåëävarta and Bakäsura. They were so strong that even the demigods in the heavenly planets were afraid of them, but Kåñëa killed them as easily as anything."

While describing the uncommon activities of Kåñëa before Uddhava, Nanda Mahäräja gradually became overwhelmed and could not speak anymore. As for mother Yaçodä, she sat by the side of her husband and heard the pastimes of Kåñëa without speaking. She was simply crying incessantly, and milk was pouring from her breasts. When Uddhava saw Mahäräja Nanda and Yaçodä so extraordinarily overwhelmed with thoughts of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and when he experienced their extraordinary affection for Him, he also became overwhelmed and began to speak as follows. "My dear mother Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja, you are most respectable among human beings because no one but you can meditate in such transcendental ecstasy."

Both Balaräma and Kåñëa are the original Personalities of Godhead from whom the cosmic manifestation is emanating. They are chief among all personalities. Both of Them are the effective cause of this material creation. Material nature is conducted by the puruña incarnations, who are all acting under Kåñëa and Balaräma. By Their partial representation They enter in the hearts of all living entities. They are the source of all knowledge and all forgetfulness also. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä, Fifteenth Chapter: "I am present in everyone's heart, and I cause one to remember and to forget. I am the original compiler of the Vedänta, and I am the actual knower of the Vedas." If, at the time of death, a person can fix his pure mind upon Kåñëa even for a moment, he becomes eligible to give up this material body and appear in his original spiritual body, just as the sun rises with all illumination. Passing from his life in this way, he immediately enters into the spiritual kingdom, Vaikuëöha. This is the result of Kåñëa conscious practice.

If we practice Kåñëa consciousness in this present body while we are in a healthy condition and in good mind, simply by chanting the holy mahä-mantra, Hare Kåñëa, we will have every possibility of fixing our mind upon Kåñëa at the time of death. If that is done, then our life becomes successful without any doubt. Similarly, if we keep our mind always absorbed in fruitive activities for material enjoyment, then naturally at the time of death we shall think of such activities and again be forced to enter into a material, conditioned body to suffer the threefold miseries of material existence. Therefore, to remain always absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness was the standard of the inhabitants of Våndävana, as exhibited by Mahäräja Nanda, Yaçodä and the gopés. If we can simply follow their footsteps, even to a minute proportion, our lives will surely become successful, and we will enter into the spiritual kingdom, Vaikuëöha.

"My dear mother Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja," Uddhava continued, "you have thus fixed your minds wholly and solely upon that Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, in His transcendental form, the cause of impersonal Brahman. The Brahman effulgence is only the bodily ray of Näräyaëa, and because you are always absorbed in ecstatic thought of Kåñëa and Balaräma, what activity remains to be performed by you? I have brought a message from Kåñëa to the effect that He will soon come back to Våndävana and satisfy you both by His personal presence. Kåñëa promised that He would come back to Våndävana after finishing His business in Mathurä. This promise He will surely fulfill. I therefore request you both, who are the best among all fortunates, to be not aggrieved on account of Kåñëa's absence.

"You are already perceiving His presence twenty-four hours a day, and yet He will come and see you very soon. Actually He is present everywhere and in everyone's heart, just as fire is present in wood. Since Kåñëa is the Supersoul, no one is His enemy, no one is His friend, no one is equal to Him, and no one is lower or higher than Him. Actually He has no father, mother, brother or relative, nor does He require society, friendship and love. He does not have a material body; He never appears or takes birth as an ordinary human being. He does not appear in higher or lower species of life like ordinary living entities, who are forced to take birth on account of their previous activities. He appears by His internal potency just to give protection to His devotee. He is never influenced by the modes of material nature, but when He appears within this material world, it seems that He acts like an ordinary living entity under the spell of the modes of material nature. In fact, He is the overseer of this material creation and is not affected by the material modes of nature. He creates, maintains and dissolves the whole cosmic manifestation. We wrongly think of Kåñëa and Balaräma as ordinary human beings. We are like dizzy men who see the whole world wheeling around them. The Personality of Godhead is no one's son; He is actually everyone's father, mother and supreme controller. There is no doubt of this. Whatever is being experienced, whatever is already in existence, whatever is not in existence, whatever will be in existence in the future, whatever is the smallest and whatever is the biggest have no separate existence outside the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Everything is resting in Him, but He is out of touch with everything manifested."

Nanda and Uddhava thus passed the whole night in discussing Kåñëa. In the morning, the gopés prepared for morning ärätrika by lighting their lamps and sprinkling butter mixed with yogurt. After finishing their maìgala-ärätrika, they engaged themselves in churning butter from yogurt. While the gopés were thus engaged, the lamps reflected on their ornaments became still more illuminated. The churning rod, their arms, their earrings, their bangles, their breasts—everything moved, and the kuìkuma powder gave their faces a saffron luster comparable to the rising sun. While churning, they also sang the glories of Kåñëa. The two sound vibrations mixed together, ascended to the sky and sanctified the whole atmosphere. After sunrise the gopés came as usual to offer their respects to Nanda Mahäräja and Yaçodä, but when they saw the golden chariot of Uddhava at the door, they began to inquire among themselves. What was that chariot, and to whom did it belong? Some of them inquired whether Akrüra, who had taken away Kåñëa, had again returned. They were not very pleased with Akrüra because, being engaged in the service of Kaàsa, he took Kåñëa away to the city of Mathurä. All the gopés conjectured that Akrüra might have come again to fulfill another cruel plan. But they thought, "We are now dead bodies without our supreme master, Kåñëa. What further act can he perpetrate on these dead bodies?" While they were talking in this way, Uddhava finished his morning ablutions, prayers and chanting and came before them.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-fifth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Uddhava Visits Våndävana."

KB 1970-1-46 / Delivery of the Message of Kåñëa to the Gopés

46 / Delivery of the Message of Kåñëa to the Gopés

When the gopés saw Uddhava, they observed that his features almost exactly resembled the features of Kåñëa, and they could understand that he was a great devotee of Kåñëa's. His hands were very long, and his arms were just like the petals of the lotus flower. He was dressed in yellow colored garments and wore a garland of lotus flowers. His face was very beautiful. Having achieved the liberation of särüpya and having the same bodily features as the Lord, Uddhava looked almost like Kåñëa. In Kåñëa's absence, the gopés had been coming dutifully to visit mother Yaçodä's house early in the morning. They knew that Nanda Mahäräja and mother Yaçodä were always griefstricken, and they had made it their first duty to come and pay their respects to the most exalted elderly personalities of Våndävana. Seeing the friends of Kåñëa, Nanda and Yaçodä would remember Kåñëa Himself and be satisfied, and the gopés also would be pleased by seeing Nanda and Yaçodä.

When the gopés saw that Uddhava was representing Kåñëa even in his bodily features, they thought that he must be a soul completely surrendered unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They began to contemplate, "Who is this boy who looks just like Kåñëa? He has the same eyes like lotus petals, the same raised nose and beautiful face, and he is smiling in the same way. In all respects he is resembling Kåñëa, Çyämasundara, the beautiful dark boy. He is even dressed exactly like Kåñëa. Where has this boy come from? Who is the fortunate girl who has him for her husband?" Thus they talked among themselves. They were very anxious to know about him, and because they were simply unsophisticated village girls, they surrounded Uddhava.

When the gopés understood that Uddhava had a message from Kåñëa, they became very happy and called him to a secluded place to sit down. They wanted to talk with him very freely and did not want to be embarrassed before unknown persons. They began to welcome him with polite words, in great submissiveness. "We know that you are a most confidential associate of Kåñëa and that He has therefore sent you to Våndävana to give solace to His father and mother. We can understand that family affection is very strong. Even great sages who have taken to the renounced order of life cannot give up family members. Kåñëa has therefore sent you to His father and mother; otherwise He has no further business in Våndävana. He is now in town. What does He have to know about Våndävana Village or the cows' pasturing grounds? These things are not at all useful for Kåñëa because He is now a man in the city.

"Surely He has nothing to do with persons who do not happen to be His family members. Why should one bother about those who are outside the family, especially and specifically those who are attached as the wives of others. Kåñëa is interested in them as long as there is a need of gratification, like the bumblebees who have interest in the flowers as long as they want to take the honey out of them. It is very natural and psychological that a prostitute does not care for her paramour as soon as he loses his money. Similarly, when the citizens find that a government is incapable of giving them full protection, they leave the country. A student, after finishing his education, gives up his relationship with the teacher and the school. A rich man, after taking his reward from his worshiper, gives him up. When the fruit season is over, the birds are no longer interested in the tree. Just after eating in the house of a lord, the guest gives up his relationship with the host. After a forest fire, when there is a scarcity of green grass, the deer and other animals give up the forest. And so a man, after enjoying his girl friend, gives up his connection with her." In this way, all the gopés began to indirectly accuse Kåñëa by citing so many similes.

Uddhava understood that the gopés of Våndävana were all simply absorbed in the thought of Kåñëa and His childhood activities. While talking about Kåñëa with Uddhava, they forgot all about their household business. They even forgot about themselves as their interest in Kåñëa increased more and more.

One of the gopés, namely Çrématé Rädhäräëé, was so much absorbed in thoughts of Kåñëa by dint of Her personal touch with Him that She actually began to talk with a bumblebee which was flying there and trying to touch Her lotus feet. While another gopé was talking with Kåñëa's messenger Uddhava, Çrématé Rädhäräëé took that bumblebee to be a messenger from Kåñëa and began to talk with it as follows. "Bumblebee, you are accustomed to drinking honey from the flowers, and therefore you have preferred to be a messenger of Kåñëa, who is of the same nature as you. I have seen on your moustaches the red powder of kuìkuma, which was smeared on the flower garland of Kåñëa while He was pressing the breast of some other girl who is My competitor. You are feeling very proud by touching that flower, and your moustaches have become reddish. You have come here carrying a message for Me. You are anxious to touch My feet. But my dear bumblebee, let me warn you—don't touch Me! I don't want any messages from your unreliable master. You are the unreliable servant of an unreliable master." It may be that Çrématé Rädhäräëé purposely addressed that bumblebee sarcastically in order to criticize the messenger Uddhava. Indirectly, Çrématé Rädhäräëé saw Uddhava as not only resembling Kåñëa's bodily features but as being equal to Kåñëa. In this way She indicated that Uddhava was as unreliable as Kåñëa Himself. Çrématé Rädhäräëé wanted to give specific reasons why She was dissatisfied with Kåñëa and His messengers.

She addressed the bumblebee, "Your master Kåñëa is exactly of your quality. You sit down on a flower, and after taking a little honey you immediately fly away and sit in another flower and taste. You're just like your master Kåñëa. He gave us the chance of tasting the touch of His lips and then left altogether. I know also that the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé, who is always in the midst of the lotus flower, is constantly engaged in Kåñëa's service. But I do not know why she has become so captivated by Kåñëa. She is attached to Him, although she knows His actual character. As far as we are concerned, we are more intelligent than that goddess of fortune. We are not going to be cheated anymore by Kåñëa or His messengers."

According to expert opinion, Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune is a subordinate expansion of Çrématé Rädhäräëé. As Kåñëa has numerous expansions of Viñëu-mürtis, so His pleasure potency, Rädhäräëé, also has innumerable expansions of goddesses of fortune. Therefore the goddess of fortune, Lakñméjé, is always anxious to be elevated to the position of the gopés.

Çrématé Rädhäräëé continued: "You foolish bumblebee, you are trying to satisfy Me and get a reward by singing the glories of Kåñëa, but it is a useless attempt. We are bereft of all our possessions. We are away from our homes and families. We know very well about Kåñëa. We know even more than you. So whatever you make up about Him will be old stories to us. Kåñëa is now in the city and is better known as the friend of Arjuna. He now has many new girl friends, and they are no doubt very happy in association with Him. Because the lusty burning sensation of their breasts has been satisfied by Kåñëa, they are now happy. If you go there and glorify Kåñëa, they may be pleased to reward you. You are just trying to pacify Me by your behavior as a flatterer, and therefore you have put your head under My feet. But I know the trick which you are trying to play. I know that you are a messenger coming from a great trickster, Kåñëa. Therefore please leave me.

"I can understand that you are very expert in reuniting two opposing parties, but at the same time you must know that I cannot place My reliance upon you, nor upon your master Kåñëa. We left our families, husbands, children and relatives only for Kåñëa, and yet He did not feel any obligation in exchange. He has left us for lost. Do you think we can place our faith in Him again? We know that Kåñëa cannot be long without the association of young women. That is His nature. He is finding difficulty in Mathurä because He is no longer in the village among innocent cowherd girls. He is in the aristocratic society and must be feeling difficulty in making friendships with the young girls. Perhaps you have come here to canvass again or to take us there. But why should Kåñëa expect us to return there? He is greatly qualified to entice all other girls, not only in Våndävana or Mathurä, but all over the universe. His wonderfully enchanting smile is so attractive and the movement of His eyebrows so beautiful that He can call for any woman from the heavenly, middle or plutonic planets. Mahä-Lakñmé, the greatest of all goddesses of fortune, also hankers to render Him some service. In comparison to all these women of the universe, what are we? We are very insignificant.

"Kåñëa advertises Himself as very magnanimous, and He is praised by great saints. His qualifications could be perfectly utilized if He would only show us mercy because we are downtrodden and neglected by Him. You poor messenger, you are only a less intelligent servant. You do not know much about Kåñëa, how ungrateful and hardhearted He has been, not only in this life, but in His previous lives also. We have all heard this from our grandmother, Paurëamäsé. She has informed us that Kåñëa was born in a kñatriya family previous to this birth and was known as Rämacandra. In that birth, instead of killing Väli, an enemy of His friend, in the manner of a kñatriya, He killed him just like a hunter. A hunter takes a secure hiding place and then kills an animal without facing it. So Lord Rämacandra, as a kñatriya, should have fought with Väli face to face, but instigated by His friend, He killed him from behind a tree. Thus He deviated from the religious principles of a kñatriya. Also, He was so attracted by the beauty of Sétä that He converted Çürpaëakhä, the sister of Rävaëa, into an ugly woman by cutting off her nose and ears. Çürpaëakhä proposed an intimate relationship with Him, and as a kñatriya, He should have satisfied her. But He was so selfish that He could not forget Sétädevé and converted Çürpaëakhä into an ugly woman. Before that birth as a kñatriya, He took His birth as a brähmaëa boy known as Vämanadeva and asked charity from Bali Mahäräja. Bali Mahäräja was so magnanimous that he gave Him whatever he had, yet Kåñëa as Vämanadeva ungratefully arrested him just like a crow and pushed him down to the Pätäla kingdom. We know all about Kåñëa and how ungrateful He is. But here is the difficulty: in spite of His being so cruel and hardhearted, it is very difficult for us to give up talking about Him. Not only are we unable to give up this talk, but great sages and saintly persons are also engaged in talking about Him. We gopés of Våndävana do not want to make anymore friendships with this blackish boy, but we do not know how we shall be able to give up remembering and talking about His activities."

Since Kåñëa is absolute, His so-called unkind activities are as relishable as His kind activities. Saintly persons and great devotees like the gopés cannot give up Kåñëa in any circumstances. Lord Caitanya therefore prayed, "Kåñëa, You are free and independent in all respects. You can either embrace me or crush me under Your feet—whatever You like. You may make me brokenhearted by not letting me see You throughout my whole life, but You are my only object of love."

"In my opinion," Çrématé Rädhäräëé continued, "one should not hear about Kåñëa, because as soon as a drop of the nectar of His transcendental activities is poured into the ear, one immediately rises above the platform of duality, attraction and rejection. Being completely freed from the attraction of material attachment, one gives up the attachment for this material world, family, home, wife, children and everything which is materially dear to every person. Being dispossessed of all material acquisition, one makes his relatives and himself unhappy. Then he wanders in search of Kåñëa, either as a human being or in other species of life, even as a bird. It is very difficult to actually understand Kåñëa, His name, His quality, His form, His pastimes, His paraphernalia and His entourage."

Çrématé Rädhäräëé continued to speak to the black messenger of Kåñëa. "Please do not talk anymore about Kåñëa. It is better to talk about something else. We are already doomed, like the black-spotted she-deer in the forest who are enchanted by the sweet musical vibration of the hunter. In the same way, we have been enchanted by the sweet words of Kåñëa, and again and again we are thinking of the rays of the nails of His toes. We are becoming more and more lustful for His association; therefore, I request you not to talk of Kåñëa anymore."

This talk of Rädhäräëé with the bumblebee messenger and Her accusing Kåñëa, and, at the same time, Her inability to give up talking about Him, are symptoms of the topmost transcendental ecstasy, called mahäbhäva. The ecstatic mahäbhäva manifestation is possible only in the persons of Rädhäräëé and Her associates. Great äcäryas like Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé and Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur have analyzed these mahäbhäva speeches of Çrématé Rädhäräëé, and they have described the different sentiments such as udghürëä, bewilderment, and jalpapratijalpa, talking in different ways. In Rädhäräëé is found the science of ujjala, or the brightest jewel or love of God. While Rädhäräëé was talking with the bee and the bee was flying hither and thither, it all of a sudden disappeared from Her sight. She was in full mourning due to separation from Kåñëa and was feeling ecstasy by talking with the bee. But as soon as the bee disappeared, She became almost mad, thinking that the messenger-bee might have returned to Kåñëa to inform Him all about Her talking against Him. "Kåñëa must have been very sorry to hear it," She thought. In this way She was very much overwhelmed with another type of ecstasy.

In the meantime, the bee, flying hither and thither, appeared before Her again. She thought, "Kåñëa is still kind to Me. In spite of the messenger carrying disruptive messages, He is so kind that He has again sent the bee to take Me to Him." Çrématé Rädhäräëé was very careful this time not to say anything against Kåñëa. "My dear friend, I welcome you," she said. "Kåñëa is so kind that He has again sent you. Kåñëa is so kind and affectionate to Me that He has sent you back, fortunately, in spite of your carrying My message against Him. My dear friend, you can ask from Me whatever you want. I shall give you anything because you are so kind upon Me. You have come to take Me to Kåñëa because He is not able to come here. He is surrounded by new girl friends in Mathurä. But you are a tiny creature. How can you take Me there? How will you be able to help Me in meeting Kåñëa while He is taking rest there along with the goddess of fortune and embracing her to His chest? Never mind. Let us forget all these things about My going there or sending you. Please let Me know how Kåñëa is faring in Mathurä. Tell Me if He still remembers His foster father, Nanda Mahäräja, His affectionate mother, Yaçodä, His cowherd friends and His poor friends like us, the gopés. I am sure that He must sometimes sing about us. We served Him just like maidservants, without any payment. Is there any possibility that Kåñëa will again come back and place His arms around us? His limbs are always fragrant with the aguru scent. Please put all these inquiries to Kåñëa."

Uddhava was standing near, and he heard Rädhäräëé talking in this way, as if She had become almost mad after Kåñëa. He was exceedingly surprised at how the gopés were accustomed to think of Kåñëa constantly in that topmost ecstasy of mahäbhäva love. He had brought a message in writing from Kåñëa, and now he wanted to present it before the gopés, just to pacify them. He said, "My dear gopés, your mission of human life is now successful. You are all wonderful devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; therefore you are eligible to be worshiped by all kinds of people. You are worshipable throughout the three worlds because your minds are wonderfully absorbed in the thought of Väsudeva, Kåñëa. He is the goal of all kinds of pious activities and ritualistic performances, such as giving in charity, rigidly following the austerity of vows, undergoing severe penances and igniting the fire of sacrifice. He is the purpose behind the chanting of different mantras, the reading of the Vedas, controlling the senses and concentrating the mind in meditation. These are some of the many different processes for self-realization and attainment of perfection of life. But actually they are only meant for realizing Kåñëa and dovetailing oneself in the transcendental loving service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is the last instruction of Bhagavad-gétä [18.66] also; although there are descriptions of different kinds of processes of self-realization, at the end Kåñëa recommended one should give up everything and simply surrender unto Him. All other processes are meant for teaching one how to surrender ultimately unto the lotus feet of Kåñëa. The Bhagavad-gétä [7.19] also says that this surrendering process is completed by a sincere person executing the processes of self-realization in wisdom and austerity after many births."

Since the perfection of such austerity was completely manifested in the life of the gopés, Uddhava was fully satisfied upon seeing their transcendental position. He continued to say: "My dear gopés, the mentality which you have developed in relationship with Kåñëa is very, very difficult to attain, even for great sages and saintly persons. You have attained the highest perfectional stage of life. It is a great boon for you that you have fixed your mind upon Kåñëa and have decided to have Kåñëa only, giving up your family, home, relatives, husbands and children for the sake of the Supreme Personality. Because your mind is now fully absorbed in Kåñëa, the Supreme Soul, universal love has automatically developed in you. I think myself very fortunate that I have been favored, by your grace, to see you in this situation."

When Uddhava said that he had a message from Kåñëa, the gopés were more interested in hearing the message than in hearing about their exalted position. They did not very much like being praised for their high position. They showed their anxiety to hear the message which Uddhava had brought from Kåñëa. Uddhava said, "My dear gopés, I am especially deputed to carry this message to you, who are such great and gentle devotees. Kåñëa has specifically sent me to you because I am His most confidential servitor."

The written message which Uddhava brought from Kåñëa was not delivered to the gopés by Uddhava, but he personally read it before them. The message was very gravely written, so that not only the gopés, but all empiric philosophers might understand how pure love of God is intrinsically integrated with all the different energies of the Supreme Lord. From Vedic information it is understood that the Supreme Lord has multi-energies, paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate. Also, the gopés were such intimate personal friends of Kåñëa that while He was writing the message for them, He was much moved and could not write distinctly. Uddhava, as the student of Båhaspati, had very sharp intelligence, so instead of handing over the written message, he thought it wise to read it personally and explain it to them.

Uddhava continued: "These are the words from the Personality of Godhead. 'My dear gopés, My dear friends, please know that separation between ourselves is impossible at any time, at any place or under any circumstances, because I am all-pervading.'"

This all-pervasiveness of Kåñëa is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä, both in the Ninth and Seventh Chapters. Kåñëa is all-pervasive in His impersonal feature; everything is resting in Him, but He is not personally present everywhere. In the Seventh Chapter also, it is stated that the five gross elements, earth, water, fire, air and sky, and the three subtle elements, mind, intelligence, and ego, are all His inferior energies. But there is another, superior energy, which is called the living entity. The living entities are also directly part and parcel of Kåñëa. Therefore Kåñëa is the source of both the material and spiritual energies. He is always intermingled with everything as cause and effect. Not only the gopés, but all living entities are always inseparably connected with Kåñëa in all circumstances. The gopés, however, are perfectly and thoroughly in cooperation in their relationship with Kåñëa, whereas the living entities under the spell of mäyä are forgetful of Kåñëa. They think themselves as separate identities having no connection with Kåñëa.

Love of Kåñëa, or Kåñëa consciousness, is therefore the perfectional stage of real knowledge in understanding things as they are. Our minds can never be vacant. The mind is constantly occupied with some kind of thought, and the subject matter of such thought cannot be outside the eight elements of Kåñëa's energy. One who knows this philosophical aspect of all thoughts is actually a wise man, and he surrenders unto Kåñëa. The gopés are the typical example of this perfectional stage of knowledge. They are not simple mental speculators. Their minds are always in Kåñëa. The mind is nothing but the energy of Kåñëa. Actually, any person who can think, feel, act and will cannot be separated from Kåñëa. But the stage in which he can understand his eternal realtionship is called Kåñëa consciousness. The diseased condition in which he cannot understand his eternal relationship with Kåñëa is the contaminated stage, or mäyä. Since the gopés are on the platform of pure transcendental knowledge, their minds are always filled with Kåñëa consciousness. For example, as there is no separation between fire and air, so there is no separation between Kåñëa and the living entities. When the living entities forget Kåñëa, they are not in their normal condition. As for the gopés, because they are always thinking of Kåñëa they are on the absolute stage of perfection in knowledge. The so-called empiric philosophers sometimes think that the path of bhakti is meant for the less intelligent, but unless the so-called man of knowledge comes to the platform of bhakti, his knowledge is certainly impure and imperfect. Actually, the stage of perfecting one's eternal relationship with Kåñëa is love in separation. But that is also illusory because there is no separation. The gopés were never separated from Kåñëa. Even from the philosophical point of view, there was no separation.

The cosmic manifestation is also not separate from Kåñëa. "Nothing is separate from Me; the whole cosmic manifestation is resting on Me and is not separate from Me. Before the creation, I was existing." This is confirmed in the Vedic literature: before creation, there was only Näräyaëa. There were no Brahmä and no Çiva as assistants. The whole cosmic manifestation is manipulated by the three modes of material nature. Brahmä is the incarnation of the quality of passion. It is said that Brahmä created this universe, but Brahmä is the secondary creator; the original creator is Näräyaëa. This is also confirmed by Çaìkaräcärya: näräyaëaù paro 'vyaktät. Näräyaëa is transcendental, beyond this cosmic creation.

Kåñëa creates, maintains, and annihilates the whole cosmic manifestation by expanding Himself in different incarnations. Everything is Kåñëa, and everything is depending on Kåñëa, but He is not perceived in the material energy. Material energy is called mäyä, or illusion. In the spiritual energy, however, Kåñëa is perceived at every step, in all circumstances. This perfectional stage of understanding is present in the gopés. As Kåñëa is always aloof from the cosmic manifestation, although it is completely dependent on Him, so a living entity is also completely aloof from his material conditional life. The material body has developed on the basis of spiritual existence. In the Bhagavad-gétä the whole cosmic manifestation is accepted as the mother of the living entities, and Kåñëa is the father. As the father impregnates the mother by injecting the living entity within the womb, so all the living entities are injected by Kåñëa in the womb of the material nature. They come out in different bodies according to their different fruitive activities. In all circumstances, the living entity is aloof from this material conditional life.

If we simply study our own bodies, we can understand how a living entity is always aloof from this bodily encagement. Every action of the body is taking place by the interaction of the three modes of material nature. We can see at every moment many changes taking place in bodies, but the spirit soul is aloof from all changes. One can neither create nor annihilate nor interfere with the actions of material nature. The living entity is therefore entrapped by the material body and is conditioned in three stages, namely while awake, asleep and unconscious. The mind is acting through all the three conditions of life; the living entity in his sleeping or dreaming condition sees something as real, and in his awake condition he sees the same thing as unreal. It is concluded, therefore, that under certain circumstances he accepts something as real, and under other circumstances he accepts the very same thing as unreal. These matters are the subject matter of study for the empiric philosopher or the säìkhya-yogé. In order to come to the right conclusion, säìkhya-yogés undergo severe austerities and penances. They practice control of the senses and renunciation.

All these different ways of determining the ultimate goal of life are compared to rivers. Kåñëa is the ocean. As the rivers flow down toward the ocean, all attempts for knowledge flow toward Kåñëa. After many, many births of endeavor, when one actually comes to Kåñëa, he attains the perfectional stage. Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä: All are pursuing the path of realizing Me, but those who have adopted courses without any bhakti find their endeavor very troublesome." Kleço ’dhikataras teñäm: Kåñëa cannot be understood unless one comes to the point of bhakti.

Three paths are enunciated in the Gétä: karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga and bhakti-yoga. Those who are too addicted to fruitive activities are advised to perform actions which will bring them to bhakti. Those who are addicted to the frustration of empiric philosophy are also advised to realize bhakti. Karma-yoga is different from ordinary karma, and jïäna-yoga is different from jïäna. Ultimately, as stated by the Lord in the Bhagavad-gétä, bhaktya mäà abhijänäti: only through execution of devotional service can one understand Kåñëa. The perfectional stage of devotional service was achieved by the gopés because they did not care to know anything but Kåñëa. It is confirmed in the Vedas, yasmin eva vijïäte sarvam eva vijïätam bhavanti. This means that simply by knowing Kåñëa all other knowledge is automatically acquired.

Kåñëa continued: "Transcendental knowledge of the Absolute is no longer necessary for you. You were accustomed to love Me from the very beginning of your lives." Knowledge of the Absolute Truth is specifically required for persons who want liberation from material existence. But one who has attained love for Kåñëa is already on the platform of liberation. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [14.26], anyone engaged in unalloyed devotional service is to be considered situated on the transcendental platform of liberation. The gopés were not actually feeling any pangs of material existence, but they were feeling the separation of Kåñëa. Kåñëa therefore said, "My dear gopés, in order to increase your superexcellent love for Me, I have purposely separated Myself from you. I have done this so that you may be in constant meditation on Me."

The gopés are in the perfectional stage of meditation. The yogés are generally more fond of meditation than the execution of devotional service to the Lord, but they do not know that the perfectional stage of devotion is the attainment of the perfection of the yoga system. This constant meditation on Kåñëa by the gopés is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [6.47] to be the topmost yoga. Kåñëa knew very well the psychology of women. When a woman's beloved is away, she thinks of him meditatively, and he is present before her. Kåñëa wanted to teach through the behavior of the gopés. One who is constantly in trance like the gopés surely attains the lotus feet of Kåñëa.

Lord Caitanya taught people in general the method of vipralambha, which is the method of rendering service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead in the feeling of separation. The six Gosvämés also taught worship of Kåñëa in the feeling of the gopés in separation. The prayers of Çréniväsa Äcärya about the Gosvämés explain these matters very clearly. Çréniväsa Äcärya said that the Gosvämés were always absorbed in the ocean of transcendental feelings in the mood of the gopés. When they lived in Våndävana they were searching for Kåñëa, crying, "Where is Kåñëa? Where are the gopés? Where are You, Çrématé Rädhäräëé?" They never said, "We have now seen Rädhä and Kåñëa, and therefore our mission is fulfilled." Their mission remained always unfulfilled; they never met Rädhä and Kåñëa. At the time of the räsa dance, those gopés who could not join the räsa-lélä with Kåñëa gave up their bodies simply by thinking of Him. Absorption in Kåñëa consciousness by feeling separation is thus the quickest method for attainment of the lotus feet of Kåñëa. By the personal statement of Kåñëa, the gopés were convinced about the strength of feelings of separation. They were actually experiencing the supernatural method of Kåñëa worship and were much relieved and happy to understand it.

They began to speak as follows: "We have heard that King Kaàsa, who was always a source of trouble for the Yadu dynasty, has now been killed. This is good news for us. We hope, therefore, that the members of the Yadu dynasty are very happy in the association of Kåñëa, who can fulfill all the desires of His devotees. My dear Uddhava, kindly let us know whether Kåñëa sometimes thinks of us while in the midst of highly enlightened society girls in Mathurä. We know that the women and girls in Mathurä are not village women. They are enlightened and beautiful. Their bashful smiling glances and other feminine features must be very pleasing to Kåñëa. We know very well that Kåñëa is always fond of the behavior of beautiful women. It seems, therefore, that He has been entrapped by the women of Mathurä. My dear Uddhava, will you kindly let us know if Kåñëa sometimes remembers us while He is in the midst of other women?"

Another gopé inquired: "Does He remember that night in the midst of kumadini flowers and moonlight, when Våndävana became exceedingly beautiful? Kåñëa was dancing with us, and the atmosphere was surcharged with the sound of foot bells. We exchanged pleasing conversation then. Does He remember that particular night? We remember that night, and we feel separation. Separation from Kåñëa makes us agitated, as if there were fire in our bodies. He proposed to come back to Våndävana to extinguish the fire, just as a cloud appears in the sky to extinguish the forest fire by its downpour."

Another gopé said, "Kåñëa has killed His enemy, and He has victoriously achieved the kingdom of Kaàsa. Maybe He is married with a king's daughter by this time and living very happily among His kinsmen and friends. Therefore, why should He come to this village of Våndävana?"

Another gopé said, "Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the husband of the goddess of fortune, and He is self-sufficient. He has no business either with us, the girls in the Våndävana forest, or with the city girls in Mathurä. He is the great Supersoul; He has nothing to do with any of us, either here or there."

Another gopé said, "It is an unreasonable hope for us to expect Kåñëa to come back to Våndävana. We should try instead to be happy in disappointment. Even Piìgalä, the great prostitute, said that disappointment is the greatest pleasure. We all know these things, but it is very difficult for us to give up the expectation of Kåñëa's coming back again. Who can forget a solitary conversation with Kåñëa, on whose breast the goddess of fortune always remains, in spite of Kåñëa's not desiring her? My dear Uddhava, Våndävana is the land of rivers, forests and cows. Here the vibration of the flute is heard, and Kåñëa, along with His elder brother, Çré Balaräma, enjoyed the atmosphere in our company. Thus the environment of Våndävana is constantly reminding us of Kåñëa and Balaräma. The impression of His footprints is on the land of Våndävana, which is the residential place of the goddess of fortune, but such signs cannot help us to get Kåñëa."

The gopés further expressed that Våndävana was still full of all opulence and good fortune; there was no scarcity or want in Våndävana as far as material necessities were concerned, but in spite of such opulence they could not forget Kåñëa and Balaräma.

"We are constantly remembering various attractive features of beautiful Kåñëa, His walking, His smiling and His joking words. We have all become lost by the dealings of Kåñëa, and it is impossible for us to forget Him. We are always praying for Him, exclaiming, 'Dear Lord, dear husband of the goddess of fortune, dear Lord of Våndävana and deliverer of the distressed devotees! We are now fallen and merged into an ocean of distress. Please, therefore, come back again to Våndävana and deliver us from this pitiable condition."

Uddhava minutely studied the transcendental abnormal condition of the gopés in their separation from Kåñëa, and he thought it wise to repeat all the pastimes of Çré Kåñëa over and over again. Materialistic persons are always in a burning condition on account of the blazing fire of material miseries. The gopés also were burning in a transcendental blazing fire due to separation from Kåñëa. The blazing fire which was exasperating the gopés, however, is different from the fire of the material world. The gopés constantly want the association of Kåñëa, whereas the materialistic person wants the advantage of material comforts.

It is stated by Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur that Kåñëa saved the cowherd boys from the blazing forest fire within a second, while their eyes were closed. Similarly, Uddhava advised the gopés that they could be saved from the fire of separation by closing their eyes and meditating on the activities of Kåñëa from the very beginning of their association with Him. From the outside, the gopés could visualize all the pastimes of Kåñëa by hearing the descriptions of Uddhava, and from inside they could remember those pastimes. From the instruction of Uddhava, the gopés could understand that Kåñëa was not separate from them. As they were constantly thinking of Kåñëa, Kåñëa was also thinking of them constantly while at Mathurä.

Uddhava's messages and instructions saved the gopés from immediate death, and the gopés acknowledged the benediction from Uddhava. Uddhava practically acted as the preceptor spiritual master of the gopés, and they in return worshiped him as they would worship Kåñëa. It is recommended in authoritative scriptures that the spiritual master should be worshiped on the level of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, because of his being His very confidential servitor, and it is accepted by great authorities that the spiritual master is the external manifestation of Kåñëa. The gopés were relieved from their transcendental burning condition by realizing that Kåñëa was with them. Internally, they remembered His association within their hearts, and externally Uddhava helped them to appreciate Kåñëa by conclusive instructions.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead is described in the scriptures as adhokñaja, which indicates that He is beyond the perception of all material senses. Although He is beyond the perception of material senses, He is present in everyone's heart. At the same time, He is present everywhere by His all-pervasive feature of Brahman. All three transcendental features of the Absolute Truth (Bhagavän the Personality of Godhead, Paramätmä the localized Supersoul, and the all-pervasive Brahman) can be realized simply by studying the condition of the gopés in their meeting with Uddhava, as described by the Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

It is said by Çréniväsa Äcärya that the six Gosvämés were always merged in thoughts of the activities of the gopés. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has also recommended the gopés' method of worship of the Supreme Personality of Godhead as superexcellent. Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé has also recommended that anyone who hears from the right source about the dealings of the gopés with Kåñëa and who follows the instructions will be elevated to the topmost position of devotional service and will be able to give up the lust of material enjoyment.

All the gopés were solaced by the instruction of Uddhava, and they requested him to stay in Våndävana for a few days more. Uddhava agreed to their proposal and stayed with them not only for a few days, but for a few months. He always kept them engaged in thinking of the transcendental message of Kåñëa and His pastimes, and the gopés were feeling as if they were experiencing direct association with Kåñëa. While Uddhava remained in Våndävana, the inhabitants enjoyed his association. As they discussed the activities of Kåñëa, the days passed just like moments. Våndävana's natural atmosphere, with the presence of the River Yamunä, its nice orchards of trees decorated with various fruits, Govardhana Hill, caves, blooming flowers—all combined to inspire Uddhava to narrate Kåñëa's pastimes. The inhabitants enjoyed Uddhava's association in the same way as they enjoyed the association of Kåñëa.

Uddhava was attracted by the attitude of the gopés because they were completely attached to Kåñëa, and Uddhava was inspired by the gopés' anxiety for Kåñëa. He began to offer them his respectful obeisances and composed songs in praise of their transcendental qualities as follows: "Among all the living entities who have accepted the human form of life, the gopés are superexcellently successful in their mission. Their thought is thoroughly absorbed in the lotus feet of Kåñëa. Great sages and saintly persons are also trying to be absorbed in meditation upon the lotus feet of Kåñëa, who is Mukunda Himself, the giver of liberation, but the gopés, having lovingly accepted the Lord, are automatically accustomed to this habit. They do not depend on any yogic practice. The conclusion is that one who has attained the gopés' condition of life does not have to take birth as Lord Brahmä or be born in a brähmaëa family or be initiated as a brähmaëa."

Çré Uddhava confirmed the statement of Bhagavad-gétä [9.32] spoken by Lord Kåñëa; one who takes shelter of Him for the right purpose, be he a çüdra or lower, will attain the highest goal of life. The gopés have set the standard of devotion for the whole world. By following in the footsteps of the gopés by constantly thinking of Kåñëa, one can attain the highest perfectional stage of spiritual life. The gopés were not born of any highly cultured family; they were born of cowherd men, and yet they developed the highest love of Kåñëa. For self-realization or God realization there is no need to take birth in a high family. The only thing needed is ecstatic development of love of God. In achieving perfection in Kåñëa consciousness, no other qualification is required than to be constantly engaged in the loving service of Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the supreme nectar, the reservoir of all pleasure. The effect of taking up Kåñëa consciousness is just like that of drinking nectar; with or without one's knowledge, it will act. The active principle of Kåñëa consciousness will manifest itself everywhere; it does not matter how and where one has taken his birth. Kåñëa will bestow His benediction upon anyone who takes to Kåñëa consciousness, without any doubt. The supreme benediction attained by the gopés in spite of their being born in the family of cowherd men was never attained even by the goddess of fortune herself, and certainly not by the denizens of heaven, though their bodily forms are like lotuses. The gopés are so fortunate that during räsa-lélä Kåñëa personally embraced them with His arms. Kåñëa kissed them face to face. Certainly it is not possible for any women in the three worlds to achieve this except the gopés.

Uddhava appreciated the exalted position of the gopés and wished to fall down and take the dust of their feet on his head. Yet he did not dare to ask the gopés to offer the dust from their feet; perhaps they would not be agreeable. He therefore desired to have his head smeared with the dust of the gopés' feet without their knowledge. He desired to become only an insignificant clump of grass or herbs in the land of Våndävana.

The gopés were so much attracted to Kåñëa that when they heard the vibration of His flute, they instantly left their families, children, honor and feminine bashfulness and ran towards the place where Kåñëa was standing. They did not consider whether they were passing over the road or through the jungles. Imperceptibly, the dust of their feet was bestowed on small grasses and herbs of Våndävana. Not daring to place the dust of the gopés' feet on his own head, Uddhava aspired to have a future birth in the position of a clump of grass and herbs. He would then be able to have the dust of the gopés' feet.

Uddhava appreciated the extraordinary fortune of the gopés, who relieved themselves of all kinds of material contamination by placing on their high, beautiful breasts the lotus feet of Kåñëa, which are not only worshiped by the goddess of fortune, but by such exalted demigods as Brahmä and Lord Çiva, and which are meditated upon by great yogés within their hearts. Thus Uddhava desired to be able to constantly pray to be honored by the dust of the gopés' lotus feet. The gopés' chanting of the transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa has become celebrated all over the three worlds.

After living in Våndävana for some days, Uddhava desired to go back to Kåñëa, and he begged permission to leave from Nanda Mahäräja and Yaçodä. He had a farewell meeting with the gopés, and taking permission of them also, he mounted his chariot to start for Mathurä.

When Uddhava was about to leave, all the inhabitants of Våndävana, headed by Mahäräja Nanda and Yaçodä, came to bid him good-bye and presented him with various kinds of valuable goods secured in Våndävana. They expressed their feelings with tears in their eyes due to intense attachment for Kåñëa. All of them desired benediction from Uddhava. They desired always to remember the glorious activities of Kåñëa and wanted their minds to be always fixed upon His lotus feet, their words always engaged in glorifying Kåñëa, and their bodies always engaged in bowing down and constantly remembering Him. This prayer of the inhabitants of Våndävana is the superexcellent type of self-realization. The method is very simple: to fix the mind always on the lotus feet of Kåñëa, to talk always of Kåñëa without passing on to any other subject matter, and to engage the body in Kåñëa's service constantly. Specifically in this human form of life, one should engage his life, his resources, words and intelligence for the service of the Lord. Such kinds of activities only can elevate a human being to the highest level of perfection. This is the verdict of all authorities.

The inhabitants of Våndävana said: "By the will of the supreme authority and according to the results of our own work, we may take our birth anywhere. It doesn't matter where we are born, but our only prayer is that we may simply be engaged in Kåñëa consciousness." A pure devotee of Lord Kåñëa never desires to be promoted to the heavenly planets, or even to Vaikuëöha or Goloka Våndävana, because he has no desire for his own personal satisfaction. A pure devotee regards both heaven and hell to be on an equal level. Without Kåñëa, heaven is hell; and with Kåñëa, hell is heaven. When Uddhava had sufficiently honored the worship of the pure devotees of Våndävana, he returned to Mathurä and to his master, Kåñëa. After offering respects by bowing down before Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, he began to describe the wonderful devotional life of the inhabitants of Våndävana. He presented all of the gifts given by the inhabitants of Våndävana to Vasudeva, the father of Kåñëa, and Ugrasena, the grandfather of Kåñëa.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-sixth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Delivery of the Message of Kåñëa to the Gopés."

KB 1970-1-47 / Kåñëa Pleases His Devotees

47 / Kåñëa Pleases His Devotees

For days together, Kåñëa heard from Uddhava all the details of his visit to Våndävana, of the condition of His father and mother, and of the gopés and the cowherd boys. Lord Kåñëa was fully satisfied that Uddhava was able to solace them by his instruction and by the message delivered to them.

Lord Kåñëa then decided to go to the house of Kubjä, the hunchback woman who had pleased Him by offering Him sandalwood when He was entering the city of Mathurä. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.22], Kåñëa always tries to please His devotees, and the devotees try to please Kåñëa. As the devotees always think of Kåñëa within their hearts, so Kåñëa also thinks of His devotees within Himself. When Kubjä was converted into a beautiful society girl, she wanted Kåñëa to come to her place so that she could try to receive and worship Him in her own way. Society girls generally try to satisfy their clients by offering their bodies to the men to enjoy. But this society girl, Kubjä, was actually captivated by a lust to satisfy her senses with Kåñëa. When Kåñëa desired to go to the house of Kubjä, He certainly had no desire for sense gratification. By supplying the sandalwood pulp to Kåñëa, Kubjä had already satisfied His senses. On the plea of her sense gratification, He decided to go to her house, not actually for sense gratification, but to turn her into a pure devotee. Kåñëa is always served by many thousands of goddesses of fortune; therefore He has no need to satisfy His senses by going to a society girl. But as He is kind to everyone, He decided to go there. It is said that the moon does not withhold its shining from the courtyard of a crooked person. Similarly, Kåñëa's transcendental mercy is never denied to anyone, whether one has rendered service unto Him through lust, anger, fear or pure love. In the Caitanya-caritämåta [M. 22.16] it is stated that if one wants to serve Kåñëa and at the same time wants to satisfy his own lusty desires, Kåñëa will handle it so that the devotee forgets his lusty desire and becomes fully purified and constantly engaged in the service of the Lord.

In order to fulfill His past promise, Kåñëa, along with Uddhava, went to the house of Kubjä. When Kåñëa reached her house, He saw that it was completely decorated in a way to excite the lusty desires of a man. This suggests that there were many nude pictures, on top of which were canopies and flags embroidered with pearl necklaces, along with comfortable beds and cushioned chairs. The rooms were provided with flower garlands and were nicely scented with incense and sprinkled with scented water. And the rooms were illuminated by nice lamps.

When Kubjä saw that Lord Kåñëa had come to her house in order to fulfill His promised visit, she immediately got up from the chair to receive Him. Accompanied by her many girl friends, she began to talk with Him with great respect and honor. After offering Him a nice place to sit, she worshiped Lord Kåñëa in a manner just suitable to her position. Uddhava was similarly received by Kubjä and her girl friends, but he was not on an equal level with Kåñëa, and he simply sat down on the floor.

Without wasting time, as one does in such situations, Kåñëa entered the bedroom of Kubjä. In the meantime, Kubjä took her bath and smeared her body with sandalwood pulp. She dressed herself with nice garments, valuable jewelry, ornaments and flower garlands. Chewing betel nut and other intoxicating eatables and spraying herself with scents, she appeared before Kåñëa. Her smiling glance and moving eyes were full of feminine bashfulness as she stood gracefully before Lord Kåñëa, who is known as Mädhava, the husband of the goddess of fortune. When Kåñëa saw that Kubjä was hesitating to come before Him, He immediately caught hold of her hand, which was decorated with bangles. With great affection, He dragged her beside Him and made her sit by His side. Simply by having previously supplied pulp of sandalwood to the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, Kubjä became free from all sinful reactions and eligible to enjoy with Him. She then took Kåñëa's lotus feet and placed them on her breasts, which were burning with the blazing fire of lust. By smelling the fragrance of Kåñëa's lotus feet, she immediately became relieved of all lusty desires. She was thus allowed to embrace Kåñëa with her two arms and thus mitigate her long-cherised desire to have Kåñëa as a visitor in her house.

It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [14.26] that without being freed of all material sinful reactions, one cannot be engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. Simply by supplying sandalwood pulp to Kåñëa, Kubjä was thus rewarded. She was not trained to worship Kåñëa in any other way; therefore she wanted to satisfy Him by her profession. It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.32] that the Lord can be worshiped even by one's profession, if it is sincerely offered for the pleasure of the Lord. Kubjä then told Kåñëa, "My dear friend, kindly remain with me at least for a few days. Enjoy with me, You and Your lotus-eyed friend. I cannot leave You immediately. Please grant my request."

As stated in the Vedic versions, the Supreme Personality of Godhead has multi-potencies. According to expert opinion, Kubjä represents the puruña-çakti potency of Kåñëa, just as Çrématé Rädhäräëé represents His cit-çakti potency. Although she requested Kåñëa to remain with her for some days, Kåñëa politely impressed upon her that it was not possible for Him to stay. Kåñëa visits this material world occasionally, whereas His connection with the spiritual world is eternal. Kåñëa is always present either in the Vaikuëöha planets or in the Goloka Våndävana planet. The technical term for His presence in the spiritual world is prakaöa-lélä.

After satisfying Kubjä with sweet words, Kåñëa returned to His place along with Uddhava. There is a warning in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam that Kåñëa is not very easily worshiped because He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the chief among the Viñëu-tattvas. To worship Kåñëa or have association with Him is not a very easy job. Specifically, there is a warning for devotees who are attracted to Kåñëa through conjugal love; it is not good for them to desire to have sense gratification by direct association with Kåñëa. Actually, the activities of sense gratification are material. In the spiritual world there are symptoms like kissing and embracing, but there is no sense-gratificatory process as it exists in the material world. This warning is specifically for those known as sahajiyä, who take it for granted that Kåñëa is an ordinary human being. They desire to enjoy sex life with Him in a perverted way. In a spiritual relationship, sense gratification is most insignificant. Anyone who desires a relationship of perverted sense gratification with Kåñëa must be considered to be less intelligent. His mentality requires to be reformed.

After a while, Kåñëa fulfilled His promise to visit Akrüra at his house. Akrüra was in relationship with Kåñëa as His servitor, and Kåñëa wanted to get some service from him. He went there accompanied by both Lord Balaräma and Uddhava. When Kåñëa, Balaräma and Uddhava were approaching the house of Akrüra, Akrüra came forward, embraced Uddhava and offered respectful obeisances, bowing down before Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma. Kåñëa, Balaräma and Uddhava offered him obeisances in turn and were offered appropriate sitting places by Akrüra. When all were comfortably seated, Akrüra washed their feet and sprinkled the water on his head. Then he offered nice flowers and sandalwood pulp in regular worship. All three of them became very satisfied by the behavior of Akrüra. Akrüra then bowed down before Kåñëa, putting his head on the ground. Then, keeping Kåñëa's lotus feet on his lap, Akrüra began to gently massage them. When Akrüra was fully satisfied in the presence of Kåñëa and Balaräma, his eyes became filled with tears of love for Kåñëa, and he began to offer his prayers as follows.

"My dear Lord Kåñëa, it is very kind of You to have killed Kaàsa and his associates. You have delivered the whole family of the Yadu dynasty from the greatest calamity. Your saving of the great Yadu dynasty will always be remembered by them. My dear Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, You are the original personality from whom everything has emanated. You are the original cause of all causes. You have inconceivable energy, and You are all-pervasive. But for Yourself, there is no other cause and effect, gross or subtle. You are the Supreme Brahman realized by the study of the Vedas. By Your inconceivable energy, You are actually visible before us. You create this cosmic manifestation by Your own potencies, and You enter into it Yourself. As the five material elements, earth, water, fire, air, and sky, are distributed in everything manifested by different kinds of bodies, so You alone enter into different varieties of bodies, created by Your own energy. You enter the body as the individual soul as well as independently as the Supersoul. The material body is created by Your inferior energy. The living entities, individual souls, are part and parcel of You, and the Supersoul is Your localized representation. This material body, the living entity and the Supersoul constitute an individual living being, but originally they are all different energies of the one Supreme Lord.

"In the material world, You are creating, maintaining and dissolving the whole manifestation by interaction of three qualities, namely goodness, passion and ignorance. You are not implicated by the activities of those material qualities because Your supreme knowledge is never overcome, as is the case with the individual living entity."

As the Supreme Lord enters into this material creation and thus the creation, maintenance and destruction are going on in their due course, so the part and parcel living entity enters the material elements and has his material body created for him. The difference between the living entity and the Lord is that the living entity is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord and has the tendency to be overcome by the interaction of material qualities. Kåñëa, the Parambrahman or the Supreme Brahman, being always situated in full knowledge, is never overcome by such activities. Therefore Kåñëa's name is Acyuta, meaning He who never falls down. Kåñëa's knowledge of spiritual identity is never overcome by material action, whereas the identity of the minute part and parcel living entities is prone to be overcome by material action. The individual living entities are eternally part and parcel of God. As minute sparks of the original fire, Kåñëa, they have the tendency to become extinguished.

Akrüra continued: "The less intelligent class of men misunderstand Your transcendental form to be also made of material energy. That concept is not at all applicable to You. Actually, You are all spiritual, and there is no difference between You and Your body. Because of this, there is no question of Your being conditioned or liberated. You are ever-liberated in any condition of life. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.11], 'Only the fools and rascals consider You to be an ordinary man.' To consider Your Lordship to be one of us, conditioned by the material nature, is a mistake due to our imperfect knowledge. When people deviate from the original knowledge of the Vedas, they try to identify the ordinary living entities with Your Lordship. Your Lordship has appeared on this earth in Your original form in order to reestablish the real knowledge that the living entities are neither one with nor equal to the Supreme God. My dear Lord, You are always situated in uncontaminated goodness (çuddha-sattva). Your appearance is necessary to reestablish actual Vedic knowledge, as opposed to the atheistic philosophy which tries to establish that God and living entities are one and the same. My dear Lord Kåñëa, this time You have appeared in the home of Vasudeva as His son, along with Your plenary expansion, Çré Balaräma. Your mission is to kill all the atheistic royal families, along with their huge military strength. You have advented Yourself to minimize the overburden of the world, and in order to fulfill this mission, You have glorified the dynasty of Yadu, appearing in the family as one of its members.

"My dear Lord, today my home has become purified by Your presence. I have become the most fortunate person in the world. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is worshipable by all different kinds of demigods, Pitås, living entities, kings and emperors, and who is the Supersoul of everything, has come into my home. The water of His lotus feet is purifying the three worlds, and now He has kindly come to my place. Who is there in the three worlds among factually learned men who will not take shelter of Your lotus feet and surrender unto You? Who, knowing well that no one can be as affectionate as You are to Your devotees, is so foolish that he will decline to become Your devotee? Throughout the Vedic literature it is declared that You are the dearmost friend of every living entity. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä: suhådäm sarva-bhütänäm. You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, completely capable of fulfilling the desires of Your devotees. You are the real friend of everyone. In spite of giving Yourself to Your devotees, You are never depleted of Your original potency. Your potency neither decreases nor increases in volume.

"My dear Lord, it is very difficult for even the great mystic yogés and demigods to ascertain Your movement. You cannot be approached by them, and yet out of Your causeless mercy You have kindly consented to come to my home. This is the most auspicious moment in the journey of my material existence. By Your grace only, I can just understand that my home, my wife, my children and my worldly possessions are all different bonds to material existence. Please cut the knot and save me from this entanglement of false society, friendship and love."

Lord Çré Kåñëa was very pleased by Akrüra's offering of prayers. His smile was captivating Akrüra more and more. The Lord replied him as follows: "My dear Akrüra, in spite of your submissiveness, I consider you to be My superior, on the level with My father and teacher and most well-wishing friend. You are, therefore, worshipable by Me, and since You are My uncle, I am always to be protected by you. I desire to be maintained by you because I am one of your own children. Apart from this filial relationship, you are always to be worshiped. Anyone who desires good fortune must offer his respectful obeisances unto personalities like you. You are more than the demigods. People go to worship the demigods when they are in need of some sense gratification; the demigods offer benediction to their devotees after being worshiped by them. But a devotee like Akrüra is always ready to offer the greatest benediction to the people. A saintly person or devotee is free to offer benediction to everyone, whereas the demigods can offer benediction only after being worshiped. One can take advantage of the place of pilgrimage only after going there. By worshiping the particular demigod, it takes a long time for fulfillment of the desire; but saintly persons like you, My dear Akrüra, can immediately fulfill all the desires of the devotees. My dear Akrüra, you are always our friend and well-wisher. You are always ready to act for our welfare. Kindly, therefore, go to Hastinäpura and see what arrangement has been made for the Päëòavas."

Kåñëa was very anxious to know about the sons of Päëòu, because at a very young age, they had lost their father. Being very friendly to His devotees, Kåñëa was anxious to know about them, and therefore He deputed Akrüra to go to Hastinäpura and get information of the real situation. Kåñëa continued to say, "I have heard that after the death of King Päëòu, his young sons, Yudhiñöhira, Bhéma, Arjuna, Nakula and Sahadeva, along with their widowed mother, have come under the charge of Dhåtaräñöra, who is to look after them as their guardian. But I have also heard that Dhåtaräñöra is not only blind from birth, but also blind in his affection for his cruel son, Duryodhana. The five Päëòavas are the sons of King Päëòu, but Dhåtaräñöra, due to his plans and designs, is not favorably disposed towards the Päëòavas. Kindly go there and study how Dhåtaräñöra is dealing with the Päëòavas. On receipt of your report, I shall consider how to favor the Päëòavas." In this way the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, ordered Akrüra to go to Hastinäpura, and then He returned home, accompanied by Balaräma and Uddhava.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-seventh Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kåñëa Pleases His Devotees."

KB 1970-1-48 / Ill-motivated Dhåtaräñöra

48 / Ill-motivated Dhåtaräñöra

Thus being ordered by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, Akrüra visited Hastinäpura. Hastinäpura is said to be the site of what is now New Delhi. The part of New Delhi, which is still known as Indraprastha, is accepted by people in general as the old capital of the Päëòavas. The very name Hastinäpura suggests that there were many hastés, or elephants. Because the Päëòavas kept many elephants in the capital, it was called Hastinäpura. Keeping elephants is a very expensive job; to keep many elephants, therefore, the kingdom must be very rich, and Hastinäpura was full of elephants, horses, chariots and other opulences. When Akrüra reached Hastinäpura, he saw that the capital was full of all kinds of opulences. The kings of Hastinäpura were taken to be the ruling kings of the whole world. Their fame was widely spread throughout the entire kingdom, and their administration was conducted under the good counsel of learned brähmaëas.

After seeing the very opulent capital city, Akrüra met King Dhåtaräñöra. He also saw grandfather Bhéñma sitting with him. After meeting them, he went to see Vidura and then Vidura's sister, Kunté. One after another, he saw the son of Somadatta, and the King of Bähléka, Droëäcärya, Kåpäcärya, Karëa and Suyodhana. (Suyodhana is another name of Duryodhana.) He saw the five Päëòava brothers and other friends and relatives living in the city. Akrüra was known as the son of Gändé, so whomever he met was very pleased to receive him. He was offered a good seat at his receptions, and he inquired all about his relatives' welfare and other activities.

Since he was deputed by Lord Kåñëa to visit Hastinäpura, it is understood that he was very intelligent in studying a diplomatic situation. Dhåtaräñöra was unlawfully occupying the throne after the death of the King Päëòu, despite the presence of Päëòu's sons. Akrüra wanted to study the whole situation by remaining there. He could understand very well that ill-motivated Dhåtaräñöra was much inclined in favor of his own sons. In fact, Dhåtaräñöra had already usurped the kingdom and was now instigating and planning to dispose of the five Päëòava brothers. Akrüra knew also that all the sons of Dhåtaräñöra, headed by Duryodhana, were very crooked politicians. Dhåtaräñöra did not act in accordance with the good instruction given by Bhéñma and Vidura, but he was being conducted by the ill instruction of such persons as Karëa, Çakuni and others. Akrüra decided to stay in Hastinäpura for a few months to study the whole political situation.

Gradually Akrüra learned from Kunté and Vidura that Dhåtaräñöra was very intolerant and envious of the five Päëòava brothers because of their extraordinary learning in military science and their greatly developed bodily strength. They acted as true chivalrous heroes, exhibited all the good qualities of kñatriyas, and were very responsible princes, always thinking of the welfare of the citizens. Akrüra also learned that the envious Dhåtaräñöra, in consultation with his ill-advised son, had tried to kill the Päëòavas by poisoning them.

Akrüra happened to be one of the cousins of Kunté; therefore, after meeting him, she began to inquire about her paternal relatives. Thinking of her birthplace, she began to cry. She asked Akrüra whether her father, mother, brothers, sisters and other friends at home were still remembering her. She especially inquired about Kåñëa and Balaräma, her glorious nephews. She asked: "Does Kåñëa, who is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is very affectionate to His devotees, remember my sons? Does Balaräma remember us?" Inside herself, Kunté felt like a she-deer in the midst of tigers, and actually her position was like that. After the death of her husband, King Päëòu, she was supposed to take care of the five Päëòava children, but Dhåtaräñöra was always planning to kill them. She was certainly living as a poor innocent animal in the midst of several tigers. Being a devotee of Lord Kåñëa, she was always thinking of Him and expecting that one day Kåñëa would come and save them from their dangerous position. She inquired from Akrüra whether Kåñëa proposed to come to advise the fatherless Päëòavas how to get free of the intriguing policy of Dhåtaräñöra and his sons. By talking with Akrüra about all these affairs, she felt herself helpless and began to exclaim: "My dear Kåñëa, my dear Kåñëa, You are the supreme mystic, the Supersoul of the universe. You are the real well-wisher of the whole universe. My dear Govinda, at this time You are far away from me, yet I pray to surrender unto Your lotus feet. At the present moment I am very much griefstricken with my five fatherless sons. I can fully understand that but for Your lotus feet there is no shelter or protection. Your lotus feet can deliver all aggrieved souls because You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead. One can be safe from the clutches of repeated birth and death by Your mercy only. My dear Kåñëa, You are the supreme pure one, the Supersoul and the master of all yogés. What can I say? I can simply offer my respectful obeisances unto You. Accept me as Your fully surrendered devotee."

Although Kåñëa was not present before her, Kunté offered her prayers to Him as if she were in His presence face to face. This is possible for anyone following in the footsteps of Kunté. Kåñëa does not have to be physically present everywhere. He is actually present everywhere by spiritual potency, and one simply has to surrender unto Him sincerely. When Kunté was offering her prayers very feelingly to Kåñëa, she could not check herself and began to cry loudly before Akrüra. Vidura was also present, and both Akrüra and Vidura became very sympathetic to the mother of the Päëòavas. They began to solace her by glorifying her sons, Yudhiñöhira, Arjuna and Bhéma. They pacified her, saying that her sons were extraordinarily powerful; she should not be perturbed about them, since they were born of great demigods, Yamaräja, Indra and Väyu.

Akrüra decided to return and report on the extreme circumstances in which he found Kunté and her five sons. He first wanted to give good advice to Dhåtaräñöra, who was so favorably inclined toward his own son and unfavorably inclined toward the Päëòavas. When Kunté and Dhåtaräñöra were sitting among friends and relatives, Akrüra began to address him, calling him "Värcitravérya." Värcitravérya means the son of Vicitravérya. Vicitravérya was the name of the father of Dhåtaräñöra, but Dhåtaräñöra was not actually the begotten son of Vicitravérya. He was the begotten son of Vyäsadeva. Formerly it was the system that if a man were unable to beget a child, his brother could beget a child in the womb of his wife. That system is now forbidden in this age of Kali. Akrüra called Dhåtaräñöra "Värcitravérya" sarcastically because he was not actually begotten by his father. He was the son of Vyäsadeva. When a child was begotten in the wife by the husband's brother, the child was claimed by the husband, but of course the child was not begotten by the husband. This sarcastic remark pointed out that Dhåtaräñöra was falsely claiming the throne on heriditary grounds. Actually the son of Päëòu was the rightful king, and in the presence of Päëòu's sons, the Päëòavas, Dhåtaräñöra should not have occupied the throne.

Akrüra then said, "My dear son of Vicitravérya, you have unlawfully usurped the throne of the Päëòavas. Anyway, somehow or other you are now on the throne. Therefore I beg to advise you to please rule the kingdom on moral and ethical principles. If you do so and try to teach your subjects in that way, then your name and fame will be perpetual." Akrüra hinted that although Dhåtaräñöra was ill-treating his nephews, the Päëòavas, they happened to be his subjects. "Even if you treat them not as the owners of the throne, but as your subjects, you should impartially think of their welfare as though they were your own sons. But if you do not follow this principle and act in just the opposite way, then you will be unpopular among your subjects, and in the next life you will have to live in a hellish condition. I therefore hope you will treat your sons and the sons of Päëòu equally. Akrüra hinted that if Dhåtaräñöra did not treat the Päëòavas and his sons as equals, then surely there would be a fight between the two camps of cousins. Since the Päëòavas cause was just, they would come out victorious, and the sons of Dhåtaräñöra would be killed. This was a prophecy told by Akrüra to Dhåtaräñöra.

Akrüra further advised Dhåtaräñöra, "In this material world, no one can remain as an eternal companion to another. By chance only we assemble together in the family, in the society, in the community or in the nation, but at the end, because every one of us has to give up the body, we must be separated. One should not, therefore, be unnecessarily affectionate toward family members." Dhåtaräñöra's affection was also unlawful and did not show much intelligence. In plain words, Akrüra hinted to Dhåtaräñöra that his staunch family affection was due to his gross ignorance of fact. Although we appear to be combined together in family, society or nation, each one of us has an individual destiny. Everyone takes birth according to individual past work; therefore everyone has to individually enjoy or suffer the result of his own karma. There is no possibility of improving one's destiny by cooperate living. Sometimes it happens that one's father accumulates wealth by illegal ways, and the son takes away the money, although it is hard-earned by the father. It is just like a small fish in the ocean who eats the material body of the large, old fish. One ultimately cannot accumulate wealth illegaly for the gratification of his family, society, community or nation. That many great empires which developed in the past are no longer existing because their wealth was squandered away by later descendants is an illustration of this principle. One who does not know this subtle law of fruitive activities and thus gives up the principles of moral and ethical principles only carries with him the reactions of his sinful activities. His ill-gotten wealth and possessions are taken by someone else, and he goes to the darkest region of hellish life. One should not, therefore, accumulate more wealth than is alloted to him by destiny; otherwise he will be factually blind to his own interest. Instead of fulfilling his self-interest, he will act in just the opposite way for his own downfall.

Akrüra continued: "My dear Dhåtaräñöra, I beg to advise you not to be blind about the fact of this material existence. Material conditional life, either in distress or in happiness, is to be accepted as a dream. One should try to bring his mind and senses under control and live very peacefully for spiritual advancement in Kåñëa consciousness." In the Caitanya-caritämåta it is said that except for persons who are in Kåñëa consciousness, everyone is always in a disturbed condition of mind and is full of anxiety. Even those who are trying for liberation, or merging into the Brahman effulgence, or the yogés who are trying to achieve perfection in mystic power, cannot have peace of mind. Pure devotees of Kåñëa have no demands to make of Kåñëa. They are simply satisfied with service to Him. Actual peace and mental tranquility can be attained only in perfect Kåñëa consciousness.

After hearing moral instructions from Akrüra, Dhåtaräñöra replied: "My dear Akrüra, you are very charitable in giving me good instructions, but unfortunately I cannot accept it. A person who is destined to die does not utilize the effect of nectar, although it may be administered to him. I can understand that your instructions are very valuable. Unfortunately, they do not stay in my flickering mind, just as the glittering lightning in the sky does not stay in a fixed cloud. I can understand only that no one can stop the onward progress of the supreme will. I understand that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, has appeared in the family of the Yadus in order to decrease the overburdened load of this earth."

Dhåtaräñöra gave hints to Akrüra that he had complete faith in Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. At the same time, he was very much partial to his family members. In the very near future, Kåñëa would vanquish all the members of his family, and in a helpless condition, Dhåtaräñöra would take shelter of Kåñëa's feet. In order to show His special favor to a devotee, Kåñëa usually takes away all the objects of his material affection. He thus forces the devotee to be materially helpless, with no alternative than to accept the lotus feet of Kåñëa. This actually happened to Dhåtaräñöra after the end of the Battle of Kurukñetra.

Dhåtaräñöra could realize two opposing factors acting before him. He could understand that Kåñëa was there to remove all the unnecessary burdens of the world. His sons were an unnecessary burden, and so he expected that they would be killed. At the same time, he could not rid himself of his unlawful affection for his sons. Understanding these two contradictory factors, he began to offer his respectful obeisances to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. "The contradictory ways of material existence are very difficult to understand; they can only be taken as the inconceivable execution of the plan of the Supreme, who by His inconceivable energy creates this material world and enters into it and sets into action the three modes of nature. When everything is created, He enters into each and every living entity and into the smallest atom. No one can understand the incalculable plans of the Supreme Lord."

After hearing this statement, Akrüra could clearly understand that Dhåtaräñöra was not going to change his policy of discriminating against the Päëòavas in favor of his sons. He at once took leave of his friends in Hastinäpura and returned to his home in the kingdom of the Yadus. After returning home, he vividly informed Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma of the actual situation in Hastinäpura and the intentions of Dhåtaräñöra. Akrüra was sent to Hastinäpura by Kåñëa to study. By the grace of the Lord, he was successful and informed Kåñëa about the actual situation.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-eighth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Ill-motivated Dhåtaräñöra."

KB 1970-1-49 / Kåñëa Erects the Dvärakä Fort

49 / Kåñëa Erects the Dvärakä Fort

After his death, Kaàsa's two wives became widows. According to Vedic civilization, a woman is never independent. She has three stages of life: In childhood a woman should live under the protection of her father, a youthful woman should live under the protection of her young husband, and in the event of the death of her husband she should live either under the protection of her grown-up children, or if she has no grown-up children, she must go back to her father and live as a widow under his protection. It appears that Kaàsa had no grown-up sons. After becoming widows, his wives returned to the shelter of their father. Kaàsa had two queens. One was Asti, and the other Präpti, and both happened to be the daughters of King Jaräsandha, the lord of the Behar Province (known in those days as Magadharaja). After reaching home, both queens explained their awkward position following Kaàsa's death. The King of Magadha, Jaräsandha, was mortified on hearing their pitiable condition due to the slaughter. When informed of the death of Kaàsa, Jaräsandha decided on the spot that he would rid the world of all the members of the Yadu dynasty. He decided that since Kåñëa had killed Kaàsa, the whole dynasty of the Yadus should be killed.

He began to make extensive arrangements to attack the kingdom of Mathurä with his innumerable military phalanxes, consisting of many thousands of chariots, horses, elephants and infantry soldiers. Jaräsandha prepared thirteen such military phalanxes in order to retaliate the death of Kaàsa. Taking with him all his military strength, he attacked the capital of the Yadu kings, Mathurä, surrounding it from all directions. Çré Kåñëa, who appeared as an ordinary human being, saw the immense strength of Jaräsandha, which appeared as an ocean about to cover a beach at any moment. He also perceived that the inhabitants of Mathurä were overwhelmed with fear. He began to think within Himself about the situation of His mission as an incarnation and how to tackle the present situation before Him. His mission was to diminish the overburdened population of the whole world; therefore He took the opportunity of facing so many men, chariots, elephants, and horses. The military strength of Jaräsandha had appeared before Him, and He decided to kill the entire force of Jaräsandha so that they would not be able to go back and again reorganize their military strength.

While Lord Kåñëa was thinking in that way, two military chariots, fully equipped with drivers, weapons, flags and other implements, arrived for Him from outer space. Kåñëa saw the two chariots present before Him, and immediately addressed His attendant brother, Balaräma, who is also known as Saìkarñaëa: "My dear elder brother, You are the best among the Äryans, You are the Lord of the universe, and specifically, You are the protector of the Yadu dynasty. The members of the Yadu dynasty sense great danger before the soldiers of Jaräsandha, and they are very much aggrieved. Just to give them protection, Your chariot is also here, filled with military weapons. I request You to sit down on Your chariot and kill all these soldiers, the entire military strength of the enemy. Naturally, both of Us have descended on this earth just to annihilate such unnecessary bellicose forces and to give protection to the pious devotees. So we have the opportunity to fulfill Our mission. Please let Us execute it." Thus Kåñëa and Balaräma, the descendants of the Gadaha King, Daçärha, decided to annihilate the thirteen military companies of Jaräsandha.

Kåñëa went upon the chariot on which Däruka was the driver and with a small army, and to the blowing of conchshells, He came out of the city of Mathurä. Curiously enough, although the other party was equipped with greater military strength, just after hearing the vibration of Kåñëa's conchshell, their hearts were shakened. When Jaräsandha saw both Balaräma and Kåñëa, he was a little bit compassionate, because both Kåñëa and Balaräma happened to be related to him as grandsons. He specifically addressed Kåñëa as Puruñädhama, meaning the lowest among men. Actually Kåñëa is known in all Vedic literatures as Puruñottama, the highest among men. Jaräsandha had no intention of addressing Kåñëa as Puruñottama, but great scholars have determined the true meaning of the word puruñädhama to be "one who makes all other personalities go downward." Actually no one can be equal to or greater than the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Jaräsandha said, "It will be a great dishonor for me to fight with boys like Kåñëa and Balaräma." Because Kåñëa had killed Kaàsa, Jaräsandha specifically addressed Him as the killer of His own relatives. Kaàsa had killed so many of his own nephews, yet Jaräsandha did not take notice of it; but because Kåñëa had killed His maternal uncle, Kaàsa, Jaräsandha tried to criticize Him. That is the way of demoniac dealing. Demons do not try to find their own faults, but try to find the faults of their friends. Jaräsandha also criticized Kåñëa for not even being a kñatriya. Because He was raised by Mahäräja Nanda, Kåñëa was not a kñatriya, but a vaiçya. Vaiçyas are generally called guptas, and the word gupta can also be used to mean "hidden." So Kåñëa was both hidden and raised by Nanda Mahäräja. Jaräsandha accused Kåñëa of three faults: that He killed His own maternal uncle, that He was hidden in His childhood, and that He was not even a kñatriya. And therefore Jaräsandha felt ashamed to fight with Him.

Next he turned toward Balaräma and addressed Him: "You, Balaräma! If You like You can fight along with Him, and if You have patience, then You can wait to be killed by my arrows. Thus You can be promoted to heaven." It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.37] that a kñatriya can become benefited in two ways while fighting. If a kñatriya gains victory in the fight, he enjoys the results of victory, but even if he is killed in the fight, he is promoted to the heavenly kingdom.

After hearing Jaräsandha speak in that way, Kåñëa answered: "My dear King Jaräsandha, those who are heroes do not talk much. Rather, they show their prowess. Because you are talking much, it appears that you are assured of your death in this battle. We do not care to hear you anymore, because it is useless to hear the words of a person who is going to die or one who is very distressed." In order to fight with Kåñëa, Jaräsandha surrounded Him from all sides with great military strength, and the sun appeared covered by the cloudy air and dust. Similarly, Kåñëa, the supreme sun, was covered by the military strength of Jaräsandha. Kåñëa's and Balaräma's chariots were marked with pictures of Garuòa and palm trees. The women of Mathurä were all standing on the tops of the houses and palaces and gates to see the wonderful fight, but when Kåñëa's chariot was surrounded by Jaräsandha's military force, they became so frightened that some of them fainted. Kåñëa saw Himself overwhelmed by the military strength of Jaräsandha. His small number of soldiers were being harassed by them, so He immediately took up His bow, named Çärìga.

He began to take His arrows from their case, and one after another He set them on the bowstring and shot them toward the enemy. They were so accurate that the elephants, horses and infantry soldiers of Jaräsandha were quickly killed. The incessant arrows thrown by Kåñëa appeared as a whirlwind of blazing fire killing all the military strength of Jaräsandha. As Kåñëa released His arrows, gradually all the elephants began to fall down, their heads severed by the arrows. Similarly, all the horses fell, and the chariots also, along with their flags. The chariot fighters and the chariot drivers fell as well. Almost all the infantry soldiers fell on the field of battle, their heads, hands and legs cut off. In this way, many thousands of elephants and horses were killed, and their blood began to flow just like the waves of a river. In that river, the severed arms of the men appeared to be snakes, their heads appeared to be tortoises, and the dead bodies of the elephants appeared to be small islands. The dead horses appeared to be sharks. By the arrangement of the supreme will, there was a great river of blood filled with paraphernalia. The hands and legs of the infantry soldiers were floating like seaweed, and the floating bows of the soldiers appeared to be waves of the river. And all the jewelry from the bodies of the soldiers and commanders appeared to be so many pebbles flowing down the river of blood.

Lord Balaräma, who is also known as Saìkarñaëa, began to fight with His club in such a heroic way that the river of blood created by Kåñëa overflooded. Those who were cowards became very much afraid upon seeing the ghastly and horrible scene, and those who were heroes began to talk delightedly among themselves about the heroism of the two brothers. Although Jaräsandha was equipped with a vast ocean of military strength, the fighting of Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma converted the whole situation into a ghastly scene which was far beyond ordinary fighting. Persons of ordinary mind cannot estimate how it could be possible, but when such activities are accepted as pastimes of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, under whose will everything is possible, then this can be understood. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is creating, maintaining and dissolving the cosmic manifestation by His will only. For Him to create such a vast scene of devastation while fighting with an enemy is not so wonderful. And yet, because Kåñëa and Balaräma were fighting with Jaräsandha just like ordinary human beings, the affair appeared to be wonderful.

All the soldiers of Jaräsandha were killed, and he was the only one left alive. Certainly he became very depressed at this point. Çré Balaräma immediately arrested him, just as, with great strength, one lion captures another lion. But while Lord Balaräma was binding Jaräsandha with the rope of Varuëa and ordinary ropes also, Lord Kåñëa, with a greater plan in mind for the future, asked Him not to arrest him. Jaräsandha was then released by Kåñëa. As a great fighting hero, Jaräsandha became very much ashamed, and he decided that he would no longer live as a king, but would resign from his position in the royal order and go to the forest to practice meditation under severe austerities and penances.

As he was returning home with other royal friends, however, they advised him not to retire, but to regain strength to fight again with Kåñëa in the near future. The princely friends of Jaräsandha began to instruct him that ordinarily it would not have been possible for him to have been defeated by the strength of the Yadu kings, but the defeat which he had experienced was simply due to his ill luck. The princely order encouraged King Jaräsandha. His fighting, they said, was certainly heroic; therefore, he should not take his defeat very seriously, as it was due only to his past mistakes. After all, there was no fault in his fighting.

In this way, Jaräsandha, the King of Magadha Province, having lost all his strength and having been insulted by his arrest and subsequent release, could do nothing but return to his kingdom. Thus Lord Kåñëa conquered the soldiers of Jaräsandha. Although Kåñëa's army was tiny in comparison to Jaräsandha's, not a pinch of His strength was lost, whereas all of Jaräsandha's men were killed.

At that time the denizens of heaven became very pleased and began to offer their respects by chanting in glorification of the Lord and by showering Him with flowers. They accepted the victory with great appreciation. Jaräsandha returned to his kingdom, and Mathurä City was made safe from the danger of an imminent attack. The citizens of Mathurä organized the combined services of a circus of professional singers, like sütas, mägadhas, and poets who could compose nice songs, and they began to chant the victory glorification of Lord Kåñëa. When Lord Kåñëa entered the city after the victory, many bugles, conches and kettledrums were sounded, and the vibrations of various musical instruments, like bherya, türya, véëä, flute and mådaìga—all joined together to make a beautiful reception. While Kåñëa was entering, the whole city was very much cleansed, all the different streets and roads were sprinkled with water, and the inhabitants, being joyous, decorated their respective houses, roads and shops with flags and festoons. The brähmaëas chanted Vedic mantras at numerous places. The people constructed road crossings, entrances, lanes and streets. When Lord Kåñëa was entering the nicely decorated city of Mathurä in a festive attitude, the ladies and girls of Mathurä prepared different kinds of flower garlands to make the ceremony more auspicious. In accordance with the Vedic custom, they took yogurt mixed with freshly grown green grass and began to strew it here and there to make the victory jubilation even more auspicious. As Kåñëa passed through the street, all the ladies and women began to regard Him with great affection. Kåñëa and Balaräma carried various kinds of booty, ornaments and jewels carefully collected from the battlefield and presented them to King Ugrasena. Kåñëa thus offered His respect to His grandfather because he was at that time the crowned king of the Yadu dynasty.

Jaräsandha, the King of Magadha, not only besieged the city of Mathurä once, but he attacked it seventeen times in the same way, equipped with the same number of military phalanxes. Each and every time, he was defeated, and all his soldiers were killed by Kåñëa, and each time he had to return disappointed in the same way. Each time, the princely order of the Yadu dynasty arrested Jaräsandha in the same way and again released him in an insulting manner, and each time Jaräsandha shamelessly returned home.

While Jaräsandha was attempting one such attack, a Yavana king somewhere to the south of Mathurä became attracted by the opulence of the Yadu dynasty and also attacked the city. It is said that the king of the Yavanas, known as Kälayavana, was induced to attack by Närada. This story is narrated in the Viñëu Puräëa. Once, Gargamuni, the priest of the Yadu dynasty, was taunted by his brother-in-law. When the kings of the Yadu dynasty heard the taunt they laughed at him, and Gargamuni became angry at the Yadu kings. He decided that he would produce someone who would be very fearful to the Yadu dynasty, so he pleased Lord Çiva and received from him the benediction of a son. He begot this son, Kälayavana, in the wife of a Yavana king. This Kälayavana inquired from Närada, "Who are the most powerful kings in the world?" Närada informed him that the Yadus were the most powerful. Being thus informed by Närada, Kälayavana attacked the city of Mathurä at the same time that Jaräsandha attempted to attack it for the eighteenth time. Kälayavana was very anxious to declare war on a king of the world who would be a suitable combatant for him, but he had not found any. However, being informed about Mathurä by Närada, he thought it wise to attack this city. When he attacked Mathurä he brought with him thirty million Yavana soldiers. When Mathurä was thus besieged, Lord Çré Kåñëa began to consider how much the Yadu dynasty was in distress, being threatened by the attacks of two formidable enemies, Jaräsandha and Kälayavana. Time was growing very short. Kälayavana was already besieging Mathurä from all sides, and it was expected that the next day Jaräsandha would also come, equipped with the same number of divisions of soldiers as in his previous seventeen attempts. Kåñëa was certain that Jaräsandha would take advantage of the opportunity to capture Mathurä when it was also being besieged by Kälayavana. He therefore thought it wise to take precautionary measures to defend the strategic points of Mathurä. If both Kåñëa and Balaräma were engaged in fighting with Kälayavana at one place, Jaräsandha might come at another place to attack the whole Yadu family and take his revenge. Jaräsandha was very powerful, and having been defeated seventeen times, he might vengefully kill the members of the Yadu family or arrest them and take them to his kingdom. Kåñëa therefore decided to construct a formidable fort in a place where no two-legged animal, either man or demon, could enter. He decided to keep His relatives there so that He would then be free to fight with the enemy. It appears that formerly Dvärakä was also part of the kingdom of Mathurä, because in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.50.49] it is stated that Kåñëa constructed a fort in the midst of the sea. Remnants of the fort which Kåñëa constructed are still existing on the Bay of Dvärakä.

He first of all constructed a very strong wall covering ninety-six square miles, and the wall itself was within the sea. It was certainly wonderful and was planned and constructed by Viçvakarmä. No ordinary architect could construct such a fort within the sea, but an architect like Viçvakarmä, who is considered to be the engineer among the demigods, can execute such wonderful craftmanship anywhere in any part of the universe. If huge planets can be floated in weightlessness in the outer space by the arrangement of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, surely the architectural construction of a fort within the sea covering a space of ninety-six square miles was not a very wonderful act.

It is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.50.50-53] that this new, well-constructed city, developed within the sea, had regular planned roads, streets and lanes. Not only were there well-planned roads, streets and lanes, but there were well-planned paths and gardens filled with plants known as kalpavåkñas, or desire trees. These desire trees are not like the ordinary trees of the material world; the desire trees are found in the spiritual world. By Kåñëa's supreme will, everything is possible, so such desire trees were planted in this city of Dvärakä constructed by Kåñëa. The city was also filled with many palaces and gopuras, or big gates. These gopuras are still found in some of the larger temples. They are very high and constructed with extreme artistic skill. Such palaces and gates held golden waterpots (kalaça). These water pots on the gates or in the palaces are considered to be auspicious signs.

Almost all the palaces were skyscrapers. In each and every house there were big pots of gold and silver and grains stocked in underground rooms. And there were many golden waterpots within the rooms. The bedrooms were all bedecked with jewels, and the floors were mosiac pavements of marakata jewels. The Viñëu Deity, worshiped by the descendants of Yadu, was installed in each house in the city. The residential quarters were so arranged that the different castes, brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas and çüdras, had their respective quarters. It appears from this that the caste system was existing even at that time. In the center of the city there was another residential quarter made specifically for King Ugrasena. This place was the most dazzling of all the houses.

When the demigods saw that Kåñëa was constructing a particular city of His own choice, they sent the celebrated pärijäta flower of the heavenly planet to be planted in the new city, and they also sent a parliamentary house, Sudharmä. The specific quality of this assembly house was that anyone participating in a meeting within it would overcome the influence of invalidity due to old age. The demigod Varuëa also presented a horse, which was all white except for black ears and which could run at the speed of the mind. Kuvera, the treasurer of the demigods, presented the art of attaining the eight perfectional stages of material opulences. In this way, all the demigods began to present their respective gifts according to their different capacities. There are thirty-three million demigods, and each of them is entrusted with a particular department of universal management. All the demigods took the opportunity of the Supreme Personality of Godhead's constructing a city of His own choice to present their respective gifts, making the city of Mathurä unique within the universe. This proves that there are undoubtedly innumerable demigods, but none of them are independent of Kåñëa. As stated in the Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 5.142], Kåñëa is the supreme master, and all others are servants. So all the servants took the opportunity of rendering service to Kåñëa when He was personally present within this universe. This example should be followed by all, especially those who are Kåñëa conscious, for they should serve Kåñëa by their respective abilities.

When the new city was fully constructed according to plan, Kåñëa transferred all the inhabitants of Mathurä and entrusted Çré Balaräma as the city father. After this He consulted with Balaräma, and being garlanded with lotus flowers, He came out of the city to meet Kälayavana, who had already seized Mathurä without taking up any weapons.

When Kåñëa came out of the city, Kälayavana, who had never seen Kåñëa before, saw Him to be extraordinarily beautiful, dressed in yellow garments. Passing through His assembly of soldiers, Kåñëa appeared like the moon in the sky passing through the assembled clouds. Kälayavana was fortunate enough to see the lines of Çrévatsa, a particular impression on the chest of Çré Kåñëa, and the Kaustubha jewel which He was wearing. Kälayavana saw Him, however, in His Viñëu form, with a well-built body, with four hands, and eyes like newly blooming lotus petals. Kåñëa appeared blissful, with a handsome forehead and beauitful face, with smiling restless eyes and moving earrings. Before seeing Kåñëa, Kälayvana had heard about Him from Närada, and now the descriptions of Närada were confirmed. He noticed Kåñëa's specific marks and the jewels on His chest, His beautiful garland of lotus flowers, His lotus-like eyes and similarly beautiful bodily features. He concluded that this beautiful personality must be Väsudeva, because every description of Närada's which he had heard previously was substantiated by the presence of Kåñëa. Kälayavana was very much astonished to see that He was passing through without any weapon in His hands and without any chariot. He was simply walking on foot. Kälayavana had come to fight with Kåñëa, and yet he had sufficient principles not to take up any kind of weapon. He decided to fight with Him hand to hand. Thus he prepared to capture Kåñëa and fight.

Kåñëa, however, went ahead without looking at Kälayavana, and Kälayavana began to follow Him with a desire to capture Him. But in spite of all his swift running, he could not capture Kåñëa. Kåñëa cannot be captured even by the mental speed attained by great yogés. He can be captured only by devotional service, and Kälayavana was not practiced in devotional service. He wanted to capture Kåñëa, and as he could not do so he was following him from behind.

Kälayavana began running very fast, and he was thinking, "Now I am nearer; I will capture Him," but he could not. Kåñëa led him far away, and He entered the cave of a hill. Kälayavana thought that Kåñëa was trying to avoid fighting with him and was therefore taking shelter of the cave. He began to chastise Him with the following words: "Oh You, Kåñëa! I heard that You are a great hero born in the dynasty of Yadu, but I see that You are verily running away from fighting, like a coward. It is not worthy of Your good name and family tradition." Kälayavana was following, running very fast, but still he could not catch Kåñëa because he was not freed from all contaminations of sinful life.

According to Vedic culture, anyone who does not live following the regulative principles of life observed by the higher castes like the brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas and even the laborer class is called mleccha. The Vedic social situation is so planned that persons who are accepted as çüdras can gradually be elevated to the position of brähmaëas by the cultural advancement known as saàskära, or the purificatory process. The version of the Vedic scriptures is that no one becomes a brähmaëa or a mleccha simply by birth; by birth everyone is accepted as çüdra. One has to elevate himself by the purificatory process to the stage of brahminical life. If he doesn't, if he degrades himself further, then he is called mleccha. Kälayavana belonged to the class of mleccha and yavanas. He was contaminated by sinful activities and could not approach Kåñëa. The principles from which higher class men are restricted, namely illicit sex indulgence, meat eating, gambling and intoxication, are part and parcel of the lives of the mlecchas and yavanas. Being bound by such sinful activities one cannot make any advancement in God realization. The Bhagavad-gétä [7.28] confirms that only one who is completely freed from all sinful reactions can be engaged in devotional service or Kåñëa consciousness.

When Kåñëa entered the cave of the hill, Kälayavana followed, chastising Him with various harsh words. Kåñëa suddenly disappeared from the demon's sight, but Kälayavana followed and also entered the cave. The first thing he saw was a man lying down asleep within the cave. Kälayavana was very anxious to fight with Kåñëa, and when he could not see Kåñëa, but saw instead only a man lying down, he thought that Kåñëa was sleeping within this cave. Kälayavana was very puffed up and proud of his strength, and he thought Kåñëa was avoiding the fight. Therefore, he very strongly kicked the sleeping man, thinking him to be Kåñëa. The sleeping man had been lying down for a very long time. When he was awakened by the kicking of Kälayavana, he immediately opened his eyes and began to look around in all directions. At last he began to see Kälayavana, who was standing nearby. This man was untimely awakened and therefore very angry, and when he looked upon Kälayavana in his angry mood, rays of fire emanated from his eyes, and Kälayavana burned into ashes within a moment.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Forty-ninth Chapter of Kåñëa, “Kåñëa Erects the Dvärakä Fort.”

KB 1970-1-50 / Deliverance of Mucukunda

50 / Deliverance of Mucukunda

When Mahäräja Parékñit heard this incident of Kälayavana's being burned to ashes, he inquired about the sleeping man from Çukadeva Gosvämé: "Who was he? Why was he sleeping there? How had he achieved so much power that instantly, by his glance, Kälayavana was burned to ashes? How did he happen to be lying down in the cave of the hill?" Many questions were put before Çukadeva Gosvämé, and Çukadeva also answered, as follows.

"My dear King, this person was born in the very great family of King Ikñväku, in which Lord Rämacandra was also born, and he happened to be the son of a great king known as Mändhätä. He himself was also a great soul and was known popularly as Mucukunda. King Mucukunda was a very strict follower of the Vedic principles of brahminical culture, and he was truthful to his promise. He was so powerful that even demigods like Indra and others used to ask him to please help in fighting with the demons, and as such, he often fought against the demons to protect the demigods."

The commander-in-chief of the demigods, known as Kärttikeya, was satisfied with the fighting of King Mucukunda, but once he asked that the King, having taken too much trouble in fighting with the demons, retire from fighting and take rest. The commander-in-chief, Kärttikeya, addressed King Mucukunda, "My dear King, you have sacrificed everything for the sake of the demigods. You had a very nice kingdom undisturbed by any kind of enemy. You left that kingdom, you neglected your opulence and possessions, and you never cared for fulfillment of your personal ambition. Due to your long absence from your kingdom while fighting with the demons on behalf of the demigods, your family, your children, your relatives and your ministers have all passed away in due course of time. Time and tide wait for no living man. Now even if you retire to your home, you will find that no one is living there. The influence of time is very strong; all your relatives have passed away in due course of time. Time is so strong and powerful because it is a representation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; time is therefore stronger than the strongest. By the influence of time, changes in subtle things can be effected without any difficulty. No one can check the process of time. As an animal tamer tames the animals according to his own will, so time also enters things according to its own will. None can supersede the arrangement made by the supreme time."

Thus addressing Mucukunda, the demigods requested him to ask for any kind of benediction he might be pleased with, excepting the benediction of liberation. Liberation cannot be awarded by any living entity except the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu. Therefore another name of Lord Viñëu or Kåñëa is Mukunda, He who can award liberation.

King Mucukunda had not slept for many, many years. He was engaged in the duty of fighting, and therefore he was very tired. So when the demigod offered benediction, Mucukunda simply thought of sleeping. He replied as follows: "My dear Kärttikeya, the best of the demigods, I want to sleep now, and I want from you the following benediction. Grant me the power to burn, by my mere glance, anyone to ashes who tries to disturb my sleeping and awakens me untimely. Please give me this benediction." The demigod agreed and also gave him the benediction that he would be able to take complete rest. Then King Mucukunda entered the cave of the mountain.

On the strength of the benediction of Kärttikeya, Kälayavana was burnt into ashes simply by Mucukunda's glancing at him. When the incident was over, Kåñëa came before King Mucukunda. Kåñëa had actually entered the cave to deliver King Mucukunda from his austerity, but He did not first appear before him. He arranged that first Kälayavana should come before him. That is the way of the activities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; He does one thing in such a way that many other purposes are served. He wanted to deliver King Mucukunda, who was sleeping in the cave, and at the same time He wanted to kill Kälayavana, who had attacked Mathurä city. By this action He served all purposes.

When Lord Kåñëa appeared before Mucukunda, the King saw Him dressed in a yellow garment, His chest marked with the symbol of Çrévatsa, and the Kaustubha-maëi hanging around His neck. Kåñëa appeared before him with four hands, as Viñëu-mürti, with a garland called vaijayanté hanging from His neck down to His knees. He was looking very lustrous, His face was very beautifully smiling, and He had nice jeweled earrings in both His ears. Kåñëa appeared more beautiful than a human can conceive. Not only did He appear in this feature, but He glanced over Mucukunda with great splendor, attracting the King's mind. Although He was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the oldest of all, He looked like a fresh young boy, and His movement was just like that of a free deer. He appeared extremely powerful; His excellence in power is so great that every human being should be afraid of Him.

When King Mucukunda saw Kåñëa's magnificent features, he wondered about His identity, and with great humility he began to inquire from the Lord: "My dear Lord, may I inquire how it is that You happened to be in the cave of this mountain? Who are You? I can see that Your feet are just like soft lotus flowers. How could You walk in this forest full of thorns and hedges? I am simply surprised to see this! Are You not, therefore, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is the most powerful amongst the powerful? Are You not the original source of all illumination and fire? Can I consider You one of the great demigods, like the sun, the moon, or Indra, King of heaven? Or are You the predominating deity of any other planet?"

Mucukunda knew well that every higher planetary system has a predominating deity. He was not ignorant like modern men who consider that this earthly planet is full of living entities and all others are vacant. The inquiry from Mucukunda about Kåñëa's being the predominating deity of a planet unknown to him is quite appropriate. Because he was a pure devotee of the Lord, King Mucukunda could immediately understand that Lord Kåñëa, who had appeared before him in such an opulent feature, could not be one of the predominating deities in the material planets. He must be the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, who has His many Viñëu forms. He therefore took Him to be Puruñottama, Lord Viñëu. He could see also that the dense darkness within the mountain cave had already been dissipated due to the Lord's presence; therefore He could not be other than the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He knew very well that wherever the Lord is personally present by His transcendental name, quality, form, etc., there cannot be any darkness of ignorance. He is like a lamp placed in the darkness; He immediately illuminates a dark place.

King Mucukunda became very much anxious to know about the identity of Lord Kåñëa, and therefore he said, "O best of human beings, if You think that I am fit to know about Your identity, then kindly tell me who You are. What is Your parentage? What is Your occupational duty, and what is Your family tradition?" King Mucukunda thought it wise, however, to identify himself to the Lord; otherwise he had no right to ask the Lord's identity. Etiquette is such that a person of less importance cannot ask the identity of a person of higher importance without first disclosing his own identity. King Mucukunda therefore informed Lord Kåñëa, "My dear Lord, I must inform You of my identification. I belong to the most celebrated dynasty of King Ikñväku, but personally I am not as great as my forefather. My name is Mucukunda. My father's name was Mändhätä, and my grandfather's name was Yuvanäçva, the great king. I was very much fatigued due to not resting for many thousands of years, and because of this all my bodily limbs were flattened and almost incapable of acting. In order to revive my energy, I was taking rest in this solitary cave, but I have been awakened by some unknown man who has forced me to wake up although I was not willing to do so. For such an offensive act, this person has been burnt into ashes simply by my glancing over him. Fortunately, now I can see You in Your grand and beautiful features. I think, therefore, that You are the cause of killing my enemy. My dear Lord, I must admit that due to the effulgence of Your body, unbearable to my eyes, I cannot see You properly. I can fully realize that by the influence of Your effulgence my powerful potency has been diminished. I can understand that You are quite fit for being worshiped by all living entities."

Seeing King Mucukunda so anxious to know about His identity, Lord Kåñëa began to answer smilingly, as follows: "My dear King, it is practically impossible to tell about My birth, appearance, disappearance and activities. Perhaps you know that My incarnation Anantadeva has unlimited mouths, and for an unlimited time he has been trying to narrate fully about My name, fame, qualities, activities, appearance, disappearance and incarnation, but still he has not been able to finish. Therefore, it is not possible to know exactly how many names and forms I possess. It may be possible for a material scientist to estimate the number of atomic particles which make up this earthly planet, but the scientist cannot enumerate My unlimited names, forms and activities. There are many great sages and saintly persons who are trying to make a list of My different forms and activities, yet they have failed to make a complete list. But since you are so anxious to know about Me, I may inform you that presently I have appeared on this planet just to annihilate the demoniac principles of the people in general and to reestablish the religious principles enjoined in the Vedas. I have been invited for this purpose by Brahmä, the superintending deity of this universe, and thus I have now appeared in the dynasty of the Yadus as one of their family members. I have specifically taken My birth as the son of Vasudeva in the Yadu Dynasty, and people therefore know Me as Väsudeva, the son of Vasudeva. You may also know that I have killed Kaàsa, who was in a previous life known as Kälanemi, as well as Pralambäsura and many other demons. They have acted as My enemies and have been killed by Me. The demon who was present before you also acted as My enemy, and you have very kindly burned him into ashes by glancing over him. My dear King Mucukunda, you are My great devotee, and just to show you My causeless mercy, I have appeared in this form. I am very affectionately inclined toward My devotees, and in your previous life, before your present condition, you acted as My great devotee and prayed for My causeless mercy. I have, therefore, come to see you to fulfill your desire. Now you can see Me to your heart's content. My dear King, now you can ask from Me any benediction that you wish, and I am prepared to fulfill your desire. It is my eternal principle that anyone who comes under My shelter must have all his desires fulfilled by My grace."

When Lord Kåñëa ordered King Mucukunda to ask a benediction from Him, the King became very joyful, and he immediately remembered the prediction of Gargamuni, who had foretold long before that in the twenty-eighth millennium of Vaivasvata Manu, Lord Kåñëa would appear on this planet. As soon as he remembered this prediction, he began to understand that the Supreme Person, Näräyaëa, was present before Him as Lord Kåñëa. He immediately fell down at His lotus feet and began to pray as follows.

"My dear Lord, O Supreme Personality of Godhead, I can understand that all living entities on this planet are illusioned by Your external energy and are enamored of the illusory satisfaction of sense gratification. Being fully engaged in illusory activities, they are reluctant to worship Your lotus feet, and because they are unaware of the benefits of surrendering unto Your lotus feet they are subjected to various miserable conditions of material existence. They are foolishly attached to so-called society, friendship and love, which simply produce different kinds of miserable conditions. Illusioned by Your external energy, everyone, both man and woman, is attached to this material existence, and all are engaged in cheating one another in a great society of the cheaters and the cheated. These foolish persons do not know how fortunate they are to have obtained this human form of life, and they are reluctant to worship Your lotus feet. By the influence of Your external energy, they are simply attached to the glare of material activities. They are attached to so-called society, friendship and love like dumb animals that have fallen into a dark well." The example of a dark well is given because in the fields there are many wells, unused for years and covered over by grass, and the poor animals, without knowing of them, fall into them, and unless they are rescued, they die. Being captivated by a few blades of grass, the animals fall into a dark well and meet death. Similarly, foolish persons, without knowing the importance of the human form of life, spoil it simply for sense gratification and die unnecessarily, without any useful purpose.

"My dear Lord, I am not an exception to this universal law of material nature. I am also one of those foolish persons who has wasted his time for nothing. And my position is especially difficult. On account of my being situated in the royal order, I was more puffed up than ordinary persons. An ordinary man thinks of becoming the proprietor of his body or of his family, but I began to think in that way on a larger scale. I wanted to be the master of the whole world, and as I became puffed up with ideas of sense gratification, my bodily concept of life became stronger and stronger. My attachment for home, wife and children, for money and for supremacy over the world, became more and more acute; in fact, it was limitless. So I remained always attached to thoughts of my material living conditions.

"Therefore, my dear Lord, I wasted so much of my valuable lifetime without any benefit. My misconception of life having been intensified, I began to think of this material body, which is just a bag of flesh and bones, as the all in all, and in my vanity I was like a dog who believes that he has become the king of human society. In this misconception of bodily life, I began to travel all over the world, accompanied by my military strength—soldiers, charioteers, elephants and horses. Assisted by many commanders and puffed up by power, I could not trace out Your Lordship, who is always sitting within my heart as the most intimate friend. I did not care for You, and this was the fault of my so-called exalted material condition. I think that, like me, all living creatures are careless about spiritual realization and are always full of anxieties, thinking, 'What is to be done?' 'What is next?' But because we are strongly bound by material desires, we continue to remain in craziness.

"Yet in spite of our being so absorbed in material thought, inevitable time, which is only a form of Yourself, is always careful about its duty, and as soon as the alloted time is over, Your Lordship immediately ends all the activities of our material dreams. As the time factor, You end all our activities, as the hungry blacksnake swiftly swallows up a small rat without any leniency. Due to the action of cruel time, the royal body which was always decorated with gold ornaments during life and which moved on a chariot drawn by beautiful horses or on the back of an elephant nicely decorated with golden ornaments, and which was advertised as the king of human society—that same royal body decomposes under the influence of inevitable time and becomes fit for being eaten by worms and insects or being turned into ashes or the stool of an animal. This beautiful body may be nice while in the living condition, but after death even the body of a king is eaten by an animal and therefore turns into stool or is cremated in the crematorium and turned into ashes or is put into an earthly grave where different kinds of worms and insects are produced out of it.

"My dear Lord, not only do we become under the full control of this inevitable time after death, but also while living, in a different way. For example, I may be a powerful king, and yet when I come home after conquering over the world I become subjected to many material conditions. It may be that when I come back after being victorious all subordinate kings come and offer their respects, but as soon as I enter into the inner section of my palace, I myself become an instrument in the hands of the queens, and for sense gratification I have to fall down at the feet of women. The material way of life is so complicated that before taking the enjoyment of material life one has to work so hard that there is scarcely an opportunity for enjoying. And to attain the youthful condition with all material facilities one has to undergo severe austerities and penances and become elevated to the heavenly planets. If one gets the opportunity of taking birth in a very rich or royal family, even then in that condition he is always anxious to maintain the status quo and prepare for the next life by performing various kinds of sacrifices and by distributing charity. Even in the royal condition of life one is not only full of anxieties because of political administration, but he is also in anxiety over being elevated to heavenly planets.

"It is therefore very difficult to get out of the material entanglement, but somehow or other if one is favored by You, by Your mercy only he is given the opportunity to associate with a pure devotee. That is the beginning point of liberation from the entanglement of material conditional life. My dear Lord, only by the association of pure devotees is one entrapped by Your Lordship, who is the controller of both the material and spiritual existences. You are the supreme goal of all pure devotees, and by association with pure devotees one can develop his dormant love for You. Therefore, development of Kåñëa consciousness in the association of pure devotees is the cause of liberation from this material entanglement.

"My dear Lord, You are so merciful that in spite of my being reluctant to associate with Your great devotees You have shown Your extreme mercy upon me as a result of my slight contact with a pure devotee like Gargamuni. By Your causeless mercy only have I lost all my material opulences, my kingdom and my family. I do not think that I could have gotten rid of all these entanglements without Your causeless mercy. Kings and emperors accept the life of austerity to forget the royal condition of life, but by Your special causeless mercy I have already been bereft of the royal condition. Other kings exert themselves to get out of the attachment of kingdom and family by acceptance of the hardships of renunciation, but by Your mercy I do not need to become a mendicant or to practice renunciation.

"My dear Lord, I therefore pray that I may simply be engaged in rendering transcendental loving service unto Your lotus feet, which is the ambition of the pure devotees who are freed from all kinds of material contamination. You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and You can offer me anything I want, including liberation. But who is such a foolish person that after pleasing You he would ask from You something which might be the cause of entanglement in this material world? I do not think any sane man would ask such a benediction from You. I therefore surrender unto You because You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, You are the Supersoul living in everyone's heart, and You are the impersonal Brahman effulgence. Moreover, You are also this material world, because this material world is only the manifestation of Your external energy. Therefore, from any angle of vision, You are the supreme shelter for everyone. Everyone, either in the material plane or in the spiritual plane, must take shelter under Your lotus feet. I therefore submit unto You, my Lord. For many, many births I have been suffering from the threefold miseries of this material existence, and I am now tired of it. I have simply been impelled by my senses, and I was never satisfied. I therefore take shelter of Your lotus feet, which are the source of all peaceful conditions of life and which can eradicate all kinds of lamentation caused by material contamination. My dear Lord, You are the Supersoul of everyone, and You can understand everything. Now I am free from all contamination of material desire. I do not wish to enjoy this material world, nor do I wish to take advantage of merging into Your spiritual effulgence, nor do I wish to meditate upon Your localized aspect of Paramätmä, for I know that simply by taking shelter of You, I shall become completely peaceful and undisturbed."

On hearing this statement of King Mucukunda, Lord Kåñëa replied, "My dear King, I am very much pleased with your statement. You have been the King of all the lands on this planet, but I am surprised to find that your mind is now freed from all material contamination. You are now fit to execute devotional service. I am most pleased to see that although I offered you the opportunity of asking from Me any kind of benediction, you did not take advantage of asking for material benefit. I can understand that your mind is now fixed in Me, and it is not disturbed by any material fault.

"The material qualities are three, namely goodness, passion and ignorance. When one is placed in the mixed material qualities of passion and ignorance, he is impelled by various kinds of dirtiness and lusty desires to try to find comfort in this material world. When he is situated in the material quality of goodness, he tries to purify himself by performing various kinds of penances and austerities. When one reaches the platform of a real brähmaëa, he aspires to merge into the existence of the Lord, but when one desires simply to render service unto the lotus feet of the Lord, that is transcendental to all these three qualities. The pure Kåñëa conscious person is therefore always free from all material qualities. My dear King, I offered to give you any kind of benediction, just to test how much you have advanced in devotional service. Now I can see that you are on the platform of the pure devotees because your mind is not disturbed by any kind of greedy or lusty desires of this material world. The yogés who are trying to elevate themselves by controlling the senses and who meditate upon Me by practicing the breathing exercise of präëäyäma are not so thoroughly freed from material desires. It has been seen in several cases that as soon as there is allurement, such yogés again come down to the material platform."

The vivid example verifying this statement is Viçvämitra Muni. Viçvämitra Muni was a great yogé who practiced präëäyäma, a breathing exercise, but still when he was visited by Menakä, a society woman of the heavenly planet, he lost all control and begot in her a daughter named Çakuntalä. But the pure devotee Haridäsa Öhäkur was never disturbed, even when all such allurements were offered by the prostitutes.

"My dear King," Lord Kåñëa continued, "I therefore give you the special benediction that you will always think of Me. Thus you will be able to traverse this material world freely, without being contaminated by the qualities." This statement of the Lord confirms that a person in true Kåñëa consciousness, engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord under the direction of the spiritual master, is never subjected to the contamination of material qualities.

"My dear King," the Lord said, "because you are a kñatriya, you have committed the offense of slaughtering animals, both in hunting and in political engagements. To become purified, just engage yourself in bhakti-yoga practice and always keep your mind absorbed in Me. Very soon you will be freed from all reactions to such sordid activities." In this statement it appears that although the kñatriyas are allowed to kill animals in the hunting process, they are not freed from the contamination of other sinful reactions. Therefore it does not matter whether one is kñatriya, vaiçya, or brähmaëa; everyone is recommended to take sannyäsa at the end of life, to engage himself completely in the service of the Lord and thus become freed from all sinful reactions of his past life.

The Lord then assured King Mucukunda, "In your next life you will take your birth as a first-class Vaiñëava, the best of brähmaëas, and in that life your only business will be to engage yourself in My transcendental service." The Vaiñëava is the first-class brähmaëa, because one who has not acquired the qualification of a bona fide brähmaëa cannot come to the platform of a Vaiñëava. When one comes to the platform of a Vaiñëava, he is completely engaged in welfare activities for all living entities. The highest welfare activity for living entities is the preaching of Kåñëa consciousness. It is stated herein that those who are specifically favored by the Lord can become absolutely Kåñëa conscious and be engaged in the preaching work of the Vaiñëava philosophy.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fiftieth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Deliverance of Mucukunda."

KB 1970-1-51 / Kåñëa, the Ranchor

51 / Kåñëa, the Ranchor

When Mucukunda, the celebrated descendant of the Ikñväku dynasty, was favored by Lord Kåñëa, he circumambulated the Lord within the cave and then came out. On coming out of the cave, Mucukunda saw that the stature of the human species had surprisingly been reduced to pigmy size. Similarly, the trees had also far reduced in size, and Mucukunda could immediately understand that the current age was Kali-yuga. Therefore, without diverting his attention, he began to travel north. Eventually he reached the mountain known as Gandhamädana. It appeared there were many trees on this mountain, such as sandalwood and other flower trees, the flavor of which made anyone joyful who reached them. He decided to remain in that Gandhamädana Mountain region in order to execute austerities and penances for the rest of his life. It appears that this place is situated in the northernmost part of the Himalayan Mountains, where the abode of Nara-Näräyaëa is situated. This place is still existing and is called Badarikäçrama. In Badarikäçrama he engaged himself in the worship of Lord Kåñëa, forgetting all pain and pleasure and the other dualities of this material world. Lord Kåñëa also returned to the vicinity of the city of Mathurä and began to fight with the soldiers of Kälayavana and kill them one after another. After this, He collected all the booty from the dead bodies, and under His direction, it was loaded on bullock carts by big men and brought back to Dvärakä.

Meanwhile, Jaräsandha again attacked Mathurä, this time with bigger divisions of soldiers, numbering twenty-three akñauhiëés.

Lord Çré Kåñëa wanted to save Mathurä from the eighteenth attack of the great military divisions of King Jaräsandha. In order to prevent further killing of soldiers and to attend to other important business, Lord Kåñëa left the battlefield without fighting. Actually He was not at all afraid, but He pretended to be an ordinary human being frightened by the immense quantity of soldiers and resources of Jaräsandha. Without any weapons He left the battlefield. Although His lotus feet were as soft as the petals of the lotus flower, He proceeded for a very long distance on foot.

This time, Jaräsandha thought that Kåñëa and Balaräma were very much afraid of His military strength and were fleeing from the battlefield. He began to follow Them with all his chariots, horses and infantry. He thought Kåñëa and Balaräma to be ordinary human beings, and he was trying to measure the activities of the Lord. Kåñëa is known as Ranchor, which means "one who has left the battlefield." In India, especially in Gujarat, there are many temples of Kåñëa which are known as temples of Ranchorjé. Ordinarily, if a king leaves the battlefield without fighting he is called a coward, but when Kåñëa enacts this pastime, leaving the battlefield without fighting, He is worshiped by the devotee. A demon always tries to measure the opulence of Kåñëa, whereas the devotee never tries to measure His strength and opulence, but always surrenders unto Him and worships Him. By following the footsteps of pure devotees we can know that Kåñëa, the Ranchorjé, did not leave the battlefield because He was afraid, but because He had some other purpose. The purpose, as it will be revealed, was to attend to a confidential letter sent by Rukmiëé, His future first wife. The act of Kåñëa's leaving the battlefield is a display of one of His six opulences. Kåñëa is the supreme powerful, the supreme wealthy, the supreme famous, the supreme wise, the supreme beautiful; similarly He is the supreme renouncer. Çrémad-Bhägavatam clearly states that He left the battlefield in spite of having ample military strength. Even without His militia, however, He alone would have been sufficient to defeat the army of Jaräsandha, as He had done seventeen times before. Therefore, His leaving the battlefield is an example of His supermost opulence of renunciation.

After traversing a very long distance, the brothers pretended to become very tired. To mitigate Their weariness They climbed up a very high mountain several miles above sea level. This mountain was called Pravarñaëa due to constant rain. The peak was always covered with clouds sent by Indra. Jaräsandha took it for granted that the two brothers were afraid of his military power and had hidden Themselves at the top of the mountain. First he tried to find Them, searching for a long time, but when he failed he decided to trap and kill Them by setting fires around the peak. He therefore surrounded the peak with oil and set it on fire. As the blaze spread more and more, Kåñëa and Balaräma jumped from the top of the mountain down to the ground—a distance of eighty-eight miles. Thus, while the peak was burning up, Kåñëa and Balaräma escaped without being seen by Jaräsandha. Jaräsandha concluded that the two brothers had been burned to ashes and that there was no need of further fighting. Thinking himself successful in his efforts, he left the city of Mathurä and returned to his home in the kingdom of Magadha. Gradually Kåñëa and Balaräma reached the city of Dvärakä, which was surrounded on all sides by the sea.

Following this, Çré Balaräma married Revaté, daughter of King Raivata, ruler of the Änarta province. This is explained in the Ninth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. After the marriage of Baladeva, Kåñëa married Rukmiëé. Rukmiëé was the daughter of King Bhéñmaka, ruler of the province known as Vidarbha. Just as Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Vasudeva, Rukmiëé is the supreme goddess of fortune, Mahä-Lakñmé. According to the authority of Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 4.76-98], the expansion of Kåñëa and Çré Rädhäräëé is simultaneous; Kåñëa expands Himself into various Viñëu-tattva forms, and Çrématé Rädhäräëé expands Herself into various çakti-tattva forms by Her internal potency, as multi-forms of the goddess of fortune.

According to Vedic convention, there are eight kinds of marriages. In the first-class marriage system, the parents of the bride and bridegroom arrange the marriage date. Then, in royal style, the bridegroom goes to the house of the bride, and in the presence of brähmaëas, priests and relatives, the bride is given in charity to the bridegroom. Besides this, there are other systems, such as the gandharva and räkñasa marriages. Rukmiëé was married to Kåñëa in the räkñasa style because she was kidnapped by Him in the presence of His many rivals, like Çiçupäla, Jaräsandha, Çälva and others. While Rukmiëé was being given in charity to Çiçupäla, she was snatched from the marriage arena by Kåñëa, exactly as Garuòa snatched the pot of nectar from the demons. Rukmiëé, the only daughter of King Bhéñmaka, was exquisitely beautiful. She was known as Ruciränanä, which means "one who has a beautiful face, expanding like a lotus flower."

Devotees of Kåñëa are always anxious to hear about the transcendental activities of the Lord. His activities of fighting, kidnapping and running away from the battlefield are all transcendental, being on the absolute platform, and devotees take a transcendental interest in hearing of them. The pure devotee does not make the distinction that some activities of the Lord should be heard and others should be avoided. There is, however, a class of so-called devotees known as präkåta sahajiyä who are very interested in hearing about Kåñëa's räsa-lélä with the gopés, but not about His fighting activities with His enemies. They do not know that His bellicose activities and His friendly activities with the gopés are equally transcendental, being on the absolute platform. The transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam are relished by pure devotees through submissive aural reception. They do not reject even a drop.

The story of Kåñëa's marriage with Rukmiëé is described as follows. The King of Vidarbha, Mahäräja Bhéñmaka, was a very qualified and devoted prince. He had five sons and only one daughter. The first son was known as Rukmé; the second, Rukmaratha; the third, Rukmabähu; the fourth and youngest, Rukmakeça; and the fifth, Rukmamälé. The brothers had one young sister, Rukmiëé. She was beautiful and chaste and was meant to be married to Lord Kåñëa. Many saintly persons and sages like Närada Muni and others used to visit the palace of King Bhéñmaka. Naturally Rukmiëé had a chance to talk with them, and in this way she obtained information about Kåñëa. She was informed about the six opulences of Kåñëa, and simply by hearing about Him, she desired to surrender herself to His lotus feet and become His wife. Kåñëa had also heard of Rukmiëé. She was the reservoir of all transcendental qualities: intelligence, liberal-mindedness, exquisite beauty and righteous behavior. Kåñëa therefore decided that she was fit to be His wife. All of the family members and relatives of King Bhéñmaka decided that Rukmiëé should be given in marriage to Kåñëa. However her elder brother, Rukmé, despite the desire of the others, arranged for her marriage with Çiçupäla, a determined enemy of Kåñëa. When the black-eyed, beautiful Rukmiëé heard the settlement, she immediately became very morose. However, being a king's daughter, she understood political diplomacy and decided that there was no use in simply becoming morose. Some steps should be taken immediately. After some deliberation, she decided to send a message to Kåñëa, and so that she might not be deceived, she selected a qualified brähmaëa as her messenger. Such a qualified brähmaëa is always truthful and is a devotee of Viñëu. Without delay, the brähmaëa was sent to Dvärakä.

Reaching the gate of Dvärakä, the brähmaëa informed the doorkeeper of his arrival, and the doorkeeper led him to the place where Kåñëa was sitting on a golden throne. Since the brähmaëa had the opportunity of being Rukmiëé's messenger, he was fortunate enough to see the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, who is the original cause of all causes. A brähmaëa is the spiritual teacher of all the social divisions. Lord Çré Kåñëa, in order to teach everyone the Vedic etiquette of how to respect a brähmaëa, immediately got up and offered him His throne. When the brähmaëa was seated on the golden throne, Lord Çré Kåñëa began to worship him exactly in the manner in which the demigods worship Kåñëa. In this way, He taught everyone that worshiping His devotee is more valuable than worshiping Himself.

In due time, the brähmaëa took his bath, accepted his meals and took to rest on a bedstead completely bedecked with soft silk. As he was resting, Lord Çré Kåñëa silently approached and, with great respect, put the brähmaëa's legs on His lap and began to massage them. In this way, Kåñëa appeared before the brähmaëa and said, "My dear brähmaëa, I hope that you are executing the religious principles without any difficulty and that your mind is always in a peaceful condition." Different classes of people in the social system are engaged in various professions, and when one inquires as to the well-being of a particular person, it must be done on the basis of that person's occupation. Therefore, when one inquires as to the welfare of a brähmaëa, the questions should be worded according to his condition of life so as not to disturb him. A peaceful mind is the basis for becoming truthful, clean, equipoised, self-controlled and tolerant. Thus by attaining knowledge and knowing its practical application in life, one becomes convinced about the Absolute Truth. The brähmaëa knew Kåñëa to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and still he accepted the respectful service of the Lord on the grounds of Vedic social convention. Lord Çré Kåñëa was playing just like a human being. Belonging to the kñatriya division of the social system, and being a young boy, it was His duty to show respect to such a brähmaëa.

Lord Kåñëa continued: "O best of all the brähmaëas, you should always remain satisfied because if a brähmaëa is always self-satisfied he will not deviate from his prescribed duties; and simply by sticking to one's prescribed duties, everyone, especially the brähmaëas, can attain the highest perfection of all desires. Even if a person is as opulent as the King of heaven, Indra, if he is not satisfied he inevitably has to transmigrate from one planet to another. Such a person can never be happy under any circumstances; but if a person's mind is satisfied, even if he is bereft of his high position, he can be happy living anywhere and everywhere."

This instruction of Kåñëa to the brähmaëa is very significant. The purport is that a true brähmaëa should not be disturbed in any situation. In this modern age of Kali-yuga, the so-called brähmaëas have accepted the abominable position of the çüdras or less than çüdras and still want to pass as qualified brähmaëas. Actually, a qualified brähmaëa always sticks to his own duties and never accepts those of a çüdra or of one less than a çüdra. It is advised in the authorized scriptures that a brähmaëa may, under awkward circumstances, accept the profession of a kñatriya or even a vaiçya, but never is he to accept the profession of a çüdra. Lord Kåñëa declared that a brähmaëa should never be disturbed by any adverse conditions of life if he scrupulously sticks to his religious principles. In conclusion, Lord Çré Kåñëa said: "I offer My respectful obeisances to the brähmaëas and Vaiñëavas, because the brähmaëas are always self-satisfied, and the Vaiñëavas are always engaged in actual welfare activities for the human society. They are the best friends of the people in general; both are free from false egoism and are always in a peaceful condition of mind."

Lord Kåñëa then desired to know about the rulers (kñatriyas) in the brähmaëa's kingdom, so He inquired whether the citizens of the kingdom were all happy. A king's qualification is judged by the temperament of the people in the kingdom. If they are very happy in all respects, it is to be understood that the king is honest and executing his duties rightly. Kåñëa said that the king in whose kingdom the citizens are happy is very dear to Him. Of course Kåñëa could understand that the brähmaëa had come with a confidential message; therefore he said, "If you have no objection, I am giving you permission to speak about your mission." Thus, being very satisfied by these transcendental pastimes with the Lord, the brähmaëa narrated the whole story of his mission to come and see Kåñëa. He got out the letter which Rukmiëé had written to Kåñëa and said, "These are the words of Princess Rukmiëé: 'My dear Kåñëa, O infallible and most beautiful one, any human being who happens to hear about Your transcendental form and pastimes immediately absorbs through his ears Your name, fame and qualities; thus all his material pangs subside, and he fixes Your form in his heart. Through such transcendental love for You, he sees You always within himself; and by this process all his desires become fulfilled. Similarly, I have heard of Your transcendental qualities. I may be shameless in expressing myself so directly, but You have captivated me and taken my heart. You may suspect that I am an unmarried girl, young in age, and may doubt my steadiness of character, but my dear Mukunda, You are the supreme lion among the human beings, the supreme person among persons. Any girl, although not yet out of her home, or any woman who may be of the highest chastity, would desire to marry You, being captivated by Your unprecedented character, knowledge, opulence and position. I know that You are the husband of the goddess of fortune and that You are very kind toward Your devotees; therefore I have decided to become Your eternal maidservant. My dear Lord, I dedicate my life and soul unto Your lotus feet. I have accepted Your Lordship as my selected husband, and I therefore request You to accept me as Your wife. You are the supreme powerful, O lotus-eyed one. Now I belong to You. If that which is enjoyable for the lion to eat is taken away by the jackal, it will be a ludicrous affair; therefore I request You to immediately take care of me before I am taken away by Çiçupäla and other princes like him. My dear Lord, in my previous life I may have done public welfare work like digging wells and growing trees, or pious activities such as performing ritualistic ceremonies and sacrifices and serving the superior spiritual master, the brähmaëas and Vaiñëavas. By these activities, perhaps I have pleased the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa. If this is so, then I wish that You, Lord Kåñëa, the brother of Lord Balaräma, would please come here and catch hold of my hand so that I may not be touched by Çiçupäla and his company.'"

Rukmiëé's marriage with Çiçupäla was already settled; therefore she suggested that Kåñëa kidnap her so that this might be changed. This sort of marriage, in which the girl is kidnapped by force, is known as räkñasa and is practiced among the kñatriyas, or the administrative, martial spirited type of men. Because her marriage was already arranged to take place the next day, Rukmiëé suggested that Kåñëa come there incognito to kidnap her and then fight with Çiçupäla and his allies like the King of Magadha. Knowing that no one could conquer Kåñëa and that He would certainly emerge victorious, she addressed Him as Ajita—the unconquerable. Rukmiëé told Kåñëa not to be concerned that many of her family members, including other women, might be wounded or even killed if the fighting took place within the palace. As the king of a country thinks of diplomatic ways to achieve his object, similarly Rukmiëé, being the daughter of a king, was diplomatic in suggesting how this unnecessary and undesirable killing could be avoided.

She explained that it was the custom of her family to visit the temple of the goddess Durgä, their family deity, before a marriage. (The kñatriya kings were mostly staunch Vaiñëavas, worshiping Lord Viñëu in either the Rädhä-Kåñëa or Lakñmé-Näräyaëa form; still, for their material welfare, they used to worship the goddess Durgä. They never made the mistake, however, of accepting the demigods as the Supreme Lord on the level of Viñëu-tattva, as did some of the less intelligent men.) In order to avoid the unnecessary killing of her relatives, Rukmiëé suggested that it would be easiest for Him to kidnap her while she was either going from the palace to the temple or else while she was returning home.

She also explained to Kåñëa why she was so anxious to be married to Him, even though her marriage was to take place with Çiçupäla, who was also qualified, being the son of a great king. Rukmiëé said that she did not think anyone was greater than Kåñëa, not even Lord Çiva, who is known as Mahädeva, the greatest of all demigods. Lord Çiva also seeks the pleasure of Lord Kåñëa in order to be delivered from his entanglement in the quality of ignorance within the material world. In spite of the fact that Lord Çiva is the greatest of all great souls, mahätmäs, he keeps on his head the purifying water of the Ganges, which emanates from a hole in this material universe made by the toe of Lord Viñëu. Lord Çiva is in charge of the material quality of ignorance, and in order to keep himself in a transcendental position, he always meditates on Lord Viñëu. Therefore Rukmiëé knew very well that obtaining the favor of Kåñëa was not an easy job. If even Lord Çiva must purify himself for this purpose, surely it would be difficult for Rukmiëé, who was only the daughter of a kñatriya king. Thus she desired to dedicate her life to observing severe austerities and penances, such as fasting and going without bodily comforts. If it were not possible in this lifetime to gain Kåñëa's favor by these activities, she was prepared to do the same lifetime after lifetime. In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.28] it is said that pure devotees of the Lord execute devotional service with great determination. Such determination, as exhibited by Rukmiëédevé, is the only price for purchasing Kåñëa's favor and is the way to ultimate success in Kåñëa consciousness.

After explaining Rukmiëédevé's statement to Kåñëa, the brähmaëa said: "My dear Kåñëa, chief of the Yadu dynasty, I have brought this confidential message for You from Rukmiëé; now it is placed before You for Your consideration. After due deliberation You can act as You please, but if You want to do something, You must do it immediately. There is not much time left for action."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fifty-first Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kåñëa, the Ranchor."

KB 1970-1-52 / Kåñëa Kidnaps Rukmiëé

52 / Kåñëa Kidnaps Rukmiëé

After hearing Rukmiëé's statement, Lord Kåñëa was very pleased. He immediately shook hands with the brähmaëa and said: "My dear brähmaëa, I am very glad to hear that Rukmiëé is anxious to marry Me, since I am also anxious to get her hand. My mind is always absorbed in the thought of the daughter of Bhéñmaka, and sometimes I cannot sleep at night because I am thinking of her. I can understand that the marriage of Rukmiëé with Çiçupäla has been arranged by her elder brother in a spirit of animosity toward Me; so I am determined to give a good lesson to all of these princes. Just as fire is extracted and utilized after manipulating ordinary wood, similarly, after dealing with these demoniac princes, I shall bring forth Rukmiëé, like fire, from their midst."

Kåñëa, upon being informed of the specific date of Rukmiëé's marriage, became anxious to leave immediately. He asked His driver, Däruka, to harness the horses for His chariot and prepare to go to the kingdom of Vidarbha. The driver, just after hearing this order, brought Kåñëa's four special horses. The names and descriptions of these horses are mentioned in the Padma Puräëa. The first one, Çaivya, was greenish; the second, Sugréva, was grayish like ice; the third, Meghapuñpa, was the color of a new cloud; and the last, Balähaka, was of ashen color. When the horses were yoked and the chariot ready to go, Kåñëa helped the brähmaëa up and gave him a seat by His side. Immediately they started from Dvärakä and within one night arrived at the province of Vidarbha. The kingdom of Dvärakä is situated in the western part of India, and Vidarbha is situated in the northern part. They are separated by a distance of not less than 1,000 miles, but the horses were so fast that they reached their destination, a town called Kuëòina, within one night, or at most, twelve hours.

King Bhéñmaka was not very enthusiastic about handing his daughter over to Çiçupäla, but he was obliged to accept the marriage settlement due to his affectionate attachment for his eldest son, who had negotiated it. As a matter of duty, he was decorating the city for the marriage ceremony and was acting in great earnestness to make it very successful. Water was sprinkled all over the streets, and the city was cleansed very nicely. Since India is situated in the tropical zone, the atmosphere is always dry. Due to this, dust always accumulates on the streets and roads; so they must be sprinkled with water at least once a day, and in big cities like Calcutta, twice a day. The roads of Kuëòina were arranged with colored flags and festoons, and gates were constructed at particular crossings. The whole city was decorated very nicely. The beauty of the city was enhanced by the inhabitants, both men and women, who were dressed in washed cloth, decorated with sandalwood pulp, pearl necklaces and flower garlands. Incense was burning everywhere, and fragrances like aguru scented the air. Priests and brähmaëas were sumptuously fed and, according to ritualistic ceremony, were given sufficient wealth and cows in charity. In this way, they were engaged in chanting Vedic hymns. The King's daughter, Rukmiëé, was exquisitely beautiful. She was very clean and had beautiful teeth. The auspicious sacred girdle was tied on her wrist. She was given various types of jewelry to put on and long silken cloth to cover the upper and lower parts of her body. Learned priests gave her protection by chanting mantras from the Säma Veda, Åg Veda and Yajur Veda. After this they chanted mantras from the Atharva Veda and offered oblations in the fire to pacify the ominous conjunctions of different stars.

King Bhéñmaka was very experienced in dealing with the brähmaëas and priests when such ceremonies were held. He specifically distinguished the brähmaëas by giving them large quantities of gold and silver, grains mixed with molasses, and cows decorated with golden ornaments. Damaghoña, Çiçupäla's father, executed all kinds of ritualistic performances to invoke good fortune for his own family. Çiçupäla's father was known as Damaghoña due to his superior ability to cut down unregulated citizens. Dama means curbing down, and ghoña means famous; so he was famous for controlling the citizens. Damaghoña thought that if Kåñëa came to disturb the marriage ceremony, he would certainly cut Him down with his military power. Therefore, after performing the various auspicious ceremonies, Damaghoña gathered his military divisions, known as Madasravi. He took many elephants, garlanded with golden necklaces, and many chariots and horses which were similarly decorated. It appeared that Damaghoña, along with his son and other companions, was going to Kuëòina, not completely forgetting the marriage, but mainly intent on fighting.

When King Bhéñmaka learned that Damaghoña and his party were arriving, he left the city to receive them. Outside the city gate there were many gardens where the guests were welcomed to stay. In the Vedic system of marriage, the bride's father receives the large party of the bridegroom and accomodates them in a suitable place for two or three days until the marriage ceremony is performed. The party led by Damaghoña contained thousands of men, among whom the prominent kings and personalities were Jaräsandha, Dantavakra, Vidüratha and Pauëòraka. It was an open secret that Rukmiëé was meant to be married to Kåñëa but that her elder brother, Rukmé, had arranged her marriage to Çiçupäla. There was also some whispering going on about a rumor that Rukmiëé had sent a messenger to Kåñëa; therefore the soldiers suspected that Kåñëa might cause a disturbance by attempting to kidnap Rukmiëé. Even though they were not without fear, they were all prepared to give Kåñëa a nice fight in order to prevent the girl from being taken away. Çré Balaräma received the news that Kåñëa had left for Kuëòina accompanied only by a brähmaëa; He also heard that Çiçupäla was there with a large number of soldiers. Suspecting that they would attack Kåñëa, Balaräma took strong military divisions of chariots, infantry, horses and elephants and arrived at the precinct of Kuëòina.

Meanwhile, inside the palace, Rukmiëé was expecting Kåñëa to arrive, but when neither He nor the brähmaëa who took her message appeared, she became full of anxiety and began to think how unfortunate she was. "There is only one night between today and my marriage day, and still neither the brähmaëa nor Çyämasundara has returned. I cannot ascertain any reason for this." Having little hope, she thought perhaps Kåñëa had found reason to become dissatisfied and had rejected her fair proposal. As a result, the brähmaëa might have become disappointed and not come back. Although she was thinking of various causes for the delay, she expected them both at every moment.

Rukmiëé further began to think that demigods such as Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva and the goddess Durgä might have been displeased. It is generally said that the demigods become angry when they are not properly worshiped. For instance, when Indra found that the inhabitants of Våndävana were not worshiping him (Kåñëa having stopped the Indra-yajïa), he became very angry and wanted to chastise them. Thus Rukmiëé was thinking that since she did not worship Lord Çiva or Lord Brahmä very much, they might have become angry and tried to frustrate her plan. Similarly she thought that the goddess Durgä, the wife of Lord Çiva, might have taken the side of her husband. Lord Çiva is known as Rudra, and his wife is known as Rudräëé. Rudräëé and Rudra refer to those who are very accustomed to putting others in a distressed condition so they might cry forever. Rukmiëé was thinking of the goddess Durgä as Girijä, the daughter of the Himalayan Mountains. The Himalayan Mountains are very cold and hard, and she thought of the goddess Durgä as hardhearted and cold. In her anxiety to see Kåñëa, Rukmiëé, who was after all still a child, thought this way about the different demigods. The gopés worship goddess Kätyäyané to get Kåñëa as their husband; similarly Rukmiëé was thinking of the various types of demigods, not for material benefit, but in respect to Kåñëa. Praying to the demigods to achieve the favor of Kåñëa is not irregular, and Rukmiëé was fully absorbed in thoughts of Kåñëa.

Even though she pacified herself by thinking that the time for Govinda to arrive had not yet expired, Rukmiëé felt that she was hoping against hope. She began to shed tears, and when they became more forceful, she closed her eyes in helplessness. While Rukmiëé was in such deep thought, auspicious symptoms appeared in different parts of her body. Trembling began to occur in her left eyelid and in her arms and thighs. When trembling occurs in these parts of the body, it is an auspicious sign indicating that something lucrative can be expected.

Just then, Rukmiëé, full of anxiety, saw the brähmaëa messenger. Kåñëa, being the Supersoul of all living beings, could understand Rukmiëé's anxiety; therefore he sent the brähmaëa inside the palace to let her know that He had arrived. When Rukmiëé saw the brähmaëa, she could understand the auspicious trembling of her body and immediately became elated. She smiled and inquired from him whether or not Kåñëa had already come. The brähmaëa replied that the son of the Yadu dynasty, Çré Kåñëa, had arrived; he further encouraged her by saying that Kåñëa had promised to carry her away without fail. Rukmiëé was so elated by the brähmaëa's message that she wanted to give him in charity everything she possessed. However, finding nothing suitable for presentation, she simply offered him her respectful obeisances. The significance of offering respectful obeisances to a superior is that the one offering obeisances is obliged to the respected person. In other words, Rukmiëé implied that she would remain ever grateful to the brähmaëa. Anyone who gets the favor of the goddess of fortune, as did this brähmaëa, is without a doubt always happy in material opulence.

When King Bhéñmaka heard that Kåñëa and Balaräma had come, he invited Them to see the marriage ceremony of his daughter. Immediately he arranged to receive Them, along with Their soldiers, in a suitable garden house. As was the Vedic custom, the King offered Kåñëa and Balaräma honey and fresh washed cloth. He was hospitable not only to Kåñëa, Balaräma and kings such as Jaräsandha, but he also received many other kings and princes according to their respective personal strength, age and material possessions. Out of curiosity and eagerness, the people of Kuëòina assembled before Kåñëa and Balaräma and began to drink the nectar of Their beauty. With tearful eyes, they offered Them their silent respects. They were very pleased, considering Lord Kåñëa the suitable match for Rukmiëé. They were so eager to unite Kåñëa and Rukmiëé that they began to pray to the Personality of Godhead: "My dear Lord, if we have performed any pious activities that You are satisfied with, kindly be merciful upon us and accept the hand of Rukmiëé." It appears that Rukmiëé was a very popular princess, and all the citizens, out of intense love for her, prayed for her best fortune. In the meantime, Rukmiëé, being very nicely dressed and protected by bodyguards, came out of the palace to visit the temple of Ambikä, the goddess Durgä.

Deity worship in the temple has been in existence since the beginning of Vedic culture. There is a class of men described in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.42] as the veda-väda-rata; they only believe in the Vedic ritualistic ceremonies, but not in the temple worship. Such foolish people may here take note that although this marriage of Kåñëa and Rukmiëé took place more than 5,000 years ago, there were arrangements for temple worship. In the Bhagavad-gétä the Lord says, yänti deva-vratä devän: "The worshipers of the demigods attain the abodes of the demigods." There were many people who worshiped the demigods and many who directly worshiped the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The system of demigod worship was directed mainly to Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, Lord Gaëeça, the sun-god and the goddess Durgä. Lord Çiva and the goddess Durgä were worshiped even by the royal families; other minor demigods were worshiped by silly inferior people. As far as the brähmaëas and Vaiñëavas are concerned, they simply worship Lord Viñëu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20] the worship of demigods is condemned, but not forbidden; there it is clearly stated that the less intelligent class of men worship the different kinds of demigods for material benefit. On the other hand, even though Rukmiëé was the goddess of fortune, she went to the temple of the goddess Durgä because the family deity was worshiped there. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.53.40-41] it is stated that as Rukmiëé was proceeding towards the temple of the goddess Durgä, within her heart she was always thinking of the lotus feet of Kåñëa. Therefore when Rukmiëé went to the temple it was not with the intention of an ordinary person, who goes to beg for material benefits; her only target was Kåñëa. When people go to the temple of a demigod, the objective is actually Kåñëa, since it is He who empowers the demigods to provide material benefits.

As Rukmiëé proceeded toward the temple, she was very silent and grave. Her mother and her girl friend were by her side, and the wife of a brähmaëa was in the center; surrounding her were royal bodyguards. (This custom of a would-be bride going to the temple of a demigod is still practiced in India.) As the procession continued, various musical sounds were heard. Drums, conchshells, and bugles of different sizes such as paëavas, turyas and bheris combined to make a sound which was not only auspicious but very sweet to hear. There were thousands of wives of respectable brähmaëas present. These women were all dressed very nicely with suitable ornaments. They presented Rukmiëé with flower garlands, sandalwood pulp and a variety of colorful garments to assist her in worshiping Lord Çiva and the goddess Durgä. Some of these ladies were very old and knew perfectly well how to chant prayers to the goddess Durgä and Lord Çiva; so, followed by Rukmiëé and others, they led these prayers before the deity.

Rukmiëé offered her prayers to the deity by saying, "My dear goddess Durgä, I offer my respectful obeisances unto you as well as to your children." The goddess Durgä has four famous children: two daughters—the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé, and the goddess of learning, Sarasvaté—and two famous sons, Lord Gaëeça and Lord Kärttikeya. They are all considered to be demigods and goddesses. Since the goddess Durgä is always worshiped along with her famous children, Rukmiëé specifically offered her respectful obeisances to the deity in that way; however her prayers were different. Ordinary people pray to the goddess Durgä for material wealth, fame, profit, strength and so on; Rukmiëé, however, desired to have Kåñëa for her husband and therefore prayed to the deity to be pleased upon her and bless her. Since she desired only Kåñëa, her worship of the demigods is not condemned. While Rukmiëé was praying, a variety of items were presented before the deity, chief of which were water, different kinds of flames, incense, garments, garlands and various foodstuffs prepared with ghee, such as puris and kacuris. There were also fruits, sugar cane, betel nuts and spices offered. With great devotion, Rukmiëé offered them to the deity according to the regulative principles directed by the old brähmaëa ladies. After this ritualistic ceremony, the ladies offered the remnants of the foodstuffs to Rukmiëé as prasädam, which she accepted with great respect. Then Rukmiëé offered her obeisances to the ladies and to the goddess Durgä. After the business of deity worship was finished, Rukmiëé caught hold of the hand of one of her girl friends and left the temple, accompanied by the others.

All the princes and visitors who came to Kuëòina for the marriage were assembled outside the temple to see Rukmiëé. The princes were especially very eager to see her because they all actually thought that they would have Rukmiëé as their wife. Struck with wonder upon seeing Rukmiëé, they thought that she was specially manufactured by the Creator to bewilder all the great chivalrous princes. Her body was well-constructed, the middle portion being thin. She had green eyes, pink lips, and a beautiful face which was enhanced by her scattered hair and by different kinds of earrings. Around her feet she wore jeweled lockets. The bodily luster and beauty of Rukmiëé appeared as if painted by an artist perfectly presenting beauty following the description of great poets. The breast of Rukmiëé is described as being a little bit high, indicating that she was just a youth not more than thirteen or fourteen years old. Her beauty was specifically intended to attract the attention of Kåñëa. Although the princes gazed upon her beautiful features, she was not at all proud. Her eyes moved restlessly, and when she smiled very simply, like an innocent girl, her teeth appeared just like lotus flowers. Expecting Kåñëa to take her away at any moment, she proceeded very slowly towards her home. Her legs moved just like a full-grown swan, and her ankle bells tinkled very mildly.

As already explained, the great chivalrous princes who assembled there were so overwhelmed by Rukmiëé's beauty that they almost became unconscious. Full of lust, they hopelessly desired Rukmiëé's hand, comparing their own beauty with hers. Çrématé Rukmiëé, however, was not interested in any of them; in her heart she was simply expecting Kåñëa to come and carry her away. As she was adjusting the ornaments on her left-hand finger, she happened to look upon the princes and suddenly saw that Kåñëa was present amongst them. Although Rukmiëé had never before seen Kåñëa, she was always thinking of Him; thus she had no difficulty in recognizing Him amongst the princely order. Kåñëa, not being concerned with the other princes, immediately took the opportunity of placing Rukmiëé on His chariot, marked by a flag bearing an image of Garuòa. He then proceeded slowly, without fear, taking away Rukmiëé exactly as the lion takes the deer from the midst of the jackals. Meanwhile Balaräma appeared on the scene with the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty.

Jaräsandha, who had many times experienced defeat by Kåñëa, began to roar: "How is this? Kåñëa is taking Rukmiëé away from us without any opposition! What is the use in our being chivalrous fighters with arrows? My dear princes, just look! We are losing our reputation by this action. It is just like the jackal taking away the booty from the lion."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fifty-second Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kåñëa Kidnaps Rukmiëé."

KB 1970-1-53 / Kåñëa Defeats All the Princes and Takes Rukmiëé Home to Dvärakä

53 / Kåñëa Defeats All the Princes and Takes Rukmiëé Home to Dvärakä

All the princes led by Jaräsandha became very angry at Kåñëa's kidnapping Rukmiëé. Struck by the beauty of Rukmiëé, they had fallen from the backs of their horses and elephants, but now they began to stand up and properly arm themselves. Picking up their bows and arrows, they began to chase Kåñëa on their chariots, horses and elephants. To check their progress, the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty turned and faced them. Thus terrible fighting between the two belligerant groups began. The princes opposing Kåñëa were led by Jaräsandha, and they were all very expert in fighting. They began to shoot their arrows at the soldiers of Yadu just as a cloud splashes the face of a mountain with torrents of rain. Gathered on the face of a mountain, a cloud does not move very much, and therefore the force of rain is much more severe on a mountain than it is anywhere else.

The opposing princes were determined to defeat Kåñëa and recapture Rukmiëé from His custody, and they fought with Him as severely as possible. Rukmiëé, seated by the side of Kåñëa, saw arrows raining from the opposing party onto the faces of the soldiers of Yadu. In a fearful attitude, she began to look on the face of Kåñëa, expressing her gratefulness that He had taken such a great risk for her sake only. Her eyes moving, she appeared to be very sorry, and Kåñëa could immediately understand her mind. He encouraged her with these words: "My dear Rukmiëé, don't worry. Please rest assured that the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty will kill all the opposing soldiers without delay."

As Kåñëa was speaking with Rukmiëé, the commanders of the Yadu dynasty's soldiers, headed by Lord Balaräma, who is also known as Saìkarñaëa, as well as by Gadadhara, not tolerating the defiant attitude of the opposing soldiers, began to strike their horses, elephants, and chariots with arrows. As the fighting progressed, the princes and soldiers of the enemy camp began to fall from their horses, elephants and chariots. Within a very short time, it was seen that millions of severed heads, decorated with helmets and earrings, had fallen on the battlefield. The soldiers' hands were cut up along with their bows and arrows and clubs; one head was piled upon another, and one horse was piled upon another. All the infantry soldiers, as well as their camels, elephants and asses, fell down with severed heads.

When the enemy, headed by Jaräsandha, found that they were gradually being defeated by the soldiers of Kåñëa, they thought it unwise to risk losing in the battle for the sake of Çiçupäla. Çiçupäla himself should have fought to rescue Rukmiëé from the hands of Kåñëa, but when the soldiers saw that Çiçupäla was not competent enough to fight with Kåñëa, they decided not to lose their strength unnecessarily; therefore they ceased fighting and dispersed.

Some of the princes, as a matter of etiquette, appeared before Çiçupäla. They saw that Çiçupäla was very much discouraged, like one who has lost his wife. His face appeared to be dried up, he had lost all his energy, and all the luster of his body had disappeared. They began to address Çiçupäla thus: "My dear Çiçupäla, don't be discouraged in this way. You belong to the royal order and are the chief amongst the fighters. There is no question of distress or happiness for a person like you because neither of these conditions is everlasting. Take courage. Don't be disappointed by this temporary reverse. After all, we are not the final actor; as puppets dance in the hands of a magician, we are all dancing by the will of the Supreme, and according to His grace only we suffer distress or enjoy happiness, which therefore balance equally in all circumstances."

The whole catastrophe of the defeat was due to the envious nature of Rukmiëé's elder brother, Rukmé. Having seen his sister forcibly taken away by Kåñëa after he had planned to marry her with Çiçupäla, Rukmé was frustrated. So he and Çiçupäla, his friend and intended brother-in-law, returned to their respective homes. Rukmé, very much agitated, was determined to personally teach Kåñëa a lesson. He called for his own soldiers—a military phalanx consisting of several thousand elephants; horses, chariots and infantry—and, equipped with this military strength, he began to follow Kåñëa to Dvärakä. In order to show his prestige, Rukmé began to promise before all the returning kings, "You could not help Çiçupäla marry my sister Rukmiëé, but I cannot allow Rukmiëé to be taken away by Kåñëa. I shall teach Him a lesson. Now I am going there." He presented himself as a big commander and vowed before all the princes present, "Unless I kill Kåñëa in the fight and bring back my sister from His clutches, I shall no more return to my capital city, Kuëòina. I make this vow before you all, and you will see that I shall fulfill it." After thus vibrating all these boasting words, Rukmé immediately got on his chariot and told his chariot driver to pursue Kåñëa. He said, "I want to fight with Him immediately. This cowherd boy has become very proud because of His tricky way of fighting with the kñatriyas, but today I shall teach Him a good lesson. Because He has the impudency to kidnap my sister, I, with my sharpened arrows, shall teach Him very good lessons indeed." Thus this unintelligent man, Rukmé, ignorant of the extent of the strength and activities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, began to voice impudent threats.

In great stupidity he soon stood before Kåñëa, telling Him repeatedly, "Stop for a minute and fight with me!" After saying this he drew his bow and directly shot three forceful arrows against Kåñëa's body. Then he condemned Kåñëa as the most abominable descendant of the Yadu dynasty and asked Him to stand before him for a minute so that he could teach Him a good lesson. "You are carrying away my sister just like a crow stealing clarified butter meant for use in a sacrifice. You are simply proud of Your military strength, but You cannot fight according to regulative principles. You have stolen my sister; now I shall relieve You of Your false prestige. You can keep my sister under Your possession only as long as I do not pinion You to the ground for good with my arrows."

Lord Kåñëa, after hearing all these crazy words from Rukmé, immediately shot an arrow and severed the string of Rukmé's bow, making him unable to use another arrow. Rukmé immediately took another bow and shot another five arrows at Kåñëa. Being attacked for the second time by Rukmé, Kåñëa again severed his bowstring. Rukmé took a third bow, and Kåñëa again cut off its string. This time, in order to teach Rukmé a lesson, Kåñëa personally shot six arrows at him, and then He shot another eight arrows. Thus four horses were killed by four arrows, the chariot driver was killed by another arrow, and the upper portion of Rukmé's chariot, including the flag, was chopped off with the remaining three arrows.

Having run out of arrows, Rukmé took the assistance of swords, shields, tridents, lances and similar other weapons used for fighting hand-to-hand, but Kåñëa immediately severed them all in the same way. Being repeatedly baffled in his attempts, Rukmé simply took his sword and ran very swiftly toward Kåñëa, just as a fly proceeds toward a fire. As soon as Rukmé reached Kåñëa, Kåñëa cut his weapon to pieces. This time Kåñëa took out His sharp sword and was about to kill him immediately, but Rukmé's sister Rukmiëé, understanding that this time Kåñëa would not excuse her brother, fell down at the lotus feet of Kåñëa and in a very grievous tone, trembling with great fear, began to plead with her husband.

Rukmiëé first addressed Kåñëa as "Yogeçvara." Yogeçvara means one who is possessed of inconceivable opulence and energy. Kåñëa possesses inconceivable opulence and energy, whereas Rukmiëé's brother had only limited military potency. Kåñëa is immeasurable, whereas her brother was measured in every step of his life. Therefore, Rukmé was not even comparable to an insignificant insect before the unlimited power of Kåñëa. She also addressed Kåñëa as the God of the gods. There are many powerful demigods, such as Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, Indra, and Candra; Kåñëa is the Lord of all these gods, whereas Rukmiëé's brother was not only an ordinary human being, but was, in fact, the lowest of all because he had no understanding of Kåñëa. In other words, a human being who has no conception of the actual position of Kåñëa is the lowest in human society. Rukmiëé also addressed Kåñëa as "Jagatpati," the master of the whole cosmic manifestation. In comparison, her brother was only a ordinary prince.

In this way, Rukmiëé compared the position of Rukmé to that of Kåñëa and very feelingly pleaded with her husband not to kill her brother just before the auspicious time of her being united with Kåñëa, but to excuse him. In other words, she displayed her real position as a woman. She was happy to get Kåñëa as her husband just at the moment when her marriage to another was to be performed, but she did not want it to be at the loss of her elder brother, who, after all, loved his young sister and wanted to hand her over to one who was, according to his own calculations, a better man. While Rukmiëé was praying to Kåñëa for the life of her brother, her whole body trembled, and because of her anxiety, her face appeared to be dried up, her throat became choked, and, due to her trembling, the ornaments on her body loosened and fell scattered on the ground. Lord Kåñëa immediately became compassionate and agreed not to kill the foolish Rukmé. But, at the same time, He wanted to give him some light punishment, so He tied him up with a piece of cloth and snipped at his moustache, beard and hair, keeping some spots here and there.

While Kåñëa was dealing with Rukmé in this way, the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty, commanded by Balaräma Himself, broke the whole strength of Rukmé's army just as an elephant in a tank discards the feeble stem of a lotus flower. In other words, as an elephant breaks the whole construction of a lotus flower while bathing in the reservoir of water, so the military strength of the Yadus broke up Rukmé's forces. Yet when the commanders of the Yadu dynasty came back to see Kåñëa, they were all surprised to see the condition of Rukmé. Lord Balaräma became especially compassionate for His sister-in-law, who was newly married to His brother. In order to please Rukmiëé, Balaräma personally untied Rukmé, and in order to further please her, Balaräma, as the elder brother of Kåñëa, spoke some words of chastisement. "Kåñëa, Your action is not at all satisfactory," He said. "This is an abomination very much contrary to our family tradition! To cut someone's hair and shave his moustache and beard is almost comparable to killing him. Whatever Rukmé might have been, he is now our brother-in-law, a relative of our family, and You should not have put him in such a condition."

After this, in order to pacify her, Lord Balaräma said to Rukmiëé, "You should not be sorry because your brother has been made very odd-looking. Everyone suffers or enjoys the results of his own actions." Lord Balaräma wanted to impress upon Rukmiëé that she should not have been sorry for the consequences suffered by her brother due to his actions. There was no need of being too affectionate toward such a brother. Lord Balaräma again turned toward Kåñëa and said, "My dear Kåñëa, a relative, even though he commits such a blunder and deserves to be killed, should be excused. For when such a relative is conscious of his own fault, that consciousness itself is like death. Therefore, there is no need in killing him." He again turned toward Rukmiëé and informed her that the current duty of the kñatriya in the human society is so fixed that, according to the principles of fighting, one's own brother may become an enemy on the opposite side. A kñatriya does not hesitate to kill his own brother. In other words, Lord Balaräma wanted to instruct Rukmiëé that Rukmé and Kåñëa were right in not showing mercy to each other in the fighting, despite the family consideration that they happened to be brothers-in-law. Çré Balaräma continued to inform Rukmiëé that kñatriyas are typical emblems of the materialistic way of life; they become puffed-up whenever there is a question of material acquisition. Therefore, when there is a fight between two belligerent kñatriyas on account of kingdom, land, wealth, women, prestige or power, they try to put one another into the most abominable condition. Balaräma instructed Rukmiëé that her affection toward her brother Rukmé, who had created enmity with so many persons, was a perverse consideration befitting an ordinary materialistic person. Her brother's character was not at all adorable, considering his treatment toward other friends, and yet Rukmiëé, as an ordinary woman, was so affectionate toward him. He was not fit to be her brother, and still Rukmiëé was lenient toward him.

"Besides that," Balaräma continued, "the consideration that a person is neutral or is one's friend or enemy is generally made by persons who are in the bodily concept of life. Such foolish persons become bewildered by the illusory energy of the Supreme Lord. The spirit soul is of the same pure quality in any embodiment of matter, but those who are not sufficiently intelligent see only the bodily differentiations of animals and men, literates and illiterates, rich and poor, and so on, which cover the pure spirit soul. Such differentiation, observed purely on the basis of the body, is exactly like differentiation between fires in terms of the different types of fuel they consume. Whatever the size and shape of the fuel, there is no such variety of size and shape of the fire which comes out. Similarly, in the sky there are no differences in size or shape."

In this way Balaräma appeased them by His moral and ethical instruction. He stated further: "This body is part of the material manifestation. The living entity or spirit soul, being in contact with matter, is transmigrating, due to illusory enjoyment, from one body to another, and that is known as material existence. This contact of the living entity with the material manifestation has neither integration nor disintegration. My dear chaste sister-in-law, the spirit soul is, of course, the cause of this material body, as much as the sun is the cause of sunlight, eyesight and the forms of material manifestation. The example of the sunshine and the material manifestation is very appropriate in the matter of understanding the living entities' contact with this material world. In the morning, there is sunrise, and the heat and light expand gradually throughout the whole day. The sun is the cause of all material production and shapes and forms; it is due to the sun that integration and disintegration of material elements take place. But as soon as the sun is set, the whole manifestation is no longer connected to the sun, which has passed from one place to another. When the sun passes from the eastern to the western hemisphere, the result of interaction due to the sunshine in the eastern hemisphere remains, but the sunshine itself is visible again on the western hemisphere. Similarly, the living entity accepts or produces different bodies and different bodily relationships in a particular circumstance, but as soon as he gives up the present body and accepts another, he has nothing to do with the former body. Similarly, the living entity has nothing to do with the next body which he accepts. He is always free from the contact of this bodily contamination. Therefore, the conclusion is that the appearance and disappearance of the body have nothing to do with the living entity, as much as the waxing and waning of the moon have nothing to do with the moon. When there is waxing of the moon, we falsely think that the moon is developing, and when there is waning of the moon we think that the moon is decreasing. Factually the moon, as it is, is always the same; it has nothing to do with such visible waxing and waning activities.

"Consciousness of material existence can be compared to sleeping and dreaming. When a man sleeps, he dreams of many nonfactual happenings, and as a result of dreaming he becomes subjected to different kinds of distress and happiness. Similarly, when a person is in the dreaming condition of material consciousness, he suffers the effects of accepting a body and giving it up again in material existence. Opposite to this material consciousness is Kåñëa consciousness. In other words, when a man is elevated to the platform of Kåñëa consciousness he becomes free from this false conception of life."

In this way, Çré Balaräma instructed them in spiritual knowledge. He addressed his sister-in-law thus: "Sweet, smiling Rukmiëé, do not be aggrieved by false motives caused by ignorance. Due to false notions only one becomes unhappy, but this unhappiness is immediately removed by discussing the philosophy of actual life. Be happy on that platform only."

After hearing such enlightening instruction from Çré Balaräma, Rukmiëé immediately became pacified and happy and adjusted her mental condition, which was very much afflicted by seeing the degraded position of her brother, Rukmé. As far as Rukmé was concerned, neither was his promise fulfilled nor his mission successful. He had come from home with his soldiers and military phalanx to defeat Kåñëa and release his sister, but on the contrary, he lost all his soldiers and military strength. He was personally much degraded, and in that condition he was very sorry; but by the grace of the Lord he could continue his life to the fixed destination. Because he was a kñatriya, he could remember his promise that he would not return to his capital city, Kuëòina, without killing Kåñëa and releasing his sister, which he had failed to do; therefore, he decided in anger not to return to his capital city, and he constructed a small cottage in the village known as Bhojakaöa and began to reside there for the rest of his life.

After defeating all the opposing elements and forcibly carrying away Rukmiëé, Kåñëa brought her to His capital city, Dvärakä, and then married her according to the Vedic ritualistic principle. After this marriage, Kåñëa became the King of the Yadus at Dvärakä. On the occasion of His marriage with Rukmiëé, all the inhabitants were happy, and in every house there were great ceremonies. The inhabitants of Dvärakä City became so pleased that they dressed themselves with the nicest possible ornaments and garments, and they went to present gifts according to their means to the newly married couple, Kåñëa and Rukmiëé. All the houses of Yadupuré (Dvärakä) were decorated with flags, festoons and flowers. Each and every house had an extra gate specifically prepared for this occasion, and on both sides of the gate there were big water jugs filled with water. The whole city was flavored by the burning of high quality incense, and at night there was illumination by thousands of lamps, decorating each and every building.

The entire city appeared jubilant on the occasion of Lord Kåñëa's marriage with Rukmiëé. Everywhere in the city there was profuse decoration of banana trees and betel nut trees. These two trees are considered very auspicious in happy ceremonies. At the same time there was an assembly of many elephants, who carried the respective kings of different friendly kingdoms. It is the habit of the elephant that whenever he sees some small plants and trees, out of his sportive frivolous nature, he uproots the trees and throws them hither and thither. The elephants assembled on this occasion also scattered the banana and betel nut trees, but in spite of such intoxicated action, the whole city, with the trees thrown here and there, looked very nice.

The friendly kings of the Kurus and the Päëòavas were represented by Dhåtaräñöra, the five Päëòu brothers, King Drupada, King Santardana, as well as Rukmiëé's father, Bhéñmaka. Because of Kåñëa's kidnapping Rukmiëé, there was initially some misunderstanding between the two families, but Bhéñmaka, King of Vidarbha, being approached by Çré Balaräma and persuaded by many saintly persons, was induced to participate in the marriage ceremony of Kåñëa and Rukmiëé. Although the incidence of Kåñëa's kidnapping was not a very happy occurrence in the kingdom of Vidarbha, kidnapping was not an unusual affair among the kñatriyas. Kidnapping was, in fact, current in almost all marriages. Anyway, King Bhéñmaka was from the very beginning inclined to hand over his beautiful daughter to Kåñëa. In one way or another his purpose had been served, and so he was pleased to join the marriage ceremony, even though his eldest son was degraded in the fight. It is mentioned in the Padma Puräëa that Mahäräja Nanda and the cowherd boys of Våndävana joined the marriage ceremony. Kings from the kingdoms of Kuru, Såïjaya, Kekaya, Vidarbha and Kunti came to Dvärakä on this occasion with all their royal paraphernalia.

The story of Rukmiëé's being kidnapped by Kåñëa was poeticized, and the professional readers recited it everywhere. All the assembled kings and, especially, their daughters were struck with wonder and became very pleased upon hearing the chivalrous activities of Kåñëa. In this way, all visitors as well as the inhabitants of Dvärakä City became joyful seeing Kåñëa and Rukmiëé together. In other words, the Supreme Lord, the maintainer of everyone, and the goddess of fortune were united, and all the people felt extremely jubilant.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fifty-third Chapter of Kåñëa, "Kåñëa Defeats all the Princes and Takes Rukmiëé Home to Dvärakä."

KB 1970-1-54 / Pradyumna Born to Kåñëa and Rukmiëé

54 / Pradyumna Born to Kåñëa and Rukmiëé

It is said that Cupid, who is directly part and parcel of Lord Väsudeva and who was formerly burnt to ashes by the anger of Lord Çiva, took birth in the womb of Rukmiëé begotten by Kåñëa. This is Kämadeva, a demigod of the heavenly planets especially capable of inducing lusty desires. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, has many grades of parts and parcels, but the quadruple expansions of Kåñëa—Vasudeva, Saìkarñaëa, Pradyumna and Aniruddha—are directly in the Viñëu category. Käma, or the Cupid demigod, who later on took his birth in the womb of Rukmiëé, was also named Pradyumna, but he cannot be the Pradyumna of the Viñëu category. He belongs to the category of jéva-tattva, but for special power in the category of demigods, he was a part and parcel of the super prowess of Pradyumna. That is the verdict of the Gosvämés. Therefore, when Cupid was burnt into ashes by the anger of Lord Çiva he merged into the body of Vasudeva, and in order to get his body again, he was begotten by Lord Kåñëa Himself; he was directly released from his body in the womb of Rukmiëé and was born as the son of Kåñëa, celebrated by the name Pradyumna. Because he was begotten by Lord Kåñëa directly, his qualities were most similar to those of Kåñëa.

There was a demon of the name Çambara who was destined to be killed by this Pradyumna. The Çambara demon knew of his destiny, and as soon as he learned that Pradyumna was born, he took the shape of a woman and kidnapped the baby from the maternity home less than ten days after his birth. The demon took him and threw him directly into the sea. But, as it is said, "Whoever is protected by Kåñëa, no one can kill; and whoever is destined to be killed by Kåñëa, no one can protect." When Pradyumna was thrown in the sea, a big fish immediately swallowed him. Later on this fish was caught by the net of a fisherman, and the fish was later on sold to the Çambara demon. In the kitchen of the demon there was a maidservant whose name was Mäyävaté. This woman had formerly been the wife of Cupid, and had been called Rati. When the fish was presented to the demon Çambara, it was taken charge of by his cook, who was to make it into a palatable fish preparation. Demons and the räkñasas are accustomed to eat meat, fish and similar non-vegetarian foods. Similarly, other demons, like Rävaëa, Kaàsa and Hiraëyakaçipu, although born of brähmaëa and kñatriya fathers, used to take meat and flesh without discrimination. This practice is still prevalent in India, and those who are meat and fish eaters are generally called demons and räkñasas.

When the cook was cutting the fish, he found a nice baby within the belly of the fish, and he immediately presented him to the charge of Mäyävaté, who was an assistant in the kitchen affairs. This woman was surprised to see how such a nice baby could remain within the belly of a fish, and the situation perplexed her. The great sage Närada then appeared and explained to her about the birth of Pradyumna, how the baby had been taken away by Çambara and later on thrown into the sea, and so on. In this way the whole story was disclosed to Mäyävaté, who had formerly been Rati, the wife of Cupid. Mäyävaté knew that she had previously been the wife of Cupid; after her husband was burnt into ashes by the wrath of Lord Çiva, she was always expecting him to come back again in the material form. This woman was engaged for cooking rice and dahl in the kitchen, but when she got this nice baby and understood that he was Cupid, her own husband, she naturally took charge of him and with great affection began to bathe him. Miraculously, the baby very swiftly grew up, and within a very short period he became a very beautiful young man. His eyes were just like the petals of lotus flowers, his arms were very long, down to the knees, and any woman who happened to see him became captivated by his bodily beauty.

Mäyävaté could understand that her former husband, Cupid, born as Pradyumna, had grown into such a nice young man, and she also gradually became captivated and lusty. She was smiling before him with a feminine attractiveness, expressing her desire for sexual unity. He therefore inquired from her, "How is it possible that first of all you were affectionate like a mother, and now you are expressing the symptoms of a lusty woman? What is the reason for such a change?" On hearing this statement from Pradyumna, the woman, Rati, replied, "My dear sir, you are the son of Lord Kåñëa. Before you were ten days old, you were stolen by the Çambara demon and later on thrown into the water and swallowed up by a fish. In this way you have come under my care, but actually, in your former life as Cupid, I was your wife; therefore, my manifestation of conjugal symptoms is not at all incompatible. Çambara wanted to kill you, and he is endowed with various kinds of mystic powers. Therefore, before he again attempts to kill you, please kill him as soon as possible with your divine power. Since you were stolen by Çambara, your mother, Rukmiëédevi, has been in a very grievous condition, like a cuckoo bird who has lost her babies. She is very affectionate toward you, and since you have been taken away from her, she has been living like a cow aggrieved over the loss of its calf."

Mäyävaté had mystic knowledge of supernatural power. Supernatural powers are generally known as mäyä, and to supersede all such supernatural power there is another supernatural power, which is called mahämäyä. Mäyävaté had the knowledge of the mystic power of mahämäyä, and she delivered to Pradyumna this specific energetic power in order to defeat the mystic powers of the Çambara demon. Thus being empowered by his wife, Pradyumna immediately went before Çambara and challenged him to fight. Pradyumna began to address him in very strong language, so that his temper might be agitated and he would be moved to fight. At Pradyumna's words, the demon Çambara, being insulted, felt just like a snake feels after being struck by one's leg. A serpent cannot tolerate being kicked by another animal or by a man, and he immediately bites the opponent.

Çambara felt the words of Pradyumna as if they were a kick. He immediately took his club in his hand and appeared before Pradyumna to fight. In great anger, he began to beat Pradyumna with his club, just as a thunderbolt beats a mountain. The demon was also groaning and making a noise like a thundering cloud. Pradyumna protected himself with his own club, and eventually he struck the demon very severely. In this way, the fighting between Çambaräsura and Pradyumna began very seriously.

But Çambaräsura knew the art of mystic powers and could raise himself in the sky and fight from outer space. There is another demon of the name Maya, and Çambaräsura learned many mystic powers from him. He thus raised himself high in the sky and began to throw various types of nuclear weapons at the body of Pradyumna. In order to combat the mystic powers or Çambaräsura, Pradyumna remembered another mystic power, known as mahävidyä, which was different from the black mystic power. The mahävidyä mystic power is based on the quality of goodness. Understanding that his enemy was formidable, Çambara took assistance from various kinds of demonic mystic powers belonging to the Guhyakas, the Gandharvas, the Piçäcas, the snakes and the Räkñasas. But although the demon exhibited his mystic powers and took shelter of supernatural strength, Pradyumna was able to counteract his strength and powers by the superior power of mahävidyä. When Çambaräsura was defeated in every respect, Pradyumna then took his sharpened sword and immediately cut off the demon's head, which was decorated with a helmet and with valuable jewels. When Pradyumna thus killed the demon, all the demigods in the higher planetary systems began to shower flowers on him.

Pradyumna's wife, Mäyävaté, could travel in outer space, and therefore they directly reached his father's capital, Dvärakä, by the airways. They passed above the palace of Lord Kåñëa and began to come down as a cloud comes down with lightning. The inner section of a palace is known as antaùpura (private apartments). Pradyumna and Mäyävaté could see that there were many women there, and they sat down among them. When the women saw Pradyumna, dressed in bluish garments, with very long arms, curling hair, beautiful eyes, a smiling reddish face, jewelry and ornaments, they first of all could not recognize him as Pradyumna, a personality different from Kåñëa. They all felt themselves to be very much blessed by the sudden presence of Kåñëa, and they wanted to hide in a different corner of the palace.

When the women saw, however, that all the characteristics of Kåñëa were not present in the personality of Pradyumna, out of curiosity they came back again to see him and his wife, Mäyävaté. All of them were conjecturing as to who he was, for he was so beautiful. Among the women was Rukmiëédevé, who was equally beautiful, with her lotus-like eyes. Seeing Pradyumna, she naturally remembered her own son, and milk began to flow from her breast out of motherly affection. She then began to wonder, "Who is this beautiful young boy? He appears to be the most beautiful person. Who is the fortunate young woman able to give birth to this nice boy in her womb and become his mother? And who is that young woman who has accompanied him? How have they met? Remembering my own son, who was stolen even from the maternity home, I can only guess that if he is living somewhere, he might have grown by this time to be like this boy." Simply by intuition, Rukmiëé could understand that Pradyumna was her own lost son. She could also observe that Pradyumna resembled Lord Kåñëa in every respect. She was struck with wonder as to how he acquired all the symptoms of Kåñëa. She therefore began to think more confidently that the boy must be her own grown-up son because she felt much affection for him, and, as an auspicious sign, her left arm was trembling.

At that very moment, Lord Kåñëa, along with His father and mother, Devaké and Vasudeva, appeared on the scene. Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, could understand everything, yet in that situation He remained silent. However, by the desire of Lord Çré Kåñëa, the great sage Närada also appeared on the scene, and he began to disclose all the

incidences—how Pradyumna had been stolen from the maternity home and how he had grown up and had come there with his wife Mäyävaté, who formerly had been Rati, the wife of Cupid. When everyone was informed of the mysterious disappearance of Pradyumna and how he had grown up, they all became struck with wonder because they had gotten back their dead son after they were almost hopeless of his return. When they understood that it was Pradyumna who was present, they began to receive him with great delight. One after another, all of the members of the family—Devaké, Vasudeva, Lord Çré Kåñëa, Lord Balaräma, and Rukmiëé and all the women of the family—began to embrace both Pradyumna and his wife Mäyävaté. When the news of Pradyumna's return was spread all over the city of Dvärakä, all the astonished citizens began to come with great anxiety to see the lost Pradyumna. They began to say, "The dead son has come back. What can be more pleasing than this?"

Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé has explained that, in the beginning, all the residents of the palace, who were all mothers and stepmothers of Pradyumna, mistook him to be Kåñëa and were all bashful, infected by the desire for conjugal love. The explanation is that Pradyumna's personal appearance is exactly like Kåñëa's, and he was factually Cupid himself. There was no cause of astonishment, therefore, when the mothers of Pradyumna and other women mistook him in that way. It is clear from the statement that Pradyumna's bodily characteristics were so similar to Kåñëa's that he was mistaken to be Kåñëa even by his mother.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Fifty-fourth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Pradyumna Born to Kåñëa and Rukmiëé."


Thus ends Volume One of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

KÅÑËA, The Supreme Personality of Godhead - Volume 2, 1970 Edition

KB 1970-2-1 / The Story of the Syamantaka Jewel

1 /The Story of the Syamantaka Jewel

There was a king of the name Saträjit within the jurisdiction of Dvärakädhäma. He was a great devotee of the sun-god, who awarded him the benediction of a jewel known as Syamantaka. Because of this Syamantaka jewel, there was a misunderstanding between King Saträjit and the Yadu dynasty. Later on the matter was settled when Saträjit voluntarily offered Kåñëa his daughter, Satyabhämä, along with the jewel Syamantaka. Not only was Satyabhämä married to Kåñëa on account of the Syamantaka jewel, but Jämbavaté, the daughter of Jämbavän, was also married to Kåñëa. These two marriages took place before the appearance of Pradyumna, as described in the last chapter. How King Saträjit offended the Yadu dynasty and how he later on came to his senses and offered his daughter and the Syamantaka jewel to Kåñëa is described as follows.

Since he was a great devotee of the sun-god, King Saträjit gradually entered into a very friendly relationship with him. The sun-god was much pleased with him and delivered to him an exceptional jewel known as Syamantaka. When this jewel was worn by Saträjit in a locket around his neck, he appeared exactly like an imitation sun-god. Putting on this jewel, he would enter the city of Dvärakä, and people would think that the sun-god had come into the city to see Kåñëa. They knew that Kåñëa, being the Supreme Personality of Godhead, was sometimes visited by the demigods, so while Saträjit was visiting the city of Dvärakä all the inhabitants except Kåñëa took him to be the sun-god himself. Although King Saträjit was known to everyone, he could not be recognized because of the dazzling effulgence of the Syamantaka jewel.

Once, mistaking him to be the sun-god, some of the important citizens of Dvärakä immediately went to Kåñëa to inform Him that the sun-god had arrived to see Him. At that time, Kåñëa was playing chess. One of the important residents of Dvärakä spoke thus: "My dear Lord Näräyaëa, You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In Your plenary portion of Näräyaëa or Viñëu, You have four hands with different symbols—the conchshell, disc, club and lotus flower. You are actually the owner of everything, but in spite of Your being the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, You have descended in Våndävana to act as the child of Yaçodämätä, who sometimes used to tie You up with her ropes, and You are celebrated, therefore, by the name Dämodara."

That Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, as accepted by the citizens of Dvärakä, was later on confirmed by the great Mäyävädé philosophical leader, Çaìkaräcärya. By accepting the Lord as impersonal, he did not reject the Lord's personal form. He meant that everything which has form in this material world is subjected to creation, maintenance and annihilation, but the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, does not have a material form subjected to these limitations. In order to convince the less intelligent class of men who take Kåñëa to be an ordinary human being, Çaìkaräcärya therefore said that God is impersonal. This impersonality means that He is not a person of this material condition. He is a transcendental personality without a material body.

The citizens of Dvärakä addressed Lord Kåñëa not only as Dämodara, but also as Govinda, which indicates that Kåñëa is very affectionate to the cows and calves; and just to refer to their intimate connection with Kåñëa, they addressed Him as Yadunandana. He is the son of Vasudeva, born in the Yadu dynasty. In this way, the citizens of Dvärakä concluded that they were addressing Kåñëa as the supreme master of the whole universe. They addressed Kåñëa in many different ways, proud of being citizens of Dvärakä who could see Kåñëa daily.

When Saträjit was visiting the city of Dvärakä, the citizens felt great pride to think that although Kåñëa was living in Dvärakä like an ordinary human being, the demigods were coming to see Him. Thus they informed Lord Kåñëa that the sun-god, with his appealing bodily effulgence, was coming to see Him. The citizens of Dvärakä confirmed that the sun-god's coming into Dvärakä was not very wonderful, because people all over the universe who were searching after the Supreme Personality of Godhead knew that He had appeared in the family of the Yadu dynasty and was living in Dvärakä as one of the members of that family. Thus the citizens expressed their joy on this occasion. On hearing the statement of His citizens, the all-pervasive Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, simply smiled. Being pleased with the citizens of Dvärakä, Kåñëa informed them that the person whom they described as the sun-god was actually King Saträjit, who had come to visit Dvärakä City to show his opulence in the form of the valuable jewel obtained from the sun-god.

Saträjit, however, did not come to see Kåñëa; he was instead overwhelmed by the jewel of Syamantaka. He installed the jewel in a temple to be worshiped by brähmaëas he engaged for this purpose. This is an instance of a less intelligent person worshiping a material thing. In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20] it is stated that less intelligent persons, in order to get immediate results from their fruitive activities, worship the demigods who are created within this universe. The word "materialist" means one concerned with gratification of the senses within this material world. Although Kåñëa later asked for this Syamantaka jewel, King Saträjit did not deliver it to Him, but he installed the jewel for his purposes of worship. And who would not worship that jewel? The Syamantaka jewel was so powerful that it was daily producing a large quantity of gold. A quantity of gold is counted by a measurement called a bhära. According to Vedic formulas, one bhära is equal to sixteen pounds of gold; one mound equals eighty-two pounds. The jewel was producing about 170 pounds of gold every day. Besides that, it is learned from Vedic literature that in whatever part of the world this jewel is worshiped there is no possibility of famine; not only that, but wherever the jewel is present, there is no possibility of anything inauspicious, such as pestilence or disease.

Lord Kåñëa wanted to teach the world that the best of everything should be offered to the ruling chief of the country. King Ugrasena was the overlord of many dynasties and happened to be the grandfather of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa asked Saträjit to present the Syamantaka jewel to King Ugrasena. Kåñëa pleaded that the best should be offered to the king. But Saträjit, being a worshiper of the demigods, had become too materialistic and, instead of accepting the request of Kåñëa, thought it wiser to worship the jewel in order to get the 170 pounds of gold every day. Materialistic persons who can achieve such huge quantities of gold every day are not interested in Kåñëa consciousness. Sometimes, therefore, in order to show special favor, Kåñëa takes away great accumulations of materialistic wealth from a person and thus makes him a great devotee. But Saträjit refused to abide by the order of Kåñëa and did not deliver the jewel to him.

After this incident, Saträjit's younger brother, in order to display the opulence of the family, took the jewel, put it on his neck and rode on horseback into the forest making a show of his material opulence. While the brother of Saträjit, who was known as Prasena, was moving here and there in the forest, a big lion attacked him, killing both him and the horse on which he was riding, and took away the jewel to his cave. The news was received by the gorilla king, Jämbavän, who then killed that lion in the cave and took away the jewel. Jämbavän had been a great devotee of the Lord since the time of Lord Rämacandra, so he did not take the valuable jewel as something he very much needed. He gave it to his young son to play with as a toy.

In the city, when Saträjit's younger brother Prasena did not return from the forest with the jewel, Saträjit became very upset. He did not know that his brother had been killed by a lion and that the lion had been killed by Jämbavän. He was thinking instead that because Kåñëa wanted that jewel and it had not been delivered to Him, Kåñëa might have therefore taken the jewel away from Prasena by force and killed him. This idea grew into a rumor which was being spread by Saträjit in every part of Dvärakä.

The false rumor that Kåñëa had killed Prasena and had taken away the jewel was spread everywhere like wildfire. Kåñëa did not like to be defamed in that way, and therefore He decided that He would go to the forest and find the Syamantaka jewel, taking with Him some of the inhabitants of Dvärakä. Along with important men of Dvärakä, Kåñëa went to search out Prasena, the brother of Saträjit, and He found him dead, killed by the lion. At the same time, Kåñëa also found the lion which had been killed by Jämbavän, who is generally called by the name Åkña. It was found that the lion had been killed by the hand of Åkña without the assistance of any weapon. Kåñëa and the citizens of Dvärakä then found in the forest a great tunnel, said to be the path to Åkña's house. Kåñëa knew that the inhabitants of Dvärakä would be afraid to enter the tunnel; therefore He asked them to remain outside, and He Himself entered the dark tunnel alone to find Åkña, Jämbavän. After entering the tunnel, Kåñëa saw that the very valuable jewel known as Syamantaka had been given to the son of Åkña as a toy, and in order to take the jewel from the child, He went there and stood before him. When the nurse who was taking care of Åkña's child saw Kåñëa standing before her, she was afraid, thinking the valuable Syamantaka jewel might be taken away by Him. She began to cry loudly out of fear.

Hearing the nurse crying, Jämbavän appeared on the scene in a very angry mood. Jämbavän was actually a great devotee of Lord Kåñëa, but because he was in an angry mood he could not recognize his master; he thought Him to be an ordinary man. This brings to mind the statement of the Bhagavad-gétä [16.21] in which the Lord advises Arjuna to get free from anger, greed and lust in order to rise up to the spiritual platform. Lust, anger and greed run parallel in the heart and check one's progress on the spiritual path.

Not recognizing his master, Jämbavän first challenged Him to fight. There was then a great fight between Kåñëa and Jämbavän in which they fought like two opposing vultures. Whenever there is an eatable corpse the vultures fight heartily over the prey. Kåñëa and Jämbavän first of all began fighting with weapons, then with stones, then with big trees, then hand to hand, until at last they were hitting one another with their fists, and the blows were like the striking of thunderbolts. Each was expecting victory over the other, but the fighting continued for days, both in daytime and at night, without stopping. In this way the fighting continued for twenty-eight days.

Although Jämbavän was the strongest living entity of that time, practically all the joints of his bodily limbs became slackened and his strength reduced to practically nil after being constantly struck by the fists of Çré Kåñëa. Feeling very tired, with perspiration all over his body, Jämbavän was astonished. Who was this opponent who was weakening him? Jämbavän was quite aware of his own superhuman bodily strength, but when he felt tired from being struck by Kåñëa, he could understand that Kåñëa was no one else but his worshipable Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This incident has a special significance for the devotees. In the beginning, Jämbavän could not understand Kåñëa because his vision was obscured by material attachment. He was attached to his boy and to the greatly valuable Syamantaka jewel, which he did not want to spare for Kåñëa. In fact, when Kåñëa came there he became angry, thinking that He had come to take away the jewel. This is the material position; although one is very strong in body, that cannot help him understand Kåñëa.

In a sporting attitude, Kåñëa wanted to engage in a mock fight with His devotee. As we have experienced from the pages of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the Supreme Personality of Godhead has all the propensities and instincts of a human being. Sometimes, in a sportive spirit, He wishes to fight to make a show of bodily strength, and when He so desires, He selects one of His suitable devotees to give Him that pleasure. Kåñëa desired this pleasure of mock fighting with Jämbavän. Although Jämbavän was a devotee by nature, he was without knowledge of Kåñëa while giving service to the Lord by his bodily strength. But as soon as Kåñëa was pleased by the fighting, Jämbavän immediately understood that his opponent was none other than the Supreme Lord Himself. The conclusion is that he could understand Kåñëa by his service. Kåñëa is sometimes satisfied by fighting also.

Jämbavän therefore said to the Lord, "My dear Lord, I can now understand who You are. You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Viñëu, the source of everyone's strength, wealth, reputation, beauty, wisdom and renunciation." This statement of Jämbavän's is confirmed by the Vedänta-sütra, wherein the Supreme Lord is declared to be the source of everything. Jämbavän identified Lord Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality, Lord Viñëu: "My dear Lord, You are the creator of the creators of the universal affairs." This statement is very instructive to the ordinary man, who is amazed by the activities of a person with an exceptional brain. The ordinary man is surprised to see the inventions of a great scientist, but the statement of Jämbavän confirms that although a scientist may be a creator of many wonderful things, Kåñëa is the creator of the scientist. He is not only the creator of one scientist, but of millions and trillions, all over the universe. Jämbavän said further, "You are not only creator of the creator, but You are also creator of the material elements which are manipulated by the so-called creators." Scientists utilize the physical elements or laws of material nature and do something wonderful, but actually such laws and elements are also the creation of Kåñëa. This is actual scientific understanding. Less intelligent men do not try to understand who created the brain of the scientist; they are simply satisfied by seeing the wonderful creation or invention of the scientist.

Jämbavän continued: "My dear Lord, the time factor which combines all the physical elements is also Your representative. You are the supreme time factor in which all creation takes place, is maintained, and is finally annihilated. And not only the physical elements and the time factors but also the persons who manipulate the ingredients and advantages of creation are part and parcel of You. The living entity is not, therefore, an independent creator. By studying all factors in the right perspective, one can see that You are the supreme controller and Lord of everything. My dear Lord, I can therefore understand that You are the same Supreme Personality of Godhead whom I worship as Lord Rämacandra. My Lord Rämacandra wanted to construct a bridge over the ocean, and I saw personally how the ocean became agitated simply by my Lord's glancing over it. And when the whole ocean became agitated, the living entities like the whales, alligators and timiìgila fish, all became perturbed. [The timiìgila fish in the ocean can swallow big aquatics like whales in one gulp.] In this way the ocean was forced to give way and allow Rämacandra to cross to the island known as Laìkä [now supposed to be Ceylon]. This construction of a bridge over the ocean from Cape Comorin to Ceylon is still well-known to everyone. After the construction of the bridge, a fire was set all over the kingdom of Rävaëa. During the fighting with Rävaëa, each and every part of Rävaëa's limbs was slashed and cut into pieces by Your sharp arrows, and his head fell to the face of the earth. Now I can understand that You are none other than my Lord Rämacandra. No one else has such immeasurable strength; no one else could defeat me in this way."

Lord Kåñëa became satisfied by the prayers and statements of Jämbavän, and to mitigate the pains of his body, He began to smear the lotus palm of His hand all over the body of Jämbavän. Jämbavän at once felt relieved from the fatigue of the great fight. Lord Kåñëa then addressed him as King Jämbavän, because he and not the lion was actually the king of the forest; with his naked hand, without a weapon, Jämbavän had killed the lion. Kåñëa informed Jämbavän that He had come to him to ask for the Syamantaka jewel because since the Syamantaka jewel had been stolen His name had been defamed by the less intelligent. Kåñëa plainly informed him that he had come there to ask him for the jewel in order to be free from this defamation. Jämbavän understood the whole situation, and to satisfy the Lord he not only immediately delivered the Syamantaka jewel, but he also brought his daughter Jämbavaté, who was of marriagable age, and presented her to Lord Kåñëa.

The episode of Jämbavaté's marriage with Kåñëa and the delivery of the jewel known as Syamantaka was finished within the mountain cave. Although the fighting between Kåñëa and Jämbavän went on for twenty-eight days, the inhabitants of Dvärakä waited outside the tunnel for twelve days, and after that they decided that something undesirable must have happened. They could not understand what had actually happened for certain, and being very sorry and tired, they had returned to the city of Dvärakä.

All the members of the family, namely the mother of Kåñëa, Devaké, His father Vasudeva, and His chief wife Rukmiëé, along with all other friends, relatives and residents of the palace, became very sorry when the citizens returned home without Kåñëa. Because of their natural affection for Kåñëa, they began to call Saträjit ill names, for he was the cause of Kåñëa's disappearance. They went to worship the goddess Candrabhägä, praying for the return of Kåñëa. The goddess was satisfied by the prayers of the citizens of Dvärakä, and she immediately offered them her benediction. Simultaneously, Kåñëa appeared on the scene accompanied by His new wife Jämbavaté, and all the inhabitants of Dvärakä and relatives of Kåñëa became joyful. The inhabitants of Dvärakä became as joyful as someone receiving a dear relative back from the dead. The inhabitants of Dvärakä had concluded that Kåñëa had been put into great difficulties due to the fighting; therefore, they had become almost hopeless of His return. But when they saw that Kåñëa had actually returned, not alone but with a new wife, Jämbavaté, they immediately performed another celebration ceremony.

King Ugrasena then called for a meeting of all important kings and chiefs. He also invited Saträjit, and Kåñëa explained before the whole assembly the incident of the recovery of the jewel from Jämbavän. Kåñëa wanted to return the valuable jewel to King Saträjit. Saträjit, however, became ashamed because he had unnecessarily defamed Kåñëa. He accepted the jewel in his hand, but he remained silent, bending his head downwards, and without speaking anything in the assembly of the kings and chiefs, he returned home with the jewel. Then he thought about how he could clear himself from the abominable action he had performed by defaming Kåñëa. He was conscious that he had offended Kåñëa very grievously and that he had to find a remedial measure so that Kåñëa would again be pleased with him.

King Saträjit was eager to get relief from the anxiety he had foolishly created due to being attracted by a material thing, specifically the Syamantaka jewel. Saträjit was truly afflicted by the offense he had committed toward Kåñëa, and he sincerely wanted to rectify it. From within, Kåñëa gave him good intelligence, and Saträjit decided to hand over to Kåñëa both the jewel and his beautiful daughter, Satyabhämä. There was no alternative for mitigating the situation, and therefore he arranged the marriage ceremony of Kåñëa and his beautiful daughter. He gave in charity both the jewel and his daughter to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Satyabhämä was so beautiful and qualified that Saträjit, in spite of being asked for the hand of Satyabhämä by many princes, was waiting to find a suitable son-in-law. By the grace of Kåñëa he decided to hand his daughter over to Him.

Lord Kåñëa, being pleased upon Saträjit, informed him that He did not have any need of the Syamantaka jewel. "It is better to let it remain in the temple as you have kept it," He said, "and every one of us will derive benefit from the jewel. Because of the jewel's presence in the city of Dvärakä, there will be no more famine or disturbances created by pestilence or excessive heat and cold."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, First Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Story of the Syamantaka Jewel."

KB 1970-2-2 / The Killing of Saträjit and Çatadhanvä

2 /The Killing of Saträjit and Çatadhanvä

After Akrüra visited Hastinäpura and reported the condition of the Päëòavas to Kåñëa, there were further developments. The Päëòavas were transferred to a house which was made of shellac and was later on set ablaze, and everyone understood that the Päëòavas along with their mother, Kunté, had been killed. This information was also sent to Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma. After consulting together, They decided to go to Hastinäpura to show sympathy to Their relatives. Kåñëa and Balaräma certainly knew that the Päëòavas could not have been killed in the devastating fire, but in spite of this knowledge They wanted to go to Hastinäpura to take part in the bereavement. On arriving in Hastinäpura, Kåñëa and Balaräma first of all went to see Bhéñmadeva, because he was the chief of the Kuru dynasty. They then saw Vidura, Gändhäré and Droëa. Other members of the Kuru dynasty were not sorry, because they wanted the Päëòavas and their mother to be killed. But some family members, headed by Bhéñma, were actually very sorry for the incident, and Kåñëa and Balaräma expressed equal sorrow, without disclosing the actual situation.

When Kåñëa and Balaräma were away from the city of Dvärakä, there was a conspiracy to take away the Syamantaka jewel from Saträjit. The chief conspirator was Çatadhanvä. Along with others, Çatadhanvä wanted to marry Satyabhämä, the beautiful daughter of Saträjit. Saträjit had promised that he would give his beautiful daughter in charity to various candidates, but later on the decision was changed, and Satyabhämä was given to Kåñëa along with the Syamantaka jewel. Saträjit had no desire to give the jewel away along with his daughter, and Kåñëa, knowing his mentality, accepted his daughter but returned the jewel. After getting back the jewel from Kåñëa, he was satisfied and kept it with him always. But in the absence of Kåñëa and Balaräma there was a conspiracy by many men, including even Akrüra and Kåtavarmä, who were devotees of Lord Kåñëa, to take the jewel from Saträjit. Akrüra and Kåtavarmä joined the conspiracy because they wanted the jewel for Kåñëa. They knew that Kåñëa wanted the jewel and that Saträjit had not delivered it properly. Others joined the conspiracy because they were disappointed in not having the hand of Satyabhämä. Some of them incited Çatadhanvä to kill Saträjit and take away the jewel.

The question is generally raised, Why did a great devotee like Akrüra join this conspiracy? And why did Kåtavarmä, although a devotee of the Lord, join the conspiracy also? The answer is given by great authorities like Jéva Gosvämé and others that although Akrüra was a great devotee, he was cursed by the inhabitants of Våndävana because of his taking Kåñëa away from their midst. Because of his wounding their feelings, Akrüra was forced to join the conspiracy declared by sinful men. Similarly, Kåtavarmä was a devotee, but because of his intimate association with Kaàsa, he was also contaminated by sinful reaction, and he also joined the conspiracy.

Being inspired by all the members of the conspiracy, Çatadhanvä one night entered the house of Saträjit and killed him while he was sleeping. Çatadhanvä was a sinful man of abominable character, and although due to his sinful activities he was not to live for many days, he decided to kill Saträjit while Saträjit was sleeping at home. When he entered the house to kill Saträjit, all the women there began to cry very loudly, but in spite of their great protests, Çatadhanvä mercilessly butchered Saträjit without hesitation, exactly as a butcher kills an animal in the slaughterhouse. Since Kåñëa was absent from home, His wife Satyabhämä was also present on the night Saträjit was murdered, and she began to cry, "My dear father! My dear father! How mercilessly you have been killed!" The dead body of Saträjit was not immediately removed for cremation because Satyabhämä wanted to go to Kåñëa in Hastinäpura. Therefore the body was preserved in a tank of oil so that Kåñëa could come back and see the dead body of Saträjit and take real action against Çatadhanvä. Satyabhämä immediately started for Hastinäpura to inform Kåñëa about the ghastly death of her father.

When Kåñëa was informed by Satyabhämä of the murder of His father-in-law, He began to lament like an ordinary man. His great sorrow is, again, a strange thing. Lord Kåñëa has nothing to do with action and reaction, but because he was playing the part of a human being He expressed His full sympathy for the bereavement of Satyabhämä, and His eyes filled with tears upon hearing about the death of His father-in-law. He thus began to lament, "Oh, what unhappy incidents have taken place!" In this way both Kåñëa and Balaräma, along with Satyabhämä, the wife of Kåñëa, immediately returned to Dvärakä and began to make plans to kill Çatadhanvä and take away the jewel. Although he was a great outlaw in the city, Çatadhanvä was still very much afraid of Kåñëa's power, and thus he became most afraid on Kåñëa's arrival.

Understanding Kåñëa's plan to kill him, he immediately went to take shelter of Kåtavarmä. But on being approached by him, Kåtavarmä said, "I shall never be able to offend Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma because They are not ordinary persons. They are the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Who can be saved from death if he has offended Balaräma and Kåñëa? No one can be saved from Their wrath." Kåtavarmä further said that Kaàsa, although powerful and assisted by many demons, could not be saved from the wrath of Kåñëa, and what to speak of Jaräsandha, who had been defeated by Kåñëa eighteen times and each time had to return from the fighting in disappointment.

When Çatadhanvä was refused help by Kåtavarmä he went to Akrüra and implored him to help. Akrüra also replied, "Both Balaräma and Kåñëa are Themselves the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and anyone who knows Their unlimited strength would never dare to offend Them or fight with Them." He further informed Çatadhanvä, "Kåñëa and Balaräma are so powerful that simply by willing They are creating the whole cosmic manifestation, maintaining it and dissolving it. Unfortunately, persons who are bewildered by the illusory energy cannot understand the strength of Kåñëa, although the whole cosmic manifestation is fully under His control." He cited, as an example, that Kåñëa, even at the age of seven years, had lifted Govardhana Hill and had continued to hold up the mountain for seven days, exactly as a child carries a small umbrella. Akrüra plainly informed Çatadhanvä that he would always offer his most respectful obeisances to Kåñëa, the Supersoul of everything that is created and the original cause of all causes. When Akrüra also refused to give him shelter, Çatadhanvä decided to deliver to the hands of Akrüra the Syamantaka jewel. Then, riding on a horse which could run at great speed and up to four hundred miles at a stretch, he fled the city.

When Kåñëa and Balaräma were informed of the flight of Çatadhanvä, They mounted Their chariot, its flag marked by the picture of Garuòa, and followed immediately. Kåñëa was particularly angry with Çatadhanvä and wanted to kill him because he had killed Saträjit, a superior personality. Saträjit happened to be the father-in-law of Kåñëa, and it is the injunction of the çästras that anyone who has rebelled against a superior person, or gurudruha, must be punished in proportion to the volume of offense. Because Çatadhanvä had killed His father-in-law, Kåñëa was determined to kill him by any means.

Çatadhanvä's horse became exhausted and died near a garden house in Mithilä. Unable to take help of the horse, Çatadhanvä began to run with great speed. In order to be fair to Çatadhanvä, Kåñëa and Balaräma also left Their chariot and began to follow Çatadhanvä on foot. While both Çatadhanvä and Kåñëa were running on foot, Kåñëa took His disk and cut off the head of Çatadhanvä. After Çatadhanvä was killed, Kåñëa searched through his clothing for the Syamantaka jewel, but He could not find it. He then returned to Balaräma and said, "We have killed this person uselessly because the jewel is not to be found on his body." Çré Balaräma suggested, "The jewel might have been kept in custody of another man in Dvärakä, so You'd better return and search it out." Çré Balaräma expressed His desire to remain in Mithilä City for some days because He enjoyed an intimate friendship with the king. Therefore, Kåñëa returned to Dvärakä, and Balaräma entered the city of Mithilä.

When the King of Mithilä saw the arrival of Çré Balaräma in his city, he became most pleased and received the Lord with great honor and hospitality. He presented many valuable presents to Balarämajé in order to seek His pleasure. At this time Çré Balaräma lived in the city for several years as the honored guest of the King of Mithilä, Janaka Mahäräja. During this time, Duryodhana, the eldest son of Dhåtaräñöra, took the opportunity of coming to Balaräma and learning from Him the art of fighting with a club.

After killing Çatadhanvä, Kåñëa returned to Dvärakä, and in order to please His wife Satyabhämä, He informed her of the death of Çatadhanvä, the killer of her father. But He also informed her that the jewel had not been found in his possession. Then, according to religious principles, Kåñëa, along with Satyabhämä, performed all kinds of ceremonies in honor of the death of His father-in-law. In that ceremony all the friends and relatives of the family joined together.

Akrüra and Kåtavarmä, who were prominent members in the conspiracy to kill Saträjit, had incited Çatadhanvä to kill him, but when they heard of the death of Çatadhanvä at Kåñëa's hand, and when they heard also that Kåñëa had returned to Dvärakä, they both immediately left Dvärakä. The citizens of Dvärakä felt themselves threatened with pestilence and natural disturbances due to the absence of Akrüra from the city. This was a kind of superstition because while Lord Kåñëa was present there could not be any pestilence, famine or natural disturbances. But in the absence of Akrüra there were some disturbances in Dvärakä. Once in the province of Käçé within the barricade of Väräëasé there was severe drought and practically no rainfall. At that time the King of Käçé arranged the marriage of his daughter, known as Gändiné, with Çvaphalka, the father of Akrüra. This was done by the King of Käçé on the advice of an astrologer, and actually it so happened that after the marriage of the King's daughter with Çvaphalka there was sufficient rainfall in the province. Due to this supernatural power of Çvaphalka, his son Akrüra was also considered equally powerful, and people were under the impression that wherever Akrüra or his father remained, there would be no natural disturbance, famine or drought. That kingdom is considered to be happy where there is no famine, pestilence, or excessive heat and cold and where people are happy mentally, spiritually and bodily. As soon as there is some disturbance, people consider the cause to be due to the absence of an auspicious personality in the city. Thus there was a rumor that because of the absence of Akrüra inauspicious things were happening. After the departure of Akrüra, some of the elderly members of the town began to perceive that there were also inauspicious signs due to the absence of the Syamantaka jewel. When Lord Çré Kåñëa heard these rumors spread by the people He decided to summon Akrüra from the kingdom of Käçé. Akrüra was Kåñëa's uncle; therefore, when he came back to Dvärakä Lord Kåñëa first of all welcomed him as befitting a superior person. Kåñëa is the Supersoul in everyone's heart; He knows everything going on in everyone's heart. He knew everything that had happened in connection with Akrüra's conspiracy with Çatadhanvä. Therefore, He smilingly began to address Akrüra.

Addressing him as the chief among magnificent men, Kåñëa said, "My dear uncle, it is already known to Me that the Syamantaka jewel was left by Çatadhanvä with you. Presently there is no direct claimant of the Syamantaka jewel, for King Saträjit has no male issue. His daughter Satyabhämä is not very anxious for this jewel, yet her expected son, as grandson of Saträjit, would, after performing the regulative principles of inheritance, be the legal claimant of the jewel." Lord Kåñëa indicated by this statement that Satyabhämä was already pregnant and that her son would be the real claimant for the jewel and would certainly take the jewel from him.

Kåñëa continued, "This jewel is so powerful that no ordinary man is able to keep it. I know that you are very pious in activities, so there is no objection to the jewel being kept with you. There is one difficulty, and that is that My elder brother, Çré Balaräma, does not believe My version that the jewel is with you. I therefore request you, O large-hearted one, to show Me the jewel before My other relatives so that they may be pacified. You cannot deny that the jewel is with you because from various kinds of rumors we can understand that you have enhanced your opulence and are performing sacrifices on an altar made of solid gold." The properties of the jewel were known: wherever the jewel remained, it would produce for the keeper almost nine mounds of pure gold daily. Akrüra was getting gold in that proportion and was distributing it very profusely at sacrificial performances. Lord Kåñëa cited Akrüra's lavishly spending in gold as positive evidence of his possessing the Syamantaka jewel.

When Lord Kåñëa, in friendly terms and in sweet language, impressed Akrüra about the real fact and Akrüra understood that nothing could be concealed from the knowledge of Çré Kåñëa, he brought the valuable jewel, shining like the sun and covered by cloth, and presented it before Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa took the Syamantaka jewel in His hand and showed it to all His relatives and friends present there and then again returned the jewel to Akrüra in their presence so that they would know that the jewel was actually being kept by Akrüra in Dvärakä City.

This story of the Syamantaka jewel is very significant. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.57.42] it is said that anyone who hears the story of the Syamantaka jewel or describes it or simply remembers it will be free from all kinds of defamation and the reactions of all impious activities and thus will attain the highest perfectional condition of peace.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Second Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Killing of Saträjit and Çatadhanvä."

KB 1970-2-3 / Five Queens Married by Kåñëa

3 /Five Queens Married by Kåñëa

There was a great rumor that the five Päëòava brothers, along with their mother Kunté, had, under the plan of Dhåtaräñöra, died in a fire accident in the house of shellac in which they were living. But then the five brothers were detected at the marriage ceremony of Draupadé; so again another rumor spread that the Päëòavas and their mother were not dead. It was a rumor, but actually it was so; they returned to their capital city, Hastinäpura, and people saw them face to face. When this news was carried to Kåñëa and Balaräma, Kåñëa wanted to see them personally, and therefore Kåñëa decided to go to Hastinäpura.

This time, Kåñëa visited Hastinäpura in state, as a royal prince, accompanied by His commander-in-chief, Yuyudhäna, and by many other soldiers. He had not actually been invited to visit the city, yet He went to see the Päëòavas out of His affection for His great devotees. He visited the Päëòavas without warning, and all of them got up from their respective seats as soon as they saw Him. Kåñëa is called Mukunda because as soon as one comes in constant touch with Kåñëa or sees Him in full Kåñëa consciousness, one immediately becomes freed from all material anxieties. Not only that, but he immediately becomes blessed with all spiritual bliss.

On receiving Kåñëa, the Päëòavas became very enlivened, just as if awakened from unconsciousness or from loss of life. When a man is lying unconscious, his senses and the different parts of his body are not active, but when he regains his consciousness, the senses immediately become active. Similarly, the Päëòavas received Kåñëa as if they had just regained their consciousness, and so they became very much enlivened. Lord Kåñëa embraced every one of them, and by the touch of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Päëòavas immediately became freed from all reactions of material contamination, and therefore they were smiling in spiritual bliss. By seeing the face of Lord Kåñëa, everyone was transcendentally satisfied. Lord Kåñëa, although the Supreme Personality of Godhead, was playing the part of an ordinary human being, and thus He immediately touched the feet of Yudhiñöhira and Bhéma because they were His two older cousins. Arjuna embraced Kåñëa as a friend of the same age, whereas the two younger brothers, namely Nakula and Sahadeva, touched the lotus feet of Kåñëa to show Him respect. After an exchange of greetings according to the social etiquette befitting the position of the Päëòavas and Lord Kåñëa, Kåñëa was offered an exalted seat. When He was comfortably seated, the newly married Draupadé, young and very beautiful in her natural feminine gracefulness, came before Lord Kåñëa to offer her respectful greetings. The Yadavas who accompanied Kåñëa to Hastinäpura were also very respectfully received; specifically, Sätyaki, or Yuyudhäna, was also offered a nice seat. In this way, when everyone else was properly seated, the five brothers took their seats nearby Lord Kåñëa.

After meeting with the five brothers, Lord Kåñëa personally went to visit Çrématé Kuntédevé, the mother of the Päëòavas, who was also the paternal aunt of Kåñëa. In offering His respects to His aunt, Kåñëa also touched her feet. Kuntédevé's eyes became wet, and, in great love, she feelingly embraced Lord Kåñëa. She then inquired from Him about the well-being of her paternal family members—her brother Vasudeva, his wife, and other members of the family. Similarly, Kåñëa also inquired from His aunt about the welfare of the Päëòava families. Although Kuntédevé was related to Kåñëa by family ties, she knew immediately after meeting Him that He was the Supreme Personality of Godhead. She remembered the past calamities of her life and how by the grace of Kåñëa the Päëòavas and their mother had been saved. She knew perfectly well that no one, without Kåñëa's grace, could have saved them from the fire accident designed by Dhåtaräñöra and his sons. In a choked up voice, she began to narrate before Kåñëa the past history of their life.

Çrématé Kunté said: "My dear Kåñëa, I remember the day when You sent my brother Akrüra to gather information about us. This means that You always remember us automatically. When You sent Akrüra, I could understand that there was no possibility of our being put into danger. All good fortune in our life began when You sent Akrüra to us. Since then, I have been convinced that we are not without protection. We may be put into various types of dangerous conditions by our family members, the Kurus, but I am confident that You remember us and that You always keep us safe and sound. Devotees who simply think of You are always immune from all kinds of material dangers, and what to speak of ourselves, who are personally remembered by You. So, my dear Kåñëa, there is no question of bad luck; we are always in an auspicious position because of Your grace. But because You have bestowed a special favor on us, people should not mistakenly think that You are partial to some and inattentive to others. You make no such distinction. No one is Your favorite and no one is Your enemy. As the Supreme Personality of Godhead, You are equal to everyone, and everyone can take advantage of Your special protection. The fact is that although You are equal to everyone, You are especially inclined to the devotees who always think of You. The devotees are related to You by ties of love. As such, they cannot forget You even for a moment. You are present in everyone's heart, but because the devotees always remember You, You also respond accordingly. Although the mother has affection for all the children, she takes special care of the one who is fully dependent. I know certainly, my dear Kåñëa, that being seated in everyone's heart, You always create auspicious situations for Your unalloyed devotees."

Then King Yudhiñöhira also praised Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality and universal friend of everyone, but because Kåñëa was taking special care of the Päëòavas, King Yudhiñöhira said: "My dear Kåñëa, we do not know what sort of pious activities we have executed in our past lives that have made You so kind and graceful to us. We know very well that the great mystics who are always engaged in meditation to capture You do not find it easy to obtain such grace, nor can they draw any personal attention from You. I cannot understand why You are so kind upon us. We are not yogés, but, on the contrary, we are attached to material contaminations. We are householders dealing in politics, worldly affairs. I do not know why You are so kind upon us."

Being requested by King Yudhiñöhira, Kåñëa agreed to stay in Hastinäpura for four months during the rainy season. The four months of the rainy season are called Cäturmäsya. During this period, the generally itinerant preachers and brähmaëas stop at a certain place and live under rigid regulative principles. Although Lord Kåñëa is above all regulative principles, He agreed to stay at Hastinäpura out of affection for the Päëòavas. Taking this opportunity of Kåñëa's residence in Hastinäpura, all the citizens of the town got the privilege of seeing Him now and then, and thus they merged into transcendental bliss simply by seeing Lord Kåñëa eye to eye.

One day while Kåñëa was staying with the Päëòavas, He and Arjuna prepared themselves to go to the forest to hunt. Both of them sat down on the chariot, which flew a flag with a picture of Hanumän. Arjuna's special chariot is always marked with the picture of Hanumän, and therefore his name is also Kapidhvaja. (Kapi means Hanumän, and dhvaja means "flag.") Thus Arjuna went to the forest with his bow and infallible arrows. He dressed himself with suitable protective garments, for he was to practice killing many enemies. He specifically entered that part of the forest where there were many tigers, deer and various other animals. Kåñëa did not go with Arjuna to practice animal killing because He doesn't have to practice anything; He is self-sufficient. He accompanied Arjuna to see how he was practicing because in the future he would have to kill many enemies. After entering the forest, Arjuna killed many tigers, boars, bisons, gavayas (a kind of wild animal), rhinoceroses, deer, hares, porcupines and similar other animals, which he pierced with his arrows. Some of the dead animals, which were fit to be offered in the sacrifices, were carried by the servants and sent to King Yudhiñöhira. Other ferocious animals, such as tigers and rhinoceroses, were killed only to stop disturbances in the forest. Since there are many sages and saintly persons who are residents of the forests, it is the duty of the kñatriya kings to keep even the forest in a peaceful condition for living.

Arjuna felt tired and thirsty from hunting, and therefore he went to the bank of the Yamunä along with Kåñëa. When both the Kåñëas, namely Kåñëa and Arjuna (Arjuna is sometimes called Kåñëa, as is Draupadé), reached the bank of the Yamunä, they washed their hands and feet and mouths and drank the clear water of the Yamunä. While they were resting and drinking water, they saw a beautiful girl of marriagable age walking alone on the bank of the Yamunä. Kåñëa asked His friend Arjuna to go forward and ask the girl who she was. By the order of Kåñëa, Arjuna immediately approached the girl, who was very beautiful. She had an attractive body and nice glittering teeth and smiling face. Arjuna inquired, "My dear girl, you are so beautiful with your raised breasts—may I ask you who you are? We are surprised to see you loitering here alone. What is your purpose in coming here? We can guess only that you are searching after a suitable husband. If you don't mind, you can disclose your purpose. I shall try to satisfy you."

The beautiful girl was the river Yamunä personified. She replied, "Sir, I am the daughter of the sun-god, and I am now performing penance and austerity to have Lord Viñëu as my husband. I think He is the Supreme Person and just suitable to become my husband. I disclose my desire thus because you wanted to know it."

The girl continued, "My dear sir, I know you are the hero Arjuna; so I may further say that I'll not accept anyone as my husband besides Lord Viñëu, because He is the only protector of all living entities and the bestower of liberation for all conditioned souls. I shall be thankful unto you if you pray to Lord Viñëu to become pleased with me." The girl Yamunä knew it well that Arjuna was a great devotee of Lord Kåñëa and that if he would pray, Kåñëa would never deny his request. To approach Kåñëa directly may sometimes be futile, but to approach Kåñëa through His devotee is sure to be successful. She further told Arjuna, "My name is Kälindé, and I live within the water of the Yamunä. My father was kind enough to construct a special house for me within the waters of the Yamunä, and I have vowed to remain in the water as long as I cannot find Lord Kåñëa." The message of the girl Kälindé was duly carried to Kåñëa by Arjuna although Kåñëa, as the Supersoul of everyone's heart, knew everything. Without further discussion, Kåñëa immediately accepted Kälindé and asked her to sit down on the chariot. Then all of them approached King Yudhiñöhira.

After this, Kåñëa was asked by King Yudhiñöhira to help in constructing a suitable house to be planned by the great architect Viçvakarmä, the celestial engineer in the heavenly kingdom. Kåñëa immediately called for Viçvakarmä, and He made him construct a wonderful city according to the desire of King Yudhiñöhira. When this city was constructed, Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira requested Kåñëa to live with them a few days more in order to give them the pleasure of His association. Lord Kåñëa accepted the request of Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira and remained there for many days more.

In the meantime, Kåñëa engaged in the pastime of offering Khäëòava Forest, which belonged to King Indra. Kåñëa wanted to give it to Agni, the fire-god. Khäëòava Forest contained many varieties of drugs, and Agni required to eat them for rejuvenation. Agni, however, did not touch Khäëòava Forest directly, but requested Kåñëa to help him. Agni knew that Kåñëa was very much pleased with him because he had formerly given Him the Sudarçana disc. So in order to satisfy Agni, Kåñëa became the chariot driver of Arjuna, and both went to the Khäëòava Forest. After Agni had eaten up the Khäëòava Forest, he was very much pleased. This time, he offered a specific bow known as Gäëòéva, four white horses, one chariot, and an invincible quiver with two specific arrows considered to be talismans, which had so much power that no warrior could counteract them. When the Khäëòava Forest was being devoured by the fire-god, Agni, there was a demon of the name Maya who was saved by Arjuna from the devastating fire. For this reason, that former demon became a great friend of Arjuna, and in order to please Arjuna he constructed a nice assembly house within the city constructed by Viçvakarmä. This assembly house had some corners so puzzling that when Duryodhana came to visit this house he was misdirected, accepting water as land and land as water. Duryodhana thus became insulted by the opulence of the Päëòavas, and he became their determined enemy.

After a few days, Kåñëa took permission from King Yudhiñöhira to return to Dvärakä. When he got permission, he went to his country, accompanied by Sätyaki, the leader of the Yadus who were living in Hastinäpura with Him. Kälindé also returned with Kåñëa to Dvärakä. After returning, Kåñëa consulted many learned astrologers to find the suitable moment at which to marry Kälindé, and then He married her with great pomp. This marriage ceremony gave much pleasure to the relatives of both parties, and all of them enjoyed the great occasion.

The kings of Avantépura (now known as Ujjain) were named Vinda and Anuvinda. Both kings were under the control of Duryodhana. They had one sister named Mitravindä, who was a very qualified, learned and elegant girl. She was the daughter of one of Kåñëa's aunts. She was to select her husband in the assembly of princes, but she strongly desired to have Kåñëa as her husband. During the assembly for selecting her husband, however, Kåñëa was present, and He forcibly carried away Mitravindä in the presence of all other royal princes. Being unable to resist Kåñëa, the princes were left simply looking at each other.

After this incident, Kåñëa married the daughter of the King of Koçala. The King of Koçala Province was called Nagnajit. He was very pious and was a follower of the Vedic ritualistic ceremonies. His most beautiful daughter was named Satyä. Sometimes Satyä was called Nagnajité, for she was the daughter of King Nagnajit. King Nagnajit wanted to give the hand of his daughter to any prince who could defeat seven very strong, stalwart bulls maintained by him. No one in the princely order could defeat the seven bulls, and therefore no one could claim the hand of Satyä. The seven bulls were very strong, and they could hardly bear even the smell of any prince. Many princes approached this kingdom and tried to subdue these bulls, but instead of controlling them, they themselves were defeated. This news was spread all over the country, and when Kåñëa heard that the girl Satyä could be achieved only by defeating the seven bulls, He prepared Himself to go to the kingdom of Koçala. With many soldiers, He approached that part of the country, known as Ayodhyä, making a regular state visit.

When it was known to the King of Koçala that Kåñëa had come to ask the hand of his daughter, he became very pleased. With great respect and pomp, he welcomed Kåñëa to the kingdom. When Kåñëa approached him, he offered Him a suitable sitting place and articles for reception. Everything appeared to be very elegant. Kåñëa also offered him respectful obeisances, thinking him to be His future father-in-law.

When Satyä, the daughter of King Nagnajit, understood that Kåñëa Himself had come to marry her, she was very much pleased that the husband of the goddess of fortune had so kindly come there to accept her. She had cherished the idea of marrying Kåñëa for a long time and was following the principles of austerities in order to obtain her desired husband. She then began to think, "If I have performed any pious activities to the best of my capacity and if I have sincerely thought all along to have Kåñëa as my husband, then Kåñëa may be pleased to fulfill my long-cherished desire." She began to offer prayers to Kåñëa mentally, thinking, "I do not know how the Supreme Personality of Godhead can be pleased upon me. He is the master and Lord of everyone. Even the goddess of fortune, whose place is next to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and Lord Çiva, Lord Brahmä and many other demigods of different planets always offer their respectful obeisances unto the Lord. The Lord also sometimes descends on this earth in different incarnations in order to fulfill the desire of His devotees. He is so exalted and great that I do not know how to satisfy Him." She thought that the Supreme Personality of Godhead could be pleased only out of His own causeless mercy upon the devotee; otherwise, there was no other means to please Him. Lord Caitanya, in the same way, prayed in His Çikñäñöaka [5] verses, "My Lord, I am Your eternal servant. Somehow or other I have fallen into this material existence. If You kindly pick me up and fix me as an atom of dust at Your lotus feet, it will be a great favor to Your eternal servant." The Lord can be pleased only by a humble attitude in the service spirit. The more we render service unto the Lord under the direction of the spiritual master, the more we make advancement on the path of approaching the Lord. We cannot demand any grace or mercy from the Lord because of our service rendered to Him. He may accept or not accept our service, but the only means to satisfy the Lord is through the service attitude, and nothing else.

King Nagnajit was already a pious king, and having Kåñëa in his palace, he began to worship Him to the best of his knowledge and capacity. He presented himself before the Lord thus: "My dear Lord, You are the proprietor of the whole cosmic manifestation, and You are Näräyaëa, the rest of all living creatures. You are self-sufficient and pleased with Your personal opulences, so how can I offer You anything? And how could I please You by such offering? It is not possible, because I am an insignificant living being. Actually I have no capacity to render any service unto You."

Kåñëa is the Supersoul of all living creatures, so He could understand the mind of Satyä, the daughter of King Nagnajit. He was also very much pleased with the respectful worship of the King in offering Him a sitting place, eatables, residence, etc. He was appreciative, therefore, that both the girl and the father of the girl were anxious to have Him as their intimate relative. He began to smile and in a great voice said, "My dear King Nagnajit, you know very well that anyone in the princely order who is regular in his position will never ask anything from anyone, however exalted he may be. Such requests by a kñatriya king from another person have been deliberately forbidden by the learned Vedic followers. If a kñatriya breaks this regulation, his action is condemned by learned scholars. But in spite of this rigid regulative principle, I am asking you for the hand of your beautiful daughter just to establish our relationship in return for your great reception of Me. You may also be pleased to be informed that in our family tradition there is no scope for our offering anything in exchange for accepting your daughter. We cannot pay any price which you may impose for delivering her." In other words, Kåñëa wanted the hand of Satyä from the King without fulfilling the condition of defeating the seven bulls.

After hearing the statement of Lord Kåñëa, King Nagnajit said, "My dear Lord, You are the reservoir of all pleasure, all opulences and all qualities. The goddess of fortune, Lakñméjé, always lives on Your chest. Under these circumstances, who can be a better husband for my daughter? Both myself and my daughter have always prayed for this opportunity. You are the chief of the Yadu dynasty. You may kindly know that from the very beginning I have made a vow to marry my daughter to a suitable candidate, one who can come out victorious in the test I have devised. I have imposed this test just to understand the prowess and position of my intended son-in-law. You are Lord Kåñëa, and You are the chief of all heroes. I am sure You shall be able to bring these seven bulls under control without any difficulty. Until now they have never been subdued by any prince; anyone who has attempted to bring them under control has simply had his limbs broken."

King Nagnajit continued his request: "Kåñëa, if You'll kindly bridle the seven bulls and bring them under control, then undoubtedly You will be selected as the desired husband of my daughter, Satyä." After hearing this statement, Kåñëa could understand that the King did not want to break his vow. Thus, in order to fulfill his desire, He tightened His belt and prepared to fight with the bulls. He immediately divided Himself into seven Kåñëas, and each one of Them immediately caught hold of a bull and bridled its nose, thus bringing it under control as if it were a plaything.

Kåñëa's dividing Himself into seven is very significant. It was known to Satyä, the daughter of King Nagnajit, that Kåñëa had already married many other wives, and still she was attached to Kåñëa. In order to encourage her, He immediately expanded Himself into seven. The purport is that Kåñëa is one, but He has unlimited forms of expansions. He married many hundreds of thousands of wives, but this does not mean that while He was with one wife the others were bereft of His association. Kåñëa could associate with each and every wife by His expansions.

When Kåñëa brought the bulls under His control by bridling their noses, their strength and pride were immediately smashed. The name and fame which the bulls had attained was thus vanquished. When the bulls had been bridled by Kåñëa, He pulled them strongly, just as a child pulls a toy wooden bull. Upon seeing this advantage of Kåñëa, King Nagnajit became very much astonished and immediately, with great pleasure, brought his daughter Satyä before Kåñëa and handed her over to Him. Kåñëa also immediately accepted Satyä as His wife. Then there was a marriage ceremony with great pomp. The queens of King Nagnajit also were very much pleased because their daughter Satyä got Kåñëa as her husband. Since the King and queens were very pleased on this auspicious occasion, there was a celebration all over the city in honor of the marriage. Everywhere was heard the sounds of the conchshell and kettledrum and various other vibrations of music and song. The learned brähmaëas began to shower their blessings upon the newly married couple. In jubilation, all the inhabitants of the city dressed themselves with colorful garments and ornaments. King Nagnajit was so pleased that he began to give a dowry to the daughter and son-in-law, as follows.

First of all he gave them ten thousand cows and three thousand well-dressed young maidservants, ornamented up to their necks. This system of dowry is still current in India especially for the kñatriya princes. Also, when a kñatriya prince is married, at least a dozen maidservants of similar age are given along with the bride. After giving the cows and maidservants, the King also enriched the dowry by giving 9,000 elephants and a hundred times more chariots than elephants. This means that he gave 900,000 chariots. And he gave a hundred times more horses than chariots, or 90,000,000 horses, and a hundred times more slaves than horses. Such slaves and maidservants were maintained by the royal princes with all provisions, as if they were their own children or family members. After giving this dowry as described, the King of the Koçala Province bade his daughter and great son-in-law be seated on a chariot. He allowed them to go to their home, guarded by a division of well-equipped soldiers. When they were travelling fast to their new home, his heart became enlivened with affection for them.

Before this marriage of Satyä with Kåñëa, there had been many competitive engagements with the bulls of King Nagnajit, and many other princes of the Yadu dynasty and of other dynasties as well had tried to win the hand of Satyä. When the frustrated princes of the other dynasties heard that Kåñëa was successful in getting the hand of Satyä by subduing the bulls, naturally they became envious. While Kåñëa was travelling to Dvärakä, all the frustrated and defeated princes encircled Him and began to shower their arrows on the bridal party. When they attacked Kåñëa's party and threw arrows like incessant torrents of rain, Arjuna, the best friend of Kåñëa, took charge of the challenge, and he alone drove them off very easily to please his great friend Kåñëa on the occasion of His marriage. He immediately took up his bow of the name Gäëòéva and chased away all the princes; exactly as a lion drives away all other small animals simply by chasing them, Arjuna drove away all the princes without killing even one of them. After this, the chief of the Yadu dynasty, Lord Kåñëa, along with His newly married wife and a huge dowry, entered the city of Dvärakä with great pomp. Kåñëa then lived there with His wife very peacefully.

Kåñëa had another aunt, His father's sister, whose name was Çrutakérti, and who was married and lived in the Kekaya province. She had a daughter whose name was Bhadrä. Bhadrä also wanted to marry Kåñëa, and her brother handed her over to Him unconditionally. Kåñëa also accepted her as His bona fide wife. Thereafter, Kåñëa married a daughter of the king of the Madras Province, and her name was Lakñmaëä. Lakñmaëä had all good qualities. She was also forcibly married by Kåñëa, who took her in the same way that Garuòa snatched the jar of nectar from the hands of the demons. Kåñëa kidnapped this girl in the presence of many other princes in the assembly of her svayaàvara. Svayaàvara is a ceremony in which the bride can select her own husband from an assembly of many princes.

The description of Kåñëa's marriage with the five girls mentioned in this chapter is not sufficient. He had many other thousands of wives besides them. The other thousands of wives were accepted by Kåñëa after killing one demon named Bhaumäsura. All these thousands of girls were held captive in the palace of Bhaumäsura, and Kåñëa released them and married them.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Third Chapter of Kåñëa, "Five Queens Married by Kåñëa."

KB 1970-2-4 / Deliverance of the Demon Bhaumäsura

4 /Deliverance of the Demon Bhaumäsura

The story of Bhaumäsura—how he kidnapped and made captive 16,000 princesses by collecting them from the palaces of various kings and how he was killed by Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord of wonderful character—is all described by Çukadeva Gosvämé to King Parékñit in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Generally, the demons are always against the demigods. This demon, Bhaumäsura, having become very powerful, took by force the umbrella from the throne of the demigod Varuëa. He also took the earrings of Aditi, the mother of the demigods. He conquered a portion of heavenly Mount Meru and occupied the portion which was known as Maëiparvata. The King of the heavenly planets, Indra, therefore came to Dvärakä to complain about Bhaumäsura before Lord Kåñëa.

Hearing this complaint by Indra, the King of heaven, Lord Kåñëa, accompanied by His wife Satyabhämä, immediately started for the abode of Bhaumäsura. Both of them rode on the back of Garuòa, who flew them to Prägjyotiñapura, the capital city of Bhaumäsura. It was not a very easy task to enter into the city of Prägjyotiñapura, because it was very well fortified. First of all, there were four formidable forts guarding the four directions of the city, and it was well-protected on all sides by formidable military strength. The next boundary was a water canal all around the city, and in addition the whole city was surrounded with electric wires. The next fortification was of anila, a gaseous substance. After this, there was a network of barbed wiring constructed by a demon of the name Mura. It appeared that the city was well-protected even in terms of today's scientific advancements.

When Kåñëa arrived, He broke all the forts to pieces by the strokes of His club, and the military strength scattered here and there by the constant onslaught of the arrows of Kåñëa. With His celebrated Sudarçana-cakra He counteracted the electrified boundary; the channels of water and the gaseous boundary were made null and void, and He cut to pieces the electrified network fabricated by the demon Mura. By the vibration of His conchshell, He not only broke the hearts of great fighters, but also the fighting machines which were there. Similarly, the walls around the city were broken by His invincible club.

The vibration of His conchshell sounded like the thunderbolt at the time of the dissolution of the whole cosmic situation. The demon Mura heard the vibration of the conchshell, awakened from his sleep, and personally came out to see what had happened. He had five heads and had long been living within the water. The Mura demon was as brilliant as the sun at the time of the dissolution of the cosmic manifestation, and his temper was like blazing fire. The effulgence of his body was so dazzling that it was difficult to see him with open eyes. When he came out, he first of all took out his trident and began to rush the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The onslaught of the demon Mura was like a big snake attacking Garuòa. His angry mood was very severe, and he appeared ready to devour the three worlds. First of all he attacked the carrier of Kåñëa, Garuòa, by whirling his trident and he began to vibrate sounds through his five faces like the roaring of a lion. The roaring produced by the vibration of his mouths spread all over the atmosphere until it extended not only all over the world, but also into outer space, up and down and out to the ten directions. In this way, the sound was rumbling throughout the whole universe.

Lord Kåñëa saw that the trident of the Mura demon was gradually rushing toward His carrier, Garuòa. Immediately, by a trick of His hand, He took two arrows and threw them toward the trident, cutting it to pieces. Simultaneously, using many arrows, He pierced the mouths of the demon Mura. When he saw himself outmaneuvered by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Mura demon immediately began to strike Him in great anger with his club. But Lord Kåñëa, with His own club, broke the club of Mura to pieces before it could reach Him. The demon, bereft of his weapon, decided to attack Kåñëa with his strong arms, but by the aid of His Sudarçana-cakra, Kåñëa immediately separated the demon's five heads from his body. The demon then fell into the water, just as the peak of a mountain falls into the ocean after being struck by the thunderbolt of Indra.

This demon Mura had seven sons, named Tämra, Antarikña, Çravaëa, Vibhävasu, Vasu, Nabhasvän and Aruëa. All of them became puffed up and vengeful because of the death of their father, and in order to retaliate, they prepared in great anger to fight with Kåñëa. They equipped themselves with necessary weapons and situated Péöha, another demon, to act as commander in the battle. By the order of Bhaumäsura, all of them combinedly attacked Kåñëa.

When they came before Lord Kåñëa, they began to shower Him with many kinds of weapons, like swords, clubs, lances, arrows and tridents. But they did not know that the strength of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is unlimited and invincible. Kåñëa, with His arrows, cut all the weapons of the men of Bhaumäsura into pieces, like grains. Kåñëa then threw His weapons, and Bhaumäsura's commander-in-chief, Péöha, along with his assistants, fell down, their military dress cut off and their heads, legs, arms and thighs severed. All of them were sent to the superintendent of death, Yamaräja.

Bhaumäsura was also known as Narakäsura, for he happened to be the son of the earth personified. When he saw that all his soldiers, commanders and fighters were killed on the battlefield by the strokes of the weapons of the Personality of Godhead, he became exceedingly angry at the Lord. He then came out of the city with a great number of elephants who had all been born and brought up on the seashore. All of them were highly intoxicated. When they came out, they saw that Lord Kåñëa and His wife were beautifully situated high in outer space just like a blackish cloud about the sun, glittering with the light of electricity. The demon Bhaumäsura immediately released a weapon called Çataghné, by which he could kill hundreds of warriors with one stroke, and simultaneously all his assistants also threw their respective weapons at the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Lord Kåñëa began to counteract all these weapons by releasing His feathered arrows. The result of this fight was that all the soldiers and commanders of Bhaumäsura fell to the ground, their arms, legs and heads separated from their trunks, and all their horses and elephants also fell with them. In this way, all the weapons released by Bhaumäsura were cut to pieces by the reaction of the Lord's arrows.

The Lord was fighting on the back of Garuòa, and Garuòa was also helping the Lord by striking the horses and the elephants with his wings and scratching their heads with his nails and sharpened beak. The elephants were feeling much pain by Garuòa's attack on them, and they were all dispersing from the battlefield. Bhaumäsura alone remained on the battlefield, and he engaged himself in fighting with Kåñëa. He saw that Kåñëa's carrier, Garuòa, was causing great disturbance to his soldiers and elephants, and in great anger he struck Garuòa with all his strength, which defied the strength of the thunderbolt. Fortunately, Garuòa was not an ordinary bird, and he felt the strokes given by Bhaumäsura just as a great elephant feels the impact of a garland of flowers.

Bhaumäsura thus came to see that none of his tricks would act upon Kåñëa, and he became aware that all his attempts to kill Kåñëa would be frustrated. Yet he attempted for the last time, taking a trident in his hand to strike Him. Kåñëa was so dexterous that before Bhaumäsura could touch his trident, his head was cut off by the sharp Sudarçana-cakra. His head, illuminated by earrings and helmets, fell down on the battlefield. On the occasion of Bhaumäsura's being killed by Lord Kåñëa, all the demon's relatives began to scream in disappointment, and the saintly persons began to glorify the chivalrous activities of the Lord. Taking this opportunity, the denizens of the heavenly planets began to shower flowers on the Lord.

At this time, the earth personified appeared before Lord Kåñëa and greeted Him with a garland of vaijayanté jewels. She also returned the dazzling earrings of Aditi, bedecked with jewels and gold. She also returned the umbrella of Varuëa, along with another valuable jewel, which she presented to Kåñëa. After this, the earth personified began to offer her prayers to Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality and master of the world, who is always worshiped by very exalted demigods. She fell down in obeisances and, in great devotional ecstasy, began to speak.

"Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the Lord, who is always present with four kinds of symbols, namely His conchshell, disc, lotus and club, and who is the Lord of all demigods. Please accept my respectful obeisances unto You. My dear Lord, You are the Supersoul, and in order to satisfy the aspiration of Your devotees, You descend on the earth in Your various transcendental incarnations, which are just appropriate to the devotees' worshipful desire. Kindly accept my respectful obeisances.

"My dear Lord, the lotus flower is grown out of Your navel, and You are always decorated with a garland of lotus flowers. Your eyes are always spread like the petals of the lotus flower, and therefore they are all-pleasing to the eyes of others. Your lotus feet are so soft and delicate that they are always worshiped by Your unalloyed devotees, and they pacify their lotus-like hearts. I therefore repeatedly offer my respectful obeisances unto You.

"You possess all kinds of religions, fame, property, knowledge and renunciation; You are the shelter of all five opulences. Although You are all-pervading, You have nevertheless appeared as the son of Vasudeva. Please, therefore, accept my respectful obeisances. You are the original Supreme Personality of Godhead and the supreme cause of all causes. Only Your Lordship is the reservoir of all knowledge. Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto You. Personally You are unborn; still, You are the father of the whole cosmic manifestation. You are the reservoir and shelter of all kinds of energies. The manifestive appearance of this world is caused by You, and You are both the cause and effect of this cosmic manifestation. Please therefore accept my respectful obeisances.

"My dear Lord, as for the three gods—Brahmä, Viñëu and Çiva—they are also not independent of You. When there is necessity of creating this cosmic manifestation, You create Your passionate appearance of Brahmä, and when You want to maintain this cosmic manifestation, You expand Yourself as Lord Viñëu, the reservoir of all goodness. Similarly, You appear as Lord Çiva, master of the modes of ignorance, and thus dissolve the whole creation. Your transcendental position is always maintained, in spite of creating these three modes of material nature. You are never entangled like the ordinary living entities with these modes of material nature.

"Actually, my Lord, You are the material nature, You are the father of the universe, and You are the eternal time that has caused the combination of nature and the material creator. Still, You are always transcendental to all these material activities. My dear Lord, O Supreme Personality of Godhead, I know that earth, water, fire, air, sky, the five sense objects, mind, the senses and their deities, egotism, as well as the total material energy—everything animate and inanimate in this phenomenal world is resting upon You. Since everything is produced of You, nothing can be separated from You. Yet, since You are transcendentally situated, neither can anything material be identified with Your personality. Everything is, therefore, simultaneously one and different from You, and the philosophers who try to separate everything from you are certainly mistaken in their viewpoint.

"My dear Lord, may I inform You that this boy, whose name is Bhagadatta, is the son of my son, Bhaumäsura. He has been very much affected by the ghastly situation created by the death of his father and has become very much confused, being afraid of the present situation. I have therefore brought him to surrender unto Your lotus feet. I request Your Lordship to give shelter to this boy and bless him with Your lotus feet. I am bringing him to You so that he may become relieved from the reactions of all the sinful activities of his father."

When Lord Kåñëa heard the prayers of mother Earth, He immediately assured her of immunity from all fearful situations. He said to Bhagadatta, "Don't be afraid." Then He entered the palace of Bhaumäsura, which was equipped with all kinds of opulences. In the palace of Bhaumäsura Lord Kåñëa saw 16,100 young princesses, who had been kidnapped and held captive there. When the princesses saw the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, enter the palace, they immediately became captivated by the beauty of the Lord and prayed for His causeless mercy. Within their minds, they decided to accept Lord Kåñëa as their husband without any hesitation. Each one of them began to pray to providence that Kåñëa might become her husband. Sincerely and seriously, they offered their hearts to the lotus feet of Kåñëa with an unalloyed devotional attitude. As the Supersoul in everyone's heart, Kåñëa could understand their uncontaminated desire, and He agreed to accept them as His wives. Thus, He arranged for suitable dresses and ornaments for them, and each of them, seated on a palanquin, was dispatched to Dvärakä City. Kåñëa also collected unlimited wealth from the palace, along with chariots, horses, jewels and treasure. He took from the palace fifty white elephants, each with four tusks, and all of them were dispatched to Dvärakä.

After this incident, Lord Kåñëa and Satyabhämä entered Amarävaté, the capital city of the heavenly planet, and they immediately entered the palace of King Indra and his wife, Çacédevé, who welcomed them. Kåñëa then presented Indra with the earrings of Aditi.

When Kåñëa and Satyabhämä were returning from the capital city of Indra, Satyabhämä remembered Kåñëa's promise to give her the plant of the pärijäta flower. Taking the opportunity of having come to the heavenly kingdom, she plucked a pärijäta plant and kept it on the back of Garuòa. Once Närada took a pärijäta flower and presented it to Kåñëa's senior wife, Çré Rukmiëédevé. On account of this, Satyabhämä developed an inferiority complex; she also wanted a flower from Kåñëa. Kåñëa could understand the competitive womanly nature of His co-wives, and He smiled. He immediately asked Satyabhämä, "Why are you asking for only one flower? I would like to give you a whole tree of pärijäta flowers."

Actually, Kåñëa had purposely taken His wife Satyabhämä with Him so she could collect the pärijäta with her own hand. But the denizens of the heavenly planet, including Indra, became very irritated. Without their permission, Satyabhämä had plucked a pärijäta plant, which is not to be found on the earth planet. Indra, along with other demigods, offered opposition to Kåñëa and Satyabhämä for taking away the plant, but in order to please His favorite wife Satyabhämä, Kåñëa became determined and adamant, so there was a fight between the demigods and Kåñëa. As, usual, Kåñëa came out victorious, and He triumphantly brought the pärijäta plant chosen by His wife to this earth planet, to Dvärakä. After this, the plant was installed in the palace garden of Satyabhämä. On account of this extraordinary tree, the garden house of Satyabhämä became extraordinarily beautiful. As the pärijäta plant came down to the earthly planet, the fragrance of the flower also came down, and the celestial swans also migrated to this earth in search of its fragrance and honey.

King Indra's behavior toward Kåñëa was not very much appreciated by great sages like Çukadeva Gosvämé. Out of His causeless mercy, Kåñëa had gone to the heavenly kingdom, Amarävaté, to present King Indra with his mother's earrings, which had been lost to Bhaumäsura, and Indra had been very glad to receive them. But when a flower plant from the heavenly kingdom was taken by Kåñëa, Indra offered to fight with Him. This was self-interest on the part of Indra. He offered his prayer, tipping down his head to the lotus feet of Kåñëa, but as soon as his purpose was served, he became a different creature. That is the way of the dealings of materialistic men. Materialistic men are always interested in their own profit. For this purpose they can offer any kind of respect to anyone, but when their personal interest is over, they are no longer friends. This selfish nature is not only found among the richer class of men on this planet, but is present even in personalities like Indra and other demigods. Too much wealth makes a man selfish. A selfish man is not prepared to take to Kåñëa consciousness and is condemned by great devotees like Çukadeva Gosvämé. In other words, possession of too many worldly riches is a disqualification for advancement in Kåñëa consciousness.

After defeating Indra, Kåñëa arranged to marry the 16,100 girls brought from the custody of Bhaumäsura. By expanding Himself in 16,100 forms, He simultaneously married them all in different palaces in one auspicious moment. He thus established the truth that Kåñëa and no one else is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. There is nothing impossible, for Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead; He is all-powerful, omnipresent and imperishable, and as such there is nothing wonderful in this pastime. All the palaces of the more than 16,000 queens of Kåñëa were full with suitable gardens, furniture and other paraphernalia, of which there is no parallel in this world. There is no exaggeration in this story from Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The queens of Kåñëa were all expansions of the goddess of fortune, Lakñméjé. Kåñëa used to live with them in different palaces, and He treated them in exactly the same way as an ordinary man treats his wife.

We should always remember that the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa was playing exactly like a human being; although He showed His extraordinary opulences by simultaneously marrying more than 16,000 wives in more than 16,000 palaces, He behaved with them just like an ordinary man, and He strictly followed the relationship between husband and wife required in ordinary homes. Therefore, it is very difficult to understand the characteristics of the Supreme Brahman, the Personality of Godhead. Even demigods like Brahmä and others are unable to probe into the transcendental pastimes of the Lord. The wives of Kåñëa were so fortunate that they got the Supreme Personality of Godhead as their husband, although their husband's personality was unknown even to the demigods like Brahmä.

In their dealings as husband and wife, Kåñëa and His queens would smile, talk, joke, embrace, and so on, and their conjugal relationship ever increasingly developed. In this way, both Kåñëa and the queens enjoyed transcendental happiness in their household life. Although each and every queen had thousands of maidservants engaged for her service, the queens were all personally attentive in serving Kåñëa. Each one of them used to receive Kåñëa personally when He entered the palace. They engaged in getting Him seated on a nice couch, presenting Him with all kinds of worshipable paraphernalia, washing His lotus feet with Ganges water, offering Him betel nuts and massaging His legs. In this way, they were giving Him relief from the fatigue of being away from home. They saw to fanning Him nicely, offering Him fragrant essential floral oil, decorating Him with flower garlands, dressing His hair, asking Him to lie down to take rest, bathing Him personally and feeding Him nice palatable dishes. All these things were done by each queen herself. They did not wait for the maidservants. In other words, Kåñëa and His different queens displayed on this earth an ideal household life.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Fourth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Deliverance of the Demon Bhaumäsura."

KB 1970-2-5 / Talks Between Kåñëa and Rukmiëé

5 /Talks Between Kåñëa and Rukmiëé

Once upon a time, Lord Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the bestower of all knowledge to all living entities from Brahmä to the insignificant ant, was sitting in the bedroom of Rukmiëé, who was engaged in the service of the Lord along with her assistant maidservants. Kåñëa was sitting on the bedstead of Rukmiëé, and the maidservants were engaged in fanning Him with cämaras (yak-tail fly-whisks).

Lord Kåñëa's dealings with Rukmiëé as a perfect husband is a perfect manifestation of the supreme perfection of the Personality of Godhead. There are many philosophers who propound a concept of the Absolute Truth in which God cannot do this or that. They deny the incarnation of God, or the Supreme Absolute Truth in human form. But actually, the fact is different: God cannot be subjected to our imperfect sensual activities. He is the all-powerful, omnipresent Personality of Godhead, and by His supreme will, He can not only create, maintain and annihilate the whole cosmic manifestation, but He can also descend as an ordinary human being in order to execute the highest mission. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, whenever there are discrepancies in the discharge of human occupational duties, He descends. He is not forced to appear by any external agency, but descends by His own internal potency in order to reestablish the standard functions of human activities as well as to simultaneously annihilate the disturbing elements in the progressive march of human civilization. In accordance with this principle of the transcendental pastimes of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, He descended in His eternal form of Çré Kåñëa in the dynasty of the Yadus.

The palace of Rukmiëé was wonderfully finished. There were many canopies hanging on the ceiling with laces bedecked with pearl garlands, and the whole palace was illuminated by the effulgence of valuable jewels. There were many flower orchards of baela and cämeli, which are considered to be the most fragrant flowers in India. There were many clusters of these plants, with blooming flowers enhancing the beauty of the palace. And because of the exquisite fragrance of the flowers, little groups of humming bees were gathered around the trees, and at night the pleasing moonshine glittered through the network of holes in the windows. There were many heavily flowered trees of pärijäta, and the mild wind stirred the flavor of the flowers all around. Within the walls of the palace, there was incense burning, and the fragrant smoke was leaking out of the window shutters. Within the room there were mattresses covered with white bedsheets resembling the foam of milk; the bedding was as soft and white as milk foam. In this situation, Lord Çré Kåñëa was very comfortably sitting and enjoying the service of Rukmiëéjé assisted by her maidservants.

Rukmiëé was also very eager to get the opportunity of serving the Supreme Personality of Godhead as her husband. She therefore wanted to serve the Lord personally and took the handle of the cämara from the hand of the maidservant and began to move the fan. The handle of the cämara was made of gold, decorated and bedecked with valuable jewels, and it became more beautiful when it was taken by Rukmiëé, because all of her fingers were beautifully set with jeweled rings. Her legs were decorated with ankle bells and jewels, which rang very softly between the pleats of her sari. Rukmiëé's raised breasts were smeared with kuìkuma and saffron; thus her beauty was enhanced by the reflection of the reddish color emanating from her covered breasts. The highly raised lower part of her buttocks was decorated with a jeweled lace girdle, and a locket of great effulgence hung on her neck. Above all, because she was engaged in the service of Lord Kåñëa—although at that time she was old enough to have grown-up sons—her beautiful body was beyond compare in the three worlds. When we take account of her beautiful face, it appears that the curling hair on her head, the beautiful earrings on her ears, her smiling mouth, and her necklace of gold, all combined to shower rains of nectar; and it was definitely proved that Rukmiëé was none other than the original goddess of fortune who is always engaged in the service of the lotus feet of Näräyaëa.

The pastimes of Kåñëa and Rukmiëé in Dvärakä are accepted by great authorities as manifestations of those of Näräyaëa and Lakñmé, which are of an exalted opulence. The pastimes of Rädhä and Kåñëa in Våndävana are simple and rural, distinguished from the polished urban characteristics of those of Dvärakä. The characteristics of Rukmiëé were unusually bright, and Kåñëa was very much satisfied with her behavior.

Kåñëa had experienced that when Rukmiëé was offered a pärijäta flower by Närada Muni, Satyabhämä had become envious of her co-wife and had immediately demanded a similar flower from Kåñëa. In fact, she could not be pacified until she was promised the whole tree. That was actually done by Kåñëa; the tree was brought down to the earth planet from the heavenly kingdom. After this episode, Kåñëa expected that because Satyabhämä had been rewarded by a full tree of pärijäta, Rukmiëé would also demand something. Rukmiëé did not mention anything of the incident, however, for she was grave and simply satisfied in her service. Kåñëa wanted to see her a bit irritated, and therefore He schemed in order to see the beautiful face of Rukmiëé in an irritated condition. Although Kåñëa had more than 16,100 wives, He used to behave with each of them with familial affection; He would create a particular situation between Himself and His wife in which the wife would criticize Him in the irritation of love, and Kåñëa would enjoy this. In this case, because Kåñëa could not find any fault with Rukmiëé, for she was very great and always engaged in His service, He smilingly, in great love, began to speak to her. Rukmiëé was the daughter of King Bhéñmaka, a powerful king. Thus Kåñëa did not address her as Rukmiëé; He addressed her this time as the princess. "My dear princess, it is very surprising. Many great personalities in the royal order wanted to marry you. Although not all of them were kings, all possessed the opulence and riches of the kingly order; they were well-behaved, learned, famous among kings, beautiful in their bodily features and personal qualifications, liberal, very powerful in strength, and advanced in every respect. They were not unfit in any way, and over and above that, your father and your brother had no objection to such marriages. On the contrary, they gave their word of honor that you would be married with Çiçupäla; the marriage was sanctioned by your parents. Çiçupäla was a great king and was so lusty and mad after your beauty that if he had married you, I think he would always have remained with you just like your faithful servant.

"In comparison to Çiçupäla, with his personal qualities, I am nothing. And you may personally realize it. I am surprised that you rejected the marriage with Çiçupäla and accepted Me, who am inferior in comparison to Çiçupäla. I think myself completely unfit to be your husband because you are so beautiful, sober, grave and exalted. May I inquire from you the reason that induced you to accept Me? Now, of course, I can address you as My beautiful wife, but still I may inform you of My actual position—that I am inferior to all those princes who wanted to marry you.

"First of all, you may know that I was so much afraid of Jaräsandha that I could not dare to live on the land, and thus I have constructed this house within the water of the sea. It is not my business to disclose this secret to others, but you must know that I am not very heroic; I am a coward and am afraid of them. Still I am not safe, because all the great kings of the land are inimical to Me. I have personally created this inimical feeling by fighting with them in many ways. Another fault is that although I am on the throne of Dvärakä, I have no immediate claim. Although I got a kingdom by killing My maternal uncle, Kaàsa, the kingdom was to go to My grandfather; so actually I have no possession of a kingdom. Besides that, I have no fixed aim in life. People cannot understand Me very well. What is the ultimate goal of My life? They know very well that I was a cowherd boy in Våndävana. People expected that I would follow the footsteps of My foster father, Nanda Mahäräja, and be faithful to Çrématé Rädhäräëé and all Her friends in the village of Våndävana. But all of a sudden I left them. I wanted to become a famous prince. Still I could not have any kingdom, nor could I rule as a prince. People are bewildered about My ultimate goal of life; they do not know whether I am a cowherd boy or a prince, whether I am the son of Nanda Mahäräja or the son of Vasudeva. Because I have no fixed aim in life, people may call Me a vagabond. Therefore, I am surprised that you could select such a vagabond husband.

"Besides this, I am not very much polished, even in social etiquette. A person should be satisfied with one wife, but you see I have married many times, and I have more than 16,000 wives. I cannot please all of them as a polished husband. My behavior with them is not very nice, and I know you are very much conscious of it. I sometimes create a situation with My wives which is not very happy. Because I was trained in a village in My childhood, I am not well acquainted with the etiquette of urban life. I do not know the way to please a wife with nice words and behavior. And from practical experience it is found that any woman who follows My way or who becomes attracted by Me is ultimately left to cry for the rest of her life. In Våndävana, many gopés were attracted to Me, and now I have left them, and they are living but are simply crying for Me in separation. I have heard from Akrüra and Uddhava that since I left Våndävana, all my cowherd boy friends, the gopés and Rädhäräëé, and My foster father Nanda Mahäräja are simply crying constantly for Me. I have left Våndävana for good and am now engaged with the queens in Dvärakä, but I am not well-behaved with any of you. So you can very easily understand that I have no steadiness of character; I am not a very reliable husband. The net result of being attracted to Me is to acquire a life of bereavement only.

"My dear beautiful princess, you may also know that I am always penniless. Just after My birth, I was carried penniless to the house of Nanda Mahäräja, and I was raised just like a cowherd boy. Although My foster father possessed many hundreds of thousands of cows, I was not proprietor of even one of them. I was simply entrusted to take care of them and tender them, but I was not the proprietor. Here also, I am not proprietor of anything, but am always penniless. There is no cause to lament for such a penniless condition; I possessed nothing in the past, so why should I lament that I do not possess anything at present? You may note also that My devotees are not very opulent persons; they also are very poor in worldly goods. Those who are very rich, possessing worldly wealth, are not interested in devotion to Me or Kåñëa consciousness. On the contrary, when a person becomes penniless, whether by force or by circumstances, he may become interested in Me if he gets the proper opportunity. Persons who are proud of their riches, even if they are offered association with My devotees, do not take advantage of consciousness of Me. In other words, the poorer class of men may have some interest in Me, but the richer class of men have no interest. I think, therefore, that your selection of Me was not very intelligent. You appear to be very intelligent, trained by your father and brother, but ultimately you have made a great mistake in selecting your life's companion.

"But there is no harm; it is better late than never. You are at liberty to select a suitable husband who is actually an equal to you in opulence, family tradition, wealth, beauty, education—in all respects. Whatever mistakes you may have made may be forgotten. Now you may chalk out your own lucrative path of life. Usually a person does not establish a marital relationship with a person who is either higher or lower than his position. My dear daughter of the King of Vidarbha, I think you did not consider very sagaciously before your marriage. Thus you made a wrong selection by choosing Me as your husband. You mistakenly heard about My having very exalted character, although factually I was nothing more than a beggar. Without seeing Me and My actual position, simply by hearing about Me, you selected Me as your husband. That was not very rightly done. Therefore I advise you that it is better late than never; you can now select one of the great kñatriya princes and accept him as your life's companion, and you can reject Me."

Kåñëa was proposing that Rukmiëé divorce Him at a time when Rukmiëé already had many grown-up children. Therefore Kåñëa's whole proposition to Rukmiëé appeared to be something unexpected, because according to Vedic culture there was no such thing as separation of husband and wife by divorce. Nor was it possible for Rukmiëé to do so in advanced age, when she had many married sons. Each and every one of Kåñëa's proposals appeared to Rukmiëé to be crazy, and she was surprised that Kåñëa could say such things. Simple as she was, her anxiety was increasing more and more at the thought of separation from Kåñëa.

Kåñëa continued: "After all, you have to prepare yourself for your next life. I therefore advise that you select someone who can help you both in this life and the next life, for I am completely unable to help. My dear beautiful princess, you know that all the members of the princely order, including Çiçupäla, Çälva, Jaräsandha, Dantavakra and even your elder brother Rukmé, are all My enemies; they do not like Me at all. They hate Me from the core of their hearts. All these princes were very much puffed up with their worldly possessions, and they did not care a fig for anyone who came before them. In order to teach them some lessons, I agreed to kidnap you according to your desire; otherwise I actually have no love for you, although you loved Me even before the marriage.

"As I have already explained, I am not very much interested in family life or love between husband and wife. By nature, I am not very fond of family life, wife, children, home and opulences. As My devotees are always neglectful of all these worldly possessions, I am also like that. Actually, I am interested in self-realization; that gives Me pleasure, and not this family life." After submitting His statement, Lord Kåñëa suddenly stopped.

The great authority Çukadeva Gosvämé remarks that Kåñëa almost always passed His time with Rukmiëé, and Rukmiëé was a bit proud to be so fortunate that Kåñëa never left her even for a moment. Kåñëa, however, does not like any of His devotees to be proud. As soon as a devotee becomes so, by some tactic He cuts down that pride. In this case also, Kåñëa said many things which were hard for Rukmiëé to hear. She could only conclude that although she was proud of her position, Kåñëa could be separated from her at any moment.

Rukmiëé was conscious that her husband was not an ordinary human being. He was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the master of the three worlds. By the way He was speaking, she was afraid of being separated from the Lord, for she had never heard such harsh words from Kåñëa before. Thus she became perplexed with fear of separation, and her heart began to palpitate. Without replying to a word of Kåñëa's statement, she simply cried in great anxiety, as if being drowned in an ocean of grief. She silently scratched the ground with the nails of her toes, which were reflecting reddish light on the ground. The tears from her eyes were pink, mixed with the black cosmetic ointment from her eyelids, and the waters were dropping down, washing the kuìkuma and saffron from her breasts. Choked up on account of great anxiety, unable to speak even a word, she kept her head downward and remained standing just like a stick. Due to extremely painful fearfulness and lamentation, she lost all her reasoning powers and became so weak that immediately her body lost so much weight that the bangles on her wrists became slackened. The cämara rod with which she was serving Kåñëa immediately fell from her hand. Her brain and memory became puzzled, and she lost consciousness. The nicely combed hair on her head scattered here and there, and she fell down straight, like a banana tree cut down by a whirlwind.

Lord Kåñëa immediately realized that Rukmiëé had not taken His words in a joking spirit. She had taken them very seriously, and in her extreme anxiety over immediate separation from Him, she had fallen into this condition. Lord Çré Kåñëa is naturally very affectionate toward His devotees, and seeing Rukmiëé's condition, His heart immediately became softened. At once He became merciful to her. The relationship between Kåñëa and Rukmiëé was as Lakñmé-Näräyaëa; therefore, He appeared before her in His four-handed manifestation of Näräyaëa. He got down from the bedstead, brought her up by her hands, and, placing His cooling hands on her face, smoothed the scattered hairs on her head. Lord Kåñëa dried the wet breast of Rukmiëéjé with His hand. Understanding the seriousness of Rukmiëé's love for Him, He embraced her to His chest.

The Supreme Personality is very expert in putting a thing reasonably for one's understanding, and thus He tried to retract all that He said before. He is the only resort for all the devotees, and so He knows very well how to satisfy His pure devotees. Kåñëa understood that Rukmiëé could not follow the statements which He had made in a joking way. To counteract her confusion, He again began to speak, as follows.

"My dear daughter of King Vidarbha, My dear Rukmiëé, please do not misunderstand Me. Don't be unkind unto Me like this. I know you are sincerely and seriously attached to Me; you are My eternal companion. The words which have affected you so much are not factual. I wanted to irritate you a bit, and I was expecting you to make counter answers to those joking words. Unfortunately, you have taken them seriously; I am very sorry for it. I expected that your red lips would tremble in anger on hearing My statement and you would chastise Me in many words. O perfection of love, I never expected that your condition would be like this. I expected that you would put your blinking eyes upon Me in retaliation, and in that way, I would be able to see your beautiful face in that angry mood.

"My dear beautiful wife, you know that we are householders. We are always busy in many household affairs, so we long for a time that we can enjoy some joking words between us. That is our ultimate game in household life. Actually, the householders work very hard day and night, but all fatigue of the day's labor becomes minimized as soon as they meet, husband and wife together, and enjoy life in many ways." Lord Kåñëa wanted to exhibit Himself just as an ordinary householder who delights himself by exchanging joking words with his wife. He therefore repeatedly requested Rukmiëé not to take those words very seriously.

In this way, when Lord Kåñëa pacified Rukmiëé by His sweet words, she could understand that what was formerly spoken by Him was not actually meant, but was spoken to evoke some joking pleasure between themselves. She was therefore pacified by hearing the words of Kåñëa. Gradually she was freed from all fearfulness of separation from Him, and she began to look on His face very cheerfully with her naturally smiling face. She said, "My dear lotus-eyed Lord, Your statement that we are not a fit combination is completely right. It is not possible for me to come to an equal level with You because You are the reservoir of all qualities, the unlimited Supreme Personality of Godhead. How can I be a fit match for You? There is no possibility of comparison with You, who are the master of all greatness, controller of the three qualities and the object of worship for great demigods like Brahmä and Lord Çiva. As far as I am concerned, I am a production of the three modes of material nature. The three modes of material nature are impediments towards the progressive advancement of devotional service. When and where can I be a fit match for You? My dear husband, You have rightly said also that being afraid of the kings, You have taken shelter in the water of the sea. But who is the king of this material world? I do not think that the so-called royal families are kings of the material world. The kings of the material world are the three modes of material nature. They are actually the controllers of this material world. You are situated in the core of everyone's heart, where You remain completely aloof from the touch of the three modes of material nature, and there is not doubt about it.

"You say You always maintain enmity with the worldly kings. But who are the worldly kings? I think the worldly kings are the senses. They are most formidable, and they control everyone. Certainly You maintain enmity with these material senses. You are never under the control of the senses; rather, You are the controller of the senses, Håñékeça. My dear Lord, You have said that You are bereft of all royal power, and that is also correct. Not only are You bereft of material world supremacy, but even Your servants, those who have some attachment to Your lotus feet, also give up the material world supremacy because they consider the material position to be the darkest region, which checks the progress of spiritual enlightenment. Your servants do not like material supremacy, so what to speak of You? My dear Lord, Your statement that You do not act as an ordinary person with a particular aim in life is also perfectly correct. Even Your great devotees and servants, known as great sages and saintly persons, remain in such a state that no one can get any clue to the aim of their lives. They are considered by the human society to be crazy and cynical. Their aim of life remains a mystery to the common human being; the lowest of the mankind can know neither You nor Your servant. A contaminated human being cannot even imagine the pastimes of You and Your devotees. O unlimited one, when the activities and endeavors of Your devotees remain a mystery to the common human being, how can they understand Your motive and endeavor? All kinds of energies and opulences are engaged in Your service, but still they are resting at Your shelter.

"You have described Yourself as penniless, but this condition is not poverty. Since there is nothing in existence but Yourself, You do not require to possess anything—You Yourself are everything. Unlike others, You do not require to purchase anything extraneously. With You all contrary things can be adjusted because You are absolute. You do not possess anything, but no one is richer than You. In the material world no one can be rich without possessing. Since Your Lordship is absolute, You can adjust the contradiction of possessing nothing but at the same time being the richest. In the Vedas it is stated that although You have no material hands and legs, You accept everything which is offered in devotion by the devotees. You have no material eyes and ears, but still You can see everything everywhere, and You can hear everything everywhere. Although You do not possess anything, the great demigods who accept prayers and worship from others come and worship You to solicit Your mercy. How can You be categorized among the poor?

"My dear Lord, You have also stated that the richest section of human society does not worship You. This is also correct, because persons who are puffed up with material possessions think of utilizing their property for sense gratification. When a poverty-stricken man becomes rich, he makes a program for sense gratification. This is due to his ignorance of how to utilize his hard-earned money. Under the spell of the external energy, he thinks that his money is properly employed in sense gratification, and thus he neglects to render transcendental service. My dear Lord, You have stated that persons who possess nothing are very dear to You; renouncing everything, Your devotee wants to possess You only. I see, therefore, that a great sage like Närada Muni who does not possess any material property is still very dear to You. And such persons do not care for anything but Your Lordship.

"My dear Lord, You have stated that a marriage between persons equal in status of social standing, beauty, riches, strength, influence and renunciation can be a suitable match. But this status of life can only be possible by Your grace. You are the supreme perfectional source of all opulences. Whatever opulent status of life one may have is all derived from You. As described in the Vedänta-sütra, janmädyasya yataù: You are the supreme source from which everything emanates, the reservoir of all pleasures. Therefore, persons who are endowed with knowledge desire only to achieve You, and nothing else. To achieve Your favor, they give up everything—even the transcendental realization of Brahman. You are the supreme ultimate goal of life. You are the reservoir of all interests of the living entities. Those who are actually well-motivated desire only You, and for this reason they give up everything to attain success. They therefore deserve to be associated with You. In the society of the servitors and served in Kåñëa consciousness, one is not subjected to the pains and pleasures of material society, which functions according to sex attraction. Therefore, everyone, man or woman, should seek to be an associate in Your society of servitors and served. You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead; no one can excel You, nor can anyone come up to an equal level with You. The perfect social system is that in which You remain in the center, being served as the Supreme, and all others engage as Your servitors. In such a perfectly constructed society, everyone can remain eternally happy and blissful.

"My Lord, You have stated that only the beggars praise Your glories, and that is also perfectly correct. But who are those beggars? Those beggars are all exalted devotees, liberated personalities and those in the renounced order of life. They are all great souls and devotees who have no other business than to glorify You. Such great souls forgive even the worst offender. These so-called beggars execute their spiritual advancement of life, tolerating all kinds of tribulations in the material world. My dear husband, do not think that out of my inexperience I accepted You as my husband; actually, I followed all these great souls. I followed the path of these great beggars and decided to surrender my life unto Your lotus feet.

"You have said that You are penniless, and that is correct. You distribute Yourself completely to these great souls and devotees. Knowing this fact perfectly well, I rejected even such great personalities like Lord Brahmä and King Indra. My Lord, the great time factor acts under Your direction only. The time factor is so great and powerful that within moments it can effect devastation anywhere within the creation. Considering all these factors, I thought Jaräsandha, Çiçupäla and similar other princes who wanted to marry Me to be no more important than ordinary insects.

"My dear all-powerful son of Vasudeva, Your statement that You have taken shelter within the water of the ocean, being afraid of all the great princes, is quite suitable, but my experience with You contradicts this. I have actually seen that You kidnapped me forcibly in the presence of all these princes. At the time of my marriage ceremony, simply by giving a jerk to the string of Your bow, You very easily drove the others away and kindly gave me shelter at Your lotus feet. I still remember vividly that You kidnapped me in the same way as a lion forcibly takes his share of hunted booty, driving away all other small animals within the twinkling of an eye.

"My dear lotus-eyed Lord, I cannot understand Your statement that women and other persons who have taken shelter under Your lotus feet pass their days only in bereavement. From the history of the world we can see that princes like Aìga, Påthu, Bharata, Yayäti and Gaya were all great emperors of the world, and there were no competitors to their exalted positions. But in order to achieve the favor of Your lotus feet, they renounced their exalted positions and entered into the forest to practice penances and austerities. When they voluntarily accepted such a position, accepting Your lotus feet as all in all, does it mean that they were in lamentation and bereavement?

"My dear Lord, You have advised me that I can still select another from the princely order and divorce myself of Your companionship. But, my dear Lord, it is perfectly well-known to me that You are the reservoir of all good qualities. Great saintly persons like Närada Muni are always engaged simply in glorifying Your transcendental characteristics. If someone simply takes shelter of such a saintly person, he immediately becomes freed from all material contamination. And by coming in direct contact with Your service the goddess of fortune agrees to bestow all her blessings. Under the circumstances, what woman who has once heard of Your glories from authoritative sources and somehow or other has tasted the nectarean flavor of Your lotus feet can be foolish enough to agree to marry someone of this material world who is always afraid of death, disease, old age and rebirth? I have therefore accepted Your lotus feet, not without consideration, but after mature and deliberate decision. My dear Lord, You are the master of the three worlds. You can fulfill all the desires of all Your devotees in this world and the next, because You are the Supreme Soul of everyone. I have therefore selected You as my husband, considering You to be the only fit personality. You may throw me in any species of life according to the reaction of my fruitive activities, and I haven't the least concern for this. My only ambition is that I may always remain fast to Your lotus feet, because You can deliver Your devotees from the illusory material existence and are always prepared to distribute Yourself to Your devotees.

"My dear Lord, You have advised me to select one of the princes such as Çiçupäla, Jaräsandha or Dantavakra, but what is their position in this world? They are always engaged in hard labor to maintain their household life, just like the bulls working hard day and night with the oil-pressing machine. They are compared to asses, beasts of burden. They are always dishonored like the dogs, and they are miserly like the cats. They have sold themselves like slaves to their wives. Any unfortunate woman who has never heard of Your glories may accept such a man as her husband, but a woman who has learned about You—that You are praised not only in this world, but in the halls of the great demigods like Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva—will not accept anyone besides Yourself as her husband. A man within this material world is just a dead body. In fact, superficially, the living entity is covered by this body, which is nothing but a bag of skin decorated with beards and moustaches, hairs on the body, nails on the fingers and hairs on the head. Within this decorated bag there are bunches of muscles, bundles of bones, and pools of blood, always mixed up with stool, urine, mucus, bile and polluted air, and enjoyed by different kinds of insects and germs. A foolish woman accepts such a dead body as her husband and, in sheer misunderstanding, loves him as her dear companion. This is only possible because such a woman has never tasted the ever-blissful flavor of Your lotus feet.

"My dear lotus-eyed husband, You are self-satisfied. You do not care whether or not I am beautiful or qualified; You are not at all concerned about it. Therefore Your nonattachment for me is not at all astonishing; it is quite natural. You cannot be attached to any woman, however exalted her position and beauty. Whether You are attached to me or not, may my devotion and attention be always engaged at Your lotus feet. The material mode of passion is also Your creation, so when You passionately glance upon me, I accept it as the greatest boon of my life. I am ambitious only for such auspicious moments."

After hearing Rukmiëé's statement and her clarification of each and every word which He had used to arouse her anger of love toward Him, Kåñëa addressed Rukmiëé as follows: "My dear chaste wife, My dear princess, I was expecting such an explanation from you, and for this purpose only I spoke all those joking words, so that you might be cheated of the real point of view. Now My purpose has been served. The wonderful explanation that you have given to each and every word of Mine is completely factual and approved by Me. O most beautiful Rukmiëé, You are My dearmost wife. I am greatly pleased to understand how much love you have for Me. Please take it for granted that no matter what ambition and desire you might have and no matter what you might expect from Me, I am always at your service. And it is a fact also that My devotees, My dearmost friends and servitors, are always free from material contamination, even though they are not inclined to ask from Me such liberation. My devotees never desire anything from Me except to be engaged in My service. And yet because they are completely dependent upon Me, even if they are found to ask something from Me, that is not material. Such ambitions and desires, instead of becoming the cause of material bondage, become the source of liberation from this material world.

"My dear chaste and pious wife, I have tested, on the basis of strict chastity, your love for your husband, and you have passed the examination most successfully. I have purposely agitated you by speaking many words which were not applicable to your character, but I am surprised to see that not a pinch of your devotion to Me has been deviated from its fixed position. My dear wife, I am the bestower of all benedictions, even up to the standard of liberation from this material world, and it is I only who can stop the continuation of material existence and call one back to home, back to Godhead. One whose devotion for Me is adulterated worships Me for some material benefit, just to keep himself in the world of material happiness, culminating in the pleasure of sex life. One who engages himself in severe penance and austerities just to attain this material happiness is certainly under the illusion of My external energy. Persons who are engaged in My devotional service simply for the purpose of material gains and sense gratification certainly are very foolish. Material happiness based on sex life is available in the most abominable species of life, such as the hogs and dogs. No one should try to approach Me for such happiness, because it is available even if one is put into a hellish condition of life. It is better, therefore, for persons who are simply after material happiness and not after Me to remain in that hellish condition."

Material contamination is so strong that everyone is working very hard day and night for material happiness. The show of religiousness, austerity penance, humanitarianism, philanthropy, politics, science—everything is aimed at realizing some material benefit. For the immediate success of material benefit, the materialistic persons generally worship different demigods, and under the spell of material propensities they sometimes take to the devotional service of the Lord. Sometimes it so happens that if a person sincerely serves the Lord and at the same time maintains material ambition, the Lord very kindly removes the sources of material happiness. Without finding any recourse in material happiness, the devotee then engages himself absolutely in pure devotional service.

Lord Kåñëa continued, "My dear best of the queens, it is clearly understood by Me that you have no material ambition; your only purpose is to serve Me, and you have long been engaged in unalloyed service. Exemplary unalloyed devotional service not only can bestow upon the devotee liberation from this material world, but it also promotes him to the spiritual world for being eternally engaged in My service. Persons who are too addicted to material happiness cannot render such service. Women whose hearts are polluted and full of material desires devise various means of sense gratification while outwardly showing themselves to be great devotees.

"My dear honored wife, although I have thousands of wives, I do not think that any one of them can love Me more than you. The practical proof of your extraordinary position is that you had never seen Me before your marriage; you had simply heard about Me from a third person, and still your faith in Me was so fixed that even in the presence of many qualified, rich and beautiful men of the royal order, you did not select any one of them as your husband, but insisted on having Me. You neglected all the princes present, and very politely you sent Me a confidential letter inviting Me to kidnap you. While I was kidnapping you, your elder brother Rukmé violently protested and fought with Me. As a result of the fight, I defeated him mercilessly and disfigured his body. At the time of Aniruddha's marriage, when we were all engaged in playing chess, there was another fight with your brother Rukmé on a controversial verbal point, and My elder brother Balaräma finally killed him. I was surprised to see that you did not utter even a word of protest over this incidence. Because of your great anxiety that you might be separated from Me, you suffered all the consequences without speaking even a word. As the result of this great silence, My dear wife, you have purchased Me for all time; I have become eternally under your control. You sent your messenger to Me inviting Me to kidnap you, and when you found that there was a little delay in My arriving on the spot, you began to see the whole world as vacant. At that time you concluded that your beautiful body was not fit to be touched by anyone else; therefore, thinking that I was not coming, you decided to commit suicide and immediately end that body. My dear Rukmiëé, such great and exalted love for Me will always remain within My soul. As far as I am concerned, it is not within My power to repay you for your unalloyed devotion to Me."

The Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa certainly has no business being anyone's husband or son or father, because everything belongs to Him and everyone is under His control. He does not require anyone's help for His satisfaction. He is ätmäräma, self-satisfied; He can derive all pleasure by Himself, without anyone's help. When the Lord descends to play the part of a human being, He plays a role either as a husband, son, friend or enemy, in full perfection. As such, when He was playing as the perfect husband of the queens, especially of Rukmiëéjé, He enjoyed conjugal love in complete perfection.

According to Vedic culture, although polygamy is allowed, none of the wives should be ill-treated. In other words, one may take many wives only if he is able to satisfy all of them equally as an ideal householder; otherwise it is not allowed. Lord Kåñëa is the world-teacher; therefore, even though He had no need for a wife, He expanded Himself into as many forms as He had wives, and He lived with them as an ideal householder, observing the regulative principles, rules and commitments in accordance with the Vedic injunctions and the social laws and customs of society. For each of His 16,108 wives, He simultaneously maintained different palaces, different establishments and different atmospheres. Thus the Lord, although one, exhibited Himself as 16,108 ideal householders.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Fifth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Talks Between Kåñëa and Rukmiëé."

KB 1970-2-6 / The Genealogical Table of the Family of Kåñëa

6 /The Genealogical Table of the Family of Kåñëa

Kåñëa had 16,108 wives, and in each of them He begot ten sons, all of them equal to their father in the opulences of strength, beauty, wisdom, fame, wealth and renunciation. "Like father like son." All the 16,108 wives of Kåñëa were princesses, and when each saw that Kåñëa was always present in her respective palace and did not leave home, they considered Kåñëa to be a henpecked husband who was very much attached to them. Every one of them thought that Kåñëa was her very obedient husband, but actually Kåñëa had no attraction for any of them. Although each thought that she was the only wife of Kåñëa and was very, very dear to Him, Lord Kåñëa, since He is ätmäräma, self-sufficient, was neither dear nor inimical to any one of them; He was equal to all the wives and treated them as a perfect husband just to please them. For Him, there was no need for even a single wife. In fact, since they were women, the wives could not understand the exalted position of Kåñëa nor the truths about Him.

All the princesses who were wives of Kåñëa were exquisitely beautiful, and each one of them was attracted by Kåñëa's eyes, which were just like lotus petals, and by His beautiful face, long arms, broad ears, pleasing smile, humorous talk and sweet words. Influenced by these features of Kåñëa, they all used to dress themselves very attractively, desiring to attract Kåñëa by their feminine bodily appeal. They used to exhibit their feminine characteristics by smiling and moving their eyebrows, thus throwing sharpened arrows of conjugal love just to awaken Kåñëa's lusty desires for them. Still, they could not arouse the mind of Kåñëa or His sex appetite. This means that Kåñëa never had any sex relations with any of His many wives, save and except to beget children.

The queens of Dvärakä were so fortunate that they got Lord Çré Kåñëa as their husband and personal companion, although He is not approachable by exalted demigods like Brahmä. They remained together as husband and wife, and Kåñëa, as an ideal husband, treated them in such a way that at every moment there was an increase of transcendental bliss in their smiling exchanges, talking and mixing together. Each and every wife had hundreds and thousands of maidservants, yet when Kåñëa entered the palaces of His thousands of wives, each one of them used to receive Kåñëa personally by seating Him in a nice chair, worshiping Him with all requisite paraphernalia, personally washing His lotus feet, offering Him betel nuts, massaging His legs to relieve them from fatigue, fanning Him to make Him comfortable, offering all kinds of scented sandalwood pulp, oils and aromatics, putting flower garlands on His neck, dressing His hair, getting Him to lie down on the bed and assisting Him in taking His bath. Thus they served always in every respect, especially when Kåñëa was eating. They were always engaged in the service of the Lord.

Of the 16,108 queens of Kåñëa, each of whom had ten sons, there is the following list of the sons of the first eight queens. By Rukmiëé, Kåñëa had ten sons: Pradyumna, Cärudeñëa, Sudeñëa, Cärudeha, Sucäru, Cärugupta, Bhadracäru, Cärucandra, Vicäru, and Cäru. None of them were inferior in their qualities to their divine father, Lord Kåñëa. Similarly, Satyabhämä had ten sons, and their names are as follows: Bhänu, Subhänu, Svarbhänu, Prabhänu, Bhänumän, Candrabhänu, Båhadbhänu, Atibhänu, Çrébhänu and Pratibhänu. The next queen, Jämbavaté, had ten sons, headed by Sämba. Their names are as follows: Sämba, Sumitra, Purujit, Çatajit, Sahasrajit, Vijaya, Citraketu, Vasumän, Draviòa and Kratu. Lord Kåñëa was specifically very affectionate to the sons of Jämbavaté. By His wife Satyä, the daughter of King Nagnajit, Lord Kåñëa had ten sons. They are as follows: Véra, Candra, Açvasena, Citragu, Vegavän, Våña, Äma, Çaìku, Vasu and Kunti. Amongst all of them, Kunté was very powerful. Kåñëa had ten sons by Kälindé, and they are as follows: Çruta, Kavi, Våña, Véra, Subähu, Bhadra, Çänti, Darça, Pürëamäsa and the youngest, Somaka. For His next wife, Lakñmaëä, the daughter of the King of Madras Province, He begot ten sons, of the names Praghoña, Gätravän, Siàha, Bala, Prabala, Ürdhvaga, Mahäçakti, Saha, Oja and Aparäjita. Similarly, His next wife, Mitravindä, had ten sons. They are as follows: Våka, Harña, Anila, Gådhra, Vardhana, Annäda, Mahäàsa, Pävana, Vahni and Kñudhi. His next wife, Bhadrä, had ten sons, of the names Saìgrämajit, Båhatsena, Çüra, Praharaëa, Arijit, Jaya, Subhadrä, Väma, Äyu and Satyaka. Besides these eight chief queens, Kåñëa had 16,100 other wives, and all of them had ten sons each.

The eldest son of Rukmiëé, Pradyumna, was married with Mäyävaté from his very birth, and afterwards he was again married with Rukmavaté, the daughter of his maternal uncle, Rukmé. From this Rukmavaté, Pradyumna had a son named Aniruddha. In this way, Kåñëa's family—Kåñëa and His wives, along with their sons and grandsons and even great-grandsons—all combined together to include very nearly one billion family members.

Rukmé, the elder brother of Kåñëa's first wife, Rukmiëé, was greatly harrassed and insulted in his fight with Kåñëa, but on the request of Rukmiëé his life was saved. Since then Rukmé had held a great grudge against Kåñëa and was always inimical toward Him. Nevertheless, his daughter was married with Kåñëa's son, and his granddaughter was married with Kåñëa's grandson, Aniruddha. This fact appeared to be a little astonishing to Mahäräja Parékñit when he heard it from Çukadeva Gosvämé. "I am surprised that Rukmé and Kåñëa, who were so greatly inimical to one another, could again be united by marital relationships between their descendants." Parékñit Mahäräja was curious about the mystery of this incident, and therefore he inquired further from Çukadeva Gosvämé. Because Çukadeva Gosvämé was a practical yogé, nothing was hidden from his power of insight. A perfect yogé like Çukadeva Gosvämé can see past, present and future in all details. Therefore, from such yogés or mystics there can be nothing concealed. When Parékñit Mahäräja inquired from Çukadeva Gosvämé, Çukadeva Gosvämé answered as follows.

Pradyumna, the eldest son of Kåñëa, born of Rukmiëé, was Cupid himself. He was so beautiful and attractive that the daughter of Rukmé, namely Rukmavaté, could not select any husband other than Pradyumna during her svayaàvara. Therefore, in that selection meeting, she garlanded Pradyumna in the presence of all other princes. When there was a fight among the princes, Pradyumna came out victorious, and therefore Rukmé was obliged to offer his beautiful daughter to him. Although a far-off enmity was always blazing in the heart of Rukmé because of his being insulted by Kåñëa's kidnapping of his sister Rukmiëé, when his daughter selected Pradyumna as her husband Rukmé could not resist consenting to the marriage ceremony just to please his sister, Rukmiëé. And so Pradyumna became the nephew of Rukmé. Besides the ten sons described above, Rukmiëé had one beautiful daughter with big eyes, and she was married to the son of Kåtavarmä, whose name was Balé.

Although Rukmé was a veritable enemy of Kåñëa, he had great affection for his sister, Rukmiëé, and he wanted to please her in all respects. On this account, when Rukmiëé's grandson Aniruddha was to be married, Rukmé offered his granddaughter Rocanä to Aniruddha. Such marriage between immediate cousins is not very much sanctioned by the Vedic culture, but in order to please Rukmiëé, Rukmé offered his daughter and granddaughter to the son and grandson of Kåñëa. In this way, when the negotiation of the marriage of Aniruddha with Rocanä was complete, a big marriage party accompanied Aniruddha and started from Dvärakä. They travelled until they reached Bhojakaöa, which Rukmé had colonized after his sister had been kidnapped by Kåñëa. This marriage party was led by the grandfather, namely Lord Kåñëa, accompanied by Lord Balaräma, as well as Kåñëa's first wife, Rukmiëé, His son Pradyumna, Jämbavaté's son Sämba and many other relatives and family members. They reached the town of Bhojakaöa, and the marriage ceremony was peacefully performed.

The King of Kaliìga was a friend of Rukmé's, and he gave him the ill advice to play with Balaräma and thus defeat Him in a bet. Amongst the kñatriya kings, betting and gambling in chess was not uncommon. If someone challenged a friend to play on the chessboard, the friend could not deny the challenge. Çré Balarämajé was not a very expert chess player, and this was known to the King of Kaliìga. So Rukmé was advised to retaliate against the family members of Kåñëa by challenging Balaräma to play chess. Although not a very expert chess player, Çré Balarämajé was very enthusiastic in sporting activities. He accepted the challenge of Rukmé and sat down to play. Betting was with gold coins, and Balaräma first of all challenged with one hundred coins, then 1,000 coins, then 10,000 coins. Each time, Balaräma lost, and Rukmé became victorious.

Çré Balaräma's losing the game was an opportunity for the King of Kaliìga to criticize Kåñëa and Balaräma. Thus the King of Kaliìga was talking jokingly and purposefully showing his teeth to Balaräma. Because Balaräma was the loser in the game, He was a little intolerant of the sarcastic joking words. He became a little agitated, and when Rukmé again challenged Balaräma, he made a bet of 100,000 gold coins. Fortunately, this time Balaräma won. Although Balarämajé had won, Rukmé, out of his cunningness, began to claim that Balaräma was the loser and that he himself had won. Because of this lie, Balarämajé became most angry with Rukmé. His agitation was so sudden and great that it appeared like a tidal wave in the ocean on a full moon day. Balaräma's eyes are naturally reddish, and when He became agitated and angry His eyes became more reddish. This time He challenged and made a bet of a hundred million coins.

Again Balaräma was the winner according to the rules of chess, but Rukmé again cunningly began to claim that he had won. Rukmé appealed to the princes present, and He especially mentioned the name of the King of Kaliìga. At that time there was a voice from the air during the dispute, and it announced that for all honest purposes Balaräma, the actual winner of this game, was being abused and that the statement of Rukmé that he had won was absolutely false.

In spite of this divine voice, Rukmé insisted that Balaräma had lost, and by his persistence it appeared that he had death upon his head. Falsely puffed up by the ill advice of his friend, he did not give much importance to the oracle, and he began to criticize Balarämajé. He said, "My dear Balarämajé, You two brothers, cowherd boys only, may be very expert in tending cows, but how can You be expert in playing chess or shooting arrows on the battlefield? These arts are well-known only to the princely order." Hearing this kind of pinching talk by Rukmé and hearing the loud laughter of all the other princes present there, Lord Balaräma became as agitated as burning cinders. He immediately took a club in His hand and, without any further talk, struck Rukmé on the head. From that one blow, Rukmé fell down immediately and was dead and gone. Thus Rukmé was killed by Balaräma on that auspicious occasion of Aniruddha's marriage.

These things are not very uncommon in kñatriya society, and the King of Kaliìga, being afraid that he would be the next to be attacked, fled from the scene. Before he could escape even a few steps, however, Balarämajé immediately captured him and, because the King was always showing his teeth while criticizing Balaräma and Kåñëa, broke all his teeth with His club. The other princes who were supporting the King of Kaliìga and Rukmé were also captured, and Balaräma beat them with His club, breaking their legs and hands. They did not try to retaliate but thought it wise to run away from the bloody scene.

During this strife between Balaräma and Rukmé, Lord Kåñëa did not utter a word, for He knew that if He supported Balaräma Rukmiëé would be unhappy, and if He said that the killing of Rukmé was unjust, then Balaräma would be unhappy. Therefore, Lord Kåñëa was silent on the death of His brother-in-law, Rukmé, on the occasion of His grandson's marriage. He did not disturb either His affectionate relationship with Balaräma or with Rukmiëé. After this, the bride and the bridegroom were ceremoniously seated on the chariot, and they started for Dvärakä, accompanied by the bridegroom's party. The bridegroom's party was always protected by Lord Kåñëa, the killer of the Madhu demon. Thus they left Rukmé's kingdom, Bhojakaöa, and happily started for Dvärakä.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Sixth Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Genealogical Table of the Family of Kåñëa."

KB 1970-2-7 / The Meeting of Uñä and Aniruddha

7 /The Meeting of Uñä and Aniruddha

The meeting of Aniruddha and Uñä, which caused a great fight between Lord Kåñëa and Lord Çiva, is very mysterious and interesting. Mahäräja Parékñit was anxious to hear the whole story from Çukadeva Gosvämé, and thus Çukadeva narrated it. "My dear King, you must have heard the name of King Bali. He was a great devotee who gave away in charity all that he had—namely, the whole world—to Lord Vämana, the incarnation of Viñëu as a dwarf brähmaëa. King Bali had one hundred sons, and the eldest of all of them was Bäëäsura."

This great hero Bäëäsura, born of Mahäräja Bali, was a great devotee of Lord Çiva and was always ready to render service unto him. Because of his devotion, he achieved a great position in society, and he was honored in every respect. Actually, he was very intelligent and liberal also, and his activities are all praiseworthy because he never deviated from his promise and word of honor; he was very truthful and fixed in his vow. In those days, he was ruling over the city of Çonitapura. By the grace of Lord Çiva, Bäëäsura had one thousand hands, and he became so powerful that even demigods like King Indra were serving him as most obedient servants.

Long ago, when Lord Çiva was dancing in his celebrated fashion called täëòava-nåtya, for which he is known as Naöaräja, Bäëäsura helped Lord Çiva in his dancing by rythmically beating drums with his one thousand hands. Lord Çiva is well-known as Äçutoña, very easily pleased, and he is also very affectionate to his devotees. He is a great protector for persons who take shelter of him and is the master of all living entities in this material world. Being pleased with Bäëäsura, he said, "Whatever you desire you can have from me because I am very much pleased with you." Bäëäsura replied, "My dear lord, if you please, you can remain in my city just to protect me from the hands of my enemies."

Once upon a time, Bäëäsura came to offer his respects to Lord Çiva. By touching the lotus feet of Lord Çiva with his helmet, which was shining like the sun globe, he offered his obeisances unto him. While offering his respectful obeisances, Bäëäsura said, "My dear lord, anyone who has not fulfilled his ambition will be able to do so by taking shelter of your lotus feet, which are just like desire trees—one can take from them anything he desires. My dear lord, you have given me one thousand arms, but I do not know what to do with them. Please pardon me, but it appears that I cannot use them properly in fighting. I cannot find anyone competent to fight with me except your lordship, the original father of the material world. Sometimes I feel a great tendency to fight with my arms, and I go out to find a suitable warrior. Unfortunately, everyone flees, knowing my extraordinary power. Being baffled at not finding a match, I simply satisfy the itching of my arms by beating them against the mountains. In this way, I tear many great mountains to pieces."

Lord Çiva realized that his benediction had become troublesome for Bäëäsura and addressed him, "You rascal! You are very eager to fight, but since you have no one to fight with, you are distressed. Although you think that there is no one in the world to oppose you except me, I say that you will eventually find such a competent person. At that time your days will come to an end, and your flag of victory will no longer fly. Then you will see your false prestige smashed to pieces!"

After hearing Lord Çiva's statement, Bäëäsura became very puffed up with his power. He was elated that he would meet someone who would be able to smash him to pieces. Bäëäsura then returned home with great pleasure, and he always waited for the day when the suitable fighter would come to cut down his strength. He was such a foolish demon. It appears that foolish, demonic human beings, when unnecessarily overpowered with material opulences, want to exhibit these opulences, and such foolish people feel satisfaction when these opulences are exhausted. The idea is that they do not know how to expend their energy for right causes, being unaware of the benefit of Kåñëa consciousness. Actually, there are two classes of men—one is Kåñëa conscious, the other is non-Kåñëa conscious. The non-Kåñëa conscious men are generally devoted to the demigods, whereas the Kåñëa conscious men are devoted to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa conscious persons utilize everything for the service of the Lord. The non-Kåñëa conscious persons utilize everything for sense gratifaction, and Bäëäsura is a perfect example of such a person. He was very anxious to utilize for his own satisfaction his extraordinary power to fight. Not finding any combatant, he struck his powerful hands against the mountains, breaking them into pieces. In contrast to this, Arjuna also possessed extraordinary powers for fighting, but he utilized them only for Kåñëa.

Bäëäsura had a very beautiful daughter, whose name was Uñä. When she had attained the age of marriage and was sleeping amongst her many girl friends, she dreamt one night that Aniruddha was by her side and that she was enjoying a conjugal relationship with him, although she had never actually seen him nor heard of him before. She awoke from her dream exclaiming very loudly, "My dear beloved, where are you?" Being exposed to her other friends in this way, she became a little bit ashamed. One of Uñä's girl friends was Citralekhä, who was the daughter of Bäëäsura's prime minister. Citralekhä and Uñä were intimate friends, and out of great curiosity Citralekhä asked, "My dear beautiful princess, as of yet you are not married to any young boy, nor have you seen any boys until now; so I am surprised that you are exclaiming like this. Who are you searching after? Who is your suitable match?"

On hearing Citralekhä's inquiries, Uñä replied, "My dear friend, in my dream I saw a nice young man who is very, very beautiful. His complexion is swarthy, his eyes are just like lotus petals, and he is dressed in yellow garments. His arms are very long, and his general bodily features are so pleasing that any young girl would be attracted. I feel much pride in saying that this beautiful young man was kissing me, and I was very much enjoying the nectar of his kissing. I am sorry to inform you that just after this he disappeared, and I have been thrown into the whirlpool of disappointment. My dear friend, I am very anxious to find this wonderful young man, the desired lord of my heart."

After hearing Uñä's words, Citralekhä immediately replied, "I can understand your bereavement, and I assure you that if this boy is within these three worlds—the upper, middle, and lower planetary systems—I must find him for your satisfaction. If you can identify him from your dream, I shall bring you peace of mind. Now, let me draw some pictures for you to inspect, and as soon as you find the picture of your desired husband, let me know. It doesn't matter where he is; I know the art of bringing him here. So, as soon as you identify him, I shall immediately arrange for it."

Citralekhä, while talking, began to draw many pictures of the demigods inhabiting the higher planetary systems, then pictures of the Gandharvas, Siddhas, Cäraëas, Pannagas, Daityas, Vidyädharas and Yakñas, as well as many human beings. (The statements of Çrémad-Bhägavatam and other Vedic literature prove definitely that on each and every planet there are living entities of different varieties. Therefore, it is foolish to assert that there are no living entities but those on this earth.) Citralekhä painted many pictures. Among those of the human beings was the Våñëi dynasty, including Vasudeva, the father of Kåñëa, Çürasena, the grandfather of Kåñëa, Çré Balarämajé, Lord Kåñëa and many others. When Uñä saw the picture of Pradyumna, she became a little bashful, but when she saw the picture of Aniruddha, she became so bashful that she immediately lowered her head and smiled, having found the man she was seeking. She identified the picture to Citralekhä as that of the man who had stolen her heart.

Citralekhä was a great mystic yoginé, and as soon as Uñä identified the picture, although neither of them had ever seen him nor knew his name, Citralekhä could immediately understand that the picture was of Aniruddha, a grandson of Kåñëa. That very night she traveled in outer space and within a very short time reached the city of Dvärakä, which was well-protected by Kåñëa. She entered the palace and found Aniruddha sleeping in his bedroom on a very opulent bed. Citralekhä, by her mystic power, immediately brought Aniruddha, in that sleeping condition, to the city of Çonitapura so that Uñä might see her desired husband. Uñä immediately bloomed in happiness and began to enjoy the company of Aniruddha with great satisfaction.

The palace in which Uñä and Citralekhä lived was so well fortified that it was impossible for any male to either enter or see inside. Uñä and Aniruddha lived together in the palace, and day after day the love of Uñä for Aniruddha grew four times upon four times. Uñä pleased Aniruddha with her valuable dresses, flowers, garlands, scents and incense. By his bedside sitting place were other paraphernalia for residential purposes—nice drinks such as milk and sherbet and nice eatables which could be chewed or swallowed. Above all, she pleased him with sweet words and very obliging service. Aniruddha was worshiped by Uñä as if he were the Supreme Personality of Godhead. By her excellent service, Uñä made Aniruddha forget all other things and was able to draw his attention and love upon her without deviation. In such an atmosphere of love and service, Aniruddha practically forgot himself and could not recall how many days he had been away from his real home.

In due course of time, Uñä exhibited some bodily symptoms by which it could be understood that she was having intercourse with a male friend. The symptoms were so prominent that her actions could no longer be concealed from anyone. Uñä was always cheerful in the association of Aniruddha, but she did not know the bounds of her satisfaction. The housekeeper and the watchmen of the palace could guess very easily that she was having relations with a male friend, and without waiting for further development, all of them informed their master, Bäëäsura. In Vedic culture, an unmarried girl having association with a male is the greatest disgrace to the family, and so the caretaker cautiously informed his master that Uñä was developing symptoms indicating a disgraceful association. The servants informed their master that they were not at all neglectful in guarding the house, being alert day and night against any young man who might enter. They were so careful that a male could not even see what was going on there, and so they were surprised that she had become contaminated. Since they could not trace out the reason for it, they submitted the whole situation before their master.

Bäëäsura was shocked to understand that his daughter Uñä was no longer a virgin maiden. This weighed heavily on his heart, and without delay he rushed towards the palace where Uñä was living. There he saw that Uñä and Aniruddha were sitting together and talking. Uñä and Aniruddha looked very beautiful together, Aniruddha being the son of Pradyumna, who was Cupid himself. Bäëäsura saw his daughter and Aniruddha as a suitable match, yet for family prestige, he did not like the combination at all. Bäëäsura could not understand who the boy actually was. He appreciated the fact that Uñä could not have selected anyone in the three worlds more beautiful. Aniruddha's complexion was brilliant and swarthy. He was dressed in yellow garments and had eyes just like lotus petals. His arms were very long, and he had nice, curling, bluish hair. The glaring rays of his glittering earrings and the beautiful smile on his lips were certainly captivating. Still, Bäëäsura was very angry.

When Bäëäsura saw him, Aniruddha was engaged in playing with Uñä. Aniruddha was nicely dressed, and Uñä had garlanded him with various beautiful flowers. The reddish kuìkuma powder put on the breasts of women was spotted here and there on the garland, indicating that Uñä had embraced him. Bäëäsura was struck with wonder that, even in his presence, Aniruddha was peacefully sitting in front of Uñä. Aniruddha knew, however, that his would-be father-in-law was not at all pleased and that he was gathering many soldiers in the palace to attack him.

Thus, not finding any other weapon, Aniruddha took hold of a big iron rod and stood up before Bäëäsura and his soldiers. He firmly took a posture indicating that if he were attacked he would strike all of the soldiers down to the ground with the iron rod. Bäëäsura and his company of soldiers saw that the boy was standing before them just like the superintendent of death with his invincible rod. Now, under the order of Bäëäsura, the soldiers from all sides attempted to capture and arrest him. When they dared to come before him, Aniruddha struck them with the rod, breaking their heads, legs, arms and thighs, and one after another, they began to fall to the ground. He killed them just as the leader of a flock of hawks kills barking dogs, one after another. In this way, Aniruddha was able to escape the palace.

Bäëäsura knew various arts of fighting, and by the grace of Lord Çiva, he knew how to arrest his opposing enemy by the use of a nägapäça, snake-noose, and so Aniruddha was seized as he came out of the palace. When Uñä received the news that her father had arrested Aniruddha, she became overwhelmed with grief and confusion. Tears began to glide down her eyes, and being unable to check herself, she began to cry very loudly.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Seventh Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Meeting of Uñä and Aniruddha."

KB 1970-2-8 / Lord Kåñëa Fights with Bäëäsura

8 /Lord Kåñëa Fights with Bäëäsura

When the four months of the rainy season passed and still Aniruddha had not returned home, all the members of the Yadu family became much perturbed. They could not understand how the boy was missing. Fortunately, one day the great sage Närada came and informed the family about Aniruddha's disappearance from the palace. He explained how Aniruddha had been carried to the city of Çonitapura, the capital of Bäëäsura's empire, and how Bäëäsura had arrested him with the nägapäça, even though Aniruddha had defeated his soldiers. This news was given in detail, and the whole story was disclosed. Then the members of the Yadu dynasty, all of whom had great affection for Kåñëa, prepared to attack the city of Çonitapura. Practically all the leaders of the family, including Pradyumna, Sätyaki, Gada, Sämba, Säraëa, Nanda, Upananda and Bhadra, combined together and gathered eighteen akñauhiëé military divisions into phalanxes. Then they all went to Çonitapura and surrounded it with soldiers, elephants, horses and chariots.

Bäëäsura heard that the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty were attacking the whole city, tearing down various walls, gates and nearby gardens. Becoming very angry, he immediately ordered his soldiers, who were of equal caliber, to go and face them. Lord Çiva was so kind to Bäëäsura that he personally came as the commander-in-chief of the military force, assisted by his heroic sons Kärttikeya and Gaëapati. Seated on his favorite bull, Nandéçvara, Lord Çiva, led the fighting against Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma. We can simply imagine how fierce the fighting was—Lord Çiva with his valiant sons on one side and Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and His elder brother, Çré Balarämajé, on the other. The fighting was so fierce that those who saw the battle were struck with wonder, and the hairs on their bodies stood up. Lord Çiva was engaged in fighting directly with Lord Kåñëa, Pradyumna was engaged with Kärttikeya, and Lord Balaräma was engaged with Bäëäsura's commander-in-chief, Kumbhäëòa, who was assisted by Küpakarëa. Sämba, the son of Kåñëa, was engaged in fighting with the son of Bäëäsura, and Bäëäsura was engaged in fighting with Sätyaki, commander-in-chief of the Yadu dynasty. In this way the fighting was waged.

News of the fighting spread all over the universe. Demigods such as Lord Brahmä, from higher planetary systems, along with great sages and saintly persons, Siddhas, Cäraëas and Gandharvas—all being very curious to see the fight between Lord Çiva, Lord Kåñëa and their assistants—were hovering over the battlefield in their airplanes. Lord Çiva is called the bhüta-nätha, being assisted by various types of powerful ghosts and denizens of the inferno—bhütas, pretas, pramathas, guhyakas, òäkinés, piçäcas, kuñmäëòas, vetälas, véëäyakas, and brahma-räkñasas. (Of all kinds of ghosts, the brahma-räkñasas are very powerful. Brähmaëas transferred to the role of ghosts become brahma-räkñasas.)

The Supreme Personality of Godhead Çré Kåñëa simply drove all these ghosts away from the battlefield, beating them with His celebrated bow, Çärìgadhanu. Lord Çiva then began to release all his selected weapons upon the Personality of Godhead. Lord Çré Kåñëa, without any difficulty, counteracted all these weapons with counter-weapons. He counteracted the brahmästra, similar to the atomic bomb, by another brahmästra, and an air weapon by a mountain weapon. When Lord Çiva released a particular weapon bringing about a violent hurricane on the battlefield, Lord Kåñëa presented just the opposing element, a mountain weapon which checked the hurricane on the spot. Similarly when Lord Çiva released his weapon of devastating fire, Kåñëa counteracted it with torrents of rain.

At last, when Lord Çiva released his personal weapon, called päçupata-çastra, Kåñëa immediately counteracted it by the näräyaëa-çastra. Lord Çiva then became exasperated in fighting with Lord Kåñëa. Kåñëa then took the opportunity to release His yawning weapon. When this weapon is released, the opposing party becomes tired, stops fighting, and begins to yawn. Consequently, Lord Çiva became so fatigued that he refused to fight anymore and began to yawn. Kåñëa was now able to turn His attention from the attack of Lord Çiva to the efforts of Bäëäsura, and He began to kill his personal soldiers with swords and clubs. Meanwhile, Lord Kåñëa's son Pradyumna was fighting fiercely with Kärttikeya, the commander-in-chief of the demigods. Kärttikeya was wounded, and his body was bleeding profusely. In this condition, he left the battlefield and, without fighting anymore, rode away on the back of his peacock carrier. Similarly, Lord Balaräma was smashing Bäëäsura's commander-in-chief, Kumbhäëòa, with the strokes of his club. Küpakarëa was also wounded in this way, and both he and Kumbhäëòa fell on the battlefield, the commander-in-chief being fatally wounded. Without guidance, all of Bäëäsura's soldiers scattered here and there.

When Bäëäsura saw that his soldiers and commanders had been defeated, his anger only increased. He thought it wise to stop fighting with Sätyaki, Kåñëa's commander-in-chief, and instead directly attacked Lord Kåñëa. Now having the opportunity to use his one thousand hands, he rushed towards Kåñëa, simultaneously working 500 bows and 2,000 arrows. Such a foolish person could never measure Kåñëa's strength. Immediately, without any difficulty, Kåñëa cut each of Bäëäsura's bows into two pieces and, to check him from going further, made his chariot horses lay on the ground. The chariot then broke to pieces. After doing this, Kåñëa blew His conchshell, Päïcajanya.

There was a demigoddess named Koöarä who was worshiped by Bäëäsura, and their relationship was as mother and son. Mother Koöarä was upset that Bäëäsura's life was in danger, so she appeared on the scene. With naked body and scattered hair, she stood before Lord Kåñëa. Çré Kåñëa did not like the sight of this naked woman, and to avoid seeing her, He turned His face. Bäëäsura, getting this chance to escape Kåñëa's attack, left the battlefield. All the strings of his bows were broken, and there was no chariot or driver, so he had no alternative than to return to his city. He lost everything in the battle.

Being greatly harassed by the arrows of Kåñëa, all the associates of Lord Çiva, the hobgoblins and ghostly bhütas, pretas and kñatriyas, left the battlefield. Lord Çiva then took to his last resort. He released his greatest death weapon, known as Çivajvara, which destroys by excessive temperature. It is said that at the end of this creation the sun becomes twelve times more scorching than usual. This twelve-times-hotter temperature is called Çivajvara. When the Çivajvara personified was released, he had three heads and three legs, and as he came toward Kåñëa it appeared that he was burning everything into ashes. He was so powerful that he made blazing fire appear in all directions, and Kåñëa observed that he was specifically coming toward Him.

As there is a Çivajvara weapon, there is also a Näräyaëajvara weapon. Näräyaëajvara is represented by excessive cold. When there is excessive heat, one can somehow or other tolerate it, but when there is excessive cold, everything collapses. This is actually experienced by a person at the time of death. At the time of death, the temperature of the body first of all increases to 107 degrees, and then the whole body collapses and immediately becomes as cold as ice. To counteract the scorching heat of the Çivajvara, there was no other weapon but Näräyaëajvara.

When Lord Kåñëa saw that the Çivajvara had been released by Lord Çiva, He had no other recourse than to release Näräyaëajvara. Lord Çré Kåñëa is the original Näräyaëa and the controller of the Näräyaëajvara weapon. When the Näräyaëajvara was released, there was a great fight between the two jvaras. When excessive heat is counteracted by extreme cold, it is natural for the hot temperature to gradually reduce, and this is what occurred in the fight between Çivajvara and Näräyaëajvara. Gradually, Çivajvara's temperature diminished, and Çivajvara began to cry for help from Lord Çiva, but Lord Çiva was unable to help him in the presence of the Näräyaëajvara. Unable to get any help from Lord Çiva, the Çivajvara could understand that he had no means of escape outside surrendering unto Näräyaëa, Lord Kåñëa Himself. Lord Çiva, the greatest of the demigods, could not help him, what to speak of the lesser demigods, and therefore Çivajvara ultimately surrendered unto Kåñëa, bowing before Him and offering a prayer so that the Lord might be pleased and give him protection.

By this incidence of the fight between the ultimate weapons of Lord Çiva and Lord Kåñëa it is proved that if Kåñëa gives someone protection, no one can kill him. But if Kåñëa does not give one any protection, then no one can save him. Lord Çiva is called Mahädeva, greatest of all demigods, although sometimes Lord Brahmä is considered the greatest of all demigods, because he can create, whereas Lord Çiva can annihilate the creations of Brahmä. But both Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva act only in one capacity. Lord Brahmä can create, and Lord Çiva can annihilate, but neither of them can maintain. Lord Viñëu, however, not only maintains, but He creates, and annihilates also. Factually, the creation is not effected by Brahmä, because Brahmä himself is created by Lord Viñëu. Lord Çiva is created, or born, of Brahmä. The Çivajvara thus understood that without Kåñëa or Näräyaëa, no one could help him. He therefore rightly took shelter of Lord Kåñëa and, with folded hands, began to pray as follows.

"My dear Lord, I offer my respectful obeisances unto You because You have unlimited potencies. No one can surpass Your potencies, and thus You are the Lord of everyone. Generally people consider Lord Çiva to be the most powerful personality in the material world, but Lord Çiva is not all-powerful; You are all-powerful. This is factual. You are the original consciousness or knowledge. Without knowledge or consciousness, nothing can be powerful. A material thing might be very powerful, but without the touch of knowledge or consciousness it cannot act. A material machine may be very gigantic and wonderful, but without the touch of someone conscious and in knowledge, the material machine is useless for all purposes. My Lord, You are complete knowledge, and there is not a pinch of material contamination in Your personality. Lord Çiva may be a powerful demigod because of his specific power to annihilate the whole creation, and similarly, Lord Brahmä may be very powerful because he can create the entire universe, but actually neither Brahmä nor Lord Çiva is the original cause of this cosmic manifestation. You are the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Brahman, and You are the original cause. The original cause of the cosmic manifestation is not the impersonal Brahman effulgence. That impersonal Brahman effulgence is resting on Your personality. As is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.4], the cause of the impersonal Brahman is Lord Kåñëa. This Brahman effulgence is likened to the sunshine which emanates from the sun globe. Therefore, impersonal Brahman is not the ultimate cause. The ultimate cause of everything is the supreme eternal form of Kåñëa. All material actions and reactions are taking place in the impersonal Brahman, but in the personal Brahman, the eternal form of Kåñëa, there is no action and reaction. My Lord, Your body is therefore completely peaceful, completely blissful and is devoid of material contamination.

"In the material body there are actions and reactions of the three modes of material nature. The time factor is the most important element and is above all others, because the material manifestation is effected by time agitation. Thus natural phenomena come into existence, and as soon as there is the appearance of phenomena, fruitive activities are visible. As the result of these fruitive activities, a living entity takes his form. He acquires a particular type of nature which is packed up in a subtle body and gross body formed by the life air, the ego, the ten sense organs, the mind and the five gross elements. These then create the type of body which later becomes the root or cause of various other bodies, which are acquired one after another by the transmigration of the soul. All these phenomenal manifestations are the combined actions of Your material energy. Unaffected by the action and reaction of different elements, You are the cause of this external energy, and because You are transcendental to such compulsions of material energy, You are the supreme tranquility. You are the last word in freedom from material contamination. I am therefore taking shelter at Your lotus feet, giving up all other shelter.

"My dear Lord, Your appearance as the son of Vasudeva in Your role as a human being is one of the pastimes of Your complete freedom. To benefit Your devotees and to vanquish the nondevotees, You appear in multi-incarnations. All such incarnations descend in fulfillment of Your promise in the Bhagavad-gétä that You appear as soon as there are discrepancies in the system of progressive life. When there are disturbances by irregular principles, my dear Lord, You appear by Your internal potency. Your main business is to protect and maintain the demigods and spiritually inclined persons and maintain the standard of material law and order. Simultaneous to the maintenance of such law and order, Your violence to the miscreants and demons is quite befitting. This is not the first time You have incarnated; it is to be understood that You have done so many, many times before.

"My dear Lord, I beg to submit that I have been very greatly chastised by the release of Your Näräyaëajvara. It is certainly very cooling, yet at the same time very severely dangerous and unbearable for all of us. My dear Lord, as long as one is forgetful of Kåñëa consciousness, driven by the spell of material desires and ignorant of the ultimate shelter at Your lotus feet, one who has accepted this material body becomes disturbed by the three miserable conditions of material nature. Because one does not surrender unto You, he therefore continues to suffer perpetually."

After hearing the Çivajvara, Lord Kåñëa replied, "O three-headed one, I am pleased with your statement. Be assured there is no more suffering for you from the Näräyaëajvara. Not only are you now free from fear of Näräyaëajvara, but anyone in the future who simply recollects this fight between Çivajvara and Näräyaëajvara will also be freed from all kinds of fearfulness." After hearing the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Çivajvara offered his respectful obeisances unto His lotus feet and left.

In the meantime Bäëäsura somehow or other recovered from his setbacks and, with rejuvenated energy, returned to fight. This time Bäëäsura appeared before Lord Kåñëa, who was seated on His chariot, with different kinds of weapons in his one thousand hands. Bäëäsura was very much agitated. He began to splash his different weapons, like torrents of rain, upon the body of Lord Kåñëa. When Lord Kåñëa saw the weapons of Bäëäsura coming at Him, like water coming out of a strainer, He took His sharp-edged Sudarçana disc and began to cut off the demon's one thousand hands one after another, just as a gardener trims the twigs of a tree with sharp cutters. When Lord Çiva saw that his devotee Bäëäsura could not be saved even in his presence, he came to his senses and personally came before Lord Kåñëa and began to pacify Him by offering the following prayers.

Lord Çiva said, "My dear Lord, You are the worshipable object of the Vedic hymns. One who does not know You considers the impersonal brahmajyoti to be the ultimate Supreme Absolute Truth, without any knowledge that You are existing behind Your spiritual effulgence in Your eternal abode. My dear Lord, You are therefore called Parambrahman. This word, Parambrahman, has been used in the Bhagavad-gétä to identify You. Saintly persons who have completely cleansed their hearts of all material contamination can realize Your transcendental form, although You are all-pervading like the sky, unaffected by any material thing. Only the devotees can realize You, and no one else. In the impersonalists' conception of Your supreme existence, the sky is just like Your navel, the fire is Your mouth, and the water is Your semina. The heavenly planets are Your head, all the directions are Your ears, the Urvé planet is Your lotus feet, the moon is Your mind, and the sun is Your eye. As far as I am concerned, I act as Your ego. The ocean is Your abdomen, and the King of heaven, Indra, is Your arm. Trees and plants are the hairs of Your body, the cloud is the hair on Your head, and Lord Brahmä is Your intelligence. All the great progenitors, known as Prajäpatis, are Your symbolic representatives. And religion is Your heart. The impersonal feature of Your supreme body is conceived of in this way, but You are ultimately the Supreme Person. The impersonal feature of Your supreme body is only a small expansion of Your energy. You are likened to the original fire, and the expansions are Your light and heat."

Lord Çiva continued: "My dear Lord, although You are manifested universally, different parts of the universe are the different parts of Your body, and by Your inconceivable potency You can simultaneously be both localized and universal. In the Brahma-saàhitä [5.37] we also find it stated that although You always remain in Your abode, Goloka Våndävana, You are nevertheless present everywhere. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, You appear to protect the devotees, which indicates good fortune for all the universe. All of the demigods are directing different affairs of the universe by Your grace only. Thus the seven upper planetary systems are being maintained by Your grace. At the end of this creation, all manifestations of Your energies, whether in the shape of demigods, human beings or lower animals, enter into You, and all immediate and remote causes of cosmic manifestation rest in You without distinctive features of existence. Ultimately, there is no possibility of distinction between Yourself and any other thing on an equal level with You or subordinate to You. You are simultaneously the cause of this cosmic manifestation and its ingredients as well. You are the Supreme Whole, one without a second. In the phenomenal manifestation there are three stages: the stage of consciousness, the stage of semiconsciousness in dreaming, and the stage of unconsciousness. But Your Lordship is transcendental to all these different material stages of existence. You exist, therefore, in a fourth dimension, and Your appearance and disappearance do not depend on anything beyond Yourself. You are the supreme cause of everything, but for Yourself there is no cause. You Yourself cause Your own appearance and disappearance. Despite Your transcendental position, my Lord, in order to show Your six opulences and advertise Your transcendental qualities, You have appeared in Your different incarnations—fish, tortoise, boar, Nåsiàha, Keçava, etc.—by Your personal manifestation; and You have appeared as different living entities by Your separated manifestations. By Your internal potency, You appear as the different incarnations of Viñëu, and by Your external potency You appear as the phenomenal world.

"Because it is a cloudy day to the common man's eyes, the sun appears to be covered. But the fact is that because the sunshine creates the cloud, even though the whole sky is cloudy, the sun can never actually be covered. Similarly, the less intelligent class of men claims that there is no God, but when the manifestation of different living entities and their activities is visible, enlightened persons see You present in every atom and through the via media of Your external and marginal energies. Your unlimited potential activities are experienced by the most enlightened devotees, but those who are bewildered by the spell of Your external energy identify themselves with this material world and become attached to society, friendship and love. Thus they embrace the threefold miseries of material existence and are subjected to the dualities of pain and pleasure. They are sometimes drowned in the ocean of attachment and sometimes taken out of it.

"My dear Lord, only by Your mercy and grace can the living entity get the human form of life, which is a chance to get out of the miserable condition of material existence. However, a person who possesses a human body but who cannot bring the senses under control is carried away by the waves of sensual enjoyment. As such, he cannot take shelter of Your lotus feet and thus engage in Your devotional service. The life of such a person is very unfortunate, and anyone living such a life of darkness is certainly cheating himself and thus cheating others also. Therefore, human society without Kåñëa consciousness is a society of cheaters and the cheated.

"My Lord, You are actually the dearmost Supersoul of all living entities and the supreme controller of everything. The human being who is always illusioned is afraid of ultimate death. A man who is simply attached to sensual enjoyment voluntarily accepts the miserable material existence and thus wanders after the will-o'-the-wisp of sense pleasure. He is certainly the most foolish man, for he drinks poison and puts aside the nectar. My dear Lord, all the demigods, including myself and Lord Brahmä, as well as great saintly persons and sages who have cleansed their hearts of this material attachment, have, by Your grace, wholeheartedly taken shelter of Your lotus feet. We have all taken shelter of You, because we have accepted You as the Supreme Lord and the dearmost life and soul of all of us. You are the original cause of this cosmic manifestation, You are its supreme maintainer, and You are the cause of its dissolution also. You are equal to everyone, the most peaceful supreme friend of every living entity. You are the supreme worshipable object for every one of us. My dear Lord, let us always be engaged in Your transcendental loving service so that we may get free from this material entanglement.

"Lastly, my Lord, I may inform You that this Bäëäsura is very dear to me. He has rendered very valuable service unto me; therefore I want to see him always happy. Being pleased with him, I have given him the assurance of safety. I pray to You, my Lord, that as You were pleased upon his forefathers King Prahläda and Bali Mahäräja, You will also be pleased with him."

After hearing Lord Çiva's prayer, Lord Kåñëa addressed him also as lord and said, "My dear Lord Çiva, I accept your statements, and your desire for Bäëäsura is also accepted by Me. I know that this Bäëäsura is the son of Bali Mahäräja, and as such I cannot kill him because that is My promise. I gave a benediction to King Prahläda that all the demons who would appear in his family would never be killed by Me. Therefore, without killing this Bäëäsura, I have simply cut off his arms to deprive him of his false prestige. The large number of soldiers which he was maintaining became a burden on this earth, and I have killed them all in order to minimize the burden. Now he has four remaining arms, and he will remain immortal, without being affected by the material pains and pleasures. I know that he is one of the chief devotees of your lordship, so you can now rest assured that henceforward he need have no fear from anything."

When Bäëäsura was benedicted by Lord Kåñëa in this way, he came before the Lord and bowed down before Him, touching his head to the earth. He immediately arranged to bring Aniruddha along with his daughter Uñä, seated on a nice chariot, and presented them before Lord Kåñëa. After this, Lord Kåñëa took charge of Aniruddha and Uñä, who had become very opulent materially because of the blessings of Lord Çiva. Thus, keeping forward a division of one akñauhiëé of soldiers, Kåñëa began to proceed toward Dvärakä. In the meantime, all the people at Dvärakä, having received the news that Lord Kåñëa was returning with Aniruddha and Uñä in great opulence, decorated every corner of the city with flags, festoons and garlands. All the big roads and crossings were carefully cleansed and sprinkled with sandalwood pulp mixed with water. Everywhere there was the flavor of sandalwood. All the citizens, accompanied by their friends and relatives, welcomed Lord Kåñëa with great pomp and jubilation. At that time, there was a tumultuous vibration of conchshells and drums and bugles to receive the Lord. In this way the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa entered His capital, Dvärakä.

Çukadeva Gosvämé assured King Parékñit that the narration of the fight between Lord Çiva and Lord Kåñëa is not at all inauspicious like ordinary fights. On the contrary, if one remembers the narration of this fight between Lord Kåñëa and Lord Çiva in the morning and takes pleasure in the victory of Lord Kåñëa, he will never experience defeat anywhere in his struggle of life.

This episode of Bäëäsura's fighting with Kåñëa and later on being saved by the grace of Lord Çiva is confirmation of the statement in the Bhagavad-gétä that the worshipers of demigods cannot achieve any benediction without its being sanctioned by the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. Here, in this narration, we find that although Bäëäsura was a great devotee of Lord Çiva, when he faced death by Kåñëa, Lord Çiva was not able to save him. But Lord Çiva appealed to Kåñëa to save his devotee, and it was thus sanctioned by the Lord. This is the position of Lord Kåñëa. The exact words used in this connection in the Bhagavad-gétä are mayaiva vihitän hi tän. This means that without the sanction of the Supreme Lord, no demigod can award any benediction to the worshiper.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Eighth Chapter, of Kåñëa, Lord Kåñëa Fights with Bäëäsura."

KB 1970-2-9 / The Story of King Någa

9 /The Story of King Någa

Once the family members of Lord Kåñëa, such as Sämba, Pradyumna, Cärubhänu and Gada, all princes of the Yadu dynasty, went for a long picnic in the forest near Dvärakä. In the course of their excursion, all of them became thirsty, and so they began to try to find out where water was available in the forest. When they approached a well, they found that there was no water in it, but on the contrary, within the well was a wonderful living entity. It was a large lizard, and all of them became astonished to see such a wonderful animal. They could understand that the animal was trapped and could not escape by its own effort, so out of compassion they tried to take the large lizard out of the well. Unfortunately, they could not get the lizard out, even though they tried to do so in many ways.

When the princes returned home, their story was narrated before Lord Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa is the friend of all living entities. Therefore, after hearing the appeal from His sons, He personally went to the well and easily got the great lizard out simply by extending His left hand. Immediately upon being touched by the hand of Lord Kåñëa, that great lizard gave up its former shape and appeared as a beautiful demigod, an inhabitant of the heavenly planets. His bodily complexion glittered like molten gold. He was decorated with fine garments, and he wore costly ornaments around his neck.

How the demigod had been obliged to accept the body of a lizard was not a secret to Lord Kåñëa, but still, for others' information, the Lord inquired, "My dear fortunate demigod, now I see that your body is so beautiful and lustrous. Who are you? We can guess that you are one of the best demigods in the heavenly planets. All good fortune to you. I think that you are not meant to be in this situation. It must be due to the results of your past activities that you have been put into the species of lizard life. Still, I want to hear from you how you were put in this position. If you think that you can disclose this secret, then please tell us your identity."

Actually this large lizard was King Någa, and when he was questioned by the Supreme Personality of Godhead he immediately bowed down before the Lord, touching to the ground the helmet on his head, which was as dazzling as the sunshine. In this way, he first of all offered his respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Lord. He then said, "My dear Lord, I am the son of King Ikñväku, and am King Någa. If you have ever taken account of all charitably disposed men, I am sure that You must have heard my name. My Lord, You are the witness. You are aware of every bit of work done by the living entities—past, present and future. Nothing can be hidden from Your eternal cognizance. Still, You have ordered me to explain my history, and I shall therefore narrate the full story."

King Någa proceeded to narrate the history of his degradation, caused by his karma-käëòa activities. He was very charitably disposed and had given away so many cows that he said the number was equal to the amount of dust on the earth, the stars in the sky and the rainfall. According to the Vedic ritualistic ceremonies, a man who is charitably disposed is commanded to give cows to the brähmaëas. From King Någa's statement, it appears that he followed this principle earnestly; however, as a result of a slight discrepancy in his action, he was forced to take birth as a lizard. Therefore it is recommended by the Lord in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.27] that one who is charitably disposed and desires to derive the benefit of his charity should offer his gifts to please Kåñëa. To give in charity means to perform pious activities. As a result of pious activities one may be elevated to the higher planetary systems; but promotion to the heavenly planets is no guarantee that one will never fall down. Rather, from the example of King Någa, it is definitely proved that fruitive activities, even if they are very pious, cannot give us eternal blissful life. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.28], the result of work, either pious or impious, is sure to bind a man unless it is discharged as yajïa on behalf of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

King Någa continued to say that the cows given in charity were not ordinary cows. Each one was very young and had given birth to only one calf. They were full of milk, very peaceful and healthy. All the cows were purchased with money that had been earned legally. Furthermore, their horns were gold-plated, their hooves were bedecked with silver plates, and they were covered with silken wrappers which were embroidered with pearls and necklaces. He stated that these valuably decorated cows were not given to any worthless person, but were distributed to the first-class brähmaëas, whom he had also decorated with nice garments and gold ornaments. The brähmaëas were well qualified, none of them were rich, and their family members were always in want for the necessities of life. A real brähmaëa never hoards money for a luxurious life, like the kñatriyas or the vaiçyas, but always keeps himself in a poverty-stricken condition, knowing that money diverts the mind to materialistic ways of life. To live in this way is the vow of a qualified brähmaëa, and all of these brähmaëas were well situated in that exalted vow. They were well learned in Vedic knowledge. They executed the required austerities and penances in their lives, and were liberal, meeting the standard of qualified brähmaëas. They were equally friendly to everyone; above all, they were young and quite fit to act as qualified brähmaëas. Besides the cows, they were also given land, gold, houses, horses and elephants. Those who were not married were given wives, maidservants, grains, silver, utensils, garments, jewels, household furniture, chariots, etc. This charity was nicely performed as a sacrifice according to the Vedic rituals. The King also stated that not only had he bestowed gifts on the brähmaëas, but he had performed other pious activities, such as digging a well, planting trees on the roadside and installing ponds on the highways.

The King continued, "In spite of all this, unfortunately one of the brähmaëa's cows chanced to enter amongst my other cows. Not knowing this, I again gave it in charity to another brähmaëa. As the cow was being taken away by the brähmaëa, its former master claimed it as his own, stating, 'This cow was formerly given to me, so how is it that you are taking it away?' Thus there was arguing and fighting between the two brähmaëas, and they came before me and charged that I had taken back a cow that I had previously given in charity." To give something to someone and then to take it away is considered a great sin, especially in dealing with a brähmaëa. When both the brähmaëas charged the King with the same complaint, he was simply puzzled as to how it had happened. Thereafter, with great humility, the King offered each of them one hundred thousand cows in exchange for the one cow that was causing the fight between them. He prayed to them that he was their servant and that there had been some mistake. Thus, in order to rectify it, he prayed that they would be very kind upon him and accept his offer in exchange for the cow. The King fervently appealed to the brähmaëas not to cause his downfall into hell because of this mistake. A brähmaëa's property is called brahma-sva, and according to Manu's law, it cannot be acquired even by the government. Both brähmaëas insisted that the cow was theirs and could not be taken back under any condition; neither of them agreed to exchange it for the one hundred thousand cows. Thus disagreeing with the King's proposal, both brähmaëas left the palace in anger, thinking that their lawful position had been usurped.

After this incident, when the time came for the King to give up his body, he was taken before Yamaräja, the superintendent of death. Yamaräja asked him whether he wanted to first enjoy the results of his pious activities or first suffer the results of his impious activities. Yamaräja also hinted that since the King had executed so many pious activities and charities, the limit of Någa's enjoyment would be unknown to him. There was practically no end to the King's material happiness, but in spite of this hint, he was bewildered. He decided to first suffer the results of his impious activities and then to accept the results of his pious activities; therefore Yamaräja immediately turned him into a lizard.

King Någa had remained in a well as a big lizard for a very long time. He told Lord Kåñëa: "In spite of being put into that degraded condition of life, I simply thought of You, my dear Lord, and my memory was never vanquished." It appears from these statements of King Någa that persons who follow the principles of fruitive activities and derive some material benefits are not very intelligent. Being given the choice by the superintendent of death, Yamaräja, King Någa could have first accepted the results of his pious activities. Instead he thought it would be better to first receive the effects of his impious activities and then enjoy the effects of his pious activities without disturbance. On the whole, he had not developed Kåñëa consciousness. The Kåñëa conscious person develops love of God, Kåñëa, not love for pious or impious activities; therefore he is not subjected to the results of such action. As stated in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.54], a devotee, by the grace of the Lord, does not become subjected to the resultant reactions of fruitive activities.

Somehow or other, as a result of his pious activities, King Någa had aspired to see the Lord. He continued to say: "My dear Lord, I had a great desire that someday I might be able to see You personally. I think that my tendency to perform ritualistic and charitable activities, combined with this great desire to see You personally, has enabled me to retain the memory of who I was in my former life, even though I became a lizard." (Such a person, who remembers his past life, is called jäti-smara.) "My dear Lord, You are the Supersoul seated in everyone's heart. There are many great mystic yogés who have eyes to see You through the Vedas and Upaniñads. In order to achieve the elevated position of being equal in quality with You, they always meditate on You within their hearts. Although such exalted saintly persons may see You constantly within their hearts, they still cannot see You eye to eye; therefore I am very much surprised that I am able to see You personally. I know that I was engaged in so many activities, especially as a king. Although I was in the midst of luxury and opulence and was subjected to so much of the happiness and misery of material existence, I am so fortunate to be seeing You personally. As far as I know, when one becomes liberated from material existence, he can see You in this way."

When King Någa elected to receive the results of his impious activities, he was given the body of a lizard because of the mistake in his pious activities; thus he could not be directly converted to a higher status of life like a great demigod. However, along with his pious activities, he thought of Kåñëa, so he was quickly released from the body of a lizard and given the body of a demigod. By worshiping the Supreme Lord, those who desire material opulences are given the bodies of powerful demigods. Sometimes these demigods can see the Supreme Personality of Godhead eye to eye, but they are still not yet eligible to enter into the spiritual kingdom, the Vaikuëöha planets. However, if the demigods continue to become devotees of the Lord, the next chance they get they will enter into the Vaikuëöha planets.

Having attained the body of a demigod, King Någa, continuing to remember everything, said, "My dear Lord, You are the Supreme Lord and are worshiped by all the demigods. You are not one of the living entities, but You are the Supreme Person, Puruñottama. You are the source of all happiness to all living entities; therefore You are known as Govinda. You are the Lord of those living entities who have accepted a material body and those who have not yet accepted a material body." (Among the living entities who have not accepted a material body are those who are hovering in the material world as evil spirits or living in the ghostly atmosphere. However, those who live in the spiritual kingdom, the Vaikuëöhalokas, have bodies that are not made of material elements.) "You are, my Lord, infallible. You are the Supreme, the purest of all living entities. You are living in everyone's heart. You are the shelter of all living entities, Näräyaëa. Being seated in the heart of all living entities, You are the supreme director of everyone's sensual activities; therefore, You are called Håñékeça.

"My dear Supreme Lord Kåñëa, because You have given me this body of a demigod, I will have to go to some heavenly planet; so I am taking this opportunity to beg for Your mercy, that I may have the benediction of never forgetting Your lotus feet, no matter to which form of life or planet I may be transferred. You are all-pervading, present everywhere as cause and effect. You are the cause of all causes, and Your potency and power are unlimited. You are the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the Supreme Brahman. I therefore offer my respectful obeisances unto You again and again. My dear Lord, Your body is full of transcendental bliss and knowledge, and You are eternal. You are the master of all mystic powers; therefore You are known as Yogeçvara. Kindly accept me as insignificant dust at Your lotus feet."

Before entering the heavenly planets, King Någa circumambulated the Lord. He touched his helmet to the lotus feet of the Lord and bowed before Him. Seeing the airplane from the heavenly planets present before him, he was given permission by the Lord to board it. After the departure of King Någa, Lord Kåñëa expressed His appreciation for the King's devotion to the brähmaëas as well as his charitable disposition and his performance of Vedic rituals. Therefore, it is recommended that if one cannot directly become a devotee of the Lord, one should follow the Vedic principles of life. This will enable him, one day, to see the Lord by being promoted either directly to the spiritual kingdom or indirectly to the heavenly kingdom, where he has hope of being transferred to the spiritual planets.

At this time, Lord Kåñëa was present among His relatives who were members of the kñatriya class. To teach them through the exemplary character of King Någa, He said: "Even though a kñatriya king may be as powerful as fire, it is not possible for him to usurp the property of a brähmaëa and utilize it for his own purpose. If this is so, how can ordinary kings, who falsely think of themselves as the most powerful beings within the material world, usurp a brähmaëa's property? I do not think that taking poison is as dangerous as taking a brähmaëa's property. For ordinary poison there is treatment—one can be relieved from its effects; but if one drinks the poison of taking a brähmaëa's property, there is no remedy for the mistake. The perfect example was King Någa. He was very powerful and very pious, but due to the small mistake of unknowingly usurping a brähmaëa's cow, he was condemned to the abominable life of a lizard. Ordinary poison affects only those who drink it, and ordinary fire can be extinguished simply by pouring water on it; but the araëi fire ignited by the spiritual potency of a brähmaëa can burn to ashes the whole family of a person who provokes such a brähmaëa." (Formerly, the brähmaëas used to ignite the fire of sacrifice not with matches or any other external fire but with their powerful mantras, called araëi.) "If someone even touches a brähmaëa's property, he is ruined for three generations. However, if a brähmaëa's property is forcibly taken away, the taker's family for ten generations before him and for ten generations after him will become subject to ruination. On the other hand, if someone becomes a Vaiñëava or devotee of the Lord, ten generations of his family before his birth and ten generations after will become liberated."

Lord Kåñëa continued: "If some foolish king who is puffed up by his wealth, prestige and power wants to usurp a brähmaëa's property, it should be understood that such a king is clearing his path to hell; he does not know how much he has to suffer for such unwise action. If someone takes away the property of a very liberal brähmaëa who is encumbered by a large dependent family, then such a usurper is put into the hell known as Kumbhépäka; not only is he put into this hell, but his family members also have to accept such a miserable condition of life. A person who takes away property which has either been awarded to a brähmaëa or given away by him is condemned to live for at least 60,000 years as miserably as an insect in stool. Therefore I instruct you, all My boys and relatives present here, do not, even by mistake, take the possession of a brähmaëa and thereby pollute Your whole family. If someone even wishes to possess such property, let alone attempts to take it away by force, the duration of his life will be reduced. He will be defeated by his enemies, and after being bereft of his royal position, when he gives up his body he will become a serpent. A serpent gives trouble to all other living entities. My dear boys and relatives, I therefore advise you that even if a brähmaëa becomes angry with you and calls you by ill names or cuts you, still you should not retaliate. On the contrary, you should smile, tolerate him and offer your respects to the brähmaëa. You know very well that even I Myself offer My obeisances to the brähmaëas with great respect three times daily. You should therefore follow My instruction and example. I shall not forgive anyone who does not follow them, and I shall punish him. You should learn from the example of King Någa that even if someone unknowingly usurps the property of a brähmaëa, he is put into a miserable condition of life."

Thus Lord Kåñëa, who is always engaged in purifying the conditioned living entities, gave instruction not only to His family members and the inhabitants of Dvärakä, but to all the members of human society. After this the Lord entered His palace.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Ninth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Story of King Någa."

KB 1970-2-10 / Lord Balaräma Visits Våndävana

10 /Lord Balaräma Visits Våndävana

Lord Balaräma became very anxious to see His father and mother, Mahäräja Nanda and Yaçodä. Therefore He started for Våndävana on a chariot with great enthusiasm. The inhabitants of Våndävana had been anxious to see Kåñëa and Balaräma for a very long time. When Lord Balaräma returned to Våndävana, all the cowherd boys and the gopés had grown up; but still, on His arrival, they all embraced Him, and Balaräma embraced them in reciprocation. After this He came before Mahäräja Nanda and Yaçodä and offered His respectful obeisances unto them. In response, mother Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja offered their blessings unto Him. They addressed Him as Jagadéçvara, or the Lord of the universe who maintains everyone. The reason for this was that both Kåñëa and Balaräma maintain all living entities, and yet Nanda and Yaçodä were put into such difficulties on account of Their absence. Feeling like this, they embraced Balaräma and, seating Him on their laps, began their perpetual crying, wetting Balaräma with their tears. Lord Balaräma then offered His respectful obeisances to the elderly cowherd men and accepted the obeisances of the younger cowherd men. Thus, according to their different ages and relationships, Lord Balaräma exchanged feelings of friendship with them. He shook hands with those who were His equals in age and friendship, and with loud laughing embraced each one of them.

After being received by the cowherd men and boys, the gopés, and King Nanda and Yaçodä, Lord Balaräma sat down, feeling satisfied, and they all surrounded Him. First Lord Balaräma inquired from them about their welfare, and then, not having seen Him for such a long time, they began to ask Him different questions. The inhabitants of Våndävana had sacrificed everything for Kåñëa, simply being captivated by the lotus eyes of the Lord. Because of their great desire to love Kåñëa, they never desired anything like elevation to the heavenly planets or merging into the effulgence of Brahman to become one with the Absolute Truth. They were not even interested in enjoying a life of opulence, but were satisfied in living a simple life in the village as cowherd men. They were always absorbed in thoughts of Kåñëa and did not desire any personal benefits, and they were all so much in love with Him that in His absence their voices faltered when they began to inquire from Balarämajé.

First Nanda Mahäräja and Yaçodämayé inquired, "My dear Balaräma, are our friends like Vasudeva and others in the family doing well? Now You and Kåñëa are grown-up married men with children. In the happiness of family life, do You sometimes remember Your poor father and mother, Nanda Mahäräja and Yaçodädevé? It is very good news that the most sinful King Kaàsa has been killed by You and that our friends like Vasudeva and the others, who had been harrassed by him, have now been relieved. It is also very good news that both You and Kåñëa defeated Jaräsandha and Kälayavana, who now is dead, and that You are now living in a fortified residence in Dvärakä."

When the gopés arrived, Lord Balaräma glanced over them with loving eyes. Being overjoyed, the gopés, who had so long been mortified on account of Kåñëa's and Balaräma's absence, began to ask about the welfare of the two brothers. They specifically asked Balaräma whether Kåñëa was enjoying His life surrounded by the enlightened women of Dvärakä Puré. "Does He sometimes remember His father Nanda and His mother Yaçodä and the other friends with whom He so intimately behaved while He was in Våndävana? Does Kåñëa have any plans to come here to see His mother Yaçodä, and does He remember us gopés who are now pitiably bereft of His company? Kåñëa might have forgotten us in the midst of the cultured women of Dvärakä, but as far as we are concerned, we are still remembering Him by collecting flowers and sewing them into garlands. When He does not come, however, we simply pass our time by crying. If only He would come here and accept these garlands that we have made. Dear Lord Balaräma, descendant of Daçärha, You know that we would give up everything for Kåñëa's friendship. Even in great distress one cannot give up the connection of family members, but although it might be impossible for others, we gave up our fathers, mothers, sisters and relatives without caring at all about our renunciation. Then, all of a sudden, Kåñëa renounced us and went away. He broke off our intimate relationship without any serious consideration and left for a foreign country. But He was so clever and cunning that He manufactured very nice words. He said, 'My dear gopés, please do not worry. The service that you have rendered Me is impossible for Me to repay.' After all, we are women, so how could we disbelieve Him? Now we can understand that His sweet words were simply for cheating us."

Another gopé, protesting Kåñëa's absence from Våndävana, began to say: "My dear Balarämajé, we are of course village girls, so Kåñëa could cheat us in that way, but what about the women of Dvärakä? Don't think they are as foolish as we are! We village women might be misled by Kåñëa, but the women in the city of Dvärakä are very clever and intelligent. Therefore I would be surprised if such city women could be misled by Kåñëa and could believe His words."

Then another gopé began to speak. "My dear friend," she said, "Kåñëa is very clever in using words. No one can compete with Him in that art. He can manufacture such colorful words and talk so sweetly that the heart of any woman would be misled. Besides that, He has perfected the art of smiling very attractively, and by seeing His smile women become mad after Him and would give themselves to Him without any hesitation."

Another gopé, after hearing this, said, "My dear friends, what is the use in talking about Kåñëa? If you are at all interested in passing away time by talking, let us talk on some subject other than Him. If cruel Kåñëa can pass His time without us, why can't we pass our time without Kåñëa? Of course, Kåñëa is passing His days very happily without us, but the difference is that we cannot pass our days very happily without Him."

When the gopés were talking in this way, their feelings for Kåñëa became more and more intensified, and they were experiencing Kåñëa's smiling, Kåñëa's words of love, Kåñëa's attractive features, Kåñëa's characteristics and Kåñëa's embraces. By the force of their ecstatic feelings, it appeared to them that Kåñëa was personally present and dancing before them. Because of their sweet remembrance of Kåñëa, they could not check their tears, and they began to cry without consideration.

Lord Balaräma could, of course, understand the ecstatic feelings of the gopés, and therefore He wanted to pacify them. He was expert in presenting an appeal, and thus, treating the gopés very respectfully, He began to narrate the stories of Kåñëa so tactfully that the gopés became satisfied. In order to keep the gopés in Våndävana satisfied, Lord Balaräma stayed there continually for two months, namely the months of Caitra (March-April) and Vaiçäkha (April-May). For those two months He kept Himself among the gopés, and He passed every night with them in the forest of Våndävana in order to satisfy their desire for conjugal love. Thus Balaräma also enjoyed the räsa dance with the gopés during those two months. Since the season was springtime, the breeze on the bank of the Yamunä was blowing very mildly, carrying the aroma of different flowers, especially of the flower known as kaumudé. Moonlight filled the sky and spread everywhere, and thus the banks of the Yamunä appeared to be very bright and pleasing, and Lord Balaräma enjoyed the company of the gopés there.

The demigod known as Varuëa sent his daughter Väruëé in the form of liquid honey oozing from the hollows of the trees. Because of this honey the whole forest became aromatic, and the sweet aroma of the liquid honey, Väruëé, captivated Balarämajé. Balarämajé and all the gopés became very much attracted by the taste of Väruëé, and all of them drank it together. While drinking this natural beverage, Väruëé, all the gopés chanted the glories of Lord Balaräma, and Lord Balaräma felt very happy, as if He had become intoxicated by drinking that Väruëé beverage. His eyes rolled in a pleasing attitude. He was decorated with long garlands of forest flowers, and the whole situation appeared to be a great function of happiness because of this transcendental bliss. Lord Balaräma smiled beautifully, and the drops of perspiration decorating His face appeared to be soothing morning dew.

While Balaräma was in that happy mood, He desired to enjoy the company of the gopés in the water of the Yamunä. Therefore He called Yamunä to come nearby. But Yamunä neglected the order of Balarämajé, considering Him to be intoxicated. Lord Balaräma became very much displeased at Yamunä's neglecting His order. He immediately wanted to scratch the land near the river with His plowshare. Lord Balaräma has two weapons, a plow and a club, and He takes service from them when they are required. This time He wanted to bring the Yamunä by force, and He took the help of His plow. He wanted to punish Yamunä because she did not come in obedience to His order. He addressed Yamunä: "You wretched river! You did not care for My order. Now I shall teach you a lesson! You did not come to Me voluntarily. Now with the help of My plow I shall force you to come. I shall divide you into hundreds of scattered streams!"

When Yamunä was threatened like this, she became greatly afraid of the power of Balaräma and immediately came in person, falling at His lotus feet and praying thus: "My dear Balaräma, You are the most powerful personality, and You are pleasing to everyone. Unfortunately, I forgot Your glorious, exalted position, but now I have come to my senses, and I remember that You hold all the planetary systems on Your head merely by Your partial expansion as Çeña. You are the sustainer of the whole universe. My dear Supreme Personality of Godhead, You are full of six opulences. Because I forgot Your omnipotence, I have mistakenly disobeyed Your order, and thus I have become a great offender. But, my dear Lord, please know that I am a surrendered soul unto You. You are very much affectionate to Your devotees. Therefore please excuse my impudence and mistakes and, by Your causeless mercy, may You now release me."

Upon displaying this submissive attitude, Yamunä was forgiven, and when she came nearby, Lord Balaräma wanted to enjoy the pleasure of swimming within her water along with the gopés in the same way an elephant enjoys himself along with his many she-elephants. After a long time, when Lord Balaräma had enjoyed to His full satisfaction, He came out of the water, and immediately a goddess of fortune offered Him a nice blue garment and a valuable necklace made of gold. After taking bath in the Yamunä, Lord Balaräma, dressed in blue garments and decorated with golden ornaments, looked very attractive to everyone. Lord Balaräma's complexion is white, and when He was properly dressed He looked exactly like the white elephant of King Indra in the heavenly planet. The River Yamunä still has many small branches due to being scratched by the plowshare of Lord Balaräma. And all these branches of the River Yamunä are still glorifying the omnipotency of Lord Balaräma.

Lord Balaräma and the gopés enjoyed transcendental pastimes together every night for two months, and time passed away so quickly that all those nights appeared to be only one night. In the presence of Lord Balaräma, all the gopés and inhabitants of Våndävana became as cheerful as they had been before in the presence of both brothers, Lord Kåñëa and Lord Balaräma.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Tenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Lord Balaräma Visits Våndävana."

KB 1970-2-11 / Deliverance of Pauëòraka and the King of Käçé

11 /Deliverance of Pauëòraka and the King of Käçé

The story of King Pauëòraka is very interesting because there have always been many rascals and fools who have considered themselves to be God. Even in the presence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, there was such a foolish person. His name was Pauëòraka, and He wanted to declare himself to be God. While Lord Balaräma was absent in Våndävana, this King Pauëòraka, the King of the Karüña province, being foolish and puffed up, sent a messenger to Lord Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa is accepted as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and King Pauëòraka directly challenged Kåñëa through the messenger, who stated that Pauëòraka, and not Kåñëa, was Väsudeva. In the present day there are many foolish followers of such rascals. Similarly, in his day, many foolish men accepted Pauëòraka as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Because he could not estimate his own position, Pauëòraka falsely thought himself to be Lord Väsudeva. Thus the messenger declared to Kåñëa that out of his causeless mercy, King Pauëòraka, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, had descended on the earth just to deliver all distressed persons.

Surrounded by many other foolish persons, this rascal Pauëòraka had actually concluded that he was Väsudeva, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This kind of conclusion is certainly childish. When children are playing, they sometimes create a king amongst themselves, and the child who is so selected thinks that he is the king. Similarly, many foolish persons, due to ignorance, select another fool as God, and then the rascal considers himself God, as if God could be created by childish play or by the votes of men. Under this false impression, thinking himself the Supreme Lord, Pauëòraka sent his messenger to Dvärakä to challenge the position of Kåñëa. The messenger reached the royal assembly of Kåñëa in Dvärakä and conveyed the message given by his master, Pauëòraka. The message contained the following statements.

"I am the only Supreme Personality of Godhead, Väsudeva. There is no man who can compete with me. I have descended as King Pauëòraka, taking compassion on the distressed conditioned souls out of my unlimited causeless mercy. You have falsely taken the position of Väsudeva without authority, but you should not propagate this false idea. You must give up Your position. O descendant of the Yadu dynasty, please give up all the symbols of Väsudeva which You have falsely assumed. And after giving up this position, come and surrender unto me. If out of Your gross impudence You do not care for my words, then I challenge You to fight. I am inviting You to a battle in which the decision will be settled."

When all the members of the royal assembly, including King Ugrasena, heard this message sent by Pauëòraka, they laughed very loudly for a considerable time. After enjoying the loud laughter of all the members of the assembly, Kåñëa replied to the messenger as follows. "O messenger of Pauëòraka, you may carry My message to your master: He is a foolish rascal. I directly call him a rascal, and I refuse to follow his instructions. I shall never give up the symbols of Väsudeva, especially My disc. I shall use this disc to kill not only King Pauëòraka but all his followers also. I shall destroy this Pauëòraka and his foolish associates, who merely constitute a society of cheaters and cheated. When this action is taken, foolish King, you will have to conceal your face in disgrace, and when your head is severed from your body by My disc, it will be surrounded by meat-eating birds like vultures, hawks and eagles. At that time, instead of becoming My shelter as you have demanded, you will be subjected to the mercy of these low-born birds. At that time your body will be thrown to the dogs, who will eat it with great pleasure."

The messenger carried the words of Lord Kåñëa to his master, Pauëòraka, who patiently heard all these insults. Without waiting longer, Lord Çré Kåñëa immediately started out on His chariot to punish the rascal Pauëòraka. Because at that time the King of Karüña was living with his friend the King of Käçé, Kåñëa surrounded the whole city of Käçé.

King Pauëòraka was a great warrior, and as soon as he heard of Kåñëa's attack, he came out of the city along with two akñauhiëé divisions of soldiers. The King of Käçé was also a friend to King Pauëòraka, and he came out with three akñauhiëé divisions. When the two kings came before Lord Kåñëa to oppose Him, Kåñëa saw Pauëòraka face to face for the first time. Kåñëa saw that Pauëòraka had decorated himself with the symbols of the conchshell, disc, lotus and club. He carried the Çärìga bow, and on his chest was the insignia of Çrévatsa. His neck was decorated with a false Kaustubha jewel, and he wore a flower garland in exact imitation of Lord Väsudeva. He was dressed in yellow colored silken garments, and the flag on his chariot carried the symbol of Garuòa, exactly imitating Kåñëa's. He had a very valuable helmet on his head, and his earrings, like swordfish, glittered brilliantly. On the whole, however, his dress and makeup were clearly imitation. Anyone could understand that he was just like someone onstage playing the part of Väsudeva in false dress. When Lord Çré Kåñëa saw Pauëòraka imitating His posture and dress, He could not check His laughter, and thus He laughed with great satisfaction.

The soldiers on the side of King Pauëòraka began to shower their weapons upon Kåñëa. The weapons, including various kinds of tridents, clubs, poles, lances, swords, daggers and arrows, came flying in waves, and Kåñëa counteracted them. He smashed not only the weapons but also the soldiers and assistants of Pauëòraka, just as during the dissolution of this universe the fire of devastation burns everything to ashes. The elephants, chariots, horses, and infantry belonging to the opposite party were scattered by the weapons of Kåñëa. The whole battlefield became scattered with the bodies of animals and chariots. There were fallen horses, elephants, men, asses and camels. Although the devastated battlefield appeared like the dancing place of Lord Çiva at the time of the dissolution of the world, the warriors who were on the side of Kåñëa were very much encouraged by seeing this, and they fought with greater strength.

At this time, Lord Kåñëa told Pauëòraka, "Pauëòraka, you requested Me to give up the symbols of Lord Viñëu, specifically My disc. Now I will give it up to you. Be careful! You falsely declare yourself to be Vasudeva, imitating Myself. Therefore no one is a greater fool than you." From this statement of Kåñëa's it is clear that any rascal who advertises himself as God is the greatest fool in human society. Kåñëa continued: "Now, Pauëòraka, I shall force you to give up this false representation. You wanted Me to surrender unto you. Now this is your opportunity. We shall now fight, and if I am defeated and you become victorious, I shall certainly surrender unto you." In this way, after chastising Pauëòraka very severely, He smashed his chariot to pieces by shooting an arrow. With the help of His disc He separated the head of Pauëòraka from his body, just as Indra shaves off the peaks of mountains by striking them with his thunderbolt. Similarly, He also killed the King of Käçé with His arrows. Lord Kåñëa specifically arranged to throw the head of the King of Käçé into the city of Käçé itself so that his relatives and family members could see it. This was done by Kåñëa just as a hurricane carries a lotus petal here and there. Lord Kåñëa killed Pauëòraka and his friend Käçéräja on the battlefield, and then He returned to His capital city, Dvärakä.

When Lord Kåñëa returned to the city of Dvärakä, all the Siddhas from the heavenly planets were singing the glories of the Lord. As far as Pauëòraka was concerned, somehow or other he was always thinking of Lord Väsudeva by falsely dressing himself in that way, and therefore Pauëòraka achieved särüpya, one of the five kinds of liberation, and was thus promoted to the Vaikuëöha planets, where the devotees have the same bodily features as Viñëu, with four hands holding the four symbols. Factually, his meditation was concentrated on the Viñëu form, but because he thought himself to be Lord Viñëu, it was offensive. After being killed by Kåñëa, however, that offense was also mitigated. Thus he was given särüpya liberation, and he attained the same form as the Lord.

When the head of the King of Käçé was thrown through the city gate, people gathered and were astonished to see that wonderful thing. When they found out that there were earrings on it, they could understand that it was someone's head. They conjectured as to whose head it might be. Some thought it was Kåñëa's head because Kåñëa was the enemy of Käçéräja, and they calculated that the King of Käçé might have thrown Kåñëa's head into the city so that the people might take pleasure that the enemy was killed. But it was finally detected that the head was not Kåñëa's, but that of Käçéräja himself. When it was so ascertained, the queens of the King of Käçé immediately approached and began to lament the death of their husband. "My dear lord," they cried, "upon your death, we have become just like dead bodies."

The King of Käçé had one son whose name was Sudakñiëa. After observing the ritualistic funeral ceremonies, he took a vow that since Kåñëa was the enemy of his father, he would kill Kåñëa and in this way liquidate his debts to his father. Therefore, accompanied by a learned priest qualified to help him, he began to worship Mahädeva, Lord Çiva. The lord of the kingdom of Käçé is Viçvanätha (Lord Çiva). The temple of Lord Viçvanätha is still existing in Väräëasé, and many thousands of pilgrims still gather daily in that temple. By the worship of Sudakñiëa, Lord Çiva was very much pleased, and he wanted to give a benediction to his devotee. Sudakñiëa's purpose was to kill Kåñëa, and therefore he prayed for a specific power by which he could kill Him. Lord Çiva advised that Sudakñiëa, assisted by the brähmaëas, execute the ritualistic ceremony for killing one's enemy. This ceremony is also mentioned in some of the Tantras. Lord Çiva informed Sudakñiëa that if such a black ritualistic ceremony were performed properly then the evil spirit named Dakñiëägni would appear to carry out any order given to him. He would have to be employed, however, to kill someone other than a qualified brähmaëa. In such a case he would be accompanied by Lord Çiva's ghostly companions, and the desire of Sudakñiëa to kill his enemy would be fulfilled.

When Sudakñiëa was encouraged by Lord Çiva in that way, he became assured that he would be able to kill Kåñëa. With a determined vow of austerity, he began to execute the black art of chanting mantras, assisted by the priests. After this, out of the fire came a great demonic form, whose hair, beard and moustache were exactly the color of hot copper. This form was very big and fierce. As the demon arose from the fire, cinders of fire emanated from the sockets of his eyes. The giant fiery demon appeared still more fierce due to the movements of his eyebrows. He exhibited long sharp teeth and, sticking out his long tongue, licked both sides of his lips. He was naked, and he carried a big trident, which was blazing like fire. After appearing from the fire of sacrifice, he stood wielding the trident in his hand. Instigated by Sudakñiëa, the demon proceeded toward the capital city, Dvärakä, along with many hundreds of ghostly companions, and it appeared that he was going to burn all outer space to ashes. The surface of the earth trembled because of his striking steps. When he entered the city of Dvärakä, all the residents panicked, just like animals at the time of a forest fire.

At that time Kåñëa was engaged in playing chess in the royal assembly council hall. All the residents of Dvärakä approached and addressed Him, "Dear Lord of the three worlds, there is a great fiery demon ready to burn the whole city of Dvärakä. Please save us." Thus, after approaching Lord Kåñëa, all the inhabitants of Dvärakä began to appeal to Him for protection from the fiery demon who had just appeared in Dvärakä to devastate the whole city.

Lord Kåñëa, who specifically protects His devotees, saw that the whole population of Dvärakä was most perturbed by the presence of the great fiery demon. He immediately began to smile and assured them, "Don't worry. I shall give you all protection." The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is all-pervading. He is within everyone's heart, and He is without also in the form of the cosmic manifestation. He could understand that the fiery demon was a creation of Lord Çiva, and in order to vanquish him He took His Sudarçana-cakra and ordered him to take the necessary steps. The Sudarçana-cakra appeared with the effulgence of millions of suns, his temperature being as powerful as that of the fire created at the end of the cosmic manifestation. By his own effulgence, the Sudarçana-cakra began to illuminate the entire universe, on the surface of the earth as well as in outer space. Then the Sudarçana-cakra began to freeze the fiery demon created by Lord Çiva. In this way, the fiery demon was checked by the Sudarçana-cakra of Lord Kåñëa, and being defeated in his attempt to devastate the city of Dvärakä, he turned back.

Having failed to set fire to Dvärakä, he went back to Väräëasé, the kingdom of Käçéräja. As a result of his return, all the priests who had helped instruct the black art of mantras, along with their employer, Sudakñiëa were burned into ashes by the glaring effulgence of the fiery demon. According to the methods of black art mantras instructed in the Tantra, if the mantra fails to kill the enemy, then, because it must kill someone, it kills the original creator. Sudakñiëa was the originator, and the priests assisted him; therefore all of them were burned to ashes. This is the way of the demons: the demons create something to kill God, but by the same weapon the demons themselves are killed.

Following just behind the fiery demon, the Sudarçana-cakra also entered Väräëasé. This city of Väräëasé had been very opulent and great for a very long time. Even now, the city of Väräëasé is very opulent and famous, and it is one of the important cities of India. There were then many big palaces, assembly houses, marketplaces and gates, with very important large monuments by the palaces and gates. Lecturing platforms could be found at each and every crossing of the roads. There was a treasury house, and elephant heads, horse heads, chariots, granaries and places for distribution of foodstuff. The city of Väräëasé had been filled with all these material opulences for a very long time, but because the king of Käçé and his son Sudakñiëa were against Lord Kåñëa, the Viñëu-cakra Sudarçana (the disc weapon of Lord Kåñëa) devastated the whole city by burning all these important places. This excursion was more ravaging than modern bombing. The Sudarçana-cakra, having thus finished his duty, came back to his Lord Çré Kåñëa at Dvärakä.

This narration of the devastation of Väräëasé by Kåñëa's disc weapon, the Sudarçana-cakra, is transcendental and auspicious. Anyone who narrates this story or anyone who hears this story with faith and attention will be released from all reaction to sinful activities. This is the assurance of Çukadeva Gosvämé who narrated this story to Parékñit Mahäräja.

Thus ends the Second Volume, Eleventh Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Deliverance of Pauëòraka and the King of Käçé."

KB 1970-2-12 / The Deliverance of Dvivida Gorilla

12 /The Deliverance of Dvivida Gorilla

While Çukadeva Gosvämé continued to speak on the transcendental pastimes and characteristics of Lord Kåñëa, King Parékñit, upon hearing him, became more and more enthusiastic and wanted to hear further. Çukadeva Gosvämé next narrated the story of Dvivida, the gorilla who was killed by Lord Balaräma.

This gorilla was a great friend of Baumäsura's or Narakäsura's, who was killed by Kåñëa in connection with his kidnapping sixteen thousand princesses from all over the world. Dvivida was the minister of King Sugréva. His brother, Mainda, was also a very powerful gorilla king. When Dvivida gorilla heard the story of his friend Baumäsura's being killed by Lord Kåñëa, he planned to create mischief throughout the country in order to avenge the death of Baumäsura. His first business was to set fires in villages, towns, and industrial and mining places, as well as the residential quarters of the mercantile men who were busy dairy farming and protecting cows. Sometimes he would uproot a big mountain and tear it to pieces. In this way he created great disturbances all over the country, especially in the province of Kathwar. The city of Dvärakä was situated in this Kathwar province, and because Lord Kåñëa used to live in this city, Dvivida specifically made it his target of disturbance.

Dvivida was as powerful as 10,000 elephants. Sometimes he would go to the seashore, and with his powerful hands he would create so much disturbance in the sea that he would overflood the neighboring cities and villages. Often he would go to the hermitages of great saintly persons and sages and cause a great disturbance by smashing their beautiful gardens and orchards. Not only did he create disturbances in that way, but sometimes he would pass urine and stool on their sacred sacrificial arena. He would thus pollute the whole atmosphere. He also kidnapped both men and women, taking them away from their residential places to the caves of the mountains. Putting them within the caves, he would close the entrances with large chunks of stone, like the bhåìgé insect, which arrests and carries away many flies and other insects and puts them within the holes of the trees where he lives. He thus regularly defied the law and order of the country. Not only that, but he would sometimes pollute the female members of many aristocratic families by forcibly raping them.

While creating such great disturbance all over the country, sometimes he heard very sweet musical sounds from the Raivataka mountain, and so he entered that mountainous region. There he saw that Lord Balaräma was present in the midst of many beautiful young girls, enjoying their company while engaged in singing and dancing. He became captivated by the beautiful features of Lord Balaräma's body, each and every part of which was very beautiful, decorated as He was with a garland of lotus flowers. Similarly, all the young girls present, dressed and garlanded with flowers, exhibited much beauty. Lord Balaräma seemed to be fully intoxicated from drinking the Väruëé beverage, and His eyes appeared to be rolling in a drunken state. Lord Balaräma appeared just like the king of the elephants in the midst of many she-elephants.

This gorilla by the name of Dvivida could climb up on the trees and jump from one branch to another. Sometimes he would jerk the branches, creating a particular type of sound, "Kila, kila," so that Lord Balaräma was greatly distracted from the pleasing atmosphere. Sometimes Dvivida would come before the women and exhibit different types of caricatures. By nature young women are apt to enjoy everything with laughter and joking, and when the gorilla came before them they did not take him seriously, but simply laughed at him. However, the gorilla was so rude that even in the presence of Balaräma he began to show the lower part of his body to the women, and sometimes he would come forward to show his teeth while moving his eyebrows. He disrespected the women, even in the presence of Balaräma. Lord Balaräma's name suggests that He is not only very powerful, but that He takes pleasure in exhibiting extraordinary strength. So He took a stone and threw it at Dvivida. The gorilla, however, artfully avoided being struck by the stone. In order to insult Balaräma, the gorilla took away the earthen pot in which the Väruëé was kept. Dvivida, being thus intoxicated, with his limited strength began to tear off all the valuable clothes worn by Balaräma and the accompanying young girls. He was so puffed up that he thought that Balaräma could not do anything to chastise him, and he continued to offend Balarämajé and His companions.

When Lord Balaräma personally saw the disturbances created by the gorilla and heard that he had already performed many mischievous activities all over the country, He became very angry and decided to kill him. Immediately He took His club in His hands. The gorilla could understand that now Balaräma was going to attack him. In order to counteract Balaräma, he immediately uprooted a big oak tree, and with great force he came and struck at Lord Balaräma's head. Lord Balaräma, however, immediately caught hold of the big tree and remained undisturbed, just like a great mountain. To retaliate, He took His club by the name of Sunanda and began to hit the gorilla with it. The gorilla's head was severely injured. Currents of blood flowed from his head with great force, but the stream of blood enhanced his beauty like a stream of liquid manganese coming out of a great mountain. The striking of Balaräma's club did not even slightly disturb him. On the contrary, he immediately uprooted another big oak tree, and after clipping off all its leaves, he began to strike Balaräma's head with it. But Balaräma, with the help of His club, tore the tree to pieces. Since the gorilla was very angry, he took another tree in his hands and began to strike Lord Balaräma's body. Again Lord Balaräma tore the tree to pieces, and the fighting continued. Each time the gorilla would bring out a big tree to strike Balaräma, Lord Balaräma would tear the tree to pieces by the striking of His club. The gorilla Dvivida would clutch another tree from another direction and again attack Balaräma in the same way. As a result of this continuous fighting, the forest became treeless. When no more trees were available, Dvivida took help from the hills and threw large pieces of stone, like rainfall, upon the body of Balaräma. Lord Balaräma, also in a great sporting mood, began to smash those big pieces of stone into mere pebbles. The gorilla, being bereft of all trees and stone slabs, now stood before Him and waved his strong fists. Then, with great force, he began to beat the chest of Lord Balaräma with his fists. This time Lord Balaräma became most angry. Since the gorilla was striking Him with his hands, He would not strike him back with His own weapons, the club or the plow. Simply with His fist He began to strike the collarbone of the gorilla. This striking proved to be fatal to Dvivida, who immediately vomited blood and fell unconscious upon the ground. When the gorilla fell, it appeared that all the hills and forests tottered.

After this horrible incident, all the Siddhas, great sages and saintly persons from the upper planetary system began to shower flowers on the person of Lord Balaräma, and sounds glorifying the supremacy of Lord Balaräma were vibrated. All of them began to chant, "All glories to Lord Balaräma! Let us offer our respectful obeisances unto Your lotus feet. By Your killing this great demon, Dvivida, You have initiated an auspicious era for the world." All such jubilant sounds of victory were heard from outer space. After killing the great demon Dvivida and being worshiped by showers of flowers and glorious sounds of victory, Balaräma returned to His capital city, Dvärakä.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twelfth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Deliverance of Dvivida Gorilla."

KB 1970-2-13 / The Marriage of Sämba

13 /The Marriage of Sämba

Duryodhana, the son of Dhåtaräñöra, had a marriageable daughter by the name of Lakñmaëä. She was a very highly qualified girl of the Kuru dynasty, and many princes wanted to marry her. In such cases, the svayaàvara ceremony is held so that the girl may select her husband according to her own choice. In Lakñmaëä's svayaàvara assembly, when the girl was to select her husband, Sämba appeared. He was the son of Kåñëa by Jämbavaté, one of the chief wives of Lord Kåñëa. This son Sämba is so named because he was a very bad child, and he always lived close to his mother. The name Sämba indicates a son who is very much his mother's pet. Ambä means mother, and sa means with. So this special name was given to him because he always remained with his mother. He was also known as Jämbavatésuta for the same reason. As previously explained, all the sons of Kåñëa were as qualified as their great father, Lord Kåñëa. Sämba wanted the daughter of Duryodhana, Lakñmaëä, although she was not inclined to have him. Therefore Sämba kidnapped Lakñmaëä by force from the svayaàvara assembly.

Because Sämba took Lakñmaëä away from the assembly by force, all the members of the Kuru dynasty, namely, Dhåtaräñöra, Bhéñma, Vidura, Ujahan and Arjuna, thought it an insult to their family tradition that the boy, Sämba, could possibly have kidnapped their daughter. All of them knew that Lakñmaëä was not at all inclined to select him as a husband and that she was not given the chance to select her own husband; instead she was forcibly taken away by this boy. Therefore, they decided that he must be punished. They unanimously declared that he was most impudent and that he had degraded the Kurus' family tradition. Therefore, all of them, under the counsel of the elderly members of the Kuru family, decided to arrest the boy but not kill him. They concluded that the girl could not be married to any boy other than Sämba since she had already been touched by him. (According to the Vedic system, once being used by some boy, a girl cannot be married or given to any other boy. Nor would anyone agree to marry a girl who had already thus associated with another boy.) The elderly members of the family, such as Bhéñma, wanted to arrest him. All the members of the Kuru dynasty, especially the great fighters, joined together just to teach him a lesson, and Karëa was made the commander-in-chief for this small battle.

While the plan was being made to arrest Sämba, the Kurus counciled amongst themselves that upon his arrest, the members of the Yadu dynasty would be very angry with them. There was every possibility of the Yadus' accepting the challenge and fighting with them. But they also thought, "If they came here to fight with us, what could they do? The members of the Yadu dynasty cannot equal the members of the Kuru dynasty because the kings of the Kuru dynasty are the emperors, whereas the kings of the Yadu dynasty are able to enjoy their landed property." The Kurus thought, "If they come here to challenge us because their son was arrested, we will nevertheless accept the fight. All of us will teach them a lesson, so that automatically they will become subdued under pressure, as the senses are subdued by the mystic yoga process, präëäyäma." (In the mechanical system of mystic yoga, the airs within the body are controlled, and the senses are subdued and checked from being engaged in anything other than meditation upon Lord Viñëu.)

After consultation and after receiving permission from the elderly members of the Kuru dynasty, such as Bhéñma and Dhåtaräñöra, six great warriors—Karëa, Çala, Bhurisrava, Yajïaketu, and Duryodhana, the father of the girl—all mahä-rathés and guided by the great fighter Bhéñmadeva, attempted to arrest the boy Sämba. There are different grades of fighters, including mahä-rathé, eka-rathé, and rathé, classified according to their fighting capacity. These mahä-rathés could fight alone with many thousands of men. All of them combined together to arrest Sämba. Sämba was also a mahä-rathé, but he was alone and had to fight with the six other mahä-rathés. Still he was not deterred when he saw all the great fighters of the Kuru dynasty coming up behind him to arrest him.

Alone, he turned towards them and took his nice bow, posing exactly as a lion stands adamant in the face of other animals. Karëa was leading the party, and he challenged Sämba, "Why are you fleeing? Just stand, and we shall teach you a lesson!" When challenged by another kñatriya to stand and fight, a kñatriya cannot go away; he must fight. Therefore, as soon as Sämba accepted the challenge and stood alone before them, he was overpowered by showers of arrows thrown by all the great warriors. As a lion is never afraid of being chased by many wolves and jackals, similarly, Sämba, the glorious son of the Yadu dynasty, endowed with inconceivable potencies as the son of Lord Kåñëa, became very angry at the warriors of the Kuru dynasty for improperly using arrows against him. He fought them with great talent. First of all, he struck each of the six charioteers with six separate arrows. Another four arrows were used to kill the charioteers' horses, four on each chariot. One arrow was used to kill the driver, and one arrow was used for Karëa as well as the other celebrated fighters. While Sämba was so diligently fighting alone with the six great warriors, they all appreciated the inconceivable potency of the boy. Even in the midst of fighting, they admitted frankly that this boy Sämba was wonderful. But the fighting was conducted in the kñatriya spirit, so all together, although it was improper, they obliged Sämba to get down from his chariot, now broken to pieces. Of the six warriors, four took care to kill Sämba's four horses, and one of them managed to cut the string of Sämba's bow so that he could no longer fight with them. In this way, with great difficulty and after a severe fight, Sämba was left bereft of his chariot, and they were able to arrest him. Thus, the warriors of the Kuru dynasty accepted their great victory and took their daughter, Lakñmaëä, away from him. Thereafter, they entered the city of Hastinäpura in great triumph.

The great sage Närada immediately carried the news to the Yadu dynasty that Sämba was arrested and told them the whole story. The members of the Yadu dynasty became very angry at Sämba's being arrested, and improperly so by six warriors. Now, with the permission of the head of the Yadu dynasty's king, Ugrasena, they prepared to attack the capital city of the Kuru dynasty.

Although Lord Balaräma knew very well that by slight provocation people are prepared to fight with one another in the age of Kali, He did not like the idea that the two great dynasties, the Kuru dynasty and the Yadu dynasty, would fight amongst themselves, even though they were influenced by Kali-yuga. "Instead of fighting with them," He wisely thought, "let Me go there and see the situation, and let Me try to see if the fight can be settled by mutual understanding." Balaräma's idea was that if the Kuru dynasty could be induced to release Sämba along with his wife, Lakñmaëä, then the fight could be avoided. He therefore immediately arranged for a nice chariot to go to Hastinäpura, accompanied by learned priests and brähmaëas, as well as by some of the elderly members of the Yadu dynasty. He was confident that the members of the Kuru dynasty would agree to this marriage and avoid fighting amongst themselves. As Lord Balaräma proceeded towards Hastinäpura in this chariot, accompanied by the learned brähmaëas and the elderly members of the Yadu dynasty, He looked like the moon shining in the clear sky amongst the glittering stars. When Lord Balaräma reached the precincts of the city of Hastinäpura, He did not enter, but stationed Himself in a camp outside the city in a small garden house. Then He asked Uddhava to see the leaders of the Kuru dynasty and inquire from them whether they wanted to fight with the Yadu dynasty or to make a settlement. Uddhava went to see the leaders of the Kuru dynasty, and he met all the important members, including Bhéñmadeva, Dhåtaräñöra, Droëäcärya, Bali, Duryodhana and Bähléka. After offering them due respects, he informed them that Lord Balaräma had already arrived at the garden, outside the city door.

The leaders of the Kuru dynasty, especially Dhåtaräñöra and Duryodhana, were very joyful because they knew very well that Lord Balaräma was a great well-wisher of their family. There were no bounds to their joy on hearing the news, and so immediately they welcomed Uddhava. In order to properly receive Lord Balaräma, they all took auspicious paraphernalia for His reception in their hands and went to see Him outside the city door. According to their respective positions, they welcomed Lord Balaräma by giving Him in charity nice cows and argha (an assortment of articles such as ärätrika water, sweet preparations of honey, butter, etc., and flowers, and garlands scented with pulp). Because all of them knew the exalted position of Lord Balaräma as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, they bowed their heads before the Lord with great respect. They all exchanged words of reception by asking one another of their welfare, and when such formality was finished, Lord Balaräma, in a great voice and very patiently, submitted before them the following words for their consideration. "My dear friends, this time I have come to you as a messenger with the order of the all-powerful King Ugrasena. Please, therefore, hear the order with attention and great care. Without wasting a single moment, please try to carry out the order. King Ugrasena knows very well that you warriors of the Kuru dynasty improperly fought with the pious Sämba, who was alone, and that with great difficulty and tactics you have arrested him. We have all heard this news, but we are not very agitated because we are most intimately related to each other. I do not think we should disturb our good relationship; we should continue our friendship without any unnecessary fighting. Please, therefore, immediately release Sämba and bring him, along with his wife, Lakñmaëä, before Me."

When Lord Balaräma spoke in a commanding tone full of heroic assertion, supremacy and chivalry, His statements were not appreciated by the leaders of the Kuru dynasty. Rather, all of them became agitated, and with great anger they said: "Hello! These words are very astonishing but quite befitting the age of Kali; otherwise how could Balaräma speak so vituperatively? The language and tone used by Balaräma are simply abusive, and due to the influence of this age, it appears that the shoes befitting the feet want to rise to the top of the head where the helmet is worn. We are connected with the Yadu dynasty by marriage, and because of this they have been given the chance to come live with us, dine with us, and sleep with us; now they are taking advantage of these privileges. They had practically no position before we gave them a portion of our kingdom to rule, and now they are trying to command us. We have allowed the Yadu dynasty to use the royal insignias like the whisk, fan, conchshell, white umbrella, crown, royal throne, sitting place, bedstead, and everything befitting the royal order. They should not have used such royal paraphernalia in our presence, but we did not check them due to our family relationships. Now they have the audacity to order us to do things. Well, this is enough of their impudence! We cannot allow them to do any more of these things, nor shall we allow them to use these royal insignias. It would be best to take all these things away; it is improper to feed a snake with milk, since such merciful activities simply increase his venom. The Yadu dynasty is now trying to go against those who have fed them so nicely. Their flourishing condition is due to our gifts and merciful behavior, and still they are so shameless that they are trying to order us. How regrettable are all these activities! No one in the world can enjoy anything if the members of the Kuru dynasty like Bhéñma, Droëäcärya and Arjuna do not allow them to. Exactly as a lamb cannot enjoy life in the presence of a lion, without our desire it is not even possible for the demigods in heaven, headed by King Indra, to find enjoyment in life, not to speak of ordinary human beings!" Actually the members of the Kuru dynasty were very puffed up due to their opulence, kingdom, aristocracy, family tradition, great warriors, family members and vast expansive empire. They did not even observe common formalities of civilized society, and in the presence of Lord Balaräma they uttered insulting words about the Yadu dynasty. Speaking in this unmannerly way, they returned to their city of Hastinäpura.

Although Lord Balaräma patiently heard their insulting words and simply observed their uncivil behavior, from His appearance it was clear that He was burning with anger and was thinking of retaliating with great vengeance. His bodily features became so agitated that it was difficult for anyone to look at Him. He laughed very loudly and said: "It is true that if a man becomes too puffed up because of his family, opulence, beauty and material advancement, he no longer wants a peaceful life but becomes belligerent toward all others. It is useless to give such a person good instruction for gentle behavior and peaceful life, but on the contrary, one should search out the ways and means to punish him." Generally, due to material opulence a man becomes exactly like an animal. To give an animal peaceful instructions is useless, and the only means is argumentum vaculum. In other words, the only means to keep animals in order is a stick. "Just see how impudent the members of the Kuru dynasty are! I wanted to make a peaceful settlement despite the anger of all the other members of the Yadu dynasty, including Lord Kåñëa Himself. They were preparing to attack the whole kingdom of the Kuru dynasty, but I pacified them and took the trouble to come here to settle the affair without any fighting. Still these rascals behave like this! It is clear that they do not want a peaceful settlement, but that they are factually warmongers. With great pride they have repeatedly insulted Me by calling the Yadus dynasty ill names.

"Even the King of heaven, Indra, abides by the order of the Yadu dynasty; and you consider King Ugrasena, who is the head of the Bhojas, Våñëis, Andhakas and Yädavas, to be the leader of a small phalanx! Your conclusion is wonderful! You do not care for King Ugrasena, whose order is obeyed even by King Indra. Consider the exalted position of the Yadu dynasty. They have forcibly used both the assembly house and the pärijäta tree of the heavenly planet, and still you think that they cannot order you. Don't you even think that Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, can sit on the exalted royal throne and command everyone? All right! If your thinking is like that, then you deserve to be taught a very good lesson. You have thought it wise that the royal insignias like the whisk, fan, white umbrella, royal throne and other princely paraphernalia not be used by the Yadu dynasty. Does this mean that even Lord Kåñëa, the Lord of the whole creation and the husband of the goddess of fortune, cannot use this royal paraphernalia? The dust of Kåñëa's lotus feet is worshiped by all the great demigods. The Ganges water is inundating the whole world, and since it is emanating from His lotus feet, its banks have turned into great places of pilgrimage. The principal deities of all planets are engaged in His service, and they consider themselves most fortunate to take the dust of the lotus feet of Kåñëa on their helmets. Great demigods like Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, and even the goddess of fortune and I are simply plenary parts of His spiritual identity, and still you think that He is not fit to use the royal insignia or even sit on the royal throne? Alas, how regrettable it is that these fools consider us, the members of the Yadu dynasty, to be like shoes and themselves like helmets. It is clear now that these leaders of the Kuru dynasty have become mad over their worldly possessions and opulence. Every statement they made was full of crazy proposals. I should immediately take them to task and bring them to their senses. If I do not take steps against them, it will be improper on My part. Therefore, on this very day, I shall rid the whole world of any trace of the Kuru dynasty. I shall finish them off immediately!" While talking like this, Lord Balaräma seemed so furious that He looked as if He could burn the whole cosmic creation to ashes. He stood up steadily, and taking His plow in His hand, began striking the earth with it. In this way the whole city of Hastinäpura was separated from the earth. Lord Balaräma then began to drag the city toward the flowing water of the river Ganges. Because of this, there was a great tremor throughout Hastinäpura, as if there had been an earthquake, and it seemed that the whole city would be dismantled.

When all the members of the Kuru dynasty saw that their city was about to fall into the water of the Ganges and when they heard their citizens howling in great anxiety, they immediately came to their senses and understood what was happening. Thus without waiting another second they brought forward their daughter Lakñmaëä. They also brought Sämba, who had forcibly tried to take her away, keeping him in the forefront with Lakñmaëä at his back. All the members of the Kuru dynasty appeared before Lord Balaräma with folded hands just to beg the pardon of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Now using good sense, they said: "O Lord Balaräma, You are the reservoir of all pleasures. You are the maintainer and support of the entire cosmic situation. Unfortunately we were all unaware of Your inconceivable potencies. Dear Lord, please consider us most foolish. Our intelligence was bewildered and not in order. Therefore we have come before You to beg Your pardon. Please excuse us. You are the original creator, sustainer and annihilator of the whole cosmic manifestation, and still Your position is always transcendental. O all-powerful Lord, great sages speak about You. You are the original puppeteer, and everything in the world is just like Your toys. O unlimited one, You have a hold on everything, and like child's play You hold all the planetary systems on Your head. When the time for dissolution comes, You close up the whole cosmic manifestation within Yourself. At that time nothing remains but Yourself lying in the Causal Ocean as Mahä-Viñëu. Our dear Lord, You have appeared on this earth in Your transcendental body just for the maintenance of the cosmic situation. You are above all anger, envy and enmity. Whatever You do, even in the form of chastisement, is auspicious for the whole material existence. We are offering our respectful obeisances unto You because You are the imperishable Supreme Personality of Godhead, the reservoir of all opulences and potencies. O creator of innumerable universes, let us fall down and offer You our respectful obeisances, again and again. We are now completely surrendered unto You. Please, therefore, be merciful upon us and give us Your protection." When the prominent members of the Kuru dynasty, beginning with grandfather Bhéñmadeva down to Arjuna and Duryodhana, had offered their respectful prayers in that way, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Balaräma, immediately became softened and assured them there was no cause for fear and that they need not worry.

For the most part it was the practice of the kñatriya kings to inaugurate some kind of fighting between the parties of the bride and bridegroom before the marriage. When Sämba forcibly took away Lakñmaëä, the elderly members of the Kuru dynasty were pleased to see that he was actually the suitable match for her. In order to see his personal strength, however, they fought with him, and without any respect for the regulations of fighting, they all arrested him. When the Yadu dynasty decided to release Sämba from the confinement of the Kurus, Lord Balaräma came personally to settle the matter, and as a powerful kñatriya, He ordered them to free Sämba immediately. The Kauravas became superficially insulted by this order, so they challenged Lord Balaräma's power. They simply wanted to see Him exhibit His inconceivable strength. Thus with great pleasure they handed over their daughter to Sämba, and the whole matter was settled. Duryodhana, being affectionate towards his daughter Lakñmaëä, had her married to Sämba in great pomp. For her dowry, he first gave 1,200 elephants, each of which were at least sixty years old; then he gave 10,000 nice horses, 6,000 chariots, which were dazzling just like the sunshine, and 1,000 maidservants who were decorated with golden ornaments. Lord Balaräma, the most prominent member of the Yadu dynasty, acted as guardian of the bridegroom Sämba and very pleasingly accepted the dowry. Balaräma was very satisfied after His great reception from the side of the Kurus, and accompanied by the newly married couple, He started towards His capital city of Dvärakä.

Lord Balaräma triumphantly reached Dvärakä, where He met with many citizens who were all His devotees and friends. When they all assembled, Lord Balaräma narrated the whole story of the marriage, and they were astonished to hear how Balaräma had made the city of Hastinäpura tremble. It is confirmed by Çukadeva Gosvämé that the site of Hastinäpura is now known as New Delhi, and the river flowing through the city is called the Yamunä, although in those days it was known as the Ganges. From authorities like Jéva Gosvämé it is also confirmed that the Ganges and Yamunä are the same river flowing in different courses. The part of the Ganges which flows through Hastinäpura to the area of Våndävana is called the Yamunä because it is sanctified by the transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa. The part of Hastinäpura which slopes towards the Yamunä becomes inundated during the rainy season and reminds everyone of Lord Balaräma's threatening to cast the city into the Ganges.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Thirteenth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Marriage of Sämba."

KB 1970-2-14 / The Great Sage Närada Visits the Different Homes of Lord Kåñëa

14 /The Great Sage Närada Visits the Different Homes of Lord Kåñëa

The great sage Närada heard that Lord Kåñëa had married 16,000 wives after He had killed the demon Narakäsura, sometimes called Bhaumäsura. Närada became astonished that Lord Kåñëa had expanded Himself into 16,000 forms and married these wives simultaneously in different palaces. Being inquisitive as to how Kåñëa was managing His household affairs with so many wives, Närada desired to see these pastimes and so set out to visit Kåñëa's different homes. When Närada arrived in Dvärakä, he saw that the gardens and parks were full of various flowers of different colors and orchards that were overloaded with a variety of fruits. Beautiful birds were chirping, and peacocks were delightfully crowing. There were tanks and ponds full of blue and red lotus flowers, and some of these sites were filled with varieties of lilies. The lakes were full of nice swans and cranes whose voices resounded everywhere. In the city there were as many as 900,000 great palaces built of first-class marble with gates and doors made of silver. The posts of the houses and palaces were bedecked with jewels such as touchstone, sapphires and emeralds, and the floors gave off a beautiful luster. The highways, lanes, streets, crossings and marketplaces were all beautifully decorated. The whole city was full of residential homes, assembly houses, and temples, all of different architectural beauty. All of this made Dvärakä a glowing city. The big avenues, crossings, lanes, streets, and also the thresholds of every residential house, were very clean. On both sides of every path there were bushes, and at regular intervals there were large trees that shaded the avenues so that the sunshine would not bother the passersby.

In this greatly beautiful city of Dvärakä, Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, had many residential quarters. The great kings and princes of the world used to visit these palaces just to worship Him. The architectural plans were made personally by Viçvakarmä, the engineer of the demigods, and in the construction of the palaces he exhibited all of his talents and ingenuity. These residential quarters numbered more than 16,000, and a different queen of Lord Kåñëa resided in each of them. The great sage Närada entered one of these houses and saw that the pillars were made of coral and the ceilings were bedecked with jewels. The walls as well as the arches between the pillars glowed from the decorations of different kinds of sapphires. Throughout the palace there were many canopies made by Viçvakarmä that were decorated with strings of pearls. The chairs and other furniture were made of ivory, bedecked with gold and diamonds, and jeweled lamps dissipated the darkness within the palace. There was so much incense and flavored gum burning that the scented fumes were coming out of the windows. The peacocks sitting on the steps became illusioned by the fumes, mistaking them for clouds, and began dancing jubilantly. There were many maidservants, all of whom were decorated with gold necklaces, bangles and beautiful saris. There were also many male servants, who were nicely dressed in cloaks and turbans and jeweled earrings. Beautiful as they were, the servants were all engaged in different household duties.

Närada saw that Lord Kåñëa was sitting with Rukmiëédevé, the mistress of that particular palace, who was bearing the rod of a cämara whisk. Even though there were many thousands of maidservants who were equally beautiful and qualified, and who were of the same age, Rukmiëédevé personally was engaged in fanning Lord Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, worshiped even by Närada, but still, as soon as He saw Närada enter the palace, Kåñëa got down immediately from Rukmiëé's bedstead and stood up to honor him. Lord Kåñëa is the teacher of the whole world, and in order to instruct everyone how to respect a saintly person like Närada Muni, Kåñëa bowed down, touching His helmet to the ground. Not only did Kåñëa bow down, but He also touched the feet of Närada and with folded hands requested him to sit on His chair. Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality worshiped by all devotees. He is the most worshiped spiritual master of everyone. The Ganges water which emanates from His feet sanctifies the three worlds. All qualified brähmaëas worship Him, and therefore He is called brahmaëya-deva.

Brahmaëya means one who fully possesses the brahminical qualifications, which are said to be as follows: truthfulness, self-control, purity, mastery of the senses, simplicity, full knowledge by practical application, and engagement in devotional service. Lord Kåñëa personally possesses all these qualities, and He is worshiped by persons who themselves possess such qualities. There are thousands and millions of names of Lord Kåñëa—Viñëu-sahasra-näma—and all of them are given to Him because of His transcendental qualities.

Lord Kåñëa in Dvärakä enjoyed the pastimes of a perfect human being. When, therefore, He washed the feet of the sage Närada and took the water on His head, Närada did not object, knowing well that the Lord did so to teach everyone how to respect saintly persons. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, who is the original Näräyaëa and eternal friend of all living entities, thus worshiped the sage Närada according to Vedic regulative principles. Welcoming him with sweet nectarean words, He addressed Närada as bhagavän, or one who is self-sufficient, possessing all kinds of knowledge, renunciation, strength, fame, beauty, and similar other opulences. He particularly asked Närada, "What can I do in your service?"

Närada replied, "My dear Lord, this kind of behavior by Your Lordship is not at all astonishing because You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead and master of all species of living entities. You are the supreme friend of all living entities, but at the same time You are the supreme chastiser of the miscreants and the envious. I know that Your Lordship has descended on this earth for the proper maintenance of the whole universe. Your appearance, therefore, is not forced by any other agency. By Your sweet will only, You agree to appear and disappear. It is my great fortune that I have been able to see Your lotus feet today. Anyone who becomes attached to Your lotus feet is elevated to the supreme position of neutrality and is uncontaminated by the material modes of nature. My Lord, You are unlimited; there is no limit to Your opulences. Great demigods like Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva are always busy placing You within their hearts and meditating upon You. The conditioned souls who have now been put into the blind well of material existence can get out of this eternal captivity only by accepting Your lotus feet. Thus, You are the only shelter of all conditioned souls. My dear Lord, You have very kindly asked what You can do for me. In answer to this I simply request that I may not forget Your lotus feet at any time. I do not care where I may be, but I pray that I may be allowed to constantly remember Your lotus feet."

The benediction which the sage Närada asked from the Lord is the ideal prayer of all pure devotees. A pure devotee never asks for any kind of material or spiritual benediction from the Lord, but his only prayer is that he may not forget the lotus feet of the Lord in any condition of life. A pure devotee does not care whether he is put in heaven or hell; he is satisfied anywhere, provided he can constantly remember the lotus feet of the Lord. Lord Caitanya also taught this same process of prayer in His Çikñäñöaka, in which He clearly stated that all He wanted was devotional service, birth after birth. A pure devotee does not even want to stop the repetition of birth and death. To a pure devotee, it does not matter whether he has to take birth again in the various species of life. His only ambition is that he may not forget the lotus feet of the Lord in any condition of life.

After departing from the palace of Rukmiëé, Näradajé wanted to see the activities of Lord Kåñëa's internal potency, yogamäyä; thus he entered the palace of another queen. There he saw Lord Kåñëa engaged in playing chess, along with His dear wife and Uddhava. The Lord immediately got up from His seat and invited Närada Muni to sit on His personal seat. The Lord again worshiped him with as much paraphernalia for reception as He had in the palace of Rukmiëé. After worshiping him properly, Lord Kåñëa acted as if He did not know what had happened in the palace of Rukmiëé. He therefore told Närada, "My dear sage, when your holiness comes here, you are full in yourself. Although we are householders and are always in need, you don't require anyone's help because you are self-satisfied. Under the circumstances, what reception can we offer you, and what can we possibly give you? Yet, since your holiness is a brähmaëa, it is our duty to offer you something as far as possible. Therefore, I beg your pleasure to order Me. What can I do for you?"

Näradajé knew everything about the pastimes of the Lord, so without any further discussion, he simply left the palace silently, in great astonishment over the Lord's activities. He then entered another palace. This time Näradajé saw that Lord Kåñëa was engaged as an affectionate father petting His small children. From there he entered another palace and saw Lord Kåñëa preparing to take His bath. In this way, Saint Närada entered each and every one of the sixteen thousand residential palaces of the queens of Lord Kåñëa, and in each of them he found Kåñëa engaged in different ways.

In one place he found Kåñëa engaged in offering oblations to the sacrificial fire and performing the ritualistic ceremonies of the Vedas as enjoined for householders. In another palace, Kåñëa was found performing the païca-yajïa sacrifice, which is compulsory for a householder. This yajïa is also known as païca-çüna. Knowingly or unknowingly, everyone, specifically the householder, is committing five kinds of sinful activities. When we receive water from a water pitcher, we kill many germs that are in it. Similarly, when we use a grinding machine or take foodstuff, we kill many germs. When sweeping a floor or igniting a fire we kill many germs, and when we walk on the street we kill many ants and other insects. Consciously or unconsciously, in all our different activities, we are killing. Therefore, it is incumbent upon every householder to perform the païca-çüna sacrifice to rid himself of the reactions to such sinful activities.

In one palace Lord Kåñëa was found engaged in feeding brähmaëas after performing ritualistic yajïas. In another palace, Närada found Kåñëa engaged in silently chanting the Gäyatré mantra, and in a third he found Him practicing fighting with a sword and shield. In some palaces Lord Kåñëa was found riding on horses or elephants or chariots and wandering hither and thither. Elsewhere He was found lying down on His bedstead taking rest, and somewhere else He was found sitting in His chair, being praised by the prayers of His different devotees. In some of the palaces He was found consulting with ministers like Uddhava and others on important matters of business. In one palace He was found surrounded by many young society girls, enjoying in a swimming pool. In another palace He was found engaged in giving well-decorated cows in charity to the brähmaëas, and in another palace He was found hearing the narrations of the Puräëas or histories, such as the Mahäbhärata, which are supplementary literatures for disseminating Vedic knowledge to common people by narrating important instances in the history of the universe. Somewhere Lord Kåñëa was found enjoying the company of a particular wife by exchanging joking words with her. Somewhere else He was found engaged along with His wife in religious ritualistic functions. Since it is necessary for householders to increase their financial assets for various expenditures, Kåñëa was found somewhere engaged in matters of economic development. Somewhere else He was found enjoying family life according to the regulative principles of the çästras.

In one palace He was found sitting in meditation as if He were concentrating His mind on the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is beyond these material universes. Meditation, as recommended in authorized scripture, is meant for concentrating one's mind on the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu. Lord Kåñëa is Himself the original Viñëu, but because He played the part of a human being, He taught us definitely by His personal behavior what is meant by meditation. Somewhere Lord Kåñëa was found satisfying elderly superiors by supplying them things which they needed. Somewhere else Näradajé found that Lord Kåñëa was engaged in discussing topics of fighting, and somewhere else in making peace with enemies. Somewhere Lord Kåñëa was found discussing the ultimate auspicious activity for the entire human society with His elder brother Lord Balaräma. Närada saw Lord Kåñëa engaged in getting His sons and daughters married with suitable brides and bridegrooms in due course of time, and the marriage ceremonies were being performed with great pomp. In one palace He was found bidding farewell to His daughters, and in another He was found receiving a daughter-in-law. People throughout the whole city were astonished to see such pomp and ceremonies.

Somewhere the Lord was seen engaged in performing different types of sacrifices to satisfy the demigods, who are only His qualitative expansions. Somewhere He was seen engaged in public welfare activities, establishing deep wells for water supply, rest houses and gardens for unknown guests, and great monastaries and temples for saintly persons. These are some of the duties enjoined in the Vedas for householders for fulfillment of their material desires. Somewhere Kåñëa was found as a kñatriya king engaged in hunting animals in the forest and riding on very beautiful sindhé horses. According to Vedic regulations, the kñatriyas were allowed to kill prescribed animals on certain occasions, either to maintain peace in the forests or to offer the animals in the sacrificial fire. Kñatriyas are allowed to practice this killing art because they have to kill their enemies mercilessly to maintain peace in society. In one situation the great sage Närada saw Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead and master of mystic powers, acting as a spy by changing His usual dress in order to understand the motives of different citizens in the city and within the palaces.

Saint Närada saw all these activities of the Lord, who is the Supersoul of all living entities but who played the role of an ordinary human being in order to manifest the activities of His internal potency. He was smiling within himself and began to address the Lord as follows: "My dear Lord of all mystic powers, object of the meditation of great mystics, the extent of Your mystic power is certainly inconceivable, even to mystics like Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva. But by Your mercy, because of my being always engaged in the transcendental loving service of Your lotus feet, Your Lordship has very kindly revealed to me the actions of Your internal potency. My dear Lord, You are worshipable by all, and demigods and predominating deities of all fourteen planetary systems are completely aware of Your transcendental fame. Now please give me Your blessings so that I may be able to travel all over the universes singing the glories of Your transcendental activities."

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Kåñëa, replied to Närada as follows: "My dear Närada, O sage among the demigods, you know that I am the supreme instructor and perfect follower of all religious principles, as well as the supreme enforcer of such principles. I am therefore personally executing such religious principles in order to teach the whole world how to act. My dear son, it is My desire that you not be bewildered by such demonstrations of My internal energy."

The Supreme Personality of Godhead was engaged in His so-called household affairs in order to teach people how one can sanctify one's household life although he may be attached to the imprisonment of material existence. Actually, one is obliged to continue the term of material existence because of household life. But the Lord, being very kind upon householders, demonstrated the path of sanctifying ordinary household life. Because Kåñëa is the center of all activities, a Kåñëa conscious householder's life is transcendental to Vedic injunctions and is automatically sanctified.

Thus Närada saw one single Kåñëa living in sixteen thousand palaces by His plenary expansions. Due to His inconceivable energy, He was visible in each and every individual queen's palace. Lord Kåñëa has unlimited power, and Närada's astonishment was boundless upon observing again and again the demonstration of Lord Kåñëa's internal energy. Lord Kåñëa behaved by His personal example as if He were very much attached to the four principles of civilized life, namely religiousness, economic development, sense gratification and salvation. These four principles of material existence are necessary for the spiritual advancement of human society, and although Lord Kåñëa had no need to do so, He exhibited His household activities so that people might follow in His footsteps for their own interest. Lord Kåñëa satisfied the sage Närada in every way. Närada was very much pleased by seeing the Lord's activities in Dvärakä, and thus he departed.

In narrating the activities of Lord Kåñëa in Dvärakä, Çukadeva Gosvämé explained to King Parékñit how Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, descends on this material universe by the agency of His internal potency and personally exhibits the principles which, if followed, can lead one to achieve the ultimate goal of life. All the queens in Dvärakä, more than sixteen thousand in number, engaged their feminine attractive features in the transcendental service of the Lord by smiling and serving, and the Lord was pleased to behave with them exactly as a perfect husband enjoying household life. One should know definitely that such pastimes cannot be performed by anyone but Lord Çré Kåñëa. Lord Çré Kåñëa is the original cause of the creation, maintenance and dissolution of the whole cosmic manifestation. Anyone who attentively hears the narrations of the Lord's pastimes in Dvärakä or supports a preacher of the Kåñëa consciousness movement will certainly find it very easy to traverse the path of liberation and taste the nectar of the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa. And thus he will be engaged in His devotional service.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Fourteenth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Great Sage Närada Visits the Different Homes of Lord Kåñëa."

KB 1970-2-15 / Lord Kåñëa's Daily Activities

15 /Lord Kåñëa's Daily Activities

From the Vedic mantras we learn that the Supreme Personality of Godhead has nothing to do: na tasya karyaà kranaà ca vidyate. If the Supreme Lord has nothing to do, then how can we speak of the activities of the Supreme Lord? From the previous chapter it is clear that no one can act in the way that Lord Kåñëa does. We should clearly note this fact: the activities of the Lord should be followed, but they cannot be imitated. For example, Kåñëa's ideal life as a householder can be followed, but if one wants to imitate Kåñëa by expanding into many forms, that is not possible. We should always remember, therefore, that Lord Kåñëa, although playing the part of a human being, nevertheless simultaneously maintains the position of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. We can follow Lord Kåñëa's dealing with His wives as an ordinary human being, but His dealing with more than sixteen thousand wives at one time cannot be imitated. The conclusion is that to become ideal householders we should follow in the footsteps of Lord Kåñëa as He displayed His daily activities, but we cannot imitate Him at any stage of our life.

Lord Kåñëa used to lie down with His sixteen thousand wives, but also He would rise up from bed very early in the morning, three hours before sunrise. By nature's arrangement the crowing of the cocks warns of the brähma-muhürta hour. There is no need of alarm clocks; as soon as the cocks crow early in the morning, it is to be understood that it is time to rise from bed. Hearing that sound, Kåñëa would get up from bed, but His rising early was not very much to the liking of His wives. The wives of Kåñëa were so much attached to Him that they would lie in bed embracing Him, but as soon as the cocks crowed, Kåñëa's wives would be very sorry and would immediately condemn the crowing.

In the garden within the compound of each palace there were pärijäta flowers. Pärijäta is not an artificial flower. We remember that Kåñëa brought the pärijäta trees from heaven and implanted them in all His palaces. Early in the morning, a mild breeze would carry the aroma of the pärijäta flower, and Kåñëa would smell it just after rising from bed. Due to this aroma, the honeybees would begin their humming vibration, and the birds also would begin their sweet chirping sounds. All together it would sound like the singing of professional chanters engaged in offering prayers to Kåñëa. Although Çrématé Rukmiëédevé, the first queen of Lord Kåñëa, knew that brähma-muhürta is the most auspicious time in the entire day, she would feel disgusted at the appearance of brähma-muhürta because she was not very happy to have Kåñëa leave her side in bed. Despite Çrématé Rukmiëédevé's disgust, Lord Kåñëa would immediately get up from bed exactly on the appearance of brähma-muhürta. An ideal householder should learn from the behavior of Lord Kåñëa how to rise early in the morning, however comfortably he may be lying in bed embraced by his wife.

After rising from bed, Lord Kåñëa would wash His mouth, hands and feet and would immediately sit down and meditate on Himself. This does not mean, however, that we should also sit down and meditate on ourselves. We have to meditate upon Kåñëa, Rädhä-Kåñëa. That is real meditation, Kåñëa is Kåñëa Himself; therefore He was teaching us that brähma-muhürta should be utilized for meditation on Rädhä-Kåñëa. By doing so, Kåñëa would feel very much satisfied, and similarly we will also feel transcendentally pleased and satisfied if we utilize the brähma-muhürta period to meditate on Rädhä and Kåñëa and if we think of how Çré Rukmiëédevé and Kåñëa acted as ideal householders to teach the whole human society to rise early in the morning and immediately engage in Kåñëa consciousness. There is no difference between meditating on the eternal forms of Rädhä-Kåñëa and chanting the mahämantra, Hare Kåñëa. As for Kåñëa's meditation, He had no alternative but to meditate on Himself. The object of meditation is Brahman, Paramätmä or the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but Kåñëa Himself is all three: He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Bhagavän; the localized Paramätmä is His plenary parcel expansion; and the all-pervading Brahman effulgence is the personal rays of His transcendental body. Therefore Kåñëa is always one, and for Him there is no differentiation. That is the difference between an ordinary living being and Kåñëa. For an ordinary living being there are many distinctions. An ordinary living being is different from his body, and he is different from other species of living entities. A human being is different from other human beings and different from the animals. Even in his own body, there are different bodily limbs. We have our hands and legs, but our hands are different from our legs. The hand cannot act like the leg, nor can the leg act like the hand. The eyes cannot hear like the ears, nor can the ears see like the eyes. All these differences are technically called svajtiya vijtiya.

The bodily limitation whereby one part of the body cannot act as another part is totally absent in the Supreme Personality of Godhead. There is no difference between His body and Himself. He is completely spiritual, and therefore there is no material difference between His body and His soul. Similarly, He is not different from His millions of incarnations and plenary expansions. Baladeva is the first expansion of Kåñëa, and from Baladeva expand Saëkarñaëa, Väsudeva, Pradyumna and Aniruddha. From Saëkarñaëa there is again an expansion of Näräyaëa, and from Näräyaëa there is a second quadruple expansion of Saëkarñaëa, Väsudeva, Pradyumna and Aniruddha. Similarly there are innumerable expansions of Kåñëa, but all of them are one. Kåñëa has many incarnations, such as Lord Nåsiàha, Lord Boar, Lord Fish and Lord Tortoise, but there is no difference between Kåñëa's original two-handed form, like that of a human being, and these incarnations of gigantic animal forms. Nor is there any difference between the action of one part of His body and that of another. His hands can act as His legs, His eyes can act as His ears, or His nose can act as another part of His body. Kåñëa's smelling and eating and hearing are all the same. We limited living entities have to use a particular part of our body for a particular purpose, but there is no such distinction for Kåñëa. In the Brahma-saàhitä it is said, aìgäni yasya sakalendriya-våtti: He can perform the activities of one limb with any other limb. So by analytical study of Kåñëa and His person, it is concluded that He is the complete whole. When He meditates, therefore, He meditates on Himself. The self-meditation by ordinary men, designated in Sanskrit as so 'ham, is simply imitation. Kåñëa may meditate on Himself because He is the complete whole, but we cannot imitate Him and meditate on ourselves. Our body is a designation; Kåñëa's body is not a designation. Kåñëa's body is also Kåñëa. There is no existence of anything foreign in Kåñëa. Whatever there is in Kåñëa is also Kåñëa. He is therefore the supreme, indestructible complete existence, or the supreme truth.

Kåñëa's existence is not relative existence. Everything else but Kåñëa is a relative truth, but Kåñëa is the Supreme Absolute Truth. Kåñëa does not depend on anything but Himself for His existence. Our existence, however is relative. For example, only when there is the light of the sun, the moon or electricity are we able to see. Our seeing, therefore, is relative, and the light of the sun and moon and electricity is also relative; they are called illuminating only because we see them as such. Dependence and relativity do not exist in Kåñëa. His activities are not dependent on anyone else's appreciation, nor does He depend on anyone else's help. He is beyond the existence of limited time and space, and because He is transcendental to time and space, He cannot be covered by the illusion of mäyä, whose activities are limited. In the Vedic literature we find that the Supreme Personality of Godhead has multi-potencies. Since all such potencies are emanations from Him, there is no difference between Him and His potencies. Certain philosophers say, however, that when Kåñëa comes He accepts a material body. But even if it is accepted that when He comes to the material world He accepts a material body, it should be concluded also that because the material energy is not different from Him, this body does not act materially. In the Bhagavad-gétä it is said, therefore, that He appears by His own internal potency, ätma-mäyä.

Kåñëa is called the Supreme Brahman because He is the cause of creation, the cause of maintenance and the cause of dissolution. Lord Brahmä, Lord Viñëu and Lord Çiva are different expansions of these material qualities. All these material qualities can act upon the conditioned souls, but there is no such action and reaction upon Kåñëa because these qualities are all simultaneously one and different from Him. Kåñëa Himself is simply sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, the eternal form of bliss and knowledge, and because of His inconceivable greatness, He is called the Supreme Brahman. His meditation on Brahman or Paramätmä or Bhagavän is on Himself only and not on anything else beyond Himself. This meditation cannot be imitated by the ordinary living entity.

After His meditation, the Lord would regularly bathe early in the morning with clear sanctified water. Then He would change into fresh clothing, cover Himself with a wrapper and then engage Himself in His daily religious functions. Out of His many religious duties, the first was to offer oblations into the sacrificial fire and silently chant the Gäyatré mantra. Lord Kåñëa, as the ideal householder, executed all the religious functions of a householder without deviation. When the sunrise became visible, the Lord would offer specific prayers to the sun-god. The sun-god and other demigods mentioned in the Vedic scriptures are described as different limbs of the body of Lord Kåñëa, and it is the duty of the householder to offer respects to the demigods and great sages, as well as the forefathers.

As it is said in the Bhagavad-gétä [3.22], The Lord has no specific duty to perform in this world, and yet He acts just like an ordinary man living an ideal life within this material world. In accordance with Vedic ritualistic principles, the Lord would offer respects to the demigods. The regulative principle by which the demigods and forefathers are worshiped is called tarpaëa, which means pleasing. One's forefathers might have to take a body on another planet, but by performance of this tarpaëa system, they become very happy wherever they may be. It is the duty of the householder to make his family members happy, and by following this tarpaëa system he can make his forefathers happy also. As the perfect exemplary householder, Lord Çré Kåñëa followed this tarpaëa system and offered respectful obeisances to the elderly superior members of His family.

His next duty was to give cows in charity to the brähmaëas. Lord Kåñëa used to give as many as 13,084 cows. Each of them was decorated with a silken cover and pearl necklace, their horns were covered with gold plating, and their hooves were silver-plated. All of them were full of milk, due to having their first-born calves with them, and they were very tame and peaceful. When the cows were given in charity to the brähmaëas, the brähmaëas also were given nice silken garments, and each was given a deerskin and sufficient quantity of sesame grains. The Lord is generally known as go-brähmaëa-hitäya ca, which means that His first duty is to see to the welfare of the cows and the brähmaëas. Thus He used to give cows in charity to the brähmaëas, with opulent decorations and paraphernalia. Then, wishing for the welfare of all living entities, He would touch auspicious articles such as milk, fire, honey, ghee (clarified butter), gold, jewels and fire. Although the Lord is by nature very beautiful due to the perfect figure of His transcendental body, still He would dress Himself in yellow colored garments and put on His necklace of Kaustubha jewels. He would wear flower garlands, smear His body with the pulp of sandalwood and decorate Himself with other similar cosmetics and ornaments. It is said that the ornaments themselves became beautiful upon being placed on the transcendental body of the Lord. After decorating Himself in this way, the Lord would then look at marble statues of the cow and calf and visit temples of God or demigods like Lord Çiva. There were many brähmaëas who would come daily to see the Supreme Lord before taking their breakfast; they were anxious to see Him, and He welcomed them.

His next duty was to please all kinds of men belonging to the different castes, both in the city and within the palace compound. He made them happy by fulfilling their different desires, and when the Lord saw them happy He also became very much pleased. The flower garlands, betel nuts, sandalwood pulp and other fragrant cosmetic articles which were offered to the Lord would be distributed by Him, first to the brähmaëas and elderly members of the family, then to the queens, then to the ministers, and if there were still some balance He would utilize it for His own personal use. By the time the Lord finished all these daily duties and activities, His charioteer Däruka would come with His wonderful chariot to stand before the Lord with folded hands, intimating that the chariot was ready, and the Lord would come out of the palace to travel. Then the Lord, accompanied by Uddhava and Sätyaki, would ride on the chariot just as the sun-god rides on his chariot in the morning, appearing with his blazing rays on the surface of the world. When the Lord was about to leave His palaces, all the queens would look at Him with feminine gestures. The Lord would respond to their greetings with smiles, attracting their hearts so much so that they would feel intense separation from the Lord.

Then the Lord would go to the assembly house known as Sudharmä. It may be remembered that the Sudharmä assembly house was taken away from the heavenly planet and was reestablished in the city of Dvärakä. The specific significance of the assembly house was that anyone who entered it would be freed from the six kinds of material pangs, namely hunger, thirst, lamentation, illusion, old age and death. These are the webs of material existence, and as long as one remained in that assembly house of Sudharmä he would not be infected by these six material webs. The Lord would say good-bye in all the sixteen thousand palaces, and again He would become one and enter the Sudharmä assembly house in procession with other members of the Yadu dynasty. After entering the assembly house, He used to sit on the exalted royal throne and would be seen to emanate glaring rays of transcendental effulgence. In the midst of all the great heroes of the Yadu dynasty, Kåñëa resembled the full moon in the sky, surrounded by multi-luminaries. In the assembly house there were professional jokers, dancers, musicians and ballet girls, and as soon as the Lord sat on His throne, they would begin their respective functions in order to please the Lord and put Him in a happy mood. First of all the jokers would talk in such a way that the Lord and His associates would enjoy their humor which would refresh the morning mood. The dramatic actors would then play their parts, and the dancing ballet girls would separately display their artistic movements. All these functions would be accompanied by the beating of mådaìga drums and the sounds of the véëä and flutes and bells, followed by the sound of the päkhvaj, another type of drum. Along with these musical vibrations, the auspicious sound of the conchshell would also be added. The professional singers called sütas and mägadhas would sing, and others would perform their dancing art. In this way, as devotees, they would offer respectful prayers to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Sometimes the learned brähmaëas present in that assembly would chant Vedic hymns and explain them to the audience to their best knowledge, and sometimes some of them would recite old historical accounts of the activities of prominent kings. The Lord, accompanied by His associates, would be very much pleased to hear them.

Once upon a time, a person arrived at the gateway of the assembly house who was unknown to all the members of the assembly, and with the permission of Lord Kåñëa he was admitted into the assembly by the doorkeeper. The doorkeeper was ordered to present him before the Lord, and the man appeared and offered his respectful obeisances unto the Lord with folded hands. It had happened that when King Jaräsandha conquered all other kingdoms many kings did not bow their heads before Jaräsandha, and as a result of this all of them, numbering twenty thousand, were arrested and made his prisoners. The man who was brought before Lord Kåñëa by the doorkeeper was a representative messenger from all these imprisoned kings. Being duly presented before the Lord, the man began to explain the actual situation as follows:

"My dear Lord, You are the eternal form of transcendental bliss and knowledge. As such, You are beyond the reach of the mental speculation or vocal description of any materialistic man within this world. A slight portion of Your glories can be known by persons who are fully surrendered unto Your lotus feet, and by Your grace only such persons become freed from all material anxieties. My dear Lord, I am not one of these surrendered souls; I am still within the duality and illusion of this material existence. I have therefore come to take shelter of Your lotus feet, for I am afraid of the cycle of birth and death. My dear Lord, I think that there are many living entities like me who are eternally entangled in fruitive activities and their resultant reactions. They are never inclined to follow Your instructions by performance of devotional service, although it is pleasing to the heart and most auspicious for one's existence. On the contrary, they are against the path of Kåñëa conscious life, and they are wandering within the three worlds impelled by the illusory energy of material existence.

"My dear Lord, who can estimate Your mercy and Your powerful activities? You are present always as the insurmountable force of eternal time, engaged in baffling the indefatigable desires of the materialists, who are thus repeatedly becoming confused and frustrated. I therefore offer my respectful obeisances unto You in Your form of eternal time. My dear Lord, You are the proprietor of all the worlds, and You have incarnated Yourself along with Your plenary expansion Lord Balaräma. It is said that Your appearance in this incarnation is for the purpose of protecting the faithful and destroying the miscreants. Under the circumstances, how is it possible that miscreants like Jaräsandha can put us into such deplorable conditions of life against Your authority? We are puzzled at the situation and cannot understand how it is possible. It may be that Jaräsandha has been deputed to give us such trouble because of our past misdeeds, but we have heard from revealed scriptures that anyone who surrenders unto Your lotus feet immediately becomes immuned to the reactions of sinful life. I have therefore been deputed by all the imprisoned kings to whole-heartedly offer ourselves unto Your shelter, and we hope that Your Lordship will now give us full protection. We have now come to the real conclusion of our lives. Our kingly positions are nothing but the reward of our past pious activities, just as our suffering imprisonment by Jaräsandha is the result of our past impious activities. We realize now that the resultant reactions of both pious and impious activities are temporary and that we can never be happy in this conditioned life. This material body is awarded to us by the modes of material nature, and on account of this we are full of anxieties. The material condition of life simply involves bearing the burden of this dead body. As a result of fruitive activities we have thus been subjected to being beasts of burden for these bodies, and being forced by conditional life, we have given up the pleasing life of Kåñëa consciousness. Now we realize that we are the most foolish persons. We have been entangled in the network of material reaction due to our ignorance. We have therefore come to the shelter of Your lotus feet, which can immediately eradicate all the results of fruitive action and thus free us from the contamination of material pains and pleasures.

Dear Lord, because we are now surrendered souls at Your lotus feet, You can give us relief from the entrapment of fruitive action made possible by the form of Jaräsandha. Dear Lord, it is known to You that Jaräsandha possesses the power of ten thousand elephants, and with this power he has imprisoned us, just as a lion hypnotizes a flock of sheep. My dear Lord, You have already fought with Jaräsandha eighteen times consecutively, out of which You have defeated him seventeen times by surpassing his extraordinary powerful position. But in Your eighteenth fight, You exhibited Your human behavior, and thus it appeared that You were defeated. My dear Lord, we know very well that Jaräsandha cannot defeat You at any time because Your power, strength, resources and authority are all unlimited. No one can equal You or surpass You. The appearance of defeat by Jaräsandha in the eighteenth engagement is nothing but an exhibition of human behavior. Unfortunately, foolish Jaräsandha could not understand Your tricks, and he has since then become puffed up over his material power and prestige. Specifically, he has arrested us and imprisoned us, knowing fully that as Your devotees, we are subordinate to Your sovereignty.

"Now I have explained our awful position, and Your Lordship can consider and do whatever You like. As the messenger and representative of all those imprisoned kings, I have submitted my words before Your Lordship and presented our prayers to You. All the kings are very anxious to see You so that they can all personally surrender at Your lotus feet. My dear Lord, be merciful upon them and act for their good fortune."

At the very moment the messenger of the imprisoned kings was presenting his appeal before the Lord, the great sage Närada also arrived. Because he was a great saint, his hair was dazzling like gold, and when he entered the assembly house it appeared that the sun-god was personally present in the midst of the assembly. Lord Kåñëa is the worshipable master of even Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva, yet as soon as He saw that the sage Närada had arrived, He immediately stood up along with His ministers and secretaries to receive the great sage and offer His respectful obeisances by bowing His head. The great sage Närada took a comfortable seat, and Lord Kåñëa worshiped him with all paraphernalia, as required for the regular reception of a saintly person. While He was trying to satisfy Näradajé, Lord Kåñëa spoke the following words in His sweet and natural voice.

"My dear great sage among the demigods, I think that now everything is well within the three worlds. You are perfectly eligible to travel everywhere in space in the upper, middle and lower planetary systems of this universe. Fortunately, when we meet you we can very easily take information from your holiness of all the news of the three worlds; within this cosmic manifestation of the Supreme Lord, there is nothing concealed from your knowledge. You know everything, and so I wish to question you. Are the Päëòavas doing well, and what is the present plan of King Yudhiñöhira? Will you kindly let Me know what they want to do at present?"

The great sage Närada spoke as follows: "My dear Lord, You have spoken about the cosmic manifestation created by the Supreme Lord, but I know that You are the all-pervading creator. Your energies are so extensive and inconceivable that even powerful personalities like Brahmä, the lord of this particular universe, cannot measure Your inconceivable power. My dear Lord, You are present as the Supersoul in everyone's heart by Your inconceivable potency, exactly like the fire which is present in everyone but which no one can see directly. In conditioned life, every living entity is within the jurisdiction of the three modes of material nature. As such, they are unable to see Your presence everywhere with their material eyes. By Your grace, however, I have seen many times the action of Your inconceivable potency, and therefore when You ask me for news of the Päëòavas, which is not at all unknown to You, I am not surprised at Your inquiry. My dear Lord, by Your inconceivable potencies You create this cosmic manifestation, maintain it and again dissolve it. It is by dint of Your inconceivable potency only that this material world, although a shadow representation of the spiritual world, appears to be factual. No one can understand what You plan to do in the future. Your transcendental position is always inconceivable to everyone. As far as I am concerned, I can simply offer my respectful obeisances unto You again and again. In the bodily concept of knowledge, everyone is driven by material desires, and thus everyone develops new material bodies one after another in the cycle of birth and death. Being absorbed in such a concept of existence, one does not know how to get out of this encagement of the material body. Out of Your causeless mercy, my Lord, You descend to exhibit Your different transcendental pastimes, which are illuminating and full of glory. Therefore I have no alternative but to offer my respectful obeisances unto You. My dear Lord, You are the Supreme Parambrahman, and Your pastimes as an ordinary human are another tactical resource, exactly like a play on the stage in which the actor plays parts different from his own identity. You have inquired about Your cousins the Päëòavas in the role of their well-wisher, and therefore I shall let You know about their intentions. Now please hear me. First of all may I inform You that King Yudhiñöhira has all material opulences which are possible to achieve in the highest planetary system, Brahmaloka. He has no material opulence for which to aspire, and yet he wants to perform Räjasüya sacrifices only to get Your association and please You.

Närada informed Lord Kåñëa, “King Yudhiñöhira is so opulent that he has attained all the opulences of Brahmaloka even on this earthly planet. He is fully satisfied, and he does not need anything more. He is full in everything, but now he wants to worship You in order to achieve Your causeless mercy, and I beg to request You to fulfill his desires. My dear Lord, in these great sacrificial performances by King Yudhiñöhira there will be an assembly of all the demigods and all the famous kings of the world.

"My dear Lord, You are the Supreme Brahman, Personality of Godhead. One who engages himself in Your devotional service by the prescribed methods of hearing, chanting and remembering certainly becomes purified from the contamination of the modes of material nature, and what to speak of those who have the opportunity to see You and touch You directly. My dear Lord, You are the symbol of everything auspicious. Your transcendental name and fame have spread all over the universe, including the higher, middle and lower planetary systems. The transcendental water which washes Your lotus feet is known in the higher planetary system as Mandäkiné, in the lower planetary system as Bhogavaté, and in this earthly planetary system as the Ganges. This sacred, transcendental water flows throughout the entire universe, purifying wherever it flows."

Just before the great sage Närada arrived in the Sudharmä assembly house of Dvärakä, Lord Kåñëa and His ministers and secretaries had been considering how to attack the kingdom of Jaräsandha. Because they were seriously considering this subject, Närada's proposal that Lord Kåñëa go to Hastinäpura for Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira's great Räjasüya sacrifice did not much appeal to them. Lord Kåñëa could understand the intentions of his associates because He is the ruler of even Lord Brahmä. Therefore, in order to pacify them, He smilingly said to Uddhava, "My dear Uddhava, you are always my well-wishing confidential friend. I therefore wish to see everything through you because I believe that your counsel is always right. I believe that you understand the whole situation perfectly. Therefore I am asking your opinion. What should I do? I have faith in you, and therefore I shall do whatever you advise." It was known to Uddhava that although Lord Kåñëa was acting like an ordinary man, He knew everything—past, present and future. However, because the Lord was trying to consult with him, Uddhava, in order to render service to the Lord, began to speak.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Fifteenth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Lord Kåñëa's Daily Activities."

KB 1970-2-16 / Lord Kåñëa in Indraprastha City

16 /Lord Kåñëa in Indraprastha City

In the presence of the great sage Närada and all the other associates of Lord Kåñëa, Uddhava considered the situation and then spoke as follows: "My dear Lord, first of all let me say that the great sage Närada Muni has requested You to go to Hastinäpura to satisfy King Yudhiñöhira, your cousin, who is making arrangements to perform the great sacrifice known as Räjasüya. I think, therefore, that Your Lordship should immediately go there to help the King in this great adventure. However, although to accept the invitation offered by the sage Närada Muni as primary is quite appropriate, at the same time, my Lord, it is Your duty to give protection to the surrendered souls. Both purposes can be served if we understand the whole situation. Unless we are victorious over all the kings, no one can perform this Räjasüya sacrifice. In other words, it is to be understood that King Yudhiñöhira cannot perform this great sacrifice without gaining victory over the belligerent King Jaräsandha. The Räjasüya sacrifice can only be performed by one who has gained victory over all directions. Therefore, to execute both purposes, we first of all have to kill Jaräsandha. I think that if we can somehow or other gain victory over Jaräsandha, then automatically all our purposes will be served. The imprisoned kings will be released, and with great pleasure we shall enjoy the spread of Your transcendental fame at having saved the innocent kings whom Jaräsandha has imprisoned.

"But King Jaräsandha is not an ordinary man. He has proved a stumbling block even to great warriors because his bodily strength is equal to the strength of 10,000 elephants. If there is anyone who can conquer this king, he is none other than Bhémasena because he also possesses the strength of 10,000 elephants. The best thing would be for Bhémasena to fight alone with him. Then there would be no unnecessary killing of many soldiers. In fact, it will be very difficult to conquer Jaräsandha when he stands with his akñauhiëé divisions of soldiers. We may therefore adopt a policy more favorable to the situation. We know that King Jaräsandha is very much devoted to the brähmaëas. He is very charitably disposed towards them; he never refuses any request from a brähmaëa. I think, therefore, that Bhémasena should approach Jaräsandha in the dress of a brähmaëa, beg charity from Him, and then personally engage in fighting Him. And in order to assure Bhémasena's victory, I think that Your Lordship should also accompany him. If the fighting takes place in Your presence, I am sure Bhémasena will emerge victorious because simply by Your presence everything impossible is made possible, just as Lord Brahmä creates this universe and Lord Çiva destroys it simply through Your influence.

"Actually, You are creating and destroying the entire cosmic manifestation; Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva are only the superficially visible causes. Creation and destruction are actually being performed by the invisible time factor, which is Your impersonal representation. Everything is under the control of this time factor. If Your invisible time factor can perform such wonderful acts through Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva, will not Your personal presence help Bhémasena to conquer Jaräsandha? My dear Lord, when Jaräsandha is killed, then the queens of all the imprisoned kings will be so joyful at their husbands' being released by Your mercy that they will all begin to sing Your glories. They will be as pleased as the gopés were when they were relieved from the hands of Çaìkhäsura. All the great sages, the King of the elephants, Gajendra, the goddess of fortune, Sétä, and even Your father and mother, were all delivered by Your causeless mercy. We also have been thus delivered, and we are always singing the transcendental glories of Your activities.

"Therefore, I think that if the killing of Jaräsandha is undertaken first, that will automatically solve many other problems. As for the Räjasüya sacrifice arranged in Hastinäpura, it will be held, either because of the pious activities of the imprisoned kings or the impious activities of Jaräsandha.

"My Lord, it appears that You are also personally to go to Hastinäpura to perform this great sacrifice so that demoniac kings like Jaräsandha and Çiçupäla may be conquered, the pious imprisoned kings released, and at the same time the great Räjasüya sacrifice performed. Considering all these points, I think that Your Lordship should immediately proceed to Hastinäpura."

This advice of Uddhava's was appreciated by all who were present in the assembly, and everyone considered that Lord Kåñëa's going to Hastinäpura would be beneficial from all points of view. The great sage Närada, the elderly personalities of the Yadu dynasty, and the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa Himself all supported the statement of Uddhava. Lord Kåñëa then took permission from His father Vasudeva and grandfather Ugrasena, and He immediately ordered His servants Däruka and Jaitra to arrange for travel to Hastinäpura. When everything was prepared, Lord Kåñëa especially bid farewell to Lord Balaräma and the King of the Yadus, Ugrasena, and after dispatching His queens along with their children and sending their necessary luggage ahead, He mounted His chariot, which bore the flag marked with the symbol of Garuòa.

Before starting the procession, Lord Kåñëa satisfied the great sage Närada by offering him different kinds of worshipable articles. Näradajé wanted to fall at the lotus feet of Kåñëa, but because the Lord was playing the part of a human being, he simply offered his respects within his mind, and fixing the transcendental form of the Lord within his heart, he left the assembly house by the airways. Usually the sage Närada never walks on the surface of the globe, but travels in outer space. After the departure of Närada, Lord Kåñëa addressed the messenger who had come from the imprisoned kings. He told him that they should not be worried. He would very soon arrange to kill the King of Magadha, Jaräsandha. Thus He wished good fortune to all the imprisoned kings and the messenger. After receiving this assurance from Lord Kåñëa, the messenger returned to the imprisoned kings and informed them of the happy news of the Lord's forthcoming visit. All the kings became joyful at the news and began to wait very anxiously for the Lord's arrival.

The chariot of Lord Kåñëa began to proceed, accompanied by many other chariots, along with elephants, cavalry, infantry and similar royal paraphernalia. Bugles, drums, trumpets, conchshells, horns and coronets all began to produce a loud auspicious sound which vibrated in all directions. The 16,000 queens, headed by the goddess of fortune Rukmiëédevé, the ideal wife of Lord Kåñëa, and accompanied by their respective sons, all followed behind Lord Kåñëa. They were dressed in costly garments decorated with ornaments, and their bodies were smeared with sandalwood pulp and garlanded with fragrant flowers. Riding on palanquins which were nicely decorated with silks, flags, and golden lace, they followed their exalted husband, Lord Kåñëa. The infantry soldiers carried shields, swords and lances in their hands and acted as royal bodyguards to all the queens. In the rear of the procession were the wives and children of all the other followers, and there were many society girls also following. Many beasts of burden like bulls, buffaloes, mules, and asses carried the camps, bedding and carpets, and the women who were following were seated in separate palanquins on the backs of camels. This panoramic procession was accompanied by the shouts of the people and was full with the display of different colored flags, umbrellas and whisks and different varieties of weapons, dress, ornaments, helmets and armaments. The procession, being reflected in the sunshine, appeared just like an ocean with high waves and sharks.

In this way the procession of Lord Kåñëa's party advanced towards Hastinäpura (New Delhi) and gradually passed through the kingdoms of Änarta (Gujarat Province), Sauvéra (Sauret), the great desert of Räjasthän, and then Kurukñetra. In between those kingdoms there were many mountains, rivers, towns, villages, pasturing grounds and mining fields. The procession passed through all of these places in its advance. On His way to Hastinäpura, the Lord crossed two big rivers, the Dåñvaté and the Sarasvaté. Then He crossed the province of Païchäla and the province of Matsya. In this way, ultimately He arrived at Indraprastha.

The audience of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is not very commonplace. Therefore, when King Yudhiñöhira heard that Lord Kåñëa had already arrived in his capital city, Hastinäpura, he became so joyful that all his hairs stood on end in great ecstasy, and he immediately came out of the city to properly receive Him. He ordered the musical vibration of different instruments and songs, and the learned brähmaëas of the city began to chant the hymns of the Vedas very loudly. Lord Kåñëa is known as Håñékeça, the master of the senses, and King Yudhiñöhira went forward to receive Him exactly as the senses meet the consciousness of life. King Yudhiñöhira was the elderly cousin of Kåñëa. Naturally he had great affection for the Lord, and as soon as he saw Him, his heart became filled with great love and affection. He had not seen the Lord for many days, and therefore he thought himself most fortunate to see Him present before him. The King therefore began to embrace Lord Kåñëa again and again in great affection.

The eternal form of Lord Kåñëa is the everlasting residence of the goddess of fortune. As soon as King Yudhiñöhira embraced Him, he became free from all the contamination of material existence. He immediately felt transcendental bliss, and he merged in an ocean of happiness. There were tears in his eyes, and his body shook due to ecstasy. He completely forgot that he was living in this material world. After this, Bhémasena, the second brother of the Päëòavas, smiled and embraced Lord Kåñëa, thinking of Him as his own maternal cousin, and thus he was merged in great ecstasy. Bhémasena also was so filled with ecstasy that for the time being he forgot his material existence. Then Lord Çré Kåñëa Himself embraced the other three Päëòavas, Arjuna, Nakula and Sahadeva. The eyes of all three brothers were inundated with tears, and Arjuna began to embrace Kåñëa again and again because they were intimate friends. The two younger Päëòava brothers, after being embraced by Lord Kåñëa, fell down at His lotus feet to offer their respects. Lord Kåñëa thereafter offered His obeisances to the brähmaëas present there, as well as to the elderly members of the Kuru dynasty, like Bhéñma, Droëa and Dhåtaräñöra. There were many kings of different provinces such as Kuru, Såïjaya and Kekaya, and Lord Kåñëa duly reciprocated greetings and respects with them. The professional reciters like the sütas, mägadhas, and vandinas, accompanied by the brähmaëas, began to offer their respectful prayers to the Lord. Artists and musicians like the Gandharvas, as well as the royal jokers, began to play their drums, conchshells, kettledrums, véëäs, mådaìgas, and bugles, and they exhibited their dancing art in order to please the Lord. Thus the all-famous Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Kåñëa, entered the great city of Hastinäpura, which was opulent in every respect. While Lord Kåñëa was entering the city, everyone was talking amongst themselves about the glories of the Lord, praising His transcendental name, quality, form, etc.

The roads, streets and lanes of Hastinäpura were all sprinkled with fragrant water through the trunks of intoxicated elephants. In different places of the city there were colorful festoons and flags decorating the houses and streets. At important road crossings there were gates with golden decorations, and at the two sides of the gates there were golden water jugs. These beautiful decorations glorified the opulence of the city. Participating in this great ceremony, all the citizens of the city gathered here and there, dressed in colorful new clothing, decorated with ornaments, flower garlands, and fragrant scents. Each and every house was illuminated by hundreds and thousands of lamps placed in different corners of the cornices, walls, columns, bases and architraves, and from far away the rays of the lamps resembled the festival of Dépävalé (a particular festival observed on the New Year's Day of the Hindu calendar). Within the walls of the houses, fragrant incense was burning, and smoke rose through the windows, making the entire atmosphere very pleasing. On the top of every house flags were flapping, and the gold water pots kept on the roofs shone very brilliantly.

Lord Kåñëa thus entered the city of the Päëòavas, enjoyed the beautiful atmosphere and slowly proceeded ahead. When the young girls in every house heard that Lord Kåñëa, the only object worth seeing, was passing on the road, they became very anxious to see this all-famous personality. Their hair loosened, and their tightened saris became slack due to their hastily rushing to see Him. They gave up their household engagements, and those who were lying in bed with their husbands immediately left them and came directly down onto the street to see Lord Kåñëa. The procession of elephants, horses, chariots, and infantry was very crowded; some, being unable to see properly in the crowd, got up on the roofs of the houses. They were pleased to see Lord Çré Kåñëa passing with His thousands of queens. They began to shower flowers on the procession, and they embraced Lord Kåñëa within their minds and gave Him a hearty reception. When they saw Him in the midst of His many queens, like the full moon situated amidst many luminaries, they began to talk amongst themselves.

One girl said to another, "My dear friend, it is very difficult to guess what kind of pious activities these queens might have performed, for they are always enjoying the smiling face and loving glances of Kåñëa." While Lord Kåñëa was thus passing on the road, at intervals some of the opulent citizens, who were all rich, respectable and freed from sinful activities presented auspicious articles to the Lord, just to offer Him a reception to the city. Thus they worshiped Him as humble servitors.

When Lord Kåñëa entered the palace, all the ladies there became overwhelmed with affection just upon seeing Him. They immediately received Lord Kåñëa with glittering eyes expressing their love and affection for Him, and Lord Kåñëa smiled and accepted their feelings and gestures of reception. When Kunté, the mother of the Päëòavas, saw her nephew Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, she became overpowered with love and affection. She at once got up from her bedstead and appeared before Him with her daughter-in-law, Draupadé, and in maternal love and affection she embraced Him. As he brought Kåñëa within the palace, King Yudhiñöhira became so confused in his jubilation that he practically forgot what he was to do at that time in order to receive Kåñëa and worship Him properly. Lord Kåñëa delightfully offered His respects and obeisances to Kunté and other elderly ladies of the palace. His younger sister, Subhadrä, was also standing there with Draupadé, and both offered their respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of the Lord. At the indication of her mother-in-law, Draupadé brought clothing, ornaments and garlands, and with this paraphernalia they received the queens Rukmiëé, Satyabhämä, Bhadrä, Jämbavaté, Kälindé, Mitravindä, Lakñmaëä and the devoted Satyä. These principal queens of Lord Kåñëa were first received, and then the remaining queens were also offered a proper reception. King Yudhiñöhira arranged for Kåñëa's rest and saw that all who came along with Him—namely His queens, His soldiers, His ministers and His secretaries—were comfortably situated. He had arranged that they would experience a new feature of reception everyday while staying as guests of the Päëòavas.

It was during this time that Lord Çré Kåñëa, with the help of Arjuna, for the satisfaction of the fire-god, Agni, allowed Agni to devour the Khäëòava Forest. During the forest fire, Kåñëa saved the demon Mayäsura, who was hiding in the forest. Upon being saved, Mayäsura felt obliged to the Päëòavas and Lord Kåñëa, and he constructed a wonderful assembly house within the city of Hastinäpura. In this way, Lord Kåñëa, in order to please King Yudhiñöhira, remained in the city of Hastinäpura for several months. During His stay, He enjoyed strolling here and there. He used to drive on chariots along with Arjuna, and many warriors and soldiers used to follow them.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Sixteenth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Lord Kåñëa in Indraprastha City."

KB 1970-2-17 / Liberation of King Jaräsandha

17 /Liberation of King Jaräsandha

In the great assembly of respectable persons, citizens, friends, relatives, brähmaëas, kñatriyas and vaiçyas, King Yudhiñöhira, in the presence of all, including his brothers, directly addressed Lord Kåñëa as follows: "My dear Lord Kåñëa, the sacrifice known as the Räjasüya yajïa is to be performed by the emperor, and it is considered to be the king of all sacrifices. By performing this sacrifice, I wish to satisfy all the demigods, who are Your empowered representatives within this material world, and I wish that You will kindly help me in this great adventure so that it may be successfully executed. As far as the Päëòavas are concerned, we have nothing to ask from the demigods. We are personally fully satisfied by being Your devotees. As You say in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20], "Persons who are bewildered by material desires worship the demigods," but our purpose is different. I want to perform this Räjasüya sacrifice and invite the demigods to show them that they have no power independent of You. They are all Your servants, and You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Foolish persons with a poor fund of knowledge consider Your Lordship an ordinary human being. Sometimes they try to find fault in You, and sometimes they defame You. Therefore I wish to perform this Räjasüya yajïa. I wish to invite all the demigods, beginning from Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva and other exalted chiefs of the heavenly planets, and in that great assembly of demigods from all parts of the universe, I want to substantiate that You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead and that everyone is Your servant.

"My dear Lord, those who are constantly in Kåñëa consciousness and who think of Your lotus feet or of Your shoes certainly become free from all contamination of material life. Persons who are engaged in Your service in full Kåñëa consciousness, who meditate upon You only or who offer prayers unto You, are purified souls. Being constantly engaged in Kåñëa conscious service, such persons become freed from the cycle of repeated birth and death. They do not even desire to become freed from this material existence or to enjoy material opulences; their desires are fulfilled by Kåñëa conscious activities. As far as we are concerned, we are fully surrendered unto Your lotus feet, and by Your grace we are so fortunate to see You personally. Therefore, naturally we have no desire for material opulences. The verdict of the Vedic wisdom is that You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead. I want to establish this fact, and I also want to show the world the difference between accepting You as the Supreme Personality of Godhead and accepting You as an ordinary powerful historical person. I wish to show the world that one can attain the highest perfection of life simply by taking shelter at Your lotus feet, exactly as one can satisfy the branches, twigs, leaves and flowers of an entire tree simply by watering the root. Thus, if one takes to Kåñëa consciousness, his life becomes fulfilled both materially and spiritually.

"This does not mean that You are partial to the Kåñëa conscious person and are indifferent to the non-Kåñëa conscious person. You are equal to everyone; that is Your declaration. You cannot be partial to one and not interested in others because You are sitting in everyone's heart as the Supersoul and giving everyone the respective results of his fruitive activities. You give every living entity the chance to enjoy this material world as he desires. As Supersoul, You are sitting in the body along with the living entity, giving him the results of his own actions as well as opportunities to turn toward Your devotional service by developing Kåñëa consciousness. You openly declare that one should surrender unto You, giving up all other engagements, and that You will take charge of him, giving him relief from the reactions of all sins. You are like the desire tree in the heavenly planets, which awards benediction according to one's desires. Everyone is free to achieve the highest perfection, but if one does not so desire, then Your awarding of lesser benedictions is not due to partiality."

On hearing this statement of King Yudhiñöhira, Lord Kåñëa replied as follows: "My dear King Yudhiñöhira, O killer of enemies, O ideal justice personified, I completely support your decision to perform the Räjasüya sacrifice. By performing this great sacrifice, your good name will remain well established forever in the history of human civilization. My dear King, may I inform you that it is the desire of all great sages, your forefathers, the demigods, and your relatives and friends, including Myself, that you perform this sacrifice, and I think that it will satisfy every living entity. But, because it is necessary, I request that you first of all conquer all the kings of the world and collect all requisite paraphernalia for executing this great sacrifice. My dear King Yudhiñöhira, your four brothers are direct representatives of important demigods like Varuëa, Indra, etc. [It is said that Bhéma was born of the demigod Varuëa, and Arjuna was born of the demigod Indra, whereas King Yudhiñöhira himself was born of the demigod Yamaräja.] Your brothers are great heroes, and you are the most pious and self-controlled king and are therefore known as Dharmaräja. All of you are so qualified in devotional service unto Me that automatically I have become rivalled by you."

Lord Kåñëa told King Yudhiñöhira that He becomes conquered by the love of one who has conquered his senses. One who has not conquered his senses cannot conquer the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is the secret of devotional service. To conquer the senses means to engage them constantly in the service of the Lord. The specific qualification of all the Päëòava brothers was that they always engaged their senses in the service of the Lord. One who thus engages his senses becomes purified, and with purified senses one can actually render service to the Lord. The Lord can thus be conquered by the devotee by loving transcendental service.

Lord Kåñëa continued: "There is no one in the three worlds of the universe, including the powerful demigods, who can surpass My devotees in any of the six opulences, namely, wealth, strength, reputation, beauty, knowledge and renunciation. Therefore, if you want to conquer the worldly kings, there is no possibility of their emerging victorious."

When Lord Kåñëa thus encouraged King Yudhiñöhira, the King's face brightened like a blossoming flower because of transcendental happiness, and thus he ordered his younger brothers to conquer all the worldly kings in all directions. Lord Kåñëa empowered the Päëòavas to execute His great mission of chastising the infidel miscreants of the world and giving protection to His faithful devotees. In His Viñëu form, the Lord therefore carries four kinds of weapons in His four hands. He carries a lotus flower and a conchshell in two hands, and in the other two hands He carries a club and a disc. The club and disc are meant for the nondevotees, but because the Lord is the Supreme Absolute, the resultant action of all His weapons is one and the same. With the club and the disc He chastises the miscreants so that they may come to their senses and know that they are not all in all. Over them there is the Supreme Lord. And by bugling with the conchshell and by offering blessings with the lotus flower, He always assures the devotees that no one can vanquish them, even in the greatest calamity. King Yudhiñöhira, being thus assured by the indication of Lord Kåñëa, ordered his youngest brother, Sahadeva, accompanied by soldiers of the Såïjaya tribe, to conquer the southern countries. Similarly, he ordered Nakula, accompanied by the soldiers of Matsyadeça, to conquer the kings of the western side. He sent Arjuna, accompanied by the soldiers of Kekayadeça, to conquer the kings of the northern side, and Bhémasena, accompanied by the soldiers of Madradeça (Madras), was ordered to conquer the kings on the eastern side.

It may be noted that by dispatching his younger brothers to conquer in different directions, King Yudhiñöhira did not actually intend that they declare war with the kings. Actually, the brothers started for different directions to inform the respective kings about King Yudhiñöhira's intention to perform the Räjasüya sacrifice. The kings were thus informed that they were required to pay taxes for the execution of the sacrifice. This payment of taxes to Emperor Yudhiñöhira meant that the king accepted his subjugation before him. In case of a king's refusal to act accordingly, there was certainly a fight. Thus by their influence and strength, the brothers conquered all the kings in different directions, and they were able to bring in sufficient taxes and presentations. These were brought before King Yudhiñöhira by his brothers.

King Yudhiñöhira was very anxious, however, when he heard that King Jaräsandha of Magadha did not accept his sovereignty. Seeing King Yudhiñöhira's anxiety, Lord Kåñëa informed him of the plan explained by Uddhava for conquering King Jaräsandha. Bhémasena, Arjuna and Lord Kåñëa then started together for Girivraja, the capital city of Jaräsandha, dressing themselves in the garb of brähmaëas. This was the plan devised by Uddhava before Lord Kåñëa started for Hastinäpura, and now it was given practical application.

King Jaräsandha was a very dutiful householder, and he had great respect for the brähmaëas. He was a great fighter, a kñatriya king, but he was never neglectful of the Vedic injunctions. According to Vedic injunctions, the brähmaëas are considered to be the spiritual masters of all other castes. Lord Kåñëa, Arjuna and Bhémasena were actually kñatriyas, but they dressed themselves as brähmaëas, and at the time when King Jaräsandha was to give charity to the brähmaëas and receive them as guests, they approached him.

Lord Kåñëa, in the dress of a brähmaëa, said to the King: "We wish all glories to your majesty. We are three guests at your royal palace, and we are coming from a great distance. We have come to ask you for charity, and we hope that you will kindly bestow upon us whatever we ask from you. We know about your good qualities. A person who is tolerant is always prepared to tolerate everything, even though distressful. Just as a criminal can perform the most abominable acts, so a greatly charitable person like you can give anything and everything he is asked for. For a great personality like you, there is no distinction between relatives and outsiders. A famous man lives forever, even after his death; therefore, any person who is completely fit and able to execute acts which will perpetuate his good name and fame and yet does not do so becomes abominable in the eyes of great persons. Such a person cannot be condemned enough, and his refusal to give charity is lamentable throughout his whole life. Your majesty must have heard the glorious names of charitable personalities such as Hariçcandra, Rantideva and Mudgala, who used to live only on grains picked up from the paddy field, and the great Mahäräja Çibi, who saved the life of a pigeon by supplying flesh from his own body. These great personalities have attained immortal fame simply by sacrificing this temporary and imperishable body." Lord Kåñëa, in the garb of a brähmaëa, thus informed Jaräsandha that fame is imperishable, but the body is perishable. If one can attain imperishable name and fame by sacrificing his perishable body, he becomes a very respectable figure in the history of human civilization.

While Lord Kåñëa was speaking in the garb of a brähmaëa along with Arjuna and Bhéma, Jaräsandha marked that the three of them did not appear to be actual brähmaëas. There were signs on their bodies by which Jaräsandha could understand that they were kñatriyas. Their shoulders were marked with an impression due to carrying bows; they had beautiful bodily structure, and their voices were grave and commanding. Thus he definitely concluded that they were not brähmaëas, but kñatriyas. He was also thinking that he had seen them somewhere before. Although these three persons were kñatriyas, they had come to his door begging alms like brähmaëas. Therefore he decided that he would fulfill their desires, in spite of their being kñatriyas. He thought in this way because their position had already been diminished by their appearing before him as beggars. "Under the circumstances," he thought, "I am prepared to give them anything. Even if they ask for my body, I shall not hesitate to offer it to them." In this regard, he began to think of Bali Mahäräja. Lord Viñëu in the dress of a brähmaëa appeared as a beggar before Bali, and in that way He snatched away all of his opulence and kingdom. He did this for the benefit of Indra, who, having been defeated by Bali Mahäräja, was bereft of his kingdom. Although Bali Mahäräja was cheated, his reputation as a great devotee who was able to give anything and everything in charity is still glorified throughout the three worlds. Bali Mahäräja could guess that the brähmaëa was Lord Viñëu Himself and that He had come to him just to take away his opulent kingdom on behalf of Indra. Bali's spiritual master and family priest, Çukräcärya, repeatedly warned him about this, and yet Bali did not hesitate to give in charity whatever the brähmaëa wanted, and at last he gave up everything to that brähmaëa. "It is my strong determination," thought Jaräsandha, "that if I can achieve immortal reputation by sacrificing this perishable body, I must act for that purpose; the life of a kñatriya who does not live for the benefit of the brähmaëa is certainly condemned."

Actually King Jaräsandha was very liberal in giving charity to the brähmaëas, and thus he informed Lord Kåñëa, Bhéma and Arjuna: "My dear brähmaëas, you can ask from me whatever you like. If you so desire, you can take my head also. I am prepared to give it."

After this, Lord Kåñëa addressed Jaräsandha as follows: "My dear King, please note that we are not actually brähmaëas, nor have we come to ask for foodstuffs or grains. We are all kñatriyas, and we have come to beg a duel with you. We hope that you will agree to this proposal. You may note that here is the second son of King Päëòu, Bhémasena, and the third son of Päëòu, Arjuna. As for Myself, you may know that I am your old enemy, Kåñëa, the cousin of the Päëòavas."

When Lord Kåñëa disclosed their disguise, King Jaräsandha began to laugh very loudly, and then in great anger and in a grave voice he exclaimed, "You fools! If you want to fight with me, I immediately grant your request. But, Kåñëa, I know that You are a coward. I refuse to fight with You because You become very confused when You face me in fighting. Out of fear of me You left Your own city, Mathurä, and now You have taken shelter within the sea; therefore I must refuse to fight with You. As far as Arjuna is concerned, I know that he is younger than me and is not an equal fighter. I refuse to fight with him because he is not in any way an equal competitor. But as far as Bhémasena is concerned, I think he is a suitable competitor to fight with me." After speaking in this way, King Jaräsandha immediately handed a very heavy club to Bhémasena, and he himself took another, and thus all of them went outside the city walls to fight.

Bhémasena and King Jaräsandha engaged themselves in fighting, and with their respective clubs, which were as strong as thunderbolts, they began to strike one another very severely, both of them being eager to fight. They were both expert fighters with clubs, and their techniques of striking one another were so beautiful that they appeared to be two dramatic artists dancing on a stage. When the clubs of Jaräsandha and Bhémasena loudly collided, they sounded like the impact of the big tusks of two fighting elephants or like a thunderbolt in a flashing electrical storm. When two elephants fight together in a sugarcane field, each of them snatches a stick of sugarcane and, by catching it tightly in its trunk, strikes the other. Each elephant heavily strikes his enemy's shoulders, arms, collarbones, chest, thighs, waist, and legs, and in this way the sticks of sugarcane are smashed. Similarly, all the clubs used by Jaräsandha and Bhémasena were broken, and so the two enemies prepared to fight with their strong-fisted hands. Both Jaräsandha and Bhémasena were very angry, and they began to smash each other with their fists. The striking of their fists sounded like the striking of iron bars or like the sound of thunderbolts, and they appeared to be like two elephants fighting. Unfortunately, however, neither was able to defeat the other because both were very expert in fighting, both were of equal strength, and their fighting techniques were equal also. Neither Jaräsandha nor Bhémasena became fatigued or defeated in the fighting, although they struck each other continually. At the end of a day's fighting, both lived at night as friends in Jaräsandha's palace, and the next day they fought again. In this way they passed twenty-seven days in fighting.

On the twenty-eighth day, Bhémasena told Kåñëa, "My dear Kåñëa, I must frankly admit that I cannot conquer Jaräsandha." Lord Kåñëa, however, knew the mystery of the birth of Jaräsandha. Jaräsandha was born in two different parts from two different mothers. When his father saw that the baby was useless, he threw the two parts in the forest, where they were later found by a black-hearted witch named Jarä. She managed to join the two parts of the baby from top to bottom. Knowing this, Lord Kåñëa therefore also knew how to kill him. He gave hints to Bhémasena that since Jaräsandha was brought to life by the joining of the two parts of his body, he could be killed by the separation of these two parts. Thus Lord Kåñëa transferred His power into the body of Bhémasena and informed him of the device by which Jaräsandha could be killed. Lord Kåñëa immediately picked up a twig from a tree and, taking it in His hand, bifurcated it. In this way He hinted to Bhémasena how Jaräsandha could be killed. Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is omnipotent, and if He wants to kill someone, no one can save that person. Similarly, if He wants to save someone, no one can kill him.

Informed by the hints of Lord Kåñëa, Bhémasena immediately took hold of the legs of Jaräsandha and threw him to the ground. When Jaräsandha fell to the ground, Bhémasena immediately pressed one of Jaräsandha's legs to the ground and took hold of the other leg with his two hands. Catching Jaräsandha in this way, he tore his body in two, beginning from the anus up to the head. As an elephant breaks the branches of a tree in two, so Bhémasena separated the body of Jaräsandha. The audience standing nearby saw that the body of Jaräsandha was now divided into two halves, so that each half had one leg, one thigh, one testicle, one breast, half a backbone, half a chest, one collarbone, one arm, one eye, one ear, and half a face.

As soon as the news of Jaräsandha's death was announced, all the citizens of Magadha began to cry, "Alas, alas," while Lord Kåñëa and Arjuna embraced Bhémasena to congratulate him. Although Jaräsandha was killed, neither Kåñëa nor the two Päëòava brothers made a claim to the throne. Their purpose in killing Jaräsandha was to stop him from creating a disturbance against the proper discharge of world peace. A demon always creates disturbances, whereas a demigod always tries to keep peace in the world. The mission of Lord Kåñëa is to give protection to the righteous persons and to kill the demons who disturb a peaceful situation. Therefore Lord Kåñëa immediately called for the son of Jaräsandha, whose name was Sahadeva, and with due ritualistic ceremonies He asked him to occupy the seat of his father and reign over the kingdom peacefully. Lord Kåñëa is the master of the whole cosmic creation, and He wants everyone to live peacefully and execute Kåñëa consciousness. After installing Sahadeva on the throne, He released all the kings and princes who had been imprisoned unnecessarily by Jaräsandha.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Seventeenth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Liberation of King Jaräsandha."

KB 1970-2-18 / Lord Kåñëa Returns to the City of Hastinäpura

18 /Lord Kåñëa Returns to the City of Hastinäpura

The kings and the princes released by Lord Kåñëa after the death of Jaräsandha were rulers of different parts of the world. Jaräsandha was so powerful in military strength that he had conquered all these princes and kings, numbering 20,800. They were all incarcerated within a mountain cave especially constructed as a fort, and for a long time they were kept in that situation. When they were released by the grace of Lord Kåñëa, they all looked very unhappy, their garments were niggardly, and their faces were almost dried up for want of proper bodily care. They were very weak due to hunger, and their faces had lost all beauty and luster. Because of the kings' long imprisonment, every part of their bodies had become slackened and invalid. But although suffering in that miserable condition of life, they had the opportunity to think about the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu.

Now before them they saw the color of the transcendental body of Lord Kåñëa, exactly like the hue of a newly arrived cloud in the sky. He appeared before them nicely covered by yellow colored silken garments, with four hands like Viñëu, and carrying the different symbols of the club, the conchshell, the disc and the lotus flower. There were marks of golden lines on His chest, and the nipples of His breast appeared to be like the whorl of a lotus flower. His eyes appeared to be spread like the petals of a lotus flower, and His smiling face exhibited the symbol of eternal peace and prosperity. His glittering earrings were set beautifully, and His helmet was bedecked with valuable jewels. The Lord's necklace of pearls and the bangles and bracelets nicely situated on His body all shone with a transcendental beauty. The Kaustubha jewel hanging on His chest glittered with great luster, and the Lord wore a beautiful flower garland. After so much distress, when the kings and princes saw Lord Kåñëa, with His beautiful transcendental features, they looked upon Him to their hearts' content, as if they were drinking nectar through their eyes, licking His body with their tongues, smelling the aroma of His body with their noses, and embracing Him with their arms. Just by dint of their being in front of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, all reactions to their sinful activities were washed away. Therefore, without reservation, they surrendered themselves at the lotus feet of the Lord. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.28] that unless one is freed from all kinds of sinful reactions, one cannot fully surrender unto the lotus feet of the Lord. All the princes who saw Lord Kåñëa forgot all their past tribulations. With folded hands and with great devotion, they began to offer prayers to Lord Kåñëa, as follows.

"Dear Lord, O Supreme Personality of Godhead, master of all demigods, You can immediately remove all Your devotees' pangs because Your devotees are fully surrendered unto You. O dear Lord Kåñëa, O eternal Deity of transcendental bliss and knowledge, You are imperishable, and we offer our respectful obeisances unto Your lotus feet. It is by Your causeless mercy that we have been released from the imprisonment of Jaräsandha, but now we pray unto You to release us from the imprisonment with the illusory energy of this material existence. Please, therefore, stop our continuous cycle of birth and death. We now have sufficient experience of the miserable material condition of life in which we are fully absorbed, and having tasted its bitterness, we have come to take shelter under Your lotus feet. Dear Lord, O killer of the demon Madhu, we can now clearly see that Jaräsandha was not at fault in the least; it is actually by Your causeless mercy that we were bereft of our kingdoms because we were very proud of calling ourselves rulers and kings. Any ruler or king who becomes too puffed up with false prestige and power does not get the opportunity to understand his real constitutional position and eternal life. Such foolish so-called rulers and kings become falsely proud of their position under the influence of Your illusory energy; they are just like a foolish person who considers a mirage in the desert to be a reservoir of water. Foolish persons think that their material possessions will give them protection, and those who are engaged in sense gratification falsely accept this material world as a place of eternal enjoyment. O Lord, O Supreme Personality of Godhead, we must admit that, before this, we were puffed up with our material opulences. Because we were all envious of each other and wanted to conquer one another, we all engaged in fighting for supremacy, even at the cost of sacrificing the lives of many citizens."

This is the disease of political power. As soon as a king or a nation becomes rich in material opulences, it wants to dominate other nations by military aggression. Similarly, mercantile men want to monopolize a certain type of business and control other mercantile groups. Degraded by false prestige and infatuated by material opulences, human society, instead of striving for Kåñëa consciousness, creates havoc and disrupts peaceful living. Thus men naturally forget the real purpose of life: to attain the favor of Lord Viñëu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The kings continued: "O Lord, we were simply engaged in the abominable task of killing citizens and alluring them to be unnecessarily killed, just to satisfy our political whims. We did not consider that Your Lordship is always present before us in the form of cruel death. We were so fooled that we became the cause of death for others, forgetting our own impending death. But, dear Lord, the retaliation of the time element, which is Your representative, is certainly insurmountable. The time element is so strong that no one can escape its influence; therefore we have received the reactions of our atrocious activities, and we are now bereft of all opulences and stand before You like street beggars. We consider our position to be Your causeless, unalloyed mercy upon us because now we can understand that we were falsely proud and that our material opulences could be withdrawn from us within a second by Your will. By Your causeless mercy only, we are now able to think of Your lotus feet. This is our greatest gain. Dear Lord, it is known to everyone that the body is a breeding ground of diseases. Now we are sufficiently aged, and instead of being proud of our bodily strength, we are getting weaker day by day. We are no longer interested in sense gratification or the false happiness derived through the material body. By Your grace, we have now come to the conclusion that hankering after such material happiness is just like searching for water in a desert mirage. We are no longer interested in the results of our pious activities, such as performing great sacrifices in order to be elevated to the heavenly planets. We now understand that such elevation to a higher material standard of life in the heavenly planets may sound very relishable, but actually there cannot be any happiness within this material world. We pray for Your Lordship to favor us by instructing us how to engage in the transcendental loving service of Your lotus feet so that we may never forget our eternal relationship with Your Lordship. We do not want liberation from the entanglement of material existence. By Your will we may take birth in any species of life; it does not matter. We simply pray that we may never forget Your lotus feet under any circumstances. Dear Lord, we now surrender unto Your lotus feet by offering our respectful obeisances unto You because You are the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, the son of Vasudeva. You are the Supersoul in everyone's heart, and You are Lord Hari, who can take away all miserable conditions of material existence. Dear Lord, Your name is Govinda, the reservoir of all pleasure. One who is engaged in satisfying Your senses automatically satisfies his own senses also, and therefore You are known as Govinda. Dear Lord, You are ever famous, for You can put an end to all the miseries of Your devotees. Please, therefore, accept us as Your surrendered servants."

After hearing the prayers of the kings released from the prison of Jaräsandha, Lord Kåñëa, who is always the protector of surrendered souls and the ocean of mercy for the devotees, replied to them as follows in His sweetly transcendental voice, which was grave and full of meaning. "My dear kings," He said, "I bestow upon you My blessings. From this day forth you will be attached to My devotional service without fail. I give you this benediction, as you have desired. You may know from Me that I am always sitting within your hearts as Supersoul, and because you have now turned your faces towards Me, I, as master of everyone, shall always give you good counsel so that you may never forget Me and so that gradually you will come back home, back to Godhead. My dear kings, your decision to give up all conceptions of material enjoyment and turn instead toward My devotional service is factually the symptom of your good fortune. Henceforward you will always be blessed with blissful life. I confirm that all you have spoken about Me in your prayers is factual. It is a fact that the materially opulent position of one who is not fully Kåñëa conscious is the cause of his downfall and of his becoming a victim of the illusory energy. In the past, there were many rebellious kings, such as Haihaya, Nahuña, Vena, Rävaëa and Narakäsura. Some of them were demigods, and some of them were demons, but because of their false perception of their positions, they fell from their exalted posts, and thus they no longer remained the kings of their respective kingdoms.

"While lost in the violence of conditional life, every one of you must understand that anything material has its starting point, growth, expansion, deterioration, and, finally, disappearance. All material bodies are subjected to these six conditions, and any relative acquisitions which are accumulated by this body are definitely subject to final destruction. Therefore, no one should be attached to perishable things. As long as one is within this material body, he should be very cautious in worldly dealings. The most perfect way of life in this material world is simply to be devoted to My transcendental loving service and to honestly execute the prescribed duties of one's particular position of life. As far as you are concerned, you all belong to kñatriya families. Therefore, you should live honestly, according to the prescribed duties befitting the royal order, and you should make your citizens happy in all respects. Keep to the standard of kñatriya life. Do not beget children out of sense gratification, but simply take charge of the welfare of the people in general. Everyone takes birth in this material world because of the contaminated desires of his previous life, and thus he is subjected to the stringent laws of nature, such as birth and death, distress and happiness, profit and loss. One should not be disturbed by duality, but should always be fixed in My service and thus remain balanced in mind and satisfied in all circumstances, considering all things to be given by Me, and one should remain undeviated from engagement in devotional service. Thus one can live a very happy and peaceful life, even within this material condition. In other words, one should actually be callous to this material body and its by-products and should remain unaffected by them. He should remain fully satisfied in the interests of the spirit soul and be engaged in the service of the Supersoul. One should engage his mind only on Me, one should simply become My devotee, one should simply worship Me, and one should offer his respectful obeisances unto Me alone. In this way, one can cross over this ocean of nescience very easily and at the end come back to Me. In conclusion, your lives should constantly be engaged in My service."

After delivering His instructions to the kings and princes, Lord Kåñëa immediately arranged for their comfort and asked many servants and maidservants to take care of them. Lord Kåñëa requested Sahadeva, the son of King Jaräsandha, to supply all necessities to the kings and also asked him to show them all respect and honor. In pursuance of the order of Lord Kåñëa, Sahadeva offered them all honor, and presented them with ornaments, garments, garlands, and other paraphernalia. After taking their baths and dressing very nicely, the kings appeared happy and gentle. Then they were supplied nice foodstuffs. Lord Kåñëa supplied everything for their comfort, as was befitting their royal positions. Since the kings were so mercifully treated by Lord Kåñëa, they felt great happiness, and all their bright faces appeared just like the stars in the sky after the end of the rainy season. They were all nicely dressed and ornamented, and their earrings glittered. Each one was then seated on a chariot bedecked with gold and jewels and drawn by decorated horses. After seeing that each was taken care of, Lord Kåñëa, in a sweet voice, asked them to return to their respective kingdoms. By His very liberal behavior, unparalleled in the history of the world, Lord Kåñëa released all the kings who had been in the clutches of Jaräsandha, and being fully satisfied, the kings began to engage in chanting His holy name, thinking of His holy form, and glorifying His transcendental pastimes as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So engaged, they returned to their respective kingdoms. The citizens of their kingdoms were very greatly pleased to see them return, and when they heard of the kind dealings of Lord Kåñëa, they all became very happy. The kings began to manage the affairs of their kingdoms in accordance with the instructions of Lord Kåñëa, and all those kings and their subjects passed their days very happily. This is the vivid example of the Kåñëa conscious society. If the people of the world divide the whole society, in terms of their respective material qualities, into four orders for material and spiritual progress, centering around Kåñëa and following the instructions of Kåñëa as stated in Bhagavad-gétä, the entire human society will undoubtedly be happy. This is the lesson that we have to take from this incident.

After thus causing the annihilation of Jaräsandha by Bhémasena and after being properly honored by Sahadeva, the son of Jaräsandha, Lord Kåñëa, accompanied by Bhémasena and Arjuna, returned to the city of Hastinäpura. When they reached the precincts of Hastinäpura, they blew their respective conchshells, and by hearing the sound vibrations and understanding who was arriving, everyone immediately became cheerful. But upon hearing the conchshells, the enemies of Kåñëa became very sorry. The citizens of Indraprastha felt their hearts become joyful simply by hearing the vibration of Kåñëa's conchshell because they could understand that Jaräsandha had been killed. Now the performance of the Räjasüya sacrifice by King Yudhiñöhira was almost certain. Bhémasena, Arjuna, and Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, arrived before King Yudhiñöhira and offered their respects to the King. King Yudhiñöhira attentively heard the narration of the killing of Jaräsandha and the setting free of the kings. He also heard of the tactics which were adopted by Kåñëa to kill Jaräsandha. The king was naturally affectionate toward Kåñëa, but after hearing the story, he became even more bound in love for Kåñëa; tears of ecstasy glided from his eyes, and he became so stunned that he was almost unable to speak.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Eighteenth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Lord Kåñëa Returns to the City of Hastinäpura."

KB 1970-2-19 / The Deliverance of Çiçupäla

19 /The Deliverance of Çiçupäla

King Yudhiñöhira became very happy after hearing the details of the Jaräsandha episode, and he spoke as follows: "My dear Kåñëa, O eternal form of bliss and knowledge, all the exalted directors of the affairs of this material world, including Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva and King Indra, are always anxious to receive and carry out orders from You, and whenever they are fortunate enough to receive such orders, they immediately take them and keep them in their hearts. O Kåñëa, You are unlimited, and although we sometimes think of ourselves as royal kings and rulers of the world and become puffed up over our paltry positions, we are very poor in heart. Actually, we are fit to be punished by You, but the wonder is that instead of punishing us, You so kindly and mercifully accept our orders and carry them out properly. Others are very surprised that Your Lordship can play the part of an ordinary human, but we can understand that You are performing these activities just like a dramatic artist. Your real position is always exalted, exactly like that of the sun, which always remains at the same temperature both during the time of its rising and the time of its setting. Although we feel the difference in temperature between the rising and the setting sun, the temperature of the sun never changes. You are always transcendentally equiposed, and thus You are neither pleased nor disturbed by any condition of material affairs. You are the Supreme Brahman, the Personality of Godhead, and for You there are no relativities. My dear Mädhava, You are never defeated by anyone. Material distinctions—'This is me.' 'This is you.' 'This is mine.' 'This is yours.'—are all conspicious by dint of their absence in You. Such distinctions are visible in the lives of everyone, even the animals, but those who are pure devotees are freed from these false distinctions. Since these distinctions are absent in Your devotees, they cannot possibly be present in You."

After satisfying Kåñëa in this way, King Yudhiñöhira arranged to perform the Räjasüya sacrifice. He invited all the qualified brähmaëas and sages to take part and appointed them to different positions as priests in charge of the sacrificial arena. He invited the most expert brähmaëas and sages, whose names are as follows: Kåñëa-dvaipäyana Vyäsadeva, Bharadväja, Sumantu, Gautama, Asita, Vasiñöha, Cyavana, Kaëva, Maitreya, Kavaña, Trita, Viçvämitra, Vämadeva, Sumati, Jaimini, Kratu, Paila, Paräçara, Garga, Vaiçampäyana, Atharvä, Kaçyapa, Dhaumya, Paraçuräma, Çukräcärya, Äsuri, Vétihotra, Madhucchandä, Vérasena, and Akåtavraëa. Besides all these brähmaëas and sages, he invited such respectful old men as Droëäcärya, Bhéñma, the grandfather of the Kurus, Kåpäcärya, and Dhåtaräñöra. He also invited all the sons of Dhåtaräñöra, headed by Duryodhana, and the great devotee Vidura was also invited. Kings from different parts of the world, along with their ministers and secretaries, were also invited to see the great sacrifice performed by King Yudhiñöhira, and the citizens, comprising learned brähmaëas, chivalrous kñatriyas, well-to-do vaiçyas, and faithful çüdras, all visited the ceremony.

The brähmaëa priests and sages in charge of the sacrificial ceremony constructed the sacrificial arena as usual with a plow of gold, and they initiated King Yudhiñöhira as the performer of the great sacrifice, in accordance with Vedic rituals. Long years ago, when Varuëa performed a similar sacrifice, all the sacrificial utensils were made of gold. Similarly, in the Räjasüya sacrifice of King Yudhiñöhira, all the utensils required for the sacrifice were golden.

In order to participate in the great sacrifice performed by King Yudhiñöhira, all the exalted demigods like Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, and Indra the King of heaven, accompanied by their associates, as well as the predominating deities of higher planetary systems like Gandharvaloka, Siddhaloka, Janaloka, Tapoloka, Nägaloka, Yakñaloka, Räkñasaloka, Pakñiloka and Cäraëaloka, as well as famous kings and their queens, were all present by the invitation of King Yudhiñöhira. All the respectable sages, kings and demigods who assembled there unanimously agreed that King Yudhiñöhira was quite competent to take the responsibility of performing the Räjasüya sacrifice; no one was in disagreement on this fact. All of them knew thoroughly the position of King Yudhiñöhira; because he was a great devotee of Lord Kåñëa, no accomplishment was extraordinary for him. The learned brähmaëas and priests saw to it that the sacrifice by Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira was performed in exactly the same way as in bygone ages by the demigod Varuëa. According to the Vedic system, whenever there is an arrangement for sacrifice, the members participating in the sacrifice are offered the juice of the soma plant. The juice of the soma plant is a kind of life-giving beverage. On the day of extracting the soma juice, King Yudhiñöhira very respectfully received the special priest who had been engaged to detect any mistake in the formalities of sacrificial procedures. The idea is that the Vedic mantras must be enuciated perfectly and chanted with the proper accent; if the priests who are engaged in this business commit any mistake, the checker or referee priest immediately corrects the procedure, and thus the ritualistic performances are perfectly executed. Unless it is perfectly executed, a sacrifice cannot yield the desired result. In this age of Kali there is no such learned brähmaëa or priest available; therefore, all such sacrifices are forbidden. The only sacrifice recommended in the çästras is the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra.

Another important procedure is that the most exalted personality in the assembly of such a sacrificial ceremony is first offered worship. After all arrangements were made for Yudhiñöhira's sacrifice, the next consideration was who should be worshiped first in the ceremony. This particular ceremony is called Agrapüjä. Agra means first, and püjä means worship. This Agrapüjä is similar to election of the president. In the sacrificial assembly, all the members were very exalted. Some proposed to elect one person as the perfect candidate for accepting Agrapüjä, and others proposed someone else.

When the matter remained undecided, Sahadeva began to speak in favor of Lord Kåñëa. He said, "Lord Kåñëa, the best amongst the members of the Yadu dynasty and the protector of His devotees, is the most exalted personality in this assembly. Therefore I think that He should without any objection be offered the honor of being worshiped first. Although demigods such as Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, Indra, the King of heavenly planets, and many other exalted personalities are present in this assembly, no one can be equal to or greater than Kåñëa in terms of time, space, riches, strength, reputation, wisdom, renunciation or any other consideration. Anything which is considered opulent is present originally in Kåñëa. As an individual soul is the basic principle of the growth of his material body, similarly Kåñëa is the Supersoul of this cosmic manifestation. All kinds of Vedic ritualistic ceremonies, such as the performance of sacrifices, the offering of oblations in the fire, the chanting of the Vedic hymns and the practice of mystic yoga—all are meant for realizing Kåñëa. Whether one follows the path of fruitive activities or the path of philosophical speculation, the ultimate destination is Kåñëa; all bona fide methods of self-realization are meant for understanding Kåñëa. Ladies and gentlemen, it is superfluous to speak about Kåñëa, because every one of you exalted personalities know the Supreme Brahman, Lord Kåñëa, for whom there are no material differences between body and soul, between energy and the energetic, or between one part of the body and another. Since everyone is a part and parcel of Kåñëa, there is no qualitative difference between Kåñëa and all living entities. Everything is an emanation of Kåñëa's energies, the material and spiritual energies. Kåñëa's energies are like the heat and light of the fire; there is no difference between the quality of heat and light and the fire itself.

"Also, Kåñëa can do anything He likes with any part of His body. We can execute a particular action with the help of a particular part of our body, but He can do anything and everything with any part of His body. And because His transcendental body is full of knowledge and bliss in eternity, He doesn't undergo the six kinds of material changes—birth, existence, growth, fruitive action, dwindling and vanishing. Unforced by any external energy, He is the supreme cause of the creation, maintenance and dissolution of everything that be. By the grace of Kåñëa only, everyone is engaged in the practice of religiousness, the development of economic conditions, the satisfaction of the senses and, ultimately, the achievement of liberation from material bondage. These four principles of progressive life can be executed by the mercy of Kåñëa only. He should therefore be offered the first worship of this great sacrifice, and no one should disagree. As by watering the root, the watering of the branches, twigs, leaves and flowers is automatically accomplished, or as by supplying food to the stomach, the nutrition and metabolism of all parts of the body are automatically established, so by offering the first worship to Kåñëa, everyone present in this meeting—including the great demigods—will be satisfied. If anyone is charitably disposed, it will be very good for him to give in charity only to Kåñëa, who is the Supersoul of everyone, regardless of his particular body or individual personality. Kåñëa is present as the Supersoul in every living being, and if we can satisfy Him, then automatically every living being becomes satisfied."

Sahadeva was fortunate to know of the glories of Kåñëa, and after describing them in brief, he stopped speaking. After this speech was delivered, all the members present in that great sacrificial assembly applauded, confirming his words continuously by saying, "Everything that you have said is completely perfect. Everything that you have said is completely perfect." King Yudhiñöhira, after hearing the confirmation of all present, especially of the brähmaëas and learned sages, worshiped Lord Kåñëa according to the regulative principles of the Vedic injunctions. First of all, King Yudhiñöhira—along with his brothers, wives, children, other relatives and ministers—washed the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa and sprinkled the water on their heads. After this, Lord Kåñëa was offered various kinds of silken garments of yellow color, and heaps of jewelry and ornaments were presented before Him for His use.

King Yudhiñöhira felt such ecstasy by honoring Kåñëa, who was his only lovable object, that tears glided down from his eyes, and although He wanted to, he could not see Lord Kåñëa very well. Lord Kåñëa was thus worshiped by King Yudhiñöhira. At that time all the members present in that assembly stood up with folded hands and began to chant, "Jaya! Jaya! Namaù! Namaù!" When all joined together to offer their respectful obeisances to Kåñëa, there were showers of flowers from the sky.

In that meeting, King Çiçupäla was also present. He was an avowed enemy of Kåñëa for many reasons, especially because of Kåñëa's having stolen Rukmiëé from the marriage ceremony; therefore, he could not tolerate such honor to Kåñëa and glorification of His qualities. Instead of being happy to hear the glories of the Lord, he became very angry. When everyone offered respect to Kåñëa by standing up, Çiçupäla remained in his seat, but when he became angry at Kåñëa's being honored, Çiçupäla stood up suddenly, and, raising his hand, began to speak very strongly and fearlessly against Lord Kåñëa. He spoke in such a way that Lord Kåñëa could hear him very distinctly.

"Ladies and gentlemen, I can appreciate now the statement of the Vedas that, after all, time is the predominating factor. In spite of all endeavors to the contrary, the time element executes its own plan without opposition. For example, one may try his best to live, but when the time for death comes, no one can check it. I see here that although there are many stalwart personalities present in this assembly, the influence of time is so strong that they have been misled by the statement of a boy who has foolishly spoken about Kåñëa. There are many learned sages and elderly persons present, but still they have accepted the statement of a foolish boy. This means that by the influence of time, even the intelligence of such honored persons as are present in this meeting can be misdirected. I fully agree with the respectable persons present here that they are competent enough to select the personality who can be first worshiped, but I cannot agree with the statement of a boy like Sahadeva, who has spoken so highly about Kåñëa and has recommended that Kåñëa is fit to accept the first worship in the sacrifice. I can see that in this meeting there are many personalities who have undergone great austerities, who are highly learned and who have performed many penances. By their knowledge and direction, they can deliver many persons who are suffering from the pangs of material existence. There are great åñis here whose knowledge has no bounds, as well as many self-realized persons and brähmaëas also, and therefore I think that any one of them could have been selected for the first worship because they are worshipable even by the great demigods, kings and emperors. I cannot understand how you could have selected this cowherd boy, Kåñëa, and have left aside all these other great personalities. I think Kåñëa to be no better than a crow—how can He be fit to accept the first worship in this great sacrifice?

"We cannot even ascertain as yet to which caste this Kåñëa belongs or what His actual occupational duty is." Actually, Kåñëa does not belong to any caste, nor does He have to perform any occupational duty. It is stated in the Vedas that the Supreme Lord has nothing to do as His prescribed duty. Whatever has to be done on His behalf is executed by His different energies.

Çiçupäla continued: "Kåñëa does not belong to a high family. He is so independent that no one knows His principles of religious life. It appears that He is outside the jurisdiction of all religious principles. He always acts independently, not caring for the Vedic injunctions and regulative principles. Therefore He is devoid of all good qualities." Çiçupäla indirectly praised Kåñëa by saying that He is not within the jurisdiction of Vedic injunction. This is true because He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. That He has no qualities means that Kåñëa has no material qualities, and because He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, He acts independently, not caring for conventions or social or religious principles.

Çiçupäla continued: "Under these circumstances, how can He be fit to accept the first worship in the sacrifice? Kåñëa is so foolish that He has left Mathurä, which is inhabited by highly elevated persons following the Vedic culture, and He has taken shelter in the ocean, where there is not even talk of the Vedas. Instead of living openly, He has constructed a fort within the water and is living in an atmosphere where there is no discussion of Vedic knowledge. And whenever He comes out of the fort, He simply harrasses the citizens like a dacoit, thief or rogue."

Çiçupäla went crazy because of Kåñëa's being elected the supreme first-worshiped person in that meeting, and he spoke so irresponsibly that it appeared that he had lost all his good fortune. Being overcast with misfortune, Çiçupäla continued to insult Kåñëa further, and Lord Kåñëa patiently heard him without protest. Just as a lion does not care when a flock of jackals howl, Lord Kåñëa remained silent and unprovoked. Kåñëa did not reply to even a single accusation made by Çiçupäla, but all the members present in the meeting, except a few who agreed with Çiçupäla, became very agitated because it is the duty of any respectable person not to tolerate blasphemy against God or His devotee. Some of them, who thought that they could not properly take action against Çiçupäla, left the assembly in protest, covering their ears with their hands in order not to hear further accusations. Thus they left the meeting condemning the action of Çiçupäla. It is the Vedic injunction that whenever there is blasphemy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one must immediately leave. If he does not do so, he becomes bereft of his pious activities and is degraded to the lower condition of life.

All the kings present, belonging to the Kuru dynasty, Matsya dynasty, Kekaya dynasty and Såïjaya dynasty, became very angry and immediately took up their swords and shields to kill Çiçupäla. Çiçupäla was so foolish that he did not become even slightly agitated, although all the kings present were ready to kill him. He did not care to think of the pros and cons of his foolish talking, and when he saw that all the kings were ready to kill him, instead of stopping, he stood to fight with them and took up his sword and shield. When Lord Kåñëa saw that they were going to engage in fighting in the arena of the auspicious Räjasüya yajïa, He personally pacified them. Out of His causeless mercy He Himself decided to kill Çiçupäla. When Çiçupäla was abusing the kings who were about to attack him, Lord Kåñëa took up His disc, which was as sharp as the blade of a razor, and immediately separated the head of Çiçupäla from his body.

When Çiçupäla was thus killed, a great roar and howl went up from the crowd of that assembly. Taking advantage of that disturbance, the few kings who were supporters of Çiçupäla quickly left the assembly out of fear of their lives. But despite all this, the fortunate Çiçupäla's spirit soul immediately merged into the body of Lord Kåñëa in the presence of all members, exactly as a burning meteor falls to the surface of the globe. Çiçupäla's soul's merging into the transcendental body of Kåñëa reminds us of the story of Jaya and Vijaya, who fell to the material world from the Vaikuëöha planets upon being cursed by the four Kumäras. For their return to the Vaikuëöha world, it was arranged that both Jaya and Vijaya for three consecutive births would act as deadly enemies of the Lord, and at the end of these lives they would again return to the Vaikuëöha world and serve the Lord as His associates.

Although Çiçupäla acted as the enemy of Kåñëa, he was not for a single moment out of Kåñëa consciousness. He was always absorbed in thought of Kåñëa, and thus he got first the salvation of säyujya-mukti, merging into the existence of the Supreme, and finally became reinstated in his original position of personal service. The Bhagavad-gétä [8.5-7] corroborates the fact that if one is absorbed in the thought of the Supreme Lord at the time of death, he immediately enters the kingdom of God after quitting his material body. After the salvation of Çiçupäla, King Yudhiñöhira rewarded all the members present in the sacrificial assembly. He sufficiently remunerated the priests and the learned sages for their engagement in the execution of the sacrifice, and after performing all this routine work, he took his bath. This bath at the end of the sacrifice is also technical. It is called the avabhåtha bath.

Lord Kåñëa thus enabled the performance of the Räjasüya yajïa arranged by King Yudhiñöhira to be successfully completed, and, being requested by His cousins and relatives, He remained in Hastinäpura for a few months more. Although King Yudhiñöhira and his brothers were not willing to have Lord Kåñëa leave Hastinäpura, Kåñëa arranged to take permission from the King to return to Dvärakä, and thus He returned home along with His queens and ministers.

The story of the fall of Jaya and Vijaya from the Vaikuëöha planets to the material world is described in the Seventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The killing of Çiçupäla has a direct link with that narration of Jaya and Vijaya, but the most important instruction that we get from this incident is that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, being absolute, can give salvation to everyone, whether one acts as His enemy or as His friend. It is therefore a misconception that the Lord acts with someone in the relationship of a friend and with someone else in the relationship of an enemy. His being an enemy or friend is always on the absolute platform. There is no material distinction.

After King Yudhiñöhira took his bath after the sacrifice and stood in the midst of all the learned sages and brähmaëas, he seemed exactly like the King of heaven and thus looked very beautiful. King Yudhiñöhira sufficiently rewarded all the demigods who participated in the yajïa, and being greatly satisfied, all of them left praising the King's activities and glorifying Lord Kåñëa.

When Çukadeva Gosvämé was narrating these incidents of Kåñëa's killing Çiçupäla and describing the successful execution of the Räjasüya yajïa by Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira, he pointed out also that after the successful termination of the yajïa there was only one person who was not happy. He was Duryodhana. Duryodhana by nature was very envious because of his sinful life, and he appeared in the dynasty of the Kurus as a chronic disease personified in order to destroy the whole family.

Çukadeva Gosvämé assured Mahäräja Parékñit that the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa—the killing of Çiçupäla and Jaräsandha and the releasing of the imprisoned kings—are all transcendental vibrations, and anyone who hears these narrations from the authorized persons will be immediately freed from all the reactions of the sinful activities of his life.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Nineteenth Chapter of Kåñëa, "The Deliverance of Çiçupäla."

KB 1970-2-20 / Why Duryodhana Felt Insulted at the End of the Räjasüya Sacrifice

20 /Why Duryodhana Felt Insulted at the End of the Räjasüya Sacrifice

King Yudhiñöhira was known as ajätaçatru, or a person who has no enemy. Therefore, when all men, all demigods, all kings, sages and saints saw the successful termination of the Räjasüya yajïa performed by King Yudhiñöhira, they became very happy. That Duryodhana alone was not happy was astonishing to Mahäräja Parékñit, and therefore he requested Çukadeva Gosvämé to explain this.

Çukadeva Gosvämé said, "My dear King Parékñit, your grandfather, King Yudhiñöhira, was a great soul. His congenial disposition attracted everyone as his friend, and therefore he was known as ajätaçatru, one who never created an enemy. He engaged all the members of the Kuru dynasty in taking charge of different departments for the management of the Räjasüya sacrifice. For example, Bhémasena was put in charge of the kitchen department, Duryodhana in charge of the treasury department, Sahadeva in charge of the reception department, Nakula in charge of the store department, and Arjuna was engaged in looking after the comforts of the elderly persons. The most astonishing feature was that Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, took charge of washing the feet of all the incoming guests. The Queen, the goddess of fortune Draupadé, was in charge of administering the distribution of food, and because Karëa was famous for giving charity, he was put in charge of the charity department. In this way Sätyaki, Vikarëa, Härdikya, Vidura, Bhüriçravä, and Santardana, the son of Bähléka, were all engaged in different departments for managing the affairs of the Räjasüya sacrifice. They were all so bound in loving affection for King Yudhiñöhira that they simply wanted to please him.

After Çiçupäla had died by the mercy of Lord Kåñëa and had become merged in the spiritual existence, and after the end of the Räjasüya yajïa, when all friends, guests and well-wishers had been sufficiently honored and rewarded, King Yudhiñöhira went to bathe in the Ganges. The city of Hastinäpura is today standing on the bank of the Yamunä, and the statement of Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.75.19] that King Yudhiñöhira went to bathe in the Ganges indicates, therefore, that during the time of the Päëòavas, the River Yamunä was also known as the Ganges. While the King was taking the avabhåtha bath, different musical instruments, such as mådaìgas, conchshells, drums, kettledrums and bugles, vibrated. In addition, the ankle bells of the dancing girls jingled. Many groups of professional singers played véëäs, flutes, gongs and cymbals, and thus a tumultuous sound vibrated in the sky. The princely guests from many kingdoms, like Såïjaya, Kämboja, Kuru, Kekaya and Koçala, were present with their different flags and gorgeously decorated elephants, chariots, horses and soldiers. All were passing in a procession, and King Yudhiñöhira was in the forefront. The executive members, such as the priests, religious ministers and brähmaëas, were performing a sacrifice, and all were loudly chanting the Vedic hymns. The demigods, the inhabitants of the Pitåloka and Gandharvaloka, as well as many sages, showered flowers from the sky. The men and women of Hastinäpura, Indraprastha, their bodies smeared with scents and floral oils, were nicely dressed in colorful garments and decorated with garlands, jewels and ornaments. They were all enjoying the ceremony, and they threw on each other liquid substances like water, oil, milk, butter and yogurt. Some even smeared these on each other's bodies. In this way, they were enjoying the occasion. The professional prostitutes were also engaged by jubilantly smearing these liquid substances on the bodies of the men, and the men reciprocated in the same way. All the liquid substances had been mixed with turmeric and saffron, and their color was a lustrous yellow.

In order to observe the great ceremony, many wives of the demigods had come in different airplanes, and they were visible in the sky. Similarly, the queens of the royal family arrived gorgeously decorated and surrounded by bodyguards on the surface on different palaquins. During this time, Lord Kåñëa, the maternal cousin of the Päëòavas, and His special friend Arjuna, were both throwing the liquid substances on the bodies of the queens. The queens became bashful, but at the same time their beautiful smiling brightened their faces. Because of the liquid substances thrown on their bodies, the saris covering them became completely wet. The different parts of their beautiful bodies, particularly their breasts and their waists, became partially visible because of the wet cloth. The queens also brought in buckets of liquid substances and sprinkled them on the bodies of their brothers-in-law. As they engaged in such jubilant activities, their hair fell loose, and the flowers decorating their bodies began to fall. When Lord Kåñëa, Arjuna and the queens were thus engaged in these jubilant activities, persons who were not clean in heart became agitated by lustful desires. In other words, such behavior between pure males and females is enjoyable, but persons who are materially contaminated become lustful.

King Yudhiñöhira, in a gorgeous chariot yoked by excellent horses, was present with his queens, including Draupadé and others. The festivities of the sacrifice were so beautiful that it appeared as if Räjasüya was standing there in person with the functions of the sacrifice.

Following the Räjasüya sacrifice, there was the Vedic ritualistic duty known as patnésaàyäja. This sacrifice was performed along with one's wife, and it was also duly performed by the priests of King Yudhiñöhira. When Queen Draupadé and King Yudhiñöhira were taking their avabhåtha bath, the citizens of Hastinäpura as well as the demigods began to beat on drums and blow trumpets out of feelings of happiness, and there was a shower of flowers from the sky. When the King and the Queen finished their bath in the Ganges, all the other citizens, consisting of all the varëas or castes—the brähmaëas, the kñatriyas, the vaiçyas, and the çüdras—took their baths in the Ganges. Bathing in the Ganges is recommended in the Vedic literatures because by such bathing one becomes freed from all sinful reactions. This is still current in India, especially at particularly auspicious moments. At such times, millions of people bathe in the Ganges.

After taking his bath, King Yudhiñöhira dressed in a new silken cloth and wrapper and decorated himself with valuable jewelry. The King not only dressed himself and decorated himself, but he also gave clothing and ornaments to all the priests and to the others who had participated in the yajïas. In this way, they were all worshiped by King Yudhiñöhira. He constantly worshiped his friends, his family members, his relatives, his well-wishers and everyone present, and because he was a great devotee of Lord Näräyaëa, or because he was a Vaiñëava, he therefore knew how to treat everyone well. The Mäyävädi philosophers' endeavor to see everyone as God is an artificial way towards oneness, but a Vaiñëava or a devotee of Lord Näräyaëa sees every living entity as part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. Therefore, a Vaiñëava's treatment of other living entities is on the absolute platform. Since one cannot treat one part of his body differently from another part because they all belong to the same body, so a Vaiñëava does not see a human being as distinct from an animal because in both of them he sees the soul and the Supersoul seated simultaneously.

When everyone was refreshed after bathing and was dressed in silken clothing with jeweled earrings, flower garlands, turbans, long wrappers and pearl necklaces, they looked, altogether, like the demigods from heaven. This was especially true of the women, who were very nicely dressed. Each wore a golden belt around the waist. They were all smiling. Spots of tilaka and curling hair were scattered here and there. This combination was very attractive.

Persons who had participated in the Räjasüya sacrifice—including the most cultured priests, the brähmaëas who had assisted in the performance of the sacrifice, the citizens of all varëas, kings, demigods, sages, saints and citizens of the Pitåloka—were all very much satisfied by the dealings of King Yudhiñöhira, and at the end they happily departed for their residences. While returning to their homes, they talked of the dealings of King Yudhiñöhira, and even after continuous talk of his greatness they were not satiated, just as one may drink nectar over and over again and never be satisfied. After the departure of all others, Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira restrained the inner circle of his friends, including Lord Kåñëa, by not allowing them to leave. Lord Kåñëa could not refuse the request of the King. He therefore sent back all the heroes of the Yadu dynasty, like Sämba and others. All of them returned to Dvärakä, and Lord Kåñëa personally remained in order to give pleasure to the King.

In the material world, everyone has a particular type of desire to be fulfilled, but one is never able to fulfill his desires to his full satisfaction. But King Yudhiñöhira, because of his unflinching devotion to Kåñëa, could fulfill all his desires successfully by the performance of the Räjasüya yajïa. From the description of the execution of the Räjasüya yajïa, it appears that such a function is a great ocean of opulent desires. It is not possible for an ordinary man to cross over such an ocean; nevertheless, by the grace of Lord Kåñëa, King Yudhiñöhira was able to cross over it very easily, and thus he became freed from all anxieties.

When Duryodhana saw that Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira had become very famous after performance of the Räjasüya yajïa and was fully satisfied in every respect, he began to burn with the fire of envy because his mind was always poisonous. For one thing, he envied the imperial palace which had been constructed by the demon Maya for the Päëòavas. The palace was excellent in its puzzling artistic workmanship and was befitting the position of great princes, kings or leaders of the demons. In that great palace, the Päëòavas were living with their family members, and Queen Draupadé was serving her husbands very peacefully. And because in those days Lord Kåñëa was also there, the palace was also decorated by His thousands of queens. When the queens, with their heavy breasts and thin waists, moved within the palace, and their ankle bells rang very melodiously with their movement, the whole palace appeared to be more opulent than the heavenly kingdoms. Because a portion of their breasts was sprinkled with saffron powder, the pearl necklaces on their breast appeared to be reddish. With their full earrings and flowing hair, the queens appeared very beautiful. After looking at such beauties in the palace of King Yudhiñöhira, Duryodhana became envious. He became especially envious and lustful upon seeing the beauty of Draupadé because he had cherished a special attraction for her from the very beginning of her marriage with the Päëòavas. In the marriage selection assembly of Draupadé, Duryodhana had also been present, and with other princes he had been very much captivated by the beauty of Draupadé, but had failed to achieve her.

Once upon a time, King Yudhiñöhira was sitting on the golden throne in the palace constructed by the demon Maya. His four brothers and other relatives, as well as his great well-wisher, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, were present and the material opulence of King Yudhiñöhira seemed no less than that of Lord Brahmä. When he was sitting on the throne surrounded by his friends, and the reciters were offering prayers to him in the form of nice songs, Duryodhana, with his younger brother, came to the palace. Duryodhana was decorated with a helmet, and he carried a sword in his hand. He was always in an envious and angry mood, and therefore, on a slight provocation, he spoke sharply with the doorkeepers and became angry. He was irritated because he failed to distinguish between water and land. By the craftmanship of the demon Maya, the palace was so decorated in different places that one who did not know the tricks would consider water to be land and land to be water. Duryodhana was also illusioned by this craftmanship, and when he was crossing water thinking it to be land, he fell down. When Duryodhana, out of his foollishness, had thus fallen, the queens enjoyed the incident by laughing. King Yudhiñöhira, could understand the feelings of Duryodhana, and he tried to restrain the queens from laughing, but Lord Kåñëa indicated that King Yudhiñöhira should not restrain them from enjoying the incident. Kåñëa desired that Duryodhana might be fooled in that way and that all of them might enjoy his foolish behavior. When everyone laughed, Duryodhana felt very insulted, and his hair stood up in anger. Being thus insulted, he immediately left the palace, bowing his head. He was silent and did not protest. When Duryodhana left in such an angry mood, everyone regretted the incident, and King Yudhiñöhira also became very sorry. But despite all occurrences, Kåñëa was silent. He did not say anything against or in favor of the incident. It appeared that Duryodhana had been put into illusion by the supreme will of Lord Kåñëa, and this was the beginning of the enmity between the two sects of the Kuru dynasty. It appeared that it was a part of Kåñëa's plan in His mission to decrease the burden of the world.

King Parékñit had inquired from Çukadeva Gosvämé as to why Duryodhana was not satisfied after the termination of the great Räjasüya sacrifice, and thus it was explained by Çukadeva Gosvämé.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twentieth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Why Duryodhana Felt Insulted at the End of the Räjasüya Sacrifice."

KB 1970-2-21 / The Battle Between Çälva and the Yadu Dynasty

21 /The Battle Between Çälva and the Yadu Dynasty

While Çukadeva Gosvämé was narrating various activities of Lord Kåñëa in playing the role of an ordinary human being, he also narrated the history of the battle between the dynasty of Yadu and a demon of the name Çälva, who had managed to possess a wonderful airship named Saubha. King Çälva was a great friend of Çiçupäla's. When Çiçupäla went to marry Rukmiëé, Çälva was one of the members of the bridegroom's party. When there was a fight between the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty and the kings of the opposite side, Çälva was defeated by the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty. But, despite his defeat, he made a promise before all the kings that he would in the future rid the whole world of all the members of the Yadu dynasty. Since his defeat in the fight during the marriage of Rukmiëé, he had maintained within himself an unforgettable envy of Lord Kåñëa, and he was, in fact, a fool, because he had promised to kill Kåñëa.

Usually such foolish demons take shelter of a demigod like Lord Çiva to execute their ulterior plans, and so Çälva, in order to get strength, took shelter of the lotus feet of Lord Çiva. He underwent a severe type of austerity during which he would eat no more than a handful of ashes daily. Lord Çiva, the husband of Pärvaté, is generally very merciful, and he becomes very quickly satisfied if someone undertakes severe austerities in order to please him. So after continued austerities by Çälva for one year, Lord Çiva became pleased with him and asked him to beg for the fulfillment of his desire.

Çälva begged from Lord Çiva the gift of an airplane which would be so strong that it could not be destroyed by any demigod, demon, human being, Gandharva, Näga, or even by any Räkñasa. Moreover, he desired that the airplane be able to fly anywhere and everywhere he would like to pilot it, and be specifically very dangerous and fearful to the dynasty of the Yadus. Lord Çiva immediately agreed to give him the benediction, and Çälva took the help of the demon Maya to manufacture this iron airplane, which was so strong and formidable that no one could crash it. It was a very big machine, almost like a big city, and it could fly so high and at such a great speed that it was almost impossible to see where it was, and so there was no question of attacking it. Although it might be dark outside, the pilot could fly it anywhere and everywhere. Having acquired such a wonderful airplane, Çälva flew it to the city of Dvärakä, because his main purpose in obtaining the airplane was to attack the city of the Yadus, toward whom he maintained a continual feeling of animosity.

Çälva thus not only attacked the city of Dvärakä from the sky, but he also surrounded the city by a large number of infantry. The soldiers on the surface began to attack the beautiful spots of the city. They began to destroy the baths, the city gates, the palaces and the skyscraper houses, the high walls around the city and the beautiful spots where people would gather for recreation. While the soldiers were attacking on the surface, the airplane began to drop big slabs of stone, tree trunks, thunderbolts, poisonous snakes and many other dangerous things. Çälva also managed to create such a strong whirlwind within the city that all of Dvärakä became dark because of the dust that covered the sky. The airplane occupied by Çälva put the entire city of Dvärakä into distress equal to that caused on the earth long, long ago by the disturbing activities of Tripuräsura. The inhabitants of Dvärakä Puré became so harrassed that they were not in a peaceful condition for even a moment.

The great heroes of Dvärakä City, headed by commanders such as Pradyumna, counterattacked the soldiers and the airplane of Çälva. When he saw the extreme distress of the citizens, Pradyumna immediately arranged his soldiers and personally got upon a chariot, encouraging the citizens by assuring safety. Following his command, many warriors like Sätyaki, Cärudeñëa and Sämba, all young brothers of Pradyumna, as well as Akrüra, Kåtavarmä, Bhänuvinda, Gada, Çuka and Säraëa—all came out of the city to fight with Çälva. All of them were great fighters; each one could fight with thousands of men. All were fully equipped with necessary weapons and assisted by hundreds and thousands of charioteers, elephants, horses and infantry soldiers. Fierce fighting began between the two parties, exactly as was formerly carried on between the demigods and the demons. The fighting was very severe, and whoever observed the fierce nature of the fight felt his hairs stand on end.

Pradyumna immediately counteracted the mystic demonstration occasioned by the airplane of Çälva, the King of Saubha. By the mystic power of the airplane, Çälva had created a darkness as dense as night, but Pradyumna all of a sudden appeared like the rising sun. As with the rising of the sun the darkness of night is immediately dissipated, so with the appearance of Pradyumna the power exhibited by Çälva became null and void. Each and every one of Pradyumna's arrows had a golden feather at the end, and the shaft was fitted with a sharp iron edge. By releasing twenty-five such arrows, Pradyumna severely injured Çälva's commander-in-chief. He then released another one hundred arrows toward the body of Çälva. After this, he pierced each and every soldier by releasing one arrow, and he killed the chariot drivers by firing ten arrows at each one of them. The carriers like the horses and elephants were killed by the release of three arrows directed toward each one of them. When everyone present on the battlefield saw this wonderful feat of Pradyumna, the great fighters on both the sides began to praise his acts of chivalry.

But still the airplane occupied by Çälva was very mysterious. It was so extraordinary that sometimes there would appear to be many airplanes in the sky, and sometimes it would be seen that there was none. Sometimes it was visible, and sometimes it was not visible, and the warriors of the Yadu dynasty became puzzled about the whereabouts of the peculiar airplane. Sometimes they would see the airplane on the ground, and sometimes they would see it flying in the sky. Sometimes they would see the airplane resting on the peak of a hill, and sometimes it was seen floating on the water. The wonderful airplane was flying in the sky like a firefly in the wind—it was not steady even for a moment. But despite the mysterious maneuvering of the airplane, the commanders and the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty would immediately rush toward Çälva wherever he was present with his airplane and soldiers. The arrows released by the dynasty of the Yadus were as brilliant as the sun and as dangerous as the tongues of serpents. All the soldiers fighting on behalf of Çälva became soon distressed by the incessant release of arrows upon them by the heroes of the Yadu dynasty, and Çälva himself became unconscious from the attack of these arrows.

The soldiers and the fighters fighting on behalf of Çälva were also very strong, and the release of their arrows also harassed the heroes of the Yadu dynasty. But still the Yadus were so strong and determined that they did not move from their strategic positions. The heroes of the Yadu dynasty were determined to either die in the battlefield or gain victory. They were confident of the fact that if they would die in the fighting they would attain a heavenly planet, and if they would come out victorious they would enjoy the world. The name of Çälva's commander-in-chief was Dyumän. He was very powerful, and although bitten by twenty-five of Pradyumna's arrows, he suddenly attacked Pradyumna with his fierce club and struck him so strongly that Pradyumna became unconscious. Immediately there was a roaring, "Now he is dead! Now he is dead!" The force of the club on the chest of Pradyumna was very severe, enough to tear asunder the chest of an ordinary man.

Pradyumna's chariot was being driven by the son of Däruka. According to Vedic military principles, the chariot driver and the hero on the chariot have to cooperate during the fighting. As such, it was the duty of the chariot driver to take care of the hero on the chariot during the dangerous and precarious fighting on the battlefield. Thus Däruka removed the body of Pradyumna from the battlefield. Two hours later, in a quiet place, Pradyumna regained his consciousness, and when he saw that he was in a place other than the battlefield he addressed the charioteer and condemned him:

"Oh, you have done the most abominable act! Why have you moved me from the battlefield? My dear charioteer, I have never heard that anyone in our family was ever removed from the battlefield. None of them left the battlefield while fighting. By this removal you have overburdened me with a great defamation. It will be said that I left the battlefield while fighting was going on. My dear charioteer, I must accuse you—you are a coward and emasculator! Tell me, how can I go before my uncle Balaräma and before my father Kåñëa, and what shall I say before them? Everyone will talk about me and say that I fled from the fighting place, and if they inquire from me about this, what will be my reply? My sisters-in-law will play jokes upon me with sarcastic words: 'My dear hero, how have you become such a coward? How have you become a eunuch? How have you become so low in the eyes of the fighters who opposed you?' I think, my dear charioteer, that you have committed a great offense by removing me from the battlefield."

The charioteer of Pradyumna replied, "My dear sir, I wish a long life for you. I think I did not do anything wrong, as it is the duty of the charioteer to help the fighter in the chariot when he is in a precarious condition. My dear sir, you are completely competent in the battlefield activities. It is the mutual duty of the charioteer and the warrior to give protection to each other in a precarious condition. I was completely aware of the regulative principles of fighting, and I did my duty. The enemy all of a sudden struck you with his club so severely that you lost consciousness. You were in a dangerous position, surrounded by your enemies. Therefore I was obliged to act as I did."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twenty-first chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Battle between Çälva and the Members of the Yadu Dynasty."

KB 1970-2-22 / The Deliverance of Çälva

22 /The Deliverance of Çälva

After talking with his charioteer, the son of Däruka, Pradyumna could understand the real circumstances, and therefore he refreshed himself by washing his mouth and hands. Arming himself properly with bows and arrows, he asked his charioteer to take him near the place where Çälva's commander-in-chief was standing. During the short absence of Pradyumna from the battlefield, Dyumän, Çälva's commander-in-chief, had been taking over the position of the soldiers of the Yadu dynasty. By appearing in the battlefield, Pradyumna immediately stopped him and struck him with eight arrows. With four arrows he killed his four horses, with one arrow he killed his chariot driver and with another arrow he cut his bow in two; with another arrow, he cut his flag into pieces, and with another he severed his head from his body.

On the other fronts, heroes like Gada, Sätyaki and Sämba were engaged in killing the soldiers of Çälva. The soldiers who were staying with Çälva in the airplane were also killed in the fighting, and they fell into the ocean. Each party began to strike the opposite party very severely. The battle was fierce and dangerous and continued for twenty-seven days without stop.

While the fight was going on in the city of Dvärakä, Kåñëa was staying at Indraprastha along with the Päëòavas and King Yudhiñöhira. This fighting with Çälva took place after the Räjasüya yajïa had been performed by King Yudhiñöhira and after the killing of Çiçupäla. When Lord Kåñëa understood that there was great danger in the city of Dvärakä, He took permission from the elderly members of the Päëòava family, especially from his aunt Kuntédevé, and started immediately for Dvärakä.

Lord Kåñëa began to think that while He was arriving in Hastinäpura with Balaräma after the killing of Çiçupäla, Çiçupäla's men must have attacked Dvärakä. On reaching Dvärakä, Lord Kåñëa saw that the whole city was greatly endangered. He placed Balarämajé in a strategic position for the protection of the city, and He Himself asked His charioteer Däruka to prepare to start. He said, "Däruka, please immediately take Me to where Çälva is staying. You may know that this Çälva is a very powerful, mysterious man. Don't fear him in the least." As soon as he got his orders from Lord Kåñëa, Däruka had Him seated on the chariot and drove very quickly toward Çälva.

The chariot of Lord Kåñëa was marked with the flag bearing the insignia of Garuòa, and as soon as the soldiers and warriors of the Yadu dynasty saw the flag, they could understand that Lord Kåñëa was on the battlefield. By this time, almost all the soldiers of Çälva had been killed, but when Çälva saw that Kåñëa had come to the battlefield, he released a great, powerful weapon which flew through the sky with a roaring sound like a great meteor. It was so bright that the whole sky lit up by its presence. But as soon as Lord Kåñëa appeared, He tore the great weapon into hundreds and thousands of pieces by releasing His own arrow.

Lord Kåñëa struck Çälva with sixteen arrows, and with showers of arrows He overpowered the airplane, just as the sun in a clear sky overpowers the whole sky by an unlimited number of molecules of sunshine. Çälva struck a severe blow to Kåñëa's left side, where the Lord was carrying His bow, Çärìga, and as a result the Çärìga bow fell from Lord Kåñëa's hand. This dropping of the bow was indeed wonderful. Great personalities and demigods who were observing the fighting between Çälva and Kåñëa became most perturbed by this, and they began to exclaim, "Alas! Alas!"

Çälva thought that he had become victorious, and with a roaring sound began to address Lord Kåñëa as follows: "You rascal, Kåñëa! You kidnapped Rukmiëé forcibly, even in our presence. You baffled my friend Çiçupäla and married Rukmiëé Yourself. And in the great assembly at King Yudhiñöhira's Räjasüya yajïa, while my friend Çiçupäla was a little absent-minded, You took an opportunity to kill him. Everyone thinks that You are a great fighter and that no one can conquer You. So now You'll have to prove Your strength. I think that if You stand before me any longer, with my sharpened arrows I shall send You to a place wherefrom You will never return."

To this Lord Kåñëa replied, "Foolish Çälva, you are talking nonsensically. You do not know that the moment of death is already upon your head. Those who are actually heroes do not talk much. They prove their prowess by practical exhibition of chivalrous activities." After saying this, Lord Kåñëa, in great anger, struck Çälva on the collarbone with His club so severely that he began to bleed internally and tremble as if he were going to collapse from severe cold. Before Kåñëa was able to strike him again, however, Çälva became invisible by his mystic power.

Within a few moments, a mysterious unknown man came before Lord Kåñëa. Crying loudly, he bowed down at the Lord's lotus feet and said to Him, "Since You are the most beloved son of Your father Vasudeva, Your mother Devaké has sent me to inform You of the unfortunate news that Your father has been arrested by Çälva and taken away by force. He took him just as a butcher mercilessly takes away an animal." When Lord Kåñëa heard this unfortunate news from the unknown man, He at first became most perturbed, just like an ordinary human being. His face showed signs of grief, and He began to cry in a pitious tone, "How could that happen? My brother Lord Balaräma is there, and it is impossible for anyone to conquer Balarämajé. He is in charge of Dvärakä City, and I know He is always alert. How could Çälva possibly enter the city and arrest My father in that way? Whatever he may be, Çälva's power is limited, so how could it be possible that he has conquered the strength of Balarämajé and taken away My father, arresting him as described by this man? Alas! Destiny is, after all, very powerful."

While Çré Kåñëa was thinking like this, Çälva brought before Him in custody a man exactly resembling Vasudeva, His father. These were all creations of the mystic power of Çälva.

Çälva began to address Kåñëa, "You rascal, Kåñëa! Look. This is Your father who has begotten You and by whose mercy You are still living. Now just see how I kill Your father. If You have any strength, try to save him." The mystic juggler, Çälva, speaking in this way before Lord Kåñëa, immediately cut off the head of the false Vasudeva. Without hesitation he took away the dead body and got into his airplane. Lord Kåñëa is the self-sufficient Supreme Personality of Godhead, yet because He was playing the role of a human being, He became very depressed for a moment, as if He had actually lost His father. But at the next moment He could understand that the arrest and killing of His father were demonstrations of the mystic powers which Çälva had learned from the demon Maya. Coming to His right consciousness, He could see that there was no messenger and no head of His father, but that only Çälva had left in his airplane, which was flying in the sky. He then began to think of slaying Çälva.

Kåñëa's reaction is a controversial point among great authorities and saintly persons. How could Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the reservoir of all power and knowledge, be bewildered in such a way? Lamentation, aggrievement and bewilderment are characteristics of persons who are conditioned souls, but how can such things affect the person of the Supreme, who is full of knowledge, power and all opulence? Actually, it is not at all possible that Lord Kåñëa was misled by the mystic jugglery of Çälva. He was displaying His pastime in playing the role of a human being. Great saintly persons and sages who are engaged in the devotional service of the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa and who have thus achieved the greatest perfection of self-realization have transcended the bewilderments of the bodily concept of life. Lord Kåñëa is the ultimate goal of life for such saintly persons. How then could Kåñëa have been bewildered by the mystic jugglery of Çälva? The conclusion is that Lord Kåñëa's bewilderment was another opulence of His supreme personality.

When Çälva thought that Kåñëa had been bewildered by his mystic representations, he became encouraged and began to attack the Lord with greater strength and energy by showering volumes of arrows upon Him. But the enthusiasm of Çälva can be compared to the speedy march of flies into a fire. Lord Kåñëa, by hurling His arrows with unfathomable strength, injured Çälva, whose armor, bow and jewelled helmet all scattered into pieces. With a crashing blow from Kåñëa's club, Çälva's wonderful airplane burst into pieces and fell into the sea. Çälva was very careful, and instead of crashing with the airplane, he managed to jump onto the land. He again rushed towards Lord Kåñëa. When Çälva ran swiftly to attack Kåñëa with His club, Lord Kåñëa cut off his hand, which fell to the ground with the club. Finally deciding to kill him, the Lord took up His wonderful disc, which was shining like the brilliant sun at the time of the dissolution of the material creation. When Lord Çré Kåñëa stood up with His disc to kill Çälva, He appeared just like the red sun rising over a mountain. Lord Kåñëa then cut off his head, and the head, with its earrings and helmet, fell on the ground. Çälva was thus killed in the same way as Våträsura was killed by Indra, the King of heaven.

When Çälva was killed, all his soldiers and followers began to cry, "Alas! Alas!" While Çälva's men were thus crying, the demigods from the heavenly planets showered flowers on Kåñëa and announced the victory by beating on drums and blowing bugles. At this very moment, other friends of Çiçupäla, such as Dantavakra, appeared on the scene to fight with Kåñëa in order to avenge the death of Çiçupäla. When Dantavakra appeared before Lord Kåñëa, he was extremely angry.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twenty-second Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Deliverance of Çälva."

KB 1970-2-23 / The Killing of Dantavakra, Vidüratha and Romaharñaëa

23 /The Killing of Dantavakra, Vidüratha and Romaharñaëa

After the demise of Çiçupäla, Çälva and Pauëòra, another foolish demoniac king of the name Dantavakra wanted to kill Kåñëa in order to avenge the death of his friend Çälva. He became so agitated that he personally appeared on the battlefield without the proper arms and ammunition and without even a chariot. His only weapon was his great anger, which was red-hot. He carried only a club in his hand, but he was so powerful that when he moved, everyone felt the earth tremble. When Lord Kåñëa saw him approaching in a very heroic mood, He immediately got down from His chariot, for it was a rule of military etiquette that fighting should take place only between equals. Knowing that Dantavakra was alone and armed with only a club, Lord Kåñëa responded similarly and prepared Himself by taking His club in His hand. When Kåñëa appeared before him, Dantavakra's heroic march was immediately stopped just as the great, furious waves of the ocean are stopped by the beach.

At that time, Dantavakra, who was the King of Karüña, stood up firmly with his club and spoke to Lord Kåñëa as follows: "It is a great pleasure and fortunate opportunity, Kåñëa, that we are facing each other eye to eye. My dear Kåñëa, after all, You are my eternal cousin, and I should not kill You in this way, but unfortunately You have committed a great mistake by killing my friend Çälva. Moreover, You are not satisfied by killing my friend, but I know that You want to kill me also. Because of Your determination, I must kill You by tearing You into pieces with my club. Kåñëa, although You are my relative, You are foolish. You are our greatest enemy, so I must kill You today just as a person removes a boil on his body by a surgical operation. I am always very much obliged to my friends, and I therefore consider myself indebted to my dear friend Çälva. I can only liquidate my indebtedness to him by killing You."

As the caretaker of an elephant tries to control the animal by striking it with his trident, so Dantavakra tried to control Kåñëa simply by speaking strong words. After finishing his vituperation, he struck Kåñëa on the head with his club and made a roaring sound like a lion. Although struck strongly by the club of Dantavakra, Kåñëa did not move even an inch, nor did He feel any pain. Taking His Kaumodaké club and moving very skillfully, Kåñëa struck the chest of Dantavakra so fiercely that the heart of Dantavakra split in twain. As a result, Dantavakra began to vomit blood, his hairs became scattered, and he fell to the ground, spreading his hands and legs. Within only a few minutes all that remained of Dantavakra was a dead body on the ground. After the death of Dantavakra, just as at the time of Çiçupäla's death, in the presence of all persons standing there, a small particle of spiritual effulgence came out of the demon's body and very wonderfully merged into the body of Lord Kåñëa.

Dantavakra had a brother named Vidüratha who became overwhelmed with grief at the death of Dantavakra. Out of grief and anger, Vidüratha was breathing very heavily, and just to avenge the death of his brother he also appeared before Lord Kåñëa with a sword and a shield in his hands. He wanted to kill Kåñëa immediately. When Lord Kåñëa understood that Vidüratha was looking for the opportunity to strike Him with his sword, He employed His Sudarçana cakra, His disc, which was as sharp as a razor, and without delay he cut off the head of Vidüratha, with its helmet and earrings.

In this way, after killing Çälva and destroying his wonderful airplane and then killing Dantavakra and Vidüratha, Lord Kåñëa at last entered His city, Dvärakä. It would not have been possible for anyone but Kåñëa to kill these great heroes, and therefore all the demigods from heaven and the human beings on the surface of the globe were glorifying Him. Great sages and ascetics, the denizens of the Siddha and Gandharva planets, the denizens known as Vidyädharas, Väsuki and the Mahänägas, the beautiful angels, the inhabitants of Pitåloka, the Yakñas, the Kinnaras and the Cäraëas all began to shower flowers upon Him and sing the songs of His victory in great jubilation. Decorating the entire city very festively, the citizens of Dvärakä held a great celebration, and when Lord Kåñëa passed through the city all the members of the Våñëi dynasty and the heroes of the Yadu dynasty followed Him with great respect. These are some of the transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa, who is the master of all mystic power and the Lord of all cosmic manifestations. Those who are fools, who are like animals, sometimes think that Kåñëa is defeated, but factually He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and no one can defeat Him. He always remains victorious over everyone. He is the only one God, and all others are His subservient order carriers.

Once upon a time, Lord Balaräma heard that there was an arrangement being made for a fight between the two rival parties in the Kuru dynasty, one headed by Duryodhana and the other by the Päëòavas. He did not like the idea that He was to be only a mediator to stop the fighting. Finding it unbearable not to take an active part on behalf of either of the parties, He left Dvärakä on the plea of visiting various holy places of pilgrimage. He first of all visited the place of pilgrimage known as Prabhäsakñetra. He took His bath there, and He pacified the local brähmaëas and offered oblations to the demigods, pitäs, great sages and people in general, in accordance with Vedic ritualistic ceremonies. That is the Vedic method of visiting holy places. After this, accompanied by some respectable brähmaëas, He decided to visit different places on the bank of the River Sarasvaté. He gradually visited such places as Påthüdaka, Bindusara, Tritaküpa, Sudarçanatértha, Viçälatértha, Brahmatértha and Cakratértha. Besides these, He also visited all the holy places on the bank of Sarasvaté River running toward the east. After this He visited all the principal holy places on the bank of the Yamunä and on the bank of the Ganges. Thus He gradually came to the holy place known as Naimiñäraëya.

This holy place, Naimiñäraëya, is still existing in India, and in ancient times it was especially used for the meetings of great sages and saintly persons with the aim of understanding spiritual life and self-realization. When Lord Balaräma visited that place there was a great sacrifice being performed by a great assembly of transcendentalists. Such meetings were planned to last thousands of years. When Lord Balaräma arrived, all the participants of the meeting—great sages, ascetics, brähmaëas and learned scholars—immediately arose from their seats and welcomed Him with great honor and respect. Some offered Him respectful obeisances, and those who were elderly great sages and brähmaëas offered Him blessings by standing up. After this formality, Lord Balaräma was offered a suitable seat, and everyone present worshiped Him. Everyone in the assembly stood up in the presence of Balaräma because they knew Him to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Education or learning means to understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead; therefore, although Lord Balaräma appeared on the earth as a kñatriya, all the brähmaëas and sages stood up because they knew who Lord Balaräma was.

Unfortunately, after being worshiped and seated at His place, Lord Balaräma saw Romaharñaëa, the disciple of Vyäsadeva (the literary incarnation of Godhead), still sitting on the Vyäsäsana. He had neither gotten up from his seat nor offered Him respects. Because he was seated on the Vyäsäsana, he foolishly thought himself greater than the Lord; therefore he did not get down from his seat or bow down before the Lord. Lord Balaräma then considered the history of Romaharñaëa: he was born in a süta family or a mixed family, born of a brähmaëa woman and kñatriya man. Therefore although Romaharñaëa considered Balaräma a kñatriya, he should not have remained sitting on a higher seat. Lord Balaräma considered that Romaharñaëa, according to his position by birth, should not have accepted the higher sitting position, because there were many learned brähmaëas and sages present. He also observed that Romaharñaëa not only did not come down from his exalted seat, but he did not even stand up and offer his respects when Balarämajé entered the assembly. Lord Balaräma did not like the audacity of Romaharñaëa, and he became very angry with him.

When a person is seated on the Vyäsäsana, he does not generally have to stand up to receive a particular person entering the assembly, but in this case the situation was different because Lord Baladeva is not an ordinary human being. Therefore, although Romaharñaëa Süta was voted to the Vyäsäsana by all the brähmaëas, he should have followed the behavior of other learned sages and brähmaëas who were present and should have known that Lord Balaräma is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Respects are always due to Him, even though such respects can be avoided in the case of an ordinary man. The appearances of Kåñëa and Balaräma are especially meant for reestablishment of the religious principles. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66], the highest religious principle is to surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is also confirmed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [6.1.15] that the topmost perfection of religiousness is to be engaged in the devotional service of the Lord.

When Lord Balaräma saw that Romaharñaëa Süta did not understand the highest principle of religiousness in spite of having studied all the Vedas, He certainly could not support his position. Romaharñaëa Süta had been given a chance to become a perfect brähmaëa, but because of his ill behavior in his relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, his low birth was immediately remembered. Romaharñaëa Süta had been given the position of a brähmaëa, but he had not been born in the family of a brähmaëa; he had been born in a pratiloma family. According to the Vedic concept, there are two kinds of mixed family heritage. They are called anuloma and pratiloma. When a male is united with a female of a lower caste, the offspring is called anuloma; but when a male unites with a woman of a higher caste, the offspring is called pratiloma. Romaharñaëa Süta belonged to the pratiloma family because his father was a kñatriya and his mother a brähmaëa. Because Romaharñaëa's transcendental realization was not perfect, Lord Balaräma remembered his pratiloma heritage. The idea is that any man can be given the chance to become a brähmaëa, but if he improperly uses the position of a brähmaëa without actual realization, then his elevation to the brahminical position is not valid.

After seeing the deficiency of realization in Romaharñaëa Süta, Lord Balaräma decided to chastise him for being puffed up. Lord Balaräma therefore said, "This man is liable to be awarded the death punishment because, although he has the good qualification of being a disciple of Lord Vyäsadeva and although he has studied all the Vedic literature from this exalted personality, he was not submissive in the presence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead." As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.18], a person who is actually a brähmaëa and is very learned must automatically become very gentle also. In the case of Romaharñaëa Süta, although he was very learned and had been given the chance to become a brähmaëa, he had not become gentle. From this we can understand that when one is puffed up by material acquisition, he cannot acquire the gentle behavior befitting a brähmaëa. The learning of such a person is as good as a valuable jewel decorating the hood of a serpent. Despite the valuable jewel on the hood, a serpent is still a serpent and is as fearful as an ordinary serpent. If a person does not become meek and humble, all his studies of the Vedas and Puräëas and his vast knowledge in the çästras become simply outward dress, like the costume of a theatrical artist dancing on the stage. Lord Balaräma began to consider thus: "I have appeared in order to chastise false persons who are internally impure but externally pose themselves to be very learned and religious. My killing of such persons is proper to check them from further sinful activity."

Lord Balaräma had avoided taking part in the Battle of Kurukñetra, and yet because of His position, the reestablishment of religious principles was his prime duty. Considering these points, He killed Romaharñaëa Süta simply by striking him with a kuça straw, which was nothing but a blade of grass. If someone questions how Lord Balaräma could kill Romaharñaëa Süta simply by striking him with a blade of kuça grass, the answer is given in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.78.28] by the use of the word prabhu (master). The Lord's position is always transcendental, and because He is omnipotent He can act as He likes without being obliged to the material laws and principles. Thus it was possible for Him to kill Romaharñaëa Süta simply by striking him with a blade of kuça grass.

At the death of Romaharñaëa Süta, everyone present became much aggrieved, and there was roaring and crying. Although all the brähmaëas and sages present there knew Lord Balaräma to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead, they did not hesitate to protest the Lord's action, and they humbly submitted, "Our dear Lord, we think that Your action is not in line with the religious principles. Dear Lord Yadunandana, we may inform You that we brähmaëas posted Romaharñaëa Süta on that exalted position for the duration of this great sacrifice. He was seated on the Vyäsäsana by our election, and when one is seated on the Vyäsäsana, it is improper for him to stand up to receive a person. Moreover, we awarded Romaharñaëa Süta an undisturbed duration of life. Under the circumstances, since Your Lordship has killed him without knowing all these facts, we think that Your action has been equal to that of killing a brähmaëa. Dear Lord, deliverer of all fallen souls, we know certainly that You are the knower of all Vedic principles. You are the master of all mystic powers; therefore ordinarily the Vedic injunctions cannot be applied to Your personality. But we request that You show Your causeless mercy upon others by kindly atoning for this killing of Romaharñaëa Süta. We do not, however, suggest what kind of act You should perform to atone for killing him; we simply suggest that some method of atonement be adopted by You so that others may follow Your action. What is done by a great personality is followed by the ordinary man."

The Lord replied, "Yes, I must atone for this action, which may have been proper for Me, but is improper for others; therefore, I think it is My duty to execute a suitable act of atonement enjoined in the authorized scriptures. Simultaneously I can also give this Romaharñaëa Süta life again, with a span of long duration, sufficient strength, and full power of the senses. Not only this, if you desire, I shall be glad to award him anything else which you may ask. I shall be very glad to grant all these boons in order to fulfill your desires."

This statement of Lord Balaräma definitely confirms that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is free to act in any way. Although it may be considered that His killing of Romaharñaëa Süta was improper, He could immediately counteract the action with greater profit to all. Therefore, one should not imitate the actions of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; one should simply follow the instructions of the Lord. All the great learned sages present realized that although they considered the action of Lord Balaräma to be improper, the Lord was able to immediately compensate with greater profits. Not wanting to detract from the mission of the Lord in killing Romaharñaëa Süta, all of them prayed, "Our dear Lord, the uncommon use of Your kuça weapon to kill Romaharñaëa Süta may remain as it is; because of Your desire to kill him, he should not be brought to life again. At the same time Your Lordship may remember that we sages and brähmaëas voluntarily gave him long life; therefore, such a benediction should not be nullified." Thus the request of all the learned brähmaëas in the assembly was ambiguous because they wanted to keep intact the benediction given by them that Romaharñaëa Süta would continue to live until the end of the great sacrifice, but at the same time they did not want to nullify Balaräma's killing him.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead therefore solved the problem in a manner befitting His exalted position, and said, "Because the son is produced from the body of the father, it is the injunction of the Vedas that the son is the father's representative. Therefore I say that Ugraçravä Süta, the son of Romaharñaëa Süta, should henceforth take his father's position and continue the discourses on the Puräëas, and because you wanted Romaharñaëa to have a long duration of life, this benediction will be transferred to his son. The son, Ugraçravä, will therefore have all the facilities you offered—long duration of life in a good and healthy body, without any disturbances and full strength of all the senses.

Lord Balaräma then implored all the sages and brähmaëas that aside from the benediction offered to the son of Romaharñaëa, they should ask from Him any other benediction, and He would be prepared to fulfill it immediately. The Lord thus placed Himself in the position of an ordinary kñatriya and informed the sages that He did not know in what way He could atone for His killing of Romaharñaëa, but whatever they would suggest He would be glad to accept.

The brähmaëas could understand the purpose of the Lord, and thus, they suggested that He atone for His action in a manner which would be beneficial for them. They said, "Our dear Lord, there is a demon of the name Balvala. He is the son of Ilvala, but he is a very powerful demon, and he visits this sacred place of sacrifice every fortnight on the full moon and moonless days and creates a great disturbance to the discharge of our duties in the sacrifice. O descendant of the Daçärha family, we all request You to kill this demon. We think that if You kindly kill him, that will be Your atonement on our behalf. The demon occasionally comes here and profusely throws upon us contaminated, impure things like puss, blood, stool, urine and wine, and he pollutes this sacred place by showering such filth upon us. After killing Balvala, You may continue touring all these sacred places of pilgrimage for twelve months, and in that way You will be completely freed from all contamination. That is our prescription."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twenty-third Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Killing of Dantavakra, Vidüratha and Romaharñaëa."

KB 1970-2-24 / The Liberation of Balvala, and Lord Balaräma's Touring the Sacred Places

24 /The Liberation of Balvala, and Lord Balaräma's Touring the Sacred Places

Lord Balaräma prepared Himself to meet the demon Balvala. At the time when the demon usually attacked the sacred place, there appeared a great hailstorm, the whole sky became covered with dust and the atmosphere became surcharged with a filthy smell. Just after this, the mischievous demon Balvala began to shower torrents of stool and urine and other impure substances on the arena of sacrifice. After this onslaught, the demon himself appeared with a great trident in his hand. He was a gigantic person, and his black body was like a huge mass of carbon. His hair, his beard and his moustache appeared reddish, like copper, and because of his great beard and moustache, his mouth appeared to be very dangerous and fierce. As soon as He saw the demon, Lord Balaräma prepared to attack him. He first began to consider how He could smash the great demon to pieces. Lord Balaräma called for His plow and club, and they immediately appeared before Him. The demon Balvala was flying in the sky, and at the first opportunity Lord Balaräma dragged him down with His plow and angrily smashed the demon's head with His club. By Balaräma's striking, the forehead of the demon became fractured. There was a profuse flow of blood from his forehead, and he began to scream loudly. In this way the demon, who had been such a great disturbance to the pious brähmaëas, fell to the ground. His falling was like a great mountain with a red oxide peak being struck by a thunderbolt and smashed to the ground.

The inhabitants of Naimiñäraëya, learned sages and brähmaëas, became most pleased by seeing this, and they offered their respectful prayers to Lord Balaräma. They offered their heartfelt blessings upon the Lord, and all agreed that Lord Balaräma's attempt to do anything would never be a failure. The sages and brähmaëas then performed a ceremonial bathing of Lord Balaräma, just as King Indra is bathed by the demigods when he is victorious over the demons. The brähmaëas and sages honored Lord Balaräma by presenting Him first-class new clothing and ornaments and the lotus flower garland of victory, the reservoir of all beauty, which was never to be dried up, being in everlasting existence.

After this incidence, Lord Balaräma took permission from the brähmaëas assembled at Naimiñäraëya and, accompanied by other brähmaëas, went to the bank of the River Kauñiké. After taking His bath in this holy place, He proceeded toward the River Sarayü and visited the source of the river. He began to travel on the bank of the Sarayü River, and He gradually reached Prayäga, where there is a confluence of three rivers, the Ganges, Yamunä and Sarasvaté. Here also He regularly took His bath, worshiped the local temples of God and, as it is enjoined in the Vedic literature, offered oblations to the forefathers and sages. He gradually reached the äçrama of the sage Pulaha and from there went to Gaëòaké on the River Gomati. After this He took His bath in the River Vipäçä. Then gradually He came to the bank of the Çoëa River. (The Çoëa River is still running as one of the big rivers in the Behar Province.) He also took His bath there and performed the Vedic ritualistic ceremonies. He continued His travels and gradually came to the pilgrimage city of Gayä where there is a celebrated Viñëu temple. According to the advice of His father Vasudeva, He offered oblations to the forefathers in this Viñëu temple. From here He traveled to the delta of the Ganges, where the sacred River Ganges mixes with the Bay of Bengal. This sacred place is called Gaìgäsägara, and at the end of January every year there is still a great assembly of saintly persons and pious men, just as there is an assembly of saintly persons in Prayäga every year which is called the Magh Mela Fair.

After finishing His bathing and ritualistic ceremonies at Gaìgäsägara, Lord Balaräma proceeded toward the mountain known as Mahendra Parvata. At this place He met Paraçuräma, the incarnation of Lord Kåñëa, and He offered him respect by bowing down before him. After this He gradually turned toward southern India and visited the banks of the River Godävaré. After taking His bath in the River Godävaré and performing the necessary ritualistic ceremonies, He gradually visited the other rivers—the Veëä, Pampä and Bhémarathé. On the bank of the River Bhémarathé there is the deity called Svämé Kärttikeya. After visiting Kärttikeya Lord Balaräma gradually proceeded to Çailapura, a pilgrimage city in the province of Mahäräñöra. Çailapura is one of the biggest districts in Mahäräñöra Province. He then gradually proceeded towards the Draviòadeça. Southern India is divided into five parts, called Païcadraviòa. Northern India is also divided into five parts, called Païcagaura. All the important äcäryas of the modern age, namely Çaìkaräcärya, Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Viñëusvämé, and Nimbärka, advented themselves in these Draviòa Provinces. Lord Caitanya appeared in Bengal, which is part of the five Gauradeças.

The most important place of pilgrimage in southern India, or Draviòa, is Veìkaöäcala, commonly known as Bälajé. After visiting this place Lord Balaräma proceeded toward Viñëukäïcé, and from there He proceeded on the bank of the Käveré. He took His bath in the River Käveré; then He gradually reached Raìgakñetra. The biggest temple in the world is in Raìgakñetra, and the Viñëu deity there is celebrated as Raìganätha. A similar temple of Raìganätha is in Våndävana, although it is not as big as the temple in Raìgakñetra.

While going to Viñëukäïcé, Lord Balaräma also visited Çivakäïcé. After visiting Raìgakñetra, He gradually proceeded toward Mathurä, commonly known as the Mathurä of southern India. After visiting this place, He gradually proceeded toward Setubandha. Setubandha is the place where Lord Rämacandra constructed the stone bridge from India to Laìkä (Ceylon). In this particularly holy place, Lord Balaräma distributed ten thousand cows to the local brähmaëa priests. It is the Vedic custom that when a rich visitor goes to any place of pilgrimage he gives in charity to the local priests gifts of horses, cows, ornaments and garments. This system of visiting places of pilgrimage and providing the local brähmaëa priests with all necessities of life has greatly deteriorated in this age of Kali. The richer section of the population, because of its degradation in Vedic culture, is no longer attracted by these places of pilgrimage, and the brähmaëa priests who depended on such visitors have also deteriorated in their professional duty of helping the visitors. These brähmaëa priests in the places of pilgrimage are called paëòa or paëòit. This means that they formerly were very learned brähmaëas and used to guide the visitors in all details of the purpose of coming there, and thus both the visitors and the priests were benefitted by mutual cooperation.

It is clear from the description of Çrémad-Bhägavatam that when Lord Balaräma was visiting the different places of pilgrimage, He properly followed the Vedic system. After distributing cows at Setubandha, Lord Balaräma proceeded toward the Kåtamälä and Tämraparëé Rivers. These two rivers are celebrated as sacred, and Lord Balaräma bathed in both. He then proceeded toward Malaya Hill. This Malaya Hill is very great, and it is said that it is one of seven peaks called the Malaya Hills. The great sage Agastya used to live there, and Lord Balaräma visited him and offered His respects by bowing down before him. After taking the sage's blessings, Lord Balaräma, with the sage's permission, proceeded toward the Indian Ocean.

At the point of the cape there is a big temple of the goddess Durgä where she is known as Kanyäkumäré. This temple of Kanyäkumäré was also visited by Lord Rämacandra, and therefore it is to be understood that the temple has been existing for millions of years. From there, Lord Balaräma went on to visit the pilgrimage city known as Phälgunatértha, which is on the shore of the Indian Ocean, or the Southern Ocean. Phälgunatértha is celebrated because Lord Viñëu in His incarnation of Ananta is lying there. From Phälgunatértha, Lord Balaräma went on to visit another pilgrimage spot known as Païcäpsarasa. There also He bathed according to the regulative principles and observed the ritualistic ceremonies. This site is also celebrated as a shrine of Lord Viñëu; therefore Lord Balaräma distributed ten thousand cows to the local brähmaëa priests.

From Cape Comarin Lord Balaräma turned toward Kerala. The country of Kerala is still existing in southern India under the name of South Kerala. After visiting this place, He came to Gokarëatértha, where Lord Çiva is constantly worshiped. Balaräma then visited the temple of Äryädevé, which is completely surrounded by water. From that island, He went on to a place known as Çürpäraka. After this He bathed in the rivers known as Täpé, Payoñëé, and Nirvindhyä, and He came to the forest known as Daëòakäraëya. This is the same Daëòakäraëya Forest where Lord Rämacandra lived while He was in exile. Lord Balaräma next came to the bank of the River Narmadä, the biggest river in central India. On the bank of this sacred Narmadä there is a pilgrimage spot known as Mähiñmaté Puré. After bathing there, according to regulative principles, Lord Balaräma returned to Prabhäsatértha, wherefrom He had begun His journey.

When Lord Balaräma returned to Prabhäsatértha He heard from the brähmaëas that most of the kñatriyas in the Battle of Kurukñetra had been killed. Balaräma felt relieved to hear that the burden of the world had been reduced. Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma appeared on this earth to lessen the burden of military strength created by the ambitious kñatriya kings. This is the way of materialistic life: not being satisfied by the absolute necessities of life, people ambitiously create extra demands, and their illegal desires are checked by the laws of nature or by laws of God, appearing as famine, war, pestilence and similar catastrophes. Lord Balaräma heard that although most of the kñatriyas had been killed, the Kurus were still engaged in fighting. Therefore He returned to the battlefield just on the day Bhémasena and Duryodhana were engaged in a personal duel. As well-wisher of both of them, Lord Balaräma wanted to stop them, but they would not stop.

When Lord Balaräma appeared on the scene, King Yudhiñöhira and his young brothers, Nakula, Sahadeva, Lord Kåñëa and Arjuna, immediately offered Him their respectful obeisances, but they did not speak at all. The reason they were silent was that Lord Balaräma was somewhat affectionate toward Duryodhana, and Duryodhana had learned from Balarämajé the art of fighting with a club. Thus, when the fighting was going on, King Yudhiñöhira and others thought that Balaräma might come there to say something in favor of Duryodhana, and they therefore remained silent. Both Duryodhana and Bhémasena were very enthusiastic in fighting with clubs, and in the midst of large audiences, each was very skillfully trying to strike the other, and while attempting to do so they appeared to be dancing. But although they appeared to be dancing, it was clear that both of them were very angry.

Lord Balaräma, wanting to stop the fighting, said, "My dear King Duryodhana and Bhémasena, I know that both of you are great fighters and are well known in the world as great heroes, but still I think that Bhémasena is superior to Duryodhana in bodily strength. On the other hand, Duryodhana is superior in the art of fighting with a club. Taking this into consideration, My opinion is that neither of you is inferior to the other in fighting. Under the circumstances, there is very little chance of one of you being defeated by the other. Therefore I request you not to waste your time in fighting in this way. I wish you to stop this unnecessary fight."

The good instruction given by Lord Balaräma to both Bhémasena and Duryodhana was intended for the equal benefit of both of them. But they were so enwrapped in anger against each other that they could only remember their long-lasting personal enmity. Each thought only of killing the other, and they did not give much importance to the instruction of Lord Balaräma. Both of them then became like madmen in remembering the strong accusations and ill behavior they had exchanged with one another. Lord Balaräma, being able to understand the destiny which was awaiting them, was not eager to go further in the matter. Therefore, instead of staying, He decided to return to the city of Dvärakä.

When He returned to Dvärakä, He was received with great jubilation by relatives and friends, headed by King Ugrasena and other elderly persons; all of them came forward to welcome Lord Balaräma. After this, He again went to the holy place of pilgrimage at Naimiñäraëya, and the sages, saintly persons and brähmaëas all received Him standing. They understood that Lord Balaräma, although a kñatriya, was now retired from the fighting business. The brähmaëas and the sages, who were always for peace and tranquility, were very pleased at this. All of them embraced Balaräma with great affection and induced Him to perform various kinds of sacrifices in that sacred spot of Naimiñäraëya. Actually Lord Balaräma had no business performing the sacrifices recommended for ordinary human beings; He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and therefore He Himself is the enjoyer of all such sacrifices. As such, His exemplary action in performing sacrifices was only to give a lesson to the common man to show how one should abide by the injunction of the Vedas.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead Balaräma instructed the sages and saintly persons at Naimiñäraëya on the subject matter of the living entities' relationship with this cosmic manifestation, on how one should accept this whole universe and on how one should relate with the cosmos in order to achieve the highest goal of perfection, the understanding that the whole cosmic manifestation is resting on the Supreme Personality of Godhead and that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is also all-pervading, even within the minutest atom, by the function of His Paramätmä feature.

Lord Balaräma then took the avabhåtha bath which is accepted after finishing sacrificial performances. After taking His bath, He dressed Himself in new silken garments and decorated Himself with beautiful jewelry amidst His relatives and friends. He appeared to be a shining full moon amidst the luminaries in the sky. Lord Balaräma is the Personality of Godhead Ananta Himself; therefore He is beyond the scope of understanding by mind, intelligence or body. He descended exactly like a human being and behaved in that way for His own purpose; we can only explain His activities as the Lord's pastimes. No one can even estimate the extent of the unlimited demonstrations of His pastimes because He is all-powerful. Lord Balaräma is the original Viñëu; therefore anyone remembering these pastimes of Lord Balaräma in the morning and evening, will certainly become a great devotee of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and thus his life will become successful in all respects.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twenty-fourth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Liberation of Balvala, and Lord Balaräma's Touring Sacred Places."

KB 1970-2-25 / Meeting of Lord Kåñëa with Sudämä Brähmaëa

25 /Meeting of Lord Kåñëa with Sudämä Brähmaëa

King Parékñit was hearing the narrations of the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa and Lord Balaräma from Çukadeva Gosvämé. These pastimes are all transcendentally pleasurable to hear, and Mahäräja Parékñit addressed Çukadeva Gosvämé as follows: "My dear Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa is the bestower of both liberation and love of God simultaneously. Anyone who becomes a devotee of the Lord automatically attains liberation without having to make a separate attempt. The Lord is unlimited, and as such, His pastimes and activities for creating, maintaining and destroying the whole cosmic manifestation are unlimited. I therefore wish to hear about His other pastimes of which you may not have spoken as yet. My dear master, the conditioned souls within this material world have been frustrated by searching out the pleasure of happiness derived from sense gratification. Such desires for material enjoyment are always piercing the heart of conditioned souls. But I am actually experiencing how the transcendental topics of Lord Kåñëa's pastimes can relieve one from the state of being affected by such sense gratificatory material activities. I think that no intelligent person can reject this method of hearing the transcendental pastimes of the Lord again and again; simply by hearing, one can remain always steeped in transcendental pleasure. Thus one will not be attracted by material sense gratification."

In this statement, Mahäräja Parékñit has used two important words: viñaëëaù and viçeñajïaù: viñaëëaù means "morose." The materialistic persons are inventing many ways and means to become fully satisfied, but actually they remain morose. The point may be raised that sometimes those who are transcendentalists also remain morose. Parékñit Mahäräja has used, however, the word viçeñajïaù. There are two kinds of transcendentalists, namely the impersonalists and the personalists. Viçeñajïaù refers to the personalists, who are interested in transcendental variegatedness. The devotees become jubilant by hearing the descriptions of the personal activities of the Supreme Lord, whereas the impersonalists, who are actually more attracted by the impersonal feature of the Lord, are only superficially attracted by the personal activities of the Lord. As such, in spite of coming in contact with the pastimes of the Lord, the impersonalists do not fully realize the benefit to be derived, and thus they remain in exactly the same morose position, due to fruitive activity, with the materialists.

King Parékñit continued: "The capacity for talking can be perfected only by describing the transcendental qualities of the Lord. The capacity for working with one's hands can be successful only when one engages himself in the service of the Lord with those hands. Similarly, one's mind can be pacified only when he simply thinks of Kåñëa in full Kåñëa consciousness. This does not mean that one has to be very thoughtful, but one simply has to understand that Kåñëa, the Absolute Truth, is all-pervasive, by His localized aspect as Paramätmä. If only one can think that Kåñëa, as Paramätmä, is everywhere, even within the atom, then one can perfect the thinking, feeling and willing function of his mind. The perfect devotee does not see the material world as it appears to material eyes, but he sees everywhere the presence of his worshipable Lord in His Paramätmä feature."

Mahäräja Parékñit continued to say that the function of the ear can be perfected simply by engagement in hearing the transcendental activities of the Lord. He said further that the function of the head can be fully utilized when the head is engaged in bowing down before the Lord and His representative. That the Lord is represented in everyone's heart is a fact, and therefore the highly advanced devotee offers his respects to every living entity, considering that the body is the temple of the Lord. But it is not possible for all men to come to that stage of life immediately, because that stage is for the first-class devotee. The second-class devotee can consider the Vaiñëavas, or the devotees of the Lord, to be representatives of Kåñëa, and the devotee who is just beginning, the neophyte or third-class devotee, can bow his head before the Deity in the temple and before the spiritual master, who is the direct manifestation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the neophyte stage, in the intermediate stage, or in the fully advanced perfected stage, one can make the function of the head perfect by bowing down before the Lord or His representative. Similarly, he can perfect the function of the eyes by seeing the Lord and His representative. In this way, everyone can elevate the functions of the different parts of his body to the highest perfectional stage simply by engaging them in the service of the Lord or His representative. If one is able to do nothing more, he can simply bow down before the Lord and His representative and drink the caraëämåta, the water which has washed the lotus feet of the Lord or His devotee.

On hearing these statements of Mahäräja Parékñit, Çukadeva Gosvämé became overwhelmed with devotional ecstasy because of King Parékñit's advanced understanding of the Vaiñëava philosophy. Çukadeva Gosvämé was already engaged in describing the activities of the Lord, and when he was asked by Mahäräja Parékñit to describe them further, he continued with great pleasure to narrate Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

There was a very nice brähmaëa friend of Lord Kåñëa. As a perfect brähmaëa, he was very elevated in transcendental knowledge, and because of his advanced knowledge, he was not at all attached to material enjoyment. Therefore he was very peaceful and had achieved supreme control over his senses. This means that the brähmaëa was a perfect devotee because unless one is a perfect devotee, he cannot achieve the highest standard of knowledge. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.19] that a person who has come to the point of perfection of knowledge surrenders unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In other words, any person who has surrendered his life for the service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead has come to the point of perfect knowledge. The result of perfect knowledge is that one becomes detached from the materialistic way of life. This detachment means complete control of the senses, which are always attracted by material enjoyment. The senses of the devotee become purified, and in that stage the senses are engaged in the service of the Lord. That is the complete field of devotional service.

Although the brähmaëa friend of Lord Kåñëa was a householder, he was not busy accumulating wealth for very comfortable living; therefore he was satisfied by the income which automatically came to him according to his destiny. This is the sign of perfect knowledge. A man who is in perfect knowledge knows that one cannot be happier than he is destined to be. In this material world, everyone is destined to suffer a certain amount of distress and to enjoy a certain amount of happiness. The amount of happiness and distress is already predestined for every living entity. No one can increase or decrease the happiness of the materialistic way of life. The brähmaëa, therefore, did not exert himself for more material happiness, but he used his time for advancement of Kåñëa consciousness. Externally he appeared to be very poor because he had no rich dress and could not provide a very rich dress for his wife, and because their material condition was not very opulent they were not even eating sufficiently, and thus both he and his wife appeared to be very thin. The wife was not very anxious for her personal comfort, but she felt very concerned for her husband, who was such a pious brähmaëa. She was trembling due to her weak health, and although she did not like to dictate to her husband, she spoke as follows:

"My dear lord, I know that Lord Kåñëa, who is the husband of the goddess of fortune, is your personal friend. You are also a devotee of Lord Kåñëa, and He is always ready to help His devotee. Even if you think that you are not rendering any devotional service to the Lord, still you are surrendered to Him, and the Lord is the protector of the surrendered soul. Moreover, I know that Lord Kåñëa is the ideal personality of Vedic culture. He is always in favor of brahminical culture and is very kind to the qualified brähmaëas. You are the most fortunate person because you have as your friend the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Lord Kåñëa is the only shelter for personalities like you because you are fully surrendered unto Him. You are saintly, learned and fully in control of your senses. Under the circumstances, Lord Kåñëa is your only shelter. Please, therefore, go to Him. I am sure that He will immediately understand your impoverished position. You are also a householder; therefore without any money you are in a distressed condition. But as soon as He understands your position, He will certainly give you sufficient riches so that you can live very comfortably. Lord Kåñëa is now the King of the Bhoja, Våñëi and Andhaka dynasties, and I have heard that He never leaves His capital city, Dvärakä. He is living there without outside engagements. He is so kind and liberal that He immediately gives everything, even His personal self, to any person who surrenders unto Him. When He is prepared to give Himself personally to His devotee, then there is nothing wonderful in giving some material riches. Of course, He does not give much material wealth to His devotee if the devotee is not very fixed, but I think in your case He knows perfectly well how much you are fixed in devotional service. Therefore He will not hesitate to award you some material benefit for the bare necessities of life."

In this way, the wife of the brähmaëa again and again requested, in great humility and submission, that he go to Lord Kåñëa. The brähmaëa thought that there was no need to ask any material benefit from Lord Çré Kåñëa, but he was induced by the repeated requests of his wife. Moreover, he thought, "If I go there I shall be able to see the Lord personally. That will be a great opportunity, even if I don't ask any material benefit from Him." When he had decided to go to Kåñëa, he asked his wife if she had anything in the home that he could offer to Kåñëa, because he must take some presentation for his friend. The wife immediately collected four palmsful of chipped rice from her neighboring friends and tied it in a small cloth, like a handkerchief, and gave it to her husband to present to Kåñëa. Without waiting any longer, the brähmaëa took the presentation and began to proceed toward Dvärakä to see his Lord. While he was proceeding toward Dvärakä he was absorbed in the thought of how he could be able to see Lord Kåñëa. He had no thought within his heart other than Kåñëa.

It was of course very difficult to reach the palaces of the kings of the Yadu dynasty, but brähmaëas were allowed to visit, and when the brähmaëa friend of Lord Kåñëa went there, he, along with other brähmaëas, had to pass through three military encampments. In each camp there were very big gates, and he also had to pass through them. After the gates and the camps, there were sixteen thousand big palaces, the residential quarters of the sixteen thousand queens of Lord Kåñëa. The brähmaëa entered one palace which was very gorgeously decorated. When he entered this beautiful palace, he felt that he was swimming in the ocean of transcendental pleasure. He felt himself constantly diving and surfacing in that transcendental ocean.

At that time, Lord Kåñëa was sitting on the bedstead of Queen Rukmiëé. Even from a considerable distance He could see the brähmaëa coming to His home, and He could recognize him as His friend. Lord Kåñëa immediately left His seat and came forward to receive His brähmaëa friend and, upon reaching him, embraced the brähmaëa with His two arms. Lord Kåñëa is the reservoir of all transcendental pleasure, and yet He Himself felt great pleasure upon embracing the poor brähmaëa because He was meeting His very dear friend. Lord Kåñëa had him seated on His own bedstead and personally brought him all kinds of fruits and drinks to offer him, as is proper in receiving a worshipable guest. Lord Çré Kåñëa is the supreme pure, but because He was playing the role of an ordinary human being, He immediately washed the brähmaëa's feet and, for His own purification, sprinkled the water onto His head. After this the Lord smeared the body of the brähmaëa with different kinds of scented pulp, such as sandalwood, aguru and saffron. He immediately burned several kinds of scented incense, and, as is usual, He offered him ärätrika with burning lamps. After thus offering him an adequate welcome and after the brähmaëa had taken food and drink, Lord Kåñëa said, "My dear friend, it is a great fortune that you have come here."

The brähmaëa, being very poor, was not dressed nicely; his clothing was torn and dirty, and his body was also very lean and thin. He appeared not to be very clean, and because of his weak body, his bones were distinctly visible. The goddess of fortune Rukmiëédevé personally began to fan him with the cämara fan, but the other women in the palace became astonished at Lord Kåñëa's behavior in receiving the brähmaëa in that way. They were surprised to see how eager Lord Kåñëa was to welcome this particular brähmaëa. They began to wonder how Lord Kåñëa could personally receive a brähmaëa who was poor, not very neat or clean, and poorly dressed; but at the same time they could realize that the brähmaëa was not an ordinary living being. They knew that he must have performed great pious activities; otherwise why was Lord Kåñëa, the husband of the goddess of fortune, taking so much care for him? They were still more surprised to see that the brähmaëa was seated on the bedstead of Lord Kåñëa. They were especially surprised to see that Lord Kåñëa had embraced him exactly as He embraced His elder brother, Balarämajé, because Lord Kåñëa used to embrace only Rukmiëé or Balaräma, and no one else.

After receiving the brähmaëa nicely, and seating him on His own cushioned bed, Lord Kåñëa said, "My dear brähmaëa friend, you are a most intelligent personality, and you know very well the principles of religious life. I believe that after you finished your education at the house of our teacher and after you sufficiently remunerated him, you must have gone back to your home and accepted a suitable wife. I know very well that from the beginning you were not at all attached to the materialistic way of life, nor did you desire to be very opulent materially, and therefore you are in need of money. In this material world, persons who are not attached to material opulence are very rarely found. Such unattached persons haven't the least desire to accumulate wealth and prosperity for sense gratification, but sometimes they are found to collect money just to exhibit the exemplary life of a householder. They show how by proper distribution of wealth one can become an ideal householder and at the same time become a great devotee. Such ideal householders are to be considered followers of My footsteps. I hope, My dear brähmaëa friend, you remember all those days of our school life when both you and I were living together at the boarding house. Actually, whatever knowledge both you and I received in our life was accumulated in our student life.

"If a man is sufficiently educated in student life under the guidance of a proper teacher, then his life becomes successful in the future. He can very easily cross over the ocean of nescience, and he is not subjected to the influence of illusory energy. My dear friend, everyone should consider his father to be his first teacher because by the mercy of one's father one gets this body. The father is therefore the natural spiritual master. Our next spiritual master is he who initiates us into transcendental knowledge, and he is to be worshiped as much as I am. The spiritual master may be more than one. The spiritual master who instructs the disciples about spiritual matters is called çikña-guru, and the spiritual master who initiates the disciple is called dékñä-guru. Both of them are My representatives. There may be many spiritual masters who instruct, but the initiator spiritual master is one. A human being who takes advantage of these spiritual masters and, receiving proper knowledge from them, crosses the ocean of material existence, is to be understood as having properly utilized his human form of life. He has practical knowledge that the ultimate interest of life, which is to be gained only in this human form, is to achieve spiritual perfection and thus be transferred back home, back to Godhead.

"My dear friend, I am Paramätmä, the Supersoul present in everyone's heart, and it is My direct order that human society must follow the principles of varëa and äçrama. As I have stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.13], the human society should be divided, according to quality and action, into four varëas. Similarly, everyone should divide his life into four parts. One should utilize the first part of life in becoming a bona fide student, receiving adequate knowledge and keeping oneself in the vow of brahmacarya, so that one may completely devote his life for the service of the spiritual master without indulging in sense gratification. A brahmacäré is meant to lead a life of austerities and penance. The householder is meant to live a regulated life of sense gratification, but no one should remain a householder for the third stage of life. In that stage, one has to return to the austerities and penances formerly practiced in brahmacäré life and thus relieve himself of the attachment to household life. After being relieved of his attachments to the materialistic way of life, one may accept the order of sannyäsa.

"As the Supersoul of the living entities, sitting in everyone's heart, I observe everyone's activity in every stage and order of life. Regardless of which stage one is in, when I see that one is engaged seriously and sincerely in discharging the duties ordered by the spiritual master, and is thus dedicating his life to the service of the spiritual master, that person becomes most dear to Me. As far as the life of brahmacarya is concerned, if one can continue the life of a brahmacäré under the direction of a spiritual master, that is extremely good; but if in brahmacäré life one feels sex impulses, then he should take leave of his spiritual master, satisfying him according to the guru's desire. According to the Vedic system, a gift is offered to the spiritual master, which is called guru-dakñiëä. Then the disciple should take to householder life and accept a wife according to religious rites."

These instructions given by Lord Kåñëa while talking with His friend the learned brähmaëa are very good for the guidance of human society. A system of human civilization that does not promote varëa and äçrama is nothing but polished animal society. Indulgence in sex life by a man or woman living single is never acceptable in human society. A man should either strictly follow the principles of brahmacäré life or, with the permission of the spiritual master, should get married. Single life with illicit sex is animal life. For the animals there is no marriage institution.

Modern society does not aim at fulfilling the mission of human life. The mission of human life is to go back home, back to Godhead. To fulfill this mission, the system of varëa and äçrama must be followed. When the system is followed rigidly and consciously, it fulfills this mission of life. When it is followed indirectly, without guidance of superior order, then it simply creates a disturbing condition in human society, and there is no peace and prosperity.

Kåñëa continued to talk with His brähmaëa friend: "My dear friend, I think you remember our activities during the days when we were living as students. You may remember that once we went to collect fuel from the forest on the order of the guru's wife. While we were collecting the dried wood, we by chance entered the dense forest and became lost. There was an unexpected dust storm and then clouds and lightning in the sky and the explosive sound of thunder. Then sunset came, and we were lost in the dark jungle. After this, there was severe rainfall; the whole ground was overflooded with water, and we could not trace out the way to return to our guru's äçrama. You may remember that heavy rainfall—it was not actually rainfall but a sort of devastation. On account of the dust storm and the heavy rain, we began to feel greatly pained, and in whichever direction we turned we were bewildered. In that distressed condition, we took each other's hand and tried to find our way out. We passed the whole night in that way, and early in the morning when our absence became known to our gurudeva, he sent his other disciples to search us out. He also came with them, and when they reached us in the jungle they found us to be very distressed.

"With great compassion our gurudeva said, 'My dear boys, it is very wonderful that you have suffered so much trouble for me. Everyone likes to take care of his body as the first consideration, but you are so good and faithful to your guru that without caring for bodily comforts you have taken so much trouble for me. I am also glad to see that bona fide students like you will undergo any kind of trouble for the satisfaction of the spiritual master. That is the way for a bona fide disciple to become free from his debt to the spiritual master. It is the duty of the disciple to dedicate his life to the service of the spiritual master. My dear best of the twice-born, I am greatly pleased by your action, and I bless you: May all your desires and ambitions be fulfilled. May the understanding of the Vedas which you have learned from me always continue to remain within your memory, so that at every moment you can remember the teachings of the Vedas and quote their instructions without difficulty. Thus you will never be disappointed in this life or in the next.'"

Kåñëa continued: "My dear friend, you may remember that many such incidents occurred while we were in the äçrama of our spiritual master. Both of us can realize that without the blessings of the spiritual master no one can be happy. By the mercy of the spiritual master and by his blessings, one can achieve peace and prosperity and be able to fulfill the mission of human life."

On hearing this, the learned brähmaëa replied, "My dear Kåñëa, You are the Supreme Lord and the supreme spiritual master of everyone, and since I was fortunate enough to live with You in the house of our guru, I think I have nothing more to do in the matter of prescribed Vedic duties. My dear Lord, the Vedic hymns, ritualistic ceremonies, religious activities, and all other necessities for the perfection of human life, including economic development, sense gratification and liberation, are all derived from one source: Your supreme personality. All the different processes of life are ultimately meant for the understanding of Your personality. In other words, they are the different parts of Your transcendental form. And yet You played the role of a student and lived with us in the house of the guru. This means that You adopted all these pastimes for Your pleasure only; otherwise there was no need for Your playing the role of a human being."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twenty-fifth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Meeting of Lord Kåñëa with Sudämä Brähmaëa."

KB 1970-2-26 / The Brähmaëa Sudämä Benedicted by Lord Kåñëa

26 /The Brähmaëa Sudämä Benedicted by Lord Kåñëa

Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Supersoul of all living entities, knows very well everyone's heart. He is especially inclined to the brähmaëa devotees. Lord Kåñëa is also called brahmaëyadeva, which means that He is worshiped by the brähmaëas. Therefore it is understood that a devotee who is fully surrendered unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead has already acquired the position of a brähmaëa. Without becoming a brähmaëa, one cannot approach the Supreme Brahman, Lord Kåñëa. Kåñëa is especially concerned with vanquishing the distress of His devotees, and He is the only shelter of pure devotees.

Lord Kåñëa was engaged for a long time in talking with Sudämä Vipra about their past association. Then, just to enjoy the company of an old friend, Lord Kåñëa began to smile, and asked, "My dear friend, what have you brought for Me? Has your wife given you some nice eatable for Me?" While He was addressing His friend, Lord Kåñëa was looking upon him and smiling with great love. He continued: "My dear friend, you must have brought some presentation for Me from your home."

Lord Kåñëa knew that Sudämä was hesitating to present Him the paltry chipped rice which was actually unfit for His eating, and understanding the mind of Sudämä Vipra the Lord said, "My dear friend, certainly I am not in need of anything, but if My devotee gives Me something as an offering of love, even though it may be very insignificant, I accept it with great pleasure. On the other hand, if a person is not a devotee, even though he may offer Me very valuable things, I do not like to accept them. I actually accept only things which are offered to Me in devotion and love; otherwise, however valuable the thing may be, I do not accept it. If My pure devotee offers Me even the most insignificant things—a little flower, a little piece of leaf, a little water—but saturates the offering in devotional love, then I not only gladly accept such an offering, but I eat it with great pleasure."

Lord Kåñëa assured Sudämä Vipra that He would be very glad to accept the chipped rice which he had brought from home, yet out of great shyness, Sudämä Vipra hesitated to present it to the Lord. He was thinking, "How can I offer such insignificant things to Kåñëa?" and he simply bowed his head.

Lord Kåñëa, the Supersoul, knows everything in everyone's heart. He knows everyone's determination and everyone's want. He knew, therefore, the reason for Sudämä Vipra's coming to Him. He knew that, driven by extreme poverty, he had come there at the request of his wife. Thinking of Sudämä as His very dear class friend, He knew that Sudämä's love for Him as a friend was never tainted by any desire for material benefit. Kåñëa thought, "Sudämä has not come asking anything from Me, but being obliged by the request of his wife, he has come to see Me just to please her." Lord Kåñëa therefore decided that He would give more material opulence to Sudämä Vipra than could be imagined even by the King of heaven.

He then snatched the bundel of chipped rice which was hanging on the shoulder of the poor brähmaëa, packed in one corner of his wrapper, and said, "What is this? My dear friend, you have brought Me nice, palatable chipped rice!" He encouraged Sudämä Vipra, saying, "I consider that this quantity of chipped rice will not only satisfy Me, but will satisfy the whole creation." It is understood from this statement that Kåñëa, being the original source of everything, is the root of the entire creation. As watering the root of a tree immediately distributes water to every part of the tree, so an offering made to Kåñëa, or any action done for Kåñëa, is to be considered the highest welfare work for everyone, because the benefit of such an offering is distributed throughout the creation. Love for Kåñëa becomes distributed to all living entities.

While Lord Kåñëa was speaking to Sudämä Vipra, He ate one morsel of chipped rice from his bundle, and when He attempted to eat a second morsel, Rukmiëédevé, who is the goddess of fortune herself, checked the Lord by catching hold of His hand. After touching the hand of Kåñëa, Rukmiëé said, "My dear Lord, this one morsel of chipped rice is sufficient to cause him who offered it to become very opulent in this life and to continue his opulence in the next life. My Lord, You are so kind to Your devotee that even this one morsel of chipped rice pleases You very greatly, and Your pleasure assures the devotee opulence both in this life and in the next." This indicates that when food is offered to Lord Kåñëa with love and devotion and He is pleased and accepts it from the devotee, Rukmiëédevé, the goddess of fortune, becomes so greatly obliged to the devotee that she has to personally go to the devotee's home to turn it into the most opulent home in the world. If one feeds Näräyaëa sumptuously, the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé, automatically becomes a guest in one's house, which means that one's home becomes opulent. The learned brähmaëa Sudämä passed that night at the house of Lord Kåñëa, and while he was there he felt as if he were living in the Vaikuëöha planet. Actually he was living in Vaikuëöha, because wherever Lord Kåñëa, the original Näräyaëa, and Rukmiëédevé, the goddess of fortune, live is not different from the spiritual planet, Vaikuëöhaloka.

The learned brähmaëa Sudämä did not appear to have received anything substantial from Lord Kåñëa while he was at His place, and yet he did not ask anything from the Lord. The next morning he started for his home, thinking always about his reception by Kåñëa, and thus he became merged in transcendental bliss. All the way home he was simply remembering the dealings of Lord Kåñëa, and he was feeling very happy to have seen the Lord.

The brähmaëa began to think as follows: "It is most pleasurable to see Lord Kåñëa, who is most devoted to the brähmaëas. How great a lover He is of the brahminical culture! He is the Supreme Brahman Himself, yet He reciprocates with the brähmaëas. He also respects the brähmaëas so much that He embraced to His chest a poor brähmaëa like me, although He never embraces anyone to His chest except the goddess of fortune. How can there be any comparison between me, a poor, sinful brähmaëa, and the Supreme Lord Kåñëa, who is the only shelter of the goddess of fortune? And yet, considering me as a brähmaëa, He embraced me with heartfelt pleasure in His two transcendental arms. Lord Kåñëa was so kind to me that He allowed me to sit down on the same bedstead where the goddess of fortune lies down. He considered me to be His real brother. How can I appreciate my obligation to Him? When I was tired, Çrématé Rukmiëédevé, the goddess of fortune, began to fan me, holding the cämara whisk in her own hand. She never considered her exalted position as the first queen of Lord Kåñëa. I was rendered service by the Supreme Personality of Godhead because of His high regard for the brähmaëas, and by massaging my legs and feeding me with His own hand, He practically worshiped me! Aspiring for elevation to the heavenly planets, or liberation or all kinds of material opulences, or perfection in the mystic yoga powers, everyone throughout the universe worships the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa. Yet the Lord was so kind to me that He did not give me even a farthing, knowing very well that I am a poverty-stricken man who, if I got some money, might become puffed up and mad after material opulence and so forget Him."

The statement of the brähmaëa Sudämä is correct. An ordinary man who is very poor and prays to the Lord for benediction in material opulence, and who somehow or other becomes richer in material opulence, immediately forgets his obligation to the Lord. Therefore, the Lord does not offer opulences to His devotee unless the devotee is thoroughly destitute. Rather, if a neophyte devotee serves the Lord very sincerely and at the same time wants material opulence, the Lord keeps him from obtaining it.

Thinking in this way, the learned brähmaëa gradually reached his own home. But on reaching there he saw that everything was wonderfully changed. He saw that in place of his cottage there were big palaces made of valuable stones and jewels, glittering like the sun, moon and rays of fire. Not only were there big palaces, but at intervals there were beautifully decorated parks, in which many beautiful men and women were strolling. In those parks there were nice lakes full of lotus flowers and beautiful lilies, and there were flocks of multicolored birds. Seeing the wonderful conversion of his native place, the brähmaëa began to think to himself, "How am I seeing all these changes? Does this place belong to me, or to someone else? If it is the same place where I used to live, then how has it so wonderfully changed?"

While the learned brähmaëa was considering this, a group of beautiful men and women with features resembling those of the demigods, accompanied by musical chanters, approached to welcome him. All were singing auspicious songs. The wife of the brähmaëa became very glad on hearing the tidings of her husband's arrival, and with great haste she also came out of the palace. The brähmaëa's wife appeared so beautiful that it seemed as if the goddess of fortune herself had come to receive him. As soon as she saw her husband present before her, tears of joy began to fall from her eyes, and her voice became so choked up that she could not even address her husband. She simply closed her eyes in ecstasy. But with great love and affection she bowed down before her husband, and within herself she thought of embracing him. She was fully decorated with a gold necklace and ornaments, and while standing among the maidservants she appeared like the wife of a demigod just alighting from an airplane. The brähmaëa was surprised to see his wife so beautiful, and in great affection and without saying a word he entered the palace with his wife.

When the brähmaëa entered his personal apartment in the palace, he saw that it was not an apartment, but the residence of the King of heaven. The palace was surrounded by many columns of jewels. The couches and the bedsteads were made of ivory, bedecked with gold and jewels, and the bedding was as white as the foam of milk and as soft as a lotus flower. There were many whisks hanging from golden rods, and many golden thrones with sitting cushions as soft as the lotus flower. In various places there were velvet and silken canopies with laces of pearls hanging all around. The structure of the building was standing on first-class transparent marble, with engravings made of emerald stones. All the women in the palace were carrying lamps made of valuable jewels. The flames and the jewels combined to produce a wonderfully brilliant light. When the brähmaëa saw his position suddenly changed to one of opulence, and when he could not determine the cause for such a sudden change, he began to consider very gravely how it had happened.

He thus began to think, "From the beginning of my life I have been extremely poverty-stricken, so what could be the cause of such great and sudden opulence? I do not find any cause other than the all-merciful glance of my friend Lord Kåñëa, the chief of the Yadu dynasty. Certainly these are gifts of Lord Kåñëa's causeless mercy. The Lord is self-sufficient, the husband of the goddess of fortune, and thus He is always full with six opulences. He can understand the mind of His devotee, and He sumptuously fulfills the devotee's desires. All these are acts of my friend, Lord Kåñëa. My beautiful dark friend Kåñëa is far more liberal than the cloud which can fill up the great ocean with water. Without disturbing the cultivator with rain during the day, the cloud brings liberal rain at night just to satisfy him. And yet when the cultivator wakes up in the morning, he considers that it has not rained enough. Similarly, the Lord fulfills the desire of everyone according to his position, and yet one who is not in Kåñëa consciousness considers all the gifts of the Lord to be less than his desire. On the other hand, when the Lord receives a little thing in love and affection from His devotee, He considers it a great and valuable gift. The vivid example is myself. I simply offered Him a morsel of chipped rice, and in exchange He has given me opulences greater than the opulence of the King of heaven."

What the devotee actually offers to the Lord is not needed by the Lord. He is self-sufficient. If the devotee offers something to the Lord, it acts for his own interest because whatever a devotee offers to the Lord comes back in a quantity a million times greater than what was offered. One does not become a loser by giving to the Lord, but he becomes a gainer by millions of times.

The brähmaëa, feeling great obligation to Kåñëa, thought, "I pray to have the friendship of Lord Kåñëa and to engage in His service, and to surrender fully unto Him in love and affection, life after life. I do not want any opulence. I only desire not to forget His service. I simply wish to be associated with His pure devotees. May my mind and activities be always engaged in His service. The unborn Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa knows that many great personalities have fallen from their positions because of extravagant opulence. Therefore, even when His devotee asks for some opulence from Him, the Lord sometimes does not give it. He is very cautious about His devotees. Because a devotee in an immature position of devotional service may, if offered great opulence, fall from his position due to being in the material world, the Lord does not offer opulence to him. This is another manifestation of the causeless mercy of the Lord upon His devotee. His first interest is that the devotee may not fall. He is exactly like a well-wishing father who does not give much wealth into the hand of his immature son, but who, when the son is grown up and knows how to spend money, gives him the whole treasury house."

The learned brähmaëa thus concluded that whatever opulences he had received from the Lord should not be used for his extravagant sense gratification, but for the service of the Lord. The brähmaëa accepted his newly-acquired opulence, but he did so in a spirit of renunciation, unattached to sense gratification, and thus he lived very peacefully with his wife, enjoying all the facilities of opulence as prasädam of the Lord. He enjoyed varieties of foodstuff by offering it to the Lord and then taking it as prasädam. Similarly, if by the grace of the Lord we get such opulences as material wealth, fame, power, education and beauty, it is our duty to consider that they are all gifts of the Lord and must be used for His service, not for our sense enjoyment. The learned brähmaëa remained in that position, and instead of deteriorating due to great opulence, his love and affection for Lord Kåñëa increased day after day. Material opulence can be the cause of degradation and also the cause of elevation, according to the purposes for which it is used. If opulence is used for sense gratification, it is the cause of degradation, and if it is used for the service of the Lord, it is the cause of elevation.

It is evident from Lord Kåñëa's dealings with Sudämä Vipra that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is very, very pleased with a person who is possessed of brahminical qualities. A qualified brähmaëa like Sudämä Vipra is naturally a devotee of Lord Kåñëa. Therefore it is said, brähmaëo vaiñëavaù: a brähmaëa is a Vaiñëava. Or sometimes it is said, brähmanaù paëòitaù. Paëòita means a highly learned person. A brähmaëa cannot be foolish or uneducated. Therefore there are two divisions of brähmaëas, namely Vaiñëavas and paëòitas. Those who are simply learned are paëòitas, but not yet devotees of the Lord, or Vaiñëavas. Lord Kåñëa is not especially pleased with them. Simply the qualification of being a learned brähmaëa is not sufficient to attract the Supreme Personality of Godhead. A brähmaëa must not only be well qualified according to the requirements stated in scriptures such as Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, but at the same time he must be a devotee of Lord Kåñëa. The vivid example is Sudämä Vipra. He was a qualified brähmaëa, unattached to all sorts of material sense enjoyment, and at the same time a great devotee of Lord Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa, the enjoyer of all sacrifices and penances, is very fond of a brähmaëa like Sudämä Vipra, and we have seen by the actual behavior of Lord Kåñëa how much He adores such a brähmaëa. Therefore, the ideal stage of human perfection is to become a brähmaëa-vaiñëava like Sudämä Vipra.

Sudämä Vipra realized that although Lord Kåñëa is unconquerable, He nevertheless agrees to be conquered by His devotees. He realized how kind Lord Kåñëa was to him, and he was always in trance, constantly thinking of Kåñëa. By such constant association with Lord Kåñëa, whatever darkness of material contamination was remaining within his heart was completely cleared away, and very shortly he was transferred to the spiritual kingdom, which is the goal of all saintly persons in the perfectional stage of life.

Çukadeva Gosvämé has stated that all persons who hear this history of Sudämä Vipra and Lord Kåñëa will know how affectionate Lord Kåñëa is to the brähmaëa devotees like Sudämä. Therefore anyone who hears this history gradually becomes as qualified as Sudämä Vipra, and he is thus transferred to the spiritual kingdom of Lord Kåñëa.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twenty-sixth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Brähmaëa Sudämä Benedicted by Lord Kåñëa."

KB 1970-2-27 / Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma Meet the Inhabitants of Våndävana

27 /Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma Meet the Inhabitants of Våndävana

Once upon a time while Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma were living peacefully in Their great city of Dvärakä, there was the rare occasion of a full solar eclipse, such as takes place at the end of every kalpa, or day of Brahmä. At the end of every kalpa the sun is covered by a great cloud, and incessant rain covers the lower planetary systems up to Svargaloka. By astronomical calculation, people were informed about this great eclipse prior to its taking place, and therefore everyone, both men and women, decided to assemble at the holy place in Kurukñetra known as Samanta-païcaka.

The Samanta-païcaka pilgrimage site is celebrated because Lord Paraçuräma performed great sacrifices there after having killed all the kñatriyas in the world twenty-one times. Lord Paraçuräma killed all the kñatriyas, and their accumulated blood flowed like a stream. Lord Paraçuräma dug five big lakes at Samanta-païcaka, and filled them with this blood. Lord Paraçuräma is Viñëu-tattva. As stated in the Éçopaniñad, Viñëu-tattva cannot be contaminated by any sinful activity. Yet although Lord Paraçuräma is fully powerful and uncontaminated, in order to exhibit ideal character, He performed great sacrifices at Samanta-païcaka to atone for His so-called sinful killing of the kñatriyas. By His example, Lord Paraçuräma established that the killing art, although sometimes necessary, is not good. Lord Paraçuräma considered Himself culpable for the sinful killing of the kñatriyas; therefore, how much more are we culpable for such abominable unsanctioned acts. Thus, killing of living entities is prohibited from time immemorial all over the world.

Taking advantage of the occasion of the solar eclipse, all important persons visited the holy place of pilgrimage. Some of the important personalities are mentioned as follows. Among the elderly persons there were Akrüra, Vasudeva and Ugrasena; among the younger generation there were Gada, Pradyumna, Sämba, and many other members of the Yadu dynasty who had come there with a view to atone for sinful activities accrued in the course of discharging their respective duties. Because almost all the members of the Yadu dynasty went to Kurukñetra, some important personalities, like Aniruddha, the son of Pradyumna, and Kåtavarmä, the commander-in-chief of the Yadu dynasty, along with Sucandra, Çuka and Säraëa remained in Dvärakä to protect the city.

All the members of the Yadu dynasty were naturally very beautiful, and yet on this occasion, when they appeared duly decorated with gold necklaces and flower garlands, dressed in valuable clothing and properly armed with their respective weapons, their natural beauty and personalities were a hundred times enhanced. The members of the Yadu dynasty came to Kurukñetra in their gorgeously decorated chariots resembling the airplanes of the demigods, pulled by big horses that moved like the waves of the ocean, and some of them rode on sturdy, stalwart elephants that moved like the clouds in the sky. Their wives were carried on beautiful palanquins by beautiful men whose features resembled those of the Vidyädharas. The entire assembly looked as beautiful as an assembly of the demigods of heaven.

After arriving in Kurukñetra, the members of the Yadu dynasty took their baths ceremoniously, with self-control, as enjoined in the çästras, and they observed fasting for the whole period of the eclipse in order to nullify the reactions of their sinful activities. Since it is a Vedic custom to give in charity as much as possible during the hours of the eclipse, the members of the Yadu dynasty distributed many hundreds of cows in charity to the brähmaëas. All those cows were fully decorated with nice dress and ornaments. The special feature of these cows was that they had golden ankle bells and flower garlands on their necks.

All the members of the Yadu dynasty again took their baths in the lakes created by Lord Paraçuräma. After this they sumptuously fed the brähmaëas with first-class cooked food, all prepared in butter. According to the Vedic system, there are two classes of food. One is called raw food, and the other is called cooked food. Raw food does not include raw vegetables and raw grains, but food boiled in water; whereas cooked food is made in ghee. Capatis, dahl, rice and ordinary vegetables are called raw foods, as are fruits and salads. But purés, kacuri, saìgosas, sweet balls, etc., are called cooked foods. All the brähmaëas invited on that occasion by the members of the Yadu dynasty were fed sumptuously with cooked food.

The ceremonial functions performed by the members of the Yadu dynasty externally resembled the ritualistic performances performed by the karmés. When a karmé performs some ritualistic ceremony, his ambition is sense gratification—good position, good wife, good house, good children or good wealth; but the ambition of the members of the Yadu dynasty was different. Their ambition was to offer perpetual faith and devotion to Kåñëa. All the members of the Yadu dynasty were great devotees. As such, after many births of accumulated pious activities, they were given the chance to associate with Lord Kåñëa. In going to take their baths in the place of pilgrimage at Kurukñetra or observing the regulative principles during the solar eclipse or feeding the brähmaëas—in all their activities—they simply thought of devotion to Kåñëa. Their ideal worshipable Lord was Kåñëa, and no one else.

After feeding the brähmaëas, it is the custom for the host, with their permission, to accept prasädam. Thus, with the permission of the brähmaëas, all the members of the Yadu dynasty took lunch. Then they selected resting places underneath big, shadowy trees, and when they had taken sufficient rest, they prepared to receive visitors, among whom there were relatives and friends, as well as many subordinate kings and rulers. There were the rulers of the Matsya Province, Uçénara Province, Koçala Province, Vidarbha Province, Kuru Province, Såïjaya Province, Kämboja Province, Kekaya Province and many other countries and provinces. Some of the rulers belonged to opposing parties, and some were friends. But above all, the visitors from Våndävana were most prominent. The residents of Våndävana, headed by Nanda Mahäräja, had been living in great anxiety because of separation from Kåñëa and Balaräma. Taking advantage of the solar eclipse, they all came to see their life and soul, Kåñëa and Balaräma.

The inhabitants of Våndävana were well-wishers and intimate friends of the Yadu dynasty. This meeting of the two parties after long separation was a very touching incident. Both the Yadus and the residents of Våndävana felt such great pleasure in meeting and talking together that it was a unique scene. Meeting after long separation, they were all jubilant; their hearts were throbbing, and their faces appeared like freshly bloomed lotus flowers. There were drops of tears falling from their eyes, the hair on their bodies stood on end, and because of their extreme ecstasy, they were temporarily speechless. In other words, they began to dive in the ocean of happiness.

While the men were meeting in that way, the women were also meeting one another in the same manner. They were embracing each other in great friendship, smiling very mildly, and looking at one another with much affection. When they were embracing each other in their arms, the saffron and kuìkuma spread on their breasts was exchanged from one person to another, and they all felt heavenly ecstasy. Due to such heart-to-heart embracing, torrents of tears glided down their cheeks. The juniors were offering obeisances to the elders, and the elders were offering their blessings to the juniors. They were thus welcoming one another and asking after each other's welfare. Ultimately, however, all their talk was only of Kåñëa. All the neighbors and relatives were connected with Lord Kåñëa's pastimes in this world, and as such Kåñëa was the center of all their activities. Whatever activities they performed—social, political, religious, or conventional—were transcendental.

The real elevation of human life rests on knowledge and renunciation. As stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, in the First Canto, devotional service rendered to Kåñëa automatically produces perfect knowledge and renunciation. The family members of the Yadu dynasty and the cowherd men of Våndävana had their minds fixed on Kåñëa. That is the symptom of all knowledge, and because their minds were always engaged in Kåñëa, they were automatically freed from all material activities. This stage of life is called yukta-vairägya as enunciated by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé [Brs 1.2.255]. Knowledge and renunciation, therefore, do not mean dry speculation and renunciation of activities. Rather, one must start speaking and acting only in relationship with Kåñëa.

In this meeting at Kurukñetra, Kuntédevé and Vasudeva, who were sister and brother, met after a long period of separation, along with their respective sons and daughters-in-law, wives, children and other family members. By talking among themselves, they soon forgot all their past miseries. Kuntédevé especially addressed her brother Vasudeva as follows: "My dear brother, I am very unfortunate, because not one of my desires has ever been fulfilled; otherwise how could it happen that although I have such a saintly brother as you, perfect in all respects, you did not inquire from me as to how I was passing my days in a distressed condition of life." It appears that Kuntédevé was remembering the miserable days when she had been banished along with her sons through the mischevious plans of Dhåtaräñöra and Duryodhana. She continued; "My dear brother, I can understand that when providence goes against someone, even one's nearest relatives also forget him. In such a condition, even one's father, one's mother or one's own children will forget him. Therefore, my dear brother, I do not accuse you."

Vasudeva replied to his sister: "My dear sister, do not be sorry, and do not blame me in that way. We should always remember that we all are only toys in the hands of providence. Everyone is under the control of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is under His control only that all kinds of fruitive actions and the resultant reactions take place. My dear sister, you know that we were very much harrassed by King Kaàsa, and by his persecutions we were scattered here and there. We were always full of anxieties. Only in the last few days have we returned to our own places, by the grace of God."

After this conversation, Vasudeva and Ugrasena received the kings who came to see them, and they sufficiently welcomed them all. Seeing Lord Kåñëa present on the spot, all the visitors felt transcendental pleasure and became very peaceful. Some of the prominent visitors were as follows: Bhéñmadeva, Droëäcärya, Dhåtaräñöra, Duryodhana, and Gändhäré along with her sons; King Yudhiñöhira along with his wife, and the Päëòavas along with Kunté; Såïjaya, Vidura, Kåpäcärya, Kuntibhoja, Viräöa, King Nagnajit, Purujit, Drupada, Çalya, Dhåñöaketu, the King of Käçé, Damaghoña, Viçäläkña, the King of Mithilä, the King of Madras (formerly known as Madra), the King of Kekaya, Yudhämanyu, Suçarmä, Bähléka along with his sons, and many other rulers who were subordinate to King Yudhiñöhira.

When they saw Lord Kåñëa with His thousands of queens, they became fully satisfied at the sight of such beauty and transcendental opulence. All who were there personally visited Lord Balaräma and Kåñëa, and being properly welcomed by the Lord they began to glorify the members of the Yadu dynasty, especially Kåñëa and Balaräma. Because he was the King of the Bhojas, Ugrasena was considered the chief Yadu, and therefore the visitors specifically addressed him: "Your majesty Ugrasena, King of the Bhojas, factually the Yadus are the only persons within this world who are perfect in all respects. All glories unto you! All glories unto you! The specific condition of your perfection is that you are always seeing Lord Kåñëa, who is sought after by many mystic yogés undergoing severe austerities and penances for great numbers of years. All of you are in direct touch with Lord Kåñëa at every moment.

"All the Vedic hymns are glorifying the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. The Ganges water is considered sanctified because of its being the water used to wash the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa. The Vedic literatures are nothing but the injunctions of Lord Kåñëa. The purpose of the study of all the Vedas is to know Kåñëa; therefore, the words of Kåñëa and the message of His pastimes are always purifying. By the influence of time and circumstances, all the opulences of this world had become almost completely wiped out, but since Kåñëa has appeared on this planet, all auspicious features have again appeared due to the touch of His lotus feet. Because of His presence, all our ambitions and desires are gradually being fulfilled. Your majesty, King of the Bhojas, you are related with the Yadu dynasty by matrimonial relationship, and by blood relationship also. As a result, you are constantly in touch with Lord Kåñëa, and you have no difficulty in seeing Him at any time. Lord Kåñëa moves with you, talks with you, sits with you, rests with you, and dines with you. The Yadus appear to be always engaged in worldly affairs which are considered to lead to the royal road to hell, but due to the presence of Lord Kåñëa, the original Personality of Godhead in the Viñëu catagory, who is omniscient, omnipresent and omnipotent, all of you are factually relieved from all material contamination, and are situated in the transcendental position of liberation and Brahman existence."

When they had heard that Kåñëa would be present in Kurukñetra because of the solar eclipse, the residents of Våndävana, headed by Mahäräja Nanda, had also decided to go there, and therefore all the members of the Yadu dynasty were attending. King Nanda, accompanied by his cowherd men, had loaded all their necessary paraphernalia on bullock carts, and all of the Våndävana residents had come to Kurukñetra to see their beloved sons Lord Balaräma and Lord Kåñëa. When the cowherd men of Våndävana arrived in Kurukñetra, all the members of the Yadu dynasty became most pleased. As soon as they saw the residents of Våndävana, they stood up to welcome them, and it appeared that they had again regained their life. Both had been very eager to meet, and when they actually came forward and met, they embraced one another to their heart's satisfaction and remained in embrace for a considerable time.

As soon as Vasudeva saw Nanda Mahäräja, he jumped and ran over to him and embraced him very affectionately. Vasudeva began to narrate his past history—how he had been imprisoned by King Kaàsa, how his babies had been killed, and how immediately after Kåñëa's birth he had carried Him to the place of Nanda Mahäräja, and how Kåñëa and Balaräma had been raised by Nanda Mahäräja and his queen, Yaçodä, as their own children. Similarly, Lord Balaräma and Kåñëa also embraced King Nanda and mother Yaçodä and then offered Their respect unto their lotus feet by bowing down. Because of Their filial affection for Nanda and Yaçodä, both Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma became choked up, and for a few seconds They could not speak. The most fortunate King Nanda and mother Yaçodä placed their sons on their laps and began to embrace Them to their full satisfaction. Because of separation from Kåñëa and Balaräma, both King Nanda and Yaçodä had been merged in great distress for a very long time. Now, after meeting Them and embracing Them, all their sufferings were mitigated.

After this, Kåñëa's mother, Devaké, and Balaräma's mother, Rohiëé, both embraced mother Yaçodä. They said, "Dear Queen Yaçodädevi, both you and Nanda Mahäräja have been great friends to us, and when we remember you we are immediately overwhelmed by the thought of your friendly activities. We are so indebted to you that even if we were to return your benediction by giving you the opulence of the King of heaven, it would not be enough to repay you for your friendly behavior. We shall never forget your kindly behavior toward us. When both Kåñëa and Balaräma were born, before they even saw Their real father and mother, They were entrusted to your care, and you raised Them as your own children, fostering Them as birds take care of their offspring in the nest. You have nicely fed, nourished and loved Them and have performed many auspicious religious ceremonies for Their benefit.

"Actually They are not our sons; They belong to you. Nanda Mahäräja and yourself are the real father and mother of Kåñëa and Balaräma. As long as They were under your care They had not even a pinch of difficulty. Under your protection, They were completely out of the way of all kinds of fear. This most affectionate care which you have taken for Them is completely befitting your elevated position. The most noble personalities do not discriminate between their own sons and the sons of others, and there cannot be any personalities more noble than Nanda Mahäräja and yourself."

As far as the gopés of Våndävana were concerned, from the very beginning of their lives, they did not know anything beyond Kåñëa. Kåñëa and Balaräma were their life and soul. The gopés were so attached to Kåñëa that they could not even tolerate not seeing Him momentarily when their eyelids blinked and impeded their vision. They condemned Brahmä, the creator of the body, because he foolishly made eyelids which blinked and checked their seeing Kåñëa. Because they had been separated from Kåñëa for so many years, the gopés, having come along with Nanda Mahäräja and mother Yaçodä, felt intense ecstasy in seeing Kåñëa. No one can even imagine how anxious the gopés were to see Kåñëa again. As soon as Kåñëa became visible to them, they took Him inside their hearts through their eyes and embraced Him to their full satisfaction. Even though they were embracing Kåñëa only mentally, they became so ecstatic and overwhelmed with joy that for the time being they completely forgot themselves. The ecstatic trance which they achieved simply by mentally embracing Kåñëa is impossible to achieve even for great yogés constantly engaged in meditation on the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa could understand that the gopés were rapt in ecstasy by embracing Him in their minds, and therefore, since He is present in everyone's heart, He also reciprocated the embracing from within.

Kåñëa was sitting with mother Yaçodä and His other mothers, Devaké and Rohiëé, but when the mothers engaged in talking, He took the opportunity and went to a secluded place to meet the gopés. As soon as He approached the gopés, the Lord began to smile, and after embracing them and inquiring about their welfare, He began to encourage them, saying, "My dear friends, you know that both Lord Balaräma and Myself left Våndävana just to please Our relatives and family members. Thus We were long engaged in fighting with Our enemies and were obliged to forget you, who were so much attached to Me in love and affection. I can understand that by this action I have been ungrateful to you, but still I know you are faithful to Me. May I inquire if you have been thinking of Us although We had to leave you behind? My dear gopés, do you now dislike remembering Me, considering Me to have been ungrateful to you? Do you take My misbehavior with you very seriously?

"After all, you should know it was not My intention to leave you; our separation was ordained by providence, who after all is the supreme controller and does as he desires. He causes the intermingling of different persons, and again disperses them as he desires. Sometimes we see that due to the presence of clouds and strong wind, atomic particles of dust and broken pieces of cotton are intermingled together, and after the strong wind subsides, all the particles of dust and cotton are again separated, scattered in different places. Similarly, the Supreme Lord is the creator of everything. The objects which we see are different manifestations of His energy. By His supreme will we are sometimes united and sometimes separated. We can therefore conclude that ultimately we are absolutely dependent on His will.

"Fortunately, you have developed loving affection for Me, which is the only way to achieve the transcendental position of association with Me. Any living entity who develops such unalloyed devotional affection for Me certainly at the end goes back to home, back to Godhead. In other words, unalloyed devotional service and affection for Me are the cause of supreme liberation.

"My dear gopé friends, you may know from Me that it is My energies only which are acting everywhere. Take, for example, an earthen pot. It is nothing but a combination of earth, water, air, fire and sky. It is always of the same physical composites, whether in its beginning, during its existence or after its annihilation. When it is created, the earthen pot is made of earth, water, fire, air and sky; while it remains, it is the same in composition; and when it is broken and annihilated, its different ingredients are conserved in different parts of the material energy. Similarly, at the creation of this cosmic manifestation, during its maintenance, and after its dissolution, everything is but a different manifestation of My energy. And because the energy is not separate from Me, it is to be concluded that I am existing in everything.

"In the same way, the body of a living being is nothing but a composition of the five elements, and the living entity embodied in the material condition is also part and parcel of Me. The living entity is imprisoned in the material condition on account of his false conception of himself as the supreme enjoyer. This false ego of the living entity is the cause of his imprisonment in material existence. As the Supreme Absolute Truth, I am transcendental to the living entity, as well as to his material embodiment. The two energies, material and spiritual, are both acting under My supreme control. My dear gopés, I request that instead of being so afflicted, you try to accept everything with a philosophical attitude. Then you will understand that you are always with Me and that there is no cause of lamentation in our being separated from one another."

This important instruction of Lord Kåñëa's to the gopés can be utilized by all devotees engaged in Kåñëa consciousness. The whole philosophy is considered on the basis of inconceivable, simultaneous oneness and difference. In Bhagavad-gétä [9.4] the Lord says that He is present everywhere in His impersonal feature. Everything is existing in Him, but still He is not personally present everywhere. The cosmic manifestation is nothing but a display of Kåñëa's energy, and because the energy is not different from the energetic, nothing is different from Kåñëa. When this absolute consciousness, Kåñëa consciousness, is absent, we are separated from Kåñëa; but fortunately, if this Kåñëa consciousness is present, then we are not separated from Kåñëa. The process of devotional service is the revival of Kåñëa consciousness, and if the devotee is fortunate enough to understand that the material energy is not separated from Kåñëa, then he can utilize the material energy and its products in the service of the Lord. But in the absence of Kåñëa consciousness, the forgetful living entity, although part and parcel of Kåñëa, falsely puts himself in the position of enjoyer of the material world and, being thus implicated in material entanglement, is forced by the material energy to continue his material existence. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [3.27]. Although a living entity is forced to act by the material energy, he falsely thinks that he is the all-in-all and the supreme enjoyer.

If the devotee knows perfectly that the arcä-vigraha, or Deity form of Lord Kåñëa in the temple, is exactly the same sac-cid-änanda-vigraha as Kåñëa Himself, then his service to the temple Deity becomes direct service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Similarly, the temple itself, the temple paraphernalia and the food offered to the Deity are also not separate from Kåñëa. One has to follow the rules and regulations prescribed by the äcäryas, and thus, under superior guidance, Kåñëa-realization is fully possible, even in this material existence.

The gopés, having been instructed by Kåñëa in this philosophy of simultaneous oneness and difference, remained always in Kåñëa consciousness and thus became liberated from all material contamination. The consciousness of the living entity who falsely presents himself as the enjoyer of the material world is called jéva-koça, which means imprisonment by the false ego. Not only the gopés but anyone who follows these instructions of Kåñëa becomes immediately freed from the jéva-koça imprisonment. A person in full Kåñëa consciousness is always liberated from false egoism; he utilizes everything for Kåñëa's service and is not at any time separated from Kåñëa.

The gopés therefore prayed to Kåñëa, "Dear Kåñëa, from Your navel emanated the original lotus flower which is the birthsite of Brahmä, the creator. No one can estimate Your glories or Your opulence, which therefore remain always a mystery even to the highest thoughtful men, the masters of all yogic power. The conditioned soul fallen in the dark well of this material existence can very easily, however, take shelter of the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa. Thus his deliverance is guaranteed." The gopés continued: "Dear Kåñëa, we are always busy in our family affairs. We therefore request that You remain within our hearts as the rising sun, and that will be Your greatest benediction."

The gopés are always liberated souls, because they are fully in Kåñëa consciousness. They only pretended to be entangled in household affairs in Våndävana. In spite of their long separation, the inhabitants of Våndävana, the gopés, were not interested in the idea of going with Kåñëa to His capital city, Dvärakä. They wanted to remain busy in Våndävana and thus feel the presence of Kåñëa in every step of their lives. They immediately invited Kåñëa to come back to Våndävana. This transcendental emotional existence of the gopés is the basic principle of Lord Caitanya's teaching. The Ratha-yäträ Festival observed by Lord Caitanya is the emotional process of taking Kåñëa back to Våndävana. Çrématé Rädhäräëé refused to go with Kåñëa to Dvärakä to enjoy His company in the atmosphere of royal opulence, but wanted to enjoy His company in the original Våndävana atmosphere. Lord Kåñëa, being profoundly attached to the gopés, never goes away from Våndävana, and the gopés and other residents of Våndävana remain fully satisfied in Kåñëa consciousness.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, twenty-seventh Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma Meet the Inhabitants of Våndävana."

KB 1970-2-28 / Draupadé Meets the Queens of Kåñëa

28 /Draupadé Meets the Queens of Kåñëa

There were many visitors who came to see Kåñëa, and among them were the Päëòavas, headed by King Yudhiñöhira. After talking with the gopés and bestowing upon them the greatest benediction, Lord Kåñëa came to welcome King Yudhiñöhira and other relatives who had come to see Him. He first of all inquired from them whether their situation was auspicious. Actually, there is no question of ill fortune for anyone who sees the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa, yet when Lord Kåñëa, as a matter of etiquette, inquired from King Yudhiñöhira about his welfare, the King became very happy by such a reception and began to address the Lord thus: "My dear Lord Kåñëa, great personalities and devotees in full Kåñëa consciousness always think of Your lotus feet and remain fully satisfied by drinking the nectar of transcendental bliss. The nectar which they constantly drink sometimes comes out of their mouths and is sprinkled on others as the narration of Your transcendental activities. This nectar coming from the mouth of a devotee is so powerful that if one is fortunate enough to have the opportunity to drink it, he immediately becomes freed from the continuous journey of birth and death. Our material existence is caused by our forgetfulness of Your personality, but fortunately, the darkness of forgetfulness is immediately dissipated if one is privileged to hear about Your glories. Therefore, my dear Lord, where is the possibility of ill fortune for one who is constantly engaged in hearing Your glorious activities?

"Since we are fully surrendered unto You and have no other shelter than Your lotus feet, we are always confident of our good fortune. My dear Lord, You are the ocean of unlimited knowledge and transcendental bliss. The result of the action of mental concoction is to exist in the three temporary phases of material life—wakefulness, sleep and deep sleep. But these conditions cannot exist in Kåñëa consciousness. All such reactions are invalidated by practice of Kåñëa consciousness. You are the ultimate destination of all liberated persons. Out of Your independent will only, You have descended on this earth by the use of Your own internal potency, yogamäyä, and in order to reestablish the Vedic principles of life, You have appeared just like an ordinary human being. Since You are the Supreme Person, there cannot, therefore, be any ill luck for one who has fully surrendered unto You."

When Lord Kåñëa was busy meeting various kinds of visitors and while they were engaged in offering prayers to the Lord, the female members of the Kuru dynasty and the Yadu dynasty took the opportunity of meeting with one another and engaging in talk of Lord Kåñëa's transcendental pastimes. The first inquiry was made by Draupadé to the wives of Lord Kåñëa. She addressed them: "My dear Rukmiëé, Bhadrä, Jämbavaté, Satyä, Satyabhämä, Kälindé, Çaibya, Lakñmaëä, Rohiëé and all other wives of Lord Kåñëa, will you please let us know how Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, accepted you as His wives and married you in pursuance of the marriage ceremonies of ordinary human beings?

To this question, the chief of the queens, Rukmiëédevé, replied, "My dear Draupadé, it was practically a settled fact that princes like Jaräsandha and others wanted me to marry King Çiçupäla, and, as is usual, all the princes present during the marriage ceremony were prepared with their armor and weapons to fight with any rival who dared to stop the marriage. But the Supreme Personality of Godhead kidnapped me the way a lion takes away a lamb from the flock. This was not, however, a very wondrous act for Lord Kåñëa, because anyone who claims to be a very great hero or king within this world is subordinate to the lotus feet of the Lord. All the kings touch their helmets to the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa. My dear Draupadé, it is my eternal desire that life after life I may be engaged in the service of Lord Kåñëa, who is the reservoir of all pleasure and beauty. This is my only desire and ambition in life."

After this, Satyabhämä began to speak. She said, "My dear Draupadé, my father was very much afflicted on the death of his brother, Prasena, and he falsely accused Lord Kåñëa of killing his brother and stealing the Syamantaka jewel, which had actually been taken by Jämbavän. Lord Kåñëa, in order to establish His pure character, fought with Jämbavän and rescued the Syamantaka jewel, which was later delivered to my father. My father was very much ashamed and sorry for accusing Lord Kåñëa of his brother's death. After getting back the Syamantaka jewel, he thought it wise to rectify his mistake, so although he had promised others my hand in marriage, he submitted the jewel and myself at the lotus feet of Kåñëa, and thus I was accepted as His maidservant and wife."

After this, Jämbavaté replied to Draupadé's question. She said, "My dear Draupadé, when Lord Kåñëa attacked my father Jämbavän, the King of the åkñas, my father did not know that Lord Kåñëa was his former master, Lord Rämacandra, the husband of Sétä. Not knowing the identity of Lord Kåñëa, my father remained continually engaged in fighting with Him for twenty-seven days. After this period, when he became very tired and fatigued, he could understand that since no one but Lord Rämacandra could defeat him, his opponent, Lord Kåñëa, must be the same Lord Rämacandra. He thus came to his senses and not only immediately returned the Syamantaka jewel, but in order to satisfy the Lord, he presented me to Him to become His wife. In this way I was married to the Lord, and thus my desire to remain life after life as a servitor of Kåñëa was fulfilled."

After this, Kälindé said, "My dear Draupadé, I was engaged in great austerities and penances in order to get Lord Kåñëa as my husband. When Lord Kåñëa became aware of this fact, He very kindly came to me along with His friend Arjuna and accepted me as His wife. Lord Kåñëa then took me away from the bank of Yamunä, and since then I have been engaged in the house of Lord Kåñëa as a sweeper. And the Lord is treating me as His wife."

After this, Mitravindä said, "My dear Draupadé, there was a great assembly of princes at my svayaàvara ceremony. Lord Kåñëa was also present in that meeting, and He accepted me as His maidservant by defeating all the princes present there. He immediately took me away to Dvärakä, exactly as a lion takes a deer from a pack of dogs. When I was thus taken away by Lord Kåñëa, my brothers wanted to fight with Him, and later on they were defeated. Thus my desire to become the maidservant of Kåñëa life after life was fulfilled."

After this, Satyä addressed Draupadé in this way: "My dear Draupadé, my father arranged for an assembly for my svayaàvara [the personal selection of a husband], and in order to test the strength and heroism of the prospective bridegrooms, my father stipulated that they each fight with his seven ferocious bulls, which had long, serpentine horns. Many heroic prospective bridegrooms tried to defeat the bulls, but unfortunately they were all severely struck, and they returned to their homes as defeated invalids. When Lord Çré Kåñëa came and fought with the bulls, they were just like playthings for Him. He captured the bulls and roped each one of them by their nostrils. Thus they came under His control, just like a goat's small kids come very easily under the control of children. My father became very pleased and married me with Lord Kåñëa in great pomp, giving as my dowry many divisions of soldiers, horses, chariots and elephants, along with hundreds of maidservants. Thus Lord Kåñëa brought me to His capital city, Dvärakä. On the way back, He was also assaulted by many princes, but Lord Kåñëa defeated all of them, and thus I have the privilege of serving His lotus feet as a maidservant."

After this, Bhadrä began to speak. She said, "My dear Draupadé, Lord Kåñëa is the son of my maternal uncle. Fortunately, I became attracted to His lotus feet. When my father understood these feelings of mine, he personally arranged for my marriage, inviting Lord Kåñëa to marry me and giving Him in dowry one akñauhiëé, or division of armed forces, along with many maidservants and other royal paraphernalia. I do not know whether I shall be able to have the shelter of Lord Kåñëa life after life, but still I pray to the Lord that wherever I may take my birth I may not forget my relationship with His lotus feet."

Then Lakñmaëä said, "My dear Queen, many times I have heard the great sage Närada glorifying the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa. I became attracted to the lotus feet of Kåñëa when I heard Närada say that the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé, was also attracted to His lotus feet. Since then I have always been thinking of Him, and thus my attraction for Him has increased. My dear Queen, my father was very affectionate toward me. When he understood that I was attracted to Kåñëa, he devised a plan. His plan was like that devised by your father; during the svayaàvara, the prospective bridegrooms had to pierce the eyes of a fish with their arrows. The difference between the competition in your svayaàvara and mine was that in your case the fish was hanging openly on the ceiling, in clear view, but in my case the fish was covered with a cloth and could only be seen by the reflection of the cloth in a pot of water. That was the special feature of my svayaàvara.

"The news of this device was spread all over the world, and when the princes heard of it, they arrived at my father's capital city from all directions, fully equipped with armor and guided by their military instructors. Each one of them desired to win me as his wife, and one after another they raised the bow and arrow which was left there for piercing the fish. Many could not even join the bowstring to the two ends of the bow, and without attempting to pierce the fish, they simply left the bow as it was and went away. Some with great difficulty drew the string from one end to the other, and being unable to tie the other end, they were suddenly knocked down by the spring-like bow. My dear Queen, you will be surprised to know that at my svayaàvara meeting there were many famous kings and heroes present. Heroes like Jaräsandha, Ambañöha, Çiçupäla, Bhémasena, Duryodhana and Karëa were, of course, able to string the bow, but they could not pierce the fish, because it was covered, and they could not trace it out from the reflection. The celebrated hero of the Päëòavas, Arjuna, was able to see the reflection of the fish on the water, but although with great caution he traced out the location of the fish and shot an arrow, he did not pierce the fish in the right spot. His arrow at least touched the fish, and so he proved himself better than all other princes.

"All the princes who had tried to pierce the target were disappointed, being baffled in their attempts, and some candidates had even left the place without making an attempt, but when at last Lord Kåñëa took up the bow, He was able to tie the bowstring very easily, just as a child plays with a toy. He placed the arrow, and looking only once at the reflection of the fish in the water, He shot the arrow, and the pierced fish immediately fell down. This victory of Lord Kåñëa was accomplished at noon, during the moment called abhijit, which is astronomically calculated as auspicious. At that time the vibration of 'Jaya! Jaya!' was heard all over the world, and from the sky came sounds of drums beat by the denizens of heaven. Great demigods were overwhelmed with joy and began to shower flowers on the earth.

"At that time, I entered the arena of competition, and the ankle bells on my legs were sounding very melodiously as I walked. I was nicely dressed with new silken garments, flowers were decorating my hair, and because of Lord Kåñëa's victory, I was in ecstatic joy and smiling very pleasingly. I was carrying in my hands a golden necklace bedecked with jewels, which was glittered at intervals. My curling hair encircled my face, which was shining with a bright luster due to the reflection of my various rings. My eyes blinking, I first of all observed all the princes present, and when I reached my Lord I very slowly placed the golden necklace on His neck. As I have already informed you, from the very beginning my mind had been attracted by Lord Kåñëa, and thus I considered the garlanding of the Lord to be my great victory. As soon as I placed my garland on the neck of the Lord, there sounded immediately the combined vibration of mådaìgas, paöahas, conchshells, drums, kettledrums and other instruments, causing a tumultuous sound, and while the music played, expert male and female dancers began to dance, and singers began to sing sweetly.

"My dear Draupadé, when I accepted Lord Kåñëa as my worshipable husband, and He also accepted me as His maidservant, there was a tumultuous roaring among the disappointed princes. All of them became very agitated because of their lusty desires, but without caring for them, my husband, in His form as the four-handed Näräyaëa, immediately took me on His chariot, which was drawn by four excellent horses. Expecting opposition from the princes, He armored Himself and took up His bow named Çärìga, but our celebrated driver, Däruka, drove the beautiful chariot without a moment's delay toward the city of Dvärakä. Thus, in the presence of all the princes, I was carried away very quickly, exactly as a deer is carried away from the flock by a lion. Some of the princes, however, wanted to check our progress, and thus, equipped with proper weapons, they opposed us, just as dogs try to oppose the progressive march of a lion. At that time, due to the arrows released by the Çärìga bow of Lord Kåñëa, some of the princes were cut on their left hands, some of them lost their legs, and some lost their heads and their lives, and others fled from the battlefield.

"The Supreme Personality of Godhead then entered the most celebrated city of the universe, Dvärakä, and as He entered the city, He appeared like the shining sun. The whole city of Dvärakä was profusely decorated on that occasion. There were so many flags and festoons and gates all over Dvärakä that the sunshine could not even enter the city. I have already told you that my father was very much affectionate to me, so when he saw that my desire was fulfilled by getting Lord Kåñëa as my husband, in great happiness he began to distribute to friends and relatives various kinds of gifts, such as valuable dresses, ornaments, bedsteads and sitting carpets. Lord Kåñëa is always self-sufficient, yet my father, out of his own accord, offered my husband a dowry consisting of riches, soldiers, elephants, chariots, horses and many rare and valuable weapons. He presented all these to the Lord with great enthusiasm. My dear Queen, at that time I could guess that in my previous life I must have performed some wonderfully pious activity, and as a result I can in this life be one of the maidservants in the house of the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

When all the principal queens of Lord Kåñëa had finished their statements, Rohiëé, as the representative of the other sixteen thousand queens, began to narrate the incident of their becoming wives of Kåñëa.

"My dear Queen, when Bhaumäsura was conquering all the world, he collected wherever possible all the beautiful daughters of the kings and kept us arrested within his palace. When news of our imprisonment reached Lord Kåñëa, He fought with Bhaumäsura and released us. Lord Kåñëa killed Bhaumäsura and all his soldiers, and although He had no need to accept even one wife, He nevertheless, by our request, married all sixteen thousand of us. My dear Queen, our only qualification was that we were always thinking of the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa, which is the way to release oneself from the bondage of repeated birth and death. My dear Queen Draupadé, please take it from us that we are not after any opulence such as kingdom, empire, or a position of heavenly enjoyment. We do not want to enjoy such material opulences, nor do we desire to achieve the yogic perfections, nor the exhalted post of Lord Brahmä. Nor do we want any of the different kinds of liberation—sälokya, särñöi, sämépya or säyujya. We are not at all attracted by any of these opulences. Our only ambition is to bear on our heads life after life the dust particles attached to the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa. The goddess of fortune also desired to keep that dust on her breast along with the fragrant saffron. We simply desire this dust, which accumulates underneath the lotus feet of Kåñëa as He travels on the land of Våndävana as a cowherd boy. The gopés especially, and also the cowherd men and the aborigine tribeswomen, always desire to become the grass and straw on the street of Våndävana, to be trampled on by the lotus feet of Kåñëa. My dear Queen, we wish to remain as such life after life, without any other desire."

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twenty-eighth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Draupadé Meets the Queens of Kåñëa."

KB 1970-2-29 / Sacrificial Ceremonies Performed by Vasudeva

29 /Sacrificial Ceremonies Performed by Vasudeva

Among the women present at Kurukñetra during the solar eclipse were Kunté, Gändhäré, Draupadé, Subhadrä and the queens of many other kings, as well as the gopés from Våndävana. When the different queens of Lord Kåñëa were submitting their statements as to how they were married and accepted by Lord Kåñëa as His wives, all the female members of the Kuru dynasty were struck with wonder. They were filled with admiration at how all the queens of Kåñëa were attached to Him with love and affection. When they heard about the queens' intensity of love and affection for Kåñëa, they could not check their eyes from filling up with tears.

While the women were engaged in conversations among themselves and the men were similarly engaged in conversation, there arrived almost all the important sages and ascetics from all directions, who had come for the purpose of seeing Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma. Chief among the sages were Kåñëa-dvaipäyana Vyäsa, the great sage Närada, Cyavana, Devala, Asita, Viçvämitra, Çatänanda, Bharadväja, Gautama, and Lord Paraçuräma along with his disciples; Vasiñöha, Gälava, Bhågu, Pulastya, Kaçyapa, Atri, Märkaëòeya, Båhaspati, Dvita, Trita, Ekata; the four Kumära sons of Brahmä, Sanaka, Sanandana, Sanätana and Sanatkumära; Aìgira and Agastya, Yäjïavalkya and Vämadeva.

As soon as the sages and ascetics arrived, all the kings, including Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira and the Päëòavas and Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, immediately got up from their seats and offered their respects by bowing down to the universally respected sages. After this, the sages were properly welcomed by being offered seats and water for washing their feet. Palatable fruits, garlands of flowers, incense, and sandalwood pulp were presented, and all the kings, led by Kåñëa and Balaräma, worshiped the sages according to the Vedic rules and regulations. When all the sages were comfortably seated, Lord Kåñëa, who descended for the protection of religion, began to address them on behalf of all the kings. When Kåñëa began to speak, all became silent, being eager to hear and understand His welcoming words to the sages.

Lord Kåñëa spoke thus: "All glories to the assembled sages and ascetics! Today we are all feeling that our lives have become successful. Today we have achieved the desired goal of life, because we are now seeing face to face all the exalted liberated sages and ascetics whom even the great demigods in the heavens desire to see. Persons who are neophytes in devotional service and who simply offer their respectful obeisances to the Deity in the temple but cannot realize that the Lord is situated in everyone's heart, and those who simply worship different demigods for fulfillment of their own lusty desires, are unable to understand the importance of these sages. They cannot take advantage of receiving these sages by seeing them with their eyes, by touching their lotus feet, by inquiring about their welfare or by diligently worshiping them."

Neophyte devotees or religionists cannot understand the importance of great mahätmäs. They go to the temple as a matter of formality and pay their respectful obeisances unto the Deity. When one is promoted to the next platform of trance consciousness, one can understand the importance of mahätmäs and devotees, and in that stage the devotee tries to please them. Therefore, Lord Kåñëa said that the neophyte cannot understand the importance of great sages, devotees or ascetics.

Kåñëa continued, "One cannot purify himself by traveling to holy places of pilgrimage and taking bath there or by seeing the Deities in the temples. But if one happens to meet a great devotee, a mahätmä who is representative of the Personality of Godhead, one becomes immediately purified. In order to become purified, there is the injunction to worship the fire, the sun, the moon, the earth, the water, the air, the sky and the mind. By worshiping all the elements and their predominating deities, one can become free from the influence of envy, but all the sins of an envious person can be nullified immediately simply by serving a great soul. My dear revered sages and respectable kings, you can take it from Me that a person who accepts this material body made of three elements—mucus, bile and air—as his own self, who considers his family and relatives as his own, and who accepts material things as worshipable, or who visits holy places of pilgrimage just to take a bath there, but never associates with great personalities, sages and mahätmäs—such a person, even in the form of a human being, is nothing but an animal, like an ass."

When the supreme authority, Lord Kåñëa, was thus speaking with great gravity, all the sages and ascetics remained in dead silence. They became amazed upon hearing Him speaking the absolute philosophy of life in such a concise way. Unless one is very much advanced in knowledge, one thinks his body to be his self, his family members to be his kith and kin, and the land of his birth to be worshipable. From this concept of life, the modern ideology of nationalism has sprung up. Lord Kåñëa condemned such ideas, and He also condemned persons who take the trouble to go to holy places of pilgrimage just to take a bath and come back without taking the opportunity to associate with the great devotees and mahätmäs living there. Such persons are compared to the most foolish animal, the ass. All those who heard considered the speech of Lord Kåñëa for some time, and they concluded that Lord Kåñëa was actually the Supreme Personality of Godhead, playing the role of an ordinary human being who is forced to take a certain type of body as a result of the reactions of his past deeds. He was assuming this pastime as an ordinary human simply to teach the people in general how they should live for perfection of the human mission.

Having concluded that Kåñëa was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the sages began to address Him thus: "Dear Lord, we, the leaders of human society, are supposed to possess the proper philosophy of life, and yet we are becoming bewildered by the spell of Your external energy. We are surprised to see Your behavior, which is just like that of an ordinary human being and which conceals Your real identity as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and we therefore consider Your pastimes to be all-wonderful.

"Our dear Lord, by Your own energy You are creating, maintaining and annihilating the whole cosmic manifestation of different names and forms, in the same way as the earth creates many forms of stone, trees and other varieties of names and forms and yet remains the same. Although You are creating varieties of manifestation through Your energy, You are unaffected by all those actions. Our dear Lord, we remain simply stunned by seeing Your wonderful actions. Although You are transcendental to this entire material creation and are the Supreme Lord and the Supersoul of all living entities, You nevertheless appear on this earth by Your internal potency to protect Your devotees and destroy the miscreants. By such appearance You reestablish the principles of eternal religion, which the human society forgets by long association with the material energy. Our dear Lord, You are the creator of the social orders and spiritual statuses of the human society according to quality and work, and when these orders are misguided by unscrupulous persons, You appear and set them right.

"Dear Lord, the Vedic knowledge is the representation of Your pure heart. Austerities, study of the Vedas, and meditative trances lead to different realizations of Your Self in Your manifested and nonmanifested aspects. The entire phenomenal world is a manifestation of Your impersonal energy, but You Yourself, as the original Personality of Godhead, are nonmanifested there. You are the Supreme Soul, the Supreme Brahman. Persons who are situated in brahminical culture, therefore, can understand the truth about Your transcendental form. Thus You always hold the brähmaëas in respect, and thus You are considered to be the topmost of all followers of brahminical culture. You are therefore known as brahmaëya-deva. Our dear Lord, You are the last word in good fortune and the last resort of all saintly persons; therefore we all consider that we have achieved the perfection of our life, education, austerity and acquisition of transcendental knowledge by meeting You. Factually, You are the ultimate goal of all transcendental achievements.

"Our dear Lord, there is no end to Your unlimited knowledge. Your form is transcendental, eternally existing in full bliss and knowledge. You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Supreme Brahman, the Supreme Soul. Being covered by the spell of Your internal potency, yogamäyä, You are now temporarily concealing Your unlimited potencies, but still we can understand Your exalted position, and therefore all of us offer You our respectful obeisances. Dear Lord, You are enjoying Your pastimes in the role of a human being, concealing Your real character of transcendental opulence; therefore, all the kings who are present here, even the members of the Yadu dynasty who are constantly mingling with You, eating with You, and sitting with You, cannot understand that You are the original cause of all causes, the soul of everyone, the original cause of all creation.

"When a person dreams at night, hallucinatory figures created by the dream are accepted as real, and the imaginary dream body is accepted as one's real body. For the time being one forgets that besides the body created in hallucination, there is another, real body in his awakened state. Similarly, in the awakened state also, the bewildered conditioned soul considers sense enjoyment to be real happiness.

"By the process of enjoyment of the senses of the material body, the spirit soul is covered, and his consciousness becomes materially contaminated. It is due to material consciousness that one cannot understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. All great mystic yogés endeavor to revive their Kåñëa consciousness by mature practice of the yoga system and thus understand Your lotus feet and meditate upon Your transcendental form. In this way the accumulated result of sinful activities is counteracted. It is said that the water of the Ganges can vanquish volumes of a person's sinful actions, but the Ganges water is glorious only due to Your lotus feet. The Ganges water is flowing as perspiration from the lotus feet of Your Lordship. And we are all so fortunate that today we have been able to directly see Your lotus feet. Dear Lord, we are all surrendered souls, devotees of Your Lordship; therefore, please be kind and bestow Your causeless mercy upon us. We know well that persons who have become liberated by constant engagement in Your devotional service are no longer contaminated by the material modes of nature; thus they have become eligible to be promoted to the kingdom of God in the spiritual world."

After first offering prayers to Lord Kåñëa, the assembled sages wanted to take permission from King Dhåtaräñöra and King Yudhiñöhira and then depart for their respective äçramas. At that time, however, Vasudeva, the father of Lord Kåñëa and the most celebrated of all pious men, approached the sages and with great humility offered his respects by falling down at their feet. Vasudeva said, "My dear great sages, you are more respected than the demigods. I therefore offer my respectful obeisances unto you. I wish that you will accept my one request, if you so desire. I shall consider it a great blessing if you kindly explain the supreme fruitive activity by which one can counteract the reactions of all other activities."

The great sage Närada was the leader of all the sages present there. Therefore he began to speak. "My dear sages," he said, "it is not very difficult to understand that because of his great goodness and simplicity, Vasudeva, who has become the father of the Personality of Godhead by accepting Kåñëa as his son, is inclined to ask us about his welfare. It is said that familiarity breeds contempt. As such, Vasudeva, having Kåñëa as his son, does not regard Kåñëa with awe and veneration. Sometimes it is seen that persons who are living on the bank of the Ganges do not consider the Ganges to be very important, and they go far away in order to take their baths at a place of pilgrimage. Being that Lord Kåñëa, whose knowledge is never second in any circumstances, is personally present, there is no need of Vasudeva's asking us for instruction.

"Lord Kåñëa is not affected by the process of creation, maintenance and annihilation; His knowledge is never influenced by any agency beyond Himself. He is not agitated by the interaction of the material qualities, which changes things in the modes of time. His transcendental form is full of knowledge which never becomes agitated by ignorance, pride, attachment, envy or sense enjoyment. His knowledge is never subjected to the laws of karma regarding pious or impious activities; nor is it influenced by the three modes of material energy. No one is greater than or equal to Him, because He is the supreme authority, the Personality of Godhead.

"The ordinary conditioned human being may think the conditioned soul, who is covered by his materialistic senses, mind and intelligence, to be equal to Kåñëa, but Lord Kåñëa is just like the sun, which, although it sometimes may appear to be so, is never covered by the cloud, snow or fog or by other planets. When the eyes of less intelligent men are covered by such influences, they think the sun to be invisible. Similarly, persons influenced by the senses and addicted to material enjoyment cannot have a clear vision of the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

The sages present then began to address Vasudeva in the presence of Lord Kåñëa, Balaräma and many other kings, and, as requested by him, they gave their instructions: "To counteract the reaction of karma, or desires impelling one to fruitive activities, one must execute the prescribed sacrifices which are meant for worshiping Lord Viñëu with faith and devotion. Lord Viñëu is the beneficiary of the results of all sacrificial performances. Great personalities and sages who are sufficiently experienced to possess vision of the three phases of the time element, namely past, present and future, and those who are able to see everything clearly through the eyes of revealed scriptures, have unanimously recommended that to purify the dust of material contamination accumulated in the heart and to clear the path of liberation and thereby achieve transcendental bliss, one must please Lord Viñëu. For everyone in the different social orders (brähmaëa, kñatriya and vaiçya) who are living as householders, this worship of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Lord Viñëu, who is known as Puruñottama, the original person, is recommended as the only auspicious path.

"All conditioned souls within this material world have deep-rooted desires to lord it over the resources of material nature. Everyone wants to accumulate riches, everyone wants to enjoy life to the greatest extent, everyone wants a wife, home and children, and everyone wants to become happy in this world and be elevated to the heavenly planets in the next life. But these desires are the causes of one's material bondage. Therefore, to get liberation from this bondage, one has to sacrifice his honestly earned riches for the satisfaction of Lord Viñëu.

"The only process to counteract all sorts of material desire is to engage oneself in the devotional service of Lord Viñëu. In this way a self-controlled person, even while remaining in householder life, should give up the three kinds of material desires, namely desire for the acquisition of material opulences, the enjoyment of wife and children, and elevation to higher planets. Eventually he may give up householder life and accept the renounced order of life, engaging himself completely in the devotional service of the Lord. Everyone, even if born in a higher status of life as brähmaëa, kñatriya, or vaiçya, is certainly indebted to the demigods, to the sages, to the forefathers, to living entities and so on, and in order to liquidate all these debts, one has to perform sacrifices, study the Vedic literature, and generate children in religious householder life. If somehow one accepts the renounced order of life without fulfilling this debt, certainly he falls down from his position. Today you have already liquidated your debts to your forefathers and the sages. Now, by performing sacrifices, you can free yourself from indebtedness to the demigods and thus take complete shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. My dear Vasudeva, certainly you have already performed many pious activities in your previous lives. Otherwise, how could you be the father of Kåñëa and Balaräma, the Supreme Personality of Godhead?"

Saintly Vasudeva, after hearing all the sages, offered his respectful obeisances unto their lotus feet. In this way he pleased the sages, and then he elected for them to perform the yajïas. When the sages were elected as priests of the sacrifices, they also in their turn induced Vasudeva to collect the required paraphernalia for executing the yajïas in that place of pilgrimage. Thus Vasudeva was persuaded to start to perform the yajïas, and all the members of the Yadu dynasty took their baths, dressed themselves very nicely, and decorated themselves beautifully and garlanded themselves with lotus flowers. Vasudeva's wives, dressed with nice garments and ornaments and golden necklaces, approached the arena of sacrifice carrying in their hands the required articles to offer in the sacrifice.

When everything was complete, there was heard the vibration of mådaìgas, conchshells, kettledrums and other musical instruments. Professional dancers, both male and female, began to dance. The sütas and mägadhas, who were professional singers, began to offer prayers by singing. The Gandharvas and their wives, whose voices were very sweet, began to sing many auspicious songs. Vasudeva anointed his eyes with collyrium, smeared butter over his body, and then, along with his eighteen wives, headed by Devaké, sat before the priests to be purified by the abhiñeka ceremony. All such ceremonies were observed strictly according to the principles of scriptures, as was done formerly in the case of the moon with the stars. Vasudeva, because he was being initiated for the sacrifice, was dressed in deerskin, but all his wives were dressed with very nice saris, bangles, necklaces, ankle bells, earrings and many other ornaments. Vasudeva looked very beautiful surrounded by his wives, exactly like the King of heaven when he performs such sacrifices.

At that time, when Lord Kåñëa and Lord Balaräma, along with Their wives, children and relatives, sat down in that great sacrificial arena, it appeared that the Supreme Personality of Godhead was present along with all His part and parcel living entities and multi-energies. We have heard from the çästras that Lord Kåñëa has multi-energies and parts and parcels, but now in that sacrificial arena all could actually experience how the Supreme Personality of Godhead eternally exists along with His different energies. At that time, Lord Kåñëa appeared as Lord Näräyaëa, and Lord Balaräma appeared as Saìkarñaëa, the reservoir of all living entities.

Vasudeva satisfied Lord Viñëu by performing different kinds of sacrifices, such as jyotiñöoma, darña and pürëamäsa. Some of these yajïas are called präkåta, and some of them are known as sauryasatra or vaikåta. Thereafter, the other sacrifices, known as agnihotra, were also performed, and the prescribed articles were offered in the proper way. In this way Lord Viñëu became pleased. The ultimate purpose of offering oblations in sacrifice is to please Lord Viñëu. But in this age of Kali it is very difficult to collect the different articles required for offering sacrifices. People have neither the means to collect the required paraphernalia nor the necessary knowledge or tendency to offer such sacrifices. Therefore, in this age of Kali, when people are mostly unfortunate, full of anxieties and disturbed by various kinds of calamities, the only sacrifice recommended is the performance of saìkértana-yajïa. Worshiping Lord Caitanya by this saìkértana-yajïa is the only recommended process in this age.

After the performance of the different sacrifices, Vasudeva offered ample riches, clothing, ornaments, cows, land and maidservants to the priests. Thereafter, all the wives of Vasudeva took their avabhåtha baths and performed the part of the sacrificial duties known as patnésaàyäja. After finishing the offering with all the required paraphernalia, they all took their baths together in the lakes constructed by Paraçuräma, which are known as the Räma-hrada. After Vasudeva and his wives took their baths, all the garments and ornaments which they wore were distributed to the subordinate persons who were engaged in singing, dancing and similar activities. We may note that the performance of sacrifice necessitates the profuse distribution of riches. Charity is offered to the priests and the brähmaëas in the beginning, and used garments and ornaments are offered in charity to the subordinate assistants after the performance of the sacrifice.

After offering the used articles to the singers and reciters, Vasudeva and his wives, dressed with new ornaments and dresses, fed everyone very sumptuously, beginning from the brähmaëas down to the dogs. After this, all the friends, family members, wives and children of Vasudeva, along with all the kings and members of the Vidarbha, Koçala, Kuru, Käçé, Kekaya and Såïjaya dynasties, assembled together. The priests, the demigods, the people in general, the forefathers, the ghosts and the Cäraëas were all sufficiently remunerated by being offered ample gifts and respectful honor. Then all the persons assembled there took permission from Lord Kåñëa, the husband of the goddess of fortune, and while glorifying the perfection of the sacrifice made by Vasudeva, they departed to their respective homes.

At that time, when King Dhåtaräñöra, Vidura, Yudhiñöhira, Bhéma, Arjuna, Bhéñmadeva, Droëäcärya, Kunté, Nakula, Sahadeva, Närada, Lord Vyäsadeva and many other relatives and kinsmen were about to part, they felt separation and therefore embraced each and every member of the Yadu dynasty with great feeling. Many others who were assembled in that sacrificial arena also departed. After this, Lord Kåñëa and Lord Balaräma, along with King Ugrasena, satisfied the inhabitants of Våndävana, headed by Mahäräja Nanda and the cowherd men, by profusely offering all kinds of gifts in order to worship them and please them. Out of their great feelings of friendship, the inhabitants of Våndävana remained there for a considerable time along with the members of the Yadu dynasty.

After performing this sacrifice, Vasudeva felt so satisfied that there was no limit to his happiness. All the members of his family were with him, and in their presence he caught hold of the hands of Nanda Mahäräja and addressed him thus: "My dear brother, the Supreme Personality of Godhead has created a great tie of bondage which is known as the bondage of love and affection. I think it is a very difficult job for even the great sages and saintly persons to cut such a tie of love. My dear brother, you have exhibited feelings of love for me, which I was not able to return. I think, therefore, that I am ungrateful. You have behaved exactly as is characteristic of saintly persons, but I shall never be able to repay you. I have no means to repay you for your friendly dealings. Nevertheless I am confident that our tie of love will never break. Our relationship of friendship must ever continue, in spite of my inability to repay you. I hope you will excuse me for this inability.

"My dear brother, in the beginning, due to my being imprisoned, I could never serve you as a friend, and although at the present moment I am very opulent, because of my material prosperity I have become blind. I therefore cannot satisfy you properly even at this time. My dear brother, you are so nice and gentle that you offer all respect to others, but you don't care for any respect for yourself. A person seeking for auspicious progress in life must not possess too much material opulence with which to become blind and puffed up, but he should take care of his friends and relatives."

When Vasudeva was speaking to Nanda Mahäräja in this way, he was influenced by a great feeling for the friendship of Nanda Mahäräja and the beneficial activities executed by King Nanda on his behalf. As such, his eyes filled with tears, and he began to cry. Desiring to please his friend Vasudeva and being affectionately bound with love for Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, Nanda Mahäräja passed three months in their association. At the end of this time, all the members of Yadu dynasty tried to please the inhabitants of Våndävana to their hearts' content. The members of the Yadu dynasty tried to satisfy Nanda Mahäräja and his associates by offering them clothing, ornaments, and many other valuable articles, and they all became fully satisfied. Vasudeva, Ugrasena, Lord Kåñëa, Lord Balaräma, Uddhava and all other members of the Yadu dynasty presented their individual gifts to Nanda Mahäräja and his associates. After Nanda Mahäräja received these farewell presentations, he, along with his associates, started for Vrajabhümi, Våndävana. The minds of the inhabitants of Våndävana remained, however, with Kåñëa and Balaräma, and therefore all of them started for Våndävana without their minds.

When the members of the Våñëi family saw all their friends and visitors departing, they observed that the rainy season was approaching, and thus they decided to return to Dvärakä. They were fully satisfied, for they regarded Kåñëa as everything. When they returned to Dvärakä, they began with great satisfaction to describe the sacrifice performed by Vasudeva, their meeting with various friends and well-wishers, and various other incidences which occurred during their travels in the places of pilgrimage.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Twenty-Ninth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Sacrificial Ceremonies Performed by Vasudeva."

KB 1970-2-30 / Spiritual Instruction for Vasudeva and Return of the Six Dead Sons of Devaké by Lord Kåñëa

30 /Spiritual Instruction for Vasudeva and Return of the Six Dead Sons of Devaké by Lord Kåñëa

It is a Vedic custom that the junior members of the family should offer respects to the elderly persons every morning. The children or the disciples especially should offer their respects to the parents or the spiritual master in the morning. In pursuance of this Vedic principle, Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma used to offer Their obeisances to Their father, Vasudeva, along with his wives. One day, after having returned from the sacrificial performances at Kurukñetra, when Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma went to offer Their respect to Vasudeva, Vasudeva took the opportunity of appreciating the exalted position of his two sons. Vasudeva had the opportunity to understand the position of Kåñëa and Balaräma from the great sages who had assembled in the arena of the sacrifice. He not only heard from the sages, but on many occasions he actually experienced that Kåñëa and Balaräma were not ordinary human beings, but were very extraordinary. Thus he believed the words of the sages that his sons Kåñëa and Balaräma were the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

With firm faith in his sons, he addressed them thus: "My dear Kåñëa, You are the sac-cid-änanda-vigraha Supreme Personality of Godhead, and my dear Balaräma, You are Saìkarñaëa, the master of all mystic powers. I have now understood that You are eternal. Both of You are transcendental to this material manifestation and to its cause, the Supreme Person Mahä-Viñëu. You are the original controller of all. You are the rest of this cosmic manifestation. You are its creator, and You are also its creative ingredients. You are the master of this cosmic manifestation, and actually this manifestation is created for Your pastimes only.

"The different material phases from the beginning to the end of the cosmos manifest under different time formulas are also Yourself, because You are both the cause and effect of this manifestation. The two features of this material world, the predominator and the predominated, are also You, and You are the supreme transcendental controller who stands above them. Therefore, You are beyond the perception of our senses. You are the supreme soul, unborn and unchanging. You are not affected by the six kinds of transformations which occur in the material body. The wonderful varieties of this material world are also created by You, and You have entered as the Supersoul into each living entity and even into the atom. You are the maintainer of everything.

"The vital force which is acting as the life principle in everything and the creative force derived from it are not acting independently, but are dependent upon You, the Supreme Person behind these forces. Without Your will, they cannot work. Material energy has no cognizance. It cannot act independently without being agitated by You. Because the material nature is dependent upon You, the living entities can only attempt to act. But without Your sanction and will they cannot perform anything or achieve the result they desire.

"The original energy is only an emanation from You. My dear Lord, the shining of the moon, the heat of the fire, the rays of the sun, the glittering of the stars, and the electric lightning which is manifested as very powerful, as well as the gravity of the mountains, the energy of the earth and the quality of its flavor—all are different manifestations of You. The pure taste of water and the vital force which maintains all life are also features of Your Lordship. The water and its taste are also Yourself.

"My dear Lord, although the forces of the senses, the mental power of thinking, willing and feeling, and the strength, movement and growth of the body appear to be performed by different movements of the airs within the body, they are all ultimately manifestations of Your energy. The vast expanse of outer space rests in Yourself. The vibration of the sky, its thunder, the supreme sound omkära and the arrangement of different words to distinguish one thing from the other are symbolic representations of Yourself. Everything is Yourself. The senses, the controllers of the senses, the demigods, and the acquisition of knowledge which is the purpose of the senses, as well as the subject matter of knowledge—all are Yourself. The resolution of intelligence and the sharp memory of the living entity are also Yourself. You are the egotistic principle in ignorance which is the cause of this material world, the egotistic principle of passion which is the cause of the senses, and the egotistic principle of goodness which is the origin or the different controlling deities of this material world. The illusory energy, or mäyä, which is the cause of the conditioned soul's perpetual transmigration from one form to another, is Yourself.

"My dear Supreme Personality of Godhead, You are the original cause of all causes, exactly as the earth is the original cause of different kinds of trees, plants and similar varieties of manifestation. As the earth is represented in everything, so You are present throughout this material manifestation as Supersoul. You are the supreme cause of all causes, the eternal principle. Everything is, in fact, a manifestation of Your one energy. The three qualities of material nature—sattva, rajas and tamas—and the result of their interaction, are linked up with You by Your agency of yogamäyä. They are supposed to be independent, but actually the total material energy is resting upon You, the Supersoul. Since You are the supreme cause of everything, the interactions of material manifestation—birth, existence, growth, transformation, deterioration and annihilation—are all absent in Yourself. Your supreme energy, yogamäyä, is acting in variegated manifestations, but because yogamäyä is Your energy, You are therefore present in everything."

In the Bhagavad-gétä, this fact is very nicely explained in the Ninth Chapter, wherein the Lord says, "In My impersonal form I am spread all over the material energy; everything is resting in Me, but I am not there." This very statement is also given by Vasudeva. To say He is not present everywhere means that He is aloof from everything, although His energy is acting everywhere. This can be understood by a crude example: In a big establishment, the energy, or the organization of the supreme boss, is working in every nook and corner of the business, but that does not mean that the original proprietor is present there, although in every department and every atmosphere the presence of the proprietor is felt by the worker. The physical presence of the proprietor in every department is formality only. Actually his energy is working everywhere. Similarly, the omnipresence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is felt in the action of His energies. Therefore the philosophy of inconceivable simultaneous oneness with and difference from the Supreme Lord is confirmed everywhere. The Lord is one, but His energies are diverse.

Vasudeva said, "This material world is like a great flowing river, and its waves are the three material modes of nature—goodness, passion and ignorance. This material body, as well as the senses, the faculties of thinking, feeling and willing and the stages of distress, happiness, attachment and lust—all are are different products of these three qualities of nature. The foolish person who cannot realize Your transcendental identity above all this material reaction continues to remain in the entanglement of fruitive activity and is subjected to the continuous process of birth and death without a chance of being freed.

This is also confirmed in a different way by the Lord in the Fourth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä. There it is said that anyone who knows the appearance and activities of the Supreme Lord Kåñëa becomes freed from the clutches of material nature and goes back home, back to Godhead. Therefore Kåñëa's transcendental name, form, activities and qualities are not products of this material nature.

"My dear Lord," Vasudeva continued, "despite all these defects of the conditioned soul, if someone somehow or other comes in contact with devotional service, he achieves this civilized human form of body with developed consciousness and thereby becomes capable of executing further progress in devotional service. And yet, illusioned by the external energy, people generally do not utilize this advantage of the human form of life. Thus they miss the chance of eternal freedom and unnecessarily spoil the progress they have made after thousands of births.

"In the bodily concept of life, one is attached to the offspring of the body, due to false egotism, and everyone in conditioned life is entrapped by false relationships and false affection. The whole world is moving under this false impression of material bondage. I know that neither of You are my sons; You are the original chief and progenitor, the Personalities of Godhead, known as Pradhäna and Puruña. But You have appeared on the surface of this globe in order to minimize the burden of the world by killing the kñatriya kings who are unnecessarily increasing their military strength. You have already informed me about this in the past. My dear Lord, You are the shelter of the surrendered soul, the supreme well-wisher of the meek and humble. I am therefore taking shelter of Your lotus feet, which alone can give one liberation from the entanglement of material existence.

"For a long time I have simply considered this body to be myself, and although You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, I consider You to be my son. My dear Lord, at the very moment when You first appeared in Kaàsa's prison house, I was informed that You were the Supreme Personality of Godhead and that You had descended for the protection of the principles of religion as well as the destruction of the unfaithful. Although unborn, You descend in every millennium to execute Your mission. My dear Lord, as in the sky there are many forms appearing and disappearing, so You also appear and disappear in many eternal forms. Who, therefore, can understand Your pastimes or the mystery of Your appearance and disappearance? Our only business should be to glorify Your supreme greatness."

When Vasudeva was addressing his divine sons in that way, Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma were smiling. Because They are very affectionate to Their devotees, They accepted all the appreciation of Vasudeva with a kindly smiling attitude. Kåñëa then began to confirm all Vasudeva's statements as follows: "My dear father, whatever you may say, We are, after all, your sons. What you have said about us is certainly a highly philosophical understanding of spiritual knowledge. I accept it in total without exception."

Vasudeva was in the complete perfection of life in considering Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma to be his sons, but because the sages assembled in the place of pilgrimage at Kurukñetra had spoken about the Lord as the supreme cause of everything, Vasudeva simply repeated it out of his love for Kåñëa and Balaräma. Lord Kåñëa did not wish to detract from His relationship with Vasudeva as father and son; therefore in the very beginning of His reply He accepted the fact that He is the eternal son of Vasudeva and that Vasudeva is the eternal father of Kåñëa. After this, Lord Kåñëa informed His father of the spiritual identity of all living entities. He continued, "My dear father, everyone, including Myself and My brother Balaräma, as well as all the inhabitants of the city of Dvärakä and the whole cosmic manifestation, is exactly as you have already explained, but all of us are also qualitatively one."

Lord Kåñëa intended for Vasudeva to see everything in the vision of a mahäbhägavata, a first-class devotee. A first-class devotee sees that all living entities are part and parcel of the Supreme Lord and that the Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart. In fact, every living entity has spiritual identity, but in contact with material existence he becomes influenced by the material modes of nature. He becomes covered by the concept of bodily life, forgetting that his spirit soul is of the same quality as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. One mistakenly considers one individual to be different from another simply because of their material bodily coverings. Because of differences between bodies, the spirit soul appears before us differently.

Lord Kåñëa then gave a nice example in terms of the five material elements. The total material elements, namely, the sky, the air, the fire, the water and the earth, are present in everything in the material world, whether in an earthen pot or in a mountain or in the trees or in an earring. These five elements are present in everything, in different proportions and quantities. A mountain is a gigantic form of the combination of these five elements, and a small earthen pot is of the same elements, but in a smaller quantity. Therefore all material items, although in different shapes or different quantities, are of the same ingredients. Similarly, the living entities—beginning from Lord Kåñëa and including the Viñëu-tattva and millions of Viñëu forms, and then the living entities in different forms, beginning from Lord Brahmä down to the small ant—are all of the same quality in spirit. Some are great in quantity, and some are small, but qualitatively they are of the same nature. It is therefore confirmed in the Upaniñads that Kåñëa, or the Supreme Lord, is the chief among all living entities, and He maintains them and supplies them with all necessities of life. Anyone who knows this philosophy is in perfect knowledge. The Vedic version tat tvam asi, "Thou art the same," does not mean that everyone is God, but everyone is qualitatively of the same nature as that of God.

After hearing Kåñëa speak the entire philosophy of spiritual life in an abbreviated summation, Vasudeva was exceedingly pleased with his son. Being thus elated, he could not speak, but remained silent. In the meantime, Devaké, the mother of Lord Kåñëa, sat by the side of her husband. Previously she had heard that both Kåñëa and Balaräma were so kind upon Their teacher that They had brought back the teacher's dead sons from the clutches of the superintendent of death, Yamaräja. Since she had heard this incident, she had been also thinking of her own sons who were killed by Kaàsa, and while remembering them she became overwhelmed with grief.

In compassion for her dead sons, Devaké began to appeal to Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma thus: "My dear Balaräma, Your very name suggests that You give all pleasure and all strength to everyone. Your unlimited potency is beyond the reach of our minds and words, and my dear Kåñëa, You are the master of all mystic yogés. I also know that You are the master of the Prajäpatis like Brahmä and his assistants, and You are the original Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa. I also know for certain that You have descended to annihilate all kinds of miscreants who have been misled in the course of time. They have lost control of their minds and senses, fallen from the quality of goodness, and have deliberately neglected the direction of the revealed scriptures by living a life of extravagancy and impudency. You have descended on the earth to minimize the burden of the world by killing such miscreant rulers. My dear Kåñëa, I know that Mahä-Viñëu, who is lying in the causal ocean of the cosmic manifestation and who is the source of this whole creation, is simply an expansion of Your plenary portion. Creation, maintenance and annihilation of this cosmic manifestation are being effected only by Your plenary portion. I am, therefore, taking shelter of You without any reservation. I have heard that when You wanted to reward Your teacher, Sändépani Muni, and he asked You to bring back his dead son, You and Balaräma immediately brought him from the custody of Yamaräja, although he had been dead for a very long time. By this act I understand You to be the supreme master of all mystic yogés. I am, therefore, asking You to fulfill my desire in the same way. In other words, I am asking You to bring back all my sons who were killed by Kaàsa; upon Your bringing them back, my heart will be content, and it will be a great pleasure for me just to see them once."

After hearing Their mother speak in this way, Lord Balaräma and Kåñëa immediately called for the assistance of yogamäyä and started for the lower planetary system known as Sutala. Formerly, in His incarnation of Vämana, the Supreme Personality of Godhead was satisfied by the king of the demons, Bali Mahäräja, who donated to Him everything he had. Bali Mahäräja was then given the whole of Sutala for his residence and kingdom. Now when this great devotee, Bali Mahäräja, saw that Lord Balaräma and Kåñëa had come to his planet, he immediately merged in the ocean of happiness. As soon as he saw Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma in his presence, he and all his family members stood up from their seats and bowed down at the lotus feet of the Lord. Bali Mahäräja offered Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma the best seat he had in his possession, and when both Lords were seated comfortably, he began to wash Their lotus feet. He then sprinkled the water on his head and on the heads of his family members. The water used to wash the lotus feet of Kåñëa and Balaräma can purify even the greatest demigods, such as Lord Brahmä.

After this, Bali Mahäräja brought valuable garments, ornaments, sandalwood pulp, betel nuts, lamps and various nectarean foodstuffs, and along with his family members he worshiped the Lord according to the regulative principles and offered his riches and body unto the lotus feet of the Lord. King Bali was feeling such transcendental pleasure that he repeatedly grabbed the lotus feet of the Lord and kept them on his chest; and sometimes he put them on the top of the head, and in this way he was feeling transcendental bliss. Tears of love and affection began to flow down from his eyes, and all his hairs stood on end. He began to offer prayers to the Lords in a voice which choked up intermittently.

"My Lord Balaräma, You are the original Anantadeva. You are so great that Anantadeva Seña and other transcendental forms have originally emanated from You and Lord Kåñëa. You are the original Personality of Godhead, and Your eternal form is all-blissful and full of complete knowledge. You are the creator of the whole world. You are the original initiator and propounder of the systems of jïäna-yoga and bhakti-yoga. You are the Supreme Brahman, the original Personality of Godhead, I therefore with all respect offer my obeisances unto both of You. My dear Lords, it is very difficult for the living entities to get to see You, yet when You are merciful upon Your devotees it becomes easy for them to see You. As such, only out of Your causeless mercy have You agreed to come here and be visible to us, who are generally influenced by the qualities of ignorance and passion.

"My dear Lord, we belong to the daitya or demon category. The demons or demonic persons—the Gandharvas, the Siddhas, the Vidyädharas, the Cäraëas, the Yakñas, the Räkñasas, the Piçäcas, the ghosts and the hobgoblins—are incapable, by nature, of worshiping You or becoming Your devotees. Instead of becoming Your devotees, they simply become impediments on the path of devotion. But, opposed to them, You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, representing all the Vedas and situated in the mode of uncontaminated goodness. Your position is always transcendental. For this reason, some of us, although born of the modes of passion and ignorance, have taken shelter of Your lotus feet and become devotees. Some of us are actually pure devotees, and some of us have taken shelter of Your lotus feet, desiring to gain something from devotion.

"By Your causeless mercy only we demons are in direct contact with Your personality. This contact is not possible even for the great demigods. No one knows how You act through Your yogamäyä potency. Even demigods cannot calculate the expanse of the activities of Your internal potency, so how is it possible for us to know it? I therefore place my humble prayers before You: please be kind to me, who am fully surrendered unto You, and favor me with Your causeless mercy so that I may simply remember Your lotus feet birth after birth. My only ambition is that I may live alone just like the paramahaàsas who, traveling alone here and there in great peace of mind, depend simply upon Your lotus feet. I also desire that if I have to associate with anyone, they may be only Your pure devotees and no one else, because Your pure devotees are always well-wishers of all living entities.

"My dear Lord, You are the supreme master and director of the whole world. Please, therefore, engage me in Your service and let me thus become freed from all material contaminations. You can purify me in that way because if someone engages himself in the loving service of Your Lordship, he immediately becomes free from all kinds of regulative principles enjoined in the Vedas."

The word paramahaàsa mentioned here means the supreme swan. It is said that the swan can draw milk out from a reservoir of water; it can take only the milk portion and reject the watery portion. Similarly, a person who can draw out the spiritual portion from this material world and who can live alone, depending only on the Supreme Spirit, not on the material world, is called paramahaàsa. When one achieves the paramahaàsa platform, he is no longer under the regulative principles of the Vedic injunctions. A paramahaàsa accepts only the association of pure devotees and rejects others who are too materially addicted. In other words, those who are materially addicted cannot understand the value of the paramahaàsa, but those who are fortunately advanced in spiritual sense take shelter of the paramahaàsa and thus successfully complete the mission of human life.

After Lord Kåñëa heard the prayers of Bali Mahäräja, He spoke as follows: "My dear King of the demons, in the millennium of the Sväyambhuva Manu, the Prajäpati known as Maréci begot six sons, all demigods, in the womb of his wife, Ürëä. Once upon a time, Lord Brahmä became captivated by the beauty of his daughter and was following her, impelled by sex desire. At that time, these six demigods looked at the action of Lord Brahmä with abhorrence. This criticism of Brahmä's action by the demigods constituted a great offense on their part, and for this reason they were condemned to take birth as the sons of the demon Hiraëyakaçipu. These sons of Hiraëyakaçipu were thereafter put in the womb of mother Devaké, and as soon as they took their birth, Kaàsa killed them one after another. My dear King of the demons, again, mother Devaké is very anxious to see these six dead sons again, and she is very much aggrieved on account of their early death at the hand of Kaàsa. I know that all of them are living with you. I have decided to take them with Me in order to pacify My mother Devaké. After seeing My mother, all these six conditioned souls will be liberated, and thus in great pleasure they will be transferred to their original planet. The names of these six conditioned souls are as follows: Smara, Udgétha, Pariñvaìga, Pataìga, Kñudrabhåt and Ghåëé. They will be again reinstated in their former position as demigods."

After thus informing the King of the demons, Kåñëa stopped speaking, and Bali Mahäräja understood the Lord's purpose. He worshiped Him sufficiently, and thereafter Lord Kåñëa and Lord Balaräma took away the six conditioned souls and returned to the city of Dvärakä, where He presented them as little babies before His mother, Devaké. Mother Devaké became overwhelmed with joy and was so ecstatic in motherly feeling that immediately milk began to flow from her breasts, and she fed the babies with great satisfaction. She began to take them on her lap again and again, smelling their heads and thinking, "He has gotten my lost children back!" For the time being she became overpowered by the energy of Viñëu, and in great motherly affection she began to enjoy the company of her lost children.

The milk from the breast of Devaké was transcendental nectar because the same milk had been sucked by Lord Kåñëa. As such, the babies who sucked the breast of Devakéjé, which had touched the body of Lord Kåñëa, immediately became self-realized persons. The babies therefore began to offer their obeisances unto Lord Kåñëa, Balaräma, their father Vasudeva, and mother Devaké. After this, they were immediately transferred to their respective heavenly planets.

After they departed, Devaké became stunned with wonder that her dead children had come back and had again been transferred to their respective planets. She could adjust the events only by thinking of Lord Kåñëa's pastimes, in which, because Lord Kåñëa's potencies are all inconceivable, anything wonderful can be performed. Without accepting the inconceivable, unlimited potencies of the Lord, one cannot understand that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Soul. By His unlimited potencies, He performs unlimited pastimes also, and no one can describe them in full nor can anyone know them all. Süta Gosvämé, speaking Çrémad-Bhägavatam before the sages of Naimiñäraëya, headed by Çaunaka Åñi, gave his verdict in this connection as follows.

"Great sages, please understand that the transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa are all eternal. They are not ordinary narrations of historical incidences. Such narrations are identical with the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself. Anyone, therefore, who hears such narrations of the Lord's pastimes becomes immediately freed from the contamination of material existence. And those who are pure devotees enjoy these narrations as nectar entering into their ears." Such narrations were described by Çukadeva Gosvämé, the exalted son of Vyäsadeva, and anyone who hears them, as well as anyone who describes them for the hearing of others, becomes Kåñëa conscious. And it is only the Kåñëa conscious persons who become eligible for going back home, back to Godhead.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Thirtieth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Spiritual Instruction for Vasudeva and Return of the Six Dead Sons of Devaké by Lord Kåñëa."

KB 1970-2-31 / The Kidnapping of Subhadrä and Lord Kåñëa's Visiting Çrutadeva and Bahuläçva

31 /The Kidnapping of Subhadrä and Lord Kåñëa's Visiting Çrutadeva and Bahuläçva

After hearing this incident, King Parékñit became more inquisitive to hear about Kåñëa and His pastimes, and thus he inquired from Çukadeva Gosvämé how his grandmother Subhadrä was kidnapped by his grandfather Arjuna at the instigation of Lord Kåñëa. King Parékñit was very much eager to learn about his grandfather's kidnapping and marriage of his grandmother.

Thus Çukadeva Gosvämé began to narrate the story as follows: "Once upon a time, your grandfather Arjuna, the great hero, was visiting several holy places of pilgrimage, and while he was thus traveling all over he happened to come to the Prabhäsakñetra. In the Prabhäsakñetra he heard the news that Lord Balaräma was negotiating the marriage of Subhadrä, the daughter of Arjuna's maternal uncle, Vasudeva. Although her father, Vasudeva, and her brother, Kåñëa, were not in agreement with Him, Balaräma was in favor of marrying Subhadrä to Duryodhana. Arjuna, however, desired to gain the hand of Subhadrä."

As he thought of Subhadrä and her beauty, Arjuna became more and more captivated with the idea of marrying her, and with a plan in mind he dressed himself like a Vaiñëava sannyäsé, carrying a tridaëòa in his hand. The Mäyävädé sannyäsés take one daëòa, or one rod, whereas the Vaiñëava sannyäsés take three daëòa, or three rods. The three rods, or tridaëòa, indicate that a Vaiñëava sannyäsé vows to render service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead by his body, mind and words. The system of tridaëòa-sannyäsa has been in existence for a long time, and the Vaiñëava sannyäsés are called tridaëòés, or sometimes tridaëòi-svämés or tridaëòi-gosvämés.

Sannyäsés are generally meant to travel all over the country for preaching work, but during the four months of the rainy season in India, from September through December, they do not travel, but take shelter in one place and remain there without moving. This non-movement of the sannyäsé is called Cäturmäsya-vrata. When a sannyäsé stays in a place for four months, the local inhabitants of that place take advantage of his presence to become spiritually advanced.

Arjuna, in the dress of a tridaëòi-sannyäsé, remained in the city of Dvärakä for four months, devising a plan whereby he could get Subhadrä as his wife. The inhabitants of Dvärakä as well as Lord Balaräma could not recognize the sannyäsé to be Arjuna; therefore all of them offered their respect and obeisances to the sannyäsé without knowing the actual situation.

One day Lord Balaräma invited this particular sannyäsé to lunch at His home. Balarämajé very respectfully offered him all kinds of palatable dishes, and the so-called sannyäsé was eating sumptuously. While eating at the home of Balarämajé, Arjuna was simply looking over beautiful Subhadrä, who was very enchanting even to the great heroes and kings. Out of love for her, Arjuna's eyes brightened, and he began to see her with glittering eyes. Arjuna decided that somehow or other he would achieve Subhadrä as his wife, and his mind became agitated on account of this strong desire.

Arjuna, the grandfather of Mahäräja Parékñit, was himself extraordinarily beautiful, and his bodily structure was very much attractive to Subhadrä. Subhadrä also decided within her mind that she would accept only Arjuna as her husband. As a simple girl, she was smiling with great pleasure, looking at Arjuna. Thus Arjuna also became more and more attracted by her. In this way, Subhadrä dedicated herself to Arjuna, and he resolved to marry her by any means. He then became absorbed twenty-four hours a day in the thought of how he could get Subhadrä as his wife. He was afflicted with the thought of getting Subhadrä, and had not a moment's peace of mind.

Once upon a time, Subhadrä, seated on a chariot, came out of the palace fort to see the gods in the temple. Arjuna took this opportunity, and with the permission of Vasudeva and Devaké, he kidnapped her. After getting on Subhadrä's chariot, he prepared himself for a fight. Taking up his bow and holding off with his arrows the soldiers ordered to check him, Arjuna took Subhadrä away. While Subhadrä was being thus kidnapped by Arjuna, her relatives and family members began to cry, but still he took her, just as a lion takes his share and departs. When it was disclosed to Lord Balaräma that the so-called sannyäsé was Arjuna and that he had planned such a device simply to take away Subhadrä and that he had actually taken her, He became very angry. Just as the waves of the ocean become agitated on a full moon day, Lord Balaräma became greatly disturbed.

Lord Kåñëa was in favor of Arjuna; therefore, along with other members of the family, He tried to pacify Balaräma by falling at His feet and begging Him to pardon Arjuna. Lord Balaräma was then convinced that Subhadrä was attached to Arjuna, and He became pleased to know that she wanted Arjuna as her husband. The matter was settled, and in order to please the newly married couple, Lord Balaräma arranged to send a dowry, consisting of an abundance of riches, elephants, chariots, horses, servants and maidservants.

Mahäräja Parékñit was very anxious to hear more about Kåñëa, and so, after finishing the narration of Arjuna's kidnapping Subhadrä, Çukadeva Gosvämé began to narrate another story, as follows.

There was a householder brähmaëa in the city of Mithilä, the capital of the kingdom of Videha. This brähmaëa, whose name was Çrutadeva, was a great devotee of Lord Kåñëa. Due to his being fully Kåñëa conscious and always engaged in the service of the Lord, he was completely peaceful in mind and detached from all material attraction. He was very learned and had no other desire than to be fully situated in Kåñëa consciousness. Although in the order of householder life, he never took great pains to earn anything for his livelihood; he was satisfied with whatever he could achieve without much endeavor, and somehow or other he lived in that way. Every day he would get necessities for life in just the quantity required, and not more. That was his destiny. The brähmaëa had no desire to get more than what he needed, and thus he was peacefully executing the regulative principles of a brähmaëa's life, as enjoined in the revealed scriptures.

Fortunately, the King of Mithilä was as good a devotee as the brähmaëa. The name of this famous King was Bahuläçva. He was very well established in his reputation as a good king, and he was not at all ambitious to extend his kingdom for the sake of sense gratification. As such, both the brähmaëa and King Bahuläçva remained pure devotees of Lord Kåñëa in Mithilä.

Since Lord Kåñëa was very merciful upon these two devotees, King Bahuläçva and the brähmaëa, Çrutadeva, He one day asked His driver, Däruka, to take His chariot into the capital city of Mithilä. Lord Kåñëa was accompanied by the great sages Närada, Vämadeva, Atri, Vyäsadeva, Paraçuräma, Asita, Aruëi, Båhaspati, Kaëva, Maitreya, Cyavana and others. Lord Kåñëa and the sages were passing through many villages and towns, and everywhere the citizens would receive them with great respect and offer them articles in worship. When the citizens came to see the Lord and all of them assembled together in one place, it seemed that the sun was present along with his various satellite planets. In that journey, Lord Kåñëa and the sages passed through the kingdoms of Änarta, Dhanva, Kurujäìgala, Kaìka, Matsya, Päïcäla, Kunti, Madhu, Kekaya, Koçala and Arëa, and thus all the citizens of these places, both men and women, could see Lord Kåñëa eye to eye. In this way they enjoyed celestial happiness, with open hearts full of love and affection for the Lord, and when they saw the face of the Lord, it seemed to them that they were drinking nectar through their eyes. When they saw Kåñëa, all the ignorant misconceptions of their lives dissipated. When the Lord passed through the various countries and the people came to visit Him, simply by glancing over them the Lord would bestow all good fortune upon them and liberate them from all kinds of ignorance. In some places, the demigods also would join with the human beings, and their glorification of the Lord would cleanse all directions of all inauspicious things. In this way, Lord Kåñëa slowly and gradually reached the kingdom of Videha.

When the news of the Lord's arrival was received by the citizens, they all felt unlimited happiness and came to welcome Him, taking gifts in their hands to offer. As soon as they saw Lord Kåñëa, their hearts immediately blossomed in transcendental bliss, just as a lotus flower blooms on the rising of the sun. Previously they had simply heard the names of the great sages, but had never seen them. Now, by the mercy of Lord Kåñëa, they had the opportunity of seeing both the great sages and the Lord Himself.

King Bahuläçva, as well as the brähmaëa, Çrutadeva, knowing well that the Lord had come there just to grace them with favor, immediately fell at the Lord's lotus feet and offered their respects. With folded hands, the King and the brähmaëa each simultaneously invited Lord Kåñëa and all the sages to his home. In order to please both of them, Lord Kåñëa expanded Himself into two and went to the houses of each one of them; yet neither the King nor the brähmaëa could understand that the Lord had gone to the house of the other. Both thought that the Lord had gone only to his own house. That He and His companions were present in both houses, although both the brähmaëa and the King thought He was present in his house only, is another opulence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This opulence is described in the revealed scriptures as vaibhava-prakäça. Similarly, when Lord Kåñëa married sixteen thousand wives, He also expanded Himself into sixteen thousand forms, each one of them as powerful as He Himself. Similarly, in Våndävana, when Brahmä stole away Kåñëa's cows, calves and cowherd boys, Kåñëa expanded Himself into many new cows, calves and cowherd boys.

Bahuläçva, the King of Videha, was very intelligent and was a perfect gentleman. He was astonished that so many great sages, along with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, were personally present in his home. He knew perfectly well that the conditioned soul, especially when engaged in worldly affairs, cannot be a hundred percent pure, whereas the Supreme Personality of Godhead and His pure devotees are always transcendental to worldly contamination. Therefore, when he found that the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa and all the great sages were at his home, he was astonished, and he began to thank Lord Kåñëa for His causeless mercy.

Feeling very much obliged and wanting to receive his guests to the best of his capacity, he called for nice chairs and cushions, and Lord Kåñëa, along with all the sages, sat down very comfortably. At that time, King Bahuläçva's mind was very restless, not because of any problems, but because of great ecstasy of love and devotion. His heart was filled with love and affection for the Lord and His associates, and his eyes were filled with tears of ecstasy. He arranged to wash the feet of his divine guests, and after washing them he and his family members sprinkled the water on their own heads. After this, he offered to the guests nice flower garlands, sandalwood pulp, incense, new garments, ornaments, lamps, cows and bulls. In a manner just befitting his royal position, he worshiped each one of them in this way. When all had been fed sumptuously and were sitting very comfortably, Bahuläçva came before Lord Kåñëa and caught His lotus feet. He placed them on his lap and, while massaging the feet with his hands, began to speak about the glories of the Lord in a sweet voice.

"My dear Lord, You are the Supersoul of all living entities and as witness within the heart are cognizent of everyone's activities. As such, being duty-bound, we always think of Your lotus feet so that we can remain in a secure position without deviating from Your eternal service. As a result of our continuous remembrance of Your lotus feet, You have kindly visited my place personally to favor me with Your causeless mercy. We have heard, my dear Lord, that by Your various statements You confirm Your pure devotees to be more dear to You than Lord Balaräma or Your constant servitor the goddess of fortune. Your devotees are dearer to You than Your first son, Lord Brahmä, and I am sure that You have so kindly visited my place in order to prove Your divine statement. I cannot imagine how people can be godless and demoniac even after knowing of Your causeless mercy and affection for Your devotees who are constantly engaged in Kåñëa consciousness. How can they forget Your lotus feet?

"My dear Lord, it is known to us that You are so kind and liberal that when a person leaves everything just to engage in Kåñëa consciousness, You sometimes give Yourself in exchange for that unalloyed service. You have appeared in the Yadu dynasty to fulfill Your mission of reclaiming all conditioned souls rotting in the sinful activities of material existence, and this appearance is already famous all over the world. My dear Lord, You are the ocean of unlimited mercy, love and affection. Your transcendental form is full of bliss, knowledge and eternity. You can attract everyone's heart by Your beautiful form as Çyämasundara, Kåñëa. Your knowledge is unlimited, and to teach all people how to execute devotional service You have sent Your incarnation Nara-Näräyaëa, who is engaged in severe austerities and penances at Badarénäräyaëa. Kindly, therefore, accept my humble obeisances at Your lotus feet. My dear Lord, I beg to request You and Your companions, the great sages and brähmaëas, to remain at my place so that this family of the famous King Nimi may be sanctified by the dust of Your lotus feet at least for a few days." Lord Kåñëa could not refuse the request of His devotee, and thus He remained there for a few days along with the sages in order to sanctify the city of Mithilä and all its citizens.

Meanwhile, the brähmaëa, simultaneously receiving Lord Kåñëa and His associates at his home, became transcendentally overwhelmed with joy. After offering his guests nice sitting places, the brähmaëa began to dance, throwing his wrap around his body. Çrutadeva, being not at all rich, offered only mattresses, wooden planks, straw carpets, etc., to his distinguished guests, Lord Kåñëa and the sages, but he welcomed them to his best capacity. He began to speak very highly of the Lord and the sages, and he and his wife washed the feet of each one of them. After this, he took the water and sprinkled it over all the members of his family, and although it appeared that the brähmaëa was very poor, he was at that time most fortunate. While Çrutadeva was welcoming Lord Kåñëa and His associates, he simply forgot himself in transcendental joy. After welcoming the Lord and His companions, according to his capacity he brought fruits, incense, scented water, scented clay, tulasé leaves, kuça straw and lotus flowers. They were not very costly items and could be secured very easily, but because they were offered with devotional love, Lord Kåñëa and His associates accepted them very gladly. The brähmaëa's wife cooked very simple foods like rice and dahl, and Lord Kåñëa and His followers were very pleased to accept them because they were offered in devotional love. When Lord Kåñëa and His associates were fed in this way, the brähmaëa Çrutadeva was thinking thus: "I am fallen into the deep, dark well of householder life and am the most unfortunate person. How has it become possible that Lord Kåñëa, who is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and His associates, the great sages, whose very presence makes a place as sanctified as a pilgrimage site, have agreed to come to my place?" While the brähmaëa was thinking in this way, the guests finished their lunch and sat back very comfortably. At that time, the brähmaëa, Çrutadeva, and his wife, children and other relatives, appeared there to render service to the distinguished guests. While touching the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa, the brähmaëa began to speak.

"My dear Lord," he said, "You are the Supreme Person, Puruñottama, situated transcendentally to the manifested and unmanifested material creation. The activities of this material world and of the conditioned souls have nothing to do with Your position. We can appreciate that it is not that only today You have given me Your audience. You are associating with all the living entities as Paramätmä since the beginning of creation."

This statement of the brähmaëa is very instructive. It is a fact that the Supreme Lord Personality of Godhead in His Paramätmä feature entered the creation of this material world as Mahä-Viñëu, Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu and Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu, and in a very friendly attitude the Lord is sitting along with the conditioned soul in the body. Therefore, every living entity has the Lord with him from the very beginning, but due to his mistaken consciousness of life, the living entity cannot understand this. When his consciousness is, however, changed into Kåñëa consciousness, he can immediately understand how Kåñëa is trying to assist the conditioned souls to get out of the material entanglement.

Çrutadeva continued, "My dear Lord, You have entered this material world as if in a sleeping condition. A conditioned soul, while sleeping, creates false or temporary worlds; he becomes busy in many illusory activities—sometimes becoming a king, sometimes being murdered or sometimes going to an unknown city—and all these are simply temporary affairs. Similarly, Your Lordship, apparently also in a sleeping condition, enters this material world to create a temporary manifestation, not for Your personal necessities, but for the conditioned soul who wants to imitate Your Lordship as enjoyer. The conditioned soul's enjoyment in the material world is temporary and illusory. And yet the conditioned soul is by himself unable to create such a temporary situation for his illusory enjoyment. In order to fulfill his desires, although they are temporary and illusory, You enter in this temporary manifestation to help him. Thus, from the beginning of the conditioned soul's entering into the material world, You are his constant companion. When, therefore, the conditioned soul comes in contact with a pure devotee and takes to devotional service, beginning from the process of hearing Your transcendental pastimes, glorifying Your transcendental activities, worshiping Your eternal form in the temple, offering prayers to You and engaging in discussion to understand Your transcendental position, he then gradually becomes freed from the contamination of material existence. His heart becomes cleansed of all material dust, and thus gradually You become visible in the heart of the devotee. Although You are constantly with the conditioned soul, only when he becomes purified by devotional service do You become revealed to him. Others, who are bewildered by fruitive activities, either by Vedic injunction or customary dealings, and who do not take to devotional service, become captivated by the external happiness of the bodily concept of life. You are not revealed to such persons. Rather, You remain far, far away from them. But for one who, being engaged in Your devotional service, has purified his heart by constant chanting of Your holy name, You become very easily understood as his eternal constant companion.

"It is said that Your Lordship, sitting in the heart of a devotee, gives him direction by which he can very quickly come back to home, back to You. This direct dictation by You reveals Your existence within the heart of the devotee. Only a devotee can immediately appreciate Your existence within his heart, whereas for a person who has only a bodily concept of life and is engaged in sense gratification You always remain covered by the curtain of yogamäyä. Such a person cannot realize that You are very near, sitting within his heart. For a nondevotee, You are appreciated only as ultimate death. The difference is like the difference between a cat's carrying its kittens in its mouth and a cat's carrying a rat in its mouth. In the mouth of the cat, the rat feels its death, whereas the kittens in the mouth of the cat feel motherly affection. Similarly, You are present to everyone, but the nondevotee feels You as ultimate cruel death, whereas for a devotee You are the supreme instructor and philosopher. The atheist, therefore, understands the presence of God as death, but the devotee understands the presence of God always within his heart, takes dictation from You, and lives transcendentally, not being affected by the contamination of the material world.

"You are the supreme controller and superintendent of the material nature's activities. The atheistic class of men simply observe the activities of material nature, but cannot find You as the original background. A devotee, however, can immediately see Your hand in every movement of material nature. The curtain of yogamäyä cannot cover the eyes of the devotee of Your Lordship, but it can cover the eyes of the nondevotee. The nondevotee is unable to see You eye to eye, just as a person whose eyes are interrupted by the covering of a cloud cannot see the sun, although persons who are flying above the cloud can see the sunshine brilliantly, as it is. My dear Lord, I offer my respectful obeisances unto You. My dear self-effulgent Lord, I am Your eternal servitor. Therefore, kindly order me—what can I do for You? The conditioned soul feels the pangs of material contamination as threefold miseries as long as You are not visible to him. And as soon as You are visible by development of Kåñëa consciousness, all miseries of material existence simultaneously become vanquished."

The Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa is naturally very much affectionately inclined to His devotees. When He heard Çrutadeva's prayers of pure devotion, He was very much pleased and immediately caught his hands and began to address Him thus: "My dear Çrutadeva, all these great sages and saintly persons have been very kind to you by personally coming here to see you. You should consider this opportunity to be a great fortune for you. They are so kind that they are traveling with Me, and wherever they go they immediately make the whole atmosphere as pure as transcendence simply by the touch of the dust of their feet. People are accustomed to go to the temples of God. They also visit holy places of pilgrimage, and after prolonged association with such activities, for many days by touch and by worship, gradually they become purified. But the influence of great sages and saintly persons is so great that by seeing them one immediately becomes completely purified.

"Moreover, the very purifying potency of pilgrimages or worship of different demigods is also achieved by the grace of saintly persons. A pilgrimage site becomes a holy place because of the presence of the saintly persons there. My dear Çrutadeva, when a person is born as a brähmaëa, he immediately becomes the best of all human beings. And if such a brähmaëa, remaining self-satisfied, practices austerities, studies the Vedas and engages in My devotional service, as is the duty of the brähmaëa—or in other words, if a brähmaëa becomes a Vaiñëava—how wonderful is his greatness! My feature of four-handed Näräyaëa is not so pleasing or dear to Me as is a brähmaëa Vaiñëava. Brähmaëa means 'one well conversant with Vedic knowledge'; a brähmaëa is the insignia of perfect knowledge, and I am the full-fledged manifestation of all gods. The less intelligent class of men do not understand Me as the highest knowledge, nor do they understand the influence of the brähmaëa Vaiñëava. They are influenced by the three modes of material nature and thus dare to criticize Me and My pure devotees. A brähmaëa Vaiñëava, or a devotee already on the brahminical platform, can realize Me within his heart, and therefore he definitely concludes that the whole cosmic manifestation and its different features are effects of different energies of the Lord. Thus he has a clear conception of the whole material nature and the total material energy, and in every action such a devotee sees Me only, and nothing else.

"My dear Çrutadeva, you may therefore accept all these great saintly persons, brähmaëas and sages as My bona fide representatives. By worshiping them faithfully, you will be worshiping Me more diligently. I consider worship of My devotees to be better than direct worship of Me. If someone attempts to worship Me directly without worshiping My devotees, I do not accept such worship, even though it may be presented with great opulence."

In this way both the brähmaëa, Çrutadeva, and the King of Mithilä, under the direction of the Lord, worshiped both Kåñëa and His followers, the great sages and saintly brähmaëas, on an equal level of spiritual importance. Both brähmaëa and King ultimately achieved the supreme goal of being transferred to the spiritual world. The devotee does not know anyone except Lord Kåñëa, and Kåñëa is most affectionate to His devotee. Lord Kåñëa remained in Mithilä both at the house of the brähmaëa Çrutadeva and at the palace of King Bahuläçva. And after favoring them lavishly by His transcendental instructions, He went back to His capital city, Dvärakä.

The instruction we receive from this incident is that King Bahuläçva and Çrutadeva the brähmaëa were accepted by the Lord on the same level because both were pure devotees. This is the real qualification for being recognized by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Because it has become the fashion of this age to become falsely proud of having taken birth in the family of a kñatriya or of a brähmaëa, we see persons without any qualification other than birth claiming to be brähmaëa or kñatriya or vaiçya. But as it is stated in the scriptures, kalau çüdra-sambhava: "In this age of Kali, everyone is a çüdra." This is because there is no performance of the purificatory processes known as saàskäras, which begin from the time of the mother's pregnancy and continue up to the point of the individual's death. No one can be classified as a member of a particular caste, especially of a higher caste—brähmaëa, kñatriya or vaiçya—simply by birthright. If one is not purified by the process of the seed-giving ceremony, or Garbhädhäna-saàskära, he is immediately classified amongst the çüdras, because only the çüdras do not undergo this purificatory process. Sex life without the purificatory process of Kåñëa consciousness is merely the seed-giving process of the çüdras or the animals. But Kåñëa consciousness is the highest perfection, by which everyone can come to the platform of a Vaiñëava. This includes having all the qualifications of a brähmaëa. The Vaiñëavas are trained to become freed from the four kinds of sinful activities—illicit sex, indulgence in intoxicants, gambling, and eating animal foodstuffs. No one can be on the brahminical platform without having these preliminary qualifications, and without becoming a qualified brähmaëa, one cannot become a pure devotee.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Thirty-First Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Kidnapping of Subhadrä and Lord Kåñëa's Visiting Çrutadeva and Bahuläçva."

KB 1970-2-32 / Prayers by the Personified Vedas

32 /Prayers by the Personified Vedas

King Parékñit inquired from Çukadeva Gosvämé about a very important topic in understanding transcendental subject matter. His question was, "Since Vedic knowledge generally deals with the subject matter of the three qualities of the material world, how then can it approach the subject matter of transcendence, which is beyond the approach of the three material modes? Since the mind is material and the vibration of words is a material sound, how can the Vedic knowledge, expressing by material sound the thoughts of the mind, approach transcendence? Description of a subject matter necessitates describing its source of emanation, its qualities and its activities. Such description can be possible only by thinking with the material mind and by vibrating material words. Although Brahman, or the Absolute Truth, has no material qualities, our power of speaking does not go beyond the material qualities. How then can Brahman, the Absolute Truth, be described by your words? I do not see how it is possible to understand transcendence from such expressions of material sound."

The purpose of King Parékñit's inquiring was to ascertain from Çukadeva Gosvämé whether the Vedas ultimately describe the Absolute Truth as impersonal or as personal. Understanding of the Absolute Truth progresses in three features—impersonal Brahman, Paramätmä localized in everyone's heart and, at last, the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa.

The Vedas deal with three departments of activities. One is called karma-käëòa, or activities under Vedic injunction which gradually purify one to understand his real position; the next is jïäna-käëòa, the process of understanding the Absolute Truth by speculative methods; and the third is upäsanä-käëòa, or worship of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and sometimes of the demigods also. The worship of the demigods recommended in the Vedas is ordered with the understanding of the demigods' relationship to the Personality of Godhead. The Supreme Personality of Godhead has many parts and parcels; some are called sväàças, or His personal expansions, and some are called vibhinnäàças, the living entities. All such expansions, both sväàças and vibhinnäàças, are emanations from the original Personality of Godhead. Sväàça expansions are called Viñëu-tattva, whereas the vibhinnäàça expansions are called jéva-tattva. The different demigods are jéva-tattva. The conditioned souls are generally put into the activities of the material world for sense gratification; therefore, as stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20], to regulate those who are very much addicted to different kinds of sense gratification the worship of demigods is sometimes recommended. For example, for persons who are very much addicted to meat-eating, the Vedic injunction recommends that after worshiping the form of the goddess Kälé and sacrificing a goat (not any other animal) under karma-käëòa regulation, the worshipers may be allowed to eat meat. The idea is not to encourage one to eat meat, but to allow one who is persistent to eat meat under certain restricted conditions. Therefore, worship of the demigods is not worship of the Absolute Truth, but by worshiping the demigods one gradually comes to accept the Supreme Personality of Godhead in an indirect way. This indirect acceptance is described in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.23] as avidhi. Avidhi means not bona fide. Since demigod worship is not bona fide, the impersonalists stress concentration on the impersonal feature of the Absolute Truth. King Parékñit's question was, which is the ultimate target of Vedic knowledge—this concentration on the impersonal feature of the Absolute Truth or concentration on the personal feature? After all, both the impersonal and personal features of the Supreme Lord are beyond our material conception. The impersonal feature of the Absolute, the Brahman effulgence, is but the rays of the personal body of Kåñëa. These rays of the personal body of Kåñëa are cast all over the creation of the Lord, and the portion of the effulgence which is covered by the material cloud is called the created cosmos of the three material qualities—sattva, rajas and tamas. How can persons who are within this clouded portion called the material world conceive of the Absolute Truth by the speculative method?

In answering King Parékñit's question, Çukadeva Gosvämé replied that the Supreme Personality of Godhead has created the mind, senses and living force for the purpose of sense gratification in transmigration from one kind of body to another, as well as for the purpose of allowing liberation from the material conditions. In other words, the senses, mind and living force can be utilized for sense gratification and transmigration from one body to another or for the matter of liberation. The Vedic injunctions are there just to give the conditioned souls the chance for sense gratification under regulative principles, and thereby also give them the chance for promotion to the higher conditions of life; ultimately, if the consciousness is purified, one comes to his original position and goes back home, back to Godhead.

The living force is intelligent. One therefore has to utilize his intelligence over the mind and the senses. When the mind and senses are purified by the proper use of intelligence, then the conditioned soul is liberated; otherwise, if the intelligence is not properly utilized in controlling the senses and mind, the conditioned soul continues to transmigrate from one kind of body to another simply for sense gratification. Another point clearly stated in the answer of Çukadeva Gosvämé is that the Lord created the mind, senses and intelligence of the individual living force. It is not stated that the living entities themselves were ever created. Just as the shining particles of the sun's rays are always existing along with the sun, the living entities exist eternally as parts and parcels of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The conditioned souls, although eternally existing as part of the Supreme Lord, are sometimes put within the cloud of the material concept of life, in the darkness of ignorance. The whole Vedic process is to alleviate that darkened condition. Ultimately, when the senses and mind of the conditioned being become fully purified, he then comes to the original position, called Kåñëa consciousness, and that is liberation.

In the Vedänta-sütra, the first sütra, or code, questions about the Absolute Truth. Athäto brahma-jijïäsä: What is the nature of the Absolute Truth? The next sütra answers that the nature of the Absolute Truth is that He is the origin of everything. Whatever we experience, even in this material condition of life, is but an emanation from Him. The Absolute Truth created the mind and senses and intelligence. This means that the Absolute Truth is not without mind, intelligence and senses. In other words, He is not impersonal. The very word "created" means that He has transcendental intelligence. For example, when the father begets a child, the child has senses because the father also has senses. The child is born with hands and legs because the father also has hands and legs. Sometimes it is said, therefore, that man is made after the image of God. The Absolute Truth is therefore the Supreme Personality, with transcendental mind, senses and intelligence. When one's mind, intelligence and senses are purified of material contamination, one can understand the original feature of the Absolute Truth as a person.

The Vedic process is to gradually promote the conditioned soul from the mode of ignorance to the mode of passion and from the mode of passion to the mode of goodness. In the mode of goodness there is sufficient light for understanding things as they are. For example, from earth a tree grows, and from the wood of the tree, fire is ignited. In that igniting process we first of all find the smoke, and the next stage is heat, and then fire. When there is actually fire, we can utilize it for various purposes; therefore, fire is the ultimate goal. Similarly, in the gross material stage of life the quality of ignorance is very much prominent. Dissipation of this ignorance takes place in the gradual progress of civilization from the barbarian stage to civilized life, and when one comes to the form of civilized life, he is said to be in the mode of passion. In the barbarian stage, or in the mode of ignorance, the senses are gratified in a very crude way, whereas in the mode of passion or in the civilized stage of life, the senses are gratified in a polished manner. But when one is promoted to the mode of goodness, one can understand that the senses and the mind are only engaged in material activities due to being covered by perverted consciousness. When this perverted consciousness is gradually transformed into Kåñëa consciousness, then the path of liberation is opened. So it is not that one is unable to approach the Absolute Truth by the senses and the mind. The conclusion is, rather, that the senses, mind and intelligence in the gross stage of contamination cannot appreciate the nature of the Absolute Truth, but, when purified, the senses, mind and intelligence can understand what the Absolute Truth is. This purifying process is called devotional service, or Kåñëa consciousness.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [15.15] it is clearly stated that the purpose of Vedic knowledge is to understand Kåñëa, and Kåñëa is understood by devotional service, beginning with the process of surrender. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [8.7], one has to think of Kåñëa always. One has to render loving service to Kåñëa always, and one has to always worship and bow down before Kåñëa. By this process only can one enter into the kingdom of God without any doubt.

When one is enlightened in the mode of goodness by the process of devotional service, he is freed from the modes of ignorance and passion. The word ätmane [10.87.2] indicates the stage of brahminical qualification in which one is allowed to study the Vedic literatures known as the Upaniñads. The Upaniñads describe in different ways the transcendental qualities of the Supreme Lord. The Absolute Truth, the Supreme Lord, is called nirguëa. That does not mean that He has no qualities. It is only because He has qualities that the conditioned living entities can have qualities. The purpose of studying the Upaniñads is to understand the transcendental quality of the Absolute Truth, as opposed to the material qualities of ignorance, passion and goodness. That is the way of Vedic understanding. Great sages like the four Kumäras, headed by Sanaka, followed these principles of Vedic knowledge and came gradually from impersonal understanding to the platform of personal worship of the Supreme Lord. It is therefore recommended that we must follow the great personalities. Çukadeva Gosvämé is also one of the great personalities, and his answer to the inquiry of Mahäräja Parékñit is authorized. One who follows in the footsteps of such great personalities surely walks very easily on the path of liberation and ultimately goes back to home, back to Godhead. That is the way of perfecting this human form of life.

Çukadeva Gosvämé continued to speak to Parékñit Mahäräja. "My dear King," he said, "I will narrate in this regard a nice story. This story is important because it is in connection with Näräyaëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This narration is a conversation between Näräyaëa Åñi and the great sage Närada. Näräyaëa Åñi still resides in Badarikäçrama in the Himalayan hills and is accepted as an incarnation of Näräyaëa. Once when Närada, the great devotee and ascetic amongst the demigods, was traveling in different planets, he desired to personally meet the ascetic Näräyaëa in Badarékäçrama and offer him his respects. This great sage incarnation of Godhead, Näräyaëa Åñi, has been undergoing great penances and austerities from the very beginning of the creation in order to teach the inhabitants of Bhäratavarña how to attain the highest perfectional stage of going back to Godhead. His austerities and penances are exemplary practices for the human being."

Badarékäçrama is situated in the northernmost part of the Himalayan Mountains and is always covered with snow. Religious Indians still go to visit this place during the summer season, when the snowfall is not very severe. Once, the incarnation of God Näräyaëa Åñi was sitting amongst many devotees in the village known as Kaläpagräma. Of course, these were not ordinary sages who were sitting with him, and the great sage Närada also appeared there. After offering his respects to Näräyaëa Åñi, Närada asked him exactly the same question asked by King Parékñit of Çukadeva Gosvämé. When Närada asked his question of Näräyaëa Åñi, the Åñi also answered by following in the footsteps of his predecessors. He narrated a story of how the same question had been discussed on the planet known as Janaloka. Janaloka is above the Svargaloka planets, such as the moon, Venus, etc. In this planet, great sages and saintly persons live, and they were also discussing the same point regarding the understanding of Brahman and His real identity.

The great sage Näräyaëa began to speak. "My dear Närada," he said, "I will tell you a story which took place long, long ago. There was a great meeting of the denizens of the heavenly planets, and almost all the important brahmacärés, such as the four Kumäras—Sanat, Sanandana, Sanaka and Sanätana Kumära—attended. Their discussion was on the subject matter of understanding the Absolute Truth, Brahman. You were not present at that meeting because you went to see My expansion Aniruddha, who lives on the island of Çvetadvépa. In this meeting, all the great sages and brahmacärés very elaborately discussed the point about which you have asked me, and it was very interesting. The discussion was so delicate that even the Vedas were unable to answer the intricate questions raised.

Näräyaëa Åñi told Näradajé that the same question which Näradajé had raised had been discussed in that meeting in Janaloka. This is the way of understanding through the paramparä, or disciplic succession. Mahäräja Parékñit was sent to Çukadeva Gosvämé; Çukadeva Gosvämé referred the matter to Närada, who had in the same way questioned Näräyaëa Åñi, who had put the matter to still higher authorities in the planet of Janaloka, where it was discussed among the great Kumäras—Sanat, Sanätana, Sanaka Kumära and Sanandana. These four brahmacärés are recognized scholars in the Vedas and çästras. Their unlimited volumes of knowledge, backed by austerities and penances, are exhibited by their sublime, ideal character. They are very amiable and gentle in behavior, and for them there is no distinction between friends, well-wishers and enemies. Being transcendentally situated, such personalities as the Kumäras are above all material considerations and are always neutral in respect to material dualities. In the discussions held among the four brothers, one of them, namely Sanandana, was selected to speak, and the other brothers became the audience to hear him.

Sanandana said, "After the dissolution of the whole cosmic manifestation, the entire energy and the whole creation in its nucleus form enters into the body of Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu. The Lord at that time remains asleep for a long, long time, and where there is again necessity of creation, the Vedas personified assemble around the Lord and begin to glorify Him, describing His wonderful transcendental pastimes. It is exactly like a king: when he is asleep in the morning, the appointed reciters come around his bedroom and begin to sing of his chivalrous activities, and while hearing of his glorious activities, the king gradually awakens.

"The Vedic reciters or the personified Vedas sing thus: 'O unconquerable, You are the Supreme Personality. No one is equal to You or greater than You. No one can be more glorious in His activities. All glories unto You! All glories unto You! By Your own transcendental nature You fully possess all six opulences. As such, You are able to deliver all conditioned souls from the clutches of mäyä. O Lord, we fervently pray that You kindly do so. All the living entities, being Your parts and parcels, are naturally joyful, eternal and full of knowledge, but due to their own faults they try to imitate You by trying to become the supreme enjoyer; thus they disobey Your supremacy and become offenders. And because of their offenses, Your material energy has taken charge of them; thus, their transcendental qualities of joyfulness, bliss and wisdom have been covered by the clouds of the three material qualities. This cosmic manifestation, made of the three material qualities, is just like a prison house for the conditioned souls. The conditioned souls are struggling very hard to escape from the material bondage, and according to their different conditions of life they have been given different types of engagement. But all engagements are based on Your knowledge. Pious activities can be executed only when inspired by Your mercy. Therefore, without taking shelter at Your lotus feet one cannot surpass the influence of material energy. Actually, we, as personified Vedic knowledge, are always engaged in Your service to help the conditioned soul understand You.' "

This prayer of the Vedas personified illustrates that the Vedas are meant for helping the conditioned souls to understand Kåñëa. All the çrutis or personified Vedas offered glories to the Lord again and again, singing, "Jaya! Jaya!" This indicates that the Lord is praised for His glories. Of all His glories the most important is His causeless mercy upon the conditioned souls in reclaiming them from the clutches of mäyä.

There are unlimited numbers of living entities in different varieties of bodies, some moving and some standing in one place, and the conditioned life of these living entities is due only to their forgetfulness of their eternal relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. When the living entity wants to lord it over the material energy by imitating the position of Kåñëa, he is immediately captured by the material energy and, according to his desire, is offered a variety of 8,400,000 different kinds of bodies. Although undergoing the threefold miseries of material existence, the illusioned living entity falsely thinks himself the master of all he surveys. Under the spell of the material energy, which represents the threefold material qualities, the living entity is so entangled that it is not at all possible for him to become free unless he is graced by the Supreme Lord. The living entity cannot conquer the influence of the material modes of nature by his own endeavor, but because material nature is working under the control of the Supreme Lord, the Lord is beyond its jurisdiction. Except for Him, all living entities, beginning from Brahmä down to an ant, are conquered by the contact of material nature.

Because He possesses in full the six opulences of wealth, strength, fame, beauty, knowledge and renunciation, the Lord alone is beyond the spell of material nature. Unless the living entity is situated in Kåñëa consciousness, he cannot approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead, yet the Lord, by His omnipotency, can dictate from within as the Supersoul. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.27], the Lord advises, "Whatever you do, do for Me; whatever you eat, first of all offer to Me; whatever charity you want to give, first give to Me; and whatever austerities and penances you want to perform, perform for Me." In this way the karmés are directed to gradually develop Kåñëa consciousness. Similarly, Kåñëa directs the philosophers to approach Him gradually by discriminating between Brahman and mäyä. At last when one is mature in knowledge, he surrenders unto Kåñëa. As Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä [7.19], "After many, many births, the wise philosopher surrenders unto Me." The yogés are also directed to concentrate their meditation upon Kåñëa within the heart, and by such continued process of Kåñëa consciousness the yogé can become free from the clutches of material energy. But, as is stated in Bhagavad-gétä [10.10], because the devotees are engaged in devotional service with love and affection from the very beginning, the Lord directs them so that they can approach Him without difficulty or deviation. Only by the grace of the Lord can the living entity understand the exact position of Brahman, Paramätmä and Bhagavän.

The statements of the personified Vedas give clear evidence that the Vedic literature is presented only for understanding Kåñëa. It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.15] that through all the Vedas it is Kåñëa alone who has to be understood. Kåñëa is always enjoying, either in the material world or in the spiritual world; because He is the supreme enjoyer, for Him there is no distinction between the material world and spiritual worlds. The material world is an impediment for the ordinary living entities because they are under its control, but Kåñëa, being the controller of the material world, has nothing to do with the impediments it offers. Therefore, in different parts of the Upaniñads, the Vedas declare: "Brahman is eternal, full of all knowledge and all bliss, but the one Supreme Personality of Godhead is existing in the heart of every living entity." Because of His all-pervasiveness, He is able to enter not only into the hearts of the living entities, but even into the atoms also. As the Supersoul, He is the controller of all activities of the living entities. He is living within all of them and witnessing their actions, allowing them to act according to their desires, and also giving them the results of their different activities. He is the living force of all things, but still He is transcendental to the material qualities. He is omnipotent; He is expert in manufacturing everything, and on account of His superior, natural knowledge, He can bring everyone under His control. As such, He is everyone's master. He is sometimes manifest on the surface of the globe, but He is simultaneously within all matter. Desiring to expand Himself in multi-forms, He glanced over the material energy, and thus innumerable living entities became manifest. Everything is created by His superior energy, and everything in His creation appears to be perfectly done without deficiency.

Those who aspire for liberation from this material world must therefore worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the ultimate cause of all causes. He is just like the total mass of earth, from which varieties of earthly pots are manufactured: the pots are made of earthly clay, they rest on the earth, and after being destroyed, their elements ultimately merge back into earth. Although the Personality of Godhead is the original cause of all varieties of manifestation, the impersonalists especially stress the Vedic statement, sarvaà khalv idaà brahma: "Everything is Brahman." The impersonalists do not take into account the varieties of manifestation emanating from the supreme cause of Brahman. They simply take into consideration that everything emanates from Brahman and after destruction merges into Brahman and that the intermediate stage of manifestation is also Brahman. Although the Mäyävädés believe that prior to its manifestation the cosmos was in Brahman, after creation it remains in Brahman and after destruction it merges into Brahman, they do not know what Brahman is. This fact is clearly described in the Brahma-saàhitä: The living entities, space, time, and the material elements like fire, earth, sky, water and mind, constitute the total cosmic manifestation, known as bhür bhuvaù svaù, which is manifested by Govinda. It flourishes on the strength of Govinda and after annihilation enters into and is conserved in Govinda. Lord Brahmä [5.1] therefore says, "I worship Lord Govinda, the original personality, the cause of all causes."

The word Brahman indicates the greatest of all and the maintainer of everything. The impersonalists are attracted by the greatness of the sky, but because of their poor fund of knowledge they are not attracted by the greatness of Kåñëa. In our practical life, however, we are attracted by the greatness of a person and not by the greatness of a big mountain. Actually the term Brahman can be applied to Kåñëa only; therefore in the Bhagavad-gétä [10.12] Arjuna admitted that Lord Kåñëa is the Parambrahman, or the supreme rest of everything.

Kåñëa is the Supreme Brahman because of His unlimited knowledge, unlimited potencies, unlimited strength, unlimited influence, unlimited beauty and unlimited renunciation. Therefore the word Brahman can be applied to Kåñëa only. Arjuna affirms that because the impersonal Brahman is the effulgence emanating as rays of Kåñëa's transcendental body, Kåñëa is the Parambrahman. Everything is resting on Brahman, but Brahman itself is resting on Kåñëa. Therefore Kåñëa is the ultimate Brahman or Parambrahman. The material elements are accepted as inferior energies of Kåñëa because by their interaction the cosmic manifestation takes place, rests on Kåñëa, and after dissolution again enters into the body of Kåñëa as His subtle energy. Kåñëa is therefore the cause of both manifestation and dissolution.

Sarvaà khalv idaà brahma means everything is Kåñëa, and that is the vision of the mahäbhägavatas. They see everything in relation to Kåñëa. The impersonalists argue that Kåñëa has transformed Himself into many and that therefore everything is Kåñëa and worship of everything is worship of Him. This false argument is answered by Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.4]: although everything is a transformation of the energy of Kåñëa, He is not present everywhere. He is simultaneously present and not present. By His energy He is present everywhere, but as the energetic He is not present everywhere. This simultaneous presence and non-presence is inconceivable to our present senses. But a clear explanation is given in the beginning of the Éçopaniñad, in which it is stated that the Supreme Lord is so complete that although unlimited energies and their transformations are emanating from Kåñëa, Kåñëa's personality is not in the least bit transformed. Therefore, since Kåñëa is the cause of all causes, intelligent persons should take shelter of His lotus feet.

Kåñëa advises everyone just to surrender unto Him alone, and that is the way of Vedic instruction. Since Kåñëa is the cause of all causes, He is worshiped by all kinds of sages and saints by observance of the regulative principles. When there is a necessity for meditation, great personalities meditate on the transcendental form of Kåñëa within the heart. In this way the minds of great personalities are always engaged in Kåñëa. With minds engaged in Kåñëa, naturally the captivated devotees simply talk of Kåñëa.

Talking of Kåñëa or singing of Kåñëa is called kértana. Lord Caitanya also recommends kértanéyaù sadä hariù, which means always thinking and talking of Kåñëa and nothing else. That is called Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa consciousness is so sublime that anyone who takes to this process is elevated to the highest perfection of life—far, far beyond the concept of liberation. In the Bhagavad-gétä, therefore, Kåñëa advises everyone to always think of Him, render devotional service to Him, worship Him and offer obeisances to Him. In this way a devotee becomes fully Kåñëa-ized and, being always situated in Kåñëa consciousness, ultimately goes back to Kåñëa.

Although the Vedas have recommended worship of different demigods as different parts and parcels of Kåñëa, it is to be understood that such instructions are meant for the less intelligent class of men, who are still attracted by material sense enjoyment. But the person who actually wants perfect fulfillment of the mission of human life should simply worship Lord Kåñëa, and that will simplify the matter and completely guarantee the success of his human life. Although the sky, the water and the land are all part and parcel of the material world, when one stands on the solid land his position is more secure than when he stands in the sky or the water. An intelligent person, therefore, does not stand under the protection of different demigods, although they are part and parcel of Kåñëa. Rather, he stands on the solid ground of Kåñëa consciousness. That makes his position sound and secure.

Impersonalists sometimes give the example that if one stands on a stone or a piece of wood, one certainly stands on the surface of the land, because the stone and wood are both resting on the surface of the earth. But it may be replied that if one stands directly on the surface of the earth, he is more secure than on the wood or stone which are resting on the earth. In other words, taking shelter of Paramätmä or taking shelter of impersonal Brahman is not as secure a course as taking direct shelter of Kåñëa in Kåñëa consciousness. The position of the jïänés and yogés is therefore not as secure as the position of the devotees of Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa has therefore advised in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20] that only a person who has lost his senses takes to the worship of demigods. And regarding persons who are attached to the impersonal Brahman, the Çrémad-Bhägavatam says, "My dear Lord, those who are thinking of themselves as liberated by mental speculation are not yet purified of the contamination of material nature because of their inability to find the shelter of Your lotus feet. Although they rise to the transcendental situation of existence in impersonal Brahman, they certainly fall from that exalted position because they have neglected to desire Your lotus feet." Lord Kåñëa therefore advises that the worshipers of the demigods are not very intelligent persons because they derive only temporary, exhaustible results. Their endeavors are those of less intelligent men. But the Lord assures that His devotee has no fear of falling.

The personified Vedas continued to pray: "Dear Lord, considering all points of view, if one has to worship someone superior to him, then just out of good behavior one should stick to the worship of Your lotus feet because You are the ultimate controller of creation, maintenance and dissolution. You are the controller of the three worlds, Bhür, Bhuvar and Svar, You are the controller of the fourteen upper and lower worlds, and You are the controller of the three material qualities. Demigods and persons advanced in spiritual knowledge are always engaged in hearing and chanting about Your transcendental pastimes because this has the specific potency of nullifying the accumulated results of sinful life. Intelligent persons factually take a dip in the ocean of Your nectarean activities and very patiently hear of them. Thus they immediately become freed from the contamination of the material qualities; they do not have to undergo severe penances and austerities for advancement of spiritual life. This chanting and hearing of Your transcendental pastimes is the easiest process for self-realization. Simply by submissive aural reception of the transcendental message, one's heart becomes cleansed of all dirty things. Thus Kåñëa consciousness becomes fixed in the heart of a devotee.

"The great authority Bhéñmadeva has also given the opinion that this process of chanting and hearing about the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the essence of all Vedic ritualistic performances. Dear Lord, the devotee who wants to elevate himself simply by this process of devotional activities, especially by hearing and chanting, very soon comes out of the clutches of the dualities of material existence. By this simple process of penance and austerity the Supersoul within the devotee's heart becomes very pleased and gives the devotee directions so that he may go back to home, back to Godhead. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [6.7] that one who engages all his activities and senses in the devotional service of the Lord becomes completely pacified because the Supersoul is satisfied with him; thus the devotee becomes transcendental to all kinds of dualities, such as heat and cold, honor and dishonor. Being freed from all dualities, he feels transcendental bliss, and he no longer suffers cares and anxieties due to material existence. Bhagavad-gétä [9.13] confirms that the devotee who is always absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness has no anxieties for his maintenance or protection. Being constantly absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness, he ultimately achieves the highest perfection. While in the material existence, he lives very peacefully and blissfully without any cares and anxieties, and after quitting this body he goes back to home, back to Godhead. The Lord confirms in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.6], 'My supreme abode is a transcendental place where going no one returns to this material world. Anyone who attains the supreme perfection, being engaged in My personal devotional service in the eternal abode, reaches the highest perfection of human life and doesn't have to come back again to the miserable material world.'

"My dear Lord, it is imperative that the living entities be engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, always rendering devotional service by prescribed methods such as hearing and chanting and executing Your orders. If a person is not engaged in Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service, it is useless for him to exhibit the symptoms of life. Generally it is accepted that if a person is breathing he is alive. But a person without Kåñëa consciousness may be compared to a bellows in a blacksmith's shop. The big bellows is a bag of skin which exhales and inhales air, and a human being who is simply living within the bag of skin and bones without taking to Kåñëa consciousness and loving devotional service is no better than the bellows. Similarly, a nondevotee's long duration of life is compared to the long existence of a tree, his voracious eating capacity is compared to the eating of dogs and hogs, and his enjoyment in sex life is compared to that of hogs and goats.

"The cosmic manifestation has been possible because of the entrance of the Supreme Personality of Godhead as Mahä-Viñëu within this material world. The total material energy becomes agitated by the glance of Mahä-Viñëu, and only then does the interaction of the three material qualities begin. Therefore it should be concluded that whatever material facilities we are trying to enjoy are available only due to the mercy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

"Within the body there are five different departments of existence, known as annamaya, präëamaya, manomaya, vijïänamaya, and at last änandamaya. In the beginning of life, every living entity is food conscious. A child or an animal is satisfied only by getting nice food. This stage of consciousness, in which the goal is to eat sumptuously, is called annamaya. Anna means food. After this one lives in the consciousness of being alive. If one can continue his life without being attacked or destroyed, one thinks himself happy. This stage is called präëamaya, or consciousness of one's existence. After this stage, when one is situated on the mental platform, that consciousness is called manomaya. The material civilization is primarily situated in these three stages, annamaya, präëamaya and manomaya. The first concern of civilized persons is economic development, the next concern is defense against being annihilated, and the next consciousness is mental speculation, the philosophical approach to the values of life.

"If by the evolutionary process of philosophical life one happens to reach to the platform of intellectual life and understands that he is not this material body, but is a spirit soul, then by evolution of spiritual life he comes to the understanding of the Supreme Lord or the Supreme Soul. When one develops his relationship with Him and executes devotional service, that stage of life is called Kåñëa consciousness, the änandamaya stage. Änandamaya is the blissful life of knowledge and eternity. As it is said in the Vedänta-sütra, änandamayo 'bhyäsät. The Supreme Brahman and the subordinate Brahman, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the living entities, are both joyful by nature. As long as the living entities are situated in the lower four stages of life, annamaya, präëamaya, manomaya and vijïänamaya, they are considered to be in the material condition of life, but as soon as one reaches the stage of änandamaya he becomes a liberated soul. This änandamaya stage is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä as the brahma-bhütä stage. There it is said that in the brahma-bhütä stage of life there is no anxiety and no hankering. This stage begins when one becomes equally disposed toward all living entities, and it then expands to the stage of Kåñëa consciousness in which one always hankers to render service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This hankering for advancement in devotional service is not the same as hankering for sense gratification in material existence. In other words, hankering remains in spiritual life, but it becomes purified. When our senses are purified, they become freed from all material stages, namely annamaya, präëamaya, manomaya and vijïänamaya, and they become situated in the highest stage—änandamaya, or blissful life in Kåñëa consciousness. The Mäyävädé philosophers consider änandamaya to be the state of being merged in the Supreme. To them, änandamaya means that the Supersoul and the individual soul become one. But the real fact is that oneness does not mean merging into the Supreme and losing one's own individual existence. Merging in the spiritual existence is the living entity's realization of qualitative oneness with the Supreme Lord in His eternity and knowledge aspects. But the actual änandamaya (blissful) stage is obtained when one is engaged in devotional service. That is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä. Mad-bhaktià labhate paräm: the brahma-bhütä änandamaya stage is complete only when there is the exchange of love between the Supreme and the subordinate living entities. Unless one comes to this änandamaya stage of life, his breathing is like the breathing of a bellows in a blacksmith's shop, his duration of life is like that of a tree, and he is no better than the lower animals like the camels, hogs and dogs.

Undoubtedly the eternal living entity cannot be annihilated at any point. But the lower species of life exist in a miserable condition, whereas one who is engaged in devotional service of the Supreme Lord is situated in the pleasurable or änandamaya status of life. The different stages described above are all in relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Although in all circumstances there exist both the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the living entities, the difference is that the Supreme Personality of Godhead always exists in the änandamaya stage, whereas the subordinate living entities, because of their minute position as fragmental portions of the Supreme Lord, are prone to fall to the other stages of life. Although in all the stages both the Supreme Lord and the living entities exist, the Supreme Personality of Godhead is always transcendental to our concept of life, whether we are in bondage or in liberation. The whole cosmic manifestation becomes possible by the grace of the Supreme Lord, it exists by the grace of the Supreme Lord, and when it is annihilated, it merges into the existence of the Supreme Lord. As such, the Supreme Lord is the supreme existence, the cause of all causes. Therefore the conclusion is that without development of Kåñëa consciousness, one's life is simply a waste of time.

Those who are very materialistic and cannot understand the situation of the spiritual world cannot understand the abode of Kåñëa. For such persons, great sages have recommended the yogic process whereby one gradually rises from meditation on the adbomen, which is called mülädhära or maëipüraka meditation. Mülädhära and maëipüraka are technical terms which refer to the intestines within the abdomen. Grossly materialistic persons think that economic development is of foremost importance because they are under the impression that a living entity exists only by eating. Such grossly materialistic persons forget that although we may eat as much as we like, if the food is not digested it produces the troubles of indigestion and acidity. Therefore, in itself, eating is not the cause of the vital energy of life. For digestion of eatables we have to take shelter of another, superior energy, which is mentioned in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.14] as vaiçvänara. Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä that He helps the digestion in the form of vaiçvänara. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is all-pervasive; therefore, His presence as vaiçvänara is not extraordinary.

Kåñëa is actually present everywhere. The Vaiñëava, therefore, marks his body with temples of Viñëu: he first marks a tilaka temple on the abdomen, then on the chest, then between the collarbones, then on the forehead, and gradually he marks the top of the head, the brahma-randhra. The thirteen temples of tilaka marked on the body of a Vaiñëava are known as follows: On the forehead is the temple of Lord Keçava, on the belly is the temple of Lord Näräyaëa, on the chest is the temple of Lord Mädhava, and on the throat, between the two collarbones, is the temple of Lord Govinda. On the right side of the waist is the temple of Lord Viñëu, on the right arm is the temple of Lord Madhusüdana, and on the right side of the collarbone is the temple of Lord Trivikrama. Similarly, on the left side of the waist is the temple of Lord Vämanadeva, on the left arm is the temple of Çrédhara, on the left side of the collarbone is the temple of Håñékeça, on the upper back the temple is called Padmanäbha, and on the lower back the temple is called Dämodara. On the top of the head the temple is called Väsudeva. This is the process of meditation on the Lord's situation in the different parts of the body, but for those who are not Vaiñëavas, great sages recommend meditation on the bodily concept of life—meditation on the intestines, on the heart, on the throat, on the eyebrows, on the forehead and then on the top of the head. Some of the sages in the disciplic succession from the great saint Aruëa meditate on the heart because the Supersoul is also staying within the heart along with the living entity. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä, Fifteenth Chapter, wherein the Lord states, "I am situated in everyone's heart."

For the Vaiñëava, the protection of the body for the service of the Lord is a part of devotional service, but those who are gross materialists accept the body as the self. They worship the body by the yogic process of meditation on the different bodily parts, such as maëipüraka, dahara and hådaya, gradually rising to the brahma-randhra on the top of the head. The first-class yogé who has attained perfection in the practice of the yoga system ultimately passes through the brahma-randhra to any one of the planets in either the material or spiritual worlds. How a yogé can transfer himself to another planet is very vividly described in the Second Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

In this regard, Çukadeva Gosvämé has recommended that the beginners worship the viräöa puruña, the gigantic universal form of the Lord. One who cannot believe that the Lord can be worshiped with equal success in the Deity or arcä form, or who cannot concentrate on this form, is advised to worship the universal form of the Lord. The lower part of the universe is considered the feet and legs of the Lord's universal form, the middle part of the universe is considered the navel or abdomen of the Lord, the upper planetary systems such as Janaloka and Maharloka are the heart of the Lord, and the topmost planetary system, Brahmaloka, is considered the top of the Lord's head. There are different processes recommended by great sages, according to the position of the worshiper, but the ultimate aim of all meditational and yogic processes is to go back home, back to Godhead. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä [15.6], anyone who reaches the highest planet, the abode of Kåñëa, or even the Vaikuëöha planets, never has to come down again to this miserable material condition of life.

The Vedic recommendation, therefore, is that one make the lotus feet of Viñëu the target of all one's efforts. Tad viñëoù paramaà padaà, Viñëuloka or the Viñëu planets, are situated above all the material planets. These Vaikuëöha planets are known as sanätana-dhäma, and they are eternal. They are never annihilated, not even by the annihilation of this material world. The conclusion is that if a human being does not fulfill the mission of his life by worshiping the Supreme Lord and does not go back to Godhead, then it is to be understood that he has been frustrated in fulfilling the main purpose of human life.

The next prayer of the personified Vedas to the Lord concerns His entering into different species of life. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä, Fourteenth Chapter, that in every species and form of life the spiritual part and parcel of the Supreme Lord is present. The Lord Himself claims in the Gétä [14.4] that He is the seed-giving father of all forms and species, and therefore they must all be considered sons of the Lord. The entrance of the Supreme Lord into everyone's heart as Paramätmä sometimes bewilders the impersonalists, who think in terms of the equality of the living entities with the Supreme Lord. They think that because the Supreme Lord enters into different bodies along with the individual soul, there is no distinction between the Lord and the individual entities. Their challenge is, "Why should individual souls worship the Paramätmä or Supersoul?" According to them, both the Supersoul and the individual soul are on the same level; they are one, without any difference between them. There is a difference, however, between the Supersoul and the individual soul, and this is explained in Bhagavad-gétä, Fifteenth Chapter, wherein the Lord says that although He is situated with the living entity in the same body, He is superior. He is dictating to or giving intelligence to the individual soul from within. It is clearly stated in the Gétä [15.15] that the Lord gives intelligence to the individual soul and that both memory and forgetfulness are due to the influence of the Supersoul. No one can act independently of the sanction of the Supersoul. Therefore, the individual soul acts according to his past karma, reminded by the Lord. The nature of the individual soul is forgetfulness, but the presence of the Lord within the heart reminds him of what he wanted to do in his past life. The intelligence of the individual soul is exhibited like fire in wood. Although fire is always fire, it is exhibited in a size proportionate to the size of the wood. Similarly, although the individual soul is qualitatively one with the Supreme Lord, he exhibits himself according to the limitations of his present body.

The Supreme Lord or the Supersoul is said to be eka-rasa. Eka means one, and rasa means mellow. The transcendental position of the Supreme Lord is that of eternity, bliss and full knowledge. His position of eka-rasa does not change in the slightest when He becomes a witness and advisor to the individual soul in each individual body.

The individual soul, beginning from Lord Brahmä down to the ant, exhibits his spiritual potency according to his present body. The demigods are in the same category with the individual souls in the bodies of the human beings or in the bodies of lower animals. Intelligent persons, therefore, do not worship different demigods, who are simply infinitesimal representatives of Kåñëa manifesting in conditioned bodies. The individual soul can exhibit his power and potencies only in proportion to the shape and constitution of the body. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, however, can exhibit His full potencies in any shape or form without any change. The Mäyävädé philosophers' thesis that God and the individual soul are one and the same cannot be accepted because the individual soul has to develop his power and potencies according to the development of different types of bodies. The individual soul in the body of a baby cannot show the full power and potency of a grown man, but the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa, even when lying on the lap of His mother as a baby, could exhibit His full potency and power by killing Pütanä and other demons who tried to attack Him. Therefore the spiritual potency of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is said to be eka-rasa, or without change. Therefore the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the only worshipable object, and this is perfectly known to persons who are uncontaminated by the force of material nature. In other words, only the liberated souls can worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Less intelligent Mäyävädés take to the worship of demigods, thinking that the demigods and the Supreme Personality of Godhead are on the same level.

The personified Vedas continued to offer their obeisances. "Dear Lord," they prayed, "after many, many births, those who have actually become wise take to the worship of Your lotus feet in complete knowledge." This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.19], wherein the Lord says that after many, many births, a great soul or mahätmä surrenders unto the Lord, knowing well that Väsudeva, Kåñëa, is the cause of all causes. The Vedas continued: "As has already been explained, since our mind, intelligence and senses have been given to us by God, when these instruments are actually purified there is no alternative than to engage them all in the devotional service of the Lord. A living entity's entrapment in different species of life is due to the misapplication of his mind, intelligence and senses in material activities. Various kinds of bodies are awarded as the result of a living entity's actions, and they are created by the material nature according to the living entity's desire. Because a living entity desires and deserves a particular kind of body, it is given to him by the material nature under the order of the Supreme Lord.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Third Canto, it is explained that under the control of superior authority a living entity is put within the semina of a male and injected into the womb of a particular female in order to develop a particular type of body. A living entity utilizes his senses, intelligence, mind, etc., in a specific way of his own choosing and thus develops a particular type of body within which he becomes encaged. In this way the living entity becomes situated in different species of life, either in a demigod, human or animal body, according to different situations and circumstances.

It is explained in the Vedic literatures that the living entities entrapped in different species of life are part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. The Mäyävädé philosophers mistake the living entity for the Paramätmä, who is actually sitting with the living entity as a friend. Because the Paramätmä, the localized aspect of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and the individual living entity are both within the body, a misunderstanding sometimes takes place that there is no difference between the two. But there is a definite difference between the individual soul and the Supersoul, and it is explained in the Varäha Puräëa as follows. The Supreme Lord has two kinds of parts and parcels: the living entity is called vibhinnäàça, and the Paramätmä or the plenary expansion of the Supreme Lord is called sväàça. The sväàça plenary expansion of the Supreme Personality is as powerful as the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself. There is not even the slightest difference between the potency of the Supreme Person and that of His plenary expansion as Paramätmä, but the vibhinnäàça parts and parcels possess only a minute portion of the potencies of the Lord. The Näräyaëa-Païcarätra states that the living entities who are the marginal potency of the Supreme Lord are undoubtedly of the same quality of spiritual existence as the Lord Himself, but they are prone to be tinged with the material qualities. Because he is prone to be subjected to the influence of material qualities, the minute living entity is called jéva. Sometimes the Supreme Personality of Godhead is also known as Çiva, the all-auspicious. So the difference between Çiva and jéva is that the all-auspicious Personality of Godhead is never affected by the material qualities, whereas the minute portions of the Supreme Personality of Godhead are prone to be affected by the qualities of material nature.

The Supersoul within the body of a particular living entity, although a plenary portion of the Lord, is worshipable by the individual living entity. Great sages have therefore concluded that the process of meditation is designed so that the individual living entity may concentrate his attention on the lotus feet of the Supersoul form (Viñëu). That is the real form of samädhi. The living entity cannot become liberated from material entanglement by his own effort. He must therefore take to the devotional service of the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord, or the Supersoul within himself. Çrédhara Svämé, the great commentator on Çrémad-Bhägavatam, has composed a nice verse in this regard, the purport of which is as follows: "My dear Lord, I am eternally Your part and parcel, but I have been entrapped by the material potencies, which are also an emanation from You. As the cause of all causes, You have entered my body as the Supersoul, and I have the prerogative to enjoy the supreme blissful life of knowledge along with You. Therefore, my dear Lord, please order me to render You loving service so that I can again be brought to my original position of transcendental bliss."

Great personalities understand that a living entity entangled in this material world cannot become freed by his own efforts. With firm faith and devotion, such great personalities engage themselves in rendering transcendental loving service to the Lord. That is the verdict of the personified Vedas.

The personified Vedas continued: "Dear Lord, it is very difficult to achieve perfect knowledge of the Absolute Truth. Your Lordship is so kind to the fallen souls that You appear in different incarnations and execute different activities. You appear even as a historical personality of this material world, and Your pastimes are very nicely described in the Vedic literatures. Such pastimes are as attractive as the ocean of transcendental bliss. People in general have a natural inclination to read narrations in which ordinary jévas are glorified, but when they become attracted by the Vedic literatures which delineate Your eternal pastimes, they actually dip into the ocean of transcendental bliss. As a fatigued man feels refreshed by dipping into a reservoir of water, so the conditioned soul who is very much disgusted with material activities becomes refreshed and forgets all the fatigue of material activities simply by dipping into the transcendental ocean of Your pastimes. And eventually he merges in the ocean of transcendental bliss. The most intelligent devotees, therefore, do not take to any means of self-realization except devotional service and constant engagement in the nine different processes of devotional life, especially hearing and chanting. When hearing and chanting about Your transcendental pastimes, Your devotees do not care even for the transcendental bliss derived from liberation or from merging into the existence of the Supreme. Such devotees are not interested even in so-called liberation, and certainly they have no interest in material activities for elevation to the heavenly planets for sense gratification. Pure devotees seek only the association of paramahaàsas, or great liberated devotees, so that they can continually hear and chant about Your glories. For this purpose the pure devotees are prepared to sacrifice all comforts of life, even giving up the material comforts of family life and so-called society, friendship and love. Those who have tasted the nectar of devotion by relishing the transcendental vibration of chanting Your glories, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, do not care for any other spiritual bliss or for material comforts, which appear to the pure devotee to be less important than the straw in the street."

The personified Vedas continued: "Dear Lord, when a person is able to purify his mind, senses and intelligence by engaging himself in devotional service in full Kåñëa consciousness, his mind becomes his friend. Otherwise, his mind is always his enemy. When the mind is engaged in devotional service of the Lord, it becomes the intimate friend of the living entity because the mind can then think of the Supreme Lord always. Your Lordship is eternally dear to the living entity, so when the mind is engaged in thought of You, one immediately feels the great satisfaction for which he has been hankering life after life. When one's mind is thus fixed on the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one does not take to any kind of inferior worship or inferior process of self-realization. By attempting to worship a demigod or by taking to any other process of self-realization, the living entity becomes a victim of the cycle of birth and death, and no one can estimate how much the living entity becomes degraded by entering the abominable species of life such as the cats and dogs."

Çré Narottama däsa Öhäkur [hari hari! vifale 2] has sung that persons who do not take to devotional service of the Lord but are attracted to the process of philosophical speculation and fruitive activities drink the poisonous results of such actions. Such persons are forced to take birth in different species of life and are forced to adopt obnoxious practices like meat-eating and intoxication. Materialistic persons generally worship the transient material body and forget the welfare of the spirit soul within the body. Some take shelter of materialistic science to improve bodily comforts, and some take to the worship of demigods in order to be promoted to the heavenly planets. Their goal in life is to make the material body comfortable while forgetting the interest of the spirit soul. Such persons are described in the Vedic literature as suicidal because attachment for the material body and its comforts forces the living entity to wander through the process of birth and death perpetually and suffer the material pangs as a matter of course. The human form of life is a chance for one to understand his position, and the most intelligent person takes to devotional service just to engage his mind, senses and body in the service of the Lord without deviation.

The personified Vedas continued: "Dear Lord, there are many mystic yogés who are very learned and deliberate in achieving the highest perfection of life. They engage themselves in the yogic process of controlling the life-air within the body. Concentrating the mind upon the form of Viñëu and controlling the senses very rigidly, they practice the yoga system, but even after much laborious austerity, penance, and regulation, they achieve the same destination as persons who are inimical toward You. In other words, both the yogés and great, wise philosophical speculators ultimately attain the impersonal Brahman effulgence, which is also automatically attained by the demons who are regular enemies of the Lord. Demons like Kaàsa, Çiçupäla and Dantavakra also attain the Brahman effulgence because they constantly meditate upon the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Women such as the gopés were attached to Kåñëa and captivated by His beauty, and their mental concentration on Kåñëa was provoked by lust. They wanted to be embraced by the arms of Kåñëa, which resemble the beautiful round shape of a snake. Similarly, there are the Vedic hymns, and we also simply concentrate our minds on the lotus feet of Your Lordship. Women like the gopés concentrate upon You dictated by lust, and we concentrate upon Your lotus feet to go back home, back to Godhead. Your enemies also concentrate upon You, thinking always how to kill You, and the yogés undertake great penances and austerities just to attain Your impersonal effulgence. All these different persons, although concentrating their minds in different ways, achieve spiritual perfection according to their different perspectives because You are equal to all Your devotees."

Çrédhara Svämé has composed a nice verse in this regard: "My dear Lord, to be engaged always in thinking of Your lotus feet is very difficult. It is possible by great devotees who have already achieved love for You and who are engaged in transcendental loving service. My dear Lord, I wish that my mind also may be engaged somehow or other on Your lotus feet, at least for some time."

The attainment of spiritual perfection by different spiritualists is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä, wherein the Lord says that He grants the perfection the devotee desires in proportion to the devotee's surrender unto Him. The impersonalists, yogés and the enemies of the Lord enter into the Lord's transcendental effulgence, but the personalists who are following in the footsteps of the inhabitants of Våndävana or strictly following the path of devotional service are elevated to the personal abode of Kåñëa, Goloka Våndävana, or to the Vaikuëöha planets. Both the impersonalists and the personalists enter into the spiritual realm or the spiritual sky, but the impersonalists are given their place in the impersonal Brahman effulgence, whereas the personalists are given a position in the Vaikuëöha planets or in the Våndävana planet, according to their desire to serve the Lord in different mellows.

The personified Vedas stated that persons who are born after the creation of this material world cannot understand the existence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead by manipulating their material knowledge. Just as a person born in a particular family cannot understand the position of his great-grandfather who lived before the birth of the recent generation, we are unable to understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa or Kåñëa, who exists eternally in the spiritual world. In the Eighth Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä [8.22] it is clearly said that the Supreme Person, who lives eternally in the spiritual kingdom of God (sanätana-dhäma), can be approached only by devotional service.

As for the material creation, Brahmä is the first created person. Before Brahmä there was no living creature within this material world; it was void and dark until Brahmä was born on the lotus flower sprouted from the abdomen of Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu. Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu is an expansion of Käraëodakaçäyé Viñëu, Käraëodakaçäyé Viñëu is an expansion of Saìkarñaëa, and Saìkarñaëa is an expansion of Balaräma. Balaräma is an immediate expansion of Lord Kåñëa. After the creation of Brahmä, the two kinds of demigods were born: demigods like the four brothers Sanaka, Sanätana, Sananda and Sanat-kumära, who are representatives of renunciation of the world, and demigods like Maréci and their descendants who are meant to enjoy this material world. From these two kinds of demigods were gradually manifested all other living entities, including the human beings. Thus any living creature within this material world, including Brahmä, all the demigods and all the räkñasas, are to be considered modern. This means that they were all recently born. Therefore, just as a person recently born in a family cannot understand the situation of his distant forefather, so anyone within this material world cannot understand the position of the Supreme Lord in the spiritual world because the material world has only recently been created. Although they have a long duration of existence, all the manifestations of the material world, namely, the time elements, the living entities, the Vedas, and the gross and subtle elements, are all created at some point. Anything manufactured within this created situation or accepted as a means to understanding the original source of creation is to be considered modern.

Therefore by the process of self-realization or God realization through fruitive activities, philosophical speculation or mystic yoga, one cannot actually approach the supreme source of everything. When the creation is completely terminated, when there is no existence of the Vedas, no existence of material time, no existence of the gross and subtle material elements, and when all the living entities are in the nonmanifested stage resting within Näräyaëa, then all these manufactured processes become null and void and cannot act. Devotional service, however, is eternally going on in the eternal spiritual world. Therefore the only factual process of self-realization or God realization is devotional service, and if one takes to this process he takes to the real process of God realization. Çréla Çrédhara Svämé has therefore composed a verse in this regard which conveys the idea that the supreme source of everything, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is so great and unlimited that it is not possible for the living entity to understand Him by any material acquisition. Everyone should therefore pray to the Lord to be engaged in His devotional service eternally, so that by the grace of the Lord one can understand the supreme source of creation. The supreme source of creation, the Supreme Lord, reveals Himself only to the devotees. In the Fourth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä [4.3] the Lord says to Arjuna, "My dear Arjuna, because you are My devotee and because you are My intimate friend I shall therefore reveal to you the process of understanding Me." In other words, the supreme source of creation, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, cannot be understood by our own endeavor. We have to please Him with devotional service, and then He will reveal Himself to us. Then we can understand Him to some extent.

There are different kinds of philosophers who have tried to understand the supreme source by their mental speculation. There are generally six kinds of mental speculators, and they are called ñaò-darçana. All these philosophers are impersonalists and are known as Mäyävädés. Every one of them has tried to establish his own opinion, although they all have later compromised and stated that all opinions lead to the same goal and that every opinion is therefore valid. According to the prayers of the personified Vedas, however, none of them are valid because their process of knowledge is created within the temporary material world. They have all missed the real point: the Supreme Personality of Godhead or the Absolute Truth can be understood only by devotional service.

One class of philosophers, known as Mémäàsakas, represented by sages such as Jaimini, have concluded that everyone should be engaged in pious activities or prescribed duties and that such activities will lead one to the highest perfection. But this is contradicted in the Ninth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, where Lord Kåñëa says that by pious activities one may be elevated to the heavenly planets, but as soon as one's accumulation of pious activities is used up, one has to leave the enjoyment of a higher standard of material prosperity in the heavenly planets and immediately come down again to these lower planets, where the duration of life is very short and where the standard of material happiness is of a lower grade. The exact words used in the Gétä are kñéëe puëye martya-lokaà viçanti. Therefore the conclusion of the Mémäàsaka philosophers, that pious activities will lead one to the Absolute Truth, is not valid. Although a pure devotee is by nature inclined to pious activities, no one can attain the favor of the Supreme Personality of Godhead by pious activities alone. Pious activities may purify one of the contamination caused by ignorance and passion, but this is automatically attained by a devotee who is constantly engaged in hearing the transcendental message of Godhead in the form of the Bhagavad-gétä, Çrémad-Bhägavatam or similar scriptures. From the Bhagavad-gétä [2.40] we understand that even a person who is not up to the standard of pious activities but who is absolutely engaged in devotional service is to be considered well situated on the path of spiritual perfection. It is also said in the Bhagavad-gétä [10.10] that a person who is engaged in devotional service with love and faith is guided from within by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Lord Himself as Paramätmä, or the spiritual master sitting within one's heart, gives the devotee exact direction by which he can gradually go back to Godhead. The conclusion of the Mémäàsaka philosophers is not actually the truth which can lead one to real understanding.

Similarly, there are Säìkhya philosophers, metaphysicians or material scientists who study this cosmic manifestation by their invented scientific method and who do not recognize the supreme authority of God as the creator of the cosmic manifestation. Rather, they wrongly conclude that the reaction of material elements is the original cause of creation. The Bhagavad-gétä, however, does not accept this theory. It is clearly said therein that behind the cosmic activities is the direction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This fact is corroborated by the Vedic [Chändogya Upaniñad 6.2.1] injunction asad vä idam agra äsét, which means that the origin of the creation existed before the cosmic manifestation. Therefore, the material elements cannot be the cause of material creation. Although the material elements are accepted as material causes, the ultimate cause is the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself. The Bhagavad-gétä [9.10] says, therefore, that material nature works under the direction of Kåñëa.

The conclusion of the atheistic Säìkhya philosophy is that because the effects of the material worlds are temporary or illusory, the cause is therefore also illusory. The Säìkhya philosophers are in favor of voidism, but the actual fact is that the original cause is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and this cosmic manifestation is the temporary manifestation of His material energy. When this temporary manifestation is annihilated, its cause, the eternal existence of the spiritual world, continues as it is, and therefore the spiritual world is called sanätana-dhäma, the eternal abode. The conclusion of the Säìkhya philosopher is therefore not valid.

Then there are the philosophers headed by Gautama and Kaëäda. They have very minutely studied the cause and effect of the material elements and have ultimately come to the conclusion that atomic combination is the original cause of creation. Present material scientists also follow in the footsteps of Gautama and Kaëäda, who propounded this theory of paramänuväda. This theory, however, cannot be supported because the original cause of everything is not inert atoms. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam as well as in the Vedas, wherein it is stated eko näräyaëa äsét, only Näräyaëa existed before the creation. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.1.1] and Vedänta-sütra 1.1.2 also say that the original cause is sentient and both indirectly and directly cognizant of everything within this creation. In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says, ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù: "I am the original cause of everything," and mattaù sarvaà pravartate: "From Me everything comes into existence." Therefore, atoms may form the basic combinations of material existence, but these atoms are generated from the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Thus the philosophy of Gautama and Kaëäda cannot be supported.

Similarly, impersonalists headed by Añöävakra and later on by Çaìkaräcärya accept the impersonal Brahman effulgence as the cause of everything. According to their theory, the material manifestation is temporary and unreal, whereas the impersonal Brahman effulgence is reality. But this theory cannot be supported either, because the Lord Himself says in the Bhagavad-gétä that this Brahman effulgence is resting on His personality. It is also confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä that the Brahman effulgence is the personal bodily rays of Kåñëa. As such, impersonal Brahman cannot be the original cause of the cosmic manifestation. The original cause is the all-perfect sentient Personality of Godhead, Govinda.

The most dangerous theory of the impersonalists is that when God comes as an incarnation He accepts a material body created by the three modes of material nature. This Mäyävädé theory has been condemned by Lord Caitanya as most offensive. He has said that anyone who accepts the transcendental body of the Personality of Godhead to be made of this material nature commits the greatest offense at the lotus feet of Viñëu. Similarly, the Bhagavad-gétä [9.11] also states that only the fools and rascals deride the Personality of Godhead when He descends in a human form. Lord Kåñëa, Lord Räma and Lord Caitanya actually move within human society as human beings.

The personified Vedas condemn the impersonal conception as a gross misrepresentation. In the Brahma-saàhitä, the body of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is described as änanda-cin-maya-rasa. The Supreme Personality of Godhead possesses a spiritual body, not a material body. He can enjoy anything through any part of His body, and therefore He is omnipotent. The limbs of a material body can perform only a particular function, just as hands can hold, but they cannot see or hear. Because the body of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is made of änanda-cin-maya-rasa or sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, He can enjoy anything and do everything with any of His limbs. Acceptance of the spiritual body of the Lord as material is dictated by the tendency to make the Supreme Personality of Godhead equal to the conditioned soul. The conditioned soul has a material body. Therefore, if God also has a material body, then the impersonalistic theory that the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the living entities are one and the same can be very easily propagandized.

Factually, when the Supreme Personality of Godhead comes He exhibits different pastimes, and yet there is no difference between His childish body when He is lying on the lap of His mother Yaçodä and His so-called grown up body fighting with the demons. In His childhood body also, He fought with demons such as Pütanä, Tåëävarta, Aghäsura, etc., with strength equal to that with which He fought in His youth against demons like Dantavakra, Çiçupäla and others. In material life, as soon as a conditioned soul changes his body, he forgets everything of his past body, but from the Bhagavad-gétä [4.1] we understand that Kåñëa, because He has a sac-cid-änanda body, did not forget instructing the sun-god about the Bhagavad-gétä millions of years ago. The Lord is therefore known as Puruñottama because He is transcendental to both material and spiritual existence. That He is the cause of all causes means that He is the cause of the spiritual world and of the material world as well. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is omnipotent and omniscient. Therefore, because a material body can be neither omnipotent nor omniscient, the Lord's body surely is not material. The Mäyävädé theory that the Personality of Godhead comes within this material world with a material body cannot be supported by any means.

It can be concluded that all the theories of the material philosophers are generated from the temporary illusory existence, like the conclusions in a dream. Such conclusions certainly cannot lead us to the Absolute Truth. The Absolute Truth can only be realized through devotional service. As the Lord says in the Bhagavad-gétä, bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti, "Only by devotional service can one understand Me." Çréla Çrédhara Svämé has composed a nice verse in this regard, which states: "My dear Lord, let others be engaged in false argument and dry speculation, theorizing upon their great philosophical theses. Let them loiter in the darkness of ignorance and illusion, falsely enjoying as if very learned scholars, although they are without knowledge of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As far as I am concerned, I wish to be liberated simply by chanting the holy names of the all-beautiful Supreme Personality of Godhead—Mädhava, Vämana, Trinayana, Saìkarñaëa, Çrépati and Govinda. Simply by chanting His transcendental names, let me become free from the contamination of this material existence."

In this way the personified Vedas said, "My dear Lord, when a living entity, by Your grace only, comes to the right conclusion about Your exalted transcendental position, at that time he no longer bothers with the different theories manufactured by the mental speculators or so-called philosophers. This is a reference to the speculative theories of Gautama, Kaëäda, Pataïjali and Kapila (Niréçvara). There are actually two Kapilas: one Kapila, the son of Kardama Muni, is an incarnation of God, and the other is an atheist of the modern age. The atheistic Kapila is often misrepresented to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead who appeared as the son of Kardama Muni during the time of Sväyambhuva Manu. Lord Kapila, the incarnation of Godhead, appeared long long ago; the modern age is the age of Vaivasvata Manu, whereas He appeared during the time of Sväyambhuva Manu.

According to Mäyävädé philosophy, this manifested world or the material world is mithyä or mäyä, false. Their preaching principle is brahma-satya jagat-mithyä. According to them, only the Brahman effulgence is true, and the cosmic manifestation is illusory or false. But according to Vaiñëava philosophy, this cosmic manifestation is caused by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.10] the Lord says that He enters within this material world by one of His plenary portions, and thus the creation takes place. From the Vedas also, we can understand that this asat or temporary cosmic manifestation is also an emanation from the Supreme sat or fact. From the Vedänta-sütra [1.1.2] also it is understood that everything has emanated from the Supreme Brahman. As such the Vaiñëavas do not take this cosmic manifestation to be false. The Vaiñëava philosopher sees everything in this material world in relationship with the Supreme Lord.

This conception of the material world is very nicely explained by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé [Brs 1.2.256], who said that renunciation of this material world as illusory or false without knowledge that the material world is also the manifestation of the Supreme Lord is of no practical value. The Vaiñëavas, however, are free of attachment to this world because generally the material world is accepted as an object of sense gratification. The Vaiñëavas are not in favor of sense gratification; therefore, they are not attached to material activities. The Vaiñëava accepts this material world according to the regulative principles of the Vedic injunctions. Since the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the original cause of everything, the Vaiñëava sees everything in relationship with Kåñëa, even in this material world. By such advanced knowledge, everything becomes spiritualized. In other words, everything in the material world is already spiritual, but due to our lack of knowledge we see things as material.

The personified Vedas presented the example that those who are seeking after gold do not reject gold earrings, gold bangles or anything else made of gold simply because they are shaped differently from the original gold. All living entities are part and parcel of the Supreme Lord and are qualitatively one, but they are now differently shaped in 8,400,000 species of life, just like many different ornaments which have been manufactured from the same source of gold. As one who is interested in gold accepts all the differently shaped gold ornaments, so a Vaiñëava, knowing well that all living entities are of the same quality as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, accepts all living entities as eternal servants of God. As a Vaiñëava, then, one has ample opportunity to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead simply by reclaiming these conditioned, misled living entities, training them in Kåñëa consciousness and leading them back to home, back to Godhead. The fact is that the minds of the living entities are now agitated by the three material qualities, and the living entities are therefore transmigrating, as if in dreams, from one body to another. When their consciousness is changed into Kåñëa consciousness, however, they immediately fix Kåñëa within their hearts, and thus their path for liberation becomes clear.

In all the Vedas the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the living entities are stated to be of the same quality—caitanya, or spiritual. This is also confirmed in the Padma Puräëa, wherein it is said that there are two kinds of spiritual entities; one is called the jéva, and the other is called the Supreme Lord. Beginning from Lord Brahmä down to the ant, all living entities are jévas, whereas the Lord is the Supreme four-handed Viñëu or Janäradana. The word ätmä can be applied only to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but because the living entities are His parts and parcels, sometimes the word ätmä is applied to them also. The living entities are therefore called jivätmä, and the Supreme Lord is called Paramätmä. Both the Paramätmä and jivätmä are within this material world, and therefore this material has a purpose other than sense gratification. The conception of a life of sense gratification is illusion, but the conception of service by the jivätmä to the Paramätmä, even in this material world, is not at all illusory. A Kåñëa conscious person is fully aware of this fact, and thus he does not take this material world to be false, but acts in the reality of transcendental service. The devotee therefore sees everything in this material world as an opportunity to serve the Lord. He does not reject anything as material, but dovetails everything in the service of the Lord. Thus a devotee is always in the transcendental position, and everything that he uses becomes spiritually purified by being used in the service of the Lord.

Çrédhara Svämé has composed a nice verse in this regard: "I worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead who is always manifested as reality even within this material world, which is considered by some to be false." The conception of the falsity of this material world is due to lack of knowledge, but a person advanced in Kåñëa consciousness sees the Supreme Personality of Godhead in everything. This is actually realization of the Vedic aphorism, sarvaà khalv idaà brahma: "Everything is Brahman."

The personified Vedas continued: "Dear Lord, less intelligent men take to other ways of self-realization, but actually there is no chance to become purified from material contamination or to stop the repeated cycle of birth and death unless one is a thoroughly pure devotee. Our dear Lord, everything is resting on Your different potencies; and everyone is supported by You, as is stated in the Vedas (eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän). Therefore Your Lordship is the supporter and maintainer of all living entities—demigods, human beings and animals. Everyone is supported by You, and You are also situated in everyone's heart. In other words, You are the root of the whole creation. Therefore those who are engaged in Your devotional service without deviation always worship You. Such devotees actually pour water on the root of the universal tree. By devotional service, therefore, one satisfies not only the Personality of Godhead but also all others, because everyone is maintained and supported by Him. Because he understands the all-pervasive feature of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, a devotee is the most practical philanthropist and altruist. Such pure devotees, thoroughly engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, very easily overcome the cycle of birth and death, and they as much as jump over the head of death."

A devotee is never afraid of death or of changing his body; his consciousness is transformed into Kåñëa consciousness, and even if he does not go back to Godhead, even if he transmigrates to another material body, he has nothing to fear. A vivid example is Bharata Mahäräja. Although in his next life he became a deer, in the life after that he became completely free from all material contamination and was elevated to the kingdom of God. The Bhagavad-gétä [9.31] affirms, therefore, that a devotee is never vanquished. A devotee's path to the spiritual kingdom, back home, back to Godhead, is guaranteed. Even though a devotee slips in one birth, the continuation of his Kåñëa consciousness elevates him further and further until he goes back to Godhead. Not only does a pure devotee purify his own personal existence, but whoever becomes his disciple also ultimately becomes purified and able to enter the kingdom of God without difficulty. Not only can a pure devotee easily surpass death, but by his grace his followers also can do so without difficulty. The power of devotional service is so great that a pure devotee can electrify another person by his transcendental instruction on crossing over the ocean of nescience.

The instructions of a pure devotee to his disciple are also very simple. No one feels any difficulty in following in the footsteps of a pure devotee. Anyone who follows in disciplic succession from recognized devotees of the Lord, such as Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, the Kumäras, Manu, Kapila, King Prahläda, King Janaka, Çukadeva Gosvämé, Yamaräja, etc., very easily finds the door of liberation open. On the other hand, those who are not devotees but are engaged in uncertain processes of self-realization, such as jïäna, yoga and karma, are understood to be still contaminated. Such contaminated persons, although apparently advanced in self-realization, cannot even liberate themselves, not to speak of others who follow them. Such nondevotees are compared to chained animals, for they are not able to go beyond the jurisdiction of the formalities of a certain type of faith. In the Bhagavad-gétä [2.42] they are condemned as veda-vädaù. They cannot understand that the Vedas deal with activities of the material modes of nature—goodness, passion and ignorance.

Lord Kåñëa advised Arjuna that one has to go beyond the jurisdiction of the duties prescribed in the Vedas and take to Kåñëa consciousness, devotional service. It is said in the Bhagavad-gétä, nistraiguëyo bhavärjuna, “My dear Arjuna, just try to become transcendental to the Vedic rituals.” This transcendental position beyond the Vedic ritualistic performances is devotional service. In the Bhagavad-gétä [14.26] the Lord clearly says that persons who are engaged in His devotional service without adulteration are situated in Brahman. Actual Brahman realization means Kåñëa consciousness and engagement in devotional service. The devotees are therefore real brahmacärés because their activities are always in Kåñëa consciousness, devotional service.

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is therefore a supreme call to all kinds of religionists asking them with great authority to join this movement by which one can learn how to love God and thus surpass all formulas and formalities of scriptural injunction. A person who cannot overcome the jurisdiction of stereotyped religious principles is compared to an animal chained up by his master. The purpose of all religion is to understand God and develop one's dormant love of Godhead. If one simply sticks to the religious formulas and formalities and does not become elevated to the position of love of God, he is considered to be a chained animal. In other words, if one is not in Kåñëa consciousness, he is not eligible for liberation from the contamination of material existence.

Çréla Çrédhara Svämé has composed a nice verse which says, "Let others engage in severe austerities, let others fall to the land from the tops of hills and give up their lives, let others travel to many holy places of pilgrimage for salvation, or let them be engaged in deep study of philosophy and Vedic literatures; let the mystic yogés engage in their meditational service, and let the different sects engage in unnecessary arguing as to which is the best. But it is a fact that unless one is Kåñëa conscious, unless one is engaged in devotional service, and unless one has the mercy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he cannot cross over this material ocean." An intelligent person, therefore, gives up all stereotyped ideas and joins the Kåñëa consciousness movement for factual liberation.

The personified Vedas continued their prayers. "Our dear Lord, Your impersonal feature is explained in the Vedas: You have no hands, but You can accept all sacrifices which are offered to You; You have no legs, but You can walk more swiftly than anyone. Although You have no eyes, You can see whatever happens in the past, present and future. Although You have no ears, You can hear everything that is said. Although You have no mind, You know everyone and everyone's activities, past, present and future, and yet no one knows who You are. You know everyone, but no one knows You; therefore, You are the oldest and supreme personality."

Similarly, in another part of the Vedas it is said, "You have nothing to do. You are so perfect in Your knowledge and potency that everything becomes manifest simply by Your will. There is no one equal to or greater than You, and everyone is acting as Your eternal servant." Thus the Vedic statements describe that the Absolute has no legs, no hands, no eyes, no ears and no mind, and yet He can act through His potencies and fulfill the needs of all living entities. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [13.14], His hands and legs are everywhere; He is all-pervasive. The hands, legs, ears and eyes of all living entities are acting and moving by the direction of the Supersoul sitting within the living entity's heart. Unless the Supersoul is present, it is not possible for the hands and legs to be active. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is so great, independent and perfect, however, that even without having any eyes, legs and ears, He is not dependent on others for His activities. On the contrary, others are dependent on Him for the activities of their different sense organs. Unless the living entity is inspired and directed by the Supersoul, he cannot act.

The fact is that ultimately the Absolute Truth is the Supreme Person. But because He is acting through His different potencies which are impossible for the gross materialists to see, the materialists accept Him as impersonal. For example, one can observe the personal artistic work in a painting of a flower, and one can understand that the color adjustment, the shape, etc., have demanded the minute attention of the artist. The artist's work is clearly exhibited in a painting of different blooming flowers. But the gross materialist, without seeing the hand of God in such artistic manifestations as the actual flowers blooming in nature, concludes that the Absolute Truth is impersonal. Actually, the Absolute is personal, but He is independent. He does not require to personally take a brush and colors to paint the flowers, but His potencies are acting so wonderfully that it appears as if flowers have come into being without the aid of an artist. The impersonal view of the Absolute Truth is accepted by less intelligent men because unless one is engaged in the service of the Lord, he cannot understand how the Supreme is acting—he cannot even know His name. Everything about His activities and personal features is revealed to the devotee only through his loving service attitude.

In the Bhagavad-gétä it is clearly said, bhoktäraà yajïa tapasäm: the Lord is the enjoyer of all kinds of sacrifices and of the results of all austerities. Then again the Lord says, sarva-loka-maheçvaram: "I am the proprietor of all planets." So that is the position of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Although He is present in Våndävana and enjoys transcendental pleasure in the company of His eternal associates, the gopés and the cowherd boys, His potencies are acting under His direction all over the creation. They do not disturb His eternal pastimes.

Through devotional service only can one understand how the Supreme Personality of Godhead, by His inconceivable potencies, simultaneously acts impersonally and as a person. He is acting just like the supreme emperor, and many thousands of kings and chiefs are working under Him. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is the supreme independent controlling person, and all the demigods—including Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, Indra the king of heaven, the king of the moon planet, and the king of the sun planet—are working under His direction. It is confirmed in the Vedas that the sun is shining, the air is blowing, and fire is distributing heat out of fear of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The material nature is producing all kinds of movable and immovable objects within the material world, but none of them can independently act or create without the direction of the Supreme Lord. All of them are acting as tributaries, just like subordinate kings who offer their annual taxes to the emperor.

The Vedic injunction states that every living entity lives by eating the remnants of foodstuffs offered to the Personality of Godhead. In great sacrifices the injunction is that Näräyaëa should be present as the supreme predominating Deity of the sacrifice, and after the sacrifice is performed, the remnants of foodstuffs are distributed amongst the demigods. This is called yajïa-bhäga. Every demigod has an allotment of yajïa-bhäga which he accepts as prasädam. The conclusion is that the demigods are not independently powerful; they are posted as different executives under the order of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and they are eating prasädam or the remnants of sacrifices. They are executing the order of the Supreme Lord exactly according to His plan. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is in the background, and His orders are carried out by others. It only appears that He is impersonal. In our grossly materialistic way, we cannot conceive how the Supreme Person is above the impersonal activities of material nature. Therefore the Lord explains in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.7] that there is nothing superior to Himself and that the impersonal Brahman is subordinately situated as a manifestation of His personal rays. Çrépada Çréla Çrédhara Svämé has therefore composed a nice verse in this regard: "Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who has no material senses but through whose direction and will all the material senses are working. He is the supreme potency of all material senses or sense organs. He is omnipotent, and He is the supreme performer of everything. Therefore He is worshipable by everyone. Unto that Supreme Person do I offer my respectful obeisances."

Kåñëa Himself declares in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.19] that He is Puruñottama, which means the Supreme Personality. Puruña means person, and uttama means supreme or transcendental. Also in Bhagavad-gétä [15.18] the Lord declares that because He is transcendental to all sentient and insentient beings, He is therefore known as the puruñottama. In another place [Bg. 9.6-8] the Lord says that as the air is situated in the all-pervading sky, so everyone is situated in Him, and everyone is acting under His direction.

The Vedas personified continued. "Our dear Lord," they prayed, "You are equal to all, with no partiality toward a particular type of living entity. As Your parts and parcels, all living entities enjoy or suffer in different conditions of life. They are just like the sparks of a fire. Just as sparks dance on a blazing fire, so all living entities are dancing on Your support. You are providing them with everything they desire, and yet You are not responsible for their position of enjoyment or suffering. There are different types of living entities—demigods, human beings, animals, trees, birds, beasts, germs, worms, insects and aquatics—and all are enjoying or suffering in life by resting on You. The living entities are of two kinds: one class is called ever-liberated, nitya-mukta, and the other class is called nitya-baddha. The nitya-mukta living entities are in the spiritual kingdom, and the nitya-baddha are in the material world.

"In the spiritual world both the Lord and the living entities are manifest in their original status, like live sparks in a blazing fire. But in the material world, although the Lord is all-pervasive in His impersonal feature, the living entities have forgotten their Kåñëa consciousness, just as sparks sometimes fall from a blazing fire and lose their original brilliant condition. Some sparks fall onto dry grass and thus ignite another big fire. This is a reference to the pure devotees who take compassion on the poor and innocent living entities. The pure devotee enlightens Kåñëa consciousness in the hearts of the conditioned souls, and thus the blazing fire of the spiritual world becomes manifest even within this material world. Some sparks fall onto water; they immediately lose their original brilliance and become almost extinct. This is comparable to the living entities who take their birth in the midst of gross materialists, in which case their original Kåñëa consciousness becomes almost extinct. Some sparks fall to the ground and remain midway between the blazing and extinct conditions. Thus some living entities are without Kåñëa consciousness, some are between having and not having Kåñëa consciousness, and some are actually situated in Kåñëa consciousness. The demigods in the higher planets, beginning from Lord Brahmä, Indra, Candra, the sun-god, the moon-god, and various other demigods, are all Kåñëa conscious. Human society is between the demigods and the animals, and thus some are more or less Kåñëa conscious, and some are completely forgetful of Kåñëa consciousness. The third-grade living entities, namely the animals, beasts, plants, trees and aquatics, have completely forgotten Kåñëa consciousness. This example stated in the Vedas of the sparks of a blazing fire is very appropriate for understanding the condition of different types of living entities. But above all other living entities is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa or Puruñottama, who is always liberated from all material conditions.

"The question may be raised as to why the living entities have fallen by chance into different conditions of life. To answer this question, we first have to understand that there cannot be any influence of chance for the living entities; chance is for nonliving entities. According to the Vedic literatures, living entities have knowledge, and thus they are called caitanya, which means in knowledge. Their situation in different conditions of life, therefore, is not accidental. It is by their choice because they have knowledge. In the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66] the Lord says, 'Give up everything and just surrender unto Me.' This process of realizing the Supreme Personality of Godhead is open for everyone, but still it is the choice of the particular living entity whether to accept or reject this proposal. In the last portion of the Bhagavad-gétä [18.72], Lord Kåñëa very plainly said to Arjuna, 'My dear Arjuna, now I have spoken everything to You. Everything now depends on whether you choose to accept it.' Similarly, the living entities who have come down to this material world have made their own choice to enjoy this material world. It is not that Kåñëa sent them into this material world. The material world is created for the enjoyment of living entities who wanted to give up the eternal service of the Lord to become the supreme enjoyer themselves. According to Vaiñëava philosophy, when a living entity desires to gratify his senses and forgets the service of the Lord, he is given a place in the material world to act freely according to his desire, and therefore he creates a condition of life in which he either enjoys or suffers. We should know definitely that both the Lord and the living entities are eternally cognizant. There is no birth and death for either the Lord or the living entities. When creation takes place, it does not mean that the living entities are created. The Lord creates this material world to give the conditioned souls a chance to elevate themselves to the higher platform of Kåñëa consciousness. If the conditioned soul does not take advantage of this opportunity, then after the dissolution of this material world, he enters into the body of Näräyaëa and remains there in deep sleep until the time of another creation.

"In this connection the example of the rainy season is very appropriate. Seasonal rainfall may be taken as the agent for creation because after the rainfall the wet fields are favorable for growing different types of vegetation. Similarly, as soon as there is creation by the Lord's glancing over the material nature, immediately the living entities spring up in their different living conditions, just as different types of vegetation grow after a rainfall. The rainfall is one, but the creation of the different vegetables is varied. The rain falls equally on the whole field, but the different vegetables sprout up in different shapes and different forms according to the seeds planted. Similarly, the seeds of our desires are varied. Every living entity has a different type of desire, and that desire is the seed which causes his growth in a certain type of body. This is explained by Rüpa Gosvämé by the word päpa-béja. Päpa means sinful. All our material desires are to be taken as päpa-béja, or the seeds of sinful desires. Bhagavad-gétä [7.15] explains that our sinful desire is that we do not surrender unto the Supreme Lord. The Lord therefore says in Bhagavad-gétä [18.66], 'I shall give you protection from the resultant actions of sinful desires.' These sinful desires are manifested in different types of bodies; therefore, no one can accuse the Supreme Lord of partiality in His giving one type of body to a certain type of living entity and another type of body to another living entity. All the bodies of the 8,400,000 species come according to the mental condition of the individual living entities. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Puruñottama, only gives them a chance to act according to their desires. Therefore, the living entities are acting, taking advantage of the facility given by the Lord.

"At the same time, they are born from the transcendental body of the Lord. This relationship between the Lord and the living entities is explained in the Vedic literatures, wherein it is said that the Supreme Lord maintains all His children, giving them whatever they want. Similarly, in the Bhagavad-gétä, the Lord says, 'I am the seed-giving father of all living entities.' It is very simple to understand that the father gives birth to the children, but the children act according to their own desires. Therefore the father is never responsible for the different futures of his children. Each child can take advantage of the father's property and instruction, but even though the inheritance and instruction may be the same for all the children, out of their different desires, each child creates a different life and thereby suffers or enjoys.

"Similarly, the Bhagavad-gétä's [9.29] instructions are equal for everyone; everyone should surrender unto the Supreme Lord, and He will take charge of them and protect them from sinful reactions. The facilities of living in the creation of the Lord are equally offered to all living entities. Whatever there is, either on the land, on water or in the sky, is equally given to all living entities. Since they are all sons of the Supreme Lord, everyone can enjoy the material facilities given by the Lord, but unfortunate living entities create unfavorable conditions of life by fighting among themselves. The responsibility for this fighting and creating favorable and unfavorable situations of life lies with the living entities, not with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore, if the living entities take advantage of the Lord's instructions as given in the Bhagavad-gétä and develop Kåñëa consciousness, then their lives become sublime, and they can go back to Godhead.

"One may argue that because this material world is created by the Lord, He is therefore responsible for its condition. Certainly He is indirectly responsible for the creation and maintenance of this material world, but He is never responsible for the different conditions of the living entities. The Lord's creation of this material world is compared to the cloud's creation of vegetation. In the rainy season the cloud creates different varieties of vegetables. The cloud pours water on the surface of the earth, but it never touches the earth directly. Similarly, the Lord creates this material world simply by glancing over the material energy. This is confirmed in the Vedas: He threw His glance over the material nature, and thus there was creation. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.10] it is also confirmed that simply by His transcendental glance over the material nature, He creates different varieties of entities, both movable and immovable, living and dead.

"The creation of the material world can therefore be taken as one of the pastimes of the Lord; it is called one of the pastimes of the Lord because He creates this material world whenever He desires. This desire of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is also extreme mercy on His part because it gives another chance to the conditioned souls to develop their original consciousness and thus go back to Godhead. Therefore no one can blame the Supreme Lord for creating this material world.

"From the subject matter under discussion, we can gain a clear understanding of the difference between the impersonalists and the personalists. The impersonal conception recommends merging in the existence of the Supreme, and the voidist philosophy recommends making all material varieties void. Both these philosophies are known as Mäyäväda. Certainly the cosmic manifestation comes to a close and becomes void when the living entities merge into the body of Näräyaëa to rest until another creation, and this may be called an impersonal condition, but these conditions are never eternal. The cessation of the variegatedness of the material world and the merging of the living entities into the body of the Supreme are not permanent because the creation will take place again, and the living entities who merge into the body of the Supreme without having developed their Kåñëa consciousness will again appear in this material world when there is another creation. The Bhagavad-gétä [9.10] confirms the fact that this material world is created and annihilated. This is going on perpetually, and conditioned souls who are without Kåñëa consciousness come back again and again whenever the material creation is manifest. If such conditioned souls take advantage of this opportunity and develop Kåñëa consciousness under the direct instruction of the Lord, then they are transferred to the spiritual world and do not have to come back again to the material creation. It is said, therefore, that the voidists and the impersonalists are not very intelligent because they do not take shelter under the lotus feet of the Lord. Because they are less intelligent, these voidists and impersonalists take to different types of austerities, either to attain the stage of nirväëa, which means finishing the material conditions of life, or to attain oneness by merging into the body of the Lord. All of them again fall down because they neglect the lotus feet of the Lord."

In the Caitanya-caritämåta, [Ädi 5.142] the author, Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämé, after studying all the Vedic literature and hearing from all authorities, has given his opinion that Kåñëa is the only supreme master and that all living entities are His eternal servants. His statement is confirmed in the prayers by the personified Vedas. The conclusion is, therefore, that everyone is under the control of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, everyone is serving under the supreme direction of the Lord, and everyone is afraid of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is out of fear of Him that activities are being rightly executed. Everyone's position is to be subordinate to the Supreme Lord, yet the Lord has no partiality in His view of the living entities. He is just like the unlimited sky; as the sparks of a fire dance in the fire, similarly, all living entities are like birds flying in the unlimited sky. Some of them are flying very high, some are flying at a lesser altitude, and some are flying at a still lesser altitude. The different birds are flying in different positions according to their respective abilities to fly, but the sky has nothing to do with this ability. In the Bhagavad-gétä [4.11] also, the Lord confirms that He awards different positions to different living entities according to their proportionate surrender. This proportionate reward by the Personality of Godhead to the living entities is not partiality. Therefore, in spite of the living entities' being situated in different positions, in different spheres, and in different species of life, all of them are always under the control of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and yet He is never responsible for their different living conditions. It is foolish and artificial, therefore, to think oneself equal to the Supreme Lord, and it is still more foolish to think that one has not seen God. Everyone is seeing God in His different aspects; the only difference is that the theist sees God as the Supreme Personality, the most beloved, Kåñëa, and the atheist sees the Absolute Truth as ultimate death.

The personified Vedas continued to pray. "Our dear Lord, from all Vedic information it is understood that You are the supreme controller, and all living entities are controlled. Both the Lord and the living entities are called nitya, eternal, and so are qualitatively one, yet the singular nitya, or the Supreme Lord, is the controller, whereas the plural nityas are controlled. The individual controlled living entity resides within the body, and the supreme controller, as Supersoul, is also present there, but the Supersoul is controlling the individual soul. That is the verdict of the Vedas. If the individual soul were not controlled by the Supersoul, then how could one explain the Vedic version that a living entity transmigrates from one body to another, enjoying and suffering the effects of his past deeds? Sometimes he is promoted to a higher standard of life, and sometimes he is degraded to a lower standard of life. Thus the conditioned souls are not only under the control of the Supreme Lord, but they are also conditioned by the control of the material nature. This relationship of the living entities to the Supreme Lord as the controlled and the controller definitely proves that although the Supersoul is all-pervasive, the individual living entities are never all-pervasive. If the individual souls were all-pervasive, there would be no question of their being controlled. The theory that the Supersoul and the individual soul are equal is therefore a polluted conclusion, and no sensible person accepts it; rather, one should try to understand the distinctions between the supreme eternal and the subordinate eternals."

The personified Vedas therefore concluded, "O Lord, both You and the limited dhruvas, the living entities, are eternal. The form of the unlimited eternal is sometimes calculated as the universal form, and in the Vedic literatures like the Upaniñads, the form of the limited eternal is vividly described. It is said therein that the original spiritual form of the living entity is one ten-thousandth the size of the tip of a hair. It is stated that the spirit is greater than the greatest and smaller than the smallest. The individual living entities, who are eternally part and parcel of God, are smaller than the smallest. With our material senses, we can perceive neither the Supreme, who is greater than the greatest, nor the individual soul, who is smaller than the smallest. We have to understand both the greatest and the smallest from the authoritative sources of Vedic literature. Vedic literature states that the Supersoul is sitting within the body of a living entity and is as big as a thumb. Therefore the argument may be put forward, how can something the size of a thumb be accommodated within the heart of an ant? The answer is that this thumb measurement of the Supersoul is imagined in proportion to the body of the living entity. In all circumstances, therefore, the Supersoul and the individual living entity cannot be taken as one, although both of them enter within the material body of a living entity. The Supersoul living within the heart is for directing or controlling the individual living entity. Although both are dhruva, or eternal, the living entity is always under the direction of the Supreme.

"It may be argued that because the living entities are born of the material nature, they are all equal and independent. In the Vedic literature, however, it is said that the Supreme Personality of Godhead impregnates the material nature with the living entities, and then they come out. Therefore, the appearance of the individual living entities is not factually due to material nature alone, just as a child produced by a woman is not her independent production. A woman is first impregnated by a man, and then a child is produced. As such, the child produced by the woman is part and parcel of the man. Similarly, the living entities are apparently produced by the material nature, but not independently. It is due to the impregnation of material nature by the supreme father that the living entities are present. Therefore the argument that the individual living entities are not part and parcel of the Supreme cannot stand. For example, the different parts and parcels of the body cannot be taken as equal to the whole; rather, the whole body is the controller of the different limbs. Similarly, the parts and parcels of the supreme whole are always dependent and are always controlled by the source of the parts and parcels. It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä that the living entities are part and parcel of Kåñëa: mamaiväàço. No sane man, therefore, will accept the theory that the Supersoul and the individual soul are of the same category. They are equal in quality, but quantitatively the Supersoul is always the Supreme, and the individual soul is always subordinate to the Supersoul. That is the conclusion of the Vedas."

Two significant words used in this connection are yanmaya and cinmaya. In Sanskrit grammar, the word mayat is used in the sense of transformation, and also in the sense of sufficiency. The Mäyävädé philosophers interpret that yanmaya or cinmaya indicates that the living entity is always equal to the Supreme. But one has to consider whether this affix, mayat, is used for sufficiency or for transformation. The living entity never possesses anything exactly in the same proportion as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore, this mayat affix cannot be used to mean that the individual living entity is self-sufficient. The individual living entity never has sufficient knowledge; otherwise, how could he have come under the control of maya, or the material energy? The word sufficient can be accepted, therefore, only in proportion to the magnitude of the living entity. The spiritual oneness of the Supreme Lord and the living entities is never to be accepted as homogeneity. Each and every living entity is individual. If homogenous oneness is accepted, then by the liberation of one individual soul, all other individual souls would have been liberated immediately. But the fact is that every individual soul is differently enjoying and suffering in the material world.

The word mayat is also used in the sense of transformation, or sometimes it is used to mean by-product. The impersonalist theory is that Brahman Himself has accepted different types of bodies and that this is His lélä or pastime. There are, however, many hundreds and thousands of species of life in different standards of living conditions, such as human beings, demigods, animals, birds and beasts, and if all of them were expansions of the Supreme Absolute Truth, then there would be no question of liberation because Brahman is already liberated. Another interpretation put forward by the Mäyävädés is that in every millennium different types of bodies are manifested, and when the millennium is closed, all the different bodies or expansions of Brahman automatically become one, ending all different manifestations. Then in the next millennium, according to this theory, Brahman again expands in different bodily forms. If we accept this theory, then Brahman becomes subject to change. But this cannot be accepted. From Vedänta-sütra we understand that Brahman is by nature joyful. He cannot, therefore, change Himself into a body which is subject to painful conditions. Actually, the living entities who are part and parcel of Brahman are infinitesimal particles prone to be covered by the illusory energy. As explained before, the particles of Brahman are like sparks blissfully dancing within a fire, but there is a chance of their falling from the fire to smoke, although smoke is another condition of fire. This material world is just like smoke, and the spiritual world is just like a blazing fire. The innumerable living entities are prone to fall down to the material world from the spiritual world when influenced by illusory energy, and it is also possible for the living entity to become liberated again when by cultivation of real knowledge he becomes completely freed from the contamination of the material world.

The theory of the asuras is that the living entities are born of material nature, or prakåti, in touch with the puruña. This theory also cannot be accepted because both the material nature and the Supreme Personality of Godhead are eternally existing. Neither the material nature nor the Supreme Personality of Godhead can be born. The Supreme Lord is known as aja, or unborn. Similarly, the material nature is also called ajä. Both these terms, aja and ajä, mean unborn. Because both the material nature and the Supreme Lord are unborn, it is not possible that they can beget the living entities. As water in contact with air sometimes presents innumerable bubbles, so a combination of material nature and the Supreme Person causes the appearence of the living entities within this material world. As bubbles in the water appear in different shapes, similarly the living entities also appear in the material world in different shapes and conditions, influenced by the modes of material nature. As such, it is not improper to conclude that the living entities appearing within this material world in different shapes, such as human beings, demigods, animals, birds, beasts, etc., all get their respective bodies due to different desires. No one can say when such desires were awakened in them, and therefore it is said, anädi-karma: the cause of such material existence is untraceable. No one knows when material life began, but it is a fact that it does have a point of beginning because originally every living entity is a spiritual spark. As sparks falling onto the ground from a fire have a beginning, similarly the living entities coming to this material world have a beginning, but no one can say when. Even during the time of dissolution, these living entities remain merged in the spiritual existence of the Lord, as if in deep sleep, but their original desires to lord it over the material nature do not subside. Again, when there is cosmic manifestation, they come out to fulfill the same desires, and therefore they appear in different species of life.

This merging into the Supreme at the time of dissolution is compared to honey. In the honeycomb, the taste of different flowers and fruits are conserved. When one drinks honey, one cannot distinguish what sort of honey has been collected from what sort of flower, but the palatable taste of the honey presupposes that the honey is not homogenous, but is a combination of different tastes. Another example is that although different rivers ultimately mix with the water of the sea, that does not mean that the individual identities of the rivers are thereby lost. Although the water of the Ganges and the Yamunä mixes with the water of the sea, the River Ganges and River Yamunä still continue to exist independently. The merging of different living entities into Brahman at the time of dissolution involves the dissolution of different types of bodies, but the living entities, along with their different tastes, remain individually submerged in Brahman until another manifestation of the material world. As the salty taste of sea water and the sweet taste of Ganges water are different, and this difference continually exists, so the difference between the Supreme Lord and the living entities continually exists, even though it appears that at the time of dissolution they merge. The conclusion is, therefore, that even when the living entities become free from all contamination of material conditions, they merge into the spiritual kingdom, but still their individual tastes in relationship with the Supreme Lord continue to exist.

The personified Vedas continued: "Our dear Lord, it is our conclusion that all living entities are attracted by Your material energy, and only due to their mistakenly identifying themselves as products of the material nature are they transmigrating from one kind of body to another in forgetfulness of their eternal relationship with You. Because of ignorance, these living entities are misidentifying themselves in different species of life, and especially when they are elevated to the human form of life, they identify with a particular class of men, or a particular nation or race or so-called religion, forgetting their real identity as eternal servants of Your Lordship. Due to this faulty conception of life, they are undergoing repeated birth and death. Out of many millions of them, if one becomes intelligent enough, by association with pure devotees, he comes to the understanding of Kåñëa consciousness and comes out of the jurisdiction of the material misconception."

In the Caitanya-caritämåta it is confirmed by Lord Caitanya that the living entities are wandering within this universe in different species of life, but if one of them becomes intelligent enough, by the mercy of the spiritual master and the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, then he begins his devotional life in Kåñëa consciousness. It is said, harià véëä na måtim taranti: without the help of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one cannot get out of the clutches of repeated birth and death. In other words, only the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, can relieve the conditioned souls from the cycle of repeated birth and death.

The personified Vedas continued: "The influence of time—past, present and future—and the material miseries, such as excessive heat, excessive cold, birth, death, old age, disease, are all simply the movement of Your eyebrows. Everything is working under Your direction. It is said in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.10] that all material activity is going on under the direction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. All the conditions of material existence are opposing elements for persons who are not surrendered unto You. But for those who are surrendered souls and are in full Kåñëa consciousness, these things cannot be a source of fearfulness. When Lord Nåsiàhadeva appeared, Prahläda Mahäräja was never afraid of Him, whereas his atheist father was immediately faced with death personified and was killed. Therefore, although Lord Nåsiàhadeva appears as death for an atheist like Hiraëyakaçipu, He is always kind and is the reservoir of all pleasure to the devotees like Prahläda. A pure devotee is not, therefore, afraid of birth, death, old age and disease.

Çrépäda Çrédhara Svämé has composed a nice verse, the purport of which is as follows: "My dear Lord, I am a living entity perpetually disturbed by the conditions of material existence. I have been cracked into different pieces by the smashing wheel of material existence, and because of my various sinful activities while existing in this material world, I am burning in the blazing fire of material reaction. Somehow or other, my dear Lord, I have come to take shelter under Your lotus feet. Please accept me and give me protection." Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkur also prays like this: "My dear Lord, O son of Nanda Mahäräja, associated with the daughter of Våñabhänu, I have come to take shelter under Your lotus feet after suffering greatly in the material condition of life, and I am praying that You please be merciful upon me. Please do not kick me away; I have no other shelter but You."

The conclusion is that any process of self-realization or God realization other than bhakti-yoga, or devotional service, is extremely difficult. Taking shelter of devotional service to the Lord in full Kåñëa consciousness is therefore the only way to become free from the contamination of material conditional life, especially in this age. Those who are not in Kåñëa consciousness are simply wasting their time, and they have no tangible proof of spiritual life.

It is said by Lord Rämacandra, "I always give confidence and security to anyone who surrenders unto Me and decides definitely that He is My eternal servant because that is My natural inclination." Similarly, Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.14], "The influence of the material nature is insurmountable, but anyone who surrenders unto Me can verily overcome the influence of material nature." The devotees are not at all interested in arguing with the nondevotees to nullify their theories. Rather than wasting their time, they always engage themselves in the transcendental loving service of the Lord in full Kåñëa consciousness.

The personified Vedas continued: "Our dear Lord, although great mystic yogés may have full control over the elephant of the mind and the hurricane of the senses, unless they take shelter of a bona fide spiritual master, they fall victims to the material influence and never become successful in their attempts at self-realization. Such unguided persons are compared to merchants going to sea on a ship without a captain. By his personal attempts, therefore, no one can get free from the clutches of material nature. One has to accept a bona fide spiritual master and work according to his direction. Then it is possible to cross over the nescience of material conditions. Çrépada Çrédhara Svämé has composed a nice verse in this connection, in which he says, "O all-merciful spiritual master, representative of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, when will my mind be completely surrendered unto your lotus feet? At that time, only by your mercy, I shall be able to get relief from all obstacles to spiritual life, and I shall be situated in blissful life."

Actually, ecstatic samädhi or absorption in the Supreme Personality of Godhead can be achieved by constant engagement in His service, and this constant engagement in devotional service can be performed only when one is working under the direction of a bona fide spiritual master. The Vedas therefore instruct that in order to know the science of devotional service, one has to submit himself unto the bona fide spiritual master. The bona fide spiritual master is he who knows the science of devotional service in disciplic succession. This disciplic succession is called çrotriyaà. The prime symptom of one who has become a spiritual master in disciplic succession is that he is one hundred percent fixed in bhakti-yoga. Sometimes people neglect to accept a spiritual master, and instead they endeavor for self-realization by mystic yoga practice, but there are many instances of failure, even by great yogés like Viçvämitra. Arjuna said in the Bhagavad-gétä [6.34] that controlling the mind is as impractical as stopping the blowing of a hurricane. Sometimes the mind is compared to a maddened elephant. Without following the direction of a spiritual master one cannot control the mind and the senses. In other words, if one practices yoga mysticism and does not accept a bona fide spiritual master, he will surely fail. He will simply waste his valuable time. The Vedic injunction is that no one can have full knowledge without being under the guidance of an äcärya. Äcäryavän puruño veda: one who has accepted an äcärya knows what is what. The Absolute Truth cannot be understood by arguments. One who has attained the perfect brahminical stage naturally becomes renounced; he does not strive for material gain because by spiritual knowledge he has come to the conclusion that in this world there is no insufficiency. Everything is sufficiently provided by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. A real brähmana, therefore, does not endeavor for material perfection; rather, he approaches a bona fide spiritual master to accept orders from him. A spiritual master's qualification is that he is brahmaniñöham, which means that he has given up all other activities and has dedicated his life to working only for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. When a bona fide student approaches a bona fide spiritual master, he submissively prays to the spiritual master, "My dear Lord, kindly accept me as your student and train me in such a way that I will be able to give up all other kinds of processes for self-realization and simply engage in Kåñëa consciousness, devotional service."

The devotee engaged by the direction of the spiritual master in the transcendental loving service of the Lord contemplates as follows: "My dear Lord, You are the reservoir of pleasure. Since You are present, what is the use of the transient pleasure derived from society, friendship and love? Persons who are unaware of the supreme reservoir of pleasure falsely engage in deriving pleasure from sense gratification, but this is transient and illusory." In this connection, Vidyäpati, a great Vaiñëava devotee and poet, says, "My dear Lord, undoubtedly there is some pleasure in the midst of society, friendship and love, although it is materially conceived, but such pleasure cannot satisfy my heart, which is like a desert." In a desert there is need of an ocean of water. But if only a drop of water is poured on the desert, what is the value of such water? Similarly, our material hearts are full of multi-desires, which cannot be fulfilled within the material society of friendship and love. When our hearts begin to derive pleasure from the supreme reservoir of pleasure, then we can be satisfied. That transcendental satisfaction is only possible in devotional service, in full Kåñëa consciousness.

The personified Vedas continued: "Our dear Lord, You are sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, the ever-blissful form of knowledge, and because the living entities are parts and parcels of Your personality, their natural state of existence is to be fully conscious of You. In this material world, anyone who has developed such Kåñëa consciousness is no longer interested in the materialistic way of life. A Kåñëa conscious being becomes disinterested in family life or opulent living conditions, and he requires only a little concession for his bodily needs. In other words, he is no longer interested in sense gratification. The perfection of human life is based on knowledge and renunciation, but it is very difficult to attempt to reach the stage of knowledge and renunciation while in family life. Kåñëa conscious persons therefore take shelter of the association of devotees or sanctified places of pilgrimage. Such persons are aware of the relationship between the Supersoul and the individual living entities, and they are never in the bodily concept of life. Because they always carry You in full consciousness within their hearts, they are so purified that any place they go becomes a holy place of pilgrimage, and the water which washes their feet is able to deliver many sinful persons hovering within this material world."

When Prahläda Mahäräja was asked by his atheistic father to describe something very good which he had learned, he replied to his father that for a materialistic person who is always full of anxieties due to being engaged in temporary and relative truths, the best course is to give up the blind well of family life and go to the forest to take shelter of the Supreme Lord. Those who are actually pure devotees are celebrated as mahätmäs, or great sages, personalities perfect in knowledge. They always think of the Supreme Lord and His lotus feet, and thus they become automatically liberated. Devotees who are always situated in that position become electrified by the inconceivable potencies of the Lord, and thus they themselves become the source of liberation for their followers and devotees. A Kåñëa conscious person is fully electrified spiritually, and therefore anyone who touches or takes shelter of such a pure devotee becomes similarly electrified with spiritual potencies. Such devotees are never puffed up with material opulences. Generally, the material opulences are good parentage, education, beauty and riches, but although a devotee of the Lord may possess all four of these material opulences, he is never carried away by the pride of possessing such distinctions. Great devotees of the Lord travel all over the world from one place of pilgrimage to another, and on their way they meet many conditioned souls and deliver them by their association and distribution of transcendental knowledge. They reside in places like Våndävana, Mathurä, Dvärakä, Jagannätha Puré and Navadvépa because only devotees assemble in such places. In this way they take advantage of saintly association, and by such association the devotees advance more and more in Kåñëa consciousness. Such advancement is not possible in ordinary household life which is devoid of Kåñëa consciousness.

The personified Vedas continue: "Our dear Lord, there are two classes of transcendentalists, the impersonalists and the personalists. The opinion of the impersonalists is that this material manifestation is false and that only the Absolute Truth is factual. The view of the personalist, however, is that the material world, although very temporary, is nevertheless not false, but is factual. Such transcendentalists have different arguments to establish the validity of their philosophies. Factually, the material world is simultaneously both truth and untruth. It is truth because everything is an expansion of the Supreme Absolute Truth, and it is untruth because the existence of the material world is temporary; it is created, and it is annihilated. Because of its different conditions of existence, the cosmic manifestation has no fixed position. Those who advocate acceptance of this material world as false are generally known by the maxim brahma satya jagan mithyä. They put forward the argument that everything in the material world is prepared from matter. For example, there are many things made of clay, such as earthen pots, dishes and balls. After their annihilation, these things may become transformed into many other material objects, but in all cases, their existence as clay continues. An earthen water jug, after being broken, may be transformed into a bowl or dish, but either as a dish, bowl or water jug, the earth itself continues to exist. Therefore, the forms of a water jug, bowl or dish are false, but their existence as earth is real. This is the impersonalists' version. This cosmic manifestation is certainly produced from the Absolute Truth, but because its existence is temporary, it is therefore false; the impersonalists' understanding is that the Absolute Truth, which is always present, is the only truth. In the opinion of other transcendentalists, however, this material world, being produced of the Absolute Truth, is also truth. The impersonalists' counter-argument is that the material world is not factual because sometimes it is found that matter is produced from spirit soul, and sometimes spirit soul is produced from matter. Such philosophers push forward the argument that although cow dung is dead matter, sometimes it is found that scorpions come out of cow dung. Similarly, dead matter like nails and hair comes out of the living body. Therefore, things produced of a certain thing are not always the same. On the strength of this argument, Mäyävädé philosophers establish that although this cosmic manifestation is certainly an emanation from the Absolute Truth, the cosmic manifestation does not necessarily have truth in it. According to this view, the Absolute Truth, Brahman, should therefore be accepted as truth, whereas the cosmic manifestation, although a product of the Absolute Truth, cannot be taken as truth.

The view of the Mäyävädé philosopher, however, is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [16.8] to be the view of the asuras, or demons. The Lord says in Bhagavad-gétä, asatyam apratiñöham te jagad ähur anéçvaram. The asuras' view of this cosmic manifestation is that the whole creation is false. The asuras think that the mere interaction of matter is the source of the creation, and there is no controller or God. But actually that is not the fact. From the Seventh Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä, we understand that the five gross elements—earth, water, air, fire and sky—plus the subtle elements—mind, intelligence and false ego—are the eight separated energies of the Supreme Lord. Beyond this inferior material energy, there is a spiritual energy, which is known as the living entities. The living entities are also accepted as the superior energy of the Lord. The whole cosmic manifestation is a combination of the inferior and superior energies, and the source of the energies is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Supreme Personality of Godhead has many different types of energies. That is confirmed in the Vedas: paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate. The transcendental energies of the Lord are variegated, and because such varieties have emanated from the Supreme Lord, they cannot be false. The Lord is ever-existing, and the energies are ever-existing. Some of the energy is temporary—sometimes manifested and sometimes unmanifested—but that does not mean that it is false. The example may be given that when a person is angry he does things which are different from his normal condition of life, but that the mood of anger only appears and disappears does not mean that the energy of anger is false. As such, the argument of the Mäyävädé philosophers that this world is false is not accepted by the Vaiñëava philosophers. It is confirmed by the Lord Himself that the view that there is no supreme cause of this material manifestation, that there is no God, and that everything is only the creation of the interaction of matter is a view of the asuras.

The Mäyävädé philosopher sometimes puts forward the argument of the snake and the rope. In the dark of evening, a curled up rope is sometimes, due to ignorance, taken for a snake. But mistaking the rope as a snake does not mean that the rope or the snake is false, and therefore this example, used by the Mäyävädés to illustrate the falsity of this material world, is not valid. When a thing is taken as fact but actually has no existence at all, it is called false. But if something is mistaken for something else, that does not mean that it is false. The Vaiñëava philosophers use a very appropriate example comparing this material world to an earthen pot. When we see an earthen pot, it does not at once disappear and turn into something else. It may be temporary, but the earthen pot is taken into use for bringing water, and we continue to see it as an earthen pot. Therefore, although the earthen pot is temporary and is different from the original earth, still we cannot say that it is false. We should therefore conclude that the entire earth and the earthen pot are both truths because one is the product of the other. We understand from Bhagavad-gétä that after the dissolution of this cosmic manifestation, the energy enters into the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is ever-existing with His varied energies. Because the material creation is an emanation from Him, we cannot say that this cosmic manifestation is a product of something void. Kåñëa is not void. Whenever we speak of Kåñëa, He is present with His form, quality, name, entourage and paraphernalia. Therefore, Kåñëa is not impersonal. The original cause of everything is neither void nor impersonal, but is the Supreme Person. Demons may say that this material creation is anéçvara, without a controller or God, but such arguments ultimately cannot stand.

The example given by the Mäyävädé philosophers that inanimate matter like nails and hair comes out from the living body is not a very sound argument. Nails and hair are undoubtedly inanimate, but they come not from the animate living being, but from the inanimate material body. Similarly, the argument that the scorpion comes from cow dung, meaning that a living entity comes from matter, is also not sound. The scorpion which comes out of the cow dung is certainly a living entity, but the living entity does not come out of the cow dung. Only the living entity's material body, or the body of the scorpion, comes out of the cow dung. The sparks of the living entity, as we understand from Bhagavad-gétä [14.3], are impregnated within material nature, and then they come out. The body of the living entity in different forms is supplied by material nature, but the living entity himself is begotten by the Supreme Lord. The father and the mother give the body which is necessary for the living entity under certain conditions. The living entity transmigrates from one body to another according to his different desires. The desires in the subtle form of intelligence, mind and false ego accompany the living entity from body to body, and by superior arrangement a living entity is put into the womb of a certain type of material body, and then he develops a similar body. Therefore, the spirit soul is not produced from matter, but it takes on a particular type of body under superior arrangement. To our present experience, this material world is a combination of matter and spirit. The spirit is moving the matter. The spirit soul (the living entity) and matter are different energies of the Supreme Lord. Since both the energies are products of the supreme eternal or the supreme truth, they are therefore factual; they are not false. Because the living entity is part and parcel of the Supreme, he is existing eternally. Therefore, there cannot be any question of birth or death. So-called birth and death occur because of the material body. The Vedic version sarvaà khalv idaà brahma means that since both the energies have emanated from the Supreme Brahman, everything that we experience is not different from Brahman.

There are many arguments about the existence of this material world, but the Vaiñëava philosophical conclusion is the best. The example of the earthen pot is very suitable: the form of the earthen pot may be temporary, but it has a specific purpose. The purpose of the earthen pot is to carry water from one place to another. Similarly, this material body, although temporary, has a special use. The living entity is given a chance from the beginning of the creation to evolve different kinds of material bodies according to the reserve desires he has accumulated from time immemorial. The human form of body is a special chance in which the developed form of consciousness can be utilized.

Sometimes the Mäyävädé philosophers push forward the argument that if this material world is truth, then why are householders advised to give up their connection with this material world and take sannyäsa? But the Vaiñëava philosopher's view of sannyäsa is not that because the world is false, one must therefore give up material activities. The purpose of Vaiñëava sannyäsa is to utilize things as they are intended. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has given two formulas for our dealing with this material world. When a Vaiñëava renounces this materialistic way of life and takes to sannyäsa, it is not on the conception of the falsity of the material world, but to devote himself fully to engaging everything in the service of the Lord. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé therefore gives this formula: one should be unattached to the material world because material attachment is meaningless. The entire material world, the entire cosmic manifestation, belongs to God, Kåñëa. Therefore, everything should be utilized for Kåñëa, and the devotee should remain unattached to material things. This is the purpose of Vaiñëava sannyäsa. A materialist sticks to the world for sense gratification, but a Vaiñëava sannyäsé, although not accepting anything for his personal sense gratification, knows the art of utilizing everything for the service of the Lord. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has therefore criticized the Mäyävädé sannyäsés because they do not know that everything has a utilization for the service of the Lord. On the contrary, they take the world to be false and thus falsely think of being liberated from the contamination of the material world. Since everything is an expansion of the energy of the Supreme Lord, the expansions are as real as the Supreme Lord is.

That the cosmic world is only temporarily manifested does not mean that it is false or that the source of its manifestation is false. Since the source of its manifestation is truth, the manifestation is also truth, but one must know how to utilize it. The same example can be cited: the temporary earthen pot is produced from the whole earth, but when it is utilized for a proper purpose, the earthen pot is not false. The Vaiñëava philosophers know how to utilize the temporary construction of this material world, just as a sane man knows how to utilize the temporary construction of the earthen pot. When the earthen pot is utilized for a wrong purpose, that is false. Similarly, this human form of body, or this material world, when utilized for false sense gratification, is false. But if this human form of body and the material creation are utilized for the service of the Supreme Lord, their activities are never false. It is therefore confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.40] that a little service attitude in utilizing this body and the material world for the service of the Lord can deliver a person from the gravest danger of life. When they are properly utilized, neither the superior nor inferior energies emanating from the Supreme Personality of Godhead are false. As far as fruitive activities are concerned, they are mainly based on the platform of sense gratification. Therefore an advanced Kåñëa conscious person does not take to them. The result of fruitive activities can elevate one to the higher planetary system, but as it is said in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.21], foolish persons, after exhausting the results of their pious activities in the heavenly kingdom, come back again to this lower planetary system and then again try to go to the higher planetary system. Their only profit is to take the trouble of going and coming back, just as at present many material scientists are spoiling their time by trying to go to the moon planet and again come back. Those who are engaged in such activities are described by the Vedas personified as andha-paramparä, or blind followers of the Vedic ritualistic ceremonies. Although such ceremonies are certainly mentioned in the Vedas, they are not meant for the intelligent class of men. Men who are too much attached to material enjoyment are captivated by the prospect of being elevated to the higher planetary systems, and so they take to such ritualistic activities. But a person who is intelligent, or who has taken shelter of a bona fide spiritual master to see things as they are, does not take to fruitive activities, but engages himself in the transcendental loving service of the Lord.

Persons who are not devotees take to the Vedic ritualistic ceremonies for materialistic reasons, and then they are bewildered. A vivid example can be given: an intelligent person possessing millions of dollars in currency notes does not hold the money without using it, even though he knows perfectly well that the currency notes in themselves are nothing but paper. When one has one million dollars in currency notes, he is actually holding only a huge bunch of papers, but if he utilizes it for a purpose, then he benefits. Similarly, although this material world may be false, just like the paper, it has its proper beneficial utilization. Because the currency notes, although paper, are issued by the government, they therefore have full value. Similarly, this material world may be false or temporary, but because it is an emanation from the Supreme Lord, it has its full value. The Vaiñëava philosopher acknowledges the full value of this material world and knows how to properly utilize it, whereas the Mäyävädé philosopher, mistaking the currency note for false paper, gives it up and cannot utilize the money. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé therefore declares that if one rejects this material world as false, not considering the importance of this material world as a means to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead, such renunciation has very little value. A person who knows the intrinsic value of this material world for the service of the Lord, who is not attached to the material world, and who renounces the material world by not accepting it for sense gratification is situated in real renunciation. This material world is an expansion of the material energy of the Lord. Therefore it is real. It is not false, as it is sometimes concluded from the example of the snake and the rope.

The personified Vedas continued: "The cosmic manifestation, because of the flickering nature of its impermanent existence, appears to less intelligent men to be false." The Mäyävädé philosophers take advantage of the flickering nature of this cosmic manifestation to prove their thesis that this world is false. According to the Vedic version, before the creation this world had no existence, and after dissolution the world will no longer be manifested. Voidists also take advantage of this Vedic version and conclude that the cause of this material world is void. But Vedic injunction does not say that it is void. The Vedic injunction defines the source of creation and dissolution as yato vä imäni bhütäni jäyante, "He from whom this cosmic manifestation has emanated and in whom, after annihilation, everything will merge." The same is explained in the Vedänta-sütra and in the first verse of the First Chapter of Çrémad-Bhägavatam by the words janmädyasya, He from whom all things emanate. All these Vedic injunctions indicate that the cosmic manifestation is due to the Supreme Absolute Personality of Godhead, and when it is dissolved it merges into Him. The same is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [8.18-21]: this cosmic manifestation is coming into existence and again dissolving, and after dissolution it merges into the existence of the Supreme Lord. This statement definitely confirms that the particular energy known as bahi-raìgä-mäyä, or the external energy, although of flickering nature, is the energy of the Supreme Lord, and as such it cannot be false. It simply appears to be false. The Mäyävädé philosophers conclude that because the material nature has no existence in the beginning and is nonexistent after dissolution, it is therefore false. But by the example of the earthen pots and dishes the Vedic version is presented: although the existence of the particular by-products of the Absolute Truth are temporary, the energy of the Supreme Lord is permanent. The earthen pot or water jug may be broken or transformed into another shape, such as that of a dish or bowl, but the ingredient, or the material basis, namely the earth, continues to be the same. The basic principle of this cosmic manifestation is always the same, Brahman, or the Absolute Truth; therefore, the Mäyävädé philosophers' theory that it is false is certainly only mental concoction. That the cosmic manifestation is flickering and temporary does not mean that it is false. The definition of falsity is that which never had any existence but is existing only in name. For instance, the eggs of a horse or the flower of the sky or the horn of a rabbit are phenomena which exist only in name. There are no horse's eggs, there is no rabbit's horn, nor are there flowers growing in the sky. There are many things which exist in name or imagination but actually have no factual manifestation. Such things can be called false. But the Vaiñëava cannot take this material world to be false simply because its temporary nature is manifesting and again dissolving.

The personified Vedas continued to say that the Supersoul and the individual soul, or Paramätmä and jévätmä, cannot be equal in any circumstance, although both of them are sitting within the same body, like two birds sitting in the same tree. As declared in the Vedas, these two birds, although sitting as friends, are not equal. One is simply a witness. This bird is Paramätmä, or the Supersoul. And the other bird is eating the fruit of the tree. That is jévätmä. When there is cosmic manifestation, the jévätmä, or the individual soul, appears in the creation in different forms, according to his previous fruitive activities, and due to his long forgetfulness of real existence, he identifies himself with a particular form awarded to him by the laws of material nature. After assuming a material form, he becomes subjected to the three material modes of nature and acts accordingly to continue his existence in the material world. While enwrapped in such ignorance, his natural opulences, although existing in minute quantity, are almost extinct. The opulences of the Supersoul, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead, however, are not diminished, although He appears within this material world. He maintains all opulences and perfections in full and yet keeps Himself apart from all the tribulations of this material world. The conditioned soul becomes entrapped in the material world, whereas the Supersoul, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead, leaves it without affection, just as a snake sheds his skin. The distinction between the Supersoul and the conditioned individual soul is that the Supersoul, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead, maintains His natural opulences, known as ñaò-aiçvarya, añöa-siddhi and añöa-guëa.

Because of their poor fund of knowledge, the Mäyävädé philosophers forget the fact that Kåñëa is always full of six opulences, eight transcendental qualities and eight kinds of perfection. The six opulences are that no one is greater than Kåñëa in wealth, in strength, in beauty, in fame, in knowledge and in renunciation. The first of Kåñëa's six transcendental qualities is that He is always untouched by the contamination of material existence. This is also mentioned in the Éçopaniñad: apäpa-viddham: just as the sun is never polluted by any contamination, the Supreme Lord is never polluted by any sinful activities. Similarly, although Kåñëa's actions might sometimes seem to be impious, He is never polluted by such actions. The second transcendental quality is that Kåñëa never dies. In the Bhagavad-gétä, Fourth Chapter, He informs Arjuna that both He and Arjuna had many appearances in this material world, but He alone remembers all such activities—past, present and future. This means that He never dies. Forgetfulness is due to death. As we die, we change our bodies. That is forgetfulness. Kåñëa, however, is never forgetful. He can remember everything that has happened in the past. Otherwise, how could He remember that He first taught the Bhagavad-gétä yoga system to the sun-god, Vivasvän? Therefore, He never dies. Nor does He ever become an old man. Although Kåñëa was a great-grandfather when He appeared on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra, He did not appear as an old man. Kåñëa cannot be polluted by any sinful activities, Kåñëa never dies, Kåñëa never becomes old, Kåñëa never becomes subjected to any lamentation, Kåñëa is never hungry, and He is never thirsty. Whatever He desires is perfectly lawful, and whatever He decides cannot be changed by anyone. These are the transcendental qualities of Kåñëa. Besides that, Kåñëa is known as Yogeçvara. He has all the opulences or facilities of mystic powers, such as aëima-siddhi, the power to become smaller than the smallest. It is stated in the Brahma-saàhitä that Kåñëa has entered even within the atom, aëòäntarastha-paramäëu-cayäntarastham. Similarly, Kåñëa, as Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu, is within the gigantic universe, and He is lying in the Causal Ocean as Mahä-Viñëu in a body so gigantic that when He exhales, millions and trillions of universes emanate from His body. This is called mahima-siddhi. Kåñëa also has the perfection of laghimä: He can become the lightest. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.13] that it is because Kåñëa enters within this universe and within the atoms that all the planets are floating in the air. That is the explanation of weightlessness. Kåñëa also has the perfection of präpti: He can get whatever He likes. Similarly, He has the facility of éçitä, controlling power. He is called the supreme controller, Parameçvara. In addition, Kåñëa can bring anyone under His influence. This is called vaçitä.

Kåñëa is endowed with all opulences, transcendental qualities and mystic powers. No ordinary living being can be compared to Him. Therefore, the Mäyävädés' theory that the Supersoul and the individual soul are equal is only a misconception. The conclusion is, therefore, that Kåñëa is worshipable and that all other living entities are simply His servants. This understanding is called self-realization. Any other realization of one's self beyond this relationship of eternal servitorship of Kåñëa is impelled by mäyä. It is said that the last snare of mäyä is to dictate to the living entity to try to become equal to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Mäyävädé philosopher claims to be equal to God, but he cannot reply to the question of why he has fallen into material entanglement. If He is the Supreme God, then how is it that he has been overtaken by impious activities and thereby subjected to the tribulations of the law of karma? When the Mäyävädés are asked about this, they cannot properly answer. The speculation that one is equal to the Supreme Personality of Godhead is another symptom of sinful life. One cannot take to Kåñëa consciousness unless he is completely freed from all sinful activities. The very fact that the Mäyävädé claims to become one with the Supreme Lord means that he is not yet freed from the reactions of sinful activities. Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.2.3] says that such persons are aviçuddha-buddhayä, which means that they falsely think themselves liberated, although at the same time they think themselves equal with the Absolute Truth. Their intelligence is not purified.

The personified Vedas said that if the yogés and the jïänés do not free themselves from sinful desires, then their particular process of self-realization will never be successful. "My dear Lord," the personified Vedas continued, "if saintly persons do not take care to eradicate completely the roots of sinful desires, they cannot experience the Supersoul, although He is sitting side by side with the individual soul. Samädhi, or meditation, means that one has to find the Supersoul within himself. One who is not free from sinful reactions cannot see the Supersoul. If a person has a jeweled locket in his necklace but forgets the jewel, it is almost as though he does not possess it. Similarly, if an individual soul meditates but does not actually perceive the presence of the Supersoul within himself, he has not realized the Supersoul. Persons who have taken to the path of self-realization must therefore be very careful to be uncontaminated by the influence of mäyä. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that a devotee should be completely free from all sorts of material desires. A devotee should not be affected by the resultant actions of karma and jïäna. One simply has to understand Kåñëa and carry out His desires. That is the pure devotional stage. Mystic yogés who still have contaminated desires for sense gratification never become successful in their attempt, nor can they realize the Supersoul within the individual self. As such, the so-called yogés and jïänés who are simply wasting their time in different types of sense gratification, either by mental speculation or by exhibition of limited mystic powers, will never become liberated from conditional life and will continue to go through repeated births and deaths. For such persons, both this life and the next life becomes sources of tribulation. Such sinful persons are already suffering tribulation in this life, and because they are not perfect in self-realization, they will be plagued with further tribulation in the next life. Despite all endeavors to attain perfection, such yogés, contaminated by desires for sense gratification, will continue to suffer in this life and in the next.

Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur remarks in this connection that if sannyäsés and persons in the renounced order of life who have left their homes for self-realization do not engage themselves in the devotional service of the Lord but become attracted by philanthropic work, such as opening educational institutions, hospitals, or even monastaries, churches or temples of demigods, they find only trouble from such engagements, not only in this life but in the next. Sannyäsés who do not take advantage of this life to realize Kåñëa simply waste their time and energy in activities outside the jurisdiction of the renounced order of life. A devotee's attempt to engage his energies in such activities as constructing a Viñëu temple is, however, never wasted. Such engagements are called Kåñëärthe akhila-ceñöä, variegated activities performed to please Kåñëa. A philanthropist's opening a school building and a devotee's constructing a temple are not on the same level. Although a philanthropist's opening an educational institution may be pious activity, it comes under the laws of karma, whereas constructing a temple for Viñëu is devotional service.

Devotional service is never within the jurisdiction of the law of karma. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that devotees transcend the reaction of the three modes of material nature and stand on the platform of Brahman realization: brahma-bhüyäya kalpate. The Bhagavad-gétä says, sa guëän samatityaitän brahma-bhüyäya: kalpate: devotees of the Personality of Godhead transcend all the reactions of the three modes of material nature and are situated on the transcendental Brahman platform. The devotees are liberated both in this life and in the next life. Any work done in this material world for Yajïa or Viñëu or Kåñëa is considered to be liberated work, but without connection with Acyuta, the infallible Supreme Personality of Godhead, there is no possibility of stopping the resultant actions of the law of karma. The life of Kåñëa consciousness is the life of liberation. The conclusion is that a devotee, by the grace of the Lord, is liberated, both in this life and the next, whereas karmés, jïänés and yogés are never liberated, either in this life or in the next.

The personified Vedas continued: "Dear Lord, anyone who, by Your grace, has understood the glories of Your lotus feet is callous to material happiness and distress. The material pangs are inevitable as long as we are existing within the material world, but a devotee does not divert his attention to such actions and reactions, which are the result of pious and impious activities. Nor is a devotee very much disturbed or pleased by praise or condemnation by the people in general. A devotee is sometimes greatly praised by the people in general because of his transcendental activities, and sometimes he is criticized, even though there is no reason for adverse criticism. The pure devotee is always callous to praise or condemnation by the ordinary people. Actually, the devotee's activities are on the transcendental plane. He is not interested in the praise or condemnation of people engaged in material activities. If the devotee can thus maintain his transcendental position, then his liberation in this life and in the next life is guaranteed by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. A devotee's transcendental position within this material world is maintained in the association of pure devotees, simply by hearing the glorious activities enacted by the Lord in different ages and in different incarnations."

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is based on this principle. Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkur has sung, "My dear Lord, let me be engaged in Your transcendental loving service, as indicated by the previous äcäryas, and let me live in the association of pure devotees. That is my desire, life after life." In other words, a devotee does not much care whether or not he is liberated, but he is anxious only for devotional service. Devotional service means that one does not do anything independently of the sanction of the äcäryas. The actions of the Kåñëa consciousness movement are directed by the previous äcäryas, headed by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé; in the association of devotees following these principles, a devotee is able to perfectly maintain his transcendental position.

In the Bhagavad-gétä, the Lord says that a devotee who knows Him perfectly is very dear to Him. Four kinds of pious men take to devotional service. If a man is pious, then in his distressed condition he approaches the Lord for mitigation of his distress. If a pious man is in need of material help, he also prays to the Lord for such help. If a pious man is actually inquisitive about the science of God, he also approaches the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. Similarly, a pious man who is simply anxious to know the science of Kåñëa also approaches the Supreme Lord. Out of these four classes of men, the last is praised by Kåñëa Himself in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.17]. A person who tries to understand Kåñëa with full knowledge and devotion by following in the footsteps of previous äcäryas conversant with the scientific knowledge of the Supreme Lord is praiseworthy. Such a devotee can understand that all conditions of life, favorable and unfavorable, are created by the supreme will of the Lord. And when he has fully surrendered unto the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord, he does not care whether his condition of life is favorable or unfavorable. A devotee takes even an unfavorable condition to be the special favor of the Personality of Godhead. Actually, there are no unfavorable conditions for a devotee. He sees everything coming by the will of the Lord as favorable, and in any condition of life he is simply enthusiastic to discharge his devotional service. This devotional attitude is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.54]: a devotee is never distressed in reverse conditions of life, nor is he overjoyed in favorable conditions. In the higher stages of devotional service, a devotee is not even concerned with the list of do's and do not's. Such a position can be maintained only by following in the footsteps of the äcäryas. Because a pure devotee follows in the footsteps of the äcäryas, any action he performs to discharge devotional service is to be understood to be on the transcendental platform. Lord Kåñëa therefore instructs us that an äcärya is above criticism. A neophyte devotee should not consider himself to be on the same plane as the äcärya. It should be accepted that the äcäryas are on the same platform as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and as such, neither Kåñëa nor His representative äcärya should be subject to any adverse criticism by the neophyte devotees.

The personified Vedas thus worshiped the Supreme Personality of Godhead in different ways. Offering worship to the Supreme Lord by praying means remembering His transcendental qualities, pastimes and activities. But the Lord's pastimes and qualities are unlimited. It is not possible for us to remember all the qualities of the Lord. Therefore, the personified Vedas worshiped to the best of their ability, and at the end they spoke as follows.

"Our dear Lord, although Lord Brahmä, the predominating deity of the highest planet, Brahmäloka, and King Indra, the predominating demigod of the heavenly planet, as well as the predominating deities of the sun planet, the moon planet, etc., are all very confidential directors of this material world, they have very little knowledge about You. Then what to speak of ordinary human beings and mental speculators? It is not possible for anyone to enumerate the unlimited transcendental qualities of Your Lordship. No one, including the mental speculators and the demigods in higher planetary systems, is actually able to estimate the length and breadth of Your form and characteristics. We think that even Your Lordship does not have complete knowledge of Your transcendental qualities. The reason is that You are unlimited. Although it is not befitting in Your case to say that You do not know Yourself, it is nevertheless practical to understand that because You have unlimited qualities and energies and because Your knowledge is also unlimited, there is unlimited competition between Your knowledge and Your expansion of energies."

The idea is that because God and His knowledge are both unlimited, as soon as God is cognizant of some of His energies, He perceives that He has still more energies. In this way, both His energies and His knowledge increase. Because both of them are unlimited, there is no end to the energies and no end to the knowledge with which to understand the energies. God is undoubtedly omniscient, but the personified Vedas say that even God Himself does not know the full extent of His energies. This does not mean that God is not omniscient. When an actual fact is unknown to a certain person, this is called ignorance or lack of knowledge. This is not applicable to God, however, because He knows Himself perfectly, but still His energies and activities increase. Therefore He also increases His knowledge to understand it. Both are increasing unlimitedly, and there is no end to it. In that sense it can be said that even God Himself does not know the limit of His energies and qualities.

How God is unlimited in His expansion of energies and activities can be roughly calculated by any sane and sober living entity. It is said in the Vedic literature that innumerable universes issue forth when Mahä-Viñëu exhales in His yoga-nidrä, and innumerable universes enter His body when He again inhales. We have to imagine that these universes, which, according to our limited knowledge, are expanded unlimitedly, are so great that the gross ingredients, the five elements of the cosmic manifestation, namely earth, water, fire, air and sky, are not only within the universe, but are covering the universe in seven layers, each layer ten times bigger than the previous one. In this way, each and every universe is very securely packed, and there are numberless universes. All these universes are floating within the innumerable pores of the transcendental body of Mahä-Viñëu. It is stated that just as the atoms and particles of dust are floating within the air along with the birds and their number cannot be calculated, so innumerable universes are floating within the pores of the transcendental body of the Lord. For this reason, the Vedas say that God is beyond the capacity of our knowledge. Abäìmanasagocara: to understand the length and breadth of God is beyond the jurisdiction of our mental speculation. Therefore, a person who is actually learned and sane does not claim to be God, but tries to understand God, making distinctions between spirit and matter. By such careful discrimination, one can clearly understand that the Supreme Soul is transcendental to both the superior and inferior energies, although He has a direct connection with both. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.4], Lord Kåñëa explains that although everything is resting on His energy, He is different or separate from the energy.

Nature and the living entities are sometimes designated as prakåti and puruña respectively. The whole cosmic manifestation is an amalgamation of the prakåti and puruña. Nature is the ingredient cause, and the living entities are the effective cause. These two causes combine together, and the effect is this cosmic manifestation. When one is fortunate enough to come to the right conclusion about this cosmic manifestation and everything which is going on within it, he knows it to be caused directly and indirectly by the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself. It is concluded in the Brahma-saàhitä, therefore, éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù anädir ädir govindaù sarva-käraëa-käraëam.

After much deliberation and consideration, when one has attained the perfection of knowledge, he comes to the conclusion that Kåñëa, or God, is the original cause of all causes. Instead of speculating about the measurement of God—whether He is so long or so wide—or philosophizing, one should come to the conclusion of Brahma-saàhitä: sarva-käraëa-käraëam: "Kåñëa, or God, is the cause of all causes." That is the perfection of knowledge.

Thus the Veda-stuti, or the prayers offered by the personified Vedas to the Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu, were first narrated in disciplic succession by Sanandana to his brothers, all of whom were born of Brahmä. In the beginning the four Kumäras were the first-born of Brahmä; therefore they are known as pürva-jäta. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.1] that the paramparä system, or the disciplic succession, begins with Kåñëa Himself. Similarly, here, in the prayers of the personified Vedas, it is to be understood that the paramparä system begins with the Personality of Godhead Näräyaëa Åñi. We should remember that this Veda-stuti is being narrated by Kumära Sanandana, and the narration is being repeated by Näräyaëa Åñi in Bodi Äçrama. Näräyaëa Åñi is the incarnation of Kåñëa for showing us the path of self-realization by undergoing severe austerities. In this age Lord Caitanya demonstrated the path of pure devotional service by putting Himself in the role of a pure devotee. Similarly, in the past Lord Näräyaëa Åñi was an incarnation of Kåñëa who performed severe austerities in the Himalayan ranges. Çré Närada Muni was hearing from Him. So in the statement given by Näräyaëa Åñi to Närada Muni, as it was narrated by Kumära Sanandana in the form of Veda-stuti, it is understood that God is the one supreme and that all others are His servants.

In the Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 5.142] it is stated, ekalä éçvara kåñëa: "Kåñëa is the only Supreme God." Ära sava bhåtya: "All others are His servants." Yäre yaiche näcäya, se taiche kare nåtya: "The Supreme Lord, as He desires, is engaging all the living entities in different activities, and thus they are exhibiting their different talents and tendencies." This Veda-stuti is thus the original instruction regarding the relationship existing between the living entity their different talents and tendencies." This Veda-stuti is thus the original instruction regarding the relationship existing between the living entity and the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The highest platform of realization for the living entity is the attainment of this devotional life. One cannot be engaged in devotional life or Kåñëa consciousness unless he is fully free from material contamination. Näräyaëa Åñi informed Närada Muni that the essence of all Vedas and Vedic literatures (namely, the four Vedas, the Upaniñads, the Puräëas) teaches the rendering of transcendental loving service to the Lord. In this connection Näräyaëa Åñi has used one particular word—rasa. In devotional service this rasa is the via media or the basic principle for exchanging a relationship between the Lord and the living entity. A rasa is also described in the Vedas as éçäväsya: "The Supreme Lord is the reservoir of all pleasure." All the Vedic literatures, the Puräëas, the Vedas, the Upaniñads, the Vedänta-sütras, etc., are teaching the living entities how to attain the stage of rasa. The Bhägavatam also says that the statements in the Mahäpuräëa (Çrémad-Bhägavatam) contain the essence of rasas in all Vedic literatures. Nigama-kalpa-taror galitaà phalaà. The Bhägavatam is the essence of the ripen fruit in the tree of the Vedic literature.

We understand that with the breathing of the Supreme Personality of Godhead there issued forth the four Vedas, namely the Åg-veda, the Säma-veda, Yajur-veda, and the Atharva-veda, and the histories like the Mahäbhärata and all the Puräëas, which are also considered to be the history of the world. The Vedic histories like the Puräëas and Mahäbhärata are called the fifth Veda.

The verses of Veda-stuti are to be considered the essence of all Vedic knowledge. The four Kumäras and all other authorized sages know perfectly that devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness is the essence of all Vedic literatures, and they are preaching this in different planets, traveling in outer space. It is stated herein that such sages, including Närada Muni, hardly ever travel on land; they are perpetually traveling in space.

Sages like Närada and the Kumäras travel throughout the universe in order to educate the conditioned souls and show them that their business in the world is not that of sense gratification, but of reinstating themselves again in their original position of devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is stated in several places that the living entities are like sparks of the fire, and the Supreme Personality of Godhead is like the fire itself. Somehow or other when the sparks fall out of the fire they lose their natural illumination; thus it is ascertained that the living entities come into this material world exactly as sparks fall from a great fire. The reason for this fall, as stated by the Gosvämés, is sense gratification. The living entity wants to imitate Kåñëa and tries to lord it over material nature; thus he forgets his original position, and his illuminating power, his spiritual identity, is extinguished. However, if a living entity takes to Kåñëa consciousness, he is reinstated in his original position. Sages and saints like Närada and the Kumäras are traveling all over the universe educating people and encouraging their disciples to preach this process of devotional service so that all the conditioned souls may be able to revive their original consciousness, or Kåñëa consciousness, and thus gain relief from the miserable conditions of material life.

Çré Närada Muni is naiñöika-brahmacäré. There are four types of brahmacäré, and the first is called sävitra, which refers to a brahmacäré who, after initiation and the sacred thread ceremony, must observe at least three days celibacy. The next is called präjäpatya, which refers to a brahmacäré who strictly observes celibacy for at least one year after initiation. The next is called brähma-brahmacäré, which refers to a brahmacäré who observes celibacy from the time of initiation up to the time of the completion of his study of Vedic literature. The next stage is called naiñöika, which refers to a brahmacäré who is celibate throughout his whole life. Out of these, the first three are upakurväna, which means that the brahmacäré can marry later on after the brahmacäré period is over. The naiñöika-brahmacäré is completely reluctant to have any sex life; therefore the Kumäras and Närada are known as naiñöika-brahmacärés. The brahmacäré system of life is especially advantageous in that it increases the power of memory and determination. It is specifically mentioned in this connection that because Närada was naiñöika-brahmacäré he could remember whatever he heard from his spiritual master and would never forget it. One who can remember everything perpetually is called çruta-dhara. A çruta-dhara brahmacäré can repeat all that he has heard verbatim without notes and without reference to books. The great sage Närada has this qualification, and therefore, taking instruction from Näräyaëa Åñi, he is engaged in propagating the philosophy of devotional service all over the world. Because such great sages can remember everything, they are very much thoughtful, self-realized and completely fixed in the service of the Lord. Thus the great sage Närada, after hearing from his spiritual master Näräyaëa Åñi, became completely realized. He became established in the truth, and he became so happy that he offered the following prayers to Näräyaëa Åñi.

A naiñöhika-brahmacäré is also called véra-vrata. Närada Muni addressed Näräyaëa Åñi as an incarnation of Kåñëa, and he specifically addressed him as the supreme well-wisher of the conditioned souls. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.8] that Lord Kåñëa descends in every millennium just to give protection to His devotees and to annihilate the nondevotees. Näräyaëa Åñi, also being an incarnation of Kåñëa, is also addressed as the well-wisher of the conditioned souls. As is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.29], everyone should know that there is no well-wisher like Kåñëa. Everyone should understand that Lord Kåñëa is the well-wisher of everyone and should take shelter unto Kåñëa. In this way one can become completely confident and satisfied knowing that he has someone who is able to give him all protection. Kåñëa Himself, His incarnations and His plenary expansions are all supreme well-wishers of the conditioned souls, but Kåñëa is the well-wisher even for the demons, for He gave salvation to all demons who came to kill Him at Våndävana; therefore Kåñëa’s welfare activities are absolute, for even though He annihilates a demon or gives protection to a devotee, His activities are one and the same. It is said that the demon Pütanä was elevated to the same position as Kåñëa’s mother. When Kåñëa kills a demon it should be known that the demon is supremely benefitted by this; however, a pure devotee is always protected by the Lord.

Närada Muni, after offering respects to his spiritual master, went to the äçrama of Vyäsadeva and narrated the entire story to his disciple. Thus Närada Muni, being properly received by Vyäsadeva in his äçrama and seated very comfortably, began to narrate what he had heard from Näräyaëa Åñi. In this way Çukadeva Gosvämé informed Mahäräja Parékñit of the answers to his questions regarding the essence of Vedic knowledge and regarding what is considered to be the ultimate goal in the Vedas. The supreme goal in life is to seek the transcendental blessings of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and thus become engaged in the loving service of the Lord. One should follow in the footsteps of Çukadeva Gosvämé and all the Vaiñëavas in the disciplic succession and should pay respectful obeisances unto Lord Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead Hari. The four sects of Vaiñëava disciplic succession, namely the Madhva-sampradäya, the Rämänuja-sampradäya, the Viñëusvämé-sampradäya, and the Nimbärka-sampradäya, in pursuance of all Vedic conclusions, agree that one should surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The Vedic literatures are divided into two parts: the çrutis and the småtis. The çrutis are the four Vedas: Åk, Säma, Atharva and Yajus, and the Upaniñads, and the småtis are the Puräëas like Mahäbhärata, which includes Bhagavad-gétä. The conclusion of all these is that one should know Çré Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is the Parampuruña, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead under whose superintendence material nature works, being created, maintained and destroyed. After the creation, the Supreme Lord incarnates into three, Brahmä, Viñëu and Lord Çiva. All of these take charge of the three qualities of material nature, but the ultimate direction is in the hand of Lord Viñëu. The complete activities of material nature under the three modes are being conducted under the direction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä, nyadarçana, and in the Vedas: sa aikñata.

The atheistic Säìkhyaite philosophers offer their arguments that this material cosmic manifestation is due to prakåti and puruña. They argue that nature and material energy constitute the material cause and the effective cause. But Kåñëa is the cause of all causes. He is the cause of all material and effective causes. Prakåti and puruña are not the ultimate cause. Superficially it appears that a child is born due to the combination of the father and mother, but the ultimate cause of both the father and the mother is Kåñëa. He is therefore the original cause, or the cause of all causes, as is confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.1].

In the material nature, both the Supreme Lord and the living entities enter. The Supreme Lord Kåñëa, by one of His plenary expansions, manifests as the Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu and the Mahä-Viñëu, the gigantic Viñëu form lying in the Causal Ocean. Then from that gigantic form of the Mahä-Viñëu, the Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu expands in every universe. From Him, Brahmä, Viñëu and Çiva expand. Viñëu enters into the hearts of all living entities, as well as into all material elements, including the atom. The Brahma-saàhitä says: aëòäntarastha-paramäëu-cayäntarastham. He is within this universe and also within every atom.

The living entity has a small material body taken from various species and forms, and similarly the whole universe is but the material body of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This body is described in the çästras as viräöa rüpa. As the individual living entity maintains his particular body, the Supreme Personality of Godhead maintains the whole cosmic creation and everything within it. As soon as the individual living entity leaves the material body, the body is immediately annihilated, and similarly as soon as Lord Viñëu leaves the cosmic manifestation, everything is annihilated. Only when the individual living entity surrenders unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead is his liberation from material existence assured. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä: mäm eva ye prapadyante mäyäm etäà taranti te. Surrendering unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead is therefore the cause of liberation and nothing else. How the living entity becomes liberated from the modes of material nature after surrendering unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead is illustrated by a sleeping man within a room. When a man is sleeping, everyone sees that he is present within the room, but actually the man himself is not within that body, for while sleeping a man forgets his bodily existence, although others may see that his body is present. Similarly, a liberated person engaged in devotional service of the Lord may be seen by others to be engaged in the household duties of the material world, but since his consciousness is fixed in Kåñëa he does not live within this world. His engagements are different, exactly as the sleeping man's engagements are different from his bodily engagements. It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [14.26] that a devotee engaged full time in the transcendental loving service of the Lord has already surpassed the influence of the three modes of material nature. He is already situated on the Brahman platform of spiritual realization, although he appears to be living within the body or within the material world.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé stated in this connection in his Bhakti-rasamåtä-sindhu that the person whose only desire is to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead may be situated in any condition in the material world, but he is to be understood as jévanmukta, that is to say he is to be considered liberated while living within the body or the material world. The conclusion, therefore, is that a person fully engaged in Kåñëa consciousness is a liberated person. Such a person has actually nothing to do with the material world. Those who are not in Kåñëa consciousness are called karmés and jïänés, and they hover on the bodily and mental platform and thus are not liberated. This situation is called kaivalya-nirasta-yoni. A person situated on the transcendental platform becomes freed from the repetition of birth and death. This is also confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä, Fourth Chapter. Simply by knowing the transcendental nature of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa, one becomes free from the chains of the repetition of birth and death, and after quitting his present body he goes back home, back to Godhead. This is the conclusion of all the Vedas. Thus one should surrender unto the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa after understanding the prayers offered by the personified Vedas.

Thus end the Bhaktivedanta purports of the Second Volume, Thirty-Second Chapter of Kåñëa, "Prayers by the Personified Vedas."

KB 1970-2-33 / The Deliverance of Lord Çiva

33 /The Deliverance of Lord Çiva

As a great devotee of Kåñëa, King Parékñit was already liberated, but for clarification he was asking various questions of Çukadeva Gosvämé. In the previous chapter, King Parékñit's question was, "What is the ultimate goal of the Vedas?" And Çukadeva Gosvämé explained the matter, giving authoritative descriptions from the disciplic succession, beginning with Sanandana down to Näräyaëa Åñi, Närada, Vyäsadeva, and then he himself. The conclusion was that devotional service, or bhakti, is the ultimate goal of the Vedas. A neophyte devotee may question, "If the ultimate goal of life, or the conclusion of the Vedas, is to elevate oneself to the platform of devotional service, then why is it observed that a devotee of Lord Viñëu is generally not very prosperous materially, whereas a devotee of Lord Çiva is found to be very opulent?" In order to clarify this matter, Parékñit Mahäräja asked Çukadeva Gosvämé: "My dear Çukadeva Gosvämé, it is generally found that those who engage in the worship of Lord Çiva, whether in human, demoniac, or demigod society, become very opulent materially, although Lord Çiva himself lives just like a poverty-stricken person. On the other hand, the devotees of Lord Viñëu, who is the controller of the goddess of fortune, do not appear to be very prosperous, and sometimes they are even found to be living without any material opulence at all. Lord Çiva lives underneath a tree or in the snow of the Himalayan Mountains. He does not even construct a house for himself, but still the worshipers of Lord Çiva are very rich. Kåñëa, or Lord Viñëu, however, lives very opulently, whether in Vaikuëöha or in this material world, but His devotees appear to be poverty-stricken. Why is this so?"

Mahäräja Parékñit's question is very intelligent. The two classes of devotees, namely the devotees of Lord Çiva and the devotees of Lord Viñëu, are always in disagreement. Even today in India these two classes of devotees still criticize each other, and especially in South India, the followers of Rämänujäcärya and the followers of Çaìkaräcärya hold occasional meetings for understanding the Vedic conclusion. Generally, the followers of Rämänujäcärya come out victorious in such meetings. So Parékñit Mahäräja wanted to clarify the situation by asking this question of Çukadeva Gosvämé. That Lord Çiva lives as a poor man although his devotees appear to be very opulent, whereas Lord Kåñëa or Lord Viñëu is always opulent, and yet His devotees appear to be poverty-stricken, is a situation which appears contradictory and puzzling to a discriminating person.

Çukadeva Gosvämé began to reply to King Parékñit's inquiry about the apparent contradictions regarding the worship of Lord Çiva and that of Lord Viñëu. Lord Çiva is the master of the material energy. The material energy is represented by goddess Durgä, and Lord Çiva happens to be her husband. Since goddess Durgä is completely under the subjugation of Lord Çiva, it is to be understood that Lord Çiva is the master of this material energy. The material energy is manifested in three qualities, namely goodness, passion and ignorance, and therefore Lord Çiva is the master of these three qualities. Although he is in association with these qualities for the benefit of the conditioned soul, Lord Çiva is the director and is not affected. Although the conditioned soul is affected by the three qualities, Lord Çiva, because he is the master of these qualities, is not affected by them.

From the statements of Çukadeva Gosvämé we can understand that the effects of worshiping different demigods are not, as some less intelligent persons suppose, the same as the effects of worshiping Lord Viñëu. He clearly states that by worshiping Lord Çiva one achieves one reward, whereas by worshiping Lord Viñëu one achieves a different reward. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.12]: those who worship the different demigods achieve the desired results which the respective demigods can reward. Similarly, those who worship the material energy receive the suitable reward for such activities, and those who worship the pitäs receive similar results. But those who are engaged in devotional service or worship of the Supreme Lord, Viñëu or Kåñëa, go to the Vaikuëöha planets or Kåñëaloka. One cannot approach the transcendental region or paravyoma, the spiritual sky, by worshiping Lord Çiva or Brahmä or any other demigod.

Since this material world is a product of the three qualities of material nature, all varieties of manifestations come from those three qualities. With the aid of materialistic science, modern civilization has created many machines and comforts of life, and yet they are only varieties of the interactions of the three material qualities. Although the devotees of Lord Çiva are able to obtain many material acquisitions, we should know that they are simply collecting products manufactured by the three qualities. The three qualities are again subdivided into sixteen, namely the ten senses (five working senses and the five knowledge-acquiring senses), the mind, and the five elements (earth, water, air, fire and sky). These sixteen items are further extensions of the three qualities. Material happiness or opulence means gratification of the senses, specifically the genitals, the tongue and the mind. By exercising our minds we create many pleasurable things just for enjoyment by the genitals and the tongue. The opulence of a person within this material world is estimated in terms of his exercise of the genitals and the tongue, or in other words, how well he is able to utilize his sexual capacities and how well he is able to satisfy his fastidious taste by eating palatable dishes. Material advancement of civilization necessitates creating objects of enjoyment by mental concoction just to become happy on the basis of these two principles: pleasures for the genitals and pleasures for the tongue. Herein lies the answer to King Parékñit's question to Çukadeva Gosvämé as to why the worshipers of Lord Çiva are so opulent.

The devotees of Lord Çiva are only opulent in terms of the material qualities. Factually, such so-called advancement of civilization is the cause of entanglement in material existence. It is actually not advancement, but degradation. The conclusion is that because Lord Çiva is the master of the three qualities, his devotees are given things manufactured by the interaction of these qualities for satisfaction of the senses. In the Bhagavad-gétä, however, we get instruction from Lord Kåñëa that one has to transcend the qualitative existence. Nistraiguëyo bhavärjuna: the mission of human life is to become transcendental to the three qualities. Unless one is nistraiguëya, he cannot get free from material entanglement. In other words, favors received from Lord Çiva are not actually beneficial to the conditioned souls, although apparently such facilities seem to be opulent.

Çukadeva Gosvämé continued: "The Supreme Personality of Godhead Hari is transcendental to the three qualities of material nature." It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.14] that anyone who surrenders unto Him surpasses the control of the three qualities of material nature. Therefore, since Hari's devotees are transcendental to the control of the three material qualities, certainly He Himself is transcendental. It is stated, therefore, in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.3.28] that Hari, or Kåñëa, is the original Supreme Personality. There are two kinds of prakåtis, or potencies, namely the internal potency and the external potency, and Kåñëa is the overlord of both these prakåtis or potencies. He is sarva-dåk, or the overseer of all the actions of the internal and external potencies, and He is also described as upadrañöa, the supreme advisor. Because He is the supreme advisor, He is above all the demigods, who merely follow the directions of the supreme advisor. As such, if one directly follows the instructions of the Supreme Lord, as inculcated in the Bhagavad-gétä and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, then gradually one becomes nirguëa, or above the interaction of the material qualities. To be nirguëa means to be bereft of material opulences because, as we have explained, material opulence means an increase of the actions and reactions of the three material qualities. By worshiping the Supreme Personality of Godhead, instead of being puffed up with material opulences one becomes enriched with spiritual advancement of knowledge in Kåñëa consciousness. To become nirguëa means to achieve eternal peace, fearlessness, religiousness, knowledge and renunciation. All these are symptoms of becoming free from the contamination of the material qualities.

Çukadeva Gosvämé, in answering Parékñit Mahäräja's question, went on to cite an historical instance regarding Parékñit Mahäräja's grandfather, King Yudhiñöhira. He said that after finishing the açvamedha sacrifice in the great sacrificial arena, King Yudhiñöhira, in the presence of great authorities, enquired on that very same point: how is it that the devotees of Lord Çiva become materially opulent, whereas the devotees of Lord Viñëu do not? Çukadeva Gosvämé specifically referred to King Yudhiñöhira as "your grandfather" so that Mahäräja Parékñit would be encouraged to think that he was related to Kåñëa and that his grandfathers were intimately connected with the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Although Kåñëa is always very satisfied by nature, when this question was asked by Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira He became even more satisfied because these questions and their answers would bear a great meaning for the entire Kåñëa conscious society. Whenever Lord Kåñëa speaks about something to a specific devotee, it is not only meant for that devotee, but for the entire human society. Instructions by the Supreme Personality of Godhead are important even to the demigods, headed by Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva and others, and anyone who does not take advantage of the instructions of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who descends within this world for the benefit of all living entities, is certainly very unfortunate.

Lord Kåñëa answered the question of Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira as follows: "If I especially favor a devotee and especially wish to care for him, the first thing I do is take away his riches." When the devotee becomes a penniless pauper or is put into a comparatively poverty-stricken position, his relatives and family members no longer take interest in him, and in most cases they give up their connection with him. The devotee then becomes doubly unhappy. First of all he becomes unhappy because his riches have been taken away by Kåñëa, and he is made even more unhappy when his relatives desert him because of his poverty-stricken position. We should note, however, that when a devotee falls into a miserable condition in this way, it is not due to past impious activities, known as karma-phala; the poverty-stricken position of the devotee is a creation of the Personality of Godhead. Similarly, when a devotee becomes materially opulent, that is also not due to his pious activities. In either case, whether the devotee becomes poorer or richer, the arrangement is made by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This arrangement is especially made by Kåñëa for His devotee just to make him completely dependent upon Him and to free him from all material obligations. He can then concentrate his energies, mind and body—everything—for the service of the Lord, and that is pure devotional service. In the Närada-païcarätra it is therefore explained, sarvopädhi-vinirmuktam, which means "being freed from all designations." Works performed for family, society, community, nation, or humanity are all designated: "I belong to this society," "I belong to this community," "I belong to this nation," "I belong to this species of life." Such identities are all merely designations. When, by the grace of the Lord, a devotee becomes freed from all designation, his devotional service is actually naiñkarma. Jïänés are very much attracted by the position of naiñkarma, in which one's actions no longer have material effect. When the devotee's actions are freed from effects, they are no longer in the category of karma-phalam, or fruitive activities. As explained before by the personified Vedas, the unhappiness and distress of a devotee are produced by the Personality of Godhead for the devotee, and the devotee therefore does not care whether he is in happiness or in distress. He goes on with his duties in executing devotional service. Although his behavior seems to be subject to the action and reaction of fruitive activities, he is actually freed from the results of action.

It may be questioned why a devotee is put into such tribulation by the Personality of Godhead. The answer is that this kind of arrangement by the Lord is just like the father's sometimes becoming unkind to his sons. Because the devotee is a surrendered soul and is taken charge of by the Supreme Lord, whenever the Lord puts him into any condition of life—either in distress or happiness—it is to be understood that behind this arrangement there is a large plan designed by the Personality of Godhead. For example, Lord Kåñëa put the Päëòavas into a distressed condition so acute that even Grandfather Bhéñma could not comprehend how such distress could occur. He lamented that although the whole Päëòava family was headed by King Yudhiñöhira, the most pious king, and protected by the two great warriors Bhéma and Arjuna, and although, above all, the Päëòavas were all intimate friends and relatives of Lord Kåñëa, they still had to undergo such tribulations. Later on, however, it was proved that this was planned by the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa as part of His great mission to annihilate the miscreants and protect the devotees.

Another question may be raised: Since a devotee is put into different kinds of happy and distressful conditions by the arrangement of the Personality of Godhead, and a common man is put into such conditions as a result of his past deeds, then what is the difference? How is the devotee any better than the ordinary karmé? The answer is that the karmés and the devotees are not on the same level. In whatever condition of life the karmé may be, he continues in the cycle of birth and death because the seed of karma, or fruitive activity, is there, and it fructifies whenever there is opportunity. By the law of karma a common man is perpetually entangled in repeated birth and death, whereas a devotee's distress and happiness, not being under the laws of karma, are part of a temporary arrangement by the Supreme Lord which does not entangle the devotee. Such an arrangement is made by the Lord only to serve a temporary purpose. If a karmé performs auspicious acts, he is elevated to the heavenly planets, and if he acts impiously, he is put into a hellish condition of life. But whether a devotee acts in a so-called pious or in an impious manner, he is neither elevated nor degraded, but is transferred to the spiritual kingdom. Therefore a devotee's happiness and distress and a karmé's happiness and distress are not on the same level. This fact is corroborated by a speech by Yamaräja to his servants in connection with the liberation of Ajämila. Yamaräja advised his followers that persons who have never uttered the holy name of the Lord nor remembered the form, quality and pastimes of the Lord should be approached by his watchguards. Yamaräja also advised his servants never to approach the devotees. On the contrary, he instructed his messengers that if they meet a devotee they should offer their respectful obeisances. So there is no question of a devotee's being promoted or degraded within this material world. As there is a gulf of difference between the punishment awarded by the mother and the punishment awarded by an enemy, so a devotee's distressed condition is not the same as the distressed condition of a common karmé.

Here another question may be raised. If God is all-powerful, why should He try to reform His devotee by putting him into distress? The answer is that when the Supreme Personality of Godhead puts His devotee into a condition of distress, it is not without purpose. Sometimes the purpose is that in distress a devotee's feelings of attachment to Kåñëa are magnified. For example, when Kåñëa, before leaving the capital of the Päëòavas for His home, was asking for permission to leave, Kuntédevé said, "My dear Kåñëa, in our distressed condition You are always present with us. Now, because we have been elevated to a royal position, You are leaving us. I would therefore prefer to live in distress than to lose You." When a devotee is put into a situation of distress, his devotional activities are accelerated. Therefore, to show special favor to a devotee, the Lord sometimes puts him into distress. Besides that, it is stated that the sweetness of happiness is sweeter to those who have tasted bitterness. The Supreme Lord descends to this material world just to protect His devotees from distress. In other words, if devotees were not in a distressed condition, the Lord would not have come down. As for His killing the demons or the miscreants, this can be easily done by His various energies, just as many asuras are killed by His external energy, goddess Durgä. Therefore the Lord does not need to come down personally to kill such demons, but when His devotee is in distress He must come. Lord Nåsiàhadeva appeared not to kill Hiraëyakaçipu but to see Prahläda and to give him blessings. In other words, because Prahläda Mahäräja was put into very great distress, the Lord appeared.

When, after the dense, dark night, there is finally sunrise in the morning, it is very pleasant. When there is scorching heat, cold water is very pleasant. And when there is freezing winter, hot water is very pleasant. Similarly, when a devotee, after experiencing the condition of the material world, relishes the spiritual happiness awarded by the Lord, his position becomes still more pleasant and enjoyable.

The Lord continued: "When My devotee is bereft of all material riches and is deserted by his relatives, friends and family members, because he has no one to look after him, he completely takes shelter of the lotus feet of the Lord." Çréla Narottamadäsa Öhäkur has sung in this connection, "My dear Lord Kåñëa, O son of Nanda Mahäräja, You are now standing before me along with Çrématé Rädhäräëé, the daughter of King Våñabhänu. I am now surrendering unto You. Please accept me. Please do not kick me away. I have no shelter other than You."

When a devotee is thus put into so-called miserable conditions and is bereft of riches and family, he tries to revive his original position of material opulence. But although he tries again and again, Kåñëa again and again takes away all his resources. Thus he finally becomes disappointed in material activities, and in that stage of frustration in all endeavors, he can fully surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Such persons are advised by the Lord from within to associate with devotees. By associating with devotees they naturally become inclined to render service to the Personality of Godhead, and they immediately get all facilities from the Lord to advance in Kåñëa consciousness. The non-devotees, however, are very careful about preserving their material condition of life. Generally, therefore, such nondevotees do not come to worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but worship Lord Çiva or other demigods for immediate material profit. In the Bhagavad-gétä it is said, therefore, käëkñantaù karmaëäà siddhià yajanta iha devatäù: the karmés, in order to achieve success within this material world, worship the various demigods. It is also stated by Lord Kåñëa that those who worship the demigods are not mature in their intelligence. The devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, therefore, because of their strong attachment for Him, do not foolishly go to the demigods.

Lord Kåñëa said to King Yudhiñöhira: "My devotee is not deterred by any adverse conditions of life; he always remains firm and steady. Therefore I give Myself to him, and I favor him so he can achieve the highest success in life." The mercy bestowed upon the tried devotee by the Supreme Personality is described as Brahman, which indicates that the greatness of that mercy can be compared only to the all-pervasive greatness. Brahman means unlimitedly great and unlimitedly expanding. That mercy is also described as parama, for it has no comparison within this material world, and it is also called sükñmam, very fine. The Lord's mercy upon the tried devotee is not only great and unlimitedly expansive, but it is of the finest quality of transcendental love between the devotee and the Lord. Such mercy is further described as cinmätram, completely spiritual. The use of the word mätram indicates absolute spirituality, with no tinge of material qualities. That mercy is also called sat, eternal, and anantakam, unlimited. Since the devotee of the Lord is awarded such unlimited spiritual benefit, why should he worship the demigods? A devotee of Kåñëa does not worship Lord Çiva or Brahmä or any other subordinate demigod. He completely devotes himself to the transcendental loving service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Çukadeva Gosvämé continued: "The demigods, headed by Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva and including Lord Indra, Candra, Varuëa and others, are apt to become very quickly satisfied and very quickly angered by the good and ill behavior of their devotees. But this is not so with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu," This means that any living entity within this material world, including the demigods, is conducted by the three modes of material nature, and therefore the qualities of ignorance and passion are very prominent within the material world. Those devotees who take blessings from the demigods are also infected with the material qualities, especially passion and ignorance. Lord Çré Kåñëa has therefore stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.23] that to take blessings from the demigods is less intelligent because when one takes benedictions from the demigods, the results of such benedictions are temporary. It is easy to get material opulence by worshiping the demigods, but the result is sometimes disastrous. As such, the benedictions derived from demigods are appreciated by the less intelligent class of men. Persons who derive benedictions from the demigods gradually become puffed up with material opulence and neglectful of their benefactors.

Çukadeva Gosvämé addressed King Parékñit thus: "My dear King, Lord Brahmä, Lord Viñëu, and Lord Çiva, the principal trio of the material creation, are able to bless or to curse anyone. Of this trio, Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva become very easily satisfied, and at the same time they become very easily angered. When they are satisfied they give benedictions without any consideration, and when they are angry, they curse the devotee without any consideration. But Lord Viñëu is not like that. Lord Viñëu is very considerate. Whenever a devotee wants something from Lord Viñëu, Lord Viñëu first of all considers whether such a benediction will ultimately be good for the devotee. Lord Viñëu never bestows any benediction which will ultimately prove disastrous to the devotee, He is, by His transcendental nature, always merciful; therefore, before giving any benediction, He considers whether it will prove beneficial for the devotee. Since the Supreme Personality of Godhead is always merciful, even when it appears that He has killed a demon, or even when He apparently becomes angry toward a devotee, His actions are always auspicious. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is therefore known as all-good. Whatever He does is good.

As for the benedictions given by demigods like Lord Çiva, there is the following historical incident cited by great sages. Once, Lord Çiva, after giving benediction to a demon named Våkäsura, the son of Çakuni, was himself entrapped in a very dangerous position. Våkäsura was searching after a benediction and was trying to decide which of the three presiding deities to worship in order to get it. In the meantime he happened to meet the great sage Närada and consulted with him as to whom he should approach to achieve quick results from his austerity. He inquired, "Of the three deities, namely Lord Brahmä, Lord Viñëu and Lord Çiva, who is most quickly satisfied?" Närada could understand the plan of the demon, and he advised him, "You had better worship Lord Çiva; then you will quickly get the desired result. Lord Çiva is very quickly satisfied and very quickly dissatisfied also. So you try to satisfy Lord Çiva." Närada also cited instances wherein demons like Rävaëa and Bäëäsura were enriched with great opulences simply by satisfying Lord Çiva with prayers. Because the great sage Närada was aware of the nature of the demon Våkäsura, he did not advise him to approach Viñëu or Lord Brahmä. Persons such as Våkäsura who are situated in the material mode of ignorance, cannot stick to the worship of Viñëu.

After receiving instruction from Närada, the demon Våkäsura went to Kedäranätha. The pilgrimage site of Kedäranätha still exists near Kashmere. It is almost always covered by snow, but for part of the year, during the month of July, it is possible to see the deity, and devotees go there to offer their respects. Kedäranätha is for the devotees of Lord Çiva. According to the Vedic principle, when something is offered to the deities to eat, it is offered in a fire. Therefore a fire sacrifice is necessary in all sorts of ceremonies. It is specifically stated in the çästras that gods are to be offered something to eat through the fire. The demon Våkäsura therefore went to Kedäranätha and ignited a sacrificial fire to please Lord Çiva.

After igniting the fire in the name of Çiva, he began to offer his own flesh, by cutting it from his body so as to please Lord Çiva. Here is an instance of worship in the mode of ignorance. In the Bhagavad-gétä [3.9], different types of sacrifice are mentioned. Some sacrifices are in the mode of goodness, some are in the mode of passion, and some are in the mode of ignorance. There are different kinds of tapasya and worship because there are different kinds of people within this world. But the ultimate tapasya, Kåñëa consciousness, is the topmost yoga and the topmost sacrifice. As confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.65], the topmost yoga is to think always of Lord Kåñëa within the heart, and the topmost sacrifice is to perform the saìkértana-yajïa.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20] it is stated that the worshipers of the demigods have lost their intelligence. As will be revealed later in this chapter, Våkäsura wanted to satisfy Lord Çiva for a third-class materialistic objective, which was temporary and without real benefit. The asuras or persons within the mode of ignorance will accept such benedictions from the demigods. In complete contrast to this sacrifice in the modes of ignorance, the arcanä-viddhi process for worshiping Lord Viñëu or Kåñëa is very simple. Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.26] that He accepts from His devotee even a little fruit, a flower or some water, which can be gathered by any person, poor or rich. Of course, those who are rich are not expected to offer only a little water, a little piece of fruit or a little leaf to the Lord. A rich man should offer according to his position, but if the devotee happens to be a very poor man the Lord will accept even the most meager offering. The worship of Lord Viñëu or Kåñëa is very simple, and it can be executed by anyone in this world. But worship in the mode of ignorance, as exhibited by Våkäsura, is not only very difficult and painful, but it is also a useless waste of time. Therefore Bhagavad-gétä says that the worshipers of the demigods are bereft of intelligence; their process of worship is very difficult, and at the same time the result obtained is flickering and temporary.

Although Våkäsura continued his sacrifice for six days, he was nevertheless unable to personally see Lord Çiva, which was his objective; he wanted to see him face to face and ask him for a benediction. Here is another contrast between a demon and a devotee. A devotee is confident that whatever he offers to the Deity in full devotional service is accepted by the Lord, but a demon wants to see his worshipable deity face to face so that he can directly take the benediction. A devotee, however, does not worship Viñëu or Lord Kåñëa for any benediction. Therefore a devotee is called akäma, free of desire, and a nondevotee is called sarva-käma, or desirous of everything. On the seventh day, the demon Våkäsura decided that he should cut off his head and offer it to satisfy Lord Çiva. Thus he took bath in the nearby lake, and without drying his body and hair, he prepared to cut off his head. According to the Vedic system, an animal which is to be offered as a sacrifice has to be bathed first, and while the animal is wet he is sacrificed. When the demon was thus preparing to cut off his head, Lord Çiva became very compassionate. This compassion, however, is a symptom of the quality of goodness. Lord Çiva is called triliìga. Therefore his manifestation of the nature of compassion is a sign of the quality of goodness. This compassion, however, is present in every living entity. The compassion of Lord Çiva was aroused because the demon was offering his flesh to the sacrificial fire. This is natural compassion. Even if a common man sees someone preparing to commit suicide, it is his duty to try to save him. He does so automatically. There is no need to appeal to him. Therefore when Lord Çiva appeared from the fire to check the demon from suicide, it was not as a very great favor to him.

The demon was saved from committing suicide by the touch of Lord Çiva; his bodily injuries immediately healed, and his body became as it was before. Then Lord Çiva told the demon, "My dear Våkäsura, you do not need to cut off your head. You can ask from me any benediction you like, and I shall fulfill your desire. I do not know why you wanted to cut off your head to satisfy me. I become satisfied even by an offering of a little water." Actually, according to the Vedic process, the Çiva liìga in the temple or the form of Lord Çiva in the temple is worshiped simply by offering Ganges water because it is said that Lord Çiva is greatly satisfied when Ganges water is poured upon his head. Generally, devotees offer Ganges water and the leaves of the bilva tree, which are especially meant for offering to Lord Çiva and the goddess Durgä. The fruit of this tree also is offered to Lord Çiva. Lord Çiva assured Våkäsura that he becomes satisfied by a very simple process of worship. Why then was he so anxious to cut off his head, and why was he taking so much pain by cutting his body to pieces and offering it in the fire? There was no need of such severe penances. Anyway, out of compassion and sympathy, Lord Çiva prepared to give him any benediction he liked.

When the demon was offered this facility by Lord Çiva, he asked for a very fearful and abominable benediction. The demon was very sinful, and sinful persons do not know what sort of benediction should be asked from the deity. Therefore he asked Lord Çiva to be benedicted with such power that as soon as he would touch anyone's head, immediately it would crack, and the man would die. The demons are described in the Bhagavad-gétä as duñkåtinas, or miscreants. Kåté means very meritorious, but when duñ, is added, it means abominable. Instead of surrendering unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the duñkåtinas worship different demigods in order to derive abominable material benefits. Sometimes such demons as material scientists discover lethal weapons. They cannot show their meritorious power by discovering something which can save man from death, but instead they discover weapons which accelerate the process of death. Because Lord Çiva is powerful enough to give any benediction, the demon could have asked of him something beneficial for human society, but for his personal interest he asked that anyone whose head would be touched by his hand would at once die.

Lord Çiva could understand the motive of the demon, and he was very sorry that he had assured him whatever benediction he liked. He would not withdraw his promise, but he was very sorry in his heart that he was to offer him a benediction so dangerous to human society. The demons are described as duñkåtinas, miscreants, because although they have brain power and merit, the merit and brain power are used for abominable activities. Sometimes, for example, the materialistic demons discover a lethal weapon. The scientific research for such a discovery certainly requires a very good brain, but instead of discovering something beneficial to human society, they discover something to accelerate the death which is already assured to every man. Similarly, Våkäsura, instead of asking Lord Çiva for something beneficial to human society, asked for something very dangerous to human society. Therefore Lord Çiva felt sorry within himself. Devotees of the Personality of Godhead, however, never ask any benediction from Lord Viñëu or Kåñëa, and even if they ask something from the Lord, it is not at all dangerous for human society. That is the difference between the demons and the devotees, or the worshipers of Lord Çiva and the worshipers of Lord Viñëu.

While Çukadeva Gosvämé was narrating the history of Våkäsura, he addressed Mahäräja Parékñit as Bhärata, referring to King Parékñit's birth in a family of devotees. Mahäräja Parékñit was saved by Lord Kåñëa while he was in his mother's womb. Similarly, he could have asked Lord Kåñëa to save him from the curse of the brähmaëa, but he did not do so. The demon, however, wanted to become immortal by killing everyone with the touch of his hand. Lord Çiva could understand this, but because he had promised, he gave him the benediction.

The demon, however, being very sinful, immediately decided that he would use the benediction to kill Lord Çiva and take away Gauré (Pärvaté) for his personal enjoyment. He immediately decided to place his hand on the head of Lord Çiva. Thus Lord Çiva was put into an awkward position because he was endangered by his own benediction to a demon. This is also another instance of a materialistic devotee's misusing the power derived from the demigods.

Without further deliberation, the demon Våkäsura immediately approached Lord Çiva to place his hand on Lord Çiva's head. Lord Çiva was so afraid of him that his body trembled, and he began to flee from the land to the sky and from the sky to other planets until he reached the limits of the universe, above the higher planetary systems. Lord Çiva fled from one place to another, but the demon Våkäsura continued to chase him. The predominating deities of other planets, such as Brahmä, Indra and Candra, could not find any way to save Lord Çiva from the impending danger. Wherever Lord Çiva went, they remained silent.

At last Lord Çiva approached Lord Viñëu, who is situated within this universe in the planet known as Çvetadvépa. Çvetadvépa is the local Vaikuëöha planet beyond the jurisdiction of the influence of external energy. Lord Viñëu in His all-pervasive feature remains everywhere, but wherever He remains personally is the Vaikuëöha atmosphere. In the Bhagavad-gétä [15.15] it is stated that the Lord remains within the heart of all living entities. As such, the Lord remains within the heart of many low-born living entities, but that does not mean that He is low-born. Wherever He remains is transformed into Vaikuëöha. So the planet within this universe known as Çvetadvépa is also Vaikuëöhaloka. It is said in the çästras that residential quarters within the forest are in the mode of goodness, residential quarters in big cities, towns and villages are in the mode of passion, and residential quarters in an atmosphere wherein indulgence in the four sinful activities of illicit sex, intoxication, meat-eating and gambling predominate are in the mode of ignorance. But residential quarters in a temple of Viñëu, the Supreme Lord, are in Vaikuëöha. It doesn't matter where the temple is situated, but the temple itself, wherever it may be, is Vaikuëöha. Similarly, the Çvetadvépa planet, although within the material jurisdiction, is Vaikuëöha.

Lord Çiva finally entered Çvetadvépa Vaikuëöha. In Çvetadvépa there are great saintly persons who are completely freed from the envious nature of the material world and are beyond the jurisdiction of the four principles of material activities, namely, religiousness, economic development, sense gratification and liberation. Anyone who enters into that Vaikuëöha planet never comes back again to this material world. Lord Näräyaëa is celebrated as a lover of His devotees, and as soon as He understood that Lord Çiva was in great danger, He appeared as a brahmacäré and personally approached Lord Çiva to receive him from a distant place. The Lord appeared as a perfect brahmacäré, with a belt around His waist, sacred thread, deerskin, a brahmacäré stick and raudra beads. (Raudra beads are different from tulasé beads. Raudra beads are used by the devotees of Lord Çiva.) Dressed as a brahmacäré, Lord Näräyaëa stood before Lord Çiva. The shining effulgence emanating from His body attracted not only Lord Çiva but also the demon Våkäsura.

Lord Näräyaëa offered his respects and obeisances unto Våkäsura, just to attract his sympathy and attention. Thus checking the demon, the Lord addressed him as follows: "My dear son of Çakuni, you appear to be very tired, as if coming from a very distant place. What is your purpose? Why have you come so far? I see that you are very tired and fatigued, so I request you to take a little rest. You should not unnecessarily tire your body. Everyone greatly values his body because with this body only can one fulfill all the desires of one's mind. We should not, therefore, unnecessarily give trouble to this body."

The brahmacäré addressed Våkäsura as the son of Çakuni just to convince him that He was known to his father, Çakuni. Våkäsura then took the brahmacäré to be someone known to his family, and therefore the brahmacäré's sympathetic words appealed to him. Before the demon could argue that he had no time to take rest, the Lord began to inform him about the importance of the body, and the demon was convinced. Any man, especially a demon, takes his body to be very important. Thus Våkäsura became convinced about the importance of his body.

Then, just to pacify the demon, the brahmacäré told him, "My dear lord, if you think that you can disclose the mission for which you have taken the trouble to come here, maybe I shall be able to help you so that your purpose will be easily served." Indirectly, the Lord informed him that because the Lord is the Supreme Brahman, certainly He would be able to adjust the awkward situation created by Lord Çiva.

The demon was greatly pacified by the sweet words of Lord Näräyaëa in the form of a brahmacäré, and at last he disclosed all that had happened in regard to the benediction offered by Lord Çiva. The Lord replied to the demon as follows: "I myself cannot believe that Lord Çiva has in truth given you such a benediction. As far as I know, Lord Çiva is not in a sane mental condition. He had a quarrel with his father-in-law Dakña, and he has been cursed to become a piçäca (ghost). Thus he has become the leader of the ghosts and hobgoblins. Therefore I cannot put any faith in his words. But if you have faith still in the words of Lord Çiva, my dear king of the demons, then why don't you make an experiment by putting your hand on your head? If the benediction proves false, then you can immediately kill this liar, Lord Çiva, so that in the future he will not dare to give out false benedictions."

In this way, by Lord Näräyaëa's sweet words and by the expansion of His superior illusion, the demon became bewildered, and he actually forgot the power of Lord Çiva and his benediction. He was thus very easily persuaded to put his hand on his own head. As soon as the demon did that, his head cracked, as if struck by thunder, and he immediately died. The demigods from heaven began to shower flowers on Lord Näräyaëa, praising Him with all glories and all thanksgiving, and they offered their obeisances to the Lord. On the death of Våkäsura, all the denizens in the higher planetary systems, namely, the demigods, the pitäs, the Gandharvas and the inhabitants of Janaloka, began to shower flowers on the Personality of Godhead.

Thus Lord Viñëu in the form of a brahmacäré released Lord Çiva from the impending danger and saved the whole situation. Lord Näräyaëa then informed Lord Çiva that this demon, Våkäsura, was killed as the result of his sinful activities. He was especially sinful and offensive because he wanted to experiment on his own master, Lord Çiva. Lord Näräyaëa then told Lord Çiva, "My dear lord, a person who commits an offense to great souls cannot continue to exist. He becomes vanquished by his own sinful activities, and this is certainly true of this demon, who has committed such an offensive act against you."

Thus, by the grace of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Näräyaëa, who is transcendental to all material qualities, Lord Çiva was saved from being killed by a demon. Anyone who hears this history with faith and devotion certainly becomes liberated from material entanglement as well as from the clutches of his enemies.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Thirty-third Chapter, of Kåñëa, "Deliverance of Lord Çiva."

KB 1970-2-34 / The Superexcellent Power of Kåñëa

34 /The Superexcellent Power of Kåñëa

Long, long ago, there was an assembly of great sages on the bank of the River Sarasvaté, and they performed a great sacrifice of the name Satrayajïa. In such assemblies, the great sages present usually discuss Vedic subject matters and philosophical topics, and in this particular meeting the following question was raised: The three predominating deities of this material world, namely, Lord Brahmä, Lord Viñëu and Lord Çiva, are directing all the affairs of the this cosmos, but who among them is the Supreme? After much discussion on this question, the great sage named Bhågu, who is the son of Lord Brahmä, was deputed to test all three predominating deities and report to the assembly as to who is the greatest.

Being thus deputed, the great sage Bhågumuni first of all went to his father's residence in Brahmäloka. The three deities are the controllers of the three material qualities, namely the qualities of goodness, passion and ignorance. The plan decided upon by the sages was for Bhågu to test which of the predominating deities possesses the quality of goodness in full. Therefore, when Bhågumuni reached his father, Lord Brahmä, because he wanted to test whether he had the quality of goodness, he purposely did not offer his respects to his father either by offering obeisances or by offering prayers. It is the duty of a son or a disciple to offer respects and recite suitable prayers when he approaches his father or spiritual master. But Bhågumuni purposefully failed to offer respects, just to see Lord Brahmä's reaction to this negligence. Lord Brahmä was very angry at his son's impudency, and he showed signs which definitely proved this to be so. He was even prepared to condemn Bhågu by cursing him, but because Bhågu was his son, Lord Brahmä controlled his anger with his great intelligence. This means that although the quality of passion was prominent in Lord Brahmä, he had the power to control it. Lord Brahmä's anger and his controlling his anger are likened to fire and water. Water is produced from fire, but at the same time, fire can be extinguished with water. Similarly, although Lord Brahmä was very angry due to his quality of passion, he could still control his passion because Bhågumuni was his son.

After testing Lord Brahmä, Bhågumuni went directly to the planet Kailäsa, where Lord Çiva resides. Bhågumuni happened to be Lord Çiva's brother. Therefore, as soon as Bhågumuni approached, Lord Çiva became very glad and personally rose to embrace him. But when Lord Çiva approached, Bhågumuni refused to embrace him. "My dear brother," he said, "you are always very impure. Because you smear your body with ashes, you are therefore not very clean. Please do not touch me." When Bhågumuni refused to embrace his brother, saying that Lord Çiva was very impure, the latter became very angry with him. It is said that an offense can be committed either with the body, with the mind or by speech. Bhågumuni's first offense, committed towards Lord Brahmä, was an offense with the mind. His second offense, committed towards Lord Çiva by insulting him, criticizing him for unclean habits, was an offense by speech. Because the quality of ignorance is prominent in Lord Çiva, when he heard Bhågu's insult, his eyes immediately became red with anger. With uncontrollable rage, he took up his trident and prepared to kill Bhågumuni. At that time, Lord Çiva's wife, Pärvaté, was present. Her personality is a mixture of the three qualities, and therefore she is called Triguëamayé. In this case, she saved the situation by evoking Lord Çiva's quality of goodness. She fell down at the feet of her husband, and with her sweet words she talked him out of killing Bhågumuni.

After being saved from the anger of Lord Çiva, Bhågumuni went directly to the planet Çvetadvépa, where Lord Viñëu was lying on a bed of flowers, accompanied by His wife, the goddess of fortune, who was engaged in massaging His lotus feet. There Bhågumuni purposely committed the greatest sin by offending Lord Viñëu by his bodily activities. The first offense committed by Bhågumuni was mental, the second offense was vocal, and the third offense was corporal. These different offenses are progressively greater in degree. An offense committed within the mind is a positive offense, the same offense, committed verbally is comparitively more grave, and when committed by bodily action it is superlative in offensiveness. So Bhågumuni committed the greatest offense by touching the chest of the Lord with his foot in the presence of the goddess of fortune. Of course, Lord Viñëu is all-merciful. He did not become angry at the activities of Bhågumuni because Bhågumuni was a great brähmaëa. A brähmaëa is to be excused even if he sometimes commits an offense, and Lord Viñëu set the example. Yet it is said that from the time of this incident, the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé, has not been very favorably disposed towards the brähmaëas, and therefore because the goddess of fortune witholds her benedictions from them, the brähmaëas are generally very poor. Bhågumuni's touching the chest of Lord Viñëu with his foot was certainly a great offense, but Lord Viñëu is so great that He did not care. The so-called brähmaëas of the Kali-yuga are sometimes very proud that they can touch the chest of Lord Viñëu with their feet. But when Bhågumuni touched the chest of Lord Viñëu with his feet, it was different because although it was the greatest offense, Lord Viñëu, being greatly magnanimous, did not take it very seriously.

Instead of being angry or cursing Bhågumuni, Lord Viñëu immediately got up from His bed along with His wife, the goddess of fortune, and offered respectful obeisances to the brähmaëa. He addressed Bhågumuni as follows: "My dear brähmaëa, it is a great blessing for Me that you have come here. Please, therefore, sit down on this cushion for a few minutes. My dear brähmaëa, I am very sorry that when you first entered I could not receive you properly. It was a great offense on My part, and I beg you to pardon Me. You are so pure and great that the water which washes your feet can purify even the places of pilgrimage. Therefore, I request you to purify the Vaikuëöha planet where I live with My associates. My dear father, O great sage, I know that your feet are very soft, like a lotus flower, and that My chest is as hard as a thunderbolt. I am therefore afraid that you may have felt some pain by touching My chest with your feet. Let Me therefore touch your feet to relieve the pain you have suffered." Lord Viñëu then began to massage the feet of Bhågumuni.

The Lord continued to address Bhågumuni. "My dear lord," He said, "My chest has now become sanctified because of the touch of your feet, and I am now assured that the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé, will be very glad to live there perpetually." Another name for Lakñmé is Caïcalä. She does not stay in one place for a long time. Therefore, we see that a rich man's family sometimes becomes poor after a few generations, and sometimes we see that a poor man's family becomes very rich. Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune, is Caïcalä in this material world, whereas in the Vaikuëöha planets she eternally lives at the lotus feet of the Lord. Because Lakñmé is famous as Caïcalä, Lord Näräyaëa indicated that she might not have been living perpetually by His chest, but because His chest had been touched by the feet of Bhågumuni, it was now sanctified, and there was no chance that the goddess of fortune would leave. Bhågumuni, however, could understand his position and that of the Lord, and he was struck with wonder at the behavior of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Because of his gratitude, his voice choked up, and he was not able to reply to the words of the Lord. Tears glided from his eyes, and he could not say anything. He simply stood silently before the Lord.

After testing Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva and Lord Viñëu, Bhågumuni returned to the assembly of great sages on the bank of the River Sarasvaté and described his experience. After hearing him with great attention, the sages concluded that of all the predominating deities, certainly Viñëu is situated in the mode of goodness in the highest degree. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, these great sages are described as brahma-vädinäm. Brahmä-vädinäm means those who talk about the Absolute Truth but have not yet come to a conclusion. Generally brahma-vädé refers to the impersonalists or to those who are students of the Vedas. It is to be understood, therefore, that all the gathered sages were serious students of Vedic literature, but had not come to definite conclusions as to who is the Supreme Absolute Personality of Godhead.

After hearing of Bhågumuni’s experience in meeting all three predominating deities, Lord Çiva, Lord Brahmä, and Lord Viñëu, the sages concluded that Lord Viñëu is the Supreme Truth, the Personality of Godhead. It is said in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.89.8-9] that after hearing the details from Bhågumuni, the sages were astonished because although Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva were immediately agitated, Lord Viñëu, in spite of being kicked by Bhågumuni, was not agitated in the least. The example is given that small lamps may become agitated by a little breeze, but the greatest lamp or the greatest illuminating source, the sun, is never moved, even by the greatest hurricane. One’s greatness has to be estimated by one’s ability to tolerate provoking situations. The sages gathered on the bank of the River Sarasvaté concluded that if anyone wants actual peace and freedom from all fearfulness, he should take shelter of the lotus feet of Viñëu. If Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva lost their peaceful attitude upon a slight provocation, how could they maintain the peace and tranquility of their devotees? As for Lord Viñëu, however, it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.29] that anyone who accepts Lord Viñëu or Kåñëa as the supreme friend attains the highest perfection of peaceful life.

The sages thus concluded that by following the principles of vaiñëava-dharma, one becomes actually perfect. But if one follows all the religious principles of a particular sect and does not become advanced in understanding the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu, all such labor of love is fruitless. To execute religious principles means to come to the platform of perfect knowledge. If one comes to the platform of perfect knowledge, then he will be disinterested in material affairs. Perfect knowledge means to know one's own self and to know the Supreme Self. The Supreme Self and the individual self, although one in quality, are different in quantity. This analytical understanding of knowledge is perfect. Simply to understand, "I am not matter; I am spirit," is not perfect knowledge. The real religious principle is devotional service, or bhakti. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66]. Lord Kåñëa says, "Give up all other religious principles and simply surrender unto Me." Therefore, the term dharma applies only to the vaiñëava-dharma or bhagavad-dharma, following which all other good qualities and advancements in life are automatically achieved.

The highest perfectional knowledge is to know the Supreme Lord. He cannot be understood by any process of religion other than devotional service; therefore, the immediate result of perfect knowledge is achieved by executing devotional service. After attainment of knowledge, one becomes disinterested in the material world. This is not because of dry philosophical speculation. The devotees become disinterested in the material world, not simply because of theoretical understanding, but practical experience. When a devotee realizes the effect of association with the Supreme Lord, he naturally hates the association of so-called society, friendship and love. This detachment is not dry, but is due to achieving a higher status of life by relishing transcendental mellows. It is further stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam that after attainment of such knowledge and detachment from material sense gratification, one's advancement in the eight opulences attained by mystic yoga practice, namely the aëimä, laghimä and präpti siddhis, etc., are also achieved without separate effort. The perfect example is Mahäräja Ambaréña. He was not a mystic yogé but was a great devotee, yet in a disagreement with Mahäräja Ambaréña, the great mystic Durväsä was defeated in the presence of his devotional attitude. In other words, a devotee does not need to practice the mystic yoga system to achieve power. The power is behind him by the grace of the Lord, just as when a small child is surrendered to a powerful father, all the powers of the father are behind him.

When a person becomes famous as a devotee of the Lord, his reputation is never to be extinguished. Lord Caitanya, when discoursing with Rämänanda Räya, questioned, "What is the greatest fame?" Rämänanda Räya replied that to be known as a pure devotee of Lord Kåñëa is the perfect fame. The conclusion, therefore, is that Viñëu-dharma, or the religion of devotional service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is meant for persons who are thoughtful. By proper utilization of thoughtfulness, one comes to the stage of thinking of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. By thinking of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one becomes free from the contamination of the faulty association of the material world, and thus one becomes peaceful. The world is in a disturbed condition because of a scarcity of such peaceful devotees in human society. Unless one is a devotee, one cannot be equal to all living entities. A devotee is equally disposed towards the animals, the human beings and all living entities because he sees every living entity as a part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. In the Éçopaniñad [6] it is clearly stated that one who has come to the stage of seeing all living beings equally does not hate anyone or favor anyone. The devotee does not hanker to possess more than he requires. Devotees are therefore akiïcana; in any condition of life a devotee is satisfied. It is said that a devotee is evenminded whether he is in hell or in heaven. A devotee is callous to all subjects other than his engagement in devotional service. This mode of life is the highest perfectional stage, from which one can be elevated to the spiritual world, back home, back to Godhead. The devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead are especially attracted by the highest material quality, goodness, and the qualified brähmaëa is the symbolic representation of this goodness. Therefore, a devotee is attached to the brahminical stage of life. He is not very much interested in passion or ignorance, although these qualities also emanate from the Supreme Lord, Viñëu. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.89.14-17] the devotees are described as nipuëa-buddhayaù, which means that they are the most intelligent class of men. Uninfluenced by attachment or hatred, the devotee lives very peacefully and is not agitated by the influence of passion and ignorance.

It may be questioned here why a devotee should be attached to the quality of goodness in the material world if he is transcendental to all material qualities. The answer is that there are different kinds of people existing in the modes of material nature. Those who are in the mode of ignorance are called räkñasas, those in the mode of passion are called asuras, and those in the mode of goodness are called suras, or demigods. Under the direction of the Supreme Lord, these three classes of men are created by material nature, but those who are in the mode of goodness have a greater chance to be elevated to the spiritual world, back home, back to Godhead.

Thus all the sages who assembled on the bank of the River Sarasvaté to try to determine who is the supreme predominating Deity became freed from all doubts about Viñëu worship. All of them thereafter engaged in devotional service, and thus they achieved the desired result and went back to Godhead.

Those who are actually anxious to become liberated from material entanglement would do better to accept at once the conclusion given by Çré Çukadeva Gosvämé in the beginning of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.1.3]. It is said there that hearing the Çrémad-Bhägavatam is extremely conducive to liberation because it is spoken by Çukadeva Gosvämé. The same fact is again confirmed by Süta Gosvämé: if anyone who is travelling aimlessly within this material world cares to hear the nectarean words spoken by Çukadeva Gosvämé, certainly he will come to the right conclusion; simply by discharging devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead he will be able to stop the fatigue of migrating from one material body to another perpetually. In other words, by proper hearing one will become fixed in loving devotional service to Viñëu. He will certainly be able to get relief from this material journey of life, and the process is very simple. One has to give aural reception to the sweet words spoken by Çukadeva Gosvämé in the form of Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

Another conclusion is that we should never consider the demigods, even Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä, to be on an equal level with Lord Viñëu. If we do this, then according to Padma Puräëa, we immediately become atheists. In the Vedic literature known as Harivaàça it is also stated that only the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu, is to be worshiped. The Hare Kåñëa mahämantra, or any such Viñëu mantra, is always to be chanted. In the Second Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Lord Brahmä says, "Both Lord Çiva and myself are engaged by the Supreme Personality of Godhead to act in different capacities under His direction." In the Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 6.83] it is also stated that the only master is Kåñëa, and everyone in all categories of life are servants of Kåñëa only.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.7] it is confirmed by the Lord that there is no truth superior to Kåñëa. Çukadeva Gosvämé also, in order to draw attention to the fact that among all Viñëu-tattva forms, Lord Kåñëa is one hundred percent the Supreme Personality of Godhead, narrated the story of an incident which took place when Lord Kåñëa was present.

Once upon a time, a brähmaëa's wife gave birth to a child. Unfortunately, however, just after being born and touching the ground, the child immediately died. The brähmaëa father took the dead child and went directly to Dvärakä to the palace of the king. The brähmaëa was very upset because of the untimely death of the child in the presence of his young father and mother. Thus his mind became very disturbed. Formerly, when there were responsible kings, up to the time of Dväpara-yuga, when Lord Kåñëa was present, the king was liable to be blamed for the untimely death of a child in the presence of his parents. Similarly, such responsibility was there during the time of Lord Rämacandra. As we have explained in the First Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.10.6], the king was so responsible for the comforts of the citizens that he was to see that there was not even excessive heat or cold. Although there was no fault on the part of the king, the brähmaëa whose child had died immediately went to the palace door and began to accuse the king as follows.

"The present King, Ugrasena, is envious of the brähmaëas!" The exact word used in this connection is brähma-dviñaù. One who is envious of the Vedas or one who is envious of a qualified brähmaëa or the brähmana caste is called brahma-dvit. So the King was accused of being brahma-dvit. He was also accused of being çaöha-dhé, falsely intelligent. The executive head of a state must be very intelligent to see to the comforts of the citizens, but, according to the brähmaëa the king was not at all intelligent, although he was occupying the royal throne. Therefore he also called him lubdha, which means greedy. In other words, a king or an executive head of state should not occupy the exalted post of presidency or kingship if he is greedy and self-interested. But it is natural that an executive head becomes self-interested when he is attached to material enjoyment. Therefore, another word used here is viñayätmanaù.

The brähmaëa also accused the king of being kñatra-bandhu, which refers to a person born in the family of kñatriyas or the royal order who is without the qualifications of a royal personality. A king should protect brahminical culture and should be very alert to the welfare of his citizens; he should not be greedy due to attachment to material enjoyment. If a person with no qualifications represents himself as a kñatriya of the royal order, he is not called a kñatriya, but a kñatra-bandhu. Similarly, if a person is born of a brähmaëa father but has no brahminical qualification, he is called brahma-bandhu, or dvija-bandhu. This means that a brähmaëa or a kñatriya is not accepted simply by birth. One has to qualify himself for the particular position; only then is he accepted as a brähmaëa or a kñatriya.

Thus the brähmaëa accused the King that his newly born baby was dead due to the disqualifications of the king. The brähmaëa took it most unnaturally, and therefore he held the king to be responsible. We also find in Vedic history that if a kñatriya king were irresponsible, sometimes a consulting board of brähmaëas maintained by the monarchy would dethrone him. Considering all these points, it appears that the post of monarch in the Vedic civilization is a very responsible one.

The brähmaëa therefore said, "No one should offer respects or worship to a king whose only business is envy. Such a king spends his time either hunting and killing animals in the forest or killing citizens for criminal acts. He has no self-control and possesses bad character. If such a king is worshiped or honored by the citizens, the citizens will never be happy. They will always remain poor, full of anxieties and aggrievement, and always unhappy." Although in modern politics the post of monarch is abolished, the president is not held responsible for the comforts of the citizens. In this age of Kali, the executive head of a state somehow or other gets votes and is elected to an exalted post, but the condition of the citizens continues to be full of anxiety, distress, unhappiness, and dissatisfaction.

The brähmaëa's second child was also born dead, and the third also. He had nine children, and each of them was born dead, and each time he came to the gate of the palace to accuse the King. When the brähmaëa came to accuse the King of Dvärakä for the ninth time, Arjuna happened to be present with Kåñëa. On hearing that a brähmaëa was accusing the King of not properly protecting him, Arjuna became inquisitive and approached the brähmaëa. He said, "My dear brähmaëa, why do you say that there are no proper kñatriyas to protect the citizens of your country? Is there not even someone who can pretend to be a kñatriya, who can carry a bow and arrow at least to make a show of protection? Do you think that all the royal personalities in this country simply engage in performing sacrifices with the brähmaëas but have no chivalrous power?" Thus Arjuna indicated that kñatriyas should not sit back comfortably and engage only in performing Vedic rituals. Rather, they must be very chivalrous in protecting the citizens. Brähmaëas, being engaged in spiritual activities, are not expected to do anything which requires physical endeavor. Therefore, they need to be protected by the kñatriyas so that they will not be disturbed in the execution of their higher occupational duties.

"If the brähmaëas feel unwanted separation from their wives and children," Arjuna continued, "and the kñatriya kings do not take care of them, then such kñatriyas are to be considered no more than stage players. In dramatical performances in the theater, an actor may play the part of a king, but no one expects any benefits from such a make-believe king. Similarly, if the king or the executive head of a state cannot give protection to the head of the social structure, he is considered merely a bluffer. Such executive heads simply live for their own livelihood while occupying exalted posts as chiefs of state. My lord, I promise that I shall give protection to your children, and if I am unable to do so, then I shall enter into blazing fire so that the sinful contamination which has infected me will be counteracted."

Upon hearing Arjuna speak in this way, the brähmaëa replied, "My dear Arjuna, Lord Balaräma is present, but He could not give protection to my children. Lord Kåñëa is also present, but He also could not give them protection. There are also many other heroes, such as Pradyumna and Aniruddha, carrying bows and arrows, but they could not protect my children." The brähmaëa directly hinted that Arjuna could not do that which was impossible for the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He felt that Arjuna was promising something beyond his power. The brähmaëa said, "I consider your promise to be like that of an inexperienced child. I cannot put my faith in your promise."

Arjuna then understood that the brähmaëa had lost all faith in the kñatriya kings. Therefore, to encourage him, Arjuna spoke as if criticizing even his friend, Lord Kåñëa. While Lord Kåñëa and others were listening, he specifically attacked Kåñëa by saying, "My dear brähmaëa, I am neither Saìkarñaëa nor Kåñëa nor one of Kåñëa's sons like Pradyumna or Aniruddha. My name is Arjuna, and I carry the bow known as Gäëòéva. You cannot insult me because I have satisfied even Lord Çiva by my prowess when we were both hunting in the forest. I had a fight with Lord Çiva, who appeared before me as a hunter, and when I satisfied him by my prowess, he gave me the weapon known as paçupatästra. Do not doubt my chivalry. I shall bring back your sons even if I have to fight with death personified." When the brähmaëa was assured by Arjuna in such exalted words, he somehow or other was convinced, and thus he returned home.

When the brähmaëa's wife was to give birth to another child, the brähmaëa began to chant, "My dear Arjuna, please come now and save my child." After hearing him, Arjuna immediately prepared himself by touching sanctified water and uttering holy mantras to protect his bows and arrows from danger. He specifically took the arrow which was presented to him by Lord Çiva, and while going out, he began to remember Lord Çiva and his great favor. In this way, he appeared in front of the maternity home, equipped with his bow, known as Gäëòéva, and with various other weapons.

It appears that Arjuna did not leave Dvärakä because he had to fulfill his promise to the brähmaëa. He was called at night when the brähmaëa's wife was to give birth to the child. While going to the maternity home to attend to the delivery case of the brähmaëa's wife, Arjuna remembered Lord Çiva, and not his friend Kåñëa; he thought that since Kåñëa could not give protection to the brähmaëa, it was better to take shelter of Lord Çiva. This is another instance of how a person takes shelter of the demigods. This is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20]: kämais tais tair håta-jïänäù: a person who loses his intelligence because of greediness and lust forgets the Supreme Personality of Godhead and takes shelter of the demigods. Of course, Arjuna was not an ordinary living entity, but because of his friendly dealings with Kåñëa, he thought that Kåñëa was unable to give protection to the brähmaëa and that he would do better to remember Lord Çiva. Later on it was proved that Arjuna's taking shelter of Lord Çiva instead of Kåñëa was not at all successful. Arjuna, however, did his best by chanting different mantras, and he took up his bow to guard the maternity home from all directions.

The brähmaëa's wife delivered a male child, and as usual the child began to cry. But suddenly, within a few minutes, both the child and Arjuna's arrows disappeared in the sky. It appeared that the brähmaëa's house was near Kåñëa's residence and that Lord Kåñëa was enjoying everything that was taking place apparently in defiance of His authority. It was He who played the trick of taking away the brähmaëa's baby as well as the arrows, including the one given by Lord Çiva, of which Arjuna was so proud. Tad bhavati alpamedhasäm: less intelligent men take shelter of the demigods due to bewilderment and are satisfied with the benefits they award.

In the presence of Lord Kåñëa and others, the brähmaëa began to accuse Arjuna: "Everyone see my foolishness! I put my faith in the words of Arjuna, who is impotent and who is expert only in false promises. How foolish I was to believe Arjuna. He promised to protect my child when even Pradyumna, Aniruddha, Lord Balaräma and Lord Kåñëa failed. If such great personalities could not protect my child, then who can do so? I therefore condemn Arjuna for his false promise, and I also condemn his celebrated bow Gäëòéva and his impudency in declaring himself greater than Lord Balaräma, Lord Kåñëa, Pradyumna and Aniruddha. No one can save my child, for he has already been transferred to another planet. Due to sheer foolishness only, Arjuna thought that he could bring back my child from another planet."

Thus condemned by the brähmaëa, Arjuna empowered himself with a mystic yoga perfection so that he could travel to any planet to find the brähmaëa's baby. It seems that Arjuna had mastered the mystic yogic power by which yogés can travel to any planet they desire. He first of all went to the planet known as Yamaloka, where the superintendent of death, Yamaräja, lives. There he searched for the brähmaëa's baby, but he was unable to find him. He then immediately went to the planet where the King of heaven, Indra, lives. When he was unable to find the baby there, he went to the planets of the fire demigods, Nairåti, and then to the moon planet. Then he went to Väyu and to Varuëaloka. When he was unable to find the baby in those planets, he went down to the Rasätala planet, the lowest of the planetary systems. After traveling to all these different planets, he finally went to Brahmaloka, where even the mystic yogés cannot go. By the grace of Lord Kåñëa, Arjuna had that power, and he went above the heavenly planets to Brahmaloka. When he was unable to find the baby even after searching all possible planets, he then attempted to throw himself into a fire, as he had promised the brähmaëa if unable to bring back his baby. Lord Kåñëa, however, was very kind toward Arjuna because Arjuna happened to be the most intimate friend of the Lord. Lord Kåñëa persuaded Arjuna not to enter the fire in disgrace. Kåñëa indicated that since Arjuna was His friend, if he were to enter the fire in hopelessness, indirectly it would be a blemish on Him. Lord Kåñëa therefore checked Arjuna, assuring him that He would find the baby. He told Arjuna, "Do not foolishly commit suicide."

After addressing Arjuna in this way, Lord Kåñëa called for His transcendental chariot. He mounted it along with Arjuna and began to proceed north. Lord Kåñëa, the all-powerful Personality of Godhead, could have brought the child back without effort, but we should always remember that He was playing the part of a human being. As a human being has to endeavor to achieve certain results, so Lord Kåñëa, like an ordinary human being, or like His friend Arjuna, left Dvärakä to bring back the brähmaëa's baby. By appearing in human society and exhibiting His pastimes as a human being, Kåñëa definitely showed that there was not a single personality greater than He. "God is great." That is the definition of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So at least within this material world, while He was present, Kåñëa proved that there was no greater personality within the universe.

Seated on His chariot with Arjuna, Kåñëa began to proceed north, crossing over many planetary systems. These are described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [4.21.12] as sapta-dvépa. Dvépa means island. All these planets are sometimes described in the Vedic literature as dvipas. The planet on which we are living is called Jambüdvépa. Outer space is taken as a great ocean of air, and within that great ocean of air there are many islands, which are the different planets. In each and every planet there are oceans also. In some of the planets, the oceans are of salt water, and in some of them there are oceans of milk. In others there are oceans of liquor, and in others there are oceans of ghee or oil. There are different kinds of mountains also. Each and every planet has a different type of atmosphere.

Kåñëa passed over all these planets and reached the covering of the universe. This covering is described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.89.4] as great darkness. This material world as a whole is described as dark. In the open space there is sunlight, and therefore it is illuminated, but in the covering, because of the absence of sunlight, it is naturally dark. When Kåñëa approached the covering layer of this universe, the four horses which were drawing His chariot—Çaibya, Sugréva, Meghapuñpa and Balähaka—all appeared to hesitate to enter the darkness. This hesitation is also a part of the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa because the horses of Kåñëa are not ordinary. It is not possible for ordinary horses to go all over the universe and then enter into its outer covering layers. As Kåñëa is transcendental, similarly His chariot and His horses and everything about Him are also transcendental, beyond the qualities of this material world. We should always remember that Kåñëa was playing the part of an ordinary human being, and His horses also, by the will of Kåñëa, played the parts of ordinary horses in hesitating to enter the darkness.

Kåñëa is known as Yogeçvara, as is stated in the last portion of Bhagavad-gétä. Yogeçvara Hari: all mystic powers are under His control. In our experience, we can see many human beings who have yogic mystic power. Sometimes they perform very wonderful acts, but Kåñëa is understood to be the master of all mystic power. Therefore, when He saw that His horses were hesitant to proceed into the darkness, He immediately released His disc, known as the Sudarçana cakra, which illuminated the sky a thousand times brighter than sunlight. The darkness of the covering of the universe is also a creation of Kåñëa's, and the Sudarçana cakra is Kåñëa's constant companion. Thus the darkness was penetrated by His keeping the Sudarçana cakra in front. Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.89.50] states that the Sudarçana cakra penetrated the darkness just as an arrow released from the Çärìga bow of Lord Rämacandra penetrated the army of Rävaëa. Su means very nice, and darsana means observation; by the grace of Lord Kåñëa's disc, Sudarçana, everything can be seen very nicely, and nothing can remain in darkness. Thus Lord Kåñëa and Arjuna crossed over the great region of darkness covering the material universes.

Arjuna then saw the effulgence of light known as the brahmajyoti. The brahmajyoti is situated outside the covering of the material universes, and because it cannot be seen with our present eyes, this brahmajyoti is sometimes called avyakta. This spiritual effulgence is the ultimate destination of the impersonalists known as Vedäntists. The brahmajyoti is also described as anantapäram, unlimited and unfathomed. When Lord Kåñëa and Arjuna reached this region of the brahmajyoti, Arjuna could not tolerate the glaring effulgence, and he closed his eyes. Lord Kåñëa's and Arjuna's reaching the brahmajyoti region is described in Harivaàça. In that portion of the Vedic literature, Kåñëa informed Arjuna, "My dear Arjuna, the glaring effulgence, the transcendental light which you are seeing, is My bodily rays. O chief of the descendants of Bharata, this brahmajyoti is Myself." As the sun disc and the sunshine cannot be separated, similarly Kåñëa and His bodily rays, the brahmajyoti, cannot be separated. Thus Kåñëa claimed that the brahmajyoti is He Himself. This is clearly stated in the Harivaàça when Kåñëa says, "ahaà saù." The brahmajyoti is a combination of the minute particles known as spiritual sparks, or the living entities known as citkana. The Vedic word so'ham, or "I am the brahmajyoti," can also be applied to the living entities, who can also claim to belong to the brahmajyoti. In the Harivaàça, Kåñëa further explains, "This brahmajyoti is an expansion of My spiritual energy."

Kåñëa told Arjuna, "The brahmajyoti is beyond the region of My external energy, known as mäyä-çakti. When one is situated within this material world, it is not possible for him to experience this Brahman effulgence. Therefore, in the material world this effulgence is not manifested, whereas in the spiritual world, it is manifested. That is the purport of the words vyakta-avyakta. In the Bhagavad-gétä [8.20] it is said avyakto ’vyaktät sanätanaù: both these energies are eternally manifested.

After this, Lord Kåñëa and Arjuna entered a vast extensive spiritual water. This spiritual water is called the Käraëärëava Ocean or Virajä which means that this ocean is the origin of the creation of the material world. In the Måtyuïjaya Tantra, a Vedic literature, there is a vivid description of this Käraëa Ocean, or Virajä. It is stated there that the highest planetary system within the material world is Satyaloka, or Brahmaloka. Beyond that there are Rudraloka and Mahä-Viñëuloka. Regarding this Mahä-Viñëuloka, it is stated in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.47], yaù käraëärëava-jale bhajati sma yoga: "Lord Mahä-Viñëu is lying in the Käraëa Ocean. When He exhales, innumerable universes come into existence, and when He inhales, innumerable universes enter within Him." In this way, the material creation is generated and again withdrawn. When Lord Kåñëa and Arjuna entered the water, it appeared that there was a strong hurricane of transcendental effulgence brewing, and the water of the Käraëa Ocean was greatly agitated. By the grace of Lord Kåñëa, Arjuna had the unique experience of being able to see the very beautiful Käraëa Ocean.

Accompanied by Kåñëa, Arjuna saw a large palace within the water. There were many thousands of pillars and columns made of valuable jewels, and the glaring effulgence of those columns was so beautiful that Arjuna became charmed by it. Within that palace, Arjuna and Kåñëa saw the gigantic form of Anantadeva, who is also known as Çeña. Lord Anantadeva or Çeñanäga was in the form of a great serpent with thousands of hoods, and each one of them was decorated with valuable, effulgent jewels, which were beautifully dazzling. Each of Anantadeva's hoods had two eyes which appeared to be very fearful. His body was as white as the mountaintop of Kailäsa, which is always covered by snow. His neck was bluish, as were His tongues. Thus Arjuna saw the Çeñanäga form, and he also saw that on the very soft, white body of Çeñanäga, Lord Mahä-Viñëu was lying very comfortably. He appeared to be all-pervading and very powerful, and Arjuna could understand that the Supreme Personality of Godhead in that form is known as Puroñottama. He is known as Puruñottama, the best, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead, because from this form emanates another form of Viñëu, which is known as Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu within the material world. The Mahä-Viñëu form of the Lord, Puruñottama, is beyond the material world. He is also known as Uttama. Tama means darkness, and ut means above, transcendental; therefore, Uttama means above the darkest region of the material world. Arjuna saw that the bodily color of Puruñottama, Mahä-Viñëu, was as dark as a new cloud in the rainy season; He was dressed in very nice yellow clothing. His face was always beautifully smiling, and His eyes, which were like lotus petals, were very attractive. Lord Mahä-Viñëu's helmet was bedecked with valuable jewels, and His beautiful earrings enhanced the beauty of the curling hair on His head. Lord Mahä-Viñëu had eight arms, all very long, reaching to His knees. His neck was decorated with the Kaustubha jewel, and His chest was marked with the symbol of çrévatsa, which means the resting place of the goddess of fortune. The Lord wore a garland of lotus flowers down to His knees. This long garland is known as a vaijayanté garland.

The Lord was surrounded by His personal associates Nanda and Sunanda, and the personified Sudarçana disc was also standing by Him. As is stated in the Vedas, the Lord has innumerable energies, and they were also standing there personified. The most important among them were as follows: puñöi, the energy for nourishment, çré, the energy of beauty, kérti, the energy of reputation, and ajä, the energy of material creation. All these energies are invested in the administrators of the material world, namely Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva and Lord Viñëu, and in the kings of the heavenly planets, Indra, Candra, Varuëa and the sun-god. In other words, all these demigods, being empowered by the Lord with certain energies, engage in the transcendental loving service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Mahä-Viñëu feature is an expansion of Kåñëa's body. It is also confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.48] that Mahä-Viñëu is a portion of a plenary expansion of Kåñëa. All such expansions are nondifferent from the Personality of Godhead, but since Kåñëa appeared within this material world to manifest His pastimes as a human being, He and Arjuna immediately offered their respects to Lord Mahä-Viñëu by bowing down before Him. It is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.89.57] that Lord Kåñëa offered respect to Mahä-Viñëu; this means that He offered obeisances unto Him only because Lord Mahä-Viñëu is nondifferent from He Himself. This offering of obeisances by Kåñëa to Mahä-Viñëu is not, however, the form of worship known as ahaìgraha-upäsanä, which is sometimes recommended for persons who are trying to elevate themselves to the spiritual world by performing the sacrifice of knowledge. This is also stated in the Bhagavad-gétä: jïäna-yajïena cäpy ante yajanto mäm upäsate.

Although there was no necessity for Kåñëa to offer obeisances, because He is the master teacher, He taught Arjuna just how respect should be offered to Lord Mahä-Viñëu. Arjuna, however, became very much afraid upon seeing the gigantic form of everything, distinct from the material experience. Seeing Kåñëa offering obeisances to Lord Mahä-Viñëu, he immediately followed Him and stood before the Lord with folded hands. After this, the gigantic form of Mahä-Viñëu, greatly pleased, smiled pleasingly and spoke as follows.

"My dear Kåñëa and Arjuna, I was very anxious to see you both, and therefore I arranged to take away the babies of the brähmaëa and keep them here. I have been expecting to see you both at this palace. You have appeared in the material world as My incarnations in order to minimize the force of the demoniac persons who burden the world. Now after killing all these unwanted demons, you will please again come back to Me. Both of you are incarnations of the great sage Nara-Näräyaëa. Although you are both complete in yourselves, to protect the devotees and to annihilate the demons and especially to establish religious principles in the world so that peace and tranquility may continue, you are teaching the basic principles of factual religion so that the people of the world may follow you and thereby be peaceful and prosperous."

Both Lord Kåñëa and Arjuna then offered their obeisances to Lord Mahä-Viñëu, and taking back the brähmaëa's children, they returned to Dvärakä via the same route by which they had entered the spiritual world. All the children of the brähmaëa had duly grown up. After returning to Dvärakä, Lord Kåñëa and Arjuna delivered to the brähmaëa all of his sons.

Arjuna, however, was struck with great wonder after visiting the transcendental world by the grace of Lord Kåñëa. And by the grace of Kåñëa he could understand that whatever opulence there may be within this material world is an emanation from Him. Any opulent position a person may have within this material world is due to Kåñëa's mercy. One should therefore always be in Kåñëa consciousness, in complete gratefulness to Lord Kåñëa, because whatever one may possess is all His mercy.

Arjuna's wonderful experience due to the mercy of Kåñëa is one of the many thousands of pastimes performed by Lord Kåñëa during His stay in this material world. They were all unique and have no parallel in the history of the world. All these pastimes prove fully that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, yet while He was present within this material world, He played just like an ordinary man possessing many worldly duties. He played the part of an ideal householder, and although He possessed 16,000 wives, 16,000 palaces and 160,000 children, He also performed many sacrifices, just to teach the royal order how to live in the material world for the welfare of humanity. As the ideal Supreme Personality, He fulfilled the desires of everyone, from the brähmaëas, the highest persons in human society, down to the ordinary living entities, including the lowest of men. Just as King Indra is in charge of distributing rain all over the world to satisfy everyone in due course, so Lord Kåñëa satisfies everyone by pouring down His causeless mercy. His mission was to give protection to the devotees and to kill the demoniac kings; therefore, He killed many hundreds and thousands of demons. Some of them He killed personally, and some of them were killed by Arjuna, who was deputed by Kåñëa. In this way He established many pious kings such as Yudhiñöhira at the helm of world affairs. Thus, by His divine arrangement He created the good government of King Yudhiñöhira, and there ensued peace and tranquility.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Second Volume, Thirty-fourth Chapter, of Kåñëa, "The Superexcellent Power of Kåñëa."

KB 1970-2-35 / Summary Description of Lord Kåñëa's Pastimes

35 /Summary Description of Lord Kåñëa's Pastimes

After returning from the spiritual kingdom, which he was able to visit personally along with Kåñëa, Arjuna was very much astonished. He thought to himself that although he was only an ordinary living entity, by the grace of Kåñëa it had been possible for him to see personally the spiritual world. Not only had he seen the spiritual world, but he had also personally seen the original Mahä-Viñëu, the cause of the material creation. It is said that Kåñëa never goes out of Våndävana. Våndävanaà parityajya na pädam ekaà gacchati. Kåñëa is supreme in Mathurä, He is more supreme in Dvärakä, and He is most supreme in Våndävana. Kåñëa's pastimes in Dvärakä are displayed by His Väsudeva portion, yet there is no difference between the Väsudeva portion manifested in Mathurä and Dvärakä and the original manifestation of Kåñëa at Våndävana. In the beginning of this book we have discussed that when Kåñëa appears, all His incarnations, plenary portions and portions of the plenary portions come with Him. Thus some of His different pastimes are manifested not by the original Kåñëa Himself but by His different portions and plenary portions of incarnation. Arjuna was therefore puzzled about how Kåñëa went to see the Käraëärëavaçäyé Viñëu in the spiritual world. This is fully discussed in the commentaries of Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur.

It is understood from the speech of Mahä-Viñëu that He was very anxious to see Kåñëa. It may be said, however, that since Mahä-Viñëu took away the brähmaëa's sons, He certainly must have gone to Dvärakä to do so. Therefore, why did He not see Kåñëa there? A possible answer is that Kåñëa cannot be seen even by the Mahä-Viñëu who is lying in the Causal Ocean of the spiritual world, unless Kåñëa gives His permission. Thus Mahä-Viñëu took away the brähmaëa's sons one after another just after their births so that Kåñëa would come personally to retrieve them and then Mahä-Viñëu would be able to see Him there. If that is so, the next question is this: Why would Mahä-Viñëu come to Dvärakä personally if He were not able to see Kåñëa? Why did He not send some of His associates to take away the sons of the brähmaëa? A possible answer is that it is very difficult to put any of the citizens of Dvärakä into trouble in the presence of Kåñëa. Therefore, it was not possible for any of Mahä-Viñëu's associates to take away the brähmaëa's sons, and thus He personally came to take them.

Another question may also be raised: The Lord is known as brahmaëya-deva, the worshipable Deity of the brähmaëas, so why was He inclined to put a brähmaëa into such a terrible condition of lamentation over one son after another until the ninth son was taken away? The answer is that Lord Mahä-Viñëu was so anxious to see Kåñëa that He did not hesitate even to give trouble to a brähmaëa. Although giving trouble to a brähmaëa is a forbidden act, Lord Viñëu was prepared to do anything in order to see Kåñëa—He was so anxious to see Him. After losing each of his sons, the brähmaëa would come to the gate of the palace and accuse the King of not being able to give the brähmaëas protection and of thus being unfit to sit on the royal throne. It was Mahä-Viñëu's plan that the brähmaëa would accuse the kñatriyas and Kåñëa, and Kåñëa would be obliged to come see Him to take back the brähmaëa's sons.

Still another question may be raised: If Mahä-Viñëu cannot see Kåñëa, then how was Kåñëa obliged to come before Him after all to take back the sons of the brähmaëa? The answer is that Lord Kåñëa went to see Lord Mahä-Viñëu not exactly to take away the sons of the brähmaëa but only for Arjuna's sake. His friendship with Arjuna was so intimate that when Arjuna prepared himself to die by entering the fire, Kåñëa wanted to give him complete protection. Arjuna, however, would not desist from entering the fire unless the sons of the brähmaëa were brought back. Therefore Kåñëa promised him, "I will bring back the brähmaëa's sons. Do not try to commit suicide."

If Lord Kåñëa were going to see Lord Viñëu only to reclaim the sons of the brähmaëa, then He would not have waited until the ninth son was taken. But when the ninth son was taken away by Lord Mahä-Viñëu and Arjuna was therefore ready to enter the fire because his promise was going to prove false, that serious situation made Lord Kåñëa decide to go with Arjuna to see Mahä-Viñëu. It is said that Arjuna is an empowered incarnation of Nara-Näräyaëa. He is even sometimes called Nara-Näräyaëa. The Nara-Näräyaëa incarnation is also one of Lord Viñëu's plenary expansions. Therefore, when Kåñëa and Arjuna went to see Lord Viñëu, it is to be understood that Arjuna visited in His Nara-Näräyaëa capacity, just as Kåñëa, when He displayed His pastimes in Dvärakä, acted in His Väsudeva capacity.

After visiting the spiritual world, Arjuna concluded that whatever opulence anyone can show within the material or spiritual worlds is all a gift of Lord Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa is manifested in various forms, as Viñëu-tattva and jéva-tattva, or, in other words, as säàça and vibhinnäàça. Viñëu-tattva is known as säàça, and jéva-tattva is known as vibhinnäàça. He can, therefore, display Himself by His different transcendental pastimes, either in the portion of säàça or vibhinnäàça, as He likes, but still He remains the original Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The concluding portion of Kåñëa's pastimes is found in the Nintieth Chapter of the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and in this chapter Çukadeva Gosvämé wanted to explain how Kåñëa lived happily at Dvärakä with all opulences. Kåñëa's opulence of strength has already been displayed in His different pastimes, and now it will be shown how His residence at Dvärakä displayed His opulences of wealth and beauty. In this material world, which is only a perverted reflection of the spiritual world, the opulences of wealth and beauty are considered to be the highest of all opulences. Therefore, while Kåñëa stayed on this planet as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, His opulences of wealth and beauty had no comparison within the three worlds. Kåñëa enjoyed sixteen thousand beautiful wives, and it is most significant that He lived at Dvärakä as the only husband of these hundreds and thousands of beautiful women. It is specifically stated in this connection that He was the only husband of sixteen thousand wives. It is, of course, not unheard of in the history of the world that a powerful king would keep many hundreds of queens, but although such a king might be the only husband of so many wives, he could not enjoy all of them at one time. Kåñëa, however, enjoyed all of His sixteen thousand wives simultaneously.

Although it may be said that yogés also can expand their bodies into many forms, the yogis’ expansion and Lord Kåñëa's expansion are not one and the same. Kåñëa is therefore sometimes called yogeçvara, the master of all yogés. In the Vedic literature we find that the yogé Saubhari Muni expanded himself into eight. But that expansion was like a television expansion. The television image is manifested in millions of expansions, but those expansions cannot act differently; they are simply reflections of the original and can only act exactly as the original does. Kåñëa's expansion is not material like the expansion of the television or the yogé. When Närada visited the different palaces of Kåñëa, he saw that Kåñëa, in His different expansions, was variously engaged in each and every palace of the queens.

It is also said that Kåñëa lived at Dvärakä as the husband of the goddess of fortune. Queen Rukmiëé is the goddess of fortune, and all the other queens are her expansions. So Kåñëa, the chief of the Våñëi dynasty, enjoyed with the goddess of fortune in full opulence. The queens of Kåñëa are described as permanently youthful and beautiful. Although Kåñëa had grandchildren and great-grandchildren, neither Kåñëa nor His queens looked older than sixteen or twenty years of age. The young queens were so beautiful that when they moved they appeared like lightning moving in the sky. They were always dressed with exalted ornaments and garments and were always engaged in sportive activities like dancing, singing or playing ball on the roofs of the palaces. The dancing and tennis playing of girls in the material world appear to be perverted reflections of the original pastimes of the original Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, and His wives.

The roads and streets of the city of Dvärakä were always crowded with elephants, horses, chariots and infantry soldiers. When elephants are engaged in service, they are given liquor to drink, and it is said that the elephants in Dvärakä were given so much liquor that they would sprinkle a great quantity of it on the road and still would walk on the streets intoxicated. The infantry soldiers passing on the streets were profusely decorated with golden ornaments, and horses and golden chariots plied along the streets. In all directions of Dvärakä City, wherever one would turn his eyes he would find green parks and gardens, and each of them was filled with trees and plants laden with fruits and flowers. Because there were so many nice trees of fruits and flowers, all the sweetly chirping birds and the buzzing bumblebees joined together to make sweet vibrations. The city of Dvärakä thus fully displayed all opulences. The heroes in the dynasty of Yadu used to think themselves the most fortunate residents of the city, and actually they enjoyed all transcendental facilities.

All the sixteen thousand palaces of Kåñëa's queens were situated in this beautiful city of Dvärakä, and Lord Kåñëa, the supreme eternal enjoyer of all these facilities, expanded Himself into sixteen thousand forms and simultaneously engaged in different family affairs in those sixteen thousand palaces. In each and every one of the palaces there were nicely decorated gardens and lakes. The crystal clear water of the lakes contained many blooming lotus flowers of different colors like blue, yellow, white and red, and the saffron powder from the lotus flowers was blown all around by the breeze. All the lakes were full of beautiful swans, ducks and cranes, crying occasionally with melodious sounds. Lord Çré Kåñëa sometimes entered those lakes, or sometimes the rivers, with His wives and enjoyed swimming pastimes with them in full jubilation. Sometimes the wives of Lord Kåñëa, who were all goddesses of fortune, would embrace the Lord in the midst of the water while swimming or taking bath, and the red vermilion of kuìkuma decorating the beauty of their breasts would adorn the chest of the Lord with a reddish color.

The impersonalists would not dare to believe that in the spiritual world there are such varieties of enjoyment, but in order to demonstrate the factual, ever-blissful enjoyment in the spiritual world, Lord Kåñëa descended on this planet and showed that the spiritual world is not devoid of such pleasurable facilities of life. The only difference is that in the spiritual world such facilities are eternal, never-ending occurrences, whereas in the material world they are simply impermanent perverted reflections. When Lord Kåñëa was engaged in such enjoyment, the Gandharvas and professional musicians would glorify Him with melodious musical concerts, accompanied by mådaìgas, drums, kettledrums, stringed instruments and brass bugles, and the whole atmosphere would change into a greatly festive celebration. In a festive mood, the wives of the Lord would sometimes sprinkle water on the Lord's body with a syringe-like instrument, and the Lord would similarly wet the bodies of the queens. When Kåñëa and the queens engaged themselves in these pastimes, it seemed as if the heavenly King, Yakñaräja, were engaged in such pastimes with his many wives. (Yakñaräja is also known as Kuvera and is considered to be the treasurer of the heavenly kingdom.) When the wives of Lord Kåñëa thus became wet, their breasts and thighs would increase in beauty a thousand times, and their long hair would fall down to decorate those parts of their bodies. The beautiful flowers which were placed in their hair would fall, and the queens, being seemingly harassed by the Lord's throwing water at them, would approach Him on the plea of snatching the syringe-like instrument, and this attempt would create a situation wherein the Lord could embrace them as they willingly approached Him. Upon being embraced, the wives of the Lord would feel on their mouths a clear indication of conjugal love, and this would create an atmosphere of spiritual bliss. When the garland on the neck of the Lord then touched the breasts of the queens, their whole bodies became covered with saffron yellow. Being engaged in their celestial pastimes, the queens forgot themselves, and their loosened hair appeared like the beautiful waves of a river. When the queens sprinkled water on the body of Kåñëa or He sprinkled water on the bodies of the queens, the whole situation appeared just like an elephant enjoying in a lake along with many she-elephants.

After enjoying fully amongst themselves, the queens and Lord Kåñëa would come out of the water, and their wet garments, which were very valuable, would be given up by them to be taken away by the professional singers and dancers. These singers and dancers had no other means of subsistence than the rewards of valuable garments and ornaments left by the queens and kings on such occasions. The whole system of society was so well planned that all the members of society in their different positions as brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras had no difficulty in earning their livelihood. There was no competition among the divisions of society. The original conception of the caste system was so planned that one group of men engaged in a particular type of occupation would not compete with another group of men engaged in a different occupation.

In this way, Lord Kåñëa used to enjoy the company of His sixteen thousand wives. Devotees of the Lord who want to love the Supreme Personality of Godhead in the mellow of conjugal love are elevated to the position of becoming wives of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa also keeps them always attached to Him by His kind behavior. Kåñëa's behavior with His wives, His movements, His talking with them, His smiling, His embracing, and similar other activities just like a loving husband kept them always very much attached to Him. That is the highest perfection of life. If someone remains always attached to Kåñëa, it is to be understood that he is liberated, and his life is successful. With any devotee who loves Kåñëa with his heart and soul, Kåñëa reciprocates in such a way that the devotee cannot remain unattached to Him. The reciprocal dealings of Kåñëa and His devotees are so attractive that a devotee cannot think of any subject matter other than Kåñëa.

For all the queens, Kåñëa only was their worshipable objective. They were always absorbed in thought of Kåñëa, the lotus-eyed and beautifully blackish Personality of Godhead. Sometimes, in thought of Kåñëa, they remained silent, and in great ecstasy of bhäva and anubhäva they sometimes spoke as if in delirium. Sometimes, even in the presence of Lord Kåñëa, they vividly described the pastimes they had enjoyed in the lake or in the river with Him. Some of such talk may be described here.

One of the queens said to the bird kuraré, "My dear kuraré, now it is very late at night. Everyone is sleeping. The whole world is now calm and peaceful. At this time, the Supreme Personality of Godhead is sleeping, although His knowledge is undisturbed by any circumstance. Then why are you not sleeping? Why are you lamenting like this throughout the whole night? My dear friend, is it that you are also attracted by the lotus eyes of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and by His sweet smiling and attractive words, exactly as I am? Do those dealings of the Supreme Personality of Godhead pinch your heart as they do mine?

"Hello cakraväké. Why have you closed your eyes? Are you searching after your husband, who might have gone to foreign countries? Why are you lamenting so pitiably? Alas, it appears that you are very much aggrieved. Or is it a fact that you also are willing to become an eternal servitor of the Supreme Personality of Godhead? I think that you are anxious to put a garland on the lotus feet of the Lord and then place it on your hair.

"O my dear ocean, why are you roaring all day and night? Don't you like to sleep? I think that you have been attacked by insomnia, or, if I am not wrong, my dear Çyämasundara has tactfully taken away your gravity and power of forbearence, which are your natural qualifications. Is it a fact that for this reason you are suffering from insomnia like me? Yes, I admit that there is no remedy for this disease.

"My dear moon-god, I think that you have been attacked by a severe type of tuberculosis. For this reason, you are becoming thinner and thinner day by day. O my lord, you are now so weak that your thin rays cannot dissipate the darkness of night. Or is it a fact that, just as I have, you also have been stunned by the mysteriously sweet words of my Lord Çyämasundara. Is it a fact that it is because of this severe anxiety that you are so grave?

"O breeze from the Himalayas, what have I done to you that you are so intent on teasing me by awakening my lust to meet Kåñëa? Do you not know that I have already been injured by the crooked policy of the Personality of Godhead? My dear Himalayan breeze, please know that I have already been stricken. There is no need to injure me more and more.

"My dear beautiful cloud, the color of your beautiful body exactly resembles my dearmost Çyämasundara's bodily hue. I think, therefore, that you are very much dear to my Lord, the chief of the dynasty of the Yadus, and because you are so dear to Him, you are, exactly as I am, absorbed in meditation. I can appreciate that your heart is full of anxiety for Çyämasundara. You appear to be excessively eager to see Him, and I see that for this reason only, there are drops of tears gliding down from your eyes, just as there are from mine. My dear black cloud, we must admit frankly that to establish an intimate relationship with Çyämasundara means to purchase unnecessary anxieties while we are otherwise comfortable at home."

Generally the cuckoo sounds its cooing vibration at the end of night or early in the morning. When the queens heard the cooing of the cuckoo at the end of night, they said, "Dear cuckoo, your voice is very sweet. As soon as you vibrate your sweet voice, we immediately remember Çyämasundara because your voice exactly resembles His. We must frankly admit that your voice is imbued with nectar, and it is so invigorating that it is competent to bring back life to those who are almost dead in separation from their dearmost friend. So we are very much obliged to you. Please let us know how we can welcome you or how we can do something for you."

The queens continued talking like that, and they addressed the mountain as follows: "Dear mountain, you are very generous. By your gravitation only, the whole crust of this earth is properly maintained, and because you are discharging your duties very faithfully, you do not know how to move. Because you are so grave, you do not move hither and thither, nor do you say anything. Rather, you always appear to be in a thoughtful mood. It may be that you are always thinking of a very grave and important subject matter, but we can guess very clearly what you are thinking of. We are sure that you are thinking of placing the lotus feet of Çyämasundara on your raised peaks, as we want to place His lotus feet on our raised breasts.

"Dear dry rivers, we know that because this is the summer season, all your beds are dry and you have no water. Because all your water has now been dried up, you are no longer beautified by blooming lotus flowers. At the present moment, you appear to be very lean and thin, so we can understand that your position is exactly like ours. We have lost everything due to being separated from Çyämasundara, and we no longer hear His pleasing words. Our hearts no longer work properly, and therefore we also have become very lean and thin. We think, therefore, that you are just like us. You have turned lean and thin because you are not getting any water from your husband, the ocean, through the clouds." The example given herewith by the queens is very appropriate. The river beds become dry when the ocean no longer supplies water through the clouds. The ocean is supposed to be the husband of the river and therefore is supposed to support her. Unless a woman is supported by the husband with the necessities of life, she also becomes as dry as a dry river.

One queen addressed a swan as follows. "My dear swan, please come here, come here. You are welcome. Please sit down and take some milk. My dear swan, can you tell me if you have any message from Çyämasundara? I take you to be a messenger from Him. If you have any such news, please tell me. Our Çyämasundara is always very independent. He never comes under the control of anyone. We have all failed to control Him, and therefore we ask you, is He keeping Himself well? I may inform you that Çyämasundara is very fickle. His friendship is always temporary; it breaks even by slight agitation. But would you kindly explain why He is so unkind to me? Formerly He said that I alone am His dearmost wife. Does He remember this assurance? Anyway, you are welcome. Please sit down. But I cannot accept your entreaty to go to Çyämasundara. When He does not care for me, why should I be mad after Him? I am very sorry to let you know that you have become the messenger of a poor-hearted soul. You are asking me to go to Him, but I am not going. What is that? You talk of His coming to me? Does He desire to come here to fulfill my long expectation for Him? All right. You can bring Him here. But don't bring with Him His most beloved goddess of fortune. Do you think that He cannot be separated from the goddess of fortune even for a moment? Could He not come here alone, without Lakñmé? His behavior is very displeasing. Does it mean that without Lakñmé, Çyämasundara cannot be happy? Can't He be happy with any other wife? Does it mean that the goddess of fortune has the ocean of love for Him, and none of us can compare to her?"

All the wives of Lord Kåñëa were completely absorbed in thought of Him. Kåñëa is known as the yogeçvara, the master of all yogés, and all the wives of Kåñëa at Dvärakä used to keep this yogeçvara within their hearts. Instead of trying to be master of all yogic mystic powers, it is better if one simply keeps the supreme yogeçvara, Kåñëa, within his heart. Thus one's life can become perfect, and one can very easily be transferred to the kingdom of God. It is to be understood that all the queens of Kåñëa who lived with Him at Dvärakä were in their previous lives very greatly exalted devotees who wanted to establish a relationship with Kåñëa in conjugal love. Thus they were given the chance to become His wives and enjoy a constant loving relationship with Him. Ultimately, they were all transferred to the Vaikuëöha planets.

The Supreme Absolute Truth Personality of Godhead is never impersonal. All the Vedic literatures glorify the transcendental performance of His various personal activities and pastimes. It is said that in the Vedas and in the Ramäyäëa, only the activities of the Lord are described. Everywhere in the Vedic literature, His glories are sung. As soon as soft-hearted people such as women hear those transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa, they immediately become attracted to Him. Soft-hearted women and girls are therefore very easily drawn to the Kåñëa consciousness movement. One who is thus drawn to the Kåñëa consciousness movement and tries to keep himself in constant touch with such consciousness certainly gets the supreme salvation, going back to Kåñëa at Goloka Våndävana. If simply by developing Kåñëa consciousness one can be transferred to the spiritual world, one can simply imagine how blissful and blessed were the queens of Lord Kåñëa, who talked with Him personally and who saw Lord Kåñëa eye to eye. No one can properly describe the fortune of the wives of Lord Kåñëa. They took care of Him personally by rendering various transcendental services like bathing Him, feeding Him, pleasing Him and serving Him. Thus no one's austerities can compare to the service of the queens at Dvärakä.

Çukadeva Gosvämé informed Mahäräja Parékñit that for self-realization the austerities and penances performed by the queens at Dvärakä have no comparison. The objective of self-realization is one: Kåñëa. Therefore, although the dealings of the queens with Kåñëa appear just like ordinary dealings between husband and wife, the principal point to be observed is the queens' attachment for Kåñëa. The entire process of austerity and penance is meant to detach one from the material world and to enhance one's attachment to Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa is the shelter of all persons advancing in self-realization. As an ideal householder, He lived with His wives and performed the Vedic rituals just to show less intelligent persons that the Supreme Lord is never impersonal. Kåñëa lived with wife and children in all opulence, exactly like an ordinary conditioned soul, just to exemplify to those souls who are actually conditioned that one may enter into the circle of family life as long as Kåñëa is the center. For example, the members of the Yadu dynasty lived in the family of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa was the center of all their activities.

Renunciation is not as important as enhancing one's attachment to Kåñëa. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is especially meant for this purpose. We are preaching on the principle that it does not matter whether a man is a sannyäsé or gåhastha. One simply has to increase his attachment for Kåñëa, and then his life is successful. Following in the footsteps of Lord Çré Kåñëa, one can live with his family members or within the society or nation, not for the purpose of indulging in sense gratification but to realize Kåñëa by advancing in attachment for Him. There are four principles of elevation from conditional life to the life of liberation, which are technically known as dharma, artha, käma and mokña (religion, economic development, sense gratification and liberation). If one lives a family life following in the footsteps of Lord Kåñëa's family members, one can achieve all four of these principles of success simultaneously by making Kåñëa the center of all activities.

It is already known to us that Kåñëa had 16,108 wives. All these wives were exalted liberated souls, and among them Queen Rukmiëé was the chief. After Rukmiëé there were seven other principal wives, and the names of the sons of these eight principal queens have already been mentioned. Besides these eight queens, Lord Kåñëa had ten sons by each of the other queens. Thus all together Kåñëa's children numbered 16,108 times ten. One should not be astonished to hear that Kåñëa had so many sons. One should always remember that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and that He has unlimited potencies. He claims all living entities as His sons, so even if He had sixteen million sons attached to Him personally, there would be no cause for astonishment.

Among Kåñëa's greatly powerful sons, eighteen sons were mahä-rathas. The mahä-rathas could fight alone against many thousands of soldiers, charioteers, cavalry and elephants. The reputations of these eighteen sons are very widespread and are described in almost all the Vedic literatures. The eighteen mahä-ratha sons are listed as Pradyumna, Aniruddha, Déptimän, Bhänu, Sämba, Madhu, Båhadbhänu, Citrabhänu, Våka, Aruëa, Puñkara, Vedabähu, Çrutadeva, Sunandana, Citrabähu, Virüpa, Kavi and Nyagrodha. Of these eighteen mahä-ratha sons of Kåñëa, Pradyumna is considered to be the foremost. Pradyumna happened to be the eldest son of Queen Rukmiëé, and he inherited all the qualities of his great father, Lord Kåñëa. He married the daughter of his maternal uncle, Rukmé, and Aniruddha, the son of Pradyumna, was born from that marriage. Aniruddha was so powerful that he could fight against ten thousand elephants. He married the granddaughter of Rukmé, the brother of his grandmother, Rukmiëé. Because the relationship between these cousins was distant, such a marriage was not uncommon. Aniruddha's son was Vajra. When the whole Yadu dynasty was destroyed by the curse of a brähmaëa, only Vajra survived. Vajra had one son whose name was Pratibähu. The son of Pratibähu was named Subähu, the son of Subähu was named Çäntasena, and the son of Çäntasena was Çatasena.

It is stated by Çukadeva Gosvämé that all the members of the Yadu dynasty had many children. Just as Kåñëa had many sons, grandsons and great-grandsons, so each one of the kings named herewith also had similar family extensions. Not only did all of them have many children, but all were extraordinarily rich and opulent. None of them were weak or short-lived, and above all, all the members of the Yadu dynasty were staunch devotees of the brahminical culture. It is the duty of the kñatriya kings to maintain the brahminical culture and to protect the qualified brähmaëas, and all these kings discharged their duties very rightly. The members of the Yadu dynasty were so numerous that it would be very difficult to describe them all even if one had a duration of life of many thousands of years. Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé informed Mahäräja Parékñit that he had heard from reliable sources that simply to teach the children of the Yadu dynasty, there were as many as 38,800,000 tutors or äcäryas. If so many teachers were needed to educate their children, one can simply imagine how vast was the number of family members. As for their military strength, it is said that King Ugrasena alone had ten quadrillion soldiers as personal bodyguards.

Before the advent of Lord Kåñëa within this universe, there were many battles between the demons and the demigods. Many demons died in the fighting, and they all were given the chance to take birth in high royal families on this earth. Because of their royal exalted posts, all these demons became very much puffed up, and their only business was to harass their subjects. Lord Kåñëa appeared on this planet just at the end of Dväpara-yuga in order to annihilate all these demonic kings. As it is said in the Bhagavad-gétä, pariträëäya sädhünäà véëäçäya ca duñkåtäm: The Lord comes to protect the devotees and to annihilate the miscreants. Some of the demigods were also asked to appear on this earth to assist in the transcendental pastimes of Lord Kåñëa. When Kåñëa appeared, He came in the association of His eternal servitors, but the demigods also were requested to come down to assist Him, and thus all of them took their births in the Yadu dynasty. The Yadu dynasty had 101 clans in different parts of the country. All the members of these different clans respected Lord Kåñëa in a manner befitting His divine position, and all of them were His devotees heart and soul. Thus all the members of the Yadu dynasty were very opulent, happy and prosperous, and they had no anxieties. Because of their implicit faith in and devotion to Lord Kåñëa, they were never defeated by any other kings. Their love of Kåñëa was so intense that in their regular activities—in sitting, sleeping, traveling, talking, sporting, cleansing and bathing—they were simply absorbed in thoughts of Kåñëa and paid no attention to bodily necessities. That is the symptom of a pure devotee of Lord Kåñëa. Just as when a man is fully absorbed in some particular thought, he sometimes forgets his other bodily activities, so the members of the Yadu dynasty acted automatically for their bodily necessities, but their actual attention was always fixed on Kåñëa. Their bodily activities were performed mechanically, but their minds were always absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness.

Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé has concluded the Ninetieth Chapter of the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam by pointing out five particular excellences of Lord Kåñëa. The first excellence is that before Lord Kåñëa's appearance in the Yadu family, the River Ganges was known as the purest of all things; even impure things could be purified simply by touching the water of the Ganges. This superexcellent power of the Ganges water was due to its having emanated from the toe of Lord Viñëu. But when Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Viñëu, appeared in the family of the Yadu dynasty, He traveled personally throughout the kingdom of the Yadus, and by His intimate association with the Yadu dynasty, the whole family not only became very famous but also became more effective in purifying others than the water of the Ganges.

The next excellence of Lord Kåñëa's appearance was that although apparently He gave protection to the devotees and annihilated the demons, both the devotees and the demons achieved the same result. Lord Kåñëa is the bestower of five kinds of liberation, of which säyujya-mukti, or the liberation of becoming one with the Supreme, was given to the demons like Kaàsa, whereas the gopés were given the chance to associate with Him personally. The gopés kept their individuality to enjoy the company of Lord Kåñëa, but Kaàsa was accepted into His impersonal brahmajyoti. In other words, both the demons and the gopés were spiritually liberated, but because the demons were enemies and the gopés were friends, the demons were killed and the gopés were protected.

The third excellence of Lord Kåñëa's appearance was that the goddess of fortune, who is worshiped by demigods like Lord Brahmä, Indra and Candra, remained always engaged in the service of the Lord, even though the Lord gave more preference to the gopés. Lakñméjé, the goddess of fortune, tried her best to be on an equal level with the gopés, but she was not successful. Nevertheless, she remained faithful to Kåñëa, although generally she does not remain at one place even if worshiped by demigods like Lord Brahmä.

The fourth excellence of Lord Kåñëa's appearance concerns the glories of His name. It is stated in the Vedic literature that by chanting the different names of Lord Viñëu a thousand times, one may be bestowed with the same benefits as by thrice chanting the holy name of Lord Räma. And by chanting the holy name of Lord Kåñëa only once, one receives the same benefit. In other words, of all the holy names of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, including Viñëu and Räma, the holy name of Kåñëa is the most powerful. The Vedic literature therefore specifically stresses the chanting of the holy name of Kåñëa: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Lord Caitanya introduced this chanting of the holy name of Kåñëa in this age, thus making liberation more easily obtainable than in other ages. In other words, Lord Kåñëa is more excellent than His other incarnations, although all of them are equally the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The fifth excellence of Lord Kåñëa's appearance is that He established the most excellent of all religious principles by His one statement in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66] that simply by surrendering unto Him, one can discharge all the principles of religious rites. In the Vedic literature there are twenty kinds of religious principles mentioned, and each of them is described in different çästras. But Lord Kåñëa is so kind to the fallen conditioned souls of this age that He personally appeared and asked everyone to give up all kinds of religious rites and simply surrender unto Him. It is said that this age of Kali is three-fourths devoid of religious principles. Hardly one fourth of the principles of religion are still observed in this age. But by the mercy of Lord Kåñëa, this vacancy of Kali-yuga has not only been completely filled, but the religious process has been made so easy that simply by rendering transcendental loving service unto Lord Kåñëa by chanting His holy names, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, one can achieve the highest result of religion, namely, being transferred to the highest planet within the spiritual world, Goloka Våndävana. One can thus immediately estimate the benefit of Lord Kåñëa's appearance and can understand that His giving relief to the people of the world by His appearance was not at all extraordinary.

Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé thus concludes his description of the superexalted position of Lord Kåñëa by glorifying Him in the following way: "O Lord Kåñëa, all glories unto You. You are present in everyone's heart as Paramätmä. Therefore You are known as Jananiväsa, one who lives in everyone's heart." As confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä, éçvaraù sarva-bhütänaà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati: The Supreme Lord in His Paramätmä feature lives within everyone's heart. This does not mean, however, that Kåñëa has no separate existence as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Mäyävädé philosophers accept the all-pervading feature of Parabrahman, but when Parabrahman, or the Supreme Lord, appears, they think that He appears under the control of material nature. Because Lord Kåñëa appeared as the son of Devaké, the Mäyävädé philosophers accept Kåñëa to be an ordinary living entity who takes birth within this material world. Therefore Çukadeva Gosvämé warns them that devaké-janma-väda [10.90.48], which means that although Kåñëa is famous as the son of Devaké, actually He is the Supersoul or the all-pervading Supreme Personality of Godhead. The devotees, however, take this word devaké-janma-väda in a different way. The devotees understand that actually Kåñëa was the son of mother Yaçodä. Although Kåñëa first of all appeared as the son of Devaké, He immediately transferred Himself to the lap of mother Yaçodä, and His childhood pastimes were blissfully enjoyed by mother Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja. This fact was also admitted by Vasudeva himself when he met Nanda Mahäräja and Yaçodä at Kurukñetra. He admitted that Kåñëa and Balaräma were actually the sons of mother Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja. Vasudeva and Devaké were only Their official father and mother. Their actual father and mother were Nanda and Yaçodä. Therefore Çukadeva Gosvämé addressed Lord Kåñëa as devaké-janma-väda.

Çukadeva Gosvämé then glorifies the Lord as one who is honored by the yadu-vara-pariñat, the assembly house of the Yadu dynasty, and as the killer of different kinds of demons. Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, could have killed all the demons by employing His different material energies, but He wanted to kill them personally in order to give them salvation. There was no need of Kåñëa's coming to this material world to kill the demons. Simply by His willing, many hundreds and thousands of demons could have been killed without His personal endeavor. But actually He descended for His pure devotees, to play as a child with mother Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja and to give pleasure to the inhabitants of Dvärakä. By killing the demons and by giving protection to the devotees, Lord Kåñëa established the real religious principle, which is simply love of God. By following the factual religious principles of love of God, even the living entities known as sthira-cara were also delivered of all material contamination and were transferred to the spiritual kingdom. Sthira means the trees and plants, which cannot move, and cara means the moving animals, specifically the cows. When Kåñëa was present, He delivered all the trees, monkeys and other plants and animals who happened to see Him and serve Him both in Våndävana and in Dvärakä.

Lord Kåñëa is especially glorified for His giving pleasure to the gopés and the queens of Dvärakä. Çukadeva Gosvämé glorifies Lord Kåñëa for His enchanting smile, by which He enchanted not only the gopés at Våndävana but also the queens at Dvärakä. The exact word used in this connection is vardhayan kämadevam. In Våndävana as the boy friend of many gopés and in Dvärakä as the husband of many queens, Kåñëa increased their lusty desires to enjoy with Him. For God realization or self-realization, one generally has to undergo severe austerities and penances for many, many thousands of years, and then it may be possible to realize God. But the gopés and the queens of Dvärakä, simply by enhancing their lusty desires to enjoy Kåñëa as their boy friend or husband, received the highest type of salvation.

This behavior of Lord Kåñëa with the gopés and queens is unique in the history of self-realization. Usually people understand that for self-realization one has to go to the forest or to the mountains and undergo severe austerities and penances. But the gopés and the queens, simply by being attached to Kåñëa in conjugal love and enjoying His company in a so-called sensuous life full of luxury and opulence, achieved the highest salvation, which is impossible to be achieved even by great sages and saintly persons. Similarly, the demons such as Kaàsa, Dantavakra, Çiçupäla, etc., also got the highest benefit of being transferred to the spiritual world.

In the beginning of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çréla Vyäsadeva offered his respectful obeisances to the Supreme Truth, Väsudeva, Kåñëa. After that he taught his son, Çukadeva Gosvämé, to preach Çrémad-Bhägavatam. It is in this connection that Çukadeva Gosvämé glorifies the Lord as jayati. Following in the footsteps of Çréla Vyäsadeva, Çukadeva Gosvämé and all the äcäryas in disciplic succession, the whole population of the world should glorify Lord Kåñëa, and for their best interest they should take to this Kåñëa consciousness movement. The process is easy and helpful. It is simply to chant the mahämantra, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Lord Caitanya has therefore recommended that one should be callous to the material ups and downs. Material life is temporary, and so the ups and downs of life may come and go. When they come, one should be as tolerant as a tree and as humble and meek as the straw in the street, but certainly he must engage himself in Kåñëa consciousness by chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, the Supersoul of all living entities, out of His causeless mercy comes down and manifests His different transcendental pastimes in different incarnations. Hearing the attractive pastimes of Lord Kåñëa's different incarnations is a chance for liberation for the conditioned soul, and the most fascinating and pleasing activities of Lord Kåñëa Himself are still more attractive because Lord Kåñëa personally is all-attractive.

Following in the holy footsteps of Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé, we have tried to present this book Kåñëa for being read and heard by the conditioned souls of this age. By hearing the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa, one is sure and certain to get salvation and be transferred back home, back to Godhead. It is recommended by Çukadeva Gosvämé that as we hear the transcendental pastimes and activities of the Lord, we gradually cut the knots of material contamination. Therefore, regardless of what one is, if one wants the association of Lord Kåñëa in the transcendental kingdom of God for eternity in blissful existence, one must hear about the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa and chant the mahämantra, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

The transcendental pastimes of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa are so powerful that simply by hearing, reading and memorizing this book Kåñëa, one is sure to be transferred to the spiritual world, which is ordinarily very difficult to achieve. The description of the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa is so attractive that automatically it gives us an impetus to study repeatedly, and the more we study the pastimes of the Lord, the more we become attached to Him. This very attachment to Kåñëa makes one eligible to be transferred to His abode, Goloka Våndävana. As we have learned from the previous chapter, to cross over the material world is to cross over the stringent laws of material nature. The stringent laws of material nature cannot check the progress of one who is attracted by the spiritual nature. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.14] by the Lord Himself: although the stringent laws of material nature are very difficult to overcome, if anyone surrenders unto the Lord, he can very easily cross over nescience. There is, however, no influence of material nature in the spiritual world. As we have learned from the Second Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the ruling power of the demigods and the influence of material nature are conspicuous by their absence in the spiritual world.

Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé has therefore advised Mahäräja Parékñit in the beginning of the Second Canto that every conditioned soul should engage himself in hearing and chanting the transcendental pastimes of the Lord. Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé also informed King Parékñit that previously many other kings and emperors went to the jungle to prosecute severe austerities and penances in order to go back home, back to Godhead. In India, it is still a practice that many advanced transcendentalists give up their family lives and go to Våndävana to live there alone and completely engage in hearing and chanting of the holy pastimes of the Lord. This system is recommended in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and the six Gosvämés of Våndävana followed it, but at the present moment many karmés and pseudo-devotees have overcrowded the holy place of Våndävana just to imitate this process recommended by Çukadeva Gosvämé. It is said that many kings and emperors formerly went to the forest for this purpose, but Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkur Gosvämé Mahäräja does not recommend that one take up this solitary life in Våndävana prematurely.

One who goes prematurely to Våndävana to live in pursuance of the instructions of Çukadeva Gosvämé again falls a victim of mäyä, even while residing in Våndävana. To check such unauthorized residence in Våndävana, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkur has sung a nice song in this connection, the purport of which is as follows: "My dear mind, why are you so proud of being a Vaiñëava? Your solitary worship and chanting of the holy name of the Lord are based on a desire for cheap popularity, and therefore your chanting of the holy name is only a pretension. Such an ambition for a cheap reputation can be compared to the stool of a hog because such popularity is another extension of the influence of mäyä." One may go to Våndävana for cheap popularity, and instead of being absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness, one may always think of money and women, which are simply temporary sources of happiness. It is better that one engage whatever money and women he may have in his possession in the service of the Lord because sense enjoyment is not for the conditioned soul.

The master of the senses is Håñékeça, Lord Kåñëa. Therefore, the senses should always be engaged in His service. As for material reputation, there were many demons like Rävaëa who wanted to go against the laws of material nature, but they all failed. One should therefore not take to the demoniac activity of claiming to be a Vaiñëava just for false prestige, without performing service to the Lord. But when one engages oneself in the devotional service of the Lord, automatically the Vaiñëava reputation comes to him. There is no need to be envious of the devotees who are engaged in preaching the glories of the Lord. We have practical experience of being advised by the so-called bäbäjés in Våndävana that there is no need to preach and that it is better to live in Våndävana in a solitary place and chant the holy name. Such bäbäjés do not know that if one is engaged in preaching work or in glorifying the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the good reputation of a preacher automatically follows one. One should not, therefore, prematurely give up the honest life of a householder to lead a life of debauchery in Våndävana. Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé's recommendation to leave home and go to the forest in search of Kåñëa is not for immature persons. Mahäräja Parékñit was mature. Even in his householder life, or from the very beginning of his life, he worshiped Lord Kåñëa's mürti. In his childhood he worshiped the Deity of Lord Kåñëa, and later, although he was a householder, he was always detached, and therefore when he got the notice of his death, he immediately gave up all connection with household life and sat down on the bank of the Ganges to hear Çrémad-Bhägavatam in the association of devotees.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta purport of the Ninetieth Chapter of Kåñëa, "Summary Description of Lord Kåñëa's Pastimes."

Thus ends Volume Two of Krsna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The Nectar of Devotion - 1970 Edition


NoD-1970: Front Flap

Front Flap & pages

The Nectar of Devotion is a unique spiritual text that explains the devotional science of bhakti-yoga, or Kåñëa consciousness. Astonishingly intimate in its detailed descriptions of the loving relationships between Lord Çré Kåñëa and His devotees, it is at the same time practical, authoritative and philosophically substantial. It is a summary study of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, which was written in Sanskrit over 400 years ago by the great philosopher-devotee Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda, and it contains hundreds of quotes from such important Vedic literatures as Bhagavad-gétä, Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the Upaniñads, Mahäbhärata and the Puräëas.

The Nectar of Devotion has been called the "lawbook of Kåñëa consciousness," for it is the text which guides the devotees of the Hare Kåñëa movement in the details of their daily lives. It elaborately explains the philosophical background behind the many rules and regulations that devotees of Kåñëa voluntarily follow, and it probes deeply into the thoughts and emotions that motivate a Kåñëa conscious devotee.

Most importantly, The Nectar of Devotion goes beyond the limitations of both empty religious sentiment and dry, impersonal philosophy. It brings the reader to a factual understanding of the eternal activities of the spiritual world and offers practical step-by-step instructions which can enable the serious student to actually enter into these pastimes, in a personal, face-to-face loving relationship with Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

THE NECTAR OF DEVOTION
A Summary Study of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé's
Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu


A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness


ISKCON PRESS
38 North Beacon Street
Boston, Massachusetts 02134


Copyright © 1970 by ISKCONPRESS
Library of Congress Catalogue Card Number: 78-118082
All Rights Reserved
Printed in the United States of America by ISKCON PRESS
Boston, Massachusetts


To the Six Gosvämés of Våndävana

nänä-çästra-vicäraëaika-nipuëau sad-dharma-saàsthäpakau
lokänäà hitakäriëau tribhuvane mänyau çaraëyäkarau
rädhä-kåñëa-padäravinda-bhajanänandena mattälikau
vande rüpa-sanätanau raghuyugau çré-jéva-gopälakau.
[Ñaò-gosvämy-añöaka 2]

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who are very expert in scrutinizingly studying all the revealed scriptures with the aim of establishing eternal religious principles for the benefit of all human beings. Thus they are honored all over the three worlds, and they are worth taking shelter of because they are absorbed in the mood of the gopés and are engaged in the transcendental loving service of Rädhä and Kåñëa."

NoD-1970: Preface

Preface

The Nectar of Devotion is a summary study of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, which was written in Sanskrit by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda. He was the chief of the six Gosvämés who were the direct disciples of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. When he first met Lord Caitanya, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda was engaged as a minister in the Mohammedan government of Bengal. He and his brother Sanätana were then named Säkara Mallik and Dabir Khäs respectively, and they held responsible posts as ministers of Nawab Hussain Shah. At that time, five hundred years ago, the Hindu society was very rigid, and if a member of the brähmaëa caste accepted the service of a Mohammedan ruler he was at once rejected from brähmaëa society. That was the position of the two brothers, Dabir Khäs and Säkara Mallik. They belonged to the highly situated särasvata-brähmaëa community, but they were ostracized due to their acceptance of ministerial posts in the government of Hussain Shah. It is the grace of Lord Caitanya that He accepted these two exalted personalities as His disciples and raised them to the position of gosvämés, the highest position of brahminical culture. Similarly, Lord Caitanya accepted Haridäsa Thäkur as His disciple although he happened to be born of a Mohammedan family, and Lord Caitanya later on made him the äcärya of the chanting of the holy name of the Lord: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

Lord Caitanya's principle is universal. Anyone who knows the science of Kåñëa and is engaged in the service of the Lord is accepted as being in a higher position than a person born in the family of a brähmaëa. That is the original principle accepted by all Vedic literatures, especially by the Bhagavad-gétä and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The principle of Lord Caitanya's movement in educating and elevating everyone to the exalted post of a gosvämé is taught in The Nectar of Devotion.

Lord Caitanya met the two brothers, Dabir Khäs and Säkara Mallik, in a village known as Rämakeli in the district of Maldah, and after that meeting the brothers decided to retire from government service and join Lord Caitanya. Säkara Mallik, who was later to become Rüpa Gosvämé, retired from his post and collected all the money he had accumulated during his service. It is described in the Caitanya-caritämåta that his accumulated savings in gold coins equalled millions of dollars and filled a large boat. He divided the money in a very exemplary manner which should be followed by devotees in particular and by humanity in general. Fifty percent of his accumulated wealth was distributed to the Kåñëa conscious persons, namely the brähmaëas and the Vaiñëavas; twenty-five percent was distributed to relatives; and twenty-five percent was kept against emergency expenditures and personal difficulties. Later on when Dabir Khäs also proposed to retire, the Nawab was very much agitated and put him into jail. But Dabir Khäs, who was later to become Çréla Sanätana Gosvämé, took advantage of his brother's personal money, which had been deposited with a village banker, and escaped from the prison of Hussain Shah. In this way both brothers joined Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu.

Rüpa Gosvämé first met Lord Caitanya at Prayäg (Allahabad, India), and on the Daçäçvamedha bathing ghat of that holy city the Lord instructed him continually for ten days. The Lord particularly instructed Rüpa Gosvämé on the science of Kåñëa consciousness. These teachings of Lord Caitanya to Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda are narrated in our book Teachings of Lord Caitanya.

Later, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda elaborated the teachings of the Lord with profound knowledge of revealed scriptures and authoritative references from various Vedic literatures. Çréla Çréniväsa Äcärya describes in his prayers to the six Gosvämés that they were all highly learned scholars, not only in Sanskrit but also in foreign languages such as Persian and Arabian. They very scrutinizingly studied all the Vedic scriptures in order to establish the cult of Caitanya Mahäprabhu on the authorized principles of Vedic knowledge. The present Kåñëa consciousness movement is also based on the authority of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda. We are therefore generally known as rüpänugas, or followers in the footsteps of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda. It is only for our guidance that Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé prepared his book Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, which is now presented in the form of The Nectar of Devotion. Persons engaged in the Kåñëa consciousness movement may take advantage of this great literature and be very solidly situated in Kåñëa consciousness.

Bhakti means devotional service. Every service has some attractive feature which drives the servitor progressively on and on. Every one of us within this world is perpetually engaged in some sort of service, and the impetus for such service is the pleasure we derive from it. Driven by affection for his wife and children, a family man works day and night. A philanthropist works in the same way for love of the greater family, and a nationalist for the cause of his country and countrymen. That force which drives the philanthropist, the householder and the nationalist is called rasa, or a kind of mellow (relationship) whose taste is very sweet. Bhakti-rasa is a mellow different from the ordinary rasa enjoyed by mundane workers. Mundane workers labor very hard day and night in order to relish a certain kind of rasa which is understood as sense gratification. The relish or taste of the mundane rasa does not long endure, and therefore mundane workers are always apt to change their position of enjoyment. A businessman is not satisfied by working the whole week; therefore, wanting a change for the weekend, he goes to a place where he tries to forget his business activities. Then, after the weekend is spent in forgetfulness, he again changes his position and resumes his actual business activities. Material engagment means accepting a particular status for some time and then changing it. This position of changing back and forth is technically known as bhoga-tyäga, which means a position of alternating sense enjoyment and renunciation. A living entity cannot steadily remain either in sense enjoyment or in renunciation. Change is going on perpetually, and we cannot be happy in either state because of our eternal constitutional position. Sense gratification does not endure for long, and it is therefore called capala-sukha, or flickering happiness. For example, an ordinary family man who works very hard day and night and is successful in giving comforts to the members of his family thereby relishes a kind of mellow, but his whole advancement of material happiness immediately terminates along with his body as soon as his life is over. Death is therefore taken as the representative of God for the atheistic class of men. The devotee realizes the presence of God by devotional service, whereas the atheist realizes the presence of God in the shape of death. At death everything is finished, and one has to begin a new chapter of life in a new situation, perhaps higher or lower than the last one. In any field of activity, political, social, national or international, the result of our actions will be finished with the end of life. That is sure.

Bhakti-rasa, however, the mellow relished in the transcendental loving service of the Lord, does not finish with the end of life. It continues perpetually and is therefore called amåta, that which does not die but exists eternally. This is confirmed in all Vedic literatures. The Bhagavad-gétä says that a little advancement in bhakti-rasa can save the devotee from the greatest danger, that of missing the opportunity for human life. The rasas derived from our feelings in social life, in family life, or in the greater family life of altruism, philanthropism, nationalism, socialism, communism, etc., do not guarantee that one's next life will be as a human being. We prepare our next life by our actual activities in the present life. A living entity is offered a particular type of body as a result of his action in the present body. These activities are taken into account by a superior authority known as daiva, or the authority of God. This daiva is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä as the prime cause of everything, and in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that a man takes his next body by daiva-netreëa, which means by the supervision of the authority of the Supreme. In an ordinary sense daiva is explained as destiny. Daiva supervision gives us a body selected from 8,400,000 forms; the choice does not depend on our selection, but is awarded to us according to our destiny. If our body at present is engaged in the activities of Kåñëa consciousness, then it is guaranteed that we will have at least a human body in our next life. A human being engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, even if unable to complete the course of bhakti-yoga, is allowed to take birth in the higher division of human society so that he can automatically further his advancement in Kåñëa consciousness. Therefore, all bona fide activities in Kåñëa consciousness are amåta, or permanent. This is the subject matter of The Nectar of Devotion.

This eternal engagement in bhakti-rasa can be understood by a serious student upon studying The Nectar of Devotion. Adoption of bhakti-rasa or Kåñëa consciousness will immediately bring one to an auspicious life free from anxieties and will bless one with transcendental existence, thus minimizing the value of liberation. Bhakti-rasa itself is sufficient to produce a feeling of liberation because it attracts the attention of the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. Generally, neophyte devotees are anxious to see Kåñëa or God, but God cannot be seen or known by our present materially blunt senses. The process of devotional service as it is recommended in The Nectar of Devotion will gradually elevate one from the material condition of life to the spiritual status, wherein the devotee becomes purified of all designations. The senses can then become uncontaminated, being constantly in touch with bhakti-rasa. When the purified senses are employed in the service of the Lord, one becomes situated in bhakti-rasa life, and any action performed for the satisfaction of Kåñëa in this transcendental bhakti-rasa stage of life can be relished perpetually. When one is thus engaged in devotional service, all varieties of rasas or mellows turn into eternity. In the beginning one is trained according to the principles of regulation under the guidance of the äcärya or spiritual master, and gradually, when one is elevated, devotional service becomes automatic and spontaneous eagerness to serve Kåñëa. There are twelve kinds of rasas, as will be explained in this book, and by renovating our relationship with Kåñëa in five primary rasas we can live eternally in full knowledge and bliss.

The basic principle of the living condition is that we have a general propensity to love someone. No one can live without loving someone else. This propensity is present in every living being. Even an animal like a tiger has this loving propensity at least in a dormant stage, and it is certainly present in the human beings. The missing point, however, is where to repose our love so that everyone can become happy. At the present moment the human society teaches one to love his country or family or his personal self, but there is no information where to repose the loving propensity so that everyone can become happy. That missing point is Kåñëa, and The Nectar of Devotion teaches us how to stimulate our original love for Kåñëa and how to be situated in that position where we can enjoy our blissful life.

In the primary stage a child loves his parents, then his brothers and sisters, and as he daily grows up he begins to love his family, society, community, country, nation, or even the whole human society. But the loving propensity is not satisfied even by loving all human society; that loving propensity remains imperfectly fulfilled until we know who is the supreme beloved. Our love can be fully satisfied only when it is reposed in Kåñëa. This theme is the sum and substance of The Nectar of Devotion, which teaches us how to love Kåñëa in five different transcendental mellows.

Our loving propensity expands just as a vibration of light or air expands, but we do not know where it ends. The Nectar of Devotion teaches us the science of loving every one of the living entities perfectly by the easy method of loving Kåñëa. We have failed to create peace and harmony in human society, even by such great attempts as the United Nations, because we do not know the right method. The method is very simple, but one has to understand it with a cool head. The Nectar of Devotion teaches all men how to perform the simple and natural method of loving Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. If we learn how to love Kåñëa, then it is very easy to immediately and simultaneously love every living being. It is like pouring water on the root of a tree or supplying food to one's stomach. The method of pouring water on the root of a tree or supplying foodstuffs to the stomach is universally scientific and practical, as every one of us has experienced. Everyone knows well that when we eat something, or in other words when we put foodstuffs in the stomach, the energy created by such action is immediately distributed throughout the whole body. Similarly, when we pour water on the root, the energy thus created is immediately distributed throughout the entirety of even the largest tree. It is not possible to water the tree part by part, nor is it possible to feed the different parts of the body separately. The Nectar of Devotion will teach us how to turn the one switch that will immediately brighten everything, everywhere. One who does not know this method is missing the point of life.

As far as material necessities are concerned, the human civilization at the present moment is very much advanced in living comfortably, but still we are not happy because we are missing the point. The material comforts of life alone are not sufficient to make us happy. The vivid example is America: the richest nation of the world, having all facilities for material comfort, is producing a class of men completely confused and frustrated in life. I am appealing herewith to such confused men to learn the art of devotional service as directed in The Nectar of Devotion, and I am sure that the fire of material existence burning within their hearts will be immediately extinguished. The root cause of our dissatisfaction is that our dormant loving propensity has not been fulfilled despite our great advancement in the materialistic way of life. The Nectar of Devotion will give us practical hints how we can live in this material world perfectly engaged in devotional service and thus fulfill all our desires in this life and the next. The Nectar of Devotion is not presented to condemn any way of materialistic life, but the attempt is to give information to religionists, philosophers and people in general how to love Kåñëa. One may live without material discomfiture, but at the same time he should learn the art of loving Kåñëa. At the present moment we are inventing so many ways to utilize our propensity to love, but factually we are missing the real point, Kåñëa. We are watering all parts of the tree but missing the tree's root. We are trying to keep our body fit by all means, but we are neglecting to supply foodstuffs to the stomach. Missing Kåñëa means missing one's self also. Real self-realization and realization of Kåñëa go together simultaneously. For example, seeing oneself in the morning means seeing the sunrise also; without seeing the sunshine no one can see himself. Similarly, unless one has realized Kåñëa there is no question of self-realization.

The Nectar of Devotion is specifically presented for persons who are now engaged in the Kåñëa consciousness movement. I beg to offer my sincere thanks to all my friends and disciples who are helping me to push forward the Kåñëa consciousness movement in the Western countries, and I beg to acknowledge, with thanks, the contribution made by my beloved disciple Çrémad Jayänanda Brahmacäré. My thanks are due as well to the directors of ISKCON Press, who have taken so much care in publishing this great literature. Hare Kåñëa.

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

13 April 1970

ISKCON Headquarters

3764 Watseka Ave.

Los Angeles, California

NoD-1970: Introduction

Introduction

Invoking auspiciousness: Lord Çré Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the cause of all causes, the reservoir of all rasas, or relationships, which are called neutrality (passive adoration), servitorship, friendship, parenthood, conjugal love, comedy, compassion, fear, chivalry, ghastliness, wonder and devastation. He is the supreme attractive form, and by His universal and transcendental attractive features He has captivated all the gopés, headed by Tärakä, Pälikä, Çyämä, Lalitä, and ultimately, Çrématé Rädhäräëé. Let His Lordship's grace be on us so that there may not be any hindrance in the execution of this duty of writing The Nectar of Devotion, impelled by His Divine Grace Çré Çrémad Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Prabhupäda.

Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda and of Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Prabhupäda, by whose inspiration I have been engaged in the matter of compiling this summary study of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu. This is the sublime science of devotional service as propounded by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who appeared 500 years ago in West Bengal, India, to propagate the movement of Kåñëa consciousness.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé begins his great book by offering his respectful obeisances unto Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, who is his elder brother and spiritual master, and he prays that Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu may be very pleasing to him. He further prays that by residing in that ocean of nectar he may always feel transcendental pleasure in the service of Rädhä and Kåñëa.

Let us offer our respectful obeisances to all the great devotees and äcäryas (holy teachers), who are compared with sharks in the great ocean of nectar and who do not care for the various rivers of liberation. Impersonalists are very fond of merging into the supreme, like rivers that come down and merge into the ocean. The ocean can be compared with liberation and the rivers with all the different paths of liberation. The impersonalists are dwelling in the river water, which eventually comes to mix with the ocean. They have no information, however, that within the ocean, as within the river, there are innumerable aquatic living entities. The sharks who dwell in the ocean do not care for the rivers which are gliding down into it. The devotees eternally live in the ocean of devotional service, and they do not care for the rivers. In other words, those who are pure devotees always remain in the ocean of transcendental loving service to the Lord and have no business with the other processes, which are compared to the rivers that only gradually come to the ocean.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé prays to his spiritual master, Çréla Sanätana Gosvämé, for the protection of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu—the Ocean of the Pure Nectar of Devotional Service—from the argumentative logicians who unnecessarily meddle in the science of service to the Lord. He compares their arguments and logic to volcanic eruptions in the midst of the ocean. In the midst of the ocean such volcanic eruptions can do very little harm, and similarly, those who are against devotional service to the Lord and who put forward many philosophical theses about the ultimate transcendental realization cannot disturb this great ocean of devotional service.

The author of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, very humbly submits that he is just trying to spread Kåñëa consciousness all over the world, although he humbly thinks himself unfit for this work. That should be the attitude of all preachers of the Kåñëa consciousness movement, following in the footsteps of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé. We should never think of ourselves as great preachers, but should always consider that we are simply instrumental to the previous äcäryas, and simply by following in their footsteps we may be able to do something for the benefit of suffering humanity.

Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu is divided into four parts, just as the ocean is sometimes divided into four parts, and there are different sections within each of these four divisions. Originally in Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, the ocean is divided like the watery ocean into east, west, north and south, while the sub-sections within these different divisions are called waves. As in the ocean there are always different waves, either on the eastern side, the western side, the northern side or the southern side, so similarly Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu has different waves. In the first part there are four waves, the first being a general description of devotional service. The second concerns the regulative principles for executing devotional service, and the third wave devotional service in ecstasy. In the fourth is the ultimate goal, love of God. These will be explicitly described along with their different symptoms.

The authorized description of bhakti, or devotional service, following in the footsteps of previous äcäryas, can be summarized in the following statement by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé: "First-class devotional service is known by one's tendency to be fully engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, serving the Lord favorably." The purport is that one may also be in Kåñëa consciousness unfavorably, but that cannot be counted as pure devotional service. Pure devotional service should be free from the desire for any material benefit or for sense gratification, as these desires are cultivated through fruitive activities and philosophical speculation. Generally, people are engaged in different activities to get some material profit, while most philosophers are engaged in proposing transcendental realization through volumes of word jugglery and speculation. Pure devotional service must always be free from such fruitive activities and philosophical speculations. One has to learn Kåñëa consciousness or pure devotional service from the authorities by spontaneous loving service.

This devotional service is a sort of cultivation. It is not simply inaction for people who like to be inactive or devote their time to silent meditation. There are many different methods for people who want this, but cultivation of Kåñëa consciousness is different. The particular word used by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé in this connection is anuçélana, or cultivation by following the predecessor teachers (äcäryas). As soon as we say "cultivation," we must refer to activity. Without activity, consciousness alone cannot help us. All activities may be divided into two classes: one class may be for achieving a certain goal, and the other may be for avoiding some unfavorable circumstance. In Sanskrit, these activities are called pravåtti and nivåtti—positive and negative action. There are many examples of negative action. For instance, a diseased person has to be cautious and take medicine in order to avoid some unfavorable illness.

Those who are cultivating spiritual life and executing devotional service are always engaged in activity. Such activity can be performed with the body or with the mind. Thinking, feeling and willing are all activities of the mind, and when we will to do something, the activity comes to be manifest by the gross bodily senses. Thus, in our mental activities we should always try to think of Kåñëa and try to plan how to please Him, following in the footsteps of the great äcäryas and the personal spiritual master. There are activities of the body, activities of the different senses and activities of speech. A Kåñëa conscious person engages his words in preaching the glories of the Lord. This is called kértana. And by his mind a Kåñëa conscious person always thinks of the activities of the Lord—as He is speaking on the battlefield of Kurukñetra or engaging in His various pastimes at Våndävana with His devotees. In this way one can always think of the activities and pastimes of the Lord. This is the mental culture of Kåñëa consciousness.

Similarly, we can offer many services with our bodily activities. But all such activities must be in relationship with Kåñëa. This relationship is established by connecting oneself with the bona fide spiritual master who is the direct representative of Kåñëa in disciplic succession. Therefore, the execution of Kåñëa conscious activities with the body should be directed by the spiritual master and then performed with faith. The connection with the spiritual master is called initiation. From the date of initiation by the spiritual master, the connection between Kåñëa and a person cultivating Kåñëa consciousness is established. Without initiation by a bona fide spiritual master, the actual connection with Kåñëa consciousness is never performed.

This cultivation of Kåñëa consciousness is not material. The Lord has generally three energies—namely, the external energy, the internal energy, and the marginal energy. The living entities are called marginal energy, and the material cosmic manifestation is the action of the external or material energy. Then there is the spiritual world, which is a manifestation of the internal energy. The living entities, who are called marginal energy, perform material activities when acting under the inferior external energy. And when they engage in activities under the internal spiritual energy, their activities are called Kåñëa conscious. This means that those who are great souls or great devotees do not act under the spell of material energy, but act instead under the protection of the spiritual energy. Any activities done in devotional service or in Kåñëa consciousness are directly under the control of spiritual energy. In other words, energy is a sort of strength, and this strength can be spiritualized by the mercy of both the bona fide spiritual master and Kåñëa.

In the Caitanya-caritämåta by Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämé, Lord Caitanya states that it is a fortunate person who comes in contact with a bona fide spiritual master by the grace of Kåñëa. One who is serious about spiritual life is given by Kåñëa the intelligence to come in contact with a bona fide spiritual master, and then by the grace of the spiritual master one becomes advanced in Kåñëa consciousness. In this way the whole jurisdiction of Kåñëa consciousness is directly under the spiritual energy—Kåñëa and the spiritual master. This has nothing to do with the material world. When we speak of Kåñëa we refer to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, along with His many expansions. He is expanded by His plenary parts and parcels, His differentiated parts and parcels and His different energies. Kåñëa, in other words, means everything and includes everything. Generally, however, we should understand Kåñëa to mean Kåñëa and His personal expansions. Kåñëa expands Himself as Baladeva, Saìkarñaëa, Väsudeva, Aniruddha, Pradyumna, Räma, Nåsiàha and Varäha, as well as many other incarnations and innumerable Viñëu expansions. These are described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam to be as numerous as the uncountable waves. So Kåñëa includes all such expansions, as well as His pure devotees. In the Brahma-saàhitä it is stated that Kåñëa's expansions are all complete in eternity, blissfulness and cognizance.

Devotional service means to prosecute Kåñëa conscious activities which are favorable to the transcendental pleasure of the Supreme Lord Kåñëa, and any activities which are not favorable to the transcendental favor of the Lord cannot be accepted as devotional service. For example, great demons like Rävaëa, Kaàsa and Hiraëyakaçipu were always thinking of Kåñëa, but they were thinking of Him as their enemy. This sort of thinking cannot be accepted as bhakti or Kåñëa consciousness.

The impersonalists sometimes misunderstand devotional service in such a way that they divide Kåñëa from His paraphernalia and pastimes. For example, the Bhagavad-gétä is spoken on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, and the impersonalists say that although Kåñëa is of interest, the battlefield of Kurukñetra isn't. The devotees, however, also know that the battlefield of Kurukñetra by itself has nothing to do with their business, but in addition they know that "Kåñëa" does not mean just Kåñëa alone. He is always with His associates and paraphernalia. For instance, if someone says, "Give something to eat to the man with the weapons," the eating process is done by the man and not by the weapons. Similarly, in Kåñëa consciousness, a devotee may be interested in the paraphernalia and locations—such as the battlefield of Kurukñetra—which are associated with Kåñëa, but he is not concerned with simply any battlefield. He is concerned with Kåñëa—His speech, His instructions, etc. It is because Kåñëa is there that the battlefield is so important.

This is the summary understanding of what Kåñëa consciousness is. Without this understanding one is sure to misunderstand why the devotees are interested in the battlefield of Kurukñetra. One who is interested in Kåñëa becomes interested in His different pastimes and activities.

The definition of a pure devotee, as given by Rüpa Gosvämé in Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, can be summarized thus: his service is favorable and is always in relation to Kåñëa. In order to keep the purity of such Kåñëa conscious activities, one must be freed from all material desires and philosophical speculation. Any desire except for the service of the Lord is called material desire. And philosophical speculation refers to the sort of speculation which ultimately arrives at a conclusion of voidism or impersonalism. This conclusion is useless for a Kåñëa conscious person. Only rarely by philosophical speculation can one reach the conclusion of worshiping Väsudeva, Kåñëa. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä itself. The ultimate end of philosophical speculation, then, must be Kåñëa, with the understanding that Kåñëa is everything, the cause of all causes, and that one should therefore surrender unto Him. If this ultimate goal is reached, then philosophical advancement is favorable, but if the conclusion of philosophical speculation is voidism or impersonalism, that is not bhakti.

Karma or fruitive activities are sometimes understood to be ritualistic activities. There are many persons who are very much attracted by the ritualistic activities described in the Vedas. But if one becomes attracted simply to ritualistic activities without understanding Kåñëa, his activities are unfavorable to Kåñëa consciousness. Actually, Kåñëa consciousness can be based simply on hearing, chanting, remembering, etc. Described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam are nine different processes, besides which everything done is unfavorable to Kåñëa consciousness. Thus, one should always be guarding against falldowns.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has also mentioned in this definition of bhakti the word jïäna-karmädi. This karmädi (fruitive work) consists of activities which are unable to help one attain to pure devotional service. Many forms of so-called renunciation are also not favorable to Kåñëa conscious devotional service.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has also quoted a definition from the Närada-païcarätra, as follows: "One should be free from all material designations and must be cleansed of all material contamination by Kåñëa consciousness. He should be restored to his pure identity, where he engages his senses in the service of the proprietor of the senses." So when our senses are engaged for the actual proprietor of the senses, that is called devotional service. In our conditional state, our senses are engaged in serving these bodily demands. When the same senses are engaged in executing the order of Kåñëa, it is called bhakti.

As long as one identifies himself as belonging to a certain family, a certain society or a certain person, he is said to be covered with designations. When one is fully aware that he does not belong to any family, society or country, but is eternally related to Kåñëa, he then realizes that his energy should be employed not in the interests of so-called family, society or country, but in the interests of Kåñëa. This is purity of purpose and the platform of pure devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness.


PART ONE

NoD 1-1970: Characteristics of Pure Devotional Service

Chapter One

Characteristics of Pure Devotional Service

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Third Canto, 29th Chapter, 10th verse, Çréla Kapiladeva, while instructing His mother, has given the following characteristics of pure devotional service: "My dear Mother, those who are My pure devotees, and who have no desire for material benefit or philosophical speculation, have their minds so much engaged in My service that they are never interested in asking Me for anything—except to be engaged in that service. They do not even beg to live in My abode with Me."

There are five kinds of liberation, namely to become one with the Lord, to live with the Supreme Lord on the same planet, to have the same features as the Lord, to enjoy the same opulences as the Lord, and to live as a companion of the Lord. A devotee, not to speak of rejecting material sense gratification, does not even want any of the five kinds of liberation. He is satisfied simply by discharging loving service to the Lord. That is the characteristic of pure devotion.

In the above statement by Kapiladeva from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the actual position of a pure devotee is described, and the primary characteristics of devotional service are also defined. Further characteristics of devotional service are described by Rüpa Gosvämé with evidences from different scriptures. He states that there are six characteristics of pure devotional service, which are as follows:

1) Pure devotional service brings immediate relief from all kinds of material distress.

2) Pure devotional service is the beginning of all auspiciousness.

3) Pure devotional service automatically puts one in transcendental pleasure.

4) Pure devotional service is rarely achieved.

5) Those in pure devotional service deride even the conception of liberation.

6) Pure devotional service is the only means to attract Kåñëa.

Kåñëa is all-attractive, but pure devotional service attracts even Him. This means that pure devotional service is even transcendentally stronger than Kåñëa Himself, because it is Kåñëa's internal potency.

Relief from Material Distress

In the Bhagavad-gétä, the Lord says that one should surrender unto Him, giving up all other engagements. The Lord also gives His word there that He will protect such surrendered souls from the reactions of all sinful activities. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that the distresses from sinful activities are due both to the sins themselves and to sins committed in our past lives. Generally, one commits sinful activities due to ignorance. But ignorance is no excuse for evading the reaction—sinful activities. Sinful activities are of two kinds: those which are mature and those which are not mature. The sinful activities for which we are suffering at the present moment are called mature. The many sinful activities stored within us for which we have not yet suffered are considered immature. For example, a man may have committed criminal acts but is not yet arrested for them. Now, as soon as he is detected, arrest is awaiting him. Similarly, for some of our sinful activities we are awaiting distresses in the future, and for others, which are mature, we are suffering at the present moment.

In this way there is a chain of sinful activities and their concomitant distresses, and the conditioned soul is suffering life after life due to these sins. He is suffering in the present life the results of sinful activities from his past life, and he is meanwhile creating further sufferings for his future life. Mature sinful activities are exhibited if one is suffering from some chronic disease, if one is suffering from some legal implication, if one is born in a low and degraded family, or if one is uneducated or very ugly.

There are many results of past sinful activities for which we are suffering at the present moment, and we may be suffering in the future due to our present sinful activities. But all of these reactions to sinful deeds can immediately be stopped if we take to Kåñëa consciousness. As evidence for this, Rüpa Gosvämé quotes from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Eleventh Canto, 14th Chapter, 18th verse. This verse is in connection with Lord Kåñëa's instruction to Uddhava, where He says, "My dear Uddhava, devotional service unto Me is just like a blazing fire which can burn into ashes unlimited fuel supplied to it." The purport is that as the blazing fire can burn any amount of fuel to ashes, so devotional service to the Lord in Kåñëa consciousness can burn up all the fuel of sinful activities. For example, in the Gétä Arjuna thought that fighting was a sinful activity, but Kåñëa engaged him on the battlefield under His order, and so the fighting became devotional service. Therefore, Arjuna was not subjected to any sinful reaction.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé quotes another verse from the Third Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 33rd Chapter, 6th verse, in which Devahüti addresses her son, Kapiladeva and says, "My dear Lord, there are nine different kinds of devotional service, beginning from hearing and chanting. Anyone who hears about Your pastimes, who chants about Your glories, who offers You obeisances, who thinks of You and, in this way, executes any of the nine kinds of devotional service—even if he is born in a family of dog-eaters [the lowest grade of mankind]—becomes immediately qualified to perform sacrifices." As such, for anyone who is actually engaged in devotional service in full Kåñëa consciousness, how is it possible that he has not become purified? It is not possible. One who is engaged in Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service has without doubt become freed from all contaminations of material sinful activities. Devotional service therefore has the power to actually nullify all kinds of reactions to sinful deeds. A devotee is nevertheless always alert not to commit any sinful activities; this is his specific qualification as a devotee. Thus the Çrémad-Bhägavatam states that by performing devotional service a person who was born even in a family of dog-eaters may become eligible to take part in the performance of the ritualistic ceremonies recommended in the Vedas. It is implicit in this statement that a person born into a family of dog-eaters is generally not fit for performing yajïa, or sacrifice. The priestly caste in charge of performing these ritualistic ceremonies recommended in the Vedas is called the brähmaëa order. Unless one is a brähmaëa, he cannot perform these ceremonies.

A person is born in a brähmaëa family or in a family of dog-eaters due to his past activities. If a person is born in a family of dog-eaters it means that his past activities are all sinful. But if even such a person takes to the path of devotional service and begins to chant the holy names of the Lord—Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare—he is at once fit to perform the ritualistic ceremonies. This means that his sinful reactions have immediately become neutralized.

It is stated in the Padma Puräëa that there are four kinds of effects due to sinful activities, which are listed as follows: 1) the effect which is not yet fructified, 2) the effect which is lying as seed, 3) the effect which is already mature, and 4) the effect which is almost mature. It is also stated that all these four effects become immediately vanquished for those who surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu, and become engaged in His devotional service in full Kåñëa consciousness.

Those effects described as "almost mature" refer to the distress from which one is suffering at present, and the effects "lying as seed" means that in the core of the heart there is a certain stock of sinful desires which are like seeds. The Sanskrit word küöam means that they are almost ready to produce the seed, or the effect of the seed. An "immature effect" refers to the case where the seedling has not begun. From this statement of Padma Puräëa it is understood that material contamination is very subtle. Its beginning, its fruition and results, and how one suffers such results in the form of distress, are part of a great chain. When one catches some disease, it is often very difficult to ascertain the cause of the disease, where it originated, and how it is maturing. The suffering of a disease, however, does not appear all of a sudden. It actually takes time. And, as in the medical field, for precaution's sake, the doctor injects a vaccination to prevent the growing of contamination, similarly, the practical injection to stop all the fructifications of the seeds of our sinful activities is simply engagement in Kåñëa consciousness.

In this connection, Çukadeva Gosvämé speaks in the Sixth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 2nd Chapter, 17th verse, about the story of Ajämila, who began life as a fine and dutiful brähmaëa but in his young manhood became wholly corrupted by a prostitute. At the end of his wicked life, just by calling the name of "Näräyaëa [Kåñëa]," he was saved despite so much sin. Çukadeva points out that austerity, charity and the performance of ritualistic ceremonies for counteracting sinful activities are recommended processes, but that by performing them one cannot remove the sinful desire-seed from the heart, as was the case with Ajämila in his youth. This sinful desire-seed can be removed only by achieving Kåñëa consciousness. And this can be accomplished very easily by chanting the mahä-mantra, or Hare Kåñëa mantra, as recommended by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. In other words, unless one adopts the path of devotional service, he cannot be one hundred percent clean from all the reactions of sinful activities.

By performing Vedic ritualistic activities, by giving money in charity and by undergoing austerity, one can temporarily become free from the reactions of sinful activities, but at the next moment he must again become engaged in sinful activities. For example, a person suffering from venereal disease on account of excessive indulgence in sex life has to undergo some severe pain in medical treatment, and he is then cured for the time being. But because he has not been able to remove the sex desire from his heart, he must again indulge in the same thing and become a victim of the same disease. So medical treatment may give temporary relief from the distress of such venereal disease, but unless one is trained to understand that sex life is abominable, it is impossible to be saved from such repeated distress. Similarly, the ritualistic performances, charity and austerity, which are recommended in the Vedas may temporarily stop one from acting in sinful ways, but as long as the heart is not clear, one will have to repeat sinful activities again and again.

Another example is given in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam of the elephant who enters into a lake and takes a bath very seriously, cleansing his body thoroughly. Then as soon as he comes onto shore he again takes some dust from the earth and throws it over his body. Similarly, a person who is not trained in Kåñëa consciousness cannot become completely free from the desire for sinful activities. Neither the yoga process, nor philosophical speculations, nor fruitive activities can save one from the seeds of sinful desires. Only by being engaged in devotional service can this be done.

There is another evidence in the Fourth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 22nd Chapter, 37th verse, wherein Sanat-kumära says, "My dear King, the false ego of a human being is so strong that it keeps him in material existence as if tied up by a strong rope. Only the devotees can cut off the knot of this strong rope very easily, by engaging themselves in Kåñëa consciousness. Others, who are not in Kåñëa consciousness but are trying to become great mystics or great ritual-performers, cannot advance like the devotees. Therefore, it is the duty of everyone to engage himself in the activities of Kåñëa consciousness in order to be freed from the tight knot of false ego and engagement in material activities."

This tight knot of false ego is due to ignorance. As long as one is ignorant about his identification, he is sure to act wrongly and thereby become entangled in material contamination. This ignorance of factual knowledge can also be dissipated by Kåñëa consciousness, as is confirmed in the Padma Puräëa as follows: "Pure devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness is the highest enlightenment, and when such enlightenment is there, it is just like a blazing forest fire, killing all the inauspicious snakes of desire." The example is being given in this connection that when there is a forest fire the extensive blazing automatically kills all the snakes in the forest. There are many, many snakes on the ground of the forest, and when a fire takes place, it burns the dried foliage, and the snakes are immediately attacked. Animals who have four legs can flee from the fire or can at least try to flee, but the snakes are immediately killed. Similarly, the blazing fire of Kåñëa consciousness is so strong that the snakes of ignorance are immediately killed.

Kåñëa Consciousness is All-Auspicious

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has given a definition of auspiciousness. He says that actual auspiciousness means welfare activities for all the people of the world. At the present moment groups of people are engaged in welfare activities in terms of society, community or nation. There is even an attempt in the form of the United Nations for world-help activity. But due to the shortcomings of limited national activities, such a general mass welfare program for the whole world is not practically possible. The Kåñëa consciousness movement, however, is so nice that it can render the highest benefit to the entire human race. Everyone can be attracted by this movement, and everyone can feel the result. Therefore, Rüpa Gosvämé and other learned scholars agree that a broad propaganda program for the Kåñëa consciousness movement of devotional service all over the world is the highest humanitarian welfare activity.

How the Kåñëa consciousness movement can attract the attention of the whole world and how each and every man can feel pleasure in this Kåñëa consciousness is stated in the Padma Puräëa as follows: "A person who is engaged in devotional service in full Kåñëa consciousness is to be understood to be doing the best service to the whole world and to be pleasing everyone in the world. In addition to human society, he is pleasing even the trees and animals because they also become attracted by such a movement." A practical example of this was shown by Lord Caitanya when He was traveling through the forests of Jharikhanda in central India for spreading His saìkértana movement. The tigers, the elephants, the deer and all other wild animals joined Him and were participating, in their own ways, by dancing and chanting Hare Kåñëa.

Furthermore, a person engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, acting in devotional service, can develop all the good qualities that are generally found in the demigods. It is said by Çukadeva Gosvämé in the Fifth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 18th Chapter, 12th verse, "My dear King, persons who have unflinching faith in Kåñëa and are without any duplicity can develop all the good qualities of the demigods. On account of a devotee's high grade of Kåñëa consciousness even the demigods like to live with him, and therefore it can be understood that the qualities of the demigods have developed within his body."

On the other hand, a person who is not in Kåñëa consciousness has no good qualities. He may be highly educated from the academic point of view, but in the actual field of his activities he can be seen to be baser than the animals. Even though a person is highly educated academically, if he cannot go beyond the sphere of mental activities then he is sure to perform only material activities and thus remain impure. There are so many persons in the modern world who have been highly educated in the materialistic universities, but it is seen that they cannot take up the movement of Kåñëa consciousness and develop the high qualities of the demigods.

For example, a Kåñëa conscious boy, even if he is not very well educated by the university standard, can immediately give up all illicit sex life, gambling, meat-eating and intoxication; whereas those who are not in Kåñëa consciousness, although very highly educated, are often drunkards, meat-eaters, sex-mongers and gamblers. These are practical proofs of how a Kåñëa conscious person becomes highly developed in good qualities, whereas a person who is not in Kåñëa consciousness cannot do so. We experience that even a young boy in Kåñëa consciousness is unattached to cinemas, night clubs, naked dance shows, restaurants, liquor shops, etc. He becomes completely freed. He saves his valuable time from being extravagantly spent in the way of smoking, drinking, attending the theater and dancing.

One who is not in Kåñëa consciousness usually cannot sit silently even for half an hour. The yoga system teaches that if you become silent you will realize that you are God. This system may be all right for materialistic persons, but how long will they be able to keep themselves silent? Artificially, they may sit down for so-called meditation, but immediately after their yogic performance, they will engage themselves again in such activities as illicit sex life, gambling, meat-eating and many other nonsensical things. But a Kåñëa conscious person gradually elevates himself without endeavoring for this so-called silent meditation. Simply because he is engaged in Kåñëa consciousness he automatically gives up all this nonsense and develops a high character. One develops the highest character by becoming a pure devotee of Kåñëa. The conclusion is that no one can truly have any good qualities if he is lacking Kåñëa consciousness.

Happiness in Kåñëa Consciousness

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has analyzed the different sources of happiness. He has divided happiness into three categories, which are: 1) happiness derived from material enjoyment, 2) happiness derived by identifying oneself with the Supreme Brahman, and 3) happiness derived from Kåñëa consciousness.

In the Tantra-çästra Lord Çiva speaks to his wife, Saté, in this way: "My dear wife, a person who has surrendered himself at the lotus feet of Govinda and who has thus developed pure Kåñëa consciousness can be very easily awarded all the perfections desired by the impersonalists; and beyond this, he can enjoy the happiness achieved by the pure devotees."

Happiness derived from pure devotional service is the highest because it is eternal. But the happiness derived from material perfection or understanding oneself to be Brahman is inferior because it is temporary. There is no preventing one's falling down from material happiness, and there is even every chance of falling down from the spiritual happiness derived out of identifying oneself with the impersonal Brahman.

It has been seen that great mäyävädé (impersonalist) sannyäsés—very highly educated and almost realized souls—may sometimes take to political activities or to social welfare activities. The reason is that they actually do not derive any ultimate transcendental happiness in the impersonal understanding and therefore must come down to the material platform and take to such mundane affairs. There are many instances, especially in India, where these mäyävädé sannyäsés descend to the material platform again. But a person who is fully in Kåñëa consciousness will never return to any sort of material platform. However alluring and attracting they may be, he always knows that no material welfare activities can be compared with the spiritual activity of Kåñëa consciousness.

The mystic perfections achieved by actually successful yogés are eight in number. Aëimä-siddhi refers to the power by which one can become so small that he can enter into a stone. Modern scientific improvements also enable us to enter into stone because they provide for excavating so many subways, penetrating the hills, etc. So, aëimä-siddhi, the mystic perfection of trying to enter into stone, has also been achieved by material science. Similarly, all of the yoga-siddhis, or perfections, are material arts. For example, in one yoga-siddhi there is development of the power to become so light that one can float in the air or on water. That is also being performed by modern scientists. They are flying in the air, they are floating on the surface of the water, and they are traveling under the water.

After comparing all these mystic yoga-siddhis to materialistic perfections it is found that the materialistic scientists try for the same perfections. So actually there is no difference between mystic perfection and materialistic perfection. A German scholar once said that the so-called yoga perfections have already been achieved by the modern scientists, and so he was not concerned with them. He intelligently went to India to learn how he could understand his eternal relationship with the Supreme Lord by means of bhakti-yoga, devotional service.

Of course, in the categories of mystic perfection there are certain processes which the material scientists have not yet been able to develop. For instance, a mystic yogé can enter into the sun planet simply by using the rays of the sunshine. This perfection is called laghimä. Similarly, a yogé can touch the moon with his finger. Though the modern astronauts go to the moon with the help of spaceships, they undergo many difficulties, whereas a person with mystic perfection can extend his hand and touch the moon with his finger. This siddhi is called präpti, or acquisition. With this präpti-siddhi, the perfect mystic yogé can not only touch the moon planet, but he can extend his hand anywhere and take whatever he likes. He may be sitting thousands of miles away from a certain place, and if he likes he can take fruit from a garden there. This is präpti-siddhi.

The modern scientists have manufactured nuclear weapons with which they can destroy an insignificant part of this planet, but by the yoga-siddhi known as éçitä one can create and destroy an entire planet simply at will. Another perfection is called vaçitä, and by this perfection one can bring anyone under his control. This is a kind of hypnotism which is almost irresistible. Sometimes it is found that a yogé who may have attained a little perfection in this vaçitä mystic power comes out among the people and speaks all sorts of nonsense, controls their minds, exploits them, takes their money and then goes away.

There is another mystic perfection which is known as präkämya (magic). By this präkämya power one can achieve anything he likes. For example, one can make water enter into his eye and then again come out from within the eye. Simply by his will he can perform such wonderful activities.

The highest perfection of mystic power is called kämävasäyitä. This is also magic, but whereas the präkämya power acts to create wonderful effects within the scope of nature, kämävasäyitä permits one to contradict nature—in other words, to do the impossible. Of course, one can derive great amounts of temporary happiness by achieving such yogic materialistic perfections.

Foolishly, people who are enamored of the glimmer of modern materialistic advancement are thinking that the Kåñëa consciousness movement is for less intelligent men. "I am better off being busy with my material comforts—maintaining a nice apartment, family and sex life." These people do not know that at any moment they can be kicked out of their material situation. Due to ignorance, they do not know that real life is eternal. The temporary comforts of the body are not the goal of life, and it is due only to darkest ignorance that people become enamored of the glimmering advancement of material comforts.

Çréla Bhaktivinode Thäkur has therefore said that the advancement of material knowledge renders a person more foolish because it causes one to forget his real identification by its glimmer. This is doom for him, because this human form of life is meant for getting out of the material contamination. By the advancement of material knowledge, people are becoming more and more entangled in material existence. They have no hope of being liberated from this catastrophe.

In the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya it is stated that Prahläda Mahäräj, a great devotee of the Lord, prayed to Nåsiàhadeva (the half-lion half-man incarnation), as follows: "My dear Lord, I repeatedly pray unto Your lotus feet that I may simply be stronger in devotional service. I simply pray that my Kåñëa consciousness may be more strong and steady, because happiness derived out of Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service is so powerful that with it one can have all the other perfections of religiousness, economic development, sense gratification and even the attainment of liberation from material existence."

Actually, a pure devotee does not aspire after any of these perfections because the happiness derived from devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness is so transcendental and so unlimited that no other happiness can be compared with it. It is said that even one drop of happiness in Kåñëa consciousness stands beyond comparison with an ocean of happiness derived from any other activity. Thus, any person who has developed even a little quantity of pure devotional service can very easily kick out all the other kinds of happiness derived from religiousness, economic development, sense gratification and liberation.

There was a great devotee of Lord Caitanya known as Kholävecä Çrédhara, who was a very poor man. He was doing a small business selling cups made from the leaves of plantain trees, and his income was almost nothing. Still, he was spending fifty percent of his small income on the worship of the Ganges, and with the other fifty percent he was somehow living. Lord Caitanya once revealed Himself to this confidential devotee, Kholävecä Çrédhara, and offered him any opulence that he liked. But Çrédhara informed the Lord that he did not want any material opulence. He was quite happy in his present position and wanted only to gain unflinching faith and devotion unto the lotus feet of Lord Caitanya. That is the position of the pure devotees. If they can be engaged twenty-four hours each day in devotional service they do not want anything else, not even the happiness of liberation or of becoming one with the supreme.

In the Närada-païcarätra it is also said that any person who has developed even a small amount of devotional service doesn't care a fig for any kind of happiness derived from religiousness, economic development, sense gratification, or the five kinds of liberation. Any kind of happiness derived from religiousness, economic development, liberation or sense gratification cannot even dare to enter into the heart of a pure devotee. It is stated that as the personal attendants and maidservants of a queen follow the queen with all respect and obeisances, similarly the joys of religiousness, economic development, sense gratification and liberation follow the devotional service of the Lord. In other words, a pure devotee does not lack any kind of happiness derived from any source. He does not want anything but service to Kåñëa, but even if he should have another desire, the Lord fulfills this without the devotee's asking.

Rareness of Pure Devotional Service

In the preliminary phase of spiritual life there are different kinds of austerities, penances and similar processes for attaining self-realization. However, even if an executor of these processes is without any material desire, he still cannot achieve devotional service. And aspiring by oneself alone to achieve devotional service is also not very hopeful because Kåñëa does not agree to award devotional service to merely anyone. Kåñëa can easily offer a person material happiness or even liberation, but He does not agree very easily to award a person engagement in His devotional service. Devotional service can in fact be attained only through the mercy of a pure devotee. In the Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 19.151) it is said: "By the mercy of the spiritual master who is a pure devotee and by the mercy of Kåñëa one can achieve the platform of devotional service. There is no other way."

The rarity of devotional service is also confirmed in the Tantra-çästra where Lord Çiva says to Saté, "My dear Saté, if one is a very fine philosopher, analyzing the different processes of knowledge, he can achieve liberation from the material entanglement. By performance of the ritualistic sacrifices recommended in the Vedas one can be elevated to the platform of pious activities and thereby enjoy the material comforts of life to the fullest extent. But all such endeavors can hardly offer anyone devotional service to the Lord, not even if one tries for it by such processes for many, many thousands of births."

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is also confirmed by Prahläda Mahäräj that merely by personal efforts or by the instructions of higher authorities one cannot attain to the stage of devotional service. One must become blessed by the dust of the lotus feet of a pure devotee who is completely freed from the contamination of material desires.

In the Fifth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 6th Chapter, 18th verse, Närada also says to Yudhiñöhira, "My dear King, it is Lord Kåñëa, known as Mukunda, who is the eternal protector of the Päëòavas and the Yadus. He is also your spiritual master and instructor in every respect. He is the only worshipable God for you. He is very dear and affectionate, and He is the director of all your activities, both individual and familial. And what's more, He sometimes carries out your orders as if He were your messenger! My dear King, how very fortunate you are, because for others all these favors given to you by the Supreme Lord would not even be dreamt of." The purport to this verse is that the Lord easily offers liberation, but He rarely agrees to offer a soul devotional service because by devotional service the Lord Himself becomes purchased by the devotee.

The Happiness of Becoming One with the Supreme

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that if brahmänanda, or the happiness of becoming one with the Supreme, is multiplied by one trillionfold, still it cannot be compared with an atomic fraction of the happiness derived from the ocean of devotional service.

In the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya Prahläda Mahäräj, while satisfying Lord Nåsiàhadeva by his prayers, says: "My dear Lord of the universe, I am feeling transcendental pleasure in Your presence and have become merged in the ocean of happiness. I now consider the happiness of brahmänanda to be no more than the water in the impression left by a cow's hoof in the earth, compared to this ocean of bliss." Similarly, it is confirmed in the Bhävärtha-dépikä, Çrédhara Svämé's commentary on the Çrémad-Bhägavatam: "My dear Lord, some of the fortunate persons who are swimming in the ocean of Your nectar of devotion, and who are relishing the nectar of the narration of Your pastimes, certainly know ecstasies which immediately minimize the value of the happiness derived from religiousness, economic development, sense gratification and liberation. Such a transcendental devotee regards any kind of happiness other than devotional service as no better than straw in the street."

Attracting Kåñëa

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has stated that devotional service attracts even Kåñëa. Kåñëa attracts everyone, but devotional service attracts Kåñëa. The symbol of devotional service in the highest degree is Rädhäräëé. Kåñëa is called Madana-mohana, which means that He is so attractive that He can defeat the attraction of thousands of Cupids. But Rädhäräëé is still more attractive, for She can even attract Kåñëa. Therefore devotees call Her Madana-mohana-mohané—the attractor of the attractor of Cupid.

To perform devotional service means to follow in the footsteps of Rädhäräëé, and devotees in Våndävana put themselves under the care of Rädhäräëé in order to achieve perfection in their devotional service. In other words, devotional service is not an activity of the material world; it is directly under the control of Rädhäräëé. In Bhagavad-gétä it is confirmed that the mahätmäs, or great souls, are under the protection of daivé prakåti, the internal energy—Rädhäräëé. So, being directly under the control of the internal potency of Kåñëa, devotional service attracts even Kåñëa Himself.

This fact is corroborated by Kåñëa in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 12th Chapter, 1st verse, where He says: "My dear Uddhava, you may know it from Me that the attraction I feel for devotional service rendered by My devotees is not to be attained even by the performance of mystic yoga, philosophical speculation, ritualistic sacrifices, the study of Vedänta, the practice of severe austerities or the giving of everything in charity. These are, of course, very nice activities, but they are not as attractive to Me as the transcendental loving service rendered by My devotees."

How Kåñëa becomes attracted by the devotional service of His devotees is described by Närada in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Seventh Canto, 10th Chapter, 37th verse. There Närada addresses King Yudhiñöhira while the King is appreciating the glories of the character of Prahläda Mahäräj. A devotee always appreciates the activities of other devotees. Yudhiñöhira Mahäräj was appreciating the qualities of Prahläda, and that is one symptom of a pure devotee. A pure devotee never thinks himself as great; he always thinks that other devotees are greater than himself. The King was thinking, "Prahläda Mahäräj is actually a devotee of the Lord, while I am nothing," and while thinking this he was addressed by Närada as follows: "My dear King Yudhiñöhira, in this world you [the Päëòava brothers] are the only fortunate people. The Supreme Personality of Godhead has appeared on this planet and is presenting Himself to you as an ordinary human being. He is always with you in all circumstances. He is living with you and covering Himself from the eyes of others. Others cannot understand that He is the Supreme Lord, but He is still living with you as your cousin, as your friend and even as your messenger. Therefore you must know that nobody in this world is more fortunate than you."

In the Bhagavad-gétä, when Kåñëa appeared in His universal form, Arjuna prayed: "My dear Kåñëa, I thought of You as my cousin-brother, and so I have shown disrespect to You in so many ways, calling You Kåñëa, or friend. But You are so great that I could not understand." So that was the position of the Päëòavas; although Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the greatest among all greats, still He remained with those royal brothers, being attracted by their devotion, by their friendship and by their love. That is the proof of how great this process of devotional service is. It can attract even the Supreme Personality of Godhead. God is great, but devotional service is greater than God because it attracts Him. People who are not in devotional service can never understand what great value there is in rendering service to the Lord.

NoD 2-1970: The First Stages of Devotion

Chapter Two

The First Stages of Devotion

The three categories of devotional service which Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé describes in Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu are listed as devotional service in practice, devotional service in ecstasy and devotional service in pure love of Godhead. There are many sub-headings in each of these categories. Generally it is understood that in the category of devotional service in practice there are two different qualities, devotional service in ecstasy has four qualities, and devotional service in pure love of Godhead has six qualities. These qualities will be explained by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé later on.

In this connection, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé suggests that the person eligible for Kåñëa consciousness or devotional service can be classified by his particular taste. He says that devotional service is a continual process from one's previous life. No one can take to devotional service unless he has had some previous connection with it. For example, suppose in this life I practice devotional service to some extent. Even though it is not one hundred percent perfectly performed, still whatever I have done will not be lost. In my next life, from the very point where I stopped in this life, I shall begin again. In this way there is always a continuity. But even if there is no continuity, if only by chance a person takes interest in a pure devotee's instruction, he can be accepted and advance in devotional service. Anyway, for persons who have a natural taste for understanding books like the Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, devotional service is easier than for those who are simply accustomed to mental speculation and argumentative processes.

To support this statement there are many authoritative assertions by the learned scholars of bygone ages. According to their general opinion, a person may become governed by certain convictions derived by his own arguments and decisions. Then another person, who may be a greater logician, will nullify these conclusions and establish another thesis. In this way the path of argument will never be safe or conclusive. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam recommends, therefore, that one follow in the footsteps of the authorities.

Here is a general description of devotional service given by Çré Rüpa Gosvämé in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu. Previously, it has been stated that devotional service can be divided into three categories—namely, devotional service in practice, devotional service in ecstasy, and devotional service in pure love of God. Now Çré Rüpa Gosvämé proposes to describe devotional service in practice.

Practice means employing our senses in some particular type of work. Therefore devotional service in practice means utilizing our different sensory organs in service to Kåñëa. Some of the senses are meant for acquiring knowledge, and some are meant for executing the conclusions of our thinking, feeling and willing. So practice means employing both the mind and the senses in practical devotional service. This practice is not for developing something artificial. For example, a child learns or practices to walk. This walking is not unnatural. The walking capacity is there originally in the child, and simply by a little practice he walks very nicely. Similarly, devotional service to the Supreme Lord is the natural instinct of every living entity. Even uncivilized men like the aborigines offer their respectful obeisances to something wonderful exhibited by nature's law, and they appreciate that behind some wonderful exhibition or action there is something supreme. So this consciousness, though lying dormant in those who are materially contaminated, is found in every living entity. And, when purified, this is called Kåñëa consciousness.

There are certain prescribed methods for employing our senses and mind in such a way that our dormant consciousness for loving Kåñëa will be invoked, as much as the child, with a little practice, can begin to walk. One who has no basic walking capacity cannot walk by practice. Similarly, Kåñëa consciousness cannot be aroused simply by practice. Actually there is no such practice. When we wish to develop our innate capacity for devotional service there are certain processes which, by our accepting and executing them, will cause that dormant capacity to be invoked. Such practice is called sädhana-bhakti.

Every living entity under the spell of material energy is held to be in an abnormal condition of madness. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is said: "Generally, the conditioned soul is mad because he is always engaged in activities which are the causes of bondage and suffering." Spirit soul in its original condition is joyful, blissful, eternal and full of knowledge. Only by his implication in material activities has he become miserable, temporary and full of ignorance. This is due to vikarma. Vikarma means actions which should not be done. Therefore, we must practice sädhana-bhakti—which means to offer maìgala-ärätrika (Deity worship) in the morning, to refrain from certain material activities, to offer obeisances to the spiritual master and to follow many other rules and regulations which will be discussed here one after another. These practices will help one to become cured of madness. As a man's mental disease is cured by the directions of a psychiatrist, so this sädhana-bhakti cures the conditioned soul of his madness under the spell of mäyä, material illusion.

Närada Muni mentions this sädhana-bhakti in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Seventh Canto, 1st Chapter, 30th verse. He says there to King Yudhiñöhira: "My dear King, one has to fix his mind on Kåñëa by any means." That is called Kåñëa consciousness. It is the duty of the äcärya, the spiritual master, to find the ways and means for his disciple to fix his mind on Kåñëa. That is the beginning of sädhana-bhakti.

Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has given us an authorized program for this purpose, centered around the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra. This chanting has so much power that it immediately attaches one to Kåñëa. That is the beginning of sädhana-bhakti. Somehow or other, one has to fix his mind on Kåñëa. The great saint Ambaréña Mahäräj, although a responsible king, fixed his mind on Kåñëa, and similarly anyone who tries to fix his mind in this way will very rapidly make progress in successfully reviving his original Kåñëa consciousness.

Now this sädhana-bhakti, or practice of devotional service, can also be divided into two parts. The first part is called regulative principles: one has to follow these different regulative principles by the order of the spiritual master, or on the strength of authoritative scriptures, and there can be no question of refusal. That is called vaidhi, or regulated. One has to do it without any argument. Another part of sädhana-bhakti is called rägänugä. Rägänugä refers to the point at which, by following the regulative principles, one becomes a little more attached to Kåñëa and executes devotional service out of natural love. For example, a person engaged in devotional service may be ordered to rise early in the morning and offer ärätrika, which is a form of Deity worship. In the beginning, by the order of his spiritual master, one rises early in the morning and offers ärätrika, but then he develops real attachment. When he gets this attachment, he automatically tries to decorate the Deity and prepare different kinds of dresses and thinks of different plans to execute his devotional service nicely. Although it is within the category of practice, this offering of loving service is spontaneous. So the practice of devotional service, sädhana-bhakti, can be divided into two parts—namely, regulative and spontaneous.

Rüpa Gosvämé defines the first part of devotional practice, or vaidhi-bhakti, as follows: "When there is no attachment or no spontaneous loving service to the Lord, and one is engaged in the service of the Lord simply out of obedience to the order of the spiritual master or in pursuance of the scriptures, such obligatory service is called vaidhi-bhakti."

These principles of vaidhi-bhakti are also described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Second Canto, 1st Chapter, verse 35, where Çukadeva Gosvämé instructs the dying Mahäräj Parékñit as to his course of action. Mahäräj Parékñit met Çukadeva Gosvämé just a week before his death, and the King was perplexed as to what should be done before he was to pass on. Many other sages also arrived there, but no one could give him the proper direction. Çukadeva Gosvämé, however, gave this direction to him as follows: "My dear King, if you want to be fearless in meeting your death next week (for actually everyone is afraid at the point of death), then you must immediately begin the process of hearing and chanting and remembering God." If one can chant and hear Hare Kåñëa and always remember Lord Kåñëa, then he is sure to become fearless of death, which may come at any moment.

In the statements of Çukadeva Gosvämé it is said that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is Kåñëa. Therefore Çukadeva recommends that one should always hear about Kåñëa. He does not recommend that one hear and chant about the demigods. The mäyävädés (impersonalists) say that you can chant any name, either that of Kåñëa or those of the demigods, and the result will be the same. But actually this is not a fact. According to the authorized version of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, one has to hear and chant about Lord Viñëu (Kåñëa) only.

So Çukadeva Gosvämé has recommended to Parékñit Mahäräj that in order to be fearless of death one has to hear and chant and remember the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, by all means. He also mentions that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is sarvätmä. Sarvätmä means "the supersoul of everyone." Kåñëa is also mentioned as éçvara, the supreme controller who is situated in everyone's heart. Therefore, if some way or other we become attached to Kåñëa, He will make us free from all danger. In the Bhagavad-gétä it is said that anyone who becomes a devotee of the Lord is never vanquished. Others, however, are always vanquished. Vanquished means that after getting this human form of life, a person does not come out of the entanglement of birth and death and thus misses his golden opportunity. Such a person does not know where he is being thrown by the laws of nature.

Suppose one does not develop Kåñëa consciousness in this human form of life. He will be thrown into the cycle of birth and death involving 8,400,000 species of life, and his spiritual identity will remain lost. One does not know whether he is going to be a plant, or a beast, or a bird, or something like that, because there are so many species of life. The recommendation of Rüpa Gosvämé for reviving our original Kåñëa consciousness is that somehow or other we should apply our minds to Kåñëa very seriously and thus also become fearless of death. After death we do not know our destination, because we are completely under the control of the laws of nature. Only Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is controller over the laws of nature. Therefore, if we take shelter of Kåñëa seriously, there will be no fear of being thrown back into the cycle of so many species of life. A sincere devotee will surely be transferred to the abode of Kåñëa, as affirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä.

In the Padma Puräëa also the same process is advised. There it is said that one should always remember Lord Viñëu. This is called dhyäna, or meditation—always remembering Kåñëa. It is said that one has to meditate with his mind fixed upon Viñëu. Padma Puräëa recommends that one always fix his mind on the form of Viñëu by meditation and not forget Him at any moment. And this state of consciousness is called samädhi, or trance.

We should always try to mold the activities of our lives in such a way that we will constantly remember Viñëu, or Kåñëa. That is Kåñëa consciousness. Whether one concentrates his mind on the four-handed form of Viñëu or on the form of two-handed Kåñëa, it is the same. The Padma Puräëa recommends: somehow or other, always think of Viñëu without forgetting Him under any circumstances. Actually, this is the most basic of all regulative principles. For, when there is an order from a superior about doing something, there is simultaneously a prohibition. When the order is that one should always remember Kåñëa, the prohibition is that one should never forget Him. Within this simple order and prohibition all regulative principles are found complete.

This regulative principle is applicable to all varëas and äçramas, the castes and occupations of life. There are four varëas, namely, the brähmaëas (priests and intellectuals), the kñatriyas (warriors and statesmen), the vaiçyas (businessmen and farmers) and the çüdras (laborers and servants). There are also four standard äçramas, namely brahmacarya (student life), gåhastha (householder), vänaprastha (retired) and sannyäsa (renounced). The regulative principles are not only for the brahmacärés (celibate students) to follow, but are applicable for all. It doesn't matter whether one is a beginner—a brahmacäré—or if one is very advanced—a sannyäsé. The principle of remembering the Supreme Personality of Godhead constantly and not forgetting Him at any moment is meant to be followed by everyone without fail.

If this injunction is followed, then all other rules and regulations will automatically fall into line. All other rules and regulations should be treated as assistants or servants to this one basic principle. The injunctions of rules and regulations and the resultant reactions are mentioned in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 5th Chapter, 1st and 2nd verses. Camasa Muni, one of the nine sages who came to instruct King Nimi, addressed the King and said, "The four social orders, namely the brähmaëas, the kñatriyas, the vaiçyas, and the çüdras, have come out of the different parts of the universal form of the Supreme Lord as follows: the brähmaëas have come out from the head, the kñatriyas have come out from the arms, the vaiçyas have come out from the waist, and the çüdras have come out from the legs. Similarly, the sannyäsés have come out from the head, the vänaprasthas from the arms, the gåhasthas from the waist, and the brahmacärés from the legs."

These different orders of society and grades of spiritual advancement are conceived in terms of qualification. It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä that the four social orders and the four spiritual orders are created by the Lord Himself, in terms of different individual qualities. As the different parts of the body have different types of activities, so the social orders and spiritual orders also have different types of activities in terms of qualification and position. The target of these activities, however, is always the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä, "He is the supreme enjoyer." So whether one is a brähmaëa or a çüdra, he has to satisfy the Supreme Lord by his activities. This is also confirmed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam by a verse which reads: "Everyone must be engaged in his particular duty, but the perfection of such work should be tested by how far the Lord is satisfied with such activities." The injunction herein is that one has to act according to his position, and by such activities one must either satisfy the Supreme Personality or else fall down from his position.

For example, a brähmaëa who is born out of the head of the Lord has as his business to preach the transcendental Vedic sounds, or çabda-brahman. Because the brähmaëa is the head, he has to preach the transcendental sound, and he also has to eat on behalf of the Supreme Lord. According to Vedic injunctions, when a brähmaëa eats it is to be understood that the Personality of Godhead is eating through him. It is not, however, that the brähmaëa should simply eat on behalf of the Lord and not preach the message of the Bhagavad-gétä to the world. Actually, one who preaches the message of the Gétä is very dear to Kåñëa, as is confirmed in the Gétä itself. Such a preacher is factually a brähmaëa and thus by feeding him one feeds the Supreme Lord directly.

Similarly, the kñatriya has to protect people from the onslaughts of mäyä. That is his duty. For example, as soon as Mahäräj Parékñit saw that a black man was attempting to kill a cow, he immediately took his sword, wanting to kill the black man, whose name was Kali.* That is a kñatriya's duty. Violence is required in order to give protection. In the Bhagavad-gétä, Lord Kåñëa directly gave His order to Arjuna to commit violence on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, just to give protection to the people in general.

The vaiçyas are meant for producing agricultural products, trading them and distributing them. And the working class, or çüdras, are those who haven't the intelligence of the brähmaëas or the kñatriyas or the vaiçyas, and therefore they are meant to help these higher classes by bodily labor. In this way, there is full cooperation and spiritual advancement amongst all the different orders of society. And when there is no such cooperation, the members of society will fall down. That is the present position in the kali-yuga, this age of quarrel. Nobody is doing his duty, and everyone is simply puffed-up by calling himself a brähmaëa (intellectual) or a kñatriya (soldier or statesman). But actually, such people are without status. They are out of touch with the Supreme Personality of Godhead because they are not Kåñëa conscious. Therefore the Kåñëa consciousness movement is intended to set the whole of human society in proper condition so that everyone will be happy and take profit from developing Kåñëa consciousness.

Lord Çré Kåñëa instructed Uddhava that by following the injunctions of the social and spiritual orders of human society one can satisfy the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and as a result of such satisfaction the whole society gets all the necessities of life amply and without difficulty. This is because, after all, the Supreme Personality of Godhead maintains all other living entities. If the whole society performs its respective duties and remains in Kåñëa consciousness, there is no doubt that all of its members will live very peacefully and happily. Without wanting the necessities of life, the whole world will be turned into Vaikuëöha, a spiritual abode. Even without being transferred to the kingdom of God, by following the injunctions of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam and prosecuting the duties of Kåñëa consciousness, all human society will be happy in all respects.

There is a similar statement by Çré Kåñëa Himself to Uddhava in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 5th Chapter, 2nd verse. The Lord says there, "My dear Uddhava, all persons are engaged in activities, whether those indicated in the revealed scriptures or ordinary worldly activities. If by the result of either of such activities they worship Me in Kåñëa consciousness, then automatically they become very happy within this world as well as in the next. Of this there is no doubt." We can conclude from this statement by Kåñëa that activities in Kåñëa consciousness will give everyone all perfection in their desires.

Thus the Kåñëa consciousness movement is so nice that there is no need of even designating oneself brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, çüdra, brahmacäré, gåhastha, vänaprastha or sannyäsé. Let everyone be engaged in whatever occupation he now has. Simply let him worship Lord Kåñëa by the result of his activities in Kåñëa consciousness. That will adjust the whole situation, and everyone will be happy and peaceful within this world. In the Närada-païcarätra the regulative principles of devotional service are described as follows: "Any activities sanctioned in the revealed scriptures and aiming at the satisfaction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead are accepted by saintly teachers as the regulative principles of devotional service. If somebody regularly executes such service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead under the direction of a bona fide spiritual master, then gradually he rises to the platform of serving in pure love of God."

NoD 3-1970: Eligibility of the Candidate for Accepting Devotional Service

Chapter Three

Eligibility of the Candidate for Accepting Devotional Service

On account of his association with mahätmäs, or great souls one hundred percent in the devotional service of the Lord, one may attain a little bit of attraction for Çré Kåñëa. But at the same time one may remain very much attached to fruitive activities and material sense enjoyment and not be prepared to undergo the different types of renunciation. Such a person, if he has unflinching attraction to Kåñëa, becomes an eligible candidate for discharging devotional service.

This attraction for Kåñëa consciousness in association with pure devotees is the sign of great fortune. It is confirmed by Lord Caitanya that only the fortunate persons, by the mercy of both a bona fide spiritual master and Kåñëa, will get the seed of devotional service. In this connection, Lord Kåñëa says in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Eleventh Canto, 20th Chapter, verse 8: "My dear Uddhava, only by exceptional fortune does someone become attracted to Me (Kåñëa). And even if one is not completely detached from fruitive activities, or is not completely attached to devotional service, such service is quickly effective."

Devotees can be divided into three classes. The first or uppermost class is described as follows: one is very expert in the study of relevant scriptures, and he is also expert in putting forward arguments in terms of those scriptures. He can very nicely present conclusions with perfect discretion and can consider the ways of devotional service in a decisive way. He understands perfectly that the ultimate goal of life is to attain to the transcendental loving service of Kåñëa, and he knows that Kåñëa is the only object of worship and love. This first-class devotee is one who has strictly followed the rules and regulations under the training of a bona fide spiritual master and has sincerely obeyed him in accord with revealed scriptures. Thus being fully trained to preach and become a spiritual master himself, he is considered first-class. A first-class devotee never deviates from the principles of higher authority, and he attains firm faith in the scriptures by understanding with all reasons and arguments. When we speak of arguments and reason, it means arguments and reason on the basis of revealed scripture. The first-class devotee is not interested in dry speculative methods meant for wasting time. In other words, one who has attained a mature determination in the matter of devotional service can be accepted as the first-class devotee.

The second-class devotee has been defined by the following symptoms: he is not very expert in arguing on the strength of revealed scripture, but he has firm faith in the objective. The purport of this description is that the second-class devotee has firm faith in the procedure of devotional service unto Kåñëa, but he may sometimes fail to offer arguments and decisions on the strength of revealed scripture to an opposing party. But at the same time he is still undaunted within himself as to his decision that Kåñëa is the supreme object of worship.

The neophyte or third-class devotee is one whose faith is not strong and, at the same time, does not recognize the decision of the revealed scripture. The neophyte's faith can be changed by someone else with strong arguments or by an opposite decision. Unlike the second-class devotee, who also cannot put forward arguments and evidences from the scripture, but who still has all faith in the objective, the neophyte has no firm faith in the objective. Thus he is called the neophyte devotee.

Further classification of the neophyte devotee is made in the Bhagavad-gétä. It is stated there that four classes of men—namely those who are distressed, those who are in need of money, those who are inquisitive and those who are wise—begin devotional service and come to the Lord for relief in the matter of their respective self-satisfaction. They go into some place of worship and pray to God for mitigation of material distress, or for some economic development, or to satisfy their inquisitiveness. And a wise man who simply realizes the greatness of God is also counted among the neophytes. Such beginners can be elevated to the second-class or first-class platform if they associate with pure devotees.

An example of the neophyte class is Mahäräj Dhruva. He was in need of his father's kingdom and therefore engaged himself in devotional service to the Lord. Then in the end when he was completely purified he declined to accept any material benediction from the Lord. Similarly, Gajendra was also distressed and prayed to Kåñëa for protection, after which he became a pure devotee. Similarly, Sanaka, Sanätana, Sananda and Sanat-kumära were all in the category of wise, saintly persons, and they were also attracted by devotional service. A similar thing happened to the assemblage in the Naimiñäraëya forest, headed by the sage Çaunaka. They were inquisitive and were always asking Süta Gosvämé about Kåñëa. Thus they achieved the association of a pure devotee and became pure devotees themselves. So that is the way of elevating oneself. In whatever condition one may be, if he is fortunate enough to associate with pure devotees, then very quickly he is elevated to the second-class or first-class platform.

These four types of devotees have been described in the Seventh Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä, and they have all been accepted as pious. Without becoming pious no one can come to devotional service. It is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä that only one who has continually executed pious activities and whose sinful reactions in life have completely stopped can take to Kåñëa consciousness. Others cannot. The neophyte devotees are classified into four groups—the distressed, those in need of money, the inquisitive and the wise—according to their gradations of pious activities. Without pious activities, if a man is in a distressed condition he becomes an agnostic, communist or something like that. Because he does not firmly believe in God, he thinks that he can adjust his distressed condition by totally disbelieving in Him.

Lord Kåñëa, however, has explained in the Gétä that out of these four types of neophytes, the one who is wise is very dear to Him because a wise man, if he is attached to Kåñëa, is not seeking an exchange of material benefits. A wise man who becomes attached to Kåñëa does not want any return from Him, neither in the form of relieving distress, nor in gaining money. This means that from the very beginning his basic principle of attachment to Kåñëa is, more or less, love. Furthermore, due to his wisdom and study of çästras (scriptures), he can understand also that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä that after many, many births, when one becomes actually wise, he surrenders unto Väsudeva, knowing perfectly well that Kåñëa (Väsudeva) is the origin and cause of all causes. Therefore, he sticks to the lotus feet of Kåñëa and gradually develops love for Him. Although such a wise man is very dear to Kåñëa, the others are also accepted as very magnanimous because even though they are distressed or in need of money, they have come to Kåñëa for satisfaction. Thus they are accepted as liberal, broad-minded mahätmäs.

Without being elevated to the position of a jïäné, or wise man, no one can stick to the principle of worshiping the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Others who are less intelligent, or those whose intelligence has been taken away by the spell of mäyä, are attached to different demigods, on account of the influence of the modes of nature. The wise man is he who has thoroughly understood that he is spirit soul and not simply a body. Because he realizes that he is spirit and that Kåñëa is the supreme spirit, he knows that his intimate relationship should be with Kåñëa, not with this body. The distressed and the man in want of money are in the material concept of life because distress and need of money are both in relationship with this body. One who is inquisitive may be a little above the distressed and the man in need of money, but still he is on the material platform. But a wise man who seeks Kåñëa knows perfectly well that he is spirit soul, or Brahman, and that Kåñëa is the supreme spirit soul, or Param-Brahman. He knows that the spirit soul, being subordinate and finite, should always dovetail himself with the infinite and supreme soul, Kåñëa. That is the relationship of the wise man with Kåñëa.

It can be concluded that a person who is freed from the bodily concept of life is an eligible candidate for pure devotional service. It is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä that after Brahman realization, when one is freed from material anxieties and can see every living entity on an equal level, he is eligible to enter into devotional service.

As has been stated before, there are three kinds of happiness: material, spiritual and devotional. Devotional service and the happiness due to its execution are not possible so long as one is materially affected. If someone has desire for material enjoyment or for becoming one with the supreme, these are both considered material concepts. Because the impersonalists cannot appreciate the spiritual happiness of association and the exchange of loving affairs with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, their ultimate goal is to become one with the Lord. This concept is simply an extension of the material idea. In the material world, everyone is trying to be the topmost head-man amongst all his fellow men or neighbors. Either communally, socially or nationally, everyone is competing to be greater than all others, in the material concept of life. This greatness can be extended to the unlimited, so that one actually wants to become one with the greatest of all, the Supreme Lord. This is also a material concept, although maybe a little more advanced.

However, the perfect spiritual concept of life is complete knowledge of one's constitutional position, and thus one knows enough to dovetail himself in the transcendental loving service to the Lord. One must know that he is finite and that the Lord is infinite. Thus it is not possible to actually become one with the Lord even if one aspires for this. It is simply not possible. Therefore, anyone who has any desire or aspiration for satisfying his senses by becoming more and more important, either in the material sense or in the spiritual sense, cannot actually relish the really sweet taste of devotional service. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has therefore compared possessing these bhukti (material) and mukti (liberation) desires with being influenced by the black art of a witch: in both cases one is in trouble. Bhukti means material enjoyment, and mukti means to become freed from material anxiety and to become one with the Lord. These desires are compared to being haunted by ghosts and witches, because while these aspirations for material enjoyment or spiritual oneness with the supreme remain, no one can relish the actual transcendental taste of devotional service.

A pure devotee never cares for liberation. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu prayed to Kåñëa: "My dear son of Nanda, I do not want any material happiness in the shape of many followers, nor immense opulence in wealth, nor any beautiful wife, nor do I want cessation from material existence. I may take birth many times, one after another, but what I pray from You is that my devotion unto You may always remain unflinching."

The attention of a pure devotee is so much attracted to glorification of the pastimes, name, qualities, forms, etc., of the Lord that the devotee does not care for mukti. Çré Bilvamaìgala Thäkur has said, "If I am engaged in devotional service unto You, my dear Lord, then very easily can I perceive Your presence everywhere. And as far as liberation is concerned, I think liberation stands at my door with folded hands waiting to serve me." To pure devotees, therefore, liberation and spiritual emancipation are not very important things.

In this connection, in the Third Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Chapter 25, verse 23, Kapiladeva has advised His mother, Devahüti, as follows: "My dear Mother, My pure devotees are charmed by seeing My different forms, the beauty of My face, the structure of My body so enchanting. My laughing, My pastimes and My glance appear to them so beautiful that their minds are always absorbed in thoughts of Me, and their lives are dedicated fully unto Me. Although such people do not desire any kind of liberation or any kind of material happiness, still I give them a place amongst My associates in the supreme abode."

This evidence from Çrémad-Bhägavatam gives assurance to the pure devotee of being elevated to association with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé remarks in this connection that one who is actually attracted by the beauty of the lotus feet of Çré Kåñëa or His service, and whose heart, by such attraction, is always full with transcendental bliss, will naturally never aspire after the liberation which is so valuable to the impersonalists.

A similar passage is also there in the Third Canto, 15th Chapter, of the same book, wherein Uddhava addresses Lord Kåñëa and says, "My dear Lord, for persons who are engaged in Your transcendental loving service there is nothing worth obtaining from religiousness, economic development, sense gratification or liberation—although happiness from these different sources can be very easily had by them. In spite of such facilities, my dear Lord, I do not aspire to achieve any such results. My only prayer is that I may have unflinching faith and devotion unto Your lotus feet."

A similar passage appears in the Third Canto, 25th Chapter, 31st verse, wherein Kapiladeva instructs His mother and says, "My dear Mother, devotees whose hearts are always filled in the service of My lotus feet, and who are prepared to do anything for My satisfaction, especially those who assemble together to understand My qualities, pastimes and form, and thus glorify Me congregationally and derive transcendental pleasure therefrom, such fortunate devotees never desire to become one with Me. And not to speak of becoming one with Me, if they are offered a post like Mine in My abode, or opulence like Mine, or even personal association with Me with similar bodily features, they refuse to accept because they are satisfied simply by being engaged in My devotional service."

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Fourth Canto, 9th Chapter, 10th verse, King Dhruva says, "My dear Lord, the transcendental pleasure derived by meditation upon Your lotus feet, which is enjoyed by the pure devotees, cannot be approached by the transcendental pleasure derived by the impersonalists through self realization. So how can the fruitive workers, who at most can aspire to promotion to the higher heavenly planets, understand You, and how can they be described as enjoying a happiness similar to the devotees' happiness?"

NoD 4-1970: Devotional Service Surpasses All Liberation

Chapter Four

Devotional Service Surpasses All Liberation

How much a devotee is seriously attached to the devotional service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead can be understood from the statement of Mahäräj Påthu (Ädiräja) which is described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Fourth Canto, 20th Chapter, 21st verse. He prays to the Supreme Personality of Godhead thusly: "My dear Lord, if after taking liberation I have no chance of hearing the glories of Your Lordship, glories chanted by pure devotees from the core of their hearts in praise of Your lotus feet, and if I have no chance for this honey of transcendental bliss, then I shall never ask for liberation or this so-called spiritual emancipation. I shall simply always pray unto Your Lordship that You may give me millions of tongues and millions of ears so that I can constantly chant and hear of Your transcendental glories."

The impersonalists desire to merge into the existence of the supreme, but without keeping their individuality they have no chance of hearing and chanting the glories of the Supreme Lord. Because they have no idea of the transcendental form of the Supreme Lord there is no chance of their chanting and hearing of His transcendental activities. In other words, unless one is already beyond liberation, one cannot relish the transcendental glories of the Lord, nor can one understand the transcendental form of the Lord.

A similar statement is found in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Fifth Canto, 14th Chapter, 43rd verse. Çukadeva Gosvämé addresses Parékñit Mahäräj there and says, "The great soul of King Bharata was so much attached to the service of the lotus feet of Kåñëa that he very easily gave up his lordship over the earthly planet and his affection for his children, society, friends, royal opulence and beautiful wife. He was so very lucky that the goddess of fortune was pleased to offer him all kinds of material concessions, but he never accepted any of these material opulences." Çukadeva Gosvämé eulogizes this behavior of King Bharata very highly. He says, "Any person whose heart is attracted by the transcendental qualities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Madhusüdana, not to speak of material opulences, does not care even for that liberation which is aspired to by many great sages."

In the Bhägavatam, Sixth Canto, 11th Chapter, 23rd verse, there is a similar statement by Våträsura, who addresses the Lord as follows: "My dear Lord, by leaving Your transcendental service I may be promoted to the planet called Dhruva-loka [the Pole Star], or I may gain lordship over all the planetary systems of the universe. But I do not aspire to this. Nor do I wish the mystic perfections of yoga practice, nor do I aspire to spiritual emancipation. All I wish for, my Lord, is Your association and transcendental service eternally."

This statement is confirmed by Lord Çiva in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Sixth Canto, 17th Chapter, 52nd verse, wherein Lord Çiva addresses Saté thusly: "My dear Saté, persons who are devoted to Näräyaëa [Kåñëa] are not afraid of anything. If they are elevated to the higher planetary systems, or if they get liberation from material contamination, or if they are pushed down to the hellish condition of life—or, in fact, in any situation whatever—they are not afraid of anything. Simply because they have taken shelter of the lotus feet of Näräyaëa, for them any position in the material world is as good as another."

There is a similar statement by Indra, the King of heaven, in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Sixth Canto, 18th Chapter, 52nd verse. There Indra addresses his mother in this manner: "My dear Mother [Aditi], persons who have given up all kinds of desire and are simply engaged in devotional service to the Lord know what is actually their self-interest. Such persons are actually serving their self-interests and are considered first-class experts in the matter of advancing to the perfectional stage of life."

In the Seventh Canto of the Bhägavatam, 6th Chapter, 23rd verse, Mahäräj Prahläda says: "My dear friends who are born into atheistic families, if you can please the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, then there is nothing more rare in this world. In other words, if the Supreme Lord Kåñëa is pleased with you, then any desire that you may have within the core of your heart can be fulfilled without any doubt. As such, what is the use of elevating yourself by the results of fruitive activities, which are automatically achieved in all events by the modes of material nature? And what is the use for you of spiritual emancipation or liberation from material bondage? If you are always engaged in chanting the glories of the Supreme Lord and always relishing the nectar of the lotus feet of the Lord, then there is no necessity for any of these." By this statement of Prahläda Mahäräj it is clearly understood that one who takes pleasure in chanting and hearing the transcendental glories of the Lord has already surpassed all kinds of material benedictions, including the results of pious fruitive activities, sacrifices and even liberation from material bondage.

Similarly, in the same Seventh Canto, 8th Chapter, 39th verse, when the demigods are offering prayers to Lord Nåsiàha, Indra, the King of heaven, says, "O Supreme One, these demons talk of our share of participation in the performances of ritualistic sacrifices, but simply by Your appearance as Lord Nåsiàhadeva You have saved us from terrible fears. Actually, our shares in the sacrificial performances are due to You only, because You are the supreme enjoyer of all sacrifices. You are the supersoul of every living entity, and therefore You are the actual owner of everything. Long were our hearts always filled with fear of this demon, Hiraëyakaçipu. But You are so kind towards us that, by killing him, You have removed that fear from within our hearts and have given us the chance to place Your Lordship within our hearts again. For persons who are engaged in the transcendental loving service of Your Lordship, all the opulences which were taken away from us by the demons are counted as nothing. Devotees do not care even for liberation, not to speak of these material opulences. Actually, we are not enjoyers of the fruits of sacrifices. Our only duty is to always be engaged in Your service, for You are the enjoyer of everything."

The purport of this statement by Indra is that, beginning from Brahmä down to the insignificant ant, no living entities are meant for enjoying the material opulences. They are simply meant for offering everything to the supreme proprietor, the Personality of Godhead. By doing so, they automatically enjoy the benefit. The example can be cited again of the different parts of the body collecting foodstuffs and cooking them so that ultimately a meal may be offered to the stomach. After it has gone to the stomach, all the parts of the body equally enjoy the benefit of the meal. So, similarly, everyone's duty is to satisfy the Supreme Lord, and then automatically everyone will become satisfied.

A similar verse is found in the Eighth Canto, 3rd Chapter, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, verse 20. Gajendra says there, "My dear Lord, I have no experience in the transcendental bliss derived from Your devotional service, so therefore I have asked from You some favor. But I know that persons who are pure devotees and have, by serving the lotus feet of great souls, become freed from all material desires, are always merged in the ocean of transcendental bliss and, as such, are always satisfied simply by glorifying Your auspicious characteristics. For them there is nothing else to aspire to or pray for."

In the Ninth Canto of the Bhägavatam, 4th Chapter, 49th verse, the lord of Vaikuëöha replies to Durväsä Muni thusly: "My pure devotees are always satisfied being engaged in devotional service, and therefore they do not aspire even after the five liberated stages, which are 1) to be one with Me, 2) to achieve residence on My planet, 3) to have My opulences, 4) to possess bodily features similar to Mine and 5) to gain personal association with Me. So, when they are not interested even in these liberated positions, you can know how little they care for material opulences or material liberation."

There is a similar prayer by the nägapatné (wives of the Käliya serpent), in the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 16th Chapter, verse 33. The nägapatné say there, "My dear Lord, the dust of Your lotus feet is very wonderful. Any person who is fortunate enough to achieve this dust does not care for heavenly planets, lordship over all the planetary systems, the mystic perfections of yoga or even liberation from material existence. In other words, anyone who adores the dust of Your lotus feet does not care a fig for all other perfectional stages."

There is a similar statement in the Tenth Canto, 87th Chapter, 17th verse, when the Çrutis, the Vedas personified, prayed to the Lord as follows: "My dear Lord, it is very difficult to understand spiritual knowledge. Your appearance here just as You are, is to explain to us this most difficult subject of knowledge of the spirit. As such, Your devotees who have left their domestic comforts to associate with the liberated äcäryas [teachers] are now fully merged in the devotional service of Your Lordship, and thus they do not care for any so-called liberation."

In explaining this verse it should be noted that spiritual knowledge means understanding the self and the supersoul, or superself. The individual soul and the supersoul are qualitatively one, and therefore both of them are known as Brahman, or spirit. But knowledge of Brahman is very difficult to understand. There are so many philosophers engaged in the matter of understanding the soul, but they are unable to make any tangible advancement. It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä that out of many millions of persons, only one may try to understand what is spiritual knowledge, and out of many such persons who are trying to understand, only one or a few may know what is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So this verse says that spiritual knowledge is very difficult to achieve, and so in order to make it more easily attainable, the Supreme Lord Himself comes in His original form as Çré Kåñëa and gives His instruction directly to an associate like Arjuna, just so that the people in general may take advantage of this spiritual knowledge. This verse also explains that liberation means having completely given up all the material comforts of life. Those who are impersonalists are satisfied by simply being liberated from the material circumstances, but those who are devotees can automatically give up material life and also enjoy the transcendental bliss of hearing and chanting the wonderful activities of Lord Kåñëa.

In the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 20th Chapter, 34th verse, Lord Kåñëa says to Uddhava as follows: "My dear Uddhava, the devotees who have completely taken shelter of My service are so steadfast in devotional service that they have no other desire. Even if they are offered the four kinds of spiritual opulences,* they will refuse to accept them. So what to speak of their desiring anything within the material world!" Similarly, Lord Kåñëa says in another passage of the Bhägavatam, Eleventh Canto, 14th Chapter, 13th verse, "My dear Uddhava, a person whose consciousness is completely absorbed in My thought and activities does not aspire even to occupy the post of Brahmä, or the post of Indra, or the post of lordship over the planets, or the eight kinds of mystic perfections, or even liberation itself." In the Twelfth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 10th Chapter, verse 6, Lord Çiva says to Devé: "My dear Devé, this great brähmaëa sage Märkaëòeya has attained unflinching faith and devotion unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and as such he does not aspire after any benedictions, including liberation from the material world."

Similarly, there is a statement in Padma Puräëa describing the ritualistic function during the month of Kärttika (October-November). During this month, in Våndävana it is the regulative principle to pray daily to Lord Kåñëa in His Dämodara form. The Dämodara form refers to Kåñëa in His childhood when He was tied up with rope by His mother, Yaçodä. Däma means ropes, and udara means the abdomen. So Mother Yaçodä, being very disturbed by naughty Kåñëa, bound Him round the abdomen with a rope, and thus Kåñëa is named Dämodara. During the month of Kärttika, Dämodara is prayed to as follows: "My dear Lord, You are the Lord of all, the giver of all benedictions." There are many demigods like Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva who sometimes offer benedictions to their respective devotees. For example, Rävaëa was blest with many benedictions by Lord Çiva, and Hiraëyakaçipu was blest by Lord Brahmä. But even Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä depend upon the benedictions of Lord Kåñëa, and therefore Kåñëa is addressed as the Lord of all benefactors. As such, Lord Kåñëa can offer His devotees anything they want, but still, the devotee's prayer continues, "I do not ask You for liberation or any material facility up to the point of liberation. What I want as Your favor is that I may always think of Your form as I see You now as Dämodara. You are so beautiful and attractive that my mind does not want anything else besides this wonderful form." In this same prayer, there is another passage in which it is said, "My dear Lord Dämodara, once when You were playing as a naughty boy in the house of Nanda Mahäräj, You broke the box containing yogurt, and because of that Mother Yaçodä considered You an offender and tied You with rope to the household grinding mortar. At that time You delivered two sons of Kuvera, Nalaküvara and Maëigréva, who were staying there as two arjuna trees in the yard of Nanda Mahäräj. My only request is that by Your merciful pastimes You may similarly deliver me."

The story behind this verse is that the two sons of Kuvera (the treasurer of the demigods) were puffed up on account of the opulence of their father, and so once on a heavenly planet they were enjoying themselves in a lake with some naked damsels of heaven. At that time the great saint Närada Muni was passing on the road and was sorry to see the behavior of the sons of Kuvera. Seeing Närada passing by, the damsels of heaven covered their bodies with cloth, but the two sons, being drunkards, did not have this decency. Närada became angry with their behavior and cursed them thusly: "You have no sense, so it is better if you become trees instead of the sons of Kuvera." Upon hearing this, the boys came to their senses and begged Närada to be pardoned for their offenses. Närada then said, "Yes, you shall become trees, arjuna trees, and you will stand at the courtyard of Nanda Mahäräj. But Kåñëa Himself will appear in time as the foster son of Nanda, and He will deliver you." In other words, the curse of Närada was a benediction to the sons of Kuvera because indirectly it was foretold that they would be able to receive the favor of Lord Kåñëa. After that, Kuvera's two sons stood as two big arjuna trees in the courtyard of Nanda Mahäräj until Lord Dämodara, in order to fulfill the desire of Närada, dragged the milling pestle to which He was tied and struck the two trees, violently causing them to fall down. From out of these fallen trees came Nalaküvara and Maëigréva, who had by then become great devotees of the Lord.

There is a passage in the Hayaçérña Puräëa which states, "My dear Lord, O Supreme Personality of Godhead, I do not want any resultant benediction from my religious life, nor do I want any economic development, nor do I want to enjoy sense gratification, nor liberation. I simply pray to be an eternal servant at Your lotus feet. Kindly oblige me and give me this benediction."

In the same Hayaçérña Puräëa, after Nåsiàhadeva wanted to give benediction to Prahläda Mahäräj, Prahläda did not accept any material benediction and simply asked the favor of the Lord to remain His eternal devotee. In this connection, Prahläda Mahäräj cited the example of Hanumän, the eternal servitor of Lord Rämacandra, who also set an example by never asking any material favor from the Lord. He always remained engaged in His service. That is the ideal character of Hanumän, for which he is still worshiped by all devotees. Prahläda Mahäräj also offered his respectful obeisances unto Hanumän. There is a well-known verse spoken by Hanumän in which he says, "My dear Lord, if You like You can give me salvation from this material existence, or the privilege of merging into Your existence, but I do not wish any of these things. I do not want anything which diminishes my relationship with You as master and servant, even after liberation."

In a similar passage in Närada-païcarätra it is stated, "My dear Lord, I do not wish any perfectional stage by performing the ritualistic religious ceremonies or by economic development or by sense gratification or liberation. I simply pray that You grant me the favor of keeping me under Your lotus feet. I do not wish any kind of liberation such as sälokya, to reside on Your planet, or särüpya, to have the same bodily features as You. I simply pray for Your favor that I may be always engaged in Your loving service."

Similarly, in the Sixth Canto, 14th Chapter, 4th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Mahäräj Parékñit inquires from Çukadeva Gosvämé, "My dear brähmaëa, I understand that the demon Våträsura was a great sinful person and that his mentality was completely absorbed in the modes of passion and ignorance. How did he develop to such a perfectional stage of devotional service to Näräyaëa? I have heard that even great persons who have undergone severe austerities and who are liberated with full knowledge must strive to become devotees of the Lord. It is understood that such persons are very rare and almost never to be seen, so I am astonished that Våträsura has become such a devotee!"

In the above verse, the most important thing to be noted is that there may be many liberated persons who might have merged into the existence of the impersonal Brahman, but a devotee of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, is very, very rare. Even out of millions of liberated persons, only one is fortunate enough to become a devotee.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, First Canto, 7th Chapter, Queen Kunté is praying to Lord Kåñëa at the time of His departure: "My dear Kåñëa, You are so great that You are inconceivable even to great stalwart scholars and paramahaàsas [fully liberated souls]. So if such great sages, who are transcendental to all the reactions of material existence, are unable to know You, then as far as we are concerned, belonging to the less intelligent woman class, how is it possible for us to know Your glories? How can we understand You?" In this verse, the particular thing to be noted is that the Personality of Godhead is not understood by great liberated persons, but only by devotees such as Queen Kunté in her humbleness. Although she was a woman and considered less intelligent than a man, still she realized the glories of Kåñëa. That is the purport of this verse.

Another passage which is very important is in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, First Canto, 6th Chapter, 10th verse, and is called the "ätmäräma verse." In this ätmäräma verse it is stated that even those who are completely liberated from material contamination are attracted by the transcendental qualities of Lord Kåñëa.* The purport of this verse is that a liberated soul has absolutely no desire at all for material enjoyment; he is wholly freed from all kinds of material desires, yet still he is irresistibly attracted by the desire to hear and understand the pastimes of the Lord. We can therefore conclude that the glories and pastimes of the Lord are not material. Otherwise, how could the liberated persons known as ätmärämas be attracted by such pastimes? That is the important point in this verse.

From the above statement it is found that a devotee is not after any of the stages of liberation. There are five stages of liberation, already explained as being 1) to become one with the Lord, 2) to live on the same planet as the Lord, 3) to obtain the same bodily features as the Lord, 4) to have the same opulences as the Lord and 5) to have constant association with the Lord. Out of these five liberated stages the one which is known as säyujya, or to merge into the existence of the Lord, is the last to be accepted by a devotee. The other four liberations, although not desired by devotees, still are not against the devotional ideals. Some of the liberated persons who have achieved these four stages of liberation may also develop affection for Kåñëa and be promoted to the Goloka Våndävana planet in the spiritual sky. In other words, those who are already promoted to the Vaikuëöha planets and possess the four kinds of liberation may also sometimes develop affection for Kåñëa and become promoted to Kåñëa-loka.

So those who are in the four liberated states may still be going through different stages of existence. In the beginning they may want the opulences of Kåñëa, but at the mature stage the dormant love for Kåñëa exhibited in Våndävana becomes prominent in their hearts. As such, the pure devotees never accept the liberation of säyujya, to become one with the supreme, though sometimes they may accept as favorable the other four liberated states.

Out of many kinds of devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the one who is attracted to the original form of the Lord, Kåñëa in Våndävana, is considered to be the foremost, first-class devotee. Such a devotee is never attracted by the opulences of Vaikuëöha, nor even of Dvärakä, the royal city where Kåñëa ruled. The conclusion of Çré Rüpa Gosvämé is that the devotees who are attracted by the pastimes of the Lord in Gokula, or Våndävana,* are the topmost devotees.

A devotee who is attached to a particular form of the Lord does not wish to change his devotion to other forms. For example, Hanumän, the devotee of Lord Rämacandra, knew that there is no difference between Lord Rämacandra and Lord Näräyaëa, and yet he still wanted to render service only unto Lord Rämacandra. That is due to the specific attraction of a particular devotee. There are many, many forms of the Lord, but Kåñëa is still the original form. Though all of the devotees of the different forms of the Lord are in the same category, still it is said that those who are devotees of Lord Kåñëa are the topmost in the list of all devotees.

NoD 5-1970: Purity of Devotional Service

Chapter Five

Purity of Devotional Service

All of the previous instructions imparted by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé in his broad statements can be summarized thusly: as long as one is materially inclined or desirous to merge into the spiritual effulgence, one cannot enter into the realm of pure devotional service. Next, Rüpa Gosvämé states that devotional service is transcendental to all material considerations and that it is not limited to any particular country, class, society or circumstance. As is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, devotional service is transcendental and has no cause. Devotional service is executed without any hope for gain, and it cannot be checked by any material circumstances. It is open for all, without any distinction, and it is the constitutional occupation of the living entities.

In the Middle Ages, after the disappearance of Lord Caitanya's great associate Lord Nityänanda, a class of priestly persons claimed to be the descendents of Nityänanda, calling themselves the gosvämé caste. They further claimed that the practice and spreading of devotional service belonged only to their particular class, which was known as Nityänanda-vaàça. In this way, they exercised their artificial power for some time, until Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Thäkur, the powerful äcärya of the Gauòéya Vaiñëava sampradäya, completely smashed their idea. There was a great hard struggle for some time, but it has turned out successfully, and it is now correctly and practically established that devotional service is not restricted to a particular class of men. Besides that, anyone who is engaged in devotional service is already on the status of being a high-class brähmaëa. So Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Thäkur's struggle for this movement has come out successful.

It is on the basis of his position that anyone can now become a Gauòéya Vaiñëava, from any part of the world or any part of the universe. Anyone who is a pure Vaiñëava is situated transcendentally, and therefore the highest qualification in the material world, namely, to be in the modes of goodness, is already achieved by such a person. Our Kåñëa consciousness movement in the Western world is based on the above-mentioned proposition of Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Prabhupäda, our spiritual master. On his authority, we are claiming members from all sections of the Western countries. The so-called brähmaëas claim that one who is not born into a brähmaëa family cannot receive the sacred thread and cannot become a high-grade Vaiñëava. But we do not accept such a theory because it is not supported by Rüpa Gosvämé nor by the strength of the various scriptures.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé specifically mentions herein that every man has the birthright to accept devotional service and to become Kåñëa conscious. He has given many evidences from many scriptures, and he has especially quoted one passage from Padma Puräëa, wherein sage Vasiñöha tells King Dilépa: "My dear King, everyone has the right to execute devotional service, just as he has the right to take early bath in the month of Mägh [December-January]." There is more evidence in Padma Puräëa, in the Käçékhaëòa portion, where it is said: "In the country known as Mayüradhvaja, the lower caste people who are considered less than çüdras are also initiated in the Vaiñëava cult of devotional service. And when they are properly dressed, with tilaka on their bodies and beads in their hands and on their necks, they appear to be coming from Vaikuëöha. In fact, they look so very beautiful that immediately they surpass the ordinary brähmaëas."

Thus a Vaiñëava automatically becomes a brähmaëa. This idea is also supported by Sanätana Gosvämé in his book Hari-bhakti-viläsa, which is the Vaiñëava guide. Therein he has clearly stated that any person who is properly initiated into the Vaiñëava cult certainly becomes a brähmaëa, as much as the metal known as kaàsa (bell metal) is turned into gold by the mixture of mercury. A bona fide spiritual master, under the guidance of authorities, can turn anyone to the Vaiñëava cult so that naturally he may come to the topmost position of a brähmaëa.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé warns, however, that if a person is properly initiated by a bona fide spiritual master, he should not think that simply by the acceptance of such initiation his business is then finished. One still has to follow the rules and regulations very carefully. If after accepting the spiritual master and being initiated one does not follow the rules and regulations of devotional service, then he is again fallen. One must be very vigilant to remember that he is the part and parcel of the transcendental body of Kåñëa, and it is his duty as part and parcel to give service to the whole, or Kåñëa. If we do not render service to Kåñëa then again we fall down. In other words, simply becoming initiated does not elevate one to the position of a high-class brähmaëa. One also has to discharge the duties and follow the regulative principles very rigidly.

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé also says that if anyone is regularly discharging devotional service there will be no question of a falldown. But even if circumstantially there is some falldown, the Vaiñëava need have nothing to do with the präyaçcitta, the ritualistic ceremony for purification. If someone falls down from the principles of devotional service, he need not take to the präyaçcitta performances for reformation. He has simply to execute the rules and regulations for discharging devotional service, and that is sufficient for his reinstatement. This is the mystery of the Vaiñëava (devotional) cult.

Practically there are three processes for elevating one to the platform of spiritual consciousness. These processes are called karma, jïäna and bhakti. Ritualistic performances are in the field of karma. Speculative processes are in the field of jïäna. One who has taken to bhakti, the devotional service of the Lord, need have nothing to do with karma or jïäna. It has been already explained that pure devotional service is without any tinge of karma or jïäna. Bhakti should have no tinge of philosophical speculation or ritualistic performances.

In this connection Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé gives evidence from Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Eleventh Canto, in which it is said by Lord Kåñëa to Uddhava, "The distinction between qualification and disqualification may be made in this way: persons who are already elevated in discharging devotional service will never again take shelter of the processes of fruitive activities or philosophical speculation. If one sticks to devotional service and is conducted by regulative principles given by the authorities and äcäryas, that is the best qualification."

This statement is supported in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, First Canto, 5th Chapter, 17th verse, wherein Çré Närada Muni advises Vyäsadeva thusly: "Even if one does not execute his specific occupational duty, but immediately takes direct shelter of the lotus feet of Hari [Kåñëa], there will be no fault on his part, and in all circumstances his position is secure. Even if, by some bad association, he falls down while executing devotional service, or if he doesn't finish the complete course of devotional service and dies untimely, still he is not at a loss. A person who is simply discharging his occupational duty in varëa and äçrama, however, with no Kåñëa consciousness, practically does not gain the true benefit of human life." The purport is that all conditioned souls who are engaged very frantically in activities for sense gratification, without knowing that this process will never help them to get out of material contamination, are awarded only with repeated births and deaths.

In the Fifth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is clearly stated by Åñabhadeva to his sons: "Persons engaged in fruitive activities are repeatedly accepting birth and death, and until they develop a loving feeling for Väsudeva, there will be no question of getting out from these stringent laws of material nature." As such, any person who is very seriously engaged in his occupational duties in the varëas and äçramas, and who does not develop love for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Väsudeva, is to be understood as simply spoiling his human form of life.

This is confirmed also in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 11th Chapter, 32nd verse, in which the Lord says to Uddhava, "My dear Uddhava, any person who takes shelter of Me in complete surrender and follows My instructions, giving up all occupational duties, is to be considered the first-class man." In this statement of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, it is understood that people who are generally attracted to philanthropic, ethical, moral, altruistic, political and social welfare activities may be considered nice men only in the calculation of the material world. From Çrémad-Bhägavatam and other authentic Vedic scriptures we learn further that if a person simply acts in Kåñëa consciousness and discharges devotional service, he is considered to be far, far better situated than all of those persons engaged in philanthropic, ethical, moral, altruistic and social welfare activities.

The same thing is still more emphatically confirmed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Eleventh Canto, 5th Chapter, 37th verse, in which Karabhäjana Muni addresses Mahäräj Nimi as follows: "My dear King, if somebody gives up his occupational duties as they are prescribed for the different varëas and äçramas, but takes complete shelter, surrendering himself unto the lotus feet of the Lord, such a person is no more a debtor, nor has he any obligation to perform the different kinds of activities we render to the great sages, ancestors, living entities and family and society members. Neither has he any need to bother executing the five kinds of yajïäs [sacrifices] for becoming free from sinful contamination. Simply by discharging devotional service he is freed from all kinds of obligations." The purport is that as soon as a man takes his birth, he is immediately indebted to so many sources. He is indebted to the great sages because he profits by reading their authoritative scriptures and books. For example, we take advantage of the books written by Vyäsadeva. Vyäsadeva has left for us all the Vedas. Before Vyäsadeva's writing, the Vedic literature was simply heard, and the disciples would learn the mantras quickly by hearing and not by reading. Later on, Vyäsadeva thought it wise to write down the Vedas because in this age people are short-memoried and unable to remember all the instructions given by the spiritual master. Therefore, he left all the Vedic knowledge in book form, such as the Puräëas, Vedänta, Mahäbhärata and Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

There are many other sages, like Çaìkaräcärya, Gautama Muni, Närada Muni, etc., to whom we are indebted because we take advantage of their knowledge. Similarly, we are obliged to our forefathers because we take our birth in a particular family, where we take all advantages and inherit property. Therefore, we are indebted to the forefathers and have to offer them piëòa (prasädam) after they are dead. Similarly, to the people in general we are also indebted, as well as to our relatives, friends and even animals such as cows and dogs who render us so much service.

In this way, we are indebted to the demigods, to the forefathers, to the sages, to the animals and to society in general. It is our duty to repay them all by proper discharge of service. But by the one stroke of devotional service, if someone gives up all obligations and simply surrenders unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he is no longer a debtor, nor obliged to any other source of benefit.

In the Bhagavad-gétä also the Lord says: "Give up all your occupations and just become surrendered unto Me. I give you assurance that I shall give you protection from all sinful reactions." One may think that because he is surrendering unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he will not be able to perform all of his other obligations. But the Lord says repeatedly, "Don't hesitate. Don't consider that because you are giving up all other engagements there will be some flaw in your life. Don't think like that. I will give you all protection." That is the assurance of Lord Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä.

There is additional evidence in the Agastya-saàhitä: "As the regulative principles of scripture are not required by a liberated person, similarly a person who is engaged duly in the service of Lord Rämacandra is also not required to discharge the ritualistic principles which are indicated in the Vedic supplimentaries." In other words, the devotees of Lord Rämacandra, or Kåñëa, are already liberated persons and are not required to follow all the regulative principles mentioned in the ritualistic portions of the Vedic literature.

Similarly, in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 5th Chapter, Karabhäjana Muni addresses King Nimi and says, "My dear King, a person who has given up the worship of the demigods and has completely concentrated his energy in the devotional service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead has become very, very dear to the Lord. As such, if by chance or mistake he does something which is forbidden, there is no need for him to perform any purificatory ceremonies. Because the Lord is situated within his heart, He takes compassion for the devotee's accidental mistake and corrects him from within." It is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä in many places that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, takes a special interest in His devotees and declares emphatically that nothing can cause His devotees to fall down. He is always protecting them.

NoD 6-1970: How to Discharge Devotional Service

Chapter Six

How to Discharge Devotional Service

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé states that his elder brother (Sanätana Gosvämé) has compiled Hari-bhakti-viläsa for the guidance of the Vaiñëavas, and therein has mentioned many rules and regulations to be followed by the Vaiñëavas. Some of them are very important and prominent, and he will now mention these very important items for our benefit. The purport of this statement is that Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé proposes to mention only basic principles, not details. For example, a basic principle is that one has to accept a spiritual master. Exactly how one follows the instructions of his spiritual master is considered a detail. For example, if one is following the instruction of his spiritual master and that instruction is different from the instructions of another spiritual master, this is called detailed information. But the basic principle of acceptance of a spiritual master is good everywhere, although the details may be different. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé does not wish to enter into details here, but he wants to place before us only the principles.

He mentions the basic principles as follows: 1) accepting the shelter of the lotus feet of a bona fide spiritual master, 2) becoming initiated by the spiritual master and learning how to discharge devotional service from him, 3) obeying the orders of the spiritual master with faith and devotion, 4) following in the footsteps of great äcäryas (teachers) under the direction of the spiritual master, 5) inquiring from the spiritual master how to advance in Kåñëa consciousness, 6) being prepared to give up anything material for the satisfaction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa (This means that when we are engaged in the devotional service of Kåñëa, we must be prepared to give up something which we may not like to give up, and also we have to accept something which we may not like to accept.), 7) residing in a sacred place of pilgrimage like Dvärakä or Våndävana, 8) dealing with the material world only as far as necessary, 9) observing the fasting day on Ekädaçé, and 10) worshiping sacred trees like the banyan tree and others.

These ten items are preliminary necessities for beginning the discharge of devotional service in regulative principles. In the beginning, if a neophyte devotee observes the above-mentioned ten principles, surely he will quickly make good advancement in Kåñëa consciousness.

The next set of instructions is listed as follows: 1) One should rigidly give up the company of nondevotees. 2) One should not instruct a person who is not desirous of accepting devotional service. 3) One should not be very enthusiastic about constructing costly temples or monasteries. 4) One should not try to read too many books, nor should one develop the idea of earning his livelihood by lecturing on or by professionally reciting Çrémad-Bhägavatam or the Bhagavad-gétä. 5) One should not be neglectful in ordinary dealings. 6) One should not be under the spell of lamentation in loss or tribulation in gain. 7) One should not disrespect the demigods. 8) One should not give unnecessary trouble to any living entity. 9) One should carefully avoid the various offenses in chanting the holy name of the Lord, or in worshiping the Deity in the temple. 10) One should be very intolerant towards the blasphemy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, or His devotees.

Without following the above-mentioned ten principles, one cannot properly elevate himself to the platform of sädhana-bhakti, or devotional service in practice. Altogether, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé mentions twenty items, and all of them are very important. Out of the twenty, the first three—namely, accepting the shelter of a bona fide spiritual master, taking initiation from him and serving him with respect and reverence—are the most important.

The next important items are as follows: 1) One should decorate the body with tilaka, which is the sign of the Vaiñëavas. (The idea is that as soon as a person sees these marks on the body of the Vaiñëava, he will immediately remember Kåñëa. Lord Caitanya said that a Vaiñëava is he whom, when seen, reminds one of Kåñëa. Therefore, it is essential that a Vaiñëava mark his body with tilaka to remind others of Kåñëa.) 2) In marking such tilaka, sometimes one may write Hare Kåñëa on the body. 3) One should accept flowers and garlands that have been offered to the Deity and the spiritual master and put them on his body. 4) One should learn to dance before the Deity. 5) One should learn to bow down immediately upon seeing the Deity or the spiritual master. 6) As soon as one visits a temple of Lord Kåñëa, one must stand up. 7) When the Deity is being borne for a stroll in the street, a devotee should immediately follow the procession. (In this connection it may be noted that in India, especially in Viñëu temples, the system is that apart from the big Deity who is permanently situated in the main area of the temple, there is another set of smaller Deities which are taken in procession in the evening. In some temples it is the custom to hold a big procession in the evening with a band playing and a nice big umbrella over the Deities, who sit on decorated thrones on the cart or palanquin which is carried by devotees. The Deities come out onto the street and travel in the neighborhood while the people of the neighborhood come out to offer prasädam. The residents of the neighborhood all follow the procession so that it is a very nice scene. When the Deity is coming out, the servitors in the temple put forward the daily accounts before Them: so much was the collection, so much was the expenditure. The whole idea is that the Deity is considered to be the proprietor of the whole establishment, and all the priests and other people taking care of the temple are considered to be the servants of the Deity. This system is very, very old and is still followed. So, therefore, it is mentioned here that when the Deity is on stroll the people should follow behind.) 8) A devotee must visit a Viñëu temple at least once or twice every day, morning and evening. (In Våndävana this system is followed very strictly. All the devotees in town go every morning and evening to visit different temples. Therefore during these times there are considerable crowds all over the city. There are about 5,000 temples in Våndävana City. Of course it is not possible to visit all the temples, but there are at least one dozen very big and important temples which were started by the Gosvämés and which should be visited.) 9) One must circumambulate the temple building at least three times. (In every temple there is an arrangement to go around the temple at least three times. Some devotees go around more than three times: ten times, fifteen times—according to their vows. The Gosvämés used to circumambulate Govardhan Hill.) 10) One should circumambulate the whole Våndävana area. 11) One must worship the Deity in the temple according to the regulative principles. (Offering ärätrika, prasädam, decorating the Deity, etc.—these things must be observed regularly.) 12) Rendering personal service to the Deities. 13) Singing. 14) Saìkértana. 15) Chanting. 16) Offering prayers. 17) Reciting notable prayers. 18) Tasting mahä-prasädam (food from the very plate offered before the Deities). 19) Drinking caraëämåtam (water from the bathing of the Deities which is offered to guests). 20) One must smell the incense and flowers offered to the Deity. 21) One must touch the lotus feet of the Deity. 22) One must see the Deity with great devotion. 23) One must offer ärätrika at different times. 24) One must hear about the Lord and His pastimes from Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the Bhagavad-gétä, and similar books. 25) One must pray to the Deity for His mercy. 26) One should remember the Deity. 27) One should meditate upon the Deity. 28) One should render some voluntary service. 29) One should think of the Lord as his friend. 30) One should offer everything to the Lord. 31) One should offer a favorite article (as food or a garment). 32) One should take all kinds of risks for Kåñëa's benefit. 33) In every condition, be a surrendered soul. 34) Pour water on the tulasé tree. 35) Regularly hear Çrémad-Bhägavatam and similar literature. 36) Live in a sacred place like Mathurä, Våndävana or Dvärakä. 37) Offer service to Vaiñëavas (devotees). 38) Arrange your devotional service according to your means. 39) In the month of Kärttika (October and November), make arrangements for special services. 40) During Janmäñöamé (the time of Kåñëa's appearance in this world) observe a special service. 41) Do whatever is done with great care and devotion for the Deity. 42) Relish the pleasure of Bhägavatam reading amongst devotees and not amongst outsiders. 43) Associate with devotees who are considered more advanced. 44) Live in the jurisdiction of Mathurä.

Now, the total regulative principles come to an aggregate of sixty-four items. As we have mentioned, the first are the primary ten regulative principles. Then come the secondary ten regulative principles, and added to these are forty-four other activities. So altogether there are sixty-four items for discharging the regulative practice of devotional service. Out of these sixty-four items, five items—namely, offering water to the tulasé tree, hearing Çrémad-Bhägavatam, associating amongst the devotees, saìkértana and living in Mathurä—are very important.

The sixty-four items of devotional service should include all of our activities of body, mind and speech. As it was stated in the beginning, the regulative principle of devotional service enjoins that all of our senses must be employed in the service of the Lord. Exactly how they can be thus employed is described in the above sixty-four items. Now, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé will give evidences from different scriptures supporting the authenticity of many of these points.

NoD 7-1970: Evidence Regarding Devotional Principles

Chapter Seven

Evidence Regarding Devotional Principles

In the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Prabuddha tells Mahäräj Nimi: "My dear King, please know for certain that in the material world there is no happiness. It is simply a mistake to think that there is happiness here, because this place is full of nothing but miserable conditions. Any person who is seriously desirous of achieving real happiness must seek out a bona fide spiritual master and take shelter of him by initiation. The qualification of a spiritual master is that he must have realized the conclusion of the scriptures by deliberation and arguments and thus be able to convince others of these conclusions. Such great personalities who have taken shelter of the Supreme Godhead, leaving aside all material considerations, are to be understood as bona fide spiritual masters. Everyone should try to find such a bona fide spiritual master in order to fulfill his mission of life, which is to transfer himself to the plane of spiritual bliss."

The purport is that one should not accept as a spiritual master someone who is Fool Number One, who has no direction according to the scriptural injunctions, whose character is doubtful, who does not follow the principles of devotional service, or who has not conquered the influence of the six sense gratifying agents. The six agents of sense gratification are the tongue, the genitals, the belly, anger, the mind and words. Anyone who has practiced controlling these six is permitted to make disciples all over the world. To accept such a spiritual master is the crucial point for advancement in spiritual life. One who is fortunate enough to come under the shelter of a bona fide spiritual master is sure to traverse the path of spiritual salvation without any doubt.

To Accept Initiation from the Spiritual Master and Receive Instructions from Him

Sage Prabuddha continued to speak to the King as follows: "My dear King, a disciple has to accept the spiritual master not only as spiritual master, but also as the representative of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the supersoul. In other words, the disciple should accept the spiritual master as God because he is the external manifestation of Kåñëa." This is confirmed in every scripture, and a disciple should accept the spiritual master as such. One should learn Çrémad-Bhägavatam seriously and with all respect and veneration for the spiritual master. Hearing and speaking Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the religious process which elevates one to the platform of serving and loving the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The attitude of the disciple should always be to satisfy the bona fide spiritual master. Then it will be very easy for him to understand spiritual knowledge. This is confirmed in the Vedas, and it will be further explained by Rüpa Gosvämé that, for a person who has unflinching faith in God and the spiritual master, everything becomes revealed very easily.

To Serve the Spiritual Master with Faith and Confidence

Regarding accepting initiation from the spiritual master, in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 17th Chapter, 22nd verse, it is stated by Lord Kåñëa: "My dear Uddhava, the spiritual master must be accepted not only as My representative but as My very self. He must never be considered on the same level with an ordinary human being. One should never be envious of the spiritual master, as one may be envious of an ordinary man. The spiritual master should always be seen as the representative of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and by serving the spiritual master, one is able to serve all the demigods."

To Follow in the Footsteps of Saintly Persons

In the Skanda Puräëa it is advised that a devotee follow the past äcäryas and saintly persons because by such following one can achieve the desired results, with no chance of lamenting or being baffled in his progress.

In the scripture known as Brahma-yämala it is stated as follows: "If someone wants to pose himself as a great devotee without following the authorities of the revealed scriptures, then his activities will never help him to make progress in devotional service. Instead, he will simply create disturbances for the sincere students of devotional service." Those who do not strictly follow the principles of revealed scriptures are generally called sahajiyä, those who have imagined everything to be cheap, and who have their own concocted ideas, and who do not follow the scriptural injunctions. Such persons are simply creating disturbances in the discharge of devotional service.

In this connection, an objection may be raised by those who are not in devotional service and who do not care for the revealed scriptures. An example of this is seen in Buddhist philosophy. Lord Buddha appeared in the family of a high-grade kñatriya king, but his philosophy was not in accord with the Vedic conclusions and therefore was rejected. Under the patronage of a Hindu king, Mahäräj Açoka, the Buddhist religion was spread all over India and the adjoining countries. However, after the appearance of the great stalwart teacher, Çaìkaräcärya, this Buddhism was driven out beyond the border of India.

The Buddhists or other religionists who do not care for revealed scriptures sometimes say that there are many devotees of Lord Buddha who show devotional service to Lord Buddha and who therefore should be considered devotees. In answer to this argument, Rüpa Gosvämé says that the followers of Buddha cannot be accepted as devotees. Although Lord Buddha is accepted as an incarnation of Kåñëa, the followers of such incarnations are not very advanced in their knowledge of the Vedas. To study the Vedas means to come to the conclusion of the supremacy of the Personality of Godhead. Therefore any religious principle which denies the supremacy of the Personality of Godhead is not accepted and is called atheism. Atheism means defying the authority of the Vedas and decrying the great äcäryas who teach Vedic scriptures for the benefit of the people in general.

Lord Buddha is accepted as an incarnation of Kåñëa in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, but in the same Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that Lord Buddha appeared in order to bewilder the atheist class of men. Therefore his philosophy is meant for bewildering the atheists and should not be accepted. If someone asks, "Why should Kåñëa propagate atheistic principles?" the answer is that it was the desire of the Supreme Personality of Godhead to end the violence which was then being committed in the name of the Vedas. The so-called religionists were falsely using the Vedas to justify such violent acts as meat-eating, and Lord Buddha came to lead the fallen people away from such a false interpretation of the Vedas. Also, for the atheist class, Lord Buddha preached atheism so that they would follow him and thus be tricked into devotional service to Lord Buddha, or Kåñëa.

Inquiring about External Religious Principles

In the Näradéya Puräëa it is said: "If one is actually very serious about devotional service, then all of his purposes will be served without any delay."

Residing in a Sacred Place

In the Padma Puräëa it is stated: "For one who has given up his material sense enjoyment and has accepted the principles of devotional service, the opulence of Viñëu-loka [the kingdom of God] is awaiting." In the same Padma Puräëa it is also said that for a person who has lived in Dvärakä for six months, for one month, or even for one fortnight, there is awaiting elevation to the Vaikuëöha-lokas and all the profits of särüpya-mukti (the privilege of having the same four-handed bodily features as Näräyaëa).

In the Brahma Puräëa it is said: "The transcendental significance of Puruñottama-kñetra, which is the 80-square-mile field of Lord Jagannätha, cannot be properly described. Even the demigods from higher planetary systems see the inhabitants of this Jagannätha Puré as having exactly the same features of body as are possessed by one in Vaikuëöha. That is, the demigods see the inhabitants of Jagannätha Puré as being four-handed."

When there was a meeting of great sages at Naimiñäraëya, Süta Gosvämé was reciting Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and the importance of the Ganges was stated as follows: "The waters of the Ganges are always carrying the flavor of tulasé offered at the lotus feet of Çré Kåñëa, and as such the waters of the Ganges are ever flowing, spreading the glories of Lord Kåñëa. Wherever the waters of the Ganges are flowing, all will be sanctified, both externally and internally."

To Accept Only What is Necessary

In the Näradéya Puräëa it is directed: "One should not accept more than necessary if he is serious about discharging devotional service." The purport is that one should not neglect following the principles of devotional service, nor should one accept the rulings of devotional service which are more than what he can easily perform. For example, it may be said that one should chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra at least 100,000 times daily on his beads. But if this is not possible, then one must minimize his chanting according to his own capacity. Generally, we recommend our disciples to chant at least 16 rounds on their japa beads daily, and this should be completed. But if one is not even able to chant 16 rounds, then he must make it up the next day. He must be sure to keep his vow. If he does not strictly follow this out, then he is sure to be negligent. That is offensive in the service of the Lord. If we encourage offenses, we shall not be able to make progress in devotional service. It is better if one fixes up a regulative principle according to his own ability and then follows that vow without fail. That will make him advanced in spiritual life.

Observing Fasting on Ekädaçé

In the Brahma-vaivarta Puräëa it is said that one who observes fasting on Ekädaçé day is freed from all kinds of reactions to sinful activities and advances in pious life. The basic principle is not just to fast, but to increase one's faith and love for Govinda, or Kåñëa. The real reason for observing fasting on Ekädaçé is to minimize the demands of the body and to engage our time in the service of the Lord by chanting or performing similar service. The best thing to do on fasting days is to remember the pastimes of Govinda and to hear His holy name constantly.

To Offer Respect to the Banyan Trees

In the Skanda Puräëa it is directed that a devotee should offer water to the tulasé plant and ämalaka trees. He should offer respect to the cows and to the brähmaëas and should serve the Vaiñëavas by offering them respectful obeisances and meditating upon them. All of these processes will help the devotee to diminish the reactions to his past sinful activities.

To Give Up the Company of Nondevotees

Lord Caitanya was once asked by one of His householder devotees what the general behavior of a Vaiñëava should be. In this connection, Lord Caitanya replied that a Vaiñëava should always give up the company of nondevotees. Then He explained that there are two kinds of nondevotees: one class is against the supremacy of Kåñëa, and another class is too materialistic. In other words, those who are after material enjoyment and those who are against the supremacy of the Lord are called avaiñëava, and their company should be strictly avoided.

In the Kätyäyana-saàhitä it is stated that even if one is forced to live within a cage of iron or in the midst of a blazing fire, he should accept this position rather than live with nondevotees who are through and through against the supremacy of the Lord. Similarly, in Viñëu-rahasya, there is a statement to the effect that one should prefer to embrace a snake, a tiger or an alligator rather than associate with persons who are worshipers of various demigods and who are impelled by material desire.

In the scriptures it is instructed that one may worship a certain demigod if he is desirous of achieving some material gain. For example, one is advised to worship the sun god if he is desirous of getting rid of a diseased condition. For a beautiful wife, one can worship Umä, the wife of Lord Çiva, and for advanced education one may worship Sarasvaté. Similarly, there is a list in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam for worshipers of all demigods, according to different material desires. But all of these worshipers, although they appear to be very good devotees of the demigods, are still considered to be nondevotees. They cannot be accepted as devotees.

The mäyävädés (impersonalists) say that one can worship any form of the Lord and that it doesn't matter because one reaches the same destination anyway. But it is clearly stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that those who are worshipers of the demigods will ultimately reach only the planets of those demigods, while those who are devotees of the Lord Himself will be promoted to the Lord's abode, the kingdom of God. So actually these persons who are worshipers of demigods have been condemned in the Gétä. It is described that due to their lusty desires they have lost their intelligence, and therefore they have taken to worshiping the different demigods. So in the Viñëu-rahasya these demigod worshipers are forcefully condemned by the statement that it is better to live with the most dangerous animals than to associate with these persons.

Another stricture is that a person may have many disciples, but he should not act in such a way that he will be obliged to any of them for some particular action or some favor. And one should also not be very enthusiastic about constructing new temples, nor should one be enthusiastic about reading various types of books, save and except the ones which lead to the advancement of devotional service. Practically, if one very carefully reads the Bhagavad-gétä, Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Teachings of Lord Caitanya and this Nectar of Devotion, that will give him sufficient knowledge to understand the science of Kåñëa consciousness. One need not take the trouble of reading other books.

In the Seventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 13th Chapter, 7th verse, Närada Muni, while discussing with Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira the various functions of the different orders in society, especially mentions rules for the sannyäsés—those persons who have renounced this material world. One who has accepted the sannyäsa order of life is forbidden to accept as a disciple anyone who is not fit. A sannyäsé should first of all examine whether a prospective student is sincerely seeking Kåñëa consciousness. If he is not, he should not be accepted. However, Lord Caitanya's causeless mercy is such that He advised all bona fide spiritual masters to speak about Kåñëa consciousness everywhere. Therefore, in the line of Lord Caitanya, even the sannyäsés can speak about Kåñëa consciousness everywhere, and if someone is seriously inclined to become a disciple, the sannyäsé always accepts him.

The one point is that without increasing the number of disciples, there is no propagation of the cult of Kåñëa consciousness. Therefore, sometimes even at a risk, a sannyäsé in the line of Caitanya Mahäprabhu may accept even a person who is not thoroughly fit to become a disciple. Later on, by the mercy of such a bona fide spiritual master, the disciple is gradually elevated. However, if one increases the number of disciples simply for some prestige or false honor, he will surely fall down in the matter of executing Kåñëa consciousness.

Similarly, a bona fide spiritual master has no business to read many books simply to show his proficiency or to get popularity by lecturing in different places. One should avoid all these things. It is also stated that a sannyäsé should not be enthusiastic about constructing temples. We can see in the life of various äcäryas in the line of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu that they are not very enthusiastic about constructing temples. However, if somebody comes forward to offer some service, the same reluctant äcäryas will encourage the building of costly temples by such servitors. For example, Rüpa Gosvämé was offered a favor by Mahäräj Mansingh, the commander-in-chief of Emperor Akbar, and Rüpa Gosvämé instructed him to construct a large temple for Govindajé, which cost vast amounts of money.

So a bona fide spiritual master should not personally take any responsibility for constructing temples, but if someone has money and wants to spend it in the service of Kåñëa, an äcärya like Rüpa Gosvämé may utilize the devotee's money to construct a nice costly temple for the service of the Lord. Unfortunately, it happens that someone who is not fit to become a spiritual master may approach wealthy persons to contribute for temple constructions. If such money is utilized by unqualified spiritual masters to live comfortably in costly temples without actually doing any preaching work, this is not acceptable. In other words, a spiritual master needn't be very enthusiastic for constructing temple buildings simply in the name of so-called spiritual advancement. Rather, his first and foremost activity should be to preach. In this connection, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Mahäräj recommended that a spiritual master print books. If one has money, instead of constructing costly temples, one should spend his money for the publication of authorized books in different languages for propagating the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

Straightforwardness in Ordinary Dealings

There is a statement in the Padma Puräëa: "Persons who are engaged in Kåñëa consciousness should never be disturbed by some material gain or loss. Even if there is some material loss, one should not be perturbed, but should always think of Kåñëa within Himself." The purport is that every conditioned soul is always absorbed in thinking of materialistic activities; he has to make himself freed from such thoughts and transfer himself completely to Kåñëa consciousness. As we have already explained, the basic principle of Kåñëa consciousness is to always think of Kåñëa. One should not be disturbed in material loss, but, rather, should concentrate his mind upon the lotus feet of the Lord.

A devotee should not be subjected to lamentation or illusion. There is the following statement in the Padma Puräëa: "Within the heart of a person who is overpowered by lamentation or anger, there is no possibility of Kåñëa being manifested."

The Demigods

One should not become neglectful to offer due respect to the demigods. One may not be a devotee of demigods, but that does not mean that he should be disrespectful to them. For example, a Vaiñëava is not a devotee of Lord Çiva or Lord Brahmä, but he is duty-bound to offer all respects to such highly-positioned demigods. According to Vaiñëava philosophy, one should offer respect even to an ant, so then what need is there to speak of such exalted persons like Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä?

In the Padma Puräëa it is said, "Kåñëa, or Hari, is the master of all demigods, and therefore He is always worshipable. But this does not mean that one should not offer respect to the demigods."

Not Giving Pain to Any Living Entity

This is the statement of Mahäbhärata: "A person who does not disturb or cause painful action in the mind of any living entity, who treats everyone just like a loving father does his children, whose heart is so pure, certainly very soon becomes favored by the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

In so-called civilized society there is sometimes agitation against cruelty to animals, but at the same time regular slaughterhouses are always maintained. A Vaiñëava is not like that. A Vaiñëava can never support animal slaughter nor even give pain to any living entity.

NoD 8-1970: Offenses to Be Avoided

Chapter Eight

Offenses to be Avoided

In the supplementary Vedic literature, there is the following list of 32 offenses in the matter of serving the Lord: 1) One should not enter the temple of the Deity in a car or palanquin or with shoes on the feet. 2) One should not fail to observe the various festivals for the pleasure of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, such as Janmäñöamé, Ratha-yäträ, etc. 3) One should not avoid bowing down before the Deity. 4) One should not enter the temple to worship the Lord without having washed his hands and feet after eating. 5) One should not enter the temple in a contaminated state. (According to Vedic scripture, if someone dies in the family the whole family becomes contaminated for some time, according to its status. For example, if the family is brähmaëa their contamination period is 12 days, for the kñatriyas and vaiçyas it is 15 days, and for çüdras 30 days.) 6) One should not bow down on one hand. 7) One should not circumambulate in front of Çré Kåñëa. (The process of circumambulating the temple is that one should begin circumambulating from the Deity's right-hand side of the temple and come round. Such circumambulation should be performed outside the temple structure at least three times daily.) 8) One should not spread his legs before the Deity. 9) One should not sit before the Deity holding the ankles, elbows or knees with his hands. 10) One should not lie down before the Deity of Kåñëa. 11) One should not accept prasädam before the Deity. 12) One should never speak a lie before the Deity. 13) One should not talk very loudly before the Deity. 14) One should not talk with others before the Deity. 15) One should not cry or howl before the Deity. 16) One should not quarrel or fight before the Deity. 17) One should not chastise anyone before the Deity. 18) One should not be charitable to beggars before the Deity. 19) One should not speak very harshly to others before the Deity. 20) One should not wear a fur blanket before the Deity. 21) One should not eulogize or praise anyone else before the Deity. 22) One should not speak any ill names before the Deity. 23) One should not pass air before the Deity. 24) One should not fail to worship the Deity according to his means. (In the Bhagavad-gétä it is stated that the Lord is satisfied even if some devotee offers him a leaf or a little water. This formula prescribed by the Lord is universally applicable, even for the poorest man. But that does not mean that one who has sufficient means to worship the Lord very nicely should also adopt this method and try to satisfy the Lord simply by offering water and a leaf. If he has sufficient means, he should offer nice decorations, nice flowers, nice foodstuffs and observe all ceremonies. It is not that one should try to satisfy the Supreme Lord with a little water and a leaf, and for himself spend all his money in sense gratification.) 25) One should not eat anything which is not offered first to Kåñëa. 26) One should not fail to offer fresh fruit and grains to Kåñëa, according to the season. 27) After cooking, no one should be offered any foodstuff unless it is first offered to the Deity. 28) One should not sit with his back towards the Deity. 29) One should not offer obeisances silently to the spiritual master; or in other words, one should recite aloud the prayers to the spiritual master while offering obeisances. 30) One should not fail to offer some praise in the presence of the spiritual master. 31) One should not praise himself before the spiritual master. 32) One should not deride the demigods before the Deity.

This is a list of 32 offenses. Besides these, there are a number of offenses which are mentioned in the Varäha Puräëa. They are as follows: 1) One should not touch the Deity in a dark room. 2) One should not fail to strictly follow the rules and regulations in worshiping the Deity. 3) One should not enter the temple of the Deity without first making some sound. 4) One should not offer any foodstuff to the Deity which has been seen by dogs or other lower animals. 5) One should not break the silence while worshiping. 6) One should not pass urine or evacuate while engaged in worshiping. 7) One should not offer incense without offering some flower. 8) Useless flowers without any fragrance should not be offered. 9) One should not fail to wash his teeth very carefully every day. 10) One should not enter the temple directly after sexual intercourse. 11) One should not touch a woman during her menstrual period. 12) One should not enter the temple after touching a dead body. 13) One should not enter the temple wearing garments of red or blue color, or which are unwashed. 14) One should not enter the temple after seeing a dead body. 15) One should not pass air within the temple. 16) One should not be angry within the temple. 17) One should not enter the temple after visiting a crematorium. 18) One should not belch before the Deity. So, until one has fully digested his food, he should not enter the temple. 19) One should not smoke marijuana or gaïjä. 20) One should not take opium or similar intoxicants. 21) One should not enter the Deity room or touch the body of the Deity after having smeared oil over his body. 22) One should not show disrespect to a scripture teaching about the supremacy of the Lord. 23) One should not introduce any opposing scripture. 24) One should not chew betel before the Deity. 25) One should not offer a flower which was kept in an unclean pot. 26) One should not worship the Lord while sitting on the bare floor: one must have a sitting place or carpet. 27) One should not touch the Deity before he has completed taking bath. 28) One should not decorate his forehead with the three-lined tilaka. 29) One should not enter the temple without washing his hands and feet.

Other rules are that one should not offer foodstuff which is cooked by a non-Vaiñëava. One should not worship the Deity before a nondevotee. One should not engage himself in the worship of the Lord while seeing a nondevotee. One should begin the worship of the demigod Gaëapati, who drives away all impediments in the execution of devotional service. In the Brahma-saàhitä it is stated that Gaëapati worships the lotus feet of Lord Nåsiàhadeva, and in that way he has become auspicious for the devotees in clearing out all impediments. Therefore, all devotees should worship Gaëapati. The Deities should not be bathed in water which has been touched by the nails or fingers. When a devotee is perspiring, he should not engage himself in worshiping the Deity. Similarly, there are many other prohibitions, such as one should not cross or step over the flowers offered to the Deities, nor should one take a vow in the name of God. These are all different kinds of offenses in the matter of executing devotional service, and one should be careful to avoid them.

In the Padma Puräëa it is stated that even a person whose life is completely sinful will be completely protected by the Lord if he simply surrenders unto Him. So it is accepted that one who surrenders unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead becomes freed from all sinful reactions. And even when a person becomes an offender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself, he can still be delivered simply by taking shelter of the holy names of the Lord: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. In other words, the chanting of Hare Kåñëa is beneficial for eradicating all sins; but if one becomes an offender to the holy names of the Lord, then he has no chance of being delivered.

The offenses against the chanting of the holy name are as follows: 1) To blaspheme the devotees who have dedicated their lives for propagating the holy name of the Lord. 2) To consider the names of demigods like Lord Çiva or Lord Brahmä to be equal to, or independent of, the name of Lord Viñëu. (Sometimes the atheistic class of men take it that any demigod is as good as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu. But one who is a devotee knows that no demigod, however great he may be, is independently as good as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore if someone thinks that he can chant Kälé, Kälé! or Durgä, Durgä! and it is the same as Hare Kåñëa, that is the greatest offense.) 3) To disobey the orders of the spiritual master. 4) To blaspheme the Vedic literature or literature in pursuance of the Vedic version. 5) To consider the glories of chanting Hare Kåñëa as imagination. 6) To give some interpretation on the holy name of the Lord. 7) To commit sinful activities on the strength of the holy name of the Lord. (Because by chanting the holy name of the Lord one can be freed from all kinds of sinful reactions, it should not be taken that one may continue to act sinfully and after that chant Hare Kåñëa to neutralize his sins. Such a dangerous mentality is very offensive and should be avoided.) 8) To consider the chanting of Hare Kåñëa as one of the auspicious ritualistic activities which are offered in the Vedas as fruitive activities (karma-käëòa). 9) To instruct a faithless person about the glories of the holy name. (Anyone can take part in chanting the holy name of the Lord, but in the beginning one should not be instructed about the transcendental potency of the Lord. Those who are too sinful cannot appreciate the transcendental glories of the Lord, and therefore it is better not to instruct them in this matter.) 10) To not have complete faith in the chanting of the holy names and to maintain material attachments, even after understanding so many instructions on this matter.

Every devotee who claims to be a Vaiñëava must guard against these offenses in order to quickly achieve the desired success.

NoD 9-1970: Further Consideration of Devotional Principles

Chapter Nine

Further Consideration of Devotional Principles

Blasphemy

One should not tolerate blaspheming of the Lord or His devotees. In this connection, in the Tenth Canto, 70th Chapter, 25th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çukadeva Gosvämé tells Parékñit Mahäräj: "My dear King, if a person, after hearing blasphemous propaganda against the Lord and His devotees, does not go away from that place, he becomes bereft of the effect of all pious activities."

In one of Lord Caitanya's Çikñäñöaka verses it is stated: "The devotee should be more tolerant than the tree and more submissive than the grass. He should offer all honor to others, but may not accept any honor for himself." In spite of Lord Caitanya's being so humble and meek as a devotee, when He was informed about injuries inflicted on the body of Çré Nityänanda, He immediately ran to the spot and wanted to kill the offenders, Jagai and Madhai. This behavior of Lord Caitanya is very significant. It shows that a Vaiñëava may be very tolerant and meek, foregoing everything for his personal honor, but when it is a question of the honor of Kåñëa or His devotee, he will not tolerate any insult.

There are three ways of dealing with such insults. If someone is heard blaspheming by words, one should be so expert that he can defeat the opposing party by argument. If he is unable to defeat the opposing party, then the next step is that he should not just stand there meekly, but should give up his life. The third process is followed if he is unable to execute the above-mentioned two processes, and this is that one must leave the place and go away. If a devotee does not do any of the above-mentioned three processes, he falls down from his position of devotion.

Tilaka, Tulasé Beads and Flower Garlands

In the Padma Puräëa there is a statement describing how a Vaiñëava should decorate his body with tilaka and beads: "Persons who put tulasé beads on the neck, who mark twelve places of their body as Viñëu temples with Viñëu's symbolic representations [the four items held in the four hands of Lord Viñëu—conch, mace, disk and lotus], and who have Viñëu tilaka on their forehead, are to be understood as the devotees of Lord Viñëu in this world. Their presence makes the world purified, and anywhere they remain they make that place as good as Vaikuëöha."

A similar statement is in the Skanda Puräëa, which says: "Persons who are decorated with tilaka or gopé-candana [a kind of clay resembling fuller's earth which is produced in certain quarters of Våndävana], and who mark their bodies all over with the holy names of the Lord, and on whose neck and breast there are tulasé beads, are never approached by the Yama-dütas." The Yama-dütas are the constables of King Yama (the Lord of death), who punishes all sinful men. Vaiñëavas are never called for by such constables of Yamaräj. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, in the narration of Ajämila's deliverance, it is said that Yamaräj gave clear instructions to his assistants not to approach the Vaiñëavas. Vaiñëavas are beyond the jurisdiction of Yamaräj's activities.

In the Padma Puräëa it is also mentioned: "A person whose body is decorated with the pulp of sandalwood, with paintings of the holy name of the Lord, is delivered from all sinful reactions, and after his death he goes directly to Kåñëa-loka to live in association with the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

The next instruction is that one should put on flower garlands which are offered to the Deity. In this connection, in the Eleventh Canto, 6th Chapter, 31st verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Uddhava says to Kåñëa, "My dear Kåñëa, I have taken things which You have used and enjoyed, such as garlands of flowers, saintly articles, garments and ornaments, and I eat only the remnants of Your foodstuff because I am Your menial servant. So, therefore, I am sure that I shall not be attacked by the spell of material energy." The purport of this verse is that for any person who simply follows these rules and regulations of decorating the body with the marks of tilaka of gopé-candana or sandalwood pulp, and who puts on the garlands which were offered to Kåñëa, there is no question of being conquered by the spell of material energy. At the time of death, there is no question of such a person being called by the constables of Yamaräj. Even if one does not accept all the Vaiñëava principles, but still takes the remnants of foodstuff offered to Kåñëa, or Kåñëa-prasädam, he will gradually become qualified to rise to the platform of a Vaiñëava.

Similarly, in the Skanda Puräëa Lord Brahmä tells Närada: "My dear Närada, anyone who puts on his neck the flower garland which was formerly used by Kåñëa becomes relieved from all disease and reactions to sinful activities, and gradually he gets liberated from the contamination of matter."

Dancing before the Deity

In the Dvärakä-mähätmya the importance of dancing before the Deity is stated by Lord Kåñëa as follows: "A person who is in a jubilant spirit, who feels profound devotional ecstasy while dancing before Me, and who manifests different features of bodily expression, can burn away all the accumulated sinful reactions he has stocked up for many, many thousands of years." In the same book there is a statement by Närada wherein he asserts: "From the body of any person who claps and dances before the Deity, showing manifestations of ecstasy, all the birds of sinful activities fly away upwards." Just as by clapping the hands one can cause many birds to fly away, similarly the birds of all sinful activities which are sitting on the body can be made to fly away simply by dancing and clapping before the Deity of Kåñëa.

Bowing Down and Standing Up in Honor of the Deity

In the Näradéya Puräëa there is a statement about bowing down and offering respect to the Deity. It is said there: "A person who has performed a great ritualistic sacrifice and a person who has simply offered his respectful obeisances by bowing down before the Lord cannot be held as equals." The person who has executed many great sacrifices will attain the result of his pious activities, but when such results are finished, he has to take birth again on the earthly planet; whereas the person who has once offered respects, bowing down before the Deity, will not again come back to this world, because he will go directly to the abode of Kåñëa.

In the Brahmäëòa Puräëa it is said: "A person who sees the Lord's Ratha-yäträ car festival and then stands up to receive the Lord can purge all kinds of sinful results from his body." A similar statement is there in the Bhaviñya Puräëa, in which it is said: "A person who follows the Ratha-yäträ car when the Rathas [Deities] pass in front or from behind, even if born of a lowly family, will surely be elevated to the position of achieving equal opulence with Viñëu."

Going to the Temple of Viñëu or to Places of Pilgrimage

It is stated in the Puräëas: "Persons who attempt to visit the holy places of pilgrimage, like Våndävana, Mathurä or Dvärakä, are actually glorified. By such traveling activities, they can pass over the desert of material existence."

In the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya, there is a statement about the benefit of visiting the temples of Lord Kåñëa. As we have explained previously, in Våndävana, Mathurä and Dvärakä the system is that all the devotees take advantage of visiting various temples situated in those holy places. It is stated in the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya: "Persons who are impelled by pure devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness and who therefore go to see the Deities of Viñëu in the temple will surely get relief from entering again into the prison house of a mother's womb." The conditioned soul forgets the trouble of living within the mother's womb during birth, but it is a very painful and terrible experience. In order to make an escape from this material condition, one is advised to visit a temple of Viñëu with devotional consciousness. Then one can very easily get out of the miserable condition of material birth.

Circumambulating the Temple of Viñëu

It is said in the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya: "A person who is circumambulating the Deity of Viñëu can counteract the circumambulation of repeated birth and death in this material world." The conditioned soul is circumambulating through repeated births and deaths on account of his material existence, and this can be counteracted simply by circumambulating the Deity in the temple.

The Cäturmäsya ceremony is observed during the four months of the rainy season in India, beginning from Çrävaëa (approximately July, August, September and October). During these four months, saintly persons who are accustomed to travel from one place to another to propagate Kåñëa consciousness remain at one place, usually a holy place of pilgrimage. During these times, there are certain special rules and regulations which are strictly followed. It is stated in the Skanda Puräëa that during this period, if someone circumambulates the temple of Viñëu at least four times, it is understood that he has traveled all over the universe. By such circumambulation, one is understood to have seen all the holy places where the Ganges water is flowing, and by following the regulative principles of Cäturmäsya one can very quickly be raised to the platform of devotional service.

Arcanä

Arcanä means to worship the Deity in the temple. By executing this process one confirms himself as not body but spirit soul. In the Tenth Canto, 81st Chapter, 16th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, it is told how Sudämä, an intimate friend of Kåñëa, while going to the house of a brähmaëa murmured to himself, "Simply by worshiping Kåñëa one can easily achieve all the results of heavenly opulence, liberation, supremacy over the planetary systems of the universe, all the opulences of this material world, and the mystic power of performing the yoga system."

The events leading to Sudämä's murmuring this statement are as follows: Çré Kåñëa had ordered His friend Sudämä to go to a brähmaëa's house and ask for some food. The brähmaëas were performing a great sacrifice, and Çré Kåñëa told Sudämä to plead with them that He and Balaräma were feeling hungry and needed some food. When Sudämä went there, the brähmaëas refused to offer anything, but the wives of the brähmaëas, upon hearing that Çré Kåñëa wanted some foodstuff, immediately took many palatable dishes and went to offer them to Çré Kåñëa. In the Viñëu-rahasya also, it is stated: "Any person within this world who is engaged in the worship of Viñëu can very easily achieve the ever-blissful kingdom of God, known as Vaikuëöha."

Rendering Service to the Lord

It is stated in the Viñëu-rahasya: "Any person who can arrange for service to the Lord in the same way that a king is given service by his attendants is surely elevated to the abode of Kåñëa after death." Actually, in India, the temples are just like royal palaces. They are not ordinary buildings because the worship of Kåñëa should be performed in just the way that a king is worshiped in his palace. So in Våndävana there are many hundreds of temples wherein the Deity is worshiped exactly like a king. In the Näradéya Puräëa it is stated: "If a person stays in the Lord's temple even for a few moments, he can surely achieve the transcendental kingdom of God."

The conclusion is that those who are rich men in society should construct beautiful temples and arrange for the worship of Viñëu, so that people may be attracted to visit such temples and thereby be offered the opportunity of dancing before the Lord, or chanting the holy name of the Lord, or else of hearing the holy name of the Lord. In this way, everyone will be given the chance to elevate himself to the kingdom of God. In other words, even a common man, simply by visiting such a temple, will be able to attain the highest benedictions, not to mention the devotees who are constantly engaged in the service of the Lord in full Kåñëa consciousness.

In this connection, there is a statement in the Fourth Canto of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, wherein King Påthu says to his subjects: "My dear citizens, please note that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Hari, is actually the deliverer of all fallen conditioned souls. No demigod can perform this act of delivering the conditioned souls, because the demigods themselves are conditioned. A conditioned soul cannot deliver another conditioned soul. Only Kåñëa or His bona fide representative can deliver him. The Ganges water which is flowing down from the toe of Lord Viñëu falls upon the earthly planet and other planets and thereby delivers all the conditioned sinful living entities. So what need is there to speak of the deliverance of persons who are always engaged in the service of the Lord? There is no doubt about their liberation, even if they have stocks of sinful activities from many, many births." In other words, a person who is engaged in the worship of the Deities can minimize his stock of sinful reactions coming from many, many previous births. This process of worshiping the Deity has already been described, and one should try to follow these rules and regulations seriously.

In the Liìga Puräëa there is a statement about glorifying and singing about the Lord. It is said there: "A brähmaëa who is constantly engaged in singing the glories of the Lord is surely elevated to the same planet as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Lord Kåñëa appreciates this singing even more than the prayers offered by Lord Çiva."

When a person loudly chants the glories of the Lord's activities, qualities, form, etc., it is called saìkértana. Saìkértana also refers to the congregational chanting of the holy name of the Lord.

In the Viñëu-dharma there is a statement glorifying this process of congregational chanting: "My dear King, this word 'Kåñëa' is so auspicious that anyone who chants this holy name immediately gets rid of the resultant actions of sinful activities from many, many births." That is a fact. There is the following statement in Caitanya-Caritämåta: "A person who chants the holy name of Kåñëa once can counteract the resultant actions of more sinful activities than he is able to perform." A sinful man can perform many, many sinful activities, but he is unable to perform so many that they cannot be wiped out by one single uttering of "Kåñëa."

In the Seventh Canto, 9th Chapter, 17th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Mahäräj Prahläda offers the following prayers to the Lord: "My dear Lord Nåsiàha, if I can be elevated to the position of Your servant, then it will be possible for me to hear about Your activities. You are the supreme friend, the supreme worshipable Deity. Your pastimes are transcendental, and simply by hearing of them one can counteract all his sinful activities. Therefore, I shall not care for all those sinful activities because simply by hearing about Your pastimes I shall get out of all the contamination of material attachment."

There are many songs about the Lord's activities. For example, there is the Brahma-saàhitä, sung by Lord Brahmä, Närada-païcarätra, sung by Närada Muni, and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, sung by Çukadeva Gosvämé. If these songs are heard by any person, he can easily get out of the clutches of material contamination. There should be no difficulty in hearing these songs of God. They are coming down from many, many millions of years ago, and people are still taking advantage of them. So why, at this time, should one not take full advantage and thus become liberated?

Glorifying the Lord's Transcendental Activities

In the First Canto, 5th Chapter, 22nd verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Närada Muni tells his disciple, Vyäsadeva, "My dear Vyäsa, you should know that persons who are engaged in executing austerities and penances, studying the Vedas, performing big sacrifices, chanting the hymns of the Vedas, speculating on transcendental knowledge and performing charitable functions have for all their auspicious activities simply to gain a place in the association of devotees and to chant the glories of the Lord." It is indicated here that chanting and glorifying the Lord is the ultimate activity of the living entity.

Japa

When a mantra or hymn is chanted softly and slowly, that is called japa. The same mantra, when chanted loudly, is called kértana. For example, the mahä-mantra (Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare) when uttered very softly only for one's own hearing is called japa. The same mantra, when chanted loudly for being heard by all others, is called kértana. The mahä-mantra can be used for japa and kértana also. When japa is practiced it is for the personal benefit of the chanter, but when kértana is performed it is for the benefit of all others who may hear.

In the Padma Puräëa there is a statement: "For any person who is chanting the holy name either softly or loudly, the paths to liberation and even heavenly happiness are at once open."

Submission

In the Skanda Puräëa there is a statement about submission unto the lotus feet of the Lord. It is said there that those who are sober devotees can offer their submission to Kåñëa in the following three ways: 1) sampräthanätmikä, very feelingly offering prayers; 2) dainyavodhikä, humbly submitting oneself; 3) lälasämayé, desiring some perfectional stage. This desiring some perfectional stage in spiritual life is not sense gratification. When one realizes something of his constitutional relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he understands his original position and wants to be reinstated in this position, either as friend, servant, parent or conjugal lover of Kåñëa. That is called lälasämayé, or very eagerly desiring to go to one's natural position. This lälasämayé stage of submission comes in the stage of perfect liberation, which is technically called svarüpa-siddhi, when the living entity understands, by perfect spiritual advancement and revelation, his original relationship with the Lord.

Submission in Feeling

In the Skanda Puräëa there is a statement by devotees praying to the Lord: "My Lord, I know that young girls have natural affection for young boys, and that young boys have natural affection for young girls. I am praying at Your lotus feet that my mind may become attracted unto You in the same spontaneous way." The example is very appropriate. When a young boy or girl sees a member of the opposite sex there is a natural attraction, without the need for any introduction. Without any training there is a natural attraction due to the sex impulse. This is a material example, but the devotee is praying that he may develop a similar spontaneous attachment for the Supreme Lord, free from any desire for profit and without any other cause. This natural attraction for the Lord is the perfectional stage of self realization.

In the same Skanda Puräëa there is a statement about submission and humbleness. It is stated there: "My dear Lord, there is no sinful living entity who is more of a sinner than myself. Nor is there a greater offender than myself. I am so greatly sinful and offensive that when I come to confess my sinful activities before You, I am ashamed." This is a natural position for a devotee. As far as the conditioned soul is concerned, there is no wonder that he has some sinful activities in his past life, and this should be admitted and confessed before the Lord. As soon as this is done the Lord excuses the sincere devotee. But that does not mean that one should take advantage of the Lord's causeless mercy and expect to be excused over and over again, while he commits the same sinful activities. Such a mentality is only for shameless persons. Here it is clearly said, "When I come to confess my sinful activities I become ashamed." So if a person is not ashamed of his sinful activities and continues to commit the same sinful activities with the knowledge that the Lord will excuse him, that is a most nonsensical proposition. Such an idea is not accepted in any part of the Vedic literature. It is a fact that by chanting the holy name of the Lord one becomes washed clean of all sinful activities from his past life. But that does not mean that after being washed off, one should again begin sinful activities and expect to be washed again. These are nonsensical propositions and are not admitted in the devotional service. Someone may think: "For a whole week I may commit sinful activities, and for one day I will go to the temple or church and admit my sinful activities so that I can become washed off and again begin my sinning." This is most nonsensical and offensive and is not acceptable to the author of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu.

In the Närada-païcarätra there is a statement of submission accompanied by the desire for perfection. The devotee says, "My dear Lord, when shall that day come when You will ask me to fan Your body, and according to Your pleasure, You will say, 'You just fan Me in this way'?" The idea in this verse is that the devotee is desiring to personally fan the body of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. That means that he is desiring to become the personal associate of the Supreme Lord. Of course, any devotee in any capacity, either as servant, friend or conjugal lover, always has direct association with the Lord. But according to his different individual taste, a person desires for just one of these relationships. Here the devotee is desiring to become a servant of the Lord and desires to fan the Lord, as does His internal energy, Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune. He also wishes that the Personality of Godhead will be pleased to give him directions as to how to fan. This submission with transcendental desire, or lälasämayé vijïapti, is the highest perfectional stage of spiritual realization.

In the same Närada-païcarätra, there is another expression of submission, wherein the devotee says, "My dear Lord, O lotus-eyed one, when will that day come when on the bank of the Yamunä, I shall become just like a madman and continue to chant Your holy name while incessant tears flow from my eyes?" This is another perfectional stage. Lord Caitanya also desired that "a moment will appear unto Me as twelve years of time, and the whole world will appear to Me as vacant on account of not seeing You, My dear Lord." One should feelingly pray and become eager to render his particular type of service to the Lord. This is the teaching of all great devotees, especially Lord Caitanya.

In other words, one should learn how to cry for the Lord. One should learn this small technique, and he should be very eager and actually cry to become engaged in some particular type of service. This is called laulyam, and such tears are the price for the highest perfection. If one develops this laulyam, or excessive eagerness for meeting and serving the Lord in a particular way, that is the price to enter into the kingdom of God. Otherwise, there is no material calculation for the value of the ticket by which one can enter the kingdom of God. The only price for such entrance is this laulyam lälasämayé, or desire and great eagerness.

Prayers

According to great learned scholars, the whole Bhagavad-gétä contains many authorized prayers, especially in the Eleventh Chapter, where Arjuna prays to the universal form of the Lord. Similarly, in the Gautaméya Tantra all the verses are called prayers. Again in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, there are hundreds of prayers to the Lord. So a devotee should select some of these prayers for his recitation. In the Skanda Puräëa the glories of these prayers are stated as follows: "Devotees whose tongues are decorated always with prayers to Lord Kåñëa are always given respect even by the great saintly persons and sages, and such devotees are actually worshipable by the demigods."

Those who are less intelligent want to worship different demigods for some material gain rather than worship Kåñëa. But here it is stated that a devotee who is always engaged in offering prayers to the Lord is worshipable even by the demigods themselves. The pure devotees have nothing to ask from any demigod, but rather the demigods are anxious to offer prayers to the pure devotees.

In the Nåsiàha Puräëa it is stated: "Any person who comes before the Deity of Lord Kåñëa and begins to chant different prayers is immediately relieved from all the reactions of sinful activities and becomes eligible, without any doubt, to enter into the Vaikuëöha-loka."

Partaking of Prasädam

There is this specific statement in the Padma Puräëa: "A person who honors the prasädam and regularly eats it, not exactly in front of the Deity, along with caraëämåtam [the water offered to the lotus feet of the Lord, which is mixed with seeds of the tulasé tree], immediately can achieve the results of pious activities which are obtained through ten thousand performances of sacrificial rites."

Caraëämåtam is obtained in the morning while the Lord is being washed before dressing. Scented with perfumes and flowers, the water comes gliding down through His lotus feet and is collected and mixed with yogurt. In this way this caraëämåtam not only becomes very tastefully flavored, but it also has tremendous spiritual value. It is described in the Padma Puräëa that even a person who has never been able to give in charity, who has never been able to perform a great sacrifice, who has never been able to study the Vedas, who has never been able to worship the Lord—or, in other words, even one who has never done any pious activities—if he simply drinks the caraëämåtam which is kept in the temple, he will become eligible to enter into the kingdom of God. In the temple it is the custom that the caraëämåtam be kept in a big pot. The devotees who come to visit and offer respects to the Deity very submissively take three drops of caraëämåtam and feel themselves happy in transcendental bliss.

Smelling the Incense

In the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya there is a statement about the incense which is offered in the temple: "When the devotees smell the good flavor of the incense which is offered to the Deity, they thus become cured of the poisonous effects of material contamination, as much as one becomes cured of a snake bite by smelling the prescribed medicinal herbs." The explanation of this verse is that there is an herb which is found in the jungles which expert persons know how to use to revive the consciousness of one who is bitten by a snake. Simply by smelling that herb one becomes immediately relieved of the poisonous effects of the snake bite. The same example is applicable: when a person comes to visit the temple and smells the incense offered to the Deity, he is cured at that time from all his material contamination.

Any devotee coming into the temple should always offer something to the Deity—fruit, flowers, incense, etc. If one cannot offer anything in cash, something else must be offered. In India the system is that all the ladies and gentlemen who come in the morning to visit the temple bring so many things. Even one morsel of rice or one morsel of flour can be offered. It is a regulative principle that one should not go to see a saintly person or the Deity in the temple without any offering. The offering may be very humble, or it may be priceless. Even a flower, a little fruit, a little water—whatever is possible—must be offered. So when a devotee comes to offer something to the Deity in the morning, he is sure to smell the good flavor of the incense, and then at once he will become cleansed of the poisonous effect of material existence.

It is stated in the Tantra-çästra: "If the smell of the garland which was offered to the Deity in the temple enters into the nostril of a person, immediately his bondage to sinful activities becomes cleared. And even if one has no sinful activities, still, by smelling such remnants of flowers, one can advance from mäyävädé (impersonalist) to devotee." There are several instances of this, a prime one being the advancement of the four Kumäras. They were impersonalist mäyävädés, but after smelling the remnants of flowers and incense in the temple, they turned to become devotees. From the above verse it appears that the mäyävädés or impersonalists are more or less contaminated. They are not pure.

It is confirmed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam: "One who has not washed off all reactions of sinful activities cannot be a pure devotee. A pure devotee has no more doubts about the supremacy of the Personality of Godhead, and thus he engages himself in Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service." A similar statement is in the Agastya-saàhitä: Just to purify the impurities of our nostrils, we should try to smell the remnants of flowers offered to Kåñëa in the temple.

Touching the Deity

In the Viñëu-dharmottara there is a statement about touching the lotus feet of the Lord. It is said: "Only a person who is initiated as a Vaiñëava and is executing devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness has the right to touch the body of the Deity." In India there was agitation during Gandhi's political movement because the lowborn classes of men like street-sweepers and caëòälas are prohibited, according to the Vedic system, from entering the temple. Due to their unclean habits they are prohibited, but at the same time they are given other facilities so they may be elevated to the highest grade of devotional service by association with pure devotees. A man born in any family is not barred, but he must be cleansed. That cleansing process must be adopted. Gandhi wanted to make them clean simply by stamping them with a fictitious name, Hari-jana (children of God), and so there was a great tug of war between the temple owners and Gandhi's followers.

But anyway, the present law is the law of all scripture—that if anyone is purified he can enter into the temple. Actually, that is the position. Only one who is properly initiated, who is properly following the rules and regulations, can enter and touch the Deity—not all. And one who touches the body of the Deity, following such regulative principles, is immediately delivered from the contamination of material sins, and all of his desires become fulfilled without delay.

In the Varäha Puräëa, also, there is a statement praising the touching of the Deity of Çré Kåñëa in the temple. A devotee says there: "My dear Vasundharä, any person who goes to Våndävana and sees the Deity of Govindadeva is free from the courthouse of Yamaräj and is allowed to enter into the highest planetary system, in which reside the demigods." This means that even an ordinary person who goes to Våndävana out of inquisitiveness and by chance sees the temple, especially that of Govindadeva, even if he is not elevated to the spiritual kingdom, is still assured promotion to the higher planetary systems. This means that simply by visiting the Deity of Govinda in Våndävana one becomes highly elevated in pious life.

Observing Ärätrika and Celebrations of the Lord

In the Skanda Puräëa there is the following description of the result of seeing ärätrika (worship) of the Deity: "If someone sees the face of the Lord while ärätrika is going on, he can be relieved of all sinful reactions coming from many, many thousands and millions of years past. He is even excused from the killing of a brähmaëa or similar prohibited activities."

As we have already explained, there are different ceremonies to be observed, such as the birthday of Kåñëa, the birthday of Lord Rämacandra, the birthday of some prominent Vaiñëavas, the ceremony of Jhulan-yäträ with the Lord sitting on a swing, Dola-yäträ (the Lord's activities in the month of March), and so on. In all festivals the Lord is seated on the car, and the car moves through different streets of the city so that people may take advantage of visiting the Lord. In the Bhaviñya Puräëa it is said: "In such a ceremony, if even a caëòäla [dog-eater], simply out of curiosity, sees the Lord on the cart, he becomes counted as one of the associates of Viñëu."

In the Garuòa Puräëa it is stated: "Any person who in gladness sees the worship of the Deity in the temple will obtain the results of kriyä-yoga which are described in the Païcarätra scripture." Kriyä-yoga is a system of practice much like practical devotional service, but it is especially meant for the mystic yogés. In other words, by this gradual process, the mystic yogés are eventually elevated to the devotional service of the Lord.

NoD 10-1970: Techniques of Hearing and Memorizing

Chapter Ten

Techniques of Hearing and Memorizing

The beginning of Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service is hearing, in Sanskrit called çravaëam. All people should be given the chance to come and join devotional parties so that they may hear. This hearing is very important for progressing in Kåñëa consciousness. When one links his ears to give aural reception to the transcendental vibrations he can quickly become purified and cleansed in the heart. Lord Caitanya has affirmed that this hearing is very important. It cleanses the heart of the contaminated soul so that he becomes quickly qualified to enter into devotional service and to understand Kåñëa consciousness.

In the Garuòa Puräëa the stress on hearing is expressed very nicely. It is said there: "The state of conditioned life in the material world is just like a man lying unconscious, having been bitten by a snake. This is because both such unconscious states can be ended by the sound of a mantra." When a man is snake-bitten he does not die immediately, but first becomes unconscious and remains in a comatose condition. Anyone who is in the material world is also sleeping, as he is ignorant of his actual self or his actual duty and his relationship with God. So materialistic life means that one is bitten by the snake of mäyä, illusion, and thus, without any Kåñëa consciousness, he is almost dead. Now the so-called dead man bitten by a snake can be brought back again to life by the chanting of some mantra. There are expert chanters of these mantras who can perform this feat. Similarly, one can be brought back into Kåñëa consciousness from the deadly unconscious state of material life by hearing of the mahä-mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

In the Fourth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 29th Chapter, 37th verse, the importance of hearing of the pastimes of the Lord is stated by Çukadeva Gosvämé to Mahäräj Parékñit: "My dear King, one should stay at a place where the great äcäryas [holy teachers] speak about the transcendental activities of the Lord, and one should give aural reception to the nectarean river flowing from the moonlike faces of such great personalities. If someone eagerly continues to hear such transcendental sounds, then certainly he will become freed from all material hunger, thirst, fear and lamentation, as well as all illusions of material existence."

Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu also recommended this process of hearing as a means of self realization in the present age of Kali. In this age it is very difficult to follow thoroughly the regulative principles and studies of the Vedas which were formerly recommended. However, if one gives aural reception to the sound vibrated by great devotees and äcäryas, that alone will give him relief from all material contamination. Therefore it is the recommendation of Caitanya Mahäprabhu that one should simply hear from authorities who are actually devotees of the Lord. Hearing from professional men will not help. If we hear from those who are actually self realized, then the nectarean rivers, like those which are flowing on the moon planet, will flow into our ears. This is the metaphor used in the above verse.

As is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, "A materialistic person can give up his material hankerings only by becoming situated in Kåñëa consciousness." Unless one finds a superior engagement he will not be able to give up his inferior engagement. In the material world everyone is engaged in the illusory activities of inferior energy, but when one is given the opportunity to relish the activities of the superior energy performed by Kåñëa, then he forgets all his lesser pleasures. When Kåñëa speaks on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, to the materialistic person it appears that this is simply talk between two friends, but actually it is a river of nectar flowing down from the mouth of Çré Kåñëa. Arjuna gave aural reception to such vibrations, and thus he became freed from all the illusions of material problems.

In the Twelfth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 3rd Chapter, 12th verse, it is stated: "A person who desires unalloyed devotional service to Lord Kåñëa, who is praised by transcendental sound vibrations, should always hear about His glorification and transcendental qualities. This will surely kill all kinds of inauspiciousness in the heart."

Also, in the Tenth Canto, 14th Chapter, 8th verse, it is said: "My dear Lord, any person who is constantly awaiting Your causeless mercy to be bestowed upon him, and who goes on suffering the resultant actions of his past misdeeds, offering You respectful obeisances from the core of his heart, is surely eligible to become liberated, for it has become his rightful claim."

This statement of Çrémad-Bhägavatam should be the guide of all devotees. A devotee should not expect immediate relief from the reactions of his past misdeeds. No conditioned soul is free from such reactionary experiences because material existence means continued suffering or enjoying of past activities. If one has finished his material activities then there is no more birth. This is only possible when one begins Kåñëa conscious activities, because such activities do not produce reaction. Therefore, as soon as one becomes perfect in Kåñëa conscious activities, he is not going to take birth again in this material world. A devotee who is not perfectly freed from the resultant actions should therefore continue to act in Kåñëa consciousness seriously, even though there may be so many impediments. When such impediments arise he should simply think of Kåñëa and expect His mercy. That is the only solace. If the devotee passes his days in that spirit, it is certain that he is going to be promoted to the abode of the Lord. By such activities, he earns his claim to enter into the kingdom of God. The exact word used in this verse is däyabhäk. Däyabhäk refers to a son's becoming the lawful inheritor of the property of the father. In a similar way, a pure devotee who is prepared to undergo all kinds of tribulations in executing Kåñëa consciousness duties becomes lawfully qualified to enter into the transcendental abode.

Remembrance

Some way or other, if someone establishes in his mind his continuous relationship with Kåñëa, this relationship is called remembrance. About this remembrance there is a nice statement in the Viñëu Puräëa, where it is said: "Simply by remembering the Supreme Personality of Godhead all living entities become eligible for all kinds of auspiciousness. Therefore let me always remember the Lord, who is unborn and eternal." In the Padma Puräëa the same remembrance is explained as follows: "Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Lord Kåñëa, because if someone remembers Him, either at the time of death or during his span of life, he becomes freed from all sinful reactions."

Meditation

Meditation means to engage the mind in thinking of the form of the Lord, of the qualities of the Lord, of the activities of the Lord and of the service of the Lord. Meditation does not mean anything impersonal or void. According to Vedic literature, meditation is always on the form of Viñëu.

In the Nåsiàha Puräëa there is a statement about meditation on the form of the Lord. It is said there: "Meditation focusing on the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead has been accepted as transcendental and beyond the experience of material pain and pleasure. By such meditation even one who is grossly miscreant can be delivered from the sinful reactions of his life."

In the Viñëu-dharma there is a statement about meditation on the transcendental quality of the Lord. It is said, "Persons who are constantly engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, and who remember the transcendental qualities of the Lord, become free from all reactions to sinful activities, and after being so cleansed they become fit to enter into the kingdom of God." In other words, no one can enter into the kingdom of God without being freed from all sinful reactions. Sinful reactions can be avoided simply by remembering the form, qualities, pastimes, etc., of the Lord.

In the Padma Puräëa there is a statement about remembering the activities of the Lord: "A person who is always engaged in meditation on the sweet pastimes and wonderful activities of the Lord surely becomes freed from all material contamination."

Meditation on Executing Devotional Service

In some of the Puräëas the evidence is given that if someone is simply meditating on devotional activities, he has achieved the desired result and has seen face to face the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In this connection, there is a story in the Brahma-vaivarta Puräëa that in the city of Pratiñöhänapura in South India there was once a brähmaëa who was not very well-to-do, but who was nevertheless satisfied in himself, thinking that because of his past misdeeds, and by the desire of Kåñëa, he did not get sufficient money and opulence. So he was not at all sorry for his poor material position, and he used to live very peacefully. He was very openhearted, and sometimes he went to hear some lectures delivered by great realized souls. At one such meeting, while he was very faithfully hearing about Vaiñëava activities, he was informed that these activities can be performed even by meditation. In other words, if a person is unable to actually perform Vaiñëava activities physically, he can meditate upon the Vaiñëava activities and thereby acquire all of the same results. Because the brähmaëa was not very well-to-do financially, he decided that he would simply meditate on grand, royal devotional activities, and he began this business thusly:

Sometimes he would take his bath in the River Godävaré. After taking his bath he would sit in a secluded place on the bank of the river, and, by practicing the yoga exercises of präëäyäma, the usual breathing exercise, he would concentrate his mind. This breathing exercise is meant to mechanically make the mind fixed upon a particular subject. That is the result of the breathing exercise and also of the different sitting postures of yoga. Formerly, even quite ordinary persons used to know how to fix the mind upon the remembrance of the Lord, and so the brähmaëa was doing this. When he had fixed the form of the Lord in his mind, he began to imagine in his meditations that he was dressing the Lord very nicely in costly clothing, with ornaments, helmets and other paraphernalia. Then he offered his respectful obeisances by bowing down before the Lord. After finishing the dressing he began to imagine that he was cleaning the temple very nicely. After cleansing the temple, he imagined that he had many water jugs made of gold and silver, and he took all those jugs to the river and filled them with the holy water. Not only did he collect water from Godävaré, but he collected from the Ganges, Yamunä, Narmadä and Käveré. Generally a Vaiñëava, while worshiping the Lord, collects water from all these rivers by mantra chanting. This brähmaëa, instead of chanting some mantra, imagined that he was physically securing water from all these rivers in golden and silver water pots. Then he collected all kinds of worshipful paraphernalia—flowers, fruits, incense and sandalwood pulp. He collected everything to place before the Deity. All these waters, flowers and scented articles were then very nicely offered to the Deities to Their satisfaction. Then he offered ärätrika, and with the regulative principles he finished all these activities in the correct worshiping method.

He would daily execute similar performances as his routine work, and he continued to do so for many, many years. Then one day the brähmaëa imagined in his meditations that he had prepared some sweet rice with milk and sugar and offered the preparation to the Deity. However, he was not very satisfied with the offering because the sweet rice had been prepared recently and it was still very hot. (This preparation, sweet rice, should not be taken hot. The cooler the sweet rice, the better its taste.) So because the sweet rice was prepared by the brähmaëa very recently, he wanted to touch it so that he could know whether it was fit for eating by the Lord. As soon as he touched the sweet rice pot with his finger, he immediately was burnt by the heat of the pot. In this way, his meditation broke. Now, when he looked at his finger, he saw that it was burnt, and he was wondering in astonishment how this could have happened. Because he was simply meditating on touching the hot sweet rice, he never thought that his finger would actually become burnt.

While he was thinking like this, in Vaikuëöha Lord Näräyaëa, seated with the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé, began to smile humorously. On seeing this smiling of the Lord, all the goddesses of fortune who were attending the Lord became very curious and asked Lord Näräyaëa why He was smiling. The Lord, however, did not reply to their inquisitiveness, but instead immediately sent for the brähmaëa. An airplane sent from Vaikuëöha immediately brought the brähmaëa into Lord Näräyaëa's presence. When the brähmaëa was thus present before the Lord and the goddesses of fortune, the Lord explained the whole story. The brähmaëa was then fortunate enough to get an eternal place in Vaikuëöha in the association of the Lord and His Lakñmés. This shows how the Lord is all-pervading, in spite of His being locally situated in His abode. Although the Lord was present in Vaikuëöha, He was present also in the heart of the brähmaëa when he was meditating on the worshiping process. Thus, we can understand that things offered by the devotees even in meditation are accepted by the Lord, and they help one achieve the desired result.

NoD 11-1970: Aspects of Transcendental Service

Chapter Eleven

Aspects of Transcendental Service

Servitorship

In the opinion of the karmés (fruitive workers), offering the results of karma is called servitorship. But according to Vaiñëava äcäryas like Rüpa Gosvämé, servitorship means to be constantly engaged in some kind of service to the Lord.

In the Skanda Puräëa it is said that those who are attached to ritualistic activities, the four orders of social life and the four orders of spiritual life, are considered devotees. But when devotees are actually engaged in offering service to the Lord directly, these must be bhägavatas, or pure devotees. Those who are engaged in fruitive activities, or prescribed duties according to the four orders of social and spiritual life, are not actually pure devotees. But still, because they are offering the result to the Lord, they are accepted as devotees. When one has no such desire, but acts spontaneously out of love of God, such a person must be accepted as a pure devotee. The conditioned souls who have come into contact with the material world are all more or less desirous of lording it over material nature. The system of varëäçrama and the prescribed duties under this system are so designed that the conditioned soul may enjoy in the material world according to his desire for sense gratification and at the same time gradually become elevated to spiritual understanding. Under these prescribed duties of varëa and äçrama there are many activities which belong to devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness. Those devotees who are householders accept Vedic ritualistic performances as well as the prescribed duties of devotional service, because both are meant for satisfying Kåñëa. When householder devotees perform some Vedic ritualistic duties, they do so to satisfy Kåñëa. As we have previously discussed, any activity aiming at satisfying the Supreme Personality of Godhead is considered devotional service.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé describes one who is fit for becoming engaged in devotional service. He says that persons who are neophytes and who have developed a little love of Godhead are not interested in the activities of sense gratification, in proportion to their devotion. But if there is still some attraction for sense gratifying activities, then the result of such activities should be offered to Kåñëa. This is also called engagement in the service of the Lord, with the Lord as the master and the worker as the servant.

In the Näradéya Puräëa there is a statement of how this servitorship is transcendental. It is said there that a person who is constantly engaged in devotional service by his body, mind and words, or even a person who is not practically engaged but is simply desiring to be so, is considered to be liberated.

Devotional Service in Friendship

Devotional service in friendship can be divided into two categories: one is to act as the confidential servant of the Lord, and the other is to act as the well-wisher of the Lord. The devotee who has confidence in devotional service to the Lord systematically follows the rules and regulations, with the faith that he will achieve the platform of transcendental life. The second type of devotional friendship is to become a well-wisher of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Bhagavad-gétä it is said that the Lord accepts a preacher as the most dear servant. Anyone who is preaching the confidential message of the Gétä to the people in general is so dear to Kåñëa that no one can be equal with him in human society.

In the Mahäbhärata, Draupadé says, "My dear Govinda, Your promise is that Your devotee can never be vanquished. I believe in that statement, and therefore in all kinds of tribulations I simply remember Your promise, and thus I live." The purport is that Draupadé and her five husbands, the Päëòavas, were put into severe tribulations by their cousin-brother, Duryodhana, as well as by others. The tribulations were so severe that even Bhéñmadeva, who was both a lifelong brahmacäré and a great warrior, would sometimes shed tears thinking of them. He was always surprised that, although the Päëòavas were so righteous and Draupadé practically the goddess of fortune, and although Kåñëa was their friend, still they had to undergo such severe tribulations. Though their tribulations were not ordinary, still Draupadé was not discouraged. She knew that because Kåñëa was their friend, ultimately they would be saved.

A similar statement is there in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 2nd Chapter, 5th verse, where Havi, the son of King Åñabha, addresses Mahäräj Nimi: "My dear King, a person who never deviates even for a moment from engagement in service at the lotus feet of the Supreme Person (engagement which is sought after even by great demigods like Indra) with firm conviction that there is nothing more worshipable or desirable than this, is called the first-class devotee."

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé says that a neophyte devotee who has simply developed a slight love of Godhead is certainly a prospective candidate for devotional service. When he becomes firmly fixed in such devotional service, that assured status becomes a confidential part of his devotional service.

Sometimes it is found that a pure devotee lies down in the temple of the Lord in order to serve Him as a confidential friend. Such friendly behavior of a devotee may be accepted as rägänugä, or spontaneous. Although, according to regulative principles, no one can lie down in the temple of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, this spontaneous love of Godhead can be grouped under devotional service in friendship.

Regarding complete self-surrender, there is a nice description in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 29th Chapter, 32nd verse, where the Lord says: "A person who has completely surrendered unto Me and has completely given up all other activities is protected by Me personally, both in this life and in the next. In other words, I wish to help him become more and more advanced in spiritual life. Such a person is to be understood as having already achieved särñöi [having equal opulences with the supreme]." It is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä that as soon as a person surrenders unto the lotus feet of Kåñëa, Kåñëa takes charge of him and gives him a guarantee of protection from all sinful reactions. He also instructs from within, so that the devotee may very quickly make advancement towards spiritual perfection.

This self-surrender is called ätma-nivedana. According to different authorities, "self" is differently defined. "Self" is sometimes considered to refer to the spirit self, or soul, and "self" is sometimes considered to refer to the mind or to the body. Full self-surrender, therefore, means not only surrendering one's self as spirit soul, but also surrendering one's mind and body to the service of the Lord. Çréla Bhaktivinode Thäkur has sung a nice song in this connection. While offering himself as a fully surrendered soul, he said, "My mind, my household affairs, my body, whatever is in my possession, my dear Lord, I offer to You for Your service. Now You can do with them as You like. You are the supreme possessor of everything, so if You like You can kill me, or if You like You can give me protection. All authority belongs to You. I have nothing to claim as my own."

Çré Yämunäcärya, in his prayers to the Lord, has expressed a similar idea in the following words: "My dear Lord, I may be living within some body as a human being or as a demigod, but whatever mode of life, I do not mind, because these bodies are simply by-products of the three modes of material nature, and I, who am in possession of these bodies, am surrendering myself unto You."

In the Hari-bhakti-viveka, there is a statement regarding how one can offer his body in self-surrender. There the devotee says, "My dear Lord, as a sold-out animal has no need to think about his maintenance and sustenance, so, because I have given up my body and soul unto You, I am no longer concerned with my maintenance and sustenance." In other words, one should not bother about his personal or family maintenance or sustenance. If one is actually surrendered in body and soul, he should always remember that his only concern is to be engaged in the service of the Lord.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that devotional service in friendship and devotional service in self-surrender are two difficult processes. Therefore such relationships with the Lord can very rarely be seen. Only for the advanced devotees are these two processes easily executed. The purport is that it is very rare to see surrender which is mixed with sincere ecstatic devotion. One must give himself completely to the will of the Lord.

In the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 40th verse, 11th Chapter, Lord Kåñëa tells Uddhava: "My dear friend, if someone offers Me the best thing in his possession, or anything which is very pleasing to him, he will be eternally benefitted."

In the Närada-païcarätra there is a statement of how one can act in all spheres of life for the satisfaction of the Lord. It is stated there that a person who is actually in devotional service must be engaged in all kinds of activities, those prescribed in the revealed scriptures and also those which are accepted for livelihood. In other words, a devotee should engage himself not only in the prescribed duties of devotional service which are mentioned in the revealed scriptures, but he should also perform the duties of his practical life in Kåñëa consciousness. For example, a devotee who has a great establishment, or factory, may offer the fruits of such a material possession for the service of the Lord.

In the Hari-bhakti-viläsa there is the following statement about self-surrender: "My dear Lord, a person who has surrendered himself unto You, and who is in firm conviction that he is Yours, and actually acts in that way by his body, mind and words, can actually relish transcendental bliss."

In the Nåsiàha Puräëa, Lord Nåsiàhadeva says: "Anyone who prays unto Me and takes shelter from Me becomes My ward, and I protect him always from all sorts of calamities."

Serving Trees such as the Tulasé

In the Skanda Puräëa there is a statement eulogizing the tulasé tree as follows: "Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the tulasé tree, which can immediately vanquish volumes of sinful activities. Simply by seeing or touching this tree one can become relieved from all distresses and diseases. Simply by offering obeisances to and pouring water on the tulasé tree, one can become freed from the fear of being sent to the court of Yamaräj [the King of death, who punishes the sinful]." If someone sows a tulasé tree somewhere, certainly he becomes devoted to Lord Kåñëa. And when the tulasé leaves are offered in devotion at the lotus feet of Kåñëa, there is the full development of love of Godhead.

In India every Hindu, even those not belonging to the Vaiñëava group, take special care of the tulasé tree. Even in great cities where it is very difficult to keep a tulasé tree, people are to be found very carefully keeping this plant. They water it and offer obeisances to it, because worship of the tulasé tree is very important in devotional service.

In the Skanda Puräëa there is another statement about tulasé, as follows: "Tulasé is auspicious in all respects. Simply by seeing, simply by touching, simply by remembering, simply by praying to, simply by bowing before, simply by hearing about or simply by sowing this tree, there is always auspiciousness. Anyone who comes in touch with the tulasé tree in the above-mentioned ways lives eternally in the Vaikuëöha world."

NoD 12-1970: Revealed Scriptures

Chapter Twelve

Revealed Scriptures

According to Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, any book which gives enlightenment in the matter of advancing devotional service is considered to be revealed scripture. Çréla Madhväcärya has also defined revealed scriptures as referring to books such as the Rämäyaëa, Mahäbhärata, Puräëas, Upaniñads, Vedänta—and any other literature which is written in pursuance of such revealed scriptures.

In the Skanda Puräëa there is the statement, "A person who is constantly engaged in reading literature enunciating the cultivation of Vaiñëava devotional service is always glorious in human society, and certainly Lord Kåñëa becomes pleased with him. A person who very carefully keeps such literature at home and offers respectful obeisances to it becomes freed from all sinful reactions and ultimately becomes worshipable by the demigods."

It is also said to Närada Muni: "My dear Närada, a person who writes Vaiñëava literature and keeps such literature at home has Lord Näräyaëa always residing in his house."

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Twelfth Canto, 12th Chapter, 12th verse, it is stated: "Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the essence of all Vedänta philosophy. Any person who has become attached in some way or other to the reading of Çrémad-Bhägavatam cannot have any taste for reading any other literature. In other words, a person who has relished the transcendental bliss of Çrémad-Bhägavatam cannot be satisfied with mundane writings."

In the Varäha Puräëa there is a statement praising the residential quarters of Mathurä. Lord Varäha tells the men of earth: "Any person who becomes attracted to places other than Mathurä will certainly be captivated by the illusory energy." In the Brahmäëòa Puräëa it is said that all the results of traveling on all the pilgrimages within the three worlds can be achieved simply by touching the holy land of Mathurä. In many çästras (scriptures) it is said that simply by hearing, remembering, glorifying, desiring, seeing, or touching the land of Mathurä, one can achieve all desires.

In the Padma Puräëa, there is a nice statement praising the service of the Vaiñëavas or devotees. In that scripture Lord Çiva tells Pärvaté, "My dear Pärvaté, there are different methods of worship, and out of all such methods the worship of the Supreme Person is considered to be the highest. But even higher than the worship of the Lord is the worship of the Lord's devotees."

A similar statement is in the Third Canto, 7th Chapter, 19th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam: "Let me become a sincere servant of the devotees because by serving them one can achieve unalloyed devotional service unto the lotus feet of the Lord. The service of devotees diminishes all miserable material conditions and develops within one a deep devotional love for the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

In the Skanda Puräëa there is a similar statement: "Persons whose bodies are marked with tilaka, symbolizing the conchshell, wheel, club and lotus—and who keep the leaves of tulasé on their heads, and whose bodies are always decorated with gopé-candana—even seen once, can help the seer be relieved from all sinful activities."

A similar statement is found in the First Canto, 19th Chapter, 30th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam: "There is no doubt about one's becoming freed from all reactions to sinful activities after visiting a devotee or touching his lotus feet or giving him a sitting place. Even by remembering the activities of such Vaiñëavas, one becomes purified, along with his whole family. And what, then, can be said of rendering direct service to him?"

In the Ädi Puräëa there is the following statement by Lord Kåñëa Himself, addressed to Arjuna: "My dear Pärtha, one who claims to be My devotee is not so. Only a person who claims to be the devotee of My devotee is actually My devotee." No one can approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead directly [Padyävalé 74]. One must approach Him through His pure devotees. Therefore, in the system of Vaiñëava activities, the first duty is to accept a devotee as spiritual master and then to render service unto him.

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé affirms that all the quotations given in the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu from different scriptures are accepted by the great äcäryas and devotees of the Lord.

In the Padma Puräëa there is a statement that one should perform the ceremonies for the Lord according to one's financial position. Everyone should observe the different ceremonies and celebrations of the Lord by all means. One of the most important of these ceremonial functions is called Ürja-vrata. Ürja-vrata is observed in the month of Kärttika (October-November); especially in Våndävana, there is a specific program for temple worship of the Lord in His Dämodara form. Dämodara refers to Kåñëa's being bound with rope by His mother, Yaçodä. It is said that just as Lord Dämodara is very dear to His devotees so the month known as Dämodara or Kärttika is also very dear to them.

The execution of devotional service during Ürja-vrata in the month of Kärttika is especially recommended to be performed at Mathurä. This system is still followed by many devotees. They go to Mathurä or Våndävana and stay there during the month of Kärttika specifically to perform devotional services during this period.

In the Padma Puräëa it is said: "The Lord may offer liberation or material happiness to a devotee, but after some devotional service has been executed, particularly in Mathurä during the month of Kärttika, the devotees want only to attain pure devotional service unto the Lord." The purport is that the Lord does not award devotional service to ordinary persons who are not serious about it. But even such unserious persons who execute devotional service according to the regulative principles during the month of Kärttika, and within the jurisdiction of Mathurä in India, are very easily awarded the Lord's personal service.

In the Bhaviñya Puräëa there is a statement about observing different ceremonies celebrating the Lord's appearance (birthday) and other transcendental activities. It is said, "My Lord Janärdana [Kåñëa], please let us know the date when Your mother Devaké devé gave birth to You. If You kindly inform us about this, then we shall observe a great celebration on this date. O killer of Keçé, we are souls one hundred percent surrendered unto Your lotus feet, and we wish only to please You with our ceremonies."

This statement of the Bhaviñya Puräëa gives evidence that by observing different functions in relationship with the Lord one is sure to become pleasing to the Lord. It is said in the Ädi Puräëa: "A person who is constantly engaged in chanting the holy name and who feels transcendental pleasure, being engaged in devotional service, is certainly awarded the facilities of devotional service, and is never given just mukti [liberation]."

Mukti means liberation from material contamination; when liberated, one does not have to take birth again in the material world. The impersonalists desire to merge into the spiritual existence, to end their individual existence, but according to Çrémad-Bhägavatam, mukti is only the beginning of one's becoming situated in his normal condition. The normal condition of every living entity is to be engaged in the devotional service of the Lord. From the statement of the Ädi Puräëa it appears that a devotee is satisfied simply with being engaged in devotional service. He does not aspire for any liberation from material conditional life. In other words, anyone who is engaged in devotional service is not in the material condition of life, although he may appear so.

Recitation of Çrémad-Bhägavatam

Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the desire-tree of Vedic wisdom. Veda itself means the aggregate of knowledge. And whatever knowledge is required for human society is perfectly presented in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. There are different branches of knowledge in the Vedic writings, including sociology, politics, medicine and military art. All these and other branches of knowledge are perfectly described in the Vedas. So, as far as spiritual knowledge is concerned, that is also perfectly described there, and Çrémad-Bhägavatam is considered to be the ripened fruit of this desire-fulfilling tree of the Vedas. A tree is honored by the production of its fruit. For example, a mango tree is considered very valuable because it produces the king of all fruits, the mango. When the mango fruit becomes ripened it is the greatest gift of that tree, and Çrémad-Bhägavatam is similarly held to be the ripened fruit of the Vedic tree. And, as ripened fruit becomes more relishable when first touched by the beak of a parrot, or çuka, so Çrémad-Bhägavatam has become more relishable by being delivered through the transcendental mouth of Çukadeva Gosvämé.

Çrémad-Bhägavatam should be received in disciplic succession without any breakage. When a ripened fruit comes from the upper part of the tree onto the ground by the process of being handed down from a higher branch to a lower branch by persons in the tree, the fruit does not break. Çrémad-Bhägavatam, when received in the paramparä system, or disciplic succession, will likewise remain unbroken. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that the disciplic succession, or paramparä, is the way of receiving transcendental knowledge. Such knowledge must come down through the disciplic succession, through authorized persons who know the real purpose of the çästra.

Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu recommended that one learn Çrémad-Bhägavatam from the mouth of the self realized person called bhägavatam. Bhägavata means "in relationship with the Personality of Godhead (Bhagavän)." So the devotee is sometimes called bhägavatam, and the book which is in relationship with devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead is also called Bhägavatam. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu recommended that in order to relish the real taste of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, one should take instruction from the person bhägavatam. Çrémad-Bhägavatam is relishable even by a liberated person. It was admitted by Çukadeva Gosvämé that although he was liberated from within the very womb of his mother, it was only after relishing Çrémad-Bhägavatam that he became a great devotee. Thus, one who is desirous of advancing in Kåñëa consciousness should relish the purport of Çrémad-Bhägavatam through the discussions of authorized devotees.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Second Canto, 1st Chapter, 9th verse, Çukadeva Gosvämé admits that although he was very much attracted by the impersonal Brahman, when he heard the transcendental pastimes of the Supreme Personality of Godhead from the mouth of his father, Vyäsadeva, he became more attracted to Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The idea is that Vyäsadeva was also a self realized soul, and his mature contribution of transcendental knowledge was delivered directly to Çukadeva Gosvämé in the manner indicated.

The importance of discussing Çrémad-Bhägavatam in the society of pure devotees is explained by Çaunaka Muni during the meeting at Naimiñäraëya, in the presence of Süta Gosvämé. Süta Gosvämé confirmed that if someone is fortunate enough to associate with a pure devotee of the Lord even for a moment, that particular moment is so valuable that even those pious activities which can promote one to the heavenly planets or give liberation from material miseries cannot compare with it. In other words, those who are attached to Çrémad-Bhägavatam do not care for any kind of benefit derived from elevation to the higher planetary kingdoms, or for the liberation which is conceived of by the impersonalists. As such, the association of pure devotees is so transcendentally valuable that no kind of material happiness can compare with it.

In the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya there is a conversation between Prahläda Mahäräj and his father, Hiraëyakaçipu, in which Hiraëyakaçipu addresses Prahläda in this way: "My dear son, association is very important. It acts just like a crystal-stone which will reflect anything which is put before it." Similarly, if we associate with the flowerlike devotees of the Lord, and if our hearts are crystal clear, then certainly the same action will be there. Another example given in this connection is that if a man is potent and if a woman is not diseased, then by their conjugation there will be conception. In the same way, if the recipient of spiritual knowledge and the deliverer of spiritual knowledge are sincere and bona fide, there will be good results.

NoD 13-1970: The Mahä-mantra

Chapter Thirteen

The Mahä-mantra

The importance of chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is very strongly stressed in the Second Canto, 1st Chapter, 11th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam in the following way: Çukadeva Gosvämé tells Mahäräj Parékñit: "My dear King, if one is spontaneously attached to the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, it is to be understood that he has attained the highest perfectional stage." It is specifically mentioned that the karmés who are aspiring after the fruitive results of their activities, the salvationists who are aspiring to become one with the Supreme Person, and the yogés who are aspiring after mystic perfections can achieve the results of all perfectional stages simply by chanting the mahä-mantra. Çukadeva uses the word nirëétam, which means "it is already decided." He was a liberated soul and therefore could not accept anything which was not conclusive. So Çukadeva Gosvämé especially stresses that it is already concluded that one who has come to the stage of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra with determination and steadiness must be considered as having already passed the trials of fruitive activities, mental speculation and mystic yoga.

The same thing is confirmed in the Ädi Puräëa by Kåñëa. While addressing Arjuna He says, "Anyone who is engaged in chanting My transcendental name must be considered to be always associating with Me. And I may tell you frankly that for such a devotee I become easily purchased."

In the Padma Puräëa also it is stated: "The chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra is present only on the lips of a person who has for many births worshiped Väsudeva." It is further said in the Padma Puräëa: "There is no difference between the holy name of the Lord and the Lord Himself. As such, the holy name is as perfect as the Lord Himself in fullness, purity and eternity. The holy name is no material sound vibration, nor has it any material contamination." The holy name cannot, therefore, be chanted offenselessly by one who has failed to purify his senses. In other words, materialistic senses cannot properly chant the holy names of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. But, by adopting this chanting process, one is given a chance to actually purify himself so that he may very soon chant offenselessly.

Caitanya Mahäprabhu has recommended that everyone chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra just to cleanse the dust from the heart. If the dust of the heart is cleansed away, then one can actually understand the importance of the holy name. For persons who are not inclined to clean the dust from their heart and want to keep things as they are, it is not possible to derive the transcendental result of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra. One should, therefore, be encouraged to develop his service attitude toward the Lord, because this will help him to chant without any offense. And so, under the guidance of a spiritual master, the disciple is trained simultaneously to render service and at the same time to chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra. As soon as one develops his spontaneous service attitude, he can immediately understand the transcendental nature of the holy names of the mahä-mantra.

In the Padma Puräëa there is a statement about the importance of living at holy places like Mathurä or Dvärakä. It is stated there: "To travel to different places of pilgrimage means to attain emancipation from material bondage. This emancipation, however, is not the highest perfectional stage. After attaining this liberated stage, one has to become engaged in devotional service to the Lord. After attainment of the brahma-bhüta [liberation] stage one can further advance to engagement in devotional service. So this attainment of transcendental loving devotional service to the Lord is the goal of life, and it can be achieved very easily for one who lives in Mathurä-maëòala even for a few seconds."

It is further said: "Who is that person who will not agree to worship the land of Mathurä? Mathurä can deliver all the desires and ambitions of the fruitive workers and of the salvationists, who desire to become one with the supreme Brahman. Certainly Mathurä will deliver the desires of the devotees, who simply aspire to be engaged in the devotional service of the Lord." In the Vedic literature it is also stated: "How wonderful it is that simply by residing in Mathurä even for one day, one can achieve a transcendental loving attitude toward the Supreme Personality of Godhead! This land of Mathurä must be more glorious than Vaikuëöha-dhäma, the kingdom of God!"

Rüpa Gosvämé has stated that the five kinds of devotional activities—namely, residing in Mathurä, worshiping the Deity of the Lord, reciting Çrémad-Bhägavatam, serving a devotee, and chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra—are so potent that a small attachment for any one of these five items can arouse devotional ecstasy even in a neophyte.

Regarding worship of the form of the Lord, or Deity, Rüpa Gosvämé has written the following verse: "My dear friends, if you still have any desire to enjoy the company of your friends within this material world, then don't look upon the form of Kåñëa, who is standing on the bank of Keçé-ghäö [a bathing place in Våndävana]. He is known as Govinda, and His eyes are very enchanting. He is playing upon His flute, and on His head there is a peacock feather. And His whole body is illuminated by the moonlight in the sky."

The purport of this verse is that if someone becomes attached to the Çré Mürti, or Deity of Kåñëa, by worshiping at home, then he will forget his relationship of so-called friendship, love and society. Thus it is the duty of every householder to install Deities of the Lord at home and to begin the process of worshiping along with all of his family members. This will save everyone from such unwanted activities as going to clubs, cinemas, dancing parties, smoking, drinking, etc. All such nonsense will be forgotten if one stresses the worship of the Deities at home.

Rüpa Gosvämé further writes, "My dear foolish friend, I think that you have already heard some of the auspicious Çrémad-Bhägavatam, which decries seeking the results of fruitive activities, economic development and liberation. I think now it is certain that gradually the verses of the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, describing the pastimes of the Lord, will enter your ears and go into your heart."

In the beginning of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is said that unless one has the capacity to throw out, just like garbage, the fruitive results of ritualistic ceremonies, economic development and becoming one with the supreme (or salvation), one cannot understand Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The Bhägavatam deals exclusively with devotional service. Only one who studies Çrémad-Bhägavatam in the spirit of renunciation can understand the pastimes of the Lord which are described in the Tenth Canto. In other words, one should not try to understand the topics of the Tenth Canto, such as the räsa-lélä (love dance), unless he has spontaneous attraction for Çrémad-Bhägavatam. One must be situated in pure devotional service before he can relish Çrémad-Bhägavatam as it is.

In the above two verses of Rüpa Gosvämé there are some metaphorical analogies, which indirectly condemn the association of materialistic society, friendship and love. People are generally attracted to society, friendship and love, and make elaborate arrangements and strong endeavors to develop these material contaminations; but to see the Çré Mürtis of Rädhä and Kåñëa is to forget such endeavors for material association. Rüpa Gosvämé composed his verse in such a way that he was seemingly praising the material association of friendship, love, etc., and was condemning the audience of Çré Mürti or Govinda. This metaphorical analogy is constructed in such a way that things which seem to be eulogized are condemned, and things which are to be condemned are eulogized. The actual import of the verse is that one must see the form of Govinda if one at all wants to forget the nonsense of material friendship, love and society.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has similarly described the transcendental nature of relishing topics which concern Kåñëa. A devotee once said, "It is very astonishing that since I have seen this Personality of Godhead who is washed by the tears of my eyes, there is shivering of my body, and He has made me a failure in executing my material duties. Since seeing Him I cannot remain silently at home. I wish to go out to Him always." The purport of this statement is that as soon as one is fortunate enough to contact a pure devotee, he must be anxious immediately to hear about Kåñëa, to learn about Kåñëa, or, in other words, to become fully Kåñëa conscious.

Similarly, there is a statement about hearing and chanting the mahä-mantra: "It is said that saints have been able to hear the vibrating strings of the véëä in the hands of Närada, who is always singing the glories of Lord Kåñëa. Now this same sound vibration has entered my ears, and I am always feeling the presence of the Supreme Personality. Gradually I am becoming bereft of all attachment for material enjoyment."

Again, he has described Mathurä-maëòala: "I remember the Lord standing by the banks of the Yamunä River, so beautiful amidst the kadamba trees, where many birds are chirping in the gardens. And these impressions are always giving me transcendental realization of beauty and bliss." This feeling about Mathurä-maëòala and Våndävana by Rüpa Gosvämé can actually be felt even by nondevotees. The places in the eighty-four-square-mile district of Mathurä are so beautifully situated on the banks of the River Yamunä that anyone who goes there will never want to return to this material world. These statements by Rüpa Gosvämé are factually realized descriptions of Mathurä and Våndävana. All these qualities prove that Mathurä and Våndävana are situated transcendentally. Otherwise, there is no possibility of invoking our transcendental sentiments in these places. Such transcendental feelings are aroused immediately and without fail after one arrives in Mathurä or Våndävana.

In these statements about devotional service, sometimes it may appear that the results have been overestimated; but actually there is no overestimation. Some devotees, as is evidenced from revealed scriptures, have had immediate results by such association, although this is not possible for all. For example, the Kumäras immediately became devotees simply by smelling the incense in the temple. Bilvamaìgala Thäkur simply heard about Kåñëa and then immediately gave up his beautiful girl friend and started out for Mathurä and Våndävana, where he became a perfect Vaiñëava. So these statements are not overestimations, nor are they stories. They are actual facts, but are true for certain devotees and do not necessarily apply to all. These descriptions, even if considered overestimations, must be taken as they are in order to divert our attention from the fleeting material beauty to the eternal beauty of Kåñëa consciousness. And for a person who is already in contact with Kåñëa consciousness, the described results are not unusual.

Some scholars argue that simply by following the principles of varëa and äçrama one can gradually rise up to the perfections reached by practicing devotional service, but this argument is not accepted by the great authorities. Lord Caitanya also condemned this idea while He was talking with Rämänanda Rai about the gradual development of devotional service. He rejected the idea of the importance of varëäçrama-dharma when it was put forward by Rämänanda Rai. He said that this advancement of varëa and äçrama is merely external. There is a higher principle. In the Bhagavad-gétä also the Lord says that one has to give up all other principles of elevation and take simply to the method of Kåñëa consciousness. That will help him in achieving the highest perfection of life.

In the Eleventh Canto, 20th Chapter, 8th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam the Lord Himself says: "One should execute the prescribed duties of varëa and äçrama as long as he has not developed spontaneous attachment for hearing about My pastimes and activities." In other words, the prescribed forms of varëa and äçrama are ritualistic ceremonies of religion intended for economic development, sense gratification or for salvation. All of these things are recommended for persons who have not developed Kåñëa consciousness; in fact, all such activities are recommended in the revealed scriptures only to bring one to the point of Kåñëa consciousness. But one who has already developed spontaneous attachment for Kåñëa does not require to execute the duties prescribed in the scriptures.

NoD 14-1970: Devotional Qualifications

Chapter Fourteen

Devotional Qualifications

Some scholars recommend that knowledge and renunciation are important factors for elevating oneself to devotional service. But actually that is not a fact. Actually, the cultivation of knowledge or renunciation, which are favorable for achieving a footing in Kåñëa consciousness, may be accepted in the beginning, but ultimately they may also come to be rejected, for devotional service is dependent on nothing other than the sentiment or desire for such service. It requires nothing more than sincerity.

It is the opinion of expert devotees that mental speculation and the artificial austerities of yoga practice may be favorable for becoming liberated from material contamination, but they will also make one's heart harder and harder. They will not help at all in the progress of devotional service. These processes are, therefore, not favorable for entering into the transcendental loving service of the Lord. Actually Kåñëa consciousness—devotional service itself—is the only way of advancing in devotional life. Devotional service is absolute; it is both the cause and the effect. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is the cause and effect of all that be, and to approach Him, the absolute, the process of devotional service—which is also absolute—has to be adopted.

This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä by the Lord Himself: "One can understand Me only through devotional service." In beginning His teaching of the Gétä, the Lord said to Arjuna, "Because you are My devotee I shall teach these secrets to you." Vedic knowledge means ultimately to understand the Supreme Lord, and the process of entering into His kingdom is devotional service. That is accepted by all authentic scriptures. Mental speculators neglect the process of devotional service, and by simply trying to defeat others in philosophical research they fail to develop the ecstasy of devotion.

In the Eleventh Canto, 20th Chapter, 31st verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Kåñëa says, "My dear Uddhava, for persons who are seriously engaged in My service, the cultivation of philosophical speculation and artificial renunciation are not very favorable. When a person becomes My devotee he automatically attains the fruits of the renunciation of material enjoyment, and he gets sufficient knowledge to understand the absolute truth." That is the test of advancement in devotional service. A devotee cannot be in darkness because the Lord shows him special favor and enlightens him from within.

In the Eleventh Canto, 20th Chapter, 32nd and 33rd verses, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam the Lord further instructs Uddhava: "My dear friend, the profits derived from fruitive activities, austerities, the culture of philosophical knowledge, renouncement, the practice of mystic yoga, charity and all similar auspicious activities are automatically achieved by My devotees—those who are simply attached to Me by loving service. These devotees have everything at their disposal, but they desire nothing outside of My devotional service. If ever a devotee should desire some material profit—to be promoted to the heavenly planets—or some spiritual profit—to go to the Vaikuëöhas—by My causeless mercy their desires are very easily fulfilled."

Actually a person who is developing Kåñëa consciousness and still has some attachment to material enjoyment will soon be freed from such a tendency by regularly discharging devotional service under the instruction of a bona fide spiritual master.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, then, recommends that one should not be attached to material sense enjoyment, but accept everything enjoyable which is in relationship to Kåñëa. For example, eating is necessary, and one wants some palatable dishes to satisfy his sense of taste. So in that case, for the satisfaction of Kåñëa rather than for the satisfaction of the tongue, some palatable dishes may be prepared and offered to Kåñëa. Then it is renunciation. Let the palatable dishes be prepared, but unless they are offered to Kåñëa one should not accept them for eating. This vow of rejecting anything which is not offered to Kåñëa is actually renunciation. And by such renunciation one is able to satisfy the demands of the senses.

The impersonalists who try to avoid everything material may undergo severe austerities, but they miss the opportunity of being engaged in the service of the Lord. Thus their renunciation is not sufficient for perfection. There are many instances where, following such artificial renunciation without any contact with devotional service, the impersonalist again fell down and became attracted to the material contamination. There are many supposed renouncers even at the present moment who officially become sannyäsés or renouncers and outwardly claim that spiritual existence is truth and material existence untruth. In this way, artificially they make a show of renunciation of the material world. However, because they cannot reach the point of devotional service, they fail to achieve the goal and again come back to material activities, such as philanthropic work, political agitation, etc. There are many instances of so-called sannyäsés who gave up the world as untruth, but again came to the material world because they were not seeking their real repose at the lotus feet of the Lord.

One should not give up anything which can be utilized in the service of the Lord. That is a secret of devotional service. Anything that can be utilized in advancing Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service should be accepted. For instance, we are using many machines for the advancement of our present Kåñëa consciousness movement, machines like typewriters, dictaphones, tape recorders, microphones and airplanes. Sometimes people ask us, "Why are you utilizing material products if you condemn the advancement of material civilization?" But actually we do not condemn. We simply ask people to do whatever they are doing in Kåñëa consciousness. This is the same principle on which, in the Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa advised Arjuna to utilize his fighting abilities in devotional service. Similarly, we are utilizing these machines for Kåñëa's service. With such sentiment for Kåñëa, or Kåñëa consciousness, we can accept everything. If the typewriter can be utilized for advancing our Kåñëa consciousness movement, we must accept it. Similarly, the dictaphone or any other machine must be used. Our vision is that Kåñëa is everything. Kåñëa is the cause and effect, and nothing belongs to us. Kåñëa's things must be used in the service of Kåñëa. That is our vision.

This does not mean, however, that we should give up the principles of discharging devotional service or neglect abiding by the rules and regulations prescribed therein. In the neophyte stage of devotion one must follow all the principles, regulated by the authority of the spiritual master. The acceptance and rejection of things should always be in pursuance of the devotional principles; not that one can independently manufacture some idea of what should be accepted or rejected. The spiritual master as the visible manifestation of Kåñëa is necessary, therefore, to direct the devotee on behalf of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The spiritual master must never be carried away by an accumulation of wealth or a large number of followers. A bona fide spiritual master will never become like that. But sometimes, if a spiritual master is not properly authorized, and only on his own initiative becomes a spiritual master, he may be carried away by an accumulation of wealth and large numbers of disciples. His is not a very high grade of devotional service. If a person is carried away by such achievements, then his devotional service becomes slackened. One should, therefore, strictly adhere to the principles of disciplic succession.

A Kåñëa conscious person, being naturally purified, has no need of developing any other purificatory process of thought or action. On account of his being highly elevated in Kåñëa consciousness, he has already acquired all the good qualities and is following the rules and regulations prescribed for the mystic yogic process. Such rules are automatically practiced by the devotees. A concrete example is the quality of nonviolence, which is considered a good qualification. A devotee is naturally nonviolent and therefore doesn't have to practice nonviolence separately. Some people seek purification by joining a vegetarian movement, but a devotee is automatically a vegetarian. He doesn't need to practice separately in this matter or to join any society for vegetarians. He is automatically a vegetarian.

There are many other instances showing that a devotee needn't practice anything but Kåñëa consciousness; all the good qualities of the demigods automatically develop within him. Those who are intentionally practicing to be vegetarians or to become nonviolent may have good qualifications by a material estimation, but these qualifications are not sufficient to make them devotees. A vegetarian is not necessarily a devotee, nor is a nonviolent person. But a devotee is automatically both vegetarian and nonviolent. We must conclude, therefore, that vegetarianism or nonviolence is not the cause of devotion.

In this connection, there is a story in the Skanda Puräëa about a hunter who was converted into a great devotee under the instruction of Närada Muni. When the hunter became a perfect devotee, he was not prepared even to kill an ant. Parvata Muni, a friend of Närada's, saw the wonderful transformation of the hunter by devotional service, and remarked: "My dear hunter, your unwillingness to kill even an ant is not very astonishing. Any person who develops the devotional attitude has all the good qualities automatically manifested in his person. A devotee is never a cause of distress to anyone."

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé affirms herein that purification of consciousness, purification of bodily activities, austerities, peace of mind, etc., all become automatically manifest in the person who is engaged in devotional service.

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé affirms herein that there are nine different kinds of devotional service, which are listed as hearing, chanting, remembering, serving, worshiping the Deity in the temple, praying, carrying out orders, serving Him as a friend and sacrificing everything for Him. Each and every one of these processes is so powerful that if anyone follows even one single one of them, he can achieve the desired perfection without fail. For example, if one is attached simply to hearing about the Lord, and another is attached to chanting the glories of the name, both will achieve their desired goal in devotional service. In the Caitanya-caritämåta this has been explained. One may execute one, two, three or all the different processes of devotional service, and at the ultimate end he will achieve the desired goal of being established in devotional service.

There are concrete examples of how a devotee discharged one of these services and achieved perfection. King Parékñit achieved the desired goal of life simply by hearing Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Çukadeva Gosvämé achieved the desired goal of life simply by reciting Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Prahläda Mahäräj became successful in his devotional service by always remembering the Lord. Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune, was successful by engaging herself in massaging the lotus feet of the Lord. King Påthu became successful by worshiping in the temple. Akrüra became successful by offering prayers. Hanumän became successful by rendering personal service to Lord Rämacandra. Arjuna became successful by being a friend of Kåñëa. And Bali Mahäräj became successful simply by offering all of his possessions to Kåñëa.

There are also examples of devotees who discharged all the different items together. In the Ninth Canto, 4th Chapter, 15th, 16th and 17th verses, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, there is a statement about Mahäräj Ambaréña, who followed every one of the devotional processes. In these verses, Çukadeva Gosvämé says, "King Ambaréña first of all concentrated his mind on the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa and then engaged his speech in describing the pastimes and activities of the Lord. He engaged his hands in washing the temple of the Lord. He engaged his ears in hearing of the transcendental glories of the Lord. He engaged his eyes in seeing the beautiful Deity in the temple. He engaged his body in associating with the pure devotees of the Lord. [When you associate with someone you have to sit down together, eat together, etc.—and in this way the touch of your body with their body is inevitable. Ambaréña Mahäräj made his association only with pure devotees and did not allow his body to be touched by anyone else.] He engaged his nostrils in smelling the flowers and tulasé which were offered to Kåñëa, and he engaged his tongue in tasting Kåñëa-prasädam [food prepared specifically for offering to the Lord, the remnants of which are taken by the devotees]. Mahäräj Ambaréña was able to offer very nice prasädam to Kåñëa because he was a king and had no scarcity of finance. He used to offer Kåñëa the most royal dishes and would then taste the remnants as Kåñëa-prasädam. There was no scarcity in his royal style because he had a very beautiful temple wherein the Deity of the Lord was decorated with costly paraphernalia and offered high grade food. So everything was available, and his engagement was always completely in Kåñëa consciousness."

The idea is that we should follow in the footsteps of great devotees. If we are unable to execute all the different items of devotional service, we must try to execute at least one of them, as exemplified by previous äcäryas. If we are engaged in the execution of all the items of devotional service, as was Mahäräj Ambaréña, then the perfection of devotional service is guaranteed from each one of these items. With the first complete engagement, one becomes automatically detached from material contamination, and liberation becomes the maidservant of the devotee. This idea is confirmed by Bilvamaìgala Thäkur: If one develops unalloyed devotion to the Lord, liberation will follow the devotee as his maidservant.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that the regulative principles of devotional service are sometimes described by authorities as the path of serving the Lord in opulence.

NoD 15-1970: Spontaneous Devotional Service

Chapter Fifteen

Spontaneous Devotional Service

The examples of spontaneous devotional service can be easily seen in Kåñëa's direct associates in Våndävana. The spontaneous dealings of the residents of Våndävana in relationship with Kåñëa are called rägänugä. These beings don't have to learn anything about devotional service; they are already perfect in all regulative principles and have achieved the spontaneous loving service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. For example, the cowherd boys who are playing with Kåñëa do not have to learn by austerities or penances or yogic practice how to play with Him. They have passed all tests of regulative principles in their previous lives, and as a result they are now elevated to the position of direct association with Kåñëa as His dear friends. Their spontaneous attitude is called rägänugä-bhakti.

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé has defined rägänugä-bhakti as spontaneous attraction for something while completely absorbed in thoughts of it, with an intense desire of love. Devotional service executed with such feelings of spontaneous love is called rägänugä-bhakti. Devotional service under the heading of rägänugä can be further divided into two categories: one category is called sensuous attraction, and the other is called relationship.

In this connection, there is a statement by Närada Muni to Yudhiñöhira in the Seventh Canto, 1st Chapter, 29th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. There Närada says, "My dear King, there are many devotees who first become attracted to the Personality of Godhead for purposes of sense gratification, from being envious of Him, out of fear of Him, or from desiring to associate affectionately with Him. Ultimately these attractions become freed from all material contamination, and gradually the worshiper develops spiritual love and achieves that ultimate goal of life which is desired by the pure devotee."

The gopés may be considered to be examples of spontaneous love in sensual attraction. The gopés are young girls, and Kåñëa is a young boy. Superficially it seems that the gopés are attracted to Kåñëa on grounds of sex. Similarly, King Kaàsa was attracted to Kåñëa because of fearfulness. Kaàsa was always fearful of Kåñëa because it had been foretold that his sister's son, Kåñëa, would kill him. Çiçupäla was also always envious of Kåñëa. And the descendants of King Yadu, due to their family relationship with Kåñëa, are always thinking of Him as one of their members. All of these different kinds of devotees have a spontaneous attraction for Kåñëa, in different categories, and they achieve the same desired goal of life.

The attraction of the gopés for Kåñëa and the affection of the members of the Yadu dynasty are both accepted as spontaneous, or rägänugä. The attraction of Kaàsa to Kåñëa in fearfulness and the attraction of Çiçupäla in enviousness are not accepted as devotional service, however, because their attitudes are not favorable. Devotional service should be executed only in a favorable frame of mind. Therefore, according to Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, such attractions are not considered to be in devotional service. Again, he analyzes the affection of the Yadus: If it is on the platform of friendship, then it is spontaneous love, but if it is on the platform of regulative principles, then it is not. And only when affection comes to the platform of spontaneous love is it counted in the category of pure devotional service.

There may be some difficulty in understanding that both the gopés and Kaàsa achieved the same goal, so this point should be clearly understood, because the attitudes of Kaàsa and Çiçupäla were different from that of the gopés. Although in all these cases the focus is on the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and all of the devotees are elevated to the spiritual world, there is still a distinction between these two classes of souls. In the First Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is said that the absolute truth is one, and He is manifested as impersonal Brahman, Paramätmä (supersoul), and Bhagavän (the Supreme Personality of Godhead). Here is a spiritual distinction. Although Brahman, Paramätmä and Bhagavän are the same and one absolute truth, still devotees like Kaàsa or Çiçupäla could attain only to the Brahman effulgence. They could not have realization of Paramätmä or Bhagavän. That is the distinction.

An analogy can be given with the sun globe and the sunshine: to remain in the sunshine does not mean one has gone to the sun globe. The temperature of the sun globe is different from the temperature of the sunshine. One who has gone through the sunshine in jet planes or in space ships has not necessarily gone to the sun globe. Although the sunshine and the sun globe are actually one and the same, still there is a distinction, for one is the energy and one is the energetic source. The absolute truth and His bodily effulgence are in the same way simultaneously one and different. Kaàsa and Çiçupäla attained to the absolute truth, but they were not allowed to enter into the Goloka Våndävana abode. Impersonalists and the enemies of the Lord are, because of attraction to God, allowed to enter into His kingdom, but they are not allowed to enter into the Vaikuëöha planets or the Goloka Våndävana planet of the Supreme Lord. To enter the kingdom and to enter the king's palace are not the same thing.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé is trying here to describe the different achievements of the impersonalists and the personalists. Generally, those who are impersonalists and inimical to the Supreme Personality of Godhead get entrance only into the impersonal Brahman, when and if they reach spiritual perfection. The impersonalist philosophers are in one sense like the enemies of the Lord because the out-and-out enemies of the Lord and the impersonalists are both allowed to enter only into the impersonal effulgence of the brahma-jyoti. So it is to be understood that they are of similar classification. And actually the impersonalists are enemies of God because they cannot tolerate the unparallelled opulence of the Lord. They try always to place themselves on the same level with the Lord. That is due to their envious attitude. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has proclaimed the impersonalists to be offenders of the Lord. The Lord is so kind, however, that even though they are His enemies, they are still allowed to enter into the spiritual kingdom and remain in the impersonal brahma-jyoti, the undifferentiated light of the absolute.

Sometimes an impersonalist may gradually elevate himself to the personal conception of the Lord. The Bhagavad-gétä confirms this: "After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me." By such surrender, an impersonalist can be elevated to the Vaikuëöha-loka (spiritual planet) where, as a surrendered soul, he attains bodily features like the Lord.

In the Brahmäëòa Puräëa it is stated: "Those who have achieved liberation from material contamination, and those who are demons and are killed by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, become absorbed in the Brahman concept of life and reside in the spiritual sky of the brahma-jyoti." That spiritual sky is far beyond the material sky, and it is confirmed also in the Bhagavad-gétä that beyond this material sky there is another, eternal sky. The enemies and the impersonalists may be allowed to enter into this Brahman effulgence, but the devotees of Kåñëa are promoted all the way to the spiritual planets. Because the pure devotees have developed their spontaneous love for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, they are allowed to enter into the spiritual planets to enjoy spiritual bliss in association with the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

In the Tenth Canto, 87th Chapter, 19th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the Vedas personified address the Lord in this way: "My dear Lord, yogés meditate upon Your localized features, and thus they achieve the spiritual perfection of being merged in the impersonal brahma-jyoti. Persons who treat You as an enemy achieve the same perfection without meditating. The gopés, who are embraced by Your serpentine hands and who have such lusty attitudes, also achieve the same perfection. And, as far as we are concerned, being different demigods in charge of the different parts of Vedic knowledge, we are always following in the footsteps of the gopés. Thus we hope to attain the same perfection." By "the same perfection" we must always remember the example of the sun and the sunshine. Those who are impersonalists can merge into the sunshinelike brahma-jyoti, whereas those who are in love with the Supreme Person enter into the supreme abode of the Lord, Goloka Våndävana.

The "lusty attitude" of the gopés does not refer to any sort of sex indulgence. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé explains that this "lusty desire" refers to the devotee's particular attitude of association with Kåñëa. Every devotee in his perfectional stage has a spontaneous attraction to the Lord. This attraction is sometimes called the "lusty desire" of the devotee. The lust is the devotee's excessive desire to serve the Lord in a particular capacity. Such desire may seem to be a desire for enjoying the Lord, but actually the endeavor is to serve the Lord in that capacity. For example, a devotee may be desiring to associate with the Personality of Godhead as His cowherd friend. He will want to serve the Lord by assisting Him in controlling the cows in the pasturing ground. This may appear to be a desire to enjoy the company of the Lord, but actually it is spontaneous love, serving Him by assisting in managing the transcendental cows.

This extreme desire to serve the Lord is manifest in the transcendental land of Braja. And it is specifically manifested amongst the gopés. The gopés' love for Kåñëa is so elevated that for our understanding it is sometimes explained as being "lusty desire."

The author of Çré Caitanya-caritämåta, Kaviräja Kåñëadäs, has explained the distinction between lusty desire and the service attitude in this statement: "Lusty desire refers to the desire to gratify one's personal senses, and transcendental desire refers to the desire for serving the senses of the Lord." In the material world there is no such thing as a lover wanting to please the senses of his beloved. Actually, in the material world, everyone wants mainly to gratify his own personal senses. The gopés, however, wanted nothing at all but to gratify the senses of the Lord, and there is no instance of this in the material world. Therefore the gopés' ecstatic love for Kåñëa is sometimes described by scholars as being like the "lusty desire" of the material world, but actually this should not be taken as a literal fact. It is simply a way of trying to understand the transcendental situation.

Great devotees up to the standard of Uddhava are very dear friends of the Lord, and they desire to follow in the footsteps of the gopés. So the gopés' love for Kåñëa is certainly not material lusty desire. Otherwise, how could Uddhava aspire to follow in their footsteps? Another instance is Lord Caitanya Himself. After accepting the sannyäsa order of life, He was very, very strict about avoiding association with women, but still He taught that there is no better method of worshiping Kåñëa than that conceived by the gopés. Thus the gopés' method of worshiping the Lord, as if impelled by lusty desire, was praised very highly even by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. This very fact means that although the attraction of the gopés for Kåñëa appears to be lusty, it is not in the least bit material. Unless one is fully situated in the transcendental position, it is very difficult to understand the relationship of the gopés with Kåñëa. But because it appears to be just like ordinary dealings of young boys and girls, it is sometimes misinterpreted to be like the ordinary sex of this material world. Unfortunately, persons who cannot understand the transcendental nature of the love affairs of the gopés and Kåñëa take it for granted that Kåñëa's love affairs with the gopés are mundane transactions, and therefore they sometimes indulge in painting licentious pictures in some modernistic style.

On the other hand, the lusty desire of Kubjä is described by learned scholars as being "almost lusty desire." Kubjä was a hunchback woman who also wanted Kåñëa with a great ecstatic love. But her desire for Kåñëa was almost mundane, and so her love cannot be compared with the love of the gopés. Her loving affection for Kåñëa is called käma-präyä, or almost like the gopés' love for Kåñëa.

NoD 16-1970: Varieties of Love for Kåñëa

Chapter Sixteen

Varieties of Love for Kåñëa

Parental Relationship

In the attitude of the denizens of Våndävana, such as Nanda Mahäräj and Mother Yaçodä, is to be found the ideal transcendental concept of becoming the father and mother of Kåñëa, the original Personality of Godhead. Factually, no one can become the father or mother of Kåñëa; but a devotee's possession of such transcendental feelings is called love of Kåñëa in parental relationship. The Våñëis (Kåñëa's relatives at Dvärakä) also felt like that. So spontaneous love of Kåñëa in the parental relationship is found both amongst those denizens of Dvärakä who belonged to the dynasty of Våñëi, as well as amongst the inhabitants of Våndävana.

Spontaneous love of Kåñëa as exhibited by the Våñëis and the denizens of Våndävana is eternally existing in them. In the stage of devotional service where regulative principles are followed, there is no necessity of discussing this love, for it must develop of itself at a more advanced stage.

Persons desiring to follow in the footsteps of such eternal devotees of the Lord as the Våñëis and Våndävana denizens are called rägänugä devotees, which means that they are trying to attain to the perfection of those devotees. These rägänugä devotees do not follow the regulative principles of devotional service very strictly, but by spontaneous nature they become attracted to some of the eternal devotees such as Nanda or Yaçodä, and they try to follow in their footsteps spontaneously. There is a gradual development of the ambition to become like a particular devotee, and this activity is called rägänugä.

We must always remember, however, that such eagerness to follow in the footsteps of the denizens of Braja (Våndävana) is not possible unless one is freed from material contamination. In following the regulative principles of devotional service, there is a stage which is called anartha-nivåtti, which means the disappearance of all material contamination. Sometimes it is found that someone is imitating such devotional love, but factually he is not freed from anarthas, or unwanted habits. It has been seen that a so-called devotee proclaims himself a follower of Nanda, Yaçodä or the gopés, while at the same time his abominable attraction for mundane sex life is visible. Such a manifestation of divine love is mere imitation and has no value. When one is actually spontaneously attracted to the loving principles of the gopés, there will be found no trace of any mundane contamination in his character.

Therefore, in the beginning, everyone should strictly follow the regulative principles of devotional service, according to the injunctions of the scriptures and the spiritual master. Only after the stage of liberation from material contamination can one actually aspire to follow in the footsteps of the devotees in Våndävana.

It is said by Çré Rüpa Gosvämé: "When one is actually liberated from material contamination, he can always remember an eternal devotee in Våndävana in order to love Kåñëa in the same capacity. And developing such an aptitude, one will always live in Våndävana, even within his mind." The purport is that, if it is possible, one should go and physically be present at Brajabhümi, Våndävana, and be engaged always in the service of the Lord, following the devotees in Brajadhäma, the spiritual realm of Braja. If it is not possible, however, to be physically present at Våndävana, one can meditate anywhere upon living in that situation. Wherever he may be, one must always think about life in Brajadhäma and about following in the footsteps of a particular devotee in the service of the Lord.

A devotee who is actually advanced in Kåñëa consciousness, who is constantly engaged in devotional service, should not manifest himself even though he has attained perfection. The idea is that he should always continue to act as a neophyte devotee as long as his material body is there. Activities in devotional service under regulative principles must be followed even by the pure devotee. But when he realizes his actual position in relationship with the Lord, he can, along with the discharging of regulative service, think within himself of the Lord, under the guidance of a particular associate of the Lord, and develop his transcendental sentiments in following that associate.

In this connection, we should be careful about the so-called siddha-praëai. The siddha-praëai process is followed by a class of men who are not very authorized and who have manufactured their own way of devotional service. They imagine that they have become associates of the Lord simply by thinking of themselves like that. This external behavior is not at all according to the regulative principles. The so-called siddha-praëai process is followed by the prakåta sahajiyä, a pseudo-sect of so-called Vaiñëavas. In the opinion of Rüpa Gosvämé, such activities are simply disturbances to the standard way of devotional service.

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé says that learned äcäryas recommended that we follow the regulative principles even after the development of spontaneous love for Kåñëa. According to the regulative principles, there are nine departmental activities, as described above, and one should specifically engage himself in the type of devotional service for which he has a natural aptitude. For example, one person may have a particular interest in hearing, another may have a particular interest in chanting, and another may have a particular interest in serving in the temple. So these, or any of the other six different types of devotional service (remembering, serving, praying, engaging in some particular service, being in a friendly relationship or offering everything in one's possession) should be executed in full earnestness. In this way everyone should act according to his particular taste.

Conjugal Love

Devotional service following in the footsteps of the gopés of Våndävana or the queens at Dvärakä is called devotional service in conjugal love. This devotional service in conjugal love can be divided into two categories. One is indirect conjugal love, the other direct. In both of these categories one has to follow the particular gopé who is engaged in such service in Goloka Våndävana. To be directly attached to the Supreme Personality of Godhead in conjugal love is technically called keli. This keli performance means to directly join with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. There are other devotees who do not wish direct contact with the Supreme Person, but who relish the conjugal love affairs of the Lord with the gopés. Such devotees enjoy simply by hearing of the activities of the Lord with the gopés.

This development of conjugal love can only be possible only with those who are already engaged in following the regulative principles of devotional service, specifically in the worship of Rädhä and Kåñëa in the temple. Such devotees gradually develop a spontaneous love for the Deity, and by hearing of the Lord's exchange of loving affairs with the gopés, they gradually become attracted to these pastimes. After this spontaneous attraction becomes highly developed, the devotee is placed in either of the above-mentioned categories.

This development of conjugal love for Kåñëa is not manifested in women only. The material body has nothing to do with spiritual loving affairs. A woman may develop an attitude for becoming a friend of Kåñëa, and, similarly, a man may develop the feature of becoming a gopé in Våndävana. How a devotee in the form of a man can desire to become a gopé is stated in the Padma Puräëa as follows: "In days gone by there were many sages in Daëòakäraëya. Daëòakäraëya is the name of the forest where Lord Rämacandra lived after being banished by his father for fourteen years. At that time there were many advanced sages who were captivated by the beauty of Lord Rämacandra and who desired to become women in order to embrace the Lord. Later on these sages appeared in Goloka Våndävana when Kåñëa advented Himself there, and they were born as gopés or girl friends of Kåñëa. In this way they attained the perfection of spiritual life."

The story of the sages of Daëòakäraëya can be explained as follows: When Lord Rämacandra was residing in Daëòakäraëya, the sages who were engaged in devotional service there became attracted by His beauty and immediately thought of the gopés at Våndävana who enjoyed conjugal loving affection with Kåñëa. In this instance it is clear that the sages of Daëòakäraëya desired conjugal love in the manner of the gopés, although they were well aware of the Supreme Lord as both Kåñëa and Lord Rämacandra. They knew that Rämacandra was an ideal king and could not accept more than one wife; but Lord Kåñëa, being the full-fledged Personality of Godhead, could fulfill the desires of all of them in Våndävana. These sages also concluded that the form of Lord Kåñëa is more attractive than that of Lord Rämacandra, and so they prayed to become gopés in their future lives to be associated with Kåñëa. Lord Rämacandra remained silent, and His silence shows that He accepted the prayers of the sages. Thus they were blest by Lord Rämacandra to have association with Lord Kåñëa in their future lives. As a result of this benediction, they all took birth as women in the wombs of gopés at Gokula, and, as they had desired in their previous lives, they enjoyed the company of Lord Kåñëa, who was present at that time in Gokula Våndävana. The perfection of their human form of life was thus achieved by their generating a transcendental sentiment to share conjugal love with Lord Kåñëa.

Conjugal love is divided into two classifications—namely, conjugal love as husband and wife and conjugal love as lover and beloved. One who develops conjugal love for Kåñëa as a wife is promoted to Dvärakä, where the devotee becomes the queen of the Lord. Those who develop conjugal love for Kåñëa as a lover are promoted to Goloka Våndävana, to associate with the gopés and enjoy loving affairs with Kåñëa there. We should note carefully, however, that this conjugal love for Kåñëa, either as gopé or queen, is not limited only to women. Even men can develop such sentiments, as was evidenced by the sages of Daëòakäraëya. If someone simply desires conjugal love but does not follow in the footsteps of the gopés, he is promoted to association with the Lord at Dvärakä.

In the Mahä-kürma Puräëa it is stated: "Great sages who were the sons of fire gods rigidly followed the regulative principles in their desire to have conjugal love for Kåñëa. As such, in their next lives they were able to associate with the Lord, the origin of all creation, who is known as Väsudeva, or Kåñëa. Every one of them got Him as their husband."

Parenthood or Friendship

Devotees who are attracted to Kåñëa as parents or as friends should follow in the footsteps of Nanda Mahäräj or Subala, respectively. Nanda Mahäräj is the foster father of Kåñëa, and out of all of the friends of Kåñëa, Subala is the most intimate in Brajabhümi.

In the development of becoming either the father or friend of the Lord, there are two varieties. One method is that one may try to become the father of the Lord directly, and the other is that one may follow Nanda Mahäräj and cherish the ideal of being Kåñëa's father. Out of these two, the attempt to directly become the father of Kåñëa is not recommended. Such a development can become polluted with mäyäväda (impersonal) philosophy. The mäyävädés or monists think that they themselves are Kåñëa, and if one thinks that he himself has become Nanda Mahäräj, then his parental love will become contaminated with the mäyäväda philosophy. The mäyäväda philosophical way of thinking is offensive, and no offender can enter into the kingdom of God to associate with Kåñëa.

In the Skanda Puräëa there is a story of an old man residing in Hastinäpur, capital of the kingdom of the Päëòus, who desired Kåñëa as his beloved son. This old man was instructed by Närada to follow in the footsteps of Nanda Mahäräj, and thus success was achieved by him.

There is a statement in the Näräyaëa-vyüha-stava prayers that persons who are always engaged in thinking of the Lord as their husband, friend, father or well-wisher are always worshipable by everyone. This spontaneous love for Kåñëa can only be developed by the special mercy of Kåñëa or His pure devotee. This process of devotional service is sometimes called puñöi-märga. Puñöi means nourishing and märga means path. Such development of sentiment nourishes devotional service to the highest standard. Thus it is called the path of nourishment, or puñöi-märga. The Vallabha-sampradäya, which belongs to the Viñëu-svämé sect of Vaiñëava religion, worships Kåñëa in this puñöi-märga. Generally devotees in Gujerat worship Bäla-Kåñëa, under this heading of puñöi-märga.

NoD 17-1970: Ecstatic Love

Chapter Seventeen

Ecstatic Love

By the process of executing regulated devotional service, one is actually elevated onto the transcendental stage, beyond the material modes of nature. At that time one's heart becomes illuminated like the sun. The sun is far above the planetary systems, and there is no possibility of its being covered by any kind of cloud; similarly, when a devotee is purified like the sun, from his pure heart there is a diffusion of ecstatic love which is more glorious than the sunshine. Only at that time is the attachment to Kåñëa perfect. Spontaneously, the devotee becomes eager to serve the Lord in his ecstatic love. At this stage the devotee is on the platform of uttama adhikäré, perfect devotion. Such a devotee has no agitation from material affections and is only interested in the service of Rädhä and Kåñëa.

To clarify, in the previous chapters, the symptoms of devotional service were explained along with instructions as to how they can be executed with our present senses, gradually rising to the platform of ecstasy of spontaneous love. And the two kinds of devotional service—namely devotional service through regulative principles and through spontaneous love—were discussed. Within the stage of the regulative principles of devotional service there are two divisions—namely executive and effective. This effective portion of devotional service is called bhäva, or ecstasy. In this connection, there is a statement in the Tantras that ecstasy is the first symptom of pure love for the Personality of Godhead, and in that stage one is sometimes found shedding tears or shivering. Not always are these symptoms manifest, but occasionally. When King Ambaréña was put into difficulty by Durväsä, he began to think of the lotus feet of the Lord, and thus there were some changes in his body, and tears were falling from his eyes. These symptoms are activities of ecstasy. They are visible in the shivering of the body and the shedding of tears. After the outward appearance of these ecstatic symptoms, they stay within the mind, and continuation of the ecstasy is called samädhi. This stage of appreciation becomes the cause of future exchanges of loving affairs with Kåñëa.

Elevation to this stage of ecstasy can be possible in two ways. One way is constant association with pure devotees. The other way is by the special mercy of Kåñëa, or by the mercy of a pure devotee of Kåñëa. Elevation to the ecstatic stage of life is generally attained through association with pure devotees, while elevation to that stage by the special mercy of Kåñëa or His devotee is very rare. The purport is that one should execute devotional service rigidly in the association of devotees so that there will be certainty in raising oneself to that ecstatic position. In special cases, of course, there is special favor from Kåñëa, and although we should always expect that, we should not sit idly and simply wait for Kåñëa's special mercy; the regular duties must be performed. It is just as when, sometimes, it is found that a person who never attended school or college may be recognized as a great scholar, or an honorary degree from great universities may be offered to him. But this does not mean that one should avoid school and expect to automatically receive an honorary degree from some university. Similarly, one should devoutly execute the regulative principles of devotional service and at the same time hope for Kåñëa's favor or for His devotee's favor.

An example of rising to the stage of ecstatic love by executing the regulative principles of devotional service is given in the life story of Närada, which is described to Vyäsadeva in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Närada tells there of his previous life and how he developed to the stage of ecstatic love. He was engaged in the service of great devotees and used to hear their talks and songs. Because he had the opportunity to hear these pastimes and songs of Kåñëa from the mouths of pure devotees, he became very attracted within his heart. Because he had become so eager to hear these topics, he gradually developed within himself an ecstatic love for Kåñëa. This ecstatic love is prior to the pure love of Kåñëa, because in the next verse Närada confirms that by the gradual process of hearing from the great sages he developed love of Godhead. In that connection, Närada continues to say in the First Canto, 5th Chapter, 28th verse, of the Bhägavatam: "First I passed my days in the association of the great sages during the rainy autumn season. Every morning and evening I heard them while they were singing and chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra, and thus gradually my heart became purified. As soon as I heard them with great attention, the influence of the modes of material ignorance and passion disappeared, and I became firmly fixed in devotional service to the Lord."

These are practical examples of how one can develop to the stage of ecstatic love simply by the association of pure devotees. It is essential, therefore, that one constantly associate with pure devotees who are engaged morning and evening in chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra. In this way one will get the chance to purify his heart and develop this ecstatic pure love for Kåñëa.

This statement is also confirmed in the Third Canto, 25th Chapter, 22nd verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, where Lord Kapila says, "My dear Mother, when a person is actually in association with pure devotees, the sublime potency of My devotional service can be experienced." In other words, when a pure devotee speaks, his words act upon the hearts of the audience. What is the secret of hearing and chanting? A professional speaker cannot impress transcendental ecstasy within the hearts of the listeners. However, when a realized soul who is engaged in the service of the Lord is speaking, he has the potency to inject spiritual life within the audience. One should, therefore, seek the association of such pure unalloyed devotees, and by such association and service a neophyte devotee will certainly develop attachment, love and devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

In the Padma Puräëa there is the story of a neophyte devotee who, in order to raise himself to the ecstatic platform, danced all night to invoke the Lord's grace upon him.

Sometimes, however, it is found that without undergoing any devotional process, one all of a sudden develops devotion for Lord Kåñëa. This sudden development of the devotional attitude in a person must be understood as a special mercy of Kåñëa or of His devotee. This apparently accidental development of ecstatic feelings through the causeless mercy of Kåñëa can be divided into three groups: simply by speaking, simply by glancing and simply by good wishes.

In the Näradéya Puräëa there is a statement about development of ecstatic love simply by speaking. Lord Kåñëa said to Närada, "O best of the brähmaëas, I wish that you may develop unalloyed devotional service to Me, which is full of transcendental bliss and all auspiciousness."

In the Skanda Puräëa there is a statement about developing ecstatic love towards Kåñëa simply by glancing. It is stated there: "When the inhabitants of Jaìgala Province saw the Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, they were so stricken with feeling that they could not withdraw their glance from Him."

As far as heartfelt wishes are concerned, there is a statement in the Çuka-saàhitä where Närada tells Çréla Vyäsadeva, "You have a son who is the greatest devotee of the Personality of Godhead, and I can observe that without any following of the regulative principles of devotional service, he is already enriched with many of the symptoms achieved by the execution of devotional service after many, many births."

As for ecstatic love of Kåñëa, there is a statement in the Seventh Canto, 4th Chapter, 26th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam in which Närada addresses King Yudhiñöhira: "My dear King, it is very difficult to describe the character of Prahläda. He developed a natural attraction for Kåñëa, and whatever I can explain about his character will simply be an arrangement of words; his actual character is impossible to describe." This means Närada himself admitted that the natural development of Prahläda's ecstatic love was by the grace of Lord Kåñëa.

This natural attraction for Kåñëa on the part of Prahläda was developed simply by the mercy of Närada. When Prahläda Mahäräj was within the womb of his mother, she was being sympathetically instructed by Närada about the science of devotional service, and at the same time Närada was wishing that the child within the womb could also take advantage of the instructions. Because Närada, an authorized devotee and great associate of the Personality of Godhead, was desiring auspiciousness for Prahläda Mahäräj, he developed all the characteristics of a high-grade devotee. This is called natural attraction. It is caused by the special grace of the Personality of Godhead or by the special grace of a great devotee like Närada.

There is a statement in the Skanda Puräëa wherein Parvata Muni tells Närada: "My dear Närada, of all saintly persons you are so great and glorious that simply by your good wishes a lowborn hunter also has become a great, elevated devotee of Lord Kåñëa."

This ecstatic love for Kåñëa can be divided into five divisions, which will be described by Çré Rüpa Gosvämé later on.

NoD 18-1970: Character of One in Ecstatic Love

Chapter Eighteen

Character of One in Ecstatic Love

Rüpa Gosvämé next describes the characteristics of a person who has actually developed his ecstatic love for Kåñëa. The characteristics are as follows:

1) He is always anxious to utilize his time in the devotional service of the Lord. He does not like to be idle. He wants service always, twenty-four hours a day without deviation.

2) He is always reserved and perseverant.

3) He is always detached from all material attraction.

4) He does not long for any material respect in return for his activities.

5) He is always certain that Kåñëa will bestow His mercy upon Him.

6) He is always very eager to serve the Lord faithfully.

7) He is very much attached to the chanting of the holy names of the Lord.

8) He is always eager to describe the transcendental qualities of the Lord.

9) He is very pleased to live in a place where the Lord's pastimes are performed, e.g., Mathurä, Våndävana, or Dvärakä.

Utilization of Time

An unalloyed devotee who has developed ecstatic love for Kåñëa is always engaging his words in reciting prayers to the Lord. Within the mind he is always thinking of Kåñëa, and with his body he is either offering obeisances by bowing down before the Deity or is engaging in some other service. During these ecstatic activities he sometimes sheds tears. In this way his whole life is engaged in the service of the Lord, with not a moment wasted on any other engagement.

Perseverance

When a person is undisturbed even in the presence of various causes of disturbance, he is called reserved and perseverant. An example of this perseverance and reservation is found in the behavior of King Parékñit, as described in the First Canto, 19th Chapter, 13th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The King says there to all the sages present before him at the time of his death, "My dear brähmaëas, you should always accept me as your surrendered servant. I have come to the bank of the Ganges just to devote my heart and soul unto the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa. So please bless me, that Mother Ganges may also be pleased with me. Let the curse of the brähmaëa's son fall upon me—I do not mind. I only request that at the last moment of my life all of you will kindly chant the holy name of Viñëu, so that I may realize His transcendental qualities."

This example of Mahäräj Parékñit's behavior, his remaining patient even at the last point of his life, his undisturbed condition of mind, is an example of reservation. This is one of the characteristics of a devotee who has developed ecstatic love for Kåñëa.

Detachment

The senses are always desiring sense enjoyment, but when a devotee develops transcendental love for Kåñëa his senses are no longer attracted by material desires. This state of mind is called detachment. There is a nice example of this detachment in connection with the character of King Bharata. In the Fifth Canto, 14th Chapter, 43rd verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated: "Emperor Bharata was so attracted by the beauty of the lotus feet of Kåñëa that even in his youthful life he gave up all kinds of attachments to family, children, friends, kingdom, etc., as though they were untouchable stools."

Emperor Bharata is a typical example of detachment. He had everything enjoyable in the material world, but he left it. This means that detachment does not mean artificially keeping oneself aloof and apart from the allurements of attachment. Even in the presence of such allurements, if one can remain unattracted by material attachments, that is called detachment. In the beginning, of course, a neophyte devotee must try to keep himself apart from all kinds of alluring attachments, but the real position of a mature devotee is that even in the presence of all allurements, he is not at all attracted. This is the actual criterion of detachment.

Pridelessness

When a devotee, in spite of possessing all the qualities of pure realization, is not proud of his position, that is called pridelessness. In the Padma Puräëa it is stated that King Bhagératha was the emperor above all other kings, yet he developed such ecstatic love for Kåñëa that he became a mendicant and went out begging even to the homes of his political enemies and untouchables. He was so humble that he respectfully bowed down before them.

There are many similar instances in the history of India. Even very recently, about 200 years ago or less, one big landlord known as Lalababu, a Calcutta landholder, became a Vaiñëava and lived in Våndävana. He was also begging from door to door, even at the homes of his political enemies. Begging involves being ready to be insulted by persons at whose home one has come. That is natural. But one has to tolerate such insults for the sake of Kåñëa. The devotee of Kåñëa can accept any position in the service of Kåñëa.

Great Hope

The strong conviction that one will certainly receive the favor of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is called in Sanskrit äçä-bandha. Äçä-bandha means to continue to think, "Because I'm trying my best to follow the routine principles of devotional service, I am sure that I will go back to Godhead, back to home."

In this connection, one prayer by Rüpa Gosvämé is sufficient to exemplify this hopefulness. He says, "I have no love for Kåñëa nor for the causes of developing love of Kåñëa—namely, hearing and chanting. And the process of bhakti-yoga, by which one is always thinking of Kåñëa and fixing His lotus feet in the heart, is also lacking in me. As far as philosophical knowledge or pious words are concerned, I don't see any opportunity for me to execute such activities. But above all, I am not even born of a nice family. Therefore I must simply pray to You, Gopé-jana-vallabha [Kåñëa, maintainer and beloved of the gopés]. I simply wish and hope that some way or other I may be able to approach Your lotus feet, and this hope is giving me pain, because I think myself quite incompetant to approach that transcendental goal of life." The purport is that under this heading of äçä-bandha, one should continue to hope against hope that some way or other he will be able to approach the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord.

Eagerness for Achieving the Desired Success

When one is sufficiently eager to achieve success in devotional service, that is called samutkaëöhä. This means complete eagerness. Actually this eagerness is the price for achieving success in Kåñëa consciousness. Everything has some value, and one has to pay the value before obtaining or possessing it. It is stated in the Vedic literature that to purchase the most valuable thing, Kåñëa consciousness, one has to develop intense eagerness for achieving success. This intense eagerness is very nicely expressed by Bilvamaìgala Thäkur in his book Kåñëa-karëämåta. He says, "I am eagerly waiting to see that boy of Våndävana whose bodily beauty is captivating the whole universe, whose eyes are always bounded by black eyebrows and expanded like lotus petals, who is always eagerly glancing over His devotees and therefore moving slightly here and there. His eyes are always moist, and His lips are colored like copper, and through those lips there comes a sound vibration which drives one madder than a mad elephant. I want so much to see Him at Våndävana!"

In the same Karëämåta there is another statement about the chanting of Rädhäräëé. It is said by one of the associates of Rädhäräëé: "O Lord Govinda, the girl who is daughter of King Våñabhänu is now shedding tears, and She is anxiously chanting Your holy name—Kåñëa! Kåñëa!"

This attachment for chanting the glories of the Lord is also stated in the Karëämåta as follows: "What shall I do for Kåñëa, who is pleasing beyond all pleasurable conceptions, and who is naughtier than all restless boys? The idea of Kåñëa's beautiful activities is attracting my heart, and I do not know what I can do!"

Attraction for Living in a Place Where Kåñëa Has His Pastimes

In the book Padyävalé by Rüpa Gosvämé there is the following statement about Våndävana: "In this place the son of Mahäräj Nanda used to live with His father, who was king of all cowherd men. In this place Lord Kåñëa broke the cart in which the Çakaöäsura demon was concealed. At this place Dämodara, who can cut the knot of our material existence, was tied up by His mother Yaçodä."

A pure devotee of Lord Kåñëa resides in the district of Mathurä or Våndävana and visits all the places where Kåñëa's pastimes were performed. At these sacred places Kåñëa displayed His childhood activities with the cowherd boys and Mother Yaçodä. The system of circumambulating all these places is still current among devotees of Lord Kåñëa, and those coming to Mathurä and Våndävana always feel transcendental pleasure. Actually, if someone goes to Våndävana, he will immediately feel separation from Kåñëa, who performed such nice activities when He was present there.

Such attraction for remembering Kåñëa's activities is known as attachment for Kåñëa. There are impersonalist philosophers and mystics, however, who by a show of devotional service want ultimately to merge into the existence of the Supreme Lord. They sometimes try to imitate a pure devotee's sentiment for visiting the holy places where Kåñëa had His pastimes, but they simply have a view for salvation, and so their activities cannot be considered attachment.

It is said by Rüpa Gosvämé that the attachment exhibited by pure devotees for Kåñëa cannot possibly be perfected in the heart of fruitive workers (karmés) or mental speculators because such attachment in pure Kåñëa consciousness is very rare and not possible to achieve even for many liberated persons. As is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, liberation from material contamination is the stage at which devotional service can be achieved. For a person who simply wants to have liberation and to merge into the impersonal brahma-jyoti, it is not possible to acquire attachment to Kåñëa. This attachment is very confidentially kept by Kåñëa and is only bestowed upon pure devotees. Even ordinary devotees cannot have such pure attachment for Kåñëa. Therefore, how is it possible for success to be achieved by persons whose hearts are contaminated by the actions and reactions of fruitive activities and who are entangled by various types of mental speculation?

There are many so-called devotees who artificially think of Kåñëa's pastimes, which are known as añöa-käléka-lélä. Sometimes one may artificially imitate these, pretending that Kåñëa is talking with him in the form of a boy, or else one may pretend that Rädhäräëé and Kåñëa both have come to him and are talking with him. Such characteristics are sometimes exhibited by the impersonalist class of men, and they may captivate some innocent persons who have no knowledge in the science of devotional service. However, as soon as an experienced devotee sees all of these caricatures, he can immediately evaluate such rascaldom. If such a pretender is sometimes seen possessing imitative attachment to Kåñëa, that will not be accepted as real attachment. It may be said, however, that such attachment is like giving a future hope to the pretender, so that he may eventually rise onto the actual platform of pure devotional service.

This imitative attachment can be divided into two headings—namely, shadow attachment and parä (transcendental) attachment. If someone, without undergoing the regulative principles of devotional service or without being guided by a bona fide spiritual master, shows such imitative attachment, it is called shadow attachment. Sometimes it is found that a person actually attached to material enjoyment or salvation has the good fortune to associate with pure devotees while they are engaged in chanting the holy name of the Lord. By the good grace of the Lord one may also cooperate and join in the chanting. At that time, simply by the association of such pure devotees, the moonlike rays from their hearts reflect on him, and by the influence of the pure devotees he may show some likeness of attachment caused by inquisitiveness, but this is very flickering. And, if by the manifestation of such shadow attachment one feels the disappearance of all material pangs, then it is called parä attachment.

Such shadow attachment or parä attachment can develop by associating with a pure devotee or by visiting holy places like Våndävana or Mathurä; or if an ordinary man develops such attachment for Kåñëa and fortunately performs devotional activities in the association of pure devotees, he can also rise up to the platform of pure devotional service. The conclusion is that transcendental attachment is so powerful that even if such attachment is seen manifested in some common man, by the association of a pure devotee it can bring one to the perfectional stage. But such attachment for Kåñëa cannot be invoked in a person without his being sufficiently blessed by the association of pure devotees.

As attachment can be invoked by the association of pure devotees, so attachment can also be extinguished by committing offenses at the lotus feet of pure devotees. To be more clear, by the association of pure devotees attachment for Kåñëa can be aroused, but if one commits offenses at the lotus feet of a devotee, his shadow attachment or parä attachment can be extinguished. This extinguishing is like the waning moon, which gradually decreases and at last becomes darkness. One should therefore be very careful while associating with pure devotees to guard against committing an offense at their lotus feet.

Transcendental attachment, either shadow or parä, can be nullified by different degrees of offenses at the lotus feet of pure devotees. If the offense is very serious, then one's attachment becomes almost nil, and if the offense is not very serious, one's attachment can become second-class or third-class.

If someone becomes attached to the principles of salvation or to merging into the existence of the brahma-jyoti, his ecstasies gradually diminish into shadow and parä attachment or else transform into the principles of ahaìgrahopäsanä. This ahaìgrahopäsanä describes a living entity when he begins spiritual realization by identifying himself with the Supreme Lord. This state of self realization is technically known as monism. The monist thinks himself one with the Supreme Lord. Thus, without differentiating between himself and the Supreme Lord, it is his view that by worshiping himself he is worshiping the supreme whole.

Sometimes it is found that a neophyte is taking part in chanting and dancing very enthusiastically, but within himself he is under the impression that he has become one with the supreme whole. This conception of monism is completely different from pure transcendental devotional service. If, however, it is seen that a person has developed a high standard of devotion without having undergone even the regulative principles, it is to be understood that his status of devotional service was achieved in a former life. For some reason or another it had been temporarily stopped, most probably by committing an offense at the lotus feet of a devotee. Now, with a good second chance, it has again begun to develop. The conclusion is that steady progress in devotional service can be attained only in the association of pure devotees.

If one can gradually advance his status in devotional service, it is to be understood that it is due to the causeless mercy of Kåñëa Himself. If a person is completely detached from material enjoyment and has developed pure ecstatic devotion, even if he is sometimes accidentally found not to be living up to the standard of devotional service, one should not be envious of him. It is confirmed also in the Bhagavad-gétä that a devotee who has unflinching faith in and devotion to the Lord, even if he is sometimes found to be accidentally deviated from pure devotional characteristics, should still be counted amongst the pure. Unflinching faith in devotional service, in Lord Kåñëa and in the spiritual master makes one highly elevated in the activities of devotional service.

In the Nåsiàha Puräëa it is stated: "If a person has completely engaged his mind, body and activities in the service of the Supreme Godhead, and externally he is found to be engaged in some abominable activities, these abominable activities will surely be very quickly vanquished by the influence of his staunch devotional force." The example is given that on the full moon there are some spots which may appear to be pockmarks. Still, the illumination spread by the full moon cannot be checked. Similarly, a little fault in the midst of volumes of devotional service is not at all to be counted as fault. Attachment for Kåñëa is transcendental bliss. Amidst unlimited volumes of transcendental bliss, a spot of some material defect cannot act in any way.

NoD 19-1970: Devotional Service in Love of God

Chapter Nineteen

Devotional Service in Love of God

When one's desire to love Kåñëa in his particular relationship becomes intensified, this is known as pure love of Godhead. In the beginning a devotee is engaged in the regulative principles of devotional service by the order of his spiritual master. When one thereby becomes completely purified of all material contamination, there develops an attachment and taste for devotional service. This taste and attachment, when gradually intensified in the course of time, becomes love. The word "love" can only be actually applied in relationship with the Personality of Godhead. In the material world, love is not applicable at all. What goes on under the name of love in the material world is nothing but lust. There is a gulf of difference between love and lust, like the difference between gold and iron. In the Närada-païcarätra it is clearly stated that when lust is completely transferred to the Supreme Godhead and the concept of kinship is completely reposed in Him, such is accepted as pure love of God by great authorities like Bhéñma, Prahläda, Uddhava and Närada.

A great authority like Bhéñma has explained that love of Godhead means completely giving up all so-called love for any other person. According to Bhéñma, love means to repose one's affection completely upon one person, withdrawing all affinities for any other person. This pure love can be transferred to the Supreme Personality of Godhead under two conditions—out of ecstasy and out of the causeless mercy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself.

Ecstatic love of Godhead can be potently invoked simply by following the rules and regulations of devotional service as they are prescribed in scriptures, under the direction of a bona fide spiritual master. In the Eleventh Canto, 2nd Chapter, 38th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam this ecstatic love, born of the execution of regulative devotional service, is explained: "A devotee, in the course of executing the regulative principles of devotional service, develops his natural Kåñëa consciousness, and being thus softened at heart he chants and dances like a madman. While performing chanting of the holy name of the Lord, he sometimes cries, sometimes talks wildly, sometimes sings, and sometimes—without caring for any outsider—dances like a madman."

In the Padma Puräëa there is a statement about ecstatic love born of spontaneous affection. Candrakänti, a celebrated fair-faced girl, rigidly observed celibacy in order to obtain Kåñëa as her husband. She always engaged herself in meditating on the transcendental form of the Lord and always chanted the glories of the Lord. She did not desire to accept anyone else as her husband. She had firmly decided that only Lord Kåñëa would be her husband.

The Lord's Extraordinary Mercy

When a devotee is found to be always associated with the Lord in ecstatic love, it is to be understood that such a position is awarded by the Lord Himself out of His causeless extraordinary mercy. An example of such extraordinary mercy is given in the Eleventh Canto, 12th Chapter, 6th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, wherein Lord Kåñëa tells Uddhava: "The gopés in Våndävana did not study the Vedas to achieve Me. Nor had they ever been in holy places of pilgrimage. Nor did they devoutly execute any regulative principle. Nor did they undergo any kind of austerity. It is simply by My association that they have attained the highest perfection of devotional service."

From the example of Candrakänti as found in the Padma Puräëa and from the example of the gopés as found in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, it appears that a devotee who always thinks of Kåñëa and who always chants His glories in ecstatic love, regardless of his condition, will attain the highest perfection of unalloyed devotional love due to Lord Kåñëa's extraordinary mercy. This is confirmed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam: "If Hari, the Supreme Lord, is worshiped, adored and loved by a person, it should be understood that the person has finished all kinds of austerities, penances and similar processes for self realization. On the other hand, if after undergoing all types of austerities, penances and mystic yoga practices, one does not develop such love for Hari, then all his performances are to be considered a useless waste of time. If someone always sees Kåñëa inside and out, then it is to be understood that he has surpassed all austerities and penances for self realization. And if, after executing all kinds of penances and austerities, one cannot always see Kåñëa inside and out, then he has executed his performances uselessly."

Spontaneous attraction to Kåñëa, which is said to be due to the extraordinary mercy of the Lord, can be placed under two headings: one is profound veneration for the greatness of the Lord, and the other may be one's automatically being attracted to Kåñëa without any extraneous consideration. In the Närada-païcarätra it is said that if on account of profound veneration for the greatness of the Supreme Lord, one attains a great affection and steady love for Him, one is certainly assured of attaining the four kinds of Vaiñëava liberation—namely, achieving the same bodily features as the Lord, achieving the same opulence as the Lord, dwelling on the planet where the Lord is residing, and attaining eternal association with the Lord. The Vaiñëava liberation is completely different from the mäyäväda liberation, which is simply a matter of being merged into the effulgence of the Lord.

In the Närada-païcarätra pure unalloyed devotional service is explained as being without any motive for personal benefit. If a devotee is continuously in love with Lord Kåñëa and his mind is always fixed upon Him, that devotional attitude will prove to be the only means of attracting the attention of the Lord. In other words, a Vaiñëava who is incessantly thinking of the form of Lord Kåñëa is to be known as a pure Vaiñëava.

Generally, a devotee who has achieved the causeless mercy of the Lord on account of following the strict rules and regulations of devotional service becomes attracted by the supreme greatness of the Lord, by the transcendental beauty of the Lord and by the spontaneous execution of devotional service. To be more clear, by executing the regulative principles of devotional service, one can fully appreciate the transcendental beauty of the Lord. In any case, such exalted positions are only possible by the extraordinary mercy of the Lord upon the devotee.

Association with Pure Devotees

Although many different processes for developing love of Godhead have been explained so far, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé now gives us a general description of how one can best achieve such a high position. The beginning of ecstatic love of Godhead is basically faith. There are many societies and associations of pure devotees, and if someone with just a little faith begins to associate with such societies, his advancement to pure devotional service is rapid. The influence of a pure devotee is such that if someone comes to associate with him with a little faith, he gets the chance of hearing about the Lord from authoritative scriptures like the Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Thus, by the mercy of the Lord, who is situated in everyone's heart, one gradually develops his faith in the descriptions of such authoritative scriptures. This is the first stage of association with pure devotees. In the second stage, after one becomes a little advanced and mature, he automatically offers to follow the principles of devotional service under the guidance of the pure devotee and accepts him as the spiritual master. In the next stage, under the guidance of the spiritual master, the devotee executes regulative devotional service, and, as a result of such activities, he becomes freed from all unwanted occupations. When he is freed from unwanted occupations, his faith becomes steadily fixed, and he develops a transcendental taste for devotional service, then attachment, then ecstasies, and in the last stage there is pure love of Godhead. These are the different stages of the development of pure love.

Only the most fortunate persons can achieve such success in life. Those who are simply academic students of the Vedic scriptures cannot appreciate how such a development takes place. In the Näräyaëa Païcarätra Lord Çiva therefore tells Pärvaté: "My dear supreme goddess, you can know from me that any person who has developed the ecstasy of love for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and who is always merged in transcendental bliss on account of this love, cannot even perceive the material distress or happiness coming from the body or mind."

Affection and the dealings of love are different branches of the original tree of love preceding the many varieties of affectionate manifestations, which will not be discussed here. These different manifestations have been described by Sanätana Gosvämé in his Bhägavatämåta. Although the subject of such affections and dealings of love are very confidential, Sanätana Gosvämé has described them very explicitly.

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé thus concludes the first division of the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, offering up his treatise for the transcendental pleasure of Sanätana Gosvämé, who has established the transcendental beauty, and of Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé and Raghunäthadäs Gosvämé. It appears from this statement that the great Çréla Jéva Gosvämé was not yet active when Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu was written.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta summary study of the first division of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, up to the descriptions of ecstatic love of Godhead, which are to follow next.


PART TWO

NoD 20-1970: Transcendental Mellow

Chapter Twenty

Transcendental Mellow

In this second division of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu the author offers his respectful obeisances unto "Sanätana." This Sanätana can be interpreted as either Çré Kåñëa Himself or as Sanätana Gosvämé, the elder brother and spiritual master of Rüpa Gosvämé. In the case where Sanätana is accepted to mean Çré Kåñëa, the obeisances are offered to Kåñëa because He is naturally so beautiful and because He is the killer of the demon Agha. If it is interpreted to mean Sanätana Gosvämé, then it is because he is so greatly favored by Rüpa Gosvämé, being always served by him, and because he is the annihilator of all kinds of sinful activities. In this division of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu the author wants to describe the general symptoms of the transcendental mellow (loving mood) of discharging devotional service.

In this division of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu there are five general topics: 1) vibhäva—special symptoms of ecstasy, 2) anubhäva—subsequent ecstasy, 3) sättvika-bhäva—constitutional ecstasy, 4) vyabhicäré-bhäva—aggressive ecstasy and 5) sthäyi-bhäva—fervent ecstasy.

The word rasa, used in the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, is understood by different persons differently because the exact English equivalent is very difficult to find. But as we have seen our spiritual master translate this word rasa into "mellow," we shall follow in his footsteps and also translate the word in that way.

The particular loving mood or attitude relished in the exchange of love with the Supreme Personality of Godhead is called rasa, or mellow. The different types of rasa, when combined together, help one to taste the mellow of devotional service in the highest degree of transcendental ecstasy. Such a position, although entirely transcendental to our experience, will be explained in this section as far as possible, following in the footsteps of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé.

Without relishing some sort of mellow or loving mood in one's activities, no one can continue to perform such activities. Similarly, in the transcendental life of Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service there must be some mellow or specific taste from the service. Generally this mellow is experienced by chanting, hearing, worshiping in the temple and being engaged in the service of the Lord. So when a person feels transcendental bliss, that is called "relishing the mellow." To be more clear, we may understand that the various feelings of happiness derived from discharging devotional service may be termed the "mellows" of devotional service.

This relishing of transcendental mellow in discharging devotional service cannot be experienced by all classes of men because this sweet loving mood is developed only from one's previous life's activities, or by the association of unalloyed devotees. As explained above, association with pure devotees is the beginning of faith in devotional service. Only by developing such faith in the association of a pure devotee, or by having in one's previous life executed devotional activities, can one actually relish the mellow of devotional service. In other words, this transcendental bliss is not to be enjoyed by any common man unless he is so extraordinarily fortunate as to be in association with devotees or to be continuing his previous birth's devotional activities.

The gradual process of development to the stage of devotional service is explained in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, First Canto: "The beginning is to hear about Lord Kåñëa in the association of devotees who have themselves cleansed their hearts by association. Hearing about the transcendental activities of the Lord will result in one's feeling transcendental bliss always." It is also explained in the Bhagavad-gétä that for one who has actually come to the spiritual platform, the first symptom visible will be that he is always joyful. This joyous life is attained by one's reaction to reading the Bhagavad-gétä or Çrémad-Bhägavatam, or else from associating with persons who are very interested in the spiritual life of Kåñëa consciousness—specifically those who have made the determination to achieve the favor of Govinda by being engaged in transcendental loving service at His lotus feet. Being encouraged by such a feeling, one who is constantly engaged in discharging the regulative principles of devotional service in such a way as to please the Supreme Personality of Godhead develops two principles of compelling force, which come under the heading of vibhäva. Thus one enjoys transcendental bliss.

There are several origins or causes for this compulsive love of Kåñëa, such as Kåñëa Himself, the devotees of Kåñëa, Kåñëa's playing on the flute, etc. The effect is sometimes loving and sometimes stunted.

There are eight transcendental symptoms found in the body during ecstasy, and all of them are possible only by a mixture of the above-mentioned five ecstatic divisions. Without some mixture of these five ecstatic principles, one cannot relish transcendental bliss. The cause or basis for relishing transcendental mellow is exactly what we mean by vibhäva. This vibhäva is divided into two—namely, basic and impetuous. In the Agni Puräëa the description of vibhäva is given as follows: "The basis from which ecstatic love is born is called vibhäva, which is divided into two—basic and impetuous." In other words, there are two kinds of ecstatic love. The object of basic ecstatic love is Kåñëa and His devotee. Lord Kåñëa is the object of basic ecstatic love, and His pure devotee, a reservoir of such love, is the object of impetuous ecstatic love. Impetuous ecstatic love, then, is that love which develops when one sees an object which reminds him of Kåñëa.

Lord Kåñëa, who is the possessor of inconceivable potencies and qualities of transcendental knowledge and bliss, is the basic cause of ecstatic love. Lord Kåñëa also becomes the reservoir (impetus) of ecstatic love by His different incarnations and expansions. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is a statement in connection with the brahma-vimohana-lélä, which demonstrates something of this impetuous feature of ecstatic love. When Brahmä was deluded by Kåñëa, who expanded Himself into so many cowherd boys, calves and cows, Kåñëa's elder brother, Çré Baladeva (a direct expansion of Kåñëa Himself), felt astonishment and said, "How wonderful it is that my ecstatic love for Kåñëa is again being attracted to so many cowherd boys, calves and cows!" He was struck with wonder by thinking in this way. This is one of the examples in which Kåñëa Himself becomes the object and reservoir of ecstatic love in the impetuous aspect.

NoD 21-1970: Qualities of Çré Kåñëa

Chapter Twenty-one

Qualities of Çré Kåñëa

Personal features can be divided into two: one feature is covered, and the other feature is manifested. When Kåñëa is covered by different kinds of dress, His personal feature is covered. There is an example of His covered personal feature in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam in connection with His Dvärakä lélä (His residence in Dvärakä as its king). Sometimes Lord Kåñëa began to play by dressing Himself like a woman. Seeing this form, Uddhava said, "How wonderful it is that this woman is attracting my ecstatic love exactly as Lord Kåñëa does. I think she must be Kåñëa covered by the dress of a woman!"

One devotee praised the bodily features of Kåñëa when he saw the Lord in His manifested personal feature. He exclaimed, "How wonderful is the personal feature of Lord Kåñëa! How His neck is just like a conchshell! His eyes are so beautiful, as though they themselves are encountering the beauty of a lotus flower. His body is just like the tämala tree, very blackish. His head is protected with a canopy of hair. There are the marks of çrévatsa on His chest, and He is holding His conchshell. By such beautiful bodily features, the enemy of the demon Madhu has appeared so pleasing that He can bestow upon me transcendental bliss simply by my seeing His transcendental qualities."

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, after consulting various scriptures, has enumerated the transcendental qualities of the Lord as follows: 1) beautiful features of the entire body; 2) marked with all auspicious characteristics; 3) extremely pleasing; 4) effulgent; 5) strong; 6) ever-youthful; 7) a wonderful linguist; 8) truthful; 9) talks pleasingly; 10) can speak fluently in all languages; 11) highly learned; 12) highly intelligent; 13) a genius; 14) artistic; 15) extremely clever; 16) expert; 17) grateful; 18) firmly determined; 19) an expert judge of time and circumstances; 20) sees and speaks on the authority of Vedas, or scriptures; 21) pure; 22) self-controlled; 23) steadfast; 24) forebearing; 25) forgiving; 26) grave; 27) self-satisfied; 28) possesses equilibrium; 29) magnanimous; 30) religious; 31) heroic; 32) compassionate; 33) respectful; 34) gentle; 35) liberal; 36) shy; 37) the protector of surrendered souls; 38) happy; 39) the well-wisher of devotees; 40) controlled by love; 41) all-auspicious; 42) most powerful; 43) all-famous; 44) popular; 45) partial to devotees; 46) very attractive to all women; 47) all-worshipable; 48) all-opulent; 49) all-honorable; 50) the supreme controller. The Supreme Personality of Godhead has all these fifty transcendental qualities in fullness as deep as the ocean. In other words, the extent of His qualities is inconceivable.

As parts and parcels of the Supreme Lord, the individual living entities can also possess all of these qualities in minute quantities, provided they become pure devotees of the Lord. In other words, all of the above transcendental qualities can be present in the devotees in minute quantity, whereas the qualities in fullness are always present in the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Besides these, there are other transcendental qualities which are described by Lord Çiva to Pärvaté in the Padma Puräëa and in the First Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, in connection with a conversation between the demigod of the earth and the King of religion, Yamaräj. It is said therein: "Persons who are desirous of becoming great personalities must be decorated with the following qualities: truthfulness, cleanliness, mercy, perseverence, renunciation, peacefulness, simplicity, control of the senses, equilibrium of the mind, austerity, equality, forbearance, placidity, learning, knowledge, opulence, chivalry, influence, strength, memory, independence, tactfulness, luster, patience, ability to talk, gravity, steadiness, faithfulness, fame, respectfulness and lack of false egotism." Persons who are desiring to become great souls cannot be without any of the above qualities, so we can know for certain that these qualities are found in Lord Kåñëa, the supreme soul.

Besides all of the above-mentioned fifty qualities, Lord Kåñëa possesses five more, which are sometimes partially manifested in the persons of Lord Brahmä or Lord Çiva. These transcendental qualities are as follows: 51) changeless; 52) all-cognizant; 53) ever-fresh; 54) sac-cid-änanda (possessing an eternal blissful body); 55) possessing all mystic perfection.

Kåñëa also possesses five other qualities, which are manifest in the body of Näräyaëa, and they are listed as follows: 56) He has inconceivable potency. 57) Uncountable universes generate from His body. 58) He is the original source of all incarnations. 59) He is the giver of salvation to the enemies whom He kills. 60) He is the attractor of liberated souls. All these transcendental qualities are manifest wonderfully in the personal feature of Lord Kåñëa.

Besides these sixty transcendental qualities, Kåñëa has four more, which are not manifest even in the Näräyaëa form of Godhead, not to speak of the demigods or living entities. They are as follows: 61) He is the performer of wonderful varieties of pastimes (especially His childhood pastimes). 62) He can attract all living entities all over the universes by playing on His flute. 63) He is surrounded by devotees endowed with wonderful love of Godhead. 64) He has a wonderful excellence of beauty which cannot be rivalled anywhere in the creation.

Adding to the list these four exceptional qualities of Kåñëa, it is to be understood that the aggregate number of qualities of Kåñëa is sixty-four. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has attempted to give evidences from various scriptures about all sixty-four qualities present in the person of the Supreme Lord.

1. Beautiful Bodily Features

Any comparison of the different parts of the Lord's body to different material objects cannot factually be a complete comparison. Ordinary persons, who cannot understand how exalted are the bodily features of the Lord, are simply given a chance to understand by a material comparison. It is said that Kåñëa's face is as beautiful as the moon, His thighs are powerful, just like the trunks of elephants, His arms are just like two pillars, His palms are expanded like lotus flowers, His chest is just like a doorway, His hips are dens, and the middle of His body is a terrace.

2. Auspicious Characteristics

There are certain characteristics of different limbs which are considered to be very auspicious and are fully present in the body of the Lord. In this connection, one friend of Nanda Mahäräj, speaking about Lord Kåñëa's auspicious bodily symptoms, said, "My dear King of the cowherds, I can find 32 auspicious symptoms on the body of your son! I am wondering how this boy could have taken his birth in the family of cowherd men." Generally, when Lord Kåñëa appears He does so in a family of kñatriyas (kings), as did Lord Rämacandra, and sometimes in a family of brähmaëas. But Kåñëa accepted the role of son to Mahäräj Nanda, despite the fact that Nanda belonged to the vaiçya community. The business of the vaiçya community is trade, commerce and the protection of cows. Therefore his friend, who may have been born into a brähmaëa family, expressed his wonder at how such an exalted child could take birth in a family of vaiçyas. Anyway, he pointed out the auspicious signs on the body of Kåñëa to the boy's foster father.

He continued: "This boy has a reddish luster in seven places—His eyes, the ends of His hands, the ends of His legs, His palate, His lips, His tongue and His nails. A reddish luster in these seven places is considered to be auspicious. Three parts of His body are very broad: His waist, forehead and chest. Three parts of His body are short: His neck, thighs and genitals. Three parts of His body are very deep: His voice, intelligence and navel. There is highness in five parts of His body: His nose, arms, ears, forehead and thighs. In five parts of His body there is fineness—His skin, the hairs on His head and on the other parts of His body, His teeth and finger tips. The aggregate of all these bodily features are manifest only in the bodies of great personalities."

The fate lines on the palm are also considered to be auspicious bodily symptoms. In this connection, one old gopé informed King Nanda: "Your son possesses various wonderful fate lines on His palms. There are the signs of lotus flowers and wheels on His palms, and on His soles there are the signs of a flag, thunderbolt, fish, rod for controlling elephants and a lotus flower. Please observe how auspicious these signs are!"

3. Pleasing

Beautiful bodily features which automatically attract the eyes are called rucira (pleasing). Kåñëa possesses this attractive feature of rucira in His personal features. In the Third Canto, 2nd Chapter, 13th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is a statement about this. "The Supreme Personality of Godhead, in His pleasing dress, appeared at the scene of the sacrificial arena when King Yudhiñöhira was performing the räja-süya sacrifice. All important personalities from different parts of the universe had been invited to the sacrificial arena, and all of them, upon beholding Kåñëa there, considered that the Creator had ended all of His craftsmanship in the creation of this particular body of Kåñëa."

It is said that the transcendental body of Kåñëa resembles the lotus flower in eight parts—namely, His face, His two eyes, His two hands, His navel, and His two feet. The gopés and inhabitants of Våndävana used to see the luster of lotus flowers everywhere, and they could hardly withdraw their eyes from such a vision.

4. Effulgent

The effulgence pervading the universe is considered to be the rays of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The supreme abode of Kåñëa is always throwing off the effulgence known as brahma-jyoti, and that effulgence is emanating from His body.

The luster of the hosts of jewels fixed on the chest of the Lord can defeat even the luster of the sun, and still, when compared with the bodily luster of the Lord, that crest of jewels appears to be only as bright as one of the stars in the sky. Therefore the transcendental influence of Kåñëa is so great that it can defeat anyone. When Kåñëa was present in the sacrificial arena of His enemy, King Kaàsa, the wrestlers present, although appreciating the softness of the body of Çré Kåñëa, were nevertheless afraid and perturbed when they thought of engaging with Him in battle.

5. Strong

A person who has extraordinary bodily strength is called baléyän. When Kåñëa killed Ariñöäsura, some of the gopés said, "My dear friends, just see how Kåñëa has killed Ariñöäsura! Although he was stronger than a mountain, Kåñëa plucked him up just like a piece of cotton and threw him away without any difficulty!" There is another passage wherein it is said: "O my dear devotees of Lord Kåñëa, may the left hand of Lord Kåñëa, which has lifted Govardhana Hill like a ball, save you from all dangers."

6. Ever-youthful

Kåñëa is beautiful at His different ages—namely, His childhood, His boyhood and His youth. Out of these three, His youth is the reservoir of all pleasures and is the time when the highest varieties of devotional service are acceptable. At that age, Kåñëa is full with all transcendental qualities and is engaged in His transcendental pastimes. Therefore, devotees have accepted the beginning of His youth as the most attractive feature in ecstatic love.

At this age Kåñëa is described as follows: "The force of Kåñëa's youth was combined with His beautiful smile, which defeated even the beauty of the full moon. He was always nicely dressed, in beauty surpassing even Cupid, and He was always attracting the minds of the gopés, who were thereby always feeling pleasure."

7. Wonderful Linguist

Rüpa Gosvämé says that a person who knows the languages of different countries, especially the Sanskrit language, which is spoken in the cities of the demigods—as well as other worldly languages, including those of the animals—is called a wonderful linguist. It appears from this statement that Kåñëa can also speak and understand the languages of the animals. An old woman in Våndävana, present at the time of Kåñëa's pastimes, once stated in surprise: "How wonderful it is that Kåñëa, who owns the hearts of all the young girls of Brajabhümi, can nicely speak the language of Brajabhümi with the gopés, while in Sanskrit He speaks with the demigods, and in the language of the animals He can even speak with the cows and buffalo! Similarly, in the language of the Kashmere Province, and with the parrots and other birds, as well as in most common languages, Kåñëa is so expressive!" She inquired from the gopés as to how Kåñëa had become so expert in speaking so many different types of languages.

8. Truthful

A person whose word of honor is never broken is called truthful. Kåñëa once promised Kunté, the mother of the Päëòavas, that He would bring her five sons back from the battlefield of Kurukñetra. After the battle was finished, when all the Päëòavas had come home, Kunté praised Kåñëa because His promise was so nicely fulfilled. She said, "Even the sunshine may one day become cool and the moonshine may one day become hot, but still Your promise will not fail. Similarly, when Kåñëa, along with Bhéma and Arjuna, went to challenge Jaräsandha, He plainly told Jaräsandha that He was the eternal Kåñëa, present along with two of the Päëòavas. The story is that both Kåñëa and the Päëòavas—in this case Bhéma and Arjuna—were kñatriyas (warrior-kings). Jaräsandha was also a kñatriya and was very charitable toward the brähmaëas. Thus Kåñëa, who had planned to fight with Jaräsandha, went to him with Bhéma and Arjuna in the dress of brähmaëas. Jaräsandha, being very charitable toward the brähmaëas, asked them what they wanted, and they expressed their desire to fight with him. Then Kåñëa, dressed as a brähmaëa, declared Himself to be the same Kåñëa who was the King's eternal enemy.

9. Pleasing Talker

A person who can speak sweetly even with his enemy just to pacify him is called a pleasing talker. Kåñëa was such a pleasing talker that after defeating His enemy, Käliya, in the water of Yamunä, He said: "My dear King of the snakes, although I have given you so much pain, please do not be dissatisfied with Me. It is My duty to protect these cows, which are worshiped even by the demigods. Only in order to save them from the danger of your presence have I been obliged to banish you from this place."

Käliya was residing within the water of the Yamunä, and as a result the back portion of that river had become poisoned. Thus so many cows who had drunk the water had died. Therefore Kåñëa, even though He was only four or five years old, dipped Himself into the water, punished Käliya very severely and then asked him to leave the place and go elsewhere.

Kåñëa said at that time that the cows are worshiped even by the demigods, and He practically demonstrated how to protect the cows. At least people who are in Kåñëa consciousness should follow in His footsteps and give all protection to the cows. Cows are worshiped not only by the demigods. Kåñëa Himself worshiped the cows on several occasions, especially on the days of Gopäñöamé and Govardhana Püjä.

10. Fluent in All Languages

A person who can speak meaningful words and with all politeness and good qualities is called vävadüka, or fluent. There is a nice statement in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam regarding Kåñëa's speaking politely. When Kåñëa politely bade His father, Nanda Mahäräj, to stop the ritualistic offering of sacrifice to the raingod, Indra, a wife of one village cowherd man became captivated. She later thus described the speaking of Kåñëa to her friends: "Kåñëa was speaking to His father so politely and gently that it was as if He were pouring nectar into the ears of all present there. After hearing such sweet words from Kåñëa, who will not be attracted to Him?"

Kåñëa's speech, which contains all good qualities in the universe, is described in the following statement by Uddhava: "The words of Kåñëa are so attractive that they can immediately change the heart of even His opponent. His words can immediately solve all of the questions and problems of the world. Although He does not speak very long, each and every word from His mouth contains volumes of meaning. These speeches of Kåñëa are very pleasing to my heart."

11. Highly Learned

When a person is highly educated and acts strictly on moral principles, he is called highly learned. A person conversant in different departments of knowledge is called educated, and because he acts on moral principles, he is called morally stout. Together, these two factors constitute learning.

Kåñëa's receiving education from Sändépani Muni is described by Çré Närada Muni as follows: "In the beginning, Lord Brahmä and others are as clouds of evaporated water from the great ocean of Kåñëa. In other words, Brahmä first received the Vedic education from Kåñëa, as the clouds receive water from the ocean. That Vedic education or instruction which was spoken by Brahmä to the world was then reposed upon the mountain of Sändépani Muni. Sändépani Muni's instructions to Kåñëa are like a reservoir of water on the mountain, which flows as a river and goes again to mix with the source, the ocean of Kåñëa." To be more clear, the idea is that Kåñëa actually cannot be instructed by anyone, just as the ocean does not receive water from any source but itself. It only appears that the rivers are pouring water into the ocean. So it is clear that Brahmä received his education from Kåñëa, and from Brahmä, via the disciplic succession, this Vedic instruction was distributed. Sändépani Muni is likened to the river which is flowing down again to that same original ocean of Kåñëa.

The Siddhas, the inhabitants of Siddha-loka (where all are born with fully developed mystic powers), and the Cäraëas, the inhabitants of a similar planet, pray to Kåñëa as follows: "My Lord Govinda, the goddess of learning, who is decorated with fourteen kinds of educational ornaments, whose intelligence is all-pervading within the four departments of the Vedas, whose attention is always on the lawbooks given by great sages like Manu, and who is appareled in six kinds of expert knowledge—namely Vedic evidence, grammar, astrology, rhetoric, vocabulary, and logic, and whose constant friends are the supplements of the Vedas and Puräëas, decorated with the final conclusion of all education—has now acquired an opportunity to sit with You as a class friend in school, and she is now engaged in Your service."

Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, does not require any education, but He gives a chance to the goddess of learning to serve Him. Being self-sufficient, Kåñëa does not require the service of any living entity, although He has many devotees. It is because Kåñëa is so kind and merciful that He gives the opportunity to everyone to serve Him, as though He requires the service of His devotees.

Regarding His moral principles, it is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam that Kåñëa is ruling over Våndävana as death personified to the thieves, as pleasing bliss to the pious, as the most beautiful Cupid to the young girls and as the most munificent personality to the poor men. He is as refreshing as the full moon to His friends, and to His opponents He is the annihilating fire generated from Lord Çiva. Kåñëa is therefore the most perfect moralist in His reciprocal dealings with different kinds of persons. When He is death personified to the thieves, it is not that He is without moral principles or that He is cruel; He is still kind, because to punish thieves with death is to exhibit the highest quality of moral principles. In the Bhagavad-gétä, also, Kåñëa says that He deals with different kinds of persons according to their dealings with Him. Kåñëa's dealings with devotees and with nondevotees, although different, are both equally good. Because Kåñëa is all good, His dealings with everyone are always good.

12. Highly Intelligent

A man is called intelligent if he has a sharp memory and fine discretion. As far as Kåñëa's memory is concerned, it is said that when He was studying in the school of Sändépani Muni in Avantépur, He showed such a sharp memory that by once taking instructions from the teacher He immediately became perfect in any subject. Actually, His going to the school of Sändépani Muni was to show the people of the world that however great or ingenious one may be, he must go to higher authorities for general education. However great one may be, he must accept a teacher or spiritual master.

Kåñëa's fine discretion was exhibited when He was fighting with the untouchable king who attacked the city of Mathurä. According to Vedic rites, those who are untouchable are not to be touched by the kñatriya kings, not even for killing. Therefore, when the untouchable king seized the city of Mathurä, Kåñëa did not think it wise to kill him directly with His own hand. Still the king had to be killed, and therefore Kåñëa decided with fine discretion that He should flee from the battlefield so that the untouchable king would chase Him. He could then lead the king to the mountain where Mucukunda was lying asleep. Mucukunda had received a benediction from Lord Çiva to the effect that when he awoke from his sleep, whomever he might see would at once be burnt to ashes. Therefore Kåñëa thought it wise to lead the untouchable king to that cave so that the king's presence would awaken Mucukunda, and he would at once be burnt to ashes.

13. Genius

A person is called a genius when he can refute any kind of opposing element with newer and newer arguments. In this connection there is a statement in Padyävalé which contains the following conversation between Kåñëa and Rädhä: One morning, when Kåñëa came to Rädhä, Rädhä asked Him, "My dear Keçava, where is Your väsa at present?" The Sanskrit word väsa has three meanings: one meaning is residence, one meaning is fragrance, and another meaning is dress.

Actually Rädhäräëé inquired from Kåñëa, "Where is Your dress?" But Kåñëa took the meaning as residence, and He replied to Rädhäräëé, "My dear captivated one, at the present moment my residence is in Your beautiful eyes."

To this Rädhäräëé replied, "My dear cunning boy, I did not ask You about Your residence. I inquired about Your dress."

Kåñëa then took the meaning of väsa as fragrance and said, "My dear fortunate one, I have just assumed this fragrance in order to be associated with Your body."

Çrématé Rädhäräëé again enquired from Kåñëa, "Where did You pass Your night?" The exact Sanskrit word used in this connection was yäminyämuñitaù. Yäminyäm means at night, and uñitaù means pass. Kåñëa, however, divided the word yäminyämuñitaù into two separate words, namely yäminyä and muñitaù. By dividing this word into two, it came out to mean that He was kidnapped by Yäminé, or night. Kåñëa therefore replied to Rädhäräëé, "My dear Rädhäräëé, is it possible that night can kidnap Me?" In this way He was answering all of the questions of Rädhäräëé so cunningly that He gladdened this dearest of the gopés.

14. Artistic

One who can talk and dress himself very artistically is called vidagdha. This exemplary characteristic was visible in the personality of Çré Kåñëa. It is spoken of by Rädhäräëé as follows: "My dear friend, just see how Kåñëa has nicely composed songs and how He dances and speaks funny words and plays on His flute, wearing such nice garlands. He has dressed Himself in such an enchanting way, as though He has defeated all kinds of players at the chessboard. He lives wonderfully at the topmost height of artistic craftsmanship."

15. Clever

A person who can perform various types of work at once is called clever. In this connection one of the gopés said: "My dear friends, just see the clever activities of Çré Kåñëa! He has composed nice songs about the cowherd boys and is pleasing the cows. By the movement of His eyes He is pleasing the gopés, and at the same time, He is fighting with demons like Ariñöäsura and others. In this way, He is sitting with different living entities in different ways, and He is thoroughly enjoying the situation."

16. Expert

Any person who can quickly execute a very difficult task is called expert. About the expertise of Kåñëa there is a statement in the Tenth Canto, 59th Chapter, 13th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, wherein Çukadeva Gosvämé tells Mahäräj Parékñit: "O best of the Kurus, Çré Kåñëa cut into pieces all the different weapons used by different fighters." Formerly, fighting was done by releasing different kinds of arrows. One party would release a certain arrow, and the other party had to defeat it by counteracting it with another arrow. For example, one party might release an arrow which would cause water to pour from the sky, and to counteract this, the opposing party would have to release an arrow which could immediately turn the water into clouds. So from this statement it appears that Kåñëa was very expert in counteracting the enemy's arrows. Similarly, at the räsa dance, each and every gopé requested that Kåñëa individually become her partner, and Kåñëa immediately expanded Himself into so many Kåñëas in order to be coupled with each and every gopé. The result was that each gopé found Kåñëa by her side.

17. Grateful

Any person who is conscious of his friend's beneficent activities and never forgets his service is called grateful. In the Mahäbhärata, Kåñëa says, "When I was away from Draupadé, she cried with the words, 'Hey, Govinda!' This call for Me has put Me in her debt, and that indebtedness is gradually increasing in My heart." This statement by Kåñëa gives evidence of how one can please the Supreme Lord simply by addressing Him: "Hey, Kåñëa! Hey, Govinda!"

The mahä-mantra (Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare) is also simply an address to the Lord and His energy. So to anyone who is constantly engaged in addressing the Lord and His energy, we can imagine how much the Supreme Lord is obliged. It is impossible for the Lord to ever forget such a devotee. It is clearly stated in this verse that anyone who addresses the Lord immediately attracts the attention of the Lord, who always remains obliged to him.

Another instance of Kåñëa's feeling of obligation is stated in connection with His dealings with Jämbavän. When the Lord was present as Lord Rämacandra, Jämbavän, the great king of the monkeys, rendered very faithful service to Him. When the Lord again appeared as Lord Kåñëa, He married Jämbavän's daughter and paid him all the respect that is usually given to superiors. Any honest person is obliged to his friend if some service has been rendered unto Him. Since Kåñëa is the supreme honest personality, how can He forget an obligation to His servitor?

18. Determined

Any person who observes regulative principles and fulfills his promises by practical activity is called determined. As far as the Lord's determination is concerned, there is an example in His dealings in the Harivaàça. This is in connection with Lord Kåñëa's fighting the King of heaven, Indra, who was forcibly bereft of the pärijäta flower. Pärijäta is a kind of lotus flower grown on the heavenly planets. Once, Satyabhämä, one of Kåñëa's queens, wanted that lotus flower, and Kåñëa promised to deliver it; but Indra refused to part with his pärijäta flower. Therefore there was a great fight, with Kåñëa and the Päëòavas on one side and all of the demigods on the other. Ultimately, Kåñëa defeated all of them and took the pärijäta flower, which He presented to His queen. So, in regard to that occurrence, Kåñëa told Närada Muni, "My dear great sage of the demigods, now you can declare to the devotees in general, and to the nondevotees in particular, that in this matter of taking the pärijäta flower, all the demigods—the Gandharvas, the Nägas, the demon Räkñasas, the Yakñas, the Pannagas—tried to defeat Me, but none could make Me break My promise to My queen."

There is another promise by Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä to the effect that His devotee will never be vanquished. So a sincere devotee who is always engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord should know for certain that Kåñëa will never break His promise. He will always protect His devotees in every circumstance.

Kåñëa showed how He fulfills His promise by delivering the pärijäta flower to Satyabhämä, by saving Draupadé from being insulted and by freeing Arjuna from the attacks of all enemies.

The promise of Kåñëa that His devotees are never vanquished had also previously been admitted by Indra when he was defeated in the Govardhana-lélä. When Kåñëa stopped the villagers of Braja (Våndävana) from worshiping Indra, Indra became angry and therefore inundated Våndävana with continual rain. Kåñëa, however, protected all of the citizens and animals of Våndävana by lifting Govardhan Hill, which served as an umbrella. After the incident was over, Indra surrendered to Kåñëa with many prayers, in which he admitted, "By Your lifting Govardhan Hill and protecting the citizens of Våndävana, You have kept Your promise that Your devotees are never to be vanquished."

19. Expert Judge of Time and Circumstances

Kåñëa was very expert in dealing with people according to circumstances, country, time and paraphernalia. How He could take advantage of a particular time, circumstance and person is expressed by Him while talking to Uddhava about His räsa dance with the gopés. He says: "The most opportune time is the full moon night in autumn, like tonight. The best place within the universe is Våndävana, and the most beautiful girls are the gopés. So, My dear friend Uddhava, I think I should now take advantage of all these circumstances and engage Myself in the räsa dance."

20. Seer by the Authority of the Scriptures

A person who acts exactly according to the tenets of scripture is called çästra-cakñus. Çästra-cakñus means one who sees through the eyes of the authorized scriptures. Actually, any man of knowledge and experience should see everything through these books. For example, with our naked eye we perceive the sun globe simply as some glaring substance, but when we see through authorized books of science and other literature, we can understand how much greater the sun globe is than this earth and how powerful it is. So seeing things through the naked eye is not actually seeing. Seeing things through the authorized books or authorized teachers is the correct way to see. So, although Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and can see all that is past, present and future, to teach the people in general He used to always refer to the scriptures. For example, in the Bhagavad-gétä, although Kåñëa was speaking as the supreme authority, He still mentioned and quoted Vedänta-sütra as authority. There is a statement in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam wherein a person jokingly says that Kåñëa, the enemy of Kaàsa, is known as the seer through the çästras. In order to establish His authority, however, He is now engaged in seeing the gopés, whereby the gopés are becoming maddened.

21. Pure

There are two kinds of supreme purity. When one type is possessed, one is able to deliver a sinful person. When the other type is possessed, one does not do anything which is impure. A person who possesses either of these qualities is called supremely pure. Kåñëa is both; He can deliver all sinful conditioned souls, and at the same time, He never does anything by which He can be contaminated.

In this connection, Vidura, while trying to detach his elder brother, Dhåtaräñöra, from his familial attachments, said, "My dear brother, you just fix your mind on the lotus feet of Kåñëa, who is worshiped with beautiful erudite verses by great sages and saintly persons. Kåñëa is the supreme deliverer amongst all other deliverers. Undoubtedly there are great demigods like Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä, but their positions as deliverers depend always upon the mercy of Kåñëa." Therefore Vidura advised his elder brother Dhåtaräñöra to concentrate his mind and worship only Kåñëa. If one simply chants the holy name of Kåñëa, this holy name will rise within one's heart like the powerful sun and will immediately dissipate all the darkness of ignorance. Vidura advised Dhåtaräñöra to therefore think always of Kåñëa so that the volumes of contaminations due to sinful activities would be washed off immediately. In the Bhagavad-gétä also Kåñëa is addressed by Arjuna as paraà brahma paraà dhäma pavitram—the supreme pure. There are many other instances exhibiting Kåñëa's supreme purity.

22. Self-controlled

A person who can control his senses fully is called vaçé, or self-controlled. In this connection it is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam: "All the 16,000 wives of Kåñëa were so exquisitely beautiful that their smiling and shyness were able to captivate the minds of great demigods like Lord Çiva. But still they could not even agitate the mind of Kåñëa, in spite of their attractive feminine behavior." Every one of the thousands of wives of Kåñëa was thinking that Kåñëa was captivated by her feminine beauty, but this was not the case. Kåñëa is therefore the supreme controller of senses, and this is admitted in the Bhagavad-gétä, where He is addressed as Håñékeça—the master of the senses.

23. Steadfast

A person who continues to work until his desired goal is achieved is called steadfast.

There was a fight between Kåñëa and King Syamantaka, and Kåñëa was to take a valuable jewel from the King. The King tried to hide himself in the forest, but Kåñëa would not become discouraged. Kåñëa finally got the jewel by seeking out the King with great steadfastness.

24. Forbearing

A person who tolerates all kinds of troubles, even though such troubles appear to be unbearable, is called forbearing.

When Kåñëa was residing at the place of His spiritual master, He did not mind taking all troubles in rendering service to His guru, although His body was very soft and delicate. It is the duty of the disciple to execute all services unto the spiritual master, despite all kinds of difficulties. The disciple living at the residence of the spiritual master has to go begging from door to door and bring everything back to the spiritual master. When prasädam is being served, the spiritual master is supposed to call each and every disciple to come eat. If by chance the spiritual master forgets to call a disciple to partake of the prasädam, it is enjoined in the scriptures that the student should fast on that day rather than accept food on his own initiative. There are many such strictures. Sometimes, also, Kåñëa went to the forest to collect dry wood for fuel.

25. Forgiving

A person who can tolerate all kinds of offenses from the opposite party is known to be forgiving.

Lord Kåñëa's forgiving quality is described in the Mahäbhärata in connection with His forbidding the killing of Çiçupäla. King Çiçupäla was the monarch of the Cedi Kingdom, and although he happened to be a cousin of Kåñëa's, he was always envious of Him. Whenever they would meet, Çiçupäla would try to insult Kåñëa and call Him ill names as much as possible. In the arena of the räja-süya sacrifice of Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira, when Çiçupäla began to call Lord Kåñëa ill names, Kåñëa did not care and remained silent. Some of the people at the arena were prepared to kill Çiçupäla, but Kåñëa restricted them. He was so forgiving. It is said that when there is a thundering sound in the clouds, the mighty lion immediately replies with his thundering roar. But the lion doesn't care when all the foolish jackals begin to make their less important sounds.

Çré Yämunäcärya praises Kåñëa's power of forgiveness with the following statement: "My dear Lord Rämacandra, You are so merciful to have excused the crow's clawing on the nipples of Jänaké simply because of his bowing down before You." Once Indra, the King of heaven, assumed the form of a crow and attacked Sétä (Jänaké), Lord Rämacandra's wife, by striking her on the breast. This was certainly an insult to the universal mother, Sétä, and Lord Rämacandra was immediately prepared to kill the crow. But because later on the crow bowed down before the Lord, He excused his offense. Çré Yämunäcärya further says in his prayer that the forgiving power of Lord Kåñëa is even greater than that of Lord Rämacandra, because Çiçupäla was always in the habit of insulting Kåñëa—not only in one lifetime, but continually throughout three lives. Still, Kåñëa was so kind that He gave Çiçupäla the salvation of merging into His existence. From this we can understand that the goal of the monist to merge into the effulgence of the supreme is not a very difficult problem. Persons like Çiçupäla who are consistently inimical to Kåñëa can also get this liberation.

26. Grave

A person who does not express his mind to everyone, or whose mental activity and plan of action are very difficult to understand, is called grave. After Lord Çré Kåñëa had been offended by Brahmä, Brahmä prayed to Him to be excused. But in spite of his offering nice prayers to Kåñëa, Brahmä could not understand whether Kåñëa was satisfied or still dissatisfied. In other words, Kåñëa was so grave that He did not take the prayers of Brahmä very seriously. Another instance of Kåñëa's gravity is found in connection with His love affairs with Rädhäräëé. Kåñëa was always very silent about His love affairs with Rädhäräëé, so much so that Baladeva, Kåñëa's elder brother and constant companion, could not understand the transformations of Kåñëa on account of His gravity.

27. Self-satisfied

A person who is fully satisfied in himself, without any hankering, and who is not agitated even in the presence of serious cause for distress, is called self-satisfied.

An example of Kåñëa's self-satisfaction was exhibited when He, Arjuna and Bhéma went to challenge Jaräsandha, the formidable king of Magadha, and Kåñëa gave all credit to Bhéma for the killing of Jaräsandha. From this we can understand that Kåñëa never cares at all for fame, although no one can be more famous.

An example of His not being disturbed was shown when Çiçupäla began to call Him ill names. All the kings and brähmaëas assembled at the sacrificial arena of Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira became perturbed and immediately wanted to satisfy Kåñëa by offering nice prayers. But all these kings and brähmaëas could not discover any disturbance in Kåñëa's person.

28. Possessing Equilibrium

A person who is unaffected by attachment and envy is said to possess equilibrium.

An example of Kåñëa's equilibrium is given in the Tenth Canto, 16th Chapter, 29th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam in connection with His chastising Käliya, the hundred-headed serpent. While Käliya was being severely punished, all of his wives appeared before the Lord and prayed as follows: "My dear Lord, You have descended to punish all kinds of demoniac living creatures. Our husband, this Käliya, is a greatly sinful creature, and so Your punishment for him is quite appropriate. We know that Your punishment for Your enemies and Your dealings with Your sons are both the same. We know that it is in thinking of the future welfare of this condemned creature that You have chastised him."

In another prayer it is said, "My dear Lord Kåñëa, best of all the Kuru dynasty, You are so impartial that even if Your enemy is qualified, You will reward him; and if one of Your sons is a culprit, You will chastise him. This is Your business, because You are the supreme author of universes. You have no partiality. If anyone finds any partiality in Your characteristics, he is surely mistaken."

29. Magnanimous

Any person who is very charitably disposed is called magnanimous.

When Kåñëa was reigning over Dvärakä, He was so magnanimous and charitably disposed that there was no limit to His charity. In fact, so great was His charity in Dvärakä that even the spiritual kingdom, with all of its opulence of cintämaëi (touchstone), desire trees and surabhi cows, was surpassed. In the spiritual kingdom of Lord Kåñëa, named Goloka Våndävana, there are surabhi cows which give unlimited quantities of milk. There are desire trees from which anyone can take all kinds of fruits, as much as he may desire. The land is made of touchstone, which when touched to iron will transform it into gold. In other words, although in the spiritual kingdom, the abode of Kåñëa, everything is wonderfully opulent, still when Kåñëa was in Dvärakä His charity exceeded the opulence of Goloka Våndävana. Wherever Kåñëa is present, the limitless opulence of Goloka Våndävana is automatically present.

It is also stated that while Lord Kåñëa was living in Dvärakä, He expanded Himself into 16,108 forms, and each and every expansion resided in a palace with a queen. Not only was Kåñëa happily living with His queens in those palaces, but He was giving in charity from each palace an aggregate number of 13,054 cows completely decorated with nice clothing and ornaments. From each of Kåñëa's 16,108 palaces, these cows were given daily. This means that 13,054 multiplied by 16,108 cows were being given in charity by Kåñëa every day. No one can estimate the value of such a large number of cows given in charity, but that was the system of Kåñëa's daily affairs while He was reigning in Dvärakä.

30. Religious

A person who personally practices the tenets of religion as they are enjoined in the çästras and who also teaches others the same principles is called religious. Simply professing a kind of faith is not a sign of religiousness. One must act according to religious principles, and by his personal example he should teach others. Such a person is to be understood as religious.

When Kåñëa was present on this planet there was no irreligion. In this connection, Närada Muni once addressed Kåñëa jokingly: "My dear Lord of the cowherd boys, Your bulls [bulls are the representation of religion], while eating grass from the pasturing ground and moving on their four legs, have certainly eaten up all the grass of irreligion!" In other words, by the grace of Kåñëa, religious principles were so well cared for that hardly any irreligious activities could be found.

It is said that because Kåñëa was constantly performing various types of sacrifices and was inviting the demigods from the higher planetary systems, the demigods were almost always absent from their consorts. Therefore the wives of the demigods, regretting the absence of their husbands, began to pray for the appearance of Lord Buddha, the ninth incarnation of Kåñëa in the age of Kali. In other words, instead of being pleased that Lord Kåñëa had come, they began to pray for Lord Buddha, who is the ninth incarnation, because Lord Buddha stopped the ritualistic ceremonies and sacrifices recommended in the Vedas in order to discourage animal killing. The demigods' wives thought that if Lord Buddha appeared, all kinds of sacrifices would be stopped, and thus their husbands would not be invited to such ceremonies and thus would not be separated from them.

Sometimes it is enquired, "Why don't the demigods from higher planetary systems come to this earth planet nowadays?" The plain answer is that since Lord Buddha appeared and began to deprecate the performance of sacrifice in order to stop animal killing on this planet, the process of offering sacrifices has been stopped, and the demigods do not care to come here anymore.

NoD 22-1970: Qualities of Kåñëa Further Explained

Chapter Twenty-two

Qualities of Kåñëa Further Explained

31. Heroic

A person who is very enthusiastic in military activities and expert in releasing different kinds of weapons is called heroic.

Regarding Kåñëa's heroism in fighting, there is the following statement: "My dear killer of the enemy, just as the elephant while taking bath in the lake destroys all the lotus stems within the water by swinging its trunk, so simply by moving Your arms, which are compared to the trunks of elephants, You have killed so many lotus-like enemies."

Regarding Kåñëa's expertise in releasing weapons, when Jaräsandha, along with thirteen divisions of soldiers, attacked Kåñëa's army, they were unable to hurt even one soldier on the side of Kåñëa. This was due to Kåñëa's expert military training. This is unique in the history of military art.

32. Compassionate

A person who is unable to bear another's distress is called compassionate.

Kåñëa's compassion for distressed persons was exhibited when He released all of the kings imprisoned by Magadhendra. While dying, Grandfather Bhéñma prayed to Kåñëa and described Him as the sun which eradicated darkness. The kings who were imprisoned by Magadhendra were put into dark cells, and when Kåñëa appeared there, the darkness immediately disappeared, just as if the sun had risen. In other words, although Magadhendra was able to imprison so many kings, upon the appearance of Kåñëa they were all released. Kåñëa did this out of His sincere compassion for the kings.

Kåñëa's compassion was also exhibited when Grandfather Bhéñma was lying on the bed of arrows which had been shot through his body. While lying in this position, Bhéñma was very anxious to see Kåñëa, and thus Kåñëa appeared there. Upon seeing the pitiable condition of Bhéñma, Kåñëa began speaking with tears in His eyes. Not only was He shedding tears, but He also forgot Himself in His compassion. Therefore, instead of offering obeisances to Kåñëa directly, devotees offer obeisances to His compassionate nature. Actually, because Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, it is very difficult to approach Him. But the devotees, taking advantage of His compassionate nature, which is represented by Rädhäräëé, always pray to Rädhäräëé for Kåñëa's compassion.

33. Respectful

A person who shows adequate respect to a spiritual master, a brähmaëa and an old person is to be understood as being respectful.

When superior persons assembled before Kåñëa, Kåñëa first of all offered respect to His spiritual master, then to His father and then to His elder brother, Balaräma. In this way Lord Kåñëa, the lotus-eyed, was completely happy and pure at heart in all of His dealings.

34. Gentle

Any person who neither becomes impudent nor exhibits a puffed-up nature is called gentle.

The example of Kåñëa's gentle behavior was manifested when He was coming to the arena of the räja-süya sacrifice arranged by Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira, Kåñëa's older cousin. Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira knew that Kåñëa was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and he was attempting to get down from his chariot to receive Kåñëa. But before Yudhiñöhira could get down, Lord Kåñëa got down from His own chariot and immediately fell at the feet of the King. Even though Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, He never forgets to show social etiquette in His dealings.

35. Liberal

Any person who is by his natural behavior very mild is called liberal.

A statement by Uddhava after the Syamantaka jewel plundering confirms that Kåñëa is so kind and favorable that if a servitor is accused even of great offenses, Kåñëa does not take this into consideration. He simply considers the service that is rendered by His devotee.

36. Shy

A person who sometimes exhibits humility and bashfulness is called shy.

As described in the Lalita-mädhava, Kåñëa's shyness was manifested when He lifted Govardhan Hill by the little finger of His left hand. All of the gopés were observing Kåñëa's wonderful achievement, and Kåñëa was also smiling at seeing the gopés. When Kåñëa's glance went over the breasts of the gopés, His hand began to shake, and upon seeing His hand shake, all of the cowherd men underneath the hill became a little disturbed. Then there was a tumultuous roaring sound, and they all began to pray to Kåñëa for safety. At this time Lord Balaräma was smiling, thinking that these cowherd men had been frightened by the shaking of Govardhan Hill. But, seeing Balaräma smile, Kåñëa thought that Balaräma had understood His mind in observing the breasts of the gopés, and He immediately became bashful.

37. Protector of Surrendered Souls

Kåñëa is the protector of all surrendered souls.

Some enemy of Kåñëa's was enlivened with the thought that he needn't fear Kåñëa because if he simply surrendered unto Him, Kåñëa would give him all protection. Kåñëa is sometimes compared with the moon, which does not hesitate to distribute its soothing rays, even on the houses of the caëòälas and untouchables.

38. Happy

Any person who is always joyful and untouched by any distress is called happy.

As far as Kåñëa's enjoyment is concerned, it is stated that the ornaments which decorated the bodies of Kåñëa and His queens were beyond the dreams of Kubera, the treasurer of the heavenly kingdom. The constant dancing before the doors of Kåñëa's palaces was not to be imagined even by the demigods in the heavenly kingdom. In the heavenly kingdom, Indra always sees the dancing of the society girls. But even Indra could not imagine how beautiful were the dances being performed at the gates of Kåñëa's palaces. Gauré means white woman, and Lord Çiva's wife is called Gauré. The beautiful women residing within the palaces of Kåñëa were so much whiter than Gauré that they were compared to the moonshine, and they were constantly visible to Kåñëa. Therefore, no one can be enjoying more than Kåñëa. The conception of enjoyment is beautiful women, ornaments and riches. And all of these things were fabulously present in the palaces of Kåñëa, defeating even the imagination of Kubera, Lord Indra or Lord Çiva.

Not even a slight distress can touch Kåñëa. Once some of the gopés went to the place where the brähmaëas were performing sacrifices and said, "My dear wives of the brähmaëas, you must know that not even a slight smell of distress can touch Kåñëa. He knows no loss, He knows no defamation, He has no fear, He has no anxiety, and He does not know calamity. He is simply encircled by the dancers of Braja and is enjoying their company in the räsa dance."

39. Well-wisher of His Devotees

It is said of Kåñëa's devotees that if they offer even a little water or a tulasé leaf in devotion to Lord Viñëu, Lord Viñëu is so kind that He will sell Himself to them.

Kåñëa's favoritism towards His devotees was exhibited in His fight with Bhéñma. When Grandfather Bhéñma was lying at the point of death on the bed of arrows, Kåñëa was present before him, and Bhéñma was remembering how Kåñëa had been kind to him on the battlefield. Kåñëa had promised that in the Battle of Kurukñetra He would not even touch a weapon to help either side; He would remain neutral. Although Kåñëa was Arjuna's charioteer, He had promised that He would not help Arjuna by using any weapons. But one day Bhéñma, in order to nullify Kåñëa's promise, exhibited his fighting spirit so magnificently against Arjuna that Kåñëa was obliged to get down from His chariot. Taking up a broken chariot wheel, He ran toward Grandfather Bhéñma as a lion runs toward an elephant to kill it. Grandfather Bhéñma remembered this scene, and He later praised Kåñëa for His glorious favoritism towards His devotee, Arjuna, even at the risk of breaking His own promise.

40. Controlled by Love

Kåñëa becomes obliged to the loving spirit of the devotee and not exactly to the service rendered. No one can serve Kåñëa completely. He is so complete and self-sufficient that He has no need of any service from the devotee. It is the devotee's attitude of love and affection for Kåñëa that makes Him obliged. A very nice example of this obligatory behavior was manifested when Sudämä Vipra went to Kåñëa's palace. Sudämä Vipra had been a class friend of Kåñëa's, and due to his poverty he was induced by his wife to see Kåñëa to request some aid. When Sudämä Vipra reached Kåñëa's palace, Kåñëa received him very well, and both He and His wife washed the feet of Sudämä Vipra, showing respect to the brähmaëa. Remembering His loving affairs with Sudämä in their childhood, Kåñëa began to shed tears while receiving him.

Another instance of Kåñëa's obligation to His devotee is described in the Tenth Canto, 9th Chapter, 14th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam where Çukadeva Gosvämé tells King Parékñit: "My dear King, when Mother Yaçodä was perspiring, tired of trying to bind Kåñëa up with rope, Kåñëa agreed to allow her to bind Him." Kåñëa, as a child, was disturbing His mother by His naughty activities, and she wanted to bind Him up. Mother Yaçodä brought some rope from the house and tried to tie up the child, but she could not tie a knot due to the shortness of the rope. She tied together many ropes, but when she finished still the rope was too short. After a while she felt very tired and began to perspire. At that time Kåñëa agreed to be bound up by His mother. In other words, no one can bind Kåñëa by any means other than love. He is bound only by obligation to His devotees, because of their ecstatic love for Him.

41. All-auspicious

A person who is always engaged in auspicious welfare activities for everyone is known as all-auspicious.

After the disappearance of Lord Kåñëa from this planet, Uddhava began to remember the activities of the Lord and said, "Kåñëa satisfied all great sages by His wonderful pastimes. He demolished all of the demoniac activities of the cruel royal order, protected all pious men, and killed all cruel fighters on the battlefield. Therefore He is all-auspicious for all men."

42. Most Powerful

A person who can always put his enemy into calamities is called powerful.

When Kåñëa was present on this planet, just as the powerful sun drives all darkness to take shelter in caves, He drove away all of His enemies, who fled like owls to take shelter beyond His sight.

43. All-famous

A person who becomes well-known due to his spotless character is called famous.

It is stated that the diffusion of Kåñëa's fame is like the moonshine which turns darkness into light. In other words, if Kåñëa consciousness is preached all over the world, the darkness of ignorance and the anxiety of material existence will turn into the whiteness of purity, peacefulness and prosperity.

When the great sage Närada was chanting the glories of the Lord, the bluish line on the neck of Lord Çiva disappeared. Upon seeing this, Gauré, the wife of Lord Çiva, suspected Lord Çiva of being someone else disguised as her husband, and out of fear she immediately left his company. Upon hearing the chanting of Kåñëa's name, Lord Balaräma saw that his dress had become white, although He was generally accustomed to a bluish dress. And the cowherd girls saw all of the water of the Yamunä River turn into milk, so they began to churn it into butter. In other words, by the spreading of Kåñëa consciousness, or the glories of Kåñëa, everything became white and pure.

44. Popular

Any person who is very dear to people in general is called a popular man.

As for Kåñëa's popularity, there is a statement in the First Canto, 11th Chapter, 8th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam that deals with His returning home from the capital of Hastinäpur. While He had been absent from Dvärakä at the Battle of Kurukñetra, all the citizens of Dvärakä had become morose. Then, when He returned, the citizens joyfully received Him and said, "My dear Lord, while You were absent from the city, we passed our days in the darkness of night. As in the darkness of night every moment appears to be a long duration of time, so while You were gone every moment appeared to us like millions of years. Your separation is completely unbearable to us." This statement shows how popular Kåñëa was all over the country.

A similar incident occurred when Kåñëa entered the arena of sacrifice, arranged by King Kaàsa for His death. As soon as He entered the place, all the sages began to cry, "Jai! Jai! Jai!" (which means "Victory!") Kåñëa was a boy at that time, and all the sages offered their respectful blessings to Him. The demigods who were present also began to offer beautiful prayers to Kåñëa. And the ladies and girls present expressed their joy from all corners of the arena. In other words, there was no one in that particular place with whom Kåñëa was not very popular.

45. Partiality to Devotees

Although Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and is therefore not partial to anyone, it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that He has special attraction for a devotee who worships His name in love and affection. When Kåñëa was on this planet, one devotee expressed his feeling in this way: "My dear Lord, if You had not appeared on this planet, then the asuras [demons] and atheists would have surely created havoc against the activities of the devotees. I cannot imagine the magnitude of such devastation prevented by Your presence." From the very beginning of His appearance, Kåñëa was the greatest enemy of all demoniac persons, although Kåñëa's enmity toward the demons is actually comparable to His friendship with the devotees. This is because any demon who is killed by Kåñëa receives immediate salvation.

46. Very Attractive to All Women

Any person who has special qualifications becomes immediately very attractive to women.

A devotee made the following statement about the queens at Dvärakä: "How shall I describe the glories of the queens of Dvärakä who were personally engaged in the service of the Lord? The Lord is so great that simply by chanting His name all the great sages like Närada can enjoy transcendental bliss. So what can be said about those queens who were at every moment seeing the Lord and serving Him personally?" Kåñëa had 16,108 wives in Dvärakä, and each and every one of them was attracted to Kåñëa just as iron is attracted by a magnet. There is a statement by a devotee: "My dear Lord, You are just like a magnet, and all the damsels of Braja are just like iron: in whichever direction You are moving they are following You as iron is attracted by magnetic force."

47. All-worshipable

A person who is respected and worshiped by all kinds of human beings and demigods is called sarvärädhya or all-worshipable.

Kåñëa is worshiped not only by all living entities, including the great demigods like Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä, but also by Viñëu expansions (forms of Godhead) such as Baladeva and Çeña. Baladeva is a direct expansion of Kåñëa, but He still accepts Kåñëa as worshipable. When Kåñëa appeared in the arena of the räja-süya sacrifice organized by Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira, to all present, including great sages and demigods, Kåñëa became the cynosure, the center of attraction, and everyone offered Him their respects.

48. All-opulent

Kåñëa is full in all opulences—namely, strength, wealth, fame, beauty, knowledge, and renunciation. When Kåñëa was present in Dvärakä, His family, which is known as the Yadu dynasty, consisted of 560 million members. And all of these family members were very obedient and faithful to Kåñëa. There were more than 900,000 big palatial buildings there to house all the people, and everyone in them respected Kåñëa as the most worshipable. Devotees were astonished to see the opulence of Kåñëa.

This was verified by Bilvamaìgala Thäkur when in Kåñëa-karëämåta he addressed Kåñëa thus: "My dear Lord, what can I say about the opulence of Your Våndävana? Simply the ornaments on the legs of the damsels of Våndävana are more than cintämaëi, and their dresses are as good as the heavenly pärijäta flowers. And the cows exactly resemble the surabhi cows in the transcendental abode. Therefore Your opulence is just like an ocean that no one can measure."

49. All-honorable

A person who is chief among all important persons is called all-honorable.

When Kåñëa was living at Dvärakä, demigods like Lord Çiva, Lord Brahmä, Indra the King of heaven and many others used to come to visit Him. The doorkeeper, who had to manage the entrance of all these demigods, one very busy day said, "My dear Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva, please sit down on this bench and wait. My dear Indra, please desist from reading your prayers. This is creating a disturbance. Please wait silently. My dear Varuëa, please go away. And my dear demigods, do not waste your time uselessly. Kåñëa is very busy; He cannot see You!"

50. Supreme Controller

There are two kinds of controllers, or lords: one who is independent is called controller, and one whose orders cannot be neglected by anyone is called controller.

Regarding Kåñëa's complete independence and lordship, Çrémad-Bhägavatam says that although Käliya was a great offender, Kåñëa still favored him by marking his head with His lotus feet, whereas Lord Brahmä, although having prayed to Kåñëa with so many wonderful verses, still could not attract Him.

This contradictory treatment by Kåñëa is just befitting His position, because in all the Vedic literature He is described as the complete independent. In the beginning of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam the Lord is described as svaräö, which means completely independent. That is the position of the supreme absolute truth. The absolute truth is not only sentient, but He is also completely independent.

As for Kåñëa's orders not being neglected by anyone, in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Third Canto, 2nd Chapter, 21st verse, Uddhava tells Vidura: "Lord Kåñëa is the master of the three modes of material nature. He is the enjoyer of all opulences, and therefore there is no one equal to or greater than Him." All the great kings and emperors used to come before Him, offer their gifts and pay obeisances with their helmets at the feet of the Lord. One devotee said, "My dear Kåñëa, when You order Brahmä—'Now you may create the universe,'—and when You order Lord Çiva—'Now you dissolve this material manifestation,'—You are in this way creating and dissolving the material creation Yourself. Simply by Your orders and by Your partial representation as Viñëu, You are maintaining the universes. In this way, O Kåñëa, O enemy of Kaàsa, there are so many Brahmäs and Çivas who are simply carrying out Your orders."

51. Changeless

Kåñëa does not change His constitutional position, not even when He appears in this material world. Ordinary living entities have their constitutional spiritual positions covered. They appear in different bodies, and under the different bodily concepts of life they act. But Kåñëa does not change His body. He appears in His own body and is therefore not affected by the modes of material nature. In the First Canto, 11th Chapter, 24th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that the special prerogative of the supreme controller is that He is not at all affected by the modes of nature. The practical example of this is that devotees who are under the protection of the Lord are also not affected by material nature. To overcome the influence of material nature is very difficult, but the devotees or the saintly persons who are under the protection of the Lord are not affected. So what need is there to speak of the Lord Himself? To be more clear, although the Lord sometimes appears in this material world, He has nothing to do with the modes of material nature, and He acts with full independence in His transcendental position. This is the special quality of the Lord.

52. All-cognizant

Any person who can understand the feelings of all persons and incidents in all places at all times is called all-cognizant.

A nice example of the all-cognizant quality of the Lord is described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, First Canto, 15th Chapter, 11th verse, in connection with Durväsä Muni's visit to the house of the Päëòavas in the forest. Following a calculated plan, Duryodhana sent Durväsä Muni and his ten thousand disciples to be guests of the Päëòavas in the forest. Duryodhana arranged for Durväsä and his men to reach the place of the Päëòavas just when the Päëòavas' lunchtime was ended, so that the Päëòavas would be caught without sufficient means to feed such a large number of guests. Knowing Duryodhana's plan, Kåñëa came to the Päëòavas and asked their wife Draupadé if there were any remnants of food which she could offer to Him. Draupadé offered Him a container in which there was only a little fragment of some vegetable preparation, and Kåñëa at once ate it. At that moment all of the sages accompanying Durväsä were taking bath in the river, and when Kåñëa felt satisfaction from eating Draupadé's offering, they also felt satisfaction, and their hunger was gone. Because Durväsä and his men were unable to eat anything more, they went away without coming into the house of the Päëòavas. In this way the Päëòavas were saved from the wrath of Durväsä. Duryodhana had sent them because he knew that the Päëòavas would not be able to receive such a large number, and thus Durväsä would become angry, and the Päëòavas would be cursed. But Kåñëa saved them from this calamity by His trick and by His all-cognizant quality.

53. Ever-fresh

Kåñëa is always remembered, and His name is always chanted by millions of devotees, but the devotees never become saturated. Instead of becoming disinterested in thinking of Kåñëa and in chanting His holy name, the devotees get newer and newer impetus to continue the process. Therefore Kåñëa is ever-fresh. Not only Kåñëa Himself, but also Kåñëa's knowledge is ever-fresh. The Bhagavad-gétä, which was imparted 5,000 years ago, is still being read repeatedly by many, many men, and still new light is always being found in it. Therefore, Kåñëa and His name, fame, qualities—and everything in relationship with Him—is ever-fresh.

All the queens at Dvärakä were goddesses of fortune. It is said in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, First Canto, 11th Chapter, 29th verse, that the goddesses of fortune are very fickle and restless, so no one can consistently captivate them. Thus one's luck will always change sometime. Yet the goddesses of fortune could not leave Kåñëa for even a moment when they were residing with Him at Dvärakä. This means that Kåñëa's attraction is ever-fresh. Even the goddesses of fortune cannot leave His company.

Regarding Kåñëa's attractive features being ever-fresh, there is a statement by Rädhäräëé in the Lalita-mädhava, in which Kåñëa is compared with the greatest sculptor because He is expert in chisling at the chastity of women. In other words, although chaste women may follow the rules and regulations of Vedic principles to become ever-faithful to their husbands, Kåñëa is able to break their stone-like chastity with the chisel of His beauty. Most of the girl friends of Kåñëa were married, but because Kåñëa was their friend before their marriages, they could not forget His attractive features, which were always fascinating to them, even after their marriages.

54. Sac-cid-änanda-vigraha

This means that Kåñëa's transcendental body is eternal, full of knowledge and bliss. Sat means ever-existing for all time and in all places; in other words, all-pervading in time and space. Cit means full of knowledge. Kåñëa has nothing to learn from anyone. He is independently full of all knowledge. Änanda means the reservoir of all pleasure. The impersonalists are seeking to merge into the Brahman effulgence of eternity and knowledge, but the major portion of the absolute pleasure which is in Kåñëa is avoided by them. One can enjoy the transcendental blissfulness of merging into the Brahman effulgence after being freed from the contamination of material illusion, false identification, attachment, detachment and material absorption. These are the preliminary qualifications of a person who can realize Brahman. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that one has to become full of joyfulness; this is not exactly joyfulness, but a sense of freedom from all anxieties. Freedom from all anxieties may be the first principle of joyfulness, but it is not actual joyfulness. Those who realize the self, or become brahma-bhüta, are only preparing themselves for the platform of joyfulness. That joyfulness can be actually achieved only when one comes into contact with Kåñëa. Kåñëa consciousness is so complete that it includes the transcendental pleasure derived from impersonal or Brahman realization. Even the impersonalist will become attracted to the personal form of Kåñëa, known as Çyämasundara.

It is confirmed by the statement of Brahma-saàhitä that the Brahman effulgence is the bodily ray of Kåñëa; the Brahman effulgence is simply an exhibition of the energy of Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the source of the Brahman effulgence, as He Himself confirms in the Bhagavad-gétä. From this we can conclude that the impersonal feature of the absolute truth is not the ultimate end; Kåñëa is the ultimate end of the absolute truth.

The Vaiñëava schools therefore never try to merge into the Brahman effulgence in their pursuit of spiritual perfection. They accept Kåñëa as the ultimate goal of self realization. Therefore Kåñëa is called parambrahman (the supreme Brahman) or parameçvara (the supreme controller). Çré Yämunäcärya has prayed as follows: "My dear Lord, I know that the gigantic universe and gigantic space and time within the universe are covered by the ten layers of the material elements, each layer ten times larger than the previous one. The three material modes of nature, the Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu, the Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu and the Mahä-Viñëu, and beyond them the spiritual sky and its spiritual planets, known as Vaikuëöhas, and the Brahman effulgence in that spiritual sky—all of these taken together are nothing but a small exhibition of Your potency."

55. Possessing All Mystic Perfections

There are many standards of perfection. The highest material perfections, obtained by perfect yogés, are listed as eight: to become the smallest of the small, to become the greatest of the great, etc. All of these material perfections, as well as all spiritual perfections, can be found fully in Kåñëa's personality.

56. Kåñëa's Inconceivable Potencies

Kåñëa is present everywhere, not only within the universe, not only within the heart of all living entities, but also within every atom. In the prayers of Queen Kunté we find mention of this inconceivable potency of Kåñëa. While Kåñëa was talking with Kunté, He simultaneously entered the womb of Uttarä, who was in danger due to the atomic weapon of Açvatthämä. Kåñëa can illusion even Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva, and He can protect all surrendered devotees from the reaction of sinful activities. These are some of the examples of His inconceivable potencies.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé therefore offers his obeisances unto Kåñëa by saying, "Kåñëa, who is present as a human being, has as His mere shadow the whole material nature. He has expanded Himself into so many cows, calves and cowherd boys, and He has again manifested Himself in all of them as the four-handed Näräyaëa. He has taught millions of Brahmäs self realization, and thus He is worshipable not only by the heads of all universes, but by everyone else also. Therefore let me always accept Him as the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

When Indra was defeated by Kåñëa in the matter of taking the pärijäta plant from heaven, Närada met Indra and criticized him: "O Indra, great King of heaven, Kåñëa has already defeated Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva. So what can be said of an insignificant demigod like you?" Närada Muni, of course, was criticizing Indra jokingly, and Indra enjoyed it. In Närada's statement it is confirmed that Kåñëa was able to illusion even Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva as well as Indra. So there is no question of Kåñëa's power to do the same to lesser living entities.

A description of Kåñëa's power in minimizing the sufferings of sinful reactions is given in Brahma-saàhitä as follows: "Beginning from the great King of heaven down to the ant, everyone is undergoing the reactions of past deeds. But a devotee of Kåñëa is relieved from such reactions by the grace of Kåñëa." This was clearly proved when Kåñëa went to the place of Yamaräja, the Lord of death, to reclaim the dead sons of His teacher. Kåñëa's teacher had requested Him to bring back his dead sons, and to do so Kåñëa went to the place of Yamaräja to claim all of those souls who had been brought there by Yamaräja and were being kept under his control. Kåñëa immediately ordered Yamaräja, "Be benefitted by My order and return those souls unto Me!" The purport of this incident is that even a person who is under the regulative principles of the laws of nature, and is therefore punishable by Yamaräja under these laws, can be granted complete immunity by the grace of Kåñëa.

Kåñëa's inconceivable potencies have been described by Çukadeva Gosvämé as follows: "Kåñëa is bewildering my intelligence because, although He is unborn, He has appeared as the son of Nanda Mahäräj. He is all-pervading, but still He is held on the lap of Yaçodä. In spite of His being all-pervasive, He has become limited by the love of Yaçodä. Although He has innumerable forms, still He is moving as one Kåñëa before His father and mother, Nanda and Yaçodä. In the Brahma-saàhitä also it is said that although Kåñëa is eternally living in Goloka Våndävana, His transcendental abode, He is still present everywhere, even within the atoms.

57. Kåñëa's Body Generates Innumerable Universes

In the Tenth Canto, 14th Chapter, 11th verse, of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Lord Brahmä says, "My dear Lord, false ego, intelligence, mind, sky, air, fire, water and earth are the material ingredients of this universe, which can be compared to a gigantic pot. In that gigantic pot my body is of insignificant measurement, and even though one of the many universes is created by me, innumerable universes are coming and going from the pores of Your body, just as atomic particles are seen flickering in the sunlight. I think I am very, very insignificant before You, and I am therefore begging Your pardon. Please be merciful toward me."

If one takes account of only one universe, he will find so many combinations of wonderful things within, because there are innumerable planets, innumerable residences and places of demigods. The length and breadth of the universe is 400 million miles by 400 million miles, and it is infested with many unfathomable regions known as pätälas, or downward planetary systems. Although Kåñëa is the origin of all this, He can always be seen in Våndävana, exhibiting His inconceivable potencies. So who can adequately worship such an all-powerful Lord, possessed of such inconceivable energy?

58. The Original Source of All Incarnations

Jayadeva Gosvämé, in his Géta-govinda, has sung as follows: "The Lord has saved the Vedas in His form as a fish, and He has borne the whole universe on His back in the form of a tortoise. He has picked up this earthly planet from the water in the form of a boar. He has killed Hiraëyakaçipu in the form of Nåsiàha. He has cheated Mahäräj Bali in the form of Vämana. He has annihilated all the dynasties of the kñatriyas in the form of Paraçuräma. He has killed all the demons in the form of Lord Räma. He has accepted the great plow in the form of Balaräma. He has annihilated all the atheistic persons in the form of Kalki. And He has saved all the poor animals in the form of Lord Buddha."* These are some of the descriptions of the incarnations emanating from Kåñëa, and from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is understood that innumerable incarnations are always coming out from the body of Kåñëa, just like waves in the ocean. No one can even count how many waves there are, and similarly no one can count how many incarnations are coming from the Lord's body.

59. Kåñëa Gives Salvation to the Enemies that He Kills

Another name for salvation is apavarga. Apavarga is the opposite of pavarga, or the various miserable conditions of material existence. Pavarga consists of the combinations of five letters: pa, pha, ba, bha, and ma. These letters are the first letters of the words for five different conditions as described below. The first letter, pa, comes from the word paräbhava, which means "defeat." In this material struggle for existence, we are simply meeting defeat. Actually, we have to conquer birth, death, disease and old age, and because there is no possibility of overcoming all these miserable conditions, due to the illusion of mäyä, we are simply meeting with paräbhava, or defeat. The next letter, pha, is taken from the word phenila. Phenila is the foam which is found on the mouth when one is very tired (as is commonly observed with horses). The letter ba comes from the word bandha, or bondage. Bha is taken from the word bhéti, or fearfulness. Ma is taken from the word måti, or death. So the word pavarga signifies our struggle for existence and our meeting with defeat, exhaustion, bondage, fearfulness and, at last, death. Apavarga means that which can nullify all of these material conditions. Kåñëa is said to be the giver of apavarga, the path of liberation.

For the impersonalist and the enemies of Kåñëa, liberation means to merge into the supreme. The demons and the impersonalists do not care for Kåñëa, but Kåñëa is so kind that He gives this liberation even to His enemies and to the impersonalists. There is the following statement in this connection: "O Muräri [Kåñëa]! How wonderful it is that although the demons, who were always envious of the demigods, have failed to penetrate Your military phalanx, they have penetrated the region of mitra, the sun globe." The word mitra is used metaphorically. Mitra means the sun globe, and mitra also means friend. The demons who opposed Kåñëa as enemies wanted to penetrate His military phalanx; but instead of doing this, they died in battle, and the result was that they penetrated the planet of Mitra, or the sun planet. In other words, they entered into the Brahman effulgence. The example of the sun planet is given here because the sun is ever-illuminating, like the spiritual sky, where there are innumerable illuminating Vaikuëöha planets. The enemies of Kåñëa were killed, and instead of penetrating Kåñëa's phalanx, they entered into the friendly atmosphere of the spiritual effulgence. That is the mercy of Kåñëa, and therefore He is known as the deliverer of His enemies also.

60. The Attractor of Liberated Souls

There are many examples of how Kåñëa attracted even great liberated souls like Çukadeva Gosvämé and the Kumäras. In this connection the following statement was given by the Kumäras: "How wonderful it is that although we are completely liberated, free from desire and situated at the stage of paramahaàsa, we are still aspiring to taste the pastimes of Rädhä and Kåñëa.

61. Performer of Wonderful Activities

In the Båhad-Vämana Puräëa, the Lord says, "Although I have many fascinating pastimes, whenever I think of the räsa-lélä, which I perform with the gopés, I become eager to have it again."

One devotee has said, "I know about Näräyaëa, the husband of the goddess of fortune, and I also know about many other incarnations of the Lord. Certainly all the pastimes of such incarnations are exciting to my mind, but still, the pastimes of the räsa-lélä performed by Lord Kåñëa Himself are wonderfully increasing my transcendental pleasure."

In the Tenth Canto, 31st Chapter, 15th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the gopés lament: "My dear Kåñëa, during the daytime when You go out into the forest of Våndävana with Your cows, we consider one moment to be twelve years, and it is very difficult for us to pass the time. And again when You come back at the end of the day, by seeing Your beautiful face we are so much attracted that we are unable to stop looking upon You constantly. At these times, when there is occasional blinking of our eyelids, we condemn the creator, Lord Brahmä, as a dunce, because he does not know how to make perfect eyes!" In other words, the gopés were disturbed by the blinking of their eyes because for the moment that their eyes were closed they could not see Kåñëa. This means that the gopés' love for Kåñëa was so great and ecstatic that they were disturbed by even His momentary absence. And when they saw Kåñëa, they were also disturbed. This is a paradox.

One gopé, expressing herself to Kåñëa, says: "When we meet You at night, we consider the duration of night to be very small. And why speak of only this night? Even if we had a night of Brahmä* we would consider it a very short time!" We get an idea of Brahmä's day from the following statement of the Bhagavad-gétä: "By human calculation, a thousand yuga cycles taken together is Brahmä's one day. And such also is the duration of his night." (Bg. 8.17) The gopés said that even if they could have that duration of night, it would still not be sufficient for their meeting with Kåñëa.

62. Kåñëa's Attractive Flute

In the Tenth Canto, 35th Chapter, 8th verse of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the gopés tell Mother Yaçodä, "When your son plays on His flute, Lord Çiva, Lord Brahmä and Indra—although they are supposed to be the greatest learned scholars and personalities—all become bewildered. Although they are all very great personalities, by hearing the sound of Kåñëa's flute they humbly bow down and become grave from studying the sound vibrated."

In his book Vidagdha-mädhava, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé thus describes the vibration of Kåñëa's flute: "The sound vibration created by the flute of Kåñëa wonderfully stopped Lord Çiva from playing his òiëòima drum, and the same flute has caused great sages like the four Kumäras to become disturbed in their meditation. It has caused Lord Brahmä, who was sitting on the lotus flower for the creative function, to become astonished. And Anantadeva, who was calmly holding all the planets on his hood, was moving in this way and that due to the transcendental vibration from Kåñëa's flute, which penetrated through the covering of this universe and reached to the spiritual sky."

63. Kåñëa is Surrounded by Loving Devotees

When we speak of Kåñëa, Kåñëa is not alone. Kåñëa means His name, His qualities, His fame, His friends, His paraphernalia, His entourage—all of these are included. When we speak of a king, it is to be understood that he is surrounded by ministers, secretaries, military commanders and many other people. Similarly, Kåñëa is not impersonal. In His Våndävana lélä especially, He is surrounded by the gopés, the cowherd boys, His father, His mother and all the inhabitants of Våndävana.

64. Kåñëa's Exquisite Beauty

In the Third Canto, 2nd Chapter, 12th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Uddhava tells Vidura, "My dear sir, Kåñëa's form was most wonderful when He appeared on this planet and exhibited the potency of His internal energy. His wonderfully attractive form was present during His pastimes on this planet, and by His internal potency He exhibited His opulences, which are striking to everyone. His personal beauty was so great that there was no necessity for His wearing ornaments on His body. In fact, instead of the ornaments beautifying Kåñëa, Kåñëa's beauty enhanced the ornaments."

Regarding the attractiveness of Kåñëa's bodily beauty and the sound vibration of His flute, in the Tenth Canto, 29th Chapter, 37th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the gopés address Kåñëa as follows: "Although our attitude towards You resembles loving affairs with a paramour, we cannot but wonder at how no woman can maintain her chastity upon hearing the vibration from Your flute. And not only women, but even stronghearted men are subject to falling down from their position at the sound of Your flute. In fact, we have seen that in Våndävana even the cows, the deer, the birds, the trees—everyone—has been enchanted by the sweet vibration of Your flute and the fascinating beauty of Your person."

In Rüpa Gosvämé's Lalita-mädhava, it is said: "One day Kåñëa happened to see the shadow of His beautiful form reflected on the jeweled foreground. Upon seeing this bodily reflection, He expressed His feelings: 'How wonderful it is that I have never seen such a beautiful form! Although it is My own form, still, like Rädhäräëé, I am trying to embrace this form and enjoy celestial bliss.' " This statement shows how Kåñëa and His shadow reflection are one and the same. There is no difference between Kåñëa and His shadow reflection, nor between Kåñëa and His picture. That is the transcendental position of Kåñëa.

The above statements describe some of the wonderful reservoirs of pleasure within Kåñëa, as well as the transcendental qualities of His personality. The transcendental qualities of Kåñëa are compared to the ocean: no one can estimate the length and breadth of the ocean. But, as one can understand the ocean's contents simply by testing one drop of it, so these statements will give us some understanding of Kåñëa's transcendental position and qualities.

In the Tenth Canto, 14th Chapter, 7th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Lord Brahmä says, "My dear Lord, the inconceivable qualities, beauties and activities which You have revealed by Your presence on this planet cannot be calculated by any material measurement. If one even tries to imagine that 'Kåñna may be like this,' that is also impossible. The day may come when the material scientist, after many, many births or after many, many years, will be able to estimate the atomic constitution of the whole world, or he may be able to count the atomic fragments that permeate the sky, or he may even give an estimate of all the atoms within the universe, but still he will never be able to count the transcendental qualities in Your reservoir of transcendental bliss."

NoD 23-1970: Kåñëa's Personality

Chapter Twenty-three

Kåñëa's Personality

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé states that although Lord Kåñëa is the reservoir of unlimited pleasure and the greatest leader of all, He is still dependent upon His devotees in three ways. According to the emotional status of the devotee, the Supreme Personality of Godhead is appreciated in three ways: as the most perfect, as very perfect and as perfect. When He exhibits Himself in fullness, He is appreciated by great learned scholars as most perfect. When He exhibits Himself in lesser degrees, He is called very perfect. And when He exhibits still less, He is called perfect. This means that Kåñëa is appreciated for three degrees of perfection. These three degrees of perfection are especially exhibited as follows: when He is in Goloka Våndävana His transcendental qualities are exhibited as most perfect, when He is in Dvärakä He exhibits His qualities as very perfect, and when He is in Mathurä He exhibits His qualities as perfect.

Kåñëa's personality is analyzed as dhérodätta, dhéra-lalita, dhéra-praçänta and dhéroddhata. If one asks how a personality can be beheld in four quite opposing ways, the answer is that the Lord is the reservoir of all transcendental qualities and activities. Therefore, His different aspects can be analyzed according to the exhibition of His limitless variety of pastimes, and as such there is no contradiction.

Dhérodätta

A dhérodätta is a person who is naturally very grave, gentle, forgiving, merciful, determined, humble, highly qualified, chivalrous and bodily attractive.

In this connection, the following statement given by Indra, the King of heaven, is very significant: "My dear Lord, I admit that I have committed great offenses unto You, but I cannot express my feelings of regret, being bewildered at seeing Your extraordinary chivalrous spirit, Your endeavor to protect Your devotees, Your determination, Your steadiness in lifting the great Hill of Govardhana, Your beautiful bodily features and Your astonishing characteristic of being pleased simply by accepting the prayers of Your devotees and offenders."

The above statement by the King of heaven is an exact corroboration of Kåñëa's being dhérodätta. Many learned scholars have agreed to also accept Lord Rämacandra as dhérodätta, but all of Lord Rämacandra's qualities are also included in the character of Lord Kåñëa.

Dhéra-lalita

A person is called dhéra-lalita if he is naturally very funny, always in full youthfulness, expert in joking, and free from all anxieties. Such a dhéra-lalita personality is generally found to be domesticated and very submissive to his lover. This dhéra-lalita trait in the personality of Kåñëa is described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam where Yajïapatné, the wife of one of the brähmaëas who were performing sacrifices in Våndävana, tells her friends: "One day Çrématé Rädhäräëé, accompanied by Her associates, was taking rest in Her garden, and at that time Lord Çré Kåñëa arrived in that assembly. After sitting down, He began to narrate very impudently about His previous night's pastimes with Rädhäräëé. While He was speaking in that way, Rädhäräëé became very embarrassed. She was feeling ashamed and was absorbed in thought, and Kåñëa took the opportunity to mark Her breasts with different kinds of tilaka. Kåñëa proved Himself to be very expert in that art." In this way Kåñëa, as dhéra-lalita, was enjoying His youthful proclivities in the company of the gopés.

Generally, those who are expert in writing drama choose to call Cupid the ideal dhéra-lalita, but we can more perfectly find in the personality of Kåñëa all the characteristics of dhéra-lalita.

Dhéra-praçänta

A person who is very peaceful, forebearing, considerate and obliging is called dhéra-praçänta. This dhéra-praçänta trait of Kåñëa was exhibited in His dealings with the Päëòavas. On account of the Päëòavas' faithful devotion to the Lord, He agreed to become their charioteer, their advisor, their friend, their messenger and sometimes their bodyguard. Such is an example of the result of devotional service towards Viñëu. When Kåñëa was speaking to Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira about religious principles, He demonstrated Himself to be a great learned scholar, but because He accepted the position of younger cousin to Yudhiñöhira, He was speaking in a very gentle tone which enhanced His beautiful bodily features. The movements of His eyes and the mode of His speech proved that He was very, very expert in giving moral instruction. Sometimes, Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira is also accepted by learned scholars as dhéra-praçänta.

Dhéroddhata

A person who is very envious, proud, easily angered, restless and complacent is called dhéroddhata by learned scholars. Such qualities were visible in the character of Lord Kåñëa because, when He was writing a letter to Kälayavana, Kåñëa addressed him as a sinful frog. In His letter Kåñëa advised Kälayavana that he should immediately go and find some dark well for his residence, because there was a black snake named Kåñëa who was very eager to devour all such sinful frogs. Kåñëa reminded Kälayavana that He could turn all the universes to ashes simply by looking at them.

The above statement by Kåñëa seems apparently to be of an envious nature, but according to different pastimes, places and times this quality is accepted as a great characteristic. Kåñëa's dhéroddhata qualities have been accepted as great because Kåñëa uses them only to protect His devotees. In other words, even undesirable traits may also be used in the exchange of devotional service.

Sometimes Bhéma, the second brother of the Päëòavas, is also described as dhéroddhata.

Once, while fighting with a demon who was appearing as a deer, Kåñëa challenged him in this way: "I have come before you as a great elephant named Kåñëa. You must leave the battlefield, accepting defeat, or else there is death awaiting you." This challenging spirit of Kåñëa's is not contradictory to His sublime character because, as the Supreme Being, everything is possible in His character.

There is a nice statement in the Kürma Puräëa about these contradictory traits of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is stated there that the Supreme Person is neither very fat nor very thin; He is always transcendental to material qualities, and yet His bodily luster is blackish. His eyes are reddish, He is all-powerful, and He is equipped with all different kinds of opulences. Contradictory traits in Kåñëa's person are not at all surprising: one should not consider the characteristics of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, to be actually contradictory. One should try to understand the traits of Kåñëa from authorities and try to understand how these characteristics are employed by the supreme will of the Lord.

In the Mahä-varäha Puräëa it is confirmed that the transcendental bodies of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and His expansions are all existing eternally. Such bodies are never material and are completely spiritual and full of knowledge. They are reservoirs of all transcendental qualities. In the Vaiñëava Tantra there is a statement that the Personality of Godhead and His expanded bodies are always free from the eighteen kinds of material contaminations,* because such bodies are always full of knowledge, bliss and eternity.

Regarding all of the above-mentioned statements, it is understood that the Mahä-Viñëu is the source of all incarnations in the material world. But because of His greater extraordinary opulence, we can understand that the son of Nanda Mahäräj is the source of the Mahä-Viñëu also. This is confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä, wherein it is stated: "Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto Govinda, whose partial representation is the Mahä-Viñëu." The gigantic form of the Mahä-Viñëu is the source of generation for innumerable universes. Innumerable universes are coming out of His exhaling breath, and the same universes are going back in with His inhaling breath. This Mahä-Viñëu is also a plenary portion of a portion of Kåñëa.

NoD 24-1970: Further Traits of Çré Kåñëa

Chapter Twenty-four

Further Traits of Çré Kåñëa

After describing the different opulences of Kåñëa, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé tries to further describe the transcendental beauties and qualities of the Lord as: decorated, enjoying, pleasing, dependable, steady and predominating. He is also described as a meticulous dresser and a magnanimous personality. These are generally considered to be the qualities of great personalities.

Decorated

It is said that a person is great if he is decorated with the qualities of being very merciful toward the unfortunate, very powerful, superior, chivalrous, enthusiastic, expert and truthful. These decorations were manifested in the character of Kåñëa during His Govardhana-lélä. At that time the whole tract of land in Våndävana was being disturbed by the rains sent by Indra, as described elsewhere above. At first Kåñëa thought, "Let me retaliate against this vengeance of Indra by destroying his heavenly kingdom," but later on, when He thought of the insignificance of the King of heaven, Kåñëa changed His mind and felt merciful toward Indra. No one is able to tolerate the wrath of Kåñëa, so instead of retaliating against Indra, He simply showed His compassion for His friends in Våndävana by lifting the whole of Govardhan Hill to protect them.

Enjoying

When a person is seen to be always happy and is accustomed to speak smilingly, he is considered to be in the mode of enjoyment. This trait was found in Kåñëa when He appeared at the sacrificial arena of King Kaàsa. It is described that the lotus-eyed Kåñëa entered amongst the wrestlers without being impolite to them, glanced over them with determination, and seemed to them just like an elephant attacking some plants. Even while speaking to them, Kåñëa was still smiling, and in this way He stood valiantly upon the wrestling dais.

Pleasing

When one's characteristics are very sweet and desirable, his personality is called pleasing. An example of Kåñëa's pleasing nature is thus described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam: "One day while Kåñëa was awaiting the arrival of Çrématé Rädhäräëé by the bank of the Yamunä, He began to make a garland of kadamba flowers. In the meantime, Çrématé Rädhäräëé appeared there, and at that time Muräri [Kåñëa], the enemy of Mura, glanced over Rädhäräëé very sweetly."

Dependable

Any person who is reliable in all circumstances is called dependable. In this connection Rüpa Gosvämé says that even the demons were relying upon the dependability of Kåñëa because they were confident that Kåñëa would never attack them without due cause. Therefore, with faith and confidence, they used to live with their doors wide open. And the demigods, although afraid of the demons, were confident of the protection of Kåñëa. Therefore, even in the midst of danger they were engaged in sportive activities. Persons who had never undergone the reformatory ritualistic ceremonies of the Vedas were confident that Kåñëa would accept only faith and devotion, and so they were engaged in Kåñëa consciousness and were freed from all anxieties. In other words, all kinds of men, from the demigods down to the uncultured, can rely on the causeless mercy of the Supreme Lord.

Steady

A person who is not disturbed even in a situation of reverses is called steady. This steadiness was observed in Kåñëa in connection with His killing the demon known as Bäëa. The Bäëa demon had many hands, and Kåñëa was cutting off these hands one after another. This Bäëa was a great devotee of Lord Çiva and the goddess Durgä. Thus, when Bäëa was being killed, Lord Çiva and Durgä became very furious at Kåñëa. But Kåñëa did not care for them.

Predominating

A person who can affect the mind of everyone is called predominating. As far as Kåñëa's predomination is concerned, in the Tenth Canto, 43rd Chapter, 14th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Kåñëa is described thus by Çukadeva Gosvämé to King Parékñit: "My dear King, Kåñëa is a thunderbolt to the wrestlers; to the common man He is the most beautiful human being; to the young girls He is just like Cupid; to the cowherd men and women He is the most intimate relative; to the impious kings He is the supreme ruler; to His parents, Nanda and Yaçodä, He is just a baby; to Kaàsa, the King of Bhoja, He is death personified; to the dull and stupid He is just like a stone; to the yogés He is the supreme absolute truth; and to the Våñëis He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In such a predominating position Kåñëa appeared in that arena along with His older brother Balaräma." When Kåñëa, the reservoir of all mellows, was present in the arena of Kaàsa, He appeared differently to the different persons who were related to Him in different mellows. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that He appears to every person according to one's relationship with Him.

Sometimes learned scholars describe "predominating" to mean a person intolerant of being neglected. This peculiarity in Kåñëa was visible when Kaàsa was insulting Mahäräj Nanda, and Vasudeva asking Kåñëa's assistance in killing Kaàsa. Kåñëa was glancing over Kaàsa with longing eyes, just like a prostitute, and He was just preparing to jump at the King.

Meticulous Dresser

A person who is very fond of dressing Himself is called lalita, or a meticulous dresser. This characteristic was found in Kåñëa in two ways: sometimes He used to decorate Çrématé Rädhäräëé with various marks, and sometimes, when He was preparing to kill demons like Ariñöäsura, He would take care to arrange His belt very nicely.

Magnanimous

Persons who can give themselves to anyone are called magnanimous. No one could be more magnanimous than Kåñëa because He is always prepared to give Himself completely to His devotee. Even to one who is not a devotee, Kåñëa in His form of Lord Caitanya is prepared to give Himself and to grant deliverance.

Although Kåñëa is independent of everyone, out of His causeless mercy He is dependent upon Garga Åñi for religious instruction; for learning the military art He is dependent upon Sätyaki; and for good counsel He is dependent upon His friend, Uddhava.

NoD 25-1970: Devotees of Kåñëa

Chapter Twenty-five

Devotees of Kåñëa

A person who is always absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness is called a devotee of Kåñëa. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that all the transcendental qualities discussed above are also found in the devotees of Kåñëa. The devotees of Kåñëa can be classified into two groups: those who are cultivating devotional service in order to enter into the transcendental kingdom, and those who are already in the perfectional stage of devotional service.

A person who has attained the stage of attraction for Kåñëa and who is not freed from the material impasse, but who has qualified himself to enter into the kingdom of God, is called sädhaka. Sädhaka means one who is cultivating devotion in Kåñëa consciousness. The description of such a devotee is found in the Eleventh Canto, 2nd Chapter, 45th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. It is said there that a person who has unflinching faith in and love for the Personality of Godhead, who is in friendship with devotees of Kåñëa, and who is very merciful to the ignorant, raising them to the standard of devotional service, and who is uninterested in nondevotees, is considered to be situated in the position of cultivating devotional service.

When one is found shedding tears by hearing of the pastimes of the Lord, it is to be understood that the blazing fire of material existence will be extinguished by such watering. When there is shivering of the body and the hairs of the body stand up, it is to be understood that the devotee is nearing perfection. An example of a sädhaka cultivating devotional service is Bilvamaìgala Thäkur.

When a person is never tired of executing devotional service and is always engaged in Kåñëa conscious activities, constantly relishing the transcendental mellows in relationship with Kåñëa, the devotee is called perfect. This perfectional stage can be achieved in two ways: one may achieve this stage of perfection by gradual progress in devotional service, or one may become perfect by the causeless mercy of Kåñëa, even though he has not executed all the details of devotional service. There is the following nice statement in the Third Canto, 15th Chapter, 25th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam describing a devotee who achieves perfection by regularly executing devotional service: A person who is freed from the false egotism of material existence, or an advanced mystic, is eligible to enter into the kingdom of God known as Vaikuëöha. Such a mystic becomes so joyful by constant execution of the regulative principles of devotional service that he thereby achieves the special favor of the Supreme Lord. Yamaräja, the mighty superintendent of death, is afraid to go near such a devotee; so we can imagine the potency of advanced devotional service, especially when devotees sit together and engage in talking of the pastimes of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Those devotees express their feelings in such a way that they automatically melt with ecstasy, and many transcendental symptoms become manifested in their bodies. Anyone desiring advancement in devotional service must follow in the footsteps of such devotees.

Prahläd Mahäräj said that no one can attain the perfectional stage of devotional service without bowing down before exalted devotees. Learned sages like Märkaëòeya Åñi attained perfection in devotional service simply by executing such regulative principles of service.

A person's achieving perfection in devotional service simply by the causeless mercy of the Lord is explained in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam in connection with the brähmaëas and their wives who were engaged in performing yajïa, or sacrifice. When the wives of the brähmaëas were favored by Lord Kåñëa and immediately attained the ecstasy of love of Godhead, their husbands began to say, "How wonderful it is that although these women have undertaken no reformatory performances such as accepting the sacred thread, have not resided in the monastaries of the spiritual master, have not observed the strict principles of celibacy, have not undergone any austerities, nor philosophized upon the observance of all ritualistic ceremonies—they still have attained the favor of Kåñëa, which is aspired after even by great mystics! How wonderful it is that these women have attained such perfection, while we, although brähmaëas who have performed all the reformatory activities, cannot attain to this advanced stage!"

There is a similar statement by Närada, addressed to Çukadeva Gosvämé: "My dear Çukadeva Gosvämé, you never took the trouble to reside under the care of a spiritual master, and yet you have attained such a great status of transcendental knowledge. You never took the trouble to undergo severe austerities, and still, how wonderful it is that you have been situated in the most perfect stage of love of Godhead."

Çukadeva Gosvämé and the wives of the brähmaëas who were performing yajïa are vivid examples of devotees who achieved the perfectional stage of devotional service by the grace of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Eternal Perfection

Persons who have achieved eternal, blissful life exactly on the level of Çré Kåñëa, and who are able to attract Lord Kåñëa by their transcendental loving service, are called eternally perfect. The technical name is nitya-siddha. There are two classes of living entities—namely, nitya-siddha and nitya-baddha. The distinction is that the nitya-siddhas are eternally Kåñëa conscious without any forgetfulness, whereas the nitya-baddhas, or eternally conditioned souls, are forgetful of their relationship with Kåñëa.

The position of the nitya-siddhas is explained in the Padma Puräëa in connection with the narration of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and Satyabhämädevé. The Lord tells Satyabhämä: "My dear Satyabhämädevé, I have descended to this earthly planet by the request of Lord Brahmä and other demigods. Those who are born into this family of Yadu are all My eternal associates. My dear wife, you should not consider that My associates are ever separated from Me; they are My personal expansions, and as such, you must know that they are almost as powerful as I am. Because of their transcendental qualities, they are very, very dear to Me, as I am very, very dear to them." Anyone who becomes exhilarated by hearing of the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa when He was present on this earth with His associates is to be understood as nitya-siddha, eternally perfect.

In the Tenth Canto, 14th Chapter, 30th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is the statement: "How wonderful are the fortunate residents of Våndävana, such as Nanda and the other cowherd men. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, the supreme Brahman, has actually become their intimate friend!"

A similar statement is there in the Tenth Canto, 26th Chapter, 10th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. When Lord Kåñëa lifted Govardhan Hill, the cowherd men, under the protection of Lord Kåñëa, became struck with wonder and went to Nanda Mahäräj and inquired from him, "My dear Nanda Mahäräj, how is it that we are so intensely attached to Kåñëa, and Kåñëa is also so affectionately attached to us? Does it mean that He is the supersoul of everyone?"

All of the residents of Våndävana and Dvärakä—namely the cowherd men and the members of the Yadu family—are eternally perfect devotees of the Lord. As the Lord descends by His causeless mercy upon this planet, so, in order to help in the pastimes of the Lord, these devotees also come here. They are not ordinary living entities or conditioned souls; they are ever-liberated persons, associates of the Personality of Godhead. And, just as Lord Kåñëa behaves like an ordinary man when He descends to this planet, so the members of the Yadu dynasty and the residents of Våndävana execute activities just like ordinary men. But they are not ordinary men; they are as liberated as Lord Kåñëa Himself.

In the Padma Puräëa, Uttara-khaëòa section, it is stated: "Just as Lord Rämacandra descends along with Lakñmaëa and Bharata, an expansion of Saìkarñaëa,* so the members of the Yadu dynasty and the cowherd men of Våndävana also descend with Lord Kåñëa in order to join in the transcendental pastimes of the Lord. When the Supreme Lord returns to His eternal abode, His associates return with Him to their respective places. As such, these ever liberated Vaiñëavas are not bound by the material laws of birth and death."

As is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä by the Lord Himself, His birth, deeds and activities are all transcendental. Similarly, the birth, deeds and activities of the associates of the Lord are also transcendental. And, as it is an offense to consider oneself to be Kåñëa, so it is offensive to consider oneself to be Yaçodä, Nanda, or any other associate of the Lord. We should always remember that they are transcendental; they are never conditioned souls.

It is described that Kåñëa, the enemy of Kaàsa, has sixty-four transcendental qualities, and all of the ever-liberated souls who accompany the Lord have the first fifty-five of the qualities, without any doubt. Such devotees are related to the Supreme Personality of Godhead in any of five transcendental mellows—namely, neutrality, servitorship, friendship, parenthood and conjugal love. These relationships with the Lord are eternal, and therefore nitya-siddha devotees do not have to strive to attain the perfectional stage by executing regulative devotional principles. They are eternally qualified to serve Kåñëa.

NoD 26-1970: Stimulation for Ecstatic Love

Chapter Twenty-six

Stimulation for Ecstatic Love

Some things which give stimulation to ecstatic love of Kåñëa are His transcendental qualities, His uncommon activities, His smiling features, His apparel, His garlands, His flute, His buffalo horn, His leg bells, His conchshell, His footprints, His place of pastimes (such as Våndävana), His favorite plant (tulasé), His devotee and the periodical occasions for remembering Him. One such occasion for remembrance is Ekädaçé, which comes twice a month on the eleventh day of the moon, both waning and waxing. On that day all the devotees remain fasting throughout the night and continually chant the glories of the Lord.

Kåñëa's Transcendental Qualities,
His Uncommon Activities and His Smile

As far as Kåñëa's transcendental qualities are concerned, they can be divided into three groups: qualities pertaining to His transcendental body, qualities pertaining to His transcendental speech, and qualities pertaining to His transcendental mind.

Kåñëa's age, His transcendental bodily features, His beauty, and His mildness are qualities pertaining to His body. There is no difference between Kåñëa and His body, and therefore the transcendental features pertaining to His body are the same as Kåñëa Himself. But because these qualities stimulate the devotee's ecstatic love, they have been analyzed as separate causes of that love. To be attracted by the qualities of Kåñëa means to be attracted by Kåñëa Himself, because there is no real distinction between Kåñëa and His qualities. Kåñëa's name is also Kåñëa. Kåñëa's fame is also Kåñëa. Kåñëa's entourage is also Kåñëa. Kåñëa and everything related with Kåñëa which gives stimulation to love of Kåñëa are all Kåñëa, but for our understanding these items can be considered separately.

Kåñëa is the reservoir of all transcendental pleasure. Therefore, the impetuses to love of Kåñëa, although seemingly different, are not actually distinct from Kåñëa Himself. In the technical Sanskrit terms, such qualities as Kåñëa's name, fame, etc., are accepted both as reservoirs of and stimulation for love of Kåñëa.

Kåñëa's age is considered in three periods: from His appearance day to the end of His sixth year is called kaumära; from the beginning of the sixth year up to the tenth year is called paugaëòa; and from the tenth to the sixteenth year is called kaiçora; after the beginning of the sixteenth year, Kåñëa is called a yauvana or a youth, and this continues with no change.

As far as Kåñëa's transcendental pastimes are concerned, they are mostly executed during the kaumära, paugaëòa and kaiçora periods. His affectionate pastimes with His parents are executed during His kaumära age. His friendship with the cowherd boys is exhibited during the paugaëòa period. And His friendship with the gopés is exhibited during the age of kaiçora. Kåñëa's pastimes at Våndävana are finished by the end of His fifteenth year, and then He is transferred to Mathurä and Dvärakä, where all other pastimes are performed.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé gives us a vivid description of Kåñëa as the reservoir of all pleasures in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu. Here are some parts of that description.

Kåñëa's kaiçora age can be divided into three parts. In the beginning of His kaiçora age—that is, at the beginning of His eleventh year, the luster of His body becomes so bright that it becomes an impetus for ecstatic love. Similarly, there are reddish borders around His eyes, and a growth of soft hairs on His body. In describing this early stage of His kaiçora age, Kundalatä, one of the residents of Våndävana, said to her friend, "My dear friend, I have just seen an extraordinary beauty appearing in the person of Kåñëa. His blackish bodily hue appears just like the indranéla jewel. There are reddish signs on His eyes, and small soft hairs are coming out on His body. The appearance of these symptoms has made Him extraordinarily beautiful."

In this connection, in the Tenth Canto, 21st Chapter, 5th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çukadeva Gosvämé tells King Parékñit: "My dear King, I shall try to describe how the minds of the gopés became absorbed in the thought of Kåñëa. The gopés would meditate on Kåñëa's dressing Himself just like a dancing actor and entering the forest of Våndävana, marking the ground with His footprints. They meditated on Kåñëa's having a helmet with a peacock feather and wearing earrings on His ears and yellow-gold colored garments covered with jewels and pearls. They also meditated on Kåñëa's blowing His flute and on all the cowherd boys' singing of the glories of the Lord." That is the description of the meditation which the gopés used to perform.

Sometimes the gopés would think about His soft nails, moving eyebrows and His teeth, which were catechu colored from chewing pan. One description was given by a gopé to her friend: "My dear friend, just see how the enemy of Agha has assumed such wonderful features! His brows are just like the brows of Cupid, and they are moving just as though they were dancing. The tips of His nails are so soft—it is as if they were dried bamboo leaves. His teeth are reddish, and so it appears that He has assumed a feature of anger. Under the circumstances, where is the chance for a young girl not to be attracted by such beautiful features and not to be afraid of becoming a victim to such beauty?"

Kåñëa's attractive features are also described by Våndä, the gopé after whom Våndävana was named. She told Kåñëa: "My dear Mädhava, Your newly-invented smile has so captivated the hearts of the gopés that they are simply unable to express themselves! As such, they have become bewildered and will not talk with others. All of these gopés have become so affected that it is as if they had offered three sprinkles of water upon their lives. In other words, they have given up all hope for their living condition." According to the Indian system, when a person is dead there is a sprinkling of water on the body. Thus, the statement of Våndä shows that the gopés were so enchanted by the beauty of Kåñëa that because they could not express their minds, they decided to commit suicide.

When Kåñëa arrived at the age of thirteen to fourteen years, His two arms and chest assumed an unspeakable beauty, and His whole form became simply enchanting. When Kåñëa attained thirteen years of age, His two arms were challenging the trunks of elephants, His rising chest was trying to come to peace talks with doors of jewels, and His two arms were minimizing the value of the bolts found on doors. Who can describe the wonderful beauty of these features of Kåñëa? The special beauty of Kåñëa's body was His mild smiling, His restless eyes and His world-enchanting songs. These are the special features of this age.

There is a statement in this connection that Kåñëa, on arriving at this age, manifested such beautiful bodily features that His restless eyes became the playthings of Cupid, and His mild smile resembled the newly-grown lotus flower. The enchanting vibration of His songs became a great impediment to the young girls, who were supposed to remain chaste and faithful to their husbands.

At this age Kåñëa enjoyed the räsa-lélä, exhibiting His power of joking with the cowherd girls and enjoying their company in the bushes of the gardens by the bank of the Yamunä.

In this connection there is the following statement: "Throughout the whole tract of land known as Våndävana there were the footprints of Kåñëa and the gopés, and in some places peacock feathers were strewn about. In some places there were nice beddings in the bushes of the Våndävana gardens, and in some places there were piles of dust due to the group-dancing of Govinda and the gopés." These are some of the features which are due to the different pastimes invented by Çré Kåñëa in the place known as Våndävana.

There is the following statement by one gopé, describing Kåñëa's attractive feature during this age: "My dear friend, just see how all of a sudden in the sky of Kåñëa there is a powerful rising sun and how this rising sun is minimizing the rays of our chastity moon. Our attraction for Kåñëa is so intense that it is drying up the lotus flower of our discrimination, and we are losing our senses in deciding whether we shall continue as chaste women or be victimized by the beauty of Kåñëa. My dear friend, I think that we have lost all hope of life!"

In the kaiçora age, beginning from the eleventh year and continuing up to the end of the fifteenth year, Kåñëa's arms, legs and thighs became marked with three divisional lines. At that time Kåñëa's chest challenged the hill of the marakata jewel. His arms challenged the pillars of the indranéla jewel, the three lines of His waist challenged the waves of the River Yamunä, and His thighs challenged beautiful bananas. One gopé said, "With all these exquisite features of His body, Kåñëa is too extraordinarily beautiful, and therefore I am always thinking of Him to protect me because He is the killer of all demons."

The idea expressed in this statement is that the gopés were comparing their attraction for Kåñëa to an attack by demons; and to counteract their attraction for the beauty of Kåñëa, they were also turning to Kåñëa hopefully, because He is the killer of all kinds of demons. In other words they were perplexed because on one hand they were attracted by the beauty of Kåñëa, and on the other they needed Kåñëa to drive away the demon of such attraction.

This kaiçora age can be translated as adolescence. At the end of this period all the gopés said, "Kåñëa is the killer of the attraction of Cupid, and as such He disturbs the patience of all newly-married girls. Kåñëa's bodily features have become so exquisite—it is as if they are all manifesting an artistic sense of the highest sort. His dancing eyes have dimmed the brilliance of the most expert dancer, and so there is no longer any comparison to the beauty of Kåñëa." Learned scholars therefore describe the features of His body at this time as nava-yauvana, newly-invented youthfulness. At this stage of Kåñëa's bodily features, the conjugal love affairs with the gopés and similar pastimes become very prominent.

There are six features of conjugal love affairs, called peacemaking, picking a quarrel, going to meet one's lover, sitting together, separation and support. Lord Kåñëa expanded an empire of these six features, of which He was the ruling prince. Somewhere He was picking quarrels with the young girls, somewhere He was scratching them with the nails of parrots, somewhere He was busy going to visit the gopés, and somewhere He was negotiating through cowherd friends to take shelter of the gopés.

Some of the gopés addressed Him thusly: "My dear Kåñëa, because of Your adolescent age, You have just become the spiritual master of these young girls, and You are teaching them to whisper among themselves. You are teaching them to offer solemn prayers, as well as training them to cheat their husbands and to join You in the gardens at night, without caring for the instructions of their superiors. You are enthusing them by the vibration of Your enchanting flute; and, as their teacher, You are teaching them all the intricacies of loving affairs."

It is said that even when Kåñëa was a boy of five He manifested such youthful energies, but learned scholars do not explain them because of the absence of suitable age. Kåñëa was beautiful because every part of His body was perfectly arranged without any defect. Such perfect bodily features of Kåñëa are described as follows: "My dear enemy of Kaàsa, Your broad eyes, Your rising chest, Your two pillar-like arms and the thin middle portion of Your body are always enchanting to every lotus-eyed beautiful girl." The ornaments on the body of Kåñëa were not actually enhancing His beauty, but just the reverse—the ornaments were beautified by Kåñëa.

A person is called mild when he cannot even bear the touch of the most soft thing. It is described that every part of Kåñëa's body was so soft that even at the touch of newly-grown leaves, the color of the touched part of His skin would change. At this kaiçora age, Kåñëa's endeavors were always bent toward arranging the räsa dance, as well as toward killing the demons in the forest of Våndävana. While Kåñëa was engaged in enjoyment with the boys and girls within the forest of Våndävana, Kaàsa used to send his associates to kill Him, and Kåñëa would show His prowess by killing them.

Kåñëa's Apparel and Garlands

Generally, there are four kinds of garments on the body of Kåñëa: His shirt, turban, belt and wearing garments. In Våndävana, He used to put on reddish garments, with a golden shirt on His body and an orange colored turban on His head. The different kinds of belts, combined with His enchanting smile, used to always increase the transcendental bliss of His associates. This dress of Kåñëa is described as gorgeous. As a baby elephant is sometimes dressed in colorful clothing, so Kåñëa's gorgeousness was manifested by decoration with such colorful clothing on the different parts of His body.

Äkalpa refers to the texture of Kåñëa's hair, His nicely dressed body annointed with sandalwood pulp and decorated with flower garlands, His tilaka, and His chewing pan. Kåñëa was decorated constantly in this äkalpa process. Kåñëa's hair was sometimes decorated with flowers placed on the middle of His head, or else reaching down to His back. In this way Kåñëa dressed His hair differently at different times. As for the ointment on His body, the pulp of sandalwood generally appeared to be white, and when it was mixed with saffron dye it appeared to be yellow.

Kåñëa used to put a vaijayanté garland around His neck. This vaijayanté garland is made of at least five differently colored flowers. The length of such a garland was always touching Kåñëa's knees or feet. Besides this garland of flowers, there were other kinds of flower garlands too—sometimes decorating His head, sometimes hanging around His neck and chest. Artistic painting with sandalwood pulp and colored sandalwood were also to be found on the body of Kåñëa.

One gopé addressed her friend and began to praise the bodily features of Kåñëa. She praised His blackish complexion, the reddish color of chewing pan enhancing His beauty hundreds of times, the curling hair on His head, the kuìkum* red spots on His body and the tilaka on His forehead.

His helmet, His earrings, His necklace, His four garments, the bangles on His head, the rings on His fingers, His ankle bells and His flute—these are the different features of Kåñëa's ornaments. Kåñëa, the enemy of Agha, always looked beautiful with His incomparable helmet, His earrings made of diamonds, His necklace of pearls, His bangles, embroidered garments and the beautiful rings on His fingers.

Kåñëa is sometimes called vanamälé. Vana means forest and mälé means gardener, so vanamälé refers to one who extensively uses flowers and garlands on different parts of His body. Kåñëa was dressed like this not only in Våndävana but also on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. Seeing such colorful dress and the garlands of different flowers, some great sages prayed, "Lord Kåñëa was going to the battlefield of Kurukñetra not to fight, but to grace all of the devotees with His presence."

Kåñëa's Flute

As far as His flute is concerned, it is said that the vibration of this wonderful instrument was able to break the meditation of the greatest sages, and Kåñëa was thus challenging Cupid by advertising His transcendental glories all over the world.

There are three kinds of flutes used by Kåñëa. One is called veëu, one is called muralé, and the third is called vaàçé. Veëu is very small, not more than six inches long, with six holes for whistling. Muralé is about eighteen inches long with a hole at the end and four holes on the body of the flute. This kind of flute produces a very enchanting sound. The vaàçé flute is about fifteen inches long, with nine holes on its body. Kåñëa used to play on these three flutes occasionally when they were needed. Kåñëa has a longer vaàçé, which is called mahänanda, or sanmohiné. When it is still longer it is called äkarñiëé. When it is even longer it is called änandiné. The änandiné flute is very pleasing to the cowherd boys and is technically named vaàsulé. These flutes were sometimes bedecked with jewels. Sometimes they were made of marble and sometimes of hollow bamboo. When the flute is made of jewels it is called sanmohiné. When made of gold, it is called äkarñiëé.

Kåñëa's Buffalo Horn

Kåñëa used a buffalo horn as a bugling instrument. This instrument was always highly polished and circled with gold bands, and on the middle there was a hole. Regarding these instruments, there is a metaphorical statement about a gopé named Tärävalé. It is said that Tärävalé became bitten by the most venomous snake of Kåñëa's flute. Then, in order to neutralize the poisonous effect, she drank the milk produced by the buffalo horn in the hand of Kåñëa. But instead of decreasing the poisonous effect, it increased it a thousand times. The gopé was thus put into the most miserable poisoned condition.

The Attraction of Kåñëa's Leg Bells

A certain gopé once stated to her friend, "My dear friend, when I heard the sound of the leg bell of Çré Kåñëa, I immediately started to go out of the house to see Him. But most regrettably, my superiors were present just before me at that time, and I could not go out."

Kåñëa's Conchshell

Kåñëa's conchshell is known as Päïcajanya. This Päïcajanya conch is also mentioned in the Bhagavad-gétä. Kåñëa sounded it before the Battle of Kurukñetra. It is said that when Lord Kåñëa blows on His transcendental conchshell, the wives of the demons become subject to abortions, and the wives of the demigods become blest with all auspiciousness. In this way, the sound of Kåñëa's conchshell used to vibrate and circulate all over the world.

Kåñëa's Footprints

It is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam that when Akrüra, who drove Kåñëa from Våndävana to Mathurä, saw the footprints of Kåñëa on the land of Våndävana, his ecstatic love for Kåñëa increased so much that the hairs on his body stood up. His eyes became overflooded with tears, and in such ecstasy he jumped out of the chariot and fell down on the ground and began to chant, "How wonderful this is! How wonderful this is!"

Similar feelings were expressed by the gopés when they were going to the bank of the Yamunä and saw Kåñëa's footprints in the dust. When Kåñëa walked on the ground of Våndävana, the marks of His sole (flag, thunderbolt, fish, a rod for controlling elephants and lotus flower) would be imprinted upon the dust of the land. The gopés became overwhelmed simply at seeing those marks on the ground.

Kåñëa's Places of Pastimes

One devotee has exclaimed, "Oh, I have not as yet visited the wonderful places where the pastimes of the Lord were performed. But simply by hearing the name of Mathurä I have become overwhelmed with joy!"

Kåñëa's Favorite Plant: Tulasé

Lord Kåñëa is very fond of tulasé leaves and buds. Because tulasé buds are usually offered up to the lotus feet of Kåñëa, a devotee once prayed to the tulasé buds to give him some information about the lotus feet of the Lord. The devotee expected that the tulasé buds would know something about the glories of Lord Çré Kåñëa's lotus feet.

Kåñëa's Devotees

One may sometimes become overwhelmed with joy by seeing a devotee of the Lord. When Dhruva Mahäräj saw two associates of Näräyaëa approaching him, he immediately stood up out of sincere respect and devotion and remained before them with folded hands; but because of his ecstatic love he could hardly offer them a proper reception.

There is a statement by a gopé who addressed Subala, a friend of Kåñëa: "My dear Subala, I know that Kåñëa is your friend and you always enjoy smiling and joking with Him. The other day I saw you both standing together, and you were keeping your hand upon Kåñëa's shoulder, and both of you were joyfully smiling. When I saw the two of you standing like that in the distance, my eyes at once became overflooded with tears."

Special Days for Remembering Kåñëa

There are many statements about the festive days in connection with Kåñëa's different activities. One of these festive days is Janmäñöamé, the day of Kåñëa's birth. This Janmäñöamé Day is the most opulent festival day for the devotees, and it is still observed with great pomp in every Hindu house in India. Sometimes even the devotees of other religious groups take advantage of this auspicious day and enjoy the performance of the ceremony of Janmäñöamé. Ecstatic love for Kåñëa is also aroused on the days of Ekädaçé, which are other festive days in connection with Kåñëa.

NoD 27-1970: Symptoms of Ecstatic Love

Chapter Twenty-seven

Symptoms of Ecstatic Love

The bodily symptoms which are manifested by a devotee in expressing ecstatic love for Kåñëa are called anubhäva. Practical examples of anubhäva are as follows: dancing, rolling on the ground, singing very loudly, stretching the body, crying loudly, yawning, breathing very heavily, neglecting the presence of others, drooling, laughing like a madman, wheeling the head and belching. When there is an extraordinary excess of ecstatic love, with all of these bodily symptoms manifested, one feels relieved transcendentally.

These symptoms are divided into two parts: one is called çéta, and the other is called kñepaëa. When there is yawning, it is called çéta, and when there is dancing it is called kñepaëa.

Dancing

While watching the räsa dance performed by Lord Kåñëa and the gopés, Lord Çiva beheld the beautiful face of Kåñëa and immediately began to dance and beat upon his small òiëòima drum. While Lord Çiva was dancing in ecstasy, his eldest son, Ganeça, joined him.

Rolling on the Ground

In the Third Canto, 1st Chapter, 31st verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Vidura inquires from Uddhava, "My dear friend, is Akrüra in an auspicious condition? He is not only a learned scholar and sinless, but he is also a devotee of Lord Kåñëa. He has such ecstatic love for Kåñëa that I have seen him rolling upon Kåñëa's footprints in the dust as if bereft of all senses." Similarly, one gopé gave a message to Kåñëa that Rädhäräëé, because of Her separation from Him and because of Her enchantment with the flavor of His flower garlands, was rolling on the ground, thereby bruising Her soft body.

Singing Loudly

One gopé informed Kåñëa that when Çrématé Rädhäräëé was singing about His glories, She enchanted all of Her friends in such a way that they became stonelike and dull. At the same time, the nearby stones began to melt away in ecstatic love.

Stretching the Body

When there was stretching of the body of Närada Muni from chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra, he chanted so loudly that it was apprehended that Lord Nåsiàha had appeared. Thus all the demons began to flee in different directions. It is also said that sometimes when Närada, the carrier of the véëä, remembers his Lord Kåñëa in great ecstasy, he begins to stretch his body so vigorously that his sacred thread gives way.

Crying Loudly

A gopé once said to Kåñëa: "My dear son of Nanda Mahäräj, by the sound of Your flute Çrématé Rädhäräëé has become full of lamentation and fear, and thus, with faltering voice, She is crying like a kurobi bird.

It is described that by hearing the vibration of Kåñëa's flute Lord Çiva becomes very puzzled and begins to cry so loudly into space that the demons become vanquished and the devotees become overwhelmed with joy.

Yawning

It is said that when the full moon rises, the lotus petals become expanded. Similarly, when Kåñëa used to appear before Rädhäräëé, Her face, which is compared with the lotus flower, would expand by Her yawning.

Breathing Heavily

As far as breathing heavily is concerned, it is stated: "Lalitä [one of the gopés] is just like a cätaké bird, which only takes water falling directly from the rain cloud and not from any other source." In this statement Kåñëa is compared to the dark cloud, and Lalitä is compared to the cätaké bird seeking only Kåñëa's company. The metaphor continues to say, "As a heavy wind sometimes disperses a mighty cloud, so the heavy breath from Lalitä's nostrils caused her to miss Kåñëa, who had disappeared by the time she recovered herself."

Neglecting the Presence of Others

As far as neglecting the presence of others is concerned, the wives of the brähmaëas who were performing sacrifices at Våndävana left home as soon as they heard that Kåñëa was nearby. They left their homes without caring for their learned husbands. The husbands began to discuss this amongst themselves: "How wonderful is the attraction for Kåñëa, that it has made these women leave us without any care!" This is the influence of Kåñëa. Anyone who becomes attracted to Kåñëa can be relieved from the bondage of birth and death, which can be compared to the locked-up homes that were neglected by the wives of the brähmaëas.

In the Padyävalé there is a statement by some devotees: "We shall not care for any outsiders. If they should deride us, we shall still not care for them. We shall simply enjoy the transcendental mellow of chanting Hare Kåñëa, and thus we shall roll on the ground and dance ecstatically. In this way we shall eternally enjoy transcendental bliss."

Drooling

As an example of the running down of saliva from the mouth, it is stated that sometimes when Närada Muni was chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra, he remained stunned for a while, and saliva oozed from his mouth.

Laughing like a Madman

When a devotee laughs very loudly like a madman, it is done out of an extraordinary agitation of ecstatic love within the heart. Such mad laughing is an expression of the condition of the heart, which is technically called aööa-häsa. When a devotee becomes affected with this mental condition, his love is expressed through the lips. The laughing sounds, coming one after another, are compared to flowers falling from the creeper of devotion which grows within the heart of the devotee. In the Caitanya-caritämåta devotional service to the Lord is also compared to a creeper which rises up to the lotus feet of Kåñëa in Goloka Våndävana.

Wheeling of the Head

One gopé told her friend: "It appears that Lord Kåñëa, the enemy of the demon Agha, has released from His mouth a whirlwind which is acting on your head and is gradually proceeding to do the same to the other lotus-eyed gopés."

Belching

Sometimes belching also becomes a symptom of ecstatic love for Kåñëa. There is evidence of this in Paurëamäsé's address to one crying associate of Rädhäräëé: "My dear daughter, don't be worried because Çrématé Rädhäräëé is belching. I am about to offer a remedial measure for this symptom. Do not cry so loudly. This belching is not due to indigestion; it is a sign of ecstatic love for Kåñëa. I shall arrange to cure this belching symptom immediately. Don't be worried." This statement of Paurëamäsé is evidence that ecstatic love for Kåñëa is sometimes manifested through belching.

Sometimes trembling of the whole body and hemorrhaging from some part of the body are also manifested in response to ecstatic love for Kåñëa, but such symptoms are very rare, and therefore Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé does not discuss any further on this point.

NoD 28-1970: Other Ecstatic Symptoms

Chapter Twenty-eight

Other Ecstatic Symptoms

Existential Ecstatic Love for Kåñëa

When a devotee is always intensely affected by love for Kåñëa in a direct relationship with Him—or even a little apart from Him—his status is called existential ecstatic love. The symptoms originating from such existential ecstatic love are divided into three headings—namely, moist, burnt and dried-up.

Moist existential ecstatic love aroused in connection with Kåñëa is divided into two: direct and indirect. Rädhäräëé was weaving a garland of kunda flowers, and, upon hearing the vibration of Kåñëa's flute, She immediately stopped Her work. This is an example of direct moistened existential ecstatic love. Indirect moistened existential ecstatic love is described in the following statement: Kåñëa, who is also called Puruñottama, is to the eyes of Mother Yaçodä just like the cloud is to the eyes of the cätaké bird. When Kåñëa had been brought to Mathurä, Mother Yaçodä, being very anxious and angry, began to rebuke the King of Mathurä.

Burnt existential ecstatic love is divided into three, and one example is as follows: One day, Mother Yaçodä was dreaming that the gigantic demon, Pütanä, was lying on the courtyard of her house, and she immediately became anxious to seek out Kåñëa.

When there are manifestations of ecstatic symptoms in the body of a nondevotee, these are called dried-up symptoms of ecstatic love. The nondevotees are actually materialistic, but in contact with some pure devotee, they sometimes may manifest some symptoms of ecstasy. Devotional scholars call these dried-up symptoms.

There are eight symptoms of existential ecstatic love: becoming stunned, perspiring, standing of the hairs on the body, faltering of the voice, trembling of the body, changing bodily colors, shedding tears, and devastation.

The scientific explanation of these eight symptoms is given by Rüpa Gosvämé as follows: When the vital force of life is in contact with the earth, it is called stunning. When the same force comes into contact with water, there is the shedding of tears. When the same force comes into contact with fire, there is perspiration. When the same force comes into contact with the sky, there is complete devastation. And when that force comes into contact with the air, there is trembling, failing of the voice and standing of the hairs on the body.

These symptoms are sometimes manifested internally and sometimes externally. The pure devotee always feels such symptomatic expressions within himself, but being afraid of outsiders he does not generally manifest them externally.

Becoming Stunned

The symptom of becoming stunned is caused by ecstatic tribulation, fearfulness, astonishment, lamentation and anger. This symptom is exhibited by a stoppage of talking, a stoppage of movement, a feeling of voidness and an extreme feeling of separation.

When Uddhava was describing Kåñëa's pastimes to Vidura, he said, "One day the gopés became stunned when Kåñëa, in the dress of a gardening maid, entered the greenhouse and enlivened them with joking and laughter. Then when Kåñëa left the greenhouse, the gopés were seeing Kåñëa so ecstatically that it was as though both their minds and eyes were following Him." These symptoms signify that although the gopés' business was not finished, they had become stunned with ecstatic love.

Another example of being stunned took place when Kåñëa was surrounded by various wrestlers in the sacrificial arena of Kaàsa. His mother, Devaké,* then became stunned, and her eyes dried up when she saw Kåñëa amongst the wrestlers.

There is also an example of the astonishment of Lord Brahmä. It is explained in the Tenth Canto, 13th Chapter, 51st verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam that when Brahmä understood that this cowherd boy was the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself, he became stunned. All of his sensual activities became stopped upon seeing all the cowherd boys again, along with Kåñëa. Lord Brahmä was so stunned that he appeared to be a golden statue with four heads. Also, when the residents of Braja found that Kåñëa had lifted Govardhan Hill with His left hand, they became stunned.

Astonishment caused by lamentation is exemplified when Kåñëa was entering into the belly of the Bakäsura demon and all the demigods from higher planets became stunned with lamentation. A similar example of becoming stunned was visible in Arjuna when he saw that Açvatthämä was attempting to release his brahmästra* at Kåñëa.

Perspiration

An example of perspiring because of jubilation is described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. One gopé addressed Rädhäräëé thusly: "My dear Rädhäräëé, You are rebuking the sunshine unnecessarily, but I can understand that You are perspiring only because of Your becoming too lusty at seeing Kåñëa."

Perspiration caused by fearfulness was exhibited by Raktak, one of the servants of Kåñëa. One day Kåñëa dressed Himself just like Abhimanyu, the husband of Rädhäräëé. Abhimanyu did not like Rädhäräëé's association with Kåñëa, and therefore when Raktak saw Kåñëa in the dress of Abhimanyu and thus mistook His identity, he began to strongly rebuke Him. As soon as Raktak finally understood that it was Kåñëa in the dress of Abhimanyu, he began perspiring. This perspiration was caused by fearfulness.

Perspiration due to anger was exhibited by Garuòa, the eagle who is the carrier of Viñëu. Once the heavenly king, Indra, was sending torrents of rain over Våndävana. Garuòa was observing the incident from above the clouds, and because of his anger, he began perspiring.

Standing of Hairs on the Body

The standing up of hair on the body was manifested when Mother Yaçodä found within Kåñëa's mouth all of the universal planetary systems. She had asked Kåñëa to open His mouth wide just to see whether He had eaten dirt. But when Kåñëa opened His mouth, she saw not only the entire earth, but also many other planets within His mouth. This caused a standing up of the hair on her body.

The standing up of hair on the body resulting from jubilation is described in the Tenth Canto, 30th Chapter, 9th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam in connection with the gopés engaged in the räsa dance. During this räsa dance Kåñëa disappeared all of a sudden with Rädhäräëé, and the gopés began to search Him out. At that time they addressed the earth and began to say, "My dear earthly planet, how many austerities and penances you must have undergone to have the lotus feet of Kåñëa always touching your surface. I think that you must be very jubilant because the trees and plants, which are just like hairs on your body, are standing up so gloriously. May we ask when did you first get these symptoms? Are you enjoying this jubilation since you were touched by the incarnation of Vämana or since you were delivered by the incarnation of Varäha?"

Kåñëa would sometimes perform mock fighting along with the cowherd boys. When Kåñëa blew His horn in this mock fighting, Çrédämä, who was on the opposing side, felt his bodily hairs stand up. Similarly, when Arjuna saw Kåñëa in His gigantic universal form, there was a standing of the hairs on his body.

Faltering of the Voice

When Kåñëa was going to Mathurä on the chariot driven by Akrüra, Yaçodä and all the gopés came to try to forbid Him to pass and to block His way. At that time Rädhäräëé was so perturbed that in a faltering voice, She requested Mother Yaçodä to please stop Akrüra.

Faltering of the voice resulting from wonder was exhibited by Brahmä. It is said in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 13th Chapter, 59th verse that, after bowing down before Lord Kåñëa, when Brahmä began to rise he prayed to the Lord in a faltering voice.

In the Tenth Canto, 29th Chapter, 27th verse, another example of faltering of the voice was exhibited by the gopés when they came to Kåñëa, desiring to dance with Him. Kåñëa asked them to go back to their husbands and homes. The gopés apparently became very angry and began to talk to Kåñëa with faltering voices.

In the Tenth Canto, 39th Chapter, 48th verse, of Çrémad-Bhägavatam a faltering voice due to jubilation was exhibited by Akrüra when he was shown all of the Vaikuëöha planets resting within the River Yamunä. When Akrüra understood that Kåñëa was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he bowed his head to Kåñëa's lotus feet and with folded hands began to pray in a faltering voice. There are also examples of faltering of the voice caused by fearfulness.

One of Kåñëa's friends praised Him thusly: "My dear friend, Your flute was given to Your servant, Patré, and when I asked him to return it he began speaking in a faltering voice, and his complexion became yellow."

Trembling

When Kåñëa was trying to capture the demon Çaìkha, Rädhäräëé began trembling out of fearfulness. Similar trembling of the body was exhibited in Sahadeva, the younger brother of Nakula. When Çiçupäla was vehemently blaspheming the Lord, Sahadeva began to tremble out of anger.

Trembling of the body was also exhibited by Rädhäräëé out of tribulation. Rädhäräëé trembled as She told one of the gopés: "Don't joke with this disappointing boy! Please ask Him not to approach Me, because He is always the cause of all grief for us."

Changing of Bodily Color

Sometimes, due to great aggrievement caused by the dealings of Kåñëa, the body changes color. The gopés therefore addressed the Lord thusly: "My dear Kåñëa, due to separation from You, all of the denizens of Våndävana have changed their color. And because of this change of color even the great sage Närada was thinking of Våndävana as a white island in the ocean of milk."

When Kåñëa and Balaräma were present in the arena of Kaàsa, Kaàsa's body changed color. Similarly, Indra's face changed color when he saw that Kåñëa was protecting all the denizens of Braja by lifting Govardhan Hill. If the color change takes place due to excessive jubilation, the hue turns red. Because such change of color is so rare, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé does not further discuss this point.

Tears

Out of jubilation, anger, or separation there may be the pouring down of tears from the eyes. When such tears are very cold they are due to jubilation, and when they are due to anger the tears become hot. In all cases there is a severe movement of the eyes, and the eyes generally become reddish. There is also an itching sensation which causes the sufferer to rub his eyes.

When the lotus-eyed Rukmiëé, the first queen of Kåñëa in Dvärakä, was shedding tears out of ecstatic jubilation, she did not like the tears. There is a passage in the Hari-vaàça wherein Satyabhämä begins to shed tears because of her great affection for Kåñëa.

An example of shedding tears because of anger was exhibited by Bhéma when he saw that Çiçupäla was insulting Kåñëa in the räja-süya arena of sacrifice. Bhéma wanted to kill Çiçupäla immediately, but because Kåñëa did not order him to do so, he became morose with anger. It is described that there were hot tears covering his eyes, as a thin cloud sometimes covers the evening moon. In the evening, when the moon is slightly covered by a thin cloud, it looks very nice, and when Bhéma was shedding tears on account of his anger, he also looked very nice.

In the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Chapter 68, verse 23, there is a nice example of Rukmiëé shedding tears of lamentation. When Kåñëa and Rukmiëé were talking, Rukmiëé became frightened of separation from Kåñëa, and therefore she began scratching the earth with her red, lotus-like nails. Because she was shedding tears, the black ointment from her eyes was dripping, along with the tears, onto her breasts, which were covered with kuìkum powder. Rukmiëé was so aggrieved that her voice was choked up.

Devastation

When a person is confused by simultaneous happiness and tribulation and does not know what to do, this state of confusion is called pralaya, or devastation. In this condition of pralaya one sometimes falls down on the ground, and all the symptoms of ecstatic love become manifest. When the gopés were searching after Kåñëa and all of a sudden He came out from the bushes and creepers, all of them became stunned and almost senseless. In this state the gopés appeared very beautiful. This is an example of pralaya, or devastation in happiness.

There are also instances of pralaya in distress. One such example is described in the Tenth Canto, 39th Chapter, 14th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, where Çukadeva Gosvämé tells King Parékñit: "My dear King, when the gopés were missing Kåñëa, they were so much absorbed in meditation upon Him that all of their senses stopped functioning, and they lost all bodily sense. It was as though they had become liberated from all material conditions."

Out of the many ecstatic symptoms of the body, the symptom of being stunned is especially significant. According to the degree of being stunned, the vital force within the body becomes agitated, and due to such a state, the other ecstatic loving symptoms sometimes become altered. These transcendental ecstatic symptoms gradually develop, and in the course of such development, they are sometimes called smoky, sometimes called blazing, and sometimes called shining. These three degrees are experienced for many, many years and extend to different parts of the body. Unlike the shedding of tears and faltering of the voice, the condition of being stunned is spread all over the body. The shedding of tears and faltering of the voice are simply localized symptoms.

The shedding of tears, however, sometimes makes the eyes become swollen and whitish, and sometimes the lenses of the eyes become differently focused. Faltering of the voice may sometimes cause choking in the throat and extreme anxiety. As the different symptoms of these ecstatic manifestations are localized, they are accompanied by different local reactions; e.g., when the throat is choked up because of a faltering voice, there may be a sound like "ghra." Such sounds choke up the voice, and with extreme mental anxiety they may manifest in different ways. All these symptoms are listed under the dried-up existential condition known as smoky, and they are exhibited in different ways.

Sometimes, while participating in ceremonies celebrating Kåñëa's pastimes, or in the society of devotees, there is dancing ecstasy. Such sentiments are called blazing.

None of the above symptoms can be manifested without the basic principle of strong attachment for Kåñëa. In the smoky condition of such ecstatic expressions, the symptoms could otherwise be hidden. This type of symptom was experienced by Priest Gargamuni, who was performing some ritualistic ceremony in the house of Nanda Mahäräj. When he heard about Kåñëa's killing of the Aghäsura demon, there were some tears visible in his eyes, his throat was trembling, and perspiration covered his whole body. In this way Priest Gargamuni's beautiful face assumed a nice condition.

When several such ecstatic symptoms are visible, the condition is called blazing. For example, some of Kåñëa's friends told Him, "My dear friend, as soon as I heard the sound of Your flute from within the forest, my hands became almost motionless and my eyes became full of tears. So much so, in fact, that I could not recognize Your peacock feather. My thighs became almost completely stunned so that I could not move even an inch. Therefore, my dear friend, I must acknowledge the wonderful vibration of Your transcendental flute."

Similarly, one gopé said to another, "My dear friend, when I heard the sound of Kåñëa's flute, I tried to hide myself from the reaction of the vibrations. But still I could not check the trembling of my body, and therefore all of my friends in the house could detect my attachment for Kåñëa without any doubt."

When the ecstatic symptoms cannot be checked, and they simultaneously appear in four or five different categories, this stage of ecstatic love is called shining. The example is cited, in this connection, that when the sage Närada saw Lord Kåñëa standing before him, his body became so stunned that he stopped playing on his véëä. Because of his faltering voice he could not offer any prayers to Kåñëa, and his eyes became filled with tears. Thus, Närada's ability to see Kåñëa was also obstructed.

When similar symptoms were manifest in the body of Çrématé Rädhäräëé, some of Her friends criticized Her: "My dear friend, You are blaming the flavor of the flowers for the tears in Your eyes. You are rebuking the air for the standing of the hairs on Your body. And You are cursing Your walking in the forest for Your thighs being stunned. But Your faltering voice reveals the cause to be different: it is just Your attachment for Kåñëa!"

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé remarks that when various symptoms become manifest very prominently, the devotee's condition can be called the brightest. For example, a friend of Kåñëa addressed Him as follows: "My dear Pétämbara, because of separation from You all the residents of Goloka Våndävana are perspiring. They are lamenting with different words, and their eyes have become moistened with tears. Actually, all of them are in great confusion."

There is a supreme symptom of ecstatic love which is called mahäbhäva. This mahäbhäva expression was possible only in Rädhäräëé, but later on when Çré Kåñëa Caitanya appeared to feel the mode of love of Rädhäräëé, He also expressed all of the symptoms of mahäbhäva. Çré Rüpa Gosvämé says in this connection that when the symptoms of ecstatic love become the most bright, that stage is accepted as mahäbhäva.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé further analyzes the ecstatic loving expression into four divisions which are called sättväbhäsä.

Sometimes impersonalists who are not actually in devotional service may also exhibit such symptoms of ecstatic love, but this is not accepted as actual ecstasy. It is a reflection only. For example, sometimes in Väräëasé, a holy city for impersonalist scholars, there may be seen a sannyäsé crying from hearing the glories of the Lord. Impersonalists also sometimes chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra and dance, but their aim is not to serve the Lord. It is to become one with the Lord and merge into His existence. Rüpa Gosvämé therefore says that even if the reactions to chanting are manifested in the impersonalist's body, they should not be considered to be symptoms of actual attachment, but reflections only, just like the sun reflected in a dark room through some polished glass. The chanting of Hare Kåñëa, however, is so nice and transcendental that it will eventually melt even the hearts of persons who are impersonalists. Rüpa Gosvämé says that the impersonalists' symptoms are simply reflections of ecstatic love, not the real thing.

Sometimes it is found that when staunch logicians, without any trace of devotional service and without actually understanding the transcendental glories of the Lord, sit down to hear the glories of the Lord, they appear to be melting and shedding tears. In this connection there is a statement by a devotee who is addressing the Lord thusly: "My dear Mukunda, I cannot properly express the glories of Your pastimes. Even when the nondevotees hear of Your glorious pastimes they become affected and shed tears and start to tremble." Such nondevotees are not actually melted; they are hard-hearted. But the influence of the glories of the Lord is so great that even the nondevotees sometimes shed tears.

Sometimes it is found that a nondevotee who has practically no taste for Kåñëa and who follows no rules or regulations can, by practice, make a show of devotional symptoms, even crying in an assembly of devotees. This shedding of tears is not actually an ecstatic loving expression, however. It is done simply by practice. Although there is no need to describe these reflections of ecstatic love, Rüpa Gosvämé gives some instances where there is no actual devotional service and such expressions are manifested.

NoD 29-1970: Expressions of Love for Kåñëa

Chapter Twenty-nine

Expressions of Love for Kåñëa

There are some bodily symptoms which express overwhelming ecstatic love. They are counted at thirty-one as follows: disappointment, lamentation, humility, guilt, fatigue, intoxication, pride, doubt, apprehension, intense emotion, madness, forgetfulness, disease, confusion, death, laziness, inertness, bashfulness, concealment, remembering, argumentativeness, anxiety, thoughtfulness, endurance, happiness, eagerness, haughtiness, envy, impudence, dizziness and alertness.

Disappointment

When one is forced to act in a way which is forbidden, or to refrain from acting in a way which is proper, he becomes regretful and thinks himself dishonored. At that time there is a sense of disappointment. In this kind of disappointment one becomes full of anxiety, sheds tears, changes bodily color, feels humility and breathes heavily.

When Kåñëa, in punishing the Käliya serpent, appeared to have drowned Himself in the poisonous water of the Yamunä, Nanda Mahäräj addressed Yaçodä Devé thusly: "My dear wife, Kåñëa has gone deep into the water, and so there is no longer any need to maintain our bodies, which are so full of sinful activities! Let us also enter into the poisonous water of the Yamunä and compensate for the sinful activities of our lives!" This is an instance of severe shock, where the devotee becomes greatly disappointed.

When Kåñëa left Våndävana, Subala, His intimate friend, decided to leave also. While leaving, Subala was contemplating that without Kåñëa there was no longer any pleasure to be found in Våndävana. The analogy is given that, as the bees go away from a flower that has no honey, so Subala left Våndävana when he found there was no longer any relishable transcendental pleasure there.

In Däna-keli-kaumudé Çrématé Rädhäräëé addresses one of Her friends in this manner: "My dear friend, if I cannot hear of the glorious activities of Kåñëa, it is better for Me to become deaf. And because I am now unable to see Him, it would be good for Me to be a blind woman." This is another instance of disappointment due to separation from Kåñëa.

There is a statement in the Hari-vaàça wherein Satyabhämä, one of the queens of Kåñëa in Dvärakä, tells her husband: "My dear Kåñëa, since I heard Närada glorifying Rukmiëé before You, I can understand that there is no need of any talking about myself." This is an instance of disappointment caused by envy. Rukmiëé and Satyabhämä were co-wives, and because Kåñëa was husband of both, there naturally was some feminine envy between them. So when Satyabhämä heard the glories of Rukmiëé, she was envious of her and thus became disappointed.

In the Tenth Canto, 51st Chapter, 29th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is this statement: "My dear Kåñëa, I cannot say that it is only other people who are implicated in material existence, because I too am much entangled with the bodily concept of life. I am always too anxious about my family, home, wife, wealth, land and kingdom. And because I have been so maddened by this material atmosphere, I am thinking now that my life has been simply spoiled." This statement is an instance of disappointment caused by lamentation.

According to Bharata Muni, this disappointment is inauspicious. But there are other learned scholars who have accepted such disappointment as being in the mood of neutrality and as being a preservative for ecstatic love.

Lamentation

When one is unsuccessful in achieving his desired goal of life, when one finds no fulfillment in his present occupation, when one finds himself in reversed conditions and when one feels guilt—at such a time one is said to be in state of lamentation.

In this condition of lamentation one becomes questioning, thoughtful, tearful, regretful and heavy-breathed. His bodily color changes, and his mouth becomes dry.

One aged devotee of Kåñëa addressed Him in this way: "My dear Kåñëa, O killer of the demon Agha, my body is now invalid due to old age. I cannot speak very fluently, my voice is faltering, my mind is not strong, and I am often attacked with forgetfulness. But, my dear Lord, You are just like the moonlight, and my only real regret is that for want of any taste for Your pleasant shining I did not advance myself in Kåñëa consciousness." This statement is an instance of lamentation due to one's being unable to achieve his desired goal.

One devotee said, "This night I was dreaming of collecting various flowers from the garden, and I was thinking of making a garland to offer to Kåñëa. But I am so unfortunate that all of a sudden my dream was over, and I could not achieve my desired goal!" This statement is an instance of lamentation resulting from nonfulfillment of one's duties.

When Nanda Mahäräj saw his foster son, Kåñëa, embarrassed in the sacrificial arena of Kaàsa, he said, "How unfortunate I am that I did not keep my son bolted within a room. Unfortunately, I have brought Him to Mathurä, and now I see that He's embarrassed by this giant elephant named Kuvalaya. It is as though the moon of Kåñëa is eclipsed by the shadow of the earth." This is an instance of lamentation caused by reversed conditions.

In the Tenth Canto, 14th Chapter, 9th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is a statement by Brahmä: "My dear Lord, just see my impudence! You are unlimited, the original Personality of Godhead, the supersoul—and You rule over the most perfect illusory energies! And just see my impudence! I wanted to supersede You by my own personal power, and I was very puffed up with this tiny power of mine. Just as a simple spark from a fire cannot do any harm to the fire, so my bewildering potency was completely unsuccessful in thwarting Your superior illusory power. Therefore I find myself to be most insignificant and think of myself as a most useless person." This statement by Brahmä is an instance of lamentation caused by committing an offense.

Humility

A sense of weakness caused by distress, fearfulness or offensiveness is called humility. In this condition one becomes talkative, small in heart, dirty in mind, full of anxiety and inactive.

In the Tenth Canto, 51st Chapter, 39th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is the following statement by King Mucukunda: "My dear Lord, because of my bad deeds in the past I am everlastingly aggrieved. I am always suffering from my desires, but still my senses are never satisfied with material enjoyments. Somehow or other I am, by Your grace, now in a peaceful condition because I have taken shelter of Your lotus feet, which are always free from all lamentation, fear and death. O supreme protector, O supreme soul! O supreme controller! Kindly give me Your protection. I am so much embarrassed." This statement by Mucukunda is an instance of humility resulting from a severely miserable condition of material existence.

When Uttarä was attacked by the brahmästra of Açvatthämä, she became afraid of losing her child, Mahäräj Parékñit, who was still within the womb. She immediately surrendered to Kåñëa and said, "My dear Lord, kindly save my child! I do not mind if I myself must be killed by the brahmästra of Açvatthämä." This is an instance of humility caused by fear.

In the Tenth Canto, 14th Chapter, 10th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Lord Brahmä says, "O infallible one! I am born in the modes of passion, and therefore I have been falsely proud of being the creator of this material world. My false pride was just like dense darkness, and in this darkness I had become blind. In my blindness I was considering myself a competitor to You, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. But, my dear Lord, even though I am accepted as the creator of this universe, I am eternally Your servant. Therefore, kindly always be compassionate toward me and excuse me in that way." This statement by Brahmä is another instance of humility resulting from committing an offense.

Sometimes there is humility due to shyness. For example, when Kåñëa stole all of the garments from the gopés while they were bathing in the river, all of them begged Kåñëa not to commit this injustice upon them. The gopés addressed Him thus: "My dear Kåñëa, we know that You are the son of Nanda Mahäräj and that You are the most beloved of all Våndävana. And You are very much loved by us also! But why are You giving us this trouble? Kindly return our garments. Just see how we are trembling from the severe cold!" This humility was due to their shyness from being naked before Kåñëa.

Guilt

When a person blames himself for committing an inappropriate action, his feeling is called guilt.

One day Çrématé Rädhäräëé was churning curd for Kåñëa. At that time the jeweled bangles on Her hands were circling around, and She was also chanting the holy name of Kåñëa. All of a sudden She thought, "I am chanting the holy name of Kåñëa, and My superiors—My mother-in-law and My sister-in-law—may hear Me!" By this thought Rädhäräëé became overanxious. This is an instance of feeling guilty because of devotion to Kåñëa.

One day the beautiful-eyed Çrématé Rädhäräëé entered into the forest to collect some flowers to prepare a garland for Kåñëa. While collecting the flowers, She became afraid that someone might see Her, and She felt some fatigue and weakness. This is an instance of guilty feelings caused by labor for Kåñëa.

There is a statement in Rasa-sudhäkara that after passing the night with Kåñëa, Rädhäräëé became so weak that She was unable to get up from bed. When Kåñëa took Her hand to help Her, Rädhäräëé felt guilty about having passed the night with Him.

Fatigue

Fatigue is felt after walking a long distance, after dancing and after sex activity. In this kind of fatigue there is dizziness, perspiration, inactivity of the limbs, yawning and very heavy breathing.

One day Yaçodä was chasing Kåñëa in the yard after He had offended Her. After a while Yaçodä became very fatigued, and therefore she was perspiring, and her bunched hair became loosened. This is an instance of becoming fatigued because of working too much.

Sometimes all of the cowherd friends of Kåñëa, along with Balaräma, danced together in some ceremony. At these times the garlands on Their necks would move, and They would begin to perspire. Their whole bodies became wet from Their ecstatic dancing. This is an instance of fatigue caused by dancing.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 33rd Chapter, 20th verse it is said that after enjoying love affairs with Kåñëa by dancing, embracing and kissing, the gopés would sometimes become very tired, and Kåñëa, out of His causeless mercy and compassion, would smear their faces with His lotus hands. This is an example of fatigue caused by laboring in the räsa dance.

Intoxication

When one becomes arrogant with false prestige due to drinking intoxicants or being too lustful, the voice becomes faulty, the eyes become swollen, and there are symptoms of redness on the body. There is a statement in the Lalita-mädhava that Lord Baladeva, intoxicated from drinking excessive quantities of honey, once began to address the ants: "O you kings of the ants! Why are you hiding yourselves in these holes?" At the same time He also addressed the King of heaven: "O King Indra! You plaything of Çacé! Why are you laughing? I am now prepared to smash the whole universe, and I know that Kåñëa will not be angry with Me."* Then He addressed Kåñëa: "My dear Kåñëa, tell Me immediately why the whole world is trembling, and why the moon has become elongated! And O you members of the Yadu dynasty, why are you laughing at Me? Please give me back My liquors made of honey from the kadamba flower!" Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé prays that Lord Balaräma will be pleased with all of us while He is thus talking just like an intoxicated person.

In this state of intoxication, Balaräma felt tired and lay down for rest. Generally, those who are exalted personalities lie down when they feel intoxicated, whereas those who are mediocre laugh and sing during intoxication, and those who are lowly use vulgar language and sometimes cry. Such intoxication is manifested according to different ages and mentalities. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé does not describe further in this direction because there is no necessity for such a discussion.

There is another description of the symptoms of intoxication in the person of Çré Rädhäräëé after She saw Kåñëa: sometimes She was walking hither and thither, sometimes She was laughing, sometimes She was covering Her face, sometimes She was talking without any meaning, and sometimes She was praying to Her associate gopés. Seeing these symptoms in Rädhäräëé, the gopés began to talk among themselves: "Just see how Rädhäräëé has become intoxicated simply by seeing Kåñëa before Her!" This is an instance of ecstatic love in intoxication.

Pride

Expressions of ecstatic love in pride may be the result of excessive wealth, exquisite beauty, first-class residence, or the attainment of one's ideal goal. One is also considered to be proud when he does not care about the neglect of others.

Bilvamaìgala Thäkur said, "My dear Kåñëa, You are leaving me, forcibly getting out of my clutches. But I shall be impressed by Your strength only when You can go forcibly from the core of my heart." This is an instance of feeling pride in ecstatic love for Kåñëa.

Once during the räsa dance, when Rädhäräëé left the arena, and Kåñëa went to seek Her out, one of the dear friends of Rädhäräëé began to address Kåñëa thusly: "My dear Kåñëa, You have been very much obliging in serving the form of our Çré Rädhäräëé, and now You have left all the other gopés to search for Her. Please allow me to inquire how You want Her to treat You." This is an instance of feeling pride on account of exquisite beauty.

Sometimes Rädhäräëé felt pride within Herself and said, "Although the cowherd boys prepare nice flower garlands for Kåñëa, when I present My garland to Him, He becomes struck with wonder and immediately accepts it and puts it on His heart."

Similarly, in the Tenth Canto, 2nd Chapter, 27th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Lord Brahmä says: "My dear Madhusüdana, persons who are pure devotees of Your Lordship actually feel Your ecstatic friendship, and as such they are never vanquished by enemies. They know they are always protected by You, and so they can matter-of-factly pass over the heads of their enemies without any care." In other words, one who has taken complete shelter under the lotus feet of the Lord is always proud of being able to conquer all enemies.

One weaver at Mathurä addressed Kåñëa in this way: "My dear King of Våndävana, I have become so proud of Your causeless mercy upon me that I do not even count upon the mercy of the Lord of Vaikuëöha, which is sought after by many great sages in deep meditation." In other words, although the yogés and great sages sit in meditation upon Lord Viñëu, who is residing in Vaikuëöha, a devotee of Kåñëa is so proud that he does not consider such meditation to be very valuable. This feeling of pride is due to one's having achieved the highest goal of life—Kåñëa.

Doubt

After Lord Brahmä had stolen all of the calves, cows and cowherd boys from Kåñëa, he was trying to go away. But all of a sudden he became doubtful about his stealing affairs and began to watch on all sides with his eight eyes. Lord Brahmä has four heads, and therefore he has eight eyes. This is an instance of ecstatic love in doubtfulness, caused by stealing.

Similarly, just to please Kåñëa, Akrüra stole the Syamantaka-maëi, a stone which can produce unlimited quantities of gold, but later on he repented his stealing. This is another instance of ecstatic love for Kåñëa in doubt caused by stealing.

The King of heaven, Indra, was advised to surrender himself at the lotus feet of Kåñëa when he was causing torrents of rain to fall on the land of Braja. At that time Indra's face became very darkened out of doubtfulness.

Apprehension

When a person becomes disturbed in his heart by seeing lightning in the sky, by seeing a ferocious animal, or by hearing a tumultuous sound, his state of mind is called apprehensive. In such a state of apprehension, one tries to take shelter of something which provides safety. There may be standing of the hairs on the body, trembling of the body and sometimes the committing of mistakes. And sometimes the body may become stunned.

In the Padyävalé there is the following statement: "My dear friend, Kåñëa's residence in the demonic circle at Mathurä, under the supremacy of the King of demons, Kaàsa, is causing me much worry." This is one instance of apprehending some danger to Kåñëa in ecstatic love for Him.

When Våñäsura appeared in Våndävana as a bull, all of the gopés became greatly affected with fear. Being perturbed in that way, they began to embrace the tämala trees. This is an instance of fearfulness caused by a ferocious animal and of the search for shelter while remembering Kåñëa in ecstatic love. Upon hearing the jackals crying in the forest of Våndävana, Mother Yaçodä sometimes became very careful about keeping Kåñëa under her vigilance, fearing that Kåñëa might be attacked by them. This is an instance of ecstatic love for Kåñëa in fearfulness caused by a tumultuous sound. This kind of fearfulness is a little different from being actually afraid. When one is afraid of something, he can still think of past and future. But when there is this kind of ecstatic apprehension, there is no scope for such thinking.

Intense Emotion

Emotion is caused by something very dear, by something very detestable, by fire, strong wind, strong rainfall, by some natural disturbance, the sight of a big elephant, or the sight of an enemy. When there is emotion caused by seeing something very dear, one can speak very swiftly and use kind words. When there is emotion caused by seeing something detestable, one cries very loudly. When there is emotion caused by seeing fire, one tries to fly away. There may also be trembling of the body, closing of the eyes and tears in the eyes. When one becomes emotional on account of a strong wind, one tries to run very swiftly and rubs his eyes. When one is emotional because of rainfall, one takes an umbrella, and there is tension in his body. When there is emotion due to a sudden disturbance, one's face becomes discolored, one becomes struck with wonder, and there is trembling of the body. If there is emotion from seeing an elephant, one may jump, show various signs of fearfulness, and sometimes one may keep looking behind him. When there is emotion due to the presence of an enemy, one looks for a fatal weapon and tries to escape.

When Kåñëa returned from the forest of Våndävana, Mother Yaçodä was so emotional from seeing her son that milk began to flow from her breasts. This is an instance of emotion caused by seeing a dear object.

In the Tenth Canto, 23rd Chapter, 13th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çukadeva Gosvämé informs King Parékñit: "My dear King, the wives of the brähmaëas were usually very much attached to the glorification of Kåñëa, and they were always anxious to get an opportunity to see Him. Because of this, when they heard that Kåñëa was nearby, they became very anxious to see Him and immediately left their homes." This is an instance of emotional activity caused by the presence of someone who is very dear.

When Pütanä, the demoniac witch, was struck down and killed by Kåñëa, Mother Yaçodä was struck with wonder and began to cry emotionally, "Oh, what is this? What is this?" When she saw that her dear baby Kåñëa was playing on the chest of the dead demonic woman, Mother Yaçodä, at a loss what to do, began to walk this way and that. This is an instance of being emotional on account of seeing something ghastly.

When Kåñëa uprooted the two arjuna trees and Yaçodä heard the sound of the trees crashing down, she became overcome with emotion and simply stared upwards, being too bewildered to know what else to do. This is an instance of being emotional from hearing a tumultuous sound.

When there was a forest fire in Våndävana, all the cowherd men assembled together and desperately appealed to Kåñëa for protection. This is an instance of emotion caused by fire.

The whirlwind demon known as Tåëävarta once carried Kåñëa off from the ground and blew Him around, along with some very big trees. At that time, Mother Yaçodä could not see her son, and she was so disturbed that she began to walk this way and that. This is an instance of emotion caused by severe wind.

In the Tenth Canto, 25th Chapter, 11th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, there is a description of Indra's causing severe torrents of rain at Våndävana. All the cows and cowherd boys became so afflicted by the wind and cold that they all gathered together to take shelter under the lotus feet of Kåñëa. This is an instance of emotion caused by severe rainfall.

There were severe torrents of hail when Kåñëa was staying in the forest of Våndävana, and the elderly persons bade Him: "Kåñëa, don't You move now! Even persons who are stronger and older than You cannot move, and You are just a little boy. So please stay still!" This is an instance of emotion caused by heavy hailing.

When Kåñëa was chastising Käliya in the poisonous water of the Yamunä, Mother Yaçodä began to speak emotionally: "Oh, see how the earth appears to be trembling! There appears to be an earth tremor, and in the sky tears are flying here and there! My dear son has entered into the poisonous water of the Yamunä. What shall I do now?" This is an instance of emotion resulting from a natural disturbance.

In the arena of Kaàsa, when Kåñëa was attacked by big elephants, all of the ladies present began to address Him in this way: "My dear boy—please leave this place immediately! Please leave this place immediately! Don't You see the big elephants coming to attack You? Your innocent gazing upon them is causing us too much perturbation!" Kåñëa then told Mother Yaçodä, "My dear Mother, don't be perturbed by the appearance of the elephants and the horses that are so forcibly coming and raising dust, causing blindness to these lotus-eyed women. Let even the Keçé demon come before Me; My arms will still be adequate for victory. So please don't be perturbed."

In the Lalita-mädhava, a friend tells Mother Yaçodä: "How wonderful it is that when the Çaìkhacüòa demon—vast and strong as a great hill—attacked your Cupid-like beautiful son, there was no one present in Våndävana to help. And yet the demon was killed by your little son. It appears to be due to the result of severe penances and austerities in your past lives that your son was saved in this way."

In the same Lalita-mädhava there is an account of Kåñëa's kidnapping Rukmiëé at her royal marriage ceremony. At that time all of the princes present began to converse amongst themselves, saying, "We have our elephants, horses, chariots, bows, arrows and swords, so why should we be afraid of Kåñëa? Let us attack Him! He is nothing but a lusty cowherd boy! He cannot take away the Princess in this way! Let us all attack Him!" This is an instance of emotion caused by the presence of enemies.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé is trying to prove by the above examples that in relationship with Kåñëa there is no question of impersonalism. All personal activities are there in relationship with Kåñëa.

Madness

Çréla Bilvamaìgala Thäkur prays in his book as follows: "Let Çrématé Rädhäräëé purify the whole world, because She has surrendered Herself completely unto Kåñëa. Out of Her ecstatic love for Him, She sometimes acted just like an addled person and attempted to churn curd, although there was no curd in the pot. And seeing this, Kåñëa became so enchanted by Rädhäräëé that He began to milk a bull instead of a cow." These are some of the instances of insanity or madness in connection with the love affairs of Rädhä and Kåñëa. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is said that when Kåñëa entered the poisonous waters of the Yamunä, Çrématé Yaçodä Devé went insane. Instead of searching for curative herbs, she began to speak to the trees as if they were snake chanters. With folded hands she began to bow down to the trees, asking them, "What is the medicinal herb which can check Kåñëa's dying from this poisonous water?" This is an instance of insanity caused by some great danger.

How a devotee can be in a state of insanity because of ecstatic love is described in the Tenth Canto, 30th Chapter, 4th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, where the gopés were searching for Kåñëa in the forests of Våndävana. The gopés were loudly singing the glories of Kåñëa and wandering from one forest to another in search of Him. They knew that Kåñëa is not localized, but all-pervading. He is in the sky, He is in the water, He is in the air, He is the supersoul in everyone's heart. Thus the gopés began to inquire from all kinds of trees and plants about the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is an instance of ecstatic madness on the part of devotees.

Similarly, there are symptoms of diseases caused by ecstatic love. This condition is credited by learned scholars as mahäbhäva. This highly elevated condition is also called divyonmäda, or transcendental madness.

Forgetfulness

When Kåñëa was absent from Våndävana and was staying in Mathurä, Çrématé Rädhäräëé sent news to Him that His mother, the Queen of Braja, was feeling such separation from Him that there was foam coming from her mouth, like the foam on the shore of the ocean. And sometimes she was raising her arms like the waves of the ocean, and because of her intense feelings of separation, she was rolling on the ground and creating a tumultuous roaring sound. And sometimes she was remaining completely silent, like a calm sea. These symptoms of separation from Kåñëa are called apasmära, or forgetfulness. One completely forgets his position when he manifests these symptoms in ecstatic love.

Another message was once sent to Kåñëa informing Him that after He had killed Kaàsa, one of Kaàsa's demon friends had gone insane. This demon was foaming at the mouth, waving his arms and rolling on the ground. This demonic demonstration is in relationship with Kåñëa in ghastly humor. This mellow or flavor is one of the indirect relationships with Kåñëa. The first five kinds of relationships are called direct, and the other seven are called indirect. Some way or other, the demon must have had some relationship with Kåñëa, because these symptoms developed when he heard that Kåñëa had already killed Kaàsa. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé remarks that there is also transcendental excellence in this kind of symptom.

Disease

When Kåñëa was absent from Våndävana and was staying at Mathurä, some of His friends informed Him, "My dear Kåñëa, because of their separation from You, the inhabitants of Braja are so afflicted that they appear to be diseased. Their bodies are feverish, and they cannot move properly. They are simply lying down on the ground and breathing heavily."

In the Tenth Canto, 12th Chapter, 41st verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Mahäräj Parékñit asked about Lord Ananta, and upon hearing this question, Çukadeva Gosvämé began to show symptoms of collapsing. Yet he checked himself and answered King Parékñit's question in a mild voice. This collapsing condition is described as a feverish state resulting from ecstatic pleasure.

There is another statement in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam telling of the damsels of Braja meeting Kåñëa at the sacred place of Kurukñetra, many years after their childhood pastimes. When they met in that sacred place, all the gopés became stunned by the occurrence of a solar eclipse. Their breathing, blinking of the eyes and all similar activities stopped, and they stood before Kåñëa just like statues. This is another instance of a diseased condition resulting from exhuberant transcendental pleasure.

NoD 30-1970: Further Features of Ecstatic Love for Kåñëa

Chapter Thirty

Further Features of Ecstatic Love for Kåñëa

Confusion

There is the following statement in the Haàsadüta: "One day when Çrématé Rädhäräëé was feeling much affliction because of Her separation from Kåñëa, She went to the bank of the Yamunä with some of Her friends. There Rädhäräëé saw a cottage wherein She and Kåñëa had experienced many loving pleasures, and by remembering those incidents She immediately became overcome with dizziness. This dizziness was very prominently visible." This is an instance of confusion caused by separation.

Similarly, there is a statement describing confusion caused by fearfulness. These symptoms were exhibited by Arjuna when he saw Kåñëa's universal form on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. His confusion was so strong that his bow and arrows fell from his hand, and he could not perceive anything clearly.

Death

Once the Bakäsura demon assumed the shape of a very big duck and opened his mouth in order to swallow Kåñëa and all the cowherd boys. When Kåñëa was entering into the demon's mouth, Balaräma and the other cowherd boys almost fainted and appeared as though they had no life. Even if they are illusioned by some ghastly scene or by any accidental occurrence, devotees never forget Kåñëa. Even in the greatest danger they can remember Kåñëa. This is the benefit of Kåñëa consciousness: even at the time of death, when all the functions of the body become dislocated, the devotee can remember Kåñëa in his innermost consciousness, and this saves him from falling down into material existence. In this way Kåñëa consciousness immediately takes one from the material platform to the spiritual world.

In this connection there is a statement about persons who died at Mathurä: "These persons had a slight breathing exhiliration, their eyes were wide open, the colors of their bodies were changed, and they began to utter the holy name of Kåñëa. In this condition they gave up their material bodies." These symptoms are prior manifestations of death.

Laziness

When, because of self-satisfaction or dislike of excessive labor, a person does not perform his duty in spite of having the energy, he is called lazy. This laziness also is manifest in ecstatic love of Kåñëa. For example, when some brähmaëas were requested by Nanda Mahäräj to circumambulate Govardhan Hill, they told him that they were more interested in offering benedictions than in circumambulating Govardhan Hill. This is an instance of laziness caused by self-satisfaction.

Once when Kåñëa, along with His cowherd boy friends, was having a mock battle, Subala showed the symptoms of fatigue. Kåñëa immediately told His other friends: "Subala is feeling too fatigued from mock-fighting with Me. So please do not disturb him anymore by inviting him to fight." This is an instance of laziness caused by dislike of excessive labor.

Inertness

In the Tenth Canto, 21st Chapter, 13th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is an appreciation by the gopés of the inertia of the cows in Våndävana. The gopés saw that the cows were hearing the sweet songs vibrated by Kåñëa's flute and were appearing to be drinking the nectar of these transcendental sounds. The calves were stunned, and they forgot to drink the milk from the milk bags. Their eyes seemed to be embracing Kåñëa, and there were tears in their eyes. This is an instance of inertia resulting from hearing the transcendental vibrations of Kåñëa's flute.

When Lakñmaëa became disturbed upon hearing words against Kåñëa, she remained inert and did not move her eyelids. This is another example of inertia caused by hearing.

In the Tenth Canto, 71st Chapter, 35th verse of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, there is an account of King Yudhiñöhira's bewilderment after his bringing Kåñëa into his home with the greatest respect. King Yudhiñöhira was very much bewildered because of his transcendental pleasure at having Kåñëa present in his house. In fact, while receiving Kåñëa, King Yudhiñöhira forgot himself. This is an instance of inertia resulting from the ecstasy of seeing Kåñëa.

There is another instance in the Tenth Canto, 39th Chapter, 34th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. When Kåñëa was going to Mathurä, all of the gopés were standing behind Kåñëa, and upon seeing the chariot leaving, they stood there stunned and did not move. They remained like that until the flag of the chariot and the dust thrown up by its wheels became invisible.

Kåñëa was once addressed by His friend thus: "My dear Mukunda [Kåñëa], due to their being separated from You, the cowherd boys are standing just like neglected Deities in the house of a professional brähmaëa." There is a class of professional brähmaëas who take to Deity worship as a means of earning their livelihood. Brähmaëas in this class are not very interested in the Deity; they are interested mainly in the money they can earn as holy men. So the Deities worshiped by such professional brähmaëas are not properly decorated, Their dress is not changed, and Their bodies are not cleaned. They look dirty and are not very attractive. Actually, Deity worship should be done very carefully: the dress should be changed daily, and as far as possible there should be ornaments. Everything should be so clean that the Diety is attractive to all visitors. Here the example is given of the Deities in the house of a professional brähmaëa because such Deities are not at all attractive. The friends of Kåñëa, in the absence of Kåñëa, were appearing like such neglected Deities.

Bashfulness

When Rädhäräëé was first introduced to Kåñëa, She felt very bashful. One of Her friends addressed Her in this way: "My dear friend, You have already sold Yourself and all Your beauty to Govinda. Now You should not be bashful. Please look upon Him cheerfully. One who has sold an elephant to another person should not make a miserly quarrel about selling the trident which controls the elephant." This kind of bashfulness is due to a new introduction in ecstatic love with Kåñëa.

The heavenly King, Indra, upon being defeated in his fight with Kåñëa for possession of the pärijäta flower, became very bashful because of his defeat. He was standing before Kåñëa, bowing down his head, when Kåñëa said, "All right, Indra, you can take this pärijäta flower. Otherwise, you will not be able to show your face before your wife, Çacédevé." Indra's bashfulness was due to defeat. In another instance, Kåñëa began to praise Uddhava for his various high qualifications. Upon being praised by Kåñëa, Uddhava also bowed down his head bashfully.

In Hari-vaàça, Satyabhämä, feeling slighted by Rukmiëé's high position, said, "My dear Kåñëa, the Raivataka Mountain is always full of spring flowers, but when I have become persona non grata to You, what is the use of my observing them?" This is an instance of bashfulness resulting from being defeated.

Concealment

There is a symptom of ecstatic love known as concealment, or trying to hide one's real mental condition by externally showing another attitude. In this state of mind one tries to hide his mind by looking away in different directions, by unnecessarily trying for something which is impossible, or by using words which cover one's real thoughts. According to äcäryas expert in the study of psychological activities, these attempts at hiding one's real affections are another part of ecstatic feeling for Kåñëa.

In the Tenth Canto, 32nd Chapter, 14th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çukadeva Gosvämé states, "My dear King, the gopés were always beautiful and decorated with confidential smiles and alluring garments. In their movements, intended to give impetus to lusty feelings, they would sometimes press Kåñëa's hand on their laps, and sometimes they would keep His lotus feet on their breasts. After doing this, they would talk with Kåñëa as if they were very angry with Him."

There is another instance of this concealment in ecstatic love. When Kåñëa, the supreme joker, planted the pärijäta tree in the courtyard of Satyabhämä, Rukmiëé, the daughter of King Vérabhadra, became very angry, but due to her natural gentle behavior, she did not express anything. No one could understand Rukmiëé's real mental condition. This is an instance of competitive concealment.

There is another instance in the First Canto, 11th Chapter, 28th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. After entering Dvärakä, Kåñëa was received in different ways by different members of His family. Upon seeing their husband from a distance, the queens of Dvärakä immediately embraced Him within their minds and slowly glanced over Him. As Kåñëa came nearer, they pushed their sons forward to embrace Him. Others were trying, out of shyness, not to shed tears, but they still could not keep the tears from gliding down. This is an instance of concealment caused by shyness.

On another occasion, when Çrématé Rädhäräëé thought that Kåñëa was involved with another woman, She addressed Her friend in this manner: "My dear friend, as soon as I think of Kåñëa the cowherd boy attached to some other woman, I become stricken with fearfulness and the hairs on My body stand up. I must be very careful that Kåñëa will not see Me at such times." This is an instance of concealment caused by shyness and diplomatic behavior.

It has been stated: "Although Çrématé Rädhäräëé developed a deep loving affection for Kåñëa, She hid Her attitude in the core of Her heart so that others could not detect Her actual condition." This is an instance of concealment caused by gentleness.

Once when Kåñëa and His cowherd friends were enjoying friendly conversation, Kåñëa began to address His associates in casual language. At that time Kåñëa's servant, Patré, was also enjoying the conversation. But then, remembering his position of servitude, Patré bowed down before his master, and with great respect and control, he stifled his smiling. This subdued smiling is an instance of concealment caused by a respectful attitude.

Remembering

There are many symptoms of ecstatic love caused by remembering Kåñëa. For example, one friend of Kåñëa informed Him, "My dear Mukunda, just after observing a bluish cloud in the sky, the lotus-eyed Rädhäräëé immediately began to remember You. And simply by observing this cloud She became lusty for Your association." This is an instance of remembering Kåñëa in ecstatic love because of seeing something resembling Him. Kåñëa's bodily complexion is very similar to the bluish hue of a cloud, so simply by observing a bluish cloud, Çrématé Rädhäräëé remembered Him.

One devotee said that even when he was not very attentive he would sometimes, seemingly out of madness, remember the lotus feet of Kåñëa within his heart. This is an instance of remembrance resulting from constant practice. In other words, devotees who are constantly thinking of the lotus feet of Kåñëa, even if they are momentarily inattentive, will see the figure of Lord Kåñëa appearing within their hearts.

Argumentativeness

Madhumaìgala was an intimate friend of Kåñëa coming from the brähmaëa community. Kåñëa's friends were mostly cowherd boys belonging to the vaiçya community, but there were others who belonged to the brähmaëa community. Actually, in Våndävana the vaiçya community and the brähmaëa community are considered prominent. This Madhumaìgala one day addressed Kåñëa in this fashion: "My dear friend, I can see that You are not aware of the peacock feathers that are falling on the ground, and at the same time You are unmindful of the flower garlands which are offered to You. I think I can guess the reason for Your absent-mindedness when I see Your two eyes flying over to the eyes of Çrématé Rädhäräëé, just like black drones flying to lotus flowers." This is an instance of an argumentative suggestion in ecstatic love.

Once while Kåñëa was out walking, one of the associates of Rädhäräëé told Her: "My dear friend, do You think that this walking personality is a tämala tree?* If He is a tämala tree, then how is it possible for Him to walk and be so beautiful? Then, this personality might be a cloud. But if He's a cloud, then where is the beautiful moon within? Under the circumstances, I think it may be granted that this person is the same enchanting Personality of Godhead by whose flute vibration the three worlds are captivated. He must be the same Mukunda who is standing before Govardhan Hill." This is another instance of an argumentative presentation of ecstatic love.

Anxiety

In the Tenth Canto, 29th Chapter, 26th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, when Kåñëa asked all the gopés to go back to their homes, they did not like it. Because of their grief at this, they were sighing heavily, and their beautiful faces appeared to be drying up. In this condition they remained, without making a sound. They began to draw lines on the ground with their toes, and with their tears they washed the black ointment from their eyes onto their breasts, which were covered with red kuìkuma powder. This is an instance of anxiety in ecstatic love.

One of the friends of Kåñëa once informed Him, "My dear killer of the demon Mura, Your kind and gentle mother is very anxious because You have not returned home, and with great difficulty she has passed the evening constantly sitting on the corridor platform of Your home. It is certainly astonishing how You could forget Your mother while You are off somewhere engaged in Your playful activities!" This is another instance of deep anxiety in ecstatic love.

When Mother Yaçodä was very anxiously waiting for Kåñëa to return from Mathurä, Mahäräj Nanda gave her this solace: "My dear Yaçodä, please don't be worried. Please dry your beautiful lotus-like face. There is no need for you to breathe so hotly. I will go immediately with Akrüra to the palace of Kaàsa and get your son back for you." Here is an instance of anxiety in ecstatic love caused by Kåñëa's awkward position.

Thoughtfulness

In the Vaiçäkha-mähätmya section of the Padma Puräëa a devotee states that though in some of the eighteen Puräëas the process of glorifying Lord Viñëu is not mentioned, and the glorifying of some demigod is offered, such glorification must be continued for millions of years. For when one studies the Puräëas very scrutinizingly, he can see that, ultimately, Lord Viñëu is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is an instance of ecstatic love developed out of thoughtfulness.

In the Tenth Canto, 68th Chapter, 30th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, there is an account of Rukmiëédevé's writing a letter to Kåñëa requesting Him to kidnap her before her marriage to another person. At that time the specific attachment of Rukmiëé for Kåñëa was expressed by Rukmiëé as follows: "My dear Lord Kåñëa, Your transcendental glories are chanted by great sages who are free from material contamination, and in exchange for such glorification You are so kind that You freely distribute Yourself to such devotees. As one can elevate oneself simply by Your grace, so also by Your direction alone one may be lost to all benedictions under the influence of eternal time. Therefore I have selected Your lordship as my husband, brushing aside personalities like Brahmä and Indra—not to mention others." Rukmiëé enhanced her love for Kåñëa simply by thinking of Him. This is an instance of thoughtfulness in ecstatic love.

Endurance

When a person is fully satisfied due to attaining knowledge, transcending all distress, or achieving his desired goal of life in transcendental devotional service to God—at that time his state of endurance or steady mind is called dhåti. At this stage one is not perturbed by any amount of loss, nor does anything appear to be unachieved by him.

According to the opinion of Bhartåhari, the learned scholar, when a person is elevated to this state of endurance, he thinks as follows: "I do not wish to be a highly posted government servant. I shall be satisfied even if I have to eat food collected by begging. I shall prefer to remain naked, without proper dress of garments. I shall prefer to lie down on the ground without any matress. And despite all these disadvantages, I shall refuse to serve anyone, not even the government." In other words, when one is in ecstatic love with the Personality of Godhead, he can endure any kind of disadvantages calculated under the material concept of life.

Nanda Mahäräj, the father of Kåñëa, used to think: "In my pasturing ground the goddess of fortune is personally present, and I possess more than ten hundred, thousand cows which loiter here and there. And above all, I have a son like Kåñëa, who is such a powerful, wonderful worker. Therefore, even though I am a householder, I am feeling so satisfied!" This is an instance of mental endurance resulting from the absence of all distress.

In another instance a devotee says, "I am always swimming in the nectarean ocean of the pastimes of the Personality of Godhead, and as such I have no more attraction for religious rituals, economic development, sense gratification, or even the ultimate salvation of merging into the existence of Brahman." This is an instance of the mind's endurance due to achieving the best thing in the world. The best thing in the world is absorption in Kåñëa consciousness.

Happiness

It is described in the Viñëu Puräëa that when Akrüra came to take Kåñëa and Balaräma to Mathurä, just by seeing Their faces he became so cheerful that all over his body there were symptoms of ecstatic love. This state is called happiness.

It is stated in the Tenth Canto, 33rd Chapter, 12th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam: "Upon seeing that Kåñëa's arm was placed on her shoulder, one of the gopés engaged in the räsa dance became so ecstatically happy that she kissed Kåñëa on His cheek." This is an instance of feeling happiness because of achieving a desired goal.

Eagerness

In the Tenth Canto, 71st Chapter, 29th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, it is said: "When Kåñëa first came from His Kingdom, Dvärakä, to Indraprastha,* the young females of the city became so eager to see Him that even at night, when they were lying down with their husbands, they could not restrain their eagerness. Even though they were not properly dressed and although their hair was loose and there were many household duties to perform, they still gave up everything and immediately went into the street to see Kåñëa." This is an instance of eagerness of ecstatic love.

In his book Stavävalé, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé has prayed for the mercy of Rädhäräëé, who was so captivated by the flute vibrations of Kåñëa that She immediately asked information of His whereabouts from residents in the Våndävana forest. Upon first seeing Kåñëa, She was filled with such ecstatic love and pleasure that She began to scratch her ears. The damsels of Braja and Rädhäräëé were very expert in talking cunningly, so as soon as they saw Kåñëa they began their talkings; and Kåñëa, pretending to go for some flowers for them, immediately left that place and entered into a mountain cave. This is another instance of eager loving exchanges on the parts of both the gopés and Kåñëa.

When Kåñëa was fighting with the Käliya snake by dancing on his heads, Käliya bit Kåñëa on the leg. At that time Garuòa became infuriated and began to murmur: "Kåñëa is so powerful that simply by His thundering voice the wives of Käliya have had miscarriages. Because my Lord has been insulted by this snake, I wish to immediately devour him, but I cannot do so in the presence of my Lord, because He may become angry with me." This is an instance of eagerness to act in ecstatic love as a result of dishonor to Kåñëa.

When Çiçupäla objected to the worship of Kåñëa in the räja-süya arena at a sacrifice organized by Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira, Nakula, the younger brother of Arjuna, said, "A person who cannot tolerate the worship of Kåñëa is my enemy and is possessed of a demonic nature. Therefore I wish to strike my left foot upon his broad head, just to punish him more strongly than the wand of Yamaräja!" Then Nakula began to lament like this: "O, all auspiciousness to Lord Kåñëa! I am so surprised to see that the condemned descendants of the Kuru dynasty, who so unlawfully occupied the throne of the Kuru kingdom, are at the same time criticizing Kåñëa with diplomatic devices. O, this is intolerable!" This is another instance of eagerness caused by dishonor to Kåñëa.

Haughtiness, Resulting in Dishonorable Words

In the Vidagdha-mädhava, Kuöilä, a sister-in-law of Rädhäräëé, began to criticize Kåñëa in this way: "Kåñëa, You are standing here, and Rädhäräëé, who has just been married to my brother, is also standing here. Now I know both of You very well, so why should I not be very anxious to protect my sister-in-law from Your dancing eyes?" This is an instance of dishonorable words used to indirectly criticize Kåñëa.

Similarly, some of the gopés once began to address Kåñëa with these dishonorable words: "My dear Kåñëa, You are a first-class thief. So please leave this place immediately. We know You love Candrävalé more than us, but there is no use in praising her in our presence! Kindly do not contaminate the name of Rädhäräëé in this place!" This is another instance of dishonorable words cast upon Kåñëa in ecstatic love.

There is another statement in the Tenth Canto, 31st Chapter, 16th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. When all the gopés came out of their homes to meet Kåñëa in the Våndävana forest, Kåñëa refused to accept them and asked them to go home, giving them some moral instruction. At that time the gopés began to speak as follows: "My dear Kåñëa, there is extreme distress in being out of Your presence, and there is extreme happiness simply in seeing You. Therefore we have all left our husbands, relatives, brothers and friends and have simply come to You, being captivated by the sound of Your transcendental flute. O infallible one, You had better know what is the reason for our coming here. In plain words, we are here simply because we have been captivated by the sweet sound of Your flute. We are all beautiful girls, and You are so foolish that You are rejecting our association. We do not know anyone, other than Yourself, who would miss this opportunity to associate with young girls in the dead of night!" This is another instance of indirect insults used against Kåñëa in ecstatic love.

In the Padyävalé, one of the friends of Rädhäräëé once addressed Her thusly: "My dear friend, please do not be too puffed up because Kåñëa has decorated Your forehead with His own hand. It may be that Kåñëa is yet attracted by some other beautiful girl. I see that the decoration on Your forehead is very nicely made, and so it appears that Kåñëa was not too disturbed in painting it. Otherwise, he could not have painted such exact lines!" This is an instance of indirect dishonor caused by Rädhä's good fortune.

In the Tenth Canto, 30th Chapter, 26th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is the following statement: "When the gopés were searching after Kåñëa and Rädhä after the räsa dance, they thus began to speak amongst themselves: 'We have seen the footprints of Kåñëa and Rädhä on the ground of Våndävana, and they are giving us great pain, because Kåñëa is everything to us. But that girl is so cunning that She has taken Him away alone and is enjoying His kissing without sharing Him with us!' " This is another instance of casting dishonorable words against Kåñëa and Rädhä, pouting over the good fortune of Çrématé Rädhäräëé.

Envy

Sometimes when the cowherd boys used to play in the forests of Våndävana, Kåñëa would play on one side, and Balaräma would play on another. There would be competition and mock fighting between the two parties, and when Kåñëa's party was defeated by Balaräma, the boys would say, "If Balaräma's party remains victorious, then who in the world can be weaker than ourselves?" This is an instance of envy in ecstatic love.

Impudence

In the Tenth Canto, 52nd Chapter, 33rd verse of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Rukmiëé addresses a letter to Kåñëa as follows: "My dear unconquerable Kåñëa, my marriage day is fixed for tomorrow. I request that You come to the city of Vidarbha without advertising Yourself. Then have Your soldiers and commanders suddenly surround and defeat all the strength of the King of Magadha and by thus adopting the methods of the demons, please kidnap and marry me."

According to the Vedic system there are eight kinds of marriages, out of which one is called räkñasa-viväha. Räkñasa-viväha refers to kidnapping a girl and marrying her by force and is considered to be a demonic method. When Rukmiëé was going to be married to Çiçupäla by the choice of her elder brother, she wrote the above letter to Kåñëa requesting Him to kidnap her. This is an instance of impudence in ecstatic love for Kåñëa.

One of the gopés said, "May Kåñëa's sweet flute be washed away by the waves of the Yamunä, and let it fall into the ocean! The sweet sound of that flute is so impudent that it makes us lose all composure before our superiors."

Dizziness

Every evening at sunset Kåñëa used to return from the pasturing ground where He herded cows. Sometimes when Mother Yaçodä could not hear the sweet vibration of His flute she would become very anxious, and because of this she would feel dizzy. Thus, dizziness caused by anxiety in ecstatic love for Kåñëa is also possible.

When Yaçodä had tied Kåñëa up one time, she began to think, "Kåñëa's body is so soft and delicate, how could I have tied Him with rope?" Thinking this, her brain became puzzled, and she felt dizziness.

The gopés were advised by their superiors to bolt the doors at night, but they were so carefree that they did not carry out this order very rigidly. Sometimes, by thinking of Kåñëa, they became so confident of being out of all danger that they would lie down at night in the courtyards of their houses. This is an instance of dizziness in ecstatic love due to natural affection for Kåñëa.

It may be questioned why devotees of Kåñëa should be attacked by dizziness, which is usually considered a sign of the modes of ignorance. To answer this question, Çré Jéva Gosvämé has said that the devotees of Lord Kåñëa are always transcendental to all the modes of material nature; when they feel dizziness or go to sleep, they are not considered to be sleeping under the modes of nature, but are accepted as being in a trance of devotional service. There is an authoritative statement in the Garuòa Puräëa about mystic yogés who are under the direct shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead: "In all three stages of their consciousness—namely, wakefulness, dreaming and deep sleep—the devotees are absorbed in the thought of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore, in their complete absorption in the thought of Kåñëa, they do not sleep."

Alertness

A devotee once stated, "I have already conquered the modes of ignorance, and I am now on the platform of transcendental knowledge. Therefore I shall be engaged only in searching after the Supreme Personality of Godhead." This is an instance of alertness in ecstatic love. Transcendental alertness is possible when the illusory condition is completely overcome. At that stage, when in contact with any reaction of material elements, such as sound, smell, touch or taste, the devotee realizes the transcendental presence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In this condition the ecstatic symptoms (i.e. standing of the hair on the body, rolling of the eyeballs and getting up from sleep) are persistently visible.

When Çrématé Rädhäräëé first saw Kåñëa, She suddenly became conscious of all transcendental happiness, and the functions of Her different limbs were stunned. When Lalitä, Her constant companion, whispered into Her ear the holy name of Kåñëa, Rädhäräëé immediately opened Her eyes wide. This is an instance of alertness caused by hearing the sound of Kåñëa's name.

One day, in a joking mood, Kåñëa informed Rädhäräëé, "My dear Rädhäräëé, I am going to give up Your company." Upon saying this, He immediately disappeared, and because of this Rädhäräëé became so afflicted that the hue of Her body changed, and She immediately fell down upon the ground of Våndävana. She had practically stopped breathing, but when She smelled the flavor of the flowers on the ground, She awoke in ecstasy and got up. This is an instance of transcendental alertness caused by smelling.

When Kåñëa was touching the body of one gopé, the gopé began to address her companion thus: "My dear friend, whose hand is this touching my body? I had become very afraid after seeing the darkened forest on the bank of the Yamunä, but suddenly the touch of this hand has saved me from hysterical fits." This is an instance of alertness caused by touching.

One of the gopés informed Kåñëa, "My dear Kåñëa, when You disappeared from the arena of the räsa dance, our most dear friend, Rädhäräëé, immediately fell on the ground and lost consciousness. But after this, when I offered Her some of Your chewed betel nut remnants, She immediately returned to consciousness with jubilant symptoms in Her body." This is an instance of alertness caused by tasting.

One night Çrématé Rädhäräëé was talking in a dream. "My dear Kåñëa," She said. "Please do not play any more jokes on Me! Please stop! And please don't touch My garments either. Otherwise I shall inform the elderly persons, and I shall disclose all of Your naughty behavior." While She was talking like this in a dream, She suddenly awoke and saw some of Her superiors standing before Her. Thus Rädhäräëé became ashamed and bowed Her head. This is an instance of alertness after awakening from sleep.

There is another instance of this. A messenger from Kåñëa came to Çrématé Rädhäräëé while She was sleeping, and Rädhäräëé immediately awakened. Similarly, when Kåñëa began to blow on His flute in the night, all of the gopés, the beautiful daughters of the cowherd men, immediately got up from their sleep. There is a very beautiful comparison made in this connection: "The lotus flower is sometimes surrounded by white swans, and sometimes it is surrounded by black wasps who are collecting its honey. When there is a thundering in the sky, the swans go away, but the black wasps stay to enjoy the lotus flowers." The gopés' sleeping condition is compared to the white swans, and the sound of Kåñëa's flute is compared to a black wasp. When Kåñëa's flute sounded, the white swans, which represent the sleeping condition of the gopés, were immediately vanquished, and the black wasp sound of the flute began to enjoy the lotus flower of the gopés' beauty.

NoD 31-1970: Additional Symptoms

Chapter Thirty-one

Additional Symptoms

All the above-mentioned thirty-one symptoms of ecstatic love are called vyabhicäré, or disturbing. All these symptoms refer to apparently disturbed conditions, but even in such disturbed conditions there is acute ecstatic love for Kåñëa. These symptoms, however, can be divided into three groups: first class, second class and third. There are many other disturbing symptoms in ecstatic love, such as envy, anxiety, pride, jealousy, conclusion, cowardliness, forgiveness, impatience, hankering, regret, doubtfulness and impudence. These are included in all the thirty-one conditions of ecstatic love. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has very nicely analyzed the different kinds of disturbing symptoms, and although it is very difficult to find the exact English equivalents for many Sanskrit words used here, his analysis will now be presented.

When one becomes malicious upon seeing another's advancement of life, his state of mind is generally called envy. When one becomes frightened at seeing a lightning bolt in the sky, that fearfulness brings on anxiety. Therefore, fearfulness and anxiety can be taken as one. When someone wants to hide his real mentality, it is called avahittha, or concealment. When a person wants to exhibit superiority, it is called pride. Both of these can be classified under pretension. In a pretentious attitude both avahittha and pride are to be found. When one cannot tolerate an offense committed by another, it is called amarña, and when one cannot tolerate the opulence of another it is called jealousy. Jealousy and amarña are both caused by intolerance. When one is able to establish the correct import of a word, it can be called conclusiveness. And before such a conclusive determination of import, there must be thoughtful consideration. Therefore, the act of consideration is present during the establishment of a conclusion. When one presents himself as ignorant, it is called humility, and when there is absence of enthusiasm it is called cowardice. Therefore, in humility, there is cowardice also. When the mind is steadfast it is called enduring, and when one can tolerate others' offenses, that is called endurance. Therefore, forgiveness and endurance can be synonymous. When one becomes anxious for time to pass, that is called impatience, and when one sees something wonderful one is said to be struck with wonder. Impatience may be caused by being struck with wonder, and so impatience and being struck with wonder can be synonymous. When anxiety is in its dormant stage it is called hankering. Therefore, anxiety and hankering can also be synonymous. When one becomes regretful for some offense, his feeling is called bashfulness. In this way, bashfulness and regret can be synonymous. Doubtfulness is one of the aspects of argument. After exhibiting impudence one becomes restless. Therefore restlessness and impudence can be synonymous.

When all such symptoms are included in ecstatic love, they are called aïcäré, or continuously existing ecstatic symptoms. All of these symptoms are transcendental, and they are exhibited in different ways, acting and interacting under different conditions. They are like the reciprocation of love between the lover and beloved.

When a person is envious or defamed, there may be a change in the color of the body. This can be classified as vibhäva, or sub-ecstasy. Sometimes illusion, collapse and strong anxiety are also considered to be vibhäva. When there are many such symptoms, they can simply be grouped together under ecstatic love.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that fright, sleep, fatigue, laziness and the madness of intoxication are sometimes grouped under continuous symptoms of ecstatic love, and they are due to a strong attraction.

False argument, determination, steadiness, remembrance, joyfulness, ignorance, humility and unconsciousness are also different symptoms of ecstatic love. Dependence is also grouped under ecstatic love, and this can be divided into superior dependence and inferior dependence. The direct differentiations between superior and inferior dependence are ascertained by Rüpa Gosvämé and will be presented in due course.

One devotee exclaimed, "Oh, I cannot see the district of Mathurä! Even though by simply hearing the name of Mathurä the hairs of my body are standing up, I cannot see the place. So of what use are my eyes?" This statement reveals a strong anxiety to see the district of Mathurä resulting from a strong attachment to Kåñëa. There is another instance of this strong attachment for Kåñëa expressed by Bhéma when he began to murmur, "My arms are just like thunderbolts, but despite these arms I could not smash Çiçupäla while he was blaspheming Kåñëa. Therefore, of what use are these strong arms?" In this instance Bhéma became angry, and, being influenced by such anger, his hopelessness became a cause for strong attachment to Kåñëa. This instance can be described as strong attachment for Kåñëa in anger.

When Arjuna witnessed the universal form of Kåñëa, whose dazzling teeth were practically devouring the very existence of the universe, Arjuna's mouth became dried up. At that time Arjuna forgot himself and could not understand that he was Arjuna, Kåñëa's friend, although he was always dependent upon Kåñëa's mercy. This incident is an example of inferior dependence.

Sometimes ghastly activities also support strong ecstatic love for Kåñëa. This state of mind is called ecstatic fearfulness under illusion. In the Tenth Canto, 23rd Chapter, 32nd verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is the following statement by the brähmaëas who were performing sacrifices: "We have all been born into three advantageous conditions: we are in high brähmaëa families, we have ceremoniously received the sacred thread, and we are also properly initiated by a spiritual master. But, alas, in spite of all these advantages, we are condemned. Even our observance of brahmacarya [celibacy] is condemned.' The brähmaëas thus began to condemn their own activities. They realized that in spite of being so elevated by birth, education and culture, they still were under the spell of the illusory energy. They also admitted that even great yogés who are not devotees of the Lord are covered by the influence of material energy. This kind of hopelessness felt by the brähmaëas who were performing ritualistic ceremonies shows practically no attachment for Kåñëa. There is another hopelessness, however, which shows attachment for Kåñëa. When the bull demon attacked the damsels of Braja, they began to cry out, "My dear Kåñëa—please save us! We are now gone!" This is hopelessness with attachment for Kåñëa.

When the Keçé demon was assassinated by Kåñëa, Kaàsa became hopeless. He began to say, "Keçédaitya was as dear to me as my own life, but he has been killed by some cowherd boy who is crude, uneducated and ignorant of fighting. Even though I have defeated the King of heaven without difficulty, still I do not know the value of life." Because this hopelessness has a slight touch of attraction for Kåñëa, it is considered to be a reflection of ecstatic love in hopelessness.

Kaàsa once rebuked Akrüra by saying, "You are such a fool that you are accepting the Supreme Personality of Godhead to be a cowherd boy, simply because He has defeated some harmless water snake! The boy may have lifted one pebble called Govardhan Hill, but what is more surprising than that is your statement that this boy is the Personality of Godhead!" This is an instance of a maliciously opposing element, caused by hopelessness in ecstatic love for Kåñëa.

One devotee tried to console a kadamba tree when the tree was lamenting because Kåñëa had not touched even its shadow. The devotee said, "My dear kadamba tree, do not be worried. Just after defeating the Käliya snake in the Yamunä River, Kåñëa will come and satisfy your desire." This is an instance of inappropriate hopelessness in ecstatic love for Kåñëa.

Garuòa, the eagle, the carrier of Viñëu, once said, "Who can be more pure than I? Where is there a second bird like me, so able and competent? Kåñëa may not like me; He may not wish to join my party, but still He has to take advantage of my wings!" This is an instance of hopelessness in the neutral mood of ecstatic love.

The symptoms of ecstatic love are sometimes grouped under four headings—namely, generation, conjunction, aggregation and satisfaction.

Kåñëa once told Rädhäräëé, "My dear friend, when You tried to meet Me alone in the morning, Your friend Mekhalä remained hungry with envy. Just look at her!" When Kåñëa was joking with Rädhäräëé in this way, Rädhäräëé moved her beautiful eyebrows crossly. Rüpa Gosvämé prays that everyone may become blessed by this movement of Çrématé Rädhäräëé's eyebrows. This is an instance of the generation of malice in ecstatic love of Kåñëa.

One night, after the Pütanä demon had been killed, baby Kåñëa could be seen playing upon her breast. Upon seeing this, Yaçodä became stunned for some time. This is an example of a conjunction of various symptoms of ecstatic love. The conjunction can be auspicious or inauspicious. That the Pütanä demon had been killed was auspicious, but that Kåñëa was playing on her breast in the dead of night, with no one to help Him in case of trouble, was inauspicious. Yaçodä was caught between auspiciousness and inauspiciousness.

After Kåñëa had just learned to walk, He was going in and out of the house very frequently. Yaçodä became surprised and said, "This child is too restless and cannot be controlled! He is incessantly going about the neighborhood of Gokula [Våndävana], and then He is coming back inside the house. I see that the child is very fearless, but in spite of His fearlessness, I am becoming more and more afraid of His falling into some danger." This again is an instance of the conjunction of two opposing elements: the child was very fearless, but at the same time Yaçodä was becoming fearful of some danger. Here danger is the cause, and Yaçodä's feelings are in conjunction of two opposing symptoms. In other words, Yaçodä was feeling both happiness and doubt, or growing fear.

When Devaké, the mother of Kåñëa, saw her son very jubilant in the presence of the wrestlers in Kaàsa's arena, two kinds of tears were simultaneously gliding down her cheeks: sometimes her tears were warm, and sometimes they were cold. This is an instance of a conjunction of jubilation and lamentation due to different causes of ecstatic love.

Once when Çrématé Rädhäräëé was standing on the bank of the Yamunä River in the forest of Våndävana, She was attacked by Kåñëa, who was stronger than She. Although She externally expressed a disturbed mood from this incident, within Herself She was smiling and feeling great satisfaction. Externally She moved Her eyebrows and made a show of rejecting Kåñëa. In this mood Rädhäräëé looked very beautiful, and Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé glorified Her beauty. This is an instance of exhibiting varying feelings in ecstatic love, although the cause is one only—Kåñëa.

Sometimes there were great festivals in the house of Nanda Mahäräj, and all of the inhabitants of Våndävana would assemble for these festivals. During one such festival, Çrématé Rädhäräëé was seen wearing a golden necklace given Her by Kåñëa. This was immediately detected by Mother Yaçodä as well as by Rädhäräëé's mother, because the necklace was too long for Rädhäräëé's neck. At the same time Rädhäräëé could see Kåñëa nearby, as well as Her own husband, Abhimanyu. So all of these things combined to make Rädhäräëé feel very much ashamed, and with Her face shrivelled She began to look very beautiful. In this case there was a combination of bashfulness, anger, jubilation and lamentation. This is an instance of an aggregate of symptoms of ecstatic love.

Kaàsa once said, "What harm can this boy do to me? He has no power." The next moment Kaàsa was informed that all of his friends had been killed by the boy. Then Kaàsa began to think in perplexity, "Shall I go immediately and surrender unto Him? But how can a great warrior do this?" The next moment he thought, "Why should I be afraid of Him? There are still so many wrestlers standing to support me." But the next moment he began to consider: "The boy is certainly not common, because He has lifted Govardhan Hill with His left hand. So what can I do in this connection? Let me go to Våndävana and inflict pains on all the residents there. But still I cannot even go out, because my heart is trembling from fear of this boy!" This condition of Kaàsa's mind reveals an instance of pride, lamentation, humility, determination, remembrance, doubtfulness, anger and fear. Actually eight different symptoms comprised the mental condition of Kaàsa. This is another instance of an aggregate of symptoms in hopeless ecstatic love.

One householder devotee once said, "My Lord, I am so wretched that these two eyes are never desiring to see the glorious city of Mathurä. Therefore, my eyes are actually condemned. I am nicely educated, but my education has simply been used in government service. I have not considered formidable time, stronger than anything else, which creates and annihilates everything. To whom shall I leave all of my wealth and fortune? I am becoming older and older. What shall I do? Shall I execute devotional service from here at home? This I cannot do, because my mind is being attracted by the transcendental land of Våndävana."

This is an instance of hopelessness, pride, doubtfulness, patience, lamentation, determination and eagerness—an aggregation of seven different symptoms in ecstatic love for Kåñëa.

There is a proverb in Sanskrit which says, "Disappointment gives rise to the greatest satisfaction." In other words, when one's sentiment or ambition becomes too great and is not fulfilled until after seemingly hopeless tribulation, that is taken as the greatest satisfaction. Once the cowherd boys in Våndävana were vainly searching after Kåñëa for a long time, and for that reason their faces became blackened, and their complexions appeared faded. Just then they could hear on the hill a faint vibration from Kåñëa's flute. Immediately all of them became very much engladdened. This is an instance of satisfaction in the midst of disappointment.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that although he has no expert knowledge about the sounds and meanings and mellows of the symptoms of ecstatic love, he has tried to give some examples of different varieties of love of Kåñëa. He further states that the thirty-one disturbing symptoms of ecstatic love, plus nine other symptoms, all taken together equal forty primary symptoms of ecstatic love. These symptoms create transformations of bodily activities as well as movements of the senses. All of them can be accepted as different feelings of the heart. Sometimes some of the feelings are quite natural. Sometimes some of the feelings are just temporary appearances. Those symptoms which are very natural always remain, both within and without the devotee.

As one can detect the color of dye a cloth was soaked in by looking at the cloth, so, simply by understanding the different signs of these symptomatic features, one can understand the actual position. In other words, although attachment for Kåñëa is one, nevertheless, because there exist different kinds of devotees, such attachment is manifested in many varieties. As clothing tinged red appears red, so the temporary appearance of a certain type of feeling can be detected or observed by the specific ecstatic symptom. In fact, all the different humors and mellows of the devotees possess various specific feelings within the mind. And, according to these differences, the symptoms of ecstatic love appear in different forms and degrees. If one's heart is highly elevated, grave and magnanimous, or if one's heart is rough and crude, different symptoms of ecstatic love will appear, influenced by the condition of the heart. Actually, people cannot generally understand such different qualities of mentality, but when one's heart is very soft or gentle, these symptoms become very easily visible, and one can understand very clearly. The heart of one who is highly elevated and grave is compared with gold. If one's heart is very soft and gentle, his heart is compared with a cotton swab. When there is an ecstatic sensation within the mind, the golden heart or grave heart is not agitated, but the soft heart immediately becomes agitated.

To offer another example, a grave, magnanimous heart is compared to a great city, and a soft heart to an insignificant cottage. There may be many lights, or even great elephants in the big city, but no one will take particular notice of them. But when such lights or elephants are seen near a small cottage, everyone can distinctly point them out.

Hardness of the heart is compared to a lightning bolt, with gold and with shellac. The lightning bolt is very strong and never becomes soft. Similarly, the hearts of those who are engaged in severe austerities and penances do not become very easily softened. The golden heart becomes melted at high temperature, as in ecstatic love. And the shellac heart is very easily melted in slight temperature.

Softness of the heart is compared with honey, with butter and with nectar. And the condition of the mind is compared with sunshine. As honey and butter become melted even in slight sunshine, so softhearted persons become easily melted. Nectar, however, is by its nature always liquid. And the hearts of those who are in pure ecstatic love with Kåñëa are by nature always liquified, just like nectar.

A pure devotee of Kåñëa is always specifically qualified with nectarean qualifications and sometimes with the qualifications of butter and honey. On the whole, all the different conditions of the heart mentioned above can be melted under certain circumstances, just as a hard diamond sometimes is melted by a combination of certain chemicals. In the Däna-keli-kaumudé it is stated, "When love develops in the heart of a devotee, he cannot check the transformation of his sentiments. It is just like at the rising of the moon, when the ebb tide of the ocean cannot be checked: immediately there must be movement of high waves." Although in its natural state, the ocean is always very grave and unfathomable, when the moon rises, nothing can check the ocean's agitation. Similarly, those who are pure devotees cannot on any account check the movements of their feelings within.

NoD 32-1970: Symptoms of Continuous Ecstasy

Chapter Thirty-two

Symptoms of Continuous Ecstasy

The continuous ecstasy of love can remain like a powerful king, subduing all temporary manifestations of love as well as any opposing elements of anger. It can be exhibited directly or indirectly, and thus ecstatic love can be described as direct or indirect. These symptoms of ecstatic love are possible only when one is fully situated in a transcendental position. Direct ecstatic love can be divided into two groups—namely, selfish and selfless.

When noncontradictory symptoms of ecstatic love are distinctly manifest, any contradictory symptoms create a sense of abomination. Contradictory ecstatic love is called selfish. That ecstatic love which can adjust all contradictory or noncontradictory symptoms is called direct selfless love. These selfless symptoms can again be divided into five groups: neutrality, servitude, fraternity, parenthood and conjugal love. Such ecstatic love assumes a particular mode in contact with different objects of love.

Neutrality can be further subdivided into general, transparent and peaceful. An attraction for Kåñëa by the people in general or by children cannot take any specific or satisfactory position. It can be manifest sometimes in trembling of the body and changing of the color of the eyes (to red, white, etc.), although there is no symptom of any particular affection.

One old man was told by a young man: "Just see how this child—only three years old—is so jubilant! Simply by seeing Kåñëa he is running so swiftly, making a tumultuous sound. Just see!" This is an instance of neutral ecstatic love in the heart of a child, without any specific subdivision. Due to the different types of attraction for Kåñëa, there are different varieties of devotees. Their symptoms are manifested transparently, just like jewels.

It is said that a great devotee brähmaëa would sometimes address the Supreme Personality of Godhead as master, and sometimes he would joke with the Lord, using different kinds of familiar words; sometimes he would protect the Lord with a filial affection, and sometimes he would cry out to the Lord, addressing Him as his beloved; and sometimes he would meditate on the Lord as the supersoul. This means that the brähmaëa expressed his ecstatic loving symptoms in different ways at different times. But in each instance, because of ecstatic love, the brähmaëa merged himself in the ocean of happiness and became situated in pure love. Thus he was a transparent medium, like a jewel that shows reality in varying colors according to its own nature.

When the great sage Närada was glorifying the pastimes of the Lord with his véëä, the four Kumäras, headed by Sanaka, although merged in the impersonal conception of Brahman, were trembling all over. Another devotee once exclaimed, "Although I can achieve liberation simply by serving the devotees, my mind is still very much anxious to see the Supreme Personality of Godhead, whose bodily complexion is just like a dark cloud." When a devotee is so anxious to contact the Supreme Personality of Godhead, that can also be accepted as a symptom of neutral love.

Generally, a devotee of Lord Kåñëa can be placed into one of three groups. One group consists of those who are completely dependent on the merciful affection of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; another group consists of devotees who are dealing with Kåñëa on friendly terms; and the third group consists of those who are dealing with Kåñëa as His superior, with parental affection. These three classes of devotees gradually develop different relationships of transcendental mellow with the Personality of Godhead. When the attraction for Kåñëa is based only on one particular humor, that is called kevala, or pure state. One in this pure state of devotional service gradually develops the desire to follow in the footsteps of an eternal associate of Kåñëa, e.g., to follow in the footsteps of Rasäla, the personal attendant of Kåñëa in Goloka Våndävana, or to follow Kåñëa's friends, like Çrédämä and Sudämä, or to follow Nanda and Yaçodä, devotees in parenthood. Ecstatic love for Kåñëa is never manifested directly with Kåñëa Himself. The devotee has to follow in the footsteps of the eternal associates of Kåñëa in Goloka Våndävana.

When transcendental humors in relationship with Kåñëa become mixed (e.g., when the relationships with Kåñëa in friendship, servitorship and parental love become mixed together), the result is called mixed humor or flavor. Such mixed transcendental flavors are manifested by such devotees as Uddhava, Bhéma and Mukharä, the personal attendant of Mother Yaçodä. Although devotional humors are sometimes found in mixtures, a particular humor is always found to be a prominent and constant factor. That prominent humor is to be accepted as the devotee's main relationship with Kåñëa. For example, Uddhava is in relationship with Kåñëa as a friend, but in Uddhava's character a trace of servitude to Kåñëa is also visible. Such friendship is called friendship in reverence. The friendship typified by Çrédämä and Sudämä, however, is the standard of friendship without any tinge of reverence.

Subordinate Ecstatic Love

The devotees who always think of Kåñëa as a superior are in subordinate ecstatic love. To such a devotee the concept of inferiority to the Lord is very prominent, and he rarely takes interest in any other kind of transcendental loving humor with the Lord.

In the Mukunda-mälä-stotra compiled by King Kulaçekhara, one of the prayers says, "My dear Lord, You are the deliverer of living entities from the hellish condition of materialistic life, but that does not matter to me. Whether I am elevated to the heavenly platform or remain on this earthly planet or am dispatched to some hellish planet, that does not matter at all to me. My only prayer is that at the time of my death I may simply remember Your two beautiful feet, which are just like lotus flowers fructifying during the autumn season."

Friendship

As far as friendship is concerned, those high-grade devotees who are almost like Kåñëa are considered to be great authorities in the modes of friendly relations with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. On that friendly platform there are different kinds of laughing and joking conversations. An example of such a friendly relationship with Kåñëa is described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam when Kåñëa was once thinking, "Today, while I was engaged in tending the cows in the pasturing ground of Våndävana, I went to collect some flowers in a beautiful garden. At that time My friends, the cowherd boys, were unhappy even to tolerate a two-minute separation from Me. And, when they found Me, there was competition between us as to who would touch the other first with the flowers we had in hand."

One friend criticized Kåñëa thus: "My dear Dämodara, although You have been defeated by Çrédämä and have become sufficiently minimized in strength, by a false expression of strength You have somehow covered Your shameful condition of defeat."

Parenthood, or Superiority

When Mother Yaçodä heard that Kåñëa's cows were being forcibly moved by the strong servants of Kaàsa and that the tender cowherd boys were trying to protect their cows, she began to think, "How can I protect these poor boys from the invasion of Kaàsa's servants?" This is an instance of a superior attitude in a devotee.

As soon as Mother Yaçodä found her son Kåñëa returning from the pasturing ground, she immediately began to pat Him, touching her fingers to the cheeks of the Lord.

NoD 33-1970: Conjugal Affection

Chapter Thirty-three

Conjugal Affection

Above even the humor of love between Kåñëa and His parents is the relationship of conjugal love. This is exhibited between the Lord and the young gopés in different ways—glancing, moving the eyebrows, speaking very sweet words, and exchanging smiles.

There is a statement in Govinda-viläsa to this effect: "Çrématé Rädhäräëé was looking for Kåñëa very anxiously and almost disappointedly." When there is such indirect expression of conjugal love, there is smiling, astonishment, enthusiasm, lamentation, anger, dread and sometimes ghastliness. These seven exchanges of conjugal love form another state of ecstatic love.

In a direct relationship of conjugal love, there is laughter, astonishment, chivalry, lamentation, anger and dread, but there is no ghastliness. These expressions are considered to be the great reservoirs of pleasure. When these seven kinds of ecstatic loving exchanges are manifested, they attain the status of steadiness by which the taste of conjugal love expands.

Laughter

After He had stolen some curd from the pots of two gopés, Kåñëa told one of His gopé friends: "My dear beautiful friend, I can take oath that I have not stolen even a drop of curd from your pot! But still, your friend, Rädhäräëé, is very shamelessly smelling the flavor of My mouth. Kindly forbid Her from this devious policy of putting Her face near Mine." When Kåñëa was speaking like this, the friends of Rädhäräëé could not check their laughter. This is an instance of ecstasy in conjugal love.

Astonishment

Once Brahmä was watching all the cows and the cowherd boys dressed in yellow garments and decorated with valuable jewels. The boys were expanding their four arms and were being worshiped by many hundreds of other Brahmäs. All the cowherd boys began to express their joyfulness for being with Kåñëa, the supreme Brahman. At that time, Brahmä showed his astonishment by exclaiming, "What am I seeing here?" This is an instance of astonishment in ecstatic love.

Chivalry

On the bank of the Yamunä once there was the crackling sound of dry leaves, giggling from the cowherd boys, and thundering from the sky. Çrédämä was tightening his belt to fight with Kåñëa, the conqueror of the demon Agha. This is an instance of chivalry in ecstatic love.

Lamentation

In the Tenth Canto, 7th Chapter, 22nd verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is a description of Kåñëa's being taken away by the whirlwind demon Tåëävarta. As Kåñëa was being thus carried up into the sky, all the gopés began to cry aloud. They approached Mother Yaçodä, stating that they could not find the son of Nanda. He had been taken away by a whirlwind. This is an instance of lamentation in ecstatic love.

When Kåñëa was fighting with Käliya, Mother Yaçodä exclaimed, "Kåñëa is now entrapped within the hoods of the Käliya snake, and yet I am not tattered to pieces! So I must admit how wonderful is the preserving power of this material body!" This is another instance of lamentation in ecstatic love.

Anger

When Kuöilä, the sister of Abhimanyu, saw Kåñëa wearing a necklace, she could understand that the jeweled ornament had been given to Him by Rädhäräëé. She therefore became absorbed in anger and began to move her eyebrows, expressing her anger in ecstatic love.

Ghastliness

There is a statement by Yämunäcärya to this effect: "Since I have begun to enjoy these transcendental exchanges of love, which are always newer and newer, whenever I remember the pleasure of past sex life, my lips curl and I wish to spit on the idea." This is an instance of ecstatic love in ghastliness.

Dread

One old devotee said, "My dear Lord, when we are away from You we become so anxious to see You again, and there is great misery in our lives. But then, when we do see You, there immediately comes the fear of separation. Under the circumstances, both when we see You and when we do not see You, we are subjected to different kinds of tribulation." This is an instance of a contradictory mixture of ecstatic love for Kåñëa. Such ecstatic love is palatable, and expert critics have compared such ecstatic love with a mixture of curd, sugar candy and a little black pepper. The combined taste is very palatable.

NoD 34-1970: The Nectar of Devotion

Chapter Thirty-four

The Nectar of Devotion

The particular type of ecstatic loving sentiment that develops within the heart of a particular devotee is considered to be vibhäva. And the resultant manifestations such as moving the eyebrows, fear, astonishment and smiling, which have been explained hereinbefore, are called anubhäva. The different causes for developing anubhäva and vibhäva are called steady ecstasy, or saïcäri-bhäva.

Whenever there is a recitation of poetry or a dramatic play on the different pastimes of Kåñëa, the audience develops different kinds of transcendental loving service for the Lord. They enjoy different types of vibhäva, anubhäva and saïcäri-bhäva.

No one, while remaining on the material platform, should discuss these different descriptions of bhäva and anubhäva by quoting different statements of transcendental literatures. Such manifestations are displays of the transcendental pleasure potency of the Lord. One should simply try to understand that on the spiritual platform, there are many varieties of reciprocal love. Such loving exchanges should never be considered to be material. In the Mahäbhärata Udyama-parva it is warned that things which are inconceivable should not be subjected to arguments. Actually, the transactions of the spiritual world are inconceivable to us in our present state of life. Great liberated souls like Rüpa Gosvämé and others have tried to give us some hints of transcendental activities in the spiritual world, but on the whole these transactions will remain inconceivable to us at the present moment. Understanding the exchanges of transcendental loving service with Kåñëa is possible only when one is actually in touch with the pleasure potency of the Supreme Lord.

In this connection Çré Rüpa Gosvämé gives an example of the clouds in the sky: the clouds in the sky arise from the ocean, and when the clouds become water again and fall to the ground, they glide back to the ocean. Similarly, the pleasure potency of Kåñëa is compared with the ocean. The pure devotee is the pleasure-possessing cloud, and when he is filled with transcendental loving service, then he can bestow his mercy as a downpour of rain—and the pleasure potency returns to the ocean of Kåñëa.

Direct and Indirect Attraction for Kåñëa

Transcendental pleasure derived from devotional service can be divided into two groups: direct devotional service and indirect devotional service. Direct devotional service is divided into five transcendental humors or flavors, and indirect devotional service is divided into seven transcendental humors. Direct devotional services are as follows: neutrality, servitude, fraternity, paternity and conjugal love. Indirect devotional service is divided into laughter, compassion, anger, chivalry, dread, astonishment and ghastliness. Devotional service can therefore be divided into twelve types, each of which has a different color. The colors are white, multicolored, orange, red, light green, grey, yellow, off-whitish, smoky, pink, black and cloudy. The twelve different kinds of transcendental humors are controlled by different incarnations of God, such as Kapila, Mädhava, Upendra, Nåsiàha, Nandanandana, Balaräma, Kürma, Kalki, Räghava, Bhärgava, Varäha and Matsya.

Sustenance, manifestation, expansion, reflection and lamentation are the five visible symptoms in exchanges of ecstatic love. The test of devotional service can therefore be made in terms of these five symptoms. In the devotional service of neutrality there is sustenance; there is expansion in chivalrous devotional service; there is reflection in compassionate devotional service; in angry devotional service there is lamentation, and so on.

An apparently pitiable condition in devotional service may appear to be distressing to the inexperienced student, but the feelings of the devotee in this pitiable condition are considered to be ecstatic by expert devotees. For example, the subject matter of the Rämäyaëa is sometimes considered to be pitiable and distressing to the heart, but actually that is not the fact. The Rämäyaëa narrates how Lord Räma was sent to the forest by His father just when He was going to be enthroned. After Lord Räma's departure, Mahäräj Daçaratha, His father, died. In the forest His wife, Sétädevé, was kidnapped by Rävaëa, and there was a great war. When Sétädevé was finally delivered from the clutches of Rävaëa, Rävaëa's whole family and kingdom, and Rävaëa himself, were vanquished. When Sétädevé came home she was tried by fire, and after some days she was again banished to the forest. All of these subjects in the Rämäyaëa seem very pitiable, and they may appear to be very distressing to the reciter, but actually this is not so. Otherwise, why would Hanumän, the great devotee of Lord Rämacandra, read daily about the activities of Lord Rämacandra, as described in the Rämäyaëa itself? The fact is that in any of the above-mentioned twelve transcendental humors of devotional service, everything is transcendentally pleasing.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé mourns in this connection for persons who are in the fire of false renunciation, the dry speculative habit, and who neglect devotional service. Persons who are attached to the ritualistic ceremonies recommended in the Vedas and to the impersonal Brahman cannot relish the transcendental pleasure of devotional service. Çré Rüpa Gosvämé advises, therefore, that devotees who have already tasted the nectar of devotion should be very careful to protect devotional service from such dry speculators, formal ritualistic elevationists and impersonal salvationists. Devotees should protect their valuable jewel of spiritual love from the clutches of thieves and burglars. In other words, a pure devotee should not describe devotional service and its different analytical aspects to dry speculators and false renouncers.

Those who are not devotees can never achieve the benefits of devotional service. For them the subject of devotional service is always very difficult to understand. Only persons who have dedicated their lives unto the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead can relish the real nectar of devotion.

When one transcends the status of ecstatic love and thus becomes situated on the highest platform of pure goodness, one is understood to have cleansed the heart of all material contamination. In that pure stage of life, one can taste this nectar, and this tasting capacity is technically called rasa, or transcendental mood.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta summary study of the second division of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, in the matter of general devotional service.


PART THREE

NoD 35-1970: Neutral Love of God

Chapter Thirty-five

Neutral Love of God

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé offers his respectful prayers to the eternal Supreme Personality of Godhead who is always so beautiful and for whom the pure devotees are always engaged in loving transcendental service. This third division of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu describes the five primary kinds of devotional service—namely, neutrality, servitude, fraternity, parenthood and conjugal love. These five items will be very elaborately explained here, and thus they have been figuratively described as the five waves on the western side of this ocean of nectar of devotion.

When one is actually able to maintain the transcendental position, his stage is called neutrality in devotional service. Some great sages have attained this neutral position by practicing austerity, penance and meditation to control the senses. Such sages are generally called mystic yogés, and in most cases they are inclined to appreciate the spiritual pleasure of the impersonal feature of the absolute truth. They are practically unaware of the transcendental pleasure derived from personal contact with the Supreme Godhead.

Actually the transcendental pleasure derived in association with the Supreme Person is far greater than the pleasure derived from impersonal Brahman realization, because of the direct meeting with the eternal form of the Lord. Impersonalists do not directly derive the transcendental pleasure of association with the Lord by hearing of His pastimes. As such, the impersonalists cannot derive any relishable transcendental pleasure from the topics of the Bhagavad-gétä, in which the Lord is personally talking with Arjuna. The basic principle of their impersonal attitude does not allow them the transcendental pleasure which is relished by a devotee whose basic principle of understanding is the Supreme Person. The impersonalistic commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä is therefore disastrous because, without understanding the transcendental pleasure of the Gétä, the impersonalist wants to interpret it in his own way. If an impersonalist can, however, come in contact with a pure devotee, his transcendental position can be changed for greater elevation. Great sages are therefore recommended to worship the form of the Lord in order to achieve that highest transcendental pleasure.

Without worshiping the arcä-vigraha, the form or Deity of the Lord, one cannot understand such literature as the Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam. For those great sages situated in the position of transcendental neutrality, the beginning should be to take shelter of Lord Viñëu, the four-handed eternal form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The mystic yogés are therefore advised to meditate on the form of Lord Viñëu as recommended by Kapila Muni in the säìkhya-yoga system. Unfortunately, many mystic yogés try to meditate on something void, and as is stated in the Gétä, the result is that they simply undergo trouble and do not achieve any tangible result.

When some great saintly persons who had undergone penances and austerities saw the four-handed transcendental form of Viñëu, they began to remark as follows: "This four-handed form of the Lord, manifested in a bluish color, is the reservoir of all pleasure and the center of our living force. Actually, when we see this eternal form of Viñëu, we, along with many other paramahaàsas, become immediately captivated by the beauty of the Lord." This appreciation of Lord Viñëu by saintly persons is an instance of situation in çänta-rasa, or the neutral stage of devotional service. In the beginning, those who are aspiring for salvation try to get out of the material entanglement by performing painful austerities and penances, and ultimately they come to the impersonal status of spiritual realization. At this brahma-bhüta stage of liberation from the material entanglement, the symptoms, as explained in the Bhagavad-gétä, are that one becomes joyous beyond any hankering or lamentation and gains a universal vision. When the devotee is situated in the çänta-rasa, or neutral stage of devotional service, he appreciates the Viñëu form of the Lord.

Actually, all Vedic culture is aiming at understanding Lord Viñëu. In the Åg Veda one mantra says that any advanced saintly person is always aspiring to be fixed in meditation upon the lotus feet of Viñëu.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is said that the foolish do not know that Viñëu is the ultimate goal of life. According to the conclusion of all authoritative Vedic scriptures, when a person comes to the stage of appreciating Viñëu, he is at the beginning of devotional service. If one cultivates devotional service further and further, under proper guidance, other features of devotional service will gradually become manifest. At this stage of çänta-rasa, one can see Lord Viñëu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the deliverer of even the demons. The Lord is appreciated by such would-be devotees as the eternal transcendental form, chief of all self-realized souls, the supersoul, the supreme Brahman, completely pacified, completely controlled and pure, merciful to the devotees and untouched by any material condition. This appreciation of Lord Viñëu in awe and veneration by the saintly is to be understood as the sign that they are situated in the çänta-rasa, or neutral stage of devotional service.

This stage of çänta-rasa can be attained by the impersonalists only when they are in association with pure devotees. Otherwise it is not possible. After Brahman realization, when a liberated soul comes in contact with a pure devotee of Lord Kåñëa and submissively accepts the teachings of Lord Kåñëa without misinterpretation, he becomes situated in this neutral stage of devotional service. The best example of saintly persons situated in the çänta-rasa are Sanaka, Sanätana, Sananda, and Sanat-kumära, the Kumära brothers. These four saintly persons (known as Catuùsana) were sons of Lord Brahmä. After their birth, when they were ordered by their father to become householders and increase human society, they refused the order. They said that they had already decided not to become entangled with family life; they would rather live as saintly brahmacärés for their own perfection. So these great saints have been living for millions of years now, but still they appear to be just like boys of four or five years. Their complexions are very fair, there is an effulgence in their bodies, and they always travel naked. These four saintly persons almost always remain together.

In one of the prayers of the Kumära brothers, the declaration is made: "My Lord Mukunda [Kåñëa, the giver of liberation], only so long as one does not happen to see Your eternal form of bliss and knowledge, appearing just like a newly-grown tämala tree, with a bluish hue—only for so long can the impersonal feature of the absolute truth, known as Brahman, be very pleasing to a saintly person."

The qualifications of a saintly person are described in the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu as follows: A saintly person is one who understands fully that simply by discharging devotional service he can become confident of liberation. He is always situated in the regulative principles of devotional life and at the same time aspires to be liberated from the material entanglement.

A saintly person thinks like this: "When shall I be able to live alone in the caves of the mountains? When shall I be dressed simply with undergarments? When shall I be satisfied by eating simply a little fruit and vegetables? When will it be possible for me to always think of the lotus feet of Mukunda, who is the source of the Brahman effulgence? When, in such a spiritual condition of life, shall I fully understand my days and nights to be insignificant moments in eternal time?"

The devotees and self-realized persons who are engaged in preaching the glories of the Lord always maintain an ecstatic love for the Lord within their hearts. Thus they are benefitted by the rays of the ecstatic moon, and they are called saintly persons.

The impulse of a saintly person is to be engaged in the study of the Vedas, especially the Upaniñadic portions, to always live in a place where there is no disturbance from the common people, to always think of the eternal form of Kåñëa, to be ready to consider and understand the absolute truth, to always be prominent in exhibiting knowledge, to see the Supreme Lord in His universal form (viçva-rüpa), to associate always with learned devotees and to discuss the conclusion of the Vedas with similarly elevated persons. All of these qualifications of a saintly person serve to raise him to the status of çänta-rasa.

In the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu it is stated that all those who attended the pious meeting held by Lord Brahmä for the study of Vedic literature like the Upaniñads became overwhelmed with ecstatic love for Kåñëa, the chief of the Yadu dynasty. Actually, the result of studying the Upaniñads is to understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Negation of material existence is only one of the subjects of the Upaniñads. The next subject concerns becoming situated in the impersonal realization. And then, after penetrating through the impersonal Brahman, when one comes to the platform of associating with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one reaches the ultimate goal in studying the Upaniñads.

Those who are situated on the platform of çänta-rasa get their impetus for advancement in devotional service by smelling the tulasé offered at the lotus feet of the Lord, by hearing the sound of His conchshell, by seeing a sanctified place in some mountain or hill, by observing a forest like the ones in Våndävana, by going to a place of pilgrimage, by visiting the course of the Ganges River, by being victorious over the dictations of bodily demands (i.e., eating, sleeping, mating and defending), by understanding the devastation of eternal time, and by constantly associating with devotees engaged in Kåñëa consciousness. All these different items are favorable in elevating saintly persons situated in çänta-rasa to the advanced stage of devotional service.

In the Third Canto, 15th Chapter, 43rd verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is a statement by the four saintly persons known as Catuùsana, headed by Sanaka-kumära. They went to visit the Lord of Vaikuëöha-loka in the spiritual sky, and when they bowed down before the Lord, the aroma of the tulasé, mixed with saffron, entered their nostrils and immediately attracted their minds. Although these four saintly persons were always absorbed in the thought of impersonal Brahman, from association with the Lord and from smelling the tulasé leaves, the hairs on their bodies immediately stood up. This shows that even a person who is situated in Brahman realization, if he is put into association with devotees in pure devotional service, will immediately become attracted to the personal feature of the Lord.

There are certain symptoms of great sages who are situated in çänta-rasa devotional service, and these symptoms are exhibited as follows: they concentrate their eyesight on the tip of the nose, and they behave just like an avadhüta. Avadhüta means a highly elevated mystic who does not care for any social, religious or Vedic conventions. Another symptom is that such persons are very careful to step forward when giving speeches. When they speak, they join together the forefinger and thumb. (This is called the jïäna-mudrä position.) They are not against the atheists, nor are they particularly inclined to the devotees. Such persons give stress to liberation and detachment from the materialistic way of life. They are always neutral and have no affection for nor misidentification with anything material. They are always grave, but fully absorbed in thoughts of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. These uncommon features develop in devotees who are situated in çänta-rasa.

Regarding concentration of the eyesight on the tip of the nose, there is a statement in the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu by a devotee who observed this being performed by a yogé. He remarked, "This great sage is concentrating his eyesight on the tip of his nose, and from this it appears that he has already realized the eternal form of the Lord within himself."

Sometimes a devotee in çänta-rasa yawns, stretches his limbs, instructs on devotional service, offers respectful obeisances unto the form of the Lord, offers nice prayers to the Lord and has a desire to give direct service with his body. These are some of the common symptoms of the devotee who is situated in neutrality. One devotee, after observing the yawning of another devotee, addressed him thus: "My dear mystic, I think that within your heart there is some ecstatic devotional love which is causing you to yawn." It is sometimes found that a devotee in the çänta-rasa falls down on the ground, his hairs stand up on his body, and he trembles all over. In this way, different symptoms of ecstatic trance are exhibited automatically by such devotees.

In the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu it is said that when Lord Kåñëa was blowing His conchshell known as Päïcajanya many great sages who were living in the caves of the mountains immediately reacted, being awakened from their trance of meditation. They immediately saw that the hairs of their bodies were standing. Sometimes devotees in çänta-rasa become stunned, peaceful, jubilant, deliberate, reflective, anxious, dexterous and argumentative. These symptoms indicate continuous ecstasy, or established emotion.

Once a great realized sage was lamenting that the Supreme Lord Kåñëa was living in Dvärakä but that he was unable to take advantage of seeing Him. After thinking this, the sage immediately became stunned. He was thinking that he was simply wasting his time. In other words, the sage lamented because the Supreme Personality of Godhead was personally present, and he still could not take advantage of this because of his meditation.

When a mystic is transcendental to all kinds of mental concoctions and is situated in Brahman, his state is called trance beyond the influence of the material conception of life. In that stage, when one hears about the transcendental pastimes of the Lord, there may be shivering in the body.

When a Brahman-realized devotee who has come to the stage of steady trance comes into contact with the eternal form of Kåñëa, his transcendental pleasure increases millions of times. One great sage once inquired from another, "My dear friend, do you think that after I perfect the eightfold yoga performance I shall be able to see the eternal form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead?" This enquiry from the sage is an instance of inquisitiveness in a devotee situated in the neutral stage of devotional service.

When Lord Kåñëa, along with His elder brother Balaräma and sister Subhadrä, came to Kurukñetra in a chariot on the occasion of a solar eclipse, many mystic yogés also came. When these mystic yogés saw Lord Kåñëa and Balaräma, they exclaimed that now that they had seen the excellent bodily effulgence of the Lord, they had almost forgotten the pleasure derived from impersonal Brahman realization. In this connection one of the mystics approached Kåñëa and said, "My dear Lord, You are always full with transcendental bliss, excelling all other spiritual positions. And so, simply by seeing You from a distant place, I have come to the conclusion that there is no need of my being situated in the transcendental bliss of impersonal Brahman."

When a great mystic was once awakened from his meditative trance by hearing the vibration of Kåñëa's Päïcajanya conchshell, the mystic became overpowered. So much so, in fact, that he began to bash his head on the ground, and with eyes full of tears of ecstatic love, he violated all the rules and regulations of his yoga performances. Thus he at once neglected the process of Brahman realization.

Bilvamaìgala Thäkur, in his book Kåñëa-karëämåta, says, "Let the impersonalists be engaged in the process of transcendental realization by worshiping the impersonal Brahman. Although I was also initiated into that path of Brahman realization, I have now become misled by a naughty boy—one who is very cunning, who is very much attached to the gopés and who has made me His maidservant. So I have now forgotten the process of Brahman realization."

Bilvamaìgala Thäkur was first spiritually initiated for impersonal realization of the absolute truth, but later on, by his association with Kåñëa in Våndävana, he became an experienced devotee. The same thing happened to Çukadeva Gosvämé, who also reformed himself by the grace of the Lord and took to the path of devotional service, giving up the way of impersonal realization.

Çukadeva Gosvämé and Bilvamaìgala Thäkur's giving up of the impersonal conception of the absolute truth and taking to devotional service are the best examples of devotees being situated in the neutral state. According to some authorities, this condition cannot be accepted as one of the transcendental humors, or rasas, but Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says that even if one does not accept it as a transcendental humor, one must still accept it as the beginning position of devotional service. However, if one is not further raised to the platform of actual service to the Lord, he is not considered to be on the platform of transcendental mellow. In this connection, in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Lord Kåñëa personally instructs Uddhava like this: "The state of being established in My personal form is called çänta-rasa, and without being situated in this position, no one can advance to actual pure devotional service." In other words, no one can be situated in the personal feature of the Supreme Personality of Godhead without being situated at least in çänta-rasa.

NoD 36-1970: Transcendental Affection (Servitude)

Chapter Thirty-six

Transcendental Affection (Servitude)

The transcendental mellow of affection has been accepted by authorities like Çrédhara Svämé as a perfectional stage of devotion. It is just above the humor of neutrality and is a requisite for the development of the serving humor. In literature such as Näma-kaumudé this state of existence is accepted as continual affection for or attraction to Kåñëa. Authorities like Çukadeva consider this stage of affection to be in the neutral stage, but in any case this affection is relished by the devotees in different transcendental tastes, and therefore the general name for this state is affection, or pure affection for Kåñëa.

Devotees engaged in servitude are attached to Kåñëa in the affection of reverence. Some of the inhabitants of Gokula (Våndävana as exhibited on earth) are attached to Kåñëa on this platform of affection in reverence. The inhabitants of Våndävana used to say, "Kåñëa is always manifest before us with a complexion like a blackish cloud. He holds His wonderful flute in His lotus hands. He is dressed in yellow silks and bedecked with a peacock feather on His head. When Kåñëa walks near Govardhan Hill with these personal features, all the inhabitants of the heavenly planets, as well as the inhabitants of this earth, feel transcendental bliss and consider themselves the eternal servants of the Lord." Sometimes the devotee becomes filled with the same awe and reverence by seeing a picture of Viñëu, who is dressed like Kåñëa and who has a similar complexion. The only difference is that Viñëu has four hands, in which He holds the conchshell, the disc, the club and the lotus flower. Lord Viñëu is always decorated with many valuable jewels, such as the candrakänta stone and the süryakänta stone.

In the Lalita-mädhava by Rüpa Gosvämé there is the following statement by Däruka, one of the servants of Kåñëa: "Certainly Lord Viñëu is very beautiful with His necklace of kaustubha jewels, His four hands holding conchshell, disc, club and lotus flower and His dazzlingly beautiful jewelry. He is also very beautiful in His eternal position, riding upon the shoulder of Garuòa. But now the same Lord Viñëu is present as the enemy of Kaàsa, and by His personal feature I am completely forgetting the opulence of Vaikuëöha."

Another devotee once said, "This Supreme Personality of Godhead from whose bodily pores come millions of universes, permanently rising, who is the ocean of mercy, who is the owner of inconceivable energies, who is always equipped with all perfections, who is the origin of all incarnations, who is the attraction for all liberated persons—this very Supreme Personality of Godhead is the supreme controller, the supremely worshipable, all-cognizant, fully determined, fully opulent, the emblem of forgiveness, the protector of surrendered souls, munificent, true to His promise, expert, all-auspicious, powerful, religious, a strict follower of the scripture, the friend of the devotees, magnanimous, influential, grateful, reputable, respectable, full of all strength and submissive to pure love. Surely He is the only shelter of devotees who are attracted to Him by the affection of servitorship."

The devotees of the Lord in servitude are divided into four classes: appointed servants (such as Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva, who are appointed to control over the material modes of passion and ignorance), devotees in servitude who are protected by the Lord, devotees who are always associates, and devotees who are simply following in the footsteps of the Lord.

In a conversation between Jämbavaté, one of Kåñëa's wives, and Kälindé, her friend, Jämbavaté enquired, "Who is this personality circumambulating our Kåñëa?"

Kälindé replied, "He is Ambikeya, the superintendent of all universal affairs."

Then Jämbavaté enquired, "Who is this personality who is trembling at the sight of Kåñëa?"

Kälindé replied, "He is Lord Çiva."

Then Jämbavaté enquired, "Who is the person offering prayers?"

Kälindé replied, "He is Lord Brahmä."

Jämbavaté then asked, "Who is that person who has fallen on the ground and is offering respect to Kåñëa?"

Kälindé replied, "He is Indra, the King of heaven."

Jämbavaté next inquired, "Who is this person who has come with the demigods and is laughing with them?"

Kälindé replied, "He is my elder brother, Yamaräja, the superintendent of death."

This conversation offers a description of all the demigods, including Yamaräja, who are engaged in services appointed by the Lord. They are called adhikåta-devatä, or demigods appointed to particular types of departmental service.

One resident of Våndävana once told Lord Kåñëa, "My dear Kåñëa, O pleasure of Våndävana! Being afraid of this material existence, we have taken shelter of You, for You can completely protect us! We are well aware of Your greatness. As such, we have given up our desire for liberation and have taken complete shelter under Your lotus feet. Since we have heard about Your ever-increasing transcendental love, we have voluntarily engaged ourselves in Your transcendental service." This statement is by a devotee who is under the protection and shelter of Lord Kåñëa.

Upon being chastised by Kåñëa's constant kicking on his head, Käliya, the black snake of the Yamunä, came to his senses and admitted, "My dear Lord, I have been so offensive unto You, but still You are so kind that You have marked my head with the impression of Your lotus feet." This also is an instance of one's taking shelter under the lotus feet of Kåñëa.

In the Aparädha-bhaïjana a pure devotee expresses his feelings: "My dear Lord, I am ashamed to admit before You that I have carried out the orders of my masters named lust, anger, avarice, illusion and envy. Sometimes I have carried out their orders in a way most abominable. Yet in spite of my serving them so faithfully, they are neither satisfied nor are they kind enough to give me relief from their service. They are not even ashamed of taking service from me in that way. My dear Lord, O head of the Yadu dynasty, now I have come to my senses, and I am taking shelter of Your lotus feet. Please engage me in Your service." This is another instance of surrendering and taking shelter of the lotus feet of Kåñëa.

There are many instances in the various Vedic writings of persons who were aspiring after liberation by speculative knowledge but gave up this process in order to take complete shelter under the lotus feet of Kåñëa. Examples of such persons are the brähmaëas headed by Çaunaka in the forest of Naimiñäraëya.* Learned scholars accept them as devotees having complete wisdom. There is a statement in the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya in which these great brähmaëas and sages, headed by Çaunaka Åñi, told Süta Gosvämé: "My dear great soul, just see how wonderful it is! Although as human beings we are contaminated with so many taints of material existence, simply by our conversing with you about the Supreme Personality of Godhead we are now gradually decrying our desire for liberation."

In Padyävalé a devotee says, "Persons who are attached to speculative knowledge for self realization, who have decided that the supreme truth is beyond meditation and who have thus become situated in the modes of goodness—let them peacefully execute their engagement. As for us, we are simply attached to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is by nature so pleasing, who possesses a complexion like a blackish cloud, who is dressed in yellow garments and who has beautiful lotus-like eyes. We wish only to meditate upon Him."

Those who are from the very beginning of their self realization attached to devotional service are called seväniñöha. Seväniñöha means simply attached to devotional service. The best examples of such devotees are Lord Çiva, King Indra, King Bahuläçva, King Ikñväku, Çrutadeva and Puëòaréka. One devotee says: "My dear Lord, Your transcendental qualities attract even the liberated souls and carry them to the assembly of devotees where Your glories are constantly chanted. Even great sages who are accustomed to live in solitary places are also attracted by the songs of Your glory. And, observing all Your transcendental qualities, I have also become attracted and have decided to dedicate my life to Your loving service."

In the city of Dvärakä the following devotees are known as Kåñëa's close associates: Uddhava, Däruka, Sätyaki, Çrutadeva, Çaträjit, Nanda, Upananda and Bhadra. All of these personalities remain with the Lord as His secretaries, but still they are sometimes engaged in His personal service. Among the Kuru dynasty, Bhéñma, Mahäräj Parékñit and Vidura are also known as close associates of Lord Kåñëa. It is said, "All the associates of Lord Kåñëa have lustrous bodily features, and their eyes are just like lotus flowers. They have sufficient power to defeat the strength of the demigods, and the specific feature of their persons is that they are always decorated with valuable ornaments."

When Kåñëa was in the capital of Indraprastha, someone addressed Him thus: "My dear Lord, Your personal associates, headed by Uddhava, are always awaiting Your order by standing at the entrance gate of Dvärakä. They are mostly looking on with tears in their eyes, and in the enthusiasm of their service they are not afraid even of the devastating fire generated by Lord Çiva. They are souls simply surrendered unto Your lotus feet."

Out of the many close associates of Lord Kåñëa, Uddhava is considered the best. The following is a description of him: "His body is blackish like the color of the Yamunä River, and it is similarly as cool. He is always decorated with flower garlands first used by Lord Kåñëa, and he is dressed with yellow silk clothing. His two arms are just like the bolts of a door, His eyes are just like lotus flowers, and he is the most important devotee amongst all the associates. Let us therefore offer our respectful obeisances unto Uddhava's lotus feet."

Uddhava has described the transcendental qualities of Çré Kåñëa as follows: "Lord Çré Kåñëa, who is our master and worshipable Deity, who is the controller of Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä, the controller of the whole universe as well, accepts the controlling orders of Ugrasena, His grandfather. He is the proprietor of millions of universes, but still He begged a little land from the ocean. And although He is just like an ocean of wisdom, still He sometimes consults me. He is so great and magnanimous, yet He is engaged in His different activities just like an ordinary person."

Those who are constantly engaged in the personal service of the Lord are called anugas, or followers. Examples of such followers are Sucandra, Maëòana, Stamba and Sutamba. They are all inhabitants of the city of Dvärakä, and they are dressed and ornamented like the other associates. The specific services entrusted to the anugas are varied. Maëòana always bears the umbrella over the head of Lord Kåñëa. Sucandra is engaged in fanning the white cämara bunch of hair, and Sutamba is engaged in supplying betel nuts. All of them are great devotees, and they are always busy in the transcendental loving service of the Lord.

As there are anugas in Dvärakä, so there are many anugas in Våndävana also. The names of the anugas in Våndävana are as follows: Raktaka, Patraka, Patré, Madhukaëöha, Madhuvrata, Rasäla, Suviläsa, Premakanda, Marandaka, Änanda, Candrahäsa, Payoda, Bakula, Rasada, and Çärada.

Descriptions of the bodily features of the anugas in Våndävana are given in the following statement: "Let us offer our respectful obeisances unto the constant associates of the son of Mahäräj Nanda. They always stay in Våndävana, and their bodies are decorated with garlands of pearls and with bangles and bracelets of gold. Their colors are like black bees and the golden moon, and they are dressed just to suit their particular special bodily features. Their specific duties can be understood from a statement by Mother Yaçodä, who said, 'Bakula, please cleanse the yellowish dress of Kåñëa. Värida, you just flavor the bathing water with aguru scent. And Rasäla, you just prepare the betel nuts. You can all see that Kåñëa is approaching. There is dust overhead, and the cows can be seen very distinctly.'"

Amongst all the anugas, Raktaka is considered to be the chief. The description of his bodily features is as follows: "He wears yellow clothing, and his bodily color is just like newly-grown grass. He is very expert in singing and is always engaged in the service of the son of Mahäräj Nanda. Let us all become the followers of Raktaka in offering transcendental loving service to Kåñëa!" An example of the attachment felt by Raktaka toward Lord Kåñëa can be understood from his statement to Rasada: "Just hear me! Please place me so that I may always be engaged in the service of Lord Kåñëa, who has now become famous as the lifter of the Govardhan Hill."

The devotees of Kåñëa engaged in His personal service are always very cautious because they know that becoming personal servitors of Lord Kåñëa is not an ordinary thing. A person who offers respect even to the ants engaged in the service of the Lord becomes eternally happy, so what is there to say of one who offers Kåñëa direct service? Raktaka once said within himself, "Not only is Kåñëa my worshipable and servable Lord, but also the girl friends of Kåñëa, the gopés, are equally worshipable and servable by me. And not only the gopés, but anyone who is engaged in the service for the Lord is also worshipable and servable by me. I know that I must be very careful not to become overly proud that I am one of the servitors and devotees of the Lord." From this statement one can understand that the pure devotees, those who are actually engaged in the service of the Lord, are always very cautious and are never overly proud of their service.

This mentality of the direct servitor of Kåñëa is called dhurya. According to expert analytical studies of the direct associates of the Lord, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has divided these into three classes—namely, dhurya, dhéra and véra. Raktaka is classified among the dhurya, or those who are always attached to serve the most beloved gopés.

One dhéra associate of Kåñëa is the son of Satyabhämä's nurse. Satyabhämä is one of the queens of Lord Kåñëa in Dvärakä, and when she was married to Kåñëa, the son of her nurse was allowed to go with her because they had lived together from childhood as brother and sister. So this gentleman, the son of Satyabhämä's nurse, used to live with Kåñëa as His brother-in-law, and sometimes as brother-in-law he used to play jokes with Kåñëa. He once addressed Kåñëa in this way: "My dear Kåñëa, I never tried to gain the favor of the goddess of fortune, who is married to You, but still I am so fortunate that I am considered one of the members of Your house, the brother of Satyabhämä."

This same person once expressed his pride, declaring, "Lord Baladeva may be a great enemy of Pralambäsura, but I have nothing to worry about from Him. And as far as Pradyumna is concerned, I have nothing to take from him, because he is simply a boy. Therefore I do not expect anything from anyone else. I simply expect the favorable glance of Kåñëa upon me, and so I am not even afraid of Satyabhämä, who is so dear to Kåñëa."

In the Fourth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 20th Chapter, 25th verse, King Påthu addresses the Lord, saying, "My dear Lord, it may happen that the goddess of fortune becomes dissatisfied with my work, or I may even have some misunderstanding with her, but I will not mind this because I have full confidence in You. You are always causelessly merciful to Your servants, and You consider even their menial service to be very much advanced. So I have confidence that You will accept my humble service, although it is not worthy of being recognized. My dear Lord, You are self-sufficient. You can do anything You like without the help of anyone else. So even if the goddess of fortune is not satisfied with me, I know You will always accept my service anyway."

Devotees attached to the transcendental loving service of the Lord may be described either as surrendered souls, as souls advanced in devotional knowledge, or as souls completely engaged in the transcendental loving service. Such devotees are called, respectively, neophyte, perfect and eternally perfect.

NoD 37-1970: Impetuses for Kåñëa's Service

Chapter Thirty-seven

Impetuses for Kåñëa's Service

The causeless mercy of Kåñëa, the dust of His lotus feet, His prasädam and association with His devotees are some impetuses toward a devotee's engagement in transcendental loving service to the Lord.

Kåñëa exhibited His causeless mercy when He was present at the departure of Grandfather Bhéñma. During the Battle of Kurukñetra, Bhéñmadeva, the grandfather of Arjuna, was lying on a bed of arrows before departing from this mortal world. When Lord Kåñëa, Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira and the other Päëòavas approached Bhéñmadeva, he was very grateful to Lord Kåñëa, and he addressed the brähmaëa military commander, Kåpäcärya, thus: "My dear Kåpäcärya, just see the wonderful causeless mercy of Lord Kåñëa! I am most unfortunate. I have no qualifications. I was opposing Kåñëa's most intimate friend, Arjuna—I even tried to kill him! I have so many disqualifications, and yet the Lord is still so kind that He has come to see me at the last point of my life. He is worshipable by all great sages, but still He is so merciful that He has come to see an abominable person like me."

Sometimes the vibration of Lord Kåñëa's flute, His bugling, His smiling, His footmarks on the ground, the transcendental fragrance of His body and the appearance of a new cloud in the sky also become impetuses for ecstatic love of Him.

In the Vidagdha-mädhava there is the following statement: "When Kåñëa was playing on His flute, Baladeva very anxiously declared, 'Just see how, after hearing the transcendental sound of Kåñëa's flute, Indra the King of heaven is crying in his heavenly kingdom! And from his teardrops falling on the ground, Våndävana appears to have become a celestial residence for the demigods.' "

Ecstatic love for Kåñëa, which is known as anubhäva, is symptomized by the following signs: one becomes engaged exclusively in the service of the Lord, being attentive to carry out the orders of the Lord faithfully; one becomes undisturbed and non-envious in full transcendental loving service to the Lord; and one makes friendship with the devotees of the Lord who are situated in faithful service to Him. All of these symptoms are called anubhäva, ecstatic love.

The first symptom of anubhäva, or engagement in a particular type of service, is exemplified by Däruka, a servant of Kåñëa who used to fan Kåñëa with a cämara, a bunch of hair. When he was engaged in such service, he was filled with ecstatic love, and the symptoms of ecstatic love became manifest in his body. But Däruka was so serious about his service that he checked all of these manifestations of ecstatic love and considered them hindrances to his engagement. He did not care very much for these manifestations, although they automatically developed.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 86th Chapter, 27th verse, there is a statement of how Çrutadeva, a brähmaëa from the country called Mithilä in northern India, would become so overpowered with joy as soon as he saw Kåñëa that immediately after bowing to the Lord's lotus feet, he would stand up and begin to dance, raising his two arms above his head.

One of the devotees of Lord Kåñëa once addressed Him in this manner: "My dear Lord, although You are not a professional dancer, by Your dancing You have so astonished us that we can understand that You are personally the master of all dancing. Certainly You must have learned this dancing art directly from the goddess of love." When a devotee dances in ecstatic love, there are manifestations of symptoms which are called sättvika. Sättvika means that they are from the transcendental platform. They are not symptoms of material emotions; they come from the soul proper.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 85th Chapter, 30th verse, Çukadeva Gosvämé tells Mahäräj Parékñit that after surrendering everything unto the lotus feet of Vämanadeva, Bali Mahäräj immediately caught hold of the lotus feet of the Lord and pressed them to his heart. Being overwhelmed with joy, he manifested all the symptoms of ecstatic love, with tears in his eyes and a faltering voice.

In such expressions of ecstatic love there are many other subsidiary symptoms, such as jubilation, withering, silence, disappointment, moroseness, reverence, thoughtfulness, remembrance, doubtfulness, confidence, eagerness, indifference, restlessness, impudence, shyness, inertness, illusion, madness, ghastliness, contemplation, dreaming, disease and signs of death. When a devotee meets Kåñëa, there are symptoms of jubilation, pride and perseverence, and when he is feeling great separation from Kåñëa, the symptoms of ghastliness, disease and the signs of death become prominent.

It is stated in the First Canto of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 11th Chapter, 4th verse, that when Lord Kåñëa returned from the battlefield of Kurukñetra to His home at Dvärakä, all the residents of Dvärakä began to talk with Him, as a child talks lovingly to his father after the father's return from foreign countries. This is an example of jubilation.

When Bahuläçva, the King of Mithilä, saw Kåñëa at his palace, he decided to offer his respects by bowing down before Him at least a hundred times, but he was so overcome by feelings of love that, after bowing down only once, he forgot his position and could not rise up again.

In the Skanda Puräëa a devotee tells Lord Kåñëa: "My dear Lord, as the sun evaporates all the water on the ground by its scorching heat, so my mental state has dried away the luster of my face and body, due to separation from You." This is an example of withering in ecstatic love.

An expression of disappointment was made by Indra, the King of heaven. When he saw the sungod, he told him, "My dear sungod, your sunshine is very glorious because it reaches unto the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa, the master of the Yadu dynasty. I have thousands of eyes, but they have proved to be useless because not even for a moment are they able to see the lotus feet of the Lord."

Reverential devotion for the Lord gradually increases and transforms itself into ecstatic love, then affection and then attachment. In the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 38th Chapter, 5th verse, Akrüra says: "Because I am going to see Lord Kåñëa today, all symptoms of inauspiciousness have already been killed. My life is now successful because I shall be able to offer my respects unto the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead!"

Another devotee in ecstatic reverential affection once said, "When will that glorious day in my life come when it will be possible for me to go to the bank of the Yamunä and see Lord Çré Kåñëa playing there as cowherd boy?"

When there is no diminishing of this ecstatic love and when it is freed from all kinds of doubt, that stage is called steady love for Kåñëa. In this stage all expressions of unhappiness by the devotee are called anubhäva, or ecstatic loving symptoms.

The symptom of ecstatic affection with reverence felt by Bali Mahäräj is expressed as follows: "My dear Lord, You have simultaneously punished me and showed me Your causeless mercy. My conclusion is that when I have taken shelter of Your lotus feet I shall never be disturbed in any condition of life. Whether You give me the opportunity to enjoy all the yogic perfections, or You put me into the most abominable condition of hellish life, I shall never be disturbed."

Kåñëa Himself, after seeing Bali Mahäräj, told Uddhava, "My dear friend, how can I express the glorious characteristics of Bali Mahäräj, the son of Virocana? Although the king of the suras [demigods] was cursed by this son of Virocana, and although I cheated him in my incarnation as Vämana, taking away his dominions throughout the universe, and although I still criticized him for not fulfilling his promise, I have just now seen him in his kingdom, and he feelingly expressed his love for me."*

When such a feeling of love becomes intensified, it is called affection. In that affectional stage no one can bear separation from Kåñëa even for a moment.

One devotee told Däruka, the servant of Kåñëa: "My dear Däruka, when you become like wood because of your separation from Kåñëa, it is not so wonderful. Whenever any devotee sees Kåñëa, his eyes become filled with water, and in separation any devotee like you would become stunned, standing just like a wooden doll. That is not a very wonderful thing."

There is a statement about Uddhava's symptoms of love. When he saw Lord Kåñëa his eyes filled with tears and created a river which flowed down toward the sea of Kåñëa to offer tribute, as a wife offers tribute to her husband. When his body erupted with goose-pimples, he appeared like the kadamba flower, and when he began to offer prayers, he appeared completely distinct from all other devotees.

When affection is symptomized by direct happiness and distress, that is called attraction. In such an attracted state of ecstatic love, one can face all kinds of disadvantages calmly. Even at the risk of death such a devotee is never bereft of the transcendental loving service of the Lord. A glorious example of this ecstatic love was exhibited by King Parékñit when he was at the point of death. Although he was bereft of his entire kingdom, which spread over all the world, and although he was accepting not even a drop of water in the seven days remaining to him, because he was engaged in hearing the transcendental pastimes of the Lord from Çukadeva Gosvämé, he was not in the least distressed. On the contrary, he was feeling direct transcendental ecstatic joy in association with Çukadeva Gosvämé.

One devotee has confidently expressed this opinion: "If a drop of Lord Kåñëa's mercy can be bestowed upon me, then I shall feel completely carefree, even in the midst of a fire or an ocean. But if I become bereft of His causeless mercy, then even if I became the King of Dvärakä, I would be simply an object for pinpricks."

Devotees such as Mahäräj Parékñit and Uddhava are all situated in ecstatic attraction on the basis of affection, and in that state of affection a feeling of friendship becomes manifest. When Uddhava was freed from all material contamination, he saw the Lord, and his throat became choked up, and he could not speak. By the movements of his eyebrows alone he was embracing the Lord. Such ecstatic love has been divided by great scholars into two groups—addition and subtraction. If a devotee is not directly associated with the Lord, it is called subtraction. In this state of love, one is constantly fixed with his mind at the lotus feet of the Lord. A devotee in this state becomes very eager to learn of the transcendental qualities of the Lord. The most important business of such a devotee is attaining the association of the Lord.

In the Nåsiàha Puräëa there is a statement about King Ikñväku which illustrates this state of ecstatic love. Because of his great affection for Kåñëa, King Ikñväku became greatly attached to the black cloud, the black deer, the deer's black eyes and to the lotus flower, which is always compared to the eyes of the Lord. In the Tenth Canto, 38th Chapter, 9th verse of the Bhägavatam, Akrüra thinks: "Since the Lord has now appeared to diminish the great burden of the world and is now visible to everyone's eyes in His personal transcendental body, when we see Him before us, is that not the ultimate perfection of our eyes?" In other words, Akrüra realized that the perfection of the eyes is fulfilled when one is able to see Lord Kåñëa. Therefore, when Lord Kåñëa was visible on the earth by direct appearance, everyone who saw Him surely attained perfection of sight.

In the Kåñëa-karëämåta written by Bilvamaìgala Thäkur there is this expression of eagerness in ecstatic love: "How miserable it is, my dear Kåñëa, O friend of the hopeless! O merciful Lord, how can I pass these thankless days without seeing You?" A similar sentiment was expressed by Uddhava when he wrote a letter to Kåñëa and said, "My dear Supreme King of Braja, You are the vision of nectar for the eyes, and without seeing Your lotus feet and the effulgence of Your body, my mind is always morose. I cannot perceive any peace under any circumstance. Besides that, I am feeling every moment's separation to be like the duration of many, many long years."

In the Kåñëa-karëämåta it is also said, "My dear Lord, You are the ocean of mercy. With my arms placed upon my head, I am bowing down before You with all humility and sincerity. I am praying unto You, my Lord. Would You be pleased just to sprinkle a little of the water of Your glance upon me? That will be a great satisfaction."

A devotee of Lord Kåñëa said, "When even Çaçiçekhara [Lord Çiva] is unable to see You, what chance is there for me, who am lower than an ordinary worm? I have only committed misdeeds. I know that I am not at all fit to offer my prayers to You, but because You are known as Dénabandhu, the friend of the fallen, I humbly pray that You will kindly purify me by the beams of Your transcendental glance. If I become thoroughly bathed by Your merciful glance, then I may be saved. Therefore, my Lord, I am requesting You to please bestow upon me Your merciful glance."

NoD 38-1970: Indifference and Separation

Chapter Thirty-eight

Indifference and Separation

The great devotee Uddhava once wrote a letter to Kåñëa: "My dear Kåñëa, I have just finished the study of all kinds of philosophical books and Vedic verses about the goal of life, and so now I have a little reputation for my studies. But still, in spite of my reputation, my knowledge is condemned, because although enjoying the effulgence of Vedic knowledge, I could not appreciate the effulgence emanating from the nails of Your toes. Therefore, the sooner my pride and Vedic knowledge are finished, the better it will be!" This is an example of indifference.

Another devotee very anxiously expressed himself thusly: "My mind is very flickering, so I cannot concentrate it upon Your lotus feet. And seeing this inefficiency in myself I become ashamed, and the whole night I am unable to sleep because I am exasperated by my great inability."

In the Kåñëa-karëämåta Bilvamaìgala Thäkur has explained his restlessness as follows: "My dear Lord, Your naughtiness in boyhood is the most wonderful thing in the three worlds. And You Yourself know what this naughtiness is. As such, You can very easily understand my flickering mind. This is known to You and myself. Therefore, I am simply yearning to know how I can fix my mind on Your lotus feet."

Another devotee expressed his impudency by saying: "My dear Lord, without considering my lowly position, I must confess to You that my eyes are just like black wasps, desiring to hover at Your lotus feet."

In the Seventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 4th Chapter, 27th verse, the great sage Närada informs Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira about Prahläda Mahäräj, who was a devotee from the very beginning of his life. The proof of Prahläda's natural devotion is that even when he was a small child he did not play with his playmates, but was always eager to preach the glories of the Lord. Instead of joining in their sportive acrobatic feats, he remained as an inactive child because he was always in trance, meditating on Kåñëa. As such, there was no possibility of his being touched by the external world.

The following statement is about a brähmaëa devotee: "This brähmaëa is very expert in all kinds of activities, but I do not know why he is looking up without moving his eyes. It appears that his body is fixed motionless just like a doll's. In this condition, I can guess that he has been captivated by the transcendental beauty of that expert flute-player, Çré Kåñëa, and, being attached to Him, he is simply staring at the black cloud, remembering the bodily hue of Çré Kåñëa." This is an example of how a devotee can become inert due to ecstatic love.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Seventh Canto, 4th Chapter, 30th verse, Prahläda Mahäräj says that even in his childhood, when he was loudly speaking the glories of the Lord, he used to dance just like a shameless madman. And sometimes, being fully absorbed in thought on the pastimes of the Lord, he used to imitate such pastimes. This is an instance of a devotee's being almost like a madman. Similarly, it is said that the great sage Närada was so ecstatically in love with Kåñëa that he would sometimes dance naked, and sometimes his whole body would become stunned. Sometimes he would laugh very loudly, sometimes he would cry very loudly, sometimes he would remain silent, and sometimes he would appear to be suffering from some disease, although he had no disease. This is another instance of becoming like a madman in the ecstasy of devotion.

In the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya it is stated that when Prahläda Mahäräj was thinking himself unfit to approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he immersed himself in great distress, in an ocean of unhappiness. As such, he used to shed tears and lie down on the floor as though unconscious.

The students of a great devotee once talked amongst themselves in this way: "My dear Godbrothers, our spiritual master, after seeing the lotus feet of the Lord, has thrown himself into the fire of lamentation, and because of this fire the water of his life has almost dried away. Let us now pour the nectar of the holy name through his ears, and by doing so the swan of his life may again show signs of life."

When Lord Kåñëa went to the city of Çoëitapura to fight with Bali's son Bäëa and to cut off all his hands, Uddhava, being separated from Kåñëa and thinking of His fight, was almost completely stunned into unconsciousness.

When a devotee is fully in love with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, there may be the following symptoms due to his feelings of separation from the Lord: feverish condition of the body, withering of the body, lack of sleep, nonattachment, inertness, appearing diseased, madness, unconsciousness and sometimes death.

As far as the feverish condition of the body is concerned, Uddhava once told Närada, "My dear great sage, the lotus flower that is a friend of the sun may be a cause of distress for us; and the fire in the ocean may cause us some burning sensation; and Indévara, the friend of a demon, may distress us in various ways—we do not mind. But the most regrettable factor is that all of them remind us of Kåñëa, and this is giving us too much distress!" This is an instance of the feverish condition which is due to being separated from Kåñëa.

Some of the devotees who went to see Kåñëa at Dvärakä and were detained at the door said: "My dear Kåñëa, O friend of the Päëòus, as the swan loves to dive into the water amongst the lily flowers and would die if he were taken from the water, so we only wish to be with You. Our limbs are being shrunken and faded because You have been taken away from us."

The King of Bahulä, although very comfortably situated in his palace, began to think the nights very long and distressing because of his separation from Kåñëa.

King Yudhiñöhira once said, "Kåñëa, the chariot driver of Arjuna, is the only relative of mine within the three worlds. Therefore, my mind is becoming maddened day and night with separation from His lotus feet, and I do not know how to situate myself or where I shall go to attain any steadiness of mind." This is another example of lack of sleep.

Some of the cowherd friends of Kåñëa said, "My dear Kåñëa, O enemy of the Mura demon, just think of Your personal servant Raktaka. Simply because he saw a peacock feather he is now closing his eyes and is no longer attentive to pasturing the cows. Rather, he has left them in a faraway pasture and has not even bothered to use his stick to control them." This is an instance of mental imbalance due to separation from Kåñëa.

When Lord Kåñëa went to the capital of King Yudhiñöhira, Uddhava was so afflicted by the fire of separation from Çré Kåñëa that the perspiring water from his enflamed body and the tears from his eyes poured from him, and in this way he became completely stunned.

When Çré Kåñëa left the city of Dvärakä to seek out the Syamantaka jewel, He was late returning home. Uddhava became so afflicted that the symptoms of disease became manifest on his body. Actually, due to his excessive ecstatic love for Kåñëa, Uddhava became known in Dvärakä as crazy. To his great fortune, on that day Uddhava's reputation as a crazy fellow was firmly established. Uddhava's craziness was practically proved when he went to Raivataka Hill to minutely observe the congested black clouds. In his disturbed condition, he began to pray to these clouds, and he expressed his jubilation by bowing down before them.

Uddhava informed Kåñëa, "My dear leader of the Yadu dynasty, Your servants in Våndävana cannot sleep at night thinking of You, so now they are all lying down on the bank of the Yamunä almost paralyzed. And it appears that they are almost dead because their breathing is very slow." This is an instance of becoming unconscious due to separation from Kåñëa.

Kåñëa was once informed, "You are the life and soul of all the inhabitants of Våndävana. So because You have left Våndävana, all of the servitors of Your lotus feet there are suffering. It is as if the lakes filled with lotus flowers have dried up from the scorching heat of separation from You." In the example given here, the inhabitants of Våndävana are compared to lakes filled with lotus flowers, and because of the scorching heat of separation from Kåñëa, the lakes—along with the lotus flowers of their lives—are being burned up. And the swans in the lakes, who are compared to the vitality of the inhabitants of Våndävana, are no longer desiring to live in that lake. In other words, because of the scorching heat, the swans are leaving the lakes. This metaphor is used to describe the condition of the devotees separated from Kåñëa.

NoD 39-1970: Ways of Meeting Kåñëa

Chapter Thirty-nine

Ways of Meeting Kåñëa

When Kåñëa and His devotees meet, it is technically called yoga, or linking up with the Lord. Such meetings between Kåñëa and His devotees can be divided into three classes—namely, perfection, satisfaction, and steadiness. When the devotee meets with Kåñëa in great eagerness, that state of meeting is called perfection.

In the Kåñëa-karëämåta, Bilvamaìgala Thäkur describes how Kåñëa meets His devotee—with peacock feather on His head, with marakata jewels on His chest, with His ever-enchanting smile, His restless eyes and His very delicate body.

In the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 38th Chapter, 31st verse, Çukadeva Gosvämé tells King Parékñit: "My dear King, as soon as Akrüra the chariot driver saw Lord Kåñëa and His elder brother Balaräma in Våndävana, he immediately got down from the chariot and, being greatly afflicted by affection for the transcendental Lord, fell down upon His lotus feet to offer respectful obeisances." These are some of the instances of perfectional meetings with Kåñëa.

When a devotee meets Kåñëa after long separation, it is called satisfaction. In the First Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 11th Chapter, 9th verse, it is stated that when Lord Kåñëa returned to His capital, Dvärakä, the inhabitants began to say, "My dear Lord, if You remain in foreign countries for so long, we shall certainly be bereft of seeing Your smiling face! And observing Your face, we, Your eternal servitors, become greatly satisfied. All the anxieties of our existence are immediately mitigated. If we cannot see You because You are long absent from Dvärakä, then it will be impossible for us to live anymore." This is an instance of satisfaction in meeting Kåñëa after long separation.

Kåñëa's personal servant, Däruka, seeing Kåñëa at the door of Dvärakä, forgot to offer Him respects with folded hands.

When a devotee is ultimately situated in association with Kåñëa, his position is called steadiness in devotional service. This steady position in devotional service is explained in the book known as Haàsadüta. It is described there how Akrüra, who was considered by the gopés to be terror personified, would talk with Kåñëa about the activities of the Kuru dynasty. A similar steady position was held by Uddhava, the disciple of Båhaspati. He would always massage the lotus feet of Kåñëa while kneeling down on the ground before Him.

When a devotee is engaged in the service of the Lord, it is called the attainment of yoga. The English equivalent to the word "yoga" is "linking up." So actual linking up with Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, begins when the devotee renders service unto Him. Devotees situated in the transcendental rasa of servitorship render their particular service whenever there is an opportunity. Sometimes they sit down in front of Kåñëa to receive orders. Some persons are reluctant to accept this level of devotional service as actual bhakti-yoga, and in some of the Puräëas also this servitorship in devotional service to Kåñëa is not accepted as the actual bhakti-yoga system. But in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it has been clearly indicated that the servitor relationship with Kåñëa is the actual beginning of yoga realization.

In the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 3rd Chapter, 33rd verse, it is stated that when devotees are engaged in the discharge of bhakti-yoga, sometimes they cry from thinking of Kåñëa, sometimes they laugh, sometimes they become jubilant, and sometimes they talk in very uncommon ways. Sometimes they dance, sometimes they sing, sometimes they are actually engaged in the service of the Lord, and sometimes they sit down silently as if absorbed in trance.

Similarly, in the Seventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Chapter 28, Prahläda Mahäräj says to his friends: "My dear friends, as soon as pure devotees of Lord Kåñëa hear of the transcendental pastimes of the Lord, who is the eternal reservoir of pastimes, or hear about His transcendental qualities they become overpowered with jubilation. Ecstatic symptoms are manifested in their bodies. They shed tears, talk falteringly, glorify the Lord in a loud voice and chant and dance in ecstasy. These ecstasies are always there, but sometimes they overcome all limits, and the symptoms become manifest to all."

In the process of surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead there are six items: to accept everything which is favorable for devotional service, to reject everything which is unfavorable for devotional service, to believe that Kåñëa will always give protection, to identify oneself with Kåñëa's devotees, to always feel inability without the help of Kåñëa, and to always think oneself inferior to Kåñëa, even though one may have full capacity to perform something on his own. When one is substantially convinced that he is always protected by Kåñëa in all circumstances, that feeling is called reverential devotion. Reverential devotion is executed in relation with the Supreme Personality of Godhead and with His other protected devotees.

When Kåñëa was residing in Dvärakä, some of the elderly members of the Yadu family would occasionally put some important matter before Him. At such a time, Kåñëa would carefully give attention to those matters. And if there were some humorous topics mentioned, Kåñëa would immediately respond with a smiling face. Sometimes when Kåñëa was executing His duties in the assembly known as Sudharmä, He would ask the elderly members for good advice. By such activities He is manifest as the supreme spiritual master, the supreme executive head, the superior intelligence, the supreme power, protector and maintainer.

NoD 40-1970: Reverential Devotion of Sons and Other Subordinates

Chapter Forty

Reverential Devotion of Sons and Other Subordinates

True reverential devotion is exhibited by persons who think themselves subordinate to Kåñëa and by persons who think themselves sons of Kåñëa. The best examples of this subordination are Säraëa, Gada and Subhadrä. They were all members of the Yadu dynasty, and they used to always think themselves protected by Kåñëa. Similarly, Kåñëa's sons, such as Pradyumna, Cärudeñëa, and Sämba, felt the same way. Kåñëa had many sons in Dvärakä. He begot ten sons by each of His 16,108 queens, and all of these sons, headed by Pradyumna, Cärudeñëa and Sämba, used to think themselves always protected by Kåñëa. When Kåñëa's sons dined with Him, they would sometimes open their mouths for Kåñëa to feed them. Sometimes when Kåñëa would pat one of His sons, the son would sit on Kåñëa's lap, and while Kåñëa was blessing the son's head by smelling it, the others would shed tears, thinking how many pious activities he must have performed in his previous life. Out of Kåñëa's many sons, Pradyumna, a son of Kåñëa's chief queen, Rukmiëé, is considered the leader. Pradyumna's bodily features resembled Kåñëa's exactly. Pure devotees of Kåñëa glorify Pradyumna because he is so fortunate: like father like son.

There is a description in the Hari-vaàça of Pradyumna's activities when he kidnapped Prabhävaté. Pradyumna addressed Prabhävaté at that time and said: "My dear Prabhävaté, just look at the head of our family, Çré Kåñëa: He is Viñëu Himself, the supreme driver of Garuòa, and He is our supreme master. Because we have become so proud and confident of His protecting us, we sometimes do not even care about fighting with Tripuräri [Lord Çiva]."

There are two kinds of devotees engaged in devotional service with awe and veneration, and the servitors in the abode of Dvärakä always worship Kåñëa as the most respectable and revered Personality of Godhead. They are captivated by Kåñëa because of His super-excellent opulences. The members who always thought themselves protected by Kåñëa could readily convert their conviction into practical demonstration, because it was sometimes found that the sons of Kåñëa acted very unlawfully in various places. Nonetheless they were given full protection by Kåñëa and Balaräma.

Even Balaräma, the elder brother of Kåñëa, sometimes unknowingly offered respect to Him. Once when Kåñëa came before Lord Balaräma, He was anxious to offer His respects to His elder brother, but at that time Balaräma's club was lowered down upon Kåñëa's lotus feet. In other words, the club in Balaräma's hand offered its own respects to Kåñëa. These feelings of subordination, as explained above, are sometimes manifested as anubhäva.

When demigods from the heavenly planets came to Çré Kåñëa, all of Kåñëa's sons followed them, and Lord Brahmä sprinkled water from his kamaëòalu upon them. When the demigods came before Kåñëa, instead of sitting on golden chairs, the sons sat down on the floor, which was covered with deerskin.

Sometimes the behavior of Kåñëa's sons appears similar to the behavior of His personal servants. For example, the sons used to offer their obeisances, they were silent, submissive and gentle, and they were always ready to carry out Kåñëa's orders, even at the risk of life. When present before Kåñëa, they bowed down on the ground. They were very silent and steady, and they used to restrain coughing and laughing before the Lord. Also, they never discussed Kåñëa's pastimes in conjugal love. In other words, devotees who are engaged in reverential devotional service should not discuss the conjugal love affairs of Kåñëa. No one should claim his eternal relationship with Kåñëa unless he is liberated. In the conditioned state of life, the devotees have to execute the prescribed duties as recommended in the codes of devotional service. When one is mature in devotional service and is a realized soul, he can know his own eternal relationship with Kåñëa. One should not artificially try to establish some relationship. In the premature stage it is sometimes found that a lusty, conditioned person will artificially try to establish some relationship with Kåñëa in conjugal love. The result of this is that one becomes prakåta-sahajiyä, or one who takes everything very cheaply. Although such persons may be very anxious to establish a relationship with Kåñëa in conjugal love, their conditioned life in the material world is still most abominable. A person who has actually established his relationship with Kåñëa can no longer act on the material plane, and his personal character cannot be criticized.

When Cupid came on one occasion to visit Lord Kåñëa, some devotee addressed him thus: "My dear Cupid, because you have been so fortunate as to have placed your eyesight on the lotus feet of Kåñëa, the drops of perspiration on your body have become frozen, and they resemble kaëöaki fruits [a kind of a small fruit found in thorny bushes]." These are signs of ecstasy and veneration unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. When the princes of the Yadu dynasty heard the vibration of Kåñëa's Päïcajanya conchshell, the hairs on their bodies immediately stood up in ecstatic jubilation. It seemed at that time that all the hairs on the bodies of the princes were dancing in ecstasy.

In addition to jubilation, there are sometimes symptoms of disappointment. Pradyumna once addressed Sämba with these words: "My dear Sämba, you are such a glorified personality! I have seen that once when you were playing on the ground, your body became covered with dust; yet, our father, Lord Kåñëa, still took you up on His lap. But I am so unfortunate that I could never get such love from our father!" This statement is an example of disappointment in love.

To regard Kåñëa as one's superior is called reverential feeling, and when, in addition to this, a devotee feels that Kåñëa is his protector, his transcendental love for Kåñëa is increased, and his combined feelings are called reverential devotion. When this steady reverential devotion increases further, it is called love of Godhead in reverential devotion. Attraction and affection are two prominent symptoms of this stage. In this reverential devotional attitude, Pradyumna never talked to his father in a loud voice. In fact, he never so much as unlocked the lips of his mouth, nor did he ever show his face filled with tears. He would always glance only at the lotus feet of his father.

There is another example of steady and fixed love for Kåñëa in the instance of Arjuna's informing Him of the death of Arjuna's son, Abhimanyu, who was also the nephew of Kåñëa. Abhimanyu was the son of Subhadrä, Kåñëa's younger sister. He was killed at the Battle of Kurukñetra by the combined efforts of all the commanders in King Duryodhana's army—namely, Karëa, Açvatthämä, Jayadratha, Bhéñma, Kåpäcärya and Droëäcärya. In order to assure Kåñëa that there was no change of love on Subhadrä's part, Arjuna informed Him: "Although Abhimanyu was killed almost in Your presence, Subhadrä's love for You is not agitated at all, nor has it even slightly changed its original color."

The affection that Kåñëa has for His devotees was expressed by Himself when He asked Pradyumna not to feel so bashful before Him. He addressed Pradyumna thus: "My dear boy, just give up your inferiority complex, and do not hang your neck. Just talk with Me in a clear voice, and do not shed tears. You can look straight at Me, and you can place your hands on My body without any hesitation. There is no need of exhibiting so much reverence before your father."

Pradyumna's attachment for Kåñëa was always exhibited by his action. Whenever he was ordered by his father to execute something, he would immediately execute the order, taking the task as nectarean even though it may have been poison. Similarly, whenever he would find something to be disapproved of by his father, he would immediately reject it as poison, even though it may have been nectarean.

Pradyumna's attachment in anxiety for Kåñëa was expressed when he said to his wife Rati: "The enemy, Çambara, is already killed. Now I am very anxious to see my father, who is my spiritual master and who always carries the conchshell known as Päïcajanya." Pradyumna felt great separation from Kåñëa when He was absent from Dvärakä at the battlefield of Kurukñetra. He said, "Since my father has left Dvärakä, I do not take much pleasure in practicing fighting, nor am I interested in any kind of sporting pastimes. And what need is there to speak of these things? I do not even wish to stay at Dvärakä in the absence of my father."

When Pradyumna came back home after killing the Çambaräsura, and as soon as he saw his father, Kåñëa, before him, he became so overjoyed that he himself could not understand his joy on that occasion. This is an instance of success in separation. A similar satisfaction was observed when Kåñëa returned from the battlefield of Kurukñetra to His home at Dvärakä. All of His sons were so overjoyed that, out of ecstasy, they repeatedly made many mistakes. These mistakes were a sign of complete satisfaction.

Every day Pradyumna looked over Kåñëa's lotus feet with tears in his eyes. These signs of reverential devotion on the part of Pradyumna can be described in the same way they have been described in the case of other devotees.

NoD 41-1970: Fraternal Devotion

Chapter Forty-one

Fraternal Devotion

When a devotee is permanently situated in devotional service, and by different symptoms of ecstasy he has developed and matured a fraternal mellow or flavor in relationship with the Personality of Godhead, at that time his feeling is called fraternal love of Godhead.

The impetus for such fraternal love of God is God Himself. When one is liberated and discovers his eternal relationship with the Supreme Lord, the Lord Himself becomes the impetus for increasing fraternal love. The eternal associates of the Lord in Våndävana have described this as follows: "The Lord, Hari, whose bodily hue is like the indranéla jewel, whose smiling is as beautiful as the kunda flower, whose silk dress is as yellow as golden autumn foliage, whose chest is beautified with garlands of flowers and who is always playing upon His flute—this enemy of the Agha demon is always attracting our hearts by wandering about Våndävana."

There are similar statements of fraternal love expressed outside the jurisdiction of Våndävana. When the sons of Päëòu, headed by Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira, saw Kåñëa in His fourhanded form on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, holding His conchshell, disk, club and lotus flower, they completely forgot themselves and became merged in the ocean of nectarean happiness. This shows how the sons of Päëòu-King Yudhiñöhira, Bhéma, Arjuna, Nakula and Sahadeva—were all caught up in fraternal love for Kåñëa.

Sometimes the different names, forms, paraphernalia and transcendental qualities provoke fraternal love: For instance, Kåñëa's nice dress, the all-auspicious symptoms on His body, His strongly-built body, His knowledge of different languages, His learned teachings in the Bhagavad-gétä, His uncommon genius in all fields of endeavor, His exhibition of expert knowledge, His mercy, His chivalry, His behavior as a conjugal lover, His intelligence, His forgiveness, His attraction for all kinds of men, His opulence and His happiness—all provoke fraternal love.

The impetus to fraternal love upon seeing the associates of Kåñëa in Våndävana is also very natural, for their personal bodily features, their qualities and dress are all equal to Kåñëa's. These associates are always happy in their service to Kåñëa, and they are generally known as vayasyas, or friends of the same age. These vayasyas are fully confident of protection by Kåñëa. Devotees sometimes pray: "Let us offer our respectful obeisances unto the vayasyas of Kåñëa, who are firmly convinced of Kåñëa's friendship and protection and whose devotion to Kåñëa is ever-fixed. They are fearless, and on a level equal with Kåñëa they discharge their transcendental loving devotional service." Such eternal vayasyas are also found beyond the jurisdiction of Våndävana, in places such as Dvärakä and Hastinäpura. Except for Våndävana, all the places of Kåñëa's pastimes are called puras (towns). Mathurä and Hastinäpura, the capital of the Kurus, are both puras. Personalities like Arjuna, Bhéma, Draupadé and Çrédämä Brähmaëa are counted amongst Kåñëa's fraternal devotees in the puras.

How the sons of Päëòu, the Päëòavas, enjoy Kåñëa's association is described as follows: "When Çré Kåñëa arrived in Indraprastha, the capital of the Kurus, Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira immediately came out to smell the flavor of Kåñëa's head." It is the Vedic custom that superiors smell the heads of their subordinates when the subordinates offer respect to the superior by touching his feet. Similarly, Arjuna and Bhéma embraced Kåñëa with great jubilation, and the two younger brothers, namely Nakula and Sahadeva, touched the lotus feet of Kåñëa with tears in their eyes and offered their respects. In this way all the five Päëòava brothers enjoyed the fraternal friendship of Kåñëa in transcendental mellow. Of the five Päëòavas, Arjuna is the most intimately connected with Kåñëa. He has a nice bow in his hand which is called Gäëòéva. His thighs are compared with the trunks of elephants, and his eyes are always reddish. When Kåñëa and Arjuna are together on a chariot, they become celestial beauties, pleasing to the eyes of everyone. It is said that once Arjuna was lying in his bed with his head upon Kåñëa's lap and was talking and joking with Kåñëa in great relaxation and was enjoying Kåñëa's company with smiling and great satisfaction.

As far as the vayasyas (friends) in Våndävana are concerned, they become greatly distressed when they cannot see Kåñëa even for a moment.

There is the following prayer by a devotee for the vayasyas in Våndävana: "All glories to Kåñëa's vayasyas, who are just like Kåñëa in their age, qualities, pastimes, dress and beauty. They are accustomed to playing on their flutes made of palm leaves, and they all have buffalo-horn bugles ornamented like Kåñëa's with jewels such as indranéla and with gold and coral. They are always jubilant like Kåñëa. May these glorious companions of Kåñëa always protect us!"

The vayasyas in Våndävana are in such intimate friendship with Kåñëa that sometimes they think themselves as good as Kåñëa. Here is an instance of such friendly feeling: When Kåñëa was holding up Govardhan Hill with His left hand, the vayasyas said, "My dear friend, You have been standing for the last seven days and nights without any rest. This is very troublesome for us because we see that you have undertaken a severely laborious task. We think, therefore, that you need not continue to stand in that way holding the hill. You can just transfer it onto Sudämä's hand. We are very much aggrieved to see You in this position. If You think that Sudämä is not able to support Govardhan Hill, then at least You should change hands. Instead of supporting it with Your left hand, please transfer it to Your right hand, so that we can give Your left hand a massage." This is an instance of intimacy, showing how much the vayasyas considered themselves to be equal to Kåñëa.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 12th Chapter, 10th verse, Çukadeva Gosvämé tells King Parékñit: "My dear King, Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead to the learned transcendentalist, He is the supreme happiness for the impersonalist, He is the supreme worshipable Deity for the devotee, and He is just like an ordinary boy to one who is under the spell of mäyä. And just imagine—these cowherd boys are now playing with the Supreme Person as though they are on an equal level! By this anyone can understand that these boys must have accumulated heaps of the results of pious activities to enable them to associate with the Supreme Personality of Godhead in such intimate friendship."

There is a description of Kåñëa's feeling for his vayasyas in Våndävana. He once said to Balaräma, "My dear brother, when My companions were being devoured by the Aghäsura, hot tears poured down from My eyes. And as they were washing My cheeks, My dear elder brother, for at least one moment I completely lost Myself."

Within Gokula, Kåñëa's vayasyas are generally divided into four groups: 1) well-wishers, 2) friends, 3) confidential friends and 4) intimate friends. Kåñëa's well-wisher friends are a little bit older than Kåñëa, and they have some parental affection for Him. Because of their being older than Kåñëa they always try to protect Him from any harm. As such, they sometimes bear weapons so that they can chastise any mischievous persons who want to do harm to Kåñëa. Counted amongst the well-wisher friends are Subhadra,* Maëòalébhadra, Bhadravardhana, Gobhaöa, Yakña, Indrabhaöa, Bhadräìga, Vérabhadra, Mahäguëa, Vijaya, and Balabhadra. They are older than Kåñëa and are always thinking of His welfare.

One of the elderly friends said, "My dear Maëòalébhadra, why are you wielding a shining sword as though you were running towards Ariñöäsura to kill him? My dear Baladeva, why are you unnecessarily bearing that heavy plow? My dear Vijaya, don't be unnecessarily agitated. My dear Bhadravardhana, there is no need to make these threatening motions. If you will all look more closely you will see that it is only a thunder cloud upon Govardhana Hill; it is not the Ariñöäsura in the shape of a bull, as you have imagined." These older, well-wishing friends of Kåñëa imagined a large cloud to be the Ariñöäsura, appearing in the shape of a huge bull. In the midst of their excitement one of them ascertained that it was actually only a cloud on Govardhan Hill. He therefore informed the others not to take the trouble of worrying about Kåñëa, because there was no present danger from Ariñöäsura.

Amongst the well-wisher friends, Maëòalébhadra and Balabhadra are the chiefs. Maëòalébhadra is described as follows: his complexion is yellowish, and his dress is very attractive. He always carries a stick of various colors. He wears a peacock feather on his head and always looks very beautiful. Maëòalébhadra's attitude is revealed in his statement: "My dear friends, our beloved Kåñëa is now very tired from working with the cows in the pasturing grounds and from traveling all over the forests. I can see that He is very fatigued. Let me massage His head silently while He is taking rest in His house. And you, Subala—you just massage His thighs."

One devotee described the personal beauty of Baladeva as follows: "Let me take shelter of the lotus feet of Balaräma, whose beauty is enhanced by the earrings touching his cheeks. His face is decorated with tilaka made from kastüré (musk), and His broad chest is decorated with a garland of guïja (small conchshells). His complexion is as white as an autumn cloud, He wears garments of blue color, and His voice is very grave. His arms are very long, touching His thighs, and He has shown His great strength by killing the Pralamba demon. Let me take shelter of this chivalrous Balaräma."*

Baladeva's affection for Kåñëa is illustrated in this statement to Subala: "My dear friend, please inform Kåñëa not to go to Käliya's lake today. Today is His birthday, and so I wish to go along with Mother Yaçodä to bathe Him. Tell Him He should not leave the house today." This shows how Balaräma, Kåñëa's elder brother, took care of Kåñëa with parental love, within the scope of fraternal affection.

Friends who were younger than Kåñëa, who were always attached to Him and who gave Him all kinds of service, are called ordinary friends, or, simply, friends. Such ordinary friends are called sakhäs, and the names of some sakhäs are Viçäla, Våñabha, Ojasvi, Devaprastha, Varüthapa, Maranda, Kusumäpéòa, Maëibandha, and Karandhama. All of these sakhä friends of Kåñëa sought only to serve Him. Sometimes some of them would rise early in the morning and immediately go to Kåñëa's place and wait at the door to see Kåñëa and to accompany Him to the pasturing grounds. In the meantime, Kåñëa would be dressed by Mother Yaçodä, and when she would see a boy standing at the door, she would call him: "Well, Viçäla, why are you standing there? Come here!" So with the permission of Mother Yaçodä, he would immediately enter the house. And while Mother Yaçodä was dressing Kåñëa, he would try to help put on Kåñëa's ankle bells, and Kåñëa would jokingly strike him with His flute. Then Mother Yaçodä would call, "Kåñëa, what is this? Why are You teasing Your friend?" And Kåñëa would laugh, and the friend would also laugh. These are some of the activities of Kåñëa's sakhäs. Sometimes the sakhäs would take care of the cows who were going hither and thither. They would tell Kåñëa, "Your cows were going off here and there," and Kåñëa would thank them.

Sometimes when Kåñëa and His sakhäs went to the pasturing ground, Kaàsa would send a demon to kill Kåñëa. Therefore, almost every day there was a fight with some different kind of demon. After fighting with a demon, Kåñëa would feel fatigued, the hairs on His head would be scattered, and the sakhäs would immediately come and try to relieve Him in different ways. Some friends would say, "My dear Viçäla, please take this fan of lotus leaves and fan Kåñëa so that He may feel some comfort. Varüthapa, you just brush the scattered hairs on Kåñëa's head which have fallen upon His face. Våñabha, don't talk unnecessarily! Immediately massage Kåñëa's body. His arms have become tired from fighting and wrestling with that demon. Oh, just see how our friend Kåñëa has become tired!" These are some examples of the treatment given to Kåñëa by the sakhäs.

One of the sakhäs, known as Devaprastha, is described as follows: he is very strong, a ready scholar, and is very expert in playing ball. He wears a white dress, and he ties his hair into a bunch with a rope. Whenever there is a fight between Kåñëa and the demons, Devaprastha is the first to help, and he fights just like an elephant.

One of the gopés once said to her friend, "My dear beautiful friend, when Kåñëa, the son of Mahäräj Nanda, was taking rest within the cave of a hill, He was keeping His head on the arms of Çrédämä, and He was putting His left hand on Dämä's chest. Taking this opportunity, Devaprastha, out of his strong affection for Kåñëa, immediately began to massage His legs." Such are the activities of Kåñëa's friends out on the pasturing grounds.

The more confidential friends are called priya-sakhäs and are almost Kåñëa's age. Because of their very confidential friendship, their behavior is only on the basis of pure friendship. Other friends' behavior is on the ground of paternal love or servitude, but the basic principle of the confidential friends is simply friendship on an equal level. Some confidential friends are as follows: Çrédämä, Sudämä, Dämä, Vasudämä, Kiìkiëi, Stokakåñëa, Aàçu, Bhadrasena, Viläsina, Puëòaréka, Viöaìka and Kalaviìka. By their various activities in different pastimes, all of these friends used to give transcendental pleasure to Kåñëa.

The behavior of these confidential friends is described by a friend of Rädhäräëé, who told Rädhäräëé: "My dear graceful Rädhäräëé, Your intimate friend, Kåñëa, is also served by His intimate boy friends. Some of them cut jokes with Him in mild voices and please Him very much by this." For example, Kåñëa had one brähmaëa friend whose name was Madhumaìgala. This boy would joke by playing the part of a greedy brähmaëa. Whenever the friends ate, he would eat more than all others, especially läòòus, of which he was very fond. Then after eating more läòòus than anyone else, Madhumaìgala would still not be satisfied, and he would say to Kåñëa, "If You give me one more läòòu, then I shall be pleased to give You my blessings so that Your friend Rädhäräëé will be very much pleased with You." The brähmaëas are supposed to give blessings to the vaiçyas (farming and merchant caste), and Kåñëa presented Himself as the son of Mahäräj Nanda, a vaiçya; so the brähmaëa boy was right in giving blessings to Kåñëa. Thus Kåñëa was very pleased by His friend's blessings, and He would supply him with more and more läòòus.

Sometimes a confidential friend would come before Kåñëa and embrace Him with great affection and love. Another friend would then come up from the rear and cover Kåñëa's eyes with his hands. Kåñëa would always feel very happy by such dealings with His confidential friends.

Out of all these confidential friends, Çrédämä is considered to be the chief. Çrédämä used to put on a yellow-colored dress. He would carry a buffalo horn, and his turban was of reddish, copper color. His bodily complexion was blackish, and around his neck there was a nice garland. He would always challenge Kåñëa in joking friendship. Let us pray to Çrédämä to bestow his mercy upon us!

Sometimes Çrédämä used to address Kåñëa: "Oh, You are so cruel that You left us alone on the bank of Yamunä, and we were all mad from not seeing You there! Now it is our great fortune that we are able to see You here. If You want to pacify us, You must embrace each one of us with Your arms. But believe me, my dear friend, a moment's absence from You creates great havoc, not only for us but for the cows also. Everything becomes disarranged, and we become mad after You."

There are other friends who are still more confidential. They are called priya-narmä, or intimate friends. Counted among the priya-narmä friends are Subala, Arjuna, Gandharva, Vasanta and Ujjvala. There was talk among the friends of Rädhäräëé, the gopés, about these most intimate friends. One gopé addressed Rädhäräëé thusly: "My dear Kåçäìgé [delicate one], just see how Subala is whispering Your message into Kåñëa's ear, how he is delivering the confidential letter of Çyämädäsé silently into Kåñëa's hand, how he is delivering the betel nuts prepared by Pälikä into Kåñëa's mouth, and how he is decorating Kåñëa with the garland prepared by Tärakä. Did you know, my dear friend, that all these most intimate friends of Kåñëa are always engaged in His service in this way?" Out of the many intimate priya-narmäs, Subala and Ujjvala are considered to be the most prominent.

Subala's body is described as follows. His complexion is just like molten gold. He is very, very dear to Kåñëa. He always has a garland around his neck, and he wears yellow clothing. His eyes are just like lotus flower petals, and he is so intelligent that by his talking and his moral instructions, all the other friends take the highest pleasure. Let us all offer our respectful obeisances unto Kåñëa's friend Subala!

The degree of intimacy shared by Kåñëa and Subala can be understood by the fact that the talks between them were so confidential that no one else could understand what they were saying.

The description of Ujjvala, another intimate friend, is given as follows. Ujjvala always wears some garment of orange color, and the movements of his eyes are always very restless. He likes to decorate himself with all kinds of flowers, his bodily hue is almost like Kåñëa's, and on his neck there is always a necklace of pearls. He is always very dear to Kåñëa. Let us all worship Ujjvala, the most intimate friend of Kåñëa!

About the confidential service of Ujjvala, this statement is to be found, addressed by Rädhäräëé to one of Her friends: "My dear friend, it is impossible for Me to keep My prestige! I wanted to avoid talking to Kåñëa anymore—but just see! There again is His friend, Ujjvala, coming to Me with his canvassing work. His entreaties are so powerful that it is very difficult for a gopé to resist her love for Kåñëa, even though she may be very bashful, devoted to her family duties and most faithful to her husband."

The following is a statement by Ujjvala, showing his jubilant nature: "My dear Kåñëa, O killer of Aghäsura, You have extended Your loving affairs so much that You can be compared to the great ocean, which is without limitations. At the same time, the young girls of the world who are all searching after the perfect lover have become just like rivers running into this ocean. Under the circumstances, all these rivers of young girls may try to divert their courses to some other place, but at the end they must come unto You."

Amongst the groups of different friends of Kåñëa, some are well-known from various scriptures, and some are well-known by popular tradition. There are three divisions amongst Kåñëa's friends: some are eternally in friendship with Kåñëa, some are elevated demigods, and some are perfected devotees. In all of these groups there are some who by nature are fixed in Kåñëa's service and are always engaged in giving counsel; some of them are very fond of joking and naturally cause Kåñëa to smile by their words; some of them are by nature very simple, and by their simplicity they please Lord Kåñëa; some of them create wonderful situations by their activities, apparently against Kåñëa; some of them are very talkative, always arguing with Kåñëa and creating a debating atmosphere; and some of them are very gentle and give pleasure to Kåñëa by their sweet words. All of these friends are very intimate with Kåñëa, and they show expertise in their different activities, their aim always being to please Kåñëa.

NoD 42-1970: Fraternal Loving Affairs

Chapter Forty-two

Fraternal Loving Affairs

Kåñëa's age, His beauty, His bugle, His flute, His conchshell and His pleasing attitude all provoke love in friendship for Him. His exceptional joking abilities, exhibited sometimes by His pretending to be a royal prince, or even the Supreme Personality of Godhead, also give impetus to devotees developing love for Kåñëa in friendship.

Learned scholars have divided Kåñëa's age into three periods: the age up to five years is called kaumära, the age from the sixth to the tenth year is called paugaëòa, and the age from the eleventh to fifteenth year is called kaiçora. While Kåñëa is spending His days as a cowherd boy, He is in the kaumära and paugaëòa ages. In the kaiçora age, when Kåñëa appeared at Gokula, He acted as a cowherd boy, and then, when He was sixteen, He went to Mathurä to kill Kaàsa.

The kaumära age is just suitable for reciprocating the love of a child with Mother Yaçodä. In the Tenth Canto, 13th Chapter, 9th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çukadeva Gosvämé tells King Parékñit: "My dear King, although Lord Kåñëa is the supreme enjoyer and the beneficiary of all kinds of sacrificial ceremonies, He still used to eat with His cowherd boy friends. This is because at that time He accepted the pastimes of an ordinary boy, keeping His flute under His arm and His bugle on the right side in His belt, along with His cane. In His left hand He would hold a lump of rice paste with yogurt, and in His fingers would be pélu, the king of fruits. When He would thus sit amongst His friends, it would appear that He was the whorl of a lotus flower and that the friends surrounding Him were petals. As they thus enjoyed joking amongst themselves, the denizens of heaven would become struck with wonder and would only stare at the scene."

Kåñëa's paugaëòa age can be further divided into three periods—namely, the beginning, middle and end. In the beginning of the paugaëòa age there is a very nice reddish luster on His lips, His abdomen is very thin, and on His neck are circles like those on a conchshell. Sometimes, some outside visitors would return to Våndävana to see Kåñëa and, upon seeing Him again, would exclaim, "My dear Mukunda, Your beauty is gradually increasing, just like the leaf on a banyan tree! My dear lotus-eyed one, Your neck is gradually manifesting circles like the conchshell. And in the shining moonlight Your teeth and cheeks are competing with the padmaräga jewels in their beautiful arrangement. I am sure that Your beautiful bodily development is now giving much pleasure to Your friends."

At this age Kåñëa was garlanded with various kinds of flowers. He used to put on a silk dress, colored with various kinds of dye. Such beautiful decorations are considered cosmetics for Kåñëa. Kåñëa would wear this dress when He used to go into the forest to tend the cows. Sometimes He would wrestle there with His different friends, and sometimes they would dance all together in the forest. These are some of the specific activities of the paugaëòa age.

The cowherd friends of Kåñëa were so happy in His company that they expressed their transcendental feelings within themselves thus: "My dear Kåñëa, You are always busy tending the cows which are scattered all over beautiful Våndävana. You have a beautiful garland, a small conchshell, a peacock feather on Your turban, yellow-colored silk cloth, decorations of karëikära flowers on Your ears and a mallékä flower garland on Your chest. Appearing so beautiful, when You pretend, just like an actor, to be fighting with us, You give us unlimited transcendental bliss."

When Kåñëa is more grown-up, in the middle age of paugaëòa, His nails become finely sharp, and His chubby cheeks become lustrous and round. On the two sides of His waist above His belt there are three distinct lines of folded skin, called tribali.

The cowherd boy friends of Kåñëa felt very proud of their association with Him. At that time the tip of His nose defeated the beauty of the sesame flowers, the luster of His cheeks defeated the glow of pearls, and the two sides of His body were exquisitely beautiful. In this age Kåñëa wore a silk dress that glittered like lightning, His head was decorated with a silk turban covered with gold lace, and in His hand He carried a stick about fifty-six inches long.* Seeing this exquisitely beautiful dress of Kåñëa, one devotee addressed his friend in this manner: "My dear friend, just look at Kåñëa! See how He is carrying in His hand a stick which is bound up and down with golden rings, how His turban with golden lace is showing such a beautiful luster, and how His dress is giving his friends the highest transcendental pleasure!"

At the end of Kåñëa's paugaëòa age, Kåñëa's hair sometimes hangs down to His hips, and sometimes it becomes scattered. In this age His two shoulders become higher and broader, and His face is always decorated with marks of tilaka. When His beautiful hair scatters over His shoulders, it appears to be a goddess of fortune embracing Him, and this embracing is highly relished by His friends. Subala once addressed Him in this way: "My dear Keçava, Your round turban, the lotus flower in Your hand, the vertical marks of tilaka on Your forehead, Your kuìkum-flavored musk and all of Your beautiful bodily features are defeating me today, although I am usually stronger than You or any of our friends. Since this is so, I do not know how these features of Your body can fail to defeat the pride of all the young girls of Våndävana. When I am so defeated by this beauty, what chance is there for those who are naturally very simple and flexible?"

At this age Kåñëa took pleasure in whispering into the ears of His friends, and the subject of His talks was the beauty of the gopés, who were just tarrying before them. Subala once addressed Kåñëa thus: "My dear Kåñëa, You are very cunning. You can understand the thoughts of others; therefore I am whispering within Your ear that all these five gopés, who are most beautiful, have been attracted by Your dress. And I believe that Cupid has entrusted them with the responsibility of conquering You." In other words, the beauty of the gopés was capable of conquering Kåñëa, although Kåñëa is the conqueror of all universes.

The symptoms of the kaiçora age are already described, and it is at this age that devotees generally most appreciate Kåñëa. Kåñëa with Rädhäräëé is worshiped as Kiçora-kiçoré. Kåñëa does not increase His age beyond this form of kaiçora, and it is confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä that although He is the oldest personality and has innumerable different forms, His original form is always youthful. In the pictures of Kåñëa on the battlefield of Kurukñetra we can see that He is youthful, although at that time He was old enough to have sons, grandsons, and great grandsons. The cowherd boy friends of Kåñëa once said, "My dear Kåñëa, You need not decorate Your body with so many ornaments. Your transcendental features are themselves so beautiful that You do not require any ornamentation." At this age, whenever Kåñëa begins to vibrate His flute early in the morning, all of His friends immediately get up from bed just to join Him in going to the pasturing grounds. One of the friends once said, "My dear cowherd friends, the sound of Kåñëa's flute from above Govardhan Hill is telling us that we need not go to search Him out on the bank of the Yamunä."

Pärvaté, the wife of Lord Çiva, told her husband: "My dear Païcamukha [five-faced], just look at the Päëòavas! After hearing the sound of Kåñëa's conchshell known as Päïcajanya, they have regained their strength and are just like lions."

At this age, Kåñëa once dressed Himself up exactly like Rädhäräëé, just to create fun among His friends. He put on golden earrings; and because He was blackish, He smeared the pulp of kuìkum all over His body in order to become as fair as She. By seeing this dress, Kåñëa's friend Subala became very astonished.

Kåñëa sometimes played with His intimate friends by engaging in fighting or wrestling with their arms, sometimes by playing ball, sometimes by playing chess, sometimes by carrying one another on the shoulders, and sometimes by exhibiting their expertness at whirling logs. And the cowherd friends used to please Kåñëa by sitting together with Him on coaches or on swings, by lying together on their beds, by joking together and by swimming in the pool. All these activities are called anubhäva. Whenever all the friends would assemble in the company of Kåñëa, they would immediately engage in all these functions, especially in dancing together. Regarding their wrestling, one friend once asked Kåñëa, "My dear friend, O killer of the Agha demon, You are very proudly wandering among Your friends trying to exhibit Your arms as very strong. Is it that You are envious of me? I know that You cannot defeat me in wrestling, and I also know that You were sitting idly for a long time because You were hopeless of defeating me."

All the friends were very daring and would risk any difficulty, because they were confident that Kåñëa would help them to be victorious in all adventures. They used to sit together and advise one another what to do, sometimes inducing one another to be engaged in welfare work. Sometimes they would offer betel nuts to one another, decorate one another's faces with tilaka or smear pulp of candana on one another's bodies. Sometimes, for the sake of amusement, they used to decorate their faces in strange ways. Another business of the friends was that each of them wanted to defeat Kåñëa. Sometimes they used to snatch His clothing or snatch away the flowers from His hands. Sometimes one would try to induce another to decorate his body for him, and failing this, they were always ready to fight, challenging one another to combat in wrestling. These were some of the general activities of Kåñëa and His friends.

Another important pastime of the friends of Kåñëa was that they served as messengers to and from the gopés; they introduced the gopés to Kåñëa and canvassed for Kåñëa. When the gopés were in disagreement with Kåñëa, these friends would support Kåñëa's side in His presence—but when Kåñëa was not present, they would support the side of the gopés. In this way, sometimes supporting one side, sometimes the other, they would talk very privately, with much whispering in the ears, although none of the business was very serious.

The servants of Kåñëa were sometimes engaged in collecting flowers, decorating His body with valuable ornaments and trinkets, dancing before Him, singing, helping Him herd the cows, massaging His body, preparing flower garlands and sometimes fanning His body. These were some of the primary duties of the servants of Kåñëa. The friends and servants of Kåñëa were combined together in serving Him, and all of their activities are known as anubhäva.

When Kåñëa came out from the Yamunä after chastising the Käliyanäga, Çrédämä wanted to embrace Him first, but he could not raise his arms because of his great feeling of respect.

When Kåñëa used to play on His flute, it appeared just like the roaring of clouds in the sky during the constellation of Sväti. According to Vedic astronomical calculation, if there is rain during the constellation of the Sväti star, any rain falling on the sea will produce pearls, and rain falling on a serpent will produce jewels. Similarly, when Kåñëa's flute roared like a thundercloud under the Sväti constellation, the resulting perspiration on Çrédämä's body appeared to be just like pearls.

When Kåñëa and Subala were embracing one another, Çrématé Rädhäräëé became a little envious, and hiding Her hot temperament She said, "My dear Subala, you are very fortunate, because even in the presence of superiors you and Kåñëa have no hesitation in putting your arms on each other's shoulders. I think it must be admitted that in your previous lives you have succeeded in many kinds of austerities." The idea is that although Rädhäräëé was accustomed to put Her arms on Kåñëa's shoulders, it was not possible for Her to do such a thing in the presence of Her superiors, whereas Subala could do so freely. Rädhäräëé therefore praised his good fortune.

When Kåñëa entered the lake of Käliya, His intimate friends became so perturbed that their bodily colors faded, and they all produced horrible gurgling sounds. At that time all of them fell down on the ground as if they were unconscious. Similarly, when there was a forest fire all of Kåñëa's friends neglected their own protection and surrounded Kåñëa on all sides to protect Him from the flames. This behavior of the friends toward Kåñëa is described by thoughtful poets as vyabhicäré. In vyabhicäré ecstatic love for Kåñëa there is sometimes madness, dexterity, fear, laziness, jubilation, pride, dizziness, meditation, disease, forgetfulness and humbleness. These are some of the common symptoms in the stage of vyabhicäré ecstatic love for Kåñëa.

When there are dealings between Kåñëa and His friends which are completely devoid of any feelings of respect, and they all treat one another on an equal level, such ecstatic love in friendship is called sthäyé. When one is situated in this confidential friendly relationship with Kåñëa, one shows symptoms of love such as attraction, affection, affinity and attachment. An example of sthäyé was exhibited when Arjuna* told Akrüra: "My dear son of Gändiné, please ask Kåñëa when I shall be able to embrace Him in my arms."

When there is full knowledge of Kåñëa's superiority and yet in dealings with Him on friendly terms respectfulness is completely absent, that stage is called affection. There is one brilliant example of this affection. When the demigods, headed by Lord Çiva, were offering respectful prayers to Kåñëa, describing the glorious opulences of the Lord, Arjuna* stood before Him with his hand on His shoulders and brushed the dust from His peacock feather.

When the Päëòavas were banished by Duryodhana and forced to live incognito in the forest, no one could trace out where they were staying. At that time, the great sage Närada met Lord Kåñëa and said, "My dear Mukunda, although You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the all-powerful person, by making friendship with You the Päëòavas have become bereft of their legitimate right to the kingdom of the world—and, moreover, they are now living in the forest incognito. Sometimes they must work as ordinary laborers in someone else's house. These symptoms appear to be very inauspicious materially, but the beauty is that the Päëòavas have not lost their faith and love for You, in spite of all these tribulations. In fact, they are always thinking of You and chanting Your name in ecstatic friendship."

Another example of acute affection for Kåñëa is given in the 10th Canto, 15th Chapter, 15th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. In the pasturing ground Kåñëa felt a little tired and wanted to take rest, so He laid down on the ground. At that time, many cowherd boys assembled there and with great affection began to sing suitable songs so that Kåñëa would rest very nicely.

There is a nice example of the friendship between Kåñëa and Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. When the fighting was going on, Açvatthämä, the son of Droëäcärya, unceremoniously attacked Kåñëa, although according to the prevailing rules of chivalry one's chariot driver should never be attacked by the enemy. But Açvatthämä behaved heinously in so many ways that he did not hesitate to attack Kåñëa's body, although Kåñëa was acting only as charioteer for Arjuna. When Arjuna saw that Açvatthämä was releasing various kinds of arrows to hurt Kåñëa, he immediately stood in front of Kåñëa to intercept all of them. At that time, although Arjuna was being harmed by those arrows, he felt an ecstatic love for Kåñëa, and the arrows appeared to him like showers of flowers.

There is another instance of ecstatic love for Kåñëa in friendship: Once when a cowherd boy named Våñabha was collecting flowers from the forest to prepare a garland to be offered to Kåñëa, the sun reached its zenith, and although the sunshine was scorching hot, Våñabha felt it as the moonshine. That is the way of rendering transcendental loving service to the Lord: When devotees are put into great difficulties—even like the Päëòavas, as described above—they feel all their miserable conditions as great facilities for serving the Lord.

Another instance of Arjuna's friendship with Kåñëa is described by Närada, who reminded Kåñëa, "When Arjuna was learning the art of shooting arrows, he could not see You for so many days. But when You arrived there, he stopped all His activities and immediately embraced You." This means that even though Arjuna was engaged in learning about the military art, he had not forgotten Kåñëa for a moment, and as soon as there was an opportunity to see Kåñëa, he immediately embraced Him.

One servant of Kåñëa named Patré once addressed Him like this: "My dear Lord, You protected the cowherd boys from the hunger of the Aghäsura demon, and You protected them from the poisonous affects of the Käliya snake. And You also saved them from the fierce forest fire. But I am suffering from Your separation, which is more severe than the hunger of Aghäsura, the poison of Lake Käliya, and the burning of the forest fire. So why should You not protect me from the pangs of separation?" Another friend once told Kåñëa: "My dear enemy of Kaàsa, since You have left us, the heat of separation has become extraordinary. And this heat is felt more severely when we understand that in Bhäëòéravana You are being refreshed by the waves of the cooling river known as Bhänütanayä [Rädhäräëé]." The purport is that when Kåñëa was engaged with Rädhäräëé, the cowherd boys headed by Subala were feeling great separation, and that was unbearable for them.

Another friend addressed Kåñëa thus: "My dear Kåñëa, O killer of Aghäsura, when You left Våndävana to kill King Kaàsa in Mathurä, all the cowherd boys became bereft of their four bhütas [the elements of earth, water, fire and space]. And the fifth bhüta, the air, was flowing very rapidly within their nostrils." When Kåñëa went to Mathurä to kill King Kaàsa, all the cowherd boys became so afflicted by the separation that they almost died. When a person is dead it is said that he has given up the five elements, known as bhütas, as the body again mixes with the five elements from which it was prepared. In this case, although the four elements of earth, water, fire and ether were already gone, the remaining element, air, was still very prominent and was blowing through their nostrils furiously. In other words, after Kåñëa left Våndävana, they were always anxious about what would happen in His fight with King Kaàsa.

Another friend once informed Kåñëa, "When one of Your friends was feeling much separation from You, there were tears covering his lotus eyes, so the black drones of sleep became discouraged from entering his eyes and left that place." When there is a lotus flower, the black drones fly into it to collect honey. The eyes of Kåñëa's friend are compared to the lotus flower, and because they were full of tears the black drones of sleep could not collect honey from his lotus eyes and therefore left the place. In other words, because he was too much afflicted, his eyes were full of tears, and he could not sleep. This is an example of staying up at night because of separation from Kåñëa.

An example of helplessness is described in the following statement: "Due to Kåñëa's departure from Våndävana to Mathurä, Kåñëa's dearest cowherd boys felt as mentally light as possible. They were like fragments of cotton, lighter than the air, and were all floating in the air without any shelter." In other words, the minds of the cowherd boys became almost vacant on account of Kåñëa's separation, and they are compared with fragments of cotton floating in the air without any shelter. An example of impatience was also shown by the cowherd boys when Kåñëa went to Mathurä. Out of the sorrow of separation, all these boys forgot to take care of their cowherding and tried to forget all the melodious songs they used to sing in the pasturing ground. At last they had no desire to live anymore, being separated from Kåñëa.

An example of stillness was described by a friend of Kåñëa, who informed Him in Mathurä that all the cowherd boys had become just like leafless trees on the tops of hills. They appeared almost naked, skinny and frail, and did not carry any fruits or flowers. He informed Kåñëa that all the cowherd boys residing in Våndävana were as still as the trees at the tops of hills. Sometimes they felt diseased from their separation from Kåñëa, and being so greatly disappointed, they were aimlessly wandering on the banks of the Yamunä.

There is also an example of madness caused by separation from Kåñëa. When Kåñëa was absent from Våndävana, all the cowherd boys became bewildered, and having given up all kinds of activities, they appeared to be mad and forgot all their regular business. They were sometimes lying down on the ground, sometimes rolling in the dust, sometimes laughing and sometimes running very swiftly. All of these symptoms gave them the appearance of madmen. One friend of Kåñëa's criticized Him by saying, "My dear Lord, You have become the King of Mathurä after killing Kaàsa, and that is very good news for us. But at Våndävana all the residents have become blind from their continuous crying over Your absence. They are full only of anxieties and are not cheered at all by Your becoming the King of Mathurä."

Sometimes there were also signs of death caused by separation from Kåñëa. Once Kåñëa was told: "My dear enemy of Kaàsa, because of their separation from You, the cowherd boys are suffering too much, and they are now lying down in the valleys, breathing only slightly. In order to sympathize with the boys' regrettable condition, even the forest friends, the deer, are shedding tears."

In the Mathurä-khaëòa chapter of the Skanda Puräëa, there is a description of Kåñëa and Balaräma, surrounded by all the cowherd boys, always engaged in taking care of the cows and calves. When Kåñëa was met by Arjuna at a potter's shop in the city of Drupadanagara, because of the similarity of their bodily features they made intimate friendship. This is an instance of friendship caused by the attraction of similar bodies.

In the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 71st Chapter, 25th verse, it is stated that when Kåñëa arrived in the city of Indraprastha, Bhéma was so overwhelmed with joy that, with tears in his eyes and a smiling face, he immediately embraced his maternal cousin. Following him were his young brothers Nakula and Sahadeva, along with Arjuna, and they all became so overwhelmed at seeing Kåñëa that with full satisfaction they embraced the Lord, who is known as Acyuta (the infallible). There is a similar statement about the cowherd boys of Våndävana. When Kåñëa was on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, all the cowherd boys came to see Him, wearing jeweled earrings in their ears. Becoming so greatly overjoyed, they extended their arms and embraced Kåñëa as their old friend. These are instances of full satisfaction in friendship with Kåñëa.

In the Tenth Canto, 12th Chapter, 11th verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that even after undergoing severe penances and austerities and performing the yogic principles, the great mystic yogés can hardly become eligible to achieve the dust of the lotus feet of Kåñëa, but the same Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is easily available to the vision of the residents of Våndävana. This means there is no comparison to these devotees' great fortune. The friendly relationship of the cowherd boys with Kåñëa is a particular type of spiritual ecstasy almost similar to the ecstasy of conjugal love. It is very difficult to explain this ecstasy of loving affairs between the cowherd boys and Kåñëa. Great expert devotees like Rüpa Gosvämé and others express their astonishment at the inconceivable feelings which are in Kåñëa and His cowherd boy friends.

This particular type of ecstatic love shared between Kåñëa and His confidential friends further develops into parental love, and on from there it may develop into conjugal love, the most exalted humor or mellow of ecstatic love between Lord Kåñëa and His devotees.

NoD 43-1970: Parenthood

Chapter Forty-three

Parenthood

When ecstatic love develops into the relationship of parenthood and becomes steadily established, the relationship is called vätsalya-rasa. The exhibition of this vätsalya-rasa standard of devotional service can be found in the dealings of Kåñëa with His devotees who represent themselves as superior personalities like father, mother, teacher, etc.

Learned scholars have described the impetus of parental love for Kåñëa, existing in the elderly personalities who are in relation with Him, as follows: "The Supreme Personality of Godhead, whose bodily complexion is just like a bluish, new-grown lotus flower, whose body is very delicate and whose lotus eyes are surrounded by scattered hair as black as bees, was walking on the streets of Våndävana when Mother Yaçodä, the beloved wife of Nanda Mahäräj, saw Him. Immediately the milk began to flow from her breasts, soaking her body." Some specific provocations for parental love of Kåñëa are listed as His blackish bodily hue, which is very attractive and pleasing to see, His all-auspicious bodily features, His mildness, His sweet words, His simplicity, His shyness, His humility, His constant readiness to offer respect to the elderly, and His charity. All of these qualities are considered ecstatic provocations for parental love.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 8th Chapter, 35th verse, it is stated by Çukadeva Gosvämé that Mother Yaçodä accepted Lord Kåñëa as her son, although He is accepted in the Vedas as the King of heaven, in the Upaniñads as the impersonal Brahman and in philosophy as the supreme male. By the yogés He is accepted as the supersoul and by the devotees as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Once Mother Yaçodä addressed one of her friends in this way: "Nanda Mahäräj, the leader of the cowherdsmen, worshiped Lord Viñëu along with me, and as a result of this worshiping Kåñëa has been saved from the clutches of Pütanä and other demons. The twin arjuna trees were, of course, broken due to a strong wind, and although Kåñëa appeared to have lifted Govardhan Hill along with Balaräma, I think that Nanda Mahäräj actually held the mountain. Otherwise how could it have been possible for a little boy to lift such a great hill?" This is another example of ecstasy in parental love. This kind of parental love is generated in a devotee out of his conviction, in love, that he himself is superior to Kåñëa and that without being taken care of by such devotee Kåñëa could not possibly live. One devotee therefore prayed to the parents of Lord Kåñëa as follows: "Let me take shelter of the elderly parental devotees of Lord Kåñëa. They are always anxious to serve Kåñëa and to maintain Him, and they are always so kind to Him. Let us offer our respectful obeisances unto them for being so kind to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is the parent of the whole universe!"

There is a similar prayer by a brähmaëa who says, "Let others worship the Vedas and the Upaniñads, and let others worship the Mahäbhärata if they are afraid of material existence and want to become liberated from that condition. But as far as I am concerned, I wish only to worship Mahäräj Nanda because the supreme absolute Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is crawling in his courtyard as his own child."

Following is a list of respectful personalities who enjoy parental affection toward Kåñëa: 1) Mother Yaçodä, the Queen of Braja, 2) Mahäräj Nanda, the King of Braja, 3) Mother Rohiëé, the mother of Balaräma, 4) all the elderly gopés whose sons were taken away by Lord Brahmä, 5) Devaké, the wife of Vasudeva, 6) the other fifteen wives of Vasudeva, 7) Kunté, the mother of Arjuna, 8) Vasudeva, the real father of Kåñëa, and 9) Sändépani Muni, Kåñëa's teacher. All these are considered respectable elderly personalities with parental love for Kåñëa. This list is in order of superior importance, and thus we can see that Mother Yaçodä and Mahäräj Nanda are considered to be the supermost of all elderly personalities.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 9th Chapter, 2nd verse, Çukadeva Gosvämé gives Mahäräj Parékñit a description of the form and beauty of Mother Yaçodä. He says, "My dear King, the wide hips of Mother Yaçodä were surrounded by silk and linen clothes, and her breasts were flowing with milk because of her affection. When she was churning butter and tightly holding the rope, the bangles on her hands and the earrings on her ears were moving, and from the nice decoration in her hair the flowers were slackening and falling down. Due to her excessive labor, there were drops of perspiration on her face."

There is another description of Mother Yaçodä in a devotee's prayer: "Let me be given protection by Mother Yaçodä, whose curly hairs are bound with thread, whose hair is very brightly beautified by the vermilion placed in the part, and whose bodily frame derides all her ornaments. Her eyes are always engaged in seeing the face of Kåñëa, and thus they are always filled with tears. She has a complexion like the bluish lotus flower, which is enhanced in beauty by her dressing herself with many colorful garments. Let her merciful glance fall on all of us so that we may be protected from the clutches of mäyä and smoothly progress in our devotional service!"

There is the following description of Mother Yaçodä's affection for Kåñëa: After rising early in the morning, Mother Yaçodä first of all offered her breast milk to Kåñëa, and then she began to chant various mantras for His protection. Then she would decorate His forehead very nicely and bind His arms with protective talismans. By all of these activities, it is definitely understood that she is the emblem of all maternal affection for Kåñëa.

The description of Nanda Mahäräj's bodily features is as follows. The hairs on his head are generally black, but some of them are grey. His garments are of greenish color, like the new-grown leaves of a banyan tree. His belly is fatty, his complexion is exactly like the full moon, and he has a beautiful moustache. When Kåñëa was a baby, one day He was walking in the courtyard, capturing the finger of His father, and because He could not walk steadily He appeared to be almost falling down. While Nanda Mahäräj was giving protection to His transcendental son in this way, all of a sudden there were drops of tears in his eyes, and he became overwhelmed with joy. Let us all offer our respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of King Nanda!

Childhood age, childish dress, movements by the child, sweet words spoken by the child, nice smiling and various forms of childish play are considered provocations for increasing the parental love for Kåñëa. The childhood ages of Kåñëa are divided into three periods: the beginning of kaumära age, the middle of kaumära age, and the end of kaumära age. During the beginning and middle of the kaumära age, Kåñëa's thighs are fatty, and the inner part of His eyes are whitish. There are signs of teeth coming out, and He is very mild and gentle. He is described as follows: "When Kåñëa had only three or four teeth coming out of His gums, His thighs were fatty, His body was very, very short, and He began to enhance the parental love of Nanda Mahäräj and Mother Yaçodä with the activities of His childish body. He was sometimes stepping with His legs again and again, sometimes crying, sometimes smiling, sometimes sucking His thumb and sometimes lying down flat. These are some of the different activities of the child Kåñëa. When Kåñëa was lying down flat, sometimes sucking the toes of His feet, sometimes throwing His legs upwards, sometimes crying and sometimes smiling, Mother Yaçodä, seeing her son in such pastimes, did not show any sign of restricting Him, but rather began to watch her child with eagerness, enjoying these childhood pastimes." In the beginning of Kåñëa's kaumära age, there were the nails of tigers set in a golden necklace about His neck. There was protective tilaka on His forehead, black mascara around His eyes and silk thread around His waist. These are the descriptions of Kåñëa's dress at the beginning of the kaumära age.

When Nanda Mahäräj saw the beauty of child Kåñëa with tiger nails on His chest, a complexion like the new-grown tämala tree, beautifully decorated tilaka made with cow's urine, arm decorations of nice silk thread and silk clothes tied around His waist—when Nanda Mahäräj saw his child like this, he never became satiated by the child's beauty.

In the middle kaumära age, the upper portion of Kåñëa's hair falls around His eyes. Sometimes He is covered with cloth around the lower part of His body, and sometimes He is completely naked. Sometimes He tries to walk, taking step by step, and sometimes He talks very sweetly, in broken language. These were some of the symptoms of His middle kaumära age. He is thus described when Mother Yaçodä once saw Him in His middle kaumära age: His scattered hairs were touching His eyebrows, and His eyes were restless, but He could not express His feelings with proper words; still, when He was talking, it was so nice and sweet to hear. When Mother Yaçodä looked at His little ears and saw Him naked, trying to run very quickly with His little legs, she was merged into the ocean of nectar. Kåñëa's ornaments at this age are a pearl hanging from the septum of His nose, butter on His lotus-like palms and some small bells hanging from His waist. It is stated that when Mother Yaçodä saw that the child was moving, ringing the bells on His waist, smiling at her with a pearl between His nostrils and with butter on His hands, she became wonderfully pleased to see her little child in that fashion.

While Kåñëa was in the middle of His kaumära age, His waist became thinner, His chest became broader, and His head was decorated with His curly hairs, resembling the falling of the wings of a crow. These wonderful features of Kåñëa's body never failed to astonish Mother Yaçodä. At the end of His kaumära age, Kåñëa carried a small stick in His hand, His clothing was a little longer, and He had a knot around His waist, resembling the hood of a snake. In that dress He used to take care of the calves near the house, and sometimes He played with cowherd boys of about the same age. He had a slender flute and a buffalo horn bugle, and sometimes He played on a flute made from the leaves of trees. These are some of the symptoms of the end of Kåñëa's kaumära age.

When Kåñëa was a little grown up and was taking care of the small calves, He would often go near the forest. And when He was a little bit late returning home, Nanda Mahäräj would immediately get up on the candraçälikä (a small shed built on the roof for getting a bird's eye view all around), and he would watch for Him. Worrying about the late arrival of his little son, Nanda Mahäräj would remain on the candraçälikä until he could indicate to his wife that Kåñëa, surrounded by His little cowherd friends, was coming back with the calves. Nanda Mahäräj would point out the peacock feather on his child's head and would inform his beloved wife how the child was pleasing his eyes.

Mother Yaçodä then addressed Nanda Mahäräj, "See my dear son, whose eyes are white, who has a turban on His head, a wrapper on His body and leg bells which tinkle very sweetly on His feet. He is coming near, along with His surabhi calves, and just see how He is wandering upon the sacred land of Våndävana!"

Similarly, Mahäräj Nanda addressed his wife, "My dear Yaçodä, just look at your offspring, Kåñëa! See His blackish bodily luster, His eyes tinged with red color, His broad chest and His nice golden necklace! How wonderful He looks, and how He is increasing my transcendental bliss more and more!"

When Kåñëa, the beloved son of Nanda Mahäräj, steps into His kaiçora age, although He becomes more beautiful, His parents still consider Him as being in the paugaëòa age—even though He is between the ages of ten and fifteen. When Kåñëa is in His paugaëòa age, some of His servants also accept Him as being in the kaiçora age. When Kåñëa performs His childish pastimes, His general practice is to break the milk and yogurt pots, throw the yogurt in the courtyard and steal the cream from the milk. Sometimes He breaks the churning rod, and sometimes He throws butter on the fire. In this way, he increases the transcendental pleasure of His Mother Yaçodä.

In this connection Mother Yaçodä once told Mukharä, her maidservant, "Just look at Kåñëa looking stealthily toward all sides and slowly stepping forward from the bushes. It appears that He is coming just to steal the butter. Don't expose yourself or He may understand that we are looking towards Him. I want to enjoy the sight of His eyebrows moving in this cunning way, and I want to see His fearful eyes and beautiful face."

In enjoying Kåñëa's attitude of stealing butter very stealthily, Mother Yaçodä experienced the ecstasy of maternal love by smelling His head, sometimes patting His body with her hand, sometimes offering blessings, sometimes ordering Him, sometimes gazing at Him, sometimes maintaining and sometimes giving Him good instructions not to become a thief. Such activities are in maternal ecstatic love. An important point to be observed in this connection is that the childish propensity of stealing is there even in the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and therefore this propensity is not artificial. However, in the spiritual relationship there is no inebriety to this stealing propensity, as there is in the material world.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 13th Chapter, verse 39, Çukadeva Gosvämé tells King Parékñit: "My dear King, as soon as the elderly gopés saw their sons coming, there was an inexpressible sign of parental love, and all of them became absorbed in affection. At first they were planning to chastise their sons for stealing butter, but as soon as the sons came before their eyes, they lost all of their angry attitudes and became overwhelmed with affection. They began to embrace their sons and smell their heads. While doing this, they became almost mad after their children." In their childhood pastimes, all these cowherd boys joined with Kåñëa in stealing butter. But rather than become angry, Mother Yaçodä became wet from the milk flowing out of her breasts. Out of her affection for Kåñëa, she began to smell His head repeatedly.

The general activities of all the mothers of the cowherd boys were to kiss them, to embrace them, to call them by their names and sometimes to mildly chastise them for their stealing habits. These manifestations of parental love are called sättvika ecstasy, wherein manifestations of eight kinds of ecstatic symptoms are visible in full. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 13th Chapter, 19th verse, Çukadeva Gosvämé tells King Parékñit: "All the mothers of the cowherd boys were illusioned by the covering influence of the yoga-mäyä potency of the Personality of Godhead, and as soon as they heard the flute-playing of their boys, they immediately stood up and mentally embraced their sons, who had been created by the direct internal potency of Kåñëa. Accepting them as their born sons, they lifted them into their arms and began to embrace them, resting the children's bodies upon their own. The emotions created by this incident were sweeter than nectar turned into a palatable intoxicant, and the milk flowing out of their breasts was immediately drunk up by the children."

In the Lalita-mädhava, compiled by Rüpa Gosvämé, Kåñëa is addressed as follows: "My dear Kåñëa, when You are engaged in herding the animals, the dust caused by the hooves of the calves and cows covers Your nice face and artistic tilaka, and You appear very dusty. But when You return home, the milk flowing out of the breasts of Your mother washes Your face of its dust covering, and it appears that You are purified by this milk. It is just like when the Deity is washed during the performance of the abhiñeka ceremony." It is the custom in the temples of Deities that if there have been some impure activities, the Deity has to be washed with milk. Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and He was washed by the milk from the breast of Mother Yaçodä, which purified Him from the dust covering.

Sometimes there are examples of Mother Yaçodä's becoming stunned in ecstasy. This was exhibited when she saw her son lifting Govardhan Hill. When Kåñëa was standing, raising the hill, Mother Yaçodä hesitated to embrace Him and became stunned. The dangerous position that Kåñëa had accepted by lifting the hill brought tears to her eyes. And with her eyes filled with tears she could not see Kåñëa anymore, and because her throat was choked up by anxiety she could not even instruct Kåñëa as to what He should do in that position. This is a symptom of becoming stunned in ecstatic love.

Mother Yaçodä sometimes enjoyed transcendental ecstasy in happiness when her child was saved from a dangerous situation, such as being attacked by Pütanä or some other demon. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 10th Canto, 17th Chapter, 15th verse Çukadeva Gosvämé says that Mother Yaçodä felt very, very fortunate when she got back her lost child. She immediately placed Him on her lap and began to embrace Him again and again. While she was thus embracing her son repeatedly, torrents of tears fell from her eyes, and she was unable to express her transcendental joy. It is stated in the Vidagdha-mädhava of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé: "My dear Kåñëa, the touch of Your mother is so pleasing and cooling that it surpasses the cooling capacity of the pulp of sandalwood and of bright moonshine mixed with the pulp of uçéra root." (Uçéra is a kind of root which when soaked with water has a very, very cooling effect. It is especially used in the scorching heat of the sun.)

The parental love of Mother Yaçodä for Kåñëa steadily increases, and her love and ecstasy are sometimes described as intense affection and sometimes as overwhelming attachment. An example of attachment for Kåñëa with overwhelming affection is given in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 6th Chapter, 27th verse, where Çukadeva Gosvämé addresses Mahäräj Parékñit in this way: "My dear King, when magnanimous Nanda Mahäräj returned from a tour, he began to smell the head of his son, and he was merged in the ecstasy of parental love." A similar statement is there in connection with Mother Yaçodä when she was too anxious to hear the sound of Kåñëa's flute, expecting Him back from the pasturing ground. Because she thought that it was getting very late, her anxiety to hear the sound of Kåñëa's flute became doubled, and milk began to flow out from her breast. In that condition she was sometimes going within the house, sometimes coming out of the house. She was constantly looking to see if Govinda was coming back along the road. When many very great sages were offering prayers to Lord Kåñëa, glorifying His activities, the Queen of Gokula, Mother Yaçodä, entered the battlefield of Kurukñetra, wetting the lower part of her sari with the milk flowing from her breast. This entrance of Mother Yaçodä at Kurukñetra was not during the Battle of Kurukñetra. At other times Kåñëa went to Kurukñetra from His paternal home (Dvärakä) during the solar eclipse, and at these times the residents of Våndävana also went to see Him there.

When Kåñëa arrived at Kurukñetra in pilgrimage, all the people assembled there began to say that Kåñëa the son of Devaké had arrived. At that time Devaké, just like an affectionate mother, began to pat Kåñëa's face. And again when people cried that Kåñëa, the son of Vasudeva, had come, both King Nanda and Mother Yaçodä became overwhelmed with affection and expressed their great pleasure.

When Mother Yaçodä, the Queen of Gokula, was going to see her son Kåñëa at Kurukñetra, one of her friends began to address her thus: "My dear Queen, the milk flowing out of your breast-mountain has already whitened the River Ganges, and the tears from your eyes, mixed with black mascara, have already blackened the color of the Yamunä. And as you are standing just between the two rivers, I think there is no need for your anxiety to see your son's face. Your parental affection has already been exhibited to Him by these two rivers!"

The same friend of Mother Yaçodä addressed Kåñëa as follows: "My dear Mukunda, if Mother Yaçodä, the Queen of Gokula, is forced to stand on fire, but is allowed to see Your lotus face, then this fire will appear to her as the Himalayan Mountains: full of ice. In the same way, if she is allowed to stay in the ocean of nectar, but is not allowed to see the lotus face of Your Grace, then even this ocean of nectar will appear to her as an ocean of arsenic poison." Let the anxiety of Mother Yaçodä of Braja, always expecting to see the lotus face of Kåñëa, be glorified all over the universe!

A similar statement was given by Kuntédevé to Akrüra: "My dear brother Akrüra, my nephew Mukunda is long absent from us. Will you kindly tell Him that His Aunt Kunté is sitting amongst the enemy and would like to know when she will be able to see His lotus face again?"

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 46th Chapter, 2nd verse, there is this statement: "When Uddhava was present at Våndävana and was narrating the activities of Kåñëa in Dvärakä, Mother Yaçodä, while hearing this narration, began to pour milk from her breasts and shed tears from her eyes." Another incident demonstrating Yaçodä's extreme love for Kåñëa occurred when Kåñëa went to Mathurä, the kingdom of Kaàsa. In separation from Kåñëa, Mother Yaçodä was looking at Kåñëa's makeup utensils, and she fell down on the ground almost unconscious, with a great sound. When she was rolling over on the ground, there were many scratches on her body, and in that piteous condition she began to cry, "O my dear son! My dear son!" And she slapped her breasts with her two hands. This activity of Mother Yaçodä is explained by expert devotees as ecstatic love in separation. Sometimes there are many other symptoms, such as great anxiety, lamentation, frustration, being stunned, humility, restlessness, madness and illusion.

As far as Mother Yaçodä's anxieties are concerned, when Kåñëa was out of the house in the pasturing ground, a devotee once told her, "Yaçodä, I think your movements have been slackened, and I see that you are full of anxieties. Your two eyes appear to be without any movement, and I feel in your breathing a kind of warmth which is bringing your breast milk to the boiling point. All these conditions prove that out of separation from your son you have a severe headache." These are some of the symptoms of Mother Yaçodä's anxiety for Kåñëa.

When Akrüra was present in Våndävana and was narrating the activities of Kåñëa in Dvärakä, Mother Yaçodä was informed that Kåñëa had married so many queens and was very busy there in His householder affairs. Hearing this, Mother Yaçodä lamented how unfortunate she was that she could not get her son married just after passing His kaiçora age, and thus she could not receive both her son and daughter-in-law at her home. She exclaimed, "My dear Akrüra, you are simply throwing thunderbolts on my head!" These are the signs of lamentation on the part of Mother Yaçodä in separation from Kåñëa.

Similarly, Mother Yaçodä felt frustration when she thought, "Although I have millions of cows, the milk of these cows could not satisfy Kåñëa. Therefore let a curse be on this milk! And I also am condemned because although I am so opulent in material prosperity, I am now unable to smell the head of my child and feed Him with my breast milk as I used to do when He was here in Våndävana." This is a sign of frustration on the part of Mother Yaçodä in separation from Kåñëa.

One friend of Kåñëa's addressed Him thus: "My dear lotus-eyed one, when You were living in Gokula You were always bearing a stick in Your hand. That stick is now lying idle in the house of Mother Yaçodä, and whenever she sees it she becomes motionless just like the stick." This is the sign of becoming stunned in separation from Kåñëa. In separation from Kåñëa Mother Yaçodä became so humble that she prayed to the creator of the universe, Lord Brahmä, with tears in her eyes: "My dear creator, won't you kindly bring my dear son Kåñëa back to me so that I can see Him at least for a moment?" Sometimes in restlessness like a madwoman Mother Yaçodä used to accuse Nanda Mahäräj, "What are you doing in the palace? You shameless man! Why do people call you the King of Braja? It is very astonishing that while being separated from your dear son Kåñëa, you are still living within Våndävana as a hard-hearted father!"

Someone informed Kåñëa about the madness of Mother Yaçodä in the following words: "In madness Mother Yaçodä has addressed the kadamba trees and inquired from them, 'Where is my son?' Similarly, she has addressed the birds and the drones and inquired from them as to whether Kåñëa has passed before them, and she has inquired if they can say anything about You. In this way, Mother Yaçodä in illusion was asking everybody about You, and she has been wandering all over Våndävana." This is madness in separation from Kåñëa.

When Nanda Mahäräj was accused by Mother Yaçodä of being "hard-hearted," he replied, "My dear Yaçodä, why are you becoming so agitated? Kindly look more carefully. Just see, your son Kåñëa is standing before you! Don't become a madwoman like this. Please keep my home peaceful." And Kåñëa was informed by some friend that His father Nanda was also in illusion in this way, in separation from Him.

When all the wives of Vasudeva were present in the arena of Kaàsa, they saw the most pleasing bodily features of Kåñëa, and immediately, out of parental affection, milk began to flow from their breasts, and the lower parts of their saris became wet. This symptom of ecstatic love is an example of the result of fulfillment of desire.

In the First Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 11th Chapter, 25th verse, it is stated, "When Kåñëa entered Dvärakä after finishing the Battle of Kurukñetra, He first of all saw His mother and all His different stepmothers and offered His respectful obeisances unto their feet. The mothers immediately took Kåñëa upon their laps, and because of their parental affection, there was milk flowing out of their breasts. So their breast milk, mixed with the water of tears, became the first offering to Kåñëa. This is one of the examples of being satisfied after a great separation.

There is a similar statement in the Lalita-mädhava: "How wonderful it is that Yaçodä, the wife of King Nanda, out of her parental affection for Kåñëa, mixed her tears and the milk from her breasts and thus bathed her dear son Kåñëa." In Vidagdha-mädhava, a devotee addresses Lord Kåñëa as follows: "My dear Mukunda, just after seeing Your face full with the flavor of the lotus flower, and being attracted by the moonlight of Your face, Mother Yaçodä became so overjoyed in her affection that immediately from the nipples of her waterpot-like breasts, milk began to flow." She was thus constantly engaged in supplying milk to Kåñëa after wetting the covering cloth over the jug.

These are some of the signs of parental love for Kåñëa by His mother, father and elderly persons. Symptoms of ecstatic love in parental affection are expressed when Kåñëa is accepted as the son. These constant transcendental emotions for Kåñëa are called steady ecstasy in parental love.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé states herein that according to some learned scholars, the three kinds of transcendental mellow so far described—namely, servitude, fraternity and parental affection—are sometimes mixed up. For example, the fraternal feelings of Balaräma are mixed with servitude and parental affection. Similarly, King Yudhiñöhira's attraction for Kåñëa is also mixed with parental affection and servitude. Similarly, the transcendental mellow of Ugrasena, Kåñëa's grandfather, is mixed with servitude and parental affection. The affection of all the elderly gopés in Våndävana is a mixture of parental love, servitude and fraternity. The affection of the sons of Mädré, Nakula and Sahadeva, as well as the affection of sage Närada, is a mixture of friendship and servitude. The affection of Lord Çiva, Garuòa and Uddhava is a mixture of servitude and fraternity.

NoD 44-1970: Devotional Service in Conjugal Love

Chapter Forty-four

Devotional Service in Conjugal Love

A pure devotee's attraction to Kåñëa in conjugal love is called devotional service in conjugal love. Although such conjugal feelings are not at all material, there is some similarity between this spiritual love and material activities. Therefore, persons who are interested only in material activities are unable to understand this spiritual conjugal love, and these devotional reciprocations appear very mysterious to them. Rüpa Gosvämé therefore describes conjugal love very briefly.

The impetuses of conjugal love are Kåñëa and His very dear consorts, such as Rädhäräëé and Her immediate associates. Lord Kåñëa has no rival: no one is equal to Him, and no one is greater than Him. His beauty is also without any rival, and because He excels all others in the pastimes of conjugal love, He is the original object of all conjugal love.

In the Géta-govinda by Jayadeva Gosvämé one gopé tells her friend: "Kåñëa is the reservoir of all pleasure within this universe. His body is as soft as the lotus flower. And His free behavior with the gopés, which appears exactly like a young boy's attraction to a young girl, is a subject matter of transcendental conjugal love." A pure devotee follows in the footsteps of the gopés and worships the gopés as follows: "Let me offer my respectful obeisances to all the young cowherd girls, whose bodily features are so attractive. Simply by their beautiful attractive features they are worshiping the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa." Out of all the young gopés, Çrématé Rädhäräëé is the most prominent.

The beauty of Çrématé Rädhäräëé is described as follows: "Her eyes defeat the attractive features of the eyes of the cakoré bird. When one sees the face of Rädhäräëé, he immediately hates the beauty of the moon. Her bodily complexion defeats the beauty of gold. Thus, let us all look upon the transcendental beauty of Çrématé Rädhäräëé." Kåñëa's attraction for Rädhäräëé is described by Kåñëa Himself thus: "When I create some joking phrases in order to enjoy the beauty of Rädhäräëé, Rädhäräëé hears these joking words with great attention; but by Her bodily features and counter words She neglects Me. And I even possess unlimited pleasure by Her neglect of Me, for She becomes so beautiful that She increases My pleasure one hundred times." A similar statement can be found in Géta-govinda, wherein it is said that when the enemy of Kaàsa, Çré Kåñëa, embraces Çrématé Rädhäräëé, He immediately becomes entangled in a loving condition and gives up the company of all other gopés.

In the Padyävalé of Rüpa Gosvämé it is stated that when the gopés hear the sound of Kåñëa's flute, they immediately forget all rebukes offered by the elderly members of their families, their defamation and the harsh behavior of their husbands. Their only thought is to go out in search of Kåñëa. When the gopés meet Kåñëa, the display of their exchanging glances as well as their joking and laughing behavior is called anubhäva, or sub-ecstasy in conjugal love.

In the Lalita-mädhava, Rüpa Gosvämé explains that the movements of Kåñëa's eyebrows are just like the Yamunä, and the smiling of Rädhäräëé is just like the moonshine. When the Yamunä and the moonshine come in contact on the bank of the river, the water tastes just like nectar, and drinking it gives great satisfaction. It is as cooling as piles of snow. Similarly, in the Padyävalé, one constant companion of Rädhäräëé says, "My dear moon-faced Rädhäräëé, Your whole body appears to be very content, yet there are signs of tears in Your eyes. Your speech is faltering, and Your chest is also heaving. By all these signs I can understand that You must have heard the blowing of Kåñëa's flute, and, as a result of this, Your heart is now melting."

In the same Padyävalé there is the following description, which is taken as a sign of frustration in conjugal love. Çrématé Rädhäräëé said, "Dear Mr. Cupid, please do not excite Me by throwing your arrows at My body. Dear Mr. Air, please do not arouse Me with the fragrance of flowers. I am now bereft of Kåñëa's loving attitude, so under the circumstances, what is the use of My sustaining this useless body? There is no need for such a body by any living entity." This is a sign of frustration in ecstatic love for Kåñëa.

Similarly, in Däna-keli-kaumudé, Çrématé Rädhäräëé, pointing to Kåñëa, says, "This clever boy of the forest has the beauty of a bluish lotus flower, and He can attract all the young girls of the universe. Now after giving Me a taste of His transcendental body, He has enthused Me, and it is more than I can tolerate. I am now feeling like a female elephant who has been enthused by a male elephant!" This is an instance of jubilation in ecstatic love with Kåñëa.

Steady ecstasy of conjugal love is the original cause of bodily enjoyment. In the Padyävalé this original cause of union is described when Rädhäräëé tells one of Her constant companions: "My dear friend, who is this boy whose eyelids, dancing constantly, have increased the beauty of His face and attracted My desire for conjugal love? His ears are decorated with the buds of açoka flowers, and He has dressed Himself in yellow robes. By the sound of His flute, this boy has already made Me impatient."

The conjugal love of Rädhä-Kåñëa is never disturbed by any personal consideration. The undisturbed nature of the conjugal love between Rädhä and Kåñëa is described thus: "Just a little distance away from Kåñëa was Mother Yaçodä, and Kåñëa was surrounded by all of His friends. In front of His eyes there was Candrävalé, and, at the same time, on a chunk of stone in front of the entrance to Braja, there was standing the demon known as Våñäsura. But even in such circumstances, when Kåñëa saw Rädhäräëé standing just behind a bush of many creepers, immediately His beautiful eyebrows moved just like lightning towards Her."

Another instance is described as follows: "On one side of the courtyard the dead body of Çaìkhäsura was lying, surrounded by many jackals. On another side were many learned brähmaëas who were all self-controlled. They were offering nice prayers, which were as soothing as the cool breeze in summer. In front of Kåñëa, Lord Baladeva was standing, causing a cooling effect. But even amidst all these different circumstances of soothing and disturbing effects, the lotus flower of ecstatic conjugal love that Kåñëa felt for Rädhäräëé could not wither." This love of Kåñëa for Rädhäräëé is often compared to a blooming lotus: the only difference is that Kåñëa's love remains ever-increasingly beautiful.

Conjugal love is divided into two portions: vipralambha, or conjugal love in separation, and sambhoga, or conjugal love in direct contact. Vipralambha, separation, has three sub-divisions known as 1) pürva-räga, or preliminary attraction, 2) mäna, or seeming anger, and 3) praväsa, or separation by distance.

When the lover and the beloved have a distinct feeling of not meeting each other, that stage is called pürva-räga, or preliminary attraction. In Padyävalé Rädhäräëé told Her companion, "My dear friend, I was just going to the bank of the Yamunä, and all of a sudden a very nice boy whose complexion is like a dark blue cloud became visible in front of My eyes. He glanced over Me in a way that I cannot describe. But since this has occured, I am sorry that I can no longer engage My mind in the duties of My household affairs." This is an instance of preliminary attraction for Kåñëa. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 53rd Chapter, verse 2, Kåñëa told the messenger brähmaëa who came from Rukmiëé: "My dear brähmaëa, just like Rukmiëé I cannot sleep at night, and My mind is always fixed on her. I know that her brother Rukmé is against Me, and due to his persuasion, My marriage with her has been cancelled." This is another instance of preliminary attraction.

As far as mäna, or anger, is concerned, there is the following incident described in Géta-govinda: "When Çrématé Rädhäräëé saw Kåñëa enjoying Himself in the company of several other gopés, She became a little jealous because Her special prestige was being dimmed. Therefore, She immediately left the scene and took shelter in a nice flower bush where the black drones were humming. Then, hiding Herself behind the creepers, She began to express Her sorrow to one of Her consorts." This is an instance of a seeming disagreement.

An example of praväsa, or being out of contact because of living in a distant place, is given in the Padyävalé as follows: "Since the auspicious day when Kåñëa left for Mathurä, Çrématé Rädhäräëé has been pressing Her head on one of Her hands and constantly shedding tears. Her face is always wet now, and therefore there is no chance of Her sleeping even for a moment." When the face becomes wet, the sleeping tendency is immediately removed. So when Rädhäräëé was always weeping for Kåñëa because of His separation, there was no chance of Her getting any sleep for Herself. In the Prahläda-saàhitä Uddhava says, "The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Govinda, painstricken due to being pierced by the arrows of Cupid, is always thinking of you [the gopés], and He is not even accepting His regular lunch. Nor is He getting any proper rest."

When the lover and beloved come together and enjoy one another by direct contact, this stage is called sambhoga. There is a statement in Padyävalé as follows: "Kåñëa embraced Çrématé Rädhäräëé in such an expert manner that He appeared to be celebrating the dancing ceremony of the peacocks."

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé thus ends the fifth wave of his Ocean of the Nectar of Devotion. He offers his respectful obeisances to the Supreme Personality of Godhead who appeared as Gopäla, the eternal form of the Lord.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta summary study of the third division of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu in the matter of the five primary relationships with Kåñëa.


PART FOUR


NoD 45-1970: Laughing Ecstasy

Chapter Forty-five

Laughing Ecstasy

In the fourth division of Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has described seven kinds of indirect ecstasies of devotional service—known as laughing, astonishment, chivalry, compassion, anger, dread and ghastliness. In this portion, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé further describes these ecstasies of devotional feelings, some being compatible and others incompatible with one another. When one kind of ecstatic devotional service overlaps with another in a conflicting way, this state of affairs is called rasäbhäsa, or perverted presentation of mellows.

Expert learned scholars say that laughing is generally found amongst youngsters or in the combination of old persons and young children. This ecstatic loving laughing is sometimes also found in persons who are very grave by nature. Once an old mendicant approached the door of Mother Yaçodä's house, and Kåñëa told Yaçodä, "My dear Mother, I don't wish to go near this skinny villain. If I go there, he might put Me within his begging bag and take Me away from You!" In this way, the wonderful child, Kåñëa, began to look at His mother, while the mendicant, who was standing in the door, tried to hide his smiling face, although he could not do so. He immediately expressed his smiling. In this instance, Kåñëa Himself is the object of laughing affairs.

Once one of Kåñëa's friends informed Him, "My dear Kåñëa, if You will open Your mouth, then I shall give You one nice sugar candy mixed with yogurt." Kåñëa immediately opened His mouth, but instead of giving Him sugar candy with yogurt, the friend dropped a flower in His mouth. After tasting this flower, Kåñëa turned His mouth in a disfigured way, and upon seeing this all His friends standing there began to laugh very loudly.

Once a palmist came to the house of Nanda Mahäräj, and Nanda Mahäräj asked him, "My dear sage, will you kindly check the hand of my child, Kåñëa? Tell me how many years He will live and whether He will become the master of thousands of cows." Upon hearing this, the palmist began to smile, and Nanda Mahäräj asked him, "My dear sir, why are you laughing, and why are you covering your face?"

In such a laughing ecstasy of love, Kåñëa or matters pertaining to Kåñëa are the cause of the laughter. In such laughing devotional service, there are symptoms of jubilation, laziness, concealed feelings and similar other seemingly disturbing elements.

According to Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé's calculation, laughter in ecstatic love can be broken down into six divisions. These divisions, according to different degrees of smiling, are called in the Sanskrit language smita, hasita, vihasita, avahasita, apahasita, and atihasita. These six classes of smiling can be classified as major and minor. The major division includes smita, hasita and vihasita smiling, and the minor division includes avahasita, apahasita and atihasita smiling.

When one is smiling but his teeth are not visible, one can distinctly mark a definite change in the eyes and in the cheeks. This is called smita smiling. Once when Kåñëa was stealing yogurt, Jaraté, the headmistress of the house, could detect His activities, and she was therefore coming very hurriedly to catch Him. At that time, Kåñëa became very much afraid of Jaraté and went to His elder brother Baladeva. He said, "My dear brother, I have stolen yogurt! Just see—Jaraté is coming hurriedly to catch Me!" When Kåñëa was thus seeking the shelter of Baladeva because He was being chased by Jaraté, all the great sages in the heavenly planets began to smile. This smiling is called smita smiling.

Smiling in which the teeth are slightly visible is called hasita smiling. One day Abhimanyu, the so-called husband of Rädhäräëé, was returning home, and at that time he could not see that Kåñëa was there in his house. Kåñëa immediately changed His dress to look exactly like Abhimanyu and approached Abhimanyu's mother, Jaöilä, addressing her thus: "My dear Mother, I am your real son Abhimanyu, but just see—Kåñëa, dressed up like me, is coming before you!" Jaöilä, the mother of Abhimanyu, immediately believed that Kåñëa was her own son and thus became very angry at her real son who was coming home. She began to drive away her real son, who was crying, "Mother! Mother! What are you doing?" Seeing this incident, all the girl friends of Rädhäräëé, who were present there, began to smile, and a portion of their teeth was visible. This is an instance of hasita smiling.

When the teeth are distinctly visible in a smile, that is called vihasita. One day when Kåñëa was engaged in stealing butter and yogurt in the house of Jaöilä, He assured His friends, "My dear friends, I know that this old lady is now sleeping very profoundly because she is breathing very deeply. Let us silently steal butter and yogurt without making any disturbance." But the old lady, Jaöilä, was not sleeping; so she could not contain her smiling, and her teeth immediately became distinctly visible. This is an instance of vihasita smiling.

In a state of smiling, when the nose becomes puffed and the eyes squint, the smiling is called avahasita. Once, early in the morning when Kåñëa returned home after performing His räsa dance, Mother Yaçodä looked upon Kåñëa's face and addressed Him thus: "My dear son, why do Your eyes look like they have been smeared with some oxides? Have You dressed Yourself with the blue garments of Baladeva?" When Mother Yaçodä was addressing Kåñëa in that way, a girl friend who was nearby began to smile with a puffed nose and squinting eyes. This is an instance of avahasita smiling. The gopé knew that Kåñëa had been enjoying the räsa dance and that Mother Yaçodä could not detect her son's activities nor understand how He had become covered with the gopés' makeup. Her smiling was in the avahasita feature.

When tears from the eyes are added to the smiling, and the shoulders are shaking, the smile is called apahasita. When child Kåñëa was dancing in response to the singing of the old maidservant Jaraté, Närada was astonished. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, who controls all the movements of great demigods like Brahmä and others, was now dancing to the indications of an old maidservant. Seeing this fun, Närada also began to dance, and his shoulders trembled, and his eyes moved. Due to his smiling, his teeth also became visible, and on account of the glaring effulgence from his teeth, the clouds in the skies turned silver.

When a smiling person claps his hands and leaps in the air, the smiling expression changes into atihasita, or overwhelming laughter. An example of atihasita was manifested in the following incident: Kåñëa once addressed Jaraté thus: "My dear good woman, the skin of your face is now slackened, and so your face exactly resembles a monkey's. As such, the King of the monkeys, Balémukha, has selected you as his worthy wife." While Kåñëa was teasing Jaraté in this way, she replied that she was certainly aware of the fact that the King of the monkeys was trying to marry her, but she had already taken shelter of Kåñëa, the killer of many powerful demons, and therefore she had already decided to marry Kåñëa instead of the King of the monkeys. On hearing this sarcastic reply by the talkative Jaraté, all the cowherd girls present there began to laugh very loudly and clap their hands. This laughter, accompanied by the clapping of hands, is called atihasita.

Sometimes there are indirect sarcastic remarks which also create atihasita circumstances. An example of one such remark was made by one of the cowherd girls to Kuöilä, the daughter of Jaöilä and sister of Abhimanyu, the so-called husband of Rädhäräëé. Indirectly Kuöilä was insulted by the following statement: "My dear Kuöilä, daughter of Jaöilä, your breasts are as long as string beans—simply dry and long. Your nose is so gorgeous that it is defying the beauty of the noses of frogs. And your eyes are more beautiful than the eyes of dogs. Your lips are defying the flaming cinders of fire, and your abdomen is as beautiful as a big drum. Therefore, my dear beautiful Kuöilä, you are the most beautiful of all the cowherd girls of Våndävana, and because of your extraordinary beauty, I think you must be beyond the attraction of the sweet blowing of Kåñëa's flute!"

NoD 46-1970: Astonishment and Chivalry

Chapter Forty-six

Astonishment and Chivalry

Astonishment

The ecstasy of astonishment in devotional service is perceived in two ways: directly, by the experience of one's own eyes, and indirectly, by hearing from others.

When Närada came to see the activities of the Lord at Dvärakä, and he saw that Kåñëa was present within every palace in the same body and was engaged in different activities, he was struck with wonder. This is one of the examples of astonishment in devotional service by direct perception. One of the friends of Mother Yaçodä says, "Yaçodä, just see the fun! On the one hand, there is your child who is always captivated by sucking the milk from your breast, and on the other hand there is the great Govardhan Hill which can obstruct the passing of the clouds. But still, just see how wonderful it is that this great Govardhan Hill is resting on the finger of your child's left hand, just as though it were a toy. Is this not very mysterious?" This statement is another example of astonishment in devotional service by direct perception.

An instance of astonishment in devotional service by indirect perception occurred when Mahäräj Parékñit heard from Çukadeva Gosvämé about Kåñëa's killing Narakäsura, who had been fighting Kåñëa with eleven divisions of akñauhiëé soldiers. Each division of akñauhiëé soldiers contained several thousand elephants, several thousand horses and chariots, and several hundreds of thousands of infantry soldiers. Narakäsura possessed eleven such divisions, and all of them were throwing arrows toward Kåñëa, but Kåñëa killed them all, simply by throwing three arrows from His side. When Mahäräj Parékñit heard of this wonderful victory, he immediately rubbed the tears from his eyes and became overwhelmed with joy. This instance is an example of astonishment in devotional service by indirect perception through aural reception.

There is another example of indirect astonishment. Trying to test Kåñëa to see if He were truly the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Brahmä stole all the cowherd boys and cows from Him. But after a few seconds, he saw that Kåñëa was still present with all the cows, calves and cowherd boys, exactly in the same way as before. When Lord Brahmä described this incident to his associates on the Satya-loka planet, they all became astonished. Brahmä told them that after taking away all the boys, he saw Kåñëa again playing with the same boys in the same fashion. Their bodily complexion was blackish, almost like Kåñëa's, and they all had four arms. The same calves and cows were still present there, in the same original fashion. Even while describing this incident, Brahmä became almost overwhelmed. "And the most astonishing thing," he added, "was that many other Brahmäs from many different universes had also come there to worship Kåñëa and His associates."

Similarly, when there was a forest fire in the Bhäëòéravana, Kåñëa instructed His friends to close their eyes tightly, and they all did this. Then when Kåñëa had extinguished the fire, the cowherd boys opened their eyes and saw that they had been relieved from the danger and that their cows and calves were all safe. They began to perceive the wonder of the situation simply by guessing how Kåñëa had saved them. This is another instance of indirect perception causing astonishment in devotional service.

The activities of a person, even if they are not very extraordinary, create an impression of wonder in the heart and mind of the person's friends. But even very wonderful activities performed by a person who is not one's friend will not create any impression. It is because of love that one's wonderful activities create an impression in the mind.

Chivalry

When on account of love and devotional service for the Lord there is special valorous enthusiasm, the resultant activities are called chivalrous. These chivalrous activities can be manifested in the acts of mock-fighting, giving in charity, showing mercy and executing religious principles. By performing chivalrous activities in fighting, one is called yuddha-véra. By charitable activities one is called däna-véra. By showing extraordinary mercy one is called dayä-véra. And when one is munificent in executing religious rites, he is called dharma-véra. In all such different chivalrous activities, Kåñëa is the object.

When a friend wants to satisfy Kåñëa by performing some chivalrous activities, the friend becomes the challenger, and Kåñëa Himself becomes the opponent; or else Kåñëa may give audience to the fighting, and by His desire another friend becomes the opponent. A friend once challenged Kåñëa thus: "My dear Mädhava, You are very restless because You think that no one can defeat You. But if You do not flee from here, then I shall show You how I can defeat You. And my friends will be very satisfied to see this!"

Kåñëa and Çrédämä were very intimate friends, yet Çrédämä, out of anger with Kåñëa, challenged Him. When both of them began to fight, all the friends on the bank of the Yamunä enjoyed the wonderful fighting of the two friends. They prepared some arrows for mock-fighting, and Kåñëa began to throw his arrows at Çrédämä. Çrédämä began to block these arrows by whirling his pole, and by Çrédämä's chivalrous activities, Kåñëa became very satisfied. Such mock-fighting generally takes place amongst chivalrous persons and creates wonderful excitement for all viewers.

There is a statement in the Hari-vaàça that sometimes Arjuna and Kåñëa fought in the presence of Kunté, and Arjuna would be defeated by Kåñëa.

In such chivalrous fighting between friends, there is sometimes bragging, self-complacence, pride, power, taking to weapons, challenging and standing as opponent. All of these symptoms become impetuses to chivalrous devotional service.

One friend challenged Kåñëa thus: "My dear friend Dämodara, You are an expert only in eating. You have defeated Subala only because he is weak and You adopted cheating means. Don't advertise Yourself to be a great fighter by such action. You have advertised Yourself as a serpent, and I am the peacock who will now defeat You." The peacock is the ablest enemy of the serpent.

In such fighting between friends, when the self-advertisement becomes personal, learned scholars say it is sub-ecstasy. When there is a roaring challenge, certain kinds of movement for fighting, enthusiasm, no weapons and assurance given to frightened witnesses—all these chivalrous activities are called sub-ecstasy.

One friend addressed Kåñëa in this manner: "My dear Madhusüdana, You know my strength, yet You are encouraging Bhadrasena, and not me, to challenge mighty Baladeva. By this action You are simply insulting me because my arms are as strong as the bolts of the gate!"

A devotee once said, "My dear Lord Kåñëa, may Your challenger, Çrédämä, become glorious for his chivalrous activities, such as vibrating like a thunder cloud and roaring like a lion. May all glories go to Çrédämä's chivalrous activities!" Chivalrous activities in the matter of fighting, charity, mercy and execution of religious rituals are called constitutional; whereas the expression of pride, emotions, endurance, kindness, determination, jubilation, enthusiasm, jealousy and remembrance are called unconstitutional. When Stokakåñëa, one of the many friends of Kåñëa, was fighting with Him, his father chastised him for fighting with Kåñëa, who was the life and soul of all residents of Våndävana. Upon hearing these chastisements, Stokakåñëa stopped his fighting. But Kåñëa continued to challenge him, and thus, in order to meet the challenge, Stokakåñëa took his pole and began to display his dexterity by whirling it.

Once Çrédämä challenged Bhadrasena and said to him, "My dear friend, you needn't be afraid of me yet. I shall first of all defeat our brother Balaräma, then I shall beat Kåñëa, and then I shall come to you." Bhadrasena therefore left the party of Balaräma and joined Kåñëa, and he agitated his friends as much as the Mandara Hill had agitated the whole ocean. By his roaring sounds he deafened all his friends, and he enthused Kåñëa with his chivalrous activities.

Once Kåñëa challenged all His friends and said, "My dear friends, just see—I am jumping with great chivalrous prowess. Please do not flee away." Upon hearing these challenging words, another friend named Varüthapa counter-challenged the Lord and struggled against Him.

One of the friends once remarked, "Sudämä is trying his best to see Dämodara defeated, and I think that if our powerful Subala joins him, they will be a very beautiful combination, like a valuable jewel bedecked with gold."

In these chivalrous activities, only Kåñëa's friends can be the opponents. Kåñëa's enemies can never actually be His opponents. Therefore, this challenging by Kåñëa's friends is called devotional service in chivalrous activities.

Däna-véra, or chivalry in the giving in charity, can be divided into two parts: munificence and renunciation. A person who can sacrifice everything for the satisfaction of Kåñëa is called munificent. When a person desires to make a sacrifice because of his seeing Kåñëa, Kåñëa is called the impetus of the munificent activity. When Kåñëa appeared as the son of Nanda Mahäräj, in clear consciousness Nanda Mahäräj desired all auspiciousness for his son and thus began to give in charity valuable cows to all the brähmaëas. The brähmaëas were so satisfied by this charitable action that they were obliged to say that the charity of Nanda Mahäräj had excelled the charity of such past kings as Mahäräj Påthu and Någa.

When a person knows the glories of the Lord completely and is prepared to sacrifice everything for the Lord, he is called sampradänaka, or one who gives everything in charity for the sake of Kåñëa.

When Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira went with Kåñëa in the arena of the räja-süya sacrifice, in his imagination he began to anoint the body of Kåñëa with pulp of sandalwood, he decorated Him with a garland hanging down to His knees, he began to give Him garments all embroidered with gold, he gave Him ornaments all bedecked with valuable jewels, and he gave Him many fully decorated elephants, chariots and horses. He further wished to give Kåñëa in charity his kingdom, his family and his personal self also. After so desiring, when there was nothing to actually give in charity, Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira became very perturbed and anxious.

Similarly, Mahäräj Bali once told his priest, Çukräcärya: "My dear sage, you are fully expert in knowledge of the Vedas, and as such you worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu, by Vedic rituals. As far as this brähmaëa dwarf [the incarnation Vämanadeva] is concerned, if He is Lord Viñëu, a simple brähmaëa, or even my enemy, I have decided to give to Him in charity all the land He has asked for." Mahäräj Bali was so fortunate that the Lord extended before Him His hand, which was reddish from touching the breast of the goddess of fortune, who is always smeared with red kuìkum powder. In other words, although the Personality of Godhead is so great that the goddess of fortune is always under His command for enjoyment, He still extended His hands to take charity from Mahäräj Bali.

A person who wants to give everything in charity to Kåñëa but does not want anything in return is considered the real renouncer. Thus, a devotee will refuse to accept any kind of liberation, even if it is offered by the Lord. Real love of Kåñëa becomes manifested when Kåñëa becomes the recipient of charity and the devotee becomes the giver.

In the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya there is another example, forwarded by Mahäräj Dhruva. He says there, "My dear Lord, I have practiced austerities and penances because I was desiring to receive something from You, but in exchange You have allowed me to see You, who are never visible even to the great sages and saintly persons. I had been searching out some pieces of broken glass, but instead I have found the most valuable jewel. I am therefore fully satisfied, my Lord. I do not wish to ask anything more from Your Lordship."

A similar statement is to be found in the Third Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 15th Chapter, 48th verse. The four sages headed by Sanaka Muni addressed the Lord as follows: "My dear Supreme Personality of Godhead, Your reputation is very attractive and free from all material contamination. Therefore You are worthy of being glorified and are actually the reservoir of all pilgrimages. Auspicious persons, who are fortunate enough to be engaged in glorifying Your attributes and who actually know what Your transcendental position is, do not even care to accept liberation offered by You. Because they are so transcendentally enriched, they do not care to accept even the post of Indra, the heavenly King. They know that the post of the King of heaven is also fearful, whereas for those who are engaged in glorifying Your transcendental qualities there is only joyfulness and freedom from all danger. As such, why should persons with this knowledge be attracted by a post in the heavenly kingdom?"

One devotee has described his feelings about the charity exhibited by King Mayüradhvaja: "I am faltering even to speak about the activities of Mahäräj Mayüradhvaja, to whom I offer my respectful obeisances." Mayüradhvaja was very intelligent, and he could understand why Kåñëa came to him once, in the garb of a brähmaëa. Kåñëa demanded from him half of his body, to be sawed off by his wife and son, and King Mayüradhvaja agreed to this proposal. On account of his intense feeling of devotional service, King Mayüradhvaja was always thinking of Kåñëa, and when he understood that Kåñëa had come in the garb of a brähmaëa, he did not hesitate to part with half of his body. This sacrifice of Mahäräj Mayüradhvaja for Kåñëa's sake is unique in the world, and we should offer our all-respectful obeisances to him. He had full knowledge of the Supreme Personality of Godhead in the garb of a brähmaëa, and he is known as the perfect däna-véra, or renouncer.

Any person who is always ready to satisfy Kåñëa and who is always dexterous in executing devotional service is called dharma-véra, or chivalrous in executing religious rituals. Only advanced devotees performing religious ritualistic performances can come to this stage of dharma-véra. Dharma-véras are produced after going through the authoritative scriptures, following moral principles, being faithful and tolerant and controlling the senses. Persons who execute religious rituals for the satisfaction of Kåñëa are steady in devotional service, whereas persons who execute religious rituals without intending to please Kåñëa are only called pious.

The best example of a dharma-véra is Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira. A devotee once told Kåñëa: "My dear Kåñëa, O killer of all demons, Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira, the eldest son of Mahäräj Päëòu, has performed all kinds of sacrifices just to please You. He has always invited the heavenly King, Indra, to take part in the yajïas [sacrifices]. Because King Indra was thus absent so often from Çacédevé, she had to pass much of her time pining over Indra's absence, with her cheeks upon her hands."

The performance of different yajïas for the demigods is considered to be worship of the limbs of the Supreme Lord. The demigods are considered to be different parts of the universal body of the Lord, and therefore the ultimate purpose in worshiping them is to please the Lord by partially worshiping His different limbs. Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira had no such material desire; he executed all sacrifices under the direction of Kåñëa, and not to take any personal advantage from them. He only desired to please Kåñëa and was therefore called the best of the devotees. He was always merged in the ocean of loving service.

NoD 47-1970: Compassion and Anger

Chapter Forty-seven

Compassion and Anger

Compassion

When the ecstasy of devotional service produces some kind of lamentation in connection with Kåñëa, it is called devotional service in compassion. The impetus of this devotional service is Kåñëa's transcendental quality, form and activities. In this ecstasy of devotional service there are sometimes symptoms like regret, heavy breathing, crying, falling on the ground and beating upon one's chest. Sometimes symptoms like laziness, frustration, defamation, humility, anxiety, moroseness, eagerness, restlessness, madness, death, forgetfulness, disease and illusion are also visible. When in the heart of a devotee there is expectation of some mishap to Kåñëa it is called devotional service in bereavement. Such bereavement is another symptom of this devotional service in compassion.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Tenth Canto, 16th Chapter, 13th verse, there is the following description. When Kåñëa was chastising the Käliyanäga in the Yamunä, the big snake wrapped his coils all over Kåñëa's body, and upon seeing Kåñëa in this situation, all His dear cowherd friends became greatly disturbed. Out of bereavement, distress and fearfulness, they became bewildered and began to fall on the ground. Because the cowherd boys were under the illusion that Kåñëa could be in some mishap, their symptoms are not at all astonishing; they had dedicated their friendship, their possessions, their desires and their very selves to Kåñëa.

When Kåñëa entered the Yamunä River, which had become very poisonous from the presence of Käliya, Mother Yaçodä feared all kinds of mishaps, and she was breathing hotly. Tears from her eyes were soaking her clothes, and she was almost collapsing.

Similarly, when the Çaìkhäsura demon was attacking Kåñëa's queens one after another, Lord Baladeva became more and more bluish.

In the Haàsadüta, the following incident is described: The gopés requested Haàsadüta to search after the marks of Kåñëa's lotus feet and to accept them as Lord Brahmä had accepted them on his helmet after he had stolen all Kåñëa's cowherd boys. Regretting his challenge to Kåñëa, Lord Brahmä had bowed down before the Lord, and his helmet became marked with the footprints of Kåñëa. The gopés reminded Haàsadüta that sometimes even the great sage Närada becomes very ecstatic by seeing these footprints, and sometimes great liberated sages also aspire to see them. "You should therefore seek very enthusiastically to find the footprints of Kåñëa," they urged. This is another instance of devotional service in compassion.

There is another instance when Sahadeva, the younger brother of Nakula, became greatly gladdened at seeing the effulgent glowing of Kåñëa's footprints. He began to cry and call out, "Mother Mädré! Where are you now? Father Päëòu! Where are you now? I am very sorry that you are not here to see these footprints of Kåñëa!" This is another instance of devotional service in compassion.

In such devotional service in compassion there are sometimes smiling symptoms, but never is there any stress or lamentation. The basic principle is always ecstatic love. The apprehension of some mishap to Kåñëa or to His beloved queens, as exhibited by Baladeva and Yudhiñöhira, has been explained above. This apprehension is not exactly due to their ignorance of the inconceivable potencies of Kåñëa but to their intense love for Him. This kind of apprehension of some mishap to Kåñëa first of all becomes manifested as an object of lamentation, but gradually it develops into such compassionate loving ecstasy that it turns to another channel and gives transcendental pleasure.

Anger

In ecstatic loving service to Kåñëa in anger, Kåñëa is always the object. In Vidagdha-mädhava, Second Canto, 53rd verse, Lalitägopé expressed her anger, which was caused by Kåñëa, when she addressed Çrématé Rädhäräëé thus: "My dear friend, my inner desires have been polluted. Therefore I shall go to the place of Yamaräja. But I am sorry to see that Kåñëa has still not given up His smiling over cheating You. I do not know how You could repose all Your loving propensities upon this lusty young boy from the neighborhood of the cowherds."

After seeing Kåñëa, Jaraté sometimes said, "O You thief of young girls' properties! I can distinctly see the covering garment of my daughter-in-law on Your person." Then she cried very loudly, addressing all the residents of Våndävana to inform them that this son of King Nanda was setting fire to the household life of her daughter-in-law.

Similar ecstatic love for Kåñëa in anger was expressed by Rohiëé-devé when she heard the roaring sound of the two falling arjuna trees to which Kåñëa had been tied. The whole neighborhood proceeded immediately towards the place where the accident took place, and Rohiëédevé took the opportunity to rebuke Mother Yaçodä as follows: "You may be very expert in giving lessons to your son by binding Him with rope, but don't you look to see if your son is in a dangerous spot? The trees are falling on the ground, and He is simply loitering there!" This expression of Rohiëédevé's anger toward Yaçodä is an example of ecstatic love in anger caused by Kåñëa.

Once, while Kåñëa was in the pasturing ground with His cowherd boys, His friends requested Him to go to the Tälavana Forest, where Gardabhäsura, a disturbing demon in the shape of an ass, resided. The friends of Kåñëa wanted to eat the fruit from the forest trees, but they could not go because of fear of the demon. Thus they requested Kåñëa to go there and kill Gardabhäsura. After Kåñëa did this, they all returned home, and their report of the day's activity perturbed Mother Yaçodä because Kåñëa had been sent alone into such danger in the Tälavana Forest. Thus she looked upon the boys with anger.

There is another instance of anger on the part of a friend of Rädhäräëé's. When Rädhäräëé was dissatisfied with the behavior of Kåñëa and had stopped talking with Him, Kåñëa was very sorry for Rädhäräëé's great dissatisfaction, and in order to beg forgiveness, He fell down at Her lotus feet. But even after this, Rädhäräëé was not satisfied, and She did not talk with Kåñëa. At that time, one of Her friends chastised Her in the following words: "My dear friend, You are allowing Yourself to be churned by the rod of dissatisfaction, so what can I say unto You? The only advice I can give You is that You had better leave this scene immediately, because Your misbehavior is giving me too much pain. I cannot bear to see Your behavior, because even though Kåñëa's peacock feather has touched Your feet, You still appear to be red-faced."

The above attitudes of dissatisfaction and anger in devotional service are called érñyu.

When Uddhava was leaving Våndävana, some of the elderly gopés rebuked him as follows: "O son of Gändiné, your cruelty is defaming the dynasty of King Yadu. You are taking Kåñëa away, keeping us in such pitiable condition without Him. Now, even before you have left, the life air of all the gopés has practically disappeared."

When Kåñëa was insulted by Çiçupäla in the assembly of räja-süya yajïa convened by Mahäräj Yudhiñöhira, there was a great turmoil amongst the Päëòavas and Kurus, involving grandfather Bhéñma. At that time Nakula said with great anger, "Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and the nails of His toes are beautified by the light emanating from the jeweled helmets of the authorities of the Vedas. If He is derided by anyone, I declare herewith as a Päëòava that I will kick his helmet with my left foot, and I will strike him with my arrows, which are as good as Yamadaëòa, the sceptor of Yamaräja!" This is an instance of ecstatic love for Kåñëa in anger.

In such a transcendental angry mood sometimes sarcastic remarks, unfavorable glances and insulting words are exhibited. Sometimes there are other symptoms, like rubbing the two hands, clacking the teeth, clamping the lips, moving the eyebrows, scratching the arms, lowering the head, breathing rapidly, uttering strong words, nodding the head, exhibiting yellowishness at the corner of the eyes, and exhibiting trembling lips. Sometimes the eyes turn red, and sometimes they fade. And there is sometimes chastisement and silence. All these symptoms of anger can be divided into two parts: constitutional and unconstitutional, or permanent and temporary symptoms. Sometimes great emotion, bewilderment, pride, frustration, illusion, impotence, jealousy, dexterity, negligence and signs of hard labor are also manifest as unconstitutional symptoms.

In all these humors of ecstatic love, the feeling of anger is accepted as the steady factor.

When Jaräsandha angrily attacked the city of Mathurä, he looked at Kåñëa with sarcastic glances. At that time Baladeva took up His plow weapon and gazed upon Jaräsandha with colored eyes.

There is a statement in the Vidagdha-mädhava wherein Çrématé Rädhäräëé, in an angry mood, addressed Her mother, Paurëamäsé, after she had accused Rädhäräëé of going to Kåñëa. "My dear mother," Rädhä declared, "what can I say to you? Kåñëa is so cruel that He often attacks Me on the street, and if I want to cry out very loudly, this boy with a peacock feather on His head immediately covers My face so that I cannot cry. And if I want to go away from the scene because I am afraid of Him, He will immediately spread His arms to block My path. If I piteously fall down at His feet, then this enemy of the Madhu demon, in an angry mood, bites My face! Mother, just try to understand My situation, and don't be unnecessarily angry with Me. Instead, please tell Me how I can save Myself from these terrible attacks of Kåñëa!"

Sometimes amongst contemporary personalities there are signs of ecstasy in anger because of love for Kåñëa. An example of such anger was exhibited in the quarrel between Jaöilä and Mukharä. Jaöilä was the mother-in-law of Rädhäräëé, and Mukharä was Her great grand-mother. Both of them were talking about Kåñëa's unnecessary harrassment of Rädhäräëé when She was walking on the street. Jaöilä said, "You cruel-faced Mukharä! By hearing your words my heart feels like it is burning in a fire!" And Mukharä replied, "You sinful Jaöilä, by hearing your words, there is aching in my head! You cannot give any evidence that Kåñëa has attacked Rädhäräëé, the daughter of my granddaughter Kértidä."

Once, when Rädhäräëé was taking off the necklace given to Her by Kåñëa, Jaöilä, her mother-in-law, told a friend: "My dear friend, just see the beautiful necklace that Kåñëa has presented to Rädhäräëé. She is now holding it, but still she wants to tell us that She has no connection with Kåñëa. This girl's activities have disgraced our whole family!"

Natural jealousy of Kåñëa by persons like Çiçupäla cannot be accepted as ecstatic love in anger with Kåñëa.

NoD 48-1970: Dread and Ghastliness

Chapter Forty-eight

Dread and Ghastliness

Dread

In ecstatic love for Kåñëa in dread, there are two causes of fear: either Kåñëa Himself or some dreadful situation for Kåñëa. When a devotee feels himself to be an offender at Kåñëa's lotus feet, at that time Kåñëa Himself becomes the objective of dreadful ecstatic love. And when out of ecstatic love friends and well-wishers of Kåñëa apprehend some danger for Him, that situation becomes the object of their dread.

When Åkñaräj was in front of Kåñëa fighting and suddenly realized that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa addressed him thus: "My dear Åkñaräj, why is your face so dry? Please do not feel threatened by Me. There is no need for your heart to tremble like this. Please calm yourself down. I have no anger toward you. You can, however, become as angry as you like with Me—to expand your service in fighting with Me and to increase My sporting attitude." In this dreadful situation in ecstatic love for Kåñëa, Kåñëa Himself is the object of dread.

There is another instance of a dreadful situation with Kåñëa as the object as follows: After being sufficiently chastised by child Kåñëa in the Yamunä River, the Käliya snake began to address the Lord, "O killer of the Mura demon, I have acquired many mystic powers by my austerity and penances, but before You I am nothing, I am most insignificant. Therefore, please be kind upon a poor soul like me, and don't be angry with me. I did not know Your actual position, and out of ignorance I have committed such horrible offenses. Please save me. I am a most unfortunate, foolish creature. Please be merciful to me." This is another instance of the ecstasy of dread in devotional service.

When the Keçé demon was causing disturbance in Våndävana by assuming a large horse's body that was so big that he could jump over the trees, Mother Yaçodä told her husband, Nanda Mahäräj, "Our child is very restless, so we had better keep Him locked up within the house. I have been very worried about the recent disturbances of the Keçé demon, who has been assuming the form of a giant horse." When it was learned that the demon was entering Gokula in an angry mood, Mother Yaçodä became so anxious to protect her child that her face dried up and there were tears in her eyes. These are some of the signs of the ecstasy of dread in devotional service, caused by seeing and hearing something that is dangerous to Kåñëa.

After the Pütanä witch had been killed, some friends of Mother Yaçodä inquired from her about the incident. Mother Yaçodä at once requested her friends, "Please stop! Please stop! Don't bring up the incident of Pütanä. I become distressed just by remembering this incident. The Pütanä witch came to devour my son, and she deceived me into letting her take the child on her lap. After that, she died and made a tumultuous sound with her gigantic body."

In the ecstasy of devotional service in dread, the unconstitutional symptoms are drying up of the mouth, exuberance, glancing towards the back side, concealing oneself, bewilderment, searching after the endangered lovable object and crying very loudly. Some other unconstitutional symptoms are illusion, forgetfulness, and expectation of danger. In all such circumstances the ecstatic dread is the steady or constant factor. Such dreadfulness is caused either by offenses committed or by dreadful circumstances. Offenses can be committed in varieties of ways, and the dread is felt by the person who has committed the offense. When dread is caused by a fearful object, this fearful object is generally a person who is fearsome in his features, nature and influence. An example of an object which caused ecstatic dread is the Pütanä witch. Dread can be caused by mischievous demonic characters, such as King Kaàsa, and it can be caused by great powerful demigods, such as Indra or Çaìkara.

Demons like Kaàsa feared Kåñëa, but their feelings cannot be described as ecstatic dread in devotional service.

Ghastliness

It is understood from authoritative sources that an attachment for Kåñëa because of feelings of disgust sometimes presents a ghastly ecstasy in devotional service. The person experiencing such ecstatic love for Kåñëa is almost always in the neutral stage of devotional service, or çänta-rasa. A description of ecstatic love caused by ghastliness is found in the following statement: "This person was formerly interested solely in the matter of lust and sense gratification, and he had perfected the greatest skill in exploiting women to fulfill his lusty desires. But now how wonderful it is that this same man is chanting the names of Kåñëa with tears in his eyes, and as soon as he sees the face of a woman, he immediately becomes disgusted. From the indication of his face, I would think that now he hates sex life."

In this mellow of devotional service in ghastliness, the sub-ecstatic symptoms are spitting upon the consideration of one's past life, contorting the face, covering the nose and washing the hands. There is also trembling of the body, forcible twisting of the body and perspiration. Other symptoms which may be present are shame, exhaustion, madness, illusion, frustration, humility, self-pity, restlessness, eagerness and stunning of the body.

When a devotee, lamenting for his past abominable activities, shows special symptoms on his body, his feeling is called ecstasy in devotional service in ghastliness. This is caused by the awakening of his Kåñëa consciousness.

In this connection there is the following statement: "How can a person take pleasure in the enjoyment of sex life in this body, which is a bag of skin and bones, filled with blood, covered by skin and flesh and which produces mucus and evil smells?" This perception is possible only for one who is awakened to Kåñëa consciousness and who has become fully cognizant of the abominable nature of this material body.

A fortunate child in the womb of his mother prayed to Kåñëa as follows: "O enemy of Kaàsa, I am suffering so much because of this material body. Now I am trapped within a mess of blood, urine and liquid stool, within the womb of my mother. Because I am living in such a condition, I am suffering great pangs. Therefore, O divine ocean of mercy, please be kind to me. I have no capacity to be engaged in Your loving devotional service, but please save me!" There is a similar statement by a person fallen in the hellish condition of life. He addressed the Supreme Lord thus: "My dear Lord, Yamaräja has placed me in a situation which is full of filthy and obnoxious smells. There are so many insects and worms, surrounded by the stools left by different kinds of diseased persons. And after visualizing this horrible scene, my eyes have become sore, and I am becoming nearly blind. I therefore pray, O my Lord, O deliverer from the hellish conditions of life. I have fallen into this hell, but I shall try to remember Your holy name always, and in this way I shall try to keep my body and soul together." This is another instance of ecstatic love for Kåñëa in an abominable situation.

It is to be understood that any person who is constantly engaged in chanting the holy names of the Lord, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, has attained a transcendental affection for Kåñëa, and as such, in any condition of life, he remains satisfied simply by remembering the Lord's name in full affection and ecstatic love.

In conclusion, it may be stated that the ecstatic love for Kåñëa in ghastliness appears during the development of dormant neutrality into developed affection.

NoD 49-1970: Mixing of Rasas

Chapter Forty-nine

Mixing of Rasas

As already described, there are twelve different kinds of rasas, or ecstatic relationships which are shared with Kåñëa. Five of these rasas are direct, and they are listed as neutrality, servitude, fraternal love, parental love, and conjugal love. Seven of the rasas are indirect, and they are listed as humor, astonishment, chivalry, compassion, anger, dread and ghastliness. The five direct rasas are eternally manifested in the Vaikuëöha world, the spiritual kingdom, whereas the seven indirect rasas are eternally manifesting and unmanifesting in Gokula Våndävana, where Kåñëa displays His transcendental pastimes in the material world.

Very often, in addition to one's regular rasa, there is found the presence of some other rasa, and the mixture of these loving humors is sometimes compatible, or palatable, and sometimes incompatible, or unpalatable. The following is a scientific analysis of the compatibility and incompatibility of the mixtures of these various rasas, or loving moods.

When in the rasa of neutral love (çänta-rasa) there are found traces of dread or astonishment, the result is compatible. When with this neutral love there are manifestations of conjugal love, chivalry, anger or dread, the result is incompatible.

When in the ecstasy of a serving humor, there are manifestations of dread, neutral love, or chivalry (such as dharma-véra and däna-véra) the result is compatible. The ecstasy of devotional service in chivalry (yuddha-véra) and anger are directly produced by Kåñëa Himself.

With the ecstasy of fraternal love, a mixture of conjugal love, laughter or chivalry is highly compatible. With the same fraternal love, a mixture of dread or parental love is most incompatible.

Although there are gulfs of differences between them, with the ecstasy of parental affection, a mixture of laughter, compassion or dread is compatible.

With the ecstasy of parental love, a mixture of conjugal love, chivalry or anger is incompatible.

With the ecstasy of devotion in conjugal love, a mixture of laughter or fraternity is compatible.

According to certain expert opinions, in the ecstasy of conjugal love, the feelings of chivalry which are known as yuddha-véra and dharma-véra are the only compatible additions. According to this view, except for these two humors, all other manifestations are taken as incompatible with conjugal love.

With the ecstasy of devotional laughter, a mixture of dread, conjugal love or parental love is compatible, whereas a mixture of compassion or ghastliness is incompatible.

With the ecstasy of devotion in astonishment, a mixture of chivalry or neutral love is compatible; whereas a mixture of anger or dread is always incompatible.

With the ecstasy of devotional chivalry, a mixture of astonishment, laughter or servitude is compatible, while a mixture of dread or conjugal love is incompatible. According to some expert opinions, the ecstasy of neutral love is always compatible with devotional service in chivalry.

With the ecstasy of compassion in devotional service, a mixture of anger or parental love is compatible; while a mixture of laughter, conjugal love or astonishment is always incompatible.

With the ecstasy of anger in devotional service, a mixture of compassion or chivalry is compatible; while a mixture of laughter, conjugal union or dread is completely incompatible.

With the ecstasy of dread in devotional service, a mixture of ghastliness or compassion is compatible.

With the ecstasy of chivalry in devotional service, a mixture of conjugal union, laughter or anger is always incompatible.

In the ecstasy of ghastliness in devotional service, feelings of neutral love, laughter or servitude are compatible; whereas feelings of conjugal union and fraternity are incompatible.

The above analysis is a sample of the study of rasäbhäsa or incompatible mixing of rasas. This transcendental science of rasäbhäsa can thoroughly explain the humors in ecstatic love which are compatible and incompatible with one another. When Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu was residing in Jagannätha Puré, many poets and devotees used to come to Him and offer their different kinds of poetry, but the regulation was that Lord Caitanya's secretary, Svarüpa Dämodara, first examined all of these writings scrutinizingly, and then if he would find that there were no incompatibilities in the rasas, or transcendental mellows, he would then allow the poet to approach Lord Caitanya and recite his poetry.

The topic of incompatibility is a very important one, and those who are pure devotees always expect to find perfect compatibility in descriptions of the different relationships with the Personality of Godhead. The study of compatibility and incompatibility sometimes becomes very involved, and a hint of why this is so is given as follows: When a friend meets another friend, the mellow produced out of that meeting is generally taken as very palatable. But actually with such meetings between two friends, there are so many feelings involved that it is difficult to ascertain when these feelings are actually becoming compatible and when they are becoming incompatible.

Expert literary scholars have analyzed the rasas which are compatible with one another by contrasting the various rasas in a particular mixture under the names "whole" and "part." According to this method, the prominent feeling is called the "whole," and the subordinate feeling is called the "part."

The following statement elucidates the subject of part and whole: "All living entities are just like sparks from the supreme fire, and as such, I do not know if I, a tiny spark, shall be able to engage myself in the transcendental loving service of this supreme fire, Lord Kåñëa." In this statement, the feelings of neutral love are taken as the whole, whereas the desire to serve the Lord is taken as the part. Actually, in the Brahman effulgence there is no chance for reciprocation of loving ecstasy between the Lord and the devotee.

There is another quotation by a devotee who laments as follows: "Alas, I am still trying to relish different pleasurable states from this body, which is simply some skin covering mucus, semina and blood. In this state of consciousness I am so condemned that I cannot relish the transcendental ecstasy of remembering the Supreme Personality of Godhead." In this statement there are two ecstatic loving humors, namely neutrality and ghastliness. Neutrality is taken here as the whole, whereas the ecstasy of ghastliness is the part.

There is a similar statement by a devotee as follows: "I shall now begin my service of fanning the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, who is seated on a golden throne. He is the supreme Param-brahma in His eternal transcendental form of a cloudy blackish complexion. Now I shall give up my affection for my material body, which is nothing but a bunch of flesh and blood." Herein also there is a combination of servitude and ghastliness, where the ecstasy of servitude is taken as the whole, and the ecstasy of ghastliness is taken as the part.

There is another statement as follows: "When shall I be freed from the mode of ignorance? And being thus purified, when shall I attain the stage of serving Kåñëa eternally? Only then shall I be able to worship Him, always observing His lotus eyes and beautiful face." In this statement the whole is the ecstasy of neutrality, and the part is servitorship.

There is another statement as follows: "Please look at this devotee of the Lord who is dancing just from remembering the lotus feet of Kåñëa. Simply by observing his dance you will lose all interest in even the most beautiful women!" In this statement the whole is in neutrality, and the part is in ghastliness.

One devotee boldly said, "My dear Lord, now I am turning my face from any thought of association with young girls. As far as Brahman realization is concerned, I have lost all interest because I am completely absorbed in thinking about You. And being absorbed so blissfully, I have lost all other desires, even the desire for mystic powers. Now my mind is only attracted to worshiping Your lotus feet." In this statement, the whole is the ecstasy of neutrality, and the part is chivalry.

In another statement, Subala is addressed thus: "My dear Subala, the damsels of Våndävana who had the opportunity of enjoying Kåñëa's kissing must be the foremost of all the fortunate women in the world." In this example, the ecstasy of fraternal devotional service is the whole, and the ecstasy of conjugal love is the part.

The following statement was made by Kåñëa to the gopés: "My dear enchanted, don't gaze at Me with longing eyes like this. Be satisfied and return to your homes in Våndävana. There is no necessity of your presence here." While Kåñëa was joking in this way with the damsels of Braja, who with great hope had come to enjoy the räsa dance with Him, Subala was also on the scene, and he began to look at Kåñëa with wide and laughing eyes. Subala's feeling contained a mixture of fraternity and laughter in devotional service. Fraternity is considered here as the whole, and the laughter is considered as the part.

The following example contains a mixture of ecstatic fraternity and laughter, taken respectively as the whole and part. When Kåñëa saw that Subala, in the dress of Rädhäräëé, was silently hiding under the shade of a beautiful açoka tree on the bank of the Yamunä, He immediately arose from His seat in surprise. Upon seeing Kåñëa, Subala tried to hide his laughter by covering his cheeks.

There is also an example of a mixture of parental love and compassion in devotional service. When Mother Yaçodä was thinking that her son was walking in the forest without any umbrella or shoes, she became greatly perturbed to think of how much difficulty Kåñëa must have been feeling. In this example the whole is the paternal love, and the part is compassion.

There is the following example of a mixture of parental love and laughter. A friend of Mother Yaçodä told her, "My dear Yaçodä, your son has very cunningly stolen a lump of butter from my home. And to make me blame my own son for His mischief, He has smeared some of the butter on my son's face while he was sleeping!" Upon hearing this, Mother Yaçodä shook her curved eyebrows. She could only look at her friend with a smiling face. May Mother Yaçodä bless everyone with this smiling attitude. In this example the whole is the parental love, and the part is the laughter.

There is an example of a mixture of several humors with devotional service as follows. When Kåñëa was holding up Govardhan Hill with His left hand, His hairs became scattered all over His shoulders, and He appeared to be perspiring. When Mother Yaçodä saw this scene, she began to tremble. Then, as she stared at the scene with broadened eyes, she saw Kåñëa begin to exhibit varieties of facial caricatures. Mother Yaçodä then became very happy and began to smile. Then again, when she thought that Kåñëa was holding up the hill for such an extremely long time, her clothes became soaked with perspiration. May Mother Yaçodä Brajeçvaré protect the whole universe by her infinite mercy! In this example, the whole is parental love, and the part is dread, wonder, laughter, compassion, etc.

There is an example of a mixture of conjugal love and fraternal affection when Çrématé Rädhäräëé said, "My dear friends, just see how Kåñëa is resting His hand on the shoulder of Subala, who is dressed up just like a young girl! I think He must be sending some message to Me through Subala. The purport is that the superiors of Rädhäräëé do not like Kåñëa or His cowherd friends to associate with Her; therefore these friends sometimes clothe themselves in female dress so they can give Rädhäräëé a message from Kåñëa. In this example the whole is conjugal love and the part is fraternity.

The following is an example of a mixture of conjugal love and laughter in devotional service: Kåñëa, in the dress of a young girl, told Rädhäräëé, "Oh, You hard-hearted girl! Don't You know that I am Your sister? Why are You unable to recognize Me? Be merciful upon Me and please capture My shoulders and embrace Me with love!" While Kåñëa was dressed up exactly like Rädhäräëé, He was speaking these nice words, and Çrématé Rädhäräëé could understand His purpose. But because She was in front of many of Her superiors, She simply smiled and did not say anything. In this instance, the ecstasy of conjugal love is taken as the whole, and the ecstasy of laughter is taken as the part.

The following illustrates a mixture of several feelings. When one of the consort friends of Candrävalé saw that Kåñëa was preparing to fight with the Våñäsura demon, she began to think: "How wonderful Kåñëa is! His mind is captivated by the eyebrows of Candrävalé in a smiling spirit, His snake-like arms are on the shoulder of His friend, and at the same time He is roaring like a lion to encourage Våñäsura to fight with Him!" This is an example of conjugal love, fraternity, and chivalry. The conjugal love is taken here as the whole, and the fraternity and chivalry are taken as the parts.

When Kubjä caught hold of Kåñëa's yellow garment because she was feeling almost lusty with sex urge, Kåñëa simply bowed down His head with His cheeks glowing in front of the many people who were standing there and laughing. This is an example of a mixture of ecstatic conjugal love and laughter. The laughter is taken as the whole, and the conjugal love is taken as the part.

Viçäla, a cowherd boy who was attempting to fight with Bhadrasena, was addressed by another cowherd boy as follows: "Why are you attempting to show your chivalrous spirit before me? Before this, you even attempted to fight with Çrédämä, but you must know that Çrédämä does not even care to fight with hundreds of Balarämas. So why are you acting so enthusiastically when you actually have no importance at all?" This is an example of a mixture of devotional fraternity and chivalry. The chivalry is taken as the whole, and the fraternity is taken as the part.

Çiçupäla was habituated to calling Kåñëa ill names, and by his insults he irritated the sons of Päëòu more than he irritated Kåñëa. The Päëòavas therefore equipped themselves with all kinds of weapons to kill Çiçupäla. Their feelings were a mixture of ecstatic anger and fraternity, the anger being taken as the whole, and fraternity as the part.

Once Kåñëa was watching Çrédämä very expertly using his stick to fight with Balaräma, who was an expert club-fighter and who had even killed the Pralambäsura demon with His club. When Kåñëa saw Balaräma finally defeated by Çrédämä, who was using only a small stick, Kåñëa became filled with pleasure and began to look upon Çrédämä with great wonder. In this instance there is a mixture of astonishment, fraternity and chivalry in devotional service. The fraternity and chivalry are considered as the parts, and the astonishment is considered as the whole.

Expert analyzers of these various kinds of mellows instruct us that when different mellows overlap one another, the mellow which is the whole, or the prominent humor, is called the permanent ecstasy. It is confirmed in the Viñëu-dharmottara that when there are many mellows of devotional ecstasy mixed together, the prominent one, or the whole, is called the steady ecstasy of devotional service. Although the subordinate mellow may be manifested for a certain time, at length it will become merged into the prominent whole. Thus it is called an unconstitutional ecstasy of devotional service.

There is a good analogy in this connection, showing the relationship between the part and the whole. Lord Vämanadeva is actually the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but He appeared to have been "born" as one of the brothers of Indra. Although Vämanadeva is sometimes taken as a less-important demigod, He is actually the maintainer of Indra, the King of the demigods. Thus, although sometimes Vämanadeva is considered to be a subordinate demigod, His actual position is that of the supreme whole, the source of the entire demigod system. In the same way, a rasa which is actually prominent may sometimes appear to be manifested in a subordinate way, although its actual position is as the main or prominent loving feeling of a devotee.

When an unconstitutional ecstasy of devotional service is manifested prominently at a certain time, it is still accepted as the part. If it is not very prominently manifested, it appears only slightly and quickly merges back into the whole. At such times of slight appearance, no consideration is given to it; as when one is eating some palatable dishes, if one also eats a small blade of grass, he will not taste it, nor will he care to distinguish what its taste is like.

NoD 50-1970: Further Analysis of Mixed Rasas

Chapter Fifty

Further Analysis of Mixed Rasas

As already described, if certain kinds of mellows become mixed and there is a joining of opposite mellows, then the situation is called incompatible. When one is eating sweet rice and something salty or sour is mixed in, the mixture is not very tasteful, and it is called incompatible.

An exemplary instance of incompatibility is the following statement by an impersonalist who was lamenting aloud, "I have been attached simply to the impersonal Brahman feature, and I have passed my days uselessly in practicing trance. I have not given any proper attention to Çré Kåñëa, who is the source of the impersonal Brahman and who is the reservoir of all transcendental pleasures." In this statement there are traces of neutrality and conjugal love, and the resulting humor is incompatible.

Sometimes it is found in places like Våndävana that a person with a slight devotional attitude of neutral love for Kåñëa may immediately and artificially try to attain to the platform of conjugal love. But because of the incompatibility of neutrality and conjugal love, the person is found to fall from the standard of devotional service.

Incompatibility was expressed by a great devotee on the platform of neutrality when he sarcastically prayed, "I am very anxious to see Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is many millions of times more affectionate than the pitås (forefathers) in the Pitå-loka, and who is always worshiped by the great demigods and sages. I am a little surprised, however, that although Kåñëa is the husband of the goddess of fortune, His body is often marked with the nail pricks of ordinary society girls!" Here is an example of incompatibility due to a mixture of neutrality and high conjugal love.

There is the following statement by a gopé: "My dear Kåñëa, the first thing You should do is just embrace me with Your strong arms. Then, my dear friend, I shall first smell Your head, and then I shall enjoy with You." This is an example of incompatibility in which conjugal love is the whole and servitorship is the part.

One devotee said, "My dear Kåñëa, how can I address You as my son when You are addressed by the great Vedäntists as the absolute truth and by the Vaiñëavas who follow the principles of Närada-païcarätra as the Supreme Personality of Godhead? You are the same Supreme Person, so how shall my tongue be so extraordinarily bold as to address You as an ordinary son?" In this statement there is a mixture of neutrality and parental love, and the result is incompatible.

Another devotee said, "My dear friend, my youthful beauty is as temporary as lightning in the sky, and therefore, my possessing attractive bodily features is unimportant. I have never met Kåñëa, so I request you to please arrange for my meeting Him immediately." In this statement there is the incompatibility of a neutral mellow mixed with conjugal love.

A lusty woman in Kailäsa once told Kåñëa: "My dear Kåñëa, may You have a long life!" Then, after saying this, she embraced Kåñëa. This is an example of incompatibility resulting from a mixture of parental love and conjugal love.

The purpose of the above analysis is to show that in the mixture of various mellows, or reciprocations of ecstatic love between Kåñëa and the devotees, if the result is not pure, there will be incompatibility. According to the opinion of stalwart devotees like Rüpa Gosvämé, as soon as there are contradictory feelings, the result is incompatible.

Once an ordinary female devotee addressed Kåñëa, "My dear boy, I know that my body is just a composition of flesh and blood and can never be enjoyable to You. But still, I have been so attracted by Your beauty that I wish that You accept me as Your conjugal lover." In this statement there is incompatibility caused by a mixture of ghastliness and conjugal love in devotional service.

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé warns devotees to not commit such incompatibilities in their writings or in their dealings. The presence of such contradictory feelings is called rasäbhäsa. When there is rasäbhäsa in any book of Kåñëa consciousness, no learned scholar or devotee will accept it.

In the Vidagdha-mädhava, second act, verse 29, Paurëamäsé tells Nändémukhé: "Just see how wonderful it is! Great sages meditate upon Kåñëa after being relieved from all material transactions, and with great difficulty they try to situate Kåñëa in their hearts. And opposed to this, this young girl is trying to withdraw her mind from Kåñëa so she can apply it in the material activities of sense gratification. What a regrettable thing it is that this girl is trying to drive away from her heart the same Kåñëa who is sought after by great sages through severe austerities and perseverance!" Although in this statement there are contradictory mellows of ecstatic devotion, the result is not incompatible because conjugal love is so elevated that it is defeating all other varieties of mellows. Çréla Jéva Gosvämé comments in this connection that such a loving state of mind is not possible for all. It is only possible in the case of the gopés of Våndävana. There are many other instances of contradictory mellows where there is no perverted experience of rasäbhäsa.

Once some minor demigod of the heavenly planets remarked: "Kåñëa, whose joking words were once the source of so much laughter for the residents of Braja, has now been attacked by the serpent king, Käliya, and He has become the object of everyone's overwhelming lamentation!" In this instance there is a mixture of laughter and compassion, but there is no incompatibility because by both of these rasas the loving affection for Kåñëa is increased.

Çrématé Rädhäräëé was once told that although She had stopped all activities, She was still the supreme source of inspiration for all kinds of devotional service. The statement says, "My dear Rädhäräëé, in separation from Kåñëa You are now as still as the most beautiful tree, whose gracefulness is not blocked by any covering of leaves. Your tranquil mood makes You appear to be completely merged in Brahman realization!" In this example there is a mixture of conjugal love and neutral love, but the conjugal love has surpassed everything. Actually, Brahman realization is only a stunted existence. There is the following statement by Kåñëa Himself: "Çrématé Rädhäräëé has become peace personified for Me. Because of Her I now go without sleep. I stare constantly without blinking my eyes, and I am always in a meditative mood. Because of Her I have even made My home in the cave of a mountain!" This is an example of conjugal love mixed with neutral love, but there is no incompatibility.

The following is a conversation consisting of questions put before Rambhä, a celebrated beautiful woman, and her corresponding answers. Rambhä was asked, "My dear Rambhä, who are you?" She answered, "I am peace personified." Question: "Then why are you in the sky?" Answer: "I am in the sky to experience the supreme absolute truth." Question: "Then why are you staring?" Answer: "Just to look into the supreme beauty of the absolute truth." Question: "Then why do you appear to be disturbed in mind?" Answer: "Because Cupid is acting." In the above example also there is no perverted representation of mellows because on the whole the ecstasy of conjugal love has exceeded the neutral position of devotional service.

In the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 60th Chapter, 44th verse, Rukmiëédevé said, "My dear husband, a woman who has no taste for the transcendental pleasure available from Your personal contact must be inclined to accept as her husband somebody who is externally a combination of mustaches, beard, body hairs, fingernails and some head hair. And within him there are muscles, bones, blood, intestinal worms, stools, mucus, bile, and similar things. Actually, such a husband is only a dead body, but due to not being attracted to Your transcendental form, a woman will have to accept this combination of stools and urine for her husband." This statement, which lists the ingredients of a material body, is not a perverted mellow in transcendental realization because it shows correct discrimination between matter and spirit.

In the Vidagdha-mädhava, second act, 42nd verse, Kåñëa tells His friend, "My dear friend, what a wonderful thing it is that since I have seen the beautiful lotus eyes of Çrématé Rädhäräëé, I have developed a tendency to spit on the moon and the lotus flower!" This is an example of conjugal love mixed with ghastliness, but there is no incompatibility.

The following is a statement which describes different mellows of devotional service: "Although Kåñëa was invincible to any enemy, the cowherd boys of Våndävana became almost blackish with astonishment upon seeing His wonderful royal garments and His fighting feats on the battlefield of Kurukñetra." In this statement, although there is a mixture of chivalrous activities and astonishment in devotional service, there is no perverted reflection of mellows.

One resident of Mathurä requested her father to bolt the doors and then go with her to the school of Sändépani Muni to find Kåñëa. She complained that Kåñëa had completely stolen her mind. In this incident there is a mixture of conjugal love and parental love, but there is no incompatibility.

A brahmänandé (impersonalist) expressed his desire as follows: "When shall I be able to see that supreme absolute Personality of Godhead who is eternal bliss and knowledge, and whose chest has become smeared with red kuìkum powder by touching the breast of Rukmiëé?" Here there is a mixture of conjugal love and neutrality. Although this is a contradiction of mellows, there is no incompatibility because even a brahmänandé will become attracted to Kåñëa.

Nanda Mahäräj told his wife, "My dear Yaçodä, although your son, Kåñëa, is as delicate and soft as the mallékä flower, He has gone to kill the Keçé demon, who is as strong as the mountain. Therefore I have become a little disturbed. But never mind, all auspiciousness to my son! I shall raise this hand which is as strong as a pillar, and I shall kill the Keçé demon, just to give freedom from all anxieties to the inhabitants of Brajamaëòala!" In this statement there are two kinds of mellows: chivalry and dread. Both of them, however, improve the position of parental love, and therefore there is no incompatibility.

In the Lalita-mädhava of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé it is stated, "After Kåñëa's arrival in Kaàsa's arena, Kaàsa's priest looked at Kåñëa with a detestful expression. The entire arena was filled with dread on the part of Kaàsa and his priest and restless expressions of pleasure on the cheeks of Kåñëa's friends. Frustration was felt by His envious rivals. The great sages meditated. Hot tears were in the eyes of Devaké and other motherly ladies, and hairs stood on the bodies of the expert warriors. There was astonishment in the hearts of demigods such as Indra. The servants danced, and the restless eyes of all the young girls glanced about." In this statement there is a description of a combination of different mellows, but there is no incompatibility.

A similar statement, which is free from incompatibility, is in the Lalita-mädhava wherein the author blesses all the readers of the book in the following manner: "Although the Supreme Personality of Godhead is able to lift a mountain with a finger of His left hand, He is always humble and meek. He is always very kind to His loving devotees. He has frustrated Indra's attempt at vengeance by refusing him the sacrifice of Indra-yajïa. He is the cause of all pleasure to all young girls. May He be ever compassionate upon you all!"

NoD 51-1970: Perverted Expression of Mellows

Chapter Fifty-one

Perverted Expression of Mellows

Rasäbhäsa, or incompatible mixtures of mellows, can be classified as uparasa (false expression) anurasa (imitation) and aparasa (perverted or misrepresented mellows).

There is the following statement by an impersonalist who had just seen Kåñëa: "When a person has passed completely from all contamination of material existence, he relishes a transcendental bliss of being established in trance. But as soon as I saw You, the original Personality of Godhead, I experienced the same bliss." This perverted reflection of mellows is called çänta-uparasa, or a perverted reflection of mixed impersonalism and personalism.

There is another statement as follows: "Wherever I am glancing I simply see Your personality. Therefore I know You are the uncontaminated Brahman effulgence, the supreme cause of all causes. I think there is nothing but You in this cosmic manifestation." This is another example of uparasa, or a perverted reflection of impersonalism and personalism.

When Madhumaìgala, an intimate friend of Kåñëa, was dancing before Kåñëa in a joking manner, no one was paying attention to him, and he jokingly said, "My dear Lord, please be merciful upon me. I am praying for Your mercy." This is an example of uparasa in fraternal affection and neutrality.

Kaàsa once addressed his sister Devaké as follows: "My dear sister, having seen your dear son Kåñëa, I think that He is so strong that He can kill even wrestlers strong as the mountains. So I will have no more anxieties about Him, even if He is engaged in a terrible fight." This is an instance of uparasa in a perverted reflection of parental love.

In the Lalita-mädhava, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says, "The wives of the yajïic brähmaëas were all young girls, and they were attracted to Kåñëa in the same way as the gopés of Våndävana. Out of their attraction they distributed food to Kåñëa." Here the two devotional mellows are conjugal love and parental love, and the result is called upa-rasa in conjugal love.

One of the friends of Çrématé Rädhäräëé told Her, "My dear friend Gändharvikä [Rädhäräëé], You were the most chaste girl in our village, but now You have divided Yourself and are partially chaste and partially unchaste. It is all due to Cupid's influence upon You after You saw Kåñëa and heard the sound of His flute." This is another example of uparasa caused by divided interests in conjugal love.

According to some expert learned scholars, the feelings between lover and beloved create perverted reflections of mellows in many ways.

"The gopés have become purified by Kåñëa's glance, and as such, Cupid's influence is distinctly visible on their bodies." Although in the material sense the glancing of a boy at a girl is a kind of pollution, when Kåñëa threw His transcendental glance at the gopés, they became purified. In other words, because Kåñëa is the absolute truth, any action by Him is transcendentally pure.

After Kåñëa chastised the Käliyanäga in the Yamunä River by dancing on his heads, the Käliyanäga's wives addressed Kåñëa, "My dear cowherd boy, we are all only young wives of the Käliyanäga, so why do you agitate our minds by sounding Your flute?" Käliya's wives were flattering Kåñëa so that He would spare their husband. Therefore this is an example of uparasa, or imitation.

One devotee said, "My dear Govinda, here is a nice flowery bush in Kailäsa. I am a young girl, and You are a young poetic boy. After this, what more can I say? You just consider." This is an example of uparasa, caused by impudency in conjugal love.

When Närada Muni was passing through Våndävana, he came to the Bhäëòéravana Forest and saw in one of the trees the famous parrot couple that always accompanies Lord Kåñëa. The couple was imitating some discussion they heard upon the Vedänta philosophy, and thus were seemingly arguing upon various philosophical points. Upon seeing this, Närada Muni was struck with wonder, and he began to stare without moving his eyelids. This is an example of anurasa, or imitation.

When Kåñëa was fleeing away from the battlefield, from a distant place Jaräsandha was watching Him with restless eyes and was feeling very proud. Being thus puffed up with his conquest, he was repeatedly laughing. This is an example of aparasa.

Everything in connection with Kåñëa is called ecstatic devotional love, although it may be exhibited in different ways: sometimes in right order and sometimes as a perverted reflection. According to the opinion of all expert devotees, anything that will arouse ecstatic love for Kåñëa is to be taken as an impetus for transcendental mellow.

Thus ends the Bhaktivedanta summary study of Çré Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé.

Concluding Words

Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé concludes by saying that Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu is very difficult for ordinary men to understand, yet he hopes that Lord Kåñëa, the eternal Supreme Personality of Godhead, will be pleased with his presentation of this book.

By rough calculation it is estimated that Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé finished Çré Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu in Gokula Våndävana in the year 1552. While physically present, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé was living in different parts of Våndävana, and his headquarters were in the temple of Rädhä-Dämodara in the present city of Våndävana. The place of Rüpa Gosvämé's bhajana, execution of devotional service, is commemorated still. There are two different tomb-like structures in the Rädhä-Dämodara temple; one structure is called his place of bhajana, and in the other his body is entombed. Behind this very tomb I have my place of bhajana, but since 1965 I have been away. The place, however, is being taken care of by my disciples. By Kåñëa's will, I am now residing at the Los Angeles Temple of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. This purport is finished today, the 30th of June, 1969.

Teachings of Lord Caitanya - 1968 Edition

TLC-1968 Front flap & pages

Front flap & pages

In the Kali Yuga the Supreme Lord comes as One Who always chants the Holy Name of Sri Krishna, Who is Sri Krishna Himself, Whose complexion is yellow.

—Srimad Bhagwatam (XI:5:32)

These words of the massive Srimad Bhagwatam, recorded by the author of the famous Bhagavad-Gita, Vyasadev, foretell the advent of Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. Lord Chaitanya, like Christ, was a spiritual revolutionary Who taught that conceptions of being Hindu, Christian, Muslim, black, white, male and female are "bodily designations that are finished when the body is finished." His Peace Formula is this: all living entities, including trees, bacteria, ants, cows and humans are eternal spiritual sparks of the Supreme Lord and all are brothers who have the same One Father. In Teachings of Lord Chaitanya, A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami presents to the West the sublime life and teachings of this great transcendental Personality of the 15th century Whose Sankirtan Movement swept first India, and now the West.

Many philosophers recognise God to be a force that is beyond name or form, but Chaitanya Mahaprabhu taught that God is a Person Who has Form, Qualities, Name and Pastimes—but Who is nevertheless Absolute and Transcendental and beyond anything we have experienced in this material world.

Lord Chaitanya journeyed up and down the subcontinent of India to deliver the easiest, most glorious method of self-realisation: chanting of the Hare Krishna Mantra. His explanations of the esoteric Vedanta Sutra converted many impersonalists, turning them "from dried sticks into blooming flowers." He led thousands in massive Kirtan parades of ecstacy, and even caused tigers in the jungles to swoon.

Teachings of Lord Chaitanya is a remarkable book which answers definitively the unanswered questions burning within man's heart. The Swamiji's chapter entitled "The Beauty of Krishna" is a description of the stunning beauty of God which stands by itself as one of the most sublime lyrical achievements in all mystic literature. His vast scholarship qualifies him as the most erudite Vedic scholar now writing in English. As Acharya (meaning one who teaches by example) of the Sankirtan Movement today, the Swami lectures at numerous temples and writes out of his daily experiences with the authority of a master, so that his books are both learned and practical, instructive as well as deeply moving. To read A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami's books is to understand that here is one who knows the Absolute Truth, one who can teach It perfectly.

Jacket painting/Jadurani

Photo/Gurudas

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness
61 Second Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10003

---------------

OTHER BOOKS BY A. C. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI


Bhagavad Gita As It Is
Srimad Bhagwatam
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Ishopanishad
Brahma Samhita
Nectar of Devotion
Back to Godhead Magazine
(Editor)

-----------------------------


TEACHINGS

of
LORD CHAITANYA

A TREATISE ON FACTUAL SPIRITUAL LIFE


BY
A.C. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI
Acharya: International Society for Krishna Consciousness


Published by:
International Society for Krishna Consciousness

Branches Throughout the World

Headquarters: 61 Second Avenue
New York City, N.Y. 10003
U.S.A.

---------------------


Copyright © 1968 International Society for Krishna Consciousness Inc. (ISKCON)
Library of Congress Catalogue Card Number: 68-29320
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
FIRST EDITION


The Prologue is reprinted from
Chaitanya—His Life and Precepts
by Srila Thakur Bhaktivinode
Calcutta, India (1895)


Readers interested in the subject matter of this
book are invited by the International Society for
Krishna Consciousness to correspond with its Secretary.


12/14 Point Bembo Typeface
Printed by Dai Nippon Printing Co., Ltd.
Tokyo, Japan

TLC-1968 The Publishers

The Publishers


Namah om vishnu padaya krishna presthaya bhutale
Srimate bhaktivedanta swamin iti namine


We offer our respectful obeisances to Bhaktivedanta Swami
Who is so dear unto Krishna on this earth due to His
taking shelter unto the Lord's Lotus Feet.


We prostrate ourselves at the Lotus Feet of our Beloved Spiritual Master and offer this treasured book to His Divine Grace on our bowed heads. We came to Him looking for broken pieces of glass, and He has bestowed upon us a priceless gem. He has opened our eyes, which were blinded by the darkness of atheism, mental speculation, and sense gratification, to the glorious light of Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. His transcendental words are seeds which in our hearts have bloomed into the perfection of human life—the discovery that God lives and that we can live with Him—Krishna Consciousness.


The Publishers

TLC-1968 DEDICATION

DEDICATION

DEDICATED TO
The Sacred Service
of
SRILA SACHCHIDANANDA BHAKTIVINODE THAKUR

Who Initiated The Teachings of Lord Chaitanya
in
The Western World
(McGill University, Canada)
in 1896
The Year Of My Birth


A. C. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI

TLC-1968 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

My thankful acknowledgement is due to Sriman Brahmananda Brahmachary (Mr. Bruce Scharf), Sriman Gargamuni Brahmachary (Mr. Gregory Scharf) and Sriman Satyabrata Brahmachary (Mr. Stanley Moskowitz) for their financial help for this publication, and I beg to thank Sriman Rayarama Brahmachary (Mr. Raymond Marais), Sriman Satsvarupa Brahmachary (Mr. Stephen Guarino) and Sriman Madhusudan Brahmachary (Mr. Michael Blumert) for editing and typing the manuscript, and Sriman Goursundar Das Adhikary (Mr. Gary McElroy) and his good wife, Srimati Govinda Dasi (Mrs. Bonnie McElroy) who are always engaged to see to my personal comforts and I am so much obliged to them for their drawing all the nice pictures contained in this great publication.

All glories to the devotees engaged in the matter of Krishna Consciousness. I am sure that Lord Sri Krishna Chaitanya Mahaprabhu will bestow His Causeless Mercy upon everyone who is engaged in pushing the cause of Krishna Consciousness.
A.C.B

TLC-1968 The Author

The Author

A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami was born Abhay Charan De on September 1, 1896 in Calcutta. In 1920 he finished his education, majoring in philosophy, English, and economics, at the University of Calcutta. Because of his involvement in Gandhi's national non-cooperation movement, however, he rejected any formal diploma. Soon afterward Abhay Charan De took up the duties of manager of a large chemical concern. Then, in 1922, he met His Divine Grace Sri Srimad Bhakti Siddhanta Saraswati Goswami Maharaj, the founder of 64 Goudiya Vaishnava Maths in India, Berlin, and London. His Divine Grace liked this educated young man and injected in him the idea of preaching Lord Chaitanya's message all over the world.

At Allahabad in 1933, Abhay Charan De was formally initiated, and in 1936, just days before His Divine Grace's departure from this mortal world, he was specifically ordered to spread Krishna Consciousness in the English language and to the West.

Thus, Back To Godhead magazine was started in 1944 with Abhay Charan De serving as editor-in-chief Back To Godhead is now being published monthly in America by his American disciples.

The Goudiya Vaishnava Society recognised him as BHAKTIVEDANTA in 1947. In 1954 he became Vanaprastha, retired from family life. In 1959 he took Sannyasa, the renounced order of spiritual life and is now known as A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami.

In September 1965, at the advanced age of 70, A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami arrived in New York City to fulfil his master's sacred mission. Immediately, young Americans were attracted to him, and in July 1966, the International Society for Krishna Consciousness was formally incorporated.

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami is the author of the remarkable Bhagavad-Gita As It Is, published in 1968 by the Macmillan Company. Presently he is working on his masterpiece, a projected 60 volume work of translation and elaborate commentary of the Srimad Bhagwatam, three volumes of which have already been published. He has also recorded a unique 33 1/3 r.p.m. record album of the mystical mantra HARE KRISHNA, entitled "Krishna Consciousness," which has met with extraordinary popularity in India and America.

TLC-1968 Preface

Preface

There is no difference between the teachings of Lord Chaitanya presented here and the teachings of Lord Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita. The teaching of Lord Chaitanya is a practical demonstration of the teaching of Lord Krishna. In the Bhagavad Gita the last word of the Lord is that everyone should surrender unto Him, Lord Krishna, and that He will take immediate charge of such a surrendered soul. The Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is already in charge of the maintenance of this Creation by His plenary expansion as Kshirodakashayee Vishnu. But such maintenance by the Lord is not specific. When, therefore, the Lord takes charge, it means that He takes particular charge of a pure devotee. A pure devotee is a soul ever surrendered to the Lord, like a child to his parents or an animal to its master. This surrendering process is manifested in six different stages, namely: ( 1) to accept things favorable for discharging devotional service, (2) to reject things unfavorable for discharging devotional service, (3) to believe firmly that the Lord will protect His devotee always, (4) to feel exclusively dependent on the Mercy of the Lord, (5) to have no separate interest besides the interest of the Lord, and (6) always to feel oneself meek and humble.

Therefore Lord Krishna demanded that one should surrender unto Him through the above-mentioned six phases of the surrendering process; but the less intelligent class of men and so-called scholars of the world misunderstood these demands of the Lord, and thus misguided the general mass of people to reject them. In the Bhagavad Gita, at the end of the Ninth Chapter, the Lord directly orders one to always think of Him, become His devotee, worship Him only, offer obeisances unto Him only—and by doing so one is sure to come to Him in His Transcendental Abode. But so-called scholarly demons misguide the mass of people, directing them not to surrender like that to the Personality of Godhead, but rather to the impersonal, non-manifested, eternal, unborn Truth. The Mayavadi, impersonalist, philosophers do not accept that the last word in the matter of understanding the Absolute Truth is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. If one desires to understand the Sun as he is, one faces first of all the sunshine, and then the Sun globe, and at last if one is able to enter into that globe, there is the possibility of seeing face-to-face the predominating Deity of the Sun. The Mayavadi philosophers, due to a poor fund of knowledge, cannot go beyond the Brahman effulgence which is like the sunshine. The Upanishads confirm that one has to penetrate the dazzling effulgence of Brahman, and then one can see the real Face of the Personality of Godhead.

Lord Chaitanya therefore teaches us directly that one has to worship Lord Krishna, Who appeared as the foster Child of the King of Braja. He also recommends that the place known as Vrindaban is as good as Lord Krishna because, Lord Krishna being the Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, there is no difference between His Name, Quality, Form, Pastimes, Entourage, and Paraphernalia.

Lord Chaitanya also recommended that the mode of worshipping the Lord in the highest perfectional stage is the method of worship conceived by the Damsels of Braja. The Damsels of Braja, the Gopis, simply loved Krishna without any motive for material or spiritual gain. He also recommended that Srimad Bhagwatam is the spotless narration of transcendental knowledge and that the highest gain in the human form of life is to develop unalloyed love of Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Lord Chaitanya's teachings are identical to those given by Lord Kapila, the original propounder of Samkhya Yoga, the Samkhya system of philosophy. This authorized system of Yoga is practiced on the principle of meditation on the Transcendental Form of the Lord. There is no meditating on something Void or impersonal involved. When one is practiced to meditate upon the Transcendental Form of Lord Vishnu, even without the sitting posture in a particular place and atmosphere, the stage is called perfect Samadhi. This perfect Samadhi of Samkhya Yoga is confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita at the end of the Sixth Chapter, where the Lord says that of of all the yogis, one who constantly thinks of the Lord within the core of his heart with love and devotion is the greatest.

Lord Chaitanya instructed this Samkhya Yoga, or system of philosophy—called Achintya Bhedabheda Tattwa (simultaneously one and different)—most practically for everyone among the mass of people, simply by chanting the Holy Name of the Lord. He says that the Holy Name of the Lord is the Sound Vibration Form of the Lord. The Lord being the Absolute Whole, there is no difference between His Holy Name and His Transcendental Form. Therefore, by chanting the Holy Name of the Lord, one can directly associate with the Supreme Lord by Sound Vibration. This Sound Vibration of the Lord has three stages of development, namely: (1) offensive stage, (2) clearing stage, and (3) transcendental stage. In the offensive stage one may desire all kinds of material happiness or distress as one acts, but in the second stage of chanting, one becomes cleared from all material contamination. But when one is situated on the transcendental stage, one achieves the most covetable perfection, the stage of loving God. Lord Chaitanya recommended that this is the highest stage of perfection for the human being.

Yoga practice is essentially meant for controlling the senses. Mind is the central controlling factor of all senses; and therefore one has to practice first controlling the mind by engaging the mind in the matter of Krishna Consciousness. The gross activities of the mind are expressed through the external senses, either for acquiring knowledge or functioning under the will, and the subtle activities of the mind are thinking, feeling, and willing, according to the different attitudes of consciousness. This consciousness is either polluted or clear. If the mind is fixed up in Krishna (His Name, Quality, Form, Pastimes, Entourage, and Paraphernalia), then the whole of the activities, subtle and gross, is changed favorably. The Bhagavad Gita's process of purifying consciousness is to fix the mind on Krishna—to talk of His Transcendental Activities, to cleanse the Temple of the Lord, to walk to the Temple of the Lord, to see the Beautiful Transcendental Form of the Lord nicely decorated, to hear His Transcendental Glories, to taste foodstuffs offered to the Lord, to smell the flowers and Tulsi leaves offered to the Lord, to associate with the Lord's devotees, to engage oneself in the activities for the interest of the Lord, and to become angry also at those who are envious of the devotees. No one can stop the activities of the mind or the senses, but one can purify such activities by changing the account. This change of account is recommended in the Bhagavad Gita (Chapter II/39). A human being is sometimes restricted in the matter of sense-gratification under certain circumstances of disease, etc. But that prescription or regulative principle is for the less intelligent class of men. Such less intelligent men, without knowing the actual process of controlling the mind and senses, either want to stop them by force, or to give them up or to be carried away by the waves of sense-gratification.

The eight formulas of practicing Yoga—regulative principles, following the rules, practicing the different sitting postures, breathing exercise, and thus to withdraw the senses from the sense objects, etc.—are meant for the persons who are too engrossed in the bodily concept of life. But the intelligent man who is situated in Krishna Consciousness, does not forcibly stop his senses from acting on behalf of Krishna.

You cannot stop a child from his playful activities and leave him inactive, but you can stop him by engaging him in superior activities. Similarly, the forceful restraint of the sense activities, by following the eight principles of Yoga practice, is recommended for an inferior class of men; but the superior class of men, being engaged in the better activities of Krishna Consciousness, naturally retire from the inferior activities of material existence.

Lord Chaitanya in this way teaches us the science of Krishna Consciousness, which is absolute. Dry mental speculators try to restrain themselves from material attachment, but it is generally found that the mind, being too strong to be controlled, sometimes drags such speculators down in the matter of sensual activities; but there is no such chance for persons in Krishna Consciousness. Therefore, one has to engage one's mind and senses in Krishna conscious activities, and how this is practically possible is taught by the Lord, Sri Krishna Chaitanya.

Before His acceptance of the Sannyas, or renounced order of life, Lord Chaitanya was known as Viswambhar. Viswambhar means the one who maintains the whole Universe as leader of all living entities. The very same maintainer and leader of all living entities appeared as Lord Sri Krishna Chaitanya to give us the sublime teachings of life, and was the ideal Teacher of the prime necessities of life. He is the most munificent Giver of the love of Krishna. He is the complete Reservoir of all mercies and auspiciousness. Although He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna, as is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Bhagavad Gita, Mahabharata and Upanishads, He appeared as worshipable by everyone in this age of disagreement. Everyone can join in His Samkirtan movement without any previous qualification, and everyone can become the most perfect human being by following His teachings. If anyone is fortunate enough to be attracted by all His Features of manifestation, one is sure to be successful in the mission of one's life. In one word, those who are interested in being situated in spiritual existence can get easily relieved from the clutches of Maya by the Grace of Lord Chaitanya, now presented in the book form of Teachings of Lord Chaitanya, non-different from the Lord.

The conditioned soul, being engrossed in the material body, increases the pages of history of all kinds of material activities. But the Teachings of Lord Chaitanya can help the human society to stop such unnecessary and temporary activities, and can elevate one to the topmost platform of spiritual activities, which begin after liberation from material bondage. Such liberated activities in Krishna Consciousness are the goal of human perfection. The false prestige of acquiring lordship over the material Nature is illusion only, and one can get illuminating knowledge from the Teachings of Lord Chaitanya, in order to advance in one's spiritual existence.

One has to suffer or enjoy the fruits of one's activity, and nobody can check the laws of material Nature which govern such things. So long as one is engaged in such activities, one is sure to be baffled in attempting to achieve the ultimate goal of life. I hope therefore most sincerely that by understanding the Teachings of Lord Chaitanya human society will have a new light of spiritual life, opening the field of activities of the pure soul.

Om Tat Sat

A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

14 March, 1968

(Birthday of Lord Chaitanya)

Sri Sri Radha Krishna Temple

New York, N.Y.

TLC-1968 Prologue

Prologue

THE LIFE OF CHAITANYA MAHAPRABHU

by
Srila Thakur Bhaktivinoda

Chaitanya Mahaprabhu was born in Mayapur in the town of Nadia, just after sunset on the evening of the 23rd Falgoon 1407 Sakabda, answering to the 18th February 1486 of the Christian Era. The moon was eclipsed at the time of His birth, and the people of Nadia were then engaged, as is usual on such occasions, in bathing in the Bhagirathi with loud cheers of Haribol. His father, Jagannath Misra, was a poor Brahmin of the Vaidic order, and His mother, Sachi Devi, was a model good woman, both descended from Brahmin stocks originally residing in Sylhet. Mahaprabhu was a beautiful child and the ladies of the town came to see Him with presents. His mother's father, Pandit Nilambar Chakravarti, a renowned astrologer, foretold that the Child would be a great personage in time; and he, therefore, gave Him the name Vishwambhar. The ladies of the neighbourhood styled Him Gour Hari on account of His golden complexion, and His mother called Him Nimai on account of the Nim tree near which He was born. Beautiful as the Lad was, everyone heartily loved to see Him every day. As He grew up He became a whimsical and frolicsome Lad. After His fifth year, He was admitted into a school where He picked up Bengali in a very short time.

Most of His contemporary biographers have mentioned certain anecdotes regarding Chaitanya which are simply records of His early miracles. It is said that when He was an infant in His mother's arms, He wept continually, and when the neighbouring ladies and His mother cried Haribol! He used to stop. Thus there was a continuation of the utterance of Haribol in the house, foreshowing the future mission of the Hero. It has also been stated that when His mother once gave Him sweetmeats to eat, He ate clay instead of the food. His mother asking for the reason, He stated that as every sweetmeat was nothing but clay transformed, He could eat clay as well. His mother, who was the consort of a pandit, explained that every article in a special state was adapted to a special use. Earth, while in the state of a jug, could be used as a water pot, but in the state of a brick such a use was not possible. Clay, therefore, in the form of sweetmeats was usable as food and not clay in its other states. The Lad was convinced and admitted His stupidity in eating clay, and agreed to avoid the mistake in future.

Another miraculous act has been related. It is said that a Brahmin on pilgrimage became a guest in His house, and cooked his food and read his grace with meditation on Krishna. In the meantime, the Lad came and ate up the cooked rice. The Brahmin, astonished at the Lad's act, cooked again at the request of Jagannath Misra. The Lad again ate up the cooked rice while the Brahmin was offering the rice to Krishna with meditation. The Brahmin was persuaded to cook for a third time. This time all the inmates of the house had fallen asleep, and the Lad showed Himself as Krishna to the traveller, and blessed him. The Brahmin was then lost in ecstasy at the appearance of the Object of his worship.

It has also been stated that two thieves stole away the Lad from His father's door with a view to purloin His jewels and gave Him sweetmeats on the way. The Lad exercised His illusory energy and deceived the thieves back towards His own house. The thieves, for fear of detection, left the Boy there and fled.

Another miraculous act has been described of the Lad's demanding and getting from Hiranya and Jagadisha all the offerings they had collected for worshipping Krishna on the day of Ekadashi. When only four years of age He sat on rejected cooking pots which were considered unholy by His mother. He explained to His mother that there was no question of holiness and unholiness as regards earthen pots thrown away after the cooking was over. These anecdotes relate to the tender age up to the fifth year.

In His eighth year, He was admitted into the tol of Gangadas Pandit in Ganganagar close by the village of Mayapur. In two years He became well read in Sanskrit Grammar and Rhetoric. His readings after that were of the nature of self-study in His own house, where He had found all-important books belonging to His father, who was a pandit himself. It appears that He read the Smriti in His own study and the Nyaya also, in competition with His friends who were then studying under the celebrated Pandit Raghunath Shiromani.

Now, after the tenth year of His age, Chaitanya became a passable scholar in Grammar, Rhetoric, the Smriti and the Nyaya. It was after this that His elder brother Vishwarup left his house and accepted the asram (status) of a sanyasi (ascetic). Chaitanya, though a very young Boy, consoled His parents, saying that He would serve them with a view to please God. Just after that, His father left this world. His mother was exceedingly sorry, and Mahaprabhu, with His usually contented appearance, consoled his widowed mother.

It was at the age of 14 or 15 that Mahaprabhu was married to Lakshmi Devi, the daughter of Ballabha Acharya, also of Nadia. He was at this age considered one of the best scholars of Nadia, the renowned seat of Nyaya philosophy and Sanskrit learning. Not to speak of the smarta pandits, the naiyaiks were all afraid of confronting Him in literary discussions. Being a married man, He went to Eastern Bengal on the banks of the Padma for acquirement of wealth. There He displayed His learning and obtained a good sum of money.

It was at this time that He preached Vaishnavism at intervals. After teaching him the principles of Vaishnavism, He ordered Tapan Misra to go and live in Benares. During His residence in East Bengal, His wife Lakshmi Devi left this world from the effects of snake-bite. On returning home, He found His mother in a mourning state. He consoled her with a lecture on the uncertainty of human affairs. It was at His mother's request that He married Vishnupriya, the daughter of Raj pandit Sanatan Misra. His comrades joined Him on His return from pravas, or sojourn.

He was now so renowned that He was considered to be the best pandit in Nadia. Keshab Misra of Kashmere, who had called himself the Great Digvijayi, came to Nadia with a view to discuss with the pandits of that place. Afraid of the so-called conquering pandit, the tol professors of Nadia left their town on pretence of invitation, and Keshab met Mahaprabhu at the Barokonaghat in Mayapur and, after a very short discussion with Him, he got defeated by the Boy and mortification obliged him to decamp. Nimai Pandit was now the most important pandit of His times.

It was at the age of 16 or 17 that He travelled to Gaya with a host of His students, and there took His spiritual initiation from Iswara Puri, a Vaishnava sanyasi and a disciple of the renowned Madhavendra Puri. Upon His return to Nadia, Nimai Pandit turned religious preacher, and His religious nature became so strongly represented that Advaita Prabhu, Srivasa and others, who had before the birth of Chaitanya already accepted the Vaishnava faith, were astonished at the change in the young Man. He was then no more a contending naiyaika, a wrangling smarta and a criticizing rhetorician. He swooned at the Name of Krishna, and behaved as an inspired man under the influence of His religious sentiment. It has been described by Murari Gupta, an eyewitness, that He showed His heavenly powers in the house of Srivasa Pandit in the presence of hundreds of His followers, who were mostly well-read scholars.

It was at this time that He opened a nocturnal school of kirtan in the compound of Srivasa Pandit with His sincere followers. There He preached, there He sang, there He danced, and there He expressed all sorts of religious feelings. Nityananda Prabhu, who was then a preacher of Vaishnavism, and who had then completed his travels all over India, joined Him by that time. In fact a host of pandit preachers of Vaishnavism, all sincere at heart, came and joined Him from different parts of Bengal. Nadia now became the regular seat of a host of Vaishnava acharyas, saintly teachers, whose mission it was to spiritualize Mankind with the highest influence of the Vaishnava, devotional, creed.

The first mandate that He issued to Prabhu Nityananda and Haridas, His close associates, was this: "Go, friends, go through the streets of the town, meet every man at his door and ask him to sing the Name of Hari with a holy life, and you then come and report to Me every evening the result of your preaching." Thus ordered, the two preachers went on and met Jagai and Madhai, the two most abominable characters. They insulted the preachers on hearing Mahaprabhu's mandate, but were soon converted by the influence of bhakti, inculcated by their Lord.

The people of Nadia were now surprised. They said, "Nimai Pandit is not only a gigantic genius, but He is certainly a missionary from God Almighty." From this time to His 23rd year, Mahaprabhu preached His principles not only in Nadia but in all important towns and villages around His city. In the houses of His followers He showed miracles, taught the esoteric principles of bhakti, and sang His samkirtan with other bhaktas, or devotees. His followers of the town of Nadia commenced to sing the Holy Name of Hari in the streets and bazaars. This created a sensation and roused different feelings in different quarters. The bhaktas were highly pleased. The smarta, caste-conscious Brahmins, became jealous of Nimai Pandit's success, and complained to Chand Kazi against the character of Chaitanya as un-Hindu. The Kazi came to Srivas Pandit's house and broke a mridanga (drum used in samkirtan) there, and declared that unless Nimai Pandit ceased to make noise about His queer religion, he should be obliged to enforce Mohamedanism on Him and His followers.

This was brought to Mahaprabhu's notice. He ordered the town-people to appear in the evening, each with a torch in his hand. This they did, and Nimai marched out with His samkirtan divided into 14 groups, and on His arrival at the Kazi's house, He held a long conversation with the Kazi, and in the end communicated into his heart His Vaishnava influence by touching his body. The Kazi then wept and admitted that he had felt a keen spiritual influence which had cleared up his doubts and produced in him a religious sentiment which gave him the highest ecstasy. The Kazi then joined the samkirtan party. The world was astonished at the spiritual power of the Great Lord, and hundreds and hundreds of heretics converted, joining the banner of Vishwambhar after this affair.

It was after this that some of the jealous and low-minded Brahmins of Kulia picked a quarrel with Mahaprabhu and collected a party to oppose Him. Nimai Pandit was naturally a soft-hearted Person, though strong in His principles. He declared that party feeling and sectarianism were the two great enemies of progress, and as long as He should continue to be an inhabitant of Nadia, belonging to a certain family, His mission would not meet with complete success. He then resolved to be a citizen of the world by cutting off His connection with a particular family, caste and creed; and, with this resolution, He embraced the position of a sanyasi at Kutwa, under the guidance of Keshab Bharati of that town, in the 24th year of His life. His mother and wife wept bitterly for His separation, but our Hero, though soft in heart, was a strong Person in principle. He left His little world in His house for the unlimited spiritual world of Krishna with Man in general.

After His sanyasa, He was induced to visit the house of Advaita prabhu in Santipur. Advaita managed to invite all His friends and admirers from Nadia and brought Sachi Devi to see her Son. Both pleasure and pain invaded her heart when she saw her Son in the attire of a sanyasi. As a sanyasi Krishna Chaitanya put up nothing but a kaupin and a bahirbas (outer covering). His head was without hair and His hands bore a danda (stick) and a kamandalu (hermit's water pot).

The holy Son fell at the feet of His beloved mother and said, "Mother! this Body is yours and I must obey your orders. Permit Me to go to Vrindaban for My spiritual attainments." The mother, in consultation with Advaita and others, asked her Son to reside in Puri, the town of Lord Jagannath, so that she might obtain His information now and then. Mahaprabhu agreed to that proposition, and in a few days left Santipur for Orissa.

His' biographers have described the journey of Krishna Chaitanya (that was the name He got after His sanyasa) from Santipur to Puri in great detail. He travelled along the side of the Bhagirathi as far as Chhatrabhog, situated now in Thana Mathurapur, Diamond Harbour 24 Pergs. There He took a boat and went as far as Pryag Ghat in the Midnapur District. Thence He walked through Balasore and Cuttack to Puri, seeing the temple of Bhubaneswar on His way. Upon His arrival at Puri, He saw Jagannath in the temple, and put up with Sarvabhauma at the request of the latter.

Sarvabhauma was a gigantic pandit of the day. His readings knew no bounds. He was the best Naiyaik of the times, and was known as the most erudite scholar in the Vedanta Philosophy of the school of Shankaracharya. He was born in Nadia (Vidyanagar) and taught innumerable pupils in the Nyaya Philosophy in his tol there. He had left for Puri sometime before the birth of Nimai Pandit. His brother-in-law, Gopinath Misra, introduced our new Sanyasi to Sarvabhauma, who was astonished at His personal beauty, and feared that it would be difficult for the young Man to maintain sanyas-dharma during the long run of His life. Gopinath, who had known Mahaprabhu from Nadia, had a great reverence for Him and gave out that the Sanyasi was not a common human being. On this point Gopinath and Sarvabhauma had a hot discussion. Sarvabhauma then requested Mahaprabhu to hear his recitation of the Vedanta Sutras, to which the latter tacitly submitted.

Chaitanya heard with silence what the great Sarvabhauma uttered with gravity, for seven days, at the end of which the latter said, "Krishna Chaitanya! I think You do not understand the Vedanta, as You do not say anything after hearing my recitation and explanations."

The reply of Chaitanya was that He understood the sutras very well, but He could not make out what Shankaracharya meant by his commentaries.

Astonished at this, Sarvabhauma said, "How is it that You understand the meanings of the sutras and do not understand the commentaries which explain the sutras? All well! If You understand the sutras, please let me have Your interpretations!"

Mahaprabhu thereupon explained all the sutras in His own way, without touching the pantheistic commentary of Shankara. The keen understanding of Sarvabhauma saw the truth, beauty and harmony of arguments in the explanations given by Chaitanya, and obliged him to utter that it was the first time that he had found one who could explain the Brahma Sutras in such a simple manner. He admitted also that the commentaries of Shankara never gave such natural explanations of the Vedanta Sutras as he had obtained from Mahaprabhu. He then submitted himself as an advocate and follower. In a few days Sarvabhauma turned out as one of the best Vaishnavas of the time. Report ran out, and the whole of Orissa sang the praise of Krishna Chaitanya. and hundreds and hundreds came to Him and became His followers. In the meantime, Mahaprabhu thought of visiting Southern India, and He started with one Krishnadas Brahmin for the journey.

His biographers have given us a detail of the journey. He first went to Kurmakshetra, where He did a miracle by curing a leper named Vasudev. He met Ramananda Rai, the governor of Vidyanagar on the banks of the Godavari, and had a philosophical conversation with him on the subject of Prembhakti, loving devotion. He worked another miracle by touching (making them immediately disappear) the seven Tal trees, through which Ramchandra, the son of Dasarath, had shot His arrow and killed the great Bali Raj. He preached Vaishnavism and nam-samkirtan, chanting of the Holy Names of God, throughout the journey. At Rangakshetra He stayed for four months in the house of one Venkata Bhatta in order to spend the rainy season. There He converted the whole family of Venkata from Ramanuji Vaishnavism into Krishna bhakta, along with the son of Venkata, a boy of ten years named Gopal, who afterwards came to Vrindaban and became one of the six Gosvamins or Prophets serving under their leader Sri Krishna Chaitanya. Trained up in Sanskrit by his uncle Probodhananda Saraswati, Gopal wrote several books on Vaishnavism.

Chaitanya visited numerous places in Southern India as far as Cape Comorin and returned to Puri in two years by Panderpur on the Bhima. In this latter place He spiritualized one Tukaram, who became from that time a religious preacher himself. This fact has been admitted in his abhangas, which have been collected in a volume by Mr. Satyendra Nath Tagore of the Bombay Civil Service. During His journey He had discussions with the Buddhists, the Jains and the Mayavadis in several places, and converted His opponents to Vaishnavism, the worship of God as a Person.

Upon His return to Puri, Raja Prataprudra Dev and several pandit Brahmins joined the banners of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. He was now twenty-seven years of age. In His 28th year He went to Bengal as far as Gaud in Maldah. There He picked up two great personages named Rupa and Sanatan. Though descended from the lines of the Karnatic Brahmins, these two brothers turned out demi-Moslems by their continual contact with Hossain Shah, the then-Emperor of Gaud. Their names had been changed by the Emperor into Dabirkhash and Saker Mallik, and their master loved them heartily as they were both learned in Persian, Arabic and Sanskrit, and were loyal servants of the state. The two gentlemen had found no way to come back as regular Hindus, and had written to Mahaprabhu while He was at Puri, for spiritual help. Mahaprabhu had written in reply that He would come to them and extricate them out of their spiritual difficulties. Now that He had come to Gaud both the brothers appeared before Him with their longstanding prayer. Mahaprabhu ordered them to go to Vrindaban and meet Him there.

Chaitanya returned to Puri through Santipur, where He again met His dear mother. After a short stay at Puri He left for Vrindaban. This time He was accompanied by one Balabhadra Bhattacharya. He visited Vrindaban and came down to Prayag (Allahabad), converting a large number of Mohamedans to Vaishnavism by argument from the Koran. The descendants of those converts are still known as Pathan Vaishnavas. Rupa Goswami met Him at Allahabad, and Chaitanya trained him up in spirituality in ten days, and directed him to go to Vrindaban on missions. His first mission was to write theological works explaining scientifically pure bhakti and prema, devotional service, and love of Godhead. The second mission was to revive the places where Krishna Chandra had in the end of Dvapara Yuga, the previous Age, exhibited His lila, or Pastimes, for the benefit of the religious world. Rupa Goswami left Allahabad for Vrindaban, and Mahaprabhu came down to Benares. There He put up in the house of Chandrasekhar, and accepted His daily bhiksha (meal) in the house of Tapan Misra. Here it was that Sanatan Goswami joined Him, and took instruction for two months in spiritual matters.

The biographers, especially Krishnadas Kaviraj, have given us details of Chaitanya's teachings to Rupa and Sanatan. Krishnadas was not a contemporary writer, but he gathered his information from the Goswamins themselves, the direct disciples of Mahaprabhu. Jiva Goswami, who was the nephew of Sanatan and Rupa, and who has left us his invaluable work the Sad-sandarbha has philosophized on the precepts of his great leader. We have gathered and summarized the precepts of Chaitanya from the books of those great writers.

While at Benares, Chaitanya had an interview with the learned sanyasis of that town in the house of a Marhatta Brahmin, who had invited all the sanyasis for an entertainment. At this interview, Chaitanya showed a miracle which attracted all the sanyasis to Him. Then ensued reciprocal conversation. The sanyasis were headed by their most learned leader Prakasananda Saraswati. After a short controversy, they submitted to Mahaprabhu, and admitted that they had been misled by the commentaries of Shankaracharya. It was impossible even for learned scholars to oppose Chaitanya for a long time, as there was some spell in Him which touched their hearts and made them weep for their spiritual improvement. The sanyasis of Benares soon fell at the Feet of Chaitanya and asked for His grace (kripa). Chaitanya then preached pure bhakti, and instilled into their hearts spiritual love for Krishna which obliged them to give up sectarian feelings. The whole of Benares, on this wonderful conversion of the sanyasis, turned Vaishnava, and they made a master samkirtan with their new Lord.

After sending Sanatan to Vrindaban, Mahaprabhu went to Puri again by the jungles, with His comrade Balabhadra. Balabhadra reported that Mahaprabhu had shown a good many miracles on His way to Puri, such as making tigers and elephants dance, on hearing the name of Krishna.

From this time, that is, from His 31st year, Mahaprabhu continually lived in Puri in the house of Kasi Misra, until His disappearance in His forty-eighth year at the time of samkirtan in the temple of Tota Gopinath. During these 18 years, His life was one of settled love and piety. He was surrounded by numerous followers, all of whom were of the highest order of the Vaishnavas, and distinguished from the common people by their purest character and learning, firm religious principles and spiritual love of Radha Krishna.

Svarup-Damodar, who had been known by the name of Purushottamacharya while Mahaprabhu was in Nadia, joined Him from Benares and accepted His service as His secretary. No production of any poet or philosopher could be laid before Mahaprabhu unless Svarup had passed it as pure and useful. Rai Ramananda was his second mate. Both he and Svarup sang while Mahaprabhu expressed His sentiment on a certain point of worship. Paramananda Puri was His minister in matters of religion. There are hundreds of anecdotes described by His biographers which we do not think it meet here to reproduce. Mahaprabhu slept short. His sentiments carried him farther and farther in the firmament of spirituality every day and night, and all His admirers and followers watched Him throughout. He worshipped, communicated with his missionaries at Vrindaban, and conversed with those religious men who newly came to visit Him. He sang and danced, took no care of Himself and oft-times lost Himself in religious beatitude. All who came to Him believed Him as the All-beautiful God appearing in the netherworld for the benefit of Mankind. He loved His mother all along, and sent her Mahaprasad, spiritual foods, now and then with those who went to Nadia. He was most amiable in nature. Humility was personified in Him. His sweet appearance gave cheer to all who came in contact with Him. He appointed Prabhu Nityananda as the missionary in charge of Bengal. He despatched six disciples, the Goswamis, to Vrindaban to preach love in the upcountry. He punished all of His disciples who deviated from a holy life. This He markedly did in the case of junior Haridas. He never lacked in giving proper instructions in life to those who solicited them. This will be seen in His teachings to Raghunath Das Goswami. His treatment of Haridas (senior) shows how He loved spiritual men, and how He defied caste distinction in the cause of spiritual brotherhood.

TLC-1968 Mission

Lord Chaitanya's Mission

Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu instructed His disciples to write books on the Science of Krishna, a task which those who follow Him have continued to carry out down to the present day. The elaborations and expositions on the philosophy taught by Lord Chaitanya are in fact the most voluminous, exacting and consistent—due to the unbreakable system of disciplic succession—of any religious culture in the world. Yet Lord Chaitanya, in His youth widely renowned as a scholar, Himself left us only eight verses, called Sikshastak, in which His mission and precepts are revealed. Here, rendered by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, are these eight supremely valuable prayers:

1.

Glory to the Sri Krishna Samkirtan which cleanses the heart of all the dust accumulated for years together. Thus the fire of conditional life, of repeated birth and death, is extinguished. This Samkirtan movement is the prime benediction for humanity at large because it spreads the rays of the benediction Moon. It is the life of all transcendental knowledge, it increases the ocean of transcendental bliss, and it helps to have a taste of thefull nectar for which we are always anxious.

2.

O my Lord! Your Holy Name alone can render all benediction upon the living beings, and therefore You have hundreds and millions of Names, like Krishna, Govinda, etc. In these transcendental Names You have invested all Your transcendental energies, and there is no hard and fast rule for chanting these Holy Names. O my Lord! You have so kindly made approach to You easy by Your Holy Names, but, unfortunate as I am, I have no attraction for Them.

3.

One can chant the Holy Name of the Lord in a humble state of mind, thinking himself lower than the straw in the street, more tolerant than the tree, devoid of all sense of false prestige, and ready to offer all respects to others. In such a state of mind one can chant the Holy Name of the Lord constantly.

4.

O almighty Lord! I have no desire to accumulate wealth, nor I have any desire to enjoy beautiful women; neither do I want any number of followers of mine. What I want only is that I may have Your causeless devotional service in my life—birth after birth.

5.

O Son of Maharaj Nanda, I am Your eternal servitor, and although I am so, somehow or other I have fallen in the ocean of birth and death. Please, therefore, pick me up from this ocean of death, and fix me as one of the atoms of Your Lotus Feet.

6.

O my Lord! when shall my eyes be decorated with tears of love, flowing constantly while I chant Your Holy Name? When will my words be choked up when uttering the Holy Name? And when will all the holes of hair on my body have eruptions by the recitation of Your Name?

7.

O Govinda! Feeling Your separation I am considering a moment twelve years or more, and tears are flowing from my eyes like torrents of rain. I am feeling all vacant in the world, in the absence of You.

8.

I do not know anyone except Krishna as my Lord, and He shall always remain as such, even if He handles me roughly by His embrace; or He may make me brokenhearted by not being present before me. He is completely free to do anything and everything, but He is always my worshipful Lord, unconditionally.

TLC-1968 Intoduction

Introduction

Delivered as five morning lectures on the Chaitanya Charitamrita; the authoritative biography of Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, written by Krishna Das Kaviraj; before the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, New York City, April 10-14, 1967.

Chaitanya means the living force. You and I can move, but a table cannot because it has no living force. Not only movement, but resistance is also a sign of living force. Chaitanya means activities, Amrita means immortal, and Charitra means character. There is no activity without living force. The material condition has living force but is not Amrita, immortal. Chaitanya Charitamrita, then, means the Character of the Living Force in Immortality.

But how is this displayed? It is not displayed by you or I—none of us are immortal in these bodies. We have living force and activities, and we are immortal by nature and constitution. But the material condition into which we have been put doesn’t allow these qualities to be displayed. It is stated in the Katha Upanishad that eternality and living force are characteristic of both ourselves and God. But God and ourselves, although both immortal, are different. The living entities have many activities, but have a tendency to fall down. God has no such tendency. He is All-powerful. He never comes under the control of material Nature, because material Nature is only a display of His energy.

There is a nice example of this: When I was flying from San Francisco, the plane was above the cloud ocean. Above the cloud was the sun; and though we came down through the cloud and everything in New York was dim, still, above the cloud, the sun was shining. A cloud cannot cover the whole world—it can’t even cover the whole United States, which is not more than a speck in the universe. From the sky the skyscrapers are very tiny, just as from God’s position all this nonsense becomes insignificant. I, the living entity, am very insignificant, and my tendency is to come down; but God hasn’t got this tendency. The Supreme Lord doesn’t come down to Maya, and more than the sun comes under the cloud. But we have the tendency to be controlled by Maya. Mayavadis, impersonalist philosophers, say that because we are under the control of Maya in this world, when God comes, He is also put under the control of Maya. This is the fallacy of their philosophy.

Lord Chaitanya therefore is not one of us. He is Krishna Himself, the Supreme Living Entity. He doesn’t come under the cloud of Maya. Krishna and His expansions, or even His higher devotees, are never in the clutches of Maya. Lord Chaitanya came to preach Krishna Bhakti: Lord Krishna Himself is teaching us how to approach Krishna; just as the teacher, seeing a student not doing well, takes the pencil and says, “Do it like this, write like this: A, B, C.” But we must not mistakenly think that the teacher is learning the ABC’s. Teaching us how to become Krishna conscious is Lord Chaitanya’s position, and we must study Him in that light.

In Bhagavad Gita [18.66] the Lord says, “Give up all this nonsense and surrender to Me.” And we say “Oh—surrender? Give up? But I have so many responsibilities.” And Maya says to us, “Don’t do it, or you’ll be out of my clutches. Stay in my clutches, and I’ll kick you.” It’s true; you are being kicked by Maya. Do you know how Maya kicks? The she-ass kicks the male-ass in the face when he comes for sex. Among the cats, they fight and whine. These are the teachings of Nature. She tricks. It is like the capture of an elephant. He is caught in the forest by the use of a trained she-elephant, who leads him and makes him fall into a pit. Maya has many activities, and her shackle is the female. Of course, male and female means this outer dress—we are all actually Krishna’s servants. But we are shackled by iron chains which are beautiful women. Every male is bound up by sex life; and therefore sex life should be controlled. Unrestricted sex life puts you fully in the clutches of Maya. Lord Chaitanya got away from this Maya at the age of twenty-four—His wife was sixteen and his mother seventy, and He was the only male of the family; He was a Brahmin, and not rich—but He took Sannyasa, the renounced order, and didn’t care for the Maya of wife and mother.

If you want to become fully Krishna conscious, you have to give up the shackles of Maya. Or, if you remain with Maya, you should live in such a way that there is no illusion. Lord Chaitanya had many house-holders among His closest devotees. Yet one renounced devotee of His, Junior Haridas, who was important for being a good Kirtan singer, glanced lustfully at a young woman, and he was at once rejected by Lord Chaitanya: “You are living with Me in the renounced order, and yet looking at a woman with lust.” This Junior Haridas later committed suicide in despair over his separation from Chaitanya. Other devotees had approached Chaitanya and asked Him to forgive Junior Haridas, but Chaitanya replied, “You all go live with him and forgive him. I’ll stay alone.” And when the news of Junior Haridas’ suicide reached Him, Lord Chaitanya, Who was aware of everything that was happening, said, “Very good, that is very good.” A householder devotee of His pleased Chaitanya, and Chaitanya, on learning of the devotee’s wife being pregnant, asked that the baby be given a certain auspicious name. So He approved of householders, having sex in a regulated way; but He was strict—like a thunderbolt—with those of the renounced order who cheated by the method known as “drinking water underwater while taking a bath on a fast day.”

From Chaitanya Charitamrita we learn how Chaitanya has taught people to become immortal. Krishna and all reformers also taught this to people; They are mortified that people should prolong their mortal life, instead of arranging it so as to make the next life immortal.

So Chaitanya Charitamrita means the Immortal Character of the Living Force. The Supreme Living Force is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. There are innumerable living entities, all individual. This is very easy to understand: We are all different, in thought, in desires—and the Supreme Lord is also an individual Person, like you and me. But He is the Leader. No one can excel Him. Among us, one can excel another in one capacity or another. Similarly, the Lord is individual, but He is Supreme. Achyuta is another name for Krishna—The Infallible. In the Bhagavad Gita, Arjuna had a delusion, but Krishna had none. God is infalliable. In the Gita He states:

“I appear in My own internal potency.” [Bg. 4.6] He is not overpowered by the material potency when He is in the material world; Krishna and the incarnations are not under its control—They are free. In Srimad Bhagwatam this is the definition of godly nature—one is not affected although in material Nature. Even a devotee can attain this freedom. Rupa Goswami explains that, if you want to remain unattached to material contamination, the formula is to make your ambition to serve Krishna. How to serve? It is not done by simply meditating, which is just an activity of the mind, but by practical work. It is achieved by working for Krishna. No resource should be left unused; whatever is there, whatever you have, should be used for Krishna by practical work. We can use everything: airplanes, the atom bomb, anything. If you speak to an audience of Krishna Consciousness, that is also service. If your mind, senses, speech, money, and energy are engaged, then you are not in material Nature. Krishna and His expansions and His devotees are not in material Nature, but foolish persons think that They are.

Chaitanya Charitamrita means that the spirit soul is immortal, and that activities in the Spiritual World are also immortal. The Mayavadis, those who hold to the view that the Absolute is impersonal and formless, say that a realized soul has no more need to talk. The Vaishnava says, “No, talking begins at that stage. Our previous talk was nonsense and had no value; now let us begin real talk: talks of Krishna.”

The Mayavadis use the example of the water pot: when the pot is not filled with water, it makes a sound; but when the pot is filled it makes no sound. But am I a water pot? Can I be compared to a water pot? Logically, an analogy points out similarities, and the greatest number of similarities between the two objects makes the best analogy. A water pot is not an active living force. A pot can’t move. So ever-silent meditation is inadequate. Why? Because we have so much to say about Krishna that we don’t have time to finish when there are only twenty-four hours in a day. The fool, however, is celebrated as long as he doesn’t speak. When he breaks his silence his lack of knowledge is exposed. Chaitanya Charitamrita shows that there are so many things to discover, simply for glorifying the Supreme.

Krishna Das Kaviraj Goswami writes: “I offer my respects to my Spiritual Masters.” He uses the plural to express the disciplic succession. Not that my Spiritual Master only is offered obeisances, but the whole Parampara, the chain of disciplic succession. The Guru is addressed in the plural to show the highest respect. After offering respect to the disciplic succession, it is offered to devotees, other Godbrothers, the Spiritual Master, expansions of Godhead, and His first manifestation of energy. Krishna Chaitanya appears in all together: God, Guru, devotee, expansion. As His associate Nityananda, He is a manifestation; as Adwaita, He is an incarnation; as Gadadhar, He is the internal potency; and as Srivas, He is the marginal living entity. Krishna is not thought of alone, but is conceived all at once, as is described by Ramanujacharya: In Suddha Adwaita philosophy energy, expansion, and incarnation are Oneness in diversity. Everything together is God.

Chaitanya Charitamrita is thus the post-graduate study of spiritual knowledge. One advances from the Bhagavad Gita, through Srimad Bhagwatam, to Chaitanya Charitamrita. Although all are on the same Absolute level, yet by comparative study, Chaitanya Charitamrita is on this higher platform, and every verse is perfectly composed. The process of offering obeisances is to directly offer respects to Chaitanya and Nityananda—these two Personalities are compared to the Sun and the Moon, who dissipate darkness. Both the Sun and the Moon have risen together in this case: Chaitanya is so kind that to dissipate the darkness They both appear together.

Who is Krishna Chaitanya? In the Upanishads, the Supreme Absolute Truth is described in an impersonal way, but the Personal view is also given in the Isha Upanishad [15], at the end, after a description of the All-pervading: “My dear Lord, You are hidden by the Cover of Brahmajyoti. Let me penetrate that Brahmajyoti to approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead.” Those who have no such power stop at the effulgence; but at the end of the Upanishad there is a hymn to the Personality of Godhead. The impersonal Brahman is described there. That Brahman is the glaring effulgence of the body of Chaitanya. The Paramatma is the partial representation of Chaitanya. He is that Supreme Personality of Godhead, full with six opulences: wealth, fame, strength, beauty, knowledge, and renunciation. You should know that He is Krishna, and nothing is equal to, or greater than, Him. There is no superior conception. He is the Supreme Person.

There is a nice verse by Rupa Goswami, who, as a confidential devotee, was taught for more than ten days continuously by Lord Chaitanya. He has written about Lord Chaitanya: “There were many incarnations of Krishna, but He excels all others. He is giving something that was never given by an incarnation before, not even by Krishna Himself.” [Madhya 19.53]

Chaitanya begins from the surrendering point, and He is completely spiritual. He begins at the end of material existence, when one gives up all material attachment. In the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna began by distinguishing the soul from matter, and ended at the point of the soul surrendered in devotion. But there is no stoppage of talk there, as the Mayavadis would have it. The real talk only begins. As is stated in the Vedanta Sutra, “Now talking begins. Now we can inquire into the Supreme Absolute Truth.” Rupa Goswami writes: “Your incarnation is greater than all. What You have given! It is the highest form of devotional service.”

One who accepts the existence of God is in devotional service. To acknowledge, “God is great” is something—but not much. Chaitanya preached like an Acharya, a great teacher, up to the point of friendship. In the Gita, Krishna showed Arjuna His Universal Form because he was a dear friend; but Arjuna asked forgiveness for this friendship on seeing Krishna as the Lord of the Universes. Through Lord Chaitanya you can become a friend of Krishna, where there is no limit. You can become a friend, not in adoration, but in complete freedom. You can also be related to God as His father. This is Srimad Bhagwatam philosophy. There is no other literature in the world where God is treated as the devotee’s son. Usually He is the Father Who supplies the demands of the son. Chaitanya is the first to treat God as a son. How? By service. The son demands, and the father supplies. You don’t take the supply, you give. Krishna’s mother, Yasoda, said to the Lord: “Here—eat or You’ll die. Eat nicely.” Krishna will depend on your mercy. This is such a uniquely high level of friendship. And you can believe that you are His father.

And, above all, you can treat Krishna as your Lover, as if He’s so much attached to you that He expresses His inability to reciprocate. ‘1 cannot repay your love. I have no more assets to return.” Krishna was thus so obliged to the Gopis, that He felt His inability to return their love. Devotional service is such an excellent platform—and this was given by Chaitanya. It was never given by any previous incarnation or Acharya.

‘Devotional service itself is the highest platform—the glorious platform which You have contributed. You are Krishna, yellowish, Sachinandan, son of Sachi. Chaitanya Charitamrita hearers may keep You in their hearts. Then it will be easy to understand Krishna through Chaitanya.” Chaitanya came to deliver Krishna. Rupa Goswami writes: ‘You are the most charitable Personality. You are delivering Krishna Prema, unalloyed love for Krishna. And so I offer You my respects.”

We have heard the phrase, ‘Love of Godhead.” How far this love of Godhead can actually be developed we can learn from the Vaishnava philosophy. Simply theoretical knowledge of love of God you can find in many places and many Scriptures; but what that love of Godhead actually is, and how it is developed—that can be found in the Vaishnava literature. It is the unique and the highest development of love of God that is given by Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.

Now we have a little sense of love. Why? It is due to love of Godhead. Anything which we find within our experience, even in this conditional life, is situated in the Supreme Lord, Who is the ultimate Source of Everything. In our original relationship with the Supreme Lord there is real love. That love is reflected through material conditions, but reflected pervertedly, and not exactly. Real love means that which is continuous, and without a break, but because that love is reflected pervertedly in this material world, love lacks continuity and is inebriating. If we want real, transcendental love, then we have to transfer our love to the Supreme Lovable Object—Krishna the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is the whole basic principle of Krishna Consciousness.

In material consciousness we are trying to love that which is not at all lovable. We are giving our love to dogs, to cats—with the risk that if we love cats and dogs too much, at the time of our death we may be fixed in thinking of them, and therefore take our next birth in a family of cats or dogs. Everything without love of Krishna leads downward. In the Hindu Scripture, the chastity of woman is very much recommended. Why? Because if a woman becomes much addicted in love of her husband, at the time of death she will remember him, and in the next life she is promoted to a man’s body. Man’s life is better than woman’s, because a man has better facility for understanding spiritual science.

But Krishna Consciousness is so nice that it makes no distinction between man and woman. In the Bhagavad Gita [9.32] you will find: “If somebody, even if he is born in a low family, even a woman or a Sudra or a Vaishya—anyone who takes shelter of Me is sure to achieve My association.” That is guaranteed. And Krishna says that if these people can achieve the highest perfection of life, then why not the real Brahmins, devotees, and saintly kings? They are sure to achieve the highest perfection.

Chaitanya Mahaprabhu gave us information: First of all you must know that in every country or every Scripture there is some hint of love of Godhead, but nobody knows what love of Godhead actually is. That is the distinction between other Scriptures and the Vedic Scriptures. The others have some idea of love of God—but regarding how to love Godhead, and what is Godhead, they have no idea. They promote official love of Godhead. But here Chaitanya Mahaprabhu gives a practical demonstration of how to love God in a conjugal relationship. Chaitanya Mahaprabhu takes the part of Radharani and tries to love Krishna as Radharani loved Him. Krishna could not understand, “How does Radharani give Me such pleasure?” So in order to study Radharani, Krishna lived Her role and tried to understand Himself. This is the secret of Lord Chaitanya’s incarnation. That is explained in the next verse.

This verse says, “I offer my respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Lord, Who is absorbed in the modes of Radharani’s thought.” He is Krishna, but He has taken the mode of Radharani to show how to love Krishna. And what is Radha Krishna? Radha Krishna is the exchange of love. And what is that love? This is not ordinary love. Krishna has immense potencies, of which three are principal: internal, external, and marginal potency. In the internal potency there are three divisions: Sambit, Alahadini and Sandhini.

The Alahadini potency is the pleasure potency. We must always know that we also have this pleasure-seeking potency. We are all trying to have pleasure; this is the nature of the living entity. We are now trying to enjoy our pleasure potency in this material condition, with this body, by bodily contact. But do you think that Krishna, Who is always Spiritual, will also seek pleasure on this material plane? What nonsense this is! Krishna describes this place as non-permanent and full of miseries. Do you think Krishna is going to seek pleasure in this material form? How is it possible? He is the Supersoul, He is the Supreme Spirit; how can He seek pleasure in matter?

Therefore, to learn how Krishna’s pleasure can be obtained, you have to study the first Nine Cantos of Srimad Bhagwatam. In the Tenth Canto, Krishna’s pleasure potency is displayed as He plays with Radharani, and as He plays with the damsels of Vraja. Unfortunately, people of less intelligence turn at once to the pleasure potency sports of Krishna in the Dasama Skanda, the Tenth Canto. These pictures of Krishna embracing Radharani, or of the Rasa Dance, are unfortunately not understood by ordinary men, because they do not understand Krishna. They will falsely understand that Krishna is like us, and just as we want to embrace a young girl, so He embraces the Gopis. These people write books because they think that this is a kind of religion where we can indulge in sex and become religionists. This is called Prakrita Sahajia—materialistic lust.

One should understand what Radha Krishna is. Radha and Krishna display the pleasure potency of the internal energy of Krishna. That pleasure potency of Krishna’s internal energy is a most difficult subject matter, unless one understands what Krishna is. Krishna cannot see any pleasure in this material world. But He has got that pleasure potency. Because we are part and parcel of Krishna, therefore that pleasure potency is within us also. But we are trying to exhibit that pleasure potency in matter, while Krishna does not. The object of His pleasure potency is Radharani. That means Krishna exhibits His potency or His energy as Radharani, and then exchanges loving affairs with Her. Krishna cannot take pleasure in this external energy. This is very difficult to understand—but just try: Krishna exhibits His internal energy, His pleasure potency, as Radharani. That means that Krishna manifests Himself. As He has so many extensions, so many expansions, so many incarnations; so Radharani is the manifestation of His internal pleasure potency.

Radharani is also Krishna. There is no difference between the energy and the energetic. Without energy there is no meaning to energetic, and without the energetic there is no meaning to energy. Similarly, without Radha there is no meaning to Krishna, and without Krishna there is no meaning to Radha. Therefore the Vaishnava philosophy first of all worships the internal pleasure potency of the Supreme Lord. It is always said, “Radha Krishna.” Although the author is going to explain the intricacies of this pleasure potency, he first of all utters the name of Radha. Similarly, those who worship the Name of Narayan first of all utter the name of Lakshmi; those who are worshippers of Lord Rama first of all utter the name of Sita. Sita Rama, Radha Krishna, Lakshmi Narayan—the potency always first.

Radha and Krishna are One. When Krishna desires to enjoy pleasure He manifests Himself. The spiritual exchange of love affair is the display of the internal potency or pleasure potency of Krishna. We say “when” Krishna desires, although just when He did desire, we cannot say. But we speak in this way because in conditional life we take it that everything has some beginning. In the Absolute, or spiritual life, there is no beginning; there is no end. But in order to understand that Radha and Krishna are One, and that They become divided, that question “When?” automatically comes to be asked. When Krishna desired to enjoy His pleasure potency, He manifested Himself in the separate Form of Radharani. Again, when Krishna wanted to understand Himself through the agency of Radha, They became united—and that unification is called Lord Chaitanya.

Why has Krishna assumed that Form? That will be explained. “What is the glory of Radha’s love?” Krishna asks. “Why is She so much in love with Me? What is the special qualification in Me that Radharani is attracted to, and what is Radharani’s process of loving Me?” He is the Supreme—why should He be attracted by anyone’s love? He is full in Himself. We search after the love of a woman because we are imperfect. The love of woman, that potency, that pleasure, is absent in me, and therefore I want a woman. But Krishna is surprised: “Why am I attracted by Radharani? And what is the special significance in Me that Radharani is so much attached to? Now, when Radharani feels My love, what is Her feeling?” In order to taste the flavor or the quality, the essence of that loving affair, Krishna appeared as the Moon appears in the sea. Just as the Moon was produced by the churning of the sea, so by churning the spiritual love affairs, the Moon appeared as Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, whose complexion was just like the Moon. This is figurative language, but it is the purport of why Chaitanya Mahaprabhu has appeared. The full significance will be explained in later chapters.

The author of Chaitanya Charitamrita is describing the manifestation of the Supreme. After offering His respects to Lord Chaitanya, he next offers them to Nityananda. Who is Nityananda? He now explains. First of all, Nityananda is manifested as Samkarshan. Samkarshan is the origin of Maha Vishnu, a form of God. This first manifestation of Krishna is Valaram, and then Samkarshan; from Samkarshan to Pradyumna: in this way the expansion takes place. It works in the same way as one candle is the origin, and another candle is lit from that original and from that another and another—this is explained in Brahma Samhita: The Supreme Lord Govinda is the Original Candle, and from that Original Candle many thousands of candles, one after another, are expanded, and they are called Vishnu. Just as one candle after another makes a very nice exhibition of light, similarly, Krishna has expanded Himself into so many lights, and wp are also lights. We are smaller lights, while Vishnu is the bigger light. But they are all Krishna, all expansions.

That Vishnu, when there is a need of material creation, expands Himself as Maha Vishnu, Who lies down on the Causal Ocean. From His nostrils all the Universes are breathed out. From that Causal Ocean all the Universes have sprung up, and this Universe also is floating in that Causal Ocean. Outside is water. You have seen the picture of Vamanadev when He expanded His leg up to the covering of the sky of this Universe. There was a hole there, and through that hole Karana water leaked in; and a little drop is flowing as the river Ganges. Therefore the Ganges is accepted as the most sacred water of Vishnu, and is worshipped by all Hindus, from the Himalayas down to the Bay of Bengal. The Maha Vishnu, lying on the Causal Ocean, is a plenary expansion of Rama. This Rama, when we say HARE KRISHNA, HARE RAMA—this Rama means the Samkarshan, Nityananda.

The author of Chaitanya Charitamrita describes what is “beyond this material expansion.” The cosmic material expansion is called Maya because it has no eternal existence. It is sometimes manifested and sometimes not manifested. Therefore it is called Maya. Krishna Das now says, “beyond this manifestation.” In the Bhagavad Gita Eighth Chapter, it is explained that there is another Nature which is eternal, and which is beyond Bakta and Abakta. Bakta means manifested, and Abakta means unmanifested. This material world has a manifested aspect and a potential state, which is called non-manifested. Beyond both the potential non-manifested stage and the manifested stage there is another, spiritual Nature. We can understand this superior Nature as the living force. That is described in the Bhagavad Gita. The living force is manifest in this body: this body is of the inferior Nature, matter. The superior Nature is the spirit that is moving the world. The symptom of that superior Nature is consciousness. Similarly, beyond this material Nature there is another, superior, Nature which is conscious. There everything is conscious. We cannot imagine that. Here the objects are not conscious. But in the Spiritual World the table is conscious, the land is conscious, the tree is conscious—everything is conscious.

Now, you cannot imagine how far this material manifestation is extended. You have no measurement. Everything is calculated by imagination or by some imperfect method. But here we are getting information of what lies beyond this. Those who believe in experimental knowledge may inquire how it is possible: We cannot calculate how far this Universe is extended, and we cannot reach even the nearest planet; so how is it that we can obtain information beyond this material Nature? That which is beyond your conceivable power is called Achintya, inconceivable. What is inconceivable, don’t argue about. It is useless. How can you? It is inconceivable.

That which is inconceivable to your limited energy, limited sense perception—how can you reach that plane by argumentative logic? Don’t argue. Then, how is it known? Accept it. The Bhagavad Gita [4.1] says: “It has to be understood by the disciplic succession.” Just as Brahma, the original creature, was given lessons by Krishna, Brahma imparted those lessons to his disciple Narada, and Narada imparted that knowledge to his disciple, Vyasdeva. Vyasdeva imparted that knowledge to his disciple, Madhvacharya; Madhvacharya on down to Madhavendra Puri, who imparted the same lesson to Ishwara Puri. And Ishwara Puri imparted the same lesson to Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.

People may ask that, if Chaitanya Mahaprabhu is Krishna Himself, then why did He need a Spiritual Master? Of course, He did not need any Spiritual Master, but just because He was playing Acharya (teaching how to behave in spiritual life), He accepted a Spiritual Master. Even Krishna accepted a Spiritual Master. That is the system. If you want to know that which is inconceivable, you must accept the disciplic succession. Because the knowledge is coming down from the Supreme, down, down, down—it is perfect. Suppose a hundred generations before, there was something confidential that your forefather told his son, which has finally been passed down to you. Although you are not in touch with the direct personality, yet because it is coming through disciplic succession, the same truth is expressed.

How was Brahma informed of this sort of knowledge? That is also stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam: The original learned scholar is Brahma; and Krishna, the Supreme Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, impressed transcendental knowledge into the heart of Brahma. By the heart. So two processes of knowledge exist: One process depends upon the Supreme Personality of Godhead as the Supersoul seated within you. He informs you. And He also expands Himself as the Spiritual Master. The Guru also informs you.

So in both ways, from within and from without, the information is transmitted. We simply have to receive it. If we receive knowledge in this way, it doesn’t matter that it is inconceivable. In the Bhagwatam, you will find much information about the Vaikuntha planetary systems, which are beyond the material Universe. Just as with Chaitanya Charitamrita, the knowledge is there, and you simply have to take it. But you have to receive it by the Parampara system. You cannot approach the Truth, which is inconceivable to your experimental knowledge. It is not possible. We want to know everything by experimental knowledge. That is foolishness. It is not possible. According to the Vedic way, sound is evidence. Sound is very important in Vedic understanding. Sound is evidence, if the sound is pure. In the material world, also, you understand things thousands of miles away simply by sound vibration. As soon as you call by telephone or radio, there is sound. In San Francisco, 3000 miles away, as soon as you receive the sound—“Mr. Such-and-Such speaking”—you understand. The evidence is sound. Where is the informant, is he standing there before you? No—but as soon as you hear the sound you know. Sound is the most authoritative evidence. These things are received by sound vibration.

We have the information that beyond this cosmic manifestation there are the very extensive Vaikunthas. This material manifestation is only one-fourth of the manifestation. There is not only this Universe, but there are innumerable Universes. Just as there are innumerable planets within this Universe, so this is only one Cosmos; there are innumerable Universes, and, all combined together they are one-fourth of the manifestation of the Creation. The other three-fourths of the manifestation is Vaikuntha Loka, the Spiritual World. In that Vaikuntha Loka every Narayan has His four expansions:. Samkarshan, Pradyumna, Aniruddha and Vasudeva. (That Samkarshan is Nityananda.) These Universes surround the body of the Supreme; and Vishnu is Master of this material Nature.

As the husband and wife combine together to create, so Maya is the wife and the Supreme Maha Vishnu is her Husband. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita [14.4]: “This expansive material Nature is My wife, and all the living entities are born of Me.” How is Vishnu contacting Maya? That contact is also described in the Bhagavad Gita: Simply by a glance: “He glanced over the material Nature and it became impregnated.” This is Spiritual. We must impregnate by a particular part of our body, but the Supreme Lord, Krishna or Vishnu, can impregnate any part by any part. Simply by glancing He can cause conception. The reason why is found in the Brahma Samhita: the spiritual body of the Supreme Lord is so powerful that any part can perform the duty of any other part. We can only touch with the hand, but Krishna can touch you by glancing. We can only see with the eyes, we cannot touch or smell with our eyes; but Krishna can smell and can also eat with His eyes.

When we offer Prasadam, foodstuffs, to Krishna, we don’t see that He is eating; but, simply by glancing at the food, He can eat. Simply by seeing. We have the idea, because we have this mouth, that unless we devour the whole thing, we cannot eat. But that everything is spiritual—that we cannot imagine. We see that we are offering to Krishna, and He is not eating. Is it by our imagination that He is accepting Prasadam? No, it is not like that. Actually, He is eating, but His eating is different from our eating. Our eating process will be similar to His when we are completely on the spiritual platform. There, every part of the body can act for the other parts of the body.

You have seen that picture where Brahma is born from the navel of Vishnu, Who is lying down. And Vishnu’s energy, Lakshmi, the Goddess of Fortune, is serving Him, sitting by the side of His leg. Vishnu does not require Lakshmi to give birth to Brahma. How then can you expect that there is sex life in the Spiritual World? Sex life here in this material world is required to produce children, but in the Spiritual World you can produce children, as many as you like, without any help from a wife. So there is no sex life there. Vishnu produces Brahma from His navel without the help of His wife. There are many such instances. This is the inconceivable spiritual energy. Because we do not experience spiritual energy, we think these are fictional stories. No. You think that way because you have no conception of spiritual energy: it is so powerful that it can do anything and everything. It has full independence.

From each pore of the body of Maha Vishnu these Universes emanate, seedlike, and then they develop. They are exhaled when He breathes also. Just as when a man is diseased the infection is carried by perspiration, by breathing and by touching: that is a scientific fact. If a man is infected with smallpox bacteria, you can simply touch his perspiration and become infected. This occurs even in this material world. So this is all possible. It is not impossible. It simply requires some intellectual capacity to understand. From Maha Vishnu’s Spiritual Body so many Universes emanate. When He exhales they come out, and when He inhales the whole thing is gone. This is the material Universe. Just imagine: the existence of each and every Universe is contained in one breath of Vishnu. That is stated in the Brahma Samhita. We have calculated the age of Brahma, but actually you cannot conceivably calculate even one day of Maha Vishnu. 4,200,000,000 years is only twelve hours of Brahma. And the whole life of Brahma is just within the period of one breath of Maha Vishnu. Just consider what is the breathing power of the Supreme Lord. That Maha Vishnu is the plenary partial representation of Krishna.

Next comes the Garbodakshayee Vishnu, from Whom Brahma is born. Within that lotus stem from this Vishnu’s navel there are so many Universes. And just as the mother increases the family members, similarly Brahma was first created by Garbodakshayee Vishnu, and Brahma created the whole human society, animal society—everything. Maha Vishnu’s plenary expansion is Garbodakshayee Vishnu, and His plenary expansion is Kshirodakshayee Vishnu. In this way, in each and every Universe, there is one Garbodakshayee Vishnu and one Kshirodakshayee Vishnu. That Kshirodakshayee Vishnu lies on the milk ocean, within this Universe, and He is the Controller and the Maintainer of the Universe. Brahma is the Creator, Vishnu is Maintainer, and when it will be required to annihilate the Universe, then Shiva will come and finish everything.

So far, Krishna Das Kaviraj has discussed Lord Chaitanya and Lord Nityananda, and now he describes Adwaita Acharya. In our morning prayers we sing the Names of Lord Chaitanya and His Associates:

Sri Krishna Chaitanya, Prabhu Nityananda, Sri Adwaita, Gadadhar, Srivasadi Gour bhaktavrinda.

They are all expansions of the same One. So Adwaita Acharya is an expansion of Maha Vishnu. You have seen the picture of Maha Vishnu lying on the Causal Ocean and breathing out innumerable universes. That Maha Vishnu is incarnated as Adwaita. This Adwaita Acharya is the incarnation of that Maha Vishnu, Who creates this material world through the agency of the material energy. Therefore Adwaita Acharya is also the Lord, or an expansion of the Lord. Why is He called Adwaita? Adwaita means nondual. His name is such because He is non-different from the Supreme Lord. And He is called Acharya, teacher, because He disseminated Krishna Consciousness. In this He is just like Chaitanya Mahaprabhu—although He is Sri Krishna Himself, He appeared as a devotee to teach how to love Krishna. So Adwaita Acharya appeared just to distribute the knowledge of Krishna Consciousness. He is also the incarnation of a devotee.

Krishna is manifested in five different expansions, and Himself and all of His other Associates appear as devotees of the Supreme Lord. Some of them are like Adwaita Acharya—He is an incarnation of Maha Vishnu. And one is known as Bhakta Nityananda Prabhu, Who also appeared as a devotee. So Chaitanya Mahaprabhu is the Source of energy for all devotees. If we take shelter of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu for Krishna Consciousness, it becomes very easy. There is a very nice song: “My dear Lord Chaitanya, please have mercy upon me, because there is no one who is such a merciful Lord as You are. You have descended to deliver all fallen souls, but You will not find a more fallen soul than me; therefore, my claim to be delivered is most urgent. Because Your mission is to deliver the fallen souls, and nobody is more fallen than me, I have my priority.”

Now the author begins his obeisances to Krishna. The author, Krishna Das, was an inhabitant of Vrindaban. Some incidents from his life will be described in the Fifth Chapter of the Chaitanya Charitamrita. He was a great devotee. He had been living in Katwa, a small subdivisional city in the district of Bardwan in Bengal, with his family who also worshipped Radha Krishna, when there was some misunderstanding—not on family matters, but about devotional service. In the midst of this misunderstanding, Nityananda Prabhu advised him in a dream to leave his home and go to Vrindaban. Although he was very old, he started out that very night, and came to live at Vrindaban. He met some of the Goswamis there. His tomb remains in the temple where I live in Vrindaban. This is Krishna Das Kaviraj Goswami, the author of Chaitanya Charitamrita. This Chaitanya Charitamrita was requested by the devotees of Vrindaban. He began at a very old age, but by the grace of Lord Chaitanya he finished this nice, most authoritative book on Chaitanya’s philosophy and life: The Character and Activities of the Eternal Living Force.

Because he lived in Vrindaban, there are three temples that are very important: One temple is Madanmohan, another is Govinda, and the third is Gopinath. These temples are the ones visited by all pilgrims. About 300 or 400 years after the construction of these temples, with the development of Vrindaban city, many other temples were built, but when Krishna Das Goswami was living, there were not so many. The only principle temples were these three—Madanmohan, Govinda, and Gopinath. Because he was a resident of Vrindaban, he must offer his respects to the deities. And his first offering is respect. He considers himself as a layman and very slow to make progress. He asks God’s favor: “My progress in spiritual life is very slow, so I am asking Your help.”

He is offering his obeisances first to Vigraha. Vigraha, according to devotional service, is the deity Who can help us in dovetailing ourselves with Krishna Consciousness. Our first business is to know Krishna, and to know our relationship with Krishna. To know Krishna is to know oneself, and to know oneself means to know one’s relationship with Krishna. What is our relationship with Krishna? That is learned by worshipping Madanmohan Vigraha. Therefore, Krishna Das Goswami first establishes his relationship with Madanmohan Vigraha. When one is established in relationship with Krishna, then he begins his function. The functional deity is Govinda.

He offers his obeisances to Govinda, Who resides in Vrindaban. Vrindaban is the place where there are desire trees. Actually, in the Spiritual World of Vrindaban, it is explained, that the land is of touchstone and the trees are desire trees. Desire tree means whatever you want you can have. And the Lord is herding spiritual cows, known as Surabhi cows. And He is worshipped by hundreds and thousands of Gopis, who are all Goddesses of Fortune. When Krishna descends, this same Vrindaban descends. Just as when a Governor or a President goes to someplace, all his entourage and paraphernalia, secretary, military—everything goes there with him. Similarly, when Krishna comes, His land also comes. Therefore Vrindaban is considered to be not in the material world. And therefore devotees take shelter in Vrindaban. Vrindaban in India is considered the replica of the original Vrindaban; and so one should accept the trees of Vrindaban as being the same Kalpa briksha, desire trees. Now, one may say of the Vrindaban trees, “Oh, we can ask anything?” But first of all you should become a devotee. You simply cannot go and test them to see whether these trees are desire trees. Actually, when the Goswamis were there, the Kalpa briksha was there. The Goswamis were each under one tree for one night, and all their wants were satisfied. So how could they live that way unless the trees were so nice as desire trees? For the common man it seems very wonderful that the Goswamis could simply live underneath one tree one night, and the next tree another night, and have everything they needed. But it is all possible. As we make progress in our devotional service, we can realize this.

There is another devotee, an Acharya, who describes Vrindaban: “When my mind becomes cleansed of all dirty hankering for material enjoyment, then I shall be able to see Vrindaban !” So Vrindaban is actually experienced by persons who have finished with material enjoyment. Everything is spiritual. This becomes revealed. We cannot challenge it. As you become more Krishna conscious, as you become more advanced, everything is revealed to you.

Actually, Vrindaban is as good as the Spiritual Vrindaban, and therefore Krishna Das Kaviraj Goswami says that underneath one of the desire trees of Vrindaban there is a nice throne decorated with valuable jewels on which Radharani and Krishna are seated. And His dear friends and the Gopis are all serving Them: somebody is singing, and somebody is dancing, somebody is offering betel nuts and refreshment, somebody is decorating with flowers. In this way there are 108 Gopis who are the constant companions of Sri Radha and Krishna. That scene is described in Chaitanya Charitamrita.

In India it is still a fashion of recreation to sit on a swinging throne, and, if it is moving, it is very refreshing. In each and every home they have a hanging throne, and when a man comes home from the office, if it is practical, it is moved for some time and he becomes refreshed. So, similarly, the same system prevails, especially in the month of Sravam, July, when there is the function called Julun. During Julun, in all the houses—not only of Vrindaban but all over India—the people hang thrones. In every house and village they place Krishna and Radha and decorate them with flowers and move the throne and offer dancing and Kirtan. If you like you can introduce that system here. Julun goes on for one month, the temples are decorated and thousands of visitors come as spectators. Generally, people go to Vrindaban at that time. Krishna and Radha are seated on the throne, surrounded by His friends.

“I offer my respects to Radha and Krishna,” Krishna Das says. This Radha and Krishna deity shows us how to serve Radha and Krishna. Madanmohan is simply to establish that “I am Your eternal servant.” Now, in Govinda, there is actually acceptance of service. Therefore it is the functional deity.

The next deity is Gopinath. The author offers blessings here to the audience in the Name of Gopinath, the Master or Proprietor of the Gopis, Who attracted all the Gopis by the sound of His flute, because He wanted to dance with them. In the Tenth Canto of Srimad Bhagwatam this is described: Some of the Gopis are sleeping somewhere with their husbands, some are taking milk, some are caring for their children—they were all busy young girls. But as soon as they heard Krishna’s flute, they at once left their places.

All these Gopis were childhood friends. In India the girls are married by the age of twelve years, and the boys are married at not less than eighteen years. Krishna was not married at that time as He was a Boy fifteen or sixteen years old. So, He called these girlfriends from their homes, although they were married, and they used to come and dance together. That is called the Rasa Dance. Hearing the transcendental sound of the flute, as soon as He would sound the vibration, all the Gopis would come and join Him at a particular place, which was called Bonsibat. If you go to Vrindaban you will find that Bonsibat still exists. It is a very sanctified place, and pilgrims go there and offer their respects. Believe it or not, it is said that there are the same trees that were there at the time of Krishna. That is not so astonishing, however, because I saw some redwood trees in Muir Forest in San Francisco which were said to be 7000 years old. So it is not impossible.

Krishna advented 5000 years ago, and if some of the trees are still standing, it is not unprecendented, because here also there are very old trees. The particular tree under which Krishna used to call the Gopis to come and dance the Rasa Dance at night with Him—that tree is still there. That is described in Chaitanya Charitamrita.

“May that Gopinath, the Master of the Gopis, Krishna, bless you. May you become blessed by Gopinath.” Gopinath is called for blessing because He used to attract the Gopis. As He attracted the Gopis by the sweet sound of His flute, so the author desires that He may also attract your mind by that transcendental vibration.


PART I


TLC 1-1968: Teachings to Rupa Goswami

Chapter One

Teachings to Rupa Goswami

Srila Rupa Goswami, the younger brother of Sanatan Goswami, went to Prayag, the modern Allahabad, with his younger brother Ballabha, and when they heard that Lord Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu was staying there, both of them became very much pleased. They went to see Lord Chaitanya and saw that the Lord was going to visit the temple of Bindumadhava. While the Lord was going, chanting and dancing, thousands of people were following Him and some of them were crying, some were laughing, some were dancing, and some singing. Some of them were fallen on the ground, offering obeisances to the Lord. And all of them were roaring with the Holy Name of Krishna, Krishna. Prayag is situated on the confluence of the Rivers Ganges and Yamuna. And it is said that in spite of its being at the junction of two rivers, it remained without being overflooded until the appearance of Lord Chaitanya, when the city was overflooded by the tide of love of Krishna.

The two brothers, Rupa Goswami and Ballabha, saw the great crowd and the wonderful scene, staying aloof in an uncrowded place. The Lord was dancing, raising His two hands, and roaring with the words, Hari Bol! Hari Bol! All the people assembled there were astonished, struck with wonder at the Lord’s activity, and it is very difficult to describe the actual situation. The Lord was acquainted with one Deccanist Brahmin, and the Lord came back to the Brahmin’s house to accept prasadam. While Lord Chaitanya was sitting at the house of this Deccanist Brahmin, the two brothers, Rupa Goswami and Ballabha, arrived there. From a distant place they fell down on the ground to offer obeisances, and were chanting many Sanskrit verses from Scriptures. The Lord saw Rupa Goswami in front of Him, thus offering obeisances. He was very much pleased, and asked him: “My dear Rupa, please get up." The Lord informed Rupa Goswami about the causeless mercy of Krishna on him, because Krishna had delivered him from the materialistic way of life which is based simply on pound-shilling-pence.

The Lord accepted the two brothers as His own devotees, and cited one verse from the Scriptures which states that a Brahmin who has studied the four Vedas may not be His devotee, but a pure devotee coming from a very low family may be accepted by Him. The Lord then embraced the two brothers, and by His causeless mercy He touched His Lotus Feet on their heads. When they were so blessed both the brothers came to offer their prayers to the Lord in their own words. The prayers said that Lord Sri Krishna Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, Who is Krishna Himself, has assumed the Form of fair complexion, Gouranga, and is the most munificent Incarnation of Krishna, because He is distributing love of Krishna. Srila Rupa Goswami also quoted one verse which was later on found in the book, Govinda Lilamrita. The verse says as follows: “Let me be surrendered unto the Lotus Feet of Sri Krishna Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, Who is the greatest, most merciful Personality of Godhead, and Who delivers those merged in ignorance, and offers them the highest gift of love of Krishna, and thus makes them mad after Krishna Consciousness. ”

After this incident the Lord was invited by Ballabha Bhatta to the other side of the Ganges, and He went there. But wherever He used to go, Rupa Goswami would follow Him, and was staying with Him. The Lord felt inconvenience in crowded places, and therefore He asked Rupa Goswami to accompany Him to the bank of the Ganges known as Dasaswamedhaghat. And for ten days He instructed Rupa Goswami about the Truth of Krishna, the principles of devotional service, and the transcendental mellows. All was described in full detail, so that in future he could distribute the science of Krishna in his book, Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu. Srila Rupa Goswami has described this incident in the first verse of Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu which speaks about the causeless mercy of the Lord upon him. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is cognizant, All-Powerful, and, by His causeless mercy, He empowers a living entity to receive His mercy. People in general, being under the spell of conditional life, are averse to devotional service and Krishna Consciousness. They are unaware of the principles of Krishna Consciousness: namely, one’s eternal relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead; the ultimate goal of life, which is to return back to Home, back to Godhead; and the process of returning to the spiritual world. These things are unknown to the conditioned soul. Lord Chaitanya, out of His causeless mercy, instructed Rupa Goswami on the principles of devotional service, and later on Rupa Goswami distributed to the people in general the science of devotional service.

Srila Rupa Goswami has described Lord Chaitanya in the Prologue to Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu as follows: “I am offering my respectful obeisances unto the Lotus Feet of the Personality of Godhead, known as Lord Chaitanyadeva because, inspired by Him, I am feeling it within my heart to write something about devotional service. Therefore, I am engaged in writing this great book on the science of devotion, known as Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu.”

Lord Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu instructed Rupa Goswami continually for ten days, and He began His teaching as follows: “My Dear Rupa, the science of devotional service is just like a great ocean, and it is not possible to show you all the length and breadth of the great ocean. But I shall simply try to explain about the nature of the ocean by just taking a drop out of it; and you can thus taste it and understand what is that ocean of devotional service.”

Within this Brahmanda, or Universe, there are innumerable living entities, and according to their own fruitive activities they are transmigrating from one species of life to another, and from one planet to another. In this way their encagement in material existence is being continued since time immemorial. The living entities are atomic parts and parcels of the Supreme Spirit. There is, however, a measurement for the length and breadth of the atomic spiritual spark. It is said in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Eighty-seventh Chapter, 36th verse, that if you divide the tip of a hair into two parts, and again if you divide one part of that into another 100 parts, such 1/10,000th part of the tip of a hair is the length and breadth of the individual soul. This is also confirmed in the Vedas, in the Svetasvataro Upanishad. [5.9]

This atomic magnitude of the individual living entity is again described in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Sixteenth Chapter, 11th verse, as follows: (This is a speech given by one of the four Kumaras, known as Sananda, on the occasion of performing a great sacrifice;) He said, O Supreme Truth! if the living entities were not infinitesimal living sparks of the Supreme Spirit, then each minute spark would have been all-pervading, and there would be no necessity of its being controlled by superior power. But if the constitution of the living entity is accepted as being the minute part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, then automatically he becomes a controlled living entity under supreme energy or power. This is his constitutional position. Therefore, if he remains as he is created in that natural position, he can attain full freedom. As such, if somebody by mistake calculates that his constitutional position is equal to the constitutional position of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, then he becomes contaminated by the doctrine of non-duality and his efforts in transcendental life are without any effect.

The Lord continues His teaching, saying that there are two kinds of living entities: one is called eternally liberated, and the other is called eternally conditioned. Out of the eternally conditioned living entities, again they are divided into two classes, namely, the moving and the non-moving entities. Those who cannot move, who, like trees, for example, are standing in one place, are called non-moving entities. And those who are moving, such as birds and beasts, are called Jangam, or moving entities. These moving entities are also divided into three: there are the tiryak, or the birds: some of them can fly in the sky, and swim on the water, as well as walk on the land. Besides this tiryak, there are aquatics; and there are animals and human beings, who are moving on the land. Out of the many millions and trillions of living entities on the land, the species of human beings are very few. Out of that small quantity of human beings there are many who are actually without any advancement in spiritual science, and are without cleanliness in their habits, without any faith in the existence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and are simply like animals. They may be deducted from the human society or from the civilized society of human beings.

We shall hardly find a few human beings who believe in the Scriptures or in the existence of God, or in good behavior for the human being. Such believers are known as Aryans, or those who believe in advancing in spiritual life. Out of such persons believing in the Scriptures and in the advancement of human civilization, there are two classes of men, who are known as the righteous and the unrighteous. Of those who are righteous, most execute fruitive activities. That means they prefer to perform righteous activities in order to derive some good result from them for sense gratification. Out of many, many such persons who are engaged in good righteous activities for sense gratification some of them come to know about the Absolute Truth, and they are called Jnanins, meaning persons who are seeking after the Absolute Truth, or philosophers—empiric philosophers. Out of many hundreds and thousands of such empiric philosophers some actually become liberated. This liberation means that theoretically one can understand that a living entity is not made of any of the material elements; that he is spirit soul, different from matter. Simply by understanding this doctrine, even theoretically, one may be called mukta, or liberated; but actually a mukta, or liberated soul, is he who understands his constitutional position as part and parcel eternal servitor of the Lord. Such liberated souls, if they are engaged with faith and devotion in the service of the Lord, are called Krishna-bhaktas, or Krishna conscious persons.

These Krishna conscious persons are free from all material desires. Those who are liberated theoretically simply know that the living entity is not made of any material element. Although they may be classified amongst the liberated souls, they have desire. They have the desire to become one with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Such persons are very much attached to the ritual performance of the Vedic injunctions, and to righteous activities, in order to enjoy material welfare. And even when some of them are out of material enjoyment, they want enjoyment in the spiritual world, to merge into the existence of the Supreme Lord. And some of them are also desirous of getting the perfection of mystic powers, known as the Yoga principles. So long as all these desires are within the heart of a person, he cannot understand the nature of pure devotional service, and on account of being agitated by such desires, he is not peaceful. So long as there is any desire for material perfection, he cannot be at peace. The devotees of Lord Krishna are not desirous of material achievement, and as such they are the only peaceful persons within this material world. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Sixth Canto, Fourteenth Chapter, 4th verse: It is said there as follows: “O great sage, out of many millions of liberated persons, and persons who have achieved success in mystic Yoga powers, one who is completely devoted to the Supreme Personality of Godhead and is therefore very peaceful is very rarely to be found.”

The Lord continued to explain that in this way many thousands and millions of living entities are wandering within this material world, and some of them, by the grace of Lord Krishna and the Spiritual Master, can get the seed of devotional service. The pious or religious man is generally inclined to worship the deities in various temples and if by chance he offers obeisances and worshipful respects to Lord Vishnu, even without his knowledge, and he receives the favor of a Vaishnava, a devotee of the Lord, at that time he accumulates some asset in the matter of approaching the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is very plainly understood from the Srimad Bhagwatam in the matter of the life of the great sage Narada. Narada got the chance of serving the Vaishnavas in his previous life, and thus he was favored by the devotees of the Lord, with the result that he became a great sage, as he is known—Narada Muni.

The Vaishnavas or devotees are generally very compassionate toward the conditioned souls, and even being uninvited by any conditioned soul, a devotee goes from door to door to enlighten people from the darkness of nescience, and to inject in them knowledge in various ways about their constitutional position of being engaged in devotional service, or Krishna Consciousness. Such persons are devotees empowered by the Lord, and they are especially empowered to distribute devotional consciousness, or Krishna Consciousness, to the people in general. They are known as authorized Spiritual Masters. It is just by the mercy of such an authorized Spiritual Master that a conditioned soul gets the seed of devotional service. The causeless mercy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is first appreciated when one is in touch with a bona fide Spiritual Master who can enlighten the conditioned soul to the highest position of devotional life. Therefore, Lord Chaitanya said that by the mercy of the Spiritual Master, one can achieve the causeless mercy of the Lord; and by the mercy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one can get the mercy of the bona fide Spiritual Master.

By such mercy from the Spiritual Master and Krishna one receives the seed of devotional service, and one has to sow the seed in the field of his heart just as a gardener sows the seed of a valuable tree. After sowing the seed one has to pour water in the form of chanting and hearing the Holy Name of the Supreme Lord, or by taking part in the discussion of the science of devotional service in the society of pure devotees. When the plant of devotional service sprouts up from the seed of devotion, it begins to grow freely, and when it is full grown it then surpasses the length and breadth of this Universe and enters into the transcendental position of the spiritual world, where everything is effulgent in the Brahmajyoti, and the plant penetrates even the Brahmajyoti, and then gradually enters into the planet known as Goloka Vrindaban, and there the plant takes shelter at the Lotus Feet of Krishna. That is the ultimate goal of devotional service. After attaining such a position, the plant produces fruit which is known as the fruit of love of Godhead. The devotee or the transcendental gardener has, however, to pour water on the plant daily, in regulation, by the process of chanting and hearing. Without chanting and hearing, or without pouring water on the root of the plant, there is every chance of the plant becoming dried up.

The Lord continued to say that there is another source of danger while pouring water on the root of the plant. When the plant of devotional service grows, some animal may come and eat the whole thing or destroy the plant, just like an ordinary plant is also destroyed by the animal. And when the green leaves of the plant are taken away by some animal, the plant generally dries up. So one has to take precaution about the plant of devotional service not being disturbed by other animals. An animal is used to refer to offenses unto the pure devotee of the Lord, which is called Vaishnava Aparadh. This offense unto the pure devotee is compared to a mad elephant: As a mad elephant, if it enters into the garden, causes tremendous loss to the plants and trees, so in the devotional discharge, if there is any offense unto the feet of the pure devotee, it creates havoc in the matter of advancing in devotional service. Therefore, one has to defend the plant by fencing it properly; one has to take care, while discharging devotional service, not to commit any offense to the pure devotees. If one is cautious in the matter of not committing offenses unto the pure devotees, then the plant of devotional service is properly protected.

Offenses are of ten kinds, and they are also known as offenses unto the Holy Name: The first offense is to blaspheme great devotees who have tried to spread the Glories of the Holy Name all over the world. If one is unnecessarily envious of a devotee who is trying to spread the Holy Name all over the world, in execution of the order of his Spiritual Master, such a rascal is the greatest offender at the Feet of the Holy Name. The Holy Name of Krishna is non-different from Krishna, and Lord Krishna cannot tolerate such offenses as to decry a pure devotee who is spreading His Holy Name all over the world. The second offense is to deny that Lord Vishnu is the Absolute Truth; There is no difference between His Name, Quality, Form, Pastimes, and Activities; but one who sees a difference in these different functions of the Supreme Lord is also an offender. In the same way, the Lord being supreme, nobody is equal to or greater than the Supreme Lord. Therefore, if anybody thinks that the Lord or His Name are equal to the personality of some demigod, he is also an offender. Such a conception of equality between the Supreme Lord and the demigods is not very congenial to the performance of devotional service.

The third offense is to consider the bona fide Spiritual Master as one of the common men. The fourth offense is to blaspheme Vedic literature and the corollaries of Vedic literature, the Puranas. The fifth offense is to consider the Glories of the Holy Name as an exaggeration. The sixth offense is to imagine a perverted meaning of the Holy Name. The seventh offense is to commit sinful activities on the strength of chanting the Holy Name. It is understood that by chanting the Holy Name one gets freed from sinful reactions, but that does not mean that one should perversely act sinfully on the strength of his chanting the Holy Name of the Lord. That is the greatest offense. The eighth offense is to consider that religious ritualistic performances, austerity or renunciation or the performance of sacrifices are on an equal level with chanting the Holy Name. Chanting of the Holy Name is as good as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and other pious activities may be a means to approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but when they are employed for some material achievement they are called offensive. The ninth offense is that the Glories of the Holy Name of God may not be preached to a faithless person, and to speak about the Glories of the Holy Name unto such persons is also another offense. The tenth and last offense is to maintain material attachment even after hearing and chanting the Holy Name of God. The idea is that by chanting the Holy Name without any offense, one may be elevated to the liberated condition. And the liberated condition means that one gets freedom from all kinds of material attachment: so if it is found that a chanter of the Holy Name still has material attachment, then that is called an offense.

When the plant of devotional service is growing, there is still another chance of disturbance. Along with the growth of the plant of devotional service there are other plants also growing. They are material desires. When one is advanced in devotional service, it is natural that many persons will come to the devotee for becoming his disciples, and will offer him some material gains. So if a person becomes attracted by the increased number of disciples and the material conveniences offered by the disciples, and forgets his duty as a bona fide Spiritual Master, that is another disturbance in the growth of the plant of devotional service. It may be that, by taking advantage of material convenience, one becomes addicted to enjoy the material comforts of life.

Another disadvantage is to desire liberation. Another disadvantage is to be neglectful of the restrictions or prohibitions. The prohibitions are mentioned in the authorized Scriptures: one should not indulge in the association of woman or illicit sex life, one should not indulge in intoxication, one should not eat anything other than Krishna prasadam (food offered to Krishna), and one should not take part in gambling. These are the restrictions for devotional service, and if one does not follow these principles strictly then there may be a severe disturbance in the discharge of devotional service.

Another disturbing element is to aspire after material name and fame by discharging devotional service. If one is not particularly careful, then by the process of watering the plant of devotional service, other unnecessary plants, as described above, may grow, and that may hamper the progress of devotional service. The idea is that, by the watering process, these unnecessary plants grow very luxuriantly and the gardener does not see the impediments offered to the main plant of devotional service. It is the duty of the neophyte devotee to cut out all the unnecessary plants grown by the watering process. In other words, if one is careful against the growth of unnecessary plants, then the main plant grows luxuriantly and reaches the ultimate goal, the planet known as Goloka Vrindaban. To reach the ultimate goal, the Goloka Vrindaban planet, is the real result of devotional service, the real fruit grown of the plant of devotional service. When the living entity engaged in such devotional service relishes that fruit of love of Godhead, then he forgets all other ritualistic activities, religiousness for improvements in economic conditions, satisfaction of the senses, and the desire to become one with the Supreme Lord by merging into His effulgence.

There are many phases of spiritual knowledge and transcendental bliss, such as performance of the ritualistic sacrifices recommended in the Vedas, the execution of austerities and pious duties, and the practice of mystic Yoga. They have their different respective results to be enjoyed by the performer, but all these results may appear to be very glittering only so long as one is not elevated to the transcendental loving service of the Lord. There is a nice comparison in this connection: that a person bitten by a serpent remains unconscious so long as there is no smelling of the particular type of medicine recommended. As soon as the bitten person smells that particular type of medicine, however, he at once becomes conscious, and no longer can he remain unconscious by the poisonous effects.

Love of Godhead can be awakened from the dormant position by executing pure devotional service. And what is that devotional service? What are its symptoms? These were all described by Lord Chaitanya to Rupa Goswami:

In the matter of pure devotional service, there cannot be any other desire than to become advanced in Krishna Consciousness. In Krishna Consciousness there is no scope for worshipping any demigods, or any other Form of Krishna, or to indulge in speculative empiric philosophy, or to be engaged in fruitive activities. One should be freed from all these contaminations. One should accept only favorable things for keeping the body and soul together, not for increasing the demands of the body. Only the bare necessities of the body should be accepted, and putting the bodily necessities second, one should primarily cultivate Krishna Consciousness by chanting the Holy Name of God. Pure devotional service means to engage all the senses that we have in the service of the Lord. At the present moment our senses are all designated because the body is designated. So we think that this body belongs to a particular society or a particular country or a particular family: that is the designative understanding of the body; and similarly the senses belong to the body, and if the senses act under such a designative concept of life, family-wise, society-wise, or nation-wise, then one cannot cultivate Krishna Consciousness. The senses must be purified. One should purely understand that he belongs to Krishna, his life belongs to Krishna, his identity is eternal servitorship to Krishna—and in this way if one engages his senses in the service of the Lord, that is called pure devotional service.

A pure devotee accepts transcendental loving service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but does not accept any kinds of liberation for his personal sense gratification. It is stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Twenty-ninth Chapter, verses 10-12, as follows: Lord Kapiladeva explains in those verses about the pure nature of devotional service: that as soon as a pure devotee hears the Glories and transcendental Qualities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Who is seated in everyone’s heart, at once his mind flows towards the Lord, as the water of the Ganges flows down towards the sea. Such spontaneous attraction of the devotee’s mind to the service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the significance of pure devotional service. Devotional service, engagement in the service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead without any cause, and without being hampered by any material impediment, is called pure devotion. The pure devotee does not desire to live in the same planet with the Personality of Godhead, he does not desire the same opulence as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and he does not desire to have the same form as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He does not desire to live along with Him side by side, neither does he desire at any time to merge into the existence of the Supreme Person, even if these things are offered by God to the devotee. The thing is that a devotee is so much absorbed in the transcendental loving service of the Lord that he has no time to think of any other benefit beyond his engagement. Just as an ordinary materialistic businessman, when he is absorbed in his business, does not think of any other thing, so a pure devotee, when he is engaged in the pure devotional service of the Lord, does not think of anything beyond that engagement.

By these symptoms alone one can be understood to be elevated to the topmost position of devotional service. And it is with such transcendental loving service alone that one can surpass the influence of Maya, and can relish pure love of Godhead. So long as one has the desire for material benefit, or for liberation, which are called the two witches of allurement, one cannot relish the taste of transcendental loving service to the Supreme Lord.

There are three stages of devotional service: the first stage is called the beginner's cultivation stage, and the second is called the realization of the service, and the third, the supreme stage, is called attainment of love of Godhead. There are nine different methods for cultivating devotional service, such as hearing, chanting, remembering, etc. All these processes are employed in the neophyte stage of cultivation. If one is engaged in the matter of chanting and hearing with devotion and faith, then gradually his material misgivings become vanquished. Gradually his faith in devotional service increases more and more, and such stages assure him a higher perfectional position. Thus, one becomes firmly fixed, increases the taste for it, becomes attached to it, and feels an ecstasy which is called the preliminary stage of love of Godhead. Attainment of ecstasy is produced by execution of the cultivation of devotional service. Such attainment, when still more developed by that same process of hearing and chanting, gradually becomes thickened, and it assumes the name of love of Godhead.

In the stage of transcendental love of God, there are further developments, which are known as transcendental affection, emotion, ecstasy, and extreme, intense attachment. These are technically known as raga, anuraga, bhava, mahabhava. These are technical terms. The process is exemplified by the gradual thickness of sugarcandy juice. Sugarcandy juice in the first stage is liquid; and when by evaporation it becomes thicker and thicker, it becomes molasses, then granules, then sugar, then rock candy, and so on. These are different stages of the liquid sugar juice, and similarly there are different stages of the development of transcendental love for the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

When one is situated on the transcendental platform, that stage is called steady. Unless one is situated on the transcendental platform, the practice or love of Godhead may not be steady. One may fall down. But when one is situated on the transcendental platform he becomes steady, and there is no fear of falling down. This stage of understanding is technically called sthaibhava.

There are still further developments stepping forward from the position of sthaibhava, and these are called vibhava, anubhava, satwik, and byabhibhachary; and when these four ingredients are added to the steadfast position of pure transcendental life, that is called exchange of rasa or transcendental flavor. This exchange of loving reciprocation between the lover and the beloved is generally called Krishna-bhakti-rasa, the transcendental taste of exchanging loving sentiments between the devotee and the Supreme Personality of Godhead. But we must know that this development of the transcendental loving exchange of flavors, stands on the steadfast position of sthaibhava, as explained before. The basic principle of vibhava is sthaibhava, and the other activities are auxilliary assistants for the development of transcendental love.

The ecstasy of transcendental love has two components, the context, and the cause of the excitement. The context is also divided into two parts: the subject and the object: The exchange of devotional service is the subject, and Krishna is the Object. And the transcendental Qualities of Krishna are the causes of excitement. That means that a devotee becomes excited to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead Krishna, being enamoured by the transcendental Qualities of Krishna. The Mayavadi philosophers say that the Absolute Truth is without specific qualities, and the Vaishnava philosophers say that being without qualities, (nirguna) means that the Absolute Truth has no material qualities, but that the spiritual qualities are so great and so enchanting that even liberated persons become attracted by the Supreme Lord. This fact is very nicely explained in the atmarama verse of Srimad Bhagwatam: those who are already situated in self-realization are also attracted by the transcendental Qualities of Krishna. That means Krishna’s Qualities are not material—they are pure and simple transcendental qualities.

The highest stage of ecstasy can be divided into thirteen transcendental activities, which are as follows: 1. dancing, 2. rolling on the floor, 3. singing, 4. clapping, 5. bristling of the body, 6. thundering, 7. yawning 8. breathing, 9. forgetting social conventions, 10. throwing down saliva, 11. laughing 12. headache, 13. coughing. All these thirteen symptoms do not awake simultaneously or at one time, but they act according to the exchange of transcendental flavor. Sometimes one symptom is prominent and at other times the other symptom is prominent. Transcendental flavor is also divided into five. Principally, the initial stage is called santa rati, appreciation of the greatness of the Supreme Personality of Godhead by persons who are liberated from the material contamination, but not exactly engaged in transcendental loving service. They are on the appreciative neutral stage.

The second stage is when a person appreciates that he is everlastingly subordinate to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and he is everlastingly dependant on the causeless mercy of the Supreme Person. At that time there is an awakening of natural affection, as a grownup son becomes attracted with the father’s benediction. At that stage a living entity wants to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead instead of being engaged in the service of Maya, Illusion. This stage is called dasya rati.

The next developed stage of transcendental love is called sakhya rati. Here one associates with the Supreme on an equal level with love and respect. That stage is further developed in the matter of joking and in exchange of different relaxations, by laughing, and so forth. This is called fraternity with the Personality of Godhead without any bondage. Practically, at that stage one forgets his inferior position as a living entity, although he has the greatest respect for the Supreme Person.

When the transcendental flavor or taste of fraternity is further developed, it is called vatsalya rati, filial affection. At that time the living entity tries to be the parent of God. Instead of the Lord being worshipped, the living entity as a parent of the Supreme Person becomes the object of worship for the Supreme Person. Then the Lord depends on the mercy of such pure devotees. This is called vatsalya rati. The Lord puts Himself under the control of the devotee for being brought up nicely. Such a devotee attains to the position of embracing the Supreme Personality of Godhead or kissing His Head. These are developments of parental filial affection for the Supreme Lord.

The next developed stage is called madhurya rati, or the transcendental exchange of tastes between the lover and the beloved in conjugal love. At this stage of loving affairs the damsels of Braja and Krishna glanced over one another in conjugal love. In that stage of transcendental loving service there is an exchange of glancing and a movement of the eyebrows and an exchange of nice pleasing words and attractive smiling between one another. Besides the five primary reciprocations of flavor there are seven secondary reciprocations, consisting of laughing, wonderful vision, chivalry, pitiableness, anger, ghastliness, and devastation. Bhisma, for example exchanged with Krishna in the transcendental flavor of chivalry. Hiranya Kasipu experienced an exchange of the ghastly and devastating Feature of the Supreme Lord.

The five primary rasas, or flavors, constantly remain within the heart of the pure devotee, and the other seven, which are secondary, sometimes appear and disappear, and enrich the existing flavors and tastes. After enriching the primary flavors, they disappear. The example of Santa Bhaktas or santa devotees are the nine yogis named Kavi, Havi, Antariksha, Prabuddha, Pippalayana, Havirhotra, Dravid or Drumil, Chamass, and Karabhajan. The four Kumaras, great sages, are: Sanaka, Sanandan, Sanatkumar and Sanatana. Examples of devotees in the transcendental mode of servitorship are, in the Gokula, Raktak, Chitrik, Patrak; these are all servants of Krishna. In Dwarka there are Daruka, and in the Vaikuntha planets, there is Hanuman, and other persons. Devotees in friendship are like Sridam in Vrindaban, and Bhima and Arjuna in Dwarka or on the Battlefield of Kurukshetra. So far as those in paternal love with Krishna are concerned, the devotees are his mother, father, uncle, and similar relatives. In conjugal love, the devotees are first the damsels of Braja, Vrindaban, and the Queens and Goddesses of Fortune in Dwarka. No one can count how many they are.

Attachment for Krishna is also of two kinds: One kind of attachment is with awe and veneration. There is a lack of freedom in such attachments, which are exhibited in Mathura and the Vaikuntha planets. In such Abodes of the Lord, the flavor of transcendental loving service is restricted. But in the Gokula, Vrindaban, the exchange of loving is freely done, and the cowherd boys and the damsels of Vrindaban, although they know that Krishna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, do not show awe and veneration on account of their thick and thin relationship in great intimacy with Him. Out of these five principal transcendental tastes, awe and veneration are sometimes impediments to perceiving the Lord’s greatness, or in the matter of service to the Lord. But in the matter of friendship and paternal affection, and in conjugal love, such awe and veneration is reduced. For example, when Krishna appeared as the Son of Vasudeva and Devaki they prayed to the Lord with awe and veneration, because they understood that the Supreme Lord Krishna or Vishnu had appeared before them as their little child. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fourty-fourth Chapter, 51st verse: Devaki and Vasudeva, after knowing the Supreme Personality of Godhead, began to pray to Him, although He was present as their Child. Similarly, when Arjuna saw the Universal Form of the Lord, he was also afraid, and he begged pardon because in his dealings with Krishna as an intimate friend, he had engaged in much unceremonious behaviour with Him.

This is stated in the Bhagavad Gita [11.41], that Arjuna prayed, “My Dear Krishna, I have sometimes insulted You, calling You my dear Friend Krishna, without knowing the greatness of Your inconceivable power. Therefore, please forgive me, because I was mad to address You like a common friend or a common man.” Similarly, when Lord Krishna was playing jokes on Rukmini, she thought Krishna might leave her, and therefore she was very much afraid and became perturbed. At that time Rukmini was fanning Krishna, and as soon as she was afraid that Krishna would leave, the fan fell down from her hand and the hairs on her head became scattered. As a plantain tree falls by a blast of windy air, so she became almost unconscious and fell down. But so far as Yasoda, Krishna’s mother in Vrindaban is concerned, it is stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Eighth Chapter, 36th verse, that the Personality of Godhead, Who is worshipped by all the Vedas and Upanishads, and the Samkhya system of philosophy, and all such authorized Scriptures—that: Personality of Godhead was accepted as if born in her belly. In the same Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Ninth Chapter, 12th verse, it is stated that mother Yasoda bound the Boy Krishna with a rope as if He was the Son born of her body, and appeared just like an ordinary child with a material body. Similarly, the description of Krishna’s being treated as an ordinary man is given in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Eighteenth Chapter, 24th verse: When He was defeated by His friends, the cowherd boys, Krishna carried. Sridam on His shoulders.

Similarly, regarding the Gopis’ dealings with Sri Krishna at Vrindaban, it is described in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Thirtieth Chapter, verses. 36-38, as follows: When Sri Krishna took away Srimati Radhika alone from. the group of the Rasa Dance, at that time Srimati Radhika thought that Krishna had left all the other Gopis. Although they are equally beautiful,. He satisfied Her in this way. With pride, She began to say, “My Dear Lord. Krishna has left the beautiful Gopis, and He is satisfied with Me alone.” She thought like that and felt pride. Addressing Krishna in the forest She said, “My Dear Krishna, I am unable to move anymore. Now if You like You. can take Me anywhere as You desire.” When Radhika requested Krishna in. such a way, Krishna replied, “You’d better come to My shoulder,” and as soon as He said this, He disappeared from the scene, on which Srimati Radhika. repented very much.

When Krishna disappeared from the scene of the Rasa Dancing, all thee Gopis began to repent, saying, “My Dear Krishna! We have come here,. leaving aside our husbands, sons, relatives, brothers, and friends! Neglecting their advice we have come to You, and You know better what is the reason for our coming here. You know that we are captivated by the sweet sound of Your flute, and therefore we have come. O, You are so cunning that at this dead of night You have left girls and women like us! It is not very good for You.”

The word sama means controlling the mind from being diverted in various ways, and fixing it up in the Supreme Personality of Godhead. And one who is so fixed up in the Supreme Personality of Godhead is situated on the sama platform. On that platform the devotee understands that Krishna is the basic principle of everything that be within our experience. The same thing is explained in the Bhagavad Gita [7.19]: after many, many births in the cultivation of knowledge, one surrenders unto Vasudeva because he can understand that Krishna is present in everything, that He is distributed all over the cosmic manifestation. Everything is under the control of the Supreme Lord, and everything, being situated in His energy, is different from Krishna in His Personal Form. The same thing is explained in the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu, in which it is said that when intelligence is fixed on Krishna, that is called the quality of sama. This is spoken by the Supreme Personality of Godhead: Samo mannisthata buddhee: that without being elevated to the platform of santa rati, nobody can be fixed in knowing the greatness of Krishna, the diffusion of His different energies which are the cause of all manifestation. The same thing is further explained in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Nineteenth Chapter, 33rd verse: equilibrium of the mind can be achieved by one who has fixed his conclusion on the Supreme Personality of Godhead as the Original Source of everything, and when one can control his senses, that is called sama. When one is ready to tolerate all kinds of suffering for controlling the senses and to keep the mind in equilibrium, that is called titiksha, or tolerance. And when one can control the urges of the tongue and the genital, that is called dhriti. From dhriti one becomes dhira, the pacified. A pacified person is never disturbed by the urges of the tongue and genital.

If one can fix up his mind in Krishna without any deviation, such a steadfast position in Krishna Consciousness is called santa rasa. In santa rasa two things are visible—unflinching faith in Krishna, and cessation from all material desires. The specific qualities of santa rasa, unflinching faith in Krishna and withdrawal from all kinds of desires which are not in connection with Krishna, are common factors in all the other rasas as well. Just like sound vibration is generally present in all other elements, namely air, fire, water, and earth: sound vibration is produced from the sky, so this sound is present in all other elements. Similarly, the qualities of santa rasa, unflinching faith in Krishna and desirelessness toward anything which is not Krishna—these two qualities are present in other transcendental relationships, such as dasya, servitorship, sakhya, fraternity, vatsalya, paternal affection, and the madhurya rasa, conjugal love.

When we speak of non-Krishna it does not mean that anything exists without Krishna. There cannot be anything non-Krishna because everything is a product of the energy of Krishna. And Krishna and His energies being identical, indirectly, everything is Krishna. As an example: consciousness is common to every living entity, but consciousness when it is purely centered on Krishna, when it is called Krishna Consciousness, is pure. And consciousness when it is other than Krishna Consciousness, or consciousness directed at sense gratification, is called non-Krishna. So in the polluted state the conception of non-Krishna comes. But in the pure state there is nothing but Krishna Consciousness. The active interest in Krishna—that Krishna is mine or I am Krishna’s, and therefore my business is to satisfy the senses of Krishna—is a higher status than the santa rasa. Simply to understand the greatness of Krishna is to achieve that status of santa rasa, in which the worshipable object is the impersonal Brahman or Paramatman. This activity of worship of the impersonal Brahman and the Paramatman is the field of activities in empiric philosophical speculation and mystic Yoga practice. But when one develops still further in Krishna Consciousness or spiritual understanding, one appreciates that that Paramatman, the Supersoul, is the eternal worshipable object, and he surrenders unto Him: Bohunam Janmanamante [7.19]: after many, many births. After many, many births in worship of the Brahman and Paramatman, when one surrenders unto Vasudeva Paramatman as the Supreme Master, and accepts oneself as eternally the servant of Vasudeva, he becomes a great transcendental realized soul. And at that time, on account of thick and thin relationship with the Supreme Absolute Truth, one begins to render some sort of transcendental loving service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. And therefore the status of santa rasa, neutrality, transforms into servitorship. It is then called dasya rasa.

In the dasya rasa status, the conception of the Supreme Lord is exhibited in the greatest quantity of awe and veneration. The greatness of the Supreme Lord is appreciated in dasya rasa also. It is marked here that in the status of santa rasa there is no spiritual activity of service, but in the status of dasya rasa, that service begins. Therefore, in the dasya rasa two qualities are there: this means the quality of the santa rasa, and the consciousness of the transcendental taste of fraternity.

The existence of the transcendental qualities of santa rasa and dasya rasa is certainly there, but beyond that there is another quality, confidential attachment, which is pure transcendental love. This confidence in the Supreme Personality is technically known as visrambha. In that status of visrambha, fraternity, there is no sense of awe or veneration toward the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As such, in the transcendental relationship of sakhya rasa there are three transcendental qualities: the sense of greatness, the sense of kinship, and the sense of intimacy without any impression of awe or veneration. Therefore, in the relationship of fraternity, one transcendental quality is further increased.

Similarly, in the status of paternal affection there are four qualities: above the three qualities already mentioned there is another sense of the devotee, that the Supreme Lord is dependent on the mercy of the devotee. As parent of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the devotee also sometimes chastises the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and considers Him as maintained by such devotee. This transcendental sense of being the maintainer of the Supreme Maintainer is very much pleasing both to the devotee and the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The Lord instructed Srila Rupa Goswami to write the transcendental literature named Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu, the Science of Devotional Service, indicating therein the substance of the five transcendental relationships. It is explained there how the transcendental quality of santa rasa in the shape of unflinching faith in Krishna, is further developed to the form of dasya rasa with the spirit of service, and then to sakhya rasa for undeterred fraternity, and can be still more developed in the transcendental flavor of paternal love, with the sense of maintaining the Lord. All culminates in the highest platform of conjugal love, wherein all the different transcendental relationships exist

TLC 2-1968: Sanatan Goswami

Chapter Two

Sanatan Goswami

I offer my respectful obeisances unto Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, by whose mercy even a person in the lowest status of life can find direction in transcendental devotional service to the Lord. [Madhya 20.1]

After Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu accepted the renounced order of life, Sannyasa, He travelled all over India. During this period, He went to Maldaha, a district in Bengal, and in that portion of the land there was a village by the name of Ramkeli. Two government ministers of the Nawab Hussain Shah’s regime lived there, namely Dabir Khas and Shakar Mallik, later renamed Sanatan Goswami and Rupa Goswami. They had a chance to meet Lord Chaitanya, and after meeting Him they decided that they would retire from the government service and join His Samkirtan movement. The two brothers at once took steps to leave their material engagements, and appointed two learned Brahmins to perform certain Vedic religious rituals in order to achieve complete freedom for the devotional service of Krishna.

These preliminary activities are known as Purascharya. The ritual function of this process is that three times a day one has to worship and offer respects to one’s forefathers, offer oblation to the fire, and respectfully offer foodstuffs to a learned Brahmin. Five items; the time, the worship, the offering of respect, the offering of oblation into the fire, and the offering of foodstuffs to a Brahmin; comprise Purascharya. In the Hari Bhakti Vilas, the directional authoritative book, these rituals are mentioned.

After performance of these religious rituals, the younger brother Shakar Mallik (Rupa Goswami), returned to his home with an immense amount of money which he had acquired during his government service. The silver and gold coins he brought back filled a large boat. After arriving home he divided the accumulated wealth first into two, and distributed one part to the Brahmins and Vaishnavas. Thus, for the satisfaction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he distributed fifty per cent of his accumulated wealth to persons engaged in the Supreme Lord’s transcendental loving service. The Brahmins are meant to understand the Absolute Truth; and thereafter, when one is actually engaged in the loving service of the Lord, he is called a Vaishnava. Both the Brahmins and the Vaishnavas are supposed to be fully engaged in transcendental service, and Rupa Goswami, considering their important transcendental position, gave them fifty per cent of his wealth. The balance was again divided into two: one part he distributed to his relatives or dependent family members, and the other he kept against personal emergency.

This distribution of personal wealth is very instructive for all who desire to be elevated to the advancement of spiritual knowledge. Generally, a person bequeaths all his accumulated wealth to the family members, and then retires from family activities for progress in spiritual knowledge. But here we find the exemplary behavior of Rupa Goswami: he gave fifty per cent of his wealth for spiritual purposes. This should be the example for every one of us. The twenty-five per cent of his accumulated wealth which he kept against personal emergency he deposited with a good business firm, since in those days there were no banks. Another ten thousand coins were deposited for expenditures by his elder brother, Sanatan Goswami.

Rupa Goswami at this time received information that Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu was preparing to proceed toward Vrindaban from Jagannath Puri. He sent two messengers to receive actual information of the Lord’s itinerary, and he made his own plans to go to Mathura to meet the Lord there. It appears that Rupa Goswami got permission to join Lord Chaitanya, but Sanatan Goswami did not. Therefore, Sanatan Goswami entrusted his responsibility in the government service to his immediate assistants, and he remained at home to study Srimad Bhagwatam.

He engaged some ten or twenty learned Brahmins, and began an intensive study of Srimad Bhagwatam in their company. While he was thus engaged, he submitted sick reports to the Nawab, but the ruler was very anxious for his advice in government matters, and therefore he suddenly appeared one day at Sanatan Goswami’s house. The Nawab entered the assembly of Sanatan Goswami and the Brahmins, and out of respect all of them stood up to receive him and they offered him a place to sit. The Nawab said:

“You have submitted sick reports, but I sent my physician to see you, and he reported that you have no illness. I did not know why you were submitting sick reports and not attending to your service, so I have personally come to see you. And I’m much perturbed by your behavior. As you know, I completely depend on you and your responsible work in governing. I was therefore free to act in other matters because I was depending on you, but if you do not join me, your past devotion will be spoiled. Now, what is your intention? Please tell me.”

On hearing this, Sanatan Goswami replied that he was unable to work anymore and it would be very kind of the Nawab if he appointed somebody else to execute the work that was entrusted to him. The Nawab became very angry at this and said, “Your elder brother lives like a hunter, and if you also retire from the administration then everything will be finished.” It is said that the Nawab used to treat Sanatan Goswami as a younger brother. The Nawab was engaged in conquering different parts of the country, and he was also engaged in hunting, and therefore he depended more or less on Sanatan Goswami for administration; and so he pleaded with him: “If you also retire from the government service, how will the administration be run?” Sanatan Goswami replied very gravely: “You are the governor of Gouda, and you punish different kinds of criminals in different ways. So you are at liberty to punish anyone according to his activity.” The purpose of his reply was that the governor was engaged in hunting animals and killing men to expand his kingdom; so let both of them suffer according to the acts they were performing.

The Nawab was intelligent, and he understood Sanatan Goswami’s purpose and left the place in an angry mood. Shortly afterward, he went off to conquer Orissa, and ordered the arrest of Sanatan Goswami until he returned.

Rupa Goswami then learned that his elder brother Sanatan had been arrested by the Nawab. He sent information by messenger that the ten thousand coins in Gouda (Bengal) in custody of the Grocer, could be used to release him from the Nawab’s detention. Rupa Goswami, with his younger brother whose name was Sri Ballabha, then started for Vrindaban to meet Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. Sanatan offered five thousand coins to the keeper of the jail in which he was being kept in custody. He advised the jailkeeper to gladly accept the five thousand coins from him and let him go, because by accepting such money he would be materially benefitted, and at the same time he would be acting very righteously in freeing Sanatan for spiritual activities.

The custodian replied, “Of course I can let you go, because you have done many services for me and you are in government service. I know that, but I am afraid of the Nawab when he hears that you are free. I’ll have to explain. How can I accept such a proposal?” Sanatan gave a story which the custodian might submit to the Nawab—as to how he had escaped—and he then raised his offer to ten thousand coins. The custodian then agreed to the proposition. as he was very anxious to get the ten thousand coins. And so he let him go.

Sanatan then proceeded to Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. He did not go on the open road but travelled instead through the jungles until he arrived at a place in Bihar called Pabda, and rested there in the hotel. The hotel keeper, meanwhile, was informed by an astrologer employed at the hotel that Sanatan Goswami had some gold coins with him, and he wanted to take them from him. And so he spoke with superficial respect: “You just take your rest tonight, and in the morning I shall arrange for you to get out of this jungle trap.” Sanatan, however, was suspicious of the behavior of the hotel keeper. and he inquired from his accompanying servant Isan whether he had some money. Isan told him that he had seven gold coins with him. Sanatan did not like the idea of the servant carrying such money. He was angry with him and said, “Why do you carry this death knell on the road?”

Sanatan at once took the seven gold coins and offered them to the hotel keeper; he then requested the hotel keeper to help him through the jungle. He informed him that he was on a special journey for the government and could not travel on the open road, and therefore it would be very kind if the hotel keeper would help him to get over the jungle mountain. The hotel keeper replied, “I understood that you had eight coins with you and I was thinking of killing you to take them. But you are very good, I can understand, and so you don’t have to offer me the money. I’ll get you out of the hill-tract."

Sanatan replied, “If you don’t accept these coins then somebody else will take them from me. Somebody will kill me for them, so better you take them. I offer them to you.” The hotel keeper then gave him full assistance and that very night he helped him to get past the hills.

When Sanatan emerged, he requested his servant to go home with the one coin that he had still with him, and he would go on alone. After the departure of his servant, Sanatan felt completely free. With torn clothing and with a water-pot in his hand he began to proceed toward Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. On the way he met his rich brother-in-law who was also in the service of the government, and who offered him an excellent blanket, which Sanatan accepted at his special request. Then he parted from him and went on alone to see Chaitanya Mahaprabhu at Benares.

When he reached Benares, he understood that the Lord was there and he was very glad. He was informed by people that Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu was staying at the house of Chandra Sekhar Acharya, and he went there. Chaitanya Mahaprabhu was inside the house and He could understand that Sanatan had arrived at the door. He asked Chandra Sekhar to call the man who was sitting at His door, “He is a Vaishnava, a great devotee of the Lord.” Chandra Sekhar went out to see the man but he saw no Vaishnava at the door; he saw only a man who appeared to be a mendicant. The Lord then asked to see the mendicant. When Sanatan entered the courtyard of the house, Lord Chaitanya hurriedly came to receive him and embraced him. When the Lord embraced him, Sanatan became overwhelmed with spiritual ecstasy, and he began to say, “My dear Lord, please do not touch me.” But both of them embraced each other and began to cry. Seeing Sanatan and Lord Chaitanya acting thus, Chandra Sekhar was struck with wonder. Lord Chaitanya received Sanatan in this way, and asked him to sit down with Him on a bench.

He was touching the body of Sanatan with his hand and Sanatan asked Him, “My dear Lord, please do not touch me.” The Lord replied, “I am touching you just for My purification, because you are a great devotee. By your devotional service you can deliver the whole universe for going back to Godhead.”

In this connection the Lord quoted a nice verse from Srimad Bhagwatam. The purport of the verse is that a person who is a devotee of Lord Krishna, one hundred per cent engaged in devotional service, is far better than a Brahmin who is learned in all the Vedic literature, but who is not engaged in the devotional service of the Lord. The devotee can purify every place and every thing because he is carrying the Supreme Lord within his heart.

In the Vedic literature it is also stated that the Supreme Personality of Godhead does not recognize even a person who is very learned in all the divisions of the Vedas; but, rather, He likes a person even if born of a low family, provided that person is a devotee. Instead of offering charities to some Brahmin who is not a devotee, if something is offered to a devotee, that offering is accepted by the Lord. In other words, anything offered to the Lord may be given to His devotees. Chaitanya Mahaprabhu also quoted from Srimad Bhagwatam that, if a Brahmin, although qualified with the twelve different qualities of a Brahmin, is not a devotee of the Supreme Lord, then he is lower than the lowest of the low—even though born in a high family. A devotee, although born in a Chandala (dogeater) family, can purify his whole family for 100 generations past and future by devotional service, whereas a proud Brahmin cannot even purify himself. It is said in the Hari Bhakti Sudodaya [13.2], “O devotee of the Lord, to see you is the perfection of the eyes, to touch your body is the perfection of bodily activities, to glorify your qualities is the perfection of the tongue—because it is very rare to find a pure devotee like you.”

The Lord next said to Sanatan that Krishna is very merciful, and is the Deliverer of the fallen soul. “He has saved you from Maharauraba.” This Maharauraba, hell, is described in Srimad Bhagwatam. It is for persons who are engaged in killing animals. It is stated there that butchers or animal-eaters go to that hell. Sanatan replied, “I do not know the mercy of Krishna, but I can understand that Your mercy is causeless upon me. You have delivered me from the entanglement of material life.”

Then the Lord inquired: “How did you get free from your custody? I understood that you were arrested.” Sanatan narrated the whole story of how he was released. Lord Chaitanya then informed him, “I have seen your two brothers, and I have advised them to proceed toward Vrindaban.”

Lord Chaitanya now introduced Chandra Sekhar to Sanatan, and there was a pleasant invitation made for Sanatan to dine with him. The Lord requested Chandra Sekhar to take Sanatan to the barber and make him gentle, because Sanatan had grown a long beard which Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu did not like. He therefore asked Chandra Sekhar to take Sanatan to a bath and get him dean-shaved. He asked him to change his clothes also.

After taking a bath and cleansing himself, Sanatan requested Chandra Sekhar to give him some good cloth. When Lord Chaitanya was informed that Sanatan did not accept new garments, but accepted only some used garments from Chandra Sekhar, He was very glad. The Lord sat down for lunch and asked Chandra Sekhar to keep food for Sanatan. Chandra Sekhar did not offer him food immediately, however, but after the Lord finished His eating there were some remnants of His foodstuff, and that was offered to Sanatan while the Lord went for His rest.

After this, Lord Chaitanya introduced one Maharastrian Brahmin, His devotee, to Sanatan; and that Maharastrian Brahmin invited Sanatan to accept lunch daily at his place, as long as he remained at Benares. Sanatan said, “So long as I remain at Benares, I will beg from door to door; and the Lord will be so good as to accept from you this invitation for daily lunch at the Brahmin’s house.”

By this behavior of Sanatan Lord Chaitanya was very much pleased; but He noticed the valuable blanket that was given to Sanatan by his brother-in-law while on route to Benares. Although Lord Chaitanya was overlooking the blanket, Sanatan understood that Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu did not approve of such a valuable garment on his body, and he planned to get rid of it. He immediately went to the bank of the Ganges and there saw a mendicant washing an old quilt. Sanatan asked him to trade the old quilt for the valuable blanket. The poor medicant thought that Sanatan was joking with him, so he said, “How is that? You appeared to be a very nice gentleman, but you are mocking me in this unmannerly way.”

Sanatan informed him, “I am not joking with you. I am very serious. Will you kindly exchange that torn quilt for this blanket?” Then Sanatan exchanged his blanket for the torn quilt, and he came before the Lord.

The Lord inquired, “Where is your valuable blanket?”

Sanatan informed Him about the exchange at the Ganges of the blanket for the torn quilt. The Lord then loved him for this and He thanked Sanatan: “You are intelligent enough and you have now finished all your attraction for material wealth.” In other words, the Lord accepts a person for devotional service only when he is completely free from all materialistic possessions. The Lord said to Sanatan, “It would not look well to become a mendicant and go begging from door to door while at the same time you have such a valuable blanket on your body; it is contradictory, and people would look at it with abhorrence.” Sanatan replied to the Lord, “Whatever I am doing to become free from material attachment, it is all Your mercy.” The Lord was very much pleased with him, and both of Them discussed spiritual advancement.

Previous to this meeting of Sanatan and Lord Chaitanya, Lord Chaitanya met the householder-devotee, Ramananda Roy. In that meeting, which is discussed in a different chapter, Lord Chaitanya asked Ramananda Roy questions and Ramananda replied as if he were the teacher of the Lord. But in this case Sanatan will put questions to the Lord and the Lord will answer them.

The instruction and teachings of Lord Chaitanya are very important for people in general. He teaches the process of devotional service, which is the constitutional position of every living entity; it is every man’s duty to advance in spiritual science. All these things are very nicely discussed in the talks between Lord Chaitanya and Sanatan Goswami. At the mercy of Lord Chaitanya Sanatan was able to put questions before Him, and these are replied to properly.

The meeting of Sanatan and Lord Chaitanya teaches us that in order to understand spiritual subject matters, one must approach a Spiritual Master like Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu and make submissive enquiries. This is also confirmed in the instruction of the Bhagavad Gita [4.34]: that one should approach a man of authority, and learn from him about spiritual science.

TLC 3-1968: Teachings to Sanatan Goswami

Chapter Three

Teachings to Sanatan Goswami

In the instructions of Lord Chaitanya to Sanatan Goswami we can understand the science of God in the matter of His transcendental Form, His opulences, and His devotional service—for everything is being described to Sanatan Goswami by the Lord Himself. At that time Sanatan fell at the feet of the Lord and with great humility asked about his own real identity. He spoke as follows:

“I am born of a lower family, my associations are all abominable, and I am fallen, the most wretched of Mankind. I was suffering in the dark well of material enjoyment, and I never knew the actual goal of my life. I do not know what is beneficial to me. Although in the mundane sphere I am what is known as a great learned man, I am in fact so much of a fool that I even accept that I am learned. You have accepted me as Your servant, and You have delivered me from the entanglement of material life. Now You can tell me what my duty is in this liberated state of life.”

In other words, as we see by this plea, liberation is not the final word in perfection. There must be activities in liberation. Sanatan clearly asks: “You have saved me from the entanglement of material existence. Now, after liberation, what is my duty? Kindly explain it to me.” Sanatan further inquired, “Who am I? Why are the three-fold miseries always giving me trouble? And, finally, tell me how I will be relieved from this material entanglement? I do not know how to question You about the advancement of spiritual life, but I beg that You kindly, mercifully, let me know everything that I should know.”

This is the process of acceptance of a spiritual master by the disciple: One should approach a spiritual master and humbly submit to him, and then inquire from him about one’s spiritual progress.

The Lord was pleased by Sanatan’s submissive behavior, and He replied as follows: “You have already received benediction from Lord Krishna, and therefore you know everything, and you are free from all the miseries of material existence.” The Lord further replied that, because Sanatan was in Krishna Consciousness, naturally, by the grace of Krishna, he was already conversant with everything, but “Because you are a humble devotee, you are asking me to confirm what is already realized by you. This is very nice.” These are the characteristics of a true devotee. In the Narada Bhakti Sutra it is said that one who is very serious about developing his Krishna Consciousness, by the grace of the Lord, has his desire for understanding Krishna fulfilled very soon. The Lord said, “You are a suitable person for protecting the devotional service of the Lord. Therefore it is My duty to instruct you in the science of God, and I will explain to you everything step by step.”

It is the duty of a disciple approaching a spiritual master to enquire about his constitutional position. In conformity to that spiritual process, Sanatan has already asked, “What am I, and why am I suffering from the three-fold miseries?” The three-fold miseries are called adhyatmic, adhibhautic, and adhidaivic. Adhyatmic means caused by the body and mind: sometimes the living entity suffers bodily, and sometimes he is distressed mentally—both are adhyatmic miseries. We experience these miseries even in the womb of our mother. There are many forms of misery that take advantage of our delicate body and give us pain.

Miseries inflicted by other living entities are called adhibhautic. There are many living entities, such as bugs born of eggs, that cause us miseries while we are sleeping in bed. There are many living entities, like cockroaches, that sometimes give us pain, and there are other living entities born on different kinds of planets, and they also cause us miseries.

So far as adhidaivic miseries are concerned, they originate with the demigods from the higher planets. For instance, sometimes we suffer from serious cold weather, sometimes we suffer from the thunderbolt, sometimes from earthquakes, tornadoes, droughts and other natural disasters. So we are always suffering one or another of these three kinds of miseries.

Sanatan’s enquiry was: “What is the position of the living entities? Why are they always undergoing these three kinds of miseries?” Sanatan has admitted his weakness: although he was known by the mass of people as a greatly learned man (and actually he was a highly learned Sanskrit scholar)—and although he accepted the designation of a very learned man given him by the mass of people, yet he did not actually know what his constitutional position was, and why he was subjected to the threefold miseries.

The necessity of approaching a spiritual master is not a fashion, but is for he who is seriously conscious of the material miseries, and who wants to be free of them. It is the duty of such a person to approach the spiritual master. We find similar circumstances in the Bhagavad Gita: When Arjuna was perplexed by so many problems involving whether to fight or not, he accepted Lord Krishna as his Spiritual Master. There also it was a case of the Supreme Spiritual Master instructing Arjuna about the constitutional position of the living entity.

In the Bhagavad Gita we are informed that the constitutional nature of the individual entity is spirit soul: he is not matter. Therefore, as spirit soul, he is part and parcel of the Supreme Soul, the Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead. We also learn that it is the duty of the spirit soul to surrender; for only then can he be happy. The last instruction of the Bhagavad Gita is that the spirit soul is to surrender completely unto the Supreme Soul, Krishna, and in that way realize happiness.

Here, also, Lord Chaitanya, in answering the questions of Sanatan, repeats the same truth; but without giving him information about the spirit soul which is already described in the Gita. He begins from the point where Krishna ended His instruction. It is accepted by great devotees that Lord Chaitanya is Krishna Himself. And from the point where He ended His instruction in the Gita, He now begins His instruction again, to Sanatan. The Lord said to Sanatan:

“Your constitutional position is that you are pure living soul. This material body is not the identity of your real self, neither is your mind your real identity, nor your intelligence, nor is false ego the real identity of the self. Your identity is that you are the eternal servitor of the Supreme Lord, Krishna. Your position is that you are transcendental. The superior energy of Krishna is spiritual in constitution, and the inferior external energy is material. You are between the material energy and the spiritual energy, and therefore your position is marginal. In other words, you belong to the marginal potency of Krishna. You are simultaneously one with, and different from, Krishna. Because you are spirit, therefore you are not different from Krishna. But because you are only a minute particle of Krishna, you are therefore different from Him.”

This simultaneous oneness and difference always exists in the relationship between the living entities and the Supreme Lord. From the marginal position of the living entities, this “simultaneously one and different” concept is understood. The living entity is just like a molecular part of the sunshine, whereas Krishna is compared to the blazing, shining sun. Lord Chaitanya compared the living entities to the blazing sparks from the fire, and the Supreme Lord to the blazing fire of the sun. The Lord cites in this connection a verse from Vishnu Purana [1.22.53], in which it is stated that everything that is manifested within this cosmic world is but an energy of the Supreme Lord. For example, as the fire emanating from one place exhibits its illumination and heat all around, so the Lord, although situated in one place in the spiritual world, manifests His different energies everywhere. And the whole world of cosmic representation is but different manifestations of His energy.

The energy of the Supreme Lord is transcendental and spiritual, and the living entities are part and parcel of that energy. But there is another energy called material energy, which is covered by the cloud of ignorance, and thereby divided into the three modes, or gunas, of material Nature [Vp 6.7.61]. Lord Chaitanya quoted from Vishnu Purana [1.3.2] that all inconceivable energies reside in the Supreme Personality of the Lord, and the whole cosmic manifestation acts due to the same inconceivable energy of the Supreme Lord.

The Lord says that the living entities are also known as Kshetrajna, or “Knower of the field of activities.” In the Thirteenth Chapter of the Gita, the body is described as the field of activities, and the living entity as Kshetrajna, the knower of that field. Although the living entity is constitutionally conversant with spiritual energy, or has the potency to understand, he is covered by the material energy, and he consequently believes this body to be himself. This is called false ego. In material existence, deluded by this false ego, the bewildered living entity changes his different bodies and suffers various kinds of miseries. The knowledge of his true position is present to different extents in different varieties of living entities.

In other words, it is to be understood that the living entity is part and parcel of the spiritual energy of the Supreme Lord. The material energy is inferior energy, and therefore man has the potency to become uncovered from this material energy and utilize the spiritual energy. It is stated in the Bhagavad Gita that the superior energy is covered by the inferior energy. Due to this covering, the living entity is subjected to the miseries of the material world, and, in proportion to the different degrees of obscureness, he suffers material miseries. Those who are a little enlightened suffer less, but, on the whole, everyone is subjected to material miseries, due to being covered by the material energy.

The Lord also quoted from the Gita, Seventh Chapter, in which it is stated that earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and ego all combine together to form the inferior energy of the Supreme Lord. But the Superior Energy is the real identity of the living being. Because of that energy the whole material world functions. The cosmic manifestation, made of material elements, has no power to act unless it is moved by the superior energy, the living entity. So, actually, the conditional life of the living entity is forgetfulness of his relationship with the Supreme Lord in the superior energy. When that relationship is forgotten, conditional life is the result. Only when man revives his real identity, that of eternal servitor to the Lord, does he become liberated.

TLC 4-1968: The Wise Man

Chapter Four

The Wise Man

Nobody can trace the history of the living entity’s entanglement in material energy. Therefore the Lord says that it is beginningless. Beginningless means that conditional life exists prior to the Creation—it is simply manifested with, and after, the creation. Due to forgetfulness of his nature, the living entity, although spirit, suffers all kinds of miseries in material existence. It is to be understood here that there are also other living entities who are not entangled in this material energy. Such living entities are situated in the Spiritual World, and they are called liberated souls. They are always engaged in Krishna Consciousness, in devotional service.

The activities of those who are conditioned by material Nature are taken into account, and in their next life, according to these activities, they are offered different grades of material bodies. In the material world the spiritual soul in conditional life is subjected to different rewards and punishments. When he is rewarded, he is elevated to the higher planets, due to his righteous activities. And there he becomes one of the many demigods. And when he is punished for his abominable activities, he is thrown into different kinds of hellish planets, and there he suffers the miseries of material existence more acutely. The Lord gives a very nice example of this punishment: Formerly a king used to punish a criminal by dunking him in the river, and then raising him again for a breath, and then again dunking him once more in the water. Material Nature punishes and rewards the individual entity in just the same way. When he is punished he is dunked into the water of material miseries, and when he is rewarded he is taken out of it for some time. Elevation of the living entity to higher planets or to a higher status of life is never permanent. He has to come down again to be submerged in the water. All this goes on in this material existence. Sometimes one is elevated to the higher planetary system, and sometimes one is thrown into the hellish condition of material life.

In this connection the Lord recites a nice verse from Srimad Bhagwatam [11.2.37], taken from the instruction of Narada Muni to Vasudeva, the father of Krishna. In this quotation from the nine sages who were instructing Maharaj Nemi, it is stated that forgetfulness of the relationship with Krishna is called Maya. Actually, Maya means “that which is not.” It has no existence. Therefore, that the living entity has no connection with the Supreme Lord is a false conception. He may not believe in the existence of God, or he may think he has no relationship with God, but these are all “illusions,” or Maya. Due to his absorption in this false conception of life, man is always fearful and full of anxieties. In other words, a Godless concept of life is Maya; and, therefore, one who is actually learned in the Vedic literature surrenders unto the Supreme Lord with great devotion, and accepts Him as the Supreme Goal. When a living entity becomes forgetful of the constitutional nature of his relationship with God, then he is at once overwhelmed by the external energy, and this is the cause of his false ego, identifying his body as himself His whole conception of the material Universe is due to this false conception of the body. He becomes attached to this body, and to the by-products of this body. To escape this entanglement he has simply to perform his duty—to surrender unto the Supreme Lord with intelligence, with devotion, and with sincere Krishna Consciousness.

A conditioned soul falsely thinks himself happy in the material world, but if he is favored by an unalloyed devotee—by hearing instruction from the unalloyed devotee—he gives up the desire for material enjoyment and becomes enlightened in Krishna Consciousness. As soon as one enters into Krishna Consciousness, his desire for material enjoyment at once is vanquished, and gradually he becomes free from material entanglement. For example, because there is no question of darkness where there is light, Krishna Consciousness is like the light that dispels the darkness of material sense enjoyment.

A Krishna conscious person is never under the false conception that he is One with God. He does not think that he would be happy by working for himself. He engages all his energy in the service of the Supreme Lord, and thereby becomes released from the clutches of illusory material energy. In this connection the Lord quotes a verse from the Bhagavad Gita, Seventh Chapter [14], to the effect that the material energy containing the three modes of material Nature is very strong. It is very difficult to escape the process of material energy, but one who surrenders unto Krishna easily becomes free from the clutches of Maya.

The Lord went on to teach that the conditioned soul, for each and every moment in which he is engaged in some fruitive activity, is forgetting his real identity. Sometimes when he is fatigued, when he is tired of material activities, he wants liberation and wants to become one with the Supreme, but at other times he thinks that by working hard for his sense gratification he will be happy. In both cases he is covered by material energy. For the enlightenment of such bewildered conditioned souls, who are working under false identification, the Lord has presented us with so much Vedic literature, such as the Vedas, the Puranas, and the Vedanta Sutra—all intended to guide the human being back to Godhead. The Lord has presented further instructions, advising that when a conditioned soul is accepted by the mercy of the spiritual master, and when he is guided by the Supersoul, he takes advantage of the various Vedic Scriptures, becomes enlightened, and makes progress in his spiritual realization. It is understood that Lord Krishna is always merciful to His devotees, and therefore He has presented all this Vedic literature, by which one can understand his relationship with Krishna, and can act in that relationship—with the result that he is gifted with the ultimate goal of life.

Actually every living entity is destined to reach the Supreme Lord, and everyone can understand his relationship with the Supreme Lord. The execution of duties to attain perfection is known as devotional service, and in maturity such devotional service becomes Love of God, the factual goal of life for every living being. The living entity is not intended to achieve success in religious perfection or economic development or sense enjoyment. Religiousness, economic development, sense enjoyment, and liberation should not actually be desired by the living entity. The real desire of the entity should be to achieve the stage of loving transcendental service to the Lord.

The All-attractive features of Lord Krishna help one in attaining Krishna Consciousness, and when one is engaged in Krishna Consciousness he can realize the relationship between Krishna and himself.

In this connection the Lord quotes one story from the commentary of Madhva which occurs in Srimad Bhagwatam, Fifth Canto [5.5.10-13]. The story involves the instruction of Sarvajna to a poor man who came to him to have his future told. When Sarvajna saw the horoscope of the poor man, he was at once astonished that the man was so poor, and he said to him, “Oh, why are you so unhappy? I see from your horoscope that you have some hidden treasure left to you by your father. The horoscope, however, states that your father could not disclose this to you because he died in a foreign place. But now you can search out the hidden treasure left by your father and be happy.” This story is cited because the living entity is suffering due to his ignorance of the hidden treasure of his Father. The hidden treasure of the Father, Krishna, is Love of Godhead. In every Vedic Scripture the conditioned soul is advised to find that hidden treasure, which is known as Love of God. As is stated in the Bhagavad Gita, a conditioned soul, although he is the son of the Wealthiest—the Personality of Godhead—does not realize it; therefore the Vedic literature is given to him to help him search out his Father and his paternal property.

Sarvajna further advised the poor man: “Don’t try to dig on the southern side of your house to find the hidden treasure. If you do so, you’ll be attacked by a poisonous wasp and you will be baffled in finding the treasure. The search should be to the eastern side where there is actual light—which is called devotional service, or Krishna Consciousness. On the southern side there is ritualistic performance of the Vedic Scripture, and on the western side there is speculative empiric knowledge, and on the northern side there is the Yoga system, or the meditational process for self realization.”

If somebody searches for his ultimate goal by the ritualistic process, he will be baffled. Such a process involves the performance of rituals under the guidance of the priest who takes money in exchange for service. A man thinks he will be happy by such performances, but actually they will not make him happy. Even if he does gain some result therefrom, it is only temporary, and his material distresses will continue. So he will never become truly happy by such a ritualistic process. Instead, his material pangs increase more and more.

Similarly, digging for the hidden treasure on the northern side is compared with one’s self-realization by dint of the meditational process. By the meditational process perfection is to think oneself One with the Supreme Lord. This merging into the Supreme by the living entity is something like the great serpent swallowing up the smaller serpent. From practical experience we see sometimes that a big serpent swallows up a smaller one, and the merging into the spiritual existence of the Supreme is analogous. The small serpent is, therefore, searching after perfection, and he is swallowed by the big serpent.

Digging on the western side is compared to the hidden treasure protected by Yakasa, the evil spirit that protects it. The idea is that hidden treasure can never be delivered by one who asks the favor of the Yakasa for attaining it. The result is that he will simply be killed. The Yogins who practice meditation are analogous to the small serpents. The speculative process of self-realization, or Jnana, is also suicidal in this case.

Actually, one has to dig for the hidden treasure from the eastern side, which is called devotional service in full Krishna Consciousness. That is the perpetual hidden treasure, and when one attains to that achievement, he becomes perpetually rich. One who is poor in devotional service and Krishna Consciousness is always in need of material gain. Sometimes he suffers the bites of poisonous things, and sometimes he is baffled; sometimes he follows the philosophy of monism and therefore loses his identity, and sometimes he is swallowed by the big serpent. By giving up all these things and becoming fixed in Krishna Consciousness, or devotional service to the Lord, he achieves the perfection of life.

TLC 5-1968: How to Approach God

Chapter Five

How to Approach God

Actually, all Vedic literature directs the human being toward the perfect stage of devotion. The paths of fruitive activities, speculative knowledge and meditation do not lead one to the perfectional stage, but the Lord actually becomes approachable by the process of devotional service. Therefore, one is recommended throughout the Vedic literature to accept the process of devotional service. Lord Chaitanya quoted in this connection a verse from the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Fourteenth Chapter [20, 21], in which the Lord says, “My dear Uddhava, neither philosophical speculation nor Yoga achievements nor penances can give Me such pleasure as can devotional service practiced by the living entities.” He can only be achieved by devotional service, as He is dear only to the devotees. If a person born in the lowest family of humanity is a devotee, then he becomes freed from all contamination. Devotional service is the only path by which to achieve the Supreme Personality of God.

This is the only perfection accepted in all Vedic literature. As a poor man upon receiving some treasure becomes at once happy, so, when one attains to devotional service, automatically the pains of material existence are vanquished. As one advances in devotional service, one attains love of Godhead, and as he advances in the love for the Supreme he becomes free from all material bondage. The disappearance of poverty and liberation from bondage are not, however, the end results of love of Krishna. Actually, the love of Krishna, love of God, exists in relishing the reciprocation of loving service. In all Vedic literature one will find that attainment of this loving relationship between the Supreme Lord and the living entities is the function of devotional service. Our actual function is devotional service, and our ultimate goal of achievement is love of Godhead. Therefore, in all Vedic literature Krishna is the ultimate center. By knowledge of Krishna all problems of life are solved.

The Lord said that, according to Padma Purana, there are different Puranas for worshipping different types of demigods; but such indications for worship only bewilder persons into thinking that the demigods are supreme. And yet, if the Puranas are scrutinized and studied it will be found that Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is the only Object of worship. For example, in the Markandio Purana there is mention of Devi worship, worship of the goddess Durga or Kali. But in that same Chandika it is also stated that all these demigods—even in the shape of Durga or Kali—are different energies of Vishnu. Therefore, even the study of the Puranas will reveal Vishnu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, to be the only Object of worship.

The conclusion is that, directly or indirectly, all types of worship are more or less indicating a worship of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna. In the Bhagavad Gita [9.23] it is confirmed that anyone who worships the demigods is in fact only worshipping Krishna, because the demigods are different parts of the Body of Vishnu, or Krishna. That such worship of demigods is really irregular is also clearly stated in the Bhagavad Gita.

Srimad Bhagwatam [11.21.42] confirms this by the question: What is the object of worshipping the different types of demigods? In Vedic literature there are various divisions of ritualistic activities. One is called Karmakanda, or purely ritualistic activities; another is called Upasana-kanda, or speculating on the Supreme Absolute Truth. What then is the purpose of the ritualistic sections of Vedic literature, and what is the purpose of different mantras or hymns indicating the worship of different types of demigods? And what is the purpose of philosophical speculation on the subject of the Absolute Truth? The Srimad Bhagwatam [11.21.43] replies that all these different methods defined in Vedic literature indicate the worship of the Supreme Lord, Vishnu. They are all indirect ways of worshipping the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Sacrifices contained in the ritualistic portion of the literature are to satisfy the Supreme Lord Vishnu, because Yajna, sacrifice, is specifically meant to satisfy Vishnu. Vishnu’s Name is also Yajneshwara, or Lord of the Sacrifices.

The neophytes are not all on the transcendental level, and therefore, according to their situations in the different modes of material Nature, they are advised to worship different types of demigods so that, gradually, they may rise to the transcendental plane and be engaged in the devotional service of Vishnu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. For example, it may be said that some of the neophytes are attached to flesh-eating; and for them the Puranas prescribe that they can eat flesh after offering it to the deity Kali.

The philosophical sections of the Vedic hymns are meant to enable one to distinguish the Supreme Personality of Godhead from Maya. After indicating the position of Maya, the Supreme Personality of Godhead is approached in pure devotional service. That is the purpose of philosophical speculation. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita in the Seventh Chapter [19]: Bahunam janmanam ante: “The philosophical speculators and empiric philosophers, after speculating for many, many births, ultimately come unto the Supreme Lord Krishna, and accept that Vasudeva (Krishna) is everything.” Therefore, all Vedic rituals and different types of worship or philosophical speculation ultimately aim at Krishna.

The Lord then told Sanatan Goswami about Krishna’s multiforms and His unlimited opulence. He also described the nature of the spiritual manifestation, the material manifestation, and the manifestation of the living entity. He also informed Sanatan Goswami that the planets in the Spiritual Sky, known as Vaikunthas, and the Universes of the material manifestation, are to be known as different types of manifestations; for they are creative manifestations of the two different types of energies—namely, the material energy and the spiritual energy. Therefore, as far as Krishna Himself is concerned, He is directly situated in His spiritual energy, or specifically in His internal potency.

To help us understand the difference between the manifestation of the spiritual energy and the material energy, there is clear analysis of the two in the Second Canto of Srimad Bhagwatam. Also, Sukadeva Goswami, by commenting on Verse One of the Tenth Canto, makes a similar clear, analytical study. Lord Chaitanya accepts Sukadeva Goswami. as an authorized commentator on the Srimad Bhagwatam. Therefore He quotes his writing in this connection; and He explains that in the Tenth Canto of the Bhagwatam the life and activities of Krishna are described because Krishna is the Shelter of all other manifestations. Therefore Sukadeva Goswami worshipped and offered his obeisances unto Krishna, the Shelter of everything.

This purport maintains that in this world there are two different principles: the one principle is the origin, or the shelter of everything, and the other principle is the deduction from the original principle. The Supreme Truth is the shelter of all manifestations. That Supreme Truth is called Asraya. All other principles, which remain under the control of the Asraya-tattwa, or the Absolute Truth, are called Asrita, or subordinate corollaries and reactions. The purpose of the material manifestation is to give the conditioned soul a chance to become liberated and return to the Asraya-tattwa, or the Absolute Truth.

So everything that is in the cosmic Creation is dependent on the Asraya-tattwa, the Supreme Absolute Truth. As such, the creative manifestation, or Vishnu manifestation, the different types of demigods and manifestations of energy, the living entities, the material elements—everything is dependent on Krishna, the Supreme Truth. Srimad Bhagwatam indicates that everything, directly and indirectly, has Krishna as the Supreme Shelter. Therefore the analytical study of Krishna is the perfect knowledge, as is confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita.

Lord Chaitanya described the different features of Lord Krishna in the following manner, and asked Sanatan Goswami to hear attentively: He said that Krishna originally is the Son of Nanda Maharaj, and He is the Absolute Supreme Truth. He is the Cause of all causes, and He is the Origin of all emanations and all incarnations, yet there in Vraja or Goloka Vrindaban He is just like a young boy. His Form is eternal, full of bliss and full of knowledge absolute. He is the Shelter of everything, and He is the Proprietor or Master of everything.

In this connection Lord Chaitanya gives evidence from Brahma Samhita, Fifth Chapter, 1st verse, which states that Krishna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and His Body is full of knowledge, eternal and blissful. He is the Original Person, known as Govinda, and He is the Cause of all causes. Therefore, Krishna is the Original Personality of Godhead; He is full of all six opulences, and His Abode is known as Goloka Vrindaban, the highest planetary system in the Spiritual Sky.

Lord Chaitanya also quotes a verse from the Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto, Third Chapter [1.3.28], in which it is stated clearly that all the incarnations described in that particular verse are either direct expansions of Krishna, or are, indirectly, expansions of the expansions of Krishna. But the Krishna Name mentioned there is the Original Personality of Godhead, and He appears on this Earth, in this Universe or in any other Universe, when there is a disturbance created by the demons, who are always trying to disrupt the administration of the demigods.

To understand Krishna there are three different processes: the process of empiric philosophical speculation, the process of meditation in the mystic Yoga system, and the process of Krishna Consciousness, or devotional service. Accordingly, in these different processes: I) by empiric philosophical speculation, the impersonal Brahman feature of Krishna is understood; 2) by the process of meditation or Yoga mysticism, the feature of the Supersoul, the All-pervading expansion of Krishna, is understood; and 3) by devotional service in full Krishna Consciousness, the Original Personality of Godhead, Krishna is realized.

In this connection Lord Chaitanya quotes first from the Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto, Second Chapter [11], which states that those who are knowers of the Absolute Truth describe the Absolute Truth in three features: some describe the Absolute as impersonal Brahman, and some describe the Absolute Truth as the localized All-pervading Supersoul, and some know that the Absolute Truth is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna. In other words, Brahman, the impersonal manifestation, and Paramatma, the localized manifestation, and the Supreme Personality of Godhead, are One and the same; but, according to the different processes adopted, He is realized in different features—Brahman, Paramatma and Bhagavan.

Impersonal Brahman realization is simple realization of the effulgence emanating from the transcendental Body of Krishna. We compare this effulgence of the transcendental Body of Krishna to the sunshine: just as the sun disc is there, the sun planet is there, and the Sungod is there, and the sunshine is the shining effulgence of that original Sungod. Similarly, Brahmajyoti, the spiritual effulgence, impersonal Brahman, is nothing but the Personal effulgence of Krishna.

To support this analysis Lord Chaitanya quotes one important verse from Brahma Samhita [5.40], where Lord Brahma says: “I worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Govinda, by Whose Personal effulgence there is the unlimited manifestation of the Brahmajyoti, and in that Brahmajyoti (the impersonal manifestation of Krishna’s Bodily effulgence) there are innumerable Universes, each full of innumerable planets.”

Lord Chaitanya further says that the Paramatma, the All-pervading feature situated in everyone’s body, is but a partial manifestation or expansion of Krishna. But because Krishna is the Soul of the soul, there He is called Paramatma, Supreme Self. Lord Chaitanya now quoted a verse from Srimad Bhagwatam [10.14.55] concerning the talks of Maharaj Parikshit and Sukadeva Goswami. In that verse it is understood that Maharaj Parikshit, while hearing about the transcendental Pastimes of Krishna in Vrindaban, inquired from his Spiritual Master, Sukadeva Goswami, as to why the inhabitants of Vrindaban were so much attached to Krishna. To this question Sukadeva Goswami answered that Krishna should be known as the Soul of all souls. He is the Soul of all individual souls, and He is also the soul of the localized Paramatma. He was acting just like a human being to attract persons to Him and to show that He is not formless.

He is as good as other living beings, but He is the Supreme and other living beings are all subordinate to Him. All living beings therefore can enjoy spiritual bliss, eternal life and full knowledge in His association. Lord Chaitanya also quotes a verse from Bhagavad Gita [10.42], in which the Supreme Lord speaks to Arjuna about His different kinds of opulences, saying that He Himself enters into this Universe by one of His plenary portions, Garbodakshayee Vishnu, and He also enters into each Universe as the Kshirodakshayee Vishnu, and then expands Himself as Supersoul in everyone’s heart. Therefore, He says, if anyone wants to understand the Supreme Absolute Truth in perfection, he must take to the process of devotional service in full Krishna Consciousness. Then it will be possible for him to understand the last word of the Absolute Truth.

TLC 6-1968: His Forms Are One and the Same

Chapter Six

His Forms Are One and the Same

By devotional service one can understand that Krishna first of all manifests Himself as Svayamrupa, His Personal Form, then as Tadekatmarupa, and then as Avesharupa. In these three features He manifests Himself in His transcendental Form. The feature of Svayamrupa is the Form in which Krishna can be understood by one who may not understand His other features. In other words, the Form in which Krishna is directly understood is called Svayamrupa, or His Personal Form. The Tadekatmarupa is that Form which most resembles the Svayamrupa, but has some differences of bodily features. This Tadekatmarupa is divided into two manifestations, called the Personal expansion and the Pastime expansion. As far as Avesharupa is concerned, sometimes Krishna empowers some suitable living entity to represent Him. When a living entity acts as a representative of the Supreme Lord, he is called Avesharupa, or Shaktavesha Avatara.

His Personal Form is again divided into two: Svayamrupa and Svayaprakash. As far as His Svayamrupa (or Pastime Form) is concerned, it is in that Form that He remains always in Vrindaban with all the inhabitants of Vrindaban. That Personal Form is again divided into two, known categorically as the Prabhava and Baibhava Forms. For example, Krishna expanded Himself in multiple Forms in the Rasa Dance. When He danced with the Gopis, He expanded Himself in multiple Forms to dance with each and every Gopi who took part in that dance. Similarly, He expanded Himself into 16,108 Forms at Dwarka when He married 16,108 wives.

There are some instances of great mystics also expanding their bodily features in a different way, but that sort of expansion by the Yoga process is not applicable to Krishna. In the Vedic history, for example, Saubhary Rishi, a sage, expanded himself into eight forms by the Yoga process, but that expansion was simply a manifestation, for Saubhary remained one. But as far as Krishna is concerned, when He manifested Himself in different Forms, each and every one of them was a separate individual. When Narada Muni visited Krishna at different palaces at Dwarka, he was astonished at this, and yet Narada is never astonished to see the expansion of the body of a Yogi since he knows the trick himself. Yet, in a verse in the Srimad Bhagwatam, it states that Narada was astonished to see the expansions of Krishna. He wonders how the Lord was present in each and every house of the 16,108 palaces with His queens.

Krishna Himself was in a different Form with each queen, and He was acting in different ways. For example, in one Form He was talking with His wife, in another Form He was engaged with His children, and in yet another Form He was performing some household work. These different activities are called actions in the Lord’s different emotions, and when He is in these “emotional” Forms, the expansions are known as Vaibhavaprakash. Similarly, there are other unlimited expansions of the Forms of Krishna, but even when they are divided or expanded without limit, they are still one and the same. There is no difference between one Form and another; that is the Absolute nature of the Personality of Godhead.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam it is stated, in the Tenth Canto, Fortieth Chapter, that at the time when Akrura was carrying both Krishna and Valaram from Gokula to Mathura, he entered into the water of the Yamuna River and could see in the waters all the spiritual planets in the Spiritual Sky. He saw there the Lord in His Vishnu Form, along with Narada and the four Kumaras, and he saw how they were worshipping. This is described in the Srimad Bhagwatam as “Form.” It is stated in the Bhagavat Purana [10.40.7] that there are many worshippers who are purified by different processes of worship, such as the Vaishnava, or the Aryans, who also worship the Supreme Lord according to their convictions and their spiritual understanding. Each process of worship involves the understanding of different Forms of the Lord, as mentioned in the Scriptures, but the ultimate idea is to worship the Supreme Lord Himself.

In the feature of His Vaibhavaprakash the Lord manifests Himself as Valaram. The feature of Valaram is as good as Krishna; the difference is that Krishna is blackish and Valaram is whitish. The Vaibhavaprakash Form was also displayed when Krishna appeared in the four-handed Form of Narayana before Devaki when He entered this world, and then at the request of His parents He transformed Himself into a two-handed Form. Therefore, sometimes He becomes four-handed and sometimes He becomes two-handed. When He is in a Form of two hands, that is actually Vaibhavaprakash, and when He is four-handed, that is Vrabhavavilasa. In His Personal Form He is just like a cowherd boy, and He thinks Himself that; but when He is in the Vasudeva Form He thinks Himself the son of a Kshatriya, and He feels Himself also to be a Kshatriya, a princely administrator.

Form, Opulence, Beauty, Wealth, Attractiveness and Pastimes are fully exhibited in His Form as the Son of Nanda. In some of the Vaishnava literature it is found that sometimes, in His Form as Vasudeva, He becomes attracted to the Form of Govinda in Vrindaban. Sometimes, as Vasudeva, He desires to enjoy as Govinda does, although the Govinda Form and the Vasudeva Form are one and the same. There is a passage in the Laleeta Madhava, Fourth Chapter [4.19], in which Krishna addresses Uddhava as follows: “My dear friend, this Govinda Form as a cowherd boy attracts Me. I wish to be like the damsels of Vraja, attracted by this Govinda Form.” Similarly, in the Eighth Chapter [8.34], Krishna says: “O how wonderful It is! Who is this Personality? After seeing Him I am attracted by Him, so that now I am desiring to embrace Him just like Radhika.” When this Form of Krishna becomes a little differentiated, it is called Tadekatma.

In this Tadekatmarupa Form there are two divisions also: One is called Svamsa. Both in the Vilasa and Svamsa Forms there are again many differential features, which are also divided into Prabhava and Baibhava. As far as the Vilasa Forms are concerned, there are innumerable Prabhava Vilasas: Krishna expands Himself as Vasudeva, Samkarshan, Pradyumna, Aniruddha. Sometimes the Lord thinks Himself a cowherd boy, and sometimes He thinks Himself the son of Vasudeva, a Kshatriya—and this “thinking” of Krishna is called “Pastimes.”

In His Prabhava Prakasa and Prabhava Vilasa He is in the same Form, but appears differently as Krishna and Valadeva. His expansion as Vasudeva, Samkarshan, Pradyumna and Aniruddha, mentioned above, is in the Original Chaturvuha, or four-armed Forms.

There are innumerable four-armed manifestations in different planets and different places. For instance, these four-armed manifestations are both in Dwarka and Mathura eternally. And from these four Forms originally there are the principle twenty-four Forms, named differently in terms of the different adjustments of the symbols held in the hands—and they are called Baibhava Vilasa. The same four Formal manifestations of Krishna are on each planet of the Spiritual Sky, called the Narayan Loka or Vaikuntha Loka. In the Vaikuntha Loka He is manifested in a four-handed Form, called Narayan. And from each Narayan there is a manifestation of the four Forms mentioned above (Vasudeva, Samkarshan, Pradyumna and Aniruddha). Therefore, Narayan is in the center, and the four Forms surround the Narayan Form.

Each of the four Forms again expands into three, and they all have their different Names, beginning from Kesava. They are twelve in all. Such Forms are known by different Names according to the different placements of the symbols in the hands of Narayan.

As far as the Vasudeva Form is concerned, the three expansions are Kesava, Narayana, and Madhava. The three Forms of Govinda are known as Govinda, Vishnu, and Sri Madhusudan. It should be noted, however, that this Govinda Form is not the same Govinda Form as manifested in Vrindaban (as the Son of Nanda). Similarly, Pradyumna is also divided into three Forms known as Trivikrama, Vamana, and Sridhar; and, similarly, there are three Forms of Aniruddha, known as Hrishikesha, Padmanava and Damodara.

TLC 7-1968: Unlimited Forms of Godhead

Chapter Seven

Unlimited Forms of Godhead

These twelve different Vaikuntha Forms of Lord Krishna are known as the predominating deities for the twelve months. According to the Vaishnava almanac, the months are called by the different Names of Krishna. This calendar begins from the month of Margasirsa, equivalent to late October-November. The month of November is known by the Vaishnavas as Kesava. December is called Narayan. January is called Madhab, and February is Govinda. March is Vishnu, April Vasudeva, May Trivikram and June Vamana. July is called Sridhar; August Hrishikesha, September is called Padmanava and October is Damodar.

This Damodar is different from the Damodar in Vraja. The Name Damodar was given when Krishna was bound by ropes by His mother—but the Damodar Form in the month of October is a different manifestation. Similarly, the Vaishnava community marks different parts of the body and each mark is known by one of these twelve different Names of the Supreme Lord. The mark on the forehead is called Kesava, and on the belly, the breast and on the arms there are different Names, the same as those of the months.

The four Forms, Vasudeva, Samkarshan, Pradyumna and Aniruddha, are also expanded in the Vilasa Murti. These are eight in number, and their Names are Purushottam, Achyuta, Nrishingha, Janardana, Hari, Krishna, Adhoksaja and Upendra. Out of these eight Names, two Names, Adhoksaja and Purushottam, are the Vilasa or Forms of Vasudeva. Similarly, Upendra and Achyuta are the Forms of Sanikarshan; Nrishingha and Janardana are the Vilasa Forms of Pradyumna; and Hari and Krishna are the two Vilasa Forms of Aniruddha. This Krishna is different from the original Krishna.

These twenty-four Forms are known as the Vilasa manifestation of the Pravhav (four-handed) Form, and they are differently named according to the different position of the symbolic representations, that is, the mace, the disc, the lotus flower and the conch shell. Out of these twenty-four Forms, there is also a division of Vilasa and Baibhava. Names mentioned herein, such as Pradyumna, Trivikram, Vamana, Hari and Krishna are also different in features. Then, corning to the Prahava Vilasa of Krishna, which is Vasudeva, Samkarshan, Pradyumna and Aniruddha; there are a total of twenty further variations. All of them have Vaikuntha planets in the Spiritual Sky, which are situated in eight different directions. And, although each of them is eternally in the Spiritual Sky, still, some of them manifest in the material world also.

In the Spiritual Sky all the planets dominated by the feature of Narayan are eternal. And the topmost planet in the Spiritual Sky is called Krishna Loka. That Krishna Loka is divided into three different portions: Gokula, Mathura, and Dwarka. In the Mathura portion the Form of Kesava is always situated. He is also represented on this earthly planet. In India there is a place called Mathura where Kesava Murti is worshipped and, similarly, there is a Purushottam Form in Jagannath Puri in Orissa. In Anandaranya there is the Form of Vishnu, and in Mayapur, the birthplace of Lord Chaitanya, there is the Form of Hari. Many other Forms are situated elsewhere on this earthly planet.

Not only in this Universe, but in all the other Universes such Forms are distributed everywhere. On this earthly planet also it is indicated that all the world is divided into seven islands, and it is understood that on each and every island there are similar Forms. But at the present moment they are found only in India. They are indicated to be in other parts of the world, but at present there is no information telling where they are situated. But from Vedic literature we can understand that there are Forms in other parts of the world.

These different Forms of Krishna are distributed all over the world and the Universes to give pleasure to the devotees. Not that the devotees are only born in India. Actually, in all parts of the world, there are devotees who have simply forgotten their identity. Such Forms-incarnate come not only to give pleasure to the devotee but to re-establish devotional service, and to perform other activities which vitally concern the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Some of them are incarnations as mentioned in the Scriptures, such as the Vishnu incarnation, Trivikram incarnation, Nrishingha incarnation and Vamana incarnation.

In the Siddhartha Samhita there is a description of the twentyfour Forms of Vishnu, named differently in terms of the different symbolic representations in the four hands. When describing the different positions of paraphernalia in the hands of Vishnu Murti, the counting should begin first with the lower right hand, then to the upper right hand, next to the upper left hand and, lastly, to the lower left hand. In this way Vasudeva is represented by club, conch shell, wheel and lotus flower. Sarnkarshan is represented by club, conch shell, lotus flower and wheel. Similarly, Pradyumna is represented by wheel, conch shell, club and lotus flower. Aniruddha is represented by wheel, club, conch shell and lotus flower.

In the Spiritual Sky the representations of Narayan, twenty in number, are calculated as follows: Hrishikesha is represented by conch shell, wheel, flower and club. Narayan is represented by conch shell, lotus flower, club and wheel. Sri Madhava is represented by club, wheel, conch shell and lotus flower. Sri Govinda is represented by wheel, club, lotus flower and conch shell. Vishnu Murti is represented by club, lotus flower, conch shell and wheel. Madhusudan is represented by wheel, conch shell, lotus flower and club. Trivikram is represented by lotus flower, club, wheel and lotus flower. Sridhar is represented by lotus flower, wheel, club and conch shell. Padmanava is represented by conch shell, lotus flower, wheel and club. Damodar is represented by lotus flower, wheel, club and conch shell. Purushottam is represented by wheel, lotus flower, conch shell, and club. Sri Achyuta is represented by club, lotus flower, wheel and conch shell. Sri Nrishingha is represented by wheel, lotus flower, club and conch shell. Janardan is represented by lotus flower, wheel, conch shell and club. Sri Hari is represented by conch shell, wheel, lotus flower and club. Sri Krishna is represented by conch shell, club, lotus flower and wheel. Adhoksaja is represented by lotus flower, club, conch shell and wheel. Upendra is represented by conch shell, club, wheel and lotus flower.

According to Hayasirsha Pancharatra there are sixteen Forms, and they are all different in Name, in terms of the wheel and club being differently situated.

The conclusion is that the Supreme Original Personality of Godhead is Krishna—He is called Leela Purushottam, and He is principally in Vrindaban as the Son of Nanda. It is also learned from the Hayasirsha Pancharacha that nine forms are protecting two Puris, known as the Mathura Puri and the Dwarka Puri: the four Forms of Vasudeva, Samkarshan, Pradyumna, and Aniruddha, and besides these four Forms, there are Narayan Forms, Nrishingha Forms, Hayagriva Forms, Varaha Forms and Brahma. The above descriptions are different manifestations of the Prakasa and Vilasa Forms of Lord Krishna.

Now Lord Chaitanya informs Sanatan Goswami that there are different Forms of the Svamsa also: Svamsa Forms are divided into the Samkarshan division and the incarnation division. From the Samkarshan division come the three Purusha Avatars: the Karanodakshayee Vishnu, Garbhodakshayee Vishnu and Kshirodakshayee Vishnu. The other division is called Leela avatars, such as the Lord’s incarnation as a Fish, as a Tortoise, etc.

There are six kinds of incarnations: 1. the Purusha Avatar incarnations, 2. the Leela Avatar incarnation, 3. the Guna Avatar, 4. the Manu Avatar, 5. the Yuga Avatar, and 6. the Saktavesh Avatar. Out of six kinds of Vilasa manifestations of Krishna there are two divisions based on His age. They are called Balya and Pauganda. The original Form of Krishna as the Son of Nanda enjoys in two Forms of childhood, namely Balya and Pauganda.

The conclusion is that there is no end to the expansions and incarnations of Krishna. Here Lord Chaitanya describes some of them to Sanatan just to give him an idea of how the Lord is expanding and how He is enjoying. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, in the First Canto, Third Chapter [26]. It is said there that there is no limit to the emanations of incarnations of the Supreme Lord, just as there is no limit to the waves of the ocean.

Krishna’s first incarnation is as the three Purusa Avatars, namely the Maha Vishnu (or Karanodakshayee) Avatar, Garbhodakshayee Avatar and Kshirodakshayee Avatar. This is confirmed in the Sasvata, Tantra.

Krishna’s energies are also divisible into three: His energy of thinking, His energy of feeling, and His energy of acting. In His energy of thinking He is the Supreme Lord, in His energy of feeling He is Lord Vasudeva, and in His energy of acting He is Samkarshan Valaram. Without thinking, feeling, and acting there could be no possibility of the Creation. Although there is no creation of the Spiritual World, yet there is the creation of this material world. But both the Spiritual World and the material world are manifestations of the energy of acting—in the Form of Samkarshan and Valaram—of Krishna.

The Spiritual World, the Vaikuntha planets and Krishna Loka, is situated in His energy of thinking. Although there is no creation of the eternal Spiritual World, still it is to be understood that they depend on the thinking energy of the Supreme Lord. This thinking energy is described in the Brahma Samhita, Fifth Chapter, second verse. It is said there that the Supreme Abode, known as Goloka, is manifested just like a lotus flower with hundreds of petals. Everything is manifested by the Ananta or Valaram or Samkarshan Form. The material cosmic manifestation and the different Universes are manifest through the Maya, or material energy. The material Nature or material energy is not the cause of all this cosmic manifestation. It is caused by the Supreme Lord, by His different expansions through the material Nature; and without the superintendence of the Supreme Lord there is no possibility of any creation.

The Form by which the energy of the material Nature works to bring about creation is called Samkarshan. It is understood that under the superintendent energy of the Supreme Lord this cosmic manifestation is created. The example is given: iron becomes hot in contact with fire, and when it is red hot, it is just like fire.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Forty-sixth Chapter, it is said that Rama and Krishna are the Origin of all living entities. These two Personalities enter into everything. A list of the incarnations occurs in the Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto, Third Chapter, as follows: 1. Kumaras, 2. Narada, 3. Varaha, 4. Matsya, 5. Yajna, 6. Naranarayan, 7. Kardemikapeel, 8. Duttatreya, 9. Hayasirsha, 10. Hansa, 11. Dhruvapriya Prishni Garva, 12. Rishava, 13. Prithu, 14. Nrishingha, 15. Kurma, 16. Dhanvantari, 17. Mohini, 18. Vamana, 19. Bhargava, 20. Raghavendra, 21. Vyas, 22. Pralambari Valarama, 23. Krishna, 24. Buddha, 25. Kalki. Almost all of these twenty-five Leela Avatars appear in one day of Brahma, which is called a Kalpa, and sometimes they are called Kalpa Avatars. Out of these, the incarnation of Hansa Mohini is not permanent; but Kapila, Dattatreya, Rishava, Dhanvantari and Vyas are five eternal Forms, and they are more celebrated. The incarnations of the Tortoise, the Fish, Naranarayan, Baraha, Hayagriva, Prisnigarbha, and Valadeva are considered as incarnations of Vaibhava. Similarly, there are three incarnations of the qualitative modes of Nature. They are called Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva.

Of the Manvantara Avatars,there are fourteen: 1. Yajna, 2. Bibhu, 3. Satyasen, 4. Hari, 5. Vaikuntha, 6. Arjita, 7. Vaman, 8. Sarbabhouma, 9. Rishava, 10. Viswaksen, 11. Dharmasetu, 12. Sudhama, 13. Yogeswar, 14. Vrihatbhanu. Out of these fourteen Manvatar incarnations, Yajna and Vamana are also Leela Avatars. The balance are Pastime Manvantar Avatars. These fourteen Manvantar Avatars are also known as Bhaiva Avatars.

The four Yuga Avatars are also described in the Bhagwatam: in the Satya Yuga the incarnation of God is white, in the Treta Yuga the incarnation of God is red, in the Dvarpara Yuga the incarnation of God is blackish; and the incarnation in the Kali Yuga is also blackish, but sometimes in a special Kali Yuga the color is yellowish. So far as the Saktavesh Avatars are concerned, they include Kapila and Rishava, the Saktavesh Avatar, Ananta, Brahma (sometimes the Lord Himself becomes Brahma), Satyasen as the incarnation of knowledge, Narada as the incarnation of devotional service, King Prithu as the incarnation of administrative power and Rishava as the incarnation of subduing evil principles.

TLC 8-1968: The Avataras

Chapter Eight

The Avataras

Lord Chaitanya continued: The expansions of Lord Krishna Who come to the material Creation are called Avataras or incarnations. Avatara means one who descends from the higher Spiritual Sky. In the Spiritual Sky there are innumerable Vaikuntha planets, and from such a planet the expansion of the Supreme Personality of Godhead comes into this Universe, and therefore He is called Avatara. Avataran means to descend.

The first descent of the Supreme Personality of Godhead from the expansion of Samkarshan is the Purusha incarnation. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, both in the First Canto, Third Chapter, as well as in the Sixth Chapter. It is said there that the Supreme Personality of Godhead descends as the first Purusha incarnation for the material Creation, and He immediately manifests sixteen elementary energies. He is known as Maha Vishnu, lying on the Causal Ocean, and He is the Original incarnation in the material world. He is the Lord of time, Nature, cause' and effect, mind, ego, and the five elements, the three modes of nature, the senses, and the Universal Form. He is independent, and the Master of all objects movable and immovable in the material world [2.6.2].

The influence of material Nature cannot reach beyond the Viroja, or Causal Ocean, and this is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Second Canto, Ninth Chapter. On the Vaikuntha planets there is no influence of the modes of material Nature. There is no mixture of the modes of goodness, passion, and ignorance, and neither is there any influence of material time. On those planets the liberated associates of Krishna live eternally, and they are worshipped both by the demigods and the demons.

The material Nature acts in two capacities, as Maya and Pradhana. Maya is the direct cause and Pradhana means the elements of material manifestation. The first Purusha Avatara, Maha Vishnu, glances over the material Nature and thereby the material Nature becomes agitated, and the Purusha Avatara thus impregnates matter with the living entities. By this glancing, consciousness is created, and consciousness is known as Maha Tattwa. The predominating deity of Maha Tattwa is Vasudeva. Consciousness is then divided into three departmental activities, under the three gunas, or modes of material Nature. Consciousness in the mode of goodness is described in the Srimad Bhagwatam Eleventh Canto, and the predominating deity is called Aniruddha. Consciousness in the mode of material passion produces intelligence, and the predominating deity is called Pradyurnna. He is the Master of the senses. Consciousness in the mode of ignorance is the cause of production of the ether, the sky, and the cause of production of the hearing instrument, the ear. The cosmic manifestation is the combination of all these, and thereby innumerable Universes are created. Nobody can count how many Universes there are.

These innumerable Universes are being produced from the pores on the body of Maha Vishnu. It is also said that, as innumerable atoms are coming and going through the holes in a window, so from the pores of the body of Maha Vishnu innumerable Universes emanate. From His breathing also innumerable Universes are being produced and annihilated. All His energies are spiritual—they have nothing to do with the material energy. In the Brahma Samhita [5.48] this fact is stated also. In the fifth Chapter, 54th verse, it is said that the predominating deity of each Universe, Brahma, lives only during one breath of Maha Vishnu. Maha Vishnu again is the original Supersoul of all the Universes, and He is also the Master of all the Universes. That is the description of the first incarnation, known as Maha Vishnu.

The second Vishnu incarnation enters into each and every Universe. In each and every Universe He spreads water from His body, and on that water He lies down. From His navel the stem of a lotus flower grows, and on that lotus flower the first creature, Brahma, is born. Within the stem of that lotus flower there are fourteen divisions of planetary systems, which are created by Brahma.

In each Universe the Lord as Vishnu maintains the Universe, tending to its needs, and although He is within the Universe, the influence of material energy cannot touch Him. The same Vishnu, when it is required, takes the Form of Lord Shiva and annihilates the cosmic creation. These three secondary incarnations; namely, Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva, are the predominating deities of the three modes of material Nature. The second incarnation of Vishnu, known as Garbhodakshayee, is worshipped as the Hiranygarbha Supersoul, Who has thousands of heads, as described in the Vedic hymns. This second incarnation, Garbhodakshayee Vishnu, is the Master of the Universe, and in each Universe there is a manifestation of the Garbhodakshayee Vishnu. Although He is within the material Nature, still He is not touched by it.

The third incarnation of Vishnu is also an incarnation of the mode of goodness. As the Kshirodhakshayee Vishnu, He is also the Supersoul of all living entities, and He resides on the ocean of milk within the Universe. Thus Lord Chaitanya described the Purusha Avatars.

He then described the Leela Avatars: He said that there is no limit or counting for the Leela, or “Pastime,” Avatars, but some of them are described by the Lord, for example: Matsya, Kurma, Raghunath, Nrishingha, Vamana and Baraha.

A description of the qualitative incarnations of Vishnu, or Guna Avatars, is as follows: Brahma is one of the living entities, but he is very powerful on account of his devotional service. Such a primal living entity, by the influence of the mode of material passion, is situated as Brahma. He is made powerful by Garbhodakshayee Vishnu directly, and therefore Brahma has power to create innumerable living entities. A description of Brahma is given in the Brahma Samhita, Fifth Chapter, 50th Verse. Brahma is likened to the valuable stones influenced by the rays of the Sun, and the Sun is likened to the Supreme Lord Garbhodakshayee Vishnu. If in some Kalpa there is no suitable living entity who can act in the position of Brahma, then Garbhodakshayee Vishnu Himself manifests as Brahma and acts in that way.

Similarly, by expanding Himself as Lord Shiva, He is engaged when there is a necessity to annihilate the Bramhanda. Lord Shiva, in association with Maya, has many Forms; generally, they are numbered at eleven. Lord Shiva is not one of the living entities—he is more-or-less Krishna Himself. The example is given of the distinction between milk and yogurt. Yogurt is a preparation of milk, but still yogurt cannot be used as milk. Similarly, Lord Shiva is an expansion of Krishna, but he cannot act as Krishna, nor can we derive the spiritual restoration from Lord Shiva that we can derive from Krishna. The essential difference is that Lord Shiva has a connection with the material Nature, but Vishnu has nothing to do with the material Nature. In Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Eighteenth Chapter [10.88.3], it is said that Lord Shiva is a combination of the three kinds of transformed consciousness, known as Baikrik, Taijsa and Tamasa.

The Vishnu incarnation, although Master of the modes of goodness within each Universe, is in no way in touch with the influence of material Nature. Everything of Vishnu is equal to Krishna, but still Krishna is the original Source. Vishnu is partial, and Krishna is whole. This is the version of the Vedic literature. In the Brahma Samhita [5.46] there is the example of an original lamp which lights a second lamp; although both the lamps are of equal candle power, still one is accepted as the original, and the other is said to be kindled by the original lamp. The Vishnu expansion is like that. He is Vishnu, He is equally powerful, but the original Vishnu is Krishna. Brahma and Lord Shiva are obedient servants of the Supreme Lord and the Supreme Lord as Vishnu is an expansion of Krishna.

After describing the Leela Avatara and Guna Avatara, Lord Chaitanya then explained to Sanatan Goswami about the Manvantara Avatara. He states that there is no counting of the Manvantara Avatara. The Manus are fourteen in one Kalpa, or one day of Brahma. One day of Brahma is calculated at 432 million years, and during that period of time there are fourteen Manus. Brahma lives for 100 years on this scale. Therefore, during the lifetime of Brahma, if fourteen Manus appear in one day, then there are 420 Manus during the month of Brahma, and during the year of Brahma there are 5,040 Manus. Brahma lives for 100 years, and it is calculated that there are five hundred four thousand Manus in one Brahma’s duration of life. There are innumerable Universes, and one can just imagine how many Manvantara incarnations there are in the total.

The Universes are being produced by the breathing out of Maha Vishnu, and no one can calculate how many Manus there are at one time. Each Manu is called by a different name. The first Manu is called Svayambhuba. He is the son of Brahma personally. The second Manu is called Swarochis; he is the son of the predominating deity of fire. The third Manu is called Uttam; and he is the son of King Priyabratha. The fourth Manu is called Tamasa; and he is the brother of Uttama. The fifth Manu is called Raivata. He is the brother of Tamasa. The sixth Manu is also the brother of Tamasa. The sixth Manu is called Chaksus; and he is the son of Chaksu. The seventh Manu is called Baivasvata. He is the son of the Sungod, born of a different wife, whose name is Chakya. The ninth Manu is called Daksasavarni. He is the son of Baruna. The tenth Manu is called Brahmasavarni, and he is the son of Upsloka. Four other Manus are known as Rudrasavarni, Dharmasavarni, Indrasavarni, and Raichya. All are sons of Lord Shiva.

After finishing the description of the Manu incarnations, the Lord described to Sanatan Goswami the Yuga Avatars. He said that there are four Yugas, or millennia. The first Yuga is called Satya, the second is called Treta, the third is called Dvapara, and the fourth is called Kali. In each millennium the Lord takes different colors in different incarnations. In the Satya Yuga the color of the principal incarnation is white. In the Treta Yuga the color of the principal incarnation is red, and in the Dvapara Yuga the color of the principal incarnation is blackish—Krishna. And, in the Kali Yuga, the color of the principal incarnation is yellow. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Eighth Chapter, as spoken by Gargamuni while calculating the horoscope of Krishna in the house of Nanda Maharaj.

In the Satya Yuga the process of self-realization is meditation, and this process of meditation was taught by the incarnation of God in the color of whiteness. This incarnation gave benediction to the sage Kardum for obtaining, as his son, an incarnation of the Personality of Godhead. In the Satya Yuga everyone meditates on Krishna, and each and every living entity is in full knowledge. Other meditations, which are not recommended in this present age, are still being attempted as meditational processes by people who are not in full knowledge.

The process for self-realization in the Treta millennium is performance of different sacrifices, and this is taught by the incarnation of God in His red color. In the Dvapara millennium, Krishna is Personally present, and He is worshipped by everyone, and that is the process of self-realization for that age. Krishna is blackish in color, He is the incarnation Himself, and He induces people to worship Him, as is stated in the Bhagavad Gita. The Srimad Bhagwatam also, in the Eleventh Canto, Fifth Chapter [11.5.29], states that the worship of Krishna is made by the hymn: “Let me offer my obeisances unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Vasudeva.” This is the hymn generally practiced by the people to worship the Supreme Lord Krishna in the Dvapara millennium.

The next millennium is Kali Yuga, in which we are now. In this age the Lord incarnates to preach chanting of the Holy Name of Krishna. The Lord appears in this age in yellowish color, and He teaches people love of God by chanting the Name of Krishna. The process of teaching is done Personally by Krishna, and He exhibits His love of Godhead by chanting, singing, and dancing with thousands of people following Him. This particular incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is foretold in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Fifth Chapter [11.5.32]; in which it is stated that the Lord incarnates in the Age of Kali as a devotee, always chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare.

But, it is stated there, His complexion is not like the Krishna of the Dvapara Yuga. He is always engaged in preaching love of Godhead through the Samkirtan movement, and those who are intelligent adopt this process of selfrealization. It is also stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Twelfth Canto, Third Chapter [12.3.52], that the self-realization which could be achieved in the Satya millennium by meditation, in the Treta millennium by the performance of different sacrifices, and in the Dvapara millennium by worshipping the Lord Krishna, could be achieved in the Age of Kali simply by chanting these Holy Names: Hare Krishna. In the Vishnu Purana [6.2.17] also the same thing is confirmed: that for this age there is no use of meditation or the performance of sacrifices or temple worship. Simply by chanting the Holy Name of Krishna—Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare—one can achieve perfect self-realization.

When Lord Chaitanya was describing the incarnation in this Age of Kali, Sanatan Goswami, who had been a government minister and was perfectly capable of drawing a conclusion, indirectly asked Lord Chaitanya, “How can one understand the advent of an incarnation?” He could understand that Lord Chaitanya was the incarnation of Krishna, corroborating the description of the incarnation of the Kali millennium; and he also could understand that, in the future, there would be many imitation incarnations following the incarnation of Lord Chaitanya, because Lord Chaitanya played as an ordinary Brahmin boy, though His devotees accepted Him as an incarnation. Sanatan knew there would be many pretenders, and so he inquired from Lord Chaitanya: “How can one understand the symptoms of an incarnation?”

The Lord replied to the inquiry of Sanatan Goswami: “As one can understand different incarnation of different millenniums with reference to the context of the Vedic literature, similarly, one can understand who is actually the incarnation of Godhead in this Age of Kali.”

Specially stressed is the reference to authoritative Scriptures: one should try to understand the characteristics of an incarnation with reference to the Scripture, not whimsically. An incarnation of the Supreme Lord never declares Himself to be an incarnation. But His followers, with reference to the context of the authoritative Scriptures, must ascertain who is an incarnation and who is a pretender.

The real incarnation is described with reference to two features: the principal feature is called Personality, and the other is called the marginal feature. Any intelligent person can understand the characteristics of an Avatara, or incarnation, by these two features. There is a description of the characteristics of the body and of the activities. The description of the body is the principal feature for identifying an incarnation, and the activities are the marginal feature. This is confirmed in the beginning of Srimad Bhagwatam, where the features are very nicely described in the 1st verse of the First Canto. In that verse there are two terms, Param and Satyam. Lord Chaitanya indicated that the words Param and Satyam show Krishna in His principal feature. The other, marginal features are that He taught Vedic knowledge to Brahma, and that He incarnates as the Purusha Avatar to create the cosmic manifestation. These are occasional features for some special purposes.

One should try to understand and distinguish the principal feature and the marginal feature of an Avatar. Nobody can declare himself an incarnation without these two features, and therefore, any intelligent man will study the principal features and marginal features before accepting a pretender. Sanatan Goswami tried to confirm Lord Chaitanya’s Personal characteristics as those of the incarnation of this age, and Lord Chaitanya confirmed it—though not directly. He simply said: “Leave aside all this discussion, let us go on about the description of the Saktavesh Avatar.”

The Lord then said that there is no limit or counting of Saktavesh Avatars, but some of them can be mentioned as examples. The Saktavesh incarnation are of two kinds: one direct, and the other indirect. When the Lord Himself comes, He is called Shakshat, or direct Saktavesh Avatar, and when He empowers some living entity to represent Him, that one is called indirect, or Avesa, incarnation.

Examples of indirect Avatars are the four Kumaras, Narada, Prithu, and Parsuram. They are actually living entities, but there is specific power given to them by the Supreme Personality of God. Examples of direct, or Shakshat, Avatar are the Shesha incarnation or Ananta incarnation.

When a specific opulence of the Supreme Lord is invested in some specific entities, they are called Avesa Avatars, The four Kumaras represent the specific opulence of knowledge of the Supreme Lord. Narada specifically represents the devotional service of the Supreme Lord. The devotional service of the Lord is there also in Lord Chaitanya, Who is considered to be the full representation of devotional service. In Brahma the opulence of creative power is invested. In Ananta the power of the sustenance of all the planets is invested. In the Shesha incarnation the power is in serving the Supreme Lord. And in King Prithu is the power of maintaining the living entities. Similarly, in Parsuram the power of killing the evil elements is invested. So far as Vibhuti, or the special favor of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is concerned, there is a description in the Bhagavad Gita, Tenth Chapter. It is said there that any living entity who appears to be especially powerful or beautiful should be known as specifically favored by the Supreme Lord.

The Lord, after finishing the description of the Saktavesh incarnation, began to speak about the age of the Supreme Lord. He said that the Supreme Lord Krishna is always like a 16-year-old boy, and when He desires to descend to this Universe, He first of all sends His father and mother, who are His devotees, and then He advents Himself as the incarnation, or comes Personally. All His activities, beginning from the killing of the Putana demon, are being displayed in innumerable Universes, and there is no limit to them. At every moment, at every second, His manifestations of different Pastimes are seen in the different Brahmandas, or Universes. Therefore, His Pastime activities are just like the waves of the Ganges River: as there is no limit to the flowing of the waves of the Ganges, similarly, there is no cessation of the manifestations of the different features of Lord Krishna’s incarnation in different Universes. He displays from childhood many Pastime functions, and ultimately He exhibits the Rasa Dance.

It is said that all the Pastime functions of Krishna are eternal, and that is confirmed in every Scripture. People in general cannot understand how Pastimes are being performed by Krishna, but Lord Chaitanya gave a comparable instance in the orbit of the Sun. According to Vedic astrological calculation, the twenty-four hours of a day and night are divided into 60 Dandas. The days are again divided into three thousand six hundred Palaas. So the Sun disc can be perceived in every 60 Palaas, and the time constitutes a Danda. Eight Dandas make one Parahara, and the Sun rises and sets within four Paraharas. Similarly, four Paraharas constitute the duration of night, and after that the Sun is again seen as risen. Similarly, all the Pastimes of Krishna can be seen in any of the Brahmandas, just like the Sun can be seen in its movement through three thousand six hundred Palaas.

Lord Krishna remains in this Universe for 125 years only, but all the Pastimes of that period are exhibited in each and every Universe, including His Appearance, His Boyhood Pastimes, His Youth, and His manifestation of later Pastimes—until the last at Dwarka. All those Pastimes are present in one or another of the myriad Brahmandas, at any given time. Therefore the Pastimes are called eternal. In other words, as the Sun is eternally existing and we can see it rise and set due to our different planetary position, similarly, the Lord’s Pastimes are going on, but only at certain intervals can we see the Pastimes of Krishna in this particular Universe. As described above, His Abode is the Supreme Planet known as Goloka Vrindaban and, being Absolute, His Name, Fame, everything is equal to Krishna. And, by the will of Krishna, the same Goloka Vrindaban is manifested in this Universe and other Universes also.

Therefore, although the Lord is always in His Supreme Abode, Goloka Vrindaban, by His Supreme will the activities there are also manifested in the innumerable Universes; and when He appears, He appears in those particular places. And in every manifestation of Krishna the six opulences are displayed.

TLC 9-1968: The Opulences of Krishna

Chapter Nine

The Opulences of Krishna

Lord Chaitanya is especially merciful to the innocent, unsophisticated person. His name is Patitpavan, the Deliverer of the most fallen conditioned soul. A conditioned soul may be fallen to the lowest position, but that does not prevent him from advancing in spiritual science, provided he is innocent. Sanatan Goswami was considered to be fallen in the social status because he was in the service of the Mohammedan government, and had been excommunicated from the Brahmin society. But because he was a sincere soul Lord Chaitanya showed him special favor by granting him a wealth of information in the matter of spiritual science.

The Lord next explained to Sanatan Goswami about the situation of different spiritual planets in the Spiritual Sky. The spiritual planets are known as Vaikuntha planets. The Universes of the material Creation have a limited length and breadth; but so far as the Vaikuntha planets are concerned, because they are spiritual, there is no limitation to their dimensions. Lord Chaitanya informed Sanatan Goswami that the length and breadth of each and every Vaikuntha planet is hundreds and thousands of millions and billions of miles. Nobody can measure billions of miles or measure the actual extent of such Vaikuntha planets. Each of them is unlimitedly expanded, and in each and every one of them there are residents who are full with all six opulences—wealth, strength, knowledge, beauty, fame, and renunciation. And the Supreme Personality of Godhead is present in each. In each and every Vaikuntha planet a different expansion of Krishna has His eternal Abode. And Krishna has His original eternal Abode on the planet called Krishna Loka, or Goloka Vrindaban.

We have experience in this Universe that even the largest planet is lying in only one corner of outer space. For example the Sun is supposed to be some million times bigger than the Earth, and still it lies in one corner of outer space. Similarly each of the Vaikuntha planets, although unlimited in length and breadth, lies in some corner of the Spiritual Sky, known as Brahmajyoti. In the Brahma Samhita this Brahmajyoti is described as Niskla ananta Asesa, or undivided and unlimited, without any trace of the material modes of Nature. All the Vaikunthas are like the petals of a lotus flower, and the principal part of that lotus is the center of all the Vaikunthas, and that is called Krishna Loka, or Goloka Vrindaban.

Therefore, the expansions of Krishna in various forms as described herein, as well as His different Abodes on the Spiritual Planets in the Spiritual Sky, are unlimited. Even demigods like Brahma and Shiva cannot see or even estimate how many planets there are or how vast is their extension. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fourteenth Chapter [10.14.21]: “No one can estimate the length and breadth of all the Vaikuntha planets.” It is said there that not only the demigods like Brahma and Shiva are unable to make such an estimate, but also Ananta, Who is an incarnation of the Lord in His opulence of strength, cannot describe any limitation to the Lord’s potency, or to the area of the different Vaikuntha planets.

In this connection the prayers of Brahma, mentioned in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fourteenth Chapter [10.14.21], are very convincing. Lord Brahma says, “O my dear Lord, O Supreme Personality of Godhead, O Supersoul, O Master of all Mystic Powers—nobody can know or explain Your potential expansion through Your Yogamaya energy, which extends all over the three worlds. The scientist and the learned man cannot even estimate the atomic constitution of any single planet. They may be able to count the molecules of snow in the sky, or they may even count the number of stars in the sky, but no one can estimate how You descend on this Earth or in this Universe, with Your innumerable transcendental potencies and energies and qualities.” Lord Brahma informed Narada that, of all the great sages who were born before Narada, including he himself, none can understand the potential strength and energy of the Supreme Lord. So he admitted that if even Ananta, who has thousands of tongues, tries to estimate the Lord’s potential energy, he will fail.

Brahma prayed, therefore: “My Lord, You are unlimited, and no one has estimated the limit to Your potencies. I think that even Your Lordship does not know the range of Your potential energies. An unlimited number of planets float in the sky just like atoms, and great Vedantists who are engaged in research to find You find everything different from You, and at last they decide that You are everything.” [10.87.41]

When Lord Krishna was within this Universe, Brahma played a trick on Him in order to confirm that the cowherd boy in Vrindaban was actually Krishna. By his power he stole all the cows and calves, and the friends of Krishna, who were engaged in herding the animals. But when he returned from hiding them to see the result, he saw that Krishna was playing with the same cows and calves and cowherd boys; because by His Vaikuntha potency He had expanded all the stolen cows, calves and friends. He saw millions and billions of them, and he also saw millions and billions of tons of cane and fruit, and lotus flowers and horns. And all the cowherd boys were decorated with different clothes and ornaments, and nobody could count their vast number. Brahma saw that each of the cowherd boys had become a fourhanded Narayan, like the predominating deity of each Brahmanda, and he saw that innumerable Brahmas also were engaged in offering obeisances to the Lord. He also saw that all of them were emanating from the body of Krishna, and after a second they were also entering into the body of Krishna. Brahma became struck with wonder by this extraordinary feat of Krishna, and in his prayer he admitted that anybody and everybody could say that he knows about Krishna—but so far as he was concerned, he did not know anything about Krishna. “My dear Lord,” he said, “the potencies and opulences which You have exhibited just now are beyond the capacity of my mind and understanding.”

Lord Chaitanya then explained that not only Krishna Loka, but even Krishna’s Abode on this planet, known as Vrindaban, cannot be estimated in potency. Vrindaban is estimated as thirty-two Scriptural miles, but even though Vrindaban in India is thirty-two miles, yet in some part of Vrindaban all the Vaikunthas exist. The area of the present Vrindaban consists of twelve orests and is about eighty-four croses, or one hundred sixty-eight miles in area. But Vrindaban City is estimated at about sixteen croses, or thirty-two miles.

The Lord again said that the potencies and opulences of Krishna are unlimited. Whatever He told to Sanatan Goswami was only a partial presentation, but by such a partial presentation one can at least imagine the whole. While Lord Chaitanya was speaking to Sanatan Goswami about the opulences of Krishna, He was deep in ecstasy, and in that transcendental state He began to cite a verse from the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Second Chapter [21], which runs as follows: After the disappearance of Krishna, Uddhava, when he met Vidura, spoke as follows: “Krishna is the Master of all demigods, including Lord Brahma, Lord Shiva and the expansion of Vishnu within this Universe. Therefore, no one is equal to or greater than Him, and He is full in all six opulences. All the demigods engaged in the administration of each Brahmanda offer their respectful obeisances, and therefore the helmets on their heads are beautiful, being decorated with designs of the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Lord.”

Therefore, as is stated in the Brahma Samhita, Fifth Chapter, 1st Verse, Krishna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and no one can be equal to or greater than Him. That is the conclusion. The rulers of this Universe, known as Brahma, Shiva and Vishnu, although being masters of each and every Universe, are also servants of the Supreme Lord Krishna.

Lord Krishna is the Cause of all causes. He is also the Cause of the Maha Vishnu, or the first incarnation controlling this material Creation. From Maha Vishnu there is Garbhodakshayee Vishnu and Kshirodakshayee Vishnu. Krishna is the Master of the Garbhodakshayee Vishnu, the Kshirodakshayee Vishnu, and He is also the Supersoul within every living entity and every Universe. The Maha Vishnu is described in the Brahma Samhita [5.48]: Through His breathing innumerable Universes are produced, and in each Universe there are innumerable Vishnu Tattwas. But Lord Krishna is the Master of Them all; or They are partial plenary expansions of Krishna.

From revealed Scriptures it is understood that Krishna lives in three transcendental places: The most confidential residence of Krishna is Goloka Vrindaban. There He stays with His father, mother, and friends; and He exhibits His transcendental relationships and His Mercy amongst His eternal entourage. There the Yogamaya acts as a maidservant in the matter of His dancing of Rasa Leela. The residents of the Vrajabhumi think, “The Lord is glorified by particles of His transcendental mercy and affection, and we, the residents of Vrindaban, have not the slightest anxiety on account of His merciful existence.”

It is stated in the Brahma Samhita, Fifth Chapter, 49th verse: all the Vaikuntha planets in the Spiritual Sky are below the planet known as Krishna Loka. The other planets are known as Vishnu Loka. In that Krishna Loka the Lord enjoys His transcendental bliss in multiple forms; and all the opulences of the Vaikunthas are fully displayed in the one Krishna planet. The associates of Krishna are also full with six opulences. In the Padmollar Khand, Two hundred twenty-fifth Chapter, 57th verse, it is stated that the material energy and the spiritual energy are separated by water which is called the Viroja River. That river is flowing from the perspiration of the first incarnation of Purusha. On the other bank of the Viroja is the eternal Nature, unlimited and all-blissful, called the Spiritual Sky; which is the Spiritual Kingdom, or the Kingdom of God.

The Spiritual Planets are called "Vaikuntha” because there is no lamentation there, no fear, and everything is eternal. The Spiritual World is calculated to be three-fourths the energies of the Supreme Lord, and the material world is one-fourth of His energy. No one can understand this three-fourths, since even this material world, which is only one-fourth of His energy, cannot be described. Lord Chaitanya now tried to convey to Sanatan Goswami something about the extent of the one-fourth display of Krishna’s energy. In this connection He cited an incident from Srimad Bhagwatam when Brahma, the Lord of the Universe, came to see Krishna at Dwarka:

When Brahma, the first creature of this Universe, approached Krishna, the doorman informed Krishna that Brahma had arrived to see Him. On hearing this Krishna inquired as to which Brahma had come? The doorman again came to Brahma and asked him, ‘Which Brahma are you? Krishna has asked.”

Brahma was struck with wonder. Why was this question asked by Krishna? He informed the doorman, ‘Please tell Him that Brahma who is the father of the four Kumaras and who has four heads has come to see Him.”

The doorman informed Krishna, and then asked Brahma to come inside. Brahma offered his obeisances unto the Lotus Feet of Krishna, and Krishna received him with all honor, and then asked him why he had come, what his purpose was.

Brahma replied, ‘I shall speak about my purpose in coming here, but first I have a doubt. Will You kindly remove it? You have asked through Your doorman which Brahma has come to see You. So may I inquire if there are any other Brahmas besides me?”

On hearing this Krishna smiled, and He at once called for many Brahmas from many other Universes. The four-headed Brahma then saw many Brahmas coming to see Krishna, and to offer their respects. Some of them had ten heads, some of them had twenty, some of them one hundred heads, and some of them a million heads. This four-headed Brahma could not even count the Brahmas coming to see Krishna to offer their obeisances. Krishna then callcd many demigods from other Universes, and all came to offer their respects to the Lord.

Seeing this wonderful exhibition by Krishna, the four-headed Brahma became nervous, and he began to think that he was just like a mosquito in the midst of many elephants. All of them came and offered their respectful obeisances unto the Lotus Feet of Krishna, and therefore Brahma thought that nobody can estimate the unlimited potency of Krishna.

All the helmets of the different demigods and Brahmas shone as they assembled there, and when combined together there was a great sound of all of them praying to the Lord. They began to say, “My dear Lord, it is a great mercy upon us that You have called us to see You. Is there any particular order? If there is any order, we will carry it out at once.”

Lord Krishna replied, “There is nothing especially required of you, but I wanted to see you so I called you all together at one time. I offer My blessings upon you. Don’t be afraid of the demons.”

All of them replied that by His mercy, “Everything is all right. There are no disturbances at the present moment. By Your incarnation everything inauspicious is vanquished.” As each of the Brahmas saw Krishna, every one thought Krishna was only within his Universe. After this incident He wished all the Brahmas farewell, and after offering their respects, they returned to their respective Universes.

On seeing this, the four-headed Brahma who had come to see Krishna at once fell down at the Feet of Krishna and said, “What I thought about You before is all nonsense. Let everyone say that they may know You in perfection, but as far as I am concerned, I cannot even conceive how great You are. You are beyond my conception, beyond my understanding.”

Krishna then informed the four-headed Brahma; “This particular Universe is only four thousand million miles broad, but there are many other millions and billions of Universes which are far, far greater than this one. Some of them are millions and billions and trillions of miles broad. All these Universes require similar strong Brahmas; not only four-headed.”

Krishna also informed Brahma, “This is only the one-quarter part of My creative potency. The three-quarters part of My creative potency is in the Spiritual Kingdom.”

The four-headed Brahma then parted from Krishna, after offering his obeisances; and he could understand what the meaning of the Lord of the three-quarters energy was.

The Lord is known therefore as Tradhiesa. This name stands for His principle Abodes; namely, Gokula, Mathura, and Dwarka. These three places are full of opulences, and Lord Krishna is the Master of them all. Krishna is therefore situated in His transcendental potency. He is the Master of all transcendental energies, and He is full with six opulences. Because He is the Master of all opulences, all the Vedic literature acclaims Krishna as the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Lord Chaitanya then sang before Sanatan Goswami a very nice song about the opulences of Krishna:

“All the Pastimes of Krishna are exactly like the activities of a human being. Therefore it is to be understood that His Form is like that of a human being. A human being is an imitation of His Form. His dress is just like a cowherd boy’s, with a flute in His hand, and He seems to be just like a newly grown youth, always playful, playing just like an ordinary boy.”

The Lord wanted to explain to Sanatan Goswami about the beautiful aspects of Krishna. He said that if anyone can understand these beautiful qualities of Krishna, he is dipped into the ocean of nectar. One of Krishna’s potencies is called Yogamaya, which is transcendental and beyond the material energy, but He exhibits His transcendental potency even within this material world just to satisfy His confidential devotees. His appearance in this material world is meant for His devotees. His qualities are so attractive that Krishna Himself becomes eager to understand Himself. He is fully decorated and stands with His body curved in three ways, and His eyebrows are always moving and His eyes are so attractive that all the Gopis become enchanted. His special Abode is on top of the Spiritual Sky, and He resides there with His similar associates, the Gopis, and all the Goddesses of Fortune. He is known there as Madanmohan.

There are many different Pastimes of Krishna such as His Pastime in the Forms of Vasudeva and Samkarshan. In the material sky His Pastimes are as the first incarnation of the Purusha, or the Creator of the material world. There are also Pastimes as the incarnation of the Fish or Tortoise, as manifestations of His incarnation of energies. There are His Pastimes in the Form of Lord Brahma and Lord Shiva, as the incarnation of the material qualities; His Pastimes as King Prithu as an empowered incarnation; His Pastimes as the Supersoul in everyone’s heart; and His Pastimes as the impersonal Brahman.

He has innumerable Pastimes, but the most important Pastimes of Krishna are His human-like activities, in which He frolics in Vrindaban, dances with the Gopis, plays with the Pandavas on the Battlefield of Kurukshetra, and plays in Mathura and Dwarka. The most important part of His exhibition of Pastimes is in the human Form, especially as a cowherd Boy with flute in hand and appearing just like a newly grown youth. A partial manifestation of His Pastimes in Goloka Mathura and Dvaravati, or Dwarka, can overflood the whole Universe with love of Godhead. Everyone can become attracted by the beautiful qualities of Krishna.

The manifestation of His internal potency is not even exhibited in the Kingdom of God, or on the planets of Vaikuntha. But He exhibits that internal potency within the Universe, by descending from His Personal Abode, through His inconceivable mercy. Krishna is so wonderful and attractive that He Himself becomes attracted by His beauty, and that is proof that He is full of all inconceivable potencies. So far as Krishna’s ornaments are concerned, when they decorate His body it appears that the ornament does not beautify Krishna, but that the ornament itself becomes beautiful since it is on His body. He appears always curved in three ways, and He attracts all the living entities and all the demigods. He attracts even the Narayan Form in each and every Vaikuntha planet.

TLC 10-1968: The Beauty of Krishna

Chapter Ten

The Beauty of Krishna

Krishna is known as Madanmohan because He conquers the mind of Cupid. He is Madanmohan by His favors to the damsels of Vraja, and by accepting their devotional service. The Lord is engaged there in the Rasa Dance as the new Cupid, after conquering Cupid’s pride. He is Madanmohan by His capacity to conquer the minds of women with His five arrows called Form, Taste, Smell, Sound and Touch. The pearls of the necklace which is hanging on the neck of Krishna are as white as ducks; and the feather of the peacock which is decorating the head of Krishna is colored just like the rainbow. His yellow garment is like lightning in the sky. Krishna is like the newly arrived clouds; and the Gopis are just like footbells on His feet. When the cloud pours rain on the grains in the field it appears that Krishna is nourishing the hearts of the Gopis by calling down His Pastime rain of mercy. The ducks fly in the sky in the rainy season, and the rainbow is also seen in the sky at that time. Krishna freely moves with His friends as a cowherd boy in Vrindaban; and when He plays His flute all the living creatures, mobile and immobile, become overwhelmed with ecstasy, and they quiver and tears flow in their eyes.

His conjugal love is the summit of His various opulences. The Lord is the Master of all riches, all strength, all fame, all beauty, all knowledge, and all renunciation. Out of these, His perfect beauty is His conjugal attraction. The Form of Krishna, the conjugal beauty, is eternally existent in Krishna alone, whereas His other opulences are present in His Narayan Form.

When Lord Chaitanya was describing the superexcellence of Krishna’s conjugal attraction, He felt a transcendental ecstasy, and caught up the hands of Sanatan Goswami and began to say how fortunate the damsels of Braja were. He recited in this connection a verse from Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Twenty-fourth Chapter [10.44.14]: “How much penance and austerities the damsels of Vrindaban must have undergone, for they are able to drink the nectar of Krishna, Who is All Beauty, All Strength, All Riches, All Fame, and Who is the center of all the beauties of bodily luster.”

The Body of Krishna, the ocean of the eternal beauty of youth, can be seen as moving in waves of beauty. And there is a whirlwind at the sound of His flute. Those waves and that whirlwind make the hearts of the Gopis flutter like dry leaves on the trees, and when the leaves fall down to Krishna’s Lotus Feet, they can never rise up again from there. There is no comparison with that beauty, because no one has beauty greater than, or equal to, Krishna. He is the Origin of all incarnations, including the Form of Narayan. Otherwise, how could the Goddess of Fortune, who is a constant companion of Narayan, give up the association of Narayan, and engage herself in penance for gaining the association of Krishna? This is the superexcellent beauty of Krishna, the everlasting mine of all beauty. And from that beauty all other beautiful things emanate.

The attitude of the Gopis is just like a mirror on which the reflection of Krishna’s beauty develops at every moment. Both Krishna and the Gopis increase their transcendental beauty at every moment, and there is always transcendental competition between them. Nobody can appreciate the beauty of Krishna by proper discharge of his occupational duty, or by austerities, or by mystic Yoga, or by cultivation of knowledge, or by offering different kinds of prayer. Only those who are on the transcendental platform of love of God—who only out of love are engaged in devotional service—can appreciate the transcendental beauty of Krishna. Such beauty of Krishna is the essence of all opulences, and His characteristics in that connection are only appreciable in Goloka Vrindaban and not anywhere else. In the Form of Narayan the beauties of mercy, reputation, etc. are all established by Krishna. But His gentleness and magnanimity cannot be possible in Narayan. They are found only in Krishna.

Lord Chaitanya very much relished all these verses from Srimad Bhagwatam which He explained to Sanatan. In particular He explained the verse from the Ninth Canto, Ninth Chapter, 24th [9.24.65] verse, as follows: “The Gopis used to relish the beauty of Krishna as a ceremony of perpetual enjoyment. They enjoyed the beautiful Face of Krishna, His beautiful Ears with earrings, His broad Forehead, and His Smile; and while enjoying the sight of Krishna’s beauty they used to criticise the defect of the creator, Brahma, for the separation from their vision of Krishna by the momentary blinking of their eyelids.”

The Vedic hymn which is known as Kamagayatri describes the Face of Krishna as the king of all moons. In metaphorical language there are many different moons, and they are all one in Krishna—the moon of the mouth, the moon of the cheeks, the moon-spots of sandalwood pulp, the beauty moon of the fingertips of His hand, and the tip of His toes—in this way there are twenty-four and a half moons, and Krishna is the central figure of all these different kinds of moons.

The dancing movement of Krishna’s earrings, eyes, and eyebrows are very attractive to the damsels of Vraja. Activities in devotional service increase the sense of devotional service. What else is there for two eyes to see beyond the face of Krishna? One cannot sufficiently see Krishna with only two eyes; and one feels incapable and thus becomes bereaved. Such bereavement is slightly reduced when one criticizes the creative power of the creator. The unsatiated seer of the face of Krishna then laments as follows:

“I do not have thousands of eyes; I have only two eyes and even these two eyes are disturbed by the movements of the eyelids. So it is to be understood that the creator of this body is not very intelligent. He is not conversant in the art of ecstasy. He is simply a prosaic creator. He does not know how to fix things in different positions for only seeing Krishna.”

The Gopi’s minds are always engaged in relishing the sweetness of Krishna’s Body. He is the Ocean of beauty, and His beautiful Face, His beautiful Smile, and the luster of His Body are always attractive to the Gopi’s mind. In the Krishna Karnamrita these three things have been described as sweet, sweeter, and sweetest. When there are three kinds of contamination in the constitutional body, it is called convulsion. So, similarly, a perfect devotee of Krishna attains a stage of convulsion when he is so overwhelmed by seeing the beauty of Krishna’s Body, His Face, and the beauty of Krishna’s Smile, This ocean of transcendental convulsion before Krishna’s beauty sometimes continues without any treatment, just as with ordinary convulsions a physician does not allow one to drink water for relief.

The devotee increasingly feels the absence of Krishna, because without Him one cannot drink the nectar of His beauty. When there is the transcendental sound of Krishna’s flute, the devotee’s anxiety to hear that flute penetrates the covering of this material world and enters into the Spiritual Sky, and the transcendental sound of the flute enters into the ears of the followers of the Gopis. The sound of Krishna’s flute always resides within the ear of the Gopis, and increases their ecstasy. At the time when it is heard no other sound can enter into the ear, and in their family activities they are not able to reply properly because all these beautiful sounds are vibrating.

Thus Lord Chaitanya explained the transcendental constitution of Krishna, His expansions, His bodily luster, and everything connected with Him. In short, Lord Chaitanya explained Krishna as He is. And, Krishna being the essence of everything, He began to explain the process by which one can approach Krishna. He said that devotional service to Krishna is the only process. This is the verdict of all Vedic literature. The sages have declared as follows: “If' somebody inquires into the Vedic literature as to what is the process of transcendental realization, or if somebody consults the Puranas (which are considered the sister literature)—in all of them the conclusion is that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna, is the Object of worship.”

Krishna is the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and He is situated in His internal potency, which is known as Swarupshakti or Atma-shakti, as described in the Bhagavad Gita. He expands Himself in various multiple Forms. Some of them are known as Personal Forms, and some of them are known as separated Forms. Thus He is enjoying in all the spiritual planets as well as in the material Universes.

The expansions of His separated Forms are called living entities, and they are classified according to the energies of the Lord. Such living entities are divided into two classes: one is eternally liberated, and the other is eternally conditioned. Eternally liberated living entities never come into contact with the material Nature, and they do not have any experience of material life. They are eternally engaged in Krishna Consciousness, or devotional service to the Lord, and they are counted as associates of Krishna. Their pleasure, the only enjoyment of their life, is derived by rendering transcendental loving service to Krishna.

Those who are eternally conditioned, on the other hand, are ever divorced from the transcendental loving service of Krishna, and thus they are subjected to the three-fold miseries of material existence. On account of the conditioned soul’s eternally existing attitude of divorce from Krishna, the spell of material energy awards him two kinds of bodily existence: one is the gross body, consisting of the five elements, and the other is the subtle body, consisting of mind, intelligence, and ego. Because he is covered by these two kinds of bodies, the conditioned soul is eternally suffering the pangs of material existence, known as the three-fold miseries. We are subjected to six kinds of enemies, such as lust and anger, etc., and that is the everlasting disease of the conditioned soul.

Diseased and conditioned, the living entity is transmigrating all over the Universe. Sometimes he is situated in the upper planetary system, and sometimes he is travelling in the lower planetary system. That becomes his normal conditioned life. This disease can be cured only when the expert physician, the bona fide Spiritual Master, is met and followed. When the conditioned soul faithfully follows the instructions of such a bona fide Spiritual Master, the material disease is cured and the living entity is promoted to the liberated stage, and again attains to the devotional service of Krishna, and goes back Home, back to Krishna.

A conditioned living entity should come to the consciousness of his real position. He should pray to the Lord: how long and how much will I be under the rule of the different bodily functions, such as lust and anger? As masters of the conditioned soul, lust and anger are never merciful; and there is no cessation of the conditioned soul’s service to such bad masters. When he comes to his real consciousness, or Krishna Consciousness, he gives up serving those bad masters and approaches Krishna with a frank and open heart to achieve His shelter. Then he prays to Krishna to be engaged in His transcendental loving service.

In the Vedic literature fruitive activities have sometimes been highly praised, and sometimes the mystic process of Yoga is praised; and, sometimes, the speculative search for knowledge is praised. They are each considered as a different way to self-realization. But in spite of praise for the different paths of self-realization, in every writing the path of devotional service has been accepted as the foremost. In other words, devotional service to Lord Krishna is the highest perfectional path of self-realization, recommended to be performed directly. The effects of fruitive activities, mystic meditation, and the cultivation of speculative knowledge are not direct methods of self-realization. They are indirect methods because without the addition of devotional service none of these recommended paths can lead to the highest perfection of selfrealization. Therefore, such paths to self-realization are ultimately dependent on the path of devotional service.

TLC 11-1968: Service to the Lord

Chapter Eleven

Service to the Lord

Any recommended path for self-realization can be successful only when it is mixed with devotional service. This was explained by Narada Muni, the Spiritual Master of Vyasadeva, when Vyasadeva was not satisfied even after compiling heaps of books of Vedic knowledge. Vyasadeva was sitting in a state of depression by the banks of the River Saraswati when Narada Muni arrived. Upon seeing Vyasa so dejected, he explained the deficiency in the compilation of his various books. He said as follows:

“Even pure knowledge without being completed by transcendental devotional service does not look well. What to speak of fruitive activities when they are not in devotional service? How can they be of any benefit to the performer?”

There are many sages who are expert in performing austerities; there are many men who give much in charity; there are many famous men, scholars and thinkers; and those who are very expert in the Vedic hymns. All such achievements are certainly very auspicious, but unless they are utilized for attaining devotional service to the Lord, they are unable to award the desired results. Therefore, in Srimad Bhagwatam [2.4.17], Sukadeva Goswami offered his respectful obeisances to the Supreme Lord, Who is the only One Who can award such success.

It is accepted by all classes of philosophers and transcendentalists that no one who lacks knowledge can be liberated from the material entanglement. Still, knowledge without being mixed with devotional service holds no possibility of awarding liberation. In other words, when Jnana, or the cultivation of knowledge, opens the path of devotional service, then alone can it give one liberation, and not otherwise.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam [10.14.4] this is also stated by Brahma: “My dear Lord, devotional service unto You is the best path for self-realization. If somebody gives up that path and becomes engaged in the cultivation of knowledge, or in speculation, he will undergo a troublesome process, without achieving any desired results. Just as a person who beats the empty husk of the wheat cannot get the grain, so those who are engaged simply in speculative knowledge cannot achieve the desired result of self-realization. Their only gain is trouble.”

The Bhagavad Gita says, in the Seventh Chapter, 14th verse, that this material Nature is very strong, and not surmountable by an ordinary living entity. Only those who surrender unto the Lotus Feet of Krishna can cross over the ocean of material existence. The self-forgetfulness of the living entity —forgetting that he is eternally the servitor of Krishna—is the cause of his hondage in conditional life, and the cause of his being attracted by the material energy. That attraction is the shackle of material energy. It is very difficult for a person to become free as long as he desires to lord it over the material Nature. It is recommended, therefore, that one should approach a Spiritual Master who can train him in devotional service, and thus he can get out of the clutches of material Nature, and achieve the Lotus Feet of Krishna.

There are divisions of human society, like the Brahmins, or intellectuals; the Kshatriyas, administrators; the Vaishyas, businessmen; and the Sudras, or laborers; and there is the Brahmachary, or student, the Grihastha or householder, the Vanaprasthas, retired; and the Sannyasis, renounced life. And, in every case, if the individuals lack engagement in devotional service, Krishna Consciousness, even though engaged in their prescribed duty, they cannot get release because of their material consciousness. On the contrary, even by discharging their prescribed duties, they glide down to hell. Therefore, all persons engaged in their prescribed occupational duties must cultivate Krishna Consciousness in devotional service, if they want liberation from the material clutches.

In this connection, Lord Chaitanya cited a verse from the Srimad Bhagwatam [11.5.2-3] which was delivered by Narada as the path of Bhagavat cultivation. He said that the four divisions of human social life, as well as the four different orders of life, are born out of the gigantic Form of the Lord: the Brahmins are born out of the mouth of the Universal Form of the Lord, the Kshatriyas are born out of the arms of His Personality, the Vaishyas are born out of His waist, and the Sudras are born from the legs of that Personality. As such, they are qualified in different modes of material Nature, within the Form of Virata Purusha. Out of these four orders of life, or social divisions, if anyone is not engaged in the devotional service of the Lord, then in spite of his being in his prescribed occupational, functional duty, he falls from his position.

Lord Chaitanya says that those of the Mayavadi, or impersonalist, school may artificially think themselves as one with God, or liberated, but according to Him and to Srimad Bhagwatam [10.2.32], they are not actually liberated. In this connection, He quoted a verse from the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Second Chapter, in which it is said: “Those who think that they are liberated in the Mayavadi philosophical way, but who do not take to the devotional service of the Lord, even after undergoing the severest type of penance or austerity, and even after sometimes approaching the Supreme post, still, for want of devotional service, fall.”

The Lord explained that Krishna is just like the Sun, and Maya, or the illusory material energy, is just like darkness. Therefore, one who is constantly in the sunshine of Krishna does not have any chance of being deluded by the darkness of material energy. This is very nicely explained in the four prime verses of Srimad Bhagwatam [2.9.34], and is also confirmed in the Second Canto of Srimad Bhagwatam, Fifth Chapter [13], which states: “The illusory energy, or Maya, is ashamed to stand before the Lord.”

But the living entities are constantly being bewildered by the same illusory energy. The living entity in his conditioned state discovers many kinds of word-jugglery for getting apparent liberation from the clutches of Maya; but actually a person who sincerely surrenders unto Krishna even by saying only once, ”My dear Lord Krishna, from this day, I am yours,” at once gets out of the clutches of the material energy.

This is confirmed in the Ramayan, Lankakanda. There the Lord says, “It is My duty and vow that if somebody surrenders unto Me without any reservation, then I give him all protection.” Somebody may develop the idea of enjoying fruitive activities, or liberation, or Jnana, or perfection in the Yoga system, but if such a person by chance becomes very intelligent, then he will give up all those paths and engage himself in sincere devotional service to the Lord. The Bhagwatam also confirms, in the Second Canto, Third Chapter [10], that a person—whatever he may be, either full with all desires for material enjoyment or desirous of liberation—if he is actually intelligent, should engage himself in perfect devotional service.

Persons who are ambitious for deriving material benefit from devotional service are not pure devotees, but because they are engaged in devotional service they are considered fortunate. They do not know that the result of devotional service is not material benediction; but, because they engage themselves in devotional service of the Supreme Lord, ultimately they will come to the understanding that material enjoyment is not the result of engagement in His devotional service. Krishna says that such persons, engaged in His devotional service, are certainly foolish for wanting some material benefit in exchange. Such persons are foolish because, instead of achieving the stage of love of Godhead, they try to accept something which is poisonous for them. Although such persons want material benefit from Krishna, Krishna being All-powerful considers the person’s position and gradually liberates him from such an ambitious life, and engages him in devotional service. And when he is actually in devotional service he forgets his past ambitions and desires for material benefits.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Fifth Canto, Nineteenth Chapter [27], this is confirmed as follows: “Lord Krishna certainly fulfills the desire of His devotees who come to Him in devotional service. But He does not fulfill such desires as would again cause miseries. In spite of being materially ambitious, because they are engaged in the transcendental service of the Lord, such devotees are gradually purified of desire for material enjoyment, and come to desire the pleasure of devotional service.”

Generally people come to the association of devotees for mitigating some material wants. But the influence of a pure devotee frees a man from all material desires, and he relishes the taste of devotional service. Devotional service is so nice and pure that it purifies the devotee, and he forgets all material ambitions as he engages fully in the transcendental loving service of Krishna. A practical example is Druva Maharaj, who wanted something from Krishna, and for that reason engaged in devotional service. But when the Lord appeared as four-handed Vishnu before Druva, he said, “My dear Lord, I engaged myself in Your devotional service with great austerity and penances, and thus I am now seeing You. It is always very difficult to see You, even for the great demigods and great sages, and I am now pleased and all my desires are satisfied.

I do not want anything further. While I was searching for some broken glass, I have found a great and valuable gem.” Druva Maharaj stated his full satisfaction, and he refused to ask anything from the Lord.

The living entity who is transmigrating through the 8,400,000 species of life is sometimes likened to a log which is gliding downstream on the waves of the river. Sometimes, by chance, the log comes to the shore and it is saved from being forced to drift further downstream. There is a nice verse in the Srimad Bhagwatam [10.38.5] in which every conditioned soul is encouraged: “Nobody should be depressed, thinking that he will never be out of the clutches of matter; because there is the possibility of being rescued exactly like the log which floats on the river for some time, and then comes to rest on the bank.” This fortunate opportunity is also discussed here by the Lord.

Such fortunate incidents are considered the beginning of the decline of one’s conditional life. They occur if there is the association of pure devotees of the Lord. By association of pure devotees of the Lord, one actually develops his attraction for Krishna. There are different types of rituals and activities: some of them develop into material enjoyment, and some of them develop into material liberation. If a living entity takes to ritualistic activities which develop into his pure devotional service to the Lord, in the association of pure devotees, then he naturally develops devotional service in his mind.

There is a nice verse in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fifty-first Chapter [10.51.53], where it is stated by Muchakunda: “My dear Lord, a living entity, while travelling in this material world through different species of life, may develop towards liberation. By chance he may come in contact with pure devotees. Only at that time is he liberated from the clutches of the material energy, and he becomes a devotee of Yourself, the Personality of Godhead.”

When a conditioned soul becomes a devotee of Krishna, Krishna by His causeless Mercy trains him in two ways: He trains him by the Spiritual Master from the outside, and He trains him from the inside by the Supersoul. In this connection there is a very nice verse in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Twenty-ninth Chapter [11.29.6], in which it is said: “O my dear Lord, if somebody should get a duration of life like Brahma’s, still he would be unable to express his gratitude to You for the benefits derived from remembering You; because, out of Your causeless mercy, You drive away all inauspicious conditions for a devotee, expressing Yourself from outside as the Spiritual Master, and from inside as the Supersoul.”

Somehow or other, if somebody gets in touch with a pure devotee and thus develops a desire for devotional service to Krishna, he gradually rises up to the platform of love of Godhead, and thus he is freed from the clutches of the material energy. This is explained in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Twentieth Chapter [11.20.8], where the Lord says: “For one who becomes attracted by the topics of My Activities out of his own accord—being neither lured nor repelled by material activities—the path of devotional service, leading to the perfection of love of God, becomes possible.”

It is not possible, however, to achieve such a stage of perfection without being favored by a pure devotee, or a Mahatma, a great soul. Without the mercy of a great soul no one can even be liberated from the material clutches, what to speak of rising to the platform of love of Godhead? This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Fifth Canto, Eleventh Chapter, spoken in connection with the meeting of the King Rohugana of the Sind province in Siberia with King Bharata. The King expressed surprise at seeing Bharata’s great stage of spiritual perfection in life.

Bharata replied: “My dear Rohugana, no one can attain the perfected stage of devotional service without being favored by a great soul, or pure devotee. No one can attain such perfectional stages simply by following the regulative principles of Scriptures, nor by acceptance of the renounced order of life, nor by prosecuting the prescribed duties of householder life, nor by becoming a great student of spiritual science, nor by accepting severe austerity and penances performed for realization.”

Similarly, in the same Bhagwatam, Seventh Canto, Fifth Chapter [32], in connection with the conversation of Prahlad Maharaj with his father, Hiranyakasipu, the following statement appears: “When the atheist father Hiranyakasipu inquired from his son where he got such an attitude of devotional service, the boy replied: ‘So long as one is not favored by the dust of the feet of pure devotees, then he cannot even touch the path of devotional service, which is the solution of all the varieties of problems of material life.”’

Lord Chaitanya said to Sanatan Goswami that all the Scriptures stress association with pure devotees of Godhead. The opportunity to associate with a pure devotee of the Supreme Lord is the beginning of one’s complete perfection. This statement is also confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto, Eighteenth Chapter [13]. It is said there that the facility and benediction achieved by the association of a pure devotee cannot be compared with anything: neither elevation to the heavenly kingdom, nor liberation from this material energy.

Lord Krishna, also, while giving instruction to Arjuna, in the Srimad Bhagavad Gita, confirmed this as the most confidential instruction, in the Eighteenth Chapter, 65th verse. The Lord said there: “My dear Arjuna, you are My affectionate friend and relative, and therefore, for your benefit, I am giving you the most confidential knowledge: Just become always mindful of Me, become always a devotee of Mine, become a constant worshipper of Me, and just become a soul surrendered to Me. That is the only way by which you can achieve My Abode. Because you are My very dear friend, My most confidential knowledge is disclosed herewith to you.”

Such a direct instruction of Krishna to Arjuna is more important than any Vedic injunctions or regulative service. There are certainly many Vedic injunctions, such as ritualistic performances, sacrificial performances, regulative duties, meditation, and the speculative process of knowledge; but Krishna’s direct order—“You just give up everything and become My devotee, My worshipper”—should be taken as the final order of the Lord, and one should follow that principle.

If one is convinced by this direct order of the Lord in the Bhagavad Gita, and becomes attached to His devotional service and gives up all other engagements, then he undoubtedly becomes successful. Srimad Bhagwatam [11.20.9] also says, to confirm this statement, that one should be engaged in other paths of selfrealization only so long as one is not convinced by the direct order of the Lord, Sri Krishna. As stated in Srimad Bhagwatam and Bhagavad Gita, the direct order of the Lord is to give up everything and be engaged in devotional service.

This firm conviction is known as faith. Faith means that one is firmly convinced that, simply by devotional service to Lord Krishna, everything else is performed—including the regulative principles of ritualistic duties, sacrifices, performance of Yoga, and the speculative pursuit of knowledge. Everything else is performed if one is convinced that devotional service to the Lord includes everything. This is also found in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Fourth Canto, Thirty-first Chapter [14]. It is said there: “As by watering the root of the tree the branches, the twigs, the leaves, and the fruits become nourished; and as in supplying foodstuffs to the stomach all the senses become satisfied—similarly, simply by devotional service to Krishna, all other worship and all other processes are completed.” Such a faithful and firmly convinced person is eligible to be elevated as a pure devotee.

Now, amongst the devotees there are three classes, according to the degree of conviction: The first class devotee is one who is conversant with all kinds of Vedic literature, and at the same time has the firm conviction mentioned above. He is a first class devotee, and he can deliver all others from the pangs of material miseries. The second class devotee is firmly convinced and of strong faith, but has no power to cite evidence from revealed Scriptures. The third class devotee is one whose faith is not very strong but is eligible to be promoted to the position of second class devotee or first class devotee by the gradual cultivation of devotional service.

It is said in Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Second Chapter, that the first class devotee always sees the Supreme Lord as the Soul of all living entities. Therefore, in seeing all living entities, he sees Krishna and nothing but Krishna. A devotee who places his full faith in the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who makes friendship with the pure devotees, who shows favor to the innocent person, and who avoids those who are atheistic or are against devotional service—such a devotee is called a second class pure devotee. And a person who is engaged in the devotional service of the Lord according to the direction of the Spiritual Master, or by family tradition, and worships the diety of the Lord, but has not much cultivation of knowledge in devotional service, and does not know who is a devotee and who is a non-devotee—such a person is called a third class pure devotee. The last-mentioned are not actually pure devotees. They are almost in the devotional line, but their position is not very secure.

The purport is that, when a person shows his love for God and his friendship for the devotees and his mercy for the innocent and his reluctance to the non-devotees, he becomes in the category of a pure devotee. Such a person, by developing devotional service, can perceive that every living entity is part and parcel of the Supreme. In each and every living entity he can see the Supreme Person, and therefore he becomes highly developed in Krishna Consciousness. At this stage he does not make any distinction as to who is a devotee and who is a non-devotee. He sees everyone in the service of the Lord. A pure devotee, however, continues to develop all great qualities in his body, while engaged in Krishna Consciousness and devotional service. It is stated in Srimad Bhagwatam, Fifth Canto, Chapter Eighteen [12], that anyone who has attained pure unalloyed devotional service to the Supreme Lord develops all the good qualities of the demigods; whereas a person who hasn’t developed pure devotional service to the Lord, in spite of his being materially qualified, is sure to go astray as he hovers on the mental plane. Therefore, his material qualification is valueless.

TLC 12-1968: The Devotee

Chapter Twelve

The Devotee

A person in Krishna Consciousness, fully devoted in the transcendental loving service of the Lord, develops many good qualities, or godly qualities—pertaining to the demigods. There are many such qualities, but Lord Chaitanya described only some of them to Sanatan Goswami: A devotee of the Lord is always kind to everyone. He does not pick a quarrel with anyone. He takes the essence of life, spiritual life. He is equal to everyone. Nobody can find fault in a devotee. His magnanimous mind is always fresh and clean and without any material obsessions. He is a benefactor to all living entities. He is peaceful and always surrendered to Krishna. He has no material desire. He is very humble and is fixed in his direction. He is victorious over the six material qualities such as lust and anger. He does not eat more than what he needs. He is always sane. He is respectful to others; but for himself he does not require any respect. He is grave. He is merciful. He is friendly. He is a poet. He is an expert. And he is silent.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Twenty-fifth Chapter [21], the person in Krishna Consciousness, devoted to the loving service of the Lord, is also described: Such a devotee or person in Krishna Consciousness is always tolerant and merciful. He is a friend to all living entities. He has no enemies. He is peaceful, and he is decorated with all good qualities. These are the symptoms of the person in Krishna Consciousness.

It is also said in the Bhagwatam that if one gets the opportunity to serve a great soul—a Mahatma—then his path to liberation is open. Those who are, however, attached to persons in the materialistic conception of life are on the path of darkness. Those who are actually holy are transcendentalists, equipoised, very peaceful, without any anger, and friendly to all living entities. Therefore becoming Krishna conscious, or a devotee of the Lord, is caused simply by association with such holy men. And to develop love of Godhead, the association of holy devotees is also needed. For anyone who comes in contact with a holy man, as mentioned above, the path of advancement in spiritual life is now opening. And, by following that path, he is sure to develop Krishna Consciousness in full devotional service.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Second Chapter [11.2.30], Vasudeva, the father of Krishna, asks Narada Muni about the welfare of life. In reply, Narada Muni quotes a passage from the discussion of the nine sages with King Nimi: “O holy sages, I am just trying to ask what the paths of well-being for every living entity are. And, a moment of association with holy men is the most valuable thing in life. That moment will open the path of advancement in spiritual life.” This is also confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Twenty-fifth Chapter [25].

Association with holy persons, and the discussion of transcendental subject matters with them convinces one about the purposeful course. Very soon, hearing of Krishna becomes pleasing to the ear, and satisfactory to one’s heart. After reception of such messages from holy persons or pure devotees, if one tries to apply them in his own life, then naturally the path of Krishna Consciousness becomes developed in faith, attachment, and devotional service—one after another.

The Lord then informed Sanatan Goswami about the behavior of a devotee. The sum and substance of such behavior enunciated by the Lord is that one should always be aloof from unholy association. That is the sum and substance of the behavior of a devotee. And what is unholy association? It is association with one who is too attached to women, and one who is not a devotee of Lord Krishna. These are unholy persons. The purport is that, as one is advised to associate with holy devotees of the Lord, so one has to be careful to avoid the association of unholy non-devotees of the Lord. Those who are pure devotees of Krishna are very careful to keep aloof from these two kinds of unholy non-devotees.

The result of unholy association with non-devotees is described in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Thirty-first Chapter [33-35]. It is said there that one should simply give up association with a person who is a playmate for women; because, in association with such an unholy person, one becomes bereft of all good qualities, such as truthfulness, cleanliness, mercifulness, gravity, intelligence, shyness, beauty, fame, forgiveness, control of the mind, control of the senses, and all opulences that are automatically achieved by the devotee. A man is never so degraded as when he is degraded by association with persons who are too attached to women.

Regarding this matter of disassociation from unholy persons, Lord Chaitanya quoted a verse from Katyayani Samhita: “One should rather tolerate the miseries of being locked in a cage full of fire than tolerate the miseries of associating with those who are not devotees of the Lord.” It is also advised that one should not see the faces of persons who are irreligious, or without any devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is recommended by the Lord that one should scrupulously renounce the association of unwanted persons, and completely take shelter of the Supreme Lord Krishna. The same instruction is also given to Arjuna by Krishna in the last pages of Bhagavad Gita [18.66]: “You give up everything and just surrender unto Me, and I shall take care of you, and protect you from all the reactions to sinful activities.”

The Lord is very kind to His devotees. He is very grateful. He is able and magnanimous. Therefore, it is our duty to believe in the words of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. And if we are intelligent enough and educated enough, we shall follow this principle without any hesitation. As said by Aukrur in addressing Krishna, in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Eighty-fourth Chapter [10.48.26]: “Who can become a surrendered soul to any other than Yourself? Who is so dear, Who is so truthful, Who is so friendly, and Who is so grateful? You are so perfect and complete that even though You give Yourself to Your devotee, still You are full and perfect. You can therefore satisfy all the desires of the devotee, even to delivering Yourself to Your devotee.”

A person who is intelligent and able to understand the philosophy of Krishna Consciousness, therefore, naturally gives up everything and takes to the shelter of Krishna only. In this connection, Lord Chaitanya recited a verse spoken by Uddhava in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Second Chapter [23]:

“How can one take shelter of anyone else but Krishna, Who is so kind? Even though Bakasur’s sister planned to kill Him when He was an infant, by applying poison to her breast and offering it to Him to suck and thus to die—still that heinous woman received salvation, and was elevated to the same post as His own mother.” The verse refers to the time Putana planned to kill Krishna when He was a child, by poisoning her breast and offering it to Him to suck. Krishna accepted it and sucked the milk from the breast of that demoniac woman, and at the same time sucked out her life also. But the result was that Putana was raised to the same post as His own mother.

There is no essential difference between a fully surrendered soul and a man in the renounced order of life. The only difference is that a fully surrendered soul has the distinguishing symptom of being completely dependent upon Krishna. This surrendering process can be characterized by six different qualities: The first quality is that one should accept everything that is favorable to the discharge of Krishna duties or devotional service. One should be determined to accept the process. The second is that he should give up everything which is unfavorable to the discharge of devotional service; and one should be so determined to give it all up. Thirdly, one should be convinced that nobody else can protect him except Krishna, and therefore he has full faith that he will be protected by the Lord. It should be mentioned here that the impersonalists think that being One with Krishna, or One with the Supreme Lord, is their actual identity. A devotee, however, does not destroy his identity, but he lives with full faith that Krishna will kindly protect him in every respect.

Fourthly, a devotee should always accept Krishna as his Maintainer. Fruitive performers generally expect protection from demigods; but a devotee does not expect any protection from any demigod. He is fully convinced that Krishna will protect him from all kinds of unfavorable conditions. Fifth, a devotee is always conscious that his desires are not independent. Unless Krishna fulfills them, his desires cannot be fulfilled. Lastly, one should always think of himself as the most fallen, so that Krishna may take care of him.

Such a surrendered soul should take shelter in a holy place like Vrindaban, Mathura, Dwarka, Mayapur, and should surrender himself to the Lord, saying, “My Lord, from today I am Yours. You can protect me or kill me as You like.” The devotee takes shelter of Krishna in such a way. Krishna is grateful and accepts him and gives him all kinds of protection. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Twenty-ninth Chapter [11.29.34]. It is said there that if a person who is about to die takes full shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and offers himself fully under His care, he actually attains immortality at that time, and is eligible to become in association with the Supreme Lord, and to enjoy transcendental bliss.

The Lord then explained to Sanatan Goswami about the various types and symptoms of practical devotional service. When devotional service becomes practical—to be performed with our present senses—at that time it is called practical devotional service. Actually, devotional service is the eternal life of the living entity, and is lying dormant in everyone’s heart. The practice which invokes that dormant devotional service is called practical devotional service. The purport is that a living entity is constitutionally part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. The Lord is compared to the Sun, and the living entities are compared to the molecules of sunshine. Under the spell of illusory energy, that spiritual spark is almost extinct. But, by practical devotional service, one is again revived to his natural constitutional position. When one is practicing such devotional service, it means that he is going back to his original normal position of liberation. Such devotional service can be practiced with one’s senses, under the direction of a bona fide Spiritual Master.

The beginning of such spiritual activities for making advancement in Krishna Consciousness, or devotional service, is to hear. Hearing is the most important subject matter for advancement in Krishna Consciousness. One should be very eager to hear favorably about Krishna. One should give up speculative knowledge or fruitive activities, and simply worship and desire to achieve love of Godhead. That love of Godhead is eternally existent within oneself. One has to simply practice the process of hearing. Hearing and chanting are the principal processes of devotional service.

Such devotional service may be regulative or affectionate. One who has not developed transcendental affection for Krishna should conduct his life under the direction of Scriptural injunction, and the guidance of the Spiritual Master. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Second Canto, First Chapter [5], Sukadeva Goswami advises Maharaj Parikshit as follows:

“O best amongst the Bharatas, it is the prime duty of persons who want to become fearless to hear about the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Hari, and to chant about Him, and always remember Him. Lord Vishnu is always to be remembered, and not to be forgotten for even a moment. He is the sum and substance of all regulative principles.”

The purport is that there are so many rules and regulations in the revealed Scriptures: so many recommended activities, and so many prohibited activities—but when all of them are taken together, it appears that remembrance of the Supreme Lord is always the essence of everything. Remembrance of the Supreme Personality of Godhead always within one’s heart is the practical action of devotional service. In that performance of devotional service there is no regulative principle. There are no do’s and don’t’s.

Generally, in devotional service, one should accept the following principles: 1. One is to take shelter of a bona fide spiritual master. 2. It is necessary to be initiated by the spiritual master; 3. to serve the spiritual master; 4. to inquire and to learn love from the Spiritual Master; 5. to follow in the footsteps of holy persons devoted to the transcendental loving service of the Lord. 6. For the satisfaction of Krishna one should be prepared to give up all kinds of enjoyment and miseries. 7. One should live in a place where Krishna had His Pastimes. 8. One should be satisfied with whatever is sent by Krishna for maintenance of his body and should not be anxious to receive more than that. 9. One should observe fasting on Ekadasee day, the eleventh day after the full moon and the eleventh day after the new moon, when no grains, cereals or beans are eaten. Simple vegetables and milk are taken in moderate amounts, and chanting of Hare Krishna, reading Scripture, etc. is increased. 10. One should show respect to devotees, the cow and trees such as the banyan tree.

These ten items are essential for a neophyte devotee who is beginning to follow the path of devotional service. The next stage is as follows: 11. One should try to avoid offenses in the service to the Lord, and in chanting the Holy Names of the Lord. There are ten kinds of offenses in chanting the Holy Name and they should be avoided. The offenses are: I. Blaspheming a devotee of the Lord; 2. Considering the Lord and the demigods on the same level, or to think that there are many Gods; 3. To neglect the orders of the spiritual master; 4. To minimize the authority of Scriptures (the Vedas); 5. To interpret the Holy Names of God; 6. To commit sin on the strength of chanting; 7. To instruct the Glories of the Lord’s Name to the unfaithful; 8. To compare the Holy Name with material piety; 9. To be inattentive while chanting the Holy Name; 10. To remain attached to material things in spite of chanting the Holy Names. 12. One should avoid the association of unholy non-devotees. 13. One should not attempt to have many disciples. 14. One should not take the trouble of understanding various books or to understand partially any particular book, and one should avoid discussing different doctrines. 15. One should be equipoised both in gain and loss. 16. One should not be subject to any kind of lamentation. 17. One should not disrespect demigods, or other Scriptures. 18. One should not tolerate blaspheming the Supreme Lord and His devotees. 19. One should avoid ordinary topics of novels and fiction, but there is no injunction that one should avoid hearing ordinary news. 20. One should not give any trouble to any living creature, including a small bug.

The first ten items are affirmative, and the second ten are prohibitive. In the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu complied by Sri Rupa Goswami, it is said that one should be very liberal in behavior and should avoid any undesirable behavior. Out of the twenty regulations mentioned above, the most important are to accept the shelter of a bona fide Spiritual Master, to be initiated by him, and to serve him.

The process of devotional service can be analyzed as follows: 1. Hearing, 2. Chanting, 3. Remembering, 4. Worshipping, 5. Praying, 6. Serving, 7. Engaging as a servitor, 8. Being friendly, 9. Offering everything, 10. Dancing before the deity, 11. Singing, 12. Informing, 13. Offering obeisances, 14. Standing up to show respect to the devotees, 15. When a devotee goes, following him up to the door, 16. Entering into the temple of the Lord, 17. Circumambulating the temple, 18. Reading prayers, 19. Vibrating hymns, 20. Performing Samkirtan, or congregational chanting, 21. Smelling the incense and the flowers offered to the deity, 22. Accepting the Prasadam (food offered to Krishna), 23. Seeing Aritrik or ceremonial performance of receiving the Lord, 24. Seeing the deity, 25. Offering to the Lord His own palatable foodstuff, 26. Meditating, 27. Offering water to the tulsi tree, 28. Offering respect to the Vaishnavas, or advanced devotees, 29. Living in Mathura or Vrindaban, 30. Understanding Srimad Bhagwatam, 31. Trying for Krishna to one’s utmost, 32. Expecting the mercy of Krishna, 33. Performing the ceremonial functions of Krishna with devotees, 34. Surrendering in all respects, 35. Observing different ceremonial functions.

To these thirty-five items another four are to be added: 1. Marking the body with sandalwood pulp to show that he is a Vaishnava, 2. Painting the body with the Holy Names of the Lord, 3. Covering the body with the remnants of the cover of the deity, 4. Accepting Charanamrita, or the water washed of the Lord. Adding these four items to the above thirty-five, we have thirty-nine items for devotional service. Out of them, 1. To associate with devotees, 2. To chant the Holy Name of the Lord, 3. To hear Srimad Bhagwatam, 4. To live in a holy place such as Mathura or Vrindaban, 5. With great devotion, to serve the deity—these five items are very important. They are especially mentioned by Rupa Goswami in his book Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu.

The thirty-nine items above, added with these five items, become forty-four. Add to that 20 preliminary occupations, and the total is sixty-four different items for conducting devotional service. One can adopt these sixty-four items by his body, mind and senses, so that gradually his devotional service becomes pure. Some of the items are completely separate, and some are identical, and others appear to be mixed.

Srila Rupa Goswami has recommended that one should live in association of those of the same mentality. Therefore, it is necessary to form some association of Krishna Consciousness and live together for the cultivation of Krishna knowledge and devotional service. The most important item for living in that association is to understand Srimad Bhagavad Gita and Srimad Bhagwatam mutually. When faith and devotion are developed, they become transformed into the worship of the deity and chanting of the Holy Name, and living in a place like Mathura and Vrindaban.

These five items, mentioned after the thirty-nine, are very important and essential. If one can simply discharge the last mentioned five items, even if they are not done sufficiently, one can be elevated to the highest perfectional stage. One may be able to perform one item or many items, according to one’s capacity, but the principle factor of one’s complete attachment to devotional service makes him advance on the path. There are many devotees in history who' attained the perfection of devotional service simply by discharging the duties in one item. And there are many other devotees, like Maharaj Amburish, who executed all the different items.

Some individual devotees who attained perfection in devotional service by executing only one item are: Maharaj Parikshit, who was liberated in full perfection simply by hearing. Sukadeva Goswami who became liberated and perfect in devotional service simply by chanting. Lakshmi, simply by serving the Lotus Feet of the Lord. King Prithu attained perfection simply by worshipping; Akrura simply by praying; Hanuman only by becoming the servant of Lord Rama. Arjuna attained perfection simply by becoming a friend to Krishna, and Bali Maharaj simply by offering whatever he had in his possession.

So far as Maharaj Amburish is concerned, he practically performed all the items of devotional service: he first of all engaged his mind on the Lotus Feet of Krishna. He engaged his words, his power of speaking, in describing the transcendental qualities of the "Supreme Personality" of Godhead. He engaged his hands in washing the temple of the deity, his ears in hearing the words of Krishna, and he engaged his eyes in beholding the deity of Krishna. He engaged his touch for rendering service to the devotees, and he engaged his sense of smell to accept the fragrance of the flowers offered to Krishna. He engaged his tongue in tasting the tulsi leaves offered to the Lotus Feet of Krishna, his legs in going into the temple of Krishna, and he engaged his head in offering obeisances unto the deity of Krishna. All his desires and ambitions were engaged in the devotional service of the Lord. Therefore, he is the leader in discharging all kinds of devotional service in different ways.

Anyone who engages in the devotional service of the Lord in full Krishna Consciousness becomes freed of all debts to the sages and demigods and forefathers, to whom we are generally indebted. In the Srimad Bhagwatam [11.5.41] this is confirmed: “Anyone who fully engages himself in the service of the Lord, without discharging any other duty, O King, is no longer indebted or servant to the demigods, to the sages, to other living entities, to his relatives, to any man, or to the forefathers.” The purport is that every man, just after his birth, becomes at once indebted to all the above personalities, and one is expected to discharge many kinds of ritualistic functions because of this indebtedness. But for a person who is fully surrendered unto Krishna, there is no obligation. In spite of not discharging such obligations, he is free from all debt to such persons.

It should be carefully noted, however, that when a person gives up all other duties and simply takes to the transcendental service of Krishna, he has no desire, and he is not subjected to, or apt to be performing, sinful activities. If, however, he performs any sinful activities—not wilfully, but by chance—then Krishna gives him all protection. He does not require to purify himself by any other method. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Fifth Chapter [11.5.42]: “A devotee who is fully engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord is protected by the Supreme Person. But in case such a devotee unintentionally commits some sinful activity, or may be obliged to act in some sinful activity under certain circumstances, God gives him all protection, being situated within his heart.”

The processes of speculative knowledge and renunciation are not practically the chief items for acquiring a higher standard of devotional service. One doesnot have to take to the principles of nonviolence and sense control, although there are rules and regulations for acquiring these qualities in other processes. Without being engaged in the practice of such processes, a devotee develops such high qualities simply by discharging devotional service to the Lord. In Srimad Bhagwatam [11.20.31], Eleventh Canto, the Lord says that for those who are actually engaged in the devotional service of the Lord there is no necessity for cultivating speculative knowledge or renunciation.

TLC 13-1968: Devotional Service in Attachment

Chapter Thirteen

Devotional Service in Attachment

Out of sheer misunderstanding some transcendentalists think that knowledge and renunciation are some of the items necessary for rising to the standard of devotional service. This is not so. The cultivation of knowledge and the renunciation of fruitive activities may be necessary to understand one’s spiritual existence in relation to the material conception of life, but they are not part and parcel of the devotional service. The results of knowledge and fruitive activities are liberation and material sense gratification, respectively. Therefore, they cannot be part and parcel of devotional service. Rather, they have no intrinsic value in the discharge of devotional service. When one is freed from the resultant action of knowledge and fruitive activities, then one can be situated in devotional service. A devotee of Lord Krishna is by nature nonviolent and self-controlled, both in the mind and the senses. Therefore, he does not have to try separately to acquire the qualifications which result from cultivating knowledge and from fruitive activities.

When Sri Uddhava was asking Krishna about the rules and regulations, and the subjects of restriction as they are stated in the Vedic language, he asked, “Why is it that from the Vedic hymns one is enlivened in the matter of material enjoyment, while, from the instruction of Vedas, one also is freed from all illusion and is encouraged to have liberation?” The rules are supposed to be ordained by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but apparently there are contradictions, and so Uddhava inquired about how to be free from these contradictory statements of the Vedas.

In reply to this, Lord Krishna informed him about the superexcellence of devotional service: “For persons who are already engaged in devotional service to Me, and who are fixed in their minds about Me, endeavoring for the cultivation of knowledge and renunciation are not practical or necessary.”

The purport is that devotional service is by itself independent of any other process. The processes of cultivating knowledge and renunciation, or meditation, may be a little helpful in the beginning, but they cannot be considered paraphernalia for discharging devotional service. In other words, devotional service can be discharged independently of the cultivation of knowledge and renunciation. In this connection, there is a verse from Skanda Purana, in which Parbut Muni said to a hunter tribesman: “O hunter, the qualifications which you have now acquired, such as nonviolence and others, are not astonishing, because one who is engaged in devotional service to the Supreme Lord cannot be the source of any trouble for anyone under any circumstances.”

The Lord next said to Sanatan Goswami: “So far I have explained devotional service under regulative principles. Now I shall explain devotional service to you in terms of transcendental attachment.”

The inhabitants of Vrindaban, Vrajabhumi, are practical living examples of devotional service. Theirs is ideal devotional service with attachment, Such devotion cannot be found anywhere else except in Vrajabhumi, Vrindaban. If one develops devotional service and attachment by following in the footsteps of the inhabitants of Vrajabhumi, that is called Raga Marga Bhakti, or devotional service in pursuance of attachment for the Lord. There is a statement in the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [1.2.272] about this: “Devotional service with ecstatic attachment for that service, which becomes a natural factor for the devotee, is called Raga, or transcendental attachment.” The devotional service discharged in that standard of Raga is called Ragatmika, devotion. Deep attachment and complete absorption in the object of love is called Raga atmika, devotion. Examples can be seen in the activities of the residents of Vrajabhumi, and one who becomes attracted to Krishna by hearing of such attachment is certainly very fortunate. When he becomes deeply affected by such devotional service as that of the residents of Vrajabhumi, and tries to follow in their footsteps, he does not care for the restrictions or regulations of the revealed Scriptures. That is the characteristic of discharging Raga Bhakti.

Devotional service with attachment is a natural inclination. One who has been attracted by such a natural inclination does not accept any argument against his conviction, even though such arguments are presented according to Scriptural injunction. This natural inclination is also based on injunction, and so a person who has attachment for that particular type of devotional service toward the Supreme Lord is not required to change it simply on the strength of Scriptural argument. In this connection we should note that the class of so-called devotees known as Prakrita-sahajia follow their own concocted ideas and represent themselves as Krishna and Radha, and indulge in debauchery. This kind of devotional service and attachment is false. They are actually gliding down the hellish path. This is not the standard of Ragatmika, or devotion. This Prakrita sahajia community is actually cheated and very unfortunate.

Devotional service with attachment can be executed in two ways: externally and internally. Externally, the devotee strictly follows the regulative principles, beginning with chanting and hearing and other regulations, while internally he always thinks of the attachment which attracts him to serve the Supreme Lord. He always thinks of his special devotional service and attachment. Such a real devotee’s attachment docs not violate the regulative principles of devotional service, but he adheres to them strictly; and yet, within his mind, he always thinks of his particular attachment.

All the inhabitants of Vrajabhumi, Vrindaban, are very dear to Krishna. A devotee in attachment selects one of the inhabitants and follows in his footsteps in order to be successful in his own devotional service. A pure devotee in attachment always follows such a personality of Vrajabhumi within himself It is advised in Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [1.2.294] that a pure devotee in devotional service with attachment, should always remember the activities of a particular inhabitant of Vraja, even though he is not able to live directly in Vrajabhumi or Vrindaban. Thus he may always think of Vrajabhumi and Vrindaban.

Such confidential devotees in attachment are divided into several categories: some of them are servants, some of them are friends, some of them are parents and some of them are conjugal lovers. In devotional service with attachment one has to follow a particular type of devotee of Vrajabhumi.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Twenty-fifth Chapter [38], it is stated: “The word Matpara is used only for persons who are satisfied with the idea of becoming an adherent of Me alone. They consider that I am their Soul, I am their Freind, I am their Son, I am their Master, I am their Well-wisher, I am their God, and I am their Supreme Goal. My dear Mother, there is no action of time upon such devotees.” In the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu, the author offers his respectful obeisances to such persons who always think of Krishna as He is, as when He is Son, Well-wisher, Brother, Father, Friend, or any such relationship. Anyone following the principles of devotional service with attachment, and in terms of a particular devotee in Vrajabhumi certainly achieves the highest perfectional love of Godhead in that spirit.

There are two developmental characteristics for such seeds of love of Godhead. They are known as Rati, or attachment, and Bhava, the condition immediately preceding love of Godhead. By these two characteristics the Supreme Lord Sri Krishna is conquered by such devotees. These two characteristics are there before any symptoms of love of Godhead. This was explained by Lord Chaitanya to Sanatan Goswami. Lord Chaitanya said that there is really no end to describing the system of devotional service with attachment, and He is simply trying to offer a sampling of such devotional service.

Lord Chaitanya then said to Sanatan Goswami that He would describe the ultimate goal of devotional service, that which is meant for such a person who wants to attain perfection. When one’s attachment for Krishna becomes very deep, this condition is called love of Godhead. Such a state of being is called the permanent situation of the devotee. Kaviraj Goswami has offered in this connection his respectful obeisances unto Lord Chaitanya for His sublime teachings of love of Godhead. It is stated in the Chaitanya Charitamrita (Madhya 23.1): “O You Supreme Personality of Godhead, whoever awarded such pure devotional service to anyone else? O most magnanimous Incarnation of the Personality of Godhead, for my part I offer my respectful obeisances to this Incarnation, known as Gaura Krishna.”

In the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [1.3.1] the state of being in love of Godhead is compared to the sunshine emanating from the Sun of love for Godhead; and this shining makes the devotee’s heart more and more lovely. The heart of such a devotee is situated in a transcendental position, beyond the modes of goodness of material Nature. And the process of making the heart further and further sterilized by the sunshine of love is called Bhava. This description of Bhava is given by Rupa Goswami. Bhava is called the permanent characteristic; and the crucial point of progress for Bhava is called the marginal state of love of Godhead. When the Bhava state becomes deeper and deeper, the learned devotees call that state of being love of Godhead. In the Narada Pancharatra there is a verse in which it is stated: “When one is firmly convinced that Vishnu is the only Object of love and worship, and there is no one else and no demigod for his devotional service, it is accepted that he is feeling intimacy in love of Godhead, as is approved by such personalities as Bhisma, Prahlad, Uddhava and Narada.”

If someone, on account of some righteous activities which provoke devotional service, is influenced by such an attitude of service, and takes shelter of the good association of the pure devotees, then he develops an attachment for chanting and hearing. In such a state of mind the development of chanting and hearing makes him advance further and further in the matter of regulative devotional service to the Supreme Lord. And, as he advances in the regulative service of the Supreme Lord, so, proportionately, his misgivings for the material world diminish. Beginning with faith, and advancing in the process of hearing and chanting, the devotee becomes more and more firmly fixed in that faith. That faith gradually develops into taste, and that taste gradually develops into attachment. When the attachment becomes purer, then it is exhibited in two characteristics, which are called Bhava and Rati. When this principle of Rati becomes deeper, it is called love of Godhead. Love of Godhead is the ultimate goal of human life.

This process is summarized in the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [1.4.15-16] by Rupa Goswami: “The first thing required is faith, and from faith one associates with pure devotees, and, by such association, one develops devotional service. And when he develops devotional service, his misgivings are diminished. Then he is situated in firm conviction, and from that conviction he develops a taste and advances up to the attachment stage of life, known as the regulated principles of devotional service. And, after that stage, when he still further makes progress, it is called Bhava, or a permanent situation. Such love of God can go further and deeper and deeper, and then is called the highest stage of love of Godhead.”

In Sanskrit, this highest stage is called Prema. The word Prema can be explained as love of God without any exchange or return. Actually, the words Prema and love are not synonymous, but still one can say that Prema is the highest stage of love. One who has attained this stage of Prema is the most perfect human being. Srimad Bhagwatam also confirms this statement in the Third Canto, Twenty-fifth Chapter [25]: Only by the association of pure devotees can one develop a taste for Krishna Consciousness; and when he tries to apply such developed Krishna Consciousness in his life, one can achieve all other things up to the stages of Bhava and Prema.

Lord Chaitanya next described the symptoms of a person who has developed from faith to the stage of Bhava. He is characterized as follows: he is never agitated even if there are causes for agitation. The next characteristic is that he does not waste his time for a moment. He is always anxious to do something for Krishna Consciousness. Even if he has no engagement, he’ll find some work to do for Krishna’s satisfaction. The next characteristic is that he does not like anything which is not connected with Krishna. He never hankers after personal respect. Although he is in the best position, still he does not hanker after being honored by others. And he is confident in his task. He is never under the impression that he is not making progress or achieving the Supreme goal of life or going back to Godhead, going back to Home. He is fully convinced that he is making progress toward that site. As such, with more and more confidence, he is always very busy to achieve that highest goal of life. He is very much attached to the gratification of the Lord, or chanting, or hearing about the Lord. At all times he is always attached to describing the transcendental qualities of the Lord. He wants to live in such places as Mathura, Vrindaban, or Dwarka. These symptoms are all visible in a person who has developed to the stage of Bhava.

This state of Bhava is described in connection with King Parikshit, when he was sitting on the bank of the Ganges to meet his death because of being cursed by a Brahmin boy. He spoke as follows: “All the Brahmins present here, as well as Mother Ganges, may know that I am a soul completely surrendered to Krishna. I do not mind even if I am immediately bitten by the snake sent by the Brahmin boy. Let the snake bite me as it likes, but I shall be pleased if all of you present here go on chanting the message of Krishna.” Such a devotee is always anxious to see that his time is not wasted in anything which is not connected with Krishna. As such, desires derived from fruitive activities, or from yogic meditation, or by the cultivation of knowledge are not liked by him. He is simply attached to favorable words in relation with Krishna. Such pure devotees of the Lord always go on praying to the Supreme Lord with tears in their eyes, and their minds are always engaged in recollecting the activities of the Lord, and with their bodies they offer obeisances. Thus they are satisfied. Any devotee who is acting in such devotional service dedicates his life and body for that purpose.

King Bharata was also a pure devotee, and under his name India is called Bharatvarsa. He left his household life and kingdom at an early age. He left his devoted, beautiful wife, his son and friends and kingdom and everything just as if they were stool. Such are the symptoms of persons who have developed Bhava in their devotional service. Such a person in devotional service always thinks of himself as the most wretched, and he is only satisfied that someday or other Krishna will be kind enough to favor him by engaging him in devotional service. In the Padma Purana another instance of the pure devotee is found, where the king, although the best of all human beings, was begging from door to door and was even praying to the lowest of human society, the Chandala.

Sri Sanatan Goswami later composed the following verse: “I am low in love of Godhead, and I haven’t any asset for hearing about devotional service. Neither do I have any understanding of the science of devotional service, nor do I have any cultivation of knowledge, nor any righteous activities behind me; nor am I born of high family. But, O Darling of the damsels of Braja, still I maintain a hope for achieving You, and that hope is disturbing me.” So a devotee, being touched deeply by such strong desire, always chants Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare.

In this connection a nice verse by Bilvamongal appears in Krishna Karnamrita [32]: “O Player of the nice flute, Krishna, the beauty of Your boyhood activities is very wonderful in this world. You know the agitation of my mind, and I know what You are. Nobody knows how confidential our relationship is. Now my eyes are anxious to sec You and Your face, but I cannot see You. Please—let me know what I shall do.” A similar passage appears in Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [1.3.38], by Rupa Goswami, which states: “O Govinda! this young girl with tears in her eyes is crying in a sweet voice, chanting Your Glories.” Such pure devotees are always anxious to describe the Glories of Krishna, and to live in a place where Krishna exhibited His Pastimes.

A similar verse appears again in Krishna Karnamrita [92]: “This Body of Krishna is so nice, His Face is so nice—everything about Him is only sweet and fragrant.” A similar passage also appears in the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [1.2.156]: “O Lotus-eyed One, when shall I be able to always chant Your Holy Name, and being agitated in that, chanting, when shall I be able to dance on the bank of the Yamuna?”

All the above descriptions made by Lord Chaitanya to Sanatan Goswami are called symptoms of the Bhava stage of devotional service. Next He proceeds to describe the symptoms of actual love for Krishna. He says that nobody can understand a person who has developed love of Krishna—neither his words, his activities, nor his symptoms. Even if one is very learned, it is very difficult for him to understand a pure devotee in love of Godhead. This is confirmed in Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu also.

A person engaged in devotional service becomes slackened in his heart when singing the glorification of the Supreme Lord. Because the Lord is very dear to him, in glorifying the Lord’s Name, Fame, etc., he becomes almost like an insane man, and in such a condition of life sometimes he laughs, sometimes he cries, sometimes he dances—and without any consideration of the situation, he continues in such activities. And,, by gradual development of his love of Godhead he increases his affection, his emotion, his ecstasy. Such attachment, Mahabhava, is the highest stage of devotional love. It can be found like molasses or sugar, which are different stages of the same thing. But the highest stage is called sugar candy. In different stages of the same juice, sugar candy becomes more and more palatable. Similarly, in love of Godhead, by a gradual process of development, transcendental pleasure is increased to the highest stage for the real devotee.

TLC 14-1968: The Ecstasy of the Lord and His Devotees

Chapter Fourteen

The Ecstasy of the Lord and His Devotees

The symptoms of highly developed devotional service exhibited by the pure devotees sometimes are imitated by persons who are not actually pure devotees of Krishna. This is described in the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu. Such symptoms without devotional service to Krishna are purposeful, they are not actual. Sometimes those who are not conversant with this science of devotional service are captivated by the exhibition of such symptoms, but those who are in knowledge of the science of devotional service do not accept such symptoms. They are simply imitation, or only the beginning. That is accepted by the learned devotees.

According to the different divisions and grades of devotees, the permanent situations of the devotional attitude are divided into five categories: 1. peacefulness, 2. servitude toward Krishna, 3. friendship with Krishna, 4. parental affection toward Krishna, and 5. conjugal love for Krishna. There is a different taste and relish in each of the different divisions of love of Godhead, and a devotee situated in a particular type of devotional service is happy in that position. The characteristic symptoms of a pure devotee are laughing and crying; when emotions are favorable, they laugh; and when the emotion is not favorable, they cry.

But above these two emotions there is the permanent situation of love which is called Sthaaibhava. In other words, the attachment to Krishna is called a permanent situation. That permanent loving attitude is sometimes mixed with different kinds of tastes, and they are named Bibhava, Anubhava, Byabhichary. Bibhava is a particular taste for attachment to Krishna, and is divided into two further categories, namely Alambana and Uddipana. The cause that increases one’s love of Krishna is said to be Bibhava, in the Agni Purana and other authoritative Scriptures. Such taste is increased as Alambana, when Krishna is the Objective. When Krishna’s transcendental qualities include a devotional emotion, by His Activities, His beautiful smiling Face and flavor of Body, the sound of His flute, His sound of the Nopur, or conch shell, the marks of His sole, His dwelling place, His paraphernalia of devotional service: such as tulsi leaves, devotees, and the performance of ceremonies, and Ekadasee—this devotional emotion so induced is called Alambana, or Uddipana. When feelitlg and emotions within oneself are exhibited, that is called Anubhava. In the Anubhava attitude, one dances and sometimes falls down, sometimes sings loudly, sometimes shows convulsions, sometimes yearns, sometimes breathes very heavily—all without any concern for the situation.

Those external features exhibited on the body of the devotees are called Udbhasvar. The Byabhichary symptoms are thirty-three in number. Such symptoms principally comprise the matter of words and different features of the body. These different features of the body, such as dancing and trembling and laughing, etc., when mixed with the Byabhichary symptoms are called Samchary. And, when Bhava, Anubhava and Byabhichary symptoms are mixed together they make the devotee dive into the ocean of immortality. That is called the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu, The Ocean of the Pure Nectar of Devotional Service; and one who is merged into that ocean is always concentratedly in transcendental pleasure on the waves and sound of that particular ocean.

The particular flavors, or tastes of the devotees who merge into that ocean of Bhakti Rasamrita are known as neutrality, servitude, friendship, parenthood and conjugal love. The conjugal love taste, however, with symptoms of decorating the body for attracting Krishna, is very prominent. The flavor of servitude increases up to affection, anger, fraternity and attachment. The relish of friendship increases up to affection, anger, fraternity, attachment and devotion. In the relish of parenthood, the attachment increases up to affection, anger, fraternity and devotion. There are special flavors of friendship with the Supreme Lord, as manifested in friends such as Subal. There the devotion increases up to Bhava.

The different flavors are also divided into two kinds of ecstasy, called Yoga and Biyoga, or meeting and separation. In the relish of friendship and parenthood, the feelings of meeting and separation are various.

The situations known as Rudha and Adhirudha are possible in the flavor or conjugal love. Conjugal love, as exhibited by the queens at Dwarka, is called Rudha, and the conjugal love exhibited at Vrindaban by the damsels of Vraja is called Adhirudha. The highest perfections of Adhirudha affection in conjugal love can be divided into two: when they are actually getting together it is called Madana, and when they are separated it is called Mohana. In the ecstasy of Madana there are symptoms of kissing one another, and in the ecstasy of Mohana there are two kinds of symptoms: Udghurna and Chitrajalpa. There are altogether ten divisions in the Chitrajalpa platform. In the Srimad Bhagwatam [10.47.12-21] there is a portion known as Bhramorgita, and different kinds of Chitrajalpa are mentioned there. Udghurna is a symptom of separation, and there is also the symptom called transcendental insanity. In that transcendental insanity one thinks that he himself has become the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In such an ecstasy he imitates the symptoms of Krishna in different ways.

There are two kinds of dresses in conjugal love. They are called Sambhoga and Bipralambha. On the Sambhoga platform the dresses are unlimited, and on the Bipralambha platform they are four in number.

The ecstasy exhibited before the meeting of the love and the beloved, and the ecstasy between them after meeting, and the state of mind of not meeting the beloved is called Bipralambha, and that Bipralambha or previous state of love is a nourishing element for meeting afterwards. When the lover and beloved meet all of a sudden and embrace one another, feeling an ecstasy of happiness, that state of mind is called Sambhoga. Sambhoga ecstasy is also known, in different situations, by four names: 1. Samksipta, 2. Samkirna, 3. Sampanna, 4 Samriddhiman. Such symptoms are also visible during dreams.

The state of being before actually meeting one another is called Purvaraga. The obstacles to the meeting of the lover and the beloved are called mana, or anger. When the lover and beloved are separated in different places, that sense is called Pravas. And the feelings of separation which are present even during the meeting, under certain conditions, are called love anxieties. This anxiety of love is exhibited in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Ninetieth Chapter [10.90.15], when the princesses were keeping awake nights watching Krishna sleeping. They were afraid of Krishna’s separation, and were talking amongst themselves of how they had been affected by the beautiful Eyes and Smiling of Krishna.

The Supreme Lover is Krishna and He is situated in Vrindaban. The Supreme Beloved is Radharani. As Krishna is the Supreme Lover, there are 64 important qualifications of Krishna, on hearing which, the devotee takes transcendental pleasure. The characteristics of Krishna are explained in the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu as follows: 1. His body is well-constructed. 2. It is full of auspicious symptoms; 3. beautiful; 4. very glorious; 5. strong; 6. always looking like a boy of sixteen; 7. well-versed in different languages; 8. truthful; 9. decorated with pleasing words; 10. expert in speaking; 11. very learned; 12. intelligent; 13. influential; 14. joyful; 15. cunning; 16. expert; 17. grateful; 18. firmly convinced. 19. He knows how to deal with different circumstances; 20. is always conversant with Scriptural injunctions; 21. clean; 22. controlled by devotees; 23. steady; 24. self-controlled; 25. forgiving; 26. grave; 27. speculative; 28. fairdealing; 29. magnanimous; 30. religious; 31. a great hero; 32. merciful; 33. respectful; 34. competent; 35. gentle; 36. modest; 37. Protector of the surrendered soul; 38. Deliverer; 39. Friend of the devotees; 40. submissive to love; 41. all auspicious; 42. most Powerful; 43. famous; 44. devoted to all living entities; 45. worshipable by everyone; 48. full with opulence; 49. Supreme; 50. full with riches.

All the above-mentioned 50 qualities are fragmentally present in every living entity. When they are completely spiritually free and situated in their original condition, all the above-mentioned 50 qualities can be perceived in human life—but in minute quantity. There are five other transcendental qualities, as mentioned below, which can be seen in Vishnu, the Supreme Lord, and partially in Lord Shiva also—but they are not visible in the living entities. They are as follows: 1. always situated in His original condition; 2. omniscient; 3. evergreen or always fresh; 4. eternally blissful; 5. conversant, the master of all perfection.

Besides the above-mentioned five transcendental qualities, there are five other qualities which can be seen in the Spiritual Sky, especially in the Vaikuntha planets where Narayana is the predominating deity. They are: 1. inconceivable potencies; 2. able to sustain innumerable Universes; 3. the Seed of all incarnations; 4. to give the highest perfection to enemies who are killed by Narayana; and 5. the most attractive of the self-realized persons. The above-mentioned 60 qualities are visible up to Narayana. And Krishna has four other special qualities which are: 1. able to manifest wonderful Pastimes, 2. His transcendental flute-playing; 3. eternal youth; 4. His Personal Beauty.

As Krishna has 64 transcendental qualities, described above, so Srimati Radharani has 25 transcendental qualities by creation, material and spiritual. But Radharani can control even Krishna by Her transcendental qualities. Such transcendental qualities are described as follows: 1. She is sweetness personified. 2. She is a fresh young girl. 3. Her eyes are always moving. 4. She is always brightly smiling. 5. She has all the signs of fortunate lines in Her body. 6. By the flavor of Her person even Krishna becomes agitated. 7. She is expert in the art of singing. 8. She can speak very nicely and sweetly. 9. She is expert in presenting Herself by feminine attraction. 10. She is modest and gentle. 11. She is always very merciful. 12. She is transcendentally cunning. 13. She knows how to dress nicely. 14. She is always shy. 15. She is always respectful. 16. She is always patient. 17. She is very grave. 18. She is enjoyable by Krishna. 19. She is always situated on the highest devotional platform. 20. She can give shelter to all kinds of devotees. 22. She is always affectionate to superior and inferior. 23. She is always obliged by the dealings of Her associates. 24. She is the greatest among all the girlfriends of Krishna. 25. She always keeps Krishna under Her control.

So Krishna and Radharani are both transcendentally qualified, and both are attractive for each other. But still, in that transcendental attractiveness, Radharani is better than Krishna. This attractiveness of Radharani is the transcendental taste in conjugal love. Similarly, there are transcendental tastes in the flavors of servitude, friendship, and other relationships with Krishna. They can be described as follows, with reference to the context of Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu.

Persons who have been thoroughly cleansed by devotional service and are always joyful and full of elevated consciousness, who are very much attached to the studies of Srimad Bhagwatam, always cheerful in the association of devotees, and who have accepted the Lotus Feet of Krishna as the ultimate shelter of their lives; who are pleased to perform all details of devotional service—have in their pure hearts the transcendental ecstasy of attachment, developed out of old and new reformatory performance. That state of being, enriched with love of Krishna and transcendental experience, becomes gradually developed into the mature oneness of spiritual life. Such a spiritual taste of life cannot be possible for those who are not in Krishna Consciousness and in devotional service.

This fact is further corroborated in the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [2.5.131], where it is said: “For the non-devotee it is very difficult to understand the taste of devotional service. Only one who has completely taken shelter of the Lotus Feet of Krishna, and whose life is merged in the ocean of devotional service, can understand this transcendental relish.”

Lord Chaitanya thus explained briefly about the transcendental situation or spiritual relish of life, and He said that this is the fifth stage of perfection. The first stage of perfection is to become a religious man in the ordinary sense in the material world. The second stage of perfection is to become materially rich. The third, stage of material perfection is complete sense enjoyment; and the fourth stage of material existence is knowledge of liberation. But above liberation are those who are already liberated: they can stand on the fifth stage of perfection, which is called Krishna Consciousness, or devotional service to the Lord. The highest perfection of such devotional service in Krishna Consciousness is described as the taste of the ecstasy of spiritual relish.

The Lord then related to Sanatan Goswami that, before teaching him, He had already taught his younger brother, Rupa Goswami, at Prayag Allahabad. He assured Sanatan Goswami that Rupa Goswami had been empowered by Him to spread the knowledge which He had given him. Similarly, He ordered Sanatan Goswami to write books on the transcendental loving service of the Lord, and authorized him to re-excavate the different sites of Krishna's Pastimes in the district of Mathura. He was also advised to construct temples at Vrindaban, and to write books on the principles of Vaishnavism, as authorized by Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. Sanatan Goswami executed all His desires; he constructed the temple of Madanmohan at Vrindaban, and he wrote books on the principles of devotional service such as Hari Bhakti Vilasa.

Lord Chaitanya taught Sanatan Goswami how to live in the material world in complete relationship with Krishna, and He taught him also that there is no necessity of dry renunciation. The purport is that, in the present day, there are many persons who accept the renounced order of life without any spiritual advancement. Lord Chaitanya did not approve of such acceptance of Sannyasa without perfect knowledge in Krishna Consciousness. Actually we find that there are many so called Sannyasis who are acting like less than ordinary men, yet are passing themselves off as the renounced order of life. Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu did not accept such hypocrisy, and He taught Sanatan Goswami to write elaborately on the subject matter in his different books.

This perfectional stage of spiritual life, even while being in the material world, is described in the Twelfth Chapter of the Bhagavad Gita [12.13-14] as follows: “Such a devotee, who is not envious of any living entity, who is friendly, who is merciful, who is detached from material possessions, who is situated in pure identification without any false conception of the body, who is equipoised both in happiness and distress, who is forgiving, always satisfied and always engaged in devotional service, always being surrendered with body and mind unto the Supreme Lord—he is very dear to Me.” Such a devotee, who never gives trouble to any living entity either by the body or by the mind, who is never affected by material distress and happiness, is never angry or pleased with anything material, who is freed from all kinds of material affection,..is very dear to the Supreme Lord. Such a devotee is never dependent on anyone in this world. He who is a soul completely surrendered to the Supreme Lord, who is purified, expert, neutral, painless, and aloof from any material endeavor which requires too much attention—such a devotee is also very dear to Lord Krishna.

A person who is never subjected to material happiness, material hatred, lamentation and ambition, and who is aloof from all auspicious and inauspicious activities of the material world and fully devoted in Krishna Consciousness—he is very dear to Lord Krishna. A devotee who treats equally a so-called enemy, and a so-called friend in the material world, and who is not disturbed by any warmth or coolness due to the affection of his skin, and who is without any attachment and equally situated when he is respected or when insulted, always grave, satisfied in any condition of life, without any fixed house for residence and always fixed in Krishna Consciousness—is very dear to Lord Krishna. Even if one is not situated in some transcendental position, still, if and when one approves of such transcendental life he also becomes very dear to Krishna.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Second Canto, Second Chapter [5], there is a very nice verse in which it is said that a devotee should always remain dependent on the mercy of the Supreme Lord. As far as his material necessities are concerned, he should be satisfied with whatever is obtained without any endeavor. Sukdeva Goswami advised in that connection: that a devotee should never approach a materialistic person for any kind of help. So far as his bodily necessities are concerned, he may pick up a torn cloth thrown in the street, he can take fruits offered by the tree, he can drink water which is flowing in the river, and he can live in the cave constructed by Nature herself, in the hill and mountain regions. Above all, if he is unable to do all these things, he should completely depend on the Supreme Lord, understanding that the Supreme Lord provides everyone with food and shelter, and therefore He will never fail to care for His devotees who have fully surrendered unto Him. In both ways the devotee is always protected, and therefore he should not be at all anxious for his maintenance of life. Sanatan Goswami thus inquired into all phases of devotional service, and Lord Chaitanya taught him most confidentially from authoritative Scriptures like Srimad Bhagwatam in the matter of devotional service and Krishna Consciousness.

He then referred to the Vedic literature known as Harivansa, about the situation of the transcendental Abode of Krishna. This information was disclosed by Indra when he offered his prayer after his defeat in challenging the potency of Krishna. In the Harivansa it is stated that above the Earth there is sky, where the birds can fly, and those who are expert in operating airplanes can fly; but the birds and those flying airplanes arc unable to reach the higher planetary systems. The first higher planetary system begins from the Sun planet. The Sun planet is situated in the middle of the Universe, and above the Sun planet there are other planetary systems where persons elevated by great austerities and penances are situated.

The whole material Universe is called Devidham, and above the Devidham, there is Shivadham, where Lord Shiva with his wife Parvati eternally reside. In that planetary system is the Spiritual Sky, where innumerable Spiritual Planets, known as Vaikunthas, are situated. And, above Them, there is Krishna’s Planet known as Goloka. Goloka means the planet of the cows. Krishna is very fond of cows, and therefore His Abode is known as Goloka. Goloka is bigger than all the material and spiritual planets put together.

In that prayer of Harivansa, Indra admitted that he could not understand the situation of Goloka even by asking Brahma. Those who are devotees of Narayana, another expansion of Krishna, become situated in the Vaikuntha Planets; but it is very difficult to reach the Goloka Planet. That can be reached only by persons who are devotees of Lord Chaitanya or Lord Sri Krishna. Indra then admitted that, “You have descended from that Goloka Planet in the Spiritual World, and the disturbance which I have created was due to my foolishness”—and he therefore begged excuse from Lord Krishna.

The last phase of the Pastimes of Lord Krishna is described in the Srimad Bhagwatam as Mousala Leela, including the mystery of Krishna’s disappearance from this material world. He played a Pastime that He was killed by a hunter. There are many disruptive explanations of the last portions of Lord Krishna’s Pastimes, such as the description of the incarnation of His hair, and Lord Chaitanya described them in their right interpretation.

As far as the incarnation of King Kansa is concerned, this is mentioned in Srimad Bhagwatam, in the Vishnu Purana, and in Mahabharata. It is stated there that the Lord snatched from His Head two kinds of hair: a grey hair and a black hair, and the separate hairs entered into the wombs of two queens of the Yadu dynasty, namely Rohini and Devaki. It is stated there that Lord Krishna descends to this material world for vanquishing all the demons; but some say that Krishna is the incarnation of Vishnu, Who is lying on the ocean of milk within this Universe. Srila Rupa Goswami and his commentator, Sri Valadev Vidya Bihshan, have discussed this point fully, and have established the exact truth. Sri Jiva Goswami also discussed this point in the Krishna Sandarbha.

When Lord Chaitanya finished his instruction to Sri Sanatan Goswami, Sanatan, being empowered and enlightened, was so transcendentally pleased that he at once fell at the Feet of Lord Chaitanya, and began to speak:

“I am born of a very low family and I have always been in association with lowly people, and therefore I am the lowest of the sinful persons. But You are so kind that You have taught me lessons which are not even understandable by the greatest being, Brahma. And by Your grace I have appreciated the conclusions which You have taught me. But I am so low that I cannot touch even a drop of the ocean of Your instruction. If You therefore want me, who am nothing but a lame man, to dance—then kindly give me Your benediction, by placing Your Feet on my head.”

He prayed for the Lord’s confirmation that the teachings might be actually evolved in his heart, by the grace of the Lord—otherwise there was no possibility of them being described by him. The purport is that Acharyas, or spiritual masters, are authorized by higher authorities. Instruction alone cannot make one an expert. Unless one is blessed by the spiritual master, or the Acharya, such teaching cannot become fully manifested. Therefore, one should seek the mercy of the spiritual master, so that the instruction of the spiritual master may develop within himself. After the prayer of Sanatan Goswami, Lord Chaitanya placed His Feet over the head of Sanatan, and gave him benediction, that all the instruction He had given him would develop in him fully.

That was the description of the ultimate stage of love of Godhead. Lord Chaitanya said that such a description cannot be made very elaborately, but He had informed him as far as possible.

CONCLUSION: Anyone who attentively hears these discussions and instructions of Lord Chaitanya to Sanatan Goswami very soon becomes situated in Krishna Consciousness, and can be engaged in devotional service to the Lord.

TLC 15-1968: Explanation of the Atmarama Verse in Srimad Bhagavatam

Chapter Fifteen

Explanation of the Atmarama Verse in Srimad Bhagwatam

Lord Chaitanya next explained a verse, appearing in Srimad Bhagwatam, which is very famous and known as the Atmarama verse: It runs as follows: Atmaramas cha munayanirg rantha apiurukrame, Kurvanti ahaituki bhaktim ittlhvambhuta guna harih. The general meaning is that those who are liberated souls and fully satisfied within themselves will later become devotees of the Lord. This is especially meant for the impersonalist class, because the impersonalist souls have no information of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They try to be satisfied in the impersonal Brahman, but Krishna is so attractive and so strong that He attracts even the minds of such impersonalists. That is the purport of the verse.

This verse had been explained previously to a great Vedantist, known as Sarvabhouma Bhattacharya. Sanatan Goswami, after taking his lessons from Lord Chaitanya, referred the incident to the Lord and prayed again for His explanation of the Atmarama verse. The author of Chaitanya Charitamrita, appreciating this explanation of the Atmarama verse, has glorified Lord Chaitanya by his prayer. Sanatan Goswami fell flat at the Feet of Lord Chaitanya, and requested Him to explain the Atmarama verse as He formerly had explained it to Sarvabhouma Bhattacharya. He explained his eagerness to hear the same explanation again, so that he might be enlightened.

When the Lord was thus requested by Sanatan Goswami He replied: “I do not understand why Sarvabhouma Bhattacharya has so much appreciated my explanation. As far as I am concerned I don’t remember what I said to him. But because you are asking, I shall try to explain whatever I can remember, by your association.” The speakerand the audience are very intimately connected; the speaker is enlightened by the presence of the audience. In transcendental subject matters the speaker or the Master can speak very nicely in relationship with the understanding of the audience. Therefore, Lord Chaitanya said, “Generally I do not know how to explain a Sanskrit verse, but I shall try to explain whatever I can by your association only.”

He then said that there are 11 different items in the Atmarama verse. They are as follows: 1. Atmarama, 2. Cha, 3. Munayah, 4. Nirgrantha, 5. Api, 6. Urukrame, 7. Kurvanti, 8. Ahaituki, 9. Bhaktim, 10. Itthvambhuta, 11. Harih. The Lord then began to explain each and every items as mentioned above:

So far as Atmarama is concerned, He said that the word Atma is used to mean:

1. the Supreme Absolute Truth, 2. the body, 3. the mind, 4. endeavor, 5. intelligence, 6. conviction, and 7. nature. Therefore, anyone who takes pleasure in the cultivation of the knowledge of these items, is called Atmarama. (The Lord explained hereinafter about the different kinds of Atmarama, or transcendentalists).

The next item is Muni. Persons who are very great thinkers are called Muni. Sometimes this Muni is also used for persons who are very grave. Muni is also used for great sages, great austere persons, great mystics and learned scholars.

The fourth item, Nirgrantha, means freed from the bondage of illusion. Another meaning of Nirgrantha is “one who has no connection with spiritual injunctions.” Grantha means revealed Scriptures. There are many instructions for spiritual realization, but persons who have no connection with such Scriptural injunctions are also known as Nirgrantha. Nir is an affix which is used with three meanings: it is used to mean no connection, and to mean constructing, and also prohibiting. There are many persons who are foolish, low-born and misbehaved, and they have no entrance into the revealed Scriptures and injunctions. Therefore, they are also called Nirgrantha. Because Grantha is also used for the purpose of riches, and for the purpose of collection, therefore Nirgrantha, in other words, means one who is after collecting riches and who is bereft of all riches.

The word Urukrama is used in the sense of a highly powerful person. Krama is also used in the sense of stepping: one who can step very far forward is also called Urukrama. The greatest stepping forward was shown by Lord Vamanadev: by stepping forward with His Foot, He covered the whole Universe. Therefore, Urukrama means the Supreme Lord Vamanadev. This extraordinary feature of Lord Vamanadev is explained in the Srimad Bhagwatam [2.7.40] as follows: “Nobody can estimate the inconceivable potencies of Lord Vishnu. Even if one can count the number of the atomic combinations of this material world, still he is not able to count the different energies of the Supreme Lord. The Lord, Vamanadev, was so powerful that by stepping forward with His foot He covered the whole Universe, beginning from the Brahmaloka down to the Patalaloka.”

The inconceivable energies of the Lord are spread all over the Creation of the Supreme Lord. He is All-pervading, and by His energy He sustains all planetary systems. And, by His display of pleasure potency, He is situated in His personal Abode, known as Goloka. By His expansion of opulence He is situated all over the Vaikuntha Planets as Narayan. By expanding His material energy, He has created innumerable Universes with innumerable planets within them. Therefore, no one can estimate the wonderful activities of the Supreme Lord. As such, the Supreme Lord is known as Urukrama, or the wonderful Actor.

In the Visvaprakash Dictionary, the meaning of the word Krama is described as an expert display of energies, as well as stepping forward very quickly, and the word Kurvanti is used for working for others. There is another word similar to this, used when the activities are done for one’s personal sense gratification. But the word Kurvanti is used when activities are performed for the satisfaction of the Supreme. Therefore this word can be used only for the purpose of rendering transcendental service to the Lord.

The word Hetu is used as the reason, or the cause. People are engaged generally in transcendental activities for three causes: namely, some of them want material happiness, some of them want mystic perfection, and some of them want liberation from this material bondage. So far as material enjoyment is concerned, there are varieties; nobody can ennumerate how many kinds of material enjoyments there are. So far as perfections in mystic powers are concerned, there are eighteen. So far as kinds of liberation from the material bondage are concerned, there are five. The state of being where all these different kinds of enjoyment are conspicuous by their absence is called Ahaituki. The qualification Ahaituki is especially mentioned because by Ahaituki service of the Lord one can achieve the favor of the Lord.

The word Bhakti is taken in ten different ways. Out of the ten, one is called Sadhan Bhakti, occupational devotional service. The other nine are called Prema Bhakti, love of Godhead. Those who are situated in the neutral position attain the development of perfection up to love of Godhead. Similarly, those who are situated in the relationship of master and servant attain love of Godhead up to the stage of attachment. Those who are in the relationship of friends attain their love of Godhead up to the point of fraternity. Those who are in love of Godhead as parents are elevated up to the point of emotion. But only those who are in conjugal love with the Supreme have ecstasy elevated to the highest of ecstasies. These are the different meanings of the term Bhakti.

The Lord then explained the different meanings of itthambhutagunah. He also explained the word Guna in its different meanings. Ittham bhuta means full transcendental, before which even the transcendental pleasure known as Brahmananda becomes like straw. In the Hari Bhakti Sudhodaya [14.36] it is said by the devotee: “My Lord, O Supreme, simply by understanding You or seeing You, the pleasure which we derive is so great that the pleasure in Brahmananda becomes insignificant.” In other words, the pleasure derived by understanding Krishna as He is, the All-attractive Reservoir of all pleasures, and. the Reservoir of all pleasure-giving tastes, with all transcendental qualifications, attracts one to become His devotee. By such attraction one can give up fruitive activities, endeavoring for liberation, or the intense desire to achieve success in Yoga mystic power. The attractive power of Krishna is so intense, that without any respect for any other means of self-realization, one surrenders unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead—simply by that attraction.

Guna means the unlimited transcendental qualities of Krishna, primarily His Sat-Chit-Ananda Form. In His transcendental blissful knowledge and eternity He is fully perfect; and, therefore, such perfection becomes more manifest when He becomes controlled by the attention of the devotee. God is so kind and merciful that He can give Himself in exchange for the devotional service of a devotee. His transcendental qualities are such that His perfection in His beauty, His perfect reciprocation of love between Himself and His devotees, and His flavor of all transcendental qualities attract different kinds of transcendentalists and liberated souls, by different manifestations of these qualities.

For example, He attracted the mind of one of the Kumaras, Sanaka, simply by the flavor of the flowers offered to Him. And the mind of Sukadeva Goswami was attracted by the transcendental Pastimes of Lord Krishna. He attracted by His Personal Beauty the minds of the damsels of Vrindaban, and He attracted the attention of Rukmini by His bodily feature and transcendental qualities. He attracts the mind of the Goddess of Fortune by playing the flute and by different other features of transcendental attraction. He attracts the minds of all young girls; He attracts the minds of elderly ladies by His childlike activities; and He attracts the minds of His friends by His friendly activities. When He appeared in Vrindaban, He attracted even the birds and beasts and the trees and the plants. Everyone became attracted in love and affection for Krishna.

The word Hari has different meanings, of which two are principals. Hari means that He takes away all inauspicious things from the devotee’s life, and that He attracts the mind of the devotee by awarding him transcendental love of Godhead. He is so attractive that anybody remembering Krishna in some way or other becomes free from the four kinds of material miseries. With special attention for His devotee, the Lord banishes the devotee’s different forms of sinful activities, which are a stumbling block for the advancement of devotional service. This is called routing the influence of ignorance. And, by hearing alone, one develops love for Him. That is the gift of the Lord. On one side He takes away our inauspicious things, and on the other side He awards the most auspicious things. That is the meaning of Hari.

When a person becomes developed in love of Godhead, then by His attractive power of transcendental qualities, He attracts the devotees body, mind and everything for the Lord. Such are the merciful activities of Krishna and such are His transcendental qualities. He is so attractive that, out of transcendental attachment for Him, a devotee will give up all the four principles of spiritual life: namely religiousness, economic development, regulation of sense gratification, and salvation. The words Api and Cha are adverbs. They can be utilized for virtually any purpose, but still the purpose of Cha, or “and,” means that the whole construction may have seven different readings.

The Lord established the import of eleven items in the verse of Atma rama. Then He began to explain the imports of each item as follows: the word Brahman means the greatest in all respects. He is the greatest in all opulences. Nobody can excel over His richness, nobody can excel over His strength, nobody can excel over His fame, nobody can excel over His beauty, nobody can excel over His knowledge, and nobody can excel over His renunciation. Therefore, the real meaning of Brahman is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna.

In the Vishnu Purana [1.12.57] the meaning of Brahman is given: He is the greatest and there is no limit to His expanding as the greatest. One may conceive of Brahman's greatness, yet it is growing in such a way that nobody can estimate how far or how great He actually is.

That Supreme Personality of Godhead is realized in three aspects, but they are all one and the same. The Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality, Krishna, is everlasting. In the Srimad Bhagwatam [2.9.33] it is said that He exists before the manifestation of this cosmic world, and He exists during its continuance, and He will continue to exist after the annihilation of this cosmic manifestation. Therefore, He is the Soul of everything great. He is All-pervading, He is All-witnessing, and He is the Supreme Form of everything.

To understand and achieve that Supreme perfection of the Absolute Truth, there are three different kinds of transcendental processes mentioned in the Vedic literature. They are called: the process of knowledge, the process of mystic Yoga, and the process of devotional service. The followers of different processes realize the Supreme Truth in different aspects; namely, those who are following the process of knowledge realize Him as impersonal Brahman; those who are following the process of Yoga realize Him as the localized Supersoul; and those who are following the process of devotional service realize Him as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna. In other words, although Brahman means Krishna and nothing else, still, according to the process followed by different transcendentalists, He is realized in three different aspects.

So far as devotional service is concerned, it is divided into two processes. In the beginning, it is called Bidhibhakti, or devotional service with regulated principles. And in the highest stage it is called Raga bhakti, or devotional service in pure love.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead is the Absolute Truth, but He is manifested by expansions of different energies also. Those who are following the principles of devotional service in regulative forms ultimately achieve the Vaikunthas in the Spiritual World. Whereas one who is following the principles of love in devotional service reaches to the Supreme Abode, Krishna Loka or Goloka.

The transcendentalists can also be divided into three: namely the Akama, or one who does not have any material desires; the Moksa kama, or persons who seek liberation from the material miseries; and Sarva kama, or persons who have material desires to enjoy. The most intelligent transcendentalist gives up all other processes and engages himself in the devotional service of the Lord, even though he may have many desires. Not by any kind of transcendental activities, either in fruitive action or the cultivation of knowledge, nor by mystic yogic cultivation, can a person achieve the highest perfection, without adding a tinge of devotional service to them.

Except for devotional service, all other forms of transcendental processes are just like nipples on the neck of a goat. There are some nipples hanging on the neck of a goat, but they do not supply milk. If one is to derive, therefore, the actual perfection of his process he must take to the devotional service of Krishna.

In Bhagavad Gita it is stated, in the Seventh Chapter, 16th verse, that there are four kinds of beginners in devotional service whose backgrounds are very righteous. They are the distressed, the inquisitive, the seeker of material profit, and the Jnani, or the wise man. These four kinds of people, when they are coated by previous righteous activities, come to the devotional service of the Lord. Out of these four, those who are distressed and those who are in need of material possessions are called devotees with desires, whereas the other two, the inquisitive and the wise, are under the heading of seeking liberation. But, because they worship Krishna, they are considered to be very fortunate. In due course of time, if they give up all their desires and become pure devotees of the Supreme Lord, they are called the most fortunate.

Such fortunate beginners can develop only in the association of pure devotees of Lord Krishna. When one is associated with such pure devotees, one becomes a pure devotee himself. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam in the First Canto, Tenth Chapter [11], as follows: “A person who is actually intelligent is able, by association with pure devotees, to hear about Lord Krishna and His activities.” These activities are very attractive, and he does not give up such association with the Lord.

Except for the association of pure devotees, any association is called Kaitava, or cheating. This is also confirmed in Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto [1.1.2]; where it is stated that any cheating process which obstructs transcendental realization is to be thrown off. By the Srimad Bhagwatam one can understand reality as it is, and that becomes auspicious in helping one to transcend the three kinds of material miseries. Srimad Bhagwatam is compiled by the greatest sage, Vyasadeva, as a work of his mature experience; and therefore, by understanding Srimad Bhagwatam, one can immediately capture the Supreme Lord within his heart, by devotional service.

Lord Chaitanya then explained that the word Projjhitta means desire for liberation, which is explained by one great commentator as the most obstructive stumbling block for realization of the Supreme Lord. But, somehow or other, if somebody comes to Krishna and begins to hear about Him, Krishna is so kind that He awards him His Lotus Feet as a center for the devotee. Such a devotee or transcendentalist forgets everything and engages himself in the devotional service of the Lord.

For anyone who comes to the Lord in devotional service, or in full Krishna Consciousness, the reward is the Supreme. Once engaged for the Supreme, he will no longer ask for anything, as does the distressed man and he who desires material possessions. The method of devotional service, the service itself, association with pure devotees in the causeless mercy of the Lord—these three things can act so wonderfully that, whether the devotee is a distressed soul or in want of material possessions or inquisitive—or even if he is a wise man cultivating knowledge—he can give up all activities, and his mind becomes absorbed in Krishna.

The summary is that, henceforward, whatever meaning would apply for all the words in the Atmarama verse will be meant only for Krishna.

So far, Lord Chaitanya has spoken only of the introduction to the Atmarama verse. Now he will explain its real position:

In the cultivation of knowledge there are two kinds of transcendentalists. One of them is the worshipper of the impersonal Brahman, and the other is the desirer of liberation. Monists worship the impersonal feature of Brahman, and therefore they are called the worshippers of Brahman. The worshippers of Brahman are divided into three further stages: the neophyte practitioner, one who is absorbed in Brahman realization, and one who has actually realized himself as Brahman. If devotional service is added, the knower of Brahman can then become liberated. Otherwise, there is no possibility.

Anyone who is fully engaged in devotional service in Krishna Consciousness is understood to be already a soul realized in Brahman. Devotional service is so strong that one is attracted to Krishna even from the process of Brahman worship. The Lord awards such a devotee the perfection of a spiritual body, and he is eternally engaged in the transcendental quality of Krishna. When he understands and becomes attracted by transcendental qualities, he wholeheartedly becomes engaged in devotional service. For example, the four Kumaras and Sukadeva Goswami were liberated souls from the very beginning, and still, later in life, they became attracted to the Pastimes of Krishna—and they became devotees. Devotees like the four Kumaras—one of whom, Sanaka Kumara, was attracted by the flavor of the flowers offered to Krishna—were all attracted by the transcendental qualities of the Lord, and thus became engaged in His devotional service. The nine mystics mentioned in the Eleventh Canto of Srimad Bhagwatam are understood to have been transcendentalists from birth by hearing the transcendental qualities of Krishna from Brahma and Lord Shiva and Narada.

Sometimes one becomes attracted to Krishna and His transcendental qualities simply by looking upon the beautiful features of His transcendental Body, and in that case also one gives up the desire for liberation and becomes engaged in the devotional service of the Lord. The devotee repents his loss of time in the so-called cultivation of knowledge, and becomes a pure devotee of the Lord.

There are two kinds of liberated souls even in this material body: the soul liberated by devotional service, and the soul liberated by the cultivation of knowledge. The difference is that the liberated soul in devotional service becomes more and more elevated, being attracted by the transcendental qualities of Krishna, whereas the dry speculators who simply cultivate knowledge without any connection with devotional service become fallen on account of their many offences.

This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Second Chapter [10.2.32]. It is said there, “ O my Lord, the intelligence of those who think themselves liberated without a touch of devotional service is not pure, because, even though they rise to the highest point of liberation by severe penances and austerity, still, with no center at Your Lotus Feet, they are sure to fall down again into this material existence.” Bhagavad Gita also confirms this, in the Eighteenth Chapter, 54th verse—one who is actually situated in the Brahman realization has nothing to lament for and nothing to desire. He is equipoised toward everyone, and thus is eligible for being situated in devotional service.

This same thing is accepted by Bilvamongal Thakur. In his later life, he lamented that, “I was situated as a monist, to become One with the Supreme Lord, but somehow or other, I contacted a Naughty Boy, and I became His eternal servitor.” In other words, those who become self-realized souls by executing devotional service can achieve a transcendental body, and by being attracted to the transcendental qualities of Krishna, they become engaged fully in pure devotional service.

Anyone who is not attracted to Krishna is understood to be still under the spell of Maya. Therefore, one who is trying to be liberated by devotional service is actually liberated from the spell of Maya. In the Eleventh Canto of Srimad Bhagwatam there are many instances of devotees who became liberated in this life simply by their engagement in devotional service.

TLC 16-1968: Conclusion of Teachings to Sanatan Goswami

Chapter Sixteen

Conclusion of Teachings to Sanatan Goswami

Persons who desire liberation by the cultivation of knowledge are of three kinds: the desirers for liberation; the liberated in this material existence; and the actually self-realized. As for desiring to become liberated, there are many such persons in this world, and sometimes they engage themselves in devotional service for this purpose. It is corroborated also in Srimad Bhagwatam, in the First Canto, Second Chapter [26], that those who actually desire liberation give up all kinds of worship of the demigods, and, without being envious of them concentrate their minds in the worship of Narayan, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Such persons are engaged in the service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Narayan; and when they are in contact with pure devotees, they become engaged in the devotional service of Krishna, and give up the idea of liberation. In the Hari Bhakti Sudhodaya, there is a nice verse in which it is stated: “O great soul, although there are many faults within this miserable life, yet there is one glory—the association of pure devotees. Cultivate such association. By such association our desire for liberation diminishes.”

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Second Chapter, verse 35, it is stated that man’s fearfulness is due to his material conception of life and to his forgetting his eternal relationship with the Supreme Lord. Therefore, he finds himself having only perverted memories. Such things have happened due to the spell of material energy. Therefore, a person with enough intelligence will engage himself in full devotional service with the Supreme Lord as his Spiritual Master and worshippable God. The purport is that nobody can attain a revolution without being engaged in devotional service to the Lord. When, however, he is free from this material contamination, he can fully engage himself in Krishna Consciousness.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fourteenth Chapter [10.14.4], it is clearly said that, for a person who is engaged in devotional service to understand things as they are, but who lacks any intention of being engaged in Krishna Consciousness, the trouble undergone for his understanding is his only achievement. There is no substance to his life. Every living entity is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, and therefore it is the duty of every living entity to serve that Supreme Whole. Without doing that the living entity falls into material contamination, and his service is lost.

Lord Chaitanya then concluded that these six kinds of Atmarama engage themselves in some kind of devotional service to Krishna. In other words, all the transcendentalists at different times ultimately come to the understanding of rendering devotional service to Krishna, and become fully Krishna conscious. Even when one is very learned, or if one is very extravangant, still, he can be engaged in the devotional service of the Lord.

The six kinds of transcendentalists are the neophyte transcendentalist, the absorbed transcendentalist, one actually situated in transcendence, a person caring for liberation, persons actually liberated, and persons who are actually engaged in their constitutional position. All of them are called Atmarama. When a person becomes Atmarama, or a great thinker in Krishna Consciousness, he is fully engaged in devotional service. There are many Atmaramas according to the grammatical rules, but one word, Atmarama, is sufficient to represent all other Atmaramas. In the collective sense all the Atmaramas are inclined to worship the Supreme Lord Krishna.

The mystic who worships the Supersoul within himself is also called Atmarama. Such Atmarama yogis are of two kinds: the one is called Sagarbha, the other is called Nigarbha. In Srimad Bhagwatam it is stated, in the Second Canto, Second Chapter [8]: “Some of the yogis meditate within the heart on the localized situation of Vishnu, Who is four-handed with four symbols: the conch shell, the wheel, the club and the lotus.” The yogi who thinks of the four-handed Vishnu becomes developed in devotional ecstasy, and attains the different symptoms of that position. Sometimes he cries, sometimes he feels separation. In this way he becomes merged in transcendental bliss. So, as a result of such transcendental bliss, he is practically entrapped like a fish.

Such Sagarbha and Nigarbha yogis can be divided into three: the beginner, the person who is already on the ascendent, and he who has already achieved a perfection. In the Bhagavad Gita they have been described in the Sixth Chapter as follows: Persons who are trying to ascend on the path of the mystic Yoga system are called Aruruksha. In Aruruksha Yoga there are different kinds of sitting postures and there is concentration of the mind. For one who is already ascended on the path of Yoga, meditation and detachment are the causes. And when one has no attachment for working in the matter of sense gratification, then gradually he becomes free, and becomes situated in ecstasy and is called Yoga Rudha. Such mystic yogis, if they in some way or other come in contact with a saintly person, also are converted to become devotees of Krishna.

So far as the word Urukrama is concerned, it is already explained: Urukrama means the Supreme Lord, and all these Atmaramas are engaged in devotional service to Urukrama. Before engaging themselves in devotional service, such transcendentalists are called Shantas, or they are called pacified devotees.

Atma, self, is also known as the mind. Sometimes there are mental speculationists who present philosophical thoughts in different ways, but when they come into contact with saintly persons engaged in devotional service, they also become devotees.

Concerning the two classes of yogis, Sagarbha and Nigarbha, the Srimad Bhagwatam, in the Tenth Canto, Eighty-seventh Chapter [10.87.18], describes them as follows: “The yogis begin their practice by worshipping the abdomen, and try to concentrate their attention on their intestines. Then gradually they rise to the heart, and concentrate the mind on the heart. Then gradually they rise to the top of the head. One who can rise to that portion is understood to have become perfect, and is no longer subjected to birth and death.” Even such yogis, if they come in contact with pure devotees, will also render causeless devotional service to the Lord.

Another meaning of Atma is to endeavor. In every practice there is endeavor, and the ultimate endeavor is to reach the highest perfectional stage of devotional service. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto, Fifth Chapter, 18th verse, it is stated that one should try for the highest achievement, which cannot be attained even in the highest planetary system—nor in the lowest. The idea is that material happiness and miseries are available, in the course of time, in any of the planetary systems; but the highest achievement, devotional service, cannot be achieved anywhere without endeavor. Therefore, in the Narada Purana, it is said that one who is serious about understanding the highest perfectional stage of devotional service, simply by his endeavor, can become successful in everything.

One cannot, therefore, achieve the highest perfectional stage of devotional service without personal endeavor. And, as is stated in the Bhagavad Gita, Tenth Chapter [10]: “For he who is constantly engaged in such devotional service, the Supreme Lord, Who is situated in everyone’s heart, gives the intelligence by which he can make undeterred progress in devotional activities.”

The word Atma is also meant for patience and perseverance. By patience and perseverance one can achieve the highest stage of devotional service.

Another meaning for Muni is “the bird and large black bee.” Another meaning of Nirgrantha is “the foolish person.” Even the birds, even the black bee, and even the foolish engage themselves in the service of the Supreme Lord, when they are favored by the pure devotee. For example, it is stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam [10.21.14] that the birds are devoted to the service of the Supreme Lord. In the Tenth Canto, Fifteenth Chapter [10.15.6], there is a statement that the black bees are following Krishna and Valarama. Taking that incident, Lord Valarama described the devotional service of the wasps unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He said, “O Supremely Virtuous One, the Original Personality of Godhead, just see how these bees and wasps are following You, glorifying Your transcendental Fame, and thus worshipping You. Actually, these wasps are not as they appear, but they are great sages, and are taking the opportunity to worship the Supreme Soul now. Although You are not knowable by ordinary persons, still they know You and they are following You and glorifying You.”

Similarly, there is another verse in Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fifteenth Chapter [10.15.7], in which the peacocks were receiving Valarama and Krishna, and it is said in this connection: “O Worshippable One, just see how the peacocks who are returning to their nests are receiving You in full pleasure. The peacocks are just like the damsels of Vraja. And the cuckoos on the branches of the trees are also receiving You in their own way. The residents of Vrindaban are so glorious that everyone is prepared to render their respective devotional service to the Lord.”

Similarly, there is another verse in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Thirty-fifth Chapter, 11th verse, in which it is stated. “O just see how the cranes and swans on the water are singing the glories of the Lord! And they are meditating, standing in the water, worshipping the Supreme Lord.” There is another verse in Srimad Bhagwatam, Second Canto, Fourth Chapter [18], in which it is stated: “Even the aborigines and uncivilized human beings like Kiratas, Huns, Andhra, Pulinda, Pukksa, Abhira, Kank, Yuvana and Khasa, and many other human beings in the lower species of life—all can be purified simply by taking center of the pure devotees.” So Sukadeva Goswami offered his respectful obeisances unto the Lord, Vishnu, Whose devotees can work so wonderfully.

Another meaning of Driti is to realize oneself as elevated. In that position one feels himself free from all miseries, and is elevated to the highest standard of life. Therefore, all devotees of Krishna in full Krishna Consciousness are free from all kinds of material pleasures. They are full with the service of the Lord, and they are always jolly, being engaged in such transcendental service. They are experienced men of happiness. They are so happy that they do not even desire to be promoted to the spiritual planets, because they are happy in every sphere of life. Being fully in the transcendental service of the Lord, they do not desire any material things or material sense pleasures. There is another verse spoken by the Goswamis in which it is stated, “Persons who have fixed up their moving senses in the service of the Supreme Lord can be called peaceful.”

And so, Atmarama means that even the birds, even the beasts, even the fools—everyone—becomes attracted by the transcendental qualities of Krishna, and they engage in His service, and therefore become liberated.

Still another meaning of Atma is “intelligence.” One who has special intelligence is also called Atmarama. Such Atmaramas with special intelligence are of two kinds: One is the learned sage, and another is the fool, one without book knowledge. But both of them may have the opportunity of associating with the pure devotee. The foolish Atmaramas can also give up everything, and in pure devotional service engage themselves in Krishna Consciousness. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, it is said that the Lord is the Origin of everything, and that everything emanates from Him. Anyone who is actually intelligent can understand the Supreme Lord Krishna as the Source of everything, and thus engages himself in His service. There is another verse in Srimad Bhagwatam, Second Canto, Seventh Chapter, 45th verse: “What to speak of persons who are intelligent enough by study of the Vedas—even less intelligent persons, like the woman, the laborer class and the Huna savarapi, the birds, the beasts—everyone can achieve the highest perfectional stage of life.” It is stated in the Bhagavad Gita, Tenth Chapter, 10th verse, that when a person becomes highly intelligent and engages himself in Krishna Consciousness, then Krishna in reciprocation gives him the intelligence by which he can be promoted to the Abode of the Supreme Lord.

The Lord said to Sanatan Goswami that the association of good devotees, engagement in the transcendental service of the Lord, understanding Srimad Bhagwatam, and chanting the Holy Name of the Lord, as well as residing in a place like Vrindaban or Mathura—these five things are very important for elevating oneself to the transcendental plane. Not to speak of attaining all the five—if one becomes expert in one of them, then he also is, without fail, elevated to the stage of love of Godhead. But anyone who is actually intelligent should give up all other desires and engage himself in the transcendental service of Krishna. The influence of devotional service is such that a person so engaged gives up all material desires and becomes fully attached to taking center unto Krishna, being moved by the transcendental qualities of the Lord. That is the beauty of the Lord to His devotee.

Another meaning of Atma is “nature.” Atmarama means that everyone is enjoying the particular nature he has acquired. But the ultimate nature, or the perpetual, eternal nature of the living entity is to serve the Supreme Lord. Anyone who attains to the perfection of understanding his real nature—of eternally being the servitor of the Lord—gives up his designative (material, or bodily) conception of life. That is real knowledge. Those who are in pursuit of knowledge and get the opportunity of associating with a pure devotee also become engaged in devotional service of the Lord. Sages like the four Kumaras, as well as the fools and the birds, can be engaged in the transcendental service of the Lord. Being favored by Krishna’s causeless mercy, everyone can be elevated to the standard of Krishna Consciousness.

One becomes attracted by the transcendental qualities of Krishna and begins his devotional service. It is stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fifteenth Chapter [10.15.8], in glorifying the land of Vrindaban: “This land, Vrajabhumi, is glorified by the touching of Your Sole. By the touching of Your Fingers, the creepers also glorify You. By Your looking on the hills and the rivers and the lower animals, they are all glorified. And, so far as the Gopis are concerned, they, being embraced by Your transcendental Arms, are also glorified.” The Gopis glorified Vrindaban in the following words: “My dear friends, all these inhabitants of our Vrajabhumi, including the birds, beasts and trees, everyone, while seeing Lord Krishna going to the pasturing ground with His friends, accompanied by Valadeva and singing on Their flutes—all are glorified.”

The Lord said that Atma also means “this body.” The yogis who practice bodily exercises, considering the body as the self, also are elevated to the transcendental service of the Lord if they are associated with pure devotees. There are many persons who have the concept of this body being the self. They are engaged in many kinds of fruitive activities, including bathing rituals and ordinary worldly activities. But when they come in contact with a pure devotee, they also engage themselves in the transcendental service of the Lord.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto, Eighteenth Chapter [12], it is stated: “O my dear Suta Goswami, you have given us the nectar of Krishna’s Lotus Feet, although we have become darkened by the sacrificial smoke of these fruitive activities.” The Srimad Bhagwatam, Fourth Canto, Twenty-first Chapter [31], states: “The Ganges water is flowing from the tip of the Lotus Feet of Krishna, and by bathing in that Ganges water, everyone—including the fruitive actors and all the sages—is washing the dirty things from within the mind."

Those who are in the concept of the body as the self, or those who are full of material desires, are also called, in a sense, Atmarama. When they are associated with the pure devotees of the Lord, they give up their material desires and become perfect in the service of the Lord. The best example of this is found in the Hari Bhakti Sudhodaya, in connection with the character of Druva. In the Seventh Chapter, 28th verse, it is stated by Maharaj Druva: “My dear Lord, I came to worship You desirous of having some land on this Earth; but, fortunately, I have You, Who are beyond the perception of great sages and saintly persons. I came to search out some particles of colored glass, but I’ve found instead a very valuable gem like You. I am satisfied. I have no desire to ask You anything.”

There is another meaning to the word Nirgrantha—“foolish hunter,” or “wretched poor man.” Such a hunter also got salvation and engaged himself in the devotional service of the Lord by association of the pure devotee Narada. The following story is about this hunter’s meeting with Narada:

There was a hunter in the forest of Prayag, who was fortunate enough to meet Narada while he was coming back from Vaikuntha after visiting Lord Narayan. Narada came to Prayag to bathe in the confluence of the Ganges and the Yamuna. While passing through the forest, he saw a bird lying on the ground, half-killed, and pierced by an arrow. It was chirping piteously. At another place he saw a deer flapping in agony. In another place he saw that a boar was suffering and, in another place, he saw a rabbit flapping in pain. All this made him very compassionate, and he bagan to think, “Who is the foolish man that has committed such sinful activities?” A devotee of the Lord is generally compassionate for the miseries of the living entities, and so what to speak of great Narada? He became very aggrieved by this scene, and after proceeding a few steps, he saw the hunter engaged in hunting with his bow and arrows. The hunter’s complexion was very black, and his eyes were red, and it was dangerous even to see him standing there with his bow and arrows, just like an associate of Yamaraja—Death. Seeing him in that position, Narada Muni entered deeper into the forest and approached him. And, while Narada Muni was passing through the forest, all the animals who were caught in the hunter’s traps fled away. The hunter became very angry over this, and he was just going to call Narada vile names but, by the influence of Narada, who was such a saintly person, the hunter could not utter ill names.

Rather, with gentle behavior, he inquired from Narada: “My dear sir, why have you come before me while I am hunting? Are you astray from the general path? By your coming here all the animals assembled in my traps have now fled away.”

Narada replied, “Yes, I’m sorry. I have come to you to find my own path, just to inquire from you. But I have seen that there are many boars and deer and rabbits on the path, and they are lying on the forest floor flapping before death, half-dead. Who has committed these sinful acts?”

The hunter replied, “What you have seen is all right; it is done by me.”

Then Narada said, “If you are hunting all these poor animals, why don’t you kill them at once? You half-kill them, and they are flapping in death-pains. This is a great sin. If you want to kill any animal, why don’t you kill it completely? Why do you leave it half-killed, and allow the animal to die flapping?”

The hunter replied, “My dear Lord, my name is Mrigari, the enemy of the animals. According to the teachings of my father, I have been raised to half-kill the animals by leaving them flapping. When a half-dead animal flaps, I take great pleasure in that.”

Narada then implored the hunter; “I beg one thing from you, and please accept it.”

The hunter replied, “Oh, yes sir, I shall give you whatever you like. If you want some animal skins, come to my home. I have so many skins of animals, tigers, and deer. Whatever you like I shall give you.”

Narada replied, “I do not want such things. But I want something else. If you kindly grant it to me, then I shall tell you. Please, henceforth from tomorrow, whenever you kill an animal, please kill it completely, and don’t leave it half-dead.”

The hunter replied, “Oh, my dear sir, what are you asking of me? Why are you asking this? What is the difference between half-killing and killing completely?”

Narada replied, “If you half-kill the animals, then they suffer too much pain, and if you give too much pain to other living entities, it is a great sin. When you kill an animal completely, there is much offense, but it is not so great as that accrued by half-killing an animal. In other words, pain which you give to the half-dead animals will have to be accepted by you also in some of the future births awaiting you.”

Although the hunter was very sinful, yet in association of a great devotee like Narada, his mind became softened, and he was afraid of the sins. Those who are grossly sinful are not afraid at all of committing sins; but here we can see that because his purification began in the association of a great devotee like Narada, he was afraid of his sinful activities.

The hunter therefore said, “My dear sir, from my childhood I have been taught to kill animals like that. So would you kindly tell me how can I get rid of all the offenses and sinful activities which I have committed? I am surrendering unto your feet. Please save me from all the reactions of my sinful activities in the past, and just direct me in the proper path so that I can be free.”

Narada replied, “If you actually want to follow my direction, then I can tell you the real path of being freed from these sinful reactions.”

The hunter agreed, and told Narada Muni, “Whatever you direct, I shall follow without any hesitation.”

Narada then asked him to first break his bow, and then he would disclose the path of liberation.

The hunter replied, “You are asking me to break my bow, but if I break it then what will be the means of my living?”

Narada replied, “Don’t worry for your living. I shall send you sufficient grains so that you can live.”

Thereupon, the hunter broke his bow and fell down at the feet of Narada. Narada got him to stand up, and instructed him: ‘Just go to your home and whatever money and valuables you have there, distribute amongst the devotees and Brahmins, and just come out with me, wearing only one cloth. Construct a small thatched house on the bank of the river, and sow the tulsi plant by the house. Just circumambulate the tulsi tree, and every day taste one fallen leaf, and always chant Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. So far as your living is concerned, I shall send you the required grains. But you will only accept as much grain as you require for yourself and your wife.”

Narada then relieved the half-dead animals and, after getting free from that dreadful condition, they fled away. By seeing the miracle executed by Narada, the black hunter was struck with wonder, and after taking him to his home, he again bowed down at his feet.

Narada returned to his place, and the hunter, after returning to his home, began to execute the instructions which Narada had given him. In the meantime, the news spread among all the villages that the hunter had become a devotee, and therefore the residents of the villages came to see the new Vaishnava. It is the custom of persons following the Vedic way of life to bring some grains or some fruits whenever they go to see some saintly person. All the villagers saw that the hunter now had turned into a great devotee, and they began to bring eatables. So every day he was offered grains and fruit, so much that no less than ten to twenty people might eat there. But, according to Narada’s instruction, he did not accept anything more than what he required to live on, for both himself and his wife.

After some days had passed, Narada said to his friend Parbut Muni: “I have a disciple. Let us go and see him, and see if he is doing well.”

When the two great sages, Narada and Parbut, came to the place of the hunter, and the hunter saw his Spiritual Master coming from the distance, he began to go to him with great respect. But while he was going to receive the great sages, there were ants on the field, and it was a hindrance to his passing. When he reached the sages, he wanted to bow down before them, but he saw there were many ants and he slowly cleared away the ants with his cloth. When Narada saw that the hunter was trying to save the lives of the ants in such a way, it reminded him of a verse from the Skanda Purana. That verse states: “Is it not wonderful for a devotee of the Lord, that he is not inclined to give any sort of pain, even to the ant?”

The purport is that, formerly, the hunter took pleasure by half-killing animals, but now that he had become a great devotee of the Lord, he was not prepared to give pain even to an ant.

The hunter received the two great sages at his house, and he offered them a sitting place, and brought water and washed their feet, and took water to them for drinking, and both the husband and wife touched the water on their heads. After this they began to feel ecstasy, and began to dance, singing Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare—raising their hands and dancing with their clothing flying.

When the two great sages saw the ecstasy of love of Godhead in the body of the hunter, Parbut Muni addressed Narada: “You are a touchstone, and so by your association even a great hunter has turned into a great devotee.”

There is a nice verse in the Skanda Purana which says: “My dear Devarsi (Narada), you are glorious, and by your mercy even the lowest creature, such as a hunter, also became elevated to such a state of devotion, and attained transcendental attachment for Krishna.”

Narada then enquired of the hunter-devotee: “Are you getting your foodstuff regularly?”

The hunter replied, “You send so many people, and they bring so much eatables that we both cannot eat so much.”

Narada replied, “That’s all right. Whatever you are getting, it is all right. Now continue your devotional service in that way.” And after saying that, both Narada and Parbut Muni disappeared from that place.

This recitation of the story of the hunter is offered by Lord Chaitanya to show that even a hunter can be engaged in the devotional service of Krishna by the influence of pure devotees.

He then said that another meaning of Atma is: all varieties of the Personality of Godhead. Generally, the Personality of Godhead Himself, Krishna, and His different expansions, are all known as the Personality of Godhead. So anyone who is engaged in the devotional service of any Form or extension of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is also called Atmarama, and all such devotees engage themselves either in the regulative principles of devotional service, or in devotional service in transcendental love.

These two kinds of devotees also are divided into three categories: the associates, those in the perfection of devotional service, and those newly-engaged in devotional service. Newly engaged devotees can be divided into two: ones who have already attained an attachment for the Lord, and others who have not attained such attachment for the Lord. And, according to the two divisions of devotional service, namely the regulative principles and attachment by transcendental love, all these four classes of devotees become eight in number. By following the regulative principles of devotion, the perfect associates of the Lord are divided further into four classes: the servants, the friends, the parental superiors, and the fiancees.

Just as devotees are sometimes perfected by devotional service, so some of them are eternally perfect. In the regulative principle of devotional service, according to the advanced standard and the beginner’s standard, there are sixteen kinds of devotees in transcendental loving service of the Lord. Therefore, such Atmaramas can be considered to exist in 32 divisions. If you apply the words Muni, Nirgrantha, Cha and Api in the 32 classes, then it becomes a description of 58 different types of devotees. All these devotees can be sheltered by one word: Atmarama. Just as in the forest, there may be different kinds of trees, but only by saying that there are trees there, the meaning is understood.

Thus the Lord completed 60 different meanings of the word Atmarama. And then He again said that Atma means “the living entity, beginning from the first living creature, Brahma, down to the ant.” He cited a verse from Vishnu Purana, Sixth Chapter, in which it is stated that the energies of the Lord are all spiritual. Of them, the energy which is known as the source of the living entity is also spiritual, but the other energy, which is full of ignorance and is manifested in material activities, is called material Nature. The living entities are innumerable, even in the material creation, and if by chance one of them or some of them can get the association of a pure devotee, then they can be engaged in the pure devotional service of Krishna. The Lord said, “Formerly I thought of 60 different meanings for the word Atmarama, but here another meaning came to My mind by your association.”

Sanatan Goswami, after hearing from the Lord about different meanings of the word Atmarama, was struck with wonder and fell down in devotion at the feet of Lord Chaitanya. He said, “I understand that You are Personally the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna, and with Your breathing there are many manifestations of the Vedic literature. You are the Teacher of Srimad Bhagwatam, so You know best the meanings of the verses of Srimad Bhagwatam. It is not possible for others to understand the confidential meanings of Srimad Bhagwatam without Your mercy.”

The Lord then replied to Sanatan Goswami, “Do not try to eulogize Me in that way. Just try to understand the real nature of Srimad Bhagwatam: Srimad Bhagwatam is the sound representation of the Supreme Lord Krishna: therefore, Srimad Bhagwatam is not different from Krishna. So, as Krishna is unlimited, similarly, in each word and each letter of Srimad Bhagwatam, there are unlimited meanings, and one can understand them by association of devotees. Don’t, then, say that Bhagwatam is a collection of answers to questions.”

There were six questions put by the sages of Nayamisharanya to Sukadeva Goswami, and Sukadeva Goswami explained or answered the six questions in the Srimad Bhagwatam. There is a verse in the Vedic literature in which Lord Shiva says, “So far as Bhagwatam is concerned, I may know or Sukadeva may know or Vyasadeva may know It or not know It—but actually Bhagwatam is to be understood by devotional service, and from a devotee, and not by one’s own intelligence or by learned comments.”

The sages of Nayamisharanya asked [1.1.23], “My dear sir, kindly tell us now, after the departure of the Lord for His own Abode, if the principles of religion have gone with Him. How can we find such principles after His departure?”

The reply was as follows [1.3.43]: “After the departure of Krishna to His Abode with all religious principles, His representation, the Srimad Bhagwatam, the Maha Purana, stands as the blazing, illuminating sun.”

The Lord then said, “I am just like a madman, to describe this verse of Atmarama in so many ways; so you must not mind if I have said something mad. But if somebody becomes a madman like Me, he can understand the real meaning of Srimad Bhagwatam as I have explained it.”

Then Sanatan Goswami, with folded hands, fell down at the feet of Lord Chaitanya and prayed as follows: “My dear Lord, You have asked me to prepare the regulative principles of devotional service, but I belong to the lowest caste. I have no knowledge. I do not know how such an important task can be finished my me. If You will kindly give me some hints about the preparation of such a book on devotional service, then it may be that I shall be qualified to write such a book.”

The Lord then blessed him, saying, “Whatever you write, by the grace of Krishna, everything will come out of your heart to be accepted as you have asked. I’ll give you some notes that you can take down: The first and foremost thing is that one should accept a bona fide Spiritual Master. That is the beginning of spiritual life.”

After indicating that one should begin by accepting a Spiritual Master, He requested Sanatan Goswami to write the symptoms of a true Guru, and the symptoms of a true devotee. The symptoms of a devotee are described in the Padma Puräëa: A person who is a qualified Brahmin, and at the same time qualified with all the symptoms of a devotee, can become the Spiritual Master of all classes of men, and such a devotee and Spiritual Master must be respected as God Himself. But a person, even though he may be born of a very respectful Brahmin family, cannot become a bona fide Spiritual Master if he is not a devotee of the Lord. One should not, therefore, be misguided to think that a bona fide Spiritual Master is required to be born of a so-called Brahmin family. The idea is that a Spiritual Master must be a qualified Brahmin—by the symptoms of his activities.

This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam [7.11.35] when Narada speaks of the different symptoms of the different divisions of social life, and when he summarizes that Brahmins and Kshatriyas and Sudras should be selected by their particular individual qualificational symptoms. And Sridhar Swami has noted, in his comment, that birth in the family of a Brahmin does not mean that one is a Brahmin—he must be qualified with the symptoms of a Brahmin, as they are described in the Shastras. Practically, also, we have experience that there are many devotees in the disciplic succession of the Gaudiya Vishnu Sampradaya, such as the two great acharyas Thakur Narottam and Shyamananda Goswami, who were not born in Brahmin families, but were accepted as Spiritual Masters by many Brahmins of fame, such as Ganganarayana [and] Ramakrishna.

In this way, there are symptoms of the prospective devotee; and both the disciple and the Spiritual Master must each see whether the other is eligible to become a bona fide Spiritual Master or a bona fide student of the Spiritual Master. Then one should know that the worshippable object is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and all kinds of different Mantras, sacred songs, should be understood.

The Lord also instructed that Sanatan should describe the symptoms of persons who are eligible to accept the Mantra, and how the Mantras should be understood and perfected by ritualistic performances. Then He described initiation, morning duties, and duties of cleanliness—washing the face, washing the teeth—working, and prayers both in the morning and in the evening; how to worship the Spiritual Master, how to mark the body with Gopi-chandan, how to collect the tulsi leaves, how to wash the room and the temple of the Lord, and how to awaken Krishna from His sleeping. He described different methods for worshipping the Lord, which is called the method of fivefold paraphernalia and fifty-fold paraphernalia. How to worship the Lord by five times offering worship and Aruti; how to offer foodstuff to Krishna, how to lay Him down on the bed. There are different symptoms of the Form of the Lord and Salagram Seela, such as the effect of going to holy places where there are different temples of the Lord, and seeing the Form of God in the temples. There is the glorifying of the transcendental Name of the Lord, and the different offences in the matter of worshipping. When worshipping the Lord there are other things: paraphernalia such as the conch shell, water, and fragrant flowers; prayers and hymns, circumambulation, offering obeisances, regulative principles of Puroscharam, and accepting Krishna Prasadam, rejecting foodstuff which is not offered to Krishna, and not indulging in defaming a devotee who has the actual symptoms of a devotee.

There are also symptoms of a holy man, the process of satisfying the sage, and rejecting the society of undesirable persons; and hearing Srimad Bhagwatam constantly. Also to be followed are duties of the day, duties of the fortnight, and observing fasting on Ekadasee day; the duties of the month, observing ceremonies like the birthday of the Lord, the three specific dates of fasting, Ekadasee, Janmastami, Vamanadvadasi, Sri Ramanavami and Nrishingha Chaturdasi. And, in observing such fasting days, there is the consideration of Beeddhaa, or overlapping of fasting days with other situations of the month, and how they are helpful in the advancement of devotional service. Lord Chaitanya instructed Sanatan Goswami that in every step he should give documentary evidence from the Puranas. Also mentioned is how to establish the temples of the Lord, and the general behavior and symptoms of a Vaishnava, and the duties and occupation of the Vaishnava. Thus the Lord in summary explained all the details of writing books on Vaishnava regulative principles.

Sanatan Goswami was a great devotee of the Lord, and was directly instructed to spread the cult of Bhakti by writing many books. There is a description of him in Chaitanya Chandrodaya [9.34], where it is said that Sanatan Goswami was one of the ministers of the Nawab Hussein government; in fact, he was the most important personality in the government. His brother, Rupa Goswami, was also a minister in the government, and both of them gave up the lucrative government service and became mendicants to serve the Supreme Lord. Within their hearts they are full of transcendental loving service, but externally they are just like ordinary mendicants, with a great liking for the cowherd boy of Vrindaban. Sanatan Goswami was very dear to all pure devotees of his time.


PART II


TLC 17-1968: Lord Chaitanya, The Original Personality of Godhead

Chapter Seventeen

Lord Chaitanya, The Original Personality of Godhead

Following in the footsteps of Kaviraj Krishnadas Goswami, we may offer our respectful obeisances unto the Lotus Feet of Lord Chaitanya.

He is described as follows: Lord Chaitanya is the only shelter for the forlorn, or the most fallen, and He is the only hope for persons who are completely devoid of spiritual knowledge. Let us try to discuss His great contribution of devotional service.

The Supremely Powerful Lord Krishna becomes manifest in five different potentialities. Although He is One without any second, still, for serving five different specific spiritual purposes, He is manifested in five. Such diversity is eternal and blissful, as opposed to the conception of montonous oneness. From the version of Vedic literature, we can understand that the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, eternally exists with His diverse energies. Lord Chaitanya appeared with full diverse energies, and they are five in number; and, therefore, He is said to be Krishna with diverse energies, presented as Lord Chaitanya.

As there is no difference between the energy and the energetic, so it is in the Lord’s appearance as Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu and His four Associates, Nityananda Prabhu, Adwaita Prabhu, Gadadhara, and Srivas. Among these five diverse manifestations of the Supreme Lord as incarnation, expansion and energies there is no spiritual difference. They are five in One Absolute Truth. For relishing transcendental flavors in the Absolute Truth they are five diverse manifestations, and they are called the Form of a devotee, the identity of a devotee, and pure devotional service personified.

Out of these five diversities of the Absolute Truth, the Form of Lord Chaitanya is the Original Personality of Godhead, Krishna. The identity of Krishna as Lord Nityananda is as the manifestation of the first expansion of the Supreme Lord. And, similarly, Adwaita Prabhu is an incarnation of the Supreme Lord. All these three belong to the category of Vishnu Tattwa, or the Supreme Absolute Truth. Srivas is the representation of a pure devotee, and Gadadhara is the representation of the internal energy of the Lord for advancement in the cause of pure devotion. Therefore Gadadhara and Srivas, although within the category of Vishnu, are diverse energies of the Supreme Lord. In other words, they are not different from the energetic, but, still, for relishing transcendental relationships, they are manifested diversely. The whole process of devotional service is transcendental reciprocation of the flavors of relationship between the worshipped and the worshipper. Without such a diverse exchange of transcendental flavors, devotional service has no meaning.

In the Vedic literature (Katho Upanishad) there is a verse which says that the Supreme Lord is the Supreme Living Entity amongst all living entities. There are innumerable living entities, but there is One Living Entity Who is the Supreme Absolute Godhead. The difference between that Singular Living Entity and the plural number of living entities is that the Singular Living Entity is the Lord of all. Lord Chaitanya is that Supreme Living Entity, Who descended Himself for claiming the fallen innumerable living entities. In other words, the specific purpose of Lord Chaitanya’s advent in recent ages was to establish the Vedic fact that there is One Supreme Personality of Godhead predominating over, or maintaining, the numerous personalities of living entities. The Mayavadi, impersonalist, philosophers cannot understand this, and therefore Lord Chaitanya advented Himself, to convince the people in general about the real nature of the relationship between the Supreme and the many entities.

In the Bhagavad Gita [18.66], the last instruction of Lord Krishna is that everyone should give up all other engagements and should engage in the devotional service of the Lord. But after His disappearance, persons with less intelligence misunderstood Him. They became contaminated with the Mayavadi philosophy, which produced so many mental speculators that people became misled about the actual position of the Absolute Truth and the living entity. Lord Chaitanya, therefore, although the Supreme Lord Krishna Himself, again appeared to teach the fallen souls of this material world how to approach Lord Krishna. The philosophy of Bhagavad Gita is that one should give up everything and be done with this world of material attachment. A pure devotee of Lord Krishna and one who follows the philosophy of Lord Chaitanya are the same. Chaitanya’s philosophy is: one should give up everything and worship God, Krishna. The difference is that Krishna, as the Supreme Lord, the personality of Godhead, spoke the same words indicating Himself, and the Mayavadi philosophers misunderstood Him. Therefore, Lord Chaitanya indicated the same thing: one should not declare himself to be as good as Krishna, but should worship Krishna as the Supreme Lord.

It is a great mistake if we accept Lord Chaitanya as one of the conditioned souls; He is to be understood as the Supreme Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna Himself, In the Chaitanya Charitamrita, therefore, it is said of Lord Chaitanya: “Krishna is now present in His five diverse manifestations,” as is being explained here. Unless one is in uncontaminated goodness, it is very difficult to understand Lord Chaitanya as the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself. Therefore, to understand Lord Chaitanya one has to follow the direct disciples of Lord Chaitanya, the six Goswamis, and especially the path chalked out by Srila Jiva Goswami.

The most astonishing factor is that Lord Chaitanya, although the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna, never exhibited Himself as Krishna. Rather, whenever He was detected by intelligent devotees as Lord Krishna, and addressed as Lord Krishna, He denied it, and sometimes He closed His ears, protesting that one should not be addressed as the Supreme Lord. This was His indirect teaching to the Mayavadi philosophers: that one should never pose oneself as the Supreme Lord falsely, and thereby misdirect the followers. The followers also should not be foolish enough to accept anyone and everyone as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, without testing with the Scriptures and by activities. One should not, however, mistake Lord Chaitanya with His five diverse manifestations as ordinary human beings. He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna Himself. The beauty of Lord Chaitanya is that, although He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself, He Himself as a great devotee is teaching all the conditioned souls how devotional service should be conducted. The conditioned souls who are interested in devotional service should follow, therefore in the exemplary footsteps of Lord Chaitanya, to learn how Krishna can be achieved by devotional service. In other words, the Supreme Lord Himself teaches the conditioned soul how He should be approached by devotional service.

By analytical study of the five diverse manifestations of the Supreme Lord we can know that Lord Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu is the Supreme Absolute, and that Lord Nityananda is an immediate expansion of the Supreme Absolute Truth. We can understand that Adwaita Prabhu is also in the category of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but he is the subordinate to Lord Chaitanya and Nityananda Prabhu. The Supreme Personality of Godhead and His immediate subordinate expansions are all worshippable by the other two, namely, the internal potential representation, and the marginal potential representation.

The internal potential representation, Gadadhara, represents the pure devotee, and the marginal potential representation is a confidential devotee. Both these categories are worshippers of the other three categories, but all of them—the two worshippable categories and the two in the worshipper category—are engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.

There is a specific difference between the pure devotee and the confidential devotee. Different potencies of the Lord are engaged in serving the Supreme Lord in different transcendental relationships. They are situated in conjugal love, in parental affection, in friendly affinity and in obedient servitude. By impartial judgement, it is found that the internal potencies of the Supreme Lord, engaged in conjugal love with Him, are the best of all devotees. As such, both internal devotees and confidential devotees are attracted by the conjugal love of the Supreme Absolute Truth, and are the most confidential devotees of Lord Chaitanya. Other pure devotees, who are more or less attached to Sri Nityananda Prabhu and to Adwaita Prabhu, are attracted by other transcendental relationships, such as parental affection, friendly affinity and obedient servitude. When such devotees are very much attached to the activities of Lord Chaitanya, at once they become confidential devotees in conjugal love with the Supreme Lord.

There is a very nice song sung by a great devotee and Acharya in the disciplic succession from Lord Chaitanya. His name is Sri Thakur Narottamdas. Sri Thakur says as follows: “When will there be a transcendental vibration all over my body simply by attending to the Name of Gauranga? When will there be incessant flowing of my tears simply by uttering Harer Nama of the Lord? When will Lord Nityananda be merciful upon me, and all my desires for material enjoyment become insignificant? When shall I be purified by giving up all contaminations of material enjoyment; and when shall I be able to see the transcendental Abode, Vrindaban? When shall I be eager to accept the six Goswamis as my prime guidance? And when shall I be able to understand the conjugal love of Krishna?” In other words, nobody should be eager to understand the conjugal love of Krishna without undergoing disciplinary training under the six Goswamis of Vrindaban.

The Samkirtan movement inaugurated by Lord Chaitanya is a transcendental Pastime of the Lord: “So that I may live simultaneously to preach and popularize this movement in the material world.” And in that Samkirtan movement of Lord Chaitanya, Nityananda and Adwaita are His expansions, and Gadadhara and Srivas are His internal and marginal potencies.

The living entities are called marginal potency because they have, potentially, both attitudes, namely the tendency to surrender unto Krishna, and the tendency for becoming independent of the Supreme Lord, and being contaminated by the material world through the propensity for material enjoyment. When a living entity is predominated over by the desire for material enjoyment and becomes entangled in material contamination, at that time he is subjected to the three-fold miseries of material existence. There is a very nice example in this connection. It is just like a seed sewn in the earth. If it is overpowered by too much water, there is no possibility of the seed being fructified. Similarly, even if a man is captivated by material enjoyment, and even if the seed of such enjoyment is within the heart of the conditioned soul but he is overwhelmed, over powered by a flood of transcendental activities in love of God, then his potential seed cannot fructify into a conditional life of material existence. The conditional living entities in the material world, especially at the present age of Kali, are being overpowered by the flood of love of God inaugurated by Lord Chaitanya and His Associates.

There is a nice verse in this connection, written by His Holiness Prabodhananda Saraswati in his book Sri Chaitanya Chandramrita [5]. In that verse it is stated that materialistic persons are very enthusiastic in the matter of maintaining their family members, wife and children; and there are many mystic speculators who are engaged in speculating on being liberated from the miseries of material life, and therefore they undergo various kinds of austerities and penances. But persons who have discovered the greatest transcendental flavor, in the movement of Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, no longer have any taste for all those activities.

Persons who are under the impression that, in the Form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and in the matter of His devotional service, there is material contamination, are called Mayavadi. According to their imperfect speculation, the impersonal Brahman is considered the only existence of the cosmic manifestation. As soon as there is a conception of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, they consider that it is in contact with Maya, or the external material energy. Similarly, such persons consider all incarnations of the Supreme Lord to be contaminated by this material Nature. According to them, this material body of the living entity, and the action of matter on all the differ. kinds of identifications of the living entity, are called material manifestation. According to them, liberation means that there is no longer any individual identification, or pure living entity. In other words, a living entity, when he is liberated, becomes One with the Supreme Impersonal Brahman.

According to Mayavadi philosophy it is understood that, in the Personality of Godhead, in the Abode of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and in the matter of devotional service, the emotional devotees are all under the spell of Maya, and are therefore subjected to the material condition. Persons who forget the transcendental nature of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, His transcendental Abode and devotional service, as well as the devotee, consider that these are different examples of material activity. Such persons are called Karmis, or actors in fruitive activities. When one thinks that there is a possibility of arguing about transcendence, he is called agnostic. And when one thinks that there is the possibility to criticize transcendence, he is called atheist. Lord Chaitanya wanted to accept all these different kinds of agnostics, atheists, skeptics, and unfaithfuls, and swallow them in the flood of love of God. Therefore, He accepted the four orders of life—and He accepted the renounced order of life, in order to attract all these forces.

Lord Chaitanya remained a householder until twenty-four only, and in the twenty-fifth year of His life, He accepted the renounced order. After accepting the renounced order, He attracted many other renounced order Sannyasis. During the time that He had been executing the Samkirtan movement in His family, many Mayavadi Sannyasis did not take His movement very seriously. Similarly, the speculative students, atheists, and those who are attached to fruitive activities and unnecessary criticism were also delivered by the Lord after He accepted the Sannyasi order of life. The Lord was so kind that He accepted all of them, and delivered to them the most important factor of life: love of God.

To fulfill the mission of the Lord, bestowing love of God upon the conditioned souls, He devised many methods to accept all those disinterested in the matter of love of God. After He accepted the renounced order, all agnostics and critics, atheists and mental speculators became the students and followers of Lord Chaitanya. Even many of those who were not Hindus or the followers of the Vedic principles of life also accepted Lord Chaitanya as the Supreme Teacher.

Those Sannyasis who were known as the Mayavadi philosophers of Benares were the only persons who avoided the mercy of Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. The plight of the Mayavadi philosophers is described as follows by Sri Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati Goswami: “The Mayavadi philosophers of Benares are less intelligent because they want to measure everything by direct perception. But everything they have is a calculation of material perception. The Absolute Truth is transcendence, but according to them there is no variegatedness in transcendence, because they say that anything which is full of variegatedness is Maya.”

During Chaitanya Mahaprabhu’s time there were other philosophers, known as the Mayavadi philosophers of Sarnatha. Sarnatha is a place near Benares where Buddhist philosophers were residing, and even today there are many Stupas of the Buddhist Mayavadi. The Mayavadi philosophers of Sarnatha are different from the impersonalists who believe in the impersonal manifestation of Brahman. According to the Sarnatha philosophers there is no spiritual existence. Spiritually, both the Mayavadi philosophers of Benares and the philosophers of Sarnatha are entrapped by the material Nature. None of them actually knows the nature of the Absolute Transcendence. The philosophers of Benares, although accepting the Vedic principles superficially and accepting themselves as transcendentalists, do not agree to accept spiritual variegatedness. They have no information about devotional service, and therefore they are called “non-devotees,” or against the devotional service of Lord Krishna.

The impersonalists speculate on the Supreme Personality of Godhead and His devotees, subjected to the direct perception of knowledge. The Lord and His devotee and His devotional service, however, are not subject to direct perception. In other words, spiritual variegatedness is unknown to the Mayavadi philosophy, and therefore all the Mayavadi philosophers and Sannyasis began to criticize Him because He was conducting the Samkirtan movement. They were surprised to see Lord Chaitanya, because He belonged to the Mayavadi sect of Sannyasis, having accepted His Sannyasa order from Keshav Bharati, who belonged to the Mayavadi school. They were surprised to see Him engaged in chanting and dancing, and not engaged in the matter of hearing or reading Vedanta, as is the custom. The Mayavadi philosophers are very fond of Vedanta, and misinterpret it in their own way. The Mayavadi Sannyasis, instead of understanding their own position, began to critize Lord Chaitanya as an unauthorized Sannyasi. They criticized that He was sentimental and not actually a bona fide Sannyasi. All these criticisms were carried to Lord Chaitanya when He was at Benares, and He was not at all surprised. He smiled when the news was carried to Him. He, however, did not associate with the Mayavadi Sannyasis, but used to remain alone and execute His own mission. And after staying for some days in Benares, He started for Mathura.

TLC 18-1968: The Conversations with Prakasananda

Chapter Eighteen

The Conversations With Prakasananda

According to the principles of the Mayavadi Sannyasis, singing, dancing, and playing on musical instruments are strictly prohibited; they are called three kinds of sinful activities. The Mayavadi Sannyasi is supposed to engage his valuable time simply in the matter of Vedanta study. When the Mayavadi Sannyasis in Benares saw that Lord Chaitanya was indulging in singing, dancing and playing musical instruments, and was always chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Ranta, Hare Hare, they concluded that this Sannyasi was not educated, and, out of sentiment, He was misleading some of the followers. Sankaracharya has said that a Sannyasi should always be engaged in studying Vedanta, and should be satisfied simply having one cloth and nothing more. Lord Chaitanya was neither studying Vedanta in formality, nor did He cease from singing and dancing, and so He was criticized by all the Sannyasis at Benares, as well as by their householder followers.

Lord Chaitanya got this news from His students and disciples, and when He heard that they were all criticizing Him, He simply smiled and started for Mathura and Vrindaban. But He came back again to Benares on His way to Jagannath Puri from Mathura. When He came back to Benares, He stayed at the house of Chandra Sekhar, who was considered a Sudra because he was a clerk. In spite of Sekhar being a Sudra, Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu made His residential quarter at his place. Lord Chaitanya made no such distinction between Brahmin or Sudra—anyone devoted, He accepted. Customarily, a Sannyasi is supposed to take shelter in the house of a Brahmin, or eat at the house of a Brahmin, but Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, as the independent Supreme Personality of Godhead, had His own discretion, and He decided to stay at Chandra Sekhar’s house.

In those days, by misuse of the Brahminical hereditary principle, the Brahmins made it a law that anyone who was not born of a Brahmin family was a Sudra. So even the Kshatriyas and the Vaidyas were also called Sudras. Vaidyas are supposed to be descendents of Brahmin fathers and Sudra wives, and therefore they are sometimes called Sudras. So Chandra Sekhar Acharya, although born of a Vaidya family, was called, at Benares, a Sudra. As long as Lord Chaitanya stayed at Benares, He stayed at Chandra Sekhar’s apartment, and He used to take His food at the place of Tapan Mishra.

When Sanatan Goswami met Lord Chaitanya at Benares he learned from Lord Chaitanya the process and principles of devotional service during two months of continuous teaching. The instructions of Lord Chaitanya to Sanatan Goswami have been described in our First Part of Lord Chaitanya’s teachings. After that teaching, Sanatan Goswami was authorized to propagate the principles of devotional service and the Srimad Bhagwatam. But, during this time, both Tapan Mishra and Chandra Sekhar Acharya were feeling very sorry about strong criticism against Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, and they came together and prayed for the Lord to meet the Mayavadi Sannyasis.

They informed Lord Chaitanya: “We have been mortified by hearing unfavorable criticism from the Mayavadi Sannyasis against You. It has become intolerable for us.” They requested He do something so that these criticisms would be stopped.

While they were thus discussing the criticism of the Mayavadi Sannyasis, a Brahmin came to Lord Chaitanya and invited Him, as he had invited all the other Sannyasis, to his place. Only Chaitanya had not been invited, and so he now had come to invite Him. He knew that Chaitanya Mahaprabhu did not mix with the Mayavadi Sannyasis, and therefore he fell down at Chaitanya Mahaprabhu’s feet and implored Him: “Although I know that You do not accept invitations, still, it is my request—please come and take Prasadam at my place with the other Sannyasis. If You accept this invitation it will be considered a special favor to me.”

The Lord took this opportunity and accepted the invitation of the Brahmin, in order to meet the Mayavadi Sannyasis. It was, practically, an arrangement made by the Lord Himself The Brahmin who invited Him knew that Lord Chaitanya did not accept any invitations, but still he was very eager to invite Him.

The next day Lord Chaitanya went to the house of the Brahmin. He saw that all the Mayavadi Sannyasis were sitting there. He offered His respects to all the Sannyasis, as was usual, and then He went to wash His Feet. After washing His Feet, He sat down at that spot, not amongst the Mayavadi Sannyasis, but in a place where water was kept for washing the feet. While He was sitting there, the other Sannyasis saw a glaring effulgence emanating from His body. All the Mayavadi Sannyasis were attracted by this glaring effulgence, and they stood up and showed Him respects. Amongst them there was one Sannyasi whose name was Prakasananda Saraswati. He was the chief amongst all the impersonalist Sannyasis, and he addressed Lord Chaitanya with great humility, and asked Him to come and sit amongst them.

He said, “My dear sir, why are You sitting in that filthy place? Please come and sit with us.”

Lord Chaitanya replied: “Oh, I belong to an inferior sect of Sannyasis. Therefore I think I should not sit with you. Let Me sit down here.”

Prakasananda Saraswati was surprised to hear such a thing from such a learned man, and he actually took His hand and requested Him to please come and sit down with him. Lord Chaitanya was seated, and Prakasananda Saraswati enquired, “I think Your name is Sri Krishna Chaitanya, and I understand that You belong to our Mayavadi sect because You have taken Your Sannyasa from Keshav Bharati, who belongs to the Sankara Sampradaya.”

According to the Sankara sect, there are ten different names for Sannyasi. Out of them, the three names, Tirtha, Asram and Saraswati, are considered to be the most enlightened and cultured among the Sannyasis. Lord Chaitanya was a Vaishnava, and therefore naturally He was humble and meek, and He wanted to give the better place to Prakasananda, who belonged to the Saraswati Sampradaya. According to Sankara principles, a disciple of the Bharatic school is called Chaitanya. But Sri Krishna Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, although He took Sannyasa, kept His Brahmachary name, without the title Bharati.

Prakasananada Saraswati inquired from Lord Chaitanya: “Well sir, You belong to our Sankara sect, and You are living at Benares. Why don’t You mix with us? What is the reason? Another thing—You are a Sannyasi. You are supposed to engage Your time simply in Vedanta study. But we see that instead of doing that You are always engaged in chanting, dancing, and playing on musical instruments. What are the reasons? These things are done by emotional and sentimental people. But You are a qualified Sannyasi. Why should You not engage Yourself in the study of Vedanta? By Your effulgence it appears to us that You are just like the Supreme Narayana, the Personality of Godhead, but Your behavior appears to be otherwise. So we are inquisitive to know, what are the reasons?”

Lord Chaitanya replied: “My dear sir, I may inform you that My Spiritual Master saw Me as a great fool, and therefore he more or less punished Me and said that, because I am such a fool, I have no jurisdiction in the study of Vedanta. So he kindly gave Me the chanting of Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. My Spiritual Master told Me: ‘You go on Chanting this Krishna Mantra, and it will make You all-perfect.”’

Actually, Lord Chaitanya was neither a fool nor ignorant of the principles of Vedanta, but His purpose was to demonstrate to modern society that for fools who have no penance and austerity behind them, and simply for some recreational purpose want to study Vedanta—that is not recommended. In His Sikshastak [3], Lord Chaitanya said that one should be in a humble state of mind, should think of himself as lower than the grass on the street, more tolerant than the tree, devoid of all false sense of prestige, and ready to offer all kinds of respects to others. In such a state of mind, one can chant Vedanta philosophy or the Holy Name of God constantly. He also wanted to teach that a serious student of transcendental science should follow exactly the words of the Spiritual Master. According to the calculation of the Spiritual Master, Lord Chaitanya appeared to be a fool, so he said that He should not indulge in the study of Vedanta but should go on chanting the Krishna Mantra. Therefore, He strictly obeyed. In other words Lord Chaitanya impressed on the Mayavadis that the words of a bona fide Spiritual Master must be strictly followed. That would make one perfect in all respects.

Vedanta means that the last word of the Vedic knowledge is to understand Krishna [Bg. 15.15]: Vedaischa sarvai aham eva vedyam: Actual understanding of the Vedanta is to know Krishna, and our relationship with Krishna. And one who understands Krishna understands everything. The knower of Krishna is always engaged in the transcendental loving service of Krishna. The Lord confirms this in Bhagavad Gita [10.8]: “I am the Source of everything, and everything emanates from Me. Therefore, one who knows Me perfectly well is fully engaged in My transcendental loving service.” A living entity is eternally related with Krishna by that relationship of Master and servant, and once that service is wanting—or, in other words, when one is not situated in Krishna Consciousness—it is to be understood that his study of Vedanta is insufficient. When one does not understand what is Krishna Consciousness, or is not engaged in the trascendental loving service of Lord Krishna, it is to be understood that he is adverse to the study of Vedanta or understanding the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The path shown by Lord Chaitanya in the matter of studying Vedanta philosophy, as explained in this connection, should be followed by all. A person who is puffed up over his so-called education, has no humility and therefore does not seek after the protection of a bona fide Spiritual Master, thinks that he does not require a bona fide Spiritual Master, and, rather by his own effort, he can achieve the highest perfection. Such persons are not eligible for the study of Vedanta Sutra. Those who are under the spell of the material energy, instead of following the instructions of the disciplic succession, try to manufacture something of their own, and thereby step outside the sphere of Vedanta study. A bona fide Spiritual Master must always condemn such independent mental speculators. If the bona fide Spiritual Master directly points out the foolishness of a disciple, that should not be taken otherwise. In other words, a person who is completely innocent in the Science of God is actually not learned. And, more or less, everyone who is not in Krishna Consciousness is subject to that foolishness.

Sometimes we display our foolishness by accepting somebody who is barely even educated as our Spiritual Master. That is another sign of our foolishness. It is our duty to understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Whose Lotus Feet are worshipped by all the Vedas. One who does not understand that Supreme Personality of Godhead, and is proud of his false understanding of Vedanta, is actually a fool. Mundane attempts at academic knowledge are another foolishness. So long as one cannot understand the cosmic manifestation as a representation of the three modes of material Nature, one must be considered in the darkness of inebriety and caught in the duality of this material world. Actually, a person who is in perfect knowledge of the Vedanta becomes a servitor of the Supreme Lord, Who is the Maintainer and Sustainer of the whole cosmic manifestation. So long as one is not transcendental to the service of the limited, he cannot be a person with Vedanta knowledge.

So long as one is in the limited jurisdiction of fruitive activities, or involved in mental speculation, he is perhaps eligible for studying or instructing on the theoretical knowledge of Vedanta Sutra, but he cannot be on the platform of understanding the Supreme, Eternal, transcendental (completely liberated) vibration of Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. In other words, anyone who has achieved his perfection in chanting the transcendental vibration Hare Krishna does not have to learn separately the philosophy of Vedanta Sutra.

Persons who are not eligible by thorough understanding of the transcendental vibration as nondifferent from the Supreme, and who try to become Mayavadi philosophers and expert in Vedanta Sutra, are all fools according to the teaching of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, or the bona fide Spiritual Master. To study Vedanta Sutra by the ascending process is another sign of foolishness. On the other hand, he who has attained the taste for chanting the transcendental vibration is actually situated at the conclusion of Vedanta. In this connection there are two verses of Srimad Bhagwatam which are very instructive: The purport of the first is that, even if a person is born in the family of the lowest of human beings, but is engaged in chanting the transcendental vibration, then it is to be understood that he has already performed all kinds of renunciation and austerities, and has performed all kinds of sacrifices, and has studied all the Brahma Sutras—so that he is now able to chant Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. The purport of the second verse is that a person who is chanting the two syllables Ha-re (ray) must be considered as having studied all the Vedas: the Rig Veda, Atharva Veda, Yaju Veda and Sama Veda.

On the other hand, there are many so-called devotees who think that Vedanta is meant for a particular class of men, and is not meant for the devotees. They do not know that Vedanta is the only plaform of pure devotees. All the great Acharyas of the four Sampradayas of the Vaishnava sect have made their commentaries on the Vedanta Sutra, but the so-called devotee class, who are known as Prakrita Sahajia, carefully avoid the study of Vedanta Sutra. The Prakrita Sahajia misunderstand the pure devotees and Vaishnav Acharyas as being mental speculators or fruitive actors. As a result of such a conclusion, they themselves become Mayavadis, and leave the service of the Supreme Lord.

Understanding the Vedanta Sutra by academic knowledge never qualifies a man for understanding the value of the transcendental vibration. Such persons who are entangled in academic knowledge are conditioned souls who are confused about the facts of I and My understanding. As such, they are unable to detach their minds from the external energy.

When a person actually attains transcendental knowledge, he becomes free from this duality and becomes engaged in transcendental loving service of the Supreme Lord. The transcendental loving service of the Supreme Lord is the only means for being detached from material activities. A person properly initiated by a bona fide Spiritual Master, and engaged in chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare, gradually becomes freed from the conception of I and Mine, and therefore becomes attached to the transcendental loving service, in one of the five different transcendental relationships. Such transcendental service is not subject matter for the gross and subtle bodies. When, however, one can understand that there is no difference between the Supreme and His Name, at that time only can he be situated in Krishna Consciousness. At that time he has no longer any necessity for grammatical adjustment of the language. Rather, he becomes more interested in the subject matter of the address: Hare Krishna—O my Lord, O energy of the Lord, please engage me in Your service!

Lord Chaitanya explained all this to Prakasananda Saraswati and told him that He had heard it from His Spiritual Master in these words. He informed Prakasananda Saraswati that His Spiritual Master had taught Him that the actual commentary on the Vedanta Sutra is Srimad Bhagwatam, as it is stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam by Vyasadeva, the Author of Vedanta Sutra.

The perfection of a student is to understand the identity of the Holy Name and the Supreme Lord. And, without being under the shelter of such a realized Spiritual Master, one’s understanding of the Supreme is simply foolishness. One can, however, fully understand the transcendental by service and devotion. When Lord Chaitanya uttered Krishna without any offense, or when He offenselessly chanted the Krishna Mantra, or Maha Mantra, He declared that it can at once deliver a conditioned soul from the material contamination. In this Age of Kali there is no other alternative to chanting this Maha Mantra. It is stated that the essence of all Vedic literature is to chant this Holy Name of Krishna: Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. He also said to Prakasananda Saraswati that, in order to convince Me about this essential fact of Vedic knowledge, he has taught Me a verse from Brihad Naradiya Puranam [38.126]:

Harer Nama Harer Nama Harer Nama Eva Kevalam. Kalau Nasteva Nasteva Nasteva Gatir Anyatha.

“In this age of quarrel and hypocrisy, the only means of deliverance is to chant the Holy Name of the Lord—and there is no other means of success.”

In three out of the four millenniums, namely the Satya Yuga, Treta Yuga and Dvapara Yuga, there was honor in understanding transcendence through the path of disciplic succession. In the present age, on account of Kali, people have no interest in the matter of the disciplic succession, but they have invented many paths of argument and logic. Such an ascending process of understanding transcendence is not approved according to the Vedic way. The Absolute Truth must descend from the Absolute platform. It is not to be understood by the ascending process. The Holy Name of the Lord, Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare is a transcendental vibration. Therefore it comes down from the transcendental platform, the Supreme Abode of Krishna. And, because there is no difference between Krishna and His Name, therefore the Holy Name of Krishna is as pure, as perfect, and as liberated as Krishna Himself. For understanding the transcendental nature of the Holy Name of God, the academic scholars have no entrance by their logic and argument. The single path to understanding the transcendental nature of Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare, is to chant these Names with faith and adherence. Such chanting will release one from the designated conditions of gross and subtle bodies.

In this age of logical argument and disagreement the chanting of Hare Krishna is the only means for self realization, and because this transcendental vibration alone can deliver the conditioned soul, therefore it is the essence of the Vedanta Sutra. In the material conception there may be duality and differences between the Name, Form, quality, emotion and activities of a person and the person himself; but so far as this transcendental vibration is concerned, there is no such limitation, because it descends from the Spiritual World. In the Spiritual World there is no such difference between the Name of the Person Whose Name is a Quality, and the Person of the Quality. There is no such difference as there is in the material world. The Mayavadi philosophers cannot understand this, and therefore they are not eligible to utter the transcendental vibration.

Lord Chaitanya then said to Prakasananda Saraswati that, because He got that order from His Spiritual Master, therefore He was constantly engaged in chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare.

“As a result of this chanting, sometimes I become impatient and cannot restrain Myself from dancing and laughing or crying or singing—just like a madman. When I first wondered whether I had become a madman by chanting this Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare, I approached My Spiritual Master and informed him that by chanting this Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare, ‘I am becoming just like a madman, so what is my actual position?”’

In the Narada Pancharatra it is stated that all the Vedic rituals and Mantras and understanding are compressed into the eight words Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare. Similarly, in the Kalisantra Upanishad, it is stated that Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare—these sixteen words—are especially meant for counteracting the contamination of Kali. To save oneself from the contamination of Kali there is no other alternative than these sixteen words.

Lord Chaitanya informed Prakasananda Saraswati that when His Spiritual Master understood Him, the Spiritual Master said: “It is the transcendental nature of the Holy Name of Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare to transport a man into spiritual madness. Anyone who sincerely chants this Holy Name is actually elevated very soon onto the platform of love of God, and therefore he becomes mad after Him. This madness of love of God is the first perfectional stage of the human being.” Generally the human being is after religiousness, economic development, sense gratification, and liberation. But this love of God is above all such perfections of life, The process is that a bona fide Spiritual Master chants the Holy Name, Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare, and the transcendental sound vibration enters into the ear of the disciple. If the disciple follows in the footsteps of his Spiritual Master and chants the Holy Name with equal respect, that becomes the worship of the transcendental Name.

When the transcendental Name becomes worshipped by the devotee, the Name Himself spreads His Glories within the heart of the devotee, and when he is perfectly qualified in chanting such transcendental vibration of the Holy Name, he is quite fit to become a Spiritual Master for delivering all the people of the world. The chanting of the Holy Name is so powerful that, gradually, it establishes its supremacy above all in the world. And the devotee who chants it becomes transcendentally situated in ecstasy, and sometimes he laughs and cries and dances in his ecstasy. Sometimes less intelligent persons put some hindrances in the way of the chanting of Hare Krishna, or the Maha Mantra; but one who is situated on the platform of love of Godhead chants the Holy Name loudly for the benefit of all persons concerned. As a result of that, everyone becomes initiated in chanting the Holy Name, Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. By the chanting and hearing of the Holy Name of Krishna, a person can remember the Forms and Qualities of Krishna.

TLC 19-1968: The Goal of Vedanta Study

Chapter Nineteen

The Goal of Vedanta Study

The transcendental ecstatic attachment for Krishna by perfectly understanding that Krishna the Person and Krishna the Name are identical is called Bhava. One who has achieved such Bhava is certainly not in the contamination of material Nature. He actually enjoys transcendental pleasure from such Bhava. And, when Bhava is more intensified, it is called love of Godhead. The Holy Name of Krishna is called the Maha Mantra (Great Chanting): therefore Lord Chaitanya explained to Prakasananda Saraswati that the Holy Name of Krishna has a specific influence on anyone who chants It and he can attain the stage of love of Godhead, or intensified Bhava. Such love of Godhead is the ultimate goal of human necessity. When one compares this love of Godhead with the other necessities of the human society, namely, religiousness, economic development, sense gratification, and liberation, they are seen as most insignificant. When one is absorbed in temporary designative existence, one hankers after sense gratification, or else after liberation. But love of Godhead is the eternal nature of the soul; it is unchangeable, without beginning, and it has no end; therefore, temporary sense gratification or a desire for liberation cannot compare with the transcendental nature of love of God. This love of God is called the fifth dimension in the human goals of life. Compared with the ocean of love of transcendental pleasure, the impersonal Brahman conception cannot measure as even one drop of water.

Lord Chaitanya now explained that His Spiritual Master had confirmed the ecstatic situation of His chanting the Holy Name of God, and had confirmed that the essence of all Vedic literature is the attainment of love of Godhead. His Spiritual Master said that Lord Chaitanya was fortunate enough to have attained such a stage of love of Godhead. By attainment of such transcendental love of Godhead, one’s heart becomes very anxious to attain direct contact with the Lord; and with that transcendental sentiment he sometimes laughs, sometimes cries, sometimes sings, sometimes dances like a madman, and sometimes he traverses hither and thither.

There are various ecstatic symptoms of the body: crying, changing the color of the body, madness, bereavement, silence, feeling proud, ecstasy, gentleness, and, often, the person in love of Godhead dances. Such dancing puts him into the ocean of the nectar of love of Krishna.

Lord Chaitanya’s Spiritual Master said to Him: “It is very good that You have attained such a perfectional stage of love of Godhead, and by Your attainment I am very much obliged to You.”

The father becomes more enlightened when he sees his son advance beyond himself. Similarly, when the Spiritual Master sees a disciple advancing, he takes more pleasure in that than in his own advancement. Lord Chaitanya’s Spiritual Master blessed Him, telling Him to “dance, sing and propagate this Samkirtan movement, and by instructing people about Krishna, try to deliver them from the nescience.”

His Spiritual Master taught Him a very nice verse from Srimad Bhagwatam which is from the Eleventh Canto, Second Chapter [11.2.40]: “A person who is constantly engaged in devotional service to Krishna by chanting His Holy Name becomes so transcendentally attached to the chanting that his heart becomes softened without any extraneous endeavor. In such a condition of softened heart he exhibits transcendental ecstasies, sometimes by laughing, sometimes by crying, sometimes by singing, sometimes by dancing—not exactly in an artistic way, but just like a madman.”

Lord Chaitanya informed Prakasananda Saraswati, “I have full faith in my Spiritual Master’s words, and therefore I am always engaged in the matter of chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. I do not know how I have become just like a madman, but the Name Krishna Himself induces Me to become so.

I realize that the transcendental pleasure derived from chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare, is just like an ocean and, in comparison, all other pleasures, including the pleasure of the impersonal conception, are like shallow water in channels.”

It appears from the talks of Lord Chaitanya that a person who cannot keep his faith in the words of the Spiritual Master and thus acts independently cannot ever attain the desired success in the matter of chanting Hare Krishna. In the Vedic literature it is said that, for one who has unflinching faith in the Supreme Lord, and similar faith in his Spiritual Master, the import of the transcendental literature becomes revealed. Lord Chaitanya firmly believed in this statement of His Spiritual Master, and He never stopped His Samkirtan movement by neglecting the instruction of His Spiritual Master. Therefore, the transcendental potency of the Holy Name encouraged Him more and more in chanting Hare Krishna, or the Maha Mantra.

Lord Chaitanya immediately informed Prakasananda that people in general in the modern age are more or less bereft of all spiritual intellect. When such persons come under the influence of Sankaracharya’s Mayavadi, or impersonalist, philosophy before beginning the most confidential Vedanta Sutras, their natural tendency toward obediance to the Supreme is checked. The Supreme Source of everything is naturally respected by everyone, but by the impersonalist conception of Sankara, this natural tendency is hampered. Therefore, the Spiritual Master of Lord Chaitanya suggested that it is better not to study the Sarirakabhasya of Sankaracharya, which is very harmful to people in general. Neither has the common man the intelligence to penetrate into the jugglery of words. He is better advised to chant the Maha Mantra: Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. In this quarrelsome Age of Kali, there is no alternative for self realization to the chanting of the Hare Krishna Maha Mantra.

After hearing the arguments and talks of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, all the the Mayavadi Sannyasis who were present became pacified, and replied in sweet words: “My dear sir, whatever You have spoken is all true. A person who attains love of Godhead is certainly very fortunate. And undoubtedly You are very fortunate that You have attained such a stage of love of Godhead. But what is the fault in Vedanta that You do not study it, although it is the duty of a Sannyasi to read and understand Vedanta?”

According to Mayavadi philosophers, Vedanta means the Sariraka commentary of Sankaracharya. By “Vedanta” and “Upanishads,” impersonal philosophers mean “according to the commentary of Sankaracharya,” the greatest teacher of Mayavadi philosophy. After Sankaracharya came Sadananda Yogi, who said that Vedanta and Upanishads should be understood through the commentary of Sankaracharya. Factually, it is not so; for the Vedanta philosophy or the Upanishads there are many other commentaries made by the Vaishnava Acharyas, rather than those of Sankaracharya. Mayavadi philosophers influenced by Sankaracharya do not find any importance in the different Vaishnava philosophical understandings.

There are four different sects of Vaishnava Acharyas, called the Suddhadvaita, Visistadvaita, Dvaidadvaita, and Achintya Bhedabheda; and all the Vaishnava Acharyas have written commentaries on the Vedanta Sutra, which the Mayavadi philosophers do not recognize. Mayavadis make a distinction between Krishna and Krishna’s Body, and therefore the worship of Krishna by the Vaishnava philosophers is not recognized by them.

Therefore, when the Mayavadi Sannyasis inquired from Lord Chaitanya as to why He did not study Vedanta Sutra, the Lord replied as follows: “My dear sir, you have inquired why I do not study Vedanta. In answer to this question I may speak something, if you won’t be sorry on hearing it.”

All the Mayavadi Sannyasis present said, “Now, we shall be very much pleased to hear You, because we see You are just like Narayan, and Your speeches are so nice that we are taking a great pleasure in hearing Your words. We are very much obliged to see You and hear You. Therefore, whatever You say, we shall be very glad to accept and hear patiently.”

Then the Lord began to speak about Vedanta philosophy as follows: Vedanta Sutra is spoken by the Supreme Lord Himself. The Supreme Lord, by His incarnation as Vyasadeva, has compiled this great philosophical treatise, Vedanta Sutra. Vyasadeva’s incarnation of the Supreme Lord means that He cannot be likened to the ordinary person, who has the four defects of material existence. The defects of the conditioned soul are: 1. he must commit mistakes, 2. he must be illusioned, 3. he must possess the tendency to cheat others, and 4. his senses must be all imperfect. When we speak of the incarnation of Godhead, we understand that He is transcendental to all these defects of the conditioned living entity. Therefore, whatever has been spoken and written by Vyasadeva is to be understood as perfect. The Upanishads and Vedanta Sutra aim at the same subject matter: the Supreme Absolute Truth; and, when we accept the import of Vedanta Sutra and the Upanishads directly, as they are stated, it becomes very glorious for us. But the commentary made by Sankaracharya is indirect, and is very dangerous for the common man, because, by understanding the import of the Upanishad in such an indirect, disruptive way, one becomes practically barred from spiritual realization.

According to Skanda and Vayn Puranas, “Sutra” means a condensed form of words, which carries meaning and import of immeasurable strength without any mistake or fault. “Vedanta” means the end of Vedic knowledge. In other words, any book which deals with the subject indicated by all the Vedas is called Vedanta. For example, the Bhagavad Gita is also Vedanta, because in the Bhagavad Gita we will find that the Lord says that the ultimate end of all Vedic research is Krishna, Therefore, Bhagavad Gita and Srimad Bhagwatam, which aim only at Krishna, are to be understood as Vedanta.

In transcendental realization there are three divisions of knowledge, and they are called Prasthana Trai. The department of knowledge which is proven by Vedic instruction, like the Upanishads, is called Sruti Prasthan. Authoritative books indicating the same thing and written by liberated souls like Vyasa—for example Bhagavad Gita, Mahabarata and the Puranas, especially the Srimad Bhagwatam, the Maha Purana—are called Nyaaprasthana. From the Vedas we understand that the Vedas originated from the breathing of Narayan. Vyasadeva, Who is an incarnation of the power of Narayan, has compiled the Vedanta Sutra. According to the Sankara commentary there appears another name, Apantartama Rishi, who is also credited with having compiled the codes of the Vedanta Sutra. According to Lord Chaitanya, the Codes of Pancharatra and the codes of Vedanta are one and the same. The Vedanta Sutra, being compiled by Vyasadeva, is to be understood as spoken by Narayan Himself. From the whole descriptive literature about the Vedanta Sutra, it is understood that there were many other Rishis contemporary with Vyasadeva who also discussed this Vedanta Sutra. The following sages—Atriya, Asmarathyk, Audulomi, Karshnajini, Kasakritsna, Jaimimi, Badari, and other sages such as Parasarikarmandi—also discussed Vedanta Sutra.

Actually, in the first three chapters of Vedanta Sutra, the relationship of the living entities with the Supreme Lord is explained, and in the Third Chapter the discharge of devotional service is explained. In the Fourth Chapter the result of the relationship of discharging devotional service is explained.

The natural commentary on the Vedanta Sutra is Srimad Bhagwatam. The great Acharyas of the four sections of the Vaishnava community—namely, Ramanujacharya, Madhvacharya, Vishnu Swami, and Nimbarka—have also written commentaries on the Vedanta Sutra in following the principles of Srimad Bhagwatam. At present the followers of all the Acharyas have written many books following the principles of Srimad Bhagwatam as the commentary on the Vedanta. Sankara’s commentary on the Vedanta Sutra, known as Sarirakabhasya is very much adored by the impersonalist class of scholars. But commentary on the Vedanta from the materialistic point of view is completely adverse to the transcendental loving position of devotional service to the Lord. And, therefore, Lord Chaitanya said that the direct commentary of the Upanishad and Vedanta Sutra is glorious, and anyone who follows the Sarirakabhasya of Sankaracharya without following the direct path is certainly doomed.

Lord Chaitanya admitted that Sankaracharya was an incarnation of Lord Shiva, and Lord Shiva is one of the greatest devotees, a Mahajan of the Bhagwat school. There are twelve great authorities on devotional service, and Lord Shiva is one of them. Then, why did he adopt the process of Mayavadi philosophy? The answer is given in the Padma Puräëa, where there is a statement by Lord Shiva as follows: “The Mayavadi philosophy is veiled Buddhist philosophy.” In other words, the void philosophy of Buddha is more or less repeated in the Mayavadi philosophy of impersonalism, althouth the Mayavadi philosophy claims to be directed by the Vedic conclusions. Lord Shiva thus admits that this philosophy was manufactured by him in the Age of Kali as a Brahmin boy to mislead the atheist class of men: “Actually, the Supreme Personality of Godhead has His transcendental Body, but I describe the Supreme as impersonal. Similarly, I have explained the Vedanta Sutra also on the same principles of Mayavadi philosophy.”

In the Shiva Puranam there is one statement by the Supreme Lord: “In the beginning of the Dvapara Yuga, under My order, there will be many sages who will bewilder the people in general by Mayavadi philosophy." In the Padma Purana, Lord Shiva personally says to Bhagavati Devi: “My dear Devi, sometimes I speak Mayavadi philosophy for persons who are engrossed in the modes of ignorance. But anyone in the modes of goodness who happens to hear this Mayavadi philosophy falls. In the Mayavadi philosophy I say that the living entity and the Supreme Lord are one and the same.”

Sadanada Yogi, one of the greatest Mayavadi Acharyas, has written in his book, Vedanta Sara, as follows: “Absolute Truth of eternity, knowledge and bliss is Brahman. Ignorance and all products of ignorance are non-Brahman. Any products out of the three modes of material Nature are covered by ignorance, and all are different from the Supreme Cause and effect. This ignorance is manifested in a collective and individual sense. Collective ignorance is called Visuddhasatvapradhana. When that Visuddhasatvapradhana becomes manifested within the ignorance of material Nature it is called the Lord, and the Lord manifests all kinds of ignorance. Therefore Hs is known as Sarvajna.” According to the Mayavadi philosophy the Lord is the product of this material Nature, and the living entity is in the lowest grade of ignorance. That is the sum and substance of the Mayavadi philosophy.

If, however, we accept directly the import of the Upanishads, it is clear that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is a Person with unlimited Potency. For example, in the Brihadarnyak it is stated that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the Origin of everything, and He has multiple different potencies: “The Supreme Personality of Godhead is transcendental to the cosmic manifestation of His time through His material energy, and He is the Origin of all religiousness, and He is the Supreme Deliverer, and He is Possesser of all opulences. Let me understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Who is just like the Sun, profusely distributing His different energies, while beyond the cloud of this material cosmic manifestation. He is the Master of masters, and He is the Supreme of the supremes. He is known as the Greatest Lord, the Personality of Godhead. His energies and potencies are multiple, variously distributed.” It is stated that Vishnu is the Supreme, and those who are saintly persons are always anxious to see the Lotus Feet of Vishnu. In the Aitariya Upanishad [1.1.1-2] also it is stated that the Lord glanced over the material Nature, and thus the cosmic manifestation came about. This is also stated in the Prasna Upanishad.

When there is a negative description of the Lord in the Vedic literature, just like Apani Pada, such a Mantra indicates that the Lord has no material body, and that He has no material Form. But He has His Spiritual Body, He has His transcendental Body, and He has His transcendental Form. The Mayavadi philosophers misunderstand this transcendental nature of the Supreme Lord, and explain the Supreme Lord as impersonal. The Lord, His Name, Form, Quality, Entourage and Abode all being in the transcendental world—how can He be a transformation of this material Nature? Everything connected with the Supreme Lord is eternal, blissful, and full of knowledge.

So, in effect, Sankaracharya delivered this Mayavadi philosophy to bewilder a certain class of atheistic people. Actually, he never meant that the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, is impersonal, with no Body or no Form. Therefore, the intelligent persons should not attend any lecture on Mayavadi philosophy. We should understand that the Supreme Personality of Godhead Vishnu is not impersonal. He is a transcendental Person. The basic principle of the cosmic manifestation is the energy of Vishnu. Mayavadi philosophy cannot trace the energy of the Supreme Lord, but in all the Vedic literature we have various evidences of the Supreme Lord’s various mainfestations of energies. Vishnu is not the product of the material Nature, but material Nature is the product of Vishnu’s potency. The Mayavadi philosopher understands that Vishnu is a product of this material Nature. If Vishnu is a product of the material Nature, He can be counted as one of the demigods. One who accepts Vishnu as one of the demigods is certainly mistaken and misled. And how he is misled is explained in the Bhagavad Gita [7.13-14]: “My material energy is so powerful that it is very difficult to surpass the spell of material Nature, even for the greatest scholar.”

TLC 20-1968: The Mayavadi Philosophers Are Converted

Chapter Twenty

The Mayavadi Philosophers Are Converted

It is concluded that Lord Krishna, or Vishnu, is not of this material world, but that He belongs to the Spiritual World. Anyone considering Him as one of the demigods of the material world is a great offender. This is called blasphemy. Lord Vishnu is, therefore, not subject to perception by the material senses, and neither can He be realized by mental speculation. There is no difference between the Body and Soul of the Supreme Lord Vishnu. In the material world there is always the difference between the body and soul.

Anything material is enjoyed by the living entities because the living entities are superior in nature, whereas the material Nature is of inferior quality. Therefore, the superior quality of Nature, the living entities, can enjoy the inferior quality of Nature, matter. Because Lord Vishnu, is in no way touched by matter, He is not subject to the enjoyment of the living entities. The living entities cannot gain knowledge of Vishnu by enjoying their mental speculative habits. The infinitesimal living entities are not, therefore, the enjoyers of Vishnu, but they are enjoyed by Lord Vishnu. If somebody thinks that Vishnu is enjoyable, then he is the greatest offender. The greatest act of blasphemy is to consider Vishnu and the living entity on the same level.

The Supreme Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, is compared with the blazing fire, whereas the innumerable living entities are compared with the sparks emanating from the blazing fire. So, although both of them are fire in quality, yet there is the distinction that Vishnu the Supreme is infinite, whereas the living entities, which are sparks, are infinitesimal. The infinitesimal living entities are emanations from the original infinite spirit. In other words, in their constitutional position as infinitesimal spirits, there is no trace of matter.

The living entities are not as great as Narayan, Vishnu, Who is beyond the Creation of this material world. This is accepted even by Sankaracharya—that Narayan is beyond this material Creation. So neither Vishnu nor the living entity are of the material Creation. Somebody may then enquire: Why were such small particles of the spirit created at all? The answer is that the completeness of perfection of the Supreme Absolute Truth is possible when He is both infinite and infinitesimal. If He is simply infinite and He is not infinitesimal, then He is not perfect. The infinite portion is the Vishnu Tattwa, or the Supreme Absolute Personality of Godhead; and the infinitesimal portion is the living entity.

By the infinite desires of the Supreme Personality of Godhead there is the existence of the Spiritual World, and by the infinitesimal desires of the living entities there is this material world. When the infinitesimal living entities are engaged in their infinitesimal desires for material enjoyment, they are called Jiva Shakti; but when they are dove-tailed with the infinite, they are called liberated souls. There is no question, therefore, as to why God created the infinitesimal portions. It is the complementary and supplementary side of the Supreme. It is essential, without any doubt, that the infinite must have the infinitesimal portions. They are inseparable parts and parcels of the Soul.

And, because they are infinitesimal parts and parcels of the Supreme, there is a reciprocation of feelings between the infinite and the infinitesimal. Had there been no infinitesimal living entities, then of course the Supreme Lord would have been inactive, and there would have not been any variegatedness in spiritual life. As there is no meaning of a king if there is no subject, therefore there is no meaning of the Supreme God if there are no infinitesimal living entities. There would have been no meaning of the word “Lord,” if there were none to overlord. The conclusion is that the living entities are counted as expansions of the energy of the Supreme Lord, and the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, Krishna, is the Energetic.

In all the Vedic literature, such as Bhagavad Gita and Vishnu Purana, there is innumerable evidence for this distinction between the energy and the Energetic. In Bhagavad Gita, Seventh Chapter, 5th verse, it is clearly stated that earth, water, fire, air and sky are five principal gross elements of the material world. Mind, intelligence and false ego are elements of the subtle matter. The whole material Nature is considered to be divided into these eight elements, which are the inferior quality of Nature. Another name for this inferior quality of Nature is Maya, or illusion. Beyond these eight kinds of inferior Nature there is another superior quality of Nature, which is called Paraprakriti. That Paraprakriti is the living entity, and the entities are found all over this material world. The purport is that the Supreme Lord is the Absolute Truth, the Energetic, and that He has energy also. That energy, when not properly manifested, or when covered by some shadow, is called Maya Shakti. The cosmic manifestation is a product of that covered Maya Shakti.

The living entities are factually beyond this covered inferior energy. The living entities have their pure spiritual existence, and their pure identity, and they have their pure mental activities. And all of them are beyond the manifestation of this cosmic world. The living entity, his mind, his intelligence, and his identity are beyond the range of this material world, but when he enters into this material world by his desire to lord it over matter, then his original mind, intelligence, and body become covered by the material energy. When he is again uncovered from these material or inferior energies, he is called liberated. And when he is liberated he has no false ego, but his real ego comes again into existence.

Foolish mental speculators think that after liberation even the identity is lost, but that is not so. Because we are eternally part and parcel, the living entity, when liberated, revives his original, eternal part-and-parcel identity. Aham Brahmasmi (I am not this body) does not mean that I lose my identity. At the present moment I say that I am matter, but in my liberated state I will understand that I am not matter, I am spirit soul, as part of the infinite. So to become Krishna conscious or spiritually conscious and to be engaged in this loving transcendental service of Krishna is the sign of the liberated stage.

In the Vishnu Purana, Sixth Chapter, 7th verse [6.7.61], it is very nicely and clearly stated: “The energy of the Supreme Lord is divided into three: Para, Kshetrajna and Avidya.” Para energy is actually the energy of the Supreme Lord; the Kshetrajna energy is called the living entities; and the Avidya energy is called this material world, or Maya. It is called Avidya, or ignorance, because under the spell of this material energy one forgets his actual position and his relationship with the Supreme Lord. It is concluded, therefore, that the living entities represent one of the energies of the Supreme Lord. Such an infinitesimal part and parcel of the Supreme Lord is called Jiva. If the Jiva is artificially put onto the same level with the infinite Supreme—because both of them are Brahman, or spirit—that will certainly lead to bewilderment.

The Mayavadi philosophers are perplexed before a learned Vaishnava philosopher because the Mayavadi cannot explain the cause of bondage of the living entities. They simply say: “It is out of ignorance,” but they cannot explain why the Supreme is covered by this ignorance. The actual solution is that the living entities, although qualitatively one with the Supreme are infinitesimal, and are not infinite. Had they been infinite there would not have been any possibility of being covered by ignorance. But, because the living entities are infinitesimal, they are covered by another, an inferior, energy. We can see their foolishness and ignorance when they try to explain that the infinite is covered by ignorance. It is an offensive attempt to qualify the infinite as subject to the spell of ignorance.

Sankara, although he attempted to cover the Supreme Lord by his Mayavadi philosophy, was doing so only by the order of the Supreme Lord. It is to be understood that his teaching was a timely necessity, but not a permanent fact. In the Vedanta Sutra this distinction between energy and the Energetic is accepted from the very beginning. In that Brahma, or Vedanta, Sutra the first aphorism, Janmadyasya, is a clear explanation that the Supreme Absolute Truth is the Origin or Source of all emanation. Therefore the emanations are His energy, whereas He is the Energetic. Sankara has falsely put his argument in this way: that if the transformation of energy is accepted, then the Supreme Absolute cannot remain immutable. But that is not true; in spite of unlimited energy being generated, why not accept that the Supreme Absolute Truth remains always the same, even though there is the emanation of unlimited energies from Him? Sankaracharya has therefore incorrectly and wrongly established the theory of illusion.

In this connection Ramanujacharya has discussed the point very nicely as follows: “If you argue that before the creation of this material world there was only one Absolute Truth, then how is it possible that the living entity emanated from Him? If He was alone, how could He produce or generate the infinitesimal living entities?” In reference to this question the Vedas state that everything is generated from the Absolute Truth, everything is being maintained by the Absolute Truth, and, after annihilation, everything enters into Him. From this statement of the Upanishads, it is clear that the living entities enter into the Supreme Existence in their liberated state without changing their original constitutional position of activity.

We must always remember that the Supreme Lord has His creative function; and, similarly, the infinitesimal living entities have also a creative function. When they are liberated and enter into the Supreme after the dissolution of this material body, their creative function is not lost. On the contrary, the creative function of the living entity becomes properly manifested in the liberated stage. If the living entity’s activities are definitely manifested when he is in this material condition, then how is it possible that when he is in his spiritual liberated stage his activities can be stopped? Entering is therefore understood in the sense that the bird enters into the trees, or the animals enter into the forest, or the flying vehicle enters into the sky.

While explaining Code Number One of the First Chapter of Vedanta Sutra, Sankara has most unceremoniously tried to explain that Brahman or the Supreme Absolute Truth is impersonal. Similarly, he has tried to twist most cunningly the doctrine of by-product into the doctrine of state of change. Actually, there is no change of state for the Supreme Absolute. It is simply by His inconceivable power of doing things that there comes a by-product. A relative truth produced out of another truth is called the transformation of a by-product. For example, when a sitting chair is produced out of crude wood it is the transformation of a by-product. Similarly, the Supreme Absolute Truth, Brahman, is immutable, and when we find a by-product—the living entity or this cosmic manifestation—it is called a transformation of that byproduct of the Supreme. Another example can be cited in this connection: that of milk and yogurt. Yogurt is a transformation of milk. In this way, if we study the living entities and the cosmic manifestation, it will appear that they are not different from the original Absolute Truth.

But from the Vedic literature we understand that the Absolute Truth has various multiforms of energy, and therefore the living entities and the cosmic manifestation are only a demonstration of His various energies. As energies are non-separable from the Energetic, therefore this transformation of the living entity and the cosmic manifestation is an inseparable truth which is part of the same Absolute Truth. Such a conclusion about the Absolute Truth and the relative truth should not be unacceptable to any sane man.

The Supreme Absolute Truth has His inconceivable potency, and out of that potential energy this cosmic manifestation has been effected. In other words, the Supreme Absolute Truth is the ingredient and the living entity and the cosmic manifestation are by-products. In the Taittiriya Upanishad it is clearly stated: Yato va imani bhutani jayande. This clearly states that the Absolute Truth is the original reservoir of all ingredients, and this material world of the living entities is produced out of those ingredients.

Less intelligent persons who cannot understand the doctrine of by-products cannot grasp how this cosmic manifestation and the living entity are simultaneously one and different from the Absolute Truth. Without understanding this truth, if, out of unnecessary fear, one concludes that this cosmic manifestation and the living entity are false, by putting forward the example of mistaking a rope for a snake, as Sankaracharya does, or mistaking the oyster shell for gold, surely that sort of argument is simply cheating. The examples of mistaking a rope for a snake and the oyster shell for gold, mentioned in the Mandukya Upanishad, have their different applications, and can be understood as follows: the living entity in his original constitution is pure spirit. And when a human being identifies himself with this material body, that is a case of accepting the rope as a snake, or the oyster shell as gold. The doctrine of transformation of state is accepted when one thing is mistaken for another. Actually, the body is not the living entity; and to accept the body as the living entity is the doctrine of transformation of state. Every conditioned soul is undoubtedly contaminated by this doctrine of transformation of state.

This conditional state of the living entity is a diseased condition. Originally, the living entity and the Original Cause of this cosmic manifestation are certainly not in this state of transformation. But mistaken thoughts and arguments can overcome a person when he forgets about the inconceivable energies and activities of the Supreme Lord. Even in the material world there are many examples: the Sun is producing unlimited energies from time immemorial, and so many by-products result from the Sun; yet there is no change in the heat and temperature of the Sun itself. If the Sun can maintain itself in its original state of temperature—although it is a material product—in spite of producing so many by-products, then is it very difficult to understand that the Supreme Absolute Truth, in spite of His producing so many by-products by His inconceivable energy, is not changed at all? Therefore, there is no question of the transformation of His state.

It is learned from the Vedic literature that there is a material product which is called touchstone which, simply by touch, can transform iron into gold. The touchstone can produce an unlimited quantity of gold, and still the touchstone itself does not change its state. Therefore, to suppose that this cosmic manifestation and the living entities are false or illusory, as advocated by the Mayavadi philosopher, is ignorance. No sane man should impose ignorance and illusion upon the Supreme Absolute Truth, Who is Absolute in everything. There is no possibility of change or ignorance or illusion with Him. Supreme Brahman is transcendental and completely different from any sort of material conception. Therefore, in the Supreme Absolute Truth, there is every possibility of inconceivable potential energy.

In the Svetasvetara Upanishad it is stated that the Supreme Absolute Personality of Godhead is full of inconceivable energies, and no one else has such energy. By the misunderstanding of such inconceivable energies of the Supreme, one may conclude that the Supreme Absolute Truth is impersonal, but this is false. Such a conclusion is only a delusion experienced by a living being when he is in an acute stage of disease. In Srimad Bhagwatam [3.33.3] also there are statements that the Supreme Atma, the Lord, has got inconceivable, innumerable potencies. In the Brahma Samhita [5.5] also it is stated that in the Supreme Spirit there are many variegated, inconceivable energies.

In the Absolute Truth there is no possibility of ignorance. Ignorance and knowledge are conceptions of this world of duality, but in the Absolute there cannot be any ignorance. Therefore it is simply foolishness to consider that the Absolute becomes covered by ignorance. If the Absolute Truth has the possibility of ignorance, how can it be said to be Absolute?

Understanding of the inconceivable energy of the Absolute is the only solution to the question of duality. In other words, the inconceivable energy of the Absolute is the cause of the doctrine of duality. By such inconceivable energy, the Supreme Absolute Truth, without being changed, can produce this cosmic manifestation and the living entities, just as the touchstone can produce unlimited quantities of gold without being changed. Because the Absolute Truth has such inconceivable energy, the material quality of covering by ignorance cannot be applied to the Absolute Truth. True variegatedness in the Absolute Truth is therefore a product of that inconceivable energy. It can be safely concluded that this cosmic manifestation is by-product of that inconceivable energy. And when we accept the inconceivable energy of the Supreme Lord, then there is no duality at all.

The expansion of the energy of the Supreme Lord is as true as the Supreme Lord. In the manifestation of the Supreme energy there is no question of transformation of state. The same example of the touchstone can be cited again: that, in spite of producing unlimited quantities of gold, the touchstone remains the same. (We hear, therefore, some sages say that the Supreme is the Ingredient or Cause of this cosmic manifestation.)

The example of accepting the rope as the snake is also not irregular. When we accept the rope as the snake it is to be understood that one has previous experience of the snake. Otherwise, how can one mistake the rope as a snake? Therefore, the conception of the snake is not untrue or unreal. It is the question of application. When, by mistake, we impose our conviction on the rope as being a snake, that is ignorance. But the very idea of the snake is not itself ignorance. Similarly, when we accept a mirage of water in the desert, there is no question of water being a false concept. Water is a fact, but the application of water in the desert is a mistake.

Therefore, this cosmic manifestation is not false, as is stated by Sankara. There is nothing false here. To consider this material manifestation as false is another ignorance. The Mayavadi theory that this world is false is ignorance. The conclusion of Vaishnava philosophy is that this cosmic manifestation is a by-product of the inconceivable energy of the Supreme Lord.

The principal word in the Vedas, Pranava Omkara, is the sound representation of the Supreme Lord. Therefore Omkara should be taken as the sound Supreme. Sankara has falsely preached Tatvamasi as the Supreme vibration in the Vedas, instead of Omkara. Omkara is the reservoir of all the energies of the Supreme Lord. The accent on the word Tatvamasi by Sankara, as the Supreme vibration of the Vedas, is wrong, because this word Tatvamasi is a secondary word only. This word suggests only a partial representation of the Vedas. In the Bhagavad Gita the Lord has in many places given importance to Omkara. The importance of Omkara is mentioned in the Eighth Chapter, 13th verse, Ninth Chapter, 17th verse, and Seventeenth Chapter, 23rd verse. Similarly, the importance of Omkara is stated in the Atharva Veda. Similarly, we get the importance of Omkara vibration in the Mandukya Upanishad.

Srila Jiva Goswami has given great importance to the word Omkara in his Bhagavat Sandarbha. He says: “Omkara is the most confidential sound representation of the Supreme Lord.” The sound representation or Name of the Supreme Lord is as good as the Supreme Lord. By vibration of such sound as Omkara, or of Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare, one can be delivered from the contamination of this material world. And, because such vibrations of transcendental sound can deliver a conditional soul, it is known as Tarak, or deliverer.

The sound vibration of the Supreme Lord is identical with the Supreme Lord. In the Narada Pancharatra also it is stated that when sound vibration is practiced by the conditioned soul, the Supreme Lord is present on the tongue of such a vibrating person. In the Mandukya Upanishad the same importance is given, in that whatever is seen as spiritual, with the addition of Omkara, is perfect spiritual vision. In the Spiritual World or in the spiritual vision there is nothing except Omkara, or the one alternate, Om. Unfortunately, Sankara has given up this chief word, Omkara, and he has whimsically accepted Tatvamasi as the Supreme vibration of the Vedas. By accepting such a secondary word of the Vedas as Tatvamasi, leaving aside the principal word Omkara, he has given up direct interpretation in favor of his own indirect interpretation of the Scripture.

TLC 21-1968: Further Talks With Prakasananda

Chapter Twenty-one

Further Talks With Prakasananda

Sripad Sankaracharya has unceremoniously obscured the Krishna Consciousness described in the Purusa Vedanta Sutra by manufacturing an indirect interpretation, and giving up the direct interpretation. But unless we take all the statements of Vedanta Sutra as self-evident, there is no need to study Vedanta Sutra. To interpret the verses of Vedanta Sutra according to one’s own whimsy is the greatest disservice to the self-evident Vedas.

So far as Omkara Pranava is concerned, He is considered the sound incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; as such Omkara is eternal, unlimited, transcendental, supreme, and indestructible. He is the beginningless, and He is the beginning, middle and end. When one understands the Omkara as such, then he becomes immortal. One should know Omkara as a representation of the Supreme situated in everyone’s heart. Anyone who understands Omkara and Vishnu as one and the same and all-pervading, never laments in the material world, nor does he remain anymore as a Sudra.

Although He (Omkara) has no material Form, He is unlimitedly expanded, and has unlimited Form. By understanding the Omkara one can become free from the duality of the material world and be placed in Absolute Knowledge. Therefore, Omkara is the most auspicious representation of the Supreme Lord. Such is the description of the Mandukya Upanishad. One should not foolishly interpret such a description of the Upanishad, and say that because the Supreme Personality of Godhead “cannot” appear Himself in this material world in His own Form, therefore the sound representation Omkara is here. By such a false interpretation, Omkara comes to be considered as something material, and the eulogizing of Omkara is misunderstood as simply an exhibition of His value. Actually, Omkara is as good as other incarnations of the Supreme Lord.

The Lord has innumerable incarnations, and Omkara is one of them, as an incarnation of the alphabet. As stated in the Bhagavad Gita [9.17]: “Amongst the letters I am Omkara”. This means that Omkara is non-different from Krishna—that is the right interpretation. The impersonalist, however, gives more importance to the Omkara than to the Personality of Godhead, Krishna. In fact, however, any representational incarnation of the Supreme Lord is non-different from Him. Such an incarnation or representation is as good spiritually as the Supreme Lord. Omkara is therefore the ultimate representation of all the Vedas. The Vedic Mantras or hymns have transcendental value because they are prefixed by the pronoun Omkara. The Vaishnavas, however, interpret Omkara as follows: By the letter O, Krishna the Supreme Personality of Godhead is indicated; by the letter U, Krishna’s eternal consort Srimati Radharani is indicated; and by the letter M, the eternal servitor of the Supreme Lord, the living entity, is indicated. Sankara has not given so much importance to the Omkara. It is found, however, in the Vedas and in the Ramayana and in the Puranas and in the Mahabarata, from the beginning to the end, and in the middle—everywhere. Thus the glories of the Supreme Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, are declared.

Thus Lord Chaitanya condemned the attempt at indirect interpretation of the Vedanta Sutra, and the Sannyasis present were all struck with wonder by His explanation. After hearing the direct interpretation of the Vedanta Sutra from Lord Chaitanya, one of the Sannyasis in the meeting immediately declared, “O Sripad Chaitanya, whatever You have explained by condemning the indirect interpretation of Omkara is not at all a useless argument. Only the fortunate persons can accept Your interpretation as the right one. Actually, every one of us now knows that the interpretations given by Sankara are all artificial and imaginary, but because we belong to the sect, therefore we took it for granted to be the right interpretation. We shall be very glad to hear You if You explain further the Vedanta Sutra by direct interpretation.”

After this, Lord Chaitanya explained each and every verse of the Vedanta by direct interpretation. He thus explained the word Brahman. Brahman means the greatest, and the direct interpretation of greatest is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Greatest means full with six opulences. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is the Reservoir of all wealth, all fame, all strength, all beauty, all knowledge, and all renunciation. When Lord Krishna was present Personally on the Earth, He exhibited these six opulences in full. Nobody was richer than Lord Krishna, nobody was more learned than Krishna, nobody was more beautiful than Krishna, nobody was stronger than Krishna, nobody was more famous than Krishna, and nobody was more renounced than Krishna. Therefore the Supreme Personality of Krishna is the Supreme Brahman. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita, Tenth Chapter [12], when Arjuna thus addressed Him: “You are Param Brahman,” the Supreme Brahman. Therefore, Brahman means the Greatest, and the greatest means the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna. He is the Shelter of the Absolute Truth, Para Tattwa, because He is Param Brahman. But, at the same time, in all His opulences and exhibitions of wealth, fame, strength, beauty, knowledge and renunciation, there is nothing material. Everything spiritual and transcendental in all the Vedic verses and hymns indicates that Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna. Wherever, therefore, the word Brahman appears in the Vedas, it should be understood to indicate Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The intelligent person at once replaces the Name Krishna wherever there is the word Brahman.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead is transcendental to the material modes of Nature, but He is fully qualified with transcendental qualities. To accept the Supreme as impersonal is to deny the manifestation of spiritual energies. When the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Brahman, is full with spiritual energies, and somebody simply accepts His impersonal exhibition of spiritual energy, then he does not accept this Absolute Truth in full. To accept It in full means to accept the spiritual variegatedness also, which is transcendental to the material modes of Nature. Therefore, failing to indicate the Supreme Lord, the impersonalist conception is incomplete.

The approved method of understanding the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna, is the path of devotional service, as is confirmed in every Vedic Scripture. The devotional service of the Lord begins by hearing about Him. There are nine different methods in devotional service, of which hearing is the basic one. Hearing, chanting, remembering, worshipping—all these are the process of attaining the highest perfection of understanding the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This process of understanding the Supreme Personality of Godhead is known as Abhidheya, or practice of devotional service within our conditional life.

In practice it is also experienced that anyone who takes to Krishna Consciousness does not like to deviate to any other consciousness. This Krishna Consciousness is a development of love for Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. And this development of love of Godhead is called the fifth dimensional interest of the human being. When one takes to this process of transcendental devotional service, or love of Godhead, he relishes his relationship with Krishna directly, and by such reciprocation in relishing transcendental dealings with Krishna, Krishna becomes gradually a Personal associate of the devotee. The devotee eternally enjoys blissful life. Therefore, the purport of the Vedanta Sutra is to re-establish the lost relationship of the human being with the Supreme Lord Krishna, to execute devotional service, and ultimately to achieve the highest goal of life, love of Godhead. These three principles of transcendental life are described in the Vedanta Sutra, and nothing more.

After this explanation of Vedanta Sutra by direct interpretation of the verses. one of the disciples of Prakasananda Saraswati, considered to be the chief amongst all his disciples, stood up in the assembly and began to praise Lord Chaitanya as Personally the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Narayan. He very much appreciated the explanation of Vedanta Sutra by Lord Chaitanya, and said publicly that the direct explanation by Lord Chaitanya of the meaning of the Upanishad and Vedanta Sutra, “is so pleasing that we forget ourselves, and forget that we belong to the Mayavadi sect.” It must be admitted herewith that the explanations by Sankaracharya of the Upanishads and Vedanta Sutra are all imaginary. We sometimes accept such imaginary explanations for the sake of sectarian feuds, but actually such an explanation does not satisfy us. Simply by accepting the order of Sannyasa one does not become free from material entaglements. Actually, if we understand the explanation given by Lord Chaitanya, that will help us. Sri Krishna Chaitanya has very nicely explained the meaning of Harer Nama Harer Nama Harer Nama Eva Kevalam—and we are all very much pleased. There is no alternative to devotional service.

Without devotional service nobody can become liberated from the material clutches. Especially in this age, when simply by chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare, one can achieve the highest liberation.”

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fourteenth Chapter [10.14.4], it is stated that, for a person who gives up the path of devotional service and simply undergoes some labor of life for knowledge, there is no other profit than taking the trouble to understand what is matter and what is spirit. It is considered useless labor to try to get grains from the husks which are empty. Similarly, in the Tenth Canto, Second Chapter, it is also said that a person who gives up the transcendental loving service of the Supreme Lord and artificially considers himself liberated, never attains to actual liberation. On the contrary, with great labor of austerity and penances he may be elevated to the status of liberation, but for want of shelter unto the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Lord, he falls down again into the material contamination.

The Supreme Brahman cannot be accepted as impersonal. Otherwise the six opulences, meaning the Supreme Personality of Godhead, will not be acceptable in the concept of Brahman. All the Vedas and the Puranas affirm that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is full of spiritual energies. Foolish persons do not accept the energy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and therefore His Pastimes and His Activities are derided by them. They misinterpret the transcendental Body of Krishna as a creation of the Material Nature, and this is the greatest offense and sinful act. One should, therefore, accept the words of Chaitanya just as He explained in this assembly.

The individual Personality of the Supreme Absolute Truth is explained in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Ninth Chapter [3-4]: “O my Supreme Lord, the transcendental Form which I am just seeing is simple transcendental pleasure without any change and without any contamination of the material modes. It is full of effulgence and there is no greater manifestation of the Absolute Truth than this. O Soul of everyone, You are the Creator of this cosmic manifestation with all the material elements, and I surrender unto You, Your transcendental Form, O Krishna! O Most Auspicious Universe! You advent Yourself in Your Original Personal Form for the Purpose of being worshipped by us. We perceive You either by meditation or by worshipping directly. Foolish persons, mostly contaminated by the material Nature, do not give much importance to Your transcendental Form, and therefore they are understood to be gliding down to hell.”

The same statement is confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita, Ninth Chapter, 11th verse: “Only the foolish persons mock at Me because I am here just like human being. Such foolish persons do not know the intrinsic value of this transcendental Form, that I am the Proprietor, I am the Master, I am the Lord of All Creation.”

For such foolish, demoniac persons, hell is also confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita, Sixteenth Chapter, 19th verse: “Such deriding persons who are envious of Me and My devotee, I put into this material world in the most degraded species of life, and being thus situated in such degraded forms, the demoniac persons have no chance to understand the Supreme Personality of God.”

The doctrine of by-product, Parinamavada, is ascertained from the very beginning of the Vedanta Sutra, but Acharya Sankara has artificially tried to hide it and to establish the doctrine of transformation of state, Vivartavata, and he has the audacity to say that Vyasa is mistaken. All the Vedic literature, including the Puranas, confirm that the Supreme Lord is the center of Spiritual energy and variegatedness. The Mayavadi philosopher, however, is puffed up, in his own incompetence, and cannot understand variegatedness in spiritual energy. He therefore falsely conceives that the spiritual variegatedness is no more than material variegatedness. Deluded by this false belief, he derides the Pastimes of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Such foolish persons, being unable to understand the spiritual activities of the Supreme Lord, consider Krishna as one of the products of this material Nature. This is the greatest offense which can be committed by any human being. Lord Chaitanya therefore establishes that Krishna is Sat Chit Ananda Vigraha, the Form of Eternity, Knowledge and Bliss, and is always engaged in His transcendental Pastimes of spiritual variegatedness.

The student of Prakasananda summarized the explanation of Lord Chaitanya and concluded: “We have practically given up the actual path of spiritual realization. We simply engage in nonsense talk. The Mayavadi philosophers who are serious about attaining benediction should engage in the devotional service of Krishna, but instead they take pleasure only in useless talk. We admit herewith that by the explanation of Sankara the actual import of Vedic literature is hidden. Only the explanation given by Chaitanya is acceptable, and all other interpretations are useless.”

After thus explaining his position, that particular student of Prakasananda Saraswati engaged himself in the chanting of Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. Prakasananda Saraswati saw that his chief student was engaged in chanting Hare Krishna, and he too admitted the fault of Sankaracharya, and spoke as follows: “Acharya Sankara wanted to establish the doctrine of monism, and therefore he had no other alternative than to interpret the Vedanta Sutra in a different way. If he accepts the Supreme Personality of Godhead, then the doctrine of monism cannot be established. Therefore, by his illusory scholarship, he has tried to cover the actual meaning of the Vedanta Sutra. Not only Sankara, but any author who wants to give his own views must curtail and misinterpret the Vedanta Sutra.”

The Lord therefore gave the direct meaning of the Vedanta Sutra. No Vedic Scripture can be used for indirect speculation; not only Sankara, but other materialistic philosophers like Kapila, Gautama, Astavakra, Patanjali —every one of them has tried to put forward philosophical speculations in a different way. The philosopher Jaimina and his other followers, who are all more or less logicians, have given up the real meaning of the Vedas, devotional service, and have tried to establish the Absolute Truth as subject to the material world. It is their opinion that if we do our material activities nicely, then if there is any God He will be pleased and give us the desired result. Similarly, the atheist Kapila has tried to establish that there is no God Who is the Creator of this material world. But he (Kapila) has analyzed the material world’s elements and their combination as the cause of creation. He has tried to establish this. Similarly, Gautama and Kanad have given stress to the material elements, and have tried to establish that atomic energy is the origin of creation. Similarly, the impersonalists and monists like Astavakra have tried to establish the impersonal effulgence of the Brahmajyoti as the Supreme. Similarly, Patanjali, one of the greatest authorities on the Yoga system, has tried to conceive an imaginary Form of the Supreme Lord.

To summarize their philosophy, it is understood that all these materialistic philosophers have tried to avoid the Supreme Personality of Godhead, as they wanted to put forward their own mentally concocted philosophies. But Vyasadeva, the learned sage and incarnation of Godhead, has thoroughly studied all these philosophical speculations of different sages; and to answer all of them he has compiled the Vedanta Sutra, which simply indicates the relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, execution of devotional service, and ultimate achievement of love of Godhead. In the very beginning of the Vedanta Sutra, the verse Janmadyasa yata appears and is explained in his Srimad Bhagwatam in which Vyasa establishes at the very beginning that the Supreme Source of everything is a cognizant, Transcendental Person.

The impersonalist tries to explain that the impersonal effulgence of the Supreme Lord, or Brahmajyoti, is beyond these material modes of Nature, but at the same time he wants to establish the Supreme Personality of Godhead as contaminated by the modes of material Nature. The Vedanta Sutra establishes that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is not only transcendental to the material modes of nature, but also that He has innumerable transcendental qualities and energies. All these speculative'philosophers are one in denying the existence of the Supreme Lord Vishnu, and they are very much enthused to put forward their own theories to be recognized by the people. Unfortunate persons become enamoured of these atheistic philosophers, and thus they can never understand the real nature of the Absolute Truth. It is better for them, therefore, to follow in the footsteps of great souls who are called Mahajans. According to Srimad Bhagwatam there are twelve Mahajans or great souls. They are: 1. Brahma, 2. Lord Shiva, 3. Narada, 4. Vaivasvata Manu, 5. Kapila (not the atheist, but the original Kapila), 6. the Kumaras, 7. Prahlada, 8. Bhisma, 9. Janaka, 10. Bali, 11. Sukadeva Goswami, 12. Yamaraj.

According to Mahabharata there is no use of arguing about the Absolute Truth. Because there are different kinds of Vedic Scriptures and philosophical understandings, and no philosopher is agreeable to another philosopher. Everyone is trying to give us his own point of view, rejecting the other. Therefore, to understand the prime necessity of religious principles is very difficult. It is better to follow in the footsteps of the great Mahajans, Great Souls, as above mentioned. One is then able to achieve the desired success. Lord Chaitanya’s teaching is just like nectar, and it holds whatever you need. The best way to take to this path, is to follow.

TLC 22-1968: The Srimad Bhagavatam

Chapter Twenty-two

The Srimad Bhagwatam

After this incident of the conversion of the Mayavadi Sannyasis into the path of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, many many scholars and inquisitive persons used to visit Lord Chaitanya at Benares. All of them could not see Chaitanya Mahaprabhu at His residence, and therefore they used to stand in line to see Lord Chaitanya as He used to pass on His way to the temple of Viswanath and Bindumadhav. One day He visited the temple along with His associates—Chandra Sekhar Acharya, Paramananda, Tapan Mishra, Sanatan Goswami, etc. He was singing,

Hari haraye namah Krishna Yadavaya namah
Gopala Govinda Rama Sri Madhusudana

—and while He was singing like that, chanting and dancing, thousands of people gathered around Him, and there was a roaring following the vibration of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. This vibration was so tumultuous that ’Prakasananda Saraswati, who was sitting nearby, came immediately along with his disciples, and as soon as he saw the beautiful Body of Lord Chaitanya and His nice dancing, along with His associates, he also joined and began to sing with Him:

Hari! Hari!

All the inhabitants of Benares were struck with wonder by seeing the dancing of Lord Chaitanya in ecstasy. Lord Chaitanya, however, checked Himself in His continuous ecstasy, and stopped His dancing when He saw that the Mayavadi Sannyasis were also present. As soon as He stopped His chanting and dancing, Prakasananda Saraswati fell at the feet of Lord Chaitanya. Lord Chaitanya tried to stop him and said: “Oh, you are the Spiritual Master of the whole world, Jagat Guru, and I am not equal even to your disciple. You should not therefore worship an inferior like Me, Who is not even equal to the disciple of your disciple. You are exactly like Supreme Brahman, and if you fall down at My Feet it is a very great offense on My part. Although you have no vision of duality, still for the teachings of the people in general you should not do this.”

Prakasananda Saraswati replied, “Previously I spoke ill of You many times. Therefore, in order to free myself from the result of my offense, I fall down at Your Feet.” He quoted in this connection a verse of Vedic literature in which it is stated that when even a liberated soul commits offense to the Supreme Lord he becomes again a victim of the material contamination. He quoted another verse from Srimad Bhagwatam, from the Tenth Canto, Thirty-fourth Chapter [10.34.9], in connection with Nanda Maharaj and the attack of a serpent who was previously Vidyadhavarehita. This serpent, being touched by the Lotus Feet of Krishna, regained his previous body and thus he was freed from the reaction of his sinful activities.

Lord Chaitanya, after hearing the equation of himself with Krishna, mildly protested against such behavior. The fact is, He wanted to warn people in general not to compare the Supreme Lord with any living entity. Although He was the Supreme Lord Himself, still, to teach us, He protested against this comparison, and said that nobody should be compared with the Supreme Lord Krishna—that is the greatest offense. Lord Chaitanya always maintained that Vishnu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is great and the living entities, however great they may be, are not the infinite, but are infinitesimal. He quoted, in this connection, a verse from Vaishnava Tantra, in the Padma Purana, where it is stated: “Any person who compares the Supreme Lord even with the greatest of demigods like Brahma and Shiva, must be considered a number one atheist.”

Prakasananda replied, “I can understand that You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna, but even though You present Youself as a devotee, still You are worshippable by me, because You are greater than all of us in education and in realization. Therefore, by blaspheming You, we committed the greatest offense and You should excuse us.”

How a devotee becomes the greatest of all transcendentalists is stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Sixth Canto, Fourteenth Chapter [5]: “There are many liberated souls, and there are many perfected souls; but out of all such liberated and perfected souls, one who is a devotee of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the best. Such devotees of the Supreme Personality of Godhead are always calm and quiet, and their perfection is very rarely to be seen even in millions of persons.”

Prakasananda quoted another verse from the Tenth Canto, Fourth Chapter, in which it is stated that duration of life, prosperity, fame, religiousness, and the benediction of higher authorities—everything gained, becomes lost by transgressing the respect of a devotee. He quoted another verse from Srimad Bhagwatam, Seventh Canto, Fifth Chapter [32], in which it is stated that the touch of the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead causes the disappearance of all kinds of misgivings of the conditioned soul. But this facility of touching the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Lord is not possible unless one receives benediction by the dust of the Lotus Feet of a pure devotee of the Lord. In other words, nobody can become a pure devotee of the Supreme Personality of Godhead without being favored by another pure devotee of the Lord.

Prakasananda Saraswati spoke further: “Now I am taking shelter of Your Lotus Feet, for I want to be elevated to be a devotee of the Supreme Lord.”

After talking in this way, both Prakasananda Saraswati and Lord Chaitanya sat together and Prakasananda Saraswati began to enquire from the Lord as follows: “Whatever You have said in pointing out discrepancies in the Mayavadi philosophy is known to us also, because we know that all the commentaries on Vedic Scriptures by Mayavadi philosophers are in error by interpretation—especially those by Sankaracharya, whose interpretation of Vedanta Sutra is all his own imagination. You have not explained the codes of Vedanta Sutra and Upanishad by Your imagination, but You have explained them as they are, and by hearing Your explanation, all of us are very pleased. Such explanations of the codes of Vedanta Sutra or Upanishads could not be given by anyone else except the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and You have all the potencies. Kindly explain further about the Vedanta Sutra, so that I may be benefitted.”

Lord Chaitanya again protested against His being called the Supreme Lord, and He said, “My dear sir, I am an ordinary living entity. I cannot know the meaning of Vedanta Sutra, but Vyasadeva, Who is an incarnation of Narayan, knows the real meaning of the Vedanta Sutra. No ordinary living being can interpret the Vedanta Sutra with his mundane education. In order to curb commentary on Vedanta Sutra by unscrupulous persons, the author, Vyasadeva Himself, has already commented on the Vedanta Sutra by writing Srimad Bhagwatam.” In other words, if the author himself explains the purport of his book, that is excellent. Nobody can understand the author’s mind unless the author himself discloses the purport of his language. Therefore Vedanta Sutra should be understood by the commentary of the Author Himself, which is Srimad Bhagwatam.

Pranava or Omkara is the divine substance of all the Vedas. Omkara is explained further in the Gayatri Mantra, as exactly explained in the Srimad Bhagwatam. There are four verses in this connection. These verses are explained to Brahma, and Brahma explained them again to Narada, and Narada explained them to Vyasa. Therefore the purport of the verses in the Srimad Bhagwatam comes down in disciplic succession. It is not that anyone and everyone can make his own commentary on the Vedanta Sutra foolishly, and mislead the readers. Anyone who wants to understand Vedanta Sutra must read Srimad Bhagwatam carefully. Under the instruction of Narada Muni, Vyasadeva compiled Srimad Bhagwatam with the purpose of explaining the Vedanta Sutra codes. Vedanta Sutra was written before Bhagwatam. After hearing from Narada Muni, Vyasadeva commentated on the Vedanta Sutra. By writing Srimad Bhagwatam He collected all the essence of the Upanishads, the purpose of which was explained also in the Vedanta Sutra. Srimad Bhagwatam is therefore the essence of all Vedic knowledge. That which is stated in the Upanishads and stated in the Vedanta Sutra is explained very nicely in the Srimad Bhagwatam.

There is a passage from Isho Upanishad, similiar to one in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eighth Canto, First Chapter [10], the purport of which is that whatever one sees in the cosmic manifestation, everywhere, is the Supreme Lord’s energy, which is non-different from Him. Therefore, He is the Controller of all living entities, and the Friend and Maintainer of everyone. We should live by the mercy of God, and by the things allotted to our particular living condition. Thus one enjoys life, and nobody should encroach on any other’s property.

In other words, the purpose of the Upanishad and Vedanta, and that of Srimad Bhagwatam, are one and the same. If anyone studies Srimad Bhagwatam carefully, he will find that all the Upanishads and Vedanta Sutra codes are nicely explained there. In Bhagwatam also the subject matter is divided into three: to establish the eternal relationship with the Supreme Lord, how to act in that relationship, and, lastly, how to achieve the highest benefit from it.

The four verses dealing with Ahameva asam agrey are the gist of the whole Bhagwatam [2.9.33-36], and this is very nicely explained as follows: “I am the Supreme Center of relationship of all living entities, and My knowledge is the Supreme Knowledge, and the process by which I can be achieved by the living entity is called Abhidheya. And, by the Abhidheya process, one attains to the highest perfection of life, love of Godhead. When one attains that stage of life, love of Godhead, then his life becomes perfect.” The explanation of these four verses is given in the Srimad Bhagwatam.

In this connection Lord Chaitanya gave a short description of the principles of the four slokas of Srimad Bhagwatam as follows: Nobody can understand the consitutional position of the Supreme Lord—how He is situated, what are His transcendental qualities, what are His transcendental activities, how He is full with six kinds of opulences. These things cannot be understood by mental speculators or by one’s academic education. These things are to be understood by the mercy of the Lord, as has been stated in the Bhagavad Gita [18.55]: one who is fortunate enough to be favored by the Supreme Lord can understand all these explanations by the mercy of the Lord.

The Lord existed before the material Creation; therefore the material ingredients and Nature and the living entities all emanated from Him, and again after dissolution they rest in Him. When the Creation is correct it is maintained by Him; at the same time, whatever manifestation we see, that is only a transformation of the external energy. When the external energy is withdrawn by the Supreme Lord, then everything enters into Him. In the first verse of Ahameva, the word, Aham, I, is mentioned three times. That is to stress that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is full with all opulences. For anyone, therefore, who cannot understand or does not believe in the transcendental Nature and Form of the Supreme Lord, and who says He is without any Form—Aham is stated three times just to chastise him.

The Lord possesses His internal energy, besides His external, marginal and relative energies, as well as the manifestation of His cosmic world and the living entities. The external energy is manifested by the qualitative modes, or gunas, of material Nature. One who can understand the nature of the living entity in the Spiritual World can actually understand Vedyam, or perfect knowledge. One cannot understand the Supreme Lord simply by seeing the material energy and the conditioned soul. But when one is in perfect knowledge, then he is free from the influence of the external energy. Just as the Moon is the reflection of the Sun, and without the existence of the Sun the Moon cannot illuminate, so this material cosmic manifestation is something like the reflection of the Spiritual World.

When one is actually liberated from the spell of the external energy, he can understand the constitutional nature of the Supreme Lord. Devotional service to the Lord is the only means for attaining Him. And this devotional service of the Lord can be accepted by everyone and anyone, in any country, in any atmosphere, and under any circumstance. Devotional Service is above the four principles of religiousness, or above the understanding of liberation. Even the preliminary process of executing devotional service is transcendental to the highest subject matter of liberation in the ordinary course of religiousness.

One should, therefore, approach a bona fide Spiritual Master, irrespective of caste, creed, color, country and place, and he must hear from that bona fide Spiritual Master everything about devotional service. The real purpose of life is to revive our dormant love of God. That is our ultimate necessity. How that love of God can be achieved is explained in the Srimad Bhagwatam. There is theoretical knowledge and specific, or realized knowledge. The perfect, realized knowledge, is obtained in realization of the teaching received from the Spiritual Master.

TLC 23-1968: Why Study the Vedanta Sutra?

Chapter Twenty-three

Why Study the Vedanta Sutra?

Knowledge means information gathered from the Scriptures, and science means practical realization of the knowledge gathered from the Scriptures. It is scientific knowledge when it is gathered from the Scriptures through the practical application of the bona fide Spiritual Master, but when interpreted by mental concoction it is personal. By scientific understanding of the information from the Scripture, through the bona fide Spiritual Master, one learns, by one’s own realization, each actual conception of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The transcendental Form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is different from material manifestation and different from the reactions of matter. Therefore, without scientific understanding of the Spiritual Form of the Personality of Godhead one becomes an impersonalist. The sunshine is itself an illumination, but that illumination is different from the Sun. Yet the Sun and the sunshine are not differently situated; without the Sun there is no sunshine, and without the sunshine there is no Sun.

Unless one is freed from the influence of material energy, one cannot understand the Supreme Lord and His different energies. One who is captivated by the spell of material energy cannot understand the Spiritual Form of the Supreme Lord. Unless there is realization of the transcendental Form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, there is no question of love of Godhead. Without realization of the transcendental Form of the Supreme Lord, love of Godhead is fictitious, and without realization of love of Godhead there is no perfection of human life. Such realization of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is as follows: it is just like the five gross elements of Nature, namely earth, water, fire, air and ether: they are both within and without all living beings in this world. Similarly, those who are devotees of the Supreme Lord can realize the Personality of Godhead both inside and outside this existence.

Pure devotees know very well that they are meant to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and all things that exist are the means for service to the Supreme Lord. Because a devotee has been blessed by the Supreme within the core of his heart, therefore, wherever he looks, he can see the Supreme Lord and nothing more. Srimad Bhagwatamconfirms this type of relationship between the devotee and the Supreme Personality of Godhead in the Eleventh Canto, Second Chapter [11.2.55], as follows: “For a person whose heart is always tied to the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Lord by the rope of love of Godhead, the Lord does not leave him even if remembrance is not very carefully done; such a person is called a first class devotee.” An example of this is described in the Bhagavata Tasumskunda: The Gopis were assembled for the Rasa Dance with Krishna, but Krishna left them, and so the assembled Gopis began to chant the Holy Name of Krishna. They became overwhelmed with madness, and began to inquire from the flowers and creepers in the forest about Krishna, Who is compared with the sky and Who is situated everywhere.

Study of Bhagwatam, therefore, means to be informed about our eternal relationship with the Supreme Lord, the procedure for how to regain Him, and the ultimate realization, which is love of Godhead.

Lord Chaitanya next explained to Prakasananda Saraswati how to achieve the Supreme Personality of Godhead by devotional service. He quoted in this connection a verse from Srimad Bhagwatam, from the Eleventh Canto, Fourteenth Chapter [11.14.21], in which the Lord says He can be realized only through devotional service, with faith and the love of the devotee, and it is devotional service only which purifies the heart of the devotee and elevates him into the ultimate realization of faith and service unto the Supreme Lord. Even though he is born of a low family such as a Chandala—one who eats dogs—yet by realization of the Supreme stage of love of Godhead one becomes full with transcendental symptoms.

These symptoms are described in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Third Chapter [11.3.31], as follows: “When devotees discuss the subject of the Supreme Lord, Who can cleanse the heart of a devotee from all kinds of sinful reaction, they become overwhelmed with ecstasies of different symptoms, on account of their devotional service; and, as such, [11.2.40] when they chant the Holy Name of the Supreme Lord, due to their spontaneous attachment for Him, they sometimes cry, sometimes laugh, sometimes dance, sometimes sing, without caring for any social convention.”

We should understand, therefore, that Srimad Bhagwatam is the real explanasion of the Brahma Sutra, and it is compiled by the Author Himself. In the Guru Purana it is said: “The Srimad Bhagwatam is the actual explanation of Brahma Sutra, and is a further explanation of Mahabarata. It is the explanation of the Gayatri Mantra and the essence of all Vedic knowledge. This Srimad Bhagwatam contains 18,000 verses, and is known as the explanation of all Vedic literature.” In the First Canto of Srimad Bhagwatam there is an enquiry by the sages of Naimisharanya to Suta Goswami, on how to know the essence of Vedic literature. In answer to the enquiry, Suta Goswami presented Srimad Bhagwatam as the essence of all the Vedas and histories and other Vedic literature. In the Twelfth Canto, Thirteenth Chapter [12.13.15] of Srimad Bhagwatam, it is clearly stated the Srimad Bhagwatam is the essence of all Vedanta knowledge, and one who relishes the knowledge from the Srimad Bhagwatam has no taste for studying any other literature. In the very beginning of Srimad Bhagwatam, the meaning and purpose of the Gayatri Mantra is also described: “I am offering my obeisances unto the Supreme Truth.” This is the first introductory verse on the Supreme Truth, described in the Bhagwatam as the Source of creation, maintenance, and dissolution of the cosmic manifestation.

Obeisances unto the Personality of Godhead, Vasudeva, directly indicate Lord Sri Krishna, Who is the Divine Son of Vasudeva and Devaki. The fact will be more explicitly presented later in the text of the Srimad Bhagwatam [1.3.28], by the direct statement of the Author, in His assertion that Sri Krishna is the Original Personality of Godhead, and all others are either His direct or indirect plenary portions, or portions of the portion. Srila Jiva Goswami has later on still more explicitly developed this subject matter in his Krishna Sandarva, and Brahmaji, the original living being, has explained the subject of Sri Krishna substantially in his treatise, called Brahma Samhita. In the Samveda Upanishad it is also said that Lord Sri Krishna is the Divine Son of Devaki.

Therefore, in this prayer of the Author of Bhagwatam, the first proposition is that Lord Sri Krishna is the Primeval Lord, and if any transcendental nomenclature for the Absolute Personality of Godhead has to be understood, it must be the Name indicated by the word Krishna, the All-attractive. In the Bhagavad Gita [10.12-14] in many passages the Lord has affirmed Himself as the Original Personality of Godhead, and it is confirmed by Arjuna, with the authorized statements of great sages like Narada, Vyasa, and many others. In the Padma Puranam also it is said that, of innumerable Names of the Lord, the Name of Krishna is the principal Name. Therefore, although Vasudeva indicates the plenary portion of the Personality of Godhead, and although all the different Forms of the Lord are identical with Vasudeva, in this text Vasudeva is principally meant to indicate the Divine Son of Vasudeva and Devaki. Sri Krishna is always meditated upon by the Paramhansas, or the most perfect of the renounced order of life. This Vasudeva, or Lord Sri Krishna. is the Cause of all causes. Everything that exists is an emanation from the Lord, and how this so happens is explained in later chapters of Srimad Bhagwatam.

The Bhagwat Puranam (Srimad Bhagwatam) is described by Mahaprabhu Sri Chaitanya as the spotless Puranam, because It contains the transcendental narration of the Personality of Godhead Sri Krishna. The history of Srimad Bhagwatam is also very glorious. It was compiled by Sri Vyasadeva from His mature experience of transcendental knowledge under the instruction of Sri Naradaji, His Sprirtual Master. Vyasadeva compiled all the Vedic literature, namely the four divisions of the Vedas, the Vedanta Sutra or Brahma Sutras, the Puranas, and the Mahabarata. But He was still not delighted in His mind. This was observed by His Spiritual Master, and thus Narada advised Him to write on the transcendental activities of the Lord, Sri Krishna. The transcendental activities of Lord Sri Krishna are described specifically in the Tenth Canto of the Book, which is considered to be the substance. But, in order to reach the substance of the Tenth Canto, one has to approach gradually by developed knowledge of the categories.

Generally, a philosophical mind is inquisitive to know what is the Origin of all creations. He sees the night sky and naturally asks what are the stars, how are they situated, who lives there, and so on. All these inquiries are quite natural for a human being, because he has a more developed consciousness than the animals. And to answer at once such a sincere inquirer, the Author of the Srimad Bhagwatam says that the Lord is the Origin of all creations. He is not only the Creator, but He is also the Maintainer of the cosmic situation, and He is also the Destroyer. The manifested Cosmic Nature is created at a certain period by the will of the Lord, it is maintained for some time, and then it is annihilated by His Will; and as such He is the Supreme Will behind all these activities.

There are atheists of various categories who do not believe in the conception of a Creator, but that is due only to their poor fund of knowledge. The modern scientist has created a sputnik, and by some arrangement or other the sputnik is thrown into outer space to fly on for some time at the control of a scientist who is far away from the flying sputniks. All the Universes, with innumerable planets within them, are similar to the sputniks, and are controlled by the Personality of Godhead.

In the Vedic literature it is said that the Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, is the Chief amongst the living personalities. All living beings, from the first created being, Brahmaji, down to the smallest ant, are all individual living beings. And, above Brahmaji, there are many other living beings with individual capacities, and the Personality of Godhead is also a similar living being, as individual as the other living beings. But the Supreme Lord, or the Supreme Living Being, has the greatest mind, with the supermost inconceivable energies of different varieties. If a man’s mind can produce a sputnik, we can very easily imagine that minds higher than man’s can produce similar other wonderful things far superior to the man-made sputniks. A reasonable person will easily accept this argument, but there are stubborn, obstinate ones who may not believe in these reasonable statements.

But Srila Vyasadeva at once accepts the Supreme Mind as the Parameswara, the Supreme Controller. He proposes to offer His respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. And that Parameswara is Sri Krishna, as is stated in the Bhagavad Gita and all other Scriptures delivered by Srila Vyasadeva, and specifically in the Srimad Bhagwatam. In the Bhagavad Gita [7.7] the Lord says that there is no other Paratattwa (Summum bonum) than Himself. Therefore, the Author at once worships the Paratattwa, Sri Krishna, Whose transcendental activities are described in the Tenth Canto.

Unscrupulous persons go at once to the Tenth Canto, and especially the five chapters where a description of the Lord’s Rasa Dance is kindly given. This portion of the Srimad Bhagwatam, however, is the most confidential part of the great literature. Unless one has thoroughly accomplished himself in the transcendental knowledge of the Lord, one is sure to misunderstand the Lord’s worshippable transcendental Pastimes in the form of Rasa Dance, and His love affairs with the Gopis. The subject matter is highly spiritual and technical, and only liberated persons who have gradually attained to the stage of Paramhansa, as referred to before, can transcendentally relish the worshippable Rasa Dance.

Srila Vyasadeva, therefore, gives us the chance for gradual development of spiritual realization before we can actually relish the essence of the Pastimes of the Lord, He therefore purposely invokes the Gayatri Mantra, “Dheemahi.” This Gayatri Mantra is meant for the spiritually advanced people. When one has attained success in the matter of chanting the Gayatri Mantra he can enter into the transcendental position of the Lord. One must acquire the Brahminical qualities, or be perfectly situated in the quality of goodness of the modes of material Nature, in order to chant the Gayatri Mantra successfully, and then attain to the stage of transcendentally realizing the Lord, His Name, His Fame, His Qualities, etc. Srimad Bhagwatam is the narration of the Swarupa or Form of the Lord, manifested by His internal potency; and this potency is distingushed from the external potency, which has manifested the cosmic world which is within our experience. Srila Vyasadeva makes a clear distinction between the two in the 1st verse of the First Chapter.

He says there that the manifestation of the internal potency is factual reality, whereas the external manifested energy in the form of material existence is temporary and illusory, no more real than the mirage in the desert. In the mirage of the desert there is no actual water. By the interaction of something else there is the appearance of water. Real water is somewhere else. Similarly, the manifestive cosmic Creation appears like reality, but the true reality, of which this is but a reflection only, is somewhere else in the Spiritual World, in which there are no mirages. Absolute Truth is there, and not here. Here everything is relative truth, one seeming truth depending on another. This cosmic Creation is an interactory resultant of the three modes of Nature, and the temporary manifestations are so created as to present an illusion of reality to the bewildered mind of the conditioned soul, appearing as so many species of life, including the higher demigods like Brahma, Indra, Chandra, etc. In fact there is no reality in the manifested world, but it appears so on account of the True Reality in the Spiritual World, where the Personality of Godhead eternally exists with His transcendental paraphernalia.

The chief engineer of a complicated construction does not personally take part in the construction, but it is he only who knows all the nooks and corners of the construction, because everything is done by his direction only. He knows everything about the construction directly and indirectly. Similarly, the Personality of Godhead, Who is the Supreme Engineer of this cosmic Creation, knows very well what is happening in the nooks and corners of the cosmic Creation, although the things are apparently done by someone else. From Brahma down to the insignificant ant, nobody is independent in material Creation, and everywhere there is the Hand of the Supreme Lord. All material elements as well as spiritual sparks are but emanations from Him only. And whatever is created in this material world is but the interaction of the two energies, material and spiritual, or the Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna (Vasudeva).

A living entity called a chemist can manufacture water in the chemical laboratory by mixing hydrogen and oxygen gases, but in reality the living entity works in the laboratory under the direction of the Supreme Lord, and the materials with which the chemist works are also supplied by the Lord. As such, the Lord knows everything directly and indirectly, and He is cognizant of all the minute details of everything, and He is fully independent. He is compared with the mine of gold, and the cosmic creations in different forms are compared with the gold rings and necklaces, etc. The gold ring and the gold necklace are qualitatively one with the gold in the mine, but quantitatively the gold in the mine and the gold in the earring or necklace are different. The whole philosophy of the Absolute Truth is, therefore, that It is simultaneously one and different. Nothing is absolutely equal to the Absolute Truth, but at the same time nothing is independent of the Absolute Truth.

Conditioned souls, beginning from Brahma, the engineer of this particular Universe, down to the insignificant ant, are all creating something, but none of them are independent of the Supreme Lord. The materialist wrongly thinks that there is no Creator save and except his own good self, and this is called Maya, or illusion. On account of his poor fund of knowledge the materialist cannot see beyond the purview of his imperfect senses, and thus he thinks that matter automatically takes its own shape without a conscious background. This is refuted in the 1st verse of the Bhagwatam by Srila Vyasadeva, Who is a liberated soul and compiled this book of authority after His mature spiritual perfection. The Complete Whole, or the Absolute Truth, being the Source of everything, nothing is independent of the Whole Body. Any action and reaction on the body becomes a cognizable fact to the embodied Whole. Similarly, if the whole Creation is the Body of the Absolute Whole, then nothing is unknown to the Absolute, directly or indirectly.

In the Sruti Mantra it is also stated that the Absolute Whole, or Brahman, is the Ultimate Source of everything. Everything emanates from Him, and everything is maintained by Him, and at the end everything enters into Him only. That is the law of Nature. In the Smriti Mantra also the same thing is confirmed. It is said there that at the beginning of Brahma’s millennium the Source from which everything emanates—and, at the end of that millennium, the reservoir that everything enters into—is the Absolute Truth, or Brahman. Material scientists haphazardly take it for granted that the ultimate source of all the planetary systems is the Sun. But they are unable to explain the source of the Sun. Herein the ultimate Source is explained. According to the Vedic literature, Brahma is the creator of this Universe, and yet he also had to meditate to get inspiration for such creation. Therefore Brahma, or the Sun, is not the ultimate creator.

It is stated here in the 1st verse of Srimad Bhagwatam that Brahma was taught the Vedic knowledge by the Personality of Godhead. One may argue that Brahma is the original living being within this Universe, and who could then give him inspiration, as there was no second being at that time? In the 1st verse of Srimad Bhagwatam it is said that the Supreme Lord inspired the secondary creator, Brahma, who then could go on with the creative functions. What we have already mentioned above about the supervising engineer is applicable here. The Real Mind behind all creative agents is the Absolute Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna. In the Bhagavad Gita [9.10] Lord Sri Krishna has Personally admitted that it is He only Who superintends over the creative energy, Prakriti, or the sum total of matter. Sri Vyasadeva, therefore, worships neither Brahma nor the Sun, but the Supreme Lord Who guides both Brahma and the Sun in their different activities of creation.

In the 1st verse of Srimad Bhagwatam the particular Sanskrit words Avijna and Swarat are significant. These two words distinguish the Lord from all other living entities. No living entity other than the Supreme Being, the Absolute Personality of Godhead, is either Avijna or Swarat—i.e., none of the entities are either fully cognizant, or fully independent. Everyone has to learn from the superior all about knowledge. Even Brahma, who is the first living being within this material world, has to meditate upon the Supreme Lord and take help from Him in order to create. When Brahma, or the Sun, cannot create anything without acquiring required knowledge from the superior, then what to speak of the material scientists who are fully dependent on so many things? Jagadish Chandra Bose, Isaac Newton, Prof. Einstein, etc. of the modern scientists who may be boastful of their respective creative energies, were also dependent on the Supreme Lord for so many things. After all, the respective, highly intelligent brains of these gentlemen were certainly not the products of any human being. The brain is created by another agent, other than the celebrated scientists themselves. If brains like that of Jagadish Bose or of Isaac Newton could have been manufactured by any human being, then they would have produced many such brains instead of eulogizing the brains of these scientists. Even the scientists could not manufacture a similar brain, what to speak of other foolish atheists who defy the authority of the Lord?

Even the Mayavadi impersonalists who flatter themselves that they have become the Lord are not Avijna or Swarat, fully cognizant or fully independent. Such Mayavadi monists undergo a severe process of austerity and penances to acquire the knowledge of becoming one with the Lord, but ultimately they become dependent on some rich follower who supplies them the requisite paraphernalia to conduct a great establishment in the form of monastery and temples. Atheists like Ravana and Hiranya Kashipu had to undergo severe penances before they could flout the authority of the Lord, and ultimately they were so helpless that they could not save themselves when the Lord appeared before them as cruel Death. The same is applicable to the modern atheists also who dare to flout the authority of the Lord. Such atheists will be dealt similar awards as were meted out to the past great atheists like Ravana and Hiranya Kashipu. History repeats itself and so what was accorded in the past, will recur again and again whenever there is such necessity. Whenever there is negligence of the authority of the Lord, the penalty by the laws of Nature is always there.

That the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, is All-perfect is confirmed in all Sruti Mantras. It is said in the Sruti Mantras that the All perfect Lord glanced over matter, and thus He created all living beings. The living beings are parts and parcels of the Lord, and He impregnates the vast material Nature with the seeds of spiritual sparks, and thus the creative energies are set in motion for so many wonderful creations. One atheist friend argued that God is no more expert than the manufacturer of a subtle watch which moves by delicate machineries. We had to reply to the atheist friend that God is still a greater mechanic than the watchmaker in the sense that He creates one machine in duplicate male and female forms. The male and female forms of different grades of machinery go on producing innumerable quantities of similar machines without the further attention of God. If a man could manufacture such sets of duplicate machines to produce further machines without any attention from the original manufacturer, then of course a man, could equal the intelligence of God. But that is not possible. Each and every one of the imperfect machines have to be handled individually by the mechanic, for nobody can be equal in intelligence to God. Another Name of God is therefore Asmaurdha. Nobody is equal to or greater than Him. Everybody has his equal or superior in intelligence, and nobody can claim that he has neither. This fact is corroborated in the Sruti Mantras, where it is said that before the Creation of the material Universe, there was the Lord, Who is the Master of everyone. The Lord instructed Brahma in the Vedic knowledge. That Personality of Godhead has to be obeyed in all respects. Anybody who wants to become free of the material entanglement must, therefore, surrender unto Him. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita also [18.66].

Unless one surrenders unto the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead it is sure and certain that one must be bewildered, even if he happens to be a great mind. When the great minds surrender unto the Lotus Feet of Vasudeva and know fully that Lord Vasudeva is the Cause of all causes, as is confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita [7.19], then only can such great minds become Mahatmas or the truly broad-minded. But such a broad-minded Mahatma is rarely seen. Only the Mahatmas, however, can understand the Supreme Lord, Who is the Absolute Personality of Godhead, the Primeval Cause of all creations. He is Parama, or Ultimate Truth, because all other truths are relatively dependent on Him. And because He is the Source of everyone’s knowledge He is omniscient, and for Him there is no illusion as there is for the relative knower.

Some scholars of the Mayavadi school argue that Srimad Bhagwatam was not compiled by Sri Vyasadeva, and some of them suggest that this book is a creation in the modern age of somebody by the name of Bopedeva. Srila Sridhar Swami, in order to refute this meaningless argument, says that there is reference to the Bhagwatam in many other of the oldest Puranas. The first Sloka, or verse, of the Srimad Bhagwatam is begun with the Gayatri Mantra, and there is reference to this as the Matsya Puranam (the oldest Puranam). In that Puranam it is said, with reference to the context of Gayatri Mantra in the Bhagwatam, that there are many narrations of spiritual instructions, beginning with the Gayatri Mantra, and also the history of Vitrasura is in Gayatri Mantra. Anyone who makes a gift of this great work on the full moon day, attains to the highest perfection of life by going back to Godhead. Similarly, there is a reference to this Bhagwatam in other Puranas where it is said that the work consists of twelve cantos and 18,000 Slokas. In the Padma Puranam also there is reference to the Bhagwatam, during the conversation of Goutam and Maharaj Amburish. The king was advised therein to read regularly Srimad Bhagwatam if he at all desired liberation from the material bondage. Under the circumstances, there is no doubt regarding the authority of Srimad Bhagwatam Puranam. Within five hundred years from the present era, many scholars, even after the time of Lord Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, have made elaborate commentaries on the Bhagwatam Puranam with unique scholarship; and the serious student will do well to make an attempt to go through them, to relish more happily the transcendental messages from the Bhagwatam.

Srila Viswanath Chakravarty Thakur specifically deals with the original and pure sex psychology (Adirasa) devoid of all mundane inebriety. The whole material world is turning on the basic principle of sex life. In the modern human civilization, sex life is the central point of all activities. Wherever we may turn our face we see a great prominence of sex life. Therefore, sex life is not unreal. Its true reality is experienced in the Spiritual World. Material sex life is but a perverted reflection of the original. The original, therefore, is in the Absolute Truth; and the Absolute Truth cannot be impersonal and have a sense of pure sex life. The impersonal monist philosophy has given an indirect impetus to the abominable mundane sex life, because it has given too much stress to the impersonality of the Ultimate Truth. The result is that men who lack knowledge have accepted the perverted sex life as all-in-all without any information about the actual spiritual form of sex. There is a distinction between sex life in the diseased condition of material life and that in the spiritual existence. The Srimad Bhagwatam will gradually elevate the unbiased reader to the highest perfectional stage of transcendence, above the three modes of material activities, namely fruitive actions. speculative philosophy, and worshipping the functional deities as they are inculcated in the Vedic verses.

Srimad Bhagwatam is the embodiment of devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna. It is therefore situated in a superior position over all other Vedic literature.

The term religiousness includes four primary subjects: namely, (1) pious activities, (2) economic development, (3) satisfaction of the senses, and (4) liberation from the material bondage. Religious life is distinguished from the irreligious life of barbarism, and human life begins from the life of religiousness. The four principles of animal life—eating, sleeping, defending and mating —are common both to the animals and the human beings. Religion is the extra concern of the human being, and without religion the so-called human life is no better than that of the animal. Therefore, in real human society there is some form of religion aiming at self realization, with reference to the eternal relationship with God.

In the lower stage of human civilization there is always a competition in lording it over material Nature; or in other words, there is a continuous rivalry for satisfying the senses. And, driven by this consciousness of sense gratification, religiousness is performed. Pious activities or religious functions are performed with an aim generally for some material gain. If such material gain is obtainable in another way, then the so-called religiousness is neglected, as we can see in the modern human civilization. The economic desires being seemingly fulfilled in another way, nobody is interested in religion now. The church, mosque, or the temple is practically always a vacant place, and people are more interested in the factories, shops, and cinemas than in the religious places formerly erected by the forefathers of different paths of religiousness. This proves definitely that religiousness is performed for economic development, and economic development is needed for sense gratification. And where one is baffled in the matter of sense gratification, he takes to the cause of salvation in order to become one with the Supreme Whole. Therefore, all these stages are different examples of the same aim of life, namely sense gratification.

In the Vedas, the above-mentioned four activities are prescribed in a regulative way so that there may not be any undue competition for the purpose of sense gratification. But Srimad Bhagwatam is transcendental to all these sense gratifying activities of the material world. It is purely transcendental literature, understandable by a particular class of men known as devotees of the Lord, who are above the competitive field of sense gratification. In the material world there is keen competition between the animals, between men, communities, or even nations in this sense gratifying activity, but the devotees of the Lord are above this. Devotees have nothing to compete for with the materialists because they are on the path back to Godhead, where everything is eternal, full, blissful. Such transcendentalists are a hundred per cent non-envious, and therefore pure in heart. In the material world everyone is envious of everyone and therefore there is competition. But the transcendentalists or devotees of the Lord are not only freed from all material enviousness, but they are kind to everyone, endeavoring to establish a competitionless society, with God in the center.

The socialist idea of society is artificially competitionless, because even in the socialistic state there is competition for the post of dictator. The fact is, therefore, that the state of sense gratification is the order of materialistic life, take it either from the Vedas or from the common human activities. As mentioned above, there are three divisions of the Vedas, namely the stage of fruitive activities for getting advancement to better planets like heaven, etc. And, above this, there are the activities of worshipping different demigods with the same intentions—of getting advanced into the different planets of the different types of demigods. And, lastly, there are the activities of reaching the Absolute Truth in His impersonal Feature, to become One with Him.

The impersonal aspect of the Absolute Truth is not the last word. Above the impersonal Feature is the Paramatma, or Supersoul, aspect, and above that there is the Personal quality of the Absolute Truth. Srimad Bhagwatam gives us information about the Absolute Truth in His Personal quality, beyond the impersonal aspect. It is therefore greater than the topics of impersonal philosophical speculations, and as such, Srimad Bhagwatam is given higher status than the Jnanakanda division of the Vedas. It is higher than the Karmakanda division as well as the Jnanakanda division and it is above the Upashanakanda division, because Srimad Bhagwatam recommends the worship of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna, the Divine Son of Vasudeva. In the Karmakanda of the Vedas there is competition for supremacy in reaching the heavenly planets for better sense gratification. And the same competition is there in the Jnanakanda or Upashanakandas. But Srimad Bhagwatam is above all of them because It aims at the Supreme Truth, the Substance or the Root of all categories. In other words, from Srimad Bhagwatam we can know the Substance as well as the relativities in the true sense and prespective. The Substance is the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and all emanations from Him are relativities in different forms of energies. The living entities are also related to all different types of His energies, and therefore nothing is different from the Substance. But, at the same time, the energies are different from the Substance. This concept is not self-contradictory. Srimad Bhagwatam explicitly deals with this simultaneously one and different philosophy of the Vedanta Sutra, which begins with the Janmadyasya Sutra.

Such knowledge of the simultaneously one and different nature of the Absolute Truth is really for the well-being of the knower. Otherwise the mental speculators mislead the people wrongly establishing the energy as Absolute. When it is understood, the truth becomes more pleasing than the imperfect concept of monism or dualism. Development of this consciousness leads one at once to the stage of freedom from the threefold miseries. The threefold miseries are 1. in relation to the body and the mind, 2. in relation to our dealings with other beings, and 3. in relation to the acts of providence, over which we have no control.

Srimad Bhagwatam begins from the surrender of the living entity unto the Absolute Person, with clear consciousness of the devotee's oneness with the Absolute, and, at the same time, his awareness of his eternal position of servitorship toward the Lord. In the material conception of his life he thinks of himself falsely as the lord of all he surveys, and therefore he is always troubled with the abovementioned threefold miseries of life. But, as soon as he comes to know his real position of transcendental servitude, he at once becomes freed from all the above-mentioned miseries. The servitor position of the living being is wasted in the material concept of his life. With a false sense of overlordship, the living being must offer his service to the relative energies of matter. When this servitorship is transferred unto the Lord in pure consciousness of spiritual identity, the living entity at once becomes freed from the encumbrances of material affliction.

Over and above this, Srimad Bhagwatam is the Personal commentary on the Vedanta Sutra by the great Author Himself—and that also in the mature stage of His spiritual realization, through the mercy of Narada. Sri Vyasadeva is the authorized incarnation of Narayan, the Personality of Godhead. Therefore, there is no question about His Authority. He is the Author of all other Vedic literature; but, surpassing all of It, He recommends the study of Srimad Bhagwatam. In other Puranas there are different methods of worshipping the demigods, but in the Bhagwatam only the Supreme Personality of Godhead is mentioned. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is the Whole Body, and the demigods are the different parts of the body. As such, by worshipping the Supreme Lord there is no need to worship the demigods, because the Supreme Lord is at once fixed in the heart. Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu has recommended this Srimad Bhagwatam as the spotless Puranam, as distinguished from all other Puranas.

The mode of receiving the transcendental message is to get it through the ears by submissiveness. No challenging mode can help the receiver in getting or realizing the transcendental message. Therefore, in the 1st verse of Srimad Bhagwatam, one particular word is used for our proper guidance. This particular word is Shushrusu: one must be anxious to hear about the transcendental message. And this qualification of hearing with interest is the prime qualification for assimilating transcendental knowledge.

Unfortunately, some persons are not interested in giving patient hearing to the message of Srimad Bhagwatam. The process is simple, but the application is difficult. Unfortunate persons will find enough time to hear ordinary social, political, and all sorts of idle talks, but when they are invited to attend a meeting of the devotees assembled to hear Srimad Bhagwatam, the unfortunate creatures will either be reluctant to attend such a meeting, or they will indulge in hearing the portion they are unfit to enter into. Professional readers of the Bhagwatam indulge in the confidential topics of the Pastimes of the Supreme Lord, which seemingly appear to be sex literature. Srimad Bhagwatam is meant to be heard from the beginning, and the class of persons who are fit to assimilate it is also mentioned in Srimad Bhagwatam 1/1/2: A bona fide audience for hearing the Srimad Bhagwatam is generated after many pious deeds. But an intelligent person, by thoughtful discretion, can believe in the assurance of the great sage Vyasadeva, and give patient hearing to the message of Srimad Bhagwatam, in order to realize directly the Supreme Personality of Godhead. And without undergoing the different Vedic stages, one can at once be lifted to the position of Paramhansa, simply by agreeing to receive patiently the message of Srimad Bhagwatam. The sages at Naimisharanya confirmed before Suta Goswami that they were increasing in their intense desire to understand the Srimad Bhagwatam. They were hearing from Suta Goswami about Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They were never satiated by such discussion, because persons who are really attached to Krishna never cease to want to hear more and more about Krishna.

Lord Chaitanya therefore advised Prakasananda Saraswati, “Always read Srimad Bhagwatam and try to understand each and every verse, and you will actually understand the Brahma Sutra. You say you are very anxious about the study of Vedanta Sutra, but you cannot understand Vedanta Sutra without understanding Srimad Bhagwatam.” He also advised Prakasananda Saraswati to always chant Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. “And, by doing that, very easily you will be liberated. And after liberation you’ll be eligible to achieve the highest goal of life, love of Godhead.”

The Lord then recited many verses from authoritative Scriptures like Srimad Bhagavad Gita and Srimad Bhagwatam, and Nrishingha Tapani. He quoted a verse from Bhagavad Gita, Eighteenth Chapter, 54th verse, that when one actually becomes self-realized, knowing he is Brahman, he becomes happy and joyful, and has no more cause for lamentation and hankering. Such a person sees all living entities on an equal level, and he becomes a pure devotee of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Similarly, in the Nrishingha Tapani it is said that when a person is actually liberated, then he can understand the transcendental Pastimes of the Supreme Lord, and thus become engaged in His devotional service. He also quoted a verse from the Second Canto of Srimad Bhagwatam [2.1.9], in which Sukadeva Goswami admits that, although he was elevated to the liberated stage and free from the clutches of Maya, still, he was attracted by the transcendental Pastimes of Krishna. And, as such, he studied Srimad Bhagwatam from his great father Vyasadeva.

He also quoted another sloka from Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, Fifteenth Chapter [43], about the Kumaras. When the Kumaras entered the temple of the Lord they were attracted by the odor of flowers and tulsi leaves offered to the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Lord with pulp of sandalwood, And, simply being incensed by the aroma of such flowers and tulsi, their minds became inclined to the service of the Supreme Lord, although they were already liberated souls. Therefore, according to Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto, Seventh Chapter [10], even if one is a liberated soul and is actually free from material contamination, still he becomes attracted to the devotional service of the Supreme Lord without any cause, and without being hampered by any material propensities. God is so attractive—therefore He is called Krishna.

Lord Chaitanya was discussing the Atmarama verse from Srimad Bhagwatam with Prakasananda Saraswati. His admirer, the Maharastrian Brahmin related in the assembly that the Lord has already explained the verse in 64 different ways. All the people assembled there were very eager to hear again from the Lord about the different versions of the Atmarama Sloka, and as they were so eager, Lord Chaitanya explained the Atmarama Sloka again, in the same way that He had explained it before to Sanatan Goswami. All the people assembled there heard the explanation of the Atmarama Sloka from the Supreme Lord, and they were amazed and considered that the Lord was nobody else than Sri Krishna Himself

TLC 24-1968: Talks with Sarvabhauma Bhattacharya

Chapter Twenty-four

Talks with Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya

When Lord Chaitanya met Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya at Jagannath Puri, Bhattacharya, as the great logician of the day, also wanted to teach Him Vedanta. Bhattacharya was an elderly man of the age of Lord Chaitanya’ s father, and therefore he took compassion on the young Sannyasi; he requested that He should learn Vedanta Sutra from him, otherwise it would be difficult to continue as a young Sannyasi. When the Lord agreed to learn Vedanta philosophy from Bhattacharya, he began to teach Him in the temple of Jagannath. Bhattacharya spoke to the Lord about Vedanta Sutra continually for seven days, and the Lord silently heard him without speaking a word. On the eighth day of teaching, Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya enquired from the Lord, “You are hearing Vedanta Sutra from me for the last week, but You do not inquire or say anything as to whether I am explaining it nicely. So I cannot tell whether You understand me or not.”

The Lord replied as follows: “I am a fool, I have no study of Vedanta Sutra, but you asked Me to hear you, and therefore I am trying to hear you.

You said that it is the duty of every Sannyasi to hear Vedanta Sutra, so I simply hear; but the meaning which you create—that I cannot understand.” In other words, the Lord was explaining that in the Mayavadi Sampradaya there are many so-called Sannyasis who are even illiterate and have not sufficient intelligence but just as a matter of formality they hear Vedanta Sutra from their Spiritual Master, although they do not understand anything. So far as Lord Chaitanya was concerned, He did not understand the explanation of Bhattacharya because He did not approve of the explanation of Mayavadi philosophy.

When He said that He was an uneducated fool Who could not follow, Bhattacharya replied to Him, “If You do not follow what I am saying, how is it that You do not inquire, but simply sit down silently? It appears that You do have something to say about my explanation.”

Then the Lord replied, “My dear sir, so far as the Vedanta Sutra or the codes of the Vedanta are concerned, I can understand the meaning very nicely, but the explanation which you are promoting is not understandable by Me. There is nothing difficult about the meaning of the original codes of Vedanta Sutra. But the way you were explaining them appears to be obscuring the real meaning of the codes. You do not elucidate the direct meaning of the Vedanta Sutra, but you imagine something and hide the true meaning. I think you have a particular doctrine, and you are trying to expound it through the codes.”

According to Mukti Upanishad, there are 108 Upanishads. Some of them are: 1. Iso, 2. Kena, 3. Katha, 4. Prasna, 5. Mund, 6. Mandukya, 7. Tittirih, 8. Aitriya, 9. Chhandogya, 10. Brihadaranoyakam, 11. Brahma, 12. Jaivalya, 13. Javala, 14. Svetsva, 15. Hansa, 16. Arunih, 17. Garbha, 18. Narayana, etc. These 108 Upanishads contain all knowledge about the Absolute Truth. Sometimes people inquire about the meaning of these 108 prayer beads, but we think because there are 108 Upanishads which contain full knowledge of the Absolute Truth, therefore 108 beads are accepted. Sometimes, on the other hand, the Vaishnava transcendentalists think there are 108 companions of Lord Krishna in His Rasa Dance, and therefore 108 beads are accepted.

Lord Chaitanya protested against misinterpretations of the statements of the Upanishads, and so any explanation which did not follow the direct meaning of the Upanishad He did not accept. The direct interpretation is called Abhidavritti, whereas the indirect method is called Lakshnavritti. The indirect meaning, or Lakshnavritti, serves no purpose. There are four kinds of understanding, called: (1) direct understanding, (2) hypothetical understanding, (3) historical understanding, and (4) sound understanding. Out of these four kinds of understanding, to receive knowledge by sound understanding, the understanding from the Vedic Scriptures (which are the sound representation of the Absolute Truth), is the best. The traditional Vedic students accept this sound understanding as the best.

For example, the stool and bone of any living entity is considered the most impure thing by the Vedic literature; but, at the same time, the Vedic literature asserts that cow dung and the conch shell are the purest of all. Apparently these statements are contradictory, but because cow dung and the conch shell have been called pure in the Vedic literature, although they are the stool and bone of living entities, they are accepted as pure without any argument. They cannot be changed by our mundane arguments added to the statements of the Vedas. If we want to understand the statements by indirect interpretation under some hypothesis, then we challenge the evidential quality of the Vedic statement. In other words, Vedic statements cannot be accepted by our imperfect interpretation; they must be accepted as they are. Otherwise there is no authority in the Vedic statement.

According to Lord Chaitanya, persons who try to always find some interpretation of the Vedic statements are not at all intelligent. They mislead their followers by some innovation of their own interpretation. In India there is a class who are known as Aryasamajist, who say that they accept only the original Vedas and no other Vedic literature. But their purpose is only to make their own interpretation, and according to Lord Chaitanya such interpretation is not accepted. Neither are they Vedic. Lord Chaitanya then said that the Vedic statements of the Upanishads are just like sunlight; as in the sunlight everything is clear and very distinct, so the statements in the Vedas are distinct and clear. The Mayavadi philosophers cover the sunlight with the cloud of their misinterpretation.

He then said that all Vedic statements of the Upanishads aim at the truth, known as Brahman. The meaning of the word Brahman is “the greatest,” and when you speak of the greatest we must immediately understand that greatest means the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Source of all emanations. Unless the greatest is filled with six opulences it cannot be the greatest; therefore the greatest, with the fullness of six opulences, means the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In other words, the Supreme Brahman is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Bhagavad Gita also, in the Tenth Chapter, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna, is accepted as the Supreme Brahman. The conceptions of the impersonal Brahman and the localized Supersoul are contained within the understanding of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Whenever we speak of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, we add the word ‘'Sri”: this means that He is full with six opulences, and, in other words, He is eternally a Person. Otherwise the six opulences cannot be present in fullness. Therefore, if we say that the Supreme Absolute Truth is impersonal, it means that He is not a Person of this material world. To distinguish His transcendental Body from the material body, some have explained Him as materially impersonal. In other words, material personality has been denied and Spiritual Personality has been established. In the Svetasvatara Upanishad, Third Chapter, 19th verse, it has been clearly explained that the Absolute Truth has no material legs and hands, but still He has spiritual hands by which He accepts everything which we offer to Him. He has no material eyes, but He has spiritual eyes by which He can see everything and anything. He has no material ears but He can hear everything and anything. He has perfect senses—therefore He knows past, future and present. He knows everything, but nobody can understand Him, because by material senses He cannot be understood. He is the Origin of all emanations and therefore He is the Supreme, the greatest, the Personality of Godhead.

There are many such Vedic hymns which definitely establish that the Supreme Absolute Truth is a Person, but that He is not a Person of this material world. In the Hayasirsa Pancharatra there is a nice verse which explains that, in each and every Upanishad the Supreme Brahman is first viewed as impersonal, but at the end there is acceptance of the Personal Form of the Supreme Lord. Another example, in the Isa Upanishad—the 15th Mantra—runs as follows:

Hiranmayena patrena satysya apihitam mukhm
Jat tvam pusan, apavrinu satya dharmaya dri staye

This verse indicates that everyone should be engaged in devotional service to the Supreme Lord; “O my Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, You are the Maintainer of the whole Universe. Everyone is sustained by Your mercy. Therefore, devotional service unto You is the true religion of life. I am therefore engaged in such devotional service, and I expect that You will please maintain me, and ever increasingly engage me in Your transcendental service. For the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the eternal Form of Sat-Chit-Ananda, and Your effulgence is spread all over the Creation, just like the sunshine. Where the sun disc is covered by the glaring sunshine, similarly Your transcendental Form is covered by the Brahmajyoti. I desire to find You within the Brahmajyoti—therefore please remove this glaring effulgence.”

In this verse of Isa Upanishad it is clearly stated that the eternal, blissful, cognizant Form of the Supreme Lord is to be found within the glaring effulgence of Brahmajyoti. Brahmajyoti is the emanation from the Personal Body of the Supreme Lord. Therefore the Personal Body of the Personality of Godhead is the source of the Brahmajyoti as it is described in the Bhagavad Gita [14.27]. The impersonal Brahman is dependent on the Supreme Personality. This is stated in the Hayasirsa Pancharatra; and, in any Upanishad or Vedic Scripture, wherever there is talk first of the impersonal Brahman, the Supreme Personality is finally established at the end. Just as we have quoted above from the Isa Upanishad, the Supreme Absolute Truth is both impersonal and Personal eternally, but His Personal aspect is more important than the impersonal concept.

The Mantra in the Taetreia Upanishad is: Yato va imani bhutani jayante. According to this Mantra this cosmic manifestation is an emanation from the Supreme Absolute Truth, and it rests also in the Supreme Absolute Truth. So the Absolute Truth becomes the ablative and causative and locative Performer. Therefore, as Performer, He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. These are the symptoms of Personality. This Absolute Truth being ablative Performer of this cosmic manifestation, it is to be concluded that He has thinking, feeling and willing. Without these three psychic symptoms there is no possibility of such a nice arrangement and design of the cosmic manifestation. Then again He is causative: He is the Original Designer of the cosmic manifestation. And He is locative: everything is resting in His energy. These are the clear symptoms of His Personality.

Then again, in the Chandyago Upanishad [6.2.3], when the Supreme Personality of Godhead desires to become many, He turns over the material Nature. As it is confirmed in the Taiitariya Upanishad, “The Lord glanced over the material Nature.” There was no existence of the cosmic manifestation before His glancing, and therefore this glancing does not mean that He has a glancing or seeing power which is materially contaminated. His seeing power existed before the material Creation, and therefore His body is also not material. His thinking, feeling and acting are transcendental. In other words it is to be concluded that the mind by which the Lord thinks, feels and wills, is transcendental; the eyes by which He glances over the material Nature are also transcendental. All of His senses existed before the material Creation, and so He has His transcendental Body, transcendental Mind, and transcendental thinking, feeling and willing, This conclusion is the purpose of all the Vedic literature. In all the Upanishads, the word Brahman is found everywhere. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Brahman, Paramatma and the Supreme Personality of Godhead are together calculated as the Absolute Truth. Therefore the Brahman conception and Paramatma realization also are grades or stages, and when ultimate realization is reached, that realization is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is the conclusion of all Vedic literature.

So, by the evidences of the different Vedic Scriptures, the Supreme Lord Krishna is accepted as the ultimate Goal of Brahman realization. Bhagavad Gita [7.7] confirms that there is nothing superior to Krishna. The great Acharya of Brahma’s disciplic succession, Madhva Acharya, has described—in connection with his explanation of the Vedanta Sutra—that everything can be seen through the authorities of the Scriptures. He has quoted a verse from the Bhobishya Purana in which it is stated that Rig Veda, Sam Veda, Atharva Veda, Mahabharata, Pancharatracum, and the original Ramayan, are actually evidential Vedic literature, and the Puranas which are accepted by the Vaishnavas are also accepted as evidential Vedic literature. Whatever is spoken in that literaute should be taken without any argument as the ultimate conclusion, and in all that literature it is found that Krishna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

TLC 25-1968: Personal and Impersonal Realization

Chapter Twenty-Five

Personal and Impersonal Realization

The Puranas are called the supplementary Vedic literature, because sometimes in the original Vedas the subject matter is too difficult to be understood by the common man. The Puranas, therefore, explain things nicely by different stories and historical incidents. So, in the Srimad Bhagwatam it is stated in the Tenth Canto, Fourteenh Chapter [10.14.32], that Maharaj Nanda and the cowherd men and inhabitants of Vrindaban generally are very fortunate because the Supreme Brahman, the Personality of Gobhead, full of bliss, is now engaged there in His eternal Pastimes as their Friend.

According to Svetasvatara Upanishad [3.19], the Mantra of Apanipado javano grahita comfirms that although Brahman has no materially created hands and legs, still He walks very stately, and He accepts everything offered to Him. These words suggest that He has transcendental limbs of the body, and therefore He is not impersonal. The person who does not understand the Vedic principles simply stresses the impersonal material features of the Supreme Absolute Truth, and thus unceremoniously calls the Absolute Truth impersonal. Although the impersonalist Mayavadi philosophers want to establish the Absolute Truth as impersonal, yet the Vedic literature itself does not confirm this. Vedic literature confirms that the Supreme Absolute has multiple energies, and still the Mayavadi impersonalists want to establish that the Absolute Truth has no energy. The Absolute Truth is therefore full of energy and He is a Person. He cannot be established as impersonal.

According to the Vishnu Purana [6.7.61–3], the living entities are considered as Kshetrajna energy. Although the living entity is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, and is fully cognizant, still he becomes entrapped in the material contamination, and therefore suffers all the miseries therein. Such living entities live in different positions in proportion to their entanglement in material Nature. The purport is that the original energy of the Supreme Lord is spiritual and non-different from the Supreme Absolute Personality of Godhead. The living entity is called the marginal energy of the Supreme Lord, whereas the material energy is called inferior. On account of possessing inert and material inebriety, the living entity, although in the marginal position, becomes entangled with the inferior energy, matter. At that time he forgets his spiritual significance and identifies himself with the material energy and therefore becomes subjected to threefold miseries. When he is, however, free from that material contamination, he proportionately becomes situated in different standards of life.

According to the Vedic instruction, everyone should understand the constitutional position of the living entity, the Lord, and the material energy in their inter-relation. First of all, one should try to understand the constitutional position of the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead. That Supreme Personality of Godhead has eternal, cognizant, blissful Body; His spiritual energy is distributed as eternity, knowledge, and bliss. In His blissful identity there is His pleasure potency, and in His eternal identity He is the Cause of everything, and in His cognizant identity He is the Supreme Knowledge. Krishna means that Supreme Knowledge. In other words, the Supreme Personality of Krishna is the Reservoir of all knowledge, all pleasure, and all eternity. That Supreme Knowledge of Krishna is exhibited in three different energies; they are called internal energy, marginal energy, and external energy. By internal energy, He exists in Himself with His spiritual paraphernalia, by marginal existence He exhibits Himself as the living entities, and by His external energy He exhibits Himself as the material energy. In each and every exhibition of His different energies there is the background of eternity, pleasure potency, and cognizance potency.

The conditioned soul is the marginal potency, overpowered by the external potency. When the marginal potency, however, comes under the spiritual potency, the marginal potency becomes eligible for love of Godhead. The Supreme Lord enjoys with six kinds of opulences and nobody can establish that He is Formless or that He is without energy. If somebody says that, it is completely against the Vedic instruction. Actually, the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the Master of all energies. The living entity, being an infinitesimal part and parcel, becomes overpowered by the material energy.

In the Mundaka Upanishad it is stated that two birds of the same feather are sitting on one tree. One of them is eating the fruit of the tree, and the other is not eating the fruit of the tree, but is witnessing the activities of the other bird. When the bird eating the fruit of the tree looks on the other bird, he becomes freed from all anxieties. This is the position of the infinitesimal living entity. So long as he is forgetful of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he is subjected to the threefold miseries; but when he looks to the Supreme Lord, or becomes a devotee of the Supreme Lord, he becomes free from all anxieties and miseries of material existence.

This position of the living entity means that he is eternally subordinate to the Supreme Lord. The Supreme Lord is always the Master of all energies, whereas the living entities are always under the energies of the Supreme Lord. The living entity, although qualitatively one with the Supreme Lord, has a tendency to lord it over the material Nature; but, being infinitesimal, the living entity has the tendency to be controlled by material Nature. This qualification of the living entity is called marginal potency. Because the living entity has a tendency for being controlled by the material Nature, he cannot at any stage of life become One with the Supreme Lord. If a living entity were equal to the Supreme Lord then there would be no chance of his being controlled by the material energy. In Bhagavad Gita [7.5], the living entity has been described as one of the energies of the Supreme Lord. Energy, although inseparable from the energetic, is still energy, and cannot be equal with the energetic. In other words, the living entity is simultaneously one and different from the Supreme Lord. The Bhagavad Gita, in the Seventh Chapter, verses 4-5, clearly states that earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego are the eight different elementary energies of the Supreme Lord. All these energies are of inferior quality, whereas the living entity has energy of superior quality. Therefore Vedic instruction confirms the transcendental Form of the Supreme Lord as eternal, blissful, and full of knowledge.

The conception of impersonalism is the opposite of the transformations of the material modes of Nature. The form beyond the modes of material Nature is not exactly like the form of this material world, but there is form, which is called spiritual form. That spiritual form cannot be compared with any one of these material forms. Anyone, therefore, who does not agree to accept the spiritual Form of the Supreme Lord, is counted among the atheists. Lord Buddha did not accept these Vedic principles, and therefore the Vedic teachers considered Him an atheist. Although Mayavadi philosophers do pretend to accept the Vedic principles, they indirectly preach the Buddhist philosophy or atheistic philosophy, without acceptance of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This philosophy is inferior to Buddha’s philosophy, which directly denies the Vedic authority; for the Mayavadi philosophy is disguised as Vedanta philosophy, and is thus more dangerous than Buddhism or atheism.

Vedanta Sutra is purely compiled by Vyasadeva for the benefit of all living entities in order to understand the philosophy of Bhakti Yoga. Unfortunately, the Mayavadi commentary, Sarirakabhasya, has practically defeated the purpose of the Vedanta Sutra. In the Mayavadi commentary, the spiritual, transcendental Form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead has been denied and the Supreme Brahman has been dragged down to a level equal with the individual Brahman, the living entity. Both of them have been denied the spiritual form of individuality, although it is clearly stated that the Supreme Lord is the One Supreme Living entity, and the living entities are many. Therefore, to consider the commentary of the Mayavadi philosophy on the Vedanta Sutra is always dangerous. The danger is in the false understanding of the living entity as equal to the Supreme Lord. A living entity can thus be falsely directed; and as a result he can never come to his actual position, his eternal activity in Bhakti Yoga. In other words, the Mayavadi philosophy has rendered the greatest disservice to humanity by promoting the impersonal view of the Supreme Lord. These philosophers are depriving human society of the real message of the Vedanta Sutra.

From the very beginning of the Vedanta Sutra it is accepted that the cosmic manifestation is a display of the energy of the Supreme Lord. In the very beginning, Janmadyasya, it is described that the Supreme Brahman is That from Whom everything is taking appearance. Everything is being maintained and everything is dissolved in Him. The Absolute Truth is the Cause of Creation, Maintenance, and Dissolution. The cause of the fruit is the tree. When the tree produces a fruit it does not mean that the tree is impersonal. The tree produces many hundreds and thousands of fruits but it remains as it is. The fruit is produced, developed, stays for some time, dwindles, and then vanishes. That does not mean that the tree has vanished. From the very beginning, therefore, the purpose of the Vedanta Sutra is the exposition of the doctrine of by-products. These activities of production, maintenance and dissolution are going on by the inconceivable energy of the Supreme Lord. The cosmic manifestation is a transformation of the energy of the Supreme Lord, although the energy of the Supreme Lord and the Supreme Lord Himself are non-different and inseparable. An example is the touchstone which produces great quantities of gold by contact with iron—but still the touchstone remains as it is. The Supreme Lord, therefore, in spite of His producing the huge material cosmic manifestation, is always in His transcendental Form.

Mayavadi philosophy has the audacity to decline acceptance of the purpose of Vyasadeva, as explained in the Vedanta Sutra, and has tried instead to establish transformation of the Supreme: a doctrine of transformation by imagination. According to Mayavadi philosophy, the cosmic manifestation is a transformation of the Absolute Truth, and the Absolute Truth has no separate existence. This is not the message of the Vedanta Sutra. This transformation has been explained by Mayavadi philosophers as false; but it is not false—it is temporary. Mayavadi philosophy says that the Absolute Truth is the only truth, and this manifestation of the world is false, Actually it is not so. The material contamination is not false; it is relative truth, and therefore it is temporary.

Pranava or Omkara is the chief indication of Vedic hymns, and Omkara is considered as the sound Form of the Supreme Lord. From Omkara, all Vedic hymns have emanated, and the world has also emanated from the Omkara sound. The world Tatvamasi, picked up from the Vedic hymns, is not the chief word, but it is an explanation of the constitutional position of the living entity. The meaning of this Tatvamasi is that the living entity is a spiritual particle of the Supreme spirit; but this is not the chief motif of the Vedanta or Vedic literature. The chief sound representation of the Supreme is Omkara.

All these faulty explanations of Vedanta Sutra are atheism. The Mayavadi philosophers do not agree to accept the eternal, transcendental Form of the Supreme Lord and they are therfore unable to be engaged in real devotional service. The Mayavadi philosopher is ever bereft of Krishna Consciousness and Krishna’s devotional service. The pure devotee of the Personality of Godhead never accepts the Mayavadi philosophy as an actual path to transscendental realization. The Mayavadi philosophers are hovering on the moral and immoral material atmosphere of the cosmic world; they are always engaged in rejecting and accepting material enjoyment. They have falsely accepted the nonspiritual as the spiritual. As a result of this misconception they have forgotten the spiritual, eternal Form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, His Name, Quality and Entourage. They consider the transcendental Pastimes, Name, Form and Quality of the Supreme as a product of material Nature, and so the Mayavadi is eternally subjected to the material miseries because of his acceptance or rejection of material pleasure and misery.

The actual devotees of the Lord are always different from the Mayavadi philosophers. lmpersonalism cannot be a representation of eternity, blissfulness, and knowledge. Being situated in imperfect knowledge of liberation, the Mayavadi decries eternity, knowledge, and blissfulness, under a misconception of materialism. They reject devotional service. Therefore they are less intelligent men. They are unable to understand the effect of devotional service. Their jugglery of words for amalgamating knowledge and the knowable and the knower into one has proved their very existence as a less intelligent class of men. The doctrine of by-product is the real purport of the beginning of Vedanta Sutra. The Lord is empowered with innumerable unlimited energies, and as such He displays the by-products of such energies in different ways. Everything is under His control. The Supreme Controller is called the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and He is manifested in innumerable energies and expansions.

TLC 26-1968: Bhattacharya Is Converted

Chapter Twenty-six

Bhattacharya Is Converted

For the impersonalist and void philosophers the next world is senseless eternity and bliss. The void philosophers want to establish that ultimately everything is senseless, and the impersonalists want to establish that the next world is simply knowledge without any activities. In other words, less intelligent salvationists want to carry imperfect knowledge into the perfect sphere of spiritual activity. The impersonalist, having experienced a great disadvantage in material activity, wants to establish spiritual life without activity. He cannot understand the activities of devotional service. Spiritual activity in devotional service is not intelligeble to the void phiolsophers and impersonalists. The Vaishnava philosophers know perfectly well that the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, having the power of innumerable potencies, can never be impersonal or void. He can present Himself in multiple Forms with innumerable energies, and still He remains Himself as the Absolute Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is competent Himself to maintain His transcendental position in spite of His becoming expanded in multiple Forms and diffused by His innumerable multiple Forms of energy.

Thus Lord Chaitanya showed many defects in the Mayavadi philosophy, and although Bhattacharya wanted to establish himself with various juggleries of words and logic, Lord Chaitanya was able to maintain Himself from such attacks, and He established that the Vedic literature is meant for three things: to understand our relationship with the Absolute Supreme Personality of Godhead, to act according to that understanding, and at the end to achieve the highest perfection of life, love of Godhead. Anybody who wants to prove something other than the above-mentioned three purposes must be the victim of his own imagination.

The Lord then quoted some verses from the Puranas, by which He wanted to establish that Sankaracharya was meant to do his teaching by the Supreme order of the Personality of Godhead. He quoted a verse from Padma Purana in which it is stated that the Lord ordered Mahadeva Lord Shiva to present some imaginary interpretation of the Vedic literature, and thus try to distract persons from the actual position of the Veda. “By such activity you try to make them atheists, and after that they can be engaged in producing more population.” In the same Padma Purana it is also said that Lord Shiva explained to his wife, Parvati, that in the Age of Kali, in the form of a Brahmin, he would preach the imperfect explanation of the Veda, known as Mayavadi, which is actually a second edition of the atheist philosophy of Buddha.

By such explanations of Lord Chaitanya, Bhattacharya was overwhelmed. And, hearing the explanation of Mayavadi philosophy from Lord Chaitanya, he could not speak, and simply remained silent for some time. Lord Chaitanya asked him, “My dear Bhattacharya, don’t be hampered with this explanation. Please take it from Me that the devotional service of the Supreme Lord is the highest perfectional stage of human understanding. Devotional service of the Lord is so attractive that even persons who are already liberated become devotees of the Lord by the inconceivable potency of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.” There are many instances of this in the Vedic literature, such as in the Srimad Bhagwatam, First Canto, Seventh Chapter [10]: therein is the famous Atmarama verse for persons who are attached to self-realization, and liberated from all material attachment. Such liberated impersonalist sages become attracted to devotional service by the various activities of Lord Krishna. That is the transcendental Quality of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Actually, the pure consciousness of the living entity is to understand himself as the eternal servant of the Supreme Lord. Under the spell of illusion, a less intelligent person accepts the gross body and the subtle body as his self; such a conception is the basis of the doctrine of transference. Actually the part and parcel of the Supreme is not subjected eternally to such a false conception of gross and subtle bodily life. The covering of the living entity by the gross and subtle body is not his eternal form, but can be changed; or, the living entity can become free from such existence. While he is in the conception of the body and mind he has certainly transferred his position from spirit to matter. Mayavadi philosophers, of course, take advantage of this doctrine of transference: they say that the living entity under the wrong impression thinks himself as part and parcel, but he is the Supreme Himself This doctrine cannot be tenable.

Bhattacharya then asked Lord Chaitanya to explain the famous Atmarama verse, as he desired to hear it from the Lord, Lord Chaitanya replied to him that, first of all, he should explain the verse according to his own understanding, and then Lord Chaitanya would explain it by His own understanding. Bhattacharya then began to explain the Atmarama Sloka with his method of logic and grammar. He explained the Atmarama Sloka in nine different ways. The Lord appreciated his erudite scholarship in explaining the verse, and said: “My dear Bhattacharya, I know that you are personally a representation of the learned scholar, like Brihashpati, and you can explain any portion of the Shastras in such a nice way. And yet your explanation is more or less based on academic education only. But there is another explanation, beside the academic, scholarly explanation.”

Then, at the request of Bhattacharya, Lord Chaitanya explained the Atmarama Sloka thus: On the basis of the analytical parts of the verse, the verse is explained as follows: 1. Atmarama, 2. Cha, 3. Munayah, 4. Nirgranthah, 5. Api, 6. Urukrama, 7. Kurvanti, 8. Ahaituki, 9. Bhaktim, 10. Itthambhutagunah, 11. Harih. (This verse is already explained in connection with the Lord’s teachings to Sanatan Goswami). Lord Chaitanya did not touch the nine different explanations of Bhattacharya, but He explained on the basis of 11 analyses of the verse, and each analytical basis He divided into five and six and, in this way, He expounded a total of 61 different explanations of the Atmarama verse. It is summarized, then, that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is full of innumerable potencies: nobody can estimate how many transcendental qualities are possessed by Him. They are always inconceivable, and any process of self-relization generally inquires into these inconceivable potencies of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, His energies, and His qualities. But those who are devotees at once accept this inconceivable position of the Supreme Lord. He explained that even great liberated souls like the Kumaras and Sukadeva Goswami also become attracted to the transcendental qualities of the Supreme Lord.

Bhattacharya then appreciated the explanation of Lord Chaitanya, and he concluded that Lord Chaitanya is none other than Krishna Himself. And he began to deprecate his own position. He related that at first he had considered Lord Chaitanya as an ordinary human being, and therefore he felt that he had been offensive to the identity of Lord Chaitanya. He fell down at the Lotus Feet of Lord Chaitanya, deprecating his own position, and requested Lord Chaitanya to show His causeless mercy upon him. Lord Chaitanya appreciated the humbleness of such a great learned scholar. He therefore exhibited His own Form, first with four hands, and then the six-handed form called Sadabhuj. Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya then repeatedly fell down on the Lotus Feet of the Lord and began to pray with various kinds of prayers composed by himself. He was a great scholar undoubtedly, and after receiving the causeless mercy of the Lord he was empowered to explain the Lord’s activities in different ways—such as being able to express the benefit of chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare.

It is said that Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya then composed 100 verses in appreciation of the Lord’s activities, and those verses are so important that even Brihashpati, the learned scholar in the heavenly planet, could not compose such nice verses. The Lord was very much pleased by hearing his composition of 100 verses, and He embraced Bhattacharya. By His touching, Bhattacharya became overwhelmed with ecstasy, and practically became unconscious. He was crying, sometimes trembling, sometimes shivering, sometimes perspiring, sometimes dancing, sometimes singing, and in this way he fell at the Lotus Feet of Lord Chaitanya. His brother-in-law, Gopinath Acharya, and the devotees of the Lord, were surprised to see the condition of Bhattacharya as he was transformed into a great devotee.

Gopinath Acharya addressed the Lord and began to thank Him: “Sir, it is by Your grace only that Bhattacharya has been transformed from his stonelike position into such a devotee.” Lord Chaitanya replied to Gopinath Acharya that, due to a devotee’s favor upon others, a stonelike man can be transformed to a mild flower-like devotee. Actually, Gopinath Acharya, the brother-in-law of Bhattacharya, had sincerely desired that such a scholar as Bhattacharya should become a devotee of the Lord. He had sincerely desired that the Lord show favor to Bhattacharya, and was glad to see his desire fulfilled by Lord Chaitanya. In other words, a devotee of the Lord is more merciful than the Lord Himself. When a devotee desires to show his mercy to a person, the Lord accepts, and by His grace such a person becomes a devotee.

Lord Chaitanya pacified Bhattacharya and asked him to go home. Bhattacharya again began to praise the Lord and said, “You have descended Yourself to deliver all the fallen souls of this material world. That project is not so difficult for You, but You have turned a stonehearted man like me, and that is Your wonderful act. I am very expert at logical arguments and grammatical explanations of the Vedic process. I am as hard as a lump of iron. But Your influence and temperature is so strong that You could melt away even hard iron like me.”

Lord Chaitanya then returned to His place and Bhattacharya, through Gopinath Acharya, sent various kinds of Prasadam from Jagannath temple. The next day, the Lord went to see the temple of Jagannath early in the morning, which is called Mongalarati. The priests in the temple brought Him a garland from the deity and offered Him various kinds of Prasadam. The Lord was very much pleased to receive them, and He at once went to the house of Bhattacharya, taking the Prasadam and the flowers to present to Bhattacharya. It was early in the morning, and Bhattacharya understood that the Lord had come and was knocking on his door. He at once rose up from his bed and began to say Krishna, Krishna!, which was heard by Lord Chaitanya. And at once he came to the door and opened it and saw the Lord standing there. He was so pleased to see the Lord early in the morning, and wanted to receive Him with all care. He again offered Him a nice seat, and both of them sat there and Lord Chaitanya offered him the Prasadam which He had received in the temple of Jagannath. Bhattacharya was very glad to receive Prasadam from the hand of Lord Chaitanya, and without taking his bath and without performing his daily duties or washing his teeth he began immediately to eat the Prasadam. Actually, he was now freed from all contamination of material attachment; and he cited a verse from Padma Purana as he began to eat the Prasadam.

In the Padma Purana it is stated that when Prasadam is brought or is received, even if it has become very dry or it is even very old or brought from a distant place, as soon as it is received it must be eaten immediately, without following any of the rules or duties of one’s daily activities. It is enjoined in the Shastras that Prasadam should be immediately taken, and there is no restriction of time and space—that is the order of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In other words, there are restrictions in accepting foodstuff from different kinds of people, but there are no such restrictions in accepting Prasadam from different kinds of people—neither a restriction as to time, place, or atmosphere. Prasadam is always transcendental, and it can be taken under any condition.

Lord Chaitanya was very much pleased to see that Bhattacharya, who always obeyed rules and regulations, could accept Prasadam without following any such rulesand regulations. Being so pleased Himself, Lord Chaitanya. embraced Bhattacharya. Both of Them began to dance in transcendental ecstasy. In that ecstasy, Lord Chaitanya explained: “My mission in Jagannath Puri is now fulfilled because I have converted a person like Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya.”

The Lord continued: “I shall be able now to attain Vaikuntha without fail.” The missionary activity of a devotee is to convert one person to become a pure devotee. Then admission to the Spiritual Kingdom is guaranteed. The Lord was so much pleased with Bhattacharya’s philosophy that He began to bless him repeatedly: “Dear Bhattacharya, now you are a completely pure devotee of Lord Krishna, and Krishna is now very much pleased with you. From today you are free from the contamination of this material body, and from today you are free from any entanglement under the spell of material energy. You are now fit to go back to Godhead, back to Home.” He then cited one nice verse from the Srimad Bhagwatam, Second Canto, Seventh Chapter [42]: “Anyone who takes complete shelter of the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Lord is favored by the Supreme Lord, Who is known as Unlimited. And such a person gets permission to cross over the ocean of nescience. Anyone who is under the misconception that this material body is himself, cannot have appreciation or causeless mercy from the Supreme Personality of Godhead.”

After this incident, Lord Chaitanya returned to His place, and Bhattacharya became a pure devotee without any faults. Since he was formerly an academic scholar, this conversion of Bhattacharya was possible only by the causeless mercy of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. From that day forward he never explained any Vedic literature without an explanation of devotional service. Gopinath Acharya, his brother-in-law, was very much pleased to see the condition of Bhattacharya, and he began to dance in ecstasy, vibrating the transcendental sound, Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare.

The next day, after visting Jagannath temple early in the morning, Bhattacharya came to the place of Lord Chaitanya and offered his respects by falling down before the Lord; and he began to explain his past undesirable behavior. He asked the Lord to say something about devotional service, and the Lord began to instruct him on the verses of Brihadnaradia Purana, in which is stated Harer Nama Harer Nama. Lord Chaitanya explained the meaning of this verse very explicitly. After hearing the explanation of the Harer Nama from Lord Chaitanya, Bhattacharya became more and more ecstatic. Seeing his condition, his brother-in-law, Gopinath Acharya, addressed him and said, “My dear Bhattacharya, what I stated before—‘when he is favored by the Supreme Lord he will understand about the techniques of devotional service’ —I am today seeing fulfilled.”

Bhattacharya offered him his due respect and replied, “My dear Gopinath Acharya, it is through your mercy that I have the mercy of the Supreme Lord.” The mercy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead can be achieved through the agency of the pure devotee. Lord Chaitanya’s mercy was bestowed upon Bhattacharya because of Gopinath Acharya’s endeavor.

Bhattacharya said to his brother-in-law: “You are a great devotee of the Lord, and I was simply blind with my academic education. So I have achieved the mercy of the Lord through your agency only.” The Lord was very much pleased to hear from Bhattacharya that a man can achieve the mercy of the Lord through the agency of the devotee, and he appreciated the verses and embraced Bhattacharya, confirming his statement.

The Lord then requested Bhattacharya to go and see Jagannath temple. Bhattacharya then started out for Jagannath temple, accompanied by Jagadananda and Damodar, two principal associates of Lord Chaitanya. He returned to his home after seeing Jagannath temple, and brought with him much nice Prasadam purchased from the temple. He sent all this Prasadam to Lord Chaitanya through his Brahmin servant, and also dispatched two verses written by him on palm tree leaves, and requested Jagadananda to do this favor and deliver them. All of them again came back to Lord Chaitanya and offered Him the Prasadam and the verses on the palm leaf. But before reaching the Lord, Mukunda Datta, who also undertook the delivery of the written palm leaf, had noted the verses down in his book. Lord Chaitanya read those verses and tore them into pieces, because He never liked to be praised by anyone. But his devotees had the verses written by Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya, from the notes of Mukunda Datta.

The purport of the verses written by Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya was praise of the Lord, the Supreme Original Personality of Godhead. He—Lord Chaitanya—has descended to preach detachment and transcendental knowledge along with devotional service to the people in general. Lord Chaitanya is the Original Personality of Godhead, and is compared with the ocean of mercy. “Let me surrender unto that Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.” The other verse states, “The Lord, seeing that devotional service was absent, descended Himself in the Form of Lord Chaitanya to preach that devotional service. Let us all surrender unto His Lotus Feet to learn from Him what is actual devotional service.” These two important verses are taken, by the devotees of the Lord in disciplic succession, as the most important jewels, and Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya has become highest amongst the devotees because of these famous verses.

Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya was thus converted to become one of the important devotees of the Lord, and he had no other interest than to serve the Lord. His only concern was to think of Lord Chaitanya constantly, and this meditation and chanting became the main purpose of his life. One day Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya came before the Lord, and after offering his respects he began to read a verse from the Srimad Bhagwatam. This verse is stated in the Tenth Canto, Fourteenth Chapter, in connection with Lord Brahma’s prayer to the Lord. Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya wanted to change two letters in the last portion of the verse, where the word Muktipade occurs. Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya wanted to change it into Bhakti. The purport of the verse is: A person who devotes his mind, body and speech to the service of the Lord, even in the midst of miserable life due to past misdeeds, is assured of liberation. And Bhattacharya wanted to change the Mukti, to Bhakti—devotional service.

The Lord inquired from Bhattacharya, “Why have you changed the original verse? The word is Mukti, and why have you changed it into Bhakti?” Bhattacharya replied that Mukti is not so valuable as Bhakti; and therefore Mukti is a sort of punishment for the pure devotee. He had therefore changed the word from Mukti to Bhakti. He began to explain his realization of Bhakti, and said, “Any person who does not accept the transcendental Personality of Godhead and His transcendental Form cannot know the Absolute Truth.

Anyone who does not understand the transcendental nature of the Body of Krishna becomes His enemy and decries or fights with Him. And for such enemies of the Lord, the destination is to merge into the Brahman effulgence of the Lord. Such kind of Mukti or liberation is never befitting the devotees of the Lord. Although there are five kinds of liberation, as, (1) getting admission to the same planet in which the Lord resides, (2) being able to associate with the Lord, (3) having a transcendental body like the Lord, (4) having opulence like the Lord, and (5) merging into the existence of the Lord, a devotee is satisfied being engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord, without any particular interest for any one of the above mentioned kinds of state of liberation. Specifically, a devotee is most averse to merging into the existence of the Lord, and becoming without any individual identity. A devotee considers oneness with the Lord as worse than hell, even though he may accept one of the other four kinds of liberation in consideration of being engaged in the service of the Lord. Of the two possibilities for merging in the Transcendence, namely, (1) becoming one with the Impersonal Brahman effulgence, and (2) becoming one with the Personality of Godhead, the latter is still more abominable to a devotee. The devotee has no other aspiration than to be always engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. On hearing this, Lord Chaitanya informed Bhattacharya that there is another purport of the word Mukti. Muktipada means directly the Personality of Godhead. That is to say, the Personality of Godhead has innumerable liberated souls engaged in His transcendental loving service, or He is the ultimate Resort for the ninth subject, called liberation. So, in either of the above mentioned import, Krishna becomes the ultimate Shelter. Sarvabhouma replied, “Inspite of such import, I prefer Bhakti to Mukti. Although according to You, there are two kinds of imports of the word Mukti, still, because this sound is equivocal, I shall prefer directly Bhakti to Mukti because by direct perception, Mukti refers to the context of becoming one with the Supreme. I therefore hate to utter the word Mukti, and I feel enthusiastic in uttering the word Bhakti.” At this, Lord Chaitanya laughed very loudly, and embraced the Bhattacharya with great love.

Thus the same Bhattacharya who took pleasure in explaining Mayavadi philosophy became a staunch devotee, so much so that he hated to utter the word Mukti. This is only possible by the causeless mercy of Lord Sri Chaitanya, and by His Grace He can turn iron into gold, like a touchstone. After this incident, all persons marked a great change in the Bhattacharya and they concluded that this was possible only by the inconceivable power of Lord Chaitanya. And they took it for granted that Lord Chaitanya was none other than Lord Krishna Himself.

TLC 27-1968: Lord Chaitanya and Ramananda Roy

Chapter Twenty-seven

Lord Chaitanya and Ramananda Roy

The author of Chaitanya Charitamrita has described Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu as the ocean of transcendental knowledge, and Sri Ramananda Roy as the cloud which is produced from the ocean. Ramananda Roy was a greatly advanced scholar in devotional service, and by the grace of Lord Chaitanya he gathered all such transcendental conclusions, just as the cloud achieves its existence from the water of the ocean. As the cloud appears from the ocean and redistributes water all over the world, and then again goes back to the ocean, so by the grace of Lord Chaitanya Ramananda Roy achieved his higher knowledge in devotional service, and thus he again went to Lord Chaitanya at Puri after retirement from service.

When Lord Chaitanya was visiting the southern part of India, He first of all visited the great temple Bisakhapattan, the temple known as Jiayar Nrishingha Kshetra. It is situated at a place known as Singachalam, five miles from the railway station Bisakhapattan. The temple is situated on the top of a hill, and there are many temples in that quarter, but Jiayar Nrishingha Kshetra temple is the biggest of them all. The temple is full of beautiful sculpture, still wonderful for many students; and, on account of its popularity, it is a very rich temple. There is an inscription in the temple which states that the king of Vijynagar formerly decorated this temple with gold, and smeared the body of the deity with gold. For facilitating attendance at the temple there are free apartments for the visitors. The temple is managed by priests who belong to the sect of Ramanujacharya.

When Lord Chaitanya visited this temple He praised the deity, and He quoted a verse from Srimad Bhagwatam [7.9.1]: “Although Lord Nrishingha is very servere to the demons and the non-devotees, He is very kind to His submissive devotees like Prahlad.” Lord Nrishingha appeared as an incarnation of Krishna when Prahlad, a boy devotee of the Lord, was too much harassed by his father, Hiranya Kasipu. As the lion is very ferocious to other animals, but is very kind and submissive to his cubs, so Lord Nrishingha, although He appeared ferocious to Hiranya Kasipu, was very kind to Prahlad, His devotee.

After visiting the temple of Jiayar Nrishingha, the Lord proceeded farther south into India, and ultimately He reached the bank of the Gudabudee. On the bank of the Gudabudee the Lord remembered the Yamuna of Vrindaban, and the nice trees on the bank were considered by Him the forest of Vrindaban; so He was in ecstasy there. After taking His bath on the bank of the Gudabudee, the Lord was sitting a little off from the bank and was chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. Sitting in that way, the Lord saw that the governor of the province, Sri Ramananda Roy, had reached the bank of the river accompanied by his associates, many Brahmins, and a band party. The Lord had asked about Ramananda Roy, the governor of this province, from Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya, and the Lord was requested by Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya to see the great devotee Ramananda Roy at Kabur.

The Lord could understand that this man approaching was Ramananda Roy, and He wanted to see him immediately. But, because He was in the renounced order of life, He restrained Himself from seeing a person of political affairs. But Ramananda Roy, as a great devotee, was attracted by the Features of Lord Chaitanya as a Sannyasi, and he himself came to see Him. Ramananda Roy, on reaching Chaitanya, prostrated himself to offer Him obeisances and respect. Lord Chaitanya received him by vibrating Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. When Ramananda Roy presented his credentials, Lord Chaitanya embraced him, and both of them became overwhelmed with ecstasy. The Brahmins who accompanied Ramananda Roy were surprised that these two persons were overwhelmed with transcendental ecstasy simply by embracing. The Brahmins were all stalwarts of the rituals, and they could not understand the meaning of these devotional symptoms. They were rather surprised to see that a great Sannyasi could touch a Sudra, and they were also surprised that Ramananda Roy, who was a great governor, and practically king of that province, was crying simply by touching a Sannyasi. While the Brahmins were considering this, Lord Chaitanya understood the unfavorable situation, and He pacified Himself.

After this, Lord Chaitanya and Ramananda Roy both sat down together, and Lord Chaitanya informed him that, “Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya has spoken very highly of you, so I have come to see you.”

Ramananda Roy replied, “Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya considers myself as one of his devotees, and therefore he very kindly recommended You to see me.” Ramananda Roy very much appreciated the Lord’s behavior for His touching a man of wealth. A king or governor or any politician is always absorbed in thoughts of political affairs and pounds-shilling-pence; therefore, such persons are avoided by a Sannyasi. But Lord Chaitanya knew Ramananda Roy to be a great devotee, and so He did not hesitate to touch and embrace him. Ramananda Roy was surprised by the behavior of Lord Chaitanya, and he cited a nice verse from Srimad Bhagwatam [10.8.4], in which it is stated that, “The great personalities and sages appear in the houses of worldly men just to show them mercy.”

Lord Chaitanya’s special treatment of Ramananda Roy indicated that, although Ramananda Roy was born of a family who were not Brahmins, still he was far, far advanced in spiritual knowledge and activity. Therefore he was more respectable than a Brahmin who happens to born in a Brahmin family. Although Sri Ramananda, out of his meek and gentle behavior, accepted himself as born of a lower Sudra family, still Lord Chaitanya considered him to be situated in the highest transcendental stage of great devotion. The devotees never advertize themselves as being great, but the Lord is very anxious to advertize the glory of the devotee. Ramananda Roy and Lord Chaitanya, just acquainted for the first time that morning at the bank of the Gudabudcc, separated, and there was an engagement made that Ramananda Roy would come in the evening to see the Lord.

In the evening, when the Lord was seated after taking His bath, Ramananda Roy came to see Him with a servant. He offered his respects and sat down before the Lord. Before Ramananda Roy could ask the Lord anything about advancement of spiritual knowledge, the Lord Himself inquired, “Please quote some verses from Scripture about the ultimate goal of life for the human being.”

Sri Ramananda Roy at once replied to the Lord that, “A person who is sincere in his occupational duty will gradually develop the sense of God consciousness.” In this connection he quoted a verse from the Vishnu Purana, in which it is stated that the Supreme Lord is worshipped by following the principles of one’s occupational duty, and there is no other alternative for satisfying the Supreme Lord from the formalities of performing one’s occupational duties. The purport is that human life is meant for understanding one’s relationship with the Supreme Lord and acting in that way. Any human being can dovetail himself with the service of the Lord by discharging his prescribed duties or occupational performances.

For this purpose, human society may be divided into four classes: namely, the intelligent class, or the Brahmins, the administrative class, or the Kshatriyas, the merchantile, or productive class, called Vaishyas, and the laborer class or the helping class, the Sudras. For each division of human society there are prescribed rules and regulations and occupational functions. The prescribed duties of the four classes or four divisions of human society are very nicely described in the Bhagavad Gita, Eighteenth Chapter, 42-44 verses. An organized, civilized society of humanity should follow such prescribed rules and regulations for particular divisions. At the same time, for spiritual advancement, they must follow the four stages of Ashrama: namely, the student life, which is called Brahmachary life; then householder’s life, then retired life, and then renounced life.

Ramananda Roy stated that persons who are strictly following the rules and regulations of these eight divisions of human society are the best, and they are actually satisfying the Supreme Lord. One who does not follow the principles of the social division and the rules of spiritual advancement is certainly spoiling his human form of life and gliding down towards hell. One can peacefully execute the goal of his human life simply by following the rules and regulations which apply to himself. The character of a particular person becomes developed by following the principles of regulation according to his birth and association and education. The divisions of society are so designed that many persons of different characteristics can be regulated under them, for the peaceful administration of social life and spiritual advancement. The social divisions of human society may be divided as follows: 1. One who has taken as the aim of his life to understand the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, and for which aim he has devoted himself to the learning of the Vedas and similar literatures, is called a Brahmin. 2. A person who has taken to the occupation of showing his force and of administering the government is called a Kshatriya. 3. One who is engaged in agriculture and herding cows and trade and business is called a Vaishya. 4. Persons who have no special knowledge but are satisfied by serving the three other higher social divisions are called Sudras. If one faithfully discharges his prescribed duties, it is surely an advancement toward perfection. Therefore, regulated life is the source of perfection for everyone. This regulated life, when culminating in devotional service to the Lord, attains its perfection. Otherwise it is a useless waste of time.

Therefore, Lord Chaitanya, after hearing from Ramananda Roy about the proper execution of regulated life, said that this is external. Indirectly, He asked Ramananda to state something which is better than this external exhibition of life. Formal execution of this ritualistic life or religious life is not very congenial unless it attains the perfection of devotional service. Actually. Lord Vishnu is not satisfied simply by the ritualistic performance of Vedic instructions, but He is actually pleased when one attains the stage of devotional service.

The verse cited by Ramananda Roy in reply to Lord Chaitanya means that, by the divisional ritualistic performances, one can rise up to the point of devotional service. In the Bhagavad Gita [18.45-46] we find that Lord Sri Krishna, Who appeared Himself for the deliverance of all classes of people, has mentioned that the human being can attain the highest perfectional stage of life by worshipping the Supreme Lord, from Whom everything has emanated, by dint of his occupational duties. It is stated in the Bhagavad Gita: “A person duly engaged in his occupational duties attains the highest perfection.” This perfectional process is followed by great devotees like Bodhyana, Tanaka, Dramida, Guhadeva, Kapardi, Bharuchi—all these great personalities have followed this particular path of perfection of the human life. The Vedic injunctions also aim at this point of life. Ramananda Roy wanted to present this fact before the Lord. But, apparently, simply discharging the ritualistic duties is not perfection. Therefore Lord Chaitanya said that it is external. Lord Chaitanya’s purport was that a man having a material conception of life, even if he follows the ritualistic regulations, cannot attain the highest perfection.

TLC 28-1968: Relationship with the Supreme Lord

Chapter Twenty-eight

Relationship with the Supreme Lord

The reason Lord Chaitanya rejected the statement of the Vishnu Purana made by Ramananda Roy is that He thus rejected a class of philosophers who are called Karmamimsat. Karmamimsat philosophers accept God as being subject to one’s work. If one works nicely, God is bound to give them good results: that is their conclusion. Therefore, from the statement of the Vishnu Purana as enunciated by Ramananda Roy, the meaning is sometimes drawn that Vishnu, the Supreme Lord, has no independence. He is bound to award a certain kind of result to the worker. Such a non-independent Supreme Personality of Godhead becomes subjected to the worshipper, and the worshipper accepts the Supreme Lord as he wishes, both impersonal and Personal, although they give more or less stress to the impersonal Feature of the Supreme Absolute Truth.

Lord Chaitanya did not like this idea of impersonalism, and therefore He rejected it. He said: “Tell Me if you know of something beyond this conception of the Supreme Absolute Truth.”

Therefore Ramananda Roy stated that it is better to give up the result of fruitive activities. Ramananda Roy understood the purpose of Lord Chaitanya. He quoted a verse from Srimad Bhagavad Gita, Ninth Chapter, 37th verse. The Lord says there that, whatever one does, whatever one eats, whatever one sacrifices, whatever one gives or whatever austerity one undergoes for a certain achievement—everything should be dedicated to the service of the Supreme Lord. Srimad Bhagwatam also, Eleventh Canto, Second Chapter, 36th verse, has a similar passage, in which it is stated that one should submit everything, the result of his fruitive activities, either by his body, by his speeches, by his mind, by his senses, by his intelligence, by his soul, or by his practical natural modes of Nature—everything should be surrendered to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Narayan.

Lord Chaitanya rejected this second statement of Ramananda Roy, and He said, “If you know something higher, state it.” The instructions of the Bhagavad Gita and the Srimad Bhagwatam, to offer everything to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is a better proposal than the impersonal idea of the Supreme Lord, and making the Supreme Lord subject to our work. But it is. still short of surrendering activities to the Supreme Lord. The worker’s. identification with material existence is not changed without proper guidance. Such activity of the fruitive worker will continue his material existence. He is simply instructed here to offer the fruitive result of his work to the Supreme Lord, but he has no idea of how to get out of the material entanglement. Therefore Lord Chaitanya rejected this proposal.

After this second rejection by Lord Chaitanya, Ramananda proposed that one should forsake his occupational activities, and by such detachment rise to the transcendental plane. This is, in other words, renunciation of one’s. worldly life. In this connection Ramananda Roy gave two evidences from the Shastras: in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, Eleventh Chapter [11.11.32], the Lord says, “In the religious Scriptures I have described ritualistic principles, and how one becomes situated in devotional service. That is the highest perfectional stage of religiousness.” Similarly, in the Bhagavad Gita, Eighteenth Chapter, 67th verse, the Lord says: “You give up all kinds of religiousness. and just surrender unto Me, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. I shall protect you from all sinful reactions, and you have nothing to be aggrieved over.”

On hearing this from Ramananda Roy, Lord Chaitanya rejected it again. By rejecting Ramananda Roy’s third proposal, Lord Chaitanya wanted to demonstrate that simple renunciation is not sufficient. There must be positive engagement. Without positive engagement the highest perfectional stage cannot be attained. Generally, in the renounced order of life, there are two kinds of philosophers: the goal of one is Nirvana, and of the other, the impersonal quality of the Brahman effulgence. They cannot conceive that they can reach beyond, or that there is a Spiritual Sky with Vaikuntha Planets. Because such mentalities cannot have any conception of the Spiritual Planets and activities, therefore Lord Chaitanya rejected the proposal of renunciation.

Ramananda Roy then gave evidence from Bhagavad Gita, Eighteenth Chapter, 54th verse, wherein the Lord says as follows: “When a person realizes himself as not different from the Supreme Absolute Truth by cultivation of knowledge, he becomes joyful and freed from all kinds of lamentation and material desires. At that time he perfects his Brahman realization by looking at everyone on the same spiritual level. This stage of Brahman realization can elevate one to the transcendental stage of devotional service.” The purport is that Ramananda Roy first suggested devotional service with renunciation of fruitive results from one’s work; but better than that stage of life is devotional service with full knowledge and spiritual realization.

Lord Chaitanya again rejected this proposal because in that stage of simply renouncing material results in Brahman realization there is no realization of the Spiritual World and the spiritual activities. Although in the Brahman realization stage there is no material contamination, yet, because there is no positive engagement in spiritual activity, it is not perfectly cleansed. It is still on the mental plane, and therefore external. The pure living entity is not liberated unless he has the complete spiritual idea and is engaged in spiritual activity. When one is absorbed in impersonal thought, or void thought, then his entrance into eternal life, blissful life, and life of knowledge is not complete. When spiritual knowledge is not complete, people will hinder you in your attempt to vacate the mind of all material variegatedness. Impersonalists are hindered in such attempts to make the mind void by artificial meditation. It is very difficult to make the mind void of material conceptions. In the Bhagavad Gita [12.5] it is stated that those who indulge in such voidness or impersonal meditation make very difficult spiritual advancement, and what they attain is not complete liberation. Therefore Lord Chaitanya rejected it.

After rejection of this fifth proposal, Ramananda Roy said that devotional service without any attempt at cultivation of knowledge or mental speculation is the highest stage of perfection. In this connection he gave evidence from Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, Fourteenth Chapter, in which Lord Brahma says to the Supreme Personality of Godhead: “My dear Lord, one should give up monistic speculation and the cultivation of knowledge altogether. He should begin his spiritual life in devotional service by receiving the information of the activities of the Lord from a realized devotee of the Lord. If one prosecutes his spiritual cultivation by following these-two principles and keeping himself rightly in the honest path of living, then, although Your Lordship is never conquerable You become conquered by him by such a process.”

When this prescription was presented by Ramananda Roy to Lord Chaitanya, the Lord at once said, “Yes, this is right.” In other words, the mission of Lord Chaitanya is as follows: In this age there is no possibility of acquiring spiritual knowledge by renunciation, or by mixed devotional service, or by fruitive results in mixed devotional service, or by the culture of knowledge. Because the people are not so advanced, and in fact most of them are fallen, and because there is no time to elevate them in a general process, the best thing, Lord Chaitanya prescribed, is to let them remain in whatever condition they are—but let them hle engaged in hearing about the activities of the Lord, as they are explained in the Bhagavad Gita and Srimad Bhagwatam. Such messages should be received by aural reception from realized souls. By this principle a person may live in whatever condition he is in, and still make progress in spiritual advancement. He will advance surely and certainly, so much so that he will be a fully realized soul of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Lord Chaitanya accepted these principles, but He requested Ramananda Roy to go further in advanced devotional service. Lord Chaitanya gave Ramananda Roy a chance to develop gradually the advancement from the principles of Varnashram Dharma (caste and the four orders of spiritual life); and, further, offering the results of all fruitive activities. Then he recommended discussion of spiritual knowledge. Lord Chaitanya rejected all of these, because in the field of executing pure devotional service there is very little use for such principles. Artificial methods of devotional service without self realization cannot be accepted as pure devotional service. Self-realized pure devotional service is completely different from all other kinds of transcendental activities. The highest stage of transcendental activities is always free from all material desires and fruitive activities, and speculative attempts at knowledge. The highest stage concentrates on a simple, favorable execution of pure devotional service.

Ramananda Roy could understand the motive of Lord Chaitanya, and therefore he stated that attainment of pure love of Godhead is the highest perfectional stage. There is a very nice verse in Padya Vali [13, 14] which is understood to be composed by Ramananda Roy himself. The purport of the verse is: “So long as there is hunger within the belly and one has a feeling for eating and drinking—so long, by taking anything eatable, one becomes happy. Similarly, there may be much paraphernalia for worshipping the Supreme Lord, but when that is mixed with pure love of Godhead, it becomes an actual source of transcendental happiness.“ There is another verse in that connection composed by Ramananda Roy, in which it is stated that even after millions and millions of births one cannot achieve a sense of devotional service. But if, somehow or other, one becomes desirous of achieving the stage of devotional service, the association of a pure devotee will help such a strong desire for serving the Lord to become prominent. One should try to have such a strong desire to become engaged in devotional service, if it is available from any source. In these two verses, Ramananda Roy has described first the regulative principles, and, second, the developed love of Godhead. Lord Chaitanya wanted to bring him up to this stage of developed love of Godhead, and to speak from that basis. Therefore, the discussion between Ramananda Roy and Lord Chaitanya will now proceed on the basis of love of Godhead:

If love of Godhead becomes elevated to personal affinity, that is called Prema Bhakti. In the beginning of Prema Bhakti there is no establishment of a particular relationship between the Supreme Lord and the devotee, but when this stage of Prema Bhakti develops further, there is manifested, in different transcendental flavors, a relationship with the Supreme Lord. The first stage is called servitude—to accept the Supreme Lord as the Master, and the devotee as the eternal servitor. When Lord Chaitanya accepted this process, Ramananda Roy described the relationship of the servitor and the Master. As cited in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Ninth Canto, Fifth Chapter [16], Durbasamuni was a great mystic Yogi and considered himself to be very elevated. Yet he envied Maharaj Amburish, who was known as the greatest devotee of the time. Durbasamani wanted to harass Maharaj Amburish, and as a result he met with great catastrophe, and Durbasamani was defeated by the Sudarsan Chakra of the Lord. The Yogi admitted his fault and said, “For pure devotees who are always engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord, nothing is considered impossible to obtain, because they’re engaged in the service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, hearing Whose very Name is sufficient for liberation.” Yamunacharya has composed various verses in his book, Strotraratna. In this Strotraratna [43], Yamunacharya writes a nice verse, the purport of which is as fol lows: “My Lord, persons who are keeping themselves independent of Your service are helpless. They’re working on their own account, and they have no support from superior authority. Therefore I long for the time when I shall be fully engaged in Your transcendental loving service, without any desire for material satisfaction or hovering over the mental plane. When I shall be engaged in such unalloyed devotional service I shall enjoy actual spiritual life.”

On hearing that statement of Ramananda Roy, the Lord requested him to go still further.

TLC 29-1968: The Transcendental Pastimes of Radha and Krishna

Chapter Twenty-nine

The Transcendental Pastimes of Radha and Krishna

When Lord Chaitanya said that that was accepted, and that he might advance further, Ramananda Roy said that fraternal relationship with Lord Krishna is a still higher transcendental position. Ramananda Roy’s purport in saying this is that, when the relationship with Krishna is increased by a more affectionate tendency, then the mood of fearfulness, the consciousness of the extra-superiority of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, becomes diminished; and there is the development of a mood of faithfulness. And this faithfulness is called friendship. In this friendly relationship, there is a sense of equality between Lord Krishna and His friends.

In this connection, Ramananda Roy quoted a nice verse from Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 12th Chapter, where Sukdeva Goswami describes Lord Krishna’s lunch with His friends in the forest where they went to play with the cows. It is said there that the cowherds boys who went to play in the forest with Krishna enjoyed transcendental friendship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Who is considered the Impersonal Brahman by great sages, considered the Supreme Personality of Godhead by the devotees; and, for the ordinary man, He is considered an ordinary human being.

Lord Chaitanya appreciated this statement by Ramananda Roy very much, but still He said, “You can advance further.” At the request of Lord Chaitanya, Ramanada Roy stated that the relationship with Krishna as son and father, the relationship of parenthood, is a still higher transcendental position.

Ramananda Roy’s meaning was that the friendly attitude toward Krishna, increased by still more affection becomes the relationship between parents and their children. In this connection Ramananda Roy quoted a nice verse from Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth canto, 8th chapter, where it is stated that the King inquired from Sukdeva Goswami as to the magnitude of righteous activities which had been performed by Yasoda, the mother of Krishna, for which the Supreme Personality of Godhead called her “mother,” and sucked at her breast. And he quoted still another verse from Srimad Bhagwatam (Tenth Canto, 9th Chapter), in which it is stated that Yasoda, the wife of Nanda, a cowherd man, received mercy from the Supreme Personality of Godhead which is incomparable, even by the mercy which is received by Brahma, the first created living being, or Lord Shiva, or even the Goddess of Fortune, Lakshmi, who is always situated on the chest of Lord Vishnu.

Lord Chaitanya asked Ramananda Roy to proceed further, to come to the point of conjugal love. Ramananda Roy, understanding the mind of Lord Chaitanya, immediately answered that the relationship of conjugal love with Krishna is the highest position. In other words, intimate relationship with Krishna develops from an ordinary conception of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, to the conception of Master and servant. And when it has become confidential, it develops into a friendly relationship, and when it is further developed, it is the relationship between parents and the children; and when it is developed to the highest point of complete love and affection, it is known as conjugal love with the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

In this connection, Ramananda Roy quoted a nice stanza from the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 47th Chapter [10.47.60], in which it is stated that the transcendental mode of ecstasy which was exhibited during the Rasa Dance of the Gopis with Krishna was never relishable even by the Goddess of Fortune, who is always situated on the chest of the Lord in the spiritual kingdom. What to speak of die experience of ordinary women?

Ramananda Roy then explained the gradual process of the development of pure love with Krishna. He stated that a person who is related to the Supreme Personality of Godhead in any one of the different modes of affection is in the relationship just suitable for him. But actually a relationship with the Supreme Lord begins with the relationship of Master and servant, and further develops into friendship, and further develops into paternal love, and further develops into conjugal love. Anyone who is situated in his particular relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead is in the best relationship for him, but when we study all these different flavors of transcendental taste in relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, we can see that the first stage is Brahmabuta, or the neutral stage of realization of the Supreme Lord. The state accompanying the conception of accepting the Lord as Master and oneself as His servant is better; and the more developed conception of that relationship is as a friend; and still further as a father; this is the superior quality of development. From friendship to paternal love, the relationship is advanced and of superior quality, and the further advance to conjugal love is the supreme relationship with the Supreme Lord.

Self realization with the sense of servitude is certainly a transcendental development. And the mode of Master and servant, with fraternity added, is a further development. And with progressive affection, it develops into parenthood. But the highest development is conjugal love in relationship with the Supreme Lord. In this connection, Ramananda Roy quoted a verse from Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [2.5.38]. It is stated there that the development of spiritual affection for the Supreme Lord is in all categories transcendental, but that the specific aptitude of a devotee to a particular state is more relishable by him than others.

Such a transcendental relationship with the Supreme Lord cannot, however, be manufactured by the mental concoction of a pseudo devotee. In this connection, Rupa Goswami in his Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu [1.2.101], has stated that devotional service without reference to the Vedic Scriptures as well as to Vedic literature, following the principles of Vedic Scripture, can never be approved. Sri Bhakti Siddhanta Saraswati Goswami Maharaj remarks that those who are professional spiritual masters, professional Bhagwatam reciters, professional performers of Kirtan, or persons who are engaged in so-called devotional service of their own mental concoction, cannot be accepted. There are different kinds of professional communities known as Aul, Vaul, Kartabhaza, Nada Darbesa, Snai, Atibibadi, Chudadhari, Gaurnaganagari. A member of the Ventor Goswami society, or the caste called Goswami, cannot be accepted as the descendent of the six original Goswamis. Similarly, so-called devotees who manufacture different kinds of songs in connection with Lord Chaitanya, or those who are professional priests or paid recitors, cannot be accepted in this connection. One who does not follow the principle of Pancharatra, and one who is an impersonalist, and one who is addicted to sex life, cannot be compared with persons who have dedicated their lives to the service of Krishna.

A pure devotee who is always engaged in Krishna Consciousness can sacrifice everything for the service of the Lord. A person who has dedicated his life to the service of Lord Chaitanya and Krishna and the Spiritual Master, or a person who is following the principles of householder life, and similarly those who are following the principles of the renounced life in the order of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, are devotees and cannot be compared to the professional men.

When one is freed from all material contamination, any one of the relationships with Krishna is relishable transcendentally. Unfortunately, those who are inexperienced in the transcendental science cannot appreciate these different stages of relationship with the Supreme Lord, and they think that all such different stages of relationship with the Supreme Lord, and all these explanations, are due to Maya. But in Chaitanya Charitamrita, the author has given a very nice practical example of this matter. He states that earth, water, fire, air, and ether are the five elements, and these five elements develop from the subtle form to the grosser form. For example, in the ether there is a characteristic which is called sound. But in the air, there is the characteristic of ether, sound, plus a sensation of touch. When one comes to the fire, there is the characteristic of ether plus the characteristic of air, plus the characteristic which is called form. So, in fire there are three characteristics; similarly, when we come to water, there are four characteristics—namely sound, touch, form and taste. When you go to earth, there are five characteristics, namely sound, touch, form, taste, and smell. As there is a development of different characteristics, beginning from ether down to earth, so, if we analyze the different relationships with Lord Krishna and the devotee, we find that all the five characteristics of the devotional attitude are present in the relationship of conjugal love. Therefore, the relationship with Krishna in conjugal love can only be accepted as the highest perfectional stage of love of God.

There is a nice verse from the Tenth Canto, 82nd Chapter of Srimad Bhagwatam [10.82.44], which can be cited here: “Devotional service for the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the life of every living entity.” And the Lord, addressing the damsels of Vraja, informed them that their love for the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the only cause of their achieving the association of the Lord. It is said that Lord Krishna, in relationship with His devotees, accepts all kinds of devotional service according to the aptitude of each particular devotee, and Krishna also responds to such a devotee in a reciprocal way. For anyone who wants the relationship with Krishna of Master and servant, He plays the part of the perfect Master. For anyone who wants Krishna as his Son, in the parental relationship, Krishna plays the part of the perfect Son. Similarly, if a devotee wants to worship Krishna in conjugal love, Krishna plays the part of husband or paramour in perfection. But He has admitted that His loving relationship with the damsels of Vraja in conjugal love is the highest perfectional stage.

In Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 32nd Chapter [10.32.22], Krishna addressed the Gopis and said, “My dear Gopis, your relationship with Me is completely transcendental, and in exchange for your love, it is not possible for Me to offer anything, even after many births. You have been able to give up all attachment for material enjoyment, and you have searched after Me. I am unable to repay your love; and therefore, be pleased with your own activities.”

Srila Bhakti Siddhanta Saraswati Goswami Maharajhas remarked that there is a class of common men who say as follows: Anyone and everyone can worship the Supreme Lord according to his particular invention of some mode of worship, and he will still achieve the Supreme Personality of Godhead. One may try to approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead, either by fruitive activities or by speculative knowledge or by meditation or by austerity—any one of the methods accepted will help one to reach the perfectional stage. They generally give the example that if anyone wants to reach a certain destination he can accept one of many different paths, and still reach the same place. Similarly, they say the Supreme Absolute Truth may be worshipped either as the Goddess Kali, or the Goddess Durga, or Lord Shiva, or Ganesha, or Rama, or Hari, or Brahma—any way that the Absolute Truth is addressed, it is all one and the same. They give an example in this connection that a man might have different names, but if he is called by any of those names he will answer.

Such explanations by mental concoction might be very pleasing to the ordinary person, but they are full of misconceptions of transcendental life. One who worships different demigods conducted by material lust cannot achieve the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The external energy of the Supreme Lord can award them some result for worshipping the particular demigods, as is stated in the Bhagavad Gita [7.23]: “One who does not worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead directly cannot achieve His association by worshipping the demigods.” The Supreme Personality of Godhead awards the benediction of His association only to persons who worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and not via the demigods. It is not a fact, therefore, that everyone and anyone can reach the Supreme Personality of Godhead by worshipping material demigods. It is surprising, therefore, how a man can imagine he will become perfect by worshipping the demigods. The result of devotional service in full Krishna Consciousness cannot be compared with the result of worshipping different demigods or by functioning in fruitive activities or by mental speculation. The results of fruitive activities are that, either one can go to the heavenly planets, or one can go to hell.

TLC 30-1968: Pure Love For Krishna

Chapter Thirty

Pure Love For Krishna

The difference between executing ordinary religious procedures and devotional service is very great. By executing religious rituals one can achieve the stage of the perfection of material gain, economic development, sense gratification, or liberation—being merged into the existence of the Supreme. But the result of transcendental devotional service is completely different from such temporary benefits of the material condition. Devotional service of the Lord is evergreen, and it is increasingly transcendentally pleasing. Therefore, there is a gulf of difference between the result of devotional service and the result of the four goals of the religious rituals. The great spiritual energy known as Jagatdhatri, or the Superintendent of the material world, or Mahamaya, and the material executive departmental directors, the demigods, and all of the products of the external energy of the Supreme Lord, are perverted reflections of the opulence of the Supreme Lord. They are, practically, order carriers of the Supreme Lord in the material creation and its management. In the Brahma Samhita [5.44, 52, 49] it is stated that the working of the supremely powerful superintendent, Durga, is just like a shadow indication of the Supreme Lord. The sun works just like the eye of the Supreme Lord. Brahma works just as reflected light of the Supreme Lord. In this way, all these demigods, and the external energy herself, Durgadevi, and different departmental directors are servants of the Supreme Lord in the material world.

In the Spiritual World there is another energy, the superior spiritual energy, or internal energy, which acts under the direction of Yogamaya. Yogamaya means the internal potency of the Supreme Lord. She also works under direction, but in the Spiritual World. When the living entity puts himself under the direction of this Yogamaya instead of Mahamaya, the result is that he becomes gradually, causelessly, a devotee of Krishna. On the other hand, those who are after material opulence and the advancement of material happiness put themselves under the care of the material energy, Mahamaya, or under the care of material demigods such as Lord Shiva and others. In the Srimad Bhagwatam it is found that when the Gopis of Vrindaban desired to have Krishna as their husband, they prayed for the gratification of their desire before the spiritual energy, Yogamaya. And in the Shapta Shati it is found that King Shurath and another merchant of the name Samadi, wanted opulence of material existence according to their material mode of Nature—and they worshipped Mahamaya. Therefore, one should not mistakenly equalize Yogamaya and Mahamaya.

There is no difference between the Holy Name of the Supreme Lord and the Supreme Lord Himself, Because the Lord is on the Absolute platform, there is no difference between His Name and Himself, There are different Names of the Supreme Lord, such as Paramatma, the Supersoul, Brahman the Supreme Absolute, Shristikarta the Creator, Narayan the Transcendental Lord, Rukminiraman the husband of Rukmini, Gopinath the Enjoyer of the Gopis, and Krishna. The Lord has different Names, and they have different purposes. When one understands the Supreme Lord as the Creator, He is different from the aspect of the Lord as Narayan. Some of the Names of the Lord as the Creator are the conception of the materialistic men. One cannot fully realize the essence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead by understanding the name of the Creator, because this material creation is the function of the external energy of the Supreme Lord. Such a conception of God includes only the external feature of the Supreme Lord.

Similarly, when we call the Supreme Lord Brahman, we cannot have any understanding of the six full opulences of the Supreme Lord. In the Brahman realization of the Supreme Lord there is no realization of His six opulences in full. Therefore, Brahman realization is not complete understanding of the Supreme Lord, not recognition of eternity, bliss, and knowledge. When we speak of the Supersoul, that is also not a full realization of the Supreme Personality of God; we understand the Supreme Lord by His All-Pervading Nature as a partial representation of His opulence. In our transcendental relationship also, one who is a devotee of Narayan in Vaikuntha, cannot realize the nature of the relationship with Krishna in Goloka Vrindaban. Nor do devotees of Krishna relish the devotional service to Narayan, because devotional service to Krishna is so attractive that such devotees do not desire to worship other forms.

Again, the Gopis of Vrindaban do not like to see Krishna as the Husband of Rukmini, neither do they address Him as Rukminiraman. In Vrindaban, Krishna is addressed as Radha-Krishna, or Krishna the Property of Radharani. In the ordinary sense, although the Husband of Rukmini and Radha’s Krishna are on the same level, still in the Spiritual World the Names are different understandings of different aspects of this Transcendental Personality. If somebody equalized Rukminiraman and Radharaman and Narayan and any other Name of the Supreme Lord as all on the same level, there is the fault of overlapping tastes, which is techically called Rasabhasa. Those who are expert devotees do not accept such amalgamation of different conceptions and aspects of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is against the conclusion of pure devotional service. But when the conceptions are scrutinizingly discriminated, many less intelligent men understand such discrimination as bigotry.

Although Sri Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is Superexcellence and beauty, still, when He is amongst the damsels of Vraja, He is known as Gopijanaballabh; then He becomes the highest perfectional stage for devotees. The devotees cannot relish the beauty of the Supreme Lord more than this. In the Srimad Bhagwatam it is confirmed, in the Tenth Canto, 33rd Chapter [10.33.6], that although Krishna the Son of Devaki is Superexcellence and the last word of beauty, still, when He is amongst the Gopis, it appears that He is a sublime Jewel set amongst divine golden craftsmanship.

Lord Chaitanya accepted this statement of the highest realization of the Supreme Lord as conjugal lover. Still, He requested Ramananda Roy to advance further.

At this request, Ramananda Roy remarked that this was the first time that he was requested to go still further than the Gopis in the matter of understanding Krishna. It has been described that there is certainly a transcendental intimacy between the damsels of Vraja and Krishna, but out of all the Gopis the relationship of Sri Radharani with Krishna in conjugal love is the most perfect stage. No common man can understand the ecstasy of transcendental love between Radharani and Krishna. Neither can he understand the transcendental flavor of the transcendental love between Krishna and the Gopis. But if anyone tries to follow in the footsteps of the Gopis, there is the possibility of becoming situated in the highest stage of such transcendental love. Anyone who wants to be elevated to such a transcendental stage of perfection should follow in the footsteps of the damsels of Vraja as the assistant maid servant of such Gopis. Lord Chaitanya exhibited the mood of Srimati Radharani when She is delegated from Dwarka by Sri Krishna.

Such a mode of transcendental love is not possible for any common man. Therefore, one should not imitate the highest perfectional stage of the loving attitude exhibited by Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. But, if somebody desires to be in that association, they may follow in the footsteps of the Gopis. In the Padma Purana it is stated that, as Radharani is dear to Krishna, similarly the Kunda, known as Radhakunda, is also very dear to Krishna. Radharani is the only selected Gopi who is dearer to Krishna than all the other Gopis. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 30th Chapter [10.30.28], it is also stated that Radharani and the Gopis render the highest perfectional loving service to the Lord, and that the Lord is so pleased with them that He does not wish to go anywhere else to leave the company of Srimati Radharani.

When Lord Chaitanya heard from Ramananda Roy about the loving affairs of Krishna and Radharani, still He requested, “You may go further, on and on.” The Lord said that He was enjoying the description of the loving affairs between Krishna and the Gopis very relishingly, “As if the river of nectar is flowing from your lips.” When Krishna danced amongst all the Gopis, He thought that, “I am not giving any special attention to Radharani.” So, because amongst the other Gopis, Radharani was not so much an object of special love, Krishna stole Her away from the area of the Rasa Dance, and thus exhibited His special favor for Her.

When this was explained by Lord Chaitanya, Ramananda Roy replied, “Now let us relish the transcendental loving affair between Krishna and Radha to which there is no comparison in this material world.” When there was a performance of Rasa Dance, Radharani all of a sudden left the area, as if She was angry that there was no special favor shown to Her. Krishna was desirous to see Radharani in order to fulfill the purpose of the Rasa Dance, but in the absence of Radharani He was sorry, and He went to search Her out. In the Gita Govinda [3.1, 2] there is a nice verse in which it is stated that the enemy of Kansa, Krishna, also wanted to be entangled in love affairs with women, and thus He simply took Radharani, away, and left the company of the other damsels of Vraja.

Krishna was much afflicted by the absence of Radharani and being thus distressed in mind, He began to search out Radharani along the banks of the Yamuna. Failing to find Her, He entered into the bushes of Vrindaban, and began to lament for Radharani. Ramananda Roy said that when we discuss the purport of these two special verses from Srimad Bhagwatam, we can relish the highest nectar of Krishna and Radha’s loving affairs.

Although there were many Gopis to dance with Krishna, still Krishna was pleased to dance with Radharani especially. In the Rasa Dance Krishna placed Himself between each two Gopis, but He was present especially with Radharani.

Radharani was not pleased with the behavior of Krishna, which is described in Ujjal Nilmoni as follows: “The path of loving affairs is just like the movement of a snake; amongst the young lovers there are two kinds of mental features, causeless and causal.” So, when Radharani, out of Her anger for not being treated specially, left the area of the Rasa Dance, Krishna was very sorry not to see Her in the presence of the other Gopis. The perfection of the Rasa Dance was considered to be complete on account of the presence of Radharani, and in Her absence Krishna thought that the Rasa Dance was now disturbed, and therefore He left the arena to search Her out.

After wandering in several places, when He could not find Radharani, He was very distressed in mind; therefore it is understood that Krishna could not enjoy His pleasure potency in the midst of all the Gopis; but in the presence of Radharani He was satisfied.

This transcendental love between Radharani and Krishna was described by Ramananda Roy. Lord Chaitanya admitted that, “I came to you for understanding about the transcendental loving affairs of Krishna and Radha, and I am very much satisfied that you have described it so nicely. I can understand now from your version that this is the highest loving state between Krishna and Radha.” Lord Chaitanya still requested him to try something more: What are the transcendental features of Krishna and the transcendental features of Radharani, and what are the transcendental features of the reciprocation of Their feelings, and what is the love between Them? If you will kindly describe all this to Me, I think I shall be very much obliged, because I know that except for you, nobody can describe such things.”

Ramananda Roy in all humility replied, “I do not know anything, but whatever You are causing me to say I am saying. I know You are Krishna Himself, but still You are relishing hearing about Krishna from me. Therefore, You will excuse me for my faulty expression. I am just trying to express whatever You are causing me to express.”

Lord Chaitanya said, “I am a Mayavadi Sannyasi. I have no knowledge of the transcendental features of devotional service. By the grace of Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya My mind is now clear and I am trying to understand the nature of devotional service to Lord Krishna. He recommended that I see you for understanding Krishna, and he said that Ramananda Roy is the only person who knows something about love of Krishna. I have come to you recommended by Sarbabhouma Bhattacharya, so you should not hesitate to relate to Me all the confidential affairs of Radha and Krishna.”

The example Lord Chaitanya set, before Ramananda Roy, was actually to take the subordinate position. And this has a very great significance. The purport is that, if anyone is serious about understanding the transcendental nature of Krishna, he should approach a person who is actually enriched with Krishna Consciousness. One should not be proud of his material birth, material opulence, material education, and material beauty and thereby try to conquer the mind of an advanced student of Krishna Consciousness. Somebody who goes thus to such an advanced Krishna conscious person, so that he will be induced favorably toward him, is under a misconception regarding this science.

One should approach a Krishna conscious person with all humility, and put relevant questions to him, and not challenge him. If anyone goes to challenge him, such a highly elevated Krishna conscious person will not be available for any tangible service. A challenging, puffed-up person will not be able to gain from a Krishna conscious man, and will continue to remain in the material conception of life. Although Lord Chaitanya was born of a high Brahmin family, and was situated in the highest perfectional stage of Sannyas, still He showed by His behavior that even an elevated person did not hesitate to take lessons from Ramananda Roy, although he appeared to be a householder, and situated in social status beneath that of a Brahmin.

Lord Chaitanya clearly showed that a sincere student never minds whether his spiritual master may be born of a very high grade Brahmin family, or of a Kshatriya family; or he may be a high grade Sannyasi, or a Brahmachary, or whatever status of life. Whoever can teach him about Krishna Science is his Guru.

TLC 31-1968: The Supreme Perfection

Chapter Thirty-one

The Supreme Perfection

Whatever he may be, whatever position He may have, if a person is fully conversant with the science of Krishna, Krishna Consciousness, he can become a bona fide Spiritual Master, initiator, or teacher of the science. In other words, the capability of becoming a bona fide Spiritual Master depends on his sufficient knowledge of the science of Krishna, Krishna Consciousness; it does not depend on a particular position in society or of birth. This conclusion of Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu is not against the Vedic injunction. On the strength of this conclusion, Lord Chaitanya, previously known as Viswambhar, accepted a Spiritual Master, Iswara Puri, who was a sannyasi. Similarly, Lord Nityananda Prabhu also accepted as his Spiritual Master Madavendra Puri, another sannyasi. This Madhavendra Puri is also known as Laksmipati Tirtha. Sri Adwaita Acharya also accepted this Madhavendra Puri as his Spiritual Master. Similarly, another great Acharya, Sri Rasikananda, accepted as his Spiritual Master Sri Shymananda, who was not born of a Brahmin family. So also Ganganarayana-chakravarty accepted as his Spiritual Master Das Gadadhar. In ancient days there was a hunter whose name was Dharma. He also became the Spiritual Master of many persons. There are plain instructions in Mahabharata and Srimad Bhagwatam (Seventh Canto, 11th Chapter [32]) in which it is stated that a person should be accepted—either a Brahmin or a Kshatriya or a Vaishya or a Sudra—by his personal qualification, and not by birth.

And, if such personal qualifications become applicable to a person who is born in a family outside the ordinary field of his actual qualification, he should be accepted by his personal qualification alone. For example, if a man is born of a Brahmin family but his personal qualification is that of a Sudra, then he should be accepted as a Sudra. Similarly, if a person is born of a Sudra family but his personal characteristics are those of a Brahmin, he should be accepted as a Brahmin. All Shastric injunctions, and the version of great sages and authorities—and their practical behavior as well—establish that a bona fide Spiritual Master is not necessarily of the caste Brahmin class. The only qualification is that he must be conversant in the science of Krishna, Krishna Consciousness. That will make him perfectly eligible to become a Spiritual Master. That is the conclusion of Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu in His discussions with Ramananda Roy.

In the Hari Bhakti Vilasa [2.12] there is the statement that, if there is a bona fide Spriritual Master born of a Brahmin family, and another who is qualified but born of a Sudra family, one should accept the Spiritual Master who is born of the Brahmin family, and not of the Sudra family. This statement is somewhat of a compromise to social understanding; but is not meant for spiritual understanding. For persons who prefer to count social status as more important than spiritual status, this injunction of the Hari Bhakti Vilasa is applicable. But not for the persons who are spiritually serious. For a person spiritually serious, the instruction of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu is that anyone—never mind what he is—if he is conversant with Krishna science must be accepted as the Spiritual Master.

There are many injunctions in the Padma Puräëa which state as follows: a highly elevated, spiritually advanced devotee of the Lord is always a first class devotee, and therefore he is a Spiritual Master. But a highly elevated person born in a Brahmin family, who is not a devotee of the Lord, cannot be a Spiritual Master. A person born in a Brahmin family may be conversant with all the rituals of the Vedic Scripture, but if he is not a pure devotee of the Lord, he cannot be a Spiritual Master. In all the Shastras, the chief qualification of a bona fide Spiritual Master is that he must be a qualified person conversant in the science of Krishna.

Lord Chaitanya therefore requested Ramananda Roy to go on teaching Him, and not to hesitate about speaking on the science of Krishna because Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu was a sannyasi in the renounced order of life. He requested him to go on speaking on the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna.

Ramananda Roy then humbly submitted: “Because You are asking me to speak on the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna, of course I must obey Your order, and whatever You would like me to say, I will speak in that way.” Ramananda Roy humbly submitted himself as a puppet, and Lord Chaitanya was the puppeteer. So, he wanted to dance according to the will of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. He expressed that his tongue was just like a string instrument, and “You are the player of the string instrument.” So, as Lord Chaitanya would play, Ramananda Roy would vibrate the sound.

He said that Lord Krishna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Source of all incarnations, and the Cause of all causes. There are innumerable Vaikuntha planets, and there are innumerable incarnations and expansions of the Supreme Lord, and there are innumerable universes also. Of all these existences the Supreme Lord Krishna is the only Source. His transcendental Body is composed of eternity and blissfulness and knowledge, and He is known as the Son of Maharaj Nanda, or as the Inhabitant of Goloka Vrindaban; He is full with six opulences—namely, all wealth, all strength, all fame, all beauty, all knowledge, and all renunciation.

In the Brahma Samhita, Fifth Chapter, 1st verse, it is confirmed that Krishna is the Supreme Lord, He is the Lord of all lords, and His transcendental Body is Sat-chit-ananda. And no one is the Source of Krishna, but Krishna is the Source of everyone. He is the Supreme Cause of all causes. He is Resident of Vrindaban, and very attractive, just like Cupid. One can worship Him by Kam Gayatri Mantra.

The description of Vrindaban is stated in the Brahma Samhita as follows: the transcendental land of Vrindaban is always spiritual. That spiritual land is full of Goddesses of Fortune, who are known as Gopis; and they are all beloved of Krishna, and Krishna is the only Lover of all those Gopis. The trees of that land are all desire trees: you can have anything you want from any tree. The land is made of touchstone, and the water is nectar, and all speech is song, and all walking is dancing, and the constant companion is the flute. Everything is self-illuminated, just as we experience the sun and the moon in this material world.

The human form of life is meant for understanding this transcendental land of Vrindaban, and one who is fortunate should cultivate knowledge of Vrindaban and the residents of Vrindaban.

In that Supreme Abode, there are the Surabhi cows, who are overflooding the land with milk. In that land, the Supreme Abode of Krishna, even a moment is not misused. Therefore, there is no past, present or future. An expansion of that Vrindaban, the Supreme Abode of Krishna, is here also on this Earth. Superior devotees worship this earthly Vrindaban as being as good as the Supreme Abode Vrindaban. Nobody can appreciate Vrindaban without being highly elevated in spiritual knowledge, Krishna Consciousness. Vrindaban in ordinary experience appears to be just like ordinary land; but in the eyes of a highly elevated devotee, it is as good as the original Vrindaban. A great saintly person, an Acharya, has expressed this in his song: “When will my mind be cleared of all dirty things, and when shall I be able to see Vrindaban as It is? And when shall I be able to understand the literature left by the Goswamins—so that I will be able to understand the transcendental Pastimes of Radha and Krishna?”

The loving affairs in Vrindaban between Krishna and the Gopis are also transcendental. They appear to be like the ordinary lust of this material world, but there is a gulf of difference between the moods of Vrindaban and this material world. In the material world there may be the temporary awakening of lust, but it disappears after so-called satisfaction. But in the Spiritual World the love between the Gopis and Krishna is constantly going on, and it is increasing at every moment. That is the difference between the love of the transcendental world, and the lust of the material world. The lust of so-called love arising out of this body, is as temporary as the body itself But the love in the Spiritual World is on the spiritual platform, and the spirit soul is eternal. And so that love is also eternal. Therefore, Krishna is addressed as the evergreen Cupid.

Lord Krishna is worshipped by the Gayatri Mantra, and the specific Mantra is called Kamagayatri. The explanation of the Kamagayatri Mantra is stated in the Vedic literature: that sound vibration which can elevate one from mental concoction is called Gayatri. The Kamagayatri Mantra is composed of 241/2 syllables, and is stated as follows:

Klim kamadevaya vidmahe puspavanaya dheemahi tanna’ nanga prachodayat.

This Kamagayatri is received from the Spiritual Master when a disciple is far advanced by chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare. In other words, this Kamagayatri Mantra and Sanksar, or reformation of a perfect Brahmin, are offered by the Spiritual Master to a student when he sees that the disciple is advanced in spiritual knowledge. Even such Kamagayatri is not uttered under certain circumstances. Still, the chanting of Hare Krishna is sufficient to elevate one to the highest spiritual platform.

In the Brahma Samhita there is a nice description of the flute of Krishna. The purport of the description is thus: “When Krishna began to play on His flute, the sound vibration entered into the ear of Brahma as the Vedic Mantra, OM. This OM is composed of three letters: A, U, and M, or a description of our relationship with the Supreme Lord. It describes our activities to achieve the highest perfection of love, and the actual position of the loving condition in the spiritual platform. When the sound vibration of Krishna’s flute became expressed through the mouth of Brahma, it became Gayatri. Therefore, being influenced by the sound vibration of the flute of Krishna, Brahma, the supreme creature and first living entity of this material world, was initiated as a Brahmin.

This remark on Brahma’s becoming a Brahmin, initiated by the flute of Krishna, is confirmed by Srila Jiva Goswami. When Brahma was enlightened by the Gayatri Mantra through the flute of Krishna, he became possessed of all Vedic knowledge. He acknowledged the benediction offered to him by Krishna, and thus he became the original Spiritual Master of all living entities.

The word Klim added to the Gayatri Mantra is explained in Brahma Samhita as the transcendental seed of love of Godhead, or the seed of the Kamagayatri. The object is Krishna, Who is the evergreen Cupid. And, by utterance of Klim Mantra, Krishna is worshipped. In the Gopal Tapini Upanishad, it is further stated that when we speak of Krishna as Cupid we should not misunderstand that He is the Cupid of this material world. As we have explained, Vrindaban is the Spiritual Abode of Krishna, and so this word Cupid is also spiritual and transcendental. One should not misunderstand the material Cupid and Krishna as being on the same level. Material Cupid is the attraction of this external flesh and body, but the spiritual Cupid is the attraction of the Supersoul upon the individual soul.

Actually, lust and the sex urge are there in spiritual life, but because the spirit soul is now embodied in material elements, that spiritual urge is expressed through this material body; and therefore it is pervertedly reflected. When one becomes actually conversant in the science of Krishna Consciousness, he can understand that his material affection of sex life is abominable, whereas spiritual sex life is desirable.

Spiritual sex life is of two kinds: one completely in the constitutional position of the self, and the other according to the object. When one has understood the truth about this life but is not completely out of the material contamination, then, although there is an understanding of spiritual life, he is not factually situated in the transcendental Abode, Vrindaban. When, however, one becomes free from all bodily sex urges, he is actually situated in the Supreme Abode of Vrindaban. When one is situated in that stage of life, the Kamagayatri and Kamavija Mantra can be uttered by the student.

Ramananda Roy then explained that Krishna is Attractive both for men and women, for the movable and the immovable—for all living entities. Therefore, He is called the transcendental Cupid. And He quoted a verse from Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 32nd Chapter [10.32.2], where the Lord appeared before the damsels of Vraja just like Cupid, while smiling and playing His flute.

There are different kinds of devotees of the Lord, and they have different aptitudes and relationships with the Supreme Lord. Any kind of relationship with the Supreme Lord is as good as any other, because the central point is Krishna. In the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu there is a nice verse in this connection, which states as follows: “Krishna is the Reservoir of all pleasure, and by the spiritual luster of His Body, He is always attracting the Gopis, especially Taraka, Pali, Shyama, and Lalita. Krishna is very dear to Radharani, the foremost Gopi.” Like Krishna, the Gopis were glorified by His Pastime activities. In other words, there are different kinds of specific relationships with Krishna, and anyone who is attracted to Krishna by a particular flavor is glorified.

Krishna is so beautiful and transcendental, and so attractive, that sometimes He becomes attractive to Himself. There is a very nice verse in Gita Govinda: “My dear friend, do you see how Krishna is enjoying His transcendental Pastimes in the springtime, by expanding the beauty of His Personal Body? And, just like the most beautiful moon, His soft legs and hands are being used on the bodies of the Gopis, and He is embracing them by different parts of the body, and thus He is so beautiful! Krishna is so beautiful that He is attractive even to Narayan, and not only to Narayan—He is also attracting the Goddesses of Fortune who associate with Narayan.”

In Srimad Bhagwatam [10.89.58] there is a nice verse in this connection. The Bhuma Purusa said to Krishna, “My dear Krishna and Arjuna, just to see You I have brought the Brahmins before You.” This is in connection with Arjuna’s attempt to save some youths, who he heard had died untimely at Dwarka. And when he failed to save them, Krishna took him to the Bhuma Purusa, and when the Bhuma Purusa brought forth those dead bodies as living entities he expressed his feelings in the following words: “Both of You appeared for the preservation of religious principles in this world, and to annihilate the demoniac persons.” In other words, the Bhuma Purusa was also attracted by the beauty of Krishna, and under some pretext He wanted to see Krishna and this Pastime was invented by him. There is another nice verse in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 16th Chapter [10.16.36], in which it is stated, “My dear Lord, we cannot estimate how this fallen snake got the opportunity of being kicked by Your Lotus Feet, for which even the Goddess of Fortune underwent austerities for several years—just to see You.” This was spoken by the wife of Kaliya, in connection with Kaliya’s punishment by Krishna.

How Krishna is attracted by His own beauty is also stated in the Laleeta Madhav, Eighth Chapter, 20th verse. Krishna, by seeing His own picture, is lamenting, “How nice this picture is, how glorious this picture is. I am also becoming attracted just like Radhika is attracted by this picture.” Krishna was attracted as much as Radhika, or Radharani, was when She saw the picture.

Thus, Ramananda Roy explained about the beauty of Krishna in summary.

He again began to speak about the spiritual energy of Krishna, headed by Srimati Radharani. It is said that Krishna has immense expansions of energy, out of which three energies are predominant: one is called internal energy, the second is called external energy, and the third is called marginal energy, or the living entity. This is confirmed in the Vishnu Purana, 6th Chapter [6.7.61]: Vishnu has one energy, which is called spiritual energy, and it is manifested in three ways. When spiritual energy is overwhelmed by ignorance, that is called marginal energy. So far as spiritual energy is concerned—because Krishna is a combination of eternity, bliss, and knowledge, the spiritual energy is also exhibited in three forms. So far as Krishna’s bliss and peacefulness are concerned, His spiritual energy is manifested as pleasure-giving potency, His eternity is manifestive energy, and His knowledge is manifested as spiritual perfection. It is confirmed in the Vishnu Purana, First Canto, 12th Chapter [1.12.69]: “The pleasure potency of Krishna can give Krishna transcendental pleasure and bliss.” Therefore, when Krishna wants to enjoy pleasure, He exhibits His own spiritual potency, known as Alhadini.

Krishna in His Spiritual From enjoys the spiritual energy, and that is the sum and substance of the Radha Krishna Pastime. These Radha Krishna Pastimes can be understood by elevated devotees only. From the ordinary platform one should not try to understand this Radha Krishna Potency, and their Pastimes. People only misunderstand it as being material.

When the pleasure potency is further condensed, it is called Mahabhava. Srimati Radharani, the eternal Consort of Krishna is a personification of that Mahabhava. This Mahabhava representation is explained by Rupa Goswami in his book Ujjal Nilmoni [4.3] in the Second Canto, 2nd Sloka. It is stated there, that although there were two competitors in love of Krishna, Radharani and Chandravali; still, by comparison, it appears that Radharani is the best, and She is possessed of the Mahabhava Svarupa. Therefore, this Mahabhava Svarupa, or personification, is applicable to Radharani only, and no one else.

Mahabhava is full of the pleasure potency, and is an exhibition of the highest attitude of love towards Krishna. She is therefore known throughout the world as the Most Beloved of Krishna. And Her name is always associated with Krishna, as Radha Krishna.

Brahma Samhita [5.37] also confirms this: Krishna expands Himself by His pleasure potency in the Spiritual World, and the potencies are all non-different from Krishna in the Absolute. Krishna, although He is always enjoying the company of His expansions of the pleasure potency, is All-pervading. Therefore, Brahma offers his respectful obeisances to Govinda, the Cause of all causes.

As Krishna is the highest emblem of spiritual perfection, so Radharani is the highest emblem of the spiritual pleasure potency meant for satisfying Krishna. Krishna is unlimited, and so Radharani is also unlimited, for His satisfaction. Krishna is satisfied by seeing Radharani, but Radharani also expands Herself in such a way that Krishna still wants to enjoy more. And, because Krishna was unable to estimate the pleasure potency of Radharani, He wanted to accept the role of Radharani. That combination is called Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.

Ramananda Roy then began to explain that Radharani is therefore the supreme emblem of the pleasure potency of Krishna. And Radharani expands Herself into different forms, known as Lalita Visakha and Her confidential associates. The Characteristics of Srimati Radharani are explained by Rupa Goswami in his book Uijal Nilmoni, and they can be understood as follows: The body of Radharani is an evolution of transcendental pleasure. That body is decorated with flowers and fragrant aromas, complete with transcendental love for Krishna. That is the personification. That transcendental body takes birth three times: first in the water of mercy, second in the water of useful beauty, and third in the water of youthful luster. After taking birth three times in that way, covered with shining garments and decorated with His Personal beauty, which is compared with cosmetics (Her beauty being the highest artistry) Her body is decorated with ornaments of the ecstasies of spiritual emotion—trembling, tears, checking of the body in transcendental pleasure, stopping of all functions of the body, perspiration, choking of the voice, blood pressure, madness, and stumbling.

There are nine symptoms of decorative transcendental pleasure potency.

Five are by Her expansion of personal beauty, decorated with garlands of flowers; and Her patient calmness is compared with a covering of cloths, cleansed by camphor. Her confidential agony for Krishna is the knot of Her hair, and the mark of telok on Her forehead is Her fortune. The hearing of Radharani is fixed on Krishna’s Name and Fame, eternally. By chewing betal nuts the lips become reddish. Similarly, the complete attachment of Radharani to Krishna has blackened the border of Her eyes. It can be compared to ointment, due to Nature joking with Radha and Krishna. Her smiling is just like the taste of camphor. The garland of separation moves on Her body when She lies down on the bed of pride, within the room of aroma. Her breast is covered by the blouse of anger, out of ecstatic affection for Krishna; and a stringed instrument is Hers for Her reputation of being the best amongst all the girlfriends of Krishna. She puts Her hand on the shoulder of His youthful posture. Although She possesses so many transcendental qualities, still She is always engaged in the service of Krishna.

Srimati Radharani is decorated with Suddipta Sattvik emotions, which include sometimes tribulation, sometimes pacification. All these transcendental ecstasies are symptoms of the body of Srimati Radharani. Suddipta Sattvik emotion is when a lover is overwhelmed with certain kinds of feelings which he or she cannot check. Radharani has another emotion which is called Kilakinchita. This Kilakinchita emotion has twenty different manifestations. Such manifestations are partly due to the body, due to the mind, and due to habit. So far as the bodily emotions are concerned, they are called posture and movement. So far as the emotions of the mind are concerned, they are the exposition of beauty, luster, complexion, mellows, talking, magnanimity and patience. As far as habitual emotions are concerned, they are pastimes, enjoyment, preparation, forgetfulness.

Jhere is the fortune telok on the forehead of Srimati Radharani, and She has a locket of Premvaichittya. Premvaichittya is the symptom of a lover that occurs when the lover and the beloved meet together, and still have a fear of separation.

Srimati Radharani is fifteen days younger than Krishna. She always keeps Her hand on the shoulder of Her friends; and She is always talking and thinking of Pastimes with Krishna. She always offers Krishna, by Her sweet talks, a kind of intoxication. She is always prepared to fulfill all the desires of Sri Krishna. In other words, She is the supply source for all the demands of Sri Krishna, and She is qualified with unnatural or uncommon qualities for the satisfaction of Krishna.

There is a nice verse in the Govinda Lilamrita [11.122] in which is stated as follows: “Who is the breeding ground of Krishna’s affection? The answer is, it is only Srimati Radhika. Who is the most dear lovable object of Krishna? The answer is, it is only Srimati Radhika, and nobody else.” Sheen in the hair and a moistness in the eyes, and firmness in the breast—all these qualities are there in Srimati Radhika. Therefore only Srimati Radhika is able to fulfill all the desires of Krishna, and nobody else can.

Sottabhama is another competitor of Srimati Radharani, but she always desires to come to the standard of Srimati Radharani. Srimati Radharani is so expert in every affair that all the damsels of Vraja come and learn all those arts from Her. She is so extraordinarily beautiful that even the Goddess of Fortune and Parvati, the wife of Lord Shiva, also desire to be elevated to the standard of Srimati Radharani’s beauty. Arundhuthi, who is known as the most chaste lady in the universe, desires to learn the standard of chastity from Srimati Radharani. Even Lord Krishna cannot estimate the highly transcendental qualities of Srimati Radharani; and therefore it is not possible for any ordinary man to estimate those qualities.

Lord Chaitanya, after hearing from Sri Ramananda Roy about the qualities of Srimati Radharani and Krishna, desired to hear from him about the reciprocal exchange of love between Radharani and Krishna. Krishna is described by Ramananda Roy as Dhirlalita, and He is always engaged in love affairs with Radharani. Dhirlalita describes a person who is very cunning and youthful, and always expert in joking, without any anxiety, and always subservient to his girlfriend. This Krishna is always engaged in the bushes of Vrindaban to enjoy lusty activities with Radharani, and thus He successfully carried out the instincts of lust.

In the Bhakti Rasamrita Sindhu there is a very nice verse in connection with the dealings of Radha and Krishna, and it is said there: “This Krishna, by His impudent and daring talks about sex indulgence, obliged Srimati Radhika to close her eyes and taking the opportunity of the closed eyes of Srimati Radharani, Krishna painted many pictures on the breasts of Radharani, which was the subject matter for joking for the friends of Radharani. Krishna was always engaged in such lustful activities, and thus He made successful His primary youthful life.”

On hearing of these transcendental activities between Radha and Krishna, Lord Chaitanya said, “My dear Ramananda, what you have explained about the transcendental Pastimes of Sri Radha and Krishna is perfectly right, but still there must be something more I should like to hear from you.”

On hearing this, Ramananda Roy said, “It is very difficult for me to express anything beyond this. But I can only say that there is an emotional activity which is called Prembilasa Bivarta. I may try to explain the Prembilasa. I do not know whether You will be happy to hear it, but I must explain it toYou.” In the Prembilasa emotion there are two kinds of emotional activities, which are called separation and meeting. That transcendental separation is so acute that it becomes more ecstatic than meeting. Ramananda Roy was expert in understanding such highly elevated dealings between Radha and Krishna, and he composed a very nice song which he narrated to the Lord. The purport of that song is as follows: the lover and the beloved, before their meeting, by the exchange of their transcendental activities, generate a kind of emotion. That emotion is called Raga, or attraction. Srimati Radharani expressed Her willingness, that “This attraction and affection between Ourselves has risen to the highest extent”—but the cause of such attraction is Radharani Herself. “Whatever the cause may be, that affection between Yourself and Myself,” said Radharani, “has mixed Us in oneness. Now it is the time of separation, so I cannot see the history of the evolution of this love between You and Me. There was no other cause or mediator in Our love, the only cause was Our meeting and visionary exchange of feelings.”

This exchange of feelings between Krishna and Radharani is very difficult to understand, unless one is elevated onto the pure platform of goodness. Such transcendental reciprocation between Radha and Krishna is not possible to understand even on the platform of material goodness. One has to transcend even material goodness in order to understand. Such an exchange of feelings between Radha and Krishna is not any subject matter of the material world. Even the highest mental speculators cannot understand this, directly or indirectly. Material activities are manifested either for the gross body or the subtle mind, but this exchange of feeling between Radha and Krishna is beyond such intellectual mental speculation. This transcendental subject matter can be understood by purified senses, freed from all the designations of the material world.

Purified senses can understand these transcendental features, but those who are impersonalists, who have no knowledge of spiritual senses, can simply discriminate within the scope of the material senses, and cannot understand the spiritual exchange or spiritual-sensual activities. Persons who are elevated in experimental knowledge can simply satisfy their blunt material senses, either by gross bodily activities or by mental speculation. Everything generated from the body or the mind is always imperfect and perishable, but transcendental spiritual activity is always bright and wonderful. Pure love on the transcendental platform is the symbol of purity—this means without any material affection, or completely spiritual. Affection for matter is perishable, therefore the inebriety of sex is there in the material world, but there is no such inebriety in the Spiritual World. Hindrances in the performance of sense satisfaction are the cause of material distress, and that is not exactly comparable with spiritual separation. In spiritual separation there is no inebriety or ineffectiveness as with matter.

Lord Chaitanya admitted that this is the highest position of transcendental loving reciprocation, and He said to Ramananda Roy, “By your grace only I have been able to understand such a high transcendental position. This transcendental position cannot be achieved without the performance of transcendental activities; so would you kindly explain to Me how I can raise Myself to this platform?”

Ramananda replied, “It is similarly difficult for me to make You understand, but so far as I am concerned, I can speak what You would like me to say before You. For no one can escape Your Supreme Will. There is nobody in the world who can surpass Your Supreme Will, and although I appear to be speaking, I am not actually the speaker—You are speaking. Therefore, You are both the speaker and the audience. Let me speak as You will me to speak, about the performance required to achieve this highest transcendental position.” Ramananda Roy then began:

The transcendental activities of Radha and Krishna are very confidential. They are not to be understood in the emotional relationship of master and servant, friend and friend, or parent and son to the Supreme Lord. This confidential subject matter can be understood in the association of the damsels of Vraja, because such confidential activities have arisen from the feelings and emotions of those damsels. Without the association of Vraja, no one can nourish or cherish such transcendental understanding. In other words, these confidential Pastimes of Radha and Krishna have expanded through the mercy of the damsels—and without their mercy we cannot understand. One has to adopt this life, to follow in the footsteps of the damsels of Vraja, and then one can understand.

When one is actually situated in that understanding, he is eligible to enter into the confidential Pastimes of Radha and Krishna. There is no other alternative way to understand this confidential part of the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna. This is confirmed in the Govinda Lilamrita [10.17], in a verse which reads as follows: “The emotional exchanges of Radha and Krishna, although manifest and very happy and expanded and unlimited, are limited for understanding to the damsels of Vraja only, or to their followers.” As no one can understand the expansion of spiritual energy of the Supreme Lord without the causeless mercy of the Supreme Lord, similarly, no one can understand the transcendental sex life between Radha and Krishna without following in the footsteps of the damsels of Vraja. There are different names for the associates of Radharani: they are called Shaktis, or personal associates, and also the Manjarys, the near assistants.

It is very difficult to express their dealings with Krishna, as they have no desire to mix with or to enjoy Krishna Personally. But they are always ready to help Radharani be with Krishna. Their affection for Krishna and Radharani is so pure that they are simply satisfied when Radha and Krishna are together, and they simply enjoy the transcendental pleasure of seeing Radha and Krishna combined, united. The actual form of Radharani is just like a creeper embracing the tree of Krishna. The damsels of Vraja, the associates of Radharani, are just like the leaves and flowers of the creeper. And when the creeper embraces the tree, automatically the leaves and flowers also take the opportunity to embrace the tree, along with the creeper.

This is confirmed in the Govinda Lilamrita [10.16] as follows: Radharani is expressed as the expansion of the pleasure potency of Krishna. As She is compared with the creeper, Her associates, the damsels of Vraja, are just like the flowers and and leaves of that creeper. When Radharani and Krishna enjoy Themselves, the damsels of Vraja enjoy the pleasure more than Radharani Herself. Although the associates of Radharani do not expect any personal attention from Krishna, still Radharani is so pleased with Her associates that She arranges a meeting of Krishna and the damsels of Vraja, individually. By many transcendental maneuvers, Radharani tries to combine or unite the associates with Krishna. Radharani takes more pleasure in these meetings than in Her own affairs. And, when Krishna sees that both Radharani and Her associates are pleased by His association, He becomes more satisfied. Such association and reciprocation of love has nothing to do with material lust, but because it resembles such unification between man and woman, or the similarity to the combination of man and woman is there, therefore sometimes it is called, in transcendental language, transcendental lust.

In Goutamiyatantra this combination of Radharani and Her relationships with Krishna is explained as follows: “Lust means that one is attached to one’s personal sense gratification. But, so far as the associates of Radharani and Radharani Herself are concerned, They had no desire for Their personal sense gratification. They want only to satisfy Krishna.” In the Srimad Bhagwatam this is further confirmed in the Tenth Canto, 31st Chapter [10.31.19], when the Gopis or damsels of Vraja were talking among themselves, as follows: “My dear Friend, Krishna, You are now roaming in the forest with Your bare feet, which You may sometimes keep on our breasts, and although we keep Your Foot on our breasts, still we think that our breasts are so hard, and Your sole is so soft. Now You are wandering in the forest, traversing over the particles of stones; and we do not know how You are feeling, because You are our life and soul. And so Your displeasure in travelling over the rough stone is giving us much distress.” Such feelings of the damsels of Vraja, are the highest emotions of Krishna Consciousness, and anyone who becomes captivated by Krishna Consciousness approaches this highest level of the Gopis.

There are sixty-four kinds of devotional service, and by performing these regulative principles one can rise up to the stage of this unconditional devotion of the Gopis. Affection for Krishna exactly on the level of the Gopis is called Raganuga, spontaneous love. In that spontaneous loving affair with Krishna, there is no necessity of following the Vedic rules and regulations.

There are different kinds of personal devotees of Lord Krishna in the transcendental Abode. For example, the servants of Krishna known as Raktak and Bhadrak are friends of Krishna, just like Sridham and Subhad; and there are parents of Krishna, just like Nanda and Yasoda, who are also engaged in the service of Krishna in their different transcendental emotions. One who desires to enter into the Supreme Abode of Krishna may take shelter of one of the above transcendental servitors, and then execute loving service in such a way as to achieve the highest result of transcendental affection with Krishna at the end. In other words, the devotee in this material world who executes loving service in pursuance of the activities of those eternal associates of Krishna also achieves the same post when he is perfect.

The sages who are known in the Upanishads and in Sruti also desire the post of the Gopis, and they also follow in the footsteps of the Gopis in order to achieve that highest goal of life. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 86th Chapter [10.87.23], as follows: The sages practice Pranayam, a trance, by controlling the breathing process and the mind and the senses, by the mystic Yoga practice. And thus try to enter into the Supreme Brahman, or be merged into the Supreme. The same thing is also obtained by persons who, atheist by Nature, fight the principle of the existence of God; if they are killed by an incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, they also achieve the same result, or merging into the Brahman existence of the Supreme Lord. But the damsels of Vrindaban worship Sri Krishna, being bitten by Him as a person is bitten by a snake, because Krishna’s body is compared with the body of a snake. The snake’s body never goes straight but it always curling, and as Krishna stands always in three-curved postures, He is compared to the snake. This snake, Krishna, had bitten the Gopis with transcendental love, and they were in a better position than all the mystic Yogis or the persons who desired to merge into the Supreme Brahman. Therefore, the sages of Dundakarannya also follow in the footsteps of the damsels of Vraja, in order to achieve a similar position. By a simple execution of the regular principles one cannot achieve that position; not unless and until one is seriously following the principles of the Gopis. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 9th Chapter [10.9.21], by a verse in which it is stated that Lord Sri Krishna, the Son of Srimati Yasoda, is not so easily available to persons following the principles of mental speculation. But He is very easily available for all kinds of living beings who follow the path of devotional service.

There are many pseudo devotional parties claiming to belong to Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu’s sect. Such pseudo devotional parties in the sect of Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, dress themselves up artificially as the damsels of Vraja. This sort of dressing is not approved by advanced spiritualists or advanced students of devotional service. Such dressing of the outward material body is another foolishness of the concept of the body being the soul. They are mistaken in considering that the spiritual body of Krishna and Radharani and their associates, the damsels of Vraja, are of material Nature. One should know perfectly that all such manifestations are expansions of eternal bliss and knowledge in the transcendental world. They have nothing to do with this material body. Therefore, the body, the dress, the decoration, and the activities of the damsels of Vrindaban do not belong to this material cosmic manifestation. Such damsels of Vrindaban are not subject matter for the attraction of persons who are in the material world. They are the transcendental attraction for the All-Attractive. Krishna is All-Attractive—therefore His name is “Krishna.” But the damsels of Vrajabhumi, Vrindaban, are attractive even to Krishna. Therefore, they are not anything of this material world.

If somebody wrongly thinks that this material body is as perfect as the spiritual body, and thus begins to worship by imitating the damsels of Vrindaban, he becomes part and parcel of the Mayavadi or impersonal philosophy. The impersonalists also recommend a process of Aham Grahapasana. This process recommends that one should worship his own body as the Supreme. By this material way of thinking, the pseudo transcendentalists dress themselves as the damsels of Vraja; but they are to be taken as the Aham Grahapasana, and are not acceptable in devotional service.

Srila Jiva Goswami, the most authentic Acharya of the Gaudiya Sampradaya, has condemned this attempt by imitators. The process of transcendental realization is to follow in the footsteps of the associates of the Supreme Lord, Krishna. And so, to think of oneself as one of the direct associates of the Supreme Lord is also condemned. The process, according to authorized Vaishnava principles, is that one should follow a particular devotee and not think of himself an associate.

Sri Ramananda Roy explained, therefore, that one should accept the mood of the damsels of Vraja. In Chaitanya Charitamrita it is clearly said that one should accept the emotional activities, and not imitate the dress, of the associates of Krishna, the damsels of Vraja. One should always think within himself about the dealings of Radha and Krishna in the transcendental world. He should think of Radha and Krishna all twenty-four hours, and be engaged in Their service within himself; not externally change his dress only. This is called the mood of the associates of friends of Radharani; and, by following the associates of Radharani, one can ultimately achieve the perfectional stage of being transferred to Goloka Vrindaban, the transcendental Abode of Krishna.

This mood of emotional pursuit of the Gopis is called Siddhadeha. Siddhadeha means the pure spiritual body which is beyond the senses, mind, and intelligence. Siddhadeha is the purified soul; and is just suitable for serving the Supreme Lord. No one can serve the Supreme Lord as His associate without being situated in that perfectly pure spiritual identity. That identity is completely free from all material contamination. It is stated in the Bhagavad Gita that a person materially contaminated transmigrates to another material body by material consciousness. At the time of death he thinks in that way, and therefore is transferred to another material body. Similarly, when one is situated in his pure spiritual identity, and thinks of spiritual loving service rendered to the Supreme Lord, he is transferred into the Spiritual Kingdom, to enter into the association of Krishna. In other words, to think of Krishna and His associates in the spiritual identity is the qualification for transference to the Spriritual Kingdom.

No one can contemplate or think of the activities of the Spiritual Kingdom without being situated in pure spiritual identity. That pure spiritual identity is called Siddhadeha. Ramananda Roy therefore expressed himself to the effect that, without attending to that Siddhadeha, no one can become an associate of the damsels, or render service directly to the Personality of Godhead, Krishna, and His eternal consort, Radharani. He quoted, in this connection, a nice verse from the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 47th Chapter [10.47.60], in which is stated the following: “Neither the Goddess of Fortune, Lakshmi, nor even the damsels of the Heavenly Kingdom could attain the facilities of the damsels of Vrajabhumi—and what to speak of others?”

Lord Chaitanya was very satisfied upon hearing this statement from Ramananda Roy, and He embraced him. Both of them began to cry in ecstasy in that transcendental realization. Both the Lord and Ramananda Roy discussed throughout the whole night the transcendental Pastimes of Radharani and Krishna, and in the morning They separated. Ramananda left to go to his place, and the Lord went to take His bath.

At the time of separation, Ramananda Roy fell down at the feet of Lord Chaitanya and prayed as follows: “My dear Lord, You have come just to deliver me from this mire of nescience. Therefore I request that You may remain here at least for ten days, and You can purify my mind of this material contamination. There is nobody else who can deliver such transcendental love of God.”

The Lord replied, “I have come to you to purify Myself by hearing from you of the transcendental Pastimes of Krishna and Radha; and I am so fortunate, for you are the only teacher of such transcendental Pastimes. I do not find anyone else in this world who can realize this transcendental loving reciprocation between Radha and Krishna. You are requesting Me to stay here for ten days, but I feel that I wish to remain with you for the rest of My life. Please come toJagannath Puri, My headquarters, and We may remain together for the rest of My life, and I can pass My remaining days in understanding Krishna and Radha by your association.”

Sriman Ramananda Roy came to see the Lord the next day in the evening, and there were discourses on this transcendental subject matter. And the Lord again began to inquire from Ramananda Roy, as follows: “What is the highest standard of education?” Ramananda Roy immediately replied that the highest standard of education is to know the science of Krishna. The standard of material education is sense gratification, but the standard of spiritual education, especially the highest standard, is to know the science of Krishna. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Fourth Canto, 29th Chapter, 47th verse, it is stated that work which pleases the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the highest standard of work, and the science or knowledge which places one in full Krishna Consciousness is the highest standard of knowledge. Similarly, Prahlad Maharaj, while instructing his childhood friends at school, also stated that hearing or chanting of the Lord, remembering, worshipping, praying, serving, making friendship with Krishna and offering everything to Him, is to be understood as the highest standard of spiritual knowledge. Then Lord Chaitanya asked Ramananda Roy, “What is the highest standard of reputation?” Ramananda Roy immediately replied that if a person is famous by a reputation of Krishna Consciousness, he is to be called the most famous man in the world. In other words, if a man is known as Krishna conscious, he is the greatest, most famous of men.

TLC 32-1968: Conclusion

Chapter Thirty-two

Conclusion

One who is famous as the man of Krishna Consciousness has eternal fame. In the material world, everyone is after three things: he wants his name to be perpetuated, he wants his fame to be broadcast all over the world, and he wants some profit out of his material activities. But he does not know that all this material name, fame, and profit belong to this temporary body; and, as soon as the body is finished, all name, fame and profit are finished. Due to ignorance, everyone is after name, fame and profit in connection with this body. But to become very famous in connection with this body, or to become known as a man of spiritually developed consciousness, without any knowledge of the Supreme Spirit, Vishnu, must be deprecated. Real fame is if one attains Krishna Consciousness in this very life.

According to Srimad Bhagwatam, there are twelve authorities. They are famous because they were all great devotees of the Lord—Brahma, Narada, Lord Shiva, Manu, Kapila, Prahlad, Janaka, Bhisma, Sukadeva Goswami, Bali, Jamaraja and the Kumaras. All these great stalwarts are devotees of the Lord, and therefore they are still remembered.

In the Garuda Purana there is a verse in which it is said that, instead of be coming a demigod such as Brahma or Lord Shiva, if one becomes a famous devotee of the Supreme Lord in this Age of Kali, that is very rare. Yudhisthira also, in connection with talks between Narada and Pundarik, said, “After many, many births, if somebody comes to understand that he is the servant of Vasudeva, that person is the most famous, and can deliver all others. Similarly, in the Bhagavad Gita [7.19] it said, “Anyone who understands that Vasudeva is everything and surrenders to Him is the most learned and wise man.” In the Agni Puranam it is said that liberation or transcendental life follows all the devotees of Godhead. In the Vrihat Naradia Purana, it is also stated that even personalities like Brahma and the other demigods do not know the value of a devotee of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Garuda Purana also it is stated that, out of many thousands of Brahmins, one is prominent who is expert in performing sacrifices; and out of thousands of such Brahmins who are expert in the performance of sacrifice, one Brahmin who is expert in the Vedanta Sutra is the most famous; and out of many, many thousands of Vedantists, one person who is a devotee of Lord Vishnu is the most famous. There are many devotees of Vishnu, and out of them, one who is an unflinching devotee is eligible to enter into the Kingdom of God. In Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, 13th Chapter [4], it is also stated that there are many students of the Vedas, but one who is always thinking of the Supreme Personality of Godhead within his heart is the best. In the Narayan prayers it is said that even Brahma if not a devotee of the Lord, He is therefore insignificant, whereas even a bacteria who is a devotee of the Lord is famous.

Lord Chaitanya at this point inquired from Ramananda Roy, “What are the most valuable riches in this world?” Ramananda Roy replied that one who has love for Radha Krishna has the most valuable jewel, the greatest riches. One who is too much addicted to material sense gratification, or to material wealth, has no such value. When one comes to the spiritual platform in Krishna Consciousness he can understand that there are no more valuable riches than love of Radha Krishna. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Maharaj Dhruva sought out the Supreme Lord because he wanted to get some land, but when he saw Krishna he said, “I am so pleased that I don’t want anything.” In the Bhagavad Gita it is also stated that if one takes shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, or is elevated to the Supreme State of love of Godhead, then there is nothing more to aspire to. Although such devotees can obtain anything they desire from the Personality of Godhead, still, a pure devotee does not ask anything from God.

When Lord Chaitanya asked Ramananda Roy what is the most painful existence, Ramananda Roy replied that separation from a pure devotee is the most painful existence in human society. In other words, where there is no known devotee of the Lord, society becomes painful, and association also becomes painful. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Third Canto, 30th Chapter [6-7], it is stated that if somebody tries to become happy simply in association with society, friendship, and love—without Krishna Consciousness—he is in the most distressed condition, bereft of the association of a pure devotee.

Lord Chaitanya then inquired from Sri Ramananda Roy: “Out of so many so-called liberated souls, who is actually liberated?”

Ramananda replied that the person who is completely saturated with devotional love of Radha and Krishna is to be considered the best of all liberated persons. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Fifth Canto, it is stated that the association of a pure devotee is more desirable than life itself, and in separation from the association of the devotee, not even a second is passed happily. Similarly, it is stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Sixth Canto, 14th Chapter: a devotee of Narayan is so rare that you can find only one out of millions and millions.

Chaitanya Mahaprabhu inquired from Sri Ramananda Roy: “There are many songs; which song do you think the best of all?”

Ramananda replied that any song which describes the Pastimes of Sri Radha and Krishna is the best song. The conditioned soul is such that everyone is captivated by sex life; all the material fiction—dramas and novels—are descriptions of love between a man and woman. As people have so much attraction for this literature, Krishna therefore appeared on this material world and displayed His transcendental loving affairs with the Gopis, and there is an immense literature dealing with the transactions between the Gopis and Krishna. Anyone who takes shelter of this story of Radha and Krishna enjoys actual happiness. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 33rd Chapter [10.33.36], it is said that the Lord, in order to show His actual life, displayed His Pastimes at Vrindaban; and any intelligent person who tries to understand the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna is the most fortunate. And that sort of song and story is the highest in the world.

Lord Chaitanya then inquired from Sri Ramananda Roy, “What is the most profitable thing in this world, the essence of all auspicious events?”

Ramananda Roy replied that there is nothing so profitable as the association of pure devotees.

Lord Chaitanya inquired: “What do you recommend a person think of?”

Ramananda Roy replied that one should always think of the Pastimes of Krishna. This is Krishna Consciousness. Krishna has multiple activities, and they are described in so many Vedic Scriptures. One should think of all those Pastimes, always; that is the best meditation, and the highest ecstasy.

In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Second Canto, 2nd Chapter [36], it is confirmed by Sukadeva Goswami that people should always think of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; not only think of Him—one should hear and chant the Name, Fame, and Glories of the Supreme Lord.

Lord Chaitanya now inquired of Ramananda Roy: “What is the best type of meditation?”

And Ramananda replied, “One who always meditates upon the Lotus Feet of Radha and Krishna is the best meditator.”

Srimad Bhagwatam confirms this in the First Canto, 2nd Chapter [14], wherein it is stated: “It is only the Supreme Personality of Godhead Who is the Master of all devotees, Whose Name we should always be chanting, and Who should be always thought of in meditation, and worshipped regularly.”

Lord Chaitanya inquired from Ramananda Roy, “Where should a person live, giving up all other pleasures?”

And Ramananda Roy replied that one should give up all other pleasures and should live in Vrindaban, the place where Lord Krishna had so many Pastimes. In the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 47th Chapter [10.47.61], it is said by Uddhava that it is best to live at Vrindaban, even as one of the plants or creepers of the land; where the Supreme Lord was, and where the Gopis went, worshipping the Supreme Lord, the ultimate Goal of all Vedic knowledge.

Chaitanya Mahaprabhu now asked, “What is the best subject to hear of?”

And Ramananda Roy replied, “The best subject matter to hear of is the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna.” Actually, when the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna are heard from the right source, one becomes at once a liberated soul. But sometimes it happens that people do not hear the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna from a person who is a realized soul. And they are therefore sometimes misguided. It is stated in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Tenth Canto, 30th Chapter [10.33.39], that one who hears about the Pastimes of Krishna with the Gopis will attain to the highest platform of devotional service, and he will be freed from the material lust which is overwhelming everyone’s heart. In other words, the actual result of hearing the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna is to get rid of all material lust. If one does not become freed from material lust, then he should not indulge in hearing the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna. Unless we hear from the right source, the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna will be misrepresented, and we shall think that it is an ordinary affair between a man and woman, and we shall be misguided.

Chaitanya Mahaprabhu next inquired from Ramananda Roy: “Who is the most worshippable deity?”

And Ramananda Roy immediately replied that the transcendental couple, Sri Radha and Krishna, is the ultimate Object of worship. There are different kinds of worshippable objects, just as the impersonalists worship the impersonal Brahmajyoti. But the result of such worship is that one becomes bereft of his living activities, and becomes just like the tree and other unmoving entities. Those who are worshippers of the Void also attain such a result. And those who are Bhukti, who are after material enjoyment, worship demigods and achieve the planets of the demigods, and in that body they enjoy material happiness.

Lord Chaitanya inquired about those who are after material happiness, and liberation from this material bondage. Where do they ultimately go? Ramananda Roy replied that ultimately, some of them become as good as the standing tree, and some of them achieve the heavenly planets to enjoy material happiness.

Ramananda Roy went on to say that those who have no taste for Krishna Consciousness or spiritual life are just like crows who take pleasure in eating the bitter margosa fruit, while the poetic cuckoo eats the seeds of the mango. Similarly, the unfortunate transcendentalists are simply speculating on dry philosophy, whereas the transcendentalists who are in love with Radha Krishna enjoy, just like the cuckoo. Therefore, those who are devotees of Radha and Krishna are the most fortunate persons in the world. Ramananda Roy compared mental speculation with the bitter margosa fruit, which is not at all edible; simply full of dry speculation, and so fit for the crowlike philosophers; however, mango seeds are very relishable, and those who are in the devotional service of Krishna and Radha are like those mango-tasting cuckoos.

Thus Ramananda Roy and Chaitanya Mahaprabhu talked together for the whole night, sometimes dancing, sometimes singing, sometimes crying. In this way the night was passed, and at dawn Ramananda Roy went to his own place, and again in the evening he came back to see Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. The next day, after talking and discussing Krishna for some time, Ramananda Roy fell at the feet of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu and began to submit: “My dear Lord, You are so kind upon me that You have spoken to me about the science of Krishna, about the science of Radharani and Their loving affairs, and Their affairs of the Rasa Dance, and Their Pastimes—I never thought that I should be able to speak on this subject matter. So have You taught me, as You formerly taught Brahma the Vedas.”

This is the system of instruction from the Supersoul. Externally He is not to be seen. Yet, internally, He speaks to the devotee, and that is confirmed in the Bhagavad Gita [10.10]: to anyone who is sincerely engaged in the service of the Lord, the Lord from within dictates, and He acts in such a nice way that he ultimately achieves the Supreme goal of life. When Brahma was born there was nobody else to instruct him. Therefore, in the Vedic literature, we find that the Supreme Lord Himself instructed Brahma about the Vedic knowledge through his heart. The same thing is also confirmed in the Srimad Bhagwatam, Second Canto, 4th Chapter [22], by Sukadeva Goswami: the Gayatri Mantra was first of all instructed by the Supreme in the heart of Brahma. Similarly, Sukadeva Goswami prayed to the Lord to also help him in speaking Srimad Bhagwatam before Maharaj Parikshit.

The first verse of the First Canto of the Srimad Bhagwatam describes the Supreme Absolute Truth, Who instructed Brahma through the heart. It is stated there by Vyasadeva, the author of Srimad Bhagwatam: “Let me offer my respectful obeisances to Sri Krishna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Who is the Cause of cosmic manifestation, its maintenance, and its dissolution.” If we scrutinizingly try to understand the Supreme Truth, we can understand that He knows everything directly and indirectly. He is the only Supreme Personality fully independent, and it is He only, alone, Who instructed Brahma as the Supersoul from within. Even the greatest learned scholar becomes bewildered about understanding the Supreme Truth, because the whole perceivable cosmic manifestation is situated in Him. Although this material manifestation is a byproduct of fire, water, and earth, still it appears just like the truth. But it is in Him only that the spiritual manifestation, the material manifestation, and the manifestation of the living entities—everything—rests. Therefore He is the Supreme Truth.

Sri Ramananda Roy continued to speak to Lord Chaitanya: “Sir, first of all I saw You as a Sannyasi, and again I saw You as a cowherd Boy. Further, I see before You a golden doll. Due to the presence of that golden doll, Your complexion has become gold, and yet I see Your complexion to be black, as a cowherd boy. Will You kindly explain why I am seeing You with such different complexions? Will You kindly explain to me without any reservation?”

Lord Chaitanya replied, “It is the nature of highly elevated devotees to see Krishna in everything. Whenever they see anything, they do not see the form of that particular thing, but they see Krishna.” This is confirmed in Srimad Bhagwatam, Eleventh Canto, 2nd Chapter: that a person who is highly elevated in devotional service sees the Supersoul, Krishna, Who is the Soul of all individual souls. A similar passage is found in the Tenth Canto, 35th Chapter, in which it is stated that all the creepers, plants and trees, full with flowers and fruits, were bent over on account of the ecstasy of love for Krishna, because Krishna was the Soul of their soul; and those trees and plants, after Krishna manifested before them, were growing thorny.

Lord Chaitanya then continued to speak, addressing Ramananda: “You have the highest conception of the Pastimes of Radha and Krishna, and you are therefore seeing Radha Krishna everywhere.”

In reply to this Ramananda Roy said, “Sir, I may request that You don’t try to hide Yourself I understand that You have accepted the complexion and mode of thinking of Srimati Radharani, so that You are trying to understand Yourself from the viewpoint of Radharani; and You are advented to take this point of view. Your incarnation is chiefly for understanding Your Own Self, but, side by side, You are distributing love of Krishna to the world. You have personally come here to deliver me. Now don’t try to deceive me, I request You, it is not good for You.”

Lord Chaitanya became very satisfied, and He smiled and showed Ramananda His real form. In other words, the Form which Lord Chaitanya manifested as the combination of Sri Radha and Krishna was first shown to Ramananda Roy. Lord Chaitanya was, therefore, Sri Krishna Himself, with the external features of the mode of Srimati Radharani. This transcendental ability of one becoming two and two becoming one is possible, and was seen by Sri Ramananda Roy. Persons who are fortunate enough to understand Lord Chaitanya as well as the Pastimes at Vrindaban of Radha and Krishna can be able, by the mercy of Sri Rupa Goswami, to know about the real identity of Sri Krishna Chaitanya Mahaprabhu.

Seeing this unique feature of Lord Chaitanya, Ramananda Roy fainted and fell down flat on the floor. While he was unconscious, Lord Chaitanya touched him, and he came to his senses. Ramananda Roy was surprised to see Lord Chaitanya in His dress of a mendicant. Lord Chaitanya then embraced him and pacified him and informed him that nobody had seen this Form except himself. “You have understood the purpose of My incarnation, and therefore you are privileged to see this particular feature of My Personality.” Lord Chaitanya continued: “My dear Ramananda, I am not a different person with fair complexion known as Gaura Purusa. I am the Selfsame Krishna—Son of Maharaj Nanda, and due to contact with the body of Srimati Radharani I have now assumed this Form. Srimati Radharani does not touch anyone else but Krishna, and therefore Srimati Radharani has influenced Me with Her complexion, mind and words, and I am just trying to understand the transcendental flavor of Krishna’s relationship.” No one should therefore eliminate Lord Chaitanya from Sri Krishna.

The fact is that both Krishna and Lord Chaitanya are the Original Personality of Godhead. In His Form of Sri Krishna He is the Supreme Enjoyer, in His Form of Lord Chaitanya He is the Supreme Enjoyed. No one can be more superexcellently attractive than Sri Krishna, and except for Krishna no one can be the Enjoyer of the Supreme Form of Devotion, Srimati Radharani. Except Sri Krishna, all other Vishnu Forms are lacking this quality.

This is explained in the Govinda description of Chaitanya Charitamrita [Ädi 4.82], where it is said that Srimati Radharani is the only personality who can infuse Sri Krishna' with transcendental pleasure. Therefore, Srimati Radharani is the chief of all the damsels of Vraja who love Govinda, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna.

‘‘Please take it from Me that I have nothing to hide from you. And even if I do try to hide from you, you are such an advanced devotee that you can understand everything of My secret. I request that you plese keep this secret, and do not disclose it to anyone. It would be considered that I am a madman. The facts which are disclosed to you cannot be understood by any materialistic person. When they hear all this description they will laugh at Me. You can understand yourself, and keep it for yourself. As a devotee becomes mad in his ecstasy of love for Krishna, so from the materialistic point of view, both yourself and Myself are the same as madmen. Therefore, don’t disclose these facts to the ordinary men, or they will laugh at Me.”

Lord Chaitanya then passed ten nights with Ramananda Roy, and enjoyed his company in discussing the Pastimes of Krishna and Radha. The discussion between Sri Chaitanya and Sri Ramananda Roy was on the highest level of love of Krishna. Some of the talks are described, but most of them could not be described. This has been analyzed in the Chaitanya Charitamrita as an examination in metallurgy. The comparison is that the discussion proceeds just like metals being studied: first copper, then bronze, then silver, gold, and at last touchstone. The preliminary discussions between Lord Chaitanya and Ramananda Roy are considered copper, and a higher discussion is considered gold. But the fifth dimension of the discussion between Ramananda Roy and Lord Chaitanya is considered to be touchstone. If, however, one is very eager to progress higher and higher to the position of the highest metallurgist, then he can understand—beginning with inquiring into the difference between copper and bronze, and then silver, and so on.

The next day, Lord Chaitanya asked Ramananda Roy to allow Him to go back to Jagannath Puri, “So that the rest of Our lives We can remain together at Jagannath Puri, and We can pass Our time in discussing Krishna.” Lord Chaitanya thus embraced Ramananda Roy and sent him to his own place. In the morning He started His further journey. Ramananda Roy and Lord Chaitanya met on the river bank where there was a deity, a temple of Hanuman. After seeing the temple of Hanuman He left that place. So long as Chaitanya Mahaprabhu remained at Kavur, all kinds of people met Him, and by His Grace everyone became a devotee of the Supreme Lord.

After the departure of Lord Chaitanya, Ramananda Roy became overwhelmed by separation from the Lord, and he decided to retire from service just to meet the Lord again at Jagannath Puri. This discussion of Ramananda Roy with Lord Chaitanya is the most concentrated form of devotional service, and by hearing the discussion of Ramananda Roy and Lord Chaitanya one can understand the Pastimes of Sri Radha and Krishna. One can also understand the confidential part played by Lord Chaitanya. If one is fortunate enough, he can place his faith in this discussion, and can enter into the transcendental association of Radha and Krishna.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

THE BHAGAVAD GITA AS IT IS


A New Translation with Commentary by A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami


With appreciations by
Allen Ginsberg, Denise Levertov, and Thomas Merton


PUBLISHED BY THE MACMILLAN COMPANY


The Bhagavad Gita As It Is is a major new translation of, and commentary upon, The Bhagavad Gita. Prepared by one of the most distinguished teachers of Vedic religion and thought, it offers illuminating new perspectives on one of the world’s great spiritual texts.

“There are many commentaries on The Bhagavad Gita, and the necessity for another should be explained on the following basis: An American lady asked me to recommend an English edition of The Bhagavad Gita which she could read. I was unable to do so in good conscience. Of course, there are many translations, but of those I have seen—not only in America, but also in India—none can be said to be authoritative, because in almost every one of them the author has expressed his personal opinion through the commentaries, without touching the spirit of The Bhagavad Gita as it is.”
—from the Introduction by A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami


“This translation and the commentary which accompanies it has as its purpose the determination to direct the reader to Krishna, rather than away from Him. In this, A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami’s work is unique among all the translations and commentaries available in this language. Unique also is the fact that The Bhagavad Gita is thus made wholly consistent and comprehensible. Krishna being the Speaker of The Gita, and It’s ultimate goal as well, this is necessarily the only translation that can present this great scripture in its true terms.”
—from the Preface by Rayarama Das Brahmachary


318 pages MACMILLAN hardcover edition: $6.95

COLLIER softcover edition: $2.95

At your bookstore or available from ISKCON


A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami is the founder of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, which now has centers in every major city in the United States, Canada, England and Germany.

---------------------------------------------------------------------


ONE OF THE MOST SUBLIME LYRICAL ACHIEVEMENTS IN ALL MYSTIC LITERATURE


In Praise of A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami:


“A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami brings to the West a salutary reminder that our highly activistic and one-sided culture lacks the inner depth of Krishna Consciousness. Without such depth our moral and political protestations are just so much verbiage.”
Thomas Merton


“He writes from not only a scholar’s but a practitioner’s, a dedicated life-long devotee’s, point of view that is honest and very moving. ”
Denise Leverton


“The HARE KRISHNA meditation led by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami transports the disciples into a state of religious ecstasy so rapturous it’s almost embarrassing to witness.”
Jane Howard "Life"


“The task he has undertaken in translating and commenting on the Bhagavata Purana, Bhagavad Gita, and Chaitanya Charitamrita necessitates a considerable erudition. His teachings are obviously significant to many of our young people and is therefore important to all of us. ”
professor Edward C. Dimock
university of chicago


“He is doing valuable work and his books are significant contributions to the salvation of human kind. ”
Sri Lal Bahadur Shastri
late prime minister of india
.


“I am greatly impressed by the recent surge of interest in Krishna Consciousness. A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami is due our respects and good wishes. ”
professor Joseph Cambell
sarah lawrence college


“The purports or explanations of A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami are transparent and exquisitely detailed expositions presented here for the first time to common public Western mind—a storehouse of old age, experience, devotion, learning, scholarship, Hindu granny wisdom sincerity, gaiety and sweet transcendental insight.”
Allen Ginsberg:

Çré Éçopaniñad - 1969 Edition

Iso back cover & front pages-1969

Back cover & front pages

Sri Isopanisad is the foremost of the 108 Upanisads. Contained within is the essence of all Vedic knowledge. Presented with the original Sanskrit text, transliterations, English synonyms and purports, by a self-realized Teacher (Acharya), this book is recommended for the novices and neophytes as well as the most highly elevated souls. Its’ contents are transcendentally pleasing to the non-deceptive and sincere aspirants of spiritual advancement in life.

-----------------------------------------------

OTHER BOOKS

by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


The Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam
Teachings of Lord Chaitanya
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead
The Nectar of Devotion
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
The Kåñëa Consciousness Movement is the Genuine Vedic Way
The First Step in God Realization
The Lord in the Heart
Pure Devotional Service: The Change in Heart The Process of Creation The Cause of All Causes

----------------------------------------------

With Introduction, Translation and Authorized Purport
By His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada
Founder-Acharya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness
Iskcon Books
Los Angeles, New York, London, Bombay

------------------------------------------------

Copyright 1969 by ISKCON Books All Rights Reserved
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 78-102853
First edition published by ISKCON Books in 1969
Fifth Printing 1972
ISKCON Books
3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90034 USA
Printed in Japan

Iso Introduction-1969

Introduction
(Teachings of the Vedas)

[Delivered as a lecture by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedänta Swämé Prabhupäda on October 6, 1969, at Conway Hall, London, England.]

Ladies and gentlemen, today's subject matter is the teachings of the Vedas. What are the Vedas? The Sanskrit verbal root of Veda can be interpreted variously, but the purpose is finally one. Veda means knowledge. Any knowledge you accept is Veda, for the teachings of the Vedas are the original knowledge. In the conditioned state, our knowledge is subjected to so many deficiencies. The difference between a conditioned soul and a liberated soul is that the conditioned soul has four kinds of defects. The first defect is that he must commit mistakes. For example, in our country, Mahätmä Gandhi was considered to be a very great personality, but he committed many mistakes. Even at the last stage of his life, his assistant warned, "Mahätmä Gandhi, don't go to the New Delhi meeting. I have some friends, and I have heard there is danger." But he did not hear. He persisted on going and was killed. Even great personalities like Mahätmä Gandhi, President Kennedy—there are so many of them—make mistakes. To err is human. This is one defect of the conditioned soul.

Another defect: to be illusioned. Illusion means to accept something which is not: mäyä. Mäyä means what is not. Everyone is accepting the body as the self. If I ask you what you are, you will say, "I am Mr. John; I am a rich man; I am this, I am that." All these are bodily identifications. But you are not this body. This is illusion.

The third defect is the cheating propensity. Everyone has the propensity to cheat others. Although a person is fool number one, he poses himself as very intelligent. Although it is already pointed out that he is in illusion and makes mistakes, he will theorize: "I think this is this, this is this." But he does not even know his own position. He writes books of philosophy, although he is defective. That is his disease. That is cheating.

Lastly, our senses are imperfect. We are very proud of our eyes. Often, someone will challenge, "Can you show me God?" But do you have the eyes to see God? You will never see if you haven't the eyes. If immediately the room becomes dark, you cannot even see your hands. So what power do you have to see? We cannot, therefore, expect knowledge (Vedas) with these imperfect senses. With all these deficiencies, in conditioned life, we cannot give perfect knowledge to anyone. Nor are we ourselves perfect. Therefore we accept the Vedas as they are.

You may call the Vedas Hindu, but Hindu is a foreign name. We are not Hindus. Our real identification is varëäçrama. Varëäçrama denotes the followers of the Vedas, those who accept the human society in eight divisions of varëa and äçrama. There are four divisions of society and four divisions of spiritual life. This is called varëäçrama. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, "These divisions are there everywhere, because they are created by God." The divisions of society are brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, çüdra. Brähmaëa refers to the very intelligent class of men, those who know what is Brahman. Similarly, the kñatriyas, the administrator group, are the next intelligent class of men. Then the vaiçyas, the mercantile group. These natural classifications are found everywhere. This is the Vedic principle, and we accept it. Vedic principles are accepted as axiomatic truth, for there cannot be any mistake. That is acceptance. For instance, in India, cow dung is accepted as pure, and yet cow dung is the stool of an animal. In one place you'll find the Vedic injunction that if you touch stool, you have to take a bath immediately. But in another place it is said that the stool of a cow is pure. If you smear cow dung in an impure place that place becomes pure. With our ordinary sense we can argue, "This is contradictory." Actually, it is contradictory from the ordinary point of view, but it is not false. It is fact. In Calcutta, a very prominent scientist and doctor analyzed cow dung and found that it contains all antiseptic properties.

In India if one person tells another, "You must do this," the other party may say, "What do you mean? Is this a Vedic injunction that I have to follow you without any argument?" Vedic injunctions cannot be interpreted. But ultimately, if you carefully study why these injunctions are there, you will find that they are all correct.

The Vedas are not compilations of human knowledge. Vedic knowledge comes from the Spiritual World, from Lord Kåñëa. Another name for the Vedas is çruti. Çruti refers to that knowledge which is acquired by hearing. It is not experimental knowledge. Çruti is considered to be like a mother. We take so much knowledge from our mother. For example, if you want to know who your father is, who can answer you? Your mother. If the mother says, "Here is your father," you have to accept it. It is not possible to experiment to find out whether he is your father. Similarly, if you want to know something beyond your experience, beyond your experimental knowledge, beyond the activities of the senses, then you have to accept Vedas. There is no question of experimenting. It has already been experimented. It is already settled. The version of the mother, for instance, has to be accepted as truth. There is no other way.

The Vedas are considered to be the mother and Brahmä is called the grandfather, the forefather, because he was the first to be instructed in the Vedic knowledge. In the beginning the first living creature was Brahmä. He received this Vedic knowledge and imparted it to Närada and other disciples and sons, and they also distributed it to their disciples. In this way, the Vedic knowledge comes down by disciplic succession. It is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä, that Vedic knowledge is understood in this way. If you make experimental endeavor, you come to the same conclusion, but just to save time you should accept. If you want to know who your father is and if you accept your mother as authority, then whatever she says can be accepted without argument. There are three kinds of evidences: pratyakña, anumäna and çabda. Pratyakña means direct. Direct evidence is not so good because our senses are not perfect. We are seeing the sun daily, and it appears to us just like a small disc, but it is actually far, far larger than many planets. Of what value is this seeing? Therefore we have to read books, then we can understand about the sun. So direct experience is not perfect. Then there is inductive knowledge: "It may be like this," hypothesis. For instance, Darwin's theory says it may be like this, it may be like that, but that is not science. That is a suggestion, and it is also not perfect. But if you receive the knowledge from the authoritative sources, that is perfect. If you receive a program guide from the radio station authorities, you accept it. You don't deny it; you don't have to make an experiment because it is received from the authoritative sources.

Vedic knowledge is called çabda-pramäëa. Another name is çruti. Çruti means that this knowledge has to be received simply by aural reception. The Vedas instruct that in order to understand transcendental knowledge we have to hear from the authority. Transcendental knowledge is knowledge from beyond this universe. Within this universe is material knowledge, and beyond this universe is transcendental knowledge. We cannot even go to the end of the universe, so how can we go to the Spiritual World? Thus to acquire full knowledge is impossible.

There is a Spiritual Sky. There is another nature that is beyond manifestation and non-manifestation. But how will you know that there is a sky where the planets and inhabitants are eternal? All this knowledge is there, but how will you make experiments? It is not possible. Therefore you have to take the assistance of the Vedas. This is called Vedic knowledge. In our Kåñëa Consciousness Movement, we are accepting knowledge from the highest authority, Kåñëa. Kåñëa is accepted as the highest authority by all classes of men. I am speaking first of the two classes of transcendentalists. One class of transcendentalist is called impersonalist, Mäyä-vädé. They are generally known as Vedäntists, led by Çaìkaräcärya. And there is another class of transcendentalist, called Vaiñëavas, like Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Viñëusvämé. Both the Çaìkara-sampradäya and the Vaiñëava-sampradäya have accepted Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Çaìkaräcärya is supposed to be an impersonalist who preached impersonalism, impersonal Brahman, but it is a fact that he is a covered personalist. In his commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä he wrote: "Näräyaëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is beyond this cosmic manifestation." And then again he confirms, "That Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, is Kåñëa. He has come as the Son of Devaké and Vasudeva." He has particularly mentioned the names of His father and mother. So Kåñëa is accepted as the Supreme Personality of Godhead by all transcendentalists. There is no doubt about it. Our source of knowledge in Kåñëa Consciousness is directly from Kåñëa, Bhagavad-gétä. We have published Bhagavad Gétä As It Is, because we accept Kåñëa as He is speaking without any interpretation. That is Vedic knowledge. Since the Vedic knowledge is pure, we accept it. Whatever Kåñëa says, we accept. This is Kåñëa Consciousness. That saves much time. If you accept the right authority or the source of knowledge, then you save much time. For example, there are two systems of knowledge in the material world, inductive and deductive. From deductive, you accept that man is mortal. Your father says man is mortal, your sister says man is mortal, everyone says man is mortal—but you do not experiment. You accept it as fact that man is mortal. If you want to research to find out whether man is mortal, you have to study each and every man, and you may come to think that there may be some man who is not dying, but you have not seen him yet. So in this way your researching will never be finished. This process is called in Sanskrit, äroha, the ascending process. If you want to attain knowledge by any personal endeavor, by exercising your imperfect senses, you will never come to the right conclusions. That is not possible.

There is a statement in Brahma-saàhitä: Just ride on the airplane which runs at the speed of mind. Our material airplanes can run 2,000 miles per hour, but what is the speed of mind? You are sitting at home, you immediately think of India, say 10,000 miles away, and at once it is in your home. Your mind has gone there. The mind-speed is so swift. Therefore it is stated, "If you travel at this speed for millions of years, you'll find that the Spiritual Sky is unlimited." It is not possible even to approach it. Therefore, the Vedic injunction is that one must approach—the word "compulsory" is used—a bona fide spiritual master, a guru. And what is the qualification of a spiritual master? He has rightly heard the Vedic message from the right source. Otherwise he is not bona fide. He must practically be firmly established in Brahman. These are the two qualities. This Kåñëa Consciousness movement is completely authorized from Vedic principles. In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says, "The actual aim of Vedic research is to find out Kåñëa." In the Brahma-saàhitä it is also stated, "Kåñëa, Govinda, has innumerable Forms, but they are all one." They are not like our forms, which are fallible. His Form is infallible. My form has a beginning, but His Form has no beginning. It is ananta. And His Form—so many multiforms—has no end. My form is sitting here and not in my apartment. You are sitting there and not in your apartment. But Kåñëa can be anywhere at one time. He can sit down in Goloka Våndävana and at the same time He is everywhere, all-pervading. He is Original, the Oldest, but whenever you look at a picture of Kåñëa you'll find a young Boy of 15-20 years old. You will never find an old man. You have seen pictures of Kåñëa as a charioteer from the Bhagavad-gétä. At that time He was not less than 100 years old. He had great-grandchildren, but He looked just like a boy. Kåñëa, God, never becomes old. That is His Supreme power. And if you want to search out Kåñëa by studying the Vedic literature, then you will be baffled. It may be possible, but it is very difficult. But you can very easily learn about Him from His devotee. His devotee can deliver Him to you: "Here He is, take Him." That is the potency of Kåñëa's devotees.

Originally there was only one Veda, and there was no necessity of reading it. People were so intelligent and had such sharp memories that by once hearing from the lips of the spiritual master they would understand. They would immediately grasp the whole purport. But 5,000 years ago Vyäsadeva put the Vedas in writing for the people in this age, Kali-yuga. He knew that eventually the people would be short-lived, their memories would be very poor and their intelligence would not be very sharp. "Therefore, let me teach this Vedic knowledge in writing." He divided the Vedas into four: Åk, Säma, Atharva, and Yajus. Then he gave the charge of these Vedas to his different disciples. He then thought of the less intelligent class of men, stré, çüdra and dvija-bandhu. He considered the woman class and çüdra class (worker class) and dvija-bandhu. Dvija-bandhu refers to those who are born in a high family but who are not properly qualified. A man born in the family of a brähmaëa, who is not qualified as a brähmaëa, is called dvija-bandhu. For these persons, he compiled Mahäbhärata, called the history of India, and the eighteen Puräëas. These are all Vedic literatures: the Puräëas, the Mahäbhärata, the four Vedas, and the Upaniñads. The Upaniñads are part of the Vedas. Then Vyäsadeva summarized all Vedic knowledge for scholars and philosophers in what is called the Vedänta-sütra. This is the last word of the Vedas. Vyäsadeva personally wrote Vedänta-sütra under the instructions of Närada, his Guru Mahäräj, spiritual master, but still he was not satisfied. That is a long story, described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Vedavyäsa was not very satisfied even after compiling many Puräëas, Upaniñads, and even after Vedänta-sütra. Then his spiritual master, Närada, instructed him, "You explain Vedänta." Vedänta means Ultimate Knowledge, and the Ultimate Knowledge is Kåñëa. Kåñëa says that throughout all the Vedas one has to understand Kåñëa. Vedänta-kåd veda-vid eva cäham. Kåñëa says, "I am the Compiler of Vedänta, and I am the Knower of the Vedas." Therefore the Ultimate Objective is Kåñëa. That is explained in all the Vaiñëava commentaries on Vedänta philosophy. We Gauòéya Vaiñëavas have our commentary on Vedänta philosophy, called Govinda-bhäñya by Baladeva Vidyäbhüñaëa. Similarly, Rämänujäcärya has a commentary and Madhväcärya has one. The version of Çaìkaräcärya is not the only commentary. There are many Vedänta commentaries, but because the Vaiñëavas did not present the first Vedänta commentary, people are under the wrong impression that Çaìkaräcärya's is the only Vedänta commentary. Besides that, Vyäsadeva himself wrote the perfect Vedänta commentary, Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Çrémad-Bhägavatam also begins with the first words of the Vedänta-sütra: janmädyasya yataù. And that janmädyasya yataù is fully explained in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The Vedänta-sütra simply hints at what is Brahman, the Absolute Truth: "The Absolute Truth is that from Whom everything emanates." This is a summary, but it is explained in detail in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. If everything is emanating from the Absolute Truth, then what is the nature of the Absolute Truth? That is explained in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The Absolute Truth must be conscious. Svaräö. He is Self-effulgent. We develop our consciousness and knowledge by receiving knowledge from others, but for Him it is said that He is Self-effulgent. The whole summary of Vedic knowledge is the Vedänta-sütra, and the Vedänta-sütra is explained by the writer himself in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. We finally request those who are actually after Vedic knowledge to try to understand the explanation of all Vedic knowledge from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam and the Bhagavad-gétä.

Iso Texts-1969

Iso Invocation-1969

INVOCATION

V paUNARmad": paUNARimadM"
paUNAARtpaUNARmaud"cyatae
paUNARsya paUNARmaAd"Aya
paUNARmaevaAvaizASyatae

TEXT

oà pürëam adaù pürëam idaà
pürëät pürëam udacyate
pürëasya pürëam ädäya
pürëam evävaçiñyate.

om—the Complete Whole; pürëam—perfectly complete; adaù—that; pürëam—perfectly complete; idam—this phenomenal world; pürëät—from the all perfect; pürëam—complete unit; udacyate—produced; pürëasya—of the Complete Whole; pürëam—completely all; ädäya—having been taken away; pürëam—the complete balance; eva—even; avaçiñyate—is remaining.

TRANSLATION

The Personality of Godhead is perfect and complete. And because He is completely perfect, all emanations from Him, such as this phenomenal world, are perfectly equipped as a complete whole. Whatever is produced of the complete whole is also complete by itself. And because He is the Complete Whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance. [& Båhad-äraëyaka Upaniñad 5.1]

PURPORT

The Complete Whole, or the Supreme Absolute Truth, is the complete Personality of Godhead. Impersonal Brahman forms an incomplete realization of the Absolute Complete, and so also does the conception of Paramätman, the Supersoul. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha: impersonal Brahman realization is the realization of His sat, or eternity aspect, and Paramätman, Supersoul realization, is the realization of His sat and cit, eternity and knowledge aspects. But realization of the Personality of Godhead is realization of all the transcendental features, sat, cit, and änanda, or bliss. In the Personal concept, this is realized in complete form (vigraha). And so the Complete Whole is not formless. If He is formless, or if He is less than His creation in any other thing, He cannot be complete. The Complete Whole must have everything, both within our experience and beyond our experience. Otherwise He cannot be complete.

The Complete Whole Personality of Godhead has immense potencies, and all of them are as complete as He is. Therefore this phenomenal or material world is also complete by itself. The twenty-four elements of which this material universe is a temporary manifestation are completely adjusted to produce complete things necessary for the maintenance and subsistence of this universe. No extraneous effort by any other unit is required for this maintenance. The universe has its own time, fixed by the energy of the Complete Whole, and when that time is complete this temporary manifestation will be annihilated by the complete arrangement of the Complete.

There is complete facility for the small complete units, namely the living beings, to realize the Complete; and all forms of incompleteness are experienced only on account of incomplete knowledge of the Complete. The human form of life is a complete manifestation of the consciousness of the living being, which is obtained after evolving through 8,400,000 species of life in the cycle of birth and death. If a human being does not realize his completeness within the Complete in this life of full consciousness, he loses the chance of realizing his completeness, and is put again into the cycle of evolution by the law of material Nature.

Because we do not know that there is a complete arrangement in Nature for our maintenance, we make efforts to utilize the resources of Nature to create a so-called complete life of sense enjoyment. This misleading life of sense-enjoyment is called illusion, because the living entity cannot enjoy the life of the senses without being dovetailed with the Complete Whole. For example, the hand of a body is a complete unit as long as it is attached to the complete body. When the hand is detached from the body, it may appear like a hand, but actually it has none of the potency of a hand. Similarly, the living beings are parts and parcels of the Complete Whole; and as long as the parts and parcels are detached from the Complete Whole, the illusory representation of completeness is not enough to bring the desired result.

The completeness of human life can only be realized when the human form of life is engaged in the service of the Complete Whole. Any service in this world, whether social, political, communal, international, or even inter-planetary, will remain incomplete unless and until it is dovetailed with the Complete Whole. And, when everything is dovetailed with the Complete Whole, the attached parts and parcels also become complete in themselves.

Iso 1-1969

Mantra One

wRzAAvaAsyaimad"ms$ava<
yaitk(Âa jagAtyaAM jagAta,
taena tya·e(na BauÃaITaA
maA gA{Da: k(sya isvaÜ"nama,

TEXT

éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà

yat kiïca jagatyäà jagat

tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä

mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam.

éça—by the Lord; väsyam—controlled; idam—this; sarvam—all: yat—whatever; kim—it (is); ca—and; jagatyäm—within the universe; jagat—all that is animate or inanimate; tena—by Him; tyaktena—set apart quota; bhuïjéthäù—must you accept; mä—do not; gådhaù—make into use; kasya svid—whom does it belong; dhanam—things necessary.

TRANSLATION

Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one must not accept other things, knowing well to Whom they belong.

PURPORT

The Vedic knowledge is infallible because it comes down through the perfect, disciplic succession of spiritual masters beginning with the Lord Himself. The Vedic knowledge is received from the transcendental sources, and the first word was spoken by the Lord Himself. The words spoken by the Lord are called apauruñeya, not delivered by any person of the mundane world. A living being of the mundane world has four defects, which are: 1. that he must commit mistakes, 2. he must sometimes be illusioned, 3. he must try to cheat others, and 4. he is endowed with imperfect senses. With these four principles of imperfection one cannot deliver perfect information in the matter of all-pervading knowledge. The Vedas are not known like that. The Vedic knowledge was originally imparted into the heart of Brahmä the first created living being, and Brahmä in his turn disseminated the knowledge to his sons and disciples, who have continued the process down through history.

The Lord being pürëam, or all-perfect, there is no chance of His being subjected to the laws of material Nature, while the living entities and inanimate objects are all controlled by the laws of Nature, and thus, ultimately, by the potency of the Lord. This Éçopaniñad is a part of the Yajur Veda, and as such it contains information as to the proprietorship of all things that exist within the universe.

This point is confirmed by the Bhagavad-gétä, in the Seventh Chapter [4-5], where parä and aparä prakåti are discussed: The elements of Nature—earth, fire, water, air, sky, mind, intelligence and ego—all belong to the inferior or material energy of the Lord, whereas the living being, the organic energy, is the superior energy, the parä prakåti, of the Lord. Both the prakåtis or energies are, emanations from the Lord, and ultimately He is the Controller of everything that exists. There is nothing in the universe which does not belong either to the parä or the aparä prakåti, and therefore everything is under the proprietary right of the Supreme Being.

The Supreme Being, the Absolute Personality of Godhead, being the complete Person, has the complete and perfect intelligence to adjust everything by His different potencies. The Supreme Being is often compared with fire, and everything—organic and inorganic—is compared with the heat and light of the fire. The fire distributes energy in the form of heat and light, and likewise the Lord displays His energy in different ways. And He remains the ultimate Controller, Sustainer and Dictator over everything. He is full of all potencies, the Knower of every thing, the Benefactor of everyone, and is full of all inconceivable opulences: power, wealth, fame, beauty, knowledge and renunciation.

One should therefore be intelligent enough to know that except for the Lord no one is the proprietor of anything; one should accept only the things which are set aside by the Lord as his quota. The cow, for example, gives milk, but she does not drink the milk. Her milk is designated as food for the human being. The cow eats grass and straw but does not drink her own milk. Such is the arrangement of the Lord, and we should be satisfied with the things that have been very kindly set aside for us by Him. We should always consider to Whom the things that we possess actually belong.

Take, for example, our dwelling house, which is made of earth, wood, stone, iron, cement, and so many other material things. If we think in terms of Çré Éçopaniñad, then we must know that we cannot produce any of the, above-mentioned building materials ourselves. We can simply bring them together and transform them into different shapes by our labor. A laborer cannot claim to be the proprietor of a thing just because he has worked hard to manufacture it.

There is always this great quarrel between the laborers and the capitalists in present-day society. The quarrel has now taken an international shape, and the world is in danger. Men face each other in enmity just like cats and dogs snarling. Çré Éçopaniñad cannot give advice to the cats and dogs, but It delivers the message of Godhead to man through the bona fide äcäryas, or holy teachers. And the human race may take this Vedic wisdom from Çré Éçopaniñad: that no one should quarrel over material possessions. One must be satisfied by whatever privileges are given to him by the mercy of the Lord. There can be no peace if the communist or the capitalist or any other party claims to be the proprietor of the resources of Nature, which are entirely the property of the Lord.

The capitalist cannot curb down the communist simply by political maneuvering, nor can the communist defeat the capitalist simply by fighting for the stolen bread. If they do not recognize the proprietorship of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, then all the property which they claim to be their own is stolen, and therefore they shall be liable to punishment by the laws of Nature. The Bomb is in the hands of both the communists and the capitalists, and if both do not recognize the proprietorship of the Supreme Lord, it is sure and certain that, ultimately, the Bomb will ruin both parties. Therefore, in order to save themselves, both must follow the instruction of Çré Éçopaniñad, and thus bring peace to the world.

Human beings are not meant for quarreling like cats and dogs. They must be intelligent enough to realize the importance of human life, and to realize the aim of human life. The Vedic literature is meant for humanity and not for cats and dogs. Cats and dogs can kill other animals for food and for that there is no question of sin on their part. But if a man kills an animal for the satisfaction of his uncontrolled taste buds, he is responsible for breaking the laws of Nature, and therefore he must be punished.

There is a standard of life for human beings which cannot apply to the animals. The tiger does not eat rice, wheat or cow's milk because it has been given its quota of foodstuff in the shape of animal food. There are many animals and birds who are either vegetarian or non-vegetarian, but none of them transgress the laws of Nature as they have been ordained by the will of the Lord. Amongst the living beings—whether animals or birds or reptiles—there is strict adherence to the laws of Nature, and therefore there is no question of sin for them, nor are the Vedic instructions meant for them. Human life alone, then, is a life of responsibility.

It is also wrong to consider that simply by becoming a vegetarian one can save himself from transgressing the laws of Nature. Vegetables also have life. One life is meant to feed another living being, and that is the law of Nature. One should not be proud of being a strict vegetarian. The point is to recognize the Supreme Lord. The animals have no developed consciousness to recognize the Lord, but a human being is sufficiently intelligent to take lessons from the Vedic literature, and thereby know how the laws of Nature are working, and derive profit out of such knowledge. If a man neglects the instruction of the Vedic literature, his life is very risky. The human being is therefore required to recognize the authority of the Supreme Lord. He must be a devotee of the Lord. He must offer everything to the service of the Lord and partake of only the remnants of foodstuff offered to the Lord. That will make, him able to discharge his duty properly. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.26] the Lord directly states that He accepts the vegetable foodstuffs from the hands of a pure devotee. Therefore a human being should not only become a strict vegetarian, but he should also be a devotee of the Lord, and offer to the Lord all his food, and only then partake of the prasädam, or mercy of God. Such a devotee can properly discharge the duty of human life. Those who do not do so are eating only sins, and thus will be subjected to the different types of distress which are the result of the various sins. [Bg. 3.13]

The root of sin is deliberate disobedience to the laws of Nature, through not recognizing the proprietorship of the Lord. Disobedience to the laws of Nature or disobedience to the order of the Lord will bring ruin to the human being. On the other hand, if one is sober and knows the laws of Nature, without being influenced by unnecessary attachment or abhorrence, he is sure to be recognized again by the Lord, and thus become eligible for going back to Godhead, back to the eternal Home.

[BTG 1956]

Iso 2-1969

Mantra Two

ku(vaRªaevaeh" k(maARiNA
ijajaIivaSaecC$taM s$amaA:
WvaM tvaiya naAnyaTaetaAe'ista
na k(maR ilapyatae nare"

TEXT

kurvann eveha karmäëi

jijéviñec chataà samäù

evaà tvayi nänyatheto 'sti

na karma lipyate nare.

kurvan—doing continuously; eva—thus; iha—during this span of life; karmäëi—work; jijéviñet—one should desire to live; çatam—one hundred; samäù—years; evam—so living; tvayi—unto you; na—no; anyathä—alternative; itaù—from this path; asti—there is; na—not; karma—work; lipyate—can be bound; nare—unto a man.

TRANSLATION

One may aspire to live for hundreds of years if he continuously goes on doing work in that way, because that sort of work will not bind him to the law of karma. And there is no alternative to this way for man.

PURPORT

No one wants to die, and everyone wants to live for as long as he can drag on. This temperament is not only visible individually, but also it is visible collectively in the community, society and nation. There is a hard struggle for life in every class of living entities, and the Veda says that this is quite natural for the living being. The living being is eternal by nature, but due to his bondage in the material existence he has to change his body from one to another. This process is called transmigration of the soul. This transmigration is also called Karma-bandhana, or being bound by one's own work. The living entity has to work for his livelihood because that is the law of material Nature, and if he does not act according to the prescribed duties of his particular life he transgresses the law of Nature, making himself bound more and more in the cycle of birth and death.

The cycle of birth and death is present in life other than the human form. When the living entity gets the. chance for human life, however, it is his chance to gel free from the chain of the law of karma. Karma, akarma, and vikarma are principles very clearly described in the Bhagavad-gétä. Actions which are done in terms of the prescribed duties mentioned in the revealed Scriptures are called karma. Actions which make one free from the cycle of birth and death are called akarma. And actions which are performed by the misuse of one's freedom, thereby directing oneself toward the lower regions of life, are called vikarma.

Of these three categories of activities, the one which makes one free from the cycle of further bondage to karma is preferred by intelligent men. Ordinary men want to perform good work in order to be recognized and to achieve some status of life in this world or in heaven, hut more advanced men want to he free altogether from the actions and reactions of work. Intelligent men know well that both good and bad works are equally causes of the material miseries of life. They therefore seek to do work which will free them from the reactions of good and bad work. This freedom from good and bad work is ascertained herewith in Çré Éçopaniñad.

The instruction of Çré Éçopaniñad is better explained in the Bhagavad-gétä, sometimes called the Gétopaniñad, the cream of all the Upaniñads. In the Bhagavad-gétä [3.9-16], the Personality of Godhead says that no one can attain the state of naiñkarma or akarma without beginning the prescribed duties mentioned in the Vedic literature. The Vedic literature can regulate the working energy of the human being in such a way that one can gradually realize the authority of the Supreme Being. When one realizes the authority of the Personality of Godhead, it is to be understood that he has attained the stage of positive knowledge. At this purified stage of life, where the modes of Nature—namely goodness, passion and ignorance—cannot act, one is enabled to work on the basis of naiñkarma, or work which does not bind one to the cycle of birth and death.

Factually, no one has to do anything more than to render devotional service to the Lord. In the lower stage of life, however, one can not at once adopt the activities of devotional service, nor can one completely stop reactionary work. A conditioned soul is accustomed to working for sense gratification, for his own selfish interest, immediate or extended. An ordinary man wants to work for his own sense enjoyment, and when the principle of sense enjoyment is extended from the individual to include the collective society, nation, or humanity in general, it assumes various attractive names such as altruism, socialism, communism, nationalism, humanitarianism, etc. These isms are certainly very attractive forms of Karma-bandhana, the bondage of one's own work, but the Vedic instruction of Çré Éçopaniñad is as follows: if you actually live for any of the above isms, make them God-centered. There is no harm in becoming a family man, an altruist, socialist, communist, nationalist, or humanitarian—provided all such activities are executed in relation with éçäväsya, the God-centered conception.

God-centered activities are evaluated in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.40] as being so rich that even a little bit of them can save one from the greatest danger. The greatest danger of life is to glide down again into the evolutionary cycle of birth and death. If some way or other a man misses the spiritual opportunity offered by his human form of life, and thus glides down again into the evolutionary cycle, it must be considered the most regrettable incidence, although foolish man cannot see this, due to his defective senses. Çré Éçopaniñad advises us, therefore, to exert our energy in the éçäväsya spirit, and in that engagement we may wish to live for many, many years. Otherwise, one's long life is no better than that of a tree, which is also a living being, and which lives for hundreds and hundreds of years. There is no point in living a long time like the trees, or breathing like the bellows, or begetting children like the hog and the dog, or eating like the camel. Even a humble life, with God-centered activities, is more valuable than the colossal hoax of so-called altruism or socialism without any relation to God.

When activities such as altruism are executed in the spirit of Çré Éçopaniñad, every one of them becomes a form of karma-yoga, as is recommended in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.5-9]. And that guarantees the executor against the dangers of the evolutionary process of birth and death. Such God-centered activities, even though half-finished, are still good for the executor, because they will guarantee him the human form of life in his next birth. In this way he can have another chance to improve his position on the path of liberation.

Iso 3-1969

Mantra Three

@s$auyaAR naAma tae laAek(A
@nDaena tamas$aAva{taA:
taAMstae ‘aetyaAiBagAcC$inta
yae ke( caAtmah"naAe janaA:

TEXT

asuryä näma te lokä

andhena tamasävåtäù

täàs te pretyäbhigacchanti

ye ke cätma-hano janäù.

asuryäù—meant for the asuras; näma—famous by the name; te—those; lokäù—planets; andhena—ignorance; tamasä—darkness; ävåtäù—covered by; tän—there; te—they; pretya—after death; abhigacchanti—do enter into; ye—anyone; ke—everyone; ca—and; ätma-hanaù—the killer of the soul; janäù—persons.

TRANSLATION

The killer of the soul, whoever he may be, must enter into the planets known as the worlds of the faithless, full of darkness and ignorance.

PURPORT

A human life is distinguished from animal life on account of its heavy responsibilities. Those who are cognizant of these responsibilities and work in that spirit are called suras, the godly. And those who are either neglectful of the responsibilities or who have no information about them are called the asuras, or demons. There are only these two kinds of human beings all over the universe. In the Åg Veda it is stated that the suras always aim at the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Lord Viñëu, and act accordingly. Their ways are as illuminated as the path of the Sun.

Intelligent human beings must always remember that this particular form of body is obtained after an evolution of many millions of years of transmigration of the soul. This material world is sometimes compared with an ocean, and this human body is compared with a solid boat, designed to cross over the ocean. The Vedic Scriptures and the äcäryas or saintly teachers, are compared with the expert boatman, and the facilities of a human body are compared with favorable breezes, which can help the boat smoothly ply to the desired destination. If, with all these facilities, a person does not fully utilize his human life for self realization, such an asura must be considered ätma-hana, a killer of the soul. The killer of the soul is destined to enter into the darkest region of ignorance to suffer perpetually, and here is a warning by Çré Éçopaniñad in clear terms.

There are swine, dogs, camels, asses, etc. whose economic necessities are just as important as ours. But the economic problems of these animals are solved under nasty conditions, while the human being is given all facilities for comfortable life by the laws of Nature, because the human form of life, is more important than animal life. And why is man given a better life than the swine and other animals? Why is a highly placed servant given all the facilities of comfortable life, rather than an ordinary clerk? The answer is that the highly placed officer has to discharge duties of a higher nature. Similarly, the human being has higher duties in life than the animals who are engaged always in the business of feeding their hungry stomachs.

The modern soul-killing civilization has only increased the problems of a hungry stomach. We approach some polished animal, a modern civilized man, and he says that he wants to work for the satisfaction of the stomach and there is no necessity for self realization. But the laws of Nature are so cruel that in spite, of his eagerness to work hard for his stomach, there is always the question of unemployment, even after denouncing the prospect of self-realization.

We are given this human form of life not to work hard like the ass, the swine and the dog, but to attain the highest perfection of life. If we do not care for self-realization, it is by the law of Nature that we have to work very hard even though we do not want to do so. In this age the human being has been forced to work hard like the ass and the bull, pulling carts. These are some of the examples of the regions where an asura is sent to work, revealed by this verse of Çré Éçopaniñad. If a man fails to discharge his duties as a human being, he is forced to transmigrate to the planets called asurya in the degraded species of life, to work hard in ignorance and darkness.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [6.41-43] it is also stated that the half-self-realized men who in their previous lives could not complete the process of approaching Godhead but had sincerely tried for it—in other words, those who failed to attain success in realizing their relation with God—are given the chance of appearing in the family of çuci or çrémata. Çuci means a spiritually advanced Brähmaëa, and çrémata means a Vaiçya, or member of the mercantile community. This means that such fallen candidates are given a better chance for culturing self-realization on account of their sincere efforts in past lives. If the fallen candidates are given the chance of taking birth in respectable noble families, we can hardly imagine the state of those who have completely achieved success in the attempt.

Simply to make an attempt for realizing God is to guarantee that the next birth will be in a noble family. But those who do not make any such attempt at all, and who want to be covered by illusion, too materialistic and attached to material enjoyment, must enter into the darkest region of hell, as is confirmed in all the Vedic literature.

Such materialistic asuras sometimes make a show of religiousness with the ultimate aim of material prosperity. The Bhagavad-gétä [16.17-18], however, rebukes them as men called great on the strength of false perfection, empowered by the votes of the ignorant and by material wealth. Such asuras, devoid of self realization and the conception of éçäväsya, the Lord, are sure to enter into the darkest regions.

The, conclusion is that we are not meant only for solving economic problems on a tottering platform, but we are also meant for solving the problems of the material life into which we have been placed by the conditions of Nature.

Iso 4-1969

Mantra Four

@naejade"kM( manas$aAe javaIyaAe
naEnaÚe"vaA @A«auvana, paUvaRmaSaRta,
taÜ"AvataAe'nyaAnatyaeita itaï"ta,
taismaªapaAe maAtair"ìA d"DaAita

TEXT

anejad ekaà manaso javéyo

nainad devä äpnuvan pürvam arñat

tad dhävato 'nyän atyeti tiñöhat

tasminn apo mätariçvä dadhäti.

anejat—fixed up; ekam—one; manasaù—more than the mind; javéyaù—speedy; na—not; enat—this Supreme Lord; deväù—the demigods like Indra, etc.; äpnuvan—can approach; pürvam—the first of all; arñat—one who knows everything; tat—that; dhävataù—those who are running; anyän—others; atyeti—surpasses; tiñöhat—although placed; tasmin—in one place; apaù—water; mätariçvä—the gods who control air and rains; dadhäti—execute.

TRANSLATION

The Personality of Godhead, although fixed in His Abode, is more swift than the mind, and can overcome all others running. The powerful demigods cannot approach Him. Although in one place, He has control over those who supply the air and rain. He surpasses all in excellence.

PURPORT

The Supreme Lord, Who is the Absolute Personality of Godhead, is not knowable even to the greatest philosopher through mental speculation. He can be known only by His devotees through His mercy in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.34] it is said that the non-devotee philosopher who can travel at the speed of the mind, or at the velocity of the air, and who can travel in space for hundreds of years, will find the Absolute still far, far away from him. As described in the Upaniñads, the Absolute Personality of Godhead has His transcendental Abode, known as Kåñëa-loka, where He remains, engaged in His Pastimes. But by His inconceivable potency He can simultaneously reach every part of the creative energy. In the Viñëu Puräëa this potency is compared with the light and heat of the fire. The fire can distribute its light and heat from one place, and similarly the Absolute Personality of Godhead, although fixed up in His transcendental Abode, can diffuse His different energies everywhere.

Such energies are innumerable, but principally they are classified into three: the internal potency, the marginal potency, and the external potency. In each and every one of them, there are hundreds and millions of sub-headings. The dominating demigods who are empowered to have control over the administration of natural phenomena such as the air, light, rain, etc. are all classified within the marginal potency of the Absolute Person. The living beings, including humans, are also products of the marginal potency of the Lord. The material world is the creation of the external potency of the Lord, and the spiritual sky, where the Kingdom of God is situated, is the manifestation of His internal potency.

The different energies of the Supreme Lord are represented everywhere by His different potencies. Although there is no difference between Him and His energies, still one should not wrongly conclude that the Supreme Lord, being thus distributed everywhere, has His Personal existence solely in the impersonal Brahman. Men are accustomed to reach conclusions only according to their own capacity to understand. But the Supreme Lord is not subject to our limited capacity to understand Him. It is for this reason that the Upaniñads warn us: no one can approach the Lord by his own limited potency.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [10.2] the Lord says that no one, not even the great åñis and suras, can know Him. So what is there to say of the asuras, who are not even qualified to understand the ways of the Lord? All these words mentioned in Mantra Four of Çré Éçopaniñad suggest very clearly that the Absolute Truth is ultimately the Absolute Person; otherwise there would have been no necessity of mentioning so many varied things in support of His Personal features.

Individual parts and parcels of the potencies of the Lord, although having all the symptoms of the Lord Himself, have limited spheres of activities, and therefore are all limited. The parts and parcels are never equal to the whole. Therefore the parts and parcels cannot appreciate the full potency of the Lord. Foolish and ignorant living beings who are parts and parcels of the Lord, under the influence of the material energy, try to make a conjecture on the transcendental position of the Lord. Çré Éçopaniñad warns them not to make any mental speculation about the identity of the Lord. Try to know the Transcendence from the superior source of the Vedas, which is already in knowledge of the Transcendence.

Every part of the Complete Whole is endowed with some particular energy to act, and forgetfulness by that part of his particular activities is called mäyä, illusion. Çré Éçopaniñad has therefore, from the very beginning, warned us that we should be careful to play the part designated for us by the Lord. This, however, does not mean that the individual soul has no initiative of his own. Because he is the part and parcel of the Lord he must have the initiative of the Lord as well. Proper use of one's initiative, active nature, with intelligence to understand that everything is but the potency of the Lord, can lead one to the revival of his original consciousness, which was lost on account of association with mäyä, the external energy.

All power is obtained from the Lord, and therefore each particular power must be utilized to execute the will of the Lord, and not otherwise. The Lord can be known by one who has adopted a submissive attitude. Perfect knowledge means to know the Lord in all His features, to know about His potencies and how such potencies are working by His will. These things are exclusively described by the Lord in the Bhagavad-gétä, which is the essence of all the Upaniñads.

Iso 5-1969

Mantra Five

tade"jaita taªaEjaita
taä," äU"re" taã"intake(
tad"ntar"sya s$avaRsya
taäu" s$avaRsyaAsya baA÷ta:

TEXT

tad ejati tan naijati

tad düre tad vantike

tad antarasya sarvasya

tad u sarvasyäsya bähyataù.

tat—this Supreme Lord; ejati—does walk; tat—He; na—not; ejati—does walk; tat—He (is); düre—far away; tat—He (is); u—also; antike—very near; tat—He (is); antar—within; asya—of this; sarvasya—all; tat—He (is); u—also; sarvasya—all; asya—of this; bähyataù—external to.

TRANSLATION

The Supreme Lord walks and does not walk. He is far away, but He is very near as well. He is within everything, and again He is outside of everything.

PURPORT

Here is an explanation of the Supreme Lord's transcendental activities by His inconceivable potencies. There are two sets of contradictory words mentioned herein to prove the inconceivable potency of the Lord. He walks, and He does not walk. These two phrases are contradictory. If someone can walk then it is improper to say that he cannot walk. These contradictions show the inconceivable power of God. With our limited fund of knowledge we cannot accommodate such things, and therefore the Lord is conceived in terms of our limited powers of understanding. The impersonalist philosophers of the mäyä-väda school accept only the impersonalist part of the Lord's activities, and refute His Personal feature. The Bhägavata school, however, accepts the Lord in both ways, i.e., as Personal and impersonal. And the Bhägavatas also accept His inconceivable potencies. Without inconceivable potency there is no meaning to the words Supreme Lord.

We should not take it for granted that because we cannot see God before our eyes there is therefore no personal existence of the Lord. To refute this sort of argument, Çré Éçopaniñad warns us that the Lord is far away from us, but He is very near to us also. The Abode of the Lord is beyond the material sky. We have no means to measure even the material sky. If just the material sky is so far, far away from us, then what of the spiritual sky, which is beyond the material sky altogether? That the spiritual sky is situated far, far away from the material world is further confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.6]. But, in spite of the Lord's being so far away, He can at once, within less than a second, descend before us with a speed more powerful than the mind or the air. He can walk so quickly that no one can surpass Him, This fact has already been described in the previous verse.

When the Personality of Godhead thus comes before us, however, we neglect Him. This negligence on the part of the foolish people, is condemned by the Lord in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.11]. The Lord says that the foolish deride Him, taking Him to be one of the mortal beings. But He is not a mortal being, nor does He come before us with a body produced of material Nature. There are many so-called scholars who say that when the Lord descends, He does so in a body of matter, just like an ordinary living being. Such foolish men place the Lord on a level equal to that of the ordinary man, not knowing His inconceivable power.

Because He is full of inconceivable potencies, God can accept our service through any sort of medium, and He can convert His different potencies according to His own will. The unbelievers argue that the Lord cannot incarnate Himself, or if at all, He descends in a form of material energy. This argument is nullified if we accept His inconceivable potencies as realities. Even if He appears before us in the form of material energy, it is quite possible for Him to convert the material energy into spiritual energy. The source of the energies being one and the same, the energies can be utilized suitably according to the will of that energetic Source. For example, the Lord appears in the Form of Arca, or Deities supposedly made of earth or stone. These forms, engraved from wood or stone or any other matter, are not idols, however, as is held by the iconoclasts.

In the present state of our imperfect material existence we cannot see the Supreme Lord on account of our imperfect vision. But still, those devotees who want to see Him by means of material vision are favored by the Lord, Who appears in so-called material form to accept the devotees' service. This does not mean that such devotees, who are in the lowest stage of devotional service, are worshiping an idol. In fact, they are worshiping the Lord, Who has agreed to appear before them in a particular way which is approachable by them. This Arca Form is not fashioned in terms of the order or whim of the worshiper. It is eternally existent with all Its paraphernalia. This can be actually felt by a sincere devotee, but not by an atheist.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [4.11] the Lord says that He treats His devotee in proportion to the degree of surrender made by the devotee. He reserves the right not to expose Himself to anyone and everyone, except those who surrender unto Him. Therefore, for the surrendered soul, He is always within reach, whereas for the non-surrendered soul, He is far, far away, and cannot be approached.

There are two words in the revealed Scriptures which are important in this connection: saguëa and nirguëa—with qualities and without qualities. Saguëa does not mean that the Lord becomes subject to the laws of material Nature when He appears, although He has qualities and appears in the material form. For Him there is no difference between material and spiritual energies, because He is the Source of such energies. He is the Controller of the different energies, and as such He cannot at any time be under their influence, as we are. The material energy works according to His direction, and therefore He can use the material energy for His purpose, but without ever being influenced by any of the qualities of His energies. Nor for this purpose does He become a formless entity at any time. Ultimately He is the eternal Form, the Primeval Lord. And the impersonal representation, or Brahman effulgence, is the glow of His Personal rays, as the Sun's rays are the glow of the Sun god.

When the boy saint Prahläda Mahäräj was in the presence of his atheist father, his father asked him, "Where is your God?" The child Prahläda replied that God resides everywhere. The father then angrily asked whether his God was within the pillar of the palace, and the child said yes. At once the atheist king broke the pillar in front of him into pieces, at which the Lord appeared as Nåsiàha (the half-man, half-lion Incarnation) from within the pillar, and killed the atheist king. This means that the Lord is within everything, which is created by His different energies. And by His inconceivable power He can appear at any place in order to favor His sincere devotee. Lord Nåsiàha appeared from within the pillar not at the order of the atheist king, but by the wish of the devotee Prahläda. An atheist cannot order the Lord to appear, but to show mercy to His devotee the Lord can appear anywhere and everywhere.

The Bhagavad-gétä [4.8] confirms this, in the statement that the Lord appears to vanquish the unbelievers and to protect the believers. To vanquish an unbeliever, of course, the Lord has sufficient energies and agents who can do the work, but to favor the devotee is a pleasing task for Him, and therefore He descends as an incarnation. He does so only to favor His devotees, then, and not for any other purpose.

In the Brahma-saàhitä [5.35] it is said that Govinda, the Primeval Lord, enters everything by His plenary portion. He enters the universe as well as the atom of the universe. He is outside in the Viräöa Form, and He is within as Antaryämé. As Antaryämé He is witness of everything that we are doing, and He gives us the result of our actions as karma-phala. We ourselves may forget what we have done in previous lives, but because the Lord is the witness of our actions, the result of our actions is always there, and we have to undergo the reactions all the same.

In fact there is nothing except God within and without. Everything is manifested of His different energies, like the heat and light of fire, which means there is a oneness among the diverse energies. In spite of this oneness, however, the Lord enjoys in His Personal Form all that is enjoyable to the little senses of the little part and parcel living entities.

Iso 6-1969

Mantra Six

yastau s$avaARiNA BaUtaA-
nyaAtmanyaevaAnaupazyaita
s$avaRBaUtaeSau caAtmaAnaM
tataAe na ivajaugAups$atae

TEXT

yas tu sarväëi bhütäny

ätmany evänupaçyati

sarva-bhüteñu cätmänaà

tato na vijugupsate.

yaù—a person; tu—but; sarväëi—all; bhütäni—living entities; ätmani—in relation with the Supreme Lord; eva—only; anupaçyati—observes in a systematic way; sarva-bhüteñu—in every living being; ca—and; ätmänam—the Supersoul; tataù—thereafter; na—not; vijugupsate—hates anyone.

TRANSLATION

A person who sees everything in relation to the Supreme Lord, and sees all entities as His parts and parcels, and who sees the Supreme Lord within everything, never hates anything, nor any being.

PURPORT

Here is an explanation of the Mahäbhägavata, the great personality who sees everything in relation to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. There are three stages of realizing the presence of the Supreme Lord: The kaniñöha adhikäré, the person who is in the lowest stage of realization of the Lord, goes to one place of worship, such as a temple, church, or mosque, in terms of his particular type of religious faith, and worships there in terms of the scriptural injunctions. Such devotees think that the Lord is there at the place of worship and nowhere else. Such devotees cannot recognize who is in what position in the devotional line, or in terms of realization of the Supreme Lord. They follow the routine formulas and sometimes quarrel among themselves, estimating one particular type of worship better than another. These kaniñöha adhikärés, in the lowest stage of devotion, are called materialistic devotees, or those just trying to transcend the material boundary to reach the spiritual plane.

Next above these kaniñöha adhikärés are the madhyam adhikärés, the devotees who are in the intermediate stage of devotional service. These madhyam adhikärés observe four principles in relation to the Supreme Lord, which are as follows:

1. They see, first of all, the Supreme Lord;
2. They see next the devotees of the Lord;
3. They see also the innocent, who have no knowledge about God; and at last,
4. They see the atheists who have no faith in the Lord, and who hate those in the devotional line.

The madhyam adhikäré devotee behaves differently toward the different above-mentioned four principles. He adores the Lord, considering Him the object of love, and he makes friendship with those who are in the devotional line. He tries to awaken the dormant love of Godhead in the hearts of the innocent people, but he does not approach the atheists who deride at the very Name of the Lord.

Above the madhyam adhikäré there is the uttama adhikäré devotee, who sees everything in relation to the Supreme Lord. He does not make any particular discrimination between the atheist and the theist, but sees in every one of them the part and parcel of God. He knows that there is no difference between a vastly learned Brähmaëa and a dog in the street, because both of them are of the Lord, though in different embodiments due to the different qualities of material action. The Brähmaëa particle of the Supreme Lord has not misused the little independence given him by the Lord, but the dog particle has misused his independence, and thus he has been punished by the law of Nature, being encaged in the ignorant form of a dog. Without considering the respective actions of the Brähmaëa and the dog, the uttama adhikäré tries to do good to both. Such a learned devotee of the Lord is not misled by the material bodies of the Brähmaëa and the dog, but he is attracted by the spiritual spark within the respective entities.

Those who imitate an uttama adhikäré in terms of the sense of oneness or fellowship, but who behave in terms of bodily relationships, are false philanthropists. Therefore the concept of universal brotherhood must be learnt from the uttama adhikäré devotee of the Lord, and not from a foolish person who has no proper vision of the individual soul and of the Supersoul—the plenary expansion of the Supreme Lord, Which dwells everywhere.

In this mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad it is clearly mentioned that one should observe, or see. This means one must follow the previous äcärya, the perfected Teacher. Anupaçyati is the exact Sanskrit word used in this connection. Anu means by following, and paçyati means to observe. One should not try to see things as he does with the naked eye. The naked eye cannot see anything properly, due to its material defectiveness. One cannot see properly unless one has heard from a superior source. And the highest source is the Vedic wisdom spoken by the Lord Himself. This truth is coming in disciplic succession from the Lord to Brahmä, from Brahmä to Närada, from Närada to Vyäsa, and from Vyäsa to many of His disciples. Formerly there was no necessity of recording the message of the Vedas because people of earlier ages were more intelligent and had sharper memories, and they could follow instructions simply by hearing once from the mouth of a bona fide spiritual master.

At present there are many commentaries on the revealed Scriptures, but most of them are not in the line of Çréla Vyäsadeva, Who originally taught the Vedic wisdom. The final, most perfect and sublime work of Çréla Vyäsadeva is the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Which is the correct commentary on the Vedänta-sütra. Similarly, there is the Bhagavad-gétä, Which is spoken by the Lord Himself and Which was recorded by Vyäsadeva. These are the more important of the many revealed Scriptures, and any commentary which does not conform to the principles of the Gétä or the Çrémad-Bhägavatam is unauthorized. There is complete symmetrical agreement between the Upaniñads, Vedänta, the Vedas, the Bhagavad-gétä and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Therefore, no one should try to reach any conclusion about the Vedas without being instructed by members of the line of Vyäsadeva, or at least those who believe in the Personality of Godhead and His diverse energies.

Only one who is already in the liberated status, according to the Bhagavad-gétä [18.54], can become an uttama adhikäré devotee, and can see everyone or every living being as his own brother. This cannot be seen by politicians who are always after some material gain. Imitation of this liberated status is to serve the outward body (for fame, or some such reward) but is not service to the spirit soul. Such imitators have no information of the Spiritual World. The uttama adhikäré sees the spirit soul of an entity, and serves him as spirit, which includes matter automatically.

Iso 7-1969

Mantra Seven

yaismana, s$avaARiNA BaUtaA-
nyaAtmaEvaABaUiã"jaAnata:
ta‡a k(Ae maAeh": k(: zAAek(
Wk(tvamanaupazyata:

TEXT

yasmin sarväëi bhütäny

ätmaiväbhüd vijänataù

tatra ko mohaù kaù çoka

ekatvam anupaçyataù.

yasmin—in the situation; sarväëi—all; bhütäni—living entities; ätmä—the spiritual spark; eva—only; abhüt—becomes a fact; vijänataù—one who knows; tatra—therein; kaù—what; mohaù—illusion; çokaù—anxiety; ekatvam—of the same quality; anupaçyataù—one who sees through authority, or one who sees constantly like that.

TRANSLATION

One who always sees all living entities as spiritual sparks, in quality one with the Lord, becomes a true knower of things. What is there as illusion or anxiety for him?

PURPORT

Except for the two more advanced devotees described above, no one can correctly see the spiritual position of a living being. The living entities are qualitatively one with the Supreme Lord, as the sparks of the fire are qualitatively one with the nature of the fire. But sparks are not fire as far as quantity is concerned. The quantity of heat and light present in the fire is not equal to the quantity of heat and light in the sparks. The Mahäbhägavata, the great devotee, sees oneness in the sense that everything is the energy of the Supreme Lord. And as there is no difference between the energy and the energetic, there is the sense of oneness. Without heat and light there is no meaning of fire, and yet heat and light from the analytical point of view are different from fire. But in synthesis, heat, light, and fire are all the same one thing.

The Sanskrit words found here, ekatvam anupaçyataù, mean to see the unity of the living entities from the viewpoint of the revealed Scriptures. Every individual spark of the Supreme Whole has almost eighty per cent of the known qualities of the Whole, but they are not as good as the Supreme Lord. These qualities are present in minute quantity, as the living entity is but a minute part and parcel of the Supreme Whole. This is like the drop of water and the ocean: The quantity of salt present in the drop is never comparable to the quantity of salt present in the complete ocean. But the quality of the salt present in the drop is equal in quality, in chemical composition, with that present in the ocean.

If the individual living being were equal both in quality and in quantity, then there would be no question of the living entity's being submerged by the influence of material energy. It has already been discussed in previous mantras that no living being, even the powerful demigods, can surpass the Supreme Being in any respect. Therefore ekatvam does not mean that a living being is equal in all respects with the Supreme Lord. It means, in a broader sense, that there is one interest, just as in a family the interest of all the members is one. In a nation, although different individual citizens are there, the national interest is one. Therefore, the living entities being parts and parcels of the same Supreme family, the interest of the Supreme Being and that of the parts and parcels is not different. Every living being is the son of the Supreme Being. As it is said in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.5-6], all living creatures, including birds, reptiles, ants, aquatics, trees, and so on, all over the universe—all are emanations from the marginal potency of the Supreme Lord. And therefore all of them belong to the same family of the Supreme Being. There is no clash of interest in spiritual life.

The spiritual entities are meant for enjoyment. By nature, by constitution, every living being—both the Supreme Lord and each different part and parcel—is meant for enjoyment eternally. The living beings who are encaged in the material tabernacle are also seeking enjoyment always, but they are seeking their enjoyment on a platform which is not meant for them. Aside from this material world, there is the spiritual platform where the Supreme Being is enjoying with His innumerable associates, without any trace of material qualities. That platform is called nirguëa. On the nirguëa platform there is no clash of enjoyment. Here in the material world there is always a clash between different individual beings, because here the center of enjoyment is missed. The center of enjoyment is the Supreme Lord, Who is the center of the sublime and spiritual räsa dance. We are all meant for joining Him, and for enjoying life with one transcendental interest and without any clash. That is the high platform of spiritual interest, and as soon as such a perfect form of oneness is realized there can be no question of illusion or lamentation.

Mäyä, or illusion, means a Godless civilization, the result of which is lamentation. The Godless civilization sponsored by the modern politicians is always full of anxieties, and that is the law of Nature. No one can surpass this law, as is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.14]. Only those who surrender at the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Lord can overcome the stringent laws of Nature. If, therefore, we wish to get rid of all sorts of illusion and anxiety and create unity of all diverse interests, we must bring God into all our activities.

The results of our activities must be used to serve the interest of the Lord, and not for any other purpose, because only by serving the interest of the Lord can we feel the ätma-bhüta interest mentioned here in Çré Éçopaniñad. This and the Brahma-bhüta interest mentioned in the Bhagavad-gétä are one and the same thing: The Supreme Ätman, or Soul, is the Lord Himself, and the minute ätman is the living entity. The Supreme Ätman or Paramätman alone maintains all the individual minute beings, because the Supreme Lord wants to derive pleasure out of their affection. The father extends himself by his children and maintains them in order to derive pleasure. If the children of the father are obedient to his will, family affairs will run smoothly with one interest and a pleasing atmosphere. Exactly the same thing is transcendentally arranged in the Brahman, or Absolute family of the Param Brahman, the Supreme Spirit.

The Param Brahman is as much a Person as the individual entities are. None of them are impersonal. Such transcendental personalities are full of transcendental bliss, knowledge and life eternal. That is the real position of spiritual existence, and as soon as one is fully cognizant of this transcendental position he at once surrenders unto the Lotus Feet of the Supreme Being, Çré Kåñëa. But such mahätmäs, Great Souls, are very rarely seen, because such transcendental realization is achieved only after many, many births. Once attained, however, there is no more illusion or distress, no more of the misery of material existence, and there is no birth and death as we experience in the present status of our life. That is the information we get from this mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad.

Iso 8-1969

Mantra Eight

s$a payaRgAAcC]$‚(mak(Ayama˜aNA-
maµaAivar"mzAuÜ"mapaApaivaÜ"-
mk(ivamaRnaISaI pair"BaU: svayamBaU-
yaARTaAtaTyataAe'TaARna, vyad"DaAcC$AìtaIBya: s$amaABya:

TEXT

sa paryagäc chukram akäyam avraëam

asnäviraà çuddham apäpa-viddham

kavir manéñé paribhüù svayambhür

yäthätathyato 'rthän vyadadhäc chäçvatébhyaù samäbhyaù.

saù—that person; paryagät—must know in fact; çukram—the omnipotent; akäyam—unembodied; avraëam—without any reproach; asnäviram—without any veins; çuddham—antiseptic; apäpa-viddham—prophylactic; kaviù—omniscient; manéñé—philosopher; paribhüù—the greatest of all; svayambhüù—self-sufficient; yäthätathyataù—just in pursuance of; arthän—desirables; vyadadhät—awards; çäçvatébhyaù—immemorial; samäbhyaù—time.

TRANSLATION

Such a person must know in fact the Greatest of all, Who is unembodied, omniscient, beyond reproach, without veins, pure and uncontaminate, the self-sufficient Philosopher Who is awarding everyone's desire since time immemorial.

PURPORT

Here is the description of the transcendental and eternal Form of the Absolute Personality of Godhead. The Supreme Lord is not formless. He has His own transcendental Form Which is not at all similar to those of the mundane world. The living entities in this world have their forms embodied by the material Nature, and they work like any material machines. The physiological and anatomical structure of the body of a living being must have a mechanical construction, with veins and so forth in the embodiment. But in the transcendental body of the Lord there is nothing like veins. It is clearly stated here that He is unembodied. That means that there is no difference between His body and soul, nor does He accept a body by the law of Nature as we do. In the material concept of bodily life, the soul is different from the gross embodiment and subtle mind. The Supreme Lord is apart from any such compartmentalized arrangement, however. There is nothing like a difference of body and mind in the Supreme Lord. He is the Complete Whole, and His mind and body and He Himself are all one and the same.

In the Brahma-saàhitä there is a similar description of the body of the Supreme Lord. He is described there as the sac-cid-änanda-vigraha. This means that He is the eternal Form fully representing transcendental Existence, Knowledge and Bliss. The Vedic literature states clearly that He has a completely different kind of transcendental body, and thus He is sometimes described as formless. This formlessness means that He has no form like ours, or that He is devoid of a form which we can perceive. In the Brahma-saàhitä [5.32] it is further said that the Lord can do anything and everything with any one of the parts of His body. It is said there that with each and every one of the parts of His body, such as the hand, He can do the work of the other senses. This means that the Lord can walk with His hands, He can accept a thing by His legs, He can see by His hands and feet, and He can eat by His eyes. In the Çruti mantras it is said that He has no hands and no legs like us, but that He has a different type of hand and leg, by which He can accept all that we offer Him, and walk faster than anyone anywhere. These things are confirmed in this mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad by the use of words like omnipotent.

The Lord's Çré Vigraha, His worshipable form, Which is installed in the temples by authorized äcäryas who have realized the Lord in terms of Mantra Seven, is also non-different from the Original Form of the Lord. The Original Form of the Lord is that of Çré Kåñëa. Çré Kåñëa expands Himself by an unlimited number of Forms like Baladeva, Räma, Nåsiàha, Varäha, etc.—and all of These are one and the same Personality of Godhead.

Similarly, the Arcä-vigraha Which is worshiped in the temples is also an expanded Form of the Lord. By worshiping the Arcä-vigraha of the Lord, one can at once approach the Lord, Who accepts the service of the devotee by His omnipotent energy without any reproach. The Vigraha of the Lord descends by request of the äcäryas, the holy teachers, and works exactly in the original way by His omnipotent energy.

Foolish people who have no knowledge of these mantras of Çré Éçopaniñad, or of any other Çruti mantras, consider that the Çré Vigraha Who is worshiped by the pure devotees is made of material elements. To the imperfect eyes of the foolish people, or to the kaniñöha adhikaris, this Form is considered material. But such people with little knowledge do not know that the Lord, being omnipotent and omniscient, can transform matter into spirit and spirit into matter, as He desires.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.11-12], the Lord regrets the fallen condition of men with little knowledge, who regard the body of the Lord as material because He descends like a man into this world. Such poorly informed persons do not know the omnipotence of the Lord. To the mental speculators, therefore, the Lord does not manifest Himself in fullness. He can be appreciated only in proportion to one's surrender to Him. And the fallen condition of the living entities is due entirely to forgetfulness of our relationship with God.

In this mantra, as well as in many others in the Vedas, it is clearly mentioned: from time immemorial, the Lord is supplying. The living being first of all desires, and then the Lord supplies the object of desire in proportion to the degree of qualification. If a man wants to be a high court judge he must not only have acquired the necessary qualifications, but he must also depend upon the disposition of the authority concerned, who can award the title of high court judge. Simple acquisition of the qualifications of a high court judge is not sufficient in order to occupy the post. This must be awarded by some superior authority. Similarly, the Lord awards enjoyment to the living being in proportion to his qualifications—in other words, by the law of karma. Those qualifications, however, are not sufficient without the mercy of the Lord.

Ordinarily the living being does not know what to ask for from the Lord or what post to qualify himself for. When the living being knows his constitutional position, however, he asks to be accepted into the transcendental association of the Lord, in order to render transcendental loving service unto Him. Instead of asking for this, the living being under the influence of material Nature asks for many other things, and his mentality is described in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.41] as divided, or splayed, intelligence. Spiritual intelligence is one, but the opposite number is of many varieties. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [Bhäg. 7.5.30-31] it is said that persons who are captivated by the temporary beauties of the external energy forget their real aim of life, which is to go back to Godhead. Forgetting this, one tries to adjust things by various plans and programs, which are compared with the process of chewing already chewed refuse. But the Lord is so kind that He allows the forgetful living being to do so without interfering in his activities. If a living being wants to go to hell, the Lord allows him to do so without interference, and if he wants to go back to home, back to Godhead, the Lord also helps him to do that.

God is described here as paribhüù, the greatest of all. No one, is greater than, or equal to Him. Other living beings are described here as beggars who ask from the Lord, and the Lord supplies their desirables. If other entities were equal to the Lord in potency, or if they were omnipotent or omniscient, there would be no question of begging from the Lord even for so-called liberation. The real liberation of the living being is to go back to Godhead. Liberation as conceived by the impersonalist remains a myth, and the begging business for sense gratification has to continue eternally, unless the beggar comes to his senses and realizes his constitutional position.

The Supreme Lord is self-sufficient. When Lord Kåñëa appeared on earth 5,000 years ago, He displayed the full manifestation of Godhead by His various activities. In His childhood He killed many powerful demons, and there was no question of His having acquired such power through any extraneous endeavor. He lifted Govardhana Hill without any practicing of weight-lifting. He danced with the gopés without any social restriction, and without any reproach. Although the gopés approached Him with feelings of amorous of love, the mixing of the gopés and Lord Kåñëa has been worshiped even by Lord Caitanya, Who was a strict sannyäsin and rigid follower of disciplinary regulations. To confirm this, Çré Éçopaniñad says that He is "antiseptic" and "prophylactic," pure and uncontaminate. He is antiseptic in the sense that even an impure thing in the estimation of the mundane world can become purified just by touching Him. The word prophylactic refers to His association, and is mentioned in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.30-31]. There it is said that a scrupulous devotee may appear in the beginning to be duräcära, not well behaved. Yet he is still to be accepted as pure because he is on the right path. That is the prophylactic nature of the Lord's association.

The Lord is also apäpaviddham, that is, nothing like sin can touch Him. Even if He may do something which appears to be sinful, such actions are all good, for there is no question of the Lord's being affected by sin. He is çuddham, most purified, often compared to the Sun. The Sun extracts moisture from many untouchable places on the earth, and itself remains pure. In fact it purifies obnoxious things by its sterilizing effect. If the Sun is so powerful, , although only a material object, we can imagine the purity and strength of the All-powerful Lord.

Iso 9-1969

Mantra Nine

@nDaM tama: ‘aivazAinta yae'ivaâAmaupaAs$atae
tataAe BaUya wva tae tamaAe ya o ivaâAyaA•ataA:

TEXT

andhaà tamaù praviçanti

ye 'vidyäm upäsate

tato bhüya iva te tamo

ya u vidyäyäà ratäù.

andham—gross ignorance; tamaù—darkness; praviçanti—enter into; ye—those; avidyäm—nescience; upäsate—worship; tataù—further; bhüyaù—considered; iva—like; te—those; tamaù—darkness; ye—those; u—also; vidyäyäm—in the culture of knowledge; ratäù—engaged in.

TRANSLATION

Those who are engaged in the culture of nescient activities shall enter into the darkest region of ignorance. Worse still are those engaged in the so-called culture of knowledge.

PURPORT

In this mantra there is a comparative study of vidyä and avidyä. Avidyä, or ignorance, is undoubtably dangerous, but vidyä, or knowledge, when mistaken or misguided, is even more dangerous. In modern human civilization this explanation of Çré Éçopaniñad is more applicable than at any other time, in the past. Modern civilization has advanced considerably in the matter of mass education, and yet the result is that people are more unhappy than before on account of too much stress on material advancement, without any taste for the most important aspect of life, the spiritual aspect.

As far as vidyä is concerned, the first mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad has explained very clearly that the Supreme Lord is the Proprietor of everything, and forgetfulness of this fact is called ignorance. The more a man forgets this fact of life, the more he is in darkness; and in view of this, a Godless civilization directed toward the so-called advancement of education is more dangerous than a civilization in which the mass of people are less advanced.

There are different classes of men, called karmis, jïänins and yogis. The karmis are those who are engaged in the activities of sense gratification. Almost 99.9 per cent of the people in modern civilization are engaged in the activities of sense gratification under the flags of various activities such as industrialism, economic development, altruism, political consciousness, and so on. But all these activities are more or less based on the satisfaction of the senses, without any reference to the sort of God consciousness described in the first mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad.

In the language of the Bhagavad-gétä, people who are engaged in gross sense gratification are müòhas—in darkness like the ass, the symbol of stupidity. People who are simply engaged in the pursuit of sense gratification, without any real profit in life, are in the estimation of Çré Éçopaniñad worshiping avidyä. And those who play the role of helping this sort of civilization in the name of educational advancement are doing more harm than those who are on the platform of gross sense gratification. The advancement of learning by the Godless people is as dangerous as a valuable jewel on the hood of a cobra. The cobra decorated with such a valuable jewel is quite as dangerous as one which is not so decorated.

Again, the advancement of educational activities by a Godless people is, according to the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya [3.11], a decoration for a dead body. In India as in many other countries, some people follow the custom of leading a procession with a decorated dead body for the pleasure of the lamenting relatives. In the same sense, modern civilization is a patchwork of activities meant to cover the perpetual miseries of material existence. Such activities are targetted toward sense gratification, but above the senses there is the mind, and above the mind there is the intelligence, and above intelligence there is the soul. Therefore, the aim of education should be self realization, realization of the spiritual values of the soul. Any education which does not lead to such a realization of life must be considered avidyä, or nescience. And to culture such nescience means going down to the darkest region of ignorance.

Such mistaken educators are known in the Vedic language by four names:

1. veda-väda-rata, [Bg. 2.42]

2. mäyayä apahåta-jïäna,
3. äsuraà bhävam,
4. narädhama. [Bg. 7.15]

The veda-väda-rata people pose themselves as very learned in the Vedic literature, but unfortunately they are completely diverted from the purpose of the Vedas. In the Bhagavad-gétä [15.15] it is said that the purpose of the Vedas is to know the Personality of Godhead, but these veda-väda-rata men are not at all interested in the Personality of Godhead. On the contrary, they are fascinated by such results as the attainment of heaven.

As is said in Mantra One of Çré Éçopaniñad, we should know that the Personality of Godhead is the Proprietor of everything, and we must be satisfied with our alloted portion of the necessities of life. The purpose of the whole Vedic literature is to awaken this God consciousness in the forgetful living being, and the same principle is presented in various ways in the world's various Scriptures for the understanding of foolish mankind. Thus the ultimate purpose is to bring one back to Godhead.

But the veda-väda-rata [Bg. 2.42] people, instead of realizing the purport of the Vedas, take it for granted that side issues such as the attainment of heavenly pleasure for sense gratification—the lust for which is the very cause of their material bondage in the first place—is the ultimate end of the Vedas. Such people misguide others by misinterpreting the Vedic literature, and sometimes they condemn the Puräëas, which are authentic Vedic explanations for laymen. The veda-väda-ratas make their own explanations of the Vedas, neglecting the authority of the great teachers, called äcäryas; and they tend to raise some unscrupulous person from among themselves as the leading exponent of Vedic knowledge.

These men are especially condemned by this mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad with the very appropriate Sanskrit word vidyä-rata. Vidyä means Veda, because the Veda is the original in all knowledge; and rata means engaged. Vidyä-rata means engaged in the study of the Vedas. As such, the so-called vidyä-ratas are condemned here because they do not know what the purpose of the Vedas is, on account of disobeying the äcäryas. Such veda-väda-ratas are accustomed to finding meaning in every word of the Vedas to suit their own purposes. They do not know that the Vedic literature is not a collection of ordinary books and cannot be understood except through the chain of disciplic succession.

One must approach a bona fide spiritual master in order to understand the transcendental message of the Vedas. That is the direction of the Kaöha Upaniñad. But these veda-väda-rata people have their own äcärya, who is not in the chain of transcendental disciplic succession. Thus they will progress into the darkest region of ignorance by misinterpreting the Vedic literature, even more so than those who have no knowledge of the Vedas at all.

The mäyayä apahåta-jïäna class of men are self-made "Gods." Such men think that they are themselves God, and there is no necessity of worshiping any other God. They will agree to worship an ordinary man if he happens to be rich, but will never worship the actual Personality of Godhead. Such foolish men cannot recognize their own foolishness, regarding the question of how God can ever have been entrapped by illusion. If God were ever entrapped by illusion, then illusion would be more powerful than God. But they also say that God is all powerful. If God is all-powerful, then how can He be over-powered by illusion? The self-made Gods cannot answer all these questions very clearly, but they are satisfied that they have become God themselves.

Iso 10-1969

Mantra Ten

@nyade"vaAò"ivaRâyaA-
nyad"Aò"r"ivaâyaA
wita zAu™auma DaIr"ANAAM
yae nastaiã"cacaiºare"

TEXT

anyad evähur vidyayä

anyad ähur avidyayä

iti çuçruma dhéräëäà

ye nas tad vicacakñire.

anyat—different; eva—certainly; ähuù—said; vidyayä—by culture of knowledge; anyat—different; ähuù—said; avidyayä—nescience; iti—thus; çuçruma—heard; dhéräëäm—from the sober sect; ye—those; naù—to us; tat—that; vicacakñire—explained.

TRANSLATION

The wise have explained to us that one result is derived from the culture of knowledge, and it is said that a different result is obtained from the culture of nescience.

PURPORT

The culture of knowledge can be practically conducted in the following way, as is advised in the Bhagavad-gétä (Thirteenth Chapter). There it is said that:

1. One should become a perfect gentleman himself, and learn to give proper respect to persons other than himself.

2. One, should not pose himself as a religionist simply for name, and fame.

3. One should not become a source of anxiety to others by the actions of his body, mind or words.

4. One should learn forbearance, even if there is provocation from others.

5. One should learn to avoid duplicity in his dealings with others.

6. One must have a bona fide spiritual master who can lead him gradually to the stage of spiritual realization, and to such an äcärya or spiritual master he must submit himself with service and relevant questions.

7. One must follow the regulative principles enjoined in the revealed Scriptures, in order to approach the platform of self realization.

8. One must be fixed up in the tenets of the revealed Scriptures.

9. One should completely refrain from practices which are detrimental to the interest of self realization.

10. One should not accept more than what he requires for the maintenance of the body.

11. One should not falsely identify himself with the material covering of the gross body nor consider as his own those who are related with his body.

12. One should always remember that so long as he has a material body, he must face the miseries of repeated birth, death, old age, and disease. There is no use in making plans to get rid of these miseries of the material body. The best thing is to find out the means by which one may regain his spiritual identity.

13. One should not be attached to more than the necessities of life required for spiritual advancement.

14. One should not be more attached to wife, children and home than is ordained in the revealed Scriptures.

15. One should not be happy or distressed in regard to the desirables and undesirables created by the mind.

16. One should become an unalloyed devotee of the Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, and serve Him with rapt attention.

17. One should develop a feeling for residing in a secluded place with a calm and quiet atmosphere favorable for spiritual culture, and thus avoid congested places where the nondevotees congregate.

18. One should become a scientist or philosopher, and make research into spiritual knowledge—not material knowledge—recognizing that spiritual knowledge is permanent, whereas material knowledge ends with the death of the body.

These eighteen items form a gradual process for developing real knowledge. Except for these eighteen items, all other items whatever are grouped within the category of nescience. Çréla Bhaktivinode Öhäkur, a great äcärya, said that all the forms of material knowledge are merely external features of the illusory energy, and by culturing them one becomes no better than an ass. Here in Çré Éçopaniñad the same principle is repeated. Material advancement of knowledge means actually converting a human being to the status of an ass. Some materialistic politicians, under cover of spiritual garments, do decry the present system of civilization as satanic, but unfortunately they do not care for the culture of real knowledge which is described in the Bhagavad-gétä, and therefore they cannot change the satanic situation.

In the modern setup of things, even a boy thinks himself self-sufficient, and pays no respect to elderly men. Thus, due to the wrong type of education imparted by our universities, boys all over the world have become the cause of headache to the elderly people. Therefore Çré Éçopaniñad warns very strongly that the culture of nescience is different from that of knowledge. The universities are, so to speak, centers of nescience only, and therefore the scientists are busy discovering lethal weapons to wipe out the existence of other countries.

University students today are not given instructions on the regulative principles of brahmäcärya, the spiritual process of life, nor do they have any faith in the respective scriptural injunctions. Religious principles are taught for the sake of name and fame only, and not for the matter of practical action. Therefore there is animosity not only in the social and political fields, but in the field of religion as well.

Nationalism in different parts of the world has also developed on account of this nescient education of the people. They have no information that this tiny earth is just a lump of matter floating in immeasurable material space along with many other lumps. In comparison to the vastness of space, these material lumps are like dust particles in the air. Because God has kindly made these lumps of matter complete in themselves, they are perfectly equipped with all necessary arrangements for floating on in space. Our sputnik drivers are very proud of their achievements, but they do not look to the Supreme Driver of these greater, more gigantic sputniks called planets.

There are innumerable suns occupying space, with innumerable arrangements of planetary systems. We small creatures, as the infinitesimal parts and parcels of the Supreme Lord, are trying to dominate these unlimited planets by repeated birth and death, but are generally frustrated by old age and disease. This span of human life is scheduled for about 100 years, although it is gradually decreasing to the limit of 20 or 30 years of life. Thanks to the culture of nescient education, befooled men have created their own nationalisms within these planets in order to grasp at sense enjoyment for these few 20 or 30 years. Such foolish people are drawing up various plans to make some demarked portion of earth as perfect as possible, which is ultimately ridiculous. And for this purpose each and every nation has become a source of anxiety for the others. More than 50% of their energy is spoiled in defense measures, with no caring for the real culture of knowledge, and they are falsely proud of becoming advanced in both material and spiritual knowledge.

Çré Éçopaniñad warns of this faulty mode of education, and the Bhagavad-gétä gives instructions as to the development of real knowledge. In this mantra there is a hint that the instruction of vidyä, knowledge, must be gained from the dhéra. Dhéra means undisturbed, not disturbed by material illusion. No one can be undisturbed unless and until he has perfect spiritual realization. When one is perfectly spiritually realized he has no more hankering for anything acquired, nor does he lament for anything lost. Such a dhéra has realized that the material body and mind which he has acquired by chance material association are foreign elements, and therefore he simply makes the best use of a bad bargain.

The material body and mind are bad bargains for the spiritual living entity. The living entity has different functions in the living world, but this material world is dead. As long as the living spiritual sparks manipulate the dead lumps of matter, the dead world appears to be a living world. But actually it is the living souls, the parts and parcels of the Supreme Living Being, which move the world. The dhéras are those who have come to know all these facts by hearing of them from superior authorities, and who have realized them by following the regulative principles.

To follow the regulative principles, one must go under the shelter of a bona fide spiritual master. The transcendental message comes down from the spiritual master to the disciple with the regulative principles, and not in the hazardous way of nescient education. One can become a dhéra only by such submissive hearing from the Personality of Godhead. The perfect disciple must be like Arjuna, and the spiritual master must be as good as the Lord Himself. These are the, processes of learning vidyä, knowledge, from the dhéra, the undisturbed.

Adhéra, one who has not undergone the training of a dhéra, cannot be an instructive leader. Modern politicians who pose themselves as dhéras are themselves adhéras. One cannot expect perfect knowledge from them. They are busy with their own remuneration in dollars and pounds. How can they lead the mass of people to the right path of self realization? One must hear submissively from the dhéra in order to get actual education in life.

Iso 11-1969

Mantra Eleven

ivaâAM caAivaâAM ca ya-
staãe"d"AeBayaM s$ah"
@ivaâyaA ma{tyauM taItvaAR
ivaâyaAma{tama´autae

TEXT

vidyäà cävidyäà ca yas

tad vedobhayaà saha

avidyayä måtyuà tértvä

vidyayämåtam açnute.

vidyäm—knowledge in fact; ca—and; avidyäm—nescience; ca—and; yaù—a person; tad—that; veda—knows: ubhayam—both; saha—simultaneously; avidyayä—by culture of nescience; måtyum—repeated death; tértvä—transcending; vidyayä—by culture of knowledge; amåtam—deathlessness; açnute—enjoys.

TRANSLATION

Only one who can learn the process of nescience and that of transcendental knowledge side by side can transcend the influence of repeated birth and death, and enjoy the full blessings of immortality.

PURPORT

Since the start of the material world everyone is trying for a permanent life, but the law of Nature is so cruel that no one has avoided the hand of death. No one wants to die. That is a practical fact. Nor does anyone want to become old or diseased. But the law of Nature does not allow anyone immunity from death, old age or disease. The advancement of material knowledge has not solved these problems of life. Material science can discover the nuclear bomb to accelerate the process of death, but it cannot discover anything which can protect man from the cruel hands of death, disease and old age.

From the Puräëas we learn of the activities of Hiraëyakaçipu: This king was materially very much advanced, and by his material acquisitions, by the strength of his nescience, he wanted to conquer death. He underwent a type of meditation so severe that all the planetary systems became disturbed by his mystic powers. He forced the creator of the universe, the demigod named Brahmä, to come down to him, and then he asked him for the benediction of becoming an amara, one who does not die. Brahmä refused to award this, however, because even he, the material creator, who has command over all the planets, is not himself an amara. He has a long duration of life, as is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [8.17], but that does not mean that he doesn't have to die.

Hiraëya means gold, and kaçipu means soft bed. This gentleman was interested in these two things, money and women, and he wanted to enjoy this sort of life by becoming artificially immortal. He asked Brahmä many things indirectly in hopes of fulfilling his desire to become an amara. He asked benediction that he might not be killed by any man, animal, god, or any living being within the categories of the 8,400,000 species. He also asked that he might not die on the land, in the air, in the water or by any weapon whatsoever. So on and on, Hiraëyakaçipu thought foolishly that this would guarantee him against death. But in the end, although Brahmä granted him all these benedictions, he was killed by the Personality of Godhead in the Form of a half-man, half-lion. And no weapon was used to kill him except the nails of the Lord. He was killed on the lap of the wonderful Living Being Who was beyond his conception.

The whole point here is that even Hiraëyakaçipu, the most powerful of materialists, could not become deathless by his various plans. What, then, will be accomplished by the tiny Hiraëyakaçipus of today, who make plans which are throttled from moment to moment?

Çré Éçopaniñad instructs us not to make one-sided attempts to win the struggle for existence. Everyone is struggling hard for existence, but the law of material Nature is so hard and fast that it does not allow any to surpass it. In order to have permanent life one must be prepared to go back to Godhead.

This process of going back to Godhead is a different branch of knowledge, and it has to be learnt from the revealed Vedic Scriptures, such as the Upaniñads, Vedänta, Bhagavad-gétä, Çrémad-Bhägavatam, etc. Therefore, to become happy in this life and to get a permanent blissful life after leaving this material body, one must take to this sacred literature and obtain transcendental knowledge. The conditioned living being has forgotten his eternal relation with God, and he has mistakenly accepted the temporary place of birth as all-in-all. The Lord has kindly delivered the above-mentioned Scriptures in India and other Scriptures in other countries to remind the forgetful human being that his home is not here in this material world. The living being is a spiritual entity, and he can only be happy by returning to his spiritual home, with the Godhead.

The Personality of Godhead, from His Kingdom, sends His bona fide servants to propagate this mission of going hack to Godhead, and sometimes He comes Himself to do this work. All living beings are His beloved sons, His parts and parcels, and therefore God is more sorry than we ourselves are for the sufferings which we are constantly undergoing in the material condition. The miseries of the material world are also indirect reminders of our incompatibility with dead matter, and intelligent living entities generally take note of these reminders, and side by side engage themselves in the culture of vidyä, or transcendental knowledge. Human life, is the best opportunity for the culture of spiritual knowledge, and the human being who does not take advantage of this opportunity in human life is called a narädhama, the lowest of human beings.

The path of avidyä, or material advancement of knowledge for sense gratification, means repetition of death and repetition of birth also. The living entity, as he is spiritually, has no birth or death. Birth and death are concerned with the outward covering of the spirit soul, the body. This is compared with the pulling on and taking off of outward garments. Foolish human beings who are grossly absorbed in the culture of avidyä, nescience, do not mind this cruel process, but, being enamored of the beauty of the illusory energy, they do the same things over repeatedly, without learning any lesson from the law of Nature.

The culture of vidyä or transcendental knowledge is essential for the human being. Unrestricted sense enjoyment in the diseased, material condition of the senses must be restricted as far as possible. Unrestricted sense enjoyment in this bodily condition is the path of ignorance and death. The living entities are not without spiritual senses. Every living being in his original spiritual form has all the senses which are now material, covered by the body and the mind. Activities of the material senses are perverted reflections of spiritual pastimes. The engagement of the spirit soul under the material covering is the diseased condition of the soul. And real sense enjoyment is possible when the disease is removed. In our pure spiritual form, freed from all material contamination, pure enjoyment of the senses is possible. The aim of human life should, therefore, not be perverted sense enjoyment, but should be to cure the material disease. Aggravating the material disease is no sign of knowledge. It is the sign of culturing avidyä, ignorance.

The degree of a fever must not be increased from 105 to 107 for good health. The degree is to be reduced to the normal state of 98.6. That should be the aim of human life. The modern trend of material civilization is to increase the degree of the feverish material condition, which has therefore reached the point of 107 in the form of atomic energy, with the foolish politicians crying that at any moment the world may go to hell. That is the result of the advancement of material knowledge, and of the neglect of the most important part of life, the culture of spiritual knowledge. Here is a warning in Çré Éçopaniñad that we must not follow such a dangerous path leading to death. On the contrary, we must side by side develop the culture of spiritual knowledge so that we may become completely free from the cruel hands of death.

This does not mean that all civic activities for the maintenance of the body should be stopped. There is no question of stopping activities, as there is no question of wiping out one's temperature altogether when trying to recover from a disease. We have already tried to explain the matter by the expression "to make the best use of a bad bargain." The culture of spiritual knowledge has to be done with the help of this body and mind, and therefore maintenance of the body and mind is required if we are to reach our goal. The normal temperature should be maintained at 98.6 degrees, but it should not be foolishly increased to the degree of l07. The great sages and saints of India wanted to maintain the normal temperature by a balanced program of material and spiritual knowledge. They never allowed the misuse of human intelligence for diseased sense gratification.

Human activities diseased by a temperament of sense gratification have been regulated in the Vedas under the principles of Salvation. This system is found in four divisions: religion, economic development, sense gratification and salvation. At the present moment the people have no interest either in religion or salvation. They have only one aim in life, sense gratification, and in order to fulfill this end they have different plans for economic development.

Misguided man thinks that religion should be maintained for its contribution to economic development, and that economic development is required for sense gratification. And in order to guarantee further sense gratification after death, in heaven, there is some system of religious observances. But this is not the purpose of the principles of salvation. The path of religion is actually for self realization. Economic development is required just to maintain the body in a sound, healthy condition. A man should live in a healthy condition of life with a sound mind just to realize vidyä, true knowledge, which is the aim of human life. This life is not meant for working like an ass or for the culture of avidyä or for sense gratification.

The path of vidyä is most perfectly presented in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.2.14]. The Bhägavatam directs a human being to utilize his life in the matter of enquiring about the Absolute Truth. The Absolute Truth is realized step by step as Brahman, Paramätman, and, at last, Bhagavän, the Personality of Godhead. This Absolute Truth is realized by the broad-minded man who has attained knowledge and detachment, having followed the 18 principles of the Bhagavad-gétä described above. The central point in these 18 principles is the attainment of transcendental devotional service to the Personality of Godhead. Therefore it is recommended for all classes of men to learn the art of devotional service to the Lord.

Religiousness, economic development and sense, gratification without the aim of attaining devotional service to the Lord are all different forms of nescience, as will, he shown hereafter in Çré Éçopaniñad. Thus, to culture vidyä, especially in this age, one must always hear and chant and worship with concentrated attention, targetted on the Personality of Godhead, Who is the Lord of the transcendentalists.

Iso 12-1969

Mantra Twelve

@nDaM tama: ‘aivazAinta
yae's$amBaUitamaupaAs$atae
tataAe BaUya wva tae tamaAe
ya o s$amBaUtyaA•ataA:

TEXT

andhaà tamaù praviçanti

ye 'sambhütim upäsate

tato bhüya iva te tamo

ya u sambhütyäm ratäù.

andham—ignorance; tamaù—darkness; praviçanti—do enter into; ye—those; asambhütim—demigods; upäsate—do worship; tataù—more than that; bhüyaù—again; iva—like that; te—who; tamaù—darkness; ye—those; u—also; sambhütyäm—in the Absolute; ratäù—engaged.

TRANSLATION

Those who are engaged in the worship of demigods enter into the darkest region of ignorance, and still more so do the worshipers of the Absolute.

PURPORT

The Sanskrit word asambhüti means those who have no independent existence. Sambhüti is the Absolute Personality of Godhead, Who is absolutely independent of everything. In the Bhagavad-gétä [10.2], the Absolute Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, positively describes Himself in the, following words: "I am the Supreme Cause of the powers delegated to the demigods, the great sages and the mystics. And because these are endowed with limited powers, it is very difficult for them to know how I appear Myself, by My own internal potency, in the form of a man."

All philosophers and great åñis, or mystics, try to distinguish the Absolute from the relative by their tiny brain power. However, this can only help them to reach the point of negating relativity, without realizing any positive trace of the Absolute. Definition of the Absolute by negation is not a concept. Such negative definitions lead one to create a concept of his own, and one then imagines that the Absolute must be formless and without qualities. But these negations are simply the opposite numbers of the relative forms and qualities, and are. themselves therefore relative. By such a concept of the Absolute one can at the utmost reach to the impersonal diligence of God, known as Brahman; but one cannot make further progress to the stage of Bhagavän, the Personality of Godhead.

Such mental speculators do not know that Kåñëa is the Absolute Personality of Godhead, and that the impersonal Brahman is the glaring effulgence of His transcendental body, while Paramätman, the Supersoul, is His all-pervading representation. They do not know that Kåñëa has His eternal Form, with transcendental qualities of eternal bliss and knowledge. The dependent demigods and great sages imperfectly realize Him as one of the powerful demigods, but they consider that the Brahman effulgence is the ultimate Absolute Truth. Kåñëa's devotees, however—who by dint of their unalloyed devotion surrender unto Him—can know that He is the Absolute Person, and that everything emanates from Him only. Such devotees continuously render loving service unto Kåñëa, the Fountainhead of everything.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.20, 23] it is also said that only bewildered persons, driven by a strong desire for sense gratification, worship the demigods for the satisfaction of temporary problems. A temporary relief from a certain difficulty by the grace of some demigod is the demand of less intelligent persons. The living being is in the material entanglement, and he has to be relieved from material bondage entirely to obtain permanent relief on the. spiritual plane, where eternal bliss, life and knowledge exist.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.23] it is said that the worshipers of the demigods can go to the planets of the respective demigods. The Moon worshipers can go to the Moon, the Sun worshipers can go to the planet of the Sun, and so on. Modern scientists are now trying to go to the Moon with the help of rockets, which is not really a new attempt. The human being with his advanced consciousness is naturally inclined to travel in outer space and to reach other planets, either by sputniks, by mystic powers, or by worshiping the, particular predominating deity on that planet. In the Vedic scriptures it is said that one can reach other planets in any of the ways mentioned above, most generally by worshiping the demigod presiding over the particular planet. But these planets are temporary residential places; the only permanent planets are the Vaikuëöha-lokas, found in the spiritual sky, where the Personality of Godhead predominates. The Bhagavad-gétä [8.16] confirms this as follows:

Even though one may rise to the highest planet, Brahma-loka, one has to come back again. But if someone attains to Me (in the spiritual world), he doesn't have to lake birth again.

Çré Éçopaniñad suggests that one, remains in the darkest region by hovering over the material planets, whatever his means may he. The whole universe is covered by the gigantic material dements, just like a coconut ball half-filled with water. As it is airtight and fully covered, the darkness within is dense, and therefore planets like the Sun and the Moon are required to illuminate the inside of the universe. Outside the universe there is a vast expansion of unlimited Brahma-jyoti space, full of Vaikuëöha-lokas.

The biggest and the highest planet in the Brahma-jyoti is the Kåñëa-loka, or Goloka Våndävana, where the Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, resides. Lord Çré Kåñëa never quits this Kåñëa-loka where He dwells with His eternal associates, and yet He is omnipresent throughout the complete material and spiritual cosmic situation. This fact has already been explained in Mantra four of Çré Éçopaniñad. The Lord is present everywhere, as the Sun is. A man can move through space with the highest possible speed, and still he will find that the Sun is there, although the Sun is situated in its own undeviating orbit.

The problem of life cannot be solved by going to the Moon. There are many pseudo-worshipers who become religionists for the sake of name and fame only. Such pseudo-religionists do not wish to get out of this universe and reach the spiritual sky. They want only to maintain the status quo in the material world, under the garb of worshiping the Lord. And the atheists and the impersonalists lead such foolish pseudo-religionists into the darkest regions by preaching the cult of atheism. The atheist directly denies the existence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and the impersonalist supports the atheist by preaching the impersonal existence of the Supreme Lord. As far as we have gone through Çré Éçopaniñad, we have not come across any mantra where the Personality of Godhead is denied. It is said that He can run faster than anyone. Those who are running after the planets are certainly persons, and if the Lord can run faster than all of them, why should He be considered impersonal? The impersonal conception of the Supreme Lord is another face of ignorance, due to an imperfect vision of the Absolute Truth.

And so the ignorant pseudo-religionists, the manufacturers of so-called incarnations—directly violating the Vedic injunctions—are liable to enter into the darkest region of the universe, on account of their business of misleading those who follow them. These impersonalists generally pose themselves as incarnations of God to the foolish, who have no knowledge of the Vedic wisdom. And if such foolish men have any knowledge at all, it is more, dangerous in their hands than ignorance itself. Such impersonalists do not even worship the demigods as is recommended in the scriptures.

In the scriptures there is a recommendation for worshiping the demigods under different circumstances, but at the same time it is said that there is no real need for this. In the Bhagavad-gétä [7.23] it is clearly stated that the results of worshiping the demigods are not permanent. The whole material world is not permanent, and therefore anything achieved here within the darkness of material existence is also impermanent. The problem, then, is how to obtain real and permanent life.

The Lord states that as soon as one reaches Him by devotional service—which is the one and only way to approach the Personality of Godhead—there is complete freedom from the bondage of birth and death. In other words, the path of salvation, or getting out of the material clutches, fully depends on the principles of knowledge and detachment. And the pseudo religionists have neither knowledge nor detachment from material affairs. Most of them want to continue in the golden shackles of material bondage, under the shadow of altruistic and philanthropic activities, and in the name of religious principles. By false religious sentiments they present a make-show of devotional service, indulging in all sorts of immoral principles, and still pass as spiritual masters and devotees of God. Such violators of religious principles have no respect for the authoritative äcäryas, the holy teachers in the strict disciplic succession; and to mislead the people in general they themselves become so-called äcäryas, without even following the principles of the äcäryas.

These rogues in human society are the most dangerous elements and, for want of religious government, they pass on without being punished by the law of the state. They cannot, however, avoid the law of the Supreme, Who has clearly declared in the Bhagavad-gétä [16.19-20] that these envious demons, in the garb of religious propagandists, shall be thrown down into the darkest region of hell. It is confirmed in Çré Éçopaniñad that the pseudo religionists are heading toward the most obnoxious place in the universe after finishing with the spiritual mastership business, which is simply for the matter of sense gratification

Iso 13-1969

Mantra Thirteen

@nyade"vaAò": s$amBavaA-
d"nyad"Aò"r"s$amBavaA-
itaita zAu™auma DaIr"ANAAM
yae nastaiã"cacaiºare"

TEXT

anyad evähuù sambhaväd

anyad ähur asambhavät

iti çuçruma dhéräëäà

ye nas tad vicacakñire.

anyat—different; eva—certainly; ähuù—it is said; sambhavät—by worshiping the Supreme Lord, the Cause of all causes; anyat—different; ähuù—it is said; asambhavät—by worshiping what is not the Supreme; iti—thus; çuçruma—I heard it; dhéräëäm—from the undisturbed authorities; ye—those; naù—unto us; tat—about that subject matter; vicacakñire—perfectly explained.

TRANSLATION

It is said that one result is obtained by worshiping the Supreme Cause of all causes, and that another is obtained by worshiping what is not supreme. All this was heard from the undisturbed authorities who clearly explained it.

PURPORT

In this mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad the system of hearing from the undisturbed authorities is confirmed. Unless one hears from the bona fide äcärya, who is never disturbed by the changes of the material world, one cannot have the real key to transcendental knowledge. The bona fide spiritual master, who has also heard the, Çruti mantras, or Vedic knowledge, from his undisturbed äcärya, never manufactures or presents anything which is not mentioned in the Vedic literature. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.25] it is clearly said that the worshipers of the Pitås, or fore-fathers, reach the forefathers, the gross materialists who make plans to remain here in this world remain here, and the devotees of the Lord, who worship none but Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Cause of all causes, reach Him in His Abode in the spiritual sky.

Here also in Çré Éçopaniñad, it is said that different results are achieved by different modes of worship. If we worship the Supreme Lord, certainly we will reach the Supreme Lord in His eternal Abode, and if we worship demigods like the Sun and Moon, we can reach these respective planets without any doubt. And if we want to remain here on this wretched planet with our planning commissions and our stop-gap political adjustments, we can certainly do that also.

Nowhere in authentic scriptures is it said that whatever you do and whatever you worship you will ultimately reach the same goal. Such foolish theories are offered by self-made masters who have no connection with the paramparä, the bona fide system of disciplic succession. The bona fide spiritual master cannot say that for everyone who has his own mode of worship—be it worship of the demigods or of the Supreme—it leads to the same goal. For a common man it is very easy to understand that a person starting by train from Bombay can reach the destination for which he has purchased his ticket, and nowhere else. A person who has purchased a ticket for Calcutta can reach Calcutta. But contemporary so-called masters preach that, whatever spiritual ticket you may purchase, it will take you to the Supreme Goal. Such mundane and compromising offers attract many foolish creatures to become puffed up with their manufactured methods of spiritual realization, but the Vedic instruction doesn't uphold them. Unless one has received knowledge from the bona fide spiritual master—one who is in the recognized line of disciplic succession—one cannot have the real thing as it is. The Bhagavad-gétä [4.2] says:

Thus, O chastiser of the foe, the yoga principles [of the Gétä] were known to the great kings. But, the paramparä system being broken, these principles appear now to be lost.

When Lord Çré Kåñëa was present in this world, the bhakti-yoga principles defined in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.3] had become distorted, and so the Lord had to re-establish the disciplic system, beginning with Arjuna, who was the most confidential friend and devotee of the Lord. The Lord clearly said to Arjuna that it was because he was His devotee and friend that the principles of the Gétä were understandable to him. In other words, no one can understand the Gétä who is not a devotee and friend of the Lord. This means that only one who follows the path of Arjuna can understand the Gétä.

At the present moment there are many interpreters of this sublime dialogue who have nothing to do with Arjuna or Lord Kåñëa. They interpret the verses of the Bhagavad-gétä in their own ways, and postulate all sorts of rubbish in the name of the Gétä. Such interpreters believe neither in Çré Kåñëa nor in His eternal Abode. So, then, what can they explain about the Bhagavad-gétä?

The Gétä [7.20, 23] clearly says that only those who have lost their senses worship the demigods. Kåñëa ultimately advises that one should give up all other ways and modes of worship, and fully surrender unto Him only [18.66]. Those persons who are cleansed of all sinful reactions can have such unflinching faith in the Supreme Lord. Others will continue hovering over the material sphere with their paltry ways of worship, and thus will be misled from the real path, under the false impression that all paths lead to the same goal.

In this mantra the Sanskrit word sambhavät, worship of the Supreme Cause, is very significant. Lord Kåñëa is the Original Personality of Godhead, and everything that exists has emanated from Him. In the Gétä [10.8] the Lord explains Himself. He says there That He is the Creator of everyone, including Brahmä, Viñëu and Çiva. And because these three principal deities of the material world are created by the Lord, He is the Creator of all that exists in the material and spiritual worlds.

In the Atharva-veda it is similarly said that One Who existed before the creation of Brahmä and One Who enlightened Brahmä with Vedic knowledge, is Lord Çré Kåñëa. "The Supreme Person desired to create the living entities, and thus Näräyaëa created all the beings. From Näräyaëa, Brahmä was born. Näräyaëa created all the Prajäpatis. Näräyaëa created Indra. Näräyaëa created the eight Vasus. Näräyaëa created the eleven Rudras. Näräyaëa created the twelve Ädityas." This Näräyaëa being the plenary manifestation of Lord Kåñëa, Näräyaëa and Kåñëa are one and the same.

There are later readings also which say that the same Supreme Lord is the Son of Devaké. His childhood with Devaké and Vasudeva and His identity with Näräyaëa have also been confirmed by Çrépad Çaìkaräcärya, even though Çaìkara does not belong to the Vaiñëava, or personalist, cult. There are still other readings, also in the Atharva Veda, such as this: "Only Näräyaëa existed in the beginning, and there was no existence of Brahmä or Çiva, nor of Agni, the fire, nor of water. There were no stars, there was no Sun, no Moon. He does not remain alone. He creates as He desires."

"In the Mokña-dharma it is said: "I created the Prajäpatis and the Rudras. They have not complete knowledge of Me because they are also covered by My illusory energy."

"In the Varäha Puräëa it is said: "Näräyaëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and from Him the four-headed Brahmä became manifested, as also did Rudra, who later became omniscient."

Thus all Vedic literature will confirm this view that Näräyaëa or Kåñëa is the Cause of all causes. In the Brahma-saàhitä [5.1] also it is said that the Supreme Lord is Çré Kåñëa. He is "Govinda," the Delighter of every living being, and He is the Primeval Cause of all causes. The really learned person will know all this by the evidence of great sages and the Vedas, and will thus decide to worship Lord Kåñëa as all-in-all.

Persons are called buddha, or really learned, who fasten themselves only to the worship of Çré Kåñëa. This conviction can he established when one hears the transcendental message from the undisturbed äcärya, with faith and love. One who has no faith in, or love for, Lord Kåñëa cannot be convinced of this simple truth. Such faithless persons are described in the Bhagavad-gétä as müòhas, foolish as the ass. It is said that the müòhas deride the Personality of Godhead because they don't have complete knowledge from the undisturbed äcärya. One who is disturbed by the whirlpool movements of the material energy is not qualified to become an äcärya.

Before hearing the Gétä, Arjuna was disturbed by this whirlpool-the reaction of family, society and community affection-and thus he wanted to become a philanthropist and a nonviolent man of the world. But when he became buddha, by hearing the Vedic knowledge of the Bhagavad-gétä from the Supreme Person, lie changed his decision and became a worshiper of Lord Çré Kåñëa, Who had Himself designed the Battle of Kurukñetra. Arjuna worshiped the Lord by fighting with his so-called relatives, and thus became a pure devotee of the Lord. Such achievements are possible only by worshiping the real Kåñëa and not by worshiping some fabricated "Kåñëa" inaugurated by foolish men who are without knowledge of the intricacies of the science of Kåñëa described in the Gétä and in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

According to the Vedänta-sütra, the Sambhüta is the source of birth and sustenance, and the reservoir after annihilation. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the natural commentary upon the Vedänta-sütras by the same author, comments that the source of all emanations is not a dead stone, but is abhijïaù, or fully conscious. Therefore, the Primeval Lord Çré Kåñëa says in the Gétä [7.26] that He is fully conscious of the past, the present and the future; and no one, including demigods such as Çiva and Brahmä, knows Him fully. Those who are disturbed by the tides of material existence cannot know Him fully. Such half-educated spiritual masters try to make some compromise, and make the mass of human beings the object of worship. They do not know that such worship of the masses is not possible, nor are the masses perfect. This is something like pouring water on the leaves of the tree, instead of watering the root. The natural process of worship is to pour water on the root of the tree from which the leaves grow. But today's disturbed leaders become more attracted by the leaves than the root, and therefore, in spite of perpetually watering the leaves, all is drying up for want of nourishment.

Çré Éçopaniñad advises us to pour water on the root, the Source of all germination. Worshiping the mass population by rendering bodily service which can never be perfect is less important than service to the soul. The soul is the root generating different types of bodies in terms of the law of karma, or material reaction. To serve only the human being by medical aids, social amenities and educational facilities, while cutting the throats of poor animals in slaughterhouses, does not add up to any valid service to the living beings.

The living being is perpetually suffering from the material disease of birth, death, old age and disease, in different types of body. The human form of life is a chance to get out of this entanglement of material existence. This can be done simply by re-establishing the lost relationship of the living entity with the Supreme Lord. And the Lord comes personally to teach us this philosophy of surrender unto the Supreme, the Sambhütam. Real service to humankind is to teach surrender unto the Supreme Lord, and to worship Him only, with full love and energy. That is the instruction of Çré Éçopaniñad in this mantra.

The simple way to worship the Supreme Lord in this age of disturbance is to hear and chant about His great activities. The mental speculators, however, think of the activities of the Lord as imaginary, and therefore they refrain from any such hearing process, and invent some jugglery of words, without any substance, to divert the attention of the poor innocent mass of people. Instead of hearing the activities of Lord Kåñëa, they prefer to advertise themselves by inducing their followers to sing about the pseudo-spiritual master. In modern times, the number of such pretenders has increased in considerable numbers, and it has become a problem for the pure devotees of the Lord to save the mass of people from the unholy propaganda of these pretenders and imitation incarnations of God.

The Upaniñads indirectly draw our attention to the Primeval Lord Çré Kåñëa, and the Bhagavad-gétä, which is the summary of all Upaniñads, directly points out Çré Kåñëa. One should, therefore, hear about Kåñëa as He is in the Gétä or in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.2.17], and that will gradually help him in cleansing his mind of all contaminated things. The Bhägavatam says: "By hearing the activities of the Lord, one draws the attention of the Lord towards the devotee. And the Lord, being situated in the heart of every living being, helps the devotee by giving him proper direction." The Bhagavad-gétä [10.10] also confirms this.

This inner direction by the Lord cleanses the heart of the devotee of all dirty things which are produced by the material modes of passion and ignorance. The non-devotees are under the direction of passion and ignorance. By passion one cannot become detached from material affinity, and by ignorance one cannot know what he actually is, and what the Lord is. Thus, in the state of passion, there is no chance for self realization however much one may play the false part of a religionist. For a devotee, by the grace of the Lord, the modes of passion and ignorance are removed, and he at once becomes situated in the quality of goodness, the sign of a perfect Brähmaëa. This stage of brahminical qualification can be earned by anyone and everyone, provided he follows the path of devotional service under the guidance of a bona fide spiritual master. The Bhägavatam [2.4.18] says that any lowborn living entity can be made purified under the guidance of a pure devotee of the Lord, because the Lord is so extraordinarily powerful.

The first sign of brahminical qualification is that the candidate becomes happy, and becomes enthusiastic in the matter of devotional service to the Lord. This unveils before him, automatically, all about the science of God. And, thus knowing the science of God, he gradually becomes loosened from his material attachments, and his doubtful mind becomes crystal clear, by the grace of the Lord. In this stage only can one become a liberated soul and see the Lord in every step of life. That is the perfection of sambhavät, as described in this mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad.

Iso 14-1969

Mantra Fourteen

s$amBaUitaM ca ivanaAzAM ca
yastaãe"d"AeBayaM s$ah"
ivanaAzAena ma{tyauM taItvaAR
s$amBaUtyaAma{tama´autae

TEXT

sambhütià ca vinäçaà ca

yas tad vedobhayaà saha

vinäçena måtyuà tértvä

sambhütyämåtam açnute.

sambhütim—the eternal Personality of Godhead, His transcendental Name, Form, Pastimes, Qualities, Paraphernalia, and the variegatedness of His abode, etc; ca—and; vinäçam—and the temporary material manifestation of demigods, man, animals, etc., along with their false name, fame, etc.; ca—also; yaù—as they are; tad—that; veda—knows; ubhayam—both; saha—along with; vinäçena—everything liable to be vanquished; måtyum—death; tértvä—surpassing; sambhütyä—in the eternal Kingdom of God; amåtam—deathlessness; açnute—enjoys.

TRANSLATION

One should know perfectly well about the Personality of Godhead and His transcendental Name, as well as the temporary material creation with its temporary demigods, men and animals. When one knows these, he surpasses death, and the ephemeral cosmic manifestation with it, and in the eternal Kingdom of God he enjoys his eternal life of bliss and knowledge.

PURPORT

Human civilization, by its so-called advancement of knowledge, has created many material things, including space capsules and atomic energy. But it has failed to create a situation in which man need not die, take his birth again, become old, or suffer from diseases. Whenever these questions are raised by an intelligent man before a so-called scientist, the scientist very cleverly replies that material science is progressing, and that it will ultimately be possible to render man deathless and ageless. Such answers by material scientists prove their gross ignorance of material Nature. In material Nature everything is under the stringent laws of matter, and must pass through six stages of existence: birth, growth, duration of life, transformation, deterioration, and death at last. Nothing that is in contact with material Nature can be beyond the above-mentioned six laws of existence, and therefore no one, whether demigod, man, animal, or tree, can survive forever here in the material world.

The duration of life may vary in different species. Lord Brahmä, the chief living being within this material world, may continue his life for millions and millions of years, while the minute germs may live just for some hours; that does not matter. No one in this material world can survive eternally. Things here are born or created under certain conditions, they stay for some time, and, if they have life then they grow, create generations, then dwindle gradually, and at last are annihilated. By that law even the Brahmäs (there are millions of Brahmäs in different universes—each one bigger than the last) are all liable to death, either today or tomorrow. Therefore, the whole material world is called Martya-loka, the place of death.

The material scientists and politicians are trying to make this place deathless because they have no information of the deathless spiritual nature, due to their ignorance of the Vedic literature. The Vedic literature is full of knowledge matured by experience. But modern man is averse to receive knowledge from the Vedas, Puräëas, and other scriptures.

In the Viñëu Puräëa [6.7.61] we have information. that Lord Viñëu, the Personality of Godhead, possesses different energies, known as parä, superior, and aparä, or avidyä—inferior. The material energy in which we are at present involved is called the avidyä, inferior, energy; and the material creation is made possible by such energy. But there is another, superior energy called the parä-çakti, where everything is different from this material inferior Nature. That nature is the eternal or deathless creation of the Lord. [Bg. 8.20]

All the material planets—upper, lower and intermediate, including the Sun, Moon and Venus—are scattered over the universe. These planets exist only during the lifetime of Brahmä. Some lower planets, however, are vanquished after the end of one day of Brahmä, and they are again recreated during the next daytime of Brahmä. Time calculation on the upper planets is different from that of ours. One of our years is equal to twenty-four hours, or one day and night, on many of the upper planets. The four ages of Earth (Satya, Tretä, Dväpara, Kali) make a duration of twenty-two thousand years and five months in terms of the lime of these upper planets. Such a length of time multiplied by one thousand is one day of Brahmä, and one night of Brahmä is the same. With such days and nights accumulating into months and years, Brahmä's life is estimated at one hundred years. And at the end of his life, the complete universal manifestation becomes vanquished.

The living beings residing in the Sun and Moon, as well as those in the Martya-loka system—which includes this Earth and many planets below the Earth—are all merged into devastating water during the nighttime of Brahmä. During this time no living beings or species of life remain manifested, although spiritually they continue to exist. This non-manifested stage is called avyakta. And again, when the entire universe is vanquished at the end of Brahmä's lifetime, there is an avyakta state. But beyond these two non-manifested states there is another, spiritual atmosphere or nature, where there is a great number of spiritual planets, existing eternally even when all the planets within this material universe are vanquished. The cosmic manifestation within the jurisdiction of the various Brahmäs is a display of one-fourth the energy of the Lord, and this energy is called inferior. The spiritual nature beyond the jurisdiction of Brahmä is called tri-pada-vibhüti, three-fourths the energy of the Lord, and is the superior energy, or parä-prakåti.

The predominating Supreme Person in the spiritual nature is Lord Çré Kåñëa. He can be approached only by unqualified devotional service, and not by anything else, such as the processes of jïäna (philosophy) and yoga (mysticism), much less that of karma (fruitive work). [Bg. 8.22] The karmis, or fruitive workers, can elevate themselves to the Svarga-loka planets, including the Sun and the Moon. Jïänins and yogis can reach still higher planets, such as the Brahma-loka; and, becoming still more qualified by devotional service, they are allowed to enter into the spiritual nature, either in the illuminating cosmic atmosphere of the spiritual sky (the Brahman), or on the planets, according to qualification. It is certain, however, that no one can enter into the spiritual planets called Vaikuëöhas without being trained in devotional service.

On the material planets, everyone from Brahmä down to the ant is trying to lord it over material Nature, and this is called the material disease. As long as this material disease continues, the living entity has to undergo the process of changing bodies, whether in the form of a demigod, a man, or an animal; and ultimately he has to endure the unmanifested condition during the two kinds of devastations: the night of Brahmä, and at the end of Brahmä's life. If we want to cease the process of repeated birth and death, and the concomitant factors of old age and disease, then we must try to enter into the spiritual planets, and Lord Kåñëa by His plenary expansions is the dominating Figure on each and every one of them. [Gopäla-täpané Upaniñad 1.21]

No one can predominate over Kåñëa. And anyone trying to predominate over material Nature is called a conditioned soul, being subject to the laws of material Nature, suffering the pangs of repeated birth and death. The Lord comes here to re-establish the principles of religion, and the basic principle is to develop the attitude of surrender toward Him. The Lord teaches this in the last portion of the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66], but foolish men have tactfully misinterpreted this prime teaching, and have misled the people in diverse ways. They have been urged to open hospitals, but are not interested in educating themselves to enter into the spiritual kingdom by devotional service. They have been taught to take interest only in temporary relief work, which can never bring about real happiness for the living entity. They start varieties of public and semi-governmental institutions for tackling the devastating power of Nature. But they don't know how to pacify insurmountable Nature.

Many men are advertised as great scholars of the Bhagavad-gétä, but they overlook the factual method presented there to pacify material Nature. Powerful Nature can only be pacified by the awakening of God consciousness, as is clearly mentioned in the Gétä [7.14].

Çré Éçopaniñad, however, teaches in this mantra that one must know both the sambhüti and the vinäça perfectly, side by side. By knowing the vinäça alone—the temporary material manifestation—you cannot save anything: In the course of Nature, there is devastation at every moment. No one can be saved from these devastations by any efforts of hospital-opening. They can be saved only by complete knowledge of the eternal life of bliss and awareness. The whole Vedic scheme is meant to educate men in this art of achieving eternal life. People are often misguided by other, temporarily attractive things based on sense gratification, but that sort of service which thus misleads them is most degraded.

You must save your fellow man in the right sense. There is no question of liking or disliking the truth. It is there. If you want to be saved from repeated birth and death you must take to the devotional service of the Lord. There can be no compromise in The matter of necessity.

Iso 15-1969

Mantra Fifteen

ih"r"Nmayaena paA‡aeNA
s$atyasyaAipaih"taM mauKa-
mtaÔvaM paUSaªapaAva{NAu
s$atyaDamaARya ä{"í"yae

TEXT

hiraëmayena pätreëa

satyasyäpihitaà mukham

tat tvaà püñann apävåëu

satya-dharmäya dåñöaye.

hiraëmayena—by effulgence of light; pätreëa—by dazzling covering; satyasya—of the Supreme Truth; apihitam—covered; mukham—the face; tat—that covering; tvam—your Self; püñan—O the Sustainer; apävåëu—kindly remove; satya—pure; dharmäya—unto the devotee; dåñöaye—for exhibiting.

TRANSLATION

O my Lord, Sustainer of all that lives, Your real face is covered by Your dazzling effulgence. Kindly remove that covering and exhibit Yourself to Your pure devotee.

PURPORT

In the Bhagavad-gétä, the Lord explains about His Personal rays, called Brahma-jyoti—the dazzling effulgence of His Personal Form—as follows:

I am the basis of the impersonal Brahman, which is immortal and imperishable, eternal, the constitutional position of ultimate happiness. (Gétä, 14/27)

Brahman, Paramätman and Bhagavän are three angles of vision of the same Absolute Truth. Brahman is the phase of the Absolute Truth most perceptible to the beginner. Paramätman is the phase of the Absolute Truth for those who have progressed. And Bhagavän is the ultimate realization of the Absolute Truth. This is confirmed in the Gétä [7.7], where the Lord says that He is the ultimate concept of the Absolute Truth. He is the source of Brahma-jyoti, as well as of the all-pervading Paramätman feature. As He says that He is the ultimate reservoir of the Brahma-jyoti, or impersonal conception of the Absolute Truth, so also He says in the Gétä [10.42] that there is no need of explaining His unlimited potency: it can be summarized in short that, by His one plenary portion—the all-pervading Paramätman—He maintains the complete material cosmic creation. And in the Spiritual World also He maintains all manifestations. Therefore, in the Çruti mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad, He is addressed as Püñan, the ultimate Maintainer.

The Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, is always full with transcendental bliss. When He was present at Våndävana in India 5,000 years ago, He always remained in transcendental bliss, even from the beginning of His childhood pastimes. The killing of varieties of demons, such as Agha, Buka, Pütanä and Pralamba were also pleasure excursions for Him. When He was within His village He was enjoying with His mother, sisters and friends as the naughty Butter Thief, and every one of His associates was enjoying celestial bliss by His stealing. The Lord is known as the Butter Thief, but the term is never used in a derogatory sense. The term Butter Thief, in the case of the Lord, is used with the understanding of the pleasure of His pure devotees. Everything that was done by the Lord at Våndävana was for the pleasure of His associates there. Such manifestations were created by Him to attract the dry speculators in the transcendental line, as well as the acrobats of the so-called haöha-yoga system, trying to find the Absolute Truth.

Of the childhood play of the Lord with His playmates, the cowherd boys, Çukadeva Gosvämé in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.12.11] said:

The Personality of Godhead, Who is perceived as the impersonal Brahman of bliss, Who is worshiped as the Supreme Lord by the devotees, and Who is considered an ordinary human being by the mundane, played with the cowherd boys who had achieved that position after a huge accumulation of pious deeds.

Thus the Lord is ever engaged in transcendental loving activities along with His spiritual associates in the various relationships of çänta, calmness, däsya, servitorship, sakhya, friendship, vätsalya, paternal affection, and mädhurya, conjugal love.

It is said that the Lord never goes out of the Våndävana-dhama, and so it may be asked how He manages the affairs of His different creations. This is answered in the Gétä [13.14-18]: He pervades all the material creation by His plenary part, known as the Puruña incarnation. The Lord has nothing to do with material creation, maintenance and destruction, but He causes it to be done by His plenary expansion, this Paramätman or Supersoul feature. Every living entity is known as ätman, soul. The principal Ätman, Who controls them all, is Paramätman—Supersoul.

The whole system of God realization is a great science. The materialists can only analyze and meditate on the twenty-four factors of the material creation. They have very little information of the Puruña, the Lord. The impersonal transcendentalists are simply bewildered by the glaring effulgence of the Brahma-jyoti. If one wants to see the Absolute Truth in full, one has to penetrate beyond the twenty-four material elements and the glaring effulgence as well. Çré Éçopaniñad hints at this direction, praying for removal of the hiraëmaya-pätra, the dazzling covering. Unless this covering is removed, and unless one can perceive the Supreme Personality of Godhead as He is, factual realization of the Absolute Truth can never be achieved.

The Paramätman feature of the Personality of Godhead is one of three plenary expansions, collectively called Viñëu-tattva. The Viñëu-tattva within the universe (one of the three principal deities—Brahmä, Viñëu and Çiva) is known as the Kñérodaka-çäyé Viñëu. He is the all-pervading Paramätman in each and every individual living entity. And the Garbhodaka-çäyé Viñëu is the collective Supersoul of all living entities. Beyond these two there is the Käraëodaka-çäyé Viñëu lying in the Causal Ocean. He is the Creator of all the universes. The yoga system teaches the serious student to meet such Viñëu-tattvas after overcoming the twenty-four material elements of cosmic creation. The culture of empiric philosophy helps one to realize the impersonal Brahma-jyoti, which is the glaring effulgence of the transcendental body of Lord Çré Kåñëa. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [14.27] as well as in the Brahma-saàhitä (5/40):

In the millions and millions of universes, there are innumerable planets, each and every one of them different from the others by cosmic constitution, and all of them situated in a corner of the Brahma-jyoti. This Brahmajyoti is the Personal ray of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Whom I do worship.

This mantra of the Brahma-saàhitä is the position of factual realization of the Absolute Truth, and the Çruti mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad under discussion is a confirmation of this mantra as a process of realization. It is a simple, prayer to the Lord to remove the Brahma-jyoti, so that one can see the real face of God.

Perfect knowledge means to know the root of Brahman. The root of Brahman is Lord Çré Kåñëa, and in scriptures such as the Çrémad-Bhägavatam the science of Kåñëa is perfectly elaborated. In the Bhägavatam, the author, Çréla Vyasadeva, has established by realization that the Supreme Truth is described either as Brahman, Paramätman or Bhagavän. But he has never said that the Supreme Truth is anywhere described as jéva, the ordinary living entity. Therefore the living entity is not the all powerful Supreme Truth. Otherwise, there would be no need of prayer by the entity for the Lord to remove the dazzling cover in order to see His real face.

The conclusion is, therefore, that in the absence of potent manifestations of the Supreme Truth, the impersonal Brahman is realized. Similarly, when there is realization of the material potencies of the Lord, with little or no information of the spiritual potency, it is called Paramätman realization. Therefore, both Brahman and Paramätman realization of the Absolute Truth are partial realizations. But when one realizes the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, in full potency after the removal of the hiraëmaya-pätra, as is prayed for in this mantra, then he realizes that Väsudevaù sarvam iti:Lord Çré Kåñëa, known as Vasudeva, is everything—Brahman, Paramätman and Bhagavän. He is Bhagavän, the root, and Brahman and Paramätman are His branches.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [6.46-47] there is a comparative, analysis of the three grades of transcendentalists, known as jïänins, the worshipers of the impersonal Brahman, the yogis, or worshipers of the Paramätman feature, and bhaktas, or devotees of Lord Çré Kåñëa. It is stated in the Gétä that amongst all types of transcendentalists, one who is a jïäni, who has cultured the Vedic knowledge, is supreme. Yet the yogis are still more than the jïänins. The yogis are far superior to fruitive workers as well. And amongst all kinds of yogis, "the one who constantly serves the Lord with all his energy is topmost."

The summary is that a philosopher is better than a laboring man, and a mystic is far superior to a philosopher. And of all the mystic yogis, one who is following bhakti-yoga, who is constantly engaged in the service of the Lord, is the highest. Çré Éçopaniñad directs us toward this perfection of life.

Iso 16-1969

Mantra Sixteen

paUSaªaek(SaeR yama s$aUyaR ‘aAjaApatya
vyaUh" r"zmaIna, s$amaUh"
taejaAe yaÔae è&paM k(lyaANAtamaM
taÔae pazyaAima yaAe's$aAvas$aAE pauç&Sa: s$aAe'h"maisma

TEXT

püñann ekarñe yama sürya präjäpatya

vyüha raçmén samüha tejaù

yatte rüpaà kalyäëatamaà tatte paçyämi

yo 'sävasau puruñaù so 'hamasmi.

püñan—the Maintainer; ekaåñe—the primeval Philosopher; yama—the regulating principal; sürya—the destination of the Süris (great devotees); präjäpatya—the well-wisher of the Prajäpatis (progenitors of Mankind); vyüha—kindly arrange; raçmén—the rays; samüha—wind up; tejaù—effulgence; yat—that; te—your; rüpam—form; kalyäëa-tamam—auspicious; tat—that; te—your; paçyämi—I may see; yaù—one who is; asau—the sun; asau—that; puruñaù—Personality of Godhead; saù—He; aham—myself; asmi—I am.

TRANSLATION

O my Lord, O primeval Philosopher, Maintainer of the universe, O regulating Principle, Destination of the pure devotees, Well-wisher of the progenitors of mankind, please remove the effulgence of Your transcendental rays, so that I can see Your Form of Bliss. You are the eternal Supreme Personality of Godhead, like unto the Sun, as am I.

PURPORT

The Sun and the Sun's rays are one and the same qualitatively. Similarly, the Lord and the living entities are one and the same in quality. The Sun is one, but the molecules of the Sun's rays are innumerable. The Sun's rays constitute part of the Sun; the Sun and the rays conjointly are the complete Sun. Within the Sun planet there is the Sun god, and similarly within the supreme spiritual planet, Goloka Våndävan, from which the effulgent Brahma-jyoti is emanating, there is the eternal Lord, as is stated in the Brahma-saàhitä [5.29]:

The transcendental Abode of Lord Kåñëa is the land of touchstones, of which the houses are built, shaded by desire trees. The Lord is engaged there in herding the surabhi cows, and is always served and surrounded by thousands of Goddesses of Fortune, who wait upon Him with all respect.

The description of this transcendental Abode of Lord Kåñëa is in the Brahma-saàhitä, and the Brahma-jyoti is described there as the supreme rays from that planet, just as the Sun's rays come from the Sun globe. Unless one surpasses the Brahma-jyoti glare, one cannot have any information of the land of the Lord. The impersonalist philosopher, being blinded by the dazzling Brahma-jyoti, cannot realize the factual Abode of the Lord, nor His transcendental form. Affected by such a poor fund of knowledge, the thinkers cannot understand the all blissful transcendental form of Lord Kåñëa. Çré Éçopaniñad, therefore, offers this prayer to the Lord to remove the effulgent rays of the Brahma-jyoti, so that the pure devotee can see His all-blissful transcendental form.

By realization of the impersonal Brahma-jyoti, one experiences the auspicious aspect of the Supreme; by experience of the Paramätman, or all-pervading feature of the Supreme, one experiences a still more auspicious enlightenment, and by meeting the Personality of Godhead face to face, the devotee experiences the most auspicious feature of the Supreme. Being addressed as the Philosopher, the Maintainer, the Well-wisher, and so forth, the Supreme Truth cannot be considered impersonal. That is the indication of Çré Éçopaniñad. The word Maintainer is especially significant: The Lord maintains His devotees specifically, although He is the Maintainer of one and all beings. By surpassing the impersonal Brahma-jyoti, when the devotee sees the personal aspect of the Lord and His most auspicious eternal form, then the devotee realizes the Absolute Truth in full. Çréla Jéva Gosvämé says in his Bhägavata-sandarbha as follows:

The complete conception of the Absolute Truth is realized in the Personality of Godhead, because, He is Almighty, with full potency in transcendence. In the Brahma-jyoti the full potency of the Absolute Truth is not realized, and therefore Brahman realization is only partial realization of the Personality of Godhead. O learned sages, the first letter of the word Bhagavän is twice significant: first in the sense of "one who fully maintains," and second in the sense of "guardian." The second letter—ga—means guide, leader or creator. The letter va (or ba) means that every being lives in Him, and He also lives in every being. In other words, the transcendental sound Bhagavän represents the infinite knowledge, potency, energy, opulence, strength and influence, all without any tinge of material inebrieties.

The Lord fully maintains His unalloyed devotees, and He guides such devotees progressively on the path of devotional perfection. As Leader of His devotees, He ultimately awards the desired result of devotional service by giving Himself to His devotees. The devotees of the Lord see the Lord eye to eye by the causeless mercy of the Lord, and thus the Lord helps His devotees to reach the supermost spiritual planet, Goloka Våndävan. As Creator, He can create all the necessary qualifications in His devotee so that the devotee can ultimately reach Him. The Lord is the Cause of all causes, and there is no cause of Him, for He is the Original Cause. As such He enjoys His own Self by manifesting His own internal potency.

The external potency is manifested not exactly by Himself, for He expands Himself as the Puruñas, and it is in these forms that He maintains the features of the material manifestation. By such expansions does He create, maintain and annihilate the cosmic manifestation.

The living entities are also differentiated expansions of His Self, and because some of the living entities desire to be lord, imitating the Supreme Lord, He allows them to enter into the cosmic creation, with the option of fully utilizing their propensity for lording it over. On account of the presence of His parts and parcels, the living entities, the whole phenomenal world is stirred into action and reaction. The living entities are given full facility to lord it over material Nature, but the ultimate controller is the Lord Himself in His plenary feature of Paramätman, the Supersoul, which is one of the Puruñas.

Therefore, there is a gulf of difference between the living entity known as ätman, and the controlling Lord, known as Paramätman—the soul and the Supersoul. Paramätman is the controller, and ätman is controlled; therefore they cannot be on the same level. The Paramätman fully cooperates with the ätman, and thus He is known as the constant companion of the living being.

This all-pervading feature of the Lord, Which exists in all circumstances of waking and sleeping, and also in potential states, and from Which the jéva-çakti (living force) is generated—as both the conditioned and the liberated souls—is known as Brahman.

Thus the Lord is the Origin of both Paramätman and Brahman, and therefore He is the Origin of all living entities, and all else that exists. One who knows this engages himself at once in the devotional service of the Lord. Such a pure and fully cognizant devotee of the Lord is fully attached to Him in heart and soul, and whenever such a devotee assembles with similar devotees, they have no other engagement but to glorify the Lord in terms of His transcendental activities. Those who are not as perfect as the pure devotees, those who have realized only the Brahman feature or the Paramätman feature of the Lord, cannot appreciate the activities of such perfect devotees. But the Lord always helps such pure devotees by supplying necessary knowledge within their hearts, and by His special favor He dissipates all the darkness of ignorance. This the philosophers and yogis cannot imagine, because they more or less depend on their own strength. As is stated in the Kaöha Upaniñad [1.2.23], the Lord can be known only to those whom He favors, and not to anyone else. And such special favors are, bestowed upon His pure devotees only. Çré Éçopaniñad here, indicates such favor of the Lord, beyond the purview of the Brahma-jyoti.

Iso 17-1969

Mantra Seventeen

vaAyaur"inalamama{ta-
maTaedM" BasmaAntaM zAr"Ir"-
maAe"M ‚(taAe smar" k{(taM smar"
‚(taAe smar" k{(taM smar"

TEXT

väyur anilam amåtam

athedaà bhasmäntaà çaréram

om krato smara kåtaà smara

krato smara kåtaà smara.

väyuù—air of life; anilam—total reservoir of air; amåtam—indestructible; atha—now; idam—this; bhasmäntam—after being turned into ashes; çaréram—body; om—O Lord; krato—the Enjoyer of all sacrifices; smara—please remember; kåtam—all that has been done by me; smara—please remember; krato—the Supreme Beneficiary; smara—please remember; kåtam—all that I have done for You; smara—please remember.

TRANSLATION

Let this temporary body be burnt into ashes, and let the air of life be merged with the totality of air. Now, O my Lord, please remember all my sacrifices, and because You are the ultimate Beneficiary, please remember all that I have done for You.

PURPORT

This temporary material body is certainly a foreign dress. In the Bhagavad-gétä [2.20] it is clearly said that after the destruction of the material body, the living entity is not annihilated, nor does he lose his identity. The identity of the living entity is never, therefore, impersonal or without form; but on the contrary, it is the material dress which is formless, and which takes a shape according to the form of the indestructible person. No living entity is originally formless, as is wrongly supposed by persons with a poor fund of knowledge. Here also in Mantra Seventeen of Çré Éçopaniñad, the principle is supported that the living entity exists after the annihilation of the material body.

In the material world there is wonderful workmanship by material Nature in the matter of creating different varieties of bodies for the living beings, in terms of their propensities for sense gratification. The one who wanted to taste stool is given a material body which is quite suitable, for eating—that of a hog. Similarly, the tiger has such a body that it can live by enjoying the blood of other animals, and by eating their flesh.

The human being is not meant for eating stool or flesh, because the shape of the teeth is different. Nor does he have any desire to taste stool, even in the most aboriginal state of life. Human teeth are so made that they can chew and cut fruit and vegetables, with two canine teeth so that one can eat flesh also.

The material bodies of all animals and men are foreign to the living entity, and change according to the desire of the being for sense gratification. In this cycle of evolution one changes bodies one after another: from aquatic life—when the world was full of water—to vegetable life, from vegetable life to worm life, from worm life to bird life, from bird life to animal life, and from animal life to the human form.

The highest development of life is this human form when it is possessed of a full sense of spiritual knowledge, and the highest development of spiritual sense is described in this mantra of the Veda: one should give up this material body to be turned into ashes, and allow the living air to merge into the eternal reservoir of air. The living being's activities are performed within the body by movements of different kinds of air, and this is called, in sum, the präëa-väyu. The yogis generally study to control the airs of the body, and the, soul is supposed to rise, up from one circle of air to another till it rises onto the brahma-randhra, or highest circle of air. Then the perfect yogi can transfer himself to any planet he likes. The process is to give up one material body and then enter into another body, and the, highest perfection of such a bodily change is possible when the living entity is able to give up this material body altogether, as is suggested in this mantra. He may then enter into the spiritual atmosphere, where he develops a completely different quality of body—a spiritual body—which never has to meet death or change.

Here in the material world one has to change his body, forced by material Nature on account of his different desires for sense gratification. These desires are represented in the various species of life, from the, germs to the most perfect material bodies, those of Brahmä and the demigods. All of these have bodies of matter in different shapes, and the intelligent person sees oneness not in the variety of bodies, but in the spiritual identity.

The spiritual spark which is the part and parcel of the Supreme Lord is the same either in the, body of a hog or in the body of a demigod. There are different bodies according to the pious and vicious activities of the living entity. The human body is highly developed, with full consciousness of the constitution of the body; and the most perfect man, according to the Vedic scriptures [Bg. 7.19], surrenders unto the Lord after many, many births of culturing knowledge. The culture of knowledge reaches perfection only when the knower comes to the point of surrendering unto the Supreme Lord, called Väsudeva. But even after attaining knowledge in the matter of one's spiritual identity, unless he comes to the point of knowing that the living entities are eternal parts and parcels of the Whole, and that they can never become the Whole, one has to fall down again into the material atmosphere, even after having become one with the Brahma-jyoti.

The Brahma-jyoti emanating from the transcendental body of the Lord is full of spiritual sparks. The spiritual sparks being individual identities with the full sense of existence, sometimes desire to become the enjoyers of the senses, and thus they are given places in the material world to become false lords, under the dictation of the senses. This sense of over-lordship is the material disease of the living being, and under the spell of such sense enjoyment he transmigrates through the different shapes of body manifested in the material world. The sense of becoming one with the Brahma-jyoti is not, therefore, mature knowledge. The sense of surrendering unto the Lord completely, and developing the sense of spiritual service is the highest perfectional stage.

In this mantra the living entity prays to enter into the spiritual Kingdom of God after relinquishing the material body and the material air. The devotee prays to the Lord to remember his activities and the sacrifices he has performed, now before his material body is turned into ashes. This prayer is made at the time of death, with full consciousness of his past deeds and of the ultimate goal. One who is completely under the rules of material law remembers the heinous activities performed during the existence of his material body, and therefore he gets another material body after death. The Bhagavad-gétä [8.6] confirms this truth. It states that at the time of death, the mind carries with it the propensities of the dying animal, and the next life is obtained in terms of that mental state.

Unlike the simple animals, who have no developed mind, the human being can remember the activities of his passing life like dreams at night, and therefore his mind remains surcharged with material desires, and he cannot enter into the spiritual kingdom with a spiritual body. The devotees, however, by practice of devotional service to the Lord, develop a sense of love for Godhead. And even if at the time of death a devotee does not remember his godly service, the Lord does not forget him. This prayer is to remind the Lord about the devotee's sacrifices, but even if there is no reminder, the Lord does not forget the devotional service of the pure devotee.

The Lord clearly describes His intimate relationship with His devotees in the Gétä [9.30-34]. Çréla Bhaktivinode Öhäkur explains the Gétä's verses in this connection:

One should accept a devotee who is on the right path of the saints, even though such a devotee may seem of loose character. One should try to understand the real import of the words "loose character." A conditioned soul has to act in double functions, namely one for the maintenance of the body, and again for self realization. Social status, mental development, cleanliness, austerity, nourishment and the struggle for existence, are all for the maintenance of the body. And the self realization part of his activities is executed in his occupation as a devotee of the Lord, and he performs action in that connection also. These two different functions go along parallel lines because a conditioned soul cannot give up the maintenance of the body. The proportion of activities for maintenance of the body decreases, however, in proportion to the increase in devotional service. And as long as the proportion of devotional service does not come to the right point, there is a chance for an occasional exhibition of worldliness. But it should be noted that such worldliness cannot continue for any length of time because, by the grace of the Lord, such imperfections will come to an end very shortly. Therefore, the path of devotional service is the only right path. Being on the right path, even an occasional occurrence of worldliness does not hamper one in the advancement of self realization.

And, in the Gétä Itself, Kåñëa says:

One who is engaged in devotional service, despite the most abominable action, is to be considered saintly because he is rightly situated. Very shortly does he become righteous, and attain to lasting peace. O son of Kunté, it is My promise that My devotee will never perish. O son of Påthä, anyone who will take shelter in Me, whether a woman or a merchant or born in a low family, can yet approach the Supreme Destination. How much greater then are the Brähmaëas, the righteous, the devotees and saintly kings! In this miserable world, these are fixed in devotional service to the Lord. Engage in My service, and surrender unto Me. Completely absorbed in Me, surely will you come to Me. (Gétä, IX/30-34)

Such facilities of devotional service are denied the impersonalists because they are attached to the Brahma-jyoti feature of the Lord. They can neither penetrate the Brahma-jyoti, as is suggested in the previous mantras, nor do they believe in the Personality of Godhead. Their business is mostly concerned with semantics, the jugglery of words of mental creation. As such the impersonalists pursue fruitless labor, as is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä in the Twelfth Chapter [5].

All the facilities suggested in this mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad can easily be obtained by constant contact with the Personal feature of the Absolute Truth. Devotional service to the Lord consists essentially of nine transcendental activities on the part of the devotee:

1. hearing about the Lord,
2. glorifying the Lord,
3. remembering the Lord,
4. serving the Lotus Feet of the Lord,
5. worshiping the Lord,
6. offering prayers to the Lord,
7. serving the Lord,
8. friendly association with the Lord,
9. surrendering everything unto the Lord.

These nine principles of devotional service, either in sum total or one by one, can help the devotee to be constantly in touch with God, and therefore at the end of life it is easy for the devotee to remember the Lord. By adopting only one of these nine principles it was possible for the following renowned devotees of the Lord to achieve the highest perfection:

1. By hearing only, Mahäräj Parékñit, the hero of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, achieved the desired result.
2. Just by glorifying the Lord, Çukadeva Gosvämé, the speaker of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, achieved his perfection.
3. By praying, Akrüra achieved the desired result.
4. By remembering, Prahläda Mahäräj achieved the desired result.
5. By worshiping, Påthu Mahäräj achieved perfection.
6. By serving the Lotus Feet of the Lord, the Goddess of Fortune, Lakñmé, achieved perfection.
7. By personal service to the Lord, Hanuman achieved the desired result.
8. By friendship, Arjuna achieved the result.
9. By surrendering everything that he had, Mahäräj Bali achieved the desired result.

Actually, the explanation of this mantra and of practically all the mantras of the Vedic hymns is summarized in the Vedänta-sütras; and then again they are properly explained in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the mature fruit of the Vedic tree of wisdom. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam this particular mantra is explained in the questions and answers of Mahäräj Parékñit and Gosvämé Çukadeva at the very beginning of their meeting. As hearing and chanting of the science of God is the basic principle of devotional life, so the complete Bhägavatam is heard by Mahäräj Paréksit and chanted by Gosvämé Çukadeva. Mahäräj Parékñit enquired from Çukadeva because Çukadeva was a greater spiritual master than any great yogi or transcendentalist of his time.

Mahäräj Parékñit's question was, "What is the duty of every man, specifically at the time of death?"

The answer by Gosvämé Çukadeva was that everyone who is desirous of being free from all anxieties should always hear about and glorify the Personality of Godhead, Who is the Supreme Director of everything, the Extinguisher of all difficulties, and the Supersoul of all living entities. [Bhäg. 2.1.5]

So-called human society is generally engaged at night in the matter of sleeping or sex indulgence. And during the daytime men are engaged in earning money as much as possible, or else in shopping for the family maintenance. People have very little time to talk about the Personality of Godhead or to make any enquiries about Him. They have dismissed the case of God's existence in so many ways, especially by declaring Him to be impersonal-that is, without any sense perception. But in the Vedic literature, whether the Upaniñads or the Vedänta-sütras or the Bhagavad-gétä or the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, in every scripture it is declared that the Lord is the sentient Being, supreme over all other living entities. And His glorious activities are identical with Himself. One should therefore not indulge in hearing and speaking of the rubbish activities of worldly politicians and the so-called big men of society, but should so mold his life that not a second is wasted without engagement in godly activities. Çré Éçopaniñad directs us towards such activities.

Unless one is accustomed to this devotional practice, what will he remember at the time of death when the body is dislocated, and how can he pray to the Almighty Lord to remember his sacrifices? Sacrifice means sacrificing the interest of the senses. One has to learn this art by employing the senses in the service of the Lord during one's lifetime, so that one can utilize the result at the time of death.

Iso 18-1969

Mantra Eighteen

@¢ae naya s$aupaTaA r"Ayae @smaAna,
ivaìAina de"va vayaunaAina ivaã"Ana,
yauyaAeDyasmaÀauò"r"ANAmaenaAe
BaUiyaï"AM tae namaoi·M( ivaDaema

TEXT

agne naya supathäräye asmän

viçväni deva vayunäni vidvän

yuyodhy asmaj juhuräëam eno

bhüyiñöhäà te nama-uktià vidhema.

agne—O my Lord, powerful like the fire; naya—kindly lead me; supathä—in the right path; räye—O the Omnipotent; asmän—all of us; viçväni—everything including; deva—O my Lord; vayunäni—all actions; vidvän—the knower; yuyodhi—get me freed from; asmat—ourselves; juhuräëam—all hindrances on the path; enas—all vices; bhüyiñöhäm—being fallen on the ground; te—unto you; namaù—of obeisances; uktim—words; vidhema—do I act.

TRANSLATION

O my Lord, powerful as the fire, Omnipotent One, now I do offer You all obeisances, falling at Your Feet on the ground. O my Lord, please lead me on the right path to reach You, and, as You know all of what I have done in the past, please make me free from the reactions to my past sins, so that there will be no hindrance to my progress.

PURPORT

This surrendering process and praying for the causeless mercy of the Lord leads the devotee progressively on the path of complete self realization. The Lord is addressed as the fire because He can burn anything into ashes—including the sins of the surrendered soul. As described in the previous mantras, the real or ultimate aspect of the Absolute is His feature as the Personality of Godhead. His impersonal feature of the Brahma-jyoti is a dazzling covering over the face of the Lord. Fruitive activities, or the karma-käëòa path of self realization, is the lowest stage in this endeavor. As soon as such activities become even slightly deviated from the regulative principles of the Vedas, such activities are transformed into vikarma, or acts against the interest of the actor. Such vikarma is enacted by the illusioned living entities simply for sense gratification, and thus such activities become hindrances on the path of self realization.

Self realization is possible for the human form of life, but not for other forms. There are 8,400,000 species or forms of life—of which the human form, with the qualifications of Brahminical culture, presents the only chance to obtain knowledge of the Transcendence. Brahminical culture means truthfulness, controlling the senses, forbearance, simplicity, full knowledge, full faith in God—and not to become simply proud of one's high parentage. To be the son of a Brähmaëa is a chance to become a Brähmaëa, just as being the son of a big man is a chance to become a big man. But such a birthright is not everything, because one still has to attain the Brahminical qualifications for himself. As soon as one becomes proud of his birth as the son of a Brähmaëa and neglects to acquire the qualifications of a real Brähmaëa, he at once becomes degraded and drawn from the path of self realization, and his life-mission as a human being is defeated.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [6.41-42] it is assured us by the Lord that the yoga-bhrañöas, or souls fallen from the path of self realization, are given a chance for rectification by taking birth either in the families of good Brähmaëas or in the families of rich merchants. These are the higher chances for self realization: to become a rich man's son, or to become the son of a good Brähmaëa. And if these chances are misused by the illusioned human being, the result is that such a man loses the good chance of human life offered by the Almighty Lord.

The regulative principles are such that one who follows them is promoted from the plane of fruitive activities to the plane of transcendental knowledge, and from transcendental knowledge he becomes perfect, after many, many births, when he surrenders unto the Lord. This is the general procedure. But one who surrenders at the very beginning, as is mentioned in this mantra, at once surpasses all the stages of progression by simple adoption of the devotional attitude. As is stated in the Gétä [18.66], the Lord at once takes charge of such a surrendered soul and makes him free from all the reactions to his sinful acts. In the karma-käëòa activities there are many sinful actions, and in jïäna-käëòa, the path of philosophical development, the number of such actions is less. But in devotional service, to the Lord, the path of bhakti, there is practically no chance of sinful reactions. One who is a devotee of the Lord attains all the good qualifications of the Lord Himself, not to mention becoming a Brähmaëa. A devotee automatically attains the qualifications of an expert Brähmaëa authorized to perform sacrifices, even though such a devotee may not have taken his birth in the family of a Brähmaëa. Such is the omnipotence of the Lord that He can make a man born in the family of a Brähmaëa as degraded as a lowborn dog-eater, and He can also make a lowborn dog-cuter more than a qualified Brähmaëa, simply on the strength of devotional service.

The omnipotent Lord, being situated within the heart of everyone, can give directions to His sincere devotee as to the right path. Such directions are especially offered to the devotee, even if he desires something else. For others God gives sanction to the doer only at the risk of the doer, but in the case of a devotee the Lord directs him in such a way that he never acts wrongly. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [11.5.42] it is said that the Lord is so kind upon His devotee that even though he sometimes falls into the entanglement of vikarma—acts against the directions of the Vedas—the Lord at once rectifies the mistakes of the devotee from within his heart, because such devotees are very dear to the Lord.

Here in this mantra the devotee prays to the Lord to rectify him from within his heart. To err is human: A conditioned soul is very often apt to commit mistakes, and the only remedial measure for such unknown sins is to give oneself up to the Lotus Feet of the Lord, so that He may guide the devotee. The Lord takes this charge for the fully surrendered souls, and thus all problems are solved simply by surrendering oneself unto the Lord and acting in terms of the Lord's directions. Such directions are given to the sincere devotee in two ways. One is by means of the saints, scriptures, and spiritual master; and the other is by the Lord Himself, residing within the heart of everyone. Thus the devotee is protected in all respects.

The Vedic knowledge is transcendental and it cannot be understood simply by mundane educational procedures. One can understand the Vedic mantras only by the grace of the Lord and the spiritual master [ÇU 6.23]. If one takes shelter of a bona fide spiritual master, it is to be understood that he has obtained the grace of the Lord. The Lord appears as the spiritual master for the devotee. And so the spiritual master, the Vedic injunctions, and the Lord Himself from within all guide the devotee in full strength, and there is no chance of such a devotee falling again into the mire of material illusion. The devotee, thus protected all around, is sure to reach the ultimate destination of perfection. The whole process is hinted at in this mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad, and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.2.17-20] still further explains this.

Hearing and chanting of the glories of the Lord are themselves acts of piety. The Lord wants everyone to do this, because He is the Well-wisher of all living entities. And by practicing this hearing and chanting of the glories of the Lord, one becomes cleansed of all undesirable things within himself. His devotion becomes fixed upon the Lord. At this stage the devotee acquires the Brahminical qualifications, and the resultant reactions of lower qualities become completely vanished. He becomes fully enlightened by such devotional service and thus knows the path of the Lord and how to attain Him. All doubts become diminished, and he becomes a pure devotee.

Thus end the Bhaktivedänta Purports to Çré Éçopaniñad, the knowledge that brings one nearer to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa.

Iso About the author-1969

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedänta Swämé Prabhupäda was born Abhay Charan De on September 1, 1896 in Calcutta. In 1920 he finished his schooling, majoring in philosophy, English and economics at the University of Calcutta. Soon afterward, Abhay Charan De took up the duties of manager of a large chemical concern. Then in 1922, he met His Divine Grace Çré Çrémad Bhakti Siddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Mahäräj, the founder of 64 Gauòéya Vaiñëava Maöhs in India, Berlin and London. His Divine Grace recently recalled the key to his approaching his spiritual master: "When I first started going to see my Guru Mahäräj, he said of me, 'This boy hears very nicely. He does not go away. So I shall make him a disciple.' That was my qualification, or whatever you may call it. I would simply ask when Guru Mahäräj would speak, then I'd sit down and go on hearing. I would understand, or not understand; others would disperse, I'd not disperse. So he remarked, 'This boy is interested to hear. Because I was serious in hearing, therefore I am now serious about kértanam, which means speaking or preaching. If one has heard nicely, then he will speak nicely."

At Allahabad in 1933, Abhay Charan De was formally initiated, and in 1936, just days before Bhakti Siddhänta Sarasvaté's departure from this mortal world, he was specifically ordered to spread Kåñëa Consciousness in the English language to the West.

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedänta Swämé Prabhupäda has told us that at first he did not take the mission given to him by his spiritual master with the utmost seriousness. But then he was reading a Bhagavad-gétä commentary by Çréla Bhaktivinode Öhäkur, who was the father of Bhakti Siddhänta Sarasvaté and the pioneer of the Kåñëa Consciousness movement in the modern age. Çréla Bhaktivinode has written that just as one cannot separate the body from the soul while in this conditioned state, so the disciple cannot separate the spiritual master's order from his very life. Çréla Prabhupäda took these words seriously, and gradually his whole life became dedicated to carrying out the orders of his Guru Mahäräj. In 1959 he look sannyäsa, the renounced order of spiritual life, and in 1965, at the advanced age of 70, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedänta Swämé Prabhupäda arrived in New York City to fulfill his master's sacred mission.

One must try to understand that Çréla Prabhupäda is neither an Indian author nor Indian culturist nor Hindu sectarian. The first teaching of the Bhagavad-gétä is that no one is Indian, no one is American—our real self is beyond this temporary bodily designation; our permanent identity, eternal, blissful and full of knowledge, is with the Supreme Personality of Godhead as His eternal servant; and our position is to be situated beyond the material universes in the spiritual planets, within the spiritual sky. This is the platform of Kåñëa Consciousness.

To think, "I am American," "I am Russian," etc. is our disease, and is due to forgetfulness of our eternal nature as spirit soul. Unfortunately, under the spell of illusion, every embodied creature is satisfied with his present material body. Even the worm in the stool is thinking, "I am all right." Despite so many disadvantages and miseries, all living entities are engaged in satisfying their senses and are thinking it is all right. Therefore when the bona fide guru comes with the transcendental message, calling the souls back to home, back to Godhead, they do not want to come out of material encagement. Often, people prefer to be encouraged in illusion and therefore pay fees to learn that they are God or equal to God in all respects and thus "free" to go on "enjoying" material life of sense gratification. So we see yoga and meditation teachers advertising that they will improve one's material facilities. They overlook the fact that elimination of sense gratification is the first step in the standard yoga or transcendental system. His Divine Grace Çréla Prabhupäda does not encourage unrestricted sense gratification, or the belief that one is God, or that God is impersonal or void. He is passing on, as it is, the information from Vedic literature, that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is a Person and that devotional service unto Him is the perfection of all purificatory processes. Lord Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä is recognized as the Supreme Lord, and Çré Éçopaniñad confirms the Personality of Godhead as the anti-material Supreme Controller and the only Enjoyer. His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedänta Swämé Prabhupäda is teaching surrender to Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord.

Çréla Prabhupäda is the living example of the saintly person pointed to in all Vedic literature who is personally free from all material contamination and active in spiritual understanding. He is the Kåñëa conscious personality who is so dear to Kåñëa, who understands that the highest welfare is not to pose oneself as the friend of humanity, but to teach that God or Kåñëa is the dear-most Friend Who alone is capable of alleviating the misery of each and every living entity. His Divine Grace is teaching what is really common sense to our intelligence, but we are so bewildered by the glitter of the material nature that we are distracted from his message. He is simply canvassing for God on the order of his spiritual master. Once Çréla Prabhupäda was asked, "Are you an incarnation of God?" "No," he answered, "I am servant of God." Then he paused and went on, "Not exactly servant. To be servant of God is not an ordinary thing." The servants or devotees of Kåñëa are so great that they are beyond the desire to merge with God. Sometimes, in their intimate association and exchange with God, they even become "greater" than Him, as when He allows some devotee to become His mother or lover. Prabhupäda's mission is not less than to distribute this topmost love of God to all persons. It is stated in the Vedic literature that a small man wants to make only himself happy, a somewhat bigger man wants to make his family or his country happy, but the great man wants to make all persons happy.

His Divine Grace produces his books by speaking them on a dictaphone. He is presently working on five books at once. These books are a matter of realization. As he has said, "When you become self-realized you automatically write volumes of books." And one of the qualifications of a devotee is that he is poetic. Çréla Prabhupäda is always immersed in Kåñëa by speaking, dictating, singing about Kåñëa's Glories, preaching formally at meetings or planning the expansion of the Kåñëa Consciousness movement. In the Seventh Chapter, it is stated that out of thousands of men few seek perfection, and out of the thousands who attain perfection hardly one knows Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa also declares in the Eighteenth Chapter that the dearmost devotee of all is he who spreads the teaching of love of Kåñëa: "Never will there be one dearer to Me."

His Divine Grace's spiritual master, Bhakti Siddhänta Sarasvaté, once drew a picture of a mådanga (a drum used on Saìkértan) and, beside it, a printing press. he said that the mådanga can be heard for several blocks, but that the press can be heard around the world. He therefore called the printing press "the big mådanga." For the purpose of world-wide service to humanity, ISKCON Press has been established, for the exclusive printing of Çréla Prabhupäda's books.

In 1968, Macmillan published The Bhagavad Gétä As It Is translated with commentary by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedänta Swämé Prabhupäda. The Gétä is the gist of the entire Vedic literature. Just this one book can free anyone from the clutches of material nature and fix one in eternal loving service unto Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead. As originally written by Çréla Prabhupäda, the manuscript of The Bhagavad Gétä As It Is is many times larger than the Macmillan version. Publication of this original expanded version is being undertaken by ISKCON. Another important published literature by Çréla Prabhupäda is his Teachings of Lord Chaitanya. This book outlines the precepts of Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the Golden Avatar Who appeared in India 500 years ago and propagated the Hare Kåñëa mantra as the means of God realization for the present age. A book called The Nectar of Devotion, an authorized summary study of Çré Rüpa Gosvämé's Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, has just been published. Çréla Prabhupäda is presently, writing a several volume work called Kåñëa, which contains all of the Pastimes of the Supreme Lord when present on this planet 5000 years ago. Translations are also underway of the Vedänta-sütras, Caitanya-caritämåta and his 12 volumes of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The literatures compiled by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedänta Swämé Prabhupäda are authorized by the disciplic succession, which is descending from Kåñëa Himself. Çréla Prabhupäda's whole life mission is to faithfully pass on the original understanding of Kåñëa Consciousness without distortion. According to the Vedic literature this descending process is the only way to realization of the Absolute Truth, since the Absolute Truth is beyond the reach of our mundane speculation.

The author is not a retired personality, despite his prodigious literary output. He personally and very intimately guides his disciples through the most practical problems of daily life. Spiritual life is practical and, due to the predominent material atmosphere of Kali-yuga, often problematic. As spiritual master, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedänta Swämé Prabhupäda is the last recourse and the ultimate standard of Kåñëa Consciousness, and he writes some twenty-five letters a day to leaders and students of his various worldwide centers. He himself resides in no one place but travels from center to center and regularly lectures. The spiritual master is responsible for his devotees; when he accepts a sincere soul as his disciple, he promises to take him back home, back to Godhead. No one should think, "Oh, everyone is taking a spiritual master; let me take one." The spiritual master as a style or as a pet is useless. Rather, his order is to be taken as one's life and soul. By taking shelter at the feet of the bona fide guru and serving him twenty-four hours a day, the fallen soul can be lifted to the spiritual sky. It is said that if the spiritual master is pleased, then one can make great advances in spiritual life. And one pure convinced devotee can make many pure devotees by his example and teachings. Those serious students with an understanding of the absolute value of the spiritual platform of life therefore honor the spiritual master with the honor due to God because the guru is the transparent via medium or representative of God and is distributing unalloyed love of God. The intelligent reader is invited to take to this philosophy with the utmost seriousness.

Iso Glossary-1969

GLOSSARY

The Nectar of Instruction - 1976 Edition

NoI Front pages

Front pages

ELEVEN LESSONS IN THE ANCENT SCIENCE OF BHAKTI-YOGA

Across five centuries and half the globe comes this compact guidebook of essential spiritual teachings. How to choose a guru, how to practice yoga, even where to live—you'll find it all in this invaluable work originally written in Sanskrit by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, the greatest spiritual genius of medieval India.

Now translated and illuminated by Rüpa Gosvämé's modern successor, His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedänta Swami Prabhupäda, The Nectar of Instruction is the key to enlightenment for all seekers on the path of spiritual perfection.

-------------------------------------------------


BOOKS by
His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 1-8 (24 Vols.)
Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (17 Vols.)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
The Nectar of Devotion
The Nectar of Instruction
Çré Éçopaniñad
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (3 Vols.)
Perfect Questions, Perfect Answers
Dialectic Spiritualism—A Vedic View of Western Philosophy (3 Vols.)
Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäräja
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
Life Comes from Life
The Perfection of Yoga
Beyond Birth and Death
On the Way to Kåñëa
Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge
Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Matchless Gift
Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)


A complete catalog is available upon request


International Society for Krishna Consciousness
3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90034


On the cover: The samädhi (tomb) of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé at the Rädhä-Dämodara temple in Våndävana, India.

-----------------------------------------------------

All Glory to Çré Guru and Gauräìga


THE NECTAR OF INSTRUCTION

An Authorized English Presentation of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé's

Çré Upadeçämåta

with the original Sanskrit text,
roman transliterations, synonyms,
translations and elaborate purports by


HIS DIVINE GRACE
A.C. Bhaktivedänta Swami Prabhupäda
Founder-Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness


THE BHAKTIVEDÄNTA BOOK TRUST
New York - Los Angeles. London. Bombay

--------------------------------------------------------


Readers interested in the subject matter
of this book are invited by
the International Society for Krishna Consciousness
to correspond with its Secretary.


International Society
for Krishna Consciousness
3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90034


© 1975 Bhaktivedänta Book Trust
All Rights Reserved
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 75-39755
International Standard Book Number: 0-912776-85-4


First printing, 1975: 10,000 copies
Second printing, 1976: 100,000 copies


Printed in the United States of America

NoI Preface

Preface

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is conducted under the supervision of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé. The Gauòéya Vaiñëavas, or Bengali Vaiñëavas, are mostly followers of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, of whom the six Gosvämés of Våndävana are direct disciples. Therefore Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkura has sung:

rüpa-raghunätha-pade ha-ibe äkuti
kabe häma bujhaba se yugala-périti
[Lälasämayé 4]

"When I am eager to understand the literature given by the Gosvämés, then I shall be able to understand the transcendental loving affairs of Rädhä and Kåñëa." Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu appeared in order to bestow upon human society the benediction of the science of Kåñëa. The most exalted of all the activities of Lord Kåñëa are His pastimes of conjugal love with the gopés. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu appeared in the mood of Çrématé Rädhäräëé, the best of the gopés. Therefore, to understand the mission of Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu and follow in His footsteps, one must very seriously follow in the footsteps of the six Gosvämés—Çré Rüpa, Sanätana, Bhaööa Raghunätha, Çré Jéva, Gopäla Bhaööa and Däsa Raghunätha.

Çré Rüpa Gosvämé was the leader of all the Gosvämés, and to guide our activities he gave us this Upadeçämåta (The Nectar of Instruction) to follow. As Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu left behind Him the eight verses known as Çikñäñöaka, Rüpa Gosvämé gave us Upadeçämåta so that we may become pure Vaiñëavas.

In all spiritual affairs, one's first duty is to control his mind and senses. Unless one controls his mind and senses, one cannot make any advancement in spiritual life. Everyone within this material world is engrossed in the modes of passion and ignorance. One must promote himself to the platform of goodness, sattva-guëa, by following the instructions of Rüpa Gosvämé, and then everything concerning how to make further progress will be revealed.

Advancement in Kåñëa consciousness depends on the attitude of the follower. A follower of the Kåñëa consciousness movement should become a perfect gosvämé. Vaiñëavas are generally known as gosvämés. In Våndävana, this is the title by which the director of each temple is known. One who wants to become a perfect devotee of Kåñëa must become a gosvämé. Go means "the senses," and svämé means "the master." Unless one controls his senses and mind, one cannot become a gosvämé. To achieve the highest success in life by becoming a gosvämé and then a pure devotee of the Lord, one must follow the instructions known as Upadeçämåta, which have been given by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has given many other books, such as Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, Vidagdha-mädhava and Lalita-mädhava, but Upadeçämåta constitutes the first instructions for neophyte devotees. One should follow these instructions very strictly. Then it will be easier to make one's life successful. Hare Kåñëa.

A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

September 20, 1975
Viçvarüpa-mahotsava
Kåñëa-Balaräma Mandira
Ramaëa-reti
Våndävana, India

NoI: verse 1

TEXT ONE

vaAcaAe vaegAM manas$a: ‚(AeDavaegAM
ijaù"AvaegAmaud"r"AepasTavaegAma,
WtaAna, vaegAAna, yaAe ivaSahe"ta DaIr":
s$avaARmapaImaAM pa{iTavaI%M s$a izASyaAta,

TEXT

väco vegaà manasaù krodha-vegaà

jihvä-vegam udaropastha-vegam

etän vegän yo viñaheta dhéraù

sarväm apémäà påthivéà sa çiñyät

väcaù—of speech; vegam—urge; manasaù—of the mind; krodha—of anger; vegam—urge; jihvä—of the tongue; vegam—urge; udara-upastha—of the belly and genitals; vegam—urge; etän—these; vegän—urges; yaù—whoever; viñaheta—can tolerate; dhéraù—sober; sarväm—all; api—certainly; imäm—this; påthivém—world; saù—that personality; çiñyät—can make disciples.

TRANSLATION

A sober person who can tolerate the urge to speak, the mind's demands, the actions of anger and the urges of the tongue, belly and genitals is qualified to make disciples all over the world.

PURPORT

In Çrémad-Bhägavatam (6.1.9-10) Parékñit Mahäräja placed a number of intelligent questions before Çukadeva Gosvämé. One of these questions was: "Why do people undergo atonement if they cannot control their senses?" For instance, a thief may know perfectly well that he may be arrested for his stealing, and he may actually even see a thief arrested by the police, yet he continues to steal. Experience is gathered by hearing and seeing. One who is less intelligent gathers experience by seeing, and one who is more intelligent gathers experience by hearing. When an intelligent person hears from the lawbooks and çästras, or scriptures, that stealing is not good and hears that a thief is punished when arrested, he refrains from theft. A less intelligent person may first have to be arrested and punished for stealing to learn to stop stealing. However, a rascal, a foolish man, may have the experience of both hearing and seeing and may even be punished, but still he continues to steal. Even if such a person atones and is punished by the government, he will again commit theft as soon as he comes out of jail. If punishment in jail is considered atonement, what is the benefit of such atonement? Thus Parékñit Mahäräja inquired:

dåñöa-çrutäbhyäà yat päpaà
jänann apy ätmano 'hitam
karoti bhüyo vivaçaù
präyaçcittam atho katham
[Bhag. 6.1.9]

kvacin nivartate 'bhadrät
kvacic carati tat punaù
präyaçcittam atho 'pärthaà
manye kuïjara-çaucavat

(Bhag. 6.1.10)

He compared atonement to an elephant's bathing. The elephant may take a very nice bath in the river, but as soon as it comes onto the bank, it throws dirt all over its body. What, then, is the value of its bathing? Similarly, many spiritual practitioners chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra and at the same time commit many forbidden things, thinking that their chanting will counteract their offenses. Of the ten types of offenses one can commit while chanting the holy name of the Lord, this offense is called nämno baläd yasya hi päpa-buddhiù, committing sinful activities on the strength of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. Similarly, certain Christians go to church to confess their sins, thinking that confessing their sins before a priest and performing some penance will relieve them from the results of their weekly sins. As soon as Saturday is over and Sunday comes, they again begin their sinful activities, expecting to be forgiven the next Saturday. This kind of präyaçcitta, or atonement, is condemned by Parékñit Mahäräja, the most intelligent king of his time. Çukadeva Gosvämé, equally intelligent, as befitting the spiritual master of Mahäräja Parékñit, answered the King and confirmed that his statement concerning atonement was correct. A sinful activity cannot be counteracted by a pious activity. Thus real präyaçcitta, atonement, is the awakening of our dormant Kåñëa consciousness.

Real atonement involves coming to real knowledge, and for this there is a standard process. When one follows a regulated hygienic process, he does not fall sick. A human being is meant to be trained according to certain principles to revive his original knowledge. Such a methodical life is described as tapasya. One can be gradually elevated to the standard of real knowledge, or Kåñëa consciousness, by practicing austerity and celibacy (brahmäcärya), by controlling the mind, by controlling the senses, by giving up one's possessions in charity, by being avowedly truthful, by keeping clean and by practicing yoga-äsanas. However, if one is fortunate enough to get the association of a pure devotee, he can easily surpass all the practices for controlling the mind by the mystic yoga process simply by following the regulative principles of Kåñëa consciousness—refraining from illicit sex, meat-eating, intoxication and gambling—and by engaging in the service of the Supreme Lord under the direction of the bona fide spiritual master. This easy process is being recommended by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé.

First one must control his speaking power. Every one of us has the power of speech; as soon as we get an opportunity we begin to speak. If we do not speak about Kåñëa consciousness, we speak about all sorts of nonsense. A toad in a field speaks by croaking, and similarly everyone who has a tongue wants to speak, even if all he has to say is nonsense. The croaking of the toad, however, simply invites the snake: "Please come here and eat me." Nevertheless, although it is inviting death, the toad goes on croaking. The talking of materialistic men and impersonalist Mäyävädé philosophers may be compared to the croaking of frogs. They are always speaking nonsense and thus inviting death to catch them. Controlling speech, however, does not mean self-imposed silence (the external process of mauna), as Mäyävädé philosophers think. Silence may appear helpful for some time, but ultimately it proves a failure. The meaning of controlled speech conveyed by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé advocates the positive process of kåñëa-kathä, engaging the speaking process in glorifying the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa. The tongue can thus glorify the name, form, qualities and pastimes of the Lord. The preacher of kåñëa-kathä is always beyond the clutches of death. This is the significance of controlling the urge to speak.

The restlessness or fickleness of the mind (mano-vega) is controlled when one can fix his mind on the lotus feet of Kåñëa. The Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.31) says:

kåñëa—sürya-sama; mäyä haya andhakära
yähäì kåñëa, tähäì nähi mäyära adhikära

Kåñëa is just like the sun, and mäyä is just like darkness. If the sun is present, there is no question of darkness. Similarly, if Kåñëa is present in the mind, there is no possibility of the mind's being agitated by mäyä's influence. The yogic process of negating all material thoughts will not help. To try to create a vacuum in the mind is artificial. The vacuum will not remain. However, if one always thinks of Kåñëa and how to serve Kåñëa best, one's mind will naturally be controlled.

Similarly, anger can be controlled. We cannot stop anger altogether, but if we simply become angry with those who blaspheme the Lord or the devotees of the Lord, we control our anger in Kåñëa consciousness. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu became angry with the miscreant brothers Jagäi and Mädhäi, who blasphemed and struck Nityänanda Prabhu. In His Çikñäñöaka Lord Caitanya wrote, tåëäd api sunécena taror api sahiñëunä: "One should be humbler than the grass and more tolerant than the tree." One may then ask why the Lord exhibited His anger. The point is that one should be ready to tolerate all insults to one's own self, but when Kåñëa or His pure devotee is blasphemed, a genuine devotee becomes angry and acts like fire against the offenders. Krodha, anger, cannot be stopped, but it can be applied rightly. It was in anger that Hanumän set fire to Laìkä, but he is worshiped as the greatest devotee of Lord Rämacandra. This means that he utilized his anger in the right way. Arjuna serves as another example. He was not willing to fight, but Kåñëa incited his anger: "You must fight!" To fight without anger is not possible. Anger is controlled, however, when utilized in the service of the Lord.

As for the urges of the tongue, we all experience that the tongue wants to eat palatable dishes. Generally we should not allow the tongue to eat according to its choice, but should control the tongue by supplying prasäda. The devotee's attitude is that he will eat only when Kåñëa gives him prasäda. That is the way to control the urge of the tongue. One should take prasäda at scheduled times and should not eat in restaurants or sweetmeat shops simply to satisfy the whims of the tongue or belly. If we stick to the principle of taking only prasäda, the urges of the belly and tongue can be controlled.

In a similar manner, the urges of the genitals, the sex impulse, can be controlled when not used unnecessarily. The genitals should be used to beget a Kåñëa conscious child, otherwise they should not be used. The Kåñëa consciousness movement encourages marriage not for the satisfaction of the genitals but for the begetting of Kåñëa conscious children. As soon as the children are a little grown up, they are sent to our Gurukula school in Dallas, Texas, where they are trained to become fully Kåñëa conscious devotees. Many such Kåñëa conscious children are required, and one who is capable of bringing forth Kåñëa conscious offspring is allowed to utilize his genitals.

When one is fully practiced in the methods of Kåñëa conscious control, he can become qualified to be a bona fide spiritual master.

In his Anuvåtti explanation of Upadeçämåta, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura writes that our material identification creates three kinds of urges—the urge to speak, the urge or demands of the mind and the demands of the body. When a living entity falls victim to these three types of urges, his life becomes inauspicious. One who practices resisting these demands or urges is called tapasvé, or one who practices austerities. By such tapasya one can overcome victimization by the material energy, the external potency of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

When we refer to the urge to speak, we refer to useless talking, such as that of the impersonal Mäyävädé philosophers, or of persons engaged in fruitive activities (technically called karma-käëòa), or of materialistic people who simply want to enjoy life without restriction. All such talks or literatures are practical exhibitions of the urge to speak. Many people are talking nonsensically and writing volumes of useless books, and all this is the result of the urge to speak. To counteract this tendency, we have to divert our talking to the subject of Kåñëa. This is explained in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.5.10-11):

na yad vacaç citra-padaà harer yaço
jagat-pavitraà pragåëéta karhicit
tad väyasaà tértham uçanti mänasä
na yatra haàsä niramanty uçikkñayäù

"Those words which do not describe the glories of the Lord, who alone can sanctify the atmosphere of the whole universe, are considered by saintly persons to be like unto a place of pilgrimage for crows. Since the all-perfect persons are inhabitants of the transcendental abode, they do not derive any pleasure there."

tad-väg-visargo janatägha-viplavo
yasmin prati-çlokam abaddhavaty api
nämäny anantasya yaço 'ìkitäni yat
çåëvanti gäyanti gåëanti sädhavaù

"On the other hand, that literature which is full of descriptions of the transcendental glories of the name, fame, forms, pastimes, etc., of the unlimited Supreme Lord is a different creation, full of transcendental words directed toward bringing about a revolution in the impious lives of this world's misdirected civilization. Such transcendental literatures, even though imperfectly composed, are heard, sung and accepted by purified men who are thoroughly honest."

The conclusion is that only when we talk about devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead can we refrain from useless nonsensical talk. We should always endeavor to use our speaking power solely for the purpose of realizing Kåñëa consciousness.

As for the agitations of the flickering mind, they are divided into two divisions. The first is called avirodha-préti, or unrestricted attachment, and the other is called virodha-yukta-krodha, anger arising from frustration. Adherence to the philosophy of the Mäyävädés, belief in the fruitive results of the karma-vädés, and belief in plans based on materialistic desires are called avirodha-préti. Jïänés, karmés and materialistic planmakers generally attract the attention of conditioned souls, but when the materialists cannot fulfill their plans and when their devices are frustrated, they become angry. Frustration of material desires produces anger.

Similarly, the demands of the body can be divided into three categories—the demands of the tongue, the belly and the genitals. One may observe that these three senses are physically situated in a straight line, as far as the body is concerned, and that the bodily demands begin with the tongue. If one can restrain the demands of the tongue by limiting its activities to the eating of prasäda, the urges of the belly and the genitals can automatically be controlled. In this connection Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says:

çaréra avidyä-jäla, jaòendriya tähe käla,
jéve phele viñaya-sägare
tä'ra madhye jihvä ati, lobhamäyä sudurmati,
tä'ke jetä kaöhina saàsäre

kåñëa baòa dayämaya, karibäre jihvä jaya,
sva-prasäda-anna dila bhäi
sei annämåta khäo, rädhä-kåñëa-guëa gäo,
preme òäka caitanya-nitäi

"O Lord! This material body is a lump of ignorance, and the senses are a network of paths leading to death. Somehow or other we have fallen into the ocean of material sense enjoyment, and of all the senses the tongue is the most voracious and uncontrollable. It is very difficult to conquer the tongue in this world, but You, dear Kåñëa, are very kind to us. You have sent this nice prasäda to help us conquer the tongue; therefore let us take this prasäda to our full satisfaction and glorify Your Lordships Çré Çré Rädhä and Kåñëa and in love call for the help of Lord Caitanya and Prabhu Nityänanda." [Prasäda-seväya 1]

There are six kinds of rasas (tastes), and if one is agitated by any one of them, he becomes controlled by the urges of the tongue. Some persons are attracted to the eating of meat, fish, crabs, eggs and other things produced by semina and blood and eaten in the form of dead bodies. Others are attracted by eating vegetables, creepers, spinach or milk products, but all for the satisfaction of the tongue's demands. Such eating for sense gratification—including the use of extra quantities of spices like chili and tamarind—is to be given up by Kåñëa conscious persons. The use of pan, haritaké, betel nuts, various spices used in pan-making, tobacco, LSD, marijuana, opium, liquor, coffee and tea is indulged in to fulfill illicit demands.

If we can practice accepting only remnants of food offered to Kåñëa, it is possible to get free from mäyä's victimization. Vegetables, grains, fruits, milk products and water are proper foods to offer to the Lord, as Lord Kåñëa Himself prescribes. However, if one accepts prasäda only because of its palatable taste and thus eats too much, he also falls prey to trying to satisfy the demands of the tongue. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu taught us to avoid very palatable dishes even while eating prasäda. If we offer palatable dishes to the Deity with the intention of eating such nice food, we are involved in trying to satisfy the demands of the tongue. If we accept the invitation of a rich man with the idea of receiving palatable food, we are also trying to satisfy the demands of the tongue. In Caitanya-caritämåta (Antya 6.227) it is stated:

jihvära lälase yei iti-uti dhäya
çiçnodara-paräyaëa kåñëa nähi päya

"That person who runs here and there seeking to gratify his palate and who is always attached to the desires of his stomach and genitals is unable to attain Kåñëa."

As stated before, the tongue, belly and genitals are all situated in a straight line, and they fall in the same category. Lord Caitanya has said, bhäla nä khäibe ära bhäla nä paribe: "Do not dress luxuriously and do not eat delicious foodstuffs." [Antya 6.236]

Those who suffer from diseases of the stomach must be unable to control the urges of the belly, at least according to this analysis. When we desire to eat more than necessary we automatically create many inconveniences in life. However, if we observe fasting days like Ekädaçé and Janmäñöamé, we can restrain the demands of the belly.

As far as the urges of the genitals are concerned, there are two—proper and improper, or legal and illicit sex. When a man is properly mature, he can marry according to the rules and regulations of the çästras and use his genitals for begetting nice children. That is legal and religious. Otherwise, he may adopt many artificial means to satisfy the demands of the genitals, and he may not use any restraint. When one indulges in illicit sex life, as defined by the çästras, either by thinking, planning, talking about or actually having sexual intercourse, or by satisfying the genitals by artificial means, he is caught in the clutches of mäyä. These instructions apply not only to householders but also to tyägés, or those who are in the renounced order of life. In his book Prema-vivarta, Chapter Seven, Çré Jagadänanda Paëòita says:

vairägé bhäi grämya-kathä nä çunibe käne
grämya-värtä nä kahibe yabe milibe äne

svapane o nä kara bhäi stré-sambhäñaëa
gåhe stré chäòiyä bhäi äsiyächa vana

yadi cäha praëaya räkhite gauräìgera sane
choöa haridäsera kathä thäke yena mane

bhäla nä khäibe ära bhäla nä paribe
hådayete rädhä-kåñëa sarvadä sevibe

"My dear brother, you are in the renounced order of life and should not listen to talk about ordinary worldly things, nor should you talk about worldly things when you meet with others. Do not think of women even in dreams. You have accepted the renounced order of life with a vow that forbids you to associate with women. If you wish to associate with Caitanya Mahäprabhu, you must always remember the incident of Choöa Haridäsa and how he was rejected by the Lord. Do not eat luxurious dishes or dress in fine garments, but always remain humble and serve Their Lordships Çré Çré Rädhä-Kåñëa in your heart of hearts." [Prema-vivarta 7.3.1-4]

The conclusion is that one who can control these six items—speech, mind, anger, tongue, belly and genitals—is to be called a svämé or gosvämé. Svämé means master, and gosvämé means master of the go, or senses. When one accepts the renounced order of life, he automatically assumes the title of svämé. This does not mean that he is the master of his family, community or society; he must be master of his senses. Unless one is master of his senses, he should not be called gosvämé, but go-däsa, servant of the senses. Following in the footsteps of the six Gosvämés of Våndävana, all svämés and gosvämés should fully engage in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. As opposed to this, the go-däsas engage in the service of the senses or in the service of the material world. They have no other engagement. Prahläda Mahäräja has further described the go-däsa as adänta-go, which refers to one whose senses are not controlled. An adänta-go cannot become a servant of Kåñëa. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam (7.5.30), Prahläda Mahäräja has said:

matir na kåñëe parataù svato vä
mitho 'bhipadyeta gåhavratänäm
adänta-gobhir viçatäà tamisraà
punaù punaç carvita-carvaëänäm

"For those who have decided to continue their existence in this material world for the gratification of their senses, there is no chance of becoming Kåñëa conscious, not by personal endeavor, by instruction from others or by joint conferences. They are dragged by the unbridled senses into the darkest region of ignorance, and thus they madly engage in what is called 'chewing the chewed.' "

NoI: verse 2

TEXT TWO

@tyaAh"Ar": ‘ayaAs$aê
‘ajalpaAe inayamaAƒah":
janas$aËÿê laAElyaM ca
SaiÑ"BaRi·(ivaRnazyaita

TEXT

atyähäraù prayäsaç ca

prajalpo niyamägrahaù

jana-saìgaç ca laulyaà ca

ñaòbhir bhaktir vinaçyati

ati-ähäraù—overeating or too much collecting; prayäsaù—overendeavoring; ca—and; prajalpaù—idle talking; niyama—rules and regulations; ägrahaù—too much attachment to (or agrahaù—too much neglect of); jana-saìgaù—association with worldly-minded persons; ca—and; laulyam—ardent longing or greed; ca—and; ñaòbhiù—by these six; bhaktiù—devotional service; vinaçyati—is destroyed.

TRANSLATION

One's devotional service is spoiled when he becomes too entangled in the following six activities: (1) eating more than necessary or collecting more funds than required; (2) overendeavoring for mundane things that are very difficult to obtain; (3) talking unnecessarily about mundane subject matters; (4) practicing the scriptural rules and regulations only for the sake of following them and not for the sake of spiritual advancement, or rejecting the rules and regulations of the scriptures and working independently or whimsically; (5) associating with worldly-minded persons who are not interested in Kåñëa consciousness; and (6) being greedy for mundane achievements.

PURPORT

Human life is meant for plain living and high thinking. Since all conditioned living beings are under the control of the Lord's third energy, this material world is designed so that one is obliged to work. The Supreme Personality of Godhead has three primary energies, or potencies. The first is called antaraìga-çakti, or the internal potency. The second is called taöastha-çakti, or the marginal potency. The third is called bahiraìga-çakti, or the external potency. The living entities constitute the marginal potency, and they are situated between the internal and external potencies. Being subordinate as eternal servants of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the jévätmäs, or atomic living entities, must remain under the control of either the internal or external potency. When they are under the control of the internal potency, they display their natural, constitutional activity—namely, constant engagement in the devotional service of the Lord. This is stated in Bhagavad-gétä (9.13):

mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha
daivéà prakåtim äçritäù
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jïätvä bhütädim avyayam

"O son of Påthä, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible."

The word mahätmä refers to those who are broad-minded, not cripple-minded. Cripple-minded persons, always engaged in satisfying their senses, sometimes expand their activities in order to do good for others through some "ism" like nationalism, humanitarianism or altruism. They may reject personal sense gratification for the sense gratification of others, like the members of their family, community or society—either national or international. Actually all this is extended sense gratification, from personal to communal to social. This may all be very good from the material point of view, but such activities have no spiritual value. The basis of such activity is sense gratification, either personal or extended. Only when a person gratifies the senses of the Supreme Lord can he be called a mahätmä, or broad-minded person.

In the above-quoted verse from Bhagavad-gétä, the words daivéà prakåtim refer to the control of the internal potency, or pleasure potency, of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This pleasure potency is manifested as Çrématé Rädhäräëé, or Her expansion Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune. When the individual jéva souls are under the control of the internal energy, their only engagement is the satisfaction of Kåñëa, or Viñëu. This is the position of a mahätmä. If one is not a mahätmä, he is a durätmä, or a cripple-minded person. Such mentally crippled durätmäs are put under the control of the Lord's external potency, mahämäyä.

Indeed, all living entities within this material world are under the control of mahämäyä, whose business is to subject them to the influence of threefold miseries: ädhidaivika-kleça (sufferings caused by the demigods, such as droughts, earthquakes and storms), ädhibhautika-kleça (sufferings caused by other living entities like insects or enemies), and ädhyätmika-kleça (sufferings caused by one's own body and mind, such as mental and physical infirmities). Daiva-bhütätma-hetavaù: the conditioned souls, subjected to these three miseries by the control of the external energy, suffer various difficulties.

The main problem confronting the conditioned souls is the repetition of birth, old age, disease and death. In the material world one has to work for the maintenance of the body and soul, but how can one perform such work in a way that is favorable for the execution of Kåñëa consciousness?

Everyone requires possessions such as food grains, clothing, money and other things necessary for the maintenance of the body, but one should not collect more than necessary for his actual basic needs. If this natural principle is followed, there will be no difficulty in maintaining the body.

According to nature's arrangement, living entities lower on the evolutionary scale do not eat or collect more than necessary. Consequently in the animal kingdom there is generally no economic problem or scarcity of necessities. If a bag of rice is placed in a public place, birds will come to eat a few grains and go away. A human being, however, will take away the whole bag. He will eat all his stomach can hold and then try to keep the rest in storage. According to scriptures, this collecting of more than necessary (atyähära) is prohibited. Now the entire world is suffering because of it.

Collecting and eating more than necessary also causes prayäsa, or unnecessary endeavor. By God's arrangement, anyone in any part of the world can live very peacefully if he has some land and a milk cow. There is no need for man to move from one place to another to earn a livelihood, for one can produce food grains locally and get milk from cows. That can solve all economic problems. Fortunately, man has been given higher intelligence for the cultivation of Kåñëa consciousness, or the understanding of God, one's relationship with Him, and the ultimate goal of life, love of God. Unfortunately, so-called civilized man, not caring for God realization, utilizes his intelligence to get more than necessary and simply eat to satisfy the tongue.

By God's arrangement there is sufficient scope for the production of milk and grains for human beings all over the world, but instead of using their higher intelligence to cultivate God consciousness, so-called intelligent men misuse their intelligence to produce many unnecessary and unwanted things. Thus factories, slaughterhouses, brothels and liquor shops are opened. If people are advised not to collect too many goods, eat too much or work unnecessarily to possess artificial amenities, they think they are being advised to return to a primitive way of life. Generally people do not like to accept plain living and high thinking. That is their unfortunate position.

Human life is meant for God realization, and the human being is given higher intelligence for this purpose. Those who believe that this higher intelligence is meant to attain a higher state should follow the instructions of the Vedic literatures. By taking such instructions from higher authorities, one can actually become situated in perfect knowledge and give real meaning to life.

In Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.2.9) Çré Süta Gosvämé describes the proper human dharma in this way:

dharmasya hy äpavargyasya
närtho 'rthäyopakalpate
närthasya dharmaikäntasya
kämo läbhäya hi småtaù

"All occupational engagements [dharma] are certainly meant for ultimate liberation. They should never be performed for material gain. Furthermore, one who is engaged in the ultimate occupational service [dharma] should never use material gain to cultivate sense gratification."

The first step in human civilization consists of occupational engagements performed according to the scriptural injunctions. The higher intelligence of a human being should be trained to understand basic dharma. In human society there are various religious conceptions characterized as Hindu, Christian, Hebrew, Mohammedan, Buddhist and so on, for without religion, human society is no better than animal society.

As stated above (dharmasya hy äpavargyasya närtho 'rthäyopakalpate), religion is meant for attaining emancipation, not for getting bread. Sometimes human society manufactures a system of so-called religion aimed at material advancement, but that is far from the purpose of true dharma. Religion entails understanding the laws of God because the proper execution of these laws ultimately leads one out of material entanglement. That is the true purpose of religion. Unfortunately people accept religion for material prosperity because of atyähära, or an excessive desire for such prosperity. True religion, however, instructs people to be satisfied with the bare necessities of life while cultivating Kåñëa consciousness. Even though we require economic development, true religion allows it only for supplying the bare necessities of material existence. Jévasya tattva jijïäsä: the real purpose of life is to inquire about the Absolute Truth. If our endeavor (prayäsa) is not to inquire about the Absolute Truth, we will simply increase our endeavor to satisfy our artificial needs. A spiritual aspirant should avoid mundane endeavor.

Another impediment is prajalpa, unnecessary talking. When we mix with a few friends, we immediately begin unnecessary talking, sounding just like croaking toads. If we must talk, we should talk about the Kåñëa consciousness movement. Those outside of the Kåñëa consciousness movement are interested in reading heaps of newspapers, magazines and novels, solving crossword puzzles and doing many other nonsensical things. In this fashion people simply waste their valuable time and energy. In the Western countries old men, retired from active life, play cards, fish, watch television and debate about useless socio-political schemes. All these and other frivolous activities are included in the prajalpa category. Intelligent persons interested in Kåñëa consciousness should never take part in such activities.

Jana-saìga refers to associating with persons not interested in Kåñëa consciousness. One should strictly avoid such association. Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkura has therefore advised us to live only in the association of Kåñëa conscious devotees (bhakta-sane väsa). One should always engage in the service of the Lord in the association of the Lord's devotees. Association with those engaged in a similar line of business is very conducive to advancement in that business. Consequently materialistic persons form various associations and clubs to enhance their endeavors. For example, in the business world we find such institutions as the stock exchange and chamber of commerce. Similarly, we have established the International Society for Krishna Consciousness to give people an opportunity to associate with those who have not forgotten Kåñëa. This spiritual association offered by our ISKCON movement is increasing day by day. Many people from different parts of the world are joining this Society to awaken their dormant Kåñëa consciousness.

Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura writes in his Anuvåtti commentary that too much endeavor to acquire knowledge on the part of mental speculators or dry philosophers falls within the category of atyähära (collecting more than needed). According to Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the endeavor of philosophical speculators to write volumes of books on dry philosophy devoid of Kåñëa consciousness is entirely futile. The work of karmés who write volumes of books on economic development also falls within the category of atyähära. Similarly, those who have no desire for Kåñëa consciousness and who are simply interested in possessing more and more material things—either in the shape of scientific knowledge or monetary gain—are all included under the control of atyähära.

Karmés labor to accumulate more and more money for future generations only because they do not know their future position. Interested only in getting more and more money for their sons and grandsons, such foolish persons do not even know what their position is going to be in the next life. There are many incidents that illustrate this point. Once a great karmé accumulated a vast fortune for his sons and grandsons, but later, according to his karma, he took his birth in a cobbler's house located near the building which in his previous life he had constructed for his children. It so happened that when this very cobbler came to his former house, his former sons and grandsons beat him with shoes. Unless the karmés and jïänés become interested in Kåñëa consciousness, they will simply continue to waste their life in fruitless activities.

Accepting some of the scriptural rules and regulations for immediate benefit, as utilitarians advocate, is called niyama-ägraha, and neglecting the rules and regulations of the çästras, which are meant for spiritual development, is called niyama-agraha. The word ägraha means "eagerness to accept," and agraha means "failure to accept." By the addition of either of these two words to the word niyama ("rules and regulations"), the word niyamägraha is formed. Thus niyamägraha has a twofold meaning that is understood according to the particular combination of words. Those interested in Kåñëa consciousness should not be eager to accept rules and regulations for economic advancement, yet they should very faithfully accept scriptural rules and regulations for the advancement of Kåñëa consciousness. They should strictly follow the regulative principles by avoiding illicit sex, meat-eating, gambling and intoxication.

One should also avoid association with Mäyävädés, who simply blaspheme Vaiñëavas (devotees). Bhukti-kämés, who are interested in material happiness, mukti-kämés, who desire liberation by merging in the existence of the formless Absolute (Brahman), and siddhi-kämés, who desire the perfection of mystic yoga practice, are classified as atyähärés. To associate with such persons is not at all desirable.

Desires to expand the mind by perfecting mystic yoga, merging in the existence of Brahman, or attaining whimsical material prosperity are all included within the category of greed (laulya). All attempts to acquire such material benefits or so-called spiritual advancement are impediments on the path of Kåñëa consciousness.

Modern warfare waged between capitalists and communists is due to their avoiding the advice of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé regarding atyähära. Modern capitalists accumulate more wealth than necessary, and the communists, envious of their prosperity, want to nationalize all wealth and property. Unfortunately the communists do not know how to solve the problem of wealth and its distribution. Consequently when the wealth of the capitalists falls into the hands of the communists, no solution results. Opposed to these two philosophies, the Kåñëa conscious ideology states that all wealth belongs to Kåñëa. Thus unless all wealth comes under the administration of Kåñëa, there can be no solution to the economic problem of mankind. Nothing can be solved by placing wealth in the hands of the communists or the capitalists. If a hundred-dollar bill is lying on the street, someone may pick it up and put it in his pocket. Such a man is not honest. Another man may see the money and decide to let it remain there, thinking that he should not touch another's property. Although this second man does not steal the money for his own purposes, he is unaware of its proper use. The third man who sees the hundred-dollar bill may pick it up, find the man who lost it and deliver it to him. This man does not steal the money to spend for himself, nor does he neglect it and let it lie in the street. By taking it and delivering it to the man who has lost it, this man is both honest and wise.

Simply transferring wealth from capitalists to communists cannot solve the problem of modern politics, for it has been demonstrated that when a communist gets money, he uses it for his own sense gratification. The wealth of the world actually belongs to Kåñëa, and every living entity, man and animal, has the birthright to use God's property for his maintenance. When one takes more than his maintenance requires—be he a capitalist or a communist—he is a thief, and as such he is liable to be punished by the laws of nature.

The wealth of the world should be used for the welfare of all living entities, for that is the plan of Mother Nature. Everyone has the right to live by utilizing the wealth of the Lord. When people learn the art of scientifically utilizing the Lord's property, they will no longer encroach upon one another's rights. Then an ideal society can be formed. The basic principle for such a spiritual society is stated in the first mantra of Çré Éçopaniñad:

éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà
yat kiïca jagatyäà jagat
tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä
mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam

"Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and should not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong."

Kåñëa conscious devotees know very well that this material world is designed by the complete arrangement of the Lord to fulfill all the necessities of life for all living beings, without their having to encroach upon the life or rights of one another. This complete arrangement affords the proper quota of wealth for everyone according to his real needs, and thus everyone may live peacefully according to the principle of plain living and high thinking. Unfortunately, materialists who have neither faith in the plan of God nor any aspiration for higher spiritual development misuse their God-given intelligence only to augment their material possessions. They devise many systems—such as capitalism and materialistic communism—to advance their material position. They are not interested in the laws of God or in a higher goal. Always anxious to fulfill their unlimited desires for sense gratification, they are conspicuous by their ability to exploit their fellow living beings.

When human society gives up these elementary faults enumerated by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé (atyähära, etc.), all enmity will cease between men and animals, capitalists and communists, and so forth. In addition, all problems of economic or political maladjustment and instability will be solved. This pure consciousness is awakened by the proper spiritual education and practice offered scientifically by the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

This Kåñëa consciousness movement offers a spiritual community that can bring about a peaceful condition in the world. Every intelligent man should purify his consciousness and rid himself of the above-mentioned six hindrances to devotional service by taking wholehearted shelter of this Kåñëa consciousness movement.

NoI: verse 3

TEXT THREE

ots$aAh"AiªaêyaAÜE"yaARta,
taÔatk(maR‘avataRnaAta,
s$aËÿtyaAgAAts$ataAe va{Ôae:
SaiÑ"BaRi·(: ‘ais$aDyaita

TEXT

utsähän niçcayäd dhairyät

tat-tat-karma-pravartanät

saìga-tyägät sato våtteù

ñaòbhir bhaktiù prasidhyati

utsähät—by enthusiasm; niçcayät—by confidence; dhairyät—by patience; tat-tat-karma—various activities favorable for devotional service; pravartanät—by performing; saìga-tyägät—by giving up the association of nondevotees; sataù—of the great previous äcäryas; våtteù—by following in the footsteps; ñaòbhiù—by these six; bhaktiù—devotional service; prasidhyati—advances or becomes successful.

TRANSLATION

There are six principles favorable to the execution of pure devotional service: (1) being enthusiastic, (2) endeavoring with confidence, (3) being patient, (4) acting according to regulative principles [such as çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù smaraëam—hearing, chanting and remembering Kåñëa], (5) abandoning the association of nondevotees, and (6) following in the footsteps of the previous äcäryas. These six principles undoubtedly assure the complete success of pure devotional service.

PURPORT

Devotional service is not a matter of sentimental speculation or imaginative ecstasy. Its substance is practical activity. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (1.1.11), has defined devotional service as follows:

anyäbhiläñitä-çünyaà
jïäna-karmädy-anävåtam
änukülyena kåñëänu-
çélanaà bhaktir uttamä

"Uttamä bhakti, or unalloyed devotion unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, involves the rendering of devotional service in a way that is favorable to the Lord. This devotional service should be free from any extraneous motive and devoid of fruitive karma, impersonal jïäna and all other selfish desires."

Bhakti is a sort of cultivation. As soon as we say "cultivation," we must refer to activity. Cultivation of spirituality does not mean sitting down idly for meditation, as some pseudo-yogés teach. Such idle meditation may be good for those who have no information of devotional service, and for this reason it is sometimes recommended as a way to check distracting materialistic activities. Meditation means stopping all nonsensical activities, at least for the time being. Devotional service, however, not only puts an end to all nonsensical mundane activities, but also engages one in meaningful devotional activities. Çré Prahläda Mahäräja recommends:

çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù
smaraëaà päda-sevanam
arcanaà vandanaà däsyaà
sakhyam ätma-nivedanam
[Bhäg. 7.5.23]

The nine processes of devotional service are as follows:

1. hearing the name and glories of the Supreme Personality of Godhead
2. chanting His glories
3. remembering the Lord
4. serving the Lord's feet
5. worshiping the Deity
6. offering obeisances unto the Lord
7. acting as the Lord's servant
8. making friends with the Lord
9. surrendering oneself fully to the Lord

Çravaëam, or hearing, is the first step in acquiring transcendental knowledge. One should not give aural reception to unauthorized persons, but should approach the proper person, as recommended in Bhagavad-gétä (4.34):

tad viddhi praëipätena
paripraçnena sevayä
upadekñyanti te jïänaà
jïäninas tattva-darçinaù

"Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you, because he has seen the truth."

It is further recommended in the Muëòaka Upaniñad, tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet: "To understand that transcendental science, one must approach a bona fide spiritual master." Thus this method of submissively receiving transcendental confidential knowledge is not merely based on mental speculation. In this regard, Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu told Rüpa Gosvämé:

brahmäëòa bhramite kona bhägyavän jéva
guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja

"In the course of traversing the universal creation of Brahmä, some fortunate soul may receive the seed of bhakti-latä, the creeper of devotional service. This is all by the grace of guru and Kåñëa." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madhya 19.151) The material world is a place of confinement for the living entities who are by nature änandamaya, pleasure-seeking. They actually want to be free from the confinement of this world of conditional happiness, but not knowing the process of liberation, they are bound to transmigrate from one species of life to another and from one planet to another. In this way the living entities are wandering throughout the material universe. When by good fortune one comes in contact with a pure devotee and hears from him patiently, one begins to follow the path of devotional service. Such an opportunity is offered to a person who is sincere. The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is giving such a chance to humanity at large. If by fortune one takes advantage of this opportunity to engage in devotional service, the path of liberation immediately opens.

One should accept this opportunity to return home, back to Godhead, very enthusiastically. Without enthusiasm, one cannot be successful. Even in the material world one has to be very enthusiastic in his particular field of activity in order to become successful. A student, businessman, artist or anyone else who wants success in his line must be enthusiastic. Similarly, one has to be very enthusiastic in devotional service. Enthusiasm means action, but action for whom? The answer is that one should always act for Kåñëa—kåñëärthäkhila-ceñöä (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu).

In all phases of life one has to perform devotional activities under the direction of the spiritual master in order to attain perfection in bhakti-yoga. It is not that one has to confine or narrow one's activities. Kåñëa is all-pervading. Therefore nothing is independent of Kåñëa, as Kåñëa Himself states in Bhagavad-gétä (9.4):

mayä tatam idaà sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

"By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them." Under the direction of the bona fide spiritual master, one has to make everything favorable for Kåñëa's service. For example, at present we are using a dictaphone. The materialist who invented this machine intended it for businessmen or writers of mundane subject matters. He certainly never thought of using the dictaphone in God's service, but we are using this dictaphone to write Kåñëa conscious literature. Of course, the manufacture of the dictaphone is wholly within the energy of Kåñëa. All the parts of the instrument, including the electronic functions, are made from different combinations and interactions of the five basic types of material energy—namely, bhümi, jala, agni, väyu and äkäça. The inventor used his brain to make this complicated machine, and his brain, as well as the ingredients, were supplied by Kåñëa. According to the statement of Kåñëa, mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni [9.4]: "Everything is depending on My energy." Thus the devotee can understand that since nothing is independent of Kåñëa's energy, everything should be dovetailed in His service.

Endeavor executed with intelligence in Kåñëa consciousness is called utsäha, or enthusiasm. The devotees find the correct means by which everything can be utilized in the service of the Lord (nirbandhaù kåñëa-sambandhe yuktaà vairägyam ucyate). The execution of devotional service is not a matter of idle meditation but practical action in the foreground of spiritual life.

These activities must be executed with patience. One should not be impatient in Kåñëa consciousness. Indeed, this Kåñëa consciousness movement was started single-handedly, and in the beginning there was no response, but because we continued to execute our devotional activities with patience, people gradually began to understand the importance of this movement, and now they are eagerly participating. One should not be impatient in discharging devotional service, but should take instructions from the spiritual master and execute them with patience, depending on the mercy of guru and Kåñëa. The successful execution of Kåñëa conscious activities requires both patience and confidence. A newly married girl naturally expects offspring from her husband, but she cannot expect to have them immediately after marriage. Of course, as soon as she is married she can attempt to get a child, but she must surrender to her husband, confident that her child will develop and be born in due time. Similarly, in devotional service surrender means that one has to become confident. The devotee thinks, avaçya rakñibe kåñëa: "Kåñëa will surely protect me and give me help for the successful execution of devotional service." This is called confidence.

As already explained, one should not be idle but should be very enthusiastic about executing the regulative principles—tat-tat-karma-pravartana. Neglect of the regulative principles will destroy devotional service. In this Kåñëa consciousness movement there are four basic regulative principles, forbidding illicit sex, meat-eating, gambling and intoxication. A devotee must be very enthusiastic about following these principles. If he becomes slack in following any of them, his progress will certainly be checked. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé therefore recommends, tat-tat-karma-pravartanät: "One must strictly follow the regulative principles of vaidhé bhakti." In addition to these four prohibitions (yama), there are positive regulative principles (niyama), such as the daily chanting of sixteen rounds on japa-mälä beads. These regulative activities must be faithfully performed with enthusiasm. This is called tat-tat-karma-pravartana, or varied engagement in devotional service.

Furthermore, in order to be successful in devotional service one must give up the association of undesirable people. This includes karmés, jïänés, yogés and other nondevotees. Once Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu was asked by one of His householder devotees about the general principles of Vaiñëavism, as well as the general routine activities of the Vaiñëava, and Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu immediately replied, asat-saìga-tyäga,—ei vaiñëava-äcära: "Characteristically, a Vaiñëava is one who gives up the association of worldly people, or nondevotees." Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkura has therefore recommended, täìdera caraëa sevi bhakta-sane väsa: one has to live in the company of pure devotees and execute the regulative principles laid down by the previous äcäryas, the six Gosvämés (namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé and Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé). If one lives in the association of devotees, there is little chance of associating with nondevotees. The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is opening many centers just to invite people to live in the company of devotees and practice the regulative principles of spiritual life.

Devotional service means transcendental activities. On the transcendental platform there is no contamination by the three modes of material nature. This is called viçuddha-sattva, the platform of pure goodness, or goodness free from contamination by the qualities of passion and ignorance. In this Kåñëa consciousness movement we require everyone to rise early in the morning, by A.M., and attend maìgala-ärati, or morning worship, then read Çrémad-Bhägavatam, perform kértana, and so forth. Thus we hold continuous activities in devotional service twenty-four hours daily. This is called sato våtti, or following in the footsteps of the previous äcäryas who expertly filled every moment of time with Kåñëa conscious activities.

If one strictly follows the advice given in this verse by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé—namely, being enthusiastic, being confident, being patient, giving up the association of unwanted persons, following the regulative principles and remaining in the association of devotees—one is sure to advance in devotional service. In this regard Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura remarks that the cultivation of knowledge by philosophical speculation, the collection of mundane opulence by the advancement of fruitive activities, and the desire for yoga-siddhis, material perfections, are all contrary to the principles of devotional service. One has to become thoroughly callous to such nonpermanent activities and turn his intention instead to the regulative principles of devotional service. According to Bhagavad-gétä (2.69):

yä niçä sarva-bhütänäà
tasyäà jägarti saàyamé
yasyäà jägrati bhütäni
sä niçä paçyato muneù

"What is night for all beings is the time of awakening for the self-controlled; and the time of awakening for all beings is night for the introspective sage."

Engagement in the devotional service of the Lord is the life and soul of the living entity. It is the desired goal and supreme perfection of human life. One has to become confident about this, and one also has to be confident that all activities other than devotional service—such as mental speculation, fruitive work or mystic endeavor—will never yield any enduring benefit. Complete confidence in the path of devotional service will enable one to attain his desired goal, but attempting to follow other paths will only succeed in making one restless. In the Seventh Canto of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated: "One must be calmly convinced that those who have given up devotional service to engage in severe austerities for other purposes are not purified in their minds, despite their advanced austerities, because they have no information of the transcendental loving service of the Lord."

It is further stated in the Seventh Canto: "Although mental speculators and fruitive actors may perform great austerities and penances, they still fall down because they do not have information about the lotus feet of the Lord." The devotees of the Lord, however, never fall down. In Bhagavad-gétä (9.31), the Supreme Personality of Godhead assures Arjuna, kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati: "O son of Kunté, declare it boldly that My devotee never perishes."

Again in Bhagavad-gétä (2.40) Kåñëa says:

nehäbhikrama-näço 'sti
pratyaväyo na vidyate
svalpam apy asya dharmasya
träyate mahato bhayät

"In this endeavor there is no loss or dimunition, and a little advancement on this path can protect one from the most dangerous type of fear."

Devotional service is so pure and perfect that once having begun, one is forcibly dragged to ultimate success. Sometimes a person will give up his ordinary material engagements and out of sentiment take shelter of the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord and thus begin the preliminary execution of devotional service. Even if such an immature devotee falls down, there is no loss on his part. On the other hand, what is the gain of one who executes the prescribed duties according to his varëa and äçrama but does not take to devotional service? Although a fallen devotee may take his next birth in a low family, his devotional service will nonetheless resume from where it left off. Devotional service is ahaituky apratihatä; it is not the effect of any mundane cause, nor can it be terminated by any mundane cause or permanently curtailed by any material interruption. Therefore a devotee should be confident about his engagement and should not be very interested in the activities of the karmés, jïänés and yogés.

There are certainly many good qualities among fruitive actors, philosophical speculators and mystic yogés, but all good qualities automatically develop in the character of a devotee. No extraneous endeavor is needed. As confirmed by Çrémad-Bhägavatam (5.18.12), all the good qualities of the demigods manifest progressively in one who has developed pure devotional service. Because a devotee is not interested in any material activity, he does not become materially contaminated. He is immediately situated on the platform of transcendental life. However, one who engages in mundane activity—be he a so-called jïäné, yogé, karmé, philanthropist, nationalist, or whatever—cannot attain the higher stage of mahätmä. He remains a durätmä, or cripple-minded person. According to Bhagavad-gétä (9.13):

mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha
daivéà prakåtim äçritäù
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jïätvä bhütädim avyayam

"O son of Påthä, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible."

Since all the devotees of the Lord are under the protection of His supreme potency, they should not deviate from the path of devotional service and take to the path of the karmé, jïäné or yogé. This is called utsähän niçcayäd dhairyät tat-tat-karma-pravartanät, enthusiastically executing the regulative activities of devotional service with patience and confidence. In this way one can advance in devotional service without hindrance.

NoI: verse 4

TEXT FOUR

d"d"Aita ‘aitagA{õ"Aita
gAu÷maAKyaAita pa{cC$ita
BauÈeÿ BaAejayatae caEva
SaiÒ"DaM ‘aIitalaºaNAma,

TEXT

dadäti pratigåhëäti

guhyam äkhyäti påcchati

bhuìkte bhojayate caiva

ñaò-vidhaà préti-lakñaëam

dadäti—gives charity; pratigåhëäti—accepts in return; guhyam—confidential topics; äkhyäti—explains; påcchati—inquires; bhuìkte—eats; bhojayate—feeds; ca—also; eva—certainly; ñaö-vidham—six kinds; préti—of love; lakñaëam—symptoms.

TRANSLATION

Offering gifts in charity, accepting charitable gifts, revealing one's mind in confidence, inquiring confidentially, accepting prasäda and offering prasäda are the six symptoms of love shared by one devotee and another.

PURPORT

In this verse Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé explains how to perform devotional activities in the association of other devotees. There are six kinds of activities: (1) giving charity to the devotees, (2) accepting from the devotees whatever they may offer in return, (3) opening one's mind to the devotees, (4) inquiring from them about the confidential service of the Lord, (5) honoring prasäda, or spiritual food, given by the devotees, and (6) feeding the devotees with prasäda. An experienced devotee explains, and an inexperienced devotee learns from him. This is guhyam äkhyäti påcchati. When a devotee distributes prasäda, remnants of food offered to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, in order to maintain our spirit of devotional service we must accept this prasäda as the Lord's grace received through the pure devotees. We should also invite pure devotees to our home, offer them prasäda and be prepared to please them in all respects. This is called bhuìkte bhojayate caiva.

Even in ordinary social activities, these six types of dealings between two loving friends are absolutely necessary. For instance, when one businessman wishes to contact another businessman he arranges a feast in a hotel, and over the feast openly expresses what he wishes to do. He then inquires from his business friend how he should act, and sometimes presents are exchanged. Thus whenever there is a dealing of préti, or love in intimate dealings, these six activities are executed. In the previous verse, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé advised that one should renounce worldly association and keep company with the devotees (saìga-tyägät sato våtteù). The International Society for Krishna Consciousness has been established to facilitate these six kinds of loving exchanges between devotees. This Society was started single-handedly, but because people are coming forward and dealing with the give-and-take policy, the Society is now expanding all over the world. We are glad that people are donating very liberally to the development of the Society's activities, and people are also eagerly accepting whatever humble contribution we are giving them in the shape of books and magazines dealing strictly with the subject matter of Kåñëa consciousness. We sometimes hold Hare Kåñëa festivals and invite life members and friends to participate in the feasting by accepting prasäda. Although most of our members come from the higher rungs of society, they nonetheless come and take whatever little prasäda we are able to offer them. Sometimes the members and supporters inquire very confidentially about the methods of performing devotional service, and we try to explain this. In this way our Society is successfully spreading all over the world, and the intelligentsia of all countries is gradually appreciating our Kåñëa conscious activities. The life of the Kåñëa conscious society is nourished by these six types of loving exchange among the members; therefore people must be given the chance to associate with the devotees of ISKCON because simply by reciprocating in the six ways mentioned above an ordinary man can fully revive his dormant Kåñëa consciousness. In Bhagavad-gétä (2.62) it is stated, saìgät saïjäyate kämaù: one's desires and ambitions develop according to the company one keeps. It is often said that a man is known by his company, and if an ordinary man associates with devotees, he will certainly develop his dormant Kåñëa consciousness. The understanding of Kåñëa consciousness is innate in every living entity, and it is already developed to some extent when the living entity takes a human body. It is said in Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.107):

nitya-siddha kåñëa-prema 'sädhya' kabhu naya
çravaëädi-çuddha-citte karaye udaya

"Pure love for Kåñëa is eternally established in the hearts of living entities. It is not something to be gained from another source. When the heart is purified by hearing and chanting, the living entity naturally awakens." Since Kåñëa consciousness is inherent in every living entity, everyone should be given a chance to hear about Kåñëa. Simply by hearing and chanting—çravaëaà kértanam—one's heart is directly purified, and one's original Kåñëa consciousness is immediately awakened. Kåñëa consciousness is not artificially imposed upon the heart, it is already there. When one chants the holy name of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the heart is cleansed of all mundane contamination. In the first stanza of His Çré Çikñäñöaka, Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu says:

ceto-darpaëa-märjanaà bhava-mahä-dävägni-nirväpaëaà
çreyaù-kairava-candrikä-vitaraëaà vidyä-vadhü-jévanam
änandämbudhi-vardhanaà prati-padaà pürëämåtäsvädanaà
sarvätma-snapanaà paraà vijayate çré-kåñëa-saìkértanam
[Çikñäñöaka 1]

"All glories to the Çré Kåñëa saìkértana, which cleanses the heart of all the dust accumulated for years and extinguishes the fire of conditional life, of repeated birth and death. This saìkértana movement is the prime benediction for humanity at large because it spreads the rays of the benediction moon. It is the life of all transcendental knowledge. It increases the ocean of transcendental bliss, and it enables us to fully taste the nectar for which we are always anxious."

Not only is the chanter of the mahä-mantra purified, but the heart of anyone who happens to hear the transcendental vibration of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is also cleansed. Even the souls embodied in lower animals, insects, trees and other species of life also become purified and prepared to become fully Kåñëa conscious simply by hearing the transcendental vibration. This was explained by Öhäkura Haridäsa when Caitanya Mahäprabhu inquired from him how living entities lower than human beings can be delivered from material bondage. Haridäsa Öhäkura said that the chanting of the holy names is so powerful that even if one chants in the remotest parts of the jungle, the trees and animals will advance in Kåñëa consciousness simply by hearing the vibration. This was actually proved by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself when He passed through the forest of Jhärikhaëòa. At that time the tigers, snakes, deer and all other animals abandoned their natural animosity and began chanting and dancing in saìkértana. Of course, we cannot imitate the activities of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, but we should follow in His footsteps. We are not powerful enough to enchant the lower animals such as tigers, snakes, cats and dogs or entice them to dance, but by chanting the holy names of the Lord we can actually convert many people throughout the world to Kåñëa consciousness. Contributing or distributing the holy name of the Lord is a sublime example of contributing or giving charity (the dadäti principle). By the same token, one must also follow the pratigåhëäti principle and be willing and ready to receive the transcendental gift. One should inquire about the Kåñëa consciousness movement and open his mind in order to understand the situation of this material world. Thus the guhyam äkhyäti påcchati principles can be served.

The members of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness invite the Society's members and supporters to dine with them when they hold love feasts in all their branches every Sunday. Many interested people come to honor prasäda, and whenever possible they invite members of the Society to their homes and feed them sumptuously with prasäda. In this way both the members of the Society and the general public are benefited. People should give up the company of so-called yogés, jïänés, karmés and philanthropists because their association can benefit no one. If one really wants to attain the goal of human life, he should associate with devotees of the Kåñëa consciousness movement because it is the only movement that teaches one how to develop love of God. Religion is the special function of human society, and it constitutes the distinction between human society and animal society. Animal society has no church, mosque or religious system. In all parts of the world, however downtrodden human society may be, there is some system of religion. Even tribal aborigines in the jungles also have a system of religion. When a religious system develops and turns into love of God, it is successful. As stated in the First Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.2.6):

sa vai puàsäà paro dharmo
yato bhaktir adhokñaje
ahaituky apratihatä
yayätmä suprasédati

"The supreme occupation [dharma] for all humanity is that by which men can attain to loving devotional service unto the transcendent Lord. Such devotional service must be unmotivated and uninterrupted in order to completely satisfy the self."

If the members of human society actually want peace of mind, tranquility and friendly relations between men and nations, they must follow the Kåñëa conscious system of religion, by which they can develop their dormant love for Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As soon as people do so, their minds will immediately be filled with peace and tranquility.

In this regard, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura warns all devotees engaged in broadcasting the Kåñëa consciousness movement not to speak to the impersonalist Mäyävädés who are always determined to oppose such theistic movements. The world is full of Mäyävädés and atheists, and the political parties of the world take advantage of Mäyäväda and other atheistic philosophies to promote materialism. Sometimes they even back a strong party to oppose the Kåñëa consciousness movement. The Mäyävädés and other atheists do not want the Kåñëa consciousness movement to develop because it educates people in God consciousness. Such is the policy of the atheists. There is no benefit in feeding a snake milk and bananas because the snake will never be satisfied. On the contrary, by taking milk and bananas the snake simply becomes more poisonous (kevalaà viña-vardhanam). If a snake is given milk to drink, its poison simply increases. For a similar reason, we should not disclose our minds to the serpent Mäyävädés and karmés. Such disclosures will never help. It is best to avoid association with them completely and never ask them about anything confidential because they cannot give good advice. Nor should we extend invitations to Mäyävädés and atheists nor accept their invitations, for by such intimate intermingling we may become affected by their atheistic mentality (saìgät saïjäyate kämaù). It is the negative injunction of this verse that we should refrain from giving anything to or accepting anything from the Mäyävädés and atheists. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has also warned, viñayéra anna khäile duñöa haya mana: "By eating food prepared by worldly people, one's mind becomes wicked." Unless one is very advanced, he is unable to utilize everyone's contribution to further the Kåñëa consciousness movement; therefore on principle one should not accept charity from the Mäyävädés or atheists. Indeed, Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has forbidden devotees to associate even with ordinary men who are too addicted to material sense gratification.

The conclusion is that we should always keep company with devotees, observe the regulative devotional principles, follow in the footsteps of the äcäryas and in full obedience carry out the orders of the spiritual master. In this way we shall be able to develop our devotional service and dormant Kåñëa consciousness. The devotee who is neither a neophyte nor a mahä-bhägavata (a greatly advanced devotee) but is within the middle status of devotional service is expected to love the Supreme Personality of Godhead, make friends with the devotees, show favor to the ignorant and reject the jealous and demoniac. In this verse there is brief mention of the process of making loving transactions with the Supreme Personality of Godhead and making friends with the devotees. According to the dadäti principle, an advanced devotee is supposed to spend at least fifty percent of his income on the service of the Lord and His devotees. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has set such an example in his life. When he decided to retire, he distributed fifty percent of his life's earnings to Kåñëa's service and twenty-five percent to his relatives and kept twenty-five percent for personal emergencies. This example should be followed by all devotees. Whatever one's income, fifty percent should be spent on behalf of Kåñëa and His devotees, and this will fulfill the demands of dadäti.

In the next verse, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé informs us what kind of Vaiñëava should be selected as a friend and how Vaiñëavas should be served.

NoI: verse 5

TEXT FIVE

k{(SNAeita yasya igAir" taM manas$aAi‰"yaeta
d"IºaAista caet‘aNAitaiBaê BajantamaIzAma,
zAu™aUSayaA BajanaivaÁamananyamanya
inand"Aid"zAUnyaô$d"maIips$atas$aËÿlabDyaA

TEXT

kåñëeti yasya giri taà manasädriyeta

dékñästi cet praëatibhiç ca bhajantam éçam

çuçrüñayä bhajana-vijïam ananyam anya-

nindädi-çünya-hådam épsita-saìga-labdhyä

kåñëa—the holy name of Lord Kåñëa; iti—thus; yasya—of whom; giri—in the words or speech; tam—him; manasä—by the mind; ädriyeta—one must honor; dékñä—initiation; asti—there is; cet—if; praëatibhiù—by obeisances; ca—also; bhajantam—engaged in devotional service; éçam—unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead; çuçrüñayä—by practical service; bhajana-vijïam—one who is advanced in devotional service; ananyam—without deviation; anya-nindä-ädi—of blasphemy of others, etc.; çünya—completely devoid; hådam—whose heart; épsita—desirable; saìga—association; labdhyä—by gaining.

TRANSLATION

One should mentally honor the devotee who chants the holy name of Lord Kåñëa, one should offer humble obeisances to the devotee who has undergone spiritual initiation [dékñä] and is engaged in worshiping the Deity, and one should associate with and faithfully serve that pure devotee who is advanced in undeviated devotional service and whose heart is completely devoid of the propensity to criticize others.

PURPORT

In order to intelligently apply the sixfold loving reciprocations mentioned in the previous verse, one must select proper persons with careful discrimination. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé therefore advises that we should meet with the Vaiñëavas in an appropriate way, according to their particular status. In this verse he tells us how to deal with three types of devotees—the kaniñöha-adhikäré, madhyama-adhikäré and uttama-adhikäré. The kaniñöha-adhikäré is a neophyte who has received the hari-näma initiation from the spiritual master and is trying to chant the holy name of Kåñëa. One should respect such a person within his mind as a kaniñöha-vaiñëava. A madhyama-adhikäré has received spiritual initiation from the spiritual master and has been fully engaged by him in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. The madhyama-adhikäré should be considered to be situated midway in devotional service. The uttama-adhikäré, or highest devotee, is one who is very advanced in devotional service. An uttama-adhikäré is not interested in blaspheming others, his heart is completely clean, and he has attained the realized state of unalloyed Kåñëa consciousness. According to Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, the association and service of such a mahä-bhägavata, or perfect Vaiñëava, are most desirable.

One should not remain a kaniñöha-adhikäré, one who is situated on the lowest platform of devotional service and is interested only in worshiping the Deity in the temple. Such a devotee is described in the Eleventh Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam (11.2.47):

arcäyäm eva haraye
püjäà yaù çraddhayehate
na tad-bhakteñu cänyeñu
sa bhaktaù präkåtaù småtaù

"A person who is very faithfully engaged in the worship of the Deity in the temple, but who does not know how to behave toward devotees or people in general is called a präkåta-bhakta, or kaniñöha-adhikäri."

One therefore has to raise himself from the position of kaniñöha-adhikäré to the platform of madhyama-adhikäré. The madhyama-adhikäré is described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (11.2.46) in this way:

éçvare tad-adhéneñu
bäliçeñu dviñatsu ca
prema-maitré-kåpopekñä
yaù karoti sa madhyamaù

"The madhyama-adhikäré is a devotee who worships the Supreme Personality of Godhead as the highest object of love, makes friends with the Lord's devotees, is merciful to the ignorant and avoids those who are envious by nature."

This is the way to cultivate devotional service properly; therefore in this verse Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has advised us how to treat various devotees. We can see from practical experience that there are different types of Vaiñëavas. The präkåta-sahajiyäs generally chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, yet they are attached to women, money and intoxication. Although such persons may chant the holy name of the Lord, they are not yet properly purified. Such people should be respected within one's mind, but their association should be avoided. Those who are innocent but simply carried away by bad association should be shown favor if they are eager to receive proper instructions from pure devotees, but those neophyte devotees who are actually initiated by the bona fide spiritual master and are seriously engaged in carrying out the orders of the spiritual master should be offered respectful obeisances.

In this Kåñëa consciousness movement a chance is given to everyone without discrimination of caste, creed or color. Everyone is invited to join this movement, sit with us, take prasäda and hear about Kåñëa. When we see that someone is actually interested in Kåñëa consciousness and wants to be initiated, we accept him as a disciple for the chanting of the holy name of the Lord. When a neophyte devotee is actually initiated and engaged in devotional service by the orders of the spiritual master, he should be accepted immediately as a bona fide Vaiñëava, and obeisances should be offered unto him. Out of many such Vaiñëavas, one may be found to be very seriously engaged in the service of the Lord and strictly following all the regulative principles, chanting the prescribed number of rounds on japa beads and always thinking of how to expand the Kåñëa consciousness movement. Such a Vaiñëava should be accepted as an uttama-adhikäré, a highly advanced devotee, and his association should always be sought.

The process by which a devotee becomes attached to Kåñëa is described in Caitanya-caritämåta (Antya 4.192):

dékñä-käle bhakta kare ätma-samarpaëa
sei-käle kåñëa täre kare ätma-sama

"At the time of initiation, when a devotee fully surrenders to the service of the Lord, Kåñëa accepts him to be as good as He Himself."

Dékñä, or spiritual initiation, is explained in the Bhakti-sandarbha (868) by Çréla Jéva Gosvämé:

divyaà jïänaà yato dadyät
kuryät päpasya saìkñayam
tasmäd dékñeti sä proktä
deçikais tattva-kovidaiù

"By dékñä one gradually becomes disinterested in material enjoyment and gradually becomes interested in spiritual life."

We have seen many practical examples of this, especially in Europe and America. Many students who come to us from rich and respectable families quickly lose all interest in material enjoyment and become very eager to enter into spiritual life. Although they come from very wealthy families, many of them accept living conditions that are not very comfortable. Indeed, for Kåñëa's sake they are prepared to accept any living condition as long as they can live in the temple and associate with the Vaiñëavas. When one becomes so disinterested in material enjoyment, he becomes fit for initiation by the spiritual master. For the advancement of spiritual life Çrémad-Bhägavatam (6.1.13) prescribes: tapasä brahmacaryeëa çamena ca damena ca. When a person is serious about accepting dékñä, he must be prepared to practice austerity, celibacy and control of the mind and body. If one is so prepared and is desirous of receiving spiritual enlightenment (divyaà jïänam), he is fit for being initiated. Divyaà jïänam is technically called tad-vijïäna, or knowledge about the Supreme. Tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet: when one is interested in the transcendental subject matter of the Absolute Truth, he should be initiated. Such a person should approach a spiritual master in order to take dékñä. Çrémad-Bhägavatam (11.3.21) also prescribes: tasmäd guruà prapadyeta jijïäsuù çreya uttamam. "When one is actually interested in the transcendental science of the Absolute Truth, he should approach a spiritual master."

One should not accept a spiritual master without following his instructions. Nor should one accept a spiritual master just to make a fashionable show of spiritual life. One must be jijïäsu, very much inquisitive to learn from the bona fide spiritual master. The inquiries one makes should strictly pertain to transcendental science (jijïäsuù çreya uttamam). The word uttamam refers to that which is above material knowledge. Tama means "the darkness of this material world," and ut means "transcendental." Generally people are very interested in inquiring about mundane subject matters, but when one has lost such interest and is simply interested in transcendental subject matters, he is quite fit for being initiated. When one is actually initiated by the bona fide spiritual master and when he seriously engages in the service of the Lord, he should be accepted as a madhyama-adhikäré.

The chanting of the holy names of Kåñëa is so sublime that if one chants the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra offenselessly, carefully avoiding the ten offenses, he can certainly be gradually elevated to the point of understanding that there is no difference between the holy name of the Lord and the Lord Himself. One who has reached such an understanding should be very much respected by neophyte devotees. One should know for certain that without chanting the holy name of the Lord offenselessly, one cannot be a proper candidate for advancement in Kåñëa consciousness. In Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.69) it is said:

yähära komala çraddhä, se 'kaniñöha' jana
krame krame teìho bhakta ha-ibe 'uttama'

"One whose faith is soft and pliable is called a neophyte, but by gradually following the process, he will rise to the platform of a first-class devotee." Everyone begins his devotional life from the neophyte stage, but if one properly finishes chanting the prescribed number of rounds of hari-näma, he is elevated step by step to the highest platform, uttama-adhikäré. The Kåñëa consciousness movement prescribes sixteen rounds daily because people in the Western countries cannot concentrate for long periods while chanting on beads. Therefore the minimum number of rounds is prescribed. However, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura used to say that unless one chants at least sixty-four rounds of japa (one hundred thousand names), he is considered fallen (patita). According to his calculation, practically every one of us is fallen, but because we are trying to serve the Supreme Lord with all seriousness and without duplicity, we can expect the mercy of Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who is famous as patita-pävana, the deliverer of the fallen.

When Çréla Satyaräja Khän, a great devotee of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, asked the Lord how a Vaiñëava could be recognized, the Lord replied:

prabhu kahe,—"yäìra mukhe çuni eka-bära
kåñëa-näma, sei püjya,—çreñöha sabäkära"

"If one hears a person say even once the word 'Kåñëa,' that person should be accepted as the best man out of the common group." (Cc. Madhya 15.106) Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu continued:

"ataeva yäìra mukhe eka kåñëa-näma
sei ta 'vaiñëava, kariha täìhära sammäna"

"One who is interested in chanting the holy name of Kåñëa or who by practice likes to chant Kåñëa's names should be accepted as a Vaiñëava and offered respects as such, at least within one's mind." (Cc. Madhya 15.111) One of our friends, a famous English musician, has become attracted to chanting the holy names of Kåñëa, and even in his records he has several times mentioned the holy name of Kåñëa. At his home he offers respect to pictures of Kåñëa and also to the preachers of Kåñëa consciousness. In all regards, he has a very high estimation for Kåñëa's name and Kåñëa's activities; therefore we offer respects to him without reservation, for we are actually seeing that this gentleman is advancing gradually in Kåñëa consciousness. Such a person should always be shown respect. The conclusion is that anyone who is trying to advance in Kåñëa consciousness by regularly chanting the holy name should always be respected by Vaiñëavas. On the other hand, we have witnessed that some of our contemporaries who are supposed to be great preachers have gradually fallen into the material conception of life because they have failed to chant the holy name of the Lord.

While giving instructions to Sanätana Gosvämé, Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu divided devotional service into three categories.

çästra-yukti nähi jäne dåòha, çraddhävän
'madhyama-adhikäré' sei mahä-bhägyavän

"A person whose conclusive knowledge of the çästras is not very strong but who has developed firm faith in chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra and who is also undeterred in the execution of his prescribed devotional service should be considered a madhyama-adhikäré. Such a person is very fortunate." (Cc. Madhya 22.67) A madhyama-adhikäré is a çraddhävän, a staunchly faithful person, and he is actually a candidate for further advancement in devotional service. Therefore in the Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.64) it is said:

çraddhävän jana haya bhakti-adhikäré
'uttama', 'madhyama', 'kaniñöha'—çraddhä-anusäré

"One becomes qualified as a devotee on the elementary platform, the intermediate platform and the highest platform of devotional service according to the development of his çraddhä [faith]." Again in Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.62) it is said:

'çraddhä'-çabde—viçväsa kahe sudåòha niçcaya
kåñëe bhakti kaile sarva-karma kåta haya

" 'By rendering transcendental service to Kåñëa, one automatically performs all subsidiary activities.' This confident, firm faith, favorable to the discharge of devotional service, is called çraddhä." Çraddhä, faith in Kåñëa, is the beginning of Kåñëa consciousness. Faith means strong faith. The words of Bhagavad-gétä are authoritative instructions for faithful men, and whatever Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä is to be accepted as it is, without interpretation. This was the way Arjuna accepted Bhagavad-gétä. After hearing Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna told Kåñëa: sarvam etad åtaà manye yan mäà vadasi keçava. "O Kåñëa, I totally accept as truth all that You have told me." (Bg. 10.14)

This is the correct way of understanding Bhagavad-gétä, and this is called çraddhä. It is not that one accepts a portion of Bhagavad-gétä according to his own whimsical interpretations and then rejects another portion. This is not çraddhä. Çraddhä means accepting the instructions of Bhagavad-gétä in their totality, especially the last instruction: sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja. "Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me." (Bg. 18.66) When one becomes completely faithful in regard to this instruction, one's strong faith becomes the basis for advancing in spiritual life.

When one fully engages in chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, he gradually realizes his own spiritual identity. Unless one faithfully chants the Hare Kåñëa mantra, Kåñëa does not reveal Himself: sevonmukhe hi jihvädau svayam eva sphuraty adaù. (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.2.234) We cannot realize the Supreme Personality of Godhead by any artificial means. We must engage faithfully in the service of the Lord. Such service begins with the tongue (sevonmukhe hi jihvädau), which means that we should always chant the holy names of the Lord and accept kåñëa-prasäda. We should not chant or accept anything else. When this process is faithfully followed, the Supreme Lord reveals Himself to the devotee.

When a person realizes himself to be an eternal servitor of Kåñëa, he loses interest in everything but Kåñëa's service. Always thinking of Kåñëa, devising means by which to spread the holy name of Kåñëa, he understands that his only business is in spreading the Kåñëa consciousness movement all over the world. Such a person is to be recognized as an uttama-adhikäré, and his association should be immediately accepted according to the six processes (dadäti pratigåhëäti, etc.). Indeed, the advanced uttama-adhikäré Vaiñëava devotee should be accepted as a spiritual master. Everything one possesses should be offered to him, for it is enjoined that one should deliver whatever he has to the spiritual master. The brahmacäré in particular is supposed to beg alms from others and offer them to the spiritual master. However, one should not imitate the behavior of an advanced devotee or mahä-bhägavata without being self-realized, for by such imitation one will eventually become degraded.

In this verse Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé advises the devotee to be intelligent enough to distinguish between the kaniñöha-adhikäré, madhyama-adhikäré and uttama-adhikäré. The devotee should also know his own position and should not try to imitate a devotee situated on a higher platform. Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura has given some practical hints to the effect that an uttama-adhikäré Vaiñëava can be recognized by his ability to convert many fallen souls to Vaiñëavism. One should not become a spiritual master unless he has attained the platform of uttama-adhikäré. A neophyte Vaiñëava or a Vaiñëava situated on the intermediate platform can also accept disciples, but such disciples must be on the same platform, and it should be understood that they cannot advance very well toward the ultimate goal of life under his insufficient guidance. Therefore a disciple should be careful to accept an uttama-adhikäré as a spiritual master.

NoI: verse 6

TEXT SIX

ä{"íE": svaBaAvajainataEvaRpauSaê d"AeSaEr,"
na ‘aAk{(tatvaimah" Ba·( janasya pazyaeta,
gAËÿAmBas$aAM na Kalau bauä,"baud"Pe(napaÆEÿr,"
“aö‰"vatvamapagAcC$ita naIr"DamaE=:

TEXT

dåñöaiù svabhäva-janitair vapuñaç ca doñair

na präkåtatvam iha bhakta janasya paçyet

gaìgämbhasäà na khalu budbuda-phena-paìkair

brahma-dravatvam apagacchati néra-dharmaiù

dåñöaiù—seen by ordinary vision; svabhäva-janitaiù—born of one's own nature; vapuñaù—of the body; ca—and; doñaiù—by the faults; na—not; präkåtatvam—the state of being material; iha—in this world; bhakta-janasya—of a pure devotee; paçyet—one should see; gaìgä-ambhasäm—of the Ganges waters; na—not; khalu—certainly; budbuda-phena-paìkaiù—by bubbles, foam and mud; brahma-dravatvam—the transcendental nature; apagacchati—is spoiled; néra-dharmaiù—the characteristics of water.

TRANSLATION

Being situated in his original Kåñëa conscious position, a pure devotee does not identify with the body. Such a devotee should not be seen from a materialistic point of view. Indeed, one should overlook a devotee's having a body born in a low family, a body with a bad complexion, a deformed body, or a diseased or infirm body. According to ordinary vision, such imperfections may seem prominent in the body of a pure devotee, but despite such seeming defects, the body of a pure devotee cannot be polluted. It is exactly like the waters of the Ganges, which sometimes during the rainy season are full of bubbles, foam and mud. The Ganges waters do not become polluted. Those who are advanced in spiritual understanding will bathe in the Ganges without considering the condition of the water.

PURPORT

Çuddha-bhakti, the activity of the soul proper—in other words, engagement in the transcendental loving service of the Lord—is performed in a liberated condition. In Bhagavad-gétä (14.26) it is stated:

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman."

Avyabhicäriëé bhakti means unalloyed devotion. A person engaged in devotional service must be free from material motives. In this Kåñëa consciousness movement, one's consciousness must be changed. If consciousness is aimed toward material enjoyment, it is material consciousness, and if it is aimed toward serving Kåñëa, it is Kåñëa consciousness. A surrendered soul serves Kåñëa without material considerations (anyäbhiläñitä-çünyam). Jïäna-karmädy-anävåtam: unalloyed devotional service, which is transcendental to the activities of the body and mind, such as jïäna (mental speculation) and karma (fruitive work), is called pure bhakti-yoga. Bhakti-yoga is the proper activity of the soul, and when one actually engages in unalloyed, uncontaminated devotional service, he is already liberated (sa guëän samatétyaitän). Kåñëa's devotee is not subjected to material condition, even though his bodily features may appear materially conditioned. One should therefore not see a pure devotee from a materialistic point of view. Unless one is actually a devotee, he cannot see another devotee perfectly. As explained in the previous verse, there are three types of devotees—kaniñöha-adhikäré, madhyama-adhikäré and uttama-adhikäré. The kaniñöha-adhikäré cannot distinguish between a devotee and nondevotee. He is simply concerned with worshiping the Deity in the temple. A madhyama-adhikäré, however, can distinguish between the devotee and nondevotee, as well as between the devotee and the Lord. Thus he treats the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the devotee and the nondevotee in different ways.

No one should criticize the bodily defects of a pure devotee. If there are such defects, they should be overlooked. What should be taken into account is the spiritual master's main business, which is devotional service, pure service to the Supreme Lord. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (9.30):

api cet suduräcäro
bhajate mäm ananya-bhäk
sädhur eva sa mantavyaù
samyag vyavasito hi saù

Even if a devotee sometimes seems to engage in abominable activities, he should be considered a sädhu, a saintly person, because his actual identity is that of one engaged in the loving service of the Lord. In other words, he is not to be considered an ordinary human being.

Even though a pure devotee may not be born in a brähmaëa or gosvämé family, if he is engaged in the service of the Lord he should not be neglected. In actuality there cannot be a family of gosvämés based on material considerations, caste or heredity. The gosvämé title is actually the monopoly of the pure devotees; thus we speak of the six Gosvämés, headed by Rüpa Gosvämé and Sanätana Gosvämé. Rüpa Gosvämé and Sanätana Gosvämé had practically become Mohammedans and had therefore changed their names to Dabira Khäsa and Säkara Mallika, but Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself made them gosvämés. Therefore the gosvämé title is not hereditary. The word gosvämé refers to one who can control his senses, who is master of the senses. A devotee is not controlled by the senses, but is the controller of the senses. Consequently he should be called svämé or gosvämé, even though he may not be born in a gosvämé family.

According to this formula, the gosvämés who are descendants of Çré Nityänanda Prabhu and Çré Advaita Prabhu are certainly devotees, but devotees coming from other families should not be discriminated against; indeed, whether the devotees come from a family of previous äcäryas or from an ordinary family, they should be treated equally. One should not think, "Oh, here is an American gosvämé," and discriminate against him. Nor should one think, "Here is a nityänanda-vaàça-gosvämé." There is an undercurrent of protest against our awarding the title gosvämé to the American Vaiñëavas of the Kåñëa consciousness movement. Sometimes people flatly tell the American devotees that their sannyäsa or title of gosvämé is not bona fide. However, according to the statements of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé in this verse, an American gosvämé and a gosvämé in a family of äcäryas are nondifferent.

On the other hand, a devotee who has attained the title of gosvämé but is not born of a brähmaëa father or of a gosvämé in the family of Nityänanda or Advaita Prabhu should not be artificially puffed up by thinking that he has become a gosvämé. He should always remember that as soon as he becomes materially puffed up, he immediately falls down. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is a transcendental science, and there is no room for jealousy. This movement is meant for the paramahaàsas who are completely free from all jealousy (paramaà nirmatsaräëäm). One should not be jealous, whether he is born in a family of gosvämés or has the title of gosvämé awarded to him. As soon as anyone becomes envious, he falls from the platform of paramahaàsa.

If we consider the bodily defects of a Vaiñëava, we should understand that we are committing an offense at the lotus feet of the Vaiñëava. An offense at the lotus feet of a Vaiñëava is very serious. Indeed, Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has described this offense as häté-mätä, the mad elephant offense. A mad elephant can create a disaster, especially when it enters into a nicely trimmed garden. One should therefore be very careful not to commit any offense against a Vaiñëava. Every devotee should be ready to take instructions from a superior Vaiñëava, and a superior Vaiñëava must be ready to help an inferior Vaiñëava in all respects. One is superior or inferior according to his spiritual development in Kåñëa consciousness. One is forbidden to observe the activities of a pure Vaiñëava from a material point of view. For the neophyte especially, considering a pure devotee from a material point of view is very injurious. One should therefore avoid observing a pure devotee externally, but should try to see the internal features and understand how he is engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. In this way one can avoid seeing the pure devotee from a material point of view, and thus one can gradually become a purified devotee himself.

Those who think that Kåñëa consciousness is limited to a certain section of people, a certain section of devotees or a certain tract of land are generally prone to see the external features of the devotee. Such neophytes, unable to appreciate the exalted service of the advanced devotee, try to bring the mahä-bhägavata to their platform. We experience such difficulty in propagating this Kåñëa consciousness all over the world. Unfortunately we are surrounded by neophyte Godbrothers who do not appreciate the extraordinary activities of spreading Kåñëa consciousness all over the world. They simply try to bring us to their platform, and they try to criticize us in every respect. We very much regret their naive activities and poor fund of knowledge. An empowered person who is actually engaged in the confidential service of the Lord should not be treated as an ordinary human being, for it is stated that unless one is empowered by Kåñëa, one cannot spread the Kåñëa consciousness movement all over the world.

When one thus criticizes a pure devotee, he commits an offense (vaiñëava-aparädha) that is very obstructive and dangerous for those who desire to advance in Kåñëa consciousness. A person cannot derive any spiritual benefit when he offends the lotus feet of a Vaiñëava. Everyone should therefore be very careful not to be jealous of an empowered Vaiñëava, or a çuddha-vaiñëava. It is also an offense to consider an empowered Vaiñëava an object of disciplinary action. It is offensive to try to give him advice or to correct him. One can distinguish between a neophyte Vaiñëava and an advanced Vaiñëava by their activities. The advanced Vaiñëava is always situated as the spiritual master, and the neophyte is always considered his disciple. The spiritual master must not be subjected to the advice of a disciple, nor should a spiritual master be obliged to take instructions from those who are not his disciples. This is the sum and substance of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé's advice in the sixth verse.

NoI: verse 7

TEXT SEVEN

syaAtk{(SNAnaAmacair"taAid"is$ataApyaivaâA
ipaÔaAepataæar"s$anasya na r"Aeicak(A nau
ik(ntvaAd"r"Ad"nauid"naM Kalau s$aEva jauí"A
svaAã"I ‚(maAà"vaita taÕ"d"maUlah"n‡aI

TEXT

syät kåñëa-näma-caritädi-sitäpy avidyä-

pittopatapta-rasanasya na rocikä nu

kintv ädaräd anudinaà khalu saiva juñöä

svädvé kramäd bhavati tad-gada-müla-hantré

syät—is; kåñëa—of Lord Kåñëa; näma—the holy name; carita-ädi—character, pastimes and so forth; sitä—sugar candy; api—although; avidyä—of ignorance; pitta—by the bile; upatapta—afflicted; rasanasya—of the tongue; na—not; rocikä—palatable; nu—oh, how wonderful it is; kintu—but; ädarät—carefully; anudinam—every day, or twenty-four hours daily; khalu—naturally; sä—that (sugar candy of the holy name); eva—certainly; juñöä—taken or chanted; svädvé—relishable; kramät—gradually; bhavati—becomes; tat-gada—of that disease; müla—of the root; hantré—the destroyer.

TRANSLATION

The holy name, character, pastimes and activities of Kåñëa are all transcendentally sweet like sugar candy. Although the tongue of one afflicted by the jaundice of avidyä [ignorance] cannot taste anything sweet, it is wonderful that simply by carefully chanting these sweet names every day, a natural relish awakens within his tongue, and his disease is gradually destroyed at the root.

PURPORT

The holy name of Lord Kåñëa, His quality, pastimes and so forth are all of the nature of absolute truth, beauty and bliss. Naturally they are very sweet, like sugar candy, which appeals to everyone. Nescience, however, is compared to the disease called jaundice, which is caused by bilious secretions. Attacked by jaundice, the tongue of a diseased person cannot palatably relish sugar candy. Rather, a person with jaundice considers something sweet to taste very bitter. Avidyä (ignorance) similarly perverts the ability to relish the transcendentally palatable name, quality, form and pastimes of Kåñëa. Despite this disease, if one with great care and attention takes to Kåñëa consciousness, chanting the holy name and hearing Kåñëa's transcendental pastimes, his ignorance will be destroyed and his tongue enabled to taste the sweetness of the transcendental nature of Kåñëa and His paraphernalia. Such a recovery of spiritual health is possible only by the regular cultivation of Kåñëa consciousness.

When a man in the material world takes more interest in the materialistic way of life than in Kåñëa consciousness, he is considered to be in a diseased condition. The normal condition is to remain an eternal servant of the Lord (jévera 'svarüpa' haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa'). This healthy condition is lost when the living entity forgets Kåñëa due to being attracted by the external features of Kåñëa's mäyä energy. This world of mäyä is called duräçraya, which means "false or bad shelter." One who puts his faith in duräçraya becomes a candidate for hoping against hope. In the material world everyone is trying to become happy, and although their material attempts are baffled in every way, due to their nescience they cannot understand their mistakes. People try to rectify one mistake by making another mistake. This is the way of the struggle for existence in the material world. If one in this condition is advised to take to Kåñëa consciousness and be happy, he does not accept such instructions.

This Kåñëa consciousness movement is being spread all over the world just to remedy this gross ignorance. People in general are misled by blind leaders. The leaders of human society—the politicians, philosophers and scientists—are blind because they are not Kåñëa conscious. According to Bhagavad-gétä, because they are bereft of all factual knowledge due to their atheistic way of life, they are actually sinful rascals and are the lowest among men.

na mäà duñkåtino müòhäù
prapadyante narädhamäù
mäyayäpahåta jïänä
äsuraà bhävam äçritäù

"Those miscreants who are grossly foolish, lowest among mankind, whose knowledge is stolen by illusion, and who partake of the atheistic nature of demons, do not surrender unto Me." (Bg. 7.15)

Such people never surrender to Kåñëa, and they oppose the endeavor of those who wish to take Kåñëa's shelter. When such atheists become leaders of society, the entire atmosphere is surcharged with nescience. In such a condition, people do not become very enthusiastic to receive this Kåñëa consciousness movement, just as a diseased person suffering from jaundice does not relish the taste of sugar candy. However, one must know that for jaundice, sugar candy is the only specific medicine. Similarly, in the present confused state of humanity, Kåñëa consciousness, the chanting of the holy name of the Lord—Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare—is the only remedy for setting the world aright. Although Kåñëa consciousness may not be very palatable for a diseased person, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé nonetheless advises that if one wants to be cured of the material disease, he must take to it with great care and attention. One begins his treatment by chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra because by chanting this holy name of the Lord a person in the material condition will be relieved from all misconceptions (ceto-darpaëa-märjanam). Avidyä, a misconception about one's spiritual identity, provides the foundation for ahaìkära, or false ego within the heart.

The real disease is in the heart. If the mind is cleansed, however, if consciousness is cleansed, a person cannot be harmed by the material disease. To cleanse the mind and heart from all misconceptions, one should take to this chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. This is both easy and beneficial. By chanting the holy name of the Lord, one is immediately freed from the blazing fire of material existence.

There are three stages in chanting the holy name of the Lord—the offensive stage, the stage of lessening offenses, and the pure stage. When a neophyte takes to the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra, he generally commits many offenses. There are ten basic offenses, and if the devotee avoids these, he can glimpse the next stage, which is situated between offensive chanting and pure chanting. When one attains the pure stage, he is immediately liberated. This is called bhava-mahä-dävägni-nirväpanam. As soon as one is liberated from the blazing fire of material existence, he can relish the taste of transcendental life.

The conclusion is that in order to get freed from the material disease, one must take to the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is especially meant for creating an atmosphere in which people can take to the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra. One must begin with faith, and when this faith is increased by chanting, a person can become a member of the Society. We are sending saìkértana parties all over the world, and they are experiencing that even in the remotest part of the world, where there is no knowledge of Kåñëa, the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra attracts thousands of men to our camp. In some areas, people begin to imitate the devotees by shaving their heads and chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, only a few days after hearing the mantra. This may be imitative, but imitation of a good thing is desired. Some imitators gradually become interested in being initiated by the spiritual master and offer themselves for initiation.

If one is sincere, he is initiated, and this stage is called bhajana-kriyä. One then actually engages in the service of the Lord by regularly chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, sixteen rounds daily, and refraining from illicit sex, intoxicants, meat-eating and gambling. By bhajana-kriyä one attains freedom from the contamination of materialistic life. He no longer goes to a restaurant or hotel to taste so-called palatable dishes made with meat and onions, nor does he care to smoke or drink tea or coffee. He not only refrains from illicit sex, but avoids sex life entirely. Nor is he interested in wasting his time in speculating or gambling. In this way it is to be understood that one is becoming cleansed of unwanted things (anartha-nivåtti). The word anartha refers to unwanted things. Anarthas are vanquished when one becomes attached to the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

When a person is relieved from unwanted things, he becomes fixed in executing his Kåñëa activities. Indeed, he becomes attached to such activities and experiences ecstasy in executing devotional service. This is called bhäva, the preliminary awakening of dormant love of Godhead. Thus the conditioned soul becomes free from material existence and loses interest in the bodily conception of life, including material opulence, material knowledge and material attraction of all variety. At such a time one can understand who the Supreme Personality of Godhead is and what His mäyä is.

Although mäyä may be present, it cannot disturb a devotee once he attains the bhäva stage. This is because the devotee can see the real position of mäyä. Mäyä means forgetfulness of Kåñëa, and forgetfulness of Kåñëa and Kåñëa consciousness stand side by side like light and shadow. If one remains in shadow, he cannot enjoy the facilities offered by light, and if one remains in light, he cannot be disturbed by the darkness of shadow. By taking to Kåñëa consciousness, one gradually becomes liberated and remains in light. Indeed, he does not even touch the darkness. As confirmed in Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.31):

kåñëa—sürya-sama, mäyä haya andhakära
yähäì kåñëa, tähäì nähi mäyära adhikära

"Kåñëa is compared to sunshine, and mäyä is compared to darkness. Wherever there is sunshine, there cannot be darkness. As soon as one takes to Kåñëa consciousness, the darkness of illusion, the influence of the external energy, will immediately vanish."

NoI: verse 8

TEXT EIGHT

taªaAmaè&pacair"taAid"s$auk(LtaRnaAnau
sma{tyaAe: ‚(maeNA r"s$anaAmanas$aI inayaAejya
itaï"na, ˜ajae tad"naur"AigA janaAnaugAAmaI
k(AlaM nayaed"iKalaimatyaupade"zAs$aAr"ma,

TEXT

tan-näma-rüpa-caritädi-sukértanänu-

småtyoù krameëa rasanä-manasé niyojya

tiñöhan vraje tad-anurägi-janänugämé

kälaà nayed akhilam ity upadeça-säram

tat—of Lord Kåñëa; näma—the holy name; rüpa—form; carita-ädi—character, pastimes and so on; su-kértana—in discussing or chanting nicely; anusmåtyoù—and in remembering; krameëa—gradually; rasanä—the tongue; manasé—and the mind; niyojya—engaging; tiñöhan—residing; vraje—in Vraja; tat—to Lord Kåñëa; anurägi—attached; jana—persons; anugämé—following; kälam—time; nayet—should utilize; akhilam—full; iti—thus; upadeça—of advice or instruction; säram—the essence.

TRANSLATION

The essence of all advice is that one should utilize one's full time—twenty-four hours a day—in nicely chanting and remembering the Lord's divine name, transcendental form, qualities and eternal pastimes, thereby gradually engaging one's tongue and mind. In this way one should reside in Vraja [Goloka Våndävana-dhäma] and serve Kåñëa under the guidance of devotees. One should follow in the footsteps of the Lord's beloved devotees, who are deeply attached to His devotional service.

PURPORT

Since the mind may be one's enemy or one's friend, one has to train the mind to become his friend. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is especially meant for training the mind to be always engaged in Kåñëa's business. The mind contains hundreds and thousands of impressions, not only of this life but also of many, many lives of the past. These impressions sometimes come in contact with one another and produce contradictory pictures. In this way the mind's function can become dangerous for a conditioned soul. Students of psychology are aware of the mind's various psychological changes. In Bhagavad-gétä (8.6) it is said:

yaà yaà väpi smaran bhävaà
tyajaty ante kalevaram
taà taà evaiti kaunteya
sadä tad-bhäva-bhävitaù

"Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits his body, that state he will attain without fail."

At the time of death, the mind and intelligence of a living entity create the subtle form of a certain type of body for the next life. If the mind suddenly thinks of something not very congenial, one has to take a corresponding birth in the next life. On the other hand, if one can think of Kåñëa at the time of death, he can be transferred to the spiritual world, Goloka Våndävana. This process of transmigration is very subtle; therefore Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé advises devotees to train their minds in order that they will be unable to remember anything other than Kåñëa. Similarly, the tongue should be trained to speak only of Kåñëa and to taste only kåñëa-prasäda. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé further advises, tiñöhan vraje: one should live in Våndävana or any part of Vrajabhümi. Vrajabhümi, or the land of Våndävana, is supposed to be eighty-four kroças in area. One kroça equals two square miles. When one makes Våndävana his residence, he should take shelter of an advanced devotee there. In this way one should always think of Kåñëa and His pastimes. This is further elucidated by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (1.2.294):

kåñëaà smaran janaà cäsya
preñöhaà nija-saméhitam
tat-tat-kathä-rataç cäsau
kuryäd väsaà vraje sadä

"A devotee should always reside in the transcendental realm of Vraja and always engage in kåñëaà smaran janaà cäsya preñöham, the remembrance of Çré Kåñëa and His beloved associates. By following in the footsteps of such associates and by entering under their eternal guidance, one can acquire an intense desire to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead."

Again Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé states in Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (1.2.295):

sevä sädhaka-rüpeëa
siddha-rüpeëa cätra hi
tad-bhäva-lipsunä käryä
vraja-lokänusärataù

"In the transcendental realm of Vraja [Vraja-dhäma] one should serve the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa, with a feeling similar to that of His associates, and one should place himself under the direct guidance of a particular associate of Kåñëa and should follow in his footsteps. This method is applicable both in the stage of sädhana [spiritual practices executed while in the stage of bondage] and in the stage of sädhya [God realization], when one is a siddha-puruña, or a spiritually perfect soul."

Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura has commented as follows upon this verse: "One who has not yet developed interest in Kåñëa consciousness should give up all material motives and train his mind by following the progressive regulative principles, namely chanting and remembering Kåñëa and His name, form, quality, pastimes and so forth. In this way, after developing a taste for such things, one should try to live in Våndävana and pass his time constantly remembering Kåñëa's name, fame, pastimes and qualities under the direction and protection of an expert devotee. This is the sum and substance of all instruction regarding the cultivation of devotional serivce.

"In the neophyte stage one should always engage in hearing kåñëa-kathä. This is called çravaëa-daçä, the stage of hearing. By constantly hearing the transcendental holy name of Kåñëa and hearing of His transcendental form, qualities and pastimes, one can attain to the stage of acceptance called varaëa-daçä. When one attains this stage, he becomes attached to the hearing of kåñëa-kathä. When one is able to chant in ecstasy, he attains the stage of smaraëävasthä, the stage of remembering. Recollection, absorption, meditation, constant remembrance and trance are the five items of progressive kåñëa-smaraëa. At first, remembrance of Kåñëa may be interrupted at intervals, but later remembrance proceeds uninterrupted. When remembrance is uninterrupted, it becomes concentrated and is called meditation. When meditation expands and becomes constant, it is called anusmåti. By uninterrupted and unceasing anusmåti one enters the stage of samädhi, or spiritual trance. After smaraëa-daçä or samädhi has fully developed, the soul comes to understand his original constitutional position. At that time he can perfectly and clearly understand his eternal relationship with Kåñëa. That is called sampatti-daçä, the perfection of life.

"Caitanya-caritämåta advises those who are neophytes to give up all kinds of motivated desires and simply engage in the regulative devotional service of the Lord according to the directions of scripture. In this way a neophyte can gradually develop attachment for Kåñëa's name, fame, form, qualities and so forth. When one has developed such attachment, he can spontaneously serve the lotus feet of Kåñëa even without following the regulative principles. This stage is called räga-bhakti, or devotional service in spontaneous love. At that stage the devotee can follow in the footsteps of one of the eternal associates of Kåñëa in Våndävana. This is called rägänuga-bhakti. Rägänuga-bhakti, or spontaneous devotional service, can be executed in the çänta-rasa when one aspires to be like Kåñëa's cows or the stick or flute in the hand of Kåñëa, or the flowers around Kåñëa's neck. In the däsya-rasa one follows in the footsteps of servants like Citraka, Patraka or Raktaka. In the friendly sakhya-rasa one can become a friend like Baladeva, Çrédämä or Sudämä. In the vätsalya-rasa, characterized by parental affection, one can become like Nanda Mahäräja and Yaçodä, and in the mädhurya-rasa, characterized by conjugal love, one can become like Çrématé Rädhäräëé or Her lady friends such as Lalitä and Her serving maids (maïjarés) like Rüpa and Rati. This is the essence of all instruction in the matter of devotional service."

NoI: verse 9

TEXT NINE

vaEku(NQ&AÀainataAe var"A maDaupaur"I ta‡aAipa r"As$aAets$avaAä,"
va{nd"Ar"Nyamaud"Ar"paAiNAr"maNAAÔa‡aAipa gAAevaDaRna:
r"ADaAku(Nx"imah"Aipa gAAeku(lapatae: ‘aemaAma{taAplaAvanaAta,
ku(yaARd"sya ivar"AjataAe igAir"taqe% s$aevaAM ivavaek(L na k(:

TEXT

vaikuëöhäj janito varä madhu-puré taträpi räsotsaväd

våndäraëyam udära-päëi-ramaëät taträpi govardhanaù

rädhä-kuëòam ihäpi gokula-pateù premämåtäplävanät

kuryäd asya viräjato giri-taöe seväà viveké na kaù

vaikuëöhät—than Vaikuëöha, the spiritual world; janitaù—because of birth; varä—better; madhu-puré—the transcendental city known as Mathurä; tatra api—superior to that; räsa-utsavät—because of the performance of the räsa-lélä; våndä-araëyam—the forest of Våndävana; udära-päëi—of Lord Kåñëa; ramaëät—because of various kinds of loving pastimes; tatra api—superior to that; govardhanaù—Govardhana Hill; rädhä-kuëòam—the place known as Rädhä-kuëòa; iha api—superior to this; gokula-pateù—of Kåñëa, the master of Gokula; prema-amåta—with the nectar of divine love; äplävanät—because of being overflooded; kuryät—would do; asya—of this (Rädhä-kuëòa); viräjataù—situated; giri-taöe—at the foot of Govardhana Hill; seväm—service; viveké—who is intelligent; na—not; kaù—who.

TRANSLATION

The holy place known as Mathurä is spiritually superior to Vaikuëöha, the transcendental world, because the Lord appeared there. Superior to Mathurä-puré is the transcendental forest of Våndävana because of Kåñëa's räsa-lélä pastimes. And superior to the forest of Våndävana is Govardhana Hill, for it was raised by the divine hand of Çré Kåñëa and was the site of His various loving pastimes. And, above all, the superexcellent Çré Rädhä-kuëòa stands supreme, for it is overflooded with the ambrosial nectarean prema of the Lord of Gokula, Çré Kåñëa. Where, then, is that intelligent person who is unwilling to serve this divine Rädhä-kuëòa, which is situated at the foot of Govardhana Hill?

PURPORT

The spiritual world is three fourths of the total creation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and it is the most exalted region. The spiritual world is naturally superior to the material world; however, Mathurä and the adjoining areas, although appearing in the material world, are considered superior to the spiritual world because the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself appeared at Mathurä. The interior forests of Våndävana are considered superior to Mathurä because of the presence of the twelve forests (dvädaça-vana), such as Tälavana, Madhuvana and Bahulävana, which are famous for the various pastimes of the Lord. Thus the interior Våndävana forest is considered superior to Mathurä, but superior to these forests is the divine Govardhana Hill because Kåñëa lifted Govardhana Hill like an umbrella, raising it with His lotuslike beautiful hand to protect His associates, the denizens of Vraja, from the torrential rains sent by the angry Indra, King of the demigods. It is also at Govardhana Hill that Kåñëa tends the cows with His cowherd friends, and there also He had His rendezvous with His most beloved Çré Rädhä and engaged in loving pastimes with Her. Rädhä-kuëòa, at the foot of Govardhana, is superior to all because it is there that love of Kåñëa overflows. Advanced devotees prefer to reside at Rädhä-kuëòa because this place is the site of many memories of the eternal loving affairs between Kåñëa and Rädhäräëé (rati-viläsa).

In Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya-lélä) it is stated that when Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu first visited the area of Vrajabhümi, He could not at first find the location of Rädhä-kuëòa. This means that Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu was actually searching for the exact location of Rädhä-kuëòa. Finally He found the holy spot, and there was a small pond there. He took His bath in that small pond and told His devotees that the actual Rädhä-kuëòa was situated there. Later the pond was excavated by Lord Caitanya's devotees, headed first by the six Gosvämés, such as Rüpa and Raghunätha däsa. Presently there is a large lake known as Rädhä-kuëòa there. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has given much stress to Rädhä-kuëòa because of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu's desire to find it. Who, then, would give up Rädhä-kuëòa and try to reside elsewhere? No person with transcendental intelligence would do so. The importance of Rädhä-kuëòa, however, cannot be realized by other Vaiñëava sampradäyas, nor can persons uninterested in the devotional service of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu understand the spiritual importance and divine nature of Rädhä-kuëòa. Thus Rädhä-kuëòa is mainly worshiped by the Gauòéya Vaiñëavas, the followers of Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya Mahäprabhu.

NoI: verse 10

TEXT TEN

k(imaRBya: pair"taAe h"re": i‘ayatayaA vyai·M( yayauÁaARinanas$a,
taeByaAe ÁaAnaivamau·(Bai·(par"maA: ‘aemaEk(inaï"Astata:
taeByastaA: pazAupaAlapaÆÿjaä{"zAstaAByaAe'ipa s$aA r"AiDak(A
‘aeï"A taã"id"yaM tad"Iyas$ar"s$aI taAM naA™ayaetk(: k{(taI

TEXT

karmibhyaù parito hareù priyatayä vyaktià yayur jïäninas

tebhyo jïäna-vimukta-bhakti-paramäù premaika-niñöhäs tataù

tebhyas täù paçu-päla-paìkaja-dåças täbhyo 'pi sä rädhikä

preñöhä tadvad iyaà tadéya-sarasé täà näçrayet kaù kåté

karmibhyaù—than all fruitive workers; paritaù—in all respects; hareù—by the Supreme Personality of Godhead; priyatayä—because of being favored; vyaktim yayuù—it is said in the çästra; jïäninaù—those advanced in knowledge; tebhyaù—superior to them; jïäna-vimukta—liberated by knowledge; bhakti-paramäù—those engaged in devotional service; prema-eka-niñöhäù—those who have attained pure love of God; tataù—superior to them; tebhyaù—better than them; täù—they; paçu-päla-paìkaja-dåçaù—the gopés who are always dependent on Kåñëa, the cowherd boy; täbhyaù—above all of them; api—certainly; sä—She; rädhikä—Çrématé Rädhikä; preñöhä—very dear; tadvat—similarly; iyam—this; tadéya-sarasé—Her lake, Çré Rädhä-kuëòa; täm—Rädhä-kuëòa; na—not; äçrayet—would take shelter of; kaù—who; kåté—most fortunate.

TRANSLATION

In the çästra it is said that of all types of fruitive workers, he who is advanced in knowledge of the higher values of life is favored by the Supreme Lord Hari. Out of many such people who are advanced in knowledge [jïänés], one who is practically liberated by virtue of his knowledge may take to devotional service. He is superior to the others. However, one who has actually attained prema, pure love of Kåñëa, is superior to him. The gopés are exalted above all the advanced devotees because they are always totally dependent upon Çré Kåñëa, the transcendental cowherd boy. Among the gopés, Çrématé Rädhäräëé is the most dear to Kåñëa. Her kuëòa [lake] is as profoundly dear to Lord Kåñëa as this most beloved of the gopés. Who, then, will not reside at Rädhä-kuëòa and, in a spiritual body surcharged with ecstatic devotional feelings [apräkåtabhäva], render loving service to the divine couple Çré Çré Rädhä-Govinda, who perform Their añöakäléya-lélä, Their eternal eightfold daily pastimes. Indeed, those who execute devotional service on the banks of Rädhä-kuëòa are the most fortunate people in the universe.

PURPORT

At the present moment almost everyone is engaged in some kind of fruitive activity. Those who are desirous of gaining material profits by working are called karmés, or fruitive workers. All living entities within this material world have come under the spell of mäyä. This is described in the Viñëu Puräëa (6.7.61):

viñëu-çaktiù parä proktä
kñetrajïäkhyä tathä parä
avidyä-karma-saàjïänyä
tåtéyä çaktir iñyate

Sages have divided the energies of the Supreme Personality of Godhead into three categories—namely, the spiritual energy, marginal energy and material energy. The material energy is considered to be the third-class energy (tåtéyä çaktiù). Those living beings within the jurisdiction of the material energy sometimes engage themselves like dogs and hogs in working very hard simply for sense gratification. However, in this life, or, after executing pious activities, in the next life, some karmés become strongly attracted to performing various kinds of sacrifices mentioned in the Vedas. Thus on the strength of their pious merit, they are elevated to heavenly planets. Actually those who perform sacrifices strictly according to Vedic injunctions are elevated to the moon and planets above the moon. As mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä (9.21), kñéëe puëye martya-lokaà viçanti: after exhausting the results of their so-called pious activities, they again return to the earth, which is called martya-loka, the place of death. Although such persons may be elevated to the heavenly planets by their pious activities and although they may enjoy life there for many thousands of years, they nonetheless must return to this planet when the results of their pious activities are exhausted.

This is the position of all karmés, including those who act piously and those who act impiously. On this planet we find many businessmen, politicians and others who are simply interested in material happiness. They attempt to earn money by all means, not considering whether such means are pious or impious. Such people are called karmés, or gross materialists. Among the karmés are some vikarmés, people who act without the guidance of Vedic knowledge. Those who act on the basis of Vedic knowledge perform sacrifices for the satisfaction of Lord Viñëu and to receive benedictions from Him. In this way they are elevated to higher planetary systems. Such karmés are superior to the vikarmés, for they are faithful to the directions of the Vedas and are certainly dear to Kåñëa. In Bhagavad-gétä (4.11), Kåñëa says: ye yathä mäà prapadyante täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham. "In whatever way one surrenders unto Me, I reward him accordingly." Kåñëa is so kind that He fulfilled the desires of the karmés and jïänés, not to speak of the bhaktas. Although the karmés are sometimes elevated to higher planetary systems, as long as they remain attached to fruitive activities they must accept new material bodies after death. If one acts piously, he can attain a new body among the demigods in the higher planetary systems, or he may attain some other position in which he can enjoy a higher standard of material happiness. On the other hand, those who are engaged in impious activities are degraded and take birth as animals, trees and plants. Thus those fruitive actors who do not care for the Vedic directions (vikarmés) are not appreciated by learned saintly persons. As stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (5.5.4):

nünaà pramattaù kurute vikarma
yad indriya-prétaya äpåëoti
na sädhu manye yata ätmano 'yam
asann api kleçada äsa dehaù

"Materialists who work hard like dogs and hogs simply for sense gratification are actually mad. They simply perform all kinds of abominable activities simply for sense gratification. Materialistic activities are not at all worthy of an intelligent man, for as a result of such activities, one gets a material body, which is full of misery." The purpose of human life is to get out of the threefold miserable conditions, which are concomitant with material existence. Unfortunately, fruitive workers are mad to earn money and acquire temporary material comforts by all means; therefore they risk being degraded to lower species of life. Materialists foolishly make many plans to become happy in this material world. They do not stop to consider that they will live only for a certain number of years, out of which they must spend the major portion acquiring money for sense gratification. Ultimately such activities end in death. Materialists do not consider that after giving up the body they may become embodied as lower animals, plants or trees. Thus all their activities simply defeat the purpose of life. Not only are they born ignorant, but they act on the platform of ignorance, thinking that they are getting material benefits in the shape of skyscraper buildings, big cars, honorable positions and so on. The materialists do not know that in the next life they will be degraded and that all their activities simply serve as paräbhava, their defeat. This is the verdict of Çrémad-Bhägavatam (5.5.5): paräbhavas tävad abodha-jätaù.

One should therefore be eager to understand the science of the soul (ätma-tattva). Unless one comes to the platform of ätma-tattva, by which one understands that the soul and not the body is oneself, one remains on the platform of ignorance. Out of thousands and even millions of ignorant people who are wasting their time simply gratifying their senses, one may come to the platform of knowledge and understand higher values of life. Such a person is called a jïäné. The jïäné knows that fruitive activities will bind him to material existence and cause him to transmigrate from one kind of body to another. As indicated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam [5.5.5] by the term çaréra-bandha (bound to bodily existence), as long as one maintains any conception of sense enjoyment, his mind will be absorbed in karma, fruitive activity, and this will oblige him to transmigrate from one body to another.

Thus a jïäné is considered superior to a karmé because he at least refrains from the blind activities of sense enjoyment. This is the verdict of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. However, although a jïäné may be liberated from the ignorance of the karmés, unless he comes to the platform of devotional service he is still considered to be in ignorance (avidyä). Although one may be accepted as a jïäné, or one advanced in knowledge, his knowledge is considered impure because he has no information of devotional service and thus neglects the direct worship of the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

When a jïäné takes to devotional service, he rapidly becomes superior to an ordinary jïäné. Such an advanced person is described as jïäna-vimukta-bhakti-parama. How a jïäné takes to devotional service is mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä (7.19), wherein Kåñëa says:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." Actually a person is wise when he surrenders unto the lotus feet of Kåñëa, but such a mahätmä, great soul, is very rare.

After taking to devotional service under the regulative principles, a person may come to the platform of spontaneous love of Godhead, following in the footsteps of great devotees like Närada and Sanaka and Sanätana. The Supreme Personality of Godhead then recognizes him to be superior. The devotees who have developed love of Godhead are certainly in an exalted position.

Of all these devotees, the gopés are recognized as superior because they do not know anything other than satisfying Kåñëa. Nor do the gopés expect any return from Kåñëa. Indeed, sometimes Kåñëa puts them into extreme suffering by separating Himself from them. Nonetheless, they cannot forget Kåñëa. When Kåñëa left Våndävana for Mathurä, the gopés became most dejected and spent the rest of their lives simply crying in separation from Kåñëa. This means that in one sense they were never actually separated from Kåñëa. There is no difference between thinking of Kåñëa and associating with Him. Rather, vipralambha-sevä, thinking of Kåñëa in separation, as Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu did, is far better than serving Kåñëa directly. Thus of all the devotees who have developed unalloyed devotional love for Kåñëa, the gopés are most exalted, and out of all these exalted gopés, Çrématé Rädhäräëé is the highest. No one can excel the devotional service of Çrématé Rädhäräëé. Indeed, even Kåñëa cannot understand the attitude of Çrématé Rädhäräëé; therefore He took Her position and appeared as Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, just to understand Her transcendental feelings.

In this way Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé gradually concludes that Çrématé Rädhäräëé is the most exalted devotee of Kåñëa and that Her kuëòa (lake), Çré Rädhä-kuëòa, is the most exalted place. This is verified in a quotation from Laghu-bhägavatämåta (Uttara-khaëòa 45), as quoted in Caitanya-caritämåta:

yathä rädhä priyä viñëos
tasyäù kuëòaà priyaà tathä
sarva-gopéñu saivaikä
viñëor atyanta-vallabhä

"Just as Çrématé Rädhäräëé is dear to the Supreme Lord Kåñëa [Viñëu], so Her bathing place [Rädhä-kuëòa] is equally dear to Kåñëa. Among all the gopés, She alone stands supreme as the Lord's most beloved."

Therefore everyone interested in Kåñëa consciousness should ultimately take shelter of Rädhä-kuëòa and execute devotional service there throughout one's life. This is the conclusion of Rüpa Gosvämé in the tenth verse of Upadeçämåta.

NoI: verse 11

TEXT ELEVEN

k{(SNAsyaAe»aE: ‘aNAyavas$aita: ‘aeyas$aIByaAe'ipa r"ADaA
ku(NxM" caAsyaA mauinaiBar"iBatastaAä{"gAeva vyaDaAiya
yat‘aeïE"r"pyalamas$aulaBaM ikM( paunaBaRi·(BaAjaAM
tat‘aemaedM" s$ak{(d"ipa s$ar": µaAtaur"AivaSk(r"Aeita

TEXT

kåñëasyoccaiù praëaya-vasatiù preyasébhyo 'pi rädhä

kuëòaà cäsyä munibhir abhitas tädåg eva vyadhäyi

yat preñöhair apy alam asulabhaà kià punar bhakti-bhäjäà

tat premedaà sakåd api saraù snätur äviñkaroti

kåñëasya—of Lord Çré Kåñëa; uccaiù—very highly; praëaya-vasatiù—object of love; preyasébhyaù—out of the many lovable gopés; api—certainly; rädhä—Çrématé Rädhäräëé; kuëòam—lake; ca—also; asyäù—of Her; munibhiù—by great sages; abhitaù—in all respects; tädåk eva—similarly; vyadhäyi—is described; yat—which; preñöhaiù—by the most advanced devotees; api—even; alam—enough; asulabham—difficult to obtain; kim—what; punaù—again; bhakti-bhäjäm—for persons engaged in devotional service; tat—that; prema—love of Godhead; idam—this; sakåt—once; api—even; saraù—lake; snätuù—of one who has bathed; äviñkaroti—arouses.

TRANSLATION

Of the many objects of favored delight and of all the lovable damsels of Vrajabhümi, Çrématé Rädhäräëé is certainly the most treasured object of Kåñëa's love. And, in every respect, Her divine kuëòa is described by great sages as similarly dear to Him. Undoubtedly Rädhä-kuëòa is very rarely attained even by the great devotees; therefore it is even more difficult for ordinary devotees to attain. If one simply bathes once within those holy waters, one's pure love of Kåñëa is fully aroused.

PURPORT

Why is Rädhä-kuëòa so exalted? The lake is so exalted because it belongs to Çrématé Rädhäräëé, who is the most beloved object of Çré Kåñëa. Among all the gopés, She is the most beloved. Similarly, Her lake, Çré Rädhä-kuëòa, is also described by great sages as the lake that is as dear to Kåñëa as Rädhä Herself. Indeed, Kåñëa's love for Rädhä-kuëòa and Çrématé Rädhäräëé is the same in all respects. Rädhä-kuëòa is very rarely attained, even by great personalities fully engaged in devotional service, not to speak of ordinary devotees who are only engaged in the practice of vaidhé bhakti.

It is stated that a devotee will at once develop pure love of Kåñëa in the wake of the gopés if he once takes a bath in Rädhä-kuëòa. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé recommends that even if one cannot live permanently on the banks of Rädhä-kuëòa, he should at least take a bath in the lake as many times as possible. This is a most important item in the execution of devotional service. Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura writes in this connection that Çré Rädhä-kuëòa is the most select place for those interested in advancing their devotional service in the wake of the lady friends (sakhés) and confidential serving maids (maïjarés) of Çrématé Rädhäräëé. Living entities who are eager to return home to the transcendental kingdom of God, Goloka Våndävana, by means of attaining their spiritual bodies (siddha-deha) should live at Rädhä-kuëòa, take shelter of the confidential serving maids of Çré Rädhä and under their direction engage constantly in Her service. This is the most exalted method for those engaged in devotional service under the protection of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. In this connection Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura writes that even great sages and great devotees like Närada and Sanaka do not get an opportunity to come to Rädhä-kuëòa to take their baths. What, then, to speak of ordinary devotees? If, by great fortune, one gets an opportunity to come to Rädhä-kuëòa and bathe even once, he can develop his transcendental love for Kåñëa, exactly as the gopés did. It is also recommended that one should live on the banks of Rädhä-kuëòa and should be absorbed in the loving service of the Lord. One should bathe there regularly and give up all material conceptions, taking shelter of Çré Rädhä and Her assistant gopés. If one is thus constantly engaged during his lifetime, after giving up the body he will return back to Godhead to serve Çré Rädhä in the same way as he contemplated during his life on the banks of Rädhä-kuëòa. The conclusion is that to live on the banks of the Rädhä-kuëòa and to bathe there daily constitute the highest perfection of devotional service. It is a difficult position to attain, even for great sages and devotees like Närada. Thus there is no limit to the glory of Çré Rädhä-kuëòa. By serving Rädhä-kuëòa, one can get an opportunity to become an assistant of Çrématé Rädhäräëé under the eternal guidance of the gopés.

NoI Appendixes

Appendixes

The Author


His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda appeared in this world in 1896 in Calcutta, India. He first met his spiritual master, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé, in Calcutta in 1922. Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, a prominent devotional scholar and the founder of sixty-four Gauòéya Maöhas (Vedic institutes), liked this educated young man and convinced him to dedicate his life to teaching Vedic knowledge. Çréla Prabhupäda became his student, and eleven years later (1933) at Allahabad he became his formally initiated disciple.

At their first meeting, in 1922, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura requested Çréla Prabhupäda to broadcast Vedic knowledge through the English language. In the years that followed, Çréla Prabhupäda wrote a commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä, assisted the Gauòéya Maöha in its work and, in 1944, without assistance, started an English fortnightly magazine, edited it, typed the manuscripts and checked the galley proofs. He even distributed the individual copies freely and struggled to maintain the publication. Once begun, the magazine never stopped; it is now being continued by his disciples in the West.

Recognizing Çréla Prabhupäda's philosophical learning and devotion, the Gauòéya Vaiñëava Society honored him in 1947 with the title "Bhaktivedänta." In 1950, at the age of fifty-four, Çréla Prabhupäda retired from married life, and four years later he adopted the vänaprastha (retired) order to devote more time to his studies and writing. Çréla Prabhupäda traveled to the holy city of Våndävana, where he lived in very humble circumstances in the historic medieval temple of Rädhä-Dämodara. There he engaged for several years in deep study and writing. He accepted the renounced order of life (sannyäsa) in 1959. At Rädhä-Dämodara, Çréla Prabhupäda began work on his life's masterpiece: a multivolume translation and commentary on the eighteen thousand verse Çrémad-Bhägavatam (Bhägavata Puräëa). He also wrote Easy Journey to Other Planets.

After publishing three volumes of Bhägavatam, Çréla Prabhupäda came to the United States, in 1965, to fulfill the mission of his spiritual master. Since that time, His Divine Grace has written over forty volumes of authoritative translations, commentaries and summary studies of the philosophical and religious classics of India.

In 1965, when he first arrived by freighter in New York City, Çréla Prabhupäda was practically penniless. It was after almost a year of great difficulty that he established the International Society for Krishna Consciousness in July of 1966. Under his careful guidance, the Society has grown within a decade to a worldwide confederation of almost one hundred äçramas, schools, temples, institutes and farm communities.

In 1968, Çréla Prabhupäda created New Våndävana, an experimental Vedic community in the hills of West Virginia. Inspired by the success of New Våndävana, now a thriving farm community of more than one thousand acres, his students have since founded several similar communities in the United States and abroad.

In 1972, His Divine Grace introduced the Vedic system of primary and secondary education in the West by founding the Gurukula school in Dallas, Texas. The school began with 3 children in 1972, and by the beginning of 1975 the enrollment had grown to 150.

Çréla Prabhupäda has also inspired the construction of a large international center at Çrédhäma Mäyäpur in West Bengal, India, which is also the site for a planned Institute of Vedic Studies. A similar project is the magnificent Kåñëa-Balaräma Temple and International Guest House in Våndävana, India. These are centers where Westerners can live to gain firsthand experience of Vedic culture.

Çréla Prabhupäda's most significant contribution, however, is his books. Highly respected by the academic community for their authoritativeness, depth and clarity, they are used as standard textbooks in numerous college courses. His writings have been translated into eleven languages. The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, established in 1972 exclusively to publish the works of His Divine Grace, has thus become the world's largest publisher of books in the field of Indian religion and philosophy. Its latest project is the publishing of Çréla Prabhupäda's most recent work: a seventeen-volume translation and commentary—completed by Çréla Prabhupäda in only eighteen months—on the Bengali religious classic Çré Caitanya-caritämåta.

In the past ten years, in spite of his advanced age, Çréla Prabhupäda has circled the globe twelve times on lecture tours that have taken him to six continents. In spite of such a vigorous schedule, Çréla Prabhupäda continues to write prolifically. His writings constitute a veritable library of Vedic philosophy, religion, literature and culture.

Glossary

Easy Journey to other planets (1970)

$1.25

OTHER BOOKS

by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 1-3 (6 Vols.)

Teachings of Lord Chaitanya

The Nectar of Devotion

Sré Éçopaniñad

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System

Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 Vols.)

Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäraj

Transcendental Teachings of Caitanya Mahäprabhu

The Perfection of Yoga

On the Way to Kåñëa

Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge

Beyond Birth and Death

Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness

Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)


Easy Journey to other planets

By Practice of Supreme Yoga

Revised Edition

His Divine Grace A .C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Founder-Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness,

The Macmillan Company, New York, New York

Collier-Macmillan Limited, London


Copyright © 1970, 1972 by ISKCON Press

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the Publisher.

The Macmillan Company 866 Third Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10022 Collier-Macmillan Canada Ltd., Toronto, Ontario

Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 72-80068

First Collier Paperbacks Edition 1972

Printed in the United States of America


Dedicated to THE SCIENTISTS OF THE WORLD

with blessings of

HIS DIVINE GRACE Çré Çrémad Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Mahäräja

my spiritual master


contents

Preface9

1. Anti-material Worlds 11

2. Varieties of Planetary Systems 53

Glossary 91

Index 94

EJ'70:Preface

Preface

A living being, especially civilized man, has a natural desire to live forever in happiness. This is quite natural because, in his original state, the living being is both eternal and joyful. However, in the present conditioned state of life, he is engaged in a struggle against recurring birth and death. Therefore he has attained neither happiness nor immortality.

The latest desire man has developed is the desire to travel to other planets. This is also quite natural, because he has the constitutional right to go to any part of the material or spiritual skies. Such travel is very tempting and exciting because these skies are full of unlimited globes of varying qualities, and they are occupied by all types of living entities. The desire to travel there can be fulfilled by the process of yoga, which serves as a means by which one can transfer himself to whatever planet he likes—possibly to planets where life is not only eternal and blissful, but where there are multiple varieties of enjoyable energies. Anyone who can attain the freedom of the spiritual planets need never return to this miserable land of birth, old age, disease and death.

One can attain this stage of perfection very easily by his individual effort. He can simply.follow, in his own home, the prescribed method of bhakti-yoga. This method, under proper guidance, is simple and enjoyable. An attempt is made herein to give information to the people in general, and to philosophers and religionists in particular, as to how one can transfer oneself to other planets by this process of bhakti-yoga—the highest of all yogic processes.

EJ'70:1 Anti-material Worlds

1 Anti-material Worlds

Materialistic science may one day finally discover the eternal anti-material world which has for so long been unknown to the wranglers of gross materialism. Regarding the scientists’ present conception of antimatter, the Times of India (Oct. 27, 1959) published the following news release:

—Stockholm, Oct. 26, 1959—Two American atomic scientists were awarded the 1959 Nobel Physics Prize today for the discovery of the antiproton, proving that matter exists in two forms -as particles and anti-particles. They are Italian-born Dr. Emilio Segre, 69, and Dr. Owen Chamberlain, born in San Francisco. According to one of the fundamental assumptions of the new theory, there may exist another world, or an anti-world, built up of anti-matter. This anti-material world would consist of atomic and sub-atomic particles spinning in reverse orbits to those of the world we know. If these two worlds should ever clash, they would both be annihilated in one blinding flash.

In this statement, the following propositions are put forward:

1. There is an anti-material atom or particle which is made up of the anti-qualities of material atoms.

2. There is another world besides this material world of which we have only limited experience.

3. The anti-material and material worlds may clash at a certain period and may annihilate one another.

Out of these three items, we, the students of theistic science, can fully agree with items No. 1 and 2, but we can agree with the third item only within the limited scientific definition of anti-matter. The difficulty lies in the fact that the scientists’ conception of anti-matter extends only to another variety of material energy, whereas the real antimatter must be anti-material, or spirit. Matter as it is constituted is subjected to annihilation, but anti- matter—if it is to be free from all material symptoms—must also be free from annihilation, by its very nature. If matter is destructible or separable, antimatter must be indestructible and inseparable. We shall try to discuss these propositions from the angle of authentic scriptural vision.

The most widely recognized scriptures in the world are the Vedas. The Vedas have been divided into four parts: Säma, Yajus, Åk and Atharva. The subject matter of the Vedas is very difficult for a man of ordinary understanding. For elucidation, the four Vedas are explained in the historical epic called the Mahäbhärata and in eighteen Puräëas. The Rämäyaëa is also a historical epic which contains all the necessary information from the Vedas. So the four Vedas, the original Rämäyaëa by Valméki, the Mahäbhärata and the Puräëas are classified as Vedic literatures. The Upaniñad are parts of the four Vedas, and the Vedänta-sütras represent the cream of the Vedas. To summarize all these Vedic literatures, the Bhagavad-gétä is accepted as the essence of all Upaniñads and the preliminary explanation of the Vedänta-sütras. One may then conclude that from the Bhagavad-gétä alone one can have the essence of the Vedas, for it is spoken by Lord Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who descends upon this material world from the anti-material world in order to give complete information of the superior form of energy.

The superior form of energy of the Personality of Godhead is described in the Bhagavad-gétä as parä prakåti. The scientists have recently discovered that there are two forms of perishable matter, but the Gétä describes most perfectly the transcendental concept of matter and anti-matter in terms of two forms of energy. There is an energy which created the material world, and in its superior form, also created the anti-material (transcendental) world. The living entities belong to the category of superior energy. The inferior energy or material energy is called aparä prakåti. In the Gétä the creative energy is thus presented in two forms, namely aparä and parä prakåti.

Matter itself has no creative power. When it is manipulated by the living energy, material things are produced. Matter in its crude form is therefore the latent energy of the Supreme Being. Whenever we think of energy, it is natural that we think of the source of energy. For example, when we think of electrical energy, we simultaneously think of the powerhouse where it is generated. Energy is not selfsufficient. It is under the control of a superior living being. For example, fire is the source of two other energies, namely light and heat. Light and heat have no independent existence outside of fire. Similarly, the inferior and superior energies are derived from a source, which one may call by any name. That source of energy must be a living being with full sense of everything. That supreme living being is the Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, or the all-attractive living being.

In the Vedas the supreme living being, or the absolute truth, is called Bhagavän—the opulent one, the living being who is the fountainhead of all energies. The discovery of the two forms of limited energies by the modern scientists is just the beginning of the progress of science. Now they must go further to discover the source of the two particles or atoms which they term material and anti-material.

How can the anti-material particle be explained? We have experience with material particles or atoms, but we have no experience with anti-material atoms. However, the Bhagavad-gétä gives the following vivid description of the anti-material particle:

This anti-material particle is within the material-body. This material body is progressively changing from childhood to boyhood, from boyhood to youth to old age, after which the anti-material particle leaves the old, unworkable body and takes up another material body. (Bg. 2.13)

This description of a living body confirms the scientific discovery that energy exists in two forms.

When one of them, the anti-material particle, is separated from the material body, the latter becomes useless for all purposes. As such, the anti-material particle is undoubtedly superior to the material energy.

No one, therefore, should lament for the loss of material energy. All varieties of sense perception in the categories of heat and cold, happiness and distress, are but interactions of material energy which come and go like seasonal changes. The temporary appearance and disappearance of such material interactions confirms that the material body is formed of a material energy inferior to the living force, or jéva energy.
(Bg. 2.14)

Any intelligent man who is not disturbed by happiness and distress, understanding that they are different material phases resulting from the interactions of the material energy, is competent to regain the anti-material world where life is eternal, full of permanent knowledge and bliss.
(Bg. 2.15)

The anti-material world is mentioned here, and in addition information is given that in the anti-material world there is no "seasonal" fluctuation. Everything there is permanent, blissful, and full of knowledge. But when we speak of it as a "world," we must remember that it has forms, paraphernalia and categories beyond our material experiences.

The material body is destructible, and as such i it is changeable and temporary. So is the material world. But the anti-material living force is non-destructible, and therefore it is permanent. Expert scientists have thus distinguished the different qualities of the material and antimaterial particles as temporary and permanent respectively.
(Bg. 2.16)

The discoverers of the two forms of matter have yet to find out the qualities of anti-matter. But a vivid description is already given in the Bhagavad-gétä as follows. The scientist can make further re-search on the basis of this valuable information.

The anti-material particle is finer than the finest of material particles. This living force is so powerful that it spreads its influence all over the material body. The anti-material particle has immense potency in comparison to the material particle, and consequently it cannot be destroyed.
(Bg. 2.17)

This is but the beginning of the description of the anti-material particle in the Gétä. It is further explained as follows:

The finest form of the anti-material particle is encaged within the gross and subtle material bodies. Although the material bodies (both gross and subtle) are subject to destruction, the finer anti-material particle is eternal. One’s interest, therefore, should be in this eternal principle.
(Bg. 2.18)

The perfection of science will occur when it is possible for the material scientists to know the qualities of the anti-material particle and liberate it from the association of non-permanent material particles. Such liberation would mark the culmination of scientific progress.

There is partial truth in the scientists’ suggestion that there may exist also another world consisting of anti-material atoms and that a clash between the material and anti-material worlds will result in the annihilation of both. There is a clash which is continually going on: the annihilation of the material particles is taking place at every moment, and the nonmaterial particle is striving for liberation. This is explained in the Gétä as follows:

The nonmaterial particle, which is the living entity, influences the material particle to work. This living entity is always indestructible. As long as the nonmaterial particle. is within the lump of material energy-known by the names of gross and subtle bodies-then the entity is manifest as a living unit. In the continuous clashing between the two particles, the nonmaterial particle is never annihilated. No one can destroy the anti-material particle at any time-past, present, or future.
(Bg. 2.19)

Therefore, we think that the theory maintaining that the material and anti-material worlds may clash, resulting in the annihilation of both worlds, is correct only within the context of the scientists’ limited definition of anti-matter. The Gétä explains the nature of the anti-material particle, which can never be annihilated:

The fine and immeasurable anti-material particle is always indestructible, permanent and eternal. After a certain period, it is liberated from material bondage by annihilation of the material particle. This same principle also operates in the case of the material and anti-material worlds. No one should fear the annihilation of the anti-material particle, for it survives the annihilation of material worlds.
(Bg. 2.21-22)

Everything that is created is annihilated at a certain stage. Both the material body and the material world are created, and they are therefore subject to annihilation. The anti-material particle, however, is never created, and consequently it is never annihilated. This also is corroborated in the Gétä:

The anti-material particle, which is the vital force, is never born or created. It exists eternally. It has neither birth dates nor death dates. It is neither repeatedly created nor repeatedly destroyed. It is eternally existing, and therefore it is the oldest of the old, and yet it is always fresh and new. Although the material particle is annihilated, the anti-material particle is never affected.
(Bg. 2.20)

The principle is also applicable to the anti-material universe as well as to the anti-material particle. When the material universe is annihilated, the anti-material universe exists in all circumstances. This will be explained in more detail later.

The scientist may also learn the following from the Gétä:

The learned man who knows perfectly well that the anti-material particle is indestructible knows that it cannot be annihilated by any means.
(Bg. 2.30)

The atomic scientist may consider annihilating the material world by nuclear weapons, but his weapons cannot destroy the anti-material world. The antimaterial particle is more clearly explained in the following lines:

It is neither cut into pieces by any material weapon, nor is it burnt by fire. Nor is it moistened by water, nor withered, nor dried up, nor evaporated in the air. It is indivisible, nonflammable, and insoluble. Because it is eternal, it can enter into and leave any sort of body. Being steady by constitution, its qualities are always fixed. It is inexplicable, because it is contrary to all material qualities. It is unthinkable by the ordinary brain. It is unchangeable. No one, therefore, should ever lament for what is an eternal anti-material principle.
(Bg. 2.23-25)

Thus, in the Bhagavad-gétä and in all other Vedic literatures the superior energy (anti-material principle) is accepted as the vital force or the living spirit. This is also called the jéva. This living principle cannot be generated by any combination of material elements. There are eight material principles which are described as inferior energies, and they are: l) earth, 2) water, 3) fire, 4) air, 5) ether, 6) mind, 7) intelligence, and 8) ego. Apart from these is the living force, or the anti-material-principle, which is described as the superior energy. These are called energies because they are wielded and controlled by the supreme living being, the Personality of Godhead (Kåñëa).

For a long time the materialist was limited within the boundary of the eight material principles mentioned above. Now it is encouraging to see that he has a little preliminary information of the antimaterial principle and the anti-material universe. We hope that with the progress of time the materialist will be able to estimate the value of the anti-material world in which there is no trace of material principles. Of course the very word "anti-material" indicates that the principle is in opposition to all material qualities.

There are, of course, the mental speculators who comment upon the anti-material principle. These fall into two main groups, and they arrive at two different erroneous conclusions. One group (the gross materialists) either denies the anti-material principle or admits only the disintegration of material combination at a certain stage (death). The other group accepts the anti-material principle as being in direct opposition to the material principle with its twenty-four categories. This group is known as the säìkhyas, and they investigate the material principles and analyze them minutely. At the end of their investigation, the säìkhyaites finally accept a transcendental (anti-material) nonactive principle. However, difficulties arise for all these mental speculators because they speculate with the help of inferior energy. They do not accept information from the superior. In order to realize the real position of the anti-material principle, one must rise to the transcendental plane of superior energy. Bhakti-yoga is the very activity of superior energy.

From the platform of the material world, one cannot estimate the real position of the anti-material world. To try to do so is like the attempt of a frog in a well to approximate the breadth and depth of the Pacific Ocean. "Is it twice as big as this well?" he asks. "Three times as big? Four times as big?" Obviously it is impossible to calculate in this way. But the Supreme Lord, who is the controller of both material and anti-material energies, descends out of His causeless mercy and gives us complete information of the anti-material world. In this way we can know what the anti-material world is. The Supreme Lord and the living entities are both anti-material in quality, we are informed. Thus, we can have an idea of the Supreme Lord by an elaborate study of the living entities. Every living entity is an individual person. Therefore, the supreme living being must also be the supreme person. In the Vedic literatures the supreme person is properly claimed to be Kåñëa. The name "Kåñëa," indicating the Supreme Lord, is the one truly intelligible name of the highest order. He is the controller of both material and antimaterial energies, and the very word "Kåñëa" signifies that He is the supreme controller. In the Gétä the Lord confirms this as follows:

There are two worlds-the material and antimaterial. The material world is composed of inferior qualitative energy divided into eight material principles. The anti-material world is made of superior qualitative energy. Because both the material and anti-material energies are emanations of the Supreme Transcendence Personality of Godhead, it is proper to conclude that I [Lord Kåñëa] am the ultimate cause of all creations and annihilations.
(Bg. 7.4-6)

Because the Lord’s two energies (inferior and superior) manifest the material and anti-material worlds, He is called the supreme absolute truth. Lord Kåñëa explains this in the Gétä thus:

I am, Arjuna, the highest principle of transcendence, and there is nothing greater than Me. Everything that be rests on My energies exactly like pearls on a thread.
(Bg. 7.7)

Long, long before the discovery of the principles of antirmatter and the anti-material worlds, the subject was delineated in the Gétä. The Gétä itself indicates that its philosophy had previously been taught to the presiding deity of the sun, which implies that the principles of the Gétä were expounded by the Personality of Godhead long before the Battle of Kurukñetra—at least some 120,000,000 years before. Now modern science has just discovered a fraction of the truths that are available in the Gétä.

The assumption of an anti-material universe is also found in the Gétä. And from all data available it is to be assumed without the slightest doubt that the antimaterial world is situated in the anti-material sky, a sky which is mentioned in the Gétä as sanätana-dhäma, or the eternal nature.

Exactly as material atoms create the material world, the anti-material atoms create the anti-material world with all its paraphernalia. The anti-material world is inhabited by anti-material living beings. In the anti-material world there is no inert matter. Everything there is a living principle, and the Supreme Personality in that region is God Himself. The denizens of the anti-material world possess eternal life, eternal knowledge and eternal bliss. In other words, they have all the qualifications of God.

In the material world the topmost planet is called Satyaloka or Brahmaloka. Beings of the greatest talents live in this planet. The presiding deity of Brahmaloka is Brahmä, the first created being of this material world. Brahmä is a living being like so many of us, but he is the most talented personality in the material world. He is not so talented that he is in the category of God, but he is in the category of those living entities directly dominated by God. God and the living entities both belong to the antimaterial world. The scientist, therefore, would be rendering service to everyone by researching the constitution of the anti-material world—how it is administered, how things are shaped there, who are the presiding personalities, and so on. Of the Vedic literatures, Çrémad-Bhägavatam deals elaborately with these matters. The Gétä is the preliminary study of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. These two important books of knowledge should be thoroughly studied by all men in the scientific world. They would give many clues to scientific progress and would indicate many new discoveries.

The transcendentalists and the materialists are two distinct classes of men. The transcendentalist gathers knowledge from authoritative scriptures like the Vedas. Vedic literature is received from authoritative sources which are in the line of transcendental disciplic succession. This disciplic succession (paramparä) is also mentioned in the Gétä. Kåñëa says in the Gétä that hundreds of thousands of years ago the Gétä was spoken to the presiding deity of the sun, who delivered the knowledge to his son Manu, from whom the present generation of Man has descended. Manu, in his turn, delivered this transcendental knowledge to his son King Ikñväku, who is the fore-father of the dynasty in which the Personality of Godhead Çré Räma appeared. This long chain of disciplic succession was broken during the advent period of Lord Kåñëa (5,000 years ago), and for this reason Kåñëa restated the Gétä to Arjuna, thereby making him the first disciple of this knowledge in this age. The transcendentalist of this age, therefore, is in the disciplic line that starts with Arjuna. Without troubling himself with materialistic research work, the transcendentalist acquires the truths concerning matter and anti-matter in the most perfect way (through this disciplic succession) and thereby saves himself much botheration.

The gross materialists, however, do not believe in the anti-material worlds of the Personality of Godhead. They are therefore unfortunate creatures, although sometimes very talented, educated and advanced otherwise. They are bewildered by the influence of the material manifestation and are devoid of knowledge of things anti-material. It is a good sign, therefore, that the materialistic scientists are gradually progressing towards the region of the antimaterial world. It may even be possible for them to make sufficient progress to be able to know the details of this anti-material world, where the Personality of Godhead resides as the predominating figure and where the living entities live with Him and serve Him. The living entities who serve the Godhead are equal in quality to Him, but at the same time they are pre-dominated as servitors. In the anti-material world there is no difference between the predominated and the predominator—the relationship is in perfection and without tinge of materialism.

The nature of the material world is destructive. According to the Gétä, there is some partial truth to the assumption of the physical scientist that there is annihilation of the material and anti-material worlds when they chance to clash. The material world is a creation of changing modes of nature. These modes (guëas) are known as sattva (goodness), rajas (passion), and tamas (ignorance). The material world is created by the mode of rajas, maintained by the mode of sattva, and annihilated by the mode of tamas. These modes are omnipresent in the material world, and as such, at every hour, every minute, every second, the process of creation, maintenance and annihilation is taking place all over the material universe. The highest planet of the material universe, Brahmaloka, is also subjected to these modes of nature, although the duration of life on that planet, due to the predominance of the mode of sattva, is said to be 4,300,000 x 1,000 x 2 x 30 x 12 x 100 solar years. Despite this long duration, however, Brahmaloka is subject to destruction. Although life on Brahmaloka is fantastically long compared to life on earth, it is only a flash in comparison to the eternal life of the nonmaterial worlds. Consequently, the speaker of the Gétä, Lord Çré Kåñëa, asserts the importance of the anti-material universe which is His abode.

Lord Kåñëa instructs that all the planets within the material universe are destroyed at the end of 4,300,000 x 1,000 x 2 x 30 x 12 x 100 solar years. And all the living beings inhabiting these material planets are destroyed materially along with the destruction of the material worlds. The living entity, however, is constitutionally an anti-material particle. But unless he elevates himself to the region of the anti-material worlds by cultivation of anti-material activities, he is destroyed materially at the annihilation of the material worlds and is subject to take rebirth in a material shape with the rebirth of a new material universe. In other words, he is subject to the pains of repeated birth and death. Only those living entities who take to the loving service of the Personality of Godhead during the manifested stage of material life are undoubtedly transferred to the antimaterial worlds after quitting the material body. Immortality is only obtained by those who return to Godhead by practice of anti-material activities.

What are these anti-material activities? They are medicines. For example, when a man falls ill, he goes to a physician who prescribes medicines which eventually cure the suffering patient. Similarly, the materialist is ailing, and he should consult an expert transcendentalist physician. What is his ailment? He is suffering the tribulations of repeated births, deaths, diseases and old age. Once he agrees to put himself under the "back to Godhead treatment," he is able to transfer himself to the anti-material world where there is eternal life instead of birth and death.

Annihilation of the material world takes place in two ways. Partial annihilation occurs at the end of. every 4,300,000 x 1,000 solar years, or at the end of each day of Brahmaloka, which is the topmost planet in the material world. During that time of partial annihilation, the topmost planets such as Brahmaloka are not annihilated, but at the end of each duration of 4,300,000 x 1,000 x 2 x 30 x12 x 100 solar years, the entire cosmic manifestation is merged into the anti-material body from whence the material principles emanate, manifest and merge after annihilation. The anti-material world, which is far removed from the material sky, is never annihilated. It absorbs the material world. It may be that a "clash" occurs between the material and anti-material worlds, as suggested by the scientists, and that the material worlds are destroyed, but there is no annihilation of the anti-material worlds. The eternally existing antimaterial world is nonmanifested to the material scientist. He can simply have information of it insofar as the principles of its existence are contrary to the modes of the material world. However, full details of the anti-material universe can be known only from the infallible source of liberated authorities who have thoroughly realized the constitution of the antimaterial principle. This information is received by aural reception by a submissive disciple of the Personality of Godhead.

The Vedic knowledge was thus imparted unto the heart of Brahmä, the first living being in the material creation. It was Brahmä who related this knowledge to the sage Närada Muni. Similarly, the Bhagavad-gétä was spoken by the Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, to Vivasvän, the presiding deity of the sun, and when the aural chain of disciplic succession was broken, Lord Kåñëa repeated the Gétä to Arjuna on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra. At that time, Arjuna took the role of disciple and student in order to receive transcendental knowledge from Çré Kåñëa. In order to drive out all misgivings which the gross materialists of the world may have, Arjuna asked all relevant questions, and the answers were given by Kåñëa so that any layman can understand them. Only those who are captivated by the glamour of the material world cannot accept the authority of Lord Kåñëa. One has to become thoroughly clean in habit and heart before one can understand the details of the anti-material world. Bhakti-yoga is a detailed scientific transcendental activity that both the neophyte and the perfect yogé can practice.

The material world is only a shadow representation of the anti-material world, and intelligent men who are clean in heart and habit will be able to learn, in a nutshell, all the details of the anti-material world from the text of the Gétä, and these are in actuality more exhaustive than material details. The basic details are as follows:

The presiding Deity of the anti-material world is Çré Kåñëa, who exists in His original personality as well as in His many plenary expansions. This personality and His plenary expansions can be known only by anti-material activities commonly known as bhakti-yoga, or devotional service. The Personality of Godhead is the supreme truth, and He is the whole anti-material principle. The material principle as well as the anti-material principle is an emanation from His person. He is the root of the complete tree. When water is poured onto the root of a tree, the branches and leaves are nourished automatically. And in the same way, when Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead, is worshiped, all details of the material worlds are enlightened, and the heart of the devotee is nourished without his having to work in a materialistic way. This is the secret of the Bhagavad-gétä.

The process of entering into the anti-material worlds differs from materialistic processes. The individual living being can very easily enter the antimaterial world by practicing anti-material activities while residing in the material world. But those who are truly gross materialists, who depend on the limited strength of experimental thought, mental speculation and materialistic science, find great difficulty in entering the anti-material worlds. The gross materialist may try to approach the anti-material worlds by endeavoring with spaceships, satellites, rockets, etc., which he throws into outer space, but by such means he cannot even approach the material planets' in the higher regions of the material sky, and what to speak of those planets situated in the antimaterial sky, which is far beyond the material universe. Even the yogés who have perfectly controlled mystic powers have great difficulty entering into that region. Master yogés who control the anti-material particle within the material body by practice of mystic powers can give up their material bodies at will at any given moment and can thus enter the anti-material worlds through a specific thoroughfare which connects the material and anti-material worlds. If they are at all able, they act in accordance with the prescribed method given in the Gétä:

Those who have realized the transcendence can reach the anti-material world by leaving their material bodies during the period of uttaräyaëa, that is, when the sun is on its northern path, or during auspicious moments in which the deities of fire and effulgence control the atmosphere.
(Bg. 8.24)

The different deities, or powerful directing officers, are appointed to act in the administration of cosmic activities. Foolish people who are unable to see the intricacies of cosmic management laugh at the idea of personal management of fire, air, electricity, days, nights, etc., by demigods. But the perfect yogés know how to satisfy these unseen administrators of material affairs and, taking advantage of the good will of these administrators, leave their material bodies at will during opportune moments arranged for entrance into the anti-material universe or into the highest planets of the material sky. In the higher planets of the material world, the yogés can enjoy more comfortable and more pleasant lives for hundreds of thousands of years, but life in those higher planets is not eternal. Those who desire eternal life enter into the anti-material universe through mystic powers at certain opportune moments that are created by the demigod administrators. These cosmic affairs are unseen by the gross materialists who reside on this seventh-class planet called "earth."

Those who are not yogés but who die at an opportune moment due to penances performed or pious acts or sacrifices, charity, etc., can rise to the higher planets after death, but are subject to return to this planet [earth]. Their going forth takes place at a period known as dhüma, the dark, moonless half of the month in which the sun is on its southern path.
(Bg. 8.25)

In summary, the Gétä recommends that one adopt the means of devotional service, or anti-material activities, if one wishes to enter the anti-material world. Those who adopt the means of devotional service, as prescribed by the expert transcendentalist, are never disappointed in their attempts to enter the anti-material worlds. Although the obstacles are many, the devotees of Lord Kåñëa can easily overcome them by rigidly following the path outlined by the transcendental devotees. Such devotees, who are passengers progressing in the journey of life towards the anti-material kingdom of God, are never bewildered. No one is cheated or disappointed when he adopts the guaranteed path of devotion for entrance into the anti-material universe. One can easily attain all the results that are derived from the studies of the Vedas, performances of sacrifice, practices of penance and offerings of charities simply by the unilateral performance of devotional service, technically known as bhakti-yoga.

Bhakti-yoga is therefore the great panacea for all, and it has been made easy to practice, especially in this iron age, by Lord Kåñëa Himself in His most sublime, liberal and munificent appearance as Lord Çré Caitanya (1486-1534), who appeared in Bengal and spread the saìkértana movement-singing, dancing, and chanting the names of God-throughout India. By Lord Caitanya’s grace, one can quickly pick up the principles of bhakti-yoga. Thus all misgivings in the heart will disappear, the fire of material tribulation will be extinguished, and transcendental bliss will be ushered in.

In the Fifth Chapter of the Brahma-saàhitä there is a description of the variegated planetary system that is within the material world. It is also indicated in the Gétä that there are variegated planetary systems in hundreds of thousands of material universes, and that altogether these universes comprise only a fraction (one-fourth) of the creative energy of the Godhead. The majority (three-fourths) of the Lord’s creative energy is manifested in the spiritual sky called the para-vyoma or the Vaikuëöhaloka. These instructions of the Brahma-saàhitä and Bhagavad-gétä may be finally confirmed by the material scientist as he researches into the existence of the antimaterial world.

In addition, a February 21st, 1960, Moscow news release reported:

Russia’s well-known professor of astronomy Boris Vorontsov-Velianino said that there must be an infinite number of planets in the universe inhabited by beings endowed with reason.

This statement of the Russian astronomer is a confirmation of the information given in the Brahma-saàhitä, which states:

yasya prabhä prabhavato jagadaëòa-koöi-

koöiñv açeñavasudhädi vibhüti-bhinnam

tad brahma niñkalam anantam açeña-bhütaà

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

According to this quote from the Brahma-saàhitä, there are not only infinite numbers of planets, as confirmed by the Russian astronomer, but there are also infinite numbers of universes. All these infinite universes with their infinite planets within are floating on and are produced from the Brahman effulgence emanating from the transcendental body of Govinda (Lord Çré Kåñëa), the primeval Lord who is worshiped by Brahmä, the presiding deity of the universe in which we are residing.

The Russian astronomer also confirms that all the planets—which are estimated to be not less than 100,000,000—are inhabited. In the Brahma-saàhitä there is indication that in each and every one of the infinite number of universes there are infinite numbers of variegated planets.

The astronomer's view was seconded by Professor Vladimir Alpatov, a biologist, who maintained that some of the above-mentioned planets had reached a state of development corresponding to that of the earth. The report from Moscow continued:

It could be that life, similar to that on earth, flourishes on such planets. Doctor of Chemistry Nikolat Zhirov, covering the problem of atmosphere on the planets, pointed out that the organism of a Martian, for instance, could very well adapt itself to normal existence with a low body temperature. He said that he felt that the gaseous composition of the atmosphere of Mars was quite suitable to sustain life of beings which have become adapted to it.

The adaptability of organisms in different varieties of planets is described in the Brahma-saàhitä as vibhüti-bhinnam, i.e., each and every one of the innumerable planets within the universes is endowed with a particular type of atmosphere, and the living beings there are advanced in science, psychology, etc., according to the superiority or inferiority of the atmosphere. Vibhüti means specific power, and bhinnam means variegated. Scientists who are attempting to explore outer space in an attempt to reach other planets by mechanical means must realize that organisms adapted to the atmosphere of the earth cannot exist in the atmospheres of other planets. As such, man’s attempts to reach the moon, the sun, or Mars are hardly worthwhile, because the different atmospheres prevailing on those planets will not sustain his life. Individually, however, one can attempt to go to any planet he desires, but this is only possible by psychological changes in the mind or by yogic powers. Mind is the nucleus of the material body. The gradual evolutionary progress of the material body depends on psychological changes within the mind. The change of the bodily construction of a worm into that of a butterfly and, in modern medical science, the conversion of a man’s body into that of a woman (or vice versa) are more or less dependent on psychological changes.

In the Bhagavad-gétä it is said that if a man, at the time of death, concentrates his mind upon the form of the Personality of Godhead Çré Kåñëa and while so doing relinquishes his body, he at once enters the spiritual existence of the anti-material world. This means that anyone who trains the mind to turn from matter to the spiritual form of the Godhead by performance of the prescribed rules of devotional service can easily attain the kingdom of God in the anti-material sky. And of this there is no doubt.

And in the same way, if one desires to enter into any other planet of the material sky, he can go there just after quitting the present body (i.e., after death). Thus if someone wants to go to the moon, the sun, or Mars, he can do so simply by performing acts for the purpose. The Gétä confirms this statement in the following words:

That upon which a person meditates at the time of death, quitting his body absorbed in the thought thereof, that particular thing he attains after death.
(Bg. 8.6)

Maharaj Bharata, despite a life of severe penances, thought of a stag at the time of his death and thus became a stag after death. However, he did retain a clear consciousness of his past life and realized his mistake. It is important to realize that one's thoughts at the time of death are influenced by the actual deeds which one performs during his life.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the process of entering the moon is described as follows:

Materialistic-minded men, who have no information of the kingdom of God, are always mad after material acquisition of wealth, fame and adoration. Such men are interested in the progressive weal of their particular family unit for their own self-satisfaction and so are also interested in the progress of social and national welfare. These men attain their desired objects by material activities. They are mechanically engaged in the ritualistic discharge of prescribed duties and are consequently inclined to satisfy the pitås, or bygone forefathers, and controlling demigods by performance of sacrifices as prescribed by the revealed scriptures. Addicted to such acts of sacrifices and ceremonial observances, such souls enter into the moon after death. When one is thus promoted to the moon, he receives the capacity to enjoy the drinking of soma-rasa, a celestial beverage. The moon is a place where the demigod Candra is the predominating deity. The atmosphere and amenities of life there are more comfortable and advantageous than those here on earth. After reaching the moon, if a soul does not utilize the opportunity for promotion to better planets, he is degraded and forced to return to earth or a similar planet. However, materialistic persons, although they may attain to the topmost planetary system, are certainly annihilated at the time of the cosmic manifestation’s dissolution.
(Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 3.32)

As far as the planetary system of the spiritual sky is concerned, there are unlimited Vaikuëöha planets in the para-vyoma. The Vaikuëöhas are spiritual planets which are manifestations of the internal potency of the Lord, and the ratio of these planets to the material planets (external energy) in the material sky is four to one. So the poor materialist is busy making political adjustments on a planet which is most insignificant in God’s creation. To say nothing of this planet earth, the whole universe with innumerable planets throughout the galaxies is comparable to a grain of mustard seed in a bag full of mustard seeds. But the poor materialist makes plans to live comfortably here and thus wastes his valuable human energy in something which is doomed to frustration. Instead of wasting his time with business speculations, he might have sought the life of plain living and high spiritual thinking and thus saved himself from perpetual materialistic unrest.

Even if a materialist wants to enjoy developed material facilities, he can transfer himself to planets where he can experience material pleasures much more advanced than those available on the earth planet. But the best plan is to prepare oneself to return to the spiritual sky after leaving the body. However, if one is intent on enjoying material facilities, one can transfer himself to other planets in the material sky by utilizing yogic powers. The playful spaceships of the astronauts are but childish entertainments and are of no use for this purpose.

The añöäìga-yoga system is a materialistic art of controlling air by transferring it from the stomach to the navel, from the chest to the collarbone and from there to the eyeballs and from there to the cerebellum and from there to any desired planet. The velocities of air and light are taken into consideration by the material scientist, but he has no information of the velocity of the mind and intelligence. We have some limited experience of the velocity of the mind, because in a moment we can transfer our minds to places hundreds of thousands of miles away. Intelligence is even finer. Finer than intelligence is the soul, which is not matter like mind and intelligence but is spirit or anti-matter. The soul is hundreds of thousands of times finer and more powerful than intelligence. We can thus only imagine the velocity of the soul in its traveling from one planet to another. Needless to say, the soul travels by its own strength and not with the help of any kind of material vehicle.

The bestial civilization of eating, sleeping, fearing and sense-gratifying has misled modern man into forgetting how powerful a soul he has. As we have already described, the soul is a spiritual spark which is many, many times more illuminating, dazzling and powerful than sun, moon, or electricity. Human life is spoiled when man does not realize his real identity with his soul. Lord Caitanya appeared with His disciple Nityänanda to save man from this type of misleading civilization.

Çrémad-Bhägavatam also describes how yogés can travel to all the planets in the universe. When the vital force is lifted to the cerebellum, there is every chance of this force bursting out from the eyes, nose, ears, etc., as these are places which are known as the seventh orbit of the vital force. But the yogés can block out these holes by complete suspension of air. The yogé then concentrates the vital force in the middle position, that is, between the eyebrows. At this position, the yogé can think of the planet into which he wants to enter after leaving the body. He can then decide whether he wants to go to the abode of Kåñëa in the transcendental Vaikuëöhas from which he will not be required to descend into the material world, or to travel to higher planets in the material universe. The perfect yogé is at liberty to do either.

For the perfect yogé who has attained success in the method of leaving his body in perfect consciousness, transferring from one planet to another is as easy as an ordinary man’s walking to the grocery store. As already discussed, the material body is just a covering of the spiritual soul. Mind and intelligence are the undercoverings, and the gross body of earth, water, air, etc., is the overcoating of the soul. As such, any advanced soul who has realized himself by the yogic process, who knows the relationship between matter and spirit, can leave the gross dress of the soul in perfect order and as he desires. By the grace of God, we have complete freedom. Because the Lord is kind to us, we can live anywhere—either in the spiritual sky or in the material sky, upon whichever planet we desire. However, misuse of this freedom causes one to fall down into the material world and suffer the threefold miseries of conditioned life. The living of a miserable life in the material world by dint of the soul’s choice is nicely illustrated by Milton in Paradise Lost. Similarly, by choice the soul can regain paradise and return home, back to Godhead.

At the critical time of death, one can place the vital force between the two eyebrows and decide where he wants to go. If he is reluctant to maintain any connection with the material world, he can, in less than a second, reach the transcendental Vaikuëöha and appear there completely in his spiritual body which will be suitable for him in the spiritual atmosphere. He has simply to desire to leave the material world both in finer and grosser forms and then move the vital force to the topmost part of the skull and leave the body from the hole in the skull called the brahma-randhra. This is easy for one perfect in the practice of yoga.

Of course man is endowed with free will, and as such if he does not want to free himself of the material world he may enjoy the life of Brahma-pada (occupation of the post of Brahmä) and visit Siddha-loka, the planets of materially perfect beings who have full capacities to control gravity, space, time, etc. To visit these higher planets in the material universe, one need not give up his mind and intelligence (finer matter), but need only give up grosser matter (the material body).

Each and every planet has its particular atmosphere, and if one wants to travel to any particular planet within the material universe, one has to adapt his material body to the climatic condition of that planet. For instance, if one wants to go from India to Europe, where the climatic condition is different, one has to change his dress accordingly. Similarly, a complete change of body is necessary if one wants to go to the transcendental planets of Vaikuëöha. However, if one wants to go to the higher material planets, he can keep his finer dress of mind, intelligence and ego, but has to leave his gross dress (body) made of earth, water, fire, etc.

When one goes to a transcendental planet, it is necessary to change both the finer and gross bodies, for one has to reach the spiritual sky completely in a spiritual form. This change of dress will take place automatically at the time of death if one so desires. But this desire is possible at death only if the desire is cultivated during life. Where one’s treasures are, there also is one’s heart. When one practices devotional service, one cultivates a desire for the kingdom of God. The following details outline a general practice by which one can prepare himself for an easy journey to the Vaikuëöha (anti-material) planets where life is free from birth, old age, disease and death.

General practice (positive functions):

l. The serious candidate must accept a bona fide spiritual master in order to be trained scientifically. Because the senses are material, it is not at all possible to realize the transcendence by them. Therefore the senses have to be spiritualized by the prescribed method under the direction of the spiritual master.

2. When the student has chosen a bona fide spiritual master, he must take the proper initiation from him. This marks the beginning of spiritual training.

3. The candidate must be prepared to satisfy the spiritual master in every way. A bona fide spiritual master who is fully cognizant of the methods of spiritual science, learned in the spiritual scriptures such as the Bhagavad-gétä, Vedänta, Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Upaniñads, etc., and who is also a realized soul who has made a tangible connection with the Supreme Lord, is the transparent medium by which the willing candidate is led to the path of the Vaikuëöhas. The spiritual master must be satisfied in all respects, because simply by his good wishes a candidate can make wonderful progress along the path.

4. The intelligent candidate places intelligent questions to the spiritual master in order to clear his path of all uncertainties. The spiritual master shows the way, not whimsically, but in accordance with the principles of the authorities who have actually traversed the path. The names of these authorities are disclosed in the scriptures, and one has simply to follow them under the direction of the spiritual master. The spiritual master never deviates from the path of the authorities.

5. The candidate should always try to follow the footsteps of the great sages who have practiced the method and obtained success. This should be taken as a motto in life. One should not superficially imitate them, but should follow them sincerely in terms of the particular time and circumstances.

6. The candidate must be prepared to change his habits in terms of the instructions contained in the books of authority, and for the satisfaction of the Lord, he must be prepared to sacrifice, both sense gratification and sense abnegation, following the example of Arjuna.

7. The candidate should live in a spiritual atmosphere.

8. He must be satisfied with as much wealth as is sufficient for maintenance only. He should not try to amass more wealth than is necessary to sustain himself in a simple way.

9. He must observe the fasting dates, such as the eleventh day of the growing and waning moon.

10. He must show respect to the banyan tree, the cow, the learned brähmaëa and the devotee.

These are the first stepping-stones towards the path of devotional service. Gradually one has to adopt other items which are negative in character.

11. One should avoid offenses in the discharge of devotional service and in chanting the holy names.

12. He should avoid extensive association with nondevotees.

13. He must not take on unlimited disciples. This means that a candidate who has successfully followed the first twelve items can also become a spiritual master himself, just as a student becomes a monitor in class with a limited number of disciples.

14. He must not pose himself as a vastly learned man simply by quoting statements in books. He must have solid knowledge of the necessary books without superfluous knowledge in others.

15. A regular and successful practice of the above fourteen items will enable the candidate to maintain mental equilibrium even amidst great trials of material loss or gain.

16. In the next stage, the candidate does not become afflicted by lamentation and illusion.

17. He does not deride another’s mode of religion or worship, nor does he deride the Personality of Godhead or His devotees.

18. He never tolerates blasphemy against the Lord or His devotees.

19. He should not indulge in the discussion of topics dealing with the relationship between man and woman; nor should he engage in useless topics concerning others’ family affairs.

20. He should not inflict pain—either in body or mind—upon other living beings, whomsoever they may be.

Out of the above twenty items, the first three positive items are imperative and most essential for the serious candidate.

There are forty-four other items to be followed by the serious candidate, but Lord Caitanya has selected five as the most important. These were selected owing to the present conditions of civic life. They are as follows:

l. One should associate with the devotees. Association with devotees is made possible by hearing them attentively, by asking them relevant questions, by supplying them food and by accepting food from them, and by giving them charity and by accepting from them whatever they offer.

2. One should chant the holy name of the Lord in all circumstances. The chanting of the Lord’s name is an easy and inexpensive process of realization. One can chant any of the innumerable names of the Lord at any time. One should try to avoid offenses. There are ten offenses which one can commit while chanting the names, and these should be avoided as far as possible. One should try to chant the names of the Lord at all times. Lord Caitanya has recommended , the sixteen-word chant called the mahä-mantra (or the "Great Chanting for Deliverance") as the sublime method in this age for attaining the antimaterial worlds of the kingdom of God. This sixteen-word chant actually utilizes only three words: Hare, Kåñëa and Räma. Hare means the energy of the Lord, and is a form of addressing this energy. Kåñëa and Räma are the names of the Lord Himself. The ; mahä-mantra—HARE KÅÑËA, HARE KÅÑËA, KÅÑËA KÅÑËA, HARE HARE/ HARE Räma, HARE Räma, Räma Räma, HARE HARE—can be sung, chanted or recited on beads.

3. One should hear the transcendental topics enunciated in the Bhagavad-gétä. This hearing is made possible through platform lectures by bona fide devotees and by authorized translations of the Gétä.

4. One should make his home at Mathurä, the birthplace of Lord Kåñëa. Or one may make his home as good as Mathurä by installing the Deity of the Lord to be worshiped by all members of the family after proper initiation from the spiritual master.

5. One should worship the installed Deity with attention and devotion so that the whole atmosphere of one’s home becomes the replica of the Lord’s abode. This is made possible by the direction of the spiritual master who knows the transcendental art and can show the candidate the proper method.

The above five items can be adopted by any man in any part of the world. Thus anyone can prepare himself for returning home, back to Godhead, by the simple method recognized by authorities such as Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who specifically advented Himself to deliver the fallen souls of this age.

For further details on this subject, one should read literatures like the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu by Rüpa Gosvämé and the Caitanya-caritämåta of Kåñëadäsa, as well as the Gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

The whole process of transferring oneself to the spiritual sky involves gradually liquidating the material composition of the gross and subtle coverings of the spirit soul. The above-mentioned five items of devotional activities are so spiritually powerful that their performance by a devotee, even in the preliminary stage, can very quickly promote the-sincere executor to the stage of bhäva (the first stage of love of Godhead), or emotion on the spiritual plane which is transcendental to mental functions. A complete absorption in bhäva, or love of God, makes one fit to be transferred to the spiritual sky just after leaving the material tabernacle. The perfection of love of God by a devotee actually situates him on the spiritual platform, even though he may still maintain a gross material body. He becomes like a red-hot iron which, when in contact with fire, actually ceases to be iron and acts like fire. These things are made possible by the Lord’s inscrutable and inconceivable energy, which material science has not the scope to calculate. One should, therefore, engage himself in devotional service with absolute faith and strive to make his faith steadfast. One should also seek the association of the standard devotees of the Lord by personal association (if possible) or by thinking of them. This association will help one develop factual devotional service to the Lord, which will cause all material misgivings to disappear like a flash of lightning. All these different stages of spiritual realization will be personally felt by the candidate, and this will create in him a firm belief that he is making positive progress on the way to the spiritual sky. Then he will become sincerely attached to the Lord and His abode. Such is the gradual process of evolving love of God, which is of prime importance for the human form of life.

There are instances in history of great personalities, including sages and kings, who attained perfection by this process. Some of them attained success even by adhering to one single item of devotional service with faith and perseverance. Some of these personalities are listed below.

1. Emperor (Mahäräja) Parékñit attained the spiritual platform simply by hearing from an authority like Çré Çukadeva Gosvämé.

2. Çré Çukadeva Gosvämé attained the same simply by recitation, verbatim, of the transcendental message which he received from his great father, Çré Vyäsadeva.

3. Emperor Prahläda attained spiritual success by remembering the Lord constantly in pursuance of instructions given by Çré Närada Muni, the great saint and devotee.

4. Lakñméjé, the goddess of fortune, attained success simply by sitting and serving the lotus feet of the Lord.

5. King Påthu attained success simply by worshiping the Lord.

6. Akrüra, the charioteer, attained success simply by chanting prayers for the Lord.

7. Hanumän (Mahävéra), the famous nonhuman devotee of Lord Çré Rämacandra, attained success simply by carrying out the orders of the Lord.

8. Arjuna, the great warrior, attained the same perfection simply by making friends with the Lord, who delivered the message of Bhagavad-gétä to enlighten Arjuna and his followers.

9. Emperor Bali attained success by surrendering everything unto the Lord, including his personal body.

These are nine standard modes of devotional service to the Lord, and a candidate can choose to adopt any one, two, three, four or all, however he likes. All the services rendered to the absolute are in themselves absolute; there are none of the material differences to be found on the spiritual platform. On the spiritual platform everything is identical with everything else, although there is transcendental variegatedness. Emperor Ambaréña adopted all the above nine items, and he attained perfect success. It was he who engaged his mind on the lotus feet of the Lord, his voice in describing the spiritual worlds, his hands in cleansing the temple of the Lord, his ears in submissively hearing the words of Lord Çré Kåñëa, his eyes in visualizing the Deities of the Lord, his body in touching the bodies of the devotees, his nostrils in smelling the flowers offered to the Lord, his tongue in tasting the food offered to the Lord, his legs in visiting the temple of the Lord, and all the energy of his life in executing the services of the Lord without in the least desiring his own sense gratification. All these activities helped him attain the perfect stage of life which defeats all dexterities of material science.

It is therefore important for all human beings to adopt these principles of spiritual realization for the perfection of life. A human being’s only obligation is spiritual realization. Unfortunately, in modern civilization, human society is too busy in discharging national duties. Actually, national duties, social duties and humanitarian duties are obligatory only to those who are bereft of spiritual duties. As soon as a man takes his birth on this earth, he not only has national, social and humanitarian obligations, but he also has obligations to the demigods who supply air, light, water, etc. He also has obligations to the great sages who have left behind them vast treasure houses of knowledge to guide him through life. He has obligations to all kinds of living beings, to his forefathers, family members and so forth and so on. But as soon as one engages himself in the one single obligatory duty—the duty of spiritual perfection—then he automatically liquidates all other obligations without having to make separate efforts.

A devotee of the Lord is never a disturbing element in society—on the contrary, he is a great social asset. Since no sincere devotee is attracted to sinful actions, as soon as a man becomes a pure devotee he can do inestimable selfless service to society for the peace and prosperity of all concerned, in this life and in the next. But even if such a devotee commits some offense, the Lord Himself rectifies it in no time. A devotee need not renounce everything and live as a hermit. He can simply remain at home and execute devotional service smoothly in any order of life. And there are instances in history of extremely cruel men becoming kindhearted simply by the execution of devotional service. Knowledge and abnegation of an inferior way of life follow automatically in the life of a pure devotee without his having to make extraneous effort.

This spiritual art and science of devotional service is the highest contribution of Indian sages to the rest of the world. Everyone interested in God realization has an obligation to perfect his life by adopting the principles of this great art and science and distributing it to the rest of the world which is still ignorant of the ultimate aim of life. Human society is destined to reach this stage of perfection by gradual development of knowledge. Indian sages, however, have already freached that position. Why do others have to wait for thousands and thousands of years to attain their heights? Why not give them the information immediately in a systematic way, so that they may save time and energy? They should take advantage of a life for which they may have labored millions of years to attain.

A Russian fiction writer is now contributing suggestions to the rest of the world that scientific progress can help man to live forever. Of course he does not believe in a Supreme Being who is the creator. As mentioned, every living being is eternal in form, 'but he has to change his outer coverings, gross and subtle, and this changing process is technically known as life and death. As long as a living being has to put 'on the shackles of material bondage, there is no relief from this changing process which continues even in the highest stage of material life. The Russian fiction writer may speculate, as fiction writers are apt to do, but saner people with some knowledge of natural law will not agree that man can live forever within this material world.

A naturalist can see the general course of material nature simply by studying a piece of fruit. A small fruit develops from a flower, grows, stays for some time on a branch, becomes full-grown, ripens, then begins to dwindle daily until it finally falls from the tree and commences to decompose into the earth and at last mingles with the earth, leaving behind its seed which in its turn grows to become a tree and produces many fruits in time, which will all meet the same fate, and so on and so on.

Similarly, a living being (as a spiritual spark, a part of the Supreme Being) takes its organic form in the womb of a mother just after sexual intercourse. It grows little by little within the womb, is born, then continues growing, becomes a child, boy, youth, adult, old man, then finally dwindles and meets death, despite all the good wishes and hopeful pipedreams of fiction writers. By comparison, there is no difference between man and the fruit. Like the fruit, the man may leave behind him his seeds of numerous children, but he cannot exist eternally within his material body due to the law of material nature.

How can anyone ignore the law of material nature? No material scientist can change the stringent laws of nature, however boastful he may be. No astronomer or scientist can change the course of the planets—he can only manufacture a paltry toy planet which he calls a satellite. Foolish children may be impressed by this and may give a great deal of credit to the inventors of modern satellites, sputniks, etc., but the saner section of humanity gives more credit to the creator of the gigantic satellites, namely the sun, stars and planets of which the material scientist can see no end. If a small toy satellite has a creator in Russia or America, it is reasonable that the gigantic satellites have their creator in the spiritual sky. If a toy satellite requires so many scientific brains for its manufacture and its orbiting, what kind of subtle and perfect brain created galaxies of stars and maintains them in their orbits? Thus far the atheistic class have not been able to answer this.

Nonbelievers put forward their own theories of the creation which usually result in statements such as, "It’s hard to understand." "Our imagination cannot conceive it, but it’s quite possible." "It’s incomprehensible," and so forth. This only means that their information has no authoritative basis and is not backed by scientific data. They simply speculate. However, authorized information is available in the Bhagavad-gétä. For instance, the Gétä informs us that within the material world there are living beings whose duration of life covers 4,300,000 x 1,000 x 2 x 30 x 12 x 100 solar years. We accept the Gétä as authority because this book of knowledge was so accepted by India’s great sages like Çaìkaräcärya, Çré Rämänujäcärya, Çré Madhväcärya, Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu and so on. The Gétä indicates that in the material world all component forms are subject to decay and death, regardless of their duration of life.

Therefore all material shapes are subject to the law of change, although potentially the material energy is conserved. Potentially, everything is eternal, but in the material world matter takes shape, remains for some time, develops into maturity, grows old, begins to dwindle and at last disappears again. This is the case with all material objects. The materialist’s suggestion that beyond the material sky there is "some other form" which is beyond the boundary of visibility and which is strange and inconceivable is but a faint indication of the spiritual sky. However, the basic principle of spirit is much closer—for it functions within all living beings. When that spiritual principle is out of the material body, then the material body has no life. Within the body of a child, for instance, the spiritual principle is present, and therefore changes take place in the body and it develops. But if the spirit leaves the body, the development stops. This law is applicable to every material object. Matter transforms from one shape to another when it is in contact with spirit. Without spirit there is no transformation. The entire universe develops in that way. It emanates from the energy of the transcendence because of the spiritual force which is His, and it develops into gigantic forms like the sun, moon, earth, etc. There are fourteen divisions of planetary systems, and although they are all different in dimension and quality, the same principle of development holds true for all. The spiritual force is the creator, and by this spiritual principle only, transformation, transition and development take place.

Life is definitely not generated simply by a material reaction like chemical combination, as many foolish men claim. Material interaction is set in motion by a superior being who creates a favorable circumstance to accommodate the spiritual living force. The superior energy handles matter in an appropriate way—as determined by the free will of the spiritual being. For example, building materials do not automatically "react" and suddenly assume the shape of a residential house. The living spiritual being handles matter appropriately by his free will and thus constructs his house. Similarly, matter is the ingredient only, but the spirit is the creator. Only a man with a poor fund of knowledge avoids this conclusion. One should not be illusioned simply by the gigantic form of the material universe. Rather, one should learn to discern the existence of supreme intelligence behind all these material manifestations. The Supreme Being, who is the supreme intelligence, is the ultimate creator, the all-attractive Personality of Godhead Çré Kåñëa. Although one may not be aware of this, there is definite information of the creator given in Vedic literatures such as the Bhagavad-gétä and especially the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The Gétä flatly denies that life simply "happens" by the lucky "interaction of certain physical and chemical combinations."

All beings, Arjuna, pass into nature which is My own at the end of the cycle; and at the beginning of the next cycle, I send them forth. Taking hold of nature which is My own, I send forth again and again this multitude of beings, which is helpless, being under the control of nature (prakåti). Under My guidance, nature (prakåti) gives birth to all things, moving and unmoving, and by this means, O Arjuna, the world revolves.
(Bg. 9.7-8, 10)

In these words, Çré Kåñëa indicates Himself to be the absolute controller.

When a satellite is thrown into outer space, a child may not understand that there are scientific brains behind it, but an intelligent adult realizes that scientific brains on earth are controlling the satellite. Similarly, less intelligent persons do not have information of the creator and His eternal abode in the spiritual world, which is far beyond our range of visibility, but in actuality there is a spiritual sky and spiritual planets which are more spacious and greater in number than those in the material sky. From the Gétä we receive information that the material universe only constitutes a fraction (one-fourth) of the creation. Such information is extensively available in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam and in other Vedic literatures.

If living energy can be generated in the scientist’s laboratory by "the interaction of certain physical and chemical combinations," then why haven’t the boastful material scientists been able to manufacture life? They should know definitely that spiritual force is distinguished from matter and that it is not possible to produce such energy by any amount of material adjustment. At present Russians and Americans are undoubtedly very much advanced in many departments of technological science, but they are still ignorant of the spiritual science. They will have to learn from superior intelligence in order to make a perfect and progressive human society.

The Russians are unaware that in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam the socialist philosophy is most perfectly described. The Bhägavatam instructs that whatever wealth exists-all natural resources (agricultural, mining, etc.)—is created by the ultimate creator, and therefore every living being has a right to take part of them. It is further said that a man should only possess as much wealth as is sufficient to maintain his body, and that if he desires more than that, or if he takes more than his share, he is subject to punishment. It is also stated that animals should he treated as one’s own children.

We believe that no nation on earth can describe socialism as well as the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Living beings other than humans can he treated as brothers and children only when one has a full conception of the creator and the actual constitution of the living being.

Man’s desire to he deathless is only realized in the spiritual world. As stated at the beginning of this essay, a desire for eternal life is a sign of dormant spiritual life. The aim of human civilization should he targetted to that end. It is possible for every human being to transfer himself to that spiritual realm by the process of bhakti-yoga, as described herein. It is a great science, and India has produced many scientific literatures by which the perfection of life may ithe realized.

Bhakti-yoga is the eternal religion of man. At a time when material science predominates all subjects—including the tenets of religion—it would be enlivening to see the principles of the eternal religion of man from the viewpoint of the modern scientist. Even Dr. S. Rädhäkrishnan admitted at the world religion conference that religion will not he accepted in modern civilization if it is not accepted by science. In reply, we are glad to announce to the lovers of the truth that bhakti-yoga is the eternal religion of the world and is intended for all living beings eternally related with the Supreme Lord.

Çréman Rämänujäcärya defines the word sanätana, or eternal, as that which has neither beginning nor end. When we speak of sanätana-dharma, eternal religion, we take this definition for granted. That which has neither beginning nor end is unlike anything sectarian which has limits and boundaries. In the light of modern science it will he possible for us to see sanätana-dharma as the main occupation of all the people of the world-nay, of all living entities of the universe. Non-sanätana religious faith may have some beginning in the annals of man, but there is no historic origin of sanätana-dharma because it eternally remains with living entities.

When a man professes to belong to a particular faith—Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Buddhist, or any other sect—and when he refers to a particular time and circumstance of birth, such designations are called non-sanätana-dharma. A Hindu may become a Muslim or a Muslim may become a Hindu or Christian, etc., but in all circumstances there is one constant. In all circumstances, he is rendering service to others. A Hindu, Muslim, Buddhist, or Christian is in all circumstances a servant of someone. The particular type of faith professed is not sanätana-dharma. Sanätana-dharma is the constant companion of the living being, the unifier of all religions. Sanätana-dharma is the rendering of service.

In the Bhagavad-gétä there are several references to sanätana-dharma. Let us learn the import of sanätana-dharma from this authority.

There is reference to the word sanätanam in the tenth verse of the Seventh Chapter, in which the Lord says that He is the eternal fountainhead of everything and is therefore sanätanam. The fountain-head of everything is described in the Upaniñads as the complete whole. Although many emanations of the fountainhead are also complete in themselves, the sanätana head does not diminish in quality or quantity.* That is because the nature of sanätana is unchangeable. Anything that changes under the influence of time and circumstances is not sanätana. Therefore anything that changes whatsoever in form or quality cannot be accepted as sanätana. That which is never created cannot change in formation and quality, even though He is the seedling source of everything.

The Lord claims to be the father of all species of life. He claims that all living beings-regardless of what they are-are part and parcel of Him. Consequently, the Bhagavad-gétä is meant for all of them. In the Gétä there is information of this sanätana nature of the Supreme Lord. There is also information of His abode, which is far beyond the material sky, and of the sanätana nature of the living beings.

Lord Kåñëa, in the Gétä, also informs us that this material world is full of miseries in the shape of birth, old age, disease and death. Even in the topmost planet of the material universe, Brahmaloka, these miseries are present. Only in His own abode is there a total absence of misery. In that abode there is no need of light from sun, moon or fire. The planets are self-luminous. Life there is perpetual and full of knowledge and bliss. That is what is known as sanätana-dhama. It is therefore natural to conclude that the living entities must return home, back to Godhead, to enjoy life in the sanätana-dhama with the sanätana-puruña or the puruñottama, Lord Çré Kåñëa. They must not remain to rot in this miserable land of material existence. There is little happiness in the material sphere—even in Brahmaloka—so plans and activities for elevation to higher planets within the material universe are carried out by less intelligent beings who take shelter of demigods and only derive benefits which endure for a limited period. Thus their religious principles and the benefits derived therefrom are only temporary. The intelligent man, however, abandons all engagements in the name of religion and takes shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and thus receives absolute protection from the Almighty Father. Sanätana-dharma is therefore the process of bhakti-yoga by which one can come to know the sanätana Lord and His sanätana abode. By this process only one can return to the spiritual universe to take part in the sanätana enjoyment prevailing there.

Those who are followers of sanätana-dharma may henceforward take up those principles in the spirit of the Bhagavad-gétä. There are no barriers for one who adopts the eternal principles. Even persons who are less enlightened can return to Godhead. This is the version taught by the Supreme Lord Himself in the Bhagavad-gétä. Mankind should be given a chance to take advantage of this opportunity. Especially at the present moment, misguided men are suffering in the darkness of materialism, and their so-called learning has enabled them to discover the atomic bomb. They are consequently on the verge of annihilation. Man’s refuge is in sanätana-dharma, which will teach him the real purpose of life and will afford him an easy journey to the spiritual planets where he can associate with the Personality of Godhead in full bliss and knowledge for eternity.

EJ'70:2 Varieties of Planetary Systems

2 Varieties of Planetary Systems

In these days, when men are trying to go to the moon, people should not think that Kåñëa consciousness is concerned with something old-fashioned. When the world is progressing to reach the moon, we are chanting Hare Kåñëa. But people should not misunderstand and assume that we are lagging behind modern scientific advancement. We have already passed all scientific advancement. In Bhagavad-gétä it is said that man’s attempt to reach higher planets is not new. Newspaper headlines read, "Man’s First Steps on the Moon," but the reporters do not know that millions and millions of men went there and came back. This is not the first time. This is an ancient practice. In Bhagavad-gétä [8.16] it is clearly stated, "My dear Arjuna, even if you go to the highest planetary system, which is called Brahmaloka, you will have to come back." Therefore, interplanetary travel is not new. It is known to the Kåñëa conscious devotees.

Since we are Kåñëa conscious, we take what Kåñëa says to be the Absolute Truth. According to Vedic literature, there are many planetary systems. The planetary system in which we are living is called Bhurloka. Above this planetary system is Bhuvarloka. Above that is Svarloka (the moon belongs to the Svarloka planetary system). Above Svarloka is Janaloka; above that is Maharloka; and above that is Satyaloka. Similarly, there are lower planetary systems. Thus there are fourteen statuses of planetary systems within this universe, and the sun is the chief planet. The sun is described in the Brahma-saàhitä:

yaccakñureña savitä sakalagrahäëäà

räjä samasta sura mürttir açeñatejäù

yasyäjïayä bhramati sambhåtakälacakro

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda (Kåñëa), the primeval Lord, by whose order the sun assumes immense power and heat and traverses its orbit. The sun, which is the chief among all planetary systems, is the eye of the Supreme Lord." (Bs. 5.52) Actually, without the sun we cannot see. We may be very proud of our eyes, but we cannot even see our next-door neighbor. People challenge, "Can you show me God?" But what can they see? What is the value of their eyes? God is not cheap. We cannot see anything, not to speak of God without sunshine. Without sunlight we are blind. At night, we cannot see anything, and therefore we use electricity because the sun is not present.

There is not only one sun in the universe, but there are millions and trillions of suns. That is also stated in the Brahma-saàhitä: yasya prabhä prabhavato jagadaëòa koöi. (Bs. 5.40) The spiritual bodily effulgence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is called the brahmajyoti, and in that brahmajyoti there are countless planets. Just as within the sunshine there are innumerable planets, similarly, in the shining effulgence of the body of Kåñëa there are innumerable planets. We have knowledge of many universes, and in each universe there is a sun. Thus there are millions and billions of universes and millions and billions of suns and moons and planets. But Kåñëa says that if one tries to go to one of these planets, he will simply waste his time.

Now someone has gone to the moon, but what will human society gain from it? If, after spending so much money, so much energy and ten years of effort, one goes to the moon and simply touches it, what is the benefit of that? One can remain there and call his friends to come, but even if one goes there and remains, what will be the benefit? As long as we are in this material world, either on this planet or other planets, the same miseries—birth, death, old age and disease—will follow us. We cannot rid ourselves of them.

If we go to live on the moon—assuming it is possible—even with an oxygen mask, how long could we stay? Furthermore, even if we had the opportunity to stay there, what would we gain? We might gain a little longer life perhaps, but we could not live there forever. That is impossible. And what would we gain by a longer life? Are not the trees living for many, many years? Near San Francisco I have seen a forest where there is a tree 7,000 years old. But what is the benefit? If one is proud of standing in one place for 7,000 years, that is not a very great credit.

How one goes to the moon, how he comes back, etc., is a great story, and this is all described in the Vedic literature. It is not a very new process. But the aim of our Kåñëa consciousness society is, different. We are not going to waste our valuable time. Kåñëa says, "Don’t waste your time attempting to go to this planet or to that planet. What will you gain? Your material miseries will follow you wherever you go." Therefore, in the Caitanya-caritämåta it is very nicely said by the author, "In this material world someone is enjoying and someone is not enjoying, but actually everyone is suffering, although some people think that they are enjoying, whereas others realize that they are suffering." Actually everyone is suffering. Who in this material world does not suffer disease? Who does not suffer from old age? Who does not die? No one wants to grow old or suffer from disease, but everyone must do so. Where then is the enjoyment? This enjoyment is all nonsense because within this material world there is no enjoyment. It is simply our imagination. One should not think, "This is enjoyment, and this is suffering." Everything is suffering! Therefore, it is stated in the Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 3.97], "The principles of eating, sleeping, mating and defending will always exist, but they will exist in different standards." For example, the Americans have taken birth in America as a result of pious activities performed in previous lifetimes. In India the people are poverty-stricken and are suffering, but although the Americans are eating very nicely buttered bread and the Indians are eating without butter, they are both eating nevertheless. The fact that India is poverty-stricken has not caused the whole population to die for want of food. The four principal bodily demands-eating, sleeping, mating and defending—can be satisfied under any circumstances, whether one is born in an impious condition or in a pious condition. The problem, however, is how to become free from the four principles of birth, death, old age and disease.

This is the real problem. It is not "What shall I eat?" The birds and beasts have no such problem. In the morning they are immediately chanting, "Jee, jee, jee, jee." They know that they will have their food. No one is dying, and there is no such thing as overpopulation because everyone is provided for by God’s arrangement. There are qualitative differences, but obtaining a superior quality of material enjoyment is not the end of life. The real problem is how to get free of birth, death, old age and disease. This cannot be solved by simply wasting time traveling within this universe. Even if one goes to the highest planet, this problem cannot be solved, for there is death everywhere.

The duration of life on the moon, according to Vedic information, is 10,000 years, and one day there is equal to six months here. Thus 10,000 multiplied by 150 years is the duration of life on the moon. However, it is impossible for earth men to go to the moon and live there for very long. Otherwise the whole Vedic literature would be false. We can attempt to go there, but it is not possible to live there. This knowledge is in the Vedas. Therefore, we are not very eager to go to this planet or that planet. We are eager to go directly to the planet where Kåñëa lives. Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä [9.25], "One can go to the moon, or one can even go to the sun or to millions and trillions of other planets, or if one is too materially attached he may remain here—but those who are My devotees will come to Me." This is our aim. Initiation into Kåñëa consciousness insures that the student ultimately can go to the supreme planet, Kåñëaloka. We are not working idly; we are also attempting to go to other planets, but we are not merely wasting time.

A sane and intelligent man does not wish to enter any of the material planets because the four conditions of material miseries exist on all of them. From Bhagavad-gétä we can understand that even if we enter Brahmaloka, the highest planetary system of this universe, the four principles of misery will be present. We learn from Bhagavad-gétä that the duration of one day on Brahmaloka is millions of years of our calculation. That is a fact.

Even the highest planetary system, Brahmaloka, may be reached, but scientists say that it will take 40,000 years at sputnik speed. Who is prepared to travel in space for 40,000 years? From the Vedic literature we can understand that we can enter any of the planets, provided we prepare for that purpose. If one prepares himself to enter into the higher planetary systems, which are said to be inhabited by demigods, he can go there. Similarly, one can go to a lower planetary system, or if one desires he can remain on this planet. Finally, if one desires, he can enter the planet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is all a matter of preparation. However, all planetary systems within our material universe are temporary. The duration of life on certain material planets may be very long, but all living entities in the material universe are eventually subject to annihilation and have to again develop other bodies. There are different types of bodies. A human body exists 100 years, whereas an insect body may exist for twelve years. Thus the duration of these different bodies is relative. If one enters the planet called Vaikuëöhaloka, the spiritual planet, however, he then achieves eternal life, full of bliss and knowledge. A human being can attain that perfection if he tries. That is stated in Bhagavad-gétä when the Lord says, "Anyone who knows in truth about the Supreme Personality of Godhead can attain to My nature."

Many people claim, "God is great," but this is a hackneyed phrase. One must know how He is great, and that can be known from authorized scripture. In the Bhagavad-gétä God describes Himself. He says, "My appearance of taking birth just like an ordinary human being is actually transcendental." God is so kind that He comes before us as an ordinary human being, but His body is not exactly like a human body. Those rascals who do not know about Him think that Kåñëa is like one of us. That is also stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

avajänanti mäà müòhä

mänuñéà tanum äçritam

paraà bhävam ajänanto

mama bhüta-maheçvaram

"Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and My supreme dominion over all that be." (Bg. 9.11) We have a chance to know about Kåñëa provided we read the right literature under the right direction, and if we simply know what the nature of God is, then by understanding this one fact alone we become liberated. It is not possible in our human condition to understand the Absolute Supreme Personality of Godhead completely, but with the help of Bhagavad-gétä the statements given by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and of the spiritual master, we can know Him to the best of our capacity. If we can know Him in reality, then immediately after leaving this body we can enter into the kingdom of God. Kåñëa says, tyaktvä dehaà punar janma na eti mämeté kaunteya: "After leaving this body, one who is in knowledge does not come again to this material world, for he enters into the spiritual world and comes to Me." (Bg. 4.9)

The purpose of our Kåñëa consciousness movement is to propagate this advanced scientific idea to people in general, and the process is very simple. Simply by chanting the holy names of God—Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare—one cleanses the dirt from his heart and gains understanding that he is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord and that it is his duty to serve Him. This process is very pleasant: we chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra, we dance rhythmically, and we eat nice prasädam. While enjoying this life, we are preparing to enter into the kingdom of God in our next life. This is not a fabrication—it is all factual. Although to a layman this appears to be a fabrication, Kåñëa reveals Himself from within to one who is serious about God realization. Both Kåñëa and the spiritual master help the sincere soul. The spiritual master is the external manifestation of God, who is situated in everyone’s heart as Supersoul. For one who is very serious about understanding the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Supersoul immediately renders assistance by directing him to a bona fide spiritual master. In this way the spiritual candidate is helped from within and without.

According to the Bhägavata Puräëa [1.2.11], the Supreme Truth is realized in three stages. First there is impersonal Brahman or the impersonal Absolute; then the Paramätmä or localized aspect of Brahman. The neutron of the atom may be taken as the representation of Paramätmä, who also enters into the atom. This is described in the Brahma-saàhitä. But ultimately the Supreme Divine Being is realized as the supreme all-attractive person (Kåñëa) with full and inconceivable potencies of opulence, strength, fame, beauty, knowledge and renunciation. These six potencies are fully exhibited by Çré Räma and Çré Kåñëa when They descend before human beings. Only a section of human beings—the unalloyed devotees—can recognize Kåñëa on the authority of revealed scriptures, but others are bewildered by the influence of material energy. The Absolute Truth is therefore the Absolute Person who has no equal or competitor. The impersonal Brahman rays are the rays of His transcendental body, just as the sun’s rays are emanations from the sun.

According to the Viñëu Puräëa [6.7.61], the material energy is called avidyä, or nescience, and is exhibited in the fruitive activities of sense enjoyment. But although the living being has the tendency to be illusioned and trapped by the material energy for sense enjoyment, he belongs to the anti-material energy or spiritual energy. In this sense the living being is the positive energy, whereas matter is the negative energy. Matter does not develop unless in contact with the superior spiritual or anti-material energy, which is directly part and parcel of the spiritual whole. The subject matter of this spiritual energy exhibited by living beings is undoubtedly very complicated for an ordinary man, who is therefore astounded by the subject. Sometimes he partially understands it through the imperfect senses, and sometimes he fails to know it altogether. It is best, therefore, to hear from the highest authority, Çré Kåñëa, or from His devotee who represents Him in the chain of disciplic succession.

This Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant for the purpose of understanding God. The spiritual master is the living representative of Kåñëa who helps externally, and Kåñëa as Supersoul helps internally. The living entity can take advantage of such guidance and make his life successful. We request that everyone read authoritative literature in order to understand this movement. We have published Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, Teachings of Lord Caitanya, Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Kåñëa and The Nectar of Devotion. We are also publishing our magazine Back to Godhead every month in many languages. Our mission is to save human society from the pitfalls of incarnating again in the cycle of birth and death.

Everyone should attempt to go to Kåñëa. We have published an article in our Back to Godhead magazine entitled "Beyond the Universe." This article describes a place beyond this universe according to knowledge which is in Bhagavad-gétä. Bhagavad-gétä is a very popular book, and there are many editions of it in America and also many from India. Unfortunately, however, many rascals have come to the West to preach Bhagavad-gétä. They are designated as rascals because they are bluffers who do not give real information. In our Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, however, the spiritual nature is authoritatively described.

This cosmic manifestation is called nature, but there is another nature, which is superior. The cosmic manifestation is inferior nature, but beyond this nature, which is manifested and unmanifested, there is another nature, which is called sanätana, eternal. It is easy to understand that everything manifested here is temporary. The obvious example is our body. If one is thirty years old, thirty years ago his body was not manifested, and in another fifty years it will again be unmanifested. That is a factual law of nature. It is manifested and again annihilated, just as waves in the sea rise frequently and then recede. The materialist, however, is simply concerned with this mortal life, which can be finished at any moment. Furthermore, as this body will die, so the entire universe, this gigantic material body, will be annihilated, and whether we are fortunate or unfortunate, on this planet or another planet, everything will be finished. Why then are we wasting our time trying to go to a planet where everything will be finished? We should try to go to Kåñëaloka. This is spiritual science; we must try to understand it, and, after understanding it ourselves, we should preach this message to the whole world. Everyone is in darkness. Although people have no knowledge, they are very proud. But it is not advancement of knowledge to go to the moon after ten years of effort and take a rock and come back. The space travelers are very proud: "Oh, I have touched it." But what have they gained? Even if we were able to live there, it would not be for long. It will all be destroyed in the end.

Try to find that planet from which one will never return, where there is eternal life, and where one can dance with Kåñëa. This is the meaning of Kåñëa consciousness. Take this movement seriously, for Kåñëa consciousness gives one a chance to reach Kåñëa and to dance with Him eternally. From Vedic literature we understand that this material world is a manifestation of only one fourth of the complete creation of God. The three-fourths portion of God’s creation is the spiritual world. That we find in Bhagavad-gétä. Kåñëa says, "This material world is but a fractional part of the whole." If we look as far as we can see—up to the sky—our vision is still confined within only one universe, and there are unlimited universes clustered together within what is called the material world. Beyond those clusters of unlimited numbers of universes, there is the spiritual sky, which is also mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä. The Lord says that beyond the material world There is another nature, which is eternal; there is no history of its beginning, and it has no end. "Eternal" refers to that which has no end and no beginning. The Vedic religion is therefore called eternal because no one can trace back when it began. The Christian religion has a history of 2,000 years, and the Mohammedan religion has a history of 5,000 years; but if one traced back Vedic religion, he would not find its historical beginning. Therefore it is called eternal religion.

We may rightly say that God created this material world, and this indicates that God existed before the creation. This very word "created" suggests that before the creation of the cosmic manifestation, the Lord was existing. Therefore God is not under the creation. If God were under the creation, how could He create? He would then be one of the objects of this material creation. God is not under the creation; He is the creator, and therefore He is eternal.

There is a spiritual sky where there are innumerable spiritual planets and innumerable spiritual living entities, but those who are not fit to live in that spiritual world are sent to this material world. The same idea is expressed in Milton’s Paradise Lost. Voluntarily we have accepted this material body, but actually we are spirit souls who should not have accepted it. When and how we accepted it cannot be traced. No one can trace the history of when the conditioned soul first accepted the material body. There are 8,400,000 forms of living entities—900,000 species of living entities are within the water, and 2,000,000 species of life are among the plants and vegetables. Unfortunately, this Vedic knowledge is not instructed by any university. But these are facts. Let the botanist and anthropologist research into the Vedic conclusion. Darwin’s theory of the evolution of organic matter is, of course, very prominent in the learning institutions. But the Bhägavata Puräëa and other authoritative scriptures of scientific magnitude describe how the living entities in different forms of body evolve one after another. It is not a new idea. But educators are giving stress only to Darwin’s theory, although in Vedic literature we have immense information of the living conditions in this material world.

We are only a fractional portion of all the living entities in the many universes of the material world. Those who are in the material world and material body are condemned. For example, the population in prison is condemned by the government, but their number is only a fraction of the whole population. It is not that the whole population goes to prison. Some, who are disobedient, are confined in prison. Similarly, the conditioned souls within this material world are only a fraction of all the living entities in the creation of God, and because they have disobeyed God—they did not abide by the order of Kåñëa—they have been put into this material world. If one is sensible and inquisitive, he should try to understand: "Why have I been put into this conditional life? I do not wish to suffer."

There are three kinds of suffering, including miseries pertaining to the body and mind. In Hawaii, in front of my house, a man was keeping some animals and birds for the purpose of taking them to be slaughtered. I gave this example to my students: "These animals are standing here, and if you tell them, ‘Oh, my dear animals, why are you standing here? Go away! You are meant for the slaughterhouse,’ they cannot go. They have no intelligence."

Suffering without knowledge, without remedy, is animal life. One who cannot understand that he is suffering and who thinks that he is very well off is in animal consciousness, not human consciousness. The human should be cognizant of suffering the threefold miseries of this planet. One should know that he is suffering in birth, suffering in death, suffering in old age and suffering in disease, and one should be inquisitive as to how he may avoid the suffering. That is real research work.

We have suffered from the beginning of our birth. As a baby, the human is tightly placed in the abdomen of the mother in an airtight bag for nine months. He cannot even move, there are insects biting him, and he cannot protest. After the child comes out, the suffering continues. The mother undoubtedly takes much care, but still the child cries because he is suffering. There are bugs biting or there are pains in his stomach; the child is crying, and the mother does not know how to pacify him. His suffering begins in the womb of his mother. Then, after his birth, as he grows up, there is more suffering. He does not want to go to school, but he is forced to. He does not want to study, but the teacher gives him tasks. If we analyze our life, we will find that it is full of suffering. Why then are we coming here? The conditioned souls are not very bright. We should inquire, "Why am I suffering?" If there is a remedy" we must take advantage of it.

We are eternally connected with the Supreme Lord, but somehow or other we are now in material contamination. Therefore, we must take up a process to go back again to the spiritual world. That linking process is called yoga. The actual translation of the word yoga is "plus," which is just the opposite of minus. At the present moment we are minus God, or minus the Supreme. When we make ourselves plus—connected—then our human form of life is perfected. During our lifetime we have to practice approaching that point of perfection, and at the time of death, when we give up this material body, that perfection has to be realized. At the time of death, one must be prepared. Students, for instance, prepare for two to five years in college, and the final test of their education is the examination. If they pass the examination, they get a degree. Similarly, in the subject of life, if we prepare for the examination at the time of death and pass it, then we are transferred to the spiritual world. Everything is examined at the time of death.

There is a very common Bengali proverb that says that whatever one does for perfection will be tested at the time of his death. Bhagavad-gétä describes what we should do at the point of our death, when we are giving up this present body. For the dyana-yogé (meditator) Çré Kåñëa speaks the following verses:

yad akñaraà veda-vido vadanti

viçanti yad yatayo véta-rägäù

yad icchanto brahmacaryaà caranti

tat te padaà saìgraheëa pravakñye

sarva-dväräëi saàyamya

mano hådi nirudhya ca

mürdhny ädhäyätmanaù präëam

ästhito yoga-dhäraëäm

"Persons learned in the Vedas, who utter omkara and who are great sages in the renounced order, enter into Brahman. Desiring such perfection, one practices celibacy. I shall now explain to you this process by which one may attain salvation. The yogic situation is that of detachment from all sensual engagements. Closing all the doors of the senses and fixing the mind on the heart and the life air at the top of the head, one establishes himself in yoga." (Bg. 8.11-12) In the yoga system this process is called pratyähära, which means, in technical language, "the opposite." Now the eyes are engaged in seeing worldly beauty, so one has to withdraw them enjoying that beauty and concentrate on seeing beauty inside. That is called pratyähära. Similarly, one has to hear the omkara sound from within.

oà ity ekäkñaraà brahma-

vyäharan mäm anusmaran

yaù prayäti tyajan dehaà

sa yäti paramäà gatim

"After being situated in this yoga practice and vibrating the sacred syllable om, the supreme combination of letters, if one thinks of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and quits his body, he will certainly reach the spiritual planets." (Bg. 8.13) In this way all the senses have to be stopped in their external activities, and the mind must be concentrated on vimumurti, the form of Lord Viñëu. That is the perfection of yoga. The mind is very turbulent, so it has to be fixed upon the heart. When the mind is fixed within the heart and the life air is transferred to the top of the head, one can attain the perfection of yoga.

The perfect yogé then determines where he is to go. There are innumerable material planets, and beyond these planets there is the spiritual world. Yogés have this information from Vedic scriptures. For example, before I came to the United States I read descriptions of it from books. Similarly, a description of the higher planets and the spiritual world can be found in the Vedic scriptures. The yogé knows everything; he can transfer himself to any planet he likes. He does not need the help of spacecraft.

Material scientists have been trying for many years, and they will go on trying for 100 or 1,000 years more, but they will never reach any planet. Maybe by a scientific process one or two men can reach some planet, but that is not the general process. The generally accepted process for transferral to other planets is the practice of the yoga system or the jïäna system. The bhakti system, however, is not meant for transferral to any material planet. Those who engage in the devotional service of Kåñëa or the Supreme Lord are not interested in any of the planets of this material world because they know that no matter to which planet one elevates himself, he will still find the four principles of material existence there nonetheless. On some planets the duration of life is much longer than on this earth, but death is there. Those who are Kåñëa conscious, however, transcend this material life of birth, death, disease and old age.

Spiritual life means release from this botheration and misery. Those who are intelligent, therefore, do not try to elevate themselves to any planet of this material world. Men are trying to reach the moon, and although it is very difficult to gain entrance to that planet, if we do gain entrance the period of our lives will be enhanced. Of course that does not apply to life in this body. If we were to enter the moon with this body, instant death would be certain.

When one enters into a planetary system, he must have a suitable body for that planet. Every planet is inhabitated by living entities with bodies suitable for that planet. For instance, we can enter the water in this body, but we cannot live there. We may stay there fifteen or sixteen hours, or maybe twenty-four hours, but that’s all. Aquatic animals, however, have particular bodies suitable for living their whole lives in water. Similarly, if one takes a fish out of water and puts it on the land, it will die instantly. As we understand that even on this planet there are different kinds of bodies for living in particular places, so, similarly, if we want to enter another planet, we have to prepare ourselves to get a suitable body.

If one transfers himself and his soul transmigrates to the moon by this yogic process, he gets a long duration of life. On the higher planets, six of our months equal one day. Thus the beings there live for 10,000years. That is the description in the Vedic literature. So undoubtedly one can get a very long duration of life, but still there is death. After 10,000 or 20,000 years, or even after millions of years (it does not matter), death comes.

Actually, we are not subject to death. That is affirmed in the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä: na hanyate hanyamäne çarére (Bg. 2.20). We are spirit soul, and therefore, we are eternal. Why then should we subject ourselves to death and birth? It is intelligent to think in this way. Those who are Kåñëa conscious are very intelligent because they are not interested in getting promotion to any planet where there is death, despite a long duration of life there. Rather, they want to get a body like God’s. Éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù. God’s body is sac-cid-änanda. Sat means eternal, and cit means full of knowledge. Änanda means full of pleasure.

As stated in our pamphlet "Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure," if we transfer ourselves to the spiritual world, to Kåñëa’s planet or to any other spiritual planet, then we will get a body similar to God’s: sac-cid-änanda—eternal, full of knowledge and full of bliss. So those who try to be Kåñëa conscious have a different aim of life than those who are trying to promote themselves to the better planets in this material world. Lord Kåñëa says, mürdhny ädhäyätmanaù präëam ästhito yoga-dhäraëäm: "The perfection of yoga is to transfer oneself to the spiritual world." (Bg. 8.12)

The spirit soul is a minute particle within the body. We cannot see it. One practices the yoga system to raise the soul to the topmost part of the head. This practice goes on while one is living, and the perfection is reached when one can place himself on the top of the head and then break through. Then he can transfer himself to whatever higher planets he likes. That is the perfection of the yogé.

If the yogé is inquisitive to see the moon, he can say, "Ah, let me see what the moon is like. Then I shall transfer myself to higher planets," just like travelers who go to Europe, California, Canada, or other countries on earth. One can transfer oneself to many planets by this yoga system, but anywhere he goes he will find visa systems and customs systems. To go to other planets, one must be qualified.

Kåñëa conscious persons are not interested in any temporary planet, even if it offers a long duration of life. If the yogé, at the time of death, can pronounce "om," the concise form of transcendental vibration, and at the same time mäm anusmaran, remember Kåñëa, Viñëu, he will attain perfection. The purpose of the entire yoga system is to concentrate the mind on Viñëu. Impersonalists imagine that they see the form of Viñëu or the Lord, but those who are personalists do not imagine this—they actually see the form of the Supreme Lord. Either way, if one concentrates his mind through imagination or if one actually sees, one has to concentrate his mind on the Viñëu form. Mäm means unto the Supreme Lord Viñëu. Anyone who leaves this body and concentrates his mind on Viñëu enters into the spiritual kingdom after quitting his body. Those who are actually yogés do not desire to enter any other planet because they know that there is temporary life on the temporary planets, and thus they are not interested. That is intelligence.

Those who are satisfied with temporary happiness, temporary life and temporary facilities are not intelligent according to Bhagavad-gétä. Antavat tu phalaà teñäà tad bhavaty alpa-medhasäm: "One whose brain substance is very meager is interested in temporary things." (Bg. 7.23) That is the version of Çrémad-Bhagavad-gétä. I am eternal, so why should I be interested in nonpermanent things? Who wants nonpermanent existence? No one wants it. If we are living in an apartment and the landlord asks us to vacate, we are sorry, but we are not sorry if we move to a better apartment. This then is our inclination. We do not wish to die because we are eternal.

The material atmosphere is robbing us of our eternality. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam says, "Our duration of life is being diminished by the sun, beginning from its rising until the time it sets." Daily we are losing the duration of our lives. If the sun rises at 5:30 in the morning, at 5:30 in the evening twelve, hours have been taken away from the duration of our lives. We will never get this time back. If we ask any scientist, "I will give you twelve million dollars. Please give me back these twelve hours," he will reply. "No, it is not possible." The scientist cannot do it. Therefore the Bhägavatam says that from sunrise to sunset the duration of our lives is being diminished.

Time is called käla—past, present, and future. What is now present, tomorrow will be past, and what is now future, tomorrow will be present. But this past, present and future are the past, present and future of the body. We do not belong to the category of the past, present and future. We belong to the category of eternity. Therefore one should be concerned with how to attain or how to be elevated to the platform of eternity. The developed consciousness of the human being should be utilized not in the animal propensities of eating, sleeping, mating and defending but in searching out the valuable path which will help him get that life of eternity. It is said that the sun is taking away our duration of life—every minute, every hour, every day—but if we engage ourselves in the topics of Uttama-çloka, the topics of the Lord, that time cannot be taken away. The time which one devotes in a Kåñëa consciousness temple cannot be taken away. It is an asset—a plus, not a minus. The duration of life, so far as the body is concerned, may be taken; however one tries to keep it intact, no one can do it. But the spiritual education which we receive in Kåñëa consciousness cannot be taken away by the sun. It becomes a solid asset.

Chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is a very easy thing to do. Time spent chanting cannot be taken away like time pertaining to the body. Fifty years ago I was a young man, but that time has been taken and cannot be returned. The spiritual knowledge which I received from my spiritual master, however, cannot be taken away but will go with me. Even after I quit this body, it will go with me; and if it is perfect in this life, then it will take me to the eternal abode.

Both the material and spiritual worlds belong to Kåñëa. We are not proprietors of anything. It is all the property of the Supreme Lord, just as everything in the state belongs to the government either in the prison house or outside the prison house. Conditioned life is just like life in a prison house in this material world. A prisoner cannot freely change from one cell to another. In free life one can go from one home to another home, but in prison life one cannot do that but must stay in his cell. All these planets are like cells. We are trying to go to the moon, but it is not practical by mechanical means. Whether we are American, Indian, Chinese or Russian, we have been given this planet to live on.We cannot leave-although there are millions and billions of planets and although we have machines by which we can—because we are conditioned by the laws of nature, God’s laws. A man who is put into a certain cell cannot change at will without superior authority. Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä that one should not try to change from one cell to another. That will not make anyone happy. If a prisoner thinks, "I am in this cell—let me request the warden to change my cell, and I will be happy," that is a mistaken idea. One cannot be happy so long as he is within the prison walls. We are trying to be happy by changing cells—from capitalism to communism. The aim should be to become free from this "ism" and that "ism." One has to change completely from this "ism" of materialism, then he can become happy. That is the program of Kåñëa consciousness.

We are taking advice from the Supreme Person. He says, "My dear Arjuna, you may be elevated to the highest planetary sytem, which is called Brahmaloka and is desirable because life there is very long." We cannot calculate even a half-day there. It is beyond our mathematical calculations. But even in Brahmaloka there is death. Therefore Kåñëa says, "Do not waste your time trying to elevate yourself or transfer yourself from this planet to that planet."

The people I have seen in America are very restless. They go from one apartment to another apartment or from one country to another country. That restlessness is there because , we are searching after our real home. To go from this place to that place will not give eternal life. Eternal life is with Kåñëa. Therefore Kåñëa says, "Everything belongs to Me, and I have the superexcellent abode, which is called Goloka Våndävana." If one wants to go there, he must simply become Kåñëa conscious and try to understand how Kåñëa appears and disappears, what His constitutional position is, what our constitutional position is, what our relationship with Him is, and how to live. Simply try to understand these ideas scientifically. Everything in Kåñëa consciousness is scientific. It is not bogus, whimsical, sentimental, fanatical or imaginative. It is truth, fact, reality. One must understand Kåñëa in truth.

We have to give up this body, willingly or unwillingly. The day will come when we will have to submit to the laws of nature and give up this body. Even President Kennedy in his procession had to submit to nature’s law and change his body for another body. He could not say, "Oh, I am the President; I am Mr. Kennedy. I cannot do that." He was forced to do it. That is the way that nature works.

The purpose of our developed human consciousness is to understand how nature works. Aside from human consciousness, there is consciousness in dogs, cats, worms, trees, birds, beasts and all other species. But we are not meant to live in that consciousness. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam [4.29.1a] says that after many, many births we have attained the human form of body. Now we should not misuse it. Please utilize this human life to develop Kåñëa consciousness and be happy.

EJ'70:Glossary

Glossary

PHILOSOPHY

One can attempt to go to any planet he desires, but this is only possible by psychological changes in the mind or by yogic powers. Mind is the nucleus of the material body. Anyone who trains the mind to turn from matter to the spiritual form of the Godhead by performance of bhakti-yoga can easily attain the kingdom of God in the anti-material sky. Of this there is no doubt.

COLLIER BOOKS

866 THIRD AVENUE,

NEW YORK. N.Y. 10022

Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness (1973)

OTHER BOOKS

by His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 1-3 (6 Vols.)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
The Nectar of Devotion
Çré Éçopaniñad
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 Vols.)
Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäräj
Transcendental Teachings of Caitanya Mahäprabhu
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
The Perfection of Yoga
Beyond Birth and Death
On the Way to Kåñëa
Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge
Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)
A complete catalogue is available upon request.


ALL GLORY TO ÇRÉ GURU AND GAURÄÌGA


Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness
His Divine Grace AC. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI PRABHUPÄDA
Founder-Äcärya International Society for Krishna Consciousness
THE BHAKTIVEDANTA BOOK TRUST
New York . Los Angeles . London . Bombay


Readers interested in the subject matter of this book are invited by the International Society for Krishna Consciousness to correspond with its Secretary.
International Society for Krishna Consciousness 3959 Landmark Street Culver City, California 90230
© 1973 the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust.
All rights reserved
First Printing, 1973:
100,000
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 73-76635 International Standard Book Number: 0-912776-43-9
Printed in the United States of America by ISKCON Press

EK 1: Choosing Human and Animal Lives

1
Choosing Human and Animal Lives

[source: 690423LE.BUF]

om ajïäna-timirändasya jïänäïjana-çaläkayä
cakñur unmélitaà yena tasmai çré-gurave namaù

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto my spiritual master, who has opened my eyes, blinded by the darkness of ignorance, with the torchlight of knowledge." [Gautaméya Tantra]

It is customary with this verse to offer obeisances to the spiritual master who enlightens his disciples in the matter of transcendental knowledge. The Vedic process does not involve research work. In mundane scholarship, we have to show our academic learning by some research, but the Vedic process is different. In the Vedic process the research work is already done; it is complete, and it is simply handed down by disciplic succession from teacher to student. There is no question of research work because the instruments and the means with which one conducts such research work are blunt and imperfect.

At this stage of our material existence, we are conditioned by many laws of nature. All conditioned souls are subject to four defects due to the imperfection of their senses. One defect is that the conditioned soul is certain to commit mistakes. There is no man who does not commit mistakes. In India, for instance, Mahätmä Gandhi was supposed to be a very great personality, but he also committed mistakes. Five minutes before he came to the meeting at which he was killed, he was warned by confidential associates not to go, but he persisted. To commit mistakes is very natural in the conditioned state of life. Indeed, the popular saying has arisen: "To err is human."

Another imperfection of the conditioned soul is that he is sure to be illusioned. Being illusioned means accepting something which is not, taking some phantasmagoria to be factual. Every one of us is under the impression that we are these bodies, but actually we are not. Accepting the body to be the self is called illusion, or mäyä. The third imperfection is that conditioned souls have a tendency to cheat. We have often heard a storekeeper say, "Because you are my friend, I won't make any profit off you." But in actuality we know that he is making at least 50% profit. There are so many instances of this cheating propensity. There are also many examples of teachers who actually know nothing but put forth theories in words like "perhaps" or "it may be," while in actuality they are simply cheating their students. The fourth imperfection is that the senses of the living entity are not perfect. Our vision is so limited that we cannot see very far away nor very near. The eye can see only under certain conditions, and therefore it is understood that our vision is limited. Similarly, all our other senses are also limited. It is not possible to understand the unlimited by these imperfect, limited senses.

The conclusion is that the Vedic process does not encourage us to endeavor to learn the Absolute Truth by employing our present senses, which are conditioned in so many ways. If we are to have knowledge, it must come from a superior source which is not conditioned by these four imperfections. That source is Kåñëa. He is the supreme authority of Bhagavad-gétä, and He is accepted as the perfect authority by so many saints and sages.

Those who are serious students of Vedic literature accept authority. Bhagavad-gétä, for example, is not a scholarly presentation which arose out of so much research work. It is perfect knowledge that was taught by Lord Kåñëa to Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, and we receive information from it that in previous ages Çré Kåñëa also taught it to the sun-god Vivasvän, and it was handed down from time immemorial from Vivasvän by disciplic succession.

imaà vivasvate yogaà
proktavän aham avyayam
vivasvän manave präha
manur ikñväkave 'bravét

"The Blessed Lord said: I instructed this imperishable science of yoga to the sun-god Vivasvän, and Vivasvän instructed it to Manu, the father of mankind, and Manu in turn instructed it to Ikñväku." (Bg. 4.1)

If we study Bhagavad-gétä according to academic knowledge or according to our own mental speculation, we are certain to commit mistakes. It is not possible to understand Bhagavad-gétä in this way. It is necessary to follow carefully in the footsteps of Arjuna. In previous ages, due to interpretation and mental speculation, the real purport of Bhagavad-gétä was lost; therefore Kåñëa re-established the teachings by giving them to Arjuna.

evaà paramparä-präptam
imaà räjarñayo viduù
sa käleneha mahatä
yogo nañöaù parantapa

sa eväyaà mayä te 'dya
yogaù proktaù purätanaù
bhakto 'si me sakhä ceti
rahasyaà hy etad uttamam

"This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way. But in course of time the succession was broken, and therefore the science as it is appears to be lost. That very ancient science of the relationship with the Supreme is today told by Me to you because you are My devotee as well as My friend; therefore, you can understand the transcendental mystery of this science." (Bg. 4.2-3)

Thus whoever follows in the footsteps of Arjuna, approaching Kåñëa in a spirit of devotion, can understand the purpose of Bhagavad-gétä as well as all other Vedic literatures.

There are four Vedas—Säma, Åk, Yajur and Atharva, and there are 108 Upaniñads, including the Éçopaniñad, Kaöha Upaniñad and Taittiréya Upaniñad, as well as the Vedänta-sütra, Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä. These literatures are not meant for any particular class of men but for the totality of human society. All societies can take advantage of Vedic knowledge to perfect human life. As pointed out before, human life is not meant for sense gratification, but for understanding God, the universe and our own identity.

From Vedic literatures we can understand that this material world is only a partial manifestation of the complete creation of God. The larger portion of God's creation is found in the spiritual world of the Vaikuëöhas. Above and beyond this material nature there is a superior spiritual nature, as Çré Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

apareyam itas tv anyäà
prakåtià viddhi me paräm
jéva-bhütäà mahä-bäho
yayedaà dhäryate jagat

"Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego—altogether these eight comprise My separated material energies. Besides this inferior nature, O mighty Arjuna, there is a superior energy of Mine which is all living entities who are struggling with material nature and sustaining the universe." (Bg. 7.4-5)

There are many material universes clustered together, and all these universes constitute the material creation. Beyond these clusters of countless material universes is the spiritual sky, which is also mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä.

na tad bhäsayate süryo
na çaçäìko na pävakaù
yad gatvä na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"That abode of Mine is not illumined by the sun or moon, nor by electricity. And anyone who reaches it never comes back to this material world." (Bg. 15.6)

That superior nature which is beyond this material nature is eternal. There is no history of its ever having begun; it has neither beginning nor end.

paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo
'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù
yaù sa sarveñu bhüteñu
naçyatsu na vinaçyati

avyakto 'kñara ity uktas
tam ähuù paramäà gatim
yaà präpya na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"There is another, eternal nature, which is transcendental to this manifested and non-manifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is. That supreme status is called unmanifested and infallible, and is the highest destination. Going there, one never returns from that, My supreme abode." (Bg. 8.20-21)

The Vedic religion, or varëäçrama-dharma, is also called eternal because no one can trace out its beginning. The Christian religion has a history of 2,000 years, and the Mohammedan religion has a history of 1,300 years, but if we try to trace out the origins of Vedic religion, we will not be able to find a beginning. Varëäçrama-dharma is accepted as the eternal religion of the living entity.

We often say that God created this material world, and this means that God existed before the world. Since the Lord was existing before this material manifestation, He is not subject to this creation. If He were subject to the laws of the material world, how could He have created it? That the Lord is simultaneously identical with His creation and yet exists in His completeness apart from it is stated in Bhagavad-gétä.

mayä tatam idaà sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
ma cähaà teñv avasthitaù

na ca mat-sthäni bhütäni
paçya me yogam aiçvaram
bhüta-bhån na ca bhüta-stho
mamätmä bhüta-bhävanaù

"In My transcendental form I pervade all this creation. All things are resting in Me, but I am not in them. Again, everything that is created does not rest on Me. Behold My mystic opulence: Although I am the maintainer of all living entities, and although I am everywhere, still My Self is the very source of creation." (Bg. 9.4-5)

Actually we are all spirit souls and are intended to associate with God in the spiritual sky where there are innumerable spiritual planets and innumerable spiritual living entities. However, those who are not fit to live in that spiritual world are sent to this material world. This very idea is expressed by Milton in Paradise Lost. Although spirit soul, we have voluntarily accepted this material body and by accepting it have also accepted the threefold miseries of material nature. Exactly when we accepted it and how we accepted it cannot be traced out. No one can trace out the history of when the conditioned soul first began accepting these material bodies.

At present Darwin's theory of the evolution of organic matter is very prominent in institutions of higher learning, but there is information given in the Padma Puräëa and other authoritative scriptures of the living entities' spiritual evolution from one bodily form to another. This Puräëa informs us that there are 8,400,000 forms of living entities, 900,000 of which live within water. There are 2,000,000 species amongst plants and vegetables alone. At present everyone is giving stress to Darwin's theory, but in Vedic literature there is immense information about the different species. Darwin expresses the opinion that the species are evolving from lower forms of life, but this is not the whole truth. The soul may progress from lower forms to higher forms, but in the beginning of creation all species were created by Çré Kåñëa, as indicated in Bhagavad-gétä.

sarva-bhütäni kaunteya
prakåtià yänti mämikäm
kalpa-kñaye punas täni
kalpädau visåjämy aham

prakåtià sväm avañöabhya
visåjämi punaù punaù
bhüta-grämam imaà kåtsnam
avaçaà prakåter vaçät

"O son of Kunté, at the end of the millennium every material manifestation enters unto My nature, and at the beginning of another millennium, by My potency I again create. The whole cosmic order is under Me. By My will is it manifested again and again, and by My will is it annihilated at the end." (Bg. 9.7-8)

All of these living entities are subject to the threefold miseries, including those miseries pertaining to the body and mind. Animals cannot understand that they are suffering, but human beings can. One who does not know that he is suffering is in animal consciousness. Animals may be standing behind a fence to be slaughtered, but they do not understand this. As human beings, we should be cognizant that we are suffering the pains of birth, old age, disease and death and should be inquisitive to know how to avoid these miseries. We have been suffering from the beginning of our birth when as a baby we were tightly placed for nine months in the womb of a mother. After birth, suffering continues; although a mother may take much care for her child, the baby still cries. Why? Because he is suffering. Either a bug is biting, or there is a pain in the stomach or some other malady. Whatever the case, the suffering goes on. The child also suffers when he is forced to go to school when he does not want to. The child does not want to study, but the teacher gives him tasks anyway. If we carefully analyze our lives, we will find that they are full of suffering. Generally speaking, conditioned souls are not very intelligent, and therefore they go on suffering without ever inquiring why. We should understand, however, that this suffering is there, and if there is a remedy we must take advantage of it.

The great sage Åñabhadeva instructed his sons in this way: "My dear boys, in this life you have acquired these beautiful bodies. Now you should know that they are not meant for sense gratification like the bodies of hogs and dogs but for spiritual realization." Essentially what Åñabhadeva is saying is that a life of sense gratification is meant for stool eaters like hogs, and now that we have a higher form of life, we should not try to imitate the lower forms.

Recently we were surprised to see, while walking in Central Park in New York City, that a group of young American boys and girls were engaged in worshiping hogs. While we were chanting Hare Kåñëa, these groups of youngsters were chanting, "Hog! Hog! Hog!" They were actually parading with hogs in Central Park and bowing down before them and worshiping them. They actually wanted one hog to become President, and they wanted the hogs to lead them. This has gone to such lengths that at one be-in in Seattle there was a demonstration with hogs in which the boys and girls undressed themselves and got in the mud and played with the hogs, and in this way they were associating with the hogs and pigs which they worshiped. All this is going on in a country where the young people have good looking bodies, a great deal of money and so many other advantages over the young people of other nations. The result of gaining all these advantages is that they have simply taken to hog worship. Such hog worship was anticipated long, long ago and was described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, which was compiled at least 5,000 years ago. The point is that a beautiful situation in life should be utilized for a beautiful end, not for degraded forms of worship.

In the Vedic histories we find that there were many, many exalted emperors and kings who practiced austerities and penances. Dhruva Mahäräja, Ambaréña Mahäräja and Yudiñöhira Mahäräja were all great kings and were most opulent, but at the same time they were great sages. Thus they set the example for those who have acquired this good opportunity of a beautiful human form of life with all the facilities for economic development and good living. This opportunity should be used to attain an even better life, and this can be actualized by practice of penance. At present we are existing in these material bodies, but if we take to the process of Kåñëa consciousness, our consciousness will be purified. Although American and European, the young students who are voluntarily practicing Kåñëa consciousness are very pleased to practice it. The process is not troublesome but pleasing. Now they are realizing that purified existence constitutes the difference between animal life and human life.

If we purify our existence simply by following the basic regulations of Kåñëa consciousness, which involve abstaining from illicit sexual connection, meat-eating, intoxication and gambling, we will gradually rise to attain our spiritual existence, which is completely pure. The sage Åñabhadeva told his sons that once they purified their existence they would have unlimited happiness. We are all intended to attain peace and happiness, but whatever peace and happiness we find in this material world is limited. If we but purify our existence and attain spiritual existence, we will experience unlimited peace and happiness.

The spiritual world is not dry or abstract; as pointed out before, there is variegatedness there. A part of the spiritual pleasure experienced in the Vaikuëöhas is the pleasure of dancing. There are also young girls and young boys there. Indeed, there is no such thing as old age, or disease, or death, or the pains of birth. If we want to participate in the unlimited happiness, knowledge and eternal life which constitute our actual heritage in the spiritual world, we should not waste this life by working hard for sense gratification and worshiping hogs. We should accept a life devoted to the cultivation of Kåñëa consciousness, and then we will get unlimited happiness and unlimited pleasure. This is the sum and substance of the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

EK 2: Hard Struggle for Happiness

2
Hard Struggle for Happiness

[sources: BTGPY13b; Progressive Ambition & BTGPY9a; Sufferings of Humanity]

In the revealed scriptures the Supreme Lord is described as sac-cid-änanda-vigraha. Sat means eternal, cit means fully cognizant, änanda means joyful, and vigraha means that He is a person. Thus the Lord, or the Supreme Godhead, who is one without a second, is a fully cognizant and eternally joyful personality with a full sense of His identity. No one is equal to Him or greater than Him. This is a concise description of the Supreme Lord.

The living entities (jévas) are minute samples of the Supreme Lord, and being so they therefore find in their activities the desire for eternal existence, for complete knowledge, and for happiness. These desires are evident in human society, and in the upper planetary systems (Svargaloka, Janaloka, Tapoloka, Maharloka, Brahmaloka, etc.) the living entities enjoy a longer duration of life, an increased amount of knowledge, and a generally more blissful existence. But even in the highest planet in this material world, where the duration of life and standard of enjoyment are thousands and thousands of times greater than those on earth, there is still old age, disease and death. Consequently the level of enjoyment is insignificant in comparison to the eternal bliss enjoyed in the company of the Supreme Lord. Loving service to the Supreme Lord in different relationships makes even the enjoyment of impersonal Brahman as insignificant as a drop of water in comparison to the ocean.

Every living being desires the topmost level of enjoyment in this material world, and yet everyone is unhappy here. This unhappiness is present on all the higher planets, despite a longer lifespan, higher standards of enjoyment and comfort. That is due to the law of material nature. We can increase the duration of life and standard to the highest capacity, and yet by the law of material nature we will be unhappy. The reason for this is that the quality of happiness which is suitable for our constitution is different from the happiness which is derived from material activities. The living entity is a minute particle of the superior spiritual energy of the Lord, which is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, and therefore he has the necessary propensity for joy which is spiritual in quality. Unfortunately for him, he is trying vainly to attain his enjoyment from the foreign atmosphere of material nature.

A fish that is taken out of the water cannot be happy by any arrangement on land. He must be supplied with water. In the same way, the minute sac-cid-änanda living entity cannot be really happy through any amount of planning conceived by his illusioned brain in this material universe. He must therefore be given a different type of happiness which is spiritual in essence. Our ambition should be aimed at enjoying spiritual bliss and not this temporary happiness. Some philosophers claim that spiritual bliss is attained by negating material happiness and material existence. Theoretical negation of material activities as propounded by Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya may be effective for an insignificant section of mankind, but the best and surest way for everyone to attain spiritual bliss was propounded by Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu by means of devotional activities. These devotional activities can change the very face of material nature.

Hankering after material happiness is called lust, and lusty activities are sure to meet with frustration in the long run. The body of a snake is very cool, but if a man, wanting to enjoy this coolness, garlands himself with a venomous snake, he will surely be killed by the snake's venomous bite. The material senses are compared to snakes; indulgence in material happiness will surely kill our spiritual identity. Therefore a sane man should be ambitious to find the real source of happiness.

In order to find this source, however, we need some knowledge of what that happiness is. There is the story of the foolish man who had no experience with sugar cane. When he asked his friend about the characteristics of sugar cane, he was imperfectly informed that sugar cane resembles the shape of a bamboo stick. Consequently he began trying to extract juice from bamboo sticks, but naturally he was baffled in his attempts. This is the situation with the illusioned living entity who, in his search for eternal happiness, tries to extract happiness from this material world, which is not only full of miseries but is also transient and flickering. In Bhagavad-gétä the material world is described as being full of miseries.

äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

"From the highest planet in the material world, down to the lowest, all are places of misery, where repeated birth and death take place. But one who attains to My abode, O son of Kunté, never takes birth again." (Bg. 8.16)

The ambition for happiness is natural and good, but the attempt to derive it from inert matter by so-called scientific arrangements is an illusory attempt doomed to frustration. Those who are befooled cannot understand this. How a person is driven by the lust for material happiness is also described in Bhagavad-gétä.

idam adya mayä labdham
imaà präpsye manoratham
idam astédam api me
bhaviñyati punar dhanam

"The demoniac person thinks: 'So much wealth do I have today, and I will gain more according to my schemes. So much is mine now, and it will increase in the future, more and more.' " (Bg. 16.13)

This atheistic or godless civilization is a huge affair contrived for the gratification of our senses, and now we are all mad after money in order to maintain this empty shell. Money is sought after by everyone because that is the medium of exchange for objects for sense gratification. Obviously the expectation of peace in such an atmosphere of gold rush pandemonium is a utopian dream. As long as there is the slightest tinge of sense gratification or desire for sense gratification, peace will remain far, far away. This is because by nature we are all eternal servants of the Supreme Lord and therefore cannot enjoy anything for our personal interests. It is therefore necessary for us to learn how to employ our senses in the transcendental service of the Lord, and to utilize everything to serve His interest. This alone can bring about much desired peace. A part of the body cannot in itself be independently happy. It can only derive its happiness and pleasure out of serving the entire body. The Supreme Lord is the whole, and we are the parts, but we are all busily engaged in activities of self-interest. No one is prepared to serve the Lord. This is the basic cause for our conditioning in material existence and for our resultant unhappiness.

From the highest executive in his skyscraper office down to the coolie in the street—all are working with the thought of accumulating wealth, legally or illegally. Actually it is all illegal, for to work for one's self-interest is both unlawful and destructive. Even the cultivation of spiritual realization for one's own self-interest is unlawful and destructive. The point is that all activities must be directed to the satisfaction of Kåñëa and His service.

Those who are not engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Supreme Lord wrongfully think that they are accumulating so much money day after day.

äçä-päça-çatair baddhäù
käma-krodha-paräyaëäù
éhante käma-bhogärtham
anyäyenärtha-saïcayän

"Being bound by hundreds and thousands of desires, by lust and anger, they secure money by illegal means for sense gratification." (Bg. 16.12)

Consequently, although there is no lack of money in the world, there is a scarcity of peace. So much human energy is being diverted to making money, for the general population has increased its capacity to make more and more dollars, but in the long run the result is that this unrestricted and unlawful monetary inflation has created a bad economy all over the world and has provoked us to manufacture huge and costly weapons to destroy the very result of such cheap money-making. The leaders of the big money-making countries are not really enjoying peace but are making plans to save themselves from imminent destruction by nuclear weapons. In fact, huge sums of money are being thrown into the sea by way of experiments with these dreadful weapons. Such experiments are being carried out not only at huge costs but also at the cost of many lives. In this way the nations are being bound by the laws of karma. When men are motivated by the impulse for sense gratification, whatever money is earned is spoiled, being spent for the destruction of the human race. The energy of the human race is thus wasted by the laws of nature because of man's aversion to the Lord, who is actually the proprietor of all energies.

Wealth is worshiped and is referred to as Mother Lakñmé, or the goddess of fortune. It is her position to serve Lord Näräyaëa, the source of all the naras, or living beings. The naras are also meant to serve Näräyaëa under the guidance of the goddess of fortune. The living being cannot enjoy the goddess of fortune without serving Näräyaëa, and therefore whoever desires to enjoy her wrongly will be punished by the laws of nature. These laws will make certain that the money itself will bring about destruction instead of peace and prosperity.

Unlawfully accumulated money is now being snatched from miserly citizens by various methods of state taxation for the future civil and international war fund, which is spending money in a wasteful and destructive manner. The citizens are no longer satisfied with just enough money to maintain a family nicely and cultivate spiritual knowledge, both of which are essential in human life. Now everyone wants money unlimitedly to satisfy insatiable desires. In proportion to the people's unlawful desires, their accumulated money is taken away by the agents of illusory energy in the shape of medical practitioners, lawyers, tax collectors, societies, constitutions, so-called holy men, famines, earthquakes, and many similar calamities. One miser who hesitated to purchase a copy of Back to Godhead spent $2,000 for a week's supply of medicine and then died. Another man who refused to spend a cent for the service of the Lord wasted thousands of dollars in a legal suit between the members of his home. There are innumerable similar instances occasioned by the dictation of illusory nature. Indeed, that is the law of nature; if money is not devoted to the service of the Lord, it must be spent as spoiled energy in the form of legal problems or diseases. Foolish people do not have the eyes to see such facts; therefore the laws of the Supreme Lord befool them.

The laws of nature do not allow us to accept more money than is required for proper maintenance. There is ample arrangement by the law of nature to provide every living being with his due share of food and shelter, but the insatiable lusts of human beings have disturbed the arrangement set forth by the Almighty Father of all species of life. By the arrangement of the Supreme Lord, there is an ocean of salt because salt is so necessary for the living being. God has, in the same manner, arranged for sufficient air and light, which are also essential. Anyone can collect any amount of salt from the natural storehouse, but constitutionally we cannot take more salt than what we need. If we take more salt, we spoil the broth, and if we take less salt our food becomes tasteless. On the other hand, if we take only what we require, our food is tasty and we are healthy.

Presently there is a great deal of concern over the fact that our natural resources are becoming polluted and exhausted. Actually there is ample supply, but due to misuse and greed everything is being spoiled. What conservationists and ecologists do not understand is that everything will continue to be spoiled by the insatiable lusts of mankind unless this Kåñëa consciousness process is taken up. It is impossible to have peace on any platform of existence without Kåñëa consciousness. Man is therefore suffering due to his insatiable desires and lusts. Not only is man suffering, but the planet on which he resides, his mother earth, represented in Çrémad-Bhägavatam by mother cow, is also suffering.

Once a well-known svämé in India was asked whether God or providence is responsible for the sufferings of humanity. The svämé replied that these sufferings were all God's pastimes or lélä. The questioner continued to ask why a living entity should be put under the dictations of the law of karma. The svämé could not answer these questions to the satisfaction of his inquirers. The monists and impersonalists who think only in terms of the oneness of the living entities with the Supreme Lord cannot give satisfactory answers to such questions. Such an imperfect reply can hardly satisfy the heart of a living entity.

The Lord is described in all scriptures as lélä-puruñottama, or the Personality of Godhead, who is by His own nature always engaged in transcendental pastimes. In the Vedänta-sütra He is also described as änandamayo 'bhyäsät. The monists and impersonalists try with great difficulty to explain this sütra in diverse ways in order to support their imperfect theory of oneness and impersonality. However, the fact remains that änanda, pleasure, cannot be enjoyed alone. That variety is the mother of enjoyment is a well-known fact. Cities, for instance, are known to be attractive if they contain a variety of things. Living entities are naturally attracted by variety, by attractive streets, buildings, cinemas, parks, conveyances, businesses, employments, foodstuffs, etc. Despite all this variety, the English poet Cowper once said, "The city is made by man, but the country is made by God." The countryside is also full of natural variegatedness in a crude form, whereas in the city this variegatedness is displayed in a modernized scientific manner. Poets like Cowper are attracted to the variegatedness of the country, and prosaic people who live in the city are attracted by the colorful varieties manufactured by man. In any case, it is variegatedness which attracts people both to the country and the city. This is the proper explanation of the verse of the Vedänta-sütra.

Many so-called svämés who are so frequently attracted by the cities often seek a kind of pleasure in society and feminine friendship. Generally they are not attracted by the natural beauty of the woods, although they may assume the dress of a man who is meant to live in the woods. Such svämés are seeking varieties of enjoyment in matter because they have no information of the variegatedness of spiritual life. On the one hand they enjoy variegatedness in matter, and on the other they deny spiritual variegatedness to the Absolute. Because they are pledged to the theory of monism and impersonalism, they deny that whatever pertains to matter can pertain also to spirit. According to them, spirit is the denial of matter. The fact is, however, that spirit is not a negation of matter, but matter is a perverted reflection of spirit.

The real pleasure of variety exists in spirit without deluding relativity. On the other hand, inert matter, in association with dynamic spirit, manifests a false representation or a perverted reflection of that very spiritual variegatedness which is so adamantly denied by the monist class of so-called svämés.

As stated before, the Supreme Lord is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, joyful by nature, and therefore He expands Himself by His different energies, parts, and differentiated and plenary portions. The Supreme Lord is the Absolute Truth, and He is one without a second, but He also includes His diverse energies, parts, and plenary portions which are simultaneously one with and different from Him. Because He is joyful by nature, He expands Himself in diverse ways, and the activities of these expansions are called His transcendental pastimes or His lélä. These pastimes, however, are not blind and inert; they exhibit full sense, independence, and freedom of action and reaction. The complexities of the actions and the reactions of the diverse energies of the Absolute Truth constitute the subject matter of a vast science called the transcendental science of God, and the Bhagavad-gétä is the ABC or primary book of knowledge for students interested in that science. Every intelligent human being should become interested in this transcendental science; indeed, according to the opinions of the sages, human life is only meant for learning this science. The opening words of the Vedänta-sütra proclaim: "Now is the time to inquire about Brahman."

Human life by nature is full of suffering, and lower life forms are even more miserable. Any sane man with properly discriminating senses can understand that life in the material world is full of miseries and that no one is free from the actions and reactions of such miseries. This is not a pessimistic view of life but is an actual fact which we should not be blind to. The miseries of life are divided into three categories, namely miseries arising from the body and mind, miseries arising from other living entities, and miseries arising due to natural calamities. A sane man must look to eliminate these miseries and thereby become happy in life. We are all trying to achieve peace and freedom from these miseries, at least unconsciously, and in the higher intellectual circles there are attempts to get rid of these miseries by ingenious plans and designs. But the power that baffles all the plans and designs of even the most intelligent person is the power of Mäyä devé, or the illusory energy. The law of karma, or the result of all actions and reactions in the material world, is controlled by this all-powerful illusory energy. The activities of this energy function according to principles and regulations, and they act consciously under the direction of the Supreme Lord. Everything is done by nature in full consciousness; nothing is blind or accidental. This material energy is also called Durgä, which indicates that it is a force which is very difficult to surpass. No one can surpass the laws of Durgä by any amount of childish plans.

To get rid of the sufferings of humanity is simultaneously a very difficult and also a very easy affair. As long as the conditioned souls, who are themselves bound up by the laws of nature, manufacture plans to get rid of the three miseries, there will be no solution. The only effective solutions are those mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä, and we have to adopt them in our practical lives for our own benefit. The three miseries of material nature are not found in the pastimes of the Supreme Lord. As mentioned before, He is eternally joyful, and His transcendental pastimes are not different from Him. Because He is the Absolute Truth, His name, fame, form, qualities and pastimes are all identical with Him. His pastimes, therefore, cannot be equated with the sufferings of humanity as the so-called svämé contends. The pastimes of the Supreme Lord are transcendental to the actual miseries and sufferings of human beings.

The sufferings of humanity are caused by the misuse of the discriminative power or the little independence which is given to individual souls. The fraudulent svämés or mental speculators, in order to remain consistent with the theory of monism, must pass off the miseries of mankind as the pastimes of God, but actually these miseries are only the enforced punishments of Mäyä devé inflicted upon the misguided conditioned souls.

As living entities, we are part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. Indeed, we actually belong to His superior energy. As such, we may join His transcendental pastimes in our unconditioned state of life, but as long as we are conditioned by the laws of karma, in contact with the inferior energy, our sufferings are our own creations, born of a gross misuse of our little independence. The impersonalist monists only misguide people by contending that the threefold miseries are a part of the Lord's pastimes. Such impersonalists and monists have misguided their followers because they incorrectly think that the Supreme Lord and the individual souls are equal in all respects. True, the individual souls are equal in quality with the Supreme Lord, but not in quantity. If the individual soul were quantitatively equal to the Supreme Lord, he would have never been subjected to the laws of material nature. Material nature is subordinate to the will of the Supreme Lord, and therefore He cannot be subjected to the laws of material nature. It is contradictory for the Lord to be subjected to the laws of His own inferior energy.

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conquerer of wealth (Arjuna), there is no truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7)

Again, Çré Kåñëa states:

tribhir guëamayair bhävair
ebhiù sarvam idaà jagat
mohitaà näbhijänäti
mäm ebhyaù param avyayam

"Deluded by the three modes (goodness, passion, and ignorance), the whole world does not know Me who am above them and inexhaustible." (Bg. 7.13)

The individual souls, who are put into the miseries of the material world, are suffering the resultant reactions of their unsanctioned activities. This is the verdict of Bhagavad-gétä.

tän ahaà dviñataù krürän
saàsäreñu narädhamän
kñipämy ajasram açubhän
äsuréñv eva yoniñu

"Envious, mischievous, the lowest of mankind, these do I ever put back into the ocean of material existence, into various demoniac species of life." (Bg. 16.19)

The parts and parcels are meant to serve the whole, and when they misuse their independence they are subject to the miseries of the laws of matter, just as criminals are subject to police action. The state considers its citizens to be its parts and parcels, and when a citizen misuses his relative independence, the state puts him under police authority. The life of a citizen outside the prison and the life of a citizen within the prison are not the same. Similarly, the sufferings of the living entities within the prison of material nature cannot be equated with the pastimes of the Supreme Lord which exist in the absolute freedom of sac-cid-änanda.

No government wants its citizens to act in such a way that they must go to prison and suffer tribulations. The prisonhouse is undoubtedly constructed by the state government, but this does not mean that the government is anxious for its citizens to be put into it. Indirectly, the disobedient citizens force the government to construct the prisonhouse. It is not done for the pleasure of the government, which has to spend a great deal of money in constructing and maintaining it. On the contrary, the government would be very glad to demolish prisons altogether provided that there are no disobedient citizens in the state. In the same way, this material world is created by the Supreme Lord, but the Supreme Lord does not will that living entities be put in it. The living entities themselves make that decision. The residents of this material world are therefore different from those who are eternally engaged in the transcendental pastimes of the Supreme Lord.

The impersonal monists have no information of full-fledged independent life in the eternal spiritual realm. According to them, the spiritual realm is simply void. This is like prisoners thinking that there is no life outside the prison. Life outside of a prison is certainly free from prison activities, but is not devoid of activity. The soul is by nature eternally active, but the impersonalists try to negate the activities of the soul in the spiritual realm. Thus they misunderstand the miseries of prison life to be the pastimes of the Supreme Lord. This is due to their poor fund of knowledge.

The Supreme Lord never creates the actions and reactions of an individual soul. In Bhagavad-gétä this matter is clearly defined in the following way:

na kartåtvaà na karmäëi
lokasya såjati prabhuù
na karma-phala-saàyogaà
svabhävas tu pravartate

nädatte kasyacit päpaà
na caiva sukåtaà vibhuù
ajïänenävåtaà jïänaà
tena muhyanti jantavaù

"The embodied spirit, master of the city of his body, does not create activities, nor does he induce people to act, nor does he create the fruits of action. All this is enacted by the modes of material nature. Nor does the Supreme Spirit assume anyone's sinful or pious activities. Embodied beings, however, are bewildered because of the ignorance which covers their real knowledge." (Bg. 5.14-15)

It is clear from these passages that the sufferings of humanity are not to be equated with the pastimes of the Supreme Being, nor is the Supreme Being responsible for them. The Lord is never responsible for anyone's vices or virtues. By vicious actions, we are put into more and more distressful conditions, whereas by pious actions we place ourselves on the path of happiness. Thus man is the architect of his own material distress or happiness. The Lord does not want the living entity to become entangled in the reactions of activities, be they good or bad. He simply wants everyone to go back home, back to Godhead. As long as we are not awakened to our pure eternal relation with God, we are certainly bewildered in our actions. Our actions, in respect to right and wrong, are all performed on the platform of ignorance. We must rise to the platform of pure knowledge, which is the pure realization that we are the eternal servitors of the Supreme Lord and enjoyers of His transcendental pastimes. The Supreme Lord is the master-enjoyer of those pastimes, and we are the servitor-enjoyers.

Transcendental knowledge is only attainable by transcendental devotional service, as described in Bhagavad-gétä.

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mam upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." (Bg. 10.10)

By rendering such devotional service only, and not by merely acquiring a bulk of discriminative knowledge, can we know the Supreme Lord as He is. When we know the Personality of Godhead in reality, we can then enter into His pastimes. That is the verdict of all revealed scriptures.

EK 3: Toward a Peaceful Society

3
Toward a Peaceful Society

[710925BG.NAI] & [660801BG.NY]

çré bhagavan uväca
idaà çaréraà kaunteya
kñetram ity abhidhéyate
etad yo vetti taà prähuù
kñetrajïa iti tad-vidaù

"The Supreme Lord said: This body, O son of Kunté, is called the field, and one who knows this body is called the knower of the field." (Bg. 13.2)

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, is instructing Arjuna about the knowledge of kñetra and kñetrajïa. Kñetra refers to the field, which is the body, and kñetrajïa refers to the knower of the field, who is the individual soul. If land is to be cultivated, there must be some cultivator, and if this body, which is likened unto a field, is to be cultivated, there must be a proprietor who can cultivate it.

Now we have these material bodies, and it is our duty to cultivate them properly. That cultivation is called akarma, or work. A person may come to our place with a hoe to cultivate land, or he may come to simply drink coffee or tea. We have been given this particular type of body to cultivate and to attain required sense objects according to our desires. This body is a gift from God. God is very kind, and if someone wants something from Him, He allows it. "All right," He says. "Take this." His relationship to us is just like the relationship of a father to a son. The son may insist upon getting something from the father, and the father may try to convince him that what he wants is not for his good, saying, "My dear son, don't touch this. This is not good for you." But when the boy insists upon it, the father will allow him to have it. The affectionate father gives the son just what he wants. Similarly, the Supreme Father gives His sons and daughters just what they want. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that all beings, in all species of life, are his children.

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving Father." (Bg. 14.4)

In this material world, the mother, prakåti, which is material nature, supplies us with the body, and the Supreme Father impregnates this matter with living souls. There is an erroneous theory current that only human beings have souls and that other living entities do not, but we understand from Vedic authority that there are over 8,000,000 species of bodies, including plants and trees, and that they all have souls, otherwise they would not be able to develop and grow. In this verse Çré Kåñëa claims that all living entities, regardless of the forms they take in this material world, are his sons, and that they are related to Him as a son is related to his father.

This Kåñëa consciousness is especially meant for understanding the position of the soul and its relationship with God.

kñetrajïaà cäpi mäà viddhi
sarva-kñetreñu bhärata
kñetra-kñetrajïayor jïänaà
yat taj jïänaà mataà mama

"O scion of Bharata, you should understand that I am also the knower in all bodies, and to understand this body and its owner is called knowledge. That is My opinion." (Bg. 13.3)

If we meditate upon this body and study whether or not we are actually the body, we will come to the conclusion that we are kñetrajïa, the knower of the body but not the body. If we study our finger and consider whether or not we are the finger, we will come to the conclusion that we are not the finger or any other part of the body, but that the finger, the arms, the legs, the head, etc. are our fingers, arms, legs, etc. In this way we can come to the conclusion that we are not these bodies but that the bodies belong to us. Therefore we say, "This is my body." Unfortunately people in this modern civilization never stop to inquire what they are or who they are. They are simply laboring hard, working hard all day in an office or factory, under the impression that, "I am this body." And if we ask people who they are, they reply, "I am Hindu, I am Moslem, I am Swedish, I am American, I am Christian, etc." These are various identifications or designations of the body, but the fact is that we are not these bodies. The body is simply the field of our activities. We are no more the body than the cultivator of a field is the field.

There are different kinds of bodies and different activities in accordance to the different types of bodies. A dog enjoys one kind of activity, a cat enjoys another, and a human enjoys another. There are differences of activity due to differences of body. When we come to the platform of truth, however, and understand that we are not these bodies, then our activities change from material activities to spiritual activities. As long as we are operating under the bodily conception of life, our activities are material, but as soon as we understand, "I do not belong to this body, ahaà brahmäsmi, I am spirit soul," our activities will be in accordance to that realization, that is to say that they will cease to be motivated from the material or bodily platform. Knowledge of our proper identity as separate from the body is real knowledge, but this knowledge is denied as long as we cling to bodily identification.

In the scriptures it is said that as long as we are in this bodily conception of life, all our activities will be defeated. A child is born into ignorance, and if as he grows older he remains under the bodily conception of life, he lives in darkness. His position is that of a çüdra. In the Vedic literatures we find that in this age everyone is born a çüdra; therefore everyone requires to be educated as to his real identity. If, however, we remain satisfied with our birth by our father and mother, we will remain in our condition as çüdra. We have to rise to the brahminical platform by following the purificatory processes.

As mentioned before, there are four basic characteristics of an impure life—illicit sex, intoxication, meat-eating and gambling. According to the Vedic principles, sex should not be indulged in outside of marriage. In human society there is therefore a system of marriage which distinguishes us from the cats and dogs. Whether we are Hindu, Moslem, or Christian, we acknowledge the system of marriage. The purpose of this system is to avoid illicit sex. According to the Vedic system, intoxication is also discouraged; nor is meat-eating advocated, for human beings should be nonviolent. We have been given sufficient grains, fruits, milk, and vegetables, and there is no necessity to kill poor animals. Some people argue that if we do not eat meat we will be undernourished, but we can see that the students of this Kåñëa consciousness movement have given up meat and are very healthy, whereas people who are eating meat are still, despite their meat-eating, subject to so many diseases and unhealthy conditions. Gambling is also discouraged because it simply agitates the mind.

This then is the purificatory process by which one can become a brähmaëa. This path is open to everyone. A brähmaëa is one who is truthful and pure, tolerant and simple, full of knowledge and faith in God. He can control his mind and his senses also. At the present moment there is a great necessity for brähmaëas, because almost everyone is a çüdra, for almost everyone is wholly engaged in maintaining the body, eating, sleeping, mating and defending—all symptoms of animals and çüdras.

Society cannot be peaceful unless there are four divisions of human beings functioning in harmony with one another. These four divisions are comprised of brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas and çüdras. These are discussed by Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä in this way:

cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöaà
guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù
tasya kartäram api mäà
viddhy akartäram avyayam

"According to the three modes of material nature and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me. And, although I am the creator of this system, you should know that I am yet the non-doer, being unchangeable." (Bg. 4.13)

These four divisions of men in human society are natural, not artificial, because in the material world everything is operating under the influence of the three modes of material nature—goodness, passion and ignorance. As long as we are in the material world, it is not possible to classify everyone in the same category because each and every person is working under the influence of the modes of material nature. However, when we transcend the material plane, there is oneness. At that time, all the divisions fall apart. The question is therefore how to transcend the modes of material nature, and that transcendence is the very process of Kåñëa consciousness. As soon as we become situated in Kåñëa consciousness, we become transcendental to the modes of material nature.

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature, and thus comes to the level of Brahman." (Bg. 14.26)

Thus one who is engaged in Kåñëa conscious activity is at once elevated to the transcendental position. By nature we are not matter but Brahman (ahaà brahmäsmi). The philosophy of Çaìkaräcärya is mainly based on the principle that we should not think that we are products of this material nature. It is by some unfortunate accident that we are in contact with material nature. Actually our nature is that of spirit, Brahman, and that nature has to be invoked. This material life is a diseased condition; when we are situated in Brahman, we are in our healthy condition. That healthy Brahman condition is immediately attained as soon as we engage ourselves one hundred percent in Kåñëa consciousness.

When we transcend material nature through the rendering of service unto Kåñëa, what is our status? Do we become zero? Some philosophies maintain that after liberation from material life, after the nirväëa of this material body, we become zero, void. That is a dangerous theory. By nature the living entity is not attracted to zero. We may be diseased and suffering from so many elements, but if our doctor comes and says, "Let me finish your ailments by killing you," we will immediately say, "No, no! Better let me suffer from the disease." We do not want to be killed just to end our miseries. Thus the theory that after material life there is void is not at all attractive. Nor is it a fact. We are sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, eternal, blissful and full of knowledge, and part and parcel of the Supreme. The Supreme Lord is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, and we are qualitatively one with Him. Although very small, a drop of seawater is as salty as the sea, and although we are but spiritual atoms, we have the same properties as the supreme spirit whole. There is no question of being void, for as living entities our spiritual properties are all there in infinite variegatedness.

If, however, out of the frustration of material existence we commit suicide, we do not end our miseries. We simply create other miseries. If one attempts suicide but does not succeed, or is somehow revived, he is subject to being punished under state law. Similarly, the laws of nature treat suicides as criminal acts. We are to end this material life only after finding out the true blissful life of eternity. We should not simply be trying to end the miseries of this life simply out of frustration, but we should engage ourselves in activities that will raise us to spiritual life.

The four divisions of human society were created by Çré Kåñëa in order to facilitate this process of elevation. Just as a student is elevated from a lower class to a post-graduate class, the divisions of labor (cätur-varëyam) are created to elevate us from the lowest stages of consciousness to the highest stage of Kåñëa consciousness. This process is a process of cooperation. In the human body, the most important part is the head, then the arms, the belly and the legs. Although the head is considered to be the most important part, there is no question of neglecting the legs or any other part. Similarly, in the divisions of human society, no one division is important to the exclusion of the others. Of these divisions, the brähmaëas are considered to be the intellectual class, the class of teachers; the kñatriyas are the administrative and military class; the vaiçyas are the mercantile and agricultural class; and the çüdras are the common laborer class. In a properly run society, all of these classes are required. If they cooperate in their progress toward Kåñëa consciousness, there is no strife amongst them.

In the present social status, we find that we are existing in these four divisions, but there is no cooperation. Everyone is dissatisfied. Today there is great strife between the capitalist class and laborer class because between them there is no compromise. There is only friction. All this strife amongst the classes is due to lack of Kåñëa consciousness. Indeed, there is not even a possibility of cooperation unless there is Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa consciousness is absolutely essential for harmonizing all facets of human society. Regardless of what class we belong to, if we cooperate in Kåñëa consciousness, there will be peace in the world.

Thus Kåñëa consciousness is the utmost necessity for all divisions of society. Every chapter and every conclusion of Bhagavad-gétä aim toward Kåñëa consciousness. Çré Kåñëa, who is speaking Bhagavad-gétä, is always stressing devotion to His personal Self.

manmanä bhava madbhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi satyaà te
pratijäne priyo 'si me

"Always think of Me and become My devotee. Worship Me and offer your homage unto Me. Thus you will come to Me without fail. I promise you this because you are My very dear friend." (Bg. 18.65)

Throughout Bhagavad-gétä we find this word mäm stressed. Mäm means "unto Me," meaning unto Kåñëa. But there are many miscreants who are interpreting this mäm to mean "everyone." When I say, "Bring me a glass of water," does it mean that I want you to bring everyone a glass of water? The individuality is there, but by jugglery of words they interpret "me" or "I" to mean "everyone." Consequently when Kåñëa says "I," the miscreants identify this "I" with themselves. This is a gross misinterpretation. Although Bhagavad-gétä is very popular in the world, due to this misinterpretation by mundane scholars, it has not been properly understood.

Bhagavad-gétä clearly explains that this cätur-varëyam system was established by Kåñëa, but He is outside of this system. When Kåñëa comes as an incarnation, He does not come as a member of any social order, not as a brähmaëa or anything else. When Kåñëa came, He came as the son of Devaké and Vasudeva. Vasudeva belonged to the royal family and was therefore a kñatriya. As such, Kåñëa played the part of a kñatriya, but this does not mean that Kåñëa belonged to the kñatriya class. There are many incarnations of Kåñëa in many forms of life. In one incarnation He appeared as a fish, as a member of the community of fishes, but this does not mean that He is a fish. If we think upon seeing a fish that it belongs to Kåñëa's family, we are mistaken. Of course, from another point of view, everything is Kåñëa, but Kåñëa is aloof from everything. This is the transcendental nature of Kåñëa, and if we understand it, we will be liberated from birth and death.

Although Kåñëa has established the four divisions of human society, He is not in anyone of them (tasya kartäram api mäà viddhy akartäram avyayam). As soon as we understand that although Kåñëa was born into a kñatriya family, He is not a kñatriya, we actually become liberated. If we think that because Kåñëa acts in a particular way—as on the battlefield He gave instructions to Arjuna to fight—He is bound by the reactions of His activities, we are mistaken. "Works do not defile Me," Çré Kåñëa says (na mäà karmäëi limpanti). In conclusion, we must accept the fact that when Kåñëa comes as one of us, He is not in actuality "one of us." He is transcendental. This fact we must learn by submissive inquiry from authoritative sources, such as Bhagavad-gétä or a spiritual master who is fully realized in Kåñëa consciousness.

Today all facets of human society are thinking that their self-interest is in maintaining this body. Consequently today's society is simply a society of cats, dogs and hogs. From Vedic literatures we can understand that we don't have to work hard all day simply to maintain this body. We are working very hard because we are trying to control material nature for the purposes of sense gratification. One who can come to understand that Kåñëa is the root of everything, the origin of everything, can understand the meaning of éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù—Kåñëa is the supreme controller. In the universe there are many éçvaras, or controllers, but Kåñëa is the supreme among all of them. Kåñëa consciousness gives us this knowledge. Without it, we will remain ignorant of our real self-interest.

Modern society is in dire need of intellectual persons or brähmaëas who can broadcast real spiritual knowledge all over the world. That is an absolute necessity for a society which is working hard simply to exploit nature. If people try to understand this Kåñëa consciousness movement scientifically and philosophically, with their best knowledge and judgement, and try to cooperate, there will be peace all over the world. In essence, the method is very simple. We need only chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare and follow the regulative principles mentioned before. By following the regulative principles, we will be avoiding the four pillars of sinful life, and by chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra, we will be associating with God constantly; thus there will be peace among all classes of men.

EK 4: Knowing Kåñëa as He Is

4
Knowing Kåñëa as He Is

[680818SB.MON]

We do not need any high qualifications to offer prayers to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Whatever our social or intellectual position may be, we can offer prayers. We do not have to be very learned or very scholarly, nor do we have to present our prayers in nicely selected words that are poetical, rhetorical or metaphorical. None of this is required, although if it is there it is very nice. We simply have to express our feelings, but in order to be able to do this we have to be aware of our position. Once we are aware of our position, our feelings can be expressed sincerely and automatically.

What is our position? This has been taught by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who teaches us how to pray in his prayer:

na dhanaà na janaà na sundaréà
kavitäà vä jagadéça kämaye
mama janmani janmanéçvare
bhavatäd bhaktir ahaituké tvayi

"O almighty Lord! I have no desire to accumulate wealth, nor have I any desire to enjoy beautiful women, nor do I want any number of followers. What I want only is that I may have Your causeless devotional service in my life—birth after birth." (Çikñäñöakam, 4)

In this prayer the word jagadéça means "Lord of the universe." Jagat means universe, and éça means Lord. Whether we are Hindu, Moslem or Christian or whatever, we must acknowledge that there is a supreme controller of this universe. This cannot be denied by anyone who has faith in God. Our conviction should be that our Supreme Father is Jagadéça, or Lord of the entire universe. Only Lord Jagadéça is in control; everyone else is controlled. The atheists, however, do not like this term because they like to think that they are in control, but actually this is not the case. All beings in the material world are subject to the three modes of material nature—goodness, passion and ignorance—but the Supreme Lord is above these modes.

tribhir guëamayair bhävair
ebhiù sarvam idaà jagat
mohitaà näbhijänäti
mäm ebhyaù param avyayam

"Deluded by the three modes (goodness, passion, and ignorance), the whole world does not know Me who am above them and inexhaustible." (Bg. 7.13)

The Brahma-saàhitä also gives us information regarding Jagadéça, the Supreme. In that work, Lord Brahmä says that the supreme controller is Lord Kåñëa Himself (éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù). The word éçvaraù means controller, and the word paramaù means supreme. All of us are controllers to some limited extent. If we have nothing to control, sometimes we keep a dog or cat so we can say, "My dear dog, please come here." In this way we can think, "I am the controller." Sometimes the tables turn, however, and we find that the dog controls the master.

This happens because actually no one is the controller, and everyone is controlled. Unfortunately we are forgetful of this situation, and this forgetfulness is called mäyä. We refuse to accept any controller of this universe because if we accept a controller we have to account for our sinful activities, just as when we accept the government we have to account for our unlawful activities. Our position is that we want to continue in our sinful activities, and therefore we deny the existence of a controller. This is the basic principle of godlessness. The current propaganda that "God is dead" is spread because people want to continue being rascals without restriction. This is the basic principle underlying the denial of God's existence. But however much we deny His existence, He will not die. In this regard, there is a Bengali proverb that says: çakuni çäpe gorumaraëa. The work çakuni means vulture. Vultures enjoy dead animal carcasses, especially the carcass of the cow. Sometimes a vulture may go for days without a carcass; therefore this proverb says that the vulture curses the cow, wishing him to die. But this does not mean that the cow will die just to oblige the vulture. Similarly, these atheistic vultures want to see God dead so they can take pleasure in thinking, "Now God is dead, and I can do anything I like."

We must know then for certain that there is a controller; that is the beginning of knowledge. Why should we deny this truth? In every field of activity we find some finite controller, so how can we deny the existence of an infinite controller in this creation? It is not without reason therefore that Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu particularly uses this word Jagadéça, Lord of the universe. He does not manufacture the term, for it is found in many different Vedic mantras. For instance:

tava kara-kamala-vare nakham adbhuta-çåìgaà
dalita-hiraëyakaçipu-tanu-bhåìgam
keçava dhåta-narahari-rüpa jaya jagadéça hare
[Daçävatära-stotra 4]

"O my Lord, Your hands are very beautiful, like the lotus flower, but with Your long nails You have ripped apart the wasp Hiraëyakaçipu. Unto You, Lord of the universe, do I offer my humble obeisances."

Hiraëyakaçipu was an atheist who denied the existence of God, but God came as Lord Nåsiàhadeva, a half-man, half-lion incarnation, and killed him. Therefore praise is given to the Lord as supreme controller of the universe and all living entities (jaya jagadéça hare).

There is also another prayer: jagannätha-svämé nayana-patha-gämé bhavatu me: "O Lord of the universe, please be visible unto me." In all these prayers, and in many others, the supreme controller of the universe is acknowledged. Everyone is trying to become supreme controllers, but it is not possible by individual, communal or national effort. Because everyone is trying to be supreme, there is great competition in the world. The world is created in such a way, however, that no one can become supreme. Regardless of what position we place ourselves in, we will find that someone is inferior to us and that someone is superior. No one individual can say, "I am the supreme. No one is above me." Nor can anyone say, "I am the most inferior. No one is below me." Once we think that we are the most inferior, we'll immediately find that someone is inferior to us; and once we think that we are supreme, we'll immediately find someone superior. This is our position.

God's position, however, is not like this. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa asserts His superiority Himself in this way:

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëa iva

"O conquerer of wealth (Arjuna), there is no truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7)

God is asamaurdha, which means that no one is equal to or superior to Him. If we find someone who has no superior, we can accept him as God. God can be defined as one who has no superior and who has no equal. This is the Vedic version. In the Upaniñads it is said, na tat samaç cäbhyadhikaç ca dåçyate: no one is found equal to or greater than Him.

Another characteristic of God is that He has nothing to do. In the material world, when a man is considered very important, he always has a great number of things to do. The President of the United States, for instance, is considered to be the supreme man in the country, but as soon as there is some disturbance in Central Europe or in any other place in the world, he immediately has to call a meeting of his cabinet to consider how to deal with the situation. So even he is required to do so many things. If he does not do anything, he is no longer the supreme man. In Vedic literatures, however, we find that God has nothing to do (na tasya käryaà karaëaà ca vidyate). Kåñëa may act in so many ways in the world, but it is not because He is required to do so. This is indicated in Bhagavad-gétä.

na me pärthästi kartavyaà
triñu lokeñu kiïcana
nänaväptam aväptavyaà
varta eva ca karmaëi

"O son of Påthä, there is no work prescribed for Me within all the three planetary systems. Neither am I in want of anything, nor have I the need to obtain anything—and yet I am engaged in work." (Bg. 3.22)

In this respect it is interesting to note that one European gentleman, who went to Calcutta and visited several temples, noted that in the temple of the goddess Kälé, the deity had a very ferocious figure, with a chopper in hand, and was cutting off the heads of demons and wearing them as garlands. In other temples he saw the deity engaged in similar activities, but when he came to the Rädhä-Kåñëa temple, he said, "I find that in this temple there is God." When asked how he concluded this, he said, "In every temple I saw that the deity was doing something, but here I see that God is simply playing a flute and enjoying Himself. He obviously has nothing to do." This is a very intelligent conclusion; indeed, it is the Vedic conclusion.

Nowadays it is becoming fashionable for people to claim that they are becoming God by meditation. This means that by meditation it is possible to transform oneself into God; in other words, God meditates, and by His meditation He becomes God. This is all nonsense. God is God, and He was always God and will always be God. Even as an infant on the lap of His mother Kåñëa is God. No meditation was required, no austerity or penance. When Pütanä, the demonic witch, came to poison Baby Kåñëa, she came as a beautiful young girl and asked Mother Yaçodä, "Oh, Yaçodämayé, you have a very nice baby. Will you kindly give Him to me so I can nurse Him?" Yaçodä was a very simple village woman, and she said, "Oh yes, you can take my child." Pütanä had smeared poison on her breasts, and she intended to kill Kåñëa by letting Him suck them. This is the demonic spirit; demons are always wanting to kill Kåñëa so they can say, "God is dead. There is no God. God is impersonal." Kåñëa was so kind to Pütanä that He allowed her to nurse Him, but when He sucked her breasts He not only sucked out the poison but her life as well. Pütanä fell to the ground dead and was immediately transformed into her original demonic form. So this is God; in the lap of His mother He is God. He does not have to become God by meditation, penance, austerity or by following rules or regulations. He is substantially and eternally God, and He has nothing to do. If one claims that he can become God by worshiping such and such a deity or by meditating, we should immediately take it that he is not a god, but a dog. In understanding God, we must be careful to accept the Vedic conclusion only: na tasya käryaà karaëaà ca vidyate: God has nothing to do. Why would God have to do something to become God? If we manufacture gold, that is artificial gold, not real gold. Gold is natural, and similarly God is natural. In His childhood pastimes, in the lap of His mother, He is God; while He is playing with His boyfriends, He is God; while He is dancing, He is God; while He is fighting at Kurukñetra, He is God; while He is married to His queens, He is God; and while He is speaking, He is God. There is no difficulty in understanding God. All that is required of us is that we listen to Kåñëa.

In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

aham sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate
iti matvä bhajante mäà
budhä bhäva-samanvitäù

"I am the source of everything; from Me the entire creation flows. Knowing this, the wise worship Me with all their hearts." (Bg. 10.8)

This means that Çré Kåñëa is the fountainhead of Lord Çiva and the origin of Viñëu and of Brahmä, and, of course, of all other demigods and other living creatures. He says further:

mamaiväàço jéva-loke
jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù
manaù-ñañöhänéndriyäëi
prakåti-sthäni karñati

"The living entities in this conditional world are My fragmental parts, and they are eternal. But due to conditioned life, they are struggling very hard with the six senses, which include the mind." (Bg. 15.7)

In the Brahma-saàhitä Lord Brahmä explains that if we are looking for God, here is God.

premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena
santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti
yaà çyämasundaram acintya-guëa-svarüpaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, Who is Çyämasundara, Kåñëa Himself, with inconceivable innumerable attributes, whom the pure devotees see in their heart of hearts with the eye of devotion tinged with the salve of love." (Bs. 5.38)

There are similar descriptions everywhere in Vedic literature, but rascals and demons are so obstinate that even though Kåñëa is confirmed to be the Supreme God by the twelve standard äcäryas (Brahmä, Närada, Çiva, Bhéñma, the Kumäras, Kapila, Manu, etc.) and by Vyäsa, Devala and many other devotees, they still refuse to accept Him. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu also confirms that Kåñëa is the Supreme Godhead, and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam says, kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam. Çrémad-Bhägavatam gives a list of all incarnations of God, and at last concludes that the name Kåñëa, which appears on this list, indicates the Supreme Personality of Godhead, whereas all other names represent manifestations or incarnations. Ete cäàça-kaläù puàsaù. All other names of God are either parts of God or portions of parts. The parts are called aàça, and the portions of parts are called kaläù. As living entities, we are aàça, but we are very fragmental aàça. All others are either aàça or kaläù, but Kåñëa is bhagavän svayam—the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Our prayers should be directed to the Supreme Personality of Godhead and none else. Therefore we pray with Brahmä:

cintämaëi-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña-
lakñävåteñu surabhér abhipälayantam
lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor, who is tending the cows, fulfilling all desire, in abodes built with spiritual gems, surrounded by millions of wish-fulfilling trees, always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds of thousands of Lakñmés, or gopés." (Bs. 5.29)

Here Kåñëa is called the original person (ädi-puruñam). We are all persons. Our father is a person, and therefore we are persons. If we trace our father's father back, we will find that he was also a person, and that his father was a person, and so on all the way back to Lord Brahmä, who was the first created person in this universe. Then we will also find that Lord Brahmä's father, Viñëu, is also a person. Everyone is a person, and Kåñëa is the supreme person. The impersonalists' understanding of God is called niräkära. Niù means "negative" and äkära means "form," so niräkära means "negative form." The impersonalists are mistaken when they think that God has no form at all. The word niräkära does not indicate that He has no form, but that he has no material form as we do. Form is there, but it is not material; it is spiritual form.

What is the value of our form? This form will be changed after a few years, as soon as we give up the body. Our forms are changed just as we change our suits and dresses, but God doesn't have a form like this; therefore He is sometimes called niräkära. Form is there, and that also has been explained in the Brahma-saàhitä. Lord Brahmä describes His form in this way:

veëuà kvaëantam aravinda-daläyatäkñaà
barhävataàsam asitämbuda-sundaräìgam
kandarpa-koöi-kamanéya-viçeña-çobhaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

aìgäni yasya sakalendriya-våttimanti
paçyanti pänti kalayanti ciraà jaganti
änanda-cinmaya-sad-ujjvala-vigrahasya
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is adept at playing on His flute, with blooming eyes like lotus petals, with head bedecked with a peacock's feather, with the figure of beauty tinged with the hue of blue clouds, and His unique loveliness charming millions of Cupids. I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, whose transcendental form is full of bliss, truth and substantiality and is thus full of the most dazzling splendor. Each of the limbs of that transcendental figure possesses, in Himself, the full-fledged functions of all the organs, and eternally sees, maintains and manifests the infinite universes, both spiritual and mundane." (Bs. 5.30, 31)

This form has nothing whatsoever to do with material forms. Impersonalists say, "Oh, you say Kåñëa has a form. If so, how can you say that He is the Supreme? The impersonal Brahman is the Supreme, and the impersonal Brahman is formless." But we have information from Bhagavad-gétä that Kåñëa is the source of the impersonal Brahman.

brahmaëo hi pratiñöhäham
amåtasyävyayasya ca
çäçvatasya ca dharmasya
sukhasyaikäntikasya ca

"And I am the basis of the impersonal Brahman, which is immortal and imperishable, eternal, the constitutional position of ultimate happiness." (Bg. 14.27)

Kåñëa certainly has form, but His form, as stated before, is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, eternal, full of bliss, and full of knowledge. The attributes of His transcendental body are summarized by Lord Brahmä in this way:

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù
sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù
anädir ädir govindaù
sarva-käraëa-käraëam

"Kåñëa, who is known as Govinda, is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal, blissful spiritual body. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin and He is the prime cause of all causes." (Bs. 5.1)

The word Govinda means "He who gives pleasure to the senses." We perceive pleasure through our senses, and therefore Kåñëa, who is the reservoir of pleasure, is called Govinda. If we serve Kåñëa with purified senses, we will begin to relish the pleasure of that supreme reservoir.

How can we describe God or understand His glories? It is not possible. God is unlimited. Regardless of our finite limitations, however, we can express our own feelings and say, "My God, my Lord." This will be accepted. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu teaches us to pray in this way:

ayi nandatanuja kiìkaraà
patitaà mäà viñame bhavämbudhau
kåpayä tava päda-paìkaja-
sthita-dhülésadåçaà vicintaya

"O son of Mahäräja Nanda, I am Your eternal servitor, and although I am so, somehow or other I have fallen in the ocean of birth and death. Please, therefore, pick me up from this ocean of death and fix me as one of the atoms at Your lotus feet." (Çikñäñöakam, 5)

This should be the standard of prayer; we should only want to be placed as one of the atoms at Kåñëa's lotus feet to render service unto Him. Everyone is praying to God with some interest, but even if we pray to God, "Give me some money, give me some relief, a nice house, a nice wife, or nice food," that is also good. Yet this is not to the standard of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu's prayer. Our only prayer should be that the Lord enable us to serve Him birth after birth. Our prayer should be, "Dear Lord, You are so great that I want to engage in Your service. I have been serving all these rascals, and I am not satisfied. Now I have come to You. Please engage me in Your service." This is the last word in prayer. Some people complain that when they pray to God they do not feel His presence. We should know that this is due to our incapacities, not God's. There are two conceptions of presence—the physical conception and the vibrational conception. The physical conception is temporary, whereas the vibrational conception is eternal. When we enjoy or relish the vibration of Kåñëa's teachings in Bhagavad-gétä, or when we chant Hare Kåñëa, we should know that by those vibrations He is immediately present. He is absolute, and because of this His vibration is just as important as His physical presence. When we feel separation from Kåñëa or the spiritual master, we should just try to remember their words of instructions, and we will no longer feel that separation. Such association with Kåñëa and the spiritual master should be association by vibration, not physical presence. That is real association. We put so much stress on seeing, but when Kåñëa was present on this earth, so many people saw Him and did not realize that He is God; so what is the advantage of seeing? By seeing Kåñëa, we will not understand Him, but by listening carefully to His teachings, we can come to the platform of understanding. We can touch Kåñëa immediately by sound vibration; therefore we should give more stress to the sound vibration of Kåñëa and of the spiritual master—then we'll feel happy and won't feel separation.

From Çrémad-Bhägavatam we understand that when Kåñëa departed from this world, Arjuna was overwhelmed with sorrow, but when he began to remember the instructions of Bhagavad-gétä, he became pacified. Arjuna was Kåñëa's constant friend, so when Kåñëa went to His abode, Arjuna was overwhelmed, but just by remembering His teachings he got relief from the pains of separation. Thus whenever we feel separation, it is best to remember the teachings. The teachings of Bhagavad-gétä were imparted to Arjuna for his happiness and for the happiness of all men. This is indicated by Kåñëa, at the beginning of the Tenth Chapter, when He says:

bhüya eva mahä-bäho
çåëu me paramaà vacaù
yat te 'haà préyamäëäya
vakñyämi hita-kämyayä

"Again, O mighty-armed Arjuna, listen to My supreme word, which I shall impart to you for your benefit and which will give you great joy." (Bg. 10.1)

By hearing the words of Lord Kåñëa and following them carefully, we will attain not only peace in the world, but the supreme peace (paräà çäntim). All that is required is that we seek refuge in the lotus feet of Kåñëa and render service unto Him by chanting His glories and pushing this Kåñëa consciousness movement in every town and village of the world. It is Kåñëa's promise that by such surrender peace and eternal life will come automatically.

tam eva çaraëaà gaccha
sarva-bhävena bhärata
tatprasädät paräà çäntià
sthänaà präpsyasi çäçvatam

"O scion of Bharata, surrender unto Him in all respects, so that by His mercy you can have transcendental peace and the eternal abode." (Bg. 18.62)

EK 5: Knowing Kåñëa's Energies

5
Knowing Kåñëa's Energies

[680613BG.MON] & [710829RA.LON] & [710919LE.NAI] & [BTGPY15a: An Essential Service]

For Kåñëa there is no difference between material and spiritual energy. For Him, it is all the same. Sometimes electricity works for cooling purposes, and sometimes it works for heating purposes, but the energy generated from the electric powerhouse is all the same. Similarly, Kåñëa's energy is always spiritual, but it is acting in different ways. In a town there may be a department of welfare and a department of police. In the eyes of the government both are the same, for both are subsidiary parts of the government, but for the individual they render different services. The material energy may be working in different ways that may not be very pleasant to the living entity, but that does not mean that material energy is not liked by Kåñëa. It is as important as spiritual energy, but it is engaged to punish the conditioned soul, just as the police department is engaged in punishing criminals. In the Brahma-saàhitä, it is confirmed that Kåñëa's energy is always spiritual, but it is acting in different ways in different fields of activities. In relation to Kåñëa there is no distinction between the energies, but for our understanding we discriminate and say that sometimes the energy is working in a material way and sometimes in a spiritual way. We are thinking that the energy is hot or cold, good or bad, pleasant or unpleasant, but in fact the energy is the same.

Kåñëa cannot distribute inferior energy because He is not inferior. He is always superior, spiritual, and therefore His energy is always spiritual. Subhadrä is the sister of Kåñëa, and from her comes the incarnation of Durgä, the personification of material energy. Subhadrä is in the spiritual world and is eternally related to Kåñëa as His energy, but when Durgä conducts her activities here in the material world, it is not that she is to be considered inferior. In the Bhagavad-gétä as well as in Brahma-saàhitä it is said that Durgä or Mäyä is acting under Kåñëa's direction, so how can she be considered inferior? Criminals may think that the police department is an inferior governmental department, but the law-abiding citizens do not think that this is so. It simply functions in a particular way. Similarly, the material energy has to act to bewilder the living entity who is under the direction of Kåñëa.

We are the living entities within the material energy, and we are in this position because we wanted to dominate material nature. Kåñëa has given us the facility, saying, "All right, you may try, but you cannot be successful." As long as we are in ignorance of how the laws of nature are working under the supreme direction of Kåñëa, we will continue to be defeated in our activities. When we understand Kåñëa in perfection, we will automatically know the laws of nature and how they are acting. Vaiñëavas are concerned with the background of the laws of material nature. When we understand Kåñëa in perfection, we can understand that there is in actuality no inferior or material energy, but that everything is spiritual. We can understand that on the higher platform whatever we are experiencing are the actions and reactions of the different energies of the Supreme Lord. When we understand Kåñëa perfectly, then these distinctions of superior and inferior energies will disappear. Whatever is engaged in the service of Kåñëa is superior energy. In the higher sense, everything is serving Kåñëa, and those who are highly elevated understand this.

That the Lord has various energies is confirmed in Vedic literatures. Yet the Supreme Lord personally has nothing to do. How is this? He has not to strive for wealth, for all wealth is His; nor for knowledge, for all knowledge is His; nor for power, for all power is His; nor for beauty, fame or renunciation, for they are all His in full. Nor does He directly manage universal affairs, for He has many assistants who can conduct affairs while He remains in His abode. This is confirmed in Çré Éçopaniñad:

anejad ekaà manaso javéyo
nainad devä äpnuvan pürvam arñat
tad dhävato 'nyän atyeti tiñöhat
tasminn apo mätariçvä dadhäti

"The Personality of Godhead, although fixed in His abode, is more swift than the mind, and can overcome all others running. The powerful demigods cannot approach Him. Although in one place, He has control over those who supply the air and rain. He surpasses all in excellence." (Çré Éçopaniñad, Mantra 4)

Thus Kåñëa has no work to perform. As the Supreme Personality of Godhead, He simply engages in enjoying Himself with the gopés (cowherd girls) and His consort Rädhäräëé. Kåñëa, as Kåñëa, does not really engage in killing demons. When Kåñëa kills demons, He is known as Väsudeva Kåñëa, not the original Kåñëa. When Kåñëa expands Himself, He first expands as Balaräma, then Saìkarñaëa, Pradyumna, Aniruddha and Väsudeva. As Väsudeva, He acts in Mathurä and Dvärakä, but as Kåñëa, in His original feature, He remains in Våndävana. This may seem to be confusing; even one of the greatest fiction writers in Bengal misunderstood and thought that Kåñëa of Våndävana, Kåñëa of Dvärakä, and Kåñëa of Mathurä were three different persons. But this is not difficult to understand if we know the nature of Kåñëa's expansions. Kåñëa is the same, and He is the one without a second, but He can expand Himself in billions and trillions of forms. This is all for the purpose of His enjoyment.

In the Tenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa explains His different manifestations to Arjuna in this way:

uccaiùçravasam açvänäà
viddhi mäm amåtodbhavam
airävataà gajendräëäà
naräëäà ca narädhipam

äyudhänäm ahaà vajraà
dhenünäm asmi kämadhuk
prajanaç cäsmi kandarpaù
sarpäëäm asmi väsukiù

"Of horses know Me to be Uccaiùçravä, who rose out of the ocean, born of the elixir of immortality; of lordly elephants I am Airävata, and among men I am the monarch. Of weapons I am the thunderbolt; among cows I am Kämadhuk, giver of abundant milk. Of procreators I am Kandarpa, the god of love; and of serpents I am Väsuki, the chief." (Bg. 10.27-28)

Lord Kåñëa further enumerated the many great manifestations of the material creation and explained how each was representative of Himself. He concluded a long detailed account of these manifestations by saying:

athavä bahunaitena
kià jïätena tavärjuna
viñöabhyäham idaà kåtsnam
ekäàçena sthito jagat

"But what need is there, Arjuna, for all this detailed knowledge? With a single fragment of Myself I pervade and support these entire universes." (Bg. 10.42)

Thus this material world is existing on one plenary portion of Kåñëa. If Kåñëa didn't enter this universe, it could not exist. Similarly, unless the spirit soul, which is a fragmental portion of Kåñëa, enters this body, this body cannot exist. As soon as the spirit soul leaves, the body immediately becomes useless; when Kåñëa enters into matter, matter has value. This is true for the minute individual atom and the great universe as well.

Since the manifestations of Kåñëa are so great, we should know that His enjoyment is far greater than ours. We have to try to understand what kind of enjoyment Kåñëa likes. Everyone knows that God is great, and we can conclude from this that His enjoyment is great also. In this regard, Svarüpa Dämodara Gosvämé has written a verse which says that although the loving affairs of Rädhä and Kåñëa may appear like ordinary material affairs, this is not actually the case. Rädhäräëé is the pleasure potency of Kåñëa. In the Vedänta-sütra the Absolute Truth is said to be always enjoying the pleasure potency. When we want pleasure, we cannot have it alone. We feel pleasure in the company of friends or family. I may speak in a room alone, but if I speak in a room before other people, the pleasure is increased. Pleasure means that there must be others, and therefore Kåñëa, the Absolute Truth, who is always engaged in enjoying Himself, has become many.

We are Kåñëa's parts and parcels and have been created to give pleasure to Kåñëa. The chief pleasure potency is Rädhäräëé, and so Rädhä-Kåñëa are always together. Whereas the material energy is conducted by the external potency, Mäyä, the spiritual world is conducted by the internal potency, Rädhäräëé. We often pray to Rädhäräëé because She is the pleasure potency of Kåñëa. The very word "Kåñëa" means all-attractive, but Rädhäräëé is so great that She attracts Kåñëa. If Kåñëa is always attractive to everyone, and Rädhäräëé is attractive to Kåñëa, how can we imagine the position of Çrématé Rädhäräëé? We should try humbly to understand and offer Her our obeisances, saying, "Rädhäräëé, You are so dear to Kåñëa. You are the daughter of King Våñabhänu, and You are Kåñëa's beloved. We offer our respectful obeisances unto You." Rädhäräëé is very dear to Kåñëa, and if we approach Kåñëa through the mercy of Rädhäräëé, we can easily attain Him. If Rädhäräëé recommends a devotee, Kåñëa immediately accepts him, however foolish he may be. Consequently in Våndävana we find that devotees chant Rädhäräëé's name more often than Kåñëa's. Wherever we go in India we will find devotees calling, "Jaya Rädhe." We should be more interested in worshiping Rädhäräëé, for however fallen we may be, if somehow or other we can please Her, we can very easily understand Kåñëa. If we try to understand Kåñëa by the speculative process, we will have to spend many lifetimes of speculation; but if we take to devotional service and just try to please Rädhäräëé, then Kåñëa can be very easily realized. Rädhäräëé is such a great devotee that She can deliver Kåñëa.

Even Kåñëa cannot understand Rädhäräëé's qualities. He fails to understand Her because She is so great. In order to understand Rädhäräëé, Kåñëa actually accepted Her position. Kåñëa thought, "Although I am full and complete in every respect, I still don't understand Rädhäräëé. Why is that?" This obliged Kåñëa to accept the propensities of Rädhäräëé, and this accounts for His manifestation as Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Caitanya Mahäprabhu is Kåñëa Himself, but He is Kåñëa accepting the propensities of Rädhäräëé. Rädhäräëé is always feeling separation from Kåñëa, and similarly, in the position of Rädhäräëé. Lord Caitanya was always feeling that separation. Furthermore, those who follow the teachings of Lord Caitanya should experience and relish the feelings of separation, not of meeting.

The gosvämés, disciples of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the most perfect and highly elevated beings, never said, "I have seen Kåñëa." Instead, they constantly cried, "Where is Rädhäräëé? Where are Lalitä and Viçäkhä and the other damsels of Våndävana?" In their mature stage of love of Godhead, when they were living in Våndävana, the gosvämés would also cry, "Rädhäräëé, where are You? Where are Your associates? Where are You, O son of Nanda Mahäräja? Where are you all?" In this way they were searching after Kåñëa, and they never at any time said, "Last night I saw Kåñëa dancing with the gopés." Such claims are not made by a mature devotee, but by one who takes things very cheaply. Some people think that Rädhä and Kåñëa are so cheap that They may be seen every night, but this is not the teaching of the gosvämés who were always searching after Kåñëa crying, "Where are You? Where are You Rädhäräëé? Where are You Kåñëa? Are You there by Govardhana Hill? Are You on the bank of the Yamunä?" In this way, throughout the whole tract of Våndävana, the gosvämés were crying and searching after Rädhä and Kåñëa like madmen.

We have to follow in the footprints of the gosvämés and search out Rädhä and Kåñëa in this way. Våndävana is in our hearts, and we must search for Him there. This is the process recommended by Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the process of worship in separation. Feeling separation from Kåñëa, Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu would throw Himself into the sea. Sometimes He would leave His room in the dead of night and disappear. No one would know where He had gone, but all the while He was searching after Kåñëa. Thus it is not that we are to enjoy the loving exchanges between Kåñëa and Rädhä like spectators at some sports show. We must feel separation from Them. The more we feel separation, the more we should understand that we are advancing. With our material senses, we cannot see Kåñëa, nor can we even hear His name. We can begin to perceive Him when we advance in devotional service. That devotional service begins with the tongue, not the legs, eyes or ears. The tongue must be utilized to chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare and take Kåñëa prasädam. Thus the tongue has a dual function, and by utilizing it in this way, we will realize Kåñëa. We cannot see Kåñëa with our material eyes, nor hear about Him with material ears, nor touch Him with our hands; but if we engage our tongue in His service, He will reveal Himself, saying, "Here I am."

This chanting of Hare Kåñëa extinguishes the blazing fire of material nature. This is also the purport to the following prayer to the spiritual master.

saàsära-dävänala-léòha-loka-
träëäya käruëya-ghanäghanatvam
präptasya kalyäëa-guëärëavasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

"The spiritual master is receiving benediction from the ocean of mercy. Just as the cloud pours water on the forest fire to extinguish it, so the spiritual master extinguishes the blazing fire of material existence. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of my spiritual master." (Çré Gurvañöakam, Verse 1)

This material world is often compared to a forest fire which takes place automatically. No one wants a forest fire, but there is often lightning, or carelessness, or friction, or whatever, and the fire immediately takes place. Similarly, this material world is beset with a blazing fire of problems. Everyone wants to live here peacefully, but situations develop in such a way that this is not possible for anyone. We struggle very hard to adjust things in so many ways, but nature's laws are so cruel and dangerous that in spite of our hopes and plans the blazing fire of the problems of material existence continues.

In this century, for instance, we have attempted to put out the fire of war, but it has not been possible. There was a First World War, and then a League of Nations was formed to try to prevent a second, but despite their attempts a second took place. Now a United Nations has been constructed to help end war, but war is going on in Vietnam, in Egypt, in Pakistan and other places. No one wants a Third World War, but it seems imminent. It is not possible to send a fire brigade, a few men with buckets of water, to extinguish a great fire in the forest. To extinguish a roaring forest fire there must be volumes of water; in other words, there must be an arrangement that is beyond human endeavor. When there is a merciful cloud over the forest fire, the cloud bursts, rain pours down in torrents, and the blazing fire is immediately extinguished. As a cloud collects water from the ocean, similarly the spiritual master collects water from Kåñëa's ocean of mercy and pours it over the blazing fire of material existence. Thus one who bestows or distributes the merciful rain of Kåñëa is called a spiritual master or guru.

In Vedic literatures it is said that in order to understand the transcendental science of Kåñëa consciousness, we must try to acquire knowledge of how to extinguish this blazing fire of problems. Scientists, philosophers and other educated men are trying very hard to extinguish it, but the result seems to be bigger and bigger bombs. The karmés or fruitive laborers are working with heart and soul, day and night, to extinguish this fire or to diminish the miserable condition of material existence by dint of hard labor. The jïänés or philosophers are also trying, but they have become disgusted and so proclaim, "This world is false." Thinking this, they try to merge into the existence of the Supreme and in this way extinguish the fire. This is like the jackel who tries to pick some grapes from a vine, and when he fails, says, "Oh, these grapes are sour anyway." The yogés or meditators try to gain superior mystic power by becoming greater than the greatest, smaller than the smallest, lighter than the lightest, and heavier than the heaviest, but this is just so much child's play. With any material body—whether it be great or small, light or heavy—the problems of material existence still remain. In this way one may progress from one stage to another, coming from the stage of karmé or fruitive laborer, to the stage of jïäné or philosopher, to the stage of yogé or meditator, but in any case one finally has to come to the platform of bhakti, or devotional service. This is the real evolutionary process. It is indicated in Bhagavad-gétä in this way:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes, and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19)

Surrender to Kåñëa is the point; that is the aim of life, and the bhaktas, the intelligent men of the world, take to this stage immediately. Therefore Kåñëa says that they are wise men. If, after many, many births one has to come to this point of surrender, then why not immediately?

The blazing fire of material nature is supervised by Durgä. Often she is portrayed with weapons in her hands. She has ten hands, and each holds a different type of weapon. This indicates that she is ruling all ten directions of this universe. She wields the different weapons to chastise the demons. There is one famous picture of a demon struggling with a lion, and the goddess Durgä is pulling the demon's hair and pushing her trident against his chest. If we study this picture we can determine that we are the demon and that the trident is the threefold miseries of material existence from which we are always suffering. Some miseries are inflicted by other living entities, some are inflicted by natural disasters, and some are inflicted by the mind and body themselves. In one way or another we are always struggling against these three types of miseries. No one in the material creation can say that he is free from them. The trident of this material nature is pressed against everyone's chest, and because of this, pure happiness within this material world is not possible. We may try to satisfy Mother Durgä by worshiping her or by giving her some bribe, but Durgä is not so easily bribed.

Therefore we should know that our aim of life should be to understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead. We should make every arrangement—social, political, philosophical or religious—but the aim should be to approach the Supreme Person. In the Vedas it is stated that the learned advanced people, the demigods of the creation, simply look to the lotus feet of Kåñëa. The aim should be the same with human civilization. Without looking to Kåñëa's lotus feet, all religious, social or political endeavors will fail.

It is not possible to make progress as long as our desires are anchored in the material world. In this regard, there is a story of a bridegroom's party who had to go to the bride's house down the river. It was settled that they would start at night by boat and reach the destination early in the morning. Therefore at night, after supper, the jubilant party got aboard a boat, made themselves comfortable and instructed the boatmen to start. Since all the members of the party were seated comfortably, and since the river breeze was very pleasant, they slept soundly that night. In the morning they all got up early, but to their astonishment they saw that the boat had not moved an inch toward the destination, even though the boatmen had rowed vigorously all night long. Finally, after inquiring, they found that despite the boatmen's rowing, the boat had not moved because they had failed to raise the anchor. The marriage ceremony was thus spoiled because of a foolish mistake.

Our present civilization is therefore a mistaken civilization because the mistaken leaders have forgotten to raise the anchor of attachment. Instead, the anchor is being more and more firmly fixed because they have structured the social order on the basis of sense gratification. This sense gratifying social and political set-up, maintained by various plans and schemes, has been described in Bhagavad-gétä, as follows:

kämam äçritya duñpüraà
dambha-mäna-madänvitäù
mohäd gåhétväsad-grähän
pravartante 'çuci-vratäù

cintäm aparimeyäà ca
pralayäntäm upäçritäù
kämopabhoga-paramä
etävad iti niçcitäù

"The demoniac, taking shelter of insatiable lust, pride, and false prestige, and being thus illusioned, are always sworn to unclean work, attracted by the impermanent. Their belief is that to gratify the senses unto the end of life is the prime necessity of human civilization. Thus, there is no measurement for their anxiety." (Bg. 16.10-11)

The leaders, like the boatmen, are all illusioned. They mislead us into taking some temporary benefit, but how long can their plans and schemes go on? If they persist until they die of heart failure or are killed by assassins, then another just like them takes their place. Even the so-called philosophers of modern society are captivated by material name and fame, and so they do not lead the general populace in the proper direction. Thus the anchor of life remains deeply fixed in the waters of nescience for the purpose of sense gratification, and thus our so-called civilization rots in a stagnant pool. Because we are not moving, we are always in the same port of problematic life. All schemes are only useless scraps of paper in the face of war, famine, earthquakes and other disasters. All these disasters are warnings from Mother Durgä, and by them she confirms her eternal superiority over the illusioned planmakers. The different weights on the anchor which keep us grounded in material life are our attachments to the material body due to our ignorance of spiritual facts, our attachment to kinsmen due to bodily relations, our attachment to our land of birth and our material possessions, our attachment to material science and our attachment to religious forms and rituals without knowing their true purpose—all these anchor the boat of the human body in the material universe. Çré Kåñëa, using the example of a strongly rooted banyan tree, advises us in Bhagavad-gétä how to get rid of this attachment once and for all:

na rüpam asyeha tathopalabhyate
nänto na cädir na ca sampratiñöhä
açvattham enaà suvirüòha-mülam
asaìga-çastreëa dåòhena chittvä

tataù padaà tat parimärgitavyaà
yasmin gatä na nivartanti bhüyaù
tam eva cädyaà puruñaà prapadye
yataù pravåttiù prasåtä puräëé

"The real form of this tree cannot be perceived in this world. No one can understand where it ends, where it begins, or where its foundation is. This banyan tree must be cut out with determination, by the weapon of detachment. Thereafter, one must seek that situation from which, having gone, one never comes back. One must surrender to that Supreme Personality of Godhead from whom everything has begun and is extending since time immemorial." (Bg. 15.3, 4)

The Personality of Godhead, who is fully cognizant of everything in His creation, informs us in our best interest that we must desire to get rid of this material existence. We must detach ourselves from everything material. To make the best use of a bad bargain, our material existence should be 100% spiritualized by constant association with Kåñëa's message, His devotees and His names. Therefore everyone who ordinarily engages in material affairs can derive the highest benefit from this Kåñëa consciousness movement. All kinds of spiritual endeavors are more or less tinged with material contamination. However, pure devotional service is transcendental to all pollution. We need not artificially adopt principles of materialism; we need only fix our minds on the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa.

EK 6: Taking to Kåñëa Consciousness

6
Taking to Kåñëa Consciousness

[source: unknown]

In India all scriptures and great spiritual teachers, including Çaìkaräcärya, an impersonalist, accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord. In the beginning of his commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä, Çaìkaräcärya says that Näräyaëa is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested creation, and in the same commentary he says that the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, is Kåñëa appearing as the son of Devaké and Vasudeva. Thus in this respect there is little difference of opinion about Kåñëa. Those who are authorities, be they personalists or impersonalists, are in agreement that Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord.

When Kåñëa was present on this planet, He proved by His activities and opulence that He is the Supreme Lord. If we are actually anxious to understand who and what the Supreme Lord is, all of the information is given in Vedic literatures. If we utilize whatever we have in our possession to understand God, Kåñëa will prove that He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. If we but accept this one fact, then all of our education is complete. It is fashionable to research to try to find out who is God, but this is not necessary. God is present, and He Himself says:

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conquerer of wealth (Arjuna), there is no truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7)

This information is not only given in Bhagavad-gétä but in other scriptures as well, and it has been accepted from the very beginning by great äcäryas (teachers) like Çaìkaräcärya, Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Lord Caitanya and many other stalwart authorities. Even at the present moment those who do not accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord are accepting the knowledge given by Kåñëa to Arjuna. So in this way they are accepting Kåñëa indirectly. If one accepts Bhagavad-gétä as a great book of knowledge, he is also accepting Kåñëa. There is no doubt that the Supreme Absolute Truth is Kåñëa and that we have our eternal relationship with Him.

Our eternal relationship with God is sabhäjana: God is great, and we are subordinate. He is the predominator, and we are the predominated. The duty of the subordinate is to please the predominator. Similarly, if we want to be happy, we must learn how to make Kåñëa happy. This is the process of Kåñëa consciousness.

But how is it to be understood that the Supreme Lord is satisfied by our service and labor? It is actually possible to perfect our service or occupational duty. Everyone has some service to perform according to his designations. He may be an Indian or American, Hindu, Muslim or Christian, man, woman, brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, çüdra or whatever—in any case he is meant to do some sort of work, and that work is his occupational duty. Perfection of duty can be tested by seeing whether the Supreme Lord is satisfied by its execution. The Supreme Lord's satisfaction can be tested by the Lord's representative, the spiritual master. Therefore it is important to seek out a real representative of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and work under him. If he is satisfied, then we should know that the Supreme Lord is also satisfied. That is explained by Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura:

yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädo
yasyäprasädän na gatiù kuto 'pi
dhyäyaà stuvaàs tasya yaças tri-sandhyaà
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

"By the mercy of the spiritual master one is benedicted by the mercy of Kåñëa. Without the grace of the spiritual master no one can make any advancement. Therefore I should always remember the spiritual master. At least three times a day I should offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of my spiritual master." (Çré Gurvañöakam, Verse 8)

The spiritual master is the representative of the Supreme Lord. How does he become the representative? If one says that such and such an object is a pair of spectacles, and if he teaches his disciple in that way, there is no mistake as to the identity of the object. The spiritual master is he who has captured the words of a particular disciplic succession. In the case given, the key word is "spectacles"—that's all. The spiritual master does not have to say anything beyond that. This is the qualification. Kåñëa says, "I am the Supreme," and the spiritual master says, "Kåñëa is the Supreme." It is not that to be a representative of Kåñëa or to be a spiritual master one has to have any extraordinary qualification. He simply has to carry the message from the authority as it is without any personal interpretation. As soon as there is some personal interpretation, the message is lost and the instructions become offensive. A person who interprets the scriptures according to his own whims should be immediately rejected.

Once Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu said, "You must at least have enough sense to test to find out who is a spiritual master and who is not." For instance, if we want to purchase something, we must at least have some idea of what that thing is, otherwise we will be cheated. If we want to purchase a mango from the market, we must at least know what type of food a mango is and what it looks like. Similarly, we must have some preliminary knowledge of the qualifications for a bona fide spiritual master. Bhagavad-gétä itself gives some information about the succession of spiritual masters. Lord Çré Kåñëa says:

imaà vivasvate yogaà
proktavän aham avyayam
vivasvän manave präha
manur ikñväkave 'bravét

evaà paramparä-präptam
imaà räjarñayo viduù
sa käleneha mahatä
yogo nañöaù parantapa

sa eväyaà mayä te 'dya
yogaù proktaù purätanaù
bhakto 'si me sakhä ceti
rahasyaà hy etad uttamam

"I instructed this imperishable science of yoga to the sun-god Vivasvän, and Vivasvän instructed it to Manu, the father of mankind, and Manu in turn instructed it to Ikñväku. This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way. But in course of time the succession was broken, and therefore the science as it is appears to be lost. That very ancient science of the relationship with the Supreme is today told by Me to you because you are My devotee as well as My friend; therefore, you can understand the transcendental mystery of this science." (Bg. 4.1-3)

That original spiritual disciplic succession was broken, but now we can receive the same message by studying Bhagavad-gétä. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa speaks to Arjuna just as in a far distant time He spoke to the sun-god. If we accept the words of Arjuna and Kåñëa, it may be possible for us to understand Bhagavad-gétä, but if we want to interpret it in our own way, the results will be nonsensical. The best way to understand Bhagavad-gétä is to accept a bona fide spiritual master. This is not very difficult.

Arjuna says that he accepts all that Kåñëa has said to him because Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead:

nañöo mohaù småtir labdhä
tvat prasädän mayäcyuta
sthito 'smi gata-sandehaù
kariñye vacanaà tava

"Arjuna said, My dear Kåñëa, O infallible one, my illusion is now gone. I have regained my memory by Your mercy, and now I am fixed without any doubt, prepared to act according to Your instructions." (Bg. 18.73)

As Arjuna, we should accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead and do as He says:

yat karoñi yad açnäsi
yaj juhoñi dadäsi yat
yat tapasyasi kaunteya
tat kuruñva madarpaëam

"O son of Kunté, all that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you may perform, should be done as an offering unto Me." (Bg. 9.27)

By accepting Kåñëa in this spirit, we can attain complete knowledge. If, however, we do not accept Kåñëa and interpret Bhagavad-gétä in our own way, then everything will be spoiled.

If we are sincere, we will get a sincere spiritual master by the grace of Kåñëa. If, however, we want to be cheated, Kåñëa will send us a cheater, and we will be cheated throughout our lives. That is actually going on. For those who do not want to understand Kåñëa as He is but want to understand by dint of their own imperfect vision, Kåñëa, God, remains unknown.

The whole process is to accept Kåñëa and His instructions and therefore to render devotional service unto Him. It is Çrématé Rädhäräëé who is the very embodiment of perfect devotional service. In the Brahma-saàhitä Rädhäräëé is described as Kåñëa's expansion of His spiritual potency. In this way, She is nondifferent from Kåñëa. The gopés, who tend Rädhä and Kåñëa, are not ordinary women or girls; they are expansions of Kåñëa's pleasure potency. Rädhäräëé and the gopés should never be accepted as ordinary women; indeed, to understand their position we need the guidance of a spiritual master. If we living entities want to actually associate with Rädhäräëé, that may be possible, although She is not an ordinary woman. We can become associates of Rädhäräëé by qualifying ourselves in advanced devotional service.

In devotional service there is no frustration; even if we perform only a small amount, it will grow. Devotional service is never lost. As far as material things are concerned, whatever we gain in the world will be lost when the body is finished. But since we are eternal spiritual sparks, our spiritual assets go with us, gradually fructifying. In this way those who have previously cultivated transcendental consciousness come in contact with Kåñëa consciousness through this movement. Interest in Kåñëa consciousness is not commonplace. In Bhagavad-gétä it is said that out of many millions and billions of persons, only one is interested in achieving perfection. If we can advertise that simply by reading this book and meditating for fifteen minutes anyone can immediately get power, become successful in business and pass his examination, many people would be attracted to the book. People are not attracted to Kåñëa consciousness because they prefer to be cheated by mäyä. They think that the perfection of life is in eating a great supply of food, or in sleeping twenty hours, or in having a new mate every night or every day. People are interested in these things, but not in the perfection of life.

Every intelligent man should at least experiment with Kåñëa consciousness. He should say, "All right. I have been enjoying this eating and sleeping for so many lives. These things were available for me to enjoy in my bird and animal bodies. Now in this life let me restrict the four principles of animalistic life—eating, sleeping, defending and mating—and let me devote my time to developing Kåñëa consciousness. In this way my life will be successful."

It is not that we have coined this term "Kåñëa consciousness." Kåñëa consciousness is the oldest phrase in the history of the world:

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi satyaà te
pratijäne priyo 'si me

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi yuktvaivam
ätmänaà matparäyaëaù

"Always think of Me. Become My devotee. Worship Me, and offer your homage unto Me. The result is that you will come to Me without fail. I promise you this, because you are My very dear friend. Engage your mind always in thinking of Me, engage your body in My service; and surrender unto Me. Completely absorbed in Me, surely will you come to Me." (Bg. 18.65, 9.34)

The phrase man-manä bhava mad-bhakto means "just be always conscious of Me." This then is Kåñëa consciousness. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa is repeatedly saying that we should worship Him, offer obeisances unto Him and then come to Him. Bhagavad-gétä clearly points to the absolute necessity of Kåñëa consciousness, and Bhagavad-gétä is accepted as the essence of the Upaniñads. Even from the historical point of view, it has no comparison. It has been calculated on the basis of archeological evidence that Kåñëa spoke Bhagavad-gétä on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra more than five thousand years ago. So this Kåñëa consciousness movement, even from the historical point of view, is five thousand years old. Its philosophy is the oldest in the history of the world. If we wish to trace it even further back, we find that Çré Kåñëa spoke it earlier to the sun-god. Kåñëa is eternal, and consciousness of Kåñëa is also eternal. In this way Kåñëa consciousness should be approached. It should not simply be considered a theory.

When Kåñëa consciousness is covered by any other consciousness, we experience our contaminated conditional life. When the sky is clear, we can see the sun's brilliant effulgence, but when it is covered by clouds, we cannot see it. We may be able to perceive the sunlight, but we cannot see the sun disc itself. When the sky is clear, it is in its natural condition. Similarly, our consciousness is eternally Kåñëa consciousness because we are part and parcel of Kåñëa eternally. This is asserted in the Fifteenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä:

mamaiväàço jéva-loke
jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù
manaù-ñañöhänéndriyäëi
prakåti-sthäni karñati

"The living entities in this conditional world are My fragmental parts, and they are eternal. But due to conditioned life, they are struggling very hard with the six senses, which include the mind." (Bg. 15.7)

Somehow or other we have come in contact with material nature, and because of the mind and the six senses, we are struggling hard to exist. That is Darwin's theory—the struggle for existence, survival of the fittest. However, the actual fact is that our constitutional position is not one of struggle. Struggle is the position of animal life. Human life should be blissful and should have as its goal spiritual advancement. At one time that was India's principle of life, and there was a class of people, the brähmaëas, who engaged themselves exclusively in spiritual culture. Although brahminical cultural life is enunciated in the scriptures of India, it is not for Indians alone, but for all human beings. The Vedas were written for all mankind, but it so happened that when the Vedas were written, what is now known as the Indian culture was the only one extant. At that time, the whole planet was called Bhäratavarña, after Emperor Bharata Mahäräja, the son of Åñabhadeva. Bharata Mahäräja ruled the whole planet, but gradually the planet was divided up. So the dharma of Vedic culture should not simply be considered Indian or Hindu in a sectarian sense.

Often the word dharma is translated to mean religion, but to conceive of dharma as a religion is to misconceive the word. In general usage, the word religion refers to a particular type of faith. The word dharma does not. Dharma indicates the natural occupation of the living entity. For example, wherever there is fire, there is heat and light, so it may be said that heat and light are the dharma of fire. Fire cannot change its dharma. In the same way, liquidity is an intrinsic quality of water, and this quality cannot be changed. If it is, it can no longer be considered water. The dharma of the individual soul can never be changed, and that dharma is the occupational duty of rendering service unto the Supreme Lord. Faiths and religions can be changed. Today I may be a Hindu, but tomorrow I may become a Christian or Moslem. In this way faiths can be changed, but dharma is a natural sequence, a natural occupation or connection.

Kåñëa says that as soon as there is a discrepancy in the discharge of the dharmas of the living entities, when there is an upsurge of unnatural activities, He descends. One of the principal purposes of His descent is to reestablish religious principles. The best system of religion is that which best trains us to surrender unto the Supreme Lord. This is the basic principle underlying Bhagavad-gétä. We can select our own religion and be Hindu, Moslem, Buddhist, Christian or whatever, as long as we know the real purpose of religion. Indeed, Çrémad-Bhägavatam does not recommend that we give up our present religion, but it does hint at the purpose of religion. That purpose is love of Godhead, and that religion which teaches us best how to love the Supreme Lord is the best religion.

In this age especially there is a general decay in the consciousness of the masses of people. A few people remember that there is a God, but for the most part people are forgetting Him. Therefore they cannot be happy. People are thinking that God is dead, or that we have no obligation to God, or that there is no God. This sort of thinking will never make for happiness. When civilization is godless or atheistic, as it is today, God or His representative comes to remind people of their relationship with the supreme consciousness.

When Sanätana Gosvämé inquired from Lord Caitanya, "What am I? Why am I always in a miserable condition? What is the position of all living entities?" Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu immediately answered that the real identity is that of servant of God. We should not understand the word "servant" in the sense of materialistic servant. To become a servant of God is a great position. People are always trying to get some government post or some position in a reputed business firm because the service rendered in such positions earns great profits. Although we are very anxious to get good positions in the government service, we do not stop to think of getting a position in God's service. God is the government of all governments.

God's service is dharma. This dharma may be described differently in different countries according to different cultural and climatic conditions or situations, but in every religious scripture obedience to God is instructed. No scripture says that there is no God or that we as living entities are independent—not the Bible, the Koran, the Vedas or even the Buddhist literatures. Generally, according to Buddhist philosophy, there is no individual soul and no supreme soul, but actually since Lord Buddha is accepted by Vedic literatures as an incarnation of God, by obeying Lord Buddha one is actually following God. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is a list of incarnations, and Lord Buddha is accepted as one of them. Çrémad-Bhägavatam was compiled by Vyäsadeva five thousand years ago, and Lord Buddha appeared about 2,600 years ago, so Çrémad-Bhägavatam actually foretold the event of his incarnation. Lord Buddha preached that there is no God and no soul, that this body is a combination of matter, and that when we dissolve this material combination, sensations of misery and happiness will no longer exist. Then Çaìkaräcärya appeared to preach that the external feature of Brahman, the body, is merely an illusion. In all religions, temple worship and acceptance of authority are present. We may accept Kåñëa, or Lord Jesus Christ, or Jehovah, or Lord Buddha, or Çaìkaräcärya, or Guru Nanak, but in any case acceptance of authority is required.

In Bhagavad-gétä Lord Çré Kåñëa is accepted as the supreme authority. Sometimes Kåñëa descends personally, and sometimes He descends by His incarnations. Sometimes He descends as sound vibration, and sometimes He descends as a devotee. There are many different categories of avatäras. In this present age Kåñëa has descended in His holy name, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu also confirmed that in this age of Kali, Kåñëa has descended in the form of sound vibration. Sound is one of the forms which the Lord takes. Therefore it is stated that there is no difference between Kåñëa and His name.

Today people have forgotten their relationship with God, but this incarnation of Kåñëa in the form of His holy names, this chanting of Hare Kåñëa, will deliver all the people of the world from their forgetfulness. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that if we chant or associate with the chanting of the holy names of Kåñëa, we will reach the highest perfectional stage of life. According to Çrémad-Bhägavatam there are different processes for different ages, but the principle of each process remains valid in all ages. It is not that the chanting of Hare Kåñëa is effective in this age and not in Satya-yuga. Nor is it that people were not chanting the holy names of Kåñëa in Satya-yuga. In Satya-yuga meditation was the main process, and great munis meditated for periods extending upwards of 60,000 years. In this age, however, perfection by that means of meditation is not possible because we are so short-lived. Consequently in this age it is especially recommended that we all sit down together and chant Hare Kåñëa. It is very easy, and everyone can take part in it. There is no necessity of education, nor are any previous qualifications required. In this age people are also very slow and unfortunate, and they are contaminated with bad association. Caitanya Mahäprabhu introduced the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare as a great means of propaganda for spreading love of God. It is not that it is recommended only for Kali-yuga. Actually, it is recommended for every age. There have always been many devotees who have chanted and reached perfection in all ages. That is the beauty of this Kåñëa consciousness movement. It is not simply for one age, or for one country, or for one class of people. Hare Kåñëa can be chanted by any man in any social position, in any country and in any age, for Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord of all people in all social positions, in all countries, in all ages.

GLOSSARY

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS
His Divine Grace
A.C. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI PRABHUPÄDA

"When one is enlightened
with the knowledge by which
nescience is destroyed,
then his knowledge reveals everything,
as the sun lights up everything
in the daytime." Bhagavad-gétä 5.16

Available from:

ISKCON BOOKS 3959 Landmark Street Culver City, California 90230

Softcover $4.95 Hardcover $10.95

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


ISKCON CENTERS AROUND THE WORLD

ISKCON is a worldwide community of devotees dedicated to the principles of bhakti-yoga. Write, call, or visit for further information. Classes are held in the evenings during the week, and a special feast and festival is held every Sunday afternoon.

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Kåñëa knowing Him to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare."
Bhagavad-gétä (7.19)

Kåñëa Consciousness
The Matchless Gift (1974)

BOOKS

by His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 1-4 ( 13 Vols.)
Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (3 Vols.)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
The Nectar of Devotion
Çré Éçopaniñad
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 Vols.)
Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäräja
Transcendental Teachings of Caitanya Mahäprabhu
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
The Perfection of Yoga
Beyond Birth and Death
On the Way to Kåñëa
Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge
Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness
Lord Caitanya in Five Features
Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)

A complete catalogue is available upon request.


International Society for Krishna Consciousness
3959 Landmark Street
Culver City, California 90230


ALL GLORY TO ÇRÉ GURU AND GAURÄÌGA
Kåñëa Consciousness

THE
MATCHLESS
GIFT


by His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda
Founder-Äcärya
International Society for Krishna Consciousness


THE BHAKTIVEDANTA
BOOK TRUST


New York . Los Angeles . London . Bombay


Readers interested in the subject matter
of this book are invited by
the International Society for Krishna Consciousness
to correspond with its Secretary.


International Society for Krishna Consciousness
3959 Landmark Street
Culver City, California 90230


© 1974 by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust (B.B.T.)
All rights reserved

First Printing, 1974: 25,000 copies


Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 73-76634
International Standard Book Number: 0-912776-61-7


Printed in the United States of America.

MG 1: Spiritual Knowledge Through Kåñëa

1/ Spiritual Knowledge Through Kåñëa

[710720LE.NY]

The aim of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to bring all living entities back to their original consciousness. All living entities within the material world are, to varying degrees, afflicted with a type of madness. This Kåñëa consciousness movement aims at curing man of his material disease and reestablishing his original consciousness. In a Bengali poem a great Vaiñëava poet has written, "When a man is haunted by ghosts, he can only speak nonsense. Similarly, anyone who is under the influence of material nature should be considered haunted, and whatever he speaks should be considered nonsense." One may be considered a great philosopher or great scientist, but if he is haunted by the ghost of mäyä, illusion, whatever he theorizes and whatever he speaks is more or less nonsensical. Today we are given the example of a psychiatrist who, when requested to examine a murderer, proclaimed that since all the patients with whom he had come in contact were more or less crazy, the court could excuse the murderer on those grounds if it so desired. The point is that in the material world it is very difficult to find a sane living entity. The prevailing atmosphere of insanity in this world is all caused by the infection of material consciousness.

The purpose of this Hare Kåñëa movement is to bring man back to his original consciousness, which is Kåñëa consciousness, clear consciousness. When water falls from the clouds, it is uncontaminated like distilled water, but as soon as it touches the ground it becomes muddy and discolored. Similarly, we are originally pure spirit soul, part and parcel of Kåñëa, and therefore our original constitutional position is as pure as God's. In Bhagavad-gétä Çré Kåñëa says:

mamaiväàço jéva-loke
jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù
manaù ñañöhänéndriyäëi
prakåti-sthäni karñati

"The living entities in this conditional world are My fragmental parts, and they are eternal. But due to conditioned life, they are struggling very hard with the six senses, which include the mind." (Bg. 15.7)

Thus all living entities are part and parcel of Kåñëa. By Kåñëa it should always be remembered that we are speaking of God, Kåñëa denoting the all-attractive Supreme Personality of Godhead. As a fragment of gold is qualitatively the same as a gold reservoir, so the minute particles of Kåñëa's body are therefore qualitatively as good as Kåñëa. The chemical composition of God's body and the eternal spiritual body of the living entity is the same-spiritual. Thus originally, in our uncontaminated condition, we possessed a form as good as God's, but just as rain falls to the ground, so we come in contact with this material world, which is manipulated by the external material energy of Kåñëa.

When we speak of external energy or material nature, the question may be raised, "Whose energy? Whose nature?" Material energy or nature is not active independently. Such a concept is foolish. In Bhagavad-gétä it is clearly stated that material nature does not work independently. When a foolish man sees a machine he may think that it is working automatically, but actually it is not—there is a driver, someone in control, although we sometimes cannot see the controller behind the machine due to our defective vision. There are many electronic mechanisms which work very wonderfully, but behind these intricate systems there is a scientist who pushes the button. This is very simple to understand: since a machine is matter, it cannot work on its own accord but must work under spiritual direction. A tape recorder works, but it works according to the plans and under the direction of a living entity, a human being. The machine is complete, but unless it is manipulated by a spirit soul, it cannot work. Similarly, we should understand that this cosmic manifestation which we call nature is a great machine and that behind this machine there is God, Kåñëa. This is also affirmed in Bhagavad-gétä where Kåñëa says:

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, producing all the moving and unmoving beings, and by its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again." (Bg. 9.10)

There are two kinds of entities—the moving (such as human beings, animals and insects) and non-moving (such as trees and mountains). Kåñëa says that material nature, which controls both kinds of entities, is acting under His direction. Thus behind everything there is a supreme controller. Modern civilization does not understand this due to lack of knowledge; it is the purpose of this Society for Kåñëa Consciousness, therefore, to enlighten all people who have been maddened by the influence of the three modes of material nature. In other words, our aim is to awaken mankind to its normal condition.

There are many universities, especially in the United States, and many departments of knowledge, but they are not discussing these points. Where is the department for this knowledge that we find given by Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä? When I spoke before students and some faculty members at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, the first question raised was: "Where is the technological department which is investigating the difference between a dead man and a living man?" When a man dies, something is lost. Where is the technology to replace it? Why don't scientists try to solve this problem? Because this is a very difficult subject matter, they set it aside and busily engage in the technology of eating, sleeping, mating and defending. However, Vedic literatures inform us that this is animal technology. Animals are also trying their best to eat well, to have an enjoyable sex life, to sleep peacefully, and to defend themselves. What then is the difference between man's knowledge and animals' knowledge? The fact is that man's knowledge should be developed to explore that difference between a living man and a dead man, a living body and a dead body. That spiritual knowledge was imparted by Kåñëa to Arjuna in the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä. Being a friend of Kåñëa's, Arjuna was a very intelligent man, but his knowledge, as all men's, was limited. Kåñëa spoke, however, of subject matters which were beyond Arjuna's finite knowledge. These subjects are called adhokñaja because our direct perception by which we acquire material knowledge fails to approach them. For example, we have many powerful microscopes to see what we cannot see with our limited vision, but there is no microscope that can show us the soul within the body. Nevertheless, the soul is there.

Bhagavad-gétä informs us that in this body there is a proprietor. I am the proprietor, and others are the proprietors of their bodies. I say, "My hand," but not "I hand." Since it is "my hand," I am different from the hand, being its owner. Similarly, we speak of "My eye," "My leg," "My this," "My that." In the midst of all of these objects which belong to me, where am I? The search for the answer to this question is the process of meditation. In real meditation, we ask, "Where am I? What am I?" We cannot find the answers to these questions by any material effort, and because of this all the universities are setting these questions aside. They say, "It is too difficult a subject." Or they brush it aside: "It is irrelevant." Thus engineers direct their attention to creating and attempting to perfect the horseless carriage and wingless bird. Formerly, horses were drawing carriages and there was no air pollution, but now there are cars and rockets, and the scientists are very proud. "We have invented horseless carriages and wingless birds," they boast. Although they invent imitation wings for the airplane or rocket, they cannot invent a soulless body. When they are able to actually do this, they will deserve credit. But such an attempt would necessarily be frustrated, for we know that there is no machine that can work without a spirit soul behind it. Even the most complicated computers need trained men to handle them. Similarly, we should know that this great machine, which is known as the cosmic manifestation, is manipulated by a supreme spirit. That is Kåñëa. Scientists are searching for the ultimate cause or the ultimate controller of this material universe and are postulating different theories and proposals, but the real means for knowledge is very easy and perfect: we need only hear from the perfect person, Kåñëa. By accepting the knowledge imparted in Bhagavad-gétä, anyone can immediately know that this great cosmic machine, of which the earth is a part, is working so wonderfully because there is a driver behind it—Kåñëa.

Our process of knowledge is very easy. Kåñëa's instruction, Bhagavad-gétä, is the principal book of knowledge given by the ädi-puruña Himself, the Supreme Primeval Person, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is indeed the perfect person. It may be argued that although we have accepted Him as a perfect person, there are many others who do not. But one should not think that this acceptance is whimsical; He is accepted as the perfect person on the evidence of many authorities. We do not accept Kåñëa as perfect simply on the basis of our whims or sentiments. No—Kåñëa is accepted as God by many Vedic authorities like Vyäsadeva, the author of all Vedic literatures. The treasurehouse of knowledge is contained in the Vedas, and their author, Vyäsadeva, accepts Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and Vyäsadeva's spiritual master, Närada, also accepts Kåñëa as such. Närada's spiritual master, Brahmä, accepts Kåñëa not only as the Supreme Person but the supreme controller as well—éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù: "The supreme controller is Kåñëa."

There is no one in the creation who can claim that he is not controlled. Everyone, regardless of how important or powerful, has a controller over his head. Kåñëa, however, has no controller; therefore He is God. He is the controller of everyone, but there is no one superior to Him, no one to control Him; nor is there anyone equal to Him, no one to share His platform of absolute control. This may sound very strange, for there are many so-called gods nowadays. Indeed, gods have become very cheap, being especially imported from India. People in other countries are fortunate that gods are not manufactured there, but in India gods are manufactured practically every day. We often hear that God is coming to Los Angeles or New York and that people are gathering to receive Him, etc. But Kåñëa is not the type of God manufactured in a mystic factory. No. He was not made God, but He is God.

We should know then on the basis of authority that behind this gigantic material nature, the cosmic manifestation, there is God—Kåñëa—and that He is accepted by all Vedic authorities. Acceptance of authority is not new for us; everyone accepts authority in some form or another. For education we go to a teacher or to a school or simply learn from our father and mother. They are all authorities, and our nature is to learn from them. In our childhood we asked, "Father, what is this?" and father would say, "This is a pen," "These are spectacles," or "This is a table." In this way from the very beginnings of life a child learns from his father and mother. He learns the names of things and the basic relations of one thing to another by questioning his parents. A good father and mother never cheat when their son inquires from them; they give exact and correct information. Similarly, if we get spiritual information from an authority and if the authority is not a cheater, then our knowledge is perfect. If we attempt to reach conclusions by dint of our own speculative powers, however, we are subject to fall into error. The process of induction, by which, reasoning from particular facts or individual cases, one can arrive at a general conclusion, is never a perfect process. Because we are limited and our experience is limited, it will always remain imperfect.

If we receive information from the perfect source, Kåñëa, and if we repeat that information, then what we are speaking can also be accepted as perfect and authoritative. The process of paramparä or disciplic succession is this very process of hearing from Kåñëa or from authorities who have accepted Kåñëa and repeating exactly what they have said. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa recommends this process of knowledge:

evam paramparä-präptam
imaà räjarñayo viduù

"This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way." (Bg. 4.2)

Formerly knowledge was passed down by great saintly kings who were the authorities. In previous ages, however, these kings were åñis—great learned scholars and devotees—and because they were not ordinary men the government which they headed worked very nicely. There are many instances in Vedic civilization of kings who attained perfection as devotees of God. For example, Dhruva Mahäräja went to the forest to search out God and by practice of severe penance and austerity found God within six months. Although he was only a five-year-old prince with a very delicate body, he was successful because he followed the directions of his spiritual master, Närada. The first month Dhruva Mahäräja was in the forest, he simply ate some fruits and vegetables once every three days and drank a little water every six days. He finally restricted his inhalation of air and stood for six months on one leg only. After he executed these severe austerities for half a year, God became manifest before him, eye to eye. It is not necessary for us to practice such severe austerities, but simply by following in the footsteps of Vedic authorities we also can see God eye to eye. This vision of God is the perfection of life.

The Kåñëa consciousness process is based on austerity, but it is not very difficult. There are restrictions governing eating and sex life (only prasädam, food first offered to Kåñëa, is taken, and sex is restricted to married life), and there are other regulations which facilitate and foster spiritual realization. It is not possible in these days to imitate Dhruva Mahäräja, but by following certain basic Vedic principles, we can make advancement in spiritual consciousness, Kåñëa consciousness. As we advance, we become perfect in knowledge. What is the use in becoming a scientist or a philosopher if we cannot say what our next life will be? A realized student of Kåñëa consciousness can very easily say what his next life is, what God is, what the living entity is and what his relationship with God is. His knowledge is perfect because it is coming from perfect books of knowledge such as Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

This, then, is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. It is very easy, and anyone can adopt it and make his life perfect. If someone says, "I'm not educated at all, and I cannot read books," he is still not disqualified. He can still perfect his life by simply chanting the mahämantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Kåñëa has given us a tongue and two ears, and we may be surprised to know that Kåñëa is realized through the ears and tongue, not through the eyes. By hearing His message, we learn to control the tongue, and after the tongue is controlled, the other senses follow. Of all the senses, the tongue is the most voracious and difficult to control, but it can be controlled simply by chanting Hare Kåñëa and tasting Kåñëa prasädam, food offered to Kåñëa.

We cannot understand Kåñëa by sensual perception or by speculation. It is not possible, for Kåñëa is so great that He is beyond our sensual range. But He can be understood by surrender. Kåñëa therefore recommends this process:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"Give up all varieties of religiousness, and just surrender unto Me; and in return I shall protect you from all sinful reactions. Therefore, you have nothing to fear." (Bg. 18.66)

Unfortunately, our disease is that we are rebellious—we automatically resist authority. Yet although we say that we don't want authority, nature is so strong that it forces authority upon us. We are forced to accept the authority of nature. What can be more pathetic than a man who claims to answer to no authority but who follows his senses blindly wherever they lead him? Our false claim to independence is simply foolishness. We are all under authority, yet we say that we don't want authority. This is called mäyä, illusion. We do, however, have a certain independence—we can choose to be under the authority of our senses or the authority of Kåñëa. The best and ultimate authority is Kåñëa, for He is our eternal well-wisher, and He always speaks for our benefit. Since we have to accept some authority, why not accept His? Simply by hearing of His glories from Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam and by chanting His names—Hare Kåñëa—we can swiftly perfect our lives.

MG 2: Getting Out the Material Mire

2/ Getting Out the Material Mire

[710721SB.NY]

Our subject matter is most sublime: the glorification of the holy name of God. This subject was discussed by Mahäräja Parékñit and Çukadeva Gosvämé, who noted that a brähmaëa, who was very fallen and addicted to all kinds of sinful activities, was saved simply by chanting the holy names of Kåñëa. This is found in the Sixth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, an epic work by Vyäsadeva describing the pastimes of Lord Kåñëa and elaborating on the philosophy of Kåñëa consciousness.

In the Fifth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the universal planetary systems are very fully explained. Within the universe there are lower, middle and higher planetary systems. Actually, not only the Bhägavatam but all religious scriptures contain descriptions of hellish or lower planetary systems and heavenly or higher systems. Çrémad-Bhägavatam gives evidence of where these planets are and indicates how far they are from this planet, just as astronomers have calculated how far the moon and other heavenly bodies are from earth. Similarly, the Bhägavatam contains descriptions of the various planets.

Even on this planet we experience different climatic conditions. In temperate countries such as the United States, the climate is different from that of a tropical country like India. Just as there are environmental differences on this planet, there are other planets which have far different atmospheres and environments. After hearing a description of such planets from Çukadeva Gosvämé, Parékñit Mahäräja said:

adhuneha mahä-bhäga yathaiva narakän naraù
nänograyätanän neyät tan me vyäkhyätum arhasi

"Sir, I have heard from you about the hellish planets. Men who are very sinful are sent to those planets." (Bhag. 6.1.6)

Parékñit Mahäräja was a Vaiñëava (devotee), and a Vaiñëava always feels compassion for others' distress. For instance, when Lord Jesus Christ appeared, he was greatly aggrieved by the miserable conditions of the people. Regardless of the country or sect to which they belong, all Vaiñëavas or devotees—any people who are God conscious or Kåñëa conscious—are thus compassionate. Therefore to blaspheme a Vaiñëava, a preacher of God's glories, is a great offense.

Kåñëa never tolerates offenses committed at the lotus feet of a pure Vaiñëava. A Vaiñëava, however, is always ready to forgive such offenses. Kåpämbudhi: A Vaiñëava is an ocean of mercy. Väïcä-kalpa-taru: Everyone has desires, but a Vaiñëava can fulfill all desires. Kalpa-taru refers to a tree in the spiritual world which is called a wish-fulfilling tree. In this material world a particular type of fruit can only be gotten from a particular type of tree, but in Kåñëaloka, as well as in all the other planets in the spiritual sky, all the trees are spiritual and will yield whatever one desires. That is described in the Brahma-saàhitä (cintämaëi prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña). A pure Vaiñëava is compared to such a wish-fulfilling tree, for he can bestow a matchless gift upon a sincere disciple—Kåñëa consciousness.

A Vaiñëava is addressed as mahä-bhäga, which means "fortunate." One who becomes a Vaiñëava and is God conscious is understood to be greatly fortunate. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the chief exponent of Kåñëa consciousness in this age, has explained that the living entities in various planetary systems all over the universe are rotating in different species of life. A living entity can go wherever he likes—to heaven or to hell—simply by preparing himself for either place. There are many heavenly planets, many hellish planets, and many species of life. Padma Puräëa estimates the species of life to be 8,400,000, and the living entity is rotating or wandering through these species and creating bodies according to his mentality in his present life. "As you sow, so shall you reap," is the law that governs here. Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that out of these numberless living entities who are transmigrating in the material world, one may be fortunate enough to take to Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa consciousness is being distributed freely everywhere, yet not everyone takes to it, especially in this age of Kali. Because of this, Çrémad-Bhägavatam characterizes people in the age of Kali as unfortunate. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that only those who are fortunate take to this Kåñëa consciousness and thus attain a pleasant and blissful life of knowledge.

It is the duty of a Vaiñëava to go from door to door to try to get unfortunate people to accept good fortune. A Vaiñëava thinks, "How can these people be delivered from their hellish life?" That was also Mahäräja Parékñit's inquiry. "Sir," he said, "you have described that because of one's sinful activities he is put into a hellish condition of life or in a hellish planetary system. Now, what are the methods by which such a person can be saved?" This is a very important question. When a Vaiñëava comes, when God Himself comes, or when God's sons or His very confidential devotees come, their only mission is to save sinful men who are suffering. They have knowledge of how to do this. When Prahläda Mahäräja met Lord Nåsiàhadeva, he said:

naivodvije para duratyaya-vaitaraëyäs
tvadvérya-gäyana-mahämåta-magna-cittaù
çoce tato vimukha-cetasa indriyärtha-
mäyä-sukhäya bharam udvahato vimüòhän
(Bhäg. 7.9.43)

"My dear Lord," Prahläda began, "I am not very anxious for my own deliverance." At this point we may contrast this attitude with that of the Mäyävädé philosophers who are very careful that their personal salvation is never interrupted. They often think, "If I go to preach and associate with others, I may fall down, and my realization will be finished." Therefore they do not come forward to preach. Only the Vaiñëavas come, even at the risk of falldown—but they do not fall down. A Vaiñëava is even willing to go to hell to deliver conditioned souls. This is also Prahläda Mahäräja's mission. He went on to say: "I am not very anxious about living in this material world. I have no anxiety for myself because somehow or other I have been trained to be Kåñëa conscious always." Because Prahläda was Kåñëa conscious, he was confident that in his next life he was going to Kåñëa. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that if one executes the regulated principles of Kåñëa consciousness carefully, it is certain that he will reach the supreme destination in his next life. Prahläda Mahäräja continues: "There is only one source of anxiety for me. I am anxious for those who are not Kåñëa conscious. For myself I have no anxiety, but I am thinking of them." And why aren't people Kåñëa conscious? Mäyä-sukhäya bharam udvahato vimüòhän (Bhäg. 7.9.43). The rascals have created a humbug civilization for temporary happiness.

Mäyä-sukhäya. Actually this is a fact. We have succeeded in creating a humbug civilization. Every year so many cars are being manufactured, and for that purpose so many roads have to be excavated, prepared and repaired. This creates problems after problems, and therefore it is mäyä-sukhäya, illusory happiness. We are trying to manufacture some way to be happy, but we only succeed in creating other problems. The United States has the world's largest number of cars, but that does not solve any problems. We have manufactured cars to help solve the problems of life, but we often experience that this also creates other problems. Once we create cars, we must travel thirty or forty miles just to meet our friends or go to a doctor. We can even go from New York to Boston in less than an hour by plane, but it takes even longer than that just to get to the airport. This situation is called mäyä-sukhäya. Mäyä means false, illusory. We try to create a very comfortable situation, but we only succeed in creating another uncomfortable situation. This is the way of the material world; if we are not satisfied by the natural comforts offered by God and nature, and we want to create artificial comforts, then we have to create discomfort also. Most people, ignorant of this fact, think that they are creating a very comfortable situation, but in actuality they end up traveling fifty miles to go to the office to earn a livelihood and fifty miles to come back.

Due to such conditions, Prahläda Mahäräja says that these vimüòhas, materialistic persons, have unnecessarily burdened themselves simply for temporary happiness. Vimüòhän, mäyä-sukhäya bharam udvahato (Bhäg. 7.9.43). Therefore in Vedic civilization it is recommended that one free himself from material life, take sannyäsa, the renounced order, and execute devotional service with no anxiety.

The taking of the renounced order, however, is not always necessary. If one can execute Kåñëa consciousness in family life, that is also recommended. Although Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura was a family man and magistrate, he still executed devotional service most excellently. Dhruva Mahäräja and Prahläda Mahäräja were also gåhasthas, householders, but they trained themselves in such a way that even as householders they were not faced with interruptions in their service. Therefore Prahläda Mahäräja said, "I have learned the art of always remaining in Kåñëa consciousness." What is that art? Tvad-vérya-gäyana-mahämåta-magna-cittaù (Bhäg. 7.9.43): simply glorifying the victorious activities and pastimes of the Lord. The word vérya means "very heroic." By reading Çrémad-Bhägavatam, we can come to understand that Kåñëa's activities, His fame, His associates and everything else about Him are all heroic. In this connection, Prahläda Mahäräja said: "I am certain that wherever I go, I can glorify Your heroic activities and be saved. There is no question of my falling down, but I am simply anxious for those who have created a type of civilization in which they are always busy working hard. I am thinking of them." Prahläda further says:

präyeëa deva munayaù sva-vimukti-kämä
maunaà caranti vijane na parärtha-niñöhäù
naitän vihäya kåpaëän vimumukña eko
nänyaà tvadasya çaraëaà bhramato 'nupaçye

"My dear Lord, there are many saintly persons and sages who are very interested in their own liberation. They live in solitary places like the Himalayan mountains, they do not talk to anyone, and they are always afraid of mixing with ordinary people in the cities and becoming disturbed or maybe even falling down. They think, 'Better let me save myself.' I regret that these great saintly persons do not come to the cities where people have manufactured a civilization based on constant hard work. Such saints are not very compassionate, but I am anxious for these fallen people who are unnecessarily working so hard simply for the gratification of the senses." (Bhäg. 7.9.44)

Even if there were some point in working that hard, such people do not know what it is. All they know is the sex urge and the brothels that gratify this urge. However, Prahläda Mahäräja has compassion for such people: naitän vihäya kåpaëän vimumukña eko. "My Lord, I do not need salvation alone. Unless I take all these fools with me, I shall not go." Thus he refused to go into the kingdom of God without taking all the fallen souls with him. This is a Vaiñëava. Nänyaà tvadasya çaraëaà bhramato 'nupaçye: "I simply want to teach them how to surrender unto You. That's all. That is my goal."

Surrender is thus emphasized because a Vaiñëava knows that as soon as he surrenders, the path is clear.

naivodvije para duratyaya-vaitaraëyäs
tvad-vérya-gäyana-mahämåta-magna-cittaù
(Bhäg. 7.9.43)

"Somehow or other, let them all bow down before Kåñëa." This is a very simple method. All one has to do is bow down before Kåñëa with faith and say, "My Lord Kåñëa, I was forgetful of You for so long, for so many lives. Now I have come to consciousness of You. Please accept me." That is all. If one simply learns this technique and sincerely surrenders himself to the Lord, his path is immediately opened. This is the aim of a real Vaiñëava.

A Vaiñëava is always thinking about how the fallen conditioned souls can be delivered and is always involved in making plans to do so. The Gosvämés, the chief disciples of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, were such Vaiñëavas, and were thus described by Çréniväsa Äcärya [Ñaò-gosvämy-añöaka 2]:

nänä-çästra-vicäraëaika-nipuëau sad-dharma-saàsthäpakau
lokänäà hitakäriëau tribhuvane mänyau çaraëyäkarau
rädhä-kåñëa-padäravinda-bhajanänandena mattälikau
vande rüpa-sanätanau raghuyugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

"The six Gosvämés—Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé—are very expert in scrutinizingly studying all the revealed scriptures with the purpose of establishing eternal religious principles for the benefit of all human beings. They are always absorbed in the mood of the gopés and are engaged in the transcendental loving service of Rädhä and Kåñëa."

With similar Vaiñëava compassion, Parékñit Mahäräja told Çukadeva Gosvämé: "You have just described the different types of hellish life. Now, tell me how those who are suffering can be delivered. Kindly explain this to me." Adhuneha mahä-bhäga yathaiva narakän naraù nänograyätanän neyät tan me [Bhag. 6.1.6]. The word naraù refers to human beings, or those who are fallen. Narakän naraù nänograyätanän neyät tan me: "How can they be delivered from their fierce miseries and horrible pains?" That is typical of a Vaiñëava heart. Mahäräja Parékñit also said, "Somehow or other they have fallen down to a hellish life, but that does not mean that they should remain in that condition. There must be some means by which they can be delivered, so kindly explain those means."

Çukadeva Gosvämé replied:

na ced ihaiväpacitià yathäàhasaù
kåtasya kuryän mana-ukta-päëibhiù
dhruvaà sa vai pretya narakän upaiti
ye kértitä me bhavatas tigma-yätanäù

"Yes, I have already described various hellish conditions typical of a severe and painful life. The point is that one has to counteract such a life." (Bhag. 6.1.7)

How can this be done? There are various ways in which sinful activities can be committed. One is by the mind. If a person thinks of committing some sinful activity and thus makes a plan—"I shall kill that man"—that is also considered to be sinful. When the mind is thinking, feeling and willing, then there is action. In certain areas of the United States, a dog owner is responsible according to law if his dog barks at someone passing on the road. Although the dog simply barks, the owner is held responsible. The dog is not responsible because it is an animal, but because the owner of the animal has made the dog his best friend, he is responsible by law. Similarly, just as the barking of a dog may be considered unlawful, offensive speech may also be considered sinful, for it is just like barking. The point is that sinful activities can be committed in so many ways—one may think of them, or one may speak sinfully, or one may actually commit a sin. In any case, they are all considered sinful activities. Dhruvaà sa vai pretya narakän upaiti: One has to suffer punishment for such activities.

People do not believe in a next life because they want to avoid botheration and punishment, but the next life cannot be avoided. It is a well known fact that we must act according to law, or we will be punished. If one commits criminal activities, the state will punish him. Sometimes, however, a criminal may escape punishment by the state, but this is not the case with God's law. One can cheat others, commit theft and hide, thereby saving himself from the punishment of the state, but one cannot save himself from the superior law, the law of nature. It is very difficult because there are many witnesses: the daylight is witness, the moonlight is witness, and Kåñëa is the supreme witness. Thus one cannot say, "I am committing this sin, but no one can see me." Kåñëa is the supreme witness sitting within the heart, and He not only notes what one is thinking and doing, but He also gives the living entity facility. If one wants to do something in order to satisfy his senses, Kåñëa gives all facility. This is stated in Bhagavad-gétä [15.15]. Sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöaù: "I am sitting in everyone's heart." Mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca: "From Me come remembrance, knowledge and forgetfulness."

In this way Kåñëa gives us a chance. If we want Kåñëa, He will give us a chance to have Him, and if we don't want Kåñëa, He will give us a chance to forget Him. If we want to enjoy life forgetting Kåñëa, forgetting God, Kåñëa will give us all facility so that we can forget, but if we want to enjoy life in Kåñëa consciousness, Kåñëa will give us the chance to make progress. That is up to us. If we think that we can be happy without Kåñëa consciousness, Kåñëa does not object to that. Yathecchasi tathä kuru. After advising Arjuna, He simply said, "Now I have explained everything to you. Whatever you desire, you can do." Arjuna replied immediately, kariñye vacanaà tava: "Now I shall execute Your order." That is Kåñëa consciousness.

God does not interfere with our tiny independence. If we want to act according to the order of God, then He will help us. Even if one falls down sometimes, if one becomes sincere, thinking, "From this time I shall remain Kåñëa conscious and execute His orders," then Kåñëa will help him. In all respects, even if one falls down, he will be excused and given more intelligence. This intelligence will say, "Don't do this. Now go on with your duty." But if one wants to forget Kåñëa, if he wants to become happy without Kåñëa, the Lord will give so many chances to enable him to forget Him life after life.

Parékñit Mahäräja said: "It is not that if I say there is no God that there will be no God or that I will not be responsible for what I do." The atheists deny God due to their sinful activities. If they thought that there were a God, they would shudder at the thought of punishment; therefore they deny His existence. When rabbits are attacked by larger animals, they close their eyes and think, "I am not going to be killed," but they are killed anyway. Similarly, we may deny the existence of God and His laws, but still God and His laws are there. In the high court, one may say, "I don't care for the law of the government," but he will be forced to accept the government law. If one denies the state law, he will be put into prison and duly punished. Similarly, one may foolishly decry the existence of God by various means ("There is no God," or "I am God"), but ultimately one is responsible for all his actions, both good and bad.

According to the law of karma, or the law governing activities, if we act properly and perform pious activities, we are awarded by good fortune, and if we act sinfully we have to suffer. Therefore Çukadeva Gosvämé says:

tasmät puraiväçv iha päpa-niñkåtau
yateta måtyor avipadyatätmanä
doñasya dåñöväguru-läghavaà yathä
bhiñak cikitseta rujäà nidäna-vit

"You should know that you are responsible, and, according to the gravity of your sins, you should accept some type of atonement as described in the çästras or scriptures." (Bhag. 6.1.8)

Just as doctors are sought when one is diseased, according to the Vedic way of life there is a class of brähmaëas to whom one should go for prescribed atonement for sinful activities. There are different types of atonement. If a person commits a sin and counteracts it by penance, that is atonement. There are examples of this in the Christian Bible. Çukadeva says that one has to execute the prescribed atonement according to the gravity of his sinful activities. A physician may prescribe an expensive medicine or a cheap medicine according to the gravity of the disease. For a headache, he may simply prescribe an aspirin, but if there is some severe illness he may prescribe a surgical operation which will cost thousands of dollars. Similarly, sinful activities are diseases, so one should follow the prescribed cures to become healthy.

By accepting the chain of birth and death, the soul accepts a diseased condition. The soul is not subject to birth, death or disease because it is pure spirit. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says that a soul has no birth (na jäyate) and that it has no death (mriyate).

na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin
näyaà bhütvä bhavitä vä na bhüyaù
ajo nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëo
na hanyate hanyamäne çarére

"For the soul there is never birth or death. Nor, having once been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain." (Bg. 2.20)

Modern civilization is in dire need of an educational system to give people instructions on what happens after death. In actuality the present educational system is most defective because unless one knows what happens after death, one dies like an animal. An animal does not know that he is subject to death or that he is going to have to take another body. Human life, however, should be more elevated. One should not simply be interested in the animalistic functions of eating, sleeping, defending and mating. A living entity may have an abundant supply of food for eating, or many nice buildings for sleeping, or good arrangements for sex life, or a good defense to protect him, but this does not mean that he is a human being. A civilization which is based on these activities should be known to be animalistic. Since animals are also interested in these functions, what is the difference between human life and animal life if a human being does not go beyond them?

The distinction can be made when a human being becomes inquisitive and asks, "Why have I been put into this miserable condition? Is there any remedy for it? Is there perpetual eternal life? I do not want to die, nor do I want to suffer. I want to live very happily and peacefully. Is there a chance for this? What is the method or science by which this can be achieved?" When these questions are asked, and steps are taken to answer them, our human civilization is the result. If the questions never arise, then that civilization should be known as animalistic. Animals and animalistic human beings are simply interested in continuing the process of eating, sleeping, mating and defending, but in actuality this process is forced to break down. The fact is that there is no real defense because no one can protect himself from the hands of cruel death. For instance, Hiraëyakaçipu, who wanted to live forever, underwent severe austerities, but he was foiled in the end by the Lord Himself in the form of a lion-man, Nåsiàhadeva, who killed Hiraëyakaçipu with His claws. So-called scientists are now claiming that some time in the future we shall stop death by scientific methods, but this is simply another crazy utterance. Stopping death is not at all possible. We may make great advancements in scientific knowledge, but there is no scientific solution to the fourfold miseries of birth, death, old age and disease.

One who is intelligent should be eager to solve these four principal problems—birth, death, old age and disease. No one wants to die, but there is no remedy. Everyone has to die. Everyone is very anxious to stop the skyrocketing increase of population by employing contraceptive methods, but still birth is going on. There is no stoppage of death, and there is no stoppage of birth. Nor can diseases be stopped, nor can old age, despite all of the latest inventions in medicine.

One might think that he has solved all the problems of his life, but where is the solution to these four problems of birth, death, old age and disease? That solution is Kåñëa consciousness. Every one of us is giving up his body at every moment, and the last phase of giving up this body is called death. But Kåñëa also says:

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9)

What happens to such a person? Mäm eti—He returns to Kåñëa. If we are to go to Kåñëa, we must prepare a spiritual body. That preparation is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. If one keeps himself in Kåñëa consciousness, he gradually prepares his next body, a spiritual body, which will carry him immediately to Kåñëaloka, Kåñëa's abode, and he will become happy living there perpetually and blissfully.

MG 3: Learning to love

3/ Learning to Love

[710722SB.NY] &[710724SB.NY]

Contamination from sinful activity requires proportionate atonement. That is the prescription of the scriptures. Çukadeva Gosvämé says that if one accepts atonement before death, in his next life he will not fall down. If he does not atone, he will carry with him the resultant reactions of his sinful activities and will have to suffer. According to law, if a man kills someone he must himself be killed. The idea of a life for a life is not a very new concept but can be found in the Manu-saàhitä, the Vedic lawbook for mankind, where it is stated that when a king hangs the murderer, the murderer is actually benefited, for if he is not killed, he will carry the reaction for his murder and will have to suffer in so many ways.

The laws of nature are very subtle and are very diligently administered, although people do not know it. In the Manu-saàhitä the concept of a life for a life is sanctioned, and it is actually observed throughout the world. Similarly, there are other laws which state that one cannot even kill an ant without being responsible. Since we cannot create, we have no right to kill any living entity, and therefore man-made laws that distinguish between killing a man and killing an animal are imperfect. Although there are imperfections in man-made laws, there cannot be defects in the laws of God. According to the laws of God, killing an animal is as punishable as killing a man. Those who draw distinctions between the two are concocting their own laws. Even in the Ten Commandments it is prescribed, "Thou shall not kill." This is a perfect law, but by discriminating and speculating men distort it. "I shall not kill man, but I shall kill animals." In this way people cheat themselves and inflict suffering on themselves and others. In any case, however, God's laws will not excuse such behavior.

Everyone is God's creature, although in different bodies or dresses. God is considered the one supreme father. A father may have many children, and some may be intelligent and others not very intelligent, but if an intelligent son tells his father, "My brother is not very intelligent; let me kill him," will the father agree? Simply because one son is not very intelligent and the other desires to kill him to avoid the burden, the father will never agree. Similarly, if God is the supreme father, why should He sanction the killing of animals who are also His sons? In Bhagavad-gétä God declares to Arjuna that all 8,400,000 species of living entities are His sons. "And I am their seed-giving father," the Lord says. Just as in ordinary material procreation the father gives the seed and the mother develops the body by supplying the necessary blood to the embryo, similarly, the living entities, parts and parcels of the supreme father, are impregnated by the Lord in material nature.

The dimension of the spirit soul is very minute and is given in the scriptures as keçägra—one ten thousandth the portion of the tip of a hair. We can hardly imagine a very small point divided into thousands of parts. In other words, it is so minute that it cannot be perceived even by the most powerful microscope. Thus the dimension of the spiritual spark is so minute that it is invisible to mundane vision. All of this information is given in the scriptures, but because we do not have the proper vision, we cannot see. Although our material eyes cannot perceive the dimension of the soul, the soul is nonetheless within the body, and as soon as it departs, it takes another body according to its work.

One should always consider that behind all these activities is superior superintendence. The living entity works in the material world just as the office worker works at his job, and a service record is kept of his performance. The living entity does not know what the opinion of his superior is, but his service record is kept in the office nonetheless, and according to his activities he is awarded promotion or increment of pay, or sometimes he may be demoted or even fired. Similarly, for all our activities there are witnesses; therefore it is said in the scriptures that the living entities are under superior supervision and that they are rewarded and punished according to their work. Now we have human bodies, but in the next life we may not have them; we may have something else, better or lower. The type of body is decided by the living entity's superiors. Generally the living entity does not know the science of how the spirit soul transmigrates from one body to another.

The spirit soul transmigrates even in the duration of one life as the body changes. When the body is first manifest in the womb of the mother, it is very small, just like a pea, and it gradually develops nine holes—two eyes, two ears, two nostrils, one mouth, one genital, and one rectum. In this way the body develops, and as long as it needs to develop within the mother's womb, it remains there. When it is sufficiently developed to go outside, it comes out and grows. Growth entails changing of the body. This change cannot be understood because it is imperceivable to the living entity. In childhood we had small bodies which now no longer exist; therefore it can be said that we have changed our bodies. Similarly, because of the nature of material things, we have to change this body when it ceases to work. Every material thing deteriorates, and like a broken machine or an old piece of cloth the body becomes useless after a certain length of time.

Although this process of growth is always taking place, the educational system in modern universities, though considered advanced, unfortunately does not deal with this. Actually there is no education without spiritual knowledge. One can learn to earn bread, eat, sleep and mate without a formal education. Animals are not educated—they are not technicians, and they have no university degrees—but they are also eating, sleeping, mating and defending. If the educational system simply teaches these processes, it does not deserve the name of education. Real education enables us to understand what we are. As long as man does not develop his consciousness by understanding the truth of the self, all of his actions will be performed in the mode of ignorance. A human life is meant for victory over the laws of material nature. Actually, we are all trying to attain that victory in order to counteract the onslaught of material nature. The ultimate victory is to conquer birth, death, disease and old age, but we have neglected this important point.

If the educational system dealt with the proper utilization of what God is supplying, it would improve. All the fruits and grains we eat are given by God, who supplies food to all living entities. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated, jévo jévasya jévanam: "One living entity is food for another." (Bhäg. 1.13.47) Animals without hands are food for animals with hands, such as ourselves. Animals with no legs are food for animals with four legs. Grass is a living entity, but it has no legs with which to move, and thus it is eaten by cows and other animals. Such nonmoving entities are food for moving animals, and in this way the world is in a constant struggle between exploiters and exploited. The weaker is exploited by the stronger; this is nature's law. Traditionally, Vaiñëavas, or devotees of Kåñëa, do not eat meat. This is not just for the sake of vegetarianism, but for the furtherance of God consciousness. In order to become God conscious, one must follow some rules and regulations. Of course one has to eat, but the proposal is that one should eat remnants of foodstuffs that are offered to Kåñëa. This is also the philosophy of Bhagavad-gétä, wherein Kåñëa says:

patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà
yo me bhaktyä prayacchati
tad ahaà bhakty-upahåtam
açnämi prayatätmanaù

"If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit or water, I will accept it." (Bg. 9.26)

It is not that Kåñëa is hungry and is begging food from us. The purpose of this offering is to create a loving transaction. Kåñëa wants this transaction: "You love Me, and I'll love you." As God, Kåñëa's energy creates and sustains everything, so why should He beg a leaf, a fruit and a little water from us? He will be very pleased, however, if we offer Him a piece of fruit, a leaf and water with love, saying, "Kåñëa, I am so poor that I cannot secure anything. I have secured this fruit and a leaf. Kindly accept them." Such an offering would make Kåñëa very glad. If He eats what we offer, our life will be successful, for we will actually make friends with Kåñëa. Fruit, flowers and water can be secured practically in any part of the world by any man, poor or rich, and can be offered. We should remember then that it is not vegetarianism which is important, nor is it that God is in need of anything. The important point is that we simply have to try to learn how to love Kåñëa.

Love begins with this give and take. We give something to our lover, he gives something to us, and in this way love develops. When we create any loving transaction with any boy or girl, man or woman, we give and take. Thus Kåñëa is teaching us how to give and take. Kåñëa is begging us: "Try to love Me. Learn how to love Me. Offer something to Me."

"Sir," we may say, "I have nothing to give You."

"Oh, you cannot collect a piece of fruit, a flower, a leaf or a little water?"

"Oh yes, why not? Anyone can collect this."

This, then, is the method of Kåñëa consciousness which allows one to make friends with Kåñëa. We can enter into any number of relationships with Kåñëa. We can become a direct servant of Kåñëa, or in the highest stages we can become Kåñëa's father, mother or lover. Kåñëa is prepared to establish a loving relationship with all living entities. In actuality this relationship is already there because He is the supreme father and we are His parts and parcels. Because the son is part of the body of the father, the relationship between them cannot be broken; it may be forgotten for some time, but as soon as one recognizes his father or son, immediately affection develops. Similarly, we are eternally related to Kåñëa, but at the present moment this relationship is simply forgotten or suppressed. Consequently, we think that we have no relationship with Kåñëa, but this is not a fact. Because we are integral with Him, because we are part and parcel of Him, our relationship with Him is eternal. That relationship simply has to be revived, and that revival is this process of Kåñëa consciousness.

At present we are under the sway of a different consciousness. One person is thinking that he is Indian, another is thinking that he is American, and someone else is thinking, "I am this," or "I am that." In this way we create so many artificial identities, but our actual identity should be, "I am Kåñëa's." When we think in this way, we are thinking in Kåñëa consciousness. Only in this way can universal love among all living entities be established. Kåñëa is related to everyone as eternal father, and consequently when we establish a Kåñëa conscious relationship, we become related to everyone. When one marries, he automatically establishes a relationship with the spouse's family. Similarly, if we reestablish our original relationship with Kåñëa, we will establish our true relationship with everyone else. That is the ground for real universal love. Universal love is artificial and cannot endure unless we establish our relationship with the center. One is American if he is born in America, and thus other Americans become members of his family, but if he is born elsewhere, he has no relationship with Americans. On the mundane platform all relationships are relative. Our relationship with Kåñëa, however, is eternal and not subject to time and circumstance. When we reestablish our relationship with Kåñëa, the questions of universal brotherhood, justice, peace and prosperity will be answered. There is no possibility of realizing these higher ideals without Kåñëa. If the central point is missing, how can there be brotherhood and peace?

In Bhagavad-gétä the peace formula is clearly given. We have to understand that Kåñëa is the only enjoyer. The consciousness of this is developed in a Kåñëa conscious temple where the central point of all activities is Kåñëa. All cooking is carried on for Kåñëa, not for one's own purposes. Ultimately we shall eat the prasädam (offered food), but when we cook we should think that we are cooking for Kåñëa and not for ourselves. When the members of a temple go into the streets, they do not do so for their own sake but to distribute Kåñëa conscious literatures in order to make people aware of Kåñëa's presence. All monies acquired are spent for Kåñëa, in spreading His message in so many ways. Such a style of life, in which everything is done for Kåñëa, promotes the development of Kåñëa consciousness within the living entity. Our activities may remain the same; we simply have to understand that we are acting for Kåñëa and not for our personal satisfaction. In this way we can come to our original consciousness and be happy. Unless one is established in his original consciousness, which is Kåñëa consciousness, he is certain to be crazy to some degree. Everyone who is not Kåñëa conscious is to be considered crazy because he exists on a platform which is temporary and transient. Since we as living entities are eternal, temporary activities are not our concern. Our engagements should be eternal because we are eternal, and that eternal engagement is the rendering of service to Kåñëa in love.

Kåñëa is the supreme eternal, and we are subordinate eternals. Kåñëa is the supreme living entity, and we are subordinate living entities. The finger is part and parcel of the total body, and its eternal function is to serve the body. Indeed, that is the very purpose for the finger, and if it cannot serve the whole body, it is diseased or useless. Similarly, as part and parcel we have to serve Kåñëa and be subordinate to Him because as the supreme father He supplies all our necessities. Such a life of subordination to Kåñëa is a normal life and is a life of actual liberation. Those who try to deny Kåñëa and live outside of any relationship to Him are actually leading a sinful life.

Çukadeva Gosvämé and Mahäräja Parékñit discussed this subject, and Parékñit Mahäräja was anxious to know how the conditioned souls could be saved from their hellish lives. It is the natural desire of a Vaiñëava to save suffering humanity. Generally others do not care whether people suffer or not, but a Vaiñëava, a devotee of the Lord, is always thinking of how to alleviate the fallen condition of the people. Christians believe that through His crucifixion Lord Jesus Christ assimilated all the sinful activities of the world's people. A devotee of the Lord is always thinking of how to assimilate the sufferings of others. A similar devotee was Väsudeva Datta, who was Lord Caitanya's associate. He told the Lord: "Now that You have come, kindly deliver all people on this earth and take them to Vaikuëöha, the spiritual world. And if You think that they are so sinful that they cannot be delivered, please transfer all their sins unto me. I shall suffer for them." This is a Vaiñëava's mercy. However, it is not that Jesus Christ or Väsudeva Datta should make a contract for our sins and that we should go on committing them, for this is a most heinous proposal. A Vaiñëava or devotee may suffer for all humanity, but the human race or a particular devotee's disciples should not take advantage of this facility and continue to commit sins. One should, rather, realize that since Lord Jesus Christ or Väsudeva Datta suffered for him, he should stop committing sins.

Factually everyone is responsible for his own sinful activities. Therefore Çukadeva Gosvämé recommends, tasmät puraiväçv iha päpa-niñkåtau: In order to free oneself from all the reactions of sinful activities, as long as one is embodied, he should atone. Yateta måtyor avipadyatätmanä doñasya dåñövä guru-läghavaà yathä bhiñak cikitseta rujäà nidäna-vit [Bhag. 6.1.8]. According to one's sinful activities, he should accept a program of atonement. As mentioned before, there are different atonements for different sinful activities. In any case, before death one should perform atonement so that he does not carry sinful activities into his next life and have to suffer then. If some atonement for our sinful activities is not performed, nature will not excuse us. We will have to suffer the effects of our sins in the next life. Such bondage to one's material activities is called karma-bandhanaù.

yajïärthät karmaëo 'nyatra
loko 'yaà karma-bandhanaù
tad-arthaà karma kaunteya
mukta-saìgaù samäcara

"Work done as a sacrifice for Viñëu has to be performed, otherwise work binds one to this material world. Therefore, O son of Kunté, perform your prescribed duties for His satisfaction, and in that way you will always remain unattached and free from bondage." (Bg. 3.9)

One may kill an animal to enjoy eating it, but he will be bound by such an action. Thus in one's next life he will become a cow or a goat, and the cow or goat will become a man and eat him. This is the Vedic statement, and as with all Vedic statements, one may believe it or not. Unfortunately, at present people are educated in such a way that they do not believe in the next life. Indeed, it seems that the more "educated" one becomes, the less he believes in God, in God's law, in the next life and in sinful and pious activities. Thus modern education is simply preparing men to become animals. If there is no education to teach a human being what he is and whether or not he is this body, he remains no better than an ass. An ass also thinks, "I am this body," as do other animals. Thus if a man thinks in the same way, how is he different from any other animal? Çrémad-Bhägavatam states:

yasyätma-buddhiù kuëape tridhätuke
sva-dhéù kalaträdiñu bhauma ijyadhéù
yat tértha-buddhiù salile na karhicij
janeñv abhijïeñu sa eva gokharaù

"For one who accepts the body—which is made of three elements—as his self, who has an affinity for intimate bodily relationships with his wife and children, who considers his land worshipable and who accepts the waters of holy places of pilgrimage but does not take advantage of the knowledge of the saintly persons there, is to be considered to be in illusion and no better than an ass or a cow." (Bhäg. 10.84.13) According to Äyur Veda, the material body is composed of three elements, kapha-pitta-vätaiù—mucus, bile and air. Within the body there is complex machinery which transforms food into liquid. There are so many complicated bodily processes going on, but what do we know of them? We say, "This is my body," but what do we know about this body? Some people even claim, "I am God," but they do not even know what is going on within their own bodies.

The body is a bag of stool, urine, blood and bones. If one believes that intelligence comes out of stool, urine, blood and bones, he is a fool. Can we create intelligence by mixing stool, urine, bones and blood? Nonetheless people still think, "I am this body." Therefore the scriptures say that whoever accepts this body as the self and accepts the bodily relations of wife, children and family as his own, is illusioned. The word kalatra means wife, and ädi means beginning. Because a man feels alone, he accepts a wife, and immediately there are children and then grandchildren. In this way there is expansion. Stré means "that which expands," so kalaträdiñu means "expansions of the self," beginning from the wife. The word bhauma refers to the land of one's birth, which the ignorant consider worshipable (ijyadhéù). People are willing to give up their lives for the land where they were born, but they do not know that land, body, wife, children, country and society really have nothing to do with them. We are spirit soul (ahaà brahmäsmi). This is realization of knowledge, and when we come to this point of knowledge, we become happy.

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"He who is transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments nor desires anything. He is equally disposed to all the living entities, and in that state he achieves pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54) One immediately becomes jolly (prasannätmä) when he comes to understand "I am spirit soul. I am Brahman. I am not this matter." The sign of this joy is that one no longer feels hankering and lamentation. Within this world everyone is subject to lamentation for that which is lost and hankering for that which must be gained, but real gain is to understand oneself and to know one's own identity.

As long as we maintain the bodily conception of life, we have to abide by the laws of material nature as well as the laws of the state and all other laws. Thus this body is called conditional, because it is subject to different conditions. There are varieties of conditions, and regardless of the condition to which we are subjected, we are responsible. If we do not atone for sinful activities committed while in this body, we will have to suffer in the next body because we will get another body according to karma (yaà yaà väpi smaran bhävaà tyajaty ante kalevaram). That is nature's law. Çukadeva Gosvämé therefore recommends that one undergo atonement according to the gravity of his sinful activities. One must follow the methods of atonement prescribed in the çästras, otherwise there is no rescue.

Parékñit Mahäräja, who was very intelligent, said, "By atonement one can become free from sinful activity, but suppose a man has committed murder and then is killed—the sinful reaction of his murder is thus neutralized, but it is not guaranteed that in his next life he'll not kill another man." Thus Parékñit Mahäräja noted that after atoning, people commit the same sins again. If a man is diseased, the physician may give him medicine and cure him, but it does not guarantee that he will not be attacked again by the same disease. Venereal diseases are often contacted again and again, despite cures, and a thief may steal again and again, despite being repeatedly being thrown into jail. Why is this? Therefore Parékñit Mahäräja noted that although atonement may be good for counteracting sinful activities already committed, it does not prevent those sins from being committed again. Everyone can see that a man who commits murder is punished, but seeing this is not enough to deter one from killing. In every scripture and in every lawbook man is warned not to kill, yet no one is concerned with these laws. What is the remedy for this? Dåñöa-çrutäbhyäà yat päpaà (Bhag. 6.1.9). By practical experience and by hearing from authorities, everyone knows what sinful activity is, and no one can say, "I do not know what sin is." What is the value of atonement if one commits the same sin again and again after atoning? Kvacin nivartate 'bhadrät kvacic carati tat punaù präyaçcittam ato 'pärthaà manye kuïjara-çaucavat (Bhag. 6.1.10). When one is being punished, he thinks, "What a mistake I have made! I shall not commit this sin anymore." But as soon as he is out of danger, he again commits the same sin.

Habit is second nature; it is very difficult to break. Çvä yadi kriyate räjä/ tat kià näçnäty upänaham (Hitopadeça): One may seat a dog on a royal throne, but as soon as he sees a shoe, he will immediately jump down and run after it simply because he is a dog. The canine qualities are there, and they cannot be changed simply by putting the dog on a throne. Similarly, we have acquired material qualities by associating with the three modes of material nature—sattva guëa, rajo guëa and tamo guëa—and our habits are formed by association with these three qualities, which are the qualities of goodness, passion and ignorance. If, however, we disassociate ourselves from the three modes of material nature, our real spiritual nature is invoked. That is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. If one is Kåñëa conscious, there is no chance of his associating with the three modes of material nature, and when one is conscious of Kåñëa, one's spiritual nature is automatically invoked. That is the secret. Those who seriously follow the process of Kåñëa consciousness, though previously habituated to many undesirable things, are able to stay on a platform where there is no material contamination simply by virtue of practicing Kåñëa consciousness.

Thus Kåñëa consciousness is an excellent medicine. Unless one comes to awareness of Kåñëa, the habits he forms in association with the three modes of material nature will continue, and he will not be able to change them. If one actually wants freedom from the repetition of birth and death, he must come to Kåñëa consciousness. In Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa says:

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman." (Bg. 14.26)

The Kåñëa consciousness process does not recommend this atonement or that atonement. One can go on experimenting by atoning, but the diseases of the soul will remain unless one comes to the platform of rendering devotional service in love and purifying his life.

MG 4: Learning Tapasya, Self-Control

4/ Learning Tapasya, Self-Control

[680912SB.SF] & [710725SB.NY] & [710725BS.NY]

If one does not come to Kåñëa consciousness, he may be relieved for the time being from the reactions of sinful activities, but he will again commit transgressions. Therefore Parékñit Mahäräja said: kvacin nivartate 'bhadrät kvacic carati tat punaù präyaçcittam ato 'pärtham (Bhag. 6.1.10): "Repetitive sinning and atoning seem to me like nothing but a waste of time." He gave the example of an elephant which cleanses his body thoroughly in a lake or reservoir, but as soon as he comes onto shore he takes dust and throws it all over his body and immediately becomes dirty again. Thus Parékñit Mahäräja said that although one may cleanse himself in the process of atonement, if he again commits the same sinful acts, what is the use? Therefore the second question put by Parékñit Mahäräja to Çukadeva Gosvämé is very important: How can one ultimately become free from all contamination brought about by the material modes of nature? If one cannot achieve liberation, what is the use of atonement?

In answer, Çukadeva Gosvämé said that merely counteracting karma, fruitive activities, by other activities cannot bring one's miseries to a final end. For example, the United Nations is attempting to establish peace in the world, but they cannot stop war. War breaks out again and again. After the First World War statesmen and diplomats manufactured the League of Nations. Then the Second World War came, and now they have devised the United Nations, but war is still going on. The actual goal is to stop war, but that cannot be done. By one action war is created, and by another action war is stopped for the time being, but again at the next opportunity there is another war. The cycle of sinful activities and atonement is like that. What we actually want is to be free from suffering and war, but that does not happen.

Çukadeva Gosvämé said that one kind of war causes a disturbance, and another kind of war stops it for some time, but that is not the ultimate solution to the problem. Çukadeva states that these troubles happen due to ignorance: avidvad-adhikäritvät. Avidvat means "lack of knowledge." Avidvat-adhikäritvät präyaçcittaà vimarçanam. Real atonement is performed in knowledge. Why is there fighting and why are there miseries? Unless these "why" questions, which in the Vedas are called Kena Upaniñad, arise in one's mind, one is not fulfilling the proper function of his human life. These questions must arise: "Why am I suffering? Wherefrom have I come? What is my constitutional position? Where shall I go after death? Why am I put into a miserable form of life? Why are there birth, death, old age and disease?"

How can these questions be solved? Çukadeva Gosvämé says: näçnataù pathyam evännaà vyädhayo 'bhibhavanti hi/ evaà niyamakåd räjan çanaiù kñemäya kalpate. If one wants to actually stop diseased life, he must follow a regulative principle. If a person does not follow the program given by a physician to cure his disease, he cannot be cured. Similarly, if one does not think or act wisely, as Vedic knowledge prescribes, how can he stop the problems of life? Simply by atonement there may be a temporary suppression of difficulties, but they will arise again.

Çukadeva Gosvämé says that in material or sinful life we act in a way in which we are forced to commit sins and suffer as a result. This is so, and if we want to stop this cycle of suffering and victimization, we have to advance in knowledge. Ordinary people, or karmés, are fruitive actors who work all day and night to get some enjoyable results and then again suffer. Thus the problems of such karmés are never solved. It is suggested therefore that one elevate himself to the platform of knowledge as prescribed in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The first necessity is tapasya, or acceptance of austerity. If a doctor advises a diabetic patient not to eat but to starve for some days, although no one likes to starve, the patient must voluntarily accept starvation if he wants to be cured. This is tapasya: voluntary acceptance of a miserable condition. The ability to do this is good, and human life is meant for that purpose. Indeed, Vedic culture prescribes tapasya, and one can see many tapasvés undergoing austerities in India. In the winter they stand in water up to their necks and meditate. Standing in water during severe cold is not very comfortable, but they voluntarily do it. In the summer they also ignite fires all around themselves and sit down in the midst of the blazes and meditate. These are examples of severe tapasya undertaken by many ascetics in India.

Some tapasya is certainly required. Without it, one can not advance in spiritual life or knowledge. If we simply engage in the animal propensities of eating, sleeping, mating and defending, not accepting the tapasya process, human life is a failure. If one wants to become an initiated member of our Kåñëa consciousness society, we first of all ask him to undergo tapasya. In the Western countries especially it is a great tapasya to give up illicit sex life, intoxication, meat-eating and gambling. Although we require only these austerities, it is very difficult to observe them. In England, a wealthy aristocrat inquired from a Vaiñëava Godbrother: "Sväméjé, can you make me a brähmaëa?" The Sväméjé replied, "Yes, why not? You just have to observe these four principles—no illicit sex, intoxication, gambling and meat-eating." "Impossible," the Britisher replied. Yes, it is impossible, for in Europe or in America self-indulgence is the way of life from the very beginning. Indian gentlemen often come to the West to learn these indulgences, and they think themselves to be thus advancing. Indians are automatically taught tapasya through their Vedic culture, but they come to America to forget that culture and accept another type of life. The real fact is, however, that if one wants to advance in spiritual understanding and solve all the problems of life, he must accept this life of tapasya—austerity and restriction.

Restriction is for human beings, not for animals. We encounter restrictions daily in our common dealings. We cannot drive a car on the left or run a red light without risking apprehension by the law. If a dog, however, walks on the left side of the street or crosses against a red light, it is not punished because it is an animal. The law therefore makes distinctions between human beings and animals because human beings supposedly have advanced consciousness. If we do not follow rules and regulations, we again lapse into animalism. Apparently propaganda is being made celebrating freedom as opposed to a regulated life, but one who sees things as they are can understand that freedom from all restriction is animal life. Therefore Çukadeva Gosvämé recommends tapasya. If we want actual freedom from the problems of life, we have to accept a life of austerity. Bondage to material life is the only other alternative.

What is tapasya? What is austerity? The first principal of austerity is brahmacarya, restricted sex life. The real meaning of brahmacarya is complete celibacy, and according to Vedic culture in the beginning of life one should strictly follow the regulations of brahmacarya. When he is grown up, the brahmacäré can marry and become gåhastha, and as a gåhastha he can have sex, but in the brahmacarya life strict celibacy is the rule. In the present age people have become degraded for want of tapasya because they are not taught how to execute tapasvé life. Criticism for its own sake will not do; one must be effectively trained in the life of tapasya.

In the Vedas it is said that those who execute a regulated life of tapasya are brähmaëas. Etad akñaraà gärgi viditväsmäû lokät praiti sa brähmaëaù/ etad akñaraà gärgy aviditväsmäl lokät praiti sa kåpaëaù. [Båhad-äraëyaka Up. 3.8.10] Everyone is dying, for no one can live here permanently, but one who dies after executing a life of tapasya is a brähmaëa, and one who dies like a cat or dog, without executing tapasya, is called a kåpaëa. These two words are used frequently in Vedic literature—brähmaëa and kåpaëa. Kåpaëa means "miser" and brähmaëa refers to a liberal, broadminded person. Brahma jänätéti brähmaëaù: One who knows the supreme, the Absolute Truth, is a brähmaëa, but one who does not know is an animal. This is the difference between animal and man; man, to deserve the name, must be educated to understand the Absolute Truth. Because human life is meant for knowledge, there are schools and colleges, philosophers and scientists and mathematicians. The processes of eating, sleeping, mating and defending need not be taught, for they are learned instinctively. Human life is obviously meant for more. It is meant for tapasya and knowledge.

There are descriptions in the Vedas of brahmacarya, celibacy, which characterize the beginning of a life dedicated to tapasya: Smaraëaà kértanaà keliù prekñaëaà guhyabhäñaëam/ saìkalpo 'dhyavasäyaç ca kriyä-nirvåttir eva ca (Çrédhara 6.1.12). To properly execute celibacy, one should not even think or even talk of sex life. Reading modern literatures and newspapers which are filled with sexual material is also against the principles of brahmacarya. Similarly, indulging in sex in any way, looking at and whispering with girls, and determining or endeavoring to engage in sex life are all against the principles of brahmacarya. One executes real brahmacarya when all these activities come to a halt.

By austerity, celibacy, and control of the mind and senses one can advance in pure life. Similarly, advancement can be made through charity properly directed. That is called tyäga, renunciation. If one has a million dollars, he should not keep it, but, as long as it is within his jurisdiction, he should spend it for Kåñëa. Money or energy is properly utilized when it is directed to Kåñëa.

As soon as one quits his body, all his monetary resources and everything else that he has collected in connection with his body is finished, for the spirit soul transmigrates to another body, and one does not know where the money which he earned in his previous body is being kept or how it is being spent. A person may leave the world declaring how the money should be spent by his sons or heirs, but even if one leaves millions of dollars, in his next life he has no claim to it. Therefore as long as it is in one's hand, it is better to spend it for a good purpose. If one spends it for bad purposes, he becomes entangled, but if he spends it for good purposes, he gets good in return. This is very clearly stated in Bhagavad-gétä.

Bhagavad-gétä explains that there are three kinds of charity—charity in the mode of goodness, passion and ignorance. A person in the mode of goodness knows where charity should be given. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says:

samo 'haà sarva-bhüteñu
na me dveñyo 'sti na priyaù
ye bhajanti tu mäà bhaktyä
mayi te teñu cäpy aham

"I envy no one, nor am I partial to anyone. I am equal to all. But whoever renders service unto Me in devotion is a friend, is in Me, and I am also a friend to him." (Bg. 9.29)

Kåñëa is not in want of money, for He is the original proprietor of everything (Éçäväsyam idaà sarvam). But still He asks us for charity. For example, Kåñëa, in the guise of Vämana, a dwarf brähmaëa, went to beg from Bali Mahäräja. Even though He is sarva-loka-maheçvaram, the proprietor of all the planets, He nonetheless says, "Please give in charity to Me." Why? It is for our interest, for the sooner we return Kåñëa's money to Kåñëa, the better situated we will be. Of course this may not be very pleasant to hear, but actually we are all thieves, for we have stolen God's property. If one who has something is not God conscious, it is to be understood that he has stolen God's property. That is the nature of material life. If this is considered thoughtfully and if one comes to real knowledge, he will realize that if we do not understand God, whose property we are using, whatever we possess is stolen property. It is also stated in Bhagavad-gétä that if one does not spend his money for yajïa, sacrifice, he is understood to be a thief (yo bhuìkte stena eva saù). For instance, if one earns a great deal of money but tries to hide it to avoid paying income tax, the government considers him to be a criminal. He cannot say, "I have earned this money. Why shall I pay tax to the government?" No, he must pay or risk punishment. Similarly, in the higher sense everything we have is Kåñëa's or God's, and it must be utilized in accordance with His desires. We may wish to construct a building, but where do we get the stone, wood and earth that the construction requires? We cannot artificially produce the wood; it is God's property. We cannot produce the metal; we must take it from the mine, which is also God's property. The earth and the bricks which are made from it are also God's. We simply give our labor, but that labor is also God's property. We work with our hands, but they are not our hands but God's, for when the power to use the hand is withdrawn by God, the hand becomes useless.

We should use this great opportunity, human life, to understand all these points which are mentioned in the authoritative books of Vedic knowledge like Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä. In the Bhägavatam Çukadeva Gosvämé declares that real atonement necessitates thoughtfulness, sobriety and meditation. One must consider whether he is the body or whether he is transcendental to the body, and one must try to know what God is. These ideas are to be studied in Kåñëa consciousness. We should not be frivolous or waste time. If one wants this knowledge, he has to practice austerity, tapasya, and the beginning of tapasya, as already explained, is brahmacarya—celibacy or restricted sex life. The pivot of material attraction is sex, not only for human society but for animal society also. Sparrows and pigeons have sex three hundred times daily, although they are strict vegetarians, and the lion, which is not a vegetarian, has sex once a year. Spiritual life is not a question of vegetarianism but of understanding higher knowledge. When one comes to the platform of elevated knowledge, he naturally becomes a vegetarian. Paëòitäù sama-darçinaù: one who is very highly learned does not distinguish between a learned scholar, a brähmaëa, an elephant, a dog and a cow. He is sama-darçé; his vision enables him to see them all equally. How is this? He does not see the body but the soul, the spiritual spark (Brahman). He thinks: "Here is a dog, but it is also a living entity, although by his past karma he has become a dog. And this learned scholar is also a living spark, but he has taken good birth because of his past karma." When one comes to that position, he does not see the body, but the spiritual spark, and he does not distinguish between one living entity and another.

Actually we do not make distinctions between carnivores and vegetarians, for the grass has life just as the cow or the lamb. A guideline, however, should be the Vedic instruction given in Éçopaniñad:

éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà
yat kiïca jagatyäà jagat
tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä
mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam

"Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one must not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong." (Éçopaniñad, Mantra 1)

Since everything is the property of the Supreme Lord, one can only enjoy what is allotted to him by the Lord, and one cannot touch another's property. According to Vedic life and according to all Vedic scriptures, a man should live on fruits and vegetables, for his teeth are made in such a way that these can be very easily eaten and digested. Although it is nature's law that one has to live by eating other living entities (jévo jévasya jévanam), one must use discretion. Fruits, flowers, vegetables, rice, grain and milk are made for human beings. Milk, for example, is an animal product, the blood of an animal transformed, but the cow delivers more milk than is needed by her calf because milk is intended for man. Man should simply take the milk and let the cows live, and thus following nature's law, man will be happy. Tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä [Éço 1]: one should take whatever God allots to him and thus live comfortably.

We have to elevate our consciousness through this science of Kåñëa. Charity is within everyone's heart, but we do not know how to make the best use of it. Whatever we spend in terms of energy should be for Kåñëa, for it all belongs to Him. By spending for Kåñëa, one will not be a loser. Kåñëa is so kind that when we offer Him food, He accepts and yet leaves everything for us to eat. Simply by offering food to Kåñëa we can become devotees. We need not spend an extra farthing. In the higher sense, everything belongs to Kåñëa, but if we offer everything to Kåñëa, we will be elevated. This is a sublime and proven way for advancement in pure life.

MG 5: Learning Steadiness in Kåñëa Consciousness

5/ Learning Steadiness in Kåñëa Consciousness

[710727SB.NY]

When one reaches the topmost position of material opulence, the tendency for renunciation is natural. There are two tendencies in this material world—bhoga (sense enjoyment) and tyäga (renunciation of this material world). Without guidance, however, one does not know how to renounce. First of all, one wants to enjoy, and when he is frustrated in enjoyment, he renounces. Again, when he is tired of renunciation, he enjoys, like a clock pendulum which swings from side to side. We are thus all vacillating from the platform of enjoyment to the platform of renunciation and back again.

Karmés, fruitive workers, try to enjoy this world and reap the fruits of it. Consequently, they are constantly traveling on expressways all day and night to engage in material enjoyment. On the other hand, there are others, predominantly the discontented youth, who don't want any part of this. Thus the world contains those engaged in bhoga and those engaged in tyäga. However, we will not be happy by following either of these paths because it is not our proper position to either enjoy or renounce. Since everything belongs to Kåñëa and nothing belongs to anyone else, whatever we possess is actually Kåñëa's property (éçäväsyam idaà sarvam). Since we have not produced the trees, plants, waters or the land, we cannot claim them. Since we actually have nothing, we can renounce nothing, or, as it is said, naked we come into this world and naked we go out. In the interim we falsely claim, "This is my country, this is my home, this is my wife, these are my children, this is my property, this is my bank balance, etc." Such claims are false because when we come into the world, we come in empty-handed, and when we go out, we go out empty-handed. What then is the meaning of bhoga and tyäga? In the light of the actual facts, they have no actual meaning. Bhoga is thievery, and tyäga, renunciation of what never belonged to us, is a form of lunacy.

In this regard, Kåñëa gives us this direction: sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja. (Bg. 18.66) Although we have created different types of religion based on bhoga and tyäga, we are thus advised to give up all of them and to surrender unto Kåñëa. It is not within our power to enjoy or to renounce. When renunciation is recommended in Bhagavad-gétä, it refers to renunciation of everything that we falsely claim to possess. A child may take a hundred dollar bill from his father and try to keep it although he may not know how to use it. The father may beg the child, "Dear boy, kindly give it to me." The child does not know that the money actually belongs to the father, nor does he know that he had best hand it to his father, for he simply does not know how to use it. Similarly, Kåñëa says, "Renounce your work for Me. Renounce your wealth and property for Me." Kåñëa is not a beggar, for everything belongs to Him, but He does treat us like small children. Compliance to His request to give everything to Him is called tyäga, renunciation, and is one of the means by which one can attain elevation to Kåñëa consciousness. Austerity, celibacy, equanimity and charity are all required for realization of the ultimate or Absolute Truth. Kåñëa consciousness is not concerned with the relative truth but with the Absolute. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam Vyäsadeva offers his obeisances to the Supreme Absolute Truth (satyaà paraà dhémahi). He offers his respects not to the relative categorical truths, but to the summum bonum, the Absolute Truth. It is the duty of brähmaëas to practice those qualities by which the Absolute Truth can be realized.

Brähmaëas must be qualified by practicing cleanliness, truthfulness, control of the mind and the senses, simplicity, and by cultivating faith in the Vedas and particularly in Bhagavad-gétä. When Kåñëa says, "I am the Supreme Lord," we have to accept Him with faith, not foolishly, but with full knowledge, and practically apply this acceptance in our daily life. A brähmaëa is not created by birth, but by education, practice and knowledge. It is not a question of birth, but quality, as pointed out by Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä:

cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöaà
guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù
tasya kartäram api mäà
viddhy akartäram avyayam

"According to the three modes of material nature and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me. And, although I am the creator of this system, you should know that I am yet the non-doer, being unchangeable." (Bg. 4.13)

One must not only have the qualities of a brähmaëa, but one should also work as a brähmaëa, for one's qualities are tested by his work. If one is a qualified engineer but simply sits down at home and does not work, what is his value? Similarly, unless one works as a brähmaëa, there is no value to his simply saying, "I am a brähmaëa." One must therefore work as a brähmaëa by fully engaging in the service of Paraà Brahman, Kåñëa, the Supreme Brahman.

How can service to the Absolute Truth be executed? Yamena niyamena ca: the practice of yoga, or linking with the supreme, is based on the principles of regulation and control. Regulation cannot be executed without control; therefore one must be thoughtful and purify himself. If one wants to pass an examination, he has to go to school, follow the principles of the school, and take some pains in his study, and then gradually he comes to be successful. If he plays all day on the street, how can he expect success? Therefore in the process being explained by Çukadeva Gosvämé, the first necessity is tapasya, austerity. Even if austerity and brahmacarya are painful because we want to be unrestricted, as soon as we are regulated, what appeared to be painful is in practice not painful.

There are two classes of men—those who are sober (dhéra) and those who are extravagant (adhéra). When one, in spite of provocation or in spite of the presence of a source of mental agitation, can remain steady in his position, he is called dhéra. An example of a dhéra is given by Kälidäsa Paëòita, a great Sanskrit poet who wrote a book called Kumära-sambhava, wherein he has given an example concerning Lord Çiva. It appears that when the demigods were fighting the demons and were being defeated, they decided that they could be saved by a commander-in-chief born from the semina of Lord Çiva. Lord Çiva, however, was in meditation, and to acquire the needed semina was very difficult. They therefore sent Pärvaté, a young girl, who appeared before Lord Çiva and worshiped his genitals. Although this young girl sat before Lord Çiva and touched his genitals, Lord Çiva was steady in meditation. Kälidäsa says, "Here is an example of a dhéra, for despite a young girl's touching his genitals, he was undisturbed."

Similarly, someone sent a young prostitute to disturb Haridäsa Öhäkura, and upon hearing her appeals for intercourse, Haridäsa Öhäkura said, "Yes, your proposal is very nice. Please sit down and let me finish my chanting, and then we shall enjoy." Morning came and the prostitute became impatient, but Haridäsa Öhäkura replied, "I'm very sorry. I could not finish my chanting. Come tonight again." The prostitute came for three nights, and on the third night she fell down at his feet, confessed her intentions, and pleaded with him, "I was induced to perform this act by a man who is your enemy. Kindly excuse me." Haridäsa Öhäkura then replied, "I know all about that, but I allowed you to come here for three days so that you could be converted and become a devotee. Now take these chanting beads, and go on chanting. I am leaving this place." Here is another example of a dhéra who has control of his body (deha), words (väc), and intelligence (buddhi). One's body, words and intelligence should be controlled by one who is dhéra and who actually knows the principles of religion.

We have been continuously committing sinful activities since time immemorial, and we do not know when this began, but this life is meant for rectification of all the mistakes that we have committed. If one sets fire to unwanted grass and creepers in a field, they will all be burned. Similarly, by the process of austerity and penance, one can liquidate all sinful activities and become purified. But Çukadeva Gosvämé suggests an alternate process (Bhag. 6.1.15): kecit kevalayä bhaktyä väsudeva-paräyaëäù/ aghaà dhunvanti kärtsnyena néhäram iva bhäskaraù. Generally, if one leads an austere and pious life of celibacy, equanimity, charity, etc., people will say that he is a very pious man, but simply by becoming Kåñëa conscious, one can kill all the resultant actions of his past sinful life. A fog disappears as soon as the sun rises, and Kåñëa rises with the brilliance of thousands of suns.

This process is accepted only by someone who is very fortunate. Caitanya Mahäprabhu therefore said: (eirüpa) brahmäëòa bhramite kona bhägyavän jéva/ guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja: "By the grace of Kåñëa and the spiritual master, a fortunate person, after wandering throughout the universe in different species of life, receives the seed of pure devotional service." Kåñëa consciousness is meant for the very fortunate, for simply by accepting this one process a person can surpass all the duties of austerity, renunciation, celibacy, etc. Çukadeva Gosvämé declares: kecit kevalayä bhaktyä: "One who is extremely fortunate takes to the process of pure devotional service." Kevala bhakti refers to pure unalloyed devotional service in which there is no desire but to please Kåñëa. One should not render devotional service just to increase his income. We want money to become happy, but if we take to Kåñëa consciousness, automatically we will become so happy that we will neglect money. Money will automatically come. Happiness will come. There is no need to endeavor for these things separately.

It was Dhruva Mahäräja who lamented, "How foolish I was that I took to devotional service with a desire for material profit." Ordinarily for material profit one goes to his boss or some rich man or demigod, but a devotee does not go anywhere but to Kåñëa, even if he has material desires. If one goes to Kåñëa even for material advantages, the day will come when he forgets material desires, just like Dhruva Mahäräja. He was repentant, and said, "I came to Kåñëa and asked for something material, just like one who has pleased a very rich man and who asks him for a few grains of rice." If a rich man agrees to give us whatever we want, but we ask him only for a few grains of rice, is that very intelligent? Asking Kåñëa for material benefit is exactly like this. One need not ask Kåñëa extraneously for material happiness, for material happiness will automatically roll before his very feet, pleading, "Please take me, please take me."

Those who are practicing Kåñëa consciousness are not in need of the material opulences—wives, children, happiness, home—for all is acquired automatically by the grace of Kåñëa. There is no need to ask Kåñëa for these material things, but one should simply request Him: "Please engage me in Your service." In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa also promises that if one engages in His service, He will supply what is needed and preserve whatever is already possessed. One of His final instructions to Arjuna indicates total dependence on Him:

cetasä sarva-karmäëi
mayi sannyasya mat-paraù
buddhi-yogam upäçritya
mac-cittaù satataà bhava

"In all activities, and for their results, just depend upon Me, and work always under My protection. In such devotional service, be fully conscious of Me." (Bg. 18.57)

MG 6: Transcending Designations and Problems

6/ Transcending Designations and Problems

[This chapter is based on 710728BS.NY]

Kåñëa consciousness is easily achieved by the mercy of Lord Caitanya, but only some are fortunate enough to have the mercy of Lord Caitanya and His disciplic succession. According to Bhagavad-gétä:

manuñyäëäà sahasreñu
kaçcid yatati siddhaye
yatatäm api siddhänäà
kaçcin mäà vetti tattvataù

"Out of many thousands among men, one may endeavor for perfection, and of those who have achieved perfection, hardly one knows Me in truth." (Bg. 7.3)

God realization is not possible for animals or for persons who are almost animals, or for animals in the shape of human beings. Contemporary civilization is by in large an assembly of animals because, as stated before, it operates on the basis of the animal propensities. The birds and beasts arise early in the morning and busy themselves trying to find food and sex and trying to defend themselves; at night they look for shelter, and in the morning they fly to a tree to find nuts and fruits. Similarly, in New York City, great hordes of people travel from one island to another by ferry boat or wait for subways in order to go to the office for the purpose of finding food. How is this an advancement over animal life? Although the ferry and subway are always crowded, and many people have to travel forty or fifty miles for bread, the birds are free to fly from one tree to another.

Real civilization is not concerned simply with man's animal needs but with enabling man to understand his relationship with God, the supreme father. One may learn about his relationship with God by any process—through Christianity, through the Vedic literatures or through the Koran—but in any case it must be learned. The purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is not to make Christians into Hindus or Hindus into Christians but to inform everyone that the duty of a human being is to understand his relationship with God. One must learn this, otherwise he is simply wasting his time by engaging in animalistic propensities. We must all try to love Kåñëa or God. If one has a process, he should practice it, or he can come and learn this process. One should not begrudge the selection of one process over another. Viñäd apy amåtaà grähyam amedhyäd api käïcanam/ nécäd apy uttamäà vidyäà stré-ratnaà duñkuläd api (Néti-darpaëa 1.16). Cäëakya Paëòita says that one must catch what is right from any source. If there is a glass of poison with some nectar in it, he says, one should take out the nectar and leave the poison. In the same way, if one finds gold in a filthy place, he should take it. Similarly, although according to the Vedic system of education one must be given instruction by intellectual persons like brähmaëas, if someone lower on the social scale has learned the truth, one should accept him as a teacher and learn from him. One should not think that just because one is lowly born he should not be accepted as a teacher.

Similarly, if one is serious about understanding God, he should not think, "I am Christian," "I am Hindu," or "I am Muslim." If one is serious about understanding love of God, he should consider which process is practical. One should not think, "Why should I follow Hindu or Vedic scriptures?" The purpose of following the Vedic scriptures is to develop love of God. When students come to America for a higher education, they do not consider the fact that the teachers may be American, German or of other nationalities. If one wants a higher education, he simply comes and takes it. Similarly, if there is an effective process for understanding and approaching God, like this Kåñëa consciousness process, one should take it.

Not all, but those who are intelligent and fortunate take to this process of devotional service (kevalayä bhaktyä), and their only desire is to serve Kåñëa. From early morning till late at night the devotees are engaged in Kåñëa's service. This is called kevalayä, pure; for them there is no other business. This process is recommended for all, and it is the perfection of all religious processes. (Sa vai puàsäà paro dharmo yato bhaktir adhokñaje). In Sanskrit, there are two words, para, and apara, which describe the superior (transcendental) and the inferior (material) approaches to religion. In the execution of material dharma, or religion performed for material gain, people generally go to a church or a temple and pray, "God, give us our daily bread." Actually, this need not be asked for, for bread is already provided for everyone. Even the birds and beasts get their bread without having to go to church to ask God for it. Similarly, our bread is also provided, whether we go to church or not. That is not a problem, for no one is dying in the streets of starvation, nor do we find a bird, beast, or even an ant dying of starvation. Food is there, and one need not bother about it. If the brain should be taxed, it should be taxed for Kåñëa or God. This is the proper utilization of time. There is no scarcity of bread in the Kingdom of God.

Tasyaiva hetoù prayateta kovido na labhyate yad bhramatäm uparyadhaù. Çrémad-Bhägavatam says that one should try to attain that which cannot be attained by traveling all over the universe. What is that? Kevalayä bhaktyä—pure devotion. By God's arrangement there is sufficient food, land and prospects for food on this planet, but we have arranged things in such a way that in one part of the world people are suffering and in another part they are throwing grains in the ocean. The Vedas say, eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän—the Supreme Person is supplying food to many living entities. The difficulty in this material world is that we take more than we need and thus create our own problems. Problems are created by men, led by the so-called politicians. According to nature's way or God's way, everything is complete. According to Çré Éçopaniñad:

oà pürëam adaù pürëam idaà
pürëät pürëam udacyate
pürëasya pürëam ädäya
pürëam evävaçiñyate

"The Personality of Godhead is perfect and complete, and because of this all emanations from Him, such as this phenomenal world, are perfectly equipped as complete wholes. Whatever is produced of the complete whole is also complete in itself. Because He is the complete whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance." (Çré Éçopaniñad, Invocation) God is complete, His creation is complete, and His arrangements are complete, but we are creating disturbances. Real education is that which makes people Kåñëa conscious so that they will properly utilize the resources of the earth and stop creating disturbances. It is not possible to solve problems by passing resolutions in the United Nations. One must know the actual method of solving problems.

Çukadeva Gosvämé says that simply by pure devotional service one can solve the problems of life. Who can do this? It is not possible for an ordinary man but for those who are väsudeva-parayaëäù, devoted to Lord Kåñëa (Väsudeva). Only those whose concern is to satisfy Kåñëa and who take to pure unalloyed devotional service can solve the problems of life.

Aghaà dhunvanti—as already explained, problems are created by sinful activities. Although there is enough food, everyone stocks more than is needed in order to make a profit or simply in order to hoard. In 1942, in India, there was an artificial famine created by people gathering money and stocking it unnecessarily. Wealthy men collected rice which was selling at six rupies a pound, and suddenly within a week the price rose to fifty rupies a pound. Consequently no rice was available on the market, and the people went hungry. An American gentleman present at the time remarked, "If people in our country were starving in this way, there would have been a revolution." The people in India, however, are so trained and cultured that in spite of this artificial famine they did not revolt but preferred to die peacefully. Of course, this is only one instance, but it shows how problems are not created by God but by man. In Germany during the First World War the women went to church and prayed to God to send their husbands, sons and brothers back safely, but none of them came back. All of the women became atheists. They did not consider that God did not advocate the war and its problems. They went to Him for a solution. When we create our own problems, we have to suffer the results.

It is a fact, however, that the problems of one who takes to the shelter of Kåñëa, God, are solved. For this reason, if for none other, one should apply his devotional service to Väsudeva, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Väsudeve bhagavati bhakti-yogaù prayojitaù. If one engages in devotional service to Väsudeva, he will receive the highest knowledge without delay (janayaty äsu vairägyam). The words jïäna-vairägyam refer to "that knowledge by which one becomes detached from material allurement." The word jïäna means knowledge, and vairägyam means detachment. Both knowledge and detachment are required in this human form of life. One should know: "I am spirit soul. I have nothing to do with this material world, but because I have a desire to enjoy it in different ways, I am transmigrating from one body to another. I do not know when this began, but it is still going on." This is real knowledge. To be knowledgeable, one must understand his constitutional position and realize how he is suffering in this material world. That perfection of knowledge comes when one becomes väsudeva-parayaëäù, devoted to Lord Väsudeva.

In Bhagavad-gétä, Lord Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19) Those great souls who know perfectly well that Kåñëa, Väsudeva, is the source of everything, are very rare. It is easy to find so-called mahätmäs (great souls) with long beards and mustaches who tell everyone that they are one with God and that when they die they will wake up and become God, but these are not really mahätmäs. Rather, they are durätmä, hard-hearted, because they want to encroach on the rightful position of Kåñëa and become one with Him. If there were a servant in the office who tried to occupy the position of employer, would the employer like it? Similarly, any living entity who is trying to become God is not very much to God's liking. Of course no one can become God, but this endeavor to become God or His competitor is not very pleasing to Him. Persons who try are described in Bhagavad-gétä as dviñataù, envious.

The Lord says:

tän ahaà dviñataù krürän
saàsäreñu narädhamän
kñipämy ajasram açubhän
äsuréñv eva yoniñu

"Envious, mischievous, the lowest of mankind, these do I ever put back into the ocean of material existence, into various demoniac species of life." (Bg. 16.19)

They are put into hellish conditions because they are envious of God's position. First they try to occupy high positions in this material world, and when they are frustrated in this attempt, they think, "Now I shall occupy the position of God." Of course this desire is also frustrated because no one can become God. God is God, and the living entity is the living entity. God is supreme and infinite; we are infinitesimal. Our position is to serve God, and when we act according to our position, we become happy. By imitating God, happiness cannot be obtained. Yasyaika-niçvasita-kälam athävalambya jévanti loma-vilajä jagad-aëòa-näthäù. (Bs. 5.48) There are innumerable universes, and within one breath of the Mahä-Viñëu these universes are inhaled and dissolved within His body. How then can a living entity become God? God is not so cheap. Therefore we must become advanced in knowledge and accept Väsudeva, Kåñëa, as the supreme. There is no question of Kåñëa being a man. At no stage in His appearance on earth did He appear as an ordinary living entity. Even as a baby He performed miraculous feats way beyond the abilities of the ordinary living entity. One should not consider that when he is surrendering to Kåñëa he is surrendering to an ordinary man but to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Indeed, that is confirmed by all Vedic literatures. Aghaà dhunvanti: All reactions to sinful activities are cancelled when one surrenders to Kåñëa. In Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa Himself advises personal surrender to Him:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"Give up all varieties of religiousness and just surrender unto Me, and in return I shall protect you from all sinful reactions. Therefore you have nothing to fear." (Bg. 18.66)

Therefore one who is a devotee (Väsudeva-parayaëäù) and who simply engages in devotional service is immediately freed from all sinful activities. Devotional service to Kåñëa or Kåñëa consciousness can never be attained by any amount of speculation but by the causeless mercy of a pure devotee of Kåñëa. It is a matchless gift bestowed by the mahätmä or great soul out of compassion for fallen living entities. It is said that by the grace of Kåñëa one gets a guru, or a spiritual master, and by the grace of the spiritual master, one gets Kåñëa. This is like the gift of the sunrise. At night there is darkness, but in the morning, as soon as the sun rises, immediately millions of miles of darkness are removed. In the same way, if we try to make the sun of Kåñëa rise within our hearts, all of our problems will be solved.

MG 7:The Matchless Gift:
Liberation in Kåñëa Consciousness

7/ The Matchless Gift:
Liberation in Kåñëa Consciousness

[710801SB.NY] & [710725SB.NY] & [710731BS.NY]

If we simply worship the original person (ädi-puruñaà), we need not fear being misled by anyone. Çrédhara Svämé, the original commentator on Çrémad-Bhägavatam, explains that one can reach the perfection of life simply by devotional service (kevalayä bhaktyä); one need not be dependent on any other process. Çukadeva Gosvämé says that one can put an end to material life by one stroke (kevalayä). There is no need to first undergo severe penance and austerity, practice celibacy, control the mind and the senses, give in charity, perform great sacrifices and become very truthful and clean. Simply by one stroke—by accepting Kåñëa consciousness—one immediately rises to the highest position. By just taking to Kåñëa consciousness, one develops all transcendental qualifications. The goldsmith uses a small hammer and taps the gold many times, but the blacksmith uses a large hammer and with one stroke his job is finished. This is the blacksmith's method: we take the big hammer of bhakti-yoga and finish all material life. There is no need to undergo the many lesser disciplines, nor to follow any other process. In actuality, there is no possibility of even following the other Vedic processes to perfection. For instance, the haöha-yoga process would say: "You have to become a strict brahmacäré and sit in the forest with your body at a right angle to the ground, pressing your nose with your finger for six months." Who could follow such an instruction? Since such a method is not practical in this present age, the goldsmith method has to be discarded. The solution is to take the blacksmith's hammer of Kåñëa consciousness and finish off all sinful reactions immediately.

By devotional service one has to become väsudeva-paräyaëa, a devotee of Lord Väsudeva or Lord Kåñëa. In other words, we have to learn how to become lovers of Väsudeva. If the world takes up this Kåñëa consciousness, the planet is certain to be peaceful. Now the earth is quickly becoming a hellish planet, and if this Kåñëa consciousness is not taken up, this hellish condition will progress despite all advances in education and economic development. Therefore those who are thoughtful should take this movement very seriously and try to understand its value. It is not something manufactured by one man or a group of disciples. It is authoritative and age-old, based on the Vedic literatures which date back thousands of years.

Néhäram iva bhäskaraù. Bhäskara refers to the sun. The sun immediately dissipates mist or fog as well as darkness. As stated before, we should try to make the sun of Kåñëa rise within our hearts. In the Caitanya-caritämåta also it is stated that Kåñëa is like the sun and that mäyä, the illusory energy, is darkness. Yähäì kåñëa, tähäì nähi mäyära adhikära: As soon as the sun of Kåñëa is present, the darkness of mäyä immediately disappears. Without following this process, it is very difficult to overcome the ocean of darkness, mäyä. If we simply teach people to surrender unto Kåñëa, God, all the fog and mist of illusion will disappear. The method is very simple: chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

The more one goes on chanting, the more the darkness of many lives is dissipated. Ceto-darpaìa-märjanam: by chanting, one can cleanse the dust from the mirror of his mind and perceive things very distinctly. Thus one will know what he is, what God is, what this world is, what our relationship with God in this world is, how to live in this world, and what our next life is. Such knowledge is not taught in schools, where one is taught how to manufacture or acquire products for sense gratification. There is always a hard struggle going on involving man's attempt to dominate material nature. However, for every convenience he manages to produce, there is an inconvenience accompanying it. For example, recently some engineers designed an airplane which can fly at great speeds without danger. When the plane flies, however, it breaks windows all over the city. Our time is thus being wasted in constructing so many devices which give us temporary and artificial convenience at the price of a proportionate amount of inconvenience. This is all part of the law of karma, the law of action and reaction. For whatever we do, there must be a reaction by which we become entangled.

That is stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

yajïärthät karmaëo 'nyatra
loko 'yaà karma-bandhanaù
tad-arthaà karma kaunteya
mukta-saìgaù samäcara

"Work done as a sacrifice for Viñëu has to be performed, otherwise work binds one to this material world. Therefore, O son of Kunté, perform your prescribed duties for His satisfaction, and in that way you will always remain unattached and free from bondage." (Bg. 3.9)

When one acts for sense gratification, work entangles him, whether the work be good or bad, but if one works for Kåñëa (yajïärthät karmaëo), he will be free, regardless of the possible desirability of his work.

Not only does Çukadeva Gosvämé recommend unalloyed devotional service, but he further says that by devotional service one's sinful activities will be negated. Every one of us is more or less sinful, for if we were not sinful we would not have been put into material bodies. As soon as one is free from sinful life, he is liberated and transferred to the spiritual world in a spiritual body. The whole process is to cleanse oneself from the contamination of sinful or material life.

Çukadeva Gosvämé said, "My dear king, those who are sinful can become purified from contamination by tapa-ädibhiù, practicing austerity." Çukadeva also said, however, that no one can become completely purified by executing this process of austerity. There are many examples of yogés who practiced austerities but did not emerge completely pure. Viçvämitra Muni, for example, was a kñatriya who wanted to become a brähmaëa and therefore began to practice austerity. Later on, however, he became a victim of Menakä, a society girl of the heavenly planets. Because Viçvämitra was not pure, he became entangled with her and begot a child. Therefore it is said that even if one performs austerities and penances, worldly circumstances are so implicating that somehow or other they will involve one again and again in the material modes of nature. There are many examples of sannyäsés who give up the world, renouncing it as false, saying, "Let me turn to Brahman," but they again become entangled in the work of the world when they set up hospitals and perform philanthropic work and welfare activities. If the world is false, why are they attracted to welfare activities? The philosophy of Kåñëa consciousness maintains that this world is not false but that it is temporary. God created this world, and He is true, so how can His creation be false? Because this is the creation of God, and God is the Absolute Truth, this creation is also true. We simply see it otherwise due to illusion. The world is a fact, but it is a temporary fact.

A person may claim something within this world to be his property, but that is a false claim. It is a fact that it is someone's property, but it is God's property (éçäväsyam idaà sarvam). This does not mean, however, that the property is false. What is false is the claim to the property, which is based upon a puffed up false consciousness that the individual is the proprietor, the master, or God. Everyone desires to be master or proprietor of something, then minister, then president, and then God. When everything else fails, the living entity wants to become God. The tendency is there to want to become the greatest of all, but the fact remains that God is the greatest and the living entity is small compared to Him. The smallest is not false, and the greatest is not false, but when the small thinks that he is great, that is false.

We understand from Vedic literature that Brahman, or the spirit, is aëor aëéyäàsam, smaller than an atom, and mahato mahéyäàsam, greater than the greatest. As far as we can conceive, the space which contains the universe is the greatest, but Kåñëa has shown millions of universes in His mouth. The greatness of God cannot be comprehended by the living entities, who are part and parcel of God. As living entities, we are very minute, infinitesimal, and God is infinite. Indeed, the magnitude of the individual spirit soul is so microscopic that it cannot be seen. One cannot even imagine it with his material senses. Therefore it is said that the spirit soul is smaller than an atom (aëor aëéyäàsam).

Since the living entities and Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, are both spirit, they are qualitatively one. Quantitatively, however, the Lord is great and the living entities are small. This fact can be accepted immediately on the basis of Vedic information. In Brahma-saàhitä it is stated, yasyaika-niçvasita-kälam athävalambya jévanti loma-vilajä jagad-aëòa-näthäù: many millions of universes come out of God's body when He exhales, and they again disappear when He inhales. Simply by His breathing, millions of universes are created and dissolved. If this is the case, then how can the living entities claim proprietorship over anything? One's position is safe only in so far as he does not falsely declare himself to be God or proprietor. It has become fashionable to claim to be God, and fools accept such claims, but from the Vedic literatures we understand that God is not so cheap.

As long as we are not making puffed up ego-centered claims, we are already liberated. There is no need to actually seek liberation. But as long as one thinks, "I am this body," he is not liberated. Liberation means knowing perfectly well that one's self is separate from the body. Therefore Çukadeva Gosvämé said, präyaçcittaà vimarçanam: "Develop your knowledge; that will give you relief." Our knowledge is perfect when we come to know that we are very small particles of spiritual sparks, and that God, the supreme, the greatest spiritual identity, supplies all our necessities (eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän). By knowing ourselves as minute particles, part and parcel of God, we can understand that our duty is to serve God. God is the center of all creation, of the whole universal body; He is the enjoyer, and we are His servitors. As this conception becomes clear, we become liberated.

Liberation entails freedom from all false conceptions. It is not that upon liberation one acquires ten hands. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam liberation is defined as muktir hitvänyathä-rüpam. Mukti means "to give up," and änyathä-rüpam denotes a false conception of life. This is to say that when one is situated in his original constitutional position, having given up all false notions, he is liberated. It is also said in Çrémad-Bhägavatam that by the aquisition of knowledge, one becomes liberated immediately. That knowledge can be very easily acquired, for it is simple: God is great, and I am very small; He is the supreme proprietor supplying all necessities, and I am His servant. Who can challenge this? It is a fact. We are simply under the false impression that we are this or that, and this leads us to the ultimate false impression that we are God. Yet we do not consider what manner of God we are. A small bodily disorder will send us to the physician. One who claims to be the supreme, therefore, should be understood to have fallen to the last snare of mäyä. One who is thus fallen cannot even be liberated, for he is bound by false impressions.

Only when one has attained proper knowledge can he actually be liberated. The stage of liberation is also called the brahma-bhütaù stage. One who has attained this stage is characterized by Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä in this way:

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments, or desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. And in that state he achieves pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54)

The joy which follows realization arises from understanding, "I was illusioned by false notions for so long. What a fool I was! I was thinking that I was God, but now I can understand that I am God's eternal servant." Upon gaining such realization, one attains liberation and becomes prasannätmä, or jolly, for this is the constitutional position of the living entity.

There is no lamentation when one is in pure consciousness, for he knows that he is a small part, a spiritual spark protected by the Supreme Lord. Where then is there scope for lamentation? A small child feels free as long as he knows that his father is there. He thinks, "My father is standing by me, so I am free. No one can harm me." Similarly, when one surrenders to Kåñëa, he has complete faith that he is not in danger because Kåñëa is protecting him. One who is thus surrendered to Kåñëa is not subject to lamentation or desire, whereas one who is not God conscious simply hankers and laments. He hankers for that which he does not possess, and he laments for that which he did possess but has lost. A God conscious person is not subject to such misery. If something is lost, he knows that it is God's wish, and he thinks, "God desired this, so it is all right." He does not desire anything, for he knows that all his necessities are being provided by Kåñëa, the supreme father.

As soon as one understands his relationship to God, he realizes universal brotherhood, for he understands that all men and animals—indeed, all life itself—are all parts of the supreme whole and are therefore all equal. Seeing this, one does not envy, exploit or trouble another living entity. Thus one who is a devotee of Kåñëa automatically develops all good qualities, for he is in the proper consciousness. Haräv abhaktasya kuto mahad-guëä mano-rathenäsati dhävato bahih. One who has developed Kåñëa consciousness will manifest all the good qualities of the demigods. Indeed, it is stated, väïcä-kalpa-tarubhyaç ca krpä-sindhubhya eva ca: A Vaiñëava or devotee of Kåñëa is an ocean of mercy to others. He gives the greatest gift to society, for society is in dire need of God consciousness. A Vaiñëava bestows the priceless gift of the mahämantra, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Simply by chanting this mantra, one can remain in a liberated state.

One should not think, however, that this state is simply a state of trance whereby one remains seated in lotus position in a corner for days on end. No, liberation means serving. One cannot simply say, "Now I have dedicated my life to Kåñëa. Let me remain seated in samädhi." The standard of surrender must be maintained by niñevayä, serving. As one serves the Supreme Lord, the Lord reveals Himself within the heart. The program of devotional service to the Lord is executed from morning to night. Indeed, Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä that one must engage in devotional service to Him twenty-four hours a day. It is not that we should meditate for fifteen minutes and then engage in all kinds of nonsense. The more we serve, the more dedicated to Kåñëa we become; therefore a person should utilize whatever talents he has for Kåñëa. There are nine processes of devotional service—hearing, chanting, remembering, serving, worshiping the Deity in the temple, praying, carrying out orders, serving the Lord as friend, and sacrificing everything for Him—and one should always keep engaged in at least one of these nine processes. One who is always engaged in Kåñëa's service never becomes disgusted (bhajatäà préti-pürvakam). Service must be rendered with love, but in the beginning this may be difficult, and so one may become disgusted. As one makes progress in Kåñëa's service, however, he will find it pleasing. This is indicated by Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä:

yat tad agre viñam iva
pariëäme 'måtopamam
tat sukhaà sättvikaà proktam
ätma-buddhi-prasäda-jam

"That which in the beginning may be just like poison, but at the end is like nectar, and which awakens one to self-realization, is said to be happiness in the mode of goodness." (Bg. 18.37)

Once one has attained the spiritual platform, it is material service that actually becomes disgusting. For example, if one chants Hare Kåñëa throughout his life, he will not grow tired of the names, but if one chants a material name over and over, he will soon become disgusted. The more one chants the names of Kåñëa, the more he becomes attached. Thus service by çravaëam and kértanam, hearing and chanting about Kåñëa, is the beginning. The next process is smaraëam—always remembering Kåñëa. When one is perfect in chanting and hearing, he will always remember Kåñëa. In this third stage, he becomes the greatest yogé.

Nor is progress in Kåñëa consciousness ever lost. In the material world, if one begins to construct a factory but does not complete it, the factory is useless for all intents and purposes. If the construction is stopped and the building half finished, whatever money is invested is lost. This is not the case with Kåñëa consciousness, for even if one does not come to the perfectional point, whatever work he does is his permanent asset, and he can begin from that point in his next life. Kåñëa also confirms in Bhagavad-gétä that one who begins Kåñëa consciousness cannot lose anything:

nehäbhikrama-näço 'sti
pratyaväyo na vidyate
svalpam apy asya dharmasya
träyate mahato bhayät

"In this endeavor there is no loss or diminution, and a little advancement on this path can protect one from the most dangerous type of fear." (Bg. 2.40)

In the Sixth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, when Arjuna asks about the fate of the unsuccessful yogé, Çré Kåñëa replies:

pärtha naiveha nämutra
vinäças tasya vidyate
na hi kalyäëa-kåt kaçcid
durgatià täta gacchati

"Son of Påthä, a transcendentalist engaged in auspicious activities does not meet with destruction either in this world or in the spiritual world; one who does good, My friend, is never overcome by evil." (Bg. 6.40)

The Lord then indicates that the unsuccessful yogé takes up his practice of Kåñëa consciousness in the next life, beginning from the point where he left off. In other words, if one has finished fifty percent of the process in one life, in the next life he begins at fifty-one percent. Whatever material assets we accumulate in our life, however, are all annihilated at death, for we cannot take material opulence with us.

However, one should not think that he will do well to wait for the next life to attain Kåñëa consciousness. We should try to fulfill the mission of Kåñëa consciousness in this life. Kåñëa promises us that one who becomes His devotee will come to Him without fail:

manmanä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi satyaà te
pratijäne priyo 'si me

"Always think of Me. Become My devotee. Worship Me, and offer your homage unto Me. The result is that you will come to Me without fail. I promise you this, because you are My very dear friend." (Bg. 18.65)

When we think of coming to Kåñëa, we should not think that we will be standing before a void or an impersonal bright light. Kåñëa, God, is a person, just as we are persons. Materially we can understand that our father is a person, and that his father is also a person, and that his father's father is a person and so on back to the supreme father, who must also be a person. This is not very difficult to understand, and it is noteworthy that God is called the supreme father not only in the Vedas but in the Bible, Koran, and other scriptures. The Vedänta-sütra also confirms that the Absolute Truth is the original father from whom everything has taken birth or emanated. This is also confirmed in the Vedas:

nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm
eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän

"The Lord is the supreme eternal amongst all eternals and the supreme living entity amongst all living entities. He is maintaining all others." The desires and life symptoms displayed by all living entities are simply reflections of the desires and life symptoms of the supreme father. In other words, our desires are born because He has desires. Because we are part and parcel of God, we have all the instincts of God in minute quantity. The sex play and sex life which we see in the material world is but the perverted reflection of the love that is found in the spiritual world. This world is material because God is forgotten here, but once He is remembered the world immediately becomes spiritual. In other words, the spiritual world is that place where Kåñëa is not forgotten. That is also the definition of the spiritual world given by Vedic literatures. We must therefore plan our lives in such a way that it will not be possible for us to forget Kåñëa for a moment. In this way, by engaging in the service of Kåñëa, we will therefore always live in Vaikuëöha or Våndävana, the abode of Kåñëa.

At present, due to our polluted consciousness, we are turning the world into a materialistic and hellish place, and because we are ignorant of our constitutional position, we have created innumerable problems, just as in dreams we create so many problems. But in actuality there are no problems. I may dream that I am in a great storm, or that I am being pursued, or that someone is taking my money, or that I am being devoured by a tiger, but actually these are all creations of my mind. Asaìgo hy ayaà puruña iti çruteù. The Vedas say that the puruña (the ätmä or the soul) has no connection with all its dreamlike material activities. Therefore we must engage in this Kåñëa consciousness process to awaken from this dreaming condition.

Above all the fruitive laborers, speculators, and mystic yogés are the bhaktas, or devotees of Kåñëa. A bhakta can be perfectly peaceful, whereas the others cannot because everyone but the bhakta, one who has pure love, has desire. A çuddha-bhakta is desireless because he is simply happy serving Kåñëa. He does not know or even care whether Kåñëa is God or not; he just wants to love Kåñëa. Nor is heconcerned with the fact that Kåñëa is omnipotent or that He is all-pervasive. In Våndävana, the cowherd boys and the gopés did not know whether Kåñëa was God or not, but they simply loved Him. Although they were not Vedäntists, yogés or karmés, they were happy because they were simple village girls and boys who wanted to see Kåñëa. This is a very highly elevated position called sarvopädhi-vinirmuktaà tat-paratvena nirmalam [Närada-païcarätra], or the stage of purity in which one is liberated from all material designations.

Although the yogés and jïänés are trying to understand God, they are not aware of their illusory condition. Mäyä-sukhäya bharam udvahato vimüòhän (Bhäg. 7.9.43): They are fools because they are working hard for illusory happiness. There is no question of peace for them. The jïänés or speculators, wanting to get relief from the hard work of this material world, reject this material world (brahma satyaà jagan-mithyä). Their position is a little higher than that of the karmés because the karmés have taken this material world as everything. They say, "Here we shall be happy," and their dharma, or religion, consists of trying to make a peaceful atmosphere within this material world. The fools do not know that this has been tried for millions of years but has never happened and never will happen. How can peace in the material world be possible when Kåñëa, the creator Himself, says that this place is meant for trouble and miseries?

äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

"From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place." (Bg. 8.16)

Duhkhälayam açäçvatam: not only is this world full of suffering, but it is also temporary. One cannot simply agree to go ahead suffering the three-fold miseries and stay here. Even that will not be allowed. In this world, he will not only be punished while staying here, but he will also be kicked out at the end. One may accumulate a large bank balance or an expensive home, a wife, children, and so many amenities, and he may think, "I am living very peacefully," but at any day he may be told, "Please get out."

"Why?" he will ask. "It is my house, and it is paid for. I have money and a job and responsibilities. Why should I get out?"

"Just get out. Don't talk. Get out."

On that day a man sees God. "Oh, I did not believe in God," he may think. "But now here is God finishing off everything." Thus it is said that the demoniac recognize Kåñëa as death, for it is at that time that He takes everything away from them.

Why do we want to see God as death? When the demon Hiraëyakaçipu saw Kåñëa, he saw Him as death personified, but the devotee, Prahläda, saw Him in His personal form as his beloved Lord. Those who challenge God will see Him in His ghastly aspect, but those who are devoted to Him will see Him in His personal form. In any case, everyone will ultimately see God.

A person who is honest can always see Kåñëa everywhere. Kåñëa says, "Try to understand Me. Try to see Me everywhere." By way of facilitating this method, the Lord says, raso 'ham apsu kaunteya: "I am the taste of water." When we are thirsty and need a glass of water, we can drink it and feel happy, understanding that the power of water to quench our thirst is Kåñëa. Similarly, as soon as there is sunrise or moonshine, we can see Kåñëa, for He says, prabhäsmi çaçi-süryayoù: "I am the sun and moon." At a further stage we can see Kåñëa as the life force within everything, as He indicates in Bhagavad-gétä:

puëyo gandhaù påthivyäà ca
tejaç cäsmi vibhävasau
jévanaà sarva-bhüteñu
tapaç cäsmi tapasviñu

"I am the original fragrance of the earth, and I am the light in fire. I am the life of all that lives, and I am the penances of all ascetics." (Bg. 7.9)

Once we understand that all things are dependent upon Kåñëa for their existence, there is no possibility of His ever becoming lost to us. In Bhagavad-gétä the Lord indicates that all things abide in Him in both their beginning and in their end and also in the interim state:

etad yonéni bhütäni
sarväëéty upadhäraya
ahaà kåtsnasya jagataù
prabhavaù pralayas tathä

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"Of all that is material and all that is spiritual in this world, know for certain that I am both its origin and dissolution. O conquerer of wealth (Arjuna), there is no truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls on a thread." (Bg. 7.6-7)

Kåñëa is easily visible, but He is only visible to those who are devoted to Him. For those who are envious, foolish or unintelligent, He obscures Himself with His veil of mäyä:

nähaà prakäçaù sarvasya
yoga-mäyä-samävåtaù
müòho 'yaà näbhijänäti
loko mäm ajam avyayam

"I am never manifest to the foolish and unintelligent. For them I am covered by My eternal creative potency (mäyä); thus the deluded world knows Me not, who am unborn and infallible." (Bg. 7.25)

This eternal creative potency, or yoga-mäyä, which obscures Kåñëa to the unintelligent, is dissolved by love. This is the verdict of Brahma-saàhitä [5.38]:

premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena
santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti

"One who has developed love for Kåñëa can see Him within his heart twenty-four hours a day."

Those who thus see Kåñëa are not anxious because they know where they are going at death. One who has taken the gift of Kåñëa consciousness knows that he will not have to return to this material world to take another body but that he will go to Kåñëa. It is not possible to go to Kåñëa unless one attains a body like Kåñëa's, a sac-cid-änanda-vigraha body, a body full of eternity, knowledge and bliss. One cannot enter into fire and not perish unless he himself becomes fire, and similarly one cannot enter into the spiritual realm in a body that is not spiritual. In a spiritual body one can dance with Kåñëa in the räsa dance like the gopés and the cowherd boys. This is not an ordinary dance, but the dance of eternity, in the association of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Only those who have become purified in their love for Kåñëa can participate in it. One therefore should not take this process of Kåñëa consciousness as something cheap, but as a matchless gift bestowed upon suffering humanity by the Lord Himself. Simply by engaging in this process, all the anxieties and fears of one's life, which in actuality revolve about the fear of death, are allayed.

APPENDIXES

GLOSSARY

ISKCON CENTERS AROUND THE WORLD

ISKCON is a worldwide community of devotees

dedicated to the principles of bhakti-yoga.

Write, call, or visit for further information.

Classes are held in the evenings during the week,
and a special feast and festival is held every Sunday afternoon.

Beyond Birth and Death (1974)

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda
Founder-Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness

THE BHAKTIVEDANTA BOOK TRUST
New York . Los Angeles . London . Bombay



Readers interested in the subject matter of this book are invited by the International Society for Krishna Consciousness to correspond with its Secretary.
International Society for Krishna Consciousness 3959 Landmark Street Culver City, California 90230
© 1972 by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust (B.B.T.)
All rights reserved


First Printing, 1972: 25,000 copies
Second Printing, 1973: 100,000 copies
Third Printing, 1974: 200,000 copies


Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 72-84844
International Standard Book Number: 0-912776-41-2

Printed in the United States of America


I. We Are Not These Bodies
II. Elevation At Death
III. Liberation From Material Planets
IV. The Sky Beyond The Universe
V. Associating With Kåñëa


His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda left India and came to America in 1965 to spread the Hare Kåñëa Movement to the Western world. He is the first successful propagator of the science of bhakti-yoga in the West and the founder and spiritual master of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, which has over seventy centers around the world. He has translated and commented upon many great Vedic literatures—Bhagavad-gétä, Upaniñads, Çrémad-Bhägavatam and others. This present booklet introduces the reader to the basic message of Bhagavad-gétä—that through Kåñëa consciousness one can transcend the relative material world of time and space and attain the perfectional platform of existence beyond birth and death.


BOOKS by His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 1-4 (13 Vols.)
Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (3 Vols.)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
The Nectar of Devotion
Çré Éçopaniñad
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 Vols.)
Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäräja
Transcendental Teachings of Caitanya Mahäprabhu
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
The Perfection of Yoga
Beyond Birth and Death
On the Way to Kåñëa
Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge
Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness
Lord Caitanya in Five Features
Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)

A complete catalogue is available upon request.

BBD 1: We Are Not These Bodies

1
We Are Not These Bodies

[660325BG.NY]

dehé nityam avadhyo 'yaà
dehe sarvasya bhärata
tasmät sarväëi bhütäni
na tvaà çocitum arhasi

"O descendant of Bharata, he who dwells in the body is eternal and can never be slain. Therefore you need not grieve for any creature." (Bhagavad-gétä 2.30)

The very first step in self-realization is realizing one's identity as separate from the body. "I am not this body but am spirit soul" is an essential realization for anyone who wants to transcend death and enter into the spiritual world beyond. It is not simply a matter of saying "I am not this body," but of actually realizing it. This is not as simple as it may seem at first. Although we are not these bodies but are pure consciousness, somehow or other we have become encased with the bodily dress. If we actually want the happiness and independence that transcend death we have to establish ourselves and remain in our constitutional position as pure consciousness.

Living in the bodily conception, our idea of happiness is like that of a man in delirium. Some philosophers claim that this delirious condition of bodily identification should be cured by abstaining from all action. Because these material activities have been a source of distress for us, they claim that we should actually stop these activities. Their culmination of perfection is in a kind of Buddhistic nirväëa in which no activities are performed. Buddha maintained that due to a combination of material elements, this body has come into existence, and that somehow or other if these material elements are separated or dismantled, the cause of suffering is removed. If the tax collectors give us too much difficulty because we happen to possess a large house, one simple solution is to destroy the house. However, Bhagavad-gétä indicates that this material body is not all in all. Beyond this combination of material elements, there is spirit, and the symptom of that spirit is consciousness.

Consciousness cannot be denied. A body without consciousness is a dead body. As soon as consciousness is removed from the body, the mouth will not speak, the eye will not see, nor the ears hear. A child can understand that. It is a fact that consciousness is absolutely necessary for the animation of the body. What is this consciousness? Just as heat or smoke are symptoms of fire, so consciousness is the symptom of the soul. The energy of the soul or self is produced in the shape of consciousness. Indeed, consciousness proves that the soul is present. This is not only the philosophy of Bhagavad-gétä but the conclusion of all Vedic literature.

The impersonalist school of Çaìkaräcärya, as well as the Vaiñëavas following in the disciplic succession from Lord Çré Kåñëa, acknowledge the factual existence of the soul, but the Buddhist philosophers do not. The Buddhists contend that at a certain stage the combination of matter produces consciousness, but this argument is refuted by the fact that although we may have all the constituents of matter at our disposal, we cannot produce consciousness from them. All the material elements may be present in a dead man, but we cannot revive that man to consciousness. This body is not like a machine. When a part of a machine breaks down, it can be replaced, and the machine will work again, but when the body breaks down and consciousness leaves the body, there is no possibility of our replacing the broken part and rejuvenating the consciousness. The soul is different from the body, and as long as the soul is there, the body is animate. But there is no possibility of making the body animate in the absence of the soul.

Because we cannot perceive the soul by our gross senses, we deny it. Actually there are so many things that are there which we cannot see. We cannot see air, radio waves or sound, nor can we perceive minute bacteria with our blunt senses, but this does not mean they are not there. By the aid of the microscope and other instruments, many things can be perceived which had previously been denied by the imperfect senses. Just because the soul, which is atomic in size, has not been perceived yet by senses or instruments, we should not conclude that it is not there. It can, however, be perceived by its symptoms and effects.

In Bhagavad-gétä Çré Kåñëa points out that all of our miseries are due to false identification with the body.

mäträ-sparçäs tu kaunteya
çétoñëa-sukha-duùkha-däù
ägamäpäyino 'nityäs
täàs titikñasva bhärata

"O son of Kunté, the nonpermanent appearance of heat and cold, happiness and distress, and their disappearance in due course, are like the appearance and disappearance of winter and summer seasons. They arise from sense perception, O scion of Bharata, and one must learn to tolerate them without being disturbed." (Bg. 2.14)

In the summertime we may feel pleasure from contact with water, but in the winter we may shun that very water because it is too cold. In either case, the water is the same, but we perceive it as pleasant or painful due to its contact with the body. All feelings of distress and happiness are due to the body. Under certain conditions the body and mind feel happiness and distress. Factually we are hankering after happiness, for the soul's constitutional position is that of happiness. The soul is part and parcel of the Supreme Being, who is sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù—the embodiment of knowledge, bliss and eternity. Indeed, the very name Kåñëa, which is nonsectarian, means "the greatest pleasure." Kåñ means greatest and ëa means pleasure. Kåñëa is the epitome of pleasure, and being part and parcel of Him, we hanker for pleasure. A drop of ocean water has all the properties of the ocean itself, and we, although minute particles of the Supreme Whole, have the same energetic properties of the Supreme.

The atomic soul, although so small, is moving the entire body to act in so many wonderful ways. In the world we see so many cities, highways, bridges, great buildings, monuments and great civilizations, but who has done all this? It is all done by the minute spirit spark within the body. If such wonderful things can be performed by the minute spirit spark, we cannot begin to imagine what can be accomplished by the Supreme Spirit Whole. The natural hankering of the minute spirit spark is for the qualities of the Whole—knowledge, bliss and eternality—but these hankerings are being frustrated due to the material body. The information on how to attain the soul's desire is given in Bhagavad-gétä.

At present we are trying to attain eternity, blissand knowledge by means of an imperfect instrument. Actually our progress towards these goals is being blocked by the material body; therefore we have to come to the realization of our existence beyond the body. Theoretical knowledge that we are not these bodies will not do. We have to keep ourselves always separate as masters of the body, not as servants. If we know how to drive a car well, it will give us good service; but if we do not know how, we will be in danger.

The body is composed of senses, and the senses are always hungry after their objects. The eyes see a beautiful person and tell us, "Oh, there is a beautiful girl, a beautiful boy. Let's go see." The ears are telling us, "Oh there is very nice music. Let us go hear it." The tongue is saying, "Oh, there is a very nice restaurant with palatable dishes. Let us go." In this way the senses are dragging us from one place to another, and because of this we are perplexed.

indriyäëäà hi caratäà
yan mano 'nuvidhéyate
tad asya harati prajïäà
väyur nävam ivämbhasi

"As a boat on the water is swept away by a strong wind, even one of the senses on which the mind focuses can carry away a man's intelligence." (Bg. 2.67)

It is imperative that we learn how to control the senses. The name gosvämé is given to someone who has learned how to master the senses. Go means senses, and svämé means controller, so one who can control the senses is to be considered a gosvämé. Kåñëa indicates that one who identifies with the illusory material body cannot establish himself in his proper identity as spirit soul. Bodily pleasure is flickering and intoxicating, and we cannot actually enjoy it because of its momentary nature. Actual pleasure is of the soul, not the body. We have to mold our lives in such a way that we will not be diverted by bodily pleasure. If somehow we are diverted, it is not possible for us to establish our consciousness in its true identity beyond the body.

bhogaiçvarya-prasaktänäà
tayäpahåta-cetasäm
vyavsäyätmikä buddhiù
samädhau na vidhéyate

traiguëya-viñayä vedä
bhavärjuna
nirdvandvo nitya-sattva-stho
niryoga-kñema ätmavän

"In the minds of those who are too attached to sense enjoyment and material opulence, and who are bewildered by such things, the resolute determination for devotional service to the Supreme Lord does not take place. The Vedas deal with the subject of the three modes of material nature. Rise above these modes, O Arjuna. Be transcendental to all of them. Be free from all dualities and from all anxieties for gain and safety, and be established in the Self." (Bg. 2.44-45)

The word veda means book of knowledge. There are many books of knowledge which vary according to the country, population, environment, etc. In India, the books of knowledge are referred to as the Vedas. In the West, they are called the Old Testament and New Testament. The Mohammedans accept the Koran. What is the purpose for all these books of knowledge? They are to train us to understand our position as pure soul. Their purpose is to restrict bodily activities by certain rules and regulations, and these rules and regulations are known as codes of morality. The Bible, for instance, has ten commandments intended to regulate our lives. The body must be controlled in order for us to reach the highest perfection, and without regulated principles, it is not possible to perfect our lives. The regulated principles may differ from country to country or from scripture to scripture, but that doesn't matter, for they are made according to the time and circumstances and mentality of the people. But the principle of regulated control is the same. Similarly, the government sets down certain regulations to be obeyed by its citizens. There is no possibility of making advancement in government or civilization without some regulations. In the verse above, Çré Kåñëa tells Arjuna that the regulative principles of the Vedas are meant to control the three modes of material nature—goodness, passion and ignorance (traiguëya-viñayä vedä). However, Kåñëa is advising Arjuna to establish himself in his pure constitutional position as spirit soul beyond the dualities of material nature.

As we have already pointed out, these dualities—such as heat and cold, pleasure and pain—arise due to the contact of the senses with their objects. In other words, they are born of identification with the body. Kåñëa indicates that those who are devoted to enjoyment and power are carried away by the words of the Vedas which promise pain or heavenly enjoyment by sacrifice and regulated activity. Enjoyment is our birthright, for it is the characteristic of the spirit soul, but the spirit soul tries to enjoy materially, and this is the mistake.

Everyone is turning to material subjects for enjoyment and is compiling as much knowledge as possible. Someone is becoming a chemist, physicist, politician or artist or whatever. Everyone knows something of everything and everything of something, and this is generally known as knowledge. But as soon as we leave the body, all of this knowledge is vanquished. In a previous life, one may be a great man of knowledge, but in this life he has to start again by going to school and learning how to read and write from the beginning. Whatever knowledge was acquired in the previous life is forgotten. The situation is that we are actually seeking eternal knowledge, but this cannot be acquired by this material body. We are all seeking enjoyment through these bodies, but bodily enjoyment is not our actual enjoyment. It is artificial. We have to understand that if we want to continue in this artificial enjoyment, we will not be able to attain our position of eternal enjoyment.

The body must be considered a diseased condition. A diseased man cannot enjoy himself properly; a man with jaundice, for instance, will taste sugar candy as bitter, but a healthy man can taste its sweetness. In either case, the sugar candy is the same, but according to our condition it tastes different. Unless we are cured of this diseased conception of bodily life, we cannot taste the sweetness of spiritual life. Indeed, it will taste bitter to us. At the same time, by increasing our enjoyment of material life, we are further complicating our diseased condition. A typhoid patient cannot eat solid food, and if someone gives it to him to enjoy, and he eats it, he is further complicating his malady and endangering his life. If we really want freedom from the miseries of material existence, we must minimize our bodily demands and pleasures.

Actually material enjoyment is not enjoyment at all. Real enjoyment does not cease. In the Mahäbhärata there is a verse—ramante yogino 'nante—to the effect that the yogés (yoginaù), those who are endeavoring to elevate themselves to the spiritual platform, are actually enjoying (ramante), but their enjoyment is anante—endless. This is because their enjoyment is in relation to the Supreme Enjoyer (Räma), Çré Kåñëa. Bhagavän Çré Kåñëa is the real Enjoyer, and Bhagavad-gétä confirms this.

bhoktäraà yajïa-tapasäà
sarva-loka-maheçvaram
suhådaà sarva-bhütänäà
jïätvä mäà çäntim åcchati

"The sages, knowing Me as the ultimate enjoyer of all sacrifices and austerities, the Supreme Lord of all planets and demigods and the benefactor and well-wisher of all living entities, attain peace from the pangs of material miseries." (Bg. 5.29)

Bhoga means enjoyment, and our enjoyment comes from understanding our position as the enjoyed. The real enjoyer is the Supreme Lord, and we are enjoyed by Him. An example of this relationship can be found in the material world between the husband and the wife: the husband is the enjoyer (puruña), and the wife is the enjoyed (prakåti). The word pri means woman. Puruña, or spirit, is the subject, and prakåti, or nature, is the object. The enjoyment, however, is participated in both by the husband and the wife. When actual enjoyment is there, there is no distinction that the husband is enjoying more or the wife is enjoying less. Although the male is the predominator, and the female is the predominated, there is no division when it comes to enjoyment. On a larger scale, no living entity is the enjoyer.

God expanded into many, and we constitute those expansions. God is one without a second, but He willed to become many in order to enjoy. We have experience that there is little or no enjoyment in sitting alone in a room talking to oneself. However, if there are five people present, our enjoyment is enhanced, and if we can discuss Kåñëa before many, many people, the enjoyment is all the greater. Enjoyment means variety. God became many for His enjoyment, and thus our position is that of enjoyed. That is our constitutional position and the purpose for our creation. Both enjoyer and enjoyed have consciousness, but the consciousness of the enjoyed is subordinate to the consciousness of the enjoyer. Although Kåñëa is the enjoyer and we the enjoyed, the enjoyment can be participated in equally by everyone. Our enjoyment can be perfected when we participate in the enjoyment of God. There is no possibility in our enjoying separately on the bodily platform. Material enjoyment on the gross bodily platform is discouraged throughout Bhagavad-gétä:

mäträ-sparçäs tu kaunteya
çétoñëa-sukha-duùkha-däù
ägamäpäyino 'nityäs
täàs titikñasva bhärata

"O son of Kunté, the nonpermanent appearance of heat and cold, happiness and distress, and their disappearance in due course, are like the appearance and disappearance of winter and summer seasons. They arise from sense perception, O scion of Bharata, and one must learn to tolerate them without being disturbed." (Bg. 2.14)

The gross material body is a result of the interaction of the modes of material nature, and it is doomed to destruction.

antavanta ime dehä
nityasyoktäù çarériëaù
anäçino 'prameyasya
tasmäd yudhyasva bhärata

"Only the material body of the indestructible, immeasurable and eternal living entity is subject to destruction; therefore, fight, O descendant of Bharata." (Bg. 2.18)

Çré Kåñëa therefore encourages us to transcend the bodily conception of existence and attain to our actual spiritual life.

guëän etän atétya trén
dehé deha-samudbhavän
janma-måtyu jarä-duùkhair
vimukto 'måtam açnute

"When the embodied being is able to transcend these three modes (goodness, passion and ignorance), he can become free from birth, death, old age and their distresses and can enjoy nectar even in this life." (Bg. 14.20)

To establish ourselves on the pure brahma-bhüta spiritual platform, above the three modes, we must take up the method of Kåñëa consciousness. The gift of Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the chanting of the names of Kåñëa—Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, facilitates this process. This method is called bhakti-yoga or mantra-yoga, and it is employed by the highest transcendentalists. How the transcendentalists realize their identity beyond birth and death, beyond the material body, and transfer themselves from the material universe to the spiritual universes are the subjects of the following chapters.

BBD 2: Elevation at Death

2
Elevation at Death

[661115BG.NY]

There are different kinds of transcendentalists who are called yogés—haöha-yogés, jïäna-yogés, dhyäna-yogés and bhakti-yogés—and all of them are eligible to be transferred to the spiritual world. The word yoga means "to link up," and the yoga systems are meant to enable us to link with the transcendental world. As mentioned in the previous chapter, originally we are all connected to the Supreme Lord, but now we have been affected by material contamination. The process is that we have to return to the spiritual world, and that process of linking up is called yoga. Another meaning of the word yoga is "plus." At the present moment we are minus God, or minus the Supreme. When we add Kåñëa—or God—to our lives, this human form of life becomes perfect.

At the time of death we have to finish that process of perfection. During our lifetime we have to practice the method of approaching that perfection so that at the time of death, when we have to give up this material body, that perfection can be realized.

prayäëa-käle manasä 'calena
bhaktyä yukto yoga-balena caiva
bhruvor madhye präëam äveçya samyak
sa taà paraà puruñam upaiti divyam

"One who, at the time of death, fixes his life air between the eyebrows and in full devotion engages himself in remembering the Supreme Lord, will certainly attain to the Supreme Personality of Godhead." (Bg. 8.10)

Just as a student studies a subject for four or five years and then takes his examination and receives a degree, similarly, with the subject of life, if we practice during our lives for the examination at the time of death, and if we pass the examination, we are transferred to the spiritual world. Our whole life is examined at the time of death.

yaà yaà väpi smaran bhävaà
tyajaty ante kalevaram
taà tam evaiti kaunteya
sadä tad-bhäva-bhävitaù

"Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits his body, that state he will attain without fail." (Bg. 8.6)

There is a Bengali proverb that says that whatever one does for perfection will be tested at the time of his death. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa describes what one should do when giving up the body. For the dhyäna-yogé (meditator) Çré Kåñëa speaks the following verses:

yad akñaraà veda-vido vadanti
viçanti yad yatayo véta-rägäù
yad icchanto brahmacaryaà caranti
tat te padaà saìgraheëa pravakñye

sarva-dväräëi saàyamya
mano hådi-nirudhya ca
mürdhny ädhäyätmanaù präëam
ästhito yoga-dhäraëäm

"Persons learned in the Vedas, who utter oàkära and who are great sages in the renounced order, enter into Brahman. Desiring such perfection, one practices celibacy. I shall now explain to you this process by which one may attain salvation. The yogic situation is that of detachment from all sensual engagements. Closing all the doors of the senses and fixing the mind on the heart and the life air at the top of the head, one establishes himself in yoga." (Bg. 8.11-12)

In the yoga system this process is called pratyähära, which means, "just the opposite." Although during life the eyes are engaged in seeing worldly beauty, at death one has to retract the senses from their objects and see the beauty within. Similarly, the ears are accustomed to hearing so many sounds in the world, but at the moment of death one has to hear the transcendental oàkära from within.

oà ity ekäkñaraà brahma-
vyäharan mäm anusmaran
yaù prayäti tyajan dehaà
sa yäti paramäà gatim

"After being situated in this yoga practice and vibrating the sacred syllable oà, the supreme combination of letters, if one thinks of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and quits his body, he will certainly reach the spiritual planets." (Bg. 8.13)

In this way, all the senses have to be stopped in their external activities and concentrated on the form of viñëumürti, the form of God. The mind is very turbulent, but it has to be fixed on the Lord in the heart. When the mind is fixed within the heart and the life air is transferred to the top of the head, one can attain perfection of yoga.

At this point the yogé determines where he is to go. In the material universe there are innumerable planets, and beyond this universe there is the spiritual universe. The yogés have information of these places from Vedic literatures. Just as one going to America can get some idea what the country is like by reading books, one can also have knowledge of the spiritual planets by reading Vedic literatures. The yogé knows all these descriptions, and he can transfer himself to any planet he likes without the help of spaceships. Space travel by mechanical means is not the accepted process for elevation to other planets. Perhaps with a great deal of time, effort and money a few men may be able to reach other planets by material means—spaceships, spacesuits, etc.—but this is a very cumbersome and impractical method. In any case, it is not possible to go beyond the material universe by mechanical means.

The generally accepted method for transferral to higher planets is the practice of the meditational yoga system or jïäna system. The bhakti-yoga system, however, is not to be practiced for transferral to any material planet, for those who are servants of Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, are not interested in any planets in this material world because they know that on whatever planet one enters in the material sky, the four principles of birth, old age, disease and death are present. On higher planets, the duration of life may be longer than on this earth, but death is there nonetheless. By "material universe" we refer to those planets where birth, old age, disease and death reside, and by "spiritual universe" we refer to those planets where there is no birth, old age, disease and death. Those who are intelligent do not try to elevate themselves to any planet within the material universe.

If one tries to enter higher planets by mechanical means, instant death is assured, for the body cannot stand the radical changes in atmosphere. But if one attempts to go to higher planets by means of the yoga system, he will acquire a suitable body for entrance. We can see this demonstrated on this earth, for we know it is not possible for us to live in the sea, in a watery atmosphere, nor is it possible for aquatics to live on the earth. As we understand that even on this planet one has to have a particular type of body to live in a particular place, so a particular type of body is required for other planets. On the higher planets, bodies live much longer than on earth, for six months on earth is equal to one day on the higher planets. Thus the Vedas describe that those who live on higher planets live upward to ten thousand earth years. Yet despite such a long life span, death awaits everyone. Even if one lives twenty thousand or fifty thousand or even millions of years, in the material world the years are all counted, and death is there. How can we escape this subjugation to death? That is the lesson of Bhagavad-gétä. (2.20)

na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin
näyaà bhütvä bhavitä vä na bhüyaù
ajo nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëo
na hanyate hanyamäne çarére

"For the soul there is never birth nor death. Nor, once having been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying, and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain."

We are spirit soul, and as such we are eternal. Why then should we subject ourselves to birth and death? One who asks this question is to be considered intelligent. Those who are Kåñëa conscious are very intelligent because they are not interested in gaining entrance to any planet where there is death. They will reject a long duration of life in order to attain a body like unto God's. Éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù. Sat means eternal, cit means full of knowledge, and änanda means full of pleasure. Kåñëa is the reservoir of all pleasure. If we transfer ourselves from this body into the spiritual world—either to Kåñëaloka, Kåñëa's planet, or any other spiritual planet—we will receive a similar sac-cid-änanda body. Thus the aim of those who are in Kåñëa consciousness is different from those who are trying to promote themselves to higher planets within this material world.

The self or soul of the individual is a minute spiritual spark. The perfection of yoga lies in the transferral of this spiritual spark to the top of the head. Having attained this, the yogé can transfer himself to any planet in the material world according to his desire. If the yogé is curious to know what the moon is like, he can transfer himself there, or if he is interested in higher planets, he can transfer himself there, just as travellers go to New York, Canada, or other cities on the earth. Wherever one goes on earth, he finds the same visa and customs systems operating, and on all the material planets one can similarly see the principles of birth, old age, disease and death operating.

Oà ity ekäkñaraà brahma: at the point of death the yogé can pronounce oà, oàkära, the concise form of transcendental sound vibration. If the yogé can vibrate this sound and at the same time (mäm anusmaran) remember Kåñëa or Viñëu, he attains the highest goal. It is the process of yoga to concentrate the mind on Viñëu. The impersonalists imagine some form of the Supreme Lord, but the personalists do not imagine this; they actually see. Whether one imagines Him or actually sees Him, one has to concentrate his mind on the personal form of Kåñëa.

ananya-cetäù satataà
yo mäà smarati nityaçaù
tasyähaà sulabhaù pärtha
nitya-yuktasya yoginaù

"For one who remembers Me without deviation, I am easy to obtain, O son of Påthä, because of his constant engagement in devotional service." (Bg. 8.14)

Those who are satisfied with temporary life, temporary pleasure and temporary facilities are not to be considered intelligent, at least not according to Bhagavad-gétä. One whose brain substance is very small is interested in temporary things, according to the Gétä. We are eternal, so why should we be interested in temporary things? No one wants a nonpermanent situation. If we are living in an apartment and the landlord asks us to vacate, we are sorry, but we are not sorry if we move into a better apartment. It is our nature, because we are permanent, to want permanent residence. We don't wish to die because in actuality we are permanent. Nor do we want to grow old or be diseased because these are all external or nonpermanent states. Although we are not meant to suffer from fever, sometimes fever comes, and we have to take precautions and remedies to get well again. The fourfold miseries are like a fever, and they are all due to the material body. If somehow we can get out of the material body, we can escape the miseries that are integral with it.

For the impersonalists to get out of this temporary body, Kåñëa here advises that they vibrate the syllable oà. In this way they can be assured of transmigration into the spiritual world. However, although they may enter the spiritual world, they cannot enter into any of the planets there. They remain outside in the brahmajyoti. The brahmajyoti may be likened unto the sunshine, and the spiritual planets may be likened unto the sun itself. In the spiritual sky the impersonalists remain in the effulgence of the Supreme Lord, the brahmajyoti. The impersonalists are placed in the brahmajyoti as spiritual sparks, and in this way the brahmajyoti is filled with spiritual sparks. This is what is meant by merging into the spiritual existence. It should not be considered that one merges into the brahmajyoti in the sense of becoming one with it; the individuality of the spiritual spark is retained, but because the impersonalist does not want to take a personal form, he is found as a spiritual spark in that effulgence. Just as the sunshine is composed of so many atomic particles, so the brahmajyoti is composed of so many spiritual sparks.

However, as living entities, we want enjoyment. Being in itself is not enough. We want bliss (änanda) as well as being (sat). In his entirety, the living entity is composed of three qualities—eternality, knowledge and bliss. Those who enter impersonally into the brahmajyoti can remain there for some time in full knowledge that they are now merged homogeneously with Brahman, but they cannot have that eternal änanda, bliss, because that part is wanting. One may remain alone in a room for some time and may enjoy himself by reading a book or engaging in some thought, but it is not possible to remain in that room for years and years at a time, and certainly not for all eternity. Therefore for one who merges impersonally into the existence of the Supreme, there is every chance of falling down again into the material world in order to acquire some association. This is the verdict of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Astronauts may travel thousands and thousands of miles, but if they do not find rest on some planet, they have to return again to earth. In any case, rest is required. In the impersonal form, rest is uncertain. Therefore Çrémad-Bhägavatam says that even after so much endeavor, if the impersonalist enters into the spiritual world and acquires an impersonal form, he returns again into the material world because of neglecting to serve the Supreme Lord in love and devotion. As long as we are here on earth, we must learn to practice to love and serve Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord. If we learn this, we can enter into those spiritual planets. The impersonalist's position in the spiritual world is nonpermanent, for out of loneliness he will attempt to acquire some association. Because he does not associate personally with the Supreme Lord, he has to return again to the world and associate with conditioned living entities there.

It is of utmost importance, therefore, that we know the nature of our constitutional position: we want eternity, complete knowledge and pleasure also. When we are left alone for a long time, we cannot have pleasure—we accept the pleasure given by the material world. In Kåñëa consciousness, real pleasure is enjoyed. In the material world it is generally accepted that the highest pleasure is sex. This is a perverted reflection of the sex pleasure in the spiritual world, the pleasure of association with Kåñëa. But we should not think that pleasure there is like the sex pleasure in the material world. No, it is different. But unless sex life is there in the spiritual world, it cannot be reflected here. Here it is simply a perverted reflection, but the actual life is there in Kåñëa, who is full of all pleasure. Therefore, the best process is to train ourselves now so that at the time of death we may transfer ourselves to the spiritual universe, to Kåñëaloka, and there associate with Kåñëa. In Brahma-saàhitä Çré Kåñëa and His abode are described thus:

cintämaëi-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña-
lakñävåteñu surabhér abhipälayantam
lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor, who is tending the cows, fulfilling all desire, in abodes built with spiritual gems, surrounded by millions of wish-fulfilling trees, always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds and thousands of lakñmés, or gopés." (Bs. 5.29)

This is a description of Kåñëaloka. The houses are made of what is called "touchstone." Whatever touchstone touches immediately turns into gold. The trees are wish-fulfilling trees or "desire trees," for one can receive from them whatever he wishes. In this world we get mangoes from mango trees and apples from apple trees, but there from any tree one can get whatever he desires. Similarly, the cows are called surabhi, and they yield an endless supply of milk. These are descriptions of the spiritual planets found in Vedic scriptures.

In this material world we have become acclimatized to birth, death and all sorts of suffering. Material scientists have discovered many facilities for sense enjoyment and destruction, but they have discovered no solution to the problems of old age, disease and death. They cannot make any machine that will check death, old age or disease. We can manufacture something that will accelerate death, but nothing that will stop death. Those who are intelligent, however, are not concerned with the fourfold miseries of material life but with elevation to the spiritual planets. One who is continuously in trance (nitya-yuktasya yoginaù) does not divert his attention to anything else. He is always situated in trance. His mind is always filled with the thought of Kåñëa, without deviation (ananya-cetäù satatam). Satatam refers to anywhere and anytime.

In India I lived in Våndävana, and now I am in America, but this does not mean that I am out of Våndävana because if I think of Kåñëa always, then I'm always in Våndävana, regardless of the material designation. Kåñëa consciousness means that one always lives with Kåñëa on that spiritual planet, Goloka Våndävana, and that one is simply waiting to give up this material body. Smarati nityaçaù means continuously remembering, and for one who is continuously remembering Kåñëa, the Lord becomes tasyähaà sulabhaù—easily purchased. Kåñëa Himself says that He is easily purchased by this bhakti-yoga process. Then why should we take to any other process? We can chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare twenty-four hours daily. There are no rules and regulations. One can chant in the street, in the subway or at his home or office. There is no tax and no expense. So why not take to it?

BBD 3: Liberation from Material Planets

3
Liberation From Material Planets

[661116BG.NY] & [661117BG.NY]

The jïänés and yogés are generally impersonalists, and although they attain the temporary form of liberation by merging into the impersonal effulgence, the spiritual sky, their knowledge, according to Çrémad-Bhägavatam, is not considered pure. By penances, austerities and meditations, they can rise up to the Supreme Absolute platform, but, as has been explained, they again fall down to the material world because they have not taken Kåñëa's personal features seriously. Unless one worships the lotus feet of Kåñëa, he again has to descend to the material platform. The ideal attitude should be: "I am Your eternal servitor. Please let me somehow engage in Your service." Kåñëa is called ajitaù—unconquerable—for no one can conquer God, but according to Çrémad-Bhägavatam, one with this attitude easily conquers the Supreme. Çrémad-Bhägavatam also recommends that we give up this futile process to measure the Supreme. We cannot even measure the limitations of space, what to speak of the Supreme. It is not possible to measure the length and breadth of Kåñëa by one's minuscule knowledge, and one who arrives at this conclusion is considered intelligent by Vedic literature. One should come to understand, submissively, that he is a very insignificant segment of the universe. Abandoning the endeavor to understand the Supreme by limited knowledge or mental speculation, we should become submissive and hear of the Supreme through authoritative sources such as Bhagavad-gétä or through the lips of a realized soul.

In Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna is hearing about God from the lips of Çré Kåñëa Himself. In this way Arjuna set the criteria for understanding the Supreme by submissive hearing. It is our position to hear Bhagavad-gétä from the lips of Arjuna or his bona fide representative, the spiritual master. After hearing, it is necessary to practice this acquired knowledge in daily life. "My dear Lord, You are unconquerable," the devotee prays, "but by this process, by hearing, You are conquered." God is unconquerable, but He is conquered by the devotee who abandons mental speculations and listens to authoritative sources.

According to Brahma-saàhitä, there are two ways of acquiring knowledge—the ascending process and descending process. By the ascending process, one is elevated by knowledge acquired by himself. In this way one thinks, "I don't care for any authorities or books. I will attain knowledge myself by meditation, philosophy, etc. In this way I will understand God." The other process, the descending process, involves receiving knowledge from higher authorities. Brahma-saàhitä states that if one takes to the ascending process and travels at the speed of mind and wind for millions of years, he will still end up not knowing. For him, the subject matter will remain elusive and inconceivable. But that subject matter is given in Bhagavad-gétä: ananya-cetäù: Kåñëa says to meditate on Him without deviation from the path of devotional service in submission. For one who worships Him in this way—tasyähaà sulabhaù: "I become easily available." This is the process: if one works for Kåñëa twenty-four hours a day, Kåñëa cannot forget him. By becoming submissive, he can attract the attention of God. As Guru Mahäräja Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté used to say, "Don't try to see God. Is God to come and stand before us like a servant just because we want to see Him? That is not the submissive way. We have to oblige Him by our love and service."

The proper process for approaching Kåñëa was given to humanity by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, and Rüpa Gosvämé, His first disciple, appreciated it. Rüpa Gosvämé was a minister in the Mohammedan government, but he left the government to become a disciple of Caitanya Mahäprabhu's. When he first went to see the Lord, Rüpa Gosvämé approached Him with the following verse [Madhya 19.53]:

namo mahä-vadänyäya kåñëa-prema-pradäya te
kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-nämne guara-tviñe namaù

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya, who is more magnanimous than any other avatära, even Kåñëa Himself, because He is bestowing freely what no one else has ever given—pure love of Kåñëa."

Rüpa Gosvämé called Caitanya Mahäprabhu "the most munificent, the most charitable personality," because He was offering the most precious thing of all very cheaply—love of God. We all want Kåñëa and are all hankering after Him. Kåñëa is the most attractive, the most beautiful, the most opulent, the most powerful and the most learned. That is the object of our hankering. We're hankering after the beautiful, the powerful, the learned, the wealthy. Kåñëa is the reservoir of all of this, so we need only turn our attention toward Him, and we will get everything. Everything—whatever we want. Whatever is our heart's desire will be fulfilled by this process of Kåñëa consciousness.

For one who dies in Kåñëa consciousness, as stated before, entrance into Kåñëaloka, the supreme abode where Kåñëa resides, is guaranteed. At this point one may ask what the advantage is in going to that planet, and Kåñëa Himself answers:

mäm upetya punar janma
duùkhälayam açäçvatam
näpnuvanti mahätmänaù
saàsiddhià paramäà gatäù

"After attaining Me, the great souls, who are yogés in devotion, never return to this temporary world, which is full of miseries, because they have attained the highest perfection." (Bg. 8.15)

This material world is certified by Çré Kåñëa, the creator, as duùkhälayam—full of miseries. How then can we make it comfortable? Is it possible to make this world comfortable by the so-called advancement of science? No, this is not possible. As a result, we do not even wish to know what these miseries are. The miseries, as stated before, are birth, old age, disease and death, and because we cannot make a solution to them we try to set them aside. Science has no power to solve these miseries that are always giving us trouble. Instead they divert our attention into making spaceships or atomic bombs. The solution to these problems is given here in Bhagavad-gétä: if one attains to Kåñëa's platform he does not have to return again to this earth of birth and death. We should try to understand that this place is full of miseries. It takes a certain amount of developed consciousness to understand this. Cats and dogs and hogs cannot understand that they are suffering. Man is called a rational animal, but his rationality is being used to further his animalistic propensities instead of finding out how to get liberation from this miserable condition. Here Kåñëa explicitly states that one who comes to Him will never be reborn to suffer miseries again. Those great souls who come to Him have attained the highest perfection of life which alleviates the living entity from the suffering of conditional existence.

One of the differences between Kåñëa and an ordinary being is that an ordinary entity can be only in one place at a time, but Kåñëa can be everywhere in the universe and yet in His own abode, simultaneously. Kåñëa's abode in the transcendental kingdom is called Goloka Våndävana. The Våndävana in India is that same Våndävana descended on this earth. When Kåñëa descends Himself by His own internal potency, His dhäma, or abode, also descends. In other words, when Kåñëa descends on this earth, He manifests Himself in that particular land. Despite this, Kåñëa's abode remains eternally in the transcendental sphere, in the Vaikuëöhas. In this verse Kåñëa proclaims that one who comes to His abode in the Vaikuëöhas never has to take birth again in the material world. Such a person is called mahätmä. The word mahätmä is generally heard in the West in connection with Mahatma Gandhi, but we should understand that mahätmä is not the title of a politician. Rather, mahätmä refers to the first-class Kåñëa conscious man who is eligible to enter into the abode of Kåñëa. The mahätmä's perfection is this: to utilize the human form of life and the resources of nature to extricate himself from the cycle of birth and death.

An intelligent person knows that he does not want miseries, but they are inflicted upon him by force. As stated before, we are always in a miserable condition due to this mind, body, natural disturbances or other living entities. There is always some kind of misery inflicted upon us. This material world is meant for misery; unless the misery is there, we cannot come to Kåñëa consciousness. Miseries are actually an impetus and help to elevate us to Kåñëa consciousness. An intelligent man questions why these miseries are inflicted on him by force. However, modern civilization's attitude is, "Let me suffer. Let me cover it by some intoxication. That's all." But as soon as the intoxication is over, the miseries return. It is not possible to make a solution to the miseries of life by artificial intoxication. The solution is made by Kåñëa consciousness.

One may point out that although the devotees of Kåñëa are trying to enter Kåñëa's planet, our interest is in going to the moon. Isn't going to the moon also perfection? The tendency to travel to other planets is always present in the living entity. One name for the living entity is sarva-gata, which means "one who wants to travel everywhere." Travel is part of the nature of the living entity. The desire to go to the moon is not a new thing. The yogés also are interested in entering the higher planets, but in Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa points out that this will not be of any help.

äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

"From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place. But one who attains to My abode, O son of Kunté, never takes birth again." (Bg. 8.16)

The universe is divided into higher, middle and lower planetary systems. The earth is considered to be a member of the middle planetary system. Kåñëa points out that even if one enters into the highest planet of all, called Brahmaloka, there is still repetition of birth and death. Other planets in the universe are full of living entities. We should not think that we are here and that all the other planets are vacant. From experience we can see that no place on earth is vacant of living entities. If we dig deep down into the earth, we find worms; if we go deep into the water, we find aquatics; if we go into the sky, we find so many birds. How is it possible to conclude that other planets have no living entities? But Kåñëa points out that even if we enter into those planets where great demigods reside, we will still be subjected to death. Again, Kåñëa repeats that upon reaching His planet, one need not take birth again.

We should be very serious about attaining our eternal life full of bliss and knowledge. We have forgotten that this is actually our aim of life, our real self-interest. Why have we forgotten? We have simply been entrapped by the material glitter, by skyscrapers, big factories and political play, although we know that however big we build skyscrapers, we will not be able to live here indefinitely. We should not spoil our energy in building mighty industries and cities to further entrap ourselves in material nature; rather, our energy should be used to develop Kåñëa consciousness in order to attain a spiritual body whereby we may enter into Kåñëa's planet. Kåñëa consciousness is not a religious formula or some spiritual recreation; it is the most important part of the living entity.

BBD 4: The Sky Beyond The Universe

4
The Sky Beyond The Universe

[661117BG.NY] & [661118BG.NY] & [661119BG.NY]

If even the higher planets in this universe are subject to birth and death, why do great yogés strive for elevation to them? Although they may have many mystic powers, these yogés still have the tendency to want to enjoy the facilities of material life. On the higher planets, it is possible to live for incredibly long lifetimes. The time calculation on these planets is indicated by Çré Kåñëa:

sahasra-yuga-paryantam
ahar yad brahmaëo viduù
rätrià yuga-sahasräntäà
te 'ho-rätra-vido janäù

"By human calculation, a thousand ages taken together is the duration of Brahmä's one day. And such also is the duration of his night." (Bg. 8.17)

One yuga covers 4,300,000 years. This number multiplied by one thousand is calculated to be twelve hours of Brahmä on the planet Brahmaloka. Similarly, another twelve hour period covers the night. Thirty such days equal a month, twelve months a year, and Brahmä lives for one hundred such years. Life on such a planet is indeed long, yet, even after trillions of years, the inhabitants of Brahmaloka have to face death. Unless we go into the spiritual planets, there is no escape from death.

avyaktäd vyaktayaù sarväù
prabhavanty ahar-ägame
rätry-ägame praléyante
tatraivävyakta-saàjïake

"When Brahmä's day is manifest, this multitude of living entities comes into being, and at the arrival of Brahmä's night, they are all annihilated." (Bg. 8.18)

At the end of the day of Brahmä, all the lower planetary systems are covered with water, and the beings on them are annihilated. After this devastation and after the night of Brahmä passes, in the morning when Brahmä arises, there is again creation and all these beings come forth. Thus subjection to creation and destruction is the nature of the material world.

bhüta-grämaù sa eväyaà
bhütvä bhütvä praléyate
rätry-ägame 'vaçaù pärtha
prabhavaty ahar-ägame

"Again and again the day comes, and this host of beings is active; and again the night falls, O Pärtha, and they are helplessly dissolved." (Bg. 8.19)

Although the living entities do not like devastation, that devastation will come and overflood the planets until all living beings on the planets stay merged in water throughout the night of Brahmä. But as day comes, the water gradually disappears.

paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo
'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù
yaù sa sarveñu bhüteñu
naçyatsu na vinaçyati

"Yet there is another nature, which is eternal and is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is." (Bg. 8.20)

We cannot calculate the extent of the material universe, but we have Vedic information that there are millions of universes within the entire creation, and beyond these material universes there is another sky which is spiritual. There all the planets are eternal, and the lives of all the beings on them are eternal. In this verse the word bhävaù means nature, and here another nature is indicated. In this world we have experience also of two natures. The living entity is spirit, and as long as he is within matter, matter is moving, and as soon as the living entity, the spiritual spark, is out of the body, the body is immovable. The spiritual nature is called Kåñëa's superior nature, and the material is called the inferior. Beyond this material nature there is a superior nature which is totally spiritual. It is not possible to understand this by experimental knowledge. We can see millions and millions of stars through a telescope, but we cannot approach them. We have to understand our incapabilities. If we cannot understand the material universe by experimental knowledge, what is the possibility of understanding God and His kingdom? It is not possible experimentally. We have to understand by hearing Bhagavad-gétä. We cannot understand who our father is by experimental knowledge; we have to hear the word of our mother and believe her. If we do not believe her, there is no way of knowing. If we just stick to the Kåñëa conscious method, all information about Kåñëa and His kingdom will be revealed.

Paras tu bhävaù means "superior nature," and avyaktaù refers to what we see manifested. We can see that the material universe is manifested through the earth, sun, stars and planets. Beyond this universe is another nature, an eternal nature. Avyaktät sanätanaù. This material nature has a beginning and an end, but that spiritual nature is sanätanaù—eternal. It has neither beginning nor end. How is this possible? A cloud may pass over the sky, and it may appear to cover a great distance, but actually it is only a small speck covering an insignificant part of the whole sky. Because we are so small, if only a few hundred miles is covered by cloud, it appears that the whole sky is covered. Similarly, this whole material universe is like a small insignificant cloud in the vast spiritual sky. It is encased by the mahat-tattva, matter. As a cloud has a beginning and an end, this material nature also has a beginning and an end. When the clouds disappear and the sky clears, we see everything as it is. Similarly, the body is like a cloud passing over the spirit soul. It stays for some time, gives some by-products, dwindles and then vanishes. Any kind of material phenomena that we observe is subject to these six transformations of material nature—it comes into being, grows, stays for a while, produces some by-products, dwindles and then vanishes. Kåñëa indicates that beyond this changing cloud-like nature there is a spiritual nature which is eternal. In addition, when this material nature is annihilated, that avyaktät sanätanaù will remain.

In Vedic literatures there is a good deal of information about the material and spiritual skies. In the Second Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there are descriptions of the spiritual sky and of its inhabitants. There is even information given that there are spiritual airplanes in the spiritual sky and that the liberated entities there travel about on these planes like lightning. Everything that we find here can also be found there in reality. Here in the material sky everything is an imitation or shadow of that which exists in the spiritual sky. As in a cinema we simply see a show or facsimile of the real thing, in Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is said that this material world is but a combination of matter modelled on the reality, just as a mannequin of a girl in a store window is modelled on a girl. Every sane man knows that the mannequin is an imitation. Çrédhara Svämé says that because the spiritual world is real, this material world, which is an imitation, appears to be real. We must understand the meaning of reality—reality means existence which cannot be vanquished; reality means eternity.

näsato vidyate bhävo
näbhävo vidyate sataù
ubhayor api dåñöo 'ntas
tv anayos tattva-darçibhiù

"Those who are seers of the truth have concluded that of the nonexistent there is no endurance, and of the existent there is no cessation. This seers have concluded by studying the nature of both." (Bg. 2.16)

Real pleasure is Kåñëa, whereas material pleasure, which is temporary, is not actual. Those who can see things as they are do not take part in shadow pleasure. The real aim of human life is to attain that spiritual sky, but, as Çrémad-Bhägavatam points out, most people do not know about it. Human life is meant to understand reality and to be transferred into it. All Vedic literature instructs us not to remain in this darkness. The nature of this material world is darkness, but the spiritual world is full of light and yet is not illumined by fire or electricity. Kåñëa hints of this in the Fifteenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä:

na tad bhäsayate süryo
na çaçäìko na pävakaù
yad gatvä na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"That abode of Mine is not illumined by the sun or moon, nor by electricity. One who reaches it never returns to this material world." (Bg. 15.6)

The spiritual world is called unmanifested because it cannot be perceived by material senses.

avyakto 'kñara ity uktas
tam ähuù paramäà gatim
yaà präpya na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"That supreme abode is called unmanifested and infallible, and it is the supreme destination. When one goes there, he never comes back. That is My supreme abode." (Bg. 8.21)

A great journey is indicated in this verse. We have to be able to penetrate outer space, traverse the material universe, penetrate its covering and enter the spiritual sky. Paramäà gatim—that journey is supreme. There is no question of going a few thousand miles away from this planet and then returning. This sort of journey is not very heroic. We have to penetrate the whole material universe. This we cannot do by spaceships but by Kåñëa consciousness. One who is absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness and who at the time of death thinks of Kåñëa is at once transferred there. If we at all want to go to that spiritual sky and cultivate eternal blissful life full of knowledge, we will have to begin now to cultivate a sac-cid-änanda body. It is said that Kåñëa has a sac-cid-änanda body—éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù—and we also have a similar body of eternity, knowledge and bliss, but it is very small and is covered by the dress of matter. If somehow or other we are able to give up this false dress, we can reach that spiritual kingdom. If once we can attain that spiritual world, return is not necessary (yaà präpya na nivartante).

Everyone then should try to go to that dhäma paramam—Kåñëa's supreme abode. Kåñëa Himself comes to call us, and He gives us literatures as guidebooks and sends His bona fide representatives. We should take advantage of this facility given to human life. For one who reaches that supreme abode, penances, austerities, yogic meditations and so on are no longer required, and for one who does not reach it, all penances and austerities are a useless waste of time. The human form of life is an opportunity to get this boon, and it is the duty of the State, of the parents, teachers and guardians to elevate those who have acquired this human form of life to attain this perfection of life. Simply eating, sleeping, mating and quarrelling like cats and dogs is not civilization. We should properly utilize this human form of life and take advantage of this knowledge to prepare ourselves in Kåñëa consciousness so that twenty-four hours of the day we will be absorbed in Kåñëa and at death at once transfer to that spiritual sky.

puruñaù sa paraù pärtha
bhaktyä labhyas tv ananyayä
yasyäntaùsthäni bhütäni
yena sarvam idaà tatam

"The Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is greater than all, is attainable by unalloyed devotion. Although He is present in His abode, He is all-pervading, and everything is situated within Him." (Bg. 8.22)

If we are at all interested in reaching that supreme abode, the process, as indicated here, is bhakti. Bhaktyä means devotional service, submission to the Supreme Lord. The root word for bhaktä is bhaj, which means service. The definition of bhakti given in the Närada-païcarätra is "freedom from designation." If one is determined to get out of all the designations that are attached to the pure spirit soul, and which arise due to the body and are always changed when the body is changed, one can attain to bhakti. Bhakti is realizing that one is pure spirit and not matter at all. Our real identity is not this body, which is simply a covering of the spirit, but our real identity is däsa, servant of Kåñëa. When one is situated in his real identity and is rendering service to Kåñëa, he is a bhakta. Håñékeëa håñékeça sevenam: when our senses are free from material designations, we will utilize them in the service of the master of the senses, Håñékeça, or Kåñëa.

As Rüpa Gosvämé points out, we have to serve Kåñëa favorably. Generally we want to serve God for some material purpose or gain. Of course one who goes to God for material gain is better than one who never goes, but we should be free from desire for material benefit. Our aim should be to understand Kåñëa. Of course Kåñëa is unlimited, and it is not possible to understand Him, but we have to accept what we can understand. Bhagavad-gétä is specifically presented for our understanding. Through receiving knowledge in this way, we should know that Kåñëa is pleased, and we should serve Him favorably according to His pleasure. Kåñëa consciousness is a great science with immense literatures, and we should utilize them for the attainment of bhakti.

Puruñaù sa paraù [Bg. 8.22]: In the spiritual sky, the Supreme Lord is present as the Supreme Person. There are innumerable self-luminous planets there, and in each one an expansion of Kåñëa resides. They are four-armed, and have innumerable names. They are all persons—they are not impersonal. These puruñaùs or persons can be approached by bhakti, not by challenge, philosophical speculation or mental concoctions or by physical exercises, but by devotion without the deviations of fruitive activity.

What is the puruñaù, the Supreme Person, like? yasyäntaùsthäni bhütäni yena sarvam idaà tatam: every living entity and everything is within Him, and yet He is without, all-pervading. How is that? He is just like the sun, which is situated in one place and yet is present all over by its rays. Although God is situated in His dhäma paramam, His energies are distributed everywhere. Nor is He different from His energies inasmuch as the sunshine and the sun are nondifferent. Since Kåñëa and His energies are non-different, we can see Kåñëa everywhere if we are advanced in devotional service.

premäïjana-cchurita bhakti-vilocanena
santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti

"I worship the original Personality of Godhead, Govinda, whom the pure devotees whose eyes are smeared with the ointment of love of Godhead always observe within their hearts." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.38)

Those who are filled with love of God see God constantly before them. It is not that we saw God yesterday night and He is no longer present. No, for one who is Kåñëa conscious, Kåñëa is always present and can be perceived constantly. We simply have to develop the eyes to see Him.

Due to our material bondage, the covering of the material senses, we cannot understand what is spiritual, but this ignorance can be removed by this process of chanting Hare Kåñëa. How is this? A sleeping man may be awakened by sound vibration. Although a man may be for all intents and purposes unconscious—he cannot see, feel, smell, etc.—the sense of hearing is so prominent that a sleeping man may be awakened just by sound vibration. Similarly, the spirit soul, although now overpowered by the sleep of material contact, can be revived by this transcendental sound vibration of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Hare Kåñëa is simply an address to the Supreme Lord and His energies. Hare means energy, and Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord, so when we chant Hare Kåñëa we are saying, "Oh energy of the Lord, O Lord, please accept me." We have no other prayer for acceptance by the Lord. There is no question of praying for daily bread, for the bread is always there. Hare Kåñëa is but an address to the Supreme Lord requesting Him to accept us. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself prayed:

ayi nandatanuja kiìkaraà patitaà mäà viñame bhavämbudhau
kåpayä tava päda-paìkaja-sthita-dhülésadåçaà vicintaya

"O son of Mahäräja Nanda, I am Your eternal servitor, and although I am so, somehow or other I have fallen in the ocean of birth and death. Please, therefore, pick me up from this ocean of death and fix me as one of the atoms of Your lotus feet." (Çikñäñöakam, 5)

The only hope for a man fallen in the middle of the ocean is that someone will come and pick him up. If someone just comes and hauls him but a few feet out of the water, he is immediately relieved. Similarly, if we are somehow lifted from the ocean of birth and death by the process of Kåñëa consciousness, we are immediately relieved.

Although we cannot perceive the transcendental nature of the Supreme Lord, His name, fame and activities, if we establish ourselves in Kåñëa consciousness, gradually God will reveal Himself before us. We cannot see God by our own endeavor, but if we qualify ourselves, God will reveal Himself, and then we will see. No one can order God to come before him and dance, but we do have to work in such a way that Kåñëa will be pleased to reveal Himself to us.

Kåñëa gives us information about Himself in Bhagavad-gétä, and there is no question of doubting it; we just have to feel it, understand it. There is no preliminary qualification necessary for the understanding of Bhagavad-gétä, because it is spoken from the Absolute platform. The simple process of chanting the names of Kåñëa will reveal what one is, what God is, what the material and spiritual universes are, why we are conditioned, how we can get out of that conditioning and everything else step by step. Actually the process of belief and revelation is not foreign to us. Every day we place faith in something that we have confidence will be revealed later. We may purchase a ticket to go to India, and on the basis of the ticket we have faith that we will be transported there. Why should we pay money for a ticket? We do not just give the money to anyone. The company is authorized and the airline is authorized, so faith is created. Without faith we cannot take one step forward in the ordinary course of our life. Faith we must have, but it must be faith in that which is authorized. It is not that we have blind faith but that we accept something that is recognized. Bhagavad-gétä is recognized and accepted as scripture by all classes of men in India, and as far as outside India is concerned, many scholars, theologians and philosophers accept Bhagavad-gétä as a great authoritative work. There is no question that Bhagavad-gétä is authority. Even Professor Albert Einstein, such a scientist, read Bhagavad-gétä regularly.

From Bhagavad-gétä we have to accept that there is a spiritual universe which is the kingdom of God. If somehow we are transported to a country where we are informed that we will no longer have to undergo birth, old age, disease and death, will we not be happy? If we heard of such a place, surely we would try as hard as possible to go there. No one wants to grow old; no one wants to die. Indeed, a place free of such sufferings would be our heart's desire. Why do we want this? Because we have the right, the prerogative, to want it. We are eternal, blissful and full of knowledge, but having been covered by this material entanglement, we have forgotten ourselves. Bhagavad-gétä gives us the advantage of being able to revive our original status.

The Çaìkarites and Buddhists claim that the world beyond is void, but Bhagavad-gétä does not disappoint us like this. The philosophy of voidness has simply created atheists. We are spiritual beings, and we want enjoyment, but as soon as our future is void, we will become inclined to enjoy this material life. In this way, the impersonalists discuss the philosophy of voidism while trying as much as possible to enjoy this material life. One may enjoy speculation in this way, but there is no spiritual benefit.

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments or desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state he attains pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54)

He who has progressed in devotional life and who is relishing service to Kåñëa will automatically become detached from material enjoyment. The symptom of one absorbed in bhakti is that he is fully satisfied with Kåñëa.

BBD 5: Associating With Kåñëa

5
Associating With Kåñëa

[661119BG.NY] & [661120BG.NY] & [661121BG.NY]

If one gets something superior, he naturally gives up all inferior things. We want enjoyment, but impersonalism and voidism has created such an atmosphere that we have become addicted to material enjoyment. There must be enjoyment in connection with the Supreme Person (puruñaù sa paraù), whom we can see face to face. In the spiritual sky we are able to speak personally with God, to play, eat with Him, etc. All of this can be attained by bhaktyä—transcendental loving service. However, this service must be without adulteration, that is to say that we must love God without expecting material remuneration. Loving God to become one with Him is also a form of adulteration.

One of the major differences between the spiritual sky and the material sky is that in the spiritual sky the head or leader of the spiritual planets has no rival. In all cases, the predominating personality in the spiritual planets is a plenary expansion of Çré Kåñëa. The Supreme Lord and His multifarious manifestations preside over all the Vaikuëöha planets. On earth, for instance, there is rivalry for the position of president or prime minister, but in the spiritual sky everyone acknowledges the Supreme Personality of Godhead to be supreme. Those who do not acknowledge Him and attempt to rival Him are placed into the material universe, which is just like a prison house. As in any city there is a prison, and the prison forms a very insignificant part of the whole city, so the material universe is a prison for the conditioned souls. It forms an insignificant part of the spiritual sky, but it is not outside the spiritual sky, just as a prison is not outside of the city.

The inhabitants of the Vaikuëöha planets in the spiritual sky are all liberated souls. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam we are informed that their bodily features are exactly like God's. On some of these planets God is manifested with two arms, and on others He has four. The inhabitants of these planets, like the Supreme Lord, also manifest two and four arms, and it is said that one cannot distinguish between them and the Supreme Person. In the spiritual world there are five kinds of liberation. Säyujya-mukti is a form of liberation in which one merges into the impersonal existence of the Supreme Lord, called Brahman. Another form of liberation is särüpya-mukti, by which one receives features exactly like God's. Another is sälokya-mukti, by which one can live in the same planet with God. By särñöi-mukti one can have opulences similar to the Supreme Lord's. Another type enables one to remain always with God as one of His associates, just like Arjuna, who is always with Kåñëa His friend. One can have any of these five forms of liberation, but of the five the säyujya-mukti, merging with the impersonal aspect, is not accepted by Vaiñëava devotees. A Vaiñëava wishes to worship God as He is and retain his separate individuality to serve Him, whereas the Mäyävädé impersonal philosopher wishes to lose his individuality and merge into the existence of the Supreme. This merging is neither recommended by Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä nor by the disciplic succession of Vaiñëava philosophers. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu wrote on this subject in His Çikñäñöakam:

na dhanaà na janaà na sundaréà
kavitäà vä jagadéça kämaye
mama janmani janmanéçvare
bhavatädbhaktir ahaituké tvayi

"O almighty Lord! I have no desire to accumulate wealth, nor have I any desire to enjoy beautiful women, nor do I want any number of followers. What I want only is that I may have Your causeless devotional service in my life—birth after birth." (Çikñäñöakam, 4)

Here Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu refers to "birth after birth." When there is birth after birth, there is no liberation. In liberation either one attains the spiritual planets or merges into the existence of the Supreme—in either case, there is no question of rebirth into the material world. But Caitanya Mahäprabhu doesn't care whether He is liberated or not: His only concern is to be engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, to serve the Supreme Lord. The devotee doesn't care where he is, nor does he care whether he is born in the animal society, human society, demigod society or whatever—he only prays to God that he shall not forget Him and that he will always be able to engage in His transcendental service. These are symptoms of pure devotion. Of course a devotee, wherever he is, remains in the spiritual kingdom, even while in this material body. But he does not demand anything from God for his own personal elevation or comfort.

Although Çré Kåñëa indicates that He can be easily reached by one who is devoted to Him, there is an element of risk involved for the yogés who practice other methods of yoga. For them, He has given directions in Bhagavad-gétä regarding the proper time to leave the gross body.

yatra käle tv anävåttim
ävåttià caiva yoginaù
prayätä yänti taà kälaà
vakñyämi bharatarñabha

"O best of the Bhäratas, I shall now explain to you the different times at which, passing away from this world, one does or does not come back." (Bg. 8.23)

Here Kåñëa indicates that if one is able to leave his body at a particular time, he can become liberated, never to return to the material world. On the other hand, he indicates that if one dies at another time, he has to return. There is this element of chance, but there is no question of chance for a devotee always in Kåñëa consciousness, for he is guaranteed entrance into the abode of Kåñëa by dint of his devotion to the Lord.

agnir jyotir ahaù çuklaù
ñaë-mäsä uttaräyaëam
tatra prayätä gacchanti
brahma brahma-vido janäù

"Those who know the Supreme Brahman pass away from the world during the influence of the fiery god, in the light, at an auspicious moment, during the fortnight of the moon and the six months when the sun travels in the north." (Bg. 8.24)

The sun spends six months on the northern side of the equator and six months on the southern side. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam we have information that as the planets are moving, so also the sun is moving. If one dies when the sun is situated in the northern hemisphere, he attains liberation.

dhümo rätris tathä kåñëaù
ñaë-mäsä dakñiëäyanam
tatra cändramasaà jyotir
yogé präpya nivartate

çukla-kåñëe gaté hy ete
jagataù çäçvate mate
ekayä yäty anävåttim
anyayävartate punaù

"The mystic who passes away from this world during the smoke, the night, the moonless fortnight, or in the six months when the sun passes to the south, or who reaches the moon planet, again comes back. According to the Vedas, there are two ways of passing from this world—one in light and one in darkness. When one passes in light, he does not come back; but when one passes in darkness, he returns." (Bg. 8.25-26)

This is all by chance. We do not know when we are going to die, and we may die accidentally at any time. But for one who is a bhakti-yogé, who is established in Kåñëa consciousness, there is no question of chance. He is always sure.

naite såté pärtha jänan
yogé muhyati kaçcana
tasmät sarveñu käleñu
yoga-yukto bhavärjuna

"The devotees who know these two paths, O Arjuna, are never bewildered. Therefore, be always fixed in devotion." (Bg. 8.27)

It has already been ascertained that at the time of death if one can think of Kåñëa, he is immediately transferred to the abode of Kåñëa.

anta-käle ca mäm eva
smaran muktvä kalevaram
yaù prayäti sa mad-bhävaà
yäti nästy atra saàçayaù

abhyäsa-yoga-yuktena
cetasä nänya-gäminä
paramaà puruñaà divyaà
yäti pärthänucintayan

"And whoever, at the time of death, quits his body remembering Me alone, at once attains My nature. Of this there is no doubt. He who meditates on the Supreme Personality of Godhead, his mind constantly engaged in remembering Me, undeviated from the path, he, O Pärtha [Arjuna], is sure to reach Me." (Bg. 8.5, 8.8)

Such meditation on Kåñëa may seem very difficult, but it is not. If one practices Kåñëa consciousness by chanting the mahä-mantra Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, he will be quickly helped. Kåñëa and His name are nondifferent, and Kåñëa and His transcendental abode are also nondifferent. By sound vibration we can have Kåñëa associate with us. If, for instance, we chant Hare Kåñëa on the street, we will see that Kåñëa is going with us, just as when we look up and see the moon overhead, we perceive that it is also going with us. If Kåñëa's inferior energy may appear to go with us, is it not possible for Kåñëa Himself to be with us when we are chanting His names? He will keep us company, but we have to qualify to be in His company. If, however, we are always merged in the thought of Kåñëa, we should rest assured that Kåñëa is always with us. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu prays:

nämnämakäri bahudhä nija-sarva-çaktis
taträrpitä niyamitaù smaraëe na kälaù
etädåçé tava kåpä bhagavan mamäpi
durdaivamédåça-mihäjani nänurägaù

"Oh my Lord! Your holy name alone can render all benediction upon the living beings, and therefore You have hundreds and millions of names, like Kåñëa and Govinda. In these transcendental names You have invested all Your transcendental energies, and there is no hard and fast rule for chanting these holy names. O my Lord! You have so kindly made approach to You easy by Your holy names, but unfortunate as I am, I have no attraction for them." (Çikñäñöakam, 2)

Merely by chanting we can have all the advantages of personal association with Kåñëa. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who is not only considered to be a realized soul but an incarnation of Kåñëa Himself, has pointed out that in this age of Kali, although men have no real facilities for self-realization, Kåñëa is so kind that He has given this çabda (sound incarnation) to be utilized as the yuga-dharma or way of realization of this age. No special qualification is necessary for this method; we need not even know Sanskrit. The vibrations of Hare Kåñëa are so potent that anyone can immediately begin chanting them without any knowledge of Sanskrit whatsoever.

vedeñu yajïeñu tapaùsu caiva
däneñu yat puëya-phalaà pradiñöam
atyeti tat sarvam idaà viditvä
yogé paraà sthänam upaiti cädyam

"A person who accepts the path of devotional service is not bereft of the results derived from studying the Vedas, performing austere sacrifices, giving charity or pursuing philosophical and fruitive activities. At the end he reaches the supreme abode." (Bg. 8.28)

Here Kåñëa says that the purpose for all Vedic instructions is to achieve the ultimate goal of life—to go back to Godhead. All scriptures from all countries aim at this goal. This has also been the message of all religious reformers or äcäryas. In the West, for example, Lord Jesus Christ spread this same message. Similarly, Lord Buddha and Mohammed. No one advises us to make our permanent settlement here in this material world. There may be small differences according to country, time and circumstance and according to scriptural injunction, but the main principle that we are not meant for this material world but for the spiritual world is accepted by all genuine transcendentalists. All indications for the satisfaction of our soul's innermost desires point to those worlds of Kåñëa beyond birth and death.

END


Complete Edition

with the original Sanskrit text, Roman transliteration, English equivalents,, translation and elaborate purports


BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is pleased to announce the publication by the Macmillan Company of the long awaited Complete Edition of Bhagavad-gétä As It Is. Translated and fully explained by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, this most basic and essential of all spiritual writings is now available in one complete, authoritative and beautifully illustrated 1,000-page volume. In India, the teachings embodied in this sacred text have remained vital for generations; today, the rapid spread of the Kåñëa consciousness movement in the West bears witness to the continued viability and universal appeal of Kåñëa's message. By reading this one book, one can attain the perfection of human life. hardcover $11.95, paperback $7.95

ISKCON is a worldwide community of devotees dedicated to the principles of bhakti-yoga.

Write, call, or visit for further information.

Classes are held in the evenings during the week, and a special feast and festival is held every Sunday afternoon.

The Supreme Lord said: For one who remembers Me without deviation, I am easy to obtain because of his constant engagement in devotional service. From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place. But one who attains to My abode never takes birth again. (Bhagavad-gétä 8.14, 8.16)

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System (1970)

95c (95 cents)


Other Books by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda
The Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam
(3 volumes)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead
(2 volumes)
The Nectar of Devotion
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Back to Godhead Magazine
(Editor)
The Kåñëa Consciousness Movement is the Genuine Vedic Way
Çré Éçopaniñad
The First Step in God Realization

The Lord in the Heart
Pure Devotional Service: The Change in Heart
The Process of Creation
The Cause of All Causes


KÅÑËA CONSCIOUSNESS
The Topmost Yoga System
His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
Prabhupäda
Founder-Äcärya of the
International Society for Krishna Consciousness
38 North Beacon Street
Boston, Massachusetts 02134


Copyright © 1970 ISKCON PRESS
Library of Congress Catalogue Card Number: 77-127182
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Printed in the United States of America by ISKCON PRESS


Contents


1 Yoga and the Master of Yoga
2 The Goal of Yoga
3 Our Real Life
4 The Hare Kåñëa Mantra
5 How Bhakti-yoga Works
6 Sources of Absolute Knowledge
Glossary
The Author

TYS 1: Yoga and the Master of Yoga

1/ Yoga and the Master of Yoga

[680326BG.SF]

Yoga means the connecting link between the soul and the Supersoul, or the Supreme and the minute living creatures. Lord Çré Kåñëa is that Supreme, the Personality of Godhead. Being, therefore, the ultimate object of yoga, Kåñëa's name is yogeçvara, the master of yoga.

At the conclusion of the Bhagavad-gétä [18.78], it is said: "Where there is Kåñëa, and where there is Arjuna, the greatest of bowmen, there, undoubtedly, is victory."

The Bhagavad-gétä is a narrative spoken by Saïjaya, the secretary of Mahäräja Dhåtaräñöra. This is just like airwaves from the radio: the play is going on in the auditorium, but you can hear from your room. So, just as we now have such a mechanical arrangement, at that time there were also certain arrangements, although there was no machine. Anyway, the secretary of Dhåtaräñöra could see what was going on in the battlefield, and he was in the palace, telling this to Mahäräja Dhåtaräñöra, who was blind. Now, the conclusion made by Saïjaya was that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

When the yoga performance is described, it is said that Kåñëa's name is yogeçvara. No one can be a better yogin than the master of yoga, and Kåñëa is the master. There are many different types of yoga. Yoga means the system, and yogin means the person who practices that system. The object of yoga, the ultimate goal, is to understand Kåñëa. Therefore, Kåñëa consciousness means to practice the topmost type of yoga.

This topmost yoga system was described by Kåñëa in the Gétä to His most intimate friend, Arjuna. In the beginning, the Lord said that this system can be practiced only by a person who has developed attachment for it. This Kåñëa conscious yoga system cannot be practiced by an ordinary man who has no attachment for Kåñëa, for it is a different system, and the topmost—bhakti-yoga.

There are five types of direct attachment, and there are seven types of indirect attachment. Indirect attachment is not bhakti. Direct attachment is called bhakti. If you are attached to Kåñëa by the direct method, it is called devotional service, and if you are attached to Kåñëa by an indirect method, it is not devotional service. But that is also attachment. King Kaàsa, for example, was the maternal uncle of Kåñëa; and there was a warning that Kaàsa would be killed by one of his sister's sons. So he became very anxious about the sons of his sister, and he decided to kill his sister. Devaké, Kåñëa's mother, was saved by her husband, Vasudeva, who made a compromise and proposed to his brother-in-law as follows: "You are afraid of the son of your sister. So your sister herself is not going to kill you." He requested, "Don't kill your sister. Save her, and I promise that all the sons born of her will be brought to you, and if you like you can kill them."

Vasudeva did this in order that his poor wife might be saved. And Vasudeva thought, "When Devaké's son is born, Kaàsa may have a change of heart." But Kaàsa was such a great demon that he killed all the sons of Devaké. It was told that the eighth son of the sister would kill him. So, when Kåñëa was in the womb of His mother, Kaàsa was always thinking of Kåñëa. You may say that he was not Kåñëa conscious, but actually he was. Not directly, not for love's sake; but as an enemy. He was Kåñëa conscious as an enemy. So, that is not devotional service. One in devotional service is Kåñëa conscious as Kåñëa's friend, Kåñëa's servant, His parent, or His lover.

You may want Kåñëa as your lover, as your son; you may want Kåñëa as your friend, you may want Kåñëa as your master, you may want Kåñëa as the Supreme Sublime. These five different kinds of direct relationship with Kåñëa are called devotion, or bhakti. They entail no material profit.

The concept of accepting God as a son is superior to the concept of accepting God as a father. There is a distinction. The relationship between father and son is that the son wants to take something from the father. The father's relationship with the son is that the father always wants to give something to the son. Therefore, the relationship with God or Kåñëa as son is better than the relationship with Kåñëa by one who thinks, "If I accept God as my father, then my business will be to ask for my necessities from the father." But, if I become the father of Kåñëa, then from the beginning of His childhood, my business will be to serve Him. The father is the parent of the child from the very beginning of his birth; therefore the concept of this relationship of Vasudeva and Devaké is sublime.

Kåñëa's foster mother, Yaçodä, is thinking, "If I do not feed Kåñëa sumptuously, He will die." She forgets that Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord, that He is sustaining the three worlds. She forgets that only one Lord is supplying the necessities of all the living entities. This same Personality of Godhead has become the son of Yaçodä, and she is thinking, "If I do not feed Him nicely, He will die." This is love. She has forgotten that it is the Supreme Personality of Godhead who has appeared before her as a little child.

This relationship of attachment is very sublime. It requires time to understand, but there is a position where, instead of asking, "O God, please give us our daily bread," you can instead think that God will die if you do not supply bread to Him. This is the ecstasy of extreme love. There is such a relationship between Kåñëa and His devotee Rädhäräëé, the greatest devotee, the greatest lover of Kåñëa. Mother Yaçodä is His lover as a parent; Sudämä is His lover as a friend; Arjuna also as a friend—there are millions and billions of different kinds of direct devotees of Kåñëa.

So the yoga systems as described here lead to bhakti-yoga, and bhakti-yoga can be practiced by persons who have developed attachment to Kåñëa. Others cannot practice it. And, if anyone is able to develop that attachment, the relationship will be that he will understand God, Kåñëa, perfectly. However we may try to understand God by our different theories or speculations, it is still a difficult job. We may say that we have understood God, but it is not possible to understand Him as He is, because we have limited senses, and He is unlimited.

It is said in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam that our senses are imperfect, all of them. We cannot understand even the material world perfectly. You have seen so many planets and stars in the sky at night, but you do not know what they are. You do not even know what the moon planet is, though men have been trying for so many years to go there in sputniks. Even this one planet, Earth! We do not know what varieties there are even on this planet! If you go to the sea, to the sky, your perception is limited. Our knowledge is, therefore, always imperfect. On that we must agree. If we foolishly think that we have acquired all forms of knowledge and we have advanced in science, this is another foolishness. It is not possible.

And, when it is not possible to understand even the material things which we daily see with our eyes, what can we say of the spiritual world and Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead? He is the supreme spiritual form, and it is not possible to understand Him by our limited senses. Then why are we bothering so much for Kåñëa consciousness, if it is not possible? If these imperfect senses cannot realize Kåñëa as He is? The answer is that if you become submissive, if you develop the spiritual attitude of following Kåñëa, and you are as a servant or a friend, as a parent or as a lover—if you begin to give service to the Supreme Lord then you can begin to know Him.

Your service begins with the tongue. How? By the tongue you can chant Hare Kåñëa, and by the tongue you can taste Kåñëa prasädam, spiritual food. So, the beginning of the process is very nice. You can chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare—and whenever prasädam is offered to you by Kåñëa, by His kindness, you accept it. The result will be that if you become submissive, and if you begin this service—chanting and eating prasädam, Kåñëa will reveal Himself before you.

You can't understand Kåñëa by speculation; that is not possible, because your senses are imperfect. But if you begin this process of service, then it will be possible—one day Kåñëa will reveal Himself to you: "I am like this." Just as Kåñëa is revealing to Arjuna. Arjuna is a devotee, and he is submissive, and he is in contact with Kåñëa as a friend. Therefore Kåñëa is revealing to him.

The Bhagavad-gétä was spoken to Arjuna, not to any Vedäntist philosophical speculator. In the beginning of the Fourth Chapter, you will note that Kåñëa says, "I am speaking to you that ancient system of yoga." It is stated, "Unto you." Arjuna was a kñatriya, a fighter. He was a householder, not even a sannyäsé, not a renouncer—but these are not qualifications to understand Kåñëa. Suppose I say I have become a sannyäsé mendicant—this is not a qualification, that I can now understand Kåñëa. Then what is the qualification? This: "One who has developed the service spirit, with love and devotion, can understand Me." No other. Not the big scholars and mental speculators; but a child can understand Kåñëa, if he has full faith in Him. So faith and devotion qualify one.

Simply by such faith and service you will understand that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Just as we are preaching Kåñëa consciousness; we are not wasting your time or our time, because we are in full faith that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Theoretically or practically, you should accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Person. Theoretically, there is the revealed scripture. You will understand from the Vedic literature, from the great devotees in the past and in the present.

For the present, there is Lord Caitanya. Lord Caitanya is the great authority. None is greater. He was mad after Kåñëa. And then, after Him, His six disciples, the gosvämés, have left us an immensely valuable literature—especially Jéva Gosvämé. They have written volumes on Kåñëa. So, under disciplic succession, we have come to this point; and if you like past history, then go back a long, long time to Vyäsadeva. He is known to have written the Çrémad-Bhägavatam and other literature on Kåñëa. Çrémad-Bhägavatam is nothing but a description of Kåñëa. Vyäsa is also the writer of the Bhagavad-gétä. The Gétä was spoken by Kåñëa and noted down by Vyäsa, who put this Gétä into the Mahäbhärata.

So Vyäsadeva accepts Kåñëa as the Supreme Person. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam he has given the description of the different incarnations; there are twenty-five of Them. And, in the conclusion, he says that the descriptions that are given of different incarnations are all parts of the representations of God. But Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself. He is not part, but one hundred percent—one hundred percent God. So there is the evidence of authority.

And, practically, if we believe the çästras, the scriptures, then we can see: Who can be more powerful than Kåñëa? Who can be more beautiful than Kåñëa? Who can be more famous than Kåñëa? Kåñëa appeared five thousand years ago, but His knowledge, which He gave in the form of the Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä, is still worshiped. It is worshiped not only by the Hindus or the Indians, but is read all over the world. In your country there are at least fifty different editions of the Bhagavad-gétä, written by different men. Similarly, in England, in Germany, in France and in all other countries, you will find hundreds of editions of the Gétä. So, who can be more famous? There are many other evidences, if you believe in çästra: Kåñëa married 16,108 wives, and He provided each one of them with a big palace, and each one of them had 10 children, and from the 10 children there were many other children born. So we have the evidence of revealed Scriptures; and in the Brahma-saàhitä also, Kåñëa is accepted as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is a very old book, supposed to have been written by Brahmä, the first living being in the universe.

In that Brahma-saàhitä, it is said, éçvaraù paramaù Kåñëaù. Éçvara means God. There are many gods. It is said that there are so many demigods, and there is the Supreme God. So Brahma-saàhitä says, éçvaraù paramaù Kåñëaù—He is the God of gods. Éçvaraù paramaù Kåñëaù, and then: sac-cid-änanda-vigraha—and His body is eternal, and full of bliss and knowledge. And next: anädiù—He has no beginning, but He is the beginning of everyone. Anädir ädir govindaù. Go means senses, go means cow, and go means land. So He is the proprietor of all land, He is the proprietor of all cows, and He is the creator of all senses.

We are after sense pleasure, but our perfection of sense pleasure can be achieved only when we reciprocate our pleasure with Kåñëa. Therefore, His name is Govinda, the Supreme Original Personality of Godhead.

The same Personality of Godhead personally spoke about Himself to Arjuna in the Gétä. How can you say that somebody, by his thinking, by speculation, can say something about God that is more important than what is being said by Kåñëa Himself? It is not possible. No one can speak better than Kåñëa about God, because God Himself is speaking. If you speak about yourself personally, who can say more than you? So, if you have faith, if you believe theoretically or practically in Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, then, by the speeches that are delivered by Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä, you can understand God. There is no difficulty.

And, if you believe Kåñëa, then the result will be that you can understand God—how He is working, how His energies are acting, how He is manifesting, what is this material world, what is the spiritual world, what are the living creatures, what is their relationship—so many things are to be found in God's literature.

The whole Vedic literature deals with three things: the first is your relationship with God; then, next, after you understand your relationship with God, you can act in that way. Just as a man or woman may not be related, but as soon as the relationship is established that one is husband and the other is wife, then the dealings begin.

Once they understand their relationship with God, people generally believe that God is the father, and the son's business is to ask Father for whatever he needs. But that is really a lesser relationship. If you understand God perfectly, then there are intimate relationships also. Your intimate relationship will be revealed when you are perfectly liberated. Each and every living creature has a particular relationship with God, but we have, for now, forgotten. When that relationship is revealed in the process of devotional activities, or Kåñëa consciousness, you will know that that is the perfection of your life. Kåñëa consciousness is a great science; it is not a sentimental speculation regarding love. It is based on scientific propositions described in the Bhagavad-gétä, in the Vedas, and in the Brahma-saàhitä; and it is accepted by authorities like Lord Caitanya, Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Närada, Asita, Vyäsa—there are so many authorities. Kåñëa consciousness is not an ordinary lovemaking or moneymaking business; it is reality, and if you stick to it seriously, your life will be perfect.

TYS 2: The Goal of Yoga

2/ The Goal of Yoga

[A STUDY IN MYSTICISM, BTG: no. 25, September 1969]

In the Bhagavad-gétä, the Sanskrit word mäm is frequently used. This word means "unto me." Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead says, "unto Me"—Kåñëa. We cannot interpret this in a different way. When I say, "Bring me a glass of water," it means that I am the person in want of the glass of water, and if you supply to me and not to others, then it is right. When Kåñëa says, "unto Me," that means Kåñëa. But philosophers are still interpreting—they say "unto something else." Even grammatically this is wrong.

One who has developed attachment to Kåñëa is Kåñëa conscious. They say if you have attachment for your lover you always think of her. That is lover consciousness. It is natural. It is stated that a woman who has another lover besides her husband shows herself very attentive to her household duties, but is always thinking, "When shall my lover and I meet in the night?" This is an example: It is possible, in spite of our false engagement, if we love somebody, to think of him always. If materially it is possible, why not spiritually? That is the whole teaching of the Bhagavad-gétä.

In the Gétä, Kåñëa says to Arjuna, "As a fighter, you have to fight. You cannot step away from the fighting. It is your duty." Nowadays I have practical experience that the draft board of your country is calling for boys to join the army, but they are not willing. They are not willing because they are not trained as kñatriyas, warriors. They are trained as çüdras, laborers. Therefore the caste system is very scientific. A section of people should be trained as brähmaëas, men of knowledge. Those who are intelligent enough in the society should be picked and trained in higher philosophical science. And those who are less intelligent than the brähmaëas should be given military training. We require everything in society—not only military men. How can everyone be a military man? Because they are sending çüdras, ordinary workers, to Vietnam, these are unnecessarily being killed. Any country which is very proud of scientific advancement, and yet does not know how to organize its society, is a fool's society.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [4.13] Kåñëa says that there are four divisions of society, brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya and çüdra. That is natural. Some are inclined toward spiritual advancement, and these are the brähmaëas. Now we are training boys who are spiritually inclined, and they are unnecessarily being forced into military service. The foolish have no knowledge that some boy is being trained up in higher science. Why should he be destroyed when he is being perfected? The intellectual persons, those boys who have brahminical qualifications, are being restrained in brahmacarya student life: they don't take to meat-eating, they don't take part in intoxication, they don't take part in gambling, they don't take part in illicit sex. They are being trained as complete brähmaëas, the highest intellectuals, the most purified persons in society. If there is one brähmaëa in a whole family, then the whole family—the whole society—becomes sanctified. But today they have no knowledge of how to train a brähmaëa, or how to train a kñatriya. In the other fields of action, in the work of çüdras and vaiçyas there is nice training. If anyone wants to be a businessman, there are colleges or technological schools. That's very nice. But why should everyone be dragged into technology? Just as in your body: for proper maintenance we require the head, the arms, the belly and the legs. All these parts of the body are required. You cannot say, "We do not require the head." That is nonsense—we require everything. Suppose there is a body without a head—it is a dead body. If the body is now intact, but there is no head, it is called a dead body. The head is considered to be the intellectual part of the body. Similarly, if there is no brähmaëa in the society, it is a dead body. If there is no spiritual man in the society, it is a dead society.

Therefore Kåñëa says, "I have created the four divisions of society, according to quality and work." If someone is working as a brahmacäré-brähmaëa and has acquired the quality of understanding Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, then why should he be called for army action? The arm of the body is the kñatriya. Of course that is required; to protect the country, to protect the society, a military arrangement should be there. No one will disapprove. But not the brähmaëas. It is putting a race horse before the work cart. A race horse is required for different purposes. The other beasts of burden—asses, mules, and oxen—are required for pulling carts.

I say this frankly—everyone may read it—that any society where there are no spiritual persons or Kåñëa consciousness is a rascal society, because it has no head. Where there is a headless man, there is a dead body. And if there is no brain, there is no head; if the brain is not working properly then he is a madman; if he has no head at all, then he is a dead man.

Do you think that in a dead society or a mad society there can be any peace? No. If the society is full of madmen, then where is the question of peace? Therefore Kåñëa consciousness is the most important study in present-day society. The men who are leading the society, the President and the Secretary of Defense should have the intelligence to understand this science of the soul.

The other day when coming to your country I met a secretary of the Japanese government in Tokyo. I wanted to explain to him that he should cooperate with this movement, but he said, "Oh, we cannot cooperate with any religious movement." He is one of the chief secretaries of the government, and he is such a fool. He is taking this movement as a religious movement, just as we have so many sentimental religions. But this is not sentimental. This is the necessity of society: a class of men should be Kåñëa conscious. Otherwise the society is doomed; it is going to hell. And, when such rascals are at the head of the government, how can there be peace? How can you expect peace in a dog's society? The dogs are by nature howling—"Woof! Woof! Woof!"—as soon as they see other dogs. So do you mean to say there will be peace if you turn human society into dog society, into cat society, into tiger society? The tiger is very powerful; he can kill many other animals. But does that mean he is a very important animal? No, he has no use in society. And now we are very powerful, and we have good weapons to fight with, and we can kill many people. But these are no qualifications for good men or a good society.

We are not meant to manufacture a society of monkeys or tigers or asses—or rascals who work very hard. Do you mean to say a society of asses will derive any benefit from life? No.

For those who have developed an attraction to Kåñëa, attachment can be developed. Before my coming to the West, there was no movement like this Kåñëa consciousness, but now it is developing. Kåñëa was not born in your country; you do not accept Kåñëa as your religious God. But Kåñëa is so attractive that although you are a foreigner, you are not foreign. To Kåñëa you are not a foreigner. He claims everybody. We make Him foreign, but this is our foolishness.

In the Gétä [14.4] Kåñëa says, "My dear Arjuna, there are many different forms and different species of life undoubtedly. But I am their father." Just see how Kåñëa is universal. He is claiming not only human society, but animal society, bird society, beast society—everyone. He says, "I am the father." So how can Kåñëa be foreign? It is a mental concoction. They say Kåñëa is Indian or Kåñëa is worshiped by the Hindus and therefore He is one of the Hindu Gods; and they think that Kåñëa is saying, "Yes, I am the Hindu God. Yes, I am Indian." But He is like the sun. Why American sun or Indian? Nothing is American or Indian; that is all artificial.

"This planet belongs to the humans, that's all." This is your communism. This present communism is defective because the Russians say that Russia is for the Russians or China is for the Chinese. Why not for others? Just think in terms of human communism! Why human communism? Living being communism! If you take this world as belonging to human society, that is defective. It belongs to everyone! It belongs to the tree community; it belongs to the beast community. They also have a right to live. Why should you cut the trees? Why should you send the bulls to the slaughterhouse? This is injustice. How can you gain justice by yourself doing injustice? We have no Kåñëa consciousness. We do not know that Kåñëa is our original father and that we are all His sons. The tree is my brother, the ant is my brother, the bull is my brother. The American is my brother, the Indian is my brother, the Chinese is my brother. Therefore, we have to develop Kåñëa consciousness. We talk all this nonsense of universal brotherhood and United Nations—all nonsense. Either you acknowledge the Father, or else you have no idea of how to realize brotherhood or humanity. Therefore, they are talking for years and years. They are the same fools. Can't you see the U.N.? They have headquarters in New York. They are simply talking nonsense, that's all. That is their business. So unless there is full Kåñëa consciousness, there cannot be any improvement of the world condition.

Kåñëa says that you have to develop your attachment for Him. Begin at the beginning, but you can do it; it is not artificial. I have a few sincere students here, just developing; they are not complete, but they are developing Kåñëa—attachment. Otherwise, why should they waste their time chanting Hare Kåñëa? They are doing it, and it can be done. You can develop love for anything if you try for it. But Kåñëa development is very natural. Because Kåñëa is not a thing belonging to a particular type of religion or sect. Kåñëa claims, "I belong to everyone." Therefore, originally, we are all connected with Kåñëa; but we have simply forgotten. This process of chanting is to evoke your remembrance of Kåñëa. It is not that we are inducting something artificially into you. No, Kåñëa is already connected with you, but you have forgotten. And we are trying to give you the process for reviving your original consciousness. So you can come to our temple; that is the beginning. You can see Kåñëa or Kåñëa's devotees, and you can chant Hare Kåñëa.

Kåñëa is not different from His name because He is absolute. He is nondifferent from His words. The name Kåñëa and the person Kåñëa are not different. Because everything is Kåñëa.

Oneness, the philosophy of monism or pantheism, is imperfect. When that oneness comes in understanding Kåñëa, that is perfection. If Kåñëa is the Supreme Absolute Truth from whom everything is emanating, then everything is Kåñëa. Just as you have a gold mine and are preparing so many golden utensils and ornaments and many other things. But they are all gold because the original is gold. So you may name it "earring," but you have to add "gold"—golden earring. You may name it "necklace," but it is gold, because originally it came from the gold-mine. Similarly, originally, everything is coming from Kåñëa.

If He is Supreme, the Absolute Truth, then nothing is different from Him. Just as, whether you say earring or necklace or bangle or wristwatch, these are all made of gold, and so they are gold. But, at the same time, you cannot say that this is all gold—you must say, "This is a gold necklace. This is a gold earring." The mäyävädén, or impersonalist, will say that everything is Brahman. But "everything is Brahman" is not right.

This is very nicely explained in the Gétä, in the Thirteenth Chapter: "I am expanded all over. That is My impersonal feature." Kåñëa is everywhere in His impersonal feature, but still He is a person. The mäyäväda philosopher thinks that if Kåñëa has become everything, then where is the possibility of Kåñëa here, apart? This is complete rascaldom because it is thinking in a material way. There is no spiritual knowledge.

In the material way, suppose you take a piece of paper and tear it into particles and throw it all over. The original paper has no existence. This is material. But we get information from the Vedas that the Absolute Truth is so perfect that if you take away the whole, still the whole remains. One minus one equals one. The material way of thinking is one minus one equals zero; but spiritually it is not like that. Spiritually, one minus one equals one, and one plus one equals one also.

Kåñëa is everything. The mäyävädéns, the impersonalists, see our Deities here and say, "Oh, they have installed some wooden forms, and they are worshiping them as God." But one who knows Kåñëa science understands that Kåñëa is everything and therefore can appear in everything. With electricity, the current is everywhere along the line, so wherever you touch you will feel it. Similarly, the Kåñëa current in His impersonal form is everywhere, and it is the technician who knows how to use the force. Before we have a phone installed, we have a telephone conversation, and we simply inform the person, before we even talk money, that he should come immediately to find out where the connection can be made. And he comes out and does his work; and we do not notice, because he knows the technique. So, one must know how to connect with Kåñëa. Kåñëa is everywhere—this is Kåñëa consciousness. But one must know how he can derive Kåñëa from the features of Kåñëa's form in wood or iron or metal.

You have to learn how to contact Kåñëa everywhere in everything. That is explained in the system of yoga. Kåñëa consciousness is also yoga, the perfect yoga, the highest of all yogic systems. A yogin may come, and we can challenge him, saying that this is the topmost yoga system, though at the same time it is very simple. You don't have to exercise your body over a period of weeks before you feel some power. But in Kåñëa consciousness you won't feel tired. All of our students are simply anxious to be overloaded with work in Kåñëa consciousness. "Prabhupäda, what can I do?" And they are actually doing it. In the material world, if you work for some time you'll feel weak.

Of course, I am not exercising myself. I am an old man of seventy-two years. I was ill, I went back to India; but I want to work. Actually, I could retire from all these activities, but as far as I can, I want to work; I want to learn day and night. At night I will work with the dictaphone, and I am sorry if I cannot work. This is Kåñëa consciousness. One must be very anxious to work. It is not an idle society. No, we have sufficient engagements: editing papers, selling papers.

Simply find out how Kåñëa conscious you can be. If you want to be really at peace, if you want to be happy, then develop Kåñëa consciousness. And the beginning is to develop attachment for Kåñëa. The process which we have prescribed is chanting and dancing before the Deities, and offering prasädam, spiritual food. This will make you more Kåñëa conscious.

The yoga system as it is described in the Bhagavad-gétä is different from the bogus yoga system which is going on in the West these days. The yoga systems which have been introduced into the West by so-called yogés are not bona fide. Yoga is difficult: the first thing is to control the senses. That is the position of the yogé: he is not allowed to indulge in sex life. If you indulge in intoxication, if you indulge in meat-eating, and if you indulge in gambling and sporting—all nonsense—you cannot at the same time become a yogé. I was astonished when a yogé came here, having advertised in India that you can be a yogé even though you may be addicted to drinking. This is not the yoga system. This is not standard. You can call it yoga, but it is not the standard yoga system.

The yoga system is especially difficult for this age. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam we understand that yoga means to concentrate one's attention on the Superself, Viñëu. He is situated in your heart. And, in order to concentrate your attention, you have to control the senses. The senses are working just like infuriated horses. If you cannot control the horses of your carriage, it will be dangerous. Just imagine that you are seated in a carriage and your horses are so furious that they are dragging you to hell. Then what is your position? The yoga system means to control these senses. The senses are also compared to serpents: The serpent does not know who is its friend and who is its enemy. It bites anyone. And, as soon as the serpent bites, the result is death. Similarly, if the uncontrolled senses work in their own way, then you should know that you are in a dangerous position.

It has been said that when one becomes too sensual, he loses his temper, he loses his identity, he forgets himself. Infuriated by the senses, a man will attack even his children, even his daughter. Therefore, for those who are advancing in spiritual life—not only for them but for everyone—the çästras, scriptures, say that you should not sit in a secluded place even with your mother, even with your daughter or your sister. Why? Because the senses are so strong that if they become infuriated, you will forget whether she's mother, sister, or daughter.

You may say that this may be true only for some foolish persons, but çästra says no—you should not sit in a secluded place even with your mother, sister or daughter, because the senses are so strong that even though you may be very moral, you may still be attracted by sex.

Our position in this world, our suffering in this world, is due to the body. This body is the cause of all miseries, and the ultimate goal of life should be to get out of this material body and be situated in the spiritual body. This is a foreign atmosphere. The soul is free spiritually, but it has been conditioned by this material atmosphere. And the body is of this matter.

A human being is fit to inquire as to whether he is this body or something else. This can be understood very easily. I am not this body, because at the time of death the body remains—although everyone cries, "Oh, the poor man is gone!" The man is lying there. Why do you say he is gone? He is lying there! At that time, we can come to our senses: the body is not the man. The real man is gone. The childhood body is changed to the youthful body, and the childhood body is gone. Similarly, when the boyhood body is gone, you'll have to accept a body like mine, an old man's body. The body is changing. Not only year after year, but at every second the body is changing. Still, you are situated there. This is very simple to understand. And because the body is there, we are suffering. Everyone is trying to get out of suffering, in any field of action; in the economic field, in the political field, or any field of activity, social or national, everyone is trying to get out of misery. There is no other activity. Either nationally or socially, individually or collectively, we are all suffering; and this suffering is due to the body.

Yoga means to inquire. What am I? If I am not this body, then what am I? I am pure soul. Now, if my bodily activities or sensual activities are incorrect, I will not be able to understand myself—what I am—and the Bhagavad-gétä says that we are all grand fools. Why fools? Since we have this body, we are fools. If somebody invites you to come to his apartment but you know it is full of danger, do you think you would like to go there? "Oh no," you will say, "I am not going there. If it is full of danger, why shall I go?" Similarly, don't you think that the body is full of danger? Then, why are you going there, taking repeated birth? When you are flying in a plane, you are always fearful that there may be a crash. And what is this crashing? It is due to the body. The soul cannot be affected by crashes. But you are always afraid.

The soul is ever-existing, and the body will not exist. And because you are existing and the soul has accepted the nonexisting body, therefore you suffer.

The problem, then, is how to get out, just as you try to get out of a fever. The fevered condition is not your permanent life. Permanent life is enjoyment, but due to the fever you cannot enjoy life. When you are sick you cannot go out; you have to rest and take so many medicines and formulas. But we don't want that—"Why should I be a sick person?" But you are diseased. Similarly, we should always know that this bodily conditional stage of the pure soul is a diseased condition. And anyone who does not know that he is suffering from disease is a fool. He is Fool Number One.

The çästra says, everyone is born a fool: because he has this body, therefore he was born a fool. No being, either American or Indian, cat or dog, is free from this. You have come to disease, that's all. If you feel, "I am an American," that is a kind of disease; if you feel, "I am an Indian," that is also a disease; if you feel, "I am a cat," that is a disease. You are not a cat, you are not a dog, you are not Indian, you are not fair, you are not black. You are your soul—that is your identity! And one who does not understand this truth, that "I am pure soul," is defeated in all his activities.

Lord Jesus Christ taught like that: If you lose your soul and gain the whole world, what do you gain? People do not know what they are, and yet they work just like madmen. Just see, all these people are working, and they are madmen. They are not Americans or Indians, Germans or Japanese. They are nothing of the kind. They have been given a chance to come to this naughty place, this Earth; and so, being born in a particular place, they have a particular kind of body—and they are mad after it.

The Bhagavad-gétä says that just as our outer garments are changed, so this body is changed. Yoga means the process of getting out of this material embodiment. Just as you are repeating changes of dress, so you are repeating birth and death, and this is the cause of your miseries. If you do not understand this, then all your activities end in defeat.

Yoga means to get out of this embodiment, and it means to know oneself. This body is born of the parents. Similarly, as pure soul, you are also the source of its birth. We do not mean birth beginning historically from a certain day and ending on a certain day. No; the soul is not like that—it has no beginning, and it has no end. But in the Bhagavad-gétä it is said that the soul is part and parcel of God. God is eternal, God is full of joy and bliss. The position of the Absolute Person, the Godhead, is that He is full of bliss, eternal, and full of knowledge. And, because we are also part and parcel of the Supreme, we have partial blissfulness and eternality, and we are full of knowledge, according to our infinitesimal size.

The human beings are understood to be the most intelligent of all living creatures, but they are misusing their intelligence. How? They are misusing their intelligence by devoting it to the animal propensities. These animal propensities are eating, sleeping, mating and fearing. You can analyze the trend of modern civilization: everyone is busy with these four principles of animal life. They are sleeping and creating some cushions for comfortable sleep. They are creating palatable dishes for the eating propensity. They are exciting sex very nicely, for the mating necessity. And they are defending their country with so many atom bombs—that is the fear propensity.

But these symptoms you will find among the animals. They are also sleeping according to their own ways, and they are defending. They may not have the atom bomb, but they have some way of defending. You can kill your enemy, or he can kill you, but there is actually no defense. You cannot defend yourself; wherever you drop the bomb, it will hurt you, due to nuclear radiation. So this is not the solution of your problems. The solution of your problems is to get out of the conditioned state of life. That is called yoga—to link yourself to the Supreme.

There is a Supreme. This material creation is so nice—don't you think there is a friend behind it? The sky is so beautiful, the foodstuff is being produced, the moon is rising in due course, the sun is rising in due course, supplying heat for your health, supplying heat to the planetary systems. Everything is arranged very nicely; and yet the fools say there is no brain behind it, but it is all happening automatically.

The fact is that there is God, Kåñëa, and we are all parts and parcels of Kåñëa. We have been conditioned in some way or other in this material atmosphere. But now we have this human form of life, and so we have to get out of the entanglement. But getting out is not possible. You cannot get out of the entanglement of the material body unless you develop your Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa consciousness is not artificial—don't think that. This international society of ours is not another political tool. This is the greatest necessity of the human being. Kåñëa consciousness, God consciousness, is there within you. Don't you find, when there is a kértana performance, that the more innocent a person is, the sooner he begins? Immediately, the child begins to clap, begins to dance. This is within them; and it is very simple, this Kåñëa consciousness.

So, unless you develop Kåñëa consciousness, there is no rescue from the entanglement of conditioned life. This you have to understand. This is not some sentiment. No, it is a great science. You have to understand it nicely. Then the human form of life will be successful, and otherwise it is defeated. You may become a very great nation, but that is not the solution to the problem of life.

By the grace of Kåñëa, I am able to serve you with my life's energy. I left the United States in 1967 in poor health; but life and death—everything—depends on Kåñëa. I thought, "Let me go back to Våndävana, because Våndävana is a sanctified place where Kåñëa consciousness is very strong." I thought that I might go there and die in Kåñëa consciousness. Of course, if you are always in the atmosphere of Kåñëa consciousness, then here also you can have Våndävana. Våndävana is not a particular place that is called Våndävana. Kåñëa says, "It is not that I live in the Kingdom of God, Vaikuëöha; nor is it that I live in the heart of the yogin." The yogin wants to find out where Kåñëa is within the heart. But Kåñëa says, "I am not in the abode in the spiritual sky, nor am I in the heart of the yogin." Then where are You? Kåñëa says, "I stay where My pure devotees are chanting My glories." That is Våndävana.

So, if that is Våndävana, then I am there. There is no difference. Wherever there is electric light, there is electricity. It is naturally understood. Similarly, wherever there is Kåñëa consciousness, it is Våndävana. We can create Våndävana by the mercy of Kåñëa, if we chant Hare Kåñëa. Perfect this Kåñëa consciousness; try to understand the philosophy behind it. It is a science, not a bluff. We can speak from any angle of vision.

Kåñëa consciousness is the great necessity of human society. Learn it and appreciate it, comprehend it and assimilate it—and teach it. It is very simple. If you offenselessly chant Hare Kåñëa, everything will be revealed from within because Kåñëa is sitting within you. If you are strong and have faith and conviction in Kåñëa, as well as in the spiritual master, the transparent via medium to Kåñëa, then Kåñëa is there. The Vedas say that if you have implicit faith in God and implicit faith in your bona fide guru, who teaches you Kåñëa consciousness, then the result will be that all the Vedic scriptures will be revealed authoritatively.

The process is spiritual; it does not require any material qualifications. The speculators who are not realized souls are covered in delusion and are simply wasting their time. Whatever they may do in their official class, they remain the same foolish rascals. But our Kåñëa conscious students will feel a change in their lives, a change in happiness, and a change in youth, also. This is reality.

I shall request you, my dear young girls and boys, to take Kåñëa consciousness very seriously, and you will be happy—your life will be perfected. It will be the sublime addition to your life. It is not a bluff. We have not come here to collect some money. Money is supplied by Kåñëa. I am going back and forth to India—not only I, but my students as well. For a rich man there would be many expenditures; it would cost ten thousand dollars for such trips. But our business is Kåñëa, and He will supply. I do not know where the money comes from, but Kåñëa supplies. In Kåñëa consciousness, you will be happy. You are the young generation; you are the flower of your country and society. Practice this most sublime system, Kåñëa consciousness. Be happy and make others happy. This is the real mission of life.

TYS 3: Our Real Life

3/Our Real Life

[A STUDY IN MYSTICISM, BTG: no. 25, September 1969]

The Bhagavad-gétä [7.3] says that out of many thousands of human beings, one may try to make perfection of his life. Man is an animal, but he has one special prerogative, rational thought. What is that rational thought? Reasoning power, argument. Now, reasoning power is there in dogs and cats as well. Suppose a dog comes up to you; if you say, "Hut!" he'll understand. The dog will understand that you don't want him. So, he has some reasoning power. But what is the special reasoning power of the human being?

As far as the bodily necessities are concerned, the reasoning power is there even in the animal. If a cat wants to steal some milk from your kitchen, she has very nice reasoning power: she is always looking to see when the master is out and she can take. So, for the four propensities of animal life—eating, sleeping, mating and defending—there is reasoning power even in the beasts. Then, what is the special reasoning power of the human being, by which he is called the rational animal?

The special reasoning power is to inquire, "Why am I suffering?" This is special reasoning. The animals are suffering, but they do not know how to remedy the suffering. But human beings are making scientific advancement and philosophical advancement, cultural advancement, religious advancement—progress in so many lines—because they want to be happy. "Where is the point of happiness?" This reasoning power is especially given to the human being. Therefore, in the Gétä, Kåñëa says, "Out of so many men, one may know Me."

Generally, the people are just like animals. They simply do not know anything beyond the necessities of the body: how to eat, how to sleep, how to mate and how to defend. And the Bhagavad-gétä says, out of many thousands, someone may develop this reasoning power: "Why am I suffering?" He asks this question: "Why am I suffering?" We do not want to suffer, but suffering is forced upon us. We do not want too much cold, but too much cold and too much heat are forced upon us.

When there is some impetus to awaken this reasoning power, it is called brahma-jijïäsä. This is found in the Vedänta-sütra. The first verse says that now, this human form of life is meant for asking the question of how to solve the problem of suffering.

So Kåñëa says that this special prerogative of the human being is not awakened very easily, except by some good association. Just as we have this Kåñëa conscious association. If we attain such association, where nice things are discussed, then that awakening of reason, that special prerogative of the human being, will come. As long as this question does not arise in one's mind, he should understand that whatever activities he is doing will lead to his defeat. He is simply leading an animal life. But, not when these questions arise: Why am I suffering? What am I? Am I meant for suffering? Am I meant for troubles?

I am undergoing troubles by nature's laws, and by the state's laws. So the question of freedom is how to become free from all these troubles. The Vedänta-sütra also says that the soul, my actual self, is by nature joyful. Yet, I am suffering. Lord Kåñëa further says that when these questions arise, gradually one comes to God. Those who have awakened to these questions are said to be on the path of perfection. And, when the question of God and our relationship with God comes, that is our final perfection of life.

Now, Kåñëa says that out of many thousands of people, one may try to make perfection of this life; and out of many millions of such persons on the path of perfection, only one may understand Kåñëa. So understanding Kåñëa is not very easy. But it is also the easiest. It is not easy, but at the same time it is the easiest. It is the easiest if you follow the prescribed forms.

Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu has introduced this chanting of Hare Kåñëa. He has not exactly introduced it; it is in the scriptures. But He has especially propagated this formula. In this age this is the easiest method of self-realization. Simply chant Hare Kåñëa. It can be done by everyone. In my classroom, I am perhaps the only Indian. My students are all Americans, and they are taking part in the chanting very nicely, chanting and dancing. That means that, in any country, in any place, this can be performed. Therefore it is the easiest. You may not understand the philosophy of the Bhagavad-gétä. That is also not very difficult; but still, if you think that you cannot understand, you can still chant very easily: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa.

If we want to understand God, Kåñëa, this is the beginning. The easiest beginning—simply chanting. Now, there are many students of my ISKCON institution. This institution is open a little over a year; but some of the students, by simply chanting, by the grace of Kåñëa, have advanced in such a way that they can talk about the science of God, and they will very easily answer those human questions. So, this is the easiest method of transcendental meditation.

Kåñëa says that out of many millions of people, one may understand Him. But, by chanting of this Hare Kåñëa, as introduced by Lord Caitanya—chanting and dancing—you can understand Kåñëa within a very short time. Knowledge begins not from Kåñëa, but from things which we are accustomed to see every day.

Land is gross. If you touch it, you can feel its hardness. But, as soon as the land becomes still finer, it is water, and the touch is soft. And then again, from water to fire, still finer. After fire or electricity the air is still finer; and after air, the sky, ether, is finer still. Beyond ether, the mind is still finer; and beyond the mind, intelligence is still finer. And, if you go beyond intelligence to understand the soul, it is finer still. From these elements people have discovered so many sciences. There are many scientists, for example, who are soil experts; they can say, by analyzing a particular type of earth, what kind of minerals are there. Somebody seeks out silver, somebody seeks out gold, somebody seeks out mica. This is knowledge of gross things—the earth. If you go to finer substances, then you study water, or liquid things, such as petrol and alcohol. Go still finer, and from water you will go to fire and electricity. If you study electricity, you have to study all sorts of books. And, from this finer fire, you will come to air. We have so much advancement in our airplanes; we are studying how they move, how they are made—now sputniks and jets—so many things are being discovered.

Next comes the study of the ethereal: electronics, ethereal transformations from one thing to another. Then, finer still, is the mind-psychology and psychiatry. But for intelligence, rationalism, there is only a little philosophical speculation. And what about the soul? Is there any science of the soul? The materialists have none. Material science has advanced to the study of the ether, or the mind and intelligence, but there is no advancement beyond that. Beyond intelligence, they do not know what exists. But here in the Bhagavad-gétä you can find this.

The Bhagavad-gétä begins at the point after intelligence. When Arjuna was perplexed at the outset, his intelligence was perplexed—whether to fight or not to fight. Kåñëa begins the Gétä from the point where intelligence fails. How does knowledge of the soul begin? It is just like a child is playing. You can understand this child's body is now so small, but one day this child will be grown up, like you or me. But the same soul will continue. So, by intelligence, you can understand that although the body is changed, the soul is there. The same soul which was existing in the body of the child is still continuing in the body of the old man. Therefore the soul is permanent, and only the body has changed. This is a very easy thing to understand. And the last change of this body is death. As at every moment, every second, every day, every hour, the body is changing, so the last change is when one cannot act with the body, and so he has to take another one. Just as, when my cloth is too worn out or old, I cannot put it on; I have to take a new cloth. It is similar with the soul. When the body is too old or unworkable, I have to change to another body. This is called death.

This is the beginning of the Bhagavad-gétä, when the preliminary knowledge of the soul is there. And you will find that there are only a few who can understand the existence of the soul as permanent, and of the body as changeable. Therefore Bhagavän, Lord Kåñëa, says that, out of many, many millions of people, one may understand it. But still, the knowledge is there. If you want to understand it, it is not difficult. You can understand it.

Now, we should inquire into the existence of the ego, the finest material substance. What is ego? I am pure soul, but with my intelligence and mind I am in contact with matter, and I have identified myself with matter. This is false ego. I am pure soul, but I am identifying falsely. For example, I am identifying with the land, thinking that I am Indian, or that I am American. This is called ahaìkära. Ahaìkära means the point where the pure soul touches matter. That junction is called ahaìkära. Ahaìkära is still finer than intelligence.

Kåñëa says that these are the eight material elements: earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and false ego. False ego means false identification. Our nescient life has begun from this false identification—thinking that I am this matter, although I am seeing every day, at every moment, that I am not this matter. Soul is permanently existing, while matter is changing. This misconception, this illusion, is called ahaìkära, false ego. And your liberation means when you are out of this false ego. What is that status? Ahaà brahmäsmi. I am Brahman, I am spirit. That is the beginning of liberation.

Of course, one may be suffering from disease, from fever, and the temperature may come down to normal, 98.6 degrees. So he is now normal, but that is not the cure. Suppose for two days he has a 98.6 degree temperature, but with a slight change of diet, a slight change of behavior, the temperature rises immediately to 100. Relapse. Similarly, simply purifying the mind, rejecting this false ahaìkära identification—I am not this body, I am not this matter; I am soul—this is not liberation. It is only the beginning of liberation. If you stick to this point, and continue—just as you might continue your activities and keep your temperature at 98.6 degrees—then you are a healthy man.

For example, in the West now there is some propaganda for taking intoxication. The people want to forget the bodily existence. But how long will you forget? There will be a relapse. You can forget for one hour or two, by intoxication, and think that I am not this body. But unless you are actually on the platform of understanding yourself by knowledge, it is not possible to continue. Still, everyone is trying to think, "I am not this body." They have experience that they are suffering so much on account of bodily identification, and so, "If only I could forget my bodily identification!"

This is only a negative conception. When you actually realize yourself, simply understanding that you are Brahman will not do. You have to engage in the activities of Brahman. Otherwise you will fall down. Simply flying very high is no solution to the problem of going to the moon. Nowadays the fools are trying to go to the moon, but they simply go 240,000 miles up from the Earth, touch the moon, and return. They are very proud. There is so much talk of aeronautics: crowds and meetings and conferences. But what have they done? What are 240,000 miles in that vast sky? If you go 240 million miles, still you are limited. So this will not do. If you want to go high, you must have permanent shelter. If you can take rest there, then you cannot fall down. But if you have no rest, then you will have to fall down. The airplane goes high, seven miles, eight miles up from the Earth, but it comes down immediately.

So, simply understanding ahaìkära means no more than understanding the false identification. Simply understanding that I am not matter, I am soul, is not perfection. The impersonalist, the void philosopher, simply thinks of the negative, that I am not this matter, I am not this body. This will not stay. You have to not only realize that you are not matter, but you have to engage yourself in the spiritual world. And that spiritual world means to be working in Kåñëa consciousness. That spiritual world, that functioning of our real life, is Kåñëa consciousness.

False ego I have already explained. It is neither matter nor spirit, but the junction—where the spirit soul comes into contact with matter and forgets himself. It is just as, in delirium, a man is diseased and his brain becomes puzzled, and gradually he forgets himself and becomes a madman. He is gradually forgetting. So there is the beginning of loss, and there is one point where he forgets. That beginning point is called ahaìkära, or false ego.

Chanting the mahämantra—Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare—is the process not merely of putting an end to this false conception of the self, but it goes beyond that, to the point where the pure spirit soul engages in his eternal, blissful, all-knowing activities in the loving service of God. This is the height of conscious development, the ultimate goal of all living entities now evolving through the cycles and species of material nature.

TYS 4: The Hare Kåñëa Mantra

4/The Hare Kåñëa Mantra

[ON CHANTING THE HARE KRISHNA MANTRA, BTG: Vol. 1, No. 07, February 1, 1967]

The transcendental vibration established by the chanting of HARE KÅÑËA, HARE KÅÑËA, KÅÑËA KÅÑËA, HARE HARE/ HARE RÄMA, HARE RÄMA, RÄMA RÄMA, HARE HARE is the sublime method for reviving our transcendental consciousness. As living spiritual souls, we are all originally Kåñëa conscious entities, but due to our association with matter from time immemorial, our consciousness is now adulterated by the material atmosphere. The material atmosphere, in which we are now living, is called mäyä, or illusion. Mäyä means that which is not. And what is this illusion? The illusion is that we are all trying to be lords of material nature, while actually we are under the grip of her stringent laws. When a servant artificially tries to imitate the all-powerful master, it is called illusion. We are trying to exploit the resources of material nature, but actually we are becoming more and more entangled in her complexities. Therefore, although we are engaged in a hard struggle to conquer nature, we are ever more dependent on her. This illusory struggle against material nature can be stopped at once by revival of our eternal Kåñëa consciousness.

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare is the transcendental process for reviving this original pure consciousness. By chanting this transcendental vibration, we can cleanse away all misgivings within our hearts. The basic principle of all such misgivings is the false consciousness that I am the lord of all I survey.

Kåñëa consciousness is not an artificial imposition on the mind. This consciousness is the original natural energy of the living entity. When we hear the transcendental vibration, this consciousness is revived. This simplest method of meditation is recommended for this age. By practical experience also, one can perceive that by chanting this mahämantra, or the Great Chanting for Deliverance, one can at once feel a transcendental ecstasy coming through from the spiritual stratum. In the material concept of life we are busy in the matter of sense gratification as if we were in the lower animal stage. A little elevated from this status of sense gratification, one is engaged in mental speculation for the purpose of getting out of the material clutches. A little elevated from this speculative status, when one is intelligent enough, one tries to find out the supreme cause of all causes—within and without. And when one is factually on the plane of spiritual understanding, surpassing the stages of sense, mind and intelligence, he is then on the transcendental plane. This chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra is enacted from the spiritual platform, and thus this sound vibration surpasses all lower strata of consciousness—namely sensual, mental and intellectual. There is no need, therefore, to understand the language of the mantra, nor is there any need for mental speculation nor any intellectual adjustment for chanting this mahämantra. It is automatic, from the spiritual platform, and as such, anyone can take part in vibrating this transcendental sound without any previous qualification. In a more advanced stage, of course, one is not expected to commit offenses on grounds of spiritual understanding.

In the beginning, there may not be the presence of all transcendental ecstasies, which are eight in number. These are: 1) Being stopped as though dumb, 2) perspiration, 3) standing up of hairs on the body, 4) dislocation of voice, 5) trembling, 6) fading of the body, 7) crying in ecstasy, and 8) trance. But there is no doubt that chanting for a while takes one immediately to the spiritual platform, and one shows the first symptom of this in the urge to dance along with the chanting of the mantra. We have seen this practically. Even a child can take part in the chanting and dancing. Of course, for one who is too entangled in material life, it takes a little more time to come to the standard point, but even such a materially engrossed man is raised to the spiritual platform very quickly. When it is chanted by a pure devotee of the Lord in love, it has the greatest efficacy on hearers, and as such this chanting should be heard from the lips of a pure devotee of the Lord, so that immediate effects can be achieved. As far as possible, chanting from the lips of nondevotees should be avoided. Milk touched by the lips of a serpent has poisonous effects.

The word Harä is the form of addressing the energy of the Lord, and the words Kåñëa and Räma are forms of addressing the Lord Himself. Both Kåñëa and Räma mean the supreme pleasure, and Harä is the supreme pleasure energy of the Lord, changed to Hare (Hah-ray) in the vocative. The supreme pleasure energy of the Lord helps us to reach the Lord.

The material energy, called mäyä, is also one of the multi-energies of the Lord. And we the living entities are also the energy, marginal energy, of the Lord. The living entities are described as superior to material energy. When the superior energy is in contact with the inferior energy, an incompatible situation arises; but when the superior marginal energy is in contact with the superior energy, called Harä, it is established in its happy, normal condition.

These three words, namely Harä, Kåñëa and Räma, are the transcendental seeds of the mahämantra. The chanting is a spiritual call for the Lord and His energy, to give protection to the conditioned soul. This chanting is exactly like the genuine cry of a child for its mother's presence. Mother Harä helps the devotee achieve the Lord Father's grace, and the Lord reveals Himself to the devotee who chants this mantra sincerely.

No other means of spiritual realization is as effective in this age of quarrel and hypocrisy as the mahämantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

TYS 5: How Bhakti-yoga Works

5/How Bhakti-yoga Works

[FROM THE LECTURES OF SWAMI A.C. BHAKTIVEDANTA, Friday evening, Dec. 30, 1966, BTG: Vol 1. No. 15, 1967]

In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa tells His disciple, Arjuna, "I am disclosing a most confidential part of knowledge to you, because you are My dear friend." As is stated in the Fourth Chapter, the Bhagavad-gétä is spoken to Arjuna because of his one qualification: he was a devotee. The Lord says that the mystery of the Bhagavad-gétä is very confidential. Without being an unalloyed devotee you cannot know it. In India there are 645 different commentaries on the Gétä. One professor has proposed that Kåñëa is a doctor and Arjuna is his patient, and has made his commentary in that way. Similarly, there are commentators and people who have taken it that everyone is perfect, and that they can interpret scripture in their own way. As far as we are concerned, we agree to read the Bhagavad-gétä according to the instructions given in the Gétä itself. This has to be taken through the paramparä, the system of disciplic succession. It is being taught by the Supreme Person because "you are My dear friend. I desire that you may become prosperous and happy. Therefore I speak to you." Kåñëa wants everyone to be happy and peaceful and prosperous, but they do not want it. Sunshine is open to everyone, but if someone wishes to remain in darkness, what can the sunshine do for him? So the Gétä is open to everyone.

There are different species of life, and lower and higher grades of understanding exist—that is a fact. But Kåñëa says that this knowledge is for anyone. If one has lower birth or whatever, it doesn't matter. The Bhagavad-gétä offers transcendental subject matter everyone can understand provided he goes along with the principle as stated in the Fourth Chapter. That is, that the Gétä [4.1] is coming down in disciplic succession: "I first of all instructed this yoga system to the sun-god Vivasvän, who taught it to Manu, who taught it to Ikñväku." From Kåñëa the disciplic succession is coming down, but "in course of time the disciplic succession was broken." Arjuna is therefore made the new disciple. In the Second Chapter, Arjuna surrenders: "So far we have been talking as friends, but now I accept You as my spiritual master." Anyone following the principle in this line accepts the guru as Kåñëa, and the student must represent Arjuna. Kåñëa is speaking as the spiritual master of Arjuna, and Arjuna says, "Whatever You are saying I accept." Read it like that—not: "I like this, so I accept it; this I don't like, and so I reject it." Such reading is useless nonsense.

The teacher must be a representative of Kåñëa, a devotee, and the student must be like Arjuna. Then this Kåñëa consciousness study is perfect. Otherwise it is a waste of time. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [3.25.25] it is stated: "If anyone wants to understand the science of Kåñëa, he should associate with pure devotees. When discussions take place among pure devotees, the potency of spiritual language is revealed." Scholarly discussion of the Gétä is futile. In the Upaniñads [ÇU 6.23] it is stated: "To one who has firm faith in God, and similar faith in God's representative, all the import of Vedic language will be revealed." We must have the qualification of being a devotee. Become dear to God. My spiritual master used to say, "Don't try to see God. Act in such a way that God will see you." We have to qualify ourselves. By your qualification God Himself will come and see you.

If one can perceive God, he is transcendental to all material demands. We are always dissatisfied in the material world in circumstances that won't continue; happiness is temporary, and temporary plight also will not exist for much time. Cold, heat, duality—it is all coming and going. To get to the absolute stage is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa is seated in everyone's heart, and as you become purified He will show you the path. And in the end you will quit this body, and you will go to the spiritual sky.

"No one knows Me," Kåñëa says, "My influence, My power and my extent. Even the maharñis [the great thinkers] don't know. I am the origin of all demigods and the origin of all åñis." There are so many forefathers we don't know of, and there are Brahmä and the demigods—what do we know? We can't reach to the platform where we can grasp God. We gather knowledge by limited senses, and Kåñëa can't be reached by the mind, the center of the senses. Imperfect senses can't grasp perfect knowledge. Mind and sense manipulation can't reach Him. If you engage the senses in the service of the Lord, however, then He will reveal Himself through your senses.

People may say, "What is the use of understanding God? What is the use? Let Him stay in His place, let me stay in my place." But in the çästras, the scriptures, it is stated that pious activities will raise us to beauty, knowledge and good birth; and that by impious (sinful) activities, we suffer. Suffering is always there, pious or impious, but a distinction is made. He who knows God, however, becomes freed from all possible sinful reactions, which no amount of piety can accomplish. If we reject God we can never be happy.

Not even considering human society, if you take the demigods who are more advanced and intelligent, they also don't know Kåñëa. The seven great sages whose planet is near the North Star also do not know. Kåñëa says: "I am the original, the source of all these demigods." He is the father of everything, not only the origin of demigods, but of the sages—and the universe. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.1.1] describes how the universal form took place, and everything is emanating from Him [vs 1.1.2]. Also Kåñëa is the origin of Paramätmä, the Supersoul; and the impersonal brahma-jyoti, the shining effulgence, is in Him. Of everything, of every conception, "I am the source." The Absolute Truth may be realized in three phases, but is one nondual truth. Brahman (the glowing effulgence), localized Supersoul, and Bhagavän—the Supreme Person—are three features or aspects of God.

If no one knows the Supreme Personality of Godhead, how can He be known? He can be known when the Supreme Lord comes before you and reveals Himself to you. Then you can know. Our senses are imperfect, and they cannot realize the Supreme Truth. When you adopt a submissive attitude and chant, realization begins from the tongue. To eat and to vibrate sound is the business of the tongue. If you can control your tongue for prasädam, spiritual food, and make the sound vibration of the holy name, then by surrender of the tongue you can control all the other senses. If you cannot control your tongue, you cannot control your senses. Taste prasädam and become spiritually advanced. You can have this process at your home: offer vegetarian foods to Kåñëa, chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra and offer obeisances:

namo brahmaëya-deväya
go-brähmaëa-hitäya ca
jagat-hitäya kåñëäya
govindäya namo namaù.
[Viñëu Puräëa 1.19.65]

Everyone can offer, and then take the food with friends. And chant before the picture of Kåñëa, and lead a pure life. Just see the result—the whole world will become Vaikuëöha, where there is no anxiety. All is anxious with us because we have accepted this material life. Just the opposite is so in the spiritual world. No one, however, knows how to get out of the material concept. Taking an intoxicant doesn't help; the same anxieties are there when you are finished being drunk. If you want to be free and want life eternal with bliss and knowledge, take to Kåñëa. No one can know God, but there is this way: the process of Kåñëa consciousness.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that no one can conquer Him or approach Him, but He becomes conquered. How? Let people remain in their own positions, but let them give up nonsense speculation through volumes of books. Thousands of books are printed and read, and after six months thrown away. This way and that—how can you know the Supreme by speculation on the information supplied by your blunt senses? Give up research—throw it away—just become submissive; acknowledge that you are limited and subordinate to material nature and to God. No one can be equal to or greater than God. So be submissive. Try to hear about the glories of the Supreme Lord from authorized sources. Such authority is handed over by disciplic succession. If we can understand by the same authority as Arjuna, that is real authority. God is always ready to reveal; you just become Kåñëa conscious. Follow the path traversed by the great äcäryas, the devoted teachers, and then everything will be known. Although He is unconquerable and unknowable, He can be known in your home.

If you take to this process and follow the principles, what will be the result? As soon as you understand, you will know that the Supreme Lord is the cause of all causes, but that He is not caused by any other cause. And He is the master of all planets. This is not accepting blindly. God has given you the power of reason, the power of arguing—but don't argue falsely. If you want to know the transcendental science you must surrender. Surrender to authority and know Him by signs. Don't surrender to a fool or a rascal. Find one who is coming in disciplic succession, one who is fully convinced about the Supreme Absolute Truth. If you find such a person, surrender and try to please him, serve him and question him. Surrender unto Him is surrender to God. Question to learn, not to waste time.

The process is there, but if we waste time by intoxication we will never see Him, the unconquerable Lord. Follow the principles and slowly but surely, without doubt, you will know. "Yes, I'm making progress," you'll say. And it is very easy, and you can execute it and be in a happy mood. Study, take part with music, eat prasädam. And no one can cheat you by this process. But if you want to be cheated—go to the cheaters.

Try to understand it from the authoritative source and apply it in your life. Amongst the dying mortals, you will become the most intelligent because you are freed from sinful actions. If you act only for Kåñëa, then you are freed from all reactions. You will have no anxiety over what is auspicious or inauspicious because you will be in touch with the most auspicious. This is the process. Ultimately, we can get in touch with Kåñëa. Life will be successful. Anyone can adopt it, because it is very simple.

Here is a nice formula presented by Kåñëa Himself: one should understand the position of Kåñëa. He is unborn and without any cause. We have experience, all of us, that we are born, and we have a cause; our father is our cause. If someone poses himself as God, he has to prove that he is unborn and uncaused. Our practical experience is that we are born. Kåñëa is not born. We have to understand this. Understanding this is to be firmly convinced He is the cause, but is not caused; and since He is not caused He is the proprietor of all manifestation. One who understands this simple philosophy is not illusioned.

We are generally illusioned. We are claiming ownership of the land. But before my birth the land was here, and after my death it will still be here. How long will I go on claiming, in body after body, "This is my land! This is my land!"? Is it not nonsense? One has to be out of illusion. We should know that whatever we are doing in the material concept of life is illusion. We have to understand whether we are illusioned or not. And all conditioned souls are illusioned. He who learns to be disillusioned gets free of all encumberances. If we want freedom from all bonds, then we have to understand God. There is no neglecting this; it is our prime duty.

Out of millions of entities, one may be enlightened. Generally we are all born fools. As soon as I take birth I am nurtured by parents and educated to falsely claim a land as my own. National education means to make you more foolish. Am I not foolish? I am changing my body like a dress life after life. You have so many minds, so many dresses—who do you claim this one? Why don't you understand: "This dress is nice, but next moment I may be in another." You are in the grip of nature. You cannot say what dress you will have: "Nature, make me American." No; material nature controls. If you live like a dog—here, take a dog's dress. If you live a godly life—here, take God.

Out of many fools someone tries to understand what I actually am. Dog? American? Russian? This real inquiry goes on. If you inquire, you have to ask someone, not just yourself. When crossing the street in a place you don't know, you have to ask the policeman or some gentleman. For "what I am" you have to go to an authority also. What is a spiritual master? He is a person conversant with the science of Kåñëa. Ordinarily nobody inquires; but if a man does, he can make progress and come to this understanding: Kåñëa is the cause of all causes.

Four kinds of people, followers of scripture and higher authority, inquire about Kåñëa. Those addicted to sinful activities can't inquire. They go on in intoxication. The righteous, pious man inquires and goes to God. Facility is given to people in this process by the authority—to make people happy, not to exploit people. The purpose of ISKCON is, in this way, to understand the science of God. You want happiness. Here it is. You are distressed by sinful reactions. But if there is no sinful reaction there is no suffering. One who knows Kåñëa without doubt is relieved of all reactions. Kåñëa says, "Come to Me, and I will give you freedom from all reactions." Don't disbelieve it. He can give you shelter; He has all power. If I give you such a promise, because I have no such power I may break the promise.

If you associate yourself with Kåñëa consciousness your dormant relationship with Kåñëa will be evoked. You have a relationship with Him. There is no question of disbelieving; it is simply foolishness. The dormant relationship is there. You want to serve Kåñëa, but simply by the spell of illusion we think we have no connection with Kåñëa. We go on doing all "independent" nonsense, and we are always anxious. When we associate with these dormant feelings for Kåñëa, however, we will become engaged in Kåñëa consciousness.

"God is unborn" indicates that He is different from the material world. We have no such experience of the unborn. This city was born—history is filled with dates. Spiritual nature, however, is unborn, and at once we can see the difference. The material nature is born. You have to understand; if Kåñëa is unborn then He is spiritual, not like one of us. Kåñëa is not some "extraordinary person who was also born." He is not born. So how can I decide He is an ordinary man? "Those who are fools and rascals think of Me as an ordinary man," Kåñëa says in the Gétä. He is different from everything in this world. He is anädi, without cause.

Kåñëa may be spiritual, but there are other spiritual bodies. We have spiritual bodies like Kåñëa's, but they are born. They are not exactly born; it is like the sparks of the fire. The sparks are not born from the fire; they are actually there. We are also not born; we are sparks that come out of the original form. Even if we are not born, the spark comes out of Kåñëa, so we are different; the sparks of the fire are fire, but they are not the original fire. As for quality, we are the same as Kåñëa. It is like the difference between father and son. Father and son are different and nondifferent at the same time. The son is an expansion of the father, but he cannot claim that he is the father; that would be nonsense.

Because Kåñëa is declaring Himself supreme proprietor, He is therefore different from anything. If I am the proprietor of New York State, I am still not New York State. In every step there is duality. No one can say we are completely one with God.

When you can understand Kåñëa's and your own position in a nice analytical way, then at once you become free from sinful reactions. This process will help you. Chant Hare Kåñëa and cleanse your mind, and you will receive the message. One has to be qualified. If you chant and hear, for no payment, you will approach God. All things will become clear and illuminated.

TYS 6: Sources of Absolute Knowledge

6/Sources of Absolute Knowledge

[SOURCE: UNKNOWN]

We require to hear about the method of relishing the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the most elevated text on the science of God consciousness, the matured and ripened fruit of the tree of Vedic wisdom. The Sanskrit word rasa means juice, just like the juice of an orange or a mango. And the author of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam requests that you kindly try to taste the rasa, or juice, of the fruit of the Bhägavatam. Why? Why shall I taste the juice of the fruit of the Bhägavatam? Because it is the ripened fruit of the Vedic desire tree. As a desire tree, whatever you want you can have from the Vedas. Veda means knowledge; it is so complete that whether you want to enjoy in this material world or you want to enjoy spiritual life, both kinds of knowledge are there. If you follow the Vedic principles, then you will be happy. This is like the codes of the state. If the citizens obey, then they will be happy, there will be no criminal trespassing, and they will enjoy life. The state does not come to you for nothing just to trouble you, but if you live according to the state law there is no question of unhappiness.

Similarly, this conditioned soul, the living entity, has come here to this material world for enjoyment and for material happiness. And the Vedas are the guidance: all right, enjoy—but you enjoy according to these principles. That is called Veda. Therefore, everything is there. Just as we sometimes perform a marriage ceremony in the temple. What is this marriage ceremony? It is the combination of man and woman, boy and girl. They are already there, they are living like friends—what is the use of this marriage ceremony? It is Vedic: the Vedas account for living together, sex life, but under some special regulations so that you may be happy. The ultimate end is to become happy. If you follow the Vedic rules and restrictions, that will not mean that you will be kept from eating or not allowed to sleep, not allowed to defend or to have sex life. It is not like that. Your bodily necessities are the same as those of the animals; the animals also eat, they also sleep, they also mate and also defend. So we require these things also. But the Vedas prescribe some regulations: you act in this way, so that you will not be unhappy. If you follow the regulation, ultimately the result will be that you will be free from the material entanglement.

This material life is not meant for the spirit soul. It is simply a misunderstanding that you want to enjoy this material life. But Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, gives us specific orders so that we can enjoy, in such a way that, at the end, we will understand that this is not our proper life—our proper life is spiritual. This human form of life is perfected as soon as we come to the understanding of spiritual existence—that I am Brahman. Otherwise, if I do not take care of my spiritual life, then the result is that I must live as the cats and dogs do. There is every possibility that my next life will be an animal life. And if, by chance or by a freak of nature, I get into animal life, then millions and millions of years will be required before again coming to this human form of life. So the human form of life is meant for self-realization, and the Vedas are the direction.

Now in the Bhagavad-gétä you will find that Kåñëa says that to study or to follow the rules and regulations of the Vedas actually means to come to the understanding of Kåñëa consciousness. That is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam also. So the Vedas give you the chance to gradually come to the point of understanding Kåñëa, after many, many births. But the Bhägavatam is called the essence of life, the ripened fruit of the Vedas, because the Bhägavatam gives you directly what is needed in your life.

The Vedas are divided into four: Säma Veda, Åk, Atharva and Yajus. Then these are explained by the Puräëas, of which there are eighteen. Then these are still further explained by the Upaniñads, of which there are 108. The Upaniñads are summarized in the Vedänta-sütra, and the Vedänta-sütra is still again explained by the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, by the same author. This is the process. So the Bhägavatam is the essence of all Vedic knowledge.

Naimiñäraëya is a very famous and sacred forest in northern India, where all the åñis, the sages, generally go to aid their spiritual advancement of life. This Çrémad-Bhägavatam was first discussed in this age in that forest. When it was discussed, the great saint Süta Gosvämé was asked by his audience: Now that Kåñëa has gone back to His abode, with whom is transcendental knowledge now resting? This question was raised. The Bhagavad-gétä was spoken by Kåñëa Himself, and it contains all descriptions of jïäna-yoga, karma-yoga, dhyäna-yoga and bhakti-yoga. Now this inquiry was made: Where can you get spiritual knowledge, now that Kåñëa is gone? The answer was that Kåñëa, having departed, has left us the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. It is the representation, the sound representation, of Kåñëa. The Bhägavatam is not different from Kåñëa, as the Gétä is not different from Kåñëa. They are absolute. Kåñëa and Kåñëa's sound vibration are not different. Kåñëa and Kåñëa's name are also not different. And Kåñëa and Kåñëa's form, again, are not different. This is absolute. It requires realization.

This Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam are sound incarnations of Kåñëa. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam is also the literary incarnation of Kåñëa, and it is the fruit of Vedic knowledge. You may have experience that there is a bird which is called a parrot. The parrot's body is green, and his beak is red. The specific qualification of the parrot is that whatever you say he can imitate. That parrot bird is touching the ripened fruit, and, naturally, if the fruit is ripened on the tree, it becomes very tasteful. Again, if the fruit is tasted by the parrot, it becomes still more tasteful. That is nature's way. So, here, it is said that this Çrémad-Bhägavatam is just like the ripened fruit of Vedic knowledge, and at the same time it is touched by Çukadeva Gosvämé, Süta's spiritual master. Çuka means parrot in Sanskrit.

This Çrémad-Bhägavatam was first explained by Çukadeva Gosvämé, though the author is his father, Vyäsa. Çukadeva was only sixteen years old when he was taught the Bhägavatam, and he was illuminated. He was already liberated in the impersonal concept of the Absolute, but after hearing the Bhägavatam from his father, he became attracted by the pastimes of Kåñëa, and he became a preacher of the Bhägavatam. First he explained it before Mahäräja Parékñit, the great king. A short history of Mahäräja Parékñit is that he was a very pious king, but unfortunately by some of his acts he was cursed by a brähmaëa boy to die within seven days. In those days if a brähmaëa should curse someone it would come true. They had the power to curse or give benediction.

So Parékñit understood that within a week he would have to die, and he prepared himself. He gave up his kingdom, entrusting it to his son, Mahäräja Janamejaya, and he detached himself from the family and sat down on the banks of the Ganges near Delhi. It was not exactly the Ganges, it was actually the Yamunä. There, because he was a great emperor, many learned sages came.

Parékñit now inquired from all the great sages present there: "What is my duty? I am going to die within seven days; now what is my duty? You are all learned sages; please just prescribe for me." So someone said to practice yoga, someone said to practice jïäna, the cultivation of knowledge; there were different opinions. But at that time Çukadeva Gosvämé entered the forest, and although Çukadeva was only sixteen, he was so learned and reputed that all the old sages, including his father, Vyäsadeva, stood up to show him respect. He was so learned. So when he appeared, it was agreed, "Here is Çukadeva Gosvämé. Let him decide what to do. We appoint him as our representative."

Çukadeva Gosvämé was thus authorized to speak, and he was asked, "What is my duty? I am very fortunate that you have come in this momentous hour. Kindly tell me what is my duty."

Çukadeva Gosvämé said, "All right, I shall explain to you the Çrémad-Bhägavatam." Then everyone present agreed.

As the Bhägavatam was first spoken by Çukadeva Gosvämé, it is therefore mentioned that as the parrot touches ripened fruit and it becomes even sweeter, so this Çrémad-Bhägavatam, because it was touched first by Çukadeva Gosvämé, has become still more tasteful.

The idea is that any Vedic literature, especially the Bhägavatam or the Gétä, should be learned as spoken by a realized soul. Especially this literature, which is called Vaiñëava literature, should not be heard from a person who is not a devotee. This point I have several times stressed. Those who are nondevotees, those who are mental speculationists, those who are fruitive workers, those who are meditators or mystic yogés, cannot explain the science of God. This is especially mentioned also by Sanätana Gosvämé, another great saint: those who are not in devotional service, nongodly, those who have no faith in God—such persons should not be allowed to speak on the Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, or any literature which is in relationship with the Supreme Lord. So it is not that anybody can speak the Bhägavatam or the Gétä and we will have to hear it. No. Sanätana Gosvämé especially prohibits us: we should not hear of the Supreme Lord from one who is not purified.

One may ask, "How can you taint the words of Kåñëa, which are naturally transcendentally pure? What is the harm if we hear from the nondevotee?" This question may be raised. The example given here is that milk is very nice and nutritious, but as soon as it is touched by a serpent it becomes poison immediately. The serpent is very envious. He bites and puts to death immediately, unnecessarily, and therefore is considered the cruelest animal amongst the living entities. In the çästra nonviolence is recommended, as in every scripture, but the serpent and the scorpion are allowed to be killed. You cannot say that milk is so nutritious, and we can drink—what is the harm if it is touched by serpents? No—the result will be death. One should not hear at least the Bhagavad-gétä and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam from those who are not devotees of the Lord, who have no realization of God and who are envious of Him. Their touch renders it poison. The words of the Lord are always sublime, but as soon as they are touched by the serpent of a nondevotee, one should be very careful about hearing.

In the Bhägavatam, it is indicated that as soon as Çukadeva touched it, it became delicious. This is the distinction. Basically it is the ripened fruit of Vedic knowledge, but at the same time it has been touched by Çukadeva Gosvämin.

The Lord is the supreme object of yoga and the reservoir of all transcendental pleasure; He reveals Himself only to His devotees and by the mercy of His devotees all can relish His intimate association.

Glossary

Ahaìkara—false ego, the junction point at which a person falsely identifies his self as the material body.

Ahaà brahmäsmi—(lit.—"I am not this body; I am Brahman") Spiritual realization of the qualitative oneness of the infinitesimal individual with the infinite Supreme Lord Kåñëa.

Bhakti-yoga—direct attachment to Kåñëa.

Brahmacarya—student life of celibacy and study of çästras under a spiritual master.

Brähmaëas—those trained in higher philosophical science, knowers of Brahman (spirit).

Kñatriya—one trained and naturally qualified for ruling and for protecting the women, children, elderly persons and Brähmaëas.

Mahämantra—Great chant for deliverance, the Hare Kåñëa mantra.

Mäyä—(Lit.-"that which is not") Material atmosphere in which the conditioned soul tries to enjoy without Kåñëa, or God.

Mäyävädés—impersonalist philosophers who believe everything is illusion; they believe only in the impersonal aspect of God, but they do not recognize the source of the impersonal Brahman, the Parambrahman, or the Personality of Godhead.

Prasädam—food made spiritual by offering it to Kåñëa.

Çästra—scripture

Çüdras—the laborer class who, by nature, serve others for their livelihood.

Vaikuëöha—where there is no anxiety, the spiritual world.

Vaiçyas—mercantile and agricultural class

Yogeçvara—the master of yoga, the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa.


The International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON)

Founder-Äcärya: His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

ISKCON is a worldwide community of devotees dedicated to the principles of bhakti-yoga. Write, call, or visit for further information. Classes are held in the evenings during the week, and a special feast and festival is held every Sunday afternoon.


BOOKS BY HIS DIVINE GRACE
A.C. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI PRABHUPÄDA
AVAILABLE FROM ISKCON PRESS


BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS
Complete Edition (ISKCON PRESS, 1971)

Bhagavad-gétä has long been appreciated as a scriptural literature of sublime importance by thoughtful men throughout the world, for its eighteen chapters shower upon man the immortal nectar of the wisdom of the Absolute. The aim of this edition of Bhagavad-gétä is to present the ancient science of yoga as presented by the speaker Himself, Lord Çré Kåñëa, without adulteration or interpretation. Although there are many translations of Bhagavad-gétä none can be said to be authoritative because in almost every one of them the author has expressed his personal opinion through the commentaries, without touching the spirit of Bhagavad-gétä as it is. His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, however, has accepted the Gétä to be perfect and complete, and he has prepared his Bhagavad-gétä As It Is with that understanding. Thus the message of this timeless classic is transmitted in its purity and fullness. By reading this book one can attain the perfection of human life.

981 pp., 56 full-color illustrations Hard $10.95 Soft $5.95


His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


The Supreme Personality of Godhead said:

"O son of Prtha, those who are not deluded, the Great Souls, are under the protection of the Divine Nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible.

"They are always engaged in chanting My glories. Endeavoring with great determination, offering homage unto Me, they worship Me with devotion
The Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, Chapter IX, verses 13 and 14.


KÅÑËA, THE SUPREME PERSONALITY OF GODHEAD
(ISKCON PRESS, 1970)

The supremely rich, powerful, famous and beautiful Personality of Godhead, who is free from all material attachment, is now available in book form. KÅÑËA, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, 750 pages of transcendental reading matter, opulently illustrated with 82 full-color plates, presents the eternal, blissfull pastimes of the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa as they are revealed in the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the ripened fruit of all Vedic literatures. The KÅÑËA Books, potent in message and rich in design, offer mankind the opportunity to attain the highest benefit by understanding the true nature of the pastimes of the Supreme Lord. Everyone would do well to procure this deluxe two-volume set to read and keep at home as a great treasure.
750 pp., 82 full-color illustrations $16.00 (per vol.-$8.00)


ÇRÉMAD-BHÄGAVATAM of Kåñëa-dvaipäyana Vyäsa—translated with elaborate commentary. (ISKCON PRESS, 1971)

Çrémad-Bhägavatam is known as the "postgraduate study" of the Bhagavad-gétä. As the Gétä contains the words and teachings of Lord Kåñëa, Çrémad-Bhägavatam contains descriptions about the glories and pastimes of Kåñëa with His devotees. Çrémad-Bhägavatam contains all knowledge—material and spiritual—for the upliftment of the human being. Its contents include: description of the avatäras of Godhead, symptoms of men in the age of quarrel, real remedy for peace in the world, comparative importance of bhakti-yoga and mystic powers, principles of saintly association and innumerable other topics.
Vol. I (Canto I) 374 pp., 24 color illus. Soft $3.95 Hard $6.95


TEACHINGS OF LORD CAITANYA—A Treatise on Factual Spiritual Life. (ISKCON, 1968)

For thousands of years, sincere souls all over the world in search of spiritual realization have accepted Bhagavad-gétä as their most basic and profound text. Lord Caitanya, the most munificent incarnation of Godhead, appeared 500 years ago to demonstrate by example how to live the teachings of Bhagavad-gétä in the present age. Teachings of Lord Caitanya recounts the words and deeds of this great saint. Lord Caitanya was famous as a scholar and spoke authoritatively on Kåñëa, yoga, liberation, and nirvana; still He is better known as the divine origin of the Hare Kåñëa movement, distributing love of God simply by singing the holy names. In His profound discourses on Vedänta and in His ecstatic saìkértana festivals, Lord Caitanya was an example to all of how to attain the ultimate goal of life—Love of God—and this most advanced work on spiritual science can bring the reader into loving reciprocation with that Absolute Truth.
292 pp., 11 illustrations, Hard $5.95 Soft $3.95


ÇRÉ ÉÇOPANIÑAD—The knowledge that brings one nearer to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. (ISKCON PRESS, 1970)

All the major scriptures of the world indicate that God is not impersonal, but is a person. From the most authoritative sources, the famed 108 Upaniñads of India, Çré Éçopaniñad supplies revealed evidence that the Personality of Godhead is the creator, maintainer and destroyer of everything that exists, and revives the dormant hope of all living beings—to transcend this conditioned state and gain the eternal, blissful association of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.
135 pp., Soft $1.95 Hard $3.00


BACK TO GODHEAD—The Magazine of the Hare Krishna Movement.

"Back to Godhead" is the only journal in the West to deliver the authorized science of God realization as delivered by the unbroken disciplic succession of spiritual masters from Lord Çré Kåñëa. Such transcendental literature is provided to revive our relationship with God, Kåñëa, now forgotten in this age of illusion. The magazine contains practical information on how to achieve God realization, with writings by His Divine Grace, photo essays, recipes, and articles by disciples based on their personal realizations. The special grace of the saìkértana movement is that it is simply joyful, and the Kåñëa conscious philosophy presented in "Back to Godhead" can deliver that joy with sincerity and intelligence.32 pp., monthly, $5.00 per year, $6.00 foreign

The Blessed Lord said: The yogé whose mind is fixed on Me verily attains the highest happiness. A true yogé observes Me in all beings, and also sees every being in Me. Indeed, the self-realized man sees Me everywhere. And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all. (Bhagavad-gétä, 9.27, 29, 47)

On the Way to Kåñëa (1973)

HIS DIVINE GRACE
A.C. BHAKTIVEDANTA
SWAM PRABHUPÄDA
Founder-Äcärya
of the International Society
for Krishna Consciousness

The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust
New York . Los Angeles . London . Bombay

© 1973 by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust.
All rights reserved

Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 72-84842
International Standard Book Number: 0-912776-39-0

Readers interested in the subject matter of this
book are invited by the International Society for
Krishna Consciousness to correspond with its Secretary.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness
3959 Landmark Street
Culver City, California 90230

First Printing, 1973: 100,000
Printed in the United States of America
by ISKCON Press

OTHER BOOKS
by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 1-3 (6 Vols.)
Teachings of Lord Chaitanya
The Nectar of Devotion
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 Vols.)
Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäräj
Transcendental Teachings of Caitanya Mahäprabhu
The Perfection of Yoga
Beyond Birth and Death
Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge
Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness
Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)

Complete catalogue is available upon request.

contents

OWK 1: Throughway to Happiness

1
Throughway to Happiness

[660909BG.NY]

Every one of us is searching after happiness, but we do not know what real happiness is. We see so much advertised about happiness, but practically speaking we see so few happy people. This is because so few people know that the platform of real happiness is beyond temporary things. It is this real happiness that is described in Bhagavad-gétä by Lord Kåñëa to Arjuna.

Happiness is generally perceived through our senses. A stone, for instance, has no senses and cannot perceive happiness and distress. Developed consciousness can perceive happiness and distress more intensely than undeveloped consciousness. Trees have consciousness, but it is not developed. Trees may stand for a long time in all kinds of weather, but they have no way of perceiving miseries. If a human being were asked to stand like a tree for only three days or even less, he would not be able to tolerate it. The conclusion is that every living being feels happiness or distress according to the degree of development of his consciousness.

The happiness that we are experiencing in the material world is not real happiness. If one asks a tree, "Are you feeling happy?" the tree, if it could, might say, "Yes, I am happy, standing here all year. I'm enjoying the wind and snowfall very much, etc." This may be enjoyed by the tree, but for the human being it is a very low standard of enjoyment. There are different kinds and grades of living entities, and their conceptions and perceptions of happiness are also of all different types and grades. Although one animal may see that another animal is being slaughtered, he will go right on chewing grass, for he has no knowledge to understand that he may be next. He is thinking that he is happy, but at the next moment he may be slaughtered.

In this way there are different degrees of happiness. Yet of all of them, what is the highest happiness? Çré Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

sukham ätyantikaà yat tad
buddhi-grähyam aténdriyam
vetti yatra na caiväyaà
sthitaç calati tattvataù

"In that joyous state (samädhi), one is situated in boundless transcendental happiness and enjoys himself through transcendental senses. Established thus, one never departs from the truth." (Bg. 6.21)

Buddhi means intelligence; one has to be intelligent if he wants to enjoy. Animals do not have really developed intelligence and so cannot enjoy life as a human being can. The hands, the nose, the eyes, the other sense organs and all the bodily parts may be present on a dead man, but he cannot enjoy. Why not? The enjoying energy, the spiritual spark, has left, and therefore the body has no power. If one looks further into the matter with a little intelligence, he can understand that it was not the body that was enjoying at all but the small spiritual spark that was within. Although one may think that he is enjoying by the bodily sense organs, the real enjoyer is that spiritual spark. That spark always has the potency of enjoyment, but it is not always manifest due to being covered by the material tabernacle. Although we may not be aware of it, it is not possible for the body to experience enjoyment without the presence of this spiritual spark. If a man is offered the dead body of a beautiful woman, will he accept it? No, because the spiritual spark has moved out of the body. Not only was it enjoying within the body, but it was maintaining the body. When that spark leaves, the body simply deteriorates.

It follows that if the spirit is enjoying, it must have its senses also, otherwise how can it enjoy? The Vedas confirm that the spirit soul, although atomic in size, is the actual enjoying agent. It is not possible to measure the soul, but that is not to say that it is without measurement. An object may seem to us to be no bigger than a point and may seem to have no length or width, but when we perceive it under a microscope we can see that it has both length and width. Similarly, the soul also has its dimensions, but we cannot perceive them. When we buy a suit or dress, it is made to fit the body. The spiritual spark must have form, otherwise how is it the material body has grown to accomodate it? The conclusion is that the spiritual spark is not impersonal. It is an actual person. God is an actual person, and the spiritual spark, being a fragmental part of Him, is also a person. If the father has personality and individuality, the son also has them; and if the son has them, we can conclude that the father has them. So how can we, as sons of God, assert our personality and individuality and at the same time deny them to our Father, the Supreme Lord?

Aténdriyam means that we have to transcend these material senses before we can appreciate real happiness. Ramante yogino 'nante satyänanda-cid-ätmani: the yogés who are aspiring after spiritual life are also tasting enjoyment by focusing on the Supersoul within. If there is no pleasure, if there is no enjoyment, then what is the point of going to so much trouble to control the senses? What kind of pleasure are the yogés relishing if they are taking so much trouble? That pleasure is ananta—endless. How is this? The spirit soul is eternal, and the Supreme Lord is eternal; therefore reciprocation of their loving exchanges is eternal. One who is actually intelligent will refrain from the flickering sensual enjoyment of this material body and fix his enjoyment in spiritual life. His participation in spiritual life with the Supreme Lord is called räsa-lélä.

We have often heard of Kåñëa's räsa-lélä with the cowherd girls in Våndävana. That is not like ordinary exchanges that take place between these material bodies. Rather it is an exchange of feelings through spiritual bodies. One has to be somewhat intelligent to understand this, for a foolish man, who cannot understand what real happiness is, seeks happiness in this material world. In India there is the story of a man who did not know what sugarcane was and was told that it was very sweet to chew. "Oh, what does it look like?" he asked. "It looks just like a bamboo rod," someone said. So the foolish man began to chew all kinds of bamboo rods. How can he begin to experience the sweetness of sugarcane? Similarly, we are trying to get happiness and pleasure, but we are trying for them by chewing this material body; therefore there is no happiness and no pleasure. For the time being there may be some little feeling of pleasure, but that is not actual pleasure, for it is temporary. It is like a show of lightning which we may see flashing in the sky that may momentarily seem like lightning, but the real lightning is beyond that. Because a person does not really know what happiness is, he deviates from real happiness.

The process for establishing oneself in real happiness is this process of Kåñëa consciousness. By Kåñëa consciousness we can gradually develop our real intelligence and naturally enjoy relishing spiritual happiness as we make spiritual progress. As we begin to relish spiritual happiness, we proportionately abandon material happiness. As we make progress in understanding the Absolute Truth, we naturally become detached from this false happiness. If somehow or other one is promoted to that stage of Kåñëa consciousness, what is the result?

yaà labdhvä cäparaà läbhaà
manyate nädhikaà tataù
yasmin sthito na duùkhena
guruëäpi vicälyate

"Upon gaining this, he thinks there is no greater gain. Being situated in such a position, one is never shaken, even in the midst of greatest difficulty." (Bg. 6.22)

When one attains that stage, other achievements appear insignificant. In this material world we are trying to achieve so many things—riches, women, fame, beauty, knowledge, etc.—but as soon as we are situated in Kåñëa consciousness we think, "Oh, no achievement is better than this." Kåñëa consciousness is so potent that a little taste can save one from the greatest danger. As one begins to relish the taste of Kåñëa consciousness, he begins to see other so-called enjoyments and attainments as flat and tasteless. And if one is situated firmly in Kåñëa consciousness, the greatest danger cannot disturb him. There are so many dangers in life because the material world is a place of danger. We tend to close our eyes to this, and because we are foolish we try to adjust to these dangers. We may have many dangerous moments in our lives, but if we are training ourselves in Kåñëa consciousness and preparing ourselves to go home, back to Godhead, we will not care for them. Our attitude will then be: "Dangers come and go—so let them happen." It is very difficult to make this kind of adjustment as long as one is on the materialistic platform and is identifying with the gross body, which is composed of perishable elements. But the more one advances in Kåñëa consciousness, the more he becomes free from bodily designations and this material entanglement.

In Çrémad-Bhägavatam the material world is compared to a great ocean. Within this material universe there are millions and billions of planets floating in space, and we can just imagine how many Atlantic and Pacific Oceans are there. In fact, the whole material universe is likened to a great ocean of misery, an ocean of birth and death. In order to cross this great ocean of nescience, a strong boat is needed, and that strong boat is the lotus feet of Kåñëa. We should immediately get aboard that boat. We should not hesitate, thinking that Kåñëa's feet are very small. The whole universe is simply resting on His leg. For one who takes shelter of His feet, it is said that the material universe is no more significant than a puddle of water found in the impression of a calf's hoof-print. There is certainly no difficulty in crossing over such a small puddle.

taà vidyäd duùkha-saàyoga-
viyogam yoga-saàjïitam

"This indeed is actual freedom from all miseries arising from material contact." (Bg. 6.23)

We are entangled in this material world due to uncontrolled senses. The yoga process is meant to control these senses. If somehow we can manage to control the senses, we can turn our face to actual spiritual happiness and make our lives successful.

sa niçcayena yoktavyo
yogo 'nirviëëa-cetasä

saìkalpa-prabhavän kämäàs
tyaktvä sarvän açeñataù
manasaivendriya-grämaà
viniyamya samantataù

çanaiù çanair uparamed
buddhyä dhåti-gåhétayä
ätma-saàsthaà manaù kåtvä
na kiïcid api cintayet

yato yato niçcalati
manaç caïcalam asthiram
tatas tato niyamyaitad
ätmany eva vaçaà nayet

"One should engage oneself in the practice of yoga with undeviating determination and faith. One should abandon, without exception, all material desires born of false ego and thus control all the senses on all sides by the mind. Gradually, step by step, with full conviction, one should become situated in trance by means of intelligence, and thus the mind should be fixed on the Self alone and should think of nothing else. From whatever and wherever the mind wanders due to its flickering and unsteady nature, one must certainly withdraw it and bring it back under the control of the Self." (Bg. 6.24-26)

The mind is always disturbed. It is going sometimes this way and sometimes that way. By yoga practice we literally drag the mind to Kåñëa consciousness. The mind strays from Kåñëa consciousness to so many exterior objects because from time immemorial, life after life, that has been our practice. Due to this, there may be great difficulty in the beginning when one tries to fix his mind in Kåñëa consciousness, but these difficulties can all be overcome.

It is because the mind is agitated and not fixed on Kåñëa that it goes from one thought to another. For instance, when we are engaged in work, memories of events that happened ten, twenty, thirty or forty years ago may suddenly come to our mind for no apparent reason. These thoughts come from our subconscious, and because they are always rising, the mind is always agitated. If we agitate a lake or a pond, all the mud from the bottom comes to the surface. Similarly, when the mind is agitated so many thoughts arise from the subconscious that have been stored there over the years. If we do not disturb a pond, the mud will settle to the bottom. This yoga process is the means to quiet the mind and allow all these thoughts to settle. For this reason there are so many rules and regulations to follow in order to keep the mind from becoming agitated. If we follow the rules and regulations, gradually the mind will come under control. There are so many don't's and so many do's, and if one is serious about training the mind, he has to follow them. If he acts whimsically, what is the possibility of the mind being controlled? When the mind is finally trained to the point where it will think of nothing but Kåñëa, it will attain peace and will become very tranquil.

praçänta-manasaà hy enaà
yoginaà sukham uttamam
upaiti çänta-rajasaà
brahma-bhütam akalmañam

"The yogé whose mind is fixed on Me verily attains the highest happiness. By virtue of his identity with Brahman, he is liberated; his mind is peaceful, his passions are quieted, and he is freed from sin." (Bg. 6.27)

The mind is always concocting objects for happiness. I am always thinking, "This will make me happy," or "That will make me happy. Happiness is here. Happiness is there." In this way the mind is taking us anywhere and everywhere. It is as though we are riding on a chariot behind an unbridled horse. We have no power over where we are going but can only sit in horror and watch helplessly. As soon as the mind is engaged in the Kåñëa consciousness process—specifically by chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare—then the wild horses of the mind will gradually come under our control. We must engage in Kåñëa's service every moment of our lives in order to keep the restless and turbulent mind from dragging us from one object to another in a vain search for happiness in the temporary material world.

yuïjann evaà sadätmänaà
yogé vigata-kalmañaù
sukhena brahma-saàsparçam
atyantaà sukham açnute

"Steady in the Self, being freed from all material contamination, the yogé achieves the highest perfectional stage of happiness in touch with the supreme consciousness." (Bg. 6.28)

Kåñëa serves as a patron for one who is devoted to Him. When one is in difficulty, his patron saves him. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa is the real friend of every living entity, and we have to revive our friendship with Him. The method for reviving this friendship is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. By practice of Kåñëa consciousness, mundane passionate hankering will come to a stop. This passionate hankering keeps us divorced from Kåñëa. Kåñëa is within us and is waiting for us to turn to Him, but we are too busy passionately eating the fruits of the tree of material desire. This passionate compulsion to enjoy these fruits must stop, and we must situate ourselves in our real identity as Brahman—pure spirit.

OWK 2: The Way of Chanting and Knowing Kåñëa

2
The Way of Chanting and Knowing Kåñëa

[660722BG.NY]

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. This is transcendental sound vibration. It will help us to cleanse the dust from the mirror of the mind. At the present moment we have accumulated so much material dust on the mirror of the mind, just as on Second Avenue (New York City) there is dust and soot over everything due to the heavy traffic. Due to our manipulation of material activities, a great deal of dust has collected over our mind's clear mirror, and as a consequence we are unable to see things in perspective. This vibration of transcendental sound (the Hare Kåñëa mantra) will cleanse away this dust and enable us to see clearly our real constitutional position. As soon as we come to understand "I am not this body; I am spirit soul, and my symptom is consciousness," we will be able to establish ourselves in real happiness. As our consciousness is purified by this process of chanting Hare Kåñëa, all our material miseries will disappear. There is a fire that is always blazing over this material world, and everyone is trying to extinguish it, but there is no possibility of extinguishing this fire of the miseries of material nature unless we are situated in our pure consciousness, in our spiritual life.

One of the purposes for Lord Kåñëa's descent or appearance in this material world is to extinguish the fire of material existence for all living entities by setting forth the dharma.

yadä yadä hi dharmasya
glänir bhavati bhärata
abhyutthänam adharmasya
tadätmänaà såjämyaham

pariträëäya sädhünäà
vinäçäya ca duñkåtäm
dharma-saàsthäpanärthäya
sambhavämi yuge yuge

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time I descend Myself. In order to deliver the pious and to annihilate the miscreants, as well as to reestablish the principles of religion, I advent Myself millennium after millennium." (Bg. 4.7-8)

In this verse the word dharma is used. This word has been translated into English in various ways. Sometimes it is translated as "faith," but according to Vedic literature, dharma is not a kind of faith. Faith may change, but dharma cannot be changed. The liquidity of water cannot be changed. If it is changed—if, for instance, water becomes solid—it is actually no longer in its constitutional position. It is existing under a certain qualifying condition. Our dharma or constitutional position is that we are part and parcel of the Supreme, and this being the case, we have to dovetail or subjugate our consciousness to the Supreme.

This position of transcendental service to the Supreme Whole is being misused due to material contact. Service is implicit in our constitutional position. Everyone is a servant, and no one is a master. Everyone is serving someone or other. Although the President may be the chief executive of the state; still he is serving the state, and when his services are no longer required, the state disposes of him. To think to oneself, "I am the master of all I survey," is called mäyä, illusion. Thus in material consciousness our service is being misused under various designations. When we can become free from these designations, that is to say when the dust has been cleared from the mirror of the mind, we will be able to see ourselves in our actual position as eternal servants of Kåñëa.

One should not think that his service in the material world and his service in the spiritual atmosphere are the same. We may shudder to think, "Oh, after liberation will I still be a servant?" This is because we have experience that being a servant in the material world is not very enjoyable, but transcendental service is not like this. In the spiritual world there is no difference between the servant and the master. Here, of course, there is distinction, but in the absolute world everything is one. For instance, in Bhagavad-gétä we can see that Kåñëa has taken the position of servant as the chariot driver of Arjuna. In his constitutional position, Arjuna is the servant of Kåñëa, but in behavior we can see that sometimes the Lord becomes the servant of the servant [Padyävalé 74]. So we should be careful not to carry materialistic ideas into the spiritual realm. Whatever we have materially experienced is but a perverted reflection of things in spiritual life.

When our constitutional position or dharma is deteriorated due to the contaminations of matter, the Lord Himself comes as an incarnation or sends some of His confidential servitors. Lord Jesus Christ called himself the "son of God," and so is a representative of the Supreme. Similarly, Mohammed identified himself as a servant of the Supreme Lord. Thus whenever there is a discrepancy in our constitutional position, the Supreme Lord either comes Himself or sends His representative to inform us of the real position of the living entity.

Therefore, one should not make the mistake of thinking that dharma is a created faith. In its proper sense, dharma cannot be divorced from the living entity at all. It is to the living entity what sweetness is to sugar, or saltiness is to salt, or solidity is to stone. In no case can it be cut off. The dharma of the living entity is to serve, and we can easily see that every living entity has the tendency to serve himself or others. How to serve Kåñëa, how to disentangle ourselves from materialistic service, how to attain Kåñëa consciousness and become free from material designations is all taught as a science by Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä.

The word sädhu in the verse quoted above, beginning pariträëäya sädhünäm (Bg. 4.8) refers to a holy man or a saintly person. A saintly person is tolerant, very kind to everyone, is a friend to all living entities, is no one's enemy and is always peaceful. There are twenty-six basic qualifications for a holy man, and in the Bhagavad-gétä we find that Çré Kåñëa Himself gives the following verdict:

api cet suduräcäro
bhajate mäm ananya-bhäk
sädhur eva sa mantavyaù
samyag vyavasito hi saù

"Even if one commits the most abominable actions, if he is engaged in devotional service, he is to be considered saintly because he is properly situated." (Bg. 9.30)

On the mundane platform, what is morality for one person is immorality for another, and what is immorality for one person is morality for another. According to the Hindu conception, the drinking of wine is immoral, whereas in the Western world, wine drinking is not considered immoral but is a common thing. So morality is dependent on time, place, circumstance, social position, etc. There is, however, a sense of morality and immorality in all societies. In this verse Kåñëa points out that even if one is engaged in immoral acts but at the same time is fully in Kåñëa consciousness, he is to be considered a sädhu or a saint. In other words, although a person may have some immoral habits due to his past association, if he is engaged fully in Kåñëa consciousness, these habits are not to be considered important. Whatever the case, if one becomes Kåñëa conscious, he will gradually be purified and will become a sädhu. As one progresses in executing Kåñëa consciousness, his bad habits diminish, and he attains to saintly perfection.

In this regard there is the story of a thief who went on a pilgrimage to a holy town, and on route he and the other pilgrims stopped to rest overnight at an inn. Being addicted to stealing, the thief began making plans to steal the other pilgrims' baggage, but he thought, "I'm going on a pilgrimage, so it doesn't seem appropriate that I should steal this baggage. No, I shall not do it." Nonetheless, due to his habit, he could not keep his hands off the baggage. So he picked up one person's bag and placed it in another place, and then another person's bag and placed it elsewhere. He spent all night placing different bags in different places, but his conscience bothered him so that he could not take anything from them. In the morning, when the other pilgrims awoke, they looked around for their bags and couldn't find them. There was a great row, and eventually, one by one, they began to find the bags in various places. After they were all found, the thief explained: "Gentlemen, I am a thief by occupation. Being that I am habituated to stealing at night, I wanted to steal something from your bags, but I thought that since I am going to this holy place, it is not possible to steal. So I may have rearranged the baggage, but please excuse me." This is the characteristic of a bad habit. He does not want to commit theft anymore, but because he is habituated, sometimes he does. Thus Kåñëa says that one who has decided to refrain from his immoral habits and make progress in Kåñëa consciousness is to be considered a sädhu, even if out of past habit or by chance he yields to his fault.

In the next verse we find that Çré Kåñëa says:

kñipraà bhavati dharmätmä
çaçvac-chäntià nigacchati
kaunteya pratijänéhi
na me bhaktaù praëaçyati

"He quickly becomes righteous and attains lasting peace. O son of Kunté, declare it boldly that My devotee never perishes." (Bg. 9.31)

Because one has committed himself to Kåñëa consciousness, it is proclaimed here by Çré Kåñëa that within a very short time he will become saintly. One may pull the plug out of an electric fan, and the fan may still go on even though the juice has been disconnected, but it is understood that the fan will soon come to a stop. Once we take shelter of the lotus feet of Kåñëa, we turn the switch off for our karmic activities, and although these activities may still revolve, it is to be understood that they will quickly diminish. It is a fact that whoever takes to Kåñëa consciousness does not have to endeavor independently to become a good man. All the good qualifications will automatically come. It is stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam that one who has attained Kåñëa consciousness has simultaneously attained all good qualities. On the other hand, if a person is devoid of God consciousness and yet has many good qualities, his good qualities are to be considered useless, for he will not in any way be prohibited from doing that which is undesirable. If one is devoid of Kåñëa consciousness, he is sure to commit mischief in this material world.

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9)

The mission for which Kåñëa appears is here further explained. When He comes with some mission, there are some activities. Of course there are some philosophers who do not believe that God comes as an incarnation. They say, "Why should God come to this rotten world?" But from Bhagavad-gétä we understand otherwise. We should always remember that we read Bhagavad-gétä as scripture, and whatever is spoken in Bhagavad-gétä must be accepted, otherwise there is no reason in reading it. In Gétä Kåñëa says that He has come as an incarnation with a mission, and along with His mission there are some activities. We can see, for example, that Kåñëa is active as chariot-driver for Arjuna and engages in so many activities on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. Just as when there is war one person or nation may side with another person or nation and show partiality, Lord Kåñëa on the battlefield shows some partiality and sides with Arjuna. Actually Kåñëa is not partial to anyone, but externally it appears that He is partial. This partiality, however, should not be accepted in the ordinary sense.

In this verse Kåñëa also points out that His descent into the material world is transcendental. The word divyam means transcendental. His activities are not in any way ordinary. Even today, in India, at the end of August the people are accustomed to celebrating Kåñëa's birthday, regardless of sect, just as in the Western world Jesus Christ's birthday is celebrated at Christmas. Kåñëa's birthday is called Janmäñöamé, and in this verse Kåñëa uses the word janma in referring to "My birth." Because there is birth, there are some activities. Kåñëa's birth and activities are transcendental, which means they are not like ordinary births and activities. One may ask how it is that His activities are transcendental. He is born, He takes part in a battle with Arjuna, he has a father by the name of Vasudeva and a mother Devaké and a family—what can be considered transcendental? Kåñëa says, evaà yo vetti tattvataù—we must know of His birth and activities in truth. When one knows of Kåñëa's birth and activities in truth, the result is: tyaktvä dehaà punar janma naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna—when he leaves this material body, he is not born again but goes directly to Kåñëa. This means that he becomes a liberated soul. He goes to the eternal spiritual world and attains his constitutional position full of bliss, knowledge and eternality. All this can be obtained simply by knowing in truth the transcendental nature of Kåñëa's birth and activities.

Ordinarily when one quits the body he has to take up another body. The lives of the living entities are going on simply due to the living entities' changing dress from one body to another—transmigration of the soul—according to the work of the living entities. At the present moment we may think that this material body is our actual body, but it is like a dress. In reality we do have an actual body, a spiritual body. This material body is superficial compared to the real spiritual body of the living entity. When this material body becomes old and worn out, or when it is rendered useless by some accident, we put it aside as we might put aside a soiled or ruined suit and take up another material body.

väsäàsi jérëäni yathä vihäya
naväni gåhëäti naro 'paräëi
tathä çaréräëi vihäya jérëäny
anyäni saàyäti naväni dehé

"As a person puts on new garments, giving up old ones, similarly, the soul accepts new material bodies, giving up the old and useless ones." (Bg. 2.22)

In the beginning the body is the size of a pea. Then it grows to become a baby, then a child, a young boy, a youth, a grown man and an old man, and finally, when it becomes useless, the living entity changes into another body. The body is therefore always changing, and death is simply the ultimate change of the present body.

dehino 'smin yathä dehe
kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä
tathä dehäntara-präptir
dhéras tatra na muhyati

"As the embodied soul continually passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. The self-realized soul is not bewildered by such a change." (Bg. 2.13)

Although the body is changing, the dweller within the body remains the same. Although the boy grows into manhood, the living entity within the body is not changed. It is not that the self who was there as a boy has gone away. Medical science agrees that at every moment the material body is changing. Just as living entities are not bewildered by this, an enlightened man is not bewildered when the body undergoes its ultimate change at death. But a person who does not understand things as they are laments. In the material condition we are simply changing bodies all the time; that is our disease. It is not that we always change to a human body. We may change to an animal body or a demigod body depending on our activities. According to the Padma Puräëa there are 8,400,000 species of life. We can take on any of them at death. But Kåñëa promises that one who knows His birth and activities in truth is freed from this cycle of transmigration.

How does one understand Kåñëa's birth and activities in truth? This is explained in the Eighteenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä:

bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti
yävän yaç cäsmi tattvataù
tato mäà tattvato jïätvä
viçate tad-anantaram

"One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service. And when one is in full consciousness of the Supreme Lord by such devotion, he can enter into the kingdom of God." (Bg. 18.55)

Here again the word tattvataù, "in truth," is used. One can understand the science of Kåñëa in truth by becoming a devotee. He who is not a devotee, who does not strive for Kåñëa consciousness, cannot understand. At the beginning of the Fourth Chapter also Kåñëa tells Arjuna [Bg. 4.3] that He is explaining this ancient science of yoga to him because Arjuna is "My devotee and My friend." For one who simply makes an academic study of Bhagavad-gétä, the science of Kåñëa remains a mystery. Bhagavad-gétä is not a book that one can just purchase from the bookstore and understand by scholarship alone. Arjuna was not a great scholar, nor a Vedäntist, nor a philosopher nor a brähmaëa, nor a renunciate; he was a family and military man. But still Kåñëa selected him to be the recipient of Bhagavad-gétä and the first authority in the disciplic succession. Why? "Because you are My devotee." That is the qualification to understand Bhagavad-gétä as it is and Kåñëa as He is—one must become Kåñëa conscious.

And what is this Kåñëa consciousness? That is the process of cleansing the dust from the mirror of the mind through the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. By chanting this mantra and by hearing Bhagavad-gétä, we can gradually attain to Kåñëa consciousness. Éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäm—Kåñëa is always present within our heart. The individual soul and the Supersoul are both sitting in the tree of the body. The individual soul (jéva) is eating the fruit of the tree, and the Supersoul (Paramätmä) is witnessing. As the individual soul begins the process of devotional service and gradually begins to develop his Kåñëa consciousness, the Supersoul who is seated within begins to help him dust all the impurities from the mirror of the mind. Kåñëa is a friend to all saintly persons, and the attempt to become Kåñëa conscious is a saintly endeavor. Çravaëam kértanam [Bhäg. 7.5.23]—by chanting and hearing one can come to understand the science of Kåñëa and thereby come to understand Kåñëa. And upon understanding Kåñëa, one can, at the moment of death, go immediately to His abode in the spiritual world. This spiritual world is described thus in Bhagavad-gétä:

na tad bhäsayate süryo
na çaçäìko na pävakaù
yad gatvä na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"That abode of Mine is not illumined by the sun or moon, nor by electricity. One who reaches it never returns to this material world." (Bg. 15.6)

This material world is always dark; therefore we require the sun, moon and electricity. The Vedas enjoin us not to remain in this darkness but to transfer ourselves to the world of illumination, the spiritual world. The word darkness has a twofold meaning; it not only means without light, but it means ignorance.

The Supreme Lord has manifold energies. It is not that he comes to this material world to perform activities. It is stated in the Vedas that the Supreme Lord has nothing to do. In Bhagavad-gétä Çré Kåñëa also says:

na me pärthästi kartavyaà
triñu lokeñu kiïcana
nänaväptam aväptavyaà
varta eva ca karmaëi

"O son of Påthä, there is no work prescribed for Me within all the three planetary systems. Nor am I in want of anything, nor have I need to obtain anything—and yet I am engaged in work." (Bg. 3.22)

We should therefore not think that Kåñëa is required to descend upon this material world and engage in so many activities. No one is equal to or greater than Kåñëa, and He has all knowledge naturally. It is not that He has to undergo penances to acquire knowledge or that He at any time has to receive knowledge or attain knowledge. At all times and in all conditions He is full of knowledge. He may be speaking Bhagavad-gétä to Arjuna, but at no time was He ever taught Bhagavad-gétä. One who can understand that this is Kåñëa's position does not have to return to the cycle of birth and death in this material world. Being under the influence of illusion, we spend our lifetimes trying to make adjustments to this material atmosphere, but this is not the purpose of human life. Human life is meant for understanding the science of Kåñëa.

Our material needs are these: the problem of eating, of mating, of sleeping, of defending ourselves and of acquiring sense gratification. These are common both to human beings and to animals. The animals are busily engaged trying to solve these problems, and if we are also only engaged in solving them how are we any different from the animals? The human being, however, has a special qualification whereby he can develop transcendental Kåñëa consciousness, but if he does not avail himself of this, he is in the animal category. The defect of modern civilization is that it puts too much stress on solving these survival problems. As spiritual living beings it is incumbent upon us to extricate ourselves from this entanglement of birth and death. We should therefore be careful not to miss the special opportunity of human life. Çré Kåñëa Himself comes to deliver Bhagavad-gétä and to help us to become God conscious. Indeed, this very material creation is given to us to utilize for this cultivation. But if after receiving this chance and this gift of human life we do not utilize them to develop Kåñëa consciousness, we shall be missing this rare opportunity. The process for cultivation is very simple: çravaëam kértanam [Bhäg. 7.5.23]—hearing and chanting. We have nothing to do other than listen, and by listening carefully, enlightenment is sure to come. Kåñëa will surely help, for He is seated within. We only have to make the effort and spare a little time. We will not need anyone to ask us whether we are making progress. We will know it automatically, just as a hungry man knows that he has been satisfied by a full meal.

Actually this process of Kåñëa consciousness or self-realization is not very difficult. Kåñëa taught it to Arjuna in Bhagavad-gétä, and if we understand Bhagavad-gétä just as Arjuna did, we will have no problem in coming to the perfectional state. But if we try to interpret Bhagavad-gétä according to our own mundane academic mentality, we spoil it all.

As stated before, this chanting of Hare Kåñëa is a process by which all contaminations due to material association are removed from the mirror of the mind. There is no need for external help in reviving our Kåñëa consciousness, for Kåñëa consciousness is dormant within the self. In fact, it is the very quality of the self. We have only to invoke it by this process. Kåñëa consciousness is an eternal fact. It is not a doctrine or set of beliefs imposed by some organization. It is within all living entities, whether they be human being or animal. When Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu was passing through the jungles of South India some five hundred years ago, He chanted Hare Kåñëa, and all the animals—the tigers, elephants and deer—joined Him in dancing to the holy names. Of course this depends on the purity of the chanting. As we progress in chanting, purification is sure to come.

OWK 3: Seeing Kåñëa Everywhere and Always

3
Seeing Kåñëa Everywhere and Always

[660805BG.NY] & [661002BG.NY]

In our practical life, Kåñëa instructs us how to invoke Kåñëa consciousness. It is not that we are to stop executing our duty or to cease from activity. Rather, activities have to be conducted in Kåñëa consciousness. Everyone has a vocation in life, but with what consciousness does he enter upon it? Everyone is thinking, "Oh, I must have a vocation in order to maintain my family." Society, the government or the family have to be satisfied, and no one is free from such consciousness. One has to be in proper consciousness to execute any activity nicely. He whose consciousness is agitated, who is like a madman, cannot execute any duty. We should execute our duty properly, but we should do it thinking to satisfy Kåñëa. It is not that we have to change our process of work, but we do have to understand for whom we are working. Whatever activity we have to do we must execute, but we should not be carried away by käma, desire. The Sanskrit word käma is used to indicate lust, desire or sense satisfaction. Çré Kåñëa instructs that we should not work for the satisfaction of käma or our own lust. The whole teaching of Bhagavad-gétä is based on this principle.

Arjuna wanted to satisfy his senses by refraining from fighting with his relatives, but Kåñëa spoke to him to convince him to execute his duty for the satisfaction of the Supreme. Materially it may seem very pious that he is giving up his claim for a kingdom and refusing to kill his relatives, but Kåñëa did not approve of this because the principle for Arjuna's decision was to satisfy his own senses. One's business or occupation need not be changed—as Arjuna's was not changed—but one does have to change his consciousness. In order to change this consciousness, however, knowledge is required. That knowledge is knowing "I am part and parcel of Kåñëa, the superior energy of Kåñëa." That is real knowledge. Relative knowledge may teach us how to repair a machine, but real knowledge is knowing our position as being integral with Kåñëa. Being part of Him, our pleasure, which is partial, is dependent on the whole. For instance, my hand can take pleasure when it is attached to my body and serves it. It does not take pleasure in serving another's body. Because we are part of Kåñëa, our pleasure is in serving Him. "I cannot be happy serving you," everyone is thinking. "I can only be happy serving myself." But no one knows who the self is. That self is Kåñëa.

mamaiväàço jéva-loke
jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù
manaù ñañöhänéndriyäëi
prakåti-sthäni karñati

"The living entities in this conditioned world are My eternal, fragmental parts. Due to conditioned life, they are struggling very hard with the six senses, which include the mind." (Bg. 15.7)

The jévas, or living entities, are now detached from the whole due to material contact. It is therefore necessary for us to strive to attach ourselves again through the latent Kåñëa consciousness that is within us. Artificially, we are trying to forget Kåñëa and live independently, but this is not possible. When we strive to live independent of Kåñëa, we come under the influence of the laws of material nature. If one thinks he is independent of Kåñëa, he becomes dependent on the illusory energy of Kåñëa, just as if one thinks that he is independent of the government and its regulations, he becomes dependent on the police force. Everyone is trying to become independent, and this is called mäyä, illusion. Individually, communally, socially, nationally, or universally, it is not possible to become independent. When we come to realize that we are dependent, we will have attained knowledge. Today so many people are striving for peace in the world, but they do not know how to implement that peace formula. The United Nations has been striving for peace for so many years, but still war is going on.

yac cäpi sarva-bhütänäm
béjaà tad aham arjuna
na tad asti vinä yat syän
mayä bhütaà caräcaram

"Furthermore, O Arjuna, I am the generating seed of all existences. There is no being—moving or unmoving—that can exist without Me." (Bg. 10.39)

Kåñëa is thus the proprietor of everything, the ultimate beneficiary and the receiver of the results of everything. We may consider ourselves to be the proprietors of the fruits of our labor, but this is a misconception. We must come to understand that Kåñëa is the ultimate proprietor of the fruits of all our works. Hundreds of people may be working in an office, but they understand that whatever profit the business makes belongs to the proprietor. As soon as a teller at the bank thinks, "Oh, I have so much money. I am the proprietor. Let me take it home with me," his trouble begins. If we think that we can use whatever wealth we have amassed for our own sense gratification, we are acting out of käma, lust. But if we come to understand that everything we have belongs to Kåñëa, we are liberated. We may have the same money in our hands, but as soon as we think that we are the proprietor, we are under the influence of mäyä. One who is situated in the consciousness that everything belongs to Kåñëa is an actual learned man.

éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà
yat kiïca jagatyäà jagat
tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä
mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam

"Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one must not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong." (Çré Éçopaniñad, Mantra 1)

This consciousness of éçäväsya—everything belongs to Kåñëa—must be revived, not only individually but nationally and universally. Then there will be peace. We often tend to be philanthropic and altruistic, and we strive to be friends with our countrymen, with our families and with all the peoples of the world—but this is based on a wrong conception. The real friend is Kåñëa, and if we want to benefit our family, nation or planet, we will work for Him. If we have our family's welfare in mind, we will try to make all members Kåñëa conscious. There are so many men trying to benefit their families, but unfortunately they do not succeed. They do not know what the real problem is.

As the Bhägavatam says, one should not attempt to become a father, or mother, or teacher unless he is able to save his children from death, from the grip of material nature. The father should be in knowledge of Kåñëa, and he should be determined that the innocent children who are entrusted to him will not have to undergo the cycle of birth and death again. He should be resolved to train his children in such a way that they will no longer have to be subjected to the painful cycle of birth and death. But before one can do this, he has to make himself expert. If he becomes expert in Kåñëa consciousness, he can help not only his children but his society and nation. But if he himself is bound by ignorance, how can he unite others who are similarly bound? Before one can make others free, he must be free himself. Actually no one is a free man, for everyone is under the spell of material nature, but one who is surrendered to Kåñëa cannot be touched by mäyä. He, of all men, is free. If one places himself in sunlight, there is no question of darkness. But if one places himself in artificial light, it may flicker and go out. Kåñëa is just like sunlight. Where He is present, there is no question of darkness and ignorance. The wise men, the mahätmäs, understand this.

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate
iti matvä bhajante mäà
budhä bhäva-samanvitäù

"I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts." (Bg. 10.8)

In this verse the word budha is used, which indicates a wise man or one who is learned. What is his symptom? He knows that Kåñëa is the fountainhead of everything, of all emanations. He knows that whatever he sees is but an emanation of Kåñëa. In the material world, sex life is the most prominent factor. Sexual attraction is found in all species of life, and one may ask where it comes from. The wise man understands that this tendency is in Kåñëa and that it is revealed in His relationships with the damsels of Vraja. Whatever is found in this material world can also be found in perfection in Kåñëa. The difference is that in the material world everything is manifest in a perverted form. In Kåñëa all of these tendencies and manifestations exist in pure consciousness, in spirit. One who knows this, in full knowledge, becomes a pure devotee of Kåñëa.

mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha
daivéà prakåtim äçritäù
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jïätvä bhütädim avyayam

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate

"O son of Påthä, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible. Always chanting My glories, endeavoring with great determination, bowing down before Me, these great souls perpetually worship Me with devotion." (Bg. 9.13-14).

Who is the great soul, the mahätmä? It is he who is under the influence of the superior energy. At present we are under the influence of Kåñëa's inferior energy. As living entities, our position is marginal—we can transfer ourselves to either of the two energies. Kåñëa is fully independent, and because we are part and parcel of Him we also have this quality of independence. Therefore we have a choice as to which energy we will function under. Because we are ignorant of the superior nature, we have no alternative but to remain in the inferior nature.

Some philosophies propound that there is no nature other than the one we are presently experiencing and that the only solution to this is to nullify it and become void. But we cannot be void because we are living entities. It does not mean that we are finished just because we change our bodies. Before we can get out from the influence of material nature, we have to understand where our place actually is, where we are to go. If we do not know where to go, then we will simply say, "Oh, we do not know what is superior and inferior. All we know is this, so let us stay here and rot." Bhagavad-gétä however, gives us information of the superior energy, the superior nature.

What Kåñëa speaks, He speaks for all eternity; it does not change. It does not matter what our present occupation is or what Arjuna's occupation was—we only have to change our consciousness. At present we are guided by the consciousness of self-interest, but we do not know what our real self-interest is. Actually we do not have self-interest, but sense interest. Whatever we are doing, we are doing to satisfy the senses. It is this consciousness that has to be changed. In its place we must implant our real self-interest—Kåñëa consciousness.

How is this done? How is it possible to become Kåñëa conscious in every step of our life? Actually Kåñëa makes it very easy for us:

raso 'ham apsu kaunteya
prabhäsmi çaçi-süryayoù
praëavaù sarva-vedeñu
çabdaù khe pauruñaà nåñu

"O son of Kunté [Arjuna], I am the taste of water, the light of the sun and the moon, the syllable oà in the Vedic mantras; I am the sound in ether and ability in man." (Bg. 7.8)

In this verse Çré Kåñëa is describing how we can become Kåñëa conscious fully, in all stages of life. All living entities must drink water. The taste of water is so nice that when we are thirsty nothing but water seems to do. No manufacturer can create the pure taste of water. We can thus remember Kåñëa or God when we drink water. No one can avoid drinking water every day of his life, so God consciousness is there—how can we forget?

Similarly, when there is some illumination, that is also Kåñëa. The original effulgence in the spiritual sky, the brahmajyoti, emanates from the body of Kåñëa. This material sky is covered. The very nature of the material universe is darkness, which we experience at night. It is being artificially illuminated by the sun, by the reflected light of the moon, and by electricity. Where is this illumination coming from? The sun is being illumined by the brahmajyoti, or the bright effulgence of the spiritual world. In the spiritual world there is no need for sun, moon or electricity because there everything is illuminated by the brahmajyoti. On this earth, however, we can remember Kåñëa whenever we see some illumination from the sun.

When we chant the Vedic mantras which begin with oà, we can also remember Kåñëa. Oà, like Hare Kåñëa, is also an address to God, and oà is also Kåñëa. Çabdaù means sound, and whenever we hear any sound we should know that it is a vibration of the original sound, the pure spiritual sound oà or Hare Kåñëa. Whatever sound we hear in the material world is but a reflection of that original spiritual sound oà. In this way when we hear sound, when we drink water, when we see some illumination, we can remember God. If we can do this, then when will we not remember God? This is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. In this way we can remember Kåñëa twenty-four hours a day, and in this way Kåñëa is with us. Of course Kåñëa is always with us, but as soon as we remember this, His presence is factual and is felt.

There are nine different processes for associating with God, and the first method of association is çravaëam—hearing. By reading Bhagavad-gétä we hear the speeches of Çré Kåñëa, which means that we are actually associating with Kåñëa or God. (We should always remember that when we speak of Kåñëa, we refer to God.) Inasmuch as we associate with God and as we go on hearing the words of Kåñëa and His names, the contamination of material nature is reduced. In understanding that Kåñëa is sound, illumination, water, and so many other things, it becomes impossible to avoid Kåñëa. If we can remember Kåñëa in this way, our association with Him is permanent.

Association with Kåñëa is like association with sunshine. Where there is sunshine, there is no contamination. As long as one is out in the ultraviolet rays of the sun, he will not be diseased. In western medicine, sunshine is recommended for all kinds of diseases, and according to the Vedas a diseased man should worship the sun for cure. Similarly, if we associate with Kåñëa in Kåñëa consciousness, our maladies are cured. By chanting Hare Kåñëa we can associate with Kåñëa, and we can see the water as Kåñëa, the sun and the moon as Kåñëa, and we can hear Kåñëa in sound and taste Him in water. Unfortunately, in our present condition we have forgotten Kåñëa. But now we have to revive our spiritual life by remembering Him.

This process of çravaëaà kértanam—hearing and chanting—was approved by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. When Lord Caitanya was speaking with Rämänanda Räya, a friend of the Lord's and a great devotee, the Lord questioned him about the methods of spiritual realization. Rämänanda recommended varëäçrama-dharma, sannyäsa, the renunciation of work, and so many other methods, but Lord Caitanya said, "No, all of these are not so good." Each time Rämänanda Räya suggested something, Lord Caitanya rejected it, requesting a better method for spiritual development. Finally Rämänanda Räya quoted a Vedic aphorism which recommended that one give up all unnecessary endeavor in mental speculation for understanding God because by speculation it is not possible to arrive at the ultimate truth. Scientists, for instance, may speculate about distant stars and planets, but they can never come to any conclusions without experience. One may go on speculating throughout his life and never reach any conclusions.

It is especially useless to speculate about God. Therefore Çrémad-Bhägavatam recommends that all sorts of speculation should be given up. It is recommended instead that one become submissive, realizing that not only is he an insignificant creature, but that this earth is only one small point in the great universe. New York City may seem very large, but when one realizes that the earth is such a small spot, and that on the earth the United States is just another small spot, and that in the United States New York City is but a small spot, and that in New York the individual is only one out of millions, then one can understand that he is not so very important after all. Realizing our insignificance in the face of the universe and God, we should not be artificially puffed-up but should be submissive. We should be very careful not to fall prey to the frog philosophy. Once there was a frog in a well, and upon being informed of the existence of the Atlantic Ocean by a friend, he asked the friend, "Oh, what is this Atlantic Ocean?"

"It is a vast body of water," his friend replied.

"How vast? Is it double the size of this well?"

"Oh no, much much larger," his friend replied.

"How much larger? Ten times the size?" In this way the frog went on calculating. But what is the possibility of his ever understanding the depths and far reaches of the great ocean? Our faculties, experience, and powers of speculation are always limited. We can only give rise to such frog philosophy. Therefore Çrémad-Bhägavatam recommends that we give up the method of speculation as a waste of time in trying to understand the Supreme.

After giving up speculation, what should we do? Bhägavatam recommends that we become submissive and hear the message of God submissively. This message may be found also in the Bhagavad-gétä and other Vedic literatures, in the Bible or the Koran—in any bona fide scripture—or it may be heard from a realized soul. The main point is that one should not speculate but should simply hear about God. What will be the result of such hearing? Regardless of what one is—whether he be a poor or rich man, an American, European or Indian, a brähmaëa, çüdra or whatever—if one but hears the transcendental word of God, the Lord, who can never be conquered by any power or force, will be conquered by love. Arjuna was a friend of Kåñëa's, but Kåñëa, although the Supreme Godhead, became Arjuna's chariot driver, a menial servant. Arjuna loved Kåñëa, and Kåñëa reciprocated his love in this way. Similarly, when Kåñëa was a child, He playfully took the shoes of His father, Nanda Mahäräja, and put them on His head. People may try very hard to become one with God, but actually we can surpass that—we can become father of God. Of course God is the father of all creatures, and He has no father Himself, but He accepts His devotee, His lover, as a father. Kåñëa agrees to be conquered by His devotee out of love. All one has to do is hear the message of the Lord very carefully.

In the Seventh Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä Çré Kåñëa gives additional ways in which He can be perceived in every step of life:

puëyo gandhaù påthivyäà ca
tejaç cäsmi vibhävasau
jévanaà sarva-bhüteñu
tapaç cäsmi tapasviñu

"I am the original fragrance of the earth, and I am the heat in fire. I am the life of all that lives, and I am the penances of all ascetics." (Bg. 7.9)

The words puëyo gandhaù refer to fragrances. Only Kåñëa can create flavors and fragrances. We may synthetically create some scents or fragrances, but these are not as good as the originals that occur in nature. When we smell a good natural fragrance, we can think, "Oh, here is God. Here is Kåñëa." Or when we see some natural beauty, we can think, "Oh, here is Kåñëa." Or when we see something uncommon, powerful or wonderful, we can think, "Here is Kåñëa." Or when we see any form of life, whether it be in a tree, in a plant, or an animal or in a human being, we should understand that this life is part and parcel of Kåñëa, for as soon as the spiritual spark, which is part and parcel of Kåñëa, is taken away from the body, the body disintegrates.

béjaà mäà sarva-bhütänäà
viddhi pärtha sanätanam
buddhir buddhimatäm asmi
tejas tejasvinäm aham

"O son of Påthä, know that I am the original seed of all existences, the intelligence of the intelligent, and the prowess of all powerful men." (Bg. 7.10)

Here again it is explicitly stated that Kåñëa is the life of all that lives. Thus at every step we can see God. People may ask, "Can you show me God?" Yes, of course. God can be seen in so many ways. But if one closes his eyes and says, "I shall not see God," then how can He be shown?

In the above verse the word béjam means seed, and that seed is proclaimed to be eternal (sanätanam). One may see a huge tree, but what is the origin of this tree? It is the seed, and that seed is eternal. The seed of existence is within every living entity. The body itself may go through so many changes—it may develop within the mother's womb, come out as a small baby and grow through childhood and adulthood—but the seed of that existence that is within is permanent. Therefore it is sanätanam. Imperceivably we are changing our bodies at every moment, at every second. But the béjam, the seed, the spiritual spark, does not change. Kåñëa proclaims Himself to be this eternal seed within all existences. He is also the intelligence of an intelligent person. Without being favored by Kåñëa, one cannot become extraordinarily intelligent. Everyone is trying to be more intelligent than others, but without the favor of Kåñëa this is not possible. Therefore whenever we encounter someone with extraordinary intelligence we should think, "That intelligence is Kåñëa." Similarly, the influence of one who is very influential is also Kåñëa.

balaà balavatäà cähaà
käma-räga-vivarjitam
dharmäviruddho bhüteñu
kämo 'smi bharatarñabha

"I am the strength of the strong, devoid of passion and desire. I am sex life which is not contrary to religious principles, O Lord of the Bhäratas [Arjuna]." (Bg. 7.11)

The elephant and the gorilla are very strong animals, and we should understand that they get their strength from Kåñëa. The human being cannot acquire such strength by his own endeavor, but if Kåñëa so favors, a man can get strength to exceed the elephant thousands of times. The great warrior Bhéma, who fought in the battle of Kurukñetra, was said to have strength ten thousand times that of an elephant. Similarly, desire or lust (käma) which is not against religious principles should also be seen as Kåñëa. What is this lust? Lust generally means sex life, but here käma refers to sex life which is not against religious principles, that is to say, sex for the begetting of good children. If one can beget good Kåñëa conscious children, he can have sex thousands of times, but if he can only beget children who are raised in the consciousness of cats and dogs, his sex life is to be considered irreligious. In religious and civilized societies, marriage is intended as an indication that a couple is to engage in sex for begetting good children. Therefore married sex life is considered religious, and unmarried sex life is considered irreligious. Actually there is no difference between the sannyäsé and the householder provided that the householder's sexual activities are based on religious principles.

ye caiva sättvikä bhävä
rajasas tämasäç ca ye
matta eveti tän viddhi
na tv ahaà teñu te mayi

"All states of being—be they of goodness, passion or ignorance—are manifested by My energy. I am, in one sense, everything—but I am independent. I am not under the modes of this material nature." (Bg. 7.12)

One may question Kåñëa in this way: "You say You are sound, water, illumination, fragrance, the seed of all, strength, and käma, desire—does that mean that you exist simply in the mode of goodness?" In the material world there are the modes of goodness, passion and ignorance. Thus far, Kåñëa has described Himself as that which is good (for instance, sex in marriage according to religious principles). But what about the other modes? Does not Kåñëa exist in them? In answer, Kåñëa replies that whatever is seen in the material world is due to an interaction of three modes of material nature. Whatever can be observed is a combination of goodness, passion or ignorance, and in all cases these three states are "produced by Me." Because they are produced by Kåñëa, their position is in Him, but He is not in them, for Kåñëa Himself is transcendental to the three modes. Thus, in another sense, bad and evil things, which are produced out of ignorance, are also Kåñëa, when they are applied by Kåñëa. How is this? For example, an electrical engineer is producing electrical energy. In our homes we are experiencing this electrical energy as coldness in the refrigerator or heat in the electric stove, but at the power plant electrical energy is neither cold nor hot. The manifestations of this energy may be different for the living entities, but for Kåñëa they are not different. Therefore Kåñëa sometimes acts on what appears to be the principles of passion or ignorance, but for Kåñëa there is nothing but Kåñëa, just as for the electrical engineer electrical energy is simply electricity and nothing else. He makes no distinction that this is "cold electricity" or that is "hot electricity."

Everything is being generated by Kåñëa. Indeed, the Vedänta-sütra confirms: athäto brahma-jijïäsä janmädy asya yataù: everything is flowing from the Supreme Absolute Truth. What the living entity is considering to be bad or good is only so for the living entity, for he is conditioned. But because Kåñëa is not conditioned, for Him there is no question of bad or good. Because we are conditioned, we are suffering from dualities, but for Him everything is perfect.

OWK 4: The Roads of the Foolish and the Wise

4
The Roads of the Foolish and the Wise

[661002BG.NY] & [661007BG.NY] & [661009BG.NY]

Kåñëa is thus explaining Himself as He is. Yet we are not attracted to Him. Why is this? The reason is given by Kåñëa Himself:

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14)

The material world is pervaded by the three qualities of material nature. All living entities are influenced by these qualities. If they are primarily influenced by the mode of goodness, they are called brähmaëas, and if they are influenced by the mode of passion, they are called kñatriyas. If they are influenced by the modes of passion and ignorance, they are vaiçyas, and if they are influenced by ignorance, they are çüdras. This is not an artificial imposition due to birth or social status but is according to guëa, or the mode of nature under which one is operating.

cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöaà
guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù
tasya kartäram api mäà
viddhy akartäram avyayam

"According to the three modes of material nature and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me. And, although I am the creator of this system, you should know that I am yet the non-doer, being unchangeable." (Bg. 4.13)

It is not that this system refers to the perverted caste system in India. Çré Kåñëa specifically states: guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù: men are classified according to the guëa or the mode under which they are operating, and this applies to men all over the universe. When Kåñëa speaks, we must understand that whatever He says is not limited but is universally true. He claims to be the father of all living entities—even the animals, the aquatics, the trees, plants, worms, birds and bees are all claimed to be His sons. Çré Kåñëa asserts that the entire universe is illusioned by the interactions of the three qualities of material nature, and we are under the spell of that illusion; therefore we cannot understand what God is.

What is the nature of this illusion, and how can it be overcome? That is also explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etaà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered to Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14)

No one can get rid of the entanglement of the three qualities of material nature by mental speculation. The three guëas are very strong and hard to overcome. Can't we feel how we are in the grip of material nature? The word guëa (mode) also means rope. When someone is bound by three strong ropes, he is certainly very tightly secured. Our hands and legs are all bound by the strong ropes of goodness, passion and ignorance. Are we therefore to abandon hope? No, for here Çré Kåñëa promises that whoever surrenders unto Him is at once free. When one becomes Kåñëa conscious—whether in this way or that way—he becomes free.

We are all related to Kåñëa, for we are all His sons. A son may have a disagreement with his father, but it is not possible for him to break that relation. In the course of his life he will be asked who he is, and he will have to reply, "I am the son of so and so." That relation cannot be broken. We are all sons of God, and that relationship with Him is eternal, but we have simply forgotten. Kåñëa is all-powerful, all-famous, all-wealthy, all-beautiful, all-knowledgeable, and He is full of renunciation as well. Although we are friends of such a great personality, we have forgotten it. If a rich man's son forgets his father, leaves home and becomes mad, he may lie on the street to go to sleep, or he may beg money for food, but all of this is due to his forgetfulness. If someone, however, gives him information that he is simply suffering because he has left his father's home and that his father, a very wealthy man and owner of vast property, is anxious to have him return—the person is a great benefactor.

In this material world we are always suffering under threefold miseries—the miseries arising from the body and the mind, from other living entities, and from natural catastrophes. Being covered by illusion, by the modes of material nature, we do not take account of these miseries. However, we should always know that in the material world we are undergoing so much suffering. One who has sufficiently developed consciousness, who is intelligent, inquires why he is suffering. "I do not want miseries. Why am I suffering?" When this question arises, there is chance for becoming Kåñëa conscious.

As soon as we surrender ourselves to Kåñëa, He welcomes us very cordially. It is just like a lost child who returns to his father and says, "My dear father, due to some misunderstanding I left your protection, but I have suffered. Now I return to you." The father embraces his son and says, "My dear boy, come on. I was so anxious for you all the days you were gone, and now I'm so happy you have come back." The father is so kind. We are in the same position. We have to surrender to Kåñëa, and it is not very difficult. When the son surrenders to the father, is it a very difficult job? It is very natural, and the father is always waiting to receive the son. There is no question of insult. If we bow down before our Supreme Father and touch His feet, there is no harm for us, nor is it difficult. Indeed, it is glorious for us. Why should we not? By surrendering unto Kåñëa we come immediately under His protection and are relieved of all miseries. This is validated by all scriptures. At the end of Bhagavad-gétä, Çré Kåñëa says:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mam ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reaction. Do not fear." (Bg. 18.66)

When we throw ourselves at the feet of God, we come under His protection, and from that time on there is no fear for us. When children are under the protection of their parents, they are fearless because they know that their parents will not let them be harmed. Mäm eva ye prapadyante: Kåñëa promises that those who surrender to Him have no cause for fear.

If surrender unto Kåñëa is such an easy thing, then why don't people do it? Instead there are many who are challenging the very existence of God, claiming that nature and science are everything and that God is nothing. So-called advancement of civilization in knowledge means that the populace is becoming more mad. Instead of being cured, the disease is being increased. People don't care for God, but they care for nature, and it is nature's business to give kicks in the form of the threefold miseries. She is always administering these kicks twenty-four hours a day. However, we have become so accustomed to being kicked that we think it is all right and consider it to be the ordinary course of things. We have become very proud of our education, but we tell material nature, "Thank you very much for kicking me. Now please continue." Thus deluded, we think that we have even conquered material nature. But how is this so? Nature is still inflicting upon us the miseries of birth, old age, disease and death. Has any one solved these problems? Then what advancement have we really made in knowledge and civilization? We are under the stringent rules of material nature, but still we are thinking that we have conquered. This is called mäyä.

There may be some difficulty in surrendering to the father of this body, for he has limited knowledge and power, but Kåñëa is not like an ordinary father. Kåñëa is unlimited and has full knowledge, full power, full wealth, full beauty, full fame and full renunciation. Shouldn't we consider ourselves lucky to go to such a father and enjoy His property? Yet no one seems to care about this, and now everyone is making propaganda that there is no God. Why do people not seek Him out? The answer is given in the next verse of Bhagavad-gétä:

na mäà duñkåtino müòhäù
prapadyante narädhamäù
mäyayäpahåta jïäna
äsuraà bhävam äçritäù

"Those miscreants who are grossly foolish, lowest among mankind, whose knowledge is stolen by illusion, and who partake of the atheistic nature of demons, do not surrender unto Me." (Bg. 7.15)

In this way the fools are categorized. A duñkåté is always acting against the scriptural injunctions. The business of current civilization is to break scriptural rules—that's all. By definition, a pious man is one who doesn't. There must be some standard to distinguish between duñkåté (an evil doer) and sukåté (a virtuous man). Every civilized country has some scripture—it may be Christian, Hindu, Moslem or Buddhist. That doesn't matter. The point is that the book of authority, the scripture, is there. One who does not follow its injunctions is considered an outlaw.

Another category mentioned in this verse is müòha, fool number one. The narädhama is one who is low in the human scale, and mäyayäpahåta-jïäna refers to one whose knowledge is carried away by mäyä, or illusion. Äsuraà bhävam äçritäù refers to those who are out and out atheists. Although there are no disadvantages to surrendering unto the Father, people who are thus characterized never do it. As a result, they are constantly punished by the agents of the Father. They have to be slapped, caned and kicked severely, and they have to suffer. Just as a father has to chastise his unruly boy, so material nature has to employ certain punishments. At the same time nature is nourishing us by supplying food and other necessities. Both processes are going on because we are sons of the wealthiest Father of all, and Kåñëa is kind even though we do not surrender unto Him. Yet despite being furnished so well by the Father, the duñkåté still performs unsanctioned actions. One is foolish if he persists in being punished, and one is low on the human scale if he does not use this human form of life to understand Kåñëa. If a man does not use his life to reawaken the relationship he has with his real Father, he is to be considered fallen in the human scale.

Animals simply eat, sleep, defend themselves, have sexual intercourse and die. They do not avail themselves of higher consciousness because that is not possible in the lower forms of life. If a human being follows the activities of the animals and does not avail himself of his ability to elevate his consciousness, he falls down the human scale and prepares for an animal body in his next life. By the grace of Kåñëa we are given a highly developed body and intelligence, but if we do not utilize them, why should He give them to us again? We must understand that this human body has developed after millions and millions of years of evolution and that in itself it is a chance to get out of the cycle of birth and death in which over eight millions species of life evolve. This chance is given by the grace of Kåñëa, and if we do not take it, are we not the lowest among men? One may be a degree holder—M.A., Ph.D., etc.—from some university, but the illusory energy takes away this mundane knowledge. He who is really intelligent will apply his intelligence to understand who he is, who God is, what material nature is, why he is suffering in material nature, and what is the remedy to this suffering.

We may apply our intelligence to manufacture an automobile, radio or television for sense gratification, but we have to understand that this is not knowledge. Rather, this is plundered intelligence. Intelligence was given to man to understand the problems of life, but it is being misused. People are thinking that they have acquired knowledge because they know how to manufacture and drive cars, but before the car was here people were still going from one place to another. It is just that the facility has been increased, but along with this facility come additional problems—air pollution and over-crowded highways. This is mäyä; we are creating facilities, but these facilities in their turn are creating so many problems.

Instead of wasting our energy to supply ourselves with so many facilities and modern amenities, we should apply intelligence to understand who and what we are. We do not like to suffer, but we should understand why suffering is being forced upon us. By so-called knowledge we have simply succeeded in manufacturing the atomic bomb. Thus the killing process has been accelerated. We are so proud to think that this is advancement of knowledge, but if we can manufacture something that can stop death, we have really advanced in knowledge. Death is already there in material nature, but we are so eager to promote it by killing everyone at one drop—this is called mäyayäpahåta-jïäna, knowledge carried away by illusion.

The äsuras, the demons and proclaimed atheists, actually challenge God. If it were not for our Supreme Father, we would not see the light of day, so what is the point of challenging Him? In the Vedas it is stated that there are two classes of men, the devas and äsuras, the demigods and demons. Who are the devas? The devotees of the Supreme Lord are called devas because they also become like God, whereas those who defy the authority of the Supreme are called äsuras or demons. These two classes are always found in human society.

Just as there are four types of miscreants who never surrender to Kåñëa, there are four types of fortunate men who worship Him, and they are categorized in the next verse:

catur-vidhä bhajante mäà
janäù sukåtino 'rjuna
ärto jijïäsur arthärthé
jïäné ca bharatarñabha

"O best among the Bhäratas [Arjuna], four kinds of pious men render devotional service unto Me—the distressed, the desirer of wealth, the inquisitive, and he who is searching for knowledge of the Absolute." (Bg. 7.16)

This material world is full of distress, and both the pious and impious are subject to it. The cold of winter treats everyone alike. It does not care for the pious or impious, the rich or the poor. The difference between the pious and the impious, however, is that the pious man thinks of God when he is in his miserable condition. Often when a man is distressed, he will go to church and pray, "Oh my Lord, I am in difficulty. Please help me." Although he is praying for some material necessity, such a man is still to be considered pious because he has come to God in his distress. Similarly, a poor man may go to church and pray, "My dear Lord, please give me some money." On the other hand, the inquisitive are usually intelligent. They are always researching to understand things. They may ask, "What is God?" and then conduct scientific research to find out. They are also considered pious because their research is directed to the proper object. The man in knowledge is called jïäné—one who has understood his constitutional position. Such ajïäné may have an impersonal conception of God, but because he is taking shelter of the ultimate, the Supreme Absolute Truth, he is also to be considered pious. These four types of men are called sukåté—pious—because they are all after God.

teñäà jïäné nitya-yukta
eka-bhaktir viçiñyate
priyo hi jïänino' tyartham
ahaà sa ca mama priyaù

"Of these, the wise one who is in full knowledge in union with Me through pure devotional service is the best. For I am very dear to him, and he is dear to Me." (Bg. 7.17)

Out of the four classes of men who approach God, he who is philosophically trying to understand the nature of God, who is trying to become Kåñëa conscious—viçiñyate—is best qualified. Indeed, Kåñëa says that such a person is very dear to Him because he has no other business than understanding God. The others are inferior. No one has to pray to God to ask for anything, and he who does so is foolish because he does not know that the all-knowing God is within his heart and is well aware when he is in distress or in need of money. The wise man realizes this and does not pray for relief from material miseries. Rather, he prays to glorify God and inform others how great He is. He doesn't pray for his personal interest, for bread, dress or shelter. The pure devotee, when he is distressed, says, "Dear Lord, this is Your kindness. You have put me into distress just to rectify me. I should be put in much greater distress, but out of Your mercy You have minimized this." This is the vision of a pure devotee who is not disturbed.

He who is in Kåñëa consciousness does not care for material distress, insult or honor because he is aloof from all these. He knows well that distress, honor and insult pertain to the body only and that he is not the body. Socrates, for instance, who believed in the immortality of the soul, was condemned to death, and upon being asked how he would like to be buried, replied, "First of all you may have to catch me." So one who knows that he is not the body is not disturbed, for he knows the soul cannot be caught, tortured, killed or buried. He who is conversant with the science of Kåñëa knows perfectly well that he is not the body, that he is part and parcel of Kåñëa, that his real relationship is with Kåñëa, and that somehow or other, although he has been put in the material body, he must remain aloof from the three qualities of material nature. He is not concerned with the modes of goodness, passion or ignorance, but with Kåñëa. One who understands this is a jïäné, a wise man, and he is very much dear to Kåñëa. A distressed man, when he is put into opulence, may forget God, but a jïäné, who knows the real position of God, will never forget Him.

There is a class of jïänés called impersonalists who say that because worshiping the impersonal is too difficult, a form of God has to be imagined. These are not real jïänés—they're fools. No one can imagine the form of God, for God is so great. One may imagine some form, but that is a concoction; it is not the real form. There are those who imagine the form of God, and there are those who deny the form of God. Neither is a jïäné. Those who imagine the form are called iconoclasts. During the Hindu-Muslim riots in India, some Hindus would go to the Moslem mosque and would break statues and images of God, and the Moslems would reciprocate in like manner. In this way they were both thinking, "We've killed the Hindu God. We've killed the Moslem God, etc." Similarly, when Gandhi was leading his resistance movement, many Indians would go to the street and destroy the mailboxes and in this way think that they were destroying the government postal service. People of such mentality are not jïänés. The religious wars between the Hindus and Moslems and Christians and non-Christians were all conducted on the basis of ignorance. One who is in knowledge knows that God is one; He cannot be Moslem, Hindu or Christian.

It is our imagination that God is such and such and such and such. That is all imagination. The real wise man knows that God is transcendental. One who knows that God is transcendental to the material modes truly knows God. God is always beside us, present in our hearts. When we leave the body, God also goes with us, and when we take on another body, He goes with us there just to see what we are doing. When shall we turn our face towards Him? He is always waiting. As soon as we turn our face toward God, He says, "My dear son, come on—sa ca mama priyaù—you are eternally dear to Me. Now you are turning your face to Me, and I am very glad."

The wise man, the jïäné, actually understands the science of God. One who only understands that "God is good" is in a preliminary stage, but one who actually understands how great and good God is, is further progressed. That knowledge is to be had in Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä. One who is actually interested in God should study the science of God, Bhagavad-gétä.

idaà tu te guhyatamaà
pravakñyämy anasüyave
jïänaà vijïäna-sahitaà
yaj jïätvä mokñyase 'çubhät

"My dear Arjuna, because you are never envious of Me, I shall impart to you this most secret wisdom, knowing which you shall be relieved of the miseries of material existence." (Bg. 9.1)

The knowledge of God imparted in Bhagavad-gétä is very subtle and confidential. It is full of jïäna, metaphysical wisdom, and vijïäna, scientific knowledge. And it is full of mystery also. How can one understand this knowledge? It must be imparted by God Himself or a bona fide representative of God. Therefore Çré Kåñëa says that whenever there is a discrepancy on understanding the science of God, He incarnates Himself.

Nor does knowledge come from sentiment. Devotion is not sentiment. It is a science. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says, "A show of spirituality without reference to the Vedic knowledge is simply a disturbance to society." One must taste the nectar of devotion by reason, argument and knowledge, and then he must pass it on to others. One should not think that Kåñëa consciousness is mere sentimentality. The dancing and singing are all scientific. There is science, and there is also loving reciprocation. Kåñëa is very dear to the wise man, and the wise man is very dear to Kåñëa. Kåñëa will return our love a thousand-fold. What capacity do we finite creatures have to love Kåñëa? But Kåñëa has immense capacity—unlimited capacity—for love.

OWK 5: Steering Toward the Supreme

5
Steering Toward the Supreme

[661009BG.NY] & [661012BG.NY]

udäräù sarva evaite
jïäné tv ätmaiva me matam
ästhitaù sa hi yuktätmä
mäm evänuttamäà gatim

"All these devotees are undoubtedly magnanimous souls, but he who is situated in knowledge of Me I consider verily to dwell in Me. Being engaged in My transcendental service, he attains Me." (Bg. 7.18)

Here Kåñëa is saying that all the men who come to Him—whether they be distressed, in need of money, curious, etc.—are welcomed, but out of them the person who is in knowledge is very dear to Him. The others are welcomed because it is understood that in course of time, if they continue on the path to God, they will become as good as the man of knowledge. Generally, however, it so happens that when one goes to church for profit, and the money doesn't come, he concludes that approaching God is nonsense, and he gives up all connection with church. That is the danger of approaching God with ulterior motives. For instance, during World War II it was reported that many wives of the German soldiers went to church to pray for their husbands' safe return, but when they found they had been killed in battle, they became atheistic. Thus we want God to become our order-supplier, and when He does not supply our order, we say that there is no God. That is the effect of praying for material things.

In this connection there is a story of a little boy, about five years old, named Dhruva, who belonged to a royal family. In the course of time his father, the king, tired of his mother and deposed her as his queen. He then took another woman as queen, and she became stepmother to the boy. She was very envious of him, and one day, as Dhruva was sitting on the father's knee, she insulted him. "Oh you cannot sit on the lap of your father," she said, "because you are not born of me." She dragged Dhruva from his father's lap and the boy became very angry. He was the son of a kñatriya, and kñatriyas are notorious for their quick tempers. Dhruva took this to be a great insult, and he went to his mother who had been deposed.

"Dear Mother," he said, "my stepmother has insulted me by dragging me from my father's lap."

"Dear son," the mother replied, "what can I do? I am helpless, and your father no longer cares for me."

"Well, how can I take revenge?" the boy asked.

"My dear boy, you are helpless. Only if God helps you can you take revenge."

"Oh, where is God?" Dhruva asked enthusiastically.

"I understand so many sages go to the jungle and forest to see God," the mother replied. "They undergo great penances and austerities in order to find God there."

At once Dhruva went to the forest and began asking the tiger and the elephant, "Oh, are you God? Are you God?" In this way he was questioning all the animals. Seeing that Dhruva was very much inquisitive, Çré Kåñëa sent Närada Muni to see about the situation. Närada quickly went to the forest and found Dhruva.

"My dear boy," Närada said, "you belong to the royal family. You cannot suffer all this penance and austerity. Please return to your home. Your mother and father are very much anxious for you."

"Please don't try to divert me in that way," the boy said. "If you know something about God, or if you know how I can see God, please tell me. Otherwise go away and don't disturb me."

When Närada saw that Dhruva was so determined, he initiated him as a disciple and gave him the mantra, oà namo bhagavate väsudeväya. Dhruva chanted this mantra and became perfect, and God came before him.

"My dear Dhruva, what do you want? You can take from Me whatever you want."

"My dear Lord," the boy replied, "I was undergoing such severe penances simply for my father's kingdom and land, but now I have seen You. Even the great sages and saints cannot see You. What is my profit? I left my home to find merely some scraps of glass and rubbish, and instead I have found a very valuable diamond. Now I am satisfied. I have no need to ask anything of You."

Thus even though one may be poverty-stricken or in distress, if he goes to God with the same determination as Dhruva, intent on seeing God and taking His benediction, and if he happens to see God, he will no longer want anything material. He comes to understand the foolishness of material possessions, and he puts the illusion aside for the real thing. When one becomes situated in Kåñëa consciousness, like Dhruva Mahäräja, he becomes fully satisfied and doesn't want anything.

The jïäné, the wise man, knows that material things are flickering. He also knows that there are three aspects that complicate all material gain—one wants profit from his work, one wants adoration from others because of his riches, and one wants fame because of his wealth. In any case, he knows that all of these apply but to the body and that when the body is finished, they also go. When the body dies, one is no longer a rich man but a spirit soul, and according to his work, he has to enter another body. The Gétä says that a wise man is not bewildered by this, for he knows what is what. Why then should he bother himself attaining material wealth? His attitude is, "I have an eternal connection with Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord. Now let me establish that relationship firmly so that Kåñëa will take me back to His kingdom."

The cosmic situation is giving us all facility to reestablish this relationship with Kåñëa and return to Godhead. This should be our mission in life. Everything we need is being supplied by God—land, grain, fruits, milk, shelter and clothing. We only have to live peacefully and cultivate Kåñëa consciousness. That should be our mission in life. We should therefore be satisfied with what God has supplied in the form of food, shelter, defense and sex, and should not want more and more and more. The best type of civilization is one that ascribes to the maxim of "plain living and high thinking." It is not possible to manufacture food or sex in a factory. These and whatever else we require are supplied by God. Our business is to take advantage of these things and become God conscious.

Although God has given us all facilities to live peacefully on this earth, cultivate Kåñëa consciousness, and finally to come to Him, in this age we're unfortunate. We are short-lived, and there are so many people without food, shelter, married life or defense from the onslaughts of nature. This is due to the influence of this age of Kali. Therefore Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, seeing the dreadful situation in this age, emphasized the absolute necessity for cultivating spiritual life. And how should we do it? Caitanya Mahäprabhu gives the formula:

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä
[Ädi 17.21]

"Just always chant Hare Kåñëa." Never mind whether you are in a factory or in a hell, in a shack or in a skyscraper—it doesn't matter. Just go on chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. There is no expense, there is no impediment, there is no caste, there is no creed, there is no color—anyone can do it. Just chant and hear.

Somehow or other, if one comes into contact with Kåñëa consciousness and executes the process under the guidance of a bona fide guide, he is sure to go back to God.

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19)

Philosophical research into the science of God has to be prosecuted for many births. God realization is very easy, but at the same time it is very difficult. It is easy for those who accept Kåñëa's word as truth, but those who try to understand through research work, by dint of advancement of knowledge, have to create their faith after finishing so much research work, and this process takes many births. There are different types of transcendentalists, called tattvavit, who know the Absolute Truth. The transcendentalists call the Absolute Truth that in which there is no duality. In the Absolute Truth there is no duality—everything is on the same level. One who knows this in truth is called tattvavit.

Kåñëa proclaims that the Absolute Truth is known in three aspects—Brahman, Paramätmä and Bhagavän—impersonal Brahman effulgence, localized Supersoul, and the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Thus there are three angles from which one may envision the Absolute Truth. One may view a mountain from a great distance and thus perceive it from one angle of vision. As he comes closer, he may see the trees and foliage of the mountain, and if he begins to climb the mountain, he will find so much variegatedness in trees, plants and animals. The objective is the same, but due to different angles of vision, sages have different conceptions of the Absolute Truth. Another example: there is the sunshine, the sun disc and the sun god. One who is in the sunshine cannot claim that he is on the sun itself, and one who is situated in the sun is, from the point of view of vision, better situated. The sunshine may be compared to the all-pervasive brahmajyoti effulgence, the localized sun-disc may be compared to the localized aspect of the Supersoul, and the sun god who resides within the sun may be compared to the Personality of Godhead. As on this earth planet we have a multivariety of living entities, we can understand from Vedic literatures that in the sun also there is a variety of living entities, but their bodies are made of fire, just as ours are made of earth.

In material nature there are five gross elements: earth, water, air, fire and space. In different planets there are different atmospheres due to one of these five elements prevailing, and there are different bodies for the living entities composed of whatever element may be predominant in a particular planet. We should not think that all planets have the same quality of life, yet there is uniformity in the sense that these five elements are present in some form or other. Thus on some planets earth is prominent, fire is prominent, water is prominent, and air and space are prominent. We should not think, therefore, that just because a planet is not composed primarily of earth, or because the atmosphere does not duplicate ours, that there is no life on these planets. Vedic literatures give us information that there are countless planets filled with living entities with different types of bodies. As, by making some material adjustment, we may qualify to enter into different material planets, by qualification we can enter into the spiritual planet where the Supreme Lord resides.

yänti deva-vratä devän
pitèn yänti pitå-vrataù
bhütäni yänti bhütejyä
yänti mad-yäjino 'pi mäm

"Those who worship the demigods will take birth among the demigods; those who worship ancestors go to the ancestors; and those who worship Me will live with Me." (Bg. 9.25)

Those who are trying to enter higher planets can go there, and those who are trying to qualify to enter into Goloka Våndävana, the planet of Kåñëa, can also enter there by the process of Kåñëa consciousness. Before going to India, we may acquire a description of what the country is like; the hearing of a place is the first experience. Similarly, if we want to get information about the planet where God lives, we have to hear. We cannot immediately make an experiment and go there. That is not possible. But we have so many descriptions of the supreme planet in Vedic literature.

For instance, the Brahma-saàhitä [5.29] states:

cintämaëi-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña-
lakñävåteñu surabhér abhipälayantam
lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor, who is tending the cows, fulfilling all desire, in abodes built with spiritual gems, surrounded by millions of wish-fulfilling trees, always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds of thousands of lakñmés, or gopés."

There are also other detailed descriptions given, specifically in Brahma-saàhitä.

Those who are trying to realize the Absolute Truth are categorized according to the aspect of the Absolute Truth upon which they concentrate. Those who concentrate on Brahman, the impersonalists, are called brahmavädés. Generally, those who are trying to realize the Absolute Truth first of all realize the brahmajyoti. Those who concentrate on the Supersoul, the localized form of the Lord in the heart, called Paramätmä, are known as paramätmävädés. The Supreme Lord, by His plenary portion, is sitting in everyone's heart, and by meditation and concentration one can perceive this form. Not only is He within everyone's heart, but He is situated also within every atom of the creation. This Paramätmä realization is the second stage. The third and last stage is the realization of Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Because there are three main stages of realization, the Supreme Absolute Truth is not attained in one birth. Bahünäà janmanäm ante. If one is fortunate, he can achieve the ultimate in one second. But generally it takes many, many years and many, many births to realize what God is.

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate
iti matvä bhajante mäà
budhä bhäva-samanvitäù

"I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts." (Bg. 10.8)

The Vedänta-sütra also confirms that the Absolute Truth is He from whom everything is born. If we truly believe that Kåñëa is the origin of everything, and if we worship Him, our whole account is closed in one second. But if one doesn't believe and says, "Oh, I want to see what God is," he has to go by stages by realizing the impersonal Brahman effulgence and then Paramätmä, the localized feature, before finally coming to the last stage of realizing, "Oh, here is the Supreme Personality of Godhead." It should be understood, however, that this process takes more time. When one through many years of research comes to realize the Absolute Truth, he concludes väsudevaù sarvam iti—"Väsudeva is all that is." Väsudeva is a name for Kåñëa, and it means "He who lives everywhere." Realizing that Väsudeva is the root of everything—mäà prapadyate—he surrenders. The surrendering process is the ultimate goal; either one does it immediately or after many births of research work. In either case, surrender must be there by realizing that "God is great, and I am His subordinate."

Understanding this, the wise man will surrender immediately and not wait to take many, many births. He understands that this information is given by the Supreme Lord out of His infinite mercy on the conditioned souls. We are all conditioned souls, suffering the threefold miseries of this material world. Now the Supreme Lord is giving us the opportunity to escape these miseries by the surrendering process.

At this point one may ask that if the Supreme Personality is the ultimate goal and one has to surrender to Him, why are there so many different processes of worship in the world? This question is answered in the next verse.

kämais tais tair håta-jïänäù
prapadyante 'nya-devatäù
taà taà niyamam ästhäya
prakåtyä niyatäù svayä

"Those whose minds are distorted by material desires surrender unto demigods and follow the particular rules and regulations of worship according to their own natures." (Bg. 7.20)

There are many different types of men in the world, and they're functioning under the different modes of material nature. Generally speaking, most men are not after liberation. If they take to spirituality, they wish to gain something by spiritual power. It is not uncommon in India for a person to go to a svämé and say, "Sväméji, could you give me some medicine? I am suffering from this disease." He thinks that because a doctor is too expensive, he can go to a svämé who can work miracles. In India also there are svämés who go to people's houses and preach, "If you give me one ounce of gold I can make it into one hundred ounces of gold." The people think, "I have five ounces of gold. Let me give it to him, and I'll get five hundred ounces." In this way the svämé collects all the gold in the village, and after collecting it, he vanishes. This is our disease: when we go to a svämé, or a temple or a church, our hearts are filled with material desires. Wanting some material profit out of spiritual life, we practice yoga just to keep our health fit. But, in order to keep healthy, why take shelter of yoga? We can become healthy through regular exercises and regulated diet. Why resort to yoga? Because: kämais tais tair håta-jïänäù. We have the material desire to keep ourselves fit and to enjoy life by going to church and making God our order-supplier.

Having material desires, men worship various demigods. They have no idea how to get out of matter; they want to utilize the material world to its best capacity. For instance, in Vedic literature there are so many recommendations: if one wants to cure his disease, he worships the sun, or if a girl wants a good husband, she worships Lord Çiva, or if one wants to become beautiful, he worships such and such god, or if one wants to become educated, he worships goddess Sarasvaté. In this way Westerners often think that the Hindus are polytheistic, but actually this worship is not to God, but to demigods. We should not think that the demigods are God. God is one, but there are demigods who are also living entities just like us. The difference is that they have a considerable amount of power. On this earth there may be a king or a president or a dictator—these are men like us, but they have some extraordinary power, and in order to get favors from them, to take advantage of their power, we worship them in one way or another. But Bhagavad-gétä condemns worship of the demigods. This verse clearly states that people worship the demigods due to käma, material lust.

This material life is simply based on lust; we want to enjoy this world, and we love this material world because we want to gratify our senses. This lust is a perverted reflection of our love of God. In our original constitution we are made to love God, but because we have forgotten God, we love matter. Love is there. Either we love matter, or we love God. But in no case can we get out of this loving propensity; indeed, we often see that when one doesn't have children, he loves a cat or a dog. Why? Because we want and need to love something. In the absence of reality, we put our faith and love in cats and dogs. Love is always there, but it is distorted into the form of lust. When this lust is baffled, we become angry; when we become angry, we become illusioned; and when we are illusioned, we are doomed. This is the process that is going on, but we have to reverse this process and turn lust into love. If we love God, we love everything. But if we do not love God, it is not possible to love anything. We may think that it is love, but it is simply a glamorized form of lust. Those who have become the dogs of lust are said to have lost all good sense: kämais tais tair håta-jïänäù [Bg. 7.20].

There are many rules and regulations for the worship of demigods in the scriptures, and one may question why the Vedic literatures recommended their worship. There is necessity. Those who are motivated by lust want the opportunity to love something, and the demigods are acknowledged as the officers of the Supreme Lord. The idea is that as one worships these demigods, he will gradually develop Kåñëa consciousness. But if one is completely atheistic and disobedient and rebellious against any authority, what hope is there? So one's obedience to a higher personality can start with the demigods.

If, however, we take directly to the worship of the Supreme Lord, worship of the demigods is not necessary. Those who worship the Supreme Lord directly show all respect to the demigods, but they do not need to worship them because they know that the supreme authority behind the demigods is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and they are engaged in worshiping Him. In any case, respect is still there. A devotee of the Lord shows respect even to an ant, what to speak of the demigods? The devotee is aware that all living entities are parts and parcels of the Supreme Lord and that they are playing different roles only.

In relation to the Supreme Lord, all beings are to be respected. Therefore a devotee refers to others as "Prabhu," meaning "My dear sir, my dear lord." Submissiveness is a qualification for a devotee of the Lord. Devotees are kind and obedient, and they have all good qualifications. In conclusion, if one becomes a devotee of the Lord, all good qualifications will automatically develop. By nature, the living entity is perfect, but due to the contamination of lust, he becomes vicious. That which is part and parcel of gold is also gold, and whatever is part and parcel of the Complete Perfect is also perfect.

oà pürëam adaù pürëam idaà
pürëät pürëam udacyate
pürëasya pürëam ädäya
pürëam evävaçiñyate

"The Personality of Godhead is perfect and complete. Because He is completely perfect, all emanations from Him, such as this phenomenal world, are perfectly equipped as a complete whole. Whatever is produced of the complete whole is also complete in itself. Because He is the complete whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance." (Çré Éçopaniñad, Invocation)

Due to the contamination of matter, the perfect living entity falls down, but this process of Kåñëa consciousness will again make him perfect. Through it, he can become truly happy, and after leaving the material body, enter into the kingdom where there is eternal life, bliss and full knowledge.

RÄJA-VIDYÄ
The King of Knowledge (1973)

© 1973 by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust (B.B.T.)
All rights reserved
First Printing, 1973: 100,000 copies
Second Printing, 1973: 160,000 copies
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 72-84845
International Standard Book Number: 0-912776-40-4
Printed in the United States of America by Donnelley Printing Co.

contents

RV 1: Räja-Vidyä: The King of Knowledge

1
Räja-Vidyä: The King of Knowledge

[661121BG.NY] & [661122BG.NY]

çré bhagavän uväca
idaà tu te guhyatamaà
pravakñyämy anasüyave
jïänaà vijïäna-sahitaà
yaj jïätvä mokñyase 'çubhät

"The Supreme Lord said: My dear Arjuna, because you are never envious of Me, I shall impart to you this most secret wisdom, knowing which you shall be relieved of the miseries of material existence." (Bg. 9.1)

The opening words of the Ninth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä indicate that the Supreme Godhead is speaking. Here Çré Kåñëa is referred to as Bhagavän. Bhaga means opulences, and vän means one who possesses. We have some conception of God, but in the Vedic literature there are definite descriptions and definitions of what is meant by God, and what is meant is described in one word—Bhagavän. Bhagavän possesses all opulences, the totality of knowledge, wealth, power, beauty, fame and renunciation. When we find someone who possesses these opulences in full, we are to know that he is God. There are many rich, wise, famous, beautiful and powerful men, but no one man can claim to possess all of these opulences. Only Kåñëa claims to possess them in totality.

bhoktäraà yajïa-tapasäà
sarva-loka-maheçvaram
suhådaà sarva-bhütänäà
jïätvä mäà çäntim åcchati

"The sages, knowing Me as the ultimate purpose of all sacrifices and austerities, the Supreme Lord of all planets and demigods and the benefactor and well-wisher of all living entities, attain peace from the pangs of material miseries." (Bg. 5.29)

Here Kåñëa proclaims that He is the enjoyer of all activities and the proprietor of all planets (sarva-loka-maheçvaram). An individual may possess a large tract of land, and he may be proud of his ownership, but Kåñëa claims to possess all planetary systems. Kåñëa also claims to be the friend of all living entities (suhådaà sarva-bhütänäm). When a person understands that God is the proprietor of everything, the friend of everyone and the enjoyer of all, he becomes very peaceful. This is the actual peace formula. No one can have peace as long as he thinks, "I am the proprietor." Who is capable of claiming proprietorship? Only a few hundred years ago the red Indians were considered to be the proprietors of America. Today we in our turn are claiming that proprietorship, but in four hundred or a thousand years perhaps someone else will come to claim the same. The land is here, and we come here and falsely claim ourselves to be proprietors of it. This philosophy of false proprietorship is not in line with Vedic injunctions. Çré Éçopaniñad states that "everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord (éçäväsyam idaà sarvam)." The truth of this statement is factual, but under illusion we are thinking that we are the proprietors. In actuality God owns everything, and therefore He is called the richest.

Of course there are many men who claim to be God. In India, for instance, at any time, one has no difficulty in finding at least one dozen people claiming to be God. But if you ask them if they are the proprietor of everything, they find this difficult to answer. This is a criterion by which we can understand who God is. God is the proprietor of everything, and, being so, He must be more powerful than anyone or anything else. When Kåñëa was personally present on this earth, no one could conquer Him. There is no record of His ever having lost a battle. He belonged to a kñatriya (warrior) family, and the kñatriyas are meant to give protection to the weak. As far as His opulence is concerned, He married 16,108 wives. Every wife had her own separate palace, and Kåñëa expanded Himself 16,108 times in order to enjoy them all. This may seem difficult to believe, but it is stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and the great sages of India recognize this as scripture and recognize Kåñëa as God.

In the first verse of this Ninth Chapter, by the word guhyatamam, Çré Kåñëa intimates that He is imparting the most confidential knowledge to Arjuna. Why is He proclaiming this to Arjuna? It is because Arjuna is anasüyu—non-envious. In the material world if someone is greater than us, we are envious. We are not only envious of one another, but of God. Also when Kåñëa says, "I am the proprietor," we disbelieve it. But this is not the case with Arjuna, who listens to Kåñëa without envy. Arjuna does not cavil with Kåñëa but agrees with whatever He says. This is his special qualification, and this is the way of understanding Bhagavad-gétä. It is not possible to understand what God is by our own mental speculations; we have to hear, and we have to accept.

Because Arjuna is not envious, Kåñëa speaks this special knowledge to him. This is not only theoretical knowledge but practical knowledge (vijïäna-sahitam). Whatever knowledge we receive from Bhagavad-gétä should not be taken for sentimentality or fanaticism. The knowledge is both jïäna and vijïäna, theoretical wisdom and scientific knowledge. If one becomes well-versed in this knowledge, liberation is certain. Life in this material world is by nature inauspicious and miserable. Mokña means liberation, and the promise is that by dint of understanding this knowledge one will attain liberation from all miseries. It is important then to understand what Kåñëa says about this knowledge.

räja-vidyä räja-guhyaà
pavitram idam uttamam
pratyakñävagamaà dharmyaà
susukhaà kartum avyayam

"This knowledge is the king of education, the most secret of all secrets. It is the purest knowledge, and because it gives direct perception of the self by realization, it is the perfection of religion. It is everlasting, and it is joyfully performed." (Bg. 9.2)

According to Bhagavad-gétä, the topmost knowledge (räja-vidyä räja-guhyam) is Kåñëa consciousness because in Bhagavad-gétä we find that the symptom of one who is actually in knowledge is that he has surrendered unto Kåñëa. As long as we go on speculating about God but do not surrender, it is understood that we have not attained the perfection of knowledge. The perfection of knowledge is:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19)

As long as we do not surrender, we cannot understand God. Surrender to God may take many births, but if we accept that God is great, it is possible to surrender unto Him immediately. But generally this is not our position in the material world. We are characteristically envious and consequently think, "Oh, why should I surrender unto God? I am independent. I shall work independently." Therefore in order to rectify this misgiving, we have to work for many births. In this regard, the name of Kåñëa is especially significant. Kåñ means "repetition of birth," and ëa means "one who checks." Our repetition of birth can be checked only by God. No one can check his repetition of birth and death without the causeless mercy of God.

The subject matter of the Ninth Chapter is räja-vidyä. Räja means "king," and vidyä means "knowledge." In ordinary life we find one person king in one subject and another in another subject. This knowledge, however, is sovereign over all others, and all other knowledge is subject or relative to it. The word räja-guhyam indicates that this sovereign knowledge is very confidential, and the word pavitram means that it is very pure. This knowledge is also uttamam; ud means "transcend," and tama means "darkness," and that knowledge which surpasses this world and the knowledge of this world is called uttamam. It is the knowledge of light, and darkness has been separated from it. If one follows this path of knowledge, he will personally understand how far he has progressed down the path of perfection (pratyakñävagamaà dharmyam). Susukhaà kartum indicates that this knowledge is very happy and joyful to execute. And avyayam indicates that this knowledge is permanent. We may work in this material world for education or riches, but these things are not avyayam, for as soon as this body is finished, everything else is also finished. With death, our education, advanced degrees, bank balances, family—everything—are all finished. Whatever we're doing in this material world is not eternal.

However, this knowledge is not like that.

nehäbhikrama-näço 'sti
pratyaväyo na vidyate
svalpam apy asya dharmasya
träyate mahato bhayät

"In this endeavor there is no loss or diminution, and a little advancement on this path can protect one from the most dangerous type of fear." (Bg. 2.40)

Knowledge in Kåñëa consciousness is so perfect that if one performs work in Kåñëa consciousness and yet does not attain perfection, in his next life he takes up from wherever he left off. In other words, actions performed in Kåñëa consciousness are durable. On the other hand, material achievements, because they pertain to the body, are vanquished at death. Knowledge that pertains to designations does not endure. I am thinking that I am a man or a woman, an American or Indian, a Christian or Hindu—these are all designations pertaining to the body, and when the body is finished, they will also be finished. We are actually spirit, and therefore our spiritual activities will go with us wherever we go.

Çré Kåñëa indicates that this king of knowledge is also happily performed. We can easily see that activities in Kåñëa consciousness are joyfully done. There is chanting and dancing, eating prasädam (food that has been offered to Kåñëa) and discussing Bhagavad-gétä. These are the main processes. There are no stringent rules and regulations that we have to sit so straight for so long or do so many gymnastics, or control our breath. No, the process is very easily and happily done. Everyone wants to dance, to sing, to eat and to hear the truth. This process is truly susukham—very happy.

In the material world there are so many gradations of education. Some people never finish grammar school or high school, whereas others go on and receive a university education, a BA, MA, PhD, and so on. But what is this räja-vidyä, the king of education, the summum bonum of knowledge? It is this Kåñëa consciousness. Real knowledge is understanding "what I am." Unless we come to the point of understanding what we are, we cannot attain real knowledge. When Sanätana Gosvämé left his government post and came to Caitanya Mahäprabhu for the first time, he asked the Lord, "What is education?" Although Sanätana Gosvämé knew a number of languages, including Sanskrit, he still inquired about real education. "The general populace calls me highly educated," Sanätana Gosvämé told the Lord, "and I am such a fool that I actually believe them."

The Lord replied, "Why should you not think you're well educated? You're a great scholar in Sanskrit and Persian."

"That may be," Sanätana Gosvämé said, "but I do not know what I am." He then went on to tell the Lord: "I do not wish to suffer, but these material miseries are forced upon me. I neither know where I've come from nor where I'm going, but people are calling me educated. When they call me a great scholar, I am satisfied, but in truth I am such a great fool that I know not what I am." Sanätana Gosvämé was actually speaking for all of us, for this is our present situation. We may be proud of our academic education, but if asked what we are, we are not able to say. Everyone is under the conception that this body is the self, but we learn from Vedic sources that this is not so. Only after realizing that we are not these bodies can we enter into real knowledge and understand what we actually are. This then, is the beginning of knowledge.

Räja-vidyä may be further defined as not only knowing what one is, but acting accordingly. If we do not know who we are, how can our activities be proper? If we are mistaken about our identity, we will also be mistaken about our activities. Simply knowing that we are not these material bodies is not sufficient; we must act according to the conviction that we are spiritual. Action based on this knowledge—spiritual activity—is work in Kåñëa consciousness. This kind of knowledge may not seem to be so easily attainable, but it is made very easy by the mercy of Kåñëa and Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu who made this knowledge easily available through the process of chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

Caitanya Mahäprabhu divided the living entities into two major categories: those that are moving and those that are not moving. Trees, grass, plants, stones, etc., do not move because they do not have sufficiently developed consciousness. Their consciousness is there, but is covered. If a living being does not understand his position, he is stonelike, although dwelling in a human body. The living entities—birds, reptiles, animals, insects, human beings, demigods, etc.—number over 8,000,000 species, and of these a very small number are human beings. Lord Caitanya further points out that out of 400,000 species of human beings, some are civilized; and out of many civilized persons, there are only a few who are devoted to the scriptures.

In the present day most people claim to be devoted to some religion—Christian, Hindu, Moslem, Buddhist, etc.—but in fact they do not really believe in the scriptures. Those who do believe in the scriptures are, by and large, attached to pious philanthropic activities. They believe that religion means yajïa (sacrifice), däna (charity) and tapas (penance). One who engages in tapasya undertakes voluntarily very rigid regulations, such as brahmacäré students (celibates) or sannyäsés (renounced order) undertake. Charity means voluntarily giving away one's material possessions. In the present age there is no sacrifice, but from historical literatures like the Mahäbhärata we get information that kings performed sacrifices by distributing rubies, gold and silver. Yajïa was primarily for kings, and charity, on a much smaller scale, was meant for householders. Those who actually believed in scriptures usually adopted some of these principles. But generally in this age people simply say that they belong to a religion but in actuality do nothing. Out of millions of such people, a very small number actually perform charity, sacrifice and penance. Caitanya Mahäprabhu further points out that out of millions who perform such religious principles all over the universe, only a few attain perfect knowledge and understand what they are.

Just knowing "I am not this body but am spirit soul" is not sufficient. We have to escape this entanglement of material nature. This is called mukti, liberation. Out of many thousands of persons who are in self-knowledge as to what and who they are, only one or two may be actually liberated. And out of many thousands who are liberated, only one or two may understand what and who Kåñëa is. So understanding Kåñëa is not such an easy job. Thus in this age of Kali, an age characterized by ignorance and chaos, liberation is out of the reach of practically everyone. One has to go through the whole ordeal of becoming civilized, then religious, and then one has to perform charities and sacrifices and come to the platform of knowledge, then to the stage of liberation, and finally, after liberation, to the understanding of what Kåñëa is.

This process is also indicated in Bhagavad-gétä:

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments or desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state he attains pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54)

These are the signs of liberation. The first symptom of one who is liberated is that he is very happy. It is not possible to find him morose. Nor does he have any anxiety. He never frets, "This thing I don't have. Oh, I must secure this thing. Oh, this bill I have to pay. I have to go here, there." One who is liberated has no anxieties at all. He may be the poorest man in the world, but he neither laments nor thinks that he is poor. Why should he think that he is poor? When we think that we are these material bodies and that we have possessions to go with them, then we think that we are poor or rich, but one who is liberated from the material conception of life has nothing to do with possessions or lack of possessions. "I have nothing to lose and nothing to gain," he thinks. "I am completely separate from all this." Nor does he see anyone else as rich or poor, educated or uneducated, beautiful or ugly, etc. He does not see any material dualities, for his vision is completely on the spiritual platform, and he sees that every living entity is part and parcel of Kåñëa. Thus seeing all entities in their true identity, he tries to take them back to Kåñëa consciousness. His viewpoint is that everyone—whether he be brähmaëa or çüdra, black or white, Hindu, Christian, or whatever—should come to Kåñëa consciousness. When one is situated in this way, then: mad-bhaktià labhate paräm—he becomes eligible for becoming a pure devotee of Kåñëa's.

Practically speaking, this process is not very easy in this age of Kali. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam a description is given of the people of this age. Their duration of life is said to be very short, they tend to be phlegmatic and slow and to sleep a great deal, and when they're not sleeping, they are busy earning money. At the most they only have two hours a day for spiritual activities, so what is the hope for spiritual understanding? It is also stated that even if one is anxious to make spiritual progress, there are many pseudo-spiritual societies to take advantage of him. People are also characterized in this age as being unfortunate. They have a great deal of difficulty meeting the primary demands of life—eating, defending, mating, and sleeping—necessities which are met even by the animals. Even if people are meeting these necessities in this age, they are always anxious about war, either defending themselves from aggressors or having to go to war themselves. In addition to this, there are always disturbing diseases and economic problems in Kali-yuga. Therefore Lord Çré Kåñëa considered that in this age it is impossible for people to come to the perfectional stage of liberation by following the prescribed rules and regulations.

Thus out of His causeless mercy, Çré Kåñëa came as Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu and distributed the means to the highest perfection of life and spiritual ecstasy by the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. This process of chanting is most practical, and it does not depend on whether one is liberated or not, or whether one's condition is conducive to spiritual life or not—whoever takes to this process becomes immediately purified. Therefore it is called pavitram (pure). Furthermore, for one who takes to this Kåñëa consciousness process, the seeds of latent reactions to his sinful actions are all nullified. Just as a fire turns whatever we put into it to ashes, this process turns to ashes all the sinful reactions of our past lives.

We must understand that our suffering is due to our sinful activity, and sinful activity is due to our ignorance. Sins, or transgressions, are committed by those who do not know what is what. A child, for instance, will naively put his hand in a fire because of ignorance. He is thus burned immediately, for the fire is impartial and does not allow any special consideration for the innocent child. It will simply act as fire. Similarly, we do not know how this material world is functioning, who its controller is, nor how it is controlled, and due to our ignorance we act in foolish ways, but nature is so stringent that she does not allow us to escape the reactions to our actions. Whether we commit an act knowingly or unknowingly, the reactions and consequent sufferings are there. However, through knowledge we can understand what the actual situation is, who God is, and what our relationship with Him is.

This knowledge by which we can gain release from suffering is possible in the human form of life, not in the animal form. To give us knowledge, to give us proper direction, there are scriptures written in various languages in all parts of the world. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu pointed out that people are forgetful from time immemorial about their relationship with the Supreme Lord; therefore Kåñëa has sent so many representatives to impart the scriptures to man. We should take advantage of these, especially of Bhagavad-gétä, which is the prime scripture for the modern world.

RV 2: Knowledge Beyond Saàsära

2
Knowledge Beyond Saàsära

[661123BG.NY]

Kåñëa specifically states that this process of Kåñëa consciousness is susukham, very pleasant and easy to practice. Indeed, the devotional process is very pleasant; we melodiously sing with instruments, and someone will listen and also join (çravaëaà kértanam). Of course the music should be in relation with the Supreme Lord, in glorification of Him. Hearing Bhagavad-gétä is also part of devotional service, and in addition to hearing it one should be eager to apply it in his life. Kåñëa consciousness is a science and should not be accepted blindly. There are nine processes of devotional service recommended (hearing, chanting, remembering, worshiping, praying, serving, engaging as a servitor of the Lord, establishing friendly relations with the Lord, offering everything to the Lord). These are all easy to practice and should be joyfully performed.

Of course if one thinks that Bhagavad-gétä and the Hare Kåñëa mantra are part of the Hindu system and doesn't want to accept them because of this, he can nonetheless attend the Christian church and sing there. There is no difference between this process and that process; the point is whatever process one follows, he must become God conscious. God is neither Moslem nor Hindu nor Christian—He is God. Nor are we to be considered Hindu, Moslem or Christian. These are bodily designations. We are all pure spirit, part and parcel of the Supreme. God is pavitram, pure, and we are also pure. Somehow or other, however, we have fallen into this material ocean, and as the waves toss, we suffer. Actually we have nothing to do with the tossing waves of material miseries. We must simply pray, "Kåñëa, please pick me up." As soon as we forget Kåñëa, the ocean of illusion is there, and it at once captures us. The chanting of Hare Kåñëa is most important in order to escape from this ocean. Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is a sound (çabda) that is non-different from Kåñëa. The sound Kåñëa and the original Kåñëa are the same. When we chant Hare Kåñëa and dance, Kåñëa is also dancing with us. Of course we may say, "Well, I do not see Him," but why do we put so much stress on seeing? Why not hearing? Seeing, tasting, smelling, touching, and hearing are all instruments for experience and knowledge. Why do we put such exclusive stress on seeing? A devotee does not wish to see Kåñëa; he is satisfied by simply hearing of Kåñëa. Seeing may eventually be there, but hearing should not be considered any less important. There are things which we hear but do not see—the wind may be whistling past our ears, and we can hear it, but there is no possibility of seeing the wind. Since hearing is no less an important experience or valid one than seeing, we can hear Kåñëa and realize His presence through sound. Çré Kåñëa Himself says, "I am not there in My abode, or in the heart of the meditating yogé but where my pure devotees are singing." We can feel the presence of Kåñëa as we actually make progress.

It is not that we should simply take things from Kåñëa and offer Him nothing. Everyone is taking something from God, so why not give something? We are taking from Kåñëa so much light, air, food, water and so on. Unless these resources are supplied by Kåñëa, no one can live. Is it love to simply keep taking and taking and taking without ever offering anything in return? Love means taking and giving also. If we just take from someone and give him nothing in return, that is not love—it is exploitation. It is not that we should just continue eating without ever offering anything to Kåñëa. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says:

patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà
yo me bhaktyä prayacchati
tad ahaà bhakty-upahåtam
açnämi prayatätmanaù

yat karoñi yad açnäsi
yaj juhoñi dadäsi yat
yat tapasyasi kaunteya
tat kuruñva mad arpaëam

"If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit or water, I will accept it. O son of Kunté, all that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you perform, should be done as an offering unto Me." (Bg. 9.26-27)

In addition to giving and receiving, in the execution of devotional service one has to submit to Kåñëa whatever distress or confidential problem he has. He should say, "Kåñëa, I am suffering in this way. I have fallen in this tossing ocean of material illusion. Kindly pick me up. I understand now that I have no identification with this material world. I am simply put here, as if thrown into the Atlantic ocean. I may not in any way identify with the Atlantic ocean, but I am subject to the tossing of the ocean. Actually I am a spiritual spark, a fragmental part of You." To our misfortune, we try to identify with this ocean and stop its tossing. We must not try to stop the tossing. It is not possible. In any case, the tossing will go on, for that is the law of nature. Only the foolish try to adjust to this world; the real problem is how to get out of it. Those who do attempt to adjust and who never turn to Kåñëa are continually subject to transmigration in the ocean of birth and death.

açraddadhänäù puruñä
dharmasyäsya parantapa
apräpya mäà nivartante
måtyu-saàsära-vartmani

"Those who are not faithful on the path of devotional service cannot attain Me, O conqueror of foes, but return to birth and death in this material world." (Bg. 9.3)

By definition, religion is that which connects us with God. If it is not capable of connecting us with God, it is no religion. Religion means searching for God, understanding God and establishing a relationship with God. This is religion. Those who are engaged in devotional service are acting for Kåñëa or God, and since in this way there is connection with God, Kåñëa consciousness is a religion.

It is not possible to manufacture a religion. A true religion must come from an authorized source, and that source is either God or His representative. Religion has been called the law of God. It is not possible for a person to manufacture a State law. The law is there, and it is given by the State. One may create some bylaws for his own society, but these laws must be sanctioned by the law of the State. Similarly, if we wish to make some principle of religion, it must be sanctioned by the Vedic authority.

Bhagavad-gétä is also religion. Great authorities like Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Viñëusvämé, Lord Caitanya, Çaìkaräcärya, and so many others have accepted Bhagavad-gétä as the supreme principle of religion and Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. There is no doubt about it. In the West also Bhagavad-gétä is accepted as a great book of philosophy, and many great scholars and philosophers in the West have read it and commented upon it. Despite acceptance by the scholars and äcäryas, there are persons who do not accept Bhagavad-gétä and who have no faith. They do not accept it at all as authority, for they think that it is some sentimental exaggeration by a man known as Kåñëa. Thus Kåñëa states in the above quoted verse that those who reject Bhagavad-gétä as authority cannot have any connection with Him, and because they have no relation to Him, they remain in the cycle of birth and death. Apräpya mäà nivartante måtyu-saàsära-vartmani (Bg. 9.3). Being subjected to saàsära, the cycle of birth and death, does not guarantee that one will necessarily get a similar facility for understanding Bhagavad-gétä in the next life. One may not necessarily be born again as a human being, or in America, or in India, or even on this planet. There is no certainty; it all depends on our work. On the path of birth and death we take our birth, remain for some time, enjoy or suffer, then again give up this body and enter into the womb of a mother, either human being or animal, then prepare another body to come out and begin our work again. This is called måtyu-saàsära-vartmani. If one wants to avoid this path, he must take to Kåñëa consciousness.

When Yudhiñöhira Mahäräja was asked, "What is the most wonderful thing in the world?" he replied, "The most wonderful thing is that every day, every moment, people are dying, and yet everyone thinks that death will not come for him." Every minute and every second we experience that living entities are going to the temple of death. Men, insects, animals, birds—everyone is going. This world, therefore, is called måtyuloka—the planet of death. Every day there are obituaries, and if we bother to go to the cemetery or crematorium grounds we can validate them. Yet everyone is thinking, "Somehow or other I'll live." Everyone is subject to the law of death, yet no one takes it seriously. This is illusion. Thinking we will live forever, we go on doing whatever we like, feeling that we will never be held responsible. This is a very risky life, and it is the densest part of illusion. We should become very serious and understand that death is waiting. We have heard the expression, "as sure as death." This means that in this world death is the most certain thing; no one can avoid it. When death comes, no longer will our puffed-up philosophy or advanced degrees help us. At that time our stout and strong body and our intelligence—which don't care for anything—are vanquished. At that time the fragmental portion (jévätmä) comes under the dictation of material nature, and prakåti (nature) gives us the type of body for which we are fit. If we want to take this risk, we can avoid Kåñëa; if we don't want to take it, Kåñëa will come to help us.

RV 3: Knowledge of Kåñëa's Energies

3
Knowledge of Kåñëa's Energies

[661123BG.NY] & [661124BG.NY]

It may be noted at this point that the Ninth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä is especially meant for those who have already accepted Çré Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In other words, it is meant for His devotees. If one does not accept Çré Kåñëa as the Supreme, this Ninth Chapter will appear as something different from what it actually is. As stated in the beginning, the subject matter of the Ninth Chapter is the most confidential material in the entire Bhagavad-gétä. If one doesn't accept Kåñëa as the Supreme, he will think the chapter to be a mere exaggeration. This is especially the case with the verses dealing with Kåñëa's relationship with His creation.

mayä tatam idaà sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

"By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them." (Bg. 9.4)

The world which we see is also Kåñëa's energy, His mäyä. Here, mayä means "by Me," as if one says, "This work has been done by me." This "by Me" does not mean that He has done His work and has finished or retired. If I start a large factory and I say, "This factory was started by me," in no case should it be concluded that I am lost or in any way not present. Although a manufacturer may refer to his products as being "manufactured by me," it does not mean that he personally created or constructed his product, but that the product was produced by his energy. Similarly, if Kåñëa says, "Whatever you see in the world was created by Me," we are not to suppose that He is no longer existing.

It is not very difficult to see God everywhere in the creation, for He is everywhere present. Just as in the Ford factory the workers see Mr. Ford in every corner, those who are conversant with the science of Kåñëa can see Him in every atom of the creation. Everything is resting on Kåñëa (mat-sthäni sarva bhütäni), but Kåñëa is not there (na cähaà teñv avasthitaù). Kåñëa and His energy are non-different, yet the energy is not Kåñëa. The sun and the sunshine are not different, but the sunshine is not the sun. The sunshine may come through our window and enter our room, but this is not to say that the sun is in our room. The Viñëu Puräëa states: parasya brähmaëaù çaktiù: parasya means supreme, brähmaëaù means Absolute Truth, and çaktiù means energy. The energy of the Supreme Absolute is everything, but in that energy Kåñëa is not to be found.

There are two kinds of energy—material and spiritual. Jévas, or individual souls, belong to the superior energy of Kåñëa, but because they are prone to be attracted to the material energy, they are called marginal energy. But actually there are only two energies. All of the planetary systems and universes are resting on the energies of Kåñëa. Just as all the planets in the solar system are resting in the sunshine, everything within the creation is resting on Kåñëa-shine. All of these potencies of the Lord give pleasure to a devotee, but one who is envious of Kåñëa rejects them. When one is a nondevotee, the statements of Kåñëa seem to be so much bluff, but when one is a devotee, he thinks, "Oh, my Lord is so powerful," and he becomes filled with love and adoration. Nondevotees think that because Kåñëa says, "I am God," they and everyone else can say the same. But if asked to show their universal form, they cannot do it. That is the difference between a pseudo god and the real God. Kåñëa's pastimes cannot be imitated. Kåñëa married over 16,000 wives and kept them nicely in 16,000 palaces, but an ordinary man cannot even keep one wife nicely. It is not that Kåñëa just spoke so many wonderful things; He also acted wonderfully. We should not believe one thing that Kåñëa says or does and reject another; if belief is there, it must be full belief.

In this regard, there is a story of Närada Muni, who was once asked by a brähmaëa: "Oh, you are going to meet the Lord? Will you please ask Him when I'm going to get my salvation?"

"All right," Närada agreed. "I shall ask Him."

As Närada proceeded, he met a cobbler who was sitting under a tree mending shoes, and the cobbler similarly asked Närada, "Oh, you are going to see God? Will you please inquire of Him when my salvation will come?"

When Närada Muni went to the Vaikuëöha planets, he fulfilled their request and asked Näräyaëa (God) about the salvation of the brähmaëa and the cobbler, and Näräyaëa replied, "After leaving this body, the cobbler shall come here to me."

"What about the brähmaëa?" Närada asked.

"He will have to remain there for a number of births. I do not know when he is coming."

Närada Muni was astonished, and he finally said, "I can't understand the mystery of this."

"That you will see," Näräyaëa said. "When they ask you what I am doing in My abode, tell them that I am threading the eye of a needle with an elephant."

When Närada returned to earth and approached the brähmaëa, the brähmaëa said, "Oh, you have seen the Lord? What was He doing?"

"He was threading an elephant through the eye of a needle," Närada answered.

"I don't believe such nonsense," the brähmaëa replied. Närada could immediately understand that the man had no faith and that he was simply a reader of books.

Närada then left and went on to the cobbler, who asked him, "Oh, you have seen the Lord? Tell me, what was He doing?"

"He was threading an elephant through the eye of a needle," Närada replied.

The cobbler began to weep, "Oh, my Lord is so wonderful, He can do anything."

"Do you really believe that the Lord can push an elephant through the hole of a needle?" Närada asked.

"Why not?" the cobbler said, "Of course I believe it."

"How is that?"

"You can see that I am sitting under this banyan tree," the cobbler answered, "and you can see that so many fruits are falling daily, and in each seed there is a banyan tree like this one. If, within a small seed there can be a big tree like this, is it difficult to accept that the Lord is pushing an elephant through the eye of a needle?"

So this is called faith. It is not a question of blindly believing. There is reason behind the belief. If Kåñëa can put a large tree within so many little seeds, is it so astounding that He is keeping all the planetary systems floating in space through His energy?

Although scientists may think that the planets are being held in space simply by nature alone, behind nature there is the Supreme Lord. Nature is acting under His guidance. As Çré Kåñëa states:

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sacaräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is being created and annihilated again and again." (Bg. 9.10)

Mayädhyakñena means "under My supervision." Material nature cannot act so wonderfully unless the Lord's hand is behind it. We cannot give any example of material things automatically working. Matter is inert, and without the spiritual touch there is no possibility of its acting. Matter cannot act independently or automatically. Machines may be very wonderfully constructed, but unless a man touches that machine, it cannot work. And what is that man? He is a spiritual spark. Without spiritual touch, nothing can move; therefore everything is resting on Kåñëa's impersonal energy. Kåñëa's energy is impersonal, but He is a person. We often hear of persons performing wonderful actions, yet despite their energetic accomplishments, they still remain persons. If this is possible for human beings, why isn't it possible for the Supreme Lord? We are all persons, but we are all dependent upon Kåñëa, the Supreme Person.

We have often seen pictures of Atlas, a stout man bearing a large planet on his shoulders and struggling very hard to hold it up. We may think that because Kåñëa is maintaining the universe, He is struggling under its burden like Atlas. But this is not the case.

na ca mat-sthäni bhütäni
paçya me yogam aiçvaram
bhüta-bhån na ca bhüta-stho
mamätmä bhüta-bhävanaù

"And yet everything that is created does not rest in Me. Behold My mystic opulence. Although I am the maintainer of all living entities and although I am everywhere, still My Self is the very source of creation." (Bg. 9.5)

Although all beings in the universe are resting in Kåñëa's energy, still they are not in Him. Kåñëa is maintaining all living entities, and His energy is all-pervading, yet He is elsewhere. This is Kåñëa's inconceivable mystic power. He is everywhere, yet He is aloof from everything. We can perceive his energy, but we cannot see Him because He cannot be seen with material eyes. However, when we develop our spiritual qualities, we sanctify our senses so that even within this energy we can see Him. Electricity, for instance, is everywhere, and an electrician is capable of utilizing it. Similarly, the energy of the Supreme Lord is everywhere, and when we become transcendentally situated, we can see God eye to eye everywhere. That spiritualization of the senses is possible through devotional service and love of God. The Lord is all-pervading all over the universe and is within the soul, the heart, water, air—everywhere. Thus if we make an image of God in anything—clay, stone, wood or whatever—it should not be considered to be just a doll. That also is God. If we have sufficient devotion, the image will also speak to us. God is everywhere impersonally (mayä tatam idaà sarvam), but if we make His personal form from anything, or if we create an image of God within ourselves, He will be present personally for us. In the çästras, there are eight kinds of images recommended, and any kind of image can be worshiped because God is everywhere. One may protest and ask, "Why should God be worshiped in images and not in His original spiritual form?" The answer is that we cannot see God immediately in His spiritual form. With our material eyes we can only see stone, earth, wood—something tangible. Therefore Kåñëa comes as arcä-vigraha, a form conveniently presented by the Supreme Lord in order for us to see Him. The result is that if we concentrate upon the image and make offerings with love and devotion, Kåñëa will respond through the image.

There are many instances of this happening. In India, there is one temple called Säkñi-Gopäla (Kåñëa is often called Gopäla). The Gopäla mürti or statue was at one time located in a temple in Våndävana. Once two brähmaëas, one old and one young, went to visit Våndävana on a pilgrimage. It was a long trip, and in those days there were no railways, so travelers underwent many hardships. The old man was much obliged to the youth for helping him on the journey, and upon arriving in Våndävana, he said to him: "My dear boy, you have rendered me so much service, and I am much obliged to you. I would like very much to return that service and give you some reward."

"My dear sir," the youth said, "you are an old man just like my father. It is my duty to serve you. I don't require any reward."

"No, I'm obliged to you, and I must reward you," the old man insisted. He then promised to give the young man his young daughter in marriage.

The old man was a very rich man, and the youth, although a learned brähmaëa, was very poor. Considering this, the youth said, "Don't promise this, for your family will never agree. I am such a poor man, and you are aristocratic, so this marriage will not take place. Don't promise this way before the Deity."

The conversation was taking place in the temple before the Deity of Gopäla Kåñëa, and the young man was anxious not to offend the Deity. However, despite the youth's pleas, the old man insisted on the marriage. After staying in Våndävana for some time, they finally returned home, and the old man informed his eldest son that his young sister was to be married to the poor brähmaëa youth. The eldest son became very angry. "Oh, how have you selected that pauper as husband for my sister? This cannot be."

The old man's wife also came to him and said, "If you marry our daughter to that boy, I shall commit suicide."

The old man was thus perplexed. After some time, the brähmaëa youth became very anxious. "He has promised to marry his daughter to me, and he made that promise before the Deity. Now he is not coming to fulfill it." He then went to see the old man to remind him of his promise.

"You promised before Lord Kåñëa," the youth said, "and you are not fulfilling that promise. How is that?"

The old man was silent. He began praying to Kåñëa, for he was perplexed. He didn't want to marry his daughter to the youth and cause such great trouble within his family. In the meantime the elder son came out and began to accuse the brähmaëa youth. "You have plundered my father in the place of pilgrimage. You gave him some intoxicant and took all his money, and now you are saying that he has promised to offer you my youngest sister. You rascal!"

In this way there was much noise, and people began to gather. The youth could understand that the old man was still agreeable but that the family was making it difficult for him. People began to gather about because of the noise which the elder son was raising, and the brähmaëa youth began to exclaim to them that the old man made this promise before the Deities but that he could not fulfill it because the family was objecting. The eldest son, who was an atheist, suddenly interrupted the youth and said, "You say that the Lord was witnessing. Well, if He comes and bears witness to this promise of my father's, you can have my sister in marriage."

The youth replied, "Yes, I shall ask Kåñëa to come as a witness." He was confident that God would come. An agreement was then made before everyone that the girl would be given in marriage if Kåñëa came from Våndävana as a witness to the old man's promise.

The brähmaëa youth returned to Våndävana and began to pray to Gopäla Kåñëa. "Dear Lord, You must come with me." He was such a staunch devotee that he spoke to Kåñëa just as one would speak to a friend. He was not thinking that the Gopäla was a mere statue or image, but he considered Him to be God Himself. Suddenly the Deity spoke to him:

"How do you think that I can go with you? I am a statue. I can't go anywhere."

"Well, if a statue can speak, he can also walk," the boy replied.

"All right then," the Deity said finally. "I shall go with you, but on one condition. In no case shall you look back to see Me. I will follow you, and you will know that I am following by the jingle of My leg bangles."

The youth agreed, and in this way they left Våndävana to go to the other town. When the trip was nearly over, just as they were about to enter his home village, the youth could no longer hear the sound of the bangles, and he began to fear. "Oh, where is Kåñëa?" Unable to contain himself any longer, he looked back. He saw the statue standing still. Because he looked back, it would go no further. He immediately ran into the town and told the people to come out and see Kåñëa who had come as a witness. Everyone was astounded that such a large statue had come from such a distance, and they built a temple on the spot in honor of the Deity, and today people are still worshiping Säkñi-Gopäla, the Lord as a witness.

We should therefore conclude that because God is everywhere, He is also in His statue, in the image made of Him. If Kåñëa is everywhere, as even the impersonalists admit, then why isn't He in His image? Whether an image or statue speaks to us or not is dependent on the degree of our devotion. But if we choose to see the image merely as a piece of wood or stone, Kåñëa will always remain wood or stone for us. Kåñëa is everywhere, but as we advance in spiritual consciousness we can begin to see Him as He is. If we put a letter into a mailbox, it will go to its destination because the mailbox is authorized. Similarly, if we worship an authorized image of God, our faith will have some effect. If we are prepared to follow the various rules and regulations—that is to say, if we become qualified—it is possible to see God anywhere and everywhere. When a devotee is present, Kåñëa, by His omnipresent energies, will manifest Himself anywhere and everywhere, but when His devotee is not there, He will not do this. There are many instances of this. Prahläda Mahäräja saw Kåñëa in a pillar. There are many other examples. Kåñëa is there; all that is required is our qualification to see Him.

Kåñëa Himself gives an example of His omnipresence in this way:

yathäkäça sthito nityaà
väyuù sarvatra-go mahän
tathä sarväëi bhütäni
mat-sthänéty upadhäraya

"As the mighty wind, blowing everywhere, always rests in ethereal space, know that in the same manner all beings rest in Me." (Bg. 9.6)

Everyone knows that the wind blows within space, and on earth it is blowing everywhere. There is no place where there is no air or wind. If we wish to drive out air, we have to create a vacuum artificially by some machine. Just as the air is blowing everywhere in space, so everything is existing within Kåñëa. If this is the case, when the material creation is dissolved, where does it go?

sarva-bhütäni kaunteya
prakåtià yänti mämikäm
kalpa-kñaye punas täni
kalpädau visåjämy aham

"O son of Kunté, at the end of the millennium every material manifestation enters into My nature, and at the beginning of another millennium, by My potency I again create." (Bg. 9.7)

Kåñëa sets His nature (prakåti) into motion, as one may wind up a clock, and when nature unwinds, it is absorbed into the Lord. The spiritual creation, however, is not like this, for it is permanent. In the material creation everything is temporary. Just as our bodies are developing due to the spiritual spark that is within, the whole creation is coming into being, developing and passing out of being, due to the spirit of the Lord which is within it. Just as our spirit is present within the body, the Lord is present within the universe as Paramätmä. Due to the presence of Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu, the material creation exists, just as due to our presence our bodies are existing. Sometimes Kåñëa manifests the material creation, and sometimes He does not. In all cases, its existence is due to His presence.

RV 4: Knowledge by Way of the Mahätmäs, Great Souls

4
Knowledge by Way of the Mahätmäs, Great Souls

[661128BG.NY] [661127BG.NY] [661201BG.NY]

The presence of Kåñëa in all aspects of the creation is perceived by the mahätmäs, the great souls, who are always engaged in the worship of Kåñëa. As Kåñëa Himself states, these great souls are conversant with the confidential knowledge found in the Ninth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, and they know Kåñëa to be the source of all things.

mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha
daivéà prakåtim äçritäù
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jïätvä bhütädim avyayam

"O son of Påthä, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible." (Bg. 9.13)

The great soul knows without a doubt that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and that He is the origin of all emanations. The Vedänta-sütra states, athäto brahma-jijïäsä: Human life is meant for inquiring about Brahman. At present we are all engaged in studying temporary, small things. Brahman means the greatest, but instead of concerning ourselves with the greatest, we have become enmeshed in trying to solve the animal problems of eating, sleeping, defending and mating. These small problems are automatically solved. Even the animals are enjoying mating, sleeping, eating and defending. The arrangements are all provided. These demands of the body are not really problems, but we have made them into problems. The Vedänta-sütra enjoins us not to concern ourselves with these problems, for they are satisfied in any form of life. Our problem is to inquire about the source of all these manifestations. The human form of life is not meant for struggling hard to solve the material problems which even a hog, a stool-eater, can solve. The hog is considered to be the lowest among animals, yet he has eating facility, mating facility, sleeping facility, and facilities for defense. Even if we don't strive for these things, we will have them. Man is meant, rather, to find out the source from which all these things are coming. The Vedänta-sütra states that Brahman is that from which everything is emanating (janmädy asya yataù). Philosophers, scientists, yogés, jïänés and transcendentalists are all trying to find out the ultimate source of everything. This source is given in Brahma-saàhitä, sarva-käraëa-käraëam: Kåñëa is the cause of all causes.

Understanding Kåñëa to be the primal source of everything, how do the great souls act? Kåñëa Himself characterizes them in this way:

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate

"Always chanting My glories, endeavoring with great determination, bowing down before Me, these great souls perpetually worship Me with devotion." (Bg. 9.14)

That glorification is this process of bhakti-yoga, the chanting of Hare Kåñëa. The great souls, understanding the nature of God, His descent and His mission, glorify Him in so many ways, but there are others who do not accept Him. Kåñëa also mentions them in the Ninth Chapter:

avajänanti mäà müòhä
mänuñéà tanum äçritam
paraà bhävam ajänanto
mama bhüta-maheçvaram

"Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and my supreme dominion over all that be." (Bg. 9.11)

The müòhas, or foolish men, who are lower than the animals, deride Him. Any person who doesn't believe in God must either be a madman or fool number one. There is no reason not to believe in God, and there is every reason to believe in Him. Man may say that he doesn't believe in God, but who gives him the power to say this? When death comes, this speaking power ceases—so who is giving the power of speech? Has the speaking power come automatically from stone? As soon as the speaking power is withdrawn by the Supreme Authority, the body is no better than stone. The very power of speech is proof that there is a Supreme Power who is giving us everything. A Kåñëa conscious person knows that whatever he has is not under his control. If we do not believe in God, we must believe in some power beyond us which is controlling us at every step, call that power God or nature or whatever. There is a controlling power in the universe, and no sane man can deny it.

Kåñëa was present on this earth and appeared just like a human being with supernatural power. At that time, however, ninety-nine percent of the people could not recognize Him as God. They could not recognize Him because they had no eyes to see (paraà bhävam ajänantaù). How is it possible to recognize God? He can be recognized through supernatural power, by the evidence of authorities, and by scriptural evidence. As far as Kåñëa is concerned, every Vedic authority has accepted Him as God. When He was present on earth, His activities displayed were superhuman. If one does not believe this, it is to be concluded that he will not believe whatever evidence is given.

One must also have the eyes to see God. God cannot be seen by material senses, therefore the bhakti-yoga process is the process of purifying the senses so that we will be able to understand what and who God is. We have power of seeing, hearing, touching, tasting and so on, but if these senses are blunt, we cannot understand God. The process of Kåñëa consciousness is the process of training these senses through regulated principles, specifically through the chanting of Hare Kåñëa.

Çré Kåñëa further characterizes the müòhas:

moghäçä mogha-karmäëo
mogha-jïänä vicetasaù
räkñasém äsuréà caiva
prakåtià mohinéà çritäù

"Those who are thus bewildered are attracted by demonic and atheistic views. In that deluded condition, their hopes for liberation, their fruitive activities, and their culture of knowledge are all defeated." (Bg. 9.12)

The word moghäçä indicates that the aspirations of the atheists will be baffled. The karmés, or fruitive laborers, are always hoping for something better to gratify their senses. There is no limit to where they will stop. They are trying to increase their bank balance and are hoping to be happy at a certain point, but that point never comes because they do not know the ultimate point of satiation. Those who are enamored by the attractions of illusory energy cannot understand the ultimate aim of life. The word mogha-karmäëaù indicates that they are laboring very hard but that in the end they will only meet with frustration. Unless we are established in Kåñëa consciousness, all of our activities will be baffled at the end.

This is not the verdict of an ordinary man, but of Çré Kåñëa Himself. If we are searching for knowledge, we should conduct research to find out whether Kåñëa is not God. Without any objective, what is the point of thousands of years of speculation? The Supreme Lord is so vast that one cannot reach Him by mental speculation. If we travel at the speed of mind and wind for millions of years, it is not possible to reach the Supreme by speculation. There is not one single instance in which one has arrived at the Supreme Absolute Truth by means of his own mental speculation. Therefore the word mogha-jïänäù indicates that the process of mundane knowledge is bewildering. Through our own endeavor it is not possible to see the sun after it has set. We have to wait until the sun reveals itself in the morning at sunrise. If it is not possible with our limited senses to perceive a material thing like the sun, how is it possible to perceive the nonmaterial? We cannot find out or understand Kåñëa by our own endeavor. We have to qualify ourselves through Kåñëa consciousness and wait for Him to reveal Himself.

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." (Bg. 10.10)

Kåñëa is within, but due to our material conditioning, we do not realize it. Those who are of the nature of fiends and demons (räkñasém äsurém) think that this material life is all and that it is the purpose of human life to squeeze out as much pleasure from matter as possible. They try squeezing, but they are constantly baffled. Squeezing material nature is not the process for finding out real pleasure. If we are searching for real pleasure, we have to take to Kåñëa consciousness. All happiness in the material world has a beginning and an end, but happiness in Kåñëa is unlimited, and there is no end. In order to get this happiness we simply have to sacrifice a little time and chant Hare Kåñëa. In former ages, the great sages and demigods used to sacrifice their whole lives for realizing the Supreme, and still they would not attain success. For this age Caitanya Mahäprabhu has given an easy process for God realization. All that is necessary is careful listening. We have to listen to Bhagavad-gétä, and we have to chant the names of Kåñëa and listen to them carefully. We should not be puffed up, falsely thinking that our knowledge is great or that we are very learned. We need only become a little gentle and submissive to hear the messages from Kåñëa.

At present, this world is being managed by the räkñasas. The räkñasas are man-eaters who eat their own sons for the satisfaction of their senses. Now great regimes have been created to smash so many people for the satisfaction of the räkñasas senses, but they do not realize that their senses will never be satisfied in this way. Nonetheless, the räkñasas are prepared to sacrifice everything to satisfy their whimsical desires. It is very difficult for them to understand the real situation because they are overly enamored with material civilization. Who then can understand? Those who are mahätmäs, whose hearts have become magnified, understand that "everything belongs to God, and I also belong to God."

Such mahätmäs are not under the control of material nature (mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha daivéà prakåtim äçritäù). God is great and the mahätmä's heart also becomes great by serving the great. Mahätmä is not a stamp for a political leader. One cannot be stamped mahätmä by votes. The standard for mahätmä is given in Bhagavad-gétä: the mahätmä is he who has taken shelter of the superior energy of the Lord. Of course all energies are His, and He does not make distinctions between spiritual energy and material energy, but for the conditioned soul who is situated marginally between material energy and spiritual energy, there is a distinction. The mahätmäs see this distinction and so take shelter under the spiritual energy (daivéà prakåtim).

By serving the great, the mahätmäs also become great through identifying with the superior energy: (ahaà brahmäsmi) "I am Brahman—spirit." It is not that they become puffed up and think that they are God. Rather, if one becomes Brahman, he must show his activities in Brahman. Spirit is active, and to become Brahman is not to become inactive. Brahman is spirit, and these material bodies are active only because Brahman is within them. If we are active despite our contact with material nature, do we cease to be active when we purify ourselves of the material contamination and establish ourselves in our proper identity as pure Brahman? Realizing "I am Brahman" means engagement in spiritual activity because we are spirit, and our activities are exhibited even though we are contaminated by matter. To become Brahman does not mean to become void but to establish ourselves in the superior nature, which means superior energy and superior activities. To become Brahman means to be completely engaged in rendering devotional service to the Lord. Thus the mahätmä understands that if service is to be rendered, it is to be to Kåñëa and no one else. We have so long served our senses; now we should serve Kåñëa.

There is no question of stopping service, for we are meant for service. Is there anyone who does not serve? If we ask the President, "Who are you serving?" he will tell us that he is serving the country. No one is devoid of service. Service we cannot stop, but we do have to redirect our service from the illusion to the reality. When this is done, we become mahätmä. This process of kértana (kértayantaù), always chanting the glories of the Lord, is the beginning of mahätmä. That process is simplified by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu who imparted to mankind this chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

There are nine different processes of devotional service, of which çravaëaà kértanam, hearing and chanting, are the most important. Kértanam actually means "describing." We can describe with music, words, pictures, etc. Çravaëam goes hand in hand with kértanam, for unless we hear, we cannot describe. We don't need any material qualifications in order to attain the Supreme. All we have to do is hear from authoritative sources and repeat accurately what we hear.

Formerly, the Vedas were heard by the student from the spiritual master, and thus the Vedas became known as çruti, meaning "that which is heard." In Bhagavad-gétä, for example, we see that Arjuna is listening to Kåñëa on the battlefield. He is not engaged in the study of Vedänta philosophy. We can hear from the Supreme Authority in any place, even in the battlefield. The knowledge is received, not manufactured. Some people think, "Why should I listen to Him? I can think for myself. I can manufacture something new." This is not the Vedic process of descending knowledge. By ascending knowledge, one tries to elevate himself by his own effort, but by descending knowledge one receives the knowledge from a superior source. In the Vedic tradition, knowledge is imparted to the student from the spiritual master, as in Bhagavad-gétä (evaà paramparä-präptam imaà räjarñayo viduù). Submissive hearing is so powerful that simply by hearing from authoritative sources we can become completely perfect. In becoming submissive, we become aware of our own imperfections. As long as we are conditioned, we are subject to four kinds of imperfections: we are sure to commit mistakes, to become illusioned, to have imperfect senses and to cheat. Therefore our attempt to understand the Absolute Truth by our faulty senses and experience is futile. We must hear from a representative of Kåñëa who is a devotee of Kåñëa's. Kåñëa made Arjuna His representative because Arjuna was His devotee: bhakto 'si me sakhä ceti.

No one can become a representative of God without being a devotee of God's. One who thinks, "I am God," cannot be a representative. Because we are part and parcel of God, our qualities are the same as His, and therefore if we study these qualities in ourselves, we come to learn something of God. This does not mean that we understand the quantity of God. This self-realization process is one way of understanding God, but in no case can we preach, "I am God." We cannot claim to be God without being able to display the powers of God. As far as Kåñëa is concerned, He proved that He was God by displaying so much power and by revealing His universal form to Arjuna. Kåñëa showed this awesome form in order to discourage people who would claim to be God. We should not be fooled by one who claims to be God; following in the footsteps of Arjuna, we should request to see the universal form before accepting anyone as God. Only a fool would accept another fool as God.

No one can be equal to God, and no one can be above Him. Even Lord Brahmä and Çiva, the most exalted demigods, are subservient to Him and pay their respectful obeisances. Instead of trying to become God by some meditational process or other, we had better hear about God submissively and try to understand Him and our relationship to Him. The representative of God or the incarnation of God never claims to be God but the servant of God. This is the sign of the bona fide representative.

Whatever we learn of God from authoritative sources can be described, and that will help us make spiritual progress. This description is called kértana. If we try to repeat what we hear, we become established in knowledge. By the process of çravaëaà kértanam, hearing and chanting, we can become free from material conditioning and attain to the kingdom of God. In this age it is impossible to practice sacrifice, speculation or yoga. There is no way open to us but the way of hearing submissively from authoritative sources. This is the way the mahätmäs received the most confidential knowledge. It is the way Arjuna received it from Kåñëa, and it is the way we must receive it from the disciplic succession stemming from Arjuna.

RV 5: Paramparä: Knowledge Through Disciplic Succession

5
Paramparä: Knowledge Through Disciplic Succession

[660713BG.NY] [660718BG.NY]

çré bhagavän uväca
imaà vivasvate yogaà
proktavän aham avyayam
vivasvän manave präha
manur ikñväkave 'bravét

"The Blessed Lord said: I instructed this imperishable science of yoga to the sun-god, Vivasvän, and Vivasvän instructed it to Manu, the father of mankind, and Manu in turn instructed it to Ikñväku." (Bg. 4.1)

Many ages ago Kåñëa imparted the divine knowledge of Bhagavad-gétä to Vivasvän, the god of the sun. To the best of our knowledge, the sun is a very hot place, and we do not consider it possible for anyone to live there. It is not even possible to approach the sun very closely with these bodies. However, from the Vedic literatures we can understand that the sun is a planet just like this one but that everything there is composed of fire. Just as this planet is predominately composed of earth, there are other planets which are predominately composed of fire, water and air.

The living entities on these various planets acquire bodies composed of elements in accordance with the predominating element on the planet; therefore those beings who live on the sun have bodies which are composed of fire. Of all beings on the sun, the principal personality is a god by the name of Vivasvän. He is known as the sun-god (sürya-näräyaëa). On all planets there are principal personalities, just as in the United States the chief person is the President. From the history called the Mahäbhärata we understand that formerly there was only one king on this planet by the name of Mahäräja Bharata. He ruled some 5,000 years ago, and the planet was named after him. Subsequently the earth has become divided into so many different countries. In this way there is usually one and sometimes many controllers of the various planets in the universe.

From this first verse of the Fourth Chapter we learn that millions of years ago Çré Kåñëa imparted the knowledge of karma-yoga to the sun god Vivasvän. Çré Kåñëa, who imparts the teachings of Bhagavad-gétä to Arjuna, here indicates that these teachings are not at all new but were enunciated many ages ago on a different planet. Vivasvän, in his turn, repeated these teachings to his son, Manu. In turn, Manu imparted the knowledge to his disciple Ikñväku. Mahäräja Ikñväku was a great king and forefather of Lord Rämacandra. The point being made here is that if one wants to learn Bhagavad-gétä and profit by it, there is a process for understanding it, and that process is described here. It is not that Kåñëa is speaking Bhagavad-gétä to Arjuna for the first time. It is estimated by Vedic authorities that the Lord imparted these divine instructions to Vivasvän some 400 million years ago. From the Mahäbhärata we understand that Bhagavad-gétä was spoken to Arjuna some 5,000 years ago. Before Arjuna, the teachings were handed down by disciplic succession, but over such a long period of time, the teachings became lost.

evaà paramparä-präptam
imaà räjarñayo viduù
sa käleneha mahatä
yogo nañöaù parantapa

sa eväyaà mayä te 'dya
yogaù proktaù purätanaù
bhakto 'si me sakhä ceti
rahasyaà hy etad uttamam

"This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way. But in course of time the succession was broken, and therefore the science as it is appears to be lost. That very ancient science of the relationship with the Supreme is today told by Me to you because you are My devotee as well as My friend; therefore you can understand the transcendental mystery of this science." (Bg. 4.2-3)

In Bhagavad-gétä a number of yoga systems are delineated—bhakti-yoga, karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga, haöha-yoga—and therefore it is here called yoga. The word yoga means "to link up," and the idea is that in yoga we link our consciousness to God. It is a means for reuniting with God or re-establishing our relationship with Him. In the course of time, this yoga imparted by Çré Kåñëa was lost. Why is this? Were there no learned sages at the time Çré Kåñëa was speaking to Arjuna? No, there were many sages present at the time. By "lost" it is meant that the purport of Bhagavad-gétä was lost. Scholars may give their own interpretation of Bhagavad-gétä, analyzing it according to their own whims, but that is not Bhagavad-gétä. This is the point that Çré Kåñëa is stressing, and a student of Bhagavad-gétä should note it. A person may be a very good scholar from the material point of view, but that does not qualify him to comment on Bhagavad-gétä. In order to understand Bhagavad-gétä, we have to accept the principle of disciplic succession (paramparä). We must enter into the spirit of Bhagavad-gétä and not approach it simply from the viewpoint of erudition.

Of all people, why did Çré Kåñëa select Arjuna as a recipient of this knowledge? Arjuna was not a great scholar at all, nor was he a yogé, meditator or a holy man. He was a warrior about to engage in battle. There were many great sages living at the time, and Çré Kåñëa could have given Bhagavad-gétä to them. The answer is that despite being an ordinary man, Arjuna had one great qualification: bhakto 'si me sakhä ceti: "You are My devotee and My friend." This was Arjuna's exceptional qualification, a qualification which the sages did not have. Arjuna knew that Kåñëa was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and therefore he surrendered himself unto Him, accepting Him as his spiritual master. Unless one is a devotee of Lord Kåñëa's, he cannot possibly understand Bhagavad-gétä. If one wants to understand Bhagavad-gétä, he cannot take help from other methods. He must understand it as prescribed in Bhagavad-gétä itself, by understanding it as Arjuna understood it. If we wish to understand Bhagavad-gétä in a different way, or give an individual interpretation, that may be an exhibition of our scholarship, but it is not Bhagavad-gétä.

By scholarship we may be able to manufacture some theory of Bhagavad-gétä, just as Mahätmä Gandhi did when he interpreted Bhagavad-gétä in an effort to support his theory of nonviolence. How is it possible to prove nonviolence from Bhagavad-gétä? The very theme of Bhagavad-gétä involves Arjuna's reluctance to fight and Kåñëa's inducing him to kill his opponents. In fact, Kåñëa tells Arjuna that the battle had already been decided by the Supreme, that the people who were assembled on the battlefield were predestined never to return. It was Kåñëa's program that the warriors were all destined to die, and Kåñëa gave Arjuna the opportunity of taking the credit of conquering them. If fighting is proclaimed a necessity in Bhagavad-gétä, how is it possible to prove nonviolence from it? Such interpretations are attempts to distort Bhagavad-gétä. As soon as the Gétä is interpreted according to the motive of an individual, the purpose is lost. It is stated that we cannot attain the conclusion of the Vedic literature by the force of our own logic or argument. There are many things which do not come within the jurisdiction of our sense of logic. As far as scriptures are concerned, we find different scriptures describing the Absolute Truth in different ways. If we analyze all of them, there will be bewilderment. There are also many philosophers with different opinions, and they're always contradicting one another. If the truth cannot be understood by reading various scriptures, by logical argument or philosophical theories, then how can it be attained? The fact is that the wisdom of the Absolute Truth is very confidential, but if we follow the authorities, it can be understood.

In India, there are disciplic successions coming from Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Nimbärka, Viñëusvämé and other great sages. The Vedic literatures are understood through the superior spiritual masters. Arjuna understood Bhagavad-gétä from Kåñëa, and if we wish to understand it, we have to understand it from Arjuna, not from any other source. If we have any knowledge of Bhagavad-gétä, we have to see how it tallies with the understanding of Arjuna. If we understand Bhagavad-gétä in the same way that Arjuna did, we should know that our understanding is correct. This should be the criteria for our studying of Bhagavad-gétä. If we actually want to receive benefit from Bhagavad-gétä, we have to follow this principle. Bhagavad-gétä is not an ordinary book of knowledge which we can purchase from the market place, read and merely consult a dictionary to understand. This is not possible. If it were, Kåñëa would never have told Arjuna that the science was lost.

It is not difficult to understand the necessity of going through the disciplic succession to understand Bhagavad-gétä. If we wish to be a lawyer, an engineer or doctor, we have to receive knowledge from the authoritative lawyers, engineers and doctors. A new lawyer has to become an apprentice of an experienced lawyer, or a young man studying to be a doctor has to become an intern and work with those who are already licensed practitioners. Our knowledge of a subject cannot be perfectionalized unless we receive it through authoritative sources.

There are two processes for attaining knowledge—one is inductive and the other is deductive. The deductive method is considered to be more perfect. We may take a premise such as, "All men are mortal," and no one need discuss how man is mortal. It is generally accepted that this is the case. The deductive conclusion is: "Mr. Johnson is a man; therefore Mr. Johnson is mortal." But how is the premise that all men are mortal arrived at? Followers of the inductive method wish to arrive at this premise through experiment and observations. We may thus study that this man died and that man died, etc., and after seeing that so many men have died we may conclude or generalize that all men are mortal, but there is a major defect in this inductive method, and that is that our experience is limited. We may never have seen a man who is not mortal, but we are judging this on our personal experience, which is finite. Our senses have limited power, and there are so many defects in our conditional state. The inductive process consequently is not always perfect, whereas the deductive process from a source of perfect knowledge is perfect. The Vedic process is such a process.

Although the authority is acknowledged, there are many passages in Bhagavad-gétä which appear to be dogmatic. For instance, in the Seventh Chapter Çré Kåñëa says:

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conqueror of wealth (Arjuna), there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7)

Çré Kåñëa is saying that there is no authority greater than Him, and this appears to be very dogmatic. If I say, "There is no one greater than me," people would think, "Oh, Sväméjé is very proud." If a man who is conditioned by so many imperfections says that he is the greatest of all, he blasphemes. But Kåñëa can say this, for we can understand from the histories that even while He was on this earth, He was considered the greatest personality of His time. Indeed, He was the greatest in all fields of activity.

According to the Vedic system, knowledge which is achieved from the greatest authority is to be considered perfect. According to the Vedas, there are three kinds of proof: pratyakña, anumäna and çabda. One is by direct visual perception. If a person is sitting in front of me, I can see him sitting there, and my knowledge of his sitting there is received through my eyes. The second method, anumäna, is auricular: we may hear children playing outside, and by hearing we can conjecture that they are there. And the third method is the method of taking truths from a higher authority. Such a saying as "Man is mortal" is accepted from higher authorities. Everyone accepts this, but no one has experienced that all men are mortal. By tradition, we have to accept this. If someone asks, "Who found this truth first? Did you discover it?" it is very difficult to say. All we can say is that the knowledge is coming down and that we accept it. Out of the three methods of acquiring knowledge, the Vedas say that the third method, that of receiving knowledge from higher authorities, is the most perfect. Direct perception is always imperfect, especially in the conditional stage of life. By direct perception we can see that the sun is just like a disc, no larger than the plate we eat on. From scientists, however, we come to understand that the sun is many thousands of times larger than the earth. So what are we to accept? Are we to accept the scientific proclamation, the proclamation of authorities, or our own experience? Although we cannot ourselves prove how large the sun is, we accept the verdict of astronomers. In this way we are accepting the statements of authorities in every field of our activities. From newspapers and radio we also understand that such and such events are taking place in China and India and other places all around the earth. We're not experiencing these events directly, and we don't know that such events are actually taking place, but we accept the authority of the newspapers and radio. We have no choice but to believe authorities in order to get knowledge. And when the authority is perfect, our knowledge is perfect.

According to the Vedic sources, of all authorities Kåñëa is the greatest and most perfect (mattaù parataraà nänyät kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya). Not only does Kåñëa proclaim Himself to be the highest authority, but this is also accepted by great sages and scholars of Bhagavad-gétä. If we do not accept Kåñëa as authority and take His words as they are, we cannot derive any benefit from Bhagavad-gétä. It is not dogmatic; it is a fact. If we study scrutinizingly what Kåñëa says, we will find that it is right. Even scholars like Çaìkaräcärya, who have different opinions from the Personality of Godhead, admit that Kåñëa is svayaà bhagavän—Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord.

Vedic knowledge is not a recent discovery. It is all old revealed knowledge. Kåñëa refers to it as purätanaù, which means ancient. Kåñëa says that millions of years before He spoke this yoga to the sun god, and we do not know how many millions of years before that He spoke it to someone else. This knowledge is always being repeated, just as summer, autumn, winter and spring are repeated every year. Our fund of knowledge is very poor; we do not even know the history of this planet more than 5,000 years back, but the Vedic literatures give us histories extending millions of years ago. Just because we have no knowledge of what happened 3,000 years ago on this planet, we cannot conclude that there was no history then. Of course one can disclaim the historical validity of Kåñëa. One may say that Kåñëa, according to Mahäbhärata, lived 5,000 years ago, and this being the case, there is no possibility of His having spoken Bhagavad-gétä to the sun god so many millions of years before. If I said that I gave a speech on the sun some millions of years ago to the sun god, people would say, "Sväméjé is speaking some nonsense." But this is not the case with Kåñëa, for He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Whether we believe that Kåñëa spoke Bhagavad-gétä to the sun god or not, this fact is being accepted by Arjuna. Arjuna accepted Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord, and therefore he knew that it was quite possible for Kåñëa to have spoken to someone millions of years before. Although Arjuna personally accepts the statements of Çré Kåñëa, in order to clarify the situation for people who would come after him, he asks:

aparaà bhavato janma
paraà janma vivasvataù
katham etad vijänéyäà
tvam ädau proktavän iti

"The sun-god Vivasvän is senior by birth to You. How am I to understand that in the beginning You instructed this science to him?" (Bg. 4.4)

Actually this is a very intelligent question, and Kåñëa answers it in this way:

bahüni me vyatétäni
janmäni tava cärjuna
täny ahaà veda sarväëi
na tvaà vettha parantapa

"Many, many births both you and I have passed. I can remember all of them, but you cannot, O subduer of the enemy!" (Bg. 4.5)

Although Kåñëa is God, He incarnates many, many times. Arjuna, being a living entity, also takes his birth many, many times. The difference between the Supreme Personality of Godhead and a living entity is, täny ahaà veda sarväëi: Kåñëa remembers the events of His past incarnations, whereas the living entity cannot remember. That is one of the differences between God and man. God is eternal, and we are also eternal, but the difference is that we are always changing our bodies. At death we forget the events of our lifetime; death means forgetfulness, that's all. At night, when we go to sleep, we forget that we are the husband of such and such a wife and the father of such and such children. We forget ourselves in sleep, but when we wake up, we remember, "Oh, I am so and so, and I must do such and such." It is a fact that in our previous lives we had other bodies with other families, fathers, mothers and so on in other countries, but we have forgotten all of these. We might have been dogs or cats or men or gods—whatever we were we have now forgotten.

Despite all these changes, as living entities, we are eternal. Just as in previous lives we have prepared for this body, in this lifetime we are preparing for another body. We get our bodies according to our karma, or activities. Those who are in the mode of goodness are promoted to higher planets, in a higher status of life (Bg. 14.14). Those who die in the mode of passion remain on earth, and those who die in the mode of ignorance may fall into the animal species of life or may be transferred to a lower planet (Bg. 14.15). This is the process that has been going on, but we forget it.

At one time, Indra, the king of heaven, committed an offense at the feet of his spiritual master, and his spiritual master cursed him to take the birth of a hog. Thus the throne of the heavenly kingdom became empty as Indra went to earth to become a hog. Seeing the situation, Brahmä came to earth and addressed the hog: "My dear sir, you have become a hog on this planet earth. I have come to deliver you. Come with me at once." But the hog replied: "Oh I cannot go with you. I have so many responsibilities—my children, wife and this nice hog society." Even though Brahmä promised to take him back to heaven, Indra, in the form of a hog, refused. This is called forgetfulness. Similarly, Lord Çré Kåñëa comes and says to us, "What are you doing in this material world? Sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja. Come to Me, and I'll give you all protection." But we say, "I don't believe You Sir. I have more important business here." This is the position of the conditioned soul—forgetfulness. This forgetfulness is quickly dissipated by following in the path of disciplic succession.

RV 6: Knowledge of Kåñëa's Appearances and Activities

6
Knowledge of Kåñëa's Appearances and Activities

[660718BG.NY][660720BG.NY]

There are two forces of nature working in us. By one we decide that in this lifetime we will make spiritual advancement, but at the next moment the other force, mäyä, or illusory energy, says, "What is all this trouble that you're going to? Just enjoy this life and be easy with yourself." This tendency to fall into forgetfulness is the difference between God and man. Arjuna is a companion and associate of Kåñëa's, and whenever Kåñëa appears on any planet, Arjuna also takes birth and appears with Him. When Kåñëa spoke Bhagavad-gétä to the sun god, Arjuna was also present with Him. But, being a finite living entity, Arjuna could not remember. Forgetfulness is the nature of the living entity. We cannot even remember what we were doing at this exact time yesterday or a week ago. If we cannot remember this, how is it possible to remember what happened in our previous lives? At this point we may ask how it is that Kåñëa can remember and we cannot, and the answer is that Kåñëa does not change His body.

ajo 'pi sann avyayätmä
bhütänäm éçvaro 'pi san
prakåtià sväm adhiñöhäya
sambhavämy ätma-mäyayä

"Although I am unborn and My transcendental body never deteriorates, and although I am the Lord of all sentient beings, I still appear in every millennium in My original transcendental form." (Bg. 4.6)

The word ätma-mäyayä means that Kåñëa descends as He is. He does not change His body, but we, as conditioned souls, change ours, and because of this we forget. Kåñëa knows not only the past, present and future of His activities, but the past, present and future of everyone's activities.

vedähaà samatétäni
vartamänäni cärjuna
bhaviñyäëi ca bhütäni
mäà tu veda na kaçcana

"O Arjuna, as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, I know everything that has happened in the past, all that is happening in the present, and all things that are yet to come. I also know all living entities; but Me no one knows." (Bg. 7.26)

In Çrémad-Bhägavatam we also find that the Supreme Lord is defined as one who knows everything. This is not the case with even the most elevated living entities, such as Brahmä and Çiva. Only Viñëu or Kåñëa knows everything. We may also ask that if the Lord does not change His body, why does He come as an incarnation? There is much difference among philosophers concerning this question. Some say that Kåñëa assumes a material body when He comes, but this is not the case. If He assumed a material body like ours, He could not remember, for forgetfulness is due to the material body. The actual conclusion is that He doesn't change His body. God is called all-powerful, and in the verse quoted above, His omnipotence is explained. Kåñëa has no birth, and He is eternal. Similarly, the living entity has no birth, and he is also eternal. It is only the body with which the living entity identifies that takes birth.

In the very beginning of Bhagavad-gétä, in the Second Chapter, Kåñëa explains that what we accept as birth and death is due to the body, and as soon as we regain our spiritual body and get out of the contamination of birth and death, we should be qualitatively as good as Kåñëa. That is the whole process of Kåñëa consciousness—the revival of our original sac-cid-änanda spiritual body. That body is eternal (sat), full of knowledge (cit), and blissful (änanda). This material body is neither sat, cit, nor änanda. It is perishable, whereas the person who is occupying the body is imperishable. It is also full of ignorance, and because it is ignorant and temporary, it is full of misery. We feel severe hot or severe cold due to the material body, but as soon as we revive our spiritual body, we become unaffected by dualities. Even while within the material bodies there are yogés who are impervious to dualities such as heat and cold. As we begin to make spiritual advancement while in the material body, we begin to take on the qualities of a spiritual body. If we put iron into a fire, it becomes hot, and then it becomes red-hot, and finally it is no longer iron, but fire—whatever it touches bursts into flames. As we become advanced in Kåñëa consciousness, our material body will become spiritualized and will no longer be affected by material contamination.

Kåñëa's birth, His appearance and disappearance, are likened unto the appearance and disappearance of the sun. In the morning it appears as if the sun is born from the eastern horizon, but actually it is not. The sun is neither rising nor setting; it is as it is in its position. All risings and settings are due to the rotation of the earth. Similarly, in Vedic literatures there are prescribed schedules for the appearance and disappearance of Çré Kåñëa. Kåñëa's rising is just like the sun. The sun's rising and setting are going on at every moment; somewhere in the world people are witnessing sunrise and sunset. It is not that at one point Kåñëa is born and at another point He is gone. He is always there somewhere, but He appears to come and go. Kåñëa appears and disappears in many universes. We only have experience of this one universe, but from Vedic literatures we can understand that this universe is but a part of the infinite manifestations of the Supreme Lord.

Although Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord and is unborn and unchangeable, He appears in His original transcendental nature. The word prakåti means "nature." In the Seventh Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, it is stated that there are many kinds of nature. These have been categorized into three basic types. There is external nature, internal nature and marginal nature. The external nature is the manifestation of this material world, and in the Seventh Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä this is described as aparä or material nature. When Kåñëa appears, He accepts the higher nature (prakåtià sväm), not the inferior material nature. Sometimes the head of a state may go to the prison house in order to inspect the prison and see the inmates there, but the prisoners are in error if they think, "The head of the state has come to prison, so he is a prisoner just like us." As pointed out before, Çré Kåñëa states that fools deride Him when He descends in human form (Bg. 9.11).

Kåñëa, as the Supreme Lord, can come here at any time, and we cannot object and say that He cannot come. He is fully independent, and He can come and disappear as He likes. If the head of a state goes to visit a prison, we are not to assume that he is forced to do so. Kåñëa comes with a purpose, and that is to reclaim fallen conditioned souls. We do not love Kåñëa, but Kåñëa loves us. He claims everyone as His son.

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving Father." (Bg. 14.4)

The father is always affectionate to the son. The son may forget the father, but the father can never forget the son. Kåñëa comes to the material universe out of His love for us to deliver us from the miseries of birth and death. He says, "My dear sons, why are you rotting in this miserable world? Come to Me, and I'll give you all protection." We are sons of the Supreme, and we can enjoy life very supremely without any misery and without any doubt. Therefore we should not think that Kåñëa comes here just as we do, being obliged by the laws of nature.

The Sanskrit word avatära literally means "he who descends." One who descends from the spiritual universe into the material universe through his own will is called an avatära. Sometimes Çré Kåñëa descends Himself, and sometimes He sends His representative. The major religions of the world—Christian, Hindu, Buddhist and Moslem—believe in some supreme authority or personality coming down from the kingdom of God. In the Christian religion, Jesus Christ claimed to be the son of God and to be coming from the kingdom of God to reclaim conditioned souls. As followers of Bhagavad-gétä, we admit this claim to be true. So basically there is no difference of opinion. In details there may be differences due to differences in culture, climate and people, but the basic principle remains the same—that is, God or His representatives come to reclaim conditioned souls.

yadä yadä hi dharmasya
glänir bhavati bhärata
abhyutthänam adharmasya
tadätmänam såjämy aham

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time I descend Myself." (Bg. 4.7)

God is very compassionate. He wishes to see our miseries cease, but we are trying to adjust to these miseries. Because we are part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, we are not meant for these miseries, but somehow or other we have voluntarily accepted them. There are miseries arising from the body and mind, from other living entities and from natural catastrophes. We are either suffering from all three of these miseries, or at least from one. We are always trying to make a solution to these miseries, and this attempt constitutes our struggle for existence. That solution cannot be made by our tiny brain. It can be made only when we take to the shelter of the Supreme Lord.

We can become happy when we are reinstated in our constitutional position, and Bhagavad-gétä is meant to reinstate us in that position. God and His representative also come to help. As stated previously, they descend upon the material world from the superior nature and are not subject to the laws of birth, old age, disease and death. Kåñëa gives Arjuna the following reasons for His descent upon the world:

pariträëäya sädhünäà
vinäçäya ca duñkåtäm
dharma-saàsthäpanärthäya
sambhavämi yuge yuge

"In order to deliver the pious and to annihilate the miscreants, as well as to re-establish the principles of religion, I advent Myself millennium after millennium." (Bg. 4.8)

Here Kåñëa says that He comes when there is a decline in dharma. The Sanskrit word dharma has been translated into English as "faith," but faith has come to mean a religious system that goes under the name of Christian, Moslem, Hindu, Buddhist, etc. But the word dharma does not have the same meaning as faith. The faith of an individual may change from Hindu to Buddhist to Christian to Moslem, etc. People have the ability to accept one faith and reject another, but dharma cannot be changed. It is the nature of every individual to render service, either to himself, his family, his community, nation or to humanity at large. This rendering of service cannot in any way be divorced from the living entity, and it is this that constitutes the dharma of every living being. Without rendering service, one cannot exist. The world goes on because we are all rendering and exchanging service. We must forget whether we are Christian, Moslem or Hindu, and we must understand that we are living entities whose constitutional position is to render service to the supreme living entity. When we reach that stage of understanding, we are liberated.

Liberation is freedom from temporary designations which we have acquired from association with material nature. Liberation is nothing more than this. Because we have material bodies, we take on so many designations; thus we call ourselves a man, a parent, an American, a Christian, Hindu, etc. These designations should be abandoned if we at all want to become free. Under no circumstances are we master. We are at the present serving, but we are serving with designations. We're the servants of a wife, of a family, of a job, of our own senses, of our children, and if we have no children we become servants of our cats or dogs. In any case, we must have someone, something to serve. If we have no wife or child, we have to catch some dog or other lower animal in order to serve it. That is our nature. We are compelled to do it. When we at last become free from these designations and begin to render transcendental loving service to the Lord, we attain our perfectional state. We then become established in our true dharma.

Thus Çré Kåñëa says that He appears whenever there is a discrepancy in the dharma of the living entities, that is to say whenever the living entities cease rendering service to the Supreme. In other words, when the living entity is too busily engaged serving his senses, and there is an over-indulgence in sense gratification, the Lord comes. In India, for instance, when people were over-indulging in animal slaughter, Lord Buddha came to establish ahiàsä, nonviolence to all living entities. Similarly, in the above-quoted verse, Çré Kåñëa says that He comes in order to protect the sädhus (pariträëäya sädhünäà). Sädhus are typified by their toleration of all other living entities. Despite all inconveniences and dangers, they try to give real knowledge to the people in general. A sädhu is not the friend of a particular society, community or country but is a friend of all—not only of human beings, but of animals and lower forms of life. In short, the sädhu is an enemy of no one and a friend to all. Consequently he is always peaceful. Such persons who have sacrificed everything for the Lord are very, very dear to the Lord. Although the sädhus do not mind if they are insulted, Kåñëa does not tolerate any insult to them. As stated in the Ninth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa is alike to all, but He is especially inclined to His devotees:

samo 'haà sarva-bhüteñu
na me dveñyo 'sti na priyaù
ye bhajanti tu mäà bhaktyä
mayi te teñu cäpy aham

"I envy no one, nor am I partial to anyone. I am equal to all. But whoever renders service unto Me in devotion is a friend, is in Me, and I am also a friend to him." (Bg. 9.29)

Although Kåñëa is neutral to all, for one who is constantly engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, who is spreading the message of Bhagavad-gétä, He gives special protection. It is Çré Kåñëa's promise that His devotee shall never perish: kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati (Bg. 9.31).

Not only does Kåñëa come to protect and save His devotees, but also to destroy the wicked (vinäçäya ca duñkåtäm). Kåñëa wanted to establish Arjuna and the five Päëòavas, who were the most pious kñatriyas and devotees, as rulers of the world, and He also wanted to vanquish the atheistic party of Duryodhana. And as mentioned before, a third reason for His coming is to establish real religion (dharma-saàsthäpanärthäya). Thus Çré Kåñëa's purpose for coming is threefold: He protects His devotees, vanquishes the demonic, and establishes the real religion of the living entity. He comes not only once, but many, many times (sambhavämi yuge yuge) because this material world is such that in the course of time, after an adjustment is made, it will again deteriorate.

The world is so conceived that even if we make a very good arrangement, it will gradually deteriorate. After World War I an armistice was signed, and there was a short period of peace, but World War II soon came, and now that that is over they are making preparations for World War III. This is the function of time (käla) in the material world. We build up a very nice house, and after fifty years it deteriorates, and after one hundred years it deteriorates even more. Similarly, when the body is young, people care for it, always lavishing affection upon it and kissing it, but when it grows old no one cares for it. This is the nature of the material world—even if a very good adjustment is made, it will in course of time be vanquished. Therefore adjustments are periodically required, and from age to age the Supreme Lord or His representative come to make adjustments in the direction of civilization. Thus Çré Kåñëa descends many times to establish or rejuvenate many different religions.

RV 7: Knowledge as Faith in Guru and surrender to Kåñëa

7
Knowledge as Faith in Guru and Surrender to Kåñëa

[660814BG.NY] [660821BG.NY] [660817BG.NY]

In the Fourth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä Çré Kåñëa concludes that of all sacrifices, the best is the acquisition of knowledge.

çreyän dravya-mayäd yajïäj
jïäna-yajïaù parantapa
sarvaà karmäkhilaà pärtha
jïäne parisamäpyate

"O chastiser of the enemy, the sacrifice of knowledge is greater than the sacrifice of material possessions. O son of Påthä, after all, the sacrifice of work culminates in transcendental knowledge." (Bg. 4.33)

Knowledge is the best sacrifice because this conditional life is due to ignorance. The purpose of sacrifice, penance, yoga and philosophical discussion is to acquire knowledge. There are three stages of transcendental knowledge by which one realizes the impersonal aspect of God (Brahman realization), the localized aspect of God within the heart and within every atom (Paramätmä or Supersoul realization) and the realization of the Supreme Personality of Godhead (Bhagavän realization). But the very first step in acquiring knowledge is coming to understand that "I am not this body. I am spirit soul, and my aim of life is to get out of this material entanglement." The point is that whatever sacrifice we make is intended to enable us to come to the point of real knowledge. The highest perfection of knowledge is given in Bhagavad-gétä as surrender to Kåñëa (bahünäà janmanäm ante jïänavän mäà prapadyate) (Bg. 7.19). The jïänavän, not the fool, surrenders unto Kåñëa, and that is the highest stage of knowledge. Similarly, at the end of Bhagavad-gétä Çré Kåñëa advises Arjuna:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reaction. Do not fear." (Bg. 18.66)

This is the most confidential part of knowledge. From all points of view, if we make an analytical study of the Vedic literatures, we will find that the ultimate summit of knowledge is to surrender unto Kåñëa. And what type of surrender is recommended? Surrender in full knowledge—when one comes to the perfectional point he must understand that Väsudeva, Kåñëa, is everything. This is also confirmed in Brahma-saàhitä:

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù
sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù
anädir ädir govindaù
sarva-käraëa-käraëam

"Kåñëa, who is known as Govinda, is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal, blissful, spiritual body. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin, and He is the prime cause of all causes." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.1)

The words sarva-käraëa indicate that Kåñëa is the cause of all causes. If we search to see who the father of our father is, and who his father is, and so on back, if it were somehow possible to trace our ancestry back through time, we would arrive at the Supreme Father, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Of course everyone wants to see God immediately, but we can see God when we are qualified and in perfect knowledge. We can see God eye to eye, just as we are seeing one another, but qualification is required, and that qualification is Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa consciousness begins with çravaëam, hearing about Kåñëa through Bhagavad-gétä and other Vedic literatures, and kértanam, repeating what we've heard and glorifying Kåñëa by chanting His names. By chanting and hearing of Kåñëa we can actually associate with Him, for He is absolute and nondifferent from His names, qualities, forms and pastimes. As we associate with Kåñëa, He helps us to understand Him and dispels the darkness of ignorance with the light of knowledge. Kåñëa is sitting within our hearts acting as guru. When we begin hearing topics about Him, the dust which has accumulated on our minds due to so many years of material contamination becomes gradually cleaned. Kåñëa is a friend to everyone, but He is a special friend to His devotees. As soon as we become a little inclined toward Him, He begins to give favorable instructions from within our hearts so that we can gradually make progress. Kåñëa is the first spiritual master, and when we become more interested in Him, we have to go to a sädhu or holy man who serves as spiritual master from without. This is enjoined by Çré Kåñëa Himself in the following verse:

tad viddhi praëipätena
paripraçnena sevayä
upadekñyanti te jïänaà
jïäninas tattva-darçinaù

"Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth." (Bg. 4.34)

It is necessary to select a person to whom we can surrender ourselves. Of course no one likes to surrender to anyone. We are puffed up with whatever knowledge we have, and our attitude is, "Oh, who can give me knowledge?" Some people say that for spiritual realization there is no need for a spiritual master, but so far as Vedic literature is concerned, and as far as Bhagavad-gétä, Çrémad-Bhägavatam and the Upaniñads are concerned, there is need of a spiritual master. Even in the material world if one wants to learn to be a musician, he has to search out a musician to teach him, or if one wants to be an engineer, he has to go to a technological college and learn from those who know the technology. Nor can anyone become a doctor by simply purchasing a book from the market and reading it at home. One has to be admitted to a medical college and undergo training under licensed doctors. It is not possible to learn any major subject simply by purchasing books and reading them at home. Someone is needed to show us how to apply that knowledge which is found in the books. As far as the science of God is concerned, Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself, advises us to go to a person to whom we can surrender. This means that we have to check to see if a person is capable of giving instructions in Bhagavad-gétä and other literatures of God realization. It is not that we are to search out a spiritual master whimsically. We should be very serious to find a person who is actually in knowledge of the subject.

In the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä Arjuna was talking to Kåñëa just like a friend, and Kåñëa was questioning how he, as a military man, could give up fighting. But when Arjuna saw that friendly talks would not make a solution to his problems, he surrendered unto Kåñëa, saying, çiñyas te 'haà çädhi mäà tväà prapannam: "Now I am Your disciple and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me." This is the process. It is not that we should blindly surrender, but we should be able to inquire with intelligence.

Without inquiry, we cannot make advancement. In school a student who makes inquiries from the teacher is usually an intelligent student. It is generally a sign of intelligence when a small child inquires from his father, "Oh, what is this? What is that?" We may have a very good spiritual master, but if we have no power to inquire, we cannot make progress. Nor should the inquiry be of the nature of a challenge. One should not think, "Now I will see what kind of spiritual master he is. I will challenge him." Our inquiries (paripraçnena) should be on the subject of service (sevayä). Without service, our inquiries will be futile, but even before making inquiries, we should have some qualification. If we go to a store to purchase some gold or jewelry and we know nothing about jewels or gold, we are likely to be cheated. If we go to a jeweler and say, "Can you give me a diamond?" he will understand that this is a fool. He could charge us any price for anything. That kind of searching will not do at all. We first have to become a little intelligent, for it is not possible to make spiritual progress otherwise.

The beginning injunction of the Vedänta-sütra is: athäto brahma-jijïäsä. "Now is the time to inquire about Brahman." The word atha means that one who is intelligent, who has come to the point of realizing the basic frustrations of material life, is capable of making inquiry. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that one should inquire from a spiritual master about subjects that are "beyond this darkness." This material world is by nature dark, and it is artificially lighted by fire. Our inquiries should be about the transcendental worlds which lie beyond this universe. If one is desirous to find out about these spiritual worlds, he should seek out a spiritual master; otherwise there is no point in searching. If I want to study Bhagavad-gétä or Vedänta-sütra in order to make material improvement, it is not necessary to find a spiritual master. One should first want to inquire about Brahman and then search out a master who has perfect vision of the Absolute Truth (jïäninas tattva-darçinaù). Kåñëa is the supreme tattva, Absolute Truth. In the Seventh Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä Çré Kåñëa states:

manuñyäëäà sahasreñu
kaçcid yatati siddhaye
yatatäm api siddhänäà
kaçcin mäà vetti tattvataù

"Out of many thousands among men, one may endeavor for perfection, and of those who have achieved perfection, hardly one knows Me in truth." (Bg. 7.3)

Thus out of many perfected spiritualists, one man may know what Kåñëa actually is. As this verse indicates, the subject matter of Kåñëa is not so easy but is very difficult. Yet Bhagavad-gétä also indicates that it is easy.

bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti
yävän yaç cäsmi tattvataù
tato mäà tattvato jïätvä
viçate tad-anantaram

"One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service. And when one is in full consciousness of the Supreme Lord by such devotion, he can enter into the kingdom of God." (Bg. 18.55)

If we accept the process of devotional service, we can understand Kåñëa very easily. Through it we can understand the science of Kåñëa perfectly and become eligible for entering into the spiritual kingdom. If, as Bhagavad-gétä says, after many births we have to eventually surrender to Kåñëa, why not surrender to Him immediately? Why wait for many, many births? If surrender is the end of perfection, why not accept perfection immediately? Of course the answer is that people are generally doubtful. Kåñëa consciousness can be attained in one second, or it cannot be had even after a thousand births and deaths. If we choose, we can immediately become great souls by surrendering to Kåñëa, but because we have doubts whether or not Kåñëa is actually the Supreme we have to take time to dissipate these doubts through study of the scriptures. By studying Bhagavad-gétä under the guidance of a bona fide spiritual master, we can remove these doubts and make definite progress.

It is the fire of knowledge that burns all doubts and fruitive activities to ashes. Çré Kåñëa gives the following information of the results of inquiring of the truth from one who has actually seen the truth.

yaj jïätvä na punar moham
evaà yäsyasi päëòava
yena bhütäny açeñäëi
drakñyasy ätmany atho mayi

api ced asi päpebhyaù
sarvebhyaù päpa-kåttamaù
sarvaà jïäna-plavenaiva
våjinaà santariñyasi

yathaidhäàsi samiddho 'gnir
bhasmasät kurute 'rjuna
jïänägniù sarva-karmäëi
bhasmasät kurute tathä

"And when you have thus learned the truth, you will know that all living beings are but parts of Me—and that they are in Me, and are Mine. Even if you are considered to be the most sinful of all sinners, when you are situated in the boat of transcendental knowledge, you will be able to cross over the ocean of miseries. As a blazing fire burns firewood to ashes, O Arjuna, so does the fire of knowledge burn to ashes all the reactions to material activities." (Bg. 4.35-37)

The fire of knowledge is ignited by the spiritual master, and when it is ablaze, all the reactions to our works are turned to ashes. The reactions to our work, or our karma, are the cause for our bondage. There are good works and bad works, and in this verse the word sarva-karmäëi indicates both. For one who wants to be liberated from this material bondage, the reactions of both good works and bad works are detrimental. In this material world we are attached to performing good works if we are situated in the modes of goodness. If we are in the modes of passion and ignorance, however, we do bad work in passion and ignorance. But for those who are going to be Kåñëa conscious, there is no need of good work or bad work. By good work we may get a good birth in an aristocratic or wealthy family, and by bad work we may take birth even in the animal kingdom or in degraded human families, but in any case birth means bondage, and one who is striving for Kåñëa consciousness is striving for liberation from the bondage of transmigration. What is the advantage of being born in a wealthy or aristocratic family if one does not get rid of his material miseries? Whether we enjoy the reactions of good work or suffer the reactions of bad, we have to take on the material body and thereby undergo the material miseries.

By engaging in the transcendental service of Kåñëa, we actually get out of the cycle of birth and death. But because the fire of knowledge is not burning in our minds, we accept material existence as happiness. A dog or hog cannot understand what kind of miserable life he is passing. He actually thinks that he is enjoying life, and this is called the covering or illusive influence of material energy. On the Bowery, there are so many drunkards lying in the street, and they're all thinking, "We are enjoying life." But those who are passing them by are thinking, "Oh how miserable they are." That is the way of the illusory energy. We may be in a miserable condition, but we accept it thinking that we are very happy. This is called ignorance. But when one is awakened to knowledge, he thinks, "Oh, I am not happy. I want freedom, but there is no freedom. I don't want to die, but there is death. I don't want to grow old, but there is old age. I don't want diseases, but there are diseases." These are the major problems of human existence, but we ignore them and concentrate on solving very minor problems. We consider economic development to be the most important thing, forgetting how long we shall live here in this material world. Economic development or no economic development, at the end of sixty or a hundred years our life will be finished. Even if we accumulate a million dollars, we must leave it all behind when we leave this body. We need to come to understand that in the material world whatever we are doing is being defeated by the influence of material nature.

We want freedom, and we want to travel all over the world and all over the universe. Indeed, that is our right as spirit soul. The spirit soul in Bhagavad-gétä is called sarva-gataù, which means that he has the ability to go wherever he likes. In the Siddhalokas there are perfected beings or yogés who can travel wherever they want without the aid of airplanes or other mechanical contrivances. Once we are liberated from material conditioning, we can become very powerful. Actually we have no idea how powerful we are as spiritual sparks. Instead we are very much satisfied staying on this earth and sending up a few spaceships, thinking that we have become greatly advanced in material science. We spend millions and millions of dollars constructing spaceships without knowing that we have the ability to travel wherever we want free of charge.

The point is that we should cultivate our spiritual potencies by knowledge. The knowledge is already there; we simply have to accept it. In former ages people underwent so many penances and austerities to acquire knowledge, but in this age this process is not possible because our lives are very short and we are always disturbed. The process for this age is the process of Kåñëa consciousness, the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, which was inaugurated by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. If, by this process, we can kindle the fire of knowledge, all of the reactions of our activities will be reduced to ashes, and we will be purified.

na hi jïänena sadåçaà
pavitram iha vidyate
tat svayaà yoga-saàsiddhaù
kälenätmani vindati

"In this world, there is nothing so sublime and pure as transcendental knowledge. Such knowledge is the mature fruit of all mysticism. And one who has achieved this enjoys the self within himself in due course of time." (Bg. 4.38)

What is that sublime and pure knowledge? It is the knowledge that we are part and parcel of God and that we are to dovetail our consciousness with the Supreme Consciousness. This is the purest knowledge in the material world. Here everything is contaminated by the modes of material nature—goodness, passion and ignorance. Goodness is also a kind of contamination. In goodness one becomes aware of his position and transcendental subjects, etc, but his defect is in thinking, "Now I have understood everything. Now I am all right." He wants to stay here. In other words, the man in the mode of goodness becomes a first class prisoner and, becoming happy in the prison house, wants to stay there. And what to speak of those in the modes of passion and ignorance? The point is that we have to transcend even the quality of goodness. The transcendental position begins with the realization ahaà brahmäsmi—"I am not this matter, but spirit." But even this position is unsettled. More is required.

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments or desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state he attains pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54)

In the brahma-bhütaù stage one no longer identifies with matter. The first symptom of one's having become established on the brahma-bhütaù platform is that one becomes jolly (prasannätmä). On that platform, there is neither lamentation nor hankering. But even if we rise to this stage and do not take to the loving service of Kåñëa, there is the possibility of falling down again into the material whirlpool. We may rise very high in the sky, but if we have no shelter there, if we do not land on some planet, we will again fall down. A simple understanding of the brahma-bhütaù stage will not help us unless we take to the shelter of Kåñëa's lotus feet. As soon as we engage ourselves in the service of Kåñëa, there is no longer any chance of falling down again into the material world.

Our nature is such that we want some engagement. A child may commit mischief, but he cannot refrain from mischief unless he is given some engagement. When he is given some toys, his attention is diverted and his mischievous activities stop. We are like mischievous children, and therefore we must have spiritual engagement. Simply understanding that we are spirit soul will not help. Understanding that we are spirit, we have to sustain the spirit by spiritual engagement. It is not uncommon in India for a man to give up all material engagements, to leave his home and family and take the renounced order, sannyäsa, and after meditating for some while, begin doing philanthropic work by opening some hospitals or engaging in politics. The hospital-making business is being conducted by the government; it is the duty of a sannyäsa to make hospitals whereby people can actually get rid of their material bodies, not patch them up. But for want of knowing what real spiritual activity is, we take up material activities.

By becoming perfect in Kåñëa consciousness, knowledge and wisdom are found in due course of time. There may be some discouragement at first, but the word kälena, meaning "in due course of time," indicates that if we simply persevere we will be successful. Faith is required, as stated in the next verse.

çraddhäväû labhate jïänaà
tat-paraù saàyatendriyaù
jïänaà labdhvä paräà çäntim
acireëädhigacchati

"A faithful man who is absorbed in transcendental knowledge and who subdues his senses quickly attains the supreme spiritual peace." (Bg. 4.39)

For those who are hesitant and have no faith, Kåñëa consciousness is very difficult. Even in our daily affairs a certain amount of faith is required. When we buy a ticket, we have faith that the airline company will take us to our destination. Without faith we cannot even live in the material world, what to speak of making spiritual progress. Where are we to keep our faith? In the authority. We should not book our ticket with an unauthorized company. Faith must be in Kåñëa, the speaker of Bhagavad-gétä. How do we become faithful? Control of the senses (saàyatendriyaù) is required. We are in the material world because we want to gratify our senses. If we have faith that a physician can cure us, and he tells us not to eat such and such, and we eat it anyway, what kind of faith do we have? If we have faith in our physician, we will follow his prescriptions for cure. The point is that we have to follow the instructions with faith. Then wisdom will come. When we attain to the stage of wisdom, the result is paräà çäntim—supreme peace. Kåñëa indicates that when one controls the senses, faith comes in the near future (acireëa). Having attained that stage of faith in Kåñëa, one feels that he is the happiest man in the world. This is our position. We have to accept the formula and execute it with faith. This faith must be in the supreme authority, not in a third class man. We must search out a spiritual master in whom we can have faith. Kåñëa is the most authorized personality, but anyone who is Kåñëa conscious can be accepted because a person fully in Kåñëa consciousness is the bona fide representative of Kåñëa. Having tasted the words of Kåñëa's representative, we will feel satisfied, just as we feel satisfied upon eating a full meal.

ajïaç cäçraddadhänaç ca
saàçayätmä vinaçyati
näyaà loko 'sti na paro
na sukhaà saàçayätmanaù

"But ignorant and faithless persons who doubt the revealed scriptures do not attain God consciousness. For the doubting soul there is happiness neither in this world nor in the next." (Bg. 4.40)

Those who are hesitant in taking this path of knowledge have no chance. Hesitation is due to ignorance (ajïaç ca). For one hesitant in taking to Kåñëa consciousness, not even this material world will be happy, and what to speak of the next life. The material world is already miserable, but if one has no faith it will be more miserable. Thus for the faithless the situation is very precarious. We may put thousands of dollars in a bank because we have faith that that bank will not close down. If we have faith in banks and airlines, why not have faith in Çré Kåñëa who is acknowledged by so many Vedic literatures and by so many sages to be the supreme authority? Our position is to follow in the footsteps of great authorities like Çaìkaräcärya, Rämänujäcärya and Caitanya Mahäprabhu. If we keep our faith by executing our duties and following in their footsteps, success is guaranteed.

As stated before, we must search out one who has seen the Absolute Truth and surrender to him and serve him. When this is done, there is no doubt about one's spiritual salvation. Everyone is anxious to see God, but in our present stage of life we are conditioned and deluded. We have no idea of things as they really are. Although we are Brahman and by nature jolly, we have somehow fallen from our constitutional position. Our nature is sac-cid-änanda, eternal, blissful and full of knowledge, yet this body is destined to die, and while it is existing it is full of ignorance and miseries. The senses are imperfect, and it is not possible to attain perfect knowledge through them. Therefore it is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that if we at all want to learn transcendental knowledge, we must approach one who has actually seen the Absolute Truth (tad-viddhi praëipätena). Traditionally, brähmaëas are meant to be spiritual masters, but in this age of Kali, it is very difficult to find a qualified brähmaëa. Consequently it is very difficult to find a qualified spiritual master. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu has recommended kibävipra, kibä nyäsé, çüdra kene naya/yei kåñëa-tattva-vettä, sei 'guru' haya: "Whether one be a brähmaëa or a çüdra or a sannyäsé or a householder, it doesn't matter. If he knows the science of Kåñëa, he's a bona fide spiritual master." (Cc. Madhya 8.128)

Bhagavad-gétä is the science of Kåñëa, and if we study it scrutinizingly with all of our argument, sense and philosophical knowledge, we will come to know that science. It is not that we are to submit ourselves blindly. The spiritual master may be self-realized and situated in the Absolute Truth, yet we have to question him in order to understand all spiritual points. If one is able to factually answer the questions about the science of Kåñëa, he is the spiritual master, regardless of where he is born or what he is—whether he be a brähmaëa or çüdra or American, Indian or whatever. When we go to a doctor, we do not ask him whether he is a Hindu, Christian or brähmaëa. He has the qualification of a medical man, and we simply surrender, saying, "Doctor, treat me. I am suffering."

Kåñëa is the ultimate goal of spiritual science. Of course when we speak of Kåñëa we refer to God. There are many names for God throughout the world and throughout the universe, but Kåñëa is the supreme name according to Vedic knowledge. Therefore Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu recommended the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare as the supreme means for realization in this age. Caitanya Mahäprabhu did not make any distinctions as to caste or social position. Indeed, most of His foremost disciples were considered to be fallen in society. Caitanya Mahäprabhu even appointed Haridäsa Öhäkura, a Mohammedan, as nämäcärya, or preceptor of the holy names. Similarly, Rüpa and Sanätana Gosvämés, two of Lord Caitanya's principle disciples, were formerly known as Säkara Mallik and Dabir Khäs, and they were employed by the Mohammedan government. In those days, the Hindus were so strict that if a brähmaëa accepted service from a non-Hindu, he was immediately ostracized from Hindu society. Despite this, Rüpa and Sanätana Gosvämés were made principle authorities in the science of Kåñëa by Caitanya Mahäprabhu. So there is no bar against anyone; anyone can become a spiritual master provided he knows the science of Kåñëa. This is the only qualification, and this science in essence is contained in Bhagavad-gétä. At the present moment, thousands of spiritual masters are needed to spread this great science throughout the world.

We should understand that when Kåñëa is speaking to Arjuna in Bhagavad-gétä, He is speaking not simply to Arjuna alone but to the whole human race. Çré Kåñëa Himself declares that simply by knowing the science of Kåñëa, Arjuna would not be subject to illusion (yaj jïätvä na punar moham). If we have a very good ship, we can easily cross the Atlantic Ocean. At present we are in the midst of the ocean of ignorance, for this material world has been likened to a great ocean of nescience. Therefore Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu prayed to Kåñëa in this way:

ayi nandatanuja kiìkaraà
patitaà mäà viñame bhavämbudhau
kåpayä tava päda-paìkaja-
sthita-dhülésadåçaà vicintaya

"O son of Mahäräja Nanda, I am Your eternal servitor, and although I am so, somehow or other I have fallen into the ocean of birth and death. Please pick me up from this ocean of death and fix me as one of the atoms at Your lotus feet." (Çikñäñöakam, 5)

If we have the boat of perfect knowledge, there is no fear, for we can cross the ocean very easily. Even if a person is most sinful, if he receives the boat of the science of Kåñëa, he can cross the ocean very easily. As stated before (Bg. 4.36), it does not matter what we were in our past lives. Because we were in ignorance, we may have committed so many abominable actions. Indeed, no one can say that he is free from sinful activity. But according to Bhagavad-gétä, this does not matter. Just by knowing the science of Kåñëa, one becomes free.

It is therefore absolutely necessary that we seek knowledge, and the perfection of knowledge is to understand Kåñëa. Today there are so many theories, and everyone claims to know the best way to live; therefore so many "ism's" have evolved. Of these, communism has become very prominent in the world. But in Çrémad-Bhägavatam we find the seed for spiritual communism. There Närada Muni explains that in this material universe—whether one be in a lower, middle or higher planetary system or even in outer space—all natural resources are manifested by the Supreme Lord. We must understand that whatever exists in this world was not produced by any human being, but everything was created by God. No sane man can deny this. Çré Éçopaniñad enjoins:

éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà
yat kiïca jagatyäà jagat
tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä
mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam

"Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One must therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one must not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong." (Çré Éçopaniñad, Mantra 1)

Consequently all living entities, beginning from Brahmä, the highest demigod, down to the lowest ant, have the right to use natural resources. Närada Muni points out that we can use these resources as much as we require, but if we take more than required, we become thieves. Unfortunately everyone is trying to conquer and predominate. Countries race to the moon in order to put up their flags and claim that planet. When Europeans came to America, they put up their flag and claimed it for their nation. This flag planting and flag waving is all due to ignorance. We do not stop to think where we are putting our flag. It is not our property, but God's. Knowing this is knowledge, and thinking that it is my property is ignorance. We have the right to utilize but not to claim or hoard.

If we throw a bag of grain into the street, pigeons may come and eat four or five small grains and then go away. They will not take more than they can eat, and having eaten they go freely on their way. But if we were to put many bags of flour on the sidewalk and invite people to come and get them, one man would take ten or twenty bags and another would take fifteen or thirty bags and so on. But those who do not have the means to carry so much away will not be able to take more than a bag or two. Thus the distribution will be uneven. This is called advancement of civilization; we are even lacking in the knowledge which the pigeons, dogs and cats have. Everything belongs to the Supreme Lord, and we can accept whatever we need, but not more. That is knowledge. By the Lord's arrangement the world is so made that there is no scarcity of anything. Everything is sufficient, provided that we know how to distribute it. However, the deplorable condition today is that one is taking more than he needs while another is starving. Consequently the starving masses are revolting and asking, "Why should we starve?" But their methods are imperfect. The perfection of spiritual communism is found in the knowledge that everything belongs to God. By knowing the science of Kåñëa, we can easily cross over the ignorance of false proprietorship.

We are actually suffering due to our ignorance. In the law court ignorance is no excuse. If we tell the judge that we are not aware of the law, we will be punished anyway. If one has illegally amassed so much wealth and yet claims ignorance of his transgression, he will be punished nonetheless. The whole world is lacking this knowledge, and therefore thousands of teachers of the science of Kåñëa are needed. There is a great necessity for this knowledge now. We should not think that because Kåñëa was born in India that the knowledge of Bhagavad-gétä is sectarian or that Kåñëa is a sectarian God. Indeed, in the Fourteenth Chapter Çré Kåñëa proclaims Himself to be the father of all beings, as pointed out previously (Bg. 14.4).

As spirit souls we are part and parcel of the Supreme Spirit, but due to our desire to enjoy this material world, we have been put into material nature. Yet in whatever species of life we may be, Kåñëa is the Father. Thus Bhagavad-gétä is not meant for any particular party or nation but for everyone all over the world—even for the animals. Now that the sons of the Supreme are committing theft due to ignorance, it is the duty of one who is conversant with Bhagavad-gétä to spread this supreme knowledge to all beings. In this way people may realize their true spiritual nature and their relationship to the supreme spiritual whole.

RV 8: Action in Knowledge of Kåñëa

8
Action in Knowledge of Kåñëa

[660803BG.NY][660801BG.NY]

na mäà karmäëi limpanti
na me karma-phale spåhä
iti mäà yo 'bhijänäti
karmabhir na sa badhyate

"There is no work that affects Me; nor do I aspire for the fruits of action. One who understands this truth about Me also does not become entangled in the fruitive reactions of work." (Bg. 4.14)

The whole world is bound by karma. We all know of the existence of microbes or germs which exist by the million within the measurement of one millimeter. In the Brahma-saàhitä it is stated that beginning with the microbe, which is called indragopa, up to Indra, the king of the heavenly planets, all are bound by karma, the reaction of work. We all have to suffer or enjoy the reactions of our work, be they good or bad. As long as we have to suffer or enjoy these reactions, we are bound to these material bodies.

By nature's arrangement the material body is given to the living entity for his suffering or enjoying. Different types of bodies are acquired for different purposes. The body of a tiger is made for killing and eating raw meat. Similarly, the hogs are made in such a way that they can eat stool. And as human beings our teeth are made for eating vegetables and fruits. All of these bodies are made according to the work done in past lives by the living entity. Our next bodies are being prepared according to the work which we are now doing, but in the previously quoted verse Çré Kåñëa indicates that one who knows the transcendental nature of His activities becomes free from the reactions of activities. Our activities should be such that we will not again become entangled in this material world. This can be made possible if we become Kåñëa conscious by studying Kåñëa, learning of the transcendental nature of His activities, and understanding how He behaves in this material world and in the spiritual world.

When Kåñëa comes on this earth, He is not like us; He is totally transcendental. We desire the fruits of our activities, but Kåñëa does not desire any fruits, nor are there any reactions to His actions. Nor does He have any desire for fruitive activity (na me karma-phale spåhä). When we enter into business, we hope for profit, and with that profit we hope to buy things that will make our life enjoyable. Whenever conditioned souls do something, there is desire for enjoyment behind it. But Kåñëa has nothing to desire. He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and He is full with everything. When Kåñëa came on this earth He had many girl friends and over 16,000 wives, and some people think that He was very sensual. But this was not the fact.

We must understand the meaning of relationships with Kåñëa. In this material world we have many relationships as father, mother, wife or husband. Whatever relationship we find here is but a perverted reflection of the relationship we have with the Supreme Lord. Whatever we find in this material world is born of the Absolute Truth, but here it is pervertedly reflected in time. Whatever relationship we have with Kåñëa goes on. If we have a relationship in friendship, that friendship is eternal and continues from life to life. In the material world, a friendship exists for a few years and then breaks; therefore it is called perverted, temporal, or unreal. If we make our friendship with Kåñëa, it will never break. If we make our master Kåñëa, we will never be cheated. If we love Kåñëa as our son, He will never die. If we love Kåñëa as our lover, He will be the best of all, and there will be no separation. Because Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord, He is unlimited and has an unlimited number of devotees. Some are trying to love Him as lover or husband, and therefore Kåñëa accepts this role. In whatever way we approach Kåñëa, He will accept us, as He states in Bhagavad-gétä.

ye yathä mäà prapadyante
täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham
mama vartmänuvartante
manuñyäù pärtha sarvaçaù

"All of them—as they surrender unto Me—I reward accordingly. Everyone follows My path in all respects, O son of Påthä." (Bg. 4.11)

The gopés or cowherd girl friends of Kåñëa underwent tremendous penances in their previous lives to attain Kåñëa as their husband. Similarly, in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çukadeva Gosvämé says that those boys who were playing with Kåñëa had undergone great penances and austerities in their previous lives in order to acquire Kåñëa as a playmate. Thus the playmates, associates and wives of Kåñëa are not ordinary living entities. Because we have no idea of Kåñëa consciousness, we take His activities as triflings, but actually they are sublime. All perfection of our desires is there; whatever desires we have constitutionally will be perfectly fulfilled when we are in Kåñëa consciousness.

Kåñëa did not need any friends to play with Him, nor did He desire a single wife. We take on a wife because we have some desire to fulfill, but Kåñëa is complete in Himself (pürëam). A poor man may desire to have a thousand dollars in the bank, but a rich man who has millions has no such desire. If Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, why should He have desires? Rather, He fulfills the desires of others. Man proposes and God disposes. If Kåñëa had any desire, He would be imperfect, for He would be lacking something. Therefore He says that He has no desire to fulfill. As Yogeçvara, or as master of all yogés, whatever He wills is immediately realized. There is no question of desire. He becomes a husband or lover or friend just to fulfill the desires of His devotees. If we accept Kåñëa as friend, master, son or lover, we will never be frustrated. Every living entity has a specific relationship with Kåñëa, but at present this relationship is covered. As we advance in Kåñëa consciousness, it will be revealed.

Although the Supreme Lord is full and has nothing to do, He works in order to set an example. He is not bound to His activities in the material world, and one who knows this also becomes free from reactional activities.

evaà jïätvä kåtaà karma
pürvair api mumukñubhiù
kuru karmaiva tasmät tvaà
pürvaiù pürvataraà kåtam

"All the liberated souls in ancient times acted with this understanding and so attained liberation. Therefore, as the ancients, you should perform your duty in this divine consciousness." (Bg. 4.15)

The process of Kåñëa consciousness requires that we follow in the footsteps of the great äcäryas who have attained success in spiritual life. If one acts by following the examples set by great äcäryas, sages, devotees and enlightened kings who have performed karma-yoga in their lives, he shall also become free.

On the battlefield of Kurukñetra, Arjuna was very much afraid of being entangled in his activities by engaging in warfare. Kåñëa therefore assured him that if he fought for His sake there would be no possibility of entanglement.

kià karma kim akarmeti
kavayo 'py atra mohitäù
tat te karma pravakñyämi
yaj jïätvä mokñyase 'çubhät

"Even the intelligent are bewildered in determining what is action and what is inaction. Now I shall explain to you what action is, knowing which you shall be liberated from all sins." (Bg. 4.16)

People are actually confused as to what is work (karma) and what is not work (akarma). Kåñëa here indicates that even great scholars (kavayaù) are bewildered about the nature of work. It is necessary to know which activities are genuine and which are not, which are bona fide and which are not, which are prohibited and which are not. If we understand the principle of work, we can become free from material bondage. It is therefore necessary to know how to conduct work so that when we leave the material body we will no longer be forced to take another but will be free to enter into the spiritual sky. The principle of proper work is clearly stated by Çré Kåñëa in the last verse of the Eleventh Chapter:

mat-karma-kån mat-paramo
mad-bhaktaù saìga-varjitaù
nirvairaù sarva-bhüteñu
yaù sa mäm eti päëòava

"My dear Arjuna, one who is engaged in My pure devotional service, free from the contamination of previous activities and from mental speculation, who is friendly to every living entity, certainly comes to Me." (Bg. 11.55)

This one verse is sufficient for understanding the essence of Bhagavad-gétä. One must be engaged in "My work." And what is this work? It is indicated in the last instruction in Bhagavad-gétä in which Kåñëa tells Arjuna to surrender unto Him (Bg. 18.66).

By the example of Arjuna we are to learn that we should only perform work which is sanctioned by Kåñëa. This is the mission of human life, but we do not know it. Because of our ignorance we engage in so much work which is connected with the bodily or material conception of life. Kåñëa wanted Arjuna to fight, and although Arjuna did not want to fight, he fought because Kåñëa desired it. We have to learn to follow this example.

Of course Kåñëa was present to tell Arjuna what his work was, but what about us? Çré Kåñëa was personally directing Arjuna to act in such and such a way, but just because Kåñëa is not personally present before us, we should not assume that there is no direction. Indeed, there is direction. In the last chapter of Bhagavad-gétä the proper work which we are to perform is given.

ya idaà paramaà guhyaà
mad-bhakteñv abhidhäsyati
bhaktià mayi paräà kåtvä
mäm evaiñyaty asaàçayaù

na ca tasmän manuñyeñu
kaçcin me priya-kåttamaù
bhavitä na ca me tasmäd
anyaù priyataro bhuvi

"For one who explains the supreme secret to the devotees, devotional service is guaranteed, and at the end he will come back to Me. There is no servant in this world more dear to Me than he, nor will there ever be one more dear." (Bg. 18.68-69)

It is therefore incumbent upon us to preach the method of Bhagavad-gétä and make people Kåñëa conscious. People are actually suffering for want of Kåñëa consciousness. We should all engage in spreading the science of Kåñëa for the benefit of the whole world. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu came with this mission of teaching Kåñëa consciousness, and He said that regardless of one's position, if he teaches Kåñëa consciousness he is to be considered a spiritual master. Both Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam are filled with information on how to become Kåñëa conscious. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu selected these two books and requested that people in all corners of the world spread this science of Kåñëa in every town and village. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu was Kåñëa Himself, and we should take this to be Kåñëa's indication of our proper work. But we should be careful to present Bhagavad-gétä as it is, without personal interpretation or motivation. Some people present interpretations of Bhagavad-gétä, but we should present the words as they are spoken by Çré Kåñëa.

One who works for Kåñëa may appear to be working like anyone else in the material world, but this is not the case. Arjuna may have fought just like an ordinary military man, but because he fought in Kåñëa consciousness, he was free from the entanglement of his activities. In this way, his work, although appearing material, was not material at all. Any action sanctioned by Kåñëa—regardless of what it may be—has no reaction. Fighting may not be a very nice thing, but sometimes, as in the case of the battle of Kurukñetra, it is an absolute necessity. On the other hand, we may perform work which may be very altruistic or humanitarian in the opinion of the world and yet be bound to material activity. So it is not the action itself which is important but the consciousness in which the action is carried out.

karmaëo hy api boddhavyaà
boddhavyaà ca vikarmaëaù
akarmaëaç ca boddhavyaà
gahanä karmaëo gatiù

"The intricacies of action are very hard to understand. Therefore one should know properly what action is, what forbidden action is, and what inaction is." (Bg. 4.17)

The path of karma is very intricate; therefore we should understand the distinctions between karma, akarma and vikarma. If we simply engage in Kåñëa consciousness, everything becomes clear. Otherwise we will have to make distinctions between what we should do and what we should not do in order not to become entangled. In the ordinary course of life we unknowingly break some law and have to suffer the consequences. Similarly, the laws of nature are very strict and stringent, and they accept no excuse. It is a law of nature that fire burns, and even if a child touches it, he will be burned despite his ignorance and innocence. Thus we have to choose our course of action very carefully lest the stringent laws of nature react to bind us to suffering. It is therefore necessary to understand what work to do and what work to avoid.

The word karma refers to prescribed duties. The word vikarma refers to activities which are against one's prescribed duties. And the word akarma refers to activities which have no reaction at all. In the execution of akarmic activities, there may appear to be some reactions, but in actuality there are not. When we work under the directions of Kåñëa, this is actually the case—there are no reactions. If we take it upon ourselves to kill someone, we are subject to capital punishment by the state government. Our actions are then called vikarma, for they are against prescribed actions. If, however, the government drafts us into the army, and we engage in battle and kill someone, we do not suffer the reactions, and this is called akarma. In the one case we are acting according to our own whims, and in the other we are acting under the direction of the government. Similarly, when we act under the direction of Kåñëa, our actions performed are called akarma, for that kind of activity has no reaction.

karmaëy akarma yaù paçyed
akarmaëi ca karma yaù
sa buddhimän manuñyeñu
sa yuktaù kåtsna-karma-kåt

"One who sees inaction in action, and action in inaction, is intelligent among men, and he is in the transcendental position, although engaged in all sorts of activities." (Bg. 4.18)

One who can actually see that despite activities there are no karmic reactions, who understands the nature of akarma, actually sees things as they are. The word akarmaëi refers to one who is trying to avoid the reactions of karma. By dovetailing his activities in Kåñëa consciousness, although one may perform all kinds of activities, he is free. On the battlefield of Kurukñetra, Arjuna engaged in fighting, and those on the side of Duryodhana also engaged in fighting. We must understand how it is that Arjuna is free from reaction whereas Duryodhana is not. Externally we can see that both parties are engaged in fighting, but we should understand that Arjuna is not bound by reactions because he is fighting under the order of Kåñëa. Thus when we see someone working in Kåñëa consciousness, we should understand that his work does not carry any reaction. One who can see such work and understand it is to be considered very intelligent (sa buddhimän). The technique is not so much in seeing what a person is doing but in understanding why he is doing it.

Actually Arjuna was engaged in very unpleasant activity on the battlefield, but because he was in Kåñëa consciousness, he suffered no reaction. We may be performing some action which we may consider to be very good work, but if we do not perform it in Kåñëa consciousness we have to suffer the reactions. From the material point of view, Arjuna's initial decision not to fight was a good one, but from the spiritual point of view it was not. When we do pious work, we get certain results. We may take a birth in a very good family, in the family of a brähmaëa or a wealthy man, we may become very rich or very learned, or we may become very beautiful. On the other hand, if we do impious work, we may have to take birth in a low class family or animal family, or become illiterate or foolish, or very ugly. Although we engage in very pious work and take a good birth, we will still be subject to the stringent laws of action and reaction. Our principal aim should be to escape the laws of this material world. If we don't understand this, we will become attracted by aristocratic families, wealth, or a good education or a beautiful body. We should come to understand that despite having all these facilities for material life, we are not free from birth, old age, disease and death. To caution us of this, Çré Kåñëa warns in Bhagavad-gétä:

äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

"From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place." (Bg. 8.16)

Even on Brahmaloka, the highest planet in the material universe, repetition of birth and death are also present. We have to go to Kåñëa's planet in order to be free from this. It may be very nice to be a rich man or a beautiful man, but how long shall we remain such? That is not our permanent life. We may remain learned, rich and beautiful for fifty, sixty or at most a hundred years, but real life is not for fifty or a hundred years, nor a thousand years nor even a million years. We are eternal, and we have to attain our eternal life. That we have not attained it is our whole problem. That problem can be solved when we are Kåñëa conscious.

If we leave this material body in Kåñëa consciousness, we will no longer have to return to the material world. The point is to avoid this material existence altogether. It is not a question of improving our condition in the material world. In prison a man may want to improve his condition to become a first class prisoner, and the government may give him A-status, but no sane man will become satisfied by becoming an A-class prisoner. He should desire to get out of the prison altogether. In the material world some of us are A-class, B-class or C-class prisoners, but in any case we are all prisoners. Real knowledge does not consist in simply getting an MA or PhD but in understanding these basic problems of existence.

yasya sarve samärambhäù
käma-saìkalpa-varjitäù
jïänägni-dagdha-karmäëaà
tam ähuù paëòitaà budhaù

"One is understood to be in full knowledge whose every act is devoid of desire for sense gratification. He is said by sages to be a worker whose fruitive action is burned up by the fire of perfect knowledge." (Bg. 4.19)

The word paëòitam means learned, and budhäù means well-versed. In the Tenth Chapter we also find the word budhäù in the verse budhä bhäva-samanvitäù (Bg. 10.8). According to Bhagavad-gétä, one may not be a learned man just because he has received a lot of education from a university. Bhagavad-gétä says that he is a learned man who can see everything on an equal level.

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

"The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog and a dog-eater (outcaste)." (Bg. 5.18)

In India, according to Vedic civilization, a brähmaëa who is learned is considered to be the topmost man in human society. The paëòita, who is learned and gentle, sees such a brähmaëa on the same level with a dog or an outcaste who eats dogs. In other words, he sees no distinctions between the highest and the lowest. Is this to say that being a learned brähmaëa is no better than being a dog? No, that is not so. But the paëòita sees them as the same because he does not see the skin but the spirit. One who has learned the art of seeing the same spirit soul within every living being is considered to be a paëòita, for in actuality every living being is a spiritual spark, part and parcel of the complete spirit whole. The spiritual spark is the same in all, but it is covered by different dresses. An honored man may come in a very shabby dress, but this does not mean that he should be dishonored. In Bhagavad-gétä these material bodies are likened unto dresses which are worn by the spirit soul.

väsäàsi jérëäni yathä vihäya
naväni gåhëäti naro paräëi
tathä çaréräëi vihäya jérëäny
anyäni saàyäti naväni dehé

"As a person puts on new garments, giving up old ones, similarly, the soul accepts new material bodies, giving up the old and useless ones." (Bg. 2.22)

Whenever we see any living entity we should think, "Here is a spirit soul." Anyone who can understand such a spiritual vision of life is paëòita. Cäëakya Paëòit gives the standard for education or the qualification for a paëòita in this way: "The learned man sees all women, with the exception of his wife, as his mother; he sees all material possessions as garbage in the street, and he looks on the sufferings of others as he would look on them in himself." Lord Buddha taught that we should not even hurt animals by word or deed. This is the qualification for a paëòita, and this should be the standard of life. It is therefore to be understood that one is to be considered educated in accordance with his vision of life and his activity in accordance with that vision, not by his academic degrees. This is the understanding of the word paëòita from Bhagavad-gétä. Similarly, the word budhäù specifically refers to one who is well-versed in the study of scripture. The results of such realization and scriptural learning are thus described in Bhagavad-gétä:

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate
iti matvä bhajante mäà
budhä bhäva samanvitäù

"I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts." (Bg. 10.8)

The well-versed person or budhäù is one who has understood that Kåñëa is the origin of all emanations. Whatever we happen to see is but an emanation of Kåñëa. For millions and millions of years sunshine has been emanating from the sun, and yet the sun is as it is. Similarly, all material and spiritual energies are coming from Kåñëa. As a result of knowing this, one becomes a devotee of Kåñëa.

Thus one who knows that he must work in Kåñëa consciousness, who no longer desires to enjoy this material world, is actually learned. Everyone is working in the material world due to lust (käma), but the wise man is free from the dictations of this lust (käma-saìkalpa-varjitäù). How is this possible? Jïänägni-dagdha-karmäëam: the fire of knowledge burns up all reactions of sinful activities. It is the most potent of purifiers. Our lives have meaning and direction only in so far as we strive to attain this transcendental knowledge of Kåñëa consciousness, räja-vidyä, which is the king of all knowledge.

GLOSSARY


Ahaà brahmäsmi—the transcendental realization of oneself to be spirit, not matter.

Ahiàsä—nonviolence to all living entities.

Akarma—activities which have no pious or sinful reactions.

Anumäëa—evidence by hearing.

Arca-vigraha—the appearance of the Supreme Lord in a Deity form engraved from wood, stone or other matter.

Anasuyu—nonenvious.

Avatära—one who descends from the spiritual universe into the material universe through his own will.

Bhagavän—Kåñëa, who possesses in full all opulences—knowledge, wealth, power, beauty, fame and renunciation.

Brahmacärés—celibate students.

Däna—charity.

Jévas—individual souls.

Käla—eternal time.

Karma—duties prescribed in the revealed scriptures.

Karmés—fruitive laborers.

Kértana—constant chanting of the glories of the Lord.

Mahätmäs—great souls.

Müòhas—foolish men who are lower than animals.

Mukti—liberation.

Parama—supreme.

Prasädam—food that has been offered to Kåñëa.

Pratyakña—evidence by direct perception.

Räja-vidyä—the king of knowledge.

Çabda—the method of taking truths from a higher authority.

Sädhu—holy man.

Çakti—energy.

Saàsära—the cycle of birth and death.

Tapasya—penance.

Vikarma—activities which are against one's prescribed duties.

Yajïa—sacrifice.

Yogeçvara—Kåñëa, the master of all yogés.


OTHER BOOKS

by His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 13 (6 Vols.)

Teachings of Lord Caitanya

The Nectar of Devotion

Çré Éçopaniñad

Easy Journey to Other Planets

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System

Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 Vols.)

Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäräj

Transcendental Teachings of Caitanya Mahäprabhu

Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure

The Perfection of Yoga

Beyond Birth and Death

On the Way to Kåñëa

Rajavidya: The King of Knowledge

Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness

Lord Caitanya in Five Features

Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)


A complete catalogue is available upon request.


ISKCON Books
3959 Landmark Street
Culver City, California 90230


This knowledge is the king of education, the most secret of all secrets. It is the purest knowledge, and because it gives direct perception of the self by realization, it is the perfection of religion. It is everlasting, and it is joyfully performed. Bhagavad-gétä 9.2

The Perfection of Yoga (1972)

ISKCON Press, New York

Contents


© 1972 by ISKCON PRESS. All rights reserved


Library of Congress Catalogue Card Nc. 72-76302

ISBN 0-912776-36-6


First Printing: 30,000 copies Second Printing: 100,000 copies

Printed in the United. States of America.


OTHER BOOKS
by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 13 (6 Vols.)

Teachings of Lord Caitanya

The Nectar of Devotion

Easy Journey to Other Planets

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System

Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 Vols.)

Transcendental Teachings of Caitanya Mahäprabhu

Beyond Birth and Death

On the Way to Kåñëa

Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge

Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness

Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)

Çré Éçopaniñad


Complete catalogue is available upon request from
ISKCON BOOKS MAIL-ORDER
3826 Willat Avenue
Culver City, Calif. 90230

PoY 1: Yoga as Reestablishing Relations with Kåñëa

1
Yoga As Reestablishing Relations With Kåñëa

[660902BG.NY]

We have heard many times of the yoga system. The yoga system is approved by Bhagavad-gétä, but the yoga system in Bhagavad-gétä is especially meant for purification. The aim is threefold: to control the senses, to purify activities and to link oneself to Kåñëa in a reciprocal relationship.

The Absolute Truth is realized in three stages: impersonal Brahman, localized Paramätmä (Supersoul) and ultimately as Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the final analysis, the Supreme Absolute Truth is a Person, and simultaneously He is the all-pervading Supersoul within the hearts of all living entities and within the core of all atoms, and He is the brahmajyoti or the effulgence of spiritual light as well. Bhagavän Çré Kåñëa is full of all opulence as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but at the same time He is full of all renunciation. In the material world we find that one who has much opulence is not very much inclined to give it up, but Kåñëa is not like this. He can renounce everything and remain complete in Himself.

When we read or study Bhagavad-gétä under a bona fide spiritual master we should not think that the spiritual master is presenting his own opinions. It is not he who is speaking. He is just an instrument. The real speaker is the Supreme Personality of Godhead who is both within and without. At the beginning of His discourse on the yoga system in the Sixth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, Çré Kåñëa says:

anäçritaù karma-phalaà
käryaà karma karoti yaù
sa sannyäsé ca yogé ca
na niragnir na cäkriyaù

"One who is unattached to the fruits of his work and who works as he is obligated is in the renounced order of life, and he is the true mystic; not he who lights no fire and performs no work." (Bg. 6.1)

Everyone is working and expecting some result. One may ask what is the purpose of working if no result is expected? A remuneration or salary is always demanded by the worker. But here Kåñëa indicates that one can work out of a sense of duty alone, not expecting the results of his activities. If one works in this way, then he is actually a sannyäsé; he is in the renounced order of life.

According to Vedic culture, there are four stages of life: brahmacäré, gåhastha, vänaprastha and sannyäsa. Brahmacäré is student life devoted to training in spiritual understanding. Gåhastha life is married householder life. Then upon reaching the approximate age of fifty, one may take the vänaprastha order—that is, he leaves his home and children and travels with his wife to holy places of pilgrimage. Finally he gives up both wife and children and remains alone to cultivate Kåñëa consciousness, and that stage is called sannyäsa, or the renounced order of life. Yet Kåñëa indicates that for a sannyäsé, renunciation is not all. In addition, there must be some duty. What then is the duty for a sannyäsé, for one who has renounced family life and no longer has material obligations? His duty is a most responsible one; it is to work for Kåñëa. Moreover, this is the real duty for everyone in all stages of life.

In everyone's life there are two duties: one is to serve the illusion, and the other is to serve the reality. When one serves the reality, he is a real sannyäsé. And when one serves the illusion, he is deluded by mäyä. One has to understand, however, that he is in all circumstances forced to serve. Either he serves the illusion or the reality. The constitutional position of the living entity is to be a servant, not a master. Everyone in the material world is a servant; no one is master. One may think that he is the master, but he is actually a servant. When one has a family he may think that he is the master of his wife, or his children, or his home, business and so on, but that is all false. One is actually the servant of his wife, of his children and of his business. The president may be considered to be the master of the country, but actually he is the servant of the country. Our position is always as servant—either as servant of the illusion or as servant of God. If, however, we remain the servant of the illusion, then our life is wasted. Of course everyone is thinking that he is not a servant, that he is working only for himself. Although the fruits of his labor are transient and illusory, they force him to become a servant of illusion or a servant of his own senses. But when one awakens to his transcendental senses and actually becomes situated in knowledge, he then becomes a servant of the reality. When one comes to the platform of knowledge, he understands that in all circumstances he is a servant. Since it is not possible for him to be master, he is much better situated serving the reality instead of the illusion. When one becomes aware of this, he attains the platform of real knowledge. By sannyäsa, the renounced order of life, we refer to one who has come to this platform. Sannyäsa is a question of realization, not social status.

It is the duty of everyone to become Kåñëa conscious and to serve the cause of Kåñëa. When one actually realizes this he becomes a mahätmä, or a great soul. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says that after many births, when one comes to the platform of real knowledge, he "surrenders unto Me." Why is this? Väsudevaù sarvam iti. The wise man realizes that "Väsudeva [Kåñëa] is everything." However, Kåñëa says that such a great soul is rarely found. Why is this? If an intelligent person comes to understand that the ultimate goal of life is to surrender unto Kåñëa, why should he hesitate? Why not surrender immediately? What is the point in waiting for so many births? When one comes to that point of surrender, he becomes a real sannyäsé. Kåñëa never forces anyone to surrender unto Him. Surrender is a result of love, transcendental love. Where there is force and where there is no freedom, there can be no love. When a mother loves a child, she is not forced to do so, nor does she do so out of expectation of some salary or remuneration.

Similarly, we can love the Supreme Lord in so many ways—we can love Him as master, as friend, as child or as husband. There are five basic rasas or relationships in which we are eternally related to God. When we are actually in the liberated stage of knowledge, we can understand that our relationship with the Lord is in a particular rasa. That platform is called svarüpa-siddhi, or real self-realization. Everyone has an eternal relationship with the Lord, either as master and servant, friend and friend, parent and child, husband and wife, or lover and beloved. These relationships are eternally present. The whole process of spiritual realization and the actual perfection of yoga is to revive our consciousness of this relationship. At present our relationship with the Supreme Lord is pervertedly reflected in this material world. In the material world, the relationship between master and servant is based on money or force or exploitation. There is no question of service out of love. The relationship between master and servant, pervertedly reflected, continues only for so long as the master can pay the servant. As soon as the payment stops, the relationship also stops. Similarly, in the material world there may be a relationship between friends, but as soon as there is a slight disagreement, the friendship breaks, and the friend becomes an enemy. When there is a difference of opinion between son and parents, the son leaves home and the relationship is severed. The same with husband and wife; a slight difference of opinion, and there is divorce.

No relationship in this material world is actual or eternal. We must always remember that these ephemeral relationships are simply perverted reflections of that eternal relationship that we have with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. We have experience that the reflection of an object in a glass is not real. It may appear real, but when we go to touch it we find that there is only glass. We must come to understand that these relationships as friend, parent, child, master, servant, husband, wife or lover are simply reflections of that relationship that we have with God. When we come to this platform of understanding, then we are perfect in knowledge. When that knowledge comes, we begin to understand that we are servants of Kåñëa and that we have an eternal love relationship with Him.

In this love relationship there is no question of remuneration, but of course remuneration is there, and it is much greater than whatever we earn here through the rendering of service. There is no limit to Çré Kåñëa's remuneration. In this connection there is the story of Bali Mahäräja, a very powerful king who conquered a number of planets. The denizens of the heavenly planets appealed to the Supreme Lord to save them, for they had been conquered by the demonic king, Bali Mahäräja. Upon hearing their pleas, Çré Kåñëa took the shape of a dwarf brähmaëa boy and approached Bali Mahäräja, saying, "My dear king, I would like something from you. You are a great monarch and are renowned for giving in charity to the brähmaëas, so would you give me something?"

Bali Mahäräja said, "I will give you what you want."

"I simply want whatever land I can cover in three steps," the boy said.

"Oh, is that all?" the king replied. "And what will you do with such a small piece of land?"

"Though it may be small, it will suffice me," the boy smiled.

Bali Mahäräja agreed, and the boy-dwarf took two steps and covered the entire universe. He then asked Bali Mahäräja where he was going to take his third step, and Bali Mahäräja, understanding that the Supreme Lord was showing him His favor, replied: "My dear Lord, I have now lost everything. I have no other property, but I do have my head. Would You so kindly step there?"

Lord Çré Kåñëa was then very much pleased with Bali Mahäräja, and He asked, "What would you like from Me?"

"I never expected anything from You," Bali Mahäräja said. "But I understand that You wanted something from me, and now I have offered You everything."

"Yes," the Lord said, "but from My side I have something for you. I shall remain always as an order-carrier servant in your court." In this way the Lord became Bali Mahäräja's doorman, and that was his return. If we offer something to the Lord, it is returned millions of times. But we should not expect this. The Lord is always eager to return the service of His servant. Whoever thinks that the service of the Lord is actually his duty is perfect in knowledge and has attained the perfection of yoga.

PoY 2: Yoga as Work in Devotion

2
Yoga As Work In Devotion

[660902BG.NY]

We have heard the names of so many different yogas and yogés, but in Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says that he is the actual yogi who has surrendered himself "fully unto Me." Kåñëa proclaims that there is no difference between renunciation (sannyäsa) and yoga.

yaà sannyäsam iti prähur
yogaà taà viddhi päëòava
na hy asannyasta-saìkalpo
yogé bhavati kaçcana

"What is called renunciation is the same as yoga, or linking oneself with the Supreme; for no one can become a yogé unless he renounces the desire for sense gratification." (Bg. 6.2)

In Bhagavad-gétä there are three basic types of yoga delineated—karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga and bhakti-yoga. The systems of yoga may be likened unto a staircase. Someone may be on the first step, someone may be halfway up, or someone may be on the top step. When one is elevated to certain levels, he is known as a karma-yogé, jïäna-yogé, etc. In all cases, the service to the Supreme Lord is the same. It is a difference in elevation only. Thus Çré Kåñëa tells Arjuna that he must understand that renunciation (sannyäsa) and yoga are the same because without being freed from desire and sense gratification one can become neither a yogé nor a sannyäsé.

There are some yogés who perform yoga for a profit, but that is not real yoga. Everything must be engaged in the service of the Lord. Whatever we do as an ordinary worker, or as a sannyäsé, or as a yogé, or as a philosopher must be done in Kåñëa consciousness. When we are absorbed in the thought of serving Kåñëa and when we act in that consciousness, we can become real sannyäsés and real yogés. For those who are taking the first step up the staircase of the yoga system, there is work. One should not think that simply because he is beginning yoga that he should stop working. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa asks Arjuna to become a yogé, but He never tells him to cease from fighting. Quite the contrary. Of course one may ask how a person may be a yogé and at the same time a warrior. Our conception of yoga practice is that of sitting very straight with legs crossed and eyes half-closed staring at the tip of our nose and concentrating in this way in a lonely place. So how is it that Kåñëa is asking Arjuna to become a yogé and at the same time participate in a ghastly civil war? That is the mystery of Bhagavad-gétä: one can remain a fighting man and at the same time be the highest yogé, the highest sannyäsé. How is this possible? In Kåñëa consciousness. One simply has to fight for Kåñëa, work for Kåñëa, eat for Kåñëa, sleep for Kåñëa and dedicate all activities to Kåñëa. In this way one becomes the highest yogé and the highest sannyäsé. That is the secret.

In the Sixth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, Çré Kåñëa instructs Arjuna how to perform meditational yoga, but Arjuna rejects this as too difficult. How then is Arjuna considered to be a great yogé? Although Kåñëa saw that Arjuna was rejecting the meditational system, He proclaimed Arjuna to be the highest yogé because "You are always thinking of Me." Thinking of Kåñëa is the essence of all yoga systems—of the haöha, karma, jïäna, bhakti or any other system of yoga, sacrifice or charity. All the recommended activities for spiritual realization end in Kåñëa consciousness, in thinking always of Kåñëa. The actual perfection of human life lies in being always Kåñëa conscious and always being aware of Kåñëa while performing all types of activities.

In the preliminary stage one is advised to always work for Kåñëa. One must be always searching out some duty or some engagement, for it is a bad policy to remain idle even for a second. When one actually becomes advanced through such engagements, then he may not work physically, but he is always engaged within by constantly thinking of Kåñëa. In the preliminary stage, however, one is always advised to engage one's senses in the service of Kåñëa. There are a variety of activities one can perform in serving Kåñëa. The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is intended to help direct aspirant devotees in these activities. For those working in Kåñëa consciousness, there are simply not enough hours in the day to serve Kåñëa. There are always activities, engagements both day and night, which the student of Kåñëa consciousness performs joyfully. That is the stage of real happiness—constant engagement for Kåñëa and spreading Kåñëa consciousness around the world. In the material world one may become very tired if he works all the time, but if one works in Kåñëa consciousness, he can chant Hare Kåñëa and engage in devotional service twenty-four hours a day and never get tired. But if we vibrate some mundane vibration, then we soon become exhausted. There is no question of becoming tired on the spiritual platform. The spiritual platform is absolute. In the material world everyone is working for sense gratification. The profits of one's labor in the material world are used to gratify one's senses. But a real yogé does not desire such fruits. He has no desire other than Kåñëa, and Kåñëa is already there.

PoY 3: Yoga as Meditation on Kåñëa

3
Yoga As Meditation On Kåñëa

[660907BG.NY]

In India there are sacred places where yogés go to meditate in solitude, as prescribed in Bhagavad-gétä. Traditionally, yoga cannot be executed in a public place, but insofar as kértana-mantra-yoga, or the yoga of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare—is concerned, the more people present, the better. When Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu was performing kértana in India some five hundred years ago, He organized in each group sixteen persons to lead the chanting, and thousands of persons chanted with them. This participation in kértana, in the public chanting of the names and glories of God, is very possible and is actually easy in this age; but as far as the meditational process of yoga is concerned, that is very difficult. It is specifically stated in Bhagavad-gétä that to perform meditational yoga one should go to a secluded and holy place. In other words, it is necessary to leave home. In this age of overpopulation it is not always possible to find a secluded place, but this is not necessary in bhakti-yoga.

In the bhakti-yoga system there are nine different processes: hearing, chanting, remembering, serving, worshiping the Deity in the temple, praying, carrying out orders, serving Kåñëa as friend and sacrificing for Him. Out of these, çravaëaà kértanam, hearing and chanting, are considered the most important. At a public kértana one person can chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, while a group listens, and at the end of the mantra, the group can respond, and in this way there is a reciprocation of hearing and chanting. This can easily be performed in one's own home, with a small group of friends or with many people in a large public place. One may attempt to practice meditational yoga in a large city or in a society, but one must understand that this is one's own concoction and is not the method recommended in Bhagavad-gétä.

The whole process of the yoga system is to purify oneself. And what is this purification? Purification ensues upon the realization of one's actual identity. Purification is realizing that "I am pure spirit—I am not this matter." Due to material contact, we are identifying ourselves with matter, and we are thinking, "I am this body." But in order to perform real yoga one must realize his constitutional position as being distinct from matter. The purpose of seeking out a secluded place and executing the meditational process is to come to this understanding. It is not possible to come to this understanding if one executes the process improperly. In any case, this is the consideration of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu:

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä

"In this age of quarrel and disagreement [Kali-yuga], there is no other way of spiritual realization but this chanting of the names. There is no other way, there is no other way, there is no other way." (Ädi 17.21)

It is generally thought, at least in the Western world, that the yoga system involves meditating on the void. But the Vedic literatures do not recommend meditating on any void. Rather, the Vedas maintain that yoga means meditation on Viñëu, and this is also maintained in Bhagavad-gétä. In many yoga societies we find that people sit cross-legged and very straight, then close their eyes to meditate, and so fifty percent of them go to sleep because when we close our eyes and have no subject matter for contemplation, we simply go to sleep. Of course this is not recommended by Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä. One must sit very straight, and the eyes be only half-closed, gazing at the tip of one's nose. If one does not follow the instructions, the result will be sleep and nothing more. Sometimes, of course, meditation goes on when one is sleeping, but this is not the recommended process for the execution of yoga. Thus to keep oneself awake Kåñëa advises that one always keep the tip of the nose visible. In addition, one must be always undisturbed. If the mind is agitated, or if there is a great deal of activity going on, one will not be able to concentrate. In meditational yoga one must also be devoid of fear. There is no question of fear when one enters spiritual life. And one must also be brahmacäré, completely free from sex life. Nor can there be any demands on one meditating in this way. When there are no demands, and one executes this system properly, then he can control his mind. After one has met all the requirements for meditation, he must transfer his whole thought to Kåñëa or Viñëu. It is not that one is to transfer his thought to vacancy. Thus Kåñëa says that one absorbed in the meditational yoga system is "always thinking of Me."

The yogé obviously has to go through a great deal of difficulty to purify the ätmä (mind, body and soul), but it is a fact that this can be done most effectively in this age simply by the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Why is this? Because this transcendental sound vibration is nondifferent from Him. When we chant His name with devotion, then Kåñëa is with us, and when Kåñëa is with us, then what is the possibility of remaining impure? Consequently, one absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness, in chanting the names of Kåñëa and serving Him always, receives the benefit of the highest form of yoga. The advantage is that he doesn't have to take all the trouble of the meditational process. That is the beauty of Kåñëa consciousness.

In yoga it is necessary to control all of the senses, and when all the senses are controlled, the mind must be engaged in thinking of Viñëu. One becomes peaceful after thus conquering material life.

jitätmanaù praçäntasya
paramätmä samähitaù
çétoñëa-sukha-duùkheñu
tathä mänäpamänayoù

"For one who has conquered the mind, the Supersoul is already reached, for he has attained tranquility." (Bg. 6.7)

This material world has been likened to a great forest fire. As in the forest, fire may automatically take place, so in this material world, although we may try to live peacefully, there is always a great conflagration. It is not possible to live in peace anywhere in the material world. But for one who is transcendentally situated—either by the meditational yoga system or by the empirical philosophical method, or by bhakti-yoga—peace is possible. All forms of yoga are meant for transcendental life, but the method of chanting is especially effective in this age. Kértana may go on for hours, and one may not feel tired, but it is difficult to sit in lotus position perfectly still for more than a few minutes. Yet regardless of the process, once the fire of material life is extinguished, one does not simply experience what is called the impersonal void. Rather, as Kåñëa tells Arjuna, one enters into the supreme abode.

yuïjann evaà sadätmänaà
yogé niyata-mänasaù
çäntià nirväëa-paramäà
mat-saàsthäm adhigacchati

"By meditating in this manner, always controlling the body, mind and activities, the mystic transcendentalist attains to peace, the supreme nirväëa which abides in Me." (Bg. 6.15)

Kåñëa's abode is not void. It is like an establishment, and in an establishment there is a variety of engagements. The successful yogé actually attains to the Kingdom of God where there is spiritual variegatedness. The yoga processes are simply ways to elevate oneself to enter into that abode. Actually we belong to that abode, but, being forgetful, we are put in this material world. Just as a madman becomes crazy and is put into a lunatic asylum, so we, losing sight of our spiritual identity, become crazy and are put into this material world. Thus the material world is a sort of lunatic asylum, and we can easily notice that nothing is done very sanely here. Our real business is to get out and enter into the Kingdom of God. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa gives information of this kingdom and also gives instructions about His position and our position—of what He is and what we are. All the information necessary is set forth in Bhagavad-gétä, and a sane man will take advantage of this knowledge.

PoY 4: Yoga as Rejected by Arjuna

4
Yoga As Rejected By Arjuna

[660914BG.NY]

There have been many yoga systems popularized in the Western World, especially in this century, but none of them have actually taught the perfection of yoga. In the Bhagavad-gétä, Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, teaches Arjuna directly the perfection of yoga. If we actually want to participate in the perfection of the yoga system, in Bhagavad-gétä we will find the authoritative statements of the Supreme Person.

It is certainly remarkable that the perfection of yoga was taught in the middle of a battlefield. It was taught to Arjuna, the warrior, just before Arjuna was to engage in a fratricidal battle. Out of sentiment, Arjuna was thinking, "Why should I fight against my own kinsmen?" That reluctance to fight was due to Arjuna's illusion, and just to eradicate that illusion, Çré Kåñëa spoke the Bhagavad-gétä to him. One can just imagine how little time must have elapsed while Bhagavad-gétä was being spoken. All the warriors on both sides were poised to fight, so there was very little time indeed—at the utmost, one hour. Within this one hour, the whole Bhagavad-gétä was discussed, and Çré Kåñëa set forth the perfection of all yoga systems to His friend Arjuna. At the end of this great discourse, Arjuna set aside his misgivings and fought.

However, within the discourse, when Arjuna heard the explanation of the meditational system of yoga—how to sit down, how to keep the body straight, how to keep the eyes half-closed and how to gaze at the tip of the nose without diverting one's attention, all this being conducted in a secluded place alone—he replied:

yo 'yaà yogas tvayä proktaù
sämyena madhusüdana
etasyähaà na paçyämi
caïcalatvät sthitià sthiräm

"O Madhusüdana, the system of yoga which You have summarized appears impractical and unendurable to me, for the mind is restless and unsteady." (Bg. 6.33)

This is important. We must always remember that we are in a material circumstance wherein at every moment our mind is subject to agitation. Actually we are not in a very comfortable situation. We are always thinking that by changing our situation we will overcome our mental agitation, and we are always thinking that when we reach a certain point, all mental agitations will disappear. But it is the nature of the material world that we cannot be free from anxiety. Our dilemma is that we are always trying to make a solution to our problems, but this universe is so designed that these solutions never come.

Not being a cheater, being very frank and open, Arjuna tells Kåñëa that the system of yoga which He has described is not possible for him to execute. In speaking to Kåñëa, it is significant that Arjuna addresses Him as Madhusüdana, indicating that the Lord is the killer of the demon Madhu. It is notable that God's names are innumerable, for He is often named according to His activities. Indeed, God has innumerable names because He has innumerable activities. We are only parts of God, and we cannot even remember how many activities we engage in from our childhood to the present. The eternal God is unlimited, and since His activities are also unlimited, He has unlimited names, of which Kåñëa is the chief. Then why is Arjuna addressing Him as Madhusüdana when, being Kåñëa's friend, he could address Him directly as Kåñëa? The answer is that Arjuna considers his mind to be like a great demon, such as the demon Madhu. If it were possible for Kåñëa to kill the demon called the mind, then Arjuna would be able to attain the perfection of yoga. "My mind is much stronger than this demon Madhu," Arjuna is saying. "Please, if You could kill him, then it would be possible for me to execute this yoga system." Even the mind of a great man like Arjuna is always agitated. As Arjuna himself says:

caïcalaà hi manaù kåñëa
pramäthi balavad dåòham
tasyähaà nigrahaà manye
väyor iva suduñkaram

"For the mind is restless, turbulent, obstinate and very strong, O Kåñëa, and to subdue it is, it seems to me, more difficult than controlling the wind." (Bg. 6.34)

It is indeed a fact that the mind is always telling us to go here, go there, do this, do that—it is always telling us which way to turn. Thus the sum and substance of the yoga system is to control the agitated mind. In the meditational yoga system the mind is controlled by focusing on the Supersoul—that is the whole purpose of yoga. But Arjuna says that controlling this mind is more difficult than stopping the wind from blowing. One can imagine a man stretching out his arms trying to stop a hurricane. Are we to assume that Arjuna is simply not sufficiently qualified to control his mind? The actual fact is that we cannot begin to understand the immense qualifications of Arjuna. After all, he was a personal friend of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is a highly elevated position and is one that cannot be at all attained by one without great qualifications. In addition to this, Arjuna was renowned as a great warrior and administrator. He was such an intelligent man that he could understand Bhagavad-gétä within one hour, whereas at the present moment great scholars cannot even understand it in the course of a lifetime. Yet Arjuna was thinking that controlling the mind was simply not possible for him. Are we then to assume that what was impossible for Arjuna in a more advanced age is possible for us in this degenerate age? We should not for one moment think that we are in Arjuna's category. We are a thousand times inferior.

Moreover, there is no record of Arjuna's having executed the yoga system at any time. At the same time Arjuna was praised by Kåñëa as the only man worthy of understanding Bhagavad-gétä. What was Arjuna's great qualification? Çré Kåñëa says, "You are My devotee. You are My very dear friend." Despite this qualification, Arjuna refused to execute the meditational yoga system described by Çré Kåñëa. What then are we to conclude? Are we to despair the mind's ever being controlled? No, it can be controlled, and the process is this Kåñëa consciousness. The mind must be fixed always in Kåñëa. Insofar as the mind is absorbed in Kåñëa it has attained the perfection of yoga.

Now when we turn to the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, in the Twelfth Canto we find Çukadeva Gosvämé telling Mahäräja Parékñit that in the Golden Age, the Satya-yuga, people were living for l00,000 years, and at that time, when advanced living entities lived for such lengths of time, it was possible to execute this meditational system of yoga. But what was achieved in the Satya-yuga by this meditational process, and in the following yuga, the Tretä-yuga, by the offering of great sacrifices, and in the next yuga, the Dväpara-yuga, by temple worship, would be achieved at the present time, in this Kali-yuga, by simply chanting the names of God, hari-kértana, Hare Kåñëa. So from authoritative sources we learn that this chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is the embodiment of the perfection of yoga for this age.

Today we have great difficulties living fifty or sixty years. A man may live at the utmost eighty or a hundred years. In addition, these brief years are always fraught with anxiety, with difficulties due to circumstances of war, pestilence, famine and so many other disturbances. We're also not very intelligent, and, at the same time, we're unfortunate. These are the characteristics of man living in Kali-yuga, a degraded age. So properly speaking we can never attain success in this meditational yoga system described by Kåñëa. At the utmost we can only gratify our personal whims by some pseudoadaptation of this system. Thus people are paying money to attend some classes in gymnastic exercises and deep-breathing, and they're happy if they think they can lengthen their lifetimes by a few years or enjoy better sex life. But we must understand that this is not the actual yoga system. In this age that meditational system cannot be properly executed. Instead, all of the perfections of that system can be realized through bhakti-yoga, the sublime process of Kåñëa consciousness, specifically mantra-yoga, the glorification of Çré Kåñëa through the chanting of Hare Kåñëa. That is recommended in Vedic Scriptures and is introduced by great authorities like Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Indeed, the Bhagavad-gétä proclaims that the mahätmäs, the great souls, are always chanting the glories of the Lord. If one wants to be a mahätmä in terms of the Vedic literature, in terms of Bhagavad-gétä and in terms of the great authorities, then one has to adopt this process of Kåñëa consciousness and of chanting Hare Kåñëa. But if we're content at making a show of meditation by sitting very straight in lotus position and going into a trance like some sort of performer, then that is a different thing. But we should understand that such show-bottle performances have nothing to do with the actual perfection of yoga. The material disease cannot be cured by artificial medicine. We have to take the real cure straight from Kåñëa.

PoY 5: Yoga as Body and Mind Control

5
Yoga As Body And Mind Control

[660914BG.NY][660907BG.NY] [660904BG.NY]

Throughout Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa was encouraging Arjuna to fight, for he was a warrior, and fighting was his duty. Although Kåñëa delineates the meditational yoga system in the Sixth Chapter, He does not stress it nor encourage Arjuna to pursue it as his path. Kåñëa admits that this meditational process is very difficult:

çré-bhagavän uväca
asaàçayaà mahä-bäho
mano durnigrahaà calam
abhyäsena tu kaunteya
vairägyeëa ca gåhyate

"The Blessed Lord said: O mighty-armed son of Kunté, it is undoubtedly very difficult to curb the restless mind, but it is possible by constant practice and by detachment." (Bg. 6.35)

Here Kåñëa emphasizes practice and renunciation as ways to control the mind. But what is that renunciation? Today it is hardly possible for us to renounce anything, for we are so habituated to such a variety of material sense pleasures. Despite leading a life of uncontrolled sense indulgence, we attend yoga classes and expect to attain success. There are so many rules and regulations involved in the proper execution of yoga, and most of us can hardly give up a simple habit like smoking.

In His discourse on the meditational yoga system, Kåñëa proclaims that yoga cannot be properly performed by one who eats too much or eats too little. One who starves himself cannot properly perform yoga. Nor can the person who eats more than required. The eating process should be moderate, just enough to keep body and soul together; it should not be for the enjoyment of the tongue. When palatable dishes come before us, we are accustomed to take not just one of the preparations but two, three and four—and upwards. Our tongue is never satisfied. But it is not unusual in India to see a yogé take only a small spoonful of rice a day and nothing more. Nor can one execute the meditational yoga system if one sleeps too much or does not sleep sufficiently. Kåñëa does not say that there is such a thing as dreamless sleep. As soon as we go to sleep, we will have a dream, although we may not remember it. In the Gétä Kåñëa cautions that one who dreams too much while sleeping cannot properly execute yoga. One should not sleep more than six hours daily. Nor can one infected by insomnia, who cannot sleep at night, successfully execute yoga, for the body must be kept fit. Thus Kåñëa outlines so many requirements for disciplining the body. All these requirements, however, can essentially be broken down into four basic rules: no illicit sexual connection, no intoxication, no meat-eating and no gambling. These are the four minimum regulations for the execution of any yoga system. And in this age who can refrain from these activities? We have to test ourselves accordingly to ascertain our success in yoga execution.

yogé yuïjéta satatam
ätmänaà rahasi sthitaù
ekäké yata-cittätmä
niräçér aparigrahaù

"A transcendentalist should always try to concentrate his mind on the Supreme Self; he should live alone in a secluded place and should always carefully control his mind. He should be free from desires and feelings of possessiveness." (Bg. 6.10)

From this verse we can understand that it is the duty of the yogé to always remain alone. Meditational yoga cannot be performed in an assembly, at least not according to Bhagavad-gétä. It is not possible to concentrate the mind in the meditational system upon the Supersoul except in a secluded place. In India, there are still many yogés who assemble at the Kumba Melä. Generally they are in seclusion, but on rare occasions they come to attend special functions. In India there are still thousands of yogés and sages, and every twelve years or so they meet in particular holy places—Allahabad, etc.—just as in America they have businessmen's conventions. The yogé, in addition to living in a secluded place, should also be free from desires and should not think that he is performing yoga to achieve some material powers. Nor should he accept gifts or favors from people. If he is properly executing this meditational yoga, he stays alone in the jungles, forests or mountains and avoids society altogether. At all times he must be convinced for whom he has become a yogé. He does not consider himself alone because at all times the Paramätmä—Supersoul—is with him. From this we can see that in modern civilization it is indeed very difficult to execute this meditational form of yoga properly. Contemporary civilization in this age of Kali has actually made it impossible for us to be alone, to be desireless and to be possessionless.

The method of executing meditational yoga is further explained in considerable detail by Kåñëa to Arjuna. Çré Kåñëa says:

çucau deçe pratiñöhäpya
sthiram äsanam ätmanaù
näty-ucchritaà nätinécaà
cailäjina-kuçottaram

tatraikägraà manaù kåtvä
yata-cittendriya-kriyaù
upaviçyäsane yuïjyäd
yogam ätma-viçuddhaye

"To practice yoga, one should go to a secluded place and should lay kuça grass on the ground and then cover it with a deerskin and a soft cloth. The seat should neither be too high nor too low and should be situated in a sacred place. The yogé should then sit on it very firmly and should practice yoga by controlling the mind and the senses, purifying the heart and fixing the mind on one point." (Bg. 6.11-12)

Generally yogés sit on tigerskin or deerskin because reptiles will not crawl on such skins to disturb their meditations. It seems that in God's creation there is a use for everything. Every grass and herb has its use and serves some function, although we may not know what it is. So in Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa has made some provision whereby the yogé doesn't have to worry about snakes. Having acquired a good sitting place in a secluded environment, the yogé begins to purify the ätmä—body, mind and soul. The yogé should not think, "Now I will try to achieve some wonderful powers." Sometimes yogés do attain certain siddhis or powers, but these are not the purpose of yoga, and real yogés do not exhibit them. The real yogé thinks, "I am now contaminated by this material atmosphere, so now I must purify myself."

We can quickly see that controlling the mind and body is not such an easy thing and that we cannot control them as easily as we can go to the store and purchase something. But Kåñëa indicates that these rules can be easily followed when we are in Kåñëa consciousness.

Of course everyone is motivated by sex life, but sex life is not actually discouraged. We have this material body, and as long as we have it, sex desire will be there. Similarly, as long as we have the body, we must eat to maintain it, and we must sleep in order to give it rest. We cannot expect to negate these activities, but the Vedic literatures do give us guidelines for regulation in eating, sleeping, mating, etc. If we at all expect success in the yoga system, we cannot allow our unbridled senses to take us down the paths of sense objects; therefore guidelines are set up. Lord Çré Kåñëa is advising that the mind can be controlled through regulation. If we do not regulate our activities, our mind will be more and more agitated. It is not that activities are to be stopped, but regulated by the mind always engaged in Kåñëa consciousness. Being always engaged in some activity connected with Kåñëa is actual samädhi. It is not that when one is in samädhi he doesn't eat, work, sleep or enjoy himself in any way. Rather, samädhi can be defined as executing regulated activities while absorbed in the thought of Kåñëa.

asaàyatätmanä yogo
duñpräpa iti me matiù
vaçyätmanä tu yatatä
çakyo 'väptum upäyataù

"For one whose mind is unbridled," Kåñëa further says, "self-realization is difficult work." (Bg. 6.36)

Anyone knows that an unbridled horse is dangerous to ride. He can go in any direction at any speed, and his rider is likely to come to some harm. Insofar as the mind is unbridled, Kåñëa agrees with Arjuna that the yoga system is very difficult work indeed. "But," Kåñëa adds, "he whose mind is controlled and strives by right means is assured of success. That is My judgement." (Bg. 6.36) What is meant by "strives by right means"? One has to try to follow the four basic regulative principles as mentioned and execute his activities absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness.

If one wants to engage in yoga at home, then he has to make certain that his other engagements are moderate. He cannot spend long hours of the day working hard to simply earn a livelihood. One should work very moderately, eat very moderately, gratify his senses very moderately and keep his life as free from anxiety as possible. In this way practice of yoga may be successful.

What is the sign by which we can tell that one has attained perfection in yoga? Kåñëa indicates that one is situated in yoga when his consciousness is completely under his control.

yadä viniyataà cittam
ätmany evävatiñöhate
nispåhaù sarva-kämebhyo
yukta ity ucyate tadä

"When the yogé, by practice of yoga, disciplines his mental activities and becomes situated in Transcendence—devoid of all material desires—he is said to have attained yoga." (Bg. 6.18)

One who has attained yoga is not dependent on the dictations of his mind; rather, the mind comes under his control. Nor is the mind put out or extinguished, for it is the business of the yogé to think of Kåñëa or Viñëu always. The yogé cannot allow his mind to go out. This may sound very difficult, but it is possible in Kåñëa consciousness. When one is always engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, in the service of Kåñëa, then how is it possible for the mind to wander away from Kåñëa? In the service of Kåñëa, the mind is automatically controlled.

Nor should the yogé have any desire for material sense gratification. If one is in Kåñëa consciousness, he has no desire other than Kåñëa. It is not possible to become desireless. The desire for sense gratification must be overcome by the process of purification, but desire for Kåñëa should be cultivated. It is simply that we have to transfer the desire. There is no question of killing desire, for desire is the constant companion of the living entity. Kåñëa consciousness is the process by which one purifies his desires; instead of desiring so many things for sense gratification, one simply desires things for the service of Kåñëa. For example, we may desire palatable food, but instead of preparing foodstuffs for ourselves, we can prepare them for Kåñëa and offer them to Him. It is not that the action is different, but there is a transfer of consciousness from thinking of acting for my senses to thinking of acting for Kåñëa. We may prepare nice milk products, vegetables, grains, fruits and other vegetarian dishes for Kåñëa and then offer them to Him praying, "This material body is a lump of ignorance and the senses are a network of paths leading to death. Of all the senses the tongue is the most voracious and difficult to control. It is very difficult to conquer the tongue in this world; therefore Çré Kåñëa has given us this nice prasädam, spiritual food, to conquer the tongue. So let us take this prasädam to our full satisfaction and glorify Their Lordships Çré Çré Rädhä and Kåñëa and in love call for the help of Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda Prabhu." In this way our karma is sacrificed, for from the very beginning we are thinking that the food is being offered to Kåñëa. We should have no personal desires for the food. Kåñëa is so merciful, however, that he gives us the food to eat. In this way our desire is fulfilled. When one has molded his life in such a way—dovetailing his desires to Kåñëa's—then it is to be understood that he has attained perfection in yoga. Simply breathing deeply and doing some exercises is not yoga as far as Bhagavad-gétä is concerned. A whole purification of consciousness is required.

In the execution of yoga, it is very important that the mind is not agitated.

yathä dépo nivätastho
neìgate sopamä småtä
yogino yata-cittasya
yuïjato yogam ätmanaù

"As a lamp in a windless place does not waver, so the transcendentalist, whose mind is controlled, remains always steady in his meditation on the transcendent Self." (Bg. 6.19)

When a candle is in a windless place, its flame remains straight and does not waver. The mind, like the flame, is susceptible to so many material desires that with the slightest agitation it will move. A little movement of the mind can change the whole consciousness. Therefore in India one seriously practicing yoga traditionally remained brahmacäré, or celibate. There are two kinds of brahmacäré; one is completely celibate and the other is gåhastha-brahmacäré, that is to say he has a wife, he does not associate with any other woman, and his relations with his own wife are strictly regulated. In this way, either by complete celibacy or restricted sex life, one's mind is kept from being agitated. Yet when one takes a vow to remain a complete celibate, his mind may still be agitated by sexual desire; therefore in India those practicing the traditional yoga under strict vows of celibacy are not allowed to sit alone even with a mother, sister or daughter. The mind is so fickle that the slightest suggestion can create havoc.

The yogé should have his mind trained in such a way that as soon as his mind wanders from meditation on Viñëu, he drags it back again. This requires a great deal of practice. One must come to know that his real happiness is in experiencing the pleasure of his transcendental senses, not the material senses. Senses are not to be sacrificed, and desires are not to be sacrificed, but there are both desires and sense satisfaction in the spiritual sphere. Real happiness is transcendental to material, sensual experience. If one is not convinced of this, he will surely be agitated and will fall down. One should therefore know that the happiness he is trying to derive from material senses is not really happiness.

Those who are actually yogés truly enjoy, but how do they enjoy? Ramante yogino 'nante—their enjoyment is unlimited, and that unlimited enjoyment is real happiness, and such happiness is spiritual, not material. This is the real meaning of Räma, as in the chant Hare Räma. Räma means enjoyment through spiritual life. Spiritual life is all pleasure, and Kåñëa is all pleasure. We do not have to sacrifice pleasure, but we do have to enjoy it properly. A diseased man cannot enjoy life; his enjoyment of life is a false enjoyment. But when he is cured and is healthy, then he is able to enjoy. Similarly, as long as we are in the material conception of life, we are not actually enjoying ourselves but are simply becoming more and more entangled in material nature. If a sick man is not supposed to eat, his eating unrestrictedly actually kills him. Similarly, the more we increase material enjoyment, the more we become entangled in this world and the more difficult it becomes to get free from the material entrapment. All of the systems of yoga are meant to disentangle the conditioned soul from this entrapment, to transfer him from the false enjoyment of material things to the actual enjoyment of Kåñëa consciousness. Çré Kåñëa says:

yatroparamate cittaà
niruddhaà yoga-sevayä
yatra caivätmanätmänaà
paçyann ätmani tuñyati

sukham ätyantikaà yat tad
buddhi-grähyam aténdriyam
vetti yatra na caiväyaà
sthitaç calati tattvataù

yaà labdhvä cäparaà läbhaà
manyate nädhikaà tataù
yasmin sthito na duùkhena
guruëäpi vicälyate

taà vidyäd duùkha-saàyoga
viyogaà yoga-saàjïitam
sa niçcayena yoktavyo
yogo 'nirviëëa-cetasä

"The stage of perfection is called trance, or samädhi, when one's mind is completely restrained from material mental activities by practice of yoga. This is characterized by one's ability to see the self by the pure mind and to relish and rejoice in the self. In that joyous state, one is situated in boundless transcendental happiness and enjoys himself through transcendental senses. Established thus, one never departs from the truth, and upon gaining this he thinks there is no greater gain. Being situated in such a position, one is never shaken, even in the midst of greatest difficulty. This indeed is actual freedom from all miseries arising from material contact." (Bg. 6.20-23)

One form of yoga may be difficult and another may be easy, but in all cases one must purify his existence to the conception of Kåñëa conscious enjoyment. Then one will be happy.

yadä hi nendriyärtheñu
na karmasv anuñajjate
sarva-saìkalpa-sannyäsé
yogärüòhas tadocyate

uddhared ätmanätmänaà
nätmänam avasädayet
ätmaiva hy ätmano bandhur
ätmaiva ripur ätmanaù

"A person is said to have attained to yoga when, having renounced all material desires, he neither acts for sense gratification nor engages in fruitive activities. A man must elevate himself by his own mind, not degrade himself. The mind is the friend of the conditioned soul, and his enemy as well." (Bg. 6.4-5)

We have to raise ourselves to the spiritual standard by ourselves. In this sense I am my own friend and I am my own enemy. The opportunity is ours. There is a very nice verse by Cäëakya Paëòit: "No one is anyone's friend, no one is anyone's enemy. It is only by behavior that one can understand who is his friend and who is his enemy." No one is born our enemy, and no one is born our friend. These roles are determined by mutual behavior. As we have dealings with others in ordinary affairs, in the same way the individual has dealings with himself. I may act as my own friend or as an enemy. As a friend, I can understand my position as spirit soul and, seeing that somehow or other I have come into contact with material nature, try to get free from material entanglement by acting in such a way as to disentangle myself. In this case I am my friend. But if even after getting this opportunity I do not take it, then I should be considered my own worst enemy.

bandhur ätmätmanas tasya
yenätmaivätmanä jitaù
anätmanas tu çatrutve
vartetätmaiva çatruvat

"For him who has conquered the mind, the mind is the best of friends; but for one who has failed to do so, his very mind will be the greatest enemy." (Bg. 6.6)

How is it possible for one to become his own friend? This is explained here; ätmä means mind, body and soul. When we speak of ätmä, insofar as we are in the bodily conception, we refer to the body. However, when we transcend the bodily conception and rise to the mental platform, ätmä refers to the mind. But actually when we are situated on the truly spiritual platform, then ätmä refers to the soul. In actuality we are pure spirit. In this way, according to one's spiritual development, the meaning of the word ätmä differs. As far as the Nirukti Vedic Dictionary is concerned, ätmä refers to body, mind and soul. However, in this verse of Bhagavad-gétä, ätmä refers to mind.

If, through yoga, the mind can be trained, then the mind is our friend. But if the mind is left untrained, then there is no possibility of leading a successful life. For one who has no idea of spiritual life, the mind is the enemy. If one thinks that he is simply the body, his mind will not be working for his benefit; it will simply be acting to serve the gross body and to further condition the living entity and entrap him in material nature. If, however, one understands one's position as spirit soul apart from the body, the mind can be a liberating factor. In itself, the mind has nothing to do, it is simply waiting to be trained, and it is best trained through association. Desire is the function of the mind, and one desires according to his association; so if the mind is to act as friend, there must be good association.

The best association is a sädhu, that is, a Kåñëa conscious person or one who is striving for spiritual realization. There are those who are striving for temporary things (asat). Matter and the body are temporary, and if one only engages himself for bodily pleasure, he is conditioned by temporary things. But if he engages himself in self-realization, then he is engaged in something permanent (sat). Obviously if one is intelligent he will associate with those who are trying to elevate themselves to the platform of self-realization through one of the various forms of yoga. The result will be that those who are sädhu, or realized, will be able to sever his attachment to material association. This is the great advantage to good association. For instance, Kåñëa speaks Bhagavad-gétä to Arjuna just to cut off his attachment to this material affection. Because Arjuna is attracted to things that are impeding the execution of his own duty, Kåñëa severs these things. To cut something, a sharp instrument is required; and to cut the mind from its attachments, sharp words are often required. The sädhu or teacher shows no mercy in using sharp words to sever the student's mind from material attractions. By speaking the truth uncompromisingly, he is able to sever the bondage. For example, at the very beginning of Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa speaks sharply to Arjuna by telling him that although he speaks like a learned man, he is actually fool number one. If we actually want detachment from this material world, we should be prepared to accept such cutting words from the spiritual master. Compromise and flattery have no effect where strong words are required.

In Bhagavad-gétä the material conception of life is condemned in so many places. One who thinks the country in which he is born is worshipable, or one who goes to holy places and yet ignores the sädhus there, is likened unto an ass. As an enemy is always thinking of doing harm, so the untrained mind will drag one deeper and deeper into material entanglement. Conditioned souls struggle very hard with the mind and with the other senses. Since the mind directs the other senses, it is of utmost importance to make the mind the friend.

jitätmanaù praçäntasya
paramätmä samähitaù
çétoñëa-sukha-duùkheñu
tathä mänäpamänayoù

"For one who has conquered the mind, the Supersoul is already reached, for he has attained tranquility. To such a man happiness and distress, heat and cold, honor and dishonor are all the same." (Bg. 6.7)

By training the mind, one actually attains tranquillity, for the mind is always dragging us over nonpermanent things, just as an unbridled horse will pull a chariot on a perilous course. Although we are permanent and eternal, somehow or other we have become attracted to nonpermanent things. But the mind can be easily trained if it is simply fixed on Kåñëa. Just as when a fort is safe when it is defended by a great general, if Kåñëa is placed in the fort of the mind, there will be no possibility of the enemy entering. Material education, wealth and power will not help one to control the mind. A great devotee prays, "When will I be able to think of You constantly? My mind is always dragging me about, but as soon as I am able to fix my mind on the lotus feet of Kåñëa, it becomes clear." When the mind is clear, it is possible to meditate on the Supersoul. The Paramätmä, or Supersoul, is always seated within the heart along with the individual soul. The yoga system involves concentrating the mind and focusing it on the Paramätmä or Supersoul seated within the heart. The above quoted verse from Bhagavad-gétä indicates that one who has conquered the mind and has overcome all attachment to nonpermanent things can be absorbed in thought of the Paramätmä. One so absorbed becomes free from all duality and false designations.

PoY 6: Yoga as Freedom from Duality and Designation

6
Yoga As Freedom From Duality And Designation

[660904BG.NY]

This material world is a world of duality—at one moment we are subjected to the heat of the summer season and at the next moment the cold of winter. Or at one moment we're happy and at the next moment distressed. At one moment honored, at the next dishonored. In the material world of duality, it is impossible to understand one thing without understanding its opposite. It is not possible to understand what honor is unless I understand dishonor. Similarly, I cannot understand what misery is if I have never tasted happiness. Nor can I understand what happiness is unless I have tasted misery. One has to transcend such dualities, but as long as this body is here these dualities will be here also. Insofar as one strives to get out of bodily conceptions—not out of the body but out of bodily conceptions—one has to learn to tolerate such dualities. In the Second Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa informs Arjuna that the duality of distress and happiness is due to the body alone. It's like a skin disease, or skin itch. Just because there is itching, one should not be mad after it to scratch it. We should not go mad or give up our duty just because mosquitoes bite us. There are so many dualities one has to tolerate, but if the mind is fixed in Kåñëa consciousness, all these dualities will seem insignificant.

How is it one can tolerate such dualities?

jïäna-vijïäna-tåptätmä
küöastho vijitendriyaù
yukta ity ucyate yogé
sama-loñöräçma-käïcanaù

"A person is said to be established in self-realization and is called a yogé (or mystic) when he is fully satisfied by virtue of acquired knowledge and realization. Such a person is situated in transcendence and is self-controlled. He sees everything—whether it be pebbles, stones or gold—as the same." (Bg. 6.8)

Jïäna means theoretical knowledge, and vijïäna refers to practical knowledge. For instance, a science student has to study theoretical scientific conceptions as well as applied science. Theoretical knowledge alone will not help. One has to be able to also apply this knowledge. Similarly, in yoga one should have not only theoretical knowledge but practical knowledge. Simply understanding "I am not this body" and at the same time acting in a nonsensical way will not help. There are so many societies where the members seriously discuss Vedänta philosophy while smoking and drinking and enjoying a sensual life. It will not help if one only has knowledge theoretically. This knowledge must be demonstrated. One who truly understands "I am not this body" will actually reduce his bodily necessities to a minimum. When one increases the demands of the body while thinking "I am not this body," then of what use is that knowledge? A person can only be satisfied when there is jïäna and vijïäna side by side.

When a person is situated on the practical level of spiritual realization, it should be understood he is actually situated in yoga. It is not that one should continue to attend yoga classes and yet remain the same throughout his life; there must be practical realization. And what is the sign of that practical realization? The mind will be calm and quiet and no longer agitated by the attraction of the material world. Thus self-controlled, one is not attracted by the material glitter, and he sees everything—pebbles, stones or gold—as the same. In the material civilization, so much paraphernalia is produced just to satisfy the senses. These things are produced under the banner of material advancement. He who is situated in yoga sees such paraphernalia as just so much rubbish in the street. Moreover:

suhån-miträry-udäséna-
madhyastha-dveñya-bandhuñu
sädhuñv api ca päpeñu
sama-buddhir viçiñyate

"A person is said to be still further advanced when he regards all—the honest well-wisher, friends and enemies, the envious, the pious, the sinner and those who are indifferent and impartial—with an equal mind." (Bg. 6.9)

There are different kinds of friends. There is suhåt, who is by nature a well-wisher and is always desiring one's welfare. Mitra refers to an ordinary friend, and udäséna is one who is neutral. In this material world someone may be my well-wisher, friend or neither friend nor enemy but neutral. Someone else may serve as a mediator between me and my enemies, and in this verse he is called madhya-stha. One may also see someone as pious and another as sinful according to his own calculations. But when he is situated in transcendence, all of these—friends, enemies or whatever—cease to exist. When one becomes actually learned, he does not see any enemy or any friend because in actuality "no one is my enemy, no one is my friend, no one is my father, no one is my mother, etc." We are all simply living entities playing on a stage in the dress of father, mother, children, friend, enemy, sinner and saint, etc. It is like a great drama with so many characters playing their parts. However, on the stage a person may be an enemy or whatever, but off the stage all the actors are friends. Similarly, with these bodies we are playing on the stage of material nature, and we attach so many designations to one another. I may be thinking, "This is my son," but in actuality I cannot beget any son. It is not possible. At the utmost I can only beget a body. It is not within any man's power to beget a living entity. Merely by sexual intercourse a living entity cannot be begotten. The living entity must be placed in the emulsification of secretions. This is the verdict of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Thus all the multifarious relationships between bodies are just so much stage play. One who is actually realized and has actually attained yoga no longer sees these bodily distinctions.

PoY 7: The Fate of the Unsuccessful Yogé

7
The Fate Of The Unsuccessful Yogé

[660914BG.NY][660918BG.NY]

It is not that Bhagavad-gétä rejects the meditational yoga process; it recognizes it as a bona fide method, but it further indicates that it is not possible in this age. Thus the subject in the Sixth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä is quickly dropped by Çré Kåñëa and Arjuna. Arjuna next asks:

ayatiù çraddhayopeto
yogäc calita-mänasaù
apräpya yoga-saàsiddhià
käà gatià kåñëa gacchati

"What is the destination of the man of faith who does not persevere, who in the beginning takes to the process of self-realization but who later desists due to worldly-mindedness and thus does not attain perfection in mysticism?" (Bg. 6.37)

In other words, he is asking what becomes of the unsuccessful yogé, or the person who attempts to perform yoga but somehow desists and does not succeed. It is something like a student who does not get his degree because he drops out of school. Elsewhere in the Gétä, Çré Kåñëa points out to Arjuna that out of many men few strive for perfection, and out of those who strive for perfection, only a few succeed. So Arjuna is inquiring after the vast number of failures. Even if a man has faith and strives for perfection in the yoga system, Arjuna points out that he may not attain this perfection due to "worldly-mindedness."

kaccin nobhaya-vibhrañöaç
chinnäbhram iva naçyati
apratiñöho mahä-bäho
vimüòho brahmaëaù pathi

"O mighty-armed Kåñëa," Arjuna continues, "does not such a man, being deviated from the path of Transcendence, perish like a riven cloud, with no position in any sphere?" (Bg. 6.38)

When a cloud is torn apart by the wind, it does not mend back together again.

etan me saàçayaà kåñëa
chettum arhasy açeñataù
tvad-anyaù saàçayasyäsya
chettä na hy upapadyate

"This is my doubt O Kåñëa, and I ask You to dispel it completely. But for Yourself, no one is to be found who can destroy this doubt." (Bg. 6.39)

Arjuna is asking this question about the fate of the unsuccessful yogé so that in the future people would not be discouraged. By a yogé, Arjuna is referring to the haöha-yogé, jïäna-yogé, and bhakti-yogé; it is not that meditation is the only form of yoga. The meditator, the philosopher and the devotee are all to be considered yogés. Arjuna is questioning for all those who are attempting to become successful transcendentalists. And how does Çré Kåñëa answer him?

çré bhagavän uväca
pärtha naiveha nämutra
vinäças tasya vidyate
na hi kalyäëa-kåt kaçcid
durgatià täta gacchati
[Bg. 6.40]

Here, as in many other places throughout the Gétä, Çré Kåñëa is referred to as Bhagavän. This is another of the Lord's innumerable names. Bhagavän indicates that Kåñëa is the proprietor of six opulences: He possesses all beauty, all wealth, all power, all fame, all knowledge and all renunciation. Living entities partake of these opulences in finite degrees. One may be famous in a family, in a town, in a country or on one planet, but no one is famous throughout the creation as is Çré Kåñëa. The leaders of the world may be famous for a few years only, but Lord Çré Kåñëa appeared 5,000 years ago and is still being worshiped. So one who possesses all six of these opulences in completeness is considered to be God.

In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa speaks to Arjuna as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and as such it is to be understood that He has complete knowledge. Bhagavad-gétä was imparted to the sun god and to Arjuna by Kåñëa, but nowhere is it mentioned that Bhagavad-gétä was imparted to Kåñëa. Why? Complete knowledge means that He knows everything that is to be known. This is an attribute of God alone. Being that Kåñëa knows everything, Arjuna is putting this question to Him about the fate of the unsuccessful yogé. There is no possibility for Arjuna to research the truth. He simply has to receive the truth from the complete source, and this is the system of disciplic succession. Kåñëa is complete, and the knowledge that comes from Kåñëa is also complete. If Arjuna receives this complete knowledge and we receive it from Arjuna as it was spoken to him, then we also receive complete knowledge. And what is this knowledge? "The Blessed Lord said: Son of Påthä, a transcendentalist engaged in auspicious activities does not meet with destruction either in this world or in the spiritual world; one who does good, My friend, is never overcome by evil." (Bg. 6.40) Here Kåñëa indicates that the very striving for yoga perfection is a most auspicious attempt. When one attempts something so auspicious, he is never degraded.

Actually Arjuna is asking a very appropriate and intelligent question. It is not unusual for one to fall down from the platform of devotional service. Sometimes a neophyte devotee does not keep the rules and regulations. Sometimes he yields to intoxication or is trapped by some feminine attractions. These are impediments on the path of yoga perfection. But Çré Kåñëa gives an encouraging answer, for He tells Arjuna that even if one sincerely cultivates only 1% worth of spiritual knowledge, he will never fall down into the material whirlpool. That is due to the sincerity of his effort. It should always be understood that we are weak and that the material energy is very strong. To adopt spiritual life is more or less to declare war against the material energy. The material energy is trying to entrap the conditioned soul as much as possible, and when the conditioned soul tries to get out of her clutches by spiritual advancement of knowledge, material nature becomes more stringent and vigorous in her efforts to test how much the aspiring spiritualist is sincere. The material energy, or mäyä, will then offer more allurements.

In this regard, there is the story of Viçvämitra Muni, a great king, a kñatriya, who renounced his kingdom and took to the yoga process in order to become more spiritually advanced. At that time the meditational yoga process was possible to execute. Viçvämitra Muni meditated so intently that Indra, the King of heaven, noticed him and thought, "This man is trying to occupy my post." The heavenly planets are also material, and there is competition—no businessman wants another businessman to exceed him. Fearing that Viçvämitra Muni would actually depose him, Indra sent one heavenly society girl, named Menakä, to allure him sexually. Menakä was naturally very beautiful, and she was intent on disrupting the muni's meditations. Indeed, he became aware of her feminine presence upon hearing the sound of her bangles, and he immediately looked up from his meditation, saw her, and became captivated by her beauty. As a result, the beautiful girl Çakuntalä was born by their conjugation. When Çakuntalä was born, Viçvämitra lamented. "Oh I was just trying to cultivate spiritual knowledge, and again I have been entrapped." He was about to flee when Menakä brought his beautiful daughter before him and chastised him. Despite her pleading, Viçvämitra resolved to leave anyway.

Thus there is every chance of failure on the yogic path when a great sage like Viçvämitra Muni falls down due to material allurement. Although the muni fell for the time being, he again resolved to go on with the yoga process, and this should be our resolve. Kåñëa informs us that such failures should not be cause for despair. There is the famous proverb that "Failure is the pillar of success." In the spiritual life especially, failure is not discouraging. Kåñëa very clearly states that even if there is failure, there is no loss either in this world or in the next. One who takes to this auspicious line of spiritual culture is never completely vanquished.

Now what actually happens to the unsuccessful spiritualist? Çré Kåñëa specifically explains:

präpya puëya-kåtäà lokän
uñitvä çäçvatéù samäù
çucénäà çrématäà gehe
yoga-bhrañöo 'bhijäyate

athavä yoginäm eva
kule bhavati dhématäm
etaddhi durlabhataraà
loke janma yad édåçam

"The unsuccessful yogé, after many, many years of enjoyment on the planets of the pious living entities, is born into a family of righteous people, or into a family of rich aristocracy. Or he takes his birth in a family of transcendentalists who are surely great in wisdom. Verily, such a birth is rare in this world." (Bg. 6.41-42)

There are many planets in the universe, and on the higher planets there are greater comforts, the duration of life is longer, and the inhabitants are more religious and godly. Since it is said that six months on earth is equal to one day on the higher planets, the unsuccessful yogé stays on these higher planets for many, many years. Vedic literatures describe their lifetimes as lasting 10,000 years. So even if one is a failure, he is promoted to these higher planets. But one cannot remain there perpetually. When the fruits or the results of one's pious activities expire, he has to return to earth. Yet even upon returning to this planet, the unsuccessful yogé meets with fortunate circumstances, for he takes his birth either in a very rich family or a pious one.

Generally, according to the law of karma, if one enacts pious deeds, he is awarded in the next life by birth into a very aristocratic family, or into a very wealthy family, or he becomes a great scholar, or he is born very beautiful. In any case, those who sincerely begin spiritual life are guaranteed human birth in the next life—not only human birth, but birth into either a very pious or a very wealthy family. Thus one with such a good birth should understand that his fortune is due to his previous pious activities and to God's grace. These facilities are given by the Lord, who is always willing to give us the means to attain Him. Kåñëa simply wants to see that we are sincere. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that every particular person has his own duty in life, regardless of his position and regardless of his society. If, however, he gives up his prescribed duty and somehow—either out of sentiment or association or craziness or whatever—takes shelter of Kåñëa, and if, due to his immaturity, he falls from the devotional path, still there is no loss for him. On the other hand, if a person executes his duties perfectly but does not approach God, then what does he earn? His life is indeed without benefit. But a person who has approached Kåñëa is better situated, even though he may fall down from the yogic platform.

Kåñëa further indicates that of all good families to be born into—families of successful merchants or philosophers or meditators—the best is the family of yogés. One who takes birth in a very rich family may be misled. It is normal for a man who is given great riches to try to enjoy those riches; thus rich men's sons often become drunkards or prostitute hunters. Similarly, one who takes birth in a pious family or in a brahminical family often becomes very puffed up and proud, thinking, "I am a brähmaëa; I am a pious man." There is chance of degradation in both rich and pious families, but one who takes birth in a family of yogés or of devotees has a much better chance of cultivating again that spiritual life from which he has fallen. Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

tatra taà buddhi-saàyogaà
labhate paurva-dehikam
yatate ca tato bhüyaù
saàsiddhau kuru-nandana

"On taking such a birth, he again revives the divine consciousness of his previous life, and he tries to make further progress in order to achieve complete success, O son of Kuru." (Bg. 6.43)

Being born in a family of those who execute yoga or devotional service, one remembers his spiritual activities executed in his previous life. Anyone who takes to Kåñëa consciousness seriously is not an ordinary person; he must have taken to the same process in his previous life. Why is this?

pürväbhyäsena tenaiva
hriyate hy avaço 'pi saù
jijïäsur api yogasya
çabda-brahmätivartate

"By virtue of the divine consciousness of his previous life, he automatically becomes attracted to the yogic principles—even without seeking them." (Bg. 6.44)

In the material world, we have experience that we do not carry our assets from one life to another. I may have millions of dollars in the bank, but as soon as my body is finished, my bank balance is also. At death, the bank balance does not go with me; it remains in the bank to be enjoyed by somebody else. This is not the case with spiritual culture. Even if one enacts a very small amount on the spiritual platform, he takes that with him to his next life, and he picks up again from that point.

When one picks up this knowledge that was interrupted, he should know that he should now finish the balance and complete the yogic process. One should not take the chance of finishing up the process in another birth but should resolve to finish it in this life. We should be determined in this way: "Somehow or other in my last life, I did not finish my spiritual cultivation. Now Kåñëa has given me another opportunity, so let me finish it up in this life." Thus after leaving this body one will not again take birth in this material world where birth, old age, disease and death are omnipresent, but will return to Kåñëa. One who takes shelter under the lotus feet of Kåñëa sees this material world simply as a place of danger. For one who takes to spiritual culture, this material world is actually unfit. Çrémate Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté used to say, "This place is not fit for a gentleman." Once one has approached Kåñëa and has attempted to make spiritual progress, Kåñëa, who is situated within the heart, begins to give directions. In the Gétä, Çré Kåñëa says that for one who wants to remember Him, He gives remembrance, and for one who wants to forget Him, He allows him to forget.

PoY 8: The Perfection of Yoga

8
The Perfection Of Yoga

[Bg. 6.45p] [Bg. 6.47p]

It is a fact therefore that in the progress of the living entity toward the perfection of yoga, birth in a family of yogés or devotees is a great boon, for such a birth gives one a special impetus.

prayatnäd yatamänas tu
yogé saàçuddha-kilbiñaù
aneka-janma-saàsiddhas
tato yäti paräà gatim

"But when the yogé engages himself with sincere endeavor in making further progress, being washed of all contaminations, then ultimately, after many, many births of practice, he attains the supreme goal." (Bg. 6.45)

When one is finally freed from all contaminations, he attains the supreme perfection of the yoga system—Kåñëa consciousness. Absorption in Kåñëa is the perfect stage, as Kåñëa Himself confirms:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19)

Thus after many lifetimes of executing pious activities, when one becomes freed from all contaminations arising from illusory dualities, he engages in the transcendental service of the Lord. Çré Kåñëa concludes His discourse on this subject in this way:

yoginäm api sarveñäà
mad-gatenäntarätmanä
çraddhävän bhajate yo mäà
sa me yuktatamo mataù

"And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all." (Bg. 6.47)

It therefore follows that the culmination of all yogas lies in bhakti-yoga, the rendering of devotional service unto Kåñëa. Actually, all of the yogas delineated in Bhagavad-gétä end on this note, for Kåñëa is the ultimate destination of all the yoga systems. From the beginning of karma-yoga to the end of bhakti-yoga is a long way to self-realization. Karma-yoga, without fruitive results, is the beginning of this path. When karma-yoga increases in knowledge and renunciation, the stage is called jïäna-yoga, or the yoga of knowledge. When jïäna-yoga increases in meditation on the Supersoul by different physical processes, and the mind is on Him, it is called añöäìga-yoga. And, when one surpasses añöäìga-yoga and comes to worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead Kåñëa, that is called bhakti-yoga, the culmination. Factually, bhakti-yoga is the ultimate goal, but to analyze bhakti-yoga minutely one has to understand the other processes. The yogé who is progressive is therefore on the true path to eternal good fortune. One who sticks to a particular point and does not make further progress is called by that particular name—karma-yogé, jïäna-yogé, dhyäna-yogé, räja-yogé, haöha-yogé, etc.—but if one is fortunate enough to come to the point of bhakti-yoga, Kåñëa consciousness, it is to be understood that he has surpassed all the other yoga systems.

Kåñëa consciousness is the last link in the yogic chain, the link that binds us to the Supreme Person, Lord Çré Kåñëa. Without this final link, the chain is practically useless. Those who are truly interested in the perfection of the yoga process should immediately take to Kåñëa consciousness by chanting Hare Kåñëa, understanding Bhagavad-gétä, and rendering service to Kåñëa through this Society for Kåñëa Consciousness and thereby surpass all other systems and attain the ultimate goal of all yoga—love of Kåñëa.

Complete Edition
BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is pleased to announce the publication by the Macmillan Company of the longawaited Complete Edition of Bhagavad-gétä As It Is. This most basic and essential of all spiritual texts is now available in one complete, authoritative, beautifully illustrated 1,000 page volume. Bhagavad-gétä has long been appreciated as a scriptural literature of sublime importance by thoughtful men throughout the world, for its eighteen chapters shower upon man the immortal nectar of the wisdom of the Absolute. In Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, the message of this timeless classic is now transmitted in its purity and fullness. By reading this book, one can attain the perfection of human life.

1,000 pages, 44 full-color reproductions
hardcover $10.95, paperback $4.95

Çrémad-Bhägavatam

Never before has this sublime Text been available to the English-speaking world. Now ISKCON Press announces the forthcoming publication of Cantos I and II of Çrémad-Bhägavatam in five richly illustrated hardcover volumes.

The science of God is greater than all other sciences, and this spiritual technology is rationally and authoritatively explained in the 18,000 verses of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, India's sublime contribution of culture, philosophy, politics, sociology, religion and love. His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda has undertaken the mighty task of rendering this supremely potent work into the English language along with Sanskrit transliterations, word for word synonyms and elaborate English purports. Thus in each verse one will find new enlightenment regarding the Absolute Truth, the origin of all emanations. Available in Spring, 1972

1775 pages, 60 fullcolor reproductions
First Canto: Vol. I - $6.50 Vol. II - $5.50 Vol. III - $6.00
Second Canto: Vol. I - $6.50 Vol. II - $6.00

ISKCON BOOKS
3826 Willat Avenue
Culver City, California 90230

The stage of perfection is called trance, or samädhi, when one's mind is completely restrained from material mental activities by practice of yoga.

In that joyous state, one is situated in boundless transcendental happiness and enjoys himself through transcendental senses.

Established thus, one never departs from the truth, and upon gaining this he thinks there is no greater gain. (Bhagavad-gétä 6.20-23)


TYS 4: The Hare Kåñëa Mantra

4/The Hare Kåñëa Mantra

[ON CHANTING THE HARE KRISHNA MANTRA, BTG: Vol. 1, No. 07, February 1, 1967]

The transcendental vibration established by the chanting of HARE KÅÑËA, HARE KÅÑËA, KÅÑËA KÅÑËA, HARE HARE/ HARE RÄMA, HARE RÄMA, RÄMA RÄMA, HARE HARE is the sublime method for reviving our transcendental consciousness. As living spiritual souls, we are all originally Kåñëa conscious entities, but due to our association with matter from time immemorial, our consciousness is now adulterated by the material atmosphere. The material atmosphere, in which we are now living, is called mäyä, or illusion. Mäyä means that which is not. And what is this illusion? The illusion is that we are all trying to be lords of material nature, while actually we are under the grip of her stringent laws. When a servant artificially tries to imitate the all-powerful master, it is called illusion. We are trying to exploit the resources of material nature, but actually we are becoming more and more entangled in her complexities. Therefore, although we are engaged in a hard struggle to conquer nature, we are ever more dependent on her. This illusory struggle against material nature can be stopped at once by revival of our eternal Kåñëa consciousness.

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare is the transcendental process for reviving this original pure consciousness. By chanting this transcendental vibration, we can cleanse away all misgivings within our hearts. The basic principle of all such misgivings is the false consciousness that I am the lord of all I survey.

Kåñëa consciousness is not an artificial imposition on the mind. This consciousness is the original natural energy of the living entity. When we hear the transcendental vibration, this consciousness is revived. This simplest method of meditation is recommended for this age. By practical experience also, one can perceive that by chanting this mahämantra, or the Great Chanting for Deliverance, one can at once feel a transcendental ecstasy coming through from the spiritual stratum. In the material concept of life we are busy in the matter of sense gratification as if we were in the lower animal stage. A little elevated from this status of sense gratification, one is engaged in mental speculation for the purpose of getting out of the material clutches. A little elevated from this speculative status, when one is intelligent enough, one tries to find out the supreme cause of all causes—within and without. And when one is factually on the plane of spiritual understanding, surpassing the stages of sense, mind and intelligence, he is then on the transcendental plane. This chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra is enacted from the spiritual platform, and thus this sound vibration surpasses all lower strata of consciousness—namely sensual, mental and intellectual. There is no need, therefore, to understand the language of the mantra, nor is there any need for mental speculation nor any intellectual adjustment for chanting this mahämantra. It is automatic, from the spiritual platform, and as such, anyone can take part in vibrating this transcendental sound without any previous qualification. In a more advanced stage, of course, one is not expected to commit offenses on grounds of spiritual understanding.

In the beginning, there may not be the presence of all transcendental ecstasies, which are eight in number. These are: 1) Being stopped as though dumb, 2) perspiration, 3) standing up of hairs on the body, 4) dislocation of voice, 5) trembling, 6) fading of the body, 7) crying in ecstasy, and 8) trance. But there is no doubt that chanting for a while takes one immediately to the spiritual platform, and one shows the first symptom of this in the urge to dance along with the chanting of the mantra. We have seen this practically. Even a child can take part in the chanting and dancing. Of course, for one who is too entangled in material life, it takes a little more time to come to the standard point, but even such a materially engrossed man is raised to the spiritual platform very quickly. When it is chanted by a pure devotee of the Lord in love, it has the greatest efficacy on hearers, and as such this chanting should be heard from the lips of a pure devotee of the Lord, so that immediate effects can be achieved. As far as possible, chanting from the lips of nondevotees should be avoided. Milk touched by the lips of a serpent has poisonous effects.

The word Harä is the form of addressing the energy of the Lord, and the words Kåñëa and Räma are forms of addressing the Lord Himself. Both Kåñëa and Räma mean the supreme pleasure, and Harä is the supreme pleasure energy of the Lord, changed to Hare (Hah-ray) in the vocative. The supreme pleasure energy of the Lord helps us to reach the Lord.

The material energy, called mäyä, is also one of the multi-energies of the Lord. And we the living entities are also the energy, marginal energy, of the Lord. The living entities are described as superior to material energy. When the superior energy is in contact with the inferior energy, an incompatible situation arises; but when the superior marginal energy is in contact with the superior energy, called Harä, it is established in its happy, normal condition.

These three words, namely Harä, Kåñëa and Räma, are the transcendental seeds of the mahämantra. The chanting is a spiritual call for the Lord and His energy, to give protection to the conditioned soul. This chanting is exactly like the genuine cry of a child for its mother's presence. Mother Harä helps the devotee achieve the Lord Father's grace, and the Lord reveals Himself to the devotee who chants this mantra sincerely.

No other means of spiritual realization is as effective in this age of quarrel and hypocrisy as the mahämantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

TYS 5: How Bhakti-yoga Works

5/How Bhakti-yoga Works

In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa tells His disciple, Arjuna, "I am disclosing a most confidential part of knowledge to you, because you are My dear friend." As is stated in the Fourth Chapter, the Bhagavad-gétä is spoken to Arjuna because of his one qualification: he was a devotee. The Lord says that the mystery of the Bhagavad-gétä is very confidential. Without being an unalloyed devotee you cannot know it. In India there are 645 different commentaries on the Gétä. One professor has proposed that Kåñëa is a doctor and Arjuna is his patient, and has made his commentary in that way. Similarly, there are commentators and people who have taken it that everyone is perfect, and that they can interpret scripture in their own way. As far as we are concerned, we agree to read the Bhagavad-gétä according to the instructions given in the Gétä itself. This has to be taken through the paramparä, the system of disciplic succession. It is being taught by the Supreme Person because "you are My dear friend. I desire that you may become prosperous and happy. Therefore I speak to you." Kåñëa wants everyone to be happy and peaceful and prosperous, but they do not want it. Sunshine is open to everyone, but if someone wishes to remain in darkness, what can the sunshine do for him? So the Gétä is open to everyone. There are different species of life, and lower and higher grades of understanding exist—that is a fact. But Kåñëa says that this knowledge is for anyone. If one has lower birth or whatever, it doesn't matter. The Bhagavad-gétä offers transcendental subject matter everyone can understand provided he goes along with the principle as stated in the Fourth Chapter. That is, that the Gétä [4.1] is coming down in disciplic succession: "I first of all instructed this yoga system to the sun-god Vivasvän, who taught it to Manu, who taught it to Ikñväku." From Kåñëa the disciplic succession is coming down, but "in course of time the disciplic succession was broken." Arjuna is therefore made the new disciple. In the Second Chapter, Arjuna surrenders: "So far we have been talking as friends, but now I accept You as my spiritual master." Anyone following the principle in this line accepts the guru as Kåñëa, and the student must represent Arjuna. Kåñëa is speaking as the spiritual master of Arjuna, and Arjuna says, "Whatever You are saying I accept." Read it like that—not: "I like this, so I accept it; this I don't like, and so I reject it." Such reading is useless nonsense.

The teacher must be a representative of Kåñëa, a devotee, and the student must be like Arjuna. Then this Kåñëa consciousness study is perfect. Otherwise it is a waste of time. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [3.25.25] it is stated: "If anyone wants to understand the science of Kåñëa, he should associate with pure devotees. When discussions take place among pure devotees, the potency of spiritual language is revealed." Scholarly discussion of the Gétä is futile. In the Upaniñads [ÇU 6.23] it is stated: "To one who has firm faith in God, and similar faith in God's representative, all the import of Vedic language will be revealed." We must have the qualification of being a devotee. Become dear to God. My spiritual master used to say, "Don't try to see God. Act in such a way that God will see you." We have to qualify ourselves. By your qualification God Himself will come and see you.

If one can perceive God, he is transcendental to all material demands. We are always dissatisfied in the material world in circumstances that won't continue; happiness is temporary, and temporary plight also will not exist for much time. Cold, heat, duality—it is all coming and going. To get to the absolute stage is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa is seated in everyone's heart, and as you become purified He will show you the path. And in the end you will quit this body, and you will go to the spiritual sky.

"No one knows Me," Kåñëa says, "My influence, My power and my extent. Even the maharñis [the great thinkers] don't know. I am the origin of all demigods and the origin of all åñis." There are so many forefathers we don't know of, and there are Brahmä and the demigods—what do we know? We can't reach to the platform where we can grasp God. We gather knowledge by limited senses, and Kåñëa can't be reached by the mind, the center of the senses. Imperfect senses can't grasp perfect knowledge. Mind and sense manipulation can't reach Him. If you engage the senses in the service of the Lord, however, then He will reveal Himself through your senses.

People may say, "What is the use of understanding God? What is the use? Let Him stay in His place, let me stay in my place." But in the çästras, the scriptures, it is stated that pious activities will raise us to beauty, knowledge and good birth; and that by impious (sinful) activities, we suffer. Suffering is always there, pious or impious, but a distinction is made. He who knows God, however, becomes freed from all possible sinful reactions, which no amount of piety can accomplish. If we reject God we can never be happy.

Not even considering human society, if you take the demigods who are more advanced and intelligent, they also don't know Kåñëa. The seven great sages whose planet is near the North Star also do not know. Kåñëa says: "I am the original, the source of all these demigods." He is the father of everything, not only the origin of demigods, but of the sages—and the universe. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.1.1] describes how the universal form took place, and everything is emanating from Him [vs 1.1.2]. Also Kåñëa is the origin of Paramätmä, the Supersoul; and the impersonal brahma-jyoti, the shining effulgence, is in Him. Of everything, of every conception, "I am the source." The Absolute Truth may be realized in three phases, but is one nondual truth. Brahman (the glowing effulgence), localized Supersoul, and Bhagavän—the Supreme Person—are three features or aspects of God.

If no one knows the Supreme Personality of Godhead, how can He be known? He can be known when the Supreme Lord comes before you and reveals Himself to you. Then you can know. Our senses are imperfect, and they cannot realize the Supreme Truth. When you adopt a submissive attitude and chant, realization begins from the tongue. To eat and to vibrate sound is the business of the tongue. If you can control your tongue for prasädam, spiritual food, and make the sound vibration of the holy name, then by surrender of the tongue you can control all the other senses. If you cannot control your tongue, you cannot control your senses. Taste prasädam and become spiritually advanced. You can have this process at your home: offer vegetarian foods to Kåñëa, chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra and offer obeisances:

namo brahmaëya-deväya
go-brähmaëa-hitäya ca
jagat-hitäya kåñëäya
govindäya namo namaù.
[Viñëu Puräëa 1.19.65]

Everyone can offer, and then take the food with friends. And chant before the picture of Kåñëa, and lead a pure life. Just see the result—the whole world will become Vaikuëöha, where there is no anxiety. All is anxious with us because we have accepted this material life. Just the opposite is so in the spiritual world. No one, however, knows how to get out of the material concept. Taking an intoxicant doesn't help; the same anxieties are there when you are finished being drunk. If you want to be free and want life eternal with bliss and knowledge, take to Kåñëa. No one can know God, but there is this way: the process of Kåñëa consciousness.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that no one can conquer Him or approach Him, but He becomes conquered. How? Let people remain in their own positions, but let them give up nonsense speculation through volumes of books. Thousands of books are printed and read, and after six months thrown away. This way and that—how can you know the Supreme by speculation on the information supplied by your blunt senses? Give up research—throw it away—just become submissive; acknowledge that you are limited and subordinate to material nature and to God. No one can be equal to or greater than God. So be submissive. Try to hear about the glories of the Supreme Lord from authorized sources. Such authority is handed over by disciplic succession. If we can understand by the same authority as Arjuna, that is real authority. God is always ready to reveal; you just become Kåñëa conscious. Follow the path traversed by the great äcäryas, the devoted teachers, and then everything will be known. Although He is unconquerable and unknowable, He can be known in your home.

If you take to this process and follow the principles, what will be the result? As soon as you understand, you will know that the Supreme Lord is the cause of all causes, but that He is not caused by any other cause. And He is the master of all planets. This is not accepting blindly. God has given you the power of reason, the power of arguing—but don't argue falsely. If you want to know the transcendental science you must surrender. Surrender to authority and know Him by signs. Don't surrender to a fool or a rascal. Find one who is coming in disciplic succession, one who is fully convinced about the Supreme Absolute Truth. If you find such a person, surrender and try to please him, serve him and question him. Surrender unto Him is surrender to God. Question to learn, not to waste time.

The process is there, but if we waste time by intoxication we will never see Him, the unconquerable Lord. Follow the principles and slowly but surely, without doubt, you will know. "Yes, I'm making progress," you'll say. And it is very easy, and you can execute it and be in a happy mood. Study, take part with music, eat prasädam. And no one can cheat you by this process. But if you want to be cheated—go to the cheaters.

Try to understand it from the authoritative source and apply it in your life. Amongst the dying mortals, you will become the most intelligent because you are freed from sinful actions. If you act only for Kåñëa, then you are freed from all reactions. You will have no anxiety over what is auspicious or inauspicious because you will be in touch with the most auspicious. This is the process. Ultimately, we can get in touch with Kåñëa. Life will be successful. Anyone can adopt it, because it is very simple.

Here is a nice formula presented by Kåñëa Himself: one should understand the position of Kåñëa. He is unborn and without any cause. We have experience, all of us, that we are born, and we have a cause; our father is our cause. If someone poses himself as God, he has to prove that he is unborn and uncaused. Our practical experience is that we are born. Kåñëa is not born. We have to understand this. Understanding this is to be firmly convinced He is the cause, but is not caused; and since He is not caused He is the proprietor of all manifestation. One who understands this simple philosophy is not illusioned.

We are generally illusioned. We are claiming ownership of the land. But before my birth the land was here, and after my death it will still be here. How long will I go on claiming, in body after body, "This is my land! This is my land!"? Is it not nonsense? One has to be out of illusion. We should know that whatever we are doing in the material concept of life is illusion. We have to understand whether we are illusioned or not. And all conditioned souls are illusioned. He who learns to be disillusioned gets free of all encumberances. If we want freedom from all bonds, then we have to understand God. There is no neglecting this; it is our prime duty.

Out of millions of entities, one may be enlightened. Generally we are all born fools. As soon as I take birth I am nurtured by parents and educated to falsely claim a land as my own. National education means to make you more foolish. Am I not foolish? I am changing my body like a dress life after life. You have so many minds, so many dresses—who do you claim this one? Why don't you understand: "This dress is nice, but next moment I may be in another." You are in the grip of nature. You cannot say what dress you will have: "Nature, make me American." No; material nature controls. If you live like a dog—here, take a dog's dress. If you live a godly life—here, take God.

Out of many fools someone tries to understand what I actually am. Dog? American? Russian? This real inquiry goes on. If you inquire, you have to ask someone, not just yourself. When crossing the street in a place you don't know, you have to ask the policeman or some gentleman. For "what I am" you have to go to an authority also. What is a spiritual master? He is a person conversant with the science of Kåñëa. Ordinarily nobody inquires; but if a man does, he can make progress and come to this understanding: Kåñëa is the cause of all causes.

Four kinds of people, followers of scripture and higher authority, inquire about Kåñëa. Those addicted to sinful activities can't inquire. They go on in intoxication. The righteous, pious man inquires and goes to God. Facility is given to people in this process by the authority—to make people happy, not to exploit people. The purpose of ISKCON is, in this way, to understand the science of God. You want happiness. Here it is. You are distressed by sinful reactions. But if there is no sinful reaction there is no suffering. One who knows Kåñëa without doubt is relieved of all reactions. Kåñëa says, "Come to Me, and I will give you freedom from all reactions." Don't disbelieve it. He can give you shelter; He has all power. If I give you such a promise, because I have no such power I may break the promise.

If you associate yourself with Kåñëa consciousness your dormant relationship with Kåñëa will be evoked. You have a relationship with Him. There is no question of disbelieving; it is simply foolishness. The dormant relationship is there. You want to serve Kåñëa, but simply by the spell of illusion we think we have no connection with Kåñëa. We go on doing all "independent" nonsense, and we are always anxious. When we associate with these dormant feelings for Kåñëa, however, we will become engaged in Kåñëa consciousness.

"God is unborn" indicates that He is different from the material world. We have no such experience of the unborn. This city was born—history is filled with dates. Spiritual nature, however, is unborn, and at once we can see the difference. The material nature is born. You have to understand; if Kåñëa is unborn then He is spiritual, not like one of us. Kåñëa is not some "extraordinary person who was also born." He is not born. So how can I decide He is an ordinary man? "Those who are fools and rascals think of Me as an ordinary man," Kåñëa says in the Gétä. He is different from everything in this world. He is anädi, without cause.

Kåñëa may be spiritual, but there are other spiritual bodies. We have spiritual bodies like Kåñëa's, but they are born. They are not exactly born; it is like the sparks of the fire. The sparks are not born from the fire; they are actually there. We are also not born; we are sparks that come out of the original form. Even if we are not born, the spark comes out of Kåñëa, so we are different; the sparks of the fire are fire, but they are not the original fire. As for quality, we are the same as Kåñëa. It is like the difference between father and son. Father and son are different and nondifferent at the same time. The son is an expansion of the father, but he cannot claim that he is the father; that would be nonsense.

Because Kåñëa is declaring Himself supreme proprietor, He is therefore different from anything. If I am the proprietor of New York State, I am still not New York State. In every step there is duality. No one can say we are completely one with God.

When you can understand Kåñëa's and your own position in a nice analytical way, then at once you become free from sinful reactions. This process will help you. Chant Hare Kåñëa and cleanse your mind, and you will receive the message. One has to be qualified. If you chant and hear, for no payment, you will approach God. All things will become clear and illuminated.

TYS 6: Sources of Absolute Knowledge

6/Sources of Absolute Knowledge

We require to hear about the method of relishing the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the most elevated text on the science of God consciousness, the matured and ripened fruit of the tree of Vedic wisdom. The Sanskrit word rasa means juice, just like the juice of an orange or a mango. And the author of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam requests that you kindly try to taste the rasa, or juice, of the fruit of the Bhägavatam. Why? Why shall I taste the juice of the fruit of the Bhägavatam? Because it is the ripened fruit of the Vedic desire tree. As a desire tree, whatever you want you can have from the Vedas. Veda means knowledge; it is so complete that whether you want to enjoy in this material world or you want to enjoy spiritual life, both kinds of knowledge are there. If you follow the Vedic principles, then you will be happy. This is like the codes of the state. If the citizens obey, then they will be happy, there will be no criminal trespassing, and they will enjoy life. The state does not come to you for nothing just to trouble you, but if you live according to the state law there is no question of unhappiness.

Similarly, this conditioned soul, the living entity, has come here to this material world for enjoyment and for material happiness. And the Vedas are the guidance: all right, enjoy—but you enjoy according to these principles. That is called Veda. Therefore, everything is there. Just as we sometimes perform a marriage ceremony in the temple. What is this marriage ceremony? It is the combination of man and woman, boy and girl. They are already there, they are living like friends—what is the use of this marriage ceremony? It is Vedic: the Vedas account for living together, sex life, but under some special regulations so that you may be happy. The ultimate end is to become happy. If you follow the Vedic rules and restrictions, that will not mean that you will be kept from eating or not allowed to sleep, not allowed to defend or to have sex life. It is not like that. Your bodily necessities are the same as those of the animals; the animals also eat, they also sleep, they also mate and also defend. So we require these things also. But the Vedas prescribe some regulations: you act in this way, so that you will not be unhappy. If you follow the regulation, ultimately the result will be that you will be free from the material entanglement.

This material life is not meant for the spirit soul. It is simply a misunderstanding that you want to enjoy this material life. But Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, gives us specific orders so that we can enjoy, in such a way that, at the end, we will understand that this is not our proper life—our proper life is spiritual. This human form of life is perfected as soon as we come to the understanding of spiritual existence—that I am Brahman. Otherwise, if I do not take care of my spiritual life, then the result is that I must live as the cats and dogs do. There is every possibility that my next life will be an animal life. And if, by chance or by a freak of nature, I get into animal life, then millions and millions of years will be required before again coming to this human form of life. So the human form of life is meant for self-realization, and the Vedas are the direction.

Now in the Bhagavad-gétä you will find that Kåñëa says that to study or to follow the rules and regulations of the Vedas actually means to come to the understanding of Kåñëa consciousness. That is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam also. So the Vedas give you the chance to gradually come to the point of understanding Kåñëa, after many, many births. But the Bhägavatam is called the essence of life, the ripened fruit of the Vedas, because the Bhägavatam gives you directly what is needed in your life.

The Vedas are divided into four: Säma Veda, Åk, Atharva and Yajus. Then these are explained by the Puräëas, of which there are eighteen. Then these are still further explained by the Upaniñads, of which there are 108. The Upaniñads are summarized in the Vedänta-sütra, and the Vedänta-sütra is still again explained by the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, by the same author. This is the process. So the Bhägavatam is the essence of all Vedic knowledge.

Naimiñäraëya is a very famous and sacred forest in northern India, where all the åñis, the sages, generally go to aid their spiritual advancement of life. This Çrémad-Bhägavatam was first discussed in this age in that forest. When it was discussed, the great saint Süta Gosvämé was asked by his audience: Now that Kåñëa has gone back to His abode, with whom is transcendental knowledge now resting? This question was raised. The Bhagavad-gétä was spoken by Kåñëa Himself, and it contains all descriptions of jïäna-yoga, karma-yoga, dhyäna-yoga and bhakti-yoga. Now this inquiry was made: Where can you get spiritual knowledge, now that Kåñëa is gone? The answer was that Kåñëa, having departed, has left us the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. It is the representation, the sound representation, of Kåñëa. The Bhägavatam is not different from Kåñëa, as the Gétä is not different from Kåñëa. They are absolute. Kåñëa and Kåñëa's sound vibration are not different. Kåñëa and Kåñëa's name are also not different. And Kåñëa and Kåñëa's form, again, are not different. This is absolute. It requires realization.

This Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam are sound incarnations of Kåñëa. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam is also the literary incarnation of Kåñëa, and it is the fruit of Vedic knowledge. You may have experience that there is a bird which is called a parrot. The parrot's body is green, and his beak is red. The specific qualification of the parrot is that whatever you say he can imitate. That parrot bird is touching the ripened fruit, and, naturally, if the fruit is ripened on the tree, it becomes very tasteful. Again, if the fruit is tasted by the parrot, it becomes still more tasteful. That is nature's way. So, here, it is said that this Çrémad-Bhägavatam is just like the ripened fruit of Vedic knowledge, and at the same time it is touched by Çukadeva Gosvämé, Süta's spiritual master. Çuka means parrot in Sanskrit.

This Çrémad-Bhägavatam was first explained by Çukadeva Gosvämé, though the author is his father, Vyäsa. Çukadeva was only sixteen years old when he was taught the Bhägavatam, and he was illuminated. He was already liberated in the impersonal concept of the Absolute, but after hearing the Bhägavatam from his father, he became attracted by the pastimes of Kåñëa, and he became a preacher of the Bhägavatam. First he explained it before Mahäräja Parékñit, the great king. A short history of Mahäräja Parékñit is that he was a very pious king, but unfortunately by some of his acts he was cursed by a brähmaëa boy to die within seven days. In those days if a brähmaëa should curse someone it would come true. They had the power to curse or give benediction.

So Parékñit understood that within a week he would have to die, and he prepared himself. He gave up his kingdom, entrusting it to his son, Mahäräja Janamejaya, and he detached himself from the family and sat down on the banks of the Ganges near Delhi. It was not exactly the Ganges, it was actually the Yamunä. There, because he was a great emperor, many learned sages came.

Parékñit now inquired from all the great sages present there: "What is my duty? I am going to die within seven days; now what is my duty? You are all learned sages; please just prescribe for me." So someone said to practice yoga, someone said to practice jïäna, the cultivation of knowledge; there were different opinions. But at that time Çukadeva Gosvämé entered the forest, and although Çukadeva was only sixteen, he was so learned and reputed that all the old sages, including his father, Vyäsadeva, stood up to show him respect. He was so learned. So when he appeared, it was agreed, "Here is Çukadeva Gosvämé. Let him decide what to do. We appoint him as our representative."

Çukadeva Gosvämé was thus authorized to speak, and he was asked, "What is my duty? I am very fortunate that you have come in this momentous hour. Kindly tell me what is my duty."

Çukadeva Gosvämé said, "All right, I shall explain to you the Çrémad-Bhägavatam." Then everyone present agreed.

As the Bhägavatam was first spoken by Çukadeva Gosvämé, it is therefore mentioned that as the parrot touches ripened fruit and it becomes even sweeter, so this Çrémad-Bhägavatam, because it was touched first by Çukadeva Gosvämé, has become still more tasteful.

The idea is that any Vedic literature, especially the Bhägavatam or the Gétä, should be learned as spoken by a realized soul. Especially this literature, which is called Vaiñëava literature, should not be heard from a person who is not a devotee. This point I have several times stressed. Those who are nondevotees, those who are mental speculationists, those who are fruitive workers, those who are meditators or mystic yogés, cannot explain the science of God. This is especially mentioned also by Sanätana Gosvämé, another great saint: those who are not in devotional service, nongodly, those who have no faith in God—such persons should not be allowed to speak on the Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, or any literature which is in relationship with the Supreme Lord. So it is not that anybody can speak the Bhägavatam or the Gétä and we will have to hear it. No. Sanätana Gosvämé especially prohibits us: we should not hear of the Supreme Lord from one who is not purified.

One may ask, "How can you taint the words of Kåñëa, which are naturally transcendentally pure? What is the harm if we hear from the nondevotee?" This question may be raised. The example given here is that milk is very nice and nutritious, but as soon as it is touched by a serpent it becomes poison immediately. The serpent is very envious. He bites and puts to death immediately, unnecessarily, and therefore is considered the cruelest animal amongst the living entities. In the çästra nonviolence is recommended, as in every scripture, but the serpent and the scorpion are allowed to be killed. You cannot say that milk is so nutritious, and we can drink—what is the harm if it is touched by serpents? No—the result will be death. One should not hear at least the Bhagavad-gétä and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam from those who are not devotees of the Lord, who have no realization of God and who are envious of Him. Their touch renders it poison. The words of the Lord are always sublime, but as soon as they are touched by the serpent of a nondevotee, one should be very careful about hearing.

In the Bhägavatam, it is indicated that as soon as Çukadeva touched it, it became delicious. This is the distinction. Basically it is the ripened fruit of Vedic knowledge, but at the same time it has been touched by Çukadeva Gosvämin.

The Lord is the supreme object of yoga and the reservoir of all transcendental pleasure; He reveals Himself only to His devotees and by the mercy of His devotees all can relish His intimate association.

Glossary

Ahaìkara—false ego, the junction point at which a person falsely identifies his self as the material body.

Ahaà brahmäsmi—(lit.—"I am not this body; I am Brahman") Spiritual realization of the qualitative oneness of the infinitesimal individual with the infinite Supreme Lord Kåñëa.

Bhakti-yoga—direct attachment to Kåñëa.

Brahmacarya—student life of celibacy and study of çästras under a spiritual master.

Brähmaëas—those trained in higher philosophical science, knowers of Brahman (spirit).

Kñatriya—one trained and naturally qualified for ruling and for protecting the women, children, elderly persons and Brähmaëas.

Mahämantra—Great chant for deliverance, the Hare Kåñëa mantra.

Mäyä—(Lit.-"that which is not") Material atmosphere in which the conditioned soul tries to enjoy without Kåñëa, or God.

Mäyävädés—impersonalist philosophers who believe everything is illusion; they believe only in the impersonal aspect of God, but they do not recognize the source of the impersonal Brahman, the Parambrahman, or the Personality of Godhead.

Prasädam—food made spiritual by offering it to Kåñëa.

Çästra—scripture

Çüdras—the laborer class who, by nature, serve others for their livelihood.

Vaikuëöha—where there is no anxiety, the spiritual world.

Vaiçyas—mercantile and agricultural class

Yogeçvara—the master of yoga, the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa.


The International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON)

Founder-Äcärya: His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

ISKCON is a worldwide community of devotees dedicated to the principles of bhakti-yoga. Write, call, or visit for further information. Classes are held in the evenings during the week, and a special feast and festival is held every Sunday afternoon.


BOOKS BY HIS DIVINE GRACE
A.C. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI PRABHUPÄDA
AVAILABLE FROM ISKCON PRESS


BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS
Complete Edition (ISKCON PRESS, 1971)

Bhagavad-gétä has long been appreciated as a scriptural literature of sublime importance by thoughtful men throughout the world, for its eighteen chapters shower upon man the immortal nectar of the wisdom of the Absolute. The aim of this edition of Bhagavad-gétä is to present the ancient science of yoga as presented by the speaker Himself, Lord Çré Kåñëa, without adulteration or interpretation. Although there are many translations of Bhagavad-gétä none can be said to be authoritative because in almost every one of them the author has expressed his personal opinion through the commentaries, without touching the spirit of Bhagavad-gétä as it is. His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, however, has accepted the Gétä to be perfect and complete, and he has prepared his Bhagavad-gétä As It Is with that understanding. Thus the message of this timeless classic is transmitted in its purity and fullness. By reading this book one can attain the perfection of human life.

981 pp., 56 full-color illustrations Hard $10.95 Soft $5.95


His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


The Supreme Personality of Godhead said:

"O son of Prtha, those who are not deluded, the Great Souls, are under the protection of the Divine Nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible.

"They are always engaged in chanting My glories. Endeavoring with great determination, offering homage unto Me, they worship Me with devotion
The Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, Chapter IX, verses 13 and 14.


KÅÑËA, THE SUPREME PERSONALITY OF GODHEAD
(ISKCON PRESS, 1970)

The supremely rich, powerful, famous and beautiful Personality of Godhead, who is free from all material attachment, is now available in book form. KÅÑËA, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, 750 pages of transcendental reading matter, opulently illustrated with 82 full-color plates, presents the eternal, blissfull pastimes of the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa as they are revealed in the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the ripened fruit of all Vedic literatures. The KÅÑËA Books, potent in message and rich in design, offer mankind the opportunity to attain the highest benefit by understanding the true nature of the pastimes of the Supreme Lord. Everyone would do well to procure this deluxe two-volume set to read and keep at home as a great treasure.
750 pp., 82 full-color illustrations $16.00 (per vol.-$8.00)


ÇRÉMAD-BHÄGAVATAM of Kåñëa-dvaipäyana Vyäsa—translated with elaborate commentary. (ISKCON PRESS, 1971)

Çrémad-Bhägavatam is known as the "postgraduate study" of the Bhagavad-gétä. As the Gétä contains the words and teachings of Lord Kåñëa, Çrémad-Bhägavatam contains descriptions about the glories and pastimes of Kåñëa with His devotees. Çrémad-Bhägavatam contains all knowledge—material and spiritual—for the upliftment of the human being. Its contents include: description of the avatäras of Godhead, symptoms of men in the age of quarrel, real remedy for peace in the world, comparative importance of bhakti-yoga and mystic powers, principles of saintly association and innumerable other topics.
Vol. I (Canto I) 374 pp., 24 color illus. Soft $3.95 Hard $6.95


TEACHINGS OF LORD CAITANYA—A Treatise on Factual Spiritual Life. (ISKCON, 1968)

For thousands of years, sincere souls all over the world in search of spiritual realization have accepted Bhagavad-gétä as their most basic and profound text. Lord Caitanya, the most munificent incarnation of Godhead, appeared 500 years ago to demonstrate by example how to live the teachings of Bhagavad-gétä in the present age. Teachings of Lord Caitanya recounts the words and deeds of this great saint. Lord Caitanya was famous as a scholar and spoke authoritatively on Kåñëa, yoga, liberation, and nirvana; still He is better known as the divine origin of the Hare Kåñëa movement, distributing love of God simply by singing the holy names. In His profound discourses on Vedänta and in His ecstatic saìkértana festivals, Lord Caitanya was an example to all of how to attain the ultimate goal of life—Love of God—and this most advanced work on spiritual science can bring the reader into loving reciprocation with that Absolute Truth.
292 pp., 11 illustrations, Hard $5.95 Soft $3.95


ÇRÉ ÉÇOPANIÑAD—The knowledge that brings one nearer to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. (ISKCON PRESS, 1970)

All the major scriptures of the world indicate that God is not impersonal, but is a person. From the most authoritative sources, the famed 108 Upaniñads of India, Çré Éçopaniñad supplies revealed evidence that the Personality of Godhead is the creator, maintainer and destroyer of everything that exists, and revives the dormant hope of all living beings—to transcend this conditioned state and gain the eternal, blissful association of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.
135 pp., Soft $1.95 Hard $3.00


BACK TO GODHEAD—The Magazine of the Hare Krishna Movement.

"Back to Godhead" is the only journal in the West to deliver the authorized science of God realization as delivered by the unbroken disciplic succession of spiritual masters from Lord Çré Kåñëa. Such transcendental literature is provided to revive our relationship with God, Kåñëa, now forgotten in this age of illusion. The magazine contains practical information on how to achieve God realization, with writings by His Divine Grace, photo essays, recipes, and articles by disciples based on their personal realizations. The special grace of the saìkértana movement is that it is simply joyful, and the Kåñëa conscious philosophy presented in "Back to Godhead" can deliver that joy with sincerity and intelligence.32 pp., monthly, $5.00 per year, $6.00 foreign

The Blessed Lord said: The yogé whose mind is fixed on Me verily attains the highest happiness. A true yogé observes Me in all beings, and also sees every being in Me. Indeed, the self-realized man sees Me everywhere. And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all. (Bhagavad-gétä, 9.27, 29, 47)

Perfect Questions Perfect Answers (1977)

Conversations between His Divine Grace A. C. BHAKTIVEDANTA, SWAMI PRABHUPÄDA and BOB COHEN a Peace Corps worker in India

On an ancient island in Bengal, between the waters of the Ganges and the Sarasvaté, a young Peace Corps. worker began a mystical, inner journey into a new and deeper reality....

BOOKS by
His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 19 (27 Vols.)
Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (17 Vols.)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
The Nectar of Devotion
The Nectar of Instruction
Çré Éçopaniñad
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (3 Vols.)
Perfect Questions, Perfect Answers
Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäräja
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
Life Comes from Life
The Perfection of Yoga
Beyond Birth and Death
On the Way to Kåñëa
Geetär-gan (Bengali)
Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge
Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Matchless Gift
Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)

A complete catalog is available upon request

Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 74-27525
International Standard Book Number: 0-912776-62-5
First printing, 1977: 220,000 copies
Printed in the United States of America

Contents

PQPA Introduction

Introduction

God, spiritual life—those were such vague terms to me before I met Çréla Prabhupäda. I have always been interested in religion, but before I met the Kåñëa conscious devotees, somehow I did not have the proper perspective needed to inquire fruitfully about spiritual life. The existence of a Creator is only common sense—but who is God? Who am I? I had been to Hebrew School and had studied Oriental philosophy, but I could never get satisfying answers to my questions. I first heard the Hare Kåñëa mantra in Greenwich Village, New York, in late 1968.

Hare Kåñëa Hare Kåñëa
Kåñëa Kåñëa Hare Hare
Hare Räma Hare Räma
Räma Räma Hare Hare.

The chanting was captivating, and it made me feel very comfortable. The mantra stuck in my mind, and I soon regretted that I had not taken a magazine from the devotees. As explained to me later, a transcendental seed had been planted that could eventually ripen into love of Godhead.

Several months later, I came across a card with the Hare Kåñëa mantra on it. The card promised, "Chant these names of God, and your life will be sublime!" I would occasionally chant, and I found that the mantra did, in fact, give me a feeling of peace of mind.

After graduating from college with a B.S. in chemistry, I joined the Peace Corps in 1971 and went to India as a science teacher. In India I inquired about the Hare Kåñëa movement. I was attracted by the chanting and intrigued by the philosophy, and I was curious about the movement's authenticity. I had visited the Kåñëa temple in New York several times before going to India, but I did not consider the seemingly austere life of a devotee for myself.

In India I first met the Kåñëa conscious devotees at a festival they were holding in Calcutta during October of 1971. The devotees explained to me the purpose of yoga and the need to inquire about spiritual life. I began to feel that the rituals and ceremonies they practiced were not dull, sentimental obligations, but a real, sensible way of life.

At first, however, it was very difficult for me to understand the philosophy of Kåñëa consciousness. In so many subtle ways, my Western upbringing prevented me from seeing things that were as plain as the nose on my face! Fortunately the devotees convinced me of the need to practice some few basic austerities, and in this way I began to gain some insight into spiritual life. I can now recall how distant and tenuous were my concepts of spirituality and transcendental existence. I met Çréla Prabhupäda briefly at this time—in November of 1971—and shortly thereafter I decided to become a vegetarian. (I was proud of being a vegetarian, but later Çréla Prabhupäda reminded me that even pigeons are, too.)

In February of 1972, I met some devotees in Calcutta who invited me to a festival in Mayapur (a holy island ninety miles to the north). The festival was to be held in honor of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who is considered an incarnation of Kåñëa Himself. I had then been planning a trip to Nepal, but the Peace Corps denied me permission to leave India, and so I went to Mayapur.

I left for Mayapur planning to stay for two days at the most, but I ended up staying a week. I was the only Western nondevotee on the island, and since I was living with the devotees on their land, this was a unique opportunity to learn intimately about Kåñëa consciousness.

On the third day of the festival, I was invited in to see Çréla Prabhupäda. He was living in a small hut—half-brick and half-thatched, with two or three pieces of simple furniture. Çréla Prabhupäda asked me to be seated and then asked how I was and whether I had any questions. The devotees had explained to me that Çréla Prabhupäda could answer my questions because he represents a disciplic succession of spiritual masters. I thought that Çréla Prabhupäda might really know what is going on in the world. After all, his devotees claimed this, and I admired and respected them. So with this in mind I began to ask my questions. Inadvertently, I had approached a guru, or spiritual master, in the prescribed way—by submissively asking questions about spiritual life.

Çréla Prabhupäda seemed pleased with me, and over the next several days, he answered my questions. I asked them mostly from an academic point of view, but he always gave me personal answers so that I would actually spiritualize my life. His answers were logical, scientific, satisfying and amazingly lucid. Before I met Çréla Prabhupäda and his disciples, spiritual life was always obscure and nebulous. But the discussions with Çréla Prabhupäda were realistic, clear and exciting! Çréla Prabhupäda was patiently trying to help me understand that Kåñëa—God—is the supreme enjoyer, supreme friend and supreme proprietor. I put forward many impediments to accepting the obvious: that I would have to become serious about God consciousness to understand God. But Çréla Prabhupäda relentlessly yet kindly urged me on. Even though I had little ability to express myself, Çréla Prabhupäda understood my every inquiry and answered perfectly.

Bob Cohen

August 14, 1974

PQPA 1: Kåñëa, the All-Attractive

1. Kåñëa, the All-Attractive
February 27, 1972

BOB: What is a scientist?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: One who knows things as they are.

BOB: He thinks he knows things as they are.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: What?

BOB: He hopes he knows things as they are.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, he is supposed to know. We approach the scientist because he is supposed to know things correctly. A scientist means one who knows things as they are. Kåñëa means "all-attractive."

BOB: All-attractive.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. So unless God is all-attractive, how can He be God? A man is important when he is attractive. Is it not?

BOB: It is so.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So, God must be attractive and attractive for all. Therefore, if God has any name, or if you want to give any name to God, only "Kåñëa" can be given.

BOB: But why only the name Kåñëa?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Because He's all-attractive. Kåñëa means "all-attractive."

BOB: Oh, I see.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. God has no name, but by His qualities we give Him names. If a man is very beautiful, we call him "beautiful." If a man is very intelligent, we call him "wise." So the name is given according to the quality. Because God is all-attractive, the name Kåñëa can be applied only to Him. Kåñëa means "all-attractive." It includes everything.

BOB: But what about a name meaning "all-powerful"?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.... Unless you are powerful, how can you be all-attractive?

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: [an American devotee, Çréla Prabhupäda's secretary] : It includes everything.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Everything. He must be very beautiful, He must be very wise, He must be very powerful, He must be very famous...

BOB: Is Kåñëa attractive to rascals?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh, yes! He was the greatest rascal also.

BOB: How is that?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: [laughing] Because He was always teasing the gopés.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Teasing?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Sometimes when Rädhäräëé would go out, Kåñëa would attack Her, and when She would fall down—"Kåñëa, don't torture Me in that way"—They would fall down, and Kåñëa would take the opportunity and kiss Her. [He laughs.] So, Rädhäräëé was very pleased, but superficially Kåñëa was the greatest rascal. So unless rascaldom is in Kåñëa, how could rascaldom be existent in the world? Our formula of God is that He is the source of everything. Unless rascaldom is in Kåñëa, how can it be manifest... because He is the source of everything. But His rascaldom is so nice that everyone worships His rascaldom.

BOB: What about the rascals who are not so nice?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, rascaldom is not nice, but Kåñëa is absolute. He is God. Therefore His rascaldom is also good. Kåñëa is all-good. God is good.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Therefore, when He becomes a rascal, that is also good. That is Kåñëa. Rascaldom is not good, but when it is practiced by Kåñëa, because He is absolutely good, that rascaldom is also good. This one has to understand.

BOB: Are there some people who do not find Kåñëa attractive?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No. All people will find Him attractive. Who is not attracted? Just give an example: "This man or this living entity is not attracted to Kåñëa." Just find such a person.

BOB: Somebody who wishes to do things in life that he may feel are wrong but who wishes to gain power or prestige or money...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB:... may find God unattractive. He may not find God attractive, because God gives him guilt.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, not God. His attraction is to become powerful. A man wants to become powerful or rich—is it not? But nobody is richer than Kåñëa. Therefore Kåñëa is attractive to him.

BOB: If a person who wants to become rich prays to Kåñëa, will he become rich?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh, yes!

BOB: He can become rich through this means?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh, yes. Because Kåñëa is all-powerful, if you pray to Kåñëa to become rich, Kåñëa will make you rich.

BOB: If somebody lives an evil life but prays to become rich, he may still become rich?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Praying to Kåñëa is not evil.

BOB: Oh, yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: [chuckling] Somehow or other he prays to Kåñëa, so you cannot say that he is evil.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä, api cet suduräcäro bhajate mäm ananya-bhäk. Have you read it?

BOB: Yes. The Sanskrit I don't know, but the English I do.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m.

BOB: "Even if the most evil man prays to Me..."

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: "... He will be elevated."

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. As soon as he begins to pray to Kåñëa, that is not evil. Therefore He is all-attractive. It is said in the Vedas that the Absolute Truth, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is the reservoir of all pleasure—raso vai saù. Everyone is hankering after someone because he realizes some mellow in it.

BOB: Excuse me?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Some mellow. Suppose a man is drinking. Why is he drinking? He is getting some mellow out of that drinking. A man is hankering after money because by possessing money he gets a mellow out of it.

BOB: What does mellow mean?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: [to Çyämasundara] How do they define mellow?

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Taste, pleasure.

BOB: OK.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Pleasing taste. So the Vedas say, raso vai saù. The exact translation of mellow is rasa. [Mälaté, Çyämasundara's wife, enters with a tray of food.] What is that?

MÄLATÉ: Eggplant, fried.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh! All-attractive! All-attractive! [Laughter.]

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: How is Kåñëa the greatest scientist?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Because He knows everything. A scientist is one who knows a subject matter thoroughly. He is a scientist. Kåñëa—He knows everything.

BOB: I am presently a science teacher.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, teaching. But, unless you have perfect knowledge, how can you teach? That is our question.

BOB: Without perfect knowledge, though, you can teach—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is cheating; that is not teaching. That is cheating. Just like the scientists say, "There was a chunk... and the creation took place. Perhaps. Maybe..." What is this? Simply cheating! It is not teaching; it is cheating.

BOB: Let me repeat what you said this morning—that was interesting. I asked about miracles, and you said that only a fool would believe in miracles because—let us say you are a child and an adult lifts this table. That's a miracle. Or you're a chemist and you combine acid and base and you make smoke, an explosion or whatever. To somebody ignorant, that's a miracle. But for everything there is a process, and so when you see a miracle, it's just ignorance of the process. So that only a fool would believe in miracles, and—you correct me if I say wrong...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, yes.

BOB: You said when Jesus came the people then were somewhat more ignorant and needed miracles as aid. I wasn't sure if that's quite what you said.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, yes. Miracles are for the ignorant.

BOB: I had asked this in relation to all the miracle men you hear about in India.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Kåñëa is the highest miracle man.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is stated by Kunté...

BOB: Without perfect knowledge, can I not teach some things? For example, I may—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You can teach up to the point you know.

BOB: Yes, but I should not claim to teach more than I know.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, that is cheating.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: In other words, he can't teach the truth with partial knowledge.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. That is not possible for any human being. A human being has imperfect senses. So how can he teach perfect knowledge? Suppose you see the sun as a disc. You have no means to approach the sun. If you say that we can see the sun by telescope and this and that, they are also made by you, and you are imperfect. So how can your machine be perfect? Therefore, your knowledge of the sun is imperfect. So don't teach about the sun unless you have perfect knowledge. That is cheating.

BOB: But what about to teach that it is supposed that the sun is 93,000,000 miles away?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: As soon as you say "it is supposed," it is not scientific.

BOB: But I think that almost all science, then, is not scientific.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is the point!

BOB: All science is based on, you know, suppositions of this or that.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. They are teaching imperfectly. Just like they are advertising so much about the moon. Do you think their knowledge is perfect?

BOB: No.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Then?

BOB: What is the proper duty of the teacher in society? Let us say a science teacher. What should he be doing in the classroom?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Classroom? You should simply teach about Kåñëa.

BOB: He should not teach about...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No. That will include everything. His aim should be to know Kåñëa.

BOB: Can a scientist teach the science of combining acid and alkaline, and this kind of science, with Kåñëa as its object?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: How can it be?

BOB: If you—when one studies science, one finds general tendencies of nature, and these general tendencies of nature point to a controlling force....

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That I was explaining the other day. I asked one chemist whether, according to chemical formulas, hydrogen and oxygen linked together become water. Do they not?

BOB: It's true.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Now, there is a vast amount of water in the Atlantic Ocean and Pacific Ocean. What quantity of chemicals was required?

BOB: How much?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. How many tons?

BOB: Many!

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So who supplied it?

BOB: This was supplied by God.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Somebody must have supplied it.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So that is science. You can teach like that.

BOB: Should one bother teaching that if you combine acid and alkaline they form a neutral?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The same thing. There are so many effervescents. So, who is performing it? Who is supplying the acid and alkaline? [There is a long pause.]

BOB: So this comes from the same source as the water.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. You cannot manufacture water unless you have hydrogen and oxygen. So, here is a vast—not only this Atlantic or Pacific: there are millions of planets, and there are millions of Atlantic and Pacific oceans. So who created this water with hydrogen and oxygen, and how was it supplied? That is our question. Somebody must have supplied it, otherwise how has it come into existence?

BOB: But should it also be taught how you make water from hydrogen and oxygen? The procedure of burning them together—should this also be taught? That is, you burn hydrogen and oxygen together...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is secondary. That is not very difficult. Just like Mälaté made this puri [a kind of bread]. So, there is flour, and there is ghee [clarified butter], and she made a puri. But unless there is ghee and flour, where is the chance of making a puri? In the Bhagavad-gétä there is this statement: "Water, earth, air, fire—they are My energies." What is your body? This external body—that is your energy. Do you know that? Your body is made out of your energy. For example, I am eating...

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So I am creating some energy, and therefore my body is maintained.

BOB: Oh, I see.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So therefore your body is made out of your energy.

BOB: But when you eat the food, there is energy from the sun in the food.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So, I am giving an example. I am creating some energy by digesting the food, and that is maintaining my body. If your energy supply is not proper, then your body becomes weak or unhealthy. Your body is made out of your own energy. Similarly, this gigantic cosmic body—the universe—is made of Kåñëa's energy. How can you deny it? As your body is made out of your energy, similarly the universal body must be made by somebody's energy. That is Kåñëa. [There is a long pause.]

BOB: I'll have to think about it to follow that.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: What is to follow? It is a fact. [He laughs.] Your hair is growing daily. Why? Because you have some energy.

BOB: The energy I obtain from my food.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Somehow or other you have obtained that energy! And through that energy your hair is growing. So if your body is manufactured by your energy, similarly the whole gigantic manifestation is made of God's energy. It is a fact! It is not your energy.

BOB: Yes. Oh, I see that.

A DEVOTEE: Just like—aren't the planets in this universe the sun's energy—a product of the sun's energy?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, but who produced the sun? That is Kåñëa's energy. Because it is heat, and Kåñëa says, bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù: "Heat—that is My energy." The sun is the representation of the heating energy of Kåñëa. It is not your energy. You cannot say, "The sun is made by me." But somebody must have made it, and Kåñëa says that He did. So, we believe Kåñëa. Therefore we are Kåñëa-ites.

BOB: Kåñëa-ites?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Our knowledge is perfect. If I say that heat is the energy of Kåñëa, you cannot deny it, because it is not your energy. In your body there is some certain amount of heat. Similarly, heat is someone's energy. And who is that person? That is Kåñëa. Kåñëa says, "Yes, it is My energy." So my knowledge is perfect. Because I take the version of the greatest scientist, I am the greatest scientist. I may be a fool personally, but because I take knowledge from the greatest scientist, I am the greatest scientist. I have no difficulty.

BOB: Excuse me?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: I have no difficulty in becoming the greatest scientist because I take the knowledge from the greatest scientist. [There is a long pause.] "This earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and ego—they are My eight separated energies."

BOB: They are separated energies?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Just like this milk. What is this milk? The separated energy of the cow. [Çyämasundara and Bob, stunned, laugh in realization.] Is it not? It is the manifestation of the separated energy of the cow.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Is it like a by-product?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: So, what is the significance of this energy's being separated from Kåñëa?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: "Separated" means that this is made out of the body of the cow but it is not the cow. That is separation.

BOB: So, this earth and all is made out of Kåñëa but it is not Kåñëa?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: It is not Kåñëa. Or, you can say, Kåñëa and not Kåñëa simultaneously. That is our philosophy. One and different. You cannot say that these things are different from Kåñëa, because without Kåñëa they have no existence. At the same time, you cannot say, "Then let me worship water. Why Kåñëa? The pantheists say that because everything is God, whatever we do is God worship. This is Mäyäväda philosophy—that because everything is made of God, therefore everything is God. But our philosophy is that everything is God but also not God.

BOB: So what on earth is God? Is there anything on earth that is God?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Because everything is made out of the energy of God. But that does not mean that by worshiping anything you are worshiping God.

BOB: So what is on earth that is not mäyä [illusion]? It is...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Mäyä means "energy."

BOB: It means energy?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Mäyä—and another meaning is "illusion." So foolish persons accept the energy as the energetic. That is mäyä. Just like sunshine. Sunshine enters your room. Sunshine is the energy of the sun. But because the sunshine enters your room, you cannot say that the sun has entered. If the sun enters your room, then your room and yourself—everything—will be finished. Immediately. You will not have the leisure to understand that the sun has entered. Is it not?

BOB: It is so.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: But you cannot say that sunshine is not the sun. Without the sun, where is the sunshine? So you cannot say that sunshine is not the sun. But at the same time, it is not the sun. It is the sun and not the sun—both. That is our philosophy. Acintya-bhedäbheda—inconceivable. In the material sense, you cannot conceive that a thing is simultaneously positive and negative. That you cannot think of. That is inconceivable energy. And because everything is Kåñëa's energy, Kåñëa can manifest Himself from any energy. Therefore, when we worship Kåñëa in a form made of something—of earth, water or something like that—that is Kåñëa. You cannot say that it is not Kåñëa. When we worship this metal form of Kåñëa [the Deity form in the temple], that is Kåñëa. That's a fact, because metal is an energy of Kåñëa. Therefore, it is nondifferent from Kåñëa, and Kåñëa is so powerful that He can present Himself fully in His energy. So this Deity worship is not heathenism. It is actually worship of God, provided you know the process.

BOB: If you know the process, then the Deity becomes Kåñëa?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Not becomes—it is Kåñëa.

BOB: The Deity is Kåñëa, but only if you know the process?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Just like this electric wire—it is electricity. One who knows the process, he can derive electricity out of it.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Otherwise it's just wire.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Just wire.

BOB: So if I build a statue of Kåñëa, it is not Kåñëa unless...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: It is Kåñëa. But you have to know the process of understanding that it is Kåñëa. It is Kåñëa.

BOB: It is not just earth and mud.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No. Earth has no separate existence without Kåñëa. Kåñëa says, "My energy." You cannot separate the energy from the energetic. It is not possible. You cannot separate heat from fire. But fire is different from the heat, and heat is different from the fire. You are taking heat; that does not mean you are touching fire. Fire, in spite of emanating heat, keeps its identity. Similarly, although Kåñëa, by His different energies, is creating everything, He remains Kåñëa. The Mäyävädé philosophers think that if Kåñëa is everything, then Kåñëa's separate identity is lost. That is material thinking. For example, by drinking this milk, little by little, when I finish, there is no more milk; it has gone to my belly. Kåñëa is not like that. He is omnipotent. We are utilizing His energy continually; still He is there, present. Just like a man begetting children unlimitedly, but the man is there. A crude example. It's not that because he has produced hundreds of children, he is finished. So, similarly, God or Kåñëa, in spite of His unlimited number of children, is there.

pürëasya pürëam ädäya
pürëam evävaçiñyate
[Éço Invocation]

"Because He is the complete whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance." This is Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa is never finished. Kåñëa is so powerful. Therefore He is all-attractive. This is one side of the display of Kåñëa's energy. Similarly, He has unlimited energies. This study of Kåñëa's energy is only one side, or a portion only. So in this way, if you go on studying Kåñëa, that is Kåñëa consciousness. It is not a bogus thing—"maybe," "perhaps not." Absolutely! It is!

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: And the study itself is never finished.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No. How can it be? Kåñëa has unlimited energy.

PQPA 2: Vedic Culture: Varëäçrama-dharma

2. Vedic Culture: Varëäçrama-dharma
February 28, 1972

BOB: I've asked devotees about how they feel towards sex in their relations, and I see the way they feel, but I can't see myself acting the same way. See, I'll be getting married at the end of this summer.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m?

BOB: I'll be getting married at the end of this summer, in September or August when I return to America. And the devotees say that the householders only have sex to conceive a child, and I cannot picture myself at all in such a position, and—What kind of sex life can one lead, living in the material world?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The Vedic principle is that one should avoid sex life altogether. The whole Vedic principle is to get liberation from material bondage. There are different attachments for material enjoyment, of which sex life is the topmost enjoyment. The Bhägavatam [5.5.8] says that this material world...

puàsaù striyä mithuné-bhävam etam

Man is attached to woman, and woman is attached to man. Not only in human society—in animal society also. That attachment is the basic principle of material life. So, a woman is hankering or seeking after the association of a man, and a man is hankering or seeking for the association of a woman. All the fiction novels, dramas, cinema and even ordinary advertisements that you see simply depict the attachment between man and woman. Even in the tailor's shop you will find in the window some woman and some man.

pravåttir eñä bhütänäà
nivåttis tu mahäphaläm
[Manu-småti 5.56]

So this attachment is already there.

BOB: Attachment between man and woman?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Man and woman. So if you want to get liberation from this material world, then that attachment should be reduced to nil. Otherwise, simply further attachment—You will have to take rebirth, either as a human being or as a demigod or as an animal, as a serpent, as a bird, as a beast. You will have to take birth. So, this basic principle of increasing attachment is not our business, although it is the general tendency. Gåha, kñetra, suta [home, land, sons]. But if one can reduce and stop it, that is first class. Therefore our Vedic system is to first of all train a boy as a brahmacäré—no sex life. The Vedic principle is to reduce attachment, not to increase it. Therefore the whole system is called varëäçrama-dharma. The Indian system calls for varëa and äçrama—four social orders and four spiritual orders. Brahmacarya [celibate student life], gåhastha [married life], vänaprastha [retired life] and sannyäsa [renounced life]—these are the spiritual orders. And the social orders consist of brähmaëas [intellectuals], kñatriyas [administrators], vaiçyas [merchants and farmers] and çüdras [ordinary workers]. So under this system, the regulative principles are so nice that

even if one has the tendency to enjoy material life, he is so nicely molded that at last he achieves liberation and goes back home, back to Godhead. This is the process. So sex life is not required, but because we are attached to it, therefore there are some regulative principles under which it is maintained.

[Chanting starts somewhere in the background, with exotic mådaìga drumbeats amidst laughing and the loud blowing of horns.]

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: It is said in Çrémad-Bhägavatam that—

puàsaù striyä mithuné-bhävam etaà
tayor mitho hådaya-granthim ähuù
ato gåha-kñetra-sutäpta-vittair
janasya moho 'yam ahaà mameti
(Bhäg. 5.5.8)

This sex life is the basic principle of material life—attachment for man or woman. And when they are united, when a man and woman are united, that attachment becomes increased, and that increased attachment will induce one to accumulate gåha (a home), kñetra (land), suta (children), äpta (friendship or society) and vitta. Vitta means money. In this way—gåha-kñetra-sutäpta-vittaiù—he becomes entangled. Janasya moho 'yam: this is the illusion. And by this illusion he thinks, ahaà mameti: "I am this body, and anything in relationship with this body is mine."

BOB: What is that again?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: This attachment increases. The material attachment involves thinking, "I am this body, and because I have this body in a particular place, that is my country." And that is going on: "I am American, I am Indian, I am German, I am this, I am that—this body. This is my country. I shall sacrifice everything for my country and society." So in this way, the illusion increases. And under this illusion, when he dies he gets another body. That may be a superior body or inferior body, according to his karma. So if he gets a superior body, then that is also an entanglement, even if he goes to the heavenly planets. But if he becomes a cat or dog, then his life is lost. Or a tree—there is every chance of it. So this science is not known in the world—how the soul is transmigrating from one body to another, and how he is being entrapped in different types of bodies. This science is unknown. Therefore when Arjuna was speaking—"If I kill my brother, if I kill my grandfather on the other side..."—he was simply thinking on the basis of the bodily concept of life. But when his problems could not be solved, he surrendered to Kåñëa and accepted Him as spiritual master. And when Kåñëa became his spiritual master, He chastised Arjuna in the beginning (Bg. 2.11):

açocyän anvaçocas tvaà
prajïä-vädäàç ca bhäñase
gatäsün agatäsüàç ca
nänuçocanti paëòitäù

"You are talking like a learned man, but you are fool number one because you are talking about the bodily concept of life." So this sex life increases the bodily concept of life. Therefore, the whole process is to reduce it to nil.

BOB: To reduce it over the stages of your life?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Reduce it. A boy is trained as a student up to twenty-five years, restricting sex life. Brahmacäré. So, some of the boys remain naiñöhika-brahmacäré [celibate for life]. Because they are given education and they become fully conversant with spiritual knowledge, they don't want to marry. That is also restricted—he cannot have sex life without being married. Therefore in human society there is marriage, not in animal society.

But people are gradually descending from human society to animal society. They are forgetting marriage. That is also predicted in the çästras. Dämpatye 'bhirucir hetuù: in the Kali-yuga [the present age of quarrel], eventually there will be no marriage performances; the boy and the girl will simply agree to live together, and their relationship will exist on sexual power. If the man or the woman is deficient in sex life, then there is divorce. So, for this philosophy there are many Western philosophers like Freud and others who have written so many books. But according to Vedic culture, we are interested in sex only for begetting children, that's all. Not to study the psychology of sex life. There is already natural psychology for that. Even if one does not read any philosophy, he is sexually inclined. Nobody is taught it in the schools and colleges. Everyone already knows how to do it. [He laughs.] That is the general tendency. But education should be given to stop it. That is real education. [There is a long pause, filled with the sound of bicycle horns, children playing, and throngs of people calling to one another.]

BOB: Presently, in America, that's a radical concept.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Well, in America there are so many things that require reformation, and this Kåñëa consciousness movement will bring that. I went to your country and saw that the boys and girls were living like friends, so I said to my students, "You cannot live together as friends; you must get yourselves married."

BOB: Many people see that even marriage is not sacred, so they find no desire to marry. Because people get married, and if things are not proper, they get a divorce so very easily—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, that also.

BOB:—that some people feel that to get married is not meaningful.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, their idea is that marriage is for legalized prostitution. They think like that, but that is not marriage. Even that Christian paper—what is that? Watch—?

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Watchtower?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Watchtower. It has criticized that one priest has allowed a marriage between two men—homosexuality. So these things are all going on. They take it purely for prostitution, that's all. So therefore people are thinking, "What is the use of keeping a regular prostitute at such heavy expenditure? Better not to have this."

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: You use that example of the cow and the market.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes—when the milk is available in the marketplace, what is the use of keeping a cow? [Everyone laughs.] It is a very abominable condition in the Western countries—I have seen it. Here also in India, gradually it is coming. Therefore we have started this Kåñëa consciousness movement to educate people in the essential principles of spiritual life. It is not a sectarian religious movement. It is a cultural movement for everyone's benefit.

PQPA 3: The Real Goal of Life

3. The Real Goal of Life
February 28, 1972 (continued)

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: This movement is especially meant to enable a human being to reach the real goal of life.

BOB: The real goal... ?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The real goal of life.

BOB: Is the real goal of life to know God?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. To go back home, back to Godhead. That is the real goal of life. The water that comes from the sea forms clouds, the clouds fall down as rain, and the actual goal is to flow down the river and again enter the sea. So, we have come from God, and now we are embarrassed by material life. Therefore, our aim should be to get out of this embarrassing situation and go back home, back to Godhead. This is the real goal of life.

mäm upetya punar janma
duùkhälayam açäçvatam
näpnuvanti mahätmänaù
saàsiddhià paramäà gatäù
[Bg. 8.15]

["After attaining Me, the great souls, who are yogés in devotion, never return to this temporary world, which is full of miseries, because they have attained the highest perfection."] That is the version of Bhagavad-gétä. If anyone comes to Me—mäm upetya: he does not come back again. Where? To this place—duùkhälayam açäçvatam. This place is the abode of miseries. Everyone knows, but they have been befooled by so-called leaders. Material life is miserable life. Kåñëa says, God says, that this place is duùkhälayam—it is a place of miseries. And it is also açäçvatam, temporary. You cannot make a compromise: "All right, let it be miserable. I shall remain here as an American or Indian." No. That also you cannot do. You cannot remain an American. You may think that, having been born in America, you are very happy. But you cannot remain an American for long. You will have to be kicked out of that place. And your next life you do not know! Therefore, it is duùkhälayam açäçvatam—miserable and temporary. That is our philosophy.

BOB: But when you have some knowledge of God, then life is not so miserable?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No! Some knowledge will not do. You must have perfect knowledge.

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù

Tattvataù means "perfectly." Perfect knowledge is being taught in Bhagavad-gétä (4.9). So, we are giving everyone in human society a chance to learn Bhagavad-gétä as it is and make his life perfect. That is the Kåñëa consciousness movement. What does your science say about the transmigration of the soul?

BOB: I think... that science... cannot deny or affirm it. Science does not know it.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Therefore I say that science is imperfect.

BOB: Science may, though, say something. It is said in science that energy is never destroyed; it is changed.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That's all right. But how the energy is working in the future—that science does not know. How is the energy diverted? How, by different manipulations, is the energy working differently? For instance, electrical energy. By different handling it is operating the heater, and it is operating the refrigerator. They are just the opposite, but the electrical energy is the same. Similarly, this energy—living energy—how is it being directed? Which way is it going? How is it fructifying in the next life? That they do not know. But in Bhagavad-gétä [2.2] it is very simply stated.

väsäàsi jérëäni yathä vihäya

You are covered by a dress, by a shirt. When this shirt is unusable, you change it. Similarly, this body is just like a shirt and coat. When it is no longer workable, we have to change it.

BOB: What is the "we" that has to change? What is constant?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is the soul.

BOB: From one life to the next?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is the soul—I. What "you" is speaking? You! What "I" is speaking? Identity: ätmä, or soul.

BOB: My soul is different from your soul?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. You are an individual soul, I am an individual soul.

BOB: You have removed yourself from karmic influences. If I was to remove myself from karmic influences, would our souls be the same or different?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The soul is of the same quality in all. You are under a certain conception of life at the present moment, and these countrymen of yours [the Kåñëa conscious devotees] were under a certain conception of life, but by training they have taken to another conception of life. So the ultimate training is how to become Kåñëa conscious. That is the perfection.

BOB: If two people are Kåñëa conscious, is their soul the same?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The soul is always the same.

BOB: In each person? In each person is it the same?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: [pointing to two devotees] If these two are Kåñëa conscious, are their souls the same?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The soul is the same but always individual, even if one is not Kåñëa conscious. For instance, you are a human being, and I am a human being. Even if I am not a Christian, even if you are not a Hindu, still we are human beings. Similarly, the soul may not be Kåñëa conscious, or he may be Kåñëa conscious—it doesn't matter. But the soul is the soul.

BOB: Can you tell me more about this?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Soul—as pure spirit, all souls are equal. Even in an animal. Therefore it is said, paëòitäù sama-darçinaù: those who are actually learned do not see the outward covering, either in a human being or in an animal.

BOB: If I may ask another question on this?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: I have considered the soul somewhat as part of God. At times I think I feel God. I'm here, and you may say God is here. So if the soul is inside me, then should I be able to feel God inside me? Not all of God, I mean, but a...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Part of God.

BOB: But I don't feel God in me, but God may be here, separate—separate from me. But should I be able to feel God inside me, since my soul is part of God?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. God is inside also. God is everywhere. God is inside and outside also. This is to be known.

BOB: How do you feel God inside you?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Not in the beginning, but you have to know from the çästras [scriptures], by the Vedic information. For example, in the Bhagavad-gétä it is said, éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati: God is there in everyone's heart. Paramäëu-cayäntara-stham: God is also within every atom. So this is the first information. And then, by the yogic process, you have to realize it.

BOB: Yogic process?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: Is chanting Hare Kåñëa such a yogic process?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, it is also a yogic process.

BOB: What kind of yogic process must I do to find out—to feel this information—to feel the soul inside?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, there are many different yogic processes, but for this age this process is very nice.

BOB: Chanting.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: Through this I can feel not only God outside but God inside?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You'll understand everything of God—how God is inside, how God is outside, how God is working. Everything will be revealed. By this attitude of service, God will reveal Himself. You cannot understand God by your endeavor. Only if God reveals Himself. For instance, when the sun is out of your sight at night, you cannot see it by your torchlight, or any light. But in the morning you can see the sun automatically, without any torchlight. Similarly, you have to create a situation—you have to put yourself in a situation—in which God will be revealed. It is not that by some method you can ask God, "Please come. I will see You." No, God is not your order carrier.

BOB: You must please God for Him to reveal Himself. Is that correct?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: How do we know when we are pleasing God?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: When we see Him. Then you will understand. Just as, when you eat, you do not require to ask anyone whether you are feeling strength or your hunger is satisfied. If you eat, you understand that you are feeling energy. You don't need to inquire from anyone. Similarly, if you actually serve God, then you will understand, "God is dictating to me. God is there. I am seeing God."

A DEVOTEE: Or God's representative.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

DEVOTEE: It comes easier.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You have to go through God's representative.

yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädaù
[Gurv-añöaka 8]

"By the mercy of the spiritual master one is benedicted by the mercy of Kåñëa." 8 If you please God's representative, then automatically God becomes pleased, and thus you can directly see Him.

AN INDIAN GENTLEMAN: How to please God's representative?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You have to carry out his orders, that's all. God's representative is the guru. He asks you to do this, to do that—if you do that, that is pleasing.

yasyäprasädän na gatiù kuto 'pi

"Without the grace of the spiritual master one cannot make any advancement." If you displease him, then you are nowhere. Therefore we worship the guru.

säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästrair
uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù
kintu prabhor yaù priya eva tasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam
[Gurv-añöaka 7]

["The spiritual master is to be honored as much as the Supreme Lord because of his being the most confidential servitor of the Lord. This is acknowledged by all revealed scriptures and is followed by all authorities. Therefore I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master, who is a bona fide representative of Lord Kåñëa."] The guru should be accepted as God. That is the injunction of all çästra.

BOB: The guru should be accepted as a representative of God?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, the guru is God's representative. The guru is the external manifestation of Kåñëa.

BOB: But different from the incarnations of Kåñëa that come?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: In what way is the external manifestation of the guru different from the external manifestation of, let us say, Kåñëa or Caitanya when They come to earth?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The guru is the representative of Kåñëa. So there are symptoms of who is a guru. The general symptoms are described in the Vedas.

tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet
samit-päëiù çrotriyaà brahma-niñöham

A guru must come in a disciplic succession, and he must have heard thoroughly about the Vedas from his spiritual master. Generally a guru's symptom is that he is a perfect devotee, that's all. And he serves Kåñëa by preaching His message.

BOB: Lord Caitanya—He was a different type of guru than you are?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, no. Gurus cannot be of different types. All gurus are of one type.

BOB: But He was—was He also an incarnation at the same time?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, He is Kåñëa Himself, but He is representing the guru.

BOB: I... I see.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: And then...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Because Kåñëa was God, He demanded:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
[Bg. 18.66]

"Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me." But people misunderstood Him. Therefore Kåñëa again came as a guru and taught people how to surrender to Kåñëa.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Doesn't He say in Bhagavad-gétä, "I am the spiritual master"?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, He is the original spiritual master because He was accepted as spiritual master by Arjuna. So what is the difficulty? Çiñyas te 'haà çädhi mäà tväà prapannam. Arjuna told the Lord, "I am Your disciple, and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me." So unless He is a spiritual master, how does Arjuna become His disciple? He is the original guru. Tene brahma hådä ya ädi-kavaye: "It is He only who first imparted Vedic knowledge unto the heart of Brahmä, the first created being." Therefore He is the original guru.

BOB: Kåñëa.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. He is the original guru. Then His disciple Brahmä is a guru, then his disciple Närada is a guru, then his disciple Vyäsa is a guru—in this way there is a guru-paramparä [disciplic succession of gurus]. Evaà paramparä-präptam: the transcendental knowledge is received through the disciplic succession.

BOB: So a guru receives his knowledge through the disciplic succession, not directly from Kåñëa? Do you receive some knowledge directly from Kåñëa?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Kåñëa's direct instruction is there: Bhagavad-gétä.

BOB: I see, but...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: But you have to learn it through the disciplic succession, otherwise you will misunderstand it.

BOB: But presently you do not receive information directly from Kåñëa? It comes through the disciplic succession from the books?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: There is no difference. Suppose I say that this is a pencil. If you say to him, "There is a pencil," and if he says to another man, "This is a pencil," then what is the difference between his instruction and my instructions?

BOB: Kåñëa's mercy allows you to know this now?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You can take Kåñëa's mercy also, provided it is delivered as it is. Just as we are teaching Bhagavad-gétä. In Bhagavad-gétä [18.66] Kåñëa says:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja

"Just give up all other forms of religion and simply surrender unto Me." Now we are saying that you should give up everything and surrender to Kåñëa. Therefore, there is no difference between Kåñëa's instruction and our instruction. There is no deviation. So if you receive knowledge in that perfect way, that is as good as receiving instruction directly from Kåñëa. But we don't change anything.

BOB: When I pray reverently, faithfully, does Kåñëa hear me?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: From me to Him?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, because He is within your heart He is always hearing you—whether you are praying or not praying. When you are doing some nonsense, He is also hearing you. And when you pray, that is very good—welcome.

BOB: To Kåñëa's ear, is praying louder than nonsense?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No. He is all-perfect. He can hear everything. Even if you don't speak, even if you simply think, "I shall do it," then He hears you. Sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöaù [Bg. 15.15]: Kåñëa is seated in everyone's heart.

BOB: But one should pray—is that so?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is his business—praying.

BOB: Whose business?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Every living entity's. That is the only business. Eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän. That is the statement of the Vedas.

BOB: What does that mean?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: He supplies everything to everyone. He is supplying food to everyone. So He is the Father. So why should you not pray, "Father, give me this"? Just as in the Christian Bible there is, "Father, give us our daily bread." That is good—they are accepting the Supreme Father. But grown-up children should not ask from the father; rather, they should be prepared to serve the father. That is bhakti [devotion].

BOB: My questions you solve so nicely. [Everyone laughs with affection.]

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Thank you very much.

BOB: So, should I ask you another question now?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh, yes. Yes!

PQPA 4: The Three Modes Of Nature

4. The Three Modes of Nature
February 28, 1972 (continued)

BOB: I have read that there are three guëas—passion, ignorance and goodness—in life. I was wishing that you would explain this somewhat, especially what is meant by the mode of ignorance and the mode of goodness.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: In goodness you can understand things—knowledge. You can know that there is God, that this world was created by Him, and so many things, actual things—the sun is this, the moon is this—perfect knowledge. If one has some knowledge, even though it may not be perfect, that is goodness. And in passion one identifies with his material body and tries to gratify his senses. That is passion. And ignorance is animal life—in ignorance, one does not know what is God, how to become happy, why we are in this world. For example, if you take an animal to the slaughterhouse, it will go. This is ignorance. But a man will protest. If a goat is to be killed after five minutes but you give it a morsel of grass, it is happy because it is eating. Just like a child—even if you are planning to kill her or kill him, he is happy and laughs because he is innocent. That is ignorance.

BOB: Being in these modes determines your karma. Is that correct?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. According to the association of the modes of nature, your activities are being contaminated.

käraëaà guëa-saìgo 'sya
sad-asad-yoni-janmasu
[Bg. 13.22]

A man gets a higher birth or lower birth according to the association of the guëas, or the modes of nature.

BOB: So cheating and like that—what mode is that?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Cheating is mixed passion and ignorance. Suppose one man cheats another. That means he wants to obtain something; he is passionate. But if he commits murder, he does not know that he will have to suffer for it, so it is a mixture of passion and ignorance.

BOB: And what about when somebody helps another person?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is goodness.

BOB: Why is that goodness? What intelligence is that? I mean—this represents knowledge of what? You said that goodness is when you have knowledge.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: Intelligence.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: So helping another person?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That means that he is ignorant and you are trying to enlighten him.

BOB: So giving intelligence...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, that is goodness.

BOB: And what about just giving assistance?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is also goodness.

BOB: If a beggar has nothing and you give him alms...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So that may still be goodness. But in your Bowery Street, they give some charity, and immediately he purchases one bottle of wine and drinks and lies down flat. [All laugh.] So that is charity. But that is not goodness; that is ignorance.

BOB: Charity is ignorance?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: There are three kinds of charities—good, passionate and ignorant. Goodness is giving charity where charity must be given. Just like this Kåñëa consciousness movement—if anyone gives charity to this movement, that is goodness because it is spreading God consciousness, Kåñëa consciousness. That is goodness. And if one gives charity for some return, that is passion. And if somebody gives in charity in an improper place and time, without respect and to an unworthy person, just like the Bowery man, that is ignorance. But Kåñëa says:

yat karoñi yad açnäsi
yaj juhoñi dadäsi yat
[Bg. 9.27]

"All that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you may perform, should be done as an offering unto Me." If Kåñëa takes, that is the perfection of charity. Or anyone who is a representative of Kåñëa—if he takes, that is perfection.

BOB: And what kind of charity is it when you give food to somebody who is hungry?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Well, that depends on the circumstances. For example, a doctor has forbidden his patient to take any solid food, and if the patient is asking, "Give me some solids," and if you give him solid food in charity, then you are not doing good to him. That is ignorance.

BOB: Are the devotees beyond accumulating karma? These devotees—do they feel karma? Do they work in these modes? Are they in the mode of goodness?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: They are above goodness! Çuddha-sattva. The devotees are not in this material world. They are in the spiritual world. That is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä (14.26):

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

["One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstances, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman."] Devotees are neither in goodness, passion nor ignorance. They are transcendental to all these qualities.

BOB: A devotee who is very faithful reaches this stage?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Devotee... You can become a devotee as they have become. It is not difficult. Simply you have to engage yourself in the transcendental loving service of the Lord, that's all.

BOB: I wish to gain more knowledge of God and be able to feel God's presence more. The reason for this is because I feel life has little meaning without this.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes! If you miss this human form of life, then it is a great loss. That is a great chance given to the living entity to get out of the entanglement of material existence.

BOB: I feel thankful that I've been able to ask these questions...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, you can learn more and more.

BOB: But I still have... my connections at home. Marriage is... I am engaged....

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, no. There are so many marriages. [He indicates Çyämasundara.] He is married. Marriage is no barrier. I told you that there are four different orders of spiritual life—brahmacäré, gåhastha, vänaprastha and sannyäsa. So after brahmacäré life, one can marry. That is not obligatory. One may remain naiñöika-brahmacäré for his whole life. But a brahmacäré can marry. And after marriage, there is vänaprastha life. This means that one is a little aloof from family—the husband and wife live separately. At that time there is no sex life. Then when he is fully renounced, detached from family life, he takes sannyäsa.

BOB: Does somebody forget his wife completely then?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Forgetting is not very difficult, if you try to forget. Out of sight, out of mind. [All laugh.] Just as I have my wife, children, grandchildren—everything. But, out of sight, out of mind, that's all. Therefore, vänaprastha, sannyäsa—everything is nicely arranged by the Vedic system.

PQPA 5: Becoming Pure

FIVE
Becoming Pure February 29, 1972

BOB: Thank you so much for allowing me to ask my questions.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is my mission. People should understand the science of God. Unless we cooperate with the Supreme Lord, our life is baffled. I have given the example many times that a screw which has fallen from a machine has no value. But when the same screw is again attached to the machine, it has value. Similarly, we are part and parcel of God. So without God, what is our value? No value! We should again come back to our position of attachment to God. Then we have value.

BOB: I met a fellow today who came in the afternoon. His reason for coming—you may find it humorous—was that he heard the hippies were in Mäyäpur.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: What?

BOB: He heard that hippies were in Mäyäpur. I was talking to him, and then some devotees were talking to him. He had said some things to me which I could find no answer for. And he said he would come back tomorrow and meet some devotees. But let me tell you what he said. This is confusing. When he was young—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: He's Indian?

BOB: Yes, Indian. He lives nearby and speaks English fairly well. When he was young he worshiped Kälé [a popular demigoddess] every day very rigorously, and then the floods came. When the floods came, the people saw hardship, and now he has no religion, and he says he finds his happiness in trying to develop love among people. And I couldn't think of what to say to him to add God and religion to his life. He says that after he dies, "maybe I'll become part of God, maybe not," but he can't worry about it now. He says he's tried these religious experiences, but they didn't work. One reason I ask this is because when I go back to America, a lot of people I come across are like this. They see that religion, like his worship of Kälé or other kinds of religion they've experienced, doesn't work. And I don't know what to say to them to convince them it's worth trying.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Do not try at the present moment. You try to be convinced yourself.

BOB: Yes. I asked him to see devotees, but then on the way out, as he was leaving down the road, I met him again and told him, "Come back," but... Oh, I see.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You first of all be convinced. And then try to convince others. Caitanya Mahäprabhu's instruction is that you can improve the welfare of others when your own life is a success:

bhärata-bhümite haila manuñya-janma yära
janma särthaka kari' kara para-upakära
[Ädi 9.41]

First make your life perfect. Then try to teach others.

BOB: The devotees have told me that without consciousness of Kåñëa all the time, you cannot be happy. But at times I feel happy.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: At times. Not always.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: But if you become Kåñëa conscious, you will feel happy always.

BOB: They had implied that you cannot feel happy without Kåñëa consciousness.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is a fact. For example, if you are an animal of the land and you are thrown into the water, you cannot be happy in water in any condition. When you are again taken up to the land, then you'll be happy. Similarly, we are part and parcel of Kåñëa. We cannot be happy without being part and parcel of Kåñëa. The same example: the machine part, without the machine, has no value, but when it is again put into the machine it has value. We are part of Kåñëa; we must join Kåñëa. And you can join Kåñëa immediately by your consciousness, simply by thinking, "I am Kåñëa's, Kåñëa is mine." That's all.

BOB: What is that? Kåñëa is...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Kåñëa is mine.

BOB: Mine?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Mine. My Kåñëa.

BOB: Ah.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Kåñëa is mine. Kåñëa is mine.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: And I am Kåñëa's. That is our actual position.

BOB: We are part of Kåñëa.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Everything is part and parcel of Kåñëa. Because everything is generated by the energy of Kåñëa and everything is the energy of Kåñëa.

AN INDIAN GENTLEMAN: Çréla Prabhupäda, I have one question. What is the status of service minus devotion?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m? That is not service, that is business. [Everyone laughs.] For example, here in Mäyäpur we have employed a contractor. That is not service—that is business. Is it not? Sometimes they will advertise, "Our customers are our masters." Is it not? But in spite of the flowery language—"Our customers are our masters"—this is business, because nobody is a qualified customer unless he pays. But service is not like that. Service—Caitanya Mahäprabhu prays to Kåñëa:

yathä tathä vä vidadhätu lampaöo
mat-präëa-näthas tu sa eva näparaù
[Çikñäñöaka 8]

"You do whatever You like, but still You are my worshipable Lord." That is service. "I don't ask any return from You." That is service. When you expect some return, that is business.

BOB: I wish to ask you to advise me on how I can come to feel closer to God. I'll be leaving you soon. And I'm—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You have to be purified.

BOB: I come to the temple at times, and then I leave, and I'm not sure how much I take with me.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: It does not take much time. Within six months you will realize your progress. But you have to follow the regulative principles. Then it will be all right. Just like these boys and girls are doing.

BOB: Yes, I see.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: They have no tendency for going to the cinema or going to a hotel. No. They have stopped all anarthas, all unnecessary things.

BOB: I—I feel that when I go back, they'll—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The whole human life is meant for purification.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA:

tapo divyaà putrakä yena sattvaà
çuddhyed yasmäd brahma-saukhyaà tv anantam
[Bhäg. 5.5.1]

Sattva means existence. So if you don't purify your existence, then you will have to change your body. From this body to that. Sometimes it may be higher, sometimes lower. For example, if you don't cure a disease, it can put you into trouble in so many ways. Similarly, if you don't purify your existence, then you will have to transmigrate from one body to another. There are very subtle laws of nature. Now there is no guarantee that you will get a very comfortable body or an American body. Therefore, it is essential for the human being to purify his existence. Unless you purify your existence, you will hanker after happiness but will not always be happy.

BOB: When I go to my job in New York, I hope I'll become pure, but I'm sure that I won't become as pure as your devotees here. I—I don't see myself doing that.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You can do as they are doing. They were not pure in the beginning; now they are pure. Similarly, you can become pure. For example, in your childhood you were not educated—but now you are educated.

BOB: So, what are the things that I may do? When I go back, I must—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: When do you go back?

BOB: I'll be going back to Chaibasa to do my work there, and...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: What is there in Chaibasa?

BOB: That is where I do my teaching. I live there.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So better not to teach—because you do not know what to teach.

BOB: [Laughs.] I'll be going—I don't like this teaching so much, and I'll be returning to America in May, but while I'm here, this is my agreement for staying in India.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: If you are serious, you can keep yourself pure anywhere. It doesn't matter whether you stay in America or India. But you must know how to keep yourself purified. That's all.

BOB: You mean by following these principles?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. I went to America, for instance, but either in America or India, I am the same man.

BOB: I—I have tried somewhat to follow since I met you the first time [a brief visit in Calcutta during November, 1971].

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m. But follow—you must strictly follow if you are serious.

BOB: Maybe—OK, maybe—what I say now is—well—the most foolish of all I've said. But let me tell you how I feel.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, no, not foolish. I don't say foolish—but imperfect.

BOB: OK. [He laughs.] Imperfect. But let me tell you. I feel that right now I admire and respect your devotees, but I don't feel as if I am part of them, or even that I have a great desire to be part of them. I feel that I just want—I want to do what is right, come closer to God, and if—and if I just go to a better life next time—I'd be satisfied.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Very good.

BOB: I guess it's material clinging, but ...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So, you just follow in their footsteps, and your desire will be fulfilled. We are training them how to become purified and happy. That is our mission. We want to see everyone happy. Sarve sukhino bhavantu. People do not know how to become happy. They do not take the standard path to become happy. They manufacture their own way. That is the difficulty. Therefore, Åñabhadeva gave this advice to his sons: "My dear boys, just undergo austerity for transcendental realization." Everyone is performing austerity. This boy I know—he had to go to a foreign country to learn commercial management. Now he is well situated. In this way, everyone must undergo some austerity for future life. So why not take that austerity for permanent happiness? You have to purify your existence and your body. As many times as you accept a material body, you will have to change it. But as soon as you get a spiritual body, there is no question of change. You already have a spiritual body. Now, due to our material contamination, we are developing the material body. But if we associate with spiritual life, then we shall develop a spiritual body. The same example I have several times given is that if you put an iron rod within fire, it will become like fire. Is it not?

BOB: Put the iron rod into fire?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, and it will become like fire.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Although iron.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Similarly, if you always keep yourself spiritually engaged, your body will act spiritually, although it is material. The same example: when an iron rod is red-hot, touch it anywhere, and it will burn. It takes on the quality of fire. Similarly, if you always keep yourself in Kåñëa consciousness, then you will become spiritualized. You will act spiritually. No more material demands.

BOB: How do I do this?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: This process. They are doing it. You have seen these boys, our six boys who have been initiated today. It is very simple. You have to follow the four restrictive regulations and chant these beads. Very easy.

BOB: Well, but, see—when I am back in Bihar and following my lifestyle there, I—if I follow all these regulative principles—some I follow now, but not all—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: "Some" means... ?

BOB: "Some"?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: There are only four regulative principles. "Some" means three, or two?

BOB: Two or three.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So why not the other one?

BOB: No, no. I mean I follow one or two. One or two I follow now.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: [Laughs.] Why not the other three? What is the difficulty? Which one do you follow?

BOB: Which one do I follow? Well, I'm almost vegetarian, but I eat eggs.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Then that is also not complete.

BOB: No, not even complete. Since last time [November], I've become vegetarian, but...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Vegetarian is no qualification.

BOB: Not much.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The pigeon is vegetarian. The monkey is vegetarian—the most rubbish creature...

BOB: Well...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The monkey is vegetarian. This naked sannyäsé lives in the forest... the most mischievous...

BOB: I—I felt that it was a little bit of progress because it was somewhat difficult at first, then easy, and I had returned to—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, you can stick to all the regulative principles, provided you take to the Kåñëa consciousness process—otherwise it is not possible.

BOB: Yes, this is it. I have—when I'm back in Bihar, and—um—my friends may say... We're sitting in the evening, and there's nothing to do but fight mosquitoes, and they say, "How about smoking some marijuana?" And I say, "Sure, there's nothing else to do," and then I sit down, and I enjoy myself for the evening. Now we did this, we got carried away, we were doing it every day and realizing we were hurting ourselves and stopped, but still on occasion we...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You have to live with us. Then your friends will not ask you, "What about marijuana?" [Bob laughs.] Keep the association of devotees. We are opening centers to give people a chance to associate with us. Why have we taken so much land [in Mäyäpur]? Those who are seriously desirous—they will come and live with us. Association is very influential. If you associate with drunkards, you become drunk; if you associate with sädhus, then you become a sädhu.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA [Çréla Prabhupäda's secretary] : He can come and stay with you in Bombay.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, you can stay with us in Bombay. But he wants friends with marijuana. That is the difficulty.

BOB: Let me ask you about something else; then maybe I'll come back to this. I find that I think of myself too much, and this way I can't think of God so much. I think of myself in too many places. How can I forget about myself so I can concentrate on other, more important things?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: As they [the devotees] have done.

BOB: [Laughs.] You are saying to me that my path—I think what you're saying is that my path to purity is to become a devotee.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Do you hesitate?

BOB: Well, I...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Is it very difficult to become a devotee?

BOB: For myself—it is. I—I don't feel so much the desire. First the devotees tell me that they have given up material life. These four regulative principles, they have explained to me, mean giving up material life, and that I see. And in place of this they have...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: What do you mean by material life? [Bob is silent] I am sitting on this bed. Is it material or spiritual?

BOB: Material.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Then how have we given up material life?

BOB: I think how I interpreted it was "a desire for our material gains..."

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: What is material?

BOB: Working towards material gains and not giving up all materials.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Material life means—when you desire to gratify your senses, that is material life. And when you desire to serve God, that is spiritual life. That is the difference between material life and spiritual life. Now we are trying to serve our senses. But instead of serving the senses, when we serve God, that is spiritual life. What is the difference between our activities and others' activities? We are using everything—table, chair, bed, tape recorder, typewriter—so what is the difference? The difference is that we are using everything for Kåñëa.

BOB: The devotees have said that the sensual pleasures they have given up are replaced with spiritual kinds of pleasures, but—see—I haven't felt this.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Spiritual pleasures come when you desire to please Kåñëa. That is spiritual pleasure. For example, a mother is more pleased by feeding her son. She's not eating, but when she sees that her son is eating very nicely, then she becomes pleased.

BOB: Hmm-m. Spiritual pleasure, then, is pleasing God.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Spiritual pleasure means the pleasure of Kåñëa.

BOB: Pleasing Kåñëa.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Material pleasure means the pleasure of the senses. That's all. This is the difference. When you simply try to please Kåñëa, that is spiritual pleasure.

BOB: I had viewed this as—my thought of pleasing God was to—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Don't manufacture your ways of pleasing God. Don't manufacture. Suppose I want to please you. Then I shall ask you, "How can I serve you?" Not that I manufacture some service. That is not pleasing. Suppose I want a glass of water. If you concoct the idea, "Sväméjé will be more pleased if I give him a glass of milk, hot milk," that will not please me. If you want to please me, then you should ask me, "How can I please you?" And if you do what I order, that will please me.

BOB: And pleasing Kåñëa, then, is being a devotee of Kåñëa.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: A devotee is one who is always pleasing Kåñëa. He has no other business. That is a devotee.

BOB: Can you tell me some more about chanting Hare Kåñëa? I have for quite some time chanted, but never regularly—just a little bit here and there. I just got beads very recently, and once in a while I feel comfortable chanting, and once in a while not comfortable at all. Maybe I don't chant properly. I don't know.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, everything has a process. You have to adopt the process.

BOB: The devotees tell me of the ecstasy they feel when chanting.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, the more you become purified, the more you will feel ecstasy. This chanting process is the purifying process.

PQPA 6: The Perfect Devotee

SIX
The Perfect Devotee February 29, 1972, evening

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Çréla Prabhupäda, this afternoon we were discussing austerities.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Mm?

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: If we don't practice austerities voluntarily, then we must involuntarily practice some austerities.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, under the direction of the spiritual master one should... You have no mind to follow austerities, but when you accept a spiritual master, you have to carry out his order. That is austerity.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Even if you don't want to practice austerity, you must.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, you must. Because you have surrendered to your spiritual master, his order is final. So even if you don't like it, you have to do it. To please me.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Ah.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: But you don't like... [He laughs.] Nobody likes to fast, but the spiritual master says, "Today, fasting," so what can be done? [Çyämasundara laughs.] A disciple is one who has voluntarily agreed to be disciplined by the spiritual master. That is austerity.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Say, like our parents or many people in the material world, completely enamored by the material life—they don't want to undergo austerity or bodily pain, but still they must. They are being forced by nature to suffer austerities.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is forced austerity. That is not good. Voluntary austerity will help.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: If you don't undergo voluntary austerity, then you must be forced to undergo austerity.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is the difference between man and animal. An animal cannot accept austerity. But a man can accept it. There is a nice foodstuff in the confectioner's shop, so a man wants to eat it, but he sees that he has no money, so he can restrain himself. But when a cow comes, immediately she pushes her mouth in. You can beat her with a stick, but she will tolerate it. She will do that. Therefore an animal cannot undergo austerity. Our austerity is very nice. We chant Hare Kåñëa, dance, and Kåñëa sends very nice foodstuffs, and we eat. That's all. Why are your people not agreeable to such austerity? Chanting, dancing and eating nicely?

BOB: What is that?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Because we are following austerities, Kåñëa sends us nice things. So we are not losers. When you become Kåñëa-ized, then you get more comforts than at the present moment. That's a fact. I have been living alone for the last twenty years, but I have no difficulties. Before taking sannyäsa I was living in Delhi. So I had no difficulties, although I was living alone.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: If you don't accept spiritual discipline, then nature will force so many calamities.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh, yes. That is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.14]:

daivé hy eñä guëa-mayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

["This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it."] Mäyä is imposing so many difficulties, but as soon as you surrender to Kåñëa, no more imposition.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: We were so foolish that we were always thinking, "In the future I'll be happy."

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, that is mäyä, illusion. That is like the ass. You sit down on the back of the ass and just take a morsel of grass. The ass is thinking, "Let me go forward a little, and I shall get the grass." [Bob laughs.] But it is always one foot distant. That is ass-ism. [They all laugh.] Everyone is thinking, "Let me go a little forward, and I'll get it. I'll be very happy."

BOB: I... I thank you so much for...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hmm?

BOB: Tomorrow I'll have to leave you and—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Don't talk l-e-a-v-e, but talk l-i-v-e.

BOB: I cannot yet, but I was thinking now of returning tomorrow to my town. But...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Don't return.

BOB: I should stay here tomorrow—here?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Stay here.

BOB: You tell me to, I'll stay.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, you are a very good boy. [There is a long pause. It is now much quieter.] It is very simple. When the living entities forget Kåñëa, they are in this material world. Kåñëa means His name, His form, His abode, His pastimes—everything.

BOB: What was that last?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Ah? Pastimes.

BOB: Pastimes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: When we speak of a king, it means the king's government, king's palace, king's queen, king's sons, secretaries, military strength—everything. Is it not?

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Similarly, Kåñëa being the Supreme Personality of Godhead, as soon as we think of Kåñëa, this means all the energies of Kåñëa. That is complete by saying, "Rädhä-Kåñëa." Rädhä represents all the energy of Kåñëa. And Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord. So when we speak of Kåñëa, the living entities are also included because the living entities are energies, different energies of Kåñëa—superior energy. So when this energy is not serving the energetic, that is material existence. The whole world is not serving Kåñëa. They are serving Kåñëa in a different way. They are serving indirectly, just as disobedient citizens serve the government indirectly. Prisoners come to the prison house on account of their disobedience of the laws of the state. So, in the prison house, they are forced to obey the laws of the state. Similarly, all the living entities here are godless, either by ignorance or by choice. They do not like to accept the supremacy of God. Demoniac. So we are trying to bring them to their original condition. That is the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

BOB: I'd like to ask you just something I talked with devotees about—medicine. I walked to the river with some devotees today. I have a cold, so I said I shouldn't go in the water. Some felt I should because it is the Ganges, and some said I shouldn't because I have a cold, and we were talking, and I don't understand. Do we get sick because of our bad actions in the past?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, that's a fact.

BOB: But when one...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Any kind of distress we suffer is due to our impious activities in the past.

BOB: But when someone is removed from karmic influence...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes?

BOB: ... does he still get sick?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No. Even if he gets sick, that is very temporary. For instance, this fan is moving. If you disconnect the electric power, then the fan will move for a moment. That movement is not due to the electric current. That is force—what is it called, physically, this force?

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Momentum.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Momentum. But as soon as it stops, no more movement. Similarly, even if a devotee who has surrendered to Kåñëa is suffering from material consequences, that is temporary. Therefore, a devotee does not take any material miseries as miseries. He takes them as Kåñëa's, God's, mercy.

BOB: A perfected soul, a devotee, a pure devotee...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: A perfected soul is one who engages twenty-four hours a day in Kåñëa consciousness. That is perfection. That is a transcendental position. Perfection means to engage in one's original consciousness. That is perfection. That is stated in Bhagavad-gétä [18.45]:

sve sve karmaëy abhirataù
saàsiddhià labhate naraù

"By following his qualities of work, every man can become perfect." Complete perfection. Saàsiddhi. Siddhi is perfection. That is Brahman realization, spiritual realization. And saàsiddhi means devotion, which comes after Brahman realization.

BOB: Could you just say that last thing again please?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Saàsiddhi.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Sam means complete.

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: And siddhi means perfection. In the Bhagavad-gétä it is stated that one who goes back to home, back to Godhead, has attained the complete perfection. So perfection comes when one realizes that he is not this body; he is spirit soul. Brahma-bhüta—that is called Brahman realization. That is perfection. And saàsiddhi comes after Brahman realization, when one engages in devotional service. Therefore if one is already engaged in devotional service, it is to be understood that Brahman realization is there. Therefore it is called saàsiddhi.

BOB: I ask you this very humbly, but do you feel diseases and sickness?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m?

BOB: Do you personally feel disease and sickness?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: Is this a result of your past karma?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: So one in this material world never escapes his karma completely?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, he escapes. No more karma for a devotee. No more karmic reaction.

BOB: But you must be the best devotee.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m... No, I don't consider myself the best devotee. I am the lowest.

BOB: No!

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You are the best devotee.

BOB: [Laughs.] Oh, no, no! But, see, you say—what you say... always seems right.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BOB: Then you must be the best devotee.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The thing is that even the best devotee, when he preaches, comes to the second-class platform of a devotee.

BOB: What would the best devotee be doing?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The best devotee does not preach.

BOB: What does he do?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: He sees that there is no need of preaching. For him, everyone is a devotee. [Bob laughs heartily.] Yes, he sees no more nondevotees—all devotees. He is called an uttama-adhikäré. But while I am preaching, how can I say I am the best devotee? Just like Rädhäräëé—She does not see anyone as a nondevotee. Therefore we try to approach Rädhäräëé.

BOB: Who is this?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Rädhäräëé, Kåñëa's consort.

BOB: Ah.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: If anyone approaches Rädhäräëé, She recommends to Kåñëa, "Here is the best devotee. He is better than Me," and Kåñëa cannot refuse him. That is the best devotee. But it is not to be imitated: "I have become the best devotee."

éçvare tad-adhéneñu
bäliçeñu dviñatsu ca
prema-maitré-kåpopekñä
yaù karoti sa madhyamaù
(Bhäg. 11.2.46)

A second-class devotee has the vision that some are envious of God, but this is not the vision of the best devotee. The best devotee sees, "Nobody is envious of God. Everyone is better than me." Just like Caitanya-caritämåta's author, Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja. He says, "I am lower than the worm in the stool."

BOB: Who is saying this?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja, the author of Caitanya-caritämåta [Ädi 5.205]: puréñera kéöa haite muïi se laghiñöha. He is not making a show. He is feeling like that. "I am the lowest. Everyone is best, but I am the lowest. Everyone is engaged in Kåñëa's service. I am not engaged." Caitanya Mahäprabhu said, "Oh, I have not a pinch of devotion to Kåñëa. I cry to make a show. If I had been a devotee of Kåñëa, I would have died long ago. But I am living. That is the proof that I do not love Kåñëa." That is the vision of the best devotee. He is so much absorbed in Kåñëa's love that he says, "Everything is going on, but I am the lowest. Therefore I cannot see God." That is the best devotee.

BOB: So a devotee must work for everybody's liberation?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. A devotee must work under the direction of a bona fide spiritual master, not imitate the best devotee.

BOB: Excuse me?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: One should not imitate the best devotee.

BOB: Imitate. Oh. I see.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: One time you said that sometimes you feel sickness or pain due to the sinful activities of your devotees. Can sometimes disease be due to that? Caused by that?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You see, Kåñëa says [Bg. 18.66]:

ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"I will deliver you from all sinful reaction. Do not fear." So Kåñëa is so powerful that He can immediately take up all the sins of others and immediately make them right. But when a living entity plays the part on behalf of Kåñëa, he also takes the responsibility for the sinful activities of his devotees. Therefore to become a guru is not an easy task. You see? He has to take all the poisons and absorb them. So sometimes—because he is not Kåñëa—sometimes there is some trouble. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu has forbidden, "Don't make many çiñyas, many disciples." But for preaching work we have to accept many disciples—for expanding preaching—even if we suffer. That's a fact. The spiritual master has to take the responsibility for all the sinful activities of his disciples. Therefore to make many disciples is a risky job unless one is able to assimilate all the sins.

väïchä-kalpa-tarubhyaç ca
kåpä-sindhubhya eva ca
patitänäà pävanebhyo
vaiñëavebhyo namo namaù
[Vaiñëava Praëäma]

["I offer my respectful obeisances unto all the Vaiñëava devotees of the Lord. They are just like desire trees who can fulfill the desires of everyone, and they are full of compassion for the fallen conditioned souls."] He takes responsibility for all the fallen souls. That idea is also in the Bible. Jesus Christ took all the sinful reactions of the people and sacrificed his life. That is the responsibility of a spiritual master. Because Kåñëa is Kåñëa, He is apäpa-viddha—He cannot be attacked by sinful reactions. But a living entity is sometimes subjected to their influence because he is so small. Big fire, small fire. If you put some big thing in a small fire, the fire itself may be extinguished. But in a big fire, whatever you put in is all right. The big fire can consume anything.

BOB: Christ's suffering was of that nature?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Mm-m?

BOB: Was Christ's suffering—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That I have already explained. He took the sinful reactions of all the people. Therefore he suffered.

BOB: I see.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: He said—that is in the Bible—that he took all the sinful reactions of the people and sacrificed his life. But these Christian people have made it a law for Christ to suffer while they do all nonsense. [Bob gives a short laugh.] Such great fools they are! They have let Jesus Christ make a contract for taking all their sinful reactions so they can go on with all nonsense. That is their religion. Christ was so magnanimous that he took all their sins and suffered, but that does not induce them to stop all these sins. They have not come to that sense. They have taken it very easily. "Let Lord Jesus Christ suffer, and we'll do all nonsense." Is it not?

BOB: It is so.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: They should have been ashamed: "Lord Jesus Christ suffered for us, but we are continuing the sinful activities." He told everyone, "Thou shalt not kill," but they are indulging in killing, thinking, "Lord Jesus Christ will excuse us and take all the sinful reactions." This is going on. We should be very much cautious: "For my sinful actions my spiritual master will suffer, so I'll not commit even a pinch of sinful activities." That is the duty of the disciple. After initiation, all sinful reaction is finished. Now if he again commits sinful activities, his spiritual master has to suffer. A disciple should be sympathetic and consider this. "For my sinful activities, my spiritual master will suffer." If the spiritual master is attacked by some disease, it is due to the sinful activities of others. "Don't make many disciples." But we do it because we are preaching. Never mind—let us suffer—still we shall accept them. Therefore your question was—when I suffer is it due to my past misdeeds? Was it not? That is my misdeed—that I accepted some disciples who are nonsense. That is my misdeed.

BOB: This happens on occasions?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. This is sure to happen because we are accepting so many men. It is the duty of the disciples to be cautious. "My spiritual master has saved me. I should not put him again into suffering." When the spiritual master is in suffering, Kåñëa saves him. Kåñëa thinks, "Oh, he has taken so much responsibility for delivering a fallen person." So Kåñëa is there.

kaunteya pratijänéhi
na me bhaktaù praëaçyati

["O son of Kunté, declare it boldly that My devotee never perishes." [Bg. 9.31]] Because the spiritual master takes the risk on account of Kåñëa.

BOB: Your suffering is not the same kind of pain...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, it is not due to karma. The pain is there sometimes, so that the disciples may know, "Due to our sinful activities, our spiritual master is suffering."

BOB: You look very well now.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: I am always well... in the sense that even if there is suffering, I know Kåñëa will protect me. But this suffering is not due to my sinful activities.

BOB: But let us say when I—in the town I live in, I take boiled water because some of the water has disease in it. Now, why should I drink boiled water if I have been good enough not to get a disease? Then I may drink any water. And if I have been not acting properly, then I shall get disease anyway.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So long as you are in the material world, you cannot neglect physical laws. Suppose you go to a jungle and there is a tiger. It is known that it will attack you, so why should you voluntarily go and be attacked? It is not that a devotee should take physical risk so long as he has a physical body. It is not a challenge to the physical laws: "I have become a devotee. I challenge everything." That is foolishness.

anäsaktasya viñayän
yathärham upayuïjataù
nirbandhaù kåñëa-sambandhe
yuktaà vairägyam ucyate
[Brs 1.2.255]

The devotee is advised to accept the necessities of life without attachment. He'll take boiled water, but if boiled water is not available, does it mean he will not drink water? If it is not available, he will drink ordinary water. We take Kåñëa prasäda, but while touring, sometimes we have to take some food in a hotel. Because one is a devotee, should he think, "I will not take any foodstuffs from the hotel. I shall starve"? If I starve, then I will be weak and will not be able to preach.

BOB: Does a devotee lose some of his individuality, in that—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, he has full individuality for pleasing Kåñëa. Kåñëa says, "You surrender unto Me." So he voluntarily surrenders. It is not that he has lost his individuality. He keeps his individuality. Just like Arjuna—in the beginning, he was declining to fight, on account of his individuality. But when he accepted Kåñëa as his spiritual master, he became çiñya [a disciple]. Then whatever Kåñëa ordered, he said yes. That doesn't mean he lost his individuality. He voluntarily accepted: "Whatever Kåñëa says, I shall do it." Just like all my disciples—they have not lost their individuality, but they have surrendered their individuality. That is required. For example, suppose a man does not use sex. It does not mean he has become impotent. If he likes, he can have sex life a thousand times. But he has voluntarily avoided it. Paraà dåñövä nivartate (Bg. 2.59): he has a higher taste. Sometimes we fast, but that does not mean we are diseased. We voluntarily fast. It does not mean that I am not hungry or cannot eat. But we voluntarily fast.

BOB: Does the devotee who surrenders keep his individual taste?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, in full.

BOB: Taste for different things?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm?

BOB: Does he keep his individual likes and dislikes?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, he keeps everything. But he gives preference to Kåñëa. Suppose I like this thing but Kåñëa says, "No, you cannot use it." Then I shall not use it. It is for Kåñëa's sake.

nirbandhaù kåñëa-sambandhe
yuktaà vairägyam ucyate
[Brs 1.2.255]

Kåñëa says positively, "I like these things." So we have to offer to Kåñëa what He likes, and then we'll take prasäda. Kåñëa likes Rädhäräëé. Therefore all the gopés, they are trying to push Rädhäräëé to Kåñëa. "Kåñëa likes this gopé. All right, push Her." That is Kåñëa consciousness. To satisfy the senses of Kåñëa, not to satisfy my senses. That is bhakti. That is called prema, love for Kåñëa. "Ah, Kåñëa likes this. I must give Him this."

BOB: There is some prasäda [food offered to Kåñëa]. It's offered, and then we go and eat, and different prasädams are served. Some I like, and some I find the taste not at all to my liking.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You should not do that. The perfection is that whatever is offered to Kåñëa you should accept. That is perfection. You cannot say, "I like this, I don't like this." So long as you make such discrimination, that means you have not appreciated what prasäda is.

A DEVOTEE: What if there is someone speaking of likes and dislikes? Say someone is preparing some prasäda...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No disliking, no liking. Whatever Kåñëa likes, that's all right.

A DEVOTEE: Yes. But say someone prepares something, like some prasäda for Kåñëa, but he does not make it so good, and it is—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, if made sincerely with devotion, then Kåñëa will like it. Just like Vidu. Vidu was feeding Kåñëa bananas, but he was so absorbed in thought that he was throwing away the real bananas and he was giving Kåñëa the skin, and Kåñëa was eating. [All laugh.] Kåñëa knew that he was giving in devotion, and Kåñëa can eat anything, provided there is devotion. It does not matter whether it is materially tasteful or not. Similarly, a devotee also takes Kåñëa prasäda, whether it is materially tasteful or not. We should accept everything.

A DEVOTEE: But if the devotion is not there, like in India...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: If devotion is not there, He doesn't like any food, either tasteful or not tasteful. He does not accept it.

A DEVOTEE: In India... Somebody—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh, India, India. Don't talk of India! Talk of philosophy. If there is not devotion, Kåñëa does not accept anything, either in India or in your country. Lord Kåñëa is not obliged to accept anything costly because it is very tasty. Kåñëa has very many tasteful dishes in Vaikuëöha. He is not hankering after your food. He accepts your devotion, bhakti. The real thing is devotion, not the food. Kåñëa does not accept any food of this material world. He accepts only the devotion.

patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà
yo me bhaktyä prayacchati
tad ahaà bhakty-upahåtam
açnämi prayatätmanaù

["If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit or water, I will accept it." [Bg. 9.26]] "Because it has been offered to Me with devotion and love"—that is required. Therefore we do not allow anyone to cook who is not a devotee. Kåñëa does not accept anything from the hands of a nondevotee. Why should He accept? He is not hungry. He does not require any food. He accepts only the devotion, that's all. That is the main point. So one has to become a devotee. Not a good cook. But if he is a devotee, then he will be a good cook also. Automatically he will become a good cook. Therefore one has to become a devotee only. Then all other good qualifications will automatically be there. And if he is a nondevotee, any good qualifications have no value. He is on the mental plane, so he has no good qualification. [There is a long pause in the conversation.]

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: And the time?

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Six o'clock.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Questions and answers are required. They are beneficial to all.

BOB: I still have a question on the prasäda.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Süta Gosvämé says:

munayaù sädhu påñöo 'haà
bhavadbhir loka-maìgalam
yat kåtaù kåñëa-sampraçno
yenätmä suprasédati
[Bhäg. 1.2.5]

["O sages, I have been justly questioned by you. Your questions are worthy because they relate to Lord Kåñëa and so are relevant to the world's welfare. Only questions of this sort are capable of completely satisfying the self."] Kåñëa-sampraçnaù, that is very good. When you discuss and hear, that is loka-maìgalam, auspicious for everyone. Both the questions and the answers.

BOB: I still do not understand so much about prasäda. But if you like I'll think about it and ask you again tomorrow.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Prasäda is always prasäda. But because we are not elevated sufficiently, therefore we do not like some prasäda.

BOB: I found specifically that what I mean—that some are too spicy, and it hurts my stomach.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Well... That is also due to not appreciating, but the cook should have consideration. Kåñëa must be offered first-class foodstuffs. So if he offers something last class, he is not performing his duty. But Kåñëa can accept anything if it is offered by a devotee, and a devotee can accept any prasäda, even if it is spicy. Hiraëyakaçipu gave his son poison [and the son offered it to Kåñëa], and the son drank it as nectar. So even if it is spicy to others' taste, it is very palatable to the devotee. What is the question of spicy? He was offered poison, real poison. And Pütanä Räkñasé—she also offered Kåñëa poison. But Kåñëa is so nice that He thought, "She took Me as My mother," so He took the poison and delivered her. Kåñëa does not take the bad side. A good man does not take the bad side—he takes only the good side. Just like one of my big Godbrothers—he wanted to make business with my Guru Mahäräja [spiritual master], but my Guru Mahäräja did not take the bad side. He took the good side. He thought, "He has come forward to give me some service."

BOB: Business with your—what was that? Business with who?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: I am talking about my Guru Mahäräja.

BOB: Oh, I see. I have another question on prasäda, if I may. Let us say some devotee has some trouble and does not eat a certain type of food—like some devotees do not eat ghee because of liver trouble. So these devotees, should they take all the prasäda?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, no. Those who are not perfect devotees may discriminate. But a perfect devotee does not discriminate. Why should you imitate a perfect devotee? So long as you have discrimination, you are not a perfect devotee. So why should you artificially imitate a perfect devotee and eat everything?

BOB: Oh.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The point is, a perfect devotee does not make any discrimination. Whatever is offered to Kåñëa is nectar. That's all. Kåñëa accepts anything from a devotee. "Whatever is offered to Me by My devotee," He accepts. The same thing for a devotee. Don't you see the point? A perfect devotee does not make any discrimination. But if I am not a perfect devotee and I have discrimination, why shall I imitate the perfect devotee? It may not be possible for me to digest everything because I am not a perfect devotee. A devotee should not be a foolish man. It is said:

kåñëa ye bhaje se baòa catura

So a devotee knows his position, and he is intelligent enough to deal with others accordingly.

PQPA 7: Acting in Knowledge of Kåñëa

7. Acting in Knowledge of Kåñëa
February 29, 1972 (evening, continued)

AN INDIAN GENTLEMAN: By what kind of actions does one earn good karma?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Good karma means what is prescribed in the Vedas. Specifically, it is prescribed that one should perform yajïa. Yajïa means actions for the satisfaction of Lord Viñëu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So good karma means performance of the yajïas as they are prescribed in the Vedic literatures. And the purpose of this yajïa is to satisfy the Supreme Lord. A good, law-abiding citizen is one whose actions satisfy the government. So, good karma is to satisfy Lord Viñëu, the Supreme Lord. Unfortunately, modern civilization does not know what the Supreme Personality of Godhead is, what to speak of satisfying Him. People do not know. They are simply busy with material activities. Therefore all of them are performing only bad karma and therefore suffering. They are blind men leading other blind men. And both are then suffering by bad karma. That is very easy to understand. If you do something criminal, you will suffer. If you do something benevolent for the state, for the people, then you are recognized; you are sometimes given a title. This is good and bad karma. So, good karma means you enjoy some material happiness; bad karma means you suffer from material distress. By good karma you get birth in a good family; you get riches, good money. Then you become a learned scholar; you become beautiful also.

[Some time passes.]

BOB: What about the person who—who is not very aware of God, but...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Then he is an animal. The animal does not know what is good. A person who does not know what is God, or one who does not try to understand what is God—he is an animal. The animals are with four legs, and that animal is with two legs. And Darwin's theory is they are monkeys. So anyone who does not know God, or does not try to understand God, is nothing but an animal.

BOB: What about the innocent people?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The animal is very innocent. If you cut its throat, it won't protest. So innocence is not a very good qualification. The animals are all innocent. Therefore you get the chance to cut their throats. So to become innocent is not a very good qualification. Our proposition is that one must be very, very intelligent, and then he can understand Kåñëa. To become an innocent, ignorant simpleton is not a very good qualification. Simplicity is all right, but one should not be unintelligent.

BOB: Can you tell me again what intelligence is?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Intelligence means... One who knows what he is, what is this world, what is God, what are the interrelations—he is intelligent. The animal does not know what he is. He thinks that he is the body. Similarly, anyone who does not know what he is, he is not intelligent.

BOB: What about a person who does—tries to do—what is right and is very conscientious instead of being unconscious about the things he does? Like the servant who is very honest to his master but knows that if he were not honest he would not be caught. If he stays honest anyway... a person like that? Is that some kind of good karma?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, to become honest is also good karma. How to become a good man is described in the Bhagavad-gétä [16.5] very elaborately.

daivé sampad vimokñäya
nibandhäyäsuré matä

So if you become qualified with the daivé sampad (transcendental qualities), then, vimokñäya—you will be liberated. And, nibandhäyäsuré—if you are qualified with the demoniac qualifications, then you will be more and more entangled. Unfortunately the modern civilization does not know what is liberation and what is entanglement. They are so much ignorant; they do not know. Suppose if I ask you what you mean by liberation, can you answer? [No answer.] And if I ask you what you mean by entanglement, can you answer? [Again no answer.] These words are there in the Vedic literature—liberation and entanglement—but, at the present moment, people do not even know what is liberation and what is entanglement. They are so ignorant and foolish, and still they are proud of their advancement in knowledge. Can you answer what is liberation? You are a professor, teacher, but if I ask you, can you explain what is liberation?

BOB: Not adequately because if I could explain, then I would become liberated very fast.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: But if you do not know what is liberation, then how fast or slow liberation? [Everyone laughs.] There is no question of liberation. It is neither fast nor slow. You should first know what is liberation. If you do not know where the train is going, then what is the use of asking, understanding, whether it is going fast or slow? You do not know your destination. What is liberation?

BOB: Umm...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: I am asking. You daily ask me. I am asking you.

BOB: [Laughs.] Ah—okay... I'll think for a moment.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Liberation is described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The exact Sanskrit word for liberation is mukti. So that is defined in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [2.10.16].

muktir hitvänyathä rüpaà
svarüpeëa vyavasthitiù

One should stop doing all nonsense, and he must be situated in his original position. But this is also more embarrassing because nobody knows his original position and how to act properly. Because people are generally acting differently, because they do not know what is proper—the modern population is so much ignorant about their life—it is a very awkward position. They do not know.

BOB: Can you tell me who is honest?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: If one does not know what is honesty, how can he be honest? But if you know what is honesty, then you can be honest. What is honesty? First of all explain.

BOB: Aaah, ummm—Honesty is doing what you really feel is right.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: A thief is feeling, "I must steal to provide for my children. It is right." Does it mean that he is honest? Everyone thinks—The butcher thinks, "It is my life. I must cut the throat of the animals daily." Just like that—what is that hunter? And Närada Muni met him?

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Mågäri.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, Mågäri. Närada asked him, "Why are you killing in this way?" And he said, "Oh, it is my business. My father taught it." So he was honestly doing that. So a feeling of honesty depends on culture. A thief's culture is different. He thinks stealing is honest.

BOB: So what is honesty?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, that is my question. [Everyone laughs.] Real honesty is that you should not encroach upon another's property. This is honesty. For instance, this is my table. If you want to take it away while going, is that honesty? So therefore the simple definition of honesty is that you should not encroach upon another's rights. That is honesty.

BOB: So somebody who is honest would be in the mode of goodness? Would that be correct?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Certainly, certainly. Because the mode of goodness means knowledge. So if you know, "This table does not belong to me; it belongs to Sväméjé," you will not try to take it away. Therefore, one must know—be thoroughly well conversant—then he can be honest.

BOB: So, now you have said the mode of goodness was knowledge of God, but somebody may be honest without having very much knowledge of God.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m?

BOB: Without—without being honest—without thinking they are honest because it is God's wishes—they just feel like they ought to be honest.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Mmm. God wishes everyone to be honest. Why should God think otherwise?

BOB: So... so you may follow God's wishes without knowing you are following God's wishes? Like somebody may be in the mode...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, following without knowing—that is absurd. You must know the order of God. And if you follow that, then that is honesty.

BOB: But somebody would not be honest without knowing God?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, because God is the supreme proprietor, the supreme enjoyer, and He is the supreme friend. That is the statement of the Bhagavad-gétä. If anyone knows these three things, then he is in full knowledge. These three things only: that God is the proprietor of everything, God is friend of everyone, and God is the enjoyer of everything. For example, everyone knows that in the body, the stomach is the enjoyer. Not the hands, legs, eyes, ears. These are there simply to help the stomach. Eyes—the vulture goes seven miles up to see where there is food for the stomach. Is it not?

BOB: That is so.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Then the wings fly there, and the jaws catch the food. Similarly, as in this body the stomach is the enjoyer, the central figure of the whole cosmic manifestation, material or spiritual, is Kåñëa, God. He is the enjoyer. We can understand this just by considering our own bodies. The body is also a creation. The body has the same mechanical nature you will find in the whole universe. The same mechanical arrangement will be found anywhere you go, even in animals. In the human body or in the cosmic manifestation—almost the same mechanism. So you can understand very easily that in this body—my body, your body—the stomach is the enjoyer. There is a central enjoyer. And the stomach is the friend also. Because if you cannot digest food, you see, then all other limbs of the body become weak. Therefore the stomach is the friend. It is digesting and distributing the energy to all the limbs of the body. Is it not?

BOB: It is so.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Similarly, the central stomach of the whole creation is God, or Kåñëa. He is the enjoyer, He is the friend, and, as the supreme proprietor, He is maintaining everyone. Just as a king can maintain the whole country's citizens because he is the proprietor. Without being the proprietor, how can one become everyone's friend? So these things have to be understood. Kåñëa is the enjoyer, Kåñëa is the proprietor, and Kåñëa is the friend. If you know these three things, then your knowledge is full; you do not require to understand anything more.

yasmin vijïäte sarvam evaà vijïätaà bhavati
[Muëòaka Up. 1.3]

If you simply understand Kåñëa by these three formulas, then your knowledge is complete. You don't require any more knowledge. But people will not agree. "Why should Kåñëa be the proprietor? Hitler should be the proprietor. Nixon ..." That is going on. Therefore you are in trouble. But if you understand these three things only, then your knowledge is complete. But you will not accept—you will put forward so many impediments to understanding these three things, and that is the cause of our trouble. But in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.29] it is plainly said:

bhoktäraà yajïa-tapasäà
sarva-loka-maheçvaram
suhådaà sarva-bhütänäà
jïätvä mäà çäntim åcchati

["The sages, knowing Me as the ultimate purpose of all sacrifices and austerities, the Supreme Lord of all planets and demigods and the benefactor and well-wisher of all living entities, attain peace from the pangs of material miseries."] But we won't take this. We shall put forward so many false proprietors, false friends, false enjoyers, and they will fight one another. This is the situation of the world. If education is given and people take this knowledge, there is immediately peace (çäntim åcchati). This is knowledge, and if anyone follows this principle, he is honest. He does not claim, "It is mine." He knows everything: "Oh, it is Kåñëa's, so therefore everything should be utilized for Kåñëa's service." That is honesty. If this pencil belongs to me, the etiquette is—My students sometimes ask, "Can I use this pencil?" "Yes, you can." Similarly, if I know that everything belongs to Kåñëa, I will not use anything without His permission. That is honesty. And that is knowledge. One who does not know is ignorant; he is foolish. And a foolish man commits criminality. All criminals are foolish men. Out of ignorance one commits lawbreaking. So ignorance is not bliss, but it is folly to be wise where ignorance is bliss. That is the difficulty. The whole world is enjoying ignorance. And when you talk about Kåñëa consciousness, they do not very much appreciate it. If I say, "Kåñëa is the proprietor; you are not the proprietor," you will not be very much satisfied. [They laugh.] Just see—ignorance is bliss. So it is my foolishness to say the real truth. Therefore it is folly to be wise where ignorance is bliss. So we are taking the risk of offending people, and they will think we are fools. If I say to a rich man, "You are not the proprietor. Kåñëa is the proprietor, so whatever money you have, spend it for Kåñëa," he will be angry.

upadeço hi mürkhänäà
prakopäya na çäntaye
[Néti Çästra]

"If you instruct a rascal, he'll be angry." Therefore we go as beggars: "My dear sir, you are a very nice man. I am a sannyäsé beggar, so I want to construct a temple. Can you spare some money?" So he will think, "Oh, here is a beggar. Give him some money." [They laugh.] But if I say, "Dear sir, you have millions of dollars at your disposal. That is Kåñëa's money. Give it to me. I am Kåñëa's servant." Oh, he'll... [Everyone laughs.] He will not be very satisfied. Rather, if I go as a beggar, he will give me something. And if I tell him the truth, he will not give me a farthing. [They laugh.] We convince him as beggars. We are not beggars. We are Kåñëa's servants. We don't want anything from anyone. Because we know Kåñëa will provide everything.

BOB: Oh-h...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: This is knowledge. For instance, a child will sometimes take something important, so we have to flatter him. "Oh, you are so nice. Please take these lozenges and give me that paper. It is nothing; it is paper." And he will say, "Oh, yes. Take. That's nice." Two-paise lozenges—very nice and sweet. So we have to do that. Why? Because a man will go to hell by taking Kåñëa's money. So some way or other, take some money from him and engage him in the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

BOB: And then he may not go to hell?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. You save him from going to hell. Because a farthing spent for Kåñëa will be accounted: "Oh, this man has given a farthing." This is called ajïäta-sukåti [spiritual activity one performs unknowingly]. They are very poor in their thought. Therefore the saintly persons move just to enlighten them a little. To give them a chance. Giving them a chance to serve Kåñëa. That is the saintly person's duty.

BOB: That is what?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is his duty. But if he takes money from others and utilizes it for his sense gratification, then he goes to hell. Then it is finished. Then he is a cheater; actually he is a criminal. You cannot take money, a farthing, from anyone, and use it for your own sense gratification.

BOB: I think of people I know who are not Kåñëa conscious.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Kåñëa means God.

BOB: They are just slightly God conscious, but still these people are honest to the extent that they don't take from other people at all. And they try to be honest with other people. Will these—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: He does not take from other people, but he takes from God.

BOB: So these people are half good?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m?

BOB: These people are then half-good?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Not good. If he does not learn this principle—that God is the proprietor... Others' things? What do you mean, "others' things"?

BOB: Like, people I'm thinking of—they're poor people who need money and food but—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Everyone needs money. Everyone needs it. Who is not poor? There are so many gentlemen sitting here. Who is not in need of money and food? You are also in need of money. So how do you distinguish poor from rich? Everyone needs it. If that is your definition... If one needs money and food, then everyone needs money and food. So everyone is poor.

BOB: So, but, well—I was thinking in terms of just people who are relatively poor.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Relatively, relatively, maybe. You are more hungry than me. That does not mean you are not hungry or I am not hungry. I do not feel hungry now. That does not mean I do not feel hungry or I am not hungry. For the time being you may not be hungry. But tomorrow you'll be hungry.

BOB: What I feel is that—somehow these people—that... Everybody around them may be stealing, but they still stand up and don't steal. These people somehow deserve something good to happen to them.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: But the man who is thinking that he is not stealing is also a thief because he does not know that everything belongs to Kåñëa. Therefore, whatever he is accepting, he is stealing.

BOB: Is he less of a thief?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You may not know that I am the proprietor of this wrapper, but if you take it away, are you not stealing?

BOB: But maybe if I know it is yours and I take it, I am a worse thief than if I do not know whose it is. I just think it may be nobody's, and I take it.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is also stealing. Because it must belong to somebody. And you take it without his permission. You may not know exactly who is the proprietor, but you know, "It must belong to someone." That is knowledge. Sometimes we see on the road so many valuable things left there—government property for repairing roads or some electrical work. A man may think, "Oh, fortunately these things are lying here, so I may take them." Is it not stealing?

BOB: It is stealing.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. He does not know that this is all government property. He takes it away. That is stealing. And when he is caught, he is arrested, and he is punished. So, similarly, whatever you are collecting—suppose you are drinking a glass of water from the river. Is the river your property?

BOB: No.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Then? It is stealing. You have not created the river. You do not know who is the proprietor. Therefore it is not your property. So, even if you drink a glass of water without knowing to whom it belongs, you are a thief. So you may think, "I am honest," but actually you are a thief. You must remember Kåñëa. "Oh, Kåñëa, it is Your creation, so kindly allow me to drink." This is honesty. Therefore a devotee always thinks of Kåñëa. In all activities: "Oh, it is Kåñëa's." This is honesty. So without Kåñëa consciousness, everyone is a rascal, is a thief, is a rogue, is a robber. These qualifications. Therefore our conclusion is that anyone who does not understand Kåñëa has no good qualifications. Neither is he honest, nor has he knowledge. Therefore he is a third-class man. Is that correct? What do you think, Giriräja?

GIRIRÄJA: [a disciple]: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: This is not dogmatism. This is a fact. [Some time elapses.] So, you have understood what is knowledge and what is honesty?

BOB: I—in a way. In a way.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: And is there another way? [Bob laughs.] Is there any other way? Defy it! [Bob laughs again. Çréla Prabhupäda also laughs.] Another way? Giriräja?

GIRIRÄJA: No.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Is there an alternative? We do not say anything that can be defied by anyone. That experience we have. Rather, we defy everyone: "Any questions?" Till now, Kåñëa has given us protection. In big, big meetings in big, big countries, after speaking I ask, "Any questions?"

BOB: Now, I have none.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: In London, we had—how many days' lectures in that—what is that? Conway Hall?

A DEVOTEE: Twelve days. Conway Hall.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Conway Hall.

A DEVOTEE: Twelve days.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. So after every meeting I was asking, "Any questions?"

BOB: Did you get many questions?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh, yes. Many foolish questions. [Everyone laughs.]

BOB: Let me ask one more question. What is being foolish?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: One having no knowledge is to be considered foolish.

AN INDIAN GENTLEMAN: Prabhupäda, I have one personal question. Can I ask?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

INDIAN GENTLEMAN: Some time ago in Calcutta they observed a week—it was named, "Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Week."

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Mmm. [He gives a quick laugh.] This is another foolishness. They are advertising prevention of cruelty, and they are maintaining thousands of slaughterhouses. You see? That is another foolishness.

INDIAN GENTLEMAN: So I wanted just to ask—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Asking—before you ask, I give you the answer. [All laugh.] That is another foolishness. They are regularly cruel to animals, and they are making a society...

BOB: Maybe this is—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Suppose a gang of thieves has a signboard—"Goodman and Company." You sometimes find such a signboard.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Our landlord in the San Francisco temple was named Goodman.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: The philosophy is that when an animal is not properly nourished, that is cruelty. Therefore instead of allowing it to starve, better to kill it. That is their theory. Is it not?

BOB: Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: They say, "Oh, it is better to kill him than to give him so much pain." That theory is coming in communist countries. An old man—grandfather—is suffering, so better to kill him. And there—in Africa there is a class of men who make a festival by killing their great-grandfathers. Is it not? Yes.

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: They eat them?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. [Çyämasundara laughs.] Yes?

A DEVOTEE: I had an uncle and aunt. They were in the Army. So when they went overseas, they could not take their dog with them. So they said, "The poor dog. He will be so heartbroken not to be with us," so they put him to sleep—killed him.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: In Gandhi's life also, he once killed one calf or some cow. It was suffering very much. So Gandhi ordered, "Instead of letting it suffer, just kill it."

GIRIRÄJA: Yesterday you said that the spiritual master may have to suffer due to the sinful activities of his disciples. What do you mean by sinful activities?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Sinful activities means that you promised, "I shall follow the regulative principles." If you do not follow, that is sinful. That is the promise. Very simple. You break the promise and do nasty things; therefore you are sinful. Is it not?

GIRIRÄJA: Yes. [pause] But there are some things that we're instructed to do...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Hm-m?

GIRIRÄJA: There are other things which we're instructed to do which, even though we try to do, we cannot do perfectly yet.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: How is that? You try to do and cannot do? How is that?

GIRIRÄJA: Like chanting attentively. Sometimes we try to, but—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Well, that is not a fault. Suppose you are trying to do something. Due to your inexperience if you sometimes fail, that is not a fault. You are trying. There is a verse in the Bhägavatam—hm-m—that if a devotee is trying his best but due to his incapability he sometimes fails, Kåñëa excuses him. And in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.30] also it is said:

api cet suduräcäro
bhajate mäm ananya-bhäk

Sometimes not willingly but due to past bad habits—habit is second nature—one does something nonsensical. But that does not mean he is faulty. But he must repent for that—"I have done this." And he should try to avoid it as far as possible. But habit is second nature. Sometimes, in spite of your trying hard, mäyä is so strong that it pushes with pitfalls. That can be excused. Kåñëa excuses. But those who are doing something willingly are not excused. On the strength that I am a devotee, if I think, "Because I am chanting, I may therefore commit all this nonsense, and it will be nullified," that is the greatest offense.

PQPA 8: Advancing in Kåñëa Consciousness

EIGHT
Advancing in Kåñëa Consciousness (an exchange of letters)

Springfield, New Jersey
June 12, 1972

Dear Prabhupäda,

I offer my humble obeisances.

I have been associating with the devotees of the New York temple. With the association of such fine, advanced devotees, I hope that I may make some advancement in Kåñëa consciousness. My fiancee has started to come to the temple and is chanting a little. She knew nothing about Kåñëa consciousness until I wrote her about it from India. Ätreya Åñi has been kind enough to invite us to his home so that we may see an ideal householder life.

I went to Bombay the end of April for termination from the Peace Corps. I was fortunate enough to come down with a minor illness, so that I had to stay in Bombay for two weeks. I spent the time with the advanced and kind devotees at Juhu. Unfortunately you had left five days previously.

I understand so little, but I have faith in the process of Kåñëa consciousness and hope to take to it more and more.

I look forward to Ätreya Åñi's description of the temple in Los Angeles and hope that I may personally hear you in New York.

Thank you for the kindness you have shown to a very undeserving boy.

Sincerely,
Bob Cohen

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
ISKCON Los Angeles
June 16, 1972

Bob Cohen
Springfield, New Jersey

My dear Bob,

Please accept my blessings. I thank you very much for your letter dated June 12, 1972. I have noted the sentiments expressed therein with great pleasure. I am very glad to hear that you are associating with us. I know that you are a very good boy, very intelligent, and your behavior is gentle, so I have all confidence that very quickly Kåñëa will bestow all His blessings upon you, and you will feel yourself becoming perfectly happy in Kåñëa consciousness. One makes his advancement in Kåñëa consciousness by voluntarily giving up his attachment to material nature, or mäyä. Such renunciation is called tapasya. But we are not very willing to perform austerities without good reason; therefore any man with a good scientific and philosophical mind, like your good self, must first appreciate what transcendental knowledge is. If you get knowledge, automatically tapasya will follow, and then you make your advancement in spiritual life. So to get knowledge is the first item for anyone who is hoping to find the perfection of his life. Therefore I advise you to read our books daily as far as possible and try to understand the subject matter from different angles of vision by discussing it frequently with the devotees at the New York temple. In this way you will gradually become convinced, and by your sincere attitude and devotional service you will make progress.

Yes, having some faith in me and in this Kåñëa consciousness process is the first and only requirement for getting actual wisdom. If there is faith, understanding will follow. And as your understanding increases, so will your disgust with the spell of illusory energy. And when you voluntarily give up your entanglements in the material world, then the progress is assured.

I think we are just now typing up the tapes of those conversations we held in Mäyäpur, and we shall be publishing them as a book. It will be called Perfect Questions, Perfect Answers. I shall send you a copy as soon as they are ready to distribute. Meanwhile, I shall be stopping in New York for two or three days on my way to London for the Ratha-yäträ Festival there. I am not yet certain when I shall be arriving in New York, but it will be some time in the early part of July. You may keep in regular contact with Bali Mardana regarding the arrival date, and I shall be very much engladdened to meet with you in New York once again. Again we shall discuss if you have any questions.

Hoping this will meet you in good health and a happy mood,

Your ever well-wisher,
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

PQPA 9: Deciding for the Future

NINE
Deciding for the Future
New York—July 4, 1972

BOB: I received your very kind letter.
ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Oh.
BOB: About a week ago.
ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Now, you are a very intelligent boy. You can try to understand this philosophy. It is very important. For sense gratification people are wasting so much energy. They are not aware of what is going to happen in the next life. There is a next life, but foolish people are ignorant. This life is preparation for the next life. That they do not know. The modern education and its universities are completely in darkness about this simple knowledge. We are changing bodies every moment—that is a medical fact. After leaving this body, we will have to accept another body. How are we going to accept that body? What kind of body? This can also be known. For example, if someone is being educated, one can understand that when he passes his examination, he is going to be an engineer or medical practitioner. Similarly, in this life, you can prepare yourself to become something in the next life.

BARBARA [Bob's wife]: Can we decide what we want to be next life?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, you can decide. We have decided that next life we are going to Kåñëa. This is our decision—back home, back to Godhead. Suppose you want to become educated. After this decision that you are going to be an engineer or you are going to be a medical practitioner, with that objective you prepare and educate yourself. Similarly, you can decide what you are going to do next life. But if you don't decide, then the material nature will decide.

BARBARA: Could I have been Kåñëa conscious in my last life?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: It doesn't matter. But you can become. Take advantage of our Kåñëa consciousness movement.

A DEVOTEE: She's asking if it was possible that in her last life she was a Kåñëa devotee and has come back again.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: When one is perfectly Kåñëa's devotee, he does not come back. But if there is a little deficiency, then there is a possibility of coming back. But even though there is a deficiency, he comes back to a nice family. Çucénäà çrématäà gehe yoga-bhrañöo 'bhijäyate. ["The unsuccessful yogé takes birth in a religious or aristocratic family." Human intelligence can decide for the future. That is human intelligence. The animal cannot decide. We have discriminatory power. If I do this, I will be benefited; if I do that, I will not be benefited. This is there in human life. So you have to use it properly. You should know what is our goal of life and decide in that way. That is human civilization....

BARBARA: Have you ever seen Kåñëa?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

BARBARA: You have?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Daily. Every moment.

BARBARA: But not in the material body?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: He has no material body.

BARBARA: Well, in the temple here they have pictures of Kåñëa....

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That is not a material body. You are seeing materially because you have material eyes. Because you have material eyes, you cannot see the spiritual form. Therefore He kindly appears to be in a material body so that you can see. However, because He has kindly made Himself just fit for your seeing, that does not mean He has a material body. Suppose the President of the United States kindly comes to your house. That does not mean that his position and your position are the same. It is his kindness. Out of love, he may come to your house, but that does not mean he is on the same level as you. Similarly, because we cannot see Kåñëa with our present eyes, Kåñëa therefore appears before us as a painting, as made of stone, as made of wood. And Kåñëa is not different from these paintings and wood because everything is Kåñëa.

BARBARA: After we die, what happens to our spirit?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: You get another body.

BARBARA: Immediately?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes. Just as when you change your apartment: you fix up your new apartment first; then you leave this one and go there.

BARBARA: So do we know what type of body we will get?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, provided you are qualified. Otherwise nature will arrange for it. Those who know—they know what is there. But for those who do not know, nature will arrange things. If you do not know, this means you have not prepared your life, so accidentally, at the time of death, your mentality will create another body, and nature will supply it.

BARBARA: And chanting—what does chanting do?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That you can ask these boys [the devotees]. They will explain.

BOB: If Kåñëa controls everything, how does Kåñëa control a nondevotee?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: By mäyä. Just as the government controls everything. A kingdom is controlled by the king's departments.

BOB: And how does Kåñëa control a devotee?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Just as you control your beloved. For example, if you have a beloved child, you control him for his benefit. If he is going to touch fire, you will immediately tell him, "No, no, my dear child. Don't touch it." So a Kåñëa conscious person, a devotee, is never misled, because Kåñëa is always guiding him, whereas those who are not Kåñëa conscious are in the charge of mäyä, and mäyä will do the needful, as you have seen.

BOB: Is it preset, when we're born, the time that we'll die?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: What?

BOB: Is the time that I'm going to die, and others are going to die, preset before we are born? When I'm born, do I have a certain given life span?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes.

A DEVOTEE: And he cannot change that?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: No, he cannot change it, but Kåñëa can change it.

DEVOTEE: If he commits suicide, is that also preset?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Not preset. That you can do because you have a little independence. It is not natural to commit suicide; it is unnatural. So because we have independence, we can go from nature to "un-nature." A prisoner cannot go out of the prison house naturally, but somehow or other he arranges to jump over the wall and goes away. Then he becomes a criminal for further imprisonment. Naturally, the prisoner cannot go out of the prison house, but if somehow or other he manages to escape, that means he becomes again a criminal. He will be arrested again, and his term of imprisonment will be increased, or he will be punished more. So, naturally we cannot violate destiny. But if we do it, then we will suffer. But our destiny can be changed by Kåñëa when we are Kåñëa conscious. We do not do it, but Kåñëa will do it. Kåñëa says: ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo mokñayiñyämi: "I shall give you protection." That change takes place for my protection.

There are two stages—nondevotee and devotee. The nondevotee is under the control of material nature, and the devotee is under the direct control of Kåñëa. In the office of a big man, an executive of a big company, there are many employees, and they are controlled by different departmental superintendents. But although outside of home he controls indirectly, the same man at home is controlling his children directly. But he is always a controller. Similarly, God is the controller always. When one becomes a devotee, he is controlled by God; when he is a nondevotee, he is controlled by His agent, mäyä. But he has to be controlled. For example, every citizen of America is controlled by the government. When he is all right, the civil department controls him; when he is not all right, the criminal department controls him. But he cannot say, "I am not controlled." That is not possible. Everyone is controlled. If somebody says, "I am not controlled," he is not sane; he is crazy. Everyone is controlled. So either you are controlled directly by God, or you are controlled by His agency, mäyä. Being controlled by mäyä, you spoil your life; you remain in material existence one birth after another, changing your bodies. But if you choose to be controlled by God, then after this body, you go back home, back to Godhead. Then your life is successful. You cannot exist without being controlled; that is not possible. That is intelligence. And that is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä. Bahünäà janmanäm ante jïänavän mäà prapadyate: "After many births of traveling or speculation, one surrenders unto Me." Väsudevaù sarvam iti: "Kåñëa, You are everything. So I have come. Accept me. I am now fully surrendered unto You, and You control me. I am controlled. For so long I have been controlled by these rascals. There is no benefit. I have been controlled by my senses. So under the control of the senses I have served so-called family, society, country, nation—up to serving the dogs. But nothing has given me satisfaction. Therefore now I have good sense; I put myself under Your control. Instead of being controlled by dog, let me be controlled by God." This is Kåñëa consciousness. Have you not seen how a man is controlled by a dog? In the street the dog stops, passes stool, and his master will stand and wait. Is it not? He is passing stool and urine, and the master is thinking, "I am master." But he is being controlled. That is mäyä. He has become servant of the dog, but he is thinking, "I am master." So unless one is Kåñëa conscious, one cannot understand. We can understand that this rascal is being controlled by his dog, but he is thinking that he is the master. We can understand. What do you think? Has he not become controlled by the dog?

BOB: That is so.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: But he is thinking, "I am the master of the dog." A family man is controlled by his wife, his children, by his servants, by everyone, but he is thinking, "I am master." President Nixon is thinking that he is master of his country, but he is controlled. At once he can be dismissed by the public, his servants! And he will take a position, claiming, "I will give you very good service," and "I shall be a first-class servant." Therefore people vote, "All right, you become president." And he is advertising: "Reelect me! Reelect me!" That means he is a servant. But he is thinking, "I am master." That is the position. Mäyä. One who is controlled by mäyä is thinking himself master, but he is a servant. And a devotee never thinks to himself, "I am master," only "I am servant." That is the difference between mäyä and reality. He at least knows: "I am never master. I am always a servant." When a servant is thinking, "I am master," that is called illusion. But when a servant thinks, "I am a servant," that is not illusion. That is mukti, liberation. Because he is not controlled by false thoughts. Try to think about this subject matter. A devotee is never controlled by false thoughts. He knows his position. Svarüpeëa vyavasthitiù. Mukti, liberation, means to be situated in one's own constitutional position. I am a servant. So if I know that I am a servant, that is my liberation. And if I think that I am master, that is bondage. This is the difference between conditioned life and liberated life.

So these Kåñëa conscious devotees are always thinking that they are servants of Kåñëa. Therefore they are all liberated. They do not endeavor for liberation. They are already liberated because they are situated in their constitutional position. They are not artificially thinking, "I am master." Otherwise, everyone is thinking, "I am master." That is illusion. You cannot be master in any state of your life; you must remain a servant. That is your position. When one thinks artificially that he is master, that is his conditioned life. And when one voluntarily surrenders to the supreme master, that is his liberation. A devotee does not try for liberation separately. As soon as he surrenders to Kåñëa or Kåñëa's representative, he is liberated.

BOB: Prabhupäda, people that engage in religions, like these "Jesus freaks" and other people, claim that Jesus is guiding them. Can this be so?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Yes, but they are not taking the guidance. Just like the Christians. Jesus is guiding them, "Thou shalt not kill," but they are killing. Where is the Jesus guidance? Simply saying, "I am guided by Jesus Christ"—will that do? "But I don't care for his words." Is that guidance? Nobody is being guided by Jesus Christ. Their claim is false. It is very hard to find a man who is actually being guided by Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ's guidance is available, but nobody is caring for him. They have taken Jesus Christ as contractor to take up their sins. That is their philosophy. They commit all kinds of sins, and poor Jesus Christ will be responsible. That is their religion. Therefore they say, "We have a very good religion. For all our sinful activities, Jesus Christ will die." So is that good religion? They have no sympathy for Jesus Christ. He died for our sins. Why should we commit sins again? Such a great life has been sacrificed for our sins, so we should be guided by Jesus Christ. But if you take it otherwise—"Ah, we shall go on committing all sins, and Jesus Christ will make a contract to nullify all my sins; I'll simply go to the church and confess and come back and again do all nonsense"—do you think that shows very good intelligence?

BOB: No.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Actually, one who is guided by Jesus Christ will certainly get liberation. But it is very hard to find a man who is actually being guided by Jesus Christ.

BOB: What about the "Jesus freaks," the young people that have joined the Jesus movement? They read the Bible very often, and they try to—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: But violence is against the Bible's injunctions. How can they kill if they are following the Bible?

BOB: I asked one this, and he claimed that Jesus was also eating meat in the Bible.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: That's all right. He may eat anything. He is powerful. But he has ordered, "Thou shalt not kill. You must stop killing." He is powerful. He can eat the whole world. But you cannot compare to Jesus Christ. You cannot imitate Jesus Christ; you have to abide by his order. Then you are guided by Jesus Christ. That is actually obedience. That is explained in the Bhägavata. One who is éçvara, who is empowered, can do anything, but we cannot imitate. We have to abide by his order: "What he says to me, that I will do." You cannot imitate. You say that Jesus Christ ate meat. Admitting that, you do not know in what condition he ate meat. He is himself eating meat, but he is advising others not to kill. Do you think that Jesus Christ was contradicting himself?

BOB: No.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: He cannot do that. That is real faith in him—that he cannot do that. So why has he eaten meat? He knows, but he has asked me not to kill. I have to follow. That is the real system. You are not Jesus Christ; you cannot imitate him. He has sacrificed his life for God. Can you do that? So why shall you imitate Jesus Christ? You are imitating Jesus Christ by eating meat. Why not imitate Jesus Christ and sacrifice your life for spreading God consciousness? What do you think? Yes, when you preach you can say what you think. They are so-called Christians—but what are they doing for God? Just consider the sun. The sun is absorbing urine. Can you drink urine? If you want to imitate the sun—"Oh, here is the sun absorbing urine. Let me drink urine"—can you? Jesus Christ is powerful; he can do everything. But we cannot imitate; we have to simply abide by his order. That is real Christianity. We cannot imitate a powerful man. That is wrong. In our Vedic literature, there was a poison ocean, so people could not find out what to do with it. Then Lord Çiva said, "All right, I'll drink it." So he drank the whole poison ocean and kept it in his throat. Can you drink poison? Not the ocean—just one cup? So how can we imitate Lord Çiva? Lord Çiva never advised that we drink poison. So you have to abide by the advice, not imitate. These LSD and marijuana people say that Lord Çiva used to smoke gaïja. But Lord Çiva drank the whole poisoned ocean. Can you do that? Lord Çiva's instructions should be taken. He says that the best worship is worship of Viñëu. Viñëor ärädhanaà param. [Padma Puräëa] When he was asked by Pärvaté what method of worship is best, then he said, "The best worship is worship of Lord Viñëu [Kåñëa]." There are many demigods, but he recommended Viñëu worship as the best. And better than Viñëu worship is worship of a Vaiñëava. Tadéyänäm—His servants, or those who are in relation to Him. For instance, we are worshiping this plant, tulasé. We are not worshiping all plants, but because this tulasé has a very intimate connection with Kåñëa, Viñëu, we are therefore worshiping her. Similarly, if anything is intimately related with Kåñëa, worship of that thing is better than worship of Viñëu.

BOB: Why is that?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Because Kåñëa will be pleased. Suppose you have a dog and some friends come and pat your dog. [Çréla Prabhupäda makes big patting motions.] You become pleased. You become pleased: "Oh, he is my good friend." You see how they think. We see this—some friend comes and says, "My, what a nice dog you have." [Laughter.] [Some Indian guests enter the room.]

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: Please have some prasäda.

[Çréla Prabhupäda continues speaking with his guests, sometimes in English and sometimes Hindi. It is his last day in New York, and his plane to London is scheduled to leave in only a few hours. Bob has brought a car to drive Çréla Prabhupäda to Kennedy Airport. The devotees are scurrying about, bringing luggage to the car, putting the manuscripts of Çréla Prabhupäda's latest translating work in order, and making other last-minute arrangements.]

ÇYÄMASUNDARA: Everything's ready, Çréla Prabhupäda. The car is waiting for us.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA: So? We can go now? All right. Hare Kåñëa!

PQPA Concluding Words

Concluding Words

On July 19, 1976, His Divine Grace Çréla Prabhupäda accepted my wife and me as his disciples and initiated us with the names Bhaktidevi dasi and Brahmatirtha dasa. As I reflect back on that day, I can see how fortunate I was to have met His Divine Grace and my Godbrothers in the Hare Kåñëa movement.

When I was handed my beads at initiation, I promised to follow the regulative principles and to chant God's names daily. Four years previously, Çréla Prabhupäda had advised me to follow these principles, and within six months, he said, I could be like the other devotees; all unnecessary things (anarthas), such as mundane movies and restaurants, would cease to attract me. "The whole human life is meant for purification," he said. I was interested in being purified, even though I did not really know what purification meant. I had gone to India with the Peace Corps hoping to find a higher level of consciousness. I could not believe that satisfying the senses was the all in all, yet I myself was bound by the senses. Later I could understand that yoga means becoming free from the dictation of the senses.

Upon returning to America, I started graduate school in geology, got married, and became somewhat entangled in domestic responsibilities, but I would very often think of my conversations with Çréla Prabhupäda, and of his instructions. One of his primary instructions was simply to associate with the devotees, and this I gladly did. Devotees are different: by understanding that loving service to the Supreme Lord is the goal of life, they avoid getting caught up in the petty affairs of sense gratification and false ego. Visiting the temple was most refreshing. Gradually, my wife and I became friends with many devotees and wanted somehow to do some service for the movement. I sponsored a Bhakti-yoga club at the university, and our apartment served as a way station for traveling parties of devotees.

As we followed Çréla Prabhupäda's instructions, even our eating became purified. In India I had told Çréla Prabhupäda that I could not offer my food as the devotees do because I did not understand that Kåñëa is God. So he told me simply to thank God for my food before eating. This we did, and finally our devotion matured, and we started actually offering our food to the Supreme Lord. What a wonderful feeling, to be cooking for the Supreme Lord! This actually freed us from the control of the tongue.

Finally, we were ready to become involved fully in temple life. By Kåñëa's grace, I obtained a job near a temple in Texas and began to take part in all the temple programs. In this way, all the anarthas disappeared, just as Çréla Prabhupäda had predicted. It was like having a burden lifted from our shoulders. We were no longer servants of our senses, but servants of God and His devotees. The value of Çréla Prabhupäda's instructions had become clear. A human being is not meant to labor like an ass and enjoy like a dog. Purification means coming to a higher level of consciousness.

Even though I have been initiated, I still admire my Godbrothers' spiritual awareness and wish to advance. Actually, initiation is the beginning.

Brahmatértha dasa Adhikäri
(Bob Cohen)

Houston, Texas
October 16, 1976

His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda appeared in this world in 1896 in Calcutta, India. He first met his spiritual master, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé, in Calcutta in 1922. Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, a prominent devotional scholar and the founder of sixty-four Gauòéya Mathas (Vedic institutes), liked this educated young man and convinced him to dedicate his life to teaching Vedic knowledge. Çréla Prabhupäda became his student, and eleven years later (1933) at Allahabad he became his formally initiated disciple.

At their first meeting, in 1922, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura requested Çréla Prabhupäda to broadcast Vedic knowledge through the English language. In the years that followed, Çréla Prabhupäda wrote a commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä, assisted the Gauòéya Matha in its work and, in 1944, without assistance, started an English fortnightly magazine, edited it, typed the manuscripts and checked the galley proofs. He even distributed the individual copies freely and struggled to maintain the publication. Once begun, the magazine never stopped; it is now being continued by his disciples in the West.

Recognizing Çréla Prabhupäda's philosophical learning and devotion, the Gauòéya Vaiñëava Society honored him in 1947 with the title "Bhaktivedanta." In 1950, at the age of fiftyfour, Çréla Prabhupäda retired from married life, and four years later he adopted the vänaprastha (retired) order to devote more time to his studies and writing. Çréla Prabhupäda traveled to the holy city of Våndävana, where he lived in very humble circumstances in the historic medieval temple of Rädhä-Dämodara. There he engaged for several years in deep study and writing. He accepted the renounced order of life (sannyäsa) in 1959. At Rädhä-Dämodara, Çréla Prabhupäda began work on his life's masterpiece: a multivolume translation and commentary on the eighteen-thousand-verse Çrémad-Bhägavatam (Bhägavata Puräëa). He also wrote Easy Journey to Other Planets.

After publishing three volumes of Bhägavatam, Çréla Prabhupäda came to the United States, in 1965, to fulfill the mission of his spiritual master. Since that time, His Divine Grace has written over forty volumes of authoritative translations, commentaries and summary studies of the philosophical and religious classics of India.

In 1965, when he first arrived by freighter in New York City, Çréla Prabhupäda was practically penniless. It was after almost a year of great difficulty that he established the International Society for Krishna Consciousness in July of 1966. Under his careful guidance, the Society has grown within a decade to a worldwide confederation of almost one hundred äçramas, schools, temples, institutes and farm communities.

In 1968, Çréla Prabhupäda created New Våndävana, an experimental Vedic community in the hills of West Virginia. Inspired by the success of New Våndävana, now a thriving farm community of more than one thousand acres, his students have since founded several similar communities in the United States and abroad.

In 1972, His Divine Grace introduced the Vedic system of primary and secondary education in the West by founding the Gurukula school in Dallas, Texas. The school began with three children in 1972, and by the beginning of 1975 the enrollment had grown to one hundred fifty.

Çréla Prabhupäda has also inspired the construction of a large international center at Çrédhama Mayapur in West Bengal, India, which is also the site for a planned Institute of Vedic Studies. A similar project is the magnificent Kåñëa-Balarama Temple and International Guest House in Våndävana, India. These are centers where Westerners can live to gain firsthand experience of Vedic culture.

Çréla Prabhupäda's most significant contribution, however, is his books. Highly respected by the academic community for their authoritativeness, depth and clarity, they are used as standard textbooks in numerous college courses. His writings have been translated into eleven languages. The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, established in 1972 exclusively to publish the works of His Divine Grace, has thus become the world's largest publisher of books in the field of Indian religion and philosophy. Its latest project is the publishing of Çréla Prabhupädas most recent work: a seventeen volume translation and commentary—completed by Çréla Prabhupäda in only eighteen months—on the Bengali religious classic Çré Caitanya-caritämåta.

In the past ten years, in spite of his advanced age, Çréla Prabhupäda has circled the globe twelve times on lecture tours that have taken him to six continents. In spite of such a vigorous schedule, Çréla Prabhupäda continues to write prolifically. His writings constitute a veritable library of Vedic philosophy, religion, literature and culture.

Glossary

A Note from the Secretary of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness

Dear Reader:
After finishing Perfect Questions, Perfect Answers, you may want to go further in understanding Kåñëa consciousness. You may want to find out more about the Kåñëa conscious philosophy; you may want to practice some of the techniques of bhakti-yoga; you may even want to become a fully Kåñëa conscious devotee. In any case, there's much you can do.

First, we have a virtual library of Kåñëa conscious books. We generally recommend starting off with Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, our spiritual master's translation and commentary for the famous Bhagavad-gétä to which he so often referred in his talks with Bob. After the Gétä comes Çrémad-Bhägavatam, a multivolume work that could be called a postgraduate study for spiritual life. All told, we've published some fifty large books of Kåñëa conscious philosophy, enough to read and study for a whole lifetime. We also have a monthly magazine, Back to Godhead, and records and tape cassettes of transcendental chanting.

If you'd like to meet and talk with devotees and get some firsthand experience of Kåñëa consciousness in action, we have about one hundred centers around the world, most of them in the United States. Generally our centers are in large cities, although we also have some fifteen Kåñëa conscious farm communities for "simple living and high thinking." All of our centers have regular classes every day, feast programs every Sunday, and also special festivals throughout the year. For more specific information, you can write or call the center nearest you. And if you ever travel to India, you can visit our International Center at Çrédhama Mayapura, the holy city where the conversations in this book took place. We also have a wonderful International Center and Guest House in Våndävana, the ancient Indian city of Lord Kåñëa's eternal pastimes.

Of course, wherever you are, you can always take advantage of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Our spiritual master says, "Just chant Hare Kåñëa, and your life will be sublime."

Finally, for any questions at all that you might have about spiritual life in Kåñëa consciousness, please feel free to get in touch with us here at our central office in Los Angeles, and we'll do whatever we can to be of service.

Yours in the service of Kåñëa,
Swarup das Adhikari
Secretary

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness

3764 Watseka Avenue

Los Angeles, California 90034

Telephone: (213)871-0717

EXPAND YOUR AWARENESS

The classics offered below are presented for those seeking inner peace and happiness. They authoritatively show the way to self-realization, and reveal many of the mysteries about God, soul, birth, death and rebirth. The books are written by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, who is gradually being recognized as the leading scholar and authority on Vedic literature and philosophy.

(1) Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

A five thousand year old book of spotless wisdom for man today. It is the most comprehensible, readable and widely read translation of the Gétä in the Western world. Both the practical and intellectual reader will enjoy it, because it reasonably answers many important questions about God, philosophy, science, politics, business, art, labor, education, sexuality and family life. And it conclusively deals with the problems of anxiety, duality, illusion and tension. Ralph Waldo Emerson said, "I owed a magnificent day to the Bhagavad-gétä. It was the first of books; it was as if an empire spoke to us, nothing small or unworthy, but large, serene, consistent, the voice of an old intelligence which in another age and climate had pondered and thus disposed of the same questions which exercise us.
56 fullcolor illustrations 37page index
Glossary of terms and characters
330 pages... $2.95

(2) Beyond Birth and Death

Did you ever wonder whether you could exist apart from your physical body? What actually happens at the time of death? Is there such a thing as reincarnation? In this book you will discover convincing and authoritative answers.
62 pages... $ .95

(3) Perfection of Yoga

An enjoyable introduction to meditation. It gives a lucid explanation of the psychology, techniques and purposes of yoga. And it makes a summary and comparison of the different yoga systems. Dr. Frank Ledworth, University of St. Andrews, said of it, "Most useful for anyone wishing to understand the meaning of yoga."
8 full-color illustrations
56 pages... $ .95

(4) Çré Éçopaniñad

This is one of the famed 108 Upaniñads, ancient classical scriptures that explain the science of selfrealization. Çré Éçopaniñad clearly describes in eighteen illuminating mantras the manifestations and characteristics of God, and man's inseparable relationship with Him. It also provides details on how one may overcome the limitations of modern education, destroy spiritual ignorance, transcend birth and death, achieve immortality, and awaken to Absolute Truth.
8 full-color illustrations
141 pages...$1.95

A Complimentary Copy...

If you order Nos. 1, 2 and 3, you will receive No. 4 without cost. Your satisfaction is assured. Just complete the coupon and mail it today.

The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust PQPA
3764 Watseka Avenue Los Angeles, Ca. 90034
Please rush me postpaid the book numbers I have circled:
1234. I am enclosing $__ in check or money order. If I
wish, I may return the books in 10 days for a complete refund.
Name__________________________
Address________________________
City_____________________
State____________________
ZIP__________


A True Account
A search for meaning carries a young American Peace Corps worker halfway around the world, to an ancient city in the midst of West Bengal. There, in a small bamboo house in the holy land of Mayapur, he finds himself at the feet of one of India's greatest saintly teachers, a teacher who seems able to tell him anything he ever wanted to know....


Transcendental Teachings of Prahläda Mahäräj

JOIN US!

We welcome everyone to join the ISKCON ashram at Hare Krishna Land and thus perfect his life by cultivating pure devotional service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Anyone of any caste, color or creed can be admitted into the ashram free of charge, and he will also receive food, clothing and shelter as he requires. All devotees, be they old or new, follow the same devotional principles, including:

(1) No eating of meat, fish or eggs
(2) No intoxication including coffee, tea and cigarettes
(3) No illicit connection with women, and
(4) No gambling

In addition, the devotees rise early in the morning, bathe, don fresh cloth, and attend a morning programme of mangala arati, prayer, Tulasi worship, class, and guru puja of the ashram's founder-acharya, His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, and His successors. The peaceful and serene atmosphere of Hare Krishna Land creates an ideal setting for those who seek the ultimate perfection of lifeservice and devotion to God.

Please write or contact AMOGHALILA DAS
BRAHMACHARY AT ISKCON, HARE KRISHNA
LAND, JUHU, BOMBAY400 049 NOW.
Hare Krishna!

1.The Dearmost Person

[What follows is based on a series of talks Çréla Prabhupäda gave in 1968 on the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Canto 7, Chapter 6.]

Today I shall speak before you of the history of a boy devotee. His name is Prahläd Mahäräj, and he was born in a family which was stubbornly atheistic. There are two kinds of men in this world; one is called the demon, and the other is called the demigod. What is the difference between them? The main difference is that the demigods or godly persons are devoted to the Supreme Lord, whereas the demons are atheistic. They do not believe in God because they are materialists. These two classes of men always exist in this world. At the present moment, due to this age of Kali (Quarrel), the number of demons has increased, but the classification has existed since the beginning of creation. This incident which I am narrating to you occurred very, very long ago, a few million years after the time of creation.

This boy Prahläd Mahäräj happened to be the son of the most atheistic person and the most materially powerful as well—so you will be interested to hear this history. Because the society was materialistic, this boy had no opportunity to glorify the Supreme Lord. The characteristic of a great soul is that he is very eager to broadcast glorification of the Supreme Lord. Lord Jesus Christ, for example, was very much eager to broadcast the glorification of God, but demoniac people misunderstood him and crucified him.

Prahläd Mahäräj was a five-year-old boy, and, when he was in school, as soon as there was a recreation period, when the teacher was off, he would say to his friends, "My dear friends, come on. We shall speak about Kåñëa consciousness." I am just opening a scene. This is Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Seventh Canto, Sixth Chapter. The devotee Prahläd is saying, "My dear boys, my dear friends, this is the time, in this young age, to prosecute Kåñëa consciousness." Before that, he had held discussions with his little friends, but they said, "Oh, we shall now play. Why take up Kåñëa consciousness?" In answer to this, Prahläd Mahäräj is stating, "If you are intelligent, then you must begin Kåñëa consciousness from childhood!"

Çrémad-Bhägavatam offers bhägavata-dharma, or scientific knowledge about God. Bhägavatam means the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and dharma means the regulative principles of understanding Kåñëa consciousness. This human form of life is very rare. It is a great opportunity. Therefore, Prahläd says, "My dear friends, you are born as civilized human beings, so this is the greatest opportunity." Although it is temporary—I do not know what is the length of my life—it is calculated that in this age the human body is meant to exist not more than a hundred years. But as the age of Kali advances, duration of life, memory, mercy, religiousness and all other such assets decrease.

Although it is temporary, you can achieve the highest perfection of life while in this human form. Why is this so important? This is the opportunity—you can understand the Supreme Lord, the all-pervading Lord. For other life forms this is not possible. By the gradual evolutionary process we come to this plane, so this is the opportunity, this human form of life. By nature's law, a human body is ultimately given to you so that you can promote yourself to the spiritual life and go back home, back to Godhead.

The ultimate goal of life is Viñëu. In another verse, Prahläd Mahäräj will say: "People who are in this material world, enamored by the material energy, do not know what the goal of human life is." Why? They have been enchanted by the glaring external energy. They have forgotten that they are spiritual energy. This is explained later on, but here he says, "This life is an opportunity to understand the ultimate goal of perfection, Viñëu." Why should we be very anxious to know Viñëu, or God? Prahläd Mahäräj gives a reason: "Viñëu is the dearmost person. That we have forgotten." We all seek for some dear friend—everyone searches in this way. A man searches for dear friendship in woman, and woman searches for dear friendship in man. Or else a man searches in man, and woman searches in woman. Everyone searches after some dear friend, some sweet friend. Why? We want the cooperation of a dear friend who will help us. This is part of the struggle for existence, and this is natural. But we do not know that our most dear friend is Viñëu, the Supreme parcel of the Supreme Lord." That is the platform of real understanding. Personality of Godhead. We are searching after some dear friend, but we do not know who this dear friend can be.

Those who have read Bhagavad-gétä will find this nice verse in the Fifth Chapter: "If you make friendship with Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, then you can understand perfectly that everything that exists in this world or other worlds is all the property of Kåñëa. He is the proprietor and enjoyer of everything." Why are you performing austerity? Why are you performing religious rituals? Why are you giving in charity? Why do you engage in righteous activities? Whatever formulas you have manufactured are meant for pleasing the Supreme Lord, and nothing more. By your actions, by your righteous activities, when the Supreme Lord is pleased, you will get the result. If by your actions you want to gain either material happiness or spiritual happiness, if you want to live on this planet or on other planets, if you want to be a human being or you want to be a tiger, cat or dog, whatever you like you will get. Therefore He is the most sincere friend. Whatever you want from Him, you can get. But the intelligent man does not want anything that is materially contaminated.

In Bhagavad-gétä you will find that Kåñëa says that one can elevate oneself to the highest planet, which is known as Brahmaloka, where the duration of life is millions and millions of years. You cannot figure the duration of life there; your arithmetic will be ineffective. The statement in Bhagvad-gétä is that Brahmä's life is so long that 4,200,000 years make one day to him. Kåñëa says, "Whatever position you want, beginning from the ant right up to Brahmä, you can have. But the repetition of birth and death will be there. However, if, somehow or other, by discharging Kåñëa consciousness in devotional service, you come to Me, then you don't have to come back again to this miserable material condition."

Prahläd Mahäräj said the same thing: We are searching for the most dear friend, Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord. Why is He the most dear friend? By nature He is dear. What is the dear most thing within yourself? Have you analyzed? You are yourself the dearmost thing. I am sitting here, but if there is a fire alarm I shall at once take care of myself: "How can I save myself?" We forget our friends and even our children: "Let me first of all save myself." Self-preservation is the first law of nature.

Ätmä, self, in the grossest sense refers to the body. In the subtler sphere the mind is ätmä, and in the real sense ätmä means the soul. In the gross stage we are very fond of protecting the body, and in a subtler stage we are very fond of protecting the mind. But above this mental, intellectual plane, where the atmosphere is spiritualized, we can understand: "I am not this mind and not this body. Aham brahmäsmi—I am a part and and parcel of the Supreme Lord." That is the platform of real understanding.

Prahläd Mahäräj says that of all living entities, Viñëu is the supreme well-wisher. Therefore we are all searching for Him. When a child cries, what does he long for? He longs for the mother. But he has no language to express this. By nature, he has his body, born of the mother's body, so there is an intimate relation with the mother's body. The child won't like any other woman. The child cries, but when the woman who is the child's mother comes and picks him up, at once he is pacified. He has no language to express all this, but the real demand is there. Similarly, we are trying to protect the body. This is self-preservation. It is a natural law of the living entity, just as eating is a natural law and sleeping is a natural law. I defend the body because within the body there is soul.

What is this soul? The soul is a part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. As we want to protect the hand or the finger because it is a part of the whole body, similarly we try to save ourselves because this is the defending process of the Supreme. The Supreme does not need defense, but this is a manifestation of our love towards Him, which is now perverted. The finger and the hand are meant to act in the interests of the whole body; as soon as I want the hand to come here, it comes, and as soon as I want the finger to play on the drum, it plays. This is the natural position. Similarly, we are searching for God, to dovetail our energy for the Supreme, but, under the spell of illusory energy, we do not know it. That is our mistake.

Now, here is an opportunity, in human life. You have come to understand about Kåñëa consciousness, about your real goal of life, because you are human beings. I cannot invite cats and dogs to sit down here. That is the difference between cats and dogs and human beings. A human being can understand the necessity of life. If he loses the opportunity, it is a great catastrophe.

Prahläd Mahäräj said, "God is the dearmost personality of all. We have to search for God." Then what about the material necessities of life? Prahläd Mahäräj replies to this, "You are after sense gratification. I know that. Sense gratification is automatically achieved by contact with this body." Because a hog has a certain type of body, his sense gratification comes from eating stool, the very thing which is most obnoxious to you. At once, after evacuating, you leave to get free from the bad smell—but the hog is waiting. As soon as you evacuate, he will at once enjoy. Other animals are not attracted because one's form of pleasure-seeking is due to his particular body. There are different types of sense gratification according to different types of bodies. Therefore, Prahläd says, "My dear friends, sense gratification is achieved according to one's particular type of body." Everyone who has a material body receives sense gratification. Don't think that the hogs eating stools are unhappy. No, they are getting fat in that way. They are very happy.

Now, if a hog can achieve sense gratification, why not a human being? But that is not our achievement. That is given by nature; the facilities of a hog's body are offered by nature, and the facilities of a dog's body are also offered by nature, or God. Why should you labor for facilities which you are destined to receive anyway, by nature's law? In every form of life the bodily demands are satisfied by the arrangement of nature. This gratification is arranged, just as there is an arrangement for distress. Do you like fever? No. Why does it come? I do not know. But it does come, does it not? Yes. Did you try for it? No. So how does it come? By nature. That is the only answer. Similarly, if miseries come by nature, your happiness will also come by nature. Don't bother about it. That is the instruction of Prahläd Mahäräj. If you can receive the miseries of life without effort, similarly, you can have your happiness also without effort.

Then, what is the real purpose of this human form of life? You have to cultivate Kåñëa consciousness. Other things will be obtained by nature's law, or God's law. Even if I don't try, whatever I am to achieve because of my past work and my particular type of body will be supplied. At any stage or in any form of life, facility is given for sense gratification. As you do not try for misery, so also happiness will take place without your control. Your real concern, therefore, should be to seek out the higher goal of human life.

PRAHLAD MAHARAJ was a boy devotee—a born sage, who, at only five years of age, used to speak to his school friends thus:—

"My dear friends, now is the time to prosecute Krishna Consciousness, while we are still young (or at least young at heart) unless we start immediately we'll never get out of the sufferings of the material entanglement......... So please at once take up the chanting of—


HARE KRISHNA HARE KRISHNA KRISHNA KRISHNA HARE HARE
HARE RAMA HARE RAMA RAMA RAMA HARE HARE.

2."We Are Spoiling Our Lives!"

Prahläd Mahäräj instructs his young friends: "My dear friends, material enjoyment involves agitating the senses. You have this material sense enjoyment, my dear friends, and your only thought is how to enjoy these senses. That's all." In possession of a particular body, we have particular senses, and we enjoy. For example, a camel enjoys thorny twigs. Why? Camels are very fond of thorny twigs because when they chew the twigs, blood comes out of the tongue, and they taste their own blood. The camel thinks this is very nice. He eats thorny twigs, the twigs cut his tongue, and blood oozes out. He tastes his own blood, but he thinks, "I am enjoying." This is sense gratification. Sex life is also like that. We taste our own blood, and we think we are enjoying. This is our foolishness.

The living entity who has contacted this material body is a spiritual being, but because he has a tendency to enjoy, to exploit this material energy, he has contacted a body. There are 8,400,000 species of living entities, each with a different body, and according to the body, they have particular senses in order to enjoy a particular type of pleasure. Prahläd Mahäräj says that this body and its particular type of enjoyment go together. Suppose you are given thorny grass or twigs: "Ladies and gentlemen, here is very nice food. It is certified by the camels. It is very good." Would you like to take it? "No! What nonsense are you offering me?" Because you have a different body, you have no taste for that. But if you offer it to a camel, because of his particular body, it is a very nice meal.

One man's food is another man's poison. If one is offered something which is not his food, he cannot take it. The stool-eating hog will not accept nice foodstuffs such as cake. Give him stool, and it will be very nice. But if you are offered the stool, because you have a different body you will say, "What are you offering?"

There are different kinds of material enjoyment, but those who are actually intelligent know that such enjoyment is due to the body. Actual happiness, however, is that which is not enjoyed by material senses but by the spiritual senses. Because we are spirit, we have spiritual senses. Now these are covered by matter, and therefore we are entrapped. Therefore, you should not endeavor to achieve material happiness. It will come. The lower animals have no business profession, but still they eat and live. So Prahläd Mahäräj says, "You need not endeavor for material pleasure. That will come. Because you have a body, it is predestined that bodily enjoyment—as you are fit to enjoy it—will come. If misery comes without our calling for it, so happiness will come without our calling for it.

Therefore, we should not be very anxious to aggravate our senses to increase material happiness. In any civilization, those who have no spiritual happiness always hanker after sense enjoyment. Prahläd Mahäräj says, "Your life is limited. Although it is very valuable, it is also very limited. And our duty is to dovetail ourselves in some way in Kåñëa consciousness and to act accordingly. You should not try to increase your material sense enjoyment. You cannot increase it. There are so many different kinds of bodies, and they are guided by nature's law: you have to eat like this, you have to live like this, you have to sleep like this. It has already been arranged."

Our higher intelligence comes with this human body. Because we have higher consciousness, we should try for the higher enjoyment in life, which is spiritual enjoyment. And how can that spiritual enjoyment be achieved? You should not waste your time simply hankering for material pleasure. Then, what is to be done? One should absorb himself in serving the Supreme Lord, who gives the pleasure of liberation. We should turn our attention to achieving the lotus feet of Kåñëa, who can give us liberation from this material world.

How long do we have to engage ourselves? Prahläd Mahäräj says, "We are now in material entanglement. Now I have this body, I will quit this body after a few years, and then I will have to accept another body. Once you take up one body and enjoy as your body's senses dictate, you prepare another body by such sense enjoyment, and you get another body as you want it." There is no guarantee that you will get a human body. That will depend on your work. If you worked just like a demigod, you get a demigod's body. And if you worked just like a dog, then you get a dog's body. This is not in your hands; it is in the hand of nature. Our duty is not to speculate on what we are going to get next. At the present moment, let us understand that we have this material body. Now, if we want to develop our spiritual consciousness or Kåñëa consciousness, then we should at once engage ourselves in this Kåñëa activity. That is auspicious for further progress.

How long should you do it? As long as this body does not stop working. We do not know when it will stop functioning. The great saint Parékñit Mahäräja got seven days notice: "Your body will fall in a week." But we do not know when our body will fall. As soon as we are on the road, there may immediately be some accident. We should always be prepared. Death is always there. We should not optimistically think, "Everyone is dying, I shall live." Why will you live if everyone is dying? Your father has died, your mother has died, your sister, your other relatives—why should you live? You will also die. And your children will also die. Therefore, before death comes, as long as we have this human intelligence, let us engage in Kåñëa consciousness. This is the prescription of Prahläd Mahäräj.

This material body is called puruñam. Everyone is anxious to enjoy. Puruña means to enjoy, or the enjoyer. There is no one in this material world who does not like to enjoy sense gratification. Therefore, the body may be what it is—either male or female—but the desire, the ambition, is to enjoy material life. So the body is called puruñam.

We do not know when this body will stop, but let us immediately engage in Kåñëa consciousness and act accordingly. "But if I immediately engage myself in Kåñëa consciousness, what about my living?" That is arranged for. I am very happy to inform you of the confidence of a student in one of our branches. There was a disagreement. One student said, "You are not looking after how to maintain the establishment," and he replied, "Oh, Kåñëa will supply."This is a very nice conviction; I was glad to hear it. If cats and dogs and hogs can get food, and if we are going to be Kåñëa conscious and fully devote our service to Kåñëa, will He not arrange for our food also? Is Kåñëa ungracious? No.

In Bhagavad-gétä you will find that the Lord says, "My dear Arjuna, I am equal to everyone. No one is the object of My envy, and no one is My special friend, but for one who engages in Kåñëa consciousness, I have special attention." If a small child is completely dependent on the mercy of his parents, the parents have special attention for that child. Although the parents are equally good to all the children, for the small children who are always crying, "Mother!" they have great concern. "Yes, my dear child? Yes?" This is natural.

If you are completely dependent on Kåñëa, who is supplying food to the dogs, birds, bees—to 8,400,000 species of life—why should He not supply to you? This conviction is called surrender. But we should not think, "Because Kåñëa is supplying my food, I shall now sleep." No, you have to work, but without fear. One should engage himself in Kåñëa consciousness.

Now calculate our duration of life. In this age it is calculated that we can live at most to a hundred years. Formerly, a human being used to live up to 100,000 years. In the Satya Yuga, or age of Goodness, they used to live 100,000 years. In the next age, Treta Yuga, they used to live for 10,000 years, and in the next, called Dväpara Yuga, they used to live for 1,000 years. Now, in this age, called Kali Yuga, the estimation is for decreases still further. Anyone can understand this. Suppose my grandfather lived 100 years, and my son is going to live for fifty years, and his son is going to live for thirty years. This is the progress of our modern civilization. We are very proud that we are happy and are improving our civilization. The result, however, is that we try to enjoy material life, but the duration of our life is shortened. This is called mäyä, illusion.

Now, accepting that we live for 100 years, the duration of life is reduced for those who have no information of spiritual life, who have not conquered sense enjoyment, or who are unable to control the mind. The lifetime of those who are too much addicted to sense gratification, according to this calculation, is at the utmost fifty years. Even if one has fifty years, if he has no information of spiritual life, his night is wasted in sleeping and sex life. That's all. He has no other interest. And in the daytime, what is his concern? "Where is money? Where is money? I must maintain this body." And when he has money: "Now let me spend for my wife and children." Then where is his spiritual realization? At night he spends his time in this way, and by day he spends time in that way. Is that his mission in life? How horrible such a life is.

The average person is illusioned in childhood—playing football and sporting. Up to twenty years, easily, you can go on like that. Then when you become old, for another twenty years you cannot do anything. When a man becomes old, his senses cannot function. You have seen many old men; they have nothing to do but rest. Just now we have received a letter from one of our students that his grandmother is paralyzed and has been suffering for the last three and a half years. So, in old age, everything is finished as soon as you are sixty years old. Therefore, from the beginning to twenty years of age, everything is spoiled; and even if you live for a hundred years, another twenty in the last stage of life is also spoiled. So forty years of your life are spoiled in that way. And in the middle age there is a very strong sex appetite, so another twenty years can be lost. Twenty years, twenty years, and twenty years—sixty years gone. How long are you going to live?

This is the analysis of life by Prahläd Mahäräj. We are spoiling our life instead of using it.

3.Family Illusion

Prahläd Mahäräj told his friends, "You have to begin Kåñëa consciousness immediately." All the boys were born of atheistic, materialistic families, but fortunately Prahläd was a great devotee of the Lord from his birth. Whenever he found an opportunity, when the teacher was out of the room, he used to speak: "My dear friends, this is the time. This is the time to begin Kåñëa consciousness."

Now, as we have stated, someone might have said, "But we are just boys. Let us play. We are not going to die immediately. Let us have some enjoyment, and then we shall begin Kåñëa consciousness." People do not know that Kåñëa consciousness is the highest enjoyment. They think that the boys who have joined this Kåñëa consciousness movement are foolish. "They have left everything, and by Prabhupäda's influence they have joined." But actually this is not so. They are all intelligent, educated boys, coming from very respectable families; they are not fools. They are actually enjoying life, otherwise they would not have spared their valuable time for this movement.

Actually there is joyful life, but people do not know. They say, "What is this Kåñëa consciousness?" When one grows into the sense gratification process, it is very difficult to get out of it. Therefore, according to Vedic regulations, in student life, beginning from five years of age, boys are taught about spiritual life. That is called brahmacarya. A brahmacäré is one who has dedicated his life for supreme Kåñëa consciousness or Brahman consciousness. He is called a brahmacäré. He is always situated in the Supreme (Brahman).

Brahmacarya has so many rules and regulations: according to brahmacäré regulations, however rich one's father may be, one should be trained by the brahmacäré system, under the guidance of a spiritual master, and he should work in the asrama of the spiritual master just like a menial servant. How is this possible? We are getting actual experience that very nice boys coming from very respectable families do not hesitate to do any work here. They are washing dishes, cleansing floors—everything. One student's mother was astonished at her boy when he visited home. Before, he would not even go to the store, and now he is engaged twenty-four hours a day. Unless one feels pleasure, how is it possible that he can engage himself in such a process as Kåñëa consciousness? This is only due to Hare Kåñëa. This is our single asset—Hare Kåñëa. One can be very jolly, simply by Kåñëa consciousness. Actually there is joyful life. But unless one is trained, one cannot live it.

Prahläd Mahäräj says that everyone is attached to family affection. If one is attached to family affairs, he cannot control his senses. Naturally, everyone wants to love. Society, friendship and love are needed. They are demands of the spirit soul, but they are being pervertedly reflected. Generally, I have seen that many ladies and gentlemen in your country have no family life, but they have placed their love in cats and dogs. Because he or she wants to love someone but does not see anyone suitable to his desire, he therefore prefers to place his valuable love in cats and dogs. Our concern is just to transfer the love—which has to be placed somewhere—to Kåñëa. This is Kåñëa consciousness. If you transfer the love to Kåñëa, that is perfection. But, because we do not know where to place our love, being frustrated and cheated, we at last place our love in cats and dogs. Everyone is entangled by this material, perverted love.

It is very difficult to develop spiritual life when one is advanced in material love. It is very difficult because this bondage of love is very strong. Therefore, Prahläd's proposition was that one should learn Kåñëa consciousness immediately from childhood. When a boy is five or six years old, he is sent to school to be trained. When he is too young it is not possible for him to go to school, but as soon as his consciousness is developed, he is sent for education. Prahläd Mahäräj says that one's education should be Kåñëa Conscious, and it should begin immediately. When one is between the ages of five to fifteen years, he is considered a boy. After sixteen years one becomes a young man. He goes on to forty years, and then after forty years he is elderly; then, after sixty years, he is an old man. Prahläd Mahäräj says that one should be taught Kåñëa consciousness from the beginning, from five to fifteen years of age. This is a very valuable time; you can train any boy in Kåñëa consciousness, and he will be perfect.

When one becomes a little more advanced in materialism, it is difficult to develop spiritual life. What is materialism? Materialism means that everyone of us in this material world, although we are spirit soul, somehow or other wants to enjoy this material world. Don't try to find out when it began, but actually that is the situation. This world is meant for enjoyment. Enjoyment is already present in my spirit soul, but we have come here to partake of contaminated enjoyment, just like a man who is on the Bowery and thinks he's enjoying. Some animals enjoy by eating stool. According to the body, we have different kinds of enjoyment. The basic principle of enjoyment is sex life. Therefore, you will find sex life not only in human society, but in cat society, dog society, bird society—everywhere. During daytime, a pigeon has sex at least twenty times. This is his enjoyment. The basic principle of material life is sex life.

Çrémad-Bhägavatam says that material enjoyment is based upon nothing more than the combination of man and woman in sex life. In the beginning a boy thinks, "Oh, that girl is nice," or the girl says, "That boy is nice. And when they meet, that material contamination becomes more prominent. My heart is already attached to material enjoyment, but as soon as I actually enjoy it, it becomes more attached, completely attached. How? As soon as a boy and girl are married, they want an apartment. Then, to maintain that apartment, they need some income. Then, when there is income, they want to have children. Then when they have children, they want social recognition—society, friendship and love. This goes on increasing. Everything requires money: where is money? A man who is too materialistic will cheat anyone, kill anyone, beg, borrow or steal—anything to bring money. He knows that his buildings, his family, his wife and children cannot continue to exist here. They are just like bubbles in the ocean: they have come into existence, and after a little while they will be gone. But he is too much attached. He will sacrifice his spiritual advancement in life for this. His perverted consciousness—"I am this body. I belong to this material world. I belong to this country. I belong to this community. I belong to this religion."—becomes greater and greater.

Where is his Kåñëa consciousness? He becomes so entangled that money becomes more valuable to him than his own life. He can risk even his own life for money. Everyone is trying to get money. Who? The householder, the laborer, the merchant, the thief, the dacoit, the rogue. What is the distinction? Everyone is after money. This is called illusion. One loses himself in the midst of this entanglement.

Prahläd Mahäräj says that in this state, when you are too much implicated in materialism, you cannot at once begin Kåñëa consciousness. Of course, Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu is so kind that even if you have missed the chance to become Kåñëa conscious in your childhood, it is better late than never. If you do understand, then begin immediately in whatever position you are. Even though you missed the opportunity to begin Kåñëa consciousness from childhood, begin now. That is Caitanya Mahäprabhu's teaching. He never said, "Because you did not begin Krishna consciousness from your childhood. you cannot make progress." No. He is very kind. He has given us this nice process of chanting: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Whether you are a young man or an old man—no matter what you are—just begin. You do not know when your life will be finished. If you begin sincerely, even for a moment, it will have great effect. It will save you from the greatest danger.

Although only five years old, Prahläd Mahäräj speaks just like a very experienced man because he received experience from his spiritual master, That will be disclosed later. Experience should not be derived from age, but from knowledge received from a superior source. One cannot become a wise man simply by advancement of age. No. That is not possible. Knowledge has to be received from a superior source. It doesn't matter whether he is a five-year-old boy or a fifty-year-old man. In Sanskrit this is phrased: "One becomes an old man without age."

He is only five years old; how can he become an old man? One becomes old by advancement in knowledge. Prahläd Mahäräj is speaking just like an old man. Suppose a man is already married and Prahläd says, "You take to Kåñëa consciousness." He will think, "Oh, how can I leave my wife? We talk so nicely together, sit together and enjoy. How can I leave?" It is a very strong combination.

I am an old man, seventy-two years old. I have been away from my family during the last fourteen years. Yet sometimes I also think of my wife. This is quite natural. But that does not mean that I have to go back. This is knowledge. One should at once understand: this is illusion. According to the Vedic system, one has to forcibly give up family life at the age of fifty. One must go. There is no alternative. The first twenty-five years are for student life. From five years to twenty-five years, one should be educated very nicely in Kåñëa consciousness. The whole basic principle should be Kåñëa conscious, nothing else. Then life will be successful. Life will be pleasing and successful, both in this world and in the next. For twenty years, from five to twenty-five, a boy should be trained. Kåñëa consciousness necessitates giving up material consciousness altogether. That is called perfect Kåñëa consciousness. But if someone is not able to capture the essence of Kåñëa consciousness, then he is allowed to have a good wife, be married, and live a peaceful householder life. And, because he has the basic principle of Kåñëa consciousness, he will not entangle himself in the material world. If one lives a simple life—plain living and high thinking—he can progress and can cultivate the same Kåñëa consciousness even within the family.

So family life is not condemned. But if a man forgets his spiritual identity and simply becomes entangled in material affairs, then he is lost. His life's mission is lost. If one thinks, "I cannot protect myself from the attack of mäyä," then let him be married. That is prescribed. We don't have illicit sex life. If you want a girl, if you want a boy, get married. Live in Kåñëa consciousness.

A person who is trained from the very beginning naturally becomes disinclined toward the material way of life, and at the age of fifty he gives it up. How do you start giving it up? That is also a concession: the husband and wife leave the children. If from twenty-five to fifty he remains in family life, he must have some grown-up children. So he entrusts all his family affairs to them. According to the Vedic system, a boy is married at the age of twenty, and a girl is married at twelve years. So, family affairs are entrusted to some of the boys who are family men, and the husband and wife go on pilgrimages to try to forget these attachments. When the gentleman is completely matured, he asks his wife to go home to his children, and he remains alone. That is the system. Otherwise, if we remain attached to material consciousness, then we will not perfect our Kåñëa consciousness. So we have to give ourselves a chance, step by step. Otherwise, if we become too materially complicated, we shall miss the opportunity of this human form of life.

Family life means that we have very loving children, and we are loved. We attract, our wife talks very nicely, and we give very nice instructions. "You do this. You do that." Thus we enjoy life. But we do not know that this enjoyment is false. We are standing on a false platform. At once, in the twinkling of an eye, we may have to give this up. Death is not under our control. From Bhagavad-gétä we learn that if one dies while too much attached to one's wife, the result will be that he will get his next life as a female. And if the wife is very attached to the husband, it is for her benefit; she gets her next life as a man. Therefore, according to the Vedic system, chastity is greatly stressed. This has nothing to do with Kåñëa consciousness; it is simply a matter of ending material consciousness. If a woman is chaste and simply thinks of one man, then the result will be that she will get a man's body in the next life. Similarly, if you are not a family man but are attached to a cat or dog, then your next life will be as a cat or dog. That is also a fact. It is better to love a woman and be attached to her. It is better to have a woman's body than to have a cat's or dog's body. These are the rules of karma, or material nature.

The whole point is that one should begin. If one thinks, "After finishing my sporting life, when I am old and there is nothing else to do, then I shall go to the Krishna Consciousness Society and hear something," at that time one can go, but one should have the opportunity now and should utilize one's life from the very beginning. Therefore, this Society's main object is to give everyone a chance to begin Kåñëa consciousness at any stage. And, by this process of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, it is very quick. There is an immediate result.

We shall request all the ladies and gentlemen who are very kindly attending our lectures or reading our literature to go home, and at your leisure hour, dance and chant, or read our books. You will find it very nice. That is our request. That is what our Society is spreading.

4.I Love Kåñëa More Than Anything!

Now Prahläd Mahäräj makes a further statement about the complications of material life. We must always remember that Kåñëa consciousness is not a method for criticizing household life. Household life is recommended, but under the condition that one should not forget about his spiritual advancement in life. The difficulty is that in the material concept of life we forget our spiritual ideal. We should, therefore, be very cautious in dealing with the materialistic world. Because our position is forgetfulness, there are so many regulations on how to become a householder, how to become a brahmacäré and how to execute the renounced order of life.

So we have to revive our Kåñëa consciousness, which is the privilege of this human form. If we fail to revive our Kåñëa consciousness, then we miss the highest opportunity. We should always remember that. Prahläd Mahäräj's position is that one should learn Kåñëa consciousness from one's childhood. Why? If we do not practice Kåñëa consciousness from childhood, in the advanced stage of materialistic life we may be completely forgetful. Although in his childhood he preached in this way, Prahläd Mahäräj himself was a householder, but he was a cautious householder. It is not harmful to become a householder and live with family, children and wife, but one should not forget his spiritual advancement—he should be Kåñëa conscious.

Prahläd Mahäräj always reminds us that if we do not practice, if we do not know what the aim of our human form of life is, then we will miss the opportunity for perfection. That is the point. Here it is said that if you do not practice, if you do not know Kåñëa consciousness from childhood, it is very difficult later, when you are materially advanced. There is a very simple example: if a boy is not educated from childhood, it is not possible when he is advanced in age. I have actual experience of this. A father and a daughter both took a B.A. examination, and the daughter came out successful while the father failed. In the advanced stage of life it is no longer possible to absorb any sort of education. If in our advanced stage we sit down for the matriculation examination, we shall fail, and a boy of fourteen will pass. Therefore Prahläd Mahäräj warns that everyone should learn the importance of the science of Godhead from childhood. Otherwise, when one is complicated in family life, it will be impossible. Of course for this age, as I have already explained, Kåñëa consciousness is easily obtainable by the process of chanting. Generally, however, in the advanced stage of life it is very difficult to have any sort of education.

Prahläd also gives another picture. First of all, the attraction for wife has already been explained. Now he explains the attraction for children. It is customary in the Vedic system that a daughter is given in charity to the son-in-law at the age of twelve or thirteen years. At that time she goes to her father-in-law's house. Her father thinks, "Oh, how can she go?" She is always on her father's mind, and he also thinks of his brother, his old father—all these complications. Similarly, Arjuna was thinking, "How am I to kill my grandfather? How is this possible?" These family relationships and family affections are very predominant, and they are all impediments to becoming Kåñëa conscious. We have to be very cautious that our family affections do not overcloud our Kåñëa consciousness. We should always know that the family relationships of this material world are simply a perverted reflection of the real relationships in the spiritual world. This family is false—not exactly false, but temporary. It is temporary, but we are eternal; we should not be misled by temporary affection. That is being explained here. Sometimes we are strongly attached to our nicely decorated apartments and nicely made dresses. We think, "How shall I leave these?" This is the materialistic way of life—there is no end to it.

Here is a very nice example. The silk worm entangles itself in its own saliva, and when the imprisonment is finally made, the silk merchants go there and take the silk prison house of the worm and remove the silk. Before the worm comes out, the silk merchant takes the cell, otherwise, if the silk worm cuts its way out, there is no silk. In the same way, our entanglement becomes so tight that we cannot come out of this cell of family attraction. Even though there are so many miseries in the materialistic way of life, we cannot break free. Why? We think that sex life and palatable eating are very nice. Therefore, in spite of so many miserable conditions, we cannot give them up.

In this way, when one is too much entangled in family life, one cannot think of his real benefit—to escape from material life. He becomes entangled. Although he is always disturbed by the threefold miseries of materialistic life, still because there is family affection he cannot come out. He does not know that he is spoiling his limited duration of life simply for the affection of family. He is spoiling the life that was meant for realizing his eternal self, for realizing his real spiritual life. But, since he is entangled in such family affection, he does not understand what he is doing. If we inquired of every family man, or anyone, whether or not he is happy in his material way of life, everyone will say, "I am not happy." But still, no one can cease material activities. Why? Because everyone has become entangled. Although one is unhappy, he does not express that unhappiness. Why? He is expected to maintain the family which he has created. His only affection is maintenance of the family, and he becomes more and more entangled. Even if one is educated, due to that affection one commits so many sinful activities.

Prahläd Mahäräj is trying to impress upon us that detachment is not possible, even if one is highly educated, unless one is trained from the very beginning. That is Prahläd's point of view. Even in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that unless one is Kåñëa conscious, he cannot become a perfect gentleman. No one can become qualified with high character unless he is Kåñëa conscious. Why? Because he is hovering on the mental plane, a person who is not in Kåñëa consciousness has no other direction than to commit sinful activities.

Prahläd says that material entanglement is something like a prison house. If we are not trained from the very beginning of our life about Kåñëa consciousness, the aim of human life, then we are shackled, just as in the prison house one is shackled with iron chains. We should always remember that the aim of human life is to get out of this material entanglement. If we are not taught at an early age, from the very beginning of school life, or at some stage of life, then the opportunity of this human life will be lost. That is his instruction. "Therefore, my demoniac friends," he addresses them again, "please give up the company of those who are simply after material enjoyment.

"Just make your associations with persons who have taken to Kåñëa Consciousness." That is his advice. He says to his friends that this Kåñëa consciousness is not difficult to attain. Why? Kåñëa consciousness is very dear to us, but we do not understand it. Anyone who takes to Kåñëa consciousness becomes more and more affected by it and forgets his material consciousness. How? It is very dear to us, but we have forgotten it.

If you are in a foreign country, you might have forgotten your home and family, your family members and friends who are very dear to you. But all of a sudden, if you remember about your home and friends, you at once become very preoccupied. "How shall I meet them?" I know in San Francisco one of our friends left his young children and went to another country, and the eldest child has now grown up. A letter came from the eldest child, and at once the father remembered and sent some money. That affection automatically came, even though he had forgotten for so many years. Similarly, our affection for Kåñëa is so intimate that as soon as there is some touch of Kåñëa consciousness, we at once revive our whole relationship with Him.

Everyone has some particular relationship with Kåñëa the Supreme Lord, that he has forgotten. As soon as we are dovetailed with Kåñëa consciousness, gradually the old consciousness of our relationship with Kåñëa is revived. And when our consciousness is actually in the clear stage, we can understand our particular relationship with Kåñëa. Someone has a relationship with Kåñëa as friend. Someone has a relationship with Kåñëa as son and parent, or as lover and beloved or husband and wife. All these relationships are pervertedly reflected in life in the material world. But as soon as we come to the platform of Kåñëa consciousness, that old relationship with Kåñëa is revived.

We love—everyone of us. I love myself. That is a fact. I love myself, and that self has an intimate relationship with Kåñëa because the self is part and parcel of Kåñëa. The self is within this body, and I love my self better than the body. Similarly, because my self is part and parcel of Kåñëa, I love Kåñëa more than anything. But we have forgotten that Kåñëa is all-pervading. God is all-pervading. This memory has simply to be revived. As soon as we revive our Kåñëa consciousness we can study everything in relationship with Kåñëa. Everything then becomes factually lovable. Now I love you or you love me. That love is on the ephemeral stage of this body. But when love of Kåñëa is developed, I will not love you only, but I will love every living entity because the outward designation, this body, is forgotten. When a man becomes fully Kåñëa conscious, he does not see, "Here is a man, here is an animal, here is a cat, here is a dog, and here is a worm." He sees everything as part and parcel of Kåñëa. This is very nicely explained in the Bhagavad-gétä. "One who is actually learned in Kåñëa consciousness becomes a lover of the universe." Unless one is situated on the Kåñëa conscious platform, there is no question of universal brotherhood.

Now we are talking of universal brotherhood. If we actually want to implement the idea of universal brotherhood, then we will have to come to the platform of Kåñëa consciousness, not material consciousness. As long as we are in material consciousness, our lovable objects will be limited. But when we are actually in Kåñëa consciousness, our lovable objects will be universal. That is stated by Prahläd Mahäräj. "Beginning from the ant or the nonmovable plants and trees and extending to the highest living creature, Brahmä, the Supreme Personality of Godhead is present everywhere by His expansion as the Paramätmä, the feature of the Lord in everyone's heart. As soon as we become Kåñëa conscious, that extension of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Paramätmä, induces us to love every object in relation with Kåñëa."

5.God Realization Is Everywhere

Mahäräj Prahläd informed his class fellows about the all-pervasiveness of the Supreme Lord. The Supreme Soul is all-pervasive, but that does not mean that He has lost His personality. That is significant. Although He is all-pervading, still He is a person. According to our material perception, if something is all-pervading, then it has no personality, no localized aspect. But God is not like that. For example, the sunshine is all-pervading, but the sun also has a localized aspect. The sun is localized in one place, and you can see it. Not only is there the sun, but within the sun planet there is a sun-god, whose name is Vivasvän. We get this information from Vedic literature; there is no way to understand what takes place on other planets but by hearing from authorized sources. The difference in modem civilization is that we hear a scientist say, "We have seen the moon; it is such and such," and we believe it. We have not gone with the scientist to see the moon, but we believe him.

Belief is the basic principle of understanding. You either believe me or him; that depends on you. If you believe a scientist, that is information, and if you believe the Vedas, that is also information. It is up to you which source you believe. According to Vedic instruction, we take infallible information from the Vedas. As I have explained, an ordinary man who is conditioned by material nature has four defects. What are those four defects? The first is that a human being is sure to commit mistakes, however great a scientist he may be. Not very long ago in this country, there was a disaster when a scientist sent a satellite up but at once it burned to ashes. So there was a mistake. There must be mistakes. This is the nature of conditioned life. The mistake may be very great or very slight—that doesn't matter. But a human being conditioned by material nature is sure to commit mistakes.

Further, man is illusioned. He accepts one thing for something else because his senses are imperfect. For example, we accept this body as the self. Actually, I am not this body; therefore the acceptance of the body as self is called illusion. The whole world is going on under the illusion that "I am this body." Therefore there is no peace because everyone is illusioned. I am thinking that I am Indian, you are thinking that you are American, and a Chinese man is thinking that he is Chinese. What is this "Chinese," "American, and "Indian"? It is the body. This is illusion.

To cheat is another condition of life. I am a fool, but I will boast that I am very learned. Everyone who is illusioned and commits mistakes is a fool, but still one poses himself as being freed from all mistakes. And above all, our senses are imperfect. We view the sun as a small disc. Why? It is far, far greater than this earth, but we see it as just a disc. We have these imperfect senses, and we are subject to become illusioned and commit mistakes, and we are influenced by the propensity to cheat.

How can one expect real knowledge from such conditioned souls? There is no possibility to receive actual knowledge from them. So, in this world, whether a man is a scientist, a philosopher or whatever he may be, or however educated he may be, because he is conditioned, he cannot give complete information. This is a fact. How do you get complete information? The process is the disciplic succession of Vedic knowledge. You can read in Bhagavad-gétä that Lord Kåñëa says to Arjuna, "The knowledge of Bhagavad-gétä was first spoken by Me to the sun-god, and the sun-god spoke it to his son, Manu. In turn, Manu spoke this knowledge to his son Ikñväku, and then Ikñväku spoke the same to his son. In this way the knowledge has come down, but unfortunately that disciplic succession is now broken. Therefore, O Arjuna, I am now preaching the same knowledge to you because you are My very dear friend and good devotee." This is the process of accepting knowledge. We have to accept the transcendental vibration.

The entire Vedic knowledge is a transcendental vibration to help us to understand the Supreme Lord. So Prahläd Mahäräj says that the Supreme Soul is identical with the all-pervading Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Brahma-saàhitä also the same information appears—that the Supreme Lord, although situated in His own transcendental abode, is all-pervading. Although He is all-pervading, present everywhere, still by our imperfect senses we cannot see Him.

Prahläd Mahäräj says, "Although He is not seen, He can still be perceived. One who is intelligent can perceive the presence of the Supreme Lord everywhere." How is this possible? During the daytime one who is in the light can see that the sun is up, even though he is in a room. Because it is daytime, because it is light, he can understand that the sun is shining. Similarly, those who have understood the whole material creation, those who have understood the whole cosmic situation, know that everything is an expansion of the energy of the Supreme Lord.

What do we see with these present material senses? We can hear and understand the five gross elements and also the finer elements; we can understand that we have mind and intelligence. Similarly, we can understand that there is soul. We can understand fire, water, earth, sky, mind and intelligence. And, if a man is further advanced, he can understand that there is a soul, and, above all, there is Supersoul. We see what is visible to the material eye. We can see earth, water, fire. But we cannot see air, although we can perceive it. By touch we can understand the air. We can understand that there is sky by sound. We can understand that we have mind because we are thinking, feeling and willing. Similarly, we can understand that we have an intelligence that guides the mind. If we go still further, we can understand, "I am consciousness."

The visible things around us are also expansions of the inferior energy of the Supreme Lord. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that we should try to understand that which is spread all over the body because that is eternal. We have to understand from the authorities, but we can also perceive it. We know that there is consciousness spread all over the body. If I pinch any part of my body, there is consciousness. Similarly, consciousness is spread all over this universe. But that is not our consciousness. That is God's consciousness. We know every part of our body. We can perceive, "This is my finger," or "This is my ear." Similarly, God, the Supreme Soul, is all-pervading by His consciousness. That is Kåñëa consciousness.

Our process is to dovetail our consciousness with Kåñëa consciousness—that will make us perfect. It is not that we merge into that consciousness. In one sense we can say "merge," but still we keep our individuality. That is the difference between impersonalist philosophy and Kåñëa's conscious philosophy. The impersonalist philosophy says that we merge into the Supreme and lose our individuality. We can say that we merge into the Supreme, but we keep our individuality. How is that? An airplane starts from the airport and climbs up and up, and when it goes very high we cannot see it because it merges into the higher sky. We can simply see sky, but the airplane is not lost—it is still there. Another example is that if a green bird enters into a big green tree, we cannot distinguish the bird from the tree, but they both exist. Similarly, the supreme consciousness is Kåñëa, and when we dovetail our individual consciousness with the Supreme, we then become perfect. An outsider may see that there is no distinction between God and men, but it is due only to a poor fund of knowledge. Every individual person, every individual being, maintains his individuality, even though he is dovetailed with the Supreme.

Prahläd Mahäräj says that we cannot see consciousness—either supreme consciousness or individual—but it is there. How is it there? We can understand the supreme consciousness and our individual consciousness simply by perception of blissfulness. Because we have consciousness, we can feel änanda, or pleasure. Without consciousness there is no feeling of pleasure. Because of that consciousness we can enjoy life by applying our senses in whatever way we like. But as soon as consciousness is gone, we cannot enjoy. I am present because of consciousness, and I am part and parcel of Kåñëa, as stated in Bhagavad-gétä.

This consciousness exists because we are part and parcel of the supreme consciousness. For example, a spark is a tiny part and parcel of the fire, yet the spark is also the fire. A drop of the Atlantic Ocean possesses the same quality. as all the ocean water—it is also salty. Similarly the pleasure potency which we feel is the presence of consciousness, and that same pleasure potency also exists in the Supreme Lord. Paramesvara means the supreme controller. We are also içvara, or controller, because we are in some control. For example, I have some controlling power to take a drink of water when I cough. According to our capacity, everyone of us has some controlling power. But we are not the supreme controller. The supreme controller is God.

Because He is the supreme controller, He is controlling all these universal energies by His different potencies. We can also understand and feel. I am controlling my bodily affairs as far as possible, but because I am not the supreme controller, if there is something wrong in this body, I have no control. I speak of this hand as "my hand" because I am working with this hand and am moving it according to my desire. I am actually the controller of my hand. But I am not the controller of your hand. If I desire that your hand move. that is not in my power; that is in your power. You can move your hand if you like. I am not the controller of your body, but the Supreme Soul is the controller of both your body and my body. That is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä. The Lord says that you are present in your body and that this body is the field of your activities.

Whatever you are doing according to the body is limited. An animal which is bound up in a certain tract of land can move there and cannot go beyond what that space allows. Similarly, your activity and my activity are bound up within the limits of our bodies. My body is my field of activities, and your body is your field of activities. But Kåñëa says, "I am present in every field." He is present as Supersoul. I know when I cough, but you do not know how I feel, and similarly, I do not know what you are doing. Kåñëa however, as Paramätmä, knows what is going on in my body, in your body, and in thousands of millions and billions of other bodies. Therefore He is the supreme controller. We have our limited energy, but He is transcendental to this limited energy. He has unlimited opulence. By His controlling power, by His supreme will, this material creation is moving. That is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä where Kåñëa states, "Under My superintendence the whole material nature is working. All wonderful things that you see in this material world are due to My supervision, My supreme control."

Prahläd Mahäräj now gives his conclusion. "My dear friends, because the Supreme Lord is present everywhere and because we are part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, our duty is to be merciful to all living entities." When a person is in a lower position, we have a duty to help him. Because he is helpless, the small child is dependent on the mercy of the parent. In the relationship of the small child and the parent there is a reciprocation of feeling. The child is always dependent on the parent. "Mother, I want this." "Yes, my dear child." We should be compassionate to all living entities and should show them mercy. How can we show our mercy? There are millions and millions of poor men, so how can we show them all mercy? They want so many things.

People are very proud that they are going to serve the poor. In what way are they going to serve? Are we able to supply clothing and food to all the needy persons of the world? That is not possible. How, then, can we be merciful to every living entity? The fact is that we cannot show any mercy to the living entities through material considerations. That is not possible. Prahläd Mahäräj is showing his class friends real mercy. They were all fools, devoid of Kåñëa, consciousness, and therefore he was showing them how to become Kåñëa conscious. This is the highest mercy. If you want to show any mercy at all to the living entities, then enlighten them in Kåñëa consciousness as Prahläd Mahäräj did. Otherwise, it is materially beyond your power to show mercy.

"My dear demoniac friends," Prahläd says, "give up this demoniac life. Give up this nonsense." The belief that there is no God is the demoniac feature that Prahläd Mahäräj requests his demoniac friends to give up. They were thinking, "Who is God? There is no God." We find in the Bhagavad-gétä that people of this mentality are called miscreants, for they always try to make mischief. They are very well educated attorneys, lawyers and so on, but their plan is to cheat. We have practically experienced it. They are highly educated with so many qualifications and are nicely dressed, but their mentality is more base than that of a dog. "This man has some money, so let us conspire to cheat him." They are simply miscreants.

Why are they cheating for? Simply for sense gratification, just like an ass who does not know the purpose of life. He takes the hundred pound burdens on his back, and he is kept by the washerman, who loads his back as much as possible. In this way the ass works the whole day with this burden simply for a few morsels of grass. Similarly, materialistic people will simply be satisfied to eat a simple piece of bread or something similar, but they work very hard. Therefore they are compared to asses. They are always planning something mischievous. They are the lowest of mankind because they do not believe in God. Why? Their actual knowledge has been plundered by the influence of this material energy. Because they deny the existence of God, illusion impels them: "Yes, there is no God. Work hard and commit sins so that you may go to hell."

Prahläd Mahäräj requests his demoniac friends to just give up this idea that there is no God. If we give up this nonsensical idea, then the Supreme Lord, who is beyond our perception, will be pleased and show His mercy to us.

SAM KIRTAN
The Devotees are here seen chanting the Holy Names of God.
This, in these dark days of quarrel and hypocrisy, practice called
Sam Kirtan is the most recommended activity for developing
God Consciousness.
HARE KRISHNA HARE KRISHNA
KRISHNA KRISHNA HARE HARE
HARE RAMA HARE RAMA
RAMA RAMA HARE HARE

ON CHANTING THE HARE KÅÑËA MANTRA

Hare Kåñëa Hare Kåñëa Kåñëa Kåñëa Hare Hare
Hare Räma Hare Räma Räma Räma Hare Hare

by
His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Contents

Biography of the Spiritual Master
On Chanting the Hare Kåñëa Mantra
What is ISKCON?
Çré Çré Çikñäñöakam Prayers

ISKCON Press
38 North Beacon St.
Boston, Mass. 02134

Brief Biography of the Spiritual Master

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada was born Abhay Charan De on September 1, 1896, in Calcutta. In 1920 he finished his schooling, majoring in philosophy, English and economics at the University of Calcutta. Soon afterward, Abhay Charan De took up the duties of manager of a large chemical concern. Then in 1922, he met His Divine Grace Çré Çrémad-Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Mahäräja, the founder of sixty-four Gauòéya Vaiñëava Maths in India, Berlin and London. Bhaktivedanta Swami recently recalled the key to his approaching his spiritual master: "When I first started going to see my Guru Mahäräj, he said of me, 'This boy hears very nicely. He does not go away. So I shall make him a disciple. That was my qualification, or whatever you may call it. I would simply ask when Guru Mahäräj would speak, then I'd sit down and go on hearing. I would understand, or not understand; others would disperse, I'd not disperse. So he remarked, 'This boy is interested to hear. Because I was serious in hearing, I am now serious about kértanam, which means speaking or preaching. If one has heard nicely, then he will speak nicely."

At Allahabad in 1933, Abhay Charan De was formally initiated, and in 1936, just days before Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté's departure from this mortal world, he was specifically ordered to spread Kåñëa consciousness in the English language to the West.

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, known as Prabhupäda to his disciples, has said that at first he did not take the mission given to him by his spiritual master with the utmost seriousness. But then he was reading a Bhagavad-gétä commentary written by Çréla Bhaktivinode Öhäkur, who was the father of Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté and the pioneer of the Kåñëa consciousness movement in the modern age. Çréla Bhaktivinode has written that just as one cannot separate the body from the soul while in this conditioned state, so the disciple cannot separate the spiritual master's order from his very life. Bhaktivedanta Swami took these words seriously, and gradually his whole life became dedicated to carrying out the orders of his Guru Mahäräj. In 1959 he took sannyäsa, the renounced order of spiritual life, and in 1965, at the advanced age of 70, A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami arrived in New York City to fulfill his master's sacred mission.

Bhaktivedanta Swami produces his books by speaking them on a dictaphone. He is presently working on five books at once. These books are a matter of realization. As he has said, "When you become self-realized you automatically write volumes of books." And one of the qualifications of a devotee is that he is poetic. Çréla Prabhupäda is always immersed in Kåñëa by speaking, dictating, singing about Kåñëa's glories, preaching formally at meetings or planning the expansion of the Kåñëa consciousness movement. In the Bhagavad-gétä, Seventh Chapter, it is stated that out of thousands of men, few seek perfection, and out of the thousands who attain perfection, hardly one knows Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa also declares in the Eighteenth Chapter that the dearmost devotee of all is he who spreads the teaching of love of Kåñëa: "Never will there be one dearer to Me."

Çréla Prabhupäda's spiritual master, His Divine Grace Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, once drew a picture of a mådaìga (drum used on saìkértana) and, beside it, a printing press. He said the mådaìga can be heard for several blocks, but that the press can be heard around the world. He therefore called the printing press "the big mådaìga." For the purpose of worldwide service to humanity, ISKCON Press has been established for the exclusive printing of Çréla Prabhupäda's books.

In 1968, Macmillan published The Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, translated with commentary by Çréla Prabhupäda. The Gétä is the gist of the entire Vedic literature. Just this one book can free anyone from the clutches of material nature and fix one in eternal loving service unto Çré Kåñëa the Personality of Godhead. As originally written by Çréla Prabhupäda, the manuscript of The Bhagavad-gétä As It Is is many times larger than the version published by Macmillan. Publication of this original, expanded version is being undertaken by ISKCON Press. Another important published literature by Çréla Prabhupäda is his Teachings of Lord Caitanya. This book outlines the precepts of Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the Golden Avatara who appeared in India 500 years ago and propagated the Hare Kåñëa mantra as the means of God realization for the present age. A book called The Nectar of Devotion, an authorized summary study of Çréla Rupa Gosvämé's Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, has just been published. Çréla Prabhupäda is presently writing a several volume work called Kåñëa, which describes the pastimes performed by the Supreme Lord when present on this planet 5000 years ago. Translations are also underway of the Vedänta-sütra, Caitanya-caritämåta and his work of twelve cantos of Çrémad-Bhagavatam. The literatures compiled by His Divine Grace are authorized by the disciplic succession, which is descending from Kåñëa Himself; Çréla Prabhupäda's whole life mission is to faithfully pass on the original understanding of Kåñëa consciousness without distortion. According to the Vedic literature this descending process is the only way to realization of the Absolute Truth, as the Absolute Truth is beyond the reach of mundane speculation or scholarship.

His Divine Grace is not a retired personality, despite his prodigious literary output. He personally and very intimately guides his disciples through the most practical problems of daily life. Spiritual life is practical and, due to the predominant material atmosphere of Kali-yuga, often problematic. As spiritual master, His Divine Grace is the last recourse and the ultimate standard of Kåñëa consciousness, and he writes some twenty-five letters a day to leaders and students of his various worldwide centers. He himself resides in no one place, but travels from center to center and regularly lectures. The spiritual master is responsible for his devotees; when he accepts a sincere soul as his disciple, he promises to take him back to home, back to Godhead. No one should think, "Oh, everyone is taking a spiritual master; let me take one." The spiritual master as a style or as a pet is useless. Rather, his order is to be taken as one's life and soul. By taking shelter at the feet of the bona fide guru and serving him twenty-four hours a day, the fallen soul can be lifted to the spiritual sky. It is said that if the spiritual master is pleased, then one can make great advances in spiritual life. And one pure convinced devotee can make many pure devotees by his example and teachings. Those serious students with an understanding of the absolute value of the spiritual platform of life therefore honor the spiritual master with the honor due to God because the guru is the transparent via media or representative of God who distributes unalloyed love of God. The reader is invited to take to this philosophy with the utmost seriousness.

On Chanting the Hare Kåñëa Mantra...

The transcendental vibration established by the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is the sublime method for reviving our transcendental consciousness. As living spiritual souls, we are all originally Kåñëa conscious entities, but due to our association with matter from time immemorial, our consciousness is now adulterated by the material atmosphere. The material atmosphere, in which we are now living, is called mäyä, or illusion. Mäyä means that which is not. And what is this illusion? The illusion is that we are all trying to be lords of material nature, while actually we are under the grip of her stringent laws. When a servant artificially tries to imitate the all-powerful master, it is called illusion. We are trying to exploit the resources of material nature, but actually we are becoming more and more entangled in her complexities. Therefore, although we are engaged in a hard struggle to conquer nature, we are ever more dependent on her. This illusory struggle against material nature can be stopped at once by revival of our eternal Kåñëa consciousness.

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare is the transcendental process for reviving this original pure consciousness. By chanting this transcendental vibration, we can cleanse away all misgivings within our hearts. The basic principle of all such misgivings is the false consciousness that I am the lord of all I survey.

Kåñëa consciousness is not an artificial imposition on the mind. This consciousness is the original natural energy of the living entity. When we hear the transcendental vibration, this consciousness is revived. This simplest method of meditation is recommended for this age. By practical experience also, one can perceive that by chanting this mahämantra, or the Great Chanting for Deliverance, one can at once feel a transcendental ecstasy coming through from the spiritual stratum. In the material concept of life we are busy in the matter of sense gratification as if we were in the lower animal stage. A little elevated from this status of sense gratification, one is engaged in mental speculation for the purpose of getting out of the material clutches. A little elevated from this speculative status, when one is intelligent enough, one tries to find out the supreme cause of all causes—within and without. And when one is factually on the plane of spiritual understanding, surpassing the stages of sense, mind and intelligence, he is then on the transcendental plane. This chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra is enacted from the spiritual platform, and thus this sound vibration surpasses all lower strata of consciousness—namely sensual, mental and intellectual. There is no need, therefore to understand the language of the mantra, nor is there any need for mental speculation nor any intellectual adjustment for chanting this mahämantra. It is automatic, from the spiritual platform, and as such, anyone can take part in vibrating this transcendental sound without any previous qualification. In a more advanced stage, of course, one is not expected to commit offenses on grounds of spiritual understanding.

In the beginning, there may not be the presence of all transcendental ecstasies, which are eight in number. These are: 1) Being stopped as though dumb, 2) perspiration, 3) standing up of haris on the body, 4) dislocation of voice, 5) trembling, 6) fading of the body, 7) crying in ecstasy, and 8) trance. But there is no doubt that chanting for a while takes one immediately to the spiritual platform, and one shows the first symptom of this in the urge to dance along with the chanting of the mantra. We have seen this practically. Even a child can take part in the chanting and dancing. Of course, for one who is too entangled in material life, it takes a little more time to come to the standard point, but even such a materially engrossed man is raised to the spiritual platform very quickly. When it is chanted by a pure devotee of the Lord in love, it has the greatest efficacy on hearers, and as such this chanting should be heard from the lips of a pure devotee of the Lord, so that immediate effects can be achieved. As far as possible, chanting from the lips of nondevotees should be avoided. Milk touched by the lips of a serpent has poisonous effects.

The word Harä is the form of addressing the energy of the Lord, and the words Kåñëa and Räma are forms of addressing the Lord Himself. Both Kåñëa and Räma mean the supreme pleasure, and Hara is the supreme pleasure energy of the Lord, changed to Hare in the vocative. The supreme pleasure energy of the Lord helps us to reach the Lord.

The material energy, called mäyä, is also one of the multi-energies of the Lord. And we the living entities are also the energy, marginal energy, of the Lord. The living entities are described as superior to material energy. When the superior energy is in contact with the inferior energy, an incompatible situation arises; but when the superior marginal energy is in contact with the superior energy, called Harä, it is established in its happy, normal condition.

These three words, namely Harä, Kåñëa and Räma, are the transcendental seeds of the mahämantra. The chanting is a spiritual call for the Lord and His energy, to give protection to the conditioned soul. This chanting is exactly like the genuine cry of a child for its mother's presence. Mother Harä helps the devotee achieve the Lord Father's grace, and the Lord reveals Himself to the devotee who chants this mantra sincerely.

No other means of spiritual realization is as effective in this age of quarrel and hypocrisy as the mahämantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

WHAT IS ISKCON?

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness was formed in July, 1966, by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda and a number of his American students. ISKCON is composed of devotees. Devotees are held together by mutual agreement to accept the principles of bhakti-yoga or devotional service as the goal of life. By mutual endeavor, the entire Society concentrates on Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead, while engaged in various tasks, cooking, eating, working in an office or chanting the holy names in the city streets. His Divine Grace is a pure devotee, and those disciples who sincerely follow his instructions have every chance of becoming pure devotees themselves. The initiated devotees in each center live in urban commune settings (with the one exception of New Våndävana, ISKCON's äçrama of homes, temples, farm land and cows in the hills of West Virginia), and are freeing themselves from the conditions of birth, death, disease and old age by fixing their minds on the eternal joyful Personality of Godhead. To live in ISKCON as an initiated student, one agrees to accept four rules: no meateating, no illicit sex, no intoxicants and no gambling. The disciples perform devotional service, duties and chanting in a life-routine characterized by simple living and high-thinking.

Kåñëa consciousness is experienced as a process of self-purification. Its means and ends are an open secret, and there is no financial charge for learning Kåñëa consciousness or receiving initiation into the chanting of Hare Kåñëa. The gist of devotional service to Kåñëa is that one takes whatever capacity or talent he or she has and dovetails it with the transcendental interest of the Supreme Enjoyer, the Absolute Truth. The writer or poet writes articles and poems for Kåñëa, and the Society publishes periodicals. The businessman does business in order to sell literature and establish many temples around the world. The householders raise children in the science of God, and husband and wife live in mutual cooperation for spiritual progress. And everyone in ISKCON goes on saìkértana. Saìkértana means chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra in the city streets for the benefit of all citizens. Çréla Prabhupäda has said that the saìkértana party is the heart and soul of the Hare Kåñëa movement. Therefore, in each of the 30 ISKCON centers, saìkértana is carried on several times daily, and all other activity is subsidiary. Our spiritual master stresses this, for we are in the line of Lord Caitanya. Caitanya Mahäprabhu is revealed by Vedic scriptures to be Kåñëa Himself, come in the mood of a pure devotee. Five hundred years ago Lord Caitanya understood from scripture that in this present age of Kali (quarrel and disturbance), when mental distraction is high and almost no one is serious about spiritual perfection, chanting alone is the most effective means of God realization. Following the saìkértana process chalked out by Lord Caitanya, the Hare Kåñëa movement of today takes parties of from five to 30 devotees, men wearing saffron robes and women wearing colorful saris. And they celebrate the holy name with dancing and melodious chanting.

The saìkértana singing is accompanied with mådaìga drum and pairs of karatals (hand cymbals). The devotees experience that this joyous singing of the names of God produces immediate feelings of ecstasy coming from the spiritual stratum. The effect is a clearing away of the dirt from the mind engrossed in the gloom of material existence. Under the instruction of the spiritual master, they gladly spread this chanting, and in reciprocation Çré Kåñëa allows all to taste the nectar for which everyone is always anxious. Because the Personality of Godhead is Absolute, His name is nondifferent from Himself. Therefore the Supreme Person, Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure, dances on the tongue of the chanter of His name; to chant and hear fixes the mind, in meditation, in direct contact with God. The mantra is not to be mistaken for an ordinary song or anything tinged with the mundane; it is a pure transcendental sound vibration of the Absolute and has been upheld as such since time immemorial by the great sages and Vedic scriptures. Lord Caitanja prays to the Supreme: "My dear Lord, You are so kind that You have invested all potency in Your Holy Name." This Absolute Presence of God in His Name holds true not only for the members of the saìkértana party, but for any living entity who hears the chanting; anyone will benefit if he simply likes the sound of the chanting, or he appreciates the presence of the saìkértana party in any way. That is the mercy of the Absolute. The holy name is compared to a fire; whether one is scientifically conversant with all the properties of fire or knows nothing about it, if one puts his hand in fire he will be burnt. Sincere chanting and hearing of the mahämantra will cleanse the mind and elevate one and all to the natural original position of spirit soul. Therefore there is no hesitancy on the devotees part in going to the largest and most public gatherings of people and broadcasting, wherever possible, the sound of the transcendental Names: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

Chanting takes place regularly in the main streets of cities like New York, Los Angeles, Boston, San Francisco, Berkeley, Detroit, Philadelphia, Washington D.C., Honolulu, London, Hamburg, Tokyo, etc., with new ISKCON centers being regularly established. The expansion of Kåñëa consciousness is realization of the prediction made by Lord Caitanya: "The chanting of Hare Kåñëa will be heard in every town and village of the world."

The Society is as famous for its Sunday feasts and festivals as for its chanting in the streets. Every Sunday, in each of the ISKCON centers, a grand feast of from 10 to 15 courses of Indian vegetarian food is prepared and distributed for guests. The feasts are arranged around festival days celebrating the Pastimes of Çré Kåñëa during His Appearance on the earth 5,000 years ago. Plays, puppet shows and chanting are regular items which invite guests to participate in the transcendental glorification of the Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa consciousness is not a dry philosophy. Residents of San Francisco appreciate the yearly Ratha-yäträ Festival in which the large cart bearing the Jagannatha Deity is wheeled to the sea. During the Ratha-yäträ celebration of 1970 more than 20,000 people followed the regal 8,000 pound carts, and thousands were fed full plates of prasädam at the seaside.

The important aim of the festivals, chanting and philosophizing is to engage people in the service of the Personality of Godhead and in feeling His soothing contact. All miseries are caused by forgetfulness of God, and ISKCON, by reviving the lost memory of the Supreme Lord in the minds of the people, is—according to the Bhagavad-gétä—performing the greatest service and highest welfare work for suffering humanity. Moreover, it is performed in this sublime and easy way, by feasting, dancing, singing and philosophizing.

Sometimes in Lord Caitanya's time, the devotees were accused by the impersonalists of being mere sentimentalists because they were always singing and dancing. The actual fact is that Kåñëa consciousness is backed by a vast learned literature, the Vedic scriptures such as Bhagavad-gétä, Çrémad-Bhagavatam, Vedänta-sütra, the Upaniñads, Mahäbhärata, Rämäyaëa, etc., so that one could read 24 hours a day without exhausting the Source. All of this Kåñëa consciousness information is understood by revelation. Simply by applying one's energy in a devotional service attitude, the knowledge becomes known to the devotee through the heart. Classes in the transcendental science of God consciousness or bhakti-yoga are held three times daily at at ISKCON centers, and the public is freely invited to attend. The Brahma Sampradayä disciplic succession, in which Çréla Prabhupäda is coming, is particularly noted for being a learned line. There is plenty of philosophy and logic in stock. There are many different religious philosophies and transcendental teachings, but the Kåñëa conscious students and ministers are unique in that they are convinced of the Personality of Godhead. Not just that they have heard "God is great," but they have heard from the spiritual master and continuously hearing from the scriptures just how great He is, how His energies are working and exactly how He is enjoying. There is no literature of theism as voluminous, exacting, consistent and clear as this Vedic literature of Kåñëa consciousness. The conviction in service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is due to direct reciprocation with Him. Simply by chanting or hearing the pastimes of the Personality of Godhead, one is contacting the Absolute—and he can feel it. By engaging the senses, the will, words and energy, the devotees are receiving constant information from the spiritual world. Kåñëa Himself describes such devotees as the topmost yogis and mystics, so it is no wonder that they are conversant with the nature of God and the way back to Godhead.

ISKCON provides formal education in the highest science, or what Bhagavad-gétä calls the "king of knowledge." According to Vedic sources, education can only be valid when there is spiritual knowledge or self-realization, and a man is said to have no qualifications if he does not know who he is in terms of self-realization or God realization. Learning the texts requires living in accordance with the scriptural injunctions without the slightest deviation. The need for Kåñëa conscious preachers is very great, and it is a full time vocation. The curriculum advances basically from student to minister; after studying and working in a temple for one year, the student may be awarded the title of bhakti-çästri, or ordained minister, with further responsibilities and with advancement of service. He may finally take the renounced order, called sannyäsa, and receive the title svämé.

As the philosophy of Kåñëa consciousness is nonsectarian, any man—Hindu or Christian—will advance in his faith by chanting the Holy Name of God and hearing the Bhagavad-gétä. Without knowledge, realization and loving service to the One Supreme God, there can be no religion. Let the inhabitants of this planet rejoice in the saìkértana movement and live to see the fulfillment of the chanting of Hare Kåñëa carried to every town and village. Only in this way can real peace prevail in the world and mankind qualify to enter into the kingdom of God.

Pictured opposite is the scene of the 1970 Ratha-yäträ Festival held in San Francisco, California. Disciples of His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda led a parade of 20,000 persons in honor of the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa, the cause of all causes. Three huge carts carried the Deity incarnations of Lord Jagannätha, His sister Subhadrä and His brother Lord Balaräma. By chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra, dancing, feasting on prasädam (spiritual food offered in love to God), and hearing the words of Çréla Prabhupäda, who personally rode in the parade, thousands of people were able to feel natural transcendental emotions in glorification of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. At all ISKCON branches around the world, similar festivals are held for the spiritual upliftment of all humanity.

Çré Çré Çikñäñöakam

The following eight verses were written by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who appeared in India 500 years ago and stressed, on scriptural evidence, that the chanting of Hare Kåñëa is the most perfect method of God realization for this present age. Caitanya Mahäprabhu is revealed by Vedic scriptures to be Kåñëa Himself in the role of a pure devotee. His verses capture the essence of the saìkértana movement of worshiping God by chanting His holy names, as followed by the disciples of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, who is himself in direct disciplic succession from Lord Caitanya.

Glory to the Çré Kåñëa Sankértana, which cleanses the heart of all the dust accumulated for years together. Thus the fire of conditional life, of repeated birth and death, is extinguished. This saìkértana movement is the prime benediction for humanity at large because it spreads the rays of the benediction moon. It is the life of all transcendental knowledge, it increases the ocean of transcendental bliss, and it helps us to have a taste of the full nectar for which we are always anxious.

O my Lord! Your holy name alone can render all benediction upon the living beings, and therefore You have hundreds and millions of names, like Kåñëa, Govinda, etc. In these transcendental names You have invested all Your transcendental energies, and there is no hard and fast rule for chanting these holy names. O my Lord! You have so kindly made approach to You easy by Your holy names, but unfortunate as I am, I have no attraction for them.

One can chant the holy name of the Lord in a humble state of mind, thinking himself lower than the straw in the street, more tolerant than the tree, devoid all sense of false prestige, and ready to offer all respects to others. In such a state of mind one can chant the holy name of the Lord constantly.

O almighty Lord! I have no desire to accumulate wealth, nor have I any desire to enjoy beautiful women, nor do I want any number of followers. What I want only is that I may have Your causeless devotional service in my life—birth after birth.

O son of Mahäräja Nanda, I am Your eternal servitor, and although I am so, somehow or other I have fallen in the ocean of birth and death. Please, therefore, pick me up from this ocean of death and fix me as one of the atoms of Your lotus feet.

O my Lord! When will my eyes be decorated with tears of love, flowing constantly while I chant Your holy name? When will my words be choked up when uttering the holy name? And when will all the holes of hair on my body have eruptions by the recitation of Your name?

O Govinda! Feeling Your separation I am considering a moment twelve years or more, and tears are flowing from my eyes like torrents of rain. I am feeling all vacant in the world in the absence of You.

I do not know anyone except Kåñëa as my Lord, and He will always remain as such, even if He handles me roughly by His embrace or makes me broken-hearted by not being present before me. He is completely free to do anything and everything, but He is always my worshipable Lord, unconditionally.

The Krsna Consciousness Handbook (1971)

FOR THE YEAR 484,
CAITANYA ERA
(March 24, 1970 March 12, 1971)

THE INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR KRISHNA CONSCIOUSNESS

HKH: Introduction

Introduction

This is the first annual edition of The Kåñëa Consciousness Handbook. The International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) was founded in 1966 by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda and is now becoming firmly established, with centers in thirty major cities around the world and world headquarters in Los Angeles, California. The goal of the Society's members is to attain love of God by following the principles of bhakti-yoga, as taught by the Vedic scriptures and the disciplic succession of spiritual masters, and to spread love of God to all people through the process of saìkértana (public chanting of the holy names of God). Another important goal of the Society is to present authoritative literature on the science of God in English and other major languages.

The purpose of this handbook is to show interested persons the full scope of ISKCON's activities. ISKCON is not concerned with accumulating financial assets, but aims at producing men and women of sublime character. This is possible only by plain living and high thinking based on the principles of devotional service to the Supreme Lord. Sincere souls everywhere are taking to this genuine movement of God realization. As is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, "This knowledge is the king of education, the most secret of all secrets. It is the purest knowledge, and because it gives direct perception of the self by realization, it is the perfection of religion. It is everlasting, and it is joyfully performed."

© 1970 ISKCON Press Printed by ISKCON Press USA

Contents

A Brief History of ISKCON

Teachings of ISKCON

Brief Biography of the Spiritual Master

Paramparä

Ministers for Kåñëa Consciousness: Qualifications, Activities, Duties, and Personal Code

Transcendental Aspects

The Qualifications and Curriculum of the Divinity Student

Qualifications of a Devotee

Principles of Devotional Service

New Våndävana

Tilaka

ISKCON Press

Preface to Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead

On Chanting the Hare Kåñëa Mantra

Books by A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

Calendar for 484 of the Caitanya Era

Devotional Prayers

Procedure for Performing A Kåñëa Conscious Marriage

Recognition of ISKCON

For more information about ISKCON, contact
ISKCON Press, 38 N. Beacon St. Boston, Massachusetts 02134. Attention: Svarupa das Brahmacari, secretary.

On The Cover: ISKCON World Headquarters, 3764 Watseka Ave. Los Angeles, California 90034

Back Cover: New Våndävana, a spiritual community developing in West Virginia. See page 31.

HKH 1: A Brief History of ISKCON

A Brief History of ISKCON

In discussing Kåñëa consciousness there is no question of ancient or modern since these teachings are eternal. Because Kåñëa consciousness is eternal it is impossible to trace an origin. This means that there never was a time when Kåñëa consciousness did not exist, so it can be said that there is no point at which Kåñëa consciousness has come into being from not being. For this reason, Kåñëa consciousness is said to be beginningless, which does not mean that it does not yet exist, but that it has always existed, so a point of "beginning" cannot be traced.

In the Bhagavad-gétä, one of the principal scriptures, it is stated that Lord Kåñëa (God) transmitted this teaching to Vivasvän, the god of the sun, many millions of years ago. Vivasvän passed the teachings on to Manu, the progenitor of all mankind, and Manu transmitted it to the royal sage, Iksväku. In this manner the teaching of Kåñëa consciousness was passed down by a process known as disciplic succession. The validity of the process of disciplic succession depends on the qualified master transmitting the teaching to the sincere student, without adding any personally motivated interpretations. The teaching must be presented to the student exactly as it was previously presented to the teacher. In this way the teaching is preserved intact and unadulterated. It may be compared to the job of the mailman who delivers the letter, but does not add to it or subtract from it. In the course of time, however, the disciplic succession was broken. In order to re-establish this disciplic succession, Kåñëa again personally transmitted this teaching to the great devotee, Arjuna, 5,000 years ago in India. This transmission is recorded in the Bhagavad-gétä.

At the time of the creation of this present universe, Lord Kåñëa personally gave this knowledge to Brahmä, the builder of the universe. Upon hearing the sound of Kåñëa playing the flute, Brahmä awoke to eternal knowledge. Brahmä transmitted the knowledge to the sage Närada, and Närada, in turn, gave the knowledge to Vyäsa, who is the compiler of the Vedic scriptures. This disciplic succession was passed down through many great teachers and eventually to Lord Krñëa Caitanya in the fifteenth century. Actually Lord Caitanya is the Supreme Lord Himself, but He appeared as a devotee of the Lord. Because He appeared as a devotee, He accepted a spiritual master in this line of disciplic succession known as the Brahma-sampradäya because it has been handed down from Lord Brahmä. Lord Caitanya travelled through India teaching the chanting of the holy names of the Lord.

In the latter half of the nineteenth century Çréla Öhäkur Bhaktivinode, a great devotee in Brahma-sampradäya, began the work of making this knowledge available to the English-speaking world. Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé, the son of Çréla Öhäkur Bhaktivinode, continued the work of making this knowledge available to the English-speaking world. In 1918 he established the Gauòéya Math Institute for teaching Kåñëa consciousness. He established sixty-four missions.

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Gosvämé, a disciple of Çré Çré Çrémad Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé, came to the United States in 1965 to continue the work of his spiritual master. In 1966 the International Society for Krishna Consciousness was established in New York City. As of May, 1970, there are thirty centers around the world.

The teaching being propagated in America and Europe today by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami and his disciples is exactly the same as that given by Lord Kåñëa to Vivasvän, Arjuna and Brahmä. It is not a question of modifying ancient teachings to fit a modern world. The relevance of Kåñëa consciousness is eternal and perfect for all people, regardless of culture, place or time. The advice given by Çré Kåñëa to Arjuna five thousand years ago in India is accepted without modification by modern Americans and Europeans.

HKH 2: Teachings of ISKCON

Teachings of ISKCON

The teachings of Kåñëa consciousness cannot properly be classified as belief. The teaching is true eternal knowledge. Belief may be either true or false, but it is still belief. Truth may be believed or disbelieved, but it is still truth. For example, a blind man might not believe in the existence of the sun, but the existence of the sun is still a fact. Similarly, the eternal, knowledgeable and blissful nature of God is a fact regardless of the belief or disbelief of anyone.

It is this fact which is the primary concern of Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa consciousness is the revival of the original consciousness of the living being—the conscious awareness that one is eternally related to God, or Kåñëa.

The true self or soul of the individual is eternal, ever-existent. Due to the ignorance of material contamination, the soul is forced to assume a continuous succession of material bodies. When one body dies, the soul immediately assumes another body and is born again. The individual forgets his past life and identifies with the present body, which is, in reality, simply a temporary covering for the soul. One must overcome this false identification with the temporary body and realize his true position. When an individual realizes that his true position is to be the loving servant of Kåñëa, he is freed from the cycle of birth and death and can resume his spiritual life, an eternal life of knowledge and bliss in the loving service of the Supreme Lord.

This transcendental loving service, called bhakti, is the goal of all religion and philosophy; actually it is the goal of life itself. The process of Kåñëa consciousness is bhakti, the ultimate goal. Kåñëa Himself is the Absolute Truth, and the function of the living entity is to live in constant loving service to the Truth. This love is reciprocal. Whatever the devotee gives to the Lord is returned with love many times over.

All living beings are already accepting love from Kåñëa in the form of their food and all material comforts, and, in fact, life itself. Kåñëa consciousness is the process of becoming aware that all this is the gift of Kåñëa and living accordingly. All facilities and abilities at our disposal should be used in service to Kåñëa. In this way one's consciousness will be raised to the transcendental platform because he will be thinking of Kåñëa. Thus all the senses and faculties can be engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. It is not necessary to wait for death to enter into the Kingdom of God, because one who is engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord is living in the Kingdom of God, even before death. He may still be on this earth, but because he is constantly serving Kåñëa, by the grace of Kåñëa he is constantly aware of Kåñëa everywhere.

One cannot make up his own God and then claim to be constantly aware of God. Kåñëa is a distinct individual with distinct characteristics. For example, if someone wants to meet the President of the United States, he cannot create a fictional president and then claim to know the President of the United States. The President is a specific person, not the creation of someone's imagination. Unless one knows that specific person, with his specific form and characteristics, he cannot claim to know the President.

Similarly, unless one knows the specific form and personality of Kåñëa, he cannot claim to know Kåñëa just because he has created some fictional God in his mind.

Actually, no one can reach God by guesswork or by his own devices. In order to know Kåñëa, one must follow the instructions of Kåñëa. These instructions are given in the scriptures.

The prime instruction is that one must revive his dormant love for Kåñëa. In the present age, known as the Kali-yuga, or the age of quarrel, the recommended method for reviving this dormant love for Kåñëa is the process of constantly chanting the holy names of Kåñëa. This was revealed by Çré Kåñëa Caitanya, who said that in this age the easiest means of spiritual realization is the chanting of the holy names. The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is dedicated to spreading the chanting of these holy names. By the mercy of Lord Caitanya, these holy names have been given to us in an easily learned and repeated form known as the mahämantra or great chanting:

Hare Krñëa Hare Kåñëa
Krñëa Kåñëa Hare Hare
Hare Räma Hare Räma
Räma Räma Hare Hare

Hare (pronounced Ha-ray) is the supreme pleasure potency of the Lord. Kåñëa is the original name of the Lord, and it means the all-attractive. Räma is another name of the Lord meaning the enjoyer because Kåñëa is the supreme enjoyer; the function of the living being is to be enjoyed by Kåñëa. Under the false impression that they are the enjoyers, the living beings are actually suffering in material existence. The living being cannot enjoy independently. It is impossible. Because the living entities are constantly trying to accomplish the impossible, they are constantly frustrated. Our limited senses do not have the capacity for independent enjoyment, but when we use our senses to please the senses of Kåñëa, then we are automatically satisfied. In so doing, the senses of the individual become dovetailed with the supreme senses of Krñëa, and the living being attains the pleasure and happiness which is otherwise impossible to find. Kåñëa consciousness is experienced as a process of self-purification. Its means and ends are an open secret, and there is no financial charge for learning Kåñëa consciousness or receiving initiation into the chanting of Hare Kåñëa. Therefore, saìkértana, or the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra in the city streets for the benefit of all citizens, is one of the more important activities of ISKCON. Saìkértana parties are frequently seen celebrating the holy name of Kåñëa with dancing and melodious singing, accompanied with mådaìga drums and pairs of karatälas (hand cymbals). The devotees experience that this joyous singing of the names of God produces immediate feelings of ecstasy. The effect is a clearing away of the dirt from the mind engrossed in the gloom of material existence. Because the Personality of Godhead is absolute, His name is nondifferent from Himself. Therefore the Supreme Person, Kåñëa, the reservoir of pleasure, allows the chanter of His name to experience the nectar of association with Him. The Society is as famous for its Sunday feasts and festivals as for its chanting in the streets. Every Sunday, in each of the ISKCON centers, a grand feast of from ten to fifteen courses of Indian vegetarian food is prepared and distributed to the guests. The feasts are arranged around festival days celebrating the pastimes of Çré Kåñëa during His appearance on the earth 5,000 years ago. Plays, puppet shows and chanting are regular items which invite guests to participate in the transcendental glorification of the Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa consciousness is not a dry philosophy. Residents of San Francisco appreciate the yearly Ratha-yäträ Festival in which the large cart bearing the Jagannätha Deity is wheeled to the sea. During the Ratha-yäträ celebration of 1969, more than 15,000 people followed the regal 8,000 pound cart, and thousands were fed full plates of prasädam at the seaside. In London, a similar procession is led to Trafalgar Square. The important aim of the festivals, chanting and philosophizing is to engage people in the service of the Personality of Godhead so they can feel His soothing contact. All miseries are caused by forgetfulness of God, and ISKCON, by reviving the lost memory of the Supreme Lord in the minds of the people, is—according to Bhagavad-gétä—performing the greatest service and highest welfare work for suffering humanity. Moreover, it is performed in this sublime and easy way, by feasting, dancing, singing and philosophizing.

In addition to chanting the holy names, one should study the scriptures thoroughly. The basic scripture of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness is the Bhagavad-gétä, which was spoken by Kåñëa to the great devotee Arjuna. Because it was spoken to a great devotee, the Bhagavad-gétä contains information which is not found in other scriptures. This is not to imply that the other scriptures are false, but in the Bible Lord Jesus Christ says, "I have more to tell, but ye cannot bear it now." The Bhagavad-gétä and the Bible are in complete agreement because the knowledge revealed in both is that the only valid life is a life of loving service to the Lord. It may appear contradictory that in the Bible it is recommended that one worship Lord Jesus Christ and in the Bhagavad-gétä it is recommended that one worship Lord Kåñëa. Actually there is only one God, but He can appear in different forms at different times and places. The form of Kåñëa is the original form from whom the other forms emanate. So Lord Jesus is actually an incarnation of God, as the son of God. It is not the purpose of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness to dissuade sincere devotees of Lord Jesus from worshiping Him. The purpose of Kåñëa consciousness is to spread love of God to all people. Anyone can practice Kåñëa consciousness by the process of chanting the holy names, but in order to teach and spread this knowledge it is necessary to have a thorough understanding of the scriptures. Bhagavad-gitä is not the only scriptural text of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. Other texts include Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çré Brahma-saàhitä, Çré Caitanya-caritämåta, Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, and many others. The texts that are studied are originally written in Sanskrit and Bengali and are presently being translated by the spiritual master and founder of the Society, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami. To learn and understand all these texts requires an intense effort and much time. The scriptures must be thoroughly learned and understood without any personally motivated interpretation. In order to teach Kåñëa consciousness one must live in exact accordance with the scriptural injunctions without the slightest deviation. Teachers of Kåñëa consciousness are badly needed in the world today, and the International Society for Krishna Consciousness is engaged in training qualified teachers. One who wishes to study Kåñëa consciousness and teach others must be completely dedicated without any outside interest whatsoever.

The students of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness lead completely regulated lives, according to the injunctions of the scriptures. They eat only foods that are specially prepared according to scriptural directions. They have no sex life outside of marriage; they take no intoxicants, and they do not indulge in gambling or idle amusements, such as movies, television, etc.

HKH 3: Brief Biography of the Spiritual Master

Brief Biography of the Spiritual Master

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda was born Abhay Charan De on September 1, 1896, in Calcutta. In 1920 he finished his schooling, majoring in philosophy, English and economics at the University of Calcutta. Soon afterward, Abhay Charan De took up the duties of manager of a large chemical concern. Then in 1922, he met His Divine Grace Çré Çrémad Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Mahäräja, the founder of sixty-four Gaudéya Vaiñëava Maths in India, Berlin and London. Bhaktivedanta Swami recently recalled the key to his approaching his spiritual master: "When I first started going to see my Guru Mahäräj, he said of me, 'This boy hears very nicely. He does not go away. So I shall make him a disciple.' That was my qualification, or whatever you may call it. I would simply ask when Guru Mahäräj would speak, then I'd sit down and go on hearing. I would understand, or not understand; others would disperse, I'd not disperse. So he remarked, 'This boy is interested to hear.' Because I was serious in hearing, I am now serious about kértanam, which means speaking or preaching. If one has heard nicely, then he will speak nicely."

At Allahabad in 1933, Abhay Charan De was formally initiated, and in 1936, just days before Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté's departure from this mortal world, he was specifically ordered to spread Kåñëa consciousness in the English language to the West.

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, known as Prabhupäda to his disciples, has said that at first he did not take the mission given to him by his spiritual master with the utmost seriousness. But then he was reading a Bhagavad-gétä commentary written by Çréla Bhaktivinode Öhäkur, who was the father of Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté and the pioneer of the Kåñëa consciousness movement in the modern age. Çréla Bhaktivinode has written that just as one cannot separate the body from the soul while in this conditioned state, so the disciple cannot separate the spiritual master's order from his very life. Bhaktivedanta Swami took these words seriously, and gradually his whole life became dedicated to carrying out the orders of his Guru Mahäräj. In 1959 he took sannyäsa, the renounced order of spiritual life, and in 1965, at the advanced age of 70, A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami arrived in New York City to fulfill his master's sacred mission.

Bhaktivedanta Swami produces his books by speaking them on a dictaphone. He is presently working on five books at once. These books are a matter of realization. As he has said, "When you become self-realized you automatically write volumes of books." And one of the qualifications of a devotee is that he is poetic. Çréla Prabhupäda is always immersed in Kåñëa by speaking, dictating, singing about Kåñëa's glories, preaching formally at meetings or planning the expansion of the Kåñëa consciousness movement. In the Bhagavad-gétä, Seventh Chapter, it is stated that out of thousands of men, few seek perfection, and out of the thousands who attain perfection, hardly one knows Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa also declares in the Eighteenth Chapter that the dearmost devotee of all is he who spreads the teaching of love of Kåñëa: "Never will there be one dearer to Me."

Bhaktivedanta Swami's spiritual master, Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, once drew a picture of a mådaìga (drum used on saìkértana) and, beside it, a printing press. He said the mådaìga can be heard for several blocks, but that the press can be heard around the world. He therefore called the printing press "the big mådaìga." For the purpose of worldwide service to humanity, ISKCON Press has been established for the exclusive printing of Çréla Prabhupäda's books.

In 1968, Macmillan published The Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, translated with commentary by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami. The Gétä is the gist of the entire Vedic literature. Just this one book can free anyone from the clutches of material nature and fix one in eternal loving service unto Çré Kåñëa the Personality of Godhead. As originally written by Çréla Prabhupäda, the manuscript of The Bhagavad-gitä As It Is is many times larger than the version published by Macmillan. Publication of this original, expanded version is being undertaken by ISKCON Press. Another important published literature by Prabhupäda is his Teachings of Lord Caitanya. This book outlines the precepts of Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the Golden Avatära who appeared in India 500 years ago and propagated the Hare Kåñëa mantra as the means of God realization for the present age. A book called The Nectar of Devotion, an authorized summary study of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé's Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, has just been published. Prabhupäda is presently writing a several volume work called Kåñëa, which contains all of the pastimes of the Supreme Lord when present on this planet 5000 years ago. Translations are also underway of the Vedänta-sütra, Caitanya-caritämåta and his work of twelve cantos of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The literatures compiled by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami are authorized by the disciplic succession, which is descending from Kåñëa Himself; Prabhupäda's whole life mission is to faithfully pass on the original understanding of Kåñëa consciousness without distortion. According to the Vedic literature this descending process is the only way to realization of the Absolute Truth, as the Absolute Truth is beyond the reach of mundane speculation or scholarship.

The author is not a retired personality, despite his prodigious literary output. He personally and very intimately guides his disciples through the most practical problems of daily life. Spiritual life is practical and, due to the predominant material atmosphere of Kali-yuga, often problematic. As spiritual master, Bhaktivedanta Swami is the last recourse and the ultimate standard of Kåñëa consciousness, and he writes some twenty-five letters a day to leaders and students of his various worldwide centers. He himself resides in no one place, but travels from center to center and regularly lectures. The spiritual master is responsible for his devotees; when he accepts a sincere soul as his disciple, he promises to take him back to home, back to Godhead. No one should think, "Oh, everyone is taking a spiritual master; let me take one." The spiritual master as a style or as a pet is useless. Rather, his order is to be taken as one's life and soul. By taking shelter at the feet of the bona fide guru and serving him twenty-four hours a day, the fallen soul can be lifted to the spiritual sky. It is said that if the spiritual master is pleased, then one can make great advances in spiritual life. And one pure convinced devotee can make many pure devotees by his example and teachings. Those serious students with an understanding of the absolute value of the spiritual platform of life therefore honor the spiritual master with the honor due to God because the guru is the transparent via media or representative of God who distributes unalloyed love of God. The reader is invited to take to this philosophy with the utmost seriousness.

HKH 4: Paramparä

Paramparä

evaà paramparä-präptam imaà

(This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way.)

Kåñëa Brahmä
Närada Vyäsa
Madhva Padmanäbha
Nåhari Mädhava
Akñobhya Jayatértha
Jïänasindhu Dayänidhi
Vidyänidhi Räjendra
Jayadharma Puruñottama
Brahmaëyatértha Vyäsatértha
Lakñmépati Mädhavendra Puré
Éçvara Puré (Nityänanda, Advaita)
Lord Caitanya Rüpa (Svarüpa, Sanätana)
Raghunätha, Jéva Kåñëa däsa
Narottama Viçvanätha
(Baladeva) Jagannätha Bhaktivinode
Gaurakiçora Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

HKH 5: Ministers for Kåñëa Consciousness:
Qualifications, Activities, Duties, and Personal Code

Ministers for Kåñëa Consciousness:
Qualifications, Activities, Duties, and Personal Code

A.Qualification and classification of different types of ministers within the Society.

The Society is somewhat unconventional in the sense that, while there are clear formal steps in advancing from student to minister, the difference in activities between student and minister change slowly over a long period of time. If, after one year, the divinity student successfully completes the required courses, passes a comprehensive examination on Bhagavad-gétä and Éçopaniñad, and proves to be otherwise deserving, he will be given the title of Bhaktiçästré. A Bhaktiçästré is considered to be an ordained minister. It should be noted here, however, that while the Bhaktiçästré must bear the responsibilities of an ordained minister, he continues in his role as fulltime student as well. At the conclusion of the second year of study, the student has the opportunity to be promoted from Bhaktiçästré to Bhaktivaibhava. Before this title is conferred, the student must have shown his ability to serve as a Bhaktiçästré, must have successfully completed the courses and seminars required in the second year of study, and must pass a comprehensive examination on Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä. At the conclusion of the fifth semester it is possible for the successful student to receive the title of Bhaktivedänta. Once this is conferred, the student ceases to pursue a formal curriculum of study and concentrates his efforts on his ministerial duties and on contributing to the education of the initiates and subordinate ministers.

There is one further formal title to be achieved by a member of the Society. After approximately seven years of service as student and minister, the male student may, if he so wishes, take the Order of Sannyäsa, or renounced order. Upon taking the Order of Sannyäsa, the student receives the title of svämé. Adopting the Order of Sannyäsa is voluntary, and one who adopts this order takes a vow never to marry. Married ministers may take Sannyäsa when the sons are old enough to take care of the wife. When a married minister adopts the Order of Sannyäsa, there is no more personal contact between him and his wife. Generally the Sannyasé (Svämé) moves to another location. In addition to a clear showing of personal worth, the Bhaktivedänta, in order to join the Renounced Order of Life (Svämé), must establish the following:

a. Intensive study of Vedic Scriptures:

1. Caitanya-caritämåta
2. Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu
3. Närada-païcarätra
4. Padma Puräëa
5. Viñëu Puräëa
6. Vedänta-sütra
7. 108 Upaniñads

b. Publication of extensive commentary on one of the above Scriptures.

c. Evidence of extensive ministry work subsequent to ordination.

B.Rules of conduct and personal standards required of ministers and students.

No eating of meat, fish, or eggs. The only food which may be eaten by students or ministers is food prepared under strict dietary regulations and offered by prescribed ceremony to Kåñëa. When traveling or under unusual circumstances, students or ministers may eat foods such as fruit or milk which can be easily offered and which do not necessarily require preparation. Under no circumstances may unoffered food be eaten. In Kåñëa consciousness, eating is an act of worship and must be conducted accordingly.

No illicit sex. Sexual relations are permitted only between individuals married by an ordained minister in Kåñëa consciousness. There is no dating or courtship. Marriage is an arrangement for two devotees of Kåñëa to serve and worship in this way. Marriage is primarily for the purpose of raising children in Kåñëa consciousness.

No intoxicants. This includes all narcotics, alcoholic beverages, tobacco, coffee and tea. The Society's efficiency in automatically getting the youth to abandon the use of marijuana, LSD and other narcotics has drawn commendations from the mayors of New York City and San Francisco. Medicines may be taken when absolutely necessary, but whenever possible medicines containing narcotic substances should be avoided. An occasional drink for "medicinal" purposes is not permitted.

No gambling. This also excludes frivolous sports and games. In addition, students are advised not to engage in any conversation that is not connected with the teachings of Kåñëa consciousness or with the execution of duties.

C.Activities of ministers of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness.

Ministers of the Society have duties to perform which are related to the congregation, to divinity students and to the Society itself. In addition, of course, they are required to pursue two activities for their own education and welfare.

Ministers must conduct services both for regular members of the congregation and for the general public. At these services the ministers lead the congregation in prayer and meditation including congregational chanting of the holy names of Kåñëa. In addition to the prayer and meditation, the minister preaches the principles of Kåñëa consciousness. In this manner he attempts to lead the members of his congregation into a better understanding of the role of the individual in society as well as the role of the individual as a servant of Kåñëa. The public is invited and encouraged to attend these services.

Ministers perform the traditional duties of faculty members of seminaries. The students are given formal instruction, are led on missionary field trips, and are given guidance in their personal lives.

Each minister is required to participate in the administration of this organization. The Society assumes total responsibility for each of its students and ministers and therefore frequently encounters serious and complex problems in securing and distributing the materials necessary to sustain these people. The growth of the Society is thought to be of great importance and therefore much time and energy is expended upon the distribution of literature and promotion of missionary activities. Finally, the Society requires its ministers to assist in the large volume of administrative work one would expect to find in an organization with 31 locations.

HKH 6: Transcendental Aspects

Transcendental Aspects

HKH 6a: Çikhä

Çikhä

The çikhä is a tuft of hair worn by the male devotees who otherwise have shaved heads. For thousands of years, devotees of Kåñëa have worn their hair in this way as a sign of surrender to the spiritual master, who is pleased to see his disciples entering into Kåñëa conscious life. To the public, such signs as the çikhä are constant reminders that the devotees of God are present, and therefore the çikhä indirectly reminds everyone of Kåñëa.

HKH 6b: Beads

Beads

Each devotee always carries a string of 108 japa beads, which are usually carried in a bead bag worn around the neck, and he chants the Hare Kåñëa mantra on these beads. Devotees also wear small beads made of tulasé, a sacred plant, around their necks. These are called kunthi-mälä and further identify one as a Vaiñëava.

HKH 6c: Ärätrika

Ärätrika

Ärätrika is a ceremony in which the Deities are presented offerings of foodstuffs, or incense, flowers, a waving handkerchief, a fan, and an offering of flames. The Deities worshiped in the Kåñëa temples are Jagannätha-svämé with Balaräma and Subhadrä, and the Rädhä-Kåñëa Deities. Every temple also has a picture of Lord Caitanya and saìkértana. The program for temple worship is as follows: Early in the morning, before sunrise, there is maìgala-ärätrika. At 8 a.m. daily, there is dressing and decorating of the altar and offering of breakfast. Then between 11:30 and 12 noon there is an offering of foodstuffs. At 5 p.m. there is the opening of the temple. The temple is closed from 1 p.m. to 4 p.m., and then dhoop ärätrika and an offering of foodstuffs, or bhoga offering are performed. In the morning, fruits and milk are offered to the Deities, and at noon, there are rice, dahl, chapatis, vegetables, milk, sweet rice and many other varieties. Then there is ärätrika after dusk and, at 9 p.m., an offering of puris, vegetables, milk, sweetmeats, etc. After this final ärätrika, the Deity rests. The throne is decorated profusely with flowers. The Deity's dress and ornaments are changed daily, and as far as possible the Deity platform and the temple room are always kept neat and clean.

Articles offered during Ärätrika Ceremony, in proper order:

l. Incense. 2. Camphor and holder. 3. Ghee lamp. 4. Conch shell and water. 5. Handkerchief. 6. Flower. 7. Peacock feather fan. 8. Cämara (yak-tail whisk).
Accessories: A. Bell, rung throughout entire ceremony. B. Water to purify hands and articles. C. Conch shell, blown at end of ceremony.

HKH 6d: Garlands

Garlands

In the daily temple worship, garlands of flowers are offered to the Jagannätha Deities; after these garlands have been worn by the Deities, they are then distributed to the various devotees to wear, and this is very auspicious. In the Vedic scripture Skanda Puräëa, Lord Brahmä states to Närada, "Anyone who puts around his neck a flower garland formerly used by Kåñëa becomes relieved of all disease and reactions to sinful activities, and gradually he becomes liberated from the contamination of matter." Other auspicious temple activities include dancing before the Deities during ärätrika and kértana, bowing down when the curtains of the altar are parted, and circumambulating the temple in front of the Deities. These are all auspicious activities. It is stated in the scriptures that as clapping one's hands causes birds to fly away, so the birds of sinful activities which are sitting on the body can be made to fly away simply by dancing and clapping before the Deity of Kåñëa. Also, incense is burned during temple ceremonies, and to engage the senses in smelling incense offered to Kåñëa is another spiritual practice of the highest order.

HKH 6e: Deities

Deities

Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is able to descend before our eyes in a Deity incarnation of wood, stone, metal, or paint, formed according to authorized descriptions of the Lord. Because with our present materially contaminated senses we cannot see the original spiritual form of the Personality of Godhead, He appears before us, out of His infinite mercy, in the visible form of the Deity, called the arcä incarnation. The arcä form of the Lord is never to be taken as a material object or idol. The example is given by Çréla Prabhupäda that just as mail deposited in an authorized mailbox on the street is accepted by the post office as equal to mail deposited in the central post office, so worship of God by worship of any authorized arcä form, such as Lord Jagannätha, the Rädhä-Kåñëa Deity, or a Païca-tattva painting of Lord Caitanya, is accepted by the Lord as being as good as personal service unto Him. For one who desires to serve the Lord, the Lord provides all facilities. He gives His instructions, the Scriptures, He sends His representative, the bona fide spiritual master, and He comes Himself in the arcä form. The Deities are cared for in a very careful and opulent manner. They are bowed to, bathed, dressed, fed, offered flowers and incense, and especially They are honored by the ärätrika ceremony.

HKH 6f: Diet

Diet

The Kåñëa conscious diet is strictly spiritual; devotees eat only food which is prepared for and offered to Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa states that He accepts "a leaf, a flower, some fruit or some water," if offered in spontaneous love. Based solely on the desires of Kåñëa, the devotees eat only vegetarian food, prepared from milk, sugar, grains, fruits, vegetables, etc., and refrain from eating meat, fish and eggs. By the act of offering nicely prepared food to the Deities, the foodstuffs take on all spiritual properties and are accepted as prasädam, or divine remnants. Because it is offered to and accepted by Kåñëa, prasädam is a spiritually purifying process on a par with chanting or hearing the pastimes of Kåñëa from the Scriptures. Anyone who joins with devotees in taking prasädam at any Kåñëa conscious temple will find that prasädam is sumptuous, nutritious and plentiful. And simply by taking prasädam one can achieve spiritual progress unobtainable for thousands of births in which no tangible link is made with God.

There are many kitchen rules for cooks and helpers preparing foodstuffs to be offered to the Lord. The primary rule is to think of Kåñëa while preparing the foods. Other rules include:

• One should wash hands thoroughly upon entering the kitchen.

• Foodstuffs should be washed as they are prepared.

• Nothing that touches the floor or other contaminated areas, such as the sink or garbage pails, should be used, unless it can be immediately cleansed.

• In all preparations, only fresh foods should be used. Neither canned foods nor leftovers are used.

• Leftovers should never be brought back into the kitchen, but should be kept in a specific place in the dining room.

• In cooking, one should refrain from using garlic, onions or mushrooms and from mixing salt with fresh milk (although salt can be mixed with other milk cultures).

• One should not taste food during its preparation, not even to see if it is done or if it is seasoned properly. Kåñëa is the first to relish prasädam.

When the food is nicely prepared, we offer it back to the Source from which everything emanates. If we remember that His "hunger" is proportional to our love, the offering is sure to be successful. One must simply place love, and a generous portion of each item to be offered, on a plate or metal tray, along with a glass of fresh water, and set it before the Deity. One should then prostrate himself and pray: "O Lord, this material body is a place of ignorance, and the senses are a network of paths to death. Somehow, we have fallen into this ocean of material sense enjoyment, and of all the senses the tongue is most voracious and uncontrollable; it is very difficult to conquer the tongue in this world. But You, dear Kåñëa, are very kind to us and have given us such nice prasädam, just to control the tongue. So now we take that prasädam to our full satisfaction, and glorify You, Lord—Rädhä and Kåñëa—and in love call for the help of Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda."

HKH 7: The Qualifications and Curriculum of the Divinity Student

The Qualifications and Curriculum of the Divinity Student

HKH 7a: Entrance Qualifications:

A. Entrance Qualifications:

Exam. There is no entrance exam required for acceptance into the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. Past education is not a requirement for serving Kåñëa. If a sincere applicant is illiterate, the International Society for Krishna Consciousness will teach him to read and write.

Interview. All prospective students are interviewed extensively, usually several times. The instructors and officers maintain a close personal contact with all students and prospective students.

Personal History and Character. The main requirements are sincerity and dedication. Any applicant will be accepted who sincerely wants to learn Kåñëa consciousness and will commit himself completely to this study with an attitude of complete cooperation with the officers and instructors. Applicants who are potential discipline problems will not be accepted. The study of Kåñëa consciousness is voluntary, and students are expected to follow the rules and regulations without being forced. For this reason sincerity and dedication are essential. Sincere applicants are accepted regardless of their past history. It is recognized that past misdeeds are due to lack of perfect knowledge, and if one seeks the perfect knowledge of Kåñëa consciousness, his misdeeds will be corrected.

HKH 7b: Curriculum

B. Curriculum:

The curriculum is designed to cover a period of 2.5 years. It is divided into five semesters running from September 1 to February 28 and then from March 1 to August 31. As with conventional educational institutions the courses are organized on the principle of semester hours, that is hours per week. The study is, however, much more intensive, as can be seen from the following curriculum, which lists a requirement of 40 semester hours in the first semester as opposed to the normal 15 hours found in most academic institutions.

The curriculum is as follows:

1st Semester:
Courses:

Bhagavad-gétä 1 (10 hrs.)

(Bhagavad-gétä is the primary scripture for Kåñëa consciousness. It is a basic revelation of the distinction between spirit and matter and of the nature and relationships of God, the living entity, time, nature and work. It is studied intensively every day.)

Éçopaniñad 1 (5 hrs.)

(Studies on the form and qualities of Kåñëa. Philosophy of the regulative principles of bhakti-yoga. Study of the form and necessity for the regulations and specific modes of worship and the philosophy behind them.)

Arcä-vigraha Philosophy (4 hrs.)

(Recognition of Kåñëa in Kåñëa conscious art, music, writing, etc. How Kåñëa can be personally present in a painting or book.)

Seminars:

Meditation (7 hrs.)

Individual chanting of the names of Kåñëa. Use of meditative aids, such as painting, etc. Instruction also given on how to meditate in unusual or undesirable surroundings.)

Public Lecturing (10 hrs.)

(Includes field trips into the streets of the city for public chanting and to other places where chanting may be requested by interested groups. Students get first-hand experience in preaching.)

2nd Semester:
Courses:

Bhagavad-gétä 2 (10 hrs.)

(Continuation of Bhagavad-gétä 1)

Éçopaniñad 2 (5 hrs.)

(Continuation of Éçopaniñad 1)

Vaiñëava Theology 1 (4 hrs.)

(Study of the different incarnations of Kåñëa, differences between Kåñëa and demigods.)

Comparative Philosophy (3 hrs.)

(Similarities and differences between Kåñëa consciousness and other teachings.)

Temple Music 1 (2 hrs.)

(Learning to play instruments used in ceremonial music. Also includes listening to tapes and records of authentic Kåñëa consciousness music.)

Seminars:

Meditation (7 hrs.)

(Continuation)

Public Lecturing (10 hrs.)

(Continuation)

3rd Semester:
Courses:

Bhagavad-gétä 3 (10 hrs.)

(Continuation)

Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1 (5 hrs.)

(Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the scripture describing the activities of Kåñëa and His devotees.)

Brahma-saàhitä 1 (3 hrs.)

(Brahma-saàhitä is the scripture describing the process and nature of the material and spiritual creations.)

Vaiñëava Theology 2 (3 hrs.)

(Continuation)

Temple Music 2 (2 hrs.)

(Continuation)

Jagannätha Püjä (2 hrs.)

(Method of worship of the form known as Jagannätha.)

Seminars

Meditation (7 hrs.)

Public Lecturing (10 hrs.)

(Continuation. Student may now lead groups.)

4th Semester:
Courses:

Bhagavad-gétä 4 (10 hrs.)

(Continuation. Student is required to begin writing commentaries.)

Çrémad-Bhägavatam 2 (5 hrs.)

(Continuation)

Brahma-saàhitä 2 (3 hrs.)

(Continuation)

Rädhä-Kåñëa Püjä (2 hrs.)

(Method of worshiping the forms of Rädhä and Kåñëa.)

Cooking 1 (lab) (4 hrs.)

(Preparation of foods for offering to Kåñëa and distribution among devotees and others.)

Philosophy of Prasädam (Spiritual Food) (4 hrs.)

(Study of the uses and spiritual values of different ingredients; scriptural references to foods; how to recognize Kåñëa in food.)

History of Saìkértana Movement (2 hrs.)

(History of Kåñëa conscious teachings on this planet. Lives of the great saints.)

Seminars:

Meditation (7 hrs.)

Public Lecturing (10 hrs.)

(Continuation. Student contacts interested groups on his own and makes arrangements for public chanting.)

5th Semester:
Courses:

Bhagavad-gétä 5 (10 hrs.)

(Continuation. Student must be able to accurately quote verses and to debate, substantiating his arguments with verses from the Bhagavad-gétä.)

Teachings of Lord Caitanya (5 hrs.)

This is the scripture describing the life and activities of Kåñëa Caitanya, Kåñëa appearing as a devotee of Kåñëa.)

The Nectar of Devotion (5 hrs.)

(This scripture goes into further detail of the activities, qualities, and bodily characteristics of Kåñëa.

Sanskrit Transliteration Reading (3 hrs.)

(Reading, with accurate pronunciation and understanding of Sanskrit, written with English characters.)

Bengali Transliteration Reading (3 hrs.)

(Reading, with accurate pronunciation and understanding of Bengali written with English characters.)

Seminars:

Meditation (7 hrs.)

(Continuation)
Public Lecturing (10 hrs.)

(Continuation)
Debating (5 hrs.)

(Debating with atheists and followers of impersonal philosophies. For purposes of debate, student will assume role of antagonist. After 2.5 years of public lecturing, students become very familiar with atheistic and impersonal arguments.)

HKH 7c: Qualifications of a Devotee

Qualifications of a Devotee

These twenty-six qualifications of a devotee are listed in the Vedic Scripture Caitanya-caritämåta.

• Kind to everyone
• Does not quarrel with anyone
• Fixed in the Absolute Truth
• Equal to everyone
• Faultless
• Charitable
• Mild
• Clean
• Simple
• Benevolent
• Peaceful
• Completely attached to Kåñëa
• Has no material hankering
• Meek
• Steady
• Self-controlled
• Does not eat more than required
• Sane
• Respectful
• Humble
• Grave
• Compassionate
• Friendly
• Poetic
• Expert
• Silent

HKH 7d: Principles of Devotional Service

Principles of Devotional Service

Generally, in devotional service, one should accept the following principles:

• Accepting the shelter of the lotus feet of a bona fide spiritual master.

• Becoming initiated by the spiritual master and learning how to discharge devotional service from him.

• Obeying the orders of the spiritual master with faith and devotion.

• Following in the footsteps of great äcäryas (teachers) under the direction of the spiritual master.

• Inquiring from the spiritual master how to advance in Kåñëa consciousness.

• Being prepared to give up anything material for the satisfaction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa. (This means that when we are engaged in the devotional service of Kåñëa, we must be prepared to give up something we may not like to give up and also accept something which we may not like to accept).

• Residing in a sacred place of pilgrimage like Dvärakä or Våndävana.

• Dealing with the material world only as far as is necessary.

• Observing the fasting day on Ekädäsé, (On Ekädaçé, the eleventh day after the full moon and the eleventh day after the new moon, no grains, cereals or beans are to be eaten. Simple vegetables and milk are taken in moderate amounts, and chanting of Hare Kåñëa, reading of Scripture, etc., is increased.)

• Worshiping sacred trees like the banyan tree and others.

These ten items are preliminary necessities for beginning the discharge of devotional service according to regulative principles. In the beginning, if a neophyte devotee observes the above mentioned ten principles, surely he will quickly make good advancement in Kåñëa consciousness.

The next set of six instructions are listed as follows:

• One should rigidly give up the company of nondevotees.

• One should not instruct a person who is not desirous of accepting devotional service.

• One should not be very enthusiastic about constructing costly temples or monasteries.

• One should not try to read too many books, nor should one develop the idea of earning his livelihood by lecturing on or by professionally reciting Çrémad-Bhägavatam or the Bhagavad-gétä.

• One should not be neglectful in ordinary dealings.

• One should not be under the spell of lamentation in loss or jubilation in gain.

The activities of devotional service can be analyzed as follows:

• hearing
• chanting
• remembering
• worshiping
• praying
• serving
• engaging as a servitor of the Lord
• establishing a friendly relationship with the Lord
• dancing before the Deity
• offering everything to the Lord
• singing
• informing
• offering obeisances
• standing up to show respect to the devotees
• when a devotee goes, following him up to the door
• entering into the temple of the Lord
• circumambulating the temple
• reading prayers
• vibrating hymns
• performing saìkértana, or congregational chanting
• smelling the incense and flowers offered to the Deity
• accepting prasädam (food which has been offered to Kåñëa)
• seeing ärätrika, the ceremonial performance of receiving the Lord
• seeing the Deity
• offering to the Lord His own palatable foodstuffs
• meditating
• offering water to the tulasé tree
• offering respect to the Vaiñëavas, or advanced devotees
• living in Mathurä or Våndävana
•understanding Çrémad-Bhägavatam
• trying for Kåñëa to one's utmost capacity
•expecting the mercy of Kåñëa
• performing the ceremonial functions of Kåñëa with devotees
• surrendering in all respects
• observing various ceremonial functions

To these thirty-five items another four are to be added:

• marking the body with sandalwood pulp to show that one is a Vaiñëava
• painting the body with the holy names of the Lord
• accepting flowers and garlands that have been offered to the Deity and spiritual master and putting them on one's body
• accepting caraëämåta, or the water from the baths of the Deities which is offered to guests.

Adding these four items to the above thirty-five, we have thirty-nine items for devotional service. Out of these, the most important items are:

• to associate with devotees
• to chant the holy name of the Lord
• to hear Çrémad-Bhägavatam
• to live in a holy place such as Mathurä or Våndävana
• to serve the Deity with great devotion

They are especially mentioned by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé in his book Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu.

HKH 7e: Chanting Offenselessly

Chanting Offenselessly

There are ten kinds of offenses in chanting the holy name, and they should be avoided. The offenses are as follows:

• to blaspheme the devotees who have dedicated their lives for propagating the holy name of the Lord.

• to consider the names of demigods like Lord Çiva or Lord Brahmä to be equal to, or independent of, the name of Lord Viñëu. (Sometimes the atheistic class of men take it that any demigod is as good as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Viñëu. But one who is a devotee knows that no demigod, however great he may be, is independently as good as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore, if somebody thinks that he can chant Kälé, Kälé! or Durgä, Durgä! and it is the same as Hare Kåñëa, that is the greatest offense.)

• to disobey the orders of the spiritual master.

• to blaspheme the Vedic literature or literature in pursuance of the Vedic version.

• to consider the glories of chanting Hare Kåñëa to be imagination.

• to interpret the holy name of the Lord.

• to commit sinful activities on the strength of the holy name of the Lord. (Because by chanting the holy name of the Lord one can be freed from all kinds of sinful reactions, it should not be taken that one may continue to act sinfully and after that chant Hare Kåñëa to neutralize his sins. Such a mentality is a very dangerous offense and should be avoided.)

• to consider the chanting of Hare Kåñëa to be one of the auspicious ritualistic activities which are offered in the Vedas as fruitive activities (karma-käëòa).

• to instruct a faithless person about the glories of the holy name. (Anyone can take part in chanting the holy name of the Lord, but in the beginning one should not be instructed about the transcendental potency of the Lord. Those who are too sinful cannot appreciate the transcendental glories of the Lord, and therefore it is better in the beginning not to instruct them in this matter.)

• to not have complete faith in the chanting of the holy names and to maintain material attachments, even after understanding so many instructions on this matter.

Every devotee who claims to be a Vaiñëava must guard against these offenses in order to quickly achieve the desired success.

HKH 7f: New Våndävana
The Community of Souls: Unity in Authority

New Våndävana
The Community of Souls: Unity in Authority

The integral or utopian community is not new in American history. Indeed, it has been a most basic part of our history from the Puritan experiment at Massachusetts Bay in the 1630's to this New Våndävana experiment in the 1970's.

Despite differences of dress and circumstance, the aim of most of these communal experiences has been basically the same: to find a setting in which God consciousness, expanded consciousness, or "Kåñëa consciousness" can be pursued so that man's journey through this temporary sphere of material existence can be successfully completed to transfer his consciousness to the Absolute or to the realms of eternality. The conception of a "community of souls" is founded on the premise that such a transferral is easier collectively than individually. Different experimenters have expressed the ideal community in different ways. Some have been more successful than others, largely depending on the authority on which the community is based. Some have been based upon a strong personal authority (Brigham Young or John Smith and the Mormons, or Humphrey Knolls and the Socialist Community at Oneida). New Våndävana is different in that it is based on perfect authority. If we analyze the various communities of the past we can see that they have fallen apart because they could not agree as to what was the center of the community, what was its aims, what was its unifying point. The most successful communities tended to be those that were strongly religious. They could unify on the basis of the worship of God. And obviously where the concept of God is most agreed upon, that community will be most united and most harmonious. So, at New Våndävana we are basing our community on God, or "Kåñëa," as revealed by guru and çästra, that is, the spiritual master and the information given by God Himself in the Vedic scripture Bhagavad-gétä. The essense of that teaching is the sublime chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, and it is through this transcendental vibration that there is unity of purpose at New Våndävana.

Transcendental Activity:
Devotion Through Work

The New Våndävana experiment helps the young people in the Society direct their service toward Kåñëa. Most Americans are acquainted with Kåñëa through the Bhagavad-gétä. In that Scripture, Kåñëa, speaking as the Supreme Godhead, gives instructions to Arjuna, a man caught in the complexities of daily life, how to attain Him, the ultimate goal of all. In brief, Kåñëa tells him to execute this work, but to do it for the sake of the Supreme. This is the primary message of the Gétä. The New Våndävana Project puts this message into practice. This is also the actualization of St. Paul's, "Whatever you do in word or in work, do everything in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through Jesus Christ, our Lord." It is not that Kåñëa consciousness is inactive in any sense. The practitioners engage in work which may appear to be ordinary work but is in fact devotional service due to the change in consciousness. Everyone in New Våndävana is aware that his work is devotional in character and is directed to the Supreme Godhead because the factual proprietor of the land, of the buildings, of the temples, of the food, of the vehicles, tools and all the varied paraphernalia is Kåñëa. The awareness of Kåñëa's proprietorship enables the devotee to advance in Kåñëa consciousness while executing his daily chores.

New Våndavana:
The Land

In August, 1968, the Society purchased 133 acres of beautiful farm and woodland near Wheeling, West Virginia. The land contains meadows, pastures and good garden land, and there are springs, creeks and waterfalls. The original buildings consist of a farmhouse, barn, and several other small buildings. More than thirty Society members have taken up permanent residence on the farm and have begun working the land to change it into a transcendental community. Already some of the old buildings have been renovated to allow for temporary residence, and several new A-frame houses have been constructed, but largely the project is in the formative stage. At present there are approximately a thousand acres of adjacent land up for sale, and as our needs require we will expand geographically. Land can be purchased in West Virginia at a nominal sum.

Indian Model

What does "New Våndävana" mean? Våndä is the Sanskrit name for the holy tulasé trees, and vana means forest. Today Våndävana is a holy town in India, some ninety miles southeast of Delhi. Five thousand years ago when Lord Kåñëa, the Absolute Godhead, descended on earth, He sported in Våndävana as a cowherd boy. Now Våndävana has thousands of temples dedicated to Lord Kåñëa, and thousands of pilgrims come there each year to pay homage to the speaker of the Bhagavad-gétä. New Våndävana will be modeled on this village, and, like its model, will have seven major temples.

New Våndävana and Cow Protection

When Kåñëa descended from the spiritual sky 5,000 years ago, He gave a practical example of the ideal life when He sported as a cowherd boy. He showed that man can live very simply and reserve his main energies for what Emerson called "high thinking" ("plain living and high thinking") by protecting and cultivating the cow. So one of the aims of New Våndävana is to protect the cow and to demonstrate the value of the cow in providing for the sustenance of man.

At New Våndävana, the cow is more than just an ordinary animal. Aside from the fact that Kåñëa was very fond of cows and that the cow is considered man's second mother in the Vedas ("dhenu mätä"), the cow represents man's religion or man's yearning and love for God. When such yearning and love are slaughtered, then man is left with the empty shell of materialism, or life without principle and meaning. So one of the main functions of New Våndävana is to demonstrate the humane practicality of cow protection.

Agricultural and Horticultural Programs

An important part of our program is the development of agricultural land. Presently four acres of garden are under cultivation. An extensive fruit orchard has just been planted. This will all increase as we reach toward our goal of self-sufficiency. With our hothouses and our canning process, we anticipate supplying our own food year round. As for animal husbandry, we now have five milk cows (Jerseys), and this will soon be tripled, giving us a more than adequate supply of milk, butter, cheeses, etc. Also, in our attempt to avoid machinery as far as possible, we have two workhorses that transport materials up from the main road and plow and cultivate our gardens. When our cows give bulls, we will use oxen to do much of the heavy work.

Primary and Secondary Education

Immediately plans call for the building of a schoolhouse and dormitories for a primary and secondary school. There are at least twenty children of Society members who wish to attend school at New Våndävana. Classes have already begun, and a schoolhouse is now under construction. The faculty of the New Våndävana School includes one PhD, several MA's and several former teachers of elementary and secondary schools.

The curriculum includes courses in Kåñëa, study of the Vedic literature, Bhagavad-gétä, Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Caitanya-caritämåta, Brahma-saàhitä, the Upaniñads and the basic çästras, as well as the basic courses in American history, American and British literature, mathematics, etc. That is, a firm basis of the traditional academic subjects, as well as practical training in horticulture, agriculture and Vedic scriptures, is being offered.

Construction of Temples and Living Quarters

The most extraordinary feature of New Våndävana will be the temples. Temples will be constructed in such a way as to create a replica of Våndävana, India. In Våndävana, India, there are seven principal temples as well as thousands of small, private temples. The "thousands" may not be realized immediately, but our program does call for the building of seven major temples, if not all on the present 133-acre site, at least on some of the adjacent land we will be acquiring in the future.

In addition to temples and a school, we are building quarters for single male students and married couples. Quarters for the unmarried men (brahmacärés) will be individual cabins designed for not more than two. Married couples (gåhasthas) will of course have their own dwellings.

A Typical Day

Specifically, how are the residents of New Våndävana engaged? The day begins at 5 a.m. as a gong announces a lively ärätrika, which involves dancing and the singing of Sanskrit songs and hymns. Then there is a group chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra and a reading and discussion of Bhagavad-gétä. This lasts until 7 a.m. Breakfast prasädam is served after the chanting, and by 8 a.m. the men are out in the fields working on the pasture or in the gardens—cultivating flowers, grains, fruits and vegetables—or building roads, clearing land, building walkways and buildings, milking cows, tending the animals, or any one of the many farm chores; and the women are engaged in preparing the main noon meal, tending children, churning butter, and cleaning. Most of the daily chores are carried on between 8 a.m. and 1 p.m., at which time the main meal of the day is served. The remainder of the afternoon is devoted to personal activities—which may include chanting, reading or bathing at the waterfall and stream that run through the property. Then at 7 p.m. another ärätrika and chanting is begun. There is usually a lecture on Bhagavad-gétä or Çrémad-Bhägavatam following the chanting. These activities usually last until 9 p.m., when more food is taken. Everyone is usually in bed around 10 or 10:30.

The children are on a slightly different schedule. They attend school from 10 to 12 a.m. and from 3 to 5 p.m. During the other hours, their training is of a practical sort, and they are under the guidance of one of the older members in the various departments of activity.

Statements by Çréla Prabhupäda on New Våndävana

"The Våndävana conception is that of a transcendental village, without any of the botheration of the modern industrial atmosphere. My idea of developing New Våndävana is to create an atmosphere of spiritual life where people in the bona fide divisions of society—namely brahmacärés, (celibate students), gåhasthas (householders), vänaprasthas (the retired), and sannyäsés (renounced holy men)—will live independently, completely depending on agricultural produce and milk from the cows."

"To retire from activities is not a very good idea for the conditioned soul. I have very good experience, not only in our country, but also in your country, that this tendency of retiring from activities pushes one down to the platform of laziness, and gradually to the ideas of the hippies.

"One should always remain active in Kåñëa's service; otherwise strong mäyä (illusion) will catch him and engage him in her service. Our constitutional position being to render service, we cannot stop activity. So New Våndävana may not be turned into a place of retirement, but some sort of activities must go on there. If there is good prospective land, we should keep cows and produce some grains, flowers and fruits, so that those living there may have sufficient work and facility for advancing in Kåñëa consciousness.

"Våndavana does not require to be modernized, because Kåñëa's Våndävana is a transcendental village. They completely depend on nature's beauty and nature's protection. The community in which Kåñëa preferred to belong was the vaiçya community, because Nanda Mahäräja (Kåñëa's foster father, with whom He spent His childhood while on Earth) happened to be a vaiçya king, or landholder, and his main business was cow protection. It is understood that he had 900,000 cows, and Kåñëa and Balaräma, along with Kåñëa's many cowherd boy friends, used to take charge of them. Every day, in the morning, Kåñëa used to go out with His friends and cows into the pasturing grounds.

"So, if you seriously want to convert this spot into New Våndävana, I shall advise you not to make it very much modernized. But as you are American boys, you must make it just suitable to your minimum needs. Nor should you make it too luxurious, as Europeans and Americans are generally accustomed. Better to live there without modern amenities and to live a natural, healthy life for executing Kåñëa consciousness. It may be an ideal village where the residents will have plain living and high thinking.

"For plain living we must have sufficient land for raising crops, and pasturing grounds for the cows. If there are sufficient grains and sufficient production of milk, then the whole economic problem is solved. You do not require any machines, cinemas, hotels, slaughterhouses, brothels, nightclubs-all these modern amenities. People in the spell of mäyä are trying to squeeze out gross pleasure from the senses, which it is not possible to derive to our heart's content. Therefore we are confused and baffled in our attempt to get eternal pleasure from gross matter. Actually, joyful life is on the spiritual platform, and therefore we should try to save our valuable time from material activities and engage it in Kåñëa consciousness.

"The idea is that people residing in New Våndävana may not have to search for work outside. Arrangements should be such that the residents will be self-satisfied. That will make an ideal äçrama. I do not know whether these ideals can be given practical shape, but I think like that, that people may be happy in any place with land or cow, without endeavoring for the so-called amenities of modern life, which simply increase anxieties for maintenance and proper equipment. The less we are anxious for maintaining our body, the more we become favorable for advancing in Kåñëa consciousness."

"Now we can work with great enthusiasm for constructing a New Våndävana in the United States of America. People who came here from Europe to this part of the world named so many new provinces, just like New England, New Amsterdam and New York. So I also came to this part of the world to preach Kåñëa consciousness, and by His grace and by your endeavor, New Våndävana is being constructed. That is my great happiness. Our sincere endeavor in the service of the Lord, and of the Lord's assistants, to make our progressive march successful-these are two important things to be followed in the spiritual advancement of life."

HKH 7g: Tilaka

Tilaka

• Forehead: Çré Keçaväya namaù
• Abdomen: Çré Näräyaëäya namaù
• Chest: Çré Mädhaväya namaù
• Throat: Çré Govindäya namaù
• Right waist: Çré Viñëave namaù
• Right forearm: Çré Madhusüdanäya namaù
• Right shoulder: Çré Trivikramäya namaù
• Left waist: Çré Vämanäya namaù
• Left forearm: Çré Çrédharäya namaù
• Left shoulder: Çré Håñékeçäya namaù
• Nape of neck: Çré Padmanäbhäya namaù
• Lower back: Çré Dämodaräya namaù
• Head: Çré Väsudeväya namaù

Tilaka is sometimes called the ornamentation of the spirit soul. The decoration, made by applying wet clay mixture, marks the body as a temple of Viñëu, the Supreme Lord. The Vaiñëava devotee marks his body in twelve places for sanctification and protection, and one who is wearing tilaka can at once be identified as a devotee of the Lord. Just as one can recognize that the strength of the government is behind a uniformed policeman, one can understand that the strength of God is behind a devotee marked with tilaka.

HKH 7h: ISKCON Press

ISKCON Press

ISKCON Press trains young men in all phases of the printing trade and turns out the society's ever increasing volume of literature. The press department was started by several of His Divine Grace's disciples who worked at commercial printing jobs for a number of years. The savings they earned over that time were eventually put toward the purchase of printing machinery, which was set up in the building owned by the Boston Center of ISKCON, and with the skill gained by years of outside experience, they began publishing the holy Vedic Scriptures, such as Éçopaniñad and Bhagavad-gétä, as translated by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, and the society's magazine, Back to Godhead, which has a monthly circulation of 150,000 and is printed in four languages. His Divine Grace has asked the press to produce a book every two months, and he has also prepared to translate sixty volumes of the Scripture Çrémad-Bhägavatam over a ten-year period. These plans are actually progressing on schedule, by the grace of Kåñëa.

ISKCON Press receives dictaphone tapes of Çréla Prabhupäda speaking; these are typed, edited and layed out, then printed, bound and shipped to worldwide centers of Kåñëa consciousness. Also in Boston, an art department of four devotees, painters, whose works are all authorized by the spiritual master, produces magnificent color illustrations for all books published by ISKCON Press. ISKCON Press is a beehive of transcendental activity existing solely for the glorification of the Supreme Lord, and it has been called the "heart of ISKCON" by Çréla Prabhupäda.

HKH 7i: Preface to Kåñëa,
The Supreme Personality of Godhead

Preface to Kåñëa,
the Supreme Personality of Godhead

HKH 7j: On Chanting the Hare Kåñëa Mantra...
...A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

On Chanting
the Hare Kåñëa Mantra
... by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

The transcendental vibration established by the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is the sublime method for reviving our transcendental consciousness. As living spiritual souls, we are all originally Kåñëa conscious entities, but due to our association with matter from time immemorial, our consciousness is now adulterated by the material atmosphere. The material atmosphere, in which we are now living, is called mäyä, or illusion. Mäyä means that which is not. And what is this illusion? The illusion is that we are all trying to be lords of material nature, while actually we are under the grip of her stringent laws. When a servant artificially tries to imitate the all-powerful master, it is called illusion. We are trying to exploit the resources of material nature, but actually we are becoming more and more entangled in her complexities. Therefore, although we are engaged in a hard struggle to conquer nature, we are ever more dependent on her. This illusory struggle against material nature can be stopped at once by revival of our eternal Kåñëa consciousness.

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare is the transcendental process for reviving this original pure consciousness. By chanting this transcendental vibration, we can cleanse away all misgivings within our hearts. The basic principle of all such misgivings is the false consciousness that I am the lord of all I survey.

Kåñëa consciousness is not an artificial imposition on the mind. This consciousness is the original natural energy of the living entity. When we hear the transcendental vibration, this consciousness is revived. This simplest method of meditation is recommended for this age. By practical experience also, one can perceive that by chanting this mahämantra, or the Great Chanting for Deliverance, one can at once feel a transcendental ecstasy coming through from the spiritual stratum. In the material concept of life we are busy in the matter of sense gratification as if we were in the lower animal stage. A little elevated from this status of sense gratification, one is engaged in mental speculation for the purpose of getting out of the material clutches. A little elevated from this speculative status, when one is intelligent enough, one tries to find out the supreme cause of all causes—within and without. And when one is factually on the plane of spiritual understanding, surpassing the stages of sense, mind and intelligence, he is then on the transcendental plane. This chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra is enacted from the spiritual platform, and thus this sound vibration surpasses all lower strata of consciousness—namely sensual, mental and intellectual. There is no need, therefore, to understand the language of the mantra, nor is there any need for mental speculation nor any intellectual adjustment for chanting this mahämantra. It is automatic, from the spiritual platform, and as such, anyone can take part in vibrating this transcendental sound without any previous qualification. In a more advanced stage, of course, one is not expected to commit offenses on grounds of spiritual understanding.

In the beginning, there may not be the presence of all transcendental ecstasies, which are eight in number. These are:
1) Being stopped as though dumb, 2) perspiration, 3) standing up of hairs on the body, 4) dislocation of voice, 5) trembling, 6) fading of the body, 7) crying in ecstasy, and 8) trance.

But there is no doubt that chanting for a while takes one immediately to the spiritual platform, and one shows the first symptom of this in the urge to dance along with the chanting of the mantra. We have seen this practically. Even a child can take part in the chanting and dancing. Of course, for one who is too entangled in material life, it takes a little more time to come to the standard point, but even such a materially engrossed man is raised to the spiritual platform very quickly. When it is chanted by a pure devotee of the Lord in love, it has the greatest efficacy on hearers, and as such this chanting should be heard from the lips of a pure devotee of the Lord, so that immediate effects can be achieved. As far as possible, chanting from the lips of nondevotees should be avoided. Milk touched by the lips of a serpent has poisonous effects.

The word Harä is the form of addressing the energy of the Lord, and the words Kåñëa and Räma are forms of addressing the Lord Himself. Both Kåñëa and Räma mean the supreme pleasure, and Hara is the supreme pleasure energy of the Lord, changed to Hare in the vocative. The supreme pleasure energy of the Lord helps us to reach the Lord.

The material energy, called mäyä, is also one of the multi-energies of the Lord. And we the living entities are also the energy, marginal energy, of the Lord. The living entities are described as superior to material energy. When the superior energy is in contact with the inferior energy, an incompatible situation arises; but when the superior marginal energy is in contact with the superior energy, called Harä, it is established in its happy, normal condition.

These three words, namely Harä, Kåñëa and Räma, are the transcendental seeds of the mahämantra. The chanting is a spiritual call for the Lord and His energy, to give protection to the conditioned soul. This chanting is exactly like the genuine cry of a child for its mother's presence. Mother Harä helps the devotee achieve the Lord Father's grace, and the Lord reveals Himself to the devotee who chants this mantra sincerely.

No other means of spiritual realization is as effective in this age of quarrel and hypocrisy as the mahämantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

Books by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

The Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam
(3 volumes)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead
(2 volumes)
The Nectar of Devotion
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Back to Godhead Magazine
(Editor)
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
The Kåñëa Consciousness Movement is the Genuine Vedic Way
Çré Éçopaniñad
The First Step in God Realization
The Lord in the Heart

For detailed information about the books of A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, please turn to page 86 of this handbook.

Calendar for 484
of the Caitanya Era

Explanation of the Calendar

Kåñëa consciousness is eternal, without beginning or end, but for purposes of impelling thoughts of Kåñëa, the devotees follow a calendar originating with the appearance day of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who is declared by the Vedic scriptures to be the avatära, or incarnation of God for this age, appeared to distribute love of Kåñëa everywhere by His saìkértana chanting movement.

The corresponding Gregorian calendar dates appear alongside the calendar dates for the Caitanya Era.

[At this point the calendar appears, difficult to reproduce in this media]

HKH 7l: Devotional Prayers

Devotional Prayers

MAÌGALÄCARAËA

vande 'haà çré-guroù çré-yuta-pada-kamalaà çré-gurun vaiñëaväàç ca
çré-rüpaà sägrajätaà saha-gaëa-raghunäthänvitaà taà sa-jévam
sädvaitaà sävadhütaà parijana-sahitaà kåñëa-caitanya-devaà
çré-rädhä-kåñëa-pädän saha-gaëa-lalitä-çré-viçäkhänvitäàç ca.

(I am offering my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of my spiritual master and unto the feet of all Vaiñëavas. I offer my respectful obeisances to Lord Kåñëa Caitanya and Lord Nityänanda, along with Advaita Äcärya, Gadädhara, Çréväsa, and other associates. I offer my respectful obeisances to Çrématé Rädhäräëé and Çré Kåñëa, along with Their associates Çré Lalitä and Viçäkhä.) [Purport]

ÇRÉLA-PRABHUPÄDA-PRAËATI

nama oà viñëu-pädäya kåñëa-preñöhäya bhütale
çrémate bhaktivedänta-svämin iti nämine

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, who is very dear to Lord Kåñëa, having taken shelter at His lotus feet.)

namas te särasvate deve gaura-väëé-pracäriëe
nirviçeña-çünyavädi-päçcätya-deça-täriëe

(Our respectful obeisances are unto you, O spiritual master, servant of Sarasvaté Gosvämé. You are kindly preaching the message of Lord Caitanyadeva and delivering the Western countries, which are filled with impersonalism and voidism.)

ÇRÉ-GURU-PRAËÄMA

om ajïäna-timirändhasya jïänäïjana-çaläkayä
cakñur unmélitaà yena tasmai çré-gurave namaù

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto my spiritual master, who has opened my eyes, blinded by the darkness of ignorance, with the torchlight of knowledge.)

ÇRÉLA-BHAKTISIDDHÄNTA-SARASVATÉ PRAËATI

nama oà viñëu-pädäya kåñëa-preñöhäya bhütale
çrémate bhaktisiddhänta-sarasvatéti nämine

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto His Divine Grace Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, who is very dear to Lord Kåñëa, having taken shelter at His lotus feet.)

çré-värñabhänavédevé-dayitäya kåpäbdhaye
kåñëa-sambandha-vijïäna-däyine prabhave namaù

(I offer my respectful obeisances to Çré Värñabhänavédevédayita Däsa [another spiritual name of Siddhänta Sarasvaté], who is favored by Çrématé Rädhäräëé and who is the ocean of transcendental mercy and the deliverer of the science of Kåñëa.)

mädhuryojjvala-premäòhya-çré-rüpänuga-bhaktida
çré-gaura-karuëä-çakti-vigrahäya namo 'stu te

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto you, who delivers devotional service which is enriched with conjugal love of Rädhä and Kåñëa, coming exactly in the line of revelation of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé.)

namas te gaura-väëé-çré-mürtaye déna-täriëe
rüpänuga-viruddhäpa-siddhänta-dhvänta-häriëe

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto you, who are the personified teachings of Lord Caitanya. You are the deliverer of the fallen souls. You do not tolerate any statement which is against the teachings of devotional service enunciated by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé.)

ÇRÉLA-GAURAKIÇORA-PRAËATI

namo gaura-kiçoräya säkñäd-vairägya-mürtaye
vipralambha-rasämbhode pädämbujäya te namaù

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto Gaura-kiçoradäsa Bäbäjé Mahäräja [the spiritual master of Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté], who is renunciation personified. He is always merged in a feeling of separation and intense love of Kåñëa.)

ÇRÉLA-BHAKTIVINODA-PRAËATI

namo bhaktivinodäya saccidänanda-nämine
gaura-çakti-svarüpäya rüpänuga-varäya te

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto Saccidänanda Bhaktivinode, who is transcendental energy of Caitanya Mahäprabhu. He is strict follower of the Gosvämés, headed by Çréla Rüpa.)

ÇRÉLA-JAGANNÄTHA-PRAËATI

gaurävirbhäva-bhümes tvaà nirddeñöä saj-jana-priyaù
vaiñëava-särvabhaumaù çré-jagannäthäya te namaù

(I offer my respectful obeisances to Jagannätha däs Bäbäjé, who is respectful to the entire Vaiñëava community and who discovered the place where Lord Caitanya appeared.)

ÇRÉ-VAIÑËAVA-PRAËÄMA

väïchä-kalpa-tarubhyaç ca kåpä-sindhubhya eva ca
patitänäà pävanebhyo vaiñëavebhyo namo namaù

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto all the Vaiñëava devotees of the Lord. They are just like desire trees who can fulfill the desires of everyone, and they are full of compassion for the fallen conditioned souls.)

ÇRÉ-GAURÄÌGA-PRAËÄMA

namo mahä-vadänyäya kåñëa-prema-pradäya te
kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-nämne gaura-tviñe namaù

(I offer my respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya, who is more magnanimous than any other avatära, even Kåñëa Himself, because He is bestowing freely what no one else has ever given-pure love of Kåñëa.)

ÇRÉ PAÏCA-TATTVA PRAËÄMA

païca-tattvätmakaà kåñëaà bhakta-rüpa-svarüpakam
bhaktävatäraà bhaktäkhyaà namämi bhakta-çaktikam

(I bow down to Lord Kåñëa, who appears as a devotee [Lord Caitanya Himself], as His personal expansion [Çré Nityänanda], His incarnation [Çré Advaita], His devotee [Çré Çréväsa], and His energy [Çré Gadädhara], and who is the source of all strength for the devotees.)

SAMBANDHÄDHIDEVER PRAËÄMA

jayatäà suratau paìgor mama manda-mater gaté
mat-sarva-sva-padämbhojau rädhä-madanamohanau

(Glory to the all-merciful Çré Rädhä and Madanamohana. They are the only shelter of my depraved and crippled self. Their lotus feet are the be-all and end-all of my life.)

ÇRÉ KÅÑËA PRAËÄMA

he kåñëa karuëä-sindho déna-bandho jagat-pate
gopeça gopikä-känta rädhä-känta namo 'stu te

(O my dear Kåñëa, You are the friend of the distressed and the source of creation. You are the master of the gopés and the lover of Rädhäräëé. I offer my respectful obeisances unto You.)

ABHIDHEYÄDHIDEVER-PRAËÄMA

dévyad-våndäraë ya-kalpadrumädhaù
çrémad-ratnägära-siàhäsana-sthau
çrémad-rädhä-çréla-govindadevau
preñöhälébhiù sevyamänau smarämi

(I meditate on Çré Rädhä and Govinda. They are seated on a throne in a mansion bedecked with gems under the desire trees in Våndävana, being served by Their loving female attendants.)

PRAYOJANÄDHIDEVER PRAËÄMA

çrémän räsa-rasärambhé vaàçévaöa-taöa-sthitaù
karñan veëu-svanair gopér gopénäthaù çriye 'stu naù

(May Lord Gopénätha confer on us His grace. He inaugurated the räsa-lélä by attracting the spiritual milkmaids of Vraja with the enchanting tune of His flute, and He is seated at the base of the vaàçévata tree.)

ÇRÉ RÄDHÄ PRAËÄMA

tapta-käïcana-gauräìgi rädhe våndävaneçvari
våñabhänu-sute devi praëamämi hari-priye

(I offer my respects to Rädhäräëé, whose bodily complexion is like molten gold and who is the Queen of Våndävana. You are the daughter of King Våñabhänu, and You are very dear to Lord Kåñëa.)

Verse quoted by Lord Caitanya, from the Båhan-Näradéya Puräëa:

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä.
(B.N. 38.126)

(Chant the holy name, chant the holy name, chant the holy name. There is no other alternative, there is no other alternative, there is no other alternative for God realization in the Age of Kali.)

ÇRÉ GURVAÑÖAKAM
(Eight Prayers Glorifying the Spiritual Master)
-by Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkur

1)

saàsära-dävänala-léòha-loka-
träëäya käruëya-ghanäghanatvam
präptasya kalyäëa-guëärëavasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

(The spiritual master is receiving benediction from the ocean of mercy. Just as the cloud pours water on the forest fire to extinguish it, so the spiritual master extinguishes the blazing fire of material existence. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master.)

2)

mahäprabhoù kértana-nåtya-géta-
väditramädyan-manaso rasena
romäïca-kampäçrutaraìgabhäjo
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

(The spiritual master is always engaged in chanting and hearing the message of Lord Caitanya and sometimes is dancing in ecstasy. Sometimes he feels quivering in his body because of spiritual trance. I offer my respectful obeisances unto such spiritual master.)

3)

çré-vigrahärädhana-nitya-nänä-
çåìgära-tan-mandiramärjanädau
yuktasya bhaktäàç ca niyuïjjato 'pi
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

(The spiritual master is always engaged along with his disciples in the temple worship of Çré Çré Rädhä and Kåñëa. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such spiritual master.)

4)

catur-vidha-çré-bhagavat-prasäda
svädv-anna-tåptän hari-bhakta-saìghän
kåtvaiva tåptià bhajataù sadaiva
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

(The spiritual master is always offering Kåñëa four kinds of foodstuffs [analyzed as those which are chewed, those which are licked up, those which are drunk and those which are swallowed]. Four kinds of prasädam are offered to Kåñëa, and when the spiritual master sees that the devotees are eating bhagavat-prasädam, he is satisfied. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such spiritual master.)

5)

çré-rädhikä-mädhavayor apära-
mädhurya-lélä guëa-rüpa-nämnäm
prati-kñaëäsvädana-lolupasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

(The spiritual master is always anxious to hear and chant about the wonderful pastimes between Rädhikä and Mädhava, which are all in the modes of loving exchanges [Mädhurya-Lélä], as well as about their quality, names and form. The spiritual master aspires after relishing these things at every moment. I offer my respectful obeisances to such spiritual master.)

6)

nikuïjjayüno ratikeli-siddhyai
yä yälibhir yuktir apekñaëéyä
taträtidäkñädati-vallabhasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

(The spiritual master is very much expert in assisting the gopés who are engaged in the perfection of Rädhä-Kåñëa conjugal love affairs. At different times they make different tasteful arrangements for such spiritual exchange, and the spiritual master is there to assist in the affairs. I offer my most humble obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master.)

7)

säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästrair
uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù
kintu prabhor yaù priya eva tasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

(The spiritual master is honored as much as the Supreme Lord because of his being the most confidential servitor of the Lord. This is acknowledged in all revealed scriptures and is followed by all authorities. Therefore I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master, who is a bona fide representative of Çré Hari [Kåñëa].)

8)

yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädo
yasyäprasädänna-gatiù kuto 'pi
dhyäyaà stuvaàs tasya yaças tri-sandhyaà
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

(By the mercy of the spiritual master one is benedicted by the mercy of Kåñëa. Without the grace of the spiritual master no one can make any advancement. Therefore I should always remember the spiritual master. At least three times a day I should offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of my spiritual master.)

ÄRÄTRIKA CEREMONY
Prayer by Çréla Bhaktivinode Öhäkur

1)

kibä jaya jaya goräcänder ärotiki sobhä

(Everyone come see all the glories of the beautiful ärätrika ceremony of Lord Caitanya.)

2)

jähnavé-taöa vane jaga jana-manolobhä

(This ärätrika ceremony on the bank of the Ganges to receive Lord Caitanya is so beautiful that it will attract the minds of all the people of the world.)

3)

kibä vasiächena goräcända ratna-siàhäsane

(Come see how Lord Caitanya is seated on the jeweled throne.)

4)

ärati karena brahmä ädideva-gane

(To offer ärätrika to Lord Caitanya all the demigods have come, headed by Lord Brahmä.)

5)

kibä dakñiëe nitäicända bäme gadädhara

(See Nityänanda Prabhu on the right side of Lord Caitanya, and on the left side, Çré Gadädhara.)

6)

nikaöe advaita prabhu çréväsa chatradhara

(Nearby are Advaita Prabhu and Çré Çréväsa, who is bearing the umbrella above Lord Caitanya's head.)

7)

kibä çaìkha bäje ghantä bäje bäje karatäla

(Listen to the sounding of the conchshells, the ringing bells, and the sound of the kartäls.)

8)

madhura mådaìga bäje çunite rasäla

(All these sounds, along with that of the sweet mådaìga, are very relishable to hear.)

Song taught by Çréla Prabhupäda, from Çrémad-Bhägavatam

samäñritä ye padapallava-plavaà
mahat-padaà puëya-yaço muräreù
bhavämbudhir vatsa-padaà paraà padaà
padaà padaà yad vipadäà na teñäm
[Bhäg. 10.14.58]

(This material world is full of danger, and the ocean of nescience is very difficult to cross. But for one who has taken shelter of the lotus feet of Çré Kåñëa, this vast ocean is like a puddle of water contained in a calf's hoofprint in the mud. There is danger at every step, but the devotee is not affected by it.)

Song about Kåñëaloka, from Çré Brahma-saàhitä

cintämaëi-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña-
lakñävåteñu surabhér abhipälayantam
lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi
[Bs. 5.29]

(I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor, who is tending the cows, yielding all desire, in abodes built with spiritual gems, surrounded by millions of purpose-trees, always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds of thousands of Lakñmés, or gopés.) (cont'd on p. 79)

Çré Çré Çikñäñöakam

Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu instructed His disciples to write books on the science of Kåñëa, a task which those who follow Him have continued to carry out down to the present day. The elaborations and expositions on the philosophy taught by Lord Caitanya are in fact the most voluminous, exacting and consistent—due to the unbreakable system of disciplic succession—of any religious culture in the world. Yet Lord Caitanya, in His youth widely renowned as a scholar, Himself left us only eight verses, called Çikñäñöakam, in which His mission and precepts are revealed.

—1—
ceto-darpaëa-märjanaà bhava-mahä-dävägni-nirväpaëaà
çreyaù kairava-candrikävitaraëaà vidyävadhüjévanam
änandämbudhi-vardhanaà pratipadaà pürëämåtäsvädanaà
sarvätma-snapanaà paraà vijayate çré-kåñëa-saëkértanam

Glory to the Çré Kåñëa Saìkértana, which cleanses the heart of all the dust accumulated for years together. Thus the fire of conditional life, of repeated birth and death, is extinguished. This saìkértana movement is the prime benediction for humanity at large because it spreads the rays of the benediction moon. It is the life of all transcendental knowledge, it increases the ocean of transcendental bliss, and it helps us to have a taste of the full nectar for which we are always anxious.

—2—
nämnämakäri bahudhä nija-sarva-çaktis taträrpitä niyamitaù smaraëe na kälaù
etädåçé tava kåpä bhagavan mamäpi durdaivamédåçamihäjani nänurägaù

O my Lord! Your holy name alone can render all benediction upon the living beings, and therefore You have hundreds and millions of names, like Kåñëa, Govinda, etc. In these transcendental names You have invested all Your transcendental energies, and there is no hard and fast rule for chanting these holy names. O my Lord! You have so kindly made approach to You easy by Your holy names, but unfortunate as I am, I have no attraction for them.

—3—
tåëädapi sunécena taror api sahiñëunä
amäninä mänadena kértanéyaù sadä hariù

One can chant the holy name of the Lord in a humble state of mind, thinking himself lower than the straw in the street, more tolerant than the tree, devoid of all sense of false prestige, and ready to offer all respects to others. In such a state of mind one can chant the holy name of the Lord constantly.

—4—
na dhanaà na janaà na sundaréà kavitäà vä jagadéça kämaye
mama janmani janmanéçvare bhavatädbhaktir ahaituké tvayi

O almighty Lord! I have no desire to accumulate wealth, nor have I any desire to enjoy beautiful women, nor do I want any number of followers. What I want only is that I may have Your causeless devotional service in my life—birth after birth.

—5—
ayi nandatanuja kiìkaraà patitaà mäà viñame bhavämbudhau
kåpayä tava päda-paìkaja-sthita-dhülésadåçaà vicintaya

O son of Mahäräja Nanda, I am Your eternal servitor, and although I am so, somehow or other I have fallen in the ocean of birth and death. Please, therefore, pick me up from this ocean of death and fix me as one of the atoms of Your lotus feet.

—6—
nayanaà galadaçrudhärayä vadanaà gadgadaruddhayä girä
pulakair nicitaà vapuù kadä tava-nämagrahaëe bhaviñyati

O my Lord! when will my eyes be decorated with tears of love, flowing constantly while I chant Your holy name? When will my words be choked up when uttering the holy name? And when will all the holes of hair on my body have eruptions by the recitation of Your name?

—7—
yugäyitaà nimeñeëa cakñuñä prävåñäyitam
çünyäyitaà jagat-sarvaà govinda-viraheëa me

O Govinda! Feeling Your separation I am considering a moment twelve years or more, and tears are flowing from my eyes like torrents of rain. I am feeling all vacant in the world in the absence of You.

—8—
äçliñya vä pädaratäà pinañöu mäm adarçanänmarmahatäà karotu vä
yathä tathä vä vidadhätu lampaöo mat-präëa-näthas tu sa eva näparaù

I do not know anyone except Kåñëa as my Lord, and He will always remain as such, even if He handles me roughly by His embrace or makes me broken-hearted by not being present before me. He is completely free to do anything and everything, but He is always my worshipable Lord, unconditionally.

SIX SYMPTOMS OF SURRENDER
in Devotional Service

• One should accept everything favorable for discharging devotional service.
• One should reject everything unfavorable for discharging devotional service.
• One should believe firmly that the Lord will protect His devotee always.
• One should feel exclusively dependent on the mercy of the Lord.
• One should have no separate interest besides the interest of the Lord.
• One should always feel oneself meek and humble.

Song about Kåñëaloka, cont'd.

veëuà kvaëantam aravinda-daläyatäkñaà
barhävataàsam asitämbuda-sundaräìgam
kandarpa-koöi-kamanéya-viçeña-çobhaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi
[Bs. 5.30]

(I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is adept in playing on His flute, with blooming eyes like lotus petals, with head bedecked with a peacock's feather, with the figure of beauty tinged with the hue of blue clouds, and His unique loveliness charming millions of Cupids.)

aìgäni yasya sakalendriya-våttimanti
paçyanti pänti kalayanti ciraà jaganti
änanda-cinmaya-sad-ujjvala-vigrahasya
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi
[Bs. 5.32]

(I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, whose transcendental form is full of bliss, truth and substantiality and is thus full of the most dazzling splendor. Each of the limbs of that transcendental figure possesses, in Himself, the full-fledged functions of all the organs and eternally sees, maintains and manifests the infinite universes, both spiritual and mundane.)

Prayer to Lord Nåsiàhadeva
for the Continued Health of Our Spiritual Master

tava kara-kamala-vare nakham adbhuta-çåìgaà
dalita-hiraëyakaçipu-tanu-bhåìgam
keçava dhåta-narahari-rüpa jaya jagadéça hare
[Daçävatära-stotra 4]

(O my Lord, Your hands are very beautiful, like the lotus flower, but with Your long nails You have ripped apart the wasp Hiraëyakaçipu. Unto You, Lord of the universe, do I offer my humble obeisances.)

(This prayer was recited by the boy devotee Prahläda Mahäräja in order to pacify Lord Nåsiàhadeva.)

Bhaja Çré Kåñëa Caitanya
Prabhu Nityänanda
Çré Advaita Gadädhara
Çréväsädi Gaura-bhakta-vånda

(I offer my obeisances unto Çré Kåñëa Caitanya, Nityänanda Prabhu, Çré Advaita, Gadädhara, Çréväsa, and all the followers of Lord Caitanya.)

Jagannätha-svämé nayana paöhagami bhavatu me

(Jagannätha-svämé—O Lord of the universe; nayana paöhagami bhavatu me—please be visible unto me.)

namo brahmaëya-deväya
go-brähmaëa-hitäya ca
jagat-hitäya kåñëäya
govindäya namo namaù
[Viñëu Puräëa 1.19.65]

(I offer my respectful obeisances to the Supreme Absolute Truth, Kåñëa, who is the well-wisher of the cows and the brähmaëas as well as the living entities in general. I offer my repeated obeisances to Govinda, who is the pleasure reservoir for all the senses.)

OBEISANCES AND RESPECTS

jaya om viñëu-päda paramahaàsa parivräjakäcärya añöottara-çata çri çrémad bhaktivedanta gosvämé mahäräja ki jaya.

(108 glories to the wandering mendicant and topmost swan-like devotee, the great preceptor Çri Srémad Bhaktivedanta Swami Mahäräja, who has taken shelter at the feet of Visnu.)

jaya om viñëu-päda paramahaàsa parivräjakäcärya añöottara-çata çri çrémad bhaktisiddhänta sarasvaté gosvämé mahäräja ki jaya.

(108 glories to the wandering mendicant and topmost swan-like devotee, the great preceptor Sré Çrémad Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé Mahäräja, who has taken shelter at the feet of Viñëu.)

ananta-koöi vaiñëava-vånda ki jaya.

(All glories to Ananta, the couch of Viñëu.)


nämäcärya haridäsa öhäkur ki jaya.

(All glories to the äcärya of the holy name, Haridäsa Öhäkur.)


premse kaho çré-kåñëa-caitanya-prabhu-nityänanda-çri-advaita-gadädhara-çré-väsädi çré-gaura-bhakta-vånda ki jaya.

(All glories to the flowing transcendental love of Lord Caitanya, Lord Nityänanda, Advaita Äcärya, Gadädhara, Çré Çréväsa, and all the devotees of Lord Gaura.)


çré -çré-rädhä-kåñëa-gopa-gopénätha çyäma-kuëòa rädhä-kuëòa giri-govardhana ki jaya.

(All glories to Çré Rädhä and Kåñëa, all the cowherd families owned by Gopénätha, the bathing tank of Çyäma [Kåñëa], the bathing tank of Rädhä, and the hill of Govardhana.)


våndävana-dhäma ki jaya. mathurä-dhäma ki jaya. navadvépa-dhäma ki jaya.

(All glories to the abodes of Våndävana, Mathurä and Navadvépa.)


jagannätha-puré-dhäma ki jaya.

(All glories to the temple of the Lord of the universe at Puré.)


gaìgämayé ki jaya, yamunämayé ki jaya.

(All glories to the sacred Ganges and Yamunä rivers.)


tulasédevé ki jaya.

(All glories to the sacred plant tulasi, which is offered at the feet of Kåñëa.)


bhaktidevé ki jaya.

(All glories to bhakti, devotional service to the Lord.)


säma-veda-bhakta-vånda ki jaya.

(All glories to the assembled devotees.)

Govinda jaya jaya!
Gopäla jaya jaya!
Rädhä-ramaëa-hari!
Govinda jaya jaya!

(Govinda-the Supreme Lord; jaya-victory; Gopäla-cowherd boy, i.e. Kåñëa; Rädhä-ramaëa—He who enjoys Rädhä [Rädhä is His pleasure potency]; Hari—the Lord.)

THE MAHÄ-MANTRA

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa,
Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare
Hare Rama, Hare Räma,
Räma Räma, Hare Hare

HKH 7m: KÅÑËA
The Supreme Personality of Godhead

-1-

KÅÑËA
The Supreme Personality of Godhead

The most comprehensive and authoritative Vedic scriptural literature is the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (the Beautiful Story of the Personality of Godhead), the mature contribution of Çréla Vyäsadeva, the compiler of the Vedas. Of the twelve cantos of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the Tenth Canto is considered the most confidential, since it describes the transcendental pastimes of Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa is a summary study of the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

Çukadeva Gosvämé, the original speaker of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, has declared that there are three classes of men and that the pastimes of Kåñëa will be relished by each of them. The liberated soul who is no longer interested in mundane topics most certainly hears about Kåñëa with the highest pleasure. The person who is trying to become liberated will also enjoy these topics of the Personality of Godhead, which purify anyone who hears them. And even the gross materialist will enjoy hearing about Kåñëa because of the resemblance between His affairs with the gopés and the loving affairs of ordinary boys and girls. This presentation of the pastimes of Kåñëa is a rare opportunity for all mankind to become attracted to the transcendental world of the Personality of Godhead and to thus derive the highest benefit.

400 pp. 84 full-color plates $8.00

HKH 7n: THE NECTAR OF DEVOTION

-2-

THE NECTAR OF DEVOTION

This book is especially intended for those who are engaged in the Kåñëa consciousness movement. The text is flooded with nectarean stories, philosophy and poetic verses about Kåñëa and His pure devotees—all taken directly from the Vedic literatures. It is a summary study of bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, which was written in Sanskrit by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, the chief of the six direct disciples of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu.

The subject matter is love of God. The Nectar of Devotion teaches us where to place our love so that all can become happy; it instructs us how to love the ultimate reservoir of love, Kåñëa, in five different transcendental mellows. The presentation of this authoritative information about the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, and our relationship to Him is simply the mercy of His pure devotee, A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, the äcärya for the present age, who is coming in disciplic succession from Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself.

404 pp. 4 full-color plates softbound, $3.95

HKH 7o: ÇRÉMAD-BHÄGAWATAM

-3-

ÇRÉMAD-BHÄGAWATAM

The Vedas are compared to a desire tree because they contain all things knowable by mankind about both mundane necessities and spiritual realization. Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the mature ripened fruit of this tree. It narrates the transcendental pastimes of the transcendental Personality of Godhead, Lord Çré Kåñëa. It is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam that this nectarean fruit is relished even by those who are already liberated from materialistic life. Great sages have declared that by careful reading of this master work, one's life will be a complete success.

Published in Delhi, India, by The League of Devotees.

Canto 1 1200 pp., 3 Volumes $16.95

HKH 7p: TEACHINGS OF LORD CAITANYA
A Treatise on Factual Spiritual Life

-4-

TEACHINGS OF LORD CAITANYA
A Treatise on Factual Spiritual Life

For thousands of years, all over the world, sincere souls in search of spiritual realization have accepted the Bhagavad-gétä as their most basic and profound text. Lord Caitanya, the most munificent incarnation of Godhead, appeared 500 years ago to demonstrate by example how to live the teachings of Bhagavad-gétä in the present age. Teachings of Lord Caitanya recounts the words and deeds of this great saint. Lord Caitanya was famous as a scholar and spoke authoritatively on Kåñëa, yoga, liberation and nirväëa. Still, He is better known as the divine origin of the Hare Kåñëa movement, distributing love of God simply by singing the holy names. In His profound discourses on Vedänta and in His ecstatic saìkértana festivals, Lord Caitanya was an example to all of how to attain the ultimate goal of life-love of God. This most advanced work on spiritual science can bring the reader into loving reciprocation with the Absolute Truth.

292 pp., ii pp. illus.; hardbound $5.95

HKH 7q: SRI ISOPANISAD
The knowledge that leads one nearer
to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa

-5-

ÇRÉ ÉÇOPANIÑAD
The knowledge that leads one nearer
to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa

All the major scriptures of the world indicate that Godhead, or the Absolute Truth, is not impersonal, but is a person. From the most authoritative sources, the famed 108 Upaniñads of India, Çré Éçopaniñad supplies revealed evidence that the Personality of Godhead is the creator, maintainer and destroyer of everything that exists. The author's transparent commentaries reveal that the Supreme Lord is "unembodied" and "formless," since His form is not a material form which is subject to birth, disease, old age and death.

In the present age of discord, Çré Éçopaniñad revives the dormant hope of all living beings—to transcend this conditioned state and gain the eternal, blissful association of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

135 pp., softbound $1.00; hardbound deluxe edition $3.00

HKH 7r: THE BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS

-6-

THE BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS

Now for the first time this renowed scripture is being brought to the West as it is-as taught by Kåñëa Himself and understood by His disciple Arjuna—in a unique translation and commentary by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami. Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the supreme authority on the Gétä, and He initially delivered the Gétä so that all persons—workers, students, philosophers, and yogés-could reach the perfection of life and be liberated from all suffering. A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami is passing on Kåñëa's mercy in its full potency, as it is, so that everyone can attain to his rightful position, full of bliss and knowledge.

From the Introduction: "The perplexities of life appear like a forest fire which takes place without being set by anyone. The man in material perplexities is he who does not understand the problems of life. Out of many many human beings, the Bhagavad-gétä is directed to the one who seeks to understand his position."

318 pp., softbound $2.95

HKH 7s: EASY JOURNEY TO OTHER PLANETS

-7-

EASY JOURNEY TO OTHER PLANETS

This book is an authentic discussion by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami on the techniques and practice of the yoga system by which one can leave this body for travel to anti-material planets where life is blissful, eternal and full of knowledge.

54 pp. $.50

HKH 7t: Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System

-8-

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System

Consisting of six lectures, this book presents the most authorized process of yoga practice in God realization, without any deviation from the original Vedic scriptural literature. In this present volume, the author forcefully exposes the speculative systems which depart from love of God as the ultimate goal of yoga.

57 pp. $.50

HKH 7u: Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure, and Other Essays

-9-

Kåñëa, The Reservoir Of Pleasure, And Other Essays

"All of us, every living being, seeks pleasure. But we do not know how to seek pleasure perfectly. With a materialistic concept of life, we are frustrated at every step in satisfying our pleasure because we have no information regarding the real level on which to have real pleasure... But in the transcendental absolute world everything is Kåñëa and provides the highest satisfaction."

43 pp. $.50

HKH 7v: BACK TO GODHEAD
The Magazine of the Hare Kåñëa Movement

-10-

BACK TO GODHEAD
The Magazine of the Hare Kåñëa Movement

Back to Godhead is the only monthly journal in the West to deliver the authorized science of God realization as delivered by the unbroken disciplic succession of spiritual masters from Lord Kåñëa. The magazine contains practical information on how to achieve God realization, with writings by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, photo essays, recipes, and articles by disciples based on their personal realizations.

32 pp., monthly; $5.00 per year, $6.00 outside U.S.A.

(Back to Godhead is also available in French, German and Japanese editions.

HKH 7w: GOVINDA ALBUM (33 1/3 rpm)

-11-

GOVINDA ALBUM (33 1 / 3 rpm)

These sound vibrations praise Lord Çré Kåñëa, the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They were first uttered millions of years ago by Lord Brahmä, the creator of this universe. Now they are sung by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, accompanied by sarod and tamboura, in a rare and unique recording.

stereo $5. 00

HKH 7x: Hare Kåñëa Album (33-1/3 rpm)

-12-

Hare Kåñëa Album (33-1 / 3 rpm)

His Divine Grace plays the holy mådanga drum with the Los Angeles Saìkértana Party. Also, Vande Ham and Çré Kåñëa Caitanya.

stereo, $4. 00

HKH 7y: Hare Kåñëa Mantra (45 rpm)

-13-

Hare Kåñëa Mantra (45 rpm)

Recorded by London's Rädhä Kåñëa Temple and produced by Beatle George Harrison on the Apple label (no. 1810).

stereo, $ 1.25

HKH 7z: GOVINDA (45 rpm)

-14-

GOVINDA (45 rpm)

"This sound vibration will purify the Western world."—A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami. Recorded by London's Rädhä Kåñëa Temple and produced by Beatle George Harrison on the Apple label.

stereo $1.25

HKH 7aa: Hare Kåñëa (45 rpm)

-15-

Hare Kåñëa (45 rpm)

Recorded by the Los Angeles Saìkértana Party in a new transcendental arrangement.

stereo $ 1.00

HKH 7bb: SPIRITUAL SKY INCENSE

-16-

SPIRITUAL SKY INCENSE

Finest quality incense, manufactured by devotees of Kåñëa. Large selection of fruit and flower flavors. Twenty sticks in each package. Each stick burns for one hour.

$1.00 per package. Sandalwood, strawberry, lemon, narcissus, etc.

HKH 7cc: WHY THESE BOOKS ARE UNIQUE

WHY THESE BOOKS ARE UNIQUE

In his commentary to Çrémad-Bhägavatam, A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami has written: "There are thousands and thousands of literary men all over the world, and for thousands of years they have created thousands of literary works for the information of the people in general. Unfortunately, none of them have brought peace and tranquility on earth, either among men or among nations. This is due to the spiritual vacuum in these literatures." According to Vedic literature, man can be happy only by self-realization and by engaging in his eternal occupation of transcendental loving service to God. Literatures which are void of glorification of the Supreme Lord are ultimately useless. The Vedic literatures describe them as decorations of a dead body or superficial agétätion of the mind. The vast body of spiritual science known as the Vedic literature presents the all-inclusive solution to all the problems of life by describing the transcendental glories of the name, fame, form and pastimes of the unlimited Supreme Lord. They are meant for bringing about a revolution in the impious life of the misdirected civilization of the world.

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, a spiritual master in disciplic succession, presents the great Vedic literatures in translations and commentaries which do not deviate in the slightest degree from the original intentions of the Vedic authorities, and he is therefore the Vedic authority for this age. A.C. Bhaktivedanta's books are unique, pure and transcendentally relishable, and they actually have the potency to end all miseries of material existence and awaken joyful spiritual life

Any of the above books may be obtained postage free* by sending payment in check or money order to:

ISKCON PRESS, 38 N. Beacon St., Boston, Mass. 02134 Att: Svarüpa däsa Brahmacäré, secretary.

*Please include additional $.50 for countries outside USA.

"Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth." (Bg. 4.34)

The path of spiritual realization is undoubtedly difficult. The Lord therefore advises us to approach a bona fide spiritual master in the line of disciplic succession from the Lord Himself. No one can be a bona fide spiritual master without following this principle of disciplic succession. The Lord is the original spiritual master, and a person in the disciplic succession can convey the message of the Lord as it is to his disciple. No one can be spiritually realized by manufacturing his own process, as is the fashion of foolish pretenders. The Bhägavatam says: "The path of religion is directly enunciated by the Lord." Therefore, mental speculation or dry arguments cannot help one progress in spiritual life. One has to approach a bona fide spiritual master to receive the knowledge. Such a teacher should be accepted in full surrender, and one should serve the spiritual master like a menial servant, without false prestige. Satisfaction of the self-realized spiritual master is the secret of advancement in spiritual life. Inquiries and submission constitute the proper combination for spiritual understanding. Unless there is submission and service, inquiries from the learned spiritual master will not be effective. One must be able to pass the test of the spiritual master, and when the spiritual master sees the genuine desire of the disciple, he automatically blesses the disciple with genuine spiritual understanding.

HKH 8: Authorized Procedure for Performing
A Kåñëa Conscious Marriage Ceremony

Authorized Procedure for Performing
A Kåñëa Conscious Marriage Ceremony

1. Preparations are made according to the instructions in the "Çré Çrémürti Püjä" booklet, published by ISKCON Los Angeles

2. The couple should wear newly bought clothes.

3. Saìkértana

4. The bride sits to the right of the groom. Garlands are offered to the priest and couple after they have been touched to the Deities' feet. Incense is lit and placed around the spot where the sacrificial fire is to be lit.

5. The priest says the first of line of the Gäyatré mantra.

6. Everyone chants japa throughout the ceremony.

7. The priest demonstrates how to take water in a spoon from a goblet. Holding the spoon in his right hand, he puts water in his left palm, once, twice, thrice. He then sips the water. He takes one more spoonful of water into his left palm to wash it, and he then throws it to the side. Then the priest passes the water goblet to the couple to be married, and they follow the same procedure. The goblet is passed around counterclockwise. The priest leads responsive chanting of

oà apavitraù pavitro vä sarvävasthäà gato 'pi vä
yaù smaret puëòarékäkñaà savähyäbhyantaraù çuciù
çré-viñëu çré-viñëu çré-viñëu
[Garuòa Puräëa]

("Unpurified or purified, or even having passed through all situations, one who remembers the lotus-eyed Supreme Personality of Godhead is cleansed without and within.") This whole procedure is executed three times.

8. The priest lectures on the importance of marriage.

9. The girl's parent or godbrother says: "_________ Däsé has been in my charge for so long, and now I am giving her unto your care. Do you accept her as your wife?"

The bridegroom says: "Yes, I accept _________ Däsé as my wife, and I shall take charge of her throughout both of our lives. We shall live together peacefully in Kåñna consciousness, and there will never be any separation."

The priest says, "Will you accept Çrémän _________ as your life's companion, serving him always, and help him to execute his Kåñëa conscious activities?"

The bride says, "Yes, I accept Çrémän _________ as my husband throughout my life. There shall never be any separation between us, either in happiness or distress. I shall serve him always, and we shall live together peacefully in Kåñëa consciousness. "

10. Garlands are exchanged by the couple. The couple exchanges sitting places. The groom places vermilion in the part of his bride's hair, and he covers her head with her sari cloth. The groom's dhoti is tied to the bride's sari, and the garments should stay tied for one week.

11. The priest sprinkles differently colored dyes up and down and sideways on the dirt where the fire is to be lit. With a candle, he lights a splinter dipped in ghee and builds a small fire. He mixes ghee with barley and sesame seeds.

12. The maìgalä-caraëa prayers and the prayers to the spiritual masters are said while the barley and sesame are passed around. When the priest says svähä, after each prayer is completed, the devotees throw the grains into the fire, and the priest spoons in ghee. The prayers are said responsively, including the svähä. The priest has to add wood to the fire to keep it going. All the dyes should be added to fire toward the end.

13. Everyone stands up, and the married couple, holding bananas before them in their folded hands, stands by the fire. The following prayer is said responsively three times:

namo brahmaëya-deväya go-brähmaëa-hitäya ca
jagat-hitäya kåñëäya govindäya namo namaù
[Viñëu Puräëa 1.19.65]
svähä svähä svähä.

14. The bananas are placed in the fire, and the priest pours any extra seeds from the bowl into the fire.

15. Everyone responsively repeats: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

16. Everyone bows down and offers obeisances to Prabhupäda.

17. Saìkértana

18. The priest mixes ashes from the fire with a little ghee left in the bowl, and a mark of ashes and ghee is placed on everyone's forehead.

19. Feast

HKH 9: Current Centers of the
International Society for Krishna Consciousness

Current Centers of the
International Society for Krishna Consciousness

Since its founding in 1966 the society has experienced phenomenal growth. It presents itself as a complex organization responsible for the welfare of thousands of people. As of 1970, there are 30 centers. Each of these centers if a self-contained unit which functions as a church, seminary, and home for each of its ministers and divinity students.

The following list is intended to identify and describe each of the locations of the society including all available information on the number and identity of the ministers, the ministerial students and the estimated size of each congregation. Since no precise records are kept, estimations are made on the basis of at least monthly attendance; that is, if a person attends less than once a month he will not be considered to be a member of the congregation. All students counted are full-time students of the society.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 7 Bury Place, London, England. It is staffed by three ministers, Mukunda däs Adhikäré, Çyämasundara däs Adhikäré, and Guru däs Adhikäré, and twelve ministerial students. Mukunda däs was initiated on Oct. 15, 1966, Çyämasundara däs on Jan. 10, 1967, and Guru däs on April 7, 1968. It has an estimated congregation of forty-five families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 2016 McKinley St. Honolulu, Hawaii 96822. It is staffed by one minister, Gaursundar däs Adhikäré, who was initiated on Feb. 19, 1967, and eleven ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of fifty families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 3720 Park Ave., Montreal, Canada. It is staffed by one minister, Çripati däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated in June, 1969, and fifteen ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of fifty families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 61 Second Ave., New York City, New York 10003. It is staffed by two ministers, Brahmänanda däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated on Oct. 23, 1966, and Åñi Kumära däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated in May, 1968, and twenty-five ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of 125 families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, New Våndävana, RD 3, Moundsville, West Virginia 26041. It is staffed by two ministers, Kértanänanda Swami, who was initiated in Oct. 23, 1966, and Hayagréva däs Adhikäré, who was initiated in Sept., 1966, and thirty ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of thirty members.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 416 South 10th St., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19147. It is staffed by one minister, Subal däs Adhikäré, who was initiated in Feb., 1967, and four ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of twenty-five families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 518 Fredrick St., San Francisco, California 94117. It is staffed by one minister, Madhaviçä däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated in Aug., 1968, and fifteen ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of 130 families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, No. 6-16, 2/Chome, Ohhashi, Meguro-ku, Tokyo, Japan. It is staffed by one minister, Sudämä däs Adhikäré, who was initiated in Sept. 1968, and six students. It has an estimated congregation of fifteen families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 40 Beverly St. Toronto, Ontario Canada. It is staffed by one minister, Jagadéça däs Adhikäré, and six students. It has an estimated congregation of twenty families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 2015 Q St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20008. It is staffed by one minister, Dämodara däs Adhikäré, and six students. It has an estimated congregation of twenty-five families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 260 Raymur St., no. 305, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. It is staffed by one minister, Cidänanda däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated in Dec. 1967, and eight students. It has an estimated congregation of thirty families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, c/o Serge Elbez, BO 113, Paris, 14, France. It is staffed by one minister, Woomäpati däs Adhikäré, and four students. It has an estimated congregation of ten families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 2210 N. Halstead St., Chicago, Ill. It is staffed by one minister, Jaya Pataka däs Brahmacäré, and four students. It has an estimated congregation of six families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 5516 Roosevelt Way N.E., Seattle, Washington 98105. It is staffed by one minister, Gajendra däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated on Dec. 1, 1968, and eight ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of fifty families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, San Jose, California. It is staffed by one minister, Cit-sukhänanda däs Adhikäré, and four ministerial students. It has a congregation of fifteen families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 2710 Durant Ave., Berkeley, California 94704. It is staffed by one minister, Bahulaçva däs Adhikäré, who was initiated in Feb., 1969, and ten ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of 250 families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 38 No. Beacon St., Boston, Massachusetts 02134. It is staffed by one minister, Satsvarüpa das Adhikäré, who was initiated on Oct. 23, 1966, and thirty-five ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of one hundred families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 298 Birrell St., Bondi, N.S.W. 2026, Sydney, Australia. It is staffed by one minister, Bali Mardan däs Brahmacäré and four students. It has an estimated congregation of fifteen families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 4549 LaClede Ave., St Louis, Missouri 63110. It is staffed by one minister, Vämanadeva das Adhikäré, and four students. It has an estimated congregation of fifteen families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 1476 Oxford Rd. N.E. 30322 Atlanta Georgia. It is staffed by one minister, Janamejaya däs Adhikäré, and four students. It has an estimated congregation of ten families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 1300 Calvert St. Baltimore, Maryland. It is staffed by one minister, Våndävana Candra däs Adhikäré, and three students. It has an estimated congregation of ten families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 104 Bradfort St., Provincetown, Massachusetts. It is staffed by one minister, Çrédämä däs Adhikäré, and four students. It has an estimated congregation of ten families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 623 Concord St., Boulder, Colorado 80302. It is staffed on one minister, Harer Näma däs Adhikäré, who was initiated on Sept. 11, 1966, and seven ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of seventy-five families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 2000 Hamburg 6, Bartel Strasse 65, Hamburg, Germany. It is staffed by one minister, Çivänanda däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated on July 12, 1967, and five ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of seventy families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 130 Woodland Drive, Laguna Beach, California 92651. It is staffed by one minister, Durlabha däs Adhikäré, who was initiated in April, 1969, and six ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of fifty families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 3764 Watseka Avenue, Los Angeles, California 90034. It is staffed by two ministers, Dayänanda däs Adhikäré who was initiated in March, 1967, and Gargamuni däs Adhikäré, who was initiated in Oct., 1966, and seventy-five ministerial students. It has an estimated congregation of 250 families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 318 E. 20th Ave., Columbus, Ohio 43201. It is staffed by one minister, Jananibas däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated in Aug. 1969, and five students. It has an estimated congregation of twenty-five families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 74 W. Forest St. Detroit, Michigan 48201. It is staffed by one minister, Bhagavän däs Adhikäré, who was initiated on June 4, 1969, and twelve students. It has an estimated congregation of fifty families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 6654 B del Playa, Goleta, Santa Barbara, California 93017. It is staffed by one minister, Revaténandana däs Brahmacäré, who was initiated in May, 1968, and ten students. It has an estimated congregation of thirty-five families.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, 3689 Park Blvd., San Diego, California. It is staffed by one minister, Tulsi däs Brahmacäré, and four students. It has an estimated congregation of twenty families.

HKH 10: Recognition of ISKCON

Recognition of ISKCON

The Selective Service System of New York State has recognized ISKCON as a religion and ministers are examined individually for ministerial exemption from military duty.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness (Canada) / La Societe lnternationale Pour la Conscience de Krishna (Canada) is incorporated as a non-profit organization with the Minister of Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Ottawa, Canada.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness, Ltd. is registered with the Registrar of Companies, London, England.

Internationale Gesellschaft fur Kåñëa Bewusstsein, E.V. is incorporated in Hamburg, West Germany.

International Society for Kåñëa Consciousness was incorporated in July, 1966, pursuant to the Religious Corporation Law of the State of New York and is registered with the County Clerk of New York County, New York

International Society for Kåñëa Consciousness is registered with the United States Treasury Department, Internal Revenue Service, as exempt from Federal income tax. Contributions, gifts, and bequests made to ISKCON are deductible by donors as provided in the Internal Revenue Code.

ISKCON
International Society for Krishna Consciousness inc.

Acharya—His Divine Grace 108 Sri Srimad A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupad

3764 WATSEKA AVENUE -LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90034

Telephone: 213-836-0966
21 3-836-9286

HKH 11: Kåñëa Consciousness-The Sankirtana Movement

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Sankirtana Movement

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is a bona fide religious society strictly following the principles described in the Vedic scriptures and practiced in India for thousands of years. Our basic beliefs are as follows:

1) The Absolute Truth is contained in all the great Scriptures of the world, the Bible, Koran, Torah, etc. However, the oldest known revealed Scriptures in existence are the Vedic literatures, most notably Bhagavad-gétä, which is the literal record of God's actual words.

2) God, or Kåñëa, is eternal, all-knowing, omnipresent, all-powerful and all-attractive, the seed-giving father of man and all living entities. He is the sustaining energy of all life, nature and the cosmic situation.

3) Man is actually not his body, but is eternal spirit soul, part and parcel of God, and therefore eternal.

4) That all men are brothers can be practiced only when we realize God as our common father.

5) All our actions should be performed as a sacrifice to the Supreme Lord: "... all that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you may perform, should be done as an offering unto Me." (Bhagavad-gétä, 9.27)

6) The food that sustains us should always be offered to the Lord before eating. In this way He becomes the offering, and such eating purifies us.

7) We can, by sincere cultivation of bona fide spiritual science, attain to the state of pure, unending blissful consciousness, free from anxiety, in this very lifetime.

8) The recommended means to attain the mature stage of love of God in the present age of Kali, or quarrel, is to chant the holy name of the Lord. The easiest method for most people is to chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.


Our basic mission is to propagate the saìkértana movement (chanting of the holy names of God) all around the world, as was recommended by the incarnation of the Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. People in this age are very much reluctant to understand God consciousness because of their unfortunate condition of life. They are working hard day and night simply for sense gratification. But this transcendental vibration of saìkértana will knock at the door of their hearts for spiritual awakening. Therefore, they should be given the chance for this opportunity.

It is not recommended that a Kåñna conscious devotee go into seclusion to chant by himself and thereby gain salvation for himself alone. Our duty and religious obligation is to go out into the streets where the people in general can hear the chanting and see the dancing. We have already seen practically how by this process many, many boys and girls of America and Europe have been saved from the immoral practices of this age and have now dedicated their lives to the service of Kåñëa.

It is hoped that the government authorities will cooperate with our saìkértana parties in enabling us to perform saìkértana on the streets. To do this it is necessary that we be able to chant the names of Kåñëa, dance, play the mådanga drum, request donations, sell our society's journal, and on occasion, sit down with the mådanga drum. As devotees of Lord Kåñëa, it is our duty to teach the people how to love God and worship Him in their daily life. This is the aim and destination of human life.

[signed] A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

HKH 12: Note on Transliterated Sanskrit Words

Note on Transliterated Sanskrit Words

The vowels are pronounced almost as in Italian. The sound of the short a is like the u in but, the long a is like the a in far and held twice as long as the short a, and e is like the a in evade. Long i is like the i in pique. The vowel r is pronounced like the re in the English word fibre. The c is pronounced as in the English word chair, and the aspirated consonants (ch, jh, dh, etc.) are pronounced as in staunch-heart, hedge-hog, red-hot, etc. The two spirants ç and ñ are pronounced like the English sh; s is pronounced as in sun.

TWO ESSAYS

Krishna The Reservoir Of Pleasure
&
Who Is Crazy?

50c

Two Essays-Krishna The Reservoir Of Pleasure

KRISHNA THE RESERVOIR OF PLEASURE

Krishna—this sound is transcendental. Krishna means the highest pleasure. All of us, every living being, seeks pleasure. But we do not know how to seek pleasure perfectly. With a materialistic concept of life, we are frustrated at every step in satisfying our pleasure because we have no information regarding the real level on which to have real pleasure. For the last few weeks we have been learning that we are not this body; we are consciousness. Not exactly consciousness, for consciousness is actually the symptom of our real identity: we are pure soul, now merged within this material body. Modern material science lays no stress on this; therefore the scientists are sometimes misled in their understanding of spirit soul. But spirit soul is a fact, which anyone can understand by the presence of consciousness. Any child can understand that consciousness is the symptom of the spirit soul.

Now the whole process we are trying to learn from the Bhagavad Gita (The Song of God) is how to bring ourselves to this level of consciousness. And if we act from the level of consciousness, then we may not be pushed again into the level of this bodily conception; and, if we can continue on that level, if we can continue to act in pure consciousness, then, at the end of this body we shall be free from material contamination, our spiritual life will be revived, and the ultimate result will be that in our next life, after leaving this body, we shall have our full, eternal spiritual life. Spirit, as we have already discussed, is described as eternal.

Even after the destruction of this body, consciousness is not destroyed. Rather, consciousness is transferred to another type of body and again makes us aware of the material conception of life. That is also described in the Bhagavad Gita. At the time of death, if our consciousness is pure, we can be sure that our next life will not be material—our next life will be spiritual. If our consciousness is not pure at the point of death, then, after leaving this body, we shall have to take another material body. That is the process which is going on. That is Nature's law.

We have now a finite body. The body which we see is the gross body. It is just like a shirt and coat: within the coat there is a shirt, and within the shirt there is a body. Similarly, the pure soul is covered by a shirt and coat. The garments are the mind, intelligence and false ego. False ego means the misconception that I am matter, that I am a product of this material world. This misconception makes me localized. For example, because I have taken my birth in India, I think myself Indian. Because I have taken my birth in America, I think myself American. But as pure soul, I am neither Indian nor American. I am pure soul. These others are designations. American, or Indian, or German, or Englishman; cat or dog, or bee or bat, man or wife: all these are designations. In spiritual consciousness we become free from all such designations. That freedom is achieved when we are constantly in touch with the supreme spirit, Krishna.

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is simply intended to keep us in constant touch with Krishna. Krishna can be in constant companionship with us because He is omnipotent. Therefore, He can be fully in touch with us by His words. His words and He are not different. That is omnipotence. Omnipotence means that everything relating to Him has the same potency. For example, here in this material world, if we are thirsty and we want water, simply repeating "Water, water, water, water," will not satisfy our thirst, because this word has not the same potency as water itself. We require the water in substance. Then our thirst will be satisfied. But in the transcendental, absolute world, there is no such difference. Krishna's name, Krishna's quality, Krishna's word—everything is Krishna and provides the same satisfaction.

Some people argue that Arjuna was talking with Krishna because Krishna was present before him, whereas in my case, Krishna is not present. So how can I get directions? But that is not a fact. Krishna is present by His words—The Bhagavad Gita. In India, when we speak on the Bhagavad Gita or Srimad-Bhagawatam, we regularly perform worship with flowers, or with other paraphernalia, as is required for worshiping. In the Sikh religion also, although they have no form of the Deity, they worship the book Granthasahib. Perhaps some of you are acquainted with this Sikh community. They worship this Grantha. Similarly, the Moslems worship the Koran. Similarly, in the Christian world, the Bible is worshiped. It is a fact that the Lord Jesus Christ is present by His words. Krishna is also present by His words.

These personalities, either God or the son of God, who come from the transcendental world, keep their transcendental identities without being contaminated by the material world. That is their omnipotence. We are in the habit of saying that God is omnipotent. Omnipotence means that He is not different from His name, from His quality, from His pastimes, from His instruction. Therefore, the discussion of Bhagavad Gita is as good as discussion with Krishna Himself.

Krishna is seated in your heart, and in my heart too. Iswara Sarva-bhutanam Hrdese Arjuna Tisthat. [Bg. 18.61] God is situated in everyone's heart. God is not away from us. He is present. He is so friendly that He remains with us in our repeated change of births. He is waiting to see when we shall turn to Him. He is so kind that though we may forget Him, He never forgets us. Although a son may forget his father, a father never forgets his son. Similarly, God, the original father of everything, everybody, all living entities, will never forsake us. We may have different bodies, but they are our shirt-coats. That has nothing to do with our real identity. Our real identity is pure soul, and that pure soul is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. There are 8,400,000 species of life. Even the biologist and the anthropologist cannot calculate this accurately, but from authoritative, revealed scripture we get this information. Human beings represent 400,000 species, and there are 8,000,000 other species. But Krishna, the Supreme Lord, claims that all of them, whether beast, man, snake, god, semi-god, demigod—anything whatever—all of them are, in reality, His sons.

The father gives the seed, and the mother receives the seed. The body is then formed, according to the mother's body. And when the body is completely formed, it comes out—either from cats, from dogs, or from man. That is the process of generation. The father gives the seed, and it is emulsified with two kinds of secretion in the womb of the mother, and on the first night the body is formed just like a pea. Then, gradually, it develops. There are nine holes that develop: two ears, two eyes, nostrils, a mouth, a navel, a penis, and an anus.

According to his last karma, or action, one gets this body to enjoy, or to suffer. That is the process of birth and death. And after finishing this life, again one dies, and again one enters into the womb of some mother. Another type of body then comes out. This is the process of reincarnation.

We should be very diligent as to how we can discontinue this process of repeated birth and death and change of body. That is the prerogative of the human form of life. We can stop this process of repeated change through birth and death. We can get our actual spiritual form again and be blissful, full of knowledge and eternal life. That is the purpose of evolution. We should not miss this. The entire process of liberation begins just as we have now begun this chanting and hearing. I wish to point out that this chanting of the holy name of God (HARE KRISHNA, HARE KRISHNA, KRISHNA KRISHNA, HARE HARE/ HARE RAMA, HARE RAMA, RAMA RAMA, HARE HARE) and hearing the truths of the Gita is as good as bodily association with Krishna. That is stated in the Gita. This process is called "kirtana". Even if one does not understand the language, still, just by hearing, he acquires some piety. His assets lead him to a pious life, even if he does not understand—it has such power.

There are two topics concerning Krishna. Two kinds of topics, actually. One topic is this Bhagavad Gita. It is spoken by Krishna. And the other topic concerning Krishna is Srimad-Bhagawatam. That is spoken about Krishna. So there are two types of Krishna katha (topics), and both of them are equally potent because they are connected with Krishna.

Because the Bhagavad Gita is spoken on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra some people have asked what we have to do with the battlefield. We have nothing to do with any battlefield. We are after knowledge of the spiritual sphere. Then, why should we bother about this battlefield? Because Krishna is on the battlefield, and therefore the whole battlefield has become Krishna-ized. Just as when an electric current is passed into some metal, the whole metal becomes surcharged with electricity; so too, when Krishna is interested in some matter, that matter becomes Krishna-ized. Otherwise, there would be no need of discussing the Battlefield of Kurukñetra. That is His omnipotence.

This omnipotence is also described in Srimad-Bhagawatam. There are many Krishna kathas. The Vedic literature is full of them. Vedas mean that they are Krishna kathas. Scripture, including the Vedas, may appear to be different, but they are all meant for Krishna katha. If we simply hear these topics on Krishna, then what will be the result? It is pure transcendental vibration, and the result will be spiritual consciousness.

We have accumulated many inauspicious things within our hearts due to our material contamination during the course of many, many births. Many, many births—not only this birth, but part births as well. So, when we search into our hearts with the Krishna katha, then the contamination we have accumulated will be washed off. Our hearts will be cleansed of all rubbish. And, as soon as all the rubbish is cleared off, then we are situated in pure consciousness.

It is very difficult to eradicate all the false designations from oneself. For example, I am Indian. It is not very easy to immediately think that I am not Indian, but pure soul. Similarly, it is not a very easy task for anyone to end his identification with these bodily designations. But still, if we continue hearing the Krishna katha, it will be very easy. Make an experiment. Make an experiment to see how easily you'll be able to free yourself from all these designations. Of course, it is not possible to clear out the rubbish from the mind all of a sudden, but we are immediately aware that the influence of the material nature has become slackened.

The material nature is working in three modes—goodness, passion, and ignorance. Ignorance is hopeless life. Passion is materialistic. One who is influenced by the modes of passion wants this false enjoyment of material existence. Because he does not know the truth, he wants to squeeze out the energy of the body just to enjoy this matter. That is called the mode of passion. As for those in the mode of ignorance, they have neither passion nor goodness. They are in the deepest darkness of life. Situated in the mode of goodness, we can understand, at least theoretically, what I am, what this world is, what God is, and what our interrelationship is. This is the mode of goodness.

By hearing Krishna katha, we will be freed from the stages of ignorance and passion. We will be situated in the mode of goodness. At least we'll have the real knowledge—knowledge of what we are. Ignorance is like the animal existence. The animal's life is full of suffering, but the animal does not know that he is suffering. Take the case of a hog. Of course, here in New York City no hog is seen. But in villages in India one sees the hog. Oh, how miserable his life is, living in a filthy place, eating stools and always unclean. Yet the hog is very happy by eating stools, and having constant sexual intercourse with the she-hog and just getting fat. The hog gets very fat, because of the spirit of enjoyment which is there—although, for him, it is sensual enjoyment.

We should not be like the hog, falsely thinking that we are very happy. Working hard all day and night, then having some sex life—we think that in this way we are very happy. But this is not happiness. This has been described in the Bhagawatam as a hog's happiness. Man's happiness is when he is situated in the mode of goodness. Then he can understand what true happiness is.

In our daily routine, if we hear this Krishna katha, the result will be that all the dirty things in the heart, accumulated life after life, will be cleared out. As a matter of fact, we will see that we are no longer in ignorance or in passion, but are situated in the mode of goodness. What is that position?

We will find ourselves joyful in every circumstance of life. We will never feel morose. In the Bhagavad Gita we find that this is our Brahma-bhuta [Bhäg. 4.30.20] (highest stage of goodness) situation. The Vedas teach us that we are not this matter. We are Brahman. Aham brahmasmi. Lord Sankaracharya preached this gospel to the world. We are not this matter; we are Brahman-spirit. When spiritual realization is actually accomplished, then our symptoms will change. What are those symptoms? When one is situated in his own spiritual consciousness, then he will have no hankering and no lamentation. Lamentation is for loss, and hankering is for gain. Two diseases characterize this material world: What we do not possess, we hanker after. "If I get these things I'll be happy. I have no money, but if I get a million dollars, then I'll be happy." And when we have a million dollars, somehow it will be lost. So we'll cry, "Oh, I have lost it!" When we hanker for earning, that is a kind of distress. And when we suffer loss, that is also distress. But if we are situated in Brahmabhuta, we will neither be distressed nor will we hanker. We will view equally everyone and everything. Even if we are situated in the midst of fiery turbulence, we will not be disturbed. That is the mode of goodness.

Bhagawatam means the science of God. If the science of God is persevered in, we will be situated in the Brahmabhuta status. From that Brahmabhuta status, we have to work, for work is recommended here. So long as we have this material body, we have to work. We cannot stop working; it is not possible. But we have to adopt the tactics of yoga, and in this way, even by doing some ordinary work, which, by destiny or circumstances we are put into, there is no harm. Suppose that, in one's own occupation, one must speak a lie or his business can't go on. Lying is not a very good thing, so one concludes that the business is not based on very moral principles and one should therefore give it up. In the Bhagavad Gita, however, we find instruction not to give it up. Even if we are put in such circumstances that our livelihood cannot go on without some unfair practice, we should not give it up. But we should try to make it purified. How is it purified? We should not take the fruitive result of our work. That is meant for God.

Sukrta means pious activities. And Duskrta means impious activities. On the material level we can be pious or impious. Either we are performing some pious activities, or we are performing some impious activities—or we have a mixture, pious and impious. Lord Krishna advises that we should act with knowledge of, or devotion to the Supreme. What does that knowledge mean? It means that I am the part and parcel of the supreme consciousness, or that I am not this body. If I identify myself as an American, as an Indian, or this or that, then I am on the material Plane. We should identify ourselves as neither Americans nor Indians, but as pure consciousness. I am a subordinate consciousness of the supreme consciousness; in other words, I am the servant of God. God is the supreme consciousness, and I am His servant. So, for our present understanding, subordinate means servant.

We don't ordinarily carry out the work of a servant in relationship to God. Nobody wants to be a servant, but everyone wants to be the master, because to become a servant is not a very palatable thing. But to become the servant of God is not exactly like this. Sometimes the servant of God becomes the master of God. The real position of the living entity is to be the servant of God, but in the Bhagavad Gita we can see that the master, Krishna, became the servant of Arjuna. Arjuna is sitting in the chariot, and Krishna is his driver. Arjuna is not the owner of the chariot, but in the spiritual relationship we should not cling to the concept of the material relationship. Although the whole relationship, just as we have experience of it in this world, is there in the spiritual world, that relationship is not contaminated by matter. Therefore it is pure and transcendental. It is of a different nature. As we become advanced in the spiritual conception of life, we can understand what the actual position in the spiritual, transcendental world is.

Here the Lord instructs us in Buddhi Yogata. Buddhi yoga means that we have full consciousness that we are not this body; and if I act with this understanding, then I am not body—I am consciousness. That is a fact. Now, if we act on the level of consciousness, then we can overcome the fruitive result of good work or bad work. It is a transcendental stage.

It means that we are acting on another's account—on the Supreme's account. We are not liable to loss or gain. When there is gain, we should not be puffed up. We should think, "This gain is for the Lord." And when there is loss, we should know that this is not our responsibility. It is God's work—His. Then we will be happy. This we have to practice: everything on account of the Supreme. This transcendental nature we have to develop. This is the trick of doing work under these present circumstances. As soon as we work on the level of bodily consciousness we become bound by the reaction of our work. But when we work through spiritual consciousness, we are not bound either by pious activities or by vicious activities. That is the technique.

Manasvinam—this word is very significant. Manasvinam means thoughtful. Unless one is thoughtful, he cannot understand that he is not this body. But if one is a little thoughtful he can understand, "Oh, I am not this body. I am consciousness." Sometimes, in our leisure time, we can see, "Oh, this is my finger, and this is my hand. This is my ear, and this is my nose. Everything is mine, but what I, what I?" I am feeling this is mine, and that I am. Simply a little thought is required. Everything is mine—my eyes, my finger, my hand. My, my, my, and what is the I? The I is that consciousness, in which I am thinking, "This is mine."

Now, if I am not this body, then why should I act for this body? I should act for myself. Then, how can I work for myself? What is my position? I am consciousness. But what kind of consciousness? Subordinate consciousness—I am part of the supreme consciousness. Then, what will my activities be? My activities will be under the guidance of the supreme consciousness, just as in the office, the managing director is the supreme consciousness. For example, in the office everyone is working under the direction of the manager; therefore they have no responsibility. They have only to discharge their duties. Either pious or impious duties—never mind. In the military line, too, the order of the captain or the commander is there. The soldier has to execute it. He does not consider whether it is pious or impious. That does not matter. He simply has to act, then he is a real soldier. He acts in that way and he gets his reward. He gets title and honor. He doesn't care. The commander says, Just go and kill the enemy, and he is rewarded. Do you think that by killing one gets reward? No—it is for the duty discharged.

Similarly, here the situation is that Krishna is instructing Arjuna. Krishna is the supreme consciousness. I am consciousness, the part and parcel of the supreme consciousness. So my duty is to act according to that supreme consciousness. For example, I consider my hand as a part of my body. Now, it is moving in its own way. "As I want, let my hand be moved. Let my legs be moved. Let my eyes be opened and see." So, I am dictating, and these parts are working. Similarly, we are all parts and parcels of the Supreme. When we train ourselves to move and act in accordance with supreme consciousness, then we become transcendental to all these pious or impious activities. That is the technique. What will the result of this technique be? We become free from the bondage of birth and death. No more birth and death.

Modern scientists and philosophers do not think about these four things: birth, death, disease, and old age. They set them aside. "Oh, let us be happy. Let us enjoy this life." But human life is meant for finding a solution to this bondage of birth, death, disease and old age. If any civilization has not found a solution to these four problems, then that is not a human civilization. Human civilization is meant for finding a complete solution to these things.

So here in the Bhagavad Gita, the Lord says, Karma jam buddhi yukta. Karmajam means whenever there is action there will be some reaction. If one acts in badness, there will be a bad reaction. But reaction, either good or bad, is, in the higher sense, all suffering. Suppose that by good action I get a good birth, fine bodily features, and a good education. All these good things I may have, but that does not mean that I am free from material pains. The material pains are birth, death, old age and disease. Even if I am a rich man, a beautiful man, an educated man, born in an aristocratic family, etc., I still cannot avoid death, old age, and disease.

So, we must not be concerned with pious activities or impious activities. We must be concerned with transcendental activities only. That will save us from this bondage of birth, death, old age and disease. That should be our aim in life. We should not be hankering after good or bad things. For example, suppose one is suffering from some disease. He is lying in bed, eating, passing nature's call uncomfortably, and taking bitter medicines. He always has to be kept clean by the nurses; otherwise there is an obnoxious smell. While he is lying in this condition some friends come to him and ask how he is feeling. "Yes, I am feeling well." What is this well? Lying in bed uncomfortably taking bitter medicine, and unable to move! Yet despite all these inconveniences he says, "I am well." Similarly, in our material conception of life, if we think, "I am happy," that is foolishness. There is no happiness in material life. It is impossible to have happiness here. In this condition, we do not know the meaning of happiness. That's why this very word is used, manasvinam—thoughtful.

We seek happiness by some extraneous, artificial means, but how long does it last? It will not endure. We again come back to sorrow. Suppose, by intoxication, we feel happy. That is not our actual happiness. Suppose I am made unconscious by chloroform, and I don't feel the pain of an operation. That does not mean that I am not having an operation. This is artificial. Real pleasure, real life exists.

As is commanded in the Bhagavad Gita by Sri Krishna, the thoughtful give up the reaction of work, being situated on the level of pure consciousness. The result is that this bondage of birth and death, disease and old age comes to an end. This end is in union with the true identity, Krishna, the reservoir of pleasure and eternal bliss. There, indeed, is the true happiness for which we are intended.

THE SOUND OF HARE KRISHNA

BLISS—what was once only a word now becomes an experience.
With HARE KRISHNA you transcend everything—even your body.
This is real freedom.

BLISS—wherever and whenever you want it. Try it and see. It's so easy
even children do it.

THE SOUNDS OF KRISHNA CONSCIOUSNESS are recorded by His Divine
Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami and his disciples. This is an invitation
to take a trip to the World which lies beyond the senses.

ISKCON
26 2nd Ave.
N.Y. C. 1.0003 $3.25

SRIMAD-BHAGAWATAM

by Krishna Dvaipayana Vyasadeva

(Picture Caption:) Swami Bhaktivedanta receiving the praises of the late Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri for his work in translating and editing the "Bhagwatam."

It has been said that one who approaches the transcendental message of the Srimad Bhagwatam has done so only after many, many births in pursuit of Truth. Now this sublime work, revealing the Glories and Pastimes of the Infinite Godhead, is at last available in English, along with Sanskrit text, Roman transliteration, English equivalents, and commentary—rendered by Swami A. C. Bhaktivedanta, the leading figure in the international Vaishnava (Devotional) movement today. Classical Vedic civilization, philosophy, sociology, politics, economics, and the deathless principles of Divine Love are here given elaborate attention by the authentic representative of these principles: a devotee in the line of disciplic succession which goes back to the days of Krishna's Appearance in this world. Price: $16.80 for 3 volumes (1200 pages).

Available from the International Society For Krishna Consciousness, 26 Second Avenue, New York, New York, 10003.

Who Is Crazy? (Original)

by
Swami A.C. Bhaktivedanta

Lord Sri Krishna says, "My dear Arjuna, there are different classes of men. One class of men, they are sleeping. And another class of men, they are awake. They are not sleeping." And how is this so? This chanting, which we have performed just now, is the wakening process for the sleeping soul. The soul is sleeping, covered by this material body. These bodily activities are in the sleeping stage. Just as we see dreams in the sleeping stage, similarly, all these bodily activities are dreams. Just think for yourself: how many incidents have there been in your past life? If you think of them, they will appear just like dreams. At least for myself this is the case. I was born in India, educated, then married, then I had very good days with my wife, got some children, some of whom died, some of whom are living, some of whom are married; now they have begotten children. All this occurred in my past life. Now it is all a dream. I have no connection with it. Similarly, in dreams I sometimes find that I have become a king. Oh, there are so many riches and so much opulence. Then, as soon as the dream is over, I come home and all is gone.

So actually, these bodily activities which we are now engaged in are not our actual life. Therefore, the Vedic mantra says, "O human race, please wake up. Just utilize the opportunity which you now have." You have a special opportunity. And what is that? This human form of life. Utilize it; don't waste it. Don't go on sleeping. This very same matter is taken up by Sri Krishna. Those who are accustomed to the yoga process know this. The first principle of the yoga process is to control the senses. This is so for every process. In any bona fide process for spiritual realization, the first principle is to control the senses. This is because the senses are dragging us into the darkest region of life. But we do not realize this.

In the Srimad Bhagawatam there is a nice verse. It says, first, man is too much addicted to this materialistic way of life. The materialistic way of life involves eating, drinking, making merry, and enjoying. That's it—that's all. Have very good food, sleep well, and defend yourself so that enemies may not enter into your country, or into your home. And, have sexual enjoyment to your heart's content. This is the materialistic way of life. But persons who are so sleeping do not realize that their real self-interest is different. Our real self-interest is that we must know of our lost relationship with the Supreme Absolute Truth.

The Supreme Absolute Truth is realized from different angles of vision, as impersonal Brahman, or localized Supersoul, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna. One who realizes the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna, automatically understands the other two features. But one who has approached only the impersonal feature of the Supreme Absolute Truth, has no information of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna. Now here, in the Bhagavad Gita, the Supreme Personality of Godhead is present before you.

Here is the picture of Sri Krishna, with his eternal consort Srimati Radharani, His pleasure potency. In this material world, the reflection of Sri Krishna and His pleasure potency exists pervertedly. As one can see in the picture, Sri Krishna is always consorting with Srimati Radharani. His features are described in Vedic literature: He stands in a very nice curved posture, blowing His flute. This picture is not drawn from artistic imagination. It is a descriptive painting from the Vedic literature. This description is in the Vedic literature.

So, in the material world there is the perverted reflection of Sri Krishna's Pastime with Radharani. It is not sex life as we have it, although it appears to be like that. It is transcendental. But that which we are after here—that is real. A young man wants a young woman, and a young woman wants a young man—this is natural. This is not artificial. It is natural because we are all part and parcel of that Supreme Being, Krishna. His attitude is in me because I am His part and parcel, just as the quality of gold is present in the minute particles of the gold. The chemical composition of gold is one hundred per cent present in a small particle of gold. Qualitatively. Therefore the enjoyment which we want between man and women is not a perversion of love and friendship. It is simply a perverted reflection. The real enjoyment is awakened in association with the Supreme Lord, Sri Krishna. It is the same pleasure, but is in its pure form. That same bliss is there for you, but don't become entangled in this perverted form of enjoyment. Don't remain asleep. Don't remain in this dreaming condition. Have the real thing. Awaken from the dream. That is the message of the Vedas.

This is the opportunity. If you miss this opportunity in the human form of life—the developed consciousness—you will slip again into the cycle of 8 million, 400 thousand species of life that is developing, one form after another. That is the gradual process of evolution. We are still within the evolutionary process, but that evolutionary process should be forward, progressive. Not degraded. Don't slide. Don't go downward. By your many years of endeavor, you have come forward to this stage of life. Now, make further progress. Progress toward Sri Krishna. Don't go back.

The Srimad Bhagawatam says that most people do not know their self-interest in life. It is like coming to a crossroads and not knowing the way. Suppose you are going to Philadelphia, and after crossing New York City, you see a crossroads, and you do not know the road. Of course, in America, there is a very efficient system of direction on the roads. That way, you have no misguidance. Similarly, in the scriptures the Vedic literature gives you direction. Yes, here is a crossing. If you want to go this way, you may. So the Bhagawatam says that people do not know the direction by which to make progress. One must know that he must make further progress toward Vishnu. Why? Because this is a very highly developed life. In this form of life, we have very high intelligence. We have more intelligence than cats and dogs and other animals. Why misdirect it? The misdirection is due to being attracted to this bodily concept of life. One is thinking, "I shall be happy utilizing the body and the senses to the utmost."

Because we do not know what our progressive life is, we are trying to squeeze the essence out of this body. To enjoy it. In the Bhagawatam there is a very good example cited about these foolish men. They are compared with the camel. The camel is a desert animal very fond of twigs containing thorns. They have very long necks, and they take a bunch of twigs with thorns and begin to chew. By contact with the thorns, blood oozes out the tongue. Naturally, if you chew thorns, your tongue will be cut. So, when they take those thorns within the mouth and begin to chew, the blood comes out. And when the blood is mixed up in that form, they eat it, because blood has a taste he likes. He thinks that twigs with thorns are very tasteful. Our sex life is like that. Just squeeze it out of the body, and we think we are enjoying it. This is our position.

Another example is given. In India the washermen keep asses. They load the ass as much as possible. The ass works all day and in the evening, his is offered some grass, and he's satisfied. For a morsel of grass, he is ready to work the whole day with a half ton of clothing on his back. Similarly, we also, the karmis, are very busy working all day and all night. And when we come home, we eat only one piece of bread. For one piece of bread, which costs not more than ten cents, one is working all day and all night. So the comparison is to the ass. The ass does not know for whom he is working so hard, and taking some bread. "This is the aim of my life." Is it my aim of life—to eat something and go to sleep, and have some sex pleasure and then die? No, this is not the aim of life. Your aim of life should be to realize yourself—that you are part and parcel of the Supreme Absolute Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna. Krishna is awaiting your arrival, so that you can enjoy life in His association.

One does not know what the progressive way of life is. Why? Because he has understood that this sense enjoyment is life's greatest pleasure. He is foolishly thinking that he will be happy by this sense enjoyment. This is just like having a horse which is not properly bridled. It is running on, running on, and you do not know where it will throw you. Similarly, uncontrolled senses are just like unbridled horses, dragging your chariot. You do not know where it will throw you. We do not realize how responsible we are for every action. To every small part of our action, there is a reaction. And our uncontrolled senses are putting us through the chain of action and reaction and dragging us into the darkest part of the universe.

Therefore, Lord Sri Krishna says that one who has learned how to control the senses is called swami. To a controlled person, worldly activities are darkness. Those who are situated in pure consciousness see that people who work hard simply for eating, sleeping, mating, and defending—these people are sleeping. And, to the persons who are engaged in these material activities, we are sleeping. They see that Swamiji has come to America to preach something to make us inactive. He is just trying to drag us from our general engagement, and he's trying to engage us in the process of Kirtan and hearing Bhagavad Gita, and wasting time. So, they believe we are sleeping. Somebody may think, these poor fellows have gathered here to waste their time in discussing something dry, which has no meaning, which is not bringing forth anything. Let us have some business discussion, so that we can gain something from it. We see that these people are sleeping and they that we are sleeping.

Now, actually, who is sleeping? He is awake who comes to the platform of consciousness that I am not this body—I am consciousness. One is awake who has understood this simple fact, that I am not this body, I am consciousness. Without consciousness, my body is useless. Therefore, I am actually consciousness. I am pure soul, and the symptom of my presence is consciousness. I am not this body. When I think deeply, I can understand that this is my body. This is not I, body. This is my body. So, one who has understood this—he is awake.

Now, the whole process described in the Bhagavad Gita is to be awake. You are pure consciousness—spirit soul. And, not only to be awake, but to act accordingly, so that, at the ultimate end, your pure consciousness may be liberated from this bodily entanglement. Then you'll get your healthy life. This is a disease, this material life. This material body is the symptom of my diseased form of life. I am not actually subject to birth and death. I am eternal. I never take my birth. I never die. This is my real position. Then, what is this birth and death? It is due to this body. Changing the body like a dress is called birth and death. But actually, I am pure soul.

Now, people are saying that god is dead. This theory is popular. They are making propaganda that the Lord is dead. But neither God nor we will ever die; neither do we have birth. In Bhagavad Gita Bhagavan, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Sri Krishna, says, "Arjuna, why are you afraid of fighting? Myself, yourself, and all these kings and soldiers who have assembled before us—all of them—they existed before, and they're existing now, and they will continue to exist in the future. There is no birth and death. So, this warfare should be on the condition of the body. Don't be afraid of it."

This point we have already discussed. One must understand this point: I am pure soul. My presence as pure soul is symptomatized by my consciousness. I know what has happened in my past life. And what is happening, that I can remember also. And, I can guess about my future life. At least, I make plans for my future. Unless I have my future, why should I plan? But, I am beyond this past, present and future. I am eternal. The Lord is eternal, and I am eternal also, as part and parcel of the Supreme God. Therefore, my self-interest is to attain that life of eternity. Life of full bliss. Life of full knowledge. That is the mission of my life. And one who takes that position seriously, who has taken up this mission of life, and is trying for that perfection, he is actually awake. And others who are not at this point, they are sleeping. This is the mark of a sleeping man. A man who is working strenuously the whole day, he is not actually awake. He is sleeping because his real intelligence is asleep. He has lost his self-interest. He does not know what the real interest of human life is.

All Vedic literature is imploring us, "Don't sleep! Don't sleep! Be awake! Be awake! Get up! Get up from this sleep! Utilize the boon which you now have. Don't be foolish."

People are working hard, and earning enough to eat. Especially in your country, there are sufficient means for eating, and nobody is starving. That's all right, but they are still not satisfied. I have studied this very carefully. The younger people all appear to be frustrated. It is not a very good condition, when the young generation, which is the future hope of the country, feels that there is no hope. Their future is dark. Why? Because they have no direction. What is the aim of life? What will they become? The philosophy is, work hard, get dollars, and enjoy as you like. This is misguidance. Therefore, the young are not happy. So, they take center of something which is objectionable for satisfaction. But that cannot give total satisfaction.

Now, here is an opportunity. The Bhagavad Gita can show you your actual life. Take advantage of it. Appeal especially to the younger people. Don't be frustrated; don't be disappointed. There is full enjoyment in your future. You are all part and parcel of the Supreme. Iswara parama Krishna, sat-chit-ananda vigraha. [Bs. 5.1] The Lord says, "Oh, these poor living entities. They are suffering so much. They are feeling frustrated. Oh, they are my parts and parcels." He is claiming. So He comes to claim you. "My dear boys, my dear children, why are you suffering? Please hear me. Give up all your engagements. Just hear Me. Try to follow what I say. I shall liberate you from all the reactions of sin." You'll find in the Bhagavad Gita that this is guaranteed. Simply surrender unto the Lord. Not only Sri Krishna, of course. Lord Jesus Christ also spoke in the same way: "Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn of me; for I am meek and lowly in heart: and ye shall find rest unto your souls. For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light." (Matthew: 1/28-30) That is the message of all persons who come from that Spiritual World—from the Kingdom of Godhead. That is the only message.

So, actually, this Bhagavad Gita is giving you the light to a happy life. Don't miss this opportunity. Try to hear it, to have it. Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu has made it very easy. To fulfill the mission of our life, there are nine different processes of devotional service: hearing, chanting, remembering, worshipping, accepting, service, offering everything, friendship and praying. Out of these nine, the first two processes, which are principle and primary, are Sravanam Kirtanam Vishnu. Hear and glorify. That will cleanse your heart of the dust which has accumulated for so many lifetimes, and you will see things very clearly.

Swami and Goswami are different synonyms of the word for persons who are in full control of the senses. Don't be thinking that you cannot control your senses. Everyone is able. You'll get strength by this process. This chanting of Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare/ Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Rama Rama, Hare Hare will help you. Don't be dejected by thinking that you have no strength. You'll get strength. Continue this process. Kirtanam Sravanam means chanting Hare Krishna, Hare Krishna, Krishna Krishna, Hare Hare. And, hear some passages from the Bhagavad Gita and Srimad Bhagawatam. Utilize these two processes, and you'll find strength for your spiritual life. One has to become situated in that position of sense control.

Now, you have no doubt seen the ocean. How full it is! The ocean is so powerful that, if it rose, all New York City would be submerged under water. But it does not disturb us. It does not go beyond its limits. For example, the Narrows is the brink of the ocean. The ocean does not come on the other side of the Narrows. This is the example. When we have controlled the senses, we shall be just like the big ocean—although full with spiritual knowledge, calm and quiet without disturbing anyone, and without being disturbed. Peaceful.

In Bengal there are about five hundred rivers. All these rivers flow down water, to the ocean. But still, the ocean, the Bay of Bengal, is calm and quiet. Quiet. Similarly, for those who have become as full and as big as the ocean, material desires may come, but they are not disturbed. Although so many rivers are flowing down water, you won't see an inch of increase in the ocean. It keeps the same level. You can take any amount of water out of it, and you can pour any amount of water into it. The sea level is always the same. This example is given. Desires we must have. We cannot extinguish desires. It is foolishness to think that we can subdue desires. Desires are the symptoms of life. Let there be desires. If I have life and consciousness, then desire must also be there. Just as, when the water flows down from the rivers to the ocean, the ocean is not disturbed, so a person need not be disturbed by these desires. This is the art. This is the secret of the perfection of your life.

Desires may come, but if you are fixed with a proper understanding, you convert your desires. The whole process is to dovetail your desires with the Lord's. The example is that Arjuna desired not to fight, but after hearing Bhagavad Gita, his desire changed. He said, "Yes, I shall fight!" He desired to fight. So there was desire. The mode of desire was changed, that's all. Similarly, we cannot stop desiring. That is not possible. But we have to change the quality of the desire. That is all. It's not very difficult: I shall do this, I shall not do this. Bhagavad Gita is meant to show us these things. Arjuna desired something before hearing Bhagavad Gita, and he desired something else after hearing Bhagavad Gita. The quality of desire changed. Similarly, by hearing the Gita you can change your desire. You don't have to stop your desire. You simply have to purify your desires. Then you'll not be disturbed by them. When your desires disturb you, you may know that you are not yet spiritually established. And when your desires enlighten you, enliven you, give you happiness—you may know that that desire is spiritual. Just as with Arjuna, the desire has to be changed.

Let desires be. Now, you can change the desires. Desire for Krishna. Don't desire for yourself. Desire for Krishna. How can I desire for Krishna? Take a practical example. Krishna came to this material world to call us; "My dear boys, please give up all your nonsensical engagements. Become a follower of Mine, and I shall protect you." This is Krishna's message. Now Bhagavad Gita is present, the message of Krishna. If you desire to preach this message of the Gita to the people of the world, that means you have changed your desire. And you can thereby purify yourself. There will be sufficient activities to execute the desire. But all those activities will be purified.

So, we don't have to stop our activities, nor our desires. But we have to dovetail them with the desires of the Lord, as Arjuna did. After dovetailing his desires with Sri Krishna's, his activities became more responsible. Just like a coward, he was refusing to fight. He was a Shatriya, a military man. His duty was to fight for a good cause. And what is a good cause? Sri Krishna instructed him to fight: "it is My plan." What can be a better cause than this? When the Supreme Personality of Godhead says that this is My wish, what can be more important? And what can be a better purpose, than one which is coming directly from the Supreme Personality of Godhead?

When we dovetail with the desire of the Supreme Lord, then our responsibility becomes more imperative, and we become more active than we are otherwise. In material activity you will get tired. This is the difference between material activity and spiritual activity. When you are engaged in spiritual activities, you'll not get tired. You have newer and newer strength to act. Therefore, desire is not to be stopped; activities are not to be stopped. Whatever potency you have in you, that is the potency given by the Supreme Lord, because you are the part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. Therefore, all the potencies that you have, they are also part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. And if you utilize them for the purposes of the Supreme Lord, then you become dove-tailed with Him, and your life becomes successful. You'll not be disturbed by material desires, you'll attain peace. The peace for which you are hankering in life after life, moment after moment—that you'll get at that time, when your desires are purified, and dovetailed with the Lord. One who desires sense gratification, the enjoyment of material satisfaction, will never be happy. That is not possible. If you want peace, if you want happiness, if you want perfection in your life, then just begin to dovetail your desires, activities, and potentials with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Then you will see what real happiness is, and can tell who is really crazy.

published by
ISKCON Press
243 East 10 st., N.Y.

Back To Godhead

is the magazine of the International Society For Krishna Consciousness.It is an instrument for training the mind to the highest and most sublime state of awareness—the awareness of the Transcendental, Infinite Godhead.

price per copy . .. $.25

Subscription rates—
1 yr .. ..... . . . $3.00
2 yrs . . . . .. . $5.50
5 yrs .... . . . $12.00
(add $.50 outside U.S.A.)
All monies tax deductible

To: ISKCON PRESS
26 Second Avenue
New York, N.Y., 10003
Enclosed please find $_____ for a _____-year
subscription to Back To Godhead Magazine.
Name ____________________
Address.____________________


THE KRISHNA CONSCIOUSNESS MOVEMENT IS AUTHORIZED (1975)

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada
Founder-Acarya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness

© Bhaktivedanta Book Trust 1975 All Rights Reserved. Printed in U.S.A.

KCA 1: The International Society for Krishna Consciousness

THE INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR KRISHNA CONSCIOUSNESS

The message of the Vedas, India's ancient spiritual and philosophical texts, is that the human form of life is meant for reviving our original God consciousness through the practice of spiritual discipline. The International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) is a worldwide, nonsectarian movement dedicated to propagating this message for the benefit of mankind. The Society was founded in 1966 by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, who had come to the United States a year earlier on the order of his spiritual master (Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé) to teach Kåñëa consciousness in the Western world.

Over the years, ISKCON has steadily grown in popularity and influence, and today it is widely recognized by theologians, scholars and laymen as a genuine and important spiritual movement. The reason for this is twofold: first, the philosophy which guides the lives of ISKCON's members is grounded firmly in the teachings of the Vedic literatures, specifically the Bhagavad-gétä and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam; second, the spiritual master and founder of ISKCON, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, is a leader of substantial erudition and integrity. As the current representative of an unbroken chain of self-realized spiritual masters, reaching back to Lord Kåñëa Himself, His Divine Grace is the leading exponent of Vedic culture in the world today.

ISKCON is an educational, cultural, and philosophical movement with nearly one hundred centers in thirty countries throughout the world. These centers enable full-time members to live in close association, following the principles of Vedic life, and also provide a place where interested visitors can learn about the philosophy and culture of Kåñëa consciousness and participate in its various functions.

The members of ISKCON are of all ages, of varying degrees of education, and from many walks of life: students, teachers, scientists, servicemen, laborers and professionals. Indeed, numerous races, creeds and nationalities are represented in ISKCON. The unifying characteristics that bring such diverse individuals to Kåñëa consciousness are high ethical standards and a sincere desire to understand spiritual truth. As a prerequisite for the serious pursuit of spiritual life, all devotees voluntarily abstain from meat-eating, illicit sex, intoxication and gambling.

In contrast to the complexity and anxiety of modern life, the Kåñëa conscious life-style is based on the principle of "simple living and high thinking." Devotees rise very early—about 4:00 A.M.—and spend the morning hours in meditation and study, attending classes in the profound and practical philosophy of Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Çréla Prabhupäda's translations of these two Vedic classics are regarded by many scholars as the most erudite and authoritative available. In the morning hours, the devotees also meditate on the mahä-mantra, composed of the following transcendental names of God: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Vedic literature states that this meditation is the simplest and most sublime process for reviving God consciousness in the current materialistic age.

During the day, the main activity is preaching Kåñëa consciousness. Many devotees go out to public places to distribute the Society's books and its official journal, Back to Godhead magazine, which has a monthly circulation of more than a million copies in thirteen languages. This literature is provided by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, the publishing arm of ISKCON, which is the exclusive publisher for the works of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. Since its inception in 1972, the BBT has quickly become the world's largest publisher and distributor of English and foreign-language editions of India's spiritual classics. To date, the BBT has published a total of sixty 400-page hardbound volumes, each profusely illustrated with original paintings by devotee artists. It is principally through the distribution of this literature (as well as by contributions from members and well-wishers) that the Society is financially maintained.

In addition to book distribution, devotees engage in a wide variety of activities, including teaching, outside jobs, artistic pursuits, and farming. The qualification in Kåñëa consciousness is not the kind of work one performs, but that it be done in the spirit of devotion to God. As Lord Krñëa tells His devotee Arjuna in the Bhagavad-gétä, "All that you do should be done as an offering unto Me." (Bg. 9.27)

Once a year, the members of ISKCON journey to the Society's international headquarters at Çrédhäma Mäyäpur, West Bengal, India. Çréla Prabhupäda has proposed establishing an Institute of Vedic Studies at this site, where visitors from all over the world can learn about Vedic culture and witness it in practice. Presently the world center includes a large facility for massive distribution of food to thousands of needy families. Another major Indian center is in Våndävana, the birthplace of Lord Kåñëa, where the Society has recently opened the magnificent Kåñëa-Balaräma Temple and International Guest House.

In the United States and other countries, ISKCON has established a series of rural äçramas, each a model of Vedic agrarian life. Avoiding modern farm machinery as far as possible, they demonstrate that a human being need not depend on the artificial economy of the city. He can live peacefully and simply in the country while pursuing a spiritual life.

For the children of ISKCON there is Gurukula, the Society's primary and secondary school system. Taught by academically qualified members of the Society, the children learn Vedic language and culture as well as the usual subjects like English, math, and history. The unique feature of Gurukula is that the entire educational process is centered around the goal of self-realization.

Throughout the world, the Kåñëa Consciousness Society has been recognized for its cultural and welfare activities. Mayors and law enforcement officials in major metropolitan areas have praised the Society for its success in helping young people overcome drug dependence. Addictions Magazine declared, "Kåñëa consciousness is close to one hundred percent successful in stopping drug use." The mayor of San Francisco has proclaimed a Ratha-yäträ Day in honor of the spectacular festival held annually by ISKCON. In addition, ISKCON is establishing centers for Vedic studies in several major American cities to enable college students and residents to take courses in Vedic philosophy, religion, arts, social thought and psychology.

Thus the International Society for Krishna Consciousness—a dynamic and effective spiritual movement—is making a significant contribution to the intellectual, cultural and spiritual life of contemporary man.

KCA 2: The Founder-Äcärya

THE FOUNDER-ÄCÄRYA

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda was born in 1896 in Calcutta, India. He first met his spiritual master, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé, in Calcutta in 1922. Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, a prominent devotional scholar and the founder of sixty-four branches of Gauòéya Maöhas (Vedic institutes), liked this educated young man and convinced him to dedicate his life to teaching Vedic knowledge in the Western world. Çréla Prabhupäda became his student, and eleven years later (1933) at Allahabad, he became his formally initiated disciple.

At their first meeting, in 1922, Çrila Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Thäkura requested Çréla Prabhupäda to broadcast Vedic knowledge through the English language. In the years that followed, Çréla Prabhupäda wrote a commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä and in 1944, without assistance, started an English fortnightly magazine.

Recognizing Çréla Prabhupäda's philosophical learning and devotion, the Gauòéya Vaiñëava Society honored him in 1947 with the title "Bhaktivedanta." In 1950, at the age of fifty-four, Çréla Prabhupäda retired from married life, and four years later he adopted the vänaprastha (retired) order to devote more time to his studies and writing. Çréla Prabhupäda traveled to the holy city of Våndävana, where he lived in very humble circumstances in the historic medieval temple of Radhä-Dämodara. There he engaged for several years in deep study and writing. He accepted the renounced order of life (sannyäsa) in 1959. At Rädhä-Dämodara, Çréla Prabhupäda began work on his life's masterpiece: a multivolume translation and commentary on the 18,000-verse Çrémad-Bhägavatam (Bhägavata Puräëa). He also wrote Easy Journey to Other Planets.

After publishing three volumes of Bhägavatam, Çréla Prabhupäda came to the United States, in 1965, to fulfill the mission of his spiritual master. Since that time, His Divine Grace has written over sixty volumes of authoritative translations, commentaries and summary studies of the philosophical and religious classics of India.

In 1965, when he first arrived by freighter in New York City, Çréla Prabhupäda was practically penniless. It was after almost a year of great difficulty that he established the International Society for Krishna Consciousness in July of 1966. Under his careful guidance, the Society has grown within a decade to a worldwide confederation of almost one hundred äçramas, schools, temples, institutes and farm communities.

In 1968, Çréla Prabhupäda created New Våndävana, an experimental Vedic community in the hills of West Virginia. Inspired by the success of New Våndävana, now a thriving farm community of more than one thousand acres, his students have since founded several similar communities in the United States and abroad.

In 1972, His Divine Grace introduced the Vedic system of primary and secondary education in the West by founding the Gurukula school in Dallas, Texas. The school began with three children in 1972, and by the beginning of 1975 the enrollment had grown to one hundred fifty.

Çréla Prabhupäda has also inspired the construction of a large international center at Çrédhäma Mäyäpur in West Bengal, India, which is also the site for a planned Institute of Vedic Studies. A similar project is the magnificent Kåñëa-Balaräma Temple and International Guest House in Våndävana, India. These are centers where Westerners can live to gain firsthand experience of Vedic culture.

Çréla Prabhupäda's most significant contribution, however, is his books. Highly respected by the academic community for their authoritativeness, depth and clarity, they are used as standard textbooks in numerous college courses. His writings have been translated into eleven languages. The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, established in 1972 exclusively to publish the works of His Divine Grace, has thus become the world's largest publisher of books in the field of Indian religion and philosophy. Its latest project is the publishing of Çréla Prabhupäda's most recent work: a seventeen-volume translation and commentary—completed by Çréla Prabhupäda in only eighteen months—on the Bengali religious classic Çré Caitanya-caritämåta.

In the past ten years, in spite of his advanced age, Çréla Prabhupäda has circled the globe twelve times on lecture tours that have taken him to six continents. In spite of such a vigorous schedule, Çréla Prabhupäda continues to write prolifically. His writings constitute a veritable library of Vedic philosophy, religion, literature and culture.

KCA 3: Reviews

REVIEWS

KCA 3a: Scholars Praise Çréla Prabhupäda's Books

Scholars Praise Çréla Prabhupäda's Books

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) adheres strictly to the principles of India's ancient Vedic culture, whose goal is the spiritual perfection of man. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is firmly based upon the conclusive truths found in Bhagavad-gétä, Çrimad-Bhägavatam, and Caitanya-caritämrta, which contain the essence of Vedic knowledge. These three major texts, translated into the English language by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda and replete with his erudite commentation, provide the philosophical and practical foundation for the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

His Divine Grace Sréla Prabhupäda is uniquely qualified to translate and teach Vedic knowledge. He is the representative of a well-documented disciplic succession of Vedic authorities. By providing guidelines for the practical implementation of the sublime Vedic teachings, Çréla Prabhupäda has for the first time successfully implanted genuine Vedic culture in the West.

The books of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda are highly respected by students, scholars and laymen alike. His works are now widely used in college courses and seminars in diverse subjects, including philosophy, religion, world literature, history, and the social sciences. The following reviews, written by scholars renowned in their fields, give graphic testimony to the scholarship and authenticity of the books of Çréla Prabhupäda, the founder-äcärya of the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

KCA 3b: Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS

"No work in all Indian literature is more quoted, because none is better loved, in the West, than the Bhagavad-gétä. Translation of such a work demands not only knowledge of Sanskrit, but an inward sympathy with the theme and a verbal artistry. For the poem is a symphony in which God is seen in all things.... The Swami does a real service for students by investing the beloved Indian epic with fresh meaning. Whatever our outlook may be, we should all be grateful for the labor that has lead to this illuminating work."

Dr. Geddes MacGregor, Emeritus Distinguished Professor of Philosophy
University of Southern California

"The Gétä can be seen as the main literary support for the great religious civilization of India, the oldest surviving culture in the world. The present translation and commentary is another manifestation of the permanent living importance of the Gétä."

Thomas Merton, Theologian

"I am most impressed with A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda's scholarly and authoritative edition of Bhagavad-gétä. It is a most valuable work for the scholar as well as the layman and is of great utility as a reference book as well as a textbook. I promptly recommend this edition to my students. It is a beautifully done book."

Dr. Samuel D. Atkins
Professor of Sanskrit, Princeton University

"...As a successor in direct line from Caitanya, the author of Bhagavad-gétä As It Is is entitled, according to Indian custom, to the majestic title of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. The great interest that his reading of the Bhagavad-gétä holds for us is that it offers us an authorized interpretation according to the principles of the Caitanya tradition."

Olivier Lacombe
Professor of Sanskrit and Indology, Sorbonne University, Paris

"I have had the opportunity of examining several volumes published by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust and have found them to be of excellent quality and of great value for use in college classes on Indian religions. This is particularly true of the BBT edition and translation of the Bhagavad-gétä."

Dr. Frederick B. Underwood
Professor of Religion, Columbia University

"...If truth is what works, as Pierce and the pragmatists insist, there must be a kind of truth in the Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, since those who follow its teachings display a joyous serenity usually missing in the bleak and strident lives of contemporary people."

Dr. Elwin H. Powell
Professor of Sociology
State University of New York, Buffalo

"There is little question that this edition is one of the best books available on the Gétä and devotion. Prabhupäda's translation is an ideal blend of literal accuracy and religious insight."

Dr. Thomas J. Hopkins
Professor of Religion, Franklin and Marshall College

"The Bhagavad-gétä, one of the great spiritual texts, is not as yet a common part of our cultural milieu. This is probably less because it is alien per se than because we have lacked just the kind of close interpretative commentary upon it that Swami Bhaktivedanta has here provided, a commentary written from not only a scholar's but a practitioner's, a dedicated lifelong devotee's point of view."

Denise Levertov, Poet

"The increasing numbers of Western readers interested in classical Vedic thought have been done a service by Swami Bhaktivedanta. By bringing us a new and living interpretation of a text already known to many, he has increased our understanding manyfold."

Dr. Edward C. Dimock, Jr.
Department of South Asian Languages and Civilization
University of Chicago

"The scholarly world is again indebted to A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. Although Bhagavad-gétä has been translated many times, Prabhupäda adds a translation of singular importance with his commentary...."

Dr. J. Stillson Judah, Professor of the History of Religions and Director of Libraries
Graduate Theological Union, Berkeley, California

"Çréla Prabhupäda's edition thus fills a sensitive gap in France, where many hope to become familiar with traditional Indian thought, beyond the commercial East-West hodgepodge that has arisen since the time Europeans first penetrated India.

"Whether the reader be an adept of Indian spiritualism or not, a reading of the Bhagavad-gétä As It Is will be extremely profitable. For many this will be the first contact with the true India, the ancient India, the eternal India."

Francois Chenique, Professor of Religious Sciences
Institute of Political Studies, Paris, France

"As a native of India now living in the West, it has given me much grief to see so many of my fellow countrymen coming to the West in the role of gurus and spiritual leaders. For this reason, I am very excited to see the publication of Bhagavad-gétä As It Is by Çré A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. It will help to stop the terrible cheating of false and unauthorized 'gurus' and 'yogés' and will give an opportunity to all people to understand the actual meaning of Oriental culture."

Dr. Kailash Vajpeye, Director of Indian Studies
Center for Oriental Studies, The University of Mexico

"... It is a deeply felt, powerfully conceived and beautifully explained work. I don't know whether to praise more this translation of the Bhagavad-gétä, its daring method of explanation, or the endless fertility of its ideas. I have never seen any other work on the Gétä with such an important voice and style.... It will occupy a significant place in the intellectual and ethical life of modern man for a long time to come."

Dr. Shaligram Shukla
Professor of Linguistics, Georgetown University

"I can say that in the Bhagavad-gétä As It Is I have found explanations and answers to questions I had always posed regarding the interpretations of this sacred work, whose spiritual discipline I greatly admire. If the aesceticism and ideal of the apostles which form the message of the Bhagavad-gétä As It Is were more widespread and more respected, the world in which we live would be transformed into a better, more fraternal place."

Dr. Paul Lesourd, Author
Professeur Honoraire, Catholic University of Paris

KCA 3c: Çrémad-Bhägavatam

ÇRÉMAD-BHÄGAVATAM

"This is a work to be treasured. No one of whatever faith or philosophical persuasion who reads these books with an open mind can fail to be both moved and impressed...."

Dr. Garry Gelade
Professor of Psychology
Oxford University

"It has been my great pleasure recently to have read the Çrémad-Bhägavatam in the superb edition authorized by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda.... I am sure this monumental work will go far to bring the sublime message of the Bhägavatam to numerous Westerners who otherwise would miss this opportunity. "

Dr. Alex Wayman
Professor of Sanskrit, Columbia University

"The Çrémad-Bhägavatam is extremely useful for all those interested in ancient India, whether their interest be that of the philosopher, the student of religion, the historian, the linguist, the sociologist or the political scientist.... I truly hope that Çréla Prabhupäda will complete his translation of the entire Bhägavata and continue to translate other eminent Sanskrit works as well. Undoubtedly, this work of Swamiji's is a great contribution to the troubled human society of today's world."

Dr. Sooda L. Bhatt
Professor of Indian Languages, Boston University

"The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust editions of famous religious classics of India, with new translations and commentaries, are an important addition to our expanding knowledge of spiritual India. The new edition of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam is particularly welcome."

Dr. John L. Mish
Chief, Oriental Division, New York Public Library

"... A commentary on the Vedänta-sütra by Çréla Vyäsadeva divided into twelve 'cantos' of which four are presented here in eight beautifully produced volumes. These lavish volumes, obviously the product of devotional effort, contain many lovely full-color illustrations...."

Choice magazine, June, 1975

"In the diversity of religious approaches offered by the yogés of India, the most significant, of course, is the way of Kåñëa consciousness. It is amazing to see how Çré Bhaktivedanta Swami has in less than ten years succeeded, by his personal devotion, untiring energy and efficient direction, in organizing the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. Now, he has undertaken the stupendous project of rendering the entire Bhägavata, the great devotional classic of India, into English. His edition is learning blended with devotional feeling and inspired by a definite purpose of communicating the intense lyrical and devotional quality of the Bhägavata. Çréla Prabhupäda has done an excellent service by his able rendition of 'the abode of divine joy' that the Bhägavata is."

Dr. Mahesh Mehta, Professor of Asian Studies
University of Windsor, Ontario, Canada

"It is axiomatic that no book can be expected entirely to satisfy all its potential readers. Here is one, however, which can be said to come remarkably close to that ideal.... we have here the ideal of what an edition of a Sanskrit text for a Western audience should be."

Dr. R. E. Asher
Professor of Linguistics, University of Edinburgh

"... For those who have no access to the Sanskrit language, these books convey, in superb manner, the message of the Bhägavatam. In addition to being a scholarly work, it directly reflects the spiritual aspirations of a religious community which has gained considerable popularity in modern America."

Dr. Alaka Hejib
Department of Sanskrit and Indian Studies, Harvard University

"Çrémad-Bhägavatam is a valuable source material and cannot but be attractive to serious students and scholars of religion and philosophy. I recommend this series, to anyone, as an important and useful reference work."

Dr. C. P. Agrawal, Chairwoman
Department of Humanities, University of Michigan

KCA 3d: Çré Caitanya-caritämåta

ÇRÉ CAITANYA-CARITÄMÅTA

"I am most happy to have these handsomely printed volumes which embody the work of so learned and sincere a believer in the message of the Caritämrta. I thank you."

Dr. Daniel H. H. Ingalls
Chairman
Department of Sanskrit and Indian Studies
Harvard University

"The appearance of an English translation of Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämi's Çré Caitanya-caritämåta by A.C. Bhaktivedanta [Founder-Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness] is a cause for celebration among both scholars in Indian studies and lay-people seeking to enrich their knowledge of Indian spirituality....It will fill a most serious lacuna in our libraries and in our courses on the religious traditions of India.

"... For the first time we possess a readily accessible edition for this great religious classic that will provide opportunity for scholars in Indian literature and followers of the Kåñëa consciousness tradition alike to compare the original text with a modern English translation and become acquainted with the deeper spiritual meaning of this work through the learned commentary of Çré Bhaktivedanta.

"... Anyone who gives a close reading to the commentary will sense that here, as in his other works, Çré Bhaktivedanta has combined a healthy mixture of the fervent devotion and aesthetic sensitivity of a devotee and the intellectual rigor of a textual scholar. At no point does the author allow the intended meaning of the text to be eclipsed by the promotion of a particular doctrinal persuasion.

"... These exquisitely wrought volumes will be a welcome addition to the libraries of all persons who are committed to the study of Indian spirituality and religious literature, whether their interests are sparked by the motivations of the scholar, the devotee or the general reader."

Dr. J. Bruce Long
Department of Asian Studies, Cornell University

"It is a remarkable document of great historical and sociological importance, giving a picturesque presentation of the socio-religious climate in the India of Çré Caitanya's times and the far-reaching social and religious changes wrought by him. As a literary piece, it is regarded as a work of great merit, having no parallel in the whole of Bengali literature. As a religious text, its sanctity is comparable to that of the Bhagavad-gétä.

"This English edition translated by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda is superb. It contains the original Sanskrit and Bengali verses with their English transliteration, synonyms, translation and elaborate purports, easily bearing testimony to the author's profound knowledge of the subject."

Dr. O.B.L. Kapoor, Emeritus Chairman and Professor, Department of Philosophy
Government Postgraduate College, Gyanpur, India

"It is a genuine joy to have this momentous biographical work on the life of Bengal's great saint Caitanya, prepared by his best-known modern interpreter, A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda."

Dr. Mark Juergensmeyer, Associate Professor of Ethics
and the Phenomenology of Religions
Graduate Theological Union, Berkeley, California

"Year by year, interest in Eastern religious thought and philosophy grows in America. The editing and translating of the important Çré Caitanya-caritämåta will make a substantial contribution to those who seek information about Indian concepts...."

Dr. Gerald A. Larue
Professor of Religion, University of Southern California

"I can recommend Çré Caitanya-caritämåta as a source of rich insights for every serious student of consciousness."

Dr. Rory O'Day, Department of Human Relations
University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada

KCA 3e: Other Major Writings by His Divine Grace

OTHER MAJOR WRITINGS BY HIS DIVINE GRACE*

"Teachings of Lord Caitanya is an authentic and lucid account, in English, of the life and philosophy of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. The spiritual movement initiated by 'the Great Master' five hundred years ago has profoundly influenced millions of men and women in India ever since, and is presently making its mark throughout the world.

"Çré A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, the present spiritual master of the movement in disciplic succession, has done a great service to the English-speaking world by making this spiritual treasure available in English."

Dr. K. L. Seshagiri Rao
Professor of Religious Studies, University of Virginia

"Kåñëa is an important book both for the new student of the history of religions and for the professional scholar. It is a helpful and significant contribution to the growing phenomenon of interest in the religions of Asia."

William A. Johnson
Professor of Philosophy, Brandeis University

"The book Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead should prove to be an important addition to materials available for college courses in religion. It is one of the best sources in English for gaining insight into the bhakti religious tradition."

Louis Roberts, Executive Chairman
Faculty of Foreign Languages and Literatures, Syracuse University

"The Perfection of Yoga is most useful for anyone wishing to understand the meaning of yoga. It also introduces the student to the study of Bhagavad-gétä and shows how direct and simple, yet in another sense, how profoundly complex is the path of spiritual growth through yoga practice. It is a scholarly book, yet has a direct personal meaning for all—a powerful combination."

Dr. Frank Ledwith, Professor of Psychology
University of St. Andrews, Fife, Scotland

"I think the best feature of the Hare Kåñëa movement is that it is providing scholars with excellent translations of the rarest books on kåñëa-bhakti."

Dr. Lawrence Shinn
Professor of Religion, Oberlin College

"I have read Çré Bhaktivedanta Swami's books with great care, attention and profound interest, and have found them to be of incalculable value to anyone who is curious about India's spiritual and cultural heritage. The author of these books displays on every page an astounding scholarship in the subjects treated, and also an understanding and ease of exposition of abstruse ideas, which are rarest gifts."

Dr. H. B. Kulkarni
Professor of English and Philosophy, Utah State University

"The publications of the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust are very valuable documents and will no doubt become classics for the English reader of Indian religious literature."

Dr. Jerry M. Chance, Chairman
Department of Philosophy and Religion, Florida A&M University

"These books are not only beautiful, but also relevant to our times, as we as a nation search for new cultural patterns for our way of life."

Dr. C. L. Spreadbury
Professor of Sociology, Stephen F. Austin State University

For more information on these publications and the Krishna Consciousness Society, please write the Society's Secretary at 3764 Watseka Avenue, Los Angeles, California 90034.

KCA 4: Decisions

DECISIONS

U. S. Courts Officially Recognize ISKCON's Public Activities

Numerous decisions in American courts over the years have supported the public programs of the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

Philadelphia

Judge Alfred L. Luongo
U. S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
The Philadelphia decree was typical, and included the following points:

Kåñëa consciousness is recognized as an authentic religion.
To broadcast the glories of God to all people, members of the Kåñëa consciousness society can perform saìkértana, a missionary activity including chanting, dancing and playing cymbals and drums; the dissemination of the word of God through preaching and reading aloud from religious literature; the distribution of religious literature, sanctified foods and flowers to the public; and the solicitation and acceptance of contributions.
In performing saìkértana, devotees can go wherever people gather—streets, byways and other public places.

Other major decisions:

Chicago

Judge Hubert F. Will
U. S. District Court for the Northern
District of Illinois, Eastern Division

Los Angeles

Judge Campbell M. Lucas
Superior Court of the State of California for the County of Los Angeles

Las Vegas

Judge Roger D. Foley
U. S. District Court for the District of Nevada

Denver

Judge Fred M. Winner
U. S. District Court of Denver, Colorado

San Francisco

Judge Melvin E. Cohn
Superior Court of the State of California in and for the County of San Mateo

KCA 5: A Short Statement of the Philosophy of Kåñëa Consciousness

A SHORT STATEMENT OF THE PHILOSOPHY OF KÅÑËA CONSCIOUSNESS

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) is a worldwide community of devotees practicing bhakti-yoga, the eternal science of loving service to God. The Society was founded in 1966 by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, a pure devotee of God representing an unbroken chain of spiritual masters originating with Lord Kåñëa Himself.

The following eight principles are the basis of the Kåñëa consciousness movement. We invite all our readers to consider them with an open mind and then visit one of the ISKCON centers to see how they are being applied in everyday life.

1. By sincerely cultivating a bona fide spiritual science, we can be free from anxiety and come to a state of pure, unending, blissful consciousness in this lifetime.
2. We are not our bodies but eternal spirit souls, parts and parcels of God (Kåñëa). As such, we are all brothers, and Kåñëa is ultimately our common father.
3. Kåñëa is the eternal, all-knowing, omnipresent, all-powerful, and all-attractive Personality of Godhead. He is the seed-giving father of all living beings, and He is the sustaining energy of the entire cosmic creation.
4. The Absolute Truth is contained in all the great scriptures of the world. However, the oldest known revealed scriptures in existence are the Vedic literatures, most notably the Bhagavad-gétä, which is the literal record of God's actual words.
5. We should learn the Vedic knowledge from a genuine spiritual master—one who has no selfish motives and whose mind is firmly fixed on Kåñëa.
6. Before we eat, we should offer to the Lord the food that sustains us. Then Kåñëa becomes the offering and purifies us.
7. We should perform all our actions as offerings to Kåñëa and do nothing for our own sense gratification.
8. The recommended means for achieving the mature stage of love of God in this age of Kali, or quarrel, is to chant the holy names of the Lord. The easiest method for most people is to chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra:

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare
Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

If you are interested in the subject matter of this booklet or would like to know more about the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, its publications and its programs we invite you to correspond with its Secretary. Or simply clip out this convenient coupon and mail it to us.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness
3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, CA 90034


@Please send me more information on the Society.
@ Please send me your catalog of publications.
NAME ____________________________
ADDRESS _________________________


"His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda is doing valuable work, and his books are significant contributions to the salvation of mankind."

Sri Lal Bahadur Shastri
Former Prime Minister of India

The Science of Self-Realization (1977)

Readers interested in the subject matter of this book are invited by the International Society for Krishna Consciousness to correspond with its Secretary.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness

3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90034


First Printing, 1977: 50,000 copies

Reprints of Prior Publications
© Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, 1968, 1969, 1970, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1976, 1977

All Rights Reserved
Printed in the United States of America


Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 77-95065
International Standard Book Number: 0-89213-101-2


BOOKS by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

Srémad Bhägavatam, cantos 1-10 (35 vols.)

Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 vols.)

Sré Caitanya-caritämrta (17 vols.)

Teachings of Lord Caitanya

The Nectar of Devotion

The Nectar of Instruction

Sré Içopaniñad

Easy Journey to Other Planets

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System

Perfect Questions, Perfect Answers

Teachings of Lord Kapila, the Son of Devahüti

Transcendental Teachings of Prahläda Mahäraja

Kåñëa, the Reservior of Pleasure

The Science of Self-Realization

The Path of Perfection

Light of the Bhägavata

Life Comes From Life

The Perfection of Yoga

Beyond Birth and Death

On the Way to Kåñëa

Geetär-gän (Bengali)

Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge

Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Matchless Gift

Back to Godhead magazine (founder)


A complete catalog is available upon request.


Bhaktivedanta Book Trust

3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90034

SSR Dedication

Dedication

According to material vision, our beloved spiritual master, guide, and friend His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda passed away from this world on November 14, 1977, but actually he is still present. As Çréla Prabhupäda often pointed out, there are two ways of associating with the spiritual master: through his physical presence (vapu) and through his instructions (väëé). Sometimes we can associate with the spiritual master through his physical presence and sometimes not, but we can always associate with him through his instructions

—The Editors

SSR Foreword

Foreword

From the very start, I knew that His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda was the most extraordinary person I had ever met. The first meeting occurred in the summer of 1966, in New York City. A friend had invited me to hear a lecture by “an old Indian swami” on lower Manhattan’s Bowery. Overwhelmed with curiosity about a swami lecturing on skid row, I went there and felt my way up a pitch-black staircase. A bell-like, rhythmic sound got louder and clearer as I climbed higher. Finally I reached the fourth floor and opened the door, and there he was.

About fifty feet away from where I stood, at the other end of a long, dark room, he sat on a small dais, his face and saffron robes radiant under a small light. He was elderly, perhaps sixty or so, I thought, and he sat cross-legged in an erect, stately posture. His head was shaven, and his powerful face and reddish horn-rimmed glasses gave him the look of a monk who had spent most of his life absorbed in study. His eyes were closed, and he softly chanted a simple Sanskrit prayer while playing a hand drum. The small audience joined in at intervals, in call-and-response fashion. A few played hand cymbals, which accounted for the bell-like sounds I’d heard. Fascinated, I sat down quietly at the back, tried to participate in the chanting, and waited.

After a few moments the swami began lecturing in English, apparently from a huge Sanskrit volume that lay open before him. Occasionally he would quote from the book, but more often from memory. The sound of the language was beautiful, and he followed each passage with meticulously detailed explanations.

He sounded like a scholar, his vocabulary intricately laced with philosophical terms and phrases. Elegant hand gestures and animated facial expressions added considerable impact to his delivery. The subject matter was the most weighty I had ever encountered: “I am not this body. I am not an Indian.... You are not Americans.... We are all spirit souls.... ”

After the lecture someone gave me a pamphlet printed in India. A photo showed the swami handing three of his books to Indian Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri. The caption quoted Mr. Shastri as saying that all Indian government libraries should order the books. “His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda is doing great work,” the Prime Minister said in another small tract, “and his books are significant contributions to the salvation of mankind.” I purchased copies of the books, which I learned the swami had brought over from India. After reading the jacket flaps, the small pamphlet, and various other literature, I began to realize that I had just met one of India’s most respected spiritual leaders.

But I could not understand why a gentleman of such distinction was residing and lecturing in the Bowery, of all places. He was certainly well educated and, by all appearances, born of an aristocratic Indian family. Why was he living in such poverty? What in the world had brought him here? One afternoon several days later, I stopped in to visit him and find out.

To my surprise, Çréla Prabhupäda (as I later came to call him) was not too busy to talk with me. In fact, it seemed that he was prepared to talk all day. He was warm and friendly and explained that he had accepted the renounced order of life in India in 1959, and that he was not allowed to carry or earn money for his personal needs. He had completed his studies at the University of Calcutta many years ago and had raised a family, and then he had left his eldest sons in charge of family and business affairs, as the age-old Vedic culture prescribes. After accepting the renounced order, he had arranged a free passage on an Indian freighter (Scindia Steamship Company’s Jaladuta) through an old family friend. In September 1965, he had sailed from Bombay to Boston, armed with only seven dollars’ worth of rupees, a trunk of books, and a few clothes. His spiritual master, His Divine Grace Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Thäkura, had entrusted him with delivering India’s Vedic teachings to the English-speaking world. And this was why, at age sixty-nine, he had come to America. He told me he wanted to teach Americans about Indian music, cooking, languages, and various other arts. I was mildly amazed.

I saw that Çréla Prabhupäda slept on a small mattress and that his clothes hung on lines at the back of the room, where they were drying in the summer afternoon heat. He washed them himself and cooked his own food on an ingenious utensil he had fashioned with his own hands in India. In this four-layer apparatus he cooked four preparations at once. Stacked all around him and his ancient-looking portable typewriter in another section of the room were seemingly endless manuscripts. He spent almost all of his waking hours—about twenty in twenty-four, I learned—typing the sequels to the three volumes I had purchased. It was a projected sixty-volume set called the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and virtually it was the encyclopedia of spiritual life. I wished him luck with the publishing, and he invited me back for Sanskrit classes on Saturdays and for his evening lectures on Monday,

Wednesday, and Friday. I accepted, thanked him, and left, marveling at his incredible determination.

A few weeks later—it was July 1966—I had the privilege of helping Çréla Prabhupäda relocate in a somewhat more respectable neighborhood, on Second Avenue. Some friends and I pitched in and rented a ground-floor storefront and a second-floor apartment, to the rear of a little courtyard, in the same building. The lectures and chanting continued, and within two weeks a rapidly growing congregation was providing for the storefront (by this time a temple) and the apartment. By now Çréla Prabhupäda was instructing his followers to print and distribute leaflets, and the owner of a record company had invited him to record an LP of the Hare Kåñëa chant. He did, and it was a huge success. In his new location he was teaching chanting, Vedic philosophy, music, japa meditation, fine art, and cooking. At first he cooked—he always taught by example. The results were the most wonderful vegetarian meals I had ever experienced. (Çréla Prabhupäda would even serve everything out himself!) The meals usually consisted of a rice preparation, a vegetable dish, capätés (tortilla-like whole-wheat patties), and dahl (a zestfully spiced mung bean or split pea soup). The spicing, the cooking medium—ghee, or clarified butter—and the close attention paid to the cooking temperature and other details all combined to produce taste treats totally unknown to me. Others’ opinions of the food, called prasäda (“the Lord’s mercy”), agreed emphatically with mine. A Peace Corps worker who was also a Chinese-language scholar was learning from Çréla Prabhupäda how to paint in the classical Indian style. I was startled at the high quality of his first canvases.

In philosophical debate and logic Çréla Prabhupäda was undefeatable and indefatigable. He would interrupt his translating work for discussions that would last up to eight hours. Sometimes seven or eight people jammed into the small, immaculately clean room where he worked, ate, and slept on a two-inch-thick foam cushion. Çréla Prabhupäda constantly emphasized and exemplified what he called “plain living and high thinking.” He stressed that spiritual life was a science provable through reason and logic, not a matter of mere sentiment or blind faith. He began a monthly magazine, and in the autumn of 1966 the New York Times published a favorable picture story about him and his followers. Shortly thereafter, television crews came out and did a feature news story.

Çréla Prabhupäda was an exciting person to know. Whether it was out of my desire for the personal benefits of yoga and chanting or just out of raw fascination, I knew I wanted to follow his progress every step of the way. His plans for expansion were daring and unpredictable—except for the fact that they always seemed to succeed gloriously. He was seventyish and a stranger to America, and he had arrived with practically nothing, yet now, within a few months, he had single-handedly started a movement! It was mind-boggling.

One August morning at the Second Avenue storefront temple, Çréla Prabhupäda told us, “Today is Lord Kåñëa’s appearance day.” We would observe a twenty-four-hour fast and stay inside the temple. That evening some visitors from India happened along. One of them—practically in tears—described his unbounded rapture at finding this little piece of authentic India on the other side of the world. Never in his wildest dreams could he have imagined such a thing. He offered Çréla Prabhupäda eloquent praise and deep thanks, left a donation, and bowed at his feet. Everyone was deeply moved. Later, Çréla Prabhupäda conversed with the gentleman in Hindi, and since what he was saying was unintelligible to me, I was able to observe how his every expression and gesture communicated to the very core of the human soul.

Later that year, while in San Francisco, I sent Çréla Prabhupäda his first airline ticket, and he flew out from New York. A sizable group of us greeted him at the terminal by chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra. Then we drove him to the eastern edge of Golden Gate Park, to a newly rented apartment and storefront temple—an arrangement very similar to that in New York. We had established a pattern. Çréla Prabhupäda was ecstatic.

A few weeks later the first mådaìga (a long clay drum with a playing head on each end) arrived in San Francisco from India. When I went up to Çréla Prabhupäda’s apartment and informed him, his eyes opened wide, and in an excited voice he told me to go down quickly and open the crate. I took the elevator, got out on the ground floor, and was walking toward the front door when Çréla Prabhupäda appeared. So eager was he to see the mådaìga that he had taken the stairway and had beaten the elevator. He asked us to open the crate, he tore off a piece of the saffron cloth he was wearing, and, leaving only the playing heads exposed, he wrapped the drum with the cloth. Then he said, “This must never come off,” and he began giving detailed instructions on how to play and care for the instrument.

Also in San Francisco, in 1967, Çréla Prabhupäda inaugurated Ratha-yäträ, the Festival of the Chariots, one of several festivals that, thanks to him, people all over the world now observe. Ratha-yäträ has taken place in India’s Jagannätha Puré each year for two thousand years, and by 1975 the festival had become so popular with San Franciscans that the mayor issued a formal proclamation—“Ratha-yäträ Day in San Francisco.”

By late 1966 Çréla Prabhupäda had begun accepting disciples. He was quick to point out to everyone that they should think of him not as God but as God’s servant, and he criticized self-styled gurus who let their disciples worship them as God. “These ‘gods’ are very cheap,” he used to say. One day, after someone had asked, “Are you God?” Çréla Prabhupäda replied, “No, I am not God—I am a servant of God.” Then he reflected a moment and went on. “Actually, I am not a servant of God. I am trying to be a servant of God. A servant of God is no ordinary thing.”

In the mid-seventies Çréla Prabhupäda’s translating and publishing intensified dramatically. Scholars all over the world showered favorable reviews on his books, and practically all the universities and colleges in America accepted them as standard texts. Altogether he produced some eighty books, which his disciples have translated into twenty-five languages and distributed to the tune of fifty-five million copies. He established one hundred eight temples worldwide, and he has some ten thousand initiated disciples and a congregational following in the millions. Çréla Prabhupäda was writing and translating up to the last days of his eighty-one-year stay on earth.

Çréla Prabhupäda was not just another oriental scholar, guru, mystic, yoga teacher, or meditation instructor. He was the embodiment of a whole culture, and he implanted that culture in the West. To me and many others he was first and foremost someone who truly cared, who completely sacrificed his own comfort to work for the good of others. He had no private life, but lived only for others. He taught spiritual science, philosophy, common sense, the arts, languages, the Vedic way of life—hygiene, nutrition, medicine, etiquette, family living, farming, social organization, schooling, economics—and many more things to many people. To me he was a master, a father, and my dearmost friend.

I am deeply indebted to Çréla Prabhupäda, and it is a debt I shall never be able to repay. But I can at least show some gratitude by joining with his other followers in fulfilling his innermost desire—publishing and distributing his books.

“I shall never die,” Çréla Prabhupäda once said. “I shall live forever in my books.” He passed away from this world on November 14, 1977, but surely he will live forever.

Michael Grant
(Mukunda däsa)

SSR Introduction

Introduction

"Who is Çréla Prabhupäda?" people often ask, and it is always a hard question to answer. For Çréla Prabhupäda always eclipsed conventional designations. At various times people have called him a scholar, a philosopher, a cultural ambassador, a prolific author, a religious leader, a spiritual teacher, a social critic, and a holy man. In truth, he was all these things and more. Certainly no one could ever have confused him with the modern entrepreneurial "gurus" who come to the West with slickly packaged, watered-down versions of Eastern spirituality (to satisfy our urge for instant well-being and exploit our well-documented spiritual naïveté.) Çréla Prabhupäda was, rather, a true holy man (sädhu) of deep intellectual and spiritual sensitivity—he had deep concern and compassion for a society which, to such a large degree, lacks real spiritual dimension.

For the enlightenment of human society, Çréla Prabhupäda produced some eighty volumes of translations and summary studies of India’s great spiritual classics, and his work has seen print both in English and in many foreign languages. Also, in 1944 Çréla Prabhupäda single-handedly launched a magazine called Back to Godhead, which today has a monthly circulation of more than half a million copies in English alone. Nearly all the interviews, lectures, essays, and letters chosen for The Science of Self Realization first appeared in Back to Godhead.

In these pages Çréla Prabhupäda presents the same message that the great sage Vyäsadeva recorded thousands of years ago, the message of ancient India’s Vedic literatures. As we shall see, he quotes freely and often from the Bhagavad-gétä, the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and other classic Vedic texts. He transmits in modern English the same timeless knowledge that other great self-realized teachers have spoken for millennia—knowledge that opens up the secrets of the self within us, nature and the universe, and the Supreme Self within and without. Çréla Prabhupäda speaks with startling clarity and a kind of convincing, simple eloquence and proves just how relevant the science of self-realization is to our modern world and our own lives.

Among the thirty-six selections chosen for this special book, we hear Çréla Prabhupäda’s moving poem upon his arrival in America, his exchange with a noted cardiologist on “soul research,” his revelations to London Broadcasting Company on reincarnation, his telling remarks to the London Times on real and false gurus, his dialogue with a German Benedictine monk on Kåñëa and Christ, his insights on superconsciousness and the law of karma, his conversation with a leading Russian scholar on spiritual communism, and his intimate talk with his disciples on the sham of modern science.

Read the selections in order, if you like, or start with the ones that first catch your interest. (The glossary at the back will explain unfamiliar words and names.) The Science of Self-Realization will challenge you and bring you inspiration and enlightenment.

—The Publishers

SSR Appreciation's of Çréla Prabhupäda's Work

Appreciation's of Çréla Prabhupäda's Work

Over the years many people have expressed their appreciation for Çréla Prabhupäda's work—bringing India's timeless science of self-realization to the West.

* * *

"His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda is doing valuable work, and his books are significant contributions to the salvation of mankind."

Sri Lal Bahadur Shastri
former Prime Minister of India

"Swami Bhaktivedanta brings to the West a salutary reminder that our highly activistic and one-sided culture is faced with a crisis that may end in self-destruction because it lacks the inner depth of an authentic metaphysical consciousness. Without such depth, our moral and political protestations are just so much verbiage."

Thomas Merton, theologian

"In the diversity of religious approaches offered by the yogis of India the most significant of course is the way of Kåñëa consciousness, shown by Çréla Prabhupäda Bhaktivedanta Swami, tenth teacher in the tradition of Mahäprabhu Caitanya. It is amazing to see how Çré Bhaktivedanta Swami has in less than ten years succeeded by his personal devotion and single-minded dedication to the task, untiring energy and efficient direction, in organizing the International Society for Krishna Consciousness having thousands of devotees, opening the Radha-Kåñëa temples in the major cities of the world and writing numerous works on the bhakti-yoga as taught by Çré Kåñëa and Çré Caitanya."

Professor Mahesh Mehta
Professor of Asian Studies
University of Windsor, Ontario, Canada

"A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda is a prestigious master and heir to a great tradition."

Joseph Jean Lanzo del Vasto
prominent French philosopher and author

"Words fail me to describe the height of scholarship and devotion manifest in Çréla Prabhupäda's vast writings. Our future generations will definitely find a better world to live in through the efforts of Çréla Prabhupäda. He stands for international brotherhood and the spiritual integration of all mankind. The literary world outside India, particularly of the West, is indebted to Çréla Prabhupäda, who has so scientifically acquainted them with what is best in Kåñëa conscious India."

Sri Viswanath Shukla Ph.D.
Professor of Hindi, M. U. Aligarh, U.P., India

"As a native of India now living in the West, it has given me much grief to see so many of my fellow countrymen coming to the West in the role of gurus and spiritual leaders. Just as any ordinary man in the West becomes conscious of Christian culture from his very birth, any ordinary man in India becomes familiar with the principles of meditation and yoga from his very birth. Unfortunately, many unscrupulous persons come from India, exhibit their imperfect and ordinary knowledge of yoga, cheat the people with their wares consisting of mantras, and present themselves as incarnations of God. So many of these cheaters have come convincing their foolish followers to accept them as God, that those who are actually well-versed and learned in Indian culture have become very concerned and troubled. For this reason, I am very excited to see the publications of Çré A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. They will help to stop the terrible cheating of false and unauthorized 'gurus' and 'yogis', and will give an opportunity to all people to understand the actual meaning of Oriental culture."

Dr. Kailash Vajpeye
Director of Indian Studies
Center for Oriental Studies, The University of Mexico

"The books of A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda are not only beautiful, but also relevant to our times, as we as a nation search for new cultural patterns for our way of life."

Dr. C. L. Spreadbury
Professor of Sociology
Stephen F. Austin State University

"It is a great honor for me to have the pleasure of examining the publications of the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, which I find to be of exceptional value for use in educational institutions and libraries. I particularly recommend the ancient classic Çrémad-Bhägavatam to all students and professors of Indian philosophy and culture. The learned author, His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami, is a world-renowned saint and savant in the field of Vedic philosophy and its practical application in the modern world. He has established over one hundred spiritual ashrams, for the study and cultivation of Vedic knowledge, throughout the world. Factually, he is unequaled in his efforts to establish the Vedic way of life, sanätana-dharma, in all countries of the world. Certainly, I am most grateful that this message of the Bhägavata is being spread for the benefit of the world by such a qualified personality as Swami Bhaktivedanta."

Dr. R. Kalia
President, Indian Library Association

"Swami Bhaktivedanta has offered to devotees of God a blessed service with his English translations and commentaries. The universal application of these truths is shown to be a promised blessing in these times of challenge when light is illumining darkness. Truly this is a holy, inspired writing for all aspiring souls seeking the why, whence and whither of life!"

Dr. Judith M. Tyberg
Founder and Director
East-West Cultural Center, Los Angeles, California

"...As a successor in direct line from Caitanya, the author is entitled, according to Indian custom, to the majestic title of His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. Swami Prabhupäda possesses total mastery of the Sanskrit language. The great interest that his reading of the Bhagavad-gétä holds for us is that it offers us an authorized interpretation according to the principles of the Caitanya tradition.... This appreciation, coming from a Christian philosopher and Indologist, is a gesture of sincere friendship."

Olivier Lacombe
Professeur Honoraire
Universite de Paris, Sorbonne
former Director, Institute of Indian Civilization, Paris

"I have read Çré Bhaktivedanta Swami's books with great care, attention, and profound interest, and have found them to be of incalculable value to anyone who is curious about India's spiritual and cultural heritage. The author of these books displays on every page an astounding scholarship in the subjects treated, and also an understanding and ease of exposition of abstruse ideas, which are rarest gifts of a man who has been rigorously brought up in the schools of Vaisnava philosophy and has absorbed its teachings so fully that he seems to have reached the highest state of spiritual illumination only few blessed souls achieve."

Dr. H. B. Kulkarni
Professor of English and Philosophy Utah State University,
Logan, Utah

"Undoubtedly, the work of Swamiji is a great contribution to the troubled human society of today's world."

Dr. Sooda L. Bhatt
Professor of Indian Languages
Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts

"The appearance of an English translation of Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Goswami's Çré Caitanya-caritämåta by A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda is a cause for celebration among both scholars in Indian studies and lay people seeking to enrich their knowledge of Indian spirituality.

"...Anyone who gives a close reading to the commentary will sense that here, as in his other works, Çré Bhaktivedanta has combined a healthy mixture of the fervent devotion and aesthetic sensitivity of a devotee and the intellectual rigor of a textual scholar.

"...These exquisitely wrought volumes will be a welcome addition to the libraries of all persons who are committed to the study of Indian spirituality and religious literature, whether their interests are sparked by the motivations of the scholar, the devotee or the general reader."

Dr. J. Bruce Long
Department of Asian Studies, Cornell University

SSR 1: Learning the Science of the Soul

I. Learning the Science of the Soul

SSR 1a: Seeing the Aim of Human Life

Seeing the Aim of Human Life

“At present, human society is being mislead by leaders who are blind, for they do not know the aim and objective of human life, which is selfrealization and the reestablishment of our lost relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead.... The Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying to enlighten human society in this important matter.”

This very important Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant to save human society from spiritual death. At present human society is being misled by leaders who are blind, for they do not know the aim and objective of human life, which is self-realization and the reestablishment of our lost relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. That is the missing point. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying to enlighten human society in this important matter.

According to Vedic civilization, the perfection of life is to realize one’s relationship with Kåñëa, or God. In the Bhagavad-gétä, which is accepted by all authorities in transcendental science as the basis of all Vedic knowledge, we understand that not only human beings but all living entities are parts and parcels of God. The parts are meant for serving the whole, just as the legs, hands, fingers, and ears are meant for serving the total body. We living entities, being parts and parcels of God, are duty-bound to serve Him.

Actually our position is that we are always rendering service to someone, either to our family, country, or society. If we have no one to serve, sometimes we keep a pet cat or dog and render service to it. All these factors prove that we are constitutionally meant to render service, yet in spite of serving to the best of our ability, we are not satisfied. Nor is the person to whom we are rendering that service satisfied. On the material platform, everyone is frustrated. The reason for this is that the service being rendered is not properly directed. For example, if we want to render service to a tree, we must water the root. If we pour water on the leaves, branches, and twigs, there is little benefit. If the Supreme Personality of Godhead is served, all other parts and parcels will be automatically satisfied. Consequently all welfare activities as well as service to society, family, and nation are realized by serving the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

It is the duty of every human being to understand his constitutional position with God and to act accordingly. If this is possible, then our lives become successful. Sometimes, however, we feel challenging and say, “There is no God,” or “I am God,” or even, “I don’t care for God.” But in actuality this challenging spirit will not save us. God is there, and we can see Him at every moment. If we refuse to see God in our life, then He will be present before us as cruel death. If we do not choose to see Him in one feature, we will see Him in another. There are different features of the Supreme Personality of Godhead because He is the original root of the entire cosmic manifestation. In one sense, it is not possible for us to escape Him.

This Kåñëa consciousness movement is not blind religious fanaticism, nor is it a revolt by some recent upstart; rather, it is an authorized, scientific approach to the matter of our eternal necessity in relation with the Absolute Personality of Godhead, the Supreme Enjoyer. Kåñëa consciousness simply deals with our eternal relationship with Him and the process of discharging our relative duties to Him. Thus, Kåñëa consciousness enables us to achieve the highest perfection of life attainable in the present human form of existence.

We must always remember that this particular form of human life is attained after an evolution of many millions of years in the cycle of transmigration of the spirit soul. In this particular form of life, the economic question is more easily solved than in the lower, animal forms. There are swine, dogs, camels, asses, and so on, whose economic necessities are just as important as ours, but the economic questions of these animals and others are solved under primitive conditions, whereas the human being is given all the facilities of leading a comfortable life by the laws of nature.

Why is a man given a better chance to live than swine or other animals? Why is a highly posted government officer given better facilities for a comfortable life than an ordinary clerk? The answer is very simple: the important officer has to discharge duties of a more responsible nature than those of an ordinary clerk. Similarly, the human being has to discharge higher duties than the animals, who are always busy with filling their hungry stomachs. But by the laws of nature, the modern animalistic standard of civilization has only increased the problems of filling the stomach. When we approach some of these polished animals for spiritual life, they say that they only want to work for the satisfaction of their stomachs and that there is no necessity of inquiring about the Godhead. Yet despite their eagerness to work hard, there is always the question of unemployment and so many other impediments incurred by the laws of nature. Despite this, they still denounce the necessity of acknowledging the Godhead.

We are given this human form of life not just to work hard like the swine or dog, but to attain the highest perfection of life. If we do not want that perfection, then we will have to work very hard, for we will be forced to by the laws of nature. In the closing days of Kali-yuga (this present age) men will have to work hard like asses for only a scrap of bread. This process has already begun, and every year the necessity for harder work for lesser wages will increase. Yet human beings are not meant to work hard like animals, and if a man fails to discharge his duties as a human being, he is forced to transmigrate to the lower species of life by the laws of nature. The Bhagavad-gétä very vividly describes how a spirit soul, by the laws of nature, takes his birth and gets a suitable body and sense organs for enjoying matter in the material world.

In the Bhagavad-gétä it is also stated that those who attempt but do not complete the path of approaching God—in other words, those who have failed to achieve complete success in Kåñëa consciousness—are given the chance to appear in the families of the spiritually advanced or in financially well-to-do mercantile families. If the unsuccessful spiritual aspirants are offered such chances of noble parentage, what of those who have actually attained the required success? Therefore an attempt to go back to Godhead, even if half finished, guarantees a good birth in the next life. Both the spiritual and the financially well-to-do families are beneficial for spiritual progress because in both families one can get a good chance to make further progress from the point where he stopped in his previous birth. In spiritual realization the atmosphere generated by a good family is favorable for the cultivation of spiritual knowledge. The Bhagavad-gétä reminds such fortunate wellborn persons that their good fortune is due to their past devotional activities. Unfortunately, the children of these families do not consult the Bhagavad-gétä, being misguided by mäyä (illusion).

Birth in a well-to-do family solves the problem of having to find sufficient food from the beginning of life, and later a comparatively easier and more comfortable way of life can be led. Being so situated, one has a good chance to make progress in spiritual realization, but as ill luck would have it, due to the influence of the present iron age (which is full of machines and mechanical people) the sons of the wealthy are misguided for sense enjoyment, and they forget the good chance they have for spiritual enlightenment. Therefore nature, by her laws, is setting fires in these golden homes. It was the golden city of Laìkä, under the regime of the demoniac Rävaëa, that was burned to ashes. That is the law of nature.

The Bhagavad-gétä is the preliminary study of the transcendental science of Kåñëa consciousness, and it is the duty of all responsible heads of state to chalk out their economic and other programs by referring to the Bhagavad-gétä. We are not meant to solve economic questions of life by balancing on a tottering platform; rather, we are meant to solve the ultimate problems of life which arise due to the laws of nature. Civilization is static unless there is spiritual movement. The soul moves the body, and the living body moves the world. We are concerned about the body, but we have no knowledge of the spirit that is moving that body. Without the spirit, the body is motionless, or dead.

The human body is an excellent vehicle by which we can reach eternal life. It is a rare and very important boat for crossing over the ocean of nescience which is material existence. On this boat there is the service of an expert boatman, the spiritual master. By divine grace, the boat plies the water in a favorable wind. With all these auspicious factors, who would not take the opportunity to cross over the ocean of nescience? If one neglects this good chance, it should be known that he is simply committing suicide.

There is certainly a great deal of comfort in the first-class coach of a train, but if the train does not move toward its destination, what is the benefit of an air-conditioned compartment? Contemporary civilization is much too concerned with making the material body comfortable. No one has information of the real destination of life, which is to go back to Godhead. We must not just remain seated in a comfortable compartment; we should see whether or not our vehicle is moving toward its real destination. There is no ultimate benefit in making the material body comfortable at the expense of forgetting the prime necessity of life, which is to regain our lost spiritual identity. The boat of human life is constructed in such a way that it must move toward a spiritual destination. Unfortunately this body is anchored to mundane consciousness by five strong chains, which are: (1) attachment to the material body due to ignorance of spiritual facts, (2) attachment to kinsmen due to bodily relations, (3) attachment to the land of birth and to material possessions such as house, furniture, estates, property, business papers, etc., (4) attachment to material science, which always remains mysterious for want of spiritual light, and (5) attachment to religious forms and holy rituals without knowing the Personality of Godhead or His devotees, who make them holy. These attachments, which anchor the boat of the human body, are explained in detail in the Fifteenth Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä. There they are compared to a deeply rooted banyan tree which is ever increasing its hold on the earth. It is very difficult to uproot such a strong banyan tree, but the Lord recommends the following process: “The real form of this tree cannot be perceived in this world. No one can understand where it ends, where it begins, or where its foundation is. But with determination one must cut down this tree with the weapon of detachment. So doing, one must seek that place from which, having once gone, one never returns, and there surrender to that Supreme Personality of Godhead from whom everything has begun and in whom everything is abiding since time immemorial.” [Bg. 15.3-4]

Neither the scientists nor speculative philosophers have yet arrived at any conclusion concerning the cosmic situation. All they have done is posit different theories about it. Some of them say that the material world is real, others say that it is a dream, and yet others say that it is ever existing. In this way different views are held by mundane scholars, but the fact is that no mundane scientist or speculative philosopher has ever discovered the beginning of the cosmos or its limitations. No one can say when it began or how it floats in space. They theoretically propose some laws, like the law of gravitation, but actually they cannot put this law to practical use. For want of actual knowledge of the truth, everyone is anxious to promote his own theory to gain certain fame, but the actual fact is that this material world is full of miseries and that no one can overcome them simply by promoting some theories about the subject. The Personality of Godhead, who is fully cognizant of everything in His creation, informs us that it is in our best interest that we desire to get out of this miserable existence. We must detach ourselves from everything material. To make the best use of a bad bargain, our material existence must be one-hundred-percent spiritualized. Iron is not fire, but it can be turned into fire by constant association with fire. Similarly, detachment from material activities can be effected by spiritual activities, not by material inertia. Material inertia is the negative side of material action, but spiritual activity is not only the negation of material action but the activation of our real life. We must be anxious to search out eternal life, or spiritual existence in Brahman, the Absolute. The eternal kingdom of Brahman is described in the Bhagavad-gétä as that eternal country from which no one returns. That is the kingdom of God.

The beginning of our present material life cannot be traced, nor is it necessary for us to know how we became conditioned in material existence. We have to be satisfied with the understanding that somehow or other this material life has been going on since time immemorial and now our duty is to surrender unto the Supreme Lord, who is the original cause of all causes. The preliminary qualification for going back to Godhead is given in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.5]: “One who is free from illusion, false prestige, and false association, who understands the eternal, who is done with material lust and is free from the duality of happiness and distress, and who knows how to surrender unto the Supreme Person attains that eternal kingdom.”

One who is convinced of his spiritual identity and is freed from the material conception of existence, who is free from illusion and is transcendental to the modes of material nature, who constantly engages in understanding spiritual knowledge and who has completely severed himself from sense enjoyment can go back to Godhead. Such a person is called amüdha, as distinguished from müdha, or the foolish and ignorant, for he is freed from the duality of happiness and distress.

And what is the nature of the kingdom of God? It is described in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.6] as follows: “That abode of Mine is not illumined by the sun or moon, nor by electricity. One who reaches it never returns to this material world.”

Although every place in the creation is within the kingdom of God because the Lord is the supreme proprietor of all planets, there is still the Lord’s personal abode, which is completely different from the universe in which we are now living. And this abode is called paramam, or the supreme abode. Even on this earth there are countries where the standard of living is high and countries where the standard of living is low. Besides this earth, there are innumerable other planets distributed all over the universe, and some are considered superior places and some inferior places. In any case, all planets within the jurisdiction of the external energy, material nature, require the rays of a sun or the light of fire for their existence, because the material universe is a region of darkness. Beyond this region, however, is a spiritual realm, which is described as functioning under the superior nature of God. That realm is described in the Upaniñads thus: “There is no need of sun, moon, or stars, nor is that abode illumined by electricity or any form of fire. All these material universes are illumined by a reflection of that spiritual light, and because that superior nature is always self-luminous, we can experience a glow of light even in the densest darkness of night.” In the Hari-vaàça the spiritual nature is explained by the Supreme Lord Himself as follows: “The glaring effulgence of the impersonal Brahman [the impersonal Absolute] illuminates all existences, both material and spiritual. But, O Bhärata, you must understand that this Brahman illumination is the effulgence of My body.” In the Brahma-saàhitä this conclusion is also confirmed. We should not think that we can attain that abode by any material means such as spaceships, but we should know for certain that one who can attain that spiritual abode of Kåñëa can enjoy eternal, spiritual bliss without interruption. As fallible living entities, we have two phases of existence. One is called material existence, which is full of the miseries of birth, death, old age, and disease, and the other is called spiritual existence, in which there is an incessant spiritual life of eternity, bliss, and knowledge. In material existence we are ruled by the material conception of the body and the mind, but in spiritual existence we can always relish the happy, transcendental contact of the Personality of Godhead. In spiritual existence, the Lord is never lost to us.

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying to bring that spiritual existence to humanity at large. In our present material consciousness, we are attached to the sensual material conception of life, but this conception can be removed at once by devotional service to Kåñëa, or Kåñëa consciousness. If we adopt the principles of devotional service, we can become transcendental to the material conceptions of life and be liberated from the modes of goodness, passion, and ignorance, even in the midst of various material engagements. Everyone who is engaged in material affairs can derive the highest benefit from the pages of Back to Godhead and the other literatures of this Kåñëa consciousness movement. These literatures help all people sever the roots of the indefatigable banyan tree of material existence. These literatures are authorized to train us to renounce everything related to the material conception of life and to relish spiritual nectar in every object. This stage is obtainable only by devotional service and nothing else. By rendering such service, one can at once get liberation (mukti) even during this present life. Most spiritual endeavors are tinged with the colors of materialism, but pure devotional service is transcendental to all material pollution. Those who desire to go back to Godhead need only adopt the principles of this Kåñëa consciousness movement and simply aim their consciousness at the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa.

SSR 1b: "Your Original Consciousness Is Kåñëa Consciousness"

"Your Original Consciousness Is Kåñëa Consciousness"

“Your Original Consciousness Is Kåñëa Consciousness,” Çréla Prabhupäda tells freelance reporter Sandy Nixon. “Now your consciousness is covered with so much rubbish. You have to cleanse it, and then—Kåñëa consciousness. Our consciousness is like water. Water is by nature clear and transparent, but sometimes it becomes muddy. If you filter all the mud out of the water, it again comes to its original clear, transparent state.”

Ms. Nixon: My first question is very basic. What is Kåñëa consciousness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa means God. We are all intimately connected with Him because He is our original father. But we have forgotten this connection. When we become interested in knowing, “What is my connection with God? What is the aim of life?” then we are called Kåñëa conscious.

Ms. Nixon: How does Kåñëa consciousness develop in the practitioner?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa consciousness is already there in the core of everyone’s heart. But because of our materially conditioned life, we have forgotten it. The process of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra—Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare. Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare—revives the Kåñëa consciousness we already have. For example, a few months ago these American and European boys and girls did not know about Kåñëa, but just yesterday we saw how they were chanting Hare Kåñëa and dancing in ecstasy throughout the whole Ratha-yäträ procession [an annual festival sponsored by the Kåñëa consciousness movement in cities around the world]. Do you think that was artificial? No. Artificially, nobody can chant and dance for hours together. They have actually awakened their Kåñëa consciousness by following a bona fide process. This is explained in the Caitanya-caritämåta [Madhya 22.107]

nitya-siddha kåñëa-prema ‘sädhya’ kabhu naya
çravanädi-çuddha-citte karaye udaya

Kåñëa consciousness is dormant in everyone’s heart, and when one comes in contact with devotees, it is awakened. Kåñëa consciousness is not artificial. Just as a young boy awakens his natural attraction for a young girl in her association, similarly, if one hears about Kåñëa in the association of devotees, he awakens his dormant Kåñëa consciousness.

Ms. Nixon: What is the difference between Kåñëa consciousness and Christ consciousness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Christ consciousness is also Kåñëa consciousness, but because at present people do not follow the rules and regulations of Christianity—the commandments of Jesus Christ—they do not come to the standard of God consciousness.

Ms. Nixon: What is unique about Kåñëa consciousness among all religions?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Primarily, religion means to know God and to love Him. That is religion. Nowadays, because of a lack of training, nobody knows God, what to speak of loving Him. People are satisfied simply going to church and praying, “O God, give us our daily bread.” In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam this is called a cheating religion, because the aim is not to know and love God but to gain some personal profit. In other words, if I profess to follow some religion but I do not know who God is or how to love Him, I am practicing a cheating religion. As far as the Christian religion is concerned, ample opportunity is given to understand God, but no one is taking it. For example, the Bible contains the commandment “Thou shall not kill,” but Christians have built the world’s best slaughterhouses. How can they become God conscious if they disobey the commandments of Lord Jesus Christ? And this is going on not just in the Christian religion, but in every religion. The title “Hindu,” “Muslim,” or “Christian” is simply a rubber stamp. None of them knows who God is and how to love Him.

Ms. Nixon: How can one tell a bona fide spiritual master from a fake?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Whoever teaches how to know God and how to love Him—he is a spiritual master. Sometimes bogus rascals mislead people. “I am God,” they claim, and people who do not know what God is believe them. You must be a serious student to understand who God is and how to love Him. Otherwise, you will simply waste your time. So the difference between others and us is that we are the only movement that can actually teach one how to know God and how to love Him. We are presenting the science of how one can know Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, by practicing the teachings of the Bhagavad-gétä and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. They teach us that our only business is to love God. Our business is not to ask God for our necessities. God gives necessities to everyone—even to one who has no religion. For example, cats and dogs have no religion, yet Kåñëa supplies them with the necessities of life. So why should we bother Kåñëa for our daily bread? He is already supplying it. Real religion means to learn how to love Him. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.2.6] says,

sa vai pumsäm paro dharmo
yato bhaktir adhoksaje

ahaituky apratihatä
yayätmä suprasédati

First-class religion teaches one how to love God without any motive. If I serve God for some profit, that is business—not love. Real love of God is ahaituky apratihatä: it cannot be checked by any material cause. It is unconditional. If one actually wants to love God, there is no impediment. One can love Him whether one is poor or rich, young or old, black or white.

Ms. Nixon: Do all paths lead to the same end?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. There are four classes of men—the karmés, the jïänés, the yogés, and the bhaktas—and each achieves a different goal. The karmés work for some material profit. For example, in the city, many people work hard day and night, and their purpose is to get some money. Thus, they are fruitive workers, or karmés. A jïäné is a person who thinks, “Why am I working so hard? The birds, bees, elephants, and other creatures have no profession, yet they are also eating. So why should I unnecessarily work so hard? Rather, let me try to solve the problems of life—birth, death, old age, and disease.” Jïänés try to become immortal. They think that if they merge into God’s existence, then they will become immune to birth, death, old age, and disease. And yogés try to acquire some mystic power to exhibit a wonderful show. For instance, a yogé can become very small: if you put him into a locked room, he can come out through any little space. By showing this kind of magic, the yogé is immediately accepted as a very wonderful man. Of course, modern yogés simply show some gymnastics—they have no real power. But a real yogé has some power, which is not spiritual but material. So the yogé wants mystic power, the jïäné wants salvation from the miseries of life, and the karmé wants material profit. But the bhakta—the devotee—doesn’t want anything for himself. He simply wants to serve God out of love, just as a mother serves her child. There is no question of profit in a mother’s service to her child. Out of pure affection and love, she cares for him.

When you come to this stage of loving God, that is perfection. Neither the karmé, the jïäné, nor the yogé can know God—only the bhakta. As Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.55], bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti: “Only through the process of bhakti can one understand God.” Kåñëa never says one can understand Him by other processes. No. Only through bhakti. If you are interested in knowing God and loving Him, then you must accept the devotional process. No other process will help you.

Ms. Nixon: What transformation does one undergo on the path...

Çréla Prabhupäda: No transformation—your original consciousness is Kåñëa consciousness. Now your consciousness is covered with so much rubbish. You have to cleanse it, and then—Kåñëa consciousness. Our consciousness is like water. Water is by nature clear and transparent, but sometimes it becomes muddy. If you filter all the mud out of the water, it again comes to its original clear, transparent state.

Ms. Nixon: Can one function better in society by becoming Kåñëa conscious?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, you can see that my disciples are not drunkards or meat-eaters, and from a physiological point of view they are very clean—they’ll never be attacked by serious diseases. Actually, giving up meat-eating is not a question of Kåñëa consciousness, but of civilized human life. God has given human society so many things to eat—nice fruits, vegetables, grain, and first-class milk. From milk one can prepare hundreds of nutritious foods, but no one knows the art. Instead, people maintain big slaughterhouses and eat meat. They are not even civilized. When man is uncivilized, he kills poor animals and eats them.

Civilized men know the art of preparing nutritious foods from milk. For instance, on our New Våndävana farm in West Virginia, we make hundreds of first-class preparations from milk. Whenever visitors come, they are astonished that from milk such nice foods can be prepared. The blood of the cow is very nutritious, but civilized men utilize it in the form of milk. Milk is nothing but cow’s blood transformed. You can make milk into so many things—yogurt, curd, ghee (clarified butter), and so on—and by combining these milk products with grains, fruits, and vegetables, you can make hundreds of preparations. This is civilized life—not directly killing an animal and eating its flesh. The innocent cow is simply eating grass given by God and supplying milk, which you can live on. Do you think cutting the cow’s throat and eating its flesh is civilized?

Ms. Nixon: No, I agree with you one hundred percent.... One thing I’m very curious about: can the Vedas be taken symbolically as well as literally?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. They must be taken as they are, not symbolically. That is why we are presenting the Bhagavad-gétä As It Is.

Ms. Nixon: Are you attempting to revive the ancient Indian caste system in the West? The Gétä mentions the caste system...

Çréla Prabhupäda: Where does the Bhagavad-gétä mention the caste system? Kåñëa says, cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöaà guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù: “I created four divisions of men according to their quality and work.” [Bg. 4.13] For instance, you can understand that there are engineers as well as medical practitioners in society. Do you say they belong to different castes—that one is in the engineer caste and the other is in the medical caste? No. If a man has qualified himself in medical school, you accept him as a doctor; and if another man has a degree in engineering, you accept him as an engineer. Similarly, the Bhagavad-gétä defines four classes of men in society: a class of highly intelligent men, a class of administrators, a class of productive men, and ordinary workers. These divisions are natural. For example, one class of men is very intelligent. But to actually meet the qualifications of first-class men as described in the Bhagavad-gétä, they need to be trained, just as an intelligent boy requires training in a college to become a qualified doctor. So in the Kåñëa consciousness movement we are training the intelligent men how to control their minds, how to control their senses, how to become truthful, how to become clean internally and externally, how to become wise, how to apply their knowledge in practical life, and how to become God conscious. All these boys [gestures toward seated disciples] have first-class intelligence, and now we are training them to use it properly.

We are not introducing the caste system, in which any rascal born in a brähmaëa family is automatically a brähmaëa. He may have the habits of a fifth-class man, but he is accepted as first class because of his birth in a brähmaëa family. We don’t accept that. We recognize a man as first class who is trained as a brähmaëa. It doesn’t matter whether he is Indian, European, or American; lowborn or highborn—it doesn’t matter. Any intelligent man can be trained to adopt first-class habits. We want to stop the nonsensical idea that we are imposing the Indian caste system on our disciples. We are simply picking out men with first-class intelligence and training them how to become first class in every respect.

Ms. Nixon: How do you feel about women’s liberation?

Çréla Prabhupäda: So-called equal rights for women means that the men cheat the women. Suppose a woman and a man meet, they become lovers, they have sex, the woman becomes pregnant, and the man goes away. The woman has to take charge of the child and beg alms from the government, or else she kills the child by having an abortion. This is the woman’s independence. In India, although a woman may be poverty-stricken, she stays under the care of her husband, and he takes responsibility for her. When she becomes pregnant, she is not forced to kill the child or maintain him by begging. So, which is real independence—to remain under the care of the husband or to be enjoyed by everyone?

Ms. Nixon: How about in spiritual life—can women also succeed in Kåñëa consciousness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We make no distinction on the basis of sex. We give Kåñëa consciousness to both men and women equally. We welcome women, men, the poor, the rich—everyone. Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.18]:

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

“The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog, and a dog-eater.”

Ms. Nixon: Could you explain the meaning of the Hare Kåñëa mantra?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is very simple. Hare means, “O energy of the Lord,” and Kåñëa means, “O Lord Kåñëa.” Just as there are males and females in the material world, similarly, God is the original male (puruña), and His energy (prakåti) is the original female. So, when we chant Hare Kåñëa, we are saying, “O Lord Kåñëa, O energy of Kåñëa, kindly engage me in Your service.”

Ms. Nixon: Could you please tell me a little bit about your life and how you knew that you were the spiritual master of the Kåñëa consciousness movement?

Çréla Prabhupäda: My life is simple. I was a householder with a wife and children—now I have grandsons—when my spiritual master ordered me to go to the Western countries and preach the cult of Kåñëa consciousness. So I left everything on the order of my spiritual master, and now I am trying to execute his order and the orders of Kåñëa.

Ms. Nixon: How old were you when he told you to go to the West?

Çréla Prabhupäda: At our first meeting, he ordered me to preach Kåñëa consciousness in the West. I was then twenty-five years old, a married man with two children. I tried my best to carry out his orders and started managing Back to Godhead magazine in 1944, when I was still in household life. I started writing books in 1959 after retiring from family life, and in 1965 I came to the United States.

Ms. Nixon: You have said that you are not God, and yet it appears to me, as an outsider, that your devotees treat you as if you were God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is their duty. Because the spiritual master is executing God’s order, he should be respected as much as God, just as a government officer should be respected as much as the government because he executes the government’s order. Even if an ordinary policeman comes, you have to respect him because he is a government man. But that does not mean he is the government. Säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästrair/ uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù [Gurv-añöaka 7]: “The spiritual master is to be honored as much as the Supreme Lord because he is the most confidential servitor of the Lord. This is acknowledged in all revealed scriptures and followed by all authorities.”

Ms. Nixon: I also wonder about the many beautiful material things that the devotees bring you. For instance, you left the airport in a beautiful, fancy car. I wonder about this because...

Çréla Prabhupäda: That teaches the disciples how to regard the spiritual master as good as God. If you respect the government representative as much as you respect the government, then you must treat him opulently. If you respect the spiritual master as much as God, then you must offer him the same facilities you would offer to God. God travels in a golden car. If the disciples offer the spiritual master an ordinary motorcar, it would not be sufficient, because the spiritual master has to be treated like God. If God comes to your home, will you bring him an ordinary motorcar—or will you arrange for a golden car?

Ms. Nixon: One of the most difficult aspects of Kåñëa consciousness for an outsider to accept is the Deity in the temple—how it represents Kåñëa. Could you talk a little bit about that?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. At the present moment, because you have not been trained to see Kåñëa, He kindly appears before you so you can see Him. You can see wood and stone, but you cannot see what is spiritual. Suppose your father is in the hospital, and he dies. You are crying by his bedside, “Now my father is gone!” But why do you say he is gone? What is that thing which is gone?

Ms. Nixon: Well, his spirit is gone.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And have you seen that spirit?

Ms. Nixon: No.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So you cannot see spirit, and God is the Supreme Spirit. Actually, He is everything—spirit and matter—but you cannot see Him in His spiritual identity. Therefore, to show kindness toward you, He appears out of His unbounded mercy in the form of a wooden or stone Deity so that you can see Him.

Ms. Nixon: Thank you very much.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Hare Kåñëa!

SSR 1c: "Real Advancement Means Knowing God"

"Real Advancement Means Knowing God"

"The purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to propagate God's name, God's glories, God's activities, God's beauty, and God's love. . . . This Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant to give perfect knowledge to human society."

Ladies and gentlemen, I thank you very much for kindly participating in this Kåñëa consciousness movement. When this society was registered in 1966 in New York, a friend suggested that it be named the Society for God Consciousness. He thought that the name Kåñëa was sectarian. The dictionary also says that Kåñëa is a Hindu god's name. But in actuality, if any name can be attributed to God, it is "Kåñëa."

Actually God has no particular name. By saying He has no name, we mean that no one knows how many names He has. Since God is unlimited, His names also must be unlimited. Therefore we cannot settle on one name. For instance, Kåñëa is sometimes called Yaçodä-nandana, the son of mother Yaçodä; or Devaké-nandana, the son of Devaké; or Vasudeva-nandana, the son of Vasudeva; or Nanda-nandana, the son of Nanda. Sometimes He is called Pärtha-särathi, indicating that He acted as the charioteer of Arjuna, who is sometimes called Pärtha, the son of Påthä.

God has many dealings with His many devotees, and according to those dealings, He is called certain names. Since He has innumerable devotees and innumerable relations with them, He also has innumerable names. We cannot hit on any one name. But the name Kåñëa means “all-attractive.” God attracts everyone; that is the definition of “God.” We have seen many pictures of Kåñëa, and we see that He attracts the cows, calves, birds, beasts, trees, plants, and even the water in Våndävana. He is attractive to the cowherd boys, to the gopés, to Nanda Mahäräja, to the Päëdavas, and to all human society. Therefore if any particular name can be given to God, that name is “Kåñëa.”

Paräçara Muni, a great sage and the father of Vyäsadeva, who compiled all the Vedic literatures, gave the following definition of God:

aiçvaryasya samagrasya
véryasya yaçasaù çriyaù
jïäna-vairägyayoç caiva
ñaëëäà bhaga itéìganä
[Viñëu Puräëa 6.5.47]

Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is thus defined by Paräçara Muni as one who is full in six opulences—who has full strength, fame, wealth, knowledge, beauty, and renunciation.

Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is the proprietor of all riches. There are many rich men in the world, but no one can claim that he possesses all the wealth. Nor can anyone claim that no one is richer than he. We understand from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, however, that when Kåñëa was present on this earth He had 16,108 wives, and each wife lived in a palace made of marble and bedecked with jewels. The rooms were filled with furniture made of ivory and gold, and there was great opulence everywhere. These descriptions are all given vividly in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. In the history of human society we cannot find anyone who had sixteen thousand wives or sixteen thousand palaces. Nor did Kåñëa go to one wife one day and another wife another day. No, He was personally present in every palace at the same time. This means that He expanded Himself in 16,108 forms. This is impossible for an ordinary man, but it is not very difficult for God. If God is unlimited, He can expand Himself in unlimited forms, otherwise there is no meaning to the word “unlimited.” God is omnipotent; He can maintain not only sixteen thousand wives but sixteen million and still encounter no difficulty, otherwise there is no meaning to the word “omnipotent.”

These are all attractive features. We experience in this material world that if a man is very rich, he is attractive. In America, for instance, Rockefeller and Ford are very attractive because of their riches. They are attractive even though they do not possess all the wealth of the world. How much more attractive, then, is God, who is the possessor of all riches.

Similarly, Kåñëa has unlimited strength. His strength was present from the moment of His birth. When Kåñëa was only three months old, the Putanä demon attempted to kill Him, but instead she was killed by Kåñëa. That is God. God is God from the beginning. He does not become God by some meditation or mystic power. Kåñëa is not that type of God. Kåñëa was God from the very beginning of His appearance.

Kåñëa also has unlimited fame. Of course, we are devotees of Kåñëa and know of Him and glorify Him, but apart from us, many millions in the world are aware of the fame of the Bhagavad-gétä. In all countries all over the world the Bhagavad-gétä is read by philosophers, psychologists, and religionists. We are also finding very good sales with our Bhagavad-gétä As It Is. This is because the commodity is pure gold. There are many editions of the Bhagavad-gétä, but they are not pure. Ours is selling more because we are presenting the Bhagavad-gétä as it is. The fame of the Bhagavad-gétä is Kåñëa’s fame.

Beauty, another opulence, is possessed unlimitedly by Kåñëa. Kåñëa Himself is very beautiful, as are all His associates. Those who were pious in a previous life receive an opportunity in this material world to take birth in good families and good nations. The American people are very rich and beautiful, and these opulences are a result of pious activities. All over the world people are attracted to the Americans because they are advanced in scientific knowledge, riches, beauty, and so on. This planet is an insignificant planet within the universe, yet within this planet, one country—America—has so many attractive features. We can just imagine, then, how many attractive features must be possessed by God, who is the creator of the entire cosmic manifestation. How beautiful He must be—He who has created all beauty.

A person is attractive not only because of his beauty, but also because of his knowledge. A scientist or philosopher may be attractive because of his knowledge, but what knowledge is more sublime than that given by Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä? There is no comparison in the world to such knowledge. At the same time, Kåñëa possesses full renunciation (vairägya). So many things are working under Kåñëa’s direction in this material world, but actually Kåñëa is not present here. A big factory may continue to work, although the owner may not be present. Similarly, Kåñëa’s potencies are working under the direction of His assistants, the demigods. Thus Kåñëa Himself is aloof from the material world. This is all described in the revealed scriptures.

God, therefore, has many names according to His activities, but because He possesses so many opulences, and because with these opulences He attracts everyone, He is called Kåñëa. The Vedic literature asserts that God has many names, but “Kåñëa” is the principal name.

The purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to propagate God’s name, God’s glories, God’s activities, God’s beauty, and God’s love. There are many things within this material world, and all of them are within Kåñëa. The most prominent feature of this material world is sex, and that also is present in Kåñëa. We are worshiping Rädhä and Kåñëa, and attraction exists between them, but material attraction and spiritual attraction are not the same. In Kåñëa, sex is real, but here in the material world it is unreal. Everything we deal with here is present in the spiritual world, but here it has no real value. It is only a reflection. In store windows we see many mannequins, but no one cares about them, because everyone knows they are false. A mannequin may be very beautiful, but still it is false. When people see a beautiful woman, however, they are attracted because they think she is real. In actuality, the so-called living are also dead, because this body is simply a lump of matter; as soon as the soul leaves the body, no one would care to see the so-called beautiful body of the woman. The real factor, the real attracting force, is the spiritual soul.

In the material world everything is made of dead matter; therefore it is simply an imitation. The reality of things exists in the spiritual world. Those who have read the Bhagavad-gétä can understand what the spiritual world is like, for there it is described:

paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo
'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù
yaù sa sarveñu bhüteñu
naçyatsu na vinaçyati

"Yet there is another nature, which is eternal and is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is.” [Bhagavad-gétä 8.20]

Scientists are attempting to calculate the length and breadth of this material world, but they cannot begin. It will take them thousands of years simply to travel to the nearest star. And what to speak of the spiritual world? Since we cannot know the material world, how can we know what is beyond it? The point is that we must know from authoritative sources.

The most authoritative source is Kåñëa, for He is the reservoir of all knowledge. No one is wiser or more knowledgeable than Kåñëa. Kåñëa informs us that beyond this material world is a spiritual sky, which is filled with innumerable planets. That sky is far, far greater than material space, which constitutes only one fourth of the entire creation. Similarly, the living entities within the material world are but a small portion of the living entities throughout the creation. This material world is compared to a prison, and just as prisoners represent only a small percentage of the total population, so the living entities within the material world constitute but a fragmental portion of all living entities.

Those who have revolted against God—who are criminal—are placed in this material world. Sometimes criminals say that they don’t care for the government, but nonetheless they are arrested and punished. Similarly, living entities who declare their defiance of God are placed in the material world.

Originally the living entities are all part and parcel of God and are related to Him just as sons are related to their father. Christians also consider God the supreme father. Christians go to church and pray, “Our Father, who art in heaven.”, The conception of God as father is also in the Bhagavad-gétä [14.4]:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all the species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father.”

There are 8,400,000 species of life—including aquatics, plants, birds, beasts, insects, and human beings. Of the human species, most are uncivilized, and out of the few civilized species only a small number of human beings take to religious life. Out of many so-called religionists, most identify themselves by designations, claiming, “I am Hindu,” “I am Muslim,” “I am Christian,” and so on. Some engage in philanthropic work, some give to the poor, and open schools and hospitals. This altruistic process is called karma-käëòa. Out of millions of these karma-käëòés, there may be one jïäné ("one who knows"). Out of millions of jïänés, one may be liberated, and out of billions of liberated souls, one may be able to understand Kåñëa. This, then, is the position of Kåñëa. As Kåñëa Himself says in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.3]:

manuñyäëäà sahasreñu
kaçcid yatati siddhaye
yatatäm api siddhänäà
kaçcin mäà vetti tattvataù

"Out of many thousands among men, one may endeavor for perfection, and of those who have achieved perfection, hardly one knows Me in truth.”

Understanding Kåñëa, then, is very difficult. But although the understanding of God is a difficult subject, God explains Himself in the Bhagavad-gétä. He says, “I am like this, and I am like this. The material nature is like this, and the spiritual nature is like that. The living entities are like this, and the Supreme Soul is like that.” Thus everything is completely described in the Bhagavad-gétä. Although understanding God is very difficult, it is not difficult when God Himself gives us His own knowledge. Actually that is the only process by which we can understand God. To understand God by our own speculation is not possible, for God is unlimited and we are limited. Our knowledge and perception are both very limited, so how can we understand the unlimited? If we simply accept the version of the unlimited, we can come to understand Him. That understanding is our perfection.

Speculative knowledge of God will lead us nowhere. If a boy wants to know who his father is, the simple process is to ask his mother. The mother will then say, “This is your father.” This is the way of perfect knowledge. Of course, one may speculate about one’s father, wondering if this is the man or if that is the man, and one may wander over the whole city, asking, “Are you my father? Are you my father?” The knowledge derived from such a process, however, will always remain imperfect. One will never find his father in this way. The simple process is to take the knowledge from an authority—in this case, the mother. She simply says, “My dear boy, here is your father.” In this way our knowledge is perfect. Transcendental knowledge is similar. I was just previously speaking of a spiritual world. This spiritual world is not subject to our speculation. God says, “There is a spiritual world, and that is My headquarters.” In this way we receive knowledge from Kåñëa, the best authority. We may not be perfect, but our knowledge is perfect because it is received from the perfect source.

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant to give perfect knowledge to human society. By such knowledge one can understand who he is, who God is, what the material world is, why we have come here, why we must undergo so much tribulation and misery, and why we have to die. Of course, no one wants to die, but death will come. No one wants to become an old man, but still old age comes. No one wants to suffer from disease, but surely enough, disease comes. These are the real problems of human life, and they are yet to be solved. Civilization attempts to improve eating, sleeping, mating, and defense, but these are not the real problems. A man sleeps, and a dog sleeps. A man is not more advanced simply because he has a nice apartment. In both cases, the business is the same—sleeping. Man has discovered atomic weapons for defense, but the dog also has teeth and claws and can also defend himself. In both cases, defense is there. Man cannot say that because he has the atomic bomb he can conquer the entire world or the entire universe. That is not possible. Man may possess an elaborate method for defense, or a gorgeous method for eating, sleeping, or mating, but that does not make him advanced. We may call his advancement polished animalism, and that is all.

Real advancement means knowing God. If we are lacking knowledge of God, we are not actually advanced. Many rascals deny the existence of God because if there is no God they can continue their sinful activities. It may be very nice for them to think that there is no God, but God will not die simply because we deny Him. God is there, and His administration is there. By His orders the sun is rising, the moon is rising, the water flows, and the ocean abides by the tide. Thus everything functions under His order. Since everything is going on very nicely, how can one realistically think that God is dead? If there is mismanagement, we may say that there is no government, but if there is good management, how can we say that there is no government? Just because people do not know God, they say that God is dead, that there is no God, or that God has no form. But we are firmly convinced that there is God and that Kåñëa is God. Therefore we are worshiping Him. That is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. Try to understand it. Thank you very much.

SSR 1d: Reincarnation and Beyond

Reincarnation and Beyond

Mike Robinson, an interviewer for the London Broadcasting Company, inquires about the science of the soul: Have we been here before? Will we be back again, or. . . ? Çréla Prabhupäda calls upon the age-old Vedic literatures for some striking answers.

Mike Robinson: Can you tell me what you believe—what the philosophy of the Hare Kåñëa movement is?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Kåñëa consciousness is not a question of belief; it is a science. The first step is to know the difference between a living body and a dead body. What is the difference? The difference is that when someone dies, the spirit soul, or the living force, leaves the body. And therefore the body is called “dead.” So, there are two things: one, this body; and the other, the living force within the body. We speak of the living force within the body. That is the difference between the science of Kåñëa consciousness, which is spiritual, and ordinary material science. As such, in the beginning it is very, very difficult for an ordinary man to appreciate our movement. One must first understand that he is a soul, or something other than his body.

Mike Robinson: And when will we understand that?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You can understand at any moment, but it requires a little intelligence. For example, as a child grows, he becomes a boy, the boy becomes a young man, the young man becomes an adult, and the adult becomes an old man. Throughout all this time, although his body is changing from a child to an old man, he still feels himself to be the same person, with the same identity. Just see: the body is changing, but the occupier of the body, the soul, is remaining the same. So we should logically conclude that when our present body dies, we get another body. This is called transmigration of the soul.

Mike Robinson: So when people die it is just the physical body that dies?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. That is explained very elaborately in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.20]: na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin... na hanyate hanyamäne çarére.

Mike Robinson: Do you often quote references?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we quote many references. Kåñëa consciousness is a serious education, not an ordinary religion. [To a devotee:] Find that verse in the Bhagavad-gétä.

Disciple:

na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin
näyaà bhütvä bhavitä vä na bhüyaù
ajo nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëo
na hanyate hanyamäne çarére

"For the soul, there is never birth nor death. Nor, having once been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying, and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain.”

Mike Robinson: Thank you very much for reading that. So can you explain to me just a bit more? If the soul is undying, does everybody’s soul go to be with God when they die?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not necessarily. If one is qualified—if he qualifies himself in this life to go back home, back to Godhead—then he can go. If he does not qualify himself, then he gets another material body. And there are 8,400,000 different bodily forms. According to his desires and karma, the laws of nature give him a suitable body. It is just like when a man contracts some disease and then develops that disease. Is that difficult to understand?

Mike Robinson: It’s very difficult to understand all of it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Suppose somebody has contracted smallpox. So, after seven days he develops the symptoms. What is that period called?

Mike Robinson: Incubation?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Incubation. So you cannot avoid it. If you have contracted some disease it will develop, by nature’s law. Similarly, during this life you associate with various modes of material nature, and that association will decide what kind of body you are going to get in the next life. That is strictly under the laws of nature. Everyone is controlled by the laws of nature—they’re completely dependent—but out of ignorance people think that they are free. They’re not free; they’re imagining that they’re free, but they are completely under the laws of nature. So, your next birth will be decided according to your activities—sinful or pious, as the case may be.

Mike Robinson: Your Grace, could you go back over that just for a minute? You said that nobody is free. Are you saying that if we live a good life, we in some way determine a good future for ourselves?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Mike Robinson: So we are free to choose what we believe to be important? Religion is important, because if we believe in God and lead a good life...

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not a question of belief. Do not bring in this question of belief. It is law. For instance, there is a government. You may believe or not believe, but if you break the law, you’ll be punished by the government. Similarly, whether you believe or don’t believe, there is a God. If you don’t believe in God and you independently do whatever you like, then you’ll be punished by the laws of nature.

Mike Robinson: I see. Does it matter what religion you believe? Would it matter if one was a devotee of Kåñëa?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not a question of religion. It is a question of science. You are a spiritual being, but because you are materially conditioned, you are under the laws of material nature. So you may believe in the Christian religion, and I may believe in the Hindu religion, but that does not mean that you are going to become an old man and I am not. We’re talking of the science of growing old. This is natural law. It is not that because you are Christian you are becoming old or because I am Hindu I am not becoming old. Everyone is becoming old. So, similarly, all the laws of nature are applicable to everyone. Whether you believe this religion or that religion, it doesn’t matter.

Mike Robinson: So, you’re saying that there’s only one God controlling all of us?

Çréla Prabhupäda: There’s one God, and one nature’s law, and we are all under that nature’s law. We are controlled by the Supreme. So if we think that we are free or that we can do anything we like, that is our foolishness.

Mike Robinson: I see. Can you explain to me what difference it makes, being a member of the Hare Kåñëa movement?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Hare Kåñëa movement is meant for those who are serious about understanding this science. There’s no question of our being some sectarian group. No. Anyone can join. Students in college can be admitted. You may be a Christian, you may be a Hindu, you may be a Muhammadan—it doesn’t matter. The Kåñëa consciousness movement admits anyone who wants to understand the science of God.

Mike Robinson: And what difference would it make to someone—being taught how to be a Hare Kåñëa person?

Çréla Prabhupäda: His real education would begin. The first thing is to understand that you are a spirit soul. And because you are a spirit soul, you are changing your body. This is the ABC of spiritual understanding. So, when your body is finished, annihilated, you are not finished. You get another body, just as you may change your coat and shirt. If you come to see me tomorrow wearing a different shirt and a different coat, does that mean you are a different person? No. Similarly, each time you die you change bodies, but you, the spirit soul within the body, remain the same. This point has to be understood; then one can make further progress in the science of Kåñëa consciousness.

Mike Robinson: I am beginning to understand, but what I’m finding difficult is how this ties in with the large numbers of your people we see handing out Hare Kåñëa literature on Oxford Street.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This literature is meant to convince people about the need for spiritual life.

Mike Robinson: And you’re really not concerned whether or not they join the Hare Kåñëa movement?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It doesn’t matter. Our mission is to educate them. People are in ignorance; they are living in a fool’s paradise, thinking that when their body is finished, everything is finished. That is foolishness.

Mike Robinson: And you are basically just concerned to tell them that there is a spiritual dimension to life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our first concern is to tell you that you are not this body, that the body is your covering (your shirt and coat) and that within the body you are living.

Mike Robinson: Yes, I think I’ve got that now. If we could go on from there—you said that how you lived made a difference in your life after death, that there are natural laws that determine your next life. How does the process of transmigration work?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The process is very subtle. The spirit soul is invisible to our material eyes. It is atomic in size. After the destruction of the gross body, which is made up of the senses, blood, bone, fat, and so forth, the subtle body of mind, intelligence, and ego goes on working. So at the time of death this subtle body carries the small spirit soul to another gross body. The process is just like air carrying a fragrance. Nobody can see where this rose fragrance is coming from, but we know that it is being carried by the air. You cannot see how, but it is being done. Similarly, the process of transmigration of the soul is very subtle. According to the condition of the mind at the time of death, the minute spirit soul enters into the womb of a particular mother through the semen of a father, and then the soul develops a particular type of body given by the mother. It may be a human being, it may be a cat, a dog, or anything.

Mike Robinson: Are you saying that we were something else before this life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Mike Robinson: And we keep corning back as something else the next time?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, because you are eternal. According to your work, you are simply changing bodies. Therefore, you should want to know how to stop this business, how you can remain in your original, spiritual body. That is Kåñëa consciousness.

Mike Robinson: I see. So if I become Kåñëa conscious, I wouldn’t risk coming back as a dog?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. [To a devotee:] Find this verse: janma karma ca me divyam...

Disciple:

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

“One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna.” [Bg. 4.9]

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is saying, “Anyone who understands Me is free from birth and death.” But one cannot understand God by materialistic speculation. That is not possible. One must first come to the spiritual platform. Then he gets the intelligence required to understand God. And when he understands God, he does not get any more material bodies. He goes back home, back to Godhead. He lives eternally; no more change of body.

Mike Robinson: I see. Now, you’ve read twice from your scriptures. Where do these scriptures come from? Can you briefly explain that?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our scriptures are coming from Vedic literature, which has existed from the beginning of creation. Whenever there is some new material creation—like this microphone, for instance—there is also some literature explaining how to deal with it. Isn’t that so?

Mike Robinson: Yes, that’s right, there is.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And that literature comes along with the creation of the microphone.

Mike Robinson: That’s right, yes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So, similarly, the Vedic literature comes along with the cosmic creation, to explain how to deal with it.

Mike Robinson: I see. So, these scriptures have been in existence since the beginning of creation. Now, if we could move on to something I believe you feel very strongly about. What is the main difference between Kåñëa consciousness and the other Eastern disciplines being taught in the West?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The difference is that we are following the original literature, and they are manufacturing their own literature. That is the difference. When there is some question on spiritual matters, you must consult the original literature, not some literature issued by a bogus man.

Mike Robinson: What about the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa...

Çréla Prabhupäda: Chanting Hare Kåñëa is the easiest process by which to become purified, especially in this age, when people are so dull that they cannot very easily understand spiritual knowledge. If one chants Hare Kåñëa, then his intelligence becomes purified, and he can understand spiritual things.

Mike Robinson: Can you tell me how you are guided in what you do?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We take guidance from the Vedic literature.

Mike Robinson: From the scriptures you quoted?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it’s all in the literatures. We’re explaining them in English. But we’re not manufacturing anything. If we were to manufacture knowledge, then everything would be spoiled. The Vedic literature is something like the literature that explains how to set up this microphone. It says, “Do it like this: some of the screws should be on this side, around the metal.” You cannot make any change; then everything would be spoiled. Similarly, because we are not manufacturing anything, one simply has to read one of our books, and he receives real spiritual knowledge.

Mike Robinson: How can the philosophy of Kåñëa consciousness affect the way people live?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It can relieve people’s suffering. People are suffering because they are misunderstanding themselves to be the body. If you think that you are your coat and shirt, and you very carefully wash the coat and shirt but you forget to eat, will you be happy?

Mike Robinson: No, I wouldn’t.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Similarly, everyone is simply washing the “coat and shirt” of the body, but forgetting about the soul within the body. They have no information about what is within the “coat and shirt” of the body. Ask anybody what he is, and he will say, “Yes, I am an Englishman,” or “I am an Indian.” And if we say, “I can see you have an English or an Indian body, but what are you?”—that he cannot say.

Mike Robinson: I see.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The whole modern civilization is operating on the misunderstanding that the body is the self (dehätma-buddhi). This is the mentality of the cats and dogs. Suppose I try to enter England, and you stop me at the border: “I am an Englishman,” you say, “but you are Indian. Why have you come here?” And the dog barks, “Rau, rau, why are you coming?” So what is the difference in mentality? The dog is thinking he’s a dog and I’m a stranger, and you are thinking you are an Englishman and I am an Indian. There’s no difference in mentality. So if you keep people in the darkness of a dog’s mentality and declare that you are advancing in civilization, you are most misguided.

Mike Robinson: Now, moving on to another point, I gather the Hare Kåñëa movement has some concern for areas of the world where there is suffering.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we have the only concern. Others are simply avoiding the main problems: birth, old age, disease, and death. Others have no solutions to these problems; they are simply talking all kinds of nonsense. People are being misguided. They are being kept in darkness. Let us start to give them some light.

Mike Robinson: Yes, but apart from giving spiritual enlightenment, are you also concerned for people’s physical well-being?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Physical well-being automatically follows spiritual well-being.

Mike Robinson: And how does that work?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Suppose you have a car. So, naturally, you take care of the car as well as yourself. But you don’t identify yourself as the car. You don’t say, “I am this car.” That is nonsense. But this is what people are doing. They are taking too much care of the bodily “car,” thinking that the car is the self. They forget that they are different from the car, that they are a spirit soul and have a different business. Just as no one can drink petrol and be satisfied, no one can be satisfied with bodily activities. One must find out the proper food for the soul. If a man thinks, “I am a car, and I must drink this petrol,” he is considered insane. Similarly, one who thinks that he is this body, and who tries to become happy with bodily pleasures, is also insane.

Mike Robinson: There’s a quote here that I’d like you to comment on. I was given this literature by your people before I came, and one of the things you say here is that “Religion without a rational basis is just sentiment.” Can you explain that?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Most religious people say, “We believe...” But what is the value of this belief? You may believe something which is not actually correct. For instance, some of the Christian people say, “We believe that animals have no soul.” That is not correct. They believe animals have no soul because they want to eat the animals, but actually animals do have a soul.

Mike Robinson: How do you know that the animal has a soul?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You can know, also. Here is the scientific proof: the animal eats, you eat; the animal sleeps, you sleep; the animal has sex, you have sex; the animal also defends, you also defend. Then what is the difference between you and the animal? How can you say that you have a soul but the animal doesn’t?

Mike Robinson: I can see that completely. But the Christian scriptures say...

Çréla Prabhupäda: Don’t bring in any scriptures; this is a commonsense topic. Try to understand. The animal is eating, you are eating; the animal is sleeping, you are sleeping; the animal is defending, you are defending; the animal is having sex, you are having sex; the animals have children, you have children; they have a living place, you have a living place. If the animal’s body is cut, there is blood; if your body is cut, there is blood. So, all these similarities are there. Now, why do you deny this one similarity, the presence of the soul? This is not logical. You have studied logic? In logic there is something called analogy. Analogy means drawing a conclusion by finding many points of similarity. If there are so many points of similarity between human beings and animals, why deny one similarity? That is not logic. That is not science.

Mike Robinson: But if you take that argument and use it the other way...

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no other way. If you are not arguing on the basis of logic, then you are not rational.

Mike Robinson: Yes, OK, but let’s start from another hypothesis. Suppose we assume that a human being has no soul...

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then you must explain the difference between a living body and a dead body. I have already explained this at the beginning. As soon as the living force, the soul, is gone from the body, even the most beautiful body has no value. No one cares for it; it’s thrown away. But now, if I touch your hair, there will be a fight. That is the distinction between a living body and a dead body. In a living body the soul is there, and in a dead body the soul is not there. As soon as the soul leaves the body, the body has no value. It is useless. This is very simple to understand, but even the biggest so-called scientists and philosophers are too dullheaded to understand it. Modern society is in a very abominable condition. There is no man with a real brain.

Mike Robinson: Are you referring to all the scientists who fail to understand the spiritual dimension in life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Real science means full knowledge of everything, material and spiritual.

Mike Robinson: But you were a chemist in secular life, were you not?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, I was a chemist in my earlier life. But it doesn’t require any great intelligence to become a chemist. Any commonsense man can do it.

Mike Robinson: But presumably you think that material science is also important, even if today’s scientists are dullheaded.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Material science is important just so far. It is not all-important.

Mike Robinson: I see. Can I come back to a question I had from before? When we were differing a few minutes ago you were saying, “Don’t bring the scriptures in; just use common sense.” But what part do the scriptures play in your religion? How important are they?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our religion is a science. When we say that a child grows into a boy, it is science. It is not religion. Every child grows into a boy. What is the question of religion? Every man dies. What is the question of religion? And when a man dies, the body becomes useless. What is the question of religion? It is science. Whether you’re Christian or Hindu or Muslim, when you die your body becomes useless. This is science. When your relative dies, you cannot say, “We are Christian; we believe he has not died.” No, he has died. Whether you are Christian or Hindu or Muslim, he has died. So when we speak, we speak on this basis: that the body is important only as long as the soul is in the body. When the soul is not there, it is useless. This science is applicable to everyone, and we are trying to educate people on this basis.

Mike Robinson: But if I understand you correctly, you seem to be educating people on a purely scientific basis. Where does religion come into it at all?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Religion also means science. People have wrongly taken religion to mean faith—“I believe.” [To a devotee:] Look up the word religion in the dictionary.

Disciple: Under religion the dictionary says, “recognition of superhuman control or power, and especially of a personal God entitled to obedience, and effecting such recognition with the proper mental attitude.”

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Religion means learning how to obey the supreme controller. So, you may be Christian and I may be Hindu; it doesn’t matter. We must both accept that there is a supreme controller. Everyone has to accept that; that is real religion. Not this “We believe animals have no soul.” That is not religion. That is most unscientific. Religion means scientific understanding of the supreme controller: to understand the supreme controller and obey Him—that’s all. In the state, the good citizen is he who understands the government and obeys the laws of the government, and the bad citizen is the one who doesn’t care for the government. So, if you become a bad citizen by ignoring God’s government, then you are irreligious. And if you are a good citizen, then you are religious.

Mike Robinson: I see. Can you tell me what you believe to be the meaning of life? Why do we exist in the first place?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The meaning of life is to enjoy. But now you are on a false platform of life, and therefore you are suffering instead of enjoying. Everywhere we see the struggle for existence. Everyone is struggling, but what is their enjoyment in the end? They are simply suffering and dying. Therefore, although life means enjoyment, at the present moment your life is not enjoyment. But if you come to the real, spiritual platform of life, then you’ll enjoy.

Mike Robinson: Can you explain to me, finally, some of the stages you go through in spiritual life? What are the spiritual stages a new devotee of Kåñëa goes through?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The first stage is that you are inquisitive. “So,” you say, “what is this Kåñëa consciousness movement? Let me study it.” This is called çraddhä, or faith. This is the beginning. Then, if you are serious, you mix with those who are cultivating this knowledge. You try to understand how they are feeling. Then you’ll feel, “Why not become one of them?” And when you become one of them, then all your misgivings soon go away. You become more faithful, and then you get a real taste for Kåñëa consciousness. Why aren’t these boys going to see the cinema? Why don’t they eat meat or go to the nightclub? Because their taste has changed. They hate all these things now. In this way, you make progress. First faith, then association with devotees, then removal of all misgivings, then firm faith, then taste, then God realization, and then love of God, the perfection. That is first-class religion. Not some ritualistic ceremony of “I believe, you believe.” That is not religion. That is cheating. Real religion means to develop your love for God. That is the perfection of religion.

Mike Robinson: Thank you very much for talking with me. It’s been a pleasure talking to you.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Hare Kåñëa.

SSR 1e: Truth and Beauty

Truth and Beauty

"Beauty is truth, truth is beauty," said Keats. "That is all ye know on earth, and all ye need to know." Or is it? In this charming yet cutting essay, which first appeared in the old tabloid version of Back to Godhead (November 20, 1958), Çréla Prabhupäda tells the unforgettable story of "liquid beauty."

There may sometimes be arguments about whether “truth” and “beauty” are compatible terms. One would willingly agree to express the truth, one might say, but since truth is not always beautiful—indeed, it is frequently rather startling and unpleasant—how is one to express truth and beauty at the same time?

In reply, we may inform all concerned that “truth” and “beauty” are compatible terms. Indeed, we may emphatically assert that the actual truth, which is absolute, is always beautiful. The truth is so beautiful that it attracts everyone, including the truth itself. Truth is so beautiful that many sages, saints, and devotees have left everything for the sake of truth. Mahatma Gandhi, an idol of the modern world, dedicated his life to experimenting with truth, and all his activities were aimed toward truth only.

Why only Mahatma Gandhi? Every one of us has the urge to search for truth alone, for the truth is not only beautiful but also all-powerful, all-resourceful, all-famous, all-renounced, and all-knowledgeable.

Unfortunately, people have no information of the actual truth. Indeed, 99.9 percent of men in all walks of life are pursuing untruth only, in the name of truth. We are actually attracted by the beauty of truth, but since time immemorial we have been habituated to love of untruth appearing like truth. Therefore, to the mundaner “truth” and “beauty” are incompatible terms. The mundane truth and beauty may be explained as follows.

Once a man who was very powerful and strongly built but whose character was very doubtful fell in love with a beautiful girl. The girl was not only beautiful in appearance but also saintly in character, and as such she did not like the man’s advances. The man, however, was insistent because of his lustful desires, and therefore the girl requested him to wait only seven days, and she set a time after that when he could meet her. The man agreed, and with high expectations he began waiting for the appointed time.

The saintly girl, however, in order to manifest the real beauty of absolute truth, adopted a method very instructive. She took very strong doses of laxatives and purgatives, and for seven days she continually passed loose stool and vomited all that she ate. Moreover, she stored all the loose stool and vomit in suitable pots. As a result of the purgatives, the so-called beautiful girl became lean and thin like a skeleton, her complexion turned blackish, and her beautiful eyes sank into the sockets of her skull. Thus at the appointed hour she waited anxiously to receive the eager man.

The man appeared on the scene well dressed and well behaved and asked the ugly girl he found waiting there about the beautiful girl he was to meet. The man could not recognize the girl he saw as the same beautiful girl for whom he was asking; indeed, although she repeatedly asserted her identity, because of her pitiable condition he was unable to recognize her.

At last the girl told the powerful man that she had separated the ingredients of her beauty and stored them in pots. She also told him that he could enjoy those juices of beauty. When the mundane poetic man asked to see these juices of beauty, he was directed to the store of loose stool and liquid vomit, which were emanating an unbearably bad smell. Thus the whole story of the beauty-liquid was disclosed to him. Finally, by the grace of the saintly girl, this man of low character was able to distinguish between the shadow and the substance, and thus he came to his senses.

This man’s position was similar to the position of every one of us who is attracted by false, material beauty. The girl mentioned above had a beautifully developed material body in accordance with the desires of her mind, but in fact she was apart from that temporary material body and mind. She was in fact a spiritual spark, and so also was the lover who was attracted by her false skin.

Mundane intellectuals and aesthetics, however, are deluded by the outward beauty and attraction of the relative truth and are unaware of the spiritual spark, which is both truth and beauty at the same time. The spiritual spark is so beautiful that when it leaves the so-called beautiful body, which in fact is full of stool and vomit, no one wants to touch that body, even if it is decorated with a costly costume.

We are all pursuing a false, relative truth, which is incompatible with real beauty. The actual truth, however, is permanently beautiful, retaining the same standard of beauty for innumerable years. That spiritual spark is indestructible. The beauty of the outer skin can be destroyed in only a few hours merely by a dose of a strong purgative, but the beauty of truth is indestructible and always the same. Unfortunately, mundane artists and intellectuals are ignorant of this beautiful spark of spirit. They are also ignorant of the whole fire which is the source of these spiritual sparks, and they are ignorant of the relationships between the sparks and the fire, which take the form of transcendental pastimes. When those pastimes are displayed here by the grace of the Almighty, foolish people who cannot see beyond their senses confuse those pastimes of truth and beauty with the manifestations of loose stool and vomit described above. Thus in despair they ask how truth and beauty can be accommodated at the same time.

Mundaners do not know that the whole spiritual entity is the beautiful person who attracts everything. They are unaware that He is the prime substance, the prime source and fountainhead of everything that be. The infinitesimal spiritual sparks, being parts and parcels of that whole spirit, are qualitatively the same in beauty and eternity. The only difference is that the whole is eternally the whole and the parts are eternally the parts. Both of them, however, are the ultimate truth, ultimate beauty, ultimate knowledge, ultimate energy, ultimate renunciation, and ultimate opulence.

Although written by the greatest mundane poet or intellectual, any literature which does not describe the ultimate truth and beauty is but a store of loose stool and vomit of the relative truth. Real literature is that which describes the ultimate truth and beauty of the Absolute.

SSR 1f: Relevant Inquiries

Relevant Inquiries

Again in the old tabloid Back to Godhead, this time dated April 20, 1960, Çréla Prabhupäda talks about the science of the soul: "...since a human being is a rational animal, he is born to make inquiries and questions. The greater the number of questions, the greater the advancement of knowledge and science. . . . The most intelligent man, however, inquires about what happens after death."

A small child walking with his father goes on inquiring constantly. He asks his father so many odd things, and the father has to satisfy him with proper answers. When I was a young father in my householder life, I was overflooded with hundreds of questions from my second son, who was my constant companion. One day it so happened that a bridegroom’s party was passing our tramcar, and the four-year-old boy, as usual, inquired what the big procession was. He was given all possible answers to his thousand and one questions regarding the marriage party, and finally he asked whether his own father was married! This question gave rise to loud laughter from all the elderly gentlemen present, although the boy was perplexed as to why we were laughing. Anyway, the boy was somehow satisfied by his married father.

The lesson from this incident is that since a human being is a rational animal, he is born to make inquiries. The greater the number of questions, the greater the advancement of knowledge and science. The whole of material civilization is based on this originally large volume of questions put by young men to their elders. When elderly persons give the proper answers to the questions of the youngsters, civilization makes progress, one step after another. The most intelligent man, however, inquires about what happens after death. The less intelligent make lesser inquiries, but the questions of those who are more intelligent go higher and still higher.

Among the most intelligent of men was Mahäräja Parékñit, the great king of the entire world, who was accidentally cursed by a brähmaëa to meet death from the bite of a serpent within seven days. The brähmaëa who cursed him was only a boy, yet he was very powerful, and because he did not know the importance of the great king, the boy foolishly cursed him to meet death within seven days. This was later lamented by the boy’s father, whom the king had offended. When the king was informed of the unfortunate curse, he at once left his palatial home and went to the bank of the Ganges, which was near his capital, to prepare for his impending death. Because he was a great king, almost all the great sages and learned scholars assembled at the place where the king was fasting prior to leaving his mortal body. At last, Çukadeva Goswami, the youngest contemporary saint, also arrived there, and he was unanimously accepted to preside at that meeting, although his great father was also present. The king respectfully offered Çukadeva Goswami the principal seat of esteem and asked him relevant questions regarding his passing from the mortal world, which was to take place on the seventh day thenceforward. The great king, as a worthy descendant of the Päëdavas, who were all great devotees, placed the following relevant inquiries before the great sage Çukadeva. “My dear sir, you are the greatest of the great transcendentalists, and therefore I submissively beg to ask you about my duties at this moment. I am just on the verge of my death. Therefore, what should I do at this critical hour? Please tell me, my lord—what should I hear, what should I worship, or whom should I remember now? A great sage like you does not stay at the home of a householder more than necessary, and therefore it is my good fortune that you have kindly come here at the time of my death. Please, therefore, give me your directions at this critical hour.”

The great sage, having thus been pleasingly requested by the king, answered his questions authoritatively, for the sage was a great transcendental scholar and was also well equipped with godly qualities, since he was the worthy son of Bädaräyaëa, or Vyäsadeva, the original compiler of the Vedic literature.

Çukadeva Goswami said, “My dear king, your inquiry is very much relevant, and it is also beneficial for all people of all times. Such inquiries, which are the highest of all, are relevant because they are confirmed by the teachings of the vedänta-darçana, the conclusion of the Vedic knowledge, and are ätmavit-sammatäù; in other words, liberated souls, who have full knowledge of their spiritual identity, put forward such relevant inquiries in order to elucidate further information about the Transcendence.”

The Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the natural commentary upon the great Vedänta (or Çäréraka) sütras, which were compiled by Çréla Vyäsadeva. The Vedänta-sütras are the topmost Vedic literature, and they contain the nucleus of basic inquiries about the transcendental subject of spiritual knowledge. Yet although Çréla Vyäsadeva compiled this great treatise, his mind was not satisfied. Then he happened to meet Çré Närada, his spiritual master, who advised him to describe the identity of the Personality of Godhead. Upon receiving this advice, Vyäsadeva meditated on the principle of bhakti-yoga, which showed him distinctly what is the Absolute and what is the relativity, or mäyä. Having achieved perfect realization of these facts, he compiled the great narration of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, or beautiful Bhägavatam, which begins with actual historical facts concerning the life of Mahäräja Parékñit.

The Vedänta-sütra begins with the key inquiry about the Transcendence, athäto brahma-jijïäsä: “One should now inquire about Brahman, or the Transcendence.”

As long as a man is in the full vigor of life, he forgets the naked truth of death, which he has to meet. Thus a foolish man makes no relevant inquiry about the real problems of life. Everyone thinks that he will never die, although he sees evidence of death before his eyes at every second. Here is the distinction between animalism and humanity. An animal like a goat has no sense of its impending death. Although its brother goat is being slaughtered, the goat, being allured by the green grass offered to it, will stand peacefully waiting to be slaughtered next. On the other hand, if a human being sees his fellow man being killed by an enemy, he either fights to save his brother or leaves, if possible, to save his own life. That is the difference between a man and a goat.

An intelligent man knows that death is born along with his own birth. He knows that he is dying at every second and that the final touch will be given as soon as his term of life is finished. He therefore prepares himself for the next life or for liberation from the disease of repeated birth and death.

A foolish man, however, does not know that this human form of life is obtained after a series of births and deaths imposed in the past by the laws of nature. He does not know that a living entity is an eternal being, who has no birth and death. Birth, death, old age, and disease are external impositions on a living entity and are due to his contact with material nature and to his forgetfulness of his eternal, godly nature and qualitative oneness with the Absolute Whole.

Human life provides the opportunity to know this eternal fact, or truth. Thus the very beginning of the Vedänta-sütra advises that because we have this valuable form of human life, it is our duty—now—to inquire, What is Brahman, the Absolute Truth?

A man who is not intelligent enough does not inquire about this transcendental life; instead, he inquires about many irrelevant matters which do not concern his eternal existence. From the very beginning of his life, he inquires from his mother, father, teachers, professors, books, and so many other sources, but he does not have the right type of information about his real life.

As mentioned before, Parékñit Mahäräja was given a warning notice that he would meet death within seven days, and he at once left his palace to prepare himself for the next stage. The king had at least seven days at his disposal in which to prepare for death, but as far as we are concerned, although at least we know that our death is sure, we have no information of the date fixed for the occurrence. I do not know whether I am going to meet death at the next moment. Even such a great man as Mahatma Gandhi could not calculate that he was going to meet with death in the next five minutes, nor could his great associates guess his impending death. Nonetheless, all such gentlemen present themselves as great leaders of the people.

It is ignorance of death and life that distinguishes an animal from a man. A man, in the real sense of the term, inquires about himself and what he is. Wherefrom has he come into this life, and where is he going after death? Why is he put under the troubles of threefold miseries although he does not want them? Beginning from one’s childhood, one goes on inquiring about so many things in his life, but he never inquires about the real essence of life. This is animalism. There is no difference between a man and an animal as far as the four principles of animal life are concerned, for every living being exists by eating, sleeping, fearing, and mating. But only the human life is meant for relevant inquiries into the facts about eternal life and the Transcendence. Human life is therefore meant for research into eternal life, and the Vedänta-sütra advises one to conduct this research now or never. If one fails to inquire now into these relevant matters about life, one is sure to go back again to the animal kingdom by the laws of nature. Therefore, even if a foolish man appears advanced in material science—that is, in eating, sleeping, fearing, mating, and so on—he cannot get free from the cruel hands of death by the law of nature. The law of nature works under three modes—goodness, passion, and ignorance. Those who live under conditions of goodness are promoted to the higher, spiritual status of life, and those who live under conditions of passion remain stationed in the same place in the material world where they are now, but those who live under conditions of ignorance are sure to be degraded to the lower species.

The modern setup of human civilization is a risky one because it offers no education about relevant inquiries into the essential principles of life. Like animals, people do not know that they are going to be slaughtered by the laws of nature. They are satisfied with a bunch of green grass, or a so-called jolly life, like the waiting goat in a slaughterhouse. Considering such a condition of human life, we are just trying to make a humble attempt to save the human being by the message of Back to Godhead. This method is not fictitious. If there is at all to be an era of reality, this message of Back to Godhead is the beginning of that era.

According to Çré Çukadeva Goswami, the real fact is that a gåhamedhé, or a person who has tied himself, like the goat meant for slaughter, in the business of family, society, community, nation, or humanity at large in regard to the problems and necessities of animal life—namely eating, sleeping, fearing, and mating—and who has no knowledge of the Transcendence is no better than an animal. He may have inquired about physical, political, economic, cultural, educational, or similar other matters of temporary, material concern, but if he has not inquired about the principles of transcendental life, he should be regarded as a blind man driven ahead by uncontrolled senses and about to fall into a ditch. That is the description of the gåhamedhé.

The opposite of the gåha-medhé, however, is the gåha-stha. The gåhastha-äsrama, or the shelter of spiritual family life, is as good as the life of a sannyäsé, a member of the renounced order. Regardless of whether one is a householder or a renunciate, the important point is that of relevant inquiries. A sannyäsé is bogus if not interested in relevant inquiries, and a grhastha, or householder, is bona fide if he is inclined to put forward such inquiries. The gåhamedhé, however, is simply interested in the animal necessities of life. By the laws of nature, the gåhamedhé’s life is full of calamities, whereas the life of the gåhastha is full of happiness. But in the modern human civilization, the gåhamedhés are posing as the gåhasthas. We should therefore know who is what. A gåhamedhé’s life is full of vices, because he does not know how to live a family life. He does not know that beyond his control is a power who supervises and controls his activities, and he has no conception of his future life. The gåhamedhé is blind to his future and has no aptitude for making relevant inquiries. His only qualification is that he is bound by the shackles of attachment to the false things he has contacted in his temporary existence.

At night such gåhamedhés waste their valuable time by sleeping or by satisfying their different varieties of sexual urges by visiting cinema shows and attending clubs and gambling houses, where women and liquor are indulged in lavishly. And during the day, they waste their valuable life in accumulating money or, if they have sufficient money to spend, by adjusting the comforts of their family members. Their standard of living and their personal needs increase with their increase in monetary income. Thus there is no limit to their expenses, and they are never satiated. Consequently there is unlimited competition in the field of economic development, and therefore there is no peace in any society of the human world.

Everyone is perplexed by the same questions about earning and spending, but ultimately one must depend on the mercy of mother nature. When there is a scarcity in production or there are disturbances caused by providence, the poor planmaking politician blames it on cruel nature but carefully avoids studying how and by whom the laws of nature are controlled. The Bhagavad-gétä, however, explains that the laws of nature are controlled by the Absolute Personality of Godhead. God alone is the controller of nature and the natural laws. Ambitious materialists sometimes examine a fragment of the law of nature, but they never care to know the maker of these laws. Most of them do not believe in the existence of an absolute person or God who controls the laws of nature. Rather, they simply concern themselves with the principles by which different elements interact, but they make no reference to the ultimate direction which makes such interactions possible. They have no relevant questions or answers in this regard. The second of the Vedänta-sütras, however, answers the essential question about Brahman by asserting that the Supreme Brahman, the Supreme Transcendence, is He from whom everything is generated. Ultimately, He is the Supreme Person.

Not only is the foolish gåhamedhé ignorant of the temporary nature of the particular type of body he has obtained, but he is also blind to the actual nature of what is happening before him in the daily affairs of his life. He may see his father die, his mother die, or a relative or neighbor die, yet he does not make the relevant inquiries about whether or not the other existing members of his family will die. Sometimes he thinks and knows that all the members of his family will die today or tomorrow and that he also will die. He may know that the whole family show—or, for that matter, the whole show of community, society, nation, and all such things—is but a temporary bubble in the air, having no permanent value. Yet he is mad after such temporary arrangements and does not concern himself with any relevant inquiries. He has no knowledge as to where he has to go after his death. He works very hard for the temporary arrangements of his family, society, or nation, but he never makes any future arrangement either for himself or for others who will pass away from this present phase of life.

In a public vehicle like a railway carriage, we meet and sit down together with some unknown friends and become members of the same vehicle for a short time, but in due course we separate, never to meet again. Similarly, in a long sojourn of life, we get a temporary sitting accommodation in a so-called family, country, or society, but when the time is up, we are unwillingly separated from one another, never to meet again. There are so many questions relevant to our temporary arrangements in life and our friends in these temporary arrangements, but a man who is a gåhamedhé never inquires about things of a permanent nature. We are all busy making permanent plans in various degrees of leadership, without knowing the permanent nature of things as they are. Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya, who especially strove to remove this ignorance in society and who advocated the cult of spiritual knowledge in regard to the all-pervading impersonal Brahman, said in despair, “Children are engaged in playing, young boys are engaged in so-called love affairs with young girls, and the old are seriously thoughtful about adjusting a baffled life of struggle. But, alas, no one is prepared to inquire relevantly into the science of Brahman, the Absolute Truth.”

Çré Çukadeva Goswami, who was asked for direction by Mahäräja Parékñit, responded to the king’s relevant inquiries by advising him as follows:

tasmäd bhärata sarvätmä
bhagavän éçvaro hariù
çrotavyaù kértitavyaç ca
smartavyaç cecchatäbhayam

“O descendant of Bhärata, it is the duty of mortal men to inquire about, hear about, glorify, and meditate upon the Personality of Godhead, who is the most attractive person because of His fullness in opulence. He is called Hari because He alone can undo the conditional existence of a living being. If we at all want to be freed from conditional existence, we must make relevant inquiries about the Absolute Truth so that He may be pleased to bestow upon us perfect freedom in life.” [Çrémad-Bhägavatam 2.1.5]

Çré Çukadeva Goswami has particularly used four words in regard to the Absolute Personality of Godhead. These words distinguish the Absolute Person, or Parabrahman, from other persons, who are qualitatively one with Him. The Absolute Personality of Godhead is addressed as sarvätmä, or all-pervading, because no one is aloof from Him, although not everyone has this realization. The Personality of Godhead, by His plenary representation, resides in everyone’s heart as Paramätmä, the Supersoul, along with each individual soul. Therefore every individual soul has an intimate relationship with Him. Forgetfulness of this eternally existing intimate relationship with Him is the cause of conditional life since time immemorial. But because He is Bhagavän, or the supreme personality, He can at once reciprocate the responsive call of a devotee. Moreover, because He is the perfect person, His beauty, opulence, fame, strength, knowledge, and renunciation are all unlimited sources of transcendental bliss for the individual soul. The individual soul becomes attracted by all these different opulences when they are imperfectly represented by other conditioned souls, but the individual soul is not satisfied by such imperfect representations, and therefore he perpetually seeks the perfect one. The Personality of Godhead’s beauty has no comparison, nor do His knowledge and renunciation. But above all, He is ésvara, or the supreme controller. We are at present being controlled by the police action of this great king. This police control is imposed upon us because of our disobedience of law. But because the Lord is Hari, He is able to cause the disappearance of our conditional life by giving us full freedom in spiritual existence. It is therefore the duty of every man to make relevant inquiries about Him and thus go back to Godhead.

SSR 1g: Soul Research

Soul Research

Çréla Prabhupäda writes a letter to noted cardiologist Dr. Wilfred G. Bigelow: "The central question, you say, is 'Where is the soul, and where does it come from?' That is not difficult to understand."


In 1968, speaking before a gathering of students at Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Çréla Prabhupäda points out an important lag in technological research. “Although you have so many departments of knowledge,” he says, “there is no department aiming to find the difference between a living body and a dead body.”

Although advanced in understanding the mechanical workings of the physical body, modern science gives but little attention to studying the spiritual spark that animates the body. In the Montreal Gazette article reproduced below, we find world-famous cardiologist Wilfred G. Bigelow urging systematic research to determine what the soul is and where it comes from. Reproduced next is Çréla Prabhupäda’s letter in response to Dr. Bigelow’s plea. Çréla Prabhupäda offers substantial Vedic knowledge on the science of the soul and suggests a practical method for scientifically understanding the spiritual spark.

Gazette Headline:

SSR 1h: Heart surgeon Wants to Know What a Soul Is

Heart surgeon Wants to Know What a Soul Is

WINDSOR—A world-famous Canadian heart surgeon says he believes the body has a soul which departs at death and theologians ought to try to find out more about it.

Dr. Wilfred G. Bigelow, head of the cardiovascular surgery unit at Toronto General Hospital, said that “as a person who believes there is a soul,” he thought the time had come “to take the mystery out of this and find out what it is.”

Bigelow was a member of a panel which appeared before the Essex County Medical-Legal Society to discuss problems associated with attempts to define the exact moment of death.

The question has become vital in the age of transplants of hearts and other organs in cases when the donors are inevitably dying.

The Canadian Medical Association has produced a widely accepted definition of death as the moment when the patient is in coma, responds to no stimulus of any kind, and brain waves recorded on a machine are flat.

The other members of the panel were Mr. Justice Edson L. Haines of the Ontario Supreme Court and J. Francis Leddy, president of the University of Windsor.

Bigelow, elaborating on points he had raised during the discussion, said in an interview later that his thirty-two years as a surgeon had left him no doubts that there is a soul.

“There are certain cases where you happen to be present at the moment when people pass from a living state to death, and some mysterious changes take place.

“One of the most noticeable is the sudden lack of life or luster to the eyes. They become opaque and literally lifeless.

“It’s difficult to document what you observe. In fact, I don’t think it can be documented very well.”

Bigelow, who became world renowned for his pioneering work in the “deep freeze” surgical technique known as hypothermia and for his heart valve surgery, said “soul research” should be undertaken by theology and allied disciplines within the university.

During this discussion Leddy said that “if there is a soul, you are not going to see it. You are not going to find it.”

“If there is a principle of vitality or life, what is it?” The problem was that “the soul doesn’t exist anywhere specifically, geographically. It’s everywhere and yet it’s nowhere in the body.”

It would “be nice to start experimenting, but I don’t know how you are going to get on any of these things,” Leddy said. He said the discussion reminded him of the Soviet cosmonaut who returned from space to report there was no God, because he didn’t see Him up there.

Maybe so, said Bigelow, but in modern medicine when something was encountered that could not be explained, “the watchword is discover the answer, take it into the laboratory, take it somewhere where you can discover the truth.”

The central question, said Bigelow, was “where is the soul and where does it come from?”

SSR 1h: Çréla Prabhupäda Gives the Vedic Evidence

Çréla Prabhupäda Gives the Vedic Evidence

My dear Dr. Bigelow:

Please accept my greetings. Recently I have read an article in the Gazette by Rae Corelli entitled “Heart Surgeon Wants to Know What a Soul Is,” and it was very interesting. Your comments show great insight, and so I thought to write you on this matter. Perhaps you may know that I am the founder-äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. I have several temples in Canada—Montreal, Toronto, Vancouver, and Hamilton. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is specifically meant to teach every soul his original, spiritual position.

Undoubtedly the soul is present in the heart of the living entity, and it is the source of all the energies for maintaining the body. The energy of the soul is spread all over the body, and this is known as consciousness. Since this consciousness spreads the energy of the soul all over the body, one can feel pains and pleasures in any part of the body. The soul is individual, and he is transmigrating from one body to another, just as a person transmigrates from babyhood to childhood, from childhood to boyhood, from boyhood to youth, and then to advanced old age. Then the change called death takes place when we change to a new body, just as we change our old dress to a new dress. This is called transmigration of the soul.

When a soul wants to enjoy this material world, forgetting his real home in the spiritual world, he takes this life of hard struggle for existence. This unnatural life of repeated birth, death, disease, and old age can be stopped when his consciousness is dovetailed with the supreme consciousness of God. That is the basic principle of our Kåñëa movement.

As far as heart transplant is concerned, there is no question of success unless the soul is there in the heart. So the presence of the soul has to be accepted. In sexual intercourse, if there is no soul, there is no conception, no pregnancy. Contraception deteriorates the womb so that it no longer is a good place for the soul. That is against the order of God. By the order of God, a soul is sent to a particular womb, but by this contraceptive he is denied that womb and has to be placed in another. That is disobedience to the Supreme. For example, take a man who is supposed to live in a particular apartment. If the situation there is so disturbed that he cannot enter the apartment, then he is put at a great disadvantage. That is illegal interference and is punishable.

The undertaking of “soul research” would certainly mark the advancement of science. But advancement of science will not be able to find the soul. The soul’s presence can simply be accepted on circumstantial understanding. You will find in the Vedic literature that the dimension of the soul is one ten-thousandth the size of a point. The material scientist cannot measure the length and breadth of a point. Therefore it is not possible for the material scientist to capture the soul. You can simply accept the soul’s existence by taking it from authority. What the greatest scientists are finding, we’ve explained long ago.

As soon as one understands the existence of the soul, he can immediately understand the existence of God. The difference between God and the soul is that God is a very great soul, and the living entity is a very small soul; but qualitatively they are equal. Therefore God is all-pervading, and the living entity is localized. But the nature and quality are the same.

The central question, you say, is “Where is the soul, and where does it come from?” That is not difficult to understand. We have already discussed that the soul is residing in the heart of the living entity and that it takes shelter in another body after death. Originally the soul comes from God. Just as a spark comes from fire, and when the spark falls down it appears to be extinguished, the spark of soul originally comes from the spiritual world to the material world. In the material world he falls down into three different conditions, which are called the modes of nature. When a spark of fire falls on dry grass, the fiery quality continues; when the spark falls on the ground, it cannot display its fiery manifestation unless the ground is favorably situated; and when the spark falls on water, it becomes extinguished. As such, we find three kinds of living conditions. One living entity is completely forgetful of his spiritual nature; another is almost forgetful but still has an instinct of spiritual nature; and another is completely in search of spiritual perfection. There is a bona fide method for the attainment of spiritual perfection by the spiritual spark of soul, and if he is properly guided then he is very easily sent back home, back to Godhead, wherefrom he originally fell.

It will be a great contribution to human society if this authorized information from the Vedic literature is presented to the modern world on the basis of modern scientific understanding. The fact is already there. It simply has to be presented for modern understanding.

Yours sincerely, A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

SSR 2: Choosing a Spiritual Master

II. Choosing a Spiritual Master

SSR 2a: What Is a Guru?

What Is a Guru?

"In all the çästras [scriptures] the guru is described to be as good as God, but the guru never says, 'I am God.' The disciple's duty is to offer respect to the guru just as he offers respect to God, but the guru never thinks, 'My disciples are offering me the same respect they offer to God; therefore I have become God.' As soon as he thinks like this, he becomes a dog."

oà ajïäna-timirändhasya
jïänäïjana-çaläkayä
cakñur unmélitaà yena
tasmai çré-gurave namaù

“I was born in the darkest ignorance, and my guru, my spiritual master, opened my eyes with the torch of knowledge. I offer my respectful obeisances unto him.” [Gautaméya Tantra]

The word ajïäna means “ignorance” or “darkness.” If all the lights in this room immediately went out, we would not be able to tell where we or others are sitting. Everything would become confused. Similarly, we are all in darkness in this material world, which is a world of tamas. Tamas or timira means “darkness.” This material world is dark, and therefore it needs sunlight or moonlight for illumination. However, there is another world, a spiritual world, that is beyond this darkness. That world is described by Çré Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.6]:

na tad bhäsayate süryo
na çaçäìko na pävakaù
yad gatvä na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"That abode of Mine is not illumined by the sun or moon, nor by electricity. One who reaches it never returns to this material world.”

The guru’s business is to bring his disciples from darkness to light. At present everyone is suffering due to ignorance, just as one contracts a disease out of ignorance. If one does not know hygienic principles, he will not know what will contaminate him. Therefore due to ignorance there is infection, and we suffer from disease. A criminal may say, “I did not know the law,” but he will not be excused if he commits a crime. Ignorance is no excuse. Similarly, a child, not knowing that fire will burn, will touch the fire. The fire does not think, “This is a child, and he does not know I will burn.” No, there is no excuse. Just as there are state laws, there are also stringent laws of nature, and these laws will act despite our ignorance of them. If we do something wrong out of ignorance, we must suffer. This is the law. Whether the law is a state law or a law of nature, we risk suffering if we break it.

The guru’s business is to see that no human being suffers in this material world. No one can claim that he is not suffering. That is not possible. In this material world, there are three kinds of suffering: adhyätmika, adhibhautika, and adhidaivika. These are miseries arising from the material body and mind, from other living entities, and from the forces of nature. We may suffer mental anguish, or we may suffer from other living entities—from ants or mosquitoes or flies—or we may suffer due to some superior power. There may be no rain, or there may be flood. There may be excessive heat or excessive cold. So many types of suffering are imposed by nature. Thus there are three types of miseries within the material world, and everyone is suffering from one, two, or three of them. No one can say that he is completely free from suffering.

We may then ask why the living entity is suffering. The answer is: out of ignorance. He does not think, “I am committing mistakes and am leading a sinful life; that is why I am suffering.” Therefore the guru’s first business is to rescue his disciple from this ignorance. We send our children to school to save them from suffering. If our children do not receive an education, we fear that they will suffer in the future. The guru sees that suffering is due to ignorance, which is compared to darkness. How can one in darkness be saved? By light. The guru takes the torchlight of knowledge and presents it before the living entity enveloped in darkness. That knowledge relieves him from the sufferings of the darkness of ignorance.

One may ask whether the guru is absolutely necessary. The Vedas inform us that he is:

tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet
samit-päëiù çrotriyaà brahma-niñöham
[Muëòaka Upaniñad 1.2.12]

The Vedas enjoin us to seek out a guru; actually, they say to seek out the guru, not just a guru. The guru is one because he comes in disciplic succession. What Vyäsadeva and Kåñëa taught five thousand years ago is also being taught now. There is no difference between the two instructions. Although hundreds and thousands of äcäryas have come and gone, the message is one. The real guru cannot be two, for the real guru does not speak differently from his predecessors. Some spiritual teachers say, “In my opinion you should do this,” but this is not a guru. Such so-called gurus are simply rascals. The genuine guru has only one opinion, and that is the opinion expressed by Kåñëa, Vyäsadeva, Närada, Arjuna, Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, and the Gosvämés. Five thousand years ago Lord Çré Kåñëa spoke the Bhagavad-gétä, and Vyäsadeva recorded it. Çréla Vyäsadeva did not say, “This is my opinion.” Rather, he wrote, çré-bhagavän uväca, that is, “The Supreme Personality of Godhead says.” Whatever Vyäsadeva wrote was originally spoken by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Çréla Vyäsadeva did not give his own opinion.

Consequently, Çréla Vyäsadeva is a guru. He does not misinterpret the words of Kåñëa, but transmits them exactly as they were spoken. If we send a telegram, the person who delivers the telegram does not have to correct it, edit it, or add to it. He simply presents it. That is the guru’s business. The guru may be this person or that, but the message is the same; therefore it is said that guru is one.

In the disciplic succession we simply find repetition of the same subject. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.34] Çré Kåñëa says:

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi yuktvaivam
ätmänaà mat-paräyaëaù

"Engage your mind always in thinking of Me, become My devotee, offer obeisances, and worship Me. Being completely absorbed in Me, surely you will come to Me.” These very instructions were reiterated by all the äcäryas, such as Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, and Caitanya Mahäprabhu. The six Goswamis also transmitted the same message, and we are simply following in their footsteps. There is no difference. We do not interpret the words of Kåñëa by saying, “In my opinion, the Battlefield of Kurukñetra represents the human body.” Such interpretations are set forth by rascals. In the world there are many rascal gurus who give their own opinion, but we can challenge any rascal. A rascal guru may say, “I am God,” or, “We are all God.” That is all right, but we should find out from the dictionary what the meaning of God is. Generally, a dictionary will tell us that the word God indicates the Supreme Being. Thus we may ask such a guru, “Are you the Supreme Being?” If he cannot understand this, then we should give the meaning of supreme. Any dictionary will inform us that supreme means “the greatest authority.” We may then ask, “Are you the greatest authority?” Such a rascal guru, even though proclaiming himself to be God, cannot answer such a question. God is the Supreme Being and the highest authority. No one is equal to Him or greater than Him. Yet there are many guru-gods, many rascals who claim to be the Supreme. Such rascals cannot help us escape the darkness of material existence. They cannot illumine our darkness with the torchlight of spiritual knowledge.

The bona fide guru will simply present what the supreme guru, God, says in bona fide scripture. A guru cannot change the message of the disciplic succession.

We must understand that we cannot carry out research to find the Absolute Truth. Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself said, “My Guru Mahäräja, My spiritual master, considered Me a great fool.” [Ädi 7.71] He who remains a great fool before his guru is a guru himself. However, if one says, “I am so advanced that I can speak better than my guru,” he is simply a rascal. In the Bhagavad-gétä [4.2] Çré Kåñëa says

evaà paramparä-präptam
imaà räjarñayo viduù
sa käleneha mahatä
yogo nañöaù parantapa

“This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way. But in course of time the succession was broken, and therefore the science as it is appears to be lost.”

Taking on a guru is not simply a fashion. One who is serious about understanding spiritual life requires a guru. A guru is a question of necessity, for one must be very serious to understand spiritual life, God, proper action, and one’s relationship with God. When we are very serious about understanding these subjects, we need a guru. We shouldn’t go to a guru simply because a guru may be fashionable at the moment. Surrender must be there, for without surrender we cannot learn anything. If we go to a guru simply to challenge him, we will learn nothing. We must accept the guru just as Arjuna accepted his guru, Çré Kåñëa Himself:

kärpaëya-doñopahata-svabhävaù
påcchämi tväà dharma-sammüòha-cetäù
yac chreyaù syän niçcitaà brühi tan me
çiñyas te 'haà çädhi mäà tväà prapannam

“Now I am confused about my duty and have lost all composure because of weakness. In this condition I am asking You to tell me clearly what is best for me. Now I am Your disciple and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me.” [Bhagavad-gétä 2.7]

This is the process for accepting a guru. The guru is Kåñëa’s representative, the former äcäryas’ representative. Kåñëa says that all äcäryas are His representatives; therefore the guru should be offered the same respect one would offer to God. As Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura says in his prayers to the spiritual master, yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädaù: “ By the mercy of the spiritual master, one receives the benediction of Kåñëa.” Thus, if we surrender to the bona fide guru, we surrender to God. God accepts our surrender to the guru.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66] Kåñëa instructs:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

“Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reaction. Do not fear.” Someone may argue, “Where is Kåñëa? I shall surrender to Him.” But no, the process is that we first surrender to Kåñëa’s representative; then we surrender to Kåñëa. Therefore it is said, säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästraiù: the guru is as good as God. When we offer respects to the guru, we are offering respects to God. Because we are trying to be God conscious, it is required that we learn how to offer respects to God through God’s representative. In all the çästras the guru is described to be as good as God, but the guru never says, “I am God.” The disciple’s duty is to offer respect to the guru just as he offers respect to God, but the guru never thinks, “My disciples are offering me the same respect they offer to God; therefore I have become God.” As soon as he thinks like this, he becomes a dog instead of God. Therefore Viçvanätha Cakravarté says, kintu prabhor yaù priya eva tasya. Because he is the most confidential servitor of God, the guru is offered the same respect that we offer God. God is always God, guru is always guru. As a matter of etiquette, God is the worshipable God, and guru is the worshiper God (sevaka-bhagavän). Therefore the guru is addressed as prabhupäda. The word prabhu means “lord,” and päda means “position.” Thus prabhupäda means “he who has taken the position of the Lord.” This is the same as säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästraiù.

Only if we are very serious about understanding the science of God is a guru required. We should not try to keep a guru as a matter of fashion. One who has accepted a guru speaks intelligently. He never speaks nonsense. That is the sign of having accepted a bona fide guru. We should certainly offer all respect to the spiritual master, but we should also remember how to carry out his orders. In the Bhagavad-gétä [4.34] Çré Kåñëa Himself tells us the method of seeking out and approaching the guru:

tad viddhi praëipätena
paripraçnena sevayä
upadekñyanti te jïänaà
jïäninas tattva-darçinaù

“Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth.” The first process is that of surrender. We have to find an exalted person and willingly surrender before him. The çästras enjoin that before we take a guru we study him carefully to find out whether we can surrender to him. We should not accept a guru suddenly, out of fanaticism. That is very dangerous. The guru should also study the person who wants to become a disciple to see if he is fit. That is the way a relationship is established between the guru and disciple. Everything is provided, but we must take up the process seriously. Then we can be trained to become a bona fide disciple. First we must find a bona fide guru, establish our relationship with him, and act accordingly. Then our life will be successful, for the guru can enlighten the sincere disciple who is in darkness.

Everyone is born a rascal and a fool. If we are born learned, why do we need to go to school? If we do not cultivate knowledge, we are no better than animals. An animal may say that there is no need of books and that he has become a guru, but how can anyone obtain knowledge without the study of authoritative books on science and philosophy? Rascal gurus try to avoid these things. We must understand that we are all born rascals and fools and that we have to be enlightened. We have to receive knowledge to make our lives perfect. If we do not perfect our lives, we are defeated. What is this defeat? The struggle for existence. We are trying to obtain a better life, to attain a superior position, and for this we are struggling very hard. But we do not know what a superior position actually is.

Whatever position we have in this material world must be given up. We may have a good position or a bad position; in any case, we cannot remain here. We may earn millions of dollars and think, “Now I am in a good position,” but a little dysentery or cholera will finish our position. If the bank fails, our position is gone. So actually there is no good position in this material world. It is a farce. Those who try to attain a better position in the material world are ultimately defeated, because there is no better position. The Bhagavad-gétä [14.26] says what the better position is:

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in the spiritual activities of unalloyed devotional service at once transcends the modes of of material nature and is elevated to the spiritual platform.”

Is there any science that gives us the knowledge by which we may become immortal? Yes, we may become immortal, but not in the material sense. We cannot receive this knowledge in so-called universities. However, there is knowledge contained in the Vedic scriptures by which we may become immortal. That immortality is our better position. No more birth, no more death, no more old age, no more disease. Thus the guru takes on a very great responsibility. He must guide his disciple and enable him to become an eligible candidate for the perfect position—immortality. The guru must be competent to lead his disciple back home, back to Godhead.

SSR 2b: Separating the Saints from the Swindlers

Separating the Saints from the Swindlers

Çréla Prabhupäda speaks out in an interview with the London Times: "If you want to be cheated, you will find many cheating gurus. But if you are sincere, you will find a sincere guru. . . . The genuine guru is God's representative, and he speaks about God and nothing else. . . . A genuine guru is not a businessman. He is a representative of God. Whatever God says, the guru repeats. He does not speak otherwise."

Reporter: Your Grace, it seems that more people than ever are seeking some kind of spiritual life. I wonder if you could tell me why this is so.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The desire for spiritual life is an absolutely natural hankering. Because we are spirit souls, we can not be happy in the material atmosphere. If you take a fish out of the water, it cannot be happy on land. Similarly, if we are without spiritual consciousness, we can never be happy. Today, so many people are after scientific advancement and economic development, but they are not happy because these are not the actual goals of life. Many young people are realizing this, and they are rejecting materialistic life and are trying to search for spiritual life. Actually this is the proper search. Krishna consciousness is the proper goal of life. Unless you take to Krishna consciousness, you cannot be happy. That is a fact. Therefore, we invite everyone to study and understand this great movement.

Reporter: What frankly worries me is that since the arrival in Britain some time ago of an Indian yogé, who was the first “guru” that most people had ever heard of, a lot of “gurus” have suddenly appeared out of nowhere. Sometimes I get the feeling that not all of them are as genuine as they ought to be. Would it be right to warn people who are thinking of taking up spiritual life that they should make sure that they have a genuine guru to teach them?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Of course, to search out a guru is very nice, but if you want a cheap guru, or if you want to be cheated, then you will find many cheating gurus. But if you are sincere, you will find a sincere guru. Because people want everything very cheaply, they are cheated. We ask our students to refrain from illicit sex, meat-eating, gambling, and intoxication. People think that this is all very difficult—a botheration. But if someone else says, “You may do whatever nonsense you like, simply take my mantra,” then people will like him. The point is that people want to be cheated, and therefore cheaters come. No one wants to undergo any austerity. Human life is meant for austerity, but no one is prepared to undergo austerity. Consequently, cheaters come and say, “No austerity. Whatever you like, you do. Simply pay me, and I’ll give you some mantra, and you’ll become God in six months.” All this is going on. If you want to be cheated like this, the cheaters will come.

Reporter: What about the person who seriously wants to find spiritual life but who happens to finish up with the wrong guru?

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you simply want an ordinary education, you have to devote so much time, labor, and understanding to it. Similarly, if you are going to take to spiritual life, you must become serious. How is it that simply by some wonderful mantras, someone can become God in six months? Why do people want something like that? This means that they want to be cheated.

Reporter: How can a person tell he has a genuine guru?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Can any of my students answer this question?

Disciple: Once I remember John Lennon asked you, “How will I know who is the genuine guru?” And you answered, “Just find out the one who is most addicted to Kåñëa. He is genuine.”

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. The genuine guru is God’s representative, and he speaks about God and nothing else. The genuine guru is he who has no interest in materialistic life. He is after God, and God only. That is one of the tests of a genuine guru: brahma-niñöham. He is absorbed in the Absolute Truth. In the Muëòaka Upaniñad [1.2.12] it is stated, çrotriyaà brahma-niñöham: “The genuine guru is well versed in the scriptures and Vedic knowledge, and he is completely dependent on Brahman.” He should know what Brahman [spirit] is and how to become situated in Brahman. These signs are given in the Vedic literature. As I said before, the real guru is God’s representative. He represents the Supreme Lord, just as a viceroy represents a king. The real guru will not manufacture anything. Everything he says is in accordance with the scriptures and the previous äcäryas. He will not give you a mantra and tell you that you will become God in six months. This is not a guru’s business. A guru’s business is to canvass everyone to become a devotee of God. That is the sum and substance of a real guru’s business. Indeed, he has no other business. He tells whomever he sees, “Please become God conscious.” If he canvasses somehow or other on behalf of God and tries to get everyone to become a devotee of God, he is a genuine guru.

Reporter: What about a Christian priest?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Christian, Muhammadan, Hindu—it doesn’t matter. If he is simply speaking on behalf of God, he is a guru. Lord Jesus Christ, for instance. He canvassed people, saying, “Just try to love God.” Anyone—it doesn’t matter who—be he Hindu, Muslim, or Christian, is a guru if he convinces people to love God. That is the test. The guru never says, “I am God,” or “I will make you God.” The real guru says, “I am a servant of God, and I will make you a servant of God also.” It doesn’t matter how the guru is dressed. As Caitanya Mahäprabhu said, “Whoever can impart knowledge about Kåñëa is a spiritual master.” A genuine spiritual master simply tries to get people to become devotees of Kåñëa, or God. He has no other business.

Reporter: But the bad gurus...

Çréla Prabhupäda: And what is a “bad” guru?

Reporter: A bad guru just wants some money or some fame.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, if he is bad, how can he become a guru? [Laughter.] How can iron become gold? Actually, a guru cannot be bad, for if someone is bad, he cannot be a guru. You cannot say “bad guru.” That is a contradiction. What you have to do is simply try to understand what a genuine guru is. The definition of a genuine guru is that he is simply talking about God—that’s all. If he’s talking about some other nonsense, then he is not a guru. A guru cannot be bad. There is no question of a bad guru, any more than a red guru or a white guru. Guru means “genuine guru.” All we have to know is that the genuine guru is simply talking about God and trying to get people to become God’s devotees. If he does this, he is genuine.

Reporter: If I wanted to be initiated into your society, what would I have to do?

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, you’d have to give up illicit sex life.

Reporter: Does that include all sex life? What is illicit sex life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Illicit sex is sex outside of marriage. Animals have sex with no restrictions, but in human society there are restrictions. In every country and in every religion, there is some system of restricting sex life. You would also have to give up all intoxicants, including tea, cigarettes, alcohol, marijuana—anything that intoxicates.

Reporter: Anything else?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You’d also have to give up eating meat, eggs, and fish. And you’d have to give up gambling as well. Unless you gave up these four sinful activities, you could not be initiated.

Reporter: How many followers do you have throughout the world?

Çréla Prabhupäda: For anything genuine, the followers may be very few. For something rubbish, the followers may be many. Still, we have about five thousand initiated disciples.

Reporter: Is the Kåñëa consciousness movement growing all the time?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is growing—but slowly. This is because we have so many restrictions. People do not like restrictions.

Reporter: Where is your following the greatest?

Çréla Prabhupäda: In the United States, Europe, South America, and Australia. And, of course, in India there are millions who practice Kåñëa consciousness.

Reporter: Could you tell me what the goal of your movement is?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to awaken man’s original consciousness. At the present moment our consciousness is designated. Someone is thinking, “I am an Englishman,” and another is thinking, “I am an American.” Actually, we do not belong to any of these designations. We are all part and parcel of God; that is our real identity. If everyone simply comes to that consciousness, all the problems of the world will be solved. Then we shall come to know that we are one—the same quality of spirit soul. The same quality of spirit soul is within everyone, although it may be in a different dress. This is the explanation given in the Bhagavad-gétä.

Kåñëa consciousness is actually a purificatory process (sarvopädhi-vinirmuktam). Its purpose is to make people free from all designations (tat-paratvena nirmalam). When our consciousness becomes purified of all designations, the activities we carry out with our purified senses make us perfect. Eventually, we reach the ideal perfection of human life. Kåñëa consciousness is also a very simple process. It is not necessary to become a great philosopher, scientist, or whatever. We need only chant the holy name of the Lord, understanding that His personality, His name, and His qualities are all absolute.

Kåñëa consciousness is a great science. Unfortunately, in the universities there is no department for this science. Therefore we invite all serious men who are interested in the welfare of human society to understand this great movement and, if possible, take part in it and cooperate with us. The problems of the world will be solved. This is also the verdict of the Bhagavad-gétä, the most important and authoritative book of spiritual knowledge. Many of you have heard of the Bhagavad-gétä. Our movement is based on it. Our movement is approved by all great äcäryas in India. Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Lord Caitanya, and so many others. You are all representatives of newspapers, so I ask you to try to understand this movement as far as possible for the good of all human society.

Reporter: Do you think your movement is the only way to know God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Reporter: How are you assured of that?

Çréla Prabhupäda: From the authorities and from God, Kåñëa. Kåñëa says:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

“Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reaction. Do not fear.” [Bhagavad-gétä 18.66]

Reporter: Does “surrender” mean that someone would have to leave his family?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No.

Reporter: But suppose I were to become an initiate. Wouldn’t I have to come and live in the temple?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not necessarily.

Reporter: I can stay at home?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Oh, yes.

Reporter: What about work? Would I have to give up my job?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, you’d simply have to give up your bad habits and chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra on these beads—that’s all.

Reporter: Would I have to give any financial support?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, that is your voluntary wish. If you give, that’s all right. And if you don’t, we don’t mind. We do not depend on anyone’s financial contribution. We depend on Kåñëa.

Reporter: I wouldn’t have to give any money at all?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No.

Reporter: Is this one of the main things that distinguishes the genuine guru from the fake guru?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a genuine guru is not a businessman. He is a representative of God. Whatever God says, the guru repeats. He does not speak otherwise.

Reporter: But would you expect to find a real guru, say, traveling in a Rolls Royce and staying in a penthouse suite in a classy hotel?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sometimes people provide us with a room in a first-class hotel, but we generally stay in our own temples. We have some one hundred temples around the world, so we don’t require to go to any hotels.

Reporter: I wasn’t trying to make any accusations. I was merely trying to illustrate that I think your warning is a valid one. There are so many people interested in finding a spiritual life, and at the same time there are a lot of people interested in cashing in on the “guru business.”

Çréla Prabhupäda: Are you under the impression that spiritual life means voluntarily accepting poverty?

Reporter: Well, I don’t know.

Çréla Prabhupäda: A poverty-stricken man may be materialistic, and a wealthy man may be very spiritual. Spiritual life does not depend on either poverty or wealth. Spiritual life is transcendental. Consider Arjuna, for instance. Arjuna was a member of a royal family, yet he was a pure devotee of God. And in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.2] Çré Kåñëa says, evaà paramparä-präptaà imaà räjarñayo viduù: “This supreme science was received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way.” In the past, all kings who were saintly understood spiritual science. Therefore, spiritual life does not depend on one’s material condition. Whatever a person’s material condition may be—he may be a king or a pauper—he can still understand spiritual life. Generally people do not know what spiritual life is, and therefore, they unnecessarily criticize us. If I asked you what spiritual life is, how would you answer?

Reporter: Well, I’m not sure.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Although you do not know what spiritual life is, you still say, “It is this,” or “It is that.” But first you should know what spiritual life is. Spiritual life begins when you understand that you are not your body. This is the real beginning of spiritual life. By seeing the difference between your self and your body, you come to understand that you are a spirit soul (ahaà brahmäsmi).

Reporter: Do you think this knowledge should be a part of everyone’s education?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. People should first be taught what they are. Are they their bodies, or something else? That is the beginning of education. Now everyone is educated to think he is his body. Because someone accidentally gets an American body, he thinks, “I am an American.” This is just like thinking, “I am a red shirt,” just because you are wearing a red shirt. You are not a red shirt; you are a human being. Similarly, this body is like a shirt or coat over the real person—the spirit soul. If we recognize ourselves simply by our bodily “shirt” or “coat,” then we have no spiritual education.

Reporter: Do you think that such education should be given in schools?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes—in schools, colleges, and universities. There is an immense literature on this subject—an immense fund of knowledge. What is actually required is that the leaders of society come forward to understand this movement.

Reporter: Have you ever had people come to you who had previously been involved with a fake guru?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, there are many.

Reporter: Were their spiritual lives in any way spoiled by the fake gurus?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, they were genuinely seeking something spiritual, and that was their qualification. God is within everyone’s heart, and as soon as someone genuinely seeks Him, He helps that person find a genuine guru.

Reporter: Have the real gurus like yourself ever tried to put a stop to the false gurus—that is, put pressure on them to put them out of business, so to speak?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, that is not my purpose. I started my movement simply by chanting Hare Kåñëa. I chanted in New York in a place called Tompkins Square Park, and soon people began to come to me. In this way, the Kåñëa consciousness movement gradually developed. Many accepted, and many did not accept. Those who are fortunate have accepted.

Reporter: Don’t you feel that people are suspicious because of their experience with fake gurus? If you went to a quack dentist and he broke your tooth, you might be suspicious about going to another dentist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Naturally, if you are cheated, you become suspicious. But this does not mean that if you are cheated once, you will always be cheated. You should find someone genuine. But to come to Kåñëa consciousness, you must be either very fortunate or well aware of this science. From the Bhagavad-gétä we understand that the genuine seekers are very few: manuñyäëäà sahasreñu kaçcid yatati siddhaye. Out of many millions of people, there may be only one who is interested in spiritual life. Generally, people are interested in eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. So how can we expect to find many followers? It is not difficult to notice that people have lost their spiritual interest. And almost all those who are actually interested are being cheated by so-called spiritualists. You cannot judge a movement simply by the number of its followers. If one man is genuine, then the movement is successful. It is not a question of quantity, but quality.

Reporter: I wondered how many people you think might have been taken in by fake gurus.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Practically everyone. [Laughter.] There is no question of counting. Everyone.

Reporter: This would mean thousands of people, wouldn’t it?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Millions. Millions have been cheated, because they want to be cheated. God is omniscient. He can understand your desires. He is within your heart, and if you want to be cheated, God sends you a cheater.

Reporter: Is it possible for everyone to attain the perfectional stage you spoke of previously?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Within a second. Anyone can attain perfection within a second—providing he is willing. The difficulty is that no one is willing. In the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66] Kåñëa says, sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja: “Simply surrender unto Me.” But who is going to surrender to God? Everyone says, “Oh, why should I surrender to God? I will be independent.” If you simply surrender, it is a second’s business. That’s all. But no one is willing, and that is the difficulty.

Reporter: When you say that lots of people want to be cheated, do you mean that lots of people want to carry on with their worldly pleasures and at the same time, by chanting a mantra or by holding a flower, achieve spiritual life as well? Is this what you mean by wanting to be cheated?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this is like a patient thinking, “I shall continue with my disease, and at the same time I shall become healthy.” It is contradictory. The first requirement is that one become educated in spiritual life. Spiritual life is not something one can understand by a few minutes’ talk. There are many philosophy and theology books, but people are not interested in them. That is the difficulty. For instance, the Çrémad-Bhägavatam is a very long work, and if you try to read this book, it may take many days just to understand one line of it. The Bhägavatam describes God, the Absolute Truth, but people are not interested. And if, by chance, someone becomes a little interested in spiritual life, he wants something immediate and cheap. Therefore, he is cheated. Actually, human life is meant for austerity and penance. That is the way of Vedic civilization. In Vedic times they would train boys as brahmacärés; no sex life was allowed at all up to the age of twenty-five. Where is that education now? A brahmacäré is a student who lives a life of complete celibacy and obeys the commands of his guru at the guru-kula [school of the spiritual master]. Now schools and colleges are teaching sex from the very beginning, and twelve-or thirteen-year-old boys and girls are having sex. How can they have a spiritual life? Spiritual life means voluntarily accepting some austerities for the sake of God realization. That is why we insist on no illicit sex, meat-eating, gambling, or intoxication for our initiated students. Without these restrictions, any “yoga meditation” or so-called spiritual discipline cannot be genuine. It is simply a business deal between the cheaters and the cheated.

Reporter: Thank you very much.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Hare Kåñëa.

SSR 2c: With All the Humility at My Command

With All the Humility at My Command

It is February 1936, in Bombay. The pure devotee who three decades later will become the world-renowned spiritual master of the Kåñëa consciousness movement glorifies his own spiritual master. Here we learn the time-honored meaning of the spiritual master, the disciple and their relationship...

säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästrair
uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù
kintu prabhor yaù priya eva tasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam
[Gurv-añöaka 7]

“In the revealed scriptures it is declared that the spiritual master should be worshiped like the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and this injunction is obeyed by pure devotees of the Lord. The spiritual master is the most confidential servant of the Lord. Thus let us offer our respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of our spiritual master.”

Gentlemen, on behalf of the members of the Bombay branch of the Gauòéya Maöha, let me welcome you all because you have so kindly joined us tonight in our congregational offerings of homage to the lotus feet of the world teacher, Äcäryadeva, who is the founder of this Gauòéya Mission and is the president-äcärya of Çré Çré Viçva-vaiñëava Räja-sabhä—I mean my eternal divine master, Paramahaàsa Parivräjakäcärya Çré Çrémad Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Goswami Mahäräja.

Sixty-two years ago, on this auspicious day, the Äcäryadeva made his appearance by the call of Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda at Çré-kñetra Jagannätha-dhäma at Puré.

Gentlemen, the offering of such an homage as has been arranged this evening to the Äcäryadeva is not a sectarian concern, for when we speak of the fundamental principle of gurudeva, or äcäryadeva, we speak of something that is of universal application. There does not arise any question of discriminating my guru from yours or anyone else’s. There is only one guru, who appears in an infinity of forms to teach you, me, and all others.

The guru, or äcäryadeva, as we learn from the bona fide scriptures, delivers the message of the absolute world, the transcendental abode of the Absolute Personality, where everything nondifferentially serves the Absolute Truth. We have heard so many times: mahäjano yena gataù sa panthäù (“Traverse the trail which your previous äcärya has passed”), but we have hardly tried to understand the real purport of this çloka. If we scrutinizingly study this proposition, we understand that the mahäjana is one, and the royal road to the transcendental world is also one. In the Muëòaka Upaniñad [1.2.12] it is said:

tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet
samit-päëiù çrotriyaà brahma-niñöham

“In order to learn the transcendental science, one must approach the bona fide spiritual master in disciplic succession, who is fixed in the Absolute Truth.”

Thus it has been enjoined herewith that in order to receive that transcendental knowledge, one must approach the guru. Therefore, if the Absolute Truth is one, about which we think there is no difference of opinion, the guru also cannot be two. The Äcäryadeva for whom we have assembled tonight to offer our humble homage is not the guru of a sectarian institution or one out of many differing exponents of the truth. On the contrary, he is the Jagad-guru, or the guru of all of us; the only difference is that some obey him wholeheartedly, while others do not obey him directly.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [11.17.27] it is said:

äcäryaà mäà vijänéyän
nävamanyeta karhicit
na martya-buddhyäsüyeta
sarva-devamayo guruù

“One should understand the spiritual master to be as good as I am,” said the Blessed Lord. “Nobody should be jealous of the spiritual master or think of him as an ordinary man, because the spiritual master is the sum total of all demigods.” That is, the äcärya has been identified with God Himself. He has nothing to do with the affairs of this mundane world. He does not descend here to meddle with the affairs of temporary necessities, but to deliver the fallen, conditioned souls—the souls, or entities, who have come here to the material world with a motive of enjoyment by the mind and the five organs of sense perception. He appears before us to reveal the light of the Vedas and to bestow upon us the blessings of full-fledged freedom, after which we should hanker at every step of our life’s journey.

The transcendental knowledge of the Vedas was first uttered by God to Brahmä, the creator of this particular universe. From Brahmä the knowledge descended to Närada, from Närada to Vyäsadeva, from Vyäsadeva to Madhva, and in this process of disciplic succession the transcendental knowledge was transmitted by one disciple to another till it reached Lord Gauräìga, Çré Kåñëa Caitanya, who posed as the disciple and successor of Çré Içvara Puré. The present Äcäryadeva is the tenth disciplic representative from Çré Rupa Goswami, the original representative of Lord Caitanya who preached this transcendental tradition in its fullness. The knowledge that we receive from our Gurudeva is not different from that imparted by God Himself and the succession of the äcäryas in the preceptorial line of Brahmä. We adore this auspicious day as Çré Vyäsa-püjä-tithi, because the Äcärya is the living representative of Vyäsadeva, the divine compiler of the Vedas, the Puräëas, the Bhagavad-gétä, the Mahäbhärata, and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

One who interprets the divine sound, or çabda-brahma, by his imperfect sense perception cannot be a real spiritual guru, because, in the absence of proper disciplinary training under the bona fide äcärya, the interpreter is sure to differ from Vyäsadeva (as the Mäyävädés do). Çréla Vyäsadeva is the prime authority of Vedic revelation, and therefore such an irrelevant interpreter cannot be accepted as the guru, or äcärya, howsoever equipped he may be with all the acquirements of material knowledge. As it is said in the Padma Puräëa:

sampradäya-vihénä ye
manträs te niñphalä matäù

“Unless you are initiated by a bona fide spiritual master in the disciplic succession, the mantra that you might have received is without any effect.”

On the other hand, one who has received the transcendental knowledge by aural reception from the bona fide preceptor in the disciplic chain, and who has sincere regard for the real äcärya, must needs be enlightened with the revealed knowledge of the Vedas. But this knowledge is permanently sealed to the cognitive approach of the empiricists. As it is said in the Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad [6.23]:

yasya deve parä bhaktir
yathä deve tathä gurau
tasyaite kathitä hy arthäù
prakäçante mahätmanaù

“Only unto those great souls who simultaneously have implicit faith in both the Lord and the spiritual master are all the imports of Vedic knowledge automatically revealed.”

Gentlemen, our knowledge is so poor, our senses are so imperfect, and our sources are so limited that it is not possible for us to have even the slightest knowledge of the absolute region without surrendering ourselves at the lotus feet of Çré Vyäsadeva or his bona fide representative. Every moment we are being deceived by the knowledge of our direct perception. It is all the creation or concoction of the mind, which is always deceiving, changing, and flickering. We cannot know anything of the transcendental region by our limited, perverted method of observation and experiment. But all of us can lend our eager ears for the aural reception of the transcendental sound transmitted from that region to this through the unadulterated medium of Çré Gurudeva or Çré Vyäsadeva. Therefore, gentlemen, we should surrender ourselves today at the feet of the representative of Çré Vyäsadeva for the elimination of all our differences bred by our unsubmissive attitude. It is accordingly said in Çré Gétä [4.34]:

tad viddhi praëipätena
paripraçnena sevayä
upadekñyanti te jïänaà
jïäninas tattva-darçinaù

“Just approach the wise and bona fide spiritual master. Surrender unto him first and try to understand him by inquiries and service. Such a wise spiritual master will enlighten you with transcendental knowledge, for he has already known the Absolute Truth.”

To receive the transcendental knowledge we must completely surrender ourselves to the real äcärya in a spirit of ardent inquiry and service. Actual performance of service to the Absolute under the guidance of the äcärya is the only vehicle by which we can assimilate the transcendental knowledge. Today’s meeting for offering our humble services and homage to the feet of the Äcäryadeva will enable us to be favored with the capacity for assimilating the transcendental knowledge so kindly transmitted by him to all persons, without distinction.

Gentlemen, we are all more or less proud of our past Indian civilization, but we actually do not know the real nature of that civilization. We cannot be proud of our past material civilization, which is now a thousand times greater than in days gone by. It is said that we are passing through the age of darkness, the Kali-yuga. What is this darkness? The darkness cannot be due to backwardness in material knowledge, because we now have more of it than formerly. If not we ourselves, our neighbors, at any rate, have plenty of it. Therefore, we must conclude that the darkness of the present age is not due to a lack of material advancement, but that we have lost the clue to our spiritual advancement, which is the prime necessity of human life and the criterion of the highest type of human civilization. Throwing of bombs from airplanes is no advancement of civilization from the primitive, uncivilized practice of dropping big stones on the heads of enemies from the tops of hills. Improvement of the art of killing our neighbors by means of machine guns and poisonous gases is certainly no advancement from primitive barbarism, which prided itself on its art of killing by bows and arrows. Nor does the development of a sense of pampered selfishness prove anything more than intellectual animalism. True human civilization is very different from all these states, and therefore in the Kaöha Upaniñad [1.3.14] there is the emphatic call:

uttiñöhata jägrata
präpya varän nibodhata
kñurasya dhärä niçitä duratyayä
durgaà pathas tat kavayo vadanti

"Please wake up and try to understand the boon that you now have in this human form of life. The path of spiritual realization is very difficult; it is sharp like a razor’s edge. That is the opinion of learned transcendental scholars.”

Thus, while others were yet in the womb of historical oblivion, the sages of India had developed a different kind of civilization, which enabled them to know themselves. They had discovered that we are not at all material entities, but that we are all spiritual, permanent, and indestructible servants of the Absolute. But because we have, against our better judgment, chosen to completely identify ourselves with this present material existence, our sufferings have multiplied according to the inexorable law of birth and death, with its consequent diseases and anxieties. These sufferings cannot be really mitigated by any provision of material happiness, because matter and spirit are completely different elements. It is just as if you took an aquatic animal out of water and put it on the land, supplying all manner of happiness possible on land. The deadly sufferings of the animal are not capable of being relieved at all until it is taken out of its foreign environment. Spirit and matter are completely contradictory things. All of us are spiritual entities. We cannot have perfect happiness, which is our birthright, however much we may meddle with the affairs of mundane things. Perfect happiness can be ours only when we are restored to our natural state of spiritual existence. This is the distinctive message of our ancient Indian civilization, this is the message of the Gétä, this is the message of the Vedas and the Puräëas, and this is the message of all the real äcäryas, including our present Äcäryadeva, in the line of Lord Caitanya.

Gentlemen, although it is imperfectly that we have been enabled by his grace to understand the sublime messages of our Äcäryadeva, Om Visëupäda Paramahamsa Parivräjakäcärya Çré Çrémad Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Goswami Mahäräja, we must admit that we have realized definitely that the divine message from his holy lips is the congenial thing for suffering humanity. All of us should hear him patiently. If we listen to the transcendental sound without unnecessary opposition, he will surely have mercy upon us. The Äcärya’s Message is to take us back to our original home, back to God. Let me repeat, therefore, that we should hear him patiently, follow him in the measure of our conviction, and bow down at his lotus feet for releasing us from our present causeless unwillingness for serving the Absolute and all souls.

From the Gétä we learn that even after the destruction of the body, the ätmä, or the soul, is not destroyed; he is always the same, always new and fresh. Fire cannot burn him, water cannot dissolve him, the air cannot dry him up, and the sword cannot kill him. He is everlasting and eternal, and this is also confirmed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [10.84.13]:

yasyätma-buddhiù kuëape tri-dhätuke
sva-dhéù kalaträdiñu bhauma ijya-dhéù
yat-tértha-buddhiù salile na karhicij
janeñv abhijïeñu sa eva go-kharaù

“Anyone who accepts this bodily bag of three elements [bile, mucus, and air] as his self, who has an affinity for an intimate relationship with his wife and children, who considers his land worshipable, who takes bath in the waters of the holy places of pilgrimage but never takes advantage of those persons who are in actual knowledge—he is no better than an ass or a cow.”

Unfortunately, in these days we have all been turned foolish by neglecting our real comfort and identifying the material cage with ourselves. We have concentrated all our energies for the meaningless upkeep of the material cage for its own sake, completely neglecting the captive soul within. The cage is meant for the undoing of the bird; the bird is not meant for the welfare of the cage. Let us, therefore, deeply ponder this. All our activities are now turned toward the upkeep of the cage, and the most we do is try to give some food to the mind by art and literature. But we do not know that this mind is also material in a more subtle form. This is stated in the Gétä [7.4]:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

“Earth, fire, water, air, sky, intelligence, mind, and ego are all My separated energies.”

We have scarcely tried to give any food to the soul, which is distinct from the body and mind; therefore we are all committing suicide in the proper sense of the term. The message of the Äcäryadeva is to give us a warning to halt such wrong activities. Let us therefore bow down at his lotus feet for the unalloyed mercy and kindness he has bestowed upon us.

Gentlemen, do not for a moment think that my Gurudeva wants to put a complete brake on the modern civilization—an impossible feat. But let us learn from him the art of making the best use of a bad bargain, and let us understand the importance of this human life, which is fit for the highest development of true consciousness. The best use of this rare human life should not be neglected. As it is said in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [11.9.29]:

labdhvä sudurlabham idaà bahu-sambhavänte
mänuñyam arthadam anityam apéha dhéraù
türëaà yateta na pated anu måtyu yävan
niùçreyasäya viñayaù khalu sarvataù syät

“This human form of life is obtained after many, many births, and although it is not permanent, it can offer the highest benefits. Therefore a sober and intelligent man should immediately try to fulfill his mission and attain the highest profit in life before another death occurs. He should avoid sense gratification, which is available in all circumstances.”

Let us not misuse this human life in the vain pursuit of material enjoyment, or, in other words, for the sake of only eating, sleeping, fearing, and sensuous activities. The Äcäryadeva’s message is conveyed by the words of Çré Rüpa Goswami [Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.2.255-256]:

anäsaktasya viñayän
yathärham upayuïjataù
nirbandhaù kåñëa-sambandhe
yuktaà vairägyam ucyate

präpaïcikatayä buddhyä
hari-sambandhi-vastunaù
mumukñubhiù parityägo
vairägyaà phalgu kathyate

“One is said to be situated in the fully renounced order of life if he lives in accordance with Kåñëa consciousness. He should be without attachment for sense gratification and should accept only what is necessary for the upkeep of the body. On the other hand, one who renounces things that could be used in the service of Kåñëa, under the pretext that such things are material, does not practice complete renunciation.

The purport of these çlokas can only be realized by fully developing the rational portion of our life, not the animal portion. Sitting at the feet of the Äcäryadeva, let us try to understand from this transcendental source of knowledge what we are, what is this universe, what is God, and what is our relationship with Him. The message of Lord Caitanya is the message for the living entities and the message of the living world. Lord Caitanya did not bother Himself for the upliftment of this dead world, which is suitably named Martyaloka, the world where everything is destined to die. He appeared before us four hundred fifty years ago to tell us something of the transcendental universe, where everything is permanent and everything is for the service of the Absolute. But recently Lord Caitanya has been misrepresented by some unscrupulous persons, and the highest philosophy of the Lord has been misinterpreted to be the cult of the lowest type of society. We are glad to announce tonight that our Äcäryadeva, with his usual kindness, saved us from this horrible type of degradation, and therefore we bow down at his lotus feet with all humility.

Gentlemen, it has been a mania of the cultured (or uncultured) society of the present day to accredit the Personality of Godhead with merely impersonal features and to stultify Him by claiming that He has no senses, no form, no activity, no head, no legs, and no enjoyment. This has also been the pleasure of the modern scholars due to their sheer lack of proper guidance and true introspection in the spiritual realm. All these empiricists think alike: all the enjoyable things should be monopolized by the human society, or by a particular class only, and the impersonal God should be a mere order-supplier for their whimsical feats. We are happy that we have been relieved of this horrible type of malady by the mercy of His Divine Grace Paramahaàsa Parivräjakäcärya Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Goswami Mahäräja. He is our eye-opener, our eternal father, our eternal preceptor, and our eternal guide. Let us therefore bow down at his lotus feet on this auspicious day.

Gentlemen, although we are like ignorant children in the knowledge of the Transcendence, still His Divine Grace, my Gurudeva, has kindled a small fire within us to dissipate the invincible darkness of empirical knowledge. We are now so much on the safe side that no amount of philosophical argument by the empiric schools of thought can deviate us an inch from the position of our eternal dependence on the lotus feet of His Divine Grace. Furthermore, we are prepared to challenge the most erudite scholars of the Mäyäväda school and prove that the Personality of Godhead and His transcendental sports in Goloka alone constitute the sublime information of the Vedas. There are explicit indications of this in the Chändogya Upaniñad [8.13.1]:

çyämäc chavalaà prapadye
çavaläc chyämaà prapadye

“For receiving the mercy of Kåñëa, I surrender unto His energy (Rädhä), and for receiving the mercy of His energy, I surrender unto Kåñëa.” Also in the Åg Veda [1.22.20]:

tad viñëoù paramaà padaà sadä
paçyanti sürayaù
divéva cakñur ätatam
viñëor yat paramaà padam

“The lotus feet of Lord Viñëu are the supreme objective of all the demigods. These lotus feet of the Lord are as enlightening as the sun in the sky.”

The plain truth so vividly explained in the Gétä, which is the central lesson of the Vedas, is not understood or even suspected by the most powerful scholars of the empiric schools. Herein lies the secret of Çré Vyäsa-püjä. When we meditate on the transcendental pastimes of the Absolute Godhead, we are proud to feel that we are His eternal servitors, and we become jubilant and dance with joy. All glory to my divine master, for it is he who has out of his unceasing flow of mercy stirred up within us such a movement of eternal existence. Let us bow down at his lotus feet.

Gentlemen, had he not appeared before us to deliver us from the thralldom of this gross worldly delusion, surely we should have remained for lives and ages in the darkness of helpless captivity. Had he not appeared before us, we would not have been able to understand the eternal truth of the sublime teaching of Lord Caitanya. Had he not appeared before us, we could not have been able to know the significance of the first çloka of the Brahma-saàhitä [5.1]:

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù
sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù
anädir ädir govindaù
sarva-käraëa-käraëam

“Kåñëa, who is known as Govinda, is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal, blissful, spiritual body. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin, and He is the prime cause of all causes.”

Personally, I have no hope for any direct service for the coming crores of births of the sojourn of my life, but I am confident that some day or other I shall be delivered from this mire of delusion in which I am at present so deeply sunk. Therefore let me with all my earnestness pray at the lotus feet of my divine master to allow me to suffer the lot for which I am destined due to my past misdoings, but to let me have this power of recollection: that I am nothing but a tiny servant of the Almighty Absolute Godhead, realized through the unflinching mercy of my divine master. Let me therefore bow down at his lotus feet with all the humility at my command.

SSR 3: Looking at the Cultural Background

III. Looking at the Cultural Background

SSR 3a: India’s Greatest Impersonalist Meditated
on Lord Kåñëa and the Bhagavad-gétä

India’s Greatest Impersonalist Meditated
on Lord Kåñëa and the
Bhagavad-gétä

Çréla Prabhupäda chastises impersonalist yogis and swamis, the nominal followers of the ninth-century teacher Çaìkara, in this commentary on the later’s Meditation on the Bhagavad-gétä: “Fools rush in where angels fear to tread. Whereas Çaìkara, the greatest of the impersonalists, offers his due respects to Kåñëa and His book Bhagavad-gétä, the foolish say that ‘we need not surrender to the personal Kåñna.’”

SSR 3b: O Bhagavad-gétä

—1—

O Bhagavad-gétä,
Through Thy eighteen chapters
Thou showerest upon man
The immortal nectar
Of the wisdom of the Absolute.
O blessed Gétä,
By Thee, Lord Kåñëa Himself
Enlightened Arjuna.
Afterward, the ancient sage Vyäsa
Included Thee in the Mahäbhärata.
O loving mother,
Destroyer of man's rebirth
Into the darkness of this mortal world,
Upon Thee I meditate.

SSR 3c: Salutations to thee, O Vyäsa.

—2—

Salutations to thee, O Vyäsa.
Thou art of mighty intellect,
And thine eyes
Are large as the petals
Of the full-blown lotus.
It was thou
Who brightened this lamp of wisdom,
Filling it with the oil
Of the Mahäbhärata.

Purport

Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya was an impersonalist from the materialistic point of view. But he never denied the spiritual form known as sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, or the eternal, all-blissful form of knowledge that existed before the material creation. When he spoke of the Supreme Brahman as impersonal, he meant that the Lord's sac-cid-änanda form was not to be confused with a material conception of personality. In the very beginning of his commentary on the Gétä, he maintains that Näräyaëa, the Supreme Lord, is transcendental to the material creation. The Lord existed before the creation as the transcendental personality, and He has nothing to do with material personality. Lord Kåñëa is the same Supreme Personality, and He has no connection with a material body. He descends in His spiritual, eternal form, but foolish people mistake His body to be like ours. Çaìkara's preaching of impersonalism is especially meant for teaching foolish persons who consider Kåñëa to be an ordinary man composed of matter.

No one would care to read the Gétä if it had been spoken by a material man, and certainly Vyäsadeva would not have bothered to incorporate it into the history of the Mahäbhärata. According to the above verses, the Mahäbhärata is the history of the ancient world, and Vyäsadeva is the writer of this great epic. The Bhagavad-gétä is identical with Kåñëa; and because Kåñëa is the Absolute Supreme Personality of Godhead, there is no difference between Kåñëa and His words. Therefore the Bhagavad-gétä is as worshipable as Lord Kåñëa Himself, both being absolute. One who hears the Bhagavad-gétä "as is" actually hears the words directly from the lotus lips of the Lord. But unfortunate persons say that the Gétä is too antiquated for the modern man, who wants to find out God by speculation or meditation.

SSR 3d: I salute Thee, O Kåñëa

—3—

I salute Thee, O Kåñëa,
O Thou who art the refuge
Of ocean-born Lakñmé
And all who take refuge
At Thy lotus feet.
Thou art indeed
The wish-fulfilling tree
For Thy devotee.
Thy one hand holds a staff
For driving cows,
And Thy other hand is raised—
The thumb touching the tip
Of Thy forefinger,
Indicating divine knowledge.
Salutations to Thee, O Supreme Lord,
For Thou art the milker
Of the ambrosia of the Gétä.

Purport

Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya explicitly says, "You fools, just worship Govinda and that Bhagavad-gétä spoken by Näräyaëa Himself," yet foolish people still conduct their research work to find out Näräyaëa; consequently they are wretched, and they waste their time for nothing. Näräyaëa is never wretched nor daridra; rather, He is worshiped by the goddess of fortune, Lakñmé, as well as by all living entities. Çaìkara declared himself to be "Brahman," but he admits Näräyaëa, or Kåñëa, to be the Supreme Personality who is beyond the material creation. He offers his respects to Kåñëa as the Supreme Brahman, or Parabrahman, because He (Kåñëa) is worshipable by everyone. Only the fools and enemies of Kåñëa, who cannot understand what the Bhagavad-gétä is (though they make commentaries on it), say, "It is not the personal Kåñëa to whom we have to surrender ourselves utterly, but the unborn, beginningless Eternal who speaks through Kåñëa." Fools rush in where angels fear to tread. Whereas Çaìkara, the greatest of the impersonalists, offers his due respects to Kåñëa and His book the Bhagavad-gétä, the foolish say that "we need not surrender to the personal Kåñëa." Such unenlightened people do not know that Kåñëa is absolute and that there is no difference between His inside and outside. The difference of inside and outside is experienced in the dual, material world. In the absolute world there is no such difference, because in the absolute everything is spiritual (sac-cid-änanda), and Näräyaëa, or Kåñëa, belongs to the absolute world. In the absolute world there is only the factual personality, and there is no distinction between body and soul.

SSR 3e: The Upaniñads

—4—

The Upaniñads
Are as a herd of cows,
Lord Kåñëa, son of a cowherd,
Is their milker,
Arjuna is the calf,
The supreme nectar of the Gétä
Is the milk,
And the wise man
Of purified intellect
Is the drinker.

Purport

Unless one understands spiritual variegatedness, one cannot understand the transcendental pastimes of the Lord. In the Brahma-saàhitä it is said that Kåñëa's name, form, qualities, pastimes, entourage, and paraphernalia are all änanda-cinmaya-rasa—in short, everything of His transcendental association is of the same composition of spiritual bliss, knowledge, and eternity. There is no end to His name, form, etc., unlike in the material world, where all things have their end. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, only fools deride Him; whereas it is Çaìkara, the greatest impersonalist, who worships Him, His cows, and His pastimes as the son of Vasudeva and pleasure of Devaké.

SSR 3f: Thou son of Vasudeva

—5—

Thou son of Vasudeva,
Destroyer of the demons Kaàsa and Cäëüra,
Thou supreme bliss of Mother Devaké,
O Thou, guru of the universe,
Teacher of the worlds,
Thee, O Kåñëa, I salute.

Purport

Çaìkara describes Him as the son of Vasudeva and Devaké. Does he mean thereby that he is worshiping an ordinary, material man? He worships Kåñëa because he knows that Kåñëa's birth and activities are all supernatural. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.9], Kåñëa's birth and activities are mysterious and transcendental, and therefore only the devotees of Kåñëa can know them perfectly. Çaìkara was not such a fool that he would accept Kåñëa as an ordinary man and at the same time offer Him all devotional obeisances, knowing Him as the son of Devaké and Vasudeva. According to the Bhagavad-gétä, only by knowing the transcendental birth and activities of Kåñëa can one attain liberation by acquiring a spiritual form like Kåñëa's. There are five different kinds of liberation. One who merges into the spiritual aura of Kåñëa, known as the impersonal Brahman effulgence, does not fully develop his spiritual body. But one who fully develops his spiritual existence becomes an associate of Näräyaëa or Kåñëa in different spiritual abodes. One who enters into the abode of Näräyaëa develops a spiritual form exactly like Näräyaëa's (four-handed), and one who enters into the highest spiritual abode of Kåñëa, known as Goloka Våndävana, develops a spiritual form of two hands like Kåñëa's. Çaìkara, as an incarnation of Lord Çiva, knows all these spiritual existences, but he did not disclose them to his then Buddhist followers because it was impossible for them to know about the spiritual world. Lord Buddha preached that the void is the ultimate goal, so how could his followers understand spiritual variegatedness? Therefore Çaìkara said, brahma satyaà jagan mithyä, or, material variegatedness is false but spiritual variegatedness is fact. In the Padma Puräëa Lord Çiva has admitted that he had to preach the philosophy of mäyä, or illusion, in the Kali-yuga as another edition of the "void" philosophy of Buddha. He had to do this by the order of the Lord for specific reasons. He disclosed his real mind, however, by recommending that people worship Kåñëa, for no one can be saved simply by mental speculations composed of word jugglery and grammatical maneuvers. Çaìkara further instructs:

bhaja govindaà bhaja govindaà
bhaja govindam müòha-mate
sampräpte sannihite käle
na hi na hi rakñati òukåï-karaëe

"You intellectual fools, just worship Govinda, just worship Govinda, just worship Govinda. Your grammatical knowledge and word jugglery will not save you at the time of death."

SSR 3g: Of that terrifying river

—6—

Of that terrifying river
Of the battlefield of Kurukñetra,
Over which the Päëòavas victoriously crossed,
Bhéñma and Droëa were like the high banks,
Jayadratha like the river's water,
The King of Gändhära the blue water-lily,
Çalya the shark, Kåpa the current,
Karëa the mighty waves,
Açvatthämä and Vikarëa the dread alligators,
And Duryodhana the very whirlpool—
But Thou, O Kåñëa, wast the ferryman!

SSR 3h: May the spotless lotus of the Mahäbhärata

—7—

May the spotless lotus of the Mahäbhärata,
Which grows on the waters
Of the words of Vyäsa
And of which the Bhagavad-gétä
Is the irresistibly sweet fragrance
And its tales of heroes
The full-blown petals
Fully opened by the talk of Lord Hari,
Who destroys the sins
Of Kali-yuga,
And on which daily light
The nectar-seeking souls,
Like so many bees
Swarming joyously—
May this lotus of the Mahäbhärata
Bestow on us the highest good.

SSR 3i: Salutations to Lord Kåñëa

—8—

Salutations to Lord Kåñëa
The embodiment of supreme bliss,
By whose grace and compassion
The dumb become eloquent
And the lame scale mountains—
Him I salute!

Purport

Foolish followers of foolish speculators cannot understand the meaning of offering salutations to Lord Kåñëa, the embodiment of bliss. Çaìkara himself offered his salutations to Lord Kåñëa so that some of his intelligent followers might understand the real fact by the example set by their great master, Çaìkara, the incarnation of Lord Çiva. But there are many obstinate followers of Çaìkara who refuse to offer their salutations to Lord Kåñëa and instead mislead innocent persons by injecting materialism into the Bhagavad-gétä and confusing innocent readers by their commentaries, and consequently the readers never have the opportunity to become blessed by offering salutations to Lord Kåñëa, the cause of all causes. The greatest disservice to humanity is to keep mankind in darkness about the science of Kåñëa, or Kåñëa consciousness, by distorting the sense of the Gétä.

SSR 3j: Salutations to that supreme shining one

—9—

Salutations to that supreme shining one
Whom the creator Brahmä, Varuëa,
Indra, Rudra, Marut, and all divine beings
Praise with hymns,
Whose glories are sung
By the verses of the Vedas,
Of whom the singers of Säma sing
And of whose glories the Upaniñads
Proclaim in full choir,
Whom the yogis see
With their minds absorbed
In perfect meditation,
And of whom all the hosts
Of gods and demons
Know not the limitations.
To Him, the Supreme God, Kåñëa, be all salutations—
Him we salute! Him we salute! Him we salute!

Purport

By recitation of the ninth verse of his meditation, quoted from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çaìkara has indicated that Lord Kåñëa is worshipable by one and all, including himself. He gives hints to materialists, impersonalists, mental speculators, "void" philosophers, and all other candidates subjected to the punishment of material miseries—just offer salutations to Lord Kåñëa, who is worshiped by Brahmä, Çiva, Varuëa, Indra, and all other demigods. He has not mentioned, however, the name of Viñëu, because Viñëu is identical with Kåñëa. The Vedas and the Upaniñads are meant for understanding the process by which one can surrender unto Kåñëa. The yogés try to see Him (Kåñëa) within themselves by meditation. In other words, it is for all the demigods and demons who do not know where the ultimate end is that Çaìkara teaches, and he especially instructs the demons and the fools to offer salutations to Kåñëa and His words, the Bhagavad-gétä, by following in his footsteps. Only by such acts will the demons be benefited, not by misleading their innocent followers by so-called mental speculations or show-bottle meditations. Çaìkara directly offers salutations to Kåñëa, as if to show the fools, who are searching after light, that here is light like the sun. But the fallen demons are like owls that will not open their eyes on account of their fear of the sunlight itself. These owls will never open their eyes to see the sublime light of Kåñëa and His words, the Bhagavad-gétä. They will, however, comment on the Gétä with their closed owl-eyes to mislead their unfortunate readers and followers. Çaìkara, however, discloses the light to his less intelligent followers and shows that the Bhagavad-gétä and Kåñëa are the only source of light. This is all to teach the sincere seekers of truth to offer salutation to Lord Kåñëa and thus surrender unto Him without misgivings. That is the highest perfection of life, and that is the highest teaching of Çaìkara, the great learned scholar whose teachings drove the voidist philosophy of Buddha out of India, the land of knowledge. Oà tat sat.

[BTG 1967]

SSR 3k: The Kåñëa Consciousness Movement
Is the Genuine Vedic Way

The Kåñëa Consciousness Movement
Is the Genuine Vedic Way

After reading an article on the Krishna consciousness movement in the Los Angeles Times (January 11, 1970), Srila Prabhupada begins an unusual correspondence with Dr. J.F. Stall, Professor of Philosophy and of South Asian Languages at the University of California, Berkeley...

Excerpt from the Los Angeles Times Article

"Dr. J. F. Staal, Professor of Philosophy and Near Eastern [sic] Languages at UC Berkeley and an instructor in Indian philosophy, believes that the Krishna sect is an authentic Indian religion and that its adherents are sincere. He attributes the Society's rapid increase in members to the tendency of today's younger generation to reject organized churchgoing while at the same time searching for fulfillment of a belief in mysticism.

"He points out, however, that persons who turn away from Christianity, Muhammadanism, and Judaism have usually lost faith with the personal god of those religions and are looking for a mystical religion without absolutes.

" 'These people in the Krishna movement have turned to Hinduism, but, curiously, it is a cult that is highly personalistic,' Staal said. 'They accept a personal god, Krishna, and Christianity has that. I feel that they have transferred some of their Christian background to a Hindu sect.'

"He also feels that they spend too much time chanting to develop a philosophy. On these grounds he and others on the faculty turned down the request to grant credit for an experimental course in Krishna consciousness that will be taught during the winter quarter by Hans Kary, president of the sect's Berkeley temple."

SSR 3l: Çréla Prabhupäda's Letter to the Los Angeles Times
January 14, 1970

Çréla Prabhupäda's Letter to the Los Angeles Times
January 14, 1970

Editor
Los Angeles Times


Dear Sir:

With reference to your article in the Los Angeles Times dated Sunday, January 11, 1970, under the heading "Krishna Chant," I beg to point out that the Hindu religion is perfectly based on the personal conception of God, or Viñëu. The impersonal conception of God is a side issue, or one of the three features of God. The Absolute Truth is ultimately the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the Paramätmä conception is the localized aspect of His omnipresence, and the impersonal conception is the aspect of His greatness and eternity. But all these combined together make the Complete Whole.

Dr. J. F. Staal's statement that the Kåñëa cult is a combination of Christian and Hindu religion, as if something manufactured by concoction, is not correct. If Christian, Muhammadan, or Buddhist religions are personal, that is quite welcome. But the Kåñëa religion has been personal from a time long, long ago when Christian, Muhammadan, and Buddhist religions had not yet come into existence. According to the Vedic conception, religion is basically made by the personal God as His laws. Religion cannot be manufactured by man or anyone except God superior to man. Religion is the law of God only.

Unfortunately, all the swamis who came before me in this country stressed the impersonal aspect of God, without sufficient knowledge of God's personal aspect. In the Bhagavad-gétä, therefore, it is said that only less intelligent persons consider that God is originally impersonal but assumes a form when He incarnates. The Kåñëa philosophy, however, based on the authority of the Vedas, is that originally the Absolute Truth is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. His plenary expansion is present in everyone's heart in His localized aspect, and the impersonal Brahman effulgence is the transcendental light and heat distributed everywhere.

In the Bhagavad-gétä it is clearly said that the aim of the Vedic way of searching out the Absolute Truth is to find the personal God. One who is satisfied only with the other aspects of the Absolute Truth, namely the Paramätmä feature or the Brahman feature, is to be considered possessed of a poor fund of knowledge. Recently we have published our Çré Éçopaniñad, a Vedic literature, and in this small booklet we have thoroughly discussed this point.

As far as the Hindu religion is concerned, there are millions of Kåñëa temples in India, and there is not a single Hindu who does not worship Kåñëa. Therefore, this Kåñëa consciousness movement is not a concocted idea. We invite all scholars, philosophers, religionists, and members of the general public to understand this movement by critical study. And if one does so seriously, one will understand the sublime position of this great movement.

The chanting process is also authorized. Professor Staal's feeling of disgust in the matter of constant chanting of the holy name of Kåñëa is a definite proof of his lack of knowledge in this authorized movement of Kåñëa consciousness. Instead of turning down the request to give Kary's course credit, he and all other learned professors of the University of California at Berkeley should patiently hear about the truth of this authorized movement so much needed at present in godless society. [Credit for the course was later established.] This is the only movement which can save the confused younger generation. I shall invite all responsible guardians of this country to understand this transcendental movement and then give us all honest facilities to spread it for everyone's benefit.

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami
Spiritual Master of the
Hare Kåñëa Movement

SSR 3m: The Exchange Between Çréla Prabhupäda and Dr. Staal

The Exchange Between Çréla Prabhupäda and Dr. Staal

January 23, 1970

Swami A.C. Bhaktivedanta

Dear Swamiji:

Thank you very much for sending me a copy of your letter to the Los Angeles Times, now also published in the Daily Californian. I think you will agree with me that apart from publicity, little is gained by discussing religious or philosophic issues through interviews and letters in the press; but allow me to make two brief observations.

First, I know that devotion to Kåñëa is old (though definitely not as old as the Vedas) and has never been influenced by Christianity, Islam, or Judaism (I never referred to Buddhism in this connection). The differences between the personal and impersonal are relatively vague, but adopting this distinction for simplicity, I expressed surprise at seeing people who have grown up in a Western culture which stresses the personal take to an Indian cult which does the same. I am less surprised when people who are dissatisfied with Western monotheism take to an Indian philosophy which stresses an impersonal absolute.

Second, I never expressed nor felt disgust at the chanting of the name of Kåñëa. I am not only not irritated at it (like some people), but I rather like it. But it is an indisputable fact that the Bhagavad-gétä (not to mention the Vedas) does not require such constant chanting. The Gétä deals with quite different subjects, which I treat at some length in my courses on the philosophies of India.

Thanking you,

Yours sincerely,
J. F. Staal
Professor of Philosophy and of South Asian Languages

January 30, 1970

J. F. Staal
Professor of Philosophy and of South Asian Languages
University of California
Berkeley, California


My dear Professor Staal:

I thank you very much for your kind letter dated January 23, 1970. In the last paragraph of your letter you have mentioned that you are not irritated at the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra (like some people), but rather like it. This has given me much satisfaction, and I am sending herewith a copy of our magazine, Back to Godhead, issue number 28, in which you will find how the students [at a program at Ohio State University] liked this chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra, although all of them were neophytes to this cult of chanting. Actually this chanting is very pleasing to the heart and is the best means of infusing spiritual consciousness, or Kåñëa consciousness, into the hearts of people in general.

This is the easiest process of spiritual realization and is recommended in the Vedas. In the Båhan-näradéya Puräëa it is clearly stated that it is only chanting of the holy name of Hari [Kåñëa] that can save people from the problems of materialistic existence, and there is no other alternative, no other alternative, no other alternative in this age of Kali.

Western culture is monotheistic, but Westerners are being misled by impersonal Indian speculation. The young people of the West are frustrated because they are not diligently taught about monotheism. They are not satisfied with this process of teaching and understanding. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is a boon to them, because they are being really trained to understand Western monotheism under the authoritative Vedic system. We do not simply theoretically discuss; rather, we learn by the prescribed method of Vedic regulations.

But I am surprised to see that in the last paragraph of your letter you say, "It is an indisputable fact that the Bhagavad-gétä (not to mention the Vedas) does not require such constant chanting." I think that you have missed the following verse in the Bhagavad-gétä, apart from many other similar verses:

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate
[Bhagavad-gétä 9.14]

The engagement of the great souls, freed from delusion and perfect in their realization of God, is described here: satataà kértayanto mäà—they are always (satataà) chanting (kértayantaù) My glories and—nitya-yuktä upäsate—always worshiping Me (Kåñëa).

So I do not know how you can say "indisputable." And, if you want references from the Vedas, I can give you many. In the Vedas, the chief transcendental vibration oàkära is also Kåñëa. Praëava oàkära is the divine substance of the Vedas. Following the Vedas means chanting the Vedic mantras, and no Vedic mantra is complete without oàkära. In the Mäëòükya Upaniñad, oàkära is stated to be the most auspicious sound representation of the Supreme Lord. This is also confirmed again in the Atharva Veda. Oàkara is the sound representation of the Supreme Lord and is therefore the principal word in the Vedas. In this connection, the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, says, praëavaù sarva-vedeñu: "I am the syllable oà in all the Vedic mantras." [Bg. 7.8]

Furthermore, in Bhagavad-gétä, Chapter Fifteen, verse 15, Kåñëa says, "I am seated in everyone's heart. By all the Vedas, I am to be known; I am the compiler of Vedänta, and I know Veda as it is." The Supreme Lord, seated in everyone's heart, is described in both the Muëòaka and Çvetäçvatara Upaniñads: dvä suparëä sayujä sakhäyä... The Supreme Lord and the individual soul are sitting in the body like two friendly birds in a tree. One bird is eating the fruits of the tree, or reactions of material activities, and the other bird, the Supersoul, is witnessing.

The goal of Vedantic study, therefore, is to know the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. This point is stressed in the Bhagavad-gétä, Chapter Eight, verse 13, where it is stated that by the mystic yoga process, ultimately vibrating the sacred syllable oà, one attains to His supreme spiritual planet. In the Vedänta-sütras, which you have certainly read, the Fourth Chapter, adhikaraëa 4, sütra 22, states positively, anävåttiù çabdät: "By sound vibration one becomes liberated." By devotional service, by understanding well the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one can go to His abode and never come back again to this material condition. How is it possible? The answer is, simply by chanting His name constantly.

This is accepted by the exemplary disciple, Arjuna, who has perfectly learned the conclusion of spiritual science from the yogeçvara, the master of mystic knowledge, Kåñëa. Recognizing Kåñëa to be the Supreme Brahman, Arjuna addresses Him, sthäne håñékeça...: "The world becomes joyful hearing Your name, and thus do all become attached to You." [Bg. 11.36] The process of chanting is herein authorized as the direct means of contacting the Supreme Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead. Simply by chanting the holy name Kåñëa, the soul is attracted by the Supreme Person, Kåñëa, to go home, back to Godhead.

In the Närada Païcarätra it is stated that all the Vedic rituals, mantras, and understanding are compressed into the eight words Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare. Similarly, in the Kali-santaraëa Upaniñad it is stated that these sixteen words, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, are especially meant for counteracting the degrading and contaminating influence of this materialistic age of Kali.

All these points are elaborately presented in my book Teachings of Lord Caitanya.

The process of chanting is, therefore, not only the sublime method for practical perfection of life but the authorized Vedic principle inaugurated by the greatest Vedic scholar and devotee, Lord Caitanya (whom we consider an incarnation of Kåñëa). We are simply following in His authorized footsteps.

The scope of the Kåñëa consciousness movement is universal. The process for regaining one's original spiritual status of eternal life, full with bliss and knowledge, is not abstract, dry theorizing. Spiritual life is not described in the Vedas as theoretical, dry, or impersonal. The Vedas aim at the inculcation of pure love of God only, and this harmonious conclusion is practically realized by the Kåñëa consciousness movement, or by chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra.

As the goal of spiritual realization is only one, love of God, so the Vedas stand as a single comprehensive whole in the matter of transcendental understanding. Only the incomplete views of various parties apart from the bona fide Vedic lines of teaching give a rupturous appearance to the Bhagavad-gétä. The reconciliative factor adjusting all apparently diverse propositions of the Vedas is the essence of the Veda, or Kåñëa consciousness (love of God).

Thanking you once again,

Yours sincerely,
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

February 8, 1970

Swami A.C. Bhaktivedanta

Dear Swamiji:

Thank you very much for your kindness in sending me your long and interesting letter of January 30, together with the last issue of Back to Godhead. So far I have had a few discussions with members of your society here, but they were not entirely satisfactory from my point of view. But now I have your much more authoritative letter, whereby the discussion moves to a higher level.

And yet, I am afraid, you have not convinced me that all the scriptures you quote prescribe only chanting of the name of Kåñëa. Let me refer only to the most important ones.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.14], kértayantaù need not mean chanting of the name of Kåñëa. It may mean glorifying, chanting, reciting, talking, and refer to songs, hymns, descriptions, or conversations. The commentators take it that way. Çaìkara in his commentary merely repeats the word, but Anandagiri in his vyäkhyä classes kértana as vedänta-çravaëaà praëava-japaç ca, "listening to the Vedänta and muttering oà" (that the Vedic oà is Kåñëa is said in the Bhagavad-gétä, where Kåñëa is also identified with many other things, and which is småti, but not in the Vedas, which are çruti). Another commentator, Hanumän, in his Paiçäca-bhäñya, says that kértayantaù merely means bhäñamänaù—"talking [about]."

More important, I think, than the precise meaning of this word, is that the entire verse does not require that everyone always engage in kértana, but merely states that some great souls do so. This is obvious from the next verse, which states that anye, "others," engage in jïäna-yajïena... yajanto mäm, "worshiping me... with the worship of knowledge." The Bhagavad-gétä is broad-minded and tolerant of a variety of religious approaches, although it also stresses one aspect above all others (i.e., sarva-phala-tyäga).*

Finally, in the last sütra of the Vedänta-sütra, anävåttiù çabdät..., çabda refers to the scripture or to the revelation of the Vedas, as is clear from the context and from the commentators. Çaìkara quotes a number of texts (ending with ity ädi-çabdebhyaù, "according to these çabdas") to support this, i.e., to support the statement that "according to the scripture there is no return." He also refers to çabda in this sütra by saying manträrtha-vädädi..., "mantras, descriptions, etc." Väcaspati Miçra in the Bhämati supports this and clarifies it further by adding that a contrary view is çruti-småti-virodhaù, "in conflict with the småti and the çruti."

Thanking you once again for your kind attention.

Yours very sincerely,
J. F. Staal

February 15, 1970

J. F. Staal
Professor of Philosophy and of South Asian Languages

My dear Dr. Staal:

I am very glad to receive your letter dated Sunday, February 8, 1970. I am very much pleased also to note the contents.

Regarding convincing you that all scriptures prescribe chanting of the name of Kåñëa, I can simply present the authority of Lord Caitanya. Lord Caitanya recommended, kértanéyaù sadä hariù ["Hari, Kåñëa, is constantly to be praised" (Çikñäñöaka 3). Similarly, Madhväcärya quotes, vede rämäyaëe caiva hariù sarvatra géyate ["Hari is sung about everywhere in the Vedas and Rämäyaëa"]. Similarly, in the Bhagavad-gétä [15.15] the Lord says, vedaiç ca sarvair aham eva vedyaù ("By all the Vedas, I am to be known").

In this way we find all the scriptures aiming at the Supreme Person. In the Åg Veda [1.22.20] the mantra is oà tad viñëoù paramaà padaà sadä paçyanti sürayaù ("The demigods are always looking to that supreme abode of Viñëu"). The whole Vedic process, therefore, is to understand Lord Viñëu, and any scripture is directly or indirectly chanting the glories of the Supreme Lord, Viñëu.

Regarding the Bhagavad-gétä, verse 9.14, kértayantaù certainly means glorifying, chanting, reciting, and talking, as you have said; but glorifying, chanting, or reciting about whom? It is certainly Kåñëa. The word used in this connection is mäm ["Me"]. Therefore, we do not disagree when a person glorifies Kåñëa, as Çukadeva did in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. This is also kértanam. The highest among all Vedic literatures is the proper place for such glorification of the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, and this is to be well understood from the verse:

nigama-kalpa-taror galitaà phalaà
çuka-mukhäd amåta-drava-saàyutam
pibata bhägavataà rasam älayaà
muhur aho rasikä bhuvi bhävukäù

"O expert and thoughtful men, relish Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the mature fruit of the desire tree of Vedic literatures. It emanated from the lips of Çré Çukadeva Gosvämé. Therefore this fruit has become even more tasteful, although its nectarean juice was already relishable for all, including liberated souls." [Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.1.3]

It is said that Mahäräja Parékñit attained salvation simply by hearing, and similarly Çukadeva Gosvämé attained salvation simply by chanting. In our devotional service there are nine different methods for achieving the same goal, love of Godhead, and the first process is hearing. This hearing process is called çruti. The next process is chanting. The chanting process is småti. We accept both çruti and småti simultaneously. We consider çruti the mother and småti the sister, because a child hears from the mother and then again learns from the sister by description.

Çruti and småti are two parallel lines. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé therefore says:

çruti-småti-puräëädi-
païcarätra-vidhià vinä
aikäntiké harer bhaktir
utpätäyaiva kalpate
[Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.2.101]

That is, without references to çruti, småti, Puräëas, and Païcarätras, unadulterated devotional service is never achieved. Therefore, anyone who shows a devotional ecstasy without reference to the çästras [Vedic scriptures] simply creates disturbances. On the other hand, if we simply stick to the çrutés, then we become veda-väda-ratäù,* who are not very much appreciated in the Bhagavad-gétä.

Therefore Bhagavad-gétä, although småti, is the essence of all Vedic scripture, sarvopaniñado gävaù.* It is just like a cow which is delivering the milk, or the essence of all the Vedas and Upaniñads, and all the äcäryas, including Çaìkaräcärya, accept the Bhagavad-gétä as such. Therefore you cannot deny the authority of the Bhagavad-gétä because it is småti; that view is çruti-småti-virodhaù, "in conflict with the småti and the çruti," as you have correctly said.

Regarding Änandagiri's quotation that kértana means vedänta-çravaëaà praëava japaç ca ["listening to the Vedänta and muttering oà"], the knower of Vedänta is Kåñëa, and He is the compiler of Vedänta. He is veda-vit and vedänta-kåt. So where is there a greater opportunity for vedänta-çravaëa than to hear it from Kåñëa?

Regarding the next verse, in which it is mentioned that jïäna-yajïena... yajanto mäm, the object of worship is Kåñëa, as indicated by mäm ["Me"]. The process is described in the Éçopaniñad, mantra 11:

vidyäà cävidyäà ca yas
tad vedobhayaà saha
avidyayä måtyuà tértvä
vidyayämåtam açnute

"Only one who can learn the process of nescience and that of transcendental knowledge side by side can transcend the influence of repeated birth and death and enjoy the full blessings of immortality."

The culture of vidyä, or transcendental knowledge, is essential for the human being, otherwise the culture of avidyä, or nescience, binds him to conditional existence on the material platform. Materialistic existence means the pursuit or culture of sense gratification, and this kind of knowledge of sense gratification (avidyä) means advancement of repeated birth and death. Those who are absorbed in such knowledge cannot learn any lesson from the laws of nature, and they do the same things over repeatedly, being enamored of the beauty of illusory things. Vidyä, or factual knowledge, on the other hand, means to know thoroughly the process of nescient activities while at the same time culturing transcendental science and thereby undeviatingly following the path of liberation.

Liberation is the enjoyment of the full blessings of immortality. This immortality is enjoyed in the eternal kingdom of God (sambhüty-amåtam açnute), the region of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and is the result obtained by worshiping the Supreme Lord, the cause of all causes, sambhavät. So in this way real knowledge, vidyä, means to worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa; that is jïäna-yajïena, the worship of knowledge.

This jïäna-yajïena... yajanto mäm is the perfection of knowledge, as stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.19]:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me [Kåñëa], knowing Me to be the cause of all causes, and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare."

If one has not yet come to this conclusion of knowledge and simply indulges in dry speculation without Kåñëa, then his hard speculative labor is something like beating empty husks of grain. The unhulled rice and the empty husks of rice look very much the same. One who knows how to get the grain out of the unhulled rice is wise, but one who beats on the empty husk, thinking to get some result, is simply wasting his labor uselessly. Similarly, if one studies the Vedas without finding the goal of the Vedas, Kåñëa, he simply wastes his valuable time.

So to cultivate knowledge for worshiping Kåñëa culminates after many, many births and deaths when one actually becomes wise. When one becomes wise in this way, he surrenders to Kåñëa, recognizing Him at last to be the cause of all causes and all that is. That sort of great soul is very rare. So those who have surrendered to Kåñëa life and soul are rare sudurlabha mahätmäs. They are not ordinary mahätmäs.

By the grace of Lord Caitanya that highest perfectional status of life is being distributed very freely. The effect is also very encouraging; otherwise, how are boys and girls without any background of Vedic culture quickly occupying the posts of rare mahätmäs simply by vibrating this transcendental sound, Hare Kåñëa? And simply on the basis of this chanting, the majority of them (those who are very sincere) are steady in devotional service and are not falling down to the four principles of material sinful life, namely (1) meat-eating, (2) illicit sexual connection, (3) taking of intoxicants, including coffee, tea, and tobacco, and (4) gambling. And that is the last sütra of the Vedänta-sütra, i.e., anävåttiù çabdät ["By sound vibration one becomes liberated"].

One has to learn by the result (phalena paricéyate). Our students are ordered to act like this, and they are not falling down. That they are remaining on the platform of pure spiritual life without hankering to culture the above principles of avidyä, or sense gratification, is the test of their proper understanding of the Vedas. They do not come back to the material platform, because they are relishing the nectarean fruit of love of God.

Sarva-phala-tyäga ["renunciation of all the fruits of one's work"] is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä by the Lord Himself in the words sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja: "Give up everything and simply surrender unto Me [Kåñëa]." The Hare Kåñëa mantra means "O Supreme Energy of Kåñëa and O Lord Kåñëa, please engage me in Your eternal service." So we have given up everything and are simply engaged in the service of the Lord. What Kåñëa orders us to do is our only engagement. We have given up all resultant actions of karma, jïäna, and yoga; and that is the stage of pure devotional service, bhaktir uttamä.

Yours sincerely,
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

February 25, 1970

Swami A.C. Bhaktivedanta
Founder-Äcärya
International Society for Krishna Consciousness

Dear Swamiji:

Thank you very much for your very interesting letter of February 15, 1970, with enclosure.

I am afraid that whenever you quote a passage purporting to show that only the chanting of the name Kåñëa is required, I can quote another one which requires something else, adding, yadi çloko 'pi pramäëam, ayam api çlokaù pramäëaà bhavitum arhati: "If mere verses are authoritative, this verse also ought to be regarded as authoritative." And there may be no end to this in the foreseeable future, as Pataïjali also says, mahän hi çabdasya prayoga-viñayaù: "For vast is the domain for the use of words."

Yours very sincerely,
J. F. Staal

3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90034

April 24, 1970

Dear Dr. Staal:

I beg to thank you very much for your kind letter dated February 25, 1970. I am sorry that I could not reply to your letter earlier because I was a little busy in the matter of purchasing a new church estate at the above address. We have secured a very nice place for a separate temple, lecture room, my quarters, and the devotees' residential quarters, all together in a nice place with all the modern amenities.

I beg to request you to visit this place at your convenience, and if you kindly let me know a day before, my students will be very glad to receive you properly.

Regarding our correspondence, actually this quotation and counter-quotation cannot solve the problem. In a court both the learned lawyers quote from law books, but that is not the solution to the case. The determination of the case is the judgment of the presiding judge. So argument cannot bring us to a conclusion.

The scriptural quotations are sometimes contradictory, and every philosopher has a different opinion, because without putting forward a different thesis, no one can become a famous philosopher. It is therefore difficult to arrive at the right conclusion. The conclusion is, as above mentioned, to accept the judgment of authority. We follow the authority of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who is nondifferent from Kåñëa, and His version according to Vedic scripture is that in this age this chanting is the only solution for all problems of life. And that is actually being shown by practical experience.

Recently there was a big procession of our students in Berkeley on the Advent Day of Lord Caitanya, and the public has remarked as follows: "This crowd of men is not like others, who assemble to break windows and create havoc." This is also confirmed by the police in the following words: "Members of the Kåñëa consciousness movement cooperated fully with the police, and their efforts to maintain peaceful order throughout the parade were so successful that only minimal police involvement was required."

Similarly, in Detroit there was a big peace march, and our men were appreciated as "angels" in the crowd. So this Kåñëa consciousness movement is actually needed at the present moment as the panacea for all kinds of problems in human society.

Other quotations will not act very appreciably at this time. In a drugstore there may be many medicines, and all may be genuine, but what is required is that an experienced physician prescribe medicine for a particular patient. We cannot say in this case, "This is also medicine, and this is also medicine." No. The medicine which is effective for a particular person is the medicine for him—phalena paricéyate.

Yours very sincerely,
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

SSR 3n: Final Note by Çréla Prabhupäda

Final Note by Çréla Prabhupäda

In a court of justice two lawyers put forward their respective relevant arguments taken from the authorized law books to decide a point, but it is up to the judge to decide the case in favor of one of the litigants. When the opposing lawyers put forward their arguments, both of them are legal and bona fide, but the judgment is given as to which argument is applicable to the particular case.

Lord Caitanya gives His judgment on the authority of çästras that the chanting of the holy names of the Lord is the only means to elevate one to the transcendental platform, and actually we can see it is effective. Each and every one of our students who has seriously taken to this process may be examined individually, and any impartial judge will find it easy to see that they have advanced in their transcendental realization further than any philosophers, religionists, yogés, karmés, etc.

We have to accept everything favorable to the circumstances. Rejection of other methods in a particular circumstance does not mean that the rejected ones are not bona fide. But for the time being, taking into consideration the age, time, and object, methods are sometimes rejected even though bona fide. We have to test everything by its practical result. By such a test, in this age the constant chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra undoubtedly proves very effective.

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

SSR 3o: Kåñëa Consciousness:
Hindu Cult or Divine Culture?

Kåñëa Consciousness:
Hindu Cult or Divine Culture?

“Sometimes Indians both inside and outside of India think that we are preaching the Hindu religion, but actually we are not.... People should not think that we are preaching a sectarian religion. No. We are simply preaching how to love God.... We are giving a spiritual culture that can solve all the problems of life, and therefore it is being accepted all over the world.”

There is a misconception that the Kåñëa consciousness movement represents the Hindu religion. In fact, however, Kåñëa consciousness is in no way a faith or religion that seeks to defeat other faiths or religions. Rather, it is an essential cultural movement for the entire human society and does not consider any particular sectarian faith. This cultural movement is especially meant to educate people in how they can love God.

Sometimes Indians both inside and outside of India think that we are preaching the Hindu religion, but actually we are not. One will not find the word Hindu in the Bhagavad-gétä. Indeed, there is no such word as Hindu in the entire Vedic literature. This word has been introduced by the Muslims from provinces next to India, such as Afghanistan, Baluchistan, and Persia. There is a river called Sindhu bordering the north western provinces of India, and since the Muslims there could not pronounce Sindhu properly, they instead called the river Hindu, and the inhabitants of this tract of land they called Hindus. In India, according to the Vedic language, the Europeans are called mlecchas or yavanas. Similarly, Hindu is a name given by the Muslims.

India's actual culture is described in the Bhagavad-gétä, where it is stated that according to the different qualities or modes of nature there are different types of men, who are generally classified into four social orders and four spiritual orders. This system of social and spiritual division is known as varëäçrama-dharma. The four varëas, or social orders, are brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya. and çüdra. The four äçramas, or spiritual orders, are brahmacarya, gåhastha, vänaprastha, and sannyäsa. The varëäçrama system is described in the Vedic scriptures known as the Puräëas. The goal of this institution of Vedic culture is to educate every man for advancement in knowledge of Kåñëa, or God. That is the entire Vedic program.

When Lord Caitanya talked with the great devotee Rämänanda Räya, the Lord asked him, "What is the basic principle of human life?" Rämänanda Räya answered that human civilization begins when varëäçrama-dharma is accepted. Before coming to the standard of varëäçrama-dharma there is no question of human civilization. Therefore, the Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying to establish this right system of human civilization, which is known as Kåñëa consciousness, or daiva-varëäçrama—divine culture.

In India, the varëäçrama system has now been taken in a perverted way, and thus a man born in the family of a brähmaëa (the highest social order) claims that he should be accepted as a brähmaëa. But this claim is not accepted by the çästra (scripture). One's forefather may have been a brähmaëa according to gotra, or the family hereditary order, but real varëäçrama-dharma is based on the factual quality one has attained, regardless of birth or heredity. Therefore, we are not preaching the present-day system of the Hindus, especially those who are under the influence of Çaìkaräcärya, for Çaìkaräcärya taught that the Absolute Truth is impersonal, and thus he indirectly denied the existence of God.

Çaìkaräcärya's mission was special; he appeared in order to reestablish the Vedic influence after the influence of Buddhism. Because Buddhism was patronized by Emperor Açoka, twenty-three hundred years ago the Buddhist religion practically pervaded all of India. According to the Vedic literature, Buddha was an incarnation of Kåñëa who had a special power and who appeared for a special purpose. His system of thought, or faith, was accepted widely, but Buddha rejected the authority of the Vedas. While Buddhism was spreading, the Vedic culture was stopped both in India and in other places. Therefore, since Çaìkaräcärya's only aim was to drive away Buddha's system of philosophy, he introduced a system called Mäyäväda.

Strictly speaking, Mäyäväda philosophy is atheism, for it is a process in which one imagines that there is God. This Mäyäväda system of philosophy has been existing since time immemorial. The present Indian system of religion or culture is based on the Mäyäväda philosophy of Çaìkaräcärya, which is a compromise with Buddhist philosophy. According to Mäyäväda philosophy there actually is no God, or if God exists, He is impersonal and all-pervading and can therefore be imagined in any form. This conclusion is not in accord with the Vedic literature. That literature names many demigods, who are worshiped for different purposes, but in every case the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, Viñëu, is accepted as the supreme controller. That is real Vedic culture.

The philosophy of Kåñëa consciousness does not deny the existence of God and the demigods, but Mäyäväda philosophy denies both; it maintains that neither the demigods nor God exist. For the Mäyävädés, ultimately all is zero. They say that one may imagine any authority—whether Viñëu, Durgä, Lord Çiva, or the sun-god—because these are the demigods generally worshiped in society. But the Mäyäväda philosophy does not in fact accept the existence of any of them. The Mäyävädés say that because one cannot concentrate one's mind on the impersonal Brahman, one may imagine any of these forms. This is a new system, called païcopäsanä. It was introduced by Çaìkaräcärya, but the Bhagavad-gétä does not teach any such doctrines, and therefore they are not authoritative.

The Bhagavad-gétä accepts the existence of the demigods. The demigods are described in the Vedas, and one cannot deny their existence, but they are not to be understood or worshiped according to the way of Çaìkaräcärya. The worship of demigods is rejected in the Bhagavad-gétä. The Gétä [7.20] clearly states:

kämais tais tair håta jïänäù
prapadyante 'nya-devatäù
taà taà niyamam ästhäya
prakåtyä niyatäù svayä

"Those whose minds are distorted by material desires surrender unto demigods and follow the particular rules and regulations of worship according to their own natures." Furthermore, in Bhagavad-gétä [2.44] Lord Kåñëa states:

bhogaiçvarya-prasaktänäà
tayäpahåta-cetasäm
vyavasäyätmikä buddhiù
samädhau na vidhéyate

"In the minds of those who are too attached to sense enjoyment and material opulence, and who are bewildered by such things, the resolute determination for devotional service does not take place." Those who are pursuing the various demigods have been described as håta jïänäù, which means "those who have lost their sense." That is also further explained in Bhagavad-gétä [7.23]:

antavat tu phalaà teñäà
tad bhavaty alpa-medhasäm
devän deva-yajo yänti
mad-bhaktä yänti mäm api

"Men of small intelligence worship the demigods, and their fruits are limited and temporary. Those who worship the demigods go to the planets of the demigods, but My devotees reach My supreme abode." The rewards given by the demigods are temporary, because any material facility must act in connection with the temporary body. Whatever material facilities one gets, whether by modern scientific methods or by deriving benedictions from the demigods, will be finished with the body. But spiritual advancement will never be finished.

People should not think that we are preaching a sectarian religion. No. We are simply preaching how to love God. There are many theories about the existence of God. The atheist, for example, will never believe in God. Atheists like Professor Jacques Monod, who won the Nobel prize, declare that everything is chance (a theory already put forward long ago by atheistic philosophers of India such as Cärväka). Then other philosophies, such as the karma-mémäàsä philosophy, accept that if one goes on doing his work nicely and honestly, automatically the result will come, without need for one to refer to God. For evidence, the proponents of such theories cite the argument that if one is diseased with an infection and takes medicine to counteract it, the disease will be neutralized. But our argument in this connection is that even if one gives a man the best medicine, he still may die. The results are not always predictable. Therefore, there is a higher authority, daiva-netreëa, a supreme director. Otherwise, how is it that the son of a rich and pious man becomes a hippie in the street or that a man who works very hard and becomes rich is told by his doctor, "Now you may not eat any food, but only barley water"?

The karma-mémäàsä theory holds that the world is going on without the supreme direction of God. Such philosophies say that everything takes place by lust (käma-haitukam). By lust a man becomes attracted to a woman, and by chance there is sex, and the woman becomes pregnant. There is actually no plan to make the woman pregnant, but by a natural sequence when a man and a woman unite, a result is produced. The atheistic theory, which is described in the Sixteenth Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä as asuric, or demoniac, is that actually everything is going on in this way, because of chance and resulting from natural attraction. This demoniac theory supports the idea that if one wants to avoid children, he may use a contraceptive method.

Actually, however, there is a great plan for everything—the Vedic plan. The Vedic literature gives directions regarding how men and women should unite, how they should beget children, and what the purpose of sex life is. Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä that sex life sanctioned by the Vedic order, or sex life under the direction of the Vedic rules and regulations, is bona fide and is acceptable to Him. But chance sex life is not acceptable. If by chance one is sexually attracted and there are children, they are called varëa-saìkara, unwanted population. That is the way of the lower animals; it is not acceptable for humans. For humans, there is a plan. We cannot accept the theory that there is no plan for human life or that everything is born of chance and material necessity.

Çaìkaräcärya's theory that there is no God and that one can go on with his work and imagine God in any form just to keep peace and tranquillity in society is also more or less based on this idea of chance and necessity. Our way, however, which is completely different, is based on authority. It is this divine varëäçrama-dharma that Kåñëa recommends, not the caste system as it is understood today. This modern caste system is now condemned in India also, and it should be condemned, for the classification of different types of men according to birth is not the Vedic or divine caste system.

There are many classes of men in society—some men are engineers, some are medical practitioners, some are chemists, tradesmen, businessmen, and so on. These varieties of classes are not to be determined by birth, however, but by quality. No such thing as the caste-by-birth system is sanctioned by the Vedic literature, nor do we accept it. We have nothing to do with the caste system, which is also at present being rejected by the public in India. Rather, we give everyone the chance to become a brähmaëa and thus attain the highest status of life.

Because at the present moment there is a scarcity of brähmaëas, spiritual guides, and kñatriyas (administrative men), and because the entire world is being ruled by çüdras, or men of the manual laborer class, there are many discrepancies in society. It is to mitigate all these discrepancies that we have taken to this Kåñëa consciousness movement. If the brähmaëa class is actually reestablished, the other orders of social well-being will automatically follow, just as when the brain is perfectly in order, the other parts of the body, such as the arms, the belly, and the legs, all act very nicely.

The ultimate goal of this movement is to educate people in how to love God. Caitanya Mahäprabhu approves the conclusion that the highest perfection of human life is to learn how to love God. The Kåñëa consciousness movement has nothing to do with the Hindu religion or any system of religion. No Christian gentleman will be interested in changing his faith from Christian to Hindu. Similarly, no Hindu gentleman of culture will be ready to change to the Christian faith. Such changing is for men who have no particular social status. But everyone will be interested in understanding the philosophy and science of God and taking it seriously. One should clearly understand that the Kåñëa consciousness movement is not preaching the so-called Hindu religion. We are giving a spiritual culture that can solve all the problems of life, and therefore it is being accepted all over the world.

SSR 4: Understanding Kåñëa and Christ

IV. Understanding Kåñëa and Christ

SSR 4a: Kåñëa or Christ—The Name Is the Same

Kåñëa or Christ—The Name Is the Same

In 1974, near ISKCON's center in Frankfurt am Main, West Germany, Çréla Prabhupäda and several of his disciples take a morning walk with Father Emmanuel Jungclaussen, a Benedictine monk from Niederalteich Monastery. Noticing that Çréla Prabhupäda is carrying meditation beads similar to the rosary, Father Emmanuel explains that he also chants a constant prayer: "Lord Jesus Christ, be merciful unto us." The following conversation ensues.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is the meaning of the word Christ?

Father Emmanuel: Christ comes from the Greek word Christos, meaning "the anointed one."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Christos is the Greek version of the word Kåñëa.

Father Emmanuel: This is very interesting.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When an Indian person calls on Kåñëa, he often says, "Kåñöa." Kåñöa is a Sanskrit word meaning "attraction." So when we address God as "Christ," "Kåñöa," or "Kåñëa," we indicate the same all-attractive Supreme Personality of Godhead. When Jesus said, "Our Father, who an in heaven, sanctified be Thy name," that name of God was "Kåñöa" or "Kåñëa." Do you agree?

Father Emmanuel: I think Jesus, as the son of God, has revealed to us the actual name of God: Christ. We can call God "Father," but if we want to address Him by His actual name, we have to say "Christ."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. "Christ" is another way of saying Kåñöa, and "Kåñöa" is another way of pronouncing Kåñëa, the name of God. Jesus said that one should glorify the name of God, but yesterday I heard one theologian say that God has no name—that we can call Him only "Father." A son may call his father "Father," but the father also has a specific name. Similarly, "God" is the general name of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, whose specific name is Kåñëa. Therefore whether you call God "Christ," "Kåñöa," or "Kåñëa," ultimately you are addressing the same Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Father Emmanuel: Yes, if we speak of God's actual name, then we must say, "Christos." In our religion, we have the Trinity: the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit. We believe we can know the name of God only by revelation from the Son of God. Jesus Christ revealed the name of the father, and therefore we take the name Christ as the revealed name of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Actually, it doesn't matter—Kåñëa or Christ—the name is the same. The main point is to follow the injunctions of the Vedic scriptures that recommend chanting the name of God in this age. The easiest way is to chant the mahä-mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Räma and Kåñëa are names of God, and Hare is the energy of God. So when we chant the mahä-mantra, we address God together with His energy. This energy is of two kinds, the spiritual and the material. At present we are in the clutches of the material energy. Therefore we pray to Kåñëa that He may kindly deliver us from the service of the material energy and accept us into the service of the spiritual energy. That is our whole philosophy. Hare Kåñëa means, "O energy of God, O God [Kåñëa], please engage me in Your service." It is our nature to render service. Somehow or other we have come to the service of material things, but when this service is transformed into the service of the spiritual energy, then our life is perfect. To practice bhakti-yoga [loving service to God] means to become free from designations like "Hindu," "Muslim," "Christian," this or that, and simply to serve God. We have created Christian, Hindu, and Muhammadan religions, but when we come to a religion without designations, in which we don't think we are Hindus or Christians or Muhammadans, then we can speak of pure religion, or bhakti.

Father Emmanuel: Mukti?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, bhakti. When we speak of bhakté, mukti [liberation from material miseries] is included. Without bhakti there is no mukti, but if we act on the platform of bhakti, then mukti is included. We learn this from the Bhagavad-gétä [14.26]:

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down under any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman."

Father Emmanuel: Is Brahman Kåñëa?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is Parabrahman. Brahman is realized in three aspects: as impersonal Brahman, as localized Paramätmä, and as personal Brahman. Kåñëa is personal, and He is the Supreme Brahman, for God is ultimately a person. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.2.11], this is confirmed:

vadanti tat tattva-vidas
tattvam yaj jïänam advayam
brahmeti paramätmeti
bhagavän iti çabdyate

"Learned transcendentalists who know the Absolute Truth call this nondual substance Brahman, Paramätmä or Bhagavän." The feature of the Supreme Personality is the ultimate realization of God. He has all six opulences in full: He is the strongest, the richest, the most beautiful, the most famous, the wisest, and the most renounced.

Father Emmanuel: Yes, I agree.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because God is absolute, His name, His form, and His qualities are also absolute, and they are nondifferent from Him. Therefore to chant God's holy name means to associate directly with Him. When one associates with God, one acquires godly qualities, and when one is completely purified, one becomes an associate of the Supreme Lord.

Father Emmanuel: But our understanding of the name of God is limited.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we are limited, but God is unlimited. And because He is unlimited, or absolute, He has unlimited names, each of which is God. We can understand His names as much as our spiritual understanding is developed.

Father Emmanuel: May I ask a question? We Christians also preach love of God, and we try to realize love of God and render service to Him with all our heart and all our soul. Now, what is the difference between your movement and ours? Why do you send your disciples to the Western countries to preach love of God when the gospel of Jesus Christ is propounding the same message?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The problem is that the Christians do not follow the commandments of God. Do you agree?

Father Emmanuel: Yes, to a large extent you're right.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then what is the meaning of the Christians' love for God? If you do not follow the orders of God, then where is your love? Therefore we have come to teach what it means to love God: if you love Him, you cannot be disobedient to His orders. And if you're disobedient, your love is not true.

All over the world, people love not God but their dogs. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is therefore necessary to teach people how to revive their forgotten love for God. Not only the Christians, but also the Hindus, the Muhammadans, and all others are guilty. They have rubber-stamped themselves "Christian," "Hindu," or "Muhammadan," but they do not obey God. That is the problem.

Visitor: Can you say in what way the Christians are disobedient?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. The first point is that they violate the commandment "Thou shalt not kill" by maintaining slaughterhouses. Do you agree that this commandment is being violated?

Father Emmanuel: Personally, I agree.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Good. So if the Christians want to love God, they must stop killing animals.

Father Emmanuel: But isn't the most important point...

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you miss one point, there is a mistake in your calculation. Regardless of what you add or subtract after that, the mistake is already in the calculation, and everything that follows will also be faulty. We cannot simply accept that part of the scripture we like, and reject what we don't like, and still expect to get the result. For example, a hen lays eggs with its back part and eats with its beak. A farmer may consider, "The front part of the hen is very expensive because I have to feed it. Better to cut it off." But if the head is missing there will be no eggs anymore, because the body is dead. Similarly, if we reject the difficult part of the scriptures and obey the part we like, such an interpretation will not help us. We have to accept all the injunctions of the scripture as they are given, not only those that suit us. If you do not follow the first order, "Thou shalt not kill," then where is the question of love of God?

Visitor: Christians take this commandment to be applicable to human beings, not to animals.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That would mean that Christ was not intelligent enough to use the right word: murder. There is killing, and there is murder. Murder refers to human beings. Do you think Jesus was not intelligent enough to use the right word—murder—instead of the word killing? Killing means any kind of killing, and especially animal killing. If Jesus had meant simply the killing of humans, he would have used the word murder.

Father Emmanuel: But in the Old Testament the commandment "Thou shalt not kill" does refer to murder. And when Jesus said, "Thou shalt not kill," he extended this commandment to mean that a human being should not only refrain from killing another human being, but should also treat him with love. He never spoke about man's relationship with other living entities, but only about his relationship with other human beings. When he said, "Thou shalt not kill," he also meant in the mental and emotional sense—that you should not insult anyone or hurt him, treat him badly, and so on.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We are not concerned with this or that testament but only with the words used in the commandments. If you want to interpret these words, that is something else. We understand the direct meaning. "Thou shalt not kill" means, "The Christians should not kill." You may put forth interpretations in order to continue the present way of action, but we understand very clearly that there is no need for interpretation. Interpretation is necessary if things are not clear. But here the meaning is clear. "Thou shalt not kill" is a clear instruction. Why should we interpret it?

Father Emmanuel: Isn't the eating of plants also killing?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Vaiñëava philosophy teaches that we should not even kill plants unnecessarily. In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.26] Kåñëa says:

patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà
yo me bhaktyä prayacchati
tad ahaà bhakty-upahåtam
açnämi prayatätmanaù

"If someone offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, a fruit, or a little water, I will accept it." We offer Kåñëa only the kind of food He demands, and then we eat the remnants. If offering vegetarian food to Kåñëa were sinful, then it would be Kåñëa's sin, not ours. But God is apäpa-viddha—sinful reactions are not applicable to Him. He is like the sun, which is so powerful that it can purify even urine—something impossible for us to do. Kåñëa is also like a king, who may order a murderer to be hanged but who himself is beyond punishment because he is very powerful. Eating food first offered to the Lord is also something like a soldier's killing during wartime. In a war, when the commander orders a man to attack, the obedient soldier who kills the enemy will get a medal. But if the same soldier kills someone on his own, he will be punished. Similarly, when we eat only prasäda [the remnants of food offered to Kåñëa], we do not commit any sin. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [3.13]:

yajïa-çiñöäçinaù santo
mucyante sarva-kilbiñaiù
bhuïjate te tv aghaà päpä
ye pacanty ätma-käraëät

"The devotees of the Lord are released from all kinds of sins because they eat food that is first offered for sacrifice. Others, who prepare food for personal sense enjoyment, verily eat only sin."

Father Emmanuel: Kåñëa cannot give permission to eat animals?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes—in the animal kingdom. But the civilized human being, the religious human being, is not meant to kill and eat animals. If you stop killing animals and chant the holy name Christ, everything will be perfect. I have not come to teach you, but only to request you to please chant the name of God. The Bible also demands this of you. So let's kindly cooperate and chant, and if you have a prejudice against chanting the name Kåñëa, then chant "Christos" or "Kåñöa"—there is no difference. Çré Caitanya said: nämnäm akäri bahudhä nija-sarva-çaktiù. "God has millions and millions of names, and because there is no difference between God's name and Himself, each one of these names has the same potency as God." [Çikñäñöaka 2] Therefore, even if you accept designations like "Hindu," "Christian," or "Muhammadan," if you simply chant the name of God found in your own scriptures, you will attain the spiritual platform. Human life is meant for self-realization—to learn how to love God. That is the actual duty of man. Whether you discharge this duty as a Hindu, a Christian, or a Muhammadan, it doesn't matter—but discharge it!

Father Emmanuel: I agree.

Çréla Prabhupäda [pointing to a string of 108 meditation beads]: We always have these beads, just as you have your rosary. You are chanting, but why don't the other Christians also chant? Why should they miss this opportunity as human beings? Cats and dogs cannot chant, but we can, because we have a human tongue. If we chant the holy names of God, we cannot lose anything; on the contrary, we gain greatly. My disciples practice chanting Hare Kåñëa constantly. They could also go to the cinema or do so many other things, but they have given everything up. They eat neither fish nor meat nor eggs, they don't take intoxicants, they don't drink, they don't smoke, they don't partake in gambling, they don't speculate, and they don't maintain illicit sexual connections. But they do chant the holy name of God. If you would like to cooperate with us, then go to the churches and chant, "Christ," "Kåñöa," or "Kåñëa." What could be the objection?

Father Emmanuel: There is none. For my part, I would be glad to join you.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, we are speaking with you as a representative of the Christian church. Instead of keeping the churches closed, why not give them to us? We would chant the holy name of God there twenty-four hours a day. In many places we have bought churches that were practically closed because no one was going there. In London I saw hundreds of churches that were closed or used for mundane purposes. We bought one such church in Los Angeles. It was sold because no one came there, but if you visit this same church today, you will see thousands of people. Any intelligent person can understand what God is in five minutes; it doesn't require five hours.

Father Emmanuel: I understand.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But the people do not. Their disease is that they don't want to understand.

Visitor: I think understanding God is not a question of intelligence, but a question of humility.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Humility means intelligence. The humble and meek own the kingdom of God. This is stated in the Bible, is it not? But the philosophy of the rascals is that everyone is God, and today this idea has become popular. Therefore no one is humble and meek. If everyone thinks that he is God, why should he be humble and meek? Therefore I teach my disciples how to become humble and meek. They always offer their respectful obeisances in the temple and to the spiritual master, and in this way they make advancement. The qualities of humbleness and meekness lead very quickly to spiritual realization. In the Vedic scriptures it is said, "To those who have firm faith in God and the spiritual master, who is His representative, the meaning of the Vedic scriptures is revealed."

Father Emmanuel: But shouldn't this humility be offered to everyone else, also?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but there are two kinds of respect: special and ordinary. Çré Kåñëa Caitanya taught that we shouldn't expect honor for ourselves, but should always respect everyone else, even if he is disrespectful to us. But special respect should be given to God and His pure devotee.

Father Emmanuel: Yes, I agree.

Çréla Prabhupäda: I think the Christian priests should cooperate with the Kåñëa consciousness movement. They should chant the name Christ or Christos and should stop condoning the slaughter of animals. This program follows the teachings of the Bible; it is not my philosophy. Please act accordingly and you will see how the world situation will change.

Father Emmanuel: I thank you very much.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Hare Kåñëa.

SSR 4b: Christ, Christians, and Kåñëa

Christ, Christians, and Kåñëa

"A Vaiñëava [a pure devotee of the Lord] is unhappy to see the suffering of others. Therefore, Lord Jesus Christ agreed to be crucified-to free others from their suffering. But his followers are so unfaithful that they have decided, 'Let Christ suffer for us, and we'll go on committing sin.' They love Christ so much that they think, 'My dear Christ, we are very weak. We cannot give up our sinful activities. So you please suffer for us.'"

The Çrémad-Bhägavatam states that any bona fide preacher of God consciousness must have the qualities of titikñä (tolerance) and karuëä (compassion). In the character of Lord Jesus Christ we find both these qualities. He was so tolerant that even while he was being crucified, he didn't condemn anyone. And he was so compassionate that he prayed to God to forgive the very persons who were trying to kill him. (Of course, they could not actually kill him. But they were thinking that he could be killed, so they were committing a great offense.) As Christ was being crucified he prayed, "Father, forgive them. They know not what they are doing."

A preacher of God consciousness is a friend to all living beings. Lord Jesus Christ exemplified this by teaching, “Thou shalt not kill.” But the Christians like to misinterpret this instruction. They think the animals have no soul, and therefore they think they can freely kill billions of innocent animals in the slaughterhouses. So although there are many persons who profess to be Christians, it would be very difficult to find one who strictly follows the instructions of Lord Jesus Christ.

A Vaiñëava is unhappy to see the suffering of others. Therefore, Lord Jesus Christ agreed to be crucified—to free others from their suffering. But his followers are so unfaithful that they have decided, “Let Christ suffer for us, and we’ll go on committing sin.” They love Christ so much that they think, “My dear Christ, we are very weak. We cannot give up our sinful activities. So you please suffer for us.”

Jesus Christ taught, “Thou shalt not kill.” But his followers have now decided, “Let us kill anyway,” and they open big, modern, scientific slaughterhouses. “If there is any sin, Christ will suffer for us.” This is a most abominable conclusion.

Christ can take the sufferings for the previous sins of his devotees. But first they have to be sane: “Why should I put Jesus Christ into suffering for my sins? Let me stop my sinful activities.”

Suppose a man—the favorite son of his father—commits a murder. And suppose he thinks, “If there is any punishment coming, my father can suffer for me.” Will the law allow it? When the murderer is arrested and says, “No, no. You can release me and arrest my father; I am his pet son,” will the police officials comply with that fool’s request? He committed the murder, but he thinks his father should suffer the punishment! Is that a sane proposal? “No. You have committed the murder; you must be hanged.” Similarly, when you commit sinful activities, you must suffer—not Jesus Christ. This is God’s law.

Jesus Christ was such a great personality—the son of God, the representative of God. He had no fault. Still, he was crucified. He wanted to deliver God consciousness, but in return they crucified him—they were so thankless. They could not appreciate his preaching. But we appreciate him and give him all honor as the representative of God.

Of course, the message that Christ preached was just according to his particular time, place, and country, and just suited for a particular group of people. But certainly he is the representative of God. Therefore we adore Lord Jesus Christ and offer our obeisances to him.

Once, in Melbourne, a group of Christian ministers came to visit me. They asked, “What is your idea of Jesus Christ?” I told them, “He is our guru. He is preaching God consciousness, so he is our spiritual master.” The ministers very much appreciated that.

Actually, anyone who is preaching God’s glories must be accepted as a guru. Jesus Christ is one such great personality. We should not think of him as an ordinary human being. The scriptures say that anyone who considers the spiritual master to be an ordinary man has a hellish mentality. If Jesus Christ were an ordinary man, then he could not have delivered God consciousness.

SSR 4c: "Thou Shalt Not Kill"

"Thou Shalt Not Kill"

At ISKCON’s Paris center Çréla Prabhupäda talked with Cardinal Jean Danielou: "... the Bible does not simply say, ‘Do not kill the human being.’ It says broadly, ‘Thou shalt not kill.’... why do you interpret this to suit your own convenience?... When there is no food, someone may eat meat in order to keep from starving. That is another thing. But it is most sinful to regularly maintain slaughterhouses just to satisfy your tongue.”

Çréla Prabhupäda: Jesus Christ said, “Thou shalt not kill.” So why is it that the Christian people are engaged in animal killing?

Cardinal Danielou: Certainly in Christianity it is forbidden to kill, but we believe that there is a difference between the life of a human being and the life of the beasts. The life of a human being is sacred because man is made in the image of God; therefore, to kill a human being is forbidden.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But the Bible does not simply say, “Do not kill the human being.” It says broadly, “Thou shalt not kill.”

Cardinal Danielou: We believe that only human life is sacred.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is your interpretation. The commandment is “Thou shalt not kill.”

Cardinal Danielou: It is necessary for man to kill animals in order to have food to eat.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Man can eat grains, vegetables, fruits, and milk.

Cardinal Danielou: No flesh?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Human beings are meant to eat vegetarian food. The tiger does not come to eat your fruits. His prescribed food is animal flesh. But man’s food is vegetables, fruits, grains, and milk products. So how can you say that animal killing is not a sin?

Cardinal Danielou: We believe it is a question of motivation. If the killing of an animal is for giving food to the hungry, then it is justified.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But consider the cow: we drink her milk; therefore, she is our mother. Do you agree?

Cardinal Danielou: Yes, surely.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So if the cow is your mother, how can you support killing her? You take the milk from her, and when she’s old and cannot give you milk, you cut her throat. Is that a very humane proposal? In India those who are meat-eaters are advised to kill some lower animals like goats, pigs, or even buffalo. But cow killing is the greatest sin. In preaching Kåñëa consciousness we ask people not to eat any kind of meat, and my disciples strictly follow this principle. But if, under certain circumstances, others are obliged to eat meat, then they should eat the flesh of some lower animal. Don’t kill cows. It is the greatest sin. And as long as a man is sinful, he cannot understand God. The human being’s main business is to understand God and to love Him. But if you remain sinful, you will never be able to understand God—what to speak of loving Him.

Cardinal Danielou: I think that perhaps this is not an essential point. The important thing is to love God. The practical commandments can vary from one religion to the next.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So, in the Bible God’s practical commandment is that you cannot kill; therefore killing cows is a sin for you.

Cardinal Danielou: God says to the Indians that killing is not good, and he says to the Jews that...

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, no. Jesus Christ taught, “Thou shalt not kill.” Why do you interpret this to suit your own convenience?

Cardinal Danielou: But Jesus allowed the sacrifice of the Paschal Lamb.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But he never maintained a slaughterhouse.

Cardinal Danielou: [Laughs.] No, but he did eat meat.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When there is no other food, someone may eat meat in order to keep from starving. That is another thing. But it is most sinful to regularly maintain slaughterhouses just to satisfy your tongue. Actually, you will not even have a human society until this cruel practice of maintaining slaughterhouses is stopped. And although animal killing may sometimes be necessary for survival, at least the mother animal, the cow, should not be killed. That is simply human decency. In the Kåñëa consciousness movement our practice is that we don’t allow the killing of any animals. Kåñëa says, patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà yo me bhaktyä prayacchati: "Vegetables, fruits, milk, and grains should be offered to Me in devotion." [Bhagavad-gétä 9.26] We take only the remnants of Kåñëa's food (prasäda). The trees offer us many varieties of fruits, but the trees are not killed. Of course, one living entity is food for another living entity, but that does not mean you can kill your mother for food. Cows are innocent; they give us milk. You take their milk—and then kill them in the slaughterhouse. This is sinful.

Student: Çréla Prabhupäda, Christianity’s sanction of meat-eating is based on the view that lower species of life do not have a soul like the human being’s.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is foolishness. First of all, we have to understand the evidence of the soul’s presence within the body. Then we can see whether the human being has a soul and the cow does not. What are the different characteristics of the cow and the man? If we find a difference in characteristics, then we can say that in the animal there is no soul. But if we see that the animal and the human being have the same characteristics, then how can you say that the animal has no soul? The general symptoms are that the animal eats, you eat; the animal sleeps, you sleep; the animal mates, you mate; the animal defends, and you defend. Where is the difference?

Cardinal Danielou: We admit that in the animal there may be the same type of biological existence as in men, but there is no soul. We believe that the soul is a human soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our Bhagavad-gétä says sarva-yonisu, “In all species of life the soul exists.” The body is like a suit of clothes. You have black clothes; I am dressed in saffron clothes. But within the dress you are a human being, and I am also a human being. Similarly, the bodies of the different species are just like different types of dress. There are soul, a part and parcel of God. Suppose a man has two sons, not equally meritorious. One may be a Supreme Court judge and the other may be a common laborer, but the father claims both as his sons. He does not make the distinction that the son who is a judge is very important and the worker-son is not important. And if the judge-son says, “My dear father, your other son is useless; let me cut him up and eat him,” will the father allow this?

Cardinal Danielou: Certainly not, but the idea that all life is part of the life of God is difficult for us to admit. There is a great difference between human life and animal life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That difference is due to the development of consciousness. In the human body there is developed consciousness. Even a tree has a soul, but a tree’s consciousness is not very developed. If you cut a tree it does not resist. Actually, it does resist, but only to a very small degree. There is a scientist named Jagadish Chandra Bose who has made a machine which shows that trees and plants are able to feel pain when they are cut. And we can see directly that when someone comes to kill an animal, it resists, it cries, it makes a horrible sound. So it is a matter of the development of consciousness. But the soul is there within all living beings.

Cardinal Danielou: But metaphysically, the life of man is sacred. Human beings think on a higher platform than the animals do.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is that higher platform? The animal eats to maintain his body, and you also eat in order to maintain your body. The cow eats grass in the field, and the human being eats meat from a huge slaughterhouse full of modern machines. But just because you have big machines and a ghastly scene, while the animal simply eats grass, this does not mean that you are so advanced that only within your body is there a soul and that there is not a soul within the body of the animal. That is illogical. We can see that the basic characteristics are the same in the animal and the human being.

Cardinal Danielou: But only in human beings do we find a metaphysical search for the meaning of life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. So metaphysically search out why you believe that there is no soul within the animal—that is metaphysics. If you are thinking metaphysically, that’s all right. But if you are thinking like an animal, then what is the use of your metaphysical study? Metaphysical means “above the physical” or, in other words, “spiritual.” In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says, sarva-yonisu kaunteya: “In every living being there is a spirit soul.” That is metaphysical understanding. Now either you accept Kåñëa’s teachings as metaphysical, or you’ll have to take a third-class fool’s opinion as metaphysical. Which do you accept?

Cardinal Danielou: But why does God create some animals who eat other animals? There is a fault in the creation, it seems.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not a fault. God is very kind. If you want to eat animals, then He’ll give you full facility. God will give you the body of a tiger in your next life so that you can eat flesh very freely. “Why are you maintaining slaughterhouses? I’ll give you fangs and claws. Now eat.” So the meat-eaters are awaiting such punishment. The animal-eaters become tigers, wolves, cats, and dogs in their next life—to get more facility.

SSR 5: Practicing Yoga in the Age of Quarrel

V. Practicing Yoga in the Age of Quarrel

SSR 5a: Superconsciousness

Superconsciousness

"The Supersoul, being present within everyone, situated everywhere, is conscious of every existence. The theory that the soul and the Supersoul are one is not acceptable, because the individual soul’s consciousness cannot act in superconsciousness. This superconsciousness can only be achieved by dovetailing individual consciousness with the superconsciousness; and this dovetailing process is called surrender, or Kåñëa consciousness.”

Kåñëa consciousness is the highest yoga performance by trained devotional yogis. The yoga system, as is stated in the standard yoga practice formula given by Lord Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä, and as recommended in the Pataïjali yoga discipline, is different from the nowadays practiced haöha-yoga as is generally understood in the Western countries.

Real yoga practice means to control the senses and, after such control is established, to concentrate the mind on the Näräyaëa form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa is the original Absolute Personality, the Godhead, and all the other Viñëu forms—with four hands, decorated with conch, lotus, club, and wheel—are plenary expansions of Kåñëa.

In the Bhagavad-gétä it is recommended that we should meditate upon the form of the Lord. For practicing concentration of the mind, one has to sit down in a secluded place sanctified by a sacred atmosphere, and the yogé should observe the rules and regulations of brahmacarya—to live a life of strict self-restraint and celibacy. No one can practice yoga in a congested city, living a life of extravagance, including unrestricted sex indulgence and adultery of the tongue.

We have already stated that yoga practice means controlling the senses, and the beginning of controlling the senses is to control the tongue. You cannot allow the tongue to take all kinds of forbidden food and drink, and at the same time improve in the practice of yoga. It is a very regrettable fact that many stray, unauthorized so-called yogis now come to the West and exploit the leaning of the people toward yoga. Such unauthorized yogis even dare to say publicly that one can indulge in drinking and at the same time practice meditation.

Five thousand years ago, in the Bhagavad-gétä dialogue, Lord Kåñëa recommended the yoga practice to His disciple Arjuna, but Arjuna flatly expressed his inability to follow the stringent rules and regulations of yoga. One should be practical in every field of activity. One should not waste his valuable time simply in practicing some gymnastic feats in the name of yoga. Real yoga is to search out the four-handed Supersoul within one’s heart and to see Him perpetually in meditation. Such continued meditation is called samädhi. If, however, one wants to meditate upon something void or impersonal, it will require a very long time to achieve anything by yoga practice. We cannot concentrate our mind on something void or impersonal. Real yoga practice is to fix the mind on the person of the four-handed Näräyaëa who dwells in everyone’s heart.

Sometimes it is said that by meditation one will understand that God is seated within one’s heart always, even when one does not know it. God is seated within the heart of everyone. Not only is He seated in the heart of the human being, but He is also within the hearts of the cats and dogs. The Bhagavad-gétä certifies this with the declaration that Içvara, the supreme controller of the world, is seated in the heart of everyone. He is present not only in everyone’s heart, but also within the atoms. No place is vacant; no place is without the presence of the Lord.

The feature of the Lord by which He is present everywhere is called the Paramätmä. Ätmä means the individual soul, and Paramätmä means the individual Supersoul. Both ätmä and Paramätmä are individual persons. The difference between them, however, is that the ätmä, or soul, is present only in one particular place, whereas the Paramätmä is present everywhere.

In this connection, the example of the sun is very nice. An individual person may be situated in one place, but the sun, even though a specific individual entity, is present over the head of every individual person. In the Bhagavad-gétä this is very nicely explained. Therefore, even though the qualities of all entities, including the Lord, are equal, the Supersoul is different from the individual soul by quantity of expansion. The Lord, or Supersoul, can expand Himself into millions of different forms, while the individual soul cannot do so.

The Supersoul, being seated in everyone’s heart, can witness everyone’s activities, past, present, and future. In the Upaniñads the Supersoul is said to be sitting with the individual soul as a friend and witness. As a friend He is always anxious to get the individual soul back home, back to Godhead. As a witness, He is the endower of all benedictions that result from the individual’s actions. The Supersoul gives the individual soul all facility for achieving whatever he may desire. But He instructs His friend, so that he may ultimately give up all other engagements and simply surrender unto God for perpetual bliss and eternal life, full of knowledge. This is the last instruction of the Bhagavad-gétä, the most authorized and widely read book on all forms of yoga.

The last word of the Bhagavad-gétä, as stated above, is the last word in the matter of perfecting the yoga system. It is further stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that a person who is always absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness is the topmost yogé. What is this Kåñëa consciousness?

Just as the individual soul is present by his consciousness throughout the whole body, so the Supersoul, or Paramätmä, is present throughout the whole creation by His superconsciousness. This superconsciousness cannot be imitated by the individual soul, who has limited awareness: I can understand what is going on within my limited body, but I cannot feel what is going on in another’s body. I am present all over my body by my consciousness, but I am not present in any other’s body by my consciousness. However, the Supersoul, or Paramätmä, being present within everyone, situated everywhere, is conscious of every existence. The theory that the soul and the Supersoul are one is not acceptable, because the individual soul’s consciousness cannot act in superconsciousness. This superconsciousness can only be achieved by dovetailing individual consciousness with the superconsciousness; and this dovetailing process is called surrender, or Kåñëa consciousness.

From the teachings of the Bhagavad-gétä we learn very clearly that Arjuna in the beginning did not want to fight with his relatives, but after understanding the Bhagavad-gétä, when he dovetailed his consciousness with the superconsciousness of Kåñëa, his consciousness was Kåñëa consciousness. A person in full Kåñëa consciousness acts by the dictation of Kåñëa, and so Arjuna agreed to fight the Battle of Kurukñetra.

In the beginning of Kåñëa consciousness this dictation of the Lord is received through the transparent medium of the spiritual master. When one is sufficiently trained and acts with submissive faith and love for Kåñëa, under the direction of the bona fide spiritual master, the dovetailing process becomes more firm and accurate. At this stage Kåñëa dictates from within. From without, the devotee is helped by the spiritual master, the bona fide representative of Kåñëa, and from within the Lord helps the devotee as caitya-guru, being seated within the heart of everyone.

Simply to understand that God is seated in everyone’s heart is not perfection. One has to be acquainted with God from within and without and thus act in Kåñëa consciousness. This is the highest perfectional stage for the human form of life, and the topmost stage in all yoga systems.

For a perfect yogé there are eight kinds of superachievements:

1. One can become smaller than an atom.

2. One can become bigger than a mountain.

3. One can become lighter than the air.

4. One can become heavier than any metal.

5. One can achieve any material effect he likes (create a planet, for example).

6. One can control others like the Lord can.

7. One can freely travel anywhere within (or beyond) the universe.

8. One can choose his own time and place of death, and take rebirth wherever he may desire.

But when one rises to the perfectional stage of receiving dictation from the Lord, one is above the stage of the material achievements above mentioned.

The breathing exercise of the yoga system that is generally practiced is just the beginning of the system. Meditation on the Supersoul is just a step forward. Achievement of wonderful material success is also only a step forward. But to attain direct contact with the Supersoul and to take dictation from Him is the highest perfectional stage.

The breathing exercises and meditational practices of yoga are very difficult in this age. They were difficult even five thousand years ago, or else Arjuna would not have rejected the proposal of Kåñëa. This age of Kali is called a fallen age. At the present moment, people in general are short-living and very slow in understanding self-realization, or spiritual life. They are mostly unfortunate, and as such, if someone is a little bit interested in self-realization, he is misguided by so many frauds. The only actual way to realization of the perfect stage of yoga is to follow the principles of the Bhagavad-gétä as they were practiced by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. This is the simplest and highest perfection of yoga practice.

Lord Caitanya practically demonstrated Kåñëa consciousness yoga simply by chanting the holy names of Kåñëa, as they are mentioned in the Vedänta, the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and many important Puräëas. The largest number of Indians follow this yoga practice, and in the United States and other countries also it is gradually growing in many cities. It is very easy and practical for this age, especially for those who are serious about success in yoga. No other process can be successful in this age.

The meditational process in right earnest was possible in the Golden Age, Satya-yuga, because the people at that time lived for a hundred thousand years on the average.

In the present age, however, if you want success in practical yoga, take to the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, and feel for yourself how you are making progress. One should know for himself how much he is progressing in yoga practice.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.2] this practice of Kåñëa consciousness is described as räja-vidyä, the king of all erudition; räja-guhyam, the most confidential system of spiritual realization; pavitram, the purest of all that is pure; susukham, very happily performed; and avyayam, inexhaustible.

Those who have taken to this most sublime bhakti-yoga system, this practice of devotional service in transcendental love of Kåñëa, can testify to how they are nicely enjoying its happy and easy execution. Yoga means controlling the senses, and bhakti-yoga means purifying the senses. When the senses are purified, they are also, automatically, controlled. You cannot stop the activities of the senses by artificial means, but if you purify the senses, not only are they kept back from rubbish engagement, but also they become positively engaged in transcendental service to the Lord.

Kåñëa consciousness is not manufactured by us through mental speculation. It is prescribed in the Bhagavad-gétä, which says that when we think in Kåñëa, chant in Kåñëa, live in Kåñëa, eat in Kåñëa, talk in Kåñëa, hope in Kåñëa, and sustain in Kåñëa, we return to Kåñëa, without any doubt. And this is the substance of Kåñëa consciousness.

SSR 5b: The Incarnation of Love of God

The Incarnation of Love of God

“Caitanya Mahäprabhu is Kåñëa Himself, and He is teaching how to develop love of God by a very simple method.... People are embarrassed by so many methods of realization. They cannot take to the actual ritualistic process of meditation or yoga; it is not possible. Therefore Lord Caitanya says that if one takes up this process of chanting, then immediately he can reach the platform of realization.”

Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the golden avatära, appeared in India nearly five hundred years ago. It is the custom in India that when a child is born, an astrologer is called for. When Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, appeared five thousand years ago, Gargamuni was called by His father, and he said, “This child formerly incarnated in three complexions, such as red and golden, and now He has appeared in blackish color.” Kåñëa’s color is described in the scriptures as blackish, just like the color of a cloud. Lord Caitanya is understood to be Kåñëa appearing in golden complexion.

There is much evidence in Vedic literature that Caitanya Mahäprabhu is an incarnation of Kåñëa, and this is confirmed by scholars and devotees. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is confirmed that the incarnation of Kåñëa, or God, in this present age, Kali-yuga, will always engage in describing Kåñëa. He is Kåñëa, but as a devotee of Kåñëa He describes Himself. And in this age His bodily complexion will not be blackish. This means that it may be white, it may be red, or it may be yellow, because these four colors—white, red, yellow, and black—are the colors assumed by the incarnations for the different ages. Therefore, since the red, white, and blackish colors were already taken by former incarnations, the remaining color, golden, is assumed by Caitanya Mahäprabhu. His complexion is not blackish, but He is Kåñëa.

Another feature of this avatära is that He is always accompanied by His associates. In the picture of Caitanya Mahäprabhu one will find that He is always followed by many devotees chanting. Whenever God incarnates He has two missions, as stated in the Bhagavad-gétä. There Kåñëa says, “Whenever I appear, My mission is to deliver the pious devotees and to annihilate the demons.” When Kåñëa appeared, He had to kill many demons. If we see a picture of Viñëu we will notice that He has a conchshell, lotus flower, club, and disc. These last two items are meant for killing demons. Within this world there are two classes of men—the demons and the devotees. The devotees are called demigods; they are almost like God because they have godly qualities. Those who are devotees are called godly persons, and those who are nondevotees, atheists, are called demons. So Kåñëa, or God, comes with two missions: to give protection to the devotees and to destroy the demons. In this age Caitanya Mahäprabhu’s mission is also like that: to deliver the devotees and to annihilate the nondevotees, the demons. But in this age He has a different weapon. That weapon is not a club or disc or lethal weapon—His weapon is the saìkértana movement. He killed the demoniac mentality of the people by introducing the saìkértana movement. That is the specific significance of Lord Caitanya. In this age people are already killing themselves. They have discovered atomic weapons with which to kill themselves, so there is no need for God to kill them. But He appeared to kill their demonic mentality. That is possible by this Kåñëa consciousness movement.

Therefore, in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is said that this is the incarnation of God in this age. And who worships Him? The process is very simple. Just keep a picture of Lord Caitanya with His associates. Lord Caitanya is in the middle, accompanied by His principal associates—Nityänanda, Advaita, Gadädhara, and Çréväsa. One simply has to keep this picture. One can keep it anywhere. It is not that one has to come to us to see this picture. Anyone can have this picture in his home, chant this Hare Kåñëa mantra, and thus worship Lord Caitanya. That is the simple method. But who will capture this simple method? Those who have good brains. Without much bother, if one simply keeps a picture of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu at home and chants Hare Kåñëa, then one will realize God. Anyone can adopt this simple method. There is no expenditure, there is no tax, nor is there any need to build a very big church or temple. Anyone, anywhere, can sit down on the road or beneath a tree and chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra and worship God. Therefore it is a great opportunity. For example, in business or political life one sometimes finds a great opportunity. Those who are intelligent politicians take a good opportunity and make a success of it the first time it comes. Similarly, in this age, those who have sufficient intelligence take to this saìkértana movement, and they advance very quickly.

Lord Caitanya is called “the golden avatära.” Avatära means “descending, coming down.” Just as one may come down from the fifth story or the one-hundredth story of a building, an avatära comes down from the spiritual planets in the spiritual sky. The sky we see with our naked eyes or with a telescope is only the material sky. But beyond this there is another sky, which is not possible to see with our eyes or instruments. That information is in the Bhagavad-gétä; it is not imagination. Kåñëa says that beyond the material sky is another sky, the spiritual sky.

We have to take Kåñëa’s word as it is. For example, we teach small children that beyond England there are other places, called Germany, India, etc., and the child has to learn about these places from the version of the teacher because they are beyond his sphere. Similarly, beyond this material sky there is another sky. One cannot experiment to find it, any more than a small child can experiment to find Germany or India. That is not possible. If we want to get knowledge, then we have to accept authority. Similarly, if we want to know what is beyond the material world then we have to accept the Vedic authority, otherwise there is no possibility of knowing. It is beyond material knowledge. One cannot go to the far planets in this universe, what to speak of going beyond this universe. The estimation is that in order to go to the highest planet of this universe with modern machinery one would have to travel for forty thousand light-years. So we cannot even travel within this material sky. Our lifetime and means are so limited that we cannot have proper knowledge of even this material world.

In the Bhagavad-gétä, when Arjuna asked Kåñëa, “Will you kindly explain the extent to which Your energies are working?” the Supreme Lord gave him so many instances, and at the end He finally said, “My dear Arjuna, what shall I explain about My energies? It is not actually possible for you to understand. But you can just imagine the expansion of My energies: this material world, which consists of millions of universes, is a display of only one fourth of My creation.” We cannot estimate the position of even one universe, and there are millions of universes. Then beyond that is the spiritual sky, and there are millions of spiritual planets. All this information is available from the Vedic literature. If one accepts Vedic literature, then he can get this knowledge. If one doesn’t accept it, there is no other means. That is our choice. Therefore, according to Vedic civilization, whenever an äcärya speaks he immediately gives references from the Vedic literature. Then others will accept it: “Yes, it is correct.” In a law court the lawyer gives references from past judgments of the court, and if his case is tight, the judge accepts. Similarly, if one can give evidence from the Vedas, then it is understood that his position is factual.

The avatära for this age, Lord Caitanya, is described in Vedic literature. We cannot accept anyone as an avatära unless he has the symptoms described in the scriptures. We do not whimsically accept Lord Caitanya as an avatära on the basis of votes. Nowadays it has become a fashion that any man can come and say that he is God or an incarnation of God, and some fools and rascals will accept it: “Oh, he is God.” We do not accept an avatära like that. We take evidence from the Vedas. An avatära must conform to descriptions in the Vedas. Then we accept him; otherwise no. For each avatära there is a description in the Vedas: He will appear at such and such a place, in such and such a form, and He will act like this. That is the nature of Vedic evidence.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is a list of the avatäras, and there is mention of Lord Buddha’s name. This Çrémad-Bhägavatam was written five thousand years ago, and it mentions different names for future times. It says that in the future the Lord would appear as Lord Buddha, his mother’s name would be Aïjana, and he would appear in Gayä. So Buddha appeared twenty-six hundred years ago, and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, which was written five thousand years ago, mentioned that in the future he would appear. Similarly, there is mention of Lord Caitanya, and similarly the last avatära of this Kali-yuga is also mentioned in the Bhägavatam. It is mentioned that the last incarnation in this age is Kalki. He will appear as the son of a brähmaëa whose name is Viñëu-yaçä, in a place called Çambhala. There is a place in India with that name, so perhaps it is there that the Lord will appear.

So an avatära must conform to the descriptions in the Upaniñads, Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Mahäbhärata, and other Vedic literatures. And on the authority of Vedic literature and the commentary of great, stalwart goswamis like Jéva Goswami, who was the greatest scholar and philosopher in the world, we can accept Lord Caitanya as an incarnation of Kåñëa.

Why did Lord Caitanya appear? In the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa says, “Give up all other engagements and simply engage in My service. I will give you protection from all results of sinful actions.” In this material world, in conditional life, we are simply creating sinful reactions. That’s all. And because of sinful reactions, we have received this body. If our sinful reactions stopped we would not have to take a material body; we should get a spiritual body.

What is a spiritual body? A spiritual body is a body which is free from death, birth, disease, and old age. It is an eternal body, full of knowledge and bliss. Different bodies are created by different desires. As long as we have desires for different kinds of enjoyment, we have to accept different kinds of material bodies. Kåñëa, God, is so kind that He awards whatever we want. If we want a tiger’s body, with tigerlike strength and teeth with which to capture animals and suck fresh blood, then Kåñëa will give us the opportunity. And if we want the body of a saintly person, a devotee engaged only in the service of the Lord, then He will give us that body. This is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä.

If a person engaged in yoga, the process of self-realization, somehow or other fails to complete the process, he is given another chance; he is given birth in a family of a pure brähmaëa or a rich man. If one is fortunate enough to take birth in such a family, he gets all facilities to understand the importance of self-realization. From the very beginning of life our Kåñëa conscious children are getting the opportunity to learn how to chant and dance, so when they are grown up they will not change, but instead will automatically make progress. They are very fortunate. Regardless of whether he is born in America or Europe, a child will advance if his father and mother are devotees. He gets this opportunity. If a child takes birth in a family of devotees, this means that in his last life he had already taken to the yoga process, but somehow or other he could not finish it. Therefore the child is given another opportunity to make progress under the care of a good father and mother so that he will again advance. In this way, as soon as one completes his development of God consciousness, then he no longer has to take birth in this material world, but returns to the spiritual world.

Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä: “My dear Arjuna, if one understands My appearance, disappearance, and activities, simply because of this understanding he is given the opportunity to take birth in the spiritual world after giving up this body.” One has to give up this body—today, tomorrow, or maybe the day after that. One has to. But a person who has understood Kåñëa will not have to take another material body. He goes directly to the spiritual world and takes birth in one of the spiritual planets. So Kåñëa says that as soon as one gets this body—it doesn’t matter if it is from India or the moon or the sun or Brahmaloka or anywhere within this material world—one should know that it is due to his sinful activities. There are degrees of sinful activities, so according to the degree of sinfulness, one takes a material body. Therefore our real problem is not how to eat, sleep, mate, and de-fend—our real problem is how to get a body that is not material but spiritual. That is the ultimate solution to all problems. So Kåñëa guarantees that if one surrenders unto Him, if one becomes fully Kåñëa conscious, then He will give one protection from all reactions to sinful life.

This assurance was given by Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä, but there were many fools who could not understand Kåñëa. In the Bhagavad-gétä they are described as müdhas. Müdha means “rascal,” and Kåñëa says in the Gétä, “They do not know what I actually am.” So many people misunderstood Kåñëa. Although Kåñëa gave us this message of the Bhagavad-gétä so that we could understand Him, many people missed the opportunity. Therefore Kåñëa, out of His compassion, came again, as a devotee, and showed us how to surrender unto Kåñëa. Kåñëa Himself came to teach us how to surrender. His last instruction in the Bhagavad-gétä is to surrender, but people—müdhas, rascals—said, “Why should I surrender?” Therefore, although Caitanya Mahäprabhu is Kåñëa Himself, this time He teaches us practically how to execute the mission of the Bhagavad-gétä. That’s all. Caitanya Mahäprabhu is teaching nothing extraordinary, nothing beyond the process of surrendering to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, which was already taught in the Bhagavad-gétä. There is no other teaching, but the same teaching is presented in different ways so that different kinds of people may take it and take the opportunity to approach God.

Caitanya Mahäprabhu gives us the opportunity to reach God directly. When Rüpa Goswami, the principal disciple of Lord Caitanya, first saw Caitanya Mahäprabhu, he was a minister in the government of Bengal but wanted to join Caitanya Mahäprabhu’s movement. So he gave up his position as a minister, and after joining, when he surrendered, he offered a nice prayer to Lord Caitanya. This prayer says:

namo mahä-vadänyäya
kåñëa-prema-pradäya te
kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-
nämne gaura-tviñe namaù
[Madhya 19.53]

“My dear Lord, You are the most munificent of all the incarnations.” Why? Kåñëa-prema-pradäya te: “You are directly giving love of God. You have no other purpose. Your process is so nice that one can immediately learn to love God. Therefore You are the most munificent of all incarnations. And it is not possible for any personality other than Kåñëa Himself to deliver this benediction; therefore I say that You are Kåñëa.” Kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-nämne: “You are Kåñëa, but You have assumed the name Kåñëa Caitanya. I surrender unto You.”

So this is the process. Caitanya Mahäprabhu is Kåñëa Himself, and He is teaching how to develop love of God by a very simple method. He says simply to chant Hare Kåñëa.

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä
[Ädi 17.21]

“In this age, simply go on chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra. There is no other alternative.” People are embarrassed by so many methods of realization. They cannot take to the actual ritualistic processes of meditation or yoga; it is not possible. Therefore Lord Caitanya says that if one takes up this process of chanting, then immediately he can reach the platform of realization.

The chanting process offered by Lord Caitanya for achieving love of God is called saìkértana. Saìkértana is a Sanskrit word. Sam means samyak—“complete.” And kértana means “glorifying” or “describing.” So complete description means complete glorification of the Supreme, or the Supreme Complete Whole. It is not that one can describe anything or glorify anything and that will be kértana. From the grammatical point of view that may be kértana, but according to the Vedic system, kértana means describing the supreme authority, the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. That is called kértana.

This devotional service begins with the method of çravaëa. Çravaëa means “hearing,” and kértana means “describing.” One should describe, and another should hear. Or the same man himself can both describe and hear. He does not need anyone else’s help. When we chant Hare Kåñëa, we chant and hear. This is complete. This is a complete method. But what is that chanting and hearing? One must chant and hear about Viñëu, Kåñëa. Not of anything else. Çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù [Bhäg. 7.5.23]: one can understand Viñëu, the all-pervading Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, by the method of hearing.

We have to hear; if one simply hears, that is the beginning. One does not need any education or development of material knowledge. Just like a child: as soon as he hears, immediately he can respond and dance. So by nature God has given us these nice instruments—ears—so that we can hear. But we must hear from the right source. That is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. One must hear from those who are devoted to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. They are called satäm. If one hears from the right source, from a realized soul, then it will act. And these words of God, or Kåñëa, are very relishable. If one is intelligent enough, he will listen to what is spoken by the realized soul. Then very soon he will be released from material entanglements.

This human life is meant for advancing on the path of liberation. That is called apavarga, freedom from entanglement. We are all entangled. Our acceptance of this material body means that we are already entangled. But we should not progress in the process of entanglement. That process is called karma. As long as the mind is absorbed in karma, we will have to accept a material body. At the time of death, our mind may be thinking, “Oh, I could not complete this work. Oh, I am dying! I have to do this. I have to do that.” This means that Kåñëa will give us another chance to do it, and so we will have to accept another body. He will give us the chance: “All right. You could not do it. Now do it. Take this body.” Therefore the Çrémad-Bhägavatam says, “These rascals have become madly intoxicated; because of intoxication they are doing something they should not have done.” What are they doing? Mahäräja Dhåtaräñöra is a very good example. Mahäräja Dhåtaräñöra was cunningly planning to kill the Päëdavas in order to favor his own sons, so Kåñëa sent His uncle, Akrüra, to advise him not to do that. Dhåtaräñöra understood Akrüra’s instructions, but he said, “My dear Akrüra, what you are saying is quite right, but it does not stand in my heart, so I cannot change my policy. I have to follow this policy and let whatever happens take place.”

So when men want to satisfy their senses, they become mad, and in this madness they’ll do anything and everything. For example, there have been many instances in material life where someone has become mad after something and has committed a criminal act such as murder. The person could not check himself. Similarly, we are accustomed to sense gratification. We are mad, and therefore our minds are fully absorbed in karma. This is very unfortunate, because our body, although temporary, is the reservoir of all misfortunes and miseries; it is always giving us trouble. These matters are to be studied. We should not be mad. Human life is not meant for that. The defect of the present civilization is that people are mad after sense gratification. That is all. They do not know the real value of life, and therefore they are neglecting the most valuable form of life, this human form.

When this body is finished there is no guarantee what kind of body one will take next. Suppose in my next life I by chance get the body of a tree. For thousands of years I will have to stand up. But people are not very serious. They even say, “What is that? Even if I have to stand up, I shall forget.” The lower species of life are situated in forgetfulness. If a tree were not forgetful it would be impossible for it to live. Suppose we were told, “You stand up for three days here!” Because we are not forgetful, we would become mad. So, by nature’s law, all these lower species of life are forgetful. Their consciousness is not developed. A tree has life, but even if someone cuts it, because its consciousness is not developed, it does not respond. So we should be very careful to utilize this human form of life properly. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant for achieving perfection in life. It is not a bluff or exploitation, but unfortunately people are accustomed to being bluffed. There is a verse by an Indian poet: “If one speaks nice things, people will quarrel with him: ‘Oh, what nonsense you are speaking.’ But if he bluffs them and cheats them, they will be very glad.” So if a bluffer says, “Just do this, give me my fee, and within six months you will become God,” then they will agree: “Yes, take this fee, and I shall become God within six months.” No. These cheating processes will not solve our problem. If one actually wants to solve the problems of life in this age, then he has to take to this process of kértana. That is the recommended process.

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä
[Ädi 17.21]

In this age, Kali-yuga, one cannot execute any process of self-realization or perfection of life other than kértana. Kértana is essential in this age.

In all Vedic literatures it is confirmed that one must meditate on the Supreme Absolute Truth, Viñëu, not on anything else. But there are different processes of meditation recommended for different ages. The process of mystic yogic meditation was possible in Satya-yuga, when men lived for many thousands of years. Now people will not believe this, but in a previous age there were people who lived for one hundred thousand years. That age was called Satya-yuga, and the meditation of mystic yoga was possible at that time. In that age the great yogé Välméki Muni meditated for sixty thousand years. So that is a long-term process, which is not possible to execute in this age. If one wishes to conduct a farce, that is another matter. But if one actually wants to practice such meditation, it takes an extremely long time to perfect. In the next age, Tretä-yuga, the process of realization was to perform the various ritualistic sacrifices recommended in the Vedas. In the next age, Dväpara-yuga, the process was temple worship. In this present age the same result can be achieved by the process of hari-kértana, glorification of Hari, Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

No other kértana is recommended. This hari-kértana was started five hundred years ago in Bengal by Lord Caitanya. In Bengal there is competition between the Vaiñëavas and the çäktas. The çäktas have introduced a certain type of kértana called kälé-kértana. But in the Vedic scriptures there is no recommendation of kälé-kértana. Kértana means hari-kértana. One cannot say, “Oh, you are Vaiñëava. You can perform hari-kértana. I shall perform çiva-kértana or devé-kértana or gaëeça-kértana.” No. The Vedic scriptures do not authorize any kértana other than hari-kértana. Kértana means hari-kértana, the glorification of Kåñëa.

So this process of hari-kértana is very simple: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Actually there are only three words: Hare, Kåñëa, and Räma. But they are very nicely arranged for chanting so that everyone can take the mantra and chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare. Since we have started this movement in the Western countries, Europeans, Americans, Africans, Egyptians, and Japanese are all chanting. There is no difficulty. They are chanting very gladly, and they are getting the results. What is the difficulty? We are distributing this chanting free of charge, and it is very simple. Simply by chanting, one can have self-realization, God realization, and when there is God realization, then nature realization is included also. For example, if one learns one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, and zero, then he has studied the entirety of mathematics, because mathematics means simply changing the places of these ten figures. That’s all. Similarly, if one simply studies Kåñëa, then all his knowledge is perfect. And Kåñëa is easily understood simply by chanting this mantra, Hare Kåñëa. So why not take this opportunity?

Take this opportunity that is being offered to human society. It is very ancient and scientific. It is not that it is a concoction that will last for only three or four years. No. In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa Himself says, “This philosophy is inexhaustible and indestructible. It is never lost or destroyed.” It may be covered for the time being, but it is never destroyed. Therefore it is called avyayam. Vyaya means “exhaustion.”

For example, one may have a hundred dollars, and if they are spent one after another, the next day it will come to zero. That is vyaya, exhaustible. But Kåñëa consciousness is not like that. If you cultivate this knowledge of Kåñëa consciousness, then it will increase. That is certified by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Änandämbudhi-vardhanam. Änanda means “pleasure,” “transcendental bliss,” and ambudhi means “ocean.” In the material world we see that the ocean does not increase. But if one cultivates Kåñëa consciousness, then his transcendental bliss will simply increase. Änandämbudhi-vardhanam. And I shall always remind everyone that the process is very simple. Anyone can chant, anywhere, without taxation or loss, but the gain is very great.

Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has explained this kértana movement in His Çikñäñöaka. Çikñä means "instruction," and añöaka means "eight." He has given us eight verses to help us understand this Kåñëa consciousness movement, and I shall explain the first of these instructions. The Lord says, ceto-darpaëa-märjanam: one should cleanse the heart. I have explained this several times, but it does not become monotonous. It is just like the chanting of Hare Kåñëa; it does not become tiresome. Our students can chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra twenty-four hours a day, and they will never get tired. They will continue to dance and chant. And anyone can try it; because it is not material, one will never get tired of chanting Hare Kåñëa. In the material world, if one chants anything, any favorite name, for three, four, or ten times, he will get tired of it. That is a fact. But because Hare Kåñëa is not material, if one chants this mantra, he will never get tired. The more one chants, the more his heart will be cleansed of material dirt and the more the problems of his life within this material world will be solved.

What is the problem of our lives? That we do not know. Modern education never gives enlightenment about the real problem of life. That is indicated in the Bhagavad-gétä. Those who are educated and are advancing in knowledge should know what is the problem of life. This problem is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä: one should always see the inconveniences of birth, death, old age, and disease. Unfortunately no one pays attention to these problems. When a man is diseased he thinks, “All right. Let me go to the doctor. He will give me some medicine, and I will be cured.” But he does not consider the problem very seriously. “I did not want this disease. Why is there disease? Is it not possible to become free from disease?” He never thinks that way. This is because his intelligence is very low-grade, just like that of an animal. An animal suffers, but it has no sense. If an animal is brought to a slaughterhouse and sees that the animal before him is being slaughtered, he will still stand there contentedly eating the grass. This is animal life. He does not know that next time it will be his turn and he will be slaughtered. I have seen it. In a Kälé temple I have seen that a goat was standing there ready to be sacrificed and another goat was very happily eating the grass.

Similarly, Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira was asked by Yamaräja, “What is the most wonderful thing in this world? Can you explain?” So Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira answered, “Yes. The most wonderful thing is that at every moment one can see that his friends, his fathers, and his relatives have died, but he is thinking, ‘I shall live forever.’” He never thinks that he will die, just as an animal never thinks that at the next moment he may be slaughtered. He is satisfied with the grass, that’s all. He is satisfied with the sense gratification. He does not know that he is also going to die.

My father has died, my mother has died, he has died, she has died. So I will also have to die. Then what is after death? I do not know. This is the problem. People do not take this problem seriously, but the Bhagavad-gétä indicates that that is real education. Real education is to inquire why, although we do not want to die, death comes. That is real inquiry. We do not want to become old men. Why does old age come upon us? We have many problems, but this is the sum and substance of all of them.

In order to solve this problem, Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu prescribes the chanting of Hare Kåñëa. As soon as our heart is cleansed by chanting this Hare Kåñëa mantra, the blazing fire of our problematic material existence is extinguished. How is it extinguished? When we cleanse our heart we will realize that we do not belong to this material world. Because people are identifying with this material world, they are thinking, “I am an Indian, I am an Englishman, I am this, I am that.” But if one chants the Hare Kåñëa mantra, he will realize that he is not this material body. “I do not belong to this material body or this material world. I am a spirit soul, part and parcel of the Supreme. I am eternally related with Him, and I have nothing to do with the material world.” This is called liberation, knowledge. If I don’t have anything to do with this material world, then I am liberated. And that knowledge is called brahma-bhüta.

A person with this realization has no duty to perform. Because we are now identifying our existence with this material world, we have so many duties. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam says that as long as there is no self-realization, we have so many duties and debts. We are indebted to the demigods. The demigods are not merely fictitious. They are real.

There are demigods controlling the sun, the moon, and the air. Just as there are directors of government departments, so for the heating department there is the sun-god, for the air department there is Varuëa, and similarly there are other departmental demigods. In the Vedas they are described as controlling deities, so we cannot neglect them. Also, there are great sages and philosophers who have given us knowledge, and we are indebted to them. So as soon as we take birth we are indebted to so many living entities, but it is impossible to liquidate all these debts. Therefore the Vedic literature recommends that one take shelter of the lotus feet of Kåñëa. And Kåñëa says, “If one takes shelter of Me, then he doesn’t have to take shelter of anyone else.”

Therefore those who are Kåñëa conscious devotees have taken shelter of Kåñëa, and the beginning is hearing and chanting. Çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù [Bhäg. 7.5.23]. So our fervent, humble request to everyone is to please accept this chanting. This movement of Kåñëa consciousness was introduced by Lord Caitanya five hundred years ago in Bengal, and now all over India and especially in Bengal there are millions of followers of Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Now this movement is starting in the Western countries, so just be very serious in understanding it. We do not criticize any other religion. Don’t take it in that way. We have no business criticizing any other process of religion. Kåñëa consciousness is giving people the most sublime religion—love of God. That’s all. We are teaching to love God. Everyone is already loving, but that love is misplaced. We love this boy or this girl or this country or that society or even the cats and dogs, but we are not satisfied. So we must place our love in God. If one places one’s love in God, he will be happy.

Don’t think that this Kåñëa consciousness movement is a new type of religion. Where is the religion which does not recognize God? One may call God “Allah” or “Kåñëa” or something else, but where is that religion which does not recognize God? We are teaching that one should simply try to love God. We are attracted by so many things, but if our love is reposed in God, then we will be happy. We don’t have to learn to love anything else; everything else is automatically included. Just try to love God. Don’t try to love just trees or plants or insects. This will never satisfy. Learn to love God. That is Caitanya Mahäprabhu’s mission; that is our mission.

SSR 5c: Chanting the Hare Kåñëa Mantra

Chanting the Hare Kåñëa Mahä-mantra

"...This simple method of meditation is recommended for this age. By practical experience also, one can perceive that by chanting this mahä-mantra, or the Great Chanting for Deliverance, one can feel a transcendental ecstasy coming through from the spiritual stratum....”

The transcendental vibration established by the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is the sublime method for reviving our transcendental consciousness. As living spiritual souls, we are all originally Kåñëa conscious entities, but due to our association with matter from time immemorial, our consciousness is now adulterated by the material atmosphere. The material atmosphere, in which we are now living, is called mäyä, or illusion. Mäyä means “that which is not.” And what is this illusion? The illusion is that we are all trying to be lords of material nature, while actually we are under the grip of her stringent laws. When a servant artificially tries to imitate the all-powerful master, he is said to be in illusion. We are trying to exploit the resources of material nature, but actually we are becoming more and more entangled in her complexities. Therefore, although we are engaged in a hard struggle to conquer nature, we are ever more dependent on her. This illusory struggle against material nature can be stopped at once by revival of our eternal Kåñëa consciousness.

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare is the transcendental process for reviving this original, pure consciousness. By chanting this transcendental vibration, we can cleanse away all misgivings within our hearts. The basic principle of all such misgivings is the false consciousness that I am the lord of all I survey.

Kåñëa consciousness is not an artificial imposition on the mind. This consciousness is the original, natural energy of the living entity. When we hear this transcendental vibration, this consciousness is revived.

This simplest method of meditation is recommended for this age. By practical experience also, one can perceive that by chanting this mahä-mantra, or the Great Chanting for Deliverance, one can at once feel a transcendental ecstasy coming through from the spiritual stratum. In the material concept of life we are busy in the matter of sense gratification, as if we were in the lower, animal stage. A little elevated from this status of sense gratification, one is engaged in mental speculation for the purpose of getting out of the material clutches. A little elevated from this speculative status, when one is intelligent enough, one tries to find out the supreme cause of all causes—within and without. And when one is factually on the plane of spiritual understanding, surpassing the stages of sense, mind, and intelligence, he is then on the transcendental plane. This chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra is enacted from the spiritual platform, and thus this sound vibration surpasses all lower strata of consciousness—namely sensual, mental, and intellectual. There is no need, therefore, to understand the language of the mantra, nor is there any need for mental speculation nor any intellectual adjustment for chanting this mahä-mantra. It is automatic, from the spiritual platform, and as such, anyone can take part in the chanting without any previous qualification. In a more advanced stage, of course, one is not expected to commit offenses on the grounds of spiritual understanding.

In the beginning, there may not be the presence of all transcendental ecstasies, which are eight in number. These are: (1) being stopped as though dumb, (2) perspiration, (3) standing up of hairs on the body, (4) dislocation of voice, (5) trembling, (6) fading of the body, (7) crying in ecstasy, and (8) trance. But there is no doubt that chanting for a while takes one immediately to the spiritual platform, and one shows the first symptom of this in the urge to dance along with the chanting of the mantra. We have seen this practically. Even a child can take part in the chanting and dancing. Of course, for one who is too entangled in material life, it takes a little more time to come to the standard point, but even such a materially engrossed man is raised to the spiritual platform very quickly. When the mantra is chanted by a pure devotee of the Lord in love, it has the greatest efficacy on hearers, and as such this chanting should be heard from the lips of a pure devotee of the Lord, so that immediate effects can be achieved. As far as possible, chanting from the lips of nondevotees should be avoided. Milk touched by the lips of a serpent has poisonous effects.

The word Harä is the form of addressing the energy of the Lord, and the words Kåñëa and Räma are forms of addressing the Lord Himself.

Both Kåñëa and Räma mean “the supreme pleasure,” and Harä is the supreme pleasure energy of the Lord, changed to Hare in the vocative. The supreme pleasure energy of the Lord helps us to reach the Lord.

The material energy, called mäyä, is also one of the multienergies of the Lord. And we, the living entities, are also the energy, marginal energy, of the Lord. The living entities are described as superior to material energy. When the superior energy is in contact with the inferior energy, an incompatible situation arises; but when the superior marginal energy is in contact with the superior energy, Harä, it is established in its happy, normal condition.

These three words, namely Hare, Kåñëa, and Räma, are the transcendental seeds of the mahä-mantra. The chanting is a spiritual call for the Lord and His energy, to give protection to the conditioned soul. This chanting is exactly like the genuine cry of a child for its mother’s presence. Mother Harä helps the devotee achieve the Lord Father’s grace, and the Lord reveals Himself to the devotee who chants this mantra sincerely.

No other means of spiritual realization is as effective in this age of quarrel and hypocrisy as the chanting of the mahä-mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

SSR 5d: Kåñëa Consciousness—The Yoga for the Modern Age

Kåñëa Consciousness—The Yoga for the Modern Age

"It is not that this movement is simply a sentimental movement. Don't think that these boys are dancing out of some religious sentiment or fanaticism. No. We have the highest philosophical and theosophical background. . . . But it is all simplified. That is the beauty of this movement. Whether one is a great scholar or a child, he can take part without any difficulty."

ceto-darpaëa-märjanaà bhava-mahä-dävägni-nirväpaëaà
çreyaù-kairava-candrikä-vitaraëaà vidyä-vadhü-jévanam
änandämbudhi-vardhanaà prati-padaà pürëämåtäsvädanaà
sarvätma-snapanaà paraà vijayate çré-kåñëa-saìkértanam
[Çikñäñöaka 1]

All glories to the saìkértana movement. Paraà vijayate çré-kåñëa-saìkértanam. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, when He was only a sixteen-year-old boy, introduced this saìkértana movement five hundred years ago in Navadvépa, India. It was not that He manufactured some religious system, just as nowadays so many religious systems are being manufactured. Actually, religion cannot be manufactured. Dharmaà tu säkñäd bhagavat-praëétam. Religion means the codes of God, the laws of God, that’s all. Certainly we cannot live without obeying the state laws, and similarly we cannot live without obeying the laws of God. And in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.7] the Lord says that whenever there are discrepancies in the prosecution of religious activities (yadä yadä hi dharmasya glänir bhavati bhärata) and there is a predominance of irreligious activities (abhyutthänam adharmasya), at that time I (Kåñëa) appear (tadätmänaà såjämy aham). And in the material world we can see the same principle demonstrated, for whenever there is disobedience of state laws, there is the advent of some particular state officer or policeman to “set things right.”

Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu is worshiped by the Goswamis. There were six Goswamis: Rüpa Goswami, Sanätana Goswami, Raghunätha Bhaööa Goswami, Jéva Goswami, Gopäla Bhaööa Goswami, and Çré Raghunätha däsa Goswami. There are three meanings of go. Go means “land,” go means “cow,”and go means “senses.” And swami means “master.” So goswami means that they were masters of the senses. When one becomes master of the senses, or goswami, he can make progress in spiritual life. That is the real meaning of swami. Swami means that one is not servant of the senses, but master of them.

One of these six Goswamis, Rüpa Goswami, was the head, and he compiled a nice verse in honor of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. He says:

anarpita-caréà cirät karuëayävatérëaù kalau
samarpayitum unnatojjvala-rasäà sva-bhakti-çriyam
hariù puraöa-sundara-dyuti-kadamba-sandépitaù
sadä hådaya-kandare sphuratu vaù çacé-nandanaù
[Caitanya-caritämåta, Ädi 1.4]

Kalau means this age, this age of Kali, the Iron Age, which is very much contaminated, an age of quarrel and disagreement. Rüpa Goswami says that in this age of Kali, when everything is disagreement and quarrel, “You have descended to offer the highest love of God.” Samarpayitum unnatojjvala-rasäm: and not only the topmost, but a very brilliant rasa, or transcendental humor. Puraöa-sundara-dyuti: Your complexion is just like gold, like the luster of gold. “You are so kind that I bless everyone [the Goswamis can bless because they are masters of the senses] that this form of the Lord, Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, may always remain dancing in everyone’s heart.”

When Rüpa Goswami first met Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu at Prayäga, Lord Caitanya was chanting and dancing in the street, “Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa.” At that time also Rüpa Goswami offered one prayer. Namo mahä-vadänyäya kåñëa-prema-pradäya te: “Oh, You are the most munificent of all incarnations because You are distributing love of Godhead.” Kåñëa-prema-pradäya te/ kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-nämne gaura-tviñe namaù: “You are Kåñëa Himself, because if You were not Kåñëa You could not distribute kåñëa-prema, or love of God, for love of Kåñëa is not so easily acquired. But You are distributing this love freely to everyone.”

In this way the saìkértana movement was inaugurated in Bengal, India, in Navadvépa. In this sense, the Bengalis are very fortunate that in their country this movement was inaugurated by Lord Caitanya, who predicted:

prthivéte ache yata nagarädi gräma
sarvatra pracära haibe mora näma
[CB Antya 4.126]

“In all the villages and towns all over the world, everywhere, this saìkértana movement will be preached.” That is His prediction.

So by the grace of Lord Caitanya, this movement is already introduced in the Western countries, beginning from New York. Our saìkértana movement was first introduced in New York in 1966. At that time I came and began to chant this Hare Kåñëa mantra in Tompkins Square. I was chanting there for three hours with a small mådaìga (drum), and these American boys assembled and gradually joined, and so it is increasing. First of all it was started in a New York storefront, 26 Second Avenue, then we started our branches in San Francisco, Montreal, Boston, Los Angeles, Buffalo, Columbus. We now [1970] have twenty-four branches, including one in London and one in Hamburg. In London they are all American boys and girls, and they are preaching. They are not sannyäsés, nor are they Vedäntists, nor Hindus, nor Indians, but they have taken this movement very seriously. Even in the London Times there was an article headlined, “Kåñëa Chant Startles London.” So we have many in the movement now. All my disciples, at least in this country, are Americans and Europeans. They are chanting, dancing, and distributing a magazine, Back to Godhead. Now we have published many books—the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, Teachings of Lord Caitanya, and Éçopaniñad. It is not that this movement is simply a sentimental movement. Don’t think that these boys are dancing out of some religious sentiment or fanaticism. No. We have the highest philosophical and theosophical background.

As an illustration, let us consider Caitanya Mahäprabhu. While He was preaching, He went to Benares, the seat of Mäyävädé sannyäsés. The followers of Çaìkaräcärya are mostly seen in Benares. When Caitanya Mahäprabhu was there, He was chanting and dancing. Some of the people very much appreciated this, and so He quickly became famous. One prominent sannyäsé, Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté, leader of many thousands of Mäyävädé sannyäsés, was informed: “Oh, from Bengal one young sannyäsé has come. He is so nicely chanting and dancing.” Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté was a great Vedäntist, and he did not like the idea. He said, “Oh, he is a pseudo-sannyäsé. He is chanting and dancing, and this is not the business of a sannyäsé. A sannyäsé should always engage himself in the study of philosophy and the Vedänta.”

Then one of the devotees who did not like the remarks of Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté came back and informed Lord Caitanya that He was being criticized. So the devotee arranged a meeting of all the sannyäsés, and there was a philosophical discussion on the Vedänta between Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté and Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu.

These accounts and philosophical discussions are given in our Teachings of Lord Caitanya. It is remarkable that Prakäçänanda himself with all his disciples became Vaiñëavas.

Similarly, Caitanya Mahäprabhu had a great discussion with Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya, the greatest logician of that time, who was also Mäyävädé, impersonalist, and he was also converted. So Caitanya Mahäprabhu’s movement is not mere sentimentalism. There is a very rich background if one wants to understand this saìkértana movement through philosophy and logic. There is ample opportunity, for this movement is based on science and on the authority of the Vedas. But it is all simplified. That is the beauty of this movement. Whether one is a great scholar or philosopher or a child, he can take part without any difficulty. Other systems of self-realization, the jïäna process or yoga process, are also recognized, but it is not possible to practice them in this age. That is the verdict of the Vedas:

kåte yad dhyäyato viñëuà
tretäyäà yajato makhaiù
dväpare paricaryäyäà
kalau tad dhari-kértanät
[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 12.3.52]

In the Satya-yuga, the Golden Age, it was possible to execute the meditation process. For instance, Välméki Muni meditated for sixty thousand years to get perfection. But where is our old age? Besides that, for the meditation process, as described in the Bhagavad-gétä, one has to select a secluded place, he has to execute it alone, he has to sit down in a rigid posture, he has to lead a life of complete celibacy, and so on. There are many rules and regulations. Thus añöäìga-yoga meditation is not possible. If one is satisfied by imitating, that is a different thing, but if one wants perfection, then he has to execute all the eight stages of añöäìga-yoga. If this is not possible, then it is a waste of time.

What is the ultimate goal of the yoga process or meditation? Contact with the Supreme, the Supersoul, the Supreme Lord, is the aim and object of all yoga processes. Similarly, philosophical research, the jïäna process, also aims at understanding the Supreme Brahman. These are recognized processes, undoubtedly, but according to authoritative description, they are not practical in this Iron Age of Kali. Therefore one has to take to this process of hari-kértana. Anyone can practice without prequalification. One doesn’t have to study philosophy or Vedänta. This was the purport of Lord Caitanya’s meeting with Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté.

When the Vedänta philosophy was thoroughly discussed between Lord Caitanya and Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté, Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté first of all asked Caitanya Mahäprabhu, “I understand that You were a very good scholar in Your early life. [Lord Caitanya was actually a very great scholar. His name was Nimäi Paëòita, and at the age of sixteen He defeated a great scholar from Kashmir, Keçava Käçméré.] And I understand that You are a great Sanskrit scholar, and that especially in logic You are a very learned scholar. You were also born in a brähmaëa family, and now You are a sannyäsé. How is it that You are chanting and dancing and not reading the Vedänta?” This was the first question asked by Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté, and Lord Caitanya replied, “Yes, the reason is that when I was initiated by My spiritual master, he said that I am fool number one. [Ädi 7.71] ‘You don’t discuss the Vedänta,’ he told Me. ‘You will simply spoil Your time. Just take to this chanting of Hare Kåñëa, and You will be successful.’” That was his reply. Of course, Caitanya Mahäprabhu was not a fool, and certainly the Vedänta is not for fools. One needs sufficient education, and one must attain a certain status before he can understand the Vedänta. In each and every word there are volumes of meanings, and there are many commentaries by Çaìkaräcärya and Rämänujäcärya, huge volumes in Sanskrit. But how can we understand Vedänta? It is not possible. It may be possible for one person or two persons to understand, but for the mass of people it is not possible. Nor is it possible to practice yoga. Therefore, if one takes to Caitanya Mahäprabhu’s method, chanting Hare Kåñëa, the first installment of gain will be ceto-darpaëa-märjanam: all the dirty things will be cleansed from the heart simply by chanting. Chant. There is no expenditure and there is no loss. If one simply chants for one week, he will see how much he will progress in spiritual knowledge.

We are attracting many students simply by chanting, and they are understanding the entire philosophy and becoming purified. This Society’s movement started only four years ago, in 1966, and we have so many branches already. The American boys and girls are taking it very seriously, and they are happy. Ask any one of them. Ceto-darpaëa-märjanam. They are cleansing the dirty things from the heart, simply by chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

The next point is bhava-mahädävägni-nirväpaëam: as soon as the heart is cleansed of all dirty things, then all the problems of material existence are immediately solved. This world has been compared to dävägni, which means a blazing fire in the forest. In this material existence no one wants unhappiness, but it comes by force. That is the law of material nature. No one wants fire, but wherever we go in a city the fire brigade is always active. There is always fire. Similarly, there are many things that no one wants. No one wants death—there is death. No one wants disease—there is disease. No one wants old age—there is old age. They are there, against our will, against our desire.

Thus we should consider the state of this material existence. This human form of life is meant for understanding, not for wasting valuable life like animals by eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. That is not advancement of civilization. The Bhägavatam says that this body is not meant for working hard simply for sense gratification.

näyaà deho deha-bhäjäà nåloke
kañöän kämän arhate viò-bhujäà ye
[Bhäg. 5.5.1]

To work very hard and satisfy oneself by sense gratification is the business of hogs, not human beings. The human being should learn tapasya. Especially in India, so many great sages, so many great kings, and so many brahmacärés and sannyäsés have passed their lives in great tapasya in order not to go further to sleep. Lord Buddha was a prince who gave up everything and engaged himself in tapasya. This is life. When King Bhärata, under whose name India was named Bhärata-varña, was twenty-four years old, he gave up his kingdom, his young wife, and young children and went away for tapasya. When Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu was only twenty-four, He gave up His young wife, mother, everything. There are many, many examples. India is the land of tapasya, but we are forgetting that. Now we are making it the land of technology. It is surprising that India is now no longer propagating this tapasya, for India is the land of dharma: dharma-kñetre kurukñetre.

But it is not only in India; everywhere in this age of iron everything is degraded, degraded in this sense: präyeëälpäyuñaù sabhya kaläv asmin yuge janäù [Bhäg. 1.1.10]. In this age of Kali the duration of life is diminished, and men are not moved to understand self-realization, and if they are, they are invariably misled by so many deceitful leaders. The age is very corrupt. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu’s process of chanting Hare Kåñëa is the best and the simplest method.

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä

“In this age of Kali there is no other religion than glorifying the Lord by utterance of His holy name, and that is the injunction of all the revealed scriptures. There is no other way, there is no other way, there is no other way.” This verse appears in the Brhan-näradéya Puräëa. Harer näma harer näma harer nämaiva kevalam. Simply chant Hare Kåñëa. There is no other alternative. Kalau nästy eva nästy eva nästy eva gatir anyathä. In this age, Kali, there is no other alternative for self-realization. So we have to accept it.

There is another similar verse in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. In the Twelfth Canto, Third Chapter [12.3.51], Parékñit Mahäräja was informed by Çukadeva Goswami of the faults of this age, and now all the symptoms of the age of Kali are apparent. In the conclusive portion, however, Çukadeva Goswami said, kaler doña-nidhe räjann asti hy eko mahän guëaù: "My dear king, this age, Kali, is full of faulty things, but there is one good opportunity." What is that? Kértanäd eva kåñëasya mukta-saìgaù paraà vrajet: “Simply by chanting this Hare Kåñëa mantra one can become liberated and go back to Godhead.”

This is practical and authorized, and one can also test himself to see how he is advancing simply by chanting. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is not something new, something that we have introduced or manufactured. It is authorized on the Vedic principles, authorized by äcäryas like Caitanya Mahäprabhu and others. And the method is very simple; there is no loss. We are not charging anything, we are not asking for fees and giving the people some secret mantra and promising them that within six months they will become God. No. This is open for everyone—children, women, girls, boys, old people—every-one can chant and see the results.

To further this end we not only are establishing New Våndävana, our farm project in West Virginia, but are establishing other spiritual communities, such as New Navadvépa and New Jagannätha Puré. We have already started New Jagannätha Puré in San Francisco, and the Ratha-yäträ festival is going on. This year there will be a great ceremony of Ratha-yäträ in London also. There will be three cars, for Jagannätha, Subhadrä, and Balaräma, and they will be taken to the River Thames. And America has imported New England and New York, so why not New Våndävana? We should especially establish this New Våndävana, because Lord Caitanya recommended, ärädhyo bhagavän vrajeça-tanayas tad-dhäma våndävanam: “Kåñëa, the son of Nanda Mahäräja, in the Våndävana-dhäma of Vrajabhümi, is the supreme worshipable Deity, and His place Våndävana is also worshipable.” The Western boys and girls are taking to Kåñëa consciousness, and they should have a place like Våndävana. Swami Kértanänanda, who went to Våndävana with me two years ago, knows what Våndävana is like, so I have instructed him to construct at least seven temples. In Våndävana, there are five thousand temples of Rädhä-Kåñëa, but the most important temples are seven, established by the Goswamis. Our program is to live in New Våndävana, depend on agriculture and cows as an economic solution, and peacefully execute Kåñëa consciousness, chant Hare Kåñëa—that is the Våndävana scheme. Yuktähära-vihärasya... yogo bhavati duùkha-hä [Bhagavad-gétä 6.17]. This human form of life isn’t meant for increasing artificial needs. We should be satisfied just to maintain the body and soul together, and the rest of the time we should enhance our Kåñëa consciousness, so that after leaving this body we won’t have to take another material body, but will be able to go back home, back to Godhead. That should be the motto of human life.

Material life means eating, sleeping, mating, and defending, and spiritual life means something more than this. This is also the difference between animal life and human life. In animal life, the common formula is eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. A dog eats, a man also eats. A man sleeps, and a dog also sleeps. A man has sex life, and the dog also has sex life. The dog defends in his own way, and man also defends in his own way, maybe by atomic bombs. These four principles are common to human beings and animals, and advancement of these four principles is not human civilization but animal civilization. Human civilization means athäto brahma-jijïäsä. In the Vedänta-sütra the first aphorism is athäto brahma jijïäsä: “Now is the time for inquiry about Brahman.” That is human life. As long as one is not spiritually inquisitive, jijïäsuù çreya uttamam, he is an animal, because he lives according to these four principles, that’s all. He must be inquisitive to know what he is and why he is put into these miseries of birth, death, old age, and disease. Is there any remedy? These matters should be questioned. That is human life; that is spiritual life.

Spiritual life means human life, and material life means animal life. That’s all. We have to make the adjustments that are recommended in the Bhagavad-gétä. Yuktähära-vihärasya. For instance, because I am going to be a spiritual man does not mean that I shall give up eating. Rather, my eating should be adjusted. The Bhagavad-gétä describes what class of food is first class, in goodness, and what class of food is in passion, and third class, in ignorance. We have to raise ourselves to the sattvic (goodness) platform of human civilization, then revive our transcendental consciousness, or Kåñëa consciousness. Everything is there in the çästras. Unfortunately, we do not consult them.

evaà prasanna-manaso
bhagavad-bhakti-yogataù
bhagavat-tattva-vijïänaà
mukta-saìgasya jäyate
[Bhäg. 1.2.20]

Unless one is liberated from the clutches of these three modes of material nature, he cannot understand God. Prasanna-manasaù. One must be a Brahman-realized soul. Brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä na çocati na käìkñati [Bg. 18.54]. These injunctions are there, so one should take advantage of these çästras and preach. That is the responsibility of intelligent men. The mass of people know that God is great, but they do not know how great God actually is. That we will find in the Vedic literature. That is our duty in this iron age. That is hari-kértana, paraà vijayate çré-kåñëa-saìkértanam: glorification of the Supreme.

SSR 5e: Meditation and the Self Within

Meditation and the Self Within

Can meditation solve our everyday problems? Is there life after death? Can drugs help us achieve self-realization? During a visit to South Africa in 1976, Çréla Prabhupäda answers these and other questions for interviewer Bill Faill of the Durban Natal Mercury.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is a name for God that means "all-attractive." Unless one is all-attractive he cannot be God. So Kåñëa consciousness means God consciousness. All of us are small particles of God, equal in quality with Him. Our position as living entities is like that of a small particle of gold in relation to a large quantity of gold.

Mr. Faill: Are we something like sparks in a fire?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Both the fire and the spark are fire, but one is big, and the other is very small. Unlike the relationship between the spark and the fire, however, our relationship with God is eternal, although at the present moment we have forgotten that relationship due to contact with the material energy. We are facing so many problems only because of this forgetfulness. If we can revive our original God consciousness, then we shall become happy. This is the sum and substance of Kåñëa consciousness. It is the best process by which to revive our original God consciousness. There are different processes of self-realization, but in the present age of Kali, people are very fallen, and they require the simple process of Kåñëa consciousness. Now they are thinking that so-called material advancement is the solution to their problems, but this is not a fact. The real solution is to get out of the material condition entirely by becoming Kåñëa conscious. Because God is eternal, we are also eternal, but in the material condition we are thinking, "I am this body," and therefore we must repeatedly change from body to body. This is due to ignorance. Actually we are not our bodies but spiritual sparks, parts and parcels of God.

Mr. Faill: Then the body is just like a vehicle for the soul?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. It is just like a motorcar. Just as you go from one place to another in a car, so due to mental concoction in the material condition of life, we are going from one position to another, trying to become happy. But nothing will make us happy unless we come to our real position, which is that we are all parts and parcels of God and that our real business is to associate with God and help all living entities by cooperating with Him. Civilized human life is attained only after a long evolution through 8,400,00 species of life. So if we don't take advantage of this civilized human life to understand who God is, who we are, and what our relationship is, but instead simply waste our life like cats and dogs, going here and there looking for sense gratification, then we will have missed a great opportunity. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant to teach people how to take full advantage of the human form of life by trying to understand God and our relationship with Him.

Mr. Faill: If we don't make the most of this life, do we get a second chance, in another life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. According to your desires at the time of death, you get another body. That body is not guaranteed to be a human body, however. As I've already explained, there are 8,400,000 different forms of life. You can enter any of them, according to your mental condition at death. What we think of at the time of death depends on how we act during our life. As long as we are in material consciousness, our actions are under the control of the material nature, which is being conducted in three modes: goodness, passion, and ignorance. These modes are like the three basic colors—yellow, red, and blue. Just as one can mix red, yellow, and blue to produce millions of colors, the modes of nature are being mixed to produce many varieties of life. To stop the repetition of birth and death in different forms of life, we must transcend the covering of material nature and come to the platform of pure consciousness. But if we do not learn the transcendental science of Kåñëa consciousness, then at death we must transfer to another body, either better or worse than our present one. If we cultivate the mode of goodness, then we are promoted to the higher planetary system, where there is a better standard of life. If we cultivate the mode of passion, then we will remain at the present stage. But if out of ignorance we commit sinful activities and violate nature's laws, then we will be degraded to animal or plant life. Then again we must evolve to the human form, a process that may take millions of years. Therefore a human being must be responsible. He must take advantage of the rare opportunity of human life by understanding his relationship with God and acting accordingly. Then he can get out of the cycle of birth and death in different forms of life and go back home, back to Godhead.

Mr. Faill: Do you think transcendental meditation is helping people?

Çréla Prabhupäda: They do not know what real meditation is. Their meditation is simply a farce—another cheating process by the so-called swamis and yogés. You're asking me if meditation is helping people, but do you know what meditation is?

Mr. Faill: A stilling of the mind—trying to sit in the center without swinging either way.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And what is the center?

Mr. Faill: I don't know.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So everyone is talking very much about meditation, but no one knows what meditation actually is. These bluffers use the word "meditation," but they do not know the proper subject for meditation. They're simply talking bogus propaganda.

Mr. Faill: Isn't meditation valuable just to get people thinking right?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Real meditation means to achieve a state in which the mind is saturated with God consciousness. But if you do not know what God is, how can you meditate? Besides, in this age people's minds are so agitated that they cannot concentrate. I have seen this so-called meditation; they are simply sleeping and snoring. Unfortunately, in the name of God consciousness or "self-realization," many bluffers are presenting nonstandard methods of meditation without referring to the authorized books of Vedic knowledge. They are simply practicing another type of exploitation.

Mr. Faill: What about some of the other teachers, like Ouspensky and Gurdjieff? In the past they brought to the West a message similar to yours.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We would have to study the particulars of their teachings to know whether they meet the Vedic standard. God consciousness is a science, just like medical science or any other science. It cannot be different because it is spoken by different men. Two plus two equals four everywhere, never five, or three. That is science.

Mr. Faill: Do you feel that others may have possibly taught the genuine method of God consciousness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Unless I study their teachings in detail, it would be very difficult to say. There are so many bluffers.

Mr. Faill: Just doing it for money.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That's all. They have no standard method. Therefore we are presenting the Bhagavad-gétä as it is, without any personal interpretation. This is standard.

Mr. Faill: Yes, if you begin dressing things up, you inevitably change them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa consciousness is not a new process. It is very, very old—and standard. It cannot be changed. As soon as you try to change it, then the potency is lost. This potency is just like electricity. If you want to generate electricity, you must follow the standard regulations, arranging all the negative and positive poles properly. You cannot construct the generator whimsically and still produce electricity. Similarly, there is a standard method of understanding Kåñëa conscious philosophy from proper authorities. If we follow their instructions, then the process will act. Unfortunately, one of the dangerous diseases of modern man is that everyone wants to do things according to his own whims. No one wants to follow the standard way. Therefore everyone is failing, both spiritually and materially.

Mr. Faill: Is the Kåñëa consciousness movement growing?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Oh, yes, very much. You may be surprised to know that we are selling books in the tens of thousands. We have about fifty books, and many librarians and college professors are very appreciative of them, because until their publication there was no such literature in existence. It is a new contribution to the world.

Mr. Faill: Kåñëa consciousness seems to involve shaving the head and wearing saffron robes. How can an ordinary man caught up in family life practice Kåñëa consciousness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The saffron robes and the shaven head are not essential, although they create a good mental situation, just as when a military man is dressed properly he gets energy—he feels like a military man. Does that mean that unless he is in uniform he cannot fight? No. In the same way, God consciousness cannot be checked—it can be revived in any circumstances—but certain conditions are helpful. Therefore we prescribe that you live in a certain way, dress in a certain way, eat in a certain way, and so on. These things are helpful for practicing Kåñëa consciousness, but they are not essential.

Mr. Faill: Then one can be a student of Kåñëa consciousness while going about normal daily life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Mr. Faill: How about drugs? Can they help in the process of God realization?

Çréla Prabhupäda: If drugs could help God realization, then drugs would be more powerful than God. How can we accept that? Drugs are chemical substances, which are material. How can something material help one realize God, who is all-spiritual? It is impossible. What one experiences from taking drugs is simply a kind of intoxication or hallucination; it is not God realization.

Mr. Faill: Do you think the great mystics down through the ages have actually seen the spiritual spark you mentioned earlier?

Çréla Prabhupäda: What do you mean by "mystic"?

Mr. Faill: It's just a name given to people who have had an experience of another level of reality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We don't use the word "mystic". Our reality is God realization, which occurs when we come to the spiritual platform. As long as we have a bodily concept of life, our understanding is sense gratification, because the body is made of senses. When we progress from the bodily platform and we see the mind as the center of sense activity, we take the mind as the final stage of realization. That is the mental platform. From the mental platform we may come to the intellectual platform, and from the intellectual platform we can rise to the transcendental platform. Finally we can rise above even the transcendental platform and come to the mature, spiritual platform. These are the stages of God realization. However, in this age, because people are so fallen, the çästras [scriptures] give the special recommendation that people come directly to the spiritual platform by chanting the holy names of God: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. If we cultivate this practice on the spiritual platform, then immediately we can realize our spiritual identity. Then the process of God realization becomes successful very quickly.

Mr. Faill: Today a lot of people are saying that we must look inward for the truth rather than outward into the world of the senses.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Looking inward means knowing that you are a spirit soul. Unless you understand that you are not the body but a soul, there is no question of looking inward.

First we have to study, "Am I this body, or am I something within this body?" Unfortunately, this subject is not taught in any school, college, or university. Everyone is thinking, "I am this body." For example, in this country people everywhere are thinking, "I am South African, they are Indian, they are Greek," and so on. Actually, everyone in the whole world is in the bodily conception of life. Kåñëa consciousness starts when one is above this bodily conception.

Mr. Faill: So the recognition of the spiritual spark comes first?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Recognizing the existence of the spirit soul within the body is the first step. Unless one understands this simple fact, there is no question of spiritual advancement.

Mr. Faill: Is it a question of just understanding it intellectually?

Çréla Prabhupäda: In the beginning, yes. There are two departments of knowledge: theoretical and practical. First one must learn spiritual science theoretically; then, by working on that spiritual platform, one comes to the point of practical realization.

Unfortunately, today almost everyone is in the darkness of the bodily conception of life. Therefore this movement is very important, because it can lift civilized men out of that darkness. As long as they are in the bodily conception of life, they are no better than animals. "I am a dog," "I am a cat," "I am a cow." Animals think like this. As soon as someone passes, a dog will bark, thinking, "I am a dog. I have been appointed here as watchdog." Similarly, if I adopt the dog's mentality and challenge foreigners—"Why have you come to this country? Why have you come to my jurisdiction?"—then what is the difference between the dog and me?

Mr. Faill: There is none. To change the subject a little, is it necessary to follow certain eating habits to practice spiritual life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the whole process is meant to purify us, and eating is part of that purification. I think you have a saying, "You are what you eat," and that's a fact. Our bodily constitution and mental atmosphere are determined according to how and what we eat. Therefore the çästras recommend that to become Kåñëa conscious, you should eat remnants of food left by Kåñëa. If a tuberculosis patient eats something and you eat the remnants, you will be infected with tuberculosis. Similarly, if you eat kåñëa-prasäda, then you will be infected with Kåñëa consciousness. Thus our process is that we don't eat anything immediately. First we offer the food to Kåñëa, then we eat it. This helps us advance in Kåñëa consciousness.

Mr. Faill: You are all vegetarians?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, because Kåñëa is a vegetarian. Kåñëa can eat anything because He is God, but in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.26] He says, "If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit, or water, I will accept it." He never says, "Give Me meat and wine."

Mr. Faill: How about the tobacco question?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Tobacco is also an intoxicant. We are already intoxicated by being in the bodily conception of life, and if we increase the intoxication, then we are lost.

Mr. Faill: You mean things like meat, alcohol, and tobacco just reinforce bodily consciousness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Suppose you have a disease and you want to be cured. You have to follow the instructions of a physician. if he says, "Don't eat this; eat only this," you have to follow his prescription. Similarly, we also have a prescription for being cured of the bodily conception of life: chanting Hare Kåñëa, hearing about Kåñëa's activities, and eating kåñëa-prasäda. This treatment is the process of Kåñëa consciousness.

SSR 6: Finding the Cure for Today's Social Ills

VI. Finding the Cure for Today's Social Ills

SSR 6a: Crime: Why and What to Do?

Crime: Why and What to Do?

In this July 1975 interview, Chicago Police Department media relations man Lt. David Mozee asks about curbing the upward-spiraling U.S. crime rate. Çréla Prabhupäda replies, "If human beings are not given the facility to learn about God, then they remain on the level of cats and dogs. You cannot have peace in a society of cats and dogs. . . . The thief and murderer already know the law, yet they still commit violent crimes due to their unclean hearts. So our process is to cleanse the heart." [related BTG articles-1, 2]

Lieutenant Mozee: I understand you have some ideas that could help us in our efforts to prevent crime. I'd be very interested to hear them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The difference between a pious man and a criminal is that one is pure in heart and the other is dirty. This dirt is like a disease in the form of uncontrollable lust and greed in the heart of the criminal. Today people in general are in this diseased condition, and thus crime is very widespread. When the people become purified of these dirty things, crime will disappear. The simplest process of purification is to assemble in congregation and chant the holy names of God. This is called saìkértana and is the basis of our Kåñëa consciousness movement. So, if you want to stop crime, then you must gather as many people as possible for mass saìkértana. This congregational chanting of the holy name of God will dissipate all the dirty things in everyone's heart. Then there will be no more crime.

Lieutenant Mozee: Do you have any feelings about crime here in the United States as opposed to the crime in your own country of India?

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is your definition of crime?

Lieutenant Mozee: Any trampling on the rights of one person by another person.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Our definition is the same. In the Upaniñads it is said, éçäväsyam idaà sarvam: "Everything belongs to God." So, everyone has the right to utilize whatever is allotted to him by God, but one may not encroach upon others' property. if one does so, he becomes a criminal. Actually the first crime is that you Americans are thinking this land of America is yours. Although two hundred years ago it was not yours, you have come from other parts of the world and claimed it as your land. Actually it is God's land, and therefore it belongs to everyone, since everyone is a child of God. But the vast majority of people have no conception of God. Practically speaking, everyone is godless. Therefore they should be educated to love God. In America, your government has a slogan: "In God we trust." Is that correct?

Lieutenant Mozee: Yes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But where is the education about God? To trust is very good, but simple trust will not endure unless it is backed up with scientific knowledge of God. One may know that he has a father, but unless he knows who his father is, his knowledge is imperfect. And that education in the science of God is lacking.

Lieutenant Mozee: Do you feel that it's lacking only here in the United States?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Everywhere. The age we live in is called Kali-yuga, the age of forgetting God. It is an age of misunderstanding and quarrel, and the people's hearts are filled with dirty things. But God is so powerful that if we chant His holy name we become purified, just as my disciples have become purified of their bad habits. Our movement is based on this principle of chanting the holy name of God. We give everyone the opportunity, without any distinction. They can come to our temple, chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra, take a little prasäda* as refreshment, and gradually become purified. So if the governmental authorities give us some facilities, then we can hold mass saìkértana. Then, without a doubt, the whole society will change.

Lieutenant Mozee: If I understand you correctly, sir, you are saying that we should emphasize a return to religious principles.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly. Without religious principles what is the difference between a dog and a man? Man can understand religion, but a dog cannot. That is the difference. So if human society remains on the level of dogs and cats, how can you expect a peaceful society? If you bring a dozen dogs and put them together in a room, will it be possible to keep them peaceful? Similarly, if human society is filled with men whose mentality is on the level of dogs, how can you expect peace?

Lieutenant Mozee: If some of my questions sound disrespectful, it is only because I do not completely understand your religious beliefs. I mean no disrespect whatsoever.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, it is not a question of my religious beliefs. I am simply pointing out the distinction between human life and animal life. Animals cannot possibly learn anything about God, but human beings can. However, if human beings are not given the facility to learn about God, then they remain on the level of cats and dogs. You cannot have peace in a society of cats and dogs. Therefore, it is the duty of the governmental authorities to see that people are taught how to become God conscious. Otherwise, there will be trouble, because without God consciousness there is no difference between a dog and a man: the dog eats, we eat; the dog sleeps, we sleep; a dog has sex, we have sex; a dog tries to defend itself, and we also try to defend ourselves. These are the common factors. The only difference is that a dog cannot be instructed about his relationship with God, but a man can.

Lieutenant Mozee: Wouldn't peace be a precursor to a return to religion? Must we not first have peace?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, no, that is the difficulty. At the present moment, no one actually knows the meaning of religion. Religion means to abide by the laws of God, just as good citizenship means to abide by the laws of the government. Because no one has any understanding of God, no one knows the laws of God or the meaning of religion. This is the present status of people in today's society. They are forgetting religion, taking it to be a kind of faith. Faith may be blind faith. Faith is not the real description of religion. Religion means the laws given by God, and anyone who follows those laws is religious, whether a Christian, a Hindu, or a Muslim.

Lieutenant Mozee: With all due respect, isn't it true that in India, where religious customs have been followed for centuries upon centuries, we are seeing not a return to but a drawing away from spiritual life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but it is due only to bad leadership. Otherwise, the vast majority of the Indian people are fully conscious of God, and they try to follow the laws of God. Here in the West, even big college professors do not believe in God or in life after death. But in India, even the poorest man believes in God and in a next life. He knows that if he commits sins he will suffer and if he acts piously he will enjoy. To this day, if there is a disagreement between two villagers, they will go to the temple to settle it, because everyone knows that the opposite parties will hesitate to speak lies before the Deities. So in most respects, India is still eighty-percent religious. That is the special privilege of taking birth in India, and the special responsibility also. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has said,

bhärata-bhümite haila manuñya-janma yära
janma särthaka kari' kara para-upakära
[Caitanya-caritämåta, Ädi 9.41]

Anyone who has taken birth in India should make his life perfect by becoming Kåñëa conscious. Then he should distribute Kåñëa consciousness all over the world.

Lieutenant Mozee: Sir, there is a Christian parable that says it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to come before the throne of God. Do you think the wealth of the United States and other Western countries is a block to spiritual faith?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Too much wealth is a block. Kåñëa states in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.44]:

bhogaiçvarya-prasaktänäà
tayäpahåta-cetasäm
vyavasäyätmikä buddhiù
samädhau na vidhéyate

If one is materially very opulent, he forgets God. Therefore too much material wealth is a disqualification for understanding God. Although there is no absolute law that only the poor man can understand God, generally if one is extraordinarily rich, his only ambition is to acquire money, and it is difficult for him to understand spiritual teachings.

Lieutenant Mozee: In America, those who belong to the Christian faith also believe these things. I don't see any vast differences between the spiritual beliefs of one religious group and another.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the essence of all religion is the same. Our proposal is that whatever religious system one follows, he should try to understand God and love Him. If you are a Christian, we do not say, "That is no good; you must become like us." Our proposition is that whether you are a Christian, Muslim, or Hindu, simply try to understand God and love Him.

Lieutenant Mozee: If I could return to my original purpose for coming, might I ask what advice you could give to assist us in reducing crime? I recognize that the first and foremost way would be a return to God, as you say—there's no doubt about that—but is there something that we could immediately do to diminish this spreading criminal mentality?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. As I've already outlined in the beginning of our talk, you should give us the facility to chant the holy name of God and distribute prasäda. Then there will be a tremendous change in the population. I came alone from India, and now I have many followers. What did I do? I asked them to sit down and chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra, and afterward I distributed a little prasäda. If this is done on a mass scale, the entire society will become very pleasing. This is a fact.

Lieutenant Mozee: Would you want to start the program in an area of affluence or an area of poverty?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We do not draw such distinctions. Any place easily available to all kinds of men would be very suitable to hold saìkértana. There is no restriction that only the poor men need the benefit but the rich do not. Everyone needs to be purified. Do you think criminality exists only in the poorer section of society?

Lieutenant Mozee: No. But I meant to ask whether there would be more of a beneficial influence—more of a strengthening of the community—if the program were held in a poorer area rather than an affluent area.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our treatment is for the spiritually diseased person. When a person is afflicted with a disease, there are no distinctions between a poor man and a rich man. They are both admitted to the same hospital. Just as the hospital should be in a place where both the poor man and the rich man can easily come, the location of the saìkértana facility should be easily accessible to all. Since everyone is materially infected, everyone should be able to take advantage.

The difficulty is that the rich man thinks he's perfectly healthy, although he's the most diseased of all. But as a policeman, you well know that there's criminality among rich men and poor men alike. So our chanting process is for everyone, because it cleanses the heart, regardless of the man's opulence or poverty. The only way to permanently change the criminal habit is to change the heart of the criminal. As you well know, many thieves are arrested numerous times and put into jail. Although they know that if they commit theft they will go to jail, still they are forced to steal because of their unclean hearts. Therefore without cleansing the heart of the criminal, you cannot stop crime simply by more stringent law enforcement. The thief and the murderer already know the law, yet they still commit violent crimes, due to their unclean hearts. So our process is to cleanse the heart. Then all the troubles of this material world will be solved.

Lieutenant Mozee: That's a very difficult task, sir.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not difficult. Simply invite everyone: "Come, chant Hare Kåñëa, dance, and take sumptuous prasädam." What is the difficulty? We are doing this at our centers, and people are coming. But because we have very little money, we can hold saìkértana only on a small scale. We invite everyone, and gradually people are coming to our centers and becoming devotees. If the government would give us a large facility, however, we could expand unlimitedly. And the problem is big; otherwise why are there national news articles asking what to do? No civil state wants this criminality. That's a fact. But the leaders do not know how to stop it. If they listen to us, however, we can give them the answer. Why crime? Because people are godless. And what to do? Chant Hare Kåñëa and take prasädam. If you like, you can adopt this process of saìkértana. Otherwise, we will continue conducting it on a small scale. We are just like a poor medical man with a small private practice who could open a big hospital if he were given the facility. The government is the executor. If they take our advice and adopt the process of saìkértana, then the problem of crime will be solved.

Lieutenant Mozee: There are many Christian organizations in the United States that give the holy communion. Why doesn't this work? Why is this not cleansing the heart?

Çréla Prabhupäda: To speak frankly, I find it difficult to find even one real Christian. The so-called Christians do not abide by the Bible's order. One of the ten commandments in the Bible is, "Thou shalt not kill." But where is that Christian who does not kill by eating the flesh of the cow? The process of chanting the Lord's holy name and distributing prasädam will be effective if carried out by persons who are actually practicing religion. My disciples are trained to strictly follow religious principles, and therefore their chanting of the holy name of God is different from others'. Theirs is not simply a rubber-stamped position. They have realized the purifying power of the holy name through practice.

Lieutenant Mozee: Sir, isn't the difficulty that although a small circle of priests and devotees may follow the religious principles, those on the fringe deviate and cause trouble? For example, assume that the Hare Kåñëa movement grows to gigantic proportions, as Christianity has. Wouldn't you then have a problem with people on the fringe of the movement who professed to be followers but were actually not?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That possibility is always there, but all I am saying is that if you are not a true Christian, then your preaching will not be effective. And because we are strictly following religious principles, our preaching will be effective in spreading God consciousness and alleviating the problem of crime.

Lieutenant Mozee: Sir, let me thank you for your time. I will deliver this tape recording to my superiors. Hopefully, it will be effective, as you are effective.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Thank you very much.

SSR 6b: Can We Keep Society from Going to the Dogs?

Can We Keep Society from Going to the Dogs?

Çréla Prabhupäda speaks out to India's Bhavan's Journal: "A dog comes when there are some eatables; I say 'Hut!' and he goes away. But again he comes-he has no memory. So when our memory of God is reducing, that means that our human qualities are reducing.... There is no religion, simply a dog's race. The dog is running on four legs, and you are running on four wheels—that's all. And you think that the four-wheel race is advancement of civilization!"

Interviewer: The first question is this: Is the influence of religion on the wane? And if so, does this factor account for the increase in corruption and the widespread deterioration of moral values?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, religion is on the wane. This is predicted in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [12.2.1]:

tataç cänudinaà dharmaù
satyaà çaucaà kñamä dayä
kälena balinä räjan
naìkñyaty äyur balaà småtiù

"In the Kali-yuga [the present age of quarrel and hypocrisy] the following things will diminish: religion, truthfulness, cleanliness, mercy, duration of life, bodily strength, and memory."

These are human assets, which make the human being distinct from the animal. But these things will decline. There will be no mercy, there will be no truthfulness, memory will be short, and the duration of life will be cut short. Similarly, religion will vanish. That means that gradually we will come to the platform of animals.

Interviewer: Religion will vanish? We'll become animals?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Especially when there is no religion, it is simply animal life. Any common man can distinguish that the dog does not understand what religion is. The dog is also a living being, but he is not interested in understanding the Bhagavad-gétä or the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. He is not interested. That is the distinction between man and dog: the animal is not interested.

So when the human beings become uninterested in religious things, then they are animals. And how can there be happiness or peace in animal society? They want to keep people like animals, and they are making a United Nations. How is it possible? United animals, society for united animals? These things are going on.

Interviewer: Do you see any hopeful signs?

Çréla Prabhupäda: At least they have detected that religion is declining. That is good. "Declining" means they are going to be animals. In logic it is said that man is a rational animal. When the rationality is missing, then he is simply an animal, not a human being. In human society either you become Christian, Muhammadan, Hindu, or Buddhist; it doesn't matter. There must be some system of religion. Human society without religion is animal society. This is a plain fact. Why are people so unhappy now? Because there is no religion. They are neglecting religion.

One gentleman has written me that Tolstoy once said, "Unless dynamite is put underneath the church, there cannot be any peace." Even now the Russian government is very strictly against God consciousness, because they think that religion has spoiled the whole social atmosphere.

Interviewer: It seems there could be some truth in that.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The religious system might have been misused, but that does not mean that religion should be avoided. Real religion should be taken. It does not mean that because religion has not been properly executed by the so-called priests, religion should be rejected. If my eye is giving me some trouble on account of a cataract, it does not mean that the eye should be plucked out. The cataract should be removed. That is Kåñëa consciousness.

Interviewer: I think history shows that many people have misused religion. Isn't that a fact?

Çréla Prabhupäda: These people have no conception of God, and they are preaching religion. What is religion? Dharmaà tu säkñäd bhagavat-praëétam: "The path of religion is directly enunciated by the Supreme Lord." They have no conception of God—they do not know what God is—and they are professing some religion. How long can it go on artificially? It will deteriorate.

That has become the present condition. They have no idea of God, so how will they know what is the order of God? Religion means the order of God. For example, law means the order of the state. If there is no state, then where is the order? We have a clear conception of God—Kåñëa. He is giving His order, and we accept it. It is clear religion. If there is no God, no conception of God, no order of God, then where is religion? If there is no government, then where is the law?

Interviewer: Well, there wouldn't be any law. It would be an outlaw society.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Outlaw—everyone is an outlaw, manufacturing his own concocted system of religion. That is going on.

Just ask—in any religious system, what is their conception of God? Can anyone tell clearly? No one can tell. But we shall immediately say,

veëuà kvaëantam aravinda-daläyatäkñaà
barhävataàsam asitämbuda-sundaräìgam
kandarpa-koöi-kamanéya-viçeña-çobhaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is adept in playing on His flute, whose blooming eyes are like lotus petals, whose head is bedecked with a peacock's feather, whose figure of beauty is tinged with the hue of blue clouds, and whose unique loveliness charms millions of Cupids." [Brahma-saàhitä 5.30] Immediately, we can give a description of God.

If there is no idea of God, then what kind of religion is that?

Interviewer: I don't know.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is bogus. People have no conception of God, and therefore they have no understanding of religion. That is the decline, and because religion is declining, the human beings are becoming more and more like animals.

"Animal" means that one has no memory. A dog comes when there are some eatables; I say "Hut!" and he goes away. But again he comes—he has no memory. So when our memory of God is reducing, that means that our human qualities are reducing. In the Kali-yuga these human qualities will be reduced. That means that people are becoming like cats and dogs.

Interviewer: Here's the second question: "The traditional charge against Vedic culture is that it is fatalistic, that it makes people slaves to the belief in predestination, and that it therefore inhibits progress. How far is this charge true?"

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is that progress? Is a dog's jumping progress? Is that progress? A dog is running here and there on four legs, and you are running here and there on the four wheels of the automobile. Is that progress? That is not the Vedic system. According to the Vedic system, the human being has a certain amount of energy, and since the human being has better consciousness than the animals, the energy of the human beings is more valuable than the energy of the animals.

Interviewer: Probably no one would dispute that the human being has more freedom or, I suppose, responsibility than the animals.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So human energy should be utilized for spiritual advancement, not that the energy should be employed to compete with the dog. The saintly person is not busy like the dog. Today people think that "dog-ness" is life, but actual life is spiritual progress. Therefore, the Vedic literature says,

tasyaiva hetoù prayateta kovido
na labhyate yad bhramatäm upary adhaù
tal labhyate duùkha vad anyataù sukhaà
kälena sarvatra gabhéra-raàhasä

"Persons who are actually intelligent and philosophically inclined should endeavor only for that purposeful end which is not obtainable even by wandering from the topmost planet [Brahmaloka] down to the lowest planet [Pätäla]. As far as happiness derived from sense enjoyment is concerned, it can be obtained automatically in the course of time, just as in the course of time we obtain miseries, even though we do not desire them." [Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.5.18]

Interviewer: Could you explain that a little further?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The human being should exert his energy for that thing which he did not get in many, many lives. In many, many lives the soul has been in the forms of dogs, or demigods, or cats, birds, beasts, and many others. There are 8,400,000 different types of bodies. So this transmigration of the soul is going on. The business in every case is sense gratification.

Interviewer: Which means?

Çréla Prabhupäda: For example, the dog is busy for sense gratification: where is food, where is shelter, where is a female, where is defense? The man is also doing the same business, in different ways. This business is going on, life after life. Even a small insect is trying for the same thing. Birds, beasts, fish—everywhere the same struggle is going on. Where is food, where is sex, where is shelter, and how to defend? The Vedic literature says that these things we have done for many, many lives, and that if we don't get out of this struggle for existence, we will have to do them again for many, many lives.

Interviewer: I'm beginning to see.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, so these things should be stopped. Therefore, Prahläda Mahäräja makes this statement:

sukham aindriyakaà daityä
deha-yogena dehinäm
sarvatra labhyate daiväd
yathä duùkham ayatnataù

"My dear friends born of demoniac families, the happiness perceived with reference to the sense objects by contact with the body can be obtained in any form of life, according to one's past fruitive activities. Such happiness is automatically obtained without endeavor, just as we obtain distress." [Bhäg. 7.6.3]

A dog has a body, and I have a body. So, my sex pleasure and the dog's sex pleasure—there is no difference, the pleasure derived out of sex is the same. A dog is not afraid of having sex pleasure on the street before everyone, and we hide it. That's all. People are thinking that to have sex pleasure in a nice apartment is advanced. However, that is not advanced. And they are making a dog's race for this so-called advancement. People do not know that according to whatever kind of body one has acquired, the pleasure is already stored up.

Interviewer: What do you mean, "the pleasure is already stored up"?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is called destiny. A pig has got a certain type of body, and his eatable is the stool. You cannot change it. The pig will not like to eat halavah [a sweetmeat made of wheat toasted in butter]. It is not possible. Because he has a particular type of body, he must eat like that. Can any scientist improve the standard of living of the pig?

Interviewer: I doubt it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore, Prahläda Mahäräja says that it is already stored up. The pleasure is basically the same, but a little different according to the body. The uncivilized man in the jungle is having the same thing.

Now people are thinking that civilization means constructing skyscraper buildings. But Vedic civilization says, No, that is not advancement. The real advancement of human life is self-realization, how much you have realized your self. Not that you have constructed skyscraper buildings.

Interviewer: But wouldn't what you're saying make sense to most people?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sometimes people misunderstand. In a high-court, a judge is sitting soberly, apparently doing nothing, and he is getting a high salary. Someone else is thinking, "I am working so hard in the same court, rubber-stamping—and not getting one tenth the salary of the judge." He is thinking, "I am so busy, working so hard, and I am not getting as good a salary as the man who is just sitting on the bench." The situation is like that: the Vedic civilization is meant for self-realization, not for a dog's race.

Interviewer: Still, isn't it usually considered honorable to work hard, to struggle, and eventually "get ahead" in life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The karmés, fruitive workers, have been described in the Bhagavad-gétä as müòhas, asses. Why are they compared to the asses? Because the ass works very hard with loads on his back, and in return his master gives him only a little morsel of grass. He stands at the door of the washerman and eats grass while again the washerman loads his back. He doesn't have the sense to think, "If I go out of the cottage of the washerman, I can get grass anywhere. Why am I carrying so much?"

Interviewer: That brings to mind some people I know.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The fruitive worker is like that. He is very busy in the office, and if you want to see him he will say, "I am very busy." So what is the result of your being so busy? He takes two pieces of toast and one cup of tea. And for this purpose you are so busy? He does not know why he is busy. In the account books he will find that the balance was one million dollars and now it has become two million. He is satisfied with that, but he will take only two pieces of toast and one cup of tea, and still he will work very hard. That is what is meant by karmé. Asses—they work like asses, without any aim in life.

But Vedic civilization is different. The accusation is not correct—people in Vedic civilization are not at all lazy. They are busy for a higher subject matter. Prahläda Mahäräja stresses that this busy-ness is so important that it should begin from one's very childhood. Kaumära äcaret präjïaù: one should not lose a second's time. That is Vedic civilization. The asses see, "These men are not working like I am"—like dogs and asses—and they consider that we are escaping. Yes, escaping your fruitless endeavor. The Vedic civilization is meant for self-realization.

Interviewer: Could you give us more of an idea what the Vedic civilization is like?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Vedic civilization begins from the varëäçrama system. In the varëäçrama system there is this arrangement: brähmaëas [intellectuals, advisors], kñatriyas [administrators], vaiçyas [merchants, farmers], çüdras [workers], brahmacärés [celibate students], gåhasthas [householders], vänaprasthas [retired married people], and sannyäsés [renounced monks].

The ultimate goal is that Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, should be worshiped. So if you worship Kåñëa, then you fulfill all your occupational duties, either as a brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, çüdra, brahmacäré, anything. Take to it immediately—take to Kåñëa consciousness. This is so important.

Interviewer: If people really knew about a life-style that was more natural, more fulfilling, what would be the problem? They actually would, as you say, take to it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But they do not know, and therefore there is no religion, simply a dog's race. The dog is running on four legs, and you are running on four wheels—that's all. And you think that the four-wheel race is the advancement of civilization.

Therefore, modern civilization is practically said to do nothing. Whatever is obtainable by destiny you will get, wherever you are. Rather, take to Kåñëa consciousness. The example is given by Prahläda Mahäräja that you do not want anything distasteful and yet it comes upon you. Similarly, even if you do not want happiness which you are destined, it will come upon you. You should not waste your energy for material happiness. You cannot get more material happiness than you are destined.

Interviewer: How can you be so sure of that?

Çréla Prabhupäda: How shall I believe it? Because you get some distressful condition, although you do not want it. For instance, President Kennedy died by the hand of his own countryman. Who wanted it, and why did it come? He was a great man, he was protected by so many, and still he was destined to be killed. Who can protect you?

So if the distressful condition comes upon me by destiny, then the opposite position—happiness—will also come. Why shall I waste my time for this rectification? Let me use my energy for Kåñëa consciousness. That is intelligent. You cannot check your destiny. Everyone will experience a certain amount of happiness and a certain amount of distress. No one is enjoying uninterrupted happiness. That is not possible.

Just as you cannot check your distress, so you cannot check your happiness. It will come automatically. So don't waste your time for these things. Rather, you should utilize your time for advancing in Kåñëa consciousness.

Interviewer: Would a Kåñëa conscious person not try for progress?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The thing is that if you try for progress vainly, then what is the use of that? If it is a fact that you cannot change your destiny, then what is the use of trying? We will be satisfied with the amount of happiness and distress we are destined.

Vedic civilization is meant for realization of God. That is the point. You'll still find in India that during important festivals many millions of people are coming to take bath in the Ganges, because they are interested in how to become liberated. They are not lazy. They are going thousands of miles, two thousand miles away, to take bath in the Ganges. They are not lazy, but they are not busy in the dog's race. Rather, they are busy right from their childhood trying to become self-realized. Kaumära äcaret präjïo dharmän bhägavatän iha. They are so busy that they want to begin the business from their very childhood. So it is the wrong conception to think that they are lazy.

Interviewer: Then the question may be raised that if destiny cannot be checked, then why not let every newborn child simply run around like an animal, and whatever is destined to happen to him will happen?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, the advantage is that you can train him spiritually. Therefore it is said, tasyaiva hetoù prayateta kovidaù: you should engage your energy for self-realization. Ahaituky apratihatä: devotional service, Kåñëa consciousness, cannot be checked. Just as material destiny cannot be checked, your advancement in spiritual life cannot be checked if you endeavor for it.

Actually, Kåñëa will change destiny—but only for His devotee. He says, ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo mokñayiñyämi: "I shall give you all protection from all reactions of sinful activities." [Bhagavad-gétä 18.66]

For instance, if one is condemned by the law court to be hanged, no one can check it. Even the same judge who has given this verdict cannot check it. But if the defendant begs for the mercy of the king, who is above all the laws, then the king can check it.

Therefore, our business is to surrender to Kåñëa. If we artificially want to be more happy by economic development, that is not possible. So many men are working so hard, but does it mean that everyone will become a Henry Ford or a Rockefeller? Everyone is trying his best. Mr. Ford's destiny was to become a rich man, but does it mean that every other man who has worked as hard as Ford will become a rich man like Ford? No. This is practical. You cannot change your destiny simply by working hard like an ass or a dog. But you can utilize that energy for improving your Kåñëa consciousness.

Interviewer: Exactly what is Kåñëa consciousness? Could you tell us more?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Love of God—that is Kåñëa consciousness. If you have not learned to love God, then what is the meaning of your religion? When you are actually on the platform of love of God, you understand your relationship with God—"I am part and parcel of God." Then you extend your love to the animal, also. If you actually love God, then your love for the insect is also there. You understand, "This insect has a different body, but he is also part and parcel of my father; therefore, he is my brother." Then you cannot maintain a slaughterhouse. If you maintain a slaughterhouse and disobey the order of Christ, "Thou shalt not kill," and you proclaim yourself Christian or Hindu, that is not religion. Then it is simply a waste of time—because you do not understand God; you have no love for God, and you are labeling yourself under some sect, but there is no real religion. That is going on all over the world.

Interviewer: How can we cure the situation?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. If you do not accept that Kåñëa is the supreme entity, then try to understand. That is education: there is someone supreme; Kåñëa is not Indian; He is God. The sun rises first in India, but that does not mean that the sun is Indian; similarly, although Kåñëa appeared in India, now He has come to the Western countries, through this Kåñëa consciousness movement.

SSR 6c: The Supreme Welfare Work

The Supreme Welfare Work

Çréla Prabhupäda exchanges letters with the Secretary of the Andhra Pradesh Relief Fund Committee of Hyderabad, India. "If you want to perform relief work by collecting funds, I think that will not be successful. You have to please the supreme authority, and that is the way to success. For example, due to the performance of saìkértana [congregational chanting of Hare Kåñëa] here, the rain has begun to fall after a drought of two years."

Revered Swamiji,

The residents of the twin cities are happy to have this opportunity to meet you and your esteemed followers. You may be aware that due to inadequate rainfall during the last two years and its complete failure this year, more than half of our state [Andhra Pradesh, a state in southern India] is in the grip of a serious drought. With a view to supplement governmental efforts to combat this evil, a Central Voluntary Organization of citizens drawn from various walks of life has been set up. The members of this organization surveyed the areas affected by drought. The situation is pathetic. There are villages where drinking water is not available for miles. Due to scarcity of fodder, the cattle owners are parting with their cattle for a nominal price. Many of the stray cattle are dying away due to unavailability of fodder and water. The food problem is also very serious. Due to high prices of food grains on the open market, purchase of grains at market prices is beyond the reach of poor villagers, with the result that at least five to six million people are hardly having one meal a day. There are many who are on the verge of starvation. The entire situation is most pathetic and heartrending.

We therefore appeal to your revered self to consider how your Society could best come to the rescue of these millions of souls who are in unimaginable distress. The Committee would like to suggest that members of your Society appeal to the bhaktas [devotees] attending your discourses to contribute their mite to the Andhra Pradesh Relief Fund.

The Committee is prepared to send some of its representatives along with members of your Society wherever you wish to distribute prasäda to the hungry millions in the state.

As mänava-sevä is mädhava-sevä ["Service to man is service to God"], the Committee is confident that even a little effort by your gracious Society will go a long way in mitigating the sufferings of hundreds and thousands of people.

Yours ever in the service of the Lord,
T. L. Kapadia, Secretary
Andhra Pradesh Relief fund Committee
Hyderabad, India

My dear Mr. Kapadia,

Please accept my greetings. With reference to your letter and your personal interview, I beg to inform you that without pleasing the Supreme Personality of Godhead, no one can become happy. Unfortunately people do not know who God is and how to make Him happy. Our Kåñëa consciousness movement is therefore meant to present the Supreme Personality of Godhead directly to the people. As stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Seventh Canto, Sixth Chapter: tuñöe ca tatra kim alabhyam ananta ädye/ kià tair guëa-vyatikaräd iha ye sva-siddhäù.

The idea stated in this verse is that by pleasing the Supreme Personality of Godhead, we please everyone, and there is no question of scarcity. Because people do not know this secret of success, they are making their own independent plans to be happy. However, it is not possible to achieve happiness in this way. On your letterhead I find many important men in this country who are interested in relieving the sufferings of the people, but they should know for certain that without pleasing the Supreme Personality of Godhead all their attempts will be futile. A diseased man cannot live simply on the strength of the help of an expert physician and medicine. If this were so, then no rich man would ever die. One must be favored by Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Therefore if you want to perform relief work simply by collecting funds, I think that it will not be successful. You have to please the supreme authority, and that is the way to success. For example, due to the performance of saìkértana here, the rain has begun to fall after a drought of two years. The last time we performed a Hare Kåñëa Festival in Delhi, there was imminent danger of Pakistan's declaring war, and when a newspaper man approached me for my opinion, I said there must be fighting because the other party was aggressive. However, because of our saìkértana movement, India emerged victorious. Similarly, when we held a festival in Calcutta, the Naxalite [Communist] movement stopped. These are facts. Through the saìkértana movement we can not only get all facilities for living, but also at the end can go back home, back to Godhead. Those who are of a demoniac nature cannot understand this, but it is a fact.

I therefore request you, as leading members of society, to join this movement. There is no loss on anyone's part for chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra, but the gain is great. According to Bhagavad-gétä [3.21], what is accepted by leading men is also accepted by common men:

yad yad äcarati çreñöhas
tat tad evetaro janaù
sa yat pramäëaà kurute
lokas tad anuvartate

"Whatever action a great man performs, common men follow in his footsteps. And whatever standards he sets by exemplary acts, all the world pursues."

The saìkértana movement of Kåñëa consciousness is very important. Therefore, through you I wish to appeal to all the leading men of India to accept this movement very seriously and give us all facility to spread this movement throughout the world. Then there will be a very happy condition, not only in India but all over the world.

Hoping this will meet you in good health,
Your ever well-wisher,
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

SSR 6d: Declaring Our Dependence on God

Declaring Our Dependence on God

In a conversation with the Back to Godhead staff, Çréla Prabhupäda discusses the American Revolution: "The Americans say they trust in God. But without the science of God, that trust is simply fictitious. First take the science of God very seriously; then put your trust in Him. . . . They're manufacturing their own way of governing. And that is their defect. They will never be successful. . . . There will always be revolutions—one after another. There will be no peace."

Back to Godhead: Thomas Jefferson put the basic philosophy of the American Revolution into the Declaration of Independence. The important men of the day who signed this document agreed that there are certain very obvious or self-evident truths, the first of which is that all men are created equal. By this they meant that all men are equal before the law and have an equal opportunity to be protected by the law.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, in that sense men are, as you say, created equal.

BTG: Another point in the Declaration of Independence is that all men are endowed by God with certain natural rights that cannot be taken away from them. These are the rights of life, liberty, and—

Çréla Prabhupäda: But animals also have the right to life. Why don't animals also have the right to live? The rabbits, for instance, are living in their own way in the forest. Why does the government allow hunters to go and shoot them?

BTG: They were simply talking about human beings.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then they have no real philosophy. The narrow idea that my family or my brother is good, and that I can kill all others, is criminal. Suppose that for my family's sake I kill your father. Is that philosophy? Real philosophy is suhådaà sarva-bhütänäm: friendliness to all living entities. Certainly this applies to human beings, but even if you unnecessarily kill one animal, I shall immediately protest, "What nonsense are you doing?"

BTG: The founders of America said that another natural right is the right to liberty, or freedom—freedom in the sense that the government doesn't have the right to tell you what kind of job you have to do.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If the government is not perfect, it should not be allowed to tell people what to do. But if the government is perfect, then it can.

BTG: The third natural right they mentioned was that every human being has the right to pursue happiness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. But your standard of happiness may be different from my standard. You may like to eat meat; I hate it. How can your standard of happiness be equal to mine?

BTG: So should everyone be free to try to achieve whatever standard of happiness he wants?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, the standard of happiness should be prescribed according to the qualities of the person. You must divide the whole society into four groups: those with brähmaëa qualities, those with kñatriya qualities, those with vaiçya qualities, and those with çüdra qualities.* Everyone should have good facility to work according to his natural qualities.

You cannot engage a bull in the business of a horse, nor can you engage a horse in the business of a bull. Today practically everyone is getting a college education. But what is taught at these colleges? Mostly technical knowledge, which is çüdra education. Real higher education means learning Vedic wisdom. This is meant for the brähmaëas. Alone, çüdra education leads to a chaotic condition. Everyone should be tested to find out which education he is suited for. Some çüdras may be given technical education, but most çüdras should work on the farms. Because everyone is coming to the cities to get an education, thinking, "We can get more money," the agriculture is being neglected. Now there is scarcity because no one is engaged in producing nice foodstuffs. All these anomalies have been caused by bad government. It is the duty of the government to see that everyone is engaged according to his natural qualities. Then people will be happy.

BTG: So if the government artificially puts all men into one class, then there can't be happiness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, that is unnatural and will cause chaos.

BTG: America's founding fathers didn't like classes, because they'd had such bad experience with them. Before the revolution, Americans had been ruled by monarchs, but the monarchs would always become tyrannical and unjust.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because they weren't trained to be saintly monarchs. In Vedic civilization, boys were trained from the very beginning of life as first-class brahmacärés [celibate students]. They went to the gurukula, the school of the spiritual master, and learned self-control, cleanliness, truthfulness, and many other saintly qualities. The best of them were later fit to rule the country.

The American Revolution has no special significance. The point is that when people become unhappy, they revolt. That was done in America, that was done in France, and that was done in Russia.

BTG: The American revolutionaries said that if a government fails to rule the people properly, then the people have the right to dissolve that government.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Just as in Nixon's case: they pulled him down. But if they replace Nixon with another Nixon, then what is the value? They must know how to replace Nixon with a saintly leader. Because people do not have that training and that culture, they will go on electing one Nixon after another and never become happy. People can be happy. The formula for happiness is there in the Bhagavad-gétä. The first thing they must know is that the land belongs to God. Why do Americans claim that the land belongs to them? When the first settlers went to America, they said, "This land belongs to God; therefore we have a right to live here." So why are they now not allowing others to settle on the land? What is their philosophy? There are so many overpopulated countries. The American government should let those people go to America and should give them facility to cultivate the land and produce grains. Why are they not doing that? They have taken others' property by force, and by force they are checking others from going there. What is the philosophy behind this?

BTG: There is no philosophy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Roguism is their philosophy. They take the property by force, and then they make a law that no one can take another's property by force. So they are thieves. They cannot restrict God's property from being occupied by God's sons. America and the other countries in the United Nations should agree that wherever there is enough land, it may be utilized by the human society for producing food. The government can say, "All right, you are overpopulated. Your people can come here. We will give them land, and they can produce food." We would see a wonderful result. But will they do that? No. Then what is their philosophy? Roguism. "I will take the land by force, and then I won't allow others to come here."

BTG: One American motto is "One nation under God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is Kåñëa consciousness. There should be one nation under God, and one world government under God as well. Everything belongs to God, and we are all His sons. That philosophy is wanted.

BTG: But in America people are very much afraid of a central government because they think that whenever there's a strong government there will always be tyranny.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If the leaders are properly trained, there cannot be tyranny.

BTG: But one of the premises of the American system of government is that if a leader has too much power, he will inevitably become corrupt.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You have to train him in such a way that he cannot become corrupt!

BTG: What is that training process?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That training is the varëäçrama-dharma*. Divide the society according to quality and train people in the principle that everything belongs to God and should be used in the service of God. Then there really can be "one nation under God."

BTG: But if society is divided into different groups, won't there be envy?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, no. Just as in my body there are different parts that work together, so the society can have different parts working for the same goal. My hand is different from my leg. But when I tell the hand, "Bring a glass of water," the leg will help. The leg is required, and the hand is required.

BTG: But in the Western world we have a working class and a capitalist class, and there is always warfare going on between the two.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. The capitalist class is required, and the working class is also required.

BTG: But they are fighting.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because they are not trained up; they have no common cause. The hand and the leg work differently, but the common cause is to maintain the body. So if you find out the common cause for both the capitalists and the workers, then there will be no fighting. But if you do not know the common cause, then there will always be fighting.

BTG: Revolution?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

BTG: Then the most important thing is to find the common cause that people can unite on?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, just like in our Kåñëa conscious society you come to consult me about every activity, because I can give you the common cause. Otherwise, there will be fighting. The government should be very expert to know the aim of life—the common cause—and they should train the people to work for the common cause. Then they will be happy and peaceful. But if people simply elect rascals like Nixon, they will never find a common cause. Any rascal can secure votes by some arrangement, and then he becomes the head of the government. The candidates are bribing, they are cheating, they are making propaganda to win votes. Somehow or other they get votes and capture the prime post. This system is bad.

BTG: So if we don't choose our leaders by popular election, how will society be governed?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You require brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras. Just as when you want to construct a building, you require engineers. You don't want sweepers. Isn't that so? What will the sweeper do? No, there must be engineers. So if you follow the division of varëäçrama, only kñatriyas are allowed to govern. And for the legislative assembly—the senators—only qualified brähmaëas. Now the butcher is in the legislative assembly. What does he know about making laws? He is a butcher, but by winning votes he becomes a senator. At the present moment, by the principle of vox populi, a butcher goes to the legislature. So everything depends on training. In our Kåñëa conscious society, we're actually doing that, but in the case of politics, they forget it. There cannot be just one class. That is foolishness, because we have to engage different classes of men in different activities. If we do not know the art, then we will fail, because unless there is a division of work, there will be havoc. We have discussed all the responsibilities of the king in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The different classes in society should cooperate exactly as the different parts of the body do. Although each part is meant for a different purpose, they all work for one cause: to maintain the body properly.

BTG: What is the actual duty of the government?

Çréla Prabhupäda: To understand what God wants and to see that society works toward that aim. Then people will be happy. But if the people work in the wrong direction, how can they be happy? The government's duty is to see that they are working in the right direction. The right direction is to know God and to act according to His instructions. But if the leaders themselves do not believe in the supremacy of God, and if they do not know what God wants to do, or what He wants us to do, then how can there be good government? The leaders are misled, and they are misleading others. That is the chaotic condition in the world today.

BTG: In the United States there has traditionally been the separation of church and state.

Çréla Prabhupäda: I am not talking about the church. Church or no church—that is not the point. The main thing is that the leaders have to accept that there is a supreme controller. How can they deny it? Everything in nature is going on under the Supreme Lord's control. The leaders cannot control nature, so why don't they accept a supreme controller? That is the defect in society. In every respect, the leaders are feeling that there must be a supreme controller, and yet they are still denying Him.

BTG: But suppose the government is atheistic...

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then there cannot be good government. The Americans say they trust in God. But without the science of God, that trust is simply fictitious. First take the science of God very seriously, then put your trust in Him. They do not know what God is, but we do. We actually trust in God.

They're manufacturing their own way of governing. And that is their defect. They will never be successful. They are imperfect, and if they go on manufacturing their own ways and means, they will remain imperfect. There will always be revolutions—one after another. There will be no peace.

BTG: Who determines the regulative principles of religion that people should follow?

Çréla Prabhupäda: God. God is perfect. He does that. According to the Vedic version, God is the leader of all living entities (nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm). We are different from Him because He is all-perfect and we are not. We are very small. We have the qualities of God, but in very small quantity. Therefore we have only a little knowledge—that's all. With a little knowledge you can manufacture a 747 airplane, but you cannot manufacture a mosquito. God has created the mosquito's body, which is also an "airplane." And that is the difference between God and us: we have knowledge, but it is not as perfect as God's. So the leaders of the government have to consult God; then they will rule perfectly.

BTG: Has God also devised the most perfect government?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Oh, yes. The kñatriyas ruled the government in Vedic times. When there was a war, the king was the first to fight. Just like your George Washington: he fought when there was a war. But what kind of president is ruling now? When there is a war, he sits very securely and telephones orders. He's not fit to be president. When there is war, the president should be the first to come forward and lead the battle.

BTG: But if man is small and imperfect, how can he execute God's perfect orders for a perfect government?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Although you may be imperfect, because you are carrying out my order, you're becoming perfect. You have accepted me as your leader, and I accept God as my leader. In this way society can be governed perfectly.

BTG: So good government means first of all to accept the Supreme Being as the real ruler of the government?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You cannot directly accept the Supreme Being. You must accept the servants of the Supreme Being—the brähmaëas or Vaiñëavas [devotees of the Lord]—as your guides. The government men are kñatriyas—the second class. The kñatriyas should take advice from the brähmaëas or Vaiñëavas and make laws accordingly. The vaiçyas should carry out the kñatriyas' orders in practice. And the çüdras should work under these three orders. Then society will be perfect.

SSR 6e: The Peace Formula

The Peace Formula

"The earth is the property of God, but we, the living entities, especially the so-called civilized human beings, are claiming God's property as our own, under both an individual and collective false conception. If you want peace, you have to remove this false conception from your mind and from the world..."

The great mistake of modern civilization is to encroach upon others' property as though it were one's own and to thereby create an unnecessary disturbance of the laws of nature. These laws are very strong. No living entity can violate them. Only one who is Kåñëa conscious can easily overcome the stringency of the laws of nature and thus become happy and peaceful in the world.

As a state is protected by the department of law and order, so the state of Universe, of which this earth is only an insignificant fragment, is protected by the laws of nature. This material nature is one of the different potencies of God, who is the ultimate proprietor of everything that be. This earth is, therefore, the property of God, but we, the living entities, especially the so-called civilized human beings, are claiming God's property as our own, under both an individual and collective false conception. If you want peace, you have to remove this false conception from your mind and from the world. This false claim of proprietorship by the human race is partly or wholly the cause of all disturbances of peace on earth.

Foolish and so-called civilized men are claiming proprietary rights on the property of God because they have now become godless. You cannot be happy and peaceful in a godless society. In the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa says that He is the factual enjoyer of all activities of the living entities, that He is the Supreme Lord of all universes, and that He is the well-wishing friend of all beings. When the people of the world know this as the formula for peace, it is then and there that peace will prevail.

Therefore, if you want peace at all, you will have to change your consciousness into Kåñëa consciousness, both individually and collectively, by the simple process of chanting the holy name of God. This is a standard and recognized process for achieving peace in the world. We therefore recommend that everyone become Kåñëa conscious by chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

This is practical, simple, and sublime. Four hundred and eighty years ago this formula was introduced in India by Lord Çré Caitanya, and now it is available in your country. Take to this simple process of chanting as above mentioned, realize your factual position by reading the Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, and reestablish your lost relationship with Kåñëa, God. Peace and prosperity will be the immediate worldwide result.

SSR 6f: Spiritual Communism

Spiritual Communism

During his visit to the Soviet Union in 1971, Çréla Prabhupäda talks with Professor Grigoriy Kotovsky, head of the India Department at the U.S.S.R. Academy of Sciences: "Whether you surrender to monarchy, aristocracy, or dictatorship, you have to surrender; that is a fact. Without surrender there is no life. It is not possible. So we are educating people to surrender to the Supreme, wherefrom you get all protection. . . . Any other surrender you have to change by revolution. But when you come to Kåñëa, then it is sufficient. You are satisfied."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The other day I was reading the paper, Moscow News. There was a Communist congress, and the President declared, "We are ready to take others' experience to improve." So I think the Vedic concept of socialism or communism will much improve the idea of communism. For example, in a socialistic state the idea is that no one should starve; everyone must have his food. Similarly, in the Vedic concept of gåhastha [householder] life it is recommended that a householder see that even a lizard or a snake living in his house should not starve. Even these lower creatures should be given food, and certainly all humans should. It is recommended that the gåhastha, before taking his lunch, stand on the road and declare, "If anyone is still hungry, please come! Food is ready!" If there is no response, then the proprietor of the household takes his lunch. Modern society takes the people as a whole as the proprietor of a certain state, but the Vedic conception is éçäväsyam idaà sarvam—everything is owned by éça, the supreme controller. Tena tyaktena bhuïjéthäù—you may enjoy what is allotted to you by Him. Mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam: but do not encroach upon others' property. This is the Éçopaniñad—Veda. The same idea is explained in the different Puräëas. There are many good concepts in the Vedic literature about communism. So I thought that these ideas should be distributed to your most thoughtful men. Therefore I was anxious to speak.

Prof. Kotovsky: It is interesting that here in our country there is now great interest in the history of old, old thought. From this point of view, our Institute translated into Russian and published many literary monuments of great Indian culture. You will be interested to discover that we published some of the Puräëas and parts of the Rämäyaëa. There are volumes in Russian of Mahäbhärata and also a second edition of Mahäbhärata, translated in full. We have also published the full translation of Manu-småti with Sanskrit commentaries. Interest in these publications was so great that they sold out in a week. They are now completely out of stock. It was impossible to get them in the book market after a month. There is great interest among reading people here in Moscow and the U.S.S.R. toward ancient Vedic culture, and from this point of view we published many such books.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Among these Puräëas, the Çrémad-Bhägavatam is called the Mahä-Puräëa.

Prof. Kotovsky: Mahä-Puräëa.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. We have translated the full text—first we present the original Sanskrit text, its transliteration, the English equivalent for each word, then the translation, and then a purport, or explanation of the verse. In this way, there are eighteen thousand verses in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. We are translating everything literally. You can see. Each and every verse is being done like that for the whole Bhägavata Puräëa. The opinion of the äcäryas, the great saintly sages who are the preachers of the Bhägavata philosophy, is nigama-kalpa-taror galitaà phalam: this is the ripened fruit of the Vedic desire tree [Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.1.3]. It is accepted by all the Indian scholars, and Lord Caitanya especially preached this Bhägavatam. So we have the complete Bhägavatam in its English translation. If you want to see it, I can show you.

Prof. Kotovsky: It seems to me that in the Moscow and Leningrad libraries we have nearly all the major texts of ancient Indian culture, beginning from the Vedas, the original texts in Sanskrit. For instance, in the Leningrad branch of our Institute there are six or eight editions of Manu-småti. This Institute was founded in Imperial Russia in Leningrad, so in Leningrad we now have a branch of our Institute dealing mainly with the history of Asiatic culture. You will find here an account of what is being translated and what studies are being done on the history of Indian religion and also the state of Indian religion, Hinduism, in Hindu India today.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Hinduism is a very complex topic.

Prof. Kotovsky: Oh, yes. [They laugh.] Really, to my understanding, it is not a religion, from the European point of view; it is a way of life—religion, philosophy, a way of life, whatever you want.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This word "Hindu" is not a Sanskrit word. It was given by the Muhammadans. You know that there is a river, Indus, which in Sanskrit is called Sindhu. The Muhammadans pronounce s as h. Instead of Sindhu, they made it Hindu. So "Hindu" is a term that is not found in the Sanskrit dictionary, but it has come into use. But the real cultural institution is called varëäçrama. There are four varëas (social divisions)—brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, and çüdra—and four äçramas (spiritual divisions)—brahmacarya, gåhastha, vänaprastha, and sannyäsa. According to the Vedic concept of life, unless people take to this system or institution of four varëas and four äçramas, actually they do not become civilized human beings. One has to take this process of four divisions of social orders and four divisions of spiritual orders; that is called varëäçrama. India's culture is based on this age-old Vedic system.

Prof. Kotovsky: Varëäçrama.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Varëäçrama. And in the Bhagavad-gétä—perhaps you have read the Bhagavad-gétä?

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There, in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.13], is the statement cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöam: this system was created by Viñëu [God]. So since varëäçrama is a creation of the Supreme, it cannot be changed. It is prevalent everywhere. It is like the sun. The sun is a creation of the Supreme. The sunshine is there in America, in Russia, and in India—everywhere. Similarly, this varëäçrama system is prevalent everywhere in some form or another. Take, for example, the brähmaëas, the most intelligent class of men. They are the brains of the society. The kñatriyas are the administrative class; then the vaiçyas are the productive class, and the çüdras are the worker class. These four classes of men are prevalent everywhere under different names. Because it is created by the original creator, so it is prevalent everywhere, varëäçrama-dharma.

Prof. Kotovsky: It is interesting that in the opinion of some European and old Russian scholars, this varëäçrama system is a later creation, and if you would read the old texts of Vedic literature, you would find a much more simple and agrarian society. It is the opinion of these scholars that the varëäçrama system was introduced in Indian society in the late age of the Vedic era but not from the beginning. And if you would analyze the old texts, you would find that in the old classical India it was not so prevalent.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As far as we are concerned, it is mentioned in the Bhagavad-gétä. Cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöam. The Bhagavad-gétä was spoken five thousand years ago, and in the Bhagavad-gétä it is said, "This system of the Bhagavad-gétä was spoken by Me to the sun-god." So if you take an estimation of that period, it comes to forty million years ago. Can the European scholars trace back history five thousand years? Can they go back forty million years? We have evidence that this varëäçrama system has been current at least five thousand years. The varëäçrama system is also mentioned in the Viñëu Puräëa [3.8.9]. Varëäçramäcäravatä puruñeëa paraù pumän. That is stated in the Viñëu Puräëa. Varëäçrama-dharma is not a phenomenon of a historical period calculated in the modern age. It is natural. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam the comparison is given that just as in the body there are four divisions—the brain division, the arms division, the belly division, and the leg division—so by nature's way these four divisions are existing in the social body. There exist a class of men who are considered the brain, a class of men who are considered the arms of the state, a class of men who are called the productive class, and so on. There is no need of tracing history; it is naturally existing from the day of creation.

Prof. Kotovsky: You have said that in any society there are four divisions, but they are not so easy to distinguish. For instance, one can group together different social classes and professional groups into four divisions in any society; there is no difficulty. The only difficulty is, for instance, in the socialistic society—in our country and other socialist societies—how you can distinguish the productive group from the workers.

Çréla Prabhupäda: For example, we belong to the intellectual class of men. This is a division.

Prof. Kotovsky: Intelligent class, brähmaëas. And you can also put together all the intelligentsia in that department.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Prof. Kotovsky: And then the administrative class.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Prof. Kotovsky: But who are the vaiçyas and çüdras? That is the difficulty. Because all others are workers—factory workers, collective farm workers, and so on. So from this point of view there is a great distinction, in my opinion, between socialist society and all societies preceding socialism, because in modern Western society you can group all social and professional classes in these particular class divisions—brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras: intellectuals, productive class, owners of the productive system (factory owners, for instance), and menial workers. But here you have no vaiçyas because you have administrative staffs in factories, and you can call them kñatriyas, and then there are the çüdras, the workers themselves, but no intermediate class.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is stated. Kalau çüdra-sambhavaù. In this age practically all men are çüdras. But if there are simply çüdras, the social order will be disturbed. In spite of your state of çüdras, the brähmaëa is found here, and that is necessary. If you do not divide the social order in such a way, there will be chaos. That is the scientific estimation of the Vedas. You may belong to the çüdra class, but to maintain social order you have to train some of the çüdras to become brähmaëas. Society cannot depend on çüdras. Nor can you depend on the brähmaëas. To fulfill the necessities of your body, there must be a brain, arms, a stomach, and legs. The legs, the brain, and the arms are all required for cooperation to fulfill the mission of the whole body. So in any society you can see that unless there are these four divisions, there will be chaos. It will not work properly. It will be mäyä, and there will be disturbances. The brain must be there, but at the present moment there is a scarcity of brains. I am not talking of your state or my state; I am taking the world as a whole. Formerly the Indian administration was a monarchy. For example, Mahäräja Parékñit was a kñatriya king. Just before his death, he renounced his royal order. He came to the forest to hear about self-realization. If you want to maintain the peace and prosperity of the whole world society, you must create a very intelligent class of men, a class of men expert in administration, a class of men expert in production, and a class of men to work. That is required; you cannot avoid it. That is the Vedic conception, mukha-bähüru-päda jäù [Çrémad-Bhägavatam 11.17.13]. Mukha means "the face," bähu means "the arms," üru means "the waist," and päda, "the legs." Whether you take this state or that state, unless there is a smooth, systematic establishment of these four orders of life, the state or society will not run very smoothly.

Prof. Kotovsky: Generally it seems to me that this whole varëäçrama system to some extent created a natural division of labor in the ancient society. But now division of labor among people in any society is much more complicated and sophisticated. So it is very confusing to group them into four classes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Confusion has come to exist because in India, at a later day, the son of a brähmaëa, without having the brahminical qualifications, claimed to be a brähmaëa; and others, out of superstition or a traditional way, accepted him as a brähmaëa. Therefore the Indian social order was disrupted. But in our Kåñëa consciousness movement we are training brähmaëas everywhere, because the world needs the brain of a brähmaëa. Although Mahäräja Parékñit was a monarch, he had a body of brähmaëas and learned sages to consult, an advisory body. It is not that the monarchs were independent. In history it is found that if some of the monarchs were not in order, they were dethroned by the brahminical advisory council. Although the brähmaëas did not take part in politics, they would advise the monarch how to execute the royal function. This is not too far in the past. How long ago was Açoka?

Prof. Kotovsky: That would be equal to what we call, in our terminology, ancient and medieval India.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Prof. Kotovsky: In old and feudal India—you are right—it was very open, and the major part of the high administrative staff in the legislative department were brähmaëas. Even in the Mogul era there were brähmaëas to advise the Muslim emperors and administrators.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a fact—the brähmaëas were accepted. They formed the advisory committee of the king. For example, Candragupta, the Hindu king, was in the age of Alexander the Great. Just before Candragupta, Alexander the Great went from Greece into India and conquered a portion. When Candragupta became emperor, he had Cäëakya as his prime minister. Perhaps you have heard this name Cäëakya?

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, he was a great brähmaëa-politician, and it is by his name that the quarter of New Delhi where all the foreign embassies are grouped together is called Cäëakya Puré. Cäëakya Paëòita was a great politician and brähmaëa. He was vastly learned. His moral instructions are still valuable. In India, schoolchildren are taught Cäëakya Paëòita's instructions. Although he was the prime minister, Cäëakya Paëòita maintained his brähmaëa spirit; he did not accept any salary. If a brähmaëa accepts a salary, it is understood that he has become a dog. That is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. He can advise, but he cannot accept employment. So Cäëakya Paëòita was living in a cottage, but he was actually the prime minister. This brahminical culture and the brahminical brain is the standard of Vedic civilization. The Manu-småti is an example of the standard of brahminical culture. You cannot trace out from history when the Manu-småti was written, but it is considered so perfect that it is the Hindu law. There is no need for the legislature to pass a new law daily to adjust social order. The law given by Manu is so perfect that it can be applicable for all time. It is stated in Sanskrit to be tri-kälädau, which means "good for the past, present, and future."

Prof. Kotovsky: I am sorry to interrupt you, but to my knowledge all of Indian society in the second half of the eighteenth century was, by order of the British administration, under a law divergent from Hindu law. There was a lot of change. The actual Hindu law that was used by the Hindus was quite different from the original Manu-småti.

Çréla Prabhupäda: They have now made changes. Even our late Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru introduced his own Hindu code. He introduced the right of divorce in marriage, but this was not in the Manu-saàhitä. There are so many things they have changed, but before this modern age the whole human society was governed by the Manu-småti. Strictly speaking, modern Hindus are not strictly following the Hindu scriptures.

But our point is not to try to bring back the old type of Hindu society. That is impossible. Our idea is to take the best ideas from the original idea. For example, in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam there is a description of the communist idea. It is described to Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira. If there is something good, a good experience, why shouldn't you adopt it? That is our point of view. Besides that, modern civilization is missing one all-important point—the aim of human life. Scientifically, the aim of human life is self-realization, ätma-tattva. It is said that unless the members of human society come to the point of self-realization, they are defeated in whatever they do. Actually it is happening in modern society, despite all economic advancement and other advancement: instead of keeping peace and tranquillity, they are fighting—individually, socially, politically, and nationally. If we think about it in a cool-headed way, we can see that in spite of much improvement in many branches of knowledge, we are keeping the same mentality that is visible in the lower animal society. Our conclusion, according to the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, is that this human body is not meant for working hard for sense gratification. But people do not know anything beyond that. They do not know about the next life. There is no scientific department of knowledge to study what happens after this body is finished. That is a great department of knowledge.

In the Bhagavad-gétä [2.13] it is said, dehino 'smin yathä-dehe. Deha means "this body." Dehinaù means "the one who owns this body." Dehino 'smin yathä dehe kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä. The dehé, the owner of the body, is within, and the body is changing from one form to another. The child has a certain type of body that changes to another type when he is older. But the owner of the body still exists throughout. Similarly, when this body is completely changed, we accept another body. People do not understand this. We are accepting different bodies, even in this life, from babyhood to childhood to boyhood to youth. That is a fact—everyone knows it. I was a child, but that childhood body is no more. I have a different body now. What is the difficulty in understanding that when this body will be no more, then I will have to accept another body? It is a great science.

Prof. Kotovsky: As you know, there are two quite opposite approaches to this problem. The approach is slightly different according to different religions, but at the same time, any religion recognizes and searches for the change-of-place experience, or transmigration of spirit. In Christian religion, in Judaism, in...

Çréla Prabhupäda: I am not talking religions with you. I am talking science and philosophy. One religion may accept one way; that is not our concern. We are concerned with the point that if the owner of the body is permanent in spite of different changes of body, there should be no difficulty in understanding that when this body changes entirely, the owner of the body will have another body.

Prof. Kotovsky: Another approach is that there is no separation. There are no two phenomena—the body and the owner of the body are the same.

Çréla Prabhupäda [emphatically]: No.

Prof. Kotovsky: When the body dies, the owner also dies.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, no. But why is there no department of knowledge in the university to study this fact scientifically? That is my proposition—they are lacking. It may be as you say or it may be as I say, but there must be a department of knowledge to study this. Recently a cardiologist in Toronto, a doctor, has accepted that there is a soul. I had some correspondence with him, and he strongly believes that there is a soul. So there is another point of view, but our process is to accept knowledge from authority. We have Kåñëa's statement on this subject, and He is authoritative. Kåñëa is accepted as the authority by all the äcäryas. The Bhagavad-gétä is accepted by scholarly and philosophical circles all over the world. Kåñëa says:

dehino 'smin yathä dehe
kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä
tathä dehäntara-präptir
dhéras tatra na muhyati

"Just as the soul gives up the childhood body and comes to the boyhood body and then to youth, the soul also gives up this body and accepts another body." [Bg. 2.13] This statement is given by Kåñëa, the greatest authority according to our tradition of knowledge. We accept such a statement without argument. That is the way of Vedic understanding.

Prof. Kotovsky: The difficulty is that our approach is that we do not believe in anything without argument. We can believe only things based on argument.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is allowed. That is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.34]. Tad viddhi praëipätena paripraçnena sevayä. Paripraçna, argument, is allowed—but not in the challenging spirit, but rather with the spirit to understand. Argument is not denied. But as far as Vedic statements are concerned, they are infallible, and the scholars of the Vedas accept them in that way. For example, cow dung is the stool of an animal. Now, the Vedic statement is that as soon as you touch the stool of any animal—even if you touch your own stool—you are impure and have to purify yourself by taking a bath. According to the Hindu system, after evacuating one has to take a bath.

Prof. Kotovsky: That is quite understandable hygienic knowledge.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes, that is right.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But in another place it is stated that cow dung, although the stool of an animal, is pure. Even if you apply it to an impure place, that place becomes purified. This is superficially contradictory. In one place it is said that the stool of an animal is impure and as soon as you touch it you have to be purified, and in another place it says that cow dung is pure. According to our knowledge, it is contradictory—but still it is accepted by those who are followers of the Vedas. And the fact is that if you analyze cow dung, you will find that it contains all antiseptic properties.

Prof. Kotovsky: This I don't know.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, one professor in a medical college analyzed it, and he found it full of antiseptic properties. So Vedic statements, even if found contradictory, if analyzed scrutinizingly will prove correct. There may be an exception. But it is accepted, and when scientifically analyzed and examined, it is found to be correct.

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes, if you analyze from the scientific point of view, that is right.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There are other instances—for example, the conchshell. The conchshell is the bone of an animal, and according to Vedic instruction if you touch the bone of an animal you become impure and have to take a bath. But this conchshell is kept in the Deity room, because it is accepted as pure by the Vedas. My point is that we accept Vedic laws without argument. That is the principle followed by scholars. If you can substantiate your statements by quotations from the Vedas, then they are accepted. You are not required to substantiate them in other ways. There are different kinds of pramäëas, or evidences. Proof by Vedic quotation is called çruti-pramäëa. As in the legal court if you can give statements from the law book your statement is accepted, so all statements you give, if supported by çruti-pramäëas, are accepted by scholars. I think you know the Vedas are known as çrutis.

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes.

Çréla Prabhupäda:

çruti-småti-puräëädi-
païcarätra-vidhià vinä
aikäntiké harer bhaktir
utpätäyaiva kalpate
[Brahma-yämala]

Any system we accept must be supported by evidences of çruti, småti, the Puräëas, and Païcarätra. That which is not proved by these pramäëas is a disturbance.

Prof. Kotovsky: Could I just say one thing? What is in the Vedas could also have been proved in a scientific way. Today, suppose there is a scientific laboratory. What is said by that lab is true. That it is true you accept, without going into the propriety of it. Suppose you have a scientific workshop or institution; if this workshop or scientific institution says, "This is not good," the general body will take it for granted: "Yes. The scientific body has said so, so it is understood."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Similarly, Vedic authoritative statements are accepted by the äcäryas [great teachers]. India is governed by the äcäryas—Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Çaìkaräcärya. They accept the Vedas, and their followers accept them. The benefit is that I do not waste my time to research whether cow dung is pure or impure; rather, because it is stated in the Vedas to be pure, I accept it. I save my time by accepting the çruti-pramäëa. In that way there are different statements in the Vedas for sociology and politics or anything, for veda means "knowledge."

sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöo
mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca
vedaiç ca sarvair aham eva vedyo
vedänta-kåd veda-vid eva cäham
[Bg. 15.15]

Prof. Kotovsky: May I put one question to you? Have you many branches of your society in the world?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Prof. Kotovsky: Where is your main center, and where are the branches of the Kåñëa consciousness society?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Of course, I have over sixty-five branches.

Prof. Kotovsky: Sixty-five branches.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and I have made my main center in Los Angeles. And now we are establishing an important center in Mäyäpura, the birthplace of Lord Caitanya. Have you been to India?

Prof. Kotovsky: Six or seven times. Now there is a very difficult situation in Calcutta because of the influx of refugees from Bangladesh.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but we had our saìkértana for ten days, and it was very wonderful. The gathering was not less than thirty thousand people daily. They were much interested in hearing our lectures, since we lecture from Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä, So people are responding from every part of the world, especially the American boys and girls. They are especially interested, and England and also Germany and France. From here I plan to go to Paris. What is the name of that place?

A disciple: In Paris? Oh, Fontenay-aux-Roses?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, they have taken a whole house, a nice house. So our process is very simple. We ask our students to observe four prohibitive principles–no illicit sex life, no eating of meat, fish or eggs, no gambling and no intoxication, including cigarettes, tea and coffee. One has to obey these four principles and chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, and you will find how, by this process only, these boys and girls are quickly improving. The process is very simple. Besides that, we have books—volumes of books—Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the Bhagavad-gétä. Throughout all these years, I have written about one dozen four-hundred-page books—Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead in two parts, Çrémad-Bhägavatam in six parts. Teachings of Lord Caitanya in one part, Nectar of Devotion in one part. So we are trying to push this Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa is a historical personality, as much as Lenin is a historical personality. Just as you are trying to understand his philosophy, we are trying to understand Kåñëa's philosophy.

Prof. Kotovsky: Are there many participants in your sixty-five branches?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Oh yes, more than one thousand initiated, and outside there are many. The one thousand have accepted the principles. Just like these boys. [Çréla Prabhupäda points to his two secretaries.]

Prof. Kotovsky: But does that mean that these students abstain from normal Western, European universities? For instance, can a normal student from one of the various universities who is attending lectures in the normal way also be initiated and admitted to your community?

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you want to live in our community and be initiated, we welcome you. If not, come try to understand our philosophy, read our books—there are so many books, magazines, questions, and answers. Try to understand the philosophy. It is not that all of a sudden a student comes and becomes our disciple. He first of all comes, associates, and tries to understand. We do not canvass. He voluntarily says that he wants to be a disciple.

Prof. Kotovsky: What happens if, for instance, one is not a student but a young worker or the young son of a farmer? Would he renounce his whole life and join your community in a given center? How would he maintain himself in his day-to-day life, in material life?

Çréla Prabhupäda: As I told you, this propaganda is meant for creating brähmaëas all over the world, because the brähmaëa element is lacking. One who seriously comes to us has to become a brähmaëa, so he should adopt the occupation of a brähmaëa and give up the occupation of a kñatriya or çüdra. But if one wants to keep his profession and also at the same time understand our movement, that is allowed. We have many professors following our movement. There is Howard Wheeler, a professor at Ohio State University. He is my disciple. He is continuing with his professorship, but almost all the money he is getting he is spending for this Kåñëa consciousness. Gåhasthas, those who are in householder life outside, are expected to contribute fifty percent of their income for our society, keep twenty-five percent for family, and keep twenty-five percent for personal emergencies. But Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu teaches that it does not matter whether one is a gåhastha (householder), or in the renounced order, or a brähmaëa, or a çüdra. Lord Caitanya says, "Anyone who understands the science of Kåñëa becomes My spiritual master." The actual words in Bengali are kibä vipra, kibä nyäsé, çüdra kene naya. Do you understand a little Bengali?

Prof. Kotovsky: A little.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, as a vibration. Yei kåñëa-tattva-vettä, sei 'guru' haya. "Anyone who understands the science of Kåñëa can become a spiritual master." [Caitanya-caritämåta, Madhya 8.128]

Prof. Kotovsky: But by creating brähmaëas from different social classes of society, you deny the old prescription of the Hindu scriptures.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, I establish it.

Prof. Kotovsky: According to all scriptures—the Puräëas, etc.—every member of one of these four classes of varëas has to be born within it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, no, no, no.

Prof. Kotovsky: That is the foundation of all the varëas...

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, no. I am sorry.

Prof. Kotovsky: The foundation of all the varëas...

Çréla Prabhupäda: You have spoken incorrectly. With great respect I beg to submit that you are not speaking correctly. In the Bhagavad-gétä [4.13] it is stated, cätur-varëyaà maya-såñöaà guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù. "These four orders of brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras were created by Me according to quality and work." There is no mention of birth.

Prof. Kotovsky: I agree with you that this is the addition of later brähmaëas who tried to perpetuate these qualities.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That has killed the Indian culture. Otherwise there would have been no necessity of the division of part of India into Pakistan. Not only that, but from the historical point of view this whole planet was Bhärata-varña, and it was controlled by one flag up to the time of Mahäräja Parékñit. Then it gradually separated. This is history. Lately they have separated Pakistan. So Bhärata-varña is now crippled into a small piece of land. Otherwise, according to Vedic scripture, this whole planet is called Bhärata-varña. Formerly it was named Ilävåta-varña. But since Emperor Bhärata ruled this planet, it is called Bhärata-varña. So this culture, Kåñëa consciousness, was always existent. Consider any religion—Christian, Muhammadan, Jewish. They are at most two to three thousand years old. But you cannot trace out the beginning of this Vedic scripture. It is therefore called sanätana, eternal. This culture is for this whole human society. It is not a religious faith. Religious faith you can change, but real dharma you cannot change. Try to understand Kåñëa. In the Bhagavad-gétä [18.66] He says, sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja: "Give up all other forms of religion and just surrender to Me." That is real knowledge—to surrender to the Supreme. You or I—anyone—is surrendered to someone. That is a fact. Our life is by surrender, is it not? Do you disagree with this point?

Prof. Kotovsky: To some extent you surrender.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, to the full extent.

Prof. Kotovsky: You have to surrender to the society, for instance. To the whole people.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, to the whole people, or to the state or to the king or the government or whatever you say. This surrender must be there.

Prof. Kotovsky: The only difficulty is that we cannot half surrender to a government or a king. The principal difference is of surrender to a king, to a person, or to the society.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, that is only a change of color. But the principle of surrender is there. Whether you surrender to monarchy, democracy, aristocracy, or dictatorship, you have to surrender; that is a fact. Without surrender there is no life. It is not possible. So we are educating people to surrender to the Supreme, wherefrom you get all protection, just as Kåñëa says (sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja). No one can say, "No, I am not surrendered to anyone." Not a single person. The difference is where he surrenders. The ultimate surrendering object is Kåñëa. Therefore in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.19] Kåñëa says, bahünäà janmanäm ante jïänavän mäà prapadyate: "After surrendering to so many things birth after birth, when one is factually wise he surrenders unto Me." Väsudevaù sarvam iti sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù: "Such a mahätmä is very rare."

Prof. Kotovsky: But at the same time it seems to me that surrender is to be accompanied by revolt. The history of mankind has proved that mankind has developed only by revolt against some kind of surrender. In the medieval age there was the French Revolution. It was revolt against surrender. But this revolution itself was surrender to the rank and file of the people. You are agreed?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Prof. Kotovsky: So it is not enough to come to a full stop. Surrender is to be accompanied with revolt against some and surrender to other people.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But the surrender will be fully stopped when it is surrender to Kåñëa.

Prof. Kotovsky: Ah, ah.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is full stop—no more surrender. Any other surrender you have to change by revolution. But when you come to Kåñëa, then it is sufficient. You are satisfied. I'll give you an example: a child is crying, and people move him from one lap to another. Oh, he does not stop. But as soon as the baby comes to the lap of his mother...

Prof. Kotovsky: It stops.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, full satisfaction. So this surrender, these changes, will go on in different categories. But the sum total of all this surrender is surrender to mäyä. Therefore, in the Bhagavad-gétä it is said that this surrender, neglecting Kåñëa, is all mäyä. Either you surrender to this or to that, but final surrender is surrender to Kåñëa; then you will be happy. The process of surrender is there, but surrender to Kåñëa keeps one quite satisfied, transcendentally.

Prof. Kotovsky: Haven't you come across hostile attitudes to your teachings from orthodox Hindus or brähmaëas in India?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have subdued them.

Prof. Kotovsky: Ah.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Any orthodox Hindu may come and challenge, but we have our weapons—the Vedic literatures. So no one has come. Even Christian priests in America love me. They say, "These boys are American, Christian, Jewish, and now they are so much after God. But we could not deliver them." They are admitting it. Their fathers and their parents come to me, offer their obeisances, and say, "Swamiji, it is our great fortune that you have come here to teach God consciousness." So on the contrary, I have been well received. In India also, since you inquired of India, all other sects are admitting that before me many kinds of swamis went to the Western countries, but they could not convert even a single person to Kåñëa consciousness. They are admitting that. As far as I am concerned, I don't take any credit, but I am confident that because I am presenting the Vedic knowledge as it is, without adulteration, it is being effective. That is my confidence. If you have the right medicine and you administer it to a patient, you must be sure that he will be cured.

Prof. Kotovsky: How many out of your one thousand disciples do you have in India itself? How many of your community do you have in India?

Çréla Prabhupäda: In India?

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In India there are many Kåñëa conscious persons—hundreds, thousands, millions. In India there is no question. There is not a single Hindu who is not Kåñëa conscious.

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes, I understand.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Vaiñëavas. This is called the Vaiñëava cult. You have been in India, so as it is commonly known, there are many millions of Vaiñëavas. For example, this gentleman [an Indian gentleman present] is the commander of Air India airlines. He is not my disciple, but he is a Vaiñëava, Kåñëa conscious. Similarly, in India there are millions of Kåñëa conscious persons. There are even Muhammadans who are Kåñëa conscious. At Gorakhpur University there is a Muhammadan professor who is a great devotee of Lord Kåñëa. So this is natural. It is said in the Caitanya-caritämåta that Kåñëa consciousness is everywhere, in everyone's heart. It simply has to be awakened by this process. That is all. It is there in your heart also. It is not that it is foreign to you. In everyone's heart there is Kåñëa consciousness. By this process we have to awaken it. It is just like the way the sun rises. It is not that all of a sudden the sun comes from nowhere. It is there, but it rises in the morning. Similarly, this Kåñëa consciousness is everywhere, but some way or another it is now covered. By this process it is reawakened and aroused by association.

Prof. Kotovsky: You came yesterday to Moscow. Have you seen something here in Moscow?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, I am not very much interested in sight-seeing.

Prof. Kotovsky: But in any case, just to stay in an old-style hotel is not interesting—not many people to see. And you are leaving the day after tomorrow?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is my program.

Prof. Kotovsky: You are leaving for the United States or for Europe?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, for Europe. Paris. And we have two very big ceremonies in London and San Francisco. They are making arrangements for the Ratha-yäträ Car Festival. This car festival is observed in Jagannätha Puré. You have been to Jagannätha Puré?

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes, the car festival has been held from immemorial times. A very old tradition. Huge cars.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and it has now been introduced in the Western countries in London and San Francisco, and gradually maybe we will introduce it in other countries also.

Prof. Kotovsky: In London there is a large Indian community.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, no. This is organized by the Englishmen and Americans. The Indian communities in London and San Francisco are trying to become—you know the word? Sahib?

Prof. Kotovsky: [Laughs.] Westernized. [They both laugh.] A very great social anthropologist at the university has written something very interesting. He says there are two processes—the process of Westernization among brähmaëas, mainly the upper class, and the process called Sanskritization, which is the process of adopting brähmaëa rituals, etc., by so-called lower classes, even untouchables. It is a very interesting process in India just now. But India's position, unfortunately, is problematic.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The difficulty is that India is nowhere. They are trying to imitate Western life, but from a materialistic or technical point of view, they are one hundred years back.

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes, that is right. But what to do for India?

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is one thing I am experiencing. If India's spiritual asset is distributed, that will increase India's honor. Because everywhere I go, people still adore Indian culture. If this treasure-house of India's spiritual knowledge is properly distributed, at least people outside of India will understand that they are getting something from India.

Prof. Kotovsky: Of course, you're right. The Indian cultural heritage is to be made known everywhere. But at the same time, in what way would this benefit the Indian masses themselves? They are sitting in India, and they have nothing to gain from the spreading of the Indian cultural heritage all over the world. Indian villages have to have fertilizers, tractors, etc.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we do not object to that.

Prof. Kotovsky: Yes, I don't think you can object, but at the same time, something has to be done in India. One may call it Westernization, but this introduction to an industrial technological revolution is needed in all fields of Indian life—agriculture, industry, etc.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Arjuna, before understanding the Bhagavad-gétä, was a fighter, and after understanding the Bhagavad-gétä he remained a fighter. So we don't want to change the position. For example, you are a respectable professor, a teacher. We don't say that you must change your position. We have come to convince you about our philosophy. That is all. Arjuna was refusing to fight. "Kåñëa, I don't want to kill my relatives. I do not want this kingdom." But he was taught the Bhagavad-gétä, and at the end when Kåñëa inquired, "What is your decision now?" he said, kariñye vacanaà tava—"Yes, I shall act as You say." [Bg. 18.72]. That means that his consciousness changed. He was a fighter, and he remained a fighter, but he changed his consciousness. We want that. We don't want to disturb the present condition of society. We are not against technology. No, but we try to make one understand this Kåñëa consciousness. That is our program.

Prof. Kotovsky: Of course, at the same time the final goal of any consciousness is to change the society—to make it a better society.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is automatic.

Prof. Kotovsky: I am not really so happy that the ultimate goal is not to disturb society, because in modern society there are many things to be changed through consciousness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That preliminary change is to follow rules and regulations of austerity. For example, don't take intoxicants.

Prof. Kotovsky: No indulging in intoxicants—simplicity, etc.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So if one takes to this process...

Prof. Kotovsky: Then the others will come automatically.

Çréla Prabhupäda: One's whole life will change, because these four things—illicit sex life, intoxicants, meat-eating and gambling—are very great impediments to social improvement.

Prof. Kotovsky: That will automatically make life simpler, because a person who does not indulge in illicit sex, intoxicants, and such other things has to lead a comparatively simple life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The other day I was speaking in Bombay with a respectable gentleman. I was telling him that Kåñëa says:

mäà hi pärtha vyapäçritya
ye 'pi syuù päpa-yonayaù
striyo vaiçyäs tathä çüdräs
te 'pi yänti paräà gatim

"Even those who are lowborn [päpa-yonayaù]—stré, vaiçyas, and çüdras—are also included by accepting Me. By accepting My shelter they are also elevated to the transcendental position." [Bg. 9.32] Now why have the higher classes of Hindu society neglected this injunction of the Bhagavad-gétä? Suppose one is päpa-yonayaù, lowborn. Kåñëa says that he can be "elevated to the transcendental position if he accepts Me." Why wasn't this message propagated by the higher class of people so that the so-called lowborn could be elevated? Why did they reject them? The result was that instead of accepting the Muhammadans, the Indians rejected them, and now they are partitioned off. They have become eternal enemies of India. So for the first time we are trying to elevate persons to the higher position of Kåñëa consciousness, even if one is lowborn. Because the soul is pure. In the Vedas it is said that the soul is untouched by any material contamination; it is simply temporarily covered. This covering should be removed. Then one becomes pure. That is the mission of human life—to uncover ourselves from this material environment, come to spiritual understanding, and surrender to Kåñëa. Then life is perfect.

SSR 6g: The Tiny World of Modern Science

The Tiny World of Modern Science

During a morning walk in April 1973, at Venice Beach, Los Angeles, Çréla Prabhupäda discusses modern science and its high priests: "They claim to have millions of dollars worth of knowledge, but if you ask them a question, they simply give you a postdated check. Why should we accept it? They cannot even produce a spear of grass through their biological or chemical experiments. Nonetheless, they are claiming that the creation is produced by some chemical or biological method. Why does no one question all this nonsense?"

Çréla Prabhupäda: The whole world of science and technology is running on the false idea that life is born from matter. We cannot allow this nonsensical theory to go unchallenged. Life does not come from matter. Matter is generated from life. This is not theory; it is fact. Science is based on an incorrect theory; therefore all its calculations and conclusions are wrong, and people are suffering because of this. When all these mistaken modern scientific theories are corrected, people will become happy. So we must challenge the scientists and defeat them. Otherwise they will mislead the entire society.

Matter changes in six phases: birth, growth, maintenance, production of by-products, dwindling, and death. But the life within matter, the spirit soul, is eternal; it goes through no such changes. Life appears to be developing and decaying, but actually it is simply passing through each of these six phases until the material body can no longer be maintained. Then the old body dies, and the soul enters a new body. When our clothing is old and worn, we change it. Similarly, one day our bodies become old and useless, and we pass on to a new body.

As Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.13], dehino 'smin yathä dehe kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä/ tathä dehäntara-präptiù: "As the embodied soul continuously passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death." And a little later [2.18]: antavanta ime dehä nityasyoktäù çarériëaù. This means that only the material body of the indestructible and eternal entity is subject to destruction. This material body is perishable, but the life within the body is nitya, eternal.

According to the Vedas, the measurement of the soul within the body is one ten-thousandth part of the tip of a hair. This is very small; in fact, it is atomic. Yet because of that atomic spiritual energy, my body is working. Is it so difficult to understand? Suppose a man thinks himself very stout and strong. Why is he stout and strong? Only because within his body is a small spiritual spark. But as soon as the spiritual spark is gone, his body dies, and his strength and vigor become void. If scientists say that matter is the cause and origin of life, then let them bring just one dead man back to life by injecting him with chemicals. But this they cannot do.

Dr. Singh: Since scientists cannot see the spirit soul, they say its existence is very doubtful.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can they see it? It is too small to see. Where is such seeing power?

Dr. Singh: Still, they want to sense it by some means.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you inject just one grain of deadly poison into someone, he immediately dies. No one can see the poison or how it acts. But the poison is acting nevertheless. In the same way, the Vedas say that because the minute particle called the soul is within the body, the whole body is working nicely. If I pinch myself, I immediately feel it, because I am conscious all over my skin. But as soon as the soul is absent, which is the case when my body dies, you can take this same skin and cut it and chop it, and no one will protest. Why is this simple thing so hard to understand? ls this not detecting spirit?

Dr. Singh: That is the soul. But what about God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all let us understand the soul. The soul is a small God. If you understand the sample, then you can understand the whole.

Now here is matter. [Çréla Prabhupäda points at a dead tree with his cane.] Formerly leaves and twigs were growing from this tree. Why are they not growing now? Can the scientists answer this question?

Karändhara däsa: They would say the chemical composition has changed.

Çréla Prabhupäda: All right, then if they are so advanced in knowledge of chemistry, they must supply the proper chemicals to make branches and leaves grow again.

Brahmänanda Swami: Knowledge means that one must be able to demonstrate his theory. They should be able to show in their laboratories that life is caused by a combination of chemicals.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the scientific method means first observation, then hypothesis, and then demonstration. But these scientists cannot demonstrate their hypothesis. They simply observe and then speak nonsense.

Scientists say that the chemicals are the cause of life. But all the chemicals that were there when the tree was living are still present. And life energy is also there. There are thousands of microbes in the tree, and they are all living entities. No one can claim that life energy is lacking in the body of this tree.

Dr. Singh: But what about the life energy of the tree itself?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the difference. The living force is individual, and the particular individual living entity which was the tree has left. This must be the case, since all the chemicals that are necessary to support life are still there yet the tree is dead.

Here is another example: suppose I am living in an apartment, and then I leave it. I am gone, but many other living entities remain there—ants, spiders, and so forth. It is not true that simply because I have left the apartment, it can no longer accommodate life. Other living entities are still living there. It is simply that I—an individual living being—have left. The chemicals in the tree are like the apartment; they are simply the environment for the individual living force—the soul—to act through. Thus the scientists will never be able to produce life in the chemical laboratory.

The so-called scientists say that life begins from chemicals. But the real question is, "Where have the chemicals come from?" The chemicals come from life, and this means that life has mystic power. For example, an orange tree contains many oranges, and each orange contains chemicals—citric acid and others. So where have these chemicals come from? Obviously they have come from the life within the tree. The scientists are missing the origin of the chemicals. They have started their investigation from the chemicals, but they cannot identify the origin of the chemicals. Chemicals come from the supreme life—God. Just as the living body of a man produces many chemicals, the supreme life (the Supreme Lord) is producing all the chemicals found in the atmosphere, in the water, in humans, in animals, and in the earth. And that is called mystic power. Unless the mystic power of the Supreme Lord is accepted, there is no solution to the problem of the origin of life.

Dr. Singh: The scientists will reply that they cannot believe in mystic power.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But they must explain the origin of the chemicals. Anyone can see that an ordinary tree is producing many chemicals; they cannot deny it. But how does it produce them? Since they cannot answer this, they must accept that the living force has mystic power. I cannot explain how my fingernail is growing out of my finger; it is beyond the power of my brain. In other words, it is growing by inconceivable potency, or acintya-çakti. So if acintya-çakti exists in an ordinary being, imagine how much acintya-çakti God possesses.

The difference between God and me is that although I have the same potencies as God, I can produce only a small quantity of chemicals, whereas He can produce enormous quantities. I can produce a little water in the form of perspiration, but God can produce the seas. Analysis of one drop of seawater gives you the qualitative analysis of the sea, without any mistake. Similarly, the ordinary living being is part and parcel of God, so by analyzing the living beings we can begin to understand God. In God there is great mystic potency. God's mystic potency is working swiftly, exactly like an electric machine. Machines operate by certain energy, and they are so nicely made that all the work is done simply by pushing a button. Similarly, God said, "Let there be creation," and there was creation. Considered in this way, the workings of nature are not very difficult to understand. God has such wonderful potencies that the creation, on His order alone, immediately takes place.

Brahmänanda Swami: Scientists don't accept God or acintya-çakti.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is their rascaldom. God exists, and His acintya-çakti also exists.

Karändhara däsa: Scientists say that life was created biochemically.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And I say to them: "Why don't you create life? Your biology and chemistry are very advanced, so why don't you create life?"

Karändhara däsa: They say they will create life in the future.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When in the future? If the scientists know the creative process, why can't they create life now? If life has a biochemical origin, and if biologists and chemists are so advanced, then why can't they create life in their laboratories? When this crucial point is raised, they say, "We shall do it in the future." Why in the future? That is nonsense. Trust no future, however pleasant. What is the meaning of their advancement? They are talking nonsense.

Karändhara däsa: They say that they are right on the verge of creating life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But that is also the future, in a different way. They must accept that they still do not know the truth about the origin of life. Since they are expecting to be able to create life in the future, presently their knowledge must be imperfect. Their proposal is something like giving someone a postdated check. Suppose I owe you ten thousand dollars and I say, "Yes, I will pay you the entire sum with this postdated check. Is that all right?" If you are intelligent, you will can see something tangible." Similarly, the scientists cannot produce even a single blade of grass by biochemistry, yet still they claim that life is produced from matter. What is this nonsense? Is no one questioning this? We can prove that life began from life. Here is the proof: when a father begets a child, the father is living, and the child is living. But where is the scientist's proof that life comes from matter? We can prove that life begins from life, and we can also prove that the original life is Kåñëa. But what evidence exists that a child is ever born out of a dead stone? The scientists cannot prove that life comes from matter. They are leaving that aside for the future.

Karändhara däsa: The basis of what the scientists call "scientific integrity" is that they talk only about what they can experience through their senses.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then they are suffering from what we call "Doctor Frog's philosophy." There was once a frog who had lived all his life in a well. One day a friend visited him and informed him of the existence of the Atlantic Ocean.

"Oh, what is this Atlantic Ocean?" asked the frog in the well.

"It is a vast body of water," his friend replied.

"How vast? ls it double the size of this well?"

"Oh, no, much larger," his friend replied.

"How much larger? Ten times the size?"

In this way the frog went on calculating. But what was the possibility of his ever understanding the depths and fur reaches of the great ocean? Our faculties, experience, and powers of speculation are always limited. The frog was always thinking in terms relative to his well. He had no power to think otherwise. Similarly, the scientists are estimating the Absolute Truth, the cause of all causes, with their imperfect senses and minds, and thus they are bound to be bewildered. The essential fault of the so-called scientists is that they have adopted the inductive process to arrive at their conclusions. For example, if a scientist wants to determine whether or not man is mortal by the inductive process, he must study every man to try to discover if some or one of them may be immortal. The scientist says, "I cannot accept the proposition that all men are mortal. There may be some men who are immortal. I have not yet seen every man. Therefore how can I accept that man is mortal?" This is called the inductive process. And the deductive process means that your father, your teacher, or your guru says that man is mortal, and you accept it.

Dr. Singh: So there is an ascending process of gaining knowledge and a descending process?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. The ascending process will never be successful, because it relies on information gathered through the senses, and the senses are imperfect. So we accept the descending process.

God cannot be known by the inductive process. Therefore He is called adhokñaja, which means "unknowable by direct perception." The scientists say there is no God, because they are trying to understand by direct perception. But He is adhokñaja; therefore the scientists are ignorant of God because they are missing the method of knowing Him. In order to understand transcendental science, one must approach a bona fide spiritual master, hear from him submissively, and render service to him. Lord Kåñëa explains this in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.34]: tad viddhi praëipätena paripraçnena sevayä.

Dr. Singh: There is a scientific journal called Nature. It contains articles concerning natural products like plants and animals, but it does not mention God—only nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We may correctly observe that plants are being produced by nature, but we must ask, "What has produced nature?" To ask this question is intelligence.

Dr. Singh: The scientists don't think about that.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So they are fools. As soon as we speak of nature, the next question should be, "Whose nature?" For instance, I speak of my nature, and you speak of your nature. Therefore, as soon as nature is mentioned, the next inquiry should be, "Whose nature?"

Nature means energy, and as soon as you speak of energy, you must accept that there is a source of that energy. For example, the source of electric energy is the electric powerhouse. Electricity is not produced automatically. We must install a powerhouse and a generator. Similarly, in the Vedas it is said that material nature is working under Kåñëa's direction.

Dr. Singh: So do you mean to say that science has started from an intermediate point—not from the original point?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is it exactly. They are ignorant of the origin. The scientists start from one point—but where does that point come from? That they do not know, in spite of vast research. One has to accept that the original source is God, who is full of all mystic powers and from whom everything emanates. He Himself says in the Bhagavad-gétä [10.8], ahaà sarvasya prabhavo mattaù sarvaà pravartate: "I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me." Our conclusions are not based on blind faith; they are most scientific. Matter comes from life. In life—in the origin—there are unlimited material resources; that is the great mystery of creation.

Modern scientific research is just like Säìkhya philosophy, which analyzes material elements. Säìkhya means "to count." We are also Säìkhya philosophers to some extent, because we count and analyze the material elements; this is land, this is water, this is air, this is sunshine, this is fire. Furthermore, I can count my mind, my intelligence, and my ego. Beyond my ego, however, I cannot count. But Kåñëa says that there is existence beyond the ego, and that existence is the living force—the spirit soul. This is what the scientists do not know. They think that life is merely a combination of material elements, but Kåñëa denies this in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.12]. Apareyam itas tv anyäà prakåtià viddhi me paräm: "Besides this inferior nature there is a superior energy of Mine." The inferior energy is the material elements, and the superior energy is the living entity.

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

"Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego—all together these eight comprise My separated material energies." [Bg. 7.4] Kåñëa explains here in the Bhagavad-gétä that väyu (gas) comes from Him, and that finer than the gases is kham (ether). Finer than ether is the mind, finer than the mind is intelligence, and finer than the intelligence is the soul. But the scientists do not know this. They can perceive only gross things. They mention väyu, but where does the väyu come from? Where does the gas come from?

Dr. Singh: That they cannot answer.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But we can answer. We have the knowledge that gas comes from kham, or ether, and ether comes from mind, mind comes from intelligence, and intelligence comes from Kåñëa's superior energy, the spirit soul.

Dr. Singh: Are both inferior and superior energies studied in Säìkhya philosophy?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Säìkhya philosophers do not know of superior energy. They simply analyze the material elements, just as the scientists do. Neither the scientists nor the Säìkhya philosophers know anything of the spirit soul. They are simply analyzing Kåñëa's material energy.

Dr. Singh: They are analyzing the creative material elements?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Material elements are not creative! The soul is creative. No one can create life with only matter, and matter cannot create itself. You, a living entity, can mix hydrogen and oxygen to create water. But matter itself has no creative energy. If you place a bottle of hydrogen near a bottle of oxygen, will they automatically combine, without your help?

Dr. Singh: No. They must be mixed.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the superior energy—the living entity—is required. Oxygen and hydrogen are inferior energy, but when the superior energy mixes them, then they can become water.

Inferior energy has no power unless superior energy is involved. This sea [indicating the Pacific Ocean] is calm and quiet. But when superior force—air—pushes it, high waves are created. The sea has no power without the superior force. Similarly, there is another force superior to the air, and another, and another, until we arrive at Kåñëa, the most superior force. This is real research. Suppose a railroad train is just starting to move. The engine pushes one car, which pushes another, and so on, until the entire train is moving. And the whole motion originates with the engineer, a living entity. Similarly, in the cosmic creation, Kåñëa gives the first push, and then, by means of many successive pushes, the entire cosmic manifestation comes into being. This is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä [9.10]: mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram. "This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and is producing all moving and unmoving beings." And a little later:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"All species of life are made possible by birth in material nature, and I am the seed-giving father." [Bg. 14.4] For example, if we sow a banyan seed, a huge tree eventually grows up and produces millions of new seeds. Each of these seeds, in turn, produces another tree with millions of new seeds, and so on. So Kåñëa is the original seed-giving father.

Unfortunately, the scientists only observe the immediate cause; they do not perceive the remote cause. There are two causes—the immediate cause and the remote cause. Kåñëa is described in the Vedas as sarva-käraëa-käraëam, the cause of all causes. If you understand the cause of all causes, then you understand everything. Yasmin vijïäte sarvam evaà vijïätaà bhavati: "If you know the original cause, the later, subordinate causes are automatically known." [Muëòaka Up. 1.3] Although the scientists are searching after the original cause, when the Vedas, which contain perfect knowledge, give the original cause, they won't accept. They keep to their partial, imperfect knowledge.

Dr. Singh: Scientists are worried about energy sources, and now they are working to utilize solar energy for cooking, lighting, and various other purposes. They are hoping that when they exhaust all other energy sources, they will be able to use solar energy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is not a very new theory. Everyone knows that because the roots of trees store the sun's energy, it is possible to get fire from a tree. These scientists are tiny creatures, but they are very proud. We don't give them credit, because they are simply stating what everyone knows. As soon as you cut a tree, you cannot get fire from it. It has to be dried in the sun. When the energy is gathered from the sun, the tree can be utilized for fire. Actually everything is being maintained by the sun's energy, but the scientists don't know where the sun's energy comes from. In the Bhagavad-gétä [15.12] Kåñëa says:

yad äditya-gataà tejo
jagad bhäsayate 'khilam
yac candramasi yac cägnau
tat tejo viddhi mämakam

"The splendor of the sun, which dissipates the darkness of this whole world, comes from Me. And the splendor of the moon and the splendor of fire are also from Me."

Again, Kåñëa says, jyotiñäà ravir aàçumän: "Of lights I am the radiant sun." [Bg. 10.21] Also, in the Eleventh Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä [11.19] Arjuna tells Kåñëa, çaçi-sürya-netram: "The sun and moon are among Your great, unlimited eyes." This knowledge is contained in the Bhagavad-gétä, but scientists cannot attain this knowledge by their speculation. Can they?

Dr. Singh: It is not possible.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And what is their knowledge? The scriptures say that even if you counted all the grains of sand on earth, you still would not be able to understand God. All this material counting does not mean that you have the capacity to understand the unlimited. But it is even beyond their capacity to count all the material things. Why are the scientists so proud of their energy and capacities? They do not even know of the material things, and what to speak of the spiritual. As far as scientists and other living entities are concerned, their knowledge is limited. But this is not so for Kåñëa. If we receive knowledge from Kåñëa, that knowledge is perfect. In the scriptures we receive information that there are nine hundred thousand species of life existing within the ocean. The information given in the scriptures is exact, because it comes from Kåñëa, and as Kåñëa Himself says: "As the Supreme Personality of Godhead, I know everything that has happened in the past, all that is happening in the present, and all things that are yet to come." [Bg. 7.26]

Dr. Singh: We have to take knowledge from the supreme knower.

Çréla Prabhupäda: For perfect knowledge we have to approach a superior person, a guru. One may try to learn a subject by reading books at home, but he can learn much better by going to college and approaching a professor. In the same way, we have to approach a guru. Of course, if we encounter a false guru, our knowledge is false. But if our guru is perfect, our knowledge is perfect. We accept Kåñëa as our guru. If He is perfect in knowledge, our knowledge is also perfect. As far as we're concerned, we do not have to be perfect in ourselves, but if we receive knowledge from the perfect, our knowledge is perfect. We cannot say that we understand that there are nine hundred thousand species of life in the ocean because we have studied the entire ocean. Rather, we say that we take this information from scriptures, and therefore it is perfect. This is the Vedic process.

Scientists may carry out much research work, but however great a scientist may be, his senses are imperfect. Therefore he cannot have perfect knowledge. What is the value of our eyes? We cannot see without sunlight, nor can we see small things without a microscope. Our eyes are imperfect, and the instruments our eyes have discovered are also imperfect. How, then, is it possible to get perfect knowledge? Because the living entity is limited, his knowledge is limited. A child may know that two plus two equals four, but when he speaks of higher mathematics, we do not take him seriously. The senses through which a scientist acquires knowledge are limited and imperfect; therefore his knowledge is limited and imperfect. In his ignorance he may claim to know everything, but that is simply nonsense.

A blind man may lead another blind man, but what does it avail them when they both fall into a ditch? The laws of nature bind us hand and foot, yet we think we are free to speculate. This is illusion. Although conditioned by so many of nature's laws, the rascals think they are free. Yet if there is a cloud, they cannot see the sun. What power have we to see? Only when nature's laws give us some facility are we able to see. Indeed, we can only experiment under certain conditions, and if the conditions are not favorable, our experiments fail. Why then are we so proud of experimental knowledge?

Why experiment? Things are already there. The sun's energy is there, given by God for us to use. What else is there to know? So many apples fall from trees. What further need is there to explain the law of gravity? Actually the scientists are lacking in common sense. They are simply concerned with "scientific" explanations. They say the law of gravity works only under certain conditions, but who has made these conditions? When Kåñëa appeared as Lord Rämacandra, He threw stones on the water, and the stones floated. The law of gravity did not work in that case. Therefore the law of gravity works only under the direction of the Supreme Lord. The law in itself is not final. A king may give a law, but he can change that law immediately. The ultimate law-giver is Kåñëa, and a law will only work by His will. Scientists try to explain God's will in so many ways, but because they are conditioned by mäyä, illusion, they can only talk like a person haunted by ghosts. Tell me, what is the scientific explanation that accounts for all the varieties of trees?

Karändhara däsa: They say that nature mutates and makes these varieties.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then it must be nature's will. And what is that will? Does the land have any will?

Karändhara däsa: Well, they are very vague on that point.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That means that they do not have perfect knowledge. They do not know that behind nature is the will of Kåñëa.

Dr. Singh: They explain that the chemical composition of these different plants is different.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That's all right, but who made these chemical compositions? As soon as you say "chemical composition," you immediately require a God.

Karändhara däsa: They say there is no need for a God, because if you mix two chemicals together...

Çréla Prabhupäda: God or not, there must be some will. There must be some consciousness. Two chemicals mix and produce such and such. Who mixes them? Consciousness is there. Well, that consciousness is Kåñëa. There is consciousness everywhere, and as soon as you accept that consciousness, you must accept consciousness as a person. Therefore, we speak of Kåñëa consciousness. In the Bhagavad-gétä it is stated that consciousness is all-pervading. You may have consciousness, and I may have consciousness, but there is another consciousness, which is all-pervading. My consciousness is limited to my body, and your consciousness is limited to yours, but there is another consciousness, which is within you, me, and everyone. That is Kåñëa consciousness.

Actually everything in the world is relative. That is a scientific fact. Our bodies, lives, intelligence, and everything else are all relative. To us an ant may seem to have a very short life, but for the ant his life is about a hundred years in duration. That hundred years is relative to the body. Similarly, Brahmä, who lives fantastically long from our point of view, only lives a hundred years from his point of view. This is relativity.

Karändhara däsa: Then the relativity is based upon our individual situation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Therefore it is said that what is food for one is poison for another. People are thinking that because they cannot survive on the moon, no other living entities can. Everyone thinks of things in a relative way, in his own terms. This is the meaning of "frog philosophy." The frog is always thinking of things in relation to his well. He has no power to conceive of the Atlantic Ocean, because his well is his only experience. God is great, but we are thinking of God's greatness in our own terms, in terms of relative greatness. Some insects are born at night; they grow at night, have their children at night, and die at night. They never see the sun; therefore they conclude that there is no such thing as day. If you asked the insect about the morning, he would say, "There cannot be any morning." Similarly, when people hear of Brahmä's long duration of life from the scriptures, they do not believe it. They say, "How can anyone live for such a long time?" In the Bhagavad-gétä [8.17] Kåñëa states:

sahasra-yuga-paryantam
ahar yad brahmaëo viduù
rätrià yuga-sahasräntäà
te 'ho-rätra-vido janäù

"By human calculation, a thousand ages taken together is the duration of Brahmä's one day. And such also is the duration of his night."

Thus Brahmä, by these calculations, lives for so many millions and trillions of years. We cannot believe this, although evidence is given in the scriptures. In other words, we conclude that Kåñëa talks nonsensically, while we speak as authorities. Even great scholars say that these scriptural statements are all mental speculations. Although these men are nothing but rascals, they pass for reputable scholars. They place themselves above God's position by attempting to refute or deny the statements of God in the revealed scriptures. In this way so many fools in the guise of scholars, scientists, and philosophers are misguiding the whole world.

Dr. Singh: Of course, so much is being written about Darwin's theory. In any library there are hundreds of books on his theories.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Do they accept or reject them?

Dr. Singh: Generally they accept him, but there are some who are very critical.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Darwin speaks about the evolution of the species of life, but he has no real information about spiritual evolution. He knows nothing about the progress of the spirit soul from lower forms of life to higher forms. He claims that man has evolved from monkeys, but we can see that the monkey is not extinct. If the monkey is the immediate forefather of man, why is the monkey still existing?

Dr. Singh: Darwin says that the species are not created independently but are descended from one another.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If there is no question of independence, how can he abruptly begin with a certain species? He must explain how the original species came into existence.

Karändhara däsa: Scientists claim that the earth was created by biological chemistry, and they refuse to teach that God created the earth, because they think everyone will consider them fools.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If their biology and chemistry are so advanced, why don't they create something? They claim they may be able to create life in the future, but why in the future? Life is already created. Is science based on the future? We should trust no future, however pleasant we may think it will be. Everyone is thinking the future will be very pleasant, but what assurance do we have of this? They have to accept that they do not know what the truth actually is. They cannot even produce a spear of grass through their biological or chemical experiments. Nonetheless they are claiming that the creation is produced by some chemical or biological method. Why does no one question all this nonsense?

Dr. Singh: In the ultimate analysis, when they consider the origin of life, they say that everything started from matter. In other words, living matter comes from nonliving matter.

Çréla Prabhupäda: From where is this living matter coming now? Did it come from nonliving matter in the past and not at the present? How is the ant coming? Is it materializing from dirt? Even an ant does not come from inert matter. What proof do they have of such a theory? Darwin claims that in the distant past no really intelligent man existed, that man simply evolved from the apes. If there was no intelligent brain in the past, how is it that these Vedic scriptures were written thousands and thousands of years ago? How do they explain a sage like Vyäsadeva?

Dr. Singh: They have no explanation. They simply say these are unknown forest sages.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Vyäsadeva may be unknown to them, but nonetheless he was there. How is it he got such a brain? He may be unknown to you or to me, but nonetheless his brain-work is there, his philosophy is there, his language, linguistics, poetic arrangements, and verbal strength. You may not know the person, but you can understand the brain.

Dr. Singh: Weren't all the varieties of animals existing from the beginning?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Simultaneous creation is verified by the Bhagavad-gétä. All the varieties of animals and men as well as demigods were existing from the beginning. A living entity wants a certain type of body, and Kåñëa gives it to him. Because he desires things in a certain way, he associates with certain qualities of nature in matter. According to his association, he receives a particular type of body. The psychological forces of the mind—thinking, feeling, and willing—determine the particular type of situation and body the living entity receives. The evolutionary process is there, but it is not an evolution of species. It is not that one species of life develops from another, for, as Kåñëa states:

avyaktäd vyaktayaù sarväù
prabhavanty ahar-ägame
rätry-ägame praléyante
tatraivävyakta-saàjïake

“When Brahmä’s day is manifest, this multitude of living entities comes into being, and at the arrival of Brahmä’s night they are all annihilated.” [Bg. 8.18]

The evolution is the spiritual evolution of the individual living entity through the various species of life. If one enters into the body of a fish, he has to undergo the evolutionary process step by step. If one is on the top of the stairs and somehow falls down, he again has to go up the evolutionary staircase step by step. Of course, the scientists are busy making so much research that they cannot understand this. If you tell them they are going to be trees in their next life, they think you are speaking nonsense. After all, what can we learn by research? When the cause of all causes is known, then everything knowable becomes known, and nothing remains unknown. As the Vedas state: yasmin vijïäte sarvam evaà vijïätaà bhavati. If we know the Absolute Truth, all other truths become known, but if we don't know the Absolute Truth, we are in ignorance. One may not be an official scientist or philosopher, but he may challenge anyone and talk boldly if he only knows one thing—Kåñëa.

This contemporary civilization is so proud of its independence, but actually it is so much dependent on oil. If the oil supply is stopped, then what will these rascal scientists do? They cannot do anything. Let them try to manufacture oil in their test tubes, enough oil to run their civilization on. At present there is a scarcity of water in India. What can the scientists do about this? They may know the chemical composition of water, but they cannot produce it when there is a great scarcity. They require the help of clouds, and all that is God's manipulation. Actually they cannot do anything. They have gone to the moon, but for all their labor they have simply taken away some dust and rocks. The rascal government exacts taxes and spends money unnecessarily. This is their intelligence. It is a state of asses, that's all. The politicians have no sympathy or compassion. They do not consider that the hard-earned money is coming from the public and that they are spending it by shooting big rockets off to other planets. All they do is promise to bring back more dust. First they may get a handful of dust, then they promise to bring back tons of dust. What is the meaning of all this?

Karändhara däsa: They believe that there may be life on Mars.

Çréla Prabhupäda: They may believe or not believe—what is the gain? What we do know is that life is here. They know this, yet they are engaged in fighting and in killing life. Here is life. Here is a human being. Life is here undoubtedly. But they are busy trying to destroy it with their big bombs. This is their scientific advancement.

Dr. Singh: They are very curious to know what is going on, on other planets.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That means that for their childish curiosity they are spending so much money. They can spend so much to satisfy their curiosity, but when so many poverty-stricken countries ask them for help, they say there is no money. They are very proud to go to the moon, but why don't they take information how to go to Kåñëa's Goloka Våndävana? If they go there, all their curiosity will be satisfied. They will learn that beyond this inferior energy there is indeed a superior, spiritual energy. This material energy cannot work independently. The spiritual energy has to join it. Material elements are not created of themselves. It is the soul that is creative. We may try to make something with matter, but matter does not create itself. Hydrogen and oxygen will come in contact only when moved by the superior energy. Only fools can expect the entire cosmic manifestation, which is only matter, to come into being automatically. We may have a nice car, but if there is no driver, what is its use? Unless a man knows how to work a machine, unless a man pushes a button, the machine does not work. Similarly, without the superior energy, the material energy cannot act. Behind this wonderful cosmic manifestation is the direction of a superior energy. All this information is given in the scriptures, but still people will not believe it.

Actually everything is God's property, but people are claiming this property to be theirs or their country's. Now they are talking about the problem of overpopulation, but the fact is that God has supplied enough. Actually there is enough land and enough food if it is properly used. People are artificially creating problems, and the scientists are helping them by giving them so many destructive devices. They simply encourage the rascals and rogues who are trying to use up God's property. If you help a murderer or a thief, you also become a criminal. Is that not so? There is so much trouble in the world because the scientists are helping all the thieves and rogues. Thus they are all criminals. Stena eva saù. One who does not recognize the proprietorship of the Supreme Lord is a thief.

Our mission is to bring these rascals to their senses. Now one must find out the means to do this. The rascals are suffering, but because they are sons of God they should not suffer. They do not know that there is God or that there is happiness. They know nothing of bliss or of eternal life. They are carrying on so much research and living for fifty, sixty, or seventy years. After that they do not know what is going to happen. They have no knowledge that life is eternal. Actually their position is like that of an animal. An animal does not know what is after death, nor does he actually contemplate death. He does not know why he is here, nor does he know the value of life. Under the influence of mäyä, the animal simply goes on eating, sleeping, defending, mating, and dying. That's all. People are endeavoring so hard, but for what purpose? They say that they are struggling so hard to make provisions for the next generation, but what are the provisions for? They cannot reply to that. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant to give real purpose to life by establishing Kåñëa, God, as the center of everything. It is therefore to the scientist's benefit to understand this important movement.

SSR 7: Returning to the Eternal Religion

VII. Returning to the Eternal Religion

SSR 7a: Çréla Prabhupäda Arrives in America

Çréla Prabhupäda Arrives in America

On September 18,1965, as the Indian steamship Jaladuta nears Boston’s Commonwealth Pier, Çréla Prabhupäda prays to Lord Kåñëa in a moving poem. "...I am simply praying for Your mercy so that I will be able to convince them about Your message... ”

1

My dear Lord Kåñëa, You are so kind upon this useless soul, but I do not know why You have brought me here. Now You can do whatever You like with me.

2

But I guess You have some business here, otherwise why would You bring me to this terrible place?

3

Most of the population here is covered by the material modes of ignorance and passion. Absorbed in material life, they think themselves very happy and satisfied, and therefore they have no taste for the transcendental message of Väsudeva. I do not know how they will be able to understand it.

4

But I know Your causeless mercy can make everything possible, because You are the most expert mystic.

5

How will they understand the mellows of devotional service? O Lord, I am simply praying for Your mercy so that I will be able to convince them about Your message.

6

All living entities have become under the control of the illusory energy by Your will, and therefore, if You like, by Your will they can also be released from the clutches of illusion.

7

I wish that You may deliver them. Therefore if You so desire their deliverance, then only will they be able to understand Your message.

8

The words of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam are Your incarnation, and if a sober person repeatedly receives them with submissive aural reception, then he will be able to understand Your message.

9

It is said in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.2.17-21]: “Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead, who is the Paramätmä [Supersoul] in everyone’s heart and the benefactor of the truthful devotee, cleanses desire for material enjoyment from the heart of the devotee who relishes His messages, which are in themselves virtuous when properly heard and chanted. By regularly hearing the Bhägavatam and rendering service unto the pure devotee, all that is troublesome to the heart is practically destroyed, and loving service unto the glorious Lord, who is praised with transcendental songs, is established as an irrevocable fact. At the time loving service is established in the heart, the modes of passion [rajas] and ignorance [tamas], and lust and desire [käma] disappear from the heart. Then the devotee is established in goodness and he becomes happy. Thus established in the mode of goodness, the man rejuvenated by loving service to the Lord gains liberation from material association [mukti] and comes to know scientifically of the Personality of Godhead. Thus the knots of the heart and all misgivings are cut to pieces. The chain of fruitive actions [karma] is terminated when one sees the self as master.”

10

He will become liberated from the influence of the modes of ignorance and passion and thus all inauspicious things accumulated in the core of the heart will disappear.

11

How will I make them understand this message of Kåñëa consciousness? I am very unfortunate, unqualified, and the most fallen. Therefore I am seeking Your benediction so that I can convince them, for I am powerless to do so on my own.

12

Somehow or other, O Lord, You have brought me here to speak about You. Now, my Lord, it is up to You to make me a success or failure as You like.

13

O spiritual master of all the worlds! I can simply repeat Your message, so if You like You can make my power of speaking suitable for their understanding.

14

Only by Your causeless mercy will my words become pure. I am sure that when this transcendental message penetrates their hearts they will certainly feel engladdened and thus become liberated from all unhappy conditions of life.

15

O Lord, I am just like a puppet in Your hands. So if You have brought me here to dance, then make me dance, make me dance. O Lord, make me dance as You like.

16

I have no devotion, nor do I have any knowledge, but I have strong faith in the holy name of Kåñëa. I have been designated as Bhaktivedanta, and now, if You like, You can fulfill the real purport of Bhaktivedanta.

Signed—the most unfortunate, insignificant beggar

A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami,

on board the ship Jaladuta, Commonwealth Pier,

Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.A.

dated 18th of September, 1965

SSR 7b: Build Your Nation on the Spiritual Platform

Build Your Nation on the Spiritual Platform

Çréla Prabhupäda gives an address at the University of Nairobi: "You are trying to develop yourselves, so please develop spiritually, for spiritual development is sound development. Don’t imitate the Americans and Europeans, who are living like cats and dogs. The atomic bomb is already there, and as soon as the next war breaks out, all their skyscrapers and everything else will be finished. Try to understand this from the real viewpoint of human life, the spiritual viewpoint....”

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for kindly coming here to participate in this meeting for spreading Kåñëa consciousness. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying to bring human society to the point where everyone’s life can become successful. The subject today is the real meaning of human life. We are trying to instruct the entire world about this meaning.

Human life is attained after many, many millions of years of evolution. We should remember that there are 8,400,000 species of life according to the Padma Puräëa. Life began with the aquatics, for we can understand from Vedic literature that at the beginning of creation the entire planet was merged in water. This material world is composed of five gross elements—earth, water, fire, air, and ether. Besides these there are three subtle elements—mind, intelligence, and ego. Behind these curtains is the spirit soul, which is covered by these eight elements. This information is given in the Bhagavad-gétä.

Human beings are not the only living entities to have a spirit soul. We are all spirit souls—beasts, birds, reptiles, insects, trees, plants, aquatics, and so on. The spirit soul is simply covered by different dresses, just as some of you are dressed in white clothes, some in green, some in red, etc. But we are not concerned with the dress; we are concerned with you as spirit soul. Thus it is said in the Bhagavad-gétä [5.18]:

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe ga vi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

“The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog, and a dog-eater. ”

The sage does not make any distinction on the basis of color, intelligence, or species. He sees every living entity as a small particle of spirit soul. It is stated:

keçägra-çata-bhägasya
çatäàçaù sädåçätmakaù
jévaù sükñma-svarüpo 'yaà
saìkhyätéto hi cit-kaëaù
[Madhya 19.140]

“There are innumerable particles of spiritual atoms, which are measured as one ten-thousandth of the upper portion of a hair.” Because we have no instrument to measure the dimensions of the spirit soul, the small particle of spirit soul is measured in this way. In other words, the soul is so small that it is smaller than an atom. That small particle is within you, within me, within the elephant, within gigantic animals, in all men, in the ant, in the tree, everywhere. However, scientific knowledge cannot estimate the dimensions of the soul, nor can a doctor locate the soul within the body. Consequently material scientists conclude that there is no soul, but that is not a fact. There is a soul. The presence of the soul makes a difference between a living body and a dead body. As soon as the soul departs from the body, the body dies. It has no value. However great a scientist or a philosopher one may be, he must admit that as soon as the soul departs from the body, the body dies. It then has no value and has to be thrown away. We should try to understand this; the soul is valuable, not the body. The fact that the soul is transmigrating is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.22]:

väsäàsi jérëäni yathä vihäya
naväni gåhëäti naro 'paräëi
tathä çaréräëi vihäya jérëäny
anyäni saàyäti naväni dehé

“As a person puts on new garments, giving up old ones, similarly, the soul accepts new material bodies, giving up the old and useless ones.”

When a suit becomes old, we give it up and accept another suit; similarly the soul is changing dresses according to desire. Because the soul is part and parcel of God, it has godly qualities. God is the supreme will, the supreme power, the supreme independent one, and we, being part and parcel of Him, have all these qualities in minute quantity. We have willing, thinking, feeling, and desiring. In the Vedas it is stated that God is the supreme living force among all living forces (cetanaç cetanänäm). He is also supplying the necessities of all living entities.

We living entities are innumerable; there is no limit to our number. God, however, is one. He is also living, as we are but we are minute particles of that living force. For example, a particle of gold is the same in quality as a gold mine. If we chemically analyze the ingredients in a small drop of water, we will find all of the ingredients that are to be found in the vast ocean. In a similar way, we are one with God, being His part and parcel. This godly particle, the soul, or the living force, is transmigrating from aquatics to trees and plants and then from trees and plants to insect life, then to reptile life, then to the bodies of birds and beasts. Darwin’s theory of evolution is but a partial explanation of the transmigration of the soul. Darwin has simply taken information from Vedic literature, but he has no conception of the soul. The difference is that the soul is transmigrating from aquatic life to plants and trees, then to insect life, then to bird life, then animal life, then human life, and within human life he moves from uncivilized life to civilized life, etc. The civilized life of a human being represents the culmination of evolution. Here is a junction: from this point we can again slide down into the cyclic process of evolution, or we can elevate ourselves to a godly life. The choice is up to us. This is indicated in the Bhagavad-gétä.

This human form of life actually means developed consciousness; therefore we should not waste our lives like cats, dogs, and hogs. That is the injunction. Although this body is perishable like a dog’s or cat’s body, it is different in that one can attain the highest perfection in this life. We are part and parcel of God, but somehow or other we have fallen into this material existence; now we have to evolve in such a way that we can go back home, back to Godhead. That is the highest perfection.

There is actually another world, a spiritual world. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [8.20]:

paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo
'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù
yaù sa sarveñu bhüteñu
naçyatsu na vinaçyati

“Yet there is another nature, which is eternal and is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is.”

In this material nature, everything is created, it stays for some time, produces some by-products, dwindles, and finally vanishes. Our bodies are created at a certain moment by sexual intercourse. The semen of the father emulsifies and takes a pea form, and the living entity, or soul, takes shelter in that form, and because it takes shelter, it develops hands, legs, eyes, etc. This development is complete in the seventh month, and in the ninth month the human being comes out of the womb. It is because the soul is present that the child develops. If the soul is not present, there is no development, and the child is born dead. We can take this dead body and preserve it in chemicals, but it will not develop. Development means change of body. All of us have had baby bodies, but those bodies are no longer existing. The body of a baby develops into the body of a child, and that body develops into the body of a boy, and that body develops into a youth’s body, which eventually turns into an old man’s body. Finally the body completely vanishes. The whole cosmic manifestation, the gigantic form of this material world, is also working according to this same process. It is created at a certain point, it develops, it is maintained, and at a certain stage it is dissolved. That is the nature of the material world. It is manifest at a certain interval, and again it vanishes (bhütvä bhütvä praléyate).

The word bhäva means “nature.” There is another nature, which never dissolves, which is eternal. As jévas, spirit souls, we are also eternal. This is verified in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.20]:

na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin
näyaà bhütvä bhavitä vä na bhüyaù
ajo nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëo
na hanyate hanyamäne çarére

“For the soul there is neither birth nor death. Nor, having once been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying, and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain.”

Just as God has no birth or death, we spirit souls can have neither birth nor death, but because we think, “I am this body,” we consider that we are born and that we die. Such thinking is called mäyä, or illusion, and as soon as we get out of this illusion of identifying the soul with the body, we attain the stage called brahma-bhüta. When one realizes ahaà brahmäsmi, “I am not this body; I am spirit soul, part and parcel of the Supreme Brahman,” he attains what is called Brahman realization. As soon as Brahman realization is attained, one becomes happy.

Is this not a fact? If you understand clearly that you have no birth and death, that you are eternal, will you not become happy? Yes, certainly. Thus when one is Brahman realized, spiritually realized, he has no more to do with hankering or lamentation. The whole world is simply hankering and lamenting. You African people are now hankering to be like Europeans and Americans, but the Europeans have lost their empire, and now they are lamenting. So in this way one party is hankering and another is lamenting. Similarly, this material life is simply a combination of hankering and lamenting. We are hankering for those things which we do not possess, and we are lamenting for those things which we have lost. That is our material business. If we realize, however, that we are part and parcel of the Supreme Personality of Godhead (Parabrahman) and that we are Brahman, then we will transcend this hankering and lamenting.

The so-called universal brotherhood or unity that the United Nations is trying to achieve is possible only when you come to the spiritual platform, or Brahman realization. Brahman realization is the aim of human life. One should not work like cats, dogs, and hogs. The hog is always very busy day and night trying to find stool, and when he finds it, he eats it and becomes sexually agitated and has sex without discrimination. A hog will have sex with its mother or sister or anyone else, and this is a hog’s life. However, the scriptures indicate that the human form of life is not meant for working hard for sense gratification like cats, dogs, and hogs. It is meant for realizing, “I do not belong to this material world. I am spirit soul and am eternal, but somehow or other I have fallen into this conditional life of birth, old age, disease, and death.” This human form of life is meant for making a solution to these four material miseries—birth, old age, disease, and death. That is the aim of human life. Just try to understand that human life is not meant for working very hard like hogs and then having some sense gratification and then all of a sudden dying.

People who do not believe in the soul are in a most unfortunate condition. They do not know where they came from nor where they are going. Knowledge of the soul is the most important knowledge, but it is not discussed in any university. But what is the constitution of this body? What is the distinction between a dead body and a living body? Why is the body living? What is the condition of the body, and what is its value? No one is presently studying these questions, but by this Kåñëa consciousness movement we are trying to educate people so that they can understand that they are not these bodies but are spirit souls. The business of human life is different from the business of cats and dogs. That is our message.

As far as the soul is concerned, the evolutionary process is going on, and we are struggling for existence, struggling to come to the point of eternal life. That eternal life is possible. If you try your best in this human form of life, in your next life you can get a spiritual body. Your spiritual body is already within you, and it will develop as soon as you become free from the contamination of this material existence. That is the aim of human life. People do not know what actual self-interest is; it is to realize oneself, to realize, “I am part and parcel of God, and I have to return to the kingdom of God to join with God.”

Just as we have a social life here, God has a social life in the spiritual kingdom. You can join Him there. It is not that after this body is finished you become void. No. That is a wrong conception. In the Bhagavad-gétä [2.12], Kåñëa told Arjuna on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra:

na tv evähaà jätu näsaà
na tvaà neme janädhipäù
na caiva na bhaviñyämaù
sarve vayam ataù param

“Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings; nor in the future shall any of us cease to be.”

The process for attaining eternal life is very easy, and yet at the same time very difficult. It is difficult because people in the beginning do not believe in the existence of transmigration of the soul. However, if we simply take knowledge from the authorities, the process becomes very simple. Our process of Kåñëa consciousness is to take knowledge from Kåñëa, the most perfect being, and not from an ordinary being conditioned by the laws of material nature. Knowledge taken from a conditioned being is sure to be defective.

What are the defects of the conditioned soul? He is sure to commit mistakes, sure to be illusioned, sure to cheat others, and sure to have imperfect senses. We cannot attain knowledge perfectly, because we want to cheat others and our senses are imperfect. Although our senses are imperfect, we are very proud of our eyes, and we want to see everything. Therefore someone says, “Can you show me God?” Actually the answer is yes. Why can’t you see God at every moment? Kåñëa says, raso ’ham apsu kaunteya: “I am the taste of water.” Everyone drinks water, and the taste is there—so if we think of this taste as God, we begin the process of God realization. Kåñëa also says, prabhäsmi çaçi-süryayoù: “I am the sunshine, and I am the moonshine.” We all see the sunshine and moonshine every day, and if we think of how it is that the sun and moon are emanating light, we will ultimately reach God. There are so many similar instances. If you want to be God conscious and realize God yourself, it is not very difficult. You have simply to follow the prescribed methods. As stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [18.55], tato mäà-tattvato jïätvä. We must simply try to understand God in truth and try to understand His appearance, disappearance, and functions. When we understand Him in truth, we immediately enter the kingdom of God. After quitting this body, the person who understands God, or Kåñëa, does not come back again to accept another material body. Kåñëa says, mäm eti: “He comes to Me.” That is our aim.

Therefore we should not waste our time living like cats and dogs. We should live comfortably, but at the same time we should be Kåñëa conscious, or God conscious. That will help us become happy. Without understanding God and without becoming God conscious, there is no possibility of peace and happiness. The way of peace and happiness is outlined in the Bhagavad-gétä.

If you really want to understand God, He is very easy to understand. God is the proprietor of everything. Éçäväsyam idaà sarvam. Unfortunately we are thinking, “I am the proprietor.” In your country, for instance, the British have sometimes claimed to be proprietors, and now you are claiming to be the proprietors—so who knows what will happen in the future? Actually no one knows who the real proprietor is. The land is there, and it is the property of God, but we are simply thinking, “I am the proprietor. I own this, and I own that.” Actually, America existed before the Europeans came, but now the Americans are thinking, “We are the proprietors.” Similarly, before them the Red Indians were thinking, “We are the proprietors.” The fact is that no man is an actual proprietor; the proprietor is God.

éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà
yat kiàca jagatyäà jagat
tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä
mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam

“Everything animate or inanimate that ftis within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one should not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong.” [Éçopaniñad 1]

This realization is wanting. Kåñëa claims proprietorship over all forms—including American forms, African forms, cat forms, dog forms, tree forms, etc.—for in actuality He is the proprietor and the supreme father. If we simply realize this, we attain God realization. Actually, if we realize God as prescribed in the authorized books and Vedic literatures, we will find that there will no longer be quarrels between this party and that party. Everything will be peaceful.

Everyone has the right to use God’s property, just as a son has the right to live at the cost of his father. It is stated in the scriptures that even a small animal in the home must be given some food. That is spiritual communism. No one should remain hungry, not even a serpent. We are always afraid of serpents, but if we find a serpent to be living in our house, it is our duty to see that the serpent is also fed. This is the conception of God consciousness, or Kåñëa consciousness: samaù sarveñu bhüteñu. One who is transcendentally situated is equally disposed to every living entity. Thus the Bhagavad-gétä [18.54] points out that when one sees everyone equally, as part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, one actually begins his devotional life. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying in an authoritative way to make everyone understand what he is and what the aim of life is. This process of purification of the heart is very easily accomplished. One simply has to chant this mahä-mantra—Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. It can actually be seen that in this movement there are boys and girls from different countries and different religions, but no one is concerned with any particular section, country, or religious body. We are simply concerned about knowing ourselves and our relationship with God.

God is the supreme proprietor, and we are all His sons, or servitors. Therefore let us engage ourselves in the service of the Lord, as recommended in the Bhagavad-gétä. As soon as we understand that God is the proprietor of everything, then all the troubles of the world will immediately be solved. This may take some time. It is not expected that everyone will understand this high philosophy, but if the intelligent people in every country try to understand it, that will be sufficient. In the Bhagavad-gétä [3.21] it is stated:

yad yad äcarati çreñöhas
tat tad evetaro janaù
sa yat pramäëaà kurute
lokas tad anuvartate

“Whatever action a great man performs, common men follow in his footsteps. And whatever standards he sets by exemplary acts, all the world pursues.”

We therefore invite the most intelligent men in the world to understand this Kåñëa conscious philosophy and try to distribute it all over the world. We have now come to these African countries, and I invite all intelligent Africans to come and understand this philosophy and distribute it. You are trying to develop yourselves, so please develop spiritually, for spiritual development is sound development. Don’t imitate the Americans and Europeans, who are living like cats and dogs. Such civilizations built on the consciousness of sense gratification cannot stand. The atomic bomb is already there, and as soon as the next war breaks out, all their skyscrapers and everything else will be finished. Try to understand this from the real viewpoint of human life, the spiritual viewpoint. This is what this Kåñëa consciousness movement is about. We therefore request you to try to understand this philosophy. Thank you very much.

SSR 7c: "A Devotee Always Feels Compassion for Others' Distress"

"A Devotee Always Feels Compassion for Others' Distress"

"When Lord Jesus Christ presented himself, for instance, he was greatly afflicted by the miserable conditions of the people. Regardless of which country or sect they belong to, all Vaiñëavas, or devotees—any people who are God conscious, or Kåñëa conscious—are thus compassionate...."

Today I shall speak to you about the glorification of the holy name of God. This was discussed between Mahäräja Parékñit and Çukadeva Goswami in connection with a brähmaëa who was very fallen and addicted to all kinds of sinful activities but was saved simply by chanting the holy name. This is found in the Sixth Canto of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

The universal planetary systems are very nicely explained in the fifth Canto of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Within the universe there are some planets which are hellish. Actually, not only the Bhägavatam but all religious scriptures contain descriptions of hell and heaven. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam you can find out where those hellish planets are and how distant they are from this planet, just as you can obtain information from modern astronomy. Astronomers have calculated how far the moon is from here and what the distance is between this planet and the sun; similarly, the Bhägavatam contains descriptions of the hellish planets.

We have experience of different atmospheric conditions even on this planet. In the Western countries near the North Pole, the climate is different than in India, which is near the equator. Just as there are differences in atmosphere and living conditions on this planet, similarly there are many planets which have different atmospheres and conditions of life.

After hearing a description of the hellish planets from Çukadeva Goswami, Parékñit Mahäräja said,

adhuneha mahä-bhäga
yathaiva narakän naraù
nänogra-yätanän neyät
tan me vyäkhyätum arhasi

“Sir, I have heard from you about the hellish planets. Men who are very sinful are sent to those planets.” [Çrémad-Bhägavatam 6.1.6] Parékñit Mahäräja is a Vaiñëava [devotee], and a Vaiñëava always feels compassion for others’ distress. He is very afflicted by the miseries of others. When Lord Jesus Christ presented himself, for instance, he was greatly afflicted by the miserable conditions of the people. Regardless of which country or sect they belong to, all Vaiñëavas, or devotees—any people who are God conscious, or Kåñëa conscious—are thus compassionate. Therefore to blaspheme a Vaiñëava, a preacher of God’s glories, is a great offense.

Kåñëa, God, is never tolerant of offenses committed at the lotus feet of a Vaiñëava. Kåpämbudhi: a Vaiñëava is an ocean of mercy. Väïchä-kalpa-taru: everyone has desires, but a Vaiñëava can fulfill all desires. Kalpa-taru means “desire tree.” There is a tree in the spiritual world which is called a desire tree. In this material world, you get a particular type of fruit from a particular type of tree, but in Kåñëaloka as well as in all the Vaikuëöha planets, all the trees are spiritual and will fulfill all your desires. That is described in the Brahma-saàhitä: cintämani-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-vrkña.

A Vaiñëava is addressed as mahä-bhäga, which means “fortunate.” One who becomes a Vaiñëava and is God conscious is understood to be greatly fortunate.

Caitanya Mahäprabhu has explained that the living entities are rotating in different species of life, in different planetary systems all over the universe. A living entity can go anywhere—to hell or heaven—as he likes and as he prepares himself. There are many heavenly planets, many hellish species of life. The living entity is rotating, wandering through these species and creating bodies according to his mentality in the present life. As you sow, so shall you reap.

Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that out of all these numberless living entities who are traveling in the material world, one is fortunate, not everyone. If everyone were fortunate, they would all have taken to Kåñëa consciousness. It is being distributed freely everywhere. But why are people not taking it? Because they are unfortunate.

Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that only those who are fortunate take to this Kåñëa consciousness, and they get hopeful life, pleasant life, blissful life, a life of knowledge.

It is the duty of a Vaiñëava to go door to door to make the unfortunate people fortunate. A Vaiñëava thinks, “How can these people be delivered from their hellish life?” That was Parékñit Mahäräja’s inquiry. “Sir,” he said, “you have described that on account of one’s sinful activities one is put into a hellish condition of life or in a hellish planetary system. Now, what are the countermethods by which such persons can be saved?” This is the question. When a Vaiñëava comes, when God Himself comes, or when God’s son or His very confidential devotees come, their only mission is to save the sinful men who are suffering. They have knowledge of how to do this.

When Prahläda Mahäräja met Nåsiàhadeva, he said:

naivodvije para duratyaya-vaitaraëyäs
tvad-vérya-gäyana-mahämåta-magna-cittaù
çoce tato vimukha-cetasa indriyärtha-
mäyä-sukhäya bharam udvahato vimüòhän

“My dear Lord,” Prahläda says, “I am not very anxious for my own deliverance.” [Bhäg. 7.9.43] Mäyävädé philosophers are very careful that their personal salvation is not interrupted. They think, “If I go to preach in association with others, I may fall down, and my realization will be finished.” Therefore they do not come. Only the Vaiñëavas come, at the risk of falldown—but they do not fall down. They may even go to hell to deliver the conditioned souls. This is Prahläda Mahäräja’s mission. He says, naivodvije: “I am not very anxious about living in this material world.”

Prahläda Mahäräja says further, “I have no anxiety for myself, because somehow or other I have been trained to be always Kåñëa conscious.” Because he is Kåñëa conscious, he is confident that in his next life he is going to Kåñëa. It is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä that if one executes the Kåñëa conscious regulative principles carefully, it is certain that he will reach the supreme destination in his next life.

Prahläda Mahäräja continues: “There is only one source of anxiety for me.” Just see—although he had no anxiety for himself, he still had anxiety. He says, çoce tato vimukha-cetasaù: “I am anxious for those persons who are not Kåñëa conscious. That is my anxiety. For myself I have no anxiety, but I am thinking of those who are not Kåñëa conscious.” Why aren’t they Kåñëa conscious? Mäyä-sukhäya bharam udvahato vimüòhän. These rascals have created a humbug civilization for temporary happiness.

Mäyä-sukhäya. Actually this is a fact. We have a humbug civilization. So many cars are being manufactured every year, and for that purpose so many roads have to be excavated and prepared. This creates problem after problem. Therefore it is mäyä-sukhäya, illusory happiness, and yet we are trying to be happy in this way. We are trying to manufacture some way to be happy, but this only creates other problems.

In your country you have the greatest number of cars, but that does not solve any problems. You have manufactured cars to help solve the problems of life, but I have experienced that this also creates more problems. When my disciple Dayänanda wanted to take me to a doctor in Los Angeles, I had to take the trouble to travel thirty miles before I could even consult the doctor. Once you create cars, then you must travel thirty or forty miles to meet your friends.

You can fly from New York to Boston in one hour, but it takes even longer than that just to get to the airport. This situation is called mäyä-sukhäya. Mäyä means “false,” “illusory.” We are trying to create some very comfortable situation, but we have created another uncomfortable situation. This is the way of the material world; if we are not satisfied by the natural comforts offered by God and nature and we want to create artificial comforts, then we have to create some discomfort also. Most people do not know that. They think that they are creating a very comfortable situation, but actually they are traveling fifty miles to go to the office to earn a livelihood and fifty miles to come back. Because of such conditions, Prahläda Mahäräja says that these vimüòhäns—these materialistic persons, these rascals—have created an unnecessary burden on themselves simply for temporary happiness. Vimüòhän, mäyä-sukhäya bharam udvahato. Therefore, in Vedic civilization it is recommended that one free himself from material life, take sannyäsa, the renounced order of life, and prosecute spiritual life with absolutely no anxiety.

If one can execute Kåñëa consciousness in family life, that is very good. Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura was a family man, a magistrate, and still he executed devotional service so nicely. Dhruva Mahäräja and Prahläda Mahäräja were gåhasthas, householders, but they trained themselves in such a way that even as householders they were faced with no interruption in their service. Therefore, Prahläda Mahäräja says, “I have learned the art of always remaining in Kåñëa consciousness.” What is that art? Tvad-vérya-gäyana-mahämåta-magna-cittaù. Simply glorifying the victorious activities and pastimes of the Lord. Vérya means “very heroic.”

Kåñëa’s activities are heroic. You can read about them in Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa’s name, His fame, His activities, His associates, and all other things related to Him are heroic. Prahläda Mahäräja says in this connection, “I am certain that wherever I go, I can glorify Your heroic activities and be safe. There is no question of my falling down. But I am simply anxious for these persons who have created a type of civilization in which they are always busy working hard. I am thinking of them.”

Prahläda says further:

präyeëa deva munayaù sva-vimukti-kämä
maunaà caranti vijane na parärtha-niñöhäù
naitän vihäya kåpaëän vimumukña eko
nänyaà tvad asya çaraëaà bhramato 'nupaçye

"My dear Lord, there are many saintly persons and sages who are very interested in their own liberation."“My dear Lord, there are many saintly persons and sages who are very interested in their own liberation.” [Bhäg. 7.9.44] Munayaù means “saintly persons” or “philosophers.” Präyeëa deva munayaù sva-vimukti-kämäù: they are very interested in their own liberation. They try to live in solitary places like the Himalaya Mountains. They do not talk to anyone, and they are always afraid of mixing with ordinary people in the city and becoming disturbed or maybe even falling down. They think, “Better let me save myself.”

Prahläda Mahäräja regrets that these great saintly persons do not come to the city, where people have manufactured a civilization of very hard work all day and night. Such saints are not very compassionate. He says, “I am anxious for these fallen people who are unnecessarily working so hard simply for sense gratification.”

Even if there were some point in working that hard, such people do not know what it is. All they know is sex. Either they go to a naked dance or to a naked club or to this or that. Prahläda Mahäräja says, naitän vihäya kåpaëän vimumukña eko: “My Lord, I do not need salvation alone. Unless I take all these fools with me, I shall not go.” He refuses to go to the kingdom of God without taking all these fallen souls with him. This is a Vaiñëava. Nänyaà tvad asya çaraëaà bhramato 'nupaçye: “I simply want to teach them how to surrender unto You. That’s all. That is my goal.”

The Vaiñëava knows that as soon as one surrenders, one’s path is clear. Naivodvije para duratyaya-vaitaraëyäs tvad-vérya-gäyana-mahämåta-magna-cittaù: “Somehow or other, let them bow down before Kåñëa.” This is a simple method. All you have to do is bow down before Kåñëa with faith and say, “My Lord Kåñëa, I was forgetful of You for so long, for so many lives. Now I have come to consciousness; please accept me.” That’s all. If one simply learns this technique and sincerely surrenders himself to the Lord, his path is immediately open. These are the philosophical thoughts of a Vaiñëava. A Vaiñëava is always thinking about how the fallen conditioned souls can be delivered. He is always involved in making plans in that way, just like the Goswamis. What was the business of the six Goswamis of Våndävana, Lord Caitanya’s direct disciples? That is stated by Çréniväsa Äcärya:

nänä-çästra-vicäraëaika-nipuëau sad-dharma-saàsthäpakau
lokänäà hita-kärinau tribhuvane mänyau çaraëyäkarau
rädhä-kåñëa-padäravinda-bhajanänandena mattälikau
vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

“The six Goswamis, namely, Çré Sanätana Goswami, Çré Rüpa Goswami, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Goswami, Çré Raghunätha däsa Goswami, Çré Jéva Goswami, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Goswami, are very expert in scrutinizingly studying the revealed scriptures with the aim of establishing eternal religious principles for the benefit of all human beings. They are always absorbed in the mood of the gopés and are engaged in the transcendental loving service of Rädhä and Kåñëa.” [Ñaò-gosvämy-añöaka 2]

With similar Vaiñëava compassion, Parékñit Mahäräja says to Çukadeva Goswami: “You have described the different types of hellish conditions of life. Now, tell me how those who are suffering can be delivered. Kindly explain this to me.

adhuneha mahä-bhäga
yathaiva narakän naraù
nänogra-yätanän neyät
tan me vyäkhyätum arhasi
[Bhag. 6.1.6]

Nara means human beings, those who are fallen. Narakän naraù/ nänogra-yätanän neyät tan me: “How can they be delivered from their fierce miseries and horrible pains?” That is a Vaiñëava heart. Mahäräja Parékñit says, “Somehow or other they have fallen down to this hellish life. But that does not mean that they should remain in that condition. There must be some means by which they can be delivered, so kindly explain that.”

Çukadeva Goswami replied:

na ced ihaiväpacitià yathäàhasaù
kåtasya kuryän mana-ukta-päëibhiù
dhruvaà sa vai pretya narakän upaiti
ye kértitä me bhavatas tigma-yätanäù

“Yes, I’ve already described the different types of hellish conditions and very severe painful life, but one has to counteract it.” [Bhag. 6.1.7]

How can this be done? Sinful activities are committed in various ways. We can commit sinful activity or thus make a plan, thinking, “I shall kill that man.” Either way, it is sinful. When the mind is thinking, feeling, and willing, then there is action.

The other day I was reading in a book that if someone’s dog barks at you when you are passing on the road, then that is an offense on the part of the dog-owner, according to law. No one should have to be scared by dogs barking, so one should take care of his dog. I read this. It is a law in your country. The dog is simply barking, but it is sinful. The dog is not responsible, because it is an animal, but because the owner of the animal has made the dog his best friend, he is responsible by law. If an outside dog enters your house, it may not be killed, but the owners of the dog may be prosecuted.

Just as the barking of the dog is unlawful, so when you speak something offensive to others, that is also sinful. That is just like barking. Therefore sinful activities are committed in so many ways. Whether we think of sinful activities, or we speak something sinful, or we actually commit a sinful activity, they are all considered sinful activities. Dhruvaà sa vai pretya narakän upaiti. One has to suffer punishment for such sinful activities.

People do not believe in a next life, because they want to avoid this botheration. But we cannot avoid it. We must act according to the law, or we will be punished. Similarly, I cannot avoid God’s law. That is not possible. I can cheat others, commit theft, and hide myself, thereby saving myself from the punishment of the state law, but I cannot save myself from the superior law, the law of nature. It is very difficult. There are so many witnesses. The daylight is witness, the moonlight is witness, and Kåñëa is the supreme witness. You cannot say, “I am committing this sin, but no one can see me.”

Kåñëa is the supreme witness sitting within your heart. He notes down what you are thinking and what you are doing. He also gives facility. If you want to do something to satisfy your senses, Kåñëa gives the facility for that action. That is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä. Sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöo: “I am sitting in everyone’s heart.” Mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca: “From Me come remembrance, knowledge, and forgetfulness.”

In this way Kåñëa gives us a chance. If you want Kåñëa, then He will give you a chance to have Him, and if you don’t want Kåñëa, then He will give you a chance to forget Him. If you want to enjoy life forgetting Kåñëa, forgetting God, then Kåñëa will give you all facility so that you can forget, and if you want to enjoy life with Kåñëa consciousness, then Kåñëa will give you the chance to make progress in Kåñëa consciousness. That is up to you.

If you think that you can be happy without Kåñëa consciousness, Kåñëa does not object to that. Yaöhecchasi tathä kuru. After advising Arjuna, He simply said, “Now I have explained everything to you. Whatever you desire you can do.” Arjuna replied immediately, kariñye vacanaà tava: “Now I shall execute Your order.” That is Kåñëa consciousness.

God does not interfere with your little independence. If you want to act according to the order of God, then God will help you. Even if you fall down sometimes, if you become sincere—”From this time on I shall remain Kåñëa conscious and execute His orders”—then Kåñëa will help you. In all respects, even if you fall down, He will excuse you and give you more intelligence. This intelligence will say, “Don’t do this. Now go on with your duty.” But if you want to forget Kåñëa, if you want to become happy without Kåñëa, He will give you so many chances that you will forget Kåñëa life after life.

Parékñit Mahäräja says here, “It is not that if I say there is no God then there will be no God or I will not be responsible for what I do.” That is the atheistic theory. Atheists do not want God, because they are always sinful—if they thought that there were God, then they would be forced to shudder at the thought of punishment. Therefore they deny the existence of God. That is their process. They think that if they do not accept God then there is no punishment and they can do whatever they like.

When rabbits are being attacked by bigger animals, they close their eyes and think, “I am not going to be killed.” But they are killed anyway. Similarly, we may deny the existence of God and the law of God, but still God and His law are there. In the high court you may say, “I don’t care for the law of the government,” but you will be forced to accept the government law. If you deny the state law, then you will be put into prison and be caused to suffer. Similarly, you may foolishly decry the existence of God—“There is no God” or “I am God”—but nevertheless you are responsible for all your actions, both good and bad.

There are two kinds of activities—good and bad. If you act nicely and perform pious activities, then you get good fortune, and if you act sinfully, then you have to suffer. Therefore Çukadeva Goswami says:

tasmät puraiväçv iha päpa-niñkåtau
yateta måtyor avipadyatätmanä
doñasya dåñövä guru-läghavaà yathä
bhiñak cikitseta rujäà nidäna-vit
[Bhag. 6.1.8]

There are different kinds of atonement. If you commit some sin and counteract it by something else, that is atonement. There are examples of this in the Christian Bible. Çukadeva Goswami says, “You should know that you are responsible, and according to the gravity of sinful life, you should accept some type of atonement as described in the çästras, the scriptures.”

Actually, just as when one is diseased he must go to a doctor and pay doctor bills as a form of atonement, according to the Vedic way of life there is a class of brähmaëas to whom one should go for the prescribed atonement according to the sins one commits.

Çukadeva Goswami says that one has to execute the prescribed atonement according to the gravity of one’s sinful life. He continues the example: doñasya dåñövä guru-läghavaà yathä bhiñak cikitseta rujäà nidänavit. When you consult a physician, he prescribes an inexpensive medicine or a costly medicine, according to the gravity of the disease. If you simply have a headache, he may prescribe an aspirin, but if you have something very severe, he immediately prescribes a surgical operation that will cost a thousand dollars. Similarly, sinful life is a diseased condition, so one must follow the prescribed cure to become healthy.

Acceptance of the chain of birth and death is a diseased condition of the soul. The soul has no birth and death and no disease, because it is spirit. Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.20]: na jäyate, the soul has no birth, and mréyate, it has no death. Nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëo/ na hanyate hanyamäne çarére. The soul is eternal and everlasting. It is not lost with the dissolution of this body. Na hanyate hanyamäne çarére. Na hanyate means that it is not killed or destroyed, even after the destruction of this body.

The missing point of modern civilization is that there is no educational system to instruct people on what happens after death. Thus we have the most defective education, because without this knowledge of what happens after death, one dies like an animal. The animal does not know that he is going to have another body; he has no such knowledge.

Human life is not meant for becoming an animal. One should not simply be interested in eating, sleeping, sex life, and defense. You may have a very nice arrangement for eating, or many nice buildings for sleeping, or a very good arrangement for sex life, or a very good defense force to protect you, but that does not mean that you are a human being. That type of civilization is animal life. Animals are also interested in eating, sleeping, and sex life, and according to their own methods they defend also. Where, then, is the distinction between human life and animal life if you simply engage in these four principles of bodily nature?

The distinction is made when a human being is inquisitive—“Why have I been put into this miserable condition? ls there any remedy for it? ls there any perpetual, eternal life? I do not want to die. I want to live very happily and peacefully. Is there a chance of this? What is that method? What is that science?” When these inquiries are there and steps are taken to answer these questions, that is human civilization; otherwise it is doggish civilization, animal civilization.

Animals are satisfied if they can eat, sleep, have some sex life, and have some defense. Actually there is no defense, because no one can protect himself from the hands of cruel death. Hiraëyakaçipu, for instance, wanted to live forever, and so he underwent severe austerities. So-called scientists are now saying that we shall stop death by scientific methods. This is also another crazy utterance. That is not possible. You may make great advancement in scientific knowledge, but there is no scientific solution to these four problems—birth, death, old age, and disease.

One who is intelligent will be eager to solve these four prime problems. No one wants to die. But there is no remedy. I have to die. Everyone is very anxious to stop the increase of population by employing so many contraceptive methods, but still, birth is going on. So there is no stoppage of birth. You may invent up-to-date medicines by your scientific methods, but you cannot stop disease. It is not possible just to take a tablet to put an end to disease.

In the Bhagavad-gétä it is said, janma-måtyu-jarä-vyädhi-duùkha-doñänudarçanam: one might think that he has solved all the problems of his life, but where is the solution to these four problems of birth, death, old age, and disease? That solution is Kåñëa consciousness.

Kåñëa also says in the same book,

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

[Bg. 4.9]

Every one of us is giving up our body at every moment. The last phase of giving up this body is called death. But Kåñëa says, “If anyone understands My appearance and disappearance and My activities—not superficially, but in truth—after giving up this body he never again accepts a material body.”

What happens to such a person? Mäm eti—he returns to Kåñëa. If you are to go to Kåñëa, then you have to prepare your spiritual body. That is Kåñëa consciousness. If you keep yourself in Kåñëa consciousness, then gradually you prepare your next body, a spiritual body, which will carry you immediately to Kåñëaloka, the abode of Kåñëa, and you will become happy. You will live there perpetually and blissfully.

SSR 7d: "They Have Given Everything to Kåñëa—And That Is Never a Mistake"

"They Have Given Everything to Kåñëa—And That Is Never a Mistake"

In his letter to Lynne Ludwig, Çréla Prabhupäda asks, "kindly forgive my beloved disciples for any unkindness or indiscretion on their part. After all, to give up one’s life completely for serving the Lord is not an easy thing, and mäyä, or the illusory material energy, tries especially hard to again entrap those who have left her service to become devotees.... They have become a little detached from mäyä’s love, or lust, and they want Kåñëa’s love, or endless, fully rewarding love, but they have not yet developed to that point, that’s all.”

Your Grace:

Please accept this letter with Love... K-Mart; San Fernando. We have talked with two of your boys at different times. Both had a very negative outlook toward the people they meet.

Do not believe this is in any way as it should be.

These boys happen to represent God. This comes from within. Their outlook must have mercy. We realize this; therefore handpick these little peaces [sic] of heaven to place in the middle of these people. Or else it will defeat your purpose.

Love Is. Let it be as it is; with Love or not at all.

My prayers be with you... and I beg yours with me.

Yours in God, Blessed Be,
Lynne Ludwig

My dear Lynne Ludwig,

Please accept my blessings. I beg to acknowledge receipt of your letter from California, and I have noted the contents carefully, although due to extensively traveling and preaching in a tour in India I have not had the opportunity to reply to you at length until now. Your complaint is that you have met two of my young disciples in California and they appeared to you to have “a very negative outlook toward the people they meet.” Of course, I do not know the case and what the circumstances are, but kindly forgive my beloved disciples for any unkindness or indiscretion on their part. After all, to give up one’s life completely for serving the Lord is not an easy thing, and mäyä, or the illusory, material energy, tries especially hard to again entrap those who have left her service to become devotees. Therefore, in order to withstand the attack of mäyä and remain strong under all conditions of temptation, young or inexperienced devotees in the neophyte stage of devotional service will sometimes adopt an attitude against those things or persons which may possibly be harmful or threatening to their tender devotional creepers. They may even overindulge in such feelings just to protect themselves, and thus they will appear to some nondevotees, who are perhaps themselves still very much enamored by the material energy of mäyä, to be negative or pessimistic.

But the actual fact is that this material world is a miserable, negative place, full of danger at every step; it is duhkùälayam açäçvatam, a temporary abode of death, birth, disease, and old age, a home of suffering and pain only. To come to the platform of understanding these things as they are is not very common, and therefore persons who attain to it are described as “great souls.”

mäm upetya punar janma
duùkhälayam açäçvatam
näpnuvanti mahätmänaù
saàsiddhià paramäà gatäù

This means that those who have understood that the material worlds are places of misery and temporality (duhkùälayam açäçvatam) never return here again, and because they are mahätmänaù, the great souls, Kåñëa keeps them with Him because they have qualified themselves to escape this nasty place by becoming His pure devotees. This verse is spoken by Kåñëa, or God Himself, in the Bhagavad-gétä [Bg. 8.15]. Who can be a more final authority? The point is that to make advancement in spiritual life, one must view everything material with a pessimistic eye unless it is utilized to serve and please Kåñëa. We are not very much hopeful for any lasting pleasure or satisfaction for our deepest cravings within this realm of gross matter.

You refer to the word “love” several times in your letter, but the actual fact is that there is no love in this material world. That is false propaganda. What they call love here is lust only, or desire for personal sense gratification:

käma eña krodha eña
rajo-guëa-samudbhavaù
mahä-çano mahä-päpmä
viddhy enam iha vairiëam

Kåñëa tells Arjuna, His disciple, that “It is lust only... which is the all-devouring, sinful enemy of this world.” [Bg. 3.37] In the Vedic language there is no word for materialistic “love,” as we call it in the present day. The word käma describes lust or material desire, not love, but the word that we find in the Vedas for actual love is premä, meaning one’s love of God only. Outside of loving God there is no possibility of loving. Rather, there is lusty desire only. Within this atmosphere of matter, the entire range of human activities—and not only every activity of human beings but all living entities—is based upon, given impetus and thus polluted by sex desire, the attraction between male and female. For that sex life, the whole universe is spinning around—and suffering! That is the harsh truth. So-called love here means that “you gratify my senses, I’ll gratify your senses,” and as soon as that gratification stops, immediately there is divorce, separation, quarrel, and hatred. So many things are going on under this false conception of love. Actual love means love of God, Kåñëa.

Everyone wants to repose his loving tendency in some object which is in his opinion worthy. But the question is one of ignorance only, because people have a poor fund of knowledge about where to find that supreme lovable object who is actually worthy to accept and reciprocate their love. People simply do not know. There is no proper information. As soon as you have some attachment for anything material, it will kick you upon the face, deteriorate, and disappoint you. It’s bound to dissatisfy and frustrate you. That’s a fact. But these young boys in your country, and all over the world, are accepting, “Yes, that is a fact,” and they are getting the right information from Kåñëa:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

“After many births and deaths, he who is actually wise surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare.” [Bg. 7.19] Again Kåñëa uses that word mahätmä, great soul. Therefore our devotees that you have met are not ordinary boys and girls. No. They are to be considered actually wise, great souls because they have experienced in many births the miserable disease of material life and have become disgusted. Therefore they are seeking higher knowledge—they are seeking something better—and when they find Kåñëa and surrender unto Him, they become mahätmäs, who are actually situated in knowledge. This material world is just like a prison house; it is a punishing place meant to bring us to that point of becoming disgusted, surrendering at last to Kåñëa, and going back to our original nature of eternal life in bliss and complete knowledge. Therefore it is to the credit of these devotees that they have done what is sudurlabhaù, very rare among all men in human society.

By surrendering to Kåñëa one will find the final object in which to invest his love: God. Love of God is present in everyone, just like fire in an unlit match, but it is covered over. But if one somehow or other develops his dormant love of God, and Kåñëa becomes his supreme adorable object, supreme friend, supreme master, or supreme lover, than he shall never again become disappointed or unhappy. Rather, because his loving propensity is rightfully placed:

mac-cittä mad-gata-präëä
bodhayantaù parasparam
kathayantaç ca mäà nityaà
tuñyanti ca ramanti ca

The devotee whose life is surrendered to Kåñëa is always enjoying “great satisfaction and bliss,” and he is constantly enlightened, always positive, not negative, as you say [Bg. 10.9]. The advanced devotee is the friend of everyone. The yoga-yukto viçuddhätmä, purified soul engaged in loving devotional service to Kåñëa, is sarva-bhütätma-bhütätmä, dear to everyone, and everyone is dear to him. In another place Kåñëa claims that yo mad-bhaktaù sa me priyaù, His devotee, who is very dear to Him, adveñöä sarva-bhütänäà maitraù karuëa eva ca, is not envious but is a kind friend to all living entities. The devotee is supposed to be, furthermore, equal to everyone (paëòitäù sama-darçinaù). He never discriminates, saying, “This one is good, this one is bad.” No.

These are descriptions of the more advanced stages of Kåñëa consciousness that devotees get by development of mature knowledge. At present many of our students are young boys. They are learning gradually, and the process is so effective, certain, and authorized that if they stick to it they will come to the right point, as you say, of loving. But that love is not material, so it should not be judged on the false, sentimental platform of ordinary, mundane dealings. That is our point. Therefore to say they are not loving may be true from the materialists’ point of view. They have given up affection for family, friends, wife, country, race, and so on, which is all based upon the bodily concept of life, or flickering sense gratification. They have become a little detached from mäyä’s love, or lust, and they want Kåñëa’s love, or endless, fully rewarding love, but they have not yet developed to that point, that’s all. We cannot expect that all of a sudden your countrymen, who are addicted to so many bad habits, will give up eating flesh, taking intoxicants, having illicit sex life, and so many other nasty things, and overnight become great, self-realized souls. That is not possible. That is utopian. But just being initiated as Kåñëa’s devotee puts one in the topmost category of human society. Sa buddhimän manuñyeñu sa yuktaù kåtsna-karma-kåt [Bg. 4.18]: “He is intelligent in human society. He is in the transcendental position, although engaged in all sorts of activities.” And although such a devotee may not yet have advanced to the highest level of spiritual understanding, still he is to be considered the most exalted personality, regardless of any temporary frailties.

api cet su-duräcäro
bhajate mäm ananya-bhäk
sädhur eva sa mantavyaù
samyag vyavasito hi saù

“Even if a devotee commits the most abominable actions, he is to be considered saintly because he is properly situated.” [Bg. 9.30] As you will say, “To err is human.” Therefore in the neophyte stage we may always expect some discrepancies. Kindly see the thing in this light and forgive their small mistakes. The big thing is that they have given everything, even their lives, to Kåñëa—and that is never a mistake.

Your ever well-wisher,
A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

SSR 7e: An Awareness of What Is Best and Most Beautiful

An Awareness of What Is Best and Most Beautiful

In Rome, during May of 1974, Çréla Prabhupäda meets with Desmond James Bernard O'Grady, a noted Irish poet: "My request to you is this. You are a poet. Just describe God. You are expert in describing, and therefore I ask you to kindly describe God in your occupation. Then your life will be successful...."

Mr. O'Grady: Your edition of the Bhagavad-gétä is very nice.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is the fifth edition in two years.

Mr. O’Grady: In which country has the Hare Kåñëa movement been the most successful?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everywhere. In Africa, America, Canada, Japan, China. But actually it has been most successful in America. Many Americans have taken to Kåñëa consciousness.

Mr. O’Grady: What about here in Rome? Have you had problems with the police?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have problems everywhere. Police sometimes harass us, but usually they become tired and eventually don’t do anything. [Laughter.]

Mr. O’Grady: The system give up? That’s marvelous. I feel very tired of the system myself. Something is wrong with the present state of affairs. Maybe you can give me some advice on how to beat the system.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You Irish people! You are never tired of fighting.

Mr. O’Grady: No. [Laughter.] It’s inside us.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Actually, the fighting has been going on constantly.

Mr. O’Grady: Well, what do you suggest we do about it? I mean, is it morally correct for me to be sitting here...

Çréla Prabhupäda: As long as we remain illusioned by the bodily conception of life, thinking we are these bodies, one man thinking “I am Irish,” another thinking “I am Italian,” “... American,” “... Indian,” and so on—as long as this goes on, the fighting will go on. You cannot stop fighting between dogs and cats. Why do they fight? The dog simply thinks, “I am a big dog.” And the cat thinks, “I am a big cat.” In the same way, if we think, “I am an Irishman” or “I am an Englishman,” then we are no better than the cats and dogs. As long as people remain in a bodily conception of life, there will be fighting.

Mr. O’Grady: What was Mahatma Gandhi fighting in the House of Commons?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That was another dog-ism. There is no difference. A dog thinks, “I am a dog,” because he has the body of a dog. If I am thinking that I am Indian because this body was born on Indian soil, then how am I different from the dog? The bodily conception of life is simply animalism. When we understand that we are not these bodies but are spirit souls, there will be peace. There cannot be any peace otherwise. Sa eva go-kharaù. The Vedic literatures state that a person in the bodily concept of life is exactly like a cow or an ass. People have to transcend this inferior conception of the self. How is that done?

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

“One who engages in the spiritual activities of unalloyed devotional service at once transcends the modes of material nature and is elevated to the spiritual platform.” [Bhagavad-gétä 14.26]

In our society, there are many Mexicans, Canadians, Indians, Jews, and Muslims, but they no longer consider themselves Muslims, Christians, Jews, or whatever. They are all servants of Kåñëa. That is Brahman realization.

Mr. O’Grady: That’s giving it a name also.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a name must be there. But although, for example, your name is different from that of another Irishman, you nonetheless all feel that you are Irish. One’s name may be different, but that doesn’t matter. The quality should be one. That is required. When we acquire Kåñëa’s quality, then, despite different names, there will be peace. That is called so ’ham. The names of different people in a nation may be different, but all the people feel the same nationality. Varieties may exist, but if the quality is the same, that is oneness, brahma-bhüta.

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

“One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments nor desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state he attains pure devotional service unto Me.” [Bg. 18.54]

This world is miserable for the materially infected person, but for the devotee, the entire world is as good as Vaikuëöha. For the impersonalist, achieving the Brahman stage, becoming one with the Absolute, is the last word.

Mr. O’Grady: Is the Absolute external or internal?

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no external or internal. The Absolute is without duality.

Mr. O’Grady: OK, but on an individual level...

Çréla Prabhupäda: We are not absolute. When we are situated on the absolute platform, we are absolute. However, now we are in the relative world. The Absolute Truth is here also, but our senses are not sufficiently elevated to understand that Absolute Truth. As long as we are under the control of time, there is no question of becoming absolute.

Mr. O’Grady: So “absolute” means life beyond time?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä [4.9]:

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the“One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna.”

That is absolute—going back home, back to Godhead. As long as one is in the material world and identifies with this body, he transmigrates from one body to another. That is not absolute. This is clearly stated here. When one goes back to the spiritual world, he attains the absolute position.

Mr. O’Grady: All right, but this is my question: Is it sufficient for us to sit here—you sitting there and we as friends sitting with you engaging in the gentle art of conversation, while across the ocean...

Çréla Prabhupäda: The point you have missed is that although you are sitting in one place and I am sitting in a different place, this difference does not affect our actual existence. We are both human beings. The conceptions of “Irishman,” “ Englishman,” “Protestant,” “Catholic,” and so on are but different dresses. One has to become free from these designations. When one is thus free, he becomes purified.

sarvopädhi-vinirmuktaà
tat-paratvena nirmalam
håñékeëa håñékeça-
sevanaà bhaktir ucyate
[Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.1.12]

When you have purified your senses and engaged those purified senses in the service of the master of the senses, Kåñëa, you have perfected your life. That is nonduality, and that is absolute.

Mr. O’Grady: But the system insists that you think yourself American or Indian or African or whatever.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Materialistic society means duality.

Mr. O’Grady: But that is unavoidable. How can you avoid material existence?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is possible in Kåñëa consciousness. The lotus lives in the water but never touches the water.

Mr. O’Grady: I don’t think you can explain situations in one area with metaphors from another. How can you argue political problems in terms of vague spiritual concepts? Their nature is completely different.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sometimes a variety of examples helps us to understand or appreciate the problem better. In the vase there is a variety of flowers, and that variety helps us better appreciate the idea of flowers. From any point of view, Kåñëa can resolve all problems. Why just the problems of Irishmen or Englishmen? All problems. That is called unity in diversity. Our students come from different backgrounds, but because they are all in Kåñëa consciousness, they are unified.

Mr. O’Grady: Very good. Yes, I accept that. I would like to know, though, that when you say “Kåñëa consciousness,” is there any difference between that and Christ consciousness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, there is no difference. Christ came to preach the message of God. If you actually become Christ conscious, you become Kåñëa conscious.

Mr. O’Grady: And does becoming Kåñëa conscious or God conscious mean becoming self-conscious? That is, conscious of who we really are?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, God consciousness includes self-consciousness, but self-consciousness is not necessarily God consciousness.

Mr. O’Grady: But it may be?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No.

Mr. O’Grady: One may achieve consciousness of the God that is within.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That means he is God conscious. You are now in the sunlight, and consciousness of the sun includes your ability to see yourself. In the darkness you cannot see yourself. At night you can’t even see your own hands or legs, but if you come before the sun, you see the sun and yourself also. Without sunlight, without God consciousness, self-consciousness is incomplete. However, God consciousness makes self-consciousness very clear.

Mr. O’Grady: We meet a lot of young people in our teaching profession, and we don’t try to teach them any kind of didactic salvation. We do try to direct them toward an awareness of what is best and what is most beautiful and what is most spiritually nourishing in the world about them—that is, insofar as the system allows us. Very frequently the students are not neutral enough to be in a spiritual condition; they are more in an emotional one. What we are faced with often is the basic question of “Who am I?” or, “What is it all about?”

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Mr. O’Grady: Or they ask, “Why am I here?”

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, very good.

Mr. O’Grady: We are asked, “Why should I be here? Who are you, teacher, and what gives you the right to tell us what to think or what to be or what not to be? Why should I read Shakespeare? Why should I listen to Mozart? I prefer Bob Dylan.” These kind of questions seem to emanate from a very disillusioned state of mind, and insecurity, and uncertainty, and a lack of credibility in the total structure of things as they are. Frequently we have to answer these questions in a cataclysmic sort of way. Rather than presenting direct answers, we must answer indirectly, taking account of the conditioning that prompted students to ask these questions in the first place. Do you think that we should try to reach them more directly?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You are talking about the problem of...

Mr. O’Grady: Modern education.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. So many questions are there, but they are not answered by modern education. “Why have I come here? What is the purpose?” These questions should be answered perfectly. Therefore the Vedas enjoin: tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet. To find answers to all these questions, one must approach a bona fide spiritual master.

Mr. O’Grady: What if you have none? What if we are told that Mr. Nixon is the bona fide spiritual master? What do we do?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, no. [Laughter.] There is a standard for bona fide spiritual masters. You have only heard one line of the verse. Who is the spiritual master? That is the next line: çrotriyaà brahma-niñöham. The word çrotriyam refers to one who has heard from another bona fide source. A spiritual master is he who has taken the message from another qualified spiritual master. This is just like a medical man who has taken the knowledge of medical science from another medical man. Similarly, the bona fide spiritual master must come in a line of successive spiritual masters. The original spiritual master is God.

Mr. O’Grady: Yes. Granted.

Çréla Prabhupäda: One who has heard from God explains the same message to his disciples. If the disciple doesn’t change the message, he is a bona fide spiritual master. That is our process. We take lessons by hearing from Kåñëa, God, and from Him understand who is perfect. Or we hear from His representative, who does not contradict Kåñëa and who has realized His message. It is not that we speak one thing and do all nonsense. One who does so is not a spiritual master.

Mr. O’Grady: Now there’s my poor old father, living west of Ireland. A simple old man, seventy-eight years now, your generation. He has gotten to the point at his age where he says, “They tell me, the priests, they tell me ultimately that it’s God who knows. But I want to know who told God.” Then he comes to me and says, “You went to school, and you read books. Tell me, who told God?” So I have no answer. That is the difference between seventy-eight and thirty-nine years.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, it is not a difference of age. The difference is knowledge. In the Brahma-sütra the question is raised: Who is God? First of all there is this question.

Mr. O’Grady: Who taught God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. First of all there is the question who is God. Then we shall ask who taught God. The Vedänta-sütra says, athäto brahma-jijïäsä: now we should inquire who is God. Unless you know who God is, how can you raise the question of who instructed God? If you don’t know God, the question does not arise who instructed God. Is this not so?

Mr. O’Grady: Yes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Who God is, is explained in the Brahma-sütra. Janmädy asya yataù: God is He from whom everything emanates. That is God—the Supreme Being from whom everything emanates. Now, what is the nature of that Supreme Being? Is He a dead stone or a living entity? That is also explained. Janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç cärtheñv abhijïaù svaräö [Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.1.1]: the Supreme Being is fully cognizant of everything, directly and indirectly. Unless He is fully cognizant of everything, He cannot be God. Then the question that you raised comes, Who taught God? And that is also answered. Svaräö: He is fully independent. He does not need to take lessons from anyone. That is God. If one needs to take lessons from others, he is not God. Kåñëa spoke the Bhagavad-gétä, and He did not have to learn it from anyone. I had to learn it from my spiritual master, but Kåñëa did not have to learn it from anyone. One who does not need to take lessons from others is God.

Mr. O’Grady: Where does human love come in?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everything is coming from God. Being part and parcel of God, we manifest partial love because the original love is there in Him. Nothing can exist if it is not in God; therefore love is there in God.

Mr. O’Grady: And manifestations of love are manifestations of God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Unless the loving propensity is there in God, how can we manifest it? A son born of a particular father has the symptoms of the father. Because the loving propensity is in God, we have that same propensity.

Mr. O’Grady: Maybe love is generated in you by the need.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, there is no question of “maybe.” We are defining God in absolute terms. Janmädy asya yataù: God is He from whom everything has emanated. The fighting propensity is also there in God, but His fighting and His loving are absolute. In the material world we experience that fighting is just the opposite of loving, but in God the fighting propensity and the loving propensity are one and the same. That is the meaning of “absolute.” We learn from the Vedic scriptures that when the so-called enemies of God are killed by God, they attain liberation.

Mr. O’Grady: Is it possible to arrive at this understanding of God alone?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Therefore we have cited this verse: tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet. The word abhigacchet means “must.” It is not possible alone. In Sanskrit grammar this is called the vidhilin form of a verb, and this form is used when there is no choice. The word abhigacchet means that one must approach a guru. That is the Vedic version. Therefore in the Bhagavad-gétä you will find that Arjuna was talking to Kåñëa, but when he saw that things were not being resolved, he surrendered himself to Kåñëa and accepted Him as his guru.

kärpaëya-doñopahata-svabhävaù
påcchämi tväà dharma-sammüòha-cetäù
yac chreyaù syän niçcitaà brühi tan me
çiñyas te 'haà çädhi mäà tväà prapannam

“Now I am confused about my duty and have lost all composure because of weakness. In this condition I am asking You to tell me clearly what is best for me. Now I am Your disciple, and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me.” [Bg. 2.7] So here we can see that Arjuna is confused about his duty.

Mr. O’Grady: Is this duty to the self, to others, or to the state?

Çréla Prabhupäda: A soldier’s duty is to fight with the enemy. Arjuna was a soldier, and Kåñëa advised him, “The opposite party is your enemy, and you are a soldier. Why are you trying to be nonviolent? This is not good.” Then Arjuna said, “Actually, I am confused. In this confusion I cannot make the right decision. I therefore accept You as my spiritual master. Please give me the proper lesson.” In a chaotic condition, in a confused state of life, one should approach another, who is in full knowledge of the matter. You go to a lawyer to solve legal problems, and you go to a physician to solve medical problems. Everyone in the material world is confused about spiritual identity. It is therefore our duty to approach a bona fide spiritual master, who can give us real knowledge.

Mr. O’Grady: I am very confused.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So you must approach a spiritual master.

Mr. O’Grady: And he makes a decision on how to help me stop this confusion?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the spiritual master is one who solves all confusion. If the spiritual master cannot save his disciple from confusion, he is not a spiritual master. That is the test.

saàsära-dävänala-léòha-loka-
träëäya käruëya-ghanäghanatvam
präptasya kalyäëa-guëärëavasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam
[Gurv-añöaka 1]

This whole confused world is just like a blazing forest fire. In a forest fire all the animals are confused. They do not know where to go to save their lives. In the blazing fire of the material world, everyone is confused. How can that blazing forest fire be extinguished? It is not possible to utilize your man-made fire brigade, nor is it possible to simply pour buckets of water. The solution comes when rain from the clouds falls on the forest fire. Only then can the fire be extinguished. That ability is not in your hands, but is in the mercy of God. So, human society is in a confused state, and it cannot find a solution. The spiritual master is one who has received the mercy of God, and he can deliver the solution to the confused man. One who has received the mercy of God can become a spiritual master and deliver that mercy to others.

Mr. O’Grady: The problem is to find this spiritual master.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not the problem. The problem is whether you are sincere. You have problems, but God is within your heart. Éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäm. God is not far away. If you are sincere, God sends you a spiritual master. Therefore God is also called caitya-guru, the spiritual master within the heart. God helps from within and from without. Everything is thus described in the Bhagavad-gétä. This material body is like a machine, but within the heart is the soul, and with the soul is the Supersoul, Kåñëa, who gives directions. The Lord says, “You wanted to do this; now here is the chance. Go and do it.” If you are sincere, you say, “Now, God, I want You.” Then He will give you directions. “Yes, now you come and get Me like this.” This is His kindness. However, if we want something else, that is all right. We can have it. God is very kind. When I want something, He is in my heart directing me and telling me how to have it. So why should He not give directions on how to have a spiritual master? First of all we must again be eager to revive our God consciousness. Then God will give us a spiritual master.

Mr. O’Grady: Thank you very much.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Thank you very much. My request to you is this. You are a poet. Just describe God. You are expert in describing, and therefore I ask you to kindly describe God in your occupation. Then your life will be successful. And if one hears you, his life will also be successful. That is the injunction:

idaà hi puàsas tapasaù çrutasya vä
sviñöasya süktasya ca buddhi-dattayoù
avicyuto 'rthaù kavibhir nirüpito
yad uttamaçloka-guëänuvarëanam
[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.5.22]

There are many leaders in society who are poets, scientists, religionists, philosophers, politicians, and so on. Those who are so expert are given this injunction: Your duty is to perfect your occupation by describing the glories of the Supreme Being.

Mr. O’Grady: My experience is that, for some extraordinary reason, one is chosen to do a particular thing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That reason is given here. Avicyutaù. The infallible choice is this: “Let them describe the glories of the Lord.”

Mr. O’Grady: But you were saying that the spiritual master is chosen. The spiritual master, the poet, the priest, is chosen by God. This person is chosen to write poems or paint pictures or make music.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So when you compose music, compose music about God. That is your perfection.

Mr. O’Grady: When one works for God in his line, then his line becomes his perfection?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Mr. O’Grady: Thank you very much.


SSR 8: Reaching Life's Perfection

8. Reaching Life's Perfection

SSR 8a: "The Human Form of Life Is Meant for God Realization"

"The Human Form of Life Is Meant for God Realization"

Çréla Prabhupäda gives an address at London’s Conway Hall, in 1969: "....If one thinks that—‘I am no one else’s servant; my business is to serve God’—then he is liberated. His heart is immediately cleansed, and he is liberated. And after one has reached that, then all one’s cares and anxieties in this world are over, because one knows, ‘I am a servant of God. God will give me protection. Why should I worry about anything?’”

Today’s subject matter is our relationship with God. That is selfrealization. The saìkértana movement is the easiest process for self-realization because it cleanses the heart. Our misunderstanding of our identity is due to the dust covering the mirror of the mind. In a mirror that is covered with dust one cannot see himself. But if it is very clear, then one can see himself. So meditation is a process for cleansing the heart. Meditation means to try to understand one’s relationship with the Supreme.

With everything with which we come in contact there is a relationship. Because I am now sitting on this cushion, the relationship is that I shall sit and the cushion will hold me. You have relationships. You are Englishmen or Indians, so there is a relationship with your society, with your family, with your friends. So what is our relationship with God?

If you ask everyone, very few people will be able to explain their relationship with God. They say, “What is God? God is dead. I don’t believe in God, not to speak of a relationship.” Because these dirty things are covering their hearts, they cannot see. We have a relationship with everything—why do we not try to understand our relationship with God? Is that very intelligent? No. That is ignorance. All the creatures in this material world are covered by the three modes of material nature. Therefore they cannot see God. They cannot understand God, nor do they try to understand Him. But God is there. In England in the morning there is mist, so you cannot see the sun behind the fog. But does this mean that there is no sun? You cannot see it because your eyes are covered. But if you send a telegram to another part of the world, they will say, “Yes, the sun is here. We can see it. It is very dazzling, full of light.” So when you deny the existence of God or you cannot ascertain your relationship with God, that means that you are lacking in knowledge. It is not that there is no God. We are lacking. The sun is not covered. The sun cannot be covered. The fog or the cloud or the mist does not have the power to cover the sun. How big the sun is! It is so many times bigger than this earth. And the clouds can cover at most ten or twenty or a hundred miles. So how can the clouds cover the sun? No. The clouds cannot cover the sun. They cover your eyes. When an enemy comes and a rabbit cannot defend himself, the rabbit closes his eyes and thinks, “My enemy is now gone.” Similarly, we are covered by the external energy of God and are thinking, “God is dead.”

The Lord has three kinds of energies. In the Viñëu Puräëa there are descriptions of the energy of the Supreme Lord. And in the Vedas also, in the Upaniñads, there are descriptions of the energies of the Supreme Lord. Paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate [Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 6.8]. Çakti means “energy.” The Lord has multienergies. The Vedas say, “God has nothing to do.” We have to work because we have no other means to exist—we have to eat, we wish to enjoy this, that—but why should God work? God does not have to work. Then how can we say that God created this universe? Is that not work? No. Then how did it happen? His multifarious energies are so strong that they are acting naturally and are full of knowledge. We can see how a flower blooms and grows and systematically displays multicolors: one side a little spot, another side a little spot, white on one side, more white on the other side. The butterfly also exhibits such artistic symmetry. So this is all being painted, but in such a perfect way and so swiftly that we cannot see how. We cannot understand how it is being done, but it is being done by the energy of the Lord.

It is due to a lack of knowledge that people say that God is dead, that there is no God, and that we have no relationship with God. These thoughts have been compared to the thoughts of a man haunted by a ghost. Just as a haunted man speaks all nonsense, when we become covered by the illusory energy of God we say that God is dead. But this is not a fact. Therefore, we need this chanting process to cleanse our heart. Take to this simple process of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra. In that way, in your family life, in your club, in your home, on the road—everywhere—chant Hare Kåñëa, and this darkness covering your heart, covering your real position, will be removed. Then you’ll understand your real constitutional position.

Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu recommended: ceto-darpaëa-märjanam. Märjanam means “cleanse,” and darpaëam means “mirror.” The heart is a mirror. It is like a camera. Just as a camera takes all kinds of pictures of days and nights, so also our heart takes pictures and keeps them in an unconscious state. Psychologists know this. The heart takes so many pictures, and therefore it becomes covered. We do not know when it has begun, but it is a fact that because there is material contact, our real identity is covered. Therefore ceto-darpaëa-märjanam: one has to cleanse his heart. There are different processes to cleanse the heart—the jïäna process, the yoga process, the meditation process, pious activities. Karma also cleanses the heart. If one acts very piously, his heart will gradually be cleansed. But although these processes are recommended for cleansing the heart, in this age they are all difficult. To follow the path of philosophical knowledge one must become a very learned scholar, one must read so many books, one must go to learned professors and scholars and speculate. One must search out a person who has seen the light. So these are all philosophical processes. Meditation is also a recommended process. One should question, “What am I?” Just consider: Am I this body? No. Am I this finger? No, this is my finger. If you contemplate your leg, you will see, “Oh, this is my leg.” Similarly, you will find everything to be “mine.” And where is that “I”? Everything is mine, but where is that “I”? When one is searching for that “I,” that is meditation. Real meditation means concentrating all the senses in that way. But that meditation process is very difficult. One must control the senses. The senses are dragging one outward, and one has to bring them inward for introspection. Therefore there are eight processes in the yoga system. The first is controlling the senses by regulative principles. Then sitting postures—that will help to concentrate the mind. If one sits leaning over, that will not help; if one sits up straight, that will help. Then controlling the breathing, then meditation, then samädhi. But today these are very, very difficult processes. No one can immediately perform them. The so-called yoga processes are fragmental—only the sitting postures and a few breathing exercises are practiced. But that cannot bring one to the perfectional stage. The actual yoga process, although a recommended Vedic process, is very difficult in this age. Similarly one can try to get knowledge by the speculative philosophical process: “This is Brahman, this is not Brahman, so what is Brahman? What is spirit soul?” Such empiric philosophical discussion is also recommended, but it is useless in this age.

Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu—not only Caitanya Mahäprabhu but also the Vedic literature—says:

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä

[Ädi 17.21]

Kalau means "in this age." Nästy eva, nästy eva, nästy eva—three times nästy eva. Eva means "certainly," and nästi means "not." "Certainly not, certainly not, certainly not." What is that "certainly not"? One cannot realize oneself by karma. That is the first "certainly not." One cannot realize oneself by jïäna. That is the second "certainly not." One cannot realize oneself by yoga. Certainly not. Kalau. Kalau means "in this age." Kalau nästy eva nästy eva nästy eva gatir anyathä. In this age one certainly cannot achieve success by any of these three methods. Then what is the recommended process? Harer näma harer näma harer nämaiva kevalam. Simply chant Hare Kåñëa. Kevalam means “only.” It is the easiest and most sublime process. This is recommended, practical, and authorized. So take it. Accept it in any condition of life. Chant. There is no expenditure, there is no loss. We are not chanting a secret. No. It is open. And by chanting you will cleanse your heart.

In this material world no one wants misery, but it comes. Unexpectedly, like a forest fire that starts without anyone’s striking a match, it comes. No one wants a war, but war is fought. No one wants famine, but famine comes. No one wants pestilence, but it comes. No one wants fighting, but there is fighting. No one wants misunderstanding, but there is. Why? This is like a blazing fire in the forest. And it cannot be extinguished by fire engines. This blazing fire of problems cannot be extinguished by our so-called advancement of knowledge. No. That is not possible, Just as one cannot extinguish a forest fire by sending a fire engine or by bringing some water, the problems of our life cannot be solved by material processes.

There are many examples. Prahläda Mahäräja says, “My dear Lord, the father and mother are not actually the protectors of the children.” The father and mother take care of their children; that is their duty. But they are not the ultimate protectors. When nature’s law calls the child, the father and mother cannot protect him. Therefore although generally it is considered a fact that the father and mother are the protectors of the child, actually it is not a fact. If someone is sailing the ocean and he thinks he has a very nice seat, will that protect him? No. Still he may drown. A nice airplane is flying in the sky, everyone is safe, but all of a sudden it crashes. Nothing material can protect us. Suppose someone is diseased. He may engage a good physician who gives good medicine, but that will not guarantee that he will live. Then what is the ultimate guarantee? Prahläda Mahäräja says, “My dear Lord, if You neglect someone, nothing can protect him.”

This is our practical experience. We can invent so many methods to solve the problems presented by the laws of material nature, but they are not sufficient. They will never solve all the problems, nor will they give actual relief. This is the fact. Therefore Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä, “Mäyä, this external energy, is very, very strong. No one can surpass it. It is almost impossible.” Then how can one get free from this material nature? Kåñëa says, “Simply by surrendering unto Me one can get relief from the onslaught of material nature.” That is a fact. So we have to cleanse the heart to learn what is our relationship with God.

In the Kaöha Upaniñad it is stated, nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm. The Supreme Absolute Personality of Godhead, or the Absolute Truth, is eternal. God is eternal, and we are also eternal. But the Vedas indicate that He is the supreme living creature. He is not dead. If He is not living, how is this world working? In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says, “Under My supervision things are going on.” In the Bible also it is said, “God created.” That is a fact. Not that at one time there was a chunk and then this happened and then that. No. The Vedas tell us the actual facts, but we have to open our eyes to see. Ceto-darpaëa-märjanam. That is the process of cleansing our hearts. When we cleanse our hearts, then we will be able to understand what Kåñëa and the Vedas say. We need to be purified. If a man is suffering from jaundice and you give him a piece of sugar candy, he will say that it is very bitter. But is sugar candy bitter? No, it is very sweet. And the medicine for jaundice is that sugar. Modern science prescribes this, and it is prescribed in the Vedic literature also. So if we take a great quantity of this sugar candy, then we will be relieved from jaundice. And when there is relief, then one says, “Oh, this is very sweet.” So the modern jaundice of a godless civilization can be cured by this chanting of Hare Kåñëa. In the beginning it may appear bitter, but when one advances, then he will see how pleasing it is.

As soon as one understands his identity, his relationship with God, then immediately he becomes happy. We are so full of miseries because we have identified ourselves with the material world. Therefore we are unhappy. Anxieties and fearfulness are due to our misidentifying with the material world. The other day I was explaining that one who identifies with this bag of bones and skin is like an animal. So by chanting Hare Kåñëa this misunderstanding will be cleansed. Cleansing of the heart means that one will understand that he does not belong to this material world. Ahaà brahmäsmi: I am spirit soul. As long as one identifies oneself with England, with India, or with America, this is ignorance. Today you are an Englishman because you were born in England, but in your next life you may not take your birth in England; it may be in China or Russia or some other country. Or you may not get this human form of body. Today you are a nationalist, you are a very great follower of your country, but tomorrow if you stay in your country you may be a cow being taken to the slaughterhouse.

So we have to thoroughly know our identity. Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that the actual identity of every living creature is that he is the eternal servant of God. If one thinks like that—“I am no one else’s servant; my business is to serve God”—then he is liberated. His heart is immediately cleansed, and he is liberated. And after one has reached that, then all one’s cares and anxieties in this world are over because one knows, “I am a servant of God. God will give me protection. Why should I worry about anything?” It is just like a child. A child knows that his mother and father will take care of him. He is free. If he should go to touch fire, his mother will take care of him: “Oh, my dear child, don’t touch.” The mother is always looking after him. So why don’t you put your trust in God? Actually, you are under the protection of God.

People go to church and say, “God, give us our daily bread.” Actually, if He did not give it to us, we would not be able to live. That is a fact. The Vedas also say that the one Supreme Personality supplies all the necessities of every other living creature. God is supplying food for everyone. We human beings have our economic problem, but what economic problem is there in societies other than human society? The bird society has no economic problem. There are 8,400,000 species of life, and out of that, human society is very, very small. So they have created problems—what to eat, where to sleep, how to mate, how to defend. These are a problem to us, but the majority of creatures—the aquatics, the fish, the plants, the insects, the birds, the beasts, and the many millions upon millions of other living creatures—do not have such a problem. They are also living creatures. Don’t think that they are different from us. It is not true that we human beings are the only living creatures and that all others are dead. No. And who is providing their food and shelter? It is God. The plants and animals are not going to the office. They are not going to the university to get technological education to earn money. So how are they eating? God is supplying. The elephant eats hundreds of pounds of food. Who is supplying? Are you making arrangements for the elephant? There are millions of elephants. Who is supplying?

So the process of acknowledging that God is supplying is better than thinking, “God is dead. Why should we go to church and pray to God for bread?” In the Bhagavad-gétä it is said, “Four kinds of people come to Kåñëa: the distressed, those who are in need of money, the wise, and the inquisitive.” One who is inquisitive, one who is wise, one who is distressed, and one who is in need of money—these four classes of men approach God. “My dear God, I am very hungry. Give me my daily bread.” That’s nice. Those who approach God in this way are recommended as sukåtinaù. Sukåté means “pious.” They are pious. Although they are asking for money, for food, they are considered pious because they are approaching God. And others are just the opposite. They are duñkåtinaù, impious. Kåté means “very meritorious,” but the word duñkåti indicates that their energy is being misused to create havoc. Just like the man who invented atomic weapons. He has a brain, but it has been misused. He has created something that is dreadful. Create something that will insure that man will no longer have to die. What is the use of creating something so that millions of people will immediately die? They will die today or tomorrow or after a hundred years. So what have the scientists done? Create something so that man will not die immediately, so that there will be no more disease, so that there will be no more old age. Then you will have done something. But the duñkåtinas never go to God. They never try to understand God. Therefore their energy is misdirected.

The gross materialists who ignore their relationship with God are described in the Bhagavad-gétä as müòhas. Müòha means “ass,” “donkey.” Those who are working very, very hard to earn money are compared to the donkey. They will eat the same four capätés [whole-wheat bread-patties] daily, but they are unnecessarily working to earn thousands of dollars. And others are described as narädhama. Narädhama means “the lowest of mankind.” The human form of life is meant for God realization. It is the right of man to try to realize God. One who understands Brahman, God, is a brähmaëa, not others. So that is the duty of this human form of life. In every human society there is some system that is called “religion” and by which one may try to understand God. It doesn’t matter whether it is the Christian religion, the Muhammadan religion, or the Hindu religion. It doesn’t matter. The system is to understand God and our relationship with Him. That’s all. This is the duty of the human beings, and if this duty is ignored in human society, then it is animal society. Animals have no power to understand what is God and their relationship with God. Their only interests are eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. If we are only concerned with these things, then what are we? We are animals. Therefore the Bhagavad-gétä says that those who ignore this opportunity are the “lowest of mankind.” They got births and yet did not utilize it for God realization but simply for the animal propensities. Therefore they are narädhama, the lowest of mankind. And there are other persons who are very proud of their knowledge. But what is that knowledge? “There is no God. I am God.” Their actual knowledge has been taken away by mäyä. If they are God, then how have they become dog? There are so many arguments against them, but they simply defy God. Atheism. Because they have taken to the process of atheism, their actual knowledge is stolen away. Actual knowledge means to know what is God and our relationship with God. If one does not know this, then it is to be understood that his knowledge has been taken away by mäyä.

So in this way, if we try to understand our relationship with God, there are ways and means. There are books, and there is knowledge, so why not take advantage of them? Everyone should take advantage of this knowledge. Try to understand that in the Bhagavad-gétä and other Vedic literatures, everywhere, it is said that God is great and that although we are qualitatively one with God, we are minute. The ocean and the minute particle of water have the same quality, but the quantity of salt in the drop of water and the quantity of salt in the ocean are different. They are qualitatively one but quantitatively different. Similarly, God is all-powerful, and we have some power. God creates everything, and we can create a small machine to fly, just like the small machines with which children play. But God can create millions of planets flying in the air. That is the qualification of God. You cannot create any planets. Even if you can create a planet, what is the benefit of that? There are millions of planets created by God. But you also have the creative power. God has power, and you have power. But His is so great that yours cannot compare to it. If you say, “I am God,” that is foolishness. You can claim that you are God, but what acts have you performed so extraordinary that you can claim that you are God? This is ignorance. The knowledge of one who thinks himself God has been taken away by the spell of mäyä. So our relationship is that God is great and we are minute. In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa clearly says, “All living entities are My parts and parcels. Qualitatively they are one with Me, but quantitatively they are different.” So we are simultaneously one with and different from God. That is our relationship. We are one because we have the same qualities as God. But if we study ourselves minutely, we will find that although we have some great qualities, God has them all in greater quantities.

We cannot have anything that is not in God. That is not possible. Therefore in the Vedänta-sütra it is said that everything that we have is also found in God. It is emanating from God. So our relationship is that because we are small, because we are minute, we are the eternal servitors of God. In this material world also, in ordinary behavior, we see that a man goes to serve another man because the other man is greater than he and can pay him a nice salary. So naturally the conclusion is that if we are small, our duty is to serve God. We have no other business. We are all different parts and parcels of the original entity.

A screw that is connected with a machine is valuable because it is working with the whole machine. And if the screw is taken away from the machine, or if it is faulty, it is worthless. My finger is worth millions of dollars as long as it is attached to this body and is serving the body. And if it is cut off from this body, then what is it worth? Nothing. Similarly, our relationship is that we are very small particles of God; therefore our duty is to dovetail our energies with Him and cooperate with Him. That is our relationship. Otherwise we are worthless. We are cut off. When the finger becomes useless the doctor says, “Oh, amputate this finger. Otherwise the body will be poisoned.” Similarly, when we become godless we are cut off from our relationship with God and suffer in this material world. If we try to join again with the Supreme Lord, then our relationship is revived.

SSR 8b: The Highest Love

The Highest Love

“Spiritual life means to associate with the Supreme Lord and to exist in bliss and knowledge eternally. Such eternal association means to play with Kåñëa, to dance with and love Kåñëa. Or Kåñëa can become your child—whatever you like.... Unless one can love Kåñëa, unless one finishes with love for cats, dogs, country, nation, and society and instead concentrates his love on Kåñëa, there is no question of happiness....”

If one protects the tender creeper of devotional service nicely, then gradually it will produce the fruit of unalloyed love for God. Unalloyed love for God means love that is not tinged by desire for material benefit, for mere philosophical understanding, nor for fruitive results. Unalloyed love is to know, “God is great, I am His part and parcel, and therefore He is my supreme lovable object.” This consciousness is the highest perfection of human life and the ultimate aim of all methods of self-realization. If one reaches this point—God is my only beloved, Kåñëa is the only lovable object—then one’s life is perfect. And when one tastes that transcendental relationship with Kåñëa, then one feels real happiness. The devotional creeper will then be so strongly protected that just by catching hold of it, one will be able to reach the supreme destination. If one climbs steadily up a tree, one eventually comes to the very top. Similarly, if one can achieve love of Godhead by catching that devotional creeper, there is no doubt that one will reach the transcendental abode of Kåñëa and will associate with Him personally, just as we are associating here, face to face.

God is not fictional or imaginary. He is as real as we are. (Actually, we are under illusion; we are living as if this body were our factual self, although this body is not at all reality, but only a temporary manifestation.) We dare to presume that there is no God or that He has no form. This mental speculation is due to a poor fund of knowledge. Lord Kåñëa and His abode exist, and one can go there, reach Him, and associate with Him. That is a fact. Spiritual life means to be in association with the Supreme Lord and to exist in bliss and knowledge eternally. Such eternal association means to play with Kåñëa, to dance with and love Kåñëa. Or Kåñëa can become your child—whatever you like.

There are five primary relationships with Kåñëa: as a passive devotee, as a servant, as a friend, as a parent, and as a lover. The cows in Kåñëa’s abode are also liberated souls. They are called surabhi cows. There are many popular pictures showing how Kåñëa loves the cows, how He embraces and kisses them. That passive relationship with Kåñëa is called çänta. Their perfect happiness is achieved when Kåñëa comes and simply touches them.

Other devotees are inclined to actually give service. They think, “Kåñëa wants to sit down. I will arrange a place for Him. Kåñëa wants to eat. I will get Him some nice food.” And they actually make these arrangements. Other devotees play with Kåñëa as friends on equal terms. They do not know that Kåñëa is God; to them, Kåñëa is their lovable friend, and they cannot forget Him for a moment. All day and all night, they think of Kåñëa. At night, when they are sleeping they think, “Oh, in the morning I shall go and play with Kåñëa.” And in the morning they go to Kåñëa’s house and stand by while Kåñëa is decorated by His mother before going out to play with His friends in the fields. There is no other activity in Krsëaloka (Kåñëa’s abode). There is no industry, no rushing to the office, or any such nonsense. There is sufficient milk and butter, and everyone eats plentifully. Kåñëa is very fond of His friends, and sometimes He enjoys stealing butter for them. One can actually live this way, and that is the perfection of existence. We should hanker for that perfectional stage of life. Kåñëa consciousness is the process to attain it.

But as long as one has even a slight attachment for this material world, one has to remain here. Kåñëa is very strict. He does not allow anyone to enter into His association who has any tinge of the material conception of life. Bhakti must be free from material contamination. Do not think, “I am a very learned scholar. I shall find out what is the Absolute Truth by mental speculation.” That is nonsense; one can go on and on speculating and will never find the source of all sources. It is said in the Brahma-saàhitä, “One can go on speculating about the Absolute Truth for millions and millions of years, and still it will not be revealed.” One can rot in this material world as he is and can go on speculating, but that is not the right process. Here is the process—bhakti-yoga.

Lord Caitanya says that to render devotional service to Kåñëa is the highest perfectional stage of life, and compared to this, other things for which people are hankering in this material world are like bubbles in the ocean. Generally, people are after rewards, and therefore they become religious. They say, “I am a Hindu,” “I am a Christian,” “I am a Jew,” “I am Muhammadan,” “I am this, I am that, and therefore I cannot change my religion. I cannot accept Kåñëa.” This is called religiosity, dharma. With such a materialistic, sectarian idea of religion, they will rot in this material world, stuck to rituals and faith. They are under the impression that if they follow their religious principles, they will get material prosperity. Of course, if one sticks to any kind of religious faith, he will get facilities for material life.

Why do people want this material prosperity? For sense gratification. They are thinking, “I shall have a very nice wife. I shall have very good children. I shall have a very good post. I shall become president. I shall become prime minister.” This is sense gratification. And when one is frustrated and has seen that to be rich or to attain the presidency cannot give him happiness, after squeezing out all the taste of sex life, when he is completely frustrated, then perhaps he takes to LSD and tries to become one with the void. But this nonsense cannot give happiness. Here is happiness: one must approach Kåñëa. Otherwise, it will end in LSD confusion and roaming in impersonal void concepts. People are frustrated. They must be frustrated if they do not have genuine spiritual life, because a person is spiritual by nature.

How can anyone be happy without Kåñëa? Suppose one is thrown into the ocean. How can he be happy there? That is not for us. One may be a very good swimmer, but how long will he be able to swim? He eventually becomes tired and drowns. Similarly, we are spiritual by nature. How can we be happy in this material world? It is not possible. But men are trying to remain here, making so many temporary adjustments for survival. This patchwork is not happiness. If one really wants happiness, here is the process: one must attain love of Godhead. Unless one can love Kåñëa, unless one finishes with love for cats, dogs, country, nation, and society and instead concentrates his love on Kåñëa, there is no question of happiness. Rüpa Goswami has given a very nice example in this regard: there are many drugs that saturate one with ideas or hallucinations. But Rüpa Goswami says that unless one tastes that final drug of love of Godhead, kåñëa-premä, he will have to be captivated by meditation, impersonal monism, and so many other distractions.

Caitanya Mahäprabhu describes that to attain unalloyed love of Kåñëa one has to execute devotional service, or Kåñëa consciousness. One has to engage oneself exclusively in serving Kåñëa. The highest perfectional stage of unalloyed devotion is to be free from all material desires, all mental speculation, and all fruitive activities. The basic principle of unalloyed devotion is that one cannot maintain any desire other than to become fully Kåñëa conscious. Even if one knows that all other forms of God are also Kåñëa, one should not worship any other form, but should concentrate on the Kåñëa form. Kåñëa has many forms, but one only has to worship Kåñëa in His form with the flute, as in the Rädhä-Kåñëa Deity. Simply concentrate on that form, and all mental speculation and fruitive activities will fall away. One has to cultivate Kåñëa consciousness favorably, and that means to execute service by which Kåñëa becomes satisfied. Kåñëa consciousness is not attained by manufacturing one’s own way. I may think that I am doing something in Kåñëa consciousness, but who has sanctioned it? For instance, in the Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna hesitated to fight, for certain moral reasons, but he was viewing the situation from the platform of fruitive activities, on which one has to enjoy or suffer the results. He was considering that if he killed his family members, he would then be subjected to many reactions. This conclusion, however, was not sanctioned by Kåñëa. The law of action and reaction in the material world is called karma, but devotional service transcends karma.

Unalloyed love must be free of all tinges of fruitive activities (karma) and all tinges of mental speculation and material desire. That unalloyed devotional service should be favorably fixed on Kåñëa. “Favorably” means in accordance with what He desires. Kåñëa desired that the Battle of Kurukñetra take place; it was all arranged by Him. Arjuna was told, “You are thinking in your own way, but even if you do not fight, rest assured that because it has been arranged by Me, none of these warriors who are assembled here are going back to their homes. They will be killed here. It has already been arranged.” God’s desire is such that one cannot change it. Kåñëa has two qualities: He can protect, and He can also kill. If He wants to kill someone, there is no power in the world that can protect him, and if He protects someone, there is no power in the world that can kill him. Kåñëa’s desire is supreme. Therefore, we have to dovetail our desires with Kåñëa’s. Whatever Kåñëa desires, no one can make null and void because He is the Supreme Lord. Therefore, our duty is to dovetail our acts with Kåñëa’s desire, not to manufacture an action and then declare: “I am doing this action in Kåñëa consciousness.” We have to be very careful to ascertain whether Kåñëa actually wants it. Such authorized knowledge is instructed by the representative of Kåñëa. In our prayers of praise to the spiritual master we are singing daily, “If the spiritual master is satisfied, then God will be satisfied. And if one dissatisfies his spiritual master, then there is no way for him to please God.”

Therefore, as far as possible, one has to execute the order of one’s spiritual master. That will enable one to progress. That is the essence of the favorable execution of Kåñëa consciousness. In my old age, I have come to America, and I am trying to teach Kåñëa consciousness, because my spiritual master gave me an order that I must do it. It is my duty. I do not know whether I shall be a success or failure. It doesn’t matter; my duty is completed if I can present before you whatever I have heard from my spiritual master. This is called the favorable execution of Kåñëa consciousness. Those who are actually serious should take the order of Kåñëa through the representative of Kåñëa as their entire life and soul. One who sticks to this principle is sure to progress. Caitanya Mahäprabhu spoke in that way, and my spiritual master used to say, “The spiritual master is the transparent via medium.” For example, I can see the letters of this book very nicely through these transparent eyeglasses, without which I cannot see because my eyes are defective. Similarly, our senses are all defective. We cannot see God with these eyes, we cannot hear Hare Kåñëa with these ears, we cannot do anything without the via medium of the spiritual master. Just as a defective eye cannot see without the via medium of spectacles, so one cannot approach the Supreme Lord without the transparent via medium of the spiritual master. “Transparent” means that the via medium must be free of contamination. If it is transparent, one can see through it.

In unalloyed love of Godhead we have to engage our senses—sarvendriya, all the senses. This means that sex is also to be engaged in Kåñëa consciousness. The conception of God as a father or mother does not allow the engagement of one’s sex in the service of the Lord because there is no sexual relationship with the father and mother. But in the conception of God as a lover, there is sexual engagement also. Therefore, Caitanya Mahäprabhu gave the most perfect information of our engagement with the Supreme Lord. In other religious conceptions of life, God is at the utmost taken as the father or mother. Many worshipers in India take goddess Kälé to be the representation of God. Of course, that is not sanctioned, but the belief is there, and also in the Christian religion the conception of God is as a father. But Caitanya Mahäprabhu informs us that one can even have sexual engagement with the Lord. This information is Caitanya Mahäprabhu’s unique contribution. In this material world, sexual engagement is considered to be the highest engagement, the greatest pleasure, although it exists only in a perverted form. No one, however, has conceived that there can be sexual engagement in the spiritual world. There is not a single instance of such theology anywhere in the entire world. This information is given for the first time by Caitanya Mahäprabhu: one can have the Supreme Personality of Godhead as one’s husband, as one’s lover. This is possible in the worship of Rädhä and Kåñëa, but no one, especially the impersonalists, can understand Rädhä-Kåñëa. The impersonalists have no idea; they cannot even conceive that God has form. But Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that not only does God have form, but He has sex life also. This is the highest contribution of Cai-tanya Mahäprabhu.

One can serve the Supreme Lord in various relationships, but in the material world those relationships exist only as perverted reflections. What is our engagement in relationship to this material world? What are our ideas of society, friendship, and love? They are all based on the material conception of life. In our society, someone is engaged as a father or mother to a son, and others are engaged as husband and wife, lover and beloved. There are other rasas (relationships) also, such as to be engaged with another as an enemy. There are twelve different relationships, out of which five are predominant. The other seven are indirect relationships, such as, for example, to be someone’s enemy. There is usually a relationship between enemies, even between a murderer and the one he murders. As far as our relationship with Kåñëa is concerned, however, even if one establishes a relationship as His enemy, then his life is successful. Therefore, when one engages his senses with Kåñëa, a relationship can be established in one of twelve different varieties, of which five varieties are direct and seven are indirect.

When Kåñëa appeared in the arena of Kaàsa, there were many big wrestlers prepared to kill Him. In fact, He was invited there to be killed. His enemy Kaàsa thought, “Soon the boys will come. We have tried for sixteen years to kill them, but that boy Kåñëa could not be killed. But now I have invited Him as a guest, and when He arrives He will fight with these wrestlers, and they will kill Him.” The demoniac or atheistic people are always thinking of Kåñëa, or God, in terms of killing Him. Therefore they present their theories that God is dead. They think that if God becomes dead, then they will be free to act however they please. But as far as their actual activities are concerned, God may be dead or alive, but God’s agent, the material energy, is so strong that no one can freely do any wrong. As soon as anyone does something wrong, there is immediate punishment. It does not require the presence of God. God may be dead or alive, but the material energy is sufficient to punish anyone who violates the material laws, even to the slightest degree. God has set these conditions, but foolish people do not understand.

Lord Caitanya, however, speaks of favorably engaging all the senses in the service of Kåñëa in pure devotional life. One should favorably engage one’s senses and should do whatever Kåñëa wants. Yet even if one engages one’s senses against the will of Kåñëa but still thinks of Kåñëa, that is also advantageous. The demon Pütanä, for example, thought of killing Kåñëa. Just as the occupation of godly persons is to serve God, so the demons and atheists are always prepared to kill God. Pütanä thought, “I shall kill Kåñëa. He is only a child.” This is another mistake of the demoniac. They think Kåñëa, or God, to be an ordinary child or man. So in this way Pütanä was thinking: “Let me smear my breast with poison, and when the child goes to suck my milk, He will die.” As we study this, we see that she approached Kåñëa as His enemy, and yet He accepted her as a friend because He is so merciful. He did not take the demoniac portion of her mentality, but He accepted her. Every living entity is conditioned, but Kåñëa is not. A doctor or psychiatrist treats madmen, but he does not become mad. Sometimes a patient may become angry with him or call him ill names, but the doctor is sober and simply treats him. Similarly, if someone regards Kåñëa as his enemy, Kåñëa does not become his enemy.

Pütanä came to poison Kåñëa, but He took it otherwise. He thought, “I have sucked her breast milk. Therefore she has become My mother.” Kåñëa treated her as His mother, and therefore she became liberated to the same position as Kåñëa’s real mother, Yaçodä. The conclusion is that the highest perfection is to establish a favorable relationship with Kåñëa, but even if one engages himself unfavorably, Kåñëa is so merciful that He at least gives one salvation. All the enemies killed by Kåñëa were immediately liberated.

Two classes of men may merge into the impersonal brahmajyoti: those who are intentionally aspiring to merge into the impersonal brahmajyoti may enter, and those who are enemies of Kåñëa and are killed by Him may also do so. Therefore, the devotee concludes, Why should I accept a condition that is offered even to God’s enemies?

Caitanya Mahäprabhu recommends pure devotional service. There should be no desire to fulfill one’s own material desires, there should be no attempt to understand Kåñëa by experimental philosophy, and there should be no fruitive activities to derive material benefits from Kåñëa. The only desire should be to serve Him favorably, as He desires. If Kåñëa wants something, then we should do it. Suppose I were to ask a disciple, “My dear student, please give me a glass of water.” It is then his duty to give me a glass of water. If he thinks, “Prabhupäda wants a glass of water, but why not give him something better? Why not a glass of hot milk?” that is not service. In his consideration, hot milk is very palatable and is better than water, yet because I have asked for water, he has to give me water, not milk. That is favorable service. One has to understand what Kåñëa wants. When there is that intimate relationship, then one can serve Kåñëa most favorably. And as long as there is not that intimate relationship, one must take information of what Kåñëa wants through the transparent medium of the spiritual master.

A Vaiñëava never thinks that he has a direct relationship with Kåñëa. Lord Caitanya says, “I am the servant of the servant of the servant of the servant—a hundred times the servant of the servant—of Kåñëa.” [Padyävalé 74] We have to agree to become the servant of the servant of the servant. This is the process of disciplic succession, and if one wants real, transcendental love of God, then he has to adopt this process. Because people do not accept this process, they do not develop real love of God. They speak of God, but actually they do not love God; because there is no cultivation of pure devotional service, they love dog.

We may say, “love of God,” but unless we adopt this principle, then we will have to love dog, not God. That is the mistake. Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that if one really wants love of God, then one has to follow the process of pure devotional service. It is not that Caitanya Mahäprabhu is speaking out of His own mental concoction; His statements are confirmed in Vedic scriptures such as the Närada-païcarätra and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. These two books, and the Bhagavad-gétä, are very authentic scriptures meant for devotees. Caitanya Mahäprabhu quotes from a verse in the Närada-païcarätra: Håñékeëa håñékeça-sevanaà bhaktir ucyate. This is the definition of pure devotional service. Håñékeëa håñékeça-sevanam. Håñékeëa means “by one’s senses.” We have to engage our senses; it is not that we engage only our minds. If someone says, “I am always thinking of Kåñëa,” that is not pure devotional service. Meditation is thinking, but no one thinks of Kåñëa; they think of void or something impersonal. If someone is thinking of Kåñëa or Näräyaëa or Viñëu, as prescribed in the Vedic scriptures, that is real yoga; yoga meditation means to focus one’s mind upon the Supersoul. The Supersoul is the representation of Kåñëa in the form of four-handed Näräyaëa. Even Pataïjali, an authority on the yoga system, prescribes meditation on Viñëu. But just as people are manufacturing bogus religious processes, the so-called yogés of today have manufactured their own way of thinking of something void.

But the Närada-païcarätra says, håñékeëa håñékeça-sevanam: one must engage not only one’s mind but one’s senses. Engage the senses in the service of the master of the senses. These three Sanskrit words are very significant. Håñékeça means “the Lord of the senses.” So bhakti-yoga means to serve with the senses the Lord of the senses. The Lord of the senses is Kåñëa. We should always remember that we have our senses because we wanted to enjoy this material world, and therefore the Lord has given us a particular set of senses for our enjoyment. The hog has a particular type of body and senses because he wanted to enjoy eating stool. Similarly, a man has a particular type of body and senses because he wanted to enjoy something else. We have a particular set of conditioned senses with which to enjoy this material world, and this is what we have to purify. Our senses are original, but now they are covered by material desires. We have to cure ourselves and become free from such desires. When one’s senses are no longer inclined toward material sense gratification, one’s status is called pure devotion.

From this verse of the Närada-païcarätra, we can understand that the spirit soul has original senses. However small a body it may have entered, the spirit soul is not impersonal; it has senses. Perhaps one may find a bug on one’s book. It is so small, smaller than a pinpoint, but still it moves; it has all the senses. The small bacteria also move, and they have their senses. Originally, all living entities have senses. It is not that the senses have developed under certain material conditions. The atheistic theory is that under material conditions we have developed senses, that in the spiritual condition there are no senses, and that we are impersonal. By logic and reason, however, that cannot be so. A minute particle of spiritual force, even if it is smaller in size than an atom, has its senses. These senses, being covered by material elements, manifest themselves in a perverted way. We have to purify the senses, and when the senses are purified, we can engage them for the pleasure of the master of the senses. Kåñëa is the master and proprietor of the senses. Therefore, because we are part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, our senses are borrowed from Him; they are on rental. The best thing is to use the senses for His sense satisfaction, and not for our own. This is the process of pure Kåñëa consciousness.

From the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Lord Caitanya gives an example of pure devotion: it is said in the Bhägavatam that Kåñëa is situated in everyone’s heart. Therefore, just as rivers flow and their natural tendency is to reach the sea, so as soon as one hears the glories of the Lord, his soul is at once attracted toward the Supreme Lord. This is the beginning of pure devotional service. As soon as there is the chanting vibration, Hare Kåñëa, immediately Kåñëa’s paraphernalia, Kåñëa’s name, Kåñëa’s fame, Kåñëa’s abode, Kåñëa’s associates—everything—all of a sudden become manifested within because He is present. This is the beginning of one’s Kåñëa consciousness. To remember by reference to a context means that as soon as one hears a code word, one at once remembers all the information behind that code. Similarly, when our minds are attracted to Kåñëa and everything about Kåñëa simply by hearing a little glorification of His qualities, that is the beginning of pure Kåñëa consciousness. Then there is no more gati, or movement of the mind.

It was just that way with the gopés: as soon as they heard the sound of Kåñëa’s flute, they gave up everything. Some of them were lying down, some were working in their family affairs, some were taking care of their children, but as soon as they heard Kåñëa’s flute, they forgot everything and rushed to Him. Their husbands, their brothers, and their fathers said, “Why are you going and leaving your duty?” But they did not care—they simply left. There is no impediment and no stumbling block in that merge of the mind with Kåñëa. This is the beginning of pure devotion.

Puruñottama means Kåñëa. The word puruña means “enjoyer.” The conditioned living entities are false enjoyers, imitation enjoyers. Here in this material world, all living entities are acting as purusas. The more exact meaning of puruña is “male.” The male is considered to be the enjoyer, and the female is considered to be the enjoyed. In the material world, whether one has a male or a female body, everyone has the propensity to enjoy, and therefore everyone is called puruña. But actually the only puruña is the Supreme Lord. We living entities are His energy, and He is the supreme enjoyer. We are not puruña. Energies are employed for enjoyment, and we are energies, instruments of the Supreme Person. Therefore Puruñottama is the supreme transcendental person, Kåñëa. When our pure devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead is employed and there are no impediments or stumbling blocks, that is the symptom of pure Kåñëa consciousness.

There is no ambition or motive in pure Kåñëa consciousness. Every other transcendental function or mode of worship is backed by a motive: someone wants salvation, someone wants material prosperity, someone wants to go to a higher planet, someone wants to go to Krsëaloka. These ambitions should not be there. A pure devotee has no such ambitions. A pure devotee does not even desire to go to the supreme abode of Kåñëa. Of course, he goes, but he has no desire. He simply wants to engage himself fully in Kåñëa’s service.

There are different kinds of salvation. There is sälokya liberation, to live on the same planet as the Supreme Lord. The residents of the Vaikuëöha planets live on the same planet as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Särñöi liberation means to have almost the same opulence as Näräyaëa. The liberated individual soul can appear just like Näräyaëa, with four hands, the four emblems, almost the same bodily features, the same opulence, the same ornaments, the same buildings, everything. Särüpya means to have the same form or features. Sämépya means never to be far away but always to be associated with the Supreme Lord. For example, just as we are sitting together, so one can associate with the Lord. This is called sämépya-mukti, the liberation of being nearer. Pure devotees, however, do not accept these various forms of liberation. They only want to be engaged in Kåñëa’s service. They are not concerned with any kind of liberation. Those who are actually Kåñëa conscious achieve the association of the Supreme Lord, but they do not desire it; their only ambition is to be engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. The highest perfection of devotional service, or Kåñëa consciousness, is exhibited when a devotee refuses to accept any benediction or profit from the Supreme Lord. Prahläda Mahäräja was offered whatever he liked, he had only to ask for it, but he said, “My Lord, I am Your eternal servant. It is my duty to serve You, so how can I accept any benefit from it? Then I would not be Your servant; I would be a merchant.” He replied in that way, and that is the sign of a pure person. Kåñëa is so kind that He fulfills all the desires of a devotee, even if he wants material benedictions. If at the bottom of the devotee’s heart there is some desire, He also fulfills that. He is so kind. But the sublime position of bhakti-yoga, or devotional service, is that a pure devotee refuses to accept the various kinds of liberation, even if offered by the Supreme Lord.

If one has material desires or motives within himself, and for fulfillment of such desires he engages himself in devotional service, the result will be that he will never get pure love of God. If one is thinking, “I am engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, in Kåñëa’s devotional service, because I want such and such an opulence,” that desire may be fulfilled, but he will never get such unalloyed love of Kåñëa as the gopés had. If one has a motive, even though he discharges his devotional duty, he still will not be able to reach the stage of pure love of Godhead. In a verse from the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, Rüpa Goswami says, “As long as one desires some material benefit [bhukti], or even if he wants salvation [mukti], then he must take those ghostly representations.” As long as that mäyä exists within one’s heart, how can one enjoy the spiritual bliss derived from pure love of Godhead? In other words, if one has material desires, or even a desire for salvation, he cannot attain pure love of Godhead. Pure devotion is devoid of all desires—it is simply to render loving service for its own sake.

There is a nice example in the life of Rüpa Goswami. Rüpa Goswami and his brother Sanätana Goswami were living separately in Våndävana and going on with their bhajana, devotional service. Rüpa was living in the forest, and there was no facility for cooking nice food or begging from the village for a capäté to eat. Rüpa Goswami was the younger brother, and he thought, “If I could get some foodstuffs, then I could prepare nice dishes and offer them to Kåñëa and invite my elder brother.” He had that desire. The next moment, a nice girl about twelve years old came and delivered an abundance of foodstuffs—milk, flour, ghee, etc. That is the Vedic system; sometimes householders present foodstuffs to mendicants and sages in the renounced order of life. Rüpa Goswami was very glad that Kåñëa had sent so many things and that he could now prepare a feast. He prepared a feast and then invited his elder brother.

When Sanätana Goswami came, he was astonished. “How have you secured such things? You have prepared such a nice feast in this forest. How is it possible?”

So Rüpa Goswami explained, “In the morning I desired for it, and by chance Kåñëa sent me all these things. A nice girl came, and she offered it to me.” He was describing the girl: “A very nice girl.”

Then Sanätana said, “This nice girl is Rädhäräëé. You have taken service from Rädhäräëé, the Lord’s eternal consort. It is a great blunder.” That is their philosophy. They would not accept service from the Lord. They simply wanted to render service. But Kåñëa is so clever that He also wants to serve His devotee. He looks for an opportunity to serve His devotee. This is spiritual competition. A pure devotee does not want anything from Kåñëa; he simply wants to serve Him. And Kåñëa also looks for the opportunity to serve His devotee. Kåñëa is always as anxious to please His devotee as the devotee is to please Him.

This is the transcendental world. On the absolute plane, there is no exploitation. Everyone wants to serve; no one wants to take service. In the transcendental world, everyone wants to give service. You want to give service to me, and I want to give service to you. This is such a nice attitude. This material world means that I want to pickpocket you, and you want to pickpocket me. That’s all. This is the material world. We should try to understand it. In the material world, everyone wants to exploit his friend, his father, his mother, everyone. But in the transcendental world, everyone wants to serve. Everyone has Kåñëa as the central point of serving, and all the devotees, either as friends or servants or parents or lovers of Kåñëa, all want to serve Him. And at the same time, Kåñëa also wants to serve them. This is a transcendental relationship; the main function is service, although there is no necessity of service, for everyone is full. There is no hunger, there is no necessity of eating, but still everyone offers nice things to eat. This is the transcendental world. Unless we attain the stage of simply serving Kåñëa or His devotee, we cannot relish the transcendental pleasure of service. If we have any motive, then that sense will never be awakened. Without a motive, without desire for personal sense gratification, service should be rendered to the Supreme Lord and His devotees.

SSR 8c: Approaching Kåñëa with Love

Approaching Kåñëa with Love

"This is the formula—we should not try to satisfy our senses separately but should try to satisfy Kåñëa's senses. Then naturally we will become satisfied. A Kåñëa conscious person is always trying to give satisfaction to Kåñëa...."

When Kåñëa was on this earth, all the residents of Våndävana loved Him. Indeed, they knew nothing but Kåñëa. They did not know whether Kåñëa is God or not God, nor were they disturbed by such thoughts as, “I shall love Kåñëa if He is God.” Their attitude was one of pure love, and they thought, “He may or may not be God—it doesn’t matter. We love Kåñëa, that’s all.” This then is the platform of real, unalloyed love. When one thinks, “If Kåñëa is God, I shall love Him,” it should be known that this is not the platform of pure love but of conditional love. While on earth, Kåñëa exhibited extraordinary powers, and the vraja-väsés, the residents of Våndävana, often thought, “Oh, Kåñëa is such a wonderful child. Maybe He is some demigod.” They thought in this way because people were generally under the impression that the demigods were all-powerful. Within the material world the demigods are powerful, but people are not aware that Kåñëa is above all of them. The highest of the demigods, Brahmä, gave his opinion of this matter in the verse éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù: “Kåñëa is the supreme controller, and His body is full of knowledge, bliss, and eternality.” Little did the residents of Våndävana know of Kåñëa’s power as the ultimate controller and master of all the demigods. What is noteworthy is that their love for Him was not subject to such considerations.

As the residents of Våndävana loved Kåñëa unconditionally, similarly Kåñëa loved them unconditionally. Vraja-jana-vallabha, giri-vara-dhäré. When the inhabitants of Våndävana stopped performing sacrifices to Lord Indra, the chief demigod of the heavens, they placed themselves in a very dangerous position. Indra became very angry and sent powerful clouds that rained over Våndävana incessantly for seven days. The whole area began to flood, and the inhabitants became very disturbed. Although He was only seven years old, Kåñëa saved the inhabitants of Våndävana by lifting Govardhana Hill and holding it up as an umbrella to shield the village. Lord Kåñëa thus taught the demigod Indra that his disturbances could be stopped simply by His little finger. Seeing this, Lord Indra bowed down before Kåñëa.

Thus Kåñëa also became known as Gopéjana-vallabha, which indicates that His only business is to protect the gopé-jana. This Kåñëa consciousness movement aims at teaching people how to become gopé-janas, or pure lovers of Kåñëa. When we reach that stage of pure love of God, the Lord will save us from any danger, even if it means His lifting a hill or a mountain. Kåñëa did not have to practice some yoga system in order to lift Govardhana Hill. As God, He is all-powerful, even as a child. He played like a child and dealt with others like a child, but when there was need, He manifested Himself as God Almighty. That is the nature of Kåñëa, or God: He does not have to practice meditation or follow some system of yoga in order to become God. He is not a manufactured type of God, but is God eternally.

Although He is God, He enjoys loving relationships with His devotees, and in order to satisfy His devotees, He often takes roles that appear to be subsidiary. Kåñëa often likes being the child of a devotee, and thus He became the beloved child of Yaçodä, Yaçodä-nandana. Because He is God and everyone worships Him, no one chastises Him. However, Kåñëa enjoys being chastised by His devotee father and mother, and because Kåñëa takes pleasure in being chastised, the devotees also take up the role, saying, “All right, I shall become Your father and chastise You.” Similarly, when Kåñëa wants to fight, one of His devotees becomes the demon Hiraëyakaçipu and fights with Him. In this way, all Kåñëa’s activities are carried out in connection with His devotees. If we aspire to become such associates of Kåñëa, we must develop Kåñëa consciousness, awareness of Kåñëa.

Yaçodä-nandana vraja-jana-raïjana. Kåñëa’s only business is satisfying the vraja-janas, and their only business is satisfying Kåñëa. This is the reciprocation of love. Yamunä-téra-vana-cäré: Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, wanders on the banks of the Yamunä to please the gopés, the cowherd boys, the birds, the bees, and the cows and calves. These are not ordinary birds, bees, cows, calves, or men; they have all reached the summit of self-realization and thus, after many, many lives, have attained a position whereby they can play with Kåñëa.

This Kåñëa consciousness movement can enable everyone to go to Krsëaloka and become Kåñëa’s associate as a friend, servant, father, or mother. Kåñëa is agreeable to take any of these positions in relation to His devotee. How He does so is all described in our book Teachings of Lord Caitanya. To realize our relationship with Kåñëa, we have but to follow in the footsteps of Lord Caitanya and His chief associates, the six Goswamis—Çré Rüpa, Sanätana, Çré Jéva, Gopäla, Raghunätha däsa, and Raghunätha Bhaööa. These Goswamis were always engaged in chanting Hare Kåñëa and dancing in ecstasy. They taught that when one is merged in kåñëa-kértana, or the chanting of the holy names of Kåñëa, he merges into the ocean of love of Kåñëa. As soon as the sound of Kåñëa’s name is vibrated, one can immediately merge into the ocean of love. That is the sign of pure devotion. Thus at kértanas the six Goswamis would merge immediately into the ocean of love of Godhead.

The six Goswamis were dear not only to the other devotees of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu but to the nondevotees as well. A pure devotee’s position is that he has no enemy because he is not envious. A pure devotee is always open to everyone, and he does not discriminate that this person can be allowed to chant Hare Kåñëa and that person should not be allowed. On the material platform, which is a platform of dualism, there are differences between high and low, man and woman, and this or that, but on the spiritual platform there are no such distinctions. The pure devotee, seeing everything with an equal mind, is therefore nonenvious. Because he is nonenvious, he is worshipable. Indeed, it may even be said that a person is worshipable simply if he is nonenvious, for it is only possible to be nonenvious on the spiritual platform. This is also the verdict of the Bhagavad-gétä [5.18-19]:

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

ihaiva tair jitaù sargo
yeñäà sämye sthitaà manaù
nirdoñaà hi samaà brahma
tasmäd brahmaëi te sthitäù

“The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog, and a dog-eater. Those whose minds are established in sameness and equanimity have already conquered the conditions of birth and death. They are flawless like Brahman, and thus they are already situated in Brahman.”

Such a position can be obtained by one who has acquired the mercy of Lord Caitanya. Upon obtaining His mercy, a person can deliver suffering humanity from material contamination. Because the six Goswamis were such devotees, we offer our respectful obeisances unto them with the mantra: vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau. The six Goswamis were expert in scrutinizingly studying all the scriptures with the aim to establish real religion in the world. They left many books to guide us, the most famous of which is Çré Rüpa Goswami’s Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (The Nectar of Devotion), which gives the neophyte devotee initial direction. The Goswamis always worked very hard, day and night, and their business was simply writing books, chanting, and dancing. Indeed, they were practically released from the bodily necessities of eating, sleeping, mating, and defending themselves out of fear. There was no question of mating at all, nor was there any question of fearing or defending, for they were totally absorbed in Kåñëa. At most they used to sleep one and a half hours daily, and they ate practically nothing. Whenever they felt hungry, they would simply go to a householder’s home and beg one or two pieces of bread.

The mission of such saintly persons is but to make suffering humanity happy by elevating everyone to spiritual consciousness. In the material world, everyone is trying to exploit one another—one nation is trying to exploit another nation, one society is trying to exploit another, one businessman is trying to exploit another, etc. This is called the struggle for existence, and out of it the people who are struggling have invented a law called “Might is right,” but we can actually see that even the most powerful must struggle, just as in the current world situation. There is a great struggle going on between Russia, America, and China. Because of such struggle, everyone is suffering. Indeed, the very struggle for existence means suffering. The pure devotees of Kåñëa, however, are interested not in exploiting others but in helping people become happy, and therefore they are worshiped on all planets. Cäëakya Paëòita even said that a rich man and a learned man cannot be compared, for a rich man may be honored in his own country or on his own planet, but a learned man, a devotee of God, is honored wherever he goes.

Nor for a devotee is there a distinction between heaven and hell, because Kåñëa is with him in both places. Where there is Kåñëa, there is no question of hell; every place is Vaikuëöha. Haridäsa Öhäkura, for instance, did not enter the Jagannätha temple at Puré, for he was born in a Muhammadan family, and the Hindus opposed the Muhammadans’ entering the temple. Haridäsa Öhäkura did not let this disturb him, however. He thought, “Oh, why should I go and disturb them? I shall chant here.” Consequently Lord Caitanya, who is Lord Jagannätha Himself, came daily to see Haridäsa. This is the power of a pure devotee: he doesn’t have to go to Jagannätha; Jagannätha comes to him. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu used to go see Haridäsa Öhäkura daily when the Lord was going to bathe in the sea. The Lord would enter Haridäsa’s cottage and ask, “Haridäsa, what are you doing?” and Haridäsa would reply, “Please come in, my Lord.” This then is the actual position of a devotee. Therefore Kåñëa says that worship of His devotee is even more valuable than worship of Himself. The devotee is actually able to deliver Kåñëa, for he knows the science of Kåñëa consciousness, the science of hearing Kåñëa’s words, eating Kåñëa prasäda, and enjoying Kåñëa. The impersonalists and voidists may preach dry philosophical treatises on ahaà brahmäsmi—“I am spirit”—but ultimately who will be attracted? What is the difference between someone who thinks, “I am a stone,” and someone who thinks, “I am void”? Why should we become stone, wood, or void? Our actual position should be in reciprocating loving affairs with Kåñëa.

The spark of love for Kåñëa is struck by the spiritual master, the pure devotee. As for myself, my spiritual master, His Divine Grace Oà Viñëupäda Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Goswami Prabhupäda, ordered me to take up the responsibility of spreading Kåñëa consciousness in the Western world. His Divine Grace had a great desire to preach Lord Caitanya’s message in the West, and my success is both his grace and pleasure. When I first met my spiritual master, I was a very young man in India, a nationalist, engaged in a very responsible office. But although I did not want to go, one of my friends, who is still living in Calcutta, forcibly took me to His Divine Grace. I was reluctant to see him because in our home our father used to receive many sannyäsés and I was not very satisfied with their dealings. I thought that Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Goswami Mahäräja might be a similar man, and if he were, what business would I have in seeing him? But my friend took me forcibly. “Why not see him?” he asked. I finally relented and went with him, and I profited.

On my first visit, His Divine Grace said that it was necessary for educated boys like me to go to foreign countries and preach the gospel of Caitanya Mahäprabhu. I replied that India was a foreign-dominated nation and that no one would hear our messages. Actually, at the time foreigners considered Indians very insignificant because in the face of so many independent nations India was still dependent, being dominated by Britain. At the time there was one Bengali poet who actually lamented that even uncivilized nations were independent, whereas India was dependent on the British. His Divine Grace convinced me that dependence and independence are simply temporary conditions, and he pointed out that because we are concerned with the eternal benefit of humanity, we should take up this challenge of Caitanya Mahäprabhu. This meeting with His Divine Grace, my Guru Mahäräja, took place in 1922, half a century ago.

I was officially initiated in 1933, just three years before the passing of Guru Mahäräja from this mortal world. At the last moment, just a fortnight before his passing away, he wrote me a letter repeating his instructions. He specifically said that I should try to preach this gospel among English-speaking people. After receiving this letter, I sometimes dreamed that Guru Mahäräja was calling me and that I was leaving home and following him. I was dreaming in this way and thinking, “I have to give up my home. My Guru Mahäräja wants me to give up my home and take sannyäsa.” At the same time I thought, “This is horrible. How can I leave my home? My wife? My children?” This is called mäyä. Actually I did not want to give up my home life, but Guru Mahäräja made me give it up. Following his orders, I left my home, including a few children, but now Guru Mahäräja has given me many nice children all over the world. Thus by serving Kåñëa no one becomes a loser, and this is an example from my own practical experience.

When I left India alone in 1965, I feared that I would have a great deal of trouble. The Indian government would not allow me to take any money out of the country, so I came with only a few books and forty rupees. I arrived in New York City in such a condition, but it was all by the grace of Guru Mahäräja and Kåñëa. Everything happens by the combined mercy of Kåñëa and the spiritual master. In the Caitanya-caritämåta it is stated that the mercy of Kåñëa and guru are combined. This is the secret of the success of this Kåñëa consciousness movement. Kåñëa is always within us, and consequently He knows everything about our purposes, and He gives us the opportunity to work as we decide. If we decide to enjoy this material world, Kåñëa gives us the intelligence to become a very shrewd businessman or a popular politician or a cunning man so that we can earn money and enjoy ourselves. According to the standards of material life, many people are becoming great. They begin as very poor men and soon, by good fortune, become millionaires. We Should not think, however, that they are attaining such success by their own puny endeavors. Without intelligence, no one can improve, and that intelligence is given by Kåñëa. In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa states that He is seated in everyone’s heart as the Supersoul and that by His will a man can remember, and by His will a man can forget. Kåñëa supplies forgetfulness and remembrance according to the living entity’s desire. If we want to forget Kåñëa and enjoy the material world, He will give us the necessary intelligence so that we can forget Him for good.

Many people are thinking, “I can enjoy this material world very nicely. Everyone is having such a good time. There is no reason I can’t enjoy myself as much as they.” This idea is illusion because there is no real enjoyment in the material world. We may rise to a very high position like President Kennedy. We may be very good-looking, very famous, very intelligent, and well educated, very wealthy and very powerful, and we may have a very beautiful wife and children and hold the highest position in the country—but at any moment we are subject to be shot down. This is the nature of the material world: we have to face danger at every step. There is no question of having pleasure without impediments. Even when the pleasures are earned, they are earned after a great deal of struggle and sacrifice, and whatever pleasure may be acquired is temporary, for in the material world there is no pleasure that can give us constant and unending enjoyment. Only Kåñëa can give us that.

Therefore Kåñëa instructs in the Bhagavad-gétä that it is the welfare of every living entity to give up this nonsensical material activity and just surrender unto Him. Unfortunately, in this age people are so attracted by the glitter of material nature, to illusion, or mäyä, that they are not very interested. Kåñëa even declares that if one surrenders unto Him, He will give all protection from all sinful reactions, but still people are so attached that they cannot do it. People always fear that by surrendering to Kåñëa they will lose something, just as I feared losing my family by going to the Western world and preaching. But Kåñëa is so kind that if He takes anything away, He will reward us a thousandfold.

The spiritual master is also kind in that he begs from door to door, country to country, town to town: “My dear ladies and gentlemen, my dear boys and girls, please take to Kåñëa consciousness.” In this way he renders very confidential service to Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord who gives the orders, and the spiritual master executes those orders; therefore the spiritual master is very dear to Kåñëa. Whether Kåñëa sends him to heaven or to hell makes no difference to him. For the spiritual master, a pure devotee, heaven and hell are both the same if there is no Kåñëa consciousness. In hell people are suffering in so many ways, and in heaven they are enjoying their senses in so many ways, but a devotee of the Lord can live any place where there is Kåñëa consciousness, and since he brings this consciousness with him, he is always self-satisfied. If he is sent to hell, he will be satisfied simply chanting Hare Kåñëa. In fact, he does not believe in hell but in Kåñëa. Similarly, if he were put in heaven, where there are so many opportunities for sense gratification, he would also remain aloof, for his senses are satisfied by Kåñëa Himself. Thus for the service of the Lord a devotee is prepared to go anywhere, and for this reason he is very dear to Kåñëa.

Renounced impersonalist philosophers say that this world is false and that the impersonal Brahman is truth. But if they are asked to go out into society where material sense gratification predominates, they will refuse for fear of being affected by those conditions. For a Kåñëa conscious person, however, there is no such difficulty. Because he is controlled and has taken shelter of Kåñëa, he is not afraid of going anywhere.

Consequently, when devotees meet in a place where there is no Kåñëa consciousness, there is no harm, for they take the opportunity to chant Hare Kåñëa and infuse the place with Kåñëa consciousness. This opportunity should always be taken. It is not that one should close himself up in a room and chant alone. The great sage Närada is a spaceman who travels all over the universe. Although he can dwell in the most elevated planets, he sometimes goes to hell and preaches there. That is the beauty of a servant of God—he is always acting out of love for Kåñëa and His parts and parcels.

The underlying principle of devotional service is unalloyed love for Kåñëa. Regardless of the position of a particular devotee—as friend, servant, parent, or lover of Kåñëa—his service is unconditional, for Kåñëa consciousness is not dependent on any material condition. It is transcendental and has nothing to do with the modes of material nature. A devotee is not afraid to go anywhere, and because of this he sees all material conditions as equal. In the world we may say that this is a good place to be and that is a bad place, but, as pointed out before, the devotee is not subject to these mental concoctions. For him the basic principle of material existence is bad, for material existence means forgetfulness of Kåñëa.

In the neutral stage of devotion one may give more importance to the impersonal effulgence of the Lord and to the Supersoul within the heart, but Kåñëa consciousness actually develops when one thinks, “Kåñëa is my very intimate master of intimate relationships.” In the beginning, of course, impersonal realization and realization of the Supersoul are part of Kåñëa consciousness. The partial realization of God in His impersonal aspect or in His aspect as Supersoul enables one to develop veneration for the Lord, but when one has an intimate relationship with Kåñëa as a friend, master, son, or lover, then the veneration disappears.

This platform of personal relationship is certainly higher than the impersonal platform or the platform of Supersoul, or Paramätmä, realization. In the neutral conception, one simply realizes that he and the Absolute Truth are one in quality, or he realizes that he is part and parcel of the Supreme. That is certainly knowledge, for when one develops a personal relationship with Kåñëa as servant, he begins to appreciate the full opulence of the Supreme Lord. One who realizes that God is full in six opulences actually begins rendering service. As soon as one becomes aware of the greatness of Kåñëa and understands Kåñëa’s superiority, his service begins. The awareness of God’s greatness increases when transcendental service is rendered. A person who serves the Lord in order to satisfy the senses of the Lord becomes satisfied, because Kåñëa is the Supersoul and the individual living entity is His part and parcel. If He is satisfied, then the living entity is satisfied. If the stomach is satisfied, then all the parts of the body are satisfied, for they receive nourishment through the stomach. When one of my Godbrothers began to fan my Guru Mahäräja [spiritual master] on a very hot day, Guru Mahäräja asked, “Why are you fanning me all of a sudden?” The boy replied, “Because if you are satisfied, we are all satisfied.” This is the formula—we should not try to satisfy our senses separately, but should try to satisfy Kåñëa’s senses. Then naturally we will become satisfied.

A Kåñëa conscious person is always trying to give satisfaction to Kåñëa, and this is the beginning of Kåñëa consciousness. Because in the impersonal conception there is no form of God, there is no opportunity to satisfy His senses. However, one who sees Kåñëa as master can render service. In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa is referred to as Håñékeça, master of the senses. When it is understood that the Absolute Truth is the master of the senses, that our senses are products of His senses, and that they should therefore be utilized for the satisfaction of His senses, Kåñëa consciousness, which is dormant within everyone, begins to awaken. Once Caitanya Mahäprabhu asked, “What is the difference between the neutral position in relation to Kåñëa and the relationship of master and servant?” In both cases one can understand that Kåñëa is great, but in the neutral position there is no inclination for service. Therefore the master-servant relationship between Kåñëa and the living entity is more elevated. Then when one attains friendship with Kåñëa, another transcendental quality is added. There is the conception that God is great and that service must be rendered unto Him, but there is also an extra feeling: “Kåñëa is my friend. Therefore I must treat Him in such a way that He will be happy.” With a friend we are not simply content with rendering service but in making him actually happy and satisfied. There is also equality in such a relationship, for Kåñëa and the devotee relate on equal terms. Thus devotees in this position actually forget Kåñëa’s superiority. When Kåñëa’s boyfriends used to ride on Kåñëa’s shoulders playing games, they did not think that they were greater than Him. There is no question of sense gratification or self-glorification, for the relationship is based on pure love. The devotee’s only desire is to give pleasure to Kåñëa, and Kåñëa also takes His friends on His shoulders to derive pleasure from them. Sometimes a person simply accepts the fact that his friend will slap his face—but there is no question of inferiority in such an action. When friendship and mutual pleasure are the basis of the relationship, there is no question of insult or inferiority.

The whole basis of Kåñëa consciousness and a relationship with Kåñëa is the pleasure potency of Kåñëa Himself. Çrématé Rädhäräëé, the damsels of Vraja, and Kåñëa’s cowherd boyfriends are all expansions of Kåñëa’s pleasure potency. We all have a tendency toward pleasure, because the source from which we emanate is fully potent in pleasure. Impersonalists cannot think in these terms, for they deny the pleasure potency; therefore the impersonalist philosophy is incomplete and inferior. Those who are in Kåñëa consciousness recognize the pleasure potency in Kåñëa and in all His paraphernalia—His friends, servants, father, mother, and consort. All relationships with Kåñëa that aim at satisfying Kåñëa’s senses are manifestations of Kåñëa’s pleasure potency.

As far as the individual soul is concerned, it is originally a part and parcel of this pleasure potency, of the reservoir of pleasure Himself. However, due to contact with material nature, the soul has forgotten its actual position and has become trapped in the evolutionary process of transmigration from one body to another. Thus one struggles hard for existence. Now we must extricate ourselves from the sufferings of the struggle, from the countless transmigrations that force us to suffer the miseries of birth, old age, disease, and death, and come to the point of our eternal life in Kåñëa consciousness. That eternal life is possible. If one tries his best in this human form of life, in his next life he will get a spiritual body. The spiritual body is already within the gross material body, but it will develop only as soon as one becomes free from the contamination of this material existence. That is the aim of human life and the actual self-interest of all people. Self-interest is actually realizing, “I am part and parcel of God. I have to return to the kingdom of God and join with Him.” Just as we have a social life here, God has a social life in the spiritual kingdom, and we can join Him there. It is not that after finishing this body we become void. In the Bhagavad-gétä [2.12] Kåñëa told Arjuna, “Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings, nor in the future shall any of us cease to be.” Our existence is therefore eternal, and the changes of birth and death are simply the changes of the temporary material bodies.

The actual process for achieving eternal life is not at all difficult. This process of Kåñëa consciousness is based on knowledge received from Kåñëa, the most perfect being. Knowledge received from others is defective because the conditioned soul is certain to commit mistakes, certain to be illusioned, certain to cheat, and certain to have imperfect senses. The knowledge received from Kåñëa, however, actually enables us to see Kåñëa. Someone may challenge, “Can you show me God?” and our answer is, “Yes. God can be seen at every moment.” Kåñëa says, raso ’ham apsu kaunteya: “I am the taste of water.” We drink water every day, and the taste of water is there, so if we think of this taste as Kåñëa, we will have begun realizing God every day. In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa further says, prabhäsmi çaçi-süryayoù: “I am the light of the sun and the moon.” Every day we receive sunlight, and in the evening there is moonshine, so if we think of the source of these emanations, we will ultimately become God conscious. There are so many similar instances given in the Bhagavad-gétä, for Kåñëa is the beginning, middle, and end of all manifestations. If we want to become God conscious and realize our own essence, it is not very difficult. We only have to understand God in truth—how He appears, how He disappears, and what His functions are—then we can become eligible to enter into the kingdom of God. After quitting this material body, a person who understands God, Kåñëa, does not return again to earth to accept another material body. Where does he go? Kåñëa says, mäm eti: “He comes to Me.” That should be the aim of any intelligent human being.

SSR Appendixes

Appendixes

SSR About the Author

About the Author

His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda appeared in this world in 1896 in Calcutta, India. He first met his spiritual master, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Goswami, in Calcutta in 1922. Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta, the foremost scholar and devotee of his time, had founded the Gauòéya Maöha (a Vedic institute with sixty-four branches throughout India). He liked this educated young man and convinced him to dedicate his life to teaching Vedic knowledge. Çréla Prabhupäda became his student, and eleven years later (1933) at Allahabad he became his formally initiated disciple.

At their first meeting, in 1922, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura requested Çréla Prabhupäda to broadcast Vedic knowledge through the English language. In the years that followed, Çréla Prabhupäda wrote a commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä, the most important Vedic text, and he assisted the Gauòéya Maöha in its work. In 1944 he singlehandedly started an English fortnightly magazine called Back to Godhead. He edited and typed the manuscripts, checked the galley proofs, and even distributed the individual copies for free and struggled to maintain the publication.

Recognizing Çréla Prabhupäda’s philosophical learning and devotion, the Gauòéya Vaiñëava Society honored him in 1947 with the title “Bhaktivedanta.” In 1950, at the age of fifty-four, Çréla Prabhupäda retired from family life. Four years later he adopted the vänaprastha (retired) order to devote more time to his studies and writing, and soon he traveled to the holy city of Våndävana. There he lived in a small room in the historic Rädhä-Dämodara temple and engaged in several years of deep study and writing. In 1959 he accepted the renounced order of life (sannyäsa). At Rädhä-Dämodara, Çréla Prabhupäda wrote Easy Journey to Other Planets and started his life’s masterpiece—a multivolume translation of and commentary on the eighteen-thousand-verse Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the cream of the Vedic literatures.

After publishing three volumes of the Bhägavatam, Çréla Prabhupäda came to the United States in 1965 to fulfill the mission of his spiritual master. At that time, His Divine Grace wrote some eighty volumes of authoritative translations, commentaries and summary studies of the philosophical and religious classics of India. When he first arrived by freighter in New York City, Çréla Prabhupäda was practically penniless. But after nearly a year of great difficulty, he founded the International Society for Krishna Consciousness in July of 1966. Before his much-lamented passing on November 14, 1977, he guided the Society and saw it grow to a worldwide confederation of more than one hundred ashrams, schools, temples, institutes and farm communities.

In 1968, Çréla Prabhupäda created New Våndävana, an experimental Vedic community in the hills of West Virginia. Inspired by the success of New Våndävana (now a thriving farm community of more than one thousand acres) his students have since founded several similar communities in the United States and abroad.

In 1975, Çréla Prabhupäda’s magnificent Kåñëa-Balaräma Temple and International Guesthouse opened in Våndävana, India. In 1978 a four-acre cultural complex (including a temple, modern theatre, guesthouse, and vegetarian restaurant) opened at Juhu Beach, in Bombay. Perhaps Çréla Prabhupäda’s most ambitious project is a planned city of fifty thousand residents in Mäyäpur, West Bengal. Çrédhäma Mäyäpur will stand as a model for the whole world—a microcosm of Vedic life as it was five thousand years ago.

In addition, Çréla Prabhupäda gave the West the Vedic system of primary and secondary education. The gurukula (“the school of the spiritual master”) started only in 1972, but already it has hundreds of students and many branches around the world.

Çréla Prabhupäda’s most significant contribution, of course, is his books. The academic community respects them for their authoritativeness, depth and clarity, and has made them standard textbooks in numerous college courses. In addition, translations of Çréla Prabhupäda’s books now appear in twenty-five languages. The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, established in 1972 to publish the works of His Divine Grace, has thus become the world’s largest publisher of books in the field of Indian religion and philosophy. A recent project has been the publishing of a seventeen-volume translation and commentary—which Çréla Prabhupäda completed in only eighteen months—on the Bengali religious classic Çré Caitanya-caritämåta. In just twelve years, in spite of his advanced age, Çréla Prabhupäda circled the globe fourteen times on lecture tours that took him to six continents. In spite of such a vigorous schedule, Çréla Prabhupäda continued to write prolifically. His writings constitute a veritable library of Vedic philosophy, religion, literature and culture.

SSR Glossary

Glossary

SSR Guide to Sanskrit Pronunciation

Guide to Sanskrit Pronunciation

Dialectic Spiritualism (1985)


DIALECTIC SPIRITUALISM

A VEDIC VIEW OF WESTERN PHILOSOPHY

HIS DIVINE GRACE A. C. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI PRABHUPÄDA

Back cover:

From 1973 to 1976, His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Svämé Prabhupäda recorded a hundred hours of discourses on thirty-six western philosopher's from Socrates to Sartre. At the final session, he gave the book its title and said, "Print it at once!"

But the next year, Çréla Prabhupäda left this mortal world, and the manuscript remained unpublished, as some of his disciples feared releasing such a controversial book. "It's an unscholarly punch in the nose," one philosophy professor object. "It's a treatise against philosophy," said another.

Now everyone can decide for himself. Despite attempts at suppression, here is Çréla Prabhupäda's last great opus—Dialectic Spiritualism, the complete and unexposed philosophy book as Çréla Prabhupäda himself spoke.

BOOKS by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

Srémad Bhägavatam, cantos 1-10 (29 vols.)

Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 vols.)

Sré Caitanya-caritämrta (17 vols.)

Teachings of Lord Caitanya

The Nectar of Devotion (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu)

The Nectar of Instruction

Sré Içopaniñad

Easy Journey to Other Planets

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System

Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead (3 vols.)

Perfect Questions, Perfect Answers

Teachings of Lord Kapila, the Son of Devahüti

Transcendental Teachings of Prahläda Mahäraja

Teachings of Queen Kunté

Kåñëa, the Reservior of Pleasure

The Science of Self-Realization

The Path of Perfection

Life Comes From Life

The Perfection of Yoga

Beyond Birth and Death

On the Way to Kåñëa

Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge

Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Matchless Gift

Back to Godhead magazine (founder)


A complete catalog is available upon request.


New Vrindaban Community

RD l, Box 319
Moundsville, W.Va. 26041


Readers interested in the subject matter of this book are invited to visit the
New Vrindaban Community, Home of Prabhupäda's Palace of Gold, Hare
Kåñëa Ridge, Moundsville, W.Va., or to correspond with the Secretary.

c/o New Vrindaban
RD 1, Box 319
Moundsville, W.Va. 26041

First Printing: 50,000 copies

1985 Prabhupäda Books

Printed in Singapore

Library of Congress Calalog Card No. 85-090424
International Standard Book Number: 0-932215-02-5

DS:Forward

FOREWORD
by
His Divine Grace Kértanänanda Swami Bhaktipäda

The idea for this book first emerged in 1973, when Çréla Prabhupäda began asking his secretary, Çyämasundara däsa adhikäré (Sam Speerstra), about Western philosophy. Çyämasundara would try to state succinctly the major ideas of certain philosophers, and Prabhupäda would give the Vedic view. As Prabhupäda traveled throughout the world preaching Kåñëa consciousness, this process continued, until finally, in 1976, Prabhupäda's editor, Hayagréva däsa adhikäré (Professor Howard Wheeler), supplied further questions for Prabhupäda and completed the editing. Then Çréla Prabhupäda gave the book its title: Dialectic Spiritualism: A Vedic View of Western Philosophy, and said, "Print it."

Almost immediately some people objected that since professional scholars had not presented the material to Çréla Prabhupäda, there might be some discrepancies. When the manuscript was shown to a philosophy professor, he called it "a treatise against philosophy," and "an unscholarly punch in the nose." Then, when Çréla Prabhupäda left this mortal world in November, 1977, the book's future became uncertain. One student tried to restate the questions. Then another tried, only to conclude that it would be better to start all over. But Çréla Prabhupäda was no longer present, and the extensive work, on which he had spent so much time, remained unavailable to the world. Finally, in 1984, Hayagréva resolved to print Çréla Prabhupäda's last great opus as it is, and for this we are all greatly indebted.

Whatever the criticisms, they are rendered insignificant in the light of Çréla Prabhupäda's brilliant insights into the problems of Western philosophy and his lucid expositories of the Vedic view. Much of the confusion arises from a difference in methodology and perspective. For many Westerners, philosophy is a kind of armchair speculation, an intellectual game, but for the follower of the Vedas, it is a matter of life and death. Or, more precisely, it is the recognition of the absolute need to stop the repetition of birth and death. For Çréla Prabhupäda, real philosophy deals with applying Absolute Knowledge in our daily lives, consciously, moment by moment. "We should act in such a way that we have to think of Kåñëa all the time," he said. "For instance, we are discussing the philosophy of Socrates in order to strengthen our Kåñëa consciousness. Therefore the ultimate goal is Kåñëa. Otherwise we are not interested in criticizing or accepting anyone's philosophy. We are neutral."

Obviously, this is not the goal of Western philosophy, which tends to see man as "the measure of all things" in a physical, humanistic universe. Western thought has always encouraged self-reliance and individualism, which are reflected even in today's street philosophy: "Do your own thing."

The Vedic view clashes fiercely with such relativistic thinking. Far from celebrating the authority of the individual mind, or the autonomy and ascendence of reason, the Vedas point out the four fundamental defects of conditioned souls. Çréla Prabhupäda made this point clear:

Of course, in European philosophy there is an attempt at more independent thought, but such independent thinking is not approved by the followers of the Vedas. The Vedic followers receive knowledge directly from authorities. They do not peculate. We cannot attain knowledge through speculation because everyone is imperfect .... According to the Vedic system, we receive knowledge from Vyäsadeva, Närada, and Çré Kåñëa Himself. This knowledge is perfect because these personalities are not subjected to the four defects of all conditioned living entities: the tendency to commit mistakes, to be illusioned, to have imperfect senses, and to cheat. ... We therefore have to receive knowledge from those who are liberated. This is the Vedic process. If we receive knowledge from Kåñëa, there cannot be any mistake, nor any question of illusion. Our senses may be imperfect, but Kåñëa's senses are perfect; therefore whatever Kåñëa says, we accept, and that acceptance is our perfection.

With these defects, a conditioned human being, cannot possibly present perfect knowledge. Therefore he is reduced to wrangling. As Çréla Prabhupäda often observed, "Being a big philosopher, a muni, means refuting the theories of others and setting up your own conclusions as supreme." There is no end to this process, nor is there perfection. "It is said that a philosopher is not a philosopher unless he differs from other philosophers," Çréla Prabhupäda said when discussing Descartes. "If one is to be a great philosopher, he has to defy all his predecessors. Scientists also work in the same way. If we try to find out whose statement is true, we have a great deal of difficulty. Therefore the Vedic çästras enjoin that we follow the personalities who have realized God ... If we follow the äcäryas in the disciplic succession, our path is clear."

Perfect knowledge can come only from a perfect source, the reservoir of knowledge, God Himself. Such knowledge is imparted by the Supreme and comes down by the paramparä process, the line of true disciplic succession, from one realized soul to another.

Çréla Prabhupäda explains the Vedic method in this way:

Every word we hear has a meaning behind it. As soon as we hear the word "water," there is a substance—water—behind the word. Similarly, as soon as we hear the word "God," there is a meaning to it. If we receive that meaning and explanation of "God" from God Himself, then it is perfect. But if we speculate about the meaning of "God," it is imperfect. Bhagavad-gétä, which is the science of God, is spoken by the Personality of Godhead Himself. This is perfect knowledge. Mental speculators, or so-called philosophers who are researching for what is actually God, will never understand the nature of God. The science of God has to be understood in disciplic succession from Brahmä, who was first instructed about knowledge of God from God Himself. (Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Purport, 3.26.33)

This does not mean, however, that the human mind is reduced to that of a robot. The mind is useful for acceptance and rejection, and one's intelligence is measured by his power of discrimination. But in the presence of the Supreme Absolute Truth, nothing is to be rejected, and discrimination has no meaning. Therefore perfect knowledge must be accepted from a perfect source. Still, history shows that thought is dynamic and progressive, and the great reformers—Välméki, Vyäsadeva, Socrates, Jesus, Mohammed, and Caitanya Mahäprabhu—all declare, directly or indirectly, that they have come not to destroy the Law of God, but to fulfill it such great souls are not content to accept something simply because it is handed down by tradition. Indeed, tradition has often proved untrustworthy, for in the course of time, and influenced by common men, its purity is lost. "This supreme science was thus received through the chain, of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way," Lord Kåñëa tells Arjuna. "But in course of time, the succession was broken, and therefore the science as it is appears to be lost." (Bg. 4.2) For this reason, Lord Kåñëa again spoke Bhagavad-gétä, reestablishing the true disciplic succession (paramparä).

Some have charged that this approach is more theosophic than philosophic. But why arbitrarily force an either/or situation? Kåñëa consciousness is the happy marriage of theology and philosophy. As Çréla Prabhupäda often said, "Religion without philosophy is sentimental and therefore fanatical; and philosophy without religion is mental speculation." However, the rejection of mental speculation does not extend to sincere philosophical speculation, which is a legitimate activity of the mind. The difference is like that between pure, fresh milk and milk contaminated by the poisonous fangs of a serpent. Philosophical speculation is the attempt to understand the Lord and His energies by using all the faculties which God has so kindly given us, whereas mental speculation is the proud attempt to use those faculties, which rightly belong to the Lord, against the Lord. Philosophical speculation leads to greater and greater awareness and appreciation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, whereas mental speculation always comes to the atheistic conclusion of the voidists: God is void and we are void, therefore let us eat, drink, and be merry, for tomorrow we die.

For example, trying to understand how the Supreme Personality of Godhead enters into the creation, maintains it, and destroys it, is proper philosophical speculation. In this sincere attempt, the previous äcäryas and the holy scriptures can guide us. But trying to figure out the origin of everything solely by the power of the tiny human brain, without referring to God or His representatives (guru-sädhu-çästra), is useless mental speculation. We may speculate in this fashion for billions of years and still not arrive at the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who lies beyond the purview of finite thought.

It is precisely on this point of the centrality of the Personality of Godhead that the Vedic observer differs radically from his Western counterpart. Both Eastern and Western philosophy wrestle with the same problems: birth, death, reincarnation, liberation, the nature of God and the soul, the creation, good and evil, human responsibility, free will, karma, material vs. spiritual, and so on. By and large, We tern thinkers are pantheistic and impersonalistic. Even great theist like Aquinas and Augustine have ultimately considered the personal aspect to be a manifestation of the impersonal principle. The impersonalism of Plato and Aristotle are indeed deeply engrained in Western thought. This is not some strange coincidence, but the result of a basic difference in methodology. Only when a sincere devotee surrenders to God does God agree to reveal Himself. "One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service," Lord Kåñëa says (Bg. 18.55). Surrender to God is a prerequisite for knowing God. Çréla Prabhupäda often remarked that when we speak of surrender, we necessarily predicate a person. According to the Vedas, the attributes and nature of that person can be known only through the person Himself. There is no room for imagination, myth, human reasoning, speculation, anthropomorphism, or whatever. In knowledge of the Personality of Godhead, Western philosophy has proved sadly deficient, as Carl Jung observed:

Hayagréva däsa: Seeing that philosophies and theologies could not give him a clear picture of God's personality, Jung concludes: "What is wrong with these philosophers? I wondered. Evidently they know of God only by hearsay."
Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is also our complaint. None of the philosophers we have discussed has given us any clear idea of God. Because they are speculating, they cannot give concrete, clear information. As far as we are concerned, our understanding of God is clear because we receive the information given by God Himself to the world.

In Western philosophy, personalism is an unknown territory, approached only in Socrates's instructions from Diotima in The Symposium, wherein Socrates was enjoined to contemplate and converse with beauty absolute, beauty simple, divine, true, unpolluted, real and wondrous. It is the same territory before which Jung stood longing for a guru. It is the borderline of the finite individual soul awaiting revelation. Personalism necessitates revelation, for the Supreme Personality of Godhead can be affirmed only by the personal descent of the Divine.

Dialectic Spiritualism should not be seen as an academic attempt at comparative philosophy, but as a devotee's informal, spontaneous response to various Western philosophers. Each philosopher is viewed in his own existential loneliness, without reference to historical influences. Each face the eternal Vedas alone. Sometimes we may imagine the court of the Last Judgement. By his own words, each man stands praised or condemned. There is no consideration for personality, no allowance for time or place. For the academician bent on the historicity of a thought, this doubtlessly seems unfair and arbitrary, but it is typically Vedic. Our thoughts and deeds are fixed in eternal time. We are responsible for even our most random, idle, or uncharacteristic statements.

Far from being detrimental, Çréla Prabhupäda's unfamiliarity with formal Western philosophy evoked the most genuine and candid responses. Of all the philosophers, he agreed most with Socrates, whom he considered Brahman realized. He often quoted Socrates's answer to the question of what should be done with him after his death: "Well, you have to catch me first. But as for my body, you can dispose of that as you like." Still, Prabhupäda considered Socrates an impersonalist because he had no specific information of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, despite his speaking of the form of Absolute Beauty. Plato, being Socrate's disciple, also ranked high in Prabhupäda's Vedic eyes, particularly for his view of the soul and reincarnation. But Prabhupäda disagreed with his recommendation of uniform education and universal military training.

Aristotle was severely criticized for his view that the souls of animals are not immortal. There are not two types of souls, mortal and immortal, as Aristotle contends. This pernicious doctrine was carried even further by Augustine, who argued that since animals do not possess an immortal soul, "they are meant for our use, dead or alive. It only remains for us to apply the commandment, 'Thou shalt not kill' to man alone, oneself and others." Strange words from a so-called saint! Unfortunately, this became the standard Christian doctrine: since animals have no souls, it is all right to kill and eat them.

Çréla Prabhupäda felt that Plotinus, following Plato's footsteps, presented a basically sound philosophy of the soul, particularly of the jévätmä's relation with the One, but, of course, Plotinus's "One" was impersonal. Prabhupäda disagreed with Origen's theory that souls are created. If they are created, how can they be immortal? "Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings," Kåñëa tells Arjuna. "Nor in the future shall any of us cease to be." (Bg. 2.12) The theory of the creation of a "human soul" at the moment of conception was also accepted by Aquinas, and thus became official Catholic doctrine. The belief that each individual human soul is created at a point in time, lives his life, and thereafter is saved or damned eternally, excludes the possibility of reincarnation.

By denying reincarnation, Augustine and Aquinas broke with the Platonic tradition, and made it difficult for subsequent philosophers to understand evil in the world. If there is no transmigration of souls, where is Divine Justice? How can we account for fortune and misfortune? Why is one man pious, knowledgeable, beautiful, or opulent, and an other man impious, ignorant, deformed, or poor? Why, on the basis of one finite lifetime, is one man eternally saved and another eternally damned? Why is God so arbitrary, so unmerciful? Having rejected the possibilities of transmigration and karma, Western philosophers have been troubled all the way down to Mill, Dewey, and Sartre. Because evil exists, they argue, either God's power is limited, or He is not all good, or He does not exist at all.

In their confrontation with the Vedic version, some of the philosophers scored high, some low, some in between. Ranking high as first-class philosophers were Socrates, Plato, Plotinus, Origen, Scotus, Descartes, Pascal, and Bergson. Çréla Prabhupäda also liked the psychologist Carl Jung ("He seems the most sensible."). After these, ranked Aquinas, Locke, Berkeley, Spinoza, Leibnitz, Kant, Schopenhauer, Alexander, Nietzsche, James, and Kierkegaard. In low regard, for various reasons, were Aristotle, Augustine, Fichte, Bacon, and Huxley. Conflicting most with Vedic thought were Machiavelli, Hume, Hegel, Hobbes, Darwin, Mill, Comte, Marx, Dewey, Sartre, and Freud.

Ultimately, no Western philosopher can measure up to the high standard of the Vedic ideal. In contrast, Çréla Prabhupäda emerges as the emissary of a higher source, for he is Lord Kåñëa's pure devotee. It is not as though he alone were speaking; rather, an unbroken line of disciplic succession speaks through him, delivering the pure knowledge of the Vedas intact. When he called the book "A Vedic view of Western philosophy," Çréla Prabhupäda humbly said, "Yes, Vedic view. After all, what is my personal view worth?"

Although Dialectic Spiritualism marks a clashing of different knowledge-acquiring processes, the inductive and deductive, we reach the mutual understanding that arises from all fruitful confrontations: a clarification of positions, from which points of agreement and contention can be discerned. Thus the book is valuable to students of all schools of philosophy and theology. If the reader chooses to accept Çréla Prabhupäda's conclusion that God has manifested Himself in sound (çabdävatära)—that is, in the Vedas, of which Bhagavad-gétä is the essence—he will have a standard by which every thought can be judged. Viewed thus, the book takes on new and profound perspectives. It is Dialectic Spiritualism read in the spirit of the dialectic itself.

DS:Preface

Preface

idaàhi puàsas tapasaùçrutasya vä
sviñöasya süktasya ca buddhi-dattayoù
avicyuto 'rthaù kavibhir nirüpito
yad-uttamaçloka-guëänuvarëanam

TRANSLATION

Learned sages have definitely concluded that the infallible fruit of knowledge, austerity, Vedic study, sacrifice, the chanting of hymns, and charity is found in the transcendental descriptions of the qualities of the Lord, who is defined in choice poetry. (Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.5.22)

PURPORT

The human intellect is developed for advancement in art, science, philosophy, physics, chemistry, psychology, economics, politics, and other fields. Through the culture of knowledge, humanity can attain the perfection of life, which culminates in the realization of the Supreme Being, Viñëu. The çruti therefore advises the learned to aspire for the service of Lord Viñëu. Unfortunately, when people are enamored by the external beauty of viñëu-mäyä, they do not understand that perfection, or self-realization, depends on Viñëu. Viñëu-mäyä means sense enjoyment, which is transient and miserable. Those who are entrapped by viñëu-mäyä utilize their knowledge for sense enjoyment. Çré Närada Muni, however, has explained that all phenomena in the universe emanate from the Lord because the Lord, through His inconceivable energies, has set in motion the actions and reactions of the creation. Everything has come into being out of His energy; everything rests on His energy, and after annihilation, everything merges into Him. Therefore nothing is different from the Lord, although the Lord is always different from His creation.

When knowledge is applied in the service of the Lord, the process of advancement becomes absolute. The Supreme Personality of Godhead and His transcendental name, fame, and glory are all nondifferent from Him; therefore all sages and devotees of the Lord have recommended that art, science, philosophy, physics, chemistry, psychology, and other branches of knowledge be wholly and solely applied in the Lord's service. Art, literature, poetry, and music may be used in glorifying the Lord. Poets and other celebrated litterateurs are generally engaged in writing of sensuous themes, but if they turn toward the service of the Lord, they can describe the Lord's transcendental pastimes. Välméki was a great poet, and Vyäsadeva was a great writer, and both completely engaged themselves in delineating the transcendental activities of the Lord, and by so doing, they have become immortal. Similarly, science and philosophy should also be applied in the service of the Lord. Advanced people are eager to understand the Absolute Truth through the medium of science, and therefore scientists should endeavor to prove the Lord's existence on a scientific basis. Philosophy should also aim to establish the Supreme Truth as sentient and all-powerful. Indeed, all other branches of knowledge should similarly be engaged in the Lord's service. This is also affirmed by Bhagavad-gétä. All knowledge not engaged in the Lord's service is but nescience. Advanced knowledge should be utilized to establish the glories of the Lord, and that is the real import of this verse. Scientific knowledge and other branches of knowledge engaged in the Lord's service are all factually hari-kértana, glorification of the Lord.

ITHE GREEK FOUNDATION

ITHE GREEK FOUNDATION

DS:Socrates (470?-399 B.C.)

Socrates (470?-399 B.C.)

Hayagréva däsa: When a student of Socrates once said, "I cannot refute you, Socrates," Socrates replied, "Say, rather, that you cannot refute the truth, for Socrates is easily refuted." He thus considered the Absolute Truth transcendental to mental speculation and personal opinion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct. If we accept Kåñëa, God, as the supreme authority, the Absolute Truth, we cannot refute what He says. Kåñëa, or God, is by definition supreme perfection, and philosophy is perfect when it is in harmony with Him. This is our position. The philosophy of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is religious because it is concerned with carrying out the orders of God. That is the sum and substance of religion. It is not possible to manufacture a religion. In Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, manufactured religion is called dharma-kaitava, just another form of cheating. Our basic principle is given in Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

dharmaà tu säkñäd bhagavat-praëétaà
na vai vidur åñayo näpi deväù
na siddha-mukhyä asurä manuñyäù
kuto nu vidyädhara-cäraëädayaù

“Real religious principles are enacted by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Although fully situated in the mode of goodness, even the great åñis who occupy the topmost planets cannot ascertain the real religious principles, nor can the demigods, nor the leaders of Siddha-loka, to say nothing of the asuras, ordinary human beings, Vidyädharas and Cäraëas." (Bhäg. 6.3.19) The word "dharma" refers to the orders given by God, and if we follow those orders, we are following dharma. An individual citizen cannot manufacture laws, because laws are given by the government. Our perfection is in following the orders of God cent per cent. Those who have no conception of God or His orders may manufacture religious systems, but our system is different.

Çyämasundara däsa: It seems that Socrates was more or less a dhyäna-yogé because he thought that we could arrive at the truth by approaching a subject from every mental angle until there was nothing left but the truth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He was a muni, a great thinker. However, the real truth comes to such a muni by that process after many, many births. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmäsudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19)

These people are known as jïänavän, wise men, and after many births, they surrender themselves to Kåñëa. They do not do so blindly, but knowing that the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the source of everything. However, this process of self-searching for knowledge takes time. If we take the instructions of Kåñëa directly and surrender unto Him, we save time and many, many births.

Çyämasundara däsa: Socrates believed that the soul, which is tied up with intelligence, carries knowledge from existence to existence. The truth can be evoked through the maieutic method, the Socratic dialectic. Since someone can make us understand the truth and admit it, we must have known the truth in a previous existence. Thus our intelligence is eternal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, because the soul is eternal, the intelligence, mind, and senses are also eternal. However, they are all now covered by a material coating, which must be cleansed. Once this material coating is washed away, the real mind, intelligence, and senses will emerge. That is stated in the Närada-païcarätra: tat paratvena nirmalam. The purificatory process necessitates being in touch with the transcendental loving service of the Lord. This means chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. Caitanya Mahäprabhu said: ceto-darpaëa-märjanam (Çikñäñöaka 1). "We must cleanse the heart." All misconceptions come from misunderstanding. We are all part and parcel of God, yet somehow or other we have forgotten this. Previously, our service was rendered to God, but now we are rendering service to something illusory. This is mäyä. Whether liberated or conditioned, our constitutional position is to render service. In the material world, we work according to our different capacities—as a politician, an industrialist, a thinker, a poet, or whatever. But if we are not connected with Kåñëa, all of this is mäyä. When we perform our duty in order to develop Kåñëa consciousness, our very same duty enables liberation from this bondage. In any case, both life and knowledge are continuous. Consequently, one person can acquire knowledge very quickly, whereas another cannot. This is proof of continuity.

Çyämasundara däsa: In a dialogue with Socrates, Protagoras said, "Truth is relative. It is only a matter of opinion." Socrates then asked, "Do you mean that truth is mere subjective opinion?" Protagoras replied, "Exactly. What is true for you is true for you, and what is true for me is true for me. Thus truth is subjective." Socrates then asked, "Do you really mean that my opinion is true by virtue of its being my opinion?" Protagoras said, "Indeed I do." Socrates then said, "My opinion is that truth is absolute, not subjective, and that you, Protagoras, are absolutely in error. Since this is my opinion, you must grant that it is true according to your philosophy." Protagoras then admitted, "You are quite correct, Socrates." Through this kind of dialogue, or dialectic, Socrates would logically convince many people.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is what we are also doing. The Absolute Truth is true for everyone, and the relative truth is relative to a particular position. The relative truth depends on the Absolute Truth, which is the summum bonum. God is the Absolute Truth, and the material world is relative truth. Because the material world is God's energy, it appears to be real or true, just as the reflection of the sun in water emits some light. That reflection is not absolute, and as soon as the sun sets, that light will disappear. Since relative truth is a reflection of the Absolute Truth, Çrémad-Bhägavatam states: satyaà paraà dhémahi, "I worship the Absolute Truth." (Bhäg. 1.1.1) The Absolute Truth is Kåñëa, Väsudeva. Oà namo bhagavate väsudeväya. This cosmic manifestation is relative truth; it is a manifestation of Kåñëa's external energy. If Kåñëa withdrew His energy, the universal creation would not exist. In another sense, Kåñëa and Kåñëa's energy are not different. We cannot separate heat from fire; heat is also fire, yet heat is not fire. This is the position of relative truth. As soon as we experience heat, we understand that there is fire. Yet we cannot say that heat is fire. Relative truth is like heat because it stands on the strength of the Absolute Truth, just as heat stands on the strength of fire. Because the Absolute is true, relative truth also appears to be true, although it has no independent existence. A mirage appears to be water because in actuality there is such a thing as water. Similarly, this material world appears attractive because there is an all-attractive spiritual world.

Hayagréva däsa: According to Socrates, the real pursuit of man is the search for the Absolute Good. Basically, Socrates is an impersonalist because he does not ultimately define this Absolute Good as a person, nor does he give it a personal name.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is the preliminary stage of understanding the Absolute, known as Brahman realization, realization of the impersonal feature. When one is further advanced, he attains Paramätmä realization, realization of the localized feature, whereby he realizes that God is everywhere. It is a fact that God is everywhere, but at the same time God has His own abode. Goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhütaù (Brahma-saàhitä 5.37). God is a person, and He has His own abode and associates. Although He is in His abode, He is present everywhere, within every atom. Aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-stham (Brahma-saàhitä 5.35). Like other impersonalists, Socrates cannot understand how God, through His potency, can remain in His own abode and simultaneously be present in every atom. The material world is His expansion, His energy.

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

"Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego—all together these eight constitute My separated material energies." (Bg. 7.4) Because His energy is expanded everywhere, He can be present everywhere. Although the energy and the energetic are nondifferent, we cannot say that they are not distinct. They are simultaneously one and different. This is the perfect philosophy of acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva.

Hayagréva däsa: The Good of which Socrates speaks is different from sattva-guëa. In The Republic, Socrates says that it is the Good which gives truth to the objects of knowledge and the very power of knowing to him who knows them. He speaks of the Form of essential goodness as the cause of knowledge and truth. Although we may consider the Good to be an object of knowledge, it would be better if we regarded it as being beyond truth and knowledge and of higher value. Both knowledge and truth are therefore to be regarded as like unto the Good, but it is incorrect to identify either with the Good. He believes that the Good must hold a higher place of honor. Objects of knowledge derive their very being and reality from the Good, which is beyond being itself and surpasses it in dignity and power.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sattva-guëa, the mode of goodness, is a position from which we can receive knowledge. Knowledge cannot be received from the platform of passion and ignorance. If we hear about Kåñëa, or God, we are gradually freed from the clutches of darkness and passion. Then we can come to the platform of sattva-guëa, and when we are perfectly situated there, we are beyond the lower modes. Çrémad-Bhägavatam says:

nañöa-präyeñv abhadreñu
nityaà bhägavata-sevayä
bhagavaty uttama-çloke
bhaktir bhavati naiñöhiké

tadä rajas-tamo-bhäväù
käma-lobhädayaç ca ye
ceta etair anäviddhaà
sthitaà sattve prasédati

"By regularly hearing the Bhägavatam and rendering service unto the pure devotee, all that is troublesome to the heart is practically destroyed, and loving service unto the glorious Lord, who is praised with transcendental songs, is established as an irrevocable fact. At the time loving service is established in the heart, the modes of passion (rajas), and ignorance (tamas), and lust and desire (käma), disappear from the heart. Then the devotee is established in goodness, and he becomes happy." (Bhäg. 1.2.18-19)

This process may be gradual, but it is certain. The more we hear about Kåñëa, the more we become purified. Purification means freedom from the attacks of greed and passion. Then we can become happy. From the brahma-bhüta platform, we can realize ourselves and then realize God. So before realizing the Supreme Good, we must first come to the platform of sattva-guëa, goodness. Therefore we have regulations prohibiting illicit sex, meat eating, intoxication, and gambling. Ultimately, we must transcend even the mode of goodness through bhakti. Then we become liberated, gradually develop love of God, and regain our original state.

nirodho 'syänuçayanam
ätmanaù saha çaktibhiù
muktir hitvänyathä rüpaà
sva-rüpeëa vyavasthitiù

"When the living entity, along with his conditional living tendency, merges with the mystic lying down of the Mahä-viñëu, it is called the winding up of the cosmic manifestation. Liberation is the permanent situation of the form of the living entity after giving up the changeable material gross and subtle bodies." (Bhäg. 2.10.6) This means giving up all material engagements and rendering full service to Kåñëa. Then we attain the state where mäyä cannot touch us. If we keep in touch with Kåñëa, mäyä has no jurisdiction.

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14) This is perfection.

Hayagréva däsa: Socrates taught a process of liberation comparable to that of dhyäna-yoga. For him, liberation meant freedom from passion, and he approved the saying gnothi seauton—"Know thyself." By knowing ourselves through meditation, or insight, we can gain self-control, and by being self-controlled, we can attain happiness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact. Meditation means analyzing the self and searching for the Absolute Truth. That is described in the Vedic literatures: dhyänävasthita-tad-gatena manasä paçyanti yaà yoginaù (Bhäg. 12.13.1). Through meditation, the yogé sees the Supreme Truth (Kåñëa, or God) within himself. Kåñëa is there. The yogé consults with Kåñëa, and Kåñëa advises him. That is the relationship Kåñëa has with the yogé. Buddhi-yogaà dadämyaham. When one is purified, he is always seeing Kåñëa within himself. This is confirmed in Brahma-saàhitä:

premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena
santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti
yaàçyämasundaram acintya-guëa-svarüpaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship the primeval Lord, Govinda, who is always seen by the devotee whose eyes are anointed with the pulp of love. He is seen in His eternal form of Çyämasundara situated within the heart of the devotee." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.38) Thus an advanced saintly person is always seeing Kåñëa. In this verse, the word syäma means "blackish," but at the same time extraordinarily beautiful. The word acintya means that He has unlimited qualities. Although He is situated everywhere, as Govinda He is always dancing in Våndävana with the gopés. In Våndävana, Kåñëa plays with His friends, and sometimes, acting as a naughty boy, teases His mother. These pastimes of the Supreme Person are described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

Çyämasundara däsa: As far as we know, Socrates was a self-taught man. Is it possible for a person to be self-taught? That is, can self-knowledge be attained through meditation, or introspection?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Ordinarily, everyone thinks according to the bodily conception. If I begin to study the different parts of my body and seriously begin to consider what I am, I will gradually arrive at the study of the soul. If I ask myself, "Am I this hand?" the answer will be, "No, I am not this hand. Rather, this is my hand." I can thus continue analyzing each part of the body and discover that all the parts are mine but that I am different. Through this method of self-study, any intelligent man can see that he is not the body. This is the first lesson of Bhagavad-gétä:

dehino 'smin yathä dehe
kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä
tathä dehäntara-präptir
dhéras tatra na muhyati

"As the embodied soul continually passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. The self-realized soul is not bewildered by such a change." (Bg. 2.13)

At one time I had the body of a child, but now that body is no longer existing. Still, I am aware that I possessed such a body; therefore from this I can deduce that I am something other than the body. I may rent an apartment, but I do not identify with it. The body may be mine, but I am not the body. By this kind of introspection, a man can teach himself the distinction between the body and the soul.

As far as being completely self-taught—according to Bhagavad-gétä and the Vedic conception, life is continuous. Since we are always acquiring experience, we cannot say that Socrates was self-taught. Rather, in his previous lives he cultivated knowledge, and this knowledge is continuing. That is a fact. Otherwise, why is one man intelligent and another man ignorant? This is due to continuity.

Hayagréva däsa: Socrates believed that through meditation, a person can attain knowledge, and through knowledge he can become virtuous. When he is virtuous, he acts in the right way, and by so doing, becomes happy. Therefore the enlightened man is meditative, knowledgeable, and virtuous. He is also happy because he acts properly.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä:

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments nor desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state he attains pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54) When one is self-realized, he immediately becomes happy, joyful (prasannätmä). This is because he is properly situated. A person may labor a long time under some mistaken idea, but when he finally comes to the proper conclusion, he becomes very happy. He thinks, "Oh, what a fool I was, going on so long in such a mistaken way." Thus a self-realized person is happy. Happiness means that you no longer have to think of attaining things. For instance, Dhruva Mahäräja told the Lord: Svämin kåtärtho 'smi. "I don't want any material benediction." Prahlada Mahäräja also said, "My Lord, I don't want any material benefits. I have seen my father, who was such a big materialist that even the demigods were afraid of him, destroyed by You within a second. Therefore I am not after these things." Real knowledge means that you no longer hanker. The karmés, jïänés, and yogés are all hankering after something. The karmés want material wealth, beautiful women and good positions. If one is not hankering for what one does not have, he is lamenting for what he has lost. The jïänés are also hankering, expecting to become one with God and merge into His existence. The yogés are hankering after some magical powers to befool others into thinking that they have become God. In India, some yogés convince people that they can manufacture gold and fly in the sky, and foolish people believe them. Even if a yogé can fly, there are many birds flying. What is the difference? An intelligent person can understand this. If a person says that he can walk on water, thousands of fools will come to see him. People will even pay ten rupees just to see a man bark like a dog, not thinking that there are many dogs barking anyway. In any case, people are always hankering and lamenting, but the devotee is fully satisfied in the service of the Lord. The devotee doesn't hanker for anything, nor does he lament.

Hayagréva däsa: Through jïäna, the path of meditation, it seems that Socrates realized Brahman. Could he also have realized Paramätmä?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Hayagréva däsa: But what of the realization of Bhagävan, Kåñëa? I thought that Kåñëa can be realized only through bhakti.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, no one can enter into Kåñëa's abode without being a purified bhakta. That is stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti
yävän yaç cäsmi tattvataù
tato mäà tattvato jïätvä
viçate tad-anantaram

"One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service. And when one is in full consciousness of the Supreme Lord by such devotion, he can enter into the kingdom of God." (Bg. 18.55) Kåñëa never says that He can be understood by jïäna, karma, or yoga. The personal abode of Kåñëa is especially reserved for the bhaktas, and the jïänés, yogés, and karmés cannot go there.

Çyämasundara däsa: When you say that Kåñëa consciousness is the ultimate goal of life, does this mean always being conscious of Kåñëa?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we should always be thinking of Kåñëa. We should act in such a way that we have to think of Kåñëa all the time. For instance, we are discussing the philosophy of Socrates in order to strengthen our Kåñëa consciousness. Therefore the ultimate goal is Kåñëa. Otherwise, we are not interested in criticizing or accepting anyone's philosophy. We are neutral.

Çyämasundara däsa: So the proper use of intelligence is to guide everything in such a way that we become Kåñëa conscious?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is it. Without Kåñëa consciousness, we remain on the mental platform. Being on the mental platform means hovering. On that platform, we are not fixed. It is the business of the mind to accept this and reject that, but when we are fixed in Kåñëa consciousness, we are no longer subjected to the mind's accepting and rejecting.

Çyämasundara däsa: Right conduct then becomes automatic?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. As soon as the mind wanders, we should immediately drag it back to concentrate on Kåñëa. While chanting, our mind sometimes wanders far away, but when we become conscious of this, we should immediately bring the mind back to hear the sound vibration of Hare Kåñëa. That is called yoga-abhyäs, the practice of yoga. We should not allow the mind to wander elsewhere. We should simply chant and hear. That is the best yoga system.

Hayagréva däsa: In addition to believing in the value of insight, or meditation, Socrates also believed that knowledge can be imparted from one person to another. He therefore asserted the importance of a guru, which he himself was for many people. Sometimes, posing as an ignorant person, Socrates would question his disciples. He would not offer the answers but would try to draw them out of his disciples, a process known as the maieutic method. He considered himself to be a kind of midwife drawing the truth from the repository of the soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is similar to our method because we say that you must approach a guru in order to learn the truth. This is the instruction given in all the Vedic scriptures. In Bhagavad-gétä, Lord Kåñëa Himself advises:

tad viddhi pranipätena
paripraçnena sevayä
upadekñyanti te jïänaà
jïäninaç tattva-darçinaù

"Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth." (Bg. 4.34) A guru who knows the truth is one who has seen the truth. People say, "Can you show me God?" It is a natural tendency to want to know something by direct perception. This is possible by advanced devotion. As I have already explained: santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti. The realized devotee is constantly seeing the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çyämasundara. You can constantly see the Supreme Lord as Paramätmä sitting within your heart, and you can take advice from Him. Kåñëa also confirms this: buddhi-yogaà dadämyaham. Yoga means concentrating the mind in order to see the Supersoul within. Therefore you have to control the activities of the senses and withdraw them from material engagement. When your concentration is perfect, when your mind is focused on Paramätmä, you always see Him. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

yoginäm api sarveñäà
mad-gatenäntarätmanä
çraddhävän bhajate yo mäà
sa me yuktatamo mataù

“And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all." (Bg. 6.47) The perfect yogé sees God constantly within. That is perfection. The process that Socrates used gave his disciples a good chance to develop their understanding. When a parent raises his child, he first of all takes his hand and teaches him how to walk. Sometimes he gives the child freedom to walk on his own, although he may sometimes fall down. The father then encourages the child, saying, "Ah, you are doing very nicely. Stand up again and walk." Similarly, the guru gives his disciple the chance to think properly in order to go back home, back to Godhead. Sometimes, when a person comes to argue, the guru says, "All right, what do you consider important?" In this way, the person's position is understood. An expert teacher knows how to capture a fool. First, let the fool go on and speak all sorts of nonsense. Then he can understand where he is having difficulty. That is also a process.

Çyämasundara däsa: Socrates recommended good association because if one is to develop good qualities, he must associate with those who are virtuous and similarly interested.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is very valuable. Without good association, we cannot develop Kåñëa consciousness. Narottama Däsa Öhäkura sings: Tädera caraëa-sebi-bhakta-sane bäs janame janame hoy ei abhiläñ. "My dear Lord, please allow me to live with those devotees who serve the lotus feet of the six Gosvämés. This is my desire, life after life." (Näma-saìkértana 7) The aim of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to create a society in which devotees can associate with one another.

Hayagréva däsa: It has been said that Socrates's philosophy is primarily a philosophy of ethics, pointing to the way of action in the world. Jïäna, or knowledge in itself, is not sufficient. It must be applied, and must serve as a basis for activity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, ethics form the basic principle of purification. We cannot be purified unless we know what is moral and what is immoral. Unfortunately, everything in this material world is more or less immoral, but we still have to distinguish between good and bad. Therefore we have regulative principles. By following them, we can come to the spiritual platform and transcend the influence of the three modes of material nature. Passion is the binding force in the material world. In a prison, prisoners are sometimes shackled, and similarly, material nature provides the shackles of sex life to bind us to this material world. This is the mode of rajas, passion. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

käma eña krodha eña
rajoguëa-samudbhavaù
mahä-çano mahä-päpmä
viddhy enam iha vairiëam

"It is lust only, Arjuna, which is born of contact with the material mode of passion and later transformed into wrath, and which is the all-devouring sinful enemy of this world." (Bg. 3.37) Rajo-guëa, the mode of passion, includes käma, lusty desires. When our lusty desires are not fulfilled, we become angry (krodha). All this binds us to the material world. As stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

tadä rajas-tamo-bhäväù
käma-lobhädayaç ca ye
ceta etair anäviddhaà
sthitaà sattve prasédati

"As soon as irrevocable loving service is established in the heart, the effects of nature's modes of passion and ignorance, such as lust, desire, and hankering, disappear from the heart. Then the devotee is established in goodness, and he becomes completely happy." (Bhäg. 1.2.19) When we are subjected to the lower material modes (rajo-guëa and tamo-guëa), we become greedy and lusty. Ethics provide a way to escape the clutches of greed and lust. Then we can come to the platform of goodness and from there attain the spiritual platform.

Hayagréva däsa: Is meditation in itself sufficient to transcend these lower modes?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. If we seek the Supersoul within, our meditation is perfect. But if we manufacture something in the name of transcendental meditation in order to bluff others, it is useless.

Çyämasundara däsa: Socrates believed that ignorance results in bad actions, and that the knowledgeable man will automatically act properly.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When an ignorant child touches fire and is burned, he cries. His distress is due to ignorance. An intelligent person will not touch fire because he knows its properties. Thus ignorance is the cause of bondage and suffering. It is due to ignorance that people commit many sinful activities and become entangled.

Çyämasundara däsa: Does this mean that when people are enlightened with proper knowledge, they will automatically become good?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

yathaidhämsi samiddho 'gnir
bhasmasät kurute 'rjuna
jïänägniù sarva-karmäëi
bhasmasät kurute tathä

"As the blazing fire turns firewood to ashes, O Arjuna, so does the fire of knowledge burn to ashes all reactions to material activities." (Bg. 4.37) The fire of knowledge consumes all sinful activities. To this end, there is need for education. People are born ignorant, and education is needed to remove their ignorance. Since they are born illusioned by the bodily conception, people act like animals. They therefore have to be educated to understand that they are different from the material body.

Çyämasundara däsa: Why is it that some people who receive this knowledge later reject it?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then it is not perfect knowledge. When one actually receives perfect knowledge, he becomes good. This is a fact. If one is not good, it is because he has not received perfect knowledge.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is there not a class of men that is always evil?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No.

Çyämasundara däsa: Can any man be made good?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly, because the soul is by nature good. The living entity is covered by the inferior modes of material nature, by passion and ignorance. When he is cleansed of this covering, his goodness will emerge. The soul is originally good because it is part and parcel of God, and God is all good. That which is part and parcel of gold is also gold. Although the soul is covered by matter, the soul is all good. When a sharpened knife is covered by rust, it loses its sharpness. If we remove the rust, the knife will once again be sharp.

Çyämasundara däsa: Does the existence of evil in the world mean that there is absolute evil?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Absolute evil means forgetfulness of the Absolute Truth. Kåñëa is the Absolute Truth, and lack of Kåñëa consciousness is absolute evil. In terms of the absolute evil, we may say that this is good and that is bad, but all this is mental concoction.

Çyämasundara däsa: Generally speaking, Socrates was more concerned with God as a moral reality than as a personal conception.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Moral reality is necessarily personal. If a man is moral, we say that he is honest. If he follows no moral principles, we say that he is dishonest. Thus morality and immorality refer to a person. How can we deny personal morality?

Çyämasundara däsa: Then if God is pure morality, He must be a person.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly. All good. God is good, and this means that He is full of morality.

Çyämasundara däsa: Socrates taught that good deeds bring happiness and that to perform them is the real goal of life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is the law of karma. If I work hard in this life, I earn money. If I study hard, I acquire an education. However, if I neither work nor study, I remain poor and uneducated. This is the law of karma. According to the Vedic varëäçrama-dharma, society is divided into four castes: brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, and çüdra. Each caste has its particular duty, but that duty is connected to God's service. In other words, everyone can satisfy the Supreme Lord by performing his duty. By walking, the legs perform their duty, and by touching or holding, the hands perform their duty. Every part of the body performs a duty alotted to it. Similarly, we are all part and parcel of God, and if we do our duty, we are serving God. This is the system of varëäçrama-dharma. Kåñëa Himself says in Bhagavad-gétä:

cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöaà
guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù

"According to the three modes of material nature and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me." (Bg. 4.13)

It is further stated:

yataù pravåttir bhütänäà
yena sarvam idaàtatam
svakarmaëä tam abhyarcya
siddhià vindati mänavaù

"By worship of the Lord, who is the source of all beings and who is all-pervading, man can, in the performance of his own duty, attain perfection." (Bg. 18.46) Thus the respective duties of the brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, or çüdra can be dovetailed to the service of the Lord, and by doing so, any man can attain perfection.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is moral improvement the highest goal of mankind, or is there something higher?

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, we must understand what morality is. Morality means discharging our prescribed duties without hindering others in the execution of their duties. That is morality.

Çyämasundara däsa: What do you consider the shortcomings of a philosophy devoted to moral improvement and knowing oneself through pure reason alone?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Knowing oneself through pure reason alone will take time. Of course, in European philosophy, there is an attempt at more independent thought, but such independent thinking is not approved by the followers of the Vedas. The Vedic followers receive knowledge directly from authorities. They do not speculate. We cannot attain knowledge through speculation because everyone is imperfect. A person may be proud of seeing, but he does not know that his eyesight is conditioned. Unless there is sunlight, he cannot see. Therefore, what is the intrinsic value of eyesight? We should not be very proud of seeing or thinking because our senses are imperfect. We therefore have to receive knowledge from the perfect. In this way, we save time.

According to the Vedic system, we receive knowledge from Vyäsadeva, Närada, and Çré Kåñëa Himself. This knowledge is perfect because these personalities are not subjected to the four defects of conditioned living entities. The conditioned living entity has a tendency to commit mistakes, to be illusioned, to have imperfect senses, and to cheat. These are the four imperfections of conditional life. We therefore have to receive knowledge from those who are liberated. This is the Vedic process. If we receive knowledge from Kåñëa, there cannot be any mistake, nor any question of illusion. Our senses may be imperfect, but Kåñëa's senses are perfect; therefore whatever Kåñëa says, we accept, and that acceptance is our perfection. A person may search for years to find out who his father is, but the immediate answer is available through his mother. The best way to solve this problem is by directly asking the mother. Similarly, all knowledge received from the perfect liberated person or from the mother Vedas is perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Socrates's emphasis was on humanity and ethical action. He said that our lives should be composed of good deeds because we can attain the highest perfection by being virtuous.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, to do good work is also recommended in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. It is possible to go home, back to Godhead, if we always work for the benefit of others. This Kåñëa consciousness movement means benefitting others twenty-four hours a day. People are lacking knowledge of God, and we are preaching this knowledge. This is the highest humanitarian work: to elevate the ignorant to the platform of knowledge.

Çyämasundara däsa: But wouldn't you say that there is something more than moral improvement? Isn't that just a by-product of something else?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, real improvement is realizing God and our relationship with Him. In order to come to this platform, morality or purity is required. God is pure, and unless we are also pure, we cannot approach God. Therefore we are prohibiting meat eating, illicit sex, intoxication, and gambling. These are immoral habits that are always keeping us impure. Unless we abandon these impure habits, we cannot progress in Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then morality is just a qualification for becoming God conscious, isn't it?

Çréla Prabhupäda: If we take to Kåñëa consciousness, we automatically become moral. On the one hand, we have to observe the regulative moral principles, and on the other hand we have to develop our tendency to serve Kåñëa more and more. By serving Kåñëa, we become moral. However, if we try to be moral without serving Kåñëa, we will fail. Therefore so-called followers of morality are always frustrated. The goal is transcendental to human morality. We have to come to the platform of Kåñëa consciousness in order to be truly moral. According to Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

yasyästi bhaktir bhagavaty akiïcanä
sarvair guëais tatra samäsate suräù
haräv abhaktasya kuto mahad-guëä
manorathenäsati dhävato bahiù

"All the demigods and their exalted qualities, such as religion, knowledge, and renunciation, become manifest in the body of one who has developed unalloyed devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Väsudeva. On the other hand, a person devoid of devotional service and engaged in material activities has no good qualities. Even if he is adept at the practice of mystic yoga or the honest endeavor of maintaining his family and relatives, he must be driven by his own mental speculations and must engage in the service of the Lord's external energy. How can there be any good qualities in such a man?" (Bhäg. 5.18.12)

The conclusion is that we cannot be moral without being devotees. We may artificially try to be moral, but ultimately we will fail.

Çyämasundara däsa: By virtue of his intelligence, Socrates could keep his passions controlled, but most people do not have such intellectual strength. They are not able to control themselves rationally and act properly. How does Kåñëa consciousness help in this endeavor?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa consciousness purifies the intelligence, the mind, and the senses. Since everything is purified, there is no chance in being employed in anything but Kåñëa consciousness. Anyone can do this under the proper guidance, whereas not everyone can do as Socrates did. The common man does not have sufficient intelligence to control himself without spiritual exercise. Yet, despite his intelligence, Socrates had no clear conception of God. In Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna tells Çré Kåñëa:

paraà brahma paraà dhäma
pavitraà paramaà bhavän
puruñaàçäçvataà divyam
ädi-devam ajaà vibhum

"You are the Supreme Brahman, the ultimate, the supreme abode and purifier, the Absolute Truth and the eternal divine person. You are the primal God, transcendental and original, and You are the unborn and all-pervading beauty." (Bg. 10.12)

The word pavitram means "the purest." This includes all morality. Acting in Kåñëa consciousness is the best morality, and this is supported in Bhagavad-gétä:

api cet suduräcäro
bhajate mäm ananya-bhäk
sädhur eva sa mantavyaù
samyag vyavasito hi saù

"Even if one commits the most abominable action, if he is engaged in devotional service, he is to be considered saintly because he is properly situated." (Bg. 9.30) Even if a person is considered immoral from the mundane point of view, he should be regarded as moral if he acts on the platform of Kåñëa consciousness. Sometimes a person in Kåñëa consciousness may appear to act immorally. For instance, in the dead of night, the young cowherd girls of Våndävana left their husbands and fathers to go to the forest to see Kåñëa. From the materialistic point of view, this is immoral, but because their actions were connected with Kåñëa, they are considered highly moral. By nature, Arjuna was not inclined to kill, even at the risk of his kingdom, but Kåñëa wanted him to fight; therefore Arjuna entered the battle and acted morally, even though he was killing people.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then, you are saying that morality is absolute as long as it is in relation with Kåñëa?

Çréla Prabhupäda: If Kåñëa or His representative says, "Do this," that act is moral. We cannot create morality. We cannot say, "I am a devotee of Kåñëa; therefore I can kill." No. We cannot do anything unless we receive a direct order.

Çyämasundara däsa: But can leading a life that is honest, or based on doing good to others, lead us to ultimate happiness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Unless we are Kåñëa conscious, there is no meaning to honesty and morality. They are artificial. People are always saying, "This is mine." But our accepting proprietorship is actually immoral hecause nothing belongs to us. Éçäväsyam idaà sarvam (Éçopaniñad 1). Everything belongs to Kåñëa. We cannot say, "This table is mine. This wife is mine. This house is mine." It is immoral to claim another's properly as our own.

Çyämasundara däsa: Socrates defines right as that which is beneficial to others, and wrong as that which does harm to others.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a general definition, but we should know what is beneficial for others. Kåñëa consciousness is beneficial, and anything else is not beneficial.

Çyämasundara däsa: For instance, he states that stealing, lying, cheating, hating, and other evils, are absolutely bad. Yet if there is a necessity to cheat or lie in order to serve Kåñëa, would that be bad?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Cheating and lying are not necessary. By cheating, we cannot serve Kåñëa. That is not the principle. However, if Kåñëa directly orders us to cheat, that is a different matter. But we cannot create that order. We cannot say, "Because I am Kåñëa conscious, it is all right for me to cheat." No. However, once Kåñëa asked Yudhiñöhira to go tell Droëäcärya that his son was dead, although his son was not. This was a kind of cheating, but because Kåñëa directly ordered it, it was all right. Orders from Kåñëa are transcendental to everything—morality and immorality. In Kåñëa consciousness, there is neither morality nor immorality. There is simply good.

Hayagréva däsa: The Athenian government accused Socrates of fostering atheism and blaspheming the gods because he felt that worship of the demigods in the Greek pantheon did not lead to self-realization.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, Socrates was right. Worship of the demigods is also discouraged in Bhagavad-gétä:

kämais tais tair håta-jïänäù
prapadyante 'nya-devatäù
taà taà niyamam ästhäya
prakåtyä niyatäù svayä

"Those whose minds are distorted by material desires surrender unto demigods and follow the particular rules and regulations of worship according to their own natures." (Bg. 7.20) Demigods are worshipped out of lust for some material benefit by one who has lost his intelligence (håta-jïäna), You may worship the demigod Sarasvaté, the goddess of learning, and thereby become a great scholar, but how long will you remain a scholar? When your body dies, your scholarly knowledge is finished. Then you have to accept another body and act accordingly. So how will scholastic knowledge help you? However, if you worship God Himself, the results are different.

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9) To worship God means to know God. Knowing God means understanding how material nature is working under His directions. Kåñëa says:

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again." (Bg. 9.10) Because impersonalists cannot understand how a person can direct the wonderful activities of material nature, they remain impersonalists. But actually God is a person, and this is the understanding we get from Bhagavad-gétä:

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conqueror of wealth [Arjuna], there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7) The word mattaù refers to a person.

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaàpravartate
iti matvä bhajante mäà
budhä bhäva-samanvitäù

"I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts." (Bg. 10.8)

The Vedänta-sütra also confirms that the Absolute Truth is a person, and when Arjuna understood Bhagavad-gétä, he addressed Kåñëa as paraà brahma paraà dhäma pavitraà paramaà bhavän. "You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the ultimate abode, the purest, the Absolute Truth, and the eternal Divine Person." (Bg. 10.12) Understanding the Absolute Truth means understanding the three features of the Absolute Truth: the impersonal, the localized, and the personal.

vadanti tat tattva-vidas
tattvaà yaj jïänam advayam
brahmeti paramätmeti
bhagavän iti çabdyate

"Learned transcendentalists who know the Absolute Truth call this nondual substance Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagävan." (Bhäg. 1.2.11) The Absolute Truth is one, but there are different features. One mountain seen from different distances appears different. From a far distance, the Absolute Truth appears impersonal, but as you approach, you see Paramätmä present everywhere. When you come even nearer, you can perceive Bhagävan, the Supreme Person.

Çyämasundara däsa: Socrates deliberately took poison in order not to contradict himself. The government told him that if he retracted his statements, he could live, but he preferred to be a martyr for his own beliefs.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is good that he stuck to his point, yet regrettable that he lived in a society that would not permit him to think independently. Therefore he was obliged to die. In that sense, Socrates was a great soul. Although he appeared in a society that was not very advanced, he was nonetheless a great philosopher.

Hayagréva däsa: Socrates considered the contemplation of beauty to be an activity of the wise man, but relative beauty in the mundane world is simply a reflection of absolute beauty. In the same way, good in the relative world is but a reflection of the absolute good. In any case, absolute good or beauty is transcendental.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is also our view. Beauty, knowledge, strength, wealth, fame, and renunciation are all transcendental. In this material world, everything is a perverted reflection. A foolish animal may run after a mirage in the desert, thinking it water, but a sane man knows better. Although there is no water in the desert, we cannot conclude that there is no water at all. Water certainly exists. Similarly, real happiness, beauty, knowledge, strength, and the other opulences exist in the spiritual world, but here they are only reflected pervertedly. Generally, people have no information of the spiritual world; therefore they have to imagine something spiritual. They do not understand that this material world is imaginary.

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9) Although people are reading Bhagavad-gétä, they cannot understand this very simple point. After giving up the material body, the devotee goes to Kåñëa. Of course, the Christians say that after death, one goes to heaven or hell, and to some extent that is a fact. If we understand Kåñëa in this lifetime, we can go to Kåñëa's eternal abode; otherwise, we remain in this material world to undergo the same cycle of birth and death. That is hell.

Hayagréva däsa: At the conclusion of The Republic, Socrates gives the analogy of humanity living within a dark cave. The self-realized teacher has seen the light outside the cave. When he returns to the cave to inform the people that they are in darkness, many consider him crazy for speaking of such a thing as the light outside. Thus the teacher often puts himself in a very dangerous position.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a fact. We often give the example of a frog within a dark well, thinking that his well is everything. When he is informed that there is an Atlantic Ocean, he cannot conceive of such a great quantity of water. Those who are in the dark well of material existence are surprised to hear that there is light outside. Everyone in the material world is suffering in the dark well of material existence, and we are throwing down this rope called Kåñëa consciousness. If people do not catch hold, what can we do? If you are fortunate, you can capture the Lord with the help of the teacher, but it is up to you to catch hold of the rope. Everyone is trying to get out of the misery of material existence. Therefore Kåñëa says:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaàçaraëaàvraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reactions. Do not fear." (Bg. 18.66) Still, due to obstinance, people refuse, or do not believe Him. The Vedas also tell us, "Don't remain in the dark well. Come out into the light." Unfortunately, people want to become perfect and yet remain in the dark well. This material universe is by nature dark, and therefore Kåñëa has supplied the sun and moon for light. Yet there is Kåñëa's kingdom, which is different, as Kåñëa Himself tells us in Bhagavad-gétä:

na tad bhäsayate süryo
na çaçäìko na pävakaù
yad gatvä na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"That supreme abode of Mine is not illumined by the sun or moon, nor by electricity. One who reaches it never returns to this material world." (Bg. 15.6) In Kåñëa's kingdom there is no need for sun, moon, or electricity. His kingdom is all effulgent. In the darkness of this material world, the only happiness is in sleep and sex. As stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

çrotavyädéni räjendra
nåëäà santi sahasraçaù
apaçyatäm ätma-tattvaà
gåheñu gåha-medhinäm

nidrayä hriyate naktaà
vyaväyena ca vä vayaù
divä cärthehayä räjan
kuöumba-bharaëena vä

"Those who are materially engrossed, being blind to the knowledge of ultimate truth, are interested in hearing about many different subjects, O Emperor. The lifetime of such envious householders is passed at night either in sleeping or in sex indulgence, and in the day either in making money or maintaining family members." (Bhäg. 2.1.2-3)

Materialists spend much time reading newspapers, novels, and magazines. They have many forms of engagement because they are ignorant of self-realization. They think that life simply means living in a family surrounded by their wife, children, and friends. They work hard during the day for money, racing their cars at breakneck speed, and at night they either sleep or enjoy sex. This is just like the life of a hog constantly searching for stool. Yet all of this is taking place in the name of civilization. This kind of hoggish civilization is condemned in the Vedic literatures. Kåñëa advises us to produce grains, eat fruits, vegetables, drink milk, and cultivate Kåñëa consciousness. In this way, we can become happy.

Hayagréva däsa: Socrates speaks of everyone sitting in the cave, watching a kind of cinema composed of imitation forms.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that people are in darkness, and everything seen in darkness is not clear. Therefore the Vedic version is: "Don't remain in darkness. Come to the light." That light is the guru.

oà ajïäna-timirändhasya jïänäïjana-çaläkayä
cakñur unmélitaà yena tasmai çré-gurave namaù

"I was born in the darkest ignorance, and my spiritual master opened my eyes with the torch of knowledge. I offer my respectful obeisances unto him." (Çré Guru Praëäma)

DS:Plato (427-347 B.C.)

Plato (427-347 B.C.)

Hayagréva däsa: For Plato, the spiritual world is not a mental conception; rather, truth is the same as ultimate reality, the ideal or the highest good, and it is from this that all manifestations and cognitions flow. Plato uses the word eidos (idea) in order to denote a subject's primordial existence, its archetypal shape. Doesn't Kåñëa use the word béjam [seed] in much the same way?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Béjaà mäà sarva-bhütänäà. "I am the original seed of all existences." (Bg. 7.10) In the Tenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa also states: mattaù sarvaà pravartate. "I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me." (Bg. 10.8) Whether we speak of the spiritual or material world, everything emanates from Kåñëa, the origin of all manifestations. The origin is what is factual. God has two energies—material and spiritual. This is also described in Bhagavad-gétä:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

apareyam itas tv anyäà
prakåtià viddhi me paräm
jéva-bhütäà mahä-bäho
yayedaà dhäryate jagat

etad-yonéni bhütäni
sarväëéty upadhäraya
ahaà kåtsnasya jagataù
prabhavaù pralayas tathä

"Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego—all together these eight constitute My separated material energies. Besides this inferior nature, O mighty-armed Arjuna, there is a superior energy of Mine, which is all living entities who are struggling with material nature and sustaining the universe. Of all that is material and all that is spiritualinthis world, know for certain that I am bothits origin and dissolution." (Bg. 7.4-6)

Gross matter, as well as the subtle mind, intelligence, and ego, are Kåñëa's separated material energies. The living entity, the individual soul (jéva) is also Kåñëa's energy, but he is superior to the material energy. When we make a comparative study of Kåñëa's energies, we find that one energy is superior and that another is inferior, but because both energies are coming from the Absolute Truth, there is no difference. In a higher sense, they are all one. In the material world, everything is created, maintained, and then annihilated, but in the spiritual world, this is not the case. Although the body is created, maintained, and annihilated, the soul is not.

na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin
näyaà bhütvä bhavitä vä na bhüyaù
ajo nityaùçäçvato 'yaà puräëo
na hanyate hanyamäne çarére

"For the soul there is never birth nor death. Nor, having once been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain." (Bg. 2.20) At death, the soul may take on another body, but one who is perfect goes directly to Kåñëa.

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9)

Or, one may go to the higher planetary systems, or the lower, or one may remain in the middle systems. In any case, it is better to go back to Godhead. This is the course of one who is intelligent.

yänti deva-vratä devän
pitèn yänti pitå-vratäù
bhütäni yänti bhütejyä
yänti mad-yäjino 'pi mäm

"Those who worship the demigods will take birth among the demigods; those who worship ghosts and spirits will take birth among such beings; those who worship ancestors go to the ancestors; and those who worship Me will live with Me." (Bg. 9.25)

Hayagréva däsa: What Plato is saying is that everything that exists has its seed or essence (eidos).

Çréla Prabhupäda: That seed is originally with Kåñëa. For instance, before its manifestation, a tree is but a seed. Yet within that seed the whole tree is present. If you sow the seed of a rose plant, roses will manifest. If you sow the seed of a mango tree, a mango tree will manifest. It is not an idea but a fact. The tree is there, but it is not developed. Although it is unmanifest, it is more than an idea.

Çyämasundara däsa: The senses perceive the changing phenomenal world, but according to Plato, the noumenal world is perceived by the mind. It is this world that is absolute, ideal, permanent, and universal. Would you say that ultimate reality is ideal in this Platonic sense?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not ideal—factual. Paraà satyaà dhémahi. "We offer our obeisances unto the Absolute Truth." This relative world is a perverted reflection of the absolute world. It is just like a shadow. A tree reflected in the water may appear to be exactly like the tree itself, but it is a perverted reflection. The actual tree is there. Similarly, this relative world is a reflection of the absolute world. In the beginning of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, it is clearly stated that this manifested creation, which is but a reflection, has its beginning in the Supreme Personality of Godhead:

janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç cärtheñv abhijïaù svaräö
tene brahma hådä ya ädi-kavaye muhyanti yat sürayaù
tejo-väri-mådäà yathä vinimayo yatra tri-sargo 'måñä
dhämnä svena sadä nirasta-kuhakaà satyaà paraà dhémahi

"I meditate upon Lord Çré Kåñëa because He is the Absolute Truth and the primeval cause of all causes of the creation, sustenance, and destruction of the manifested universes. He is directly and indirectly conscious of all manifestations, and He is independent because there is no other cause beyond Him. It is He only who first imparted the Vedic knowledge unto the heart of Brahmäjé, the original living being. By Him, even the great sages and demigods are placed into illusion, as one is bewildered by the illusory representations of water seen in fire, or land seen on water. Only because of Him do the material universes, temporarily manifested by the reactions of the three modes of nature, appear factual, although they are unreal. I therefore meditate upon Him, Lord Çré Kåñëa, who is eternally existent in the transcendental abode, which is forever free from the illusory representations of the material world. I meditate upon Him, for He is the Absolute Truth." (Bhäg. 1.1.1)

In Bhagavad-gétä, the example of the banyan tree is given:

ürdhva-mülam adhaù-çäkham
açvatthaà prähur avyayam
chandäàsi yasya parëäni
yas taà veda sa veda-vit

"There is a banyan tree which has its roots upward and its branches down, and whose leaves are the Vedic hymns. One who knows this tree is the knower of the Vedas." (Bg. 15.1) The tree of the phenomenal world has its roots upward, which indicates that it is but a reflection of the real tree. The real tree is there, but because the tree perceived in the phenomenal world is a reflection, it is perverted. So the absolute world is a fact, but we cannot arrive at it by speculation. Our process is to know about the absolute world from the absolute person. That is the difference between our process and Plato's. Plato wants to reach the absolute point through the dialectic process. We, however, receive information from Bhagavad-gétä that there is a superior world or nature which exists even after this phenomenal cosmic manifestation is annihilated.

paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo
'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù
yaù sa sarveñu bhüteñu
naçyatsu na vinaçyati

"Yet there is another nature, which is eternal and is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is." (Bg. 8.20)

Hayagréva däsa: Plato considered the material world restricted to limitations of time and space, but the spiritual world transcends both.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Hayagréva däsa: He also believed that time began with the creation of the material world. How does this relate to the Vedic version?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Time is eternal. The past, present, and future are three features of time, but they are relative. Your past, present, and future are not the same as those of Brahmä. Brahmä lives for millions of years, and within this span we may have many pasts, presents, and futures. These are relative according to the person, but time itself is eternal. Is that clear? Past, present, and future are relative according to the body, but time has no past, present, or future.

Hayagréva däsa: Plato considered material nature, or prakåti, to have always been existing in a chaotic state. God takes matter and fashions it into form in order to create the universe.

Çréla Prabhupäda: More precisely, Kåñëa sets prakåti in motion, and the products are manifesting automatically. A printer may set up a press in such a way that many magazines can be printed completely. The seeds, or béjams, are created by God in such a way that creations are manifest automatically. These seeds are God's machines. He has created these seeds only. The seed of the entire universe is coming from Him. Yasyaika niçvasita kälam athävalambya (Brahma-saàhitä 5.48). When God breathes, millions of seeds of universes emanate from His body, and we call this creation. When He inhales, they return, and we call this annihilation. Things are manifest or unmanifest depending on His breathing. When He exhales, everything is manifest. When He inhales, everything is finished. Only a fool thinks that God's breathing and our breathing are the same. Bhagavad-gétä says:

avajänanti mäà müòhä
mänuñéà tanum äçritam
paraà bhävam ajänanto
mama bhüta-maheçvaram

"Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and My supreme dominion over all that be." (Bg. 9.11) Even Lord Brahma and Lord Indra were bewildered to see that this cowherd boy is God Himself.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato's word for God is demiurge, which in Greek means master builder, architect, or hand-worker.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In Sanskrit this is called såñöi-kartä, but this conception is secondary. Lord Brahma is såñöi-kartä, and Brahma is inspired by Kåñëa. The original master, Kåñëa, is not såñöi-kartä because He does not do anything directly. As stated in the Vedas: svä-bhäviké jïäna-bala-kriyä ca, "His potencies are multifarious, and thus His deeds are automatically performed as a natural sequence." (Çvetäçvatara-upaniñad 6.8). As soon as He wants something done, it is actualized. Sa aikñata—sa imäl lokän asåjata (Aitareya-upaniñad 1.1.1-2). When He glances at matter, creation takes place immediately. His energy is so perfect that simply by willing and glancing, everything is immediately and perfectly created. For instance, this flower is Kåñëa's energy. It requires a highly talented brain to color it and adjust it in such a way, but it is growing automatically. This is the way of Kåñëa's energy. This flower is a very small thing, but the entire cosmic manifestation is created on the same basis. Paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate. Kåñëa has multi-energies, fine and subtle. As soon as Kåñëa thinks, "This thing must come into being immediately," that thing is prepared by so many subtle energies. Kåñëa doesn't have to do anything with His hands. He simply desires something, and it is created. Lord Brahmä is supposed to be the direct creator of the universe, but there are millions of universes and millions of Brahmäs. There are also millions of suns and other luminaries. There is no limit, and all this material creation is but the energy of Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato conceives of God as the essence of perfection, the supreme ideal, and the supreme good.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to Paräçara Muni, perfection belongs to Him who has complete knowledge, wealth, beauty, power, fame, and renunciation. God has everything in full, and there is no vacancy in Him.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato's philosophy points to a personal conception, but there is no idea of what God looks like, or what He says.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Vedic literatures not only present this person but describe Him.

veëuà kvaëantam aravinda-daläyatäkñaà
barhävataàsam asitämbuda-sundaräìgam
kandarpa-koöi-kaminéya-viçeña-çobhaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is adept in playing on His flute, whose blossoming eyes are like lotus petals, whose head is bedecked with a peacock's feather, whose figure of beauty is tinged with the hue of blue clouds, and whose unique loveliness charms millions of Cupids." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.30) In this way, Lord Kåñëa's form and activities are concretely described. In the Vedas, everything is factual. Plato thinks that the creator may be a person, but he does not know what kind of person He is, nor does he know of His engagements.

Hayagréva däsa: Later, in The Republic, in the allegory of the cave mentioned before, Socrates states that in the world of knowledge, the last thing to be perceived, and only with great difficulty, is the essential form of goodness. He considers this form to be the cause of whatever is right and good. He states that without having had a vision of this form, one cannot act with wisdom, neither in his own life, nor in matters of state. Here again, form is mentioned, but not personality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is contradictory. As soon as we understand that there are instructions from God, we must understand that there is form, and when we understand that there is form, we must understand that there is personality. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

na tv evähaà jätu näsaà
na tvaà neme janädhipäù
na caiva na bhaviñyämaù
sarve vayam ataù param

"Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings; nor in the future shall any of us cease to be." (Bg. 2.12) This means that in the past, present, and future, Kåñëa, Arjuna, and all other living entities exist as personalities and have form. There is no question of formlessness. Kåñëa never said that in the past we were formless and that only in the present we have form. Rather, He condemns the impersonal version that says when God takes on form, that form is illusion, mäyä.

avyaktaà vyaktim äpannaà
manyante mäm abuddhayaù
paraà bhävam ajänanto
mamävyayam anuttamam

"Unintelligent men, who know Me not, think that I have assumed this form and personality. Due to their small knowledge, they do not know My higher nature, which is changeless and supreme." (Bg. 7.24) In this way, the impersonalists who claim that God is ultimately formless are condemned as abuddhayaù, unintelligent. When one maintains that God accepts a body composed of mäyä, he is called a Mäyävädé.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Plato, God is the ideal of every object, the ideal representation of everything. The individual soul is therefore a tiny portion of this ideal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The material world is a perverted reflection of the spiritual world. For instance, in this material world there is love, the sex urge. This is also present in the spiritual world, but it is present in its perfection. There is beauty, and there is attraction between Kåñëa, a young boy, and Rädhäräëé, a young girl. But that attraction is perfection.

In this world, that attraction is reflected in a perverted way. A young boy and girl fall in love, become frustrated, and separate. Therefore this is called perverted. Nonetheless, reality is there, and in reality there is no separation. It is perfect. That love is so nice that it is increasing pleasure.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato called love in the material world lust, or sensual love. There was also ideal, Platonic love, or intellectual love. By this, one observes the soul in a person and loves that soul, not the body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, spiritual love is factual. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

"The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog and a dog-eater [outcaste]." (Bg. 5.18) The learned person sees all these living entities with an equal vision because he does not see the outward covering. He sees the spirit soul within everyone. When we talk to a person, we do not talk to that person's dress but to the person himself. Similarly, those who are learned do not distinguish between outward bodies. The outward body has developed according to the karma of the living entity, but it is ephemeral. It is the soul that is real.

Hayagréva däsa: For Plato, perfection within the world of the senses can never be attained.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is correct. Everything material has some defect. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

saha-jaà karma kaunteya
sa-doñam api na tyajet
sarvärambhähi doñeëa
dhümenägnir ivävåtäù

"Every endeavor is covered by some sort of fault, just as fire is covered by smoke. Therefore one should not give up the work which is born of his nature, O son of Kunté, even if such work is full of fault." (Bg. 18.48) If we execute our prescribed duties according to the çästras, we can still attain perfection, even though there are some defects. Through Kåñëa consciousness, everyone can become perfect, regardless of his situation. A brähmaëa may give knowledge, a kñatriya may give protection, a vaiçya may provide food, and a çüdra may provide general help for everyone. Although there may be imperfections in the execution of our duty, perfection can be attained by following the injunctions.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato perceives man's soul in a marginal, intermediate position between two worlds. The soul belongs to the ideal world, but he has taken on a material body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we agree that the conditioned soul is marginal energy. He can have a spiritual body or a material body, but until he is trained in acquiring a spiritual body, he will have to have a material body. However, when he engages in devotional service, his so-called material body is transformed into a spiritual body. For instance, if you put an iron rod into fire, it becomes red hot, and when it is red hot, it is no longer iron but fire. Similarly, when you are fully Kåñëa conscious, your body is no longer material but spiritual.

Hayagréva däsa: Plato believed that God put intelligence in the soul, and the soul in the body, in order that He might be the creator of a work which is by nature best.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that the living entity is part and parcel of God.

mamaiväàço jéva-loke
jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù

"The living entities in this conditioned world are My eternal fragmental parts." (Bg. 15.7) The living entity almost has all the qualities of God, but he has them in minute quantity. We may create large airplanes and take some credit, but we cannot create a fiery ball like the sun and have it float in space. That is the difference between God and us. By God's power, millions and millions of planets are floating in space. We may manufacture some things out of the materials given by God, but we cannot create these materials. For instance, it is not possible to manufacture gold, although God has created so many gold mines.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato reasoned that the soul, being eternal, must have existed previously in the ideal world, where it learned about eternal principles. Because we can recollect the eternal ideas quite easily, they are latent, or dormant within us.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul is eternally spiritual, and therefore all goodness resides in it. But due to contact with matter, the soul becomes conditioned. When the soul engages in his original work by rendering service to Kåñëa, he immediately attains all spiritual qualities.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Plato, the longing for immortality is inborn. Man is yearning to realize this perfection.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we desire to live eternally because we are in fact eternal. The living entity does not like changing material bodies. Birth and death are a botheration. He is afraid of taking birth, and he is afraid of dying, but he does not know how to get rid of these botherations. However, according to Bhagavad-gétä (4.9), as soon as we understand Kåñëa, we immediately transcend this transmigration.

Hayagréva däsa: Plato perceives that every object in the universe is made with some purpose, and its ideal goal is to move toward the ideal in which its archetype or essence resides. According to the Vedic version, Kåñëa is the all-attractive object of the universe; therefore all things must be moving toward Him. How is it that the individual soul apparently turns from Kåñëa to participate in the world of birth and death?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is due to mäyä, illusion. He should not have deviated, but due to the influence of mäyä, he is deviating and consequently suffering. Therefore Kåñëa says, sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekam (Bg. 18.66). "Stop this material plan making, surrender unto Me, and do what I say. Then you will be happy." This is very practical. According to Bhagavad-gétä, the living entities are now forgetful of their relationship with God. They have taken on these material bodies because they have a desire to imitate God. They cannot be God, but simply imitations. A woman may dress like a man, but she cannot become a man despite her dress. The living entity, being part and parcel of God, may believe that he is just like God, the supreme enjoyer, and he may think, "I shall enjoy myself." However, because he is not the actual enjoyer, he is given a false platform for enjoying. That platform is the material world. On this false platform, the individual soul experiences frustration. It cannot be said that this frustration is one step forward towards his real life. If one is actually intelligent, he thinks, "Why am I being frustrated? What is real perfection?" This is the beginning of the Vedänta-sütra: athäto brahma-jijïäsä. When he becomes frustrated with the material world, the living entity asks, "What is Brahman?" For instance, Sanätana Gosvämé was a finance minister, but when he became frustrated, he approached Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Our real life begins when we become frustrated with material existence and approach a real spiritual master. If we do not do this, we will certainly be frustrated in whatever we attempt in this material world. Çrémad-Bhägavatam says:

paräbhavas tävad abodha-jäto
yävan na jijïäsata ätma-tattvam
yävat kriyäs tävad idaà mano vai
karmätmakaà yena çaréra-bandhaù

"As long as one does not inquire about the spiritual values of life, one is defeated and subjected to miseries arising from ignorance. Be it sinful or pious, karma has its resultant actions. If a person is engaged in any kind of karma, his mind is called karmätmaka, colored with fruitive activity. As long as the mind is impure, consciousness is unclear, and as long as one is absorbed in fruitive activity, he has to accept a material body." (Bhäg. 5.5.5)

In ignorance, the living entity tries to approach the ideal life, but he is ultimately defeated. He must come to the point of understanding himself. When he understands what he is, he knows, "I am not matter; I am spirit." When he understands this, he begins to make spiritual inquiries, and by this, he can again return home, back to Godhead.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato believes that we must mold our lives in such a way as to attain perfection.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is Kåñëa consciousness, devotional service. We are the eternal servants of God, of Kåñëa, and as long as we are in the material world, we should be trained to serve God. As soon as our apprenticeship is completed, we are promoted to the spiritual world to render the same service in fact. We are chanting here, and in the spiritual world we will also be chanting. We are serving here, and there we will also be serving. However, here we experience a probational apprenticeship. There, that service is factual. But even though this is an apprenticeship, because devotional service is absolute, it is not different from the real world. Therefore if one engages in devotional service, he is already liberated. His very activities are liberated; they are not at all material. One who does not know anything about devotional service thinks, "Oh, what are they doing? Why are they chanting? Anyone can chant. How is this spiritual?" People do not know that the names of Kåñëa are as good as Kåñëa. They are absolute.

Çyämasundara däsa: Socrates maintained that one must become perfectly good, but he gives no clear idea of just how this is done.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Being perfectly good means acting for the perfectly good, Kåñëa. In Kåñëa consciousness, we are given an actual occupation by which we can become perfectly good. The activities of a person in Kåñëa consciousness appear to be perfectly good even to a materialistic person. Anyone can appreciate the good character and qualifications of devotees. Yasyästi bhaktir bhagavaty akiïcanä (Bhäg. 5.18.12). If one has developed Kåñëa consciousness, he will manifest all the good qualities of the demigods. This is a test to tell how we are advancing toward perfection. These qualities will be visible even in this material world. This is not simply a question of the ideal, the inaccessible. This can be factually experienced. And the devotee does not want anything other than engagement in Kåñëa consciousness. He doesn't want material sense gratification at all. That is perfection.

Hayagréva däsa: For Plato, perfect happiness lies in attempting to become godly. Insofar as man is godly, he is ethical. Evil forces within man combat his efforts to attain this ultimate goal. But Plato was not a determinist; he emphasized freedom of the will, and insisted that evil acts are due to man's failure to meet his responsibilities. Evil does not come from God, who is all good.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everything comes from God, but we have to make our choice. Both the university and the prison are government institutions, but the prison is meant for criminals, and the university for scholars. The government spends money to maintain both institutions, but we make our choice either to go to prison or the university. That is the minute independence present in every human being. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

samo 'haà sarva-bhüteñu
na me dveñyo 'sti na priyaù
ye bhajanti tu mäà bhaktyä
mayi te teñu cäpy aham

"I envy no one, nor am I partial to anyone. I am equal to all. But whoever renders service unto Me in devotion is a friend, is in Me, and I am also a friend to him." (Bg. 9.29) It is not that out of envy God makes someone unhappy and someone else happy. This is not God's business. Happiness and unhappiness are our creation. The government does not tell us to become criminals, but it is our fault if we become criminals and suffer. Of course, God is ultimately responsible. God gives us suffering or happiness, but we create the situation which is made into fact by the potency of God.

Hayagréva däsa: Plato conceives of death as being the end of the sensory life of the individual, his thoughts, perceptions, and experiences. The individual then returns to the ideal world from which he came.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he believes in the eternity of the soul. There are three stages: awakening, dreaming, and deep sleep, or unconsciousness. When a man dies, he goes from the awakening state into the dreaming state, and then enters the state of deep sleep. Transmigration means that he gives up the gross body and carries the subtle body—the mind, intelligence, and false ego—into another body. Until the other body is properly prepared, he remains in a state of deep sleep. When the body is prepared after seven months [for the human being], he then regains consciousness. At this point, he thinks, "O my Lord, why am I put into this situation? Why am I packed tightly in this womb?"

In the womb, he feels very uncomfortable, and if he is pious, he prays to God for relief. At this time, he promises God that he will become a devotee. When he comes out of the womb, the different stages of life begin: childhood, youth, manhood, middle age, old age, and then again death. It is like a flower that goes through different stages. In the beginning, the flower is only a bud, and it eventually blossoms and looks very beautiful. By gradually developing our Kåñëa consciousness, the beauty of our life can eventually be manifest.

Hayagréva däsa: Plato also stressed the process of remembering. For instance, a boy may be ignorant of a certain subject, but a teacher can elicit answers from him that will suggest that he acquired this certain knowledge in a previous existence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and therefore we find that some students are more intelligent than others. Why is this? One student can grasp the subject very quickly, while another cannot.

pürväbhyäsena tenaiva
hriyate hy avaço 'pi saù

"By virtue of the divine consciousness of his previous life, he automatically becomes attracted to the yogic principles, even without seeking them." (Bg. 6.44) Some men may be born in rich families and may acquire a good education, whereas others may be born in poor families and remain uneducated. If one is extraordinarily rich, educated, aristocratic, and beautiful, we should understand that he is reaping the results of his previous good activities. In any case, regardless of one's position in this world, everyone has to be educated to Kåñëa consciousness. In this sense, everyone has an equal opportunity. As stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

kiräta-hüëändhra-pulinda-pulkaçä
äbhéra-çumbhä yavanäù khasädayaù
ye 'nye ca päpä yad-apäçrayäçrayäù
çudhyanti tasmai prabhaviñëave namaù

"Kirätas, Hüëas, Ändhras, Pulindas, Pulkaças, Äbhéras, Çumbhas, Yavanas, and the Khasa races, and even others who are addicted to sinful acts, can be purified by taking shelter of the devotees of the Lord due to His being the supreme power. I beg to offer my respectful obeisances unto Him." (Bhäg. 2.4.18) So even if one has the body of an aborigine, he can be trained in Kåñëa consciousness because that consciousness is on the platform of the soul.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning education, it is stated in The Republic: 'The soul of every man possesses the power of learning the truth and the organ to see it with. Just as one might have to turn the whole body around for the eye to see light instead of darkness, so the entire soul must be turned away from this changing world, until its eye can bear to contemplate reality and that supreme splendor which we have called the Good. Hence there may well be an art whose aim would be to affect this very thing: the conversion of the soul, in the readiest way. Not to put the power of sight into the soul's eye, which already has it, but to insure that, instead of looking in the wrong direction, it is turned the way it ought to be."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is the purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement. It is certainly an art. It is a process of purifying the senses. When the senses are purified, our main objective is attained. We do not say that sensory activities are to be stopped. They are to be redirected. Presently, the eyes are seeing things material. The eyes want to see beautiful objects, and we say, "Yes, you can see the beautiful form of Kåñëa." The tongue wants to taste palatable food, and we say, "Yes, you can take this Kåñëa prasädam, but do not eat meat or other foods you cannot offer to Kåñëa." Everything is given; we simply have to purify the senses. According to Bhagavad-gétä:

viñayä vinivartante
nirähärasya dehinaù
rasa-varjaà raso 'py asya
paraà dåñövä nivartate

"The embodied soul may be restricted from sense enjoyment, though the taste for sense objects remains. But, ceasing such engagements by experiencing a higher taste, he is fixed in consciousness." (Bg. 2.59)

Hayagréva däsa: Neither Socrates nor Plato ever mentions service to God, though they speak of the contemplation of God's reality, or the supreme splendor, or good. It is always contemplation or meditation that is stressed, as in jïäna-yoga.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is but one process of knowing God, and it may be partially helpful to know God as He is. However, when we come to know God, we understand, "He is great, and I am small." It is the duty of the small to serve the great. That is nature's way. Everyone is serving in one way or another, but when we realize that we are servants and not the master, we realize our real position. It is our natural position to serve. If someone doesn't have a family to serve, he keeps a dozen dogs and serves them. Especially in Western countries, we see that in old age, when one has no children, he keeps two or three dogs and tries to serve them. Our position as servant is always there, but when we think that we are masters, we are illusioned. The word mäyä means that we are serving while thinking that we are masters. Mäyä means "that which is not," or, "that which is not factual." Through meditation, when we become realized, we can understand, "Oh, I am a servant. Presently I am serving mäyä, illusion. Now let me serve Kåñëa." This is perfection. The spiritual master engages us from the very beginning in the service of God. Then we can attain perfection quickly.

Hayagréva däsa: In The Republic, Plato constructs an ideal state in which the leaders possess nothing of their own, neither property nor family. He fell that people should live together in a community where wives and children are held in common to guard against corruption, bribery, and nepotism in government. Elite philosophers should mate with women of high qualities in order to produce the best children for positions of responsibility. How does this correspond to the Vedic version?

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to Vedic civilization, a man should accept a wife for putra, for sons. Putra-piëòa-prayojanam. A putra, or son, should offer piëòa so that after death the father will be elevated if he is in an undesirable position. Marriage is for begetting good sons who will deliver one from the fire of hell. Therefore the çraddhä ceremony is there because even if the father is in hell, he will be delivered. It is the son who offers the çraddhä oblation, and this is his duty. Therefore one accepts a wife for putra, a good son, not for sex enjoyment. One who utilizes his sex life in a religious way will get a good son who can deliver him. Therefore Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä: dharmäviruddho bhüteñu kämo 'smi bharatarñabha. "I am sex life which is not contrary to religious principles." (Bg. 7.11) Sex contrary to religious principle is sense gratification that leads us into a hellish condition. Therefore, according to Vedic civilization, we should marry and beget good progeny. Although my Guru Mahäräja was a sannyäsé brahmacäré, he used to say, "If I could produce really Kåñëa conscious children, I would have sex a hundred times. But why should I have sex just to produce cats and dogs?" The çästras also say:

gurur na sa syät sva-jano na sa syät
pitä na sa syäj janané na sä syät
daivaà na tat syän na patiç ca sa syän
na mocayed yaù samupeta-måtyum

"One who cannot deliver his dependents from the path of repeated birth and death should never become a spiritual master, a father, a husband, a mother, or a worshipable demigod." (Bhäg. 5.5.18) It is the duty of the father and mother to rescue their children from the cycle of birth and death. If one can do this, he can in turn be rescued by his putra if he happens to fall into a hellish condition.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato believed that the perfect state should be organized in such a way that men can strive for the ideal. He equates political activity with moral endeavor, and he says that the ruler of the state must be a wise man (philosopher king), or a group of wise men. In a perfect society, each individual functions to his best capacity according to his natural abilities. This leads to the most harmonious type of society.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This idea is also found in Bhagavad-gétä, in which Kåñëa says that the ideal society is a society of four varëas: brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, and çüdra. In human society, as well as animal society, every living being is under the influence of the modes of material nature—sattva-guëa, rajo-guëa, and tamo-guëa—that is, goodness, passion, and ignorance. By dividing men according to these qualities, society can be perfect. If a man in the mode of ignorance assumes a philosopher's post, havoc will result. Nor can we have a philosopher work as an ordinary laborer. There must be some scientific division in order to perfect society. According to the Vedas, the brähmaëas, the most intelligent men interested in transcendental knowledge and philosophy, should be given a topmost post, and the kñatriyas, the administrators, should work under their instructions. The administrators should see that there is law and order and that everyone is doing his duty. The next section is the productive class, the vaiçyas, who are engaged in agriculture and cow protection. There are also the çüdras, the common laborers, who work for the benefit of the other sections. Of course, now there is industrialization, and large scale industry means exploitation. Such industry was unknown to Vedic civilization. Then, people lived by agriculture and cow protection. If there are healthy cows and enough milk, everyone can get grains, fruits, vegetables, and other foods. That is sufficient in itself. Unfortunately, modern civilization has taken to animal eating, and this is barbarous. This is not even human.

Ideal society is a society of brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam, these divisions are compared to the body: the head, the arms, the belly, and the legs. All parts of the body are meant to keep the body fit. Comparatively, the head is more important than the legs. However, without the help of the legs, the body cannot properly work. The head must give the directions to the body to go to this place or that, but if the legs are unfit to walk, the body cannot move. Therefore there must be cooperation, and this cooperation is found in the ideal state. Nowadays, rascals, fools, and asses are being voted in as administrators. If a person can secure a vote in some way or another, he is given the post of an administrator, even though he may be rascal number one. So what can be done? For this reason, people cannot be happy.

The ideal state functions under the directions of the brähmaëas. The brähmaëas themselves are not personally interested in political affairs or administration because they have a higher duty. Presently, because the head is missing, the social body is a dead body. The head is very important, and our Kåñëa consciousness movement is attempting to create some brähmaëas who can properly direct society. The administrators will be able to rule very nicely under the instructions of the philosophers and theologians—that is, God conscious people. A person who is theistic will never condone the opening of slaughterhouses. Because there are many rascals heading the government, animal slaughter is allowed. When Mahäräja Parékñit saw the personification of Kali trying to kill a cow, he immediately drew his sword and said, "Who are you? Why are you trying to kill this cow?" That was a real king.

Çyämasundara däsa: A similar social structure was also observed by Plato. However, he advocated three divisions instead of four. The guardians were men of wisdom who ruled and governed. The warriors were courageous, and they protected the others. The artisans performed their services obediently and were motivated to work by their need to satisfy their appetites. In addition, he saw in man a threefold division of intelligence, courage, and appetite, which correspond to the modes of goodness, passion, and ignorance possessed by the soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul does not possess three qualities. That is a mistake. The soul is by nature pure, but due to his contact with the modes of material nature, he is dressed differently. This Kåñëa consciousness movement aims at removing this material dress. Therefore our first instruction is, "You are not this body."

Hayagréva däsa: In The Republic, Plato states that the best form of government is an enlightened monarchy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we agree. Evaà paramparä-präptam imaà räjarñayo viduù. "This supreme science was received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way." (Bg. 4.2) A räjarñi is a saintly king who is an ideal ruler. We offer respect to Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira, Mahäräja Parékñit, and Lord Rämacandra because they set examples as ideal kings.

Hayagréva däsa: Plato maintained that when a monarchy degenerates, it becomes a tyranny. When an aristocratic rule deteriorates, it becomes an oligarchy, a government ruled by corrupt men. He considered democracy to be one of the worst forms of government because when it deteriorates, it degenerates to mob rule.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is now the case. Instead of one saintly king, there are many thousands of so-called kings who are looting the people's hard-earned money by income tax and other means. In the Vedic system, however, there was a way to keep the monarchy from degenerating into tyranny. The monarch was guided by a counsel of learned men, brähmaëas, great saintly persons. Even Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira and Lord Rämacandra were guided by brähmaëas. It was the duty of the monarch to act according to the decisions of the learned scholars, brähmaëas, and sädhus, saintly persons. When Vena Mahäräja was not ruling properly, the brähmaëas came and advised him to act otherwise. When he refused, they cursed him, and he died. The great Påthu Mahäräja was his son. A great sage is required to occupy the role of a monarch. Then everything is perfect in government. The present democratic systems are ludicrous because they are composed of rascals who simply bribe one another. When they attain their post, they plunder and take bribes. If the head of the state can understand Bhagavad-gétä, his government will be automatically perfect. Formerly, Bhagavad-gétä was explained to the monarchs for that reason. Imaà räjarñayo viduù (Bg. 4.2).

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato's system was somewhat democratic in that he felt that everyone should be given a chance to occupy the different posts.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You can also say that we are democratic because we are giving even the lowest caëòäla a chance to become a brähmaëa by becoming Kåñëa conscious. As soon as one becomes Kåñëa conscious, he can be elevated to the highest position, even though he may be born in a family of caëòälas.

aho bata çvapaco 'to garéyän
yaj-jihvägre vartate näma tubhyam
tepus tapas te juhuvuù sasnur äryä
brahmänücur näma gåëanti ye te

"O my Lord, a person who is chanting Your holy name, although born of a low family like that of a caëòäla [dog eater], is situated on the highest platform of self-realization. Such a person must have performed all kinds of penances and sacrifices according to Vedic rituals and studied the Vedic literatures many, many times after taking his bath in all the holy places of pilgrimage. Such a person is considered to be the best of the Äryan family." (Bhäg. 3.33.7)

Also, in Bhagavad-gétä, it is stated:

mäà hi pärtha vyapäçritya
ye 'pi syuù päpa-yonayaù
striyo vaiçyäs tathäçüdräs
te 'pi yänti paräà gatim

"O son of Påthä, those who take shelter in Me, though they be of lower birth—women, vaiçyas [merchants] as well as çüdras [workers]—can approach the supreme destination." (Bg. 9.32) Kåñëa says that everyone can go back home, back to Godhead. Samo 'haà sarva-bhüteñu. "I am equal to everyone. Everyone can come to Me." (Bg. 9.29) There is no hindrance.

Çyämasundara däsa: Plato believed that the state should train its citizens to become virtuous. According to his system of education, the first three years of life were spent playing and training the body. From age three to six, the children were taught religious stories. From seven to ten, they were taught gymnastics; from ten to thirteen, reading and writing; from fourteen to sixteen, poetry and music; from sixteen to eighteen, mathematics; and from eighteen to twenty, military drill. From that time on, those who were scientific and philosophical remained in school until they were thirty-five. If they were warriors, they engaged in military exercises.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Was this educational program for all men, or were there different types of education for different men?

Çyämasundara däsa: No, this applied to all.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Oh, this is not desirable. If a boy is intelligent and inclined to philosophy and theology, why should he be made to take military training?

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, according to Plato's system, everyone took two years of military drill.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But why waste two years? We cannot even waste two days.

Çyämasundara däsa: This type of education was designed in order to determine a person's category. It is not that one belongs to a particular class according to qualifications.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we also say that, but that tendency or disposition is to be ascertained by the spiritual master, by the teacher who trains the boy. The teacher should be able to see whether a boy is fit for military training, for administration, or for philosophy. It is not that everyone should take the same training. One should be trained fully according to his particular tendency. If a boy is by nature inclined to philosophical study, why should he waste his time in the military? And if he is by nature inclined to military training, why should he waste his time with other studies? Arjuna belonged to a kñatriya family, and this family was trained in the military. The Päëòavas were never trained as philosophers. Droëäcärya was their master and teacher, and although he was a brähmaëa, he taught them the military science, not brahma-vidyä. Brahma-vidyä is theology, philosophy. It is not that everyone should be trained in everything; that is a waste of time. If a student is inclined toward production, business, or agriculture, he should be trained in those fields. If he is philosophical, he should be trained as a philosopher. If he is militaristic, he should be trained as a warrior. And if he is simply dull, he should remain a çüdra, a laborer. These four classes are selected by their symptoms and qualifications. Närada Muni also says that one should be selected according to qualifications. Even if one is born in a brähmaëa family, he should be considered a çüdra if his qualifications are such. And if one is born in a çüdra family, he should be considered a brähmaëa if his symptoms are brahminical. It is not that everyone should be regarded in the same way. The spiritual master should be expert enough to recognize the tendencies of the student, and the student should immediately be trained in that line. This will bring about perfection.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Plato's system, this tendency won't emerge unless one practices everything.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, that is wrong because the soul is continuous; therefore the soul retains some tendencies from his previous birth. According to Vedic culture, immediately after a boy's birth, astrological calculations were made. Astrology can help if there is a first-class astrologer who can tell what line a boy is coming from and how he should be trained. Of course, logical and physical symptoms are considered. If a boy does not fulfill the role assigned, he can be transferred to another class. Generally, it is ascertained from birth whether a child has a particular tendency, but this tendency may change according to circumstance. Someone may have brahminical training in a previous birth, and the symptoms may be exhibited, but he should not think that because he has taken birth in a brähmaëa family that he is automatically a brähmaëa. It is not a question of birth but of qualification.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then what would you say is the purpose of the state, of all these social orders, and the state government?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The ultimate purpose is to make everyone Kåñëa conscious. That is the perfection of life. The entire social structure should be molded with this aim in view. Of course, this is not possible for everyone. All students in a university do not receive the Ph. D. degree, but the idea of perfection is to pass the Ph.D. examination. The professors of the university should be maintained, although there are not many high caliber students to pass their classes. It is not that the university should close its higher classes. Similarly, an institution like this Kåñëa consciousness Society should be maintained to make at least a small percentage of the population Kåñëa conscious.

Çyämasundara däsa: So the goal of government should be to enable everyone to become Kåñëa conscious?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, Kåñëa consciousness is the highest goal. Everyone should help and take advantage of this. Regardless of our social position, we can come to the temple and worship God. The instructions are for everyone, and prasädam is distributed to everyone; therefore there is no difficulty. Everyone can contribute to this Kåñëa consciousness movement. The brähmaëas can contribute their intelligence, the kñatriyas their charity, the vaiçyas grains, milk, fruits, and flowers, and the çüdras bodily service. By such joint cooperation, everyone attains the same goal—the highest perfection.

DS:Aristotle (384-322 B.C.)

Aristotle (384-322 B.C.)

Hayagréva däsa: Plato made a sharp distinction between the material and spiritual universes, but this dualism is not expressed by Aristotle. Since matter is simply one of God's energies, the finite reflects the infinite. Matter is a potency in the process of realizing itself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Aristotle may know something of God's energies, but our point is that we can know everything about God from God Himself. Then our knowledge is perfect. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

mayy äsakta-manäù pärtha
yogaà yuïjan mad-äçrayaù
asaàçayaà samagraà mäà
yathä jïäsyasi tac chåëu

"Now hear, O son of Påthä, how by practicing yoga in full consciousness of Me, with mind attached to Me, you can know Me in full, free from doubt." (Bg. 7.1) This is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. Of course, we may speculate about God, and if we just think of God, that will help to some extent. If we are in darkness, we may speculate and concoct ideas about the sun. This is one kind of knowledge. However, if we come out of the darkness and see the sun, if we come to the light, our knowledge is complete. We may contemplate the sun in darkness, but the best process is to come into the sunshine and see for ourselves.

Hayagréva däsa: Aristotle does not believe that material objects are trying to realize God, as Plato does, but that God is realizing Himself through material objects, and God does this in a variegated and infinite way. God realizes the potentiality of a flower, or of a man, by creating a flower or a man perceivable by the material senses. So, in a sense, the world is more real to Aristotle than to Plato.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since God has created the material world with all its variety, He is in full awareness of how to act properly. That is God's perfection. He knows how to do everything perfectly and in a natural way. A child naturally knows how to put food into his mouth. He does not have to learn this. God's knowledge of everything is already there. It is not that He has to receive this knowledge through some source, or by creating. He is already fully aware of these things. He doesn't have to realize Himself or His potentiality through matter.

Hayagréva däsa: Aristotle would say that a flower is real because it has its basis in the ultimate reality, God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is the ultimate reality, how is it He is not in full knowledge of everything at all times? There is no question of realizing Himself through matter.

Hayagréva däsa: Plato would say that a flower is but a shadow of reality. Which point of view would be closer to the Vedic version?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Whatever is in the material world is but a perverted reflection of the spiritual world. It is our experience that in the material world, objects are created, but in the spiritual world, nothing is created. Everything is there everlastingly.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle says that imperfection is inherent in the substance matter. Because man is made of matter, he must be imperfect.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Man is not made of matter but is covered by matter. Man is made of spirit. If God is spirit, man is also spirit. In the Bible, it is also said that man is made in the image of God; therefore man is originally perfect. A person is generally supposed to be healthy, but if he falls into a diseased condition, it is not his imperfection. It is something external that has attacked a healthy man. According to his original nature, man is healthy.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Aristotle, the goal of action is to realize our potential and attain the greatest happiness or pleasure. Since God created man for self-realization, it is realization that will bring him satisfaction.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that in the beginning God created man imperfect. Otherwise, why is there need for self-realization?

Çyämasundara däsa: A piece of wood has the potential to become fire. It is not fire until it is kindled. Man is similar.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that the living entity is part and parcel of God, and if God is all good, the living entity is also all good. A part of gold cannot be iron; it also must be gold. However, the part is not equal to the whole. A gold earring is also gold, but it is not as great as the gold mine. Nevertheless, the quality of the gold earring and the quality of gold in the gold mine are the same. If God is perfect, the living entity must also be perfect in quality. If God has the quality of goodness, the living entity must have it also. Why should he be imperfect? That would indicate that God is unjust. Why should God create something that has to come to the perfectional point by realization?

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle would say that the activities of the mind are pure and perfect, but that those of the body and matter are impure and imperfect. Therefore one must realize himself through the activities of the mind alone.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, the mind is never perfect. The mind's business is to accept this and reject that, and therefore it is very flickering. The mind is subtler than the body, but the mind is not the soul, nor is the mind perfect. Above the mind there is intelligence, and above the intelligence there is the soul. That soul is perfect in quality, and it has all the qualities of God in minute quantity.

Çyämasundara däsa: By mind, Aristotle means the rational faculty of intelligence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Intelligence is above the mind. Intelligence controls the mind, and intelligence is of the soul. Therefore the whole background is the soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: The mind must act or contemplate in accordance with logic. Logic is defined as the method of drawing correct inferences.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The mind may logically accept something and again logically reject it. Where, then, is perfect logic?

Çyämasundara däsa: Perfect logic is simply a method for finding the truth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But the mind is constantly accepting and rejecting. How can it ascertain the truth according to logic? If our authority is the mind, does this mean that the mind of everyone is an authority? The mind may constantly search, but it will never be successful because the truth is beyond its reach. A follower of the Vedas does not accept this speculative method as a path to truth or perfection.

Hayagréva däsa: For both Plato and Aristotle, God is known by reason, not by revelation or religious experiences.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We are all limited, and God is unlimited; therefore we cannot understand God by our limited sensory powers. Consequently, God must be known by revelation.

ataù çré-kåñëa-nämädi
na bhaved grähyam indriyaiù
sevonmukhe hi jihvädau
svayam eva sphuraty adaù

"Material senses cannot appreciate Kåñëa's holy name, form, qualities, and pastimes. When a conditioned soul is awakened to Kåñëa consciousness and renders service by using his tongue to chant the Lord's holy name and taste the remnants of the Lord's food, the tongue is purified, and one gradually comes to understand who Kåñëa really is." (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.2.234) It is not possible to know God by mental speculation. When we engage in His service, He reveals Himself. Çré Kåñëa says:

nähaà prakäçaù sarvasya
yoga-mäyä-samävåtaù
müòho 'yaà näbhijänäti
loko mäm ajam avyayam

"I am never manifest to the foolish and unintelligent. For them I am covered by My eternal creative potency [yoga-mäyä]; and so the deluded world knows Me not, who am unborn and infallible." (Bg. 7.25) It is a fact that unless God reveals Himself, He is not known. Therefore He appears, and great authorities like Vyäsadeva, Närada, Çukadeva Gosvämé, Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, and Caitanya Mahäprabhu—great scholars and transcendentalists—accept Him as He reveals Himself. Arjuna saw God face to face, and he accepted Him. When we are freed by our service, God reveals Himself.

Hayagréva däsa: Well, Aristotle emphasizes man's use of reason, and he sees man's happiness depending on acting in a rational way, which is the way of virtue and intellectual insight. There is a suggestion of sense control, but no bhakti. Is it possible to attain happiness simply by controlling the senses with the mind?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and that is the process of becoming a human being. Animals are ignorant of this process, and they act only for their sense gratification. Their only business is eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. Through proper guidance, a human being can engage in contemplation, but he should be guided by authorities, otherwise he may contemplate with his limited senses for many millions of years and not be able to understand God.

Hayagréva däsa: But for happiness, or änanda, isn't bhakti essential?

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is full änanda, full bliss. Sac-cid-änanda. He is eternal and in full knowledge of everything. Unless we come in contact with God, there is no question of änanda. Raso vai saù. From the Vedic literatures, we understand that God is the unlimited reservoir of all pleasure; consequently, when we come in contact with God, we will taste that pleasure. Material pleasure is only a perverted reflection of the real pleasure.

Çyämasundara däsa: Rather than personal guidance, Aristotle emphasized rational logic.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but when you are guided, you have to sacrifice your logic to accept the superior logic of your guide.

Çyämasundara däsa: He felt that the mind can be its own guide.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As I said, the mind will carry you this way and that. In Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna says that the mind is more difficult to control than the wind. If a horse is not controlled, if it is allowed to run at will, it will cause some disaster. When the horse is guided, it can take you to your destination. We should therefore know how to control the mind by the intelligence.

Çyämasundara däsa: But because the mind is an aspect of God, we find our perfection or happiness in the contemplation of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everything is an aspect of God. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa points out that He has eight separated energies. So why stress the mind? Because we have lost God's association, we are all searching after Him. We are struggling, but we do not know why. This is due to ignorance. If, by good fortune, we chance to meet a bona fide guru, the guru can inform us, "You are searching after God. This is the way. You only have to follow." It is then that we can become happy.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle believed that the truth is inherent or innate within everything. For him, truth is the agreement of knowledge with reality. It corresponds with things in the objective world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If truth is within everything, then it must be drawn out. However, it is not drawn out by matter but by spirit. This means that the help of a superior energy is necessary. According to Bhagavad-gétä, the living entity is the superior energy, and matter is the inferior. It is the inferior energy that must be controlled by the superior. Both God and the living entities are eternal, but God is the Supreme Eternal. Living entities are nitya-kåñëa-däsa, eternal servants of God. When they tend to disobey God, they suffer. If we want to use our logic, we can understand that through our independent action, we have failed. Therefore we must take the advice of superior intelligence. That advice is given in Bhagavad-gétä. It is not that we can attain the truth through our own independent speculation. If we want to know who our father is, we may speculate forever, but it is much simpler to ask our mother. Otherwise we may go on searching and searching for millions of years and never know. What is the point in all this vain research? We should conclude that insofar as we are in the material, illusory condition, it is our duty to take help from God or His representative, who does not set forth anything that is not originally spoken by God. For instance, God says, "Surrender unto Me," and God's representative says, "Surrender unto God." If a rascal says, "I am God," he should be kicked. The living entities are part and parcel of God, and a part can never become the whole. A real representative of God acknowledges himself as the servant of God, and he requests everyone to surrender unto God. For perfect knowledge, we have to take guidance either directly from God, as Arjuna did, or from God's representative. Then we will be successful in ascertaining the truth.

Hayagréva däsa: Aristotle outlines three different conceptions of the soul: one, the soul itself is a separate substance; two, the body is but the instrument of the soul; and three, the soul is the actual form of the body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The body is like the clothes of the soul, and our clothes are designed to fit our body. A coat has arms because we have arms, and pants have legs because we have legs. So the body is like the coat and pants of the soul, and since the body has form, the soul also has the same form. The cloth, which is the body, originally has no shape, but when it comes into contact with the soul, it assumes a shape.

Çyämasundara däsa: It appears that Aristotle equates the soul with the intelligence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul has intelligence, but his intelligence is misused if it is limited to the mind. The intelligence should rise above the mind. The mind is superior to gross matter, the intelligence is superior to the mind, and the soul is superior to the intelligence. Superior to the soul is the ultimate cause of the soul, the Supreme Lord.

Çyämasundara däsa: Because he equates the soul's immortality with reason, Aristotle believes that it is only the rational soul, the human soul, that is immortal. Animals also have souls, but he saw them limited to sense, desire, and animation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Animals are also rational. If a dog enters my room, and I say, "Out!" the dog immediately understands and goes away. How can we say that there is no rationality at work? If I place my finger before an ant, that ant will turn away immediately. If you give a cow meat, the cow will not touch it. The cow understands that its food consists of grasses and grains. Animals have rationality, but one aspect of rationality is lacking: an animal cannot think of God. This is the main difference between animals and men. A man's rationality is so developed that he can think of God, whereas an animal cannot. But we should not think that the souls of animals are not immortal. This theory has given the Christians a basis for killing animals, but they cannot prove that an animal's soul is irrational or mortal. A man eats, sleeps, defends, and mates, and an animal does the same. So what is the difference?

Çyämasundara däsa: Perhaps the difference is one of mental activity. A man has the capacity to think in a more complicated way.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But mental activity means accepting and rejecting. Animals also accept and reject; therefore they have mental activity.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what of developed intelligence?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Of course, man has a more highly developed intelligence, but we should not think that an animal has no intelligence at all. The father has more intelligence than his small child, but this is because the child has not grown to attain that standard. Similarly, an animal is making progress up the evolutionary scale. It has intelligence, but it is not highly developed. Plants, animals, and men possess consciousness. It has been proven by Doctor Jagadish Candra Bose that a tree is conscious of your cutting it. However, the tree does not feel it very much. If you hit an animal, the animal feels it more, and if you hit a man, a man feels it even more than an animal. It is a question of developed consciousness, of developed intelligence. That development has to do with the body. As soon as you receive the body of a tree, your consciousness is plugged up. It is not so active. When you attain the human form, consciousness is more developed, and that developed consciousness should be further developed so that you can come to Kåñëa consciousness, which is the highest perfection of the living entity.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle conceived of the soul as having a dual nature. There is an individual soul, which awakens at birth and acquires impressions during one's lifetime. Thus it grows and develops, but it is not eternal. It is subject to conditioning. It is like the souls of animals. Then there is also a rational soul, the active soul, which is eternal, though not perfect. This is man's motivating principle and purpose for living.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is the eternal, changeless soul. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

bahüni me vyatétäni
janmäni tava cärjuna
täny ahaà veda sarväëi
na tvaà vettha parantapa

"Many, many births both you and I have passed. I can remember all of them, but you cannot, O subduer of the enemy!" (Bg. 4.5) That is the real meaning of eternity—eternal knowledge. Thus there are two kinds of souls: the Supersoul (Paramätmä), who is Kåñëa Himself, and the ordinary soul (jéva), which is possessed by every living entity.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Aristotle, the rational soul is eternal, yet he says that it is not perfect.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he has to accept two souls, one perfect and rational, and another imperfect and irrational. The soul that is perfect and rational is Kåñëa, the Supersoul.

Çyämasundara däsa: He doesn't say anything about the Supersoul accompanying the individual soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is because he does not know. He suggests that there is a dual nature, but he has no idea. The dual nature he refers to is not of the soul but the mind. The soul is one. When you are on the mental platform, it appears that the soul has a dual nature, but when the soul's perfection is attained, you think only of Kåñëa. There is no question of duality.

Hayagréva däsa: In Politics, Aristotle writes: "The beauty of the body is seen, but the beauty of the soul is not seen." Is this true?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The beauty of the soul is real, and the beauty of the body is superficial. In the material world, we see many ugly and many beautiful bodies, but here ugliness and beauty are artificial. The beauty of the soul, however, is real, not artificial. Unless we see the beauty of the Supersoul, Kåñëa, we have no idea what actual beauty is. Therefore the devotees want to see the beauty of Kåñëa, not the artificial beauty of this material world.

Hayagréva däsa: Is there no correspondence between a beautiful body and a beautiful soul? Aren't they linked by karma?

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is some correspondence because we say that this material world is a perverted reflection of the spiritual. Originally, the soul is beautiful, but here that beauty is covered. We can only have a glimpse of the real beauty from the material covering, but we have to wait in order to see the actual beauty of the soul. That beauty is the real form of the body.

Hayagréva däsa: It is said that Socrates was physically ugly but that he had a very beautiful soul, and consequently people were attracted to him.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In India, it is said that the quail is black and ugly like a crow, but when it sings, its song is so beautiful that people are attracted. The beauty of the body is secondary, and the beauty of the soul is primary. A beautiful man who is a fool is beautiful only as long as he does not speak. As soon as he speaks, we can understand his actual position. Essentially, external beauty is useless. If an ugly man speaks well, he attracts many people, and if a beautiful man speaks nonsense, no one cares for him. Real attraction is one thing, and artificial attraction is another.

Çyämasundara däsa: In man's search for truth, the role of logic is paramount. According to Aristotle's principle of contradiction, a proposition cannot be both true and false at the same time.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is on the relative platform. At one time we may accept something to be true, and at another time we may reject it as untrue. On the mental platform we cannot know what is true and what is not. Therefore we have to learn the truth from the Supreme Truth. Truth is truth. It is not subject to speculation. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that after many lives of speculation, the man of wisdom surrenders unto the Supreme Absolute Truth. In the beginning, a man may employ deductive logic, but in the end, he surrenders. He comes to the conclusion: Väsudevaù sarvam iti (Bg. 7.19). "God is everything; therefore I must surrender." This is the perfection and ultimate end of the mental processes of speculation. That is, speculation is abandoned.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle more or less utilizes the process of saìkhya-yoga by analyzing objects and placing them into general categories. These categories become more and more general until one reaches the final cause, or ultimate category.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this is the process of neti-neti, by which one eventually hopes to attain Brahman by understanding what Brahman is not. According to this process, one goes through the universe saying neti-neti, "This is not Brahman, that is not Brahman. This is not truth, that is not truth." This is the same inductive process. For instance, if you want to determine whether or not man is mortal, you may search from man to man and conclude whether each man is mortal or not. In this way, you can go on indefinitely seeing that all men are dying. Then why not accept the fact that man is mortal? In your attempt to find an immortal man, you are bound to be frustrated. You will only find mortality. This is the result of the neti-neti process.

Çyämasundara däsa: The idea is that through this process, we can come to the final cause, the final category.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The final category is that we are part and parcel of God. That's all.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle believed that matter as such has an inherent design. If it did not, it would be devoid of shape or form. Brute matter has to be activated; otherwise it would remain in a dormant state of nonexistence. Matter must be acted upon from without in order to be realized.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that the Supreme Absolute must have form. Éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù (Brahma-saàhitä 5.1). The word vigraha indicates form. That form is not dead but is the activating spirit. Kåñëa's form is sac-cid-änanda, eternal, fully cognizant, and blissful. Our bodies are neither fully cognizant nor fully blissful, but Kåñëa's is. He knows past, present, and future, and He is always happy. Our knowledge is limited, and we are always full of anxieties.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Aristotle, a form has innate purpose, or entelechy. Therefore all matter has some form for its actualization. The world is an unfolding of phenomena realizing itself. In other words, nature has a purpose.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We agree with this. According to Padma Puräëa, there are 8,400,000 various forms, and none of them are accidental. By karma, one receives a particular type of form. Brahmä receives his form according to his karma, and the dog or cat receives his form according to his. There is no question of accident. Nature unfolds in accordance with a plan, by virtue of which these various forms are existing.

yas tv indra-gopam athavendram aho sva-karma-
bandhänurüpa-phala-bhäjanam ätanoti
karmäëi nirdahati kintu ca bhakti-bhäjäà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"Let me offer my respectful obeisances unto the original Personality of Godhead, Govinda, who regulates the sufferings and enjoyments of fruitive activity for everyone: from the heavenly King Indra down to the smallest insect [indra-gopa]. That very Personality of Godhead destroys the fruitive karma of one engaged in devotional service." (Brahma-saàhitä, 5.54) From Indra down to indra-gopa, a microscopic germ, all living entities are working out the results of their karma. If one's karma is good, he attains a higher form; if it is not good, he attains a lower form.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle also believed that everything is designed by God for the attainment of some particular objective. This indicates a grand scheme.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is the process of evolution. The living entity passes from one species to another, from trees to vegetables, to insects, to fish, birds, beasts, and humans. In the human form, evolution is fully manifest. It is like a flower unfolding from a bud. When the living entity attains the human form, his proper duty is to understand his lost relationship with God. If he misses this opportunity, he may regress. Aristotle is correct therefore in saying that everything has a purpose. The whole creative process aims at bringing the living entity back to Godhead.

Çyämasundara däsa: Does everything eventually come to that point?

Çréla Prabhupäda: As a human being, you can properly utilize your consciousness, or you can misuse it. That is up to you. Kåñëa gives Arjuna instructions and then tells him that the decision is up to him. Under the orders of Kåñëa, nature has brought you through so many species. Now, as a human, you have a choice whether to return to God or again undergo the cycle of birth and death. If you are fortunate, you make the proper choice according to the instructions of the spiritual master and Kåñëa. Then your life is successful.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle sees a hierarchy of forms extending from minerals, vegetables, animals, to human beings, and ultimately God, who is pure form and pure act. God is devoid of all potentiality, or materiality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no guarantee that we will move upwards in that hierarchy. It is a fact that the individual soul transmigrates from one form to another, but how can you say that the next form you attain will be closer to perfection? If you have a human form in this life, there is no guarantee that you will get a higher form in the next. You accept another form just as you accept another dress. That dress may be valuable, or of no value whatsoever. I get a dress according to the price I pay, and I accept a form according to my work.

Çyämasundara däsa: But in order to attain perfection, we must move toward God. This is the goal for which the living entity is initially created.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is very expertly explained in Vedic literature as karma, akarma, and vikarma. You bring about your own form. You enjoy or suffer according to your work. In any case, a material form is never perfect because it undergoes six changes. It is born, grows, it stays for a while, it leaves some by-products, dwindles, and then vanishes. When your form vanishes, you have to take on another form, which also undergoes the same processes. When a form vanishes, it decomposes, and various elements return to nature. Water returns to water, earth returns to earth, air returns to air, and so forth.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle's God is the unmoved mover. He is perfect, and He wants nothing. He does not have to actualize Himself because He is completely actualized.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We also agree that God is all perfect. Paräçara Muni defines God as the totality of wisdom, strength, wealth, fame, beauty, and renunciation. All these qualities are possessed by Kåñëa in full, and when Kåñëa was present, anyone could see that He was all perfect. One who is perfect can rule others, and we accept the leadership of a person according to his degree of perfection. If one is not somewhat wise, beautiful, wealthy, and so forth, why should we accept him as a leader? One who is supremely perfect in all these qualities is the supreme leader. That is natural. Since Kåñëa is supremely perfect, we should accept Him as our leader.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle sees God as pure thought (nous). God's life is the life of the mind, but God does not need to do anything to further perfect Himself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When he says that God is mind, what does he mean? Does he have some conception of God's personality? God must be a person. Otherwise, how could He think?

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle sees God as constantly engaged in self-contemplation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Does this mean that when one is perfect, he engages in no activity? Does God simply sit down and meditate? If so, what is the difference between a stone and God? A stone sits; it has no activity. How is inactivity perfection? Kåñëa never meditates, yet when He speaks, He delivers perfect knowledge. Kåñëa enacts various pastimes: He fights with demons, protects His devotees, dances with the gopés, and delivers words of enlightenment. There is no question of God sitting down like a stone and engaging in self-meditation.

Çyämasundara däsa: But is it not possible to meditate while acting?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly, but God doesn't have to meditate. Why should He meditate? He is perfect. Meditation means coming from the imperfect stage to the perfect stage. Since God is perfect to begin with, what business does He have meditating? Everything is actualized by His will alone.

Çyämasundara däsa: Doesn't He contemplate His own activities?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why should He if He is perfect? Aristotle recommends that a man should meditate to become perfect. This meditation presupposes imperfection. Contemplation is recommended for living entities, but we should understand that whatever God desires or wills immediately comes into being. This information is given in the Vedas. Paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate. God's multi-energies are so powerful that everything is immediately actualized as soon as He desires.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what about the meditations of the Buddha?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Buddha's mission was different. He was setting an example for miscreants who were engaged in mischievous activities. He was recommending that they sit down and meditate, just as you tell a mischievous child to sit in a corner and be quiet.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, Aristotle isn't saying that we should put an end to our activities. Rather, we should always contemplate God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is our process, as recommended by Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù
smaraëaà päda-sevanam
arcanaà vandanaà däsyaà
sakhyam ätma-nivedanam

iti puàsärpitä viñëau
bhaktiç cen nava-lakñaëä
kriyeta bhagavaty addhä
tan manye 'dhétam uttamam

"Hearing and chanting about the transcendental holy name, form, qualities, paraphernalia, and pastimes of Lord Viñëu, remembering them, serving the lotus feet of the Lord, offering the Lord respectful worship with sixteen types of paraphernalia, offering prayers to the Lord, becoming His servant, considering the Lord one's best friend, and surrendering everything unto Him [in other words, serving Him with the body, mind, and words]—these nine processes are accepted as pure devotional service. One who has dedicated his life to the service of Kåñëa through these nine methods should be understood to be the most learned person, for he has acquired complete knowledge." (Bhäg. 7.5.23-24)

We should always think of Viñëu. Kåñëa consciousness means remembering Kåñëa and acting for Him. When you sweep Kåñëa's temple, you remember Kåñëa. When you cook for Kåñëa, you remember Kåñëa. When you talk about Kåñëa, you remember Kåñëa. This is also the process recommended in Bhagavad-gétä. The topmost yogé is always thinking of Kåñëa.

yoginäm api sarveñäà
mad-gatenäntarätmanä
çraddhävän bhajate yo mäà
sa me yuktatamo mataù

"And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all." (Bg. 6.47)

Hayagréva däsa: For Aristotle, God essentially does not have any knowledge of the world, and consequently He cannot return the love He receives. He neither loves nor cares for mankind.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What kind of God is this? If one knows nothing of God, one should not speak of God. God certainly reciprocates. As we offer our love to God, He responds and cooperates accordingly. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

ye yathä mäà prapadyante
täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham
mama vartmänuvartante
manuñyäù pärtha sarvaçaù

"All of them—as they surrender unto Me—I reward accordingly. Everyone follows My path in all respects, O son of Påthä." (Bg. 4.11) When we fully surrender to God in loving service, we can understand God's nature.

Hayagréva däsa: For Aristotle, God is loved by everything in the universe, and He attracts all objects in the universe just as a magnet attracts nails. Everything is striving toward Him and longing for Him, but there is no mention of Him as a person. Yet Aristotle speaks of God as pure form. Would this be an imagined form like that of the Mäyävädés?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it appears that Aristotle is Mäyävädé. One has to speculate if he does not receive perfect knowledge from God Himself. Unless God is all attractive, how can He be God? Therefore the word "Kåñëa," which means "all attractive," is the perfect name for God because God is attracting everyone. In Våndävana, He attracts His parents, the cowherd boys and girls, the animals, the fruits and flowers, the water—everything. You have read the descriptions of how the water of the Yamunä stopped flowing as soon as she saw Kåñëa. So even the water was attracted to Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle believed that thought and activity are one with God. There is no dualism because God is pure act and pure thought.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is so. God only needs to think of a thing for that thing to be created or actualized. God's thinking, feeling, willing, and acting are the same. Because I am imperfect, when I think of something, it may or may not happen, but whenever God thinks something it takes place. Because Kåñëa thought that the battle of Kurukñetra should take place, there was no stopping it. At first, Arjuna declined to fight, but Kåñëa plainly told him that whether he fought or not, most of the people there were destined to die. He therefore told Arjuna to become an instrument and take the credit for killing them. No one can check whatever God decides. It doesn't matter whether you help God or not, but it is for your interest that you become His instrument.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle says that one should perform his activities in such a way that he is always contemplating God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the process of bhakti. Unless one is a devotee, how can he constantly think of God? Rüpa Gosvämé gives the example of a woman who has a paramour other than her husband. She performs her household chores very nicely, but she is always thinking, "When will my lover come at night?" If it is possible to think of someone like this all the time materially, why not spiritually? It is a question of practice. Despite engaging in so many different types of work, you can think of God incessantly. Now, Aristotle may have some conception of God, but he has no clear idea of Kåñëa's personality. We can think specifically and concretely of God because we receive information from Vedic literature that God is a person and appears a certain way. In Bhagavad-gétä, it is stated that impersonalists experience a great deal of trouble because they have no clear idea of God.

kleço 'dhikataras teñäm
avyaktäsakta-cetasäm
avyaktähi gatir duùkhaà
dehavadbhir aväpyate

"For those whose minds are attached to the unmanifested, impersonal feature of the Supreme, advancement is very troublesome. To make progress in that discipline is always difficult for those who are embodied." (Bg. 12.5) If you have no conception of God's form, your attempt to realize God will be very difficult.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle conceives of God as the greatest good, as pure thought. When we act, we should always contemplate the good. In this way, we can lead a godly life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You cannot contemplate the good unless you are guided by the good. Arjuna, for instance, was guided by the Supreme Good; therefore despite his activity, which was fighting, he performed the greatest good.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle believes that there is a grand design in the universe because everything is evolving from one form to another to realize its most perfect form. Everything is being attracted by the most perfect form.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Does he say that there is only one perfect form, or a variety of perfect forms? What does he mean? Is everyone striving to come to the perfect form? Is that form one or various?

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, since each material form is designed by God and moves toward God in its longing for perfection, there must be a variety of forms.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If that is the case, it tallies with the Vedic conception. We say that Kåñëa and His associates are perfect; therefore this flower, for instance, attains its perfect form when it is in Kåñëa-loka, Kåñëa's planet. Everything in Kåñëa-loka is perfect because everything there is directly related to Kåñëa. Consequently, in Kåñëa-loka, the Yamunä River, the Våndävana forest, the flowers, the beasts, the birds, and the men and women are nondifferent from Kåñëa.

änanda-cinmaya-rasa-pratibhävitäbhis
täbhir ya eva nija-rüpatayä kaläbhiù
goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhüto
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who resides in His own realm, Goloka, with Rädhä, who resembles His own spiritual figure and who embodies the ecstatic potency [hlädiné]. Their companions are Her confidantes, who embody extensions of Her bodily form, and who are imbued and permeated with ever-blissful spiritual rasa." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.37)

When Brahmä stole all the cowherd boys and calves, Kåñëa immediately expanded Himself into many cowherd boys and calves, each with different features and mentalities. The mothers of the cowherd boys could not understand that their real sons had been stolen. Because Kåñëa was substituting for them, the mothers' love for their sons increased. Thus Kåñëa can expand Himself in many ways—as cows, calves, trees, boys, girls, and so on. Yet Kåñëa is still one.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle would say that since God has a spiritual form, He is without plurality in the sense that He is composed of no parts. In other words, He is pure spirit.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, God is one without plurality. The sun may be visible to millions of persons, still the sun is one. At noon, millions of men may claim, "The sun is over my head," but does this mean that everyone has a different sun? No, the sun is one, but the sun can represent itself variously.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle gave two arguments for God's existence. One is that there is a design in the universe, and a design presupposes a designer. The other holds that there must be a first cause, a cause of all causes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is so. A designer moreover presupposes a person. Kåñëa explains in Bhagavad-gétä:

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again." (Bg. 9.10) Kåñëa is also the directing cause, the puruña, the cause of all causes. Anädir ädir govindaù sarva-käraëa-käraëam. "Govinda [Kåñëa] is the origin of all. He has no other origin, and He is the prime cause of all causes." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.1)

Hayagréva däsa: In Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle writes: "Moral excellence is concerned with pleasure and pain; it is pleasure that makes us perform base action, and pain that prevents us from acting nobly. For that reason, as Plato says, men must be reared from childhood to feel pleasure and pain at the proper things. This is proper education." How does this correspond to the Vedic view of education?

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Vedic view, there is no pleasure in this material world. We may make all kinds of arrangements for pleasure, but we may suddenly have to die. So where is the pleasure? If we make arrangements for pleasure and then do not enjoy it, we are disappointed. We are constantly trying to attain pleasure by inventing so many contrivances, but because we are controlled by some superior force, we may at any moment be kicked out of our house of pleasure. The conclusion is that there is no pleasure in this material world. Pleasure here is an illusion, a mirage. In a desert, you may hallucinate water, but ultimately you will die of thirst.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Aristotle, virtue is the golden mean, or that activity between two extreme activities. By his intelligence, man can perceive and act upon that golden mean. Ultimately, all virtues are summed up in the virtue of justice, which means doing the right thing for everyone concerned so that everyone's rights will be protected.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if everyone's rights are to be protected, how can you kill animals? Why shouldn't animals have the right to live? According to the Vedic conception, even if you kill one ant unconsciously, you are responsible. Because we are killing so many ants and microbes unconsciously, we therefore have to perform païca-yajïa, sacrifice. We may consciously avoid killing animals, but we may be unconsciously killing many. Therefore, in either case, sacrifice is compulsory.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle believes that virtue can be analyzed, that any situation can be analyzed by the intelligence, and then that intelligence can be applied to correct action.

Çréla Prabhupäda: By intelligence he should try to understand whether or not animals have souls. If an animal doesn't have a soul, how is it he is acting like a human being? He is eating, sleeping, mating and defending. How can you say he has no soul? The life symptoms are the same.

Çyämasundara däsa: He equates the immortal soul with rational activity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, animals have rational activities. I have already explained this. A philosopher certainly must know the symptoms of the soul, and these must be defined. We receive perfect information on this subject from Bhagavad-gétä, when Kåñëa says:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father." (Bg. 14.4)

Does this mean that God is the father only of human beings? For instance, the Jews say that they are the only selected people of God. But what kind of God is this who selects some people and condemns others? This is God: Kåñëa says, sarva-yoni. "I am the father of all species of life," Everyone is God's son. How can I kill and eat any living entity? He is my brother in any case. Suppose a man has five sons, and two of them are fools. Does this mean that the intelligent sons have the right to kill and eat the foolish ones? Would the father like this? Who would ask the father, "Father, these two sons are fools and useless rascals. So let us cut them to pieces and eat them."? Will the father agree to this? Or will the state agree? And why should God agree?

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle claims that one can use his intelligence to practice virtue, but you once said that because a thief considers theft a virtue, he can use his intelligence to steal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a thief's intelligence has been described as duñkåtina. The word kåti means "very meritorious," and the word duñ means "misapplied." Is that virtuous when one's intelligence is misapplied? When merit and intelligence are properly used for the proper activity, that is virtue. Such activity will not entangle a man. That is intelligence and virtue.

Çyämasundara däsa: Ambition is one of the Aristotelean virtues, but one can have the ambition to steal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it was Hitler's ambition to become total ruler of Europe. He killed many people and then finally killed himself. So what was all this ambition worth? All these politicians are very ambitious, but they are ambitious to unlawfully encroach upon the rights of others. We should have the ambition to become the sincere servant of God. That is real ambition.

Çyämasundara däsa: Among virtues, Aristotle includes courage, temperance, liberality, magnificence, and ambition.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is the magnificence of killing animals? How can you have no kindness for poor animals and yet talk of magnificence? Haräv abhaktasya (Bhäg. 5.18.12). If your ultimate conclusion is not God consciousness, you have no good qualities. You can be neither a scientist, nor a philosopher, because you are narädhama, hovering on the mental platform. Thus you concoct so many theories.

Çyämasundara däsa: As far as Aristotle's social philosophy is concerned, he says that man is basically a political and social animal and that he must exist in some society in order to fulfill himself. Men live together to transcend their crude natural condition and arrive at a civilized culture of ethical and intellectual life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If that is done, that is all right, but he is philosophizing that animals have no souls. Following his philosophy, people are saying, "Let's kill the animals and eat them." So what is the benefit of this grouping together in a society? We should instead group together to cultivate knowledge of God. This is what is required. What is the use in living together just to plunder other nations and kill other living entities? Such a group is a group of rogues and gangsters. Even today in the United Nations people are grouping together and planning to encroach upon one another. So what is the point in all these groups of gangsters?

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle is talking about the ideal way a state or a political body should be organized. He says that ideally a state should be formed in order to educate men to the highest level.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if we do not know what is education, or if we do not know the highest level of education, or if we do not even know the primary principles of a virtuous life, how can we speak of such things? Therefore we should be very careful to take bona fide guidance. According to Vedic civilization, Manu is the law-giver, and he is considered perfect. Manu, for instance, states that a woman should not be given independence. Now, certain groups are asking, "Why not?" Thus there is a confrontation, and Manu is surely being attacked, but Manu's conception is right in any case. Instruction should be taken from liberated persons. What can a group of fools do? One liberated personality like Manu can give the right directions. Presently, in the name of independence, there is havoc.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle's state would be tightly controlled either by a monarch or a group of men intellectually and morally superior. These would guide the rest of the people.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that would be very nice. Unless one is morally superior, he cannot guide. Nowadays, in democracies, all kinds of rascals are voted into positions of authority. What is the use in such groups?

Çyämasundara däsa: Aristotle condemns democracy because in a democracy each person strives for his own self-interest.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is going on. Monarchy is good if the monarch is trained in such a way that he can rule properly. That was the Vedic system. Even then, the monarch was controlled by great sages. In a proper government, the brähmaëas and sages should form an advisory committee. They should not participate in politics. The kñatriyas, who are ambitious to rule, should rule under the guidance of the brähmaëas and sages. Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira was very pious, and people were very happy because he acted under the guidance of brähmaëas and sages. Formerly, the monarch was guided by priestly, religious, or saintly people. That was very nice. This Kåñëa consciousness movement can guide society, but presently society is in such a state that it does not even want to consider the importance of this movement. This is unfortunate. Still, we have to struggle to spread Kåñëa consciousness because we are representatives of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa's desires are our commands.

IITHE EARLY THEISTS

IITHE EARLY THEISTS

DS:Plotinus (205?-270 A.D.)

Plotinus (205?-270 A.D.)

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus, as well as Origen, studied philosophy in Alexandria under the supposed founder of Neo-Platonism, Ammonius Saccas. Plotinus ascribed to a theory of emanation, which holds that the soul emanates from the intelligence just as the intelligence emanates from the One. The intelligence (nous) is multiple and yet one at the same time. The One is omnipresent, devoid of multiplicity, impersonal, and transcendental. For Plotinus, there is a kind of hierarchy headed by the One, to which the intelligence and individual souls are subordinate.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Vedic conception, the Supreme Absolute Truth is one. The individual souls are of the same quality as the Supreme One, but they are fragmental parts, and they emanate from Him. The individual souls have the same intelligence and mind, but their jurisdiction is limited. As individual souls, we are present, but we are not omnipresent. God is omnipresent. We have some knowledge, but we are not omniscient. We are not dull matter, but are sentient beings. The Supreme One has all spiritual qualities in full, whereas we have them in minute quantity. We are like sparks, and the Supreme One is like a great fire. That is our constitutional position in relation to the One. When sparks fly away from a great fire, they are extinguished. When we turn from the One, our illumination is obscured, and we are enveloped in mäyä, darkness. If we revive our relationship with the One, we can revive our illuminating power, which is our spiritual power, and live with the Supreme One in a peaceful, eternal life of bliss.

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus was an impersonalist in that he believed that by attributing qualities to God, we necessarily limit Him. Although the One is transcendental, there is no multiplicity in Him. At the same time, God is the cause of all multiplicities.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Vedic conception, the Supreme One is the cause of all living entities.

nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm
eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän
tam ätmasthaà ye 'nupaçyanti dhéräs
teñäàçäntiùçäçvaté netareñäm
(Kaöha 2.2.13)

In the Kaöha Upaniñad, as well as the Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad, it is said that the Supreme Personality of Godhead maintains innumerable living entities. He is the Supreme Eternal Being. Among eternal living beings, He is the chief. He has unlimited transcendental qualities and is therefore omnipresent, omniscient, and omnipotent. If He did not have these qualities, He could not be perfect. He is the unlimited cause of everything, and, being unlimited, cannot be limited. I do not know what Plotinus means when he says that God's attributes are limiting. In no way can God be limited. Everything is Brahman unlimitedly. Mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni (Bg. 9.4). Everything emanates from Him, and everything rests on Him. Considered impersonally, God is everywhere, and considered personally, He is localized. The impersonal effulgence, however, emanates from the person. This is verified by Bhagavad-gétä:

brahmaëo hi pratiñöhäham
amåtasyävyayasya ca
çäçvatasya ca dharmasya
sukhasyaikäntikasya ca

"And I am the basis of the impersonal Brahman, which is the constitutional position of ultimate happiness, and which is immortal, imperishable, and eternal." (Bg. 14.27)

Although the sun is situated in one place, its rays are distributed throughout the universe; similarly, the Supreme Lord unlimitedly expands His transcendental impersonal feature, the brahmajyoti. If we consider the personality, it may appear that He is limited, but He is not.

Through His energies, He is unlimited.

vadanti tat tattva-vidas
tattvaà yaj jïänam advayam
brahmeti paramätmeti
bhagavän iti çabdyate

"Learned transcendentalists who know the Absolute Truth call this nondual substance Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagävan." (Bhäg. 1.2.11) The impersonal feature is all-pervading. The localized aspect, the Paramätmä, is also omnipresent, living within the hearts of all living entities. The personal feature, the Paramätmä, is even within every atom and is thus worshipped by the devotee. When the devotee is present, the Supreme Lord is also personally present, although He resides in Goloka Våndävana. That is the nature of His omnipresence. No one can calculate the distance to Goloka Våndävana, but when a devotee like Prahläda is in danger, the Supreme Lord is immediately present. He can protect His devotee even though He be trillions of miles away. This is the meaning of omnipresence.

Hayagréva däsa: Although Plotinus believed that God is present in all objects throughout the universe, God remains distinct from all created things and also transcendental to them. Thus God is more than all pervading.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is clearly explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

mayätatam idaà sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

na ca mat-sthäni bhütäni
paçya me yogam aiçvaram
bhüta-bhån na ca bhüta-stho
mamätmä bhüta-bhävanaù

yathäkäça-sthito nityaà
väyuù sarvatra-go mahän
tathä sarväëi bhütäni
mat-sthänéty upadhäraya

"By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them. And yet everything that is created does not rest in Me. Behold My mystic opulence! Although I am the maintainer of all living entities, and although I am everywhere, still My Self is the very source of creation. As the mighty wind, blowing everywhere, always rests in ethereal space, know that in the same manner all beings rest in Me." (Bg. 9.4-6)

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus envisioned the individual souls existing in different states: some embodied, others unembodied. Some are celestial and do not suffer, whereas others are terrestrial. In any case, they are all individuals.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No one can count the number of souls. They have the same qualities possessed by the One, but they have them in minute quantity. Some of these souls have fallen into the material atmosphere, whereas others, called nitya-mukta, are everlastingly liberated. The nitya-muktas are never conditioned. These souls that have fallen into this material world in order to gratify their senses are called nitya-baddha, eternally conditioned. By "eternal," we mean that no one can estimate the amount of time the conditioned soul has to spend within the material world. The creation goes on perpetually; sometimes it is manifest and sometimes not. Without Kåñëa consciousness, the conditioned souls continue to exist within the material world. Before the creation, the conditioned soul is present in a dormant condition, and when the manifestation comes out from the Mahä-viñëu, the individual soul awakens. For the deliverance of such conditioned souls, the Supreme Personality of Godhead descends Himself, or sends His incarnation or devotee to call the nitya-baddhas back home, back to Godhead. Those who are fortunate take advantage of this. Those who are unfortunate are not interested and thus remain conditioned within this material world. The material world is created and annihilated, and the conditioned souls suffer in this cycle.

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus believed that the soul is eternal and incorporeal in men, animals, and even plants. In this, he differed from many other philosophers at the time.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is also the Vedic conclusion (sarva-yoniñu) that the living soul, which is part and parcel of God, is present in all different life species. Those who are foolish think the animal has no soul, but there is no rational basis for this belief. An animal may be less intelligent than a man, just as a child may be less intelligent than his father, but this does not mean that no soul is present. This type of mentality is ruining civilization. People have become so degraded that they even think that an embryo has no soul. From Kåñëa we understand that everyone has a soul and that the soul is undoubtedly present in all different life forms. The individual soul evolves from a lower type of body to a higher one, and this is the meaning of spiritual evolution. Once in the human form, the individual soul can understand the teachings of Bhagavad-gétä, and, if he likes, surrender to the Supreme Lord and return to the Godhead. If he does not care to do so, he remains in this material world to undergo the tribulations of repeated birth, old age, disease, and death. Thus he takes on another corporeal body.

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus sees the soul as returning to God, the One, through three stages. In the first, the individual soul must learn detachment from the material world. In the second, he separates himself from the reasoning process itself. This is the highest point that philosophy or mental speculation can attain. In the third stage, the intellect transcends itself into the realm of the unknown, the One. Plotinus writes: "Because it is intellect, it contemplates what it contemplates [the One] by reasoning of that in it which is not intellect."

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Vedas, there are also three stages: karma, jïäna, and yoga. The karmés try to improve their condition by material science and education. Some try to go to the heavenly planets by performing pious activities. Superior to the karmés are the jïänés, who speculate on the Absolute Truth and conclude that God is impersonal. The yogés attempt to acquire some mystic powers by practicing the mystic yoga system. By this system, they acquire añöa-siddhi, eight different perfections. They can become lighter than the lightest, smaller than the smallest, bigger than the biggest, and so on. Real yoga, however, means seeing the Supreme within the core of the heart. All three processes require a strenuous endeavor. The supreme process is bhakti-yoga, whereby one simply surrenders to the Supreme. The Supreme One gives the bhakti-yogé the intelligence by which he can be freed from material entanglement.

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." (Bg. 10.10)

Hayagréva däsa: For Plotinus, matter is evil in the sense that it imprisons the soul, yet the visible cosmos is beautiful. Evil does not arise from the creator.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, being attracted by this illusory energy, the individual soul comes here for sense gratification. The Supreme Lord does not desire him to come, but he comes propelled by his personal desires. God gives the living entity freedom, and in the beginning, the conditioned living entity begins life from a very exalted position in this material world. Sometimes he has the powers of a Brahmä, but due to material activities, he becomes entangled and degraded. He can thus fall from the position of a Brahmä to that of a worm in stool. Therefore we find so many different species. Degradation and elevation are thus taking place, and the living entity is sometimes elevated and sometimes degraded. In this way, he suffers. When he understands that degradation and elevation are perpetually taking place, and are the cause of his suffering, he begins to seek for the Supreme One, Kåñëa. By the grace of Kåñëa, he gets a bona fide spiritual master, and by the mercy of both, he gets a chance to engage in devotional service. With a little effort and sincerity, the conditioned living entity attains perfection in devotional service and returns back to Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: Although most of Plotinus's philosophy deals with the impersonal aspect, he writes, "Let us flee to the beloved fatherland. The fatherland for us is there whence we have come. There is the Father."

Çréla Prabhupäda: As long as we speculate, we will be confused and will not know whether the Supreme Absolute Truth is personal or impersonal. However, when there is a question of love between the Absolute and the individual souls, there must be a personal conception. In truth, God is a person, Kåñëa. When the living entity, by the mercy of Kåñëa, contacts a devotee, his impersonal conceptions are subordinated to the personal aspect, and he worships Kåñëa and His devotee.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the soul's conditioning, or fall, Plotinus believes that the human soul never entirely leaves the intelligible or spiritual realm.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because the living entity is an eternal spiritual being, he is not a product of this material world. He is part and parcel of the Supreme One, but he is embodied by the material elements. As the material elements change, he becomes old. When our clothes no longer fit, or if they wear out, we have to acquire new ones. Material life means change, but as spirit souls, we are eternal and changeless. Material life is not very happy because it is always changing. Whether we are in a comfortable or miserable condition, our condition will change for better or worse. In any case, we have to save ourselves from the repetition of changing bodies. If we want to remain in our original spiritual form, we have to take to Kåñëa consciousness.

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus writes: "If the souls remain in the intelligible realm with the Soul, they are beyond harm, and share in the Soul's governance. They are like kings who live with the high King and govern with him and like him, and do not come down from the palace.... But there comes a point at which they come down from this state, cosmic in its dimensions, to one of individuality. They wish to become independent.... When a soul remains for long in this withdrawal in estrangement from the whole, with never a glance toward the intelligible, it becomes a thing fragmented, isolated, and weak...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is his falldown and the beginning of his material tribulations. As long as the living entity is maintained in the material world, he thinks of material happiness, and, according to nature's law, he accepts a variety of bodies. Although conditioned, the spirit soul remains part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. Yet according to the circumstance, he thinks in terms of a particular body. He thinks that he is a dog, a man, an aquatic, and so on. According to material considerations, one thinks himself an American, Indian, Hindu, Moslem, male, or female. All these designations are due to the body, and when one understands that he is different from the body, he begins his spiritual education. Understanding himself as the eternal part and parcel of God leads to liberation. When one advances, he understands that the Supreme Truth is the Supreme Person, Kåñëa. He then engages in Kåñëa's service, and that is his actual spiritual life. Kåñëa lives in the Vaikuëöha planets in the spiritual world, and the devotee can be promoted to any of these planets, or to the supreme planet, Goloka Våndävana. Once he is there, he is happy as an associate of Kåñëa, and he can enjoy life eternally.

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus conceives of the soul as basically having two parts, a lower part directed toward the corporeal, and a higher part directed toward the spiritual.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and that means that the soul is prone to fall. Because the individual soul is very minute, there is the tendency to fall, just as a small spark may fall from a fire. Because we are only minute particles of God, we can become entangled by His material external energy. An unintelligent man may commit some crime and go to jail, but we should not think that he has been created for the purpose of going to jail. It is said that those who descend into the material world are less intelligent because they think that they can enjoy life independent of Kåñëa. A rich man's son may think that he can live independent of his father, but that is his foolishness. The Supreme Father is full in all opulences, and if we live under His care, we naturally live very comfortably. When an intelligent man realizes that he is the son of Kåñëa, he thinks, "Let me go back to my Father." This is the proper use of intelligence. An intelligent person knows perfectly well that he will be happy with Kåñëa and unhappy without Him. Learning this is part of the Kåñëa consciousness process. Without Kåñëa consciousness, a man cannot be happy.

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus also believes that the cosmic order awards and punishes everyone according to merit.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When a father sees that his son has gone astray, he tries to bring him back home, either through punishment or some other way. This is the duty of an affectionate father. Those who are foolishly suffering in the material world are being punished for the purposes of correction. This is to bring the living entity to his proper position. If one is sufficiently intelligent, he surrenders to Kåñëa, revives his old constitutional position, and attains the spiritual platform of bliss and knowledge.

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus uses the following metaphor: "We are like a chorus that allows the audience to distract its attention from the conductor. If, however, we were to turn towards our conductor, we would sing as we should and would really be with him. We're always around the One. If we were not, we would dissolve and cease to exist. Yet our gaze does not remain fixed upon the One. When we look at it, we then attain the end of our desires and find rest. Then it is that, all discord past, we dance an inspired dance around it. In this dance, the soul looks upon the source of life, the source of the Intelligence, the root of Being, the cause of the Good, the root of the Soul. All these entities emanate from the One without any lessening, for it is not a material mask."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a good metaphor. God is an individual, and the countless souls are also individuals. Sometimes they sing in tune, and sometimes their attention is diverted by the audience. When this happens, they fall out of tune. Similarly, when we divert our attention to the illusory energy, we fall down. Of course, we remain part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, but the influence of material energy covers us, and we identify with the gross elements life after life. We identify with the body, which is but a changing dress. Therefore we must first of all understand that we are not the gross material covering. This is taught in the very beginning of Bhagavad-gétä, wherein Kåñëa explains to Arjuna that since he is not the body, he should not consider the battle from a material, bodily platform. Our identity is that of spirit soul, part and parcel of the Supreme Spirit. We should therefore act according to His directions. By doing so, we become freed from material designations and gradually develop our Kåñëa consciousness.

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus accounts for the soul's conditioning in this way: "How is it, then, that souls forget the divinity that begot them? This evil that has befallen them has its source in self-will, in being born, in becoming different, and desiring to be independent. Once having tasted the pleasures of independence, they use their freedom to go any direction that leads away from their origin. And when they have gone a great distance, they even forget that they came from it."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct. The more one turns from Kåñëa, the more degraded one becomes. I have already explained that the living entity may begin his life as Lord Brahmä and eventually become so degraded that he becomes a worm in stool. Again, by nature's way, one may evolve to the human form, which gives him a chance to understand how he has fallen from his original position. By taking to Kåñëa consciousness, he can put an end to this transmigration. Everyone has to give up the material body, but when a devotee gives up his body, he does not have to accept another. He is immediately transferred to the spiritual world. Mäm eti (Bg. 4.9). "He comes to Me." For a devotee, death means giving up the material body and remaining in the original, spiritual body. It is said that whether a devotee lives or dies, his business is the same: devotional service. Those who are degraded in material life—like butchers, who daily cut the throats of many animals—are advised, "Don't live, and don't die." This is because their present life is abominable, and their future life will be filled with suffering. The devotee is liberated because he is indifferent to living or dying. He is jévan-mukta, which indicates that although his body is rotting in the material world, he is liberated. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa affirms that His devotee is not subject to the modes of material nature.

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome, but those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14) The devotee is therefore situated on the Brahman platform. It is our constitutional position to serve: either mäyä or Kåñëa. Jivera 'svarupa' haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa'. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has given our real identity as being the eternal servant of Kåñëa. Presently everyone is rendering service to his family, community, nation, and so on. When this service is rendered cent per cent to Kåñëa, we are liberated. Due to a poor fund of knowledge, impersonalists think that mukti, liberation, means inactivity, but there is no basis for this belief. The soul is naturally active, and because the soul is within the body, the body is engaged in many activities. The body in itself is inactive, but it acts because the soul is present. When we give up the bodily conception, why should activities stop? Mäyävädés cannot understand that the active principle is the soul. When the active principle leaves the body, the body is called dead. Even if one is liberated from the material body, he must act. That is also explained in the Bhakti-çästra:

sarvopädhi-vinirmuktaà
tat-paratvena nirmalam
håñékeëa håñékeça-
sevanaà bhaktir ucyate

"Bhakti, or devotional service, means engaging all our senses in the service of the Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the master of all the senses. When the spirit soul renders service unto the Supreme, there are two side effects. He is freed from all material designations, and, simply by being employed in the service of the Lord, his senses are purified." (Närada-païcarätra)

Hayagréva däsa: Plotinus writes: "A soul in such a condition [of forgetfulness] can be turned about and led back to the world above and the supreme existent, the One. This can be done by a two-fold discipline: By showing it the low value of the things it esteems at present, and by informing—reminding!—it of its nature and worth."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this is the process. One may understand or not, but if one is engaged in Kåñëa's service under the direction of the spiritual master, he automatically gives up the service of mäyä and is liberated.

viñayä vinivartante
nirähärasya dehinaù
rasa-varjaà raso 'py asya
paraà dåñövä nivartate

"The embodied soul may be restricted from sense enjoyment, though the taste for sense objects remains. But, ceasing such engagements by experiencing a higher taste, he is fixed in consciousness." (Bg. 2.59) However, if he again voluntarily accepts mäyä's service, he again becomes conditioned. By rendering service to Kåñëa under the guidance of a bona fide spiritual master, we can come to understand all that need be known. The devotees do not speculate about their position; they know it by the grace of Kåñëa.

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

teñäm evänukampärtham
aham ajïäna-jaà tamaù
näçayämy ätma-bhävastho
jïäna-dépena bhäsvatä

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me. Out of compassion for them, I, dwelling in their hearts, destroy with the shining lamp of knowledge, the darkness born of ignorance." (Bg. 10.10-11)

DS:Origen (185-254)

Origen (185-254)

Hayagréva däsa: Origen is generally considered the founder of formal Christian philosophy, because he was the first to attempt to establish Christianity on the basis of philosophy as well as faith. He believed that the ultimate spiritual reality consists of the supreme, infinite Person, God, as well as individual personalities. Ultimate reality may be defined as the relationships of persons with one another and with the infinite Person Himself. In this view, Origen differs from the Greeks, who were basically impersonalists.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our Vedic conception is almost the same. Individual souls, which we call living entities, are always present, and each one of them has an intimate relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In material conditional life, the living entity has forgotten this relationship. By rendering devotional service, he attains the liberated position and at that time revives his relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: Origen ascribed to a doctrine of the Trinity, in which God the Father is supreme. God the Son, called the Logos, is subordinate to the Father. It is the Son who brings the material world into existence. That is, God the Father is not the direct creator; rather, it is the Son who creates directly, like Lord Brahmä. The third aspect of the Trinity is the Holy Spirit, who is subordinate to the Son. According to Origen, all three of these aspects are divine and co-eternal. They have always existed simultaneously as the Trinity of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Vedas, Kåñëa is the original Personality of Godhead. As confirmed by Bhagavad-gétä: ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù. "I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds." (Bg. 10.8) Whether you call this origin the Father, Son, or Holy Spirit, it doesn't matter. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is the origin. According to the Vedic conception, there are two types of expansion: God's personal expansions, called Viñëu-tattva, and His partial part-and-parcel expansions called jéva-tattva. There are many varieties of personal expansions: puruña-avatäras, çaktyäveça-avatäras, manvantara-avatäras, and so on. For the creation of this material world, the Lord expands as Brahmä, Viñëu, and Maheçvara (Çiva). Viñëu is a personal expansion, and Brahmä is a jéva-tattva expansion. Between the personal Viñëu-tattva expansion and the jéva-tattva expansion is a kind of intermediate expansion called Çiva, or Maheçvara. The material ingredients are given, and Brahmä creates the particular creation. Viñëu maintains the creation, and Lord Çiva annihilates it. It is the nature of the external potency to be created, maintained, and dissolved. More detailed information is given in the Caitanya-caritämåta. In any case, the jévas, or living entities, are all considered to be sons of God. They are situated in one of two positions: liberated or conditioned. Those who are liberated can personally associate with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and those who are conditioned within this material world have forgotten the Supreme Lord. Therefore they suffer within this material world in different bodily forms. They can be elevated, however, through the practice of Kåñëa consciousness under the guidance of the çästras and the bona fide guru.

Hayagréva däsa: Origen believed that it is through the combined working of divine grace and man's free will that the individual soul attains perfection, which consists of attaining a personal relationship with the infinite Person.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and that is called bhakti-märga. The Absolute Truth is manifested in three features: Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagävan. Bhagävan is the personal feature, and the Paramätmä, situated in everyone's heart, may he compared to the Holy Spirit. The Brahman feature is present everywhere. The highest perfection of spiritual life includes the understanding of the personal feature of the Lord. When one understands Bhagävan, one engages in His service. In this way, the living entity is situated in his original constitutional position and is eternally blissful.

Hayagréva däsa: Origen considered that just as man's free will precipitated his fall, man's free will can also bring about salvation. Man can return to God by practicing material detachment. Such detachment can be made possible by help from the Logos, the Christ.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is also our conception. The fallen soul is transmigrating within this material world, up and down in different forms of life. When his consciousness is sufficiently developed, he can be enlightened by God, who gives him instructions in the Bhagavad-gétä. Through the spiritual master's help, he can attain full enlightenment. When he understands his transcendental position of bliss, he automatically gives up material bodily attachments. Then he attains freedom. The living entity attains his normal, constitutional position when he is properly situated in his spiritual identity and engaged in the service of the Lord.

Hayagréva däsa: Origen believed that all the elements found in the material body are also found in the spiritual body, which he called the "interior man." Origen writes: "There are two men in each of us—As every exterior man has for homonym the interior man, so it is for all his members, and one can say that every member of the exterior man can be found under this name in the interior man—" Thus for every sense that we possess in the exterior body, there is a corresponding sense in the interior, or spiritual body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The spirit soul is now within this material body, but originally the spirit soul had no material body. The spiritual body of the spirit soul is eternally existing. The material body is simply a coating of the spiritual body. The material body is cut, like a suit, according to the spiritual body. The material elements—earth, water, air, fire, etc.—become like a clay when mixed together, and they coat the spiritual body. It is because the spiritual body has a shape that the material body also takes a shape. In actuality, the material body has nothing to do with the spiritual body; it is but a kind of contamination causing the suffering of the spirit soul. As soon as the spirit soul is coated with this material contamination, he identifies himself with the coating and forgets his real spiritual body. That is called mäyä, ignorance, or illusion. This ignorance continues as long as we are not fully Kåñëa conscious. When we become fully Kåñëa conscious, we understand that the material body is but the external coating and that we are different. When we attain this uncontaminated understanding, we arrive at what is called the brahma-bhüta platform. When the spirit soul, which is Brahman, is under the illusion of the material bodily conditioning, we are on the jéva-bhüta platform. Brahma-bhüta is attained when we no longer identify with the material body but with the spirit soul within. When we come to this platform, we become joyful.

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments nor desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state, he attains pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54) In this position, one sees all living entities as spirit souls; he does not see the outward covering. When he sees a dog, he sees a spirit soul covered by the body of a dog. This state is also described in Bhagavad-gétä.

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

“The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog, and a dog-eater [outcaste]." (Bg. 5.18) When one is in the body of an animal, he cannot understand his spiritual identity. This identity can best be realized in a human civilization in which the varëäçrama system is practiced. This system divides life into four äçramas (brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, and çüdrä), and four varëas (brahmacäré, gåhastha, vänaprastha, and sannyäsé). The highest position is that of a brähmaëa-sannyäsé, a platform from which one may best realize his original constitutional position, act accordingly, and thus attain deliverance, or mukti. Mukti means understanding our constitutional position and acting accordingly. Conditional life, a life of bondage, means identifying with the body and acting on the bodily platform. On the mukti platform, our activities differ from those enacted on the conditional platform. Devotional service is rendered from the mukti platform. If we engage in devotional service, we maintain our spiritual identity and are therefore liberated, even though inhabiting the conditional, material body.

Hayagréva däsa: Origen also believed that the interior man, or the spiritual body, also has spiritual senses that enable the soul to taste, see, touch, and contemplate the things of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. That is devotional life.

Hayagréva däsa: During his lifetime, Origen was a famous teacher and was very much in demand. For him, preaching meant explaining the words of God and no more. He believed that a preacher must first be a man of prayer and must be in contact with God. He should not pray for material goods but for a better understanding of the scriptures.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a real preacher. As explained in Vedic literatures: çravaëaà kértanaà. First of all, we become perfect by hearing. This is called çravaëaà. When we are thus situated by hearing perfectly from an authorized person, our next stage begins: kértana, preaching. In this material world, everyone is hearing something from someone else. In order to pass examinations, a student must hear his professor. Then, in his own right, he can become a professor himself. If we hear from a spiritualized person, we become perfect and can become real preachers. We should preach about Viñëu for Viñëu, not for any person within this material world. We should hear and preach about the Supreme Person, the transcendental Personality of Godhead. That is the duty of a liberated soul.

Hayagréva däsa: As far as contradictions and seeming absurdities in scripture are concerned, Origen considered them to be stumbling blocks permitted to exist by God in order for man to pass beyond the literal meaning. He writes that "everything in scripture has a spiritual meaning, but not all of it has a literal meaning."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Generally speaking, every word in scripture has a literal meaning, but people cannot understand it properly because they do not hear from the proper person. They interpret instead. There is no need to interpret the words of God. Sometimes the words of God cannot be understood by an ordinary person; therefore we may require the transparent medium of the guru. Since the guru is fully cognizant of the words spoken by God, we are advised to receive the words of the scriptures through the guru. There is no ambiguity in the words of God, but due to our imperfect knowledge, we sometimes cannot understand. Not understanding, we try to interpret, but because we are imperfect, our interpretations are also imperfect. The purport is that the words of God, the scriptures, should be understood from a person who has realized God.

Hayagréva däsa: For Origen, there are two rebirths. The first is a baptism, which is something like a mystical union between Christ and the soul. Baptism marked the first stage in spiritual life: from there, one could regress or progress. Baptism is compared to a shadow of the ultimate rebirth, which is complete purification and rebirth in the spiritual world with Christ. When the soul is reborn with Christ, it receives a spiritual body like Christ and beholds Christ face to face.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is the position of Christ?

Hayagréva däsa: He is seated at the right hand of the Father in the kingdom of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But when Christ was present on earth, many people saw him.

Hayagréva däsa: They saw him in many different ways, just as the people saw Kåñëa in many different ways.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Is it that Christ is seen in his full spiritual body?

Hayagréva däsa: When the soul is reborn with Christ, it beholds Christ's spiritual body through its spiritual senses.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. We also think in this way.

Hayagréva däsa: Origen did not believe that the individual soul has been existing from all eternity. It was created. He writes: "The rational natures that were made in the beginning did not always exist; they came into being when they were created."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not correct. Both the living entity and God are simultaneously eternally existing, and the living entity is part and parcel of God. Although eternally existing, the living entity is changing his body. Na hanyate hanyamäne çarére (Bg. 2.20). One body after another is being created and destroyed, but the living being is eternally existing. So we disagree when Origen says that the soul is created. Our spiritual identity is never created. That is the difference between spirit and matter. Material things are created, but the spiritual is without beginning.

na tv evähaà jätu näsaà
na tvaà neme janädhipäù
na caiva na bhaviñyämaù
sarve vayam ataù param

"Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings; nor in the future shall any of us cease to be." (Bg. 2.12)

Hayagréva däsa: Origen differed from later Church doctrine in his belief in transmigration. Although he believed that the soul was originally created, he also believed that it transmigrated because it could always refuse to give itself to God. So he saw the individual soul as possibly rising and falling perpetually on the evolutionary scale. Later Church doctrine held that one's choice for eternity is made in this one lifetime. As Origen saw it, the individual soul, falling short of the ultimate goal, is reincarnated again and again.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the Vedic version. Unless one is liberated and goes to the kingdom of God, he must transmigrate from one material body to another. The material body grows, remains for some time, reproduces, grows old, and becomes useless. Then the living entity has to leave one body for another. Once in a new body, he again attempts to fulfill his desires, and again he goes through the process of dying and accepting another material body. This is the process of transmigration.

Hayagréva däsa: It is interesting that neither Origen nor Christ rejected transmigration. It wasn't until Augustine that it was denied.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Transmigration is a fact. A person cannot wear the same clothes all of his life. Our clothes become old and useless, and we have to change them. The living being is certainly eternal, but he has to accept a material body for material sense gratification, and such a body cannot endure perpetually. All of this is thoroughly explained in Bhagavad-gétä.

dehino 'smin yathä dehe
kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä
tathä dehäntara-präptir
dhéras tatra na muhyati

"As the embodied soul continuously passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. The self-realized soul is not bewildered by such a change." (Bg. 2.13)

çaréraà yad aväpnoti
yac cäpy utkrämatéçvaraù
gåhétvaitäni saàyäti
väyur gandhän iväçayät

"The living entity in the material world carries his different conceptions of life from one body to another, as the air carries aromas." (Bg. 15.8)

DS:Augustine (354-430)

Augustine (354-430)

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine considered the soul to be spiritual and incorporeal, but he also believed that the soul of the individual does not exist prior to birth. The soul attains its immortality only at death, and then goes on to live through eternity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If the soul is created, how is it immortal? How can the soul sometimes not be eternal?

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine would say that the soul is immortal after it is created, but that at a certain point it is brought into being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then what does he consider death to be?

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine recognizes two types of death: physical death, wherein the soul leaves the body; and soul-death, which is the death experienced by the soul when God abandons it. When one is damned, he faces not only physical death but spiritual soul-death as well.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Figuratively speaking, when one forgets his position, he undergoes a kind of death, but the soul is eternal. What Augustine calls spiritual death is forgetfulness. When one is unconscious, he forgets his identity, but when one is dead, he cannot revive his consciousness. Of course, until one acquires his freedom from material existence, he is spiritually dead, even though existing in the material form. Forgetfulness of our real identity is a kind of death. When we are alive to God consciousness, we are actually alive. In any case, the soul is eternal and survives the annihilation of the body.

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine would consider that in some cases the forgetful stage is eternal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not. Our consciousness can always be revived, and that is the conviction of this Kåñëa consciousness movement. We say that a man is unconscious when he is sleeping, but if you call him again and again, the sound of his name enters his ear, and he awakes. Similarly, this process of chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra awakens us to spiritual consciousness. Then we can live a spiritual life.

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine would say that God eternally abandons the damned soul to eternal perdition.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He may be "eternally abandoned" in the sense that he may remain forgetful for millions of years. It may seem eternal, but our spiritual consciousness can be revived at any moment by good association, by the method of hearing and chanting. Devotional service therefore begins with çravaëaà, hearing. In the beginning, especially, hearing is very important. If we hear the truth from a self-realized soul, we can awake to spiritual life and remain spiritually alive in devotional service.

Hayagréva däsa: In The City of God, Augustine refers to two cities, or societies: one demonic, and the other divine. In one city, love of God and the spirit is the unifying factor; and in the other, love of the world and the flesh is dominant. Augustine writes: "These are two loves, the one of which is holy, the other unholy; one social, the other individualistic; the one is subject to God, the other sets itself up as a rival to God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: A similar allegory is given in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The body is likened to a city, and the soul is likened to the king of that city. The body has nine gates, and the king can leave the city through these gates. These detailed descriptions are given in Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine seems to admit the transcendence of God, but not His omnipresence as the Paramätmä accompanying each individual soul. He writes: "God is not the soul of all things, but the maker of all souls."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then how is God all pervading? The Paramätmä is accepted as the Supersoul both in Brahma-saàhitä and in Bhagavad-gétä.

upadrañöänumantä ca
bhartä bhoktä maheçvaraù
paramätmeti cäpy ukto
dehe 'smin puruñaù paraù

"Yet in this body there is another, a transcendental enjoyer who is the Lord, the supreme proprietor, who exists as the overseer and permitter, and who is known as the Supersoul." (Bg. 13.23) God is present in every atom.

viñöabhyäham idaà kåtsnam
ekäàçena sthito jagat

"With a single fragment of Myself I pervade and support this entire universe." (Bg. 10.42)

vadanti tat tattva-vidas
tattvaà yaj jïänam advayam
brahmeti paramätmeti
bhagavän iti çabdyate

"Learned transcendentalists who know the Absolute Truth call this nondual substance Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagävan." (Bhäg. 1.2.11) Certainly God has the potency of omnipresence. This cannot be denied.

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine disagrees with Origen's contention that the body is like a prison. He writes: "If the opinion of Origen and his followers were true—that matter was created that souls might be enclosed in bodies, as in penitentiaries for the punishment of sin—then the higher and lighter bodies should have been for those whose sins were slight, and the lower and heavier ones for those whose crimes were great."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul is essentially part and parcel of God, but is imprisoned in different types of bodies. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father." (Bg. 14.4) From material nature, the mother, different species are coming. They are found in earth, water, air, and even fire. The individual souls, however, are part and parcel of the Supreme, who impregnates them within this material world. The living entity then comes out into the material world through the womb of some mother. It appears that the soul is coming out of matter, but it is not composed of matter.

The souls, always part and parcel of God, assume different types of bodies according to pious or impious activities or desires. The desires of the soul determine higher or lower bodies. In any case, the soul is the same. It is therefore said that those who are advanced in spiritual consciousness see the same soul in each and every body, be it the body of a dog, or a brähmaëa.

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

"The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog, and a dog-eater [outcaste]." (Bg. 5.18)

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine looked on Adam as the root of mankind. He writes: "God knew how good it would be for this community often to recall that the human race had its roots in one man, precisely to show how pleasing it is to God that men, though many, should be one."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our Vedic conception is similar. We say that mankind has come from Manu. From Manu, we get the Sanskrit word mäëuñaù, which means "coming from Manu," or "human being." Manu himself comes from Brahmä, who is the first living being. Thus living beings come from other living beings, not from matter. Brahmä, in his turn, comes from the Supreme Lord as rajo-guëa avatära. Indeed, Brahmä is the incarnation of rajo-guëa, the mode of passion. All living beings ultimately come from the supreme living Being.

Hayagréva däsa: Like Origen, Augustine considered the soul to be created at a particular time, but unlike Origen, he rejected reincarnation: "Let these Platonists stop threatening us with reincarnation as punishment for our souls. Reincarnation is ridiculous. There is no such thing as a return to this life for the punishment of souls. If our creation, even as mortals, is due to God, how can the return to bodies, which are gifts of God, be punishment?"

Çréla Prabhupäda: Does he think that the assumption of the body of a hog or similar lower creature is not punishment? Why does one person get the body of King Indra or Lord Brahmä, and another the body of a pig or insect? How does he explain the body of a pig? If the body is a gift from God, it can also be a punishment from God. When one is rewarded, he gets the body of a Brahmä or a King Indra, and if he is punished, he gets the body of a pig.

Hayagréva däsa: What about the body of a man? Is that a gift or punishment?

Çréla Prabhupäda: There are many men who are well situated, and others who are suffering. Suffering and enjoyment take place according to the body. As explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

mäträ-sparçäs tu kaunteya
çétoñëa-sukha-duùkha-däù
ägamäpäyino 'nityäs
täàs titikñasva bhärata

"O son of Kunté, the nonpermanent appearance of happiness and distress, and their disappearance in due course, are like the appearance of winter and summer seasons. They arise from sense perception, O scion of Bharata, and one must learn to tolerate them without being disturbed." (Bg. 2.14) An old man may perceive cold very acutely, whereas a young child may not perceive it. Perception is relative to the body. An animal may go naked and not feel the cold, whereas a man cannot. Thus the body is a source of suffering and enjoyment. Or we may consider this punishment and reward.

Hayagréva däsa: For Augustine, the soul of each individual man is not necessarily condemned to earth due to his own desire or sin, but due to the original sin of Adam, the first man. He writes: "When the first couple [Adam and Eve] were punished by the judgement of God, the whole human race...was present in the first man. And what was born was not human nature as it was originally created, but as it became after the first parents' sin and punishment—as far, at least, as concerns the origin of sin and death." In this sense, the individual partakes of the karma of the entire race.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If this is the case, why does he call the body a gift? Why does he say that it is not punishment? The original man was punished, as well as the man after him, and so on. Sometimes a father's disease is inherited by the son. Is this not a form of punishment?

Hayagréva däsa: Then the human form is a punishment in itself?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. At the same time, you can consider human life a gift because it is given by God. We should think that if God has given us this body for our punishment, it is His mercy, because by undergoing punishment we may become purified and progress toward God. Devotees think in this way. Although the body is a form of punishment, we consider it a reward because by undergoing the punishment, we are progressing toward God realization. Even when the body is given by God for our correction, it can thus be considered a gift.

Hayagréva däsa: For Augustine, the physical body precedes the spiritual: "What is sown a natural body, arises a spiritual body. If there is a natural body, there is also a spiritual body....But it is not the spiritual that comes first, but the physical. The first man was of the earth, earthly; the second man is from heaven, heavenly.... But the body which, of the life-giving spirit, will become spiritual and immortal will under no condition be able to die. It will be immortal, just as the created soul is immortal."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why does he speak of immortality in connection with man only? Every living entity has an immortal body. As we said, entering the mortal body is a kind of punishment. The individual undergoes an evolutionary process from lower to higher species. Every soul is part and parcel of God, but due to some sinful activity, the living entity comes into this material world. In the Bible, it is said that due to disobedience to God, Adam and Eve lost paradise and had to come into the material world. The soul belongs to the paradise in heaven, the planets of Kåñëa, but somehow or other he has fallen into this material world and has taken on a body. According to our activities, we are elevated or degraded as a demigod, human being, animal, tree, or plant. In any case, the soul is always aloof from the material body. This is confirmed by Vedic literatures. Our actual spiritual life begins when we are freed from material contamination, or transmigration.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning peace, Augustine writes: "Peace between a mortal man and his Maker consists in ordered obedience, guided by faith, under God's eternal law; peace between man and man consists in regulated fellowship... .The peace of the heavenly city lies in a perfectly ordered and harmonious communion of those who find their joy in God and in one another in God. Peace in its final sense is the calm that comes of order."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Peace means coming in contact with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. A man in ignorance thinks that he is the enjoyer of this world, but when he contacts the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the supreme controller, he understands that God is the enjoyer. We are servants meant to supply enjoyment to God. A servant supplies the needs of his master. Actually, the master has no needs, but he enjoys the company of his servants, who in turn enjoy his company. A public servant is very happy when he receives a good government job, and a master is happy to acquire a very faithful servant. This is the relationship between the individual soul and God, and when this relationship is destroyed, it is said that the individual soul exists in mäyä. When the relationship is restored, the individual is situated in his spiritual consciousness, which we call Kåñëa consciousness, by which he understands that the supreme God is the actual enjoyer and proprietor as well as the Supreme Being. When we understand God's transcendental qualities, we become happy and attain peace.

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine felt that neither activity nor meditation should be exclusive but should complement one another: "No man must be so committed to contemplation as, in his contemplation, to give no thought to his neighbor's needs, nor so absorbed in action as to dispense with the contemplation of God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Unless you think of God, how can you be active in the service of God? Real meditation is meditation on the Supreme Personality of Godhead, or the Supersoul within the core of the heart. Activity and meditation should go together, however. If we sit down and think of God, it is commendable, but if we work for God as God desires, our position is superior. If you love me and simply sit and think of me, that is commendable. That may be considered meditation. However, if you love me, it is better that you carry out my orders. That is more important.

Hayagréva däsa: Augustine conceived of a spiritual world in which the movements of the spiritual bodies "will be of such unimaginable beauty that I dare not say more than this: There will be such poise, such grace, such beauty as become a place where nothing unbecoming can be found. Wherever the spirit wills, there, in a flash, the body will be....God will be the source of every satisfaction. He will be the consummation of all our desiring, the object of our unending vision, of our unlessening love, of our unwearying praise....The souls in bliss will still possess freedom of will, though sin will have no power to tempt them."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, sin cannot touch one who remains in contact with God. According to our desires, we associate with the modes of material nature and acquire different types of bodies. Nature, the agent of Kåñëa, affords us facilities by giving us a body, which is like a machine. When a son insists, "Father, give me a cycle," the affectionate father complies. This is a typical relationship between a father and his son. As explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà
håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati
bhrämayan sarva-bhütäni
yanträrüòhäni mäyayä

"The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart, O Arjuna, and is directing the wanderings of all living entities, who are seated as on a machine made of the material energy." (Bg. 18.61) The Supreme Father, Kåñëa, is within the core of everyone's heart. As the living entity desires, the Father supplies a body manufactured by material nature. This body is destined to suffer, but the spiritual bodies in the Vaikuëöhas are not subject to birth, old age, disease, or death, nor the threefold miseries. They are eternal and full of knowledge and bliss.

Hayagréva däsa: For Augustine, the mind, reason, and the soul are one and the same.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, these are different identities. The mind acts according to the intelligence, but the intelligence of different living entities differs. Similarly, minds also differ. A dog's intelligence is not equal to that of a human being, but this is not to say that the dog does not have a soul. The soul is placed in different bodies that have different types of intelligence and different ways of thinking, acting, feeling, and willing. So the mind and intelligence differ according to the body, but the soul remains the same.

Hayagréva däsa: By identifying the soul with mind and reason, Augustine could justify killing animals. He writes: "Indeed, some people try to stretch the prohibition ['Thou shalt not kill.'] to cover beasts and cattle, and make it unlawful to kill any such animal. But then, why not include plants and anything rooted in and feeding on the soil?...Putting this nonsense aside, we do not apply 'Thou shalt not kill' to plants, because they have no sensation; nor to irrational animals that fly, swim, walk, or creep, because they are linked to us by no association or common bond. By the creator's wise ordinance, they are meant for our use, dead or alive. It only remains for us to apply the commandment, 'Thou shalt not kill' to man alone, oneself and others."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Bible says, "Thou shalt not kill," without qualification. Our Vedic philosophy admits that one living entity serves as food for another living entity. That is natural. As stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.13.47], those animals who have hands eat animals without hands. The four-legged animals eat animals that cannot move, as well as plants and vegetables. Thus the weak is food for the strong. This is a natural law. Our Kåñëa consciousness philosophy, however, is not based on the view that plant life is less sensitive than animal life, or animal life is less sensitive than human life. We consider all human beings, animals, plants, and trees to be living entities, spirit souls. We may eat an animal or a vegetable—whatever the case, we must inevitably eat some living entity. It therefore becomes a question of selection. Apart from vegetarian or nonvegetarian diets, we are basically concerned with Kåñëa prasädam. We take only the remnants of whatever Kåñëa eats. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà
yo me bhaktyä prayacchati
tad ahaà bhakty-upahåtam
açnämi prayatätmanaù

"If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, a fruit, or water, I will accept it." (Bg. 9.26) This is our philosophy. We are concerned with taking the remnants of Kåñëa's food, which we call prasädam, mercy. We should not touch meat or anything else not offerable to Kåñëa.

yajïa-çiñöäçinaù santo
mucyante sarva-kilbiñaiù
bhuïjate te tv aghaàpapa
ye pacanty ätma-käraëät

"The devotees of the Lord are released from all kinds of sins because they eat food which is offered first for sacrifice. Others, who prepare food for personal sense enjoyment, verily eat only sin." (Bg. 3.13)

IIISCHOLASTICISM

IIISCHOLASTICISM

DS:Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274)

Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274)

Hayagréva däsa: Thomas Aquinas compiled the entire Church doctrine in Summa Theologiae, which constitutes the official philosophy of the Roman Catholic Church. Aquinas did not make Augustine's sharp distinction between the material and spiritual worlds, or between secular society and the city of God. For him, both material and spiritual creations have their origin in God. At the same time, he admits that the spiritual world is superior to the material.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When we speak of "material world" we refer to that which is temporary. Some philosophers like the Mäyävädés claim that the material world is false, but we Vaiñëavas prefer to say that it is temporary or illusory. It is a reflection of the spiritual world, but in itself it has no reality. We therefore sometimes compare the material world to a mirage in the desert. In the material world, there is no happiness, but the transcendental bliss and happiness existing in the spiritual world are reflected here. Unintelligent people chase after this illusory happiness, forgetting the real happiness that is in spiritual life.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas agreed with both the statements of Anselm and Abelard: "I believe in order that I may understand," and, "I understand in order that I may believe." Thus reason and revelation complement one another as a means to truth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since human reason is not perfect, revelation is also needed. The truth is attained through logic, philosophy, and revelation. According to the Vaiñëava tradition, we arrive at the truth through the guru, the spiritual master, who is accepted as the representative of the Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead. He transmits the message of the truth because he has seen the Absolute Truth through the disciplic succession. If we accept the bona fide spiritual master and please him by submissive service, by virtue of his mercy and pleasure, we can understand God and the spiritual world by revelation. We therefore offer our respects to the spiritual master in the prayer:

yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädo
yasyäprasädän na gatiù kuto 'pi
dhyäyan stuvaàs tasya yaças tri-sandhyaà
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

"By the mercy of the spiritual master, one receives the benediction of Kåñëa. Without the grace of the spiritual master, one cannot make any advancement. Therefore, I should always remember and praise the spiritual master, offering respectful obeisances unto his lotus feet at least three times a day." (Çré Gurv-añöaka 8) We can understand God if we please the spiritual master, who carries the Lord's message without speculation. It is stated: sevonmukhe hi jihvädau svayam eva sphuraty adaù (Padma Puräëa). When we engage our senses in the Lord's service, the Lord is revealed.

Hayagréva däsa: For Aquinas, God is the only single essence that consists of pure form. He felt that matter is only a potential, and, in order to be real, must assume a certain shape or form. In other words, the living entity has to acquire an individual form in order to actualize himself. When matter unites with form, the form gives individuality and personality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Matter in itself has no form; it is the spirit soul that has form. Matter is a covering for the actual form of the spirit soul. Because the soul has form, matter appears to have form. Matter is like cloth that is cut to fit the body. In the spiritual world, however, everything has form: God and the spirit souls.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas believed that only God and the angels have nonmaterial form. There is no difference between God's form and God's spiritual Self.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Both the individual souls and God have form. That is real form. Material form is but a covering for the spiritual body.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas set forth five basic arguments for God's existence: first, God necessarily exists as the first cause; second, the material world cannot create itself but needs something external, or spiritual, to create it; third, because the world exists, there must be a creator; fourth, since there is relative perfection in the world, there must be absolute perfection underlying it; and fifth, since the creation has design and purpose, there must be a designer who planned it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We also honor these arguments. Also, without a father and mother, children cannot be brought into existence. Modern philosophers do not consider this strongest argument. According to Brahma-saàhitä, everything has a cause, and God is the ultimate cause.

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù
sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù
anädir ädir govindaù
sarva-käraëa-käraëam

"Kåñëa, who is known as Govinda, is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal, blissful, spiritual body. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin, and He is the prime cause of all causes." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.1)

Hayagréva däsa: He also states that the relative perfection we find here necessitates an absolute perfection.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the spiritual world is absolute perfection, and this temporary material world is but a reflection of that spiritual world. Whatever perfection we find in this material world is derived from the spiritual world. Janmädy asya yataù. According to Vedänta-sütra, whatever is generated comes from the Absolute Truth.

Hayagréva däsa: Today, some scientists even admit Aquinas's argument that since nothing can create itself in this material world, something external, or spiritual, is required for initial creation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a mountain cannot create anything, but a human being can give form to a stone. A mountain may be very large, but it remains a stone incapable of giving shape to anything.

Hayagréva däsa: Unlike Plato and Aristotle, Aquinas maintained that God created the universe out of nothing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, the universe is created by God, certainly, but God and His energies are always there. You cannot logically say that the universe was created out of nothing.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas would contend that since the material universe could not have arisen out of God's spiritual nature, it had to be created out of nothing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Material nature is also an energy of God's. As Kåñëa states in the Bhagavad-gétä:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

"Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego—all together these eight constitute My separated material energies." (Bg. 7.4) All of these emanate from God, and therefore they are not unreal. They are considered inferior because they are God's separated material energies. The sound that comes from a tape recorder may sound exactly like the original person's voice. The sound is not the person's voice itself, but it has come from the person. If one cannot see where the sound is coming from, one may suppose that the person is actually speaking, although the person may be far away. Similarly, the material world is an expansion of the Supreme Lord's energy, and we should not think that it has been brought into existence out of nothing. It has emanated from the Supreme Truth, but it is the inferior, separated energy. The superior energy is found in the spiritual world, which is the world of reality. In any case, we cannot agree that the material world has come from nothing.

Hayagréva däsa: Well, Aquinas would say that it was created by God out of nothing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You cannot say that God's energy is nothing. His energy is exhibited and is eternally existing with Him. God's energy must be there. If God doesn't have energy, how can He be God?

na tasya käryaà karaëaà ca vidyate
na tat-samaç cäbhyadhikaç ca dåçyate
paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate
sväbhäviké jïäna-bala-kriyä ca

"He does not possess bodily form like that of an ordinary living entity. There is no difference between His body and His soul. He is absolute. All His senses are transcendental. Any one of His senses can perform the action of any other sense. Therefore, no one is greater than Him, or equal to Him. His potencies are multifarious, and thus His deeds are automatically performed as a natural sequence." (Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 6.8) God has multi-energies, and the material energy is but one. Since God is everything, you cannot say that the material universe comes from nothing.

Hayagréva däsa: Like Augustine, Aquinas believed that sin and man are concomitant. Due to Adam's original sin, all men require salvation, which can be obtained only through God's grace. But the individual has to assent by his free will for God's grace to function.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we call that assent bhakti, devotional service.

ataù çré-kåñëa-nämädi
na bhaved grähyam indriyaiù
sevonmukhe hi jihvädau
svayam eva sphuraty adaù

"Material senses cannot appreciate Kåñëa's holy name, form, qualities, and pastimes. When a conditioned soul is awakened to Kåñëa consciousness and renders service by using his tongue to chant the Lord's holy name, and taste the remnants of the Lord's food, the tongue is purified, and one gradually comes to understand who Kåñëa really is." (Padma Puräëa)

Bhakti is our eternal engagement, and when we engage in our eternal activities, we attain salvation, or liberation. When we engage in false activities, we are in illusion, mäyä. Mukti, liberation, means remaining in our constitutional position. In the material world, we engage in many different activities, but they all refer to the material body. In the spiritual world, the spirit engages in the Lord's service, and this is liberation, or salvation.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas considered sins to be both venial and mortal. A venial sin is one that can be pardoned, but a mortal sin cannot. A mortal sin stains the soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When a living entity disobeys the orders of God, he is put into this material world, and that is his punishment. He either rectifies himself by good association, or undergoes transmigration. By taking on one body after another, he is subject to the tribulations of material existence. The soul is not stained, but he can participate in sinful activity. Although you cannot mix oil and water, oil floating on water is carried away by water. As soon as we are in contact with material nature, we come under the clutches of the material world.

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

"The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities, which are in actuality carried out by nature." (Bg. 3.27) As soon as the living entity enters the material world, he loses his own power. He is completely under the clutches of material nature. Oil never mixes with water, but it may be carried away by the waves.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas felt that the monastic vows of poverty, celibacy, and obedience give a direct path to God, but he did not think that these austerities were meant for the masses of men. He looked on life as a pilgrimage through the world of the senses to the spiritual world of God, from imperfection to perfection, and the monastic vows are meant to help us on this path.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, according to the Vedic instructions, we must take to the path of tapasya, voluntary self-denial. Tapasä brahmacaryena. Tapasya, or austerity, begins with brahmacarya, celibacy. We must first learn to control the sex urge. That is the beginning of tapasya. We must control the senses and the mind, then we should give everything that we have to the Lord's service. By following the path of truth and remaining clean, we can practice yoga. In this way, it is possible to advance toward the spiritual kingdom. All of this can be realized, however, by engaging in devotional service. If we become devotees of Kåñëa, we automatically attain the benefits of austerities without having to make a separate effort. By one stroke, devotional service, we can acquire the benefits of all the other processes.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas did not believe in a soul per se as being divorced from a particular form. God did not create a soul capable of inhabiting any body or form; rather, He created an angelic soul, a human soul, an animal soul, or a plant soul. Here again, we find the conception of the soul's creation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul is not created but is eternally existing along with God. The soul has the independence to turn from God, in which case he becomes like a spark falling from a great fire. When the spark is separated, it loses its illumination. In any case, the individual soul is always there. The master and His servants are there eternally. We cannot say that the parts of a body are separately created. As soon as the body is present, all the parts are there with it. The soul is never created, and it never dies. This is confirmed in the very beginning of Bhagavad-gétä:

na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin
näyaà bhütvä bhavitä vä na bhüyaù
ajo nityaùçäçvato 'yaà puräëo
na hanyate hanyamäne çarére

"For the soul there is never birth nor death. Nor, having once been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain." (Bg. 2.20) It may appear that the soul comes into existence and dies, but this is because he has accepted the material body. When the material body dies, the soul transfers to another body. When the soul is liberated, he doesn't have to accept another material body. He can return home, back to Godhead, in his original spiritual body. The soul was never created but is always existing with God. If we say that the soul was created, the question may be raised whether or not God, the Supreme Soul, was also created. Of course, this is not the case. God is eternal, and His parts and parcels are also eternal. The difference is that God never accepts a material body, whereas the individual soul, being but a small particle, sometimes succumbs to the material energy.

Hayagréva däsa: Is the soul eternally existing with God in a spiritual form?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Hayagréva däsa: So the soul has a form that is incorruptible. Is this not also the form of the material body?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The material body is an imitation. It is false. Because the spiritual body has form, the material body, which is a coating, takes on form. As I have already explained, a cloth originally has no form, but a tailor can cut the cloth to fit a form. In actuality, this material form is illusory. It originally has no form. It takes on form for a while, and when it becomes old and useless, it returns to its original position. In Bhagavad-gétä (18.61), the body is compared to a machine. The soul has his own form, but he is given a machine, the body, which he uses to wander throughout the universe, attempting to enjoy himself.

Hayagréva däsa: I think that part of the problem is that Augustine and Aquinas could not conceive of a spiritual form. When they speak of form, they think that matter must necessarily be involved. Aquinas followed the Augustinian and Platonic doctrines maintaining that if the soul is independent from matter, man loses his basic unity. He saw man as both body and soul. A man is a particular type of soul in a specific body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you are dressed, it appears that you are not different from your clothes. Your clothes move just as you do, but you are completely different.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas did not believe that the living entity has pure spiritual form as such. Matter is necessary to give the soul form.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. He has his original form.

Hayagréva däsa: Is this the form of the body?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is the form of the spirit. The body takes on form because the spirit has form. Matter has no form, but it coats the spiritual form of the soul and thus takes on form.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas considered sex to be meant exclusively for the begetting of children, and the parents are responsible for giving their children a spiritual education.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also the Vedic injunction. You should not beget children unless you can liberate them from the cycle of birth and death.

gurur na sa syät sva-jano na sa syät
pitä na sa syäj janané na sä syät
daivaà na tat syän na patiç ca sa syän
na mocayed yaù samupeta-måtyum

"One who cannot deliver his dependents from the path of repeated birth and death should never become a spiritual master, a father, a husband, a mother, or a worshipable demigod." (Bhäg. 5.5.18)

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas argued that sex for reasons other than propagation is "repugnant to the good of nature, which is the conservation of the species." Considering today's overpopulation, does this argument still hold?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The conservation of the species doesn't enter into it. Illicit sex is sinful because it is for sense gratification instead of the begetting of children. Sense gratification in any form is sinful.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the state, Aquinas believed like Plato in an enlightened monarchy, but in certain cases, he felt that it is not necessary for man to obey human laws if these laws are opposed to human welfare and are instruments of violence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but first of all we must know what our welfare is. Unfortunately, as materialistic education advances, we are missing the aim of life. Life's aim is declared openly in the Vedänta-sütra: athäto brahma-jijïäsä. Life is meant for understanding the Absolute Truth. Vedic civilization is based on this principle, but modern civilization has deviated and is devoting itself to that which cannot possibly relieve us from the tribulations of birth, old age, disease, and death. So-called scientific advancement has not solved life's real problems. Although we are eternal, we are presently subjected to birth and death. In this age of Kali-yuga, people are slow to learn about self-realization. People create their own way of life, and they are unfortunate and disturbed.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas concludes that if the laws of God and man conflict, we should obey the laws of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. We can also obey the man who obeys the laws of God. It is useless to obey an imperfect person. That is the blind following the blind. If the leader does not follow the instructions of the supreme controller, he is necessarily blind, and he cannot lead. Why should we risk our lives by following blind men who believe that they are knowledgeable but are not? We should instead decide to take lessons from the Supreme Person, Kåñëa, who knows everything perfectly. Kåñëa knows past, present, and future, and what is for our benefit.

Hayagréva däsa: For Aquinas, all earthly powers exist only by God's permission. Since the Church is God's emissary on earth, the Church should control secular power as well. He felt that secular rulers should remain subservient to the Church, which should be able to excommunicate a monarch and dethrone him.

Çréla Prabhupäda: World activities should be regulated so that God is the ultimate goal of understanding. Although the Church, or the brähmaëas, may not directly carry out administrative activities, the government should function under their supervision and instructions. That is the Vedic system. The administrators, the kñatriyas, used to take instructions from the brähmaëas, who could deliver a spiritual message. It is mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä (4.1) that millions of years ago, Kåñëa instructed the sun god in the yoga of Bhagavad-gétä. The sun god is the origin of the kñatriyas. If the king follows the instructions of the Vedas or other scriptures through the brähmaëas, or through a bona fide church, he is not only a king but a saintly person as well. The kñatriyas should follow the orders of the brähmaëas, and the vaiçyas should follow the orders of the kñatriyas. The çüdras should follow the instructions of the three superior orders.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the beauty of God, Aquinas writes: "God is beautiful in Himself and not in relation to some limited terminus....It is clear that the beauty of all things is derived from the divine beauty....God wishes to multiply His own beauty as far as possible, that is to say, by the communication of His likeness. Indeed, all things are made in order to imitate divine beauty in some fashion."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, God is the reservoir of all knowledge, beauty, strength, fame, renunciation, and wealth. God is the reservoir of everything, and therefore whatever we see that is beautiful emanates from a very minute part of God's beauty.

yad yad vibhütimat sattvaà
çrémad ürjitam eva vä
tat tad evävagaccha tvaà
mama tejo-'àça-sambhavam

"Know that all beautiful, glorious, and mighty creations spring from but a spark of My splendor." (Bg. 10.41)

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the relationship between theology and philosophy, Aquinas writes: "As sacred doctrine is based on the light of faith, so is philosophy founded on the natural light of reason....If any point among the statements of the philosophers is found contrary to faith, this is not philosophy but rather an abuse of philosophy, resulting from a defect in reasoning."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is correct. Due to material conditional life, every man is defective. The philosophy of defective people cannot help society. Perfect philosophy comes from one who is in contact with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and such philosophy is beneficial. Speculative philosophers base their beliefs on imagination.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas concluded that divine revelation is absolutely necessary because very few men can arrive at the truth through the philosophical method. It is a path full of errors, and the journey takes a long time.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact. We should directly contact the Supreme Person, Kåñëa, who has complete knowledge. We should understand His instructions and try to follow them.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas believed that the author of sacred scriptures can be only God Himself, who can not only "adjust words to their meaning, which even man can do, but also adjust things in themselves." Also, scriptures are not restricted to one meaning.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The meaning of scriptures is one, but the interpretations may be different. In the Bible it is stated that God created the universe, and that is a fact. One may conjecture that the universe was created out of some chunk, or whatever, but we should not interpret scripture in this way. We present Bhagavad-gétä as it is without interpretation or motive. We cannot change the words of God. Unfortunately, many interpreters have spoiled the God consciousness of society.

Hayagréva däsa: In this, Aquinas seems to differ from the official Catholic doctrine, which admits only the Pope's interpretation. For him, the scriptures may contain many meanings according to our degree of realization.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The meaning is one, but if we are not realized, we may interpret many meanings. It is stated both in the Bible and Bhagavad-gétä that God created the universe.

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate

"I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me." (Bg. 10.8) If it is a fact that everything is an emanation of God's energy, why should we accept a second meaning or interpretation? What is the possible second meaning?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, in the Bible it is stated that after creating the universe, God walked through paradise in the afternoon. Aquinas would consider this to have an interior, or metaphorical, meaning.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God can create, He can also walk, speak, touch, and see. If God is a person, why is a second meaning necessary? What could it possibly be?

Hayagréva däsa: Impersonal speculation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is the creator of all things, He must be a person. Things appear to come from secondary causes, but actually everything is created by the Supreme Creator.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas seems to have encouraged individual interpretation. He writes: "It belongs to the dignity of divine scripture to contain many meanings in one text, so that it may be appropriate to the various understandings of men for each man to marvel at the fact that he can find the truth that he has conceived in his own mind expressed in divine scripture."

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. If one's mind is perfect, he may give a meaning, but, according to our conviction, if one is perfect, why should he try to change the word of God? And if one is imperfect, what is the value of his change?

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas doesn't say "change."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Interpretation means change. If man is imperfect, how can he change the words of God? If the words can be changed, they are not perfect. So there will be doubt whether the words are spoken by God or by an imperfect person.

Hayagréva däsa: The many different Protestant faiths resulted from such individual interpretation. It's surprising to find this viewpoint in Aquinas.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As soon as you interpret or change the scripture, the scripture loses its authority. Then another man will come and interpret things in his own way. Another will come and then another, and in this way the original purport of the scripture is lost.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas believed that it is not possible to see God in this life. He writes: "God cannot be seen in His essence by one who is merely man, except he be separated from this mortal life....The divine essence cannot be known through the nature of material things."

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he mean by divine essence? For us, God's divine essence is personal. When one cannot conceive of the Personality of Godhead, he sees the impersonal feature everywhere. When one advances further, he sees God as the Paramätmä within his heart. That is the result of yoga meditation. Finally, if one is truly advanced, he can see God face to face. When Kåñëa came, people saw Him face to face. Christians accept Christ as the son of God, and when he came, people saw him face to face. Does Aquinas think that Christ is not the divine essence of God?

Hayagréva däsa: For a Christian, Christ must be the divine essence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And didn't many people see him? Then how can Aquinas say that God cannot be seen?

Hayagréva däsa: It's difficult to tell whether Aquinas is basically impersonalist or personalist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That means that he is speculating.

Hayagréva däsa: He writes about the personal feature in this way: "Because God's nature has all perfection and thus every kind of perfection should be attributed to Him, it is fitting to use the word 'person' to speak of God; yet when used of God it is not used exactly as it is of creatures but in a higher sense....Certainly the dignity of divine nature surpasses every nature, and thus it is entirely suitable to speak of God as a 'person.'" Aquinas is no more specific than this.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Christ is accepted as the son of God, and if the son can be seen, why can't the Father be seen? If Christ is the son of God, who is God? In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says: ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù. "Everything is emanating from Me." (Bg. 10.8) Christ says that he is the son of God, and this means that he emanates from God. Just as he has his personality, God also has His personality. Therefore we refer to Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning God's names, Aquinas writes: "Yet since God is simple and subsisting, we attribute to Him simple and abstract names to signify His simplicity, and concrete names to signify His subsistence and perfection; although both these kinds of names fail to express His mode of being, because our intellect does not know Him in this life as He is."

Çréla Prabhupäda: One of God's attributes is being. Similarly, one of His attributes is attraction. God attracts everything. The word "Kåñëa" means "all attractive." What, then, is wrong with addressing God as Kåñëa? Because Kåñëa is the enjoyer of Rädhäräëé, His name is Rädhikä-ramaëa. Because He exists, He is called the Supreme Being. In one sense, God has no name, but in another sense He has millions of names according to His activities.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas maintains that although the names apply to God to signify one reality, they are not synonymous because they signify that reality under diverse aspects.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God's names are there because He has different features and activities.

Hayagréva däsa: But Aquinas asserts that no name belongs to God in the same sense that it belongs to creatures.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The names of creatures are also derived from God. For instance, Hayagréva appeared as the horse incarnation, and therefore a devotee is named Hayagréva, which means "servant of God." This name is not created; it refers to the activities of God.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas believed that names of God that imply relation to creatures are predicated of God temporarily. He writes: "Though God is prior to the creature, still, because the signification of 'Lord' includes the idea of a servant and vice versa, these two relative terms, Lord and servant, are simultaneous by nature. Hence God was not 'Lord' until He had a creature subject to Himself....Thus names which import relation to creatures are applied to God temporarily, and not from eternity, since God is outside the whole order of creation."

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is always existing as the Lord, and His servants are existing everlastingly with Him. How can He be the Lord without a servant? How can it be that God has no servants?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, the contention is that creatures were created at one point in time, and before that, God must have been by Himself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a material idea. It is the material world that is created, not the spiritual world. The spiritual world and God are existing everlastingly. The bodies of creatures in this material world are created, but God is always in the spiritual world with countless servants. According to our philosophy, there is no limit to living entities. Those who do not like to serve are put into this material world. As far as our identity as eternal servant is concerned, that is eternal, whether we are in the material or spiritual world. If we do not serve God in the spiritual world, we come down into the material world to serve the illusory energy of God. In any case, God is always master, and the living entity always servant. In the material world, the living entity, although a servant, is thinking of himself as a master. This is a false conception that creates many disturbances. This forgetfulness or misconception is not possible in the spiritual world. There, the self-realized souls know their position as eternal servants of God, the eternal spiritual master.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas felt that the less determinate God's name, the more universal and absolute it is. He therefore believed that the most proper name for God is "He who is."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why? If God is active and has created the entire universe, what is wrong in addressing Him according to His activities and attributes?

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas claims that the very essence of God is the sheer fact of His being, the fact that He is.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He is, certainly, but "He is" means that He is existing in His abode with His servants, playmates, hobbies, and paraphernalia. Everything is there. We must ask what is the meaning or nature of His being.

Hayagréva däsa: It seems that Aquinas was basically impersonalist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. He could not determine whether God is personal or impersonal. His inclination was to serve God as a person, but he had no clear conception of His personality. Therefore he speculates.

Hayagréva däsa: In the Vedas, is there an equivalent to "He who is?"

Çréla Prabhupäda: Oà tat sat is impersonal. This mantra, however, can also be extended as oà namo bhagavate väsudeväya. The word väsudeva means "one who lives everywhere," and refers to Bhagävan, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. God is both personal and impersonal, but the impersonal feature is secondary. According to Bhagävan Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä:

brahmaëo hi pratiñöhäham
amåtasyävyayasya ca
çäçvatasya ca dharmasya
sukhasyaikäntikasya ca

"And I am the basis of the impersonal Brahman, which is the constitutional position of ultimate happiness, and which is immortal, imperishable and eternal." (Bg. 14.27) What is the purport to that?

Hayagréva däsa [reading]: "The constitution of Brahman is the beginning of transcendental realization. Paramätmä, the Supersoul, is the middle, the second stage in transcendental realization, and the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the ultimate realization of the Absolute Truth."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is divine essence.

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas was perhaps the most prolific of the Church writers. His Summa Theologiae still serves as official Roman Catholic doctrine. Since the words of Christ are often allegorical, they have always been open to many different interpretations.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not very good.

Hayagréva däsa: Christ used a lot of parables to simplify a transcendental message. For instance, he likened the word of the kingdom of God to a seed that sometimes falls among thorns, or on rocky land, and even somtimes in a fertile place, where it grows.

Çréla Prabhupäda: A similar description is given in the Upaniñads, wherein the living entity is compared to a spark, and God to the fire. When the sparks are in the fire, they are illuminated, but when they fall from the fire, their position is different. The sparks may fall on rock, in the water, or on the ground, just as the living entity may fall into the modes—sattva-guëa, rajo-guëa, and tamo-guëa—within the material world.

DS:John Duns Scotus (1265?-1308)

John Duns Scotus (1265?-1308)

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus, a Thirteenth Century Scotsman, was Thomas Aquinas's principal antagonist. Whereas Aquinas emphasized the intellect, Scotus emphasized what he called the primacy of will. The will is even superior to the intellect, and this is true for both God and man. Scotus felt that if this were not the case, the will would not be free but would be controlled by the intellect, which is exterior to the soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Vedic understanding, intelligence, or intellect, is superior to the mind, and superior to the intelligence is the ego. The mind is superior to the gross senses and controls them.

indriyäëi paräëy ähur
indriyebhyaù paraà manaù
manasas tu parä buddhir
yo buddheù paratas tu saù

"The working senses are superior to dull matter; mind is higher than the senses; intelligence is still higher than the mind; and he [the soul] is even higher than the intelligence." (Bg. 3.42)

If the mind acts intelligently, the senses can be utilized for self-realization. If the mind does not act intelligently, the senses act for material sense gratification. This is the conclusion of Bhagavad-gétä.

bandhur ätmätmanas tasya
yenätmaivätmanä jitaù
anätmanas tu çatrutve
vartetätmaiva çatruvat

"For him who has conquered the mind, the mind is the best of friends; but for one who has failed to do so, his very mind will be the greatest enemy." (Bg. 6.6)

A dog also has a mind, but his intelligence is inferior to that of human beings. When a dog sees some eatables, he will come for them, although his master may drive him away. If he has a little intelligence, he goes away when his master tells him to, but due to his limited intelligence, after a few minutes he may return. He has a mind capable of remembering that there is something eatable for him, but he hasn't sufficient intelligence to know that the food is forbidden. That is the difference between the mind and the intelligence. Therefore, according to the Vedic understanding, intelligence is superior to the mind.

Hayagréva däsa: Where does the will enter?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Thinking, feeling, and willing are activities of the mind, and are within the mind.

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus believes that everything is subordinate to the divine will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Of course, because the divine will is always perfect. Whatever is divine is perfect and flawless. Whatever the Supreme Divine Personality wills actually becomes a fact. Our thinking, feeling, and willing differ from the supreme will of the Personality of Godhead. Our mind proposes, and God disposes. We may express our will, but unless our desires are sanctioned by the will of the Supreme, they cannot be fulfilled. Despite our willing to live to a certain age, for instance, we cannot do so if God does not will us to. In every sphere of activity, we express our will, but our will must be sanctioned by the supreme will in order to be successful. Therefore God's will is called supreme.

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus would say that everything is good because it is sustained by God's absolute will. God's killing is good, for instance, simply because God wills it to be so.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Because God is perfect, whatever He does is perfect.

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus's view is in opposition to that of Aquinas, who would say that everything is subordinate to the divine intelligence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what does he understand by the divine intelligence? In relation to us, divine intelligence is this: We living entities are eternal servants of God, but we have wanted to become God ourselves, master of everything. Ignorance, or mäyä, thus differs from divine intelligence. In the ignorance of materialism, people work very hard to become monarchs of all they survey. All this is taking place under various "ism's." We are thinking that we are proprietors, but the Supreme Lord is the only factual proprietor.

éçäväsyam idam sarvaà
yat kiïca jagatyäà jagat
tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä
mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam

"Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one should not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong." (Éçopaniñad 1)

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus believes that there is an interplay of the will and the intellect because before we will something to be, we must first know the facts about it. Despite this counterplay, Scotus maintains that the will alone is the total cause of volition in the will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is thinking, feeling, and willing. When we are ignorant, we think our will is supreme. So-called philosophers like to say, "I think," or "I believe," but this is not perfect knowledge. Perfect knowledge is thinking as God Himself thinks.

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus affirmed that it was the Church's unfailing authority that provided the criterion of truth. Church dogma was sacred, and philosophy was naturally subordinate to it. Revelation was behind all Church dogma, and therefore sacred dogma is not open for debate.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If by "church" we mean an institution wherein we can learn about God, then philosophy is certainly subordinate. In such a Church, we can learn what God Himself is, what He is willing, and how He is acting. We may learn this either from the Bible or another scripture. However, if the Church is polluted by imperfect interpretation, and there are different factions, the truth is lost. At such a time, the authority of Christ is no longer imparted. People become free to think and act as they like, and thus God's kingdom is lost.

Hayagréva däsa: Because the paramparä is broken?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. The Church is the supreme authority provided that it maintains itself in exactly the same way and does not deviate from its beginning. As soon as we interpret and divide, the message is lost.

Hayagréva däsa: The Protestants claimed that the paramparä of the Catholic Church was broken, therefore they broke from Catholicism and fragmented into many different sects.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, they condemned the Catholic Church because its paramparä was broken, but they concluded, "Let us also break." Those who first broke away from the message as it is and those who followed them by breaking away themselves are both to blame. Since the original solidarity of the Christian religion is broken, the Christian religion is dwindling and losing its importance.

Hayagréva däsa: For Scotus, apart from being a human being, each individual is also a specific personality. The individual is the ultimate reality because prior to existence he existed in essence in the mind of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The real fact is that the living entity is eternal, and the material world is created to satisfy his false existence, which is called false ego (ahaìkära). The individual is thinking that he is independent and can act independent of God. That is the beginning of paradise lost, of Adam's fall. When Adam and Eve thought that they could do something independently, they were condemned. Every living entity is the eternal servant of God, and he must act according to the desire or will of the Supreme Lord. When he deviates from this principle, he is lost. Losing paradise, he comes into the material world, and God gives him certain facilities to act, but says, "If you act according to this system, you can come back to Me. If you do not follow this system, you go down and down." That is the process of transmigration, the rotation of the cycle of birth and death. This is all due to disobeying God. When the living entity hears the instructions of the Supreme Lord, he again revives his original constitutional position and returns home, back to Godhead.

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reactions. Do not fear." (Bg. 18.66)

Hayagréva däsa: Aquinas believed that the angels—what the Vedas might call devas—have pure spiritual forms, but Scotus argues that only God Himself has a purely spiritual form since only God is perfect essence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, since God exists in His spiritual form, He never falls down; therefore He is sometimes called Acyuta. When a person falls from his original, spiritual position, he is cyuta, fallen. God, however, is Acyuta because He is not subject to falling down.

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus rejects the method of negation, the neti-neti process, as being of no particular value. Knowledge of God must be positive, and negative concepts only presuppose a positive concept.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the neti-neti process is for those who are still speculating. This is an indirect process by which one negates everything material. Positive understanding means taking direct knowledge from God Himself.

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conqueror of wealth [Arjuna], there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7) If we accept the words of God, we save ourselves much labor. We cannot understand God by speculation, but still we are inclined to speculate. But knowing God perfectly is knowing God beyond a doubt. Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

mayy äsakta-manäù pärtha
yogaà yuïjan mad-äçrayaù
asaàçayaà samagraà mäà
yathä jïäsyasi tac chåëu

"Now hear, O son of Påthä, how by practicing yoga in full consciousness of Me, with mind attached to Me, you can know Me in full, free from doubt." (Bg. 7.1) The word asaàçayam means "without a doubt," and samagram means "complete." Following Kåñëa and trying to understand Him is called bhakti-yoga, and such yoga is possible for one who is actually attached to Kåñëa. Therefore our first business is learning how to be attached to Kåñëa (mayy äsakta-manäù pärtha). There are nine different aspects of bhakti-yoga: çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù smaraëaà, etc. Of these, çravaëaà (hearing), and kértanaà (chanting), are most important. Then there is remembering, worshipping in the temple according to the regulations, rising early in the morning, offering ärätrika, and so forth. This is the process of bhakti-yoga meant to increase our devotion for Kåñëa. When attachment increases, we become very obedient and always engage devotedly in His service. When Kåñëa sees that we are obeying Him, He reveals Himself.

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." (Bg. 10.10) These are the words of Çré Kåñëa speaking directly to Arjuna, and we take this to be a perfect statement. What is the purport I give to this in Bhagavad-gétä As It Is?

Hayagréva däsa [reading]: "In this verse the word buddhi-yogam is very significant. We may remember that in the Second Chapter, the Lord, instructing Arjuna, said that He had spoken to him of many things, and that He would instruct him in the way of buddhi-yoga. Now buddhi-yoga is explained. Buddhi-yoga itself is action in Kåñëa consciousness; that is the highest intelligence. Buddhi means intelligence, and yogam means mystic activities, or mystic elevation. When one tries to go back home, back to Godhead, and takes fully to Kåñëa consciousness in devotional service, his action is called buddhi-yogam. In other words, buddhi-yogam is the process by which one gets out of the entanglement of this material world. The ultimate goal of progress is Kåñëa. People do not know this; therefore the association of devotees and a bona fide spiritual master is important. One should know that the goal is Kåñëa, and when the goal is assigned, then the path is slowly but progressively traversed and the ultimate goal reached.

"When a person knows the goal of life but is addicted to the fruits of activities, he is acting in karma-yoga. When he knows that the goal is Kåñëa, but he takes pleasure in mental speculations to understand Kåñëa, he is acting in jïäna-yoga. And when he knows the goal and seeks Kåñëa completely in Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service, he is acting in bhakti-yoga, or buddhi-yoga, which is the complete yoga. This complete yoga is the highest perfectional stage of life.

"A person may have a bona fide spiritual master and may be attached to a spiritual organization, but still, if he is not intelligent enough to make progress, then Kåñëa from within gives him instructions so that he may ultimately come to Him without difficulty. The qualification is that a person always engage himself in Kåñëa consciousness and with love and devotion render all kinds of services. He should perform some sort of work for Kåñëa, and that work should be with love. If a devotee is intelligent enough, he will make progress on the path of self-realization. If one is sincere and devoted to the activities of devotional service, the Lord gives him a chance to make progress and ultimately attain to Him."

Çréla Prabhupäda: So this is the process in summary.

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus argued for the existence of God on the basis of primary cause, but he felt that the proposition "God exists" is not of much use unless we understand what God is and know something of His nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is the Supreme Father, and He has created everything within our experience. When we are convinced that there is certainly a creator, we can make further progress to understand the nature of that creator. Is He animate or inanimate? Is He matter, or a living being? Further analysis takes up from this point, but first we must understand that God is the creator. That is very well explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father." (Bg. 14.4) Everything is coming from the womb (yoni) of material nature. If the earth or material nature is the mother, there must be a father. Of course, atheists think that a mother can give birth without a father, but that thinking is most unnatural. One next asks, "Who is my father? What is his position? How does he talk? How does he live?" First we must understand that there is a creator father, and then we can understand His nature. This understanding must be beyond a doubt (asaàçayaà).

Hayagréva däsa: Scotus was also opposed to Aquinas in his belief that the human soul can be separated from the body, and when it is separated, it is not changed at all. When the soul is united with the body, it activates the body, but the soul itself is beyond corruption. The individual soul is incapable of destroying itself or giving itself being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The individual soul is always separate from the body. That is the Vedic injunction: asaìgo hyayaà puruñaù iti (Båhad-äraëyakopanéñat 4.3.16). If the body actually mixed with the soul, how could the soul give up one body and accept another? The soul is always aloof from the body, from its material formation. The living entity, the jéva-soul, is always asaìga, incorruptible.

IVRENAISSANCE THOUGHT

IVRENAISSANCE THOUGHT

DS:Niccolo Machiavelli (1469-1527)

Niccolo Machiavelli (1469-1527)

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli has been called the most influential political philosopher of the Renaissance, and his philosophy of politics has influenced rulers down to modern times. He is typical of the Renaissance in that he turned from the subjects of the Church fathers—such as God, heaven, and salvation—to concentrate on man and nature. The Renaissance marked a decline in the Church's power, and philosophy began a process of secularization. Machiavelli himself admitted that his most famous work, The Prince, does not apply to a Utopian state composed of good citizens; rather, it is an unscrupulous philosophy that applies to corrupt citizens. The Prince is a guidebook for a tyrant, and it contains the advice he chose to impart to the ruling Medici family. It is a justification for immoral actions. Power is the ultimate goal, and in the quest for power, the end justifies the means. Success in attaining power makes one the object of obedience and respect. Failure is the only sin.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So, this is politics, the occupation of kñatriyas. In Bhagavad-gétä, the qualities of a kñatriya are given:

çauryaà tejo dhåtir däkñyaà
yuddhe cäpy apaläyanam
dänam éçvara-bhävaç ca
kñätraà karma svabhäva-jam

"Heroism, power, determination, resourcefulness, courage in battle, generosity, and leadership are the qualities of work for the kñatriyas" (Bg. 18.43) Of course, in modern politics, the king or president does not come onto the battlefield to exhibit his courage. He simply appears when there is a battle of words, but when there is an actual battle, he remains in a secluded place and lets the citizens fight. And he institutes a draft board to assure that they will. According to the Vedic system, however, when there is a fight, the king or president must be present on the battlefield and should lead the fight himself so that his men will be encouraged. This is called yuddhe cäpy apaläyanam. The leader of a nation should fight with all his ability and be determined either to gain victory in the battle, or lay down his life. Bhagavad-gétä itself is a guidebook for kñatriyas and was originally spoken to the sun-god millions of years ago. Sometimes, people try to interpret Bhagavad-gétä as a philosophy of nonviolence, but in politics there must be violence, because the king must emerge victorious. It is stated in the Vedas that if the king is victorious, he will be respected. Strength must be there. Apart from this, the chief of state must also be charitable, and formerly all the great kings performed big yajïas, sacrifices.

annäd bhavanti bhütäni
parjanyäd anna-sambhavaù
yajïäd bhavati parjanyo
yajïaù karma-samudbhavaù

"All living bodies subsist on food grains, which are produced from rains. Rains are produced by performance of yajïa [sacrifice], and yajïa is born of prescribed duties." (Bg. 3.14) When sufficient sacrifices are performed by the royal head of government, rainfall results. Power in itself is not sufficient. One must be powerful enough to fully satisfy the citizens by supplying them sufficient grains so that men and animals can eat and be satisfied. This is an ability that the politician or prince should have. He should be not only powerful but charitable as well. Taxes exacted from the citizens should be properly utilized in performing sacrifices. Of course, it is not possible to perform yajïas today as previously. Formerly, they used to sacrifice tons of ghee and grain in the fire, but today that is impractical. The best yajïa for today is saìkértana-yajïa propagated by this Kåñëa consciousness movement. The heads of state should encourage this.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli felt that the prince must at least exhibit five basic virtues, whether he has them or not. These are mercy, faith, integrity, humanity, and religion. He writes: "It is not necessary for a prince to have all the above-mentioned qualities, but it is very necessary to seem to have them. I would even be so bold as to say that to possess them and always to practice them is dangerous, but to appear to possess them is useful. Thus it is well to seem merciful, faithful, humane, sincere, religious, and also to be so; but you must have your mind so disposed that, when it is needful to be otherwise, you can change to the opposite qualities."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, Machiavelli may think like that, but unless a prince or king possesses all these qualities, he is unworthy. If he is unworthy, he cannot remain a prince because he is situated artificially. Because the kings lacked the proper qualities, monarchy is finished today, and democracy has become prominent. In Indian history, however, there were kings like Mahäräja Parékñit, who actually possessed all good qualities. When Parékñit Mahäräja went on a tour of his kingdom and saw a black man attempting to kill a cow, the Mahäräja immediately drew his sword and said, "Who is this person trying to kill a cow in my kingdom? He must be punished." A king must exhibit such determination to give protection to all the inhabitants of his kingdom. At the present moment, governments are not offering protection for animals. They are killing cows, although cows are supplying milk from which we can make wonderful preparations. This is Kali-yuga, and the government does not exhibit good sense in any field. Since the government is unworthy of governing, there is chaos throughout the world. According to Vedic civilization, the king is worshipped as God in human form and is therefore called Naradeva. If the good qualities are lacking in a king, he can no longer be considered Naradeva, and he cannot rule for very long, because his rule is artificial. Therefore in Kali-yuga, the royal order is finished.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli didn't say that this is the way political life ought to be. Rather, since this is the way political life is at present, this is the best way a prince can rule.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our principles should be the same, whether in the past, present, or future. Kåñëa delivered Bhagavad-gétä millions of years ago to the king of the sun, Vivasvän. Five thousand years ago He repeated these same principles to Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. It is not that the principles have changed. Whether one is a prince, president, or whatever, the ruling principles should be maintained. Then the people will benefit. It is said that when Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira ruled, the people suffered neither from intense heat nor intense cold. There was regular rainfall, and people were free from all anxiety. Such is an ideal kingdom in which the people are happy in all respects.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli thought that the ruler should take the sins of the state upon himself, just as Christ took upon himself the sins of the world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if the ruler himself is sinful, how can he assume the sins of others?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, Machiavelli felt that evil in politics was a necessity. He writes: "A man who wishes to make a profession of goodness in everything must necessarily come to grief among so many who are not good."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if one is not good himself, how can he introduce anything that is good? Presently, in India, there are many people claiming to be big mahdtmds, religionists, scholars, and politicians, but they cannot even protect the cows. Bhagavad-gétä says:

kåñi-gorakñya-väëijyaà
vaiçya-karma svabhäva-jam

"Farming, cow protection, and business are the qualities of work for the vaiçyas." (Bg. 18.44) It is at least the duty of the state to protect the cow, which is a special animal. It is the king's duty to protect the welfare of all citizens, including the cows. If the king or president does no more than sit in an exalted position, the people will not be happy. Even in America, the people dragged their president down when they were discontent with him. In any case, the head of state must be ideal and exhibit the ideal princely characteristics.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli suggested that since the people usually desire peace, the prince should promote peace in his public addresses. On the other hand, the army always prefers war, which gives opportunities for promotion, and the prince should also appease the militarists. Although publicly promoting peace, the prince can break his promise whenever necessary to start a war abroad, especially when there is trouble at home.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No one can introduce peace unless he is educated in God consciousness. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

bhoktäraà yajïa-tapasäà
sarva-loka-maheçvaram
suhådaà sarva-bhütänäà
jïätvä mäà çäntim åcchati

“The sages, knowing Me as the ultimate purpose of all sacrifices and austerities, the Supreme Lord of all planets and demigods and the benefactor and well-wisher of all living entities, attain peace from the pangs of material miseries." (Bg. 5.29) The king should not think of his kingdom as his property or his father's property. Rather, knowing himself to be the representative of the Supreme Father, he must understand that the state belongs to the Supreme Father. He is a representative whose duty is to protect the state and the citizens. The proprietor of the state is God Himself. There is not a spot of land throughout the universe that is not owned by the Supreme Personality of Godhead; therefore all property should be engaged for the satisfaction of God. Bhoktäraà yajïa-tapasäm. Everything must be carried out for the satisfaction of the Supreme Lord, and this is ideal activity for all societies.

ataù pumbhir dvija-çreñöhä
varëäçrama-vibhägaçaù
svanuñöhitasya dharmasya
saàsiddhir hari-toñaëam

"O best among the twiceborn, it is therefore concluded that the highest perfection one can achieve, by discharging his prescribed duties [dharma] according to caste divisions and orders of life, is to please the Lord Hari." (Bhäg. 1.2.13) According to the çästras, there are social divisions—brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, and çüdra—and these divisions allow for proper management. It is the king's duty to divide human society according to the varëäçrama-dharma. There should be genuine brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, çüdras, brahmacärés, gåhasthas, vänaprasthas, and sannyäsés. No one should cheat but should carry out his duty accordingly. The king must know what is sin so that he can take precautions against it. But if he supports sinful activities—for instance, if he maintains a slaughterhouse—how can he become sinless? The çästras say that the king attains political power by pious activities, but if he does not give security to the citizens, he loses his power automatically.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli certainly believed that the people should be protected, but he also believed in the use of power and might. If there are internal difficulties, they must be put down by force. If this proves impossible, the prince should divert people's attention by starting a war abroad. He even felt that it was better to go to war than to remain neutral because a neutral nation is hated by the loser and not respected by the winner. Consequently, he praised power and war.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He praises war because he cannot manage internally. That is most inhumane.

Hayagréva däsa: "Trouble at home, war abroad" is one of his most famous points.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and sometimes the governments create artificial restlessness and poverty. We have seen in 1940, when the Second World War was going on, that the government created an artificial famine in order to get men to fight. People who didn't work had no alternative but to join the military. The government increased the price of food, and I remember the price of rice jumping from six rupees to ten rupees. The very next day, the price rose to twenty rupees. Then it jumped again to fifty rupees, whereas formerly it was only six. This is all the results of politics. When the government is not pious or strong, this will go on, and the people will be unhappy.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli's view of man was very cynical. He wrote: "In constituting and legislating for a commonwealth, it must be taken for granted that all men are wicked."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is not philosophy, considering all men wicked.

Hayagréva däsa: Well, he considered that men are so created that they desire all things, although they cannot acquire them. Men are never satisfied. As soon as they have one thing, they crave another.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore it is the duty of the government to introduce Kåñëa consciousness so that the people can know the way of peace and happiness.

Hayagréva däsa: As long as the prince benefitted the people, they would be entirely his.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But he must know how to benefit them.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli was very fond of speaking of "the common good," and he set love of country and the common good above the Christian love of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what is his common good? He is thinking that people must have enough to eat, but it is for the common good of everyone to love God. Love of God is for everyone, and God is one. When we become lovers of God, our lives are perfected.

Hayagréva däsa: But if the people are basically wicked, he argued, a strong prince is necessary to control them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why should the people remain wicked? It is the king's duty to see that all the citizens become gentlemen. He should not allow them to remain wicked. The educational, social, and religious systems should be so perfect that the people become God conscious. At least a sector of the people, the brähmaëas, should be perfect.

Hayagréva däsa: But he felt that if the prince were perfectly virtuous or truthful in all cases, he couldn't possibly survive in the political world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is why there are social divisions: brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras. It is not possible for everyone to be truthful, but at least a section of the people should be ideal so that others can take advantage of their good advice. It is not that everyone is in the same position, nor that everyone should join the military. Only those who are interested in fighting should join the military.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli recommended compulsory military service as a primary form of education for everyone.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nothing is meant for everyone. There must be divisions. Machiavelli had no idea that brahminical training is absolutely necessary for intelligent men.

Hayagréva däsa: Since youth should especially become used to hardships, he considered war as a form of education.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, any education requires hardships, and to become a brähmaëa or brahmacäré requires the greatest hardships. In any case, there must be educational divisions, just as there are divisions in the human body: the head, arms, belly, and legs. Military education is education of the arms, but where is the education for the brain? Unless the head is educated, how will the arms act?

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli recommended a democratic republic for a society consisting of virtuous people. In such a state, the ruler must obtain the people's consent. But he considered such a society to be purely Utopian.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a completely virtuous society is Utopian in this age. It is not possible. Yet a section of the population can be ideally virtuous, and the remainder may take lessons from them. It is not possible for everyone to become a brähmaëa, but a few can be trained. The sky may be full of stars, but one moon is all that is necessary. If the populace consists of fools and rascals, how can anything be managed? There must be at least a section that shines like the moon.

Hayagréva däsa: This cynical view of mankind was partially based on the Christian doctrine—or at least on the doctrine of Augustine—which held that man is by nature corrupt. Whereas Augustine believed in the saving grace of God, Machiavelli believed in man's willpower to overcome bad fortune.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But who adjusts good and bad fortune? If we consider good and bad fortune, we must consider a dispenser, a supreme power or controller, and that supreme power is God. Therefore people should be educated in God consciousness by reading transcendental literatures like Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli's attitude toward religion has greatly influenced modern governments. He considered religion to be a department of the state; it should not be separate in the sense that it should not compete.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In that I agree. It is the government's duty to give protection to religion, and if that religion is scientific, the state will be sound. America is presently strong in many respects, and now America must become strong in God consciousness. It is very good to write, "In God We Trust," but we must also know who God is and why we should trust in Him. We are therefore trying to introduce this science of God, Kåñëa consciousness.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli felt that as long as religion is not detrimental to the state, the state may accept it as valid. But in one sense, religion is subordinate to the state.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Of course, they are separate, but the state must know what religion is and how to introduce it to the general public. There is no question of blind faith. The government is maintaining many different departments: an engineering department, medical department, military department, and so forth. Similarly, a religious department may be subordinate to the state because all other departments are subordinate, but religion must be based on scientific knowledge. If the state takes advantage of the Vedic literatures, it can introduce a scientific system of religion. Then the people will be knowledgeable and happy.

Hayagréva däsa: For Machiavelli, the only sin is not acting for the common good. First, the ruler must protect the citizens from physical harm. Citizens are happy when they obey the laws, follow customs, and pray to God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If the ruler must first of all protect the citizens from physical harm, how can he advocate animal slaughter? Animals are also subjects because they are born in a country. A citizen is anyone who is born in a state. So how can a ruler discriminate between one type of citizen and another? If he discriminates, he cannot speak of common good. He can only say "man's good." According to the common good, animals as well as men are protected.

Hayagréva däsa: Machiavelli placed love of country and the common good above everything else. He rarely uses the word "God" or "Providence," but prefers the word "fortune." It is fortune that plays tricks on men and changes friends into enemies.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is fortune, who is misfortune? Since God is the supreme controller, He is both fortune and misfortune. When you act wrongly, punishment comes from God, and when you act properly, the reward comes from God.

Hayagréva däsa: Love of country transcends everything religious and moral, so that one may even lose his own soul for his country's sake. Indeed, Machiavelli wrote: "I love my country more than my soul."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But how long will he remain in his country?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, he remained from 1469 to 1527.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So what is that? Time and the soul are eternal. Such deification of one's country is not very intelligent.

DS:Francis Bacon (1561-1626)

Francis Bacon (1561-1626)

Hayagréva däsa: Francis Bacon is generally acknowledged as the founding father of modern science in England, and although he did not work in a modern laboratory like today's scientists, he inspired what has become known as the scientific method. He believed that science could give man a mastery over nature that would improve his life on this earth. For Bacon, science was not simply an intellectual or academic undertaking, but a utilitarian one.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is erroneous for Bacon or any other scientist to think that science can control nature. It is not possible to control birth, old age, disease, and death. During our lifetime, we may be able to make some changes and give some facilities, but that is not the ultimate end.

Hayagréva däsa: Bacon disliked mental speculation about God because we cannot expect God to conform to our own conception. Due to God's infinitude, no conception of God can be unbelievable. By and large, Bacon relegated theology to the realm of faith, and science to the realm of knowledge of the world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is good to be a master architect and make a house with all modern facilities, but if these facilities cause us to forget life's real aim, we have lost a great deal. It is better to remain without facilities, evacuate in the field, and bathe in the river, than overly concern ourselves with modern amenities, facilities for a pampered life. If we forget our real business—how to revive God consciousness—we have not advanced but regressed.

Hayagréva däsa: Bacon did not conceive of science as being a disunifying factor as far as religion or God is concerned. Rather, he believed that science could enable civilization to progress. It could be a binding force between man and God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is certainly a very good idea, but many modern scientists are denying the existence of God. Many are claiming that God is dead, that there is no need of God, or that we can manufacture God and man in our own way.

Hayagréva däsa: Bacon considered some knowledge to be supernatural in that it comes from God, whereas other forms of knowledge are attained through man's own attempts. He admits that the material senses are imperfect and act like false mirrors, which distort the actual world. Thus men are constantly being deceived.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, although they are advancing the cause of material science, they are forgetting God in the process. This is most degrading. Men should prove by scientific methods that God exists and is doing everything. Scientists should use a scientific method to understand how the supreme intelligent Being is working. God's scientific knowledge is perfect, and knowledge that complies with this is very good. But if men have a little knowledge and defy the existence of God, their knowledge is useless. So their little knowledge has become a dangerous thing.

Hayagréva däsa: Bacon says something very much like this. He writes: "It is true, that a little philosophy inclineth man's mind to atheism; but depth in philosophy bringeth men's minds about to religion."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father." (Bg. 14.4) If we have a little intelligence and think about this verse, we can understand that all living entities are coming from some womb. Since everyone is the child of some mother, there must be a father. When we are grown, we must understand our father, his property, and his desire. How can we deny a universal father?

Hayagréva däsa: This is Bacon's conclusion: "For a while, the mind of man looketh upon second causes scattered, it may sometimes rest in them, and go no further; but when it beholdeth the chain of them, confederate and linked together, it must needs fly to Providence and Deity."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. This is the version given in Bhagavad-gétä.

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate

"I am the origin of everything. Everything is emanating from Me." (Bg. 10.8) The Vedänta-sütra also states: janmädyasya yataù. "The Supreme Being is He from whom everything is emanating." It is a fact that there must be a source of everything, and it is the business of philosophy to find that original source. It is neither scientific nor philosophic to try to obscure or ignore the original source.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning superstition, Bacon writes: "It were better to have no opinion of God at all than such an opinion as is unworthy of Him. For one is unbelief, and the other is contumely."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why should we remain superstitious? Why not introduce education whereby everyone can understand God and His nature? We are trying to establish such an institution with this Kåñëa consciousness movement. If the government participates and cooperates, the masses of people can understand this science of God and benefit.

Hayagréva däsa: Bacon distinguished between sects and religions. Sects change, but true religion "is built upon the rock; the rest are tossed on the waves of time...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Real religion comes directly from God because religion is the law of God. Therefore we must philosophically and scientifically understand God and His law. That is the perfection of knowledge.

Hayagréva däsa: Many of the Indian sects are successful in America because their leaders do not impose any restrictions,

Çréla Prabhupäda: They have no conception of God. They come for some material profit, and this is revealed in the course of time.

Hayagréva däsa: Bacon also believed in the divine right of kings, maintaining that the king is empowered by God to make laws. He also felt that a national church could best provide for the people's spiritual needs.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore it is necessary that the king be so trained as not to misuse his power. According to the Vedic system, the king was educated to abide by the instructions of saintly persons, brähmaëas. The brähmaëas would advise, and the king would follow their desire. If a king misuses his power, he is good for nothing. His monarchy will be abolished, and the people will replace it with something else.

DS:Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679)

Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679)

Çyämasundara däsa: It is Hobbes who declared, "Whatever exists is matter, and whatever changes is motion." For him, mental or spiritual entities are not realities in their own right, but are merely by-products of matter. Spirit and mind perish when the material basis is destroyed.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Spirit is not a combination of material conditions. If so, why not combine matter in such a way as to produce living spirit, living forms?

Hayagréva däsa: Hobbes believed that a "substance incorporeal" is contradictory because nothing exists in the world but bodies. He defined God as "a most pure, simple, invisible, spirit corporeal."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why invisible? When Kåñëa came, He was certainly visible, for Arjuna was talking to Him face to face. God's visibility or invisibility depends on God's own good will. He is visible to one who is competent or perfect. Not only was He visible to Arjuna, but He reciprocated by answering Arjuna's questions. If we become qualified like Arjuna, we can see God and talk with Him. Then God will give direct instructions. God is invisible for one who is imperfect, but for one who is perfect, He is certainly visible.

Çyämasundara däsa: Empiricists maintain that the only proof we have of anything is through our senses.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that since the senses are imperfect, whatever you believe through them is imperfect. This is very simple. When the sun rises in the morning, it is many millions of miles away, but can a child tell how far away it is? Who can really tell how far away the sun is?

Çyämasundara däsa: They have invented certain instruments to measure distance.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore they have learned from some authority. Because they could not measure with their own senses, they have turned to instruments. But we should take the help of the expert instrument driver, Çré Kåñëa. What is the value of our senses if they are imperfect?

Çyämasundara däsa: So the mind or soul is not simply a physiological system?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul is a different energy. Heat and light emanate from the same source, fire. Nonetheless, heat is not light, and light is not heat. Sometimes we may feel heat, but that does not mean that there is light. Sometimes we may have light, but that does not mean that there is heat. Still, heat and light come from the same source.

Çyämasundara däsa: How is it that the soul and mind are different from the body?

Çréla Prabhupäda: They are not different, but they are being manifested in different phases. At the moment, we are experiencing sunshine, and we are feeling heat from the sun, but if we approach the sun, we feel much more intense heat. If we approach very closely, we will be disintegrated.

Çyämasundara däsa: But how is it that the soul is not produced by the body? How do we know that it is not a mere by-product?

Çréla Prabhupäda: At death, all the physical parts of the body are present. But why is the man dead? What is missing? His heart may be present, but why is it not beating? All the parts of the body may be present, yet you can see that the body is dead. What is it that is missing?

Çyämasundara däsa: Impulses are no longer being sent from the brain to the heart.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But why has the brain stopped? The brain's construction is all there. What is missing? Why not replace what is missing? If you are a mechanic, and the machine stops, you should be able to find the defect and immediately repair it. But no one has been able to do this with the body, no scientist or philosopher. They cannot meet such a challenge.

Hayagréva däsa: Hobbes is best known as a political philosopher, and in his most famous work, The Leviathan, he set forth his socio-political theories, as Machiavelli had done in The Prince. Hobbes's ruling body, or monarch, his "mortal god," who was under the immortal God, was The Leviathan, who would rule above the law. Now, according to the Vedic conception, is the king, or head of state, above the law?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. The king is also under the law. As we understand it from Bhagavad-gétä, Çré Kåñëa imparted His laws to the sun god. Since the sun god followed these laws, he is, compared to a common man, a supremely elevated being. The king is supposed to be the representative of God in the state, and the king's perfection lies in following the laws of Kåñëa. If the king follows the order of Kåñëa, the king's orders are final. In Bhagavad-gétä (4.1-2), Kåñëa says that He originally imparted the laws of Bhagavad-gétä to the sun god, Vivasvän, who imparted them to Manu, the father of man, who in turn imparted them to Ikñväku, and in this way Bhagavad-gétä was received via disciplic succession and imparted to the räjarñis, the saintly kings. If the king rules according to Bhagavad-gétä, he cannot be subjected to any other law. If the king follows the laws given by God, he is above mundane laws and conventions.

Hayagréva däsa: Hobbes compares man to a machine ultimately made by God, but he does not consider this machine to be controlled directly by God but by The Leviathan, the king or ruler.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. God is situated in everyone's heart, and every moment He is witnessing the actions of the soul. He knows what the soul desires, and He sees how the soul is manipulating the machine of the body. This is clearly explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà
håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati
bhrämayan sarva-bhütäni
yanträrüòhäni mäyayä

"The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart, O Arjuna, and is directing the wanderings of all living entities, who are seated as on a machine made of the material energy." (Bg. 18.61) If a person wants to enjoy this material world as a human being, God gives him the opportunity to become a human being, and if he wants to enjoy it as a dog, God gives him the body of a dog. This is all God's mercy. As long as the individual living entity wants to enjoy this material world, God gives all facility through a particular body. The body itself is material and is supplied by prakåti, material nature. The machine is composed of material ingredients supplied by prakåti, which follows the orders of Kåñëa, and it is given for the enjoyment of the living entity. The living entity, or jéva, sits in that machine and travels, just as a person travels in a car. He receives a particular machine in some species on some planet. There are innumerable planets, and over eight million different species. Due to his contact with material nature, the living entity desires so many things, and God is so merciful that He supplies all facilities. At the same time, God is a friend to everyone, and when the jéva is prepared to understand ultimate happiness from God, God says, "Give up all your nonsensical plans and surrender unto Me." This is the living entity's perfection, and if he does not come to this perfect stage, he will constantly desire so many things. God will then supply an unlimited number of machines to go here and there, and up and down, within this universe. Either you go up, or you come down. When you come down, you enter the lower species, and when you go up, you enter the higher species. These include the demigods like Lord Indra and Lord Brahmä. There are different types of life, and some endure millions of years, while others endure only a few moments. In any case, every opportunity is given by the Supreme Lord because He is the supreme controller. Man proposes, and God disposes. As long as we continue to propose this and that, we'll never be happy, but when we agree to comply with God's plans, we will attain happiness.

Hayagréva däsa: Hobbes would say that since warfare is perpetual, and the struggle for existence goes on and on, the Leviathan is necessary. It is the fear of death that drives men together into a social contract, and it is the Leviathan who places everything under a common power and authority. This Leviathan is like God's representative or lieutenant, who has sovereignty under God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the perfection of monarchy. Therefore the king is called nåpadeva, or naradeva, God in human form.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hobbes, the Leviathan must be sufficiently strong to enforce the social contract, the law. It is he who can punish anyone who does not live up to his end of the bargain. In this way, society and peace will be preserved.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But who is the right man? Since men are always defective, how is this possible? This means that we have to accept a man or an authority who is infallible, who is beyond suspicion.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yes, and therefore Hobbes says that such a man must be something like a mortal god. If such a mortal god cannot be found, a government has to be instituted.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Such a man has to be the direct representative of God. He not only has to understand what is written in the scriptures; he has to follow the instructions as well. This is the exalted position of the bona fide spiritual master.

säkñäd dharitvena samasta-çästrair
uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù
kintu prabhor yaù priya eva tasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

"The spiritual master is to be honored as much as the Supreme Lord, because he is the most confidential servitor of the Lord. This is acknowledged in all revealed scriptures and followed by all authorities. Therefore I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master, who is a bona fide representative of Çré Hari [Kåñëa]." (Çré Gurv-añöaka 7) The spiritual master, or guru, is the direct representative of Kåñëa because he is the most confidential servant of Kåñëa. Therefore his position is as good as Kåñëa's. He renders the most confidential service by trying to bring everyone to Kåñëa consciousness. Unless we come to that position, we will never be happy. Hobbes says that we have to find some sort of mortal god, but such a person must be one who actually knows God. We have to understand the qualifications of the bona fide guru from the Vedas. Then we have to approach the guru submissively. The guru is expert in transcendental Vedic knowledge, and he has fully given himself to Kåñëa. He is no longer disturbed by anything material. He is full in Brahman realization, and he is free from all material contamination. These are some of the preliminary qualifications of a godly man, but since Hobbes did not know these qualifications, he could never find such a man. Even when Kåñëa Himself was present, not everyone could understand that He was the Supreme Personality of Godhead. How will we be able to find the godly man unless we know what is God and what is a godly man? In order to find this out, we have to approach Bhagavad-gétä; otherwise our knowledge will remain imperfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: In Hobbes's case, a godly man is only necessary insofar as he is required to maintain peace.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But since godly men cannot be found, peace is maintained for a while, and then again there is disturbance. Social contracts can never be absolute because things are always changing. A certain social condition may prevail for a while, but in fifty years it will be totally different. How can we make a social contract that will never change? It is not possible in the material world. In the Vaikuëöha-loka, the spiritual sky, the social condition never changes. It is eternal. The inhabitants there are pleased to be with Kåñëa and dance, eat, play, and live with Him. That condition is eternal, nitya-siddha. Kåñëa is always there, and He is always tending surabhi cows. He is always playing on His flute, and He is always dancing with His friends, the gopés. Our business should be to enter into that eternal play, and that is the process of Kåñëa consciousness.

Hayagréva däsa: Hobbes claims that the Leviathan could not only be an individual but also a group of individuals.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a group of individuals can run the government provided they are devotees. But if this group is composed of rogues and rascals, it cannot represent God. Representatives of God abide by the laws of God.

dharmaà tu säkñäd bhagavat-praëétaà
na vai vidur åñayo näpi deväù
na siddha-mukhyä asurä manuñyäù
kuto nu vidyädhara-cäraëädayaù

"Real religious principles are enacted by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Although fully situated in the mode of goodness, even the great åñis who occupy the topmost planets cannot ascertain the real religious principles, nor can the demigods, or the leaders of Siddhaloka, to say nothing of the asuras, ordinary human beings, Vidyädharas and Cäraëas." (Bhäg. 6.3.19) Actual religion, or law, consists of what God Himself says. If we manufacture our own laws, without referring to God's program, we will ultimately fail.

Hayagréva däsa: In Leviathan, Hobbes writes: "Some men have pretended for their disobedience to their sovereign a new covenant, made not with men but with God, and this also is unjust; for there is no covenant with God but by mediation of somebody that represents God's person, which none does but God's lieutenent, who has this sovereignty under God." But might not this argument of divine right be used by a tyrant to discourage his subjects from rebelling? What guidelines are there to assure against this?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everything depends on the king's accepting the absolute instructions of God. In the Vedic civilization, the king absolutely followed the regulations given by God. The king's activities were confirmed by saintly persons, sages, and then they were carried out. It was not that the king acted whimsically. There was always an advisory board composed of saintly persons, who knew the Vedas very well. The sages used to guide the monarch, and therefore the monarch was the absolute governing body. The ministers helped, but the king was educated by God's direct instructions. For instance, Kåñëa gave direct instructions to the sun god (Bg. 4.1). According to Vedic tradition, there are two kñatriya (administrative) families: one coming from the sun god (sürya-vaàça), and one coming from the moon god (candra-vaàça). Sürya, the sun god, is the original kñatriya, and from him came Vaivasvata Manu. This is the age of Vaivasvata Manu, and from him came his son Ikñväku. Kåñëa's instructions are explicitly given in Bhagavad-gétä, and if governments throughout the world take them up, they will attain perfection. Then there will be no disturbances, and there will be peace and happiness. That will make a perfect world. Kåñëa has given instructions in all fields of activity, but people are so foolish due to their demoniac tendencies that they attempt to manufacture their own standards. If the heads of state are degraded either individually or collectively, how can there be good government?

Çyämasundara däsa: Hobbes contends that in the natural state, man is like all other animals. Might makes right, and the strongest always prevail. Therefore it is necessary that man form a social contract and volunteer to restrict natural liberties for the sake of self-preservation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not natural liberty but ghostly liberty. There are many haunted people, and in their unnatural condition they are falsely thinking, "I am God." The natural condition is to think, "I am God's servant." Any condition devoid of Kåñëa consciousness is unnatural. Kåñëa is the supreme, and I am His subordinate. My business is to render service unto Him. This is the natural position.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yet when men group together in a society to preserve themselves, they make a contract to the effect that they will not kill one another.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why not a group of asses? What is their utility? Do you mean to say that because a group of asses congregate that some good will come of it? These rogues are always making contracts after a big war. After World War I, they made a contract through the League of Nations, and that failed. Then they had a Second World War, and they formed the United Nations and made more contracts. Eventually that will all be dissolved again. These contracts and compromises may serve some purposes for the time being, but ultimately they are useless.

Çyämasundara däsa: Men in society volunteer, "I will not kill you or steal your property if you will not kill me or steal my property."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the thieves' contract. But, after all, if you remain a thief, what is the improvement? Thieves may steal some valuable things, and afterwards they congregate and say, "Let's divide the property honestly." Thieves are all dishonest, although they talk of honesty among themselves. Originally, everyone immigrated to America, and the whole land was stolen from the Indians. Now the thieves have formed a government and will not allow outsiders in without visas and passports and so many things. This is the kind of morality that is going on.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hobbes's social contract was something like the converse of the Golden Rule: "Do not do unto others what you would not have them do unto you."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That was also Buddha's theory. Lord Buddha pointed out that if someone hurts us, we feel pain. Why, therefore, should we hurt others? Of course, third and fourth-class men have to be taught in this way. But in Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells Arjuna, "Kill them!" Does this mean that Kåñëa's position is reduced? It is a question of the intelligence of the men involved.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, Hobbes is trying to determine how society can live peacefully.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, people have tried many times but have always failed. There cannot be any peace in this material world. Kåñëa says plainly:

äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

"From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place. But one who attains to My abode, O son of Kunté, never takes birth again." (Bg. 8.16) Since this is a place of misery, how can we establish peace here? We cannot. The material universe is structured in such a way that peace is not possible. As Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura says: saàsära-dävänala-léòha-loka (Çré Gurv-añöaka 1). This material world is exactly like a blazing forest fire. No one wants fire in a forest, but it takes place naturally. No one wants to fight, but fighting takes place. How can you check it simply by making a contract? We are thinking that the material world is a nice place to live, but this is like a man thinking that stool is nice because it has been dried in the sun. If the stool is soft, it is not so good. But in either case, it is stool. Padaà padaà yad vipadäà na teñäm (Bhäg. 10.14.58). In this world, there is danger at every step. Throughout history, people have tried to make contracts for peace, but it is not possible. One may refuse to submit to Kåñëa, but nature will not allow this. If we do not submit to Kåñëa, nature will punish us so that we will finally be obliged to submit to Him. That is nature's law. If We voluntarily submit to Kåñëa, that is for our benefit, but if we do not, nature's laws are so stringent that they will always give us trouble, and at the end we will be obliged to agree: väsudevah sarvaà iti. "Väsudeva, Kåñëa, is everything." (Bg. 7.19) If, after many births of struggle, we have to come to this point, why waste our time? Why not surrender to Kåñëa immediately? Otherwise, we will go on suffering according to nature's law.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hobbes is called a utilitarian because he accepts a thing only if it's pragmatic or useful.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is relative. A child is satisfied if you give him five rupees, but if you give his father five rupees, the man will think, "What is the use of this?" So the utility of five rupees is relative. Hobbes's conception of utility is not the same as Kåñëa's conception. Arjuna was thinking that he was speaking like a very learned man, but immediately Kåñëa told him that he was not (Bg. 2.11). All this is relative. The hog thinks that he is in a comfortable position and is eating very nicely, but he is eating stool and living in garbage. Crows believe one thing, and swans believe another. An imperfect man like Hobbes may believe one thing to be pragmatic, but one who is perfect may consider something totally different to be pragmatic.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hobbes accepted religion only as a practical instrument. He says that it doesn't have any real value as a science but that it may be used by the state to pacify the people or to keep them confused.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he does not know what religion is. Of course, some people have made religion into a certain type of faith, but actually religion means one's inherent characteristic. Religion is to the living entity what sweetness is to sugar. It is an inherent characteristic that cannot be separated. Every living entity is rendering service to someone. Everyone is subordinate to someone else, or to his senses. It is the characteristic of the living entity to be subordinate and to render service. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says, "Surrender unto Me." (Bg. 18.66) That is our first business, but we are too busy trying to become Kåñëa. Therefore we say, "I am God," or, "You are God," or, "We are all God." The living entity is not the Supreme God, but he is playing that way. When a man is haunted by ghosts, he says many nonsensical things. Similarly, when the living entity is under the clutches of the material energy, he speaks in such a way.

Çyämasundara däsa: What about this idea of utility? What do you think of something being accepted only as long as it is useful?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is our foolishness that we accept something temporarily useful. Our real desire is to have eternal life. We want something that is eternally useful, but in the material world we are always being frustrated. We want to live here permanently, but nature will not allow this. Even if there is no disturbance in the form of war, we will still not be allowed to remain.

Çyämasundara däsa: A utilitarian would say that a thing should be used only insofar as it is required for some time. Then something else can be used, and in this way we can adjust things indefinitely.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But another point is that no one wants anything to change. Why? People want permanence because they are seeking their eternal, spiritual nature.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hobbes might say that although we may be seeking something eternal, we may employ temporary things just as long as they are useful.

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, we must know what our eternal life is; then we can try to use everything favorable to further that end. Kåñëa is the ultimate goal, and whatever is favorable in helping us toward Him should be accepted. That is real utilitarianism. For instance, Arjuna said, "What should I do? Kill or not kill? Kåñëa wants me to kill. All right, I'll kill." This is utilitarianism.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hobbes, the goal is a peaceful society.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not possible. The goal should be the advancement of Kåñëa consciousness. Then peace will follow automatically.

Çyämasundara däsa: His utilitarianism means the acceptance of whatever is favorable for the preservation of society.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In any case, society cannot be preserved. So many societies have come and gone. British society. Roman society. Greek society. Only Kåñëa's society is eternal. Knowing this is intelligence. Nitya-lélä-praviñöa. "Now he has entered the eternal society of Kåñëa." This is what we say when our guru passes away. We are accepting Kåñëa as the Supreme and glorifying Him here on earth. This same process will go on there in the spiritual sky, in Kåñëa's abode. However, there it will take place in a perfect way. Here we are just practicing.

VRATIONALISM

VRATIONALISM

DS:Rene Descartes (1596-1650)

Rene Descartes (1596-1650)

Hayagréva däsa: In Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes writes: "The power of forming a good judgement and of distinguishing the true from the false, which is called good sense or reason, is by nature equal in all men.... God has given to each of us some light with which to distinguish truth from error." Is he speaking of the Supersoul, or another form of intellection?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Supersoul is one thing, and reasoning is another. Still, reasoning should be there. For instance, through reasoning, we can understand that the body is just a lump of matter composed of skin, bone, muscle, blood, stool, urine, and so forth. Through our reasoning power, we can ask if a combination of these ingredients can bestow life, and we can come to understand that life is different from a lump of matter.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Descartes, all truth can be derived from reason, which is superior to and independent of sense experience. Knowledge is deductible from self-evident concepts, or innate, necessary ideas. In other words, he disagrees with those empiricists who believe that truth can be derived only from sense experience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We cannot understand God through sense experience, but through our reason we can understand that there is God. We can reason, "I have my father, and my father also has a father, who has a father, and so on. Therefore there must be a Supreme Father." God is the supreme and original Father, and by reasoning we can understand that He exists. Similarly, we can also understand by reasoning that God is the creator. We see that everything has a maker, a creator, and we can conclude that this great cosmic manifestation also has a creator. This is reasoning, but rascals speculate that in the beginning there was a big chunk of matter and an explosion, or whatever, that started the universe. But if there were an explosion, there must have been some explosive, and if there were some explosive, there must have been some worker to set it off. Otherwise, how did the chunk of matter explode? Through our reason we can perceive that everything has some creator or cause.

Hayagréva däsa: Descartes claims that good sense or reason is by nature equal in all men, but doesn't the reasoning power differ?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, otherwise why is one man intelligent and another ignorant? When, through reasoning, one concludes that the living force within the body is different from the body itself, he is on the human platform. If he considers life to be nothing more than a combination of material ingredients, he remains an animal. That is the verdict of the Vedas.

yasyätma-buddhiù kuëape tri-dhätuke
sva-dhéù kalaträdiñu bhauma ijya-dhéù
yat-tértha-buddhiù salile na karhicij
janeñv abhijïeñu sa eva go-kharaù

"A human being who identifies this body made of three elements with his self, who considers the by-products of the body to be his kinsmen, who considers the land of birth worshipable, and who goes to the place of pilgrimage simply to take a bath rather than meet men of transcendental knowledge there, is to be considered like an ass or a cow." (Bhäg. 10.84.13) If one thinks that he is the body, he is no better than an animal. So through reasoning, we can conclude that the soul is not this and not that. This is the neti-neti process. We then have to continue our search and ask, "What is soul? What is Brahman?" We can then conclude that Brahman is the origin of matter and that matter is developed by the soul. That is the Vedic conclusion in the Vedänta-sütra. The act of sex, for instance, cannot bring about pregnancy unless a soul is present. People may have sex many times, and no pregnancy may result. You may sow a seed, and a tree may develop, but if you fry that seed before sowing it, it will not fructify because it is unsuitable for the soul to remain. The conclusion is that the soul is the basis of matter. Although the soul cannot be perceived materially, it is certainly there. Yet its presence can be understood by its symptoms, which are consciousness and bodily development. Just as the individual soul is the living force that gives life to the body, God is the supreme living force that gives life to the entire cosmic manifestation.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes's method involved searching within one's self for a basis of truth. That basis he found to be self-consciousness. He concluded that first of all, I exist, and then reasoned that God exists necessarily.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. I exist, my father exists, my grandfather exists, and so on; therefore God exists. In Sanskrit, we use the word ahaìkära, "I am." At the present moment, we exist, but our conception of existence is incorrect. We are thinking, "I exist through my body." We do not understand how it is we exist. By reasoning and understanding, we have to come to know that we are spirit soul and not the body. It is the spirit soul that exists. By reasoning, we can understand that we existed as a child, as a young man, and as an old man, and that after the body is finished, we will continue to exist. I still exist, and I have passed through many bodies, and by reasoning I can conclude that even after this body is destroyed, I will continue to exist. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin
näyaà bhütvä bhavitä vä na bhüyaù
ajo nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëo
na hanyate hanyamäne çarére

"For the soul there is never birth nor death. Nor, having once been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain." (Bg. 2.20) Even when the body is annihilated, the spirit soul continues. We can arrive at this conclusion through experience, and our experience can be confirmed by the çästras. This can also be concluded by reason. If this is supported in so many ways, it is a fact.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes claims that truth must be self-evident and innate, like the intuitive knowledge "I exist."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is innate knowledge: I exist now, I existed in the past, and I shall continue to exist in the future. This is also confirmed by Bhagavad-gétä:

na tv evähaà jätu näsaà
na tvaà neme janädhipäù
na caiva na bhaviñyämaù
sarve vayam ataù param

"Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings; nor in the future shall any of us cease to be." (Bg. 2.12) This is confirmed by Kåñëa, and my reasoning also agrees. The body changes during one lifetime. As I exist in a body that is different now from my childhood body, in the future I will continue to exist in a different body.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Descartes, whatever is clear and distinct—such as the mind's consciousness of itself—must be true.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this is true. I think in this way, and this is corroborated by authoritative scriptures and confirmed by the äcäryas. It is not that we think in a whimsical way. Çré Kåñëa, Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, and all the äcäryas agree; therefore there is no doubt.

Hayagréva däsa: In Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes further writes: "I fall into error because the power which God has given me of distinguishing the true from the false is not in me an infinite power." If we can never be certain that we can distinguish truth from error, where does certainty lie?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainty is in Kåñëa because He is absolute. He is infinite, and we are finite. The soul is finite Brahman, and the infinite Brahman is God. All religions accept the fact that God is the Supreme Father and that all living entities are His sons. Our existence is based on the mercy of the Supreme Father, and we can reach this conclusion by reasoning.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes claims that the elementary truths of consciousness are innate in man's personality and that they provide man with immediate and rational proof.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact. Because I am part and parcel of the Supreme Perfection, I am minutely perfect. A particle of gold may be minute, but it is gold nonetheless. Because I am part and parcel of the Supreme Perfection, I am perfect in minute quantity. Of course, I cannot become as great; that is the difference. We are qualitatively one with God and quantitatively different. All of the qualities found in God are also found in us in minute quantity. Due to association with mäyä, we have become imperfect. The whole process is to return to the perfectional point through Kåñëa consciousness, and that is called mukti, liberation. When we are situated in our original form, we attain perfection.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes says that the alleged truths which appear to our senses are unreliable and that only innate ideas are clear and unmuddled by the senses because they are derived from our own nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Is it that the truth has to be established by oneself and not by others?

Çyämasundara däsa: He first searched within himself to find some innate basis for truth. First of all, he discovered that "I am."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Ages ago, there were many people who could understand this. A fool thinks that all others are fools. A deaf man will talk very softly because he thinks that the sound he is making is sufficient. He has no other experience. Everyone thinks that all others are like himself. It is not that Descartes was the first man to realize the identification of the self, "I am." This awareness has been existing a very long time. Kåñëa says:

aham eväsam evägre
nänyad yat sad-asat param
paçcäd ahaà yad etac ca
yo 'vaçiñyeta so 'smy aham

"Brahmä, it is I, the Personality of Godhead, who was existing before the creation when there was nothing but Myself. Nor was there the material nature, the cause of this creation. That which you see now is also I, the Personality of Godhead, and after annihilation what remains will also be I, the Personality of Godhead." (Bhäg. 2.9.33) This is Kåñëa talking about the creation, but we can also say the same. We existed before these bodies were created, and we will continue to exist when these bodies are annihilated. However, our business involves these little bodies, and Kåñëa's business involves the whole universe. That is the difference. So this conception of "I" is present in God as well as in the living entity. What is so new about all this?

Hayagréva däsa: Descartes considers God a substance that is infinite, immutable, independent, all-knowing, and all-powerful. He is the creator of all things. Descartes writes: "Perhaps all those perfections which I am attributing to God are in some fashion potentially in me, although they do not show themselves, or issue an action."

Çréla Prabhupäda: I have often explained that the qualities that are infinitely present in God are finitely present in the living entities. For instance, the creative force is also within us, and we can create an airplane that can fly. However, we cannot create another planet that can float in space. Although we may be able to create so many wonderful devices, we are still finite. The creative power is present both in God and in the living entities because the living entities are part and parcel of God. God's knowledge is total, and our knowledge lies only within our limited sphere. God knows everything, and we know some things. The difference was pointed out by Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä:

vedähaà samatétäni
vartamänäni cärjuna
bhaviñyäëi ca bhütäni
mäà tu veda na kaçcana

"O Arjuna, as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, I know everything that has happened in the past, all that is happening in the present, and all things that are yet to come. I also know all living entities, but Me no one knows." (Bg. 7.26)

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes worked with a four-part methodology which is now called Cartesian methodology. First of all, one is never to accept anything as true which is not known truly and distinctly to be true.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Of course it is commendable not to accept anything blindly, but if you do not have the intelligence to understand, you have to consult one who is intelligent.

Çyämasundara däsa: He felt that the truth must be as clear and distinct as mathematical proof.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is good provided one is a mathematician, but if one is a plowman, what can he understand about mathematics?

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Descartes, it was up to those who could understand mathematics to chalk out the truth and pass it on to those less intelligent.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In other words, higher truth cannot be understood by everyone. We have to accept the truth from authorities. Therefore we take the Vedas as truth. Çruti-pramänam. When the Vedas give evidence, we accept it whether we understand it or not.

Çyämasundara däsa: The second part of his methodology involved dividing the complex into simpler and simpler parts in order to arrive at a solution. In this way, the whole will be proved.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But one must be expert in analysis. If I give you a typewriter to fix, and you know nothing about the machine, you will open it up, see all the parts, and not know how to adjust it. It is easy to open the machine up, but it is very difficult to adjust it.

Çyämasundara däsa: The third part involved arranging ideas from the simplest to the more complex according to the sequence of events.

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, we must understand that we are spirit soul. That is the first step in our process. We must first understand ourselves and how we are existing despite these changes of bodies. We have to study ourselves as masters of our bodies. Then we can conclude that for the universal body there is another source. That is the Supersoul, or God. Just as my body is existing due to my presence, the gigantic viräö body exists due to the presence of the Supersoul. Everything in the universe is constantly looking fresh and new; therefore there must be a large soul maintaining it. This is confirmed by the Vedas: aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-stham (Brahma-saàhitä 5.35). God is all-pervasive as Brahman, and He is also within the smallest atom. By His plenary expansion, God pervades the entire universe. According to the Vedas, there are different manifestations of God: Mahä-viñëu, Käraëodakaçäyé-viñëu, Garbhodakaçäyé-viñëu, and Kñérodakaçäyé-viñëu. What is the difficulty in understanding this? In large lamps and small lamps there is the same electricity. The Mäyävädé philosophers consider only the similitude; they do not take the varieties into account. God is all-pervasive, but there is variety.

Çyämasundara däsa: How is it that we create the body by our presence?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You create your body by your work. A dog has created his body according to his desire, and a tiger creates his body according to his. In any case, the soul is the same. The learned man, the paëòita, does not see the external varieties, but the soul within. According to their desires and activities, souls are acquiring different bodies; therefore there are 8,400,000 different types of bodies. Kåñëa claims all of these as His sons. Ahaà béja-pradaù pitä. "I am the seed-giving father." (Bg. 14.4) Kåñëa, the Father of all, gives the seed, but the son creates his own situation. Some of His sons are very rich, some very poor, some are great scientists and philosophers, and some are simply rascals. When a child is born, the father does not say, "You become a rascal," or, "You become a scientist," or whatever. The father sees them all as his sons.

Çyämasundara däsa: The fourth part of Cartesian methodology involves taking into account the most detailed points and making sure that nothing is omitted.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is knowledge. For instance, we are considering the details when we consider the difference between the Supreme Lord and ourselves.

Çyämasundara däsa: And we can place everything in the scheme of Kåñëa's creation?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Kåñëa says ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù. "I am the origin of all." (Bg. 10.8) Kåñëa says that He is the béja, the seed or soul, the spiritual spark of all living entities.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes also suggested rules of conduct which everyone should follow. He felt that we should obey the laws and customs of our nation, religious faith, and family tradition, and should avoid extreme behavior.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a good proposal. Actually, family tradition is respected in Vedic civilization. In Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna argues:

kula-kñaye praëaçyanti
kula-dharmäù sanätanäù
dharme nañöe kulaà kåtsnam
adharmo 'bhibhavaty uta

"With the destruction of dynasty, the eternal family tradition is vanquished, and thus the rest of the family becomes involved in irreligious practice." (Bg. 1.39) This means that Arjuna was respecting family tradition, but Kåñëa pointed out that this consideration was material. It really has no spiritual value. Therefore Kåñëa chastised Arjuna, telling him that he was situated on the material platform. Arjuna was lamenting over things for which a learned man does not lament. So, perhaps Descartes made these propositions for ordinary men, but they are not for those who are highly elevated or spiritually advanced.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes considered these practical rules for daily conduct. He also believed that we should stand by the convictions we have formed and be resolute in the course of action we have chosen.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This could also be a dog's obstinacy. However, if our final conclusion is true, then this obstinacy is nice. But if we have not reached the final goal, the Absolute Truth, such obstinacy is an impediment to advancement. This should not be generally applied because in the neophyte stage, we must be flexible. In the advanced stage, when we are firmly situated in the truth, it is, of course, good to stand by our convictions. That is determination. For instance, we have understood that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. No one can change us in this conviction. In the Christian system, they say that only Jesus Christ can help one go back to Godhead. That was meant for those whom Jesus Christ instructed because Jesus Christ saw that if the people left him, they would go to ruination. He saw that these inferior people had to stick to him in order to progress. Lord Buddha rejected the Vedas, but this does not mean that Vedic authority is diminished. The men to whom he spoke were not able to understand the authority of the Vedas, and they were misusing the Vedic rituals. This is all relative truth, but Absolute Truth is different. Relative truth is within Absolute Truth, but Absolute Truth is independent of relative truth.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Descartes, we should adapt ourselves and our ambitions to our environment and fortune, instead of defying them. In other words, we should be satisfied with what we have and utilize it to the best of our ability.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is nice. In Vedic civilization, for instance, there is no great endeavor for economic development. In India, you will still find villagers satisfied with whatever they have. There are even street sweepers who are great devotees. After they work, they bathe, put on tilaka, and sit down to chant and worship the Deity. Why should we be unnecessarily ambitious? Better to be satisfied.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes also believed that we should carefully choose the life work which is best for our personal selves.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, if you are given that freedom, a drunkard will say that the best thing is to drink and sleep. Everyone has his own program, which he thinks is the best. So who will judge what is best? According to Vivekananda's philosophy, whatever philosophy you select is all right. That is nonsense.

Hayagréva däsa: In the same Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes writes: "It is not in truth an imperfection in God that He has given me the freedom of assenting or not assenting to things of which He has not placed a clear and distinct knowledge in my understanding. On the other hand, it is an imperfection in me that I do not use this freedom righ...."

But then, why doesn't God give us the understanding by which we can choose properly in all cases? Why can't we have free will and at the same time infallible judgement?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Free will means that you can act wrongly. Unless there is a chance of your acting properly or improperly, there is no question of free will. If I only act in one way, I have no freedom. We have freedom because we can sometimes act improperly.

Hayagréva däsa: In other words, freedom means that a man may know better, yet still act wrongly?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is free will: the freedom to misuse free will. A thief may know that stealing is bad, yet he steals. That is his free will in action. He cannot check his greed, despite his knowing that he is acting improperly and that he will be punished. He knows all the repercussions that result from stealing, yet he steals and misuses his free will. So unless there is a possibility of misusing our free will, there is no question of freedom.

Hayagréva däsa: In the Meditations, Descartes maintains that when one does not know God, he really has no perfect knowledge of anything, and when he knows God, he knows everything else.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and knowledge of God means following the instructions of God. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa imparts the most confidential knowledge to Arjuna, but it is ultimately up to Arjuna to accept it or reject it. At the conclusion of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells him:

iti te jïänam äkhyätaà
guhyäd guhyataraà mayä
vimåçyaitad açeñeëa
yathecchasi tathä kuru

"Thus I have explained to you the most confidential of all knowledge. Deliberate on this fully, and then do what you wish to do." (Bg. 18.63) This is free will. It depends on the individual whether to act according to the instructions of God or according to his own whims and sensual inclinations.

Hayagréva däsa: Descartes further writes: "I see that the certainty in truth of all knowledge depends on knowledge of the true God, and that before I knew Him I could have no perfect knowledge of any other thing.

And now that I know Him, I have the means of acquiring a perfect knowledge of innumerable things...." Descartes goes on to conclude that since God is all good, He would not deceive him in matters pertaining to the Godhead.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If he follows God's instructions and has real knowledge of God, he will never be misled, but if he selects a false God, or if he has not met the real God, he is subject to being misled. To save him from this danger, God imparts instructions in Bhagavad-gétä. Whoever follows these instructions will be perfect. If we receive knowledge of the soul from God, there is no chance in being mistaken. As soon as we think in our own way, we are subject to error because we are imperfect and finite. Kåñëa precisely says that the soul is within the body, and if we accept this, we can immediately understand that the soul is different from the body. Kåñëa says that the owner of the body is the soul within the body, and immediately the false impression that one is the body, which is a fool's conclusion, should be eradicated. The light is there, but those who do not accept it prefer to live as fools and speculate.

Çyämasundara däsa: It was Descartes's contention that the most perfect and highest emotion is intellectual love of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä. Kåñëa says that the jïäné-bhakta, the intelligent bhakta, is very dear to Him.

teñäà jïäné nitya-yukta
eka-bhaktir viçiñyate
priyo hi jïänino 'tyartham
ahaà sa ca mama priyaù

"Of these, the wise one who is in full knowledge in union with Me through pure devotional service is the best. For I am very dear to him, and he is dear to Me." (Bg. 7.17) An unintelligent devotee may accept the principles today, and leave tomorrow. A person who accepts the Kåñëa conscious philosophy intelligently is very rare. We should not accept it by sentiment, but by intelligence.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Descartes, real happiness arises from consciousness of perfection.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that consciousness is Kåñëa consciousness, the awareness that God is the supreme and that I am His eternal servant. This consciousness is happiness, and it is confirmed by Bhagavad-gétä. When Dhruva Mahäräja was offered all the riches in the world by Kuvera, the treasurer of the demigods, he said, "Please benedict me so that I may have unflinching faith in the lotus feet of Kåñëa." That is proper intelligence. Similarly, when Prahläda Mahäräja was offered whatever he wanted by Lord Nåsiàhadeva, he said, "What should I ask from You? My father was a great materialist, so great that the demigods were afraid of his anger, yet You have finished him in one second. What then is the value of this material power and opulence? Please engage me in the service of Your servants. That is all I want."

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes maintains that a man is virtuous insofar as his reason controls his passion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, if one can control his passions somehow or other, he is freed from many troubles.

viñayä vinivartante
nirähärasya dehinaù
rasa-varjaà raso 'py asya
paraà dåñövä nivartate

"The embodied soul may be restricted from sense enjoyment, though the taste for sense objects remains. But, ceasing such engagements by experiencing a higher taste, he is fixed in consciousness." (Bg. 2.59) People are suffering due to their passionate activities. Therefore there are many Vedic rules and regulations governing action. If we can subdue our passionate impulses, we can save ourselves a great deal of trouble. Due to passion, one becomes a drunkard, engages in illicit sex, gambles, and acts unreasonably. If one can check his passion by reason, he can save himself from the greatest danger.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes had a great reverence for theology, the science of God, because he felt that it was an open road to heaven for everyone, the intelligent and unintelligent alike. For Descartes, theology is concerned with real truths that transcend human reason.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that we have to take the truth from the revealed scriptures. Every revealed scripture gives some hint of an understanding of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: First of all, Descartes tried to find some basis for truth. Then he came to the proof of the existence of God. As far as philosophy is concerned, he maintained that it lacks certainty and that its tenets are always subject to dispute.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we agree with that. It is said that a philosopher is not a philosopher unless he differs from other philosophers. If one is to be a great philosopher, he has to defy all his predecessors. Scientists also work in the same way. If we try to find out whose statement is true, we have a great deal of difficulty. Therefore the Vedic çästras enjoin that we follow the personalities who have realized God, and therefore we follow Prahläda Mahäräja, Dhruva Mahäräja, Vyäsadeva, Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, Kapila-deva, the twelve mahäjanas, and their followers, the followers of Brahmä's disciplic succession, the Brahma-sampradäya, the Rudra-sampradäya, the Viñëusvämé-sampradäya, the Rämänuja-sampradäya, and so on. If we follow the äcäryas in the disciplic succession, our path is clear.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes felt that because science is based on philosophical principles which have no basis in themselves, science is not worthy of our cultivation. He condemns people for using scientific technology to make more money. He said, "I am resolved no longer to seek any science other than knowledge of myself."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but he had no guru.

Çyämasundara däsa: No, he didn't accept a guru. He accepted only what he could know through self-realization, the innate truths that he discovered in himself by meditation. First, he came to the understanding that I am, and later he concluded that because I am, God is.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a nice conclusion.

Çyämasundara däsa: He had an obsession for the need of absolute certainty because he felt that all the conclusions of the philosophers before him were dubious. He believed that every idea must be subjected to doubt until the truth or falsity can be ascertained, just as a mathematical formula can be ascertained. Every idea must be subjected to cross examination.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But when will these doubts be finished? Your standard of understanding self-evident truths may be different from mine. So what is the standard? He must give some standard.

Çyämasundara däsa: When Descartes meditated on the first philosophy, he concluded, cogito ergo sum, "I think; therefore I exist." He felt that everything was subject to doubt with the exception of the act of doubting itself. Since doubting is a part of thinking, the act of thinking is an undeniable experience. Therefore he concluded that because I doubt, I think, and because I think, I exist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a good argument. If I do not exist, how can I think? But is he condemning doubt or accepting doubt? What is his position?

Çyämasundara däsa: He accepts doubt as the only real fact. Because I can doubt that my hand exists, it may be a hallucination, a dream. I can doubt that everything perceived exists because it may all be a dream, but the fact that I am doubting cannot be doubted.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So what is his conclusion? Should one stop doubting or continue doubting? If I doubt everything, I may come to the truth and then doubt the truth.

Çyämasundara däsa: His point is that the truth cannot be doubted, but that to discover the truth, we have to doubt everything. When we come to the truth, the truth will be undoubtable.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But how do you come to the truth if your business is simply doubting? How will you ever stop doubting?

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, I cannot doubt that I am, that I exist. That truth is undoubtable. So he proceeds from there to the fact that since I exist, God exists.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then his point is that by doubting, we come to a point where there is no more doubt. That is good. Doubt in the beginning, then the truth as the conclusion. But in any case, that doubt must be resolved. I doubt because I am imperfect and because my knowledge is imperfect. So another question is how we can obtain perfection. As long as we are imperfect, there will be doubt.

Çyämasundara däsa: He says that even though I am imperfect, there exists perfect knowledge, or a self-conscious awareness of perfect ideas within myself. Knowledge of the perfect is innate within me, and I can know it through meditation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also acceptable.

Çyämasundara däsa: Because I understand that I think, I can establish existence of my soul beyond all doubt.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everyone thinks. Everyone is there, and everyone has a soul. There are countless souls, and this has to be accepted.

Çyämasundara däsa: What about a blade of grass, for instance?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it has a way of thinking. That has to be accepted. It is not that we have souls and that the grass has no soul, or that animals have no souls. Jagadish Candra Bose has proved by a machine that plants can feel and think. "I think, therefore I am" is a good proposition because everyone thinks and everyone exists. There are 8,400,000 species of living entities, and they are all thinking, and they all have individual souls.

Hayagréva däsa: There is a lot of conjecture in Descartes concerning the location of the soul. In his Meditations, he writes: "Although the soul is joined to the whole body, there is yet a certain part in which it exercises its functions more particularly than in all the others; and that is usually believed to be the brain, or possibly the heart; the brain, because it is with it that the organs of sense are connected, and the heart because it is apparently in it that we experience the passions." Descartes then goes on to conclude that the soul is situated in a small appendage of the brain called the pineal body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This speculation means that he has no definite information. Therefore we have to accept God's instructions. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa specifically states:

éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà
håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati

"The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart, O Arjuna." (Bg. 18.61) There are two kinds of éçvaras, controllers. One is the individual living entity, the jéva, and the other is the Supreme Living Being, the Paramätmä, or Supersoul. From the Vedas, we understand that both are sitting together within this body, which is compared to a tree. Both the Supersoul and the individual soul are living within the heart.

Hayagréva däsa: But at the same time, doesn't the soul pervade the whole body?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. That is also explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

yathä prakäçayaty ekaù
kåtsnaà lokam imaà raviù
kñetraà kñetré tathä kåtsnaà
prakäçayati bhärata

"O son of Bharata, as the sun alone illuminates all this universe, so does the living entity, one within the body, illuminate the entire body by consciousness." (Bg. 13.34) This is the illumination of the soul. It is like the sun, which is situated in one particular location, yet its illumination is spread everywhere. Similarly, although the soul is situated within the heart, his illumination is characterized by what we call consciousness. As soon as the soul leaves the heart, consciousness is immediately absent from the entire body. At one moment, there may be consciousness, and at the next moment there may be no consciousness at all. When there is no consciousness, one may hack the body to pieces, and no pain will be felt. This is because something is missing, and that something is the soul. When the soul is gone, consciousness is absent from the body. Both the individual soul and individual consciousness are immortal. Under the influence of mäyä, the illusory energy, our consciousness is absorbed in many material things: society, nationality, sex life, speculation, and so forth. Kåñëa consciousness means purifying the consciousness so that it will remain fixed only on Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: Descartes writes: "I know that brutes do many things better than we do, but I am not surprised at it; for that also goes to prove that they act by force of nature. If they could think as we do, they would have an immortal soul as well as we. But this is not likely, because there is no reason for believing it of some animals without believing it of all, and there are many of them too imperfect to make it possible to believe it of them, such as oysters, sponges, etc."

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, living entities do not act by force of nature, but by force of God. Even in the heart of the brute, God is also present. God is within all, and He gives us instructions so that we can advance. When we attain the platform of human life, we have the alternative to refuse God's instructions. Lower life forms do not have the power to refuse.

Hayagréva däsa: You have just said that whatever grows has a soul, including the grass.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, in a dormant stage. For instance, a child has a soul, but it is not yet developed because the body is not yet developed. According to the body and circumstances, the soul acts.

Hayagréva däsa: Descartes equated the mind, the higher mental processes, with the soul. He believed in an incorporeal, immortal, human mind, which has been mysteriously injected somewhere into the body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, the mind is not the soul but an instrument through which the soul acts. The mind is rejecting and accepting according to the dictations of the soul. Although I walk with my legs, I do not consider myself to be my legs. Although I think with my mind, I am not my mind. Some philosophers identify the mind with the self, and this is a mistake. Intelligence is subtler than the mind, and the mind is subtler than the senses. The gross senses can be seen, but the center of the senses, the mind, cannot be seen. Therefore it is called subtle. The mind is guided by the intelligence, which is even subtler. The background of that intelligence is the soul. The mind is the instrument by which we think, but that instrument is not "I."

Hayagréva däsa: For Descartes, animals are mere machines that react. He felt that they have no souls or minds, and hence no consciousness at all, and the basis for this view is ratiocination, language. In other words, because they have no language, they simply act as machines.

Çréla Prabhupäda: They have languages, but you do not understand them.

Hayagréva däsa: Scientists claim to be able to communicate verbally with dolphins.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That may be, but Kåñëa was speaking with everyone, even with the birds. When one gopé went to the Yamunä to bathe, she was surprised to see that Kåñëa was speaking with the birds. Because Kåñëa is God, He can understand everyone's language. That is a qualification described in the Nectar of Devotion as vävadüka. When a human being can understand many languages, he is called a linguist. Another name for Kåñëa is vävadüka, which indicates that He can understand everyone's language, even the languages of the birds and bees. That is the potency of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes considers five basic ideas to be inherent within every man, ideas which every man knows without having to verify. One is that God is innate to us as our own soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this is because we are part and parcel of God. For instance, in the material world, everyone knows that he has a father. This is common knowledge.

Çyämasundara däsa: Secondly, it is impossible for something to originate out of nothing; every effect must have a cause, and therefore there is a cause of everything.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we have discussed this. That ultimate cause is Kåñëa. We do not accept the Mäyävädé philosophy because they philosophize in a negative way to try to make the ultimate truth zero.

Çyämasundara däsa: Thirdly, it is impossible for a thing to exist and not exist at the same time.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Who protests this? Who says that something can exist and not exist simultaneously? Who is he trying to refute?

Çyämasundara däsa: He is not refuting anyone. He says that this is an innate idea that we know for certain without having to verify.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This body is a temporary manifestation, and this soul is always existing. Eventually, this body will not exist, but the owner of the body is eternal and existing eternally. If something is a temporary manifestation, we can say that it is simultaneously existing and not existing. On the material platform, everything is existing and not existing because it is temporary. For instance, we are existing in this room right now, but at the next moment we may not be existing. The whole cosmic manifestation is like that. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

näsato vidyate bhävo
näbhävo vidyate sataù
ubhayor api dåñöo 'ntas
tv anayos tattva-darçibhiù

"Those who are seers of the truth have concluded that of the nonexistent there is no endurance, and of the existent there is no cessation. This they have concluded by studying the nature of both." (Bg. 2.16) Because the soul is never created, the soul never dies. Everything that is born must die.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes's fourth innate idea is that whatever is done can never be undone.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Karma cannot be undone. However, it can change. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells us to abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Him. If we do so, He will relieve us of all the reactions of karma. (Bg. 18.66) So in this sense it is not a fact that what is done cannot be undone.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes is thinking in the realm of the physical. After I throw a ball, that ball can never be unthrown.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a child's knowledge, not a philosopher's. Direct perception is childish. A child believes so many things by direct perception. I remember that when I first saw a train in Calcutta, I thought that within the engine there must have been horses, otherwise the train could not have run. This kind of thinking is not really philosophy. Of course, it is a part of philosophy because all philosophers are nature's children. Therefore they think in that way.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes's fifth principle is that we cannot be nonexistent as long as we are thinking.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have already discussed this. Everyone thinks, and therefore everyone is a soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes also gives two arguments for the existence of God. First, an innate idea of an infinite being necessitates the existence of that infinite being because a finite being could not possibly create such an idea. In other words, because I can think of the infinite, the infinite must exist. The infinite must have put that thought in my head.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There are many ways of thinking of the infinite. The voidists think of the infinite as zero, void. Descartes may be thinking in one way, but someone else may be thinking in another.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes argues that because we can conceive of perfection, perfection must be there.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but just because I am thinking of something does not mean that it exists. Everyone is thinking in his own way. Who will decide which way of thinking is correct? Who will judge? Therefore we ultimately have to accept the confirmation of authorities. If our thinking is confirmed by the authorities, it is all right; otherwise it cannot be accepted.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes was thinking more in terms of mathematics. If we begin counting, we can conceive of numbers stretching to infinity. So the fact that one can think of infinity necessitates the infinite.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But the voidists are thinking that the infinite is zero. Some mathematicians calculate that infinity means zero.

Çyämasundara däsa: Secondly, God is an absolutely perfect being, and perfection necessarily implies existence. Since God's existence is the same as His essence, He must exist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is our proposition. We say that Kåñëa is the sum total of all wealth, knowledge, fame, power, beauty, and renunciation. Because these opulences are attractive, and Kåñëa has them in full, Kåñëa is all-attractive. All these attractive qualities must be there in Kåñëa in totality. That is Paräçara Muni's definition of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: This is similar to Descartes's contention that perfect beauty and wisdom must exist somewhere because we can conceive of the fact.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù (Brahma-saàhitä 5.1). No one is richer, more famous, wiser, more beautiful, or more powerful than Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the sum total of all qualities; therefore He is complete. Because we are part and parcel of the complete, we can think of the complete. Because I am the son of my father, I can think of my father. Similarly, Kåñëa is the Father of all living entities, and every living entity has the power to offer his respects to God. Unfortunately, the living entity is artificially educated by society not to obey God, and that is the cause of his suffering.

Çyämasundara däsa: When Descartes inspects reality, he concludes that reality consists of substances. He defines substance as "a thing which exists in such a way as to stand in need of nothing beyond itself." He says that there is only one absolutely independent substance—God. All other substances are created by Him. There are also two types of substances—matter and spirit.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is all described in Bhagavad-gétä. The summum bonum substance is Kåñëa, and everything emanates from Him. All these emanations can be divided into two categories: inferior and superior. The inferior energy is matter, and the superior energy is spirit. Everything that we see or experience is a combination of the inferior and superior energies. Since these energies emanate from Kåñëa, Kåñëa is the origin of everything, the cause of all causes.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes states that the chief attribute of this spirit or soul is consciousness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is so.

Çyämasundara däsa: And the chief attribute of the body is extension. Both the body and mind are finite and depend upon God for their existence, whereas God is completely independent.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Jévera 'svarüpa' haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa' (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 20.108). Therefore every living entity is the eternal servant of God, or Kåñëa. Since we all depend upon Kåñëa for our existence, it is our duty to please Him. That is the process of bhakti. In the material world, we see that we depend upon our employer for our salary. Therefore we always have to please him. Eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän. (Kaöha Upaniñad 2.2.13) God is providing everything for everyone. So why not please Him? Our only duty is to please Him, and that process is perfectly manifested in Våndävana. It is in Våndävana that everyone is trying to please Kåñëa, and because they are trying to please Him, they are happy. Kåñëa in turn is pleasing them.

jaya rädhä-mädhava kuïja-bihäré
gopé-jana-vallabha giri-vara-dhäré
jaçodä-nandana, braja-jana-raïjana,
jämuna-téra-vana-cäré

"Kåñëa is the lover of Rädhä. He displays many amorous pastimes in the groves of Våndävana. He is the lover of the cowherd maidens of Vraja, the holder of the great hill named Govardhana, the beloved son of mother Yaçodä, the delighter of the inhabitants of Vraja, and He wanders in the forests along the banks of the River Yamunä." (from Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura's Gétävalé) Kåñëa engages in pleasing the gopéjana, and the gopéjana is engaged in pleasing Kåñëa. That is the perfect relationship. In a perfect family, the head of the family tries to please all the members by providing them with food, shelter, clothing, and everything else. Therefore he works hard to please them, and their duty is to please him. When the father comes home, the wife and sons try to please him, and that makes the perfect home. Similarly, God is the original creator, and we are all subordinates maintained by Him. Our only duty is to please Him, and if He is pleased, we will all remain pleased. If we pour water on the root of a tree, all the parts of the tree—the leaves and flowers and branches—are nourished. The process of bhakti-yoga is the process of pleasing the Lord. This is our only business, and as long as we take to some other business, we are in mäyä. We have no other business. The living entity who does not serve Kåñëa is in mäyä and is diseased, and the living entity who is constantly engaged in Kåñëa's service is liberated and situated in his constitutional position. If anyone within the creation is not cooperating with God or not satisfying the senses of the Lord, he is not in his normal condition. It is the function of this Kåñëa consciousness movement to engage everyone in Kåñëa's service and bring everyone to his normal condition. People are suffering because they are in an abnormal condition.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes believed that God's truth is the basis for our knowledge of the truth, and that God is truth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since God is truth, everything is emanating from the truth. We are trying to employ everything in the service of the truth. Because God is truth, we do not say that the world is false. The Mäyävädés claim that the world is false, but we say that it is temporary. For instance, this flower is the creation of God. It therefore cannot be false; it is truth. It should therefore be employed in the service of the truth, and that is our reason for offering it to Kåñëa. Suppose you work very hard to make something beautiful, and then you bring it to me, and I say, "Oh, it is all false." Will you be pleased with me? You will say, "What is this nonsense? I have travelled so far and have made such a beautiful thing, and he says it is false." Similarly, since God has created such a wonderful universe, why should we say that it is false? Our philosophy is that the universe is God's creation and therefore should be employed in God's service. For instance, we are using this tape recorder to record this conversation. It is being used for Kåñëa. We do not say, "Oh, it is false. It is material. We won't use it." That is the position of the Jains, who do not take advantage of these things. We say, rather, that we can use these devices, but not for our personal sense gratification. That is real vairägya, detachment.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes maintains that we can know and understand truth because God is true. This is the basis for our knowledge. God's existence assures us that this external world is not a fiction.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is what I was explaining. Because God is truth, His creation cannot be untrue. It is untrue when I see everything devoid of God. If I see this table as unrelated to God, it is untruth. However, when I see this table as a product of God's energy, I am seeing it in the proper way. In other words, I am seeing God. One who has no sense of God sees the table as a temporary creation, something produced by nature's law. He sees that it comes from zero, and that it will return to zero, and that ultimately it is zero, false. We do not say this. We do not say that Kåñëa is zero but that this table comes from Kåñëa's energy. Kåñëa's energy is not zero, and the table is not zero. Whatever is within our experience has some relationship with Kåñëa. The vision of that relationship is Kåñëa consciousness. Generally, people have no vision of Kåñëa. Their only vision is that of their family, their wife, their children, their this and their that. That is mäyä.

Çyämasundara däsa: If people see nothing in relation to Kåñëa, how can they justify saying that it is all a dream, that it is unreal?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because they cannot understand the beginning, they say that it is a temporary manifestation. People may say that this tree has come out of nothing and that when the tree dies, it will again become nothing. However, this tree has not come out of nothing, but from a seed, and Kåñëa says, ahaà béja-pradaù pitä. "I am the original seed of all existences." (Bg. 14.4) In a cinema, an image comes from a small hole, and we see it expanded on the screen. When the projector stops, the pictures on the screen cease to exist. People may say that these pictures come from nothing, but actually they are focused by the projector that projects the film, and behind that film there is an actual performance. Similarly, the material world is a perverted reflection of the spiritual world. That spiritual world is reality, not zero. When we see a photograph, we understand that it is an image of something actual. This material world is like something being played on a screen. Therefore the Mäyävädé philosophers say that it is false. In one sense, it is false, in that the show is not an actual performance. But it is a reflection of the original play under a different process. Because the original play is not within our vision, we are thinking that the projection on the screen has come from zero. However, one who knows things as they are knows that the projection has come from reality, even though it is temporary and not permanently existing. In other words, the reality is the basis of what is being shown. When we see this, there is no question of anything being false.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes sees matter operating like a machine under mechanical laws. The sum total of all motion in the world is always constant; it neither increases nor decreases. However, he claims that the soul is unaffected by mechanical causes and is therefore immortal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yet somehow or other he has been put into this mechanical process.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yes, and this was Descartes's problem. He could not understand how spirit and matter interact, how the nondimensional, nonextended spirit can have a three dimensional body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you are on the land and fall into the water, your struggle begins. This means that on land you are safe, but somehow or other you have fallen into this material struggle. Spirit is spirit, and matter is matter, but now they have come in contact with one another. We have caused this contact because we have misused our independence. A boy may stand firmly beside the water, but if he wants to enjoy the water, he may fall in. If he cannot manage to swim, he is lost. This is our position. The spirit soul has a spiritual body, but he accepts a foreign body. The spirit soul has a body, and his business is to enjoy life, but because he falls within the jurisdiction of matter, he cannot enjoy his labor. As long as he is within water, there is no possibility of happiness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Does the spiritual body have dimensions? Does it exist in space?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it has dimensions. It has length, breadth, and everything. Otherwise, how can we say that it is one ten-thousandth of the tip of a hair? In other words, there is measurement, but that measurement is beyond our imagination. The soul is something different. It is inconceivable. If the spirit soul has no body, how can the material body develop? A material body is like a coat molded in the form of the spiritual body. You cannot make a dress without measuring the body.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then the spiritual body is very small?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You cannot imagine it. Because the materialists cannot see or measure the spiritual body, they say that it does not exist.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes says that the soul exists, but not that it occupies space.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that his conception of space is limited. The material body is a body that has a beginning and an end. Your coat is made at a certain date. The spiritual body is changing dress from one material body to another, just as you change your clothes.

Çyämasundara däsa: After the soul has fallen into matter, can it be delivered through proper knowledge?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement. Even if a person is an expert swimmer, how long can he swim? He will eventually succumb because he is in a fallen condition. However, if one is elevated just one inch above the water, he is immediately safe. The water may remain in its position, but he is transcendental to it. This transcendental position is Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: In other words, the spirit soul can rise above matter, above the water.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, just like a flying fish. This fish may swim within the water, but suddenly he may fly over it. As soon as you become Kåñëa conscious, you can fly over the water of material existence. Then you can gradually come to land.

Çyämasundara däsa: If the spirit is unlimited and has unlimited power, how does it fall within matter?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It does not have unlimited power. Its power is so great that in the material sense it is unlimited, but actually it is not unlimited.

Çyämasundara däsa: How is it able to be confined by something as limited as a body?

Çréla Prabhupäda: I have already explained this. It is like falling into the water. As spirit soul, we have nothing to do with this material body, but somehow or other we have come in contact with it. There is a cause, but instead of finding out this cause, we should realize that we are in a dangerous position.

Çyämasundara däsa: But if the spirit has great power, and the body has limited power, how is it that this limited power is able to hold onto the great power, to capture it and keep it?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The material energy is Kåñëa's energy, and each and every energy of Kåñëa is as great as Kåñëa. Therefore Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä:

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14)

Çyämasundara däsa: In other words, it is sometimes stronger than the spiritual energy?

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you come in contact with the material energy without a specific purpose, it is stronger. Kåñëa's representative comes into the material energy in order to preach. Although he is within the material energy, he is not under its control. But if you come in contact with material energy without serving Kåñëa's purpose, you suffer. For instance, in a jail there are many superintendents and government officials. There are also prisoners. However, their conditions differ. We cannot say that because they are all in jail that they are all suffering in the same way. The superintendent is there because he is serving the government's purpose. Therefore he is not subject to the laws of the jail. When you are in the service of Kåñëa, you are no longer under the laws of mäyä. You are liberated.

Çyämasundara däsa: So the prisoners who have forgotten their real service have been weakened?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, because they have disobeyed and have forgotten their subordinate position. They want to be independent of the state, and therefore they have been put into jail.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then for them, the material energy is stronger.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. It is stronger for them. Those who are conditioned and are serving the material energy cannot escape through their own endeavor. They are dependent on the mercy of Kåñëa and His representatives.

DS:Blaise Pascal (1623-1666)

Blaise Pascal (1623-1666)

Hayagréva däsa: Pascal saw man situated in the universe between two extremes: infinity and nothingness. Man has a body like the animals, and an intellect like the angels or demigods. As such, he is neither a demigod nor an animal but somewhere between the two. He is intelligent enough to know that he is in a miserable situation, despite his great desire to be happy. Man engages in all kinds of pastimes and diversions to forget his misery, but nothing ultimately helps. What man once possessed and now has lost is perfect happiness. All men suffer and complain, despite their situation, and Pascal believed that the emptiness felt by man can only be filled by God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, life after life, the living entity strives for happiness, but he only becomes more morose because he does not take shelter of Kåñëa. He manufactures new ways to sport. He dives in the water, and flies in the air, and God is supplying him all facilities. If you want to fly, become a bird. If you want to dive, become a fish. Sometimes, after making many attempts to be happy, the living entity gives up his planmaking and surrenders to Kåñëa. Kåñëa says, "Surrender unto Me, and I will make you happy." God comes personally as Lord Rämacandra, Lord Kåñëa, and Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu to give instructions how to surrender and attain happiness.

Hayagréva däsa: Whereas Descartes emphasized the importance of reason, Pascal believed that the principles that are understood by the heart are absolutely certain and adequate to overcome all skepticism and doubt. Is this because the Supersoul speaks within the heart?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. As Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä:

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." (Bg. 10.10) Every living entity is living with God, but out of ignorance he does not know this. As we have stated before, there are two birds situated in the tree of the body. One bird is enjoying the fruits of the tree, while the other bird is witnessing. God gives instructions whereby we can return home, but nondevotees will not accept these instructions. A devotee strictly follows the orders of God, but the demoniac act according to their own whims, even though knowing God's desires. There is no doubt that God is giving instructions. Instructions are given externally through God's agent, the spiritual master, and through the scriptures. Instructions are given internally through the conscience, the Supersoul.

Çyämasundara däsa: Pascal was a mystic who believed very deeply in God, but he was also a skeptic in the sense that he believed that we cannot prove the existence of God by our reason or any other way. Therefore he emphasized that we have to believe in God with our heart.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact. You cannot prove the existence of God by your material senses.

ataù çré-kåñëa-nämädi
na bhaved grähyam indriyaiù
sevonmukhe hi jihvädau
svayam eva sphuraty adaù

"Material senses cannot appreciate Kåñëa's holy name, form, qualities and pastimes. When a conditioned soul is awakened to Kåñëa consciousness and renders service by using his tongue to chant the Lord's holy name and taste the remnants of the Lord's food, the tongue is purified, and one gradually comes to understand who Kåñëa really is." (Padma Puräëa) The senses are incompetent to appreciate God, but if you are anxious to know God, you should render Him service. Then He will let you know what He is. The more we engage in God's service, the more He reveals. He cannot be perceived by our senses; therefore His name is adhokñaja, which means that He is beyond our sense perception. We worship the Deity of God in the temple, but the gross materialist with his sense perception can never understand that the Deity is God. He will say that it is simply a stone carving. Therefore we have to believe in God with our heart. Because the atheist does not believe in God with his heart, he sees only a piece of stone.

Çyämasundara däsa: Pascal says that the heart has reasons which the mind does not know.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the mind is an instrument; it is not something final. For instance, the brain is instrumental just like this tape recorder. Behind the mind there is the intelligence, and behind the intelligence there is the soul.

Hayagréva däsa: Pascal ascribed to the doctrine of original sin, which holds that at one time man fell from grace by committing some sin or other, and this fall from grace accounts for his present position between the angels and the beasts. In other words, original sin accounts for man's encagement in matter.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. This is also our philosophy.

Hayagréva däsa: What was this original sin?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Disobedience—refusing to serve Kåñëa. Sometimes a servant thinks, "Why am I serving this master? I myself must become a master." The living entity is eternally part and parcel of God, and his duty is to serve God. When he thinks, "Why should I serve God? I shall enjoy myself instead," he brings about his downfall. Original sin means refusing to serve God and attempting instead to become God. Mäyävädés, for instance, are still attempting to become God, despite their knowledge and philosophy. If by meditation or some material effort, we can become God, what is the meaning of God? It is not possible to become God. The attempt to become God is the original sin, the beginning of sinful life.

Hayagréva däsa: Pascal believed that it is impossible for man to understand the universe or his position in it. We cannot look for certainty or stability in the material world because our reasoning powers are always being deceived. Therefore man must surrender to the dictates of his heart and to God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is our position. We are not depending on the heart, however, because the dictations of the heart are not appreciated by nondevotees. Direct instructions are given in Bhagavad-gétä and explained by the spiritual master. If we take the advice of God and His representative, we will not be misled.

Hayagréva däsa: Of all things in the world, Pascal considered this to be the strangest: "A man spends many days and nights in rage and despair over the loss of his job or for some imaginary insult to his honor, yet he does not consider with anxiety and emotion that he will lose everything by death. It is a monstrous thing to see in the same heart and at the same time this sensibility to trifles and the strange insensibility to the greatest objects (death). It is an incomprehensible enchantment, and a supernatural slumber, which indicates as its cause an all-powerful force."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, according to Bhagavad-gétä, when one does not believe in God, or when one disobeys God's orders, God comes as death. Then all power, pride, imagination, and plans are broken. After this, one may attain the body of an animal because in his life he acted like an animal. This is the process of transmigration. This is suffering.

Hayagréva däsa: Pascal writes: "If we submit everything to reason, our religion will have no mysterious and supernatural element. If we offend the principles of reason, our religion will be absurd and ridiculous."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes that is a fact. The orders of God constitute religion, and if we carry out these orders, we are religious. Pseudo-religions, religions that cheat, are condemned in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Any religious system which has no conception of God and which annually changes its resolutions is not a religion but a farce.

Hayagréva däsa: Pascal seems to be saying that we should not accept our faith blindly, but at the same time we should not expect everything to be comprehensible to our understanding.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. A father may tell his child to do something, although the child may not comprehend it. In any case, we understand that the father's plans are complete and good for the son. If the son says, "No, I don't wish to do this," he may fall down. God's orders constitute religion, but there is no question of blind following. We must understand God's nature and realize that He is all perfect. In this way, we can understand that whatever He says is also perfect and that we should therefore accept it. If we apply our finite reasoning and try to change God's instructions according to our whims, we will suffer.

Çyämasundara däsa: Pascal claims that by faith we have to make a forced option, or what he calls a religious wager. We either have to cast our lot on the side of God—in which case we have nothing to lose in this life and everything to gain in the next—or we deny God and jeopardize our eternal position.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is our argument. If there are two people, and neither has experience of God, one may say that there is no God, and the other may say that there is God. So both must be given a chance. The one who says that there is no God dismisses the whole case, but the one who says that there is a God must become cautious. He cannot work irresponsibly. If there is a God, he cannot run risks. Actually, both are taking risks because neither knows for certain that there is a God. However, it is preferable that one believe.

Çyämasundara däsa: Pascal says that there is a fifty-fifty chance.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, so take the fifty percent chance in favor.

Çyämasundara däsa: Pascal also advocated that. We have nothing to lose and everything to gain.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. We also advise people to chant Hare Kåñëa. Since you have nothing to lose and everything to gain, why not chant?

Çyämasundara däsa: Pascal's religious wager rests upon the assumption that God will punish the individual who refuses to believe in Him, and reward the one who believes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, God is the Supreme Person who rewards and punishes. Lord Viñëu has four hands holding four symbolic objects. Two hands are for punishment, and two for protection. The conch shell and lotus give protection to the devotees, and the club and disc punish the nondevotees.

Hayagréva däsa: Pascal writes: "Man is great in that he knows himself to be miserable. A tree does not know itself to be miserable....These miseries prove man's greatness. They are the miseries of a great lord, a deposed king."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Çrémad-Bhägavatam points out that we are trying to live long, but a tree lives longer. Does this mean that the tree has attained perfection? Does perfection mean longevity? We may analyze life's conditions in this way in order to understand that perfection means coming to God consciousness and understanding God and our relationship with Him.

Hayagréva däsa: For Pascal, knowledge can be attained only by curbing the passions, submitting to God, and accepting God's revelation. He considered himself a Christian.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, without religion, one is an animal. Amongst animals, there is no discussion of God and no sense of religion. Presently, society is becoming degraded because governments are forbidding the discussion of God in schools and colleges. This causes increased suffering.

Hayagréva däsa: Although Pascal was considered a great philosopher, he concluded that philosophy in itself only leads to skepticism. Faith is needed. "Hear God" was his favorite motto.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Philosophy means understanding the truth. Sometimes philosophers spend their time speculating about sex and thus become degraded. Sex is present in animals as well as man. Sex is not life itself; it is only a symptom of life. If we emphasize only this symptom, the results are not philosophy. Philosophy means finding out the Absolute Truth. The real subject of philosophy is Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagävan.

DS:Benedict Spinoza (1632-1677)

Benedict Spinoza (1632-1677)

Hayagréva däsa: Spinoza asserts that God cannot be a remote cause of the creation. He sees the creation flowing from God just as conclusions flow from principles in mathematics. God is free to create, but He is the immanent cause; the creation is but an extension.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, because He creates through His energy. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

"Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego—all together these eight constitute My separated material energies." (Bg. 7.4) The material world is composed of these eight material elements, and because it is made out of God's energy, it is called the creation of God. More directly, however, it is His energies that create the material universe. The ingredients come from Him, and prakåti, nature, creates. God is both the remote and immanent cause of the creation because the elements are God's energies.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza sees God as the universal principle that binds together all the relationships in the material world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is nothing but a principle, He has no personal activity. Is it that Spinoza is an impersonalist?

Çyämasundara däsa: He states that God is the sum total of everything.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly God is everything, but why shouldn't we utilize discrimination? By saying that God is a principle like light, we imply that God is like a material thing. According to him, what is man's position in relationship with God?

Çyämasundara däsa: He states that the infinite universe is like a machine, yet all things are conditioned to exist in a particular way, and this is necessitated by the divine nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everything may be like a machine, but a machine is devised by a person. So according to him, who is God? Is God the machine, or the person who devises the machine?

Çyämasundara däsa: For him, God is the absolute universal principle behind everything. God is a thinking thing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If He is thinking, He must be the creator of that machine.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yes, he says that God is the creator, but we cannot know anything beyond the fact that God is that thinking and extended thing. Because we are aware of mind and matter, God must be thinking, and God must have extension. He claims that man cannot know more than that about God. Extension means that God takes up space.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is everything, He must exist in space. That is understood. But it must also be understood that if God is thinking, He is a person. How can He simply be a principle? How can we say that God is nothing but a principle and yet is thinking? The sun is working according to certain principles. It has to be at a certain place at a certain time. There is no question of thinking. If I say that the sun, which is a principle, is thinking, I am contradicting myself. If God is reason, God is a person, not a principle. Has Spinoza not explained what that principle is?

Çyämasundara däsa: He says that everything is God, and that God is everything.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is logical, but what is his conception of God? Is He a person or not? According to the Vedic version, the person is the origin, and the impersonal aspect is secondary. God is a person, and His influence or His supremacy is in everything.

éçäväsyam idam sarvaà
yat kiïca jagatyäà jagat
tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä
mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam

"Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one should not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong." (Éçopaniñad 1) Everything is made of God's energy, and therefore indirectly everything is God. Yet at the same time, everything is not God. That is Caitanya Mahäprabhu's philosophy of acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva: everything is simultaneously one with and different from God. Everything is God, but at the same time, we are not worshipping this table. We are worshipping the personal God. Although everything is God, we cannot necessarily conceive of God in everything.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza says that we can appreciate God by intellectually appreciating all of His creation and therefore understanding that God is the perfect principle behind everything. In this way, we can have an intellectual love for Him.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is a person, otherwise why are we worshipping the Deity? What is the difference between the Deity and this table? God has a personal form, but this table is not that form. Everything is the manifestation of God's energy. The Viñëu Puräëa gives the example of fire, which expands as light and heat. Light and heat are nothing but fire, but at the same time, light and heat are not fire. They are simultaneously one and different. God is everything, but everything is not God. This table is God in the sense that it is part of God, but we cannot worship this table. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

mayätatam idaà sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

"By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them." (Bg. 9.4) For instance, in the solar system, everything is resting on the sun's energy, but everything is not the sun. The sunshine is different from the sun, yet the sunshine is nothing but the sun. It is simultaneously one and different. This is perfect philosophy. Everything that is manifest is due to God, and when God withdraws His energy, there is no existence. It is insufficient to understand God simply as a principle. Spinoza says that God is a principle, but actually God is the Supreme Person. God expands His energy, and that energy is His principle.

Çyämasundara däsa: God is identical with the substance of the world, the stuff the world is made of.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, you cannot separate the energy from the energetic. That is one fact, but at the same time you cannot say that the sunshine is the same as the sun. It is identical and at the same time different.

Çyämasundara däsa: In a sense, Spinoza would agree in that he says there is a God who is substance but who also has an infinite number of attributes unknown to man.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That's all right, but the attributes are simultaneously God and not God. There is substance and category. Gold is the substance, and a gold ring is the category. The gold ring is certainly gold, but the original substance gold is different.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza would call God the substance and the things of this world the categories. Because the categories are made of the substance, they are all God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This clay pot is made of earth, but would you say that it is the whole earth? You may call it earthly, just as you may call the creation godly. That is pantheism.

Hayagréva däsa: Spinoza writes: 'The more we understand individual objects, the more we understand God." Is this the proper process? Or is it that the more we understand God, the more we understand individual objects?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everything is related to God. In the material world, for instance, things are composed of the five gross elements, which are expansions of God's energies. An intelligent person sees everything in relation to God's expansions of energy. A devotee does not look on anything as being separate from God. Since he is a lover of God, he wants to engage everything in God's service because he understands that everything is God's property. The asuras have no conception of God, nor do they obey or love Him. The demoniac living entity thinks that the material world is created for his enjoyment. He does not see the material world as an expansion of God's energy. One who uses material products for his personal benefit is called a thief because he does not acknowledge the proprietorship of the creator, God. If we do not consider everything to be prasäda, the mercy of God, we become thieves subject to punishment. The conclusion is that the devotee sees every material object related to God and tries to use everything for God's benefit.

Hayagréva däsa: The emphasis in Spinoza is on intellectual knowledge of God through self-knowledge. He writes: "He who knows himself and knows his affections clearly and distinctly—and that with the accompaniment of the idea of God—is joyous, for he knows and loves God." Through knowledge of the self, we can come to know something of God. In this way, man can be happy and love God. There is no mention of service, however.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Love means service. When a mother loves her child, she renders him service.

dadäti pratigåhëäti
guhyam äkhyäti påcchati
bhuìkte bhojayate caiva
ñaò-vidhaà préti-lakñaëam

"Offering gifts in charity, accepting charitable gifts, revealing one's mind in confidence, inquiring confidentially, accepting prasäda, and offering prasäda are the six symptoms of love shared by one devotee and another." (Çré Upadeçämåta 4) Love means giving to one's beloved and also accepting some gift from him. Dadäti pratigåhëati. Love means feeding one's beloved and also taking food from him. It means disclosing one's mind to him, and understanding his mind also. There are six reciprocal relationships in love. Love includes service.

Hayagréva däsa: Spinoza's God is basically not personal. His love for God is more intellectual or philosophical than religious. He takes the typical impersonalist stand in his belief in the identity of the individual soul with God. This is not to say that he believed that the individual soul is infinite but that it is not distinct from God. He writes: "Thus that love of the soul is a part of the infinite love with which God loves Himself." He sees the soul's intellectual love of God, and God's love for the individual soul, to be one and the same.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There are five kinds of love: çänta, däsya, sakhya, vätsalya, and mädhurya. In the beginning, there is love in awe and adoration (çänta), and one thinks, "Oh, God is so great. God is everything." When the soul understands God's unlimited potencies, the soul adores Him, and that adoration is also love. When our love advances, we serve God as a servant serves his master (däsya). As the service becomes more intimate, friendship is established, and a reciprocal relationship of service is developed. This is the kind of service one friend renders to another. As this develops, the love turns into paternal love (vätsalya), and this expands into conjugal love (mädhurya). Thus there are different stages of love of God, and Spinoza only touches the beginning one: adoration and appreciation of God's powerful expansions. That is commendable, but when this love expands, it reaches the platforms of däsya, sakhya, vätsalya, and mädhurya-rasa.

Hayagréva däsa: It appears that Spinoza believes in the Paramätmä present within all beings but not in the jéva accompanying the Paramätmä. Is this not a typical impersonalist position?

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he does not know what is love. If God loves the living entity, He must be both well-wisher and friend. Because God expands Himself unlimitedly, He lives in the living entity. This is the conclusion of Bhagavad-gétä:

éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà
håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati

"The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart, O Arjuna." (Bg. 18.61) The Upaniñads also give the example of two birds sitting on a tree. One bird is eating the fruit of that tree, and the other is simply witnessing. The bird that witnesses is God, the Paramätmä. Thus God, the Paramätmä, and the individual soul, the jévätmä, live together on the same tree of the body. This is confirmed throughout the Vedic literature.

sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöo
mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca

"I am seated in everyone's heart, and from Me come remembrance, knowledge, and forgetfulness." (Bg. 15.15) God reminds the living entity that unless Brahman is present, he cannot remember anything. The Paramätmä is always there with the jévätmä.

Hayagréva däsa: Spinoza does not believe that God has a body because "by body we understand a certain quantity possessing length, breadth, and depth, limited by some fixed form; and that to attribute these to God, a being absolutely infinite, is the greatest absurdity."

Çréla Prabhupäda: God has a body, but it is not like this material body, which is limited. Spinoza's view comes from imperfect knowledge of God's spiritual qualities. It is confirmed in Vedic literatures that God has a body: sac-cid-änanda-vigraha. Vigraha means "body" or "form." God's form is eternal, and He is all-aware. Sac-cit. He is also always blissful. The material body is neither eternal nor blissful, nor all-aware, and therefore it is different from God's body, which possesses different qualities and is all spiritual.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the individual material body, Spinoza asserts that each soul coincides with its body. That is, the soul acquires the body that befits it. However, the soul can progress beyond bodies to come to know spiritual truths by turning toward God rather than the material world, or, as Spinoza would put it, God's "extensions."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The extension or expansion is also God, but at the same time, God is not personally present in the extension. The extension or expansion comes from the person. We might compare the expansions to the government and the person to the governor. The government is under the control of the governor, just as the impersonal expansion of God is under the control of the Supreme Person, Kåñëa. Pantheism says that because everything is God, God Himself has no individual personal existence. To say that everything is God and that God is no more than everything is a material conception. In the material world, if you tear a piece of paper into pieces and throw the pieces away, the original paper is lost. The spiritual conception is different. God may expand Himself unlimitedly through His extensions, but He still remains complete in His own person.

Hayagréva däsa: Spinoza believed that as long as man is composed of body and soul, he will be under the mode of passion, and as long as the soul is confined to the body, the living entity will necessarily be attached to the physical world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we call this mäyä, forgetfulness. The real aim of life, however, is to learn how to distinguish the soul from the material body so that when they separate, we may remain in our original, spiritual form. As long as we are attached to the material body, we have to continue to transmigrate from one body to another. If we give up our attachment to the material body, we are liberated from transmigration, and this is called mukti. It is possible to remain in our spiritual body by always thinking of God. That is the real meaning of meditation. This is confirmed by Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä:

manmanä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi satyaà te
pratijäne priyo 'si me

"Always think of Me and become My devotee. Worship Me and offer your homage unto Me. Thus you will come to Me without fail. I promise you this because you are My very dear friend." (Bg. 18.65)

Hayagréva däsa: Spinoza considered good and evil to relate only to man. They have no basis in God, who is beyond both.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if everything is in God, as Spinoza thinks, what is man's position? God is there, but what is the position of evil? Evil is there, but he says that there is no evil in God. If this is the case, where does evil come from? According to the Vedas, good and evil also emanate from God. It is said that evil is His back, and that good is His front.

Çyämasundara däsa: Since the absolute reality is perfect, error and evil do not really exist because they would imply imperfection. According to Spinoza, since everything is God, everything must be perfect.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Pürëät pürëam udacyate (Éçopaniñad, Invocation). Everything that is produced from the perfect is also perfect. Because God is perfect, the expansions of God are also perfect. If things are perfect in themselves, as long as we keep them in a perfect state, they are perfect. Because material nature is temporary, in the course of time it will become imperfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza says that imperfection or error arises from a partial view of the whole. They are not viewed under the aspect of the eternal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that when the material energy is wound up, it again enters into Him. In the material world, everything is temporary, and everything will eventually be annihilated.

sarva-bhütäni kaunteya
prakåtià yänti mämikäm
kalpa-kñaye punas täni
kalpädau visåjämy aham

"O son of Kunté, at the end of the millennium, every material manifestation enters into My nature, and at the beginning of another millennium, by My potency I again create." (Bg. 9.7) This body will eventually catch some disease, and there will be some so-called imperfection. You cannot consider that disease or imperfection is not in perfect order. This cosmic manifestation is created by Lord Brahmä, maintained by Lord Viñëu, and annihilated by Lord Çiva. There is perfect order here, and this annihilation is also perfect. Thus in a larger sense you can also say that when the body grows old, catches some disease, and dies, these events are also in perfect order. From one point of view, we may see birth, old age, disease and death as imperfections, but actually they are in perfect order. In order to fulfill the whole plan, there must be some disease, or some destruction. We cannot call this imperfection. The plan of destruction is there from the beginning, and that plan is perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza says that we err because we cannot see the whole.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the mistake is also in perfect order. For instance, it was the plan of Kåñëa that so many warriors die on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. That was all in perfect order because it was all planned by God. Paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate (Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 6.8). The Vedas say that the energies of the Lord are multifarious, and just as God is perfect, His energies are also perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Spinoza, evil is due to ignorance, an inability to see reality in its entirety, which is all good because it is God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, evil is due to ignorance. That is a fact. In a higher sense, there is no evil. Ignorance may be considered the cause of evil.

Hayagréva däsa: In his Ethics, Spinoza writes: "Properly speaking, God loves no one and hates no one; for God is not affected with any emotion of joy or sorrow, and consequently, He neither loves nor hates anyone."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and therefore He is called ätmäräma. Being complete in Himself, He doesn't require anything from anyone. However,. He states in Bhagavad-gétä:

patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà
yo me bhaktyä prayacchati
tad ahaà bhakty-upahåtam
açnämi prayatätmanaù

"If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, a fruit, or water, I will accept it." (Bg. 9.26) It is not for God's benefit that He accepts the offering of His devotee; rather, it is for the devotee's benefit to offer something out of love so that his love for God will develop. If we are decorated, our reflection in the mirror is automatically decorated. If we are God's reflections, we also become decorated if God is decorated.

Hayagréva däsa: When Kåñëa destroys demons, does He do so without passion or hatred?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. He kills demons for their benefit.

Hayagréva däsa: Spinoza writes: "No sorrow can exist with the accompanying idea of God. No one can hate God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: By nature, God is always full of pleasure. He is sac-cid-änanda. He is the very source of pleasure. When Kåñëa dances with the gopés, He appears very pleasing, and when He kills a demon, He appears very pleasing also. It is not that He is morose when He destroys a demon. He knows that He is not killing the demon, but awarding him salvation.

Hayagréva däsa: What about the contention that no one can hate God? What of Kaàsa and others?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Hatred of God is demoniac. Naturally, the living entity is in love with God, and he certainly should love God, but when he is in mäyä, he considers himself separate from God. Instead of loving Him, he begins to consider God a competitor and hindrance to sense gratification. It is then that he thinks of avoiding God, or killing Him. The living entity then thinks, "I will become an absolute sense gratifier." In this way, he becomes demoniac.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza defines the supreme virtue to be understanding God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Therefore Bhagavad-gétä says:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmäsudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19) Unless we come to that point, our knowledge is necessarily imperfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza's idea of understanding God is understanding nature. This is because he believes that God reveals Himself in nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, just as in order to understand the sun, we have to understand the sunshine. If we study nature, daiva-çakti, we can get some idea of God. Those who are just beginning to understand God are nature worshippers. They cannot go directly to God. The study of nature is the first stage of understanding God.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza stresses the importance of the intellect, which allows a man to understand the laws of his own personality and thereby control his emotions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he mean by the emotions?

Çyämasundara däsa: Acting emotionally means acting instinctively by one's senses without intelligent consideration.

Çréla Prabhupäda: A madman acts according to his emotions. But what is the source of these emotions? Unless there are emotions in the whole substance, how can emotions exist? There must be emotions in the whole. The substance is the origin, and therefore emotion is a category. Unless emotions are already there in the substance, how can they be manifest? How can you neglect your emotions? If emotions exist in the substance, they have some purpose. Why is he trying to negate his emotions?

Çyämasundara däsa: He thinks that emotions will only lead one to error.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Whatever the case, emotions are concomitant factors in the substance. Every madman also has a mind just as a sane man, but the sane man does not commit mistakes because his mind is in order. Similarly, when emotions are not in order, they lead to trouble, but when emotions are in order, they serve a purpose and are proper. Spinoza does not know this?

Çyämasundara däsa: He claims that the intelligence can direct the emotions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Love of God is an emotion. One may cry in the perfectional stage of devotional service. When Caitanya Mahäprabhu threw Himself into the ocean, that was an emotional act, but that was also a perfect act. According to his emotions, Caitanya Mahäprabhu was considering one moment to be like a yuga, like forty-three million years. This was because He was feeling separation from Kåñëa. When we feel separation from Govinda, Kåñëa, our emotions are in perfect order. That is the perfection of life. However, when the emotions are misused, that is mäyä.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza believes that by nourishing our intelligence, we can will things accordingly. First of all, our will should be subordinate to our intelligence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is already subordinate to our intelligence.

Çyämasundara däsa: But in a madman, is it not reversed?

Çréla Prabhupäda: A madman actually loses his intelligence. He thinks wildly. This is due to derangement, to a loss of intelligence.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza says that God's intelligence controls His will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a different thing. In God, there is no such distinction. There is no distinction between God's body, soul, mind, and intelligence. In Him, everything is absolute. You cannot say that this is God's intelligence, or that this is God's mind. If you make these distinctions, how can you say that God is absolute? In the relative material world, there are such distinctions. We say that this is the intelligence, this is the mind, this is the soul, and so on, but in the spiritual world, there are no such distinctions. Everything is spirit.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Spinoza, nature and God are one, and the moral and the natural are the same.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sexual desire is a part of nature. Why is it sometimes called immoral?

Çyämasundara däsa: It is immoral when it is unnatural.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then we must distinguish between what is natural and unnatural. Whatever is done in God's service is natural and moral, and whatever is not done in His service is unnatural and immoral. Everything in nature is for the satisfaction of God. God has created this flower, and this flower should therefore be employed in God's service. That is moral. As soon as you take this flower for your own sense enjoyment, that is immoral.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza states that man should act for his own self-preservation because this is a natural law.

Çréla Prabhupäda: All preservation depends on God; therefore self-preservation means surrendering to God. A child can preserve himself by surrendering to his parents' will, but if he acts independently, he may be in trouble. If we do not surrender to God, there is no question of preservation. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

sarva-karmäëy api sadä
kurväëo mad-vyapäçrayaù
mat-prasädäd aväpnoti
çäçvataà padam avyayam

"Though engaged in all kinds of activities, My devotee, under My protection, reaches the eternal and imperishable abode by My grace." (Bg. 18.56) Kåñëa tells Arjuna to surrender unto Him. "I will give you all protection." Without Kåñëa, we can not protect ourselves. When Lord Rämacandra wanted to kill Rävaëa, no one could preserve him, not even Lord Çiva or Goddess Durgä. Although there was a huge arrangement for the slaughter of the Päëòavas, no one could kill them because they were protected by Kåñëa. Self-preservation means taking shelter of Kåñëa and depending on Him. Räkhe kåñëa märeke märe kåñëa räkheke. "If Kåñëa protects one, who can kill him? And if Kåñëa wants to kill one, who can protect him?" Just surrender unto Kåñëa, and you will never be destroyed. That is self-preservation. Kåñëa tells Arjuna: kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati. "O son of Kunté, declare it boldly that My devotee never perishes." (Bg. 9.31).

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza believes that the more we understand reality, the more we understand God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is because God is reality, and forgetfulness of God is illusion. Illusion is also God, but in illusion we forget God; therefore it is not real. Sunshine and darkness are both reality because they exist side by side. Wherever there is light, there is also shadow. How can we say that the shadow is not reality? It is mäyä, but because mäyä attacks the individual soul, Kåñëa is forgotten. In that sense, illusion or the unreal is also reality.

Çyämasundara däsa: But in illusion we forget the reality, the light.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. But this is so-called illusion. It is darkness, the atmosphere in which Kåñëa is forgotten. Mäyä is the shadow of darkness, yet even if we come under the shadow of darkness, reality remains. That atmosphere of the unreal is existing side by side with the real. Kåñëa states, "Mäyä is Mine." (Bg. 9.10) It is created by God; therefore how can it be unreal? Kåñëa is reality, and everything dovetailed to Kåñëa is reality. Therefore mäyä, or the unreal, is also Kåñëa. However, when we are in Kåñëa consciousness, we are situated in reality. This material world is called the unreal, but if we are Kåñëa conscious, there is nothing unreal.

Çyämasundara däsa: Because there is no forgetfulness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. As long as you are engaged in the service of Kåñëa, there is nothing unreal for you.

Çyämasundara däsa: Spinoza also believed that man, by subordinating his spirit to natural necessity, finds perfect peace.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that natural necessity means surrender unto Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the Supersoul, and naturally if I surrender unto Him, I will find perfect peace.

tam eva çaraëaà gaccha
sarva-bhävena bhärata
tat-prasädät paräàçäntià
sthänaà präpsyasi çäçvatam

"O scion of Bharata, surrender unto Him utterly. By His grace you will attain transcendental peace and the supreme and eternal abode." (Bg. 18.62)

DS:Gottfried von Leibnitz (1646-1716)

Gottfried von Leibnitz (1646-1716)

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz was a German mathematician and philosopher who maintained that in the universe, every act has a purpose, and the purpose of the universe is to realize the goal set forth by God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, actually the goal is to reach God. The ignorant do not know this. Instead, they are hoping for something that can never be realized. This is the version of Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

na te viduù svärtha-gatiàhi viñëuà
duräçayä ye bahir-artha-mäninaù
andhä yathändhair upanéyamänäs
te 'péça-tantryäm uru-dämni baddhäù

"Persons who are strongly entrapped by the consciousness of enjoying material life, and who have therefore accepted as their leader or guru a similar blind man attached to external sense objects, cannot understand that the goal of life is to return home, back to Godhead, and to engage in the service of Lord Viñëu. As blind men guided by another blind man miss the right path and fall into a ditch, materially attached men led by another materially attached man are bound by the ropes of fruitive labor, which are made of very strong cords, and they continue again and again in materialistic life, suffering the threefold miseries." (Bhäg. 7.5.31) Throughout history, people have been trying to adjust situations by manipulating the material, external energy, but they do not know that they are bound fast by the laws of material nature. No one can violate the laws of nature. As Caitanya Mahäprabhu explained:

kåñëa bhuli' sei jéva anädi-bahirmukha
ataeva mäyä täre deya saàsära-duùkha

"Forgetting Kåñëa, the living entity has been attracted by the external feature from time immemorial. Therefore the illusory energy (mäyä) gives him all kinds of misery in his material existence." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 20.117) Mäyä, the illusory energy, ties the living entity by his neck, just as one ties a dog. The dog thinks, "I am very happy and free. My master is controlling me." In Bhagavad-gétä, it is also stated:

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

"The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities, which are in actuality carried out by nature." (Bg. 3.27) Prakåti, material nature, is controlling the living entity by her different modes, but in ignorance the living entity is thinking, "I am inventing, I am acting, I am progressing." This is called mäyä, illusion. No one can progress or improve without Kåñëa consciousness.The living entities have come into this material world because they wanted to imitate Kåñëa. Therefore they have been given a chance to engage in so-called enjoyment. At the same time, Kåñëa is so kind that He has given them the Vedas, the right directions. He says, "All right, if you want to enjoy, enjoy in this way so that one day you may come back to Me." If a child insists on acting improperly, the father may be very careful in giving him what he wants, and at the same time directing him.

There are two kinds of activities. One is pravåtti, by which we become very much attached to the material world. By the other type of activity, nivåtti, we become detached. Both activities are mentioned in the Vedas. However, there is a plan. Because the living entities have forgotten or disobeyed Kåñëa and are trying to enjoy life by imitating Him, they are placed into this material world. Under the supervision of the superintendent of this material world, Durgä, these living entities can return home, back to Godhead. That is the plan, and there is really no other. Every one of us has to go back home, back to Godhead. If we do so immediately and voluntarily, we save time; otherwise we waste time. We have to come to this point. Therefore Bhagavad-gétä says: bahünäà janmanäm ante (Bg. 7.19). After struggling for many births, the wise man surrenders unto Kåñëa. The final point is surrender, and mäyä gives the living entity trouble in many different ways so that he will eventually come to this point. When he becomes frustrated in his attempts at sense gratification, it should be understood that he is receiving special favor. When Kåñëa is anxious to reform the living entity, He bestows His mercy by first of all taking away all his money. This is a special favor. The living entity always wants to delay, but by special favor Kåñëa draws the living entity to Him by force. This is explained in Caitanya-caritämåta. The living entity wants Kåñëa, or God, but at the same time he wants to enjoy the material world. This is inconsistent, because desiring God means rejecting the material world. Sometimes the living entity is caught between these two desires, and when Kåñëa sees this, He places him in a hopeless condition. He takes away all his money, and then the living entity sees that all his so-called relatives and friends turn from him, saying, "Oh, this man is useless. He has no money." In this hopeless condition, the living entity surrenders to Kåñëa.

All beings are trying to be happy in this material world, but it is nature's plan to give them trouble. In other words, every attempt at happiness will be frustrated so that eventually the living entity will turn to Kåñëa. This is the plan: to bring the living entity back home, back to Godhead. This plan does not apply to just a few living entities. It is not that some will remain here and others will go back to Godhead. No, the whole plan is that everyone must come back to Godhead. Some living entities are very obstinate, just like bad boys. The father says, "Come on," but the boy says, "No, I'll not go." It is then the father's business to drag him. At the end of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

sarva-guhyatamaà bhüyaù
çåëu me paramaà vacaù
iñöo 'si me dåòham iti
tato vakñyämi te hitam

"Because you are My very dear friend, I am speaking to you the most confidential part of knowledge. Hear this from Me, for it is for your benefit." (Bg. 18.64) Then He says, "Surrender unto Me, and I will give you all protection." (Bg. 18.66) In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa instructed Arjuna in karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga, and other yogas, but His final instruction was to surrender.

Çyämasundara däsa Leibnitz agrees that the mechanics of nature serve to fulfill God's purposes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that's it. All the laws of nature are working under Kåñëa's direction.

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again." (Bg. 9.10) Material nature is the goddess Durgä. It is she who is the superintendent of the fort. Material nature is like a fort which no one can leave. Durgä is the confidential maidservant of Kåñëa, but she has a very thankless task of punishing the demoniac living entities, who are thinking, "I will worship my mother Durgä," not knowing that her engagement is punishment. She is not an ordinary mother. She gives the demonic living entity whatever he wants. "Give me money. Give me a good wife. Give me reputation. Give me strength." Goddess Durgä says, "All right, take these things, but at the same time you will be frustrated with them." On the one hand, the living entity is given whatever he wants, and on the other there is frustration and punishment. This is nature's law, and nature is functioning under the instructions of Kåñëa. The living entity in the material world has revolted against Kåñëa. He wants to imitate Kåñëa and become the enjoyer; therefore Kåñëa gives him all the resources of material enjoyment, but at the same time He punishes him. The goddess Durgä is so powerful that she can create, maintain, and dissolve, but she is working just like a shadow. A shadow does not move independently. The movement is coming from Kåñëa. A fool thinks that material nature is there for his enjoyment. This is the materialistic view. When he sees a flower, he thinks, "Nature has produced this flower for me. Everything is for me." In the Bible, it is stated that animals are placed under the dominion or protection of men, but men mistakenly think, "They are given to us to kill and eat." If I entrust you to someone, is it proper that he eat you? What kind of intelligence is this? This is all due to a lack of Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz believed that truth could be represented by an exact, mathematical science of symbols, which could form a universal language, a linguistic calculus. He believed in a rational world and an empirical world, and that each stood opposed to the other. He felt that each had its own truth, which applied to itself, and that each had to be understood according to its own logic. Thus for Leibnitz, there are two kinds of truth. One is the truth of reason, which is a priori. This is innate knowledge which we have prior to and independent of our experience in the material world. The other truth is a posteriori, which is knowledge acquired from experience. This is accidental knowledge in the sense that it is not necessary.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The real truth is that God has a plan, and one has to be taught that plan by one who knows it. This is explained in Caitanya-caritämåta:

nitya-siddha kåñëa-prema 'sädhya' kabhu naya
çravaëädi-çuddha-citte karaye udaya

"Pure love for Kåñëa is eternally established in the hearts of living entities. It is not something to be gained from another source. When the heart is purified by hearing and chanting, the living entity naturally awakens." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 22.107) The truth is there, but we have forgotten it. Through the process of chanting and hearing, we can revive the truth, which is that we are eternal servants of Kåñëa. The living entity is good by nature because he is part and parcel of the supreme good, but due to material association, he has become conditioned. Now we have to again draw forth this goodness through the process of Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: As an innate, or a priori truth, Leibnitz gives the example of a triangle: three angles of a triangle must always equal two right angles. This is a truth of reason which is necessarily permanent. The other type of truth is gathered by experience and is called accidental, or unnecessary. For example, we see that snow is white, but it is also possible that snow may be red.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is also experienced that the three angles of a triangle must always equal two right angles.

Çyämasundara däsa: But this truth exists independently.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How is that? Not everyone knows how a triangle is formed. Only when you study geometry do you understand. You cannot ask any child or any man who has no knowledge of geometry.

Çyämasundara däsa: Whether the man knows it or not, this truth exists.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But truth by definition exists. It is not this truth or that truth. You may know it or not, but truth exists. So why is he using this particular example?

Çyämasundara däsa: Because there is also another kind of truth, which may say that snow is white, but that truth is not absolute because snow could conceivably be red. However, a triangle must always have certain innate properties. That is a necessary truth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Any mathematical calculation is like that. Why use this example? Two plus two equals four. That is always the truth according to mathematical principles.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz was trying to prove that there are certain truths that we cannot deny, that exist independent of our knowledge, and that are fundamental. There are other truths, like snow is white, which may or may not be true because our senses deceive us.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But that is due to our defective senses. It is a fact that snow is white. Now why should it be red? In any case, we have no experience of red snow. Pure snow is white by nature. It may assume another color due to contact with something else, but actually it is white. It is an innate truth that the three angles of a triangle must always equal two right angles, and it is also an innate truth that snow is white, that water is liquid, that stone is hard, and that sugar is sweet. These are fundamental truths that cannot be changed. Similarly, the living entity is the eternal servant of God, and that is his natural position. Water may become hard due to temperature changes, but as soon as the temperature rises, the water again turns into a liquid. Thus the liquidity of water is the truth, the constitutional position of water, because water by definition is a liquid. Similarly, the whiteness of snow is truth, and the servitude of the living entity is truth. In the conditional world, the living entity serves mäyä, and that is not truth. We cannot consider that there are two types of truth. Truth is one. What we take to be not truth is mäyä. There cannot be two truths. Mäyä has no existence, but it appears to be true or factual due to our imperfect senses. A shadow has no existence, but it resembles whatever projects it. In the mirror, you may see your face in exactly the same way that it exists, but that is not truth. The truth is one, and there cannot be two. What is taken for truth at the present moment is called mäyä.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz says that innate truths are governed by the principle of contradiction. That is, the opposite of the truth is impossible to conceive.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The opposite is mäyä.

Çyämasundara däsa: For instance, it is impossible to conceive that the three angles of a triangle cannot equal two right angles.

Çréla Prabhupäda: My point is that there are not two types of truth. When you think that there are, you are mistaken. When you think that two plus two equals five, you are mistaken. Two plus two is always four, and that is the truth. Similarly, snow is always white, and when you think that snow is red, it is the same as thinking that two plus two equals five. It is an untruth. You cannot say that the whiteness of snow is another type of truth. You may make a mistake by thinking snow to be red, but this mistake cannot invalidate the truth that snow is white or that water is liquid. There is one truth, and any other truth is but a shadow. It is not true. Our language must be exact. You can see your face in the mirror as exactly the same, but it is a shadow only; therefore it is not truth. You cannot say that the reflection of your face in the mirror is another type of truth.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz would call this type of truth conditional truth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That conditional truth is not the truth. For instance, the living entity is trying to become master of the material world. He thinks, "I am monarch of all I survey." That is not the truth. The truth is that he is the eternal servant of God. You cannot say that because he is trying to imitate God that he is God. There cannot be a second God. God is one, and that is the Absolute Truth. Our point is that we do not accept the proposition that truth is two. There are relative truths, but Kåñëa is the Absolute Truth. Kåñëa is the substance, and everything is emanating from Kåñëa by Kåñëa's energy. Water is one of Kåñëa's energies, but that energy is not the Absolute Truth. Water is always a liquid, but that is relative truth. Absolute Truth is one. Leibnitz should more precisely say that there is Absolute Truth and relative truth, not that there are two types of truth.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Leibnitz's law of continuity, everything in nature goes by steps and not leaps. In other words, there are no gaps in nature. Everything is connected, and there is gradual differentiation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, there are two processes: gradual and immediate. Of course, in one sense everything is gradual, but if the gradual process takes place quickly, it appears immediate. For instance, if you want to go to the top of the building, you can go step by step, and that is gradual. But you may also take an elevator, which may take just a second. The process of elevation is the same, but one takes place very quickly, and the other is gradual. Foolish people say that a flower is created by nature, but in fact the flower is growing due to the energy of Kåñëa. His energy is so perfect that He doesn't have to take a brush and canvas and try to paint a flower like an artist. The flower appears and grows automatically. Kåñëa is so powerful that whatever He desires immediately happens. This process is very quick, and it appears to be magical. Still, the process is there.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz sees in nature a combination of forces or activities at work. According to the law of motion, there is an uninterrupted series of regularly progressive changes in a body as it moves. If a ball rolls along the floor, it goes progressively, without gaps or sudden changes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: I explained that. The complete motion is part of the same process. However, the ball has no power to move of itself. If you push it in one way, it will roll slowly, and if you push it in another way, it will roll quickly. All these wonderful processes are happening in material nature due to the will of the Supreme. The process takes place automatically, but it is initially pushed by God, who created this material nature. In the beginning, material nature was unmanifest. Gradually, the three qualities or modes came into being, and by the interaction of the modes, many manifestations arose. First there was space, then sky, then sound, one after another. Kåñëa's push is so perfect that everything comes into being automatically in perfect order. Foolish people think that everything comes about automatically without an initial push, without a background. Therefore they think there is no God. This cosmic manifestation has not come about automatically. Kåñëa is the creator, and He gives nature its original purpose. A potter may make a clay pot on a wheel, but the wheel is not the original cause of the pot. It is the potter who gives force to the wheel. Foolish people think that the wheel moves automatically, but behind the wheel's movement there is the potter who gives it force. There is no question of nature creating independently. Everything results from God, Kåñëa.

As soon as you speak of a process, you imply that everything is linked together, that one event follows another. That is nature's way. The first creation is the mahat-tattva, the sum total of material energy. Then there is an interaction of the three guëas, qualities, and then there is mind, ego, and intelligence. In this way, creation takes place. This is explained in the Second Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The Supreme Lord impregnates matter, prakåti, by glancing at her. In the material world, one has to impregnate by the sexual process, but in the Vedas it is stated that Kåñëa impregnated the total material energy simply by His glance. This is due to His omnipotence. When Kåñëa throws His glance toward material nature, material nature is immediately activated, and events begin to happen. So the original cause of the creation is Kåñëa's glance. Materialists cannot understand how Kåñëa can set material nature into motion just by glancing at it, but that is due to their material conception.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz says that space and time are mere appearances and that the ultimate reality is different.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The ultimate reality is Kåñëa, sarva-käraëa-käraëam (Brahma-saàhitä 5.1), the cause of all causes.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz calls the ultimate entities monads. The word "monad" means "unity," or, "oneness." He says that the stuff out of which even atoms are made are all monads, the ultimate particles.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That small particle is not final. Within that particle there is Kåñëa. Aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-stham (Brahma-saàhitä 5.35).

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz says that these monads are individual, conscious, active, and alive, and that they range in quality from the lowest type (matter) through the higher types, such as souls, to the highest, which is God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Does he state that within the atom there is the soul?

Çyämasundara däsa: His theory is that even the atoms are composed of these monads, which possess activity, consciousness, individuality, and other inherent qualities. The monad is the force or activity that constitutes the essence of a substance.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We understand from Brahma-saàhitä that Kåñëa is within the atom. That is Kåñëa who is the substance, the summum bonum. He is smaller than the smallest, and is within everything. That is His all-pervasive nature.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then how are the individualities accounted for?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Every individual soul is awarded a portion of independence because each is part and parcel of God. Thus he has the quality of independence, but in minute quantity. That is his individuality. We consider the atom to be the smallest particle of matter, but we say that Kåñëa is the force within the atom. Leibnitz is suggesting that some force or power exists, but we are directly saying that the force or power is Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: But he says that the force or power in each atom is individual, separate, different.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is so. By His omnipotence, Kåñëa can expand Himself in innumerable forms. Advaitam acyutam anädim ananta rüpam (Brahma-saàhitä 5.33). The word ananta means unlimited, and it is clearly said aëòäntara-stham: He is within the atom.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is he within each atom as an individual entity different from every other entity?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. If Kåñëa is there, He is individual. There are varieties of atoms, and sometimes they are combined together.

Çyämasundara däsa: How is each Kåñëa different? How is it He is an individual in each of the atoms?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why is He not an individual? Kåñëa is always an individual. He is always a person, the Supreme Person, and He can expand Himself innumerably.

Çyämasundara däsa: And is Paramätmä a person?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, every expansion is a person. We are all atomic expansions of Kåñëa, and we are all individual persons. Paramätmä is another expansion, but that is a different kind of expansion.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is the jévätmä, the individual soul, also a person?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. If he were not a person, then how would you account for the differences? We are all different persons. You may agree with my opinion or not, but in any case you are an individual. Kåñëa is also an individual. Nityo nityänäà. There are innumerable individual souls, but He is the supreme individual person. Now Leibnitz may say that within the atom there is a monad, or whatever—you could call it by any name you want—but within the atom the force is Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz maintains that the lowest type of monad is found within material atoms, and then they progress to higher monads, which are souls.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Directly we say Kåñëa, and that is automatically spiritual.

Çyämasundara däsa: He says that each monad has an inner or mental activity, a spiritual life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As soon as we say Kåñëa, we include everything.

Çyämasundara däsa: So even within material atoms, there is a spiritual life, a spiritual force?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, force means spiritual force.

Çyämasundara däsa: He says that all bodies are ultimate quantums of force, and that the essential nature of all bodies is force.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that force is the spiritual soul. Without the spirit soul, the body has no force. It is a dead body.

Çyämasundara däsa: But even within the dead body there are forces. There is the force of decomposition.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is within the atom, and the body is a combination of so many atoms; therefore the force for creating other living entities is also there even in the process of decomposition. When the individual soul's force is stopped within a particular body, we call that body a dead body. Still, Kåñëa's force is there because the body is a combination of atoms.

Çyämasundara däsa: He says that what is manifested to our senses, what occupies space and exists in time, is only an effect of the basic nature, which is transcendental to the physical nature. Physical nature is just an effect of a higher nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Physical nature is a by-product. As I have explained, according to your desire, you receive or create a body. Physical nature is subservient to the soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Leibnitz, these monads create bodies.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, at the time of death, you think in a certain way, and your next body is created. Therefore you create your next body according to your karma.

Çyämasundara däsa: But does the monad of a hydrogen molecule, for instance, create its own body? Does it only accidentally become part of a water molecule?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nothing is accidental.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then does it also desire to become a water molecule? Does the hydrogen desire to combine with oxygen and become water?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. The ultimate desire is of Kåñëa. If you take it in that way, Kåñëa is within every atom, and therefore Kåñëa wants whatever is to be. Therefore He wills that these two elements become one, and therefore the molecules combine to create water, or whatever. Thus there is a creation, and again there is another creation, and so on. In any case, the ultimate brain governing all creation is Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: But does the hydrogen molecule have an independent desire?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, because Kåñëa is within the atoms, they combine. It is not that the atoms as matter are individually willing to combine; rather, because Kåñëa is within the atoms, He knows that by certain combinations, certain creations will result.

Çyämasundara däsa: But does the individual soul have a little independence to choose?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Bhagavad-gétä states that when the individual soul wants to act, Kåñëa gives the orders. Man proposes, and God disposes.

Çyämasundara däsa: So we have no free will?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not without the sanction of Kåñëa. Without Him, we cannot do anything. Therefore He is the ultimate cause.

Çyämasundara däsa: But I thought you have been saying that we have a little independence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have the independence in the sense that we may deny or affirm, but unless Kåñëa sanctions, we cannot do anything.

Çyämasundara däsa: If we desire something, we take a body because of that desire. Now, can a hydrogen molecule desire to become a part of water and be given a body accordingly? Does it have the independence to desire something?

Çréla Prabhupäda: As far as we understand from the Vedas—aëòäntara-stha paramäëu-cayäntara-stham (Brahma-saàhitä 5.35)—Kåñëa is within the paramäëu. It is not stated that the soul is within the paramäëu.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then the individual soul is not present within the atom?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. But Kåñëa is present.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then Leibnitz's view does not accord with the Vedas?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is this because he states that in matter there is also this kind of individuality?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That individuality is in Kåñëa. As I have stated, Kåñëa knows that a certain element will be formed when so many atoms combine. It is not the individual soul enacting this, but Kåñëa Himself directly.

Çyämasundara däsa: But when we refer to the living entities, the individual soul is also there?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the individual soul is within the body. Both are present within the body: Kåñëa and the individual soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Leibnitz, substance is defined as being capable of action.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Substance is original, and extensions are categories. Since substance is the original cause, He is completely able to act. To be means to act. Without activity, what is the meaning of existence?

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz states that the monads change in their appearance because their inner desire compels them to pass from one phenomenal representation to another.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The monad does not change, but the mind changes. At any rate, I do not know what Leibnitz means by monads. He is simply complicating matters.

Çyämasundara däsa: By definition, the monad is a small unit, a unity, which is the substance behind everything, even the atom.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is Kåñëa. Kåñëa is fully independent.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yet Leibnitz says that a monad changes his appearance according to his desires.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is the case for the individual souls, but Kåñëa is not like that. Kåñëa is acyuta. He does not change. It is Kåñëa who creates the entire cosmic energy. By His plan and devices, so many creations are divided into different parts, and they change. Material objects change according to the will of God, Kåñëa. These individual monads are more precisely the Supersoul existing within matter, within the atom.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz would say that each particle of Supersoul, or each monad, is self-contained, that there is no loss or gain of force.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, each is eternal.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the relationship between the soul and body, Leibnitz writes: "Insofar as the soul has perfection and distinct thoughts, God has accomodated the body to the soul, and has arranged beforehand that the body is impelled to execute its orders."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is explained in Bhagavad-gétä (18.61) that the body is like a machine. Because the soul wants to walk or move in a certain way, he is given this instrument. The soul has particular desires, and God gratifies these desires through His material agent, a particular type of body. Therefore there are birds flying, fish swimming, animals hunting in forests, men in cities, and so on. According to Padma Puräëa, there are 8,400,000 different bodies created to gratify the desires of the soul. Thus the machine of the body is supplied by nature under the orders of God.

Hayagréva däsa: For Leibnitz, in that the soul is perfect, it controls the body. However, "insofar as the soul is imperfect and its perceptions are confused, God has accomodated the soul to the body, in such a sort that the soul is swayed by the passions arising out of corporeal representations."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is explained in Bhagavad-gétä that the soul in the material world is influenced by the three modes of material nature.

na tad asti påthivyäà vä
divi deveñu vä punaù
sattvaà prakåti-jair muktaà
yad ebhiù syät tribhir guëaiù

"There is no being existing, either here or among the demigods in the higher planetary systems, which is freed from the three modes of material nature." (Bg. 18.40) He receives a particular type of body according to his position in respect to the modes. If his appetite is insatiable and his eating indiscriminate, he receives the body of a pig. If he wants to kill and eat bloody meat, he gets the body of a tiger. If he wants to eat Kåñëa prasädam, he is given the body of a brähmaëa. Thus we receive different types of bodies according to our desires. People attempt to gratify their desires because they think that by doing so they will be happy. Unfortunately, people do not know that they will be happy only by completely abiding by the orders of God. Kåñëa comes personally to request the living entity to abandon his material desires and act according to God's orders.

Hayagréva däsa: In Monadology, Leibnitz writes: "The soul changes its body only gradually and by degrees, so that it is never deprived of all its organs at once. There is often a metamorphosis in animals, but never metempsychosis or transmigration of souls."

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is his understanding of the soul?

Hayagréva däsa: He believes that it is not possible for souls to be entirely separate from bodies. For living entities, a body must always accompany the soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to Vedic understanding, the body changes, but the soul remains eternal. Even in one lifetime we can see that our material body is changing from childhood to youth to old age, yet the soul remains the same. When the body dies, the soul takes on another body. This is the first lesson of Bhagavad-gétä. If the soul is distinct from the body, it is nonsensical to say that a soul cannot exist without a body.

Hayagréva däsa: Leibnitz elaborates on this: "There is, strictly speaking, neither absolute birth nor complete death consisting in the separation of the soul from the body. What we call birth is development or growth, and what we call death is envelopment and diminution."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But that is the process of transmigration. Why does he deny it? The diminution is temporary. The living entity is not dead; he goes on to develop another body.

Hayagréva däsa: He seems to be saying that as soon as the human soul leaves the body, it must immediately enter another body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the case, but that is the process of transmigration. So why does he deny transmigration?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, he denies the existence of the soul apart from some form of material body. He writes: "God alone is wholly without body."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is, He has no material body. He does not transmigrate. According to Bhagavad-gétä, müòhäs, fools, consider Kåñëa's body to be like that of a human being.

avajänanti mäà müòhä
mänuñéà tanum äçritam
paraà bhävam ajänanto
mama bhüta-maheçvaram

"Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and My supreme dominion over all that be." (Bg. 9.11) Kåñëa does not change His body as an ordinary living entity does. He is the Supreme Person. Because He does not change His body, He remembers everything in the past. When we receive a body, we do not remember our past lives, but Kåñëa remembers because His body never changes. God is without a body in the sense that He has no material body.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to his doctrine of preestablished harmony, Leibnitz likens the soul and the body to two perfectly synchronized clocks, both going at the same speed but both separate.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the soul is different from the body, but the body is manifest due to the soul's desire. The body is the instrument of the soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: Does the body ever affect the soul?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul is unaffected by the body, but the body is helping the soul to fulfill its desires. I am using this microphone to serve my purposes, but this microphone is not influencing me. It is not that this microphone wills that I dictate this or that. The body is a combination of atoms. If Kåñëa is within the atoms, the monads of the atoms and the monad in the body are different. If the monad is a small united particle, Leibnitz is speaking of the Supersoul. Although the Supersoul appears innumerable, it is in actuality one. As stated in Éçopaniñad:

yasmin sarväëi bhütäny
ätmaiväbhüd vijänataù
tatra ko mohaù kaù çoka
ekatvam anupaçyataù

"One who always sees all living entities as spiritual sparks, in quality one with the Lord, becomes a true knower of things, and there is no illusion or anxiety for him." (Éçopaniñad 7) Although we find the Supersoul all-pervasive, there is but one. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä:

samaà sarveñu bhüteñu
tiñöhantaà parameçvaram
vinaçyatsv avinaçyantaà
yaù paçyati sa paçyati

"One who sees the Supersoul accompanying the individual soul in all bodies and who understands that neither the soul nor the Supersoul is ever destroyed, actually sees." (Bg. 13.28) The devotee always sees all things in Kåñëa, and Kåñëa in all things. That is the true vision of oneness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz believes that God creates the principle of preestablished harmony, that He sets the two clocks in motion and synchronizes them. The body is acting, but the soul is independent. It is not really affected by the body.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We also agree to that, but why use the example of clocks? Why not analyze the relationship between the body and the soul? You cannot consider them separately, because they are combined. The fallacy of this analogy is that two individual clocks are not combined at any point.

Çyämasundara däsa: The common point is their synchronization.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But eventually one clock will go faster than the other. You cannot consider the body and soul as completely separate entities working independent of one another. It is stated in the Vedic çästras that the soul is the master of the body; therefore you cannot say that the body is working independently. If I tell my body to place this hand here, my hand will move to this spot. It is not that suddenly my hand moves without my desire.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz would say that the act of your desiring and the act of the hand moving are simultaneous but separate.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In Sanskrit, this argument is called käkatäléya-nyäya. Once, when a crow flew into a täl tree, the fruit on that tree immediately fell to the ground. One observer said that the crow lighted on the tree first, and then the fruit fell, and the other observer said that the fruit fell before the crow could light. This kind of argument has no value. We say that if Kåñëa so desires, a stone can float on the water, despite the law of gravitation. Although the law of gravitation is working here, there are so many huge planets floating in space. All these laws act according to Kåñëa's desire. By the law of gravitation, all these planets would have fallen into the causal ocean and hit the Garbhodakaçäyé-viñëu in the head because He is lying on that ocean. But by His order all these planets are floating in space. Similarly, if God so desires, a rock may fall into the water, but the water will not give way. The rock will simply float. Since God is the ultimate monad, this is possible. Whatever God wills will come into effect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz admits that the monads are spiritual in nature and therefore immortal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we agree to that. Both Kåñëa and the living entity are spiritual. Ultimately, everything is spiritual because everything is Kåñëa's energy. If Kåñëa is the original cause, matter can be changed into spirit, and spirit into matter. Electricity may be used to heat or to cool, but in either case, the original energy is electricity. Similarly, the original cause is Kåñëa; therefore He has the power to change matter into spirit, or spirit into matter.

Çyämasundara däsa: He states that unlike the other monads, God is absolute necessity and eternal truth, and He is governed by the law of contradiction. That is to say, it is impossible to conceive of no God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The atheists say that there is no God, although God is there. Unless God is there, where is the idea of God coming from? The atheist refuses to accept God. Similarly, the impersonalists refuse to accept a Supreme Personality of Godhead. Unless the idea of personality is there, how can they consider God to be impersonal? All this is due to frustration.

Hayagréva däsa: Leibnitz pictures a city of God very much like that of Augustine. He writes: "God is the monarch of the most perfect republic composed of all the spirits, and the happiness of this city of God is His principal purpose."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. If everyone becomes Kåñëa conscious and acts according to the instructions of Kåñëa, this hellish world will become the city of God.

Hayagréva däsa: Leibnitz further writes: "We must not therefore doubt that God so ordained everything that spirits not only shall live forever, because this is unavoidable, but that they shall also preserve forever their moral quality, so that His city may never lose a person."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this is Vaikuëöha consciousness. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

avyakto 'kñara ity uktas
tam ähuù paramäà gatim
yaà präpya na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"That supreme abode is called unmanifested and infallible, and it is the supreme destination. When one goes there, he never comes back. That is My supreme abode." (Bg. 8.21) That spiritual sky, or city of God, is well known to Vedic students.

Hayagréva däsa: Leibnitz did not believe that the city of God is divorced from the natural world. In Monadology, he writes: "The assembly of all spirits must compose the city of God, that is, the most perfect state possible and of the most perfect of monarchs [God]. This city of God, this truly universal monarchy, is a moral world within the natural world, and the highest and most divine of the works of God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and we can realize this city immediately if we come to the proper consciousness that this planet does not belong to any particular nation but to God Himself. If people accept this principle, the entire world will become the city of God. Presently, the United Nations is attempting to settle all the problems of the world, but the leaders themselves have an animalistic mentality. They are thinking, "I am this body, I am American, or Indian, or whatever." People must give up these designations and understand their real identity as part and parcel of God. The entire planet belongs to God. We are His sons, and it is possible for us to live peacefully understanding that our Father is supplying us everything. If there is scarcity, it is due to improper distribution. If everyone abides by the orders of God, and everything produced is divided among the sons of God, there no question of scarcity. Since people are denying the actual fact that everything belongs to God, and since they are hoarding goods, there is scarcity. If people want to remain in animal consciousness, they will continue to suffer. Once they come to Kåñëa consciousness, they will realize the city of God, even within this material world.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz also states that the world could have been otherwise if God so desired, but that He chose this particular arrangement as the best possible.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, God can do as He likes, but this world was not exactly planned by God. It is given to the living entities who want to imitate God. The plan is shaped according to the desires of the living entities who want to lord it over material nature. This is not God's plan. This material world is like a prison supported by the government because there are criminals. It is God's plan that all the living entities in the material world give up their striving and return home, back to Godhead.

Çyämasundara däsa: But from the standpoint of the ingredients of this world, is this the best possible world?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The spiritual world is the best possible world. This planet earth is not a very good planet; there are many other planets even in the material world thousands of times better. The higher you go in the planetary systems, the more comforts and amenities you find. The next planetary system is a thousand times superior to this one, and the planetary system above that is a thousand times superior still. In Brahmä-loka, the highest planet, twelve hours of Brahmä's day are beyond our comprehension.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz accepts the conditions of this material world as being the best we can hope for, the best of a bad bargain.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But Bhagavad-gétä states that this is a place of misery:

äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

"From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place. But one who attains to My abode, O son of Kunté, never takes birth again." (Bg. 8.16) This place is meant for suffering. We cannot stay here for very long, even if we agree to stay in such an uncomfortable situation. We have to change our body and go to a higher or lower situation. On the whole, material life is miserable. There is no question of happiness.

Çyämasundara däsa: He also states that because there is more good than evil in this world, the creation of this world is justified.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, there is good and evil according to our angle of vision. A devotee sees this material world as good. In the material world, people are always complaining and are in a distressed condition, but a devotee sees that there is really no distressed condition. Everything is happiness because he lives with Kåñëa. Because he dovetails everything with Kåñëa, including himself, for him there is no misery.

Çyämasundara däsa: He also says that if the world had not been worth creating, God would not have created it. The fact that He created it makes it worth creating.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is stated in the Vedas:

oà pürëam adaù pürëam idea
pürëät pürëam udacyate
pürëasya pürëam ädäya
pürëam evävaçiñyate

"The Personality of Godhead is perfect and complete, and because He is completely perfect, all emanations from Him, such as this phenomenal world, are perfectly equipped as complete wholes. Whatever is produced of the complete whole is also complete in itself. Because He is the complete whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance." (Éçopaniñad Invocation) The creator is complete, and the creation is also complete. Nothing incomplete can be created by the complete. In that sense, everything that is wanted in this world is here. The arrangement is complete.

VIBRITISH EMPIRICISM

VIBRITISH EMPIRICISM

DS:John Locke (1632-1704)

John Locke (1632-1704)

Hayagréva däsa: In Essay Concerning Human Understanding, Locke writes: "This argument of universal consent, which is made use of to prove innate principles, seems to me a demonstration that there are none such because there are none to which all mankind give a universal consent." That is, it cannot be argued that all people have an innate or inborn idea of God. But do innate ideas have to be universal? Might they not differ from person to person?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Innate ideas depend on the development of our consciousness. Animals have no innate idea of God due to their undeveloped consciousness. In every human society, however, men have some innate idea of a superior power. For instance, even aborigines offer obeisances when they see lightning. The offering of obeisances to something wonderful or powerful is innate in man. The consciousness of offering respects is not developed in animals. When we have developed this innate idea to its fullest extent, we are Kåñëa conscious.

Hayagréva däsa: Wouldn't it be better to say that the living entity is born with certain tendencies, which carry over from the previous life, and that all he needs is to meet with some stimulus in order for them to be manifest?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. For instance, when an animal is born, it naturally searches for the nipples of its mother. This means that the animal has had experience in a previous life, and therefore knows how to find food. Although the animal may not be able to see, it knows how to search for its food by virtue of past experience. This proves the eternal continuity of the soul. Presently, I am living in this room, and if I go away for ten years, then return, I can still remember where the bathroom and living room are. This remembrance is due to my having lived here before. In material life, the living entity passes through different species, or forms.

Hayagréva däsa: Locke would argue that the idea of Kåñëa is not innate because it is not universally assented to. Since not everyone acknowledges that Kåñëa is God, Locke would say that the idea is not inborn in the mind.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In the material world, different living entities have different ideas. The ideas of a person with developed consciousness are different from those of a person with undeveloped consciousness. If someone is Kåñëa conscious shortly after his birth, we are to understand that he has previously contemplated Kåñëa. In Bhagavad-gétä, Çré Kåñëa says:

tatra taà buddhi-saàyogaà
labhate paurva-dehikam
yatate ca tato bhüyaù
saàsiddhau kuru-nandana

"On taking such a birth, he again revives the divine consciousness of his previous life, and he again tries to make further progress in order to achieve complete success." (Bg. 6.43) Our culture of Kåñëa consciousness is never lost; it grows until it is perfected. Therefore Kåñëa says:

nehäbhikrama-näço 'sti
pratyaväyo na vidyate
svalpam apy asya dharmasya
träyate mahato bhayät

"In this endeavor there is no loss or diminution, and a little advancement on this path can protect one from the most dangerous type of fear." (Bg. 2.40) We have the example of Ajämila, who cultivated Kåñëa consciousness in the beginning of his life, and then fell down and became the greatest debauchee. Yet at the end of his life, he again remembered Näräyaëa and attained salvation.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke maintains that there are two basic ideas: those which come from sensations, external experience, and those provided by inner reflection.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is known as pratyakña pramäëa. However, we have to go higher. Pratyakña, paro'kña, anumäna, adhokñaja, and aparäjita. These are different stages of knowledge. Pratyakña means direct knowledge, paro'kña is knowledge received from others, and anumäna, inference, is knowledge acquired after judging direct knowledge and knowledge received from authorities. Adhokñaja is knowledge beyond the limits of direct perception. Aparäjita is spiritual knowledge. All the stages of knowledge advance toward spiritual knowledge. Direct perception is material.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke states that the mind can reflect only after it has acquired some sense experience. In other words, only after acquiring some knowledge of this world through the senses can we have thoughts and ideas.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but my ideas may not always be true. I may have experience of gold and a mountain, and I may dream of a golden mountain, but a golden mountain does not exist in the external world.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke distinguished between simple ideas and complex ideas. There are four types of simple ideas: those we perceive from one sense, such as sound, touch, and so on; those we receive from two or more senses, such as motion or space; those we receive by reflection, such as remembering, reasoning, knowing, and believing; and those we receive from both sensation and reflection, ideas of existence, or unity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: These all arise out of different material conditions. For instance, how do we experience ether? By sound. We can neither see nor touch ether. As the material condition changes, the sense perception also changes. We can sense air and water by touch, fire by form, and fragrance by smell. In the beginning, the living entity has his mind, intelligence, and ego, but presently the mind, intelligence and ego are false, just as this present body is false. The spirit soul has a body, but this body is covered. Similarly, the mind, ego, and intelligence are covered by material conditioning. When they are uncovered, we acquire our pure mind, pure intelligence, and pure identity. Devotional service means bringing the soul to his original, pure condition. In Kåñëa consciousness, everything is pure: pure mind, pure intelligence, and pure ego. Tat-paratvena nirmalam (Närada-païcarätra). Everything is purified when it is connected with the supreme spirit. When we are purified, we have nothing to do with the material mind, body, intelligence, or ego. We are purely spiritual.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke is trying to find a basis for knowledge beginning with sense perception. He states that the mind receives knowledge from the senses and is able to reflect on this.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we agree that the mind receives knowledge through the senses. Then there is thinking, feeling, and willing. There is also judgment and work. We receive many impressions and then plan something. We think and feel, and then we put the plan into action. That action is the process of work.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke states that these simple ideas combine to form complex or abstract ideas like the conception of God. This is an enlargement upon the simple ideas of existence, knowledge, time, power, and so on. We combine these to make a complex idea like the idea of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is not a complex idea but a perfect idea. However, God is so great that He is naturally complex to the ordinary man.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke states that there are three types of complex ideas: that which depends upon substances like roundness, hardness, and so on; that which is a relation between one idea and another, agreeing or disagreeing with another; and that which is a substance or body subsisting by itself and providing the basis for experience. Because we can know only the quality of a substance, we cannot know what the substance itself is, nor where it comes from, nor how it is produced. The nature of ultimate reality cannot be known or proved.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is a fact that it cannot be known by such mental speculation, but it can be known from a person who knows it. Locke may not know, but someone else may know. Everyone thinks that others are like himself. Because he does not know, he thinks that others do not know. But that is not a fact. There may be someone who knows.

tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet
samit-päëiùçrotriyaà brahma-niñöham

"In order to learn the transcendental science, one must approach the bona fide spiritual master in disciplic succession, who is fixed in the Absolute Truth." (Muëòaka Upaniñad 1.2.12) The Vedas tell us to seek out the person who knows. That is the bona fide guru. Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that such a guru is one who knows that the ultimate reality is Kåñëa. That is the most important qualification.

kibä vipra, kibä nyäsé, çüdra kene naya
yei kåñëa-tattva-vettä, sei guru haya

"Whether one is a brähmaëa, a sannyäsé, or a çüdrä—regardless of what he is—he can become a spiritual master if he knows the science of Kåñëa." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 8.128)

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke claims that objective reality has primary qualities that are inseparable from the object itself, just as the color red is inseparable from a red object.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that which cannot be separated is called dharma. Dharma is the particular characteristic of a particular thing. For every living entity, dharma means rendering service to Kåñëa, the supreme. That is liberation and the perfection of life.

Hayagréva däsa: Some people claim to remember events from their previous lives. How are these reminiscences different from innate ideas?

Çréla Prabhupäda: An innate idea is inevitable. The idea that God is great and that I am controlled is innate everywhere, but sometimes out of ignorance, one tries to become God. That is not possible. That is mäyä, and one simply suffers. It is an innate idea with the living entity that he is a servant and that God is great.

Hayagréva däsa: Locke further writes: "The knowledge of our own being we have by intuition. The existence of God, reason clearly makes known to us. We have a more certain knowledge of the existence of a God than of anything our senses can discover." How is this? If this is the case, how is it that some men have no conception of God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everyone has some conception of God, but under the spell of mäyä, the living entity tries to cover that conception. How can any sane man deny God's existence? Some superior power must be present to create the vast ocean, land, and sky. No one can avoid some conception of God, but one can artificially and foolishly attempt to avoid it. This is called atheism, and this will not endure. One's foolishness will ultimately be exposed.

Hayagréva däsa: Locke recommends four tests to know whether knowledge is true, by which we can perceive agreement or disagreement between ideas.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Whether we agree or not, truth is truth. There is no question of my agreement or disagreement.

Çyämasundara däsa: We can objectively study something to see if there is agreement or disagreement. It is not that knowledge depends on our subjective opinion. There must be some scientific proof.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our test of truth is Vedic evidence. For instance, it is stated in the Vedas that cow stool is pure. We accept this as true. We cannot reach this conclusion by argument.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke states that God must be a thinking being because matter, which is senseless, could never produce sense experience, perception, and thoughts.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly. By definition, God has full knowledge of everything. Kåñëa says:

vedähaà samatétäni
vartamänäni cärjuna
bhaviñyäëi ca bhütäni
mäà tu veda na kaçcana

"O Arjuna, as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, I know everything that has happened in the past, all that is happening in the present, and all things that are yet to come. I also know all living entities, but Me no one knows." (Bg. 7.26) Kåñëa also told Arjuna that millions of years ago He instructed the sun god in the philosophy of Bhagavad-gétä. Kåñëa also points out that Arjuna took birth with Him, but that Arjuna had forgotten. Kåñëa knows everything. That is the meaning of omniscience.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke also says that since there are no innate ideas, moral, religious, and political values must be regarded as products of experience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We should understand what is the best experience. For instance, we consider Manu to be the authority on political and social affairs. Manur ikñväkave 'bravét (Bg. 4.1). Manu instructed his son Ikñväku. If this depends on experience, we should accept perfect, unadulterated experience.

Çyämasundara däsa: He states that values must obey the will of God as expressed in natural law, the laws upon which men agree, such as social contracts, and the established traditions, customs, and opinions of mankind. He states that our laws must be obeyed in such a way that we will exist in harmony.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And what is that harmony? Perfect harmony is in knowing that we are part and parcel of God. In this body, there are different parts, and each part has a particular function. When each part performs its function, the body is harmonious. The hand is meant for touching, lifting, and grasping, but if the hand says, "I shall walk," there is disharmony. Being part and parcel of God, we have a particular function. If we fulfill that function, there is harmony. If we do not, there is disharmony. The law of nature means working in harmony with the desire of God.

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again." (Bg. 9.10) Under Kåñëa's superintendence, everything is functioning in harmony. Events do not happen blindly. In any organization, there is a supreme authority under whose orders everything moves in harmony. Harmony means that there must be some supreme superintendent. It is generally said that obedience is the first law of discipline. There cannot be harmony without obedience.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke would say that we have to obey the laws of nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everyone is obeying the laws of nature. Yasyäjïayä bhramati. Brahma-saàhitä (5.52) states that the sun is moving in its orbit fixed by the law of Govinda. The ocean has certain limitations fixed by the Supreme. All nature is functioning according to the law of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke believes that we must also obey the laws upon which we agree, that is, the social contract.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is the law: we must surrender to Kåñëa. When we agree to the laws of the Supreme, that is religion.

Çyämasundara däsa: Men agree socially not to steal one another's property, or to kill one another. Shouldn't we obey these laws of man?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Men's laws are imitations of God's laws. God's law states: Éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà. "Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord." (Éçopaniñad 1) Every living entity is the son of God, and he has the right to live at the cost of God. Everyone is eating food supplied by God. The animals are eating their food. The cow is eating grass, but why should we kill the cow? This is against God's law. We have rice, grains, fruits, vegetables, and so on. These are for us. Tigers do not come to eat our fruits or grains, so why should we kill tigers? A tiger is not encroaching upon our rights.

Hayagréva däsa: Locke argues on behalf of private property given to man by God. He believes that a man may have stewardship over a certain amount of property. Is this in compliance with the Éçopaniñadic version?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä. "One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota." (Éçopaniñad 1) Everything belongs to God. A father may have many sons and be the ultimate proprietor of his house, yet he gives different rooms to his sons. The obedient son is satisfied with what his father has alloted him. The disobedient son simply wants to disturb his other brothers, and so he claims their rooms. This creates chaos and confusion in the world. The United Nations has been formed to unify nations, but they have not succeeded. People continue to encroach on one another's property, and therefore there is no peace. If we accept God as the supreme proprietor, and are satisfied with the allotment He has given us, there will be no trouble. Unfortunately, we are not satisfied.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Locke's utilitarian ethic, happiness is the greatest good, and obedience to the moral law results in happiness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But the difficulty is that here in this material world, happiness is temporary. And even if we follow moral laws, other people will give us trouble. There are people who don't care whether you are moral or immoral. Bhagavad-gétä confirms that this is not a place of happiness. Duùkhälayam açäçvatam. "This temporary world is full of miseries." (Bg. 8.15) Therefore we have to find where real happiness exists. That is the spiritual world. Happiness here is only another illusion. It is not possible. If Kåñëa Himself says that this is a place of misery, how can we find happiness here? In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa speaks of real happiness:

sukham ätyantikaà yat tad
buddhi-grähyam aténdriyam
vetti yatra na caiväyaà
sthitaç calati tattvataù

"In that joyous state, one is situated in boundless transcendental happiness and enjoys himself through transcendental senses. Established thus, one never departs from the truth, and upon gaining this, he thinks there is no greater gain." (Bg. 6.21) Real happiness is beyond the senses. It is aténdriya. In other words, we have to purify our senses in order to attain it. This is also confirmed by Åñabhadeva:

näyaà deho deha-bhäjäà nåloke
kañöän kämän arhate viò-bhujäà ye
tapo divyaà putrakä yena sattvaà
çuddhyed yasmäd brahma-saukhyaà tv anantam

"Of all the living entities who have accepted material bodies in this world, one who has been awarded this human form should not work hard day and night for sense gratification, which is available even for dogs and hogs that eat stool. One should engage in penance and austerity to attain the divine position of devotional service. By such activity, one's heart is purified, and when one attains this position, he attains eternal, blissful life, which is transcendental to material happiness and which continues forever." (Bhäg. 5.5.1) Presently, our existence is impure. If a man is suffering from jaundice, he tastes sweet things as bitter. In order to taste real happiness, we have to purify our senses. Materialists think that as soon as they have sexual intercourse, they will be happy, but that is not real happiness. We cannot even enjoy that happiness. The conclusion is that we should not seek happiness like cats, dogs, and hogs, but as human beings. This means tapasya, purification of the senses. First we must be cured of this material disease, then we can taste real happiness in our healthy life. A sane man knows that he is spirit soul covered by a material coating. So let this coating be washed away by devotional service. Tat-paratvena nirmalam (Närada-païcarätra). When we engage in devotional service, we remove the false coating, and our real senses emerge. We enjoy those real senses by serving Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Locke also says that all men are born free and equal in the state of nature and that they have formed a social contract; therefore the government must be based on and subject to the mutual consent of all the citizens.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That agreement can be reached when everyone is situated on the spiritual platform. On the material platform, people are subject to the three modes of material nature: goodness, passion, and ignorance. How can the vote of a God conscious man and the vote of a drunkard be equal? Equality is not possible unless everyone comes to the spiritual platform.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is it true that all men are born free and equal?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact. If we are not free, how can we commit sin? Committing sin means that we have the freedom to commit sins. And equality means that we all have small independence. We are equal in the sense that we can properly utilize or misuse our independence. Because we all have independence, we are equal. If we misuse it, we go downward, and if we use it properly, we go upward. In the use of our independence, we have equal rights.

DS:George Berkeley (1685-1753)

George Berkeley (1685-1753)

Hayagréva däsa: Berkeley seems to argue against objective reality. For instance, three men standing in a field looking at a tree could all have different impressions or ideas of the tree. The problem is that although there are three different impressions of the tree, there is no tree as such. Now, how does the tree as such exist? In the mind of God? Is it possible for a conditioned living entity to perceive the suchness or essence of anything?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since everything is God, or an expansion of God's energy, how can a tree or anything else exist independent of God? A clay pot is not different from earth. Since there is nothing but God's energy, how can we avoid God? Since nothing can exist independent of God, whatever we see must refer to God. As soon as we see a clay pot, we remember the potter. God is not only the original creator; He is the ingredient, the category, and the original substance as well. According to the Vedic conception, God is everything. That is a nondual conception. If you separate anything from God, you cannot say, sarvaà khalv idaà brahma (Chändogya Upaniñad 3.14.1). "Everything is Brahman." Everything refers to God, and everything is God's property; therefore whatever exists should be utilized for God's service, and that is the object of our Kåñëa consciousness movement.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley maintained that nothing exists outside perception. Matter is simply perceived. For instance, this table is only an immaterial substance which enters my mind. It is not made of matter.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then what is your mind? Is the mind also immaterial? This is the Çünyavädé position. They believe that everything is zero.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley says that everything is spiritual, not zero.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The spiritual is not an idea but a fact. The Çünyavädés cannot understand how spirit has form. They have no idea of sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, our spiritual form of bliss. They really have no idea of spiritual existence.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley says that everything has form, but that it is not made of matter.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is nice. Everything has form. It is not necessary that the form be material. We say that God has a spiritual form.

Çyämasundara däsa: But Berkeley goes so far as to say that everything is made of spirit.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, in the higher sense, everything is spirit. We always say that materialism means forgetfulness of Kåñëa. As soon as we dovetail everything to Kåñëa, nothing is material but spiritual.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley uses the example of a book on a table. The only way the book exists is through the idea or sense impression in the mind. It doesn't enter the mind as matter but as spirit, something immaterial.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If it is not matter, it is spirit. If everything is spirit, why distinguish between the idea of the book and the book?

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, for him there is no difference.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But he explains that the book is not material. If everything is spiritual, the idea is spiritual as well 'as the book. Why make the distinction? Sarvaà khalv idam brahma (Chändogya Upaniñad 3.14.1). If everything is Brahman, why make these distinctions between the idea of the book and the book? Why is he trying so hard to attempt to explain?

Çyämasundara däsa: He also states that God creates all objects.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that's right, and because God creates all objects, there is no object that is not true. We cannot say that something false comes from something true. If God is truth, then whatever emanates from God is also truth. It is Mäyävädé philosophy to say that everything that we are seeing is false. Brahma satyaàjagan mithyä.

Çyämasundara däsa: No, he says it is real because God perceives it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If it is real, and my idea of it is real, then everything is real. Why make these distinctions? Our philosophy is that there cannot be these distinctions. If the world emanates from God, can it be false? If everything is spiritual, why does he make the distinction in saying that it is not matter, that it is something else? As soon as we bring up the subject of matter, we imply that matter is something separately existing. In other words, there is duality. As soon as you say that this is not matter, you are making matter into something that is not true. If everything emanates from God and is true, there is no question of there being anything that is not true. If everything is spiritual, we cannot make these distinctions. When he says, "This is not matter," he implies that there is matter somewhere. If everything is spirit, there is no question of material existence.

Çyämasundara däsa: He says that there are two types of objects: those which we actively sense, perceive, and experience, and those which are passively sensed, perceived, and experienced. Both are basically the same because they are equally spiritual.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But two types means duality. How does he distinguish between this type and that type? He distinguishes between the senses and the objects of the senses. If everything is spiritual, we can say that there is spiritual variety. But the senses and the objects of the senses are all real.

Çyämasundara däsa: No, he says that they are real and made of spirit. They are not real in the sense that they are made of matter.

Çréla Prabhupäda: I do not understand this logic. If everything is spirit, why is he making these distinctions? There is no need to make such distinctions if you are spiritually realized. Rather, you can say that these are spiritual varieties. For instance, you can say that stone is not water, that air is not stone, that water is not air, and so on. These are all spiritual varieties. The exact Sanskrit word is saviçeña, which indicates that everything is spirit but that there is variety.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley says that if no one experiences a thing, not even God, then it cannot exist. Things can exist only when they are perceived by God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means in one word that there is no existence except God, that nothing exists but God.

Çyämasundara däsa: He uses the example of the far side of the North Star. We will never be able to perceive it from our viewpoint, but because God can perceive it, it must exist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That's nice. The idea that something does not exist because I cannot perceive it is not very logical. I may not perceive many things, but that does not mean that they do not exist. In the beginning, this is what I understood you to say Berkeley was saying. That kind of logic is contradictory. God's perception is different. He is unlimited, and we are limited. Since He is unlimited, His perception is unlimited; therefore there are unlimited varieties of existence that we have not even perceived. We cannot say that objects do not exist just because we cannot perceive them.

Çyämasundara däsa: He says that objects exist because of perception, whether it is God's perception or ours.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God's perception is another thing. Perception means cetana. Nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm (Kaöha Upaniñad 2.2.13). The word cetana means "living." We are living, and God is also living, but He is the supreme living entity. We are the subordinate entities. Our perception is limited, and God's perception is unlimited. It is admitted that everything exists due to God's perception. Many objects exist that are not within our experience or perception. However, God experiences everything. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that He knows everything, past, present, and future (Bg. 7.26). Nothing is beyond His experience.

Çyämasundara däsa: He says that because God experiences all objects, objects are rendered potentially perceptible to human minds.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That's all right, because as we advance in Kåñëa consciousness, we experience objects through God, not directly. That is stated in the Vedas: yasmin vijïäte sarvam evaà vijïätam bhavanti. God experiences all things, and if we receive our experience from God, we are advanced. We are preaching that people should receive their experience, their perception, through Kåñëa. We shouldn't try to speculate because speculation is always imperfect. We are searching after the original source of everything, and Kåñëa says: ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù (Bg. 10.8). Kåñëa is the root of all emanations, of all creation. The conclusion should be that we should receive our experience through God; therefore we accept the experience of the Vedas. The Vedas were spoken by God, and they contain knowledge given by God. The word veda means knowledge, and the knowledge of the Vedas is perfect. The Vedic system is çruti-pramänam. As soon as an experience is corroborated or verified by Vedic statement, it is perfect. There is no need to philosophize. If we can receive perfect knowledge directly from the Vedas, why should we speculate? Why should we take so much unnecessary trouble?

dharmaù svanuñöhitaù puàsäà
viñvaksena-kathäsu yaù
notpädayed yadi ratià
çrama eva hi kevalam

"Duties [dharma] executed by men, regardless of occupation, are only so much labor if they do not provoke attraction for the message of the Supreme Lord." (Bhäg. 1.2.8) My speculation is always imperfect because I am imperfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: There is an inherent tendency in men to want to experience something first hand rather than through someone else.

Çréla Prabhupäda: From the beginning of our lives, we are experiencing things through authority. A child receives experience by asking his parents. A child knows nothing about fire, and he wants to touch it because it is red. However, he receives knowledge from his parents that he shouldn't touch fire. In this way, he comes to understand certain basic laws of nature. The Vedas tell us that in order to know the transcendental science of Kåñëa, we must approach a guru. We cannot speculate about God, the spiritual world, and spiritual life.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley says that the world is real because if it were not real, we could not experience it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also our version. The world is real because it was created by God. But the Mäyävädés say that the world is unreal. Brahma satyaàjagan mithyä.

Çyämasundara däsa: He states that the only way we can know that this table exists is through our senses, but these sense impressions are subtle, not material.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Instead of saying that they are not material, he should say that they are abstract. Abstract is the original position. The Çünyavädés cannot understand the abstract; therefore they say that the abstract is zero, nothing. But the abstract is not nothing.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley says that if this table were composed of matter, we would not be able to experience it because the only objects capable of entering our experience must be sensitive substances.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is nondifferent from everything because everything is Kåñëa. Fools look at the Deity and say, "This is not Kåñëa, this is stone." Because a fool cannot see anything but stone, God appears to him as stone. Unfortunate atheists make these distinctions. They will say, "Everything is Brahman, but not this stone Deity." Or, they will say, "Why go to the temple to worship when God is everywhere?" What they are saying is that God is everywhere, but not in the temple. This means that they have no clear idea. We see that everything has form. Are we to assume that we have form and God hasn't? Impersonalists have no conception of Kåñëa's original form. Kåñëa very kindly and mercifully appears before us so that we can experience Him. Ultimately, there is no distinction between matter and spirit, but because at the present moment I cannot conceive of spiritual form, God appears in the form of the Deity. Kåñëa says:

kleço 'dhikataras teñäm
avyaktäsakta-cetasäm
avyaktähi gatir duùkhaà
dehavadbhir aväpyate

"For those whose minds are attached to the unmanifested, impersonal feature of the Supreme, advancement is very troublesome. To make progress in that discipline is always difficult for those who are embodied." (Bg. 12.5) People are going through unnecessary labor in order to meditate on something impersonal. Because they have no idea of God, they superficially say, "Everything is God." Still, they cannot see God in the temple in His arca-vigraha form. They cannot understand why all the äcäryas like Rämänujäcärya and Madhväcärya have established these temples. Are these äcäryas simply fools? There has been Deity worship since time immemorial. Are all the people who have participated in Deity worship fools?

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley says that spirit is the only genuine substance, that there is no substance that exists without thinking. In other words, there is thinking involved even in objects like this table. This table is made of spirit, and spirit is thinking and thoughtful.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That's nice. His conclusion is that everything is Brahman because thinking is also Brahman. At the present moment, we cannot perceive the spiritual; therefore God, out of His unlimited kindness, comes to us in a small, tangible, concrete form that we can dress, feed, and handle. We cannot say that this form is different from God.

arcye viñëau çilädhér guruñu
nara-matir vaiñëave jäti-buddhiù

"One who considers the arca-mürti or worshipable Deity of Lord Viñëu to be stone, the spiritual master to be an ordinary human being, and a Vaiñëava to belong to a particular caste or creed, is possessed of hellish intelligence and is doomed." (Padma Puräëa) It is horrible to think of these spiritual things in a material way. We should always offer respect and consider that Kåñëa is present. We should not think that the Deity is simply stone and cannot hear or see. There are sixty-four items mentioned in Nectar of Devotion (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu) that guide us in Deity worship.

Hayagréva däsa: In his last dialogue, Berkeley writes: "The apprehension of a distant Deity naturally disposes men to be negligent of their moral actions, which they would be more cautious of in case they thought Him immediately present and acting on their minds without the interposition of matter, or unthinking second causes."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Vedic çästras say that God is everywhere; He is not distant. In Queen Kunté's prayers, it is said that God is both distant and near. God's proximity is manifest in His Paramätmä feature. He is living in everyone's heart. Éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati (Bg. 18.61). If He is within our heart, how can He be distant? At the same time, He is present in His personal feature in Goloka Våndävana, which is far, far beyond this material existence. That is God's all-pervasive quality. Although He is far, far away, He is still very near. The sun may be very far away, but its light is present in my room. Similarly, God is both far away and also within my heart. One who is expert in seeing God sees Him in both ways. Goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhütaù (Brahma-saàhitä 5.37). Although He is living in His own abode, eternally enjoying Himself with His associates, He is still present everywhere. That is God.

Hayagréva däsa: In what way is God concerned with the moral or immoral actions of man? Is God indifferent to them, or has He simply set the laws of nature in motion, allowing men to follow their own course and reap the fruits of their own karma?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because we have disobeyed God, we are thrown into this material world and placed under the supervision of material nature for correction. As long as we are in the material world, there is a distinction between what is moral and immoral. Actually, moral and immoral have no meaning, but in the material world, we have conceptions of them. When we are in the spiritual world, there is no conception of immorality. For instance, the gopés went to see Kåñëa in the dead of night, and ordinarily this is considered immoral, but because they were going to see Kåñëa, it was not immoral. In one sense, in the spiritual world everything is moral. In the material world there is duality in order for the material creation to work properly.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley gives two arguments for the existence of God: first, the things we perceive in our waking state are more vivid than those things we imagine or dream about, and this is because God's mind is activating these things.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We accept that. God is the superior mind, and because God sees, we can see. Because God walks, we can walk. This is also admitted in Brahma-saàhitä: yasya prabhä prabhavato jagadaëòa-koöi (Brahma-saàhitä 5.40). Due to the bodily effulgence of Kåñëa, many universes have come into being. In these universes, there are many varieties, many planets, and on each of the planets are many different living entities. All these varieties are there because they are emanating from Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Secondly, the things we perceive do not obey our wishes as our imaginations do, but resist them because they obey the will of God. God's will is arbitrary, and we cannot predict it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore it is better to always obey the orders of God. If we do what God says, we are perfect. In any case, there is no need for all this speculation. The basic proof of God is God. Kåñëa says, "I am God," and Närada, Vyäsadeva, and Arjuna agree, "Yes, You are God." If we accept Kåñëa as God, we save ourselves much labor. Why speculate? In the causal ocean, the Mahä-viñëu is inhaling and exhaling, and many universes are being manifest and then destroyed by His breathing. When He breathes out, all the universes are created, and when He breathes in, they all return to His body. This entire creation is the dream of God, Mahä-viñëu.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley would maintain that our dreams are imperfect, and when we open our eyes, we see that everything is perfect; therefore there must be a perfect person, a perfect dreamer.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But when we open our eyes and see perfection, that is also dreaming. But the dreaming of the perfect is perfect also. That is absolute. Unless we accept the absolute, how can we say that His dream is perfect? The dream of the absolute is also perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: He also asserts a doctrine of divine arbitrariness. Because God's will is arbitrary, we cannot predict what will happen.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct. Therefore a Vaiñëava says, "If Kåñëa wills, I will do this." He never says, "I will do this." If Kåñëa so desires, a thing will be done. A Vaiñëava always considers himself helpless without God. As far as we are concerned, we are always incapable.

Çyämasundara däsa: Berkeley states that our repeated experience will discern the regular activity or will of God, and that by experiencing nature, we can understand that God's will is regular. In other words, we can come to understand the habits of God by observing the laws of nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä that nature is working under His direction (Bg. 9.10). Nature is not blind. Because it is working under the direction of God, it is perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: He also states that there is no necessary connection between cause and effect, but that things follow one another in sequence in time.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If there is no cause, why does he say that effect follows cause in a sequential order? This is contradictory. The supreme cause is Kåñëa, the cause of all causes. In that sense, we cannot say that there is no cause. The ultimate cause is the supreme, and to Kåñëa there is no difference between cause and effect. Since He is the supreme cause, He affects everything. In the absolute sense, there is no difference between cause and effect.

Çyämasundara däsa: As an example, he would say that a rock falling in the water will not necessarily splash, but that it regularly follows in sequence that it will splash.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But we say that if God does not will this, it will not happen. It is all dependent on the supreme will. It is not necessary for the rock to splash. It is not compulsory. If God so wills, it will simply float. We admit that everything is affected by the will of God; therefore our best course is to depend totally on His will.

DS:David Hume (1711-1776)

David Hume (1711-1776)

Hayagréva däsa: Abstract objects, relations, space, time, and matter are all considered by Hume to be mind-dependent perceptions. For him, perceptions or impressions are all there is. He rejected revealed religion, which he considered dogmatic, and accepted "natural religion" instead, a religion wherein the existence of God can be proved or even shown to be probable by argument and reason. According to Hume, we really know nothing of God; at the most we can know only of people's ideas of God, and these are but perceptions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is that natural religion?

Hayagréva däsa: Hume writes: "The whole course of nature raises one hymn to the praises of its creator. I have found a Deity, and here I stop my enquiry. Let those go further who are wiser or more enterprising."

Çréla Prabhupäda: He admits that the senses are imperfect, and at the same time that there is a God. Now, if our senses are imperfect, how can we imagine God to be like this or that? If God explains Himself, why should we not accept His version?

Hayagréva däsa: In Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, Hume opposes the search for God in the ideal world. He writes: "Why not stop at the material world? How can we satisfy ourselves without going on ad infinitum?...If the material world rests upon a similar ideal world, this ideal world must rest upon some other, and so on without end. It were better, therefore, never to look beyond the present material world. By supposing it to contain the principle of its order within itself, we really assert it to be God, and the sooner we arrive at the divine being, so much the better. When you go one step beyond the mundane system, you only excite an inquisitive humor which it is impossible ever to satisfy."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The material world by definition is full of misery, and those who are advanced therefore search for another world where there is no misery. Everyone is searching for a happy world that is permanent, and that search is not unnatural. There is such a world, and since it exists, why should we not hanker after it? If we look at the world objectively, we can see that no one is really happy—that is, unless he is an animal. Animals do not know what is happiness or distress. They remain satisfied in any condition. A man, however, feels pain more acutely.

Hayagréva däsa: Hume felt that the sooner we find God the better, and therefore he opposed going beyond the mundane system in search of Him.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You cannot find God in your present conditional state. You may glimpse the fact that there is God, but you cannot understand His forms and pastimes by speculation. Therefore revelation is there for those fortunate people who are seriously searching for God. God is living within, and when we are serious, He reveals Himself. It is also possible to learn about God directly from a person who knows God. Bhagavad-gétä is God's direct revelation, and if we try to understand it, we can understand what God is.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume maintains that all that we are, all that we know, is merely a sequence of ideas.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But behind the ideas there must be a fact. Otherwise, how can we have the ideas?

Çyämasundara däsa: He separates facts from ideas. For instance, I may think that this table is red, but I may be wrong; it could be brown.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Your idea may be incorrect, but actually the table has some color, be it red, yellow, or whatever. If you have some eye disease, you cannot determine the color, but one whose eyes are not diseased can tell you. Because our eyes are diseased and we cannot see things properly, we have to receive knowledge from one who is not diseased. Hume is wrong when he says that there is no possibility of attaining right knowledge.

Çyämasundara däsa: He admits that the external world is full of concrete objects, but he thinks that we are also one of those objects because the self is "nothing but a bundle or collection of different perceptions, which succeed each other with inconceivable rapidity and are in a perpetual flux and movement." Our consciousness is composed of only our observations of material nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is so far as direct perception is concerned, but indirect perception is different. It may be taken from authorities.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume distrusts all authority. For him, the only certainty is found in mathematical proofs and immediate sense perceptions. We can perceive that there is time and space, but this is the only knowledge that he will admit.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And beyond time and space?

Çyämasundara däsa: We cannot know anything.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Perhaps you cannot, but there is a process whereby we can know. We cannot say that beyond the mind there is no time or perception. There are insects that are born in the evening and die in the morning, and during that time they experience a lifespan. For a man, this is only twelve hours of life, but the insect cannot live beyond that time. From Bhagavad-gétä we understand that Brahmä lives for many thousands of years, and that compared to him we are like insects. Everything is relative: our lifespan, knowledge, and perception. We are small human beings, and what is impossible for us is not necessarily impossible for others. Hume is talking from the relative platform.

Çyämasundara däsa: He believes that objects are only relative, not that there is anything absolute.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But as soon as he speaks of relative, he posits the existence of the absolute. If there is no absolute, how can we have the conception of an object being relative?

Çyämasundara däsa: He believes that things exist only in relation to one another.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then what is the supreme relation?

Çyämasundara däsa: He doesn't admit one.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to logic, at the end of all relative truths there is Absolute Truth, the summum bonum. But if Hume denies substance, he has no idea of the summum bonum, the ultimate substance.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume says that an object like an apple consists only of certain sensory qualities, like sweetness or color, and that the individual consists of only a series of mental activities, not of a soul capable of creating experiences.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Inert objects have certain qualities, but the living entity possesses senses by which he can appreciate those qualities. He is therefore superior to inert matter. Because the living entity has senses, he can appreciate sense objects. We have eyes with which we can see color and perceive beauty.

Hayagréva däsa: Hume is famous for his skepticism. He rejected revealed scriptures and looked toward science instead.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If he preaches skepticism, why should we believe his words? If he does not believe the statements of others, why should others accept his statements?

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume postulates three laws whereby perceptions are associated or connected with one another. First, according to his principle of resemblance, a picture, for instance, makes us think of the original. Secondly, according to the principle of contiguity, if I mention a room in this building, I think of other rooms also. Third, according to the principle of cause and effect, if I think of a wound, I automatically think of pain. Thus he suggests that our whole being consists of such a stream of ideas and associations, which follow one another perpetually.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is the nature of the relative world. We cannot understand what a father is without understanding what a son is. We cannot conceive of a husband without a wife.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume denies the existence of an ultimate reality, asserting that only the phenomena of the senses exists.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But where do these phenomena come from? If there are phenomena, there must be noumena.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume suggests that it is possible that the world has existed since eternity and that therefore no first cause is required.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what about the manifestation of past, present, and future? Why does death take place if there is no cause?

Çyämasundara däsa: The body is like a machine which is born and dies.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you say machine, you automatically presuppose the beginning of the machine. In other words, the machine must be made by someone.

Çyämasundara däsa: The machines may be like the seasons. They may come and go.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, they may come and go, and then come again, but what is the meaning of this?

Çyämasundara däsa: They may be eternally existing facts without cause or creator. Hume says that we may believe in a creator if we like, but this is based on mere probability, not knowledge. We may think as we like.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, he goes on talking as he likes. In other words, you can speak all kinds of nonsense, and I can too. You are right, and I am right, and everything is right.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume divided human understanding into two categories: relationships among ideas and relationships among facts. The first involves mathematics. Two plus two equals four is true whether it refers to something existing in nature or not. According to the relationships among facts, this is a knowledge to be assumed on the basis of sense experience. According to the information we have based on sense perceptions, we believe that the sun will rise tomorrow. However, there is a possibility that the world will end, and the sun will not rise tomorrow.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why is this so? Who makes this possible or impossible? The sun may rise, or the sun may not rise. Is this accidental, or is this according to someone's will?

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume would say that it is accidental.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nothing is accidental. Everything is symmetrical. According to Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä, everything in nature is working under His direction. The sun rises because God has so ordained it. If God does not ordain it, the sun will not rise. It is not accidental at all.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume denies cause and effect relationships. We associate friction with heat, but he says that it is a mistake to assume that friction causes heat. For him, there is merely a repetition of two incidents. The effect may habitually attend the cause, but it is not necessarily its consequence. There is only association, not cause and effect.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But who made the laws of association? The association may be accidental, but as soon as there is friction, there is heat. This means that in nature there is a systematic law.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume would say that this law is not ultimate reality but mere probability.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nonetheless, there are physical laws. The sequence of these laws may differ because they are created by someone who can change them. A legislature may assemble today and pass a certain law, but tomorrow it may assemble again and nullify that law. Similarly, a supreme will makes these laws, and He can also nullify or change them. As far as you are concerned, when there is friction, there is heat. It is not that we can rub our hands together without experiencing a sensation of heat. This means that we are subject to the supreme will. God gives us a chance to speak all kinds of nonsense, but He can stop us immediately. At any instant, our tongue may be in a dead body. The supreme will gives us the freedom to talk in this way or that, and concoct all kinds of philosophies, but at any moment He can put an end to all of this. Thus the supreme will is the ultimate cause of all causes.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume rejected the idea of absolute matter and the conception of the soul as a substance. He also rejected the utility of scientific laws and moral principles as objective realities. He claims that all religious ideas are relative, maintaining that there is no certainty in religious matters.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Religion means love of God, and there are different religious processes. If we ultimately develop love of God, we have realized the first and most important factor of religion. If love of God is absent, what passes for religion is not really religion. It is simply a show.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume states that even the idea of God is merely probable but not certain.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We do not agree to that. As soon as we speak of authority, we posit the existence of a supreme authority. We call that supreme authority God.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume would say that we would have to accept the authority of our senses.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The senses are imperfect, and God is beyond the senses. We cannot see God, touch Him, or hear Him because our senses are imperfect. A man with imperfect senses says that there is no God, but those who have cleansed their senses can see God, touch Him, and talk with Him.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume denies the existence of miracles.

Çréla Prabhupäda: One thing may be a miracle for one person and not for another. An electric fan may seem like a miracle for a child, but not for his father. So our conception of miracles is also relative.

Hayagréva däsa: On this subject, Hume writes: "All the new discoveries in astronomy, which prove the immense grandeur and magnificence of the works of nature, are so many additional arguments for a Deity, according to the true system of theism." In this way, Hume rejects the necessity or desirability of miracles as well as the conception of a God transcendental to His creation. He states that it is not the being of God that is in question, but God's nature, which cannot be ascertained through study of the universe itself. However, if the universe can only be studied by imperfect senses, what is the value of our conclusion? How can we ever come to know the nature of God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to our Vedic philosophy, the nature of God can be explained by God Himself. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells Arjuna:

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conqueror of wealth, there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7) We accept this as a fact, because it is not possible for anyone to be greater than God. It is God's nature to be the greatest in everything: wealth, fame, power, beauty, knowledge, and renunciation. If we can find one who is garnished with such greatness, we have found God. These qualities are found in Kåñëa, and therefore we accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord.

Hayagréva däsa: In Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, Hume writes: "All religious systems, it is confessed, are subject to great and insuperable difficulties. Each disputant triumphs in his turn, while he carries on an offensive war and exposes the absurdities, barbarities and pernicious tenets of his antagonists. But all of them, on the whole, prepare a complete triumph for the skeptic, who tells them that no system ought ever be embraced....A total suspense of judgement is here our only reasonable recourse."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We do not accept this. We believe that we can know God from God Himself. Religion refers to the principles given by God. If there are no directions given by God, there is no religion. Religion is not a kind of blind faith; it is factual because it is given by God Himself. If you know God and follow His instructions, you are religious.

Hayagréva däsa: Hume did believe that religion is necessary. He says that religion, however corrupted, is still better than no religion at all.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We agree to that, but religion without philosophy and logic is simply sentiment. That will not help us. Real religion is given by Çré Kåñëa.

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi yuktvaivam
ätmänaà mat-paräyaëaù

"Engage your mind always in thinking of Me, offer obeisances and worship Me. Being completely absorbed in Me, surely you will come to Me." (Bg. 9.34) If we always think of God, we will become purified. Religion means meditating upon God and thinking of Him. Therefore temple worship is necessary to facilitate our constantly thinking of God. But if we do not know of God's form, how can we offer Him worship? How can we think of Him? We then have to construct a pseudo religion, and this kind of religion will not help us.

Hayagréva däsa: Hume's conception of religion is utilitarian and social. He writes: "The proper office of religion is to regulate the heart of man, humanize their conduct, infuse the spirit of temperance, order, and obedience...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We also say that religion is the greatest welfare work for all humanity. For instance, religion forbids illicit sex, and if people indulge in illicit sex, society will become chaotic. If we continue eating meat, we revolt against God's will because God is the father of all living entities. When other foods are available, why should we kill animals to eat meat? When there is a wife, why should we have illicit sex? A religious man is necessarily a man of good character. If we are God conscious, all good qualities are automatically manifest. A devotee can sacrifice his own interests because he is a devotee. Others cannot do this.

Hayagréva däsa: Hume felt that one must first be a philosophical skeptic before accepting the revealed truths of religion. Ultimately, he insists that these truths can be accepted only on faith, not experience or reason.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why not on reason? We can use our reason to consider that everything has some proprietor and that it is quite reasonable that this vast universe also has a proprietor. Is there a fault in this logic? Of course, now astronomers are saying that in the beginning there was a chunk, but where did that chunk come from? Where did gas come from? Where did fire come from? There is a proprietor, and He is described in Bhagavad-gétä. Mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù (Bg. 9.10). It is completely illogical to think that there is no universal proprietor.

Hayagréva däsa: As far as we can ascertain, Hume personally had no religion, no faith in the Christian or any other God. He also rejected the contention that argument or reason could justify a faith. He is a skeptic who denies the possibility of attaining certainty outside of a mere sequence of perceptions or ideas.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In other words, all statements are to be rejected except his.

Hayagréva däsa: Well, he claims that man cannot know ultimate reality or possess knowledge of anything beyond a mere awareness of phenomenal, sensory images.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If man cannot possess knowledge, why should we accept Hume's knowledge? It is better to stop the search for knowledge altogether, is it not? Why does Hume bother to write so many books? He is simply trying to set up his own system as supreme. But a skeptic has no foundation for anything.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume says that if we like, we can attribute the order and design of the world to an architect, but as far as he is concerned, there is no proof that a superior architect exists.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If something is artistic and systematic, we must admit that there is some intelligence behind it. We have no other experience. According to our experience, things do not work well without some brain behind them. When we see that the cosmic manifestation is systematic, we must admit that there is a guiding intelligence.

Çyämasundara däsa: He feels that if such an architect exists, he must be responsible for evil in nature. He therefore concludes that God is either finite or imperfect. If He were perfect, there would be no evil, and if He were infinite in power, He could eliminate it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is absolute, and for Him there is no evil. For Him, there is only good, otherwise He could not be called absolute. What we think is evil, is good to God. A father may slap his child, and that child may cry. For the child, this is evil, but for the father, this is good, because he thinks, "I have done right. Although he is crying, he will not commit this same mistake again." Chastisement may sometimes appear evil, but that is relative to our position. Whose opinion are we to take?

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume would say that this means that God is limited.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is nonsense. If God is limited, He cannot be God.

Çyämasundara däsa: The logic is that God must be limited in His goodness to allow evil to exist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is unlimitedly good.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then God must be limited in His power because He cannot eliminate evil.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Evil works under His guidance. God controls both good and evil; therefore He is called the supreme controller. He is not limited in any way. The exact word used in Sanskrit is ananta, unlimited. God is advaitam acyutam anantam: nondual, infallible, and unlimited.

Çyämasundara däsa: Concerning world morality, Hume maintains that morality consists of values formulated by the individual for himself as a matter of personal opinion. Each man may do as his conscience dictates.

Çréla Prabhupäda: One man may say that his conscience dictates this, and another that his conscience dictates something else. Therefore there is no agreement.

Çyämasundara däsa: However, in society, Hume would say that moral values are relative to public opinion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then we have to accept the opinion of the majority. This is democracy.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yet Hume admits that it is up to the individual whether to accept public opinion or reject it. Although the law is there, and society agrees to it, it is still up to the individual to follow it or not.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you do not follow the law, you will be punished by the state. So we can conclude that independent thinking is not absolute. It is also relative.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume would say that it is not logic or reason that determines morality, but sentiment.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We cannot decide what is moral or immoral. Only the supreme will can decide that.

Çyämasundara däsa: It is the sentiment of the individual that decides. A person should act according to the way he feels at the moment, according to his personal opinion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You may be satisfied with your personal opinion, but if it is not approved by others in society, you are living in a fool's paradise.

Çyämasundara däsa: The remedy for this is social. We should try to change the laws or opinions of the state so that they will comply with a certain type of morality. If I think that something is right, but the state says that it is wrong, I should act politically to change it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But public opinion and individual opinion are not final. Above them is the supreme will of Kåñëa, and that ultimately determines what is moral or immoral.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume believed that moral sentiments enhance the social good, whereas immoral attitudes are egotistic and anti-social.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In any case, for him the social body is the authority. Ultimately, we have to depend on some authority for all sanction. We propose that the supreme authority is Kåñëa, and that whatever He sanctions is moral, and whatever He does not sanction is immoral. Arjuna was thinking that it was moral to be nonviolent on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, but Kåñëa told him otherwise. Instead of depending on the social, political, or communal body to determine morality, we should depend on the supreme will of the supreme authority. We maintain that all morality is relative to Kåñëa's sanction. Killing is considered immoral, but because Kåñëa ordered Arjuna to fight, Arjuna's killing was not immoral. When our actions are approved by the supreme authority, we are moral. If our acts are not approved by the supreme authority, we are immoral. Morality and immorality have no fixed position. When something is approved by Kåñëa, it is moral. Thus what is considered immoral may actually be moral, and vice versa, depending on the orders or desires of Kåñëa. In a war, a soldier may kill many human beings and be awarded many medals for this, but if he kills one person when he returns home, he is considered immoral, and he is hanged. Even on the mundane platform, morality and immorality depend on the sanction of the state. The state says, "It is moral that you kill this man because he is an enemy." And the state also says, "If you kill, you will be hanged." In this way, people accept authority. Everything in the universe depends on Kåñëa's will, on His authority. In the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that He comes to reestablish religious principles (Bg. 4.8), but at the conclusion He states that one should reject all religious principles and simply surrender unto Him and accept His order (18.66). This is the confidential teaching of Bhagavad-gétä. In any case, He is the ultimate authority, and surrender unto Him is the ultimate religious principle.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume lays the groundwork for permissiveness in modern society because he leaves it up to the individual to choose a specific ethical attitude. In other words, to do as he pleases.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But this is not possible because no one can do as he pleases. In life, there are many stumbling blocks. A person may propose a certain action, but his proposal may not be practical. We cannot act independently. Otherwise, there will be chaos. There must be some authority.

VIIGERMAN IDEALISM

VIIGERMAN IDEALISM

DS:Immanuel Kant (1724-1804)

Immanuel Kant (1724-1804)

Çyämasundara däsa: In Critique of Pure Reason, Kant asks the fundamental question, "How are a priori synthetic judgments possible?" How can we apprehend the relationship between cause and effect? Where does this facility come from? What is the source of knowledge? He proposes that one knowledge-acquiring process, the transcendental aesthetic, synthesizes sense experience through the concepts of time and space. The mind acts upon sensory perceptions and applies time and space relations to them. Knowledge of time and space is a priori, prior to and independent of sense experience. It is an internal creation of the mind. Even before we sense anything, we have an idea of time and space.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He speaks of the transcendental aesthetic, but we understand the real meaning of transcendental to be beyond the senses—that is, referring to something not in our experience. We have to receive this knowledge from higher authority, paramparä, a source beyond the reach of the material senses. By sense perception, we have no knowledge of the spiritual world, but in Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that there is another nature, a spiritual nature, which is beyond this material nature (Bg. 8.20). We have to understand this through transcendental knowledge; we cannot experience it.

ataù çré-kåñëa-nämädi
na bhaved grähyam indriyaiù
sevonmukhe hi jihvädau
svayam eva sphuraty adaù

"Material senses cannot appreciate Kåñëa's holy name, form, qualities, and pastimes. When a conditioned soul is awakened to Kåñëa consciousness and renders service by using his tongue to chant the Lord's holy name and taste the remnants of the Lord's food, the tongue is purified, and one gradually comes to understand who Kåñëa really is." (Padma Puräëa). The names, qualities, pastimes, and nature of God cannot be understood by these material senses, but if we engage in God's service, they will all be revealed. Vaikuëöha and Goloka Våndävana, Kåñëa's abode, will then be confirmed. These truths are revealed gradually; they are not abruptly understood. Common men cannot understand the meaning of going back to Godhead. They say, "What nonsense is this?" They cannot understand because it is transcendental, beyond the reach of the gross senses. It is revealed knowledge. If one becomes submissive and engages in the service of the Lord and the spiritual master, all these truths will be revealed. No one can mislead a person who receives knowledge through revelation. From Bhagavad-gétä, we understand that there is a transcendental abode, cintämaëi, and we cannot forget this even if offered a great fortune to forget. On the other hand, if we offer a person a million dollars to believe in the transcendental abode, he will not believe in it. Transcendental knowledge is not a matter of speculation. It is received from higher authority. As we progress in bhakti-yoga, these things become clear.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant strongly advocated the right and duty of every man to judge for himself in religious and secular matters. "Have courage to make use of your own intellect" was his motto. He emphasized individual freedom and the ability of man to intuit the truth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Does this mean that whatever anyone does is perfectly right? If we are given that freedom, then anyone can do as he likes.

Hayagréva däsa: At the same time, Kant considered the Bible to be the best vehicle for the instruction of the public in a truly moral religion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he has accepted some authority. Where is his freedom then?

Hayagréva däsa: The individual can intuit truths within, but can be helped from without by scripture.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that we should not be totally independent. We should be dependent on some authority, and that authority should be recognized. Then knowledge is possible. That is Vaiñëavism.

Çyämasundara däsa: Descartes believed that knowledge comes through innate ideas, and Hume opposed this by saying that knowledge comes from sense experience. Kant tries to unify these extremes.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Knowledge comes from purified sense experience. That is sevä. I may see Kåñëa, whereas others may see a stone. This means that my eyes and vision are different.

premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena
santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti
yaàçyämasundaram acintya-guëa-svarüpaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship the primeval Lord, Govinda, who is always seen by the devotee whose eyes are anointed with the pulp of love. He is seen in His eternal form of Çyämasundara situated within the heart of the devotee." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.38) When our eyes are anointed with the ointment of love of God, we can truly see. The same applies to the rest of the senses. Unless our senses are purified, we can neither see nor know.

Çyämasundara däsa: In Critique of Pure Reason, Kant wrote: "Thoughts without content are empty, perceptions without conceptions are blind....Understanding can perceive nothing, the senses can think nothing. Knowledge arises only from their united action."

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you try to understand through the senses, that is called pratyakña. There is knowledge through direct perception, pratyakña, and knowledge received from higher authorities, paro'kña. When we apply our senses and come to the same conclusion, that is anumäna. For instance, a higher authority says that there is a spiritual world. Now, how can we come to this conclusion? Obviously, we have to apply our senses. We can reason, "I am a combination of spirit and matter. That is a fact. However, I cannot see the spirit at the present moment, but I know that there is spirit." If we understand that there is a material world, we can also understand that there is a spiritual world. We can arrive at this conclusion by applying our senses and reason. If a material world is possible, certainly a spiritual world is possible. This is preliminary knowledge. When we see a dead body, we understand that something is missing. We see this with our senses, and from higher authority, from Bhagavad-gétä, we understand that this something that is missing is eternal.

avinäçi tu tad viddhi
yena sarvam idaàtatam
vinäçam avyayasyäsya
na kaçcit kartum arhati

"Know that which pervades the entire body is indestructible. No one is able to destroy the imperishable soul." (Bg. 2.17) That consciousness is spread throughout the body. It is eternal and spiritual. Through our sense experience, we can also understand that the body is constantly changing from the body of a child to that of an old man, and that this consciousness is continuing. Despite the different bodily changes, consciousness is enduring. The basic principles of knowledge are received from higher authorities, just as preliminary mathematical information is given by the teacher when he informs the student that two plus two equals four. God has given us reason, senses, and consciousness, and by applying them, we can arrive at the proper conclusion.

Hayagréva däsa: In Critique of Judgement, Kant writes: "Absolutely no human reason...can hope to understand the production of even a blade of grass by mere mechanical causes. That crude matter should have originally formed itself according to mechanical laws, that life should have sprung from the nature of what is lifeless, that matter should have been able to dispose itself into the form of a self-maintaining purpose—is contradictory to reason."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and therefore we have to learn from an authority, from one who is cognizant and knows things as they are. Matter certainly cannot combine itself without a brain behind it, and that brain is the Supreme Lord, God. It is unreasonable to think that matter automatically combines independent of intelligence to form the sun, moon, and other planets.

Çyämasundara däsa: If we are unable to receive knowledge from a higher authority, is it possible to have it innately inside of us?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Innate knowledge is knowledge that is already there. We say that Kåñëa is the caitya-guru because Kåñëa is within. Kåñëa is everything both inside and outside. Within, He is the Paramätmä, the Supersoul, and outside He is the spiritual master and the çästra, the scripture. Kåñëa is trying to help the conditioned soul in both ways: from within and without. It is therefore said that the spiritual master is the representative of Kåñëa because Kåñëa appears outside as the spiritual master. Inside, He is personally present as Paramätmä.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kant, the second knowledge-attaining process is the transcendental analytic. First, the mind applies the concept of time and space. Then it applies the categories of quantity, cause and effect, quality, modality, and so on.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is all right.

Çyämasundara däsa: The third process is the transcendental dialectic, whereby the human mind seeks to understand everything. But since sensory information is inadequate, the mind tries to go beyond sense experience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How is that?

Çyämasundara däsa: The mind is aware that there is an ultimate reality, a thing in itself, a noumenon, which produces each phenomenon. But because the mind is not equipped to sense this ultimate reality, the mind must forever remain agnostic.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why agnostic? He should go to higher authorities. If we hear a sound on the roof, we may speculate that the sound is this or that, but with our imperfect senses we cannot ascertain what made the sound. But if someone is actually on the roof, he can tell us, "The sound was made by this." Why should we remain satisfied with an agnostic position? We should satisfy ourselves by asking, "Is there someone on the roof?" If someone says, "Yes, I am here," then we can ask him what made the sound. Therefore the Vedas enjoin: tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet (Muëòaka Upaniñad 1.2.12). In order to understand what is beyond the senses, we must approach a spiritual master who can impart information. When we actually want to understand transcendental subjects, we must approach a guru. And what is a guru?

tasmäd guruà prapadyeta
jijïäsuùçreya uttamam
çäbde pare ca niñëätaà
brahmaëy upaçamäçrayam

"Any person who is seriously desirous of achieving real happiness must seek out a bona fide spiritual master and take shelter of him by initiation. A spiritual master must have realized the conclusion of the scriptures by deliberation and arguments and thus be able to convince others of these conclusions. Such great personalities who have taken complete shelter of the Supreme Godhead, leaving aside all material considerations, are to be understood as bona fide spiritual masters." (Bhäg. 11.3.21) A guru is one who is well versed in the Vedic literatures, çruti. And how can we understand that he is? Brahmaëy upaçamäçrayam. One who knows the Vedas forgets everything material and concerns himself only with spirit soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant was just exploring the possibility that although we cannot know ultimate reality by our senses, the mind nevertheless wants to know it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But that is misleading. No one can ascertain the Absolute Truth by mental speculation. That is impossible. The çästras state: panthästu koöi-çata-vatsara-sampragamyaù (Brahma-saàhitä 5.34). Even if we travel at the speed of mind for thousands of years, we cannot find Kåñëa. If this is the case, a man, who lives the utmost for only a hundred years, cannot understand Kåñëa through his material senses. The material attempt will be futile. The Vedas say that the devotee who has received a little grace from Kåñëa's lotus feet can understand Him. Others will speculate for millions of years to no end. Kåñëa can be understood only through the grace of Kåñëa. Because the devotee is engaged in Kåñëa's service, Kåñëa reveals Himself.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant would also say that we cannot experience God through our senses but only through faith and intuitive reason. Speculative reason is unable to attain to a sure or adequate conception of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct: it is not possible to understand God by mental speculation. When God explains Himself, we can understand Him. The devotees can accept the Supreme Personality of Godhead and His instructions, but a nondevotee or atheist, unable to understand, simply speculates. It is not possible for a speculator to reach the vicinity of God. We can understand God only by God's mercy, which is bestowed by a pure devotee surrendered to God. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa explicitly states:

nähaà prakäçaù sarvasya
yoga-mäyä-samävåtaù
müòho 'yaà näbhijänäti
loko mäm ajam avyayam

"I am never manifest to the foolish and unintelligent. For them, I am covered by My eternal creative potency (yoga-mäyä); and so the deluded world knows Me not, who am unborn and infallible." (Bg. 7.25) Revelation means that God opens the curtain for His devotee. The sun is in the sky all the time, but at night it is obscured. By God's mercy, the sun rises in the morning, and everyone can immediately see the light. At night, we may speculate about the sun, but when the sun rises in the morning, we can immediately understand what the sun is.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant maintains that the mental speculators try to reconstruct ultimate reality by applying mundane categories to it. They attempt through the mind to create what they believe to be the real world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: For mental speculators, the real world is nothing more than the negation of this world. This is voidism. In this world, we experience that everything is material. The mental speculator's materialistic thinking induces him to conclude that the spiritual must be the opposite of the material. Since the material has form, the spiritual must be formless, or void. This is typical materialistic thinking. He thinks, "Since this is not truth, the opposite must be truth."

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant says that "the world is my representation." That is, this real world becomes an ideal construction in the mind of man.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We try to construct an ideal world, but we are frustrated here because everything is temporary; therefore we can understand that the ideal must be eternal. No one wants to die; we all want to live. However, this is hopeless because the body is not eternal. Therefore we understand that in the ideal world, the body is eternal.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant acknowledges that there is a design in nature but that man, not being able to know the total design, cannot know for certain whether there is a designer. The design, as man sees it, does not necessarily prove the existence of the designer. His existence can only be intuited.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As soon as we see pottery, we immediately understand that there is a potter. It is impossible for pottery to be made any other way.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant maintains that due to the overwhelming effects of suffering and natural calamities, it is impossible for man to see nature's final end.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nature does not have a final end; nature is only an instrument. If I beat you with a stick, it is I, not the stick, that is beating you. When we receive pains and tribulations from nature, we should understand that nature is an instrument designed by God. Çétoñëa-sukha-duùkheñu (Bg. 12.18). By witnessing the changes of seasons, heat and cold, happiness and distress, we can understand that there is a designer or brain behind the functionings of material nature.

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again." (Bg. 9.10)

Hayagréva däsa: Kant would say that the design can be intuited but not known.

Çréla Prabhupäda: To a foolish man, everything is unknown, but a man in knowledge knows everything from authority, or from direct perception. Some way or other, the knowledge is there. Something is unknown when one doesn't care to know, or doesn't want to receive the knowledge.

Çyämasundara däsa: When man realizes the futility of mental speculation, he attempts to create ideas about the universe which transcend the bounds of experience. For Kant, this is the third stage, the transcendental dialectic. These ideas belong to the realm of pure reason, or transcendental reason, and are not mere fictions. They spring from the very nature of reason itself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We are all seeking eternity. Because we understand that we are eternal souls, we know that this is not our place, and are therefore seeking the eternal world. The spirit soul does not feel comfortable within this material body. This is understood when we conclude that we must return to the spiritual world and attain a spiritual body. Information on how this is done is given in Bhagavad-gétä, wherein Kåñëa says that one who understands Him and develops love for Him attains a spiritual body that will enable him to see God. If we are very anxious to see Kåñëa and full in Kåñëa consciousness, we will be transferred to Kåñëa's abode at the time of death. This is Kåñëa's promise in Bhagavad-gétä.

Çyämasundara däsa: Transcendental reasoning is in man to guide his understanding to clearer and wider knowledge. For instance, the idea of a Supreme Being is a regulative principle of reason because it tells us to view everything in the world as if it proceeded from a necessary cause, the Supreme Being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Supreme Being is the cause of all causes.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant says that it is the natural impulse of pure reason to perceive a total regularity in everything. To arrive at this total synthesis, the mind must suppose that there is a Supreme Being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is confirming the statements of Bhagavad-gétä.

Çyämasundara däsa: He claims that it is impossible to arrive at the ultimate reality by pure reason alone because phenomena are endless.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore he has to accept Kåñëa's assertions. He has to admit that he is puzzled with these various changes in phenomena. As soon as we come to Kåñëa, we find out that Kåñëa is behind the changing phenomena and that the universe is working under His direction. This is the perfect conclusion.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Kant, when we examine material phenomena by our reason, we arrive at certain contradictions called antimonies—that is, two opposing statements regarded to be true.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In Sanskrit, this is called viruddhärtha, words that mean both yes and no.

Çyämasundara däsa: For instance: "The world has a beginning in time, and is enclosed within limits of space." And, "The world has no beginning in time, and no limits in space, but is infinite." As far as reason is concerned, both conclusions are true.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So how is this adjusted? The adjustment is given in Bhagavad-gétä, wherein Kåñëa says that this phenomenal world of materials comes into existence, is annihilated, and then comes again into existence.

avyaktäd vyaktayaù sarväù
prabhavanty ahar-ägame
rätry-ägame praléyante
tatraivävyakta-saàjïake

bhüta-grämaù sa eväyaà
bhütvä bhütvä praléyate
rätry-ägame 'vaçaù pärtha
prabhavaty ahar-ägame

"When Brahmä's day is manifest, this multitude of living entities comes into being, and at the arrival of Brahmä's night they are all annihilated. Again and again the day comes, and this host of beings is active; and again the night falls, O Pärtha, and they are helplessly dissolved." (Bg. 8.18-19)

Çyämasundara däsa: Another antimony of Kant's is: "Every composite substance in the world is made up of simple parts, and nothing whatever exists but the simple, or what is composed out of the simple." And, "No composite thing in the world is made up of simple parts, nor does anything simple exist anywhere in the world."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that the whole world is made of material energy, and this is the simplistic view. Now, there are many component parts of material energy: the mahat-tattva, the pradhäna, the puruña, the twenty-four elements, the five gross elements, eight subtle elements, the senses, the objects of the senses, and so forth. In this way, when we begin to analyze material energy, so many complications arise.

Çyämasundara däsa: Another antimony deals with causal relations: "Causality and conformity with laws of nature are not the only causality from which all the phenomena of the world can be derived. To explain those phenomena, it is necessary to suppose that there is also a free causality." And, "There is no freedom, but all that comes to be in the world takes place entirely in accordance with laws of nature."

Çréla Prabhupäda: He cannot explain the cause because he does not know it. The ultimate cause is Kåñëa, God. Events may seem miraculous because we cannot understand how they are taking place. God's energy is so subtle that it works simply by His will. By His will, all processes in nature take place, but they take place so swiftly that we see them as miracles. Actually, there is no such thing as a miracle; we only see it as a miracle. Kåñëa is floating many planets in space, and this may seem like a miracle, but to Kåñëa it is not. Kåñëa is known as Yogeçvara, the master of all mystic power.

Çyämasundara däsa: Another antimony questions the existence of an Absolute Being: "There exists an absolutely necessary being, which belongs to the world either as a part or as the cause." And, "There nowhere exists an absolutely necessary being, either in the world or outside, as its cause." Thus, according to reason, we can conclude that there is either a God or no God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What reasoning can support the nonexistence of God?

Çyämasundara däsa: We can conclude this by using the senses.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But where do you get your senses?

Çyämasundara däsa: One could say that they are only a combination of matter.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But where does this matter come from?

Çyämasundara däsa: According to material reasoning, one can say that there is no necessary cause.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But we can see that matter is growing, coming into existence like a tree.

Çyämasundara däsa: It may have been eternally existing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How is that? A tree is not eternally existing. This brass pot is not eternally existing. Someone has made it.

Çyämasundara däsa: But the matter itself could have been eternally existing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But we can see that it is not only existing. It is growing. A tree is wood, and wood is matter. How is it growing? Similarly, our material bodies take birth at a certain moment, grow, reproduce, dwindle, and finally vanish. This is the nature of all matter. Everything starts out as a seed and grows from there. Now, where does the seed come from? Kåñëa says, béjaà mäm sarva-bhütänäà. "I am the original seed of all existences." (Bg. 7.10) Therefore Kåñëa is the cause of everything.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant's point is that these antimonies arise from the attempt by reason to apply its categories to the Absolute, the transcendent. But by mundane reasoning alone, we cannot approach the Absolute.

Çréla Prabhupäda: By our reasoning, we can see that everything is growing and that the entire cosmic manifestation must have grown from a source.

Çyämasundara däsa: But this is transcendental reasoning.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, common reason. Everything is growing from a certain source; therefore this material world must have grown from a certain source. It is very simple.

Çyämasundara däsa: But some people can look at the seed of a tree and come to a different conclusion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, we also receive this information from authoritative literature, from the Vedas.

Çyämasundara däsa: Someone can apply material reasoning and arrive at a different conclusion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But is this reasoning proved by experience? Can a man prove that he is born without a father? How did the material body come into existence? How can one deny his father? How can one deny the cause? He cannot because his very existence is depending on some cause.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant is simply saying that whenever we begin to speculate about the Absolute, we run into contradictions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Contradiction is due to imperfect knowledge. Unless we conclude that Kåñëa is the cause of all causes, our knowledge is doomed to be imperfect. Vedic literature says that Kåñëa glanced at material nature and impregnated her. Then so many products developed, including all these categories. Matter and spirit combined to bring this whole cosmic manifestation into existence.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kant, cause and effect relationships are also a priori conceptions, mental creations, like time and space. Prior to sense experience, we have an idea of them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: I take my birth at a certain time, and I die at a certain time. Time is existing before my birth, and it will continue to exist after my death. Similarly with space. This body is temporarily manifest in time, for a certain period considered my lifespan. During that time, I occupy some space, and that is a temporary occupation. Time and space, however, are eternally there. At least, time is eternally there, because space is also born in time.

Çyämasundara däsa: How is that?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We receive information from Çrémad-Bhägavatam that because this material space is also äkäça, it is born of the finer, subtle mind and intelligence. These descriptions are given in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Space is also created.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hume had said that cause and effect are habitual assumptions, that we naturally assume that a certain effect follows a certain cause but that the cause does not necessarily bring about the effect.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We don't agree with that. There cannot be an effect without a cause. Let him prove first that there is an existence without a cause.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, Hume gave the example of a footprint on the beach. Normally we can assume that a human being left the footprint.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why normally assume? If it is actually there, it is a fact.

Çyämasundara däsa: Possibly something else left the footprint. Someone could have made a cast of a foot, or some other possibility may exist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is nonsense. Why should someone make a footprint to mislead you? But even if he does, that is the cause. The cause is that someone came to mislead you.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant would say that when we see something, we intuitively understand the cause and effect relationship.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You may or may not understand what the cause is, but there must be a cause. Without a cause, nothing can happen. People foolishly inquire when or why the living entity fell into material nature, but what is the use of this question? There is certainly a cause, but instead of trying to find out the cause, we should try to treat the disease. Why waste time?

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant concludes that because the mind imposes a priori laws upon nature as both necessary and universal, the mind is creative and does not come into the world a blank slate.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is a fact that the mind is creative. It creates and then rejects. That is the mind's business—saàkalpa-vikalpa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant would say that apart from using the categories of thought—like quantity, quality, cause and effect, and modality—there is only mere guesswork and imperfect dogma. The mind is not satisfied with this partial explanation; it wants to grasp reality in a comprehensive way. The mind wants to know something beyond these categories, and this is the realm of the transcendental dialectic.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This inquisitiveness is actual philosophy. We are searching for the cause of all causes. A thoughtful man is naturally interested in the ultimate cause of everything. That is human nature. It is the mahätmä who searches after the ultimate cause and finds it. The Vedänta-sütra therefore begins with the inquiry: athäto brahma-jijïäsä. "What is the ultimate cause? What is Brahman?" It answers: janmädyasya yataù. "Brahman is the supreme source from whom everything emanates." Unless we go to the supreme source, we cannot be satisfied. Those who approach this source through mental speculation attain the impersonal feature. From this point, they can make further advancement. In Éçopaniñad, there is a prayer petitioning the Supreme:

hiraëmayena pätreëa
satyasyäpihitaà mukham
tat tvaà püñann apävåëu
satya-dharmäya dåñöaye

"O my Lord, sustainer of all that lives, Your real face is covered by Your dazzling effulgence. Please remove that covering and reveal Yourself to Your pure devotee." (Éçopaniñad 15) If we penetrate this impersonal Brahman, we will arrive at Kåñëa, and then be satisfied. Therefore it is stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmäsudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19)

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant says that after the futile attempt to apply categorical analysis to transcendental knowledge, a man attempts to create other ideas about the universe which transcend sense experience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In other words, after failing to attain material knowledge, he attempts to attain transcendental knowledge. What is this?

Çyämasundara däsa: Rather, he fails to understand transcendental knowledge when applying the techniques of material knowledge.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he cannot approach transcendental knowledge with material senses. If this is not possible, how can he hope to form valid ideas about transcendence?

Çyämasundara däsa: Through pure reason.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He admits that the material senses cannot reach transcendence, but he is not clear about the meaning of this pure reason. If the senses are imperfect, and if your reasoning is fed by the senses, your reasoning is also imperfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant maintains that reason can act a priori, separate or independent of the senses, to understand that there is God and a soul.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is possible.

Çyämasundara däsa: In fact, Kant recognizes three ideals of pure reason: the soul, the ultimate world, and God. These ideals transcend the bounds of sensory experience; they are innate and a priori.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also true.

nitya-siddha kåñëa-prema 'sädhya' kabhu naya
çravaëädi-çuddha-citte karaye udaya

"Pure love for Kåñëa is eternally established in the hearts of living entities. It is not something to be gained from another source. When the heart is purified by hearing and chanting, the living entity naturally awakens." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 22.107) It is our natural tendency to offer service to the Lord. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has also said that the living entity is God's eternal servant. The tendency to offer service is natural. Somehow or other, it has been covered by material ignorance.

Çyämasundara däsa: Whereas sense perception cannot provide any information about the soul and God, pure reason can provide us with certain conceptions, but not much more.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We cannot know more by our personal attempt, but these subjects can be known by a process called guru-paramparä. When God speaks, it is possible to know. We hear from God in order to understand what, who, and where He is. In this way, our knowledge is perfect. According to Kant, we cannot attain reality or God through reason and the senses. That is a fact admitted in the Vedas. The word vacanam means "words," and manaù means "mind." We cannot reach the Supreme either by words or the mind.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant suggests that certain knowledge of God's existence would destroy a man's freedom and reduce human experience to a show of puppets frantically attempting to attain the favor of the Almighty. Thus uncertainty is a necessary ingredient for faith.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Faith should not be blind. If it is, it is useless. We may believe in the government, but the government is not dependent on faith. There is a government, and we are under the government's laws and therefore have to obey them. There is no question of faith. Similarly, one who knows God becomes dependent on Him, and that is not faith but fact. The devotee is happy depending on God. He knows that it is foolishness to think himself independent. A child voluntarily depends on his parents and is therefore happy.

Çyämasundara däsa: Since our knowledge is limited to mere phenomena, faith is necessary to acquire knowledge of God, freedom, and immortality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, faith is not a fact but a compromise. It is good that he admits that we cannot approach God ultimately by our senses or reason, but faith alone also is not sufficient, not perfect. Western philosophers have created so many different faiths. One may believe in one faith, and another person in another, but this is faith, not fact. The fact is this: if we are convinced that there is a God and that He is omnipotent, we have to admit that by His omnipotence He can descend into the world. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that He descends into the world for two reasons: to rectify the discrepancies in religion, and to please His devotees who are always anxious to see Him. Some people may say that God is partial, but He is not. God is kind both to His devotees and to the miscreants and demons. When the miscreants are killed by God, they attain immediate salvation, and when the devotees see God, they can understand His actual position. In Våndävana, God displays Himself just as He does in the spiritual world. It is His nature to play with the cowherd boys and dance with the gopés. When the devotees understand this, they become encouraged by knowing that after finishing the material body, they will return to Kåñëa to join in His pastimes. This information is not only understood from the çästras, but is actually demonstrated by Kåñëa. Thus this knowledge is doubly confirmed. When we hear about God and His activities, we can also realize them because God is absolute. There is no difference between seeing Him and hearing about Him. In this way, true knowledge is attained. However expert a logician one may be, it is not possible by reason, logic, or mundane knowledge to approach the Supreme Absolute. It is possible to understand God only when He descends Himself, gives information about Himself, and displays His pastimes.

Çrémad-Bhägavatam is a chronicle of the descents of God. If we try to understand God through Çrémad-Bhägavatam or Bhagavad-gétä, we become a bhägavata. In Bhagavad-gétä, God speaks about Himself and His activities, and Çrémad-Bhägavatam is a record of God's activities and pastimes. The first nine cantos are devoted to the understanding of the transcendental nature of God, and the Tenth Canto is a chronicle of God's activities before the eyes of the people of the world. However, those who are miscreants will think that God is just a famous person, or a superhuman being, and that's all.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning religion and faith, Kant writes: "There is only one (true) religion, but there can be faiths of several kinds. It is therefore more fitting to say, 'This man is of this or that faith (Jewish, Mohammedan, Catholic, Lutheran), than he is of this or that religion.'"

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct. Since religion means obedience to God, it does not refer to some sect. People are trying to understand God in different ways, but these ways are not real religion; they are methods of understanding God. Religion begins when we have understood God and are rendering Him service.

Çyämasundara däsa: In Critique of Practical Reason, Kant affirmed that moral laws are necessary and universal objects of the human will and must be accepted as valid for everyone. We can know what is morally right a priori, by intuition.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Morality is relative. It varies according to the development of a particular society. For instance, there are many immoral acts taking place in modern society, but no one cares. People go ahead and act as they please.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then there is no universal morality?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Universal morality means obeying God. That's all.

Çyämasundara däsa: But are any of God's laws fixed?

Çréla Prabhupäda: All laws are included if you obey God. That is universal morality.

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi satyaà te
pratijäne priyo 'si me

"Always think of Me and become My devotee. Worship Me and offer your homage unto Me. Thus you will come to Me without fail. I promise you this because you are My very dear friend." (Bg. 18.65) This is the basis of morality. We must become Kåñëa's servitor. Since so many immoral activities are being accepted as moral, how else can a person know what is moral and what is not?

Hayagréva däsa: Kant writes: "For a rational but finite being, the only thing possible is an endless progress from the lower to the higher degrees of moral perfection."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that there is an endless struggle to understand real morality. This is not necessary. We need only accept the orders of God and follow them. That is ultimate reality.

Hayagréva däsa: What Kant means by morality is rather vague. He does not give specific outlines for action. Rather, he writes, "The moral individual is to do what is good only because it is good." According to his categorical imperative, man should act in such a way that the maxim of his actions might become the principle for universal law.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But that is impossible for the individual soul. It is impossible for a conditioned living entity to do something that will be universally accepted.

Hayagréva däsa: Then man cannot establish a universal law by his own action?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Only God can do so. Only God can say, sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekam. "Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me." (Bg. 18.66) If an individual conditioned soul says this, who will accept him?

Çyämasundara däsa: But Kant says that there are certain imperatives that we are born with.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What are these? He should say specifically. The only universal imperative is that you should be obedient to God. That's all.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant rejects the traditional proofs of God's existence in order to clear the ground for his assertion that God is morally necessary in a moral universe. In this universe, every soul is an end in itself, and these individual souls are like citizens in a "kingdom of ends."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why does he use the word "kingdom" if he does not accept the king?

Hayagréva däsa: No, he would say that the king is a moral necessity in a moral universe. He simply rejects the traditional proofs.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That's all right, but he sees the individual souls as ends in themselves. There is no question of such independence, because everything is part and parcel of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. God is behind nature, and if our morality denies the existence of God, what is its value? One man may think that animal killing is good, while another may think that it is immoral. So who is correct? There must be some authority to establish morality. Morality must have some background, otherwise it will change at any moment.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant also writes: "It does not enter men's heads that when they fulfill their duty to men (themselves and others), they are, by these very acts, performing God's commands and are therefore in all their actions and abstentions, so far as these concern morality, perpetually in the service of God, and that it is absolutely impossible to serve God directly in any other way "

Çréla Prabhupäda: If man does not serve God, how can he know how to serve humanity? If he does not receive information from God about how to serve humanity, what is the value of his humanitarianism? The best way to serve mankind is to preach this message of Bhagavad-gétä so that everyone can become a faithful servant of God. When we are God's servants, we can render service not only to our fellow man but to all other living entities as well. However, if we manufacture our service, it is useless.

Hayagréva däsa: In the preface to one of his last works, Religion Within the Limits of Reason Alone, Kant seems to shift his position to say that morality "extends itself to the idea of a powerful moral Lawgiver, outside of mankind." Still, he believes that knowledge of God is ultimately uncertain.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is uncertain for one who does not have perfect knowledge. If you believe in God and know God, you can get perfect knowledge from Him. Then you'll become perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Ideally, for Kant, it is the moral obligation of everyone to obey the moral commands.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not moral commands, but the supreme command. As I said, what is moral for you may be immoral for others. One man's food is another's poison. If Kåñëa tells Yudhiñöhira to lie, that lying is moral. Kåñëa tells Arjuna to fight and kill, and that killing is moral. Morality means obeying God's order. Because your senses are imperfect, you cannot create morality. You cannot even know what is moral. Therefore you should follow the orders of Kåñëa or His representative. The real categorical imperative is to obey the Supreme. That is morality, and anything else is immoral.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then we are not born with a priori knowledge of what is right?

Çréla Prabhupäda: A priori in the sense that we know we have to obey Kåñëa. That knowledge is manifest even in uncivilized men. When aborigines see a thunderbolt, they offer prayers. It is natural and inborn to offer obeisances.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant says that it is not the act itself which is good or bad, but the will behind the act.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but that will has to be developed. A child has will, but it has to be developed by his teacher. Everyone in the material world is in ignorance; therefore it is called a place of darkness. The Vedas advise: "Don't remain in darkness. Go to the light." The spiritual world is light. In the material world, since our will is in darkness, it is bound to be imperfect. The will has to be dragged to the light, and that requires superior help. We cannot think, "I am doing this for a good cause; therefore it is good." In this way, people manufacture all kinds of creeds and act in every way. Guidance is required. We must consult a superior authority for confirmation.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant believed that only man can be regarded as nature's own end, or highest product, because on earth only man is capable of complying with the categorical imperative, the moral law.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if nature creates man, then nature is supreme. However, nature is only dull matter.

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

"Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego—all together these eight constitute My separated material energies." (Bg. 7.4) Human beings cannot create these things, nor can nature in itself create them. So how can nature create man? How can man be considered nature's own end or highest product? What is the logic in this philosophy?

Hayagréva däsa: Kant would say that man is nature's final end because man's moral nature alone is worthwhile.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We object to his emphasizing that man is a product of nature. Nature itself cannot make man. Nature provides the body, just as a tailor provides a suit. This body is but the outward covering of the living entity. The living entity within the body is not created by material nature. He is part and parcel of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant says that man belongs to "the kingdom of ends" because man is not just an object of utility but an end in himself. Since he alone possesses self-direction, or dignity, he should never stoop to sell himself like a commodity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And what is that end? Kant does not give any concrete example. Man's dignity is his inherent quality of obedience to the Supreme. It is that obedience that we should not sacrifice. We are not independent, but subordinate to God's will. Kant may be a strict moralist, but that is not the highest platform. We have to transcend even the moral principle to attain perfection. There is morality and immorality in the material world because there are the three modes of material nature operating: goodness, passion, and ignorance. Morality is on the platform of goodness. According to the transcendental, spiritual point of view, the entire material world is condemned. One may be a first-class prisoner, or a second-class prisoner, a brähmaëa or a çüdra. Whatever the case, one is still a conditioned soul. Of course, as far as conditional life is concerned, there is value in morality. Morality may help us come to the transcendental platform, but coming to that platform is not dependent on morality. It is independent of everything. Kåñëa's order is above morality.

Çyämasundara däsa: But might not morality help us see behind the moral law and transcend it?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not necessarily. In Bhagavad-gétä, we find that Arjuna was trying to become moral by not killing his relatives, but that could not help him. Rather, by directly abiding by the orders of Kåñëa, he transcended morality. So morality in itself does not always help.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant spoke of "the starry sky above, and the moral law within." This seems to echo Christ's teaching that "the kingdom of God is within you."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, if you are actually a lover of God and His instructions, the kingdom of God is within.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant proposes that since the moral law cannot possibly be fulfilled within the limits of one lifetime, the soul must be immortal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a very good proposition. That is real evolution. Darwin had no idea of the existence of the soul, and he gave some theories about material evolution, which we do not accept. But there is spiritual evolution. Even though a devotee falls down, what he has earned in devotional service will never be lost. In the next life, he begins from that point. However, as far as material activities are concerned, they vanish with the change of body.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant also proposes that since only God can insure the human endeavor for the supreme good, God's existence is a necessary postulate of practical reason.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have already explained this. Whatever devotional service is rendered in this life is taken up in the next. Who can give the living entity that chance but God? I may forget, but God does not forget. God is Paramätmä. He is within, and He knows what the living entity has done to this point.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kant, the summum bonum is virtue combined with happiness. Happiness is the knowledge of doing what is right.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Happiness means spiritual happiness. There is no material happiness because whatever is material is temporary. Since the spirit soul is eternal, he must have spiritual happiness. That happiness is Kåñëa consciousness. If you know that you are the eternal servant of Kåñëa, and you are serving Kåñëa, that service is your happiness. Even if your duty is painful, you are still happy because you know that you are acting for Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant points out that on earth, happiness does not necessarily accompany goodness; therefore there must be a God who sees that a virtuous man finds his deserved happiness in a future life. Without such justice, there would be no meaning to morality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, in the last mantra of Éçopaniñad, it is stated:

agne naya supathä räye asmän
viçväni deva vayunäni vidvän
yuyodhy asmaj juhuräëam eno
bhüyiñöhäà te nama-uktià vidhema

"O my Lord, powerful as fire, omnipotent One, now I offer You all obeisances, falling on the ground at Your feet. O my Lord, please lead me on the right path to reach You, and, since You know all that I have done in the past, please free me from the reactions to my past sins so that there will be no hindrance to my progress." (Éçopaniñad 18) We should be very sincere in our service to God so that He will relieve us of the reactions of our karma. Unless there is a Supreme, what is the value of morality?

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant would say that in his earthly life, a man should not be motivated toward moral conduct out of any expectation of happiness, but out of a sense of duty, or reverence for the moral law.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that means unmotivated service. It is not that we love Kåñëa just to receive some benefit. It is our duty. That is pure morality. Knowing that we are part and parcel of Kåñëa, we should render service to Kåñëa without ulterior motivation.

Çyämasundara däsa: The goal of Kant's personal ethics is twofold: it is a person's duty to attain his own perfection and also to seek the happiness of others.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is Kåñëa consciousness. A Kåñëa conscious man is not happy thinking, "I have now contacted Kåñëa; therefore my business is finished." Other living entities are also part and parcel of Kåñëa, but due to misguidance, they are not serving Him. Consequently, they are not attaining happiness. It is the duty of one who knows Kåñëa to preach about Him out of mercy. Those who are satisfied just tending to their own personal spiritual life are not as highly elevated as those who try to enlighten others.

Çyämasundara däsa: Pure practical reason, the free will's ability to choose, takes priority over pure speculative reason, or theorizing about reality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is not sufficient to merely understand that there is a God. We must render service to God. Our Kåñëa consciousness movement means applying knowledge of Kåñëa. If you are a devotee, you must demonstrate it. My Guru Mahäräja therefore condemned those who make a show of being devotees and spend all day and night within closed doors chanting Hare Kåñëa. Sometimes such people smoke and have illicit sex because they are not mature in their devotional service. A neophyte should work for Kåñëa; otherwise he will simply be a showbottle. We have to spread Caitanya Mahäprabhu's teachings all over the world.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant concludes that self-realization is superior to mere philosophy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This Kåñëa consciousness movement is a practical demonstration of this. Since we know that we are the eternal servants of Kåñëa, we engage in His service. Kåñëa wants it to be known that He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. We may either accept this or not—that is all right with Kåñëa—but it is our business to inform everyone that Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord and that everyone else is His eternal servant. If we enlighten people in this way, we are engaged in Kåñëa's service. It is not that we go to church and ask God, "Give us our daily bread." God is giving bread daily to everyone, even to birds and beasts; therefore it is not practical to ask God for what He is already supplying. According to our Vaiñëava philosophy, we must work for Kåñëa. We are not just theorizing, but practicing.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant rejected church-going as a means to salvation. He states that "sensuous representation of God is contrary to the command of reason: 'Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image,' etc."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If someone imagines an image, that is not good. An image arises from the imagination. However, it is different to keep a photograph of your beloved. The photograph of your beloved is not imaginary. It is a fact.

Hayagréva däsa: Although rejecting prayer as an inner formal service to God, Kant believed that it is good to teach children to pray so that in their early years they might accustom themselves to a life pleasing to God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Religion means pleasing God, and that is not restricted to children.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the Christian belief in the resurrection of the body, Kant writes: "For who is so fond of his body that he would wish to drag it about with him through all eternity if he could get on without it?"

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is natural to want to retain one's body. Even though his life is abominable, a hog will cry when being captured or killed. He does not consider his body to be undesirable, although he is eating stool and living in a filthy place. It is natural to want to protect one's body perpetually, regardless of one's condition. This tendency is there because the living entity is eternal, and he is hankering after that eternity. It is his mistake to desire this eternity in a material body.

Çyämasundara däsa: In his book Eternal Peace, Kant asserts that there can be peace in the world if certain laws are followed.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We often hear that peace can be attained, but it can be attained only when we understand that Kåñëa is the factual proprietor of everything. We must accept Kåñëa as our friend and understand that we are not the proprietors of anything. We must know that everything belongs to Kåñëa if peace is to reign.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning government, Kant writes: "An ethical commonwealth can be thought of only as a people under divine commands, as a people of God....This would be a commonwealth wherein God would be the Lawgiver."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If the king or president and the people abide by the orders of God, the state will be ideal.

Hayagréva däsa: Kant's state would be theocratic in its constitution; however, since priests receive gifts from God directly, they would construct an aristocratic government.

Çréla Prabhupäda: A theocratic government is properly outlined in Manu-saàhitä, given by Manu for the benefit of all human society.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant believes that there should be a world state in which everyone can participate, and a system of international law regulating relationships between various nations or states.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is also our position, the proposition of the International Society for Kåñëa consciousness. There is one God, and there should be one state. If we can turn the majority of people to Kåñëa consciousness, they will vote for Kåñëa conscious people, and they will not be exploited. The principles that we are following individually can be introduced on a larger scale.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kant believes that the leaders should follow the moral principles, but he rejects Plato's idea that the philosophers should be kings. Rather, they should serve as advisors only. Then they will be able to exercise good judgment.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also the Vedic system. The brähmaëas advise the kñatriyas. If the brähmaëas are empowered and try to administer, their philosophical qualities will be diminished. They should remain free and act only as advisors.

DS:Johann Gottlieb Fichte (1762-1814)

Johann Gottlieb Fichte (1762-1814)

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte is not as important as Kant or Hegel, but he is in the same tradition. He followed pretty much in the footsteps of Kant. In his first work, entitled Our Belief in a Divine Government of the Universe, he writes: "Our belief in a moral world order must be based on the concept of a supersensible world." That is, without the conception of a transcendental reality, morality in the world has no basis.

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, he must define morality. He cannot do this simply by saying, "Our moral principles are...." It is not sufficient to imagine moral principles. Everyone is always saying, "This is moral, and this is immoral." There must be some standard. Following the Vedic scriptures, we say: kåñi-gorakñya-väëijyaà (Bg. 18.44). Cows should be protected. Others claim that cows should be killed in a religious place, in a mosque, synagogue, or whatever. So who is to say what is moral?

Hayagréva däsa: Following Kant, Fichte would emphasize inner reality, intuition, or conscience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Fichte may follow Kant, and I may follow Kåñëa, but if there is a contradiction, who is to decide which is moral? Who is to be our leader? How can we decide? In any case, we cannot avoid following some leader, be this leader Lenin, Kåñëa, Kant, or whoever.

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte would emphasize the use of individual intuition, or conscience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our conscience is determined according to our association. There is no standard conscience. The conscience of a drunkard says that drinking is good, and the conscience of a devotee says that chanting is good. So which are we to follow? We may follow one definition of God, and others may follow another definition. There must be some standard.

dharmaà tu säkñäd bhagavat-praëétaà
na vai vidur åñayo näpi devaù
na siddha-mukhyä asurä manuñyäù
kuto nu vidyädhara-cäraëädayaù

"Real religious principles are enacted by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Although fully situated in the mode of goodness, even the great åñis who occupy the topmost planets cannot ascertain the real religious principles, nor can the demigods or the leaders of Siddhaloka, to say nothing of the asuras, ordinary human beings, Vidyädharas and Cäraëas." (Bhäg. 6.3.19) The definition of God and the orders of God are standard. We cannot manufacture God or morality.

Hayagréva däsa: For Fichte, the world has no objective reality outside of its being an instrument for the enactment of duty. He sees the world of the senses as the "stuff of duty." He writes, "Our world is the centralized material of our duty....It is our duty that is revealed in the world of the senses."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If there is no definition of duty, everyone can manufacture his own. Our standard is given by Lord Kåñëa:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekam çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reaction. Do not fear." (Bg. 18.66) So whatever duties have been manufactured should be given up. It is not necessary to go on speculating, because the instructions are very clear. For our standard, we refer to the Vedas. Çabda-pramäëam. If our actions are approved by Vedic injunctions, they will meet the standard and be perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Fichte believes that the world is a rational unified system directed toward a purpose. It is not a mere machine.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we agree to that. The material world is created for the pastimes of the conditioned soul, just as the spiritual world is manifest for the pastimes of Kåñëa. Those who are eternally liberated and enjoy Kåñëa are called nitya-mukta. The nitya-baddha is a soul conditioned by material nature. These souls, or jévas, are given a chance to play as they like, and they have come here to satisfy their material senses. Ultimately, they should come to their real senses and understand that it is not their business to enjoy material sense objects here but to return home, back to Godhead. This is a good plan, and one who takes advantage of it does not deviate. If one follows the Vedic instructions concerning eating, sleeping, defending, and mating, he can become eligible to return to Godhead very quickly. However, those who manufacture their own way and go against the plan become implicated in karma-bandhana. The word bandhana means "to be implicated."

Çyämasundara däsa: Fichte claims that because the world is a rational system, reason has a very important place. Reason is a real entity or power which performs purposeful acts.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is so. Caitanya Mahäprabhu pointed out that the living entity is the eternal servant of Kåñëa. If he utilizes his reason, he can understand very well what he is doing here. He can understand that he is receiving everything through his senses, and by acting in this way and that, has become a servant of his senses. People cannot master their senses, yet they are prepared to try to master the world, or society. The living entity is not the master, yet he artificially attempts to be master. We attain knowledge when we realize that we are not masters but the eternal servants of Kåñëa. People are trying to serve their senses, their family, their country, society, dog, or whatever. This service is misplaced. By the use of reason, we can come to the understanding that we are eternal servants of Kåñëa. When we abandon the service of the senses, of mäyä, and take to Kåñëa's service, we attain liberation, mukti.

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte believes that true atheism consists in "...refusing to obey the voice of one's conscience until one thinks that one can foresee the success of one's actions and thus elevating one's own judgment above that of God and in making oneself into God. He who wills to do evil in order to produce good is a godless person."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you do not know God or His orders, how can you verify your duty? Do you simply manufacture your duty? Anyone can do that. First of all, you must understand what is meant by duty. Duty means following the orders given by your superior, but if you have no superior, if you have no conception of the Supreme and His order, how can you know your duty? Of course, you may imagine your duty. Is this what he advises?

Hayagréva däsa: He is vague on this point.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because he does not know. According to the Vedas, we have definite, prescribed duties. Society is divided into eight divisions comprising the varëäçrama-dharma. There are four varëas (brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, and çüdra), and four äçramas (brahmacäré, gåhastha, vänaprastha, and sannyäsa). Whatever you do, you must function according to one of these varëas or äçramas, and there are duties prescribed for each. If you follow the principles that are set forth specifically for each stage of life, you are doing your duty.

Hayagréva däsa: For Fichte, our knowledge of God arises from the enactment of our duty.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is all right, but what is our duty? God must assign our duty for us to understand God by enacting our duty. But if we have no conception of God, how can we know what our duty is?

Çyämasundara däsa: For Fichte, self-consciousness is the basic principle of human knowledge and our means for searching out the Absolute.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That self-consciousness should be "I am the eternal servant of Kåñëa." This can be realized by practice, by education, and by study of the Vedas.

Çyämasundara däsa: Fichte believes that the philosopher's search for the truth begins with a demand for fulfillment—that is, "Think thyself!"

Çréla Prabhupäda: We should think, "What am I?" By profound meditation, we can understand, "I am not this body but something else. I am eternal. I existed in the past, I exist now, and I will continue to exist in the future. Whatever I am doing now in the material world is separate and temporary. But what is my eternal duty?" If we understand our position and learn from a spiritual master that we are the eternal servants of Kåñëa, we will take to Kåñëa's service—that is, if we are sensible. In this way, we can attain a higher position.

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte was ambiguous and vague when he wrote of God as a personal being. He seemed to lean toward pantheism or impersonalism.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If he is an impersonalist, he has no understanding of his master, God, who is giving him his duty.

Hayagréva däsa: He looked on the attribution of personality to God as simply a multiplication of oneself in one's own thoughts.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If our understanding of God is only impersonal, where is God's leadership? Is there any question of leadership in impersonalism?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, he feels that if you attribute personality to God, you are projecting yourself onto God—that is, you are manufacturing God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We cannot manufacture God by giving Him imaginary attributes. Whatever attributes we ascribe to Him must be logical. For instance, we say, "God is great" because we have some conception of greatness, and we understand that greatness must be in God, Or we say that God is supremely wealthy, and that also is quite reasonable. We say that God is supreme, and that also logically follows. The attributes of God given by Paräçara Muni—knowledge, fame, wealth, strength, beauty, and renunciation—all combine to give a reasonable definition.

Hayagréva däsa: Like many other impersonalists, Fichte believes that if you attribute personality to God, you necessarily limit Him.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He is thinking that God's personality is finite like his, and that is his mistake. Kåñëa's personality is not like that of an ordinary man. As soon as it was necessary to protect the inhabitants of Våndävana from the torrents of Indra, Kåñëa immediately lifted Govardhana Hill to serve as an umbrella. When He did this, He appeared as a seven-year-old boy. He did not have to meditate for years in order to become God. Presently, rascals are meditating to try to become God, but what kind of God? God is always God. He is the transcendental personality, and there is no need for Him to meditate.

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte rejects the personality of God because he felt that "the concept of God as a separate substance is impossible and contradictory."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since God is everything, there is no question of separation. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

mayä tatam idaà sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

"By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them." (Bg. 9.4) If everything is in God, how can He be separate?

Hayagréva däsa: He rejects God as a separate person.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is everything, why is He not a separate person also? There is no question of rejection. If he admits that God is everything, how can he reject God's personality?

Hayagréva däsa: Since Fichte's pantheism would not admit that God is more than the creation, he would reject the transcendental personality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then he is trying to create God after his own conceptions. But if he admits that God is everything, how can he reject God's transcendental personality? If God is everything, He is that which is transcendental, as well as what is not. Those who follow the Vedas do not reject any part of God. They see God in everything. Éçäväsyam idam sarvaà (Éçopaniñad 1). A real Vaiñëava sees everything related to God. If one thinks, "This is matter, and this is spirit," he is speculating. We have to see God in relation to everything. When we do not, everything becomes material. Materialism means forgetfulness of God.

Hayagréva däsa: Most people, including Fichte, would find it difficult to concentrate on the transcendental personality of Kåñëa, especially when they know nothing about Kåñëa.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It requires a little intelligence and purification. Once the impurities are cleansed from the mirror of the mind, we can understand; otherwise, we think of God as a ordinary person.

änanda-cinmaya-rasa-pratibhävitäbhis
täbhir ya eva nija-rüpatayä kaläbhiù
goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhüto
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who resides in His own realm, Goloka, with Rädhä, who resembles His own spiritual figure and who embodies the ecstatic potency [hlädiné]. Their companions are Her confidantes, who embody extensions of Her bodily form and who are imbued and permeated with ever-blissful spiritual rasa." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.37) God is a person living in Goloka Våndävana, dancing with the gopés, and playing with the cowherd boys. Despite this, God is everywhere. It is not that because He is dancing, He has no time to go anywhere. Although He dances in Goloka Våndävana, He is still present everywhere. Éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd-deçe. "The Supreme Lord is in everyone's heart." (Bg. 18.61) By His inconceivable potencies, God can be in one place and everywhere else simultaneously. This is the philosophy of acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva—simultaneously, inconceivably one with the creation and different from it.

Hayagréva däsa: Although an impersonalist, Fichte is certainly not an inactivist. In The Vocation of Man, he writes: "Not merely to know, but according to thy knowledge to do, is thy vocation—Not for idle contemplation of thyself, not for brooding over devout sensations—no, for action art thou here; thine action, and thine action alone, determines thy worth."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and that is also the philosophy of our Kåñëa consciousness movement, which maintains that we are meant for rendering daily service to Kåñëa. We do not believe that you should simply sit down, smoke cigarettes, and speculate on God. What will be the use of such speculation? We advocate a practical life of action devoted to Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: In this, Fichte seems closer to Vaiñëavism than most impersonalists, who advocate inaction and meditation on the void. At the same time, how can you act without directing your action toward some person or specific goal?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Even in India, the impersonalists have some activities. Çaìkaräcärya gives many vairägya instructions, which are more difficult to perform than the Vaiñëava instructions. As far as Vaiñëavism is concerned, Caitanya Mahäprabhu taught through His personal example that there is no time for inactivity. We should not sit idly and gossip about God or imagine what He is like. Both personalists and impersonalists are fully engaged: the impersonalists in reading Vedänta-sütra, and the personalists in rendering service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Çyämasundara däsa: Fichte says that in order to understand reality, reason must follow a process called the dialectical method, which involves thesis, antithesis, and synthesis. First comes the thesis, which fails to provide an adequate solution; this gives rise to an antithesis, the opposite, which is also inadequate; the dilemma is resolved by combining the two into a synthesis.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The thesis is that I am trying to be master of this material world. The antithesis is that my spiritual master informs me that I am the eternal servant of God. The synthesis is that I become master and servant simultaneously, because by serving Kåñëa, I master my senses.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Fichte, the thesis is the ego; the antithesis is the non-ego; and the synthesis is the unification of ego and non-ego.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The ego arises when I think, "I am the monarch of all I survey." The antithesis is, "I am not the monarch but the servant of my senses." Through the synthesis, I become a servant of Kåñëa and simultaneously a master of the senses, a svämé, or gosvämé.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Fichte, this dialectical process is endless, for each synthesis in turn becomes a new thesis, etc. However, the ultimate synthesis is the Absolute, or God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is explained in Bhagavad-gétä that those who attempt to attain God in this way, through the process of mental speculation, eventually attain God, but only after many lives. However, one who is intelligent immediately surrenders when he understands God to say, "Just surrender unto Me." This saves time. You can come to the ultimate synthesis, God, by immediately surrendering. If you can perfect your life immediately, why perpetuate this process?

Çyämasundara däsa: Fichte states that the original thesis, or the starting point, is the person and his consciousness, the ego. The antithesis is the object of consciousness, phenomena, the non-ego. The synthesis arises with the unification of the subject-object.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Vedas admit that there is direct knowledge, then knowledge received from authority. These combine to form transcendental, spiritual knowledge. At present, our ego is false because we are thinking, "I am matter. I am this body." When we come to real knowledge, we understand that we are spirit soul. This is our true identity. The function of the individual spirit soul is to eternally serve the supreme spirit soul, Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Fichte, ultimate reality is the moral ego. This is the pure will, active reason, or the good.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, God is also the ego. We say, "I am," and God also says, "I am." However, God's "I am" is superior to ours. He is the eternal primal living force. We are also eternal living force, but we are subordinate.

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte considered faith to be the real basis of action. He felt that knowledge in itself was insufficient.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, faith must be there. We see faith exhibited even amongst the lower species. We see cygnets following their mother swan into the water to swim and play. Faith is quite natural.

Hayagréva däsa: In Kåñëa consciousness, does faith or knowledge serve as the basis for action?

Çréla Prabhupäda: In the last chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells us to abandon everything and just surrender unto Him (Bg. 18.66). Now this requires full faith. If we speculate about this, we do not have faith. In Caitanya-caritämåta, faith is described:

çraddhä'-çabde—viçväsa kahe sudåòha niçcaya
kåñëe bhakti kaile sarva-karma kåta haya

"By rendering transcendental loving service to Kåñëa, one automatically performs all subsidiary activities. This confident, firm faith, favorable to the discharge of devotional service, is called çraddhä." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 22.62) Faith means believing firmly. If we have firm faith, we will become perfect by surrendering unto Kåñëa. If we still have reservations, we cannot have firm faith. We may then ask how this faith comes to be, and to this, Bhagavad-gétä answers:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmäsudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19) This faith, therefore, is not very easily come by. Piety is also required of a candidate. Kåñëa appeared on the battlefield of Kurukñetra five thousand years ago, and Bhagavad-gétä has recently been studied by many people like Gandhi, Dr. Radhakrishnan, Vivekananda, and Aurovinda. But where is their faith? They have taken advantage of Bhagavad-gétä by interpreting it according to their own pleasure. They have never taught complete surrender unto Kåñëa. That requires firm faith in Kåñëa. In any case, in this Kåñëa consciousness movement, we are teaching our students how to capture Kåñëa through firm faith. There are many faithless people, including yogés and svämés, who are commenting on Bhagavad-gétä, but this is useless. In the beginning, there must be firm faith. Faith is the foundation. If the foundation is lost, how can a big building stand?

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte believes that faith is innate in all men. He writes: "So has it been with all men who have ever seen the light of the world. Without being conscious of it, they apprehend all the reality which has an existence for them through faith alone. This faith forces itself on them simultaneously with their existence. It is born with them. How could it be otherwise?"

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and this faith is also strengthened by experience. For instance, in the world we understand that everything has some proprietor. Since this is the case, why shouldn't the entire cosmic manifestation have a proprietor? We may not see the proprietor, but we accept His existence on faith.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the infallibility of conscience, Fichte writes: "This voice of my conscience announces to me precisely what I ought to do, and what leave undone, in every particular situation of life....To listen to it, to obey honestly and unreservedly...is my true vocation, the whole end and purpose of my existence."

Çréla Prabhupäda: As soon as he says that he listens, he indicates that someone is speaking. That someone is God situated in everyone's heart and dictating. This is explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà
håd-deçe'rjuna tiñöhati
bhrämayan sarva-bhütäni
yanträruòhäni mäyayä

"The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart, O Arjuna, and is directing the wanderings of all living entities, who are seated as on a machine, made of the material energy." (Bg. 18.61) Thus God is dictating to everyone. He is telling the thief, "You may go out and steal, but this is not good. If you are arrested, you'll be punished." That dictation is there, and if one disobeys and goes ahead and steals, he commits sin. God is there giving dictations within, the heart, and we may either obey or disobey. If we obey, we become devotees. As I said before, the dictations come from the heart, and also from the scriptures and the spiritual master. If we regularly disobey, how can we be happy?

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte is typical of the impersonalist in his desire to merge into what he calls "the universal Ego." He feels that this should be our ultimate goal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In this material world, we all have some ego. We think, "I am the husband of this woman, I am the head of this family, I am the president of this state, and so on." These are different manifestations of ego. However, we cannot say, "I am the master of this entire universe. I am the universal ego." That is also called false ego.

Hayagréva däsa: Fichte thinks that we can go through the universe embracing and assimilating everything until we finally unify with the impersonal Absolute.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As soon as we speak of "Absolute," there is no distinction between the impersonal and the personal. If there is a distinction, you are not referring to the Absolute. It is contradictory to speak of the "impersonal Absolute."

Hayagréva däsa: More precisely, Fichte would consider the original thesis to be one's own consciousness, or ego; the antithesis to be the object of consciousness, sense phenomena, or the non-ego; and the synthesis to be the unification of these opposites.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He is distinguishing between the ego and non-ego, and between the personal and the impersonal, but in the Absolute, there are no such distinctions.

vadanti tat tattva-vidas
tattvaà yaj jïänam advayam
brahmeti paramätmeti
bhagavän iti çabdyate

"Learned transcendentalists who know the Absolute Truth call this non-dual substance Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagävan." (Bhäg. 1.2.11) In the Absolute, there is no duality. When we search for the Absolute Truth, we may realize it in three different aspects: as Brahman, as Paramätmä, and as Bhagävan. Depending on our relationship to the Absolute, the Absolute appears in different ways, but this is not due to some inconsistency in the Absolute. The Absolute is always one, but due to our relative position, we see the Absolute as the impersonal all-pervading Brahman, as the localized Supersoul, or as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Bhagävan. Ultimately, the Absolute is Bhagävan, and the impersonal feature is resting on Him. Brahmaëo hi pratiñöhäham. "I am the basis of the impersonal Brahman." (Bg. 14.27) We may attempt to merge with the impersonal aspect, Brahman, but our position will not be permanent. As for merging or unifying with the Absolute Supreme Personality of Godhead, Bhagävan, this is not possible. It is not possible for the finite living entity to become the infinite God.

DS:George Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831)

George Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831)

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel sought to synthesize other philosophies to arrive at the truth, and in so doing, he concluded that everything that exists is reason; what is real is rational, and what is rational is real.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he wanted to arrive at the Absolute in whom there is no duality. That is Kåñëa. Kåñëa says:

pariträëäya sädhünäà
vinäçäya ca duñkåtäm
dharma-saàsthäpanärthäya
sambhavämi yuge yuge

"In order to deliver the pious and to annihilate the miscreants, as well as to reestablish the principles of religion, I advent Myself millennium after millennium." (Bg. 4.8) He comes to earth to protect the devotees and kill the demons. Although He actually did this, we should not think that He is partial. When He killed the great demon Pütanä, for instance, Pütanä attained a position like Kåñëa's mother Yaçodä. Because Kåñëa is Absolute, there is no difference between His loving Yaçodä and killing Pütanä. Whatever He does is good: be it killing or loving. The two opposites are reconciled in Him. The Sanskrit word for this is viruddärtha-sambandha.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel saw that his predecessors had become so increasingly abstract in trying to find out the nature of substance, that they had reduced substance to nothingness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This was due to ignorance. That is called virasa. When one cannot understand the nature or form of God through speculation, out of frustration he says, "Oh, there is no God."

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel's predecessors analyzed an object into smaller and smaller parts until they arrived at a nonentity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The fact is that the Absolute cannot be divided into parts. In Bhagavad-gétä it is stated:

nainaà chindanti çasträëi
nainaà dahati pävakaù
na cainaà kledayanty äpo
na çoñayati märutaù

"The soul can never be cut into pieces by any weapon, nor can he be burned by fire, nor moistened by water, nor withered by the wind." (Bg. 2.23) It is possible to cut a material thing into pieces, but it is impossible to divide a spiritual being. A spiritual being is inexhaustible. The Mäyävädés think that since the Absolute is all-pervading, He has no form, but this is incorrect. The Absolute can maintain His form as He is and yet expand Himself. Kåñëa says, mayä tatam idam sarvaà jagad avyakta-mürtinä. "By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded." (Bg. 9.4) Kåñëa has three features: brahmeti paramätmeti bhagavän iti çabdyate (Bhäg. 1.2.11)—the impersonal, localized, and personal. Unless we come to understand this science, it is very difficult to know the forms of the Absolute Truth. One who is incompetent, who has a poor fund of knowledge, concludes that the Absolute Truth is niräkära, void, but this is not so.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel wanted to reverse the trend from abstraction to concretion. He believed that every phenomenal object has its relationship with the whole, which is reality. To understand reality, we must examine all objects and relate them to the whole and to each other.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is our process. The whole is Kåñëa, and everything is related to Kåñëa. Because we see everything related to Kåñëa, we do not artificially renounce anything, but try to utilize everything in the service of Kåñëa. Although the Mäyävädé philosophers say that everything is Brahman, their process is neti-neti: "Not this, not that." In this way, the Mäyävädés say that Kåñëa and His worship are also mäyä. Our philosophy is that everything is a manifestation of Kåñëa's energy; the energy and the energetic are one. Närada explained:

idaà hi viçvaà bhagavän ivetaro
yato jagat-sthäna-nirodha-sambhaväù
tad dhi svayaà veda bhaväàs tathäpi te
prädeça-mätraà bhavataù pradarçitam

"The Supreme Lord Personality of Godhead is Himself this cosmos, and still He is aloof from it. From Him only has this cosmic manifestation emanated, in Him it rests, and unto Him it enters after annihilation. Your good self knows all about this. I have given only a synopsis." (Bhäg. 1.5.20) The whole universe is Bhagävan, Kåñëa, but it appears to be separate. How it is not separate can be understood through Kåñëa consciousness. Ordinary men think of Kåñëa and non-Kåñëa, but there is no non-Kåñëa. That is illusion. Everything is Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, nothing can be separated from the spiritual whole because everything is related to it. For Kant, phenomenon is the mode in which things-in-themselves represent themselves to the individual.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is explained in Bhagavad-gétä that Kåñëa has two energies: the spiritual and the material. His spiritual energy is described as superior, and His material energy as inferior. These designations are given for our consideration because we cannot understand otherwise, but the fact is that there is only one energy: the superior spiritual energy. When this spiritual energy is covered by ignorance, it is called material energy. The sky is naturally clear, and we can normally see the sun, but when there are clouds, we cannot see it. Still, the sun is there. When we cannot see Kåñëa or understand Him, we experience what is called the material energy. The fact is that there is nothing material because everything is Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel says that objects themselves are the spirit expressing itself in objective nature, whereas Kant maintains that the spirit expresses itself through objects. There is a distinction made between the spirit within the object expressing itself, and the spirit as the object.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The object as it is is spirit. In one sense, the sunshine is not the sun, but at the same time, it is not different from the sun because it is the sun's heat and light. Therefore our philosophy is acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva: simultaneously one and different. All these objects are actually spirit, but if we have no sense of Kåñëa, we consider them to be material. Sometimes people criticize us for using material devices like dictaphones, typewriters, and airplanes, but we reply that these things are spiritual. If they are used for our sense gratification, they are material, but if used in relation to Kåñëa, they are spiritual. It is the consciousness that is important. Rüpa Gosvämé says:

anäsaktasya viñayän
yathärham upayuïjataù
nirbandhaù kåñëa-sambandhe
yuktaà vairägyam ucyate

präpaïcikatayä buddhyä
hari-sambandhi-vastunaù
mumukñubhiù parityägo
vairägyaà phalgu kathyate

"One is said to be situated in the fully renounced order of life if he lives in accordance with Kåñëa consciousness. He should be without attachment for sense gratification and should accept only what is necessary for the upkeep of the body. On the other hand, one who renounces things which could be used in the service of Kåñëa, under the pretext that such things are material, does not practice complete renunciation." (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.2.255-256) Everything has its relationship with Kåñëa. Rejecting everything as false is artificial renunciation. Our method is to renounce things for our sense gratification, but accept everything for Kåñëa's satisfaction. Kåñëa says:

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman." (Bg. 14.26) As soon as we engage fully in devotional service, we are immediately spiritualized. When we are in devotional service, the spiritual quality of everything is revived. In truth, everything is spirit, but it is covered by our material consciousness, just as gold may be covered by mud. If we cleanse the heart, we immediately understand that things are spiritual. In material consciousness, we conceive of ourselves as Americans, Indians, men, women, and so on, but when we come to our spiritual consciousness, we realize, "I am Kåñëa's servant." Thus we understand that we are spiritual. These material conceptions are like dreams. When we are dreaming, we may think that we are this or that, or that we are performing so many acts, but when we awake, we understand our real identity. Because we are part and parcel of Kåñëa, we have no duty other than to serve Kåñëa. When this consciousness comes, everything is spiritual.

Hayagréva däsa: In Philosophy of Religion, Hegel writes: "God is a living God, who is acting and working. Religion is a product of the divine spirit; it is not a discovery of man, but a work of divine operation and creation in Him (God)."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is very important to understand that a man cannot manufacture religion. We define religion as "the orders given by God." As stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

yadä yadä hi dharmasya
glänir bhavati bhärata
abhyutthänam adharmasya
tadätmänaà såjämy aham

pariträëäya sädhünäà
vinäçäya ca duñkåtäm
dharma-saàsthäpanärthäya
sambhavämi yuge yuge

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time, I descend Myself. In order to deliver the pious and to annihilate the miscreants, as well as to reestablish the principles of religion, I appear Myself millennium after millennium." (Bg. 4.7-8) This is religion. Religion rests on the orders of Kåñëa, or God, and if you strictly follow Kåñëa's instructions, you are religious, pious, and transcendental. If you defy Kåñëa and manufacture your own religion, you are asuric, demoniac.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Plato's and Kant's philosophy, these temporary objects are representations of an ideal. This table, for instance, represents or expresses the ideal table, but it is not the ideal itself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We also say that this material world is a perverted reflection of the spiritual world. It is like a mirage. Çrédhara Svämé said that it is due to the actuality of the spiritual world that this illusory world appears to be true. Because there is in reality a real table, we can perceive this table. Although the entire material creation is but a perverted reflection of the reality, people are enamored by it. People take this to be a real table, a real body, a real society, real happiness, and so on.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel would say that these are genuine externalizations of the reality, that this is a real table and that these are real objects. It is not that they are images of the real, but that they themselves are real.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he mean by real? For us, reality means that which does and will exist. If this is not the case, it is not real.

näsato vidyate bhävo
näbhävo vidyate sataù
ubhayor api dåñöo 'ntas
tv anayos tattva-darçibhiù

"Those who are seers of the truth have concluded that of the nonexistent there is no endurance, and of the existent there is no cessation. This seers have concluded by studying the nature of both." (Bg. 2.16) Reality refers to that which exists eternally. This table exists temporarily; therefore it cannot be classified as reality. It is like a dream or hallucination because it is temporary. We cannot say that a dream is real, although in a dream everything appears to be real.

Çyämasundara däsa: But isn't there a table on the spiritual platform? An absolute table?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, in Kåñëa's abode there are tables, chairs, all kinds of furniture eternally existing. But these things are manifest here only temporarily.

Çyämasundara däsa: Which is correct? Does the spirit express itself in this object, or is it that the spirit is this object?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The object is an expression of the spiritual energy. Whatever is manifest is the energy of Kåñëa, but one energy is eternal, and another energy is temporary. That which is manifest temporarily is material, and that which is manifest eternally is spiritual.

Çyämasundara däsa: So, in that sense, can you say that this table is made of spirit, but at the same time is not?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Originally, it is made of spirit in the sense that Kåñëa is the whole spirit, and because it is Kåñëa's energy, it is factually Kåñëa. You may make various images out of clay. You may mold pots and bricks, and they may be manifest temporarily as pots and bricks, but originally they are clay, and when they are destroyed, they will again merge into their original condition. There are three conditions: the formless condition, the form, and again a merging into the formless. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Kåñëa tells Lord Brahmä:

aham eväsam evägre
nänyad yat sad-asat param
paçcäd ahaà yad etac ca
yo 'vaçiñyeta so 'smy aham

"It is I, the Personality of Godhead, who was existing before the creation when there was nothing but Myself. Nor was there the material nature, the cause of this creation. That which you see now is also I, the Personality of Godhead, and after annihilation what remains will also be I, the Personality of Godhead." (Bhäg. 2.9.33) So, Kåñëa existed in the beginning of the creation; He maintains the creation; and when the creation is annihilated, He continues to exist.

Çyämasundara däsa: Therefore the Mäyävädés would say that this table is mäyä?

Çréla Prabhupäda: They say that it is mäyä, but we say that it is temporary.

Çyämasundara däsa: But there's also a spiritual world full of form?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but the Mäyävädés do not know of this. What is the source of these forms? The Vedänta-sütra states: janmädy asya. Form comes from the original source. These forms that we see here are not eternal forms. They are imitations, perverted reflections of eternal forms. A reflection is not eternal.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel says that these forms are not eternal but that the interaction of forms is an eternal process.

Çréla Prabhupäda: A mirage is neither factual nor eternal, but there is factual and eternal water. Otherwise, how could anyone have a conception of water?

Çyämasundara däsa: But if the universe is rational and everything has a purpose, this temporary form is also spiritual because it has some kind of purpose.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we are utilizing everything for Kåñëa's purpose. Our proposal is to make the best use of a bad bargain.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what if a person doesn't know the purpose? Is the object still spiritual?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Whether a person knows or does not know, fact is fact. We have only to receive knowledge from one who knows. All objects are spiritual, but one who does not have knowledge does not have the eyes to see that spirituality.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then, is God's plan unfolding itself everywhere, whether we understand it or not?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, He reveals Himself in Bhagavad-gétä, and He sends His representative to unfold His plan. The essence of things is spiritual, but our imperfect vision makes things material.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel believes that everything has a purpose, that the whole universe is rational, and that it is unfolding under the direction of reason, the spirit of the Absolute.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly. Only rascals think that there is no purpose in life, that everything is a result of chance.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, in order to understand this reality, we must examine the interrelationships of things.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We are also teaching that. The origin of everything is Kåñëa, and Kåñëa's energetic expansions constitute everything.

parasya brahmaëaù säkñäj
jäta-vedo 'si havyaväö
devänäà puruñäìgänäà
yajïena puruñaà yajeti

"O fire-god, you are a part of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Hari, and you carry to Him all the offerings of sacrifices. Therefore we request you to offer to Him the sacrificial ingredients we are offering the demigods, for the Lord is the real enjoyer." (Bhäg. 5.20.17) Physical existence is heat and light, and these energies emanate from Kåñëa, the original light. Everything material and spiritual is composed of heat and light. One who has eyes to see that which is spiritual can see.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel attempted to establish the relationship between concrete realities. Isolated facts, or moments, as he calls them, can never constitute the truth because the truth is the whole, an integrated unity that is organic and dynamic.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Just by analyzing ourselves, we can understand that I, the soul, am existing and that my bodily features are changing. When things change, we call them material. The spirit soul exists in all conditions, and that is the difference between spirit and matter.

Çyämasundara däsa: Moments, factors in the organic whole, progress in an evolutionary way according to the course set by reason, which Hegel calls the Welt Geist, the World Spirit.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That World Spirit is a person. Unless you accept a personal God, there is no question of reason. The reason guiding everything in the universe is explained in Bhagavad-gétä: mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù. "This material nature is working under My direction." (Bg. 9.10) Direction means reason; therefore as soon as you speak of reason, you must accept the Supreme Person who is directing everything according to His supreme reason.

Çyämasundara däsa: Would you say that all world events are expressions of this World Spirit, or world reason, unfolding itself? If so, what is the ultimate purpose of that plan?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, there is a plan, otherwise why would Kåñëa say adhyakñeëa, superintendence? There is a plan, direction, and also reason. The living entities are part and parcel of Kåñëa, and somehow or other they wanted to enjoy this material world. Therefore Kåñëa has given them a chance, just as a father gives a chance to his small children to play. Kåñëa says:

sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöo
mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca

"I am seated in everyone's heart, and from Me come remembrance, knowledge, and forgetfulness." (Bg. 15.15) The whole plan is that Kåñëa gives the living entity freedom to play and then again come home. He says, "All right, you want to play, but when you are tired of all this nonsense, give it up and come back to Me." This world is like a playground for conditioned souls, and the body is like a small field (kñetra) on which the living entity wants to play.

idaà çaréraà kaunteya
kñetram ity abhidhéyate
etad yo vetti taà prähuù
kñetra-jïa iti tad-vidaù

"This body, O son of Kunté, is called the field, and one who knows this body is called the knower of the field." (Bg. 13.2) The material body is nothing but a field of action, and Kåñëa says, "All right, utilize this field and enjoy yourself. When you are exhausted playing in this field, you can have another." In this way, the living entity is changing bodies, changing different fields of action.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is this play aimless, or is there gradual evolution?

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is a goal. Kåñëa gives us knowledge, and the Vedas are also there. Kåñëa says, "This play is not very healthy; therefore I request that you give it up and come back to Me." This is the plan.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to the Hegelian dialectic, being and nothing are empty abstractions. Being is the thesis, nothing is the antithesis, and the synthesis is change, becoming.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The question of becoming arises because we are now in this awkward, marginal position. Although I am eternal, I have been trapped by something mortal. Consequently, I am changing my position, and this is called transmigration. When I cease transmigrating, I attain my own true being, which is eternal.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel believes that when the dialectic is exhausted, it reveals the whole, unified Absolute Truth. But since nature is constantly unfolding, guided by the World Spirit, the dialectic process continues indefinitely.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In other words, you cannot find out the ultimate synthesis. Therefore you have to receive information from çästra. The thesis is that the soul within the body is immortal, and the antithesis is that the body is mortal. The liberation of the soul from the body is the synthesis. When we understand that we are in an awkward position within this material world, we strive for liberation. Unless we understand that we are entrapped, there is no question of liberation.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel understood the Absolute Truth to be always changing and yet always permanent.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Absolute does not change. Even we are permanent. Being part and parcel of Kåñëa, we are permanent even though we are moving about in these material bodies. Although Kåñëa manifests Himself in various expansions, He remains the same.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel saw the Absolute Truth unfolding itself in history, biology, sociology, and other sciences.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is in the center of everything, and everything is emanating from Kåñëa. Temporary manifestations come from Kåñëa and then return to Kåñëa. History is simply repetition.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, God, or the Absolute Truth, manifests in three forms: the idea-in-itself, the idea-for-itself, and the idea-in-and-for-itself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he is trying to create God. For him, God is an idea. Is this his philosophy? The Mäyävädés also believe that actually there is no God, that God is created by man's imagination, that He is impersonal or dead. So many people are busy creating God. Vivekananda, for instance, claimed Ramakrishna to be God.

Hayagréva däsa: In maintaining that God's essence is "thought and thinking"—despite whatever images God may assume—Hegel is basically an impersonalist. He writes: "God is in His very essence thought and thinking, however His image and configuration be determined otherwise."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is Absolute, His image is also Absolute and also God. If God is Absolute, His words are also Absolute and are non-different from Him. The image of God worshipped in the temple is God Himself because God is Absolute. God says that earth, water, fire, and everything else is His energy, and even if we think that the image of God is made of stone, we must acknowledge that the stone is God's energy. Even though a copper wire may not be electricity, it carries electricity, and if you touch it, you will understand it to be nondifferent from electricity. We may think materially that an object is different from God, but spiritually, everything is God.

arcye viñëau çilädhér guruñu
nara-matir vaiñëave jäti-buddhiù

"One who considers the arca-mürti or worshipable Deity of Lord Viñëu to be stone, the spiritual master to be an ordinary human being, and a Vaiñëava to belong to a particular caste or creed, is possessed of hellish intelligence and is doomed." (Padma Puräëa) We should not look upon the Deity as something material, as stone (çilä). As soon as Caitanya Mahäprabhu saw the Jagannätha Deity, Caitanya Mahäprabhu immediately fainted. In order to realize God's omnipresence, we must be trained to follow God's instructions. It appears that Hegel is theorizing that God is an idea, but God is substance.

Çyämasundara däsa: And what do you mean by substance?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Substance is something concrete. You may form an idea of a golden mountain, but there,is a difference between that idea and the golden mountain itself. When you actually see and touch a golden mountain, it is a fact. That fact is substance.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, there is idea, substance, and the synthesis, which is spirit.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to our philosophy, spirit is realized in three phases: Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagävan. Realizing Brahman is like realizing the sunshine, which is impersonal. Realizing Paramätmä is like realizing the sun disc itself, which is localized. However, if we have the capacity to enter the sun, we will see the sun god himself, and this may be compared to Bhagävan realization, the personal feature of God. Once we realize the personal feature, we automatically understand the impersonal and localized features. According to Brahma-saàhitä (5.40), the impersonal brahmajyoti is the bodily rays of Kåñëa. Similarly, Paramätmä is the localized feature of Kåñëa sitting in everyone's heart. The sun is one, not many, but it is capable of being reflected in countless waterpots. One who sees the sun's reflections in the pots may think, "Oh, there are millions of suns." One who has seen only the sunshine thinks of the sun impersonally. But when one knows the sun god, he has attained personal realization. The Supreme Personality of Godhead is a person, Çré Kåñëa. When you have a clear conception of God, you understand this. You cannot make God into an idea. Ideas arise because there is substance.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel uses the word "idea" to refer to rational form, which precedes material or physical form.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is stated in Brahma-saàhitä that Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, has form (vigraha), but what kind of form is this? Éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù. "Kåñëa is the Supreme Godhead, and He has an eternal, blissful, spiritual body." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.1) Sat means eternal. Presently, we have bodies which are asat, temporary, but Kåñëa's body is different from ours. The word änanda means blissful; Kåñëa is always blissful. And cit means knowledge; Kåñëa knows everything. In this way, He is different from us. He is not an idea but substance itself.

Çyämasundara däsa: When we were discussing Plato, you agreed that the ideal precedes the physical representation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: From the çästras we learn that there is a spiritual world, and that this material world is a perverted reflection of that world. From the çästras we also understand that the houses in the spiritual world are made of cintämaëi. Cintämaëi prakara-sadmasu. In this world, we have no experience of cintämaëi [philosophers' stone], a stone that turns other metals to gold, but we may have some idea by hearing from authorities. It is not that we manufacture or think up the spiritual world. In other words, we have ideas of substances which we may not have seen.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, spirit generates ideas and actualizes them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that everything comes from Kåñëa. Why just ideas and substances? Why this or that? Why so many distinctions? Everything comes from Him. Unless there is substance in the spiritual world, nothing could exist. In the final analysis, we have to accept the fact that everything is emanating from the substance. Janmädy asya. All ideas can be traced back to the original substance, which is Kåñëa. Therefore Kåñëa says, "Everything is emanating from Me." If you attain Kåñëa, therefore, you attain the ultimate substance. If you understand God, you understand everything.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then you would say that form precedes idea, not that idea precedes form?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, form precedes idea. Kåñëa says, sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöo mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca. "I am seated in everyone's heart, and from Me come remembrance, knowledge, and forgetfulness." (Bg. 15.15) As far as man is concerned, he cannot invent anything. He can only discover things that are already there.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel sees idea and substance opposing one another as thesis and antithesis; spirit is the synthesis containing both.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we agree. Viruddhärtha-sambandha. Contradictory things are adjusted in Kåñëa; therefore we say that Kåñëa is inconceivable. He is simultaneously one with and different from His creation. Since it is impossible to conceive of these things in the material world, they are called inconceivable.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then, if we can conceive of something, must it exist somewhere?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. It is a fact that you cannot conceive of anything that does not have existence. In this material world, we understand that one plus one equals two, and that one minus one equals zero, but in the spiritual world, this law does not apply. There, one plus one equals one, and one minus one equals one.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what of the idea that God is evil? Can I conceive of this?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, God is also evil, but not according to our understanding. God is Absolute, and evil and good are reconciled in Him. We cannot say that because we think of God as evil that He is evil. Rather, we say that He is all good because He is Absolute.

Çyämasundara däsa: What of the idea that God does not exist?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is a fact that He does not exist as far as rascals are concerned. Since a rascal cannot understand God, God does not exist for him.

Çyämasundara däsa: What of the idea that I am God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also a fact because you are part and parcel of God. You may say, "I am an American," and President Nixon can also say, "I am an American," but this does not mean that you are President Nixon. It is madness to claim such a thing.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning God and man, Hegel writes: "God is only God insofar as He knows Himself; His self-knowledge is moreover His consciousness of Himself in man, and man's knowledge of God, a knowledge that extends itself into the self-knowledge of man in God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If he accepts the existence of God and man, why does he not agree to receive knowledge of God from God Himself? Why speculate? To possess knowledge of God, man had best take knowledge from God Himself. Yet Hegel is opposed to receiving knowledge or instructions from an exterior source. It stands to reason that if you want to know about me and my nature, you had best take knowledge from me personally instead of speculating. In Bhagavad-gétä, God explains Himself, and if we accept this knowledge, which is given by God, our knowledge of God will be perfect. Why waste time speculating?

Hayagréva däsa: Perhaps without speculation, a philosopher wouldn't be able to write so many books.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. When you have perfect knowledge, you can write perfectly. Without perfect knowledge, your writings will simply be nonsensical. If there is any meaning in our books, it is there because we are not speculating about God but are understanding God from God Himself. This is the paramparä system. According to Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura, säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästrair (Çré Gurv-añöaka 7). All scriptures accept the guru, the spiritual master, as the Supreme Lord Himself because he does not concoct anything. He is the servant of God, and his knowledge is given by God. If Hegel accepts the fact that he is a man and that God exists, he should logically receive knowledge about God from God Himself.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, the absolute idea, the idea-in-and-for-itself, manifests itself in the objective mind in the form of laws, morality, and social ethics, and the free will develops in these areas.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the field of the free will. As soon as we accept a controller, all these are manifest. Laws will come, morality will come, and social ethics will come. Since atheists do not accept the controller, they act immorally. Unless we have a platform on which to execute the free will, there is no meaning to free will. There must be some law, some system of morality. At the same time, Kåñëa told Arjuna to do whatever he decides (Bg. 18.63). That is free will. After explaining Bhagavad-gétä to him, Kåñëa told him that the choice was his.

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel placed a great deal of emphasis on human freedom. He accused the "Orientals," specificially the Hindus, of not knowing "that the spirit is free in itself or that man is free in himself. Because they do not know it, they are not free."

Çréla Prabhupäda: He speaks of human freedom, but he is subjected to birth, old age, disease, and death. Where is his freedom when he dies?

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel writes that "only the Germanic nations have in and through Christianity achieved the consciousness that man qua man is free and that freedom of the spirit constitutes his very nature."

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Christian religion, a man has the freedom either to go to heaven or to hell. That is, he has the freedom to make a choice. However, if he goes to hell, where is his freedom? Every citizen has the freedom either to live as a free citizen or to go to jail, but if one goes to jail, where is freedom? His freedom is dependent on someone else who gives him a chance to either remain free or go to prison. Our freedom is relative, and God is the supreme absolute controller. It is God who gives the living entity the freedom to make his choice. The living entity is never completely free, as God is.

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel criticized Hinduism as a theocracy in which man is handed laws from an exterior God; for Hegel, this is a blind following of an exterior will, a following not confirmed within the individual himself. He believed that man could best attain God through the exercise of his own free will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If this is the case, why can't animals attain God? They are also given a free will.

Hayagréva däsa: He claims that animals have no will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If they have no will, why do they go different directions?

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel even went further to say in The Philosophy of Right and Law that animals have no right to life because they have no will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, you must determine what is life. Animals are eating, sleeping, defending, and mating just as we are. A small ant has all the life symptoms that we have. Who is to say that a man has more right to live than an ant? The life symptoms are the same.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, the individual conscience evaluates itself and sets its own standard of morality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our morality is not like that because we accept morality from a higher authority. Our morality is standardized. Kåñëa says, "Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me." (Bg. 18.66) This is the morality we accept. The laws of man are imperfect, but God's are perfect. Why should we accept the imperfect advice of other men?

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel sees the subjective mind dealing with inner experiences, the objective mind with exterior, and the absolute mind dealing with both, and uniting them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct. Anyone can understand that this is the case with the Absolute.

Çyämasundara däsa: This Absolute expresses itself in three forms: art, religion, and philosophy. In art, the Absolute assumes the form we call beauty.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we define God as all beautiful.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel considers religion to be like an art form. Whereas philosophy conceives or thinks of the Absolute, religion represents or pictures it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Without a philosophical basis, religion is simply sentiment.

Çyämasundara däsa: He maintains that art is an expression of spirit.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, everything is an expression of spirit. How is that a definition of art?

Çyämasundara däsa: What about a tree? Can we say that a tree is the artful display of the Absolute?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a tree is also a form of art. Kåñëa is the supreme artist also.

Çyämasundara däsa: The absolute mind expresses itself through religion, which presents the Absolute Truth as representations in our consciousness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Religion means accepting God. If he thinks that religion is a mere representation in our consciousness, he has no clear idea of religion. Abiding by the laws of God is religion.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, the highest form in which the Absolute manifests itself is philosophy, which is the synthesis of art and religion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Philosophy also means obeying the orders of God. Anything else is dry speculation. God says, "Thou shalt not kill." If we are religious, we stop killing. However, if we understand why we should not kill, we are philosophic. There are many people who accept Kåñëa as God, but an advanced devotee understands Kåñëa, and therefore he is very dear to Kåñëa. But highest of all is love of Kåñëa. The gopés were not philosophers, but they loved Kåñëa without ulterior consideration. Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself expressed this love of Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Once, you said that even higher than philosophy is the practice of philosophy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the gopés were practicing philosophy because they were loving Kåñëa. Moreover, they were enjoying the results of philosophy.

Hayagréva däsa: Since the body is the soul's instrument, Hegel considered injury to the body to be injury to the person himself. In The Philosophy of Right and Law, he says: "It is but vain sophistry that says that the real person—the soul—cannot be injured by maltreatment offered to one's body....Violence done to the body is really done to me."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then what is the justification for killing animals?

Hayagréva däsa: He would say that a person can possess his body because he can put his will into it. Animals, however, have no right to life because they do not put their will into the possession of their bodies.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If that is the case, why do animals object when you kill them? What kind of philosophy is he expounding?

Hayagréva däsa: He says that mankind has the right of absolute proprietorship. He writes: "A thing belongs to the accidental first comer who gets it, because a second comer cannot take possession of what is already the property of another."

Çréla Prabhupäda: In other words, might makes right. But consider, how would you take ownership of gold? First of all, you must hunt out gold that has no proprietor. You must inquire who the actual proprietor of the gold is. You may claim first proprietorship, but the gold was there in the first place. Whose property is it? Who made the gold and kept it before you came along?

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel would say that "the first comer is not legal owner by virtue of his being the first comer, but because he has free will." That is, it is mine because I put my will into it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That's all right, but someone made the gold and kept it before you went to capture it. Since this was the case, by willing it to be yours, or by taking it, you become a common thief, not a philosopher. Our claim to proprietorship is false because we are neither the creators nor maintainers of property.

Çyämasundara däsa: As far as action is concerned, activity in accordance with conscience is proper activity for Hegel.

Çréla Prabhupäda: A thief becomes accustomed to stealing, and therefore his conscience says, "Yes, I must steal. It is my right." The conscience of a murderer tells him to murder. Originally, the Bible said, "Thou shalt not kill," but people have created a conscience by which they can think, "Yes, killing is all right." Conscience is created by association. If our association is good, we create a good conscience, and if it is bad, we create a bad conscience. There is no absolute standard for the conscience. Conscience means discriminating power.

Çyämasundara däsa: He maintains that there is an absolute conscience, which is pure rationality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Pure rationality is Kåñëa consciousness. Unless we come to that platform, so-called conscience and philosophy have no value.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel believes that punishment for crime is justified because it vindicates justice and restores rights.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Therefore when one kills an animal, he should be prepared to be killed. That is justice. According to the Manu-saàhitä, it is justice to hang a murderer. It is unjust to save him because if he is not hanged in this life, he escapes justice, and has to suffer severely in the next. In order to be saved from many troubles in the next life, the murderer should be killed. The king who is hanging him is doing him justice in rendering a life for a life. But according to Vedic philosophy, if one kills an animal, he should also be prepared to be killed. A sane man would not run such a risk.

Çyämasundara däsa: If I observe in nature that living entities are killing one another to eat, it only seems rational that I should be able to eat animals.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, Vedic philosophy also accepts the fact that one living being is food for another.

ahastäni sahastänäm
apadäni catuñ-padäm
phalgüni tatra mahatäà
jévo jévasya jévanam

"Those who are devoid of hands are prey for those who have hands; those devoid of legs are prey for the four-legged. The weak are the subsistence of the strong, and the general rule holds that one living being is food for another." (Bhäg. 1.13.47) But this does not mean that you should kill your son and eat him. There must be discrimination. It is nature's law that we have to eat other living beings in order to exist; therefore we can eat fruit and vegetables. We can take these without killing the trees and plants. But if we eat animals, we have to kill them. The point is that we should act intelligently to make the best of a bad bargain. We take fruits, grains, vegetables, and milk products, and offer them to Kåñëa. If there is any responsibility, it is Kåñëa's. After offering the food to Kåñëa, we then accept it as prasädam.

yajïa-çiñöäçinaù santo
mucyante sarva-kilbiñaiù
bhuïjate te tv aghaà papa
ye pacanty ätma-käraëät

"The devotees of the Lord are released from all kinds of sins because they eat food which is offered first for sacrifice. Others, who prepare food for personal sense enjoyment, verily eat only sin." (Bg. 3.13) If you cook for yourself, you have to take all the responsibility for your sinful activity, even if you are a vegetarian. We therefore take the remnants of yajïa, sacrifice, and in this way we perform yajïa. It is not that we prepare food directly for our own consumption.

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel was a strong believer in the right of man to choose his own occupation. He writes: "In the Platonic State, subjective freedom was of no account, since the government assigned to each individual his occupation. In many Oriental states, this assignment results from birth. The subjective choice which ought to be respected requires free choice by individuals."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The occupations are already given, but you have the freedom to select one of them. Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä:

cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöaà
guëa karma-vibhägaçaù

"According to the three modes of material nature and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me." (Bg. 4.13) One can make his selection according to his qualifications. A man can become an engineer, for instance, when he becomes qualified to do the work. The words used are guëa-karma: the work is determined by one's qualities, not by birth. It is not that one automatically becomes a brähmaëa because he is born in a brähmaëa family. Rather, he has a better chance of being trained as a brähmaëa if his father is a brähmaëa, just as one stands a better chance of being trained as a musician or a cobbler if those are his father's occupations. However, it is not that a cobbler cannot become a brähmaëa. If he acquires the qualifications, he should be considered a brähmaëa. Nor is it that a brähmaëa's son necessarily becomes a brähmaëa without qualification. The point is that we must first attain the qualifications and then work accordingly.

Çyämasundara däsa: Concerning the state, Hegel writes: "The state is the realization of the ethical ideal....We must therefore worship the state as the manifestation of the divine on earth."

Çréla Prabhupäda: First, we have to understand the duty of the state. If it is accepted that the state is the representative of God, the state's first business is to make its citizens God conscious. Any state that neglects this duty should be immediately rejected as unqualified. The leader may either be a president or a king—it doesn't matter. In Vedic culture, the king is called naradeva, God in human form, and he is offered respect in that way. A king is respected because he is considered God's representative. We also present ourselves as Kåñëa's representative. And what is our duty? To lift others to God consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel recommended a constitutional monarch to be the executor for the World Spirit, but he was so vague that even Hitler could utilize his political philosophy to his ends.

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, the monarch has to be educated. Hitler came not as a king but a usurper. Nowadays, any rascal can assume power. Because the leaders are not trained to protect the citizens, the whole world is in trouble. A leader can whimsically declare war and involve all the citizens. In Vedic monarchy, there is a kind of disciplic succession wherein the king trains his son, and in this way he can govern properly.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Hegel, in a well-ordered monarchy, only the law has objective power; the king is simply the servant of the law.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is constitutional monarchy, a showbottle king. If a king is God conscious and is trained up properly and has complete power, he is a räjarñi. In Bhagavad-gétä, it is mentioned that the ancient saintly kings had understood this science of Kåñëa consciousness (Bg. 4.2). They were not ordinary men. The king was supposed to have been saintly. He had to understand the philosophy of Bhagavad-gétä and introduce an educational system so that the people could understand the science of God. That is the very first duty of the state and king. It is also stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam that one should not become a head of state, a father, or a guru if he cannot save his wards from the imminent danger of death (Bhäg. 5.5.18). We are now entangled in repeated birth and death, and it is the state's duty to promote liberation from this cycle.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel considers it the purpose of the state and king to apply the moral law.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is the duty of the king, but the leaders in modern democratic states are concerned only with exacting taxes. It is stated in the çästras that if the leaders keep the citizens morally blind and exact taxes from them, the leaders will go to ruination. Because they are sinfully earning money, they suffer in this life and the next. Similarly, when the guru accepts disciples, he takes the responsibility for their sinful reactions. When a king levies taxes, he takes a share of the sinful reactions of the citizens. If the citizens are pious, both the king and the citizens will profit. If not, if it is a case of the blind leading the blind, they will lead one another to hell. The main point is that the head of state should be a representative of God, and his duty should be to train citizens to become God conscious.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel also maintains that each state should be independent in itself and not be subordinate to other states.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Every state may be independent in an individual capacity, but every state is dependent on God's order. If the states are representatives of God, how can they be independent?

Çyämasundara däsa: He claims that there is no higher body to judge the states, and that their differences must be settled by war.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is a higher authority if there is religion, philosophy, and learned brähmaëas.

Çyämasundara däsa: He can see no potential world authority.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is because the Vedic varëäçrama dharma has been rejected. According to that system, the brahminical culture was superior to the kñatriya culture. The brähmaëas are to advise the kings. Because people have rejected the Vedic system, they say that there is no authority.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, there was no judge to settle the dispute between Räma and Rävaëa, and that resulted in war.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The judge was Lord Rämacandra Himself. He is God.

Çyämasundara däsa: In a sense, Hegel glorifies war. "War protects the people from the corruption which an everlasting peace would bring upon them," he says.

Çréla Prabhupäda: At the conclusion of the battle of Kurukñetra, Sanjaya points out that wherever there is Kåñëa, there will be victory (Bg. 18.78). If there is a war, the party that is God conscious will be victorious. If neither side is God conscious, it is a demonic war. It is not justified; it is just like a cat and dog fight. If we fight, we should fight on behalf of the Supreme God. That is called dharma-yuddha. Arjuna did not want to fight, but Kåñëa told him, "I am on your side. Fight." Arjuna was victorious because God was on his side.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, because the conflict itself is purifying, it has some ethical value. He writes, "By war, the ethical health of the nation is preserved, and its finite aims uprooted."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then he wants continuous war? If that is the case, Hitler is a first-class man. But why is he condemned? Of course, in the material world, there are opposing elements, and therefore there must be war. It is not that war can be stopped. Rather, the party that has Kåñëa's support will emerge victorious. We don't say that you can stop war, but that if you fight, you should fight on behalf of Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what of Hegel's view that progress comes only through conflict, and that peace means stagnation?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We do not agree that peace is stagnation. Our peace is working for Kåñëa. That is real peace. We are educating people to understand that Kåñëa is our friend, and this is not stagnation. Telling people about Kåñëa is our peace.

Çyämasundara däsa: Are we not in a state of war with material nature, mäyä?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We don't fight with mäyä. Those who are under mäyä's clutches and who are being kicked by mäyä are struggling with mäyä. We have nothing to do with mäyä.

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14) If mäyä does not disturb us, what is the point of fighting?

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel looks on world history as the supreme tribunal, the higher judge of events. History will bear out the worth of an empire and national policy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that whatever empire comes will certainly fall. There is no need to study history to know that. A godless empire will never endure.

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel considered history and theology to be intrinsic. History is "a justification of God," and tells the story of man's elevation to God. Without the history of man, God would be alone and lifeless. Since God is not transcendental but is manifest in the world, He depends on human history.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if God is dependent on human history, how can He be God? God is always independent. Janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç cärtheñv abhijïaù sva-räö (Bhäg. 1.1.1). If He is dependent on anything, He is not God.

Hayagréva däsa: Does the history of man necessarily make any sense? Hegel looked on history as evolutionary.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As soon as there is creation, there is history. This history will continue until the universe is annihilated. We may superficially consider history as existing from the beginning to the end of the universal manifestation, just as we may consider our personal history to extend from our birth to our death, but God is not subjected to such a history. It is not that God is created at a certain point and then annihilated. Since God is eternal, there is no question of history in respect to Him. History is for the finite, for things that have a past, present, and future. Since there is no past, present, and future for God, there is no history. You must have a past, present, and future in order to have history.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel believes that the dominant nation in any epoch represents a dominant phase of the Absolute at that time. For instance, if the United States is currently predominant, the Absolute is being expressed through the United States.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Aeons ago, the Absolute Truth was connected to the dominant nation. That is, to Mahäräja Parékñit. Because Mahäräja Parékñit and Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira were representing God, they could dominate the entire world. Now all that is lost, and today there are many small states that are not God conscious; therefore they are fighting each other like cats and dogs. Still, it is a fact that Vedic kings like Mahäräja Rämacandra, Mahäräja Påthu, Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira, and Mahäräja Parékñit were actually representatives of God. In those days, one king ruled the entire world. Therefore there was no trouble.

Çyämasundara däsa: Could America's dominance in this century be attributed to God's will?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Whenever we see some extraordinary power, we should understand that it is derived from God's power. We may therefore say that the predominance of America is due to God's favor. However, if Americans spread Kåñëa consciousness and make their president Kåñëa conscious, America will be God's empowered nation. Let the president be Kåñëa conscious. Why not? Educate the American people to be Kåñëa conscious and elect a Kåñëa conscious president. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is in your hands, and it is up to you to utilize it and become the factual leaders of the world. It was my mission to go to America and educate the Americans in Kåñëa consciousness because I knew that if they become Kåñëa conscious, the whole world will follow. You are young men, and this mission is in your hands. A few Communists like Stalin and Lenin formed a big Communist Party, and now this Party is dominating most of the world. It was started simply by a few men. Now many of you young Americans have understood this God conscious philosophy, and it is up to you to spread this movement. You should not become stagnant, thinking, "Now I have understood Kåñëa consciousness. Now let me sit down and just chant Hare Kåñëa." This is not desired. Go spread Kåñëa consciousness, and in this way glorify your nation.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Hegel's aesthetics, beauty is the Absolute penetrating the world of the senses.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, Kåñëa is the most beautiful. Because Kåñëa is beautiful, even the chirping of a bird is beautiful. Kåñëa is the reservoir of all pleasure and beauty. Beauty is appreciated in the world because beauty is one of Kåñëa's qualities. Whatever little beauty we find in this material world is but the perverted reflection of Kåñëa's beauty.

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel feels that art is a combination of spiritual content and sensuous form, and that the artist should try to imbue his material forms with spiritual content.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We agree with that. When we are painting pictures, playing music, or writing books, we are placing Kåñëa at the center.

Çyämasundara däsa: Of all the arts, Hegel says, music and poetry are the highest.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, therefore we are writing many books. Vyäsadeva has written many great epics in praise of Kåñëa. Lord Brahmä has written Brahma-saàhitä, cintämaëi prakara-sadmasu. There are many poems in praise of Kåñëa; therefore another name for Kåñëa is Uttama-çloka, the greatest of poems. He is described in beautiful poetry in the Vedic literatures. It is not very important whether it is poetry or prose. Anything sublime is called poetry. It is not that it has to be written in meter.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Hegel, religion is pure thought put into form.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He has no knowledge of what religion is. Religion is neither imagination nor pure thought. Religion is the order coming from the most pure. This cannot be imagined or created. We need only receive the instructions from the most pure. These are given in Bhagavad-gétä. We are not imagining this.

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel maintained that since God is necessarily manifest in the infinite, the incarnation is central to any religion. In order for God to be manifest, He has to incarnate as a finite man.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God becomes a mere man and is to be considered such, why should His instructions be followed?

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel did not believe in following any exterior will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he is either godless, or that God has no meaning for him.

Hayagréva däsa: He interpreted the goal of Indian philosophy to be nirväëa, spiritual as well as physical extinction.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everyone acknowledges physical extinction, and as far as the spiritual is concerned, there is no such thing as extinction. The spirit is eternal.

na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcin
näyaà bhütvä bhavitä vä na bhüyaù
ajo nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëo
na hanyate hanyamäne çarére

"For the soul there is never birth nor death. Nor, having once been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain." (Bg. 2.20) If the spirit is annihilated, how is it different from matter?

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel believed that in the highest religion, God is seen as Father, Son, and all-pervasive Holy Spirit. Thus he considered Christianity to be the perfect religion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Is it perfect to say that God only has one son? If God is unlimited, why is He limited to only one son?

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, he claims that Christ represents nature, or the objective world, because Christ is God incarnate.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When there is an incarnation of God as the son of God, and an incarnation of God as God Himself, which is superior? If God has begotten a son, God is a father, a person. How can a son be born of an impersonal father? What evidence do we have of such a thing ever happening?

Çyämasundara däsa: Hegel would like to have philosophy without religion because he saw religion as basically an encumbrance.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Such a philosophy is simply mental speculation. If he claims that philosophy is superior to religion, then religion supported by philosophy is real religion; otherwise it is sentiment. As I stated before, the orders of God constitute religion. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says, "Surrender unto Me." This is religion. When we try to understand why Kåñëa wants us to surrender unto Him, why we are obliged to surrender unto Him, we are in the realm of philosophy. When philosophy supports religion, it is perfect. It is neither sentiment, nor mental speculation.

Hayagréva däsa: In The Phenomenology of the Spirit, Hegel deprecates the use of plants and animals as objects of religion, considering it a kind of pantheism typical of Hinduism. How would worship of the tulasé plant or the cow differ?

Çréla Prabhupäda: God has specifically said that among plants, He is the tulasé. It is not that the Hindus are worshipping just any plant. For instance, in Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says, praëavaù sarva-vedeñu. "I am the syllable oà in the Vedic mantras." (Bg. 7.8) Therefore the word Oà is used in mantras, as in oà tad viñëoù paramaà padam. We know that oàkara is God because God says so. God gives instructions on how He should be realized, and we have only to follow. What is the point in speculating? We can never understand the unlimited God by our limited speculation.

Hayagréva däsa: But if God is in all animals and in all plants, why concentrate on any particular ones? Why not worship all?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is especially prohibited. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

mayä tatam idam sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

"By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them." (Bg. 9.4) The soul and the Supersoul exist within the body of a dog, but this does not mean that the barking of a dog is the word of God. Vivekananda said that we should worship daridra, the poor man in the street. He even used the word daridra-näräyaëa, indicating that Näräyaëa, God, has become poor, daridra. Although the body of a daridra rests in God, Näräyaëa, we should not consider his body to be the body of Näräyaëa. Everything in a government may rest on the orders of the king, but the king is not personally present everywhere. According to the acintya-bhedäbheda philosophy, God is simultaneously one with and different from His creation. God is undoubtedly present in the heart of the daridra, the poor man, but we should not consider the daridra to be God. That is an impersonalist Mäyävädé mistake. That is pantheism.

Hayagréva däsa: When Lord Kåñëa says that He is sex life according to dharma, does that mean that He can be perceived in that way?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, if one performs the Garbhädhäna ceremony to beget a Kåñëa conscious child, Kåñëa is remembered. It is the duty of the father to remember Kåñëa while having sex, thinking, "Kåñëa, give me a child who will be Your devotee." This kind of sex is for Kåñëa, and is Kåñëa, but if one has sex for his own sense enjoyment, that is demoniac.

Hayagréva däsa: But isn't Kåñëa present nonetheless?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is always present, but when we hold the Garbhädhäna ceremony to beget a Kåñëa conscious child, we remember Kåñëa. The rules and regulations for the Garbhädhäna ceremony are given in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. As soon as society abandons this ceremony, people become degraded.

Hayagréva däsa: So the philosophy behind reverence for the tulasé plant and the cow, or the sexual ceremony, is that these can bring remembrance of Kåñëa.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Kåñëa says:

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate

"Always chanting My glories, endeavoring with great determination, bowing down before Me, these great souls perpetually worship Me with devotion." (Bg. 9.14) If somehow or other you always think of Kåñëa, you become Kåñëa conscious.

Hayagréva däsa: Is it that you shouldn't think of Kåñëa in any other way? For instance, as a palm tree?

Çréla Prabhupäda: When Kåñëa says that among trees He is the tulasé, or whatever, we should simply accept it. For instance, He says, raso 'ham apsu kaunteya. "I am the taste of water." (Bg. 7.8) When we follow these instructions, we think, "I am drinking water and am feeling satisfaction. This satisfaction is Kåñëa." In this way, we can remember Him.

Hayagréva däsa: Hegel mistook this for pantheism.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He is mistaken in so many ways.

DS:Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860)

Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860)

Hayagréva däsa: For Schopenhauer, happiness is inactive satisfaction, inactivity, nirväëa. Since the will to live is the irrational urge that brings about all suffering, he advocates the extinction of this world. In The World As Idea, he writes: "The Vedas and Puräëas have no better simile than a dream for the whole knowledge of the actual world, which they call the web of mäyä....Indeed, life is a long dream....What is this world of perception besides being my idea? Is that of which I am conscious only as idea, exactly like my own body, of which I am doubly conscious, in one aspect as idea, in another aspect as will?" He goes on to conclude that life is a projection of the will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, life is a projection of the will, or material desire. The living entity cannot be desireless. Nirväëa means that material desires are finished, but because the living entity is an eternal spiritual being, he has spiritual desires. Now these spiritual desires are covered by material desires, but in any case, desire is the constant companion of the living entity. Because he is materially covered, he considers the temporary world to be reality, but because it is constantly changing, it is not. According to the type of body we get, we have different desires. The soul transmigrates in this material world from one body to another, and he creates desires accordingly. The supreme will affords him different bodies in order to fulfill his will or material desires. The living entity is willing, and the supreme will, God, or Kåñëa, understanding the finite will, gives him facilities to fulfill his particular desire. Therefore will is the cause of this material existence. However, we say that since you are a living being, you must have desires. If your desires are stopped, you become like a stone. Instead of trying to put an end to all desire, you should try to cleanse this diseased form of desire. That is the process of bhakti.

sarvopädhi-vinirmuktaà
tat-paratvena nirmalam
håñékeëa håñékeça-
sevanaà bhaktir ucyate

"Bhakti, or devotional service, means engaging all our senses in the service of the Lord, the master of all the senses. When the spirit soul renders service unto the Supreme, there are two side effects. He is freed from all material designations, and, simply by being employed in the service of the Lord, his senses are purified." (Bhakti-rasämåta sindhu, 1.1.12) Presently, our desires are desires of the body (upädhi). When the living entity acquires the body of an American, a European, a Chinaman, or whatever, he thinks in a certain way. When he changes his body to that of a dog, he spends his time barking. According to his desires, he has received a particular type of body. These desires are temporary, and the living entity moves from one body to another. Therefore in one sense this is all a dream. It is a fact that we cannot fulfill our material desires, which come and go like dreams. Now all material activities, subtle or gross, are manifestations of different desires, and therefore the Mäyävädé philosophers say brahma satyaà jagan mithyä. The dreamer is a fact, but the dream is false. Our Vaiñëava philosophy agrees that the dreamer is the factual living entity, and the dream is temporary; therefore the dreamer has to be brought to the real spiritual platform so that his material dreams can be extinguished. When we abandon the dream and awaken to reality, that is Kåñëa consciousness, or bhakti.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then will or desire can never be annihilated?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, not even for a second. Because we are living, we must will and desire. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that we cannot live for a second without will, without desires.

na hi kaçcit kñaëam api
jätu tiñöhaty akarmakåt
käryate hy avaçaù karma
sarvaù prakåti-jair guëaiù

"All men are forced to act helplessly according to the impulses born of the modes of material nature; therefore no one can refrain from doing something, not even for a moment." (Bg. 3.5)

Çyämasundara däsa: Don't the Buddhists advocate a state of desirelessness, or nonwillingness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: They believe that if you dismantle this material combination, this material body, there will no longer be will, desire, or suffering. But this is not a fact. You are the eternal servant of Kåñëa, and you do not die after the destruction of the body. Thinking, feeling, and willing are carried from this body to another body in the process of transmigration. When the body dies, the living entity is carried away by his will. According to our will, we receive another body at the time of death. That body may be the body of a demigod, dog, human, or whatever. In any case, will, or desire, is the carrier.

Hayagréva däsa: Schopenhauer was profoundly influenced by some of the Vedic literatures. For example, he writes: "Every keen pleasure is an error and an illusion, for no attained wish can give lasting satisfaction; and moreover, every possession and every happiness is but lent by chance for an uncertain time, and may therefore be demanded back the next hour. All pain rests on the passing away of such illusion; thus both arise from defective knowledge. The wise man therefore holds himself equally aloof from joy and sorrow, and no event disturbs his composure."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, in this material world, people say, "This is good, and this is bad," but factually there is no question of good and bad. This is all on the temporary platform. The Mäyävädés use the word "false," but we say "temporary." It is also stated in Bhagavad-gétä that the pains and pleasures experienced in the material world do not touch the spirit soul. Under illusion, a spirit soul, concerned with a material body, thinks that the pains and pleasures are his, but this is not a fact. Therefore Kåñëa instructs that the pleasures and pains simply touch the body, not the soul. Kåñëa says:

mäträ-sparçäs tu kaunteya
çétoñëa-sukha-duùkha-däù
ägamäpäyino ‘nityäs
täàs titikñasva bhärata

"O son of Kunté, the nonpermanent appearance of happiness and distress, and their disappearance in due course, are like the appearance and disappearance of winter and summer seasons. They arise from sense perceptions, and one must learn to tolerate them without being disturbed." (Bg. 2.14) Since pleasures and pains come and go in due course, they are not the reality. So why bother about them? If I feel pain, let me tolerate it and go about my business.

Çyämasundara däsa: Schopenhauer sees happiness in the world as a negative state at best, a momentary suspension of suffering.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is also explained by Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Sometimes when a man is to be punished, he is held under water to the point of suffocation. Then he is let up, and when he comes up for temporary relief, he thinks, "Ah! Happiness at last!" The point is, he should do something that will relieve him of his unhappiness permanently.

Çyämasundara däsa: Schopenhauer says, "Human life must be some kind of mistake." The greatest crime of man was that he was ever born.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you understand that there is a crime, you must understand that someone is there to punish you. If you suffer because of that crime, you must understand that there is someone who has judged you to be criminal.

Çyämasundara däsa: He concludes, however, that because the world is mad or irrational, it could not possibly have an author. If there were a God, He would have set the world in order.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have certainly experienced that there are madmen in the world, but there are also hospitals where such men can be treated. The world may be mad, but there is hospitalization. Unfortunately, Schopenhauer has no knowledge of the hospital or of the treatment. He speaks of sinful life, but he does not accept the judge who gives the punishment for sinful life. He sees that the world is mad, but he does not know the treatment for madmen.

Hayagréva däsa: In The World As Will, Schopenhauer writes: "My body is the objectivity of my will....Besides will and idea, nothing is known to us or thinkable—The genitals are properly the focus of the will, and consequently the opposite pole of the brain, the representative of knowledge....In this respect...they were worshipped by the Hindus in the liìgam, which are thus the symbol of the assertion of the will. Knowledge, on the other hand, affords the possibility of the suppression of willing, of salvation through freedom, of conquest and annihilation of the world."

Çréla Prabhupäda: As I said before, willing is done in accordance with the body, but we should understand that we have nothing to do with this material world, which is the production of the material will. We are spiritual, and when we will spiritually, we are Kåñëa conscious. When we will materially, we get different types of material bodies. It is true that the basis of material life is sex. We always say:

yan maithunädi-gåhamedhi-sukhaà hi tucchaà
kaëòüyanena karayor iva duùkha-duùkham
tåpyanti neha kåpaëä bahu-duùkha-bhäjaù
kaëòütivan manasijaà viñaheta dhéraù

"Sex life is compared to the rubbing of two hands to relieve an itch. Gåhamedhis, so-called gåhasthas who have no spiritual knowledge, think that this itching is the greatest platform of happiness, although actually it is a source of distress. The kåpaëas, the fools who are just the opposite of brähmaëas, are not satisfied by repeated sensuous enjoyment. Those who are dhéra, however, who are sober, and who tolerate this itching, are not subjected to the sufferings of fools and rascals." (Bhäg. 7.9.45). The basic principle of those who are addicted to the material world is maithuna, sexual intercourse. This strong desire for sex continues as long as we are in material existence, because that is the center of all pleasure. However, when we get a taste of Kåñëa's pleasure, we can give this up.

viñayä vinivartante
nirähärasya dehinaù
rasa-varjaà raso 'py asya
paraà dåñövä nivartate

"The embodied soul may be restricted from sense enjoyment, though the taste for sense objects remains. But, ceasing such engagements by experiencing a higher taste, he is fixed in consciousness." (Bg. 2.59)

Çyämasundara däsa: Schopenhauer considers sex to be selfishness, whereas real love means sympathy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sex is animalistic. It is not love but lust. Sex means the mutual satisfaction of senses, and that is lust. All this lust is taking place under the name of love, and out of illusion, people mistake this lust for love. Real love says, "People are suffering from a lack of Kåñëa consciousness. Let us do something for them so that they can understand the value of life."

Çyämasundara däsa: He also considered immoral acts to result from a sense of egoism.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is so. People think, "Why should I surrender to Kåñëa? Kåñëa is a person, and I am also a person." Such thinking is demoniac. Rascals cannot understand that by surrendering unto the supreme will and satisfying the supreme will, salvation can be attained.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yet Schopenhauer felt that it is possible to crush egoism and desire by love and sympathy for others.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, without love, nothing can be sustained. If I do not love Kåñëa, I cannot surrender unto Him. A small child naturally surrenders unto his parents because there is love for the parents. The more you love, the more your surrender is perfect. When there is a lack of love, the mentality by which you can surrender will not develop. If you have some love for me, you will carry out my orders. There is no question of forcing one to surrender. The living entity is free to love or to reject. Without freedom, there cannot be love. Kåñëa consciousness means learning to love Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Schopenhauer looked on love as compassionate sympathy for one who is suffering. Through this compassionate love, we can lose desire.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why should you love those who are suffering and not those who are enjoying?

Çyämasundara däsa: Schopenhauer sees everyone as suffering.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we agree to this. Everyone within material nature is suffering. Therefore Kåñëa descends and delivers Bhagavad-gétä. Kåñëa is described as the deliverer of all fallen souls. A Vaiñëava takes sannyäsa, the renounced order, out of compassion for others, because his only duty is to preach the message of Kåñëa consciousness. People in the world are suffering due to their ignorance. They think, "Oh, now I have a nice car, apartment, and girlfriend; therefore I am happy." Actually, this is not happiness but suffering. Because the Vaiñëava loves Kåñëa and understands that he is part and parcel of Kåñëa, he realizes that the conditioned living entities are suffering for want of Kåñëa consciousness. Therefore, out of compassion, the Vaiñëava takes sannyäsa and goes forth to preach.

Hayagréva däsa: As for the nature of the world, Schopenhauer is vague, but he sees material life as basically irrational and whimsical.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact, and therefore we are changing bodies. This means that our material mind is not fixed; it is constantly rejecting and accepting. Mäyävädé philosophers and Buddhists say that since these material pleasures and pains arise from this material combination, the best course is to dismantle it. They do not say that the soul is the basis, but that the material body is nothing but a combination of the material elements. They therefore advise us to let the earth return to earth, the water return to water, and so on. In this way, they tell us that we should strive to become zero, to attain nirväëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Leibnitz claimed that this is the best of all possible worlds, and you agreed because the world is God's arrangement. But Schopenhauer sees this as the worst of all possible worlds.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no doubt that whatever Kåñëa creates is perfect. However, since the nature of this world is material, there are three modes working: goodness, passion, and ignorance. As you work, you receive the results, the reactions. We do not agree that this is the worst of worlds. Why should God create the worst of anything?

Çyämasundara däsa: Schopenhauer believes this because the world is so full of madness and frustration.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Had he taken his frustration seriously, it might have made him successful. We receive many letters from frustrated students who understand that frustration is another hell, and eventually they come to understand that they should seek the real shelter. So frustration is really not so bad. If you are put in a dangerous position, and you know how to save yourself from it, that very danger will later give you pleasure.

Çyämasundara däsa: Schopenhauer claims that the working of the world is ethically evil.

Çréla Prabhupäda: To some extent that is right because when you are in prison, you will find that there is evil. But that evil is good for you. It is there so that you can learn a lesson. When you are out of the prison, you will be able to love someone.

Hayagréva däsa: For Schopenhauer, there is frustration behind all material pleasures and endeavors. Happiness eludes us. As soon as we attain the objects of our desires, they no longer appear the same. "They soon grow stale or forgotten," he writes, "and though not openly disowned, are yet always thrown aside as vanished illusions."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, all this is going on, and therefore the living entity acquires one body after another.

Hayagréva däsa: He sees us moving through a constant transition from desire to satisfaction and then to a new desire, "the rapid course of which is called happiness, and the slow course sorrow...." It is this flux from desire to satisfaction that characterizes the will's activities in the phenomenal world. Outside of this, there is only nirväëa, extinction.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not a fact. We have to understand that behind the will and its satisfaction is a person who is willing. Schopenhauer does not take that person into consideration; he considers only the will and its satisfaction. It is the individual soul who is willing. If he succeeds in stopping this flickering willing, what next? Even the stopping of the will is temporary. One kind of willing may be stopped, but there will be another kind of willing and satisfaction. We must understand that behind the whimsical will is the spirit soul. When that spirit soul understands his real identification as the eternal servant of Kåñëa, his will is purified. We should not be satisfied by simply trying to annihilate the whimsical will. We should understand the real will of the real person. That is the beginning of spiritual life.

Hayagréva däsa: Schopenhauer believes that voluntary and complete chastity is the first step in asceticism, or in the denial of the will to live. "Chastity denies the assertion of the will which extends beyond the individual life," he writes, "and gives the assurance that with the life of the body, the will, whose manifestation it is, ceases."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but he must understand that behind the will there is a person who is willing. It will not help us simply to negate the temporary material will. We have to will in reality, and that is our eternal willing, that is Kåñëa consciousness. In the material world, the will is directed toward sense satisfaction because the living entity has forgotten the spiritual field of willing. When the same will is directed towards satisfying the senses of the Supreme, that is the eternal willing of the living entity. Jévera 'svarüpa' haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa' (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 20.108). When we come to the platform of real knowledge, we understand that we are the eternal servants of God. When our will is concentrated on how to serve God, we attain our real position of eternity, bliss, and knowledge.

Hayagréva däsa: Although Schopenhauer officially takes an atheistic stand, he writes: "If a man fears death as his annihilation, it is just as if he were to think that the sun cries out at evening, 'Woe is me! For I go down to eternal night....' Thus suicide appears to us as a vain and therefore foolish action...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, because the will is there, death is not the stoppage of life. One simply gets another life.

dehino 'smin yathä dehe
kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä
tathä dehäntara-präptir
dhéras tatra na muhyati

"As the embodied soul continuously passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. The self-realized soul is not bewildered by such a change." (Bg. 2.13) This is proof that the life of the person who is willing is eternal. His desire and will are eternal, but Schopenhauer does not know what his eternal willing is. His eternal will is to serve Kåñëa always. It is a fact that suicide is no solution. One just implicates himself more and more. If we kill the body given by God, we have to accept another body, or remain a ghost. If I live in this body eighty years, and then commit suicide, I have to remain a ghost for five years before I get a chance to receive another body. Of course, you may argue that since the soul is everlasting, it makes no difference whether the body is killed. It is all right if the body is annihilated, but you cannot deliberately kill the body because that is hindering its progress. The living entity is destined to live in a particular body, and if you destroy that body, he has to wait for another. This means that you are interfering with his spiritual evolution, his spiritual progress. Therefore you are liable for punishment.

Hayagréva däsa: Schopenhauer also looked on Indian philosophy as a philosophy of the denial of the will, and he cited many examples of suicide as a religious act.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But he did not study Vedic philosophy and religion perfectly. He has some idea of some portions of the Mäyävädé and Buddhist philosophies, but evidently he did not know about Vaiñëavism. Although he has touched Bhagavad-gétä, he did not study it thoroughly, because in Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells Arjuna that if he only tried to attain knowledge of God, his life and will would be purified, and he would return back to Godhead upon giving up the body.

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so ’rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9) Either Schopenhauer did not study Bhagavad-gétä thoroughly, or he could not understand for want of a real spiritual master. According to Bhagavad-gétä itself, we should go to a bona fide guru who has seen the truth. Schopenhauer is speculating on the basis of his own experience; therefore, although everything is there in Bhagavad-gétä, he could not see it.

Hayagréva däsa: As examples of the denial of the will to live, Schopenhauer cites the religious suicides under the wheels of the Jagannätha carts, and the ritual of saté.

Çréla Prabhupäda: These are not suicides. These are acts based on the understanding that because we are getting different types of bodies, we are suffering a variety of miseries. When one voluntarily accepts death in these ways, he thinks of his spiritual life while dying, and he attains it.

yaà yaà väpi smaran bhävaà
tyajaty ante kalevaram
taà tam evaiti kaunteya
sadä tad-bhäva-bhävitaù

"Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits the body, that state he will attain without fail." (Bg. 8.6) Therefore King Kulaçekhara prayed that Kåñëa take him while he was in good health and remembering Kåñëa, because he feared forgetting Kåñëa when dying in a diseased condition. Often, when death comes, a person is in a coma, his bodily functions are impeded, he dreams in various ways, and so on. Therefore an intelligent man sometimes thinks that it would be more desirable to meet death in sound health so that he can think of his next life and go back to Godhead. If a person thinks of Lord Jagannätha while dying, he goes back to Lord Jagannätha. That is not suicide but the voluntary acceptance of death so that one can immediately transfer to the spiritual world.

Hayagréva däsa: And that is effective?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Hayagréva däsa: What of Caitanya Mahäprabhu's throwing Himself in the ocean?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, that was different. That was an act of ecstasy.

Çyämasundara däsa: Schopenhauer noted that the will forces a person to live even when he has nothing to live for. It impels him to suffer day after day. He compares it to the alms which a beggar receives one day just so he can live in hunger the next day. All this misery and frustration are not partaken by a few men, but by all.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is certainly a good point, but why does the individual hanker after something when he is being frustrated? The point is that there is a goal, and the individual is hankering after that goal. In order to understand what that goal actually is, we should approach a spiritual master.

Hayagréva däsa: According to Schopenhauer, the man of knowledge is not perturbed in any condition. "Such a man would regard death as a false illusion," he writes, "an impudent specter which frightens the weak but has no power over him who knows that he is himself the will of which the whole world is the objectification or copy, and that therefore he is always certain of life and also of the present—"

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is contradictory. On the one side there is a desire for the certainty of life, and on the other he says that nirväëa is the only answer. Which does he want? He is simply trying to adjust things. He cannot understand the philosophy behind purification of the will.

Hayagréva däsa: One of the first major Western philosophers to have read Bhagavad-gétä, Schopenhauer feels that it was Kåñëa's assurance of immortality that brought Arjuna to fight.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but what is Schopenhauer's philosophy of the immortal living being? He does not understand that just as the living entity is immortal, his will is also immortal. If the soul is immortal, how can his will be stopped? How is nirväëa possible?

Hayagréva däsa: He offers no solution other than suppression of the will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But that is not possible. He must change the quality of his willing in order to be happy. That is the process of bhakti.

sarvopädhi-vinirmuktaà
tat-paratvena nirmalam
håñékeëa håñékeça-
sevanaà bhaktir ucyate

"Bhakti, or devotional service, means engaging all our senses in the service of the Lord, the master of all the senses. When the spirit soul renders service unto the Supreme, there are two side effects. He is freed from all material designations, and, simply by being employed in the service of the Lord, his senses are purified." (Bhakti-rasämåta sindhu, 1.1.12) Bhakti is the purification process: çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù. Chanting and hearing the pastimes of the Lord will purify us. Schopenhauer misses the point of Bhagavad-gétä. Although he accepts the fact that life is eternal, he thinks that its purpose is nirväëa. Unfortunately, he does not know what real nirväëa is. Nirväëa means putting an end to the whimsical will and coming to the platform of willing in Kåñëa consciousness.

Hayagréva däsa: Schopenhauer was impressed that the religion of India has endured for more than four thousand years. He writes that such a religion "cannot be arbitrarily invented superstition, but must have its foundation in the nature of man."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Within the Vedic religion there are two basic sects: Mäyävädé and Vaiñëava. Both acknowledge the fact that the material world is flickering and transient and that there is another life in the spiritual world. For the Mäyävädés, spiritual life means merging into the Brahman effulgence, and for the Vaiñëava it means associating personally with God in His abode, Goloka Våndävana, Vaikuëöha. Both envision a spiritual life attainable after death.

Hayagréva däsa: Schopenhauer considered Indian religion to be based on the denial of the will.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, denial of the will for material happiness, but it is not the will itself that is denied. While denying the will for material happiness, we must assert the will for spiritual happiness. When denying one thing, we must accept something else. No one can remain in a neutral position. Paraà dåñövä nivartate (Bg. 2.59). We give up the inferior for the superior.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Schopenhauer, there are three means of salvation: aesthetic, ethical, and religious. Through aesthetic salvation, contemplation of the Platonic ideals through poetry, music, and art, we are transported above passion, desire and willing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is nothing new. It is mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä, and the students of this Kåñëa consciousness movement abandoned their abominable living habits because they received a better life with superior thoughts, philosophy, food, song, poetry, and art. When the mind is filled with Kåñëa, there is no chance in its engaging in the contemplation of nonsense.

Çyämasundara däsa: Aesthetic salvation is a temporary experience. When we look at a beautiful painting, for instance, we momentarily transcend the lower levels of consciousness and become desireless.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we admit that this may be the case, but we wish to remain in that higher consciousness continually, not momentarily. This is possible through practice. By practice, a child learns to read and write, and thus becomes educated. It is not a momentary thing. If we practice Kåñëa consciousness daily, lower consciousness will automatically vanish. Çré-vigrahärädhana-nitya-nänä-çåìgära-tan-mandira-märjanädau (Çré Gurv-añöakam 3). The spiritual master engages his disciples in the temple worship of the Lord. You cannot derive benefit from worshipping the Deities unless the aesthetic sense is applied with reverence and respect.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to ethical salvation, we should attempt to satisfy the will. When it is satisfied, no new desires can arise. This brings permanent happiness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Apart from the individual will, there is the supreme will. If we satisfy the supreme will, we are happy. Yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädo (Çré Gurv-añöakam 8). Our philosophy is that by satisfying the spiritual master, the representative of God, we satisfy the supreme will. It is not our will that is to be satisfied, but the will of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: By religious salvation, the most effective type of salvation, the will is denied through asceticism. In this way, Schopenhauer believed that we could attain the state of nirväëa, nothingness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Such people claim that when there is no longer any sense of pleasure and pain, there is no world. The fact is, there are three stages: waking, sleeping, and total unconsciousness. In all three stages, the will is there. A person can emerge from a state of total unconsciousness and immediately remember his waking state and his dreams. Therefore the will is there. The will cannot be killed because it is the function of the soul. Since the soul is eternal, willing is also eternal. The will may be suppressed for some time, however. For instance, after death, when a living entity enters a womb, he spends the next nine months developing his next body, and there is a suspension of the will. However, according to your will, you develop a certain type of body. When you emerge from your mother's womb, the willing process resumes. Death means a suspension of the will for a few months, that's all. If you train your willing process improperly, you have to suffer life after life, but if you train it properly, you can go to Vaikuëöha immediately after death.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning religious practices, Schopenhauer writes that "the Christian mystic and teacher of Vedänta agree that all outward works and religious exercises are superfluous for him who has attained to perfection." But doesn't Kåñëa recommend just the opposite?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. In Bhagavad-gétä, He says:

yajïa-däna-tapaù-karma
na tyäjyaà käryam eva tat
yajïo dänaà tapaç caiva
pävanäni manéñiëäm

"Acts of sacrifice, charity, and penance are not to be given up but must be performed. Indeed, sacrifice, charity, and penance purify even the great souls." (Bg. 18.5) If we give up the ritualistic ceremonies, there is every chance that we will fall down. Even though we may be liberated, we should continue performing sacrifices, charities, and penance in order to keep our position secure.

Hayagréva däsa: In discussing the functions of the brain, Schopenhauer notes that the need for sleep is directly proportionate to the intensity of our mental activities. Dull creatures like reptiles and fish sleep little and lightly; the more intelligent animals sleep deeply and long. 'The more completely awake a man is," he writes, "the clearer and more lively his consciousness, the greater for him is the necessity of sleep, and thus the deeper and longer he sleeps."

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Those who are ignorant, materially covered, sleep more, and those who are spiritually enlightened sleep less. Sleep is a necessity of the body, not of the soul; therefore those who are spiritually advanced do not require a lot of sleep. Nidrähära-vihärakädi-vijitau. We understand that Rüpa Gosvämé conquered sleeping, eating, and mating. When we are spiritually engaged, we consider sleep a waste of time. Those who are interested in spiritual life adjust their lives in such a way that their sleep is practically nil. Arjuna was addressed as Guòäkeça, "one who has conquered sleep."

Hayagréva däsa: Schopenhauer recommends about eight hours of sleep a night. How many are recommended in the Vedic tradition?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sleep should be avoided, but since that is not possible, it should be adjusted to the minimum. The Gosvämés did not sleep more than two hours daily. Even some karmés are so absorbed in their work that they practically don't sleep at all. It is said that Napolean slept while riding his horse, and Gandhi slept while riding in a car. Generally, six hours is sufficient.

Hayagréva däsa: In The Ages of Life, Schopenhauer writes: "A complete and adequate notion of life can never be attained by anyone who does not reach old age, for it is only the old man who sees life whole and knows its natural course....He alone has a full sense of its utter vanity, whereas others never cease to labor under the false notion that everything will come out right in the end."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This may seem to be the case, but in Western countries we observe old men still following the path of sense gratification. So what is the use of their experience? Unless one receives training, it is not sufficient to become an old man in order to understand the purpose of life. Training is required from early childhood. According to the Vedic plan, an old man should take the renounced order of sannyäsa and completely devote his time and energy to understanding and serving God. We do not become spiritually mature just by growing old. We should be trained from the very beginning as brahmacäré.

Hayagréva däsa: Schopenhauer points out that it is customary to call youth the happy part of life and old age the sad part, but factually this is not the case. "This would be true if it were the passions that made a man happy," he writes, "but a man feels happy just insofar as his intellect is the predominating part of him."

Çréla Prabhupäda: For modern civilization, happiness means sense gratification. Desire for sense gratification continues even when one is an old man; therefore early training is required. It is said that one can become an old man even without advancing in age. This means that it is knowledge that is important, not age. If one is not educated properly, he becomes an old fool.

Hayagréva däsa: Schopenhauer notes that in the Upaniñads, the natural human life span is set at a hundred years. "To come to one's end before the age of ninety means to die of disease," he writes. "In other words, prematurely."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. In this millennium, the maximum age is one hundred years, but in former millennia, men used to live for a thousand years. In the Tretä-yuga, the life span was ten thousand years, and in the Satya-yuga, it was one hundred thousand years. Presently, in Kali-yuga, life has become so degraded that people expect to live only about seventy years. As one becomes more sensuous, his life span decreases. That is the law of nature.

VIIIEVOLUTIONARY NATURALISM

VIIIEVOLUTIONARY NATURALISM

DS:Charles Robert Darwin (1809-1882)

Charles Robert Darwin (1809-1882)

Hayagréva däsa: Darwin's conception of evolution rests on the premise that there is a real genetic change from generation to generation. In other words, he rejects the Platonic eidos (idea, type, or essence) for a species. Whereas Kåñëa says that He is the generating seed of all existences, Darwin would reject the existence of a particular seed for a particular type. There are no fixed species, but shifting, evolving, physical forms, constantly changing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. The forms are already there from the beginning of creation. There is evolution, however, but Darwin thinks that this is an evolution of the body. That is incorrect. The body never evolves, but the soul within the body evolves and transmigrates from one body to another. The soul is within the body, and as he desires, he evolves. A man may desire to change apartments, and he may move from one apartment to another, but it is the man who is doing the changing, not the apartment. According to the Vedic conception, the soul evolves, not the body.

Çyämasundara däsa: Darwin originated the doctrine of natural selection and survival of the fittest. An animal, he maintains, will develop in a way that is best suited for survival in his environment, and he will pass on his superior qualities to his offspring. Some species survive, and others, not so suitable to the environment, die out.

Çréla Prabhupäda: A snake gives birth to many hundreds of snakes at a time, and if so many snakes are allowed to exist, there will he a disturbance. Therefore, according to nature's law, the big snakes eat up the small snakes. Nature's law is not blind, because behind it there is a brain, and that brain is God.

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again." (Bg. 9.10) Whatever is taking place in material nature is being directed by the Supreme Lord, who maintains everything in order. When one species becomes overly dominant, nature arranges to curb it. According to the theory of Malthus, whenever there is overpopulation, there must be some war, epidemic, or earthquake. These natural activities do not take place by chance but are planned. If Darwin says it is a matter of chance, his knowledge is insufficient.

Çyämasundara däsa: Darwin also sees a plan or design in nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you see a plan or design, you must ask, "Whose design?" As soon as you admit that there is a design, you must admit a designer. It is nonsense to say that nature is simply working mechanically. If so, there must be some mechanic to set it in motion. The sun rises exactly to the minute, to the second, and the seasons also come according to plan. Behind the great machine of nature there is a brain that has set it in order. We explain the original source of everything as Brahman, the Absolute Truth, Kåñëa. Scientists admit that they do not know where things are coming from, but when they see them, they suddenly claim to have invented them. But that is not invention. These things are already there.

Çyämasundara däsa: From scientific research, it is concluded that through the years, animals have evolved toward more and more complex forms, from very simple forms found in the sea to more complex forms, such as dinosaurs and so on. These forms eventually died out, and other forms evolved from them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you say they died out, you mean that those animals no longer exist on this earth. But how can you say that they are not existing somewhere else? Now, according to Darwin's theory of evolution, the human body evolved from the simians.

Çyämasundara däsa: He claims that they are related, that they come from the same ancestor.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is another thing. Everything is related. But he claims that the ape's body or monkey's body developed into a human body. If that is the case, why haven't the simians ceased to exist? We can see that apes, monkeys, and human beings are existing simultaneously. Scientists cannot prove that no human being existed aeons ago. If man evolved from the ape, the ape should no longer exist. Kärya-käraëa. When the effect is there, the cause is finished.

Çyämasundara däsa: It is not that the monkey caused the man to exist; rather, they came from a common ancestor.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that we all come from God, the same ancestor, the same father. The original father is Kåñëa.

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father." (Bg. 14.4)

Çyämasundara däsa: Any any rate, according to Darwin's theory, there is an evolution from simpler forms to more complex forms, from small one-celled animals to more complex animals like man.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But at the present moment, the simple forms are existing along with the complex. It is not that the simplest developed into the most complex. My present body has developed from my childhood body, but that childhood body is no longer existing. Presently, the species are simultaneously existing.

Çyämasundara däsa: But they find no evidence that all these complex forms existed in earlier times.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Earlier times or modern times are not in question. When I see all the 8,400,000 species still existing, where is the question of development? You may not know or have evidence that these forms existed long ago, but that is due to your imperfect knowledge. These species are all existing now, and they were existing millions of years ago. You may not have evidence of this, but that is a different thing. We accept evolution, but we also accept the fact that the species are all existing simultaneously now. If they are not existing on this planet, they are existing on some other. Of course, Darwin had no chance to study that. We accept the proposition that there is an evolutionary process from aquatics to insects to birds to animals and to humans, but we do not accept Darwin's theory that one species becomes extinct as another survives. All are existing simultaneously.

Çyämasundara däsa: But there are many forms that are extinct on this planet.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But has Darwin seen all the planets and all the universes? Has he the power to see everything? Since our powers are limited, we cannot conclude that a particular species is extinct. Of course, the scientists do not accept the fact that our senses, by which we are gathering information, are limited. But they are. It is not possible to excavate the entire earth. We can only take samples. Our first charge against Darwin is that human life was always existing. He cannot prove that at a certain time there was no human life. It is not that the bodies of the species are changing. These bodies are already there. Rather, the soul is changing bodies, transmigrating from one body to another, and this is actual evolution. It is the evolution or progress of the soul from one body to another.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the soul, Darwin writes: "A few persons feel anxiety from the impossibility of determining at what precise period in the development of the individual, from the first trace of a minute germinal vesicle, man becomes an immortal being, and there is no greater cause for anxiety because the period cannot possibly be determined in the gradually ascending organic scale." That is, it is impossible to know at what point the immortal soul inhabits these species.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul is the most important factor, and in order to understand the soul, education is required. It is the soul that moves the body, whether that body be that of an ant, bacteria, a human being, animal, or whatever. Nothing can move without the presence of the soul, and each and every individual soul is immortal.

Çyämasundara däsa: As mentioned, Darwin doesn't accept the fact that there are a fixed number of species. Rather, he maintains that the species may vary at different times according to natural selection. There are new species always evolving.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what does he know of all the species? Does he have a complete list of all the species in the universe? From Padma Puräëa, we learn that there are 8,400,000 species. First of all, we must understand what all these species are. You may walk through a market and see many different types of people. As you walk, you continue to see different types of people, but you cannot say that a particular type no longer exists because you do not see it anymore. The point is that you can neither see nor comprehend the beginning or the end.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, they claim that everything started with a one-celled animal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But where did that animal come from?

Çyämasundara däsa: From chemical combinations.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then who supplied the chemicals?

Çyämasundara däsa: Scientists are not so concerned with who, but with the existing phenomena.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Mere study of phenomena is childish. Real science means finding the original cause. Darwin may have studied this island or that island, or he may have dug holes in this desert or that desert, but he has not seen the other millions of planets that are existing in the universe. He has not excavated and dug into the depths of all the other planets. How, then, can he conclude that this is all? He speaks of natural selection, but he has not perfectly studied nature. He has only studied nature functioning in a particular place, and a very small place at that. When we speak of nature, we refer to prakåti. We refer to the universe. There are millions of universes, and Darwin has not studied them, yet he is drawing all these conclusions. There is certainly natural selection, but Darwin does not know how it is working. Darwin's defect is that he has no information of the soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: The fact remains that excavations throughout the world prove the existence of species that no longer exist on this planet.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But nature is not confined to this one planet. When you speak of material nature, you must include all the planets in the universe.

Çyämasundara däsa: But the scientists have no evidence that all the species have been existing from time immemorial.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You cannot give evidence that the sun existed millions of years ago; still, we conclude that it did. The sun was not just created this morning. Within the sun, everything is existing, and if the sun is existing, other things must be existing also. Darwin draws conclusions about nature from a limited study of this one planet. This is not full knowledge. If your knowledge is not perfect, why should we accept your theories? Whether complex life-forms were existing on this planet millions of years ago is not really the point. All these forms are existing in nature. According to the Vedas, the species in nature are fixed at 8,400,000. These may or may not be existing in your neighborhood, but that is not important. The number is fixed, and they are simultaneously existing. There may be an evolution from simpler forms to more complex, but it is not that a species becomes extinct. Real evolution is the evolution of the soul through the existing species. Now, we admit that with the changes of seasons, or with extreme heat or cold, differences may arise, but it is not that the species are new. If there is a great flood, and all the men on earth are drowned, the human species is not extinct. Man may or may not survive certain catastrophes; this does not affect the species. We cannot say that the human species is extinct, but that under these circumstances man has survived or not survived. Whatever the case, human beings are existing somewhere else.

Çyämasundara däsa: When the Padma Puräëa says that there are 400,000 species of human life, what does it mean?

Çréla Prabhupäda: There are differences in culture and in body types. Scientists will say that human beings are all of one species, but when they speak of species, they mean something different. The Vedas, for instance, would consider the Negroes and Aryans to belong to different species. As far as Kåñëa consciousness is concerned, bodies may differ; it doesn't matter. Our classification is on the basis of the soul. The soul is equal despite different types of bodies. The soul is one and does not change.

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

"The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog, and a dog-eater [outcaste]." (Bg. 5.18) One who sees to the bottom, sees the soul. Because Darwin and other material scientists have no information of the soul, they have missed the whole point. On the material platform, one material form may be superior to another, just as one apartment may be better than another, but these are material considerations. Now, according to our position, we may evolve from lower apartments to higher, but it can also work the other way around. If we are not able to pay the rent or price for a higher apartment, we have to enter a lower one. It is not that the soul is necessarily progressing from lower to higher forms.

Çyämasundara däsa: Darwin would claim that all living things on earth are evolving from lower to higher.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Generally, that may be accepted because at certain periods people may be constructing certain types of apartments, but the apartments themselves are not evolving. Evolution takes place within the apartment according to the desire of the jéva, the living entity. Darwin thinks that it is the apartment that is changing, but actually it is the desire of the jéva. According to our mentality at the time of death, we get a certain type of apartment. In any case, the apartment is already there. It is not that I have to create it. The types of apartments are fixed at 8,400,000, and we can enter into any of them. You cannot conceive of a type of apartment beyond this number. A hotel keeper knows that different customers want different types of facilities; therefore he makes arrangements to receive all kinds of customers. Similarly, this is God's creation, and God knows how many different ways a living entity can think and desire; therefore God has created all these species. If the living entity thinks in a certain way, God says, "Come on. Here is the body that you want."

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

"The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities, which are in actuality carried out by nature." (Bg. 3.27) Nature is giving us all facilities. God, as the Paramätmä within the heart of everyone, knows what the living entity wants, and orders nature to give it to him.

Çyämasundara däsa: But presently we see that on this planet there are no longer any dinosaurs. That type of apartment is no longer available.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As I said before, you may or may not have seen dinosaurs. In any case, you have certainly not seen all the 8,400,000 species of life. This does not mean that these species are no longer existing. They may be existing on some other planet. You have no information of this. Scientists are experimenting with their imperfect senses, but we are receiving knowledge from a different source. Regardless of the amount of scientific research, the conclusions will always be imperfect because the senses are imperfect.

Hayagréva däsa: At first, Darwin was a Christian, but his faith in the existence of a personal God eventually faded. He finally wrote: "The whole subject is beyond the scope of man's intellect—The mystery of the beginning of things is insoluble by us, and I for one must be content to remain an agnostic...." He based The Origin of Species on evidence he had amassed on a voyage around the world from 1830 to 1836.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In any case, his research was limited. He certainly could not have investigated all the species on the planet.

Hayagréva däsa: He spent the rest of his life writing about the information he gathered during this voyage. According to his theory of natural selection, the best and fittest survive, and therefore the race necessarily and steadily improves. But then, in Kali-yuga, isn't there steady degeneration?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we can actually see that the human race has become degraded.

Hayagréva däsa: What is the cause of this?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Improper education. Every individual person is a soul, and each has a particular type of body. The human body in particular requires education. The soul evolves through various species according to his desires. Material nature supplies the bodies, acting under the orders of God. God exists within the core of everyone's heart, and when the individual soul desires something, material nature, following the orders of God, gives him a machine in the form of a body. When we attain the human form, we can either regress to the animal form, or make spiritual progress. Animals also have desires, but they change bodies and species according to the laws of nature. The human body in particular is meant for understanding God, acting accordingly, and returning home, back to Godhead. If we do not utilize this opportunity, we regress to lower species.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to the Vedic version, were there higher life forms on this planet millions of years ago?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. The Vedas inform us that the first created creature within this universe is also the most intelligent—Lord Brahmä. How, then, can we accept the theory that the intellect develops over so many millions of years? We receive Vedic knowledge from Brahmä, who was instructed by Kåñëa. Darwin's theory that intellect developed is not scientific. It is merely a suggestion, a guess.

Çyämasundara däsa: When Brahmä created, were there also other developed life-forms beside man?

Çréla Prabhupäda: All the forms have been existing since the creation.

Çyämasundara däsa: What evidence do we have that higher life-forms existed on this planet millions of years ago?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The authority of Vedic literature.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what other authority is acceptable? If we dig up a bone and make a test with our senses, isn't that authoritative?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is bone authority. You may be satisfied with such authority, but we have our own. You will accept your authority, and I will accept mine. That is a different matter. Scientific authority is always relative, just like scientific knowledge. Theories are always being contradicted by other theories. Has Darwin gone down to the bottom of the sea and excavated there? Who has dug into the layers of the earth below the sea to find out what is there? All Mr. Frog knows is that his well is only three feet deep and three feet wide. If you tell him of the existence of the Atlantic Ocean, he will say, "How big is it? Twice as big as my well? Ten times as big?" Since he can never conceive of the Atlantic Ocean, what good will his investigations do? What knowledge can he have of the vast ocean? Therefore we must take knowledge from one who has created the Atlantic Ocean. In this way, our knowledge will be perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: But certain of Darwin's theories appear factual. For instance, no one can deny the fact that the fittest survive.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We may try to adjust things, but if our adjustments are not approved by the Supreme, they will not be successful. According to nature's way, parents have affection for their children, but if parents do not take care of them, the children will not survive. Still, the parents' care is not the last word. If the child is condemned by the Supreme Lord, he will not exist despite the parents' care. In other words, we have to go to the Supreme Lord if we ultimately want to survive. If Kåñëa does not want us to survive, we will not be able to survive, despite all our attempts. All these natural laws are working under one controller, God. Electricity may serve many purposes, but the powerhouse is one. It is generating energy for all. We may utilize the same electrical current to serve different purposes, but the power is the same.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, the same current may be working in both the deer and the tiger, but the tiger is able to kill the deer. In this case, one survives, and the other does not.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the law of karma, no one will survive. The body is the field of activity, and we are given license to act within this body for some time. That is all. There is no question of survival.

Çyämasundara däsa: By survival, Darwin means that the species will survive.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no question of survival. The species are always there.

Çyämasundara däsa: But why is there no evidence that human civilizations existed on this earth millions of years ago?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our evidence for a previous Vedic civilization is çruti, spoken evidence. For instance, Vyäsadeva received Vedic knowledge from Närada, and Närada received Vedic knowledge from Lord Brahmä millions and millions of years ago. We can hardly calculate one of Brahmä's days in which fourteen Manus come and go. Each Manu lives for 306,720,000 years. According to the Vedic calculations, millions, billions, and trillions of years are not very astonishing. When Brahmä was born, he was educated by God. This means that this Vedic philosophy was existing then.

Çyämasundara däsa: But if the earth is so old, it must have undergone many transformations.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but this doesn't matter. After one day of Brahmä, there is devastation. Brahmä lives for a hundred years composed of his incredibly long days, and at the end of each day there is devastation. So there are many devastations, and we are not very amazed to hear about them. Nor are we amazed at hearing about the passage of millions and trillions of years. This is nothing. According to Vedic historical methods, trillions and trillions of years account for nothing. Even though we do not find evidence of civilization existing on this earth millions of years ago, we cannot conclude that there was no civilization. We can only conclude that our knowledge is imperfect.

Hayagréva däsa: Debating against Darwinism, William Jennings Bryan, a famous lawyer and politician, said, "They (the Darwinists) do not dare to tell you that it began with God and ended with God—Darwin says the beginning of all things is a mystery unsolvable by us. He does not pretend to say how these things started."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The material world is created, and the living entities are allowed to act within it. Since the living entities all come from God, God says béjaà mäà sarva-bhütänäà viddhi pärtha sanätanam. "O son of Påthä, know that I am the original seed of all existences." (Bg. 7.10) Material nature is the mother, and God, the father, gives the béjaà, the seed. The mother's womb cannot produce in itself, but when the spiritual seed is given, the body can form and develop. The living entity, an eternal part and parcel of God, is put into material nature and develops a body according to his desire. This is the actual beginning of life.

Hayagréva däsa: According to the Biblical version, God created man in His image some six thousand years ago.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It was not so recent. According to the Vedas, this creation goes back millions and millions of years. Whatever the case, God created this cosmic manifestation and impregnated it with living entities to appear in different species according to their desires. The individual soul proposes, and God disposes. All the species have been existing from the very beginning. It is not that there was no human form in the beginning of the creation. This is very easy to understand. The body is created by material nature, and the soul, part and parcel of God, is placed into the body according to his desires. Material energy is called the inferior energy of God, and the living entity, the individual soul, is called the superior energy. Both come from God, and therefore it is said that God, the Absolute Truth, is He from whom everything flows.

Hayagréva däsa: In The Descent of Man, Darwin writes: "The idea of a universal and beneficent creator does not seem to arise in the mind of man until he has been elevated by a long continued culture."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, culture is very important, because we can be elevated by spiritual association. According to our cultural life, we can go to higher planetary systems, remain where we are, or go back home, back to Godhead. Therefore culture is most important.

Çyämasundara däsa: Darwin felt that if we could sufficiently understand the evolutionary process, we could control it. Today, people speak of conquering nature, and claim that man is now living a longer, healthier life than ever before.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is just more nonsense. My grandmother lived ninety-six years, but I don't expect to live that long. The life span is decreasing. People are not sufficiently healthy because they are not getting proper food. Where is the medicine that puts an end to all disease? Every time you discover new medicines, new diseases come along. There is no question of stopping them. Even if you find a cure for cancer, you cannot put an end to death. However great our scientific advancements may be, we can never put an end to birth, old age, disease, and death. The attempt is a waste of time. Our business is to utilize our time in such a way that after giving up this material body, we can return home, back to Godhead.

Çyämasundara däsa: Darwin made the evolution of species seem so mechanically arranged that God is removed from the picture. It appears as if combinations of ingredients created animals, and that they evolved from one another.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Combination means God, because it is God who is combining. It is not that the combination takes place automatically. A cook combines many ingredients when he is making a preparation. It is not that the ingredients can combine themselves. Darwin should have asked how the combination comes about, but it appears that he did not even raise this question. Material elements, ingredients, do not combine automatically. There must be a living entity who combines them.

Çyämasundara däsa: One theory is that everything emanates from some energy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That energy must belong to the energetic. When a computer works, there must be someone pushing the button. According to the Vedas, as soon as God wishes, material energy is immediately set into action. Then things emerge automatically. A man may say that there is no God behind the material energy, but if God withdrew such a man's speaking power, he would not even have the ability to deny God's existence. In order to support Darwin's theories, Western philosophers and historians reject the fact that the Vedic literatures were composed thousands of years ago. But the discovery of the Ajanta Caves proves that there were very intelligent people living many thousands of years ago. But these scientists are simply searching after bones. What is more important? Välméki's Rämäyaëa, or a pile of bones?

In ages past, the memories of the students were very sharp because they were pure brahmacärés, strictly celibate. There was no need to write these literatures down. According to the çruti system, the student heard the subject matter once from the spiritual master, and after that he could recall every word. Now Darwin and other material scientists are trying to understand phenomena, Kåñëa's energy, but they are not interested in knowing the source of this energy. Kåñëa says, ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù. "I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds." (Bg. 10.8) If we are Kåñëa conscious, we know that Kåñëa is the original source of all energy. If a person becomes a chemist or physicist, his duty should be to prove that Kåñëa is the original source of all energy. Then his knowledge of chemistry and physics is perfect. People want knowledge through the modern scientific method; therefore if one is a real scientist, it is his duty to prove that this material energy is coming from Kåñëa. If one is a biologist, or naturalist, it is his duty to prove that all life-forms are coming from Kåñëa. Unfortunately, scientists are thinking, "Oh, we shall create something." But they cannot create anything because God is doing all the creating. They are trying to imitate God just as a child seeing his mother cooking. "Oh, I shall cook too!" It is childish play, and for this play they are spending much labor and many billions of dollars. They try to create a human in a test tube, but every day many humans are being born. They are trying to create something artificial, that's all. By God's multi-energies, everything is being created automatically. All ingredients are given by Kåñëa. Your intelligence and your body are given by Kåñëa. He gives us everything, and we cannot do anything without Him. When we act, we should try to satisfy Kåñëa; then our action will be successful. It is not possible to go outside the boundaries of Kåñëa.

DS:Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-1895)

Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-1895)

Hayagréva däsa: Huxley felt that the main difference between man and the animals is the ability to speak. In his essay "Man and the Lower Animals," he writes: "Man alone possesses the marvelous endowment of intelligible rational speech, whereby...he has slowly accumulated and organized the experience which is almost lost with the cessation of every individual life and other animals"

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is another misconception. Everyone speaks his own language. Animals have theirs, and human beings theirs.

Hayagréva däsa: He specifically mentions "intelligible, rational speech."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Animals have rational speech.

Hayagréva däsa: They may be able to articulate certain basic facts to one another, but they have no culture or history. They have not been able to accumulate and organize the experience of their species.

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Vedic tradition, the Sanskrit language is the mother of all languages and is spoken in the higher planetary systems, but this is not to say that one is an animal if he doesn't speak Sanskrit. Everyone has his own language—Englishmen, Indians, animals, birds, whatever. It is education that is really important, not language. A human being with developed consciousness can receive a spiritual education, whereas animals cannot. That is the main difference. It is not basically a question of language, because knowledge can be imparted in any language, just as we are imparting Vedic knowledge in English and other languages. It is not language that distinguishes man from the lower species, but knowledge. Animals cannot receive knowledge of God, but a human being, regardless of his language, can understand God if knowledge is properly imparted to him.

Hayagréva däsa: Although Huxley defended Darwin's theory of evolution, he differed in his belief in the survival of those who are "ethically the best." In Evolution and Ethics, he writes: "Social progress means a checking of the cosmic process at every step and the substitution for it of another, which may be called the ethical process; the end of which is not the survival of those who may happen to be the fittest... but of those who are ethically the best."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The cosmic process cannot be checked. It continues functioning in different modes: goodness, passion, and ignorance. In the mode of goodness, there is advancement, but ultimately the individual has to transcend the mode of goodness to come to the platform of the all-good, the platform of pure goodness. In the material world, whatever process we accept for advancement is conditioned by goodness, passion, and ignorance. It is very difficult in the material world to keep a process pure; therefore the soul must come to the platform of goodness and then transcend it. The platform of pure goodness is called bhakti, and on that platform our transactions are only with God. It is only when we come to that platform that we can survive. Otherwise, no one survives, because everyone has to continue transmigrating from one body to another. Tathä dehäntara-präptir (Bg. 2.13). However, when we come to the platform of pure goodness, we can understand God and transcend repeated birth and death.

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9) Apart from this, there is no meaning to survival. Survival means that the soul remains pure in its original position and does not transmigrate. Survival is only in the spiritual world, where there is no change.

Çyämasundara däsa: Huxley believed that it is within our own hands to guide our ethical evolution.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is certainly within our hands. First of all, you hear that it is wrong to steal and that those who steal go to jail. Then it is up to you to steal or not.

Çyämasundara däsa: Huxley believed that we have to qualify ourselves ethically to be worthy to survive. It is not just a question of the physically fittest.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nobody is fit to survive. This idea of survival is simply nonsense. However, we can elevate our consciousness and that of all human society by this Kåñëa consciousness process. This is a question of education. When we become Kåñëa conscious, we become worthy to survive. We no longer have to undergo the process of transmigration.

Çyämasundara däsa: Huxley maintains that the most morally worthy ought to survive.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The most morally worthy is he who is Kåñëa conscious. There is no question of ought; rather, he will survive. But as far as morality is concerned, what is Huxley's morality? We say that cow killing is immoral, but others say that it is moral because by eating beef, the body is developed. Which morality is more worthy for us to select? There are many questions like this, and one person says that this is moral, whereas another says it is immoral. Of course, the meat eaters claim that morality depends on what the majority wants—that is, the majority of meat eaters. Such people will naturally agree that cow killing is very nice, but does this make cow killing moral?

Çyämasundara däsa: Huxley believes that because nature is amoral, man must not imitate but must combat nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no question of combatting nature. You cannot conquer nature. Of course, everyone is perpetually trying to fight nature, but in Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14) It is impossible to defeat material nature. You are trying to live, but material nature deals death to everyone. This combat is going on, but nature is always stronger. No one has ever been successful in battling nature.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is it true that nature is amoral?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nature is most moral because she is abiding by the order of Kåñëa. How can nature be mistaken? In Brahma-saàhitä (5.44) it is said: såñöi-sthiti-pralaya-sädhana-çaktir-ekä chäyeva yasya bhuvanäni vibharti durgä. Durgä, material nature, is so powerful that she can create, maintain, and annihilate.

Çyämasundara däsa: Huxley based his morality on sympathy, and he claimed that nature has no sympathy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nature has all sympathy because she is working under the orders of Kåñëa. Nature is very much like the police. When a person breaks the law, he thinks that the police are most unsympathetic, but if a person abides by the law, the police are friends and protectors. In any case, this is the proposal.

Çyämasundara däsa: It would appear that if one man's house burns down and another man's doesn't, there is no sympathy involved—just arbitrariness and chance.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not arbitrary. It is not by chance. It is clearly stated that material nature is working under the orders of Kåñëa. Since Kåñëa is not immoral, one carrying out His orders cannot be immoral. The apparent punishment dealt by nature is also sympathy. Mother Durgä is always seen with a trident in her hand, and she is always punishing, but this is indirectly moral. She is punishing living entities so that they will become Kåñëa conscious. She puts them in all kinds of miserable conditions in order to bring them to awareness of Kåñëa, to the consciousness whereby they can understand that if they surrender unto Kåñëa, they will be free. It is not possible to conquer nature by material contrivances. We can conquer nature only by rendering devotional service to the Lord. The material attempt to conquer or control nature is man's disease, his attempt to imitate Kåñëa. Such imitation is never perfection.

Çyämasundara däsa: Still, Huxley felt that man could improve his environment. Agriculturally, for instance.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but although the governments are promising people more and more, the people are becoming more miserable. They give man food to eat, facilities to sleep, to have sex life, and assurance from danger. These are the primary necessities, and even an animal can be satisfied with these. But man cannot. Because he has developed consciousness, man wants something more. Therefore in human society there is music, art, philosophy, and religion. But if man utilizes his developed consciousness simply to eat, sleep, defend, and mate, he will never be satisfied. Man's higher consciousness should be utilized to develop Kåñëa consciousness. The material struggle for survival is not natural. Struggle is unnatural. Our natural condition is enjoyment.

Çyämasundara däsa: But, by use of intelligence, can't man come to understand the world, and in this way make his own world?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

antavat tu phalaà teñäà
tad bhavaty alpa-medhasäm
devän deva-yajo yänti
mad-bhaktä yänti mäm api

"Men of small intelligence worship the demigods, and their fruits are limited and temporary. Those who worship the demigods go to the planets of the demigods, but My devotees ultimately reach My supreme planet." (Bg. 7.23) It is up to you. If you want to remain here, you can. Kåñëa has given us intelligence and all facilities. It is now up to us to make our choice, whether to go to heaven, hell, or to Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: Huxley looked on civilization as something of an attempt to give order to nature. Civilization might be defined then as a complex ethical understanding between men enabling as many men as possible to survive.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not possible. You cannot dictate to nature; rather, nature will dictate death to you. According to the laws of material nature, there is no question of survival. When you can actually dictate to material nature, then you can survive. This is possible only through Brahman realization, as explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

mäà ca yo'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman." (Bg. 14.26)

Hayagréva däsa: Huxley saw the Indian philosopher as buckling under a stronger cosmos. He writes: "By the Ganges, ethical man admits that the cosmos is too strong for him—"

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Hayagréva däsa: "—and destroying every bond which ties him to it by ascetic discipline, he seeks salvation in absolute renunciation."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct.

Hayagréva däsa: However, Huxley saw this attempt as "flight from the battlefield." Exhorting Englishmen to cosmic battle, he writes, "We are grown men, and must play the man 'strong in will to strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.'"

Çréla Prabhupäda: And at last to die. He may not yield, but nature will kick him and say, "You must die." In any case, Mr. Huxley is no longer surviving. Whether we be Englishmen, Frenchmen, Americans, or whatever, we cannot survive but have to succumb to the dictations of material nature. According to Bhagavad-gétä:

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

"The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities, which are in actuality carried out by nature." (Bg. 3.27) It is false ego that says, "I shall survive. I am an Englishman." According to the law of nature, death is unavoidable for everyone; therefore the intelligent man first of all considers how he can transcend death. It is explained in Bhagavad-gétä that if we understand Kåñëa, we can survive.

Hayagréva däsa: It is not that Huxley believed in any kind of material immortality. In Evolution and Ethics, he writes of transmigration and karma: "Every sentient being is reaping as it has sown; if not in this life, then in one or other of the infinite series of antecedent existences of which it is the latest term." Also, of Indian philosophy: "The substance of the cosmos was Brahman, that of individual man Ätman; and the latter was separated from the former only, if I may so speak, by its phenomenal envelope, by the casing of sensations, thoughts, and desires, pleasures and pains, which make up the illusive phantasmagoria of life."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Brahman is not separated from ätmä; rather, they are eternally co-existing. That is explained in the Thirteenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, wherein Çré Kåñëa discusses the body, kñetra, which is the field of action, and the ätmä, the individual soul, who is the owner of the field and who works in it. It is also pointed out that there is another owner:

upadrañöänumantä ca
bhartä bhoktä maheçvaraù
paramätmeti cäpy ukto
dehe 'smin puruñaù paraù

"Yet in this body there is another, a transcendental enjoyer who is the Lord, the supreme proprietor, who exists as the overseer and permitter, and who is known as the Supersoul." (Bg. 13.23) The ätmä, the individual soul, knows only his own body, but the Supersoul knows everything about everybody. I may know the pains and pleasures of my body, but I am ignorant of the pains and pleasures of another. The Supersoul, Paramätmä, knows everything about all bodies in the universe. There is no question of separation; rather, the two are eternally co-existing.

Hayagréva däsa: Huxley's understanding is similar to that of the Saìkarites: the ätmä is imprisoned within the body, and when he attains enlightenment, "the bubble of illusion will burst, and the freed individual Ätman will lose itself in the universal Brahman."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This does not mean that the ätmä becomes Paramätmä. A drop of water may merge into the sea, but it does not become the sea. The sea remains the same, whether a drop of water merges with it or not. When a green bird enters a green tree, you may not be able to see the bird anymore, but it is foolish to think that the bird has become one with the tree. The individual ätmä retains his individuality, although our defective vision may not be able to perceive it. The Saìkarites mistakenly think that the individual soul merges with the Supreme and becomes the Supreme, but this is not the case. In all cases, he retains his individuality.

Hayagréva däsa: Huxley writes: "There was no external power which could effect the sequence of cause and effect which gives rise to karma; none but the will of the subject of the karma which could put an end to it."

Çréla Prabhupäda: As long as the individual soul acts according to bodily designations, he is not free. When he gives up these designations and agrees to become Kåñëa-däsa, the servant of Kåñëa, he saves himself.

Hayagréva däsa: But is there any question of liberation independent of Kåñëa?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. It is explained in Bhagavad-gétä (Bg. 3.9) that we should work only for Kåñëa. Otherwise, we become entangled. Freeom means acting on behalf of the Supreme. By acting in this way, we are not bound by karma. When a soldier follows his orders and kills on the battlefield, he receives medals, but as soon as he kills one man on his own behalf, he is considered a murderer and is subject to be hanged. This is karma-bandhanaù, bondage to karma. The act may be the same, but in one instance the soldier is acting under the orders of the state, and in the other he is acting for his own sense gratification. Similarly, when you act for Kåñëa, you act in freedom, and when you act for yourself, you are bound by karma. That is the main teaching throughout Bhagavad-gétä. Arjuna was thinking of leaving the battlefield due to personal considerations, but when he understood that it was his duty to fight on Kåñëa's behalf, he agreed.

Hayagréva däsa: In Evolution and Ethics, Huxley tries to relate karma to evolution: "In the theory of evolution, the tendency of a germ to develop according to a certain specific type...is its karma....The snow-drop is a snowdrop and not an oak, and just that kind of snowdrop, because it is the outcome of the karma of an endless series of past existences."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct. This process is called karma-bandhanaù. One takes on one body after another until he reaches the human form. He is then capable of deciding whether he should continue or put an end to this process of karma-bandhanaù by surrendering to Kåñëa. If he surrenders to Kåñëa, the process stops, and if he does not, the process continues according to the laws of nature.

Hayagréva däsa: As soon as Huxley became a Darwinist, he rejected a supernatural God and the Bible, proclaiming that "argument from design" had "received its death blow." Unlike Spinoza, he did not accept a pantheistic God, but believed in "the Divine government of the universe," and felt that the cosmic process is rational and not accidental. Still, he rejected a personal God concerned with morality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a mistake. Nature in itself is not rational; it is simply dead matter. A piece of wood is not rational, but the carpenter who shapes it is. The cosmic process may be rational, but this is only because there is a rational being behind it. That rational being is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Nature cannot be rational out of its own accord any more than a piece of wood can become a table without a carpenter.

Çyämasundara däsa: Huxley felt that man must remain an agnostic because he cannot know God, even though God may exist.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why can man not know Him?

Çyämasundara däsa: Because He does not appear in phenomenal form.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what if He appears? You say that you cannot see Him in a phenomenal form, but God can appear and teach you. Then you can know Him. We don't try to attain knowledge of God by speculating, nor do we try to get knowledge of God from fools, rascals, and philosophers. We take knowledge directly from God Himself. God appears and gives us the instructions of Bhagavad-gétä, and we take our knowledge from this.

Çyämasundara däsa: In any case, Huxley agreed that we can never realize God by the empiric method.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is nice. We agree that God cannot be known by our present senses. However, we do not agree that God cannot be known at all. The present senses can be purified by Kåñëa consciousness, and with purified senses, we can come to know God.

Çyämasundara däsa: Huxley also introduced the conception called epiphenomenalism, the belief that the mind and consciousness are products of the physical process.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We also accept the fact that the mind is physical and that consciousness is also physical and yet subtle.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Huxley, when the body dies, the mind and consciousness also die.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But he has no information of the soul. Wherever there is the soul, there is mind, consciousness, and everything else. The mind, consciousness, and intelligence are all present, but now they are materially contaminated. What we have to do is to purify them. It is not that we are to try to make our mind, consciousness and intelligence nil. That is not possible.

Çyämasundara däsa: But when the body dies, does the individual consciousness also die with it?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. How can you die? Your consciousness simply carries you to another body.

DS:Henri Bergson (1859-1941)

Henri Bergson (1859-1941)

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson maintained that God's reality can be intuited only by mystical experience. The creative effort "is of God if it is not God Himself." This knowledge of God leads to activity, not passivity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, knowledge of God certainly leads to activity. For instance, in bhakti-yoga we are engaged twenty-four hours daily in Kåñëa's service. It is not that we just sit down and meditate. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that the best activity is to preach the message of Bhagavad-gétä:

ya idaà paramaà guhyaà
mad-bhakteñv abhidhäsyati
bhaktià mayi paräà kåtvä
mäm evaiñyaty asaàçayaù

"For one who explains the supreme secret to the devotees, devotional service is guaranteed, and at the end he will come back to Me." (Bg. 18.68) This is also Caitanya Mahäprabhu's order: "Become a guru by spreading Kåñëa consciousness." To be a guru means to be active.

Hayagréva däsa: The word "mystic" can have many different meanings. When Bergson says that God's reality can be intuited only by mystical experience, what is meant?

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is mystical for one who does not know God, but for one who knows God and receives orders from Him, God is a perceivable person. The word "mystic" may imply something vague or obscure.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson believed that the mystic who has contact with God can lead others and teach them to become godly.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is very nice. Then by "mystic," he means God's representative. That is the spiritual master who is following in the disciplic succession. The Bhagavad-gétä tells us to approach a guru who has realized the truth, God. It is not that the mystic poses himself to be God. No, he surrenders unto Kåñëa and teaches others to do so. In this way, he teaches us how to become godly. Actually, it is better to say God conscious instead of godly. One who is God conscious is a true mystic.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to modern interpretations, a mystic is someone mysterious or magical.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the meaning has degraded to that because so many gurus come over, display miracles, and claim to be God. So these rascals are misleading the unintelligent who want to see miracles, and the unintelligent look on these miracles as mysticism. It is another case of the cheaters and the cheated.

Hayagréva däsa: Originally, the Greek word mystikos referred to one initiated in secret religious rites, and today the word has degenerated to mean something obscure or occult. For Bergson, a mystic is one who can commune with God through contemplation and love, participate in God's love for mankind, and aid the divine purpose. This is the real meaning of "creative evolution."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, everyone is in ignorance due to a long separation from God. In the material world, the living entity has forgotten his relationship with God; therefore he acts only for sense gratification. He awakens to his real life when he is given instructions on how to become God conscious; otherwise, he lives like an animal. Sentiment is one thing, but when religion is understood in the light of good logic and philosophy, we can attain a perfect understanding of God. Without philosophy, religion is simply sentiment. Sentiment in itself does not help very much. A sentimentalist may be interested one day and disinterested another. As stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, religion means learning how to love God. At the present moment, in our physical condition, we cannot see God, but by hearing about Him, we can develop our dormant love.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson envisioned two types of religion: static and dynamic. Static religion is comprised of myths devised by human intelligence as a means of defense against life's miseries. Fearful of the future, man attempts to overcome his condition by constructing religious myths.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Whatever is created by human beings is not acceptable. We do not follow such faiths because human beings are always imperfect. We cannot accept anything manufactured by human beings; we must take our information directly from God, as it is given in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Bhagavad-gétä and other scriptures. Dharmaà tu säkñäd bhagavat-praëétam. "Real religious principles are enacted by the Supreme Personality of Godhead." (Bhäg. 6.3.19) Kåñëa says, "Surrender unto Me." This is real religion. It is not man-made. Man is constantly creating so many ism's, but these are not perfect. Religion that leads us to surrender to God is real religion. Otherwise it is bogus.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Bergson, real religion is dynamic.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is so. It is not static because it is on the spiritual platform. The spirit is the dynamic force in this body. There is no question of the spirit being static.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson says that prompted by the vital impulse, by dynamic religion, the human will identifies with the divine will in a mystical union.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. We are teaching people to agree with the divine will, which means surrendering to God. Oneness means agreeing with this teaching.

Çyämasundara däsa: Real religion is a mystic oneness with God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, oneness means that I agree with God. God says, "Surrender," and I say, "Yes, I surrender." God tells Arjuna, "Fight," and Arjuna fights. Oneness means that we agree with God on all points.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson felt that the greatest obstacle to creative evolution is the struggle with materialism. He believed that politics and economic reforms cannot help matters.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Politics and economic reforms can help provided they are properly guided—that is, provided they aim at helping our understanding of our relationship with God. Vedic civilization was divided into four varëas and four äçramas, and these divisions were meant to help people develop their dormant God consciousness. Unfortunately, today the kñatriyas, the administrators, have forgotten the real objective of human life. Now they are thinking only of caring for the body, living comfortably, and gratifying their senses. But that is not the real purpose of human civilization.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson believed that the spirit of mysticism must be kept alive by the fortunate few who know God "until such time as a profound change in the material conditions imposed on humanity by nature should permit, in spiritual matters, of a profound transformation."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and this Kåñëa consciousness movement is dedicated to bringing about this change. I have already said that a perfect society is centered in love of God. This love is without motive. It is a natural love, like the love between a son and his father or mother. The material conditions provoke certain bodily demands: eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. At present, people are interested only in these four activities.

Hayagréva däsa: How are these material conditions going to change?

Çréla Prabhupäda: These daily bodily necessities will remain, but in addition, people should understand God and His instructions. That will bring about change. We are not neglecting the bodily necessities, but we realize that our main business is advancing in Kåñëa consciousness. Presently, Kåñëa consciousness is not supported by the state or social leaders. People are busy thinking of eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. It is not that these activities stop when we are Kåñëa conscious; rather, they are regulated.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson was optimistic in his belief that the mystics, through love, would eventually help mankind return to God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this is the real purpose of human life. Man has the opportunity afforded by nature to understand the instructions of the Vedas and the spiritual master. Only a suicidal civilization remains in darkness, concerned only with the bodily necessities.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Bergson, the nature of God is love, through which the world comes into being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, of course God loves. Unless He loves, why does He come down personally to give us instructions through the scriptures?

Hayagréva däsa: In Creative Evolution, Bergson writes: "For an ego which does not change does not endure, and a psychic state which remains the same so long as it is not replaced by the following state does not endure either." He sees all psychic states of the individual, including the ego, as constantly changing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is the false ego that says, "I am this body." By education, we can come to understand that we are spirit soul. Then the activities of the soul begin. The first lesson of Bhagavad-gétä instructs us that the living entity is not the material body but the soul within. That soul is Brahman, pure spirit. Once we understand that we are not the body, our struggle to maintain the body stops. Brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä (Bg. 18.54). Once we understand that we are spirit soul, we concern ourselves with elevating the spirit soul to the highest perfection. We then come to understand that we are not only spirit soul, but that everyone else is spirit soul as well. We then want everyone to be given a chance to attain perfect understanding.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson's Vitalism states that the life force cannot be explained by physics and chemistry or the other sciences. It is separate from Darwin's mechanical laws. Science will never be able to accurately explain the source of life, which is nonmaterial.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is very nice. He is speaking of the soul, but he is unable to capture the idea positively. It is true that the soul is not controlled by physical laws, and that is verified by Bhagavad-gétä itself:

nainaà chindanti çasträëi
nainaà dahati pävakaù
na cainaà kledayanty äpo
na çoñayati märutaù

"The soul can never be cut into pieces by any weapon, nor can he be burned by fire, nor moistened by water, nor withered by the wind." (Bg. 2.23) The vital force, or the soul, can be temporarily covered by physical elements, but the soul itself does not belong to any of the physical elements. The soul is a living force, and it has a little independence. The supreme living force is God, and the individual soul is part and parcel of God, just as sparks are part of a great fire. The individual soul misuses his independence when he himself wants to become God and lord it over material nature. He then falls from his purely spiritual position into the physical encagement, and, forgetting his real identity, he thinks that he is the body. But he is not. The body is a circumstantial covering, a dress. The living, vital force is different.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson says that the reality, the living force, is always in a state of becoming and never at rest. Logical or scientific explanations are ineffective because they deal with static problems.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, so-called scientists do not know the real basic principle; therefore they are misled and misleading. The soul is living force. The soul has a little independence, and he wants to enjoy the material world, which he cannot do. By running after phantasmagoria and trying to lord it over material nature, he becomes more and more entrapped.

Çyämasundara däsa: Being constantly dynamic, changing, and unpredictable, the life force is too elusive for scientific investigation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this is so. Because it is living force, it must be dynamic. Living force is not dead stone. We are all living force. We may be sitting here now, or we may be leaving. No one can check these movements in time. Not even God interferes with our dynamic force. He allows us to do whatever we like. If God interferes with our independence, we are no longer living entities. We become dead stones. Therefore God does not interfere; He gives us full freedom. At the same time, He comes down to instruct us, saying, "Why are you so engaged in this foolish activity? Please come to Me, back home, back to Godhead. Then you will be happy."

Çyämasundara däsa: For Bergson, the unpredictable life force is constantly creating new things.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is creating new things in the material phenomena, but when the life force is spiritually situated, there are no such changes. Our only business is to serve Kåñëa. And even in the service of Kåñëa, there are many varieties, but those are spiritual varieties. At the present moment, we are creating material varieties and a variety of bodies, all subject to the threefold miseries and to birth, death, old age, and disease. As long as we are materially entrapped, our dynamic force is creating trouble, and we are becoming more and more entangled.

Çyämasundara däsa: Can we ever predict the movements of the life force?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is moving in a variety of dresses, but its ultimate future is to return home, back to Godhead. But because the individual soul is acting unintelligently, he has to be kicked in the face very strongly by material nature. Then he will come to his senses. That is his position. When he thinks intelligently, he realizes that it is his duty to serve Kåñëa instead of his own material body. In this material world, we see that everybody is trying to be happy, but everyone is constantly being frustrated. This is because material happiness ultimately means frustration. This is mäyä's way of kicking.

Çyämasundara däsa: In any case, the life force will eventually return to Godhead?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, everyone will sooner or later. Some sooner, and some later.

Çyämasundara däsa: But can we predict that the process of punishment will have some permanent effect? Many prisoners leave the prison, but some come back.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is nothing permanent. Because we have a little independence, we have the freedom to misuse our independence again and return to the prison; otherwise there is no meaning to independence. Independence means that you can do what you like.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson spoke of the soul as elan vital, "vital impulse."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The soul is a living, vital force, and is therefore dynamic. It is never at rest, but is always working through the mind, intelligence, and body.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is the soul present in the same quantity in every living body?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Its measurement is the same: one ten thousandth part of the tip of a hair.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what about its amount of energy?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the same amount of spiritual energy is everywhere, in the ant and in the elephant.

Çyämasundara däsa: When you say that the soul is one ten thousandth part of the tip of a hair, this seems to denote a physical size. That is, this seems to be a physical concept.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Material size and spiritual size are not the same. Spiritual size is permanent, and material size is changing. We give this example of the tip of a hair because you have no spiritual vision. Therefore you have to understand by a material example.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson believes that the qualities of the soul can be perceived only by intuition, not by the senses.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct. The soul cannot be experienced by the senses, but we can understand that the soul is absent from a dead man. We see the dead body, and this is called perception. Then we understand that there is something intangible that is absent, and we call that the soul. This is the process of intuition.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning remembering and forgetting, Bergson writes: "The cerebral mechanism is arranged just so as to drive back into the unconscious almost the whole of this past, and to admit beyond the threshold only that which can cast light on the present situation or further the action now being prepared—in short, only that which can give useful work."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The cerebral mechanism is a machine, just like this microphone. This machine has nothing to do with my voice, but it amplifies it so that others may hear. In this way, the machine can help. Similarly, the brain is a machine that can help us understand God. Human beings have a good machine, but they do not know the use of it. That is their misfortune.

Hayagréva däsa: Doesn't Kåñëa arrange this cerebral mechanism, causing remembrance and forgetfulness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, because He is the supreme power, He can do this. If we persistently want to forget Kåñëa, despite Kåñëa's instructions, Kåñëa, who is within the heart, gives us a chance to become more and more forgetful so that we completely forget our relationship with God. Kåñëa says:

tän ahaà dviñataù krürän
saàsäreñu narädhamän
kñipämy ajasram açubhän
äsuréñv eva yoniñu

"Those who are envious and mischievous, who are the lowest among men, are cast by Me into the ocean of material existence, into various demoniac species of life." (Bg. 16.19) He also says:

sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöo
mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca

"I am seated in everyone's heart, and from Me come remembrance, knowledge, and forgetfulness." (Bg. 15.15) It is Kåñëa's punishment that the living entity remains in perpetual darkness, but it is the mercy of Kåñëa's devotee, the Vaiñëava, that he remembers his relationship with Kåñëa. Therefore Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says, "O Vaiñëava, please accept me as your dog." The cerebral mechanism, the brain, is a machine, and according to one's desires, he remembers Kåñëa or forgets Him. Just as Kåñëa enables the demoniac to be punished, He gives the devotee the intelligence by which he can remember and understand.

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." (Bg. 10.10)

Hayagréva däsa: Can we forget Kåñëa eternally?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, it is not possible. A son may be separated from his father, but it is not possible for him to forget his father eternally. Sometimes he remembers his father. The father is always remembering the son, and looking forward to the time when the son will obey his orders. So there is no question of forgetting perpetually.

Çyämasundara däsa: Because the living entity has independence, at one moment he may be liberated, and at another moment, conditioned?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa has given you liberation. When you misuse your liberation, you become entrapped.

Çyämasundara däsa: But is this all predictable? Can we know it beforehand?

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is the use of all this prediction? The prediction is that the living entity will be kicked, kicked, kicked, and kicked, until someday he will come to Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: So after falling down many times, the living entity will eventually come to Kåñëa and remain permanently. Is that right?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, there is no question of permanence. Because the living entity has independence, he can misuse that independence and fall down again. A man is not permanently free just because he's released from prison. He can return to prison again. There is no guarantee. This is what is meant by eternally conditioned. The living entities in the spiritual sky who are eternally liberated will never be conditioned because they never choose to misuse their independence. They are very experienced.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning karma and transmigration, Bergson writes: "What are we, in fact, what is our character, if not the condensation of the history that we have lived from our birth—nay, even before our birth, since we bring with us prenatal dispositions. Doubtless we think with only a small part of our past, but it is with our entire past, including the original dint of our soul, that we desire, will, and act." Although we cannot recall much of the past, our present state has grown out of it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is our defect that we cannot recall the past; therefore little tests are there to remind us of our opportunity to take advantage of Vedic knowledge. We have forgotten, but our forgetfulness is not perpetual. When we are reminded, we can come to our real consciousness, Kåñëa consciousness. Forgetting Kåñëa, God, people are thinking that they are masters of everything. Many so-called scientists are decrying God, and claiming that they can do everything independently. This attitude is demoniac. Sädhu, çästra, and guru are here to remind us that we are under the clutches of mäyä and that we are not to remain in this position.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson is essentially saying that our past activities have determined what we are today.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is karma. According to our past karmas, we are in a particular position. However, this position can be changed; it is not that it will have to continue indefinitely. Kåñëa says that we are suffering due to our past misdeeds, and this suffering was caused by our not surrendering to Him. If we surrender to Kåñëa, He will put an end to all the reactions of karma. So we do not have to continue to suffer the reactions of our past activities.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson writes: "From this survival of the past, it follows that consciousness cannot go through the same state twice. Circumstances may still be the same, but they will act no longer on the same person, since they find him at a new moment of his history. Our personality, which is being built up each instant with its accumulated experience, changes without ceasing."

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no cessation because the soul is eternal. Consciousness is also eternal, but it is changing according to the circumstances, association, time, place, and personalities involved. Good association is required, because by it, our consciousness can be changed from material to spiritual. The purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to change our consciousness from absorption in material things to Kåñëa. This requires guidance, which is provided by Kåñëa's instructions and the spiritual master. Kåñëa is so kind that He has given us çästra, sädhu, and guru.

Hayagréva däsa: But if the personality is determined by experience, and experience is forgotten at death, then a new personality must emerge at rebirth. How can the personality be built up with accumulated experience?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We may forget our deeds in the past, but Kåñëa does not forget them. He therefore gives us a chance to fulfill previous desires. At death, the body changes, but the soul does not change. The soul continues and brings with him reactions of past deeds. Even though the soul forgets what he has done in the past, Kåñëa is there to remind him that he wanted to do this or that.

Hayagréva däsa: So the person is the same, but the personality changes?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. This personality can be perfected if we follow the instructions of Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: But personality, as we understand it, changes from life to life, doesn't it?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but according to your work, your body will be selected. It is not that you select your body. Because you have acted in a certain way, superior authorities select your body according to your activities.

Hayagréva däsa: If at death the soul takes the mind, intelligence, and ego with it into a new body, isn't it possible for the mind to remember past lives?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and there are many instances of this. Bharata Mahäräja received the body of a deer, but by the grace of Kåñëa he remembered everything about his past life. Although Bharata Mahäräja was a devotee, he neglected his devotional service due to being overly attached to a deer. Since he was thinking of the deer at the time of death, he received the body of a deer, but out of His great mercy, Kåñëa reminded him of his situation. In his next birth, therefore, Mahäräja Bharata was born into a good brähmaëa family.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson says that "our personality shoots, grows, and ripens without ceasing." If this is so, how can the jéva regress to a lower form of life? How could a greater experience be confined to a lesser one?

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to nature's process, everything is calculated at the time of death. Here in Hawaii we see that there are many boys addicted to the water sport called surfing. Now they are creating a mentality which will enable them to become aquatics. So naturally at the time of death they will think of all these things, and nature will give them a body accordingly. We cannot check this process. After death, we are completely under nature's control. We cannot dictate. Since people cannot or will not understand this, they conclude that there is no life after death.

Hayagréva däsa: How could a great personality like Indra, with his mind, intelligence, and ego all intact, possibly become a hog?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, this can be done, because as long as we are materially existing, our thoughts are under the modes of material nature. Sometimes our thoughts are in the mode of goodness, sometimes in passion, and sometimes in ignorance. Accordingly, we go up and down the scale in different species. In order to keep ourselves on the proper platform, we should engage in devotional service. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä:

mäà ca yo'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman." (Bg. 14.26) If we stay on the Brahman platform, there is no degradation. We are trying to do this by engaging ourselves every moment in Kåñëa consciousness.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson saw change as maturation. He writes: "We are seeking only the precise meaning that our consciousness gives to this word, 'exist,' and we find that, for a conscious being, to exist is to change, to change is to mature, to mature is to go on creating oneself endlessly."

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not necessary to struggle to attain our highest position, because that position is indicated by Çré Kåñëa: "Abandon all dharmas and surrender unto Me. I will give you all protection." (Bg. 18.66) Unfortunately, the living entity thinks that Kåñëa is an ordinary human being and therefore incapable of granting the topmost position. Therefore he goes on with his plan making. After many, many births, he finally comes to the conclusion that everything is Kåñëa. Väsudevaù sarvam iti sa mahätmäsudurlabhaù (Bg. 7.19). But why go through many births of struggle? If we at once accept Kåñëa's instructions, we can become perfect immediately.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson sees the life impulse moving through the universe and creating new forms and varieties, just as an artist creates different paintings. The creations progressively improve.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, you might call that evolution. The living entity moves through 8,400,000 species, and each is better than the last, until one comes to the human form. Once he has reached the human platform, he may choose to become a demigod like Lord Brahmä. Brahmä is also a living entity; he is not in the Viñëu category. Yet Brahmä has such power that he can create this universe. God can create infinite universes, but Brahmä can create at least one universe. Of course, from the human form, one can also regress to lower forms.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Bergson, world evolution moves progressively through history as instinct, intelligence, and intuition.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then he agrees that one moves from the lower stages to the higher.

Çyämasundara däsa: To realization?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Realization means arriving at the truth.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson says that understanding through intuition is superior to understanding through the intelligence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct.

Çyämasundara däsa: He sees the creative process as advancing up to the level of immortality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we are receiving different types of bodies, and when we are perfectly situated in Kåñëa consciousness, we no longer receive material bodies.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then although the life force itself is eternal, the forms advance up to the form of immortality?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The forms are changing, but the living force is not changing. The forms are changing, but the person within the forms is permanent. When he identifies with the body, he thinks that he is changing.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is the progress toward human immortality a creative process? By creative, Bergson implies that we are creating our immortality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, you are always immortal. You are immortal by constitution, but you are changing bodies. The process is creative in the sense that you create your own body or your next body as you desire. If you create within yourself the mentality of a dog, you will get the body of a dog in the next life. Similarly, if you create the mentality of a servant of God, you return to Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: In Creative Evolution, Bergson writes: "We may conclude, then, that individuality is never perfect, and that it is often difficult, sometimes impossible, to tell what is an individual, and what is not, but that life nevertheless manifests a search for individuality, as if it strove to constitute systems naturally isolated, naturally closed."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why is there a search for individuality? We are all naturally individuals.

na tv evähaà jätu näsaà
na tvaà neme janädhipäù
na caiva na bhaviñyämaù
sarve vayam ataù param

"Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings; nor in the future shall any of us cease to be." (Bg. 2.12) We are individuals in the past, present, and future. Our individuality is always there, but in quantity we are not as great as Kåñëa. Compared to Him, our intelligence is very meager. When we utilize our individuality properly and follow Kåñëa's instructions, we perfect our lives. Mäyävädé philosophers want to annihilate this individuality, but this is not possible. We are perpetually individuals, and God is also an individual. It is incorrect to think that by killing individuality, we become one with God.

Our individuality is retained. Even though for a time we may think, "I will merge into the existence of God," we will fall down again due to individuality. In any case, there is no need for a search for individuality because we are always individuals.

Hayagréva däsa: According to Bergson, we can see the creation as either coming from God, or moving toward Him. Depending on our viewpoint, "we perceive God as efficient cause or as final cause."

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is always there. He was there before the creation, and when the creation is finished, He will be there. God is not part of the creation. Being the creator, He exists before, during, and after His creation. This is standard Vedic knowledge.

aham eväsam evägre
nänyad yat sad-asat param
paçcäd ahaà yad etac ca
yo 'vaçiñyeta so'smy aham

"It is I, the Personality of Godhead, who was existing before the creation, when there was nothing but Myself. Nor was there the material nature, the cause of this creation. That which you see now is also I, the Personality of Godhead, and after annihilation, what remains will also be I, the Personality of Godhead." (Bhäg. 2.9.33)

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson is saying that God is the beginning, middle, and end, depending on our point of view.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not dependent on our viewpoint. God is always there, but because we are imperfect, we are thinking in this limited way. This cosmic manifestation is a temporary creation to give the individual soul a chance to develop his consciousness. If he does not do so, and there is universal annihilation, he must remain in an unconscious position. When there is creation, he again comes to consciousness. This is the cycle that is going on. But God is always there.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson further writes: "If life realizes a plan, it ought to manifest a greater harmony the further it advances, just as a house shows better and better the idea of the architect as stone is set upon stone. If, on the contrary, the unity of life is to be found solely in the impetus that pushes it along the road of time, the harmony is not in front but behind. The unity is given at the start as an impulsion, not placed at the end as an attraction."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is what is called nature's course. First of all, something is created, it develops, stays for a while, leaves some by-products, grows old, dwindles, and finally vanishes. These are the changes that all material things are subject to, but the spirit soul is not material and therefore has nothing to do with bodily changes. The soul has his perpetual duty and activity, which is devotional service. If we are trained in our perpetual duty, we can put an end to bodily changes, remain in our eternal, spiritual body, and return home, back to Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: So creative evolution must necessarily be the evolution of the soul?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, since the soul is ever existing, there is no question of evolution. As long as the soul is entangled in material existence and bodily conceptions, he thinks that a superior body evolves from an inferior one. However, if his consciousness is changed, there is no changing bodies. He remains in his eternal body.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson thinks that it is the vital force that is guiding everyone and creating its own evolution.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the vital force will determine this. But the individual must be educated to know how to make progress. It is ultimately up to the spirit soul whether to surrender to Kåñëa or not. The living entity has the right to accept or reject. If he takes the right path, he progresses, but if he rejects this path, he will regress. This depends on him.

Hayagréva däsa: There seems to be a basic contradiction between Bergson and the Vedas, as far as the evolution of the universe is concerned.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Anything material, be it the universe or whatever, undergoes the basic changes I mentioned. Since its birth, this universe has been increasing in volume, and that is material change. This has nothing to do with the spiritual. Just as we have a soul within this body, the universe also has a soul within, and that is the Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu. Viñëu is not changing, but the universe is.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson theorizes that the further life advances, the greater harmony is being realized.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is harmonious change, just as a child's body harmoniously changes into a boy's body. In any case, change is there.

Hayagréva däsa: So there is harmony in the beginning, middle, and end?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everything is in harmony, be it material or spiritual. That is God's law.

Hayagréva däsa: If everything is always in harmony, evolution has an incidental meaning.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is harmony: One is an aquatic, then an insect, then a plant, then a tree, and so on up to the body of a human being. Change is there, but there is harmony. Once one has attained a human body, he can decide whether or not to stop this evolutionary process, or to remain in it. If one accepts the instructions of Kåñëa, he can put an end to this bothersome evolution. If not, he remains. This is the version of Bhagavad-gétä:

açraddadhänäù puruñä
dharmasyäsya parantapa
apräpya mäà nivartante
måtyu-saàsära-vartmani

"Those who are not faithful on the path of devotional service cannot attain Me, O conqueror of foes, but return to birth and death in this material world." (Bg. 9.3) By following Kåñëa's instructions, we can become completely detached from the cycle of birth and death.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson sees man as the culmination of earth's evolution. He writes: "Man might be considered the reason for the existence of the entire organization of life on our planet."

Çréla Prabhupäda: On this planet there are different types of men. Not everyone is in the same position. There are fools and sages, rich men and poor.

Hayagréva däsa: He is speaking of mankind in general.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he mean by all mankind? Everyone is an individual. In any case, man is not the highest form of life.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson sees the material worlds as being basically isolated from one another. He writes: "It is not artificially, for reasons of mere convenience, that we isolate our solar system: Nature itself invites us to isolate it."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We feel isolated because we are individuals. In a prison, every criminal is different from every other criminal, and everyone has to suffer the consequences of his criminal activities. Thus every individual is suffering or enjoying according to his past deeds. If there is combination, you forget individuality. But that is not possible.

Hayagréva däsa: We feel isolated as individuals, but in addition we feel isolated communally on this planet. Man has never been able to communicate with beings on other planets.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is the point in communicating with other planets? They are also like this planet. People there have their individuality also.

Hayagréva däsa: Well, man has always had the desire to communicate with something outside of this world, something higher. Basically, this must be a desire to reach God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since God is there, why not communicate with Him? There is no point in communicating with other planets. Other living entities cannot help us. If we communicate with God, Kåñëa, we automatically understand everything else. If you hear people talking on other planets, what benefit will you derive? It is better to listen to Kåñëa speaking Bhagavad-gétä.

Hayagréva däsa: Is this isolation between worlds characteristic only of the lower and middle planetary systems? Is there as much isolation between the higher systems?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Isolation is always there. Even in this world, crows remain to themselves, and swans remain to themselves. This isolation is natural because everyone is functioning under the different modes of material nature. However, if people come to Kåñëa consciousness, there is no longer isolation because everyone is engaged in the Lord's service.

Hayagréva däsa: Bergson sees the universe itself as expanding and evolving. He writes: "For the universe is not made, but is being made continually. It is growing, perhaps indefinitely, by the addition of new worlds."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the universes emanate from the breathing of Mahä-viñëu. If we accept the fact that the universe is increasing, then universes may come out like particles and then begin to develop. We see that for everything material, there is a small beginning. When the living entity enters the womb, he is very small indeed. A banyan tree begins to grow from a small seed. This is the way of nature. It is a fact that the universe is increasing, but not perpetually. It increases to a certain extent, stops, dwindles, and vanishes.

Hayagréva däsa: Modern astronomers theorize that the universe is expanding and that the systems are exploding outward into space and moving proportionately further and further from one another, just like raisins expanding in dough when it is heated in the oven.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That expansion goes on to a certain extent. Then it Stops.

Hayagréva däsa: But Bergson sees the universe as evolving toward some grand harmony.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he mean by grand harmony? Everything is increasing, and everything will eventually dwindle and be annihilated. That is the course of material nature, and the harmony is in this process.

Hayagréva däsa: In attempting to relate God to the universe, Bergson speaks of "a center from which worlds shoot out like rockets in a fireworks display."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The creation is like a wheel rotating. There are spokes, and there is a rim. There is also a center around which everything revolves. Ahaà sarvasya prabhavo mattaù sarvaà pravartate. "I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me." (Bg. 10.8) That center is God, and all the parts are revolving around Him. In any case, the center remains where it is, and is always the same.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson spoke of the world as "a machine for the making of gods." In a sense, this world is a training ground wherein we can make ourselves immortal.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You are immortal already. You have just forgotten.

mamaiväàço jéva-loke
jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù
manaù-ñañöhänéndriyäëi
prakåti-sthäni karñati

"The living entities in this conditioned world are My eternal, fragmental parts. Due to conditioned life, they are struggling very hard with the six senses, which include the mind." (Bg. 15.7) There is bewilderment, but no change. We are fixed as spirit soul. It is as if we are dreaming: "Oh, I have fallen into the Pacific Ocean. I am drowning. Save me!" We may dream so many troublesome things, but actually there is no Pacific Ocean, and we are not drowning. It is simply a dream. The temporary covering of the body is just like a dream, and as soon as you come to Kåñëa consciousness, you wake up. When you are awake, the dream has no value. However, when the dream is happening, you are thinking that it is real, but since it has no value, it is called mäyä. Mäyä means "that which has no real existence but appears to."

Çyämasundara däsa: Does mäyä mean nothingness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You cannot say that. It is nothing appearing like something, but we do not say that it is nothing. Mäyävädés say that it is nothing, but we say that it is temporary. How can you say that a cloud is nothing? A cloud appears, remains for a while, and then goes. The body is there temporarily for a few years, or a few hours. It is like a cloud. We cannot say that it is nothing, but that it is temporary.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson thought that the life force, passing through different bodies, will eventually become immortal on this planet.

Çréla Prabhupäda: At present, people are living for an average of seventy years, at the utmost a hundred. They are thinking that they would like to live for a hundred and seventy years, but in this material world, seventy, a hundred and seventy, or seventeen million years are the same. The years will eventually end. However, one who only lives for seventy years thinks that a million years is immortality.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson is interested in knowing the course of future evolution. He feels that because man has progressed from the instinctive stage to the intelligent and then to the intuitive stages, he will eventually attain the immortal stage.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is very nice, the idea that man will attain perfection. Progress means that you go forward, that you do not remain stagnant. The Vedas say:

tad viñëoù paramaà padaà
sadä paçyanti sürayaù
divéva cakñur ätataà
viñëor yat paramaà padam

"The lotus feet of Lord Viñëu are the supreme objective of all the demigods. These lotus feet of the Lord are as enlightening as the sun in the sky." (Åg Veda 1.22.20) Those who are learned and advanced in knowledge are called sürayaù. Modern scientists are looking forward to going to other planets, but those who are learned are looking forward to going to the lotus feet of Viñëu. They are thinking, "When will I reach You?" The goal is there, and those who know it do not miss it. One who is Kåñëa conscious knows the goal and attempts to reach it. Those who do not know the goal waste their time philosophizing and misleading others. This is the blind leading the blind.

Hayagréva däsa: So when Bergson refers to the universe as "a machine for the making of gods," in what sense is he correct?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, in one sense there is no making of gods, because the demigods are already there. All the parts of the wheel are there complete. Our normal life is a life in Kåñëa consciousness. That is mukti, liberation. It is not a question of becoming something different, but of returning to normal health, to our constitutional position. In mäyä, a man is diseased, and in his delirium, he speaks all kinds of nonsense.

Hayagréva däsa: Then instead of speaking of the universe as a machine for the making of gods, it would be better to call it a hospital for the curing of souls.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is a hospital. When we are cured, we are freed from all designations, which begin with the body. People are thinking, "I am European, American, Christian, Hindu," and so on. These are all misconceptions. Our real position is that we are part and parcel of Kåñëa and are His eternal servants. It is not that a man can be made into a demigod or God. Man is already part and parcel of God. He has to understand his position in order to attain mukti. After all, what is a demigod? There is no difference between a demigod and a man. A demigod is in a better position, that's all. A high court judge and a layman are both human beings, but the judge is in a superior position. The demigods are elevated due to their being situated in a higher mode, in sattva-guëa. On this earth, rajo-guëa and tamo-guëa, passion and ignorance, are prominent. Being spirit soul, however, we are not subject to any guëa. We are transcendental. If we keep ourselves in our constitutional transcendental position by engaging in devotional service, we are above all the guëas, including sattva-guëa. This is the liberation attained by devotional service. The devotees are not interested in becoming demigods. After all, the demigods are also rotting in this material world. For a devotee, Brahmä, Indra, Candra, and the other demigods are no better than small insects. Everyone has a different type of body according to karma, whether it be Brahmä's body or an ant's body. One who has attained liberation is not at all concerned with the body; therefore devotees are not interested in being elevated to higher planetary systems. In fact, one devotee prays, "I don't care to be a Brahmä. I would prefer to be a small ant in the house of a devotee." This is the Vaiñëava position.

Çyämasundara däsa: Bergson conceived of two types of morality: closed and open. Closed morality depends on prevailing conventions, or social pressures. This is traditional morality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That kind of morality changes according to time and circumstance. What is moral in one society may be considered immoral in another.

Çyämasundara däsa: Open morality is determined by individuals and is guided by intuition. Bergson saw this as the morality of saints like St. Paul or St. Francis.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If we are God conscious, we can tell what is real morality. Because St. Paul was a sädhu, he could say what morality is. Our process is sädhu, guru, çästra. We have to accept knowledge through saintly persons, and this knowledge has to be confirmed by the scriptures and explained by the guru. In this way, our knowledge can be perfect. The scriptures are already there. We have to read them and understand how they have been realized and followed by saintly persons. If there is any difficulty in understanding, we should inquire from the spiritual master. In this way, sädhu, guru, and çästra confirm one another. It is not that we try to understand these scriptures directly. We have to see how the scriptural injunctions are being followed by saintly persons.

DS:Samuel Alexander (1859-1938)

Samuel Alexander (1859-1938)

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander is the philosopher of emergent evolution. For him, external objects have an existence independent of consciousness. Unlike many other philosophies, Alexander's neo-realism contends that something may exist even though it is not perceived.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is so. God exists whether we perceive Him or not. God is the original creator, and just as everyone has a father, all living entities are coming originally from this original father. The father is there. Fact is fact, whether anyone perceives it or not. You may not have seen my father, but you know that I had a father. You do not have to perceive him directly to know that he is a fact. Because I exist, my father is essential. That is understood and assumed by everyone. Therefore people say, "What is your father's name?" instead of, "Do you have a father?" It is assumed that one has a father, even though this father is not immediately perceived.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander uses the example of a house: whether we are conscious of a house or not, the house itself is a real entity unaffected by our awareness of it. It has a real, objective existence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, as far as that proposition is concerned, if we accept the fact that we are eternal, it is very natural to assume that we have an eternal house, an eternal home. That is back home, back to Godhead. When people ask, "Where do you live?" they are asking for your residence. Your present address may not be your birthplace, but it is a fact that we must live somewhere. No one may be interested in knowing where I live, but everyone knows that I have a place to live.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander believes that our consciousness of an object gives us only limited perspective. When we shift our position, our perspective changes. If I see a table, that table has an objective reality; it is not just a mental image.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, you cannot say that the table is just a mental image. If someone throws the table and knocks you down, you will bleed. That is not simply mental.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander also claims that even illusions or hallucinations are genuinely real objects. If I think I see a snake, which is really a rope, the illusion of that snake is real.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is in reality a snake, otherwise how can the image of a snake come to the imagination? I may falsely take a rope to be a snake, but that doesn't matter. In reality, the snake exists.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Alexander, the mind never creates anything new, but rearranges things. Since everything already exists, there is no question of creating anything.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, you cannot create anything. You can only transform. This table is nothing but wood. The wood is not my creation; it is already there. I have only transformed the wood into a shape called a table. It is said that necessity is the mother of invention. When I need something to sit on, I invent a chair.

Çyämasundara däsa: Some philosophers reason that because man feels a necessity for God, he has invented God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not invented. He knows God. And this is perfectly natural. Any sane man would ask, "Who is the original father?" There is no question of inventing the original father. Anyone can understand that there is an original father by philosophical research. The Vedänta-sütra states, janmädy asya yataù. "God is the original father of everyone." Invention refers to a thing that I create which was not in existence, and discovery refers to something I find that is already there. Invention and discovery practically convey the same idea because nothing is new. In the case of God, it is discovery. There is no question of invention.

Hayagréva däsa: In his major work, Space, Time and Deity, Alexander writes: "Religion leans on metaphysics for the justification of its indefeasible conviction of the reality of its object (God); philosophy leans on religion to justify it in calling the possessor of deity by the religious name of God. The two methods of approach are therefore complementary."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have often said that philosophy without religion is mental speculation, and religion without philosophy is sentiment. The combination of the two is most desirable. Bhagavad-gétä is religion and philosophy combined. Religion is explained in terms of worship of God, and philosophy is explained in terms of the immortality of the soul, and other subjects. Thus Bhagavad-gétä is the supreme combination of religion and philosophy.

Hayagréva däsa: If religion is like hunger, God is the food for that hunger. Alexander writes: "This religious appetite may either be stirred in us directly by the impact of the world with its tendency to deity, or it may first be felt by us as a need of our nature—"

Çréla Prabhupäda: We are seeking love of God beginning with our own body. We love this body because we live within it, and as long as the living soul is there, the body has value. The living soul is valuable because he is part and parcel of God. We also understand from Bhagavad-gétä that within the body God is also living. So within there are two kñetra-jïas, one who knows the individual body, and the other who knows all bodies. The ultimate conclusion is that because the Supreme Living Entity, God, is within the body and within the universe, we are attracted by love, society, friendship, communalism, and nationalism. When all this culminates in love for God, we attain perfection. We are searching for love of God, but we are moving by degrees from one platform to another.

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander writes: "It is idle to hope that by defining God in conceptual terms, whether as the sum of reality, or the perfect being, or the first cause, or by other device, we can establish the connection between such a being and the rest of our experience. We do but start with an abstraction, and we do but end with one. Proofs of God's existence in nature there are none, if such a God is to be identified with the object of worship."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We can understand the presence of God in nature, and we can certainly see His presence there. We can understand that there is a proprietor of the land, sea, and air. We may not be able to see the proprietor of the universe, but from our present experience with proprietorship, we can understand that there must be an ultimate proprietor. God is the proprietor of the sun, moon, and the sky itself. Vedic literatures describe the moon as the mind of God, the sun as the eyes of God, the land as the food of God, and the waters as the semina of God. This is the beginning of impersonal realization, but we should understand that there is a person in the background. Although we have not seen the Governor of Hawaii, we can understand that he is present by seeing the different branches of government. Similarly, as long as we are not qualified to see the Supreme Personality of Godhead, we can understand that this is God's hand, this is God's heart, His mind, His eyes, and so on. When we are qualified, we can personally see God, face to face.

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander felt that "even the description of God...is full of figurative language." For him, it is impossible to describe God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If it is impossible, why is he trying? Why shouldn't we accept the Vedic descriptions? In Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna tells Kåñëa:

paraà brahma paraà dhäma
pavitraà paramaà bhavän
puruñaàçäçvataà divyam
ädi-devam ajaà vibhum

ähus tväm åñayaù sarve
devarñir näradas tathä
asito devalo vyäsaù
svayaà caiva bravéñi me

"You are the Supreme Brahman, the ultimate, the supreme abode and purifier, the Absolute Truth and the eternal divine person. You are the primal God, transcendental and original, and You are the unborn and all-pervading beauty. All the great sages such as Närada, Asita, Devala, and Vyäsa proclaim this of You, and now You Yourself are declaring it to me." (Bg. 10.12-13) If all authorities accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, what further evidence do we need? No further argument is necessary. Things should be simplified.

Çyämasundara däsa: The mind is always reorganizing existing things, new comes from old, and from this, Alexander draws his idea of evolution.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since there is gold and mountains, I can imagine a gold mountain. I can combine many ideas with my imagination. The mind creates some ideas, and then rejects them to create others, and then rejects them also. The mind is not satisfied with creating something final. The mind by nature is creative. It creates something, then thinks, "Oh, this is not perfect," and then begins again. That is the mind's business: accepting and rejecting.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Alexander, the mind has two functions: contemplation and enjoyment. Contemplation involves perceiving the qualities of an object—for instance, an apple's redness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Or, if I see a tamarind, I immediately salivate.

Çyämasundara däsa: Enjoyment involves a mental awareness of inner, physiological activity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, there are many examples. One may dream of a sex object and have a nocturnal discharge. The mind creates things in this way, and there are actual physical reactions. In a dream, the mind may create a tiger, and the dreamer may cry aloud in fright. But actually there is no tiger.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander believes that even these dream images have an objective reality in our consciousness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, when I dream of a woman or a tiger, they exist in objective reality. The impressions in my mind are created hallucinations, but they may evoke physical reactions.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander describes time as an infinity of single instants, and space as an infinity of points. Together, they constitute primordial reality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we also consider time and space to be reality. Time is eternal, and therefore we take time to be another feature of God. Space is a later creation. Space is prakåti. Prakåti refers to nature, the elements like earth, water, fire, ether, space. Space or sky is one of the fundamental factors of prakåti. Prakåti, käla, jéva, Bhagävan: nature, time, the individual soul, and God. These are all realities, and they are all eternal. There is only one ultimate creator, Bhagävan, and the jévätmä, the individual soul, is the subsequent creator. God creates wood, and from this wood I create a table or a chair. Thus I am the subsequent, not the ultimate creator. Both creators, Bhagävan and jévätmä, are eternal. Because the creation has a past, present, and future, time is also eternal.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is there such a thing as spiritual space?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Of course. If not, how could there be a spiritual world? The quality is different, but the ingredients are exactly the same.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander, like Bergson, also believes that nothing remains at rest, that everything is in perpetual transition.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we also accept that. Everything is going forward. That is called jagat.

Çyämasundara däsa: Can this be said of the activities in the spiritual world?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We are speaking of the material world. The spiritual world is different. In the spiritual world, activities are eternal. In the material world, they are not.

Çyämasundara däsa: But isn't the motion of everything eternal?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That motion is the interaction of the three modes: goodness, passion, and ignorance. In course of time, these modes react, and creation takes place. There is certainly motion. Without motion, there cannot be creation. Material nature is composed of earth, water, fire, ether, and space. Whatever you see is composed of one or more of these ingredients. There are also subtler ingredients: mind, intelligence, and ego. These are the eight material elements given in Bhagavad-gétä, and they are considered the differentiated energy of Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander's primary category is more abstract. He says that it is motion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But where does the motion come from? Motion means that there must be someone there to push.

Çyämasundara däsa: Another major category is identity, or diversity. Everything has a personal identity and individuality differentiating it from every other thing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is called sajätéyo vijätéya in Sanskrit. There is difference (vijätéya) even between like things. There may be two mango trees, but there is still a difference between them. They may be one as mango trees, but there is still individuality. Similarly, my fingers are one, but each finger is different from the other. Sajätéya refers to the same category, but even within that category there is a difference.

Çyämasundara däsa: Existence, or being, is another major category.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That existence is composed of one or more of the five elements. One ingredient may be more prominent than the other, but there is at least one ingredient.

Çyämasundara däsa: Relation and order are other categories. Everything relates to everything else, and there is order in everything.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, there is certainly order in prakåti. The sun rises and sets at designated times. There is order everywhere.

Çyämasundara däsa: The mind also occupies space and works in time.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we are occupying space, and since the mind is within us, the mind also occupies space. From practical experience we can understand that the mind can immediately travel thousands of miles with no difficulties.

Çyämasundara däsa: But is that distance within me, or does my mind actually travel there?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It travels. It actually occupies space. Unless it occupies space, how could it travel? It travels so fast that you can't exactly remember how it is going, but as soon as it reaches its destination, you can apprehend it. In any case, it occupies space.

Çyämasundara däsa: The mind can leave the body and go somewhere?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not leave. It is just like a shoot: it extends. At night, when we are dreaming, the subtle body also extends and comes back again. In fact, we may take the subtle bodies in dreams to be very important at the time.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander maintains that new categories are constantly being uncovered because evolution is progressing. The living entity can evolve into new forms that we now know nothing about.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, we do not agree. We know that the days are going on now, and will continue, just as we have experienced them in the past. In the past there was summer, autumn, winter, and spring, and in the future these will also be experienced. Of course, the old order changes and yields to the new, but from our past experience we know what will be there.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then in the future there will be nothing unpredictable appearing, such as an entirely new form of existence?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Why should there be? Why should there be a winter without spring, or a spring without summer? Why should there be a new type of man? A new species? According to the Vedic version, everything is here. The number of species in the water, in air, and on land is fixed. There is no question of the species increasing.

Çyämasundara däsa: Some scientists predict that the future man will have no bodily hair, that his head will be very large due to increased brain capacity, that the rest of his body will be atrophied, that he may lose some of his toes, and so on.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is more foolishness. There has never been such a thing, nor will there ever be. Man has always had ten toes, and he always will.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander believes that man may evolve to the demigod platform in the future, that he may have super consciousness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is possible. Yänti deva-vratä devän (Bg. 9.25). If you are fond of the demigods, you will go to the demigods. Pitèn yänti pitå-vratäù (Bg. 9.25). Or you can go to the ancestors. Or remain within this material world.

Çyämasundara däsa: But Alexander thinks that evolution is moving in this way, progressing from inorganic life, to organic, to mental, and to demigod.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can life come from inorganic matter? That is nonsense. What evidence do we have that life is developing from inorganic matter? If that is the case, why don't they manufacture life in the laboratory? Living force cannot be produced from matter. Matter is different from living force, or soul. Of course, in one sense, they are both the energy of God, but categorically they are different. You cannot even manufacture an ant. You may have all the chemicals, but you cannot inject the soul. The soul appears in different ways. For instance, fermentation, perspiration. When rock and water decompose, there may be fermentation, and it may be possible that the soul takes advantage of this and comes out, being born in some life form. In any case, life never comes from matter. It is thought by the foolish that scorpions are born out of rice, but actually the scorpion lays its eggs within the rice, and by the fermentation, or heating of the rice, the eggs incubate, and scorpions are born. But this does not mean that matter itself is producing life. The Vedas accept the fact that living creatures can arise from fermentation, but this is only because the soul finds refuge there.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what of the idea that nature is progressing? Will man some day evolve to the demigod stage?

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the Vedas, the demigods were created before men. First, Lord Brahmä was created, and from Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva was created. By created, I mean born. Similarly, from Brahmä, others came, the Prajäpatis, and then the Manus. There were many. There is no question of these personalities emerging from inorganic life. Lord Brahmä came from the navel of Viñëu. You may ask, What is the origin of Viñëu? We have no information of this because Viñëu is the origin, and it was from Him that Brahmä and all the other demigods came. Then the animals and others came. The first created being is Lord Brahmä, and he is also the most intelligent. It is not that he evolved from animals or man. These evolutionists propose that life evolves from the lowest to the highest, but we believe that it begins with the highest, with Viñëu. Kåñëa says, ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù. "I am the origin of everything." (Bg. 10.8) How can you say that higher species will develop from the lower? God is the origin. Vedänta-sütra also says, "The Absolute Truth is He from whom everything is generating." The Absolute Truth is the supreme life, and from Him all life is coming. What evidence do we have of a dead stone giving birth to a man or animals?

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander felt that in the future, the race of man will evolve into super-conscious beings, into demigods.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, we have no information of this. Why is he so anxious about the planet earth? These super-conscious beings are already existing on Siddha-loka, Gandharva-loka, and many other higher planets. There are millions of planets with super-human beings. From the çästras we learn that the inhabitants of Siddha-loka can fly from one planet to another without the aid of a space vehicle.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander proposes that nature develops bodies to that point.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. Bodies never develop in that way. There are different types of bodies, and the soul takes shelter of a particular type, selecting bodies just as a person selects clothes in a store. When we are within a suit, the suit moves. Bodies are selected according to the soul's desires. By your karma, you get a particular type of body. We have already discussed this.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then demigods will not evolve on this planet in the natural course of things?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No.

Çyämasundara däsa: How is genius, accounted for?

Çréla Prabhupäda: When one is born a genius, we must understand that in his previous life he cultivated a particular faculty, and that knowledge is being manifested in this life. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that if a yogé does not complete the yoga process, he is given another chance (Bg. 6.41). It is not that these things happen accidently.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then, through the practice of yoga, a higher consciousness can be developed?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. For instance, we are practicing bhakti-yoga to develop Kåñëa consciousness. As far as your spiritual development is concerned, you must understand that you are spirit soul. Then you can qualify yourself to return to the spiritual world. There you can associate with the Lord and engage in spiritual activities. The çästras tell us that we should try for spiritual perfection and not waste our time endeavoring for material comforts. Material comforts and distresses automatically come; there is no need in wasting time striving for them. In nature, there are many millions of living entities without business or profession, yet they are living, eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. These things will come automatically. Our endeavor should be for spiritual emancipation.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Alexander, on the mental level, we are capable of enjoying objects and receiving pleasure from them, but cannot understand them as they are. On the higher level, we can contemplate objects and understand them as they are, as well as enjoy them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is our philosophy. A common man may see a rose and think, "Oh, I will offer this nice flower to my girlfriend." But when a devotee sees a rose, he thinks, "How wonderfully God's energy is acting!" He understands that it is through Kåñëa's energy that such a wonderful flower exists, and therefore he knows that the flower should be offered to Kåñëa. After all, since Kåñëa produced it, it is Kåñëa's property. After offering the rose to Kåñëa, the devotee smells it. Then it is prasädam, the Lord's mercy. This is higher consciousness. Lower consciousness thinks, "Let me pick it and enjoy it!" That is mere enjoyment without understanding. An animal eats just as man eats, but a man should have sufficiently developed consciousness to understand that what he is eating is given by Kåñëa. The Vedas state: eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän. "The Supreme Lord is supplying all necessities of life to everyone." (Kaöha Upaniñad 2.2.13). When one understands that Kåñëa is supplying everything, he thinks, "First, let me offer this to Kåñëa." If everything is not offered in sacrifice to the Supreme Lord, we will be entangled. Higher consciousness is mature consciousness. It is like a flower that has blossomed and is emitting a fragrance. That full blossom of consciousness is Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander believes that the entire world is moving to that point.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, nature is giving us the chance, but because we have independence, we may or may not take the opportunity.

Çyämasundara däsa: Will only certain individuals attain that higher consciousness, or will the whole world attain it?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a nonsensical question. Sometimes rascals inquire, "Swaméjé, if everyone becomes God conscious and goes back to Godhead, then who will remain here?" What is the meaning of such a nonsensical question? Why is a fool anxious for everyone? Why is he not anxious for himself? It is the same to ask, "If everyone is honest, then who will go to jail?" As if maintaining the jail is a very important business!

Çyämasundara däsa: During Alexander's day, people were very optimistic about man's future, thinking that everyone would be benefitted by scientific discoveries.

Çréla Prabhupäda: People think that by nature's way, they will be promoted, that once they have attained the status of man, they cannot be degraded. But if one can go up, he can also go down. The rich can become poor again. Theosophists and others think that everything goes up, progresses. They don't even have the common sense to look around them.

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander distinguished between deity and God Himself. For him, deity is a relative term for the next highest level of existence. For an ant, a dog may be a deity; for a dog, a man may be a deity; for a man, a demigod may be a deity. Deity is always one evolutionary step ahead of us. Alexander defines God as "the being which possesses deity in full." That is, God is always one step ahead of every creature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He does not know the exact Vedic science of God, but as a philosopher he is suggesting a very nice method. For an ant, a bird is a deity; for a bird, a cat is a deity, and so on according to one's position. And if you continue searching, you will find someone who has no one to worship. The ant must worship the bird, the bird worship the cat, and so on, but when we arrive at a person who has no one to worship, we have arrived at God. In the lower stages, there are always higher living beings, but when we come to the highest living being, we come to God Himself. This is explained in the Vedic literatures:

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù
sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù
anädir ädir govindaù
sarva-käraëa-käraëam

"Kåñëa, who is known as Govinda, is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal, blissful, spiritual body. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin, and He is the prime cause of all causes." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.1) And in Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conqueror of wealth, there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7) There is no authority superior to Kåñëa. As long as one has a superior, he is not God, but a servant of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander believes that lower organisms strive to emulate higher. Animals strive to become like men, and men strive to become like gods.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no question of striving. It is by nature's way that the lower animals come to the platform of men. The living entity evolves from one life form to another, but this is with the help of nature. This law holds, up to the human platform. Having developed consciousness, the human being has the power of discrimination. Originally, the soul is given independence. Kåñëa tells Arjuna, "Whatever you like, you do." (Bg. 18.63) God is the Supersoul, and we are the jéva souls subordinate to Him. Therefore we are called taöastha, which means that we are marginal; we can go either way. We may take God's side, or mäyä's side. That is our choice. When we don't want to serve God, we are sent to mäyä to serve her. Man's position as a subordinate remains the same, but in mäyä he thinks, "I am the master." This is just like a child trying to act against his father's wishes. When he is given a chance to do as he likes, the child thinks, "Oh, I am independent now." Actually he is never independent, but he thinks that he is. When death comes, no one is independent. Although man continually serves mäyä life after life, he still thinks of himself as independent. Only when we surrender to Kåñëa do we enjoy our real independence.

Çyämasundara däsa: But don't lower forms try to emulate higher ones?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is natural. Everyone wants a higher position because everyone is trying to be master. That is the whole problem. One can be a master to some extent: a head clerk in an office, a president, or prime minister. There is much ambition in the material world because materialistic men are guided by the idea that "I shall become like Kåñëa." When their efforts fail in-the material world, they strive to merge into Kåñëa. This is Mäyävädé philosophy. Not knowing that they are already Brahman, spirit soul, they consider themselves the Supreme Brahman, God Himself. Therefore they sit and meditate, thinking, "I am moving the sun. I am moving the moon." This is simply imagination. This is the last snare of mäyä. Mäyä first of all allures us to become a big merchant, a prime minister, a president. Mäyä is always saying, "Become this, become that, become, become." Mäyä is always telling us to work under her direction. Finally, she says, "Now you have failed in all these things. It is better now that you become God, and attain your real status again." So the living entity begins to think, "I am God," but mäyä is still kicking him. As soon as this so-called God gets some toothache, he runs to the doctor. He does not stop to think, "What kind of God am I?"

Çyämasundara däsa: But what is that urge for promotion?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not the individual's urge. Nature is giving the impetus. For instance, when you were a child, there was no sex urge, but when you attained adolescence, immediately the sex urge became manifest. Similarly, the perfection of consciousness is there, but unless you come to the platform of human life, it will not develop.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is there also an urge among lower animals to improve themselves, to be promoted?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but all that is being carried out by nature. That is evolution. Darwin has taken this idea from the Vedas, but he has no idea of the soul. The only business of animals is eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. You may call this the struggle for existence. They are simply trying to live; they have no other ambition. If a man, having attained the human stage, is interested only in these things, he is no better than an animal. Nowadays, these are being taught by modern civilization. They teach you how to live comfortably with a car, a bungalow, a girlfriend, and restaurants. All living entities in this material world have the propensity to enjoy. On one platform, the living entity enjoys certain types of pleasure, but he is always wanting more. It is the spirit of material enjoyment that brings about the disease of materialistic life.

Çyämasundara däsa: So the urge to advance is perverted by the urge to enjoy?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, perverted. The living entity's position is to serve Kåñëa, but instead he is serving his senses and thinking that he is enjoying. You can see how everyone is working hard day and night in order to enjoy. Everyone is thinking that he will be happy if he just becomes a millionaire. Animals work hard to get some food, and as soon as they acquire food, they are satisfied. But human beings are not so easily satisfied. They are so passionate that they are constantly working very hard to be happy. People do not understand that in material life, they cannot be happy in any position.

Çyämasundara däsa: Can the urge to advance be the desire to become godly?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Desire means that one has lost his real happiness dancing with God like the gopés. Änandamayo 'bhyäsät. The Vedänta-sütra says that by nature, the living entity wants änanda, bliss. Because he seeks änanda in a perverted way, he is confused and frustrated; therefore he thinks, "Not this state but that will give me happiness." However, when he goes to his desired state, he again finds unhappiness. This is because he is seeking änanda in a perverted way. In Vaikuëöha-loka, there is eternal happiness because everyone is surrendered to Kåñëa. In Våndävana, all the cowherd boys, gopés, cows, trees, and other living entities are centered about Kåñëa. They are all concerned with making Kåñëa happy. Only on that platform will we avoid confusion and frustration.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander says that at this point, we cannot know the qualities of the next stage of evolution.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He may not know, but we know. One who has Kåñëa as his master and teacher knows everything. Yasmin vijïäte sarvam eva vijïätaà bhavanti. If you understand Kåñëa, you understand everything.

Hayagréva däsa: Again, concerning the conception of deity, which is so central, Alexander writes: 'The infinitude of God's deity marks the difference between Him and all other empirical beings....Not only is God infinite in extent and duration, but His deity is also infinite in both respects."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is infinite deity, He is not subject to created living beings. It is incorrect to think of God's deity as one of the deities within this material world. A person who thinks in this way is condemned as a müòhä. "Because I appear as an ordinary human being," Kåñëa tells us, "müòhäs, asses, consider Me an ordinary human." (Bg. 9.11)

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander states that God is both body and soul, and that His soul is His deity. "All finites are included in Him," he writes, "and are fragments of God's body, though their individuality is not lost in it—God is...an individual being just as man or any other finite is, only that He is infinite."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is right. God is a person, but not like us. People mistake Him to be like an ordinary human being, but this is due to illusion. Kåñëa is infinite, and Arjuna is finite. It is explained in Bhagavad-gétä that Kåñëa, being infinite, knows everything in the past, present, and future (Bg. 4.5). That is one of the differences between an ordinary living entity and God. The living entity forgets, but God does not.

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander sees God's body as neither spaceless nor timeless, for it is space-time itself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, since everything emanates from Him, there is nothing separate from Him. God includes everything. Everything is part and parcel of God. The Mäyävädés say that everything is one, but they do not accept the variety. The wheel is one, but there are different parts: the rim, the spokes, and the hub.

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander writes: "Now the body of God is the whole universe, and there is no body outside His. For Him, therefore, all objects are internal, and the distinction of organic and special senses disappears."

Çréla Prabhupäda: For the impersonalists who are not familiar with the personal form of God, Arjuna in Bhagavad-gétä requested Kåñëa to show His universal form, the viräö-rüpa. Arjuna himself was accepting the person Kåñëa as the Supreme, but he knew that those with a poor fund of knowledge would not accept Him. For this reason, in the Eleventh Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, the universal form of God is very elaborately explained. However, we should understand that since the universal form was shown by Kåñëa, Kåñëa is the originator. It is not that the universal form is the origin. It was manifested by Kåñëa, and Lord Kåñëa's natural form is that of Kåñëa Himself. The universal form is a feature. This is also confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä: ahaà sarvasya prabhavo mattaù sarvaà pravartate. "I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me." (Bg. 10.8) Since everything emanates from Him, the universal form has also emanated from Him. One who understands this becomes Kåñëa's devotee.

Hayagréva däsa: For Alexander, theism is equated with personalism, and pantheism with impersonalism. He writes: "For theism, God is an individual being distinct from the finite beings which make up the world....For pantheism, God is eminent in the universe of finite things...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: When we cannot understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead, God is impersonal. The sunshine is impersonal, but the sun god is in the background. Because we are on a lower platform, we cannot talk with the sun god; we can experience only the sunshine. Similarly, the expansion of God's energy is impersonal, but the personality is in the background. Because we are in the material energy, we are not in direct touch with God; therefore we say that God is impersonal. If we become devotees, we can talk with God in person, just as the cowherd boys and girls did in Våndävana. It is also stated, nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm (Kaöha-Up. 2.2.13). God is an eternal, living being, and we are also eternal, living beings. Yet He is different from us in that He is the chief. He has arranged everything for us in both the material and spiritual worlds. He has given us air, water, and fire in order to live. He is the maintainer, and we are subordinate jévas.

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander seems to acknowledge both theistic and pantheistic views.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, as I said, because water has come from God, we say that it is God's semina. Because light has come from Him, we say that the sun is his eye. In that everything is an emanation from God, everything is related to God. In any case, the impersonal features are subordinate to the personal.

mayä tatam idam sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

"By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them." (Bg. 9.4) Just as the sunshine depends on the sun itself, so the entire cosmic manifestation depends on God. Kåñëa says that although everything is resting on Him, He is personally not present. Queen Kunté also says, "You are within and without, yet fools cannot see you." These verses spoken by Queen Kunté are given in Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

namasye puruñaà tvädyam
éçvaraà prakåteù param
alakñyaà sarva-bhütänäm
antar bahir avasthitam

mäyä-javanikäcchannam
ajïädhokñajam avyayam
na lakñyase müòha-dåçä
naöo näöyadharo yathä

tathä paramahaàsänäà
munénäm amalätmanäm
bhakti-yoga-vidhänärthaà
kathaà paçyema hi striyaù

"O Kåñëa, I offer my obeisances unto You because You are the original personality and are unaffected by the qualities of the material world. You are existing both within and without everything, yet You are invisible to all. Being beyond the range of limited sense perception, You are the eternally irreproachable factor covered by the curtain of deluding energy. You are invisible to the foolish observer, exactly as an actor dressed as a player is not recognizable. You Yourself descend to propagate the transcendental science of devotional service unto the hearts of the advanced transcendentalists and mental speculators, who are purified by being able to discriminate between matter and spirit. How, then, can we women know You perfectly?" (Bhäg. 1.8.18-20)

This is a very good example. Kåñëa is playing on the stage, and His son is seeing Him, and another friend is saying, "Do you see your father?" But the son does not recognize his father. A devotee can understand, but a speculator with limited sense perception cannot.

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander writes: "It is not so much that God is in everything but rather that everything is in God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since there is nothing but God, how can anything be without God? Since everything is God's expansion, how can we be sometimes with God and sometimes without Him? When we are not in God, we are in mäyä, but mäyä is also God's. It is illusion to think that we are without God.

Hayagréva däsa: After analyzing both theism and pantheism, the personal and impersonal, Alexander finds them both defective in themselves, but he concludes, "if a choice must be made, it is theistic"

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that when one comes to the personal aspect of God, he sees that everything refers to God and that there is nothing independent. To the unintelligent, it appears that the cosmic manifestation is different from Bhagävan, but actually nothing can exist without the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: At times, Alexander takes the Aristotelian view in maintaining that "there is no reciprocal action from God. For though we speak, as we inevitably must, in human terms of God's response to us, there is no direct experience of that response except through our own feeling that devotion to God or worship carries with it its own satisfaction."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he does not understand God's omnipotence. God is omnipotent, and He comes before Arjuna to speak Bhagavad-gétä. Being all powerful, God can come and speak to His devotee. If He cannot, what is the meaning of His omnipotence? Kåñëa reciprocates with the advanced devotees.

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." (Bg. 10.10) God talks to His devotee who is fully in love with Him, but He does not talk with ordinary men.

premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena
santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti
yaàçyämasundaram acintya-guëa-svarüpaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship the primeval Lord, Govinda, who is always seen by the devotee whose eyes are anointed with the pulp of love. He is seen in His eternal form of Çyämasundara situated within the heart of the devotee." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.38) Just as a king talks with his immediate officers and ministers and not with the ordinary man in the street, God personally talks to His devotees but not to the nondevotees or atheists. We understand that Kåñëa talked to the gopés and gopas in Våndävana and reciprocated with His parents, Mother Yaçodä and Mahäräja Nanda. The cowherd boys who played with Kåñëa amassed many pious activities in their previous lives to arrive at a position where they could play with God. This is not an ordinary position. People generally think that such play is inconceivable, but when we come to that platform of devotion, we can play with God, ride on God's shoulders, and talk with Him just as with an ordinary friend. Of course, one comes to that position of perfection after many millions of pious births.

Hayagréva däsa: Within the same book, Space, Time and Deity, Alexander contradicts himself on this issue of reciprocation. "God reciprocates the worship man pays Him and the confidence he reposes in Him," he writes. "There is always the double relationship of need. If man wants God and depends upon Him, God wants man, and is so far dependent."

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is not dependent on anyone. God is independent, but that statement is acceptable in the sense that sometimes God wants to become dependent. That is according to His pleasure. Sometimes He accepts some of His devotees in ways that He can depend on them. He became dependent on Mother Yaçodä, just as an ordinary child becomes dependent on his mother. Although everything is dependent on God, and He is not dependent on anyone, He takes pleasure in this kind of relationship.

Hayagréva däsa: I don't think Alexander understood it in that way.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is not a very ordinary thing to understand. It cannot be understood by mental speculation.

Hayagréva däsa: Alexander also writes that God Himself is involved in our acts and their issues. "Not only does He matter to us, but we matter to Him." Is this actually so?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, although we are sons of God, we are fallen conditioned souls and are suffering. Therefore God is very compassionate, and He comes personally to teach us. He says, "Why are you rotting in this material world? Surrender to Me and go back to Godhead. Then you will be happy." God is the father of everyone, and it is natural for a father to be concerned about his sons. Presently we are conditioned by material nature because we are disobedient. God, being the Supreme Father, feels for our suffering. But He is not suffering. The devotees of God also feel for the conditioned souls, and Kåñëa's devotees are very dear to Him because they are trying to spread His instructions, Bhagavad-gétä. The devotees are acting on behalf of God to deliver conditioned souls.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander believed that man, being part of God, is capable of cooperating with God to make further progress in the universe.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is real life, cooperating with God. But in this material world, man is uncooperative. Kåñëa says, "Surrender unto Me," but no one wants to do this. Even when people attain the highest levels of human life wherein their karma is regulated and they possess knowledge and yogic abilities, they still will not surrender to Kåñëa.

kåñëa-bhakta—niñkäma, ata eva 'çänta'
bhukti-mukti-siddhi-kämé—sakali 'açänta'

"Because a devotee of Lord Kåñëa is desireless, he is peaceful. Fruitive workers desire material enjoyment, jïänés desire liberation, and yogés desire material opulence; therefore they are all lusty and cannot be peaceful." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 19.149) The karmés want sense enjoyment, the jïänés want mukti, liberation, and the yogés want yoga-siddhis, the yoga powers. All these people are demanding various things: sense gratification, liberation, mystic powers. Only the Kåñëa-bhakta makes no demands. He says, "Dear Lord, I am Your eternal servitor. I surrender unto You. Now do whatever You like with me."

bhoktäraà yajïa-tapasäà
sarva-loka-maheçvaram
suhådaà sarva-bhütänäà
jïätvä mäàçäntim åcchati

"The sages, knowing Me as the ultimate purpose of all sacrifices and austerities, the Supreme Lord of all planets and demigods and the benefactor and well-wisher of all living entities, attain peace from the pangs of material miseries." (Bg. 5.29) By understanding that Kåñëa is the supreme enjoyer, the supreme proprietor, and the supreme friend, we can become çänta, peaceful.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander felt that man should cooperate with God in order to usher in a higher stage of consciousness, the next stage of evolution. This is man's responsibility.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what is the next stage of evolution? When man is prepared to cooperate with God, he has already attained the highest position. Unfortunately, no one wants to cooperate. There is simply enjoyment; there is no more evolution. If you come to the point of worshipping the Supreme Lord, there is no question of evolution. You have already attained the highest form of evolution.

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman." (Bg. 14.26) The Brahman platform is already attained; he doesn't have to strive to become Brahman. He immediately transcends the three guëas and comes to the platform of spirit. Without being Brahman, how can you serve the Supreme Brahman?

Alexander speaks of the higher stages of evolution, but he has no real knowledge of them. According to the Vaiñëava philosophy, there are five basic stages: çänta, däsya, sakhya, vätsalya, and mädhurya. When you attain the brahma-bhüta stage and understand that you are not the body but spirit soul, you have attained the çänta platform. On that platform, you think, "Oh, God is so great!" From the çänta stage, you can progress to the däsya stage, wherein you realize that God is so great that some service must be rendered to Him. In the sakhya stage, you not only know that God is great and render service to God, but you also serve God as a friend, like Arjuna. On the vätsalya platform, service is rendered to Kåñëa as a father or a mother. Yaçodä, for instance, rendered service to Kåñëa as a mother, and she was always thinking, "Kåñëa is hungry. I must feed Him. I must protect Him from monkeys and fire." On the platform of mädhurya-rasa, the highest platform, you can enter into intimate pastimes with Kåñëa. Although there are many stages in spiritual life, there is actually no difference between them. It is not that those who serve Kåñëa as friends are inferior to Rädhäräëé, who serves Kåñëa as His consort.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander sees the freedom of the will operating as an activity not subject to extraneous forces. It is the expression of a person acting to serve not only his own interests but those of society as well.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In a state, a citizen also cooperates in two ways. When he does not break the law, he cooperates as a free citizen, and when he breaks the law, he cooperates by going to prison. He either cooperates by free will or by force. Forceful cooperation is inferior. Caitanya Mahäprabhu said:

jévera 'svarüpa' haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa'
kåñëera 'taöasthä-çakti' 'bhedäbheda-prakäça
süryäàça-kiraëa, yaiche agni-jvälä-caya
sväbhävika kåñëera tina-prakära 'çakti' haya

"It is the living entity's constitutional position to be an eternal servant of Kåñëa because he is the marginal energy of Kåñëa, and a manifestation simultaneously one and different from the Lord, like a molecular particle of sunshine or fire. Kåñëa has three varieties of energy." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 20.108-109) By his constitutional position, the living entity is the eternal servant of Kåñëa. In the Vaikuëöha planets, cooperation is voluntary, and here in this material world, cooperation is forced. In the material world, we are serving mäyä, working under her force. We can avoid that force only by voluntarily cooperating with Kåñëa.

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14) Automatic cooperation is bhakti, and forced cooperation is karma. These may appear to be the same, but they are not. The karmi may be typing, and the bhakta may be typing, but the karmi is typing under the force of mäyä, to earn money for sense gratification, and the bhakta is typing for the glorification of Kåñëa. The activity is the same, but the consciousness is different.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander believed that when one has attained the higher levels of evolution, he can see that everything on the lower levels is determined.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. For instance, we should not try to improve our economic condition because it is already decided. Why is one man born rich, and another born to work so hard? Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.5.18) says that we should not strive hard for material happiness, because material happiness and distress come automatically. An intelligent man utilizes his time to develop his Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander accepted Plato's three greatest values in life—truth, beauty, and goodness—as values to be accepted by the majority.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Unfortunately, in the material world, no one likes the truth. At least in this age, the majority of people are not truthful. As soon as one becomes truthful, he becomes a brähmaëa. Where are the brähmaëas in this age? Kalau çüdra sambhava. In Kali-yuga, everyone is a çüdra. If Alexander thinks that everyone will accept truthfulness as a great value, he is mistaken.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Alexander, there is a practical criterion for truth, but he preferred the coherence principle by which the majority opinion determined truth by mutual agreement.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because he is European, he is thinking in a democratic way. The hard fact is that truth is not accepted by ordinary men. Truth is truth. Either it is in your mind or not; truth is absolute. Only highly elevated persons can understand the truth. Out of many truthful men, perhaps only one can understand Kåñëa as He is.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander defines a good person as one who integrates and controls his impulses for the best interests of himself and society.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is also described in Vedic literatures:

tapasä brahmacaryeëa
çamena ca damena ca
tyägena satya-çaucäbhyäà
yamena niyamena vä

"To concentrate the mind, one must observe a life of celibacy and not fall down. One must undergo the austerity of voluntarily giving up sense enjoyment. One must then control the mind and senses, give charity, be truthful, clean and nonviolent, follow the regulative principles, and regularly chant the holy name of the Lord." (Bhag. 6.1.13) These are the processes by which we may become perfect, but if we become devotees of Kåñëa, we immediately attain all the good qualities. Yasyästi bhaktir bhagavaty akiïcanä sarvair guëais tatra samäsate suräù. "All the demigods and their exalted qualities, such as religion, knowledge, and renunciation, become manifest in the body of one who has developed unalloyed devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead." (Bhäg. 5.18.12).

Çyämasundara däsa: In the second sense of the word "good," Alexander says that whatever enhances man's welfare or happiness is good.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not necessarily so. One may open hospitals to help people, but spreading Kåñëa consciousness is greater welfare work. What is really good for man is Kåñëa bhakti. Nothing else.

Çyämasundara däsa: Alexander maintains that goodness consists of modifications in the environment that will aid man in his spiritual pursuits.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is what we are trying to do in this Kåñëa consciousness movement. It is not that everyone can follow the regulative principles strictly. We are proposing that people chant Hare Kåñëa. Whatever the situation, somehow or other, we must engage our mind in Kåñëa. Rüpa Gosvämé said: yena tena prakäreëa manaù kåñëe niveçayet [Brs. 1.2.4]. "Never mind the rules and regulations. Just fix your mind on Kåñëa! As soon as you become Kåñëa conscious, the regulative principles will be your servants."

Hayagréva däsa: As for the existence of evil and suffering in the world, Alexander writes: "God is not responsible for the miseries endured in working out His providence, but rather we are responsible for our acts...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we create our own miserable condition, just as a silkworm creates a cocoon, becomes entrapped and dies.

açraddadhänäù puruñä
dharmasyäsya parantapa
apräpya mäà nivartante
måtyu-saàsära-vartmani

“Those who are not faithful on the path of devotional service cannot attain Me, O conqueror of foes, but return to birth and death in this material world." (Bg. 9.3) Because the living entity acts independently, not caring for God's instructions, he is entangled, and he suffers. In this Way, he creates his own suffering.

DS:Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche (1844-1900)

Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche (1844-1900)

Hayagréva däsa: Whereas Schopenhauer spoke of the blind will of the individual as being the basic propelling force that keeps us tied to material existence, to transmigration, Nietzsche spoke of der wille zur macht, "the will to power," which is a different type of will. This will is not so much a subjugating of others as a mastering of one's lower self. It is characterized by self-control and an interest in art and philosophy. Most people are envious of others, but it is the duty of the philosopher to transcend this envy by sheer willpower. In Nietzsche's words, the philosopher "shakes off with one shrug much vermin that would have buried itself deep in others." When the philosopher has rid himself of resentment and envy, he can even embrace his enemies with a kind of Christian love. An example of such a powerful man in action would be that of Socrates meeting his death with good cheer and courage.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is called spiritual power. Envy is a symptom of conditioned life. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam, it is stated that the neophyte who is beginning to understand the Vedic literatures should not be envious. In this material world, everyone is envious. People are even envious of God and His instructions. Consequently, people do not like to accept Kåñëa's instructions. Although Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and is accepted as such by all äcäryas, there are men called müòhäs who either reject Kåñëa's instructions or try to eschew some contrary meaning from them. This envy is symptomatic of conditioned souls. Unless we are liberated from conditioned life, we will remain confused under the influence of the external material energy. Until we come to the spiritual platform, there is no possibility of escaping from envy and pride by so-called power. The transcendental stage is described in Bhagavad-gétä as brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä samaù sarveñu bhüteñu (18.54). When we attain that stage, we can look at everyone with the same spiritual understanding.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche calls the man who possesses such spiritual power the Ubermensch, a word literally meaning "above man," and often translated as "the superman." The Ubermensch is totally self-possessed, fearless of death, simple, self-knowing, and self-reliant. He does not need any props, and he is so powerful that he can change the lives of others simply on contact. Neitzsche never referred to any historical person as the Ubermensch, and he did not consider himself such.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We accept the guru as the superman because he is worshipped like God. Yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädaù (Çré Gurv-añöaka 8). By the mercy of the superman, one can get in touch with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Caitanya Mahäprabhu also accepts this:

brahmäëòa bhramite kona bhägyavän jéva
guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja

"According to their karma, all living entities are wandering throughout the entire universe. Some of them are being elevated to the upper planetary systems, and some are going down into the lower planetary systems. Out of many millions of wandering living entities, one who is very fortunate gets an opportunity to associate with a bona fide spiritual master by the grace of Kåñëa. By the mercy of both Kåñëa and the spiritual master, such a person receives the seed of the creeper of devotional service." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 19.151) By the mercy of Kåñëa and the guru, or the superman, we receive information about spiritual life so that we can return home, back to Godhead. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu requested everyone to become gurus, or supermen. The superman distributes transcendental knowledge strictly according to the authorized version he has received from his superior. This is called paramparä, the disciplic succession. One superman delivers this supreme knowledge to another superman, and this knowledge was originally delivered by God Himself.

Hayagréva däsa: In Thus Spake Zarathustra, Nietzsche concludes that all men want power. At the top of the hierarchy in the quest for power is the ascetic and the martyr. The Ubermensch would be one who has conquered his passions and attained all good qualifications. His actions are creative, and he does not envy others. He is constantly aware that death is always present, and he is so superior to others that he is almost like God in the world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In Sanskrit, the Ubermensch or superman is called a svämé, or gosvämé. He is described by Rüpa Gosvämé:

väco vegaà manasaù krodha-vegaà
jihvä-vegam udaropastha-vegam
etän vegän yo viñaheta dhéraù
sarväm apémäà påthivéà sa çiñyät

"A sober person who can tolerate the urge to speak, the mind's demands, the actions of anger, and the urges of the tongue, belly, and genitals, is qualified to make disciples all over the world." (Upadeçämåta 1) These forces that drive men are six in number: speech, the tongue, mind, anger, belly, and genitals. A gosvämé can control these forces, especially the genitals, belly, and tongue, which are very hard to control. Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says: tä'ra madhye jihvä ati, lobhamoy sudurmati, tä'ke jetä kaöhina saàsäre. "Among the senses, the tongue is the most voracious and uncontrollable; it is very difficult to conquer the tongue in this world." (Gétävalé, Prasäda-seväya 1) The force of the tongue is very great, and for its gratification we create many artificial edibles. Nonsensical habits like smoking, drinking, and meat eating have entered society due to the urges of the tongue. There is no real need for these undesirable things. A person does not die because he cannot smoke, eat meat, or drink intoxicants. Rather, without these indulgences, he can elevate himself to the highest platform. Due to the urges of the tongue, people have become addicted to drinking, smoking, meat eating, and frivolous conversation. It is therefore said that one who can control the tongue can control the urges of the other senses also. One who can control all the senses, beginning with the tongue, is called a gosvämé or svämé, or, as Nietzsche would say, the Ubermensch. But this is not possible for an ordinary man.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche believed that everyone seeks power, but that the weak seek it vainly; instead of trying to conquer themselves, they attempt to conquer others, and this is the will to power misdirected or misinterpreted. For instance, in his will to power, Hitler sought to subjugate the world, but was ultimately unsuccessful, and he brought disaster upon himself and Germany. The Ubermensch, on the other hand, strives to overcome himself, and demands more of himself than others. In this striving for perfection, he transcends the ordinary man.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Politicians like Hitler are not able to control the force of anger. A king or politician has to use anger properly. Narottama Däsa Öhäkura says that we should control our powers and apply them in the proper cases. We may become angry, but our anger must be controlled. We should utilize anger at the proper place and in the proper circumstances. Although a king may not be angry by nature, he has to display his anger toward a criminal. It is not good for a king to try to control his anger when a criminal act is performed; therefore Narottama Däsa Öhäkura says that anger is controlled when it is properly used. Käma-krodha-lobha-moha. Käma refers to lust; krodha means anger; lobha means greed; and moha means illusion. These can all be properly utilized. For instance, käma, which is great eagerness, or lusty desire, can be utilized in attaining the lotus feet of Kåñëa. If we desire Kåñëa, our strong desire is very laudable. Similarly, anger can be properly utilized. Although Caitanya Mahäprabhu taught that we should be very submissive, humbler than the grass and more tolerant than a tree, He became angry upon seeing Nityananda Prabhu hurt by Jagäi and Mädhäi. Everything can be properly utilized in the service of Kåñëa, but not for personal aggrandizement. In the material world, everyone is certainly after power, but the real superman is not after power for himself. He himself is a mendicant, a sannyäsé, but he acquires power for the service of the Lord. For instance, I came to the U.S.A. not to acquire material power but to distribute Kåñëa consciousness. By the grace of Kåñëa, all facilities have been afforded, and now, from the material point of view, I have become somewhat powerful. But this is not for my personal sense gratification; it is all for the spreading of Kåñëa consciousness. The conclusion is that power for Kåñëa's service is very valuable, and power for our own sense gratification is to be condemned.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche was not very clear about the utilization of power, but he concluded that power results from self-control. According to him, no one has ever attained the level of the superman.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You cannot do anything without power. Power is required for Kåñëa's service, not for sense gratification. One who can act according to this principle is a superman. Generally, people use power for their own sense gratification, and therefore it is not easy to find anyone on the level of the superman.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche claims that because the Ubermensch subjugates his own passions, he is beyond good and evil and not subject to mundane dualities.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, because the superman acts on behalf of God, he is transcendental. At the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna was thinking like an ordinary person in his reluctance to kill his kinsmen. From the material point of view, nonviolence is a good qualification. Arjuna was excusing the others, although they had insulted him and his wife and usurped his kingdom. He pleaded on their behalf before Lord Kåñëa, arguing that it would be better to let them enjoy his kingdom. "I am not going to fight." Materially, this appears very laudable, but spiritually it is not, because Kåñëa wanted him to fight. Finally, Arjuna carried out Kåñëa's order and fought. Clearly, this kind of fighting was not for personal aggrandizement, but for the service of Kåñëa. By using his power for the service of the Lord, Arjuna became a superman.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning religion, Nietzsche felt that because Christ's own disciples misunderstood him, Christianity as such never existed. "The last Christian died on the cross," he wrote. Although Christ was totally pure and free from all resentment and envy, Christianity has had envy and resentment as its focal point from its very beginning, even though it calls itself the religion of love. Thus Nietzsche proclaimed, "God is dead," in the sense that the God of the Christian religion is dead.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you create an artificial god, it is better that he is dead so that he cannot inflict more injuries.

Hayagréva däsa: Then it is better to have no conception of God than a bad conception?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, better. But Christ was the embodiment of tolerance. There is no doubt about this.

Hayagréva däsa: It is not that Nietzsche criticizes Christ himself, but his followers.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, actually we can see that the Christians hate the Jews because the Jews crucified Christ. They even utilize the symbol of the cross to remind people that the Jews crucified him. Even in the churches there are pictures of Lord Jesus, with thorns on his head, being forced to carry his cross. In this way, the people are reminded of all the troubles that the Jews gave to Christ. Emphasizing Christ on the cross is a way of prolonging resentment against the Jews. But the fact is that Christ had many other activities, which are not brought into prominence. Actually, it is very painful for a devotee to see his master being crucified. Even though Christ was crucified, that scene in his life should not be emphasized.

Hayagréva däsa: Neitzsche considered Buddhism and Hinduism superior to Christianity, but he disliked the nihilism of the Buddhists and the caste system of the Hindus, especially the Hindu treatment of the untouchables.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a later concoction by the caste Hindus. The true Vedic religion does not speak of untouchables. Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself demonstrated His system by accepting so-called untouchables like Haridasa Öhäkura, who was born in a Mohammedan family. Although Haridasa Öhäkura was not accepted by Hindu society, Caitanya Mahäprabhu personally indicated that he was most exalted. Haridasa Öhäkura would not enter the temple of Lord Jagannätha because he did not want to create commotion, but Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself came to see Haridasa Öhäkura every day. It is a basic principle in the Vedic religion that we should not be envious of anyone. Kåñëa Himself says in Bhagavad-gétä:

mäà hi pärtha vyapäçritya
ye 'pi syuù päpa-yonayaù
striyo vaiçyäs tathäçüdräs
te 'pi yänti paräà gatim

"O son of Påthä, those who take shelter in Me, though they be of lower birth—women, vaiçyas [merchants], as well as çüdras [workers]—can attain the supreme destination." (Bg. 9.32) Despite birth in a lower family, if one is a devotee, he is eligible to practice Kåñëa consciousness And return to God, provided the necessary spiritual qualifications are there.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche believed that by stressing the transcendental world, a person would come to resent this world. He therefore personally rejected all formal religions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This material world is described as a place of suffering. Äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäùpunar ävartino 'rjuna. "From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery, wherein repeated birth and death take place." (Bg. 8.16) We do not know whether Nietzsche realized this or not, but if one really understands the soul, he can realize that this material world is a place of suffering. Being part and parcel of God, the soul has the same qualities possessed by God. God is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, eternal, full of knowledge and bliss, and He is eternally enjoying Himself in the company of His associates. The living entities have the same nature, but in material life, eternity, knowledge, and bliss are absent. It is therefore better that we learn to detest material existence and try to give it up. Paraà dåñövä nivartate (Bg. 2.59). The Vedas advise us to understand the spiritual world and try to return there. Tamasi mä jyotir gama. The spiritual world is the kingdom of light, and this material world is the kingdom of darkness. The sooner we learn to avoid the world of darkness and return to the kingdom of light, the better it is.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche was greatly influenced by the ancient Greeks, and he was astounded that out of so few men, so many great individuals emerged. He believed that mankind ought to be constantly striving to produce such great men, men who conquer their evil instincts, and he considered this to be mankind's only duty.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everyone is trying to be a great man, but one's greatness is accepted when he becomes God realized. The word veda means "knowledge," and a person is great when he is conversant with the lessons of the Vedas. The object of knowledge, as described in Bhagavad-gétä, is God, or the self. Since the individual is part and parcel of God, one is self-realized whether he realizes himself or God. There are different methods for self-realization, which is difficult. However, if one realizes God, he automatically realizes himself. If the sun is out, we can see everything very clearly. In the Vedas [Muëòaka Up. 1.3], it is said, yasmin vijïäte sarvam evam vijïätaà bhavati. By understanding God, we understand all other things and automatically become jolly. Brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä (Bg. 18.54). The word prasannätmä means "jolly." Samaù sarveñu bhüteñu (Bg. 18.54). At that time, we can see that everyone is exactly like ourselves, because everyone is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. At this point, service of the Lord begins, and we attain the platform of knowledge, bliss, and eternity.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche emphatically states that there has never been a superman. "All too similar are men to each other," he writes. "Verily, even the greatest found I all too human." Nor does the superman evolve in the Darwinian sense. The Ubermensch is a possibility at present if man uses all of his spiritual and physical energies. But how is the superman possible without an object for his spiritual energies?

Çréla Prabhupäda: We become supermen if we engage in the service of the Supreme Person. The Supreme Being is a person, and the superman is also a person. Nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm(Kaöha-Upaniñad 2.2.13). God is the chief amongst all personalities. The superman has no other business than carrying out the orders of the Supreme Being.

anyäbhiläñitä-çünyaà
jïäna-karmädy-anävåtam
änukülyena kåñëänu-
çélanaà bhaktir uttamä

"Uttama bhakti, or unalloyed devotion unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, involves the rendering of devotional service in a way that is favorable to the Lord. This devotional service should be free from any extraneous motive and devoid of fruitive karma, impersonal jïäna, and all other selfish desires." (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.1.11) Kåñëa comes to make everyone a superman. He therefore orders, sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekam çaraëaà vraja. "Just give up everything and surrender to Me." (Bg. 18.66) Unless we are supermen, we cannot understand this instruction. If we can surrender to Kåñëa, we are supermen.

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19) The ordinary man thinks, "I have my independence and can do something myself. Why should I surrender?" However, as soon as he realizes that his only duty is to surrender to Kåñëa, and that he has no other duty in this material world, he becomes the superman. This consciousness is attained after many, many births.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche would reject dependence on anything exterior to the superman himself. That is, he would reject props. But isn't it impossible for a man to elevate himself to that platform independent of the Supreme Lord?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Of course, and therefore Kåñëa says, "Depend upon Me." You have to be dependent, and if you do not depend on Kåñëa, you have to depend on the dictations of mäyä, illusion. There are many philosophers and politicians dependent on others, or dependent on their own whimsical ideas, but we should depend on the perfect instructions of God. The fact is that every living being is dependent; he cannot be independent. If he voluntarily depends on the instructions of God, he becomes the superman.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche's superman seems to resemble the haöha-yogé who elevates himself seemingly independent of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, seemingly. As soon as a haöha-yogé gets some extraordinary mystic powers, he thinks that he has become God. This is another mistake, because no one can become God. To some extent, a yogé may attain some mystical powers by practice, or by the favor of the Lord, but these powers are not sufficient to enable him to become God. There are many who think that through meditation, or haöha-yoga, it is possible to become equal to God, but this is another illusion, another dictation of mäyä. Mäyä is always saying, "Why depend on God? You can become God yourself."

Hayagréva däsa: Independence seems to be central to Nietzsche's philosophy. In a sense, his superman is somewhat like Hiraëyakaçipu, who made the demigods tremble to see his austerities.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and ultimately he was outwitted by the Supreme Himself. It is not good to struggle for material power and control over others. If one becomes a servant of God, he becomes the superman automatically and acquires many subordinate followers. One does not have to undergo severe austerities to control others. Everything can be mastered in one stroke. As soon as you become a devout servant of God, many people will follow you. Separate endeavor is not required.

Hayagréva däsa: And what of sense control?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Control of the senses is automatically there.

yasyästi bhaktir bhagavaty akiïcanä
sarvair guëais tatra samäsate suräù
haräv abhaktasya kuto mahad-guëä
manorathenäsati dhävato bahiù

"All the demigods and their exalted qualities, such as religion, knowledge, and renunciation, become manifest in the body of one who has developed unalloyed devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Väsudeva. On the other hand, a person devoid of devotional service and engaged in material activities has no good qualities. Even if he is adept at the practice of mystic yoga, or the honest endeavor of maintaining his family and relatives, he must be driven by his own mental speculations and must engage in the service of the Lord's external energy. How can there be any good qualities in such a man?" (Bhäg. 5.18.12) If one becomes a devotee of the Supreme Lord, he controls his senses and many other living entities. But he never thinks that he has become God or the actual controller. Rather, he receives his power automatically.

Hayagréva däsa: One last point on Nietzsche. He believed in eternal recurrence—that is, after this universe has been destroyed, it will be repeated again after many aeons.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In Bhagavad-gétä, it is stated, bhütvä bhütvä praléyate (Bg. 8.19). This material world is manifest at a certain point, maintained for a certain period, then destroyed. Brahmä, Viñëu, and Çiva are in charge of creation, maintenance, and destruction. Above them is Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is the nature of everything material to be created, maintained, and annihilated.

Hayagréva däsa: Well, that's one type of general repetition, but Nietzsche believed that everything will be repeated infinitely in every detail. That is, the detailed arrangements of this world will eventually recur sometime in the future.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The creation will be repeated in detail in that the twenty-four elements will again be assembled. There are the five gross elements—earth, water, fire, air, and ether—and three subtle elements: mind, intelligence, and ego. There are the ten senses, and the five sense objects. All these will be created again.

Hayagréva däsa: That's one type of detail, but he believes that eventually, Friedrich Nietzsche will live again from 1844 to 1900.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The year 1844 is an element of time, and from the moment of creation, we may begin to assign dates. In this way, the date may again be repeated. For instance, every day is a new day, but in every day there is six o'clock, eight o'clock, and so on. There is automatic repetition.

Hayagréva däsa: If this is the case, if one has to continue being Friedrich Nietzsche, or whoever, how is liberation possible?

Çréla Prabhupäda: This material world is created for the conditioned soul, who is put here in order to learn his position as the eternal servant of God. Lord Brahmä, the first created being in the universe, is given the Vedic instructions, and he distributes them through the disciplic succession, from Brahmä to Närada, from Närada to Vyäsadeva, from Vyäsadeva to Çukadeva Gosvämé, and so on. These instructions encourage the conditioned soul to return home, back to Godhead. If the conditioned soul rejects them, he remains in the material world until it is annihilated. At that time, he remains in an unconscious state, just like a child within the womb of his mother. In due course of time, his consciousness revives, and he again takes birth. The point is that anyone can take advantage of the Vedic instructions and go back to Godhead. Unfortunately, the conditioned living entities are so attached to the material world that they repeatedly want to take up material bodies. In this way, history repeats. There is again creation, maintenance, and destruction.

Hayagréva däsa: Nietzsche believes that even the minute details will recur. That is, he would again be Friedrich Nietzsche, living in Germany, going through the same actions, writing the same books, and so on.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why is he so attached to Germany? That is his attachment for mäyä. Under mäyä's influence, we think that we will again return in these same bodies and do the same things. Sometimes when people hanker after this repetition, they go to an astrologer and ask, "Can we again come back as husband and wife?" This is all due to attachment. There may be an accidental recurrence, and one will again be a husband and have a wife, but he will not have exactly the same wife. That is an illusion. What is the point in combining the same husband and wife? The living entities combine for some sense gratification, and they get it, be it this husband or that wife. The purpose is the same, though the minute details are different.

Hayagréva däsa: Sometimes people claim to have experiences of deja-vu, thinking that they have been at the same spot before doing the same thing. This convinced Nietzsche of the doctrine of eternal recurrence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: People simply want the same atmosphere. This is due to mäyä's influence.

IXUTILITARIANISM AND POSITIVISM

IXUTILITARIANISM AND POSITIVISM

DS:John Stuart Mill (1806-1873)

John Stuart Mill (1806-1873)

Hayagréva däsa: In Essay on Nature, Mill writes: "The order of nature, insofar as unmodified by man, is such as no Being whose attributes are justice and benevolence would have made with the intention that his rational creatures should follow it as an example—It could only be as a designedly imperfect work which man, in his limited sphere, is to exercise justice and benevolence in amending."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Man is called a rational animal; he has a rational nature and an animal nature. Eating, sleeping, mating, and defending are activities common to animals, but a man should cultivate his rational nature. For instance, by his reason, man can understand that it is not necessary to eat meat in order to live a healthy life. It is not that man should be carried by nature's way, which says that man can eat anything. Human beings are accustomed to eating the most abominable foods, and in so doing, they become implicated. Beyond eating, sleeping, mating, and defending, man should search out the Absolute Truth. In this way, man's rationality is properly used. Otherwise, he remains an animal.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill claimed that the world, or nature, can be improved by man's efforts, but that perfection is not possible.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In one sense, that is correct. This world is so made that although you make it perfect today, tomorrow it will deteriorate. Nonetheless, the world can be improved by this Kåñëa consciousness. You can better the world by bringing people to Kåñëa consciousness and delivering the message of Kåñëa to whomever you meet. That is the best social activity you can perform.

Çyämasundara däsa: The goal of the utilitarians was more specifically to obtain whatever the people desire or require.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The people desire happiness. The utilitarians try to give people artificial happiness, happiness separate from Kåñëa, but we are trying to give direct happiness, happiness that is connected with Kåñëa. If we purify our existence, we can attain spiritual, eternal happiness and bliss. Everyone is working hard for happiness, but how can happiness be attained in a diseased condition? The material disease is an impediment to happiness. This disease has to be cured.

Hayagréva däsa: Mill felt that virtues like courage, cleanliness, and self-control are not instinctive in man but have to be cultivated. In Nature, he writes: "The truth is that there is hardly a single point of excellence belonging to human character which is not decidedly repugnant to the untutored feelings of human nature—"

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Therefore there are educational systems in human society. Men should be educated according to the instructions given in the Vedic literatures. Bhagavad-gétä is the grand summation of all Vedic literature, and therefore everyone should read it as it is. It is not necessary to interpret.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Mill, there are several ways to ascertain knowledge. For instance, we can determine the cause and the effects of things by determining whether the phenomena under investigation have only one circumstance in common. If so, we can conclude that the circumstance alone is the cause of the effect.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly there is the natural law of cause and effect, but if we go further to determine the cause, we ultimately arrive at Kåñëa. Everything has an original source, a cause. If you try to find out the cause of this and that, and conduct research, that is called darçana, which means "to find the cause." Therefore philosophy is called darçana-çästra, which means "finding the cause of the cause." The idea is that we ultimately arrive at Kåñëa, the original cause of everything.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what kind of test can we apply to phenomena to find out the cause? How can we determine that God is the cause behind everything?

Çréla Prabhupäda: For every phenomenon, there is a cause, and we know that God is the ultimate cause. Mill may give many methods for studying immediate causes, but we are interested in the ultimate cause of everything. The ultimate cause has full independence to do anything and everything beyond our calculation. Everything that we see is but an effect of His original push.

Çyämasundara däsa: If we see rain falling and want to prove that God is the cause of rain, what test can we apply?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The çästras, the Vedic literatures. We are advised to see through the çästras because we cannot see directly. Since our senses are defective, direct perception has no value. Therefore we have to receive knowledge through authoritative instruction.

Çyämasundara däsa: In other words, when we see an apple fall from a tree, we have to see through the eyes of the çästras in order to see God in that act?

Çréla Prabhupäda: God has made His laws so perfect that one cause effects one thing, and that in turn effects another, and so on. We may see an apple grow and explain it as "nature," but this nature is working according to certain laws. An apple has a certain color and taste because it is following specific laws set down by Kåñëa. Kåñëa's energies are perfect and are working perfectly. Everything is being carried out under systematic laws, although we may not perceive these laws.

Çyämasundara däsa: Scientists admit that nothing can come out of nothing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If something emerges, there must be a cause in the background. We say that the root cause of everything is Brahmän, the Absolute Truth.

Hayagréva däsa: Mill certainly did not see God as the cause of evil. In fact, he considered God at war against it. Man's role is to help God end this war. He writes: "If Providence is omnipotent, Providence intends whatever happens, and the fact of its happening proves that Providence intended it. If so, everything which a human being can do is predestined by Providence and is a fulfillment of its designs. But if, as is the more religious theory, Providence intends not all which happens, but only what is good, then indeed man has it in his power, by his voluntary actions, to aid the intentions of Providence...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Providence desires only the good. The living entity is in this material world due to the improper utilization of his will. Even though he wants to enjoy this material world, God is so kind that He gives him facilities and directions. When a child wants to play in a certain way, he is guided by some nurse or servant hired by the parents. Our position is something like that. We have given up the company of God to come to this material world to enjoy ourselves. So God has allowed us to come here, saying, "All right, enjoy this experience, and when you understand that this material enjoyment is ultimately frustrating, you can come back." Thus the Supreme Lord is guiding the enjoyment of all living beings, especially human beings, so that they may again return home, back to Godhead. Nature is the agent acting under the instructions of God. If the living entity is overly addicted to misuse his freedom, he is punished. This punishment is a consequence of the living entity's desire. God does not want a human being to become a pig, but when one develops such a mentality by eating anything and everything, God gives the facility by providing the body of a hog. God is situated in everyone's heart, and is noting the desires of the living entity from within. According to one's desires, God orders material nature to provide a particular body.

Hayagréva däsa: Mill further writes: "Limited as, on this showing, the divine power must be by inscrutable but insurmountable obstacles, who knows what man could have been created without desires which never are to be, and even which never ought to be, fulfilled?" Thus Mill concludes that the existence of evil, or pain and death, excludes the existence of an omnipotent God. He sees man in a position to "aid the intentions of Providence" by surmounting his evil instincts. God is not infinite in His power, because if He were, there would be no evil.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Evil is undoubtedly created by God, but this was necessary due to the human being's misuse of his free will. God gives man good directions, but when man is disobedient, evil is naturally there to punish him. Evil is not desired by God, yet it is created because it is necessary. Although a government constructs prisons, it prefers to construct universities so that people can attain an education and become highly enlightened. Because some people misuse their independence, prisons are necessary. We suffer due to our evil activities. Thus God, being supreme, punishes us. When we are under the protection of God, nothing is evil; everything is good. God does not create evil, but man's evil activities provoke God to create an evil situation.

Hayagréva däsa: In the Judeo-Christian tradition, God is at war with Satan. In Vedic literatures, there are also wars between the demigods and the demons, as well as Kåñëa and the demons, but these wars do not seem to be taken as serious confrontations between God and His enemies. Isn't Kåñëa's mood always playful?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since Kåñëa is all powerful, when He is fighting with demons, He is actually playing. This fighting does not affect His energy. It is like a father fighting with his small child. One slap is sufficient. Kåñëa gives the demons a chance to play by fighting Him, but one strong slap is sufficient. There is no question of fighting with God. He is omnipotent. However, when a living entity is disobedient and harasses the devotees, God kills him. Pariträëäya sädhünäà vinäçäya ca duñkåtäm (Bg. 4.8). When Kåñëa descends on this earth, He chastises the demons and protects His devotees. Whenever there is a fight between the demons and the demigods, God takes the side of the demigods.

Hayagréva däsa: Mill saw it more like an actual struggle between God and Satan, or evil.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is struggle because the demons are always transgressing God's rules. A demon is one who rejects God's rules, and a demigod is one who accepts them. That is the main difference, as stated in the çästras.

Hayagréva däsa: But Mill pictures God Himself as struggling hard in the fight to conquer the demons.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God has no reason to struggle. According to the Vedas, He is so powerful that He has nothing to do. Just as a king may have many servants, ministers, and soldiers to carry out his desires, Kåñëa has many energies that act according to His order. Kåñëa Himself has nothing to do. He is playing His flute and enjoying Himself. That is änanda. Although He is enjoying Himself, the universe is going on in accordance with His orders, through the agencies of His multi-energies. There is no question of God struggling. He doesn't even have to fight. His various agents can easily enough kill all the evil elements in the world.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill believed that God is good, but that He is involved in a world not of His own making.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Is God to be judged by Mr. Mill? God is good, but not as good as Mr. Mill thinks He ought to be? Is this his opinion of God? Is God good in all conditions? Or is God only good when Mr. Mill considers Him good? What is God's position?

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill says that the presence of evil indicates that if God were everything, He would not be completely good.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore God has to depend on the opinion of Mr. Mill. Is it that Mr. Mill does not approve of all God's activities?

Çyämasundara däsa: He maintains that God is good, but that He is limited in His power. If His power were absolute, everything would be good.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How nonsensical! Everything is good! That is our philosophy. When God kills a demon, immediately flowers are showered from the sky. Whatever God does is good. Kåñëa danced with other men's wives in the dead of night, and this activity is worshipped as räsa-lélä. However, if an ordinary man does this, he is immediately condemned as a debauchee. In all circumstances, God is good and worshipable. It is not that we subject God to our judgement, saying, "Oh yes, You are good, but not so good." Fools think, "I am better than God. I can create my own God." God creates us; we cannot create God. Unfortunately, Mill did not know what is evil and what is good. He should have known that whatever is created by God is good, even if it appears to be evil to us. We may think that such and such is evil, but actually it is good. If we do not know how it is good, that is our fault. God cannot be placed under our judgement. In all circumstances, God is good.

Hayagréva däsa: Mill was particularly interested in the role of authority. In Utility of Religion, he writes, "Consider the enormous influence of authority on the human mind....Authority is the evidence on which the mass of mankind believe everything which they are said to know except facts of which their own senses have taken cognizance. It is the evidence on which even the wisest receive all those truths of science, or facts in history or in life, of which they have not personally examined the proofs...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: You can neither defy nor deny real authority. We are presenting our Kåñëa consciousness movement on this principle. We should carry out the orders of the authority, and Kåñëa, or God, is the Supreme Authority. Whatever He says must be accepted without interpretation. In this way, everyone can be happy. Those who are sane do not hesitate to accept God's authority, and they become happy abiding by His orders. Those who exactly follow the instructions of the Supreme Authority are also authorities. The spiritual master is the authoritative servant, and God is the authoritative master. If we follow the instructions of the authoritative servant, we in turn become authoritative servants of the spiritual master.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning morality, Mill writes: "Belief, then, in the supernatural, great as are the services which it rendered in the earlier stages of human development, cannot be considered to be any longer required either for enabling us to know what is right and wrong in social morality, or for supplying us with motives to do right and to abstain from wrong."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Morality means abiding by the orders of God. That is real morality. Other moralities are manufactured, and they differ in different countries. Religion and real morality, however, function according to the same principle. Religion means carrying out the orders of God, and morality means following those principles whereby we can fulfill the desires of God. Before the battle of Kurukñetra, Arjuna considered killing to be immoral, but when he understood from the instructions of Kåñëa that the fight was necessary, he decided to carry out his duty as a kñatriya. So this is morality. Ultimately, morality means carrying out the desires of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Mill, there are two moral sanctions of conduct. One is internal, which is our conscience and sense of duty.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he mean by conscience? A sense of duty is different from the conscience. It is our duty to receive instructions from higher personalities. If we do not, how can we know our duty?

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill felt that our duty is that which produces the most good for the most people.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is all so vague. What if everyone wants to take drugs? Is it our duty to help them? How can a rascal understand what his duty is? One has to be trained to know.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill would say that there is a rational or guiding principle for action, and this is the golden rule of the Christians: "Do unto others, as you would have them do unto you."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that you have to approach Christ. You cannot manufacture golden rules yourself. You have to abide by the orders of Christ, and that means approaching a superior authority.

Çyämasundara däsa: The second sanction of moral conduct is external: the fear of displeasing other men or God. We hope to win favor through acting morally.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This also means accepting authority. Therefore the Vedas tell us that if we want to be really learned, we must approach a guru. Did John Stuart Mill have a guru?

Çyämasundara däsa: His father, James Mill, was also a great philosopher.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In any case, we must accept some authority, be it Christ or Kåñëa. Our duty lies in following the orders of the higher authority. Of course, we accept Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, as our authority.

Hayagréva däsa: Mill himself rejected many basic Christian tenets, and he even believed that there is no intrinsic value in the belief in the immortality of the soul. He writes: "Those who believe in the immortality of the soul generally quit life with fully as much if not more reluctance as those who have no such expectation."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have daily experience of how the soul continues, even though the body changes. In our own family we can see that the body of an infant changes into the body of a boy, a young man, a middle-aged man, and then an old man. In any condition, the soul is the same. Why is it difficult to understand the immortality of the soul? If we cannot understand it, we are not very intelligent.

yasyätma-buddhiù kuëape tri-dhätuke
sva-dhéù kalaträdiñu bhauma ijya-dhéù
yat-tértha-buddhiù salile na karhicij
janeñv abhijïeñu sa eva go-kharaù

"A human being who identifies this body made of three elements with his self, who considers the by-products of the body to be his kinsmen, who considers the land of birth worshipable, and who goes to the place of pilgrimage simply to take a bath rather than meet men of transcendental knowledge there is to be considered like an ass or a cow." (Bhäg. 10.84.13) If a person does not understand the immortality of the soul, he is an animal. There is no question of belief. It is a fact. If a man says, "I don't believe that I will grow old," he is ignorant of facts. If he does not die when he is young, he necessarily grows old. This is a question of common sense, not of beliefs. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that there was never a time when we did not exist, nor will there ever be a time when we will cease to exist (Bg. 2.12). The soul is immortal; he never takes birth, and he never dies. This is the beginning of knowledge. First of all, we must understand what we are. If we do not, we will surely be wrongly directed. We will take care of the body just as a foolish man might take care of a bird cage, and neglect the bird within it.

Hayagréva däsa: Mill was not only a utilitarian but a humanist, and he felt that a religion of humanity can have a greater effect than a supernatural religion. The religion of humanity would foster unselfish feelings and would have man at the center.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Without God, how can it be a religion? As I have already explained, religion means carrying out the orders of God.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning immortality, Mill asserts that there is no evidence for the immortality of the soul, and none against it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he need to be convinced? There is a great deal of evidence. It is mankind's misfortune that a person like Mill cannot understand a simple truth that even a child can understand.

Hayagréva däsa: Ultimately, Mill considered the whole domain of the supernatural as removed from the region of belief into that of simple hope.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is neither hope nor belief, but a fact. At any rate, to those who are Kåñëa conscious, it is a fact. Kåñëa came and gave Arjuna instructions, and those instructions are recorded.

Hayagréva däsa: Mill was such a staunch humanist that he wrote: "I will call no being good who is not what I mean when I apply that epithet to my fellow creatures, and if such a being can sentence me to hell for not so calling him, to hell I will go."

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is always good, and if one does not know the goodness of God, he is imperfect. According to all Vedic literatures, God is always good and always great. What does Mill consider to be a good man?

Hayagréva däsa: One who works for what he calls "the greatest happiness principle," that is, the greatest happiness for everyone on earth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Is there any man who can do good for all?

Hayagréva däsa: Christ said that no man is good, that there is only one good, and that is God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact. You may think that this man is good, but he is limited in his power. He may still think in terms of his nation or society. Only a pure devotee of Kåñëa can be good because he abides by the order of the Supreme Good. Even if one has the desire to be a good man, it is not possible independent of God. In any case, these are all mental concoctions: good and bad. One who is not God conscious is necessarily bad, and one who is God conscious is good. This should be the only criterion.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what of Mill's contention that the good gives the greatest pleasure to the greatest number of people?

Çréla Prabhupäda: And what if the people are fools and rascals? The greatest number of people may say that cigarettes are very nice, but does this mean that they are desirable?

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill makes a distinction between the quality and the quantity of pleasure. Certain pleasures are superior to others.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you have quality, the quantity naturally decreases. For instance, ordinary people take pleasure in eating, sleeping, mating, drinking, smoking, and so on. The pleasure of Kåñëa consciousness is a transcendental pleasure, but the people who take to it are very few. Generally, since conditioned souls are fools, the pleasure that is most popular is the one followed by the greatest number of fools. According to our Vedic philosophy, man is born a fool, but he can be made intelligent through education and culture.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill advocated utilizing those principles that can give the pleasure of highest quality to the maximum people. He also wrote: "It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied. It is better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But how often will you find a Socrates? You cannot find Socrates loitering on every street. There will only be one in millions. There is no question of the maximum number of people. Men of Socrates's caliber are a minimum. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

manuñyäëäà sahasreñu
kaçcid yatati siddhaye
yatatäm api siddhänäà
kaçcin mäà vetti tattvataù

"Out of many thousands among men, one may endeavor for perfection, and of those who have achieved perfection, hardly one knows Me in truth." (Bg. 7.3) This is not a question of quantity, but of quality.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill felt that the highest quality of pleasure might also be enjoyed by a larger number. All men should be trained to find pleasure according to this higher standard.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that the maximum pleasure should be introduced to the maximum number of people. Unfortunately, it is not accepted by the greatest number but by a few only. This Kåñëa consciousness movement, for instance, cannot be understood by the masses. Only a few who are fortunate can understand. There may be millions of stars in the sky, but there is only one moon, and that is sufficient to drive away the darkness. It is not possible to have many moons, although there may be many glowworms.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill was trying to ascertain that standard of pleasure which is most desirable.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That he does not know. That he has to learn from the Vedas. Ordinary men take sex to be the highest pleasure, and the entire material world is existing because of sex, but how long does this sex pleasure last? A few minutes only. A man who is wise does not want pleasure that lasts only a few minutes but pleasure that continues perpetually. Nitya means "eternal," and änanda means "bliss." The Vedas state that those who are intelligent are not interested in transient pleasure but in eternal pleasure. They know their constitutional position; they know they are not the body. The pleasures of the body are transient and are sought by rascals. If one identifies with the body, he naturally seeks bodily pleasure. One who knows that he is not the body but eternal spirit soul seeks eternal spiritual pleasure.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill believed that a small amount of a higher type of pleasure is superior to a greater amount of a lower type.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is our philosophy. In Bhagavad-gétä it is said:

nehäbhikrama-näço 'sti
pratyaväyo na vidyate
svalpam apy asya dharmasya
träyate mahato bhayät

"In this endeavor there is no loss or diminution, and a little advancement on this path can protect one from the most dangerous type of fear." (Bg. 3.40) Even if one falls down from Kåñëa consciousness, he still gains from what little he has experienced. On the other hand, if one works according to the varëäçrama dharma but does not take to devotional service, all his labors go in vain. There are many students who come to Kåñëa consciousness for a few days and then go away, but they return again because the quality is so great. Hare Kåñëa is so potent. Save for Kåñëa consciousness, everything is being dissipated by time, by the sun's progress through the sky. Everything in this world is transient, but because we are eternal spirit souls, we should accept only that which has permanent value. It is foolishness to be satisfied with anything else.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill would have said that the only standard we have for understanding what is desirable is the fact the people desire it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We should desire Kåñëa, but people do not know about Kåñëa. People are thinking, "I love my country," or, "I love my body." What is this love? Because we are spirit soul and are within the body, we say, "I love."

Çyämasundara däsa: But Mill reasons that if something is desired, it is desirable per se.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Living entities desire many things. A hog desires stool, but is that desirable? The men on the Bowery are interested only in drinking. Is that very desirable? Caitanya Mahäprabhu desires Kåñëa, and that is a different type of desire. That should be the real standard for desire. We should know what the greatest personalities, the mahäjanas, are desiring, and we should make that our standard. We may desire something that is harmful for us, and not desire the good. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa wanted Arjuna to fight, but this was not Arjuna's desire. Arjuna initially wanted to leave the battlefield, but he changed his mind because Kåñëa wanted him to fight. The point is that we should desire what is desired by the great personalities, not by ourselves. After all, what are we? We should always consider ourselves to be fools.

Çyämasundara däsa: Mill advocated complete freedom so that everyone can express himself as he pleases.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is nonsense. No one has that freedom.

Çyämasundara däsa: But he felt that everyone should be free.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then everyone should be a philosopher. Mill has his own philosophy, and everyone else has his.

Çyämasundara däsa: He believed that if everyone is free to compete, the best will emerge.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is not freedom but competition. Our viewpoint is that everyone is ultimately dependent on Kåñëa. Of course, in illusion we are dependent on mäyä, but in any case, we must be dependent.

DS:Auguste Comte (1798-1857)

Auguste Comte (1798-1857)

Hayagréva däsa: Comte is the French founder of Positivism. He felt that theology dealt solely with the heart, or sentiments, and that metaphysics dealt solely with the intellect, but that Positivism reconciled the two. In A General View of Positivism, he writes: "It is a fundamental doctrine of Positivism.. .that the heart preponderates over the intellect. The intellect should devote itself exclusively to the problems which the heart suggests, the ultimate object being to find proper satisfaction for our various wants."

Çréla Prabhupäda: From Bhagavad-gétä, we understand that above the gross senses are the mind, intelligence, or intellect, and then the soul. The soul is the original principle of all activities, which are manifest in grosser and grosser ways. First, there are the gross activities of the body, then the subtle activities of the mind, and then the still more subtle activities of the intellect, and finally the spiritual activities. In this way, the different platforms of knowledge and understanding are categorized.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte believed that theology, metaphysics and Positivism constitute three stages through which the perfect society evolves. In the beginning, the theological stage, man moves from polytheism to monotheism. In the second stage, the metaphysical, man abandons the first stages and places his faith in impersonal forces, like cause and effect, gravity, and so on.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This philosophy is imperfect. From the personal platform, you have to reach the person, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. How can the law of gravitation save you? It is an energy of God, a natural law. When we speak of law, we predicate the fact that someone makes the law.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte suggests that primitive man worships personal forms in nature, and that as man becomes more sophisticated, he worships impersonal forms.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is backwards. The personal aspect is higher. Of course, if one does not know the Supreme Personality of Godhead, that is a different matter. Foolish men attempt to worship the impersonal. Primitive man by nature wants to worship a person. Because people do not know who that person is, out of frustration they turn to impersonalism. As far as our philosophy is concerned, we know the person because the personal God has told us, "Here I am." When He is present, He proves that He is God, the Supreme Lord. When people see Him, they write books about Him. When Vyäsadeva saw Kåñëa, He abandoned all other literatures to write of Kåñëa's activities in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. He knew by personal, meditative, and authoritative knowledge that Kåñëa is God. One who does not know Kåñëa may turn to impersonalism.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte believed that above the metaphysical platform is the Positivist stage wherein man abandons theological and metaphysical explanations in order to acquire positive knowledge. In this stage, man is sufficiently competent to ascertain facts and amass scientific data.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We don't agree with this. It is not that science is above metaphysics; rather, real scientific knowledge is metaphysical.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte maintained that the more facts that we discover through science, the more complicated science becomes. Thus science advances toward the positive stage.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that it becomes more superficial. Complete knowledge means finding the original cause. Sense perception is considered scientific, but the Vedas state that sense perception is misleading and is not independent. For instance, at the moment you can see me, but if there were no sunlight, you would not be able to see me. Your seeing is dependent on the sun, but you have not supplied the sun. The sun has come into being by someone else's arrangement, and your seeing is dependent on that arrangement. Therefore your seeing has no intrinsic value.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte considered sociology to be the most complex science because it depends on all the other sciences for its understanding. It is the science of human behavior, of group relations.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sociology is already given by Kåñëa. It is not Comte's gift. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöaà
guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù
tasya kartäram api mäà
viddhy akartäram avyayam

"According to the three modes of material nature and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me. And, although I am the creator of this system, you should know that I am yet the non-doer, being unchangeable." (Bg. 4.13) This is perfect sociology. If you try to create some system, that system will be imperfect because you are imperfect. There will not be peace. Certainly, human groups are necessary, but they must have a scientific basis. Kåñëa says that He has created the varëas; therefore we have to accept the system as it is given. Just as different parts of your body work in order to sustain the body, the different parts of society should work to maintain the social order. It is not that you can artificially create social orders. When people attempt this, they create only havoc.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte believed that man's scientific attempt to improve nature is more desirable than a passive belief in God. He writes: "Even the laws of the solar system are very far from perfect...the increasing imperfection of the economy of nature becomes a powerful stimulus to all our faculties, whether moral, intellectual, or practical....The conception of man becoming, without fear or boast, the arbiter within certain limits, of his own destiny, has in it something far more satisfying than the old belief in Providence, which implied our remaining passive."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he has no knowledge of God. There is no question of passivity. God is the ultimate controller of everything, and although He may act through different agents, the ultimate decision is given by Him. He is sitting in everyone's heart observing the activities of the individual soul, and without His permission, no one can act. He gives intelligence, and He also causes one to forget. By God's grace, we can have the power to remember activities long past. In any case, God is the ultimate director. Man cannot be independent, because man's actions are impelled by the three modes of material nature.

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

"The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities, which are in actuality carried out by nature." (Bg. 3.27) The ultimate director is the Supersoul situated in the heart of every living entity and within every atom.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte believed that social reforms are implemented more by love than anything else. His motto was: "Love for the principle, order for the basis, progress for the end."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Unfortunately, he does not know what the end is. He is simply theorizing. The end is Viñëu. Çrémad-Bhägavatam states:

na te viduù svärtha-gatià hi viñëuà
duräçayä ye bahir-artha-mäninaù
andhä yathändhair upanéyamänäs
te 'péça-tantryäm uru-dämni baddhäù

"Persons who are strongly entrapped by the consciousness of enjoying material life, and who have therefore accepted as their leader or guru a similar blind man attached to external sense objects, cannot understand that the goal of life is to return home, back to Godhead, and engage in the service of Lord Viñëu. As blind men guided by another blind man miss the right path and fall into a ditch, materially attached men led by another materially attached man are bound by the ropes of fruitive labor, which are made of very strong cords, and they continue again and again in materialistic life, suffering the threefold miseries." (Bhäg. 7.5.31) Unless we know the end, all our theorizing will not help. All their humanitarian work will never be successful because they have missed the main point: Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte would agree with Protagoras's saying, "Man is the measure of all things." He writes: "The universe is to be studied not for its own sake, but for the sake of man, or rather of humanity. To study in any other spirit would not only be immoral, but also highly irrational."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our view is that man should be anxious to understand the Absolute Truth. Human intelligence is meant for searching out the ultimate source of everything. It is useless to try to improve man's material situation. Every living being is destined to undergo a certain amount of happiness and distress. By virtue of our past activities, we get a particular type of body destined to suffer or enjoy. That cannot be changed. You may call this either fatalism or destiny, but it is a fact that every man is destined in this way, and his destiny cannot be changed. However, his intelligence can change his position in reference to God. Presently, man is forgetful of God and his relationship with God. Human life is meant for changing this position. Man's economic position is already fixed by destiny and cannot be changed. This is also confirmed in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. When we engage in devotional service, we can change our destiny. Otherwise, destiny is fixed.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte distinguishes between atheism and Positivism in this way: "Atheism, even from the intellectual point of view, is a very imperfect form of emanicipation; for its tendency is to prolong the metaphysical stage indefinitely by continuing to seek for new solutions to theological problems instead of setting aside all inaccessible researches on the grounds of their utter inutility....The true Positivist spirit consists in studying the How instead of the Why." Since religious questions can never be answered, they had best be forgotten.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can man forget? If man does not believe in God, God comes as death. How can man counteract death? From Bhagavad-gétä we understand that God appears as death for the atheists, and in this way God convinces the atheists, "Here I am." No one can avoid this. No one can become independent by atheistic speculation.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte equated intellectual and moral improvement with material progress. He writes: "A nation that has made no efforts to improve itself materially will take but little interest in moral or mental improvement."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The standard of material improvement is not actually fixed. One person may be satisfied with certain material conditions, while another may be dissatisfied with the same conditions. The question is, "What should the standard of material life be?" As far as Vedic civilization is concerned, the material necessities are eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. These are present in both the animal and human kingdoms. Standards, however, vary, according to different cultures.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte felt that we should deal only with information that can be verified by experiment, or demonstration.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then, how are these planets floating in the air? What is the scientific explanation for that? Who made this cosmic arrangement? If they don't know, then what is the value of their scientific knowledge? Because they cannot answer these questions, they say that they are not worth knowing.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte would feel that such knowledge is not very useful.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But knowledge means finding out the source of knowledge, the source of everything. You are seeing only a portion of someone's actions and reactions, but you do not know who that someone is. If you don't know, you cannot pose as a man of knowledge.

Çyämasundara däsa: Comte is interested in knowledge dealing with sense phenomena, knowledge that can be directly, scientifically utilized.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, naturally you can perceive a tree growing, but a man interested in knowledge wants to know the origin of that tree. One who does not or cannot know says, "It doesn't matter," but if you are serious about knowledge, it matters. Knowledge of the tree's origin is certainly practical. We understand that a tree comes from a seed, but where does the seed come from? How is it that so much potency is given to the seed? Who gives that seed such potency?

Çyämasundara däsa: Is that knowledge useful?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Of course, it may not be useful for a fool. For a fool, such scientific knowledge is of no use, but for a real scientist, knowledge of the origin of things is most essential. Only a fool would say that such knowledge is useless. A scientific man wants to find the cause of things, whether knowledge of that cause is immediately useful or not. Higher knowledge has no value for an ordinary man. In this Kali-yuga, the ordinary man is a fool. He thinks, "Why are people wasting their time searching for God?" For a fool, the search for God is unimportant, but for a scientist, it is most important.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte felt that it was the working man, the çüdra, who is most apt to be the arbiter of Positivism, not the scientist or philosopher. He writes: "The occupations of working men are evidently far more conducive to philosophical views than those of the middle classes, since they are not so absorbing as to prevent continuous thought, even during the hours of labor."

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can the working man become an arbiter? Every working man requires some manager to direct him, and in Communist countries we have seen that there is a managerial class as well as a Working class. If this is the case, how can the worker help us? He is always subordinate to some manager.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte wanted to form working men's clubs that would be dedicated to the philosophy of Positivism. These would form "a provisional substitute for the church of old times, or rather to prepare the way for the religious building of the new form of worship, the worship of humanity."

Çréla Prabhupäda: His conception of humanity is not very clear. What does he mean by humanity? What does the working class know of humanity? If by "humanity" he means the totality of all human beings, he must still admit that every human being has some individuality. Even if you consider all humanity to be the same, how will you account for individuality?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, it is his contention and that of Communism in general that all men are basically the same in relation to the state.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, they are all under the laws of the state, but their thinking, feeling, and willing are not under the state. Men think, feel, and will differently. How, then, can they be one? Of course, human beings have two arms, two legs, and one head, but the working of the brain differs according to the individual. It is not possible to adjust these differences and reconcile all humanity as a whole. Everyone will not be in total agreement. People have their own tastes even in eating, sleeping, mating, and defending—to say nothing of thinking, feeling, and willing. If you try to force uniformity, you will create dissatisfaction.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte felt that Positivism and Communism—which was then in its formative stage—could go hand in hand. He writes: "Positivism has nothing to fear from Communism; on the contrary, it will probably be accepted by most Communists among the working classes...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: He speaks of a working class but not a managerial class. He wants a classless society, but he wants it populated only by working men. But the fact is that working men require direction, just as the legs and hands require directions from the brain. That is quite natural. It is not possible for the working classes not to be under someone's direction.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the different qualities of men and women, Comte wrote: "In all kinds of force, for the physical, intellectual or practical, it is certain that men surpass women, in accordance with a general law which prevails throughout the animal kingdom....If there were nothing else to do but to love...women would be supreme."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is a natural distinction between men and women. How can it be changed? Women are meant for certain activities, just as men are. You may try to change this artificially, but basically it cannot be changed. A woman becomes pregnant, but a man does not. How can this be changed?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, from this he concludes that women, being dominated by love, are morally superior to men. He envisioned woman as "the spontaneous priestess of humanity. She personifies in the purest form the principle of love upon which the unity of our nature depends."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is Comte's imagination. When a woman is misguided, she becomes dangerous, and there is no question of love. According to the Vedic conception, women and children are on the same level, and they should both be protected by men. In childhood a woman is protected by her father, in youth by her husband, and in old age by her grown sons. Women should never be given independence, but they should be given protection. In this way, their natural love for father, husband, and children will develop very smoothly. Thus the relationship between women and men should be established very happily so that both can execute their real function: cooperative spiritual life. The woman should look after the comfort of the man, and the man, who works hard, should also look after her comfort. Then both will be satisfied, and their spiritual lives will progress. A man is meant to work hard, and a woman is meant to give comfort and love in the home. In this way, man and woman can combine so that both can progress in spiritual life.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte felt that love of God is inconsistent with love for our fellow men, and that it has always interfered with man's love of woman. He writes: "It was impiety for the knight to love his lady better than his God; and thus the best feelings of man's nature were repressed by his religious faith. Women, therefore, are not really interested in perpetuating the old system (of religion); and the very instincts by which their nature is characterized will soon incline them to abandon it."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Generally, women are interested in a comfortable home life. That is their nature. They are not spiritually very advanced or interested, but if a man has spiritual interests, and the woman helps the man—either as a mother, wife, or daughter—both can make spiritual progress. However, the woman must remain subordinate, and the man must make spiritual progress. Because the woman helps the man, she shares his spiritual benefits.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte envisioned women primarily as companions of men. He writes: "The first aspect then, under which Positivism considers woman, is simply as the companion of man, irrespective of her maternal duties....For perfect friendship, difference of sex is essential, as excluding the possibility of rivalry."

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to the bodily demands, there are sexual necessities. Women should not only give sex pleasure to their husbands, but should also prepare good food. After coming home from a day of hard work, the man should be supplied good food, comfort, and sex. Then the home becomes very happy, and both husband and wife are satisfied.

Then they can improve their real business, which is spiritual understanding. Human life is meant for progressing spiritually, and people must first of all know that the spirit soul is at the basis even of material life. The body is built upon the soul. Although women are generally less intelligent, this understanding is required of both men and women. With the help of the husband, a woman can become more intelligent. In Vedic history, we have the example of Kapila-deva giving spiritual instructions to his mother Devahüti. Whether the woman is a daughter, wife, or mother, if she remains subordinate, she can receive knowledge from either her father, husband, or son. In the Puräëas, there is the example of Lord Çiva answering the spiritual questions of Pärvaté. Women supply the comforts of the tongue, belly, and genitals, and, remaining submissive, they are instructed in spiritual life. Thus there is cooperative advancement.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte felt that at least in the beginning stages of Positivism, women should take the place of God as an object of man's affection and love. He writes: "From childhood, each of us will be taught to regard women's sex as the principal source of human happiness and improvement, whether in public life or in private....In a word, man will kneel to women, and to women alone....She will be regarded by man as the most perfect personification of humanity....The worship of women, when it has assumed a more systematic shape, will be valued for its own sake as a new instrument of happiness and moral growth....The worship of women satisfies this condition, and is so far of greater efficacy, than the worship of God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is the duty of men to protect women and maintain them comfortably, not worship them. It is not a very good proposal to worship a woman as God. Then man will be henpecked. Worship is reserved for God only, and is not meant for others. However, cooperation between men and women for the sake of worshipping God is desirable. It is not that a man or a woman should be worshipped as God. Sometimes, affection is so strong that a person may see another person as God, but that is sentimentalism. God is different from men and women, who are but living entities meant to worship God. A woman should always be engaged in assisting a man in every respect in his religious, social, and family life. That is the real benefit of conjugal life.

Hayagréva däsa: Comte writes that "the whole effect of Positivist worship will be to make men feel clearly how far superior in every respect is the synthesis founded on the love of humanity to that founded on the love of God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Love of humanity means raising humanity to the point where people can understand the real goal of life. We do not serve humanity by keeping people in darkness. We must enlighten others with knowledge, and ultimate knowledge means understanding God, our relationship with God, and the activities of that relationship. That is real humanitarian work. Mankind must be informed of the nature of the body and the soul and the necessities and goal of the soul. In this way, we can really serve humanity. We do not serve it by encouraging the animal propensities.

XCOMMUNISM

XCOMMUNISM

DS:Karl Marx (1818-1883)

Karl Marx (1818-1883)

Hayagréva däsa: Marx was a descendent of rabbis on both sides of his family, but Marx's father was converted to Christianity, and Marx received a Christian education. In any case, Marx himself opposed both Christianity and Judaism. At the age of twenty-three, after having studied some philosophy in his university classes, Marx became an avowed atheist. It was Hegel who wrote: "Because the accidental is not, God or the Absolute is." On this, Marx commented: "Obviously the reverse can also be said." That is, because God is not, the accidental is.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can any sensible man accept the view that everything is accidental? Is a child taking birth accidental? There must have been unity between a father and a mother. Marx, for instance, may not have wanted to die, but he was forced to. How can this take place accidentally? There must be some superior force. We may not wish to have an accident, but accidents happen nonetheless. This is a question of common sense. In nature, we see that there are many planets in the sky, and they are not accidentally colliding, but are remaining in their positions. The sun rises according to precise calculations. Since universal functions are going on very systematically, there must be some brain behind them, and we call this supreme brain God. How can you deny this?

Hayagréva däsa: Marx felt that true philosophy would say: "In simple truth, I bear hate for any and every God." He saw this as philosophy's "own avowal, its own judgement against all heavenly and earthly gods who do not acknowledge human self-consciousness as the supreme divinity. There must be no other on a level with it."

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can human intelligence be perfect unless it comes to the point of understanding the Absolute Truth, the original cause of everything? Our consciousness must progress, and progress means moving toward the ultimate goal. If a human being is ignorant of the ultimate cause and the ultimate goal, of what value is his intelligence?

Hayagréva däsa: Marx considered religion to be the pastime of degraded men who attempt to escape reality. He writes: "Religion is the sigh of the distressed creature, the soul of a heartless world, as it is also the spirit of a spiritless condition. It is the opium of the people." Being an illusion, religion cannot solve any of man's problems, but can only complicate them. "The more man puts into God," Marx wrote, "the less he retains in himself."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We can actually see that the Communists are not being so greatly favored without God. Now the Chinese and Russians are disagreeing. Differences of opinion will still be there, whether people deny God or not. So how have they improved matters? Both Communists and capitalists need to understand the nature of God. We have seen that denying God and acting independently have not brought peace.

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx believed that everything is produced from economic struggle, and that religion is a technique invented by the bourgeoisie or the capitalists to dissuade the masses from revolution by promising them a better existence after death.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He himself has created a philosophy that is presently being enforced by coercion and killing. As we have often explained, religion is that part of our nature which is permanent, which we cannot give up. No one can give up his religion. And what is that religion? Service. Marx desires to serve humanity by putting forward his philosophy; therefore that is his religion. Everyone is trying to render some service. The father is trying to serve his family, the statesman is trying to serve his country, and the philanthropist is trying to serve all humanity. Whether you are Karl Marx, or Stalin, or Gandhi, a Hindu, a Muslim, or a Christian, you must serve. Because we are presently rendering service to so many people and concepts, we are becoming confused. Therefore Kåñëa advises us to give up all other service and serve Him alone.

Hayagréva däsa: Like Comte, Marx hoped that the worker would eventually eliminate religion. He wrote: "The political emancipation of the Jew, the Christian, the religious man in general, is the emancipation of the state from Judaism, from Christianity, from religion generally." Thus the worker would become the savior of mankind by freeing man from a religion that worships a supernatural being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Has that actually happened? Marx is dead and gone, yet his Communist theory is being exhibited in practice, and still we see that they have not liberated anyone. Now the Russians are not relating congenially with the Chinese. Why is this? They have abolished God, and the working class is there. Why, then, is there dissension and desire?

Hayagréva däsa: Marx felt that religion was blocking man's path to happiness. He wrote: "The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. The demand to abandon the illusions about their condition is the demand to give up a condition that requires illusion. Hence criticism of religion is...criticism of this vale of tears whose halo is religion."

Çréla Prabhupäda: A religious system deteriorates when there is no understanding of its philosophical basis. People are apt to reject such sentimental religions. We must understand in fact that God is at the top of all cosmic manifestations and activities. Laws given by the supreme head of the cosmic manifestation constitute what we call religion. If we create our own religious systems on the basis of sentiments, we create only troubles and will be misunderstood. We must understand that there is a brain behind all the cosmic manifestations, and if we know the nature of this brain and how it is working, we attain real scientific understanding.

Hayagréva däsa: Marx encouraged labor not for the construction of temples but for the benefit of man himself. He writes: "The alien being, to whom labor and the produce of labor belong, and in whose service labor is done and for whose benefit the produce of labor is provided, can only be man himself."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We must come to the understanding that it is beneficial for man to abide by the orders of God. If there is any organization at all, there is a director, even in Communist countries. Leaders are necessary, and the supreme leader is called God. It is not that the Communists can do without leaders. Even Karl Marx provided leadership. Now it is up to people to decide whether to work under the leadership of God, or under Marx and Lenin. We cannot avoid leadership; so now the question remains, "Whose leadership is perfect?" That we must decide.

Hayagréva däsa: Like Comte, Marx believed that atheism was unnecessary because it was negative denial, whereas socialism is positive assertion. Marx writes: "Socialism is man's positive self-consciousness, no longer mediated through the annulment of religion, just as real life is man's positive reality through Communism."

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have made our point that real religion is not sentiment and that leadership has to be accepted, be it Communist, theist, or atheist. When leadership is selected, and directions are given by the leader, we can call it some "ism," but in any case, religion means accepting the leadership of God and His directions. I don't think that even the Communists can basically change this concept. They also have a leader—Marx, Lenin, or Stalin—and they are giving directions for the people to follow. Similarly, Kåñëa is there, and we are following His instructions. So factually what is the difference? In either case, there is authority. We have to select the best leader, and we also have to select a criterion for establishing him.

Hayagréva däsa: For Marx, there is nothing spiritual in the universe. He writes: "An incorporeal substance is just as much a contradiction as an incorporeal body. Body, being, substance are one and the same real idea. One cannot separate the thought from matter which thinks."

Çréla Prabhupäda: When there is no spirit soul within the body, the body is considered dead. Otherwise, what is the difference between a dead body and a living body?

Hayagréva däsa: He further writes: "Since only what is material is perceptible, knowable, nothing is known of the existence of God. I am sure only of my own existence."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if he does not know of the spirit soul, how can he be certain of his own existence? What is his idea of life? Why is the body like a dead stone when life has ended? He must first understand what life is.

Hayagréva däsa: He felt that consciousness is basically social. "Life is not determined by consciousness," he writes, "but consciousness by life.... Consciousness is therefore from the very beginning a social product, and remains so as long as men exist at all."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then why does life have an end? Why does he cease to exist? What is the answer to this? The soul of man exists, but why does he die? Death is a fact, and it cannot be denied. During this lifetime, he may speak very loudly, but as soon as he is dead, he can speak no more. Where is consciousness then?

Hayagréva däsa: Marx opposed Comte's recommendation of the worship of women, and also the worship of God in nature. "There is no question," he writes, "that modern sciences, which along with modern industry, have revolutionized the whole of nature and put an end to man's childish attitude toward nature, as well as to other forms of childishness....The position as regards to the worship of female is the same as nature worship."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But how has science overcome the basic laws of nature? Has man put an end to birth, death, old age, and disease? If not, what is the meaning of revolutionizing or conquering nature? Nature's laws are going on just as before. Before Marx died, his father and mother died, and their parents died before them, and so on. How has man then conquered nature? Death, old age, and disease continue. Where is the improvement?

Hayagréva däsa: If there is no improvement, he would feel that it is because religion has been an impediment.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This has nothing to do with religion. This is the work of nature. When a man takes birth, he faces death. How has science revolutionized this matter? Nature's work is going on despite all the theories of Marx and others. So how have they surpassed the laws of nature?

Hayagréva däsa: Marx felt that religion is the cause of constant antagonism between men. "The most persistent form of antagonism between the Jew and the Christian is religious antagonism," he writes. "How does one solve an antagonism? By making it impossible. And how is a religious antagonism made impossible? By abolishing religion."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The question of antagonism is solved if we know God and God's desires. If we know the government and its laws, there is no antagonism. Antagonism is there when so-called religious systems do not know of God and His desires. God and His regulations are clearly described in the Bhagavad-gétä, and therefore we are advocating the reading of Bhagavad-gétä so people will know God and His instructions. As I have said before, religion means understanding God according to a system. God is the supreme proprietor and the supreme friend of everyone. He is the enjoyer of everything. People claim that their religion is better than others, but first of all we must know what religion is. It is knowing the orders of the supreme proprietor, and living according to them. If we do not know what religion is, why criticize religion and create antagonisms?

Hayagréva däsa: Marx felt that both Christian and Jew should cast off their respective religions, "as nothing more than different stages of evolution of the human spirit, as different snakeskins shed by history." Then man will no longer be bothered by religious antagonisms but will be able to enjoy a scientific and human relationship.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When people stamp themselves Christians, Jews, Hindus, and Moslems without knowing God and His desires, there will naturally be antagonism. Therefore we should scientifically understand what is religion and who is God. Then this antagonism will cease.

Hayagréva däsa: Marx believed that the state should eventually assume the role of Christ. He writes: "Religion is merely the indirect recognition of man through a mediator. The state is the mediator between man and the freedom of man. As Christ is the mediator on whom man unburdens all his own divinity and his whole religious burden, so also the state is the mediator on which man places all his unholiness and his whole human burden."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Christ gave the knowledge by which we can be relieved of the material body, and that is the function of all religious scripture. Religious scriptures should give information about God's exact position. When people learn scientifically of God's existence and their relationship with God, everything will be adjusted. Our Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying to give people an exact idea of God, exact definitions, and exact instructions.

Hayagréva däsa: Here is a point that most Communists would choose to ignore: "To practice one's own particular religion is explicitly included among the rights of man," Marx writes. "The privilege of religion is a universal human right."

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is always the state's duty to see that there is freedom of religion. It is also the state's duty to see that when a person is propagating a particular type of religion, he is acting according to it.

Hayagréva däsa: Marx felt, however, that religion should be individual, not communal. "But liberty as a right of man is not based on the association of man with man, but rather on a separation of man from man. It is the right of the separation, the right of the limited individual, limited to himself."

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no question of separation. When we accept God as the Supreme Father, we accept His sons as brothers who should be obedient to Him. If we all obey the Supreme Father, how will there be differences of opinion? When we do not know the Supreme Father and do not obey Him, there is dissension. It is the son's duty to obey the father and enjoy his property. It is a question of the father being the center.

Hayagréva däsa: Marx believed that if man persists in worshipping God, he should do so privately and not communally.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If God is a fact, and man must worship Him, then why not communally? Does he think that every individual should manufacture his own God and worship Him? God is the Supreme Father, the Father of every man, of every living entity. How can He be different? There may be ten sons in a family, but the father is one. It is not that the different sons say, "Oh, I will select my own father." It is not possible. The difficulty is that no one knows the Supreme Father, and no one is prepared to obey His orders. That is the difficulty.

Hayagréva däsa: Marx was hoping that the isolation of religion would lead to its dissolution.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The dissolution of religion means animalism, and we have come to that point in human history. That is the defect in modern society. If people are serious about religion, they should sit down together and acknowledge God as the Supreme Father. Once people do this, they will not fight among themselves. In any case, religion will not dissolve because it is an inherent quality within every living entity. When I was in Russia, I saw that even the young men there were also interested in God. Belief in God cannot be avoided.

Çyämasundara däsa: As far as Marx's political philosophy is concerned, we should try to change the world, not interpret it. Dialectic materialism is based on the Hegelian dialectic of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis, which he applied to economics and sociology. The thesis is the capitalist bourgeoisie; the antithesis is the proletariat; and the synthesis is a classless, or Communistic, society.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But how is it possible to have a classless society? We find that there are different classes of men by nature. Kåñëa says: Cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöaà guëa-karma-vibhägaçaù. "According to the three modes of material nature and the work associated with them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me." (Bg. 4.13) Also:

brähmaëa-kñatriya-viçäà
çüdräëäà ca parantapa
karmäëi pravibhaktäni
svabhäva-prabhavair guëaiù

"Brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas and çüdras are distinguished by their qualities of work, O chastiser of the enemy, in accordance with the modes of nature." (Bg. 18.41) Since this is the case, how can we bring different natures to the same level?

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx felt that it was the mode of production that determined our beliefs and ideas. He wrote: "It is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousness."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a question of training. The next question is, What is the center of that training? What is the motto?

Çyämasundara däsa: The motto is: "From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The contributions of different living entities are different. A scientific man contributes one thing, a philosopher another, and a worker something else. Trees are also contributing, as well as birds and beasts. The cow contributes milk, and the dog contributes its service as a watchdog. Everyone is contributing, giving, and taking. This arrangement is already there by nature. But what is Marx's idea of a classless society?

Çyämasundara däsa: He felt that the means of production should be owned in common so that there would be no exploitation of workers.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is the question of exploitation? I am a religious preacher, and my contribution is spiritual knowledge. Where is the exploitation? As far as a classless society is concerned, I have been to Moscow and have seen women sweeping the streets while the big bosses sit in their cars and watch. So where is this classless society? As long as you maintain a society, you have to make some distinction between upper and lower. However, if the central point is one, it doesn't matter on what level we work. Our bodies have different parts, which are all working to contribute to the whole.

Çyämasundara däsa: They claim to look on it the same way. The scientist or manager is in a top position, but the worker is considered to occupy as glorious a position.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But we have seen in Moscow that not everyone is satisfied. One boy came to us and lamented that he was not allowed to leave the country. The point is that you will never be able to make everyone happy. Nor will there ever be a classless society because the mentalities of people differ. How can you say that your mentality is the same as mine?

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx believed that it was possible to have a uniformity of ideas and purpose if the means of production are controlled. The problem is that the capitalists, who own the means of production, control people's ideas.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not possible for everyone to think uniformly, but it is possible to find a central interest. For instance, in our Society for Kåñëa consciousness, our central interest is Kåñëa. People are working in different ways, but everyone is convinced that he is working to render service to Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Marx, the center is the state, which in time will wither away. Then a classless society will emerge.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if you make the state the center, there is no question of a classless society. In the state, there is always a leader, a president or prime minister. Khruschev was the head, and when people were dissatisfied, they drove him from office. This means that the head was not perfect and that people were dissatisfied with him. This is going on even in noncommunist countries. So what is the difference between Marx's theory and others? What is taking place inside Russia is also taking place outside. First of all, the person in the center must be perfect; then his dictations can be considered perfect. If you put a lot of imperfect men in office, what is the point in changing governments? The same corruption will go on.

Çyämasundara däsa: Presumably, the perfect leader would be one who follows Marx's philosophy perfectly.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But his philosophy is not perfect. He proposes a classless society, but that will never emerge. When you run a government, there must be administrators, and also people to sweep the streets. So how will a classless society come about? When will the street sweeper be satisfied to see someone enjoying an administrative position? Now, in this Kåñëa consciousness society, I sit on a vyäsäsana, and you offer me garlands. Why is this? You do this willingly because you see that there is a perfect man you can follow. Unless you are convinced that the leader is perfect, there is no question of bowing down and working hard like menial servants.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Communists, Lenin was a perfect man.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But who is following Lenin? Lenin's perfection was in overthrowing the royal family. What other perfection has he given? People are not happy simply reading books. You cannot make people happy artificially, by force. Unless there is a perfect ideal man in the center, there cannot be a classless society. It is not possible. We have seen in Russia that people do not feel that there is perfection in the center.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, the goal is the production of goods for the material well being of all people.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is useless. We have seen that production in America is beyond comparison in the world, and that is a capitalist society. Yet despite so much production, people are not satisfied. The young men especially are confused. It is nonsensical to think that by increasing production you will satisfy people. Man is not created simply to eat. Man also has a brain and spiritual and intellectual necessities. In India, we have seen people sitting silently in a solitary place and practicing yoga. There is no question of production satisfying them. The proposition that everyone will be satisfied by increasing production is a proposition for animals. The basic principle is nonsensical and due to insufficient knowledge. Perhaps Marx was thinking like that because he was coming from a country where people were starving. This means that he has no conception of what happiness actually is.

Happiness is in understanding the truths given in Bhagavad-gétä. We are happy when we know that God is the proprietor of everything and that He is the supreme enjoyer. We are not enjoyers; we are all workers. By nature there are enjoyers and workers. In your body, for instance, the stomach enjoys, and all the other parts work to satisfy the stomach. When the stomach is satisfied, all other parts of the body are nourished. Everywhere we look, we see that there are those who are enjoying, and those who are working. There is no question of a Communist or capitalist society. You cannot avoid the fact that there must be directors, or enjoyers, and workers. We therefore have to find out how both the manager and the worker can feel equal happiness. There must be cooperation for a central purpose, and a classless society is possible only when Kåñëa is at the center. Then the brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras all work for His satisfaction.

yataù pravåttir bhütänäà
yena sarvam idaà tatam
svakarmaëä tam abhyarcya
siddhià vindati mänavaù

"By worship of the Lord, who is the source of all beings, and who is all pervading, man can, in the performance of his own duty, attain perfection." (Bg. 18.46) Each class works in his own way for the satisfaction of Kåñëa. The brähmaëa contributes one thing, and the kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras, something else:

çamo damas tapaùçaucaà
kñäntir ärjavam eva ca
jïänaà vijïänam ästikyaà
brahma-karma svabhäva-jam

çauryaà tejo dhåtir däkñyaà
yuddhe cäpy apaläyanam
dänam éçvara-bhävaç ca
kñätraà karma svabhäva-jam

kåñi-gorakñya-väëijyaà
vaiçya-karma svabhäva-jam
paricaryätmakaà karma
çüdrasyäpi svabhäva-jam

"Peacefulness, self-control, austerity, purity, tolerance, honesty, wisdom, knowledge, and religiousness—these are the qualities by which the brähmaëas work. Heroism, power, determination, resourcefulness, courage in battle, generosity, and leadership are the qualities of work for the kñatriyas. Farming, cow protection and business are the qualities of work for the vaiçyas, and for the çüdras there is labor and service to others." (Bg. 18.42-44)

Çyämasundara däsa: How does this differ from the Communist state wherein the street sweepers, the managers, the farmers, and the military all contribute for the central purpose, the state?

Çréla Prabhupäda: If the state is not perfect, no one will be willing to contribute to it. Of course, you may force people to contribute to it; that is a different thing. But voluntary contribution will be there only when people are satisfied that the center is perfect. In any case, there will never be a classless society because there will always be an intellectual class, an administrative class, a mercantile class, and a working class. People will never find perfection in the state; therefore the workers will always remain dissatisfied. If not, why are they always running their leaders out of office?

Çyämasundara däsa: In examining history, Marx noted that the main production amongst the ancient Greeks and Romans was carried out by slaves, and in feudal times by serfs.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But the Communists have also created slaves; they call them workers. When you have workers, you must also have people directing them. Therefore a dictator is needed. There must be directors and workers in any society, but they should be so satisfied that they forget their differences. That is, there should be no envy. If you make the center anything other than Kåñëa, you will have nothing but materialistic activity. Materialism necessarily means exploitation. The only solution is Kåñëa consciousness. We must make Kåñëa the center, and work for Him. This is the formula: pour water on the root of the tree, and all the branches, twigs, and leaves will be satisfied. By satisfying Kåñëa, we satisfy everyone. Arjuna had many problems, but by satisfying Kåñëa, all his problems were resolved. When we put Kåñëa at the center, everything we do is absolute. We may either write books or wash the dishes; our activities will not collide because they are on the absolute platform. In Våndävana, some living entities are cowherd boys, some are cows, some are trees, and so on, but they are all satisfied because Kåñëa is the center, and they are happy by loving Him. When people become Kåñëa conscious and understand how to love Kåñëa, there will be a classless society. Otherwise, it is not possible. It is all bogus, humbug.

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx felt that in the capitalistic state, a few men control at the expense of many.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But there are only a few men in the Kremlin. What is the difference? Marx was interested in changing society, but we can see there is no difference. Society can be changed only when the center is Kåñëa. The people in this International Society for Kåñëa consciousness have actually changed their lives. Unless the consciousness of people is changed, how can the social structure change? First of all, we must change the consciousness; then society will change. If the consciousness of people does not change first, how will they accept a new theory? First, we must change the heart, and that is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. Ceto-darpaëa-märjanam (Çikñäñöaka 1). By chanting, we cleanse the mirror of the mind.

If the consciousness is the same, what do you gain by changing the form of government? You will have the same situation. When you see stool on the ground, one side is dry, and the other side is moist. If you think, "Oh, this side is very nice because it is dry," you are very foolish. After all, any way you look at it, it is stool. There will always be people who are hungry, and people who are wealthy. There will always be people with different ideas and capacities. People will never become the same. Temporary situations are created by materialistic men or by the laws of nature; they come and they go. Kåñëa tells us in Bhagavad-gétä that we should be fixed on the absolute platform and not worry about these temporary things. Ägamäpäyino 'nityäs täàs titikñasva (Bg. 2.14). A sane man should not bother with these temporary "ism's." We do not support capitalism or Communism, this idea or that idea. Our only concern is how to satisfy Kåñëa. We know perfectly well that all these systems will come and go, that if they are existing now, in the future they will not continue to exist. We must fix ourselves up with that system which is eternal.

Çyämasundara däsa: In Marx's society, private property would be abolished, and there would be common ownership of the means of production. That is, everything would be state owned.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, we have seen in Moscow that the people do not like to go shopping because they are obliged to stand in line for hours. So that system does not appear to be working very well. If you cannot get what you want, what is the use of the stores? Besides, what is the state but an extension of the individual self? The self is extended in the form of one's family, children, community, and nation. So-called nationalism and Communism are just extensions of the self. The labels are different; the quality remains the same. We may steal ourselves, or have others steal for us. What is the difference? We may say, "Nothing is mine." That much is a fact. But we also say, "Everything belongs to God." We can live very comfortably in this world with the consciousness that everything belongs to God. God has given us the opportunity to live here, and we should satisfy and glorify God.

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx saw the capitalists as parasites living at the cost of the workers.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But the Communists are also living at the cost of the workers. They are drawing big salaries while others are sweeping the streets. So what is the difference?

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx felt that the price of a product should equal the labor expended on it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, we see that in India the price of ghee has risen, but people are still buying ghee. The price may be two hundred rupees a kilo, or two rupees a kilo. The man who is destined to purchase it will do so, regardless of price.

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx would say that no profit should be made off the ghee.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He is simply pointing out some anomalies, but these anomalies cannot be checked even by the Communists. They will appear in different ways because that is the nature of material existence. Material existence means exploitation, and these anomalies can be checked only when there is Kåñëa consciousness. You may say that one should not make a profit, but no one will accept this theory. The tendency to make a profit is there, and you cannot stop it. The exploitative mind is there, whether one is a Communist or a capitalist.

In Bengali, this is called mäyä-tattva. It is a bug's business to suck the blood of others. In the winter, the bug dries up, but as soon as summer comes, he immediately starts sucking again. In the material world, the mentality is to exploit others and become fat like a bug. Whether you are a Commmunist in the winter, or a capitalist in the summer, your tendencies are the same. As soon as you have an opportunity, you will become fat by extracting the blood of others. Unless there is a change in heart, this cannot be stopped.

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx felt that only the workers are entitled to the surplus value of a product.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But as soon as a worker gets some money, he becomes a proprietor, takes advantage of his position, and becomes a capitalist. What is the point in changing your designation? A change in mentality is needed.

Çyämasundara däsa: Since capital is unnecessary for production, Marx urged the workers to unite and violently overthrow the capitalists.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When one is very poor, he favors his brothers who are also poor and working hard. But as soon as one gets a little money, he immediately becomes a capitalist. This is because everyone in this material world is thinking, "I shall become the Lord." In material life, everyone is searching for a profit, for some adoration, for a position. How can you equalize people forcibly? It is not possible.

Çyämasundara däsa: The Communists have played upon this profiteering tendency. If the worker produces more, he is glorified by the state and given a small bonus as incentive.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he has a tendency to lord it over the creation, and he wants some profit, some bribe. Everyone wants some profit, and the state cannot destroy this tendency, neither by law nor by force.

Çyämasundara däsa: The Communists are trying to centralize everything—money, communications, and transport—by putting everything in the hands of the state.

Çréla Prabhupäda: To what benefit? As soon as all the wealth is centralized, the members of the central government will appropriate it just as Stalin and Khruschev did. All these ideas are useless as long as the tendency for exploitation is not reformed. The Russians have organized their country according to Marx's theories, yet all their leaders have turned out to be cheaters. Where is their program for reforming this cheating propensity? In any case, the leaders will never be able to train the people to think that everything belongs to the state. This idea is simply Utopian nonsense.

Çyämasundara däsa: Another slogan of Marx is: "Human nature has no reality." He believes that man's nature changes through history according to material conditions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he know of human nature? It is certainly true that everything in this cosmic creation, or jagat, is changing. Your body changes daily. Everything is changing, just like the waves in the ocean. It does not take a very advanced philosophy to understand this. Marx's theory is also changing. It cannot last. Man does, however, have a fundamental nature that never changes, and that is his spiritual nature. We are teaching people to act according to their changeless spiritual nature, and this means serving Kåñëa. If we try to serve Kåñëa now, we will continue to serve Him when we go to Vaikuëöha, the spiritual world. Therefore loving service to Lord Kåñëa is called nitya, eternal.

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate

"Always chanting My glories, endeavoring with great determination, bowing down before Me, these great souls perpetually worship Me with devotion." (Bg. 9.14) The Communists try to replace Kåñëa with the state, expecting people to think, "Nothing in my favor; everything in favor of the state." But people will never accept this. It is impossible. All the rascals can do is force the people to work, as Stalin did. As soon as someone opposed Stalin, Stalin immediately had his throat cut. The same disease is there today. So how will their program be successful?

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx believed that human nature is a product of environment. By putting a man in a factory and getting him to identify with the state, he would be transformed into a selfless person.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The basic disease of man is envy, and as long as he is envious, he will remain selfish. When a man sees that he is working very hard but that the profits are not coming to him, his enthusiasm will immediately slacken. In Bengal, there is a proverb: "As a proprietor, I can turn sand into gold, but as soon as I am no longer the proprietor, the gold becomes sand." The Russian people are in this position. They are not as rich as the Europeans and Americans, and because of this, they are unhappy. If people cannot make a profit from their work, they will eventually lose all interest in their country. The average man will think, "Whether I work or not, I get the same result. I cannot adequately feed and clothe my family." Thinking in this way, he will lose his incentive to work. A scientist will see that despite his high position, his wife and children are dressed just like common laborers.

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx felt that industrial and scientific work constitute the highest kind of activity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But unless the scientists and industrialists receive sufficient profit, they will be reluctant to work for the state.

Çyämasundara däsa: The Russian goal is the production of material goods for the enhancement of human well-being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Their human well-being actually means, "If you don't agree with me, I'll cut your throat." This was Stalin's idea of human well-being, and anyone who disagreed with him was killed or imprisoned. They say that a few must suffer for the sake of many, but we have personally seen that Russia has achieved neither general happiness nor prosperity. In Moscow, for instance, none of the big buildings have been recently built. They are old and ravaged, or poorly renovated. And there are also long lines in the stores. These are indications that the economic condition is unsound.

Çyämasundara däsa: Lenin reinforced all of Marx's ideas and added a few of his own. He saw history moving in leaps and progressing toward the Communistic era. He wanted Russia to leap into the dictatorship of the proletariat, which he called the final stage of historical development.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We can say with confidence—and they may note it carefully—that after the Bolshevik Revolution, there will be other revolutions, because as long as people live on the mental platform, there will be revolutions. Our proposition is to give up all these mental concoctions and come to the spiritual platform where there are no longer revolutions. As Dhruva Mahäräja said: "Now that I am seeing God, I am completely satisfied. Now all kinds of theories are finished." God consciousness is the final revolution. There will be repeated revolutions in this material world until people come to Kåñëa consciousness. People are trying to approach an objective, but they do not know that the final objective is Kåñëa. They are trying to make adjustments with materialistic revolutions, not knowing that they are spiritual beings and that without God, there is no question of happiness. We are part and parcel of the Supreme Spirit, Kåñëa, but we have left His association and fallen from the spiritual world because of our desire to enjoy this material world. Unless we reawaken the understanding of our spiritual position and return to the spiritual world, we can never be happy, just as a fish can never be happy out of water. We may theorize for many lifetimes, but we will continue to see one revolution after another. History repeats itself. The old orders change, yielding their places to the new.

Çyämasundara däsa: Marx believed that the Communist revolution would be the final revolution because it is the perfect answer to all social contradictions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As long as the Communist idea remains materialistic, it cannot be the final revolution. It must be spiritualized. They believe that the state is the owner of everything, but the real owner is God. When they come to this conclusion, the Communistic idea will be perfect. In our International Society for Kåñëa consciousness, we are practicing perfect spiritual Communism by doing everything for Kåñëa. We know that Kåñëa is the supreme enjoyer of the result of all work. Bhoktäraà yajïa-tapasäà (Bg. 5.29). The Communist philosophy as it is now practiced is vague, but it can become perfect if the conclusion of Bhagavad-gétä is accepted: that is, Kåñëa is the supreme proprietor, the supreme enjoyer, and the supreme friend of everyone. Now people mistrust the state, but if people accept Kåñëa as their friend, they will have perfect confidence in Kåñëa, just as Arjuna had on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. The great victory of Arjuna and his associates on the battlefield showed that his confidence in Kåñëa was justified.

yatra yogeçvaraù kåñëo
yatra pärtho dhanur-dharaù
tatra çrér vijayo bhütir
dhruvä nétir matir mama

"Wherever there is Kåñëa, the master of all mystics, and wherever there is Arjuna, the supreme archer, there will also certainly be opulence, victory, extraordinary power, and morality. That is my opinion." (Bg. 18.78) If Kåñëa is at the center of society, the people will be perfectly secure and prosperous. The Communist idea is welcomed, provided they are prepared to replace the so-called state with God. That is religion.

XIAMERICAN PRAGMATISM

XIAMERICAN PRAGMATISM

DS:William James (1842-1910)

William James (1842-1910)

Hayagréva däsa: In his most famous book, The Varieties of Religious Experience, James writes: "Were we to limit our view to it, we should have to define religion as an external art, the art of winning the favor of God....The relation goes direct from heart to heart, from soul to soul, between man and his maker."

Çréla Prabhupäda: There are varieties of living beings living everywhere from the water up to the higher planetary systems. In fact, Padma Puräëa informs us that there are 8,400,000 species: plants, creepers, trees, insects, aquatics, birds, animals, and so forth. God is concerned with all of them, because they are all part and parcel of God. In one word, God is the Father and maintainer of all living entities. He has two subordinate energies—material and spiritual. In the material world, material nature is the mother, God is the Father, and the various living entities are all sons maintained by the Supreme Father. This is the basis of universal brotherhood. It is also confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä (sarva-yoniñu, Bg. 14.4) that material nature is the mother and that Kåñëa is the seed-giving father. If we understand these relationships, we will attain peace and advanced knowledge.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning the founding of religions, James writes: "The founders of every church owed their power originally to the fact of their direct personal communion with the divine. Not only the superhuman founders, the Christ, the Buddha, Mohammed, but all the originators of Christian sects have been in this case;—so personal religion should seem the primordial thing, even to those who continue to esteem it incomplete."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the Supreme Father is a person. We have no experience of a father being anything but a person. Just as in the material world, all fathers are persons, the ultimate Father is also a person. The personal conception of God is there in every religion: Christian, Mohammedan, and Vedic. In the Vedic religion, it is stated, oà tad viñëoù paramaà padam. Those who are spiritually advanced know that the Supreme Father is Lord Viñëu. Lord Viñëu and Kåñëa are the same. Impersonal realization is imperfect and incomplete, whereas Bhagävan, the personal God, is the ultimate end of realization. Our first business is to know God and our relationship with Him. Then we can act accordingly to perfect our lives. This is the process of God realization.

Hayagréva däsa: James considered religion to be the source of philosophy. He writes: "Since the relation (of man to God) may be either moral, physical, or ritual, it is evident that out of religion in the sense in which we take it, theologies, philosophies, and ecclesiastical organizations may secondarily grow."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Philosophy means advancing knowledge, and we are perfecting our knowledge when we begin our understanding of God. Due to foolishness, we sometimes deride God's existence. Sometimes we concoct some imaginary idea, and sometimes we have impersonal and pantheistic conceptions. Philosophy is the search for God, but due to our imperfection, we have different opinions and conceptions of Him. God is a person, and when we know God, talk with Him, see Him, feel His presence, and play with Him, we have attained the highest platform of God realization. We then come to realize that God is great and that we are small and always subordinate. Carrying out God's orders is religion, and the more we realize this, the more we perfect our religion.

Çyämasundara däsa: James noted that there are two fundamental philosophical temperaments. One is called tender-mindedness, and this is typified by the rationalist, the idealist, the optimist, the religionist, and the dogmatist. Tough-mindedness is typified by the empiricist, the materialist, the pessimist, the atheist, the fatalist, and the skeptic.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This depends upon our education, whether we become tender or tough-minded. In either case, we propose that originally the soul is good. Tenderness and toughness are developed later on. They are not the standard. When you come to the platform of the soul, everything is good. From Bhagavad-gétä, we understand that every living entity is part and parcel of God, and God is good. Arjuna accepts Kåñëa as paraà brahma paraà dhäma pavitraà (Bg. 10.12). The word pavitra means "pure." Because we are part of God, we are pure. Impurities are acquired due to contamination in this material world. We may be either tender or tough-minded: this is due to our impurity acquired in this material world. We don't credit a person either way, being tender or tough. A man suffering from a headache thinks that it is better to be suffering from indigestion instead, and vice versa. Because the pure soul is affected by the three guëas—sattva, rajas, and tamas—he is suffering. He must be relieved from all suffering. From the material point of view, one may be a brähmaëa contaminated by sattva-guëa, or a çüdra contaminated by tamo-guëa or rajo-guëa, but from the spiritual platform, both are contaminated by material nature. Because of this, both are suffering. It is explained in Bhagavad-gétä that the brähmaëa thinks, "Oh, I am so pure and learned. I am so this, I am so that." This is called contamination by sattva-guëa. He is not thinking that he is part and parcel of Kåñëa. As long as we are affected by these material modes of nature, our position is the same.

Çyämasundara däsa: James called himself a radical empiricist. He did not see the universe as a neat set of relationships because direct experience informs us that facts are mosaic and discontinuous in their design. Thus for him the universe is a composition of facts which do not form a perfect unity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because he is seeing the universe with imperfect eyes, it appears imperfect. Actually, everything is complete. According to the first verse of Éçopaniñad:

oà pürëam adaù pürëam idea
pürëät pürëam udacyate
pürëasya pürëam ädäya
pürëam evävaçiñyate

"The Personality of Godhead is perfect and complete, and because He is completely perfect, all emanations from Him, such as this phenomenal world, are perfectly equipped as complete wholes. Whatever is produced of the complete whole is also complete in itself. Because He is the complete whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance." (Éçopaniñad, Invocation) God is perfect, and whatever is created by God is perfect. James thinks that it is imperfect because he cannot see it through the eyes of God.

Çyämasundara däsa: For James, the ultimate unification of the universe is never fully attained. He writes: "The universe continually grows in quantity by new experiences that graft themselves upon the older mass; but these very new experiences often help the mass to a more consolidated form."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This conception results from a poor fund of knowledge. The universe is complete, but man alone is not complete. Because the universe is created by a perfect being, it is also perfect. It is not that the universe is evolving. It has been perfect since its creation. Since our knowledge is imperfect, we think that it is evolving.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is this because my observations of the universe are evolving toward a unity?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, this is James's criterion for truth: that which I perceive is true. Truth is what one can experience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what you can perceive may also be wrong because you are not perfect. You may think an imperfect thing perfect, or a perfect thing imperfect. In the çästras it is stated that because human beings are controlled by the mode of passion, they love to work very hard, and thus they think that hard work is happiness. At the same time, the çästras point out that hard work for sense gratification is also being carried on by hogs and dogs. Animals are also working hard for some remuneration, for food, or sense enjoyment. This is called mäyä, illusion.

Çyämasundara däsa: James felt that truth is more than just an agreement of idea with reality. It also has practical significance. What is practical is true.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the truth must be practical. From the verses of Prabodhänanda Sarasvaté, we can understand that one who receives but the slightest merciful glance of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu considers Brahmän and liberation to be hellish. Kaivalyaà narakäyate. Such a person also considers the heavenly planets to be mere phantasmagoria, and the yoga-siddhis, the yoga potencies, to be unimportant. Materialists suffer in this material condition, but a devotee is always satisfied. Although others are full of anxiety, a devotee sees everything as pleasing. All of this is possible by a fragment of the merciful glance of Caitanya Mahäprabhu. This is practical. As soon as we become Kåñëa conscious, all this takes place.

Çyämasundara däsa: For James, truth means experience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also our proposal. Bhaktiù pareçänubhavo viraktir anyatra caiña (Bhäg. 11.2.42). One who is advanced in bhakti is no longer interested in material enjoyment. Unless we come to detest material things, it is to be understood that we are not making progress. When a hungry man eats, he feels satisfied, and his body gains strength. Similarly, when we advance in Kåñëa consciousness, we feel spiritually strong and lose our taste for material enjoyment.

Çyämasundara däsa: James felt that truths can be created or developed in the same way as wealth or health.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Health may be created, but truth cannot. It is not that truth is developing; rather, you are gradually progressing towards truth. It is not that the sun is developing, but as the clouds disappear, your ability to see the sun develops. The sun is fixed in its position.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, for James, truth is a system of verification. That is, ideas become true or are made true through our experience of them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, as you make progress, truth is revealed. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that as we surrender unto Him, He reveals Himself proportionately (Bg. 4.11).

Çyämasundara däsa: But if an idea works, and is applied to concrete facts of experience, we can accept it as a true idea. As our experiences develop, our life progresses. If an idea works in my experience, it becomes true for me.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is our process. In the beginning, it is through faith that we enter into the Kåñëa consciousness movement. In the beginning, we have no practical experience of Kåñëa consciousness. We may see that people who are Kåñëa conscious appear to have very bright faces, and our interest may increase on seeing this. Thus we first come with a little faith and interest, and as we associate with the devotees, our interest increases.

Çyämasundara däsa: So our experiences prove that the ideas are true.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, otherwise how can European and American boys be satisfied with so few material possessions? They are realizing in practice that a simple life is better than an artificial one.

Çyämasundara däsa: But what is practical for one person may not be for another. What is the criterion?

Çréla Prabhupäda: There are relative truths, and there is the Absolute Truth. Some people are interested in one, and some in the other. We may accept some temporary means to attain a goal; however, the ultimate goal is to please Kåñëa, and for this end we may adopt some temporary, relative means.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to James, one who believes has a greater chance to discover the truth than one who doubts.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is so.

ajïaç cäçraddadhänaç ca
saàçayätmä vinaçyati
näyaà loko 'sti na paro
na sukhaà saàçayätmanaù

"But ignorant and faithless persons who doubt the revealed scriptures do not attain God consciousness. For the doubting soul, there is happiness neither in this world nor in the next." (Bg. 4.40) Those who are doubters are finished. Is James a believer or a doubter?

Çyämasundara däsa: He was a believer, a New England Protestant. He says that one who disbelieves faces the risk of losing any chance of discovering the truth.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is so. This means that we accept the fact that God is truth and that He is existing. He believes that we have a better chance to get at the truth by believing in God, and God is truth; therefore God is existing. If you believe that you can become warm by getting next to fire, you are asserting the existence of fire. Unless there is a fire, how can there be warmth? So the belief itself is the proof.

Çyämasundara däsa: For James, the mind must survive the body, since the mind is not dependent on the body for its existence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a fact. When the gross body is finished, the subtle body consisting of the mind, intelligence, and ego remains. These guide us to another gross body. They are like the aroma coming from a rose. We can see the rose, but we cannot see the aroma. Still, the aroma is being scattered by the air. Similarly, when the spirit soul gives up the gross body, it is carried by the mind, intelligence, and ego. According to our desire, that subtle body enters another gross body.

Çyämasundara däsa: If the mind and intelligence are not material, do they not die?

Çréla Prabhupäda: To die means to disappear. The mind disappears when you are liberated.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then I carry my mind with me throughout all my lifetimes?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, as long as you are not liberated.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is this the same mind I have now and have always had?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but the body, which is material and gross, changes. The subtle material body—mind, intelligence, and false ego—accompanies us until we are liberated.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning nondevotional religions, James gives the following estimation of impersonalism and Buddhism: "There are systems of thought which the world usually calls religious, and yet do not positively assume a God. Buddhism is in this case. Popularly, of course, the Buddha himself stands in place of a God; but in strictness the Buddhistic system is atheistic."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and that is also the description given in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Lord Buddha appeared at a time when people were atheistic and accustomed to killing many animals in sacrificial offerings. Lord Buddha was very much aggrieved to see poor animals being killed unnecessarily; therefore he preached a religion of nonviolence. Because the people were atheists, Lord Buddha, in order to bring them under his control, agreed with them and said, "Yes, there is no God, but listen to me." This is a kind of transcendental cheating. In the beginning he said there is no God, but he is God Himself. In this way, people accepted his words and instructions. Animal killers cannot understand God and religion, although they may have some vague idea. Lord Buddha wanted to stop their sinful activities and reestablish a system of religion dedicated to nonviolence. Therefore he rejected the Vedas, which allow restricted animal sacrifice.

Hayagréva däsa: For James, religion means surrender and total involvement. He writes: "In the religious life....surrender and sacrifice are positively espoused: even unnecessary givings-up are added in order that the happiness may increase. Religion thus makes easy and felicitous what in any case is necessary....It becomes an essential organ of our life, performing a function which no other portion of our life can so successfully fulfill."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, society without religion is animalistic. We have already defined religion as understanding, loving, and obeying God. These principles are personally taught by God Himself in Bhagavad-gétä:

manmanä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi satyaà te
pratijäne priyo 'si me

"Always think of Me and become My devotee. Worship Me and offer your homage unto Me. Thus you will come to Me without fail. I promise you this because you are My very dear friend." (Bg. 18.65) We may think of God either as a personal God or a localized or all-pervading God, but in any case, God has form. It is easier to think of the form of the Lord. Attempting to meditate on the impersonal aspect is very troublesome (Bg. 12.5). Although Kåñëa has different incarnations and forms, He is the Supreme; therefore we meditate upon Him. In our Kåñëa consciousness movement, we can think of Kåñëa easily because His form, the Deity, is in the temple. We also have the perfect instructions of Bhagavad-gétä. God gives perfect instructions in everything: religion, politics, sociology, philosophy, science, physics, and history. Those who are fortunate will see the actual form of God according to His instructions, and perfect their lives. This is what is wanted.

Hayagréva däsa: James sees happiness as an integral part of religion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you know and follow God, you become happy.

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments nor desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state he attains pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54) As soon as we are God realized, we transcend duality and all distress, and become immediately happy. There is no longer hankering and lamentation. We no longer distinguish between men and nations. We see everyone within the material world—whether man, animal, or a tree—as a living entity, a part and parcel of God. In this way, we have a clear understanding and a perfect life.

Hayagréva däsa: In The Varieties of Religious Experience, James further writes: "If a creed makes a man feel happy, he almost inevitably adopts it. Such a belief ought to be true; therefore it is true—such rightly or wrongly, is one of the immediate inferences of the religious logic used by ordinary men."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, if you have a clear conception of God, and have decided to obey Him and love Him, you will be happy. This is the process utilized by this Kåñëa consciousness movement. We have no other business than obeying the orders of God. God has told us to preach this confidential philosophy of Bhagavad-gétä everywhere. Since we are trying to love God and obey His orders, we are eager to spread this Kåñëa consciousness movement. Otherwise, it is Kåñëa's business. Why should we bother about Him? We are attempting to spread this movement because we love Kåñëa, and He is happy that His message is being spread throughout the world. That is our happiness also. Since we are serving God without a doubt, we also feel happiness. This is reciprocation with God. This is religion. Religion is not sentiment, but actual realization of God, the actual carrying out of His orders. Our progressive life is secure if we are happy when God is happy.

Hayagréva däsa: James sees the lover of God as being a morally free person. He writes: "St. Augustine's maxim, 'If you but love God, you may do as you incline—' is morally one of the profoundest of observations, yet it is pregnant, for such persons, with passports beyond the bounds of conventional morality."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is very nicely put. If God is satisfied with our action, our action is moral. Conventional morality, which says, "This is good, and this is bad," is a mental concoction. Morality refers to the activities which satisfy God. If our action dissatisfies God, it is immoral. We therefore sing every day, yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädo (Çré Gurv-añöaka 8). The orders of God are carried out by the representative of God, the spiritual master. When we have no direct connection with God, the spiritual master serves as a transparent intermediary between God and ourselves. In the perfectional stage, of course, we can talk with God directly, but in the beginning, the neophyte must receive instructions from the spiritual master who is directly connected with God. If we satisfy the spiritual master, we have satisfied God, and this is our happiness.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning evil, James writes: "Evil is a disease; and worry over disease is itself an additional form of disease, which only adds to the original complaint....The best repentence is to up and act for righteousness, and forget that you ever had relations with sin."

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you are in a diseased condition, your suffering increases. When no one attempts to extinguish a fire, it increases. Debts unpaid will compound interests. Therefore diseases, fire, and debts should not be left unattended. They should be completely extinguished. We must know that our suffering is due to our disobedience to the orders of God, to our being irreligious. We have a relationship with God, but because we are now covered by material contamination, we are ignorant of it. We are thinking of ourselves as independent, and that is our foolishness. The demoniac and atheistic incorrectly think themselves independent of the orders of God; therefore they are forced to accept what they do not want: the punishments of birth, old age, disease, and death. Despite this punishment, the atheists still deny God's existence. God is there, and His orders are there. We should accept the instructions of a bona fide spiritual master, the representative of God, and execute them. Then we become happy and overcome the results of evil.

Çyämasundara däsa: Like Mill and others, James felt that due to the existence of evil in the universe, God is not unlimited.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He did not know that evil does not exist independent of God. According to the çästras, evil is the back side of God. Back side or front side, God is God. God is absolute. It is not that I can neglect or deny my back. I cannot say, "Beat me on my back side." The back is as important as the front. Those who are sinful cannot stand the front of God. Therefore Kåñëa says:

yeñäà tv anta-gataà päpaà
janänäà puëya-karmaëäm
te dvandva-moha-nirmuktä
bhajante mäà dåòha-vratäù

"Persons who have acted piously in previous lives and in this life, whose sinful actions are completely eradicated, and who are freed from the duality of delusion, engage themselves in My service with determination." (Bg. 7.28) Unless we are completely uncontaminated, we cannot come to Kåñëa consciousness. Once we surrender unto Kåñëa and accept His orders, Kåñëa immediately relieves us from all sinful reactions.

Çyämasundara däsa: James defines the world as the "stuff of pure experience," and says that experience is sometimes manifest as mind, and sometimes as matter.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is made up of experience, but whose experience? It is not due to your experience that these flowers are here. You have not created these flowers. He speaks of pure experience, but he does not know that it is Kåñëa's experience.

na tasya käryaà karaëaà ca vidyate
na tat-samaç cäbhyadhikaç ca dåçyate
paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate
sväbhäviké jïäna-bala-kriyä ca

"He does not possess bodily form like that of an ordinary living entity. There is no difference between His body and His soul. He is absolute. All His senses are transcendental. Any one of His senses can perform the action of any other sense. Therefore, no one is greater than Him or equal to Him. His potencies are multifarious, and thus His deeds are automatically performed as a natural sequence." (Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 6.7-8) According to the Vedas, the Supreme is equipped with different kinds of energies, and those energies can be experienced. This universe and everything within the cosmic manifestation is designed by the Supreme. Everything is a result of His multi-energies. In order for a man to create a flower on canvas, he must be thoroughly experienced in his art, but we can see that the multi-energies of Kåñëa are working so nicely that flowers appear automatically.

Hayagréva däsa: James divides religion into two basic types. One he calls the "sky-blue optimistic gospel," and the other "pessimistic" in its recognition of the futility and miseries of materialistic life. He felt that the completest religions take a pessimistic view of material existence, and offer liberation from it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, only an animal is not pessimistic about life in this material world. A man is capable of knowing the threefold sufferings of material life. There are sufferings of the mind and body, sufferings offered by other living entities, and sufferings forced upon us by natural catastrophes and the laws of nature. The world is full of suffering, but under the spell of mäyä, illusion, we think we are progressing. Ultimately, whatever we do, death is there to annihilate the results. Under these circumstances, there is no happiness within this material world. We may make all arrangements for happiness, but at any moment, death may capture us. So what happiness can we have here? Therefore an intelligent man is always pessimistic about material life. He knows that he will not be allowed to be happy here. As we further advance, we understand the orders of Kåñëa: sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekam çaraëaà vraja. "Abandon all religions and just surrender unto Me." (Bg. 18.66) We must surrender to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and after surrendering and understanding Him fully, we can go to the world that is full of bliss, knowledge, and eternal life. Unless we take a pessimistic view of this material world, we will remain attached to it, and the repetition of birth and death will ensue. In this world, everyone is attempting to live permanently, but nature does not allow this. People work very hard, and sometimes get good results, bad results, or frustration. So where is happiness? Happiness is understanding God, acting according to His advice, and returning home, back to Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: James believes that there is a certain composite picture of universal saintliness, which is the same in all religions, and of which the features can be easily traced. He has noted that holymen possess: "One, a feeling of being in a wider life than that of this world's selfish little interest; and a conviction...of the existence of an Ideal Power."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that feeling is there because the greatness of God is experienced. God is great in six opulences: wealth, strength, fame, knowledge, beauty, and renunciation.

Hayagréva däsa: Secondly, holymen possess "a sense of the friendly continuity of the Ideal Power with our own life, in a willing self-surrender to its control."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, there is a friendly continuity. There are five basic relationships. In the first, the relationship is between master and servant, then friend to friend, son to father, father to son, and beloved to beloved. All of these are friendly relationships, and every living entity has a natural instinct to accept any one of them. Thus our friendly relationships with God can be chosen. Someone may like to relate to Him as a servant, a friend, a father, a son, or a conjugal lover. When we are free from material contamination, our particular relationship is revived, and we understand ourselves as eternal parts and parcels of God.

Hayagréva däsa: Thirdly, the holyman experiences "an immense elation and freedom, as the outlines of the confining selfhood melt down."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, material selfishness is mäyä. Those who are enchanted by the spell of mäyä do not know that their real self-interest is in knowing their relationship with God. Our first duty is to have a complete idea of God and our relationship with Him. According to the Vedic process, whether we take up the haöha-yoga, jïäna-yoga, or bhakti-yoga system, the purpose is realization of God. A perfect human being knows that God is supplying his necessities and that he need not try to improve his economic condition. A sädhu, or holyman, is not interested in improving his material condition, but his spiritual condition.

Hayagréva däsa: Lastly, James speaks of the holyman experiencing "a shifting of the emotional center toward loving and harmonious affections, toward 'yes' and away from 'no' where the claims of the non-ego are concerned."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, God is always asking us to obey His orders, and as soon as we do so, as soon as we agree with Him, we become liberated. Çrémad-Bhägavatam describes liberation as giving up everything except devotional life.

näräyaëa-paräù sarve
na kutaçcana bibhyati
svargäpavarga-narakeñv
api tulyärtha-darçinaù

"Devotees solely engaged in the devotional service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, never fear any condition of life. For them, the heavenly planets, liberation, and the hellish planets are all the same, because such devotees are interested only in the service of the Lord." (Bhäg. 6.17.28) Life is meant for rendering devotional service to the Lord, and as soon as we understand this and commit ourselves to the rendering of such service, we are liberated. That is called mukti.

Hayagréva däsa: James believes that the existence of many religions in the world is not regrettable because different types of men necessitate different types of religion. "Some may really be the better for a religion of consolation and reassurance," he writes, "whilst others are better for one of terror and reproof...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: I have said that religion means accepting God as the Supreme Father, material nature as the mother, and all living entities as sons of God. The father is the maintainer, and all his sons have the right to live at his expense. Every living being should be satisfied with his condition, which is given by God. No one should encroach upon the rights of others, including the rights of animals to live peacefully. According to Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura, a happy life means living in the family of Kåñëa without violating the rules and regulations. In a family, the sons can live very happily by obeying their father. So there may be many types of religion, but awareness of this basic relationship with God and His creation should be there.

Hayagréva däsa: Since James was acquainted only with the impersonalist Vedänta school of Hinduism, he wrote of samädhi instead of devotional service. "When a man comes out of samädhi" he writes, "...he remains 'enlightened, a sage, a prophet, a saint, his whole character changed, his life changed, illumined."'

Çréla Prabhupäda: Samädhi means ecstasy, and if we are in God consciousness, we are in samädhi. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa speaks of the yogé in samädhi:

yoginäm api sarveñäà
mad-gatenäntarätmanä
çraddhävän bhajate yo mäà
sa me yuktatamo mataù

"And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all." (Bg. 6.47) In samädhi, the mind is always absorbed in God. If we continue in Kåñëa consciousness, we are in samädhi.

Hayagréva däsa: James describes samädhi to be a union in which the individual has lost contact with the external world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes.

Hayagréva däsa: And he therefore concludes that "Mystical states cannot be sustained for long. Except in rare instances, half an hour, or at most an hour or two, seems to be the limit beyond which they fade into the light of common day. Often, when faded, their quality can but imperfectly be reproduced in memory; but when they recur, it is recognized; and from one recurrence to another it is susceptible of continuous development in what is felt as inner richness and importance."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that richness is perfected when we think of Kåñëa constantly. That is recommended in the Sixth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, which I quoted previously. Consequently, in our Kåñëa consciousness movement, we are devoted to thinking of Kåñëa twenty-four hours daily. When we do not fall down from the yoga principle, we experience samädhi.

Hayagréva däsa: James himself claims to have experienced such a state momentarily, under the influence of ether. And today, people claim to induce mystical states through psychedelic drugs.

Çréla Prabhupäda: These are artificial means, and they cannot be sustained. It is better to engage in the bona fide devotional process—çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoùsmaraëaà päda-sevanam (Bhäg. 7.5.23)—always hearing about Kåñëa, talking about Him, remembering Him, serving Him in the temple, distributing His literatures, and so on. There are many services we can render in order to be fully absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness.

Hayagréva däsa: After analyzing many different religious experiences, James arrives at five basic conclusions. One: "That the visible world is part of a more spiritual universe from which it draws its chief significance."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the material universe is existing on the spiritual effulgence of the Lord, just as all the planets are resting upon the sunshine. Everything rests on the spiritual effulgence of the Lord, but when we forget the Lord, we call this the material world. Actually, the material world is in the spiritual world, but forgetfulness of God is material. When we revive our dormant God consciousness, the material world no longer exists. For a person truly advanced in God consciousness, there is nothing material. Everything is spiritual.

Hayagréva däsa: You are anticipating James's second conclusion, which is: "Union or harmonious relation with that higher universe is our true end."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is so. When we no longer forget our eternal relationship with God, nothing is material.

Hayagréva däsa: Third, prayer, or communion with God, "is a process wherein work is really done, and spiritual energy flows in and produces effects, psychological or material, within the phenomenal world." And, fourth, religion produces "a new zest which adds itself like a gift to life."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, realizing God's creation with awe, veneration, and appreciation constitutes one type of relationship called çänta-rasa. From there, we can progress to the point of däsya-rasa, which involves serving God, and finally to the mädhurya-rasa, which includes accepting God as our most beloved object. The devotee may choose whichever relationship he likes; the result is the same. However, by comparative study, the sädhus have decided that the mädhurya-rasa, our relationship with God as lover and beloved, is the highest relationship.

Hayagréva däsa: Finally, religion produces "an assurance of safety and a temper of peace, and, in relation to others, a preponderance of loving affections."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is very nice. A devotee is always at peace because he is always confident that since he is sincerely serving Kåñëa, Kåñëa will save him from all danger. Prahläda Mahäräja was always peaceful, although his demoniac father, Hiraëyakaçipu, attempted to kill him in so many ways. God always protects His devotee, and therefore the pure devotee is not disturbed by any material condition. He has firm faith in God, and this is called surrender. Full surrender means accepting everything favorable to God consciousness and rejecting everything unfavorable. When we enter the family of God, we have firm faith and security under the protection of God.

Hayagréva däsa: James then concludes that "in opening ourselves to God's influence, our deepest destiny is fulfilled."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that fulfillment is what is wanted. God demands that we fully surrender unto Him, and when we do so, our lives are perfected.

DS:John Dewey (1859-1952)

John Dewey (1859-1952)

Hayagréva däsa: Dewey believed that religions are basically myths and that experience is of the utmost necessity. He considered philosophy superior to religion. "The form [in philosophy] ceases to be that of the story told in imaginative and emotional style," he writes, "and becomes that of rational discourse observing the canons of logic." For him, the Vedic accounts of Kåñëa's pastimes would be purely mythical.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa is a historical fact; He is not imaginary. The Mahäbhärata is accepted by all Indian authorities, especially by the äcäryas who control the spiritual life of India. They do not, however, accept Mr. Dewey's imaginative thinking.

Hayagréva däsa: When science began to investigate the phenomenal universe without admitting the proprietorship of God, a breakdown in morality and value ensued. Dewey tried to reassemble these shattered values in a philosophical way, but he, like science, attempted to do so without acknowledging the proprietorship of a Supreme Being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is simply a form of lunacy because everything has a proprietor. Why should this great cosmic manifestation not have a proprietor? It is natural and logical to accept a proprietor. Who would think that an organized nation has no government? How can a logical man come to such conclusions?

Hayagréva däsa: He felt that science dealt a death blow to the orthodox, historical religions as we know them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As I have repeatedly explained, religion means accepting the laws of God. The whole cosmic manifestation has a date of creation and is therefore historical. Anything material that has a beginning has a history, but long before this cosmic manifestation was created, religion existed. We are tiny people and know the small history of this world, which extends for some thousands of years, but the history of Brahmä is far different. That history covers billions and billions of earth years. At the same time, our history is different from an ant's history. So, historically speaking, everything is relative according to the living entity computing or experiencing the history. Most people have no information of greater personalities, which we call the demigods, but Vedic literatures inform us that in the higher planetary systems, the standard of life is different and the duration longer. Unless one has thorough knowledge of the entire universe, religions may seem imaginary, but what is imaginary to one may be factual to another. For an ant, the history of man is imaginary. Unfortunately, scientists and philosophers on this planet are thinking in their own terms and taking everything they think to be factual. On the other hand, whatever they cannot conceive, they consider mythological.

Hayagréva däsa: Writing in the early part of this century, Dewey felt that it was high time to set aside all superstitious religions. According to him, logic "demands that in imagination we wipe the slate clean and start afresh by asking what would be the idea of the unseen...." In other words, we must define God and religion anew.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is required. Çrémad-Bhägavatam rejects all religions considered to be "cheating religions," because they do not contain perfect knowledge.

dharmaù projjhita-kaitavo 'tra paramo nirmatsaräëäà satäà
vedyaà västavam atra vastu çivadaà täpa-trayonmülanam
çrémad-bhägavate mahä-muni-kåte kià vä parair éçvaraù
sadyo hådy avarudhyate 'tra kåtibhiù çuçrüñubhis tat-kñaëät

"Completely rejecting all religious activities which are materially motivated, this Bhägavata Puräëa propounds the highest truth, which is understandable by those devotees who are pure in heart. The highest truth is reality distinguished from illusion for the welfare of all. Such truth uproots the threefold miseries. This beautiful Bhägavatam, compiled by the great sage Çré Vyäsadeva, is sufficient in itself for God realization. As soon as one attentively and submissively hears the message of Bhägavatam, he becomes attached to the Supreme Lord." (Bhäg. 1.1.2)

The sum and substance of the Bhägavata religion is the acceptance of God as supreme controller. Janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç cärtheñv abhijïaù svaräö (Bhäg. 1.1.1). That is the principle: Brahman is He from whom everything emanates. Unless we know the ultimate source of emanation, our knowledge is imperfect. Our experience tells us that everything has a source of emanation. Similarly, this entire creation has a history and a source from which it has emanated. Just because we are unable to reach that source, we should not think that it is imaginary. There is no question of starting a new religion because religion is always there. Someone must be the supreme controller, and that someone is called God. Dewey may ask, "Well, what is your experience?" We experience inert matter without consciousness, and we experience consciousness. We cannot go beyond this. Above these, there is one controller, a third element, which is the Absolute Truth, the controller of all visible animate and inanimate objects. Why is it difficult to understand this?

Hayagréva däsa: In A Common Faith, Dewey writes: "What I have been criticizing is the identification of the ideal with a particular Being, especially when that identification makes necessary the conclusion that this Being is outside of nature, and what I have tried to show is that the ideal itself has its roots in natural conditions "

Çréla Prabhupäda: God does not arise out of nature. God is the supreme controller in charge of nature. How can anyone think that this great phenomenon which we call nature has no controller? How can anyone think that everything is happening automatically?

Hayagréva däsa: Dewey sees God emerging out of man's striving for perfection.

Çréla Prabhupäda: God is already there, and man's perfection depends on his ability to understand God. It is not that a perfect man can create God through his imagination. Anything created by man is controlled, but God is the supreme controller. If man dies under the control of the Supreme, how can he be said to create or control the Supreme? If he cannot control what is already imposed by God—birth, old age, disease, and death—how can he imagine or create God? First, one should become independent of the laws of God before thinking of creating God.

Hayagréva däsa: It appears that Dewey wants to use the word "God" to serve his own ends: promoting his philosophic conception of "the working union of the ideal and actual." He writes: "Use of the words God or divine to convey the union of actual with ideal may protect man from a sense of isolation and from consequent despair or defiance."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Of course, one may define God, but one must be a muni, a very learned man, to define Him properly. For instance, one may say, "God is there," or, "God is great." We can go on from there to define His greatness. This greatness includes ultimate greatness in six opulences: power, wealth, knowledge, fame, beauty, and renunciation. Only God possesses these opulences in complete fullness. When Kåñëa was present on this planet, He proved that He was the strongest, the most influential, the most beautiful and pure, and the most supremely wise. Kåñëa's teachings, Bhagavad-gétä, are still being studied all over the world. Great äcäryas like Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Nimbarka, Çaìkaräcärya, and Caitanya Mahäprabhu have all accepted Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord. There is complete agreement among the authorities that Kåñëa is God. There is no question of mythology. Kåñëa's lifting of Govardhana Hill is described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and when speculators read it, they consider it to be mythological. But, really, is it difficult for God to lift a hill? If He is all powerful, what is the difficulty? When God comes and shows His godly powers, we should not consider it mythical.

Hayagréva däsa: Unlike Marx and Comte, Dewey rejects humanity as an object of worship. He writes: "Nature produces whatever gives reinforcement and direction but also what occasions discord and confusion. The divine is thus a term of human choice and aspiration."

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no question of human choice. Can you say that death is your choice? Obviously there is force, and where is that force coming from? No one wants to die, but everyone dies. No one wants to grow old, but everyone grows old. We must understand the origin of this enforcement. The supreme authority, the supreme force, is God. You may call this God "nature," or whatever, but you must admit that there is something supreme controlling you. How can we philosophize and imagine that man can become God?

Hayagréva däsa: Dewey writes that "a humanistic religion, if it excludes our relationship to nature, is pale and thin, as it is presumptuous, when it takes humanity as an object of worship."

Çréla Prabhupäda: For a God conscious person, everything is worshipable, even an ant. But the supremely worshipable is God: éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù. Some people think that nature is the supreme, but those who are aware of God know that God is the controller of nature also. Mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram, "This material nature is working under My direction, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings." (Bg. 9.10) Nature is only matter, and matter cannot act independently. Matter is being handled and controlled by a living being, who is the superior nature. Bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù khaà mano buddhir eva ca (Bg. 7.4). Earth, water, air, fire, and so forth constitute inferior nature. Above and beyond this is the superior nature. The living entities are finite controllers, but above them is another controller, the supreme controller who is God. It is very easy to understand. There are two natures: an active and an inactive nature. Above both of these natures is an active personality who is controlling both.

Çyämasundara däsa: As far as his methodology is concerned, Dewey believed that practical consequences are the only valid test of truth. He claimed that the proof of an idea consists in its being subject to predictable results.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If an idea is concocted, its results cannot be ascertained. If it is factual, the results can be predicted.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Dewey, the object of inquiry is belief itself. Because we want something to believe in, we ask questions. This is the nature of inquiry.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Vedänta-sütra advises us to find out the ultimate cause of everything, to inquire into the Absolute Truth. But inquiries should be directed to a person who knows. Otherwise, what is the use in inquiring? The Vedas advise us to approach a bona fide spiritual master, a guru, if we want to find the truth. Unfortunately, at the present moment, there are many pseudo gurus; therefore we have to add this word "bona fide." Otherwise, the word guru means bona fide, because one who is not bona fide cannot be a guru. Now, when we speak of inquiry, we mean learning the truth. Therefore we should inquire from one who knows the truth, otherwise our inquiry has no validity. Tad viddhi praëipätena paripraçnena sevayä. "Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him." (Bg. 4.34) This is the Vedic injunction. The inquiry should be genuine, and the answer should come from a genuine person.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey believes that the final outcome of inquiry is the fulfillment of human needs. By practical action, we can change the external environment.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Unless a human being inquires about the Absolute Truth, he is not considered sufficiently developed in his human form. For the consciousness to be developed, one must inquire about the self, asking, "What am I?" If this question is not asked, he is still in ignorance.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey felt that by inquiry, we can determine what is wrong with our environment, act to change it, and fulfill human needs.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If a person is serious, inquiry will clear up everything. If he inquires about the aim of human life, he is intelligent. It is not possible for animals to ask these questions. Animals are only eating, sleeping, defending, and mating.

Çyämasundara däsa: But should the aim of our inquiry be to change our external environment?

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you are seriously inquiring, and if you know things as they are, you will change your activities. We are preaching that it is our business to know Kåñëa. If people take this movement seriously, their entire mode of living will be changed. This is happening now. Previously, our students were leading a certain undesirable type of life, and since they have come to Kåñëa consciousness, their entire lives have been changed.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then, setting aside trying to improve the environment, we should first try to change our consciousness?

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is the consciousness that needs to be changed, either by hearing from authority, or by circumstances. There are two processes by which knowledge can be attained—by hearing, and by direct experience. An intelligent person can understand by hearing. He knows that if he acts in a such a way, he will fall into danger. So he learns by listening to authorities. A less intelligent man has to experience an awkward or dangerous position in order to change his consciousness. For him, hearing is not sufficient. Of the two processes, learning by hearing is better. It is therefore our process to approach the bona fide teacher and learn from him. That is the process of brahmacarya. It is not that we have to learn by practical experience. The experience is already there. We only have to hear of it and accept it; then it becomes easier. We should not say, "Let me fall into the ditch, then I shall cry." Better we take good advice and avoid the ditch altogether.

Hayagréva däsa: In the realm of philosophy and religion, Dewey believes that certainty is impossible. He writes: "Any philosophy that in its quest for certainty ignores the reality of the uncertain in the ongoing processes of nature, denies the conditions out of which it arises."

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is uncertainty when you do not accept the reality. The reality is God, and God explains how nature is working. If we do not accept His explanation, our position is very precarious, very uncertain. But if God comes and reveals Himself and His activities, and we consider them mythological, how can we be convinced? How can we ever be certain?

Hayagréva däsa: For Dewey, there is but one sure road of access to truth: what he calls "the road of patient, cooperative inquiry operating by means of observation, experiment, record, and controlled reflection."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The record is there in the Mahäbhärata, and those who have seen have confirmed it. Vyäsadeva, Närada, and Arjuna all confirm that everything is there in the record, but if people do not believe, how can they be convinced? Conditioned living entities do not have the perfect senses to see, and if they remain unconvinced, they will always live in darkness. They may go on imagining in the dark, but they will never attain perfect knowledge in this way.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey set down five steps for solving problems and attaining truths: we observe a problem and consider its nature; we intellectualize and analyze it; we hypothesize and consider solutions; we analyze our hypothesis according to past experience, and choose possible solutions; and we put the solutions into practice.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our process for solving problems is Kåñëa. Kåñëa says, kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati. "O son of Kunté, declare it boldly that My devotee never perishes." (Bg. 9.31) When we take shelter of Kåñëa, our problems are solved. Yatra yogeçvaraù kåñëaù (Bg. 18.78). Kåñëa is the reservoir of all mystic power. He is yogeçvaraù. It is not the bhakta's business to strive to become a yogé; rather, he takes shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is yogeçvaraù, the master of all mystic power. We consider this to be the solution to all our problems.

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14) There are various methods for solving problems, but the best method is to surrender unto Kåñëa. Then all problems are solved.

Çyämasundara däsa: On the social platform as well?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. Everything is solved. For instance, the Päëòavas had a political problem, and when they took shelter of Kåñëa, their political and social problems were solved.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Dewey, truth must satisfy human needs and improve social conditions. He sees truth as a practical tool.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We are the ones who have created social problems. Kåñëa is perfect, andwhatever Kåñëa has created is perfect. Oà pürëam adaù pürëam idaà (Éçopaniñad, Invocation). Things appear to be imperfect because we disobey Kåñëa's orders. If we remain faithful to Kåñëa, there are no problems. People speak of truth, but unfortunately, they do not know the truth.

na te viduù svärtha-gatià hi viñëuà
duräçayä ye bahir-artha-mäninaù
andhä yathändhair upanéyamänäs
te 'péça-tantryäm uru-dämni baddhäù

"Persons who are strongly entrapped by the consciousness of enjoying material life, and who have therefore accepted as their leader or guru a similar blind man attached to external sense objects, cannot understand that the goal of life is to return home, back to Godhead, and engage in the service of Lord Viñëu. As blind men guided by another blind man miss the right path and fall into a ditch, materially attached men led by another materially attached man are bound by the ropes of fruitive labor, which are made of very strong cords, and they continue again and again in materialistic life, suffering the threefold miseries." (Bhäg. 7.5.31) The ultimate truth, the ultimate objective, is Viñëu. Unfortunately, people are trying to solve the problems of this world without referring to Viñëu. Of course, this is not possible.

Çyämasundara däsa: How does worship of Viñëu solve social problems?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Man who executes this varëäçrama-dharma satisfies Viñëu. The brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, and çüdras have various prescribed duties. If they follow them, all problems are solved. Unfortunately, in India this varëäçrama-dharma has been killed. Now everyone is a çüdrä. The word çüdra refers to an unintelligent person. Since everyone is unintelligent, how can they solve problems? What can they do? They are trying to run a democratic government according to the votes of çüdräs, but çüdräs cannot solve anything. Once, America belonged to the red Indians, but they did not develop it. Why couldn't they improve their condition? The land and everything else was there. But when the Europeans came, they developed the land. Çüdras cannot actualize anything. If we once again establish the varëäçrama-dharma, all problems will be solved. That was the plan of my Guru Mahäräja. Daiva-varëäçrama refers to that which is stated by Kåñëa. The varëas are not established by birth, but by qualification. By qualification, one is a brähmaëa or a çüdra. By following the course prescribed for our varëa, we can satisfy Lord Viñëu and in this way be happy.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey writes: "The good man is the man who no matter how morally worthy he has been, is moving to become better. Growth itself is the only moral end."

Çréla Prabhupäda: In the beginning, a devotee may still do something wrong, but because he has taken to Kåñëa consciousness, he is accepted as a sädhu.

api cet suduräcäro
bhajate mäm ananya-bhäk
sädhur eva sa mantavyaù
samyag vyavasito hi saù

"Even if one commits the most abominable actions, if he is engaged in devotional service, he is to be considered saintly because he is properly situated." (Bg. 9.30) There may be many discrepancies in one's life, but if one's heart is in the right place, if he is working for Kåñëa consciousness, he is considered a sädhu, even though he has not corrected his bad habits. Kñipraà bhavati dharmätmäçaçvac-chäntià nigacchati. "He quickly becomes righteous and attains lasting peace." (Bg. 9.31) Because he has taken to Kåñëa consciousness, all his bad habits will be rectified very soon.

Çyämasundara däsa: In other words, he is striving to improve his moral condition?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. If one takes to Kåñëa consciousness, his morality will gradually develop.

yasyästi bhaktir bhagavaty akiïcanä
sarvair guëais tatra samäsate suräù

"All the demigods and their exalted qualities, such as religion, knowledge, and renunciation, become manifest in the body of one who has developed unalloyed devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Väsudeva." (Bhäg. 5.18.12) All good qualities will automatically come. We should stick to the four regulative principles: avoiding illicit sex, intoxication, meat eating, and gambling. And we should chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. By abiding by the orders of the spiritual master, everything will automatically develop. All good moral qualities will follow. It is not that we have to develop these qualities separately or independently. All good qualities are already there in the spirit soul, but presently they are covered by material contamination. When we are purified by Kåñëa consciousness, all these original qualities emerge. Håñékeëa håñékeça-sevanaà bhaktir ucyate (Bhakti-rasämåta sindhu, 1.1.12). We should purify our senses by engaging them in the service of the master of the senses, Kåñëa. That is the process of bhakti.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey did not believe in absolute good or evil; each situation must be treated individually.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Whatever is done in Kåñëa consciousness is good, and whatever is done for something other than Kåñëa's satisfaction is useless, although it may be ethically correct.

Çyämasundara däsa: He felt that the greatest good is the elimination of the greatest evil. It is the fulfillment of man's greatest needs.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The highest objective is Kåñëa, Viñëu. By becoming a Vaiñëava, we attain the highest perfection of human life. The greatest need is Kåñëa consciousness, pure, supreme consciousness. Every living entity is Kåñëa's part and parcel. Mamaiväàço jéva-loke jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù. "The living entities in this conditioned world are my eternal fragmental parts." (Bg. 15.7) Therefore we must always remember that, being part and parcel of Kåñëa, it is our duty to serve Kåñëa. In perverted consciousness, we think, "I am Kåñëa. I am God." That is not Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey believed that we should not choose good or evil simply on the basis of some theory. We should choose in order to alleviate specific evils.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The viräö-rüpa, the universal form of the Lord, was manifest before Arjuna. Arjuna then saw that everything within the universe is part and parcel of that viräö-rüpa, within which everything has a function, a duty. When we work according to that function, problems are automatically solved.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Dewey, we can never attain absolute certainty or perfection. We can only attain higher levels of moral progress.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he has no knowledge of absolute perfection.

Çyämasundara däsa: The world can be made better by man's efforts, but perfection in the world is not possible.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a different thing. This world is so made that if you perfect it today, tomorrow it will deteriorate. Therefore in one sense you cannot make it perfect. But you can improve it.

pariträëäya sädhünäà
vinäçäya ca duñkåtäm
dharma-saàsthäpanärthäya
sambhavämi yuge yuge

"In order to deliver the pious and to annihilate the miscreants, as well as to reestablish the principles of religion, I advent Myself millennium after millennium." (Bg. 4.8) Any bad condition can be improved by Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa and Kåñëa consciousness are the same. If you are in Kåñëa consciousness, you are living with Kåñëa, and if you are living with Kåñëa, then what is your fear? On the battlefield of Kurukñetra, Arjuna was fearless because Kåñëa was beside him.

samäçritä ye padapallava-plavaà
mahat-padaà puëya-yaço muräreù
bhavämbudhir vatsa-padaà paraà adaà
padaà padaà yad vipadäà na teñäm

"For one who has accepted the boat of the lotus feet of the Lord, who is the shelter of the cosmic manifestation and is famous as Mukunda, the giver of liberation, the ocean of the material world is like the water contained in a calf’s hoofprint. Vaikuëöha is his goal, not the place where there is danger at every step." (Bhäg. 10.14.58) In this material world, there is danger at every step, but as soon as we understand Kåñëa, we become eligible to be transferred to the spiritual world.

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9)

Çyämasundara däsa: So people are removed from all danger, or evil, by becoming Kåñëa conscious?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly. Therefore this is the best welfare activity for the entire world. By other means, people may be able to give some temporary benefit or temporary relief, but the situation will again deteriorate. You may give charity to a needy man, and this charity will serve him for a temporary period, but if you give him Kåñëa premä he is immediately transferred to the spiritual world. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu is called the most munificent incarnation because He has delivered Kåñëa premä to the world. Namo mahä-vadänyäya kåñëa-prema-pradäya te kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-nämne gaura-tviñe namaù.

Çyämasundara däsa: But the goal of the utilitarians is to achieve what the people desire and require.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The people desire and require happiness, but they are searching for it in temporary things.

åñabha uväca
näyaà deho deha-bhäjäà nåloke
kañöän kämän arhate viò-bhujäà ye
tapo divyaà putrakä yena sattvaà
çuddhyed yasmäd brahma-saukhyaà tv anantam

"Lord Rsabhadeva told His sons: My dear boys, of all the living entities who have accepted material bodies in this world, one who has been awarded this human form should not work hard day and night simply for sense gratification, which is available even for dogs and hogs that eat stool. One should engage in penance and austerity to attain the divine position of devotional service. By such activity, one's heart is purified, and when one attains this position, he attains eternal, blissful life, which is transcendental to material happiness, and which continues forever." (Bhäg. 5.5.1) Purify your existence, and you will attain eternal happiness and bliss. Everyone is working hard for happiness, but how can happiness be attained in a diseased condition? First the disease must be cured because it is an impediment to happiness. The real disease is janma-måtyu-jarä-vyädhi (Bg. 13.9): birth, old age, disease, and death. Cure these, and you will attain real happiness. Whatever you may desire, the ultimate end is happiness. Unfortunately, a diseased person is thinking, "I am happy." This is false happiness. Although you are dying, you are thinking that you are happy. This is called a fool's paradise.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey felt that the desirable course of action should meet certain conditions subject to prediction, and should be based on judgments or appraisals that might serve as guidelines to future activity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is predictable: You say, "I don't want to die." I say, "Come to this position, and you will not die."

Çyämasundara däsa: Is there some experience that would show this to be a predictable result?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes. You might not have the experience, but your superiors do.

äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

"From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place. But one who attains to My abode, O son of Kunté, never takes birth again." (Bg. 8.16) If we go to Kåñëa, we will never come back to this material world again. Who can excel Kåñëa's experience? Since He knows past, present, and future, it is to our good to accept His instructions.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey would recommend basing our judgments on personal experience.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We may not have personal experience, but we can take the advice of a person who does. Such experience is as good as our own. You may not have gone to New York, but because others have purchased tickets there and gone and returned, you can take advantage of their experience and learn something about that place.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey claims that value exists only where there is satisfaction.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Unless you have faith in a person, how can you be satisfied? You should find a person in whom you can place your faith. Who can be a better person than Kåñëa?

Çyämasundara däsa: If certain conditions are met, satisfaction is transformed into value. If my hunger is satisfied by eating certain food, that food is given value.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is Kåñëa who gives that value. In the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna was refusing to fight, but because he valued Kåñëa and was satisfied by his faith in Kåñëa, he was victorious.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Dewey, moral laws may serve as guidelines for action. They are comparable to physical laws, in that if I act in a certain way, I can expect a certain result.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We prescribe:

ädau çraddhä tataù sädhu-saìgo 'tha bhajana-kriyä
tato 'nartha-nivåttiù syät tato niñöhä rucis tataù
athäsaktis tato bhävas tataù premäbhyudaïcati
sädhakänäm ayaà premëaù prädurbhäve bhavet kramaù

"In the beginning, the neophyte devotee must have a preliminary desire for self-realization. This will bring him to the stage of trying to associate with persons who are spiritually elevated. In the next stage, he becomes initiated by an elevated spiritual master, and, under his instruction, begins the process of devotional service. By execution of devotional service under the guidance of the spiritual master, he becomes free from all material attachment, attains steadiness in self-realization, and acquires a taste for hearing about the Absolute Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa. This taste leads him further forward to attachment for Kåñëa consciousness, which is matured in bhäva, or the preliminary stage of transcendental love of God. Real love for God is called premä, the highest perfectional stage of life." (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu [1.4.15-16]) If you follow one step after the other, you get the results. If you have faith, and associate with the devotees, you will be eager to execute devotional service. Then all misgivings are eradicated, and your faith becomes firm. Unless you experience the next result, how can you make progress? Moral guidelines are also given by Rüpa Gosvämé:

utsähän niçcayäd dhairyät
tat-tat-karma-pravartanät
saìga-tyägät sato våtteù
ñaòbhir bhaktiù prasidhyati

"There are six principles favorable to the execution of pure devotional service: being enthusiastic, endeavoring with confidence, being patient, acting according to regulative principles [such as çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù smaraëam—hearing, chanting, and remembering Kåñëa], abandoning the association of nondevotees, and following in the footsteps of the previous acäryäs. These six principles undoubtedly assure the complete success of pure devotional service." (Upadeçämåta, 3) We should be patient, enthusiastic, and firmly convinced. We should be fair in our dealings, and should associate with saintly persons. In this way, we can advance.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then the results follow these guidelines predictably and automatically?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, one after another. A teacher instructs his students, and when they realize one instruction, he gives another, then another. In this way, the students can make progress. Consider the guidelines. First of all, we must be enthusiastic. Unless we are enthusiastic, how can we enter into any activity? We should also be patient. We should not think, "Oh, I am working so hard, but am getting no results." The results will come in time. We should also have firm conviction that because we have taken the path of the mahäjanas, the path prescribed by Kåñëa, success is imminent. Although success may be delayed, it doesn't really matter. We must know that success will definitely come. We must also perform our prescribed duties fairly and in good faith. And we should also associate with saintly people. This will give us impetus. If we follow these guidelines, the result is certain and predictable.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey believes that moral laws are not inflexible absolute rules that never permit exceptions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The real moral law is the law of the Supreme. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa described many different types of yoga: dhyäna-yoga, jïäna-yoga, haöha-yoga, and so on. However, at the end, He said, sarva-dharmän parityajya. "Abandon all these dharmas and surrender unto Me." (Bg. 18.66) Kåñëa's word is the ultimate morality. Vaiñëavas do not consider this or that moral or immoral. Whatever Kåñëa or His representative orders is moral. That is our position.

Çyämasundara däsa: Dewey claims that we place value upon that which we must act on.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, there is certainly value in Kåñëa, and because Arjuna followed the decision of Kåñëa, he became victorious, enjoyed his kingdom, and became a famous devotee. These were practical results of his activities. Parékñit Mahäräja compared the battle of Kurukñetra to a great ocean in which Bhéñma, Droëa, Karëa, and others were like great sharks. It was important for his grandfather, Arjuna, to cross that ocean, which was dangerously infested with many ferocious fish. Although this was very difficult, by the grace of Kåñëa it was possible.

yatra yogeçvaraù kåñëo
yatra pärtho dhanur-dharaù
tatra çrér vijayo bhütir
dhruvä nétir matir mama

"Wherever there is Kåñëa, the master of all mystics, and wherever there is Arjuna, the supreme archer, there will also certainly be opulence, victory, extraordinary power, and morality. That is my opinion." (Bg. 18.78)

XIIEXISTENTIALISM

XIIEXISTENTIALISM

DS:Soren Aabye Kierkegaard (1813-1855)

Soren Aabye Kierkegaard (1813-1855)

Hayagréva däsa: Kierkegaard, a Danish philosopher, a Christian, is often called the father of existentialism. He believed that if the truths of religions are not innate within man, they must be transmitted by a teacher. Since man would be overawed by God, if God Himself came to teach as He is, God comes instead as a servant of God in human form, or, for a Christian, as Jesus Christ.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Generally, because men are on the animal platform, some system of education is required. When man's consciousness is advanced, he can be educated in the understanding of God through the teachings of the authorities. That is the Vedic system. In the human form, the living entity is sometimes very inquisitive, and wants to understand God. That is technically called brahma-jijïäsä: interest in the Absolute. That is possible only in the human form. If we are anxious to know about God, we have to approach a guru, otherwise we cannot understand the nature of God or of our relationship with Him. Accepting a guru is not a fashion but a necessity. A guru is one who is fully trained in the ocean of spiritual knowledge, or Vedic knowledge. Vedic words or sound vibrations are not ordinary, material vibrations. They are completely spiritual. The Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, for instance, is a purely spiritual sound. Once a person is fully trained in the ocean of spiritual sound, he is no longer interested in materialistic life. Nor does such a person manufacture gold, or juggle words to attract foolish people and make money. A guru by definition is one who is no longer interested in material things. He has taken shelter of the Supreme Lord, and his material desires have completely ceased. We should approach such a bona fide guru, surrender unto him, serve him, and then question him about God and our relationship with God.

Hayagréva däsa: Is Kierkegaard correct in maintaining that man would be overawed if God came to teach as He is? Didn't Kåñëa, as He is, come to teach Bhagavad-gétä?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Kåñëa came as He is, but people misunderstood Him because He appeared to them as an ordinary human being. Because they could not surrender unto Him, He came later as a devotee, Caitanya Mahäprabhu, to teach men how to approach God. That is the concept of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya understood His activities and wrote about a hundred verses in appreciation. Two of these verses read:

vairägya-vidyä-nija-bhakti-yoga-
çikñärtham ekaù puruñaù puräëaù
çré-kåñëa-caitanya-çaréra-dhäré
kåpämbudhir yas tam ahaà prapadye

kälän nañöaàbhakti-yogaà nijaà yaù
präduñkartuà kåñëa-caitanya-nämä
ävirbhütas tasya pädäravinde
gäòhaà gäòhaà léyatäà citta-bhåìgaù

"Let me take shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, who has descended in the form of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu to teach us real knowledge, His devotional service, and detachment from whatever does not foster Kåñëa consciousness. He has descended because He is an ocean of transcendental mercy. Let me surrender unto His lotus feet. Let my consciousness, which is like a honeybee, take shelter of the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who has just now appeared as Çré Kåñëa Caitanya Mahäprabhu to teach the ancient system of devotional service to Himself. This system had almost been lost due to the influence of time." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 6.254-255) Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya thus understood that Caitanya Mahäprabhu is the very same Kåñëa come to teach bhakti-yoga and the process of renunciation. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu taught the very same philosophy: Bhagavad-gétä. However, instead of coming as Kåñëa, He came as a devotee of Kåñëa. Rüpa Gosvämé also appreciated Caitanya Mahäprabhu as the most munificent incarnation because He not only gives Kåñëa, but pure love of Kåñëa. Namo mahä-vadänyäya kåñëa-prema-pradäya te. In order to give Himself to the devotee, Kåñëa demands full surrender, but Caitanya Mahäprabhu, without making any demands, gives pure love of Kåñëa. Because we are all His sons, Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, is affectionate towards us. Because we are rotting in this material world, Kåñëa comes Himself, or as a devotee, and leaves His instructions. He is always anxious to enlighten a human being and show him how to return home, back to Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning God's personality, Kierkegaard writes: "God is certainly personal, but whether He wishes to be so in relation to the individual depends upon whether it pleases God. It is the grace of God that He wishes to be personal in relation to you; if you throw away His grace, He punishes you by behaving objectively (impersonally) towards you."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a very good point. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

kleço 'dhikataras teñäm
avyaktäsakta-cetasäm
avyaktä hi gatir duùkhaà
dehavadbhir aväpyate

"For those whose minds are attached to the unmanifested, impersonal feature of the Supreme, advancement is very troublesome. To make progress in that discipline is always difficult for those who are embodied." (Bg. 12.5)

Hayagréva däsa: Because the ordinary man does not wish to have a personal relationship with God, "in that sense one may say that the world does not have a personal God, despite all the proofs....There are no longer the men living who could bear the pressure and weight of having a personal God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a personal God makes demands, just as Kåñëa demands in Bhagavad-gétä:

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi yuktvaivam
ätmänaà mat-paräyaëaù

"Engage your mind always in thinking of Me, offer obeisances and worship Me. Being completely absorbed in Me, surely you will come to Me." (Bg. 9.34) This is God's demand, and if we carry it out, we attain perfection. Tyaktvä dehaà punar janma naiti mäm eti (Bg. 4.9) It is clearly stated that when a devotee gives up his material body, he does not accept another, but returns back to Godhead in his original spiritual body.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard observed three basic stages in a typical life: the aesthetic, the ethical, and the religious. In the aesthetic stage, a person may be either a hedonist in search of pleasure or romantic love, or an intellectual interested in philosophical speculation. Kierkegaard says that both are uncommitted because they do not have specific goals.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can a philosopher have no ultimate goal?

Çyämasundara däsa: On this platform, they are only mental speculators. They become bored, and their lives become empty.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is the result of impersonalism and voidism. Impersonalists or voidists are not necessarily overcome by despair, but they are often disgusted with their present lives because they do not know the aim of life. When one has no goal, he becomes disappointed in life, and that is the cause of despair.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard sees men as indulging in sense gratification and mental speculation in order to cover up their basic despair.

Çréla Prabhupäda: In the material world, when a man's business fails, or when he experiences some great shock, he takes to intoxication in order to forget.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard suggests that this despair may serve as the first stepping stone toward self-realization. Understanding that the aesthetic life ends in despair, a person abandons it for the next stage.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We agree with this. According to the Vedänta-sütra, people begin to inquire about self-realization after they have worked very hard and still have not attained life's goal. At this point, people begin to think, "What is the purpose of life?" That is called brahma-jijïäsä, inquiry into the ultimate truth of life. Such an inquiry is natural, and necessary for further development.

Çyämasundara däsa: In order to attain self-realization, we must face certain choices. For Kierkegaard, life is an "either/or" decision. Realizing this, we advance to the ethical stage. The emphasis here is on action.

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, we must understand how action or activity comes about. What is the origin of action? Modern science is interested in describing or witnessing life's activities, and scientists claim that life develops automatically due to nature's interactions, but from Bhagavad-gétä we understand that behind all these material activities, there is God. Material nature is a machine working under God's directions. Vedänta-sütra explains that the Absolute Truth is that from which all things emanate, and Çrémad-Bhägavatam discusses the nature of that origin. First, we must understand that the origin is consciousness. Life does not arise from bones and stones. Once we understand that the creation does not take place automatically, we must admit that there is a creator.

Çyämasundara däsa: At the ethical stage, man may perform pious works or humanitarian deeds, and Kierkegaard sees this as a step in the right direction toward authentic selfhood. By making the proper ethical decisions, we can approach self-awareness and the religious stage.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what is the ultimate decision? Why do people become moral? Simply to feed the poor and become humanitarians?

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kierkegaard, it does not much matter what we choose, but the fact that we make the choice. Through choosing, we discover our own integrity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But it is not clear how a person makes the right decisions. One man may choose to slaughter, and another may choose to help others. A man may give charity to others, and at the same time encourage killing animals. What are the ethics involved? On the one hand, Vivekananda was advocating feeding the poor, but on the other hand he was suggesting feeding them with Mother Kälé's prasädam, with bulls. So what kind of ethics are these? What is the value of ethics if they are based on imperfect knowledge?

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard would say that by-turning inward, we would make the proper decision. This entails self-knowledge and self-commitment.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what is that inwardness? One may simply think, "I will protect my brother by killing another." What are the ethics involved? We must have some standard by which to make the right decision.

Çyämasundara däsa: His standard would be, "Choose thyself."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But without knowing yourself, how can you make a choice? And how can you know yourself unless you go to one who knows things as they are? Most people think that they are the body. What kind of self-knowledge is this? If one identifies with the body, he is no better than an ass. Then what is the value of his philosophy?

yasyätma-buddhiù kuëape tridhätuke
sva-dhéù kalaträdiñu bhauma ijya-dhéù
yat-tértha-buddhiù salile na karhicij
janeñv abhijïeñu sa eva go-kharaù

"A human being who identifies this body made of three elements with his self, who considers the by-products of the body to be his kinsmen, who considers the land of birth worshipable, and who goes to the places of pilgrimage simply to take a bath rather than meet men of transcendental knowledge there, is to be considered like an ass or cow." (Bhäg. 10.84.13)

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard emphasizes the very act of deciding, not the decision.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But unless we know the aim of life, how can we make the right decision? It is childish to say that we become enlightened by choosing either this or that. A child chooses to play sometimes with one toy and sometimes with another, but where is his enlightenment? Animals also make their decisions. The ass decides to eat a morsel of grass and work all day carrying loads. If the decision is not important, why not decide for unrestricted sense gratification?

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard would say that unrestricted sense gratification ultimately leads to boredom and despair.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if we think that it is the aim of life, it is not boring. If we choose according to our whims, we can make any decision. A man on the Bowery may decide to purchase a bottle of whiskey as soon as he gets some money.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard would say that there is no commitment to a higher ethic there. On the ethical level, we would have to take up a good cause and make decisions based on that.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But such good causes are relative. Who is to decide what's a good cause?

Çyämasundara däsa: If we begin to anticipate death, we will make the right decision, considering each act to be our last. In this way, the truth will emerge.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, a man should think, "I do not wish to die, but death is overcoming me. What is the cause of this? What should I do?" No one wants to die, but death overcomes everyone. No one wants to be diseased, but diseases are inevitable. These are real human problems that cannot be overcome simply by making some whimsical decisions. We should decide, "I do not wish to suffer, but suffering is coming upon me. Now, I must make a permanent solution to this problem." This is the real decision: putting a permanent end to suffering. We should understand that the body exists for a few years and then is doomed to perish, that the body is external, and that we should not make our decisions on the basis of the body, but the soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kierkegaard, a man whose consciousness is unhappy is alienated from both past and future. He wishes to forget the past, and the future holds no hope. In proper consciousness, when the personality is integrated, the past and future are unified, and we can make the proper decision.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Your decision should be based on the fact that you are part and parcel of Kåñëa. Kåñëa told Arjuna that in the past he was existing, and that he would continue to exist in the future. Our decision should be based on the platform of the soul.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard sees the self as unifying past and future and thus establishing its integrity as an integrated whole. Then the self is capable of making decisions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If he comes to the platform of the self, he must accept the fact that the self is eternal in order to integrate past, present, and future.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yes, this is the highest stage, the religious. On this platform, one commits himself to God and obeys God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That would be the stage of Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard believed that in the religious stage, there is intense suffering, comparable to the suffering of Job.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Why is this? If one is Kåñëa conscious, why should he suffer?

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, Kierkegaard was a Christian. Christ suffered for our sins, and the process of overcoming sin is a kind of suffering.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But that is a wrong theory. If Christ is God, or the son of God, why should he suffer? What kind of God is subjected to suffering? Why should either God or man suffer? The whole point is that if there is suffering, you must put an end to it. Many so-called Christians think that because they have some contract with Christ, because Christ suffered for their sins, they can go on sinning. Is this a very good philosophy?

Çyämasundara däsa: As an existentialist, Kierkegaard believed that existence is prior to essence, and that to attain self-realization, we must pass through these various stages.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is correct. We are transmigrating through different species and eventually arriving at the human form wherein we can understand the purpose of life. At the perfectional stage, we become Kåñëa conscious; therefore existence precedes essence.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kierkegaard, the culmination of commitment is religious life, which is epitomized in the inwardness of suffering.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Suffering arises because we identify with the body. When a person has an automobile accident, he may not actually suffer, but because he identifies himself with matter, with the body, he suffers. Because God is always in full knowledge and is always transcendental to the material world, God never suffers. It is a question of knowledge whether there is suffering or not.

Çyämasundara däsa: But don't penance and austerity involve suffering?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. For those who are advanced in knowledge, there is no suffering. Of course, there may be some bodily pain, but a person in knowledge understands that he is not the body; therefore, why should he suffer? He thinks, "Let me do my duty. Hare Kåñëa." That is the advanced stage. Suffering is due to ignorance.

Çyämasundara däsa: But doesn't one forsake bodily comforts by serving God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Rüpa and Sanätana Gosvämé were high government ministers, but they abandoned their material opulence in order to bestow mercy upon the common people. Thus they accepted a mere loincloth and slept under a different tree every night. Of course, foolish people might say that they were suffering, but they were merged in the ocean of transcendental bliss writing about Kåñëa's pastimes with the gopés. They engaged their minds in thoughts of Kåñëa and the gopés, and they wrote books from day to day. There was no question of their suffering, although a fool may think, "Oh, these men were ministers, high government officials, and they were so comfortable with their families and homes. Now they have no home, and are going about in loincloths, and eating very little." A materialist would think that they were suffering, but they were not suffering. They were enjoying.

Çyämasundara däsa: Some Christians emphasize the value of suffering, thinking that to abandon worldly life is to abandon pleasure and to suffer.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is due to a poor fund of knowledge. They have developed this philosophy after the demise of Jesus Christ. It is more or less concocted.

Hayagréva däsa: Apart from suffering, Kierkegaard emphasized the importance of love in the religious life. In his book Works of Love, he considers God to be the hidden source of all love. "God you must love in unconditional obedience," he writes, "even if that which He demands of you may seem injurious to you For God's wisdom is incomparable with respect to your own "

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is also the instruction of Bhagavad-gétä. God demands that we give up all our plans as well as the plans of others, and accept His plan. Sarva-dharmän parityajya (Bg. 18.66). "Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me." If we fully depend on Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, He will guide us home.

Hayagréva däsa: In defining love, Kierkegaard points out that St. Paul considered love to be "the fulfillment of the law." "Love is a matter of conscience," Kierkegaard writes, "and hence it is not a matter of impulse and inclination; nor is it a matter of emotion, nor a matter for intellectual calculation Christianity really knows only one kind of love, spiritual love...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, love in the material world is impossible, because everyone is interested only in his own sense gratification. The love experienced between men and women is not actually love, but lust, because both parties are interested in their own sense gratification. Love means that one does not think of his own sense gratification, but of the sense gratification of his beloved. That is pure love, and that is not possible in the material world. We see examples of pure love, however, in the Vedic depictions of Våndävana, a village wherein men, animals, fruits, flowers, water, and everything else exist only for the sake of loving Kåñëa. They are not interested in any return from Kåñëa. Now, that is real love. Anyäbhiläñitäçünyaà. If one loves God with some motive, that is material love. Pure love is interested only in satisfying the desires of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. When we speak of love in the material world, we are misusing the word. Lusty desires take the place of real love. Real love applies only to God—individually, collectively, or any other way. Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is the supreme object of love, and this love can be expressed through adoration, service, or friendship. Or we can love Him as a child, or as a conjugal lover. There are five basic relationships expressing true love of Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: For Kierkegaard, love of God is the decisive factor, and from it stems love of neighbor. "If you love God above all else," he writes, "then you also love your neighbor, and in your neighbor, everyman....To help another man to love God is to love the other man; to be helped by another man to love God is to be loved."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is the basis of our Kåñëa consciousness movement. We're learning how to love God, and teaching the same principle to the whole world. We're teaching that God is one, and that no one is equal to Him, nor greater than Him. God is never dead. If love of God is taught by a religion, that religion should be considered first class, be it Christian, Hindu, Moslem, or whatever. The test of a religion is this: "Have the followers learned how to love God?" God is the center of love, and since everything is God's expansion, a lover of God is a lover of everyone. He does not discriminate by thinking that only man should be loved and given service. No. He is interested in all living entities, regardless of the forms in which they are existing. A lover of God loves everyone, and his love reaches everyone. When we water the root of a tree, we are nourishing all parts of the tree: the trunk, branches, twigs, and leaves. When we give the stomach food, we satisfy the entire body. God is everything. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä, mayä tatam idam sarvaà (Bg. 9.4). Nothing can exist without God because everything is His expansion. Viñëu Puräëa says that God is present everywhere, although situated in His own abode, just as the light and heat of the sun are present everywhere, although the sun is situated in one place. God is all pervading. Nothing can exist without Him. At the same time, this does not mean that everything is God. Rather, everything is resting on His energy. Despite His expansions, He maintains His personality.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard also considered faith to be an important part of religion. For him, the opposite of faith is sin, which is the same as despair.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you are in Kåñëa consciousness, there is no question of sin. It is not a question of faith, but of fact. At the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna did not want to fight, but he finally decided to abide by the order of Kåñëa. That is piety: satisfying the higher authority, God. In the material world, we imagine this or that to be sinful or pious, but these are mental concoctions. They have no value.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard would define piety as faith in the orders of God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That means he must receive God's orders. But if a person has no conception of God, if he conceives of God impersonally, there is no question of God's orders. If God is impersonal, He has no mouth with which to speak, no eyes with which to see. Therefore there is no question of His giving orders.

Hayagréva däsa: In his Journals, Kierkegaard writes: "There is a God; His will is made known to me in holy scripture and in my conscience. This God wishes to intervene in the world. But how is He to do so except with the help of man?"

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sädhu-çästra-guru. We can approach God by understanding a saintly person, studying the Vedic scriptures, and following the instructions of the bona fide spiritual master. Sädhu, çästra, and guru should corroborate. A sädhu is one who talks in terms of the scriptures, and the guru is one who teaches according to the scriptures. A guru cannot manufacture words that are not in the çästras. When we receive instructions from all three, we can progress perfectly in our understanding of the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: Kierkegaard writes: "The only adequate way to express a sense of God's majesty is to worship Him....It is so easy to see that one to whom everything is equally important and equally insignificant can only be interested in one thing: obedience."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and God demands that full obedience: sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja (Bg. 18.66). Our original obedience should be to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and we should obey the spiritual master because he is God's representative. If a person does not directly receive the orders of God, he cannot be a bona fide guru. A guru cannot manufacture anything; he simply presents what God speaks in the çästras. When God comes as an incarnation, He also gives references to the scriptures, just as Kåñëa referred to the Brahma-sütra in Bhagavad-gétä. Although Kåñëa is God, and His word is final, He still gives honor to the Brahma-sütra because in that work spiritual knowledge is set forth logically and philosophically. It is not that we accept just anyone's proclamations about God. Statements must be corroborated by the standard scriptures.

Hayagréva däsa: Kierkegaard says that we should "renounce everything as an act of worship offered to God, and not so because He needs to use us as an instrument; but to renounce everything as the most insignificant superfluity and article of luxury—that means to worship."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, worship begins with the renunciation of ulterior motives. Our only business is to love God, and a first-class religious system teaches its followers to love God without ulterior motive. Such worship cannot be checked by material considerations. We can love God in any condition, and God will help.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard lamented the disintegration of Christianity as an effective form of worship. He considered modern Christendom to be a kind of sickness, a corruption of Christ's original message.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Christianity is Christianity, and you cannot call it modern or ancient, nor can you say that God is modern or ancient. We say that either a person is a Christian or not. Either he follows the orders of Christ, or he doesn't. If you do not follow the tenets of your religion, how can you claim to belong to that religion? This applies to all religions. For instance, there are many so-called Hindus who do not believe in anything, yet they consider themselves Hindus and brähmaëas. This is insulting.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard saw Christian despair as a "sickness unto death." The wish to die is the result of despair.

Çréla Prabhupäda: People try to avoid the results of their sinful activities by killing themselves, but this is not possible. Suicide is just another sin. Therefore those who commit suicide become ghosts.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard believed that a man should live as if he were to die at any moment. He should act as if each act were to be his last.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This requires practice, and therefore we are recommending the chanting of Hare Kåñëa without cessation. Of course, death may come at any moment, and if we are chanting Hare Kåñëa, that death is a happy death.

Çyämasundara däsa: According to Catholicism, at the time of death, a priest can absolve you of your sins.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Provided you have the consciousness to understand the words of the priest.

Çyämasundara däsa: Even though one has committed many sins throughout his life, he can be absolved of his sins on his deathbed.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is quite possible because a priest can remind you of God at the time of death. Your thoughts at the time of death are very important. There are so many examples: Ajämila, and Bharata Mahäräja. Therefore King Kulaçekhara prays, "Let me die immediately while I am thinking of Kåñëa." Of course, unless we are practiced, it is not possible to think of Kåñëa at the time of death, because at that time there are many bodily disturbances. Therefore from the beginning, austerities are required.

Hayagréva däsa: Kierkegaard writes: "The true relation in prayer is not when God hears what is prayed for, but when the person praying continues to pray until he is the one who hears what God wills."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is very nice. Through prayer, one becomes qualified to understand God, talk with God, and receive His directions.

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." (Bg. 10.10) Our ultimate goal is to give up this material world and return to God. Prayer is just one form of service. There are nine basic processes we can follow in the rendering of devotional service:

çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù
smaraëaà päda-sevanam
arcanaà vandanaà däsyaà
sakhyam ätma-nivedanam

"Hearing and chanting about the holy name, form, qualities, paraphernalia, and pastimes of Lord Viñëu, remembering them, serving the lotus feet of the Lord, offering the Lord respectful worship with sixteen types of paraphernalia, offering prayers to the Lord, becoming His servant, considering the Lord one's best friend, and surrendering everything unto Him—these nine processes are accepted as pure devotional service." (Bhäg. 7.5.23) Prayer is vandanam. If we accept all nine processes, or just one of them, we can progress in spiritual life. Christians and Mohammedans offer prayers, and Hindus render service in the temple. The Deities are decorated, the temples are cleansed, and food is offered. This is called arcanam, and through this process we can engage in devotional service. God is within, and when He sees that we are sincere in His service, He takes charge and gives directions by which we can swiftly approach Him. God is complete in Himself; He is not hankering after our service, but if we offer Him service, we can become purified. When we are purified, we can talk with God and see Him. We can receive His instructions personally, just as Arjuna did.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kierkegaard, faith is revealed in the selfs relation to its own self, through its willingness to be its authentic self and to stand transparently before God in full integrity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: For the Mäyävädés, self-realization means becoming one with the Supreme Self, but such merging is not possible. Standing transparent before God means engaging in God's service. To engage in God's service, you must understand that you are part and parcel of the Supreme. A part of the body engages in the service of the entire body. As soon as you engage in God's service, you are self-realized. That is mukti, liberation. The karmés, jïänés, and yogés are trying to realize the self, but because they are not engaged in rendering service to the Supreme Self, they are not liberated. We are therefore pushing this Kåñëa consciousness for the ultimate self-realization of everyone.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard sees self-realization arising out of the expression of the will. The more self-realized a person is, the more will he has. When we are fully ourselves, we are fully willed, and able to make the proper decisions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if you are part and parcel of the whole, you have to take decisions from the whole. You cannot make the decisions. A finger does not make decisions for the entire body. The only decision you can make is the decision to serve Kåñëa. The orders come from the superior. Arjuna was ordered by Kåñëa to fight, and at the conclusion of Bhagavad-gétä, he decided to abide by Kåñëa's will. This is the only decision we can make: to abide by Kåñëa's will or not. Kåñëa or His representative makes all the other decisions.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then what is the meaning of full will?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Full will means to surrender fully, to follow absolutely the orders of the Supreme.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard saw that even despair can bear fruit in that it can lead us to desire a genuine life of self-realization. It can be a springboard for a higher consciousness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When one despairs, that is a great happiness. Then everything is finished. All responsibility is gone, and the person is relieved. Out of despair, Arjuna was thinking of becoming a mendicant. When we despair of all happiness in material life, we may then turn to spiritual life. Sometimes Kåñëa smashes all of our material resources so that out of despair we may fully engage in Kåñëa's service. Kåñëa sometimes wrecks a person materially when a person wants to become God conscious but at the same time wants material enjoyment due to strong attachment. Sometimes, when God smashes a person's material hopes, the person thinks that God is unkind to him, and the person despairs. He doesn't realize that this is God's mercy, that God is removing impediments so that the person can fully and absolutely surrender.

Once Indra, the king of heaven, was forced to be a hog, and he had to enter the material world as a lowly animal. As a hog, he had a hog-wife, hog-children, and so on. Finally, Lord Brahmä came down and told him, "My dear Indra, you have forgotten your position. You were once a heavenly king and possessed great opulence. Now that you are a hog, you have forgotten your previous exalted existence. Please leave this filthy life and come with me." Yet, despite all Brahmä's pleadings, Indra was not convinced. He said, "Why should I go with you? I am very happy. I have my wife, children, and home." Seeing that Indra had become very much attached to his hog-existence, Brahmä began to kill all his hog-children, and eventually his hog-wife. When Indra saw that his wife was killed, he despaired: "Oh! You have killed all my family!" It was only then that Indra agreed to go with Lord Brahmä. Similarly, Kåñëa sometimes creates a situation in which the living entity will despair, and, out of despair, turn to Kåñëa and fully surrender unto Him.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard was considering the despair of thinking, "Oh, I am a sinner," and believing that we will never be relieved of sin. He claims that this leads us even further into a sinful life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no question of despair because of sin. A person sins out of ignorance. If you ask a butcher, "Why are you committing sins?" he will say, "This is my business. What is sinful about it?" When Närada informed the hunter that killing animals was sinful, the hunter did not despair, but was elevated to Kåñëa consciousness by Närada's instructions.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard believes that faith conquers sin and despair.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Faith means faith in God. To strengthen our faith in God, we have to give up all hope of happiness in this material life. We have to despair of material happiness.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kierkegaard, existence is continuous and therefore forever incomplete.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The system is complete when we surrender unto Kåñëa. God has a complete system by which we can progress to God consciousness. When we become fully conscious, we have attained completion. As long as we have not reached that point, we are progressing.

Hayagréva däsa: "God is the wellspring of all individuality," Kierkegaard writes. "To have individuality is to believe in the individuality of everyone else; for the individuality is not mine; it is the gift of God through which He permits me to be, and through which He permits everyone to be."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This fact is also explained in Kaöha Upaniñad: nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm. God is a living being, and we are also living beings. Just as He is eternal, we are also eternal. Qualitatively, we are one; but quantitatively, we are different. God is maintaining everyone, and all the living entities are being maintained. We are all individual, eternal parts of God, and our natural position, being parts of Him, is to love Him.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard sees the individual in a continuous state of becoming.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Becoming what? What is the goal? The goal is Kåñëa consciousness. Therefore in Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says:

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conqueror of wealth, there is no truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me as pearls are strung on a thread." (Bg. 7.7) Kåñëa is the ultimate truth, the supreme goal, and completion means coming to Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: But isn't there still a process of becoming, even when we are fully Kåñëa conscious and in association with Kåñëa?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. The becoming process ends. There are, however, varieties, which are spiritual. Everything is complete, but varieties are enjoyed. Sometimes, Kåñëa is a cowherd boy, sometimes He is Yaçodä's child, sometimes He is Rädhäräëé's consort, sometimes He is in Mathurä, sometimes He is in Våndävana. There are many spiritual varieties, but everything is complete in itself. There is no question of becoming. We reach the point where we are simply enjoying variety. That is all.

Çyämasundara däsa: What is the difference between spiritual variety and material variety?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Material variety is artificial. It is like a man satisfied with a plastic flower. Enjoyment of a plastic flower cannot be the same as the enjoyment of a real flower. A plastic flower has no aroma. It is artificial, bluff.

Çyämasundara däsa: Whereas Hegel emphasized speculative thought, Kierkegaard emphasized action. He saw freedom in proper action.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, spiritual life means proper action. It is improper to think that one is inactive when he attains the perfectional stage. That is the Mäyävädé theory. Mäyävädés contend that a jug will make a big sound if it is not full of water. They equate fullness with silence. But from Bhagavad-gétä, we understand that the soul is never inactive. Sometimes, however, we see that inactivity is recommended. This means that we should not speak or act foolishly. If we cannot talk intelligently, we had better stop talking. But that inactivity cannot be equated with perfection.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard found truth in the relative and subjective, in personal, individual reflection, in what he calls "inward passion."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Truth is truth, and that is absolute. You may manufacture relative truths, but the Absolute Truth is one. If we have no knowledge of the Absolute Truth, we emphasize relative truths. There may be inward passion, or whatever, but if we do not know the ultimate goal, we may be misled. It is all right to say that passion is truth, but passion means activity. Where will your activity end? What is the purpose of your activity? You may drive your car, but if you do not know where to go, what is the point? You are wasting your energy. Of course, one may say, "I do not know where to go, but that doesn't matter. Just let me start my car and go." But is this a very good proposal?

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kierkegaard, it is not what is done, but how it is done.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is a dog's obstinacy.

Çyämasundara däsa: This is a kind of subjectivity that is always uncertain. Uncertainty creates anxiety.

Çréla Prabhupäda: One who does not know life's aim will always be in anxiety.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Kierkegaard, this anxiety and uncertainty are dispelled by what he calls "the leap of faith."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, but the leap must be made when there is a goal. Unless you know the goal, the fixed point, your passion and energy may be misused, misdirected.

Çyämasundara däsa: As a Christian, Kierkegaard felt that our energy should be used to reach God through Christ.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a good position. That is our process. But it is not necessary to pass through the lower stages. Why not take to God immediately, if you can reach God through Jesus Christ? Our process is that you must surrender yourself to the guru in order to understand the highest truth.

tad viddhi praëipätena
paripraçnena sevayä
upadekñyanti te jïänaà
jïäninas tattva-darçinaù

"Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth." (Bg. 4.34) Çrémad-Bhägavatam also states:

tasmäd guruà prapadyeta
jijïäsuùçreya uttamam
çäbde pare ca niñëätaà
brahmaëy upaçamäçrayam

"Any person who is seriously desirous of achieving real happiness must seek out a bona fide spiritual master and take shelter of him by initiation. The qualification of a spiritual master is that he must have realized the conclusion of the scriptures by deliberation and arguments and thus be able to convince others of these conclusions. Such great personalities who have taken complete shelter of the Supreme Godhead, leaving aside all material consideration, are to be understood as bona fide spiritual masters." (Bhäg. 11.3.21) This is the process. It is not that we continue in our own way, hoping to take the right path through experience. In the middle of the vast ocean, you do not know where to direct your ship. You may go one way, and then you may go another. If you do not know the direction, your endeavors will be frustrated. A captain, a compass, and a sextant are needed. The captain is the guru who gives directions. If you have a ship without a captain, you will go one way and then another, and waste your energy. If Kierkegaard accepts Christ, he is accepting some guidance.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard says: "God does not think, He creates; God does not exist, He is eternal. Man thinks and exists, and existence separates thought and being."

Çréla Prabhupäda: What does he mean that God is eternal and does not exist?

Çyämasundara däsa: For him, the word "existence" refers to that which is coming into being. God does not "exist" in the sense that He is always the same.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That means He is perfect. God does not progress from one state to another. If that is Kierkegaard's philosophy, he should agree to follow the orders of God. Why experiment? God is omnipotent and all powerful. We agree that He does not have to make plans. He creates automatically. His energies are so perfect and subtle, that as soon as He thinks, a thing is realized. It is created perfectly.

Çyämasundara däsa: Kierkegaard sees man's existence as a state of constantly becoming. Man's thought is separate from his being.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then why not unite thought and being by surrendering to Kåñëa?

DS:Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980)

Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980)

Hayagréva däsa: Descartes and Leibnitz believed that before the creation, the concept of man existed in essence in the mind of God, just as a machine exists in the mind of its manufacturer before it is constructed. Sartre takes exception to this. In The Humanism of Existentialism, he writes: "Atheistic existentialism, which I represent, is more coherent. It states that if God does not exist, there is at least one being in whom existence precedes essence, a being who exists before he can be defined by any concept, and that this being is man, or, as Heidegger says, human reality."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But where does human reality come from? There are also other realities. Why is he stressing human reality?

Hayagréva däsa: As for man's origin, Sartre would say that man is "thrown into the world."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Thrown by whom? The word "throw" implies a thrower.

Hayagréva däsa: Sartre isn't really interested in a thrower. "Existentialism isn't so atheistic that it wears itself out showing God doesn't exist," he writes. "Rather, it declares that even if God did exist, that would change nothing. There you've got our point of view. Not that we believe that God exists, but that we think that the problem of His existence is not the issue."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if you and others exist, why doesn't God exist? Why deny God and His existence? Let them all exist.

Çyämasundara däsa: Since Sartre sees man as having been thrown into the world and abandoned, for him, God is dead.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Abandoned by God does not mean that God is dead. You have to admit that you are condemned to the material world, but just because you are condemned, you should not think that God is also condemned. God is always in Vaikuëöha. He is not dead.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre believes that because we have been abandoned, we must rely on ourselves alone.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But God has not abandoned us. God is not partial. He does not accept one person and abandon another. If you feel abandoned, it is because you have done something that has brought this condition about. If you rectify your position, you will be accepted again.

Hayagréva däsa: But Sartre would deny God's existence, particularly that of a personal God.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But his denial should be based on some logic or reason. Why mention the word "God," if God does not exist? God is there, but Sartre denies God's existence. This is inconsistent. If God does not exist, why even mention the word? His proposal is that he does not want God to exist.

Hayagréva däsa: He wants to set the whole question aside in order to place emphasis on man, on human reality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you believe in your existence, why not believe in the existence of another? There are 8,400,000 different species existing in multifarious forms. Why shouldn't God exist? According to the Vedic understanding, God is also a living being, but He is different in that He is the chief, supreme living being. According to Bhagavad-gétä, mattaù parataraà nänyat (Bg. 7.7). There is no living being superior to God. We all experience the fact that there are beings more intelligent than we. God is the ultimate intelligence. Why can't a person who exceeds all others in intelligence exist? There is no question of "if God exists." God must exist. In the çästras He is described as the superlative personality, as the super powerful, the super intelligent. We can see in this world that everyone is not on an equal level, that there are varying degrees of perfection. This indicates that there is a superlative, and if we go on searching—either for wealth, intelligence, power, beauty, or whatever—we will find that God possesses all qualities to the superlative degree, and that every other living entity possesses qualities in degrees relative to Him. How, then, can we rationally deny His existence?

Hayagréva däsa: According to Sartre, the first principle of existentialism is that "man is nothing else but what he makes of himself." This can be true only if there is no God to conceive of human nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If man is what he makes of himself, why doesn't man exist as a superman? If his capacities are completely independent of anyone else, why is he in his present situation?

Hayagréva däsa: That is also Sartre's question. He therefore emphasizes man's responsibility. "But if existence really does precede essence," he writes, "man is responsible for what he is. Thus existentialism's first move is to make every man aware of what he is and to make the full responsibility of his existence rest on him."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If man is responsible, who gave him this responsibility? What does he mean by responsibility? You feel responsible to someone when someone gives you duties to discharge. If there is no duty, or overseer, where is your responsibility?

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre sees man as being overwhelmed by his very responsibility. He is in anguish and anxiety because he has the freedom to change himself and the world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that man is in an awkward position. He wants peace, but he does not know how to attain it. But this does not mean that peace is not possible. Peace is not possible for a man in ignorance.

Çyämasundara däsa: Anxiety arises from responsibility. Man thinks that he has to choose properly in order to enjoy something. If he chooses wrongly, he must suffer.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, responsibility is there, but why not take it to transfer yourself to a safe place where there is no anxiety? It may be that you do not know of a safe place, but if there is such a place, why not ask someone who knows? Why constantly remain disappointed and anxious? The safe place where there is no anxiety is called Vaikuëöha. The word Vaikuëöha means "no anxiety."

Hayagréva däsa: Sartre believes that the task of existentialism is "to make every man aware of what he is and to make the full responsibility of his existence rest on him....And when we say that a man is responsible for himself, we do not only mean that he is responsible for his own individuality, but that he is responsible for all men."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Suppose I want to benefit you, and you are free. Your freedom means that you can accept or reject my good intentions. How can I be responsible for you if you don't obey? How can you be responsible for me? Sartre claims that you are responsible for others, but if others do not follow your instructions, how can you be considered responsible? This is all contradictory. Unless there is some standard, there must be contradiction. According to the Vedic version, God is the Supreme Person, and we should all be His obedient servants. God gives us some duty, and we are responsible to carry that duty out. Our real responsibility is to God. If we reject God, society becomes chaotic. Religion means avoiding chaos and meeting our responsibility to God by fulfilling our duty. Responsibility rests on us, and it is given by God. If we make spiritual progress by fulfilling our duty, we can finally live with God personally.

Hayagréva däsa: Sartre claims that the existentialist does not actually want to deny God's existence. Rather, "the existentialist thinks it very distressing that God does not exist because all possibility of finding values in a heaven of ideas disappears along with Him....If God didn't exist, everything would be possible. That is the very starting point of existentialism. Indeed, everything is permissible if God does not exist...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he does not know the meaning of God. As we have many times said, God is the Supreme Being, the Supreme Father who impregnates material nature with countless living entities. As soon as we accept material nature as the mother, we must accept some father. Therefore there is a conception of God the Father in all human societies. It is the father's duty to maintain his children, and therefore God is maintaining all the living entities within the universe. There is no question of rationally denying this.

Hayagréva däsa: Well, Sartre at least makes the attempt. He writes: "Since we have discarded God the Father, there has to be someone to invent values. You've got to take things as they are. Moreover, to say that we invent values means nothing else but this: Life has no meaning a priori. Before you become alive, life is nothing; it's up to you to give it a meaning, and value is nothing else but the meaning that you choose."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore everyone invents his own meaning? If this is the case, how will people ever live peacefully in society? Since everyone has his own idea of life, there can be no harmony. What kind of government would exist?

Hayagréva däsa: Recently, Sartre has turned to Marxism.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But in Communist countries, there are very strong governments. It is not possible for a people to avoid government or leadership.

Çyämasundara däsa: Regardless of the form of government, Sartre believes that man is basically free.

Çréla Prabhupäda: As soon as you speak of freedom, you refer to some living being. Matter itself has no freedom. It is the active principle that is free.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre maintains that man is condemned to be free, that this is a fate from which man cannot escape.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If man is condemned, who has condemned him?

Çyämasundara däsa: Man is condemned by accident, thrown into the world.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Is it simply by accident that one person is condemned and another blessed? Is it an accident that one man is in jail and another is not? What kind of philosophy is this? Such so-called philosophy simply misleads people. Nothing is accidental. We agree that the living entity is condemned to this material world, but when we speak of condemnation, we also speak of blessedness. So what is that blessedness?

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre argues that man is condemned in the sense that he cannot escape this freedom. Since man is free, he is responsible for his activities.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you are responsible, then your freedom is not accidental. How is it you are accidentally responsible? If there is responsibility, there must be someone you are responsible to. There must be someone who is condemning you or blessing you. These things cannot happen accidentally. His philosophy is contradictory.

Çyämasundara däsa: Man's nature is an indefinite state of freedom. Man has no definite nature. He is continually creating it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he is eternal. But the living entity does not change accidentally. His changes take place under certain regulations, and he attains specific bodies according to his karma, not by accident.

Çyämasundara däsa: But we have no fixed nature in the sense that today I may be happy and tomorrow unhappy.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is true to some extent. When you are placed into the sea, you have no control. You move according to the waves. This means that there is a power that is controlling you. However, if you put yourself in better circumstances, you will be able to control. Because you have placed yourself under the control of material nature, you act according to the modes of material nature.

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

"The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities, which in actuality are carried out by nature." (Bg. 3.27) Because you are conditioned, your freedom is checked. When you are thrown into the ocean of material existence, you essentially lose your freedom. Therefore it is your duty to get yourself liberated.

Çyämasundara däsa: Because we are one thing today and something else tomorrow, Sartre says that our essential nature is "no-thingness."

Çréla Prabhupäda: You are nothing in the sense that you are under the full control of a superior power, being carried away by the waves of mäyä. In the ocean of mäyä, you may say, "I am nothing," but actually you are something. Your something-ness will be very much exhibited to you when you are put on land. Out of despair, you conclude that your nature is that of nothingness. Sartre's philosophy is a philosophy of despair, and we say that it is unintelligent because despair is not the result of intelligence.

Çyämasundara däsa: Although the basis of our nature is nothingness, Sartre maintains that man chooses or creates his own nature.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a fact. Therefore you should create your nature as something, not nothing. In order to do that, however, you have to take lessons from a higher personality. Before philosophizing, Sartre should have taken lessons from a knowledgeable person. That is the Vedic injunction.

tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet
samit-päëiù çrotriyaà brahma-niñöham

"In order to learn the transcendental science, one must approach the bona fide spiritual master in disciplic succession, who is fixed in the Absolute Truth." (Muëòaka Upaniñad 1.2.12)

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre sees our nature as always in the making, as continually becoming.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not in the making. It is changing. But man can make his nature in the sense that he can decide not to change. He can understand that changes are taking place despite the fact that he does not want them. Man can mold his nature by deciding to serve Kåñëa, not by dismissing the whole matter, and, out of confusion and disappointment, claiming it to be nothing. The attempt to make life zero is due to a poor fund of knowledge.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre sees that we are constantly choosing or making our life, but that everything ends at death. That is, man is always in the process of becoming until death. At death, everything is finished.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Death means changing into another body. The active principle on which the body stands does not die. Death is like changing apartments. A sane man can understand this.

Hayagréva däsa: Although man has no determined nature other than nothingness, Sartre sees man as a being striving to be God. He writes: "To be man means to reach toward being God. Or if you prefer, man fundamentally is the desire to be God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: On the one hand, he denies the existence of God, and on the other, he tries to be God. If there is no God, there is no question of desiring to be God. How can one desire to be something that does not exist?

Hayagréva däsa: He is simply stating that man wants to be God. As far as God's existence is concerned, he prefers to set this question aside.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But that is the main question of philosophy! God has created everything: your mind, intelligence, body, existence, and the circumstances surrounding you. How can you deny His existence? Or set it aside as not relevant? In the Vedas, it is stated that in the beginning, God existed, and the Bible also states that in the beginning there was God. In this material universe, existence and annihilation are both temporary. According to the laws of material nature, the body is created on a certain day, it exists for some time, and then is eventually finished. The. entire cosmic manifestation has a beginning, middle, and end. But before this creation, who was there? If God were not there, how could the creation logically be possible?

Hayagréva däsa: As far as we've seen, most philosophers are concerned with resolving this question.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not all philosophers are denying God's existence, but most are denying His personal existence. We can understand, however, that God is the origin of everything, and that this cosmic manifestation emanates from Him. God is there, nature is there, and we are also there, like one big family.

Hayagréva däsa: Sartre would not admit the existence of an originator in whom things exist in their essence prior to creation. He would say that man simply exists, that he just appears.

Çréla Prabhupäda: A person appears due to his father and mother. How can this be denied? Does he mean to say, "I suddenly just dropped from the sky."? Only a fool would say that he appeared without parents. From our experience we can understand that all species of life are manifest from some mother. Taken as a whole, we say that the mother is material nature. As soon as a mother is accepted, the father must also be accepted. It is most important to know where you came from. How can you put this question aside?

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre believes that man's fundamental desire is the "desire to be." That is, man seeks existence rather than mere nothingness.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is so. Because man is eternal, he has the desire to exist eternally. Unfortunately, he puts himself under certain conditions that are not eternal. That is, he tries to maintain a position that will not endure eternally. Through Kåñëa consciousness, we attain and retain our eternal position.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre feels that man wants solidity. He is not satisfied with being a mere being-for-itself. He also desires to be being-in-itself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nothing in the material world exists eternally. A tree may exist for ten thousand years, but eventually it will perish. In the material world, nothing stays forever. What he is seeking is actual spiritual life. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa speaks of another nature, a nature that is permanent, sanätana.

paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo
'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù
yaù sa sarveñu bhüteñu
naçyatsu na vinaçyati

"Yet there is another nature, which is eternal and is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is." (Bg. 8.20) After the annihilation of this material universe, that sanätana nature will abide.

Çyämasundara däsa: This desire to be being-in-itself is the desire to be God, which Sartre maintains is man's fundamental desire.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is more or less Mäyävädé philosophy. The Mäyävädés believe that when they attain complete knowledge, they become God. Because man is part and parcel of God, he wants to be united with God. It is like a man who has been away from home for a long time. Naturally he wants to go home again.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre believes that this desire to be God is bound to fail.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly, because man is not God. If he is God, how has he become something else? His very desire to be God means that he is not God at the present moment. A man cannot become God, but he can become godly. Existing in darkness, we desire light. We may come into the sunshine, but this does not mean that we become the sun. When we come to the platform of perfect knowledge, we become godly, but we do not become God. If we are God, there is no question of being something other than God. There is no question of being ignorant. Another name for Kåñëa is Acyuta, which means, "He who never falls down." This means that He never becomes not-God. He is God always. You cannot become God through some mystic practice. This passion to become God is useless because it is doomed to frustration.

Çyämasundara däsa: Therefore Sartre calls man a "useless passion."

Çréla Prabhupäda: A man is not useless if he attempts to be Kåñëa conscious. The attempt to be Kåñëa conscious and the attempt to be Kåñëa are totally different. One is godly, the other asuric.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre then reasons that because it is impossible to become God, everything else is useless.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is foolishness. You are not God, but God's servant. You have chosen to attempt to become God, but you have found this to be impossible. Therefore you should give up this notion and decide to become a good servant of God, instead of a servant of mäyä. That is the proper decision.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre concludes that since things have no reason to exist, life has no essential purpose.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Nothing can exist without a purpose. There is also a supreme cause. The defect in such philosophers is that they do not have sufficient brain substance to go further than what they superficially see. They are not capable of understanding the cause of causes. Many modern scientists also maintain that nature, prakåti, is the sole cause of existence, but we do not ascribe to such a theory. We understand that God is behind nature, and that nature is not acting independently. Nature is phenomena, but behind or beyond nature is noumena, God, Kåñëa.

In Bhagavad-gétä, philosophy like Sartre's is called asuric, or demoniac. Demons do not believe in a superior cause. They consider that everything is accidental. They say that a man and a woman unite accidentally, and that their child is the result of sex, and nothing more. Therefore they claim that there is no purpose to existence.

asatyam apratiñöhaà te
jagad ähur anéçvaram
aparaspara-sambhütaà
kim anyat käma-haitukam

"They say that this world is unreal, that there is no foundation and that there is no God in control. It is produced of sex desire, and has no cause other than lust." (Bg. 16.8) This type of philosophy is called asuric, demoniac, because it is of the nature of darkness, ignorance.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Sartre, being-for-itself refers to human consciousness, which is subjective, individual, incomplete, and indeterminate. It is nothingness in the sense that it has no density or mass.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Because he is so materialistic, his senses cannot perceive anything that is not concrete. According to Vedic philosophy, the senses and their objects are created simultaneously. Unless there is an aroma, the sense of smell has no value. Unless there is beauty, the eyes have no value. Unless there is music, the ears have no value. Unless there is something soft, the sense of touch has no value. There is no question of nothingness. There must be interaction.

Çyämasundara däsa: Since man's essential nature is an undetermined nothingness, Sartre believes that man is free to choose to be either a coward or a hero. Our situation is in our own hands.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you claim that you were tossed into the world by some superior power, or by accident, what can you do? How can you become a hero? If you try to become a hero, you will be kicked all the more because you are placed here by a superior power. If a culprit under police custody attempts to become a hero, he will be beaten and punished. Actually, you are neither a coward nor a hero. You are an instrument. You are completely under the control of a superior power.

Çyämasundara däsa: Well, if someone is attacking you, you have the power to choose to be a hero and defend yourself, or to run.

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is not heroic to defend oneself. That is natural. If that is the case, even a dog can be a hero when he is attacked. Even an ant can be a hero. Heroism and cowardice are simply mental concoctions. After all, you are under the control of a power that can do what He likes with you. Therefore there is no question of your becoming a hero or a coward.

Çyämasundara däsa: Suppose someone is in danger, and you rescue him. Isn't that being heroic?

Çréla Prabhupäda: All you can rescue is the exterior dress. Saving that dress is not heroism. It is not even protection. One can be a real hero only when he is fully empowered or fully protected. Such a person can only be a devotee, because only Kåñëa can fully protect or empower.

Çyämasundara däsa: Being free, man is subject to what Sartre calls "bad faith," a kind of self-deception. Through bad faith, man loses his freedom and responsibility.

Çréla Prabhupäda: You certainly have limited freedom to choose, but if you choose improperly, you have to suffer. Responsibility and freedom go hand in hand. At the same time, there must be discrimination. Without it, our freedom is blind. We cannot understand right from wrong.

Çyämasundara däsa: A man in bad faith drifts along from day to day without being involved, avoiding responsible decisions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that he has decided to drift. His drifting is a decision.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre believes that bad faith must be replaced by a solid choosing, and by faith in that choice.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if he makes the wrong decision, what is the value of his action? Moths fly very valiantly and courageously into the fire. Is that a very good decision?

Çyämasundara däsa: Due to bad faith, people treat others as objects instead of persons. Sartre advocates rectifying this situation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He speaks of bad faith, but what about good faith?

Çyämasundara däsa: If bad faith is the avoidance of decisions, good faith would mean making decisions courageously and following them out, regardless of what these decisions are.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what if your decision is wrong?

Çyämasundara däsa: For Sartre, it is not a question of right or wrong.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then whatever decision I make is final and absolute? This means that the insect's decision to enter the fire is a proper decision. This is the philosophy of insects. If man can do as he pleases, where is his responsibility?

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre believes that the fate of the world depends on man's decisions. Obviously, if man decides properly, the world would be a better place.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore we are trying to introduce this Kåñëa consciousness in order to make the world into Vaikuëöha, into a place where there is no anxiety. But this is not a blind decision. It is the decision of a higher authority; therefore it is perfect.

Çyämasundara däsa: Many people call Sartre's philosophy pessimistic because he maintains that man is a "useless passion" vainly striving in a universe without a purpose.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Sartre may be a useless passion, but we are not. No sane man is useless. A sane man will follow a superior authority. That is Vedic civilization. If one approaches a bona fide spiritual master, he will not be bewildered. Sartre believes that the universe is without a purpose because he is blind. He has no power to see that there is a plan. Therefore, according to Bhagavad-gétä, his philosophy is asuric, demoniac. Everything in the universe functions according to some plan. The sun and moon rise, and the seasons change according to plan.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Sartre, man stands alone in the world, yet he is not alone if he is a being-for-others. Man needs others for his own self-realization.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means that man requires a guru.

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre does not speak of a guru but of interaction with others for self-understanding.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If this is required, why not interact with the best man? If we require others to understand ourselves, why should we not seek the best man for our own understanding? We should receive help from the man who knows. If you take the advice of one who can give you the right direction, your end will be glorious. That is the Vedic injunction. Tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet (Muëòaka Upaniñad 1.2.12).

Çyämasundara däsa: Sartre feels that in the presence of others, man is ashamed.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Man is ashamed if he is not guided by a superior. If you are guided by a superior, you will be glorious, not ashamed. Your superior is that person who can lead you to the glory of Kåñëa consciousness.

XIIIPSYCHOANALYSIS

XIIIPSYCHOANALYSIS

DS:Sigmund Freud (1856-1934)

Sigmund Freud (1856-1934)

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud saw a conflict between the primal self, which he called the id, and the ethical self, the ego. It is the id that attempts to gratify all needs, and its basic motivating force is the libido, the sexual instinct. When the id comes in contact with the senses, the ego is formed. The superego is a modified part of the ego, which is formed through experiences related to one's parents. The superego is characterized by the feelings of conscience, and it is the principal repressive factor in the ego's striving to curb the primitive, sex-motivated, lawless tendencies of the id.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We also agree that everyone has a sexual appetite, and it is stated in çästras that sex is the principal bond to the material world. Actually, everyone has a tendency not only for sex, but for intoxication and meat eating also. These tendencies are inherent in the living entity. According to the çästras, we are allowed sexual intercourse in marriage, but we are prohibited from having any other sex. Kåñëa says, dharmäviruddho bhüteñu kämo 'smi. "I am sex life which is not contrary to religious principles." (Bg. 7.11) This means that sex life has to be regulated. Of course, people have a perverted tendency to have sex against the Vedic injunctions. The Vedas give regulations for all undesirable activities, not only sex, but meat eating and intoxication as well. The idea is to restrict these anarthas, these unwanted things, so that the living entity may eventually be freed of them. In the conditioned state, everyone creates a false ego, thinking, "I am American, I am Hindu, I am Christian, Moslem, Russian, I am a human being, I am this body, I am this and that." This is false ego. Superior ego says, "I am Brahman. I am the eternal servant of Kåñëa." If we understand the self in this way, false ego automatically vanishes. Our senses are gross, but they are controlled by the mind. The mind is part of the subtle body, and the mind in turn is controlled by the intelligence. The intelligence is controlled by the ego, and if this ego is false, the entire structure is false. False ego thinks, "I am this body." This is false identification. When the ego is thus deluded, everything subordinate to it is also illusioned because everything else is standing on a false platform. Therefore the Vedas advise us to come to the platform of knowledge, and this is called brahma-jïäna. As Bhagavad-gétä states:

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments nor desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state, he attains pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54) When we come to the knowledge that we are not the body but pure spirit soul, we immediately become happy. All the neuroses and problems that Freud is trying to cure are due to false ego. When we understand our actual position, the blazing fire of material existence is immediately extinguished. Freud is describing this blazing fire, and he is trying to treat people within this fire. But how can a person be happy when there is fire all about? It is the fire itself that must be extinguished, or the person himself must be removed from the fire. Then there will be happiness.

I recall some years ago in India, when a criminal was pleading insanity to a murder charge, a psychiatrist was called to judge whether this person was sane during the time of the murder. The psychiatrist said, "I have examined many people, and I have concluded that more or less, everyone is insane. If his innocence depends upon his sanity, then I would say that he should be excused, but as far as I know, everyone is more or less insane." This is also our conclusion. Whoever is infected with this material nature is more or less insane. When the living entity takes on the material body, he must be crazy. Therefore everyone is speaking in different ways.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud believed that painful or traumatic experiences, often repressed by forgetfulness, lie deep in our subconscious. By recalling them, we may be able to overcome the neuroses that they inflict.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our process is different. When you give a man a better thing, he will forget inferior things.

viñayä vinivartante
nirähärasya dehinaù
rasa-varjaà raso 'py asya
paraà dåñövä nivartate

"The embodied soul may be restricted from sense enjoyment, though the taste for sense objects remains. But, ceasing such engagements by experiencing a higher taste, he is fixed in consciousness." (Bg. 2.59) Fear is created when we are not in Kåñëa consciousness. This is a characteristic of the conditioned soul. As soon as we become Kåñëa conscious, our fears and anxieties automatically vanish.

näräyaëa-paräù sarve
na kutaçcana bibhyati
svargäpavarga-narakeñv
api tulyärtha-darçinaù

"Devotees solely engaged in the devotional service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, never fear any condition of life. For them the heavenly planets, liberation, and the hellish planets are all the same, for such devotees are interested only in the service of the Lord." (Bhäg. 6.17.28) When we are God conscious, we don't fear anything. Although Prahläda Mahäräja's demonic father threatened him with death and put him in all kinds of frightful circumstances, Prahläda remained quiet and peaceful. Indeed, his father asked him, "Prahläda, how is it that you are so proud and fearless when I am trying to chastise you?" Prahläda replied, 'The person who gives you your power is the same person who is protecting me." Forgetfulness of painful experiences is in itself artificial. People forget because they are not properly trained. There is no usefulness in forgetting painful experiences. When we are Kåñëa conscious, we are not afraid to remember them. We actually thank Kåñëa, and say, "Kåñëa, You are so kind that You have saved me from so many frightful situations. Now I am sure that I am pure and have my safety in You." A Kåñëa conscious man is not frightened by any of his past experiences. Rather, he laughs at them, thinking, "What a fool I was to have been afraid of all these things!"

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud did not believe that forgetfulness is artificial. He felt that it is a natural instinct to forget painful experiences.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Well, that is so. For instance, when you were in the womb of your mother, you were in a very, very painful situation. Now you have forgotten that experience, and that forgetfulness is certainly natural. It is a fact that you were confined to a womb, but you cannot remember this. When you think about it, you can understand what a horrible situation that was. However, the çästras say that even though you have forgotten this, you have not escaped the situation. You are waiting for a similar painful experience.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud contends that anxieties and tensions are caused by the id's primitive instincts that are always forcing us to act contrary to the rational, moral ego and superego.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Anxieties will continue as long as you are in the material condition. In conditioned life, you cannot be freed from anxiety.

Çyämasundara däsa: Is this because we are always desiring something and being frustrated?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Frustration must be there because you do not desire the right thing. You are desiring something that is not permanent, and this is a cause for anxiety. We wish to live forever, but we have accepted this temporary material body. Therefore there is no question of living forever, and we are always anxious because we fear that death is coming. We fear death and the destruction of the body, and this is the main cause of our anxiety. Anxiety is due to our acceptance of something which will not exist, which is temporary.

Çyämasundara däsa: The ego develops strategies of defense against this anxiety engendered by the id. Whenever there is a strong animalistic desire, the ego represses it for self-preservation.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Repression is always there. If we are diseased, and the doctor advises us not to take solid food, we have to repress our appetite. In the system of brahmacarya, the brahmacäré represses his desire for sex. This is called tapasya, voluntary repression. Of course, this is very difficult without some better engagement. Therefore, as I said, we have to replace an inferior engagement with a superior one. When you are captivated by seeing the beautiful form of Kåñëa, you naturally no longer desire to see the beautiful form of a young woman.

Çyämasundara däsa: The Buddhists speak not only of the repression of desires, but of their extinction.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We don't advocate that. There will always be desires, and sometimes we have to repress them. My Guru Mahäräja used to say that as soon as you rise from bed, you should beat your mind a hundred times with your shoes, and when you go to bed at night, you should beat your mind a hundred times with a broomstick. In this way, you will be able to control your mind. Wild tigers have to be controlled by repression, but when the tigers are under control, there is no question of repression. Then you can play with the tigers, and they will be your friends. So repression is not always bad.

Hayagréva däsa: Freud considered sexual repression to be harmful, but sublimation to be often beneficial. He didn't advocate total sexual freedom; rather, he suggested that instead of trying to deny the sex drive, we should try to redirect it, perhaps to some artistic activity, or positive study.

Çréla Prabhupäda: This means diverting our attention, and that is recommended in the Vedic culture for the brahmacäré. If we are taught Kåñëa from the very beginning of life, we will forget sex. Even if an adult takes to Kåñëa consciousness seriously, he can also forget sex. That is the experience of Yamunäcärya,: Yadävadhi mama cettaù padäravinde, kåñëa-padäravinde. "Since I have been engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, every time I think of sex, I spit." [Brs 2.5.72] If we engage in sex without restriction, we will eventually become impotent. That is nature's way of punishment. Sex cannot be artificially repressed, but there is a proper training process.

Hayagréva däsa: Freud believed that sex could not be stamped out, and that if one tried, it would manifest itself in undesirable neurosis.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He did not know the training process of Kåñëa consciousness. According to our philosophy, as long as we have sexual inclinations, we have to accept a material body and become entangled in the miseries of material existence. However, there is such a thing as spiritual life, and if we are trained spiritually, we will no longer be bothered by material desires.

Hayagréva däsa: In exploring the realm of infantile sexuality, Freud discovered a definite sexual nature in the early stages of childhood. He concluded that sexual activities in childhood were normal, and this led him to write that "in a normal sex life, no neurosis is possible."

Çréla Prabhupäda: It all depends on the child's training. If a child is trained as a brahmacäré, he will have no inclination for sex. Sometimes a father enjoys sex before his children, and the children imitate. It is the nature of a child to imitate, especially his parents. According to Vedic civilization, as soon as a child is four or five years old, he is sent to a gurukula, where he is disciplined. There, he practically forgets sex life. But when he becomes a young man, he may naturally have a little tendency for sex, and if this is the case, the guru suggests marriage. If, on the other hand, one can perfectly control his sexual tendencies, he can become a sannyäsé. My Guru Mahäräja, for instance, never married. This is all a matter of education.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud believed that many of our present unconscious wishes and conflicts have their origins in these infantile experiences.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That may be, but you are not going to be an infant again. So why not forget all this? After this life, you will be placed in the womb of another mother, and all those experiences will happen again. It is therefore the duty of the guru and the parents to save the living entity from rebirth.

gurur na sa syät sva-jano na sa syät
pitä na sa syäj janané na sä syät
daivaà na tat syän na patiç ca sa syän
na mocayed yaù samupeta-måtyum

"One who cannot deliver his dependents from the path of repeated birth and death should never become a spiritual master, a father, a husband, a mother, or a worshipable demigod." (Bhäg. 5.5.18) Janma-måtyu-jarä-vyädhi. At the time of death, we will again experience this horrible situation. We will again have to enter a womb, be confined, and undergo birth. Whether we forget these experiences or not, we will have to undergo them again and again if we do not become Kåñëa conscious.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud felt that most of our problems, which are sexual in nature, can be cured by recalling painful experiences and objectively analyzing them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We must understand why this sex problem is there. If we tolerate a little itching sensation, we will be spared much pain. Yan maithunädi-gåhamedhi-sukhaà hi tucchaà kaëòüyanena karayor iva duùkha-duùkham. "Sex life is compared to the rubbing of two hands to relieve an itch. Gåhamedhis, householders without spiritual knowledge, think that this itching is the greatest platform of happiness, although it is actually a source of distress." (Bhäg. 7.9.45) When ordinary men are overly attached to materialistic life, their only happiness is sexual intercourse. The çästras say that happiness derived from sexual intercourse is very, very insignificant. Indeed, it is not even happiness. At best, it may be considered a tenth-class happiness. Because people have no idea of the happiness of Kåñëa consciousness, they think that sex is the highest happiness. But if we analyze it, what kind of happiness is it? When we have an itch, we scratch it and feel some pleasure, but after that pleasure passes, the effects are abominable. The itch becomes worse. The çästras tell us that if we just try to tolerate this itching sensation, we will be spared a great deal of pain. This is possible if we practice this Kåñëa consciousness.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud believed that neuroses, disorders, anxieties, and frustrations have their origin in repression.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And I am telling you that all these are due to sex. But we are not advocating repression. We give facility in the form of a wife. The sex impulse is to be directed to the wife.

Çyämasundara däsa: But Freud insisted that the sex impulse is present at the very beginning of life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We also admit that. We say that as soon as the living being is embodied, he experiences hunger and sex. Why is that? Ähära-nidrä-vyaväyaù. We find these impulses even in animals. These drives are already there. What is the use in philosophizing about them?

Çyämasundara däsa: Through psychoanalysis, pent-up emotions can be released, and the original shock mitigated by remembering and confessing.

Çréla Prabhupäda: But what guarantee is there that we will not receive another shock? The living entity is receiving shock after shock. You try to cure him of one, and another comes. It is a fact that material life is painful. As soon as you receive this material body, you must suffer the threefold miseries. Everyone is seeking happiness, but unless materialistic life is stopped, unless we put an end to birth, old age, disease, and death, there is no question of happiness. Materialistic life is a disease, and Vedic civilization attempts to cure this disease. Our program is total cure. No more shock. Freud's treatment is useless because he cannot guarantee that there will not be another shock. If you are situated in real Kåñëa consciousness, the worst type of misery may face you, and you will not be disturbed. You will not experience any shock at all. Freud was trying to cure his patients of the results of some shock they had experienced years ago , but there is no guarantee that a similar shock will not come again. Rather, the living entity will receive one shock after another after another.

daivé hy eñä guëamayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." (Bg. 7.14) As soon as we try to solve one problem, another problem comes, then another. If we are in Kåñëa consciousness, there are no more shocks.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud believed that our present personality is greatly influenced by our sexual experiences in infancy and childhood.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Therefore we are trying to train our boys as brahmacärés. Of course, there is the tendency for sex, but by practicing brahmacarya, by diverting our attention to Kåñëa, there will be very little chance that a shock will come about. If the Vedic system is followed by human society, these shocks will not be there.

Hayagréva däsa: Freud also tied infantilism in with the religious impulse. He wrote: "Psychoanalysis, which has taught us the intimate connection between the father complex and belief in God, has shown us that the personal God is psychologically nothing but an exalted father....Youthful persons lose their religious belief as soon as the authority of the father breaks down." Thus Freud sees God as a father figure arising out of the helplessness experienced by the little child.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can a little child invent his father? Was he not born of his father? And how can he abandon the idea of his father? Without a father, how can one come into being? Even Freud had a father, grandfather, great grandfather, and so on back. We speak of God as the first father because there is no one beyond Him.

Hayagréva däsa: Still, Freud considers belief in God as infantile. In The Future of an Illusion, he writes: "Man cannot remain a child forever; he must venture at last into the hostile world." Instead of continuing to dwell in such a nursery, man should try to rid himself of the psychic crutch of religion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is his definition of childishness? Everyone must be a child, and everyone must have a father. Just as we cannot deny our biological father, we cannot deny the ultimate Supreme Father.

Hayagréva däsa: It is not that he is denying biological fathers, but the idea of a Supreme Father, which he felt arose out of man's initial helpless state.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Helplessness is always there, because the threefold miseries will always exist in material life. There will always be miseries arising from the body and mind, miseries inflicted by other living entities, and natural catastrophes. In addition, there is always birth, old age, disease, and death. It is only a fool or a rascal who hopes against hope and makes plans to overcome all these difficulties. However we may plan, nature is so strong that it will smash our plans to pieces with the kick of death. Man hopes against hope to adjust material things so that he can be happy in this world, but this is foolishness. Man is helpless at every step.

Hayagréva däsa: Freud felt that belief in God the Father is "so patently infantile, so incongruous with reality, that to one whose attitude to humanity is friendly, it is painful to think that the great majority of mortals will never be able to rise above this view of life."

Çréla Prabhupäda: So what is his reality? Belief in God may be infantile to him, but what is he except a child? He also makes plans, and that in itself is childish. How is it that he is more than a child? Can he give an ultimate solution that will rid man of his helplessness?

Hayagréva däsa: Well, he personally hoped that psychoanalysis would provide the answers.

Çréla Prabhupäda: How can a common man understand psychoanalysis? The fact is that there is a supreme controller who is present everywhere. Psychoanalysis should begin with this point. Why is he defying this fact?

Hayagréva däsa: He sincerely believed that the maturation process necessarily entails ridding oneself of religion. He writes: "If one attempts to assign religion its place in man's evolution, it seems not so much to be a lasting acquisition as a parallel to the neurosis which the civilized individual must pass through on his way from childhood to maturity."

Çréla Prabhupäda: He has reached this conclusion because he has seen so many sentimental religions, but first of all he must understand what religion actually is. Religion is not possible without an understanding of God, and a religion without God cannot truly be called a religion. According to the Vedic system, religion refers to the orders of God; therefore if we have no conception of God, we cannot be said to have a religion. If we do not know God or His nature, how can we know the orders God is giving?

Hayagréva däsa: It has often been noted—initially by Jung—that Freud tried to repress religious feelings within himself. In a letter, he once confided, "I cannot rid myself of certain materialistic prejudices, and I would carry them over into the research of the occult."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Religion is neither occult nor obscure. Of course, everything is obscure for an unintelligent person who has no idea of either God or religion.

Hayagréva däsa: In the same letter, Freud continues: "Thus I am entirely incapable of considering the 'survival of the personality' after death, even as a mere scientific possibility....I think, therefore, it is better if I continue confining myself to psychoanalysis."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But if he cannot understand the eternity of the soul, he will be deficient in psychoanalysis as well. Even within one lifetime, we can see that the body changes while the soul remains the same. We go through the changes of childhood, youth, manhood, middle age, and old age, but the soul, the person, is always there.

Hayagréva däsa: In Beyond the Pleasure Principle, Freud theorizes on the death instinct. Equating a child's fondness to repeat a certain act that gives him pleasure with the tendency to restore a previous state of affairs, he concludes that if instincts aim at the past, they would necessarily tend to regress to the prenatal state. This is a desire to "return to the womb" that brought Freud to write: "The goal of all life is death." For him, death is the cessation of suffering.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If this is the case, why are people afraid of death? Why do people go to a doctor when they fear some disease? If death is ultimate happiness, why do people try to avoid it?

Hayagréva däsa: Once, after an argument with Jung, Freud fainted, and his words when he came to were, "How sweet it must be to die."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Now, what pleasure does one derive from being dead? What is the pleasure of extinction? That is the pleasure of a stone.

Hayagréva däsa: Well, he did speak of return to the "quiescence of the inorganic world."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Then why bother philosophizing or psychoanalyzing? Just commit suicide and become like a stone. Why take up so much time? If it is better to die, then become a stone, and be happy. If ultimate happiness is extinction, why write so many books?

Hayagréva däsa: Freud considered the quietude that follows the sexual act to be very much like death, because desires are extinguished. Thus sleep often follows sexual intercourse. In this sense, the pursuit of pleasure is a drive to extinction.

Çréla Prabhupäda: If this is the purpose of life, we should pray to God to make us dogs and hogs because these animals have very good facilities for sex life. They all consider sex to be the ultimate goal, and then sleep.

åñabha uväca
näyaà deho deha-bhäjäà nåloke
kañöän kämän arhate viò-bhujäà ye
tapo divyaà putrakä yena sattvaà
çuddhyed yasmäd brahma-saukhyaà tv anantam

"Lord Rsabhadeva told His sons: My dear boys, of all the living entities who have accepted material bodies in this world, one who has been awarded this human form should not work hard day and night simply for sense gratification, which is available even for dogs and hogs that eat stool. One should engage in penance and austerity to attain the divine position of devotional service. By such activity, one's heart is purified, and when one attains this position, he attains eternal, blissful life, which is transcendental to material happiness, and which continues forever." (Bhäg. 5.5.1) Human life is meant for tapasya, for putting an end to sex. This is the process of brahmacarya.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Freud, the sexual energy, or libido, is not only manifest through sexual intercourse. It is associated with a wide variety of pleasurable sensations relating to bodily activities and including pleasures of the mouth and the different organs.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We have already said that the only happiness in this material world is considered to be sexual. Yan maithunädi (Bhäg. 7.9.45). The word ädi means the basic principle, which, in the material world, is sex. What is materialistic happiness? It is enjoying this life with one's friends and family. But what kind of pleasure is this? It is compared to a drop of water in the desert. Actually, we are seeking unlimited pleasure. Änandamayo 'bhyäsät. How can this drop of water in the desert, which is materialistic pleasure, ever satisfy us? No one is satisfied, although people are having sex in so many different ways. And now young girls are almost going naked, and the female population is increasing everywhere. As soon as there is an increase in the female population, the women say, "Where are the men?" There then must be disaster because every woman is trying to attract a man, and men will take advantage of this situation. When milk is available in the market, what is the use in keeping a cow? The more men become attached to women, the more the female population will increase.

Çyämasundara däsa: How is that?

Çréla Prabhupäda: When you have more sex, your power to beget a male child is diminished. When the man is less potent, a girl is born, and when a man is more potent, a boy is born. If a man's discharge is larger, there will be a male child. If the woman's discharge is larger, there will be a female child. When women are easily available, men become weak, and they beget female children because they lose their power from overindulgence. Sometimes they even become impotent. If you don't restrict your sex life, there will be so many disasters. Yämunäcärya, says:

yadävadhi mama cetaù kåñëa-pädäravinde
nava-nava-rasa-dhämanudyata rantum äsét
tadävadhi bata näré-saìgame smaryamäne
bhavati mukha-vikäraù suñöhu niñöhévanaà ca

"Since I have been engaged in the transcendental loving service of Kåñëa, realizing ever-new pleasure in Him, whenever I think of sex pleasure, I spit at the thought, and my lips curl with distaste."

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud would consider this a form of repression.

Çréla Prabhupäda: His idea of repression is different from ours. Our repression means rising early in the morning, attending maìgala-äratik, chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, and engaging in devotional service. In this way, we repress material propensities.

Çyämasundara däsa: In other words, it's repression with awareness and knowledge.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Actual knowledge will come later. In the beginning, there is obedience to the spiritual master. In this way, we will not become habituated to undesirable activity.

Çyämasundara däsa: Yet by remembering some traumatic or shocking experience, our tensions are often relieved, and personality disorders rectified. This is a fact of psychoanalysis.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That may be, but when a seed has fructified and grown into a tree, it is no longer possible to rectify the seed. The seed is no longer there. It has changed into a tree. Freud may be able to find out the cause, but does he know the cure? Our cure is to divert the attention to Kåñëa. By understanding Kåñëa, we automatically forget our problems. Kåñëa is the panacea for all diseases.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud also investigated projection, that is attributing one's own personality onto others. A man may regard others as a thief because he's a thief himself.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We accept that. Ätmanä manyate jagat. Everyone thinks others to be like himself.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud also felt that children act in different ways to win the love and affection of their parents.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Children imitate. In Agra, I have seen two and three-year-old children try to imitate the sexual intercourse of their parents. They did not know anything about sex pleasure, but they were imitating what they had seen. Children do not know the value of things, but they imitate their parents. There is no fixed pattern of development for the personality of children. You can mold children in any way. They are like soft dough, and you can make out of them what you like. All you have to do is put them into the mold. Many of the neuroses Freud talked about are not experienced in Indian families. If you place a child in good association, he will act properly, and if you place him in bad association, he will act improperly. A child has no independence in that sense.

Çyämasundara däsa: Freud believed that our behavior must be understood in terms of our entire life history.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is so. Therefore in our Vedic system, it is forbidden for the husband and wife to speak of sex even jokingly before a small child, because the child cannot understand. If children know of sexual intercourse, it is because they have learned about it from their parents.

Hayagréva däsa: Although often avoiding the very subject of religion, Freud sometimes took an agnostic stand. He writes: "Of the reality value of most religions we cannot judge; just as they cannot be proved, neither can they be refuted."

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, he does not know what religion is. As we have said, religion means the orders given by God. Since he has no conception of God, how can he know anything of God's orders? He is acquainted only with fictitious religions, which have been described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.1.2] as kaitava—cheating religions. Real religion is law. Just as you cannot manufacture laws in your home, you cannot manufacture religion.

Hayagréva däsa: Freud further writes: "The riddles of the universe only reveal themselves slowly to our inquiry. To many questions science can as yet give no answer; but scientific work is our only way to the knowledge of external reality. ...No, science is no illusion. But it would be an illusion to suppose that we can get anywhere else what it cannot give us."

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, we have to learn what the object of knowledge is. The word veda means "knowledge," and anta means "ultimate." Unless you come to the ultimate point of knowledge, or Vedänta, your knowledge is imperfect or insufficient. The ultimate object of knowledge is God, and if we cannot define God or explain His nature, we have not reached the ultimate point of knowledge. God is a fact, but unfortunately we have no clear idea of Him. This means that our knowledge has not reached the ultimate point—that is, it is imperfect. If the knowledge of a philosopher or scientist is imperfect, of what value is it? According to the Vedic method, we receive our knowledge from the perfect person: Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: As for the origin of religions, Freud writes: "As it is a delicate task to decide what God has Himself ordained and what derives rather from the authority of an all-powerful parliament or a supreme judicial decision, it would be an indubitible advantage to leave God out of the question altogether, and to admit honestly the purely human origin of all cultural laws and institutions."

Çréla Prabhupäda: God does not derive power from anyone. As stated in the beginning of Çrémad-Bhägavatam: janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç cärtheñv abhijïaù sva-räö (Bhäg. 1.1.1). The Supreme God, the Absolute Truth, knows everything in complete detail. The word abhijïaù means "complete awareness." How is it God has complete knowledge? From whom has He received this knowledge? The answer is: sva-räö. He does not receive it from anyone. He is completely independent. If God has to receive knowledge from Mr. Freud, He is not God. God is the only person who is completely independent.

na tasya käryaà karaëaà ca vidyate
na tat-samaç cäbhyadhikaç ca dåçyate
paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate
sväbhäviké jïäna-bala-kriyä ca

"He does not possess bodily form like that of an ordinary living entity. There is no difference between His body and His soul. He is absolute. All His senses are transcendental. Any one of His senses can perform the action of any other sense. Therefore, no one is greater than Him or equal to Him. His potencies are multifarious, and thus His deeds are automatically performed as a natural sequence." (Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 6.7-8) God is naturally all perfect, and He doesn't have to adopt some process in order to become perfect. Anyone who is trying to be perfect is not God. When Kåñëa was only three months old, He could kill the big giant Pütanä. His potencies are there automatically, whether He appears as a child or as a young man. Nowadays, so-called yogés are trying to become God by meditating, but Kåñëa did not have to meditate. If God is always God, He doesn't have to learn anything from anyone. That is the true meaning of independence. If we want to know something about God, we should receive knowledge from Him directly, or from a person who knows Him. This is the direction given in Bhagavad-gétä:

tad viddhi praëipätena
paripraçnena sevayä
upadekñyanti te jïänaà
jïäninas tattva-darçinaù

"Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth." (Bg. 4.34) The word tattva-darçinaù refers to one who factually knows about God. It is necessary to learn about God from one who has seen Him eye to eye. Arjuna, for instance, was talking to God on the battlefield of Kurukñetra. If we wish to understand God, we should understand Him as Arjuna did. What was Arjuna's understanding? That is found in the Tenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä:

paraà brahma paraà dhäma
pavitraà paramaà bhavän
puruñaà çäçvataà divyam
ädi-devam ajaà vibhum

ähus tväm åñayaù sarve
devarñir näradas tathä
asito devalo vyäsaù
svayaà caiva bravéñi me

"You are the Supreme Brahman, the ultimate, the supreme abode and purifier, the Absolute Truth, and the eternal divine person. You are the primal God, transcendental and original, and You are the unborn and all-pervading beauty. All the great sages such as Närada, Asita, Devala, and Vyäsa proclaim this of You, and now You Yourself are declaring it to me." (Bg. 10.12-13)

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning early religious training, Freud writes: "So long as a man's early years are influenced by the religious thought-inhibition and by the lower one derived from it, as well as by the sexual one, we cannot really say what he is actually like." Freud strongly believed that early religious education warps a man's natural development.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What is wrong with informing a child that there is a Supreme Being controlling the whole cosmic situation? Is it that Freud did not believe in education?

Hayagréva däsa: He felt that children should not be indoctrinated with religious "thought-inhibitions."

Çréla Prabhupäda: But there must be some form of education, and spiritual education is the most important. The only business of human life is to learn about God. Lower species cannot understand God, but understanding is possible in the human form. Therefore spiritual education is primary.

Hayagréva däsa: Marx called religion "the opiate of the people," and Freud similarly says that "the consolations of religion may be compared to that of a narcotic."

Çréla Prabhupäda: As I have said before, neither Marx nor Freud know what religion is, and that is their difficulty. First, they have to learn what religion is before they can discuss it intelligently.

Hayagréva däsa: Freud writes: "The believer will not let his faith be taken from him neither by arguments nor by prohibitions. And even if it did succeed with some, it would be a cruel thing to do. A man who has for decades taken a sedative is naturally unable to sleep if he is deprived of it...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is also cruel to mislead people by telling them that God the Father is simply an infantile conception. That is real cruelty. It is cruel to stress sex and death and deny the conception of God as the Supreme Father.

Hayagréva däsa: Freud would not think that it is cruelty to disenchant man with an illusion. He writes: "I disagree with you when you go on to argue that man cannot in general do without the consolation of the religious illusion, that without it he would not endure the troubles of life, the cruelty of reality."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Without a spiritual education, man remains an animal. A man's life should be more than merely eating, sleeping, mating, defending, and dying. Man should strive to advance in spiritual knowledge. Spiritual education means understanding God. Freud may deny the existence of God, but in any case the conception of God is there in human society. One may accept or reject different conceptions of God, but the fact is undeniable that in every civilized country, there is some form of religion. One may be Christian, Buddhist, Hindu, or Moslem: the designation is not very important. Understanding God is the important factor, because that ultimate understanding is Vedänta, the ultimate conclusion of all knowledge. Athäto brahma-jijïäsä. Now, in this human form, is the time to inquire, "What is Brahman?" Brahman, the Absolute Truth, is the goal of real knowledge. Man does not have to be educated to understand sex. According to a Bengali proverb, you do not have to be taught how to cry, or how to enjoy sex. When you lament, you automatically cry, and when there is the impulse to enjoy sex, you enjoy it automatically. This doesn't require the help of an educator like Mr. Freud. Everyone, animals and human beings, knows how to enjoy sex. There is no question of a "sex philosophy." Philosophy means inquiring into the Absolute Truth, Brahman, the supreme controller, He from whom everything has emanated. Philosophy is concerned with understanding where things come from. We may inquire into the origin of life on earth, and conclude that life comes from water, earth, or fire. Then, where do earth, water, and fire come from?

He who is the source of everything is the Absolute Truth. In Bhagavad-gétä, Lord Kåñëa says:

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate
iti matvä bhajante mäà
budhä bhäva-samanvitäù

"I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts." (Bg. 10.8) You become a devotee of Kåñëa when you perfectly understand that Kåñëa is the ultimate source. This knowledge comes after many lifetimes of searching and searching.

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19) After understanding that Väsudeva, Kåñëa, is everything, the mahätmä, the great soul, begins his bhajana, his worship.

mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha
daivéà prakåtim äçritäù
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jïätvä bhütädim avyayam

"O son of Påthä, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible." (Bg. 9.13)

Hayagréva däsa: Freud admits that without religion man will "find himself in a difficult situation. He will have to confess his utter helplessness and his insignificant part in the working of the universe." Yet he goes on to say that without religion, man will venture at last into the hostile world, and this venture is his "education to reality."

Çréla Prabhupäda: And what service has Mr. Freud rendered? He has misled the world and made it more difficult for people to accept the words of God. Men who are innocent accept the words of God, but now many have become "over intelligent," and they think that sex is God. It will take some time to counteract this type of mentality, but man must eventually learn that his happiness is found in understanding and accepting the way of life defined by God Himself.

Hayagréva däsa: Christ pointed out that unless one becomes as a little child, he shall not enter into the kingdom of God, but Freud advocates "growing up" and setting this illusion aside.

Çréla Prabhupäda: He may advocate so many things, but if he does not know the meaning of God, or God's nature, what is the value of his knowledge? According to the Vedic philosophy, we should receive knowledge from a person who knows God. If one has not known God, his knowledge is useless, or, even worse, misleading. It is a fact that there is a supreme controller, and real education means understanding how the supreme controller is working. Denying Him is useless. He is there beyond our control, and we cannot avoid His control. We may make plans to live here very happily, but today or tomorrow, we may die. How can we deny the fact that we are being controlled? Knowledge means understanding how the supreme controller is controlling. People who defy religion and deny the existence of a supreme controller are like the jackal that keeps jumping and jumping, trying to reach grapes on a high vine. After seeing that he cannot reach the grapes, he says to himself, "Oh, there is no need to reach them. They are sour anyway." People who say that we do not need to understand God are indulging in sour-grape philosophy.

DS:Carl Gustav Jung (1875-1961)

Carl Gustav Jung (1875-1961)

Hayagréva däsa: Jung gave the following criticism of Sigmund Freud: "Sexuality evidently meant more to Freud than to other people. For him it was something to be religiously observed....One thing was clear; Freud, who had always made much of his irreligiosity, had now constructed a dogma, or rather, in the place of a jealous God whom he had lost, he had substituted another compelling image, that of sexuality."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact. He has taken sexuality to be God. It is our natural tendency to accept a leader, and Freud abandoned the leadership of God and took up the leadership of sex. In any case, we must have leadership. That is our position. In Russia, I pointed out that there is no difference in our philosophic processes. However, whereas they accept Lenin as their leader, we accept Kåñëa. It is the nature of human beings to accept a leader. It is unfortunate that Freud lost God's leadership and took up instead the leadership of sex.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung concluded: "Freud never asked himself why he was compelled to talk continually of sex, why this idea had taken such possession of him. He remained unaware that his 'monotony of interpretation' expressed a flight from himself, or from that other side of him which might perhaps be called mystical. So long as he refused to acknowledge that side, he could never be reconciled with himself."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that was because he was accepting the leadership of sexuality. If we accept the leadership of Kåñëa, our life becomes perfect. All other leadership is mäyä's leadership. There is no doubt that we have to accept a leader, and therefore he was constantly speaking about sex. Those who have taken God as their leader will speak only of God, nothing else. Jévera 'svarüpa' haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa' (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 20.108) According to Caitanya Mahäprabhu's philosophy, we are all eternal servants of God, but as soon as we give up God's service, we have to accept the service of mäyä.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Freud, the unconscious process, the id, was invariably animalistic and lawless, whereas for Jung, these unconscious energies were potentially sources of positive creative activity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The subconscious state is covered by our present consciousness, and it can also be covered by Kåñëa consciousness. In that case, the subconscious states will no longer be able to react. For instance, the subconscious sex drive is there, but because Yamunäcärya, was in Kåñëa consciousness, he could overcome it. The subconscious experiences, which have been gathering for life after life, which are stored, as it were, will not be able to overcome the individual if he is fully Kåñëa conscious.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung sees the mind as being composed of a balance of the conscious and the unconscious, or subconscious. It is the function of the personality to integrate these. For instance, if one has a strong sex drive, he can sublimate or channel that drive into creative art or religious activity.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is our process. The sex impulse is natural for everyone in the material world. If we think of Kåñëa embracing Rädhärani, or dancing with the gopés, our material sex impulse is sublimated and weakened. If we hear about the pastimes of Kåñëa and the gopés from the right source, lusty desire within the heart will be suppressed, and we will be able to develop devotional service. What we must understand is that Kåñëa is the only puruña, enjoyer. If we help Him in His enjoyment, we also receive enjoyment. We are predominated, and He is the predominator. On the material platform, if a husband wants to enjoy his wife, the wife must voluntarily help him in that enjoyment. By helping him, the wife also becomes an enjoyer. The predominator, the enjoyer, is Kåñëa, and the predominated, the enjoyed, are the living entities. Actually, both enjoy, but one enjoys as the predominated, and the other as the predominator. When the predominated helps the predominator, that is the perfection of enjoyment. We must admit that sex desire is present in everyone, both male and female, and from an impartial point of view, it appears that the male is the enjoyer and the female the enjoyed, but if the female agrees to be enjoyed, she naturally becomes the enjoyer. All living entities are described as prakåti, female. Kåñëa is puruña, male. When the living entities agree to help Kåñëa's sex desire, they become enjoyers.

Çyämasundara däsa: What is meant by Kåñëa's sex desire?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You might more correctly say "sense enjoyment." Kåñëa is the supreme proprietor of the senses, and when we help Kåñëa in His sense enjoyment, we also naturally partake of it. The sweet rasagulla is to be enjoyed, and therefore the hand takes it and puts it into the mouth so that it can be tasted and go to the stomach. It is not that the hand tries to enjoy it directly. Kåñëa is the only direct enjoyer; all others are indirect enjoyers. By satisfying Kåñëa, we also satisfy others. We cannot possibly satisfy others directly. For instance, when a wife sees her husband eating and enjoying himself, she becomes happy. Upon seeing the predominator happy, the predominated becomes happy.

Çyämasundara däsa: In the individual, should the unconscious state be predominated by the conscious?

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is being done. Unconscious or subconscious states sometimes emerge; we are not always aware of them. But consciousness is always there. Actually, the word "unconscious" is not a good word because it implies a lack of consciousness. "Subconscious" is a better word.

Çyämasundara däsa: Psychologists say that the unconscious or subconscious often acts through the conscious, but that we do not know it.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is what I am saying. The subconscious is there, but it is not always manifest. Sometimes it is suddenly manifest, just as a bubble will suddenly emerge in a pond. The energy was there within all the time, but suddenly it comes out, just like a bubble popping to the surface of the water. You may not be able to understand why it emerges, but it is assumed that it was in the subconscious state and then suddenly manifests. That subconscious state does not necessarily have any connection with our present consciousness. It is like a stored impression, a shadow, or a photograph. The mind takes many snapshots, and they are stored.

Çyämasundara däsa: Does the subconscious mind think like the conscious mind?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, but the impressions are there, and they may suddenly come to the surface.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Jung, there are two types of subconscious states. One is the personal unconscious, consisting of those personal items stored from our individual childhood, a repressed history of stored impressions that can be aroused to consciousness in dreams and through psychoanalysis. The second is what Jung calls the collective unconscious, consisting of the collective experience of the race, archetypal images passed on from generation to generation, and common to men all over the globe.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, we might even call that tradition. Of course, we emphasize paramparä, which is different. Paramparä means receiving proper knowledge from the Supreme. This is not something archetypal. Archetypes may change, but the knowledge received from Kåñëa is different. Spiritual knowledge imparted in Bhagavad-gétä is not knowledge coming from tradition. Rather, we learn it from a great authority like Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung could see that the soul is always longing for light, and he wrote of the urge within the soul to rise out of primal darkness, making note of the pent-up feelings in the eyes of primitive people, and even a certain sadness in the eyes of animals, "a poignant message which speaks to us out of that existence."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, every living entity, including man, is constitutionally a servant. Therefore everyone is seeking some master, and that is our natural propensity. You can often see a puppy attempt to take shelter of some boy or man, and that is his natural tendency. He is saying, "Give me shelter. Keep me as your friend." A child or a man also wants some shelter in order to be happy. That is our constitutional position. When we attain the human form, when our consciousness is developed, we should take Kåñëa as our shelter and our leader. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells us that if we want shelter and guidance, we should take Him. "Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender to Me." (Bg. 18.66) This is the ultimate instruction of Bhagavad-gétä.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung would say that our understanding of Kåñëa as the Supreme Father and the cause of all causes is an archetypal understanding that is shared by all humans. People may represent Him in different ways, but the archetype is the same.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, it is exactly the same. Kåñëa, or God, is the Supreme Father. A father has many sons, and all men are sons of God, born of their father. This is an experience common to everyone at all times.

Çyämasundara däsa: There are certain common archetypes in the dream life of all men, and even similar symbols found among the Incas of South America, or the Vaiñëavas of India, or inhabitants of the Pacific Islands. Could this be due to a common ancestry in the original Vedic culture?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Vedic culture or no Vedic culture, there are many similarities experienced in human existence. Because we are all living beings, the similarities are there. Every living being eats, sleeps, mates, fears, and dies. These are experiences common to everyone; therefore there must be similarities in representations, or whatever.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung believes that the unconscious sometimes emerges in the form of a superiority or inferiority complex, by which we react in inhibited or arrogant fashions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: What are we? Inferior or superior? In Kåñëa consciousness, we consider ourselves servants of God. We are not guided by impulses or complexes; we are guided directly by the superior.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung states that there are two basic attitudes: extrovertive and introvertive.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The introvert is called a muni because he is introspective. The extrovert is generally guided by rajas, the mode of passion.

Çyämasundara däsa: The personality and behavior of a living entity are determined by the interaction between the unconscious and the conscious mind.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Full consciousness in Sanskrit is called jägaraëam. Dreaming is called svapnaù, and suñuptiù refers to no consciousness, as in an anesthetized state.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung would call the dreaming state the unconscious also. The contents of the unconscious spill over into the conscious mind during dreams.

Çréla Prabhupäda: I do not like the word "unconscious" because it implies lack of consciousness. When you are anesthetized, you are unconscious. In such a state, you can be cut open and not even know it. However, when you sleep or dream, a mere pinch will awake you. As I said before, "subconscious" is a better word.

Çyämasundara däsa: Both Jung and Freud used the word "unconscious" to refer to the subconscious mind that determines our personality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When the living entity is in the womb of the mother, he is unconscious. Death means remaining unconscious for seven or nine months. The living entity does not die; he simply remains unconscious for that duration. That is called suñuptiù. When you have an operation, an anesthetic is administered, and you are unconscious for a period. When the anesthetic wears off, you emerge into the dream state. That dream state is actually a state of consciousness. When you dream, the mind works.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung believes that if we don't awaken to the many unconscious factors governing our personality, we will remain slaves to our unconscious life. The point of psychoanalysis is to reveal them to us and enable us to face them.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is what we are teaching. We say that presently the soul is in an unconscious state, and we are telling the soul, "Please wake up! You are not this body!" It is possible to awaken the human being, but other living entities cannot be awakened. A tree, for instance, has consciousness, but he is so packed in matter that you cannot raise him to Kåñëa consciousness. Jagadish Candra Bose proved that a tree feels pain when it is cut, although this pain is very slightly manifest. A human being, on the other hand, has developed consciousness, which is manifest in different stages. Lower life forms are more or less in a dream state, or unconscious.

Hayagréva däsa: In his autobiography, Memories, Dreams, Reflections, Jung writes: "I find that all my thoughts circle around God like the planets around the sun, and are as irresistibly attracted by Him. I would feel it to be the grossest sin if I were to oppose any resistance to this force." Jung also sees all creatures as parts of God, and at the same time unique in themselves. "Like every other being," he writes, "I am a splinter of the infinite Deity...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is also our philosophy that we are part and parcel of God, just as sparks are part of a fire.

Hayagréva däsa: "It was obedience which brought me grace," he writes. "One must be utterly abandoned to God; nothing matters but fulfilling His will. Otherwise all is folly and meaningless."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Very good. Surrender unto God is real spiritual life. Sarva dharmän parityajya (Bg. 18.66). Surrender to God means accepting that which is favorable to God and rejecting that which is unfavorable. The devotee is always convinced that God will give him all protection. He remains humble and meek, and thinks of himself as one of the members of God's family. This is real spiritual communism. Communists think, "I am a member of a certain community," but it is man's duty to think, "I am a member of God's family." God is the Supreme Father, material nature is the mother, and living entities are all sons of God.

There are living entities everywhere: on land, and in the air, and water. There is no doubt that material nature is the mother, and according to our experience, we can understand that a mother cannot produce a child without a father. It is absurd to think that a child can be born without a father. A father must be there, and the Supreme Father is God. In Kåñëa consciousness, a person understands that the creation is a spiritual family headed by one Supreme Father.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung writes: "According to the Bible. ..God has a personality and is the ego of the universe, just as I myself am the ego of my psychic and physical being."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, the individual is conscious of his own body, but not the bodies of others. Beside the individual soul, or consciousness in the body, there is the Paramätmä, the Supersoul, the super consciousness present in everyone's heart. This is discussed in Bhagavad-gétä:

kñetrajïaà cäpi mäà viddhi
sarva-kñetreñu bhärata
kñetra-kñetrajïayor jïänaà
yat taj jïänaà mataà mama

"O scion of Bharata, you should understand that I am also the knower in all bodies, and to understand this body and its owner is called knowledge. That is My opinion. " (Bg. 13.3)

Hayagréva däsa: Recalling his difficulties in understanding God's personality, Jung writes: "Personality, after all, surely signifies character...certain specific attributes. But if God is everything, how can He still possess a distinguishable character...? Moreover, what kind of character or what kind of personality does He have? Everything depends on that, for unless one knows the answer, one cannot establish a relationship with Him."

Çréla Prabhupäda: God's character is transcendental, not material. He also has many attributes. For instance, He is very kind to His devotees, and this kindness may be considered one of His characteristics or attributes. He also has unlimited qualities, and sometimes He is described according to these transcendental qualities. His qualities, however, are permanent. Whatever qualities or characteristics we have are but minute manifestations of God's. God is the origin of all attributes and characteristics. As indicated in the çästras, He also has a mind, senses, feelings, sense perception, sense gratification, and everything else. Everything is there unlimitedly, and since we are part and parcel of God, we possess His qualities in minute quantities. The original qualities in God are manifest minutely in ourselves. According to the Vedas, God is a person just like us, but His personality is unlimited. Just as my consciousness is limited to this body, and His consciousness is super consciousness within everybody, so I am a person confined to this particular body, and He is the super person living within all. As Kåñëa tells Arjuna in Bhagavad-gétä, the personality of God and that of the individual are eternally existing.

na tv evähaà jätu näsaà
na tvaà neme janädhipäù
na caiva na bhaviñyämaù
sarve vayam ataù param

"Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings; nor in the future shall any of us cease to be." (Bg. 2.12) Both God and the living entity are persons, but God's personality is unlimited, and the individual personality is limited. God has unlimited power, strength, influence, knowledge, beauty, and renunciation. We have limited, finite power, knowledge, influence, and so on. That is the difference between the two personalities.

Hayagréva däsa: Seeing that philosophies and theologies could not give him a clear picture of God's personality, Jung concludes: "What is wrong with these philosophers? I wondered. Evidently they know of God only by hearsay."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is also our complaint. None of the philosophers we have discussed has given us any clear idea of God. Because they are speculating, they cannot give concrete, clear information. As far as we are concerned, our understanding of God is clear because we receive the information given by God Himself to the world. Kåñëa is accepted as the Supreme Person by Vedic authorities; therefore we should have no reason not to accept Him as such. Näräyaëa, Lord Çiva, and Lord Brahmä possess different percentages of God's attributes, but Kåñëa possesses all the attributes cent per cent, in totality. Rüpa Gosvämé has analyzed this in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, which we have translated as The Nectar of Devotion. God is a person, and if we study the attributes of man, we can also know something of God's. Just as we enjoy ourselves with friends, parents, and others, God also enjoys Himself in various relationships. There are five primary and seven secondary relationships that the living entities can have with God. Since we take pleasure in these relationships, God is described as akhila-rasämåta-sindhu, the reservoir of all pleasure. There is no need to speculate about God, or try to imagine Him. The process for understanding is described in Bhagavad-gétä:

mayy äsakta-manäù pärtha
yogaà yuïjan mad-äçrayaù
asaàçayaà samagraà mäà
yathä jïäsyasi tac chåëu

"Now hear, O son of Påthä, how by practicing yoga in full consciousness of Me, with mind attached to Me, you can know Me in full, free from doubt." (Bg. 7.1) You can learn about God by always keeping yourself under His protection, or under the protection of His representative. Then, without a doubt, you can perfectly understand God. Otherwise, there is no question of understanding Him.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung continues: "At least they (the theologians) are sure that God exists, even though they make contradictory statements about Him....God's existence does not depend on our proofs....I understand that God was, for me at least, one of the most certain and immediate of experiences."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a transcendental conviction. One may not know God, but it is very easy to understand that God is there. We have to learn about God's nature, but there is no doubt that God is there. Any sane man can understand that he is being controlled. So, who is that controller? The supreme controller is God. This is the conclusion of a sane man. Jung is right when he says that God's existence does not depend on our proof.

Hayagréva däsa: Recalling his early spiritual quests, Jung writes: "In my darkness...I could have wished for nothing better than a real, live guru, someone possessing superior knowledge and ability, who would have disentangled from me the involuntary creations of my imagination...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, according to Vedic instructions, we must have a guru in order to acquire perfect knowledge.

tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet
samit-päëiùçrotriyaà brahma-niñöham

"In order to learn the transcendental science, one must approach the bona fide spiritual master in disciplic succession, who is fixed in the Absolute Truth." (Muëòaka Upaniñad 1.2.12) The guru must factually be a representative of God. He must have seen and experienced God in fact, not simply in theory. We have to approach such a guru, and by service, surrender, and sincere inquiry, we can come to understand what is God. The Vedas inform us that a person can understand God when he has received a little mercy from His Lordship; otherwise, he may speculate for millions and millions of years. Bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti. "One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service." (Bg. 18.55) This process of bhakti includes çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù, hearing and chanting about Lord Viñëu and always remembering Him. Satataà kértayanto mäà (Bg. 9.14). The devotee is always glorifying the Lord. Çrémad-Bhägavatam says:

naivodvije para duratyaya-vaitaraëyäs
tvad-vérya-gäyana-mahämåta-magna-cittaù
çoce tato vimukha-cetasa indriyärtha-
mäyä-sukhäya bharam udvahato vimüòhän

"O best of the great personalities, I am not at all afraid of material existence, for wherever I stay I am fully absorbed in thoughts of Your glories and activities. My concern is only for the fools and rascals who are making elaborate plans for material happiness and maintaining their families, societies, and countries. I am simply concerned with love for them." (Bhäg. 7.9.43) The devotee's consciousness is always immersed in the ocean of the pastimes and unlimited activities of the Supreme Lord. That is transcendental bliss. The spiritual master trains his disciple to remain always in the ocean of God consciousness. One who works under the directions of the äcärya knows everything about God.

Hayagréva däsa: When in Calcutta in 1938, Jung met some celebrated gurus, but generally avoided so-called holymen. "I did so because I had to make do with my own truth," he writes, "not to accept from others what I could not attain on my own."

Çréla Prabhupäda: On the one hand, he says he wants a guru, and then on the other, he doesn't want to accept one. Doubtless, there are many cheating gurus in Calcutta, and Jung might have seen some bogus gurus he did not like. In any case, the principle of accepting a guru cannot be avoided. It is absolutely necessary.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning consciousness after death, Jung feels that the individual must pick up the level of consciousness which he left.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and therefore according to that consciousness, we have to accept a body. That is the process of the soul's transmigration. An ordinary person can see only the gross material body, but accompanying this body is the mind, intelligence, and ego. When the body is finished, these remain, although they cannot be seen. A foolish man thinks that everything is finished at death, but the soul carries the mind, intelligence, and ego—that is, the subtle body—with it into another body. This is confirmed by Bhagavad-gétä: na hanyate hanyamäne çarére. "He is not slain when the body is slain." (Bg. 2.20)

Hayagréva däsa: Jung believes that individual consciousness cannot supersede world consciousness. He writes: "If there were to be a conscious existence after death, it would, so it seems to me, have to continue on the level of consciousness attained by humanity, which in any age has an upper thought variable limit."

Çréla Prabhupäda: It is clearly explained in Bhagavad-gétä that although the body is destroyed, the consciousness continues. According to one's consciousness, he acquires another body, and again in that body, the consciousness begins to mold its future lives. If a person were a devotee in his past life, he would again become a devotee after his death. Once the material body is destroyed, the same consciousness begins to work in another body. Consequently, we find that some people quickly accept Kåñëa consciousness, whereas others take a longer time. Bahünäà janmanäm ante (Bg. 7.19) This indicates that the consciousness is continuing, although the body is changing. Bharata Mahäräja, for instance, changed many bodies, but his consciousness continued, and he remained fully Kåñëa conscious. We may see a person daily, but we cannot visualize his intelligence. We can understand that a person is intelligent, but we cannot see intelligence itself. When one talks, we can understand that there is intelligence at work. When the gross body is dead and no longer capable of talking, why should we conclude that the intelligence is finished? The instrument for speech is the gross body, but when the body is finished, we should not conclude that consciousness and intelligence are finished. After the destruction of the gross body, the mind and intelligence continue. Because they require a body to function, they develop a body, and that is the process of the soul's transmigration.

Hayagréva däsa: Still, what of Jung's contention that the individual's level of consciousness cannot supersede whatever knowledge is available on this planet?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, it can supersede, provided we acquire knowledge from authority. You may not have seen India, but a person who has seen India can describe it to you. We may not be able to see Kåñëa, but we can learn of Him from an authority who knows. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa tells Arjuna that there is an eternal nature:

paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo
'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù
yaù sa sarveñu bhüteñu
naçyatsu na vinaçyati

"Yet there is another nature, which is eternal and is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is." (Bg. 8.20). On this earth, we encounter temporary nature. Here, things take birth, remain for some time, change, grow old, and are finally destroyed. There is dissolution in this material world, but there is another world in which there is no dissolution. We have no personal experience of this other world, but we can understand that it exists when we receive information from authority. It is not necessary to know it by personal experience. Parokñäparokña. There are different stages of knowledge, and not all knowledge can be acquired by direct perception. That is not possible.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung believed in the importance of consciousness elevation. He writes: "Only here, in life on earth, can the general level of consciousness be raised. That seems to be man's metaphysical task...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, our consciousness should be developed. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä:

präpya puëya-kåtäà lokän
uñitvä çäçvatéù samäù
çucénäàçrématäà gehe
yoga-bhrañöo 'bhijäyate

athavä yoginäm eva
kule bhavati dhématäm
etaddhi durlabhataraà
loke janma yad édåçam

tatra taà buddhi-saàyogaà
labhate paurva-dehikam
yatate ca tato bhüyaù
saàsiddhau kuru-nandana

"The unsuccessful yogé, after many, many years of enjoyment on the planets of the pious living entities, is born into a family of righteous people, or into a family of rich aristocracy. Or he takes his birth in a family of transcendentalists who are surely great in wisdom. Verily, such a birth is rare in this world. On taking such a birth, he again revives the divine consciousness of his previous life, and he tries to make further progress in order to achieve complete success." (Bg. 6.41-43)

So if one's yoga practice is incomplete, or if he dies prematurely, his consciousness accompanies him, and in the next life, he begins at the point where he left off. His intelligence is revived. In an ordinary class, we can see that some students learn very quickly, while others cannot understand. This is evidence for the continuation of consciousness. If a person is extraordinarily intelligent, his previously developed consciousness is being revived. The fact that we have undergone previous births is also evidence for the immortality of the soul.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung speaks of the paradox of death: from the point of view of the ego, death is a horrible catastrophe, "a fearful piece of brutality." Yet from the point of view of the psyche, the soul, death is "...a joyful event. In the light of eternity, it is a wedding."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, death is horrible for one who is going to accept a lower form of life, and it is a pleasure for the devotee, because he is returning home, back to Godhead.

Hayagréva däsa: Death is not always a joyful event for the soul?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No. How can it be? If one has not developed his spiritual consciousness, death is very horrible. The tendency in this life is to become very proud, and often people think, "I don't care for God. I am independent." Crazy people talk in this way, but after death, they have to accept a body according to the dictations of nature. Nature says, "My dear sir, since you have worked like a dog, you can become a dog. Since you have been surfing in the sea, you can now become a fish." These bodies are awarded according to a superior order.

karmaëä daiva-netreëa
jantur dehopapattaye
striyäù praviñöa udaraà
puàso retaù-kaëäçrayaù

"Under the supervision of the Supreme Lord and according to the result of his work, the living entity, the soul, is made to enter into the womb of a woman through the particle of male semina and to assume a particular type of body." (Bhäg. 3.31.1) When we are in touch with the modes of material nature, we are creating our next body. How can we stop this process? This is nature's way. If we are infected by some disease, we will necessarily get that disease. There are three modes of material nature—tamo-guëa, rajo-guëa, and sattva-guëa—and our bodies are acquired according to our association with them. As far as the unsuccessful yogé is concerned, he is given a chance to revive his spiritual consciousness in his next life. In general, the human form affords us a chance to make progress in Kåñëa consciousness, especially when we are born in an aristocratic, brähmaëa, or Vaiñëava family.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning saàsära, Jung writes: "The succession of birth and death is viewed [in Indian philosophy] as an endless continuity, as an eternal wheel rolling on forever without a goal. Man lives and attains knowledge and dies and begins again from the beginning. Only with the Buddha does the idea of a goal emerge, namely, the overcoming of earthly existence."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Overcoming earthly existence means entering into the spiritual world. The spirit soul is eternal, and it can pass from this atmosphere into another. That is clearly explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna." (Bg. 4.9) Those who continue to revolve in the cycle of birth and death require another material body, but those who are Kåñëa conscious go to Kåñëa. They do not acquire another material body. Those who are not envious of Kåñëa accept His instructions, surrender unto Him, and understand Him. For them, this is the last material birth. For those who are envious, however, transmigration is continuous.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning karma, Jung writes: "The crucial question is whether a man's karma is personal or not. If it is, then the preordained destiny with which a man enters life presents an achievement of previous lives, and a personal continuity therefore exists. If, however, this is not so, and an impersonal karma is seized upon in the act of birth, then that karma is incarnated again without there being any personal continuity."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Karma is always personal.

Hayagréva däsa: When Buddha was asked whether karma is personal or not, he avoided answering. He said that knowing this would not contribute to liberation from the illusion of existence.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Buddha refused to answer because he did not teach about the soul or accept the personal soul. As soon as you deny the personal aspect of the soul, there is no question of a personal karma. Buddha wanted to avoid this question. He did not want his whole philosophy dismantled.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung asks, "Have I lived before in the past as a specific personality, and did I progress so far in that life that I am now able to seek a solution?"

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is a fact.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung admits that he doesn't know.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

tatra taà buddhi-saàyogaà
labhate paurva-dehikam
yatate ca tato bhüyaù
saàsiddhau kuru-nandana

"On taking such a birth, he again revives the divine consciousness of his previous life, and he again tries to make further progress in order to achieve complete success, O son of Kuru." (Bg. 6.43)

Hayagréva däsa: "I could well imagine that I might have lived in former centuries and there encountered questions I was not yet able to answer," Jung writes. "I had to be born again because I had not fulfilled the task that was given to me."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is a fact.

Hayagréva däsa: "When I die, my deeds will follow along with me—that is how I imagine it."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is personal karma.

Hayagréva däsa: "I will bring with me what I have done," Jung concludes. "In the meantime it is important to insure that I do not stand at the end with empty hands."

Çréla Prabhupäda: If you are making regular progress in Kåñëa consciousness, your hands will not be empty at the end. Completeness means returning home, back to Godhead. This return is not empty. Because the Mäyävädés cannot understand the positivity of God's kingdom, they try to make it empty. Eternal life with Kåñëa is our aspiration. A Vaiñëava does not want emptiness. Since materialists are thinking that everything will be empty at the end of life, they conclude that they should enjoy themselves now as much as possible. Therefore sense enjoyment is at the core of material life, and materialists are mad after it.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung believes that we are reborn because we relapse again into desires, feeling that something remains to be completed. "In my case," he writes, "it must have been primarily a passionate urge toward understanding....for that was the strongest element in my nature. "

Çréla Prabhupäda: That understanding for which he is longing is understanding of Kåñëa. That is explained in Bhagavad-gétä:

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." (Bg. 7.19) Our understanding is complete when we come to the point of understanding Kåñëa. Then our material journey comes to an end. Tyaktvä dehaà punar janma naiti mäm eti so'rjuna. "Upon leaving the body, he does not take birth again into this material world, but attains My eternal abode." (Bg. 4.9) Lord Kåñëa Himself gives instructions by which He can be understood.

mayy äsakta-manäù pärtha
yogaà yuïjan mad-äçrayaù
asaàçayaà samagraà mäà
yathä jïäsyasi tac chåëu

"Now hear, O son of Påthä, how by practicing yoga in full consciousness of Me, with mind attached to Me, you can know Me in full, free from doubt." (Bg. 7.1) If we can understand Kåñëa completely, we will take our next birth in the spiritual world.

Hayagréva däsa: Concerning scripture, Jung writes: "The word of God comes to us, and we have no way of distinguishing to what extent it is different from God."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The word of God is not at all different from God. Since God is absolute, both He and His words are the same. God's name and God are the same. God's pastimes and God are the same. God's Deity and God are the same. Anything related to God is God. For instance, Bhagavad-gétä is God. Mayä tatam idam sarvaà (Bg. 9.4). Everything is God, and when we are complete in God realization, we can understand this. Otherwise we cannot. Everything is God, and without God, nothing can exist.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung conceived of the false ego in terms of persona. "The persona" he writes, "is the individual's system of adaptation to, or the manner he assumes in dealing with, the world....The persona is that which in reality one is not, but which oneself as well as others think one is.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Our real persona is that we are eternal servants of God. When we realize this, our persona becomes our salvation and perfection. The person must be there, but as long as we are in the material world, our persona identifies with our family, community, body, nation, ideal, and so on. The person is there and must continue, but proper understanding is realizing that we are eternal servants of Kåñëa. As long as we are in the material world, we labor under the delusion of the false ego, thinking, "I am American. I am Russian. I am Hindu, etc." This is false ego at work. In reality, we are all servants of God. When we speak of false ego, we also admit a real ego, a purified ego, who understands that he is the servant of Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung envisioned the self as a personality composed of the conscious and also the subconscious. He writes: 'The self is not only the center but also the whole circumference which embraces both conscious and unconscious."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Everything depends on the personality, and it is the personality that is surrounded by so many conceptions. In conditional life, we may have many different types of dreams, but when we are purified—like Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu—we dream of Kåñëa's pastimes. In the purified state, we dream about Kåñëa and His activities and instructions.

Hayagréva däsa: Although the self can never be fully known by the individual, it does have individuality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We can know that we are individual persons with our own ideas and activities. The problem is purifying our ideas and activities. When we understand our role as servants of Kåñëa, we are purified.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Jung, the purpose of psychoanalysis is to come to grips with our unconscious shadow personality in order to know completely who we are.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That means attaining real knowledge. When Sanätana Gosvämé approached Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, he said, "Please reveal to me who and what I am." In order to understand our real identity, we require the assistance of a guru.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung says that in the shadow personality of all males, there is a bit of the female, and in all females there is a bit of the male. Because we repress these aspects of the shadow personality, we do not understand our actions.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that every living entity is by nature a female, prakåti. Prakåti means female, and puruña means male. In this material world, although we are prakåti, we are posing ourselves as puruña. Because the jévätmä, the individual soul, has the propensity to enjoy as a male, he is sometimes described as puruña, but actually the jévätmä is not puruña. He is prakåti. As I said before, prakåti means dominated, and puruña means predominator. The only predominator is Kåñëa; therefore originally we are all female by constitution.

Çyämasundara däsa: In the male species, at any rate, the temperament is different, isn't it? There is dominance and aggression.

Çréla Prabhupäda: There is no different temperament. We can see that the female also has the same temperament because she wants to be treated equally, just like a man. In any case, the real position is that every living entity is originally female, but under illusion he attempts to become a male, an enjoyer. This is called mäyä. Although a female by constitution, the living entity is trying to imitate the supreme male, Kåñëa. When we come to our original consciousness, we understand that we are not the predominator but the predominated.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung noticed male and female characteristics reflected in nature. For instance, a mountain may be considered male because it is strong and dominant, whereas the sea is female because it is passive and is the womb of life.

Çréla Prabhupäda: These are all mental concoctions. They have no real scientific value. You may imagine things like this, but the real identity of these things is different. Life is not generated from the ocean; rather, everything is generated from the breathing of Lord Viñëu, who lies in the causal ocean. If I am lying on this bed, and something emanates from my breathing, does this mean that something is emanating from the bed?

Çyämasundara däsa: But aren't there specific male and female characteristics?

Çréla Prabhupäda: The only male is God. Male means enjoyer, and female means enjoyed. But for God, no one is the enjoyer. Therefore He is the only male.

Çyämasundara däsa: Then is it false to think of anything as masculine besides God?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Masculine is different. We speak of the masculine gender. The liìga is the symbol of masculinity in the material body. In Bengali, it is said that one can tell if an animal is male or female simply by raising its tail. But these are material considerations. The real male is Kåñëa.

Çyämasundara däsa: But couldn't you refer to the ocean as "mother ocean"?

Çréla Prabhupäda: You may in the sense that the ocean contains so many living entities, just as the female contains a child within her womb. Or you may speak of a mountain as being male because of its strength and durability. In that sense, you may make these comparisons, but you should not think that these are the real identities of these things.

Çyämasundara däsa: For Jung, the soul, or self, is the center of organization within the personality, and seeks a harmonious balance between the conscious and the unconscious.

Çréla Prabhupäda: When we speak of personality, we must admit the existence of the soul. Because you are a living entity, you have a separate identity called personality. Unless there is an individual soul, there is no possibility of personality.

Çyämasundara däsa: Jung said that the self is rarely completely balanced. But don't we say that the self is always stable?

Çréla Prabhupäda: No, when the self is under the influence of mäyä, he is not balanced. He is imbalanced and ignorant. His true consciousness is covered. When rain falls from the sky, it is clear, but as soon as it touches the earth, it becomes muddy. Originally, the soul's consciousness is clear, but when it comes in contact with the three modes of material nature, it is muddied.

Hayagréva däsa: "If the soul is anything," Jung writes, "it must be of unimaginable complexity and diversity, so that it cannot possibly be approached through a mere psychology of instinct."

Çréla Prabhupäda: According to Caitanya Mahäprabhu, we can understand the soul through training. By negation, we can understand, "I am not this, I am not that." Then we can come to understand.

nähaà vipro na ca nara-patir näpi vaiçyo na çüdro
nähaà varëé na ca gåha-patir no vanastho yatir vä
kintu prodyan-nikhila-paramänanda-pürnämåtäbdher
gopé-bhartuù pada-kamalayor däsa-däsänudäsaù

"I am not a brähmaëa, I am not a kñatriya, I am not a vaiçya or a çüdra. Nor am I a brahmacäré, a householder, a vänaprastha, or a sannyäsé. I identify Myself only as the servant of the servant of the servant of the lotus feet of Lord Çré Kåñëa, the maintainer of the gopés. He is like an ocean of nectar, and He is the cause of universal transcendental bliss. He is always existing with brilliance." (Caitanya-caritämåta, Madh. 13.80) That is our real identification. As long as we do not identify ourselves as eternal servants of Kåñëa, we will be subject to various false identifications. Bhakti, devotional service, is the means by which we can be purified of false identification.

Hayagréva däsa: "I can only gaze with wonder and awe at the depths and heights of our psychic nature," Jung writes. "Its non-spatial universe conceals an untold abundance of images which have accumulated over millions of years of living development and become fixed in the organism."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Since we are constantly changing bodies, constantly undergoing transmigration, we are accumulating various experiences. However, if we remain fixed in Kåñëa consciousness, we do not change. There is none of this fluctuation once we understand our real identification, which is, "I am the servant of Kåñëa, and my duty is to serve Him." Arjuna realized this after hearing Bhagavad-gétä, and he told Çré Kåñëa:

nañöo mohaù småtir labdhä
tvat-prasädän mayäcyuta
sthito 'smi gata-sandehaù
kariñye vacanaà tava

"My dear Kåñëa, O infallible one, my illusion is now gone. I have regained my memory by Your mercy, and I am now firm and free from doubt and am prepared to act according to Your instructions." (Bg. 18.73) So after hearing Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna comes to this conclusion, and his illusion is dispelled by Kåñëa's mercy. Arjuna is then fixed in his original position. And what is this? Kariñye vacanaà tava. "Whatever you say, I will do." At the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa told Arjuna to fight, and Arjuna refused. At the conclusion, Arjuna's illusion is dispelled, and he is situated in his original constitutional position. Thus our perfection lies in executing the orders of Kåñëa.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung classifies five types of rebirth. One is metempsychosis, by which "...one's life is prolonged in time by passing through different bodily existences; or, from another point of view, it is a life-sequence interrupted by different reincarnations....It is by no means certain whether continuity of personality is guaranteed or not: there may be only a continuity of karma."

Çréla Prabhupäda: A personality is always there, and bodily changes do not affect it. However, one identifies himself according to his body. When the soul, for instance, is within the body of a dog, he thinks according to that particular bodily conception. He thinks, "I am a dog, and I have my particular duty." In human society, when one is born in America, for instance, he thinks, "I am an American, and I have my duty." According to the body, the personality is manifest, but in all cases, personality is there.

Hayagréva däsa: But is this personality continuous?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Certainly the personality is continuous. At death, the same soul passes into another gross body, along with its mental and intellectual identifications. The individual acquires different types of bodies, but the person is the same.

Hayagréva däsa: This would correspond to what Jung calls reincarnation, the second type of rebirth: "This concept of rebirth necessarily implies the continuity of personality," he writes. "Here the human personality is regarded as continuous and accessible to memory, so that when one is incarnated or born, one is able, at least potentially, to remember that he has lived through previous existences and that these existences were one's own, i.e., that they had the same ego-form as the present life. As a rule, reincarnation means rebirth in a human body."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Not necessarily into a human body. From Çrémad-Bhägavatam, we learn that Bharata Mahäräja became a deer in his next life, and after being a deer, he became a brähmaëa. The soul is changing bodies just as a man changes his dress. The man is the same, although his dress may be different.

väsäàsi jérëäni yathä vihäya
naväni gåhëäti naro 'paräëi
tathä çaréräëi vihäya jérëäny
anyäni saàyäti naväni dehé

"As a person puts on new garments, giving up old ones, similarly, the soul accepts new material bodies, giving up the old and useless ones." (Bg. 2.22) When a dress is old and cannot be used anymore, one has to exchange it for another. In a sense, you purchase a new dress with the money, or karma, you have accumulated in your life. The man is the same, but his dress is supplied according to the price he can pay. According to your karma, you receive a certain type of body.

Hayagréva däsa: For Jung, the third type of rebirth, called resurrection, may be of two types: "It may be a carnal body, as in the Christian assumption that this body will be resurrected." That is, according to Christian doctrine, at the end of the world, the gross bodies will reassemble themselves and ascend into heaven, or descend into hell.

Çréla Prabhupäda: And what will the person do in the meantime?

Hayagréva däsa: I don't know. Obviously the material elements disperse.

Çréla Prabhupäda: The material body is finished, but the spiritual body is always there. This type of resurrection talked about is applicable to God and His representatives, not to all. In this case, it is not a material body, but a spiritual one. When God appears, He appears in a spiritual body, and this body does not change. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that He spoke to the sun god millions of years ago, and Arjuna questioned how this could be possible. Kåñëa replies that although Arjuna had been present, he could not remember. Remembrance is possible only if one does not change bodies. Changing bodies means forgetting.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung admits that on a higher level, the process is not material. "It is assumed that the resurrection of the dead is the raising up of the corpus gloriaficationis, the subtle body, in the state of incorruptibility."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is the spiritual body, which never changes. According to the Mäyävädé conception, the Absolute Truth is impersonal, and when He comes as a person, He accepts a material body. Those who are advanced in spiritual knowledge, who accept the Bhagavad-gétä, understand that this is not the case.

avajänanti mäà müòhä
mänuñéà tanum äçritam
paraà bhävam ajänanto
mama bhüta-maheçvaram

"Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and My supreme dominion over all that be." (Bg. 9.11) Because Kåñëa appears like a human being, the unintelligent think that He is nothing but a human being. They have no knowledge of the spiritual body.

Hayagréva däsa: The fourth form of rebirth is called renovatio, and this refers to "the transformation of a mortal into an immortal being, of a corporeal into a spiritual being, and of a human into a divine being." As an example, Jung cites the ascension of Christ into heaven.

Çréla Prabhupäda: We say that the spiritual body never dies, and the material body is subject to destruction. Näyaà hanti na hanyate (Bg. 2.19). After the material body's destruction, the "spiritual body is still there. It is neither generated nor killed.

Hayagréva däsa: But aren't there examples of a kind of ascension into heaven? Didn't Arjuna ascend?

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, and Yudhiñöhira. There are many instances. The special instance is Kåñëa Himself and His associates. But we should never consider their bodies material. They didn't go through death of any sort, although their bodies traveled to the higher universe. But it is also a fact that everyone possesses a spiritual body.

Hayagréva däsa: The fifth type of rebirth is indirect, like an initiation ceremony, or the twice-born ceremony of transformation. "Through his presence at the rite, the individual participates in divine grace."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, one's first birth is by his father and mother, and the next birth is by the spiritual master and Vedic knowledge. When one takes his second birth, he comes to understand that he is not the material body. That is spiritual education. That birth of knowledge, or birth into knowledge, is called dvijaù.

Hayagréva däsa: In one of his last books, The Undiscovered Self, Jung writes: "The meaning and purpose of religion lie in the relationship of the individual to God (Christianity, Judaism, Islam) or to the path of salvation and liberation (Buddhism). From this basic fact all ethics is derived, which without the individual's responsibility before God can be called nothing more than conventional morality."

Çréla Prabhupäda: First of all, we understand from Bhagavad-gétä that no one can approach God without being purified of all sinful reactions. Only one who is standing on the platform of pure goodness can understand God and engage in His service. From Arjuna, we understand that God is paraà brahma paraà dhäma pavitraà paramaà bhavän (Bg. 10.12). He is the Supreme Brahman, the ultimate, the supreme abode and purifier. Paraà-brahma indicates the Supreme Brahman. Every living being is Brahman spiritually, but Kåñëa is the Paraà-brahma, the Supreme Brahman. He is also paraà-dhäma, the ultimate abode of everything. And pavitraà paramaà, the purest of the pure. In order to approach the purest of the pure, one must become completely pure, and to this end, morality and ethics are necessary. Therefore in our Kåñëa consciousness movement, we prohibit illicit sex, meat eating, intoxication, and gambling, the four pillars of sinful life. If we can avoid these, we can remain on the platform of purity. Kåñëa consciousness is based on this morality, and one who cannot follow these principles falls down from the spiritual platform. Purity is the basic principle of God consciousness, and is essential for the reestablishment of our eternal relationship with God.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung sees atheistic Communism as the greatest threat in the world today. He writes: "The state has taken the place of God; that is why, seen from this angle, the socialist dictatorships are religions, and state slavery is a form of worship."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, I agree with him. Atheistic Communism has contributed to the degradation of human civilization. The Communists supposedly believe in the equal distribution of wealth. According to our understanding, God is the Father, material nature the mother, and living entities the sons. The sons have a right to live at the cost of the father. The entire universe is the property of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and living entities are being supported by the Supreme Father.

However, we should be satisfied with the supplies allotted to us. According to Éçopaniñad, tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä (Éçopaniñad 1). We should be satisfied with our allocation, and not envy another or encroach upon his property. We should not envy the capitalists or the wealthy because everyone is given his allotment by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore everyone should be satisfied with what he receives. On the other hand, no one should exploit others. One may be born in a wealthy family, but he should not interfere with the rights of others. Whether one is rich or poor, he should be God conscious, accept God's arrangement, and serve God to his fullest. This is the philosophy of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and it is confirmed by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. We should be content with our allocations from God, and concern ourselves with advancing in Kåñëa consciousness. If we become envious of the rich, we will be tempted to encroach upon their allotment, and in this way we are diverted from our service to the Lord. The main point is that everyone, rich or poor, should engage in God's service. If everyone does so, there will be real peace in the world.

Hayagréva däsa: In the socialist state, the goals of religion are turned into worldly promises of bread, "the just distribution of material goods, universal prosperity in the future, and shorter working hours."

Çréla Prabhupäda: This is because they have no understanding of spiritual life, nor can they understand that the person within the body is eternal and spiritual. Therefore they recommend immediate sense gratification.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung believed, however, that Marxism cannot possibly replace religion. "A natural function which has existed from the beginning... cannot be disposed of with rationalistic and so-called enlightened criticism."

Çréla Prabhupäda: The Communists are concerned with adjusting material things that can never be adjusted. They imagine that they can solve problems, but ultimately their plans will fail. The Communists do not understand what religion is. It is not possible to avoid religion. Everything has a particular characteristic. Salt is salty, sugar is sweet, and chili is hot and pungent. These are intrinsic characteristics. Similarly, the living entity has an intrinsic quality. His characteristic is to render service, be he a Communist, a theist, a capitalist, or whatever. In all countries, people are working and rendering service to their respective governments—be they capitalists or Communists—and the people are not profiting. Therefore we say that if people follow the footsteps of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu by serving Kåñëa, they will be happy. In the material world, people are rendering service, and they are not happy doing so because their service is actually meant for Kåñëa. Therefore, for the sake of happiness, people should individually and collectively render service to Kåñëa. When that service is misplaced, we are never happy. Both Communists and capitalists are saying, "Render service to me," but Kåñëa says, sarva-dharmän parityajya (Bg. 18.66). "Just render Me service, and I will free you from all sinful reactions."

Hayagréva däsa: Jung feels that materialistic capitalism cannot possibly defeat a pseudo-religion like Marxism. The only solution is to adopt a nonmaterialistic religion. "The antidote should in this case be an equally potent faith of a different and nonmaterialistic kind...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That religion is this Kåñëa consciousness movement. Kåñëa has nothing to do with any materialistic "ism," and this movement is directly connected with Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. God demands complete surrender, and we are teaching, "You are servants, but your service is being wrongly placed. Therefore you are not happy. Just render service to Kåñëa, and you will find happiness." We neither support Communism nor capitalism, nor do we advocate the adoption of pseudo religions. We are for Kåñëa only.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung laments the absence of a potent nonmaterialistic faith in the West that "could block the progress of a fanatical ideology" like Marxism. He sees mankind as desperately in need of a religion that has immediate meaning.

Çréla Prabhupäda: That nonmaterial religion which is above everything—Marxism and capitalism—is this Kåñëa consciousness movement. If we cultivate Kåñëa consciousness, we will transcend sinful reactions and make spiritual progress. Janma karma ca me divyam (Bg. 4.9). Kåñëa says that just by knowing of His transcendental appearance and pastimes, we will not take birth in this material world again.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung writes: "It is unfortunately only too clear that if the individual is not truly regenerated in spirit, society cannot be either, for society is the sum total of individuals in need of redemption."

Çréla Prabhupäda: True, the basis of change is the individual. Now there are a few disciples individually initiated into Kåñëa consciousness, and if a large percentage can thus become invigorated, the face of the world will change. There is no doubt of this.

Hayagréva däsa: For Jung, the salvation of the world consists in the salvation of the individual soul. "His individual relation to God would be an effective shield against these pernicious influences."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, those who seriously take to Kåñëa consciousness are never troubled by Marxism, this-ism, or that-ism. A Marxist may take to Kåñëa consciousness, but a Kåñëa conscious devotee would never become a Marxist. That is not possible. It is explained in Bhagavad-gétä that when one knows the highest perfection of life, he cannot be misled by a third or fourth-class philosophy.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung also felt that materialistic progress could be a possible enemy to the individual. "A favorable environment merely strengthens the dangerous tendency to expect everything to originate from outside," he writes, "even that metamorphosis which external reality cannot provide, mainly, a deep-seated change of the inner man...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes everything originates from inside, from the soul. It is confirmed by Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura and others that material progress is essentially an expansion of the external energy, mäyä, illusion. We are all living in illusion, and so-called scientists and philosophers cannot even understand God and their relationship to Him, despite their material advancement. Material advancement and knowledge are actually hindrances to the progressive march of Kåñëa consciousness. To live a saintly life, we minimize our necessities. We are not after luxurious living. We feel that life is meant for spiritual progress and Kåñëa consciousness, not for material advancement.

Hayagréva däsa: To inspire this deep-seated change in the inner man, Jung feels that a proper teacher is needed, someone to explain religion.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, according to the Vedic injunction, it is essential to seek out a guru, who, by definition, is a representative of God. Säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästrair (Çré Gurv-añöaka 7). The representative of God is worshipped as God, but he never says, "I am God." Although he is worshipped as God, he is the servant of God. God Himself is always master. Caitanya Mahäprabhu requested everyone to become a guru. "Whatever you are, it doesn't matter. Simply become a guru and deliver all these people who are in ignorance." One may say, "I am not very learned. How can I become a guru?" Caitanya Mahäprabhu said that it is not necessary to be a learned scholar, for there are many so-called learned scholars who are fools. It is only necessary to impart Kåñëa's instructions, which are already there in Bhagavad-gétä. Whoever explains Bhagavad-gétä as it is is a guru by definition. If one is fortunate enough to approach such a guru, his life becomes successful.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung points out that "our philosophy is no longer a way of life, as it was in antiquity; it has turned into an exclusively intellectual and academic affair."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is also our opinion. Mental speculation has no value in itself. We must be directly in touch with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and, using all reason, assimilate the instructions given by Him. We can then follow these instructions in our daily life and do good to others by teaching Bhagavad-gétä.

Hayagréva däsa: He sees on the one hand an exclusively intellectual philosophy, and on the other, denominational religions with "archaic rites and conceptions," which have "become strange and unintelligible to the man of today...."

Çréla Prabhupäda: That is because preachers of religion are simply dogmatic. They have no clear idea of God; they make only official proclamations. When one does not understand, he cannot make others understand. But there is no such vanity in Kåñëa consciousness, which is clear in every respect. This is the expected movement Mr. Jung wanted. Every sane man should cooperate with this movement and liberate human society from the gross darkness of ignorance.

Hayagréva däsa: He describes the truly religious man as one "who is accustomed to the thought of not being sole master of his own house. He believes that God, and not he himself, decides in the end."

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, that is the natural situation. What decisions can we make? Since there is already a controller over us, how can we be absolute? Everyone should depend on the supreme controller and fully surrender to Him.

Hayagréva däsa: Jung feels that modern man should ask himself, "Have I any religious experience and immediate relation to God, and hence that certainty which will keep me, as an individual, from dissolving in the crowd?" Our relationship with God ultimately assures our own individuality.

Çréla Prabhupäda: Yes, all living entities are individuals, and God is the supreme individual. According to the Vedic version, all individuals are subordinate to Him. Nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm (Kaöha-upaniñad 2.2.13). The supreme individual is one, and the subordinate are many. The supreme individual is maintaining His subordinates, just as a father maintains his family. When the children learn to enjoy their father's property without encroaching upon one another, accepting what is allotted them, they will attain peace.

Hayagréva däsa: That ends our session on Jung.

Çréla Prabhupäda: So far, he seems the most sensible.

GLOSSARY

(A note on Sanskrit Pronunciation:

GLOSSARY

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Çré Brahma-saàhitä

Bs Introduction

Introduction

The origins of the text known as Brahma-samhita are lost in cosmic antiquity. According to Vedic tradition, these "Hymns of Brahma" were recited or sung countless millennia ago by the first created being in the universe, just prior to the act of creation. The text surfaced and entered calculable history early in the sixteenth century when it was discovered by a pilgrim exploring the manuscript library of an ancient temple in what is now Kerala state in South India. Prior to the introduction of the printing press, texts like Brahma-samhita existed only in manuscript form, painstakingly handwritten by scribes and kept under brahminical custodianship in temples, where often they were worshiped as sastra-Deity, or God incarnate in holy scripture.

The pilgrim who rescued Brahma-samhita from obscurity was no ordinary pilgrim, and His pilgrimage was not meant, as is the custom, for self-purification but for world-purification. He was Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu-saint, mystic, religious reformer, and full incarnation of the Supreme Lord, Sri Krsna, descending into the present epoch for the salvation of all souls. At the time of His discovery of the text, Sri Caitanya was touring South India, preaching His message of love of Krsna and promulgating the practice of sankirtana, congregational singing of the holy names of God. Sri Caitanya commenced this tour shortly after becoming a monk (sannyasi), at age twenty four, and the tour lasted approximately two years. After a southward journey from Puri (in Orissa State) that carried Him to holy places such as Sri Ranga-ksetra, Setubandha Ramesvara, and finally Kanyakumari (Cape Comorin), he turned northward and, traveling along the bank of the Payasvini River in Travancore state, reaches the temple of Adi-kesava, in Trivandrum district.

Sri Caitanya's principal biographer, Krsnadasa Kaviraja Gosvami, writes in Caitanya-caritamrta (Madhya-lila, Ch. 9) that upon beholding the holy image of Adi-kesava (Krsna) in the temple, Caitanya was overwhelmed with spiritual ecstasy, offered fervent prayers, and chanted and danced in rapture, a wondrous sight that was received with astonished appreciation by the devotees there. After discussing esoteric spiritual matters among some highly advanced devotees present, Sri Caitanya found "one chapter of the Brahma-samhita" (what we now have as Brahma-samhita is, according to tradition, only one of a hundred chapters composing an epic work lost to humanity). Upon discovering the manuscript, Sri Caitanya felt great ecstasy and fell into an intense mystic rapture that overflowed onto the physical realm, producing a profusion of tears, trembling and perspiration. (We would search the literature of the world in vain to find a case in which the discovery of a lost book inspired such unearthly exhilaration!) Intuiting the Brahma-samhita to be a "most valuable jewel," He employed a scribe in hand-copying the manuscript and departed with the copy for His return journey to the north.

Upon His return to Puri (Madhya-lila, Ch. 11), Sri Caitanya presented Brahma-samhita to appreciative followers like Ramananda Raya and Vasudeva Datta, for whom Caitanya arranged copies to be made. As word of the discovery of the text spread within the Vaisnava community, "each and every Vaisnava" copied it. Gradually, Brahma-samhita was "broadcast everywhere" and became one of the major texts of the Gaudiya-Vaisnava canon. "There is no scripture equal to the Brahma-samhita as far as the final spiritual conclusion is concerned," exults Krsnadasa Kaviraja. "Indeed, that scripture is the supreme revelation of the glories of Lord Govinda, for it reveals the topmost knowledge about Him. Since all conclusions are briefly presented in Brahma-samhita, it is essential among all the Vaisnava literatures." (Madhya-lila 9.239-240)

Now, what of the text itself? What are its contents? A synopsis of the Brahma-samhiti is provided by Srila Prabhupada, founder-acarya of the Krsna consciousness movement, in his commentary to the Caytanya-caritamrta. It is quoted here in full:

In [Brahma-samhita], the philosophical conclusion of acintya-bhedabheda-tattva (simultaneous oneness and difference) is presented. [It] also presents methods of devotional service, the eighteen-syllable Vedic hymn, discourses on the soul, the Supersoul and fruitive activity, an explanation of kama-gayatri, kama-bija and the original Maha-Visnu, and a specific description of the spiritual world, specifically Goloka Vrndavana. Brahma-samhita also explains the demigod Ganesa, the Garbhodakasayi Visnu, the origin of the Gayatri mantra, the form of Govinda and His transcendental position and abode, the living entities, the highest goal, the goddess Durga, the meaning of austerity, the five gross elements, love at Godhead, impersonal Brahman, the initiation of Lord Brahma, and the vision of transcendental love enabling one to see the Lord. The steps of devotional service are also explained. The mind, yoga-nidra, the goddess of fortune, devotional service in spontaneous ecstasy, incarnations beginning with Lord Ramacandra. Deities, the conditioned soul and its duties, the truth about Lord Visnu, prayers, Vedic hymns, Lord Siva, Vedic literature. personalism and impersonalism, good behavior and many other subjects are also discussed. There is also a description of the sun and the universal forms of the Lord. All these subjects are conclusively explained in a nutshell in this Brahma-samhita. (Madhya-lila, Vol. 4, p. 37)

In spite of the seeming topical complexity of the text, the essential core of the Brahma-samhita consists of a brief description of the enlightenment of Lord Brahma by Lord Sri Krsna, followed by Brahma's extraordinarily beautiful prayers elucidating the content of his revelation: an earthly,beatific vision of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Sri Krsna, and His eternal, transcendental abode, Goloka Vrndavana, beyond the material cosmos. This core of the text stretches through verse twenty-nine to fifty-six, and a brief, subsequent exposition by Lord Krsna on the path of krsna-bhakti, love of God, brings the text to a close.

The Brahma-samhita's account of Brahma's enlightenment is quite interesting and can be summarized here. When Lord Vishnu (Garbhodakasayi Vishnu) desires to recreate the universe, a divine golden lotus flower grows from His navel, and Brahma is born from this lotus. As he is not born from parents, Brahma is known as "Svayambhu" ("self-existent" or "unoriginated"). Upon his emergence from the lotus, Brahma begins-in preparation for his role as secondary creator-to contemplate the act of cosmic creation but, seeing only darkness about, is bewildered in the performance of his duty. Sarasvati, the goddess of learning, appears before him and instructs him to meditate upon the kama-bija mantra (Klim krsnaya govindaya gopijana-vallabhaya svaha), promising that this mantra "will assuredly fulfill your heart's desire." Lord Brahma thus meditates upon Lord Krsna in His spiritual realm and hears the divine sound of Krsna`s flute. The kama-gayatri mantra (Klim kamadevaya vidmahe puspa-banaya dhimahi tan no nangah pracodayat), the "mother of the Vedas," is made manifest from the sound of Krsna's flute, and Brahma, thus initiated by the supreme primal preceptor Himself, begins to chant the Gayatri. (As Srila Prabhupada puts it, "When the sound vibration of Krsna's flute is expressed through the mouth of Brahma, it becomes gayatri" [teachings of Lord Caitanya, p. 322]). Enlightened by meditation upon the sacred Gayatri, Brahma "became acquainted with the expanse of the ocean of truth." Inspired by his profound and sublime realizations, his heart overflowing with devotion and transcendental insight, Lord Brahma spontaneously begins to offer a series of poem-prayers to the source of his enlightenment and the object of his devotion, Lord Sri Krsna. These exquisite verses form the heart of the Brahma-samhita.

There is nothing vague about Brahma's description of the Lord and His abode. No dim, nihilistic nothingness, no blinding bright lights, no wispy, dreamy visions of harps and clouds; rather, a vibrant, luminescent world in transcendental color, form, and sound-a sublimely variegated spiritual landscape populated by innumerable blissful, eternally liberated souls reveling in spiritual cognition, sensation, and emotion, all in relationship with the all-blissful, all-attractive Personality of Godhead. Here is a sample:

I worship Govinda [Krsna, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor who is tending the cows, yielding all desire, in abodes built with spiritual gems. surrounded by millions or purpose trees, always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds of thousands of Laksmis or gopis. I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is adept in playing on His flute, with blooming eyes like lotus petals, with head decked with peacock's feather, with the figure of beauty tinged with the hue of blue clouds, and His unique loveliness charming millions of Cupid.

... I worship [Goloka Vrndavana] ... where every tree is a transcendental purpose tree; where the soil is the purpose gem, all water is nectar, every word is a song, every gait is a dance, the flute is the favorite attendant.... where numberless milk cows always emit transcendental oceans of milk.

The commentator reminds us (p. 104) that in the transcendental region of Goloka are found the same elements as are found in the mundane worlds, but in their highest purity and beauty: "... trees and creepers, mountains, rivers and forests, water, speech, movement, music of the flute, the sun and the moon, tasted and taste ..." Krsna's divine abode, Goloka Vrndavana, is a world in the fullest and realist sense.

There are those who will have difficulty with Brahma's highly graphic and personalistic depiction of the spiritual world and of the liberated state. Some, for instance, whose conception of transcendence is determined by a certain logical fallacy based on the arbitrary assumption that spirit is the literal opposite of matter (and thus that because matter has form and variety spirit must necessarily be formless and unvariegated), conceive of ultimate reality as some sort of divine emptiness. However, any conception of transcendence that projects or analogizes from our limited sensory and cognitive experience within the material world is, by its very nature, limited and speculative and thus unreliable. No accumulated quantity of sense data within this world can bring us to knowledge of what lies beyond it. Residents of the material world cannot get even a clue of transcendence, argues our Brahma-samhita commentator, "by moving heaven and earth through their organic senses" (p. xix).

The Brahma-samhita teaches what transcendence, truth, ultimate reality can be apprehended only by the mercy of the supreme transcendent entity the Absolute Truth Himself, and that perception of ultimate reality is a function not of speculative reason but of direct spiritual cognition through divine revelation. This revelation is evolved through bhakti, pure, selfless love of God. Only by such spiritual devotion can Krsna be seen: "I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord ... whom the pure devotees see in their heart of hearts with the eye of devotion tinged with the salve of love" (verse 38). Further, as our commentator explains, "the form of Krsna is visible (to the eye of the pure spiritual self) in proportion to its purification by the practice of devotion" (p. 75). Bhakti as a state of consciousness, then, is attained through bhakti as a practice, a discipline. For this reason, Lord Krsna in His response to Brahma at the end of the text, summarizes the path or bhakti in five aphorisms. This devotional discipline goes far beyond conventional piety. It necessitates "constant endeavor for self-realization" (verse 59) involving both a turning from worldly, sense-gratificatory activities as well as sincere absorption in spiritual practices and behavior, under the guidance of authorized scripture. Through such practice, then, the materialist is purified of his tendency toward philosophical negation and comes to understand the nature of positive transcendence.

Others will find Lord Brahma's vision of the spiritual realm problematic for a related, but perhaps more subjective, emotional reason that goes to the heart of the human condition. There is a kind of ontological anxiety, a conscious or subconscious apprehension about beingness or existence itself, that goes along with embodied life-in-the-world-that accompanies the soul's descent into the temporal, endlessly changing world of matter. Material bodies and minds are subjected to a huge variety of objective and subjective discomfitures, unpleasantries, and abject sufferings within the material world. Viewed philosophically, embodied person hood, false-self (ahakara), is, to a greater or lesser degree, innately a condition of suffering. Because personal existence has been experienced by materialists as essentially painful, writes Prabhupada in his Bhagavad-gita commentary, "the conception of retaining the personality after liberation from matter frightens them. When they are informed that spiritual life is also individual and personal, they become afraid of becoming persons again, and so they naturally prefer a kind of merging into the impersonal void" (4.10, purport). Entering the path of bhakti, however, such persons can gradually begin to experience their real, spiritual selves and a release from egoistic anxiety. In that purified state, they become able to relish Brahma's vision of blissful, personal spiritual existence in Goloka.

Still others. however, might criticize Brahma-samhita on the grounds that the text, being quite specific and concrete in its depiction, merely offers another limited, sectarian view of God and His abode-a view in conflict with other, similarly limited views. Such persons prefer a kind of genericized Deity who doesn't offend variant theological views with definable, personal attributes. Brahma-samhita, however, is not a polemic against "competing" conceptions of the Deity (except those, of courses, which would deny His transcendental person hood). Vaisnava tradition does not dismiss images of the Divine derived from authoritative scripture from beyond its own cultural and conceptual borders. It respects any sincere effort at serving the Supreme Person, although naturally it holds its own texts as most comprehensive and authoritative. It promotes neither an arrogant sectarianism that would constrain transcendence to exclusive cultural, ideational, or linguistic forms (and burn a few heretics), nor a syncretistic ecumenism that would try to pacify all claimants on the truth by departicularizing it into bland vagary. Let the syncretists and the sectarians come together to appreciate, at least, the aesthetic magnificence of Brahma's theistic epiphany.

What we are experiencing through Lord Brahma in his samhita is not mystic hallucination nor quaint mythologizing nor an exercise in pious wishful thinking. We are getting a glimpse, however dimmed by our own insensitivities, into the spiritual world as seen by one whose eyes are "tinged with the salve of love." We are seeing, through Brahma, an eternal, transcendental world of which the present world is a mere reflection. Goloka is infinitely more real than the shadowy world we perceive daily through our narrow senses. Brahma's vision of the spiritual realm is not his alone. It is shared by all those who give themselves fully unto the loving service of Lord Krsna-though Brahma admits that Goloka is known "only to a very few self-realized souls in this world" (verse 56). We are not asked to accept Brahma's account of transcendence uncritically and dogmatically but to avail ourselves of the spiritual discipline, bhakti-yoga, that will gradually lead us to our own experiential understanding of this highest truth. The publishers of this small volume hope that a careful perusal of the text will inspire bhakti in the heart of the reader. It should be noted that Brahma-samhita is an advanced spiritual text and is more easily understood once one already has some familiarity with texts such as Bhagavad-gita, Srimad-Bhagavatam, Caitanya-cariramrta, and Bhakti-rasamrta-sindhu.

This volume is a new and expanded edition of an English language Brahma-samhita edition published in India in 1932 by the Gaudiya Math (a Caitanya-Vaisnava religious institution), with subsequent reprints in 1958 and 1973. These editions featured the English translation and commentary of Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Gosvami (1874-1937), a great Vaisnava saint and scholar of wide repute and the founder of the Gaudiya Math. It was Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati who inspired the founder and spiritual master of the Hare Krsna movement, his dearmost disciple Srila A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, to journey to and teach Krsna consciousness in the West, beginning in 1965.

As per Srila Prabhupada's instructions regarding the publication of this volume, Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati's somewhat technical and sometimes difficult prose has been left intact and virtually untouched. Fearing that any editorial (grammatical and stylistic) tampering with Bhaktisiddhanta's text might result in inadvertent changes in meaning, Prabhupada asked that it be left as is, and the editors of this volume have complied with his wishes. Only typographical errors have been corrected, capitalization has been standardized, Sanskrit terms in devanagari script appearing within the English text have been transliterated, and already transliterated terms have been adjusted to international standards.

In this edition, the original devanagari text is shown for each verse of the Brahma-samhita-, followed by roman transliteration, then by a word-for-word translation into English. (The original Indian edition lacked the latter two features.) These, in turn, are followed by Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati's full English translation and commentary. His commentary closely follows that of his father, Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura ( 1838-1914), the great Vaisnava saint, reformer, and prolific scholar who initiated a revival of pure Caitanya-Vaisnavism during the latter part of the nineteenth century.

Finally an index and glossary have been added for the convenience of the reader, as well as several color plates.

The Indian edition of Brahma-samhita included the complete text, in Sanskrit, of the commentary of Jiva Gosvami, the great Caitanyite philosopher, but that has been excluded from this edition because, in light of the relative few in the West who would benefit from its inclusion, it was decided that the necessary doubling of the volume's size and price would be disadvantageous.

In his commentary to the twenty-eighth verse of the text, Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati writes that Lord Caitanya "taught this hymn to His favorite disciples in as much as it fully contains all the transcendental truths regarding Vaisnava philosophy," and he asks his readers to "study and try to enter into the spirit of his hymn with great care and attention, as a regular daily function." His disciple Srila Prabhupada was very fond of Brahma's prayers to Lord Krsna (... govindam adi-purusam tam aham bhajami), and there are several recordings of Prabhupada singing these prayers with obvious, intense devotion. The publishers join with the commentator in inviting readers to dive deeply into the sweet, transcendental ocean of Brahma's hymns as a daily meditation.

Subhananda Dasa

Bs Foreword

Foreword

The materialistic demeanor cannot possibly stretch to the transcendental autocrat who is ever inviting the fallen conditioned souls to associate with Him through devotion or eternal serving mood. The phenomenal attractions are often found to tempt sentient beings to enjoy the variegated position which is opposed to undifferenced monism. People are so much apt to indulge in transitory speculations even when they are to educate themselves on a situation beyond their empiric area or experiencing jurisdiction. The esoteric aspect often knocks them to trace out immanence in their outward inspection of transitory and transformable things. This impulse moves them to fix the position of the immanent to an indeterminate impersonal entity, no clue of which could be discerned by moving earth and heaven through their organic senses.

The lines of this booklet will surely help such puzzled souls in their march towards the personality of the immanent lying beyond their sensuous gaze of inspection. The very first stanza of this publication will revolutionize their reserved ideas when the nomenclature of the Absolute is put before them as "Kåñëa." The speculative mind would show a tendency of offering some other attributive name to designate the unknown object. They will prefer to brand Him by their experience as the "creator of this universe," "the entity beyond phenomena"—far off the reference of any object of nature and void of all transformation. So they will urge that the very fountainhead should have no conceivable designation except to show a direction of the invisible, and inaudible untouchable, nonfragrant and unperceivable object. But they will not desist from contemplating on the object with their poor fund of experience. The interested enquirer will be found to hanker after the records left by erudite savants to incompatible hallucinative views of savage demonstration. In comparing the different names offered by different thoughts of mankind, a particular judge would decide in favor of some nomenclature which will suit best his limited and specific whims. The slave mentality of an individual will no doubt offer invective assertions to the rest who will be appealing to him for a revelation of his decision. To remedy this evil, the hymns of the accepted progenitor of the phenomena would do great help in taking up the question of nomenclature which is possessed of adequate power to dispel all imaginations drawn out of their experiencing the phenomena by their tentative exploitations.

The first hymn will establish the supremacy of the Absolute Truth, if His substratum is not shot by the bullets of limited time, ignorance and uncomfortable feeling, as well as by recognizing the same as an effect instead of accepting Him as the prime cause. He will be satisfied to mark that the object of their determination is the par-excellent Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa who has eternally embodied Himself in His ever-presence, all-blissful, all-pervasive perfected knowledge as the very fountainhead of all prime causes of unending nonbeginning time, the supplying fosterer of all entities, viz., mundane and transcendental.

The subsequent lines will go to determine the different aspects of the Absolute, who are but emanations of the supreme fountainhead Kåñëa, the attractive entity of all entities. Moreover, the derivative proclamation of the nomenclature will indicate the plane of uninterrupted, unending, transcendental felicity and the nomenclature Himself is the source of the two components which go by the names of efficient and material causes. The very transcendental name "Kåñëa" is known as the embodiment of all the transcendental eternal rasas as well as the origin of all eclipsed conceptions of interrupted rasas found in the mentality of animated beings which are successfully depicted by litterateurs and rhetoricians for our mundane speculation.

The verses of Brahma-saàhitä are a full elucidation of the origination of phenomenal and noumenic conceptions. The hymns of the incarnated prime potency has dealt fully with the monotheistic speculations of different schools which are busy to give an outer cover of an esoteric concoction without any reference to the true eternal aspect of transcendental nontransformable and imperishable manifestation of the immanent. The hymns have also dealt with different partial aspects of the personality of the Absolute who is quite isolated from the conception of the enjoyers of this phenomenal world.

A very close attention and a comparative study of all prevailing thoughts and conceptions will relieve and enlighten all—be he a materialist, a downright atheist, an agnostic, a sceptic, a naturalist, a pantheist or a panantheist—busy with their knowledge of three dimensions only by their speculative exertions.

This booklet is only the fifth chapter of the Hymns of Brahmä which were recorded in a hundred chapters. The Supreme Lord Çré Caitanya picked up this chapter from the temple of Ädi-keçava at Tiruvattar, a village lying under the government of Travancore, for the assurance of all God-loving, and especially Kåñëa-loving, people in this conditioned jurisdiction. This booklet can easily be compared with another book which passes by the name of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Though it has got a reference in the pantheon of Puräëas, the Bhägavatam corroborates the same idea of this Païcarätra.

The devotees should consider that these two books tend to the identical Kåñëa who is the fountainhead of all transcendental and mundane entities and has a manifestive exhibition of the plenary variegatedness.

Aspersions of calumniation are restricted in the limited world, whereas transcendence cannot admit such angularities being an angle of 180 degrees or void of any angular discrepancies.

The publisher is carried away to the realm of gratitude when his stores of publication are scrutinized. Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda has given an elucidatory purport of the conception of the most sublime fountainhead of all entities in Bengali, and one of his devout followers has rendered that into English for propagatory purpose. The purports and the translations are traced to the backgrounds of the writings of Çréla Jéva Gosvämé, a contemporary follower of the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya. The emotional aspirations will find fair play in perusing the texts of this brochure by one and all who have any interest in pure theistic achievements. The materialistic inspection often goes on to say that the provincial conception of theism has made the depicting of transcendental unity into diverse face quite opposed to the ethical consideration of the limited region. But we differ from such erroneous considerations when we get a prospective view of the manifested transcendentality eliminating all historicities and allegorical enterprises. All our enjoying mood should have a different direction when we take into account the transcendental entity who has obsessed all frailties and limitations of nature. So we solicit the happier mood of the scrutinizers to pay special attention to the importance of manifestive transcendence in Kåñëa.

It was found necessary to publish this small book for the use of English-knowing people who are interested in the acme of transcendental truths in their manifestive phases. The theme delineated in the texts of this book is quite different from the ordinary heaps of poetical mundane literature, as they are confined to our limited aspiration of senses. The book was found in the South some four centuries ago and it is again brought into light in the very same country after a long time, just like the worshiping of the Goddess Ganges by the offering of her own water.

Siddhänta Sarasvaté
Shree Gaudiya Math,
Calcutta, the 1st August, 1932.

Çré Brahma-saàhitä
Chapter Five

Bs 5.1

TEXT 1

TEXT

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù

sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù

anädir ädir govindaù

sarva-käraëa-käraëam

SYNONYMS

éçvaraù—the controller; paramaù—supreme; kåñëaù—Lord Kåñëa; sat—comprising eternal existence; cit—absolute knowledge; änanda—and absolute bliss; vigrahaù—whose form; anädiù—without beginning; ädiù—the origin; govindaù—Lord Govinda; sarva-käraëa-käraëam—the cause of all causes.

TRANSLATION

Kåñëa who is known as Govinda is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal blissful spiritual body. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin and He is the prime cause of all causes.

PURPORT

Kåñëa is the exalted Supreme entity having His eternal name, eternal form, eternal attribution and eternal pastimes. The very name "Kåñëa" implies His love-attracting designation, expressing by His eternal nomenclature the acme of entity. His eternal beautiful heavenly blue-tinged body glowing with the intensity of ever-existing knowledge has a flute in both His hands. As His inconceivable spiritual energy is all-extending, still He maintains His all-charming medium size by His qualifying spiritual instrumentals. His all-accommodating supreme subjectivity is nicely manifested in His eternal form. The concentrated all-time presence, uncovered knowledge and inebriating felicity have their beauty in Him. The mundane manifestive portion of His own Self is known as all-pervading Paramätmä, Éçvara (Superior Lord) or Viñëu (All-fostering). Hence it is evident that Kåñëa is sole Supreme Godhead. His unrivaled or unique spiritual body of superexcellent charm is eternally unveiled with innumerable spiritual instrumentals (senses) and unreckonable attributes keeping their signifying location properly, adjusting at the same time by His inconceivable conciliative powers. This beautiful spiritual figure is identical with Kåñëa and the spiritual entity of Kåñëa is identical with His own figure.

The very intensely blended entity of eternal presence of felicitous cognition is the charming targeted holding or transcendental icon. It follows that the conception of the indistinguishable formless magnitude (Brahman) which is an indolent, lax, presentment of cognitive bliss, is merely a penumbra of intensely blended glow of the three concomitants, viz., the blissful, the substantive and the cognitive. This transcendental manifestive icon Kåñëa in His original face is primordial background of magnitudinal infinite Brahman and of the all-pervasive oversoul. Kåñëa as truly visioned in His variegated pastimes, such as owner of transcendental cows, chief of cowherds, consort of milk-maids, ruler of the terrestrial abode Gokula and object of worship by transcendental residents of Goloka beauties, is Govinda. He is the root cause of all causes who are the predominating and predominated agents of the universe. The glance of His projected fractional portion in the sacred originating water viz., the personal oversoul or Paramätmä, gives rise to a secondary potency—nature who creates this mundane universe. This oversoul's intermediate energy brings forth the individual souls analogously to the emanated rays of the sun.

This book is a treatise of Kåñëa; so the preamble is enacted by chanting His name in the beginning.

[Ädi 2.107] [Madhya 8.137, 20.154, 21.35] [BTG #33]

Bs 5.2

TEXT 2

TEXT

sahasra-patra-kamalaà

gokuläkhyaà mahat padam

tat-karëikäraà tad-dhäma

tad-anantäàça-sambhavam

SYNONYMS

sahasra-patra—possessing a thousand petals; kamalam—a lotus; gokula-äkhyam—known as Gokula; mahat padam—the superexcellent station; tat—of that (lotus); karëikäram—the whorl; tat—of Him (Kåñëa); dhäma—the abode; tat—that (Gokula); ananta—of His infinitary aspect, Balaräma; aàça—from a part; sambhavam—produced.

TRANSLATION

[The spiritual place of transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa is portrayed in the second verse.] The superexcellent station of Kåñëa, which is known as Gokula, has thousands of petals and a corolla like that of a lotus sprouted from a part of His infinitary aspect, the whorl of the leaves being the actual abode of Kåñëa.

PURPORT

Gokula, like Goloka, is not a created mundane plane-unbounded character forms the display of His unlimited potency and His propagating manifestation. Baladeva is the mainstay of that energy. The transcendental entity of Baladeva has two aspects viz., infinite spiritual manifestation and infinite accommodating space for insentient gross things. The uniquadrantal delineation of material universe will be dealt within the proper place. The triquadrantal extensions of the transcendental infinitary field of the almighty, unlamenting, nonperishing and nonapprehending unlimited situations of halo which are fully spiritual majestic foliation. This very majestical extension portrays the manifested lofty rich feature of the vaster unlimited region or greater atmosphere which has its resplendent location wholly beyond the realm of mundane nature, on the further shore of Virajä surrounded by the halo of Brahman or indistinguishable entity. This majestical power of unlimited spirit emanates on the upper portion of the luminous sphere into the most charming Gokula or eternally existing Goloka, exceedingly beautified by the assorted display of effulgence. Some designate this region as the abode of the Supreme Näräyaëa, or the original fountainhead. Hence Gokula, which is identical with Goloka, is the supreme plane. The same sphere shines as Goloka and Gokula respectively by its upper or transcendental and lower or mundane situation.

Çré Sanätana Gosvämé has told us as follows in his Båhad-bhägavatämåta which embodies the final essence of all the books of instructions: "He displays His pastimes here in this land as He is used to do in Goloka. The difference between the two planes lies only in their locations as high and low; that is, in other words, Kåñëa plays exactly the same part in Goloka as He exhibits on the mundane plane of Gokula. There is practically no difference between Gokula and Goloka save that this what exists in the shape of Goloka in the upper region is the same as Gokula on the mundane plane when Kåñëa showed His various activity there. Çré Jéva Gosvämé has also inculcated the same in the Bhagavat-sandarbha of his 'Six Treatises.' " To ascertain the plane of Goloka-Våndävana is the eternal abode of Kåñëa and Goloka and Våndävana are identically one, and though both are identical, yet Kåñëa's inconceivable energy has made Goloka the acme of this spiritual kingdom and Gokula of Mathurä province forming a part of the mundane plane which is also a manifestation of triquadrantal vibhüti (conducting majesty). Poor human understanding cannot possibly make out how the extensive triquadrantal, which is beyond human comprehension, can be accommodated in the limited nether material universe of a uniquadrantal disclosure. Gokula is a spiritual plane, hence his condescended position in the region of material space, time, etc., is in no way restricted but unlimitedly manifested with his full boundless propriety. But conditioned souls are apt to assert a material conception in regard to Gokula by their miserable senses so as to bring him below the level of their intellect. Though the eye of an observer is impeded by a cloud when gazing at the sun and though the tiny cloud can never really cover the sun, still the clouded vision apparently observes the sun as covered by the cloud. In just the same way the conditioned souls with their obscured intelligence, senses and decisions, accept Gokula as a piece of measurable land. We can see Gokula from Goloka which is eternal. This is also a mystery. The attainment of final beatitude is the success in attaining one's eternal self. The success in identifying the true self is finally achieved when the screen of gross and subtle coils of conditioned souls is removed by the sweet will of Kåñëa. However, the idea of Goloka is seen to differ from Gokula till the success in unalloyed devotion is achieved. The transcendental plane of infinite spiritual manifestation having thousands of petals and corolla like those of the lotus, is Gokula, the eternal abode of Kåñëa.

[BTG #33] [Madhya 20.258]

Bs 5.3

TEXT 3

TEXT

karëikäraà mahad yantraà

ñaö-koëaà vajra-kélakam

ñaò-aìga-ñaö-padé-sthänaà

prakåtyä puruñeëa ca

premänanda-mahänanda-

rasenävasthitaà hi yat

jyoté-rüpeëa manunä

käma-béjena saìgatam

SYNONYMS

karëikäram—the whorl; mahat—great; yantram—figure; ñaö-koëam—a hexagon; vajra—like a diamond; kélakam—the central support; ñaö-aìga-ñaö-padé—of the eighteen-syllable mantra with sixfold divisions; sthänam—the place of manifestation; prakåtyä—along with the predominated aspect of the Absolute; puruñeëa—along with the predominating aspect of the Absolute; ca—also; prema-änanda—of the bliss of love of God; mahä-änanda—of the great transcendental jubilations; rasena—with the rasa (mellow); avasthitam—situated; hi—certainly; yat—which; jyotiù-rüpeëa—transcendental; manunä—with the mantra; käma-béjena—with the käma-béja (kléà); saìgatam—joined.

TRANSLATION

The whorl of that transcendental lotus is the realm wherein dwells Kåñëa. It is a hexagonal figure, the abode of the indwelling predominated and predominating aspect of the Absolute. Like a diamond the central supporting figure of self-luminous Kåñëa stands as the transcendental source of all potencies. The holy name consisting of eighteen transcendental letters is manifested in a hexagonal figure with sixfold divisions.

PURPORT

The transcendental pastimes of Kåñëa are twofold, viz., manifested and nonmanifested. The pastimes in Våndävana visible to mortal eyes are the manifestive lélä of Çré Kåñëa, and that which is not so visible, is nonmanifestive lélä of Kåñëa. The nonmanifestive lélä is always visible in Goloka and the same is visible to human eyes in Gokula, if Kåñëa so desires. In his Kåñëa-sandarbha Çré Jéva Gosvämé Prabhu says, "Nonmanifestive pastimes are expressed in manifestive kåñëa-lélä, and goloka-lélä is the nonmanifestive pastimes of Kåñëa visualized from the mundane plane." This is also corroborated by Çré Rüpa in his Bhägavatämåta. The progressive transcendental manifestation of Gokula is Goloka. So Goloka is the selfsame majestic manifestation of Gokula. The eternal pastimes of Çré Kåñëa, although not visible in Gokula, are eternally manifested in Goloka. Goloka is the transcendental majestic manifestation of Gokula. The manifestations of the nonmanifestive pastimes of Kåñëa with regard to the conditioned souls, are twofold, viz., (1) worship through the channel of the mantras (inaudibly recited, liberating, self-dedicatory. transcendental sounds), (2) spontaneous outflow of heart's spiritual love for Kåñëa. Çré Jéva Gosvämé has said that worship through the mantra is possible permanently in the proper place, when confined to one pastime. This meditative manifestation of Goloka is the pastime attended with the worship of Kåñëa through the mantra. Again, the pastimes that are performed in different planes and in different moods, are autocratic in diverse ways; hence svä-rasiké, i.e., spontaneous, outflow of heart's spiritual love for Kåñëa. This çloka conveys a twofold meaning. One meaning is that in the pastime attended with worship through the mantra consisting of eighteen transcendental letters, transcendental words contained in the said mantra being differently placed make a manifestation of only one lélä of Çré Kåñëa. As for example kléà kåñëäya govindäya gopéjana-vallabhäya svähä—this is a hexagonal mantra consisting of six transcendental words, viz., (1) kåñëäya, (2) govindäya, (3) gopéjana, (4) vallabhäya, (5) svä, (6) hä. These six transcendental words, when placed juxtapositionally. indicate the mantra.

The hexagonal great transcendental machinery is in this wise. The principal seed, i.e. kléà, is situated in the instrument as the central pivot. Anybody with an impression of such an instrument in his mind and concentrating his thought on such spiritual entities, can attain, like Candradhvaja, to the knowledge of the cognitive principle. The word svä indicates kñetrajïa i.e., one who is conversant with one's inner self, and the word hä indicates the transcendental nature. This meaning of the mantra has also been corroborated by Çré Hari-bhakti-viläsa. The general meaning is this that one who is desirous of entering into the esoteric pastimes of Kåñëa will have to practice His transcendental service along with the culture of the devotional knowledge relative to Him. (1) kåñëa-svarüpa—the proper Self of Kåñëa; (2) kåñëasya cin-maya-vraja-lélä-viläsa-svarüpa—the true nature of Kåñëa's transcendental pastimes in Vraja; (3) tat-parikara-gopéjana-svarüpa—the true nature of His spiritual associates in Vraja, viz., the spiritual milkmen and the milkmaids; (4) tad-vallabha—the true nature of self-surrender to Kåñëa in the footsteps of the spiritual milkmaids of Vraja; (5) çuddha-jévasya cid-(jïäna)-svarüpa—the true nature of the spiritual knowledge of the unalloyed individual soul; (6) cit-prakåtir arthät kåñëa-sevä-svabhäva—the true nature of transcendental service to Kåñëa is this that the esoteric relation is established on the awakening of one's pure cognition. The meaning is that rasa is only the transcendental service of the central refuge Çré Kåñëa, as predominating aspect of the Absolute, by one's ego as the spiritual maid of the predominated moiety of the absolute integer, attended with pure devotion in the shape of one's entire self-surrender. The pastime in Goloka or in Gokula during the stage of devotional progress, is the meditative worship through the mantra, and during the stage of perfection the pastimes manifest themselves as the unrestrained transcendental jubilations. This is the real aspect of Goloka or Gokula, which will be made more explicit in due course. The meaning of the words jyoté-rüpeëa manunä is that the transcendental meaning is expressed in the mantra by means of which, on transcendental desire of love for Kåñëa and the service of Kåñëa being added, one is established in the eternal love of Kåñëa. Such eternal pastimes are eternally manifested in Goloka.

Bs 5.4

TEXT 4

TEXT

tat-kiïjalkaà tad-aàçänäà

tat-paträëi çriyäm api

SYNONYMS

tat—of that (lotus); kiïjalkam—the petals; tat-aàçänäm—of His (Kåñëa's) fragmental portions; tat—of that (lotus); paträëi—the leaves; çriyäm—of the gopés (headed by Çrématé Rädhäräëé); api—also.

TRANSLATION

The whorl of that eternal realm Gokula is the hexagonal abode of Kåñëa. Its petals are the abodes of gopés who are part and parcel of Kåñëa to whom they are most lovingly devoted and are similar in essence. The petals shine beautifully like so many walls. The extended leaves of that lotus are the gardenlike dhäma, i.e. spiritual abode of Çré Rädhikä, the most beloved of Kåñëa.

PURPORT

The transcendental Gokula is shaped like the lotus. The eternal world is like a hexagonal figure; in that the entities Çré Rädhä-Kåñëa, appearing in the form of a mantra consisting of eighteen transcendental letters, are centered. The propagating manifestations emanating from the cit potency are present there with the said entities as the center. Çré Rädhä-Kåñëa is the primary cause or the seed Himself. Gopäla-täpané says, "Oàkära" signifies the All-Powerful Gopäla and His potency; and "kléà" is the same as oàkära. Hence käma-béja or the primary cause of all-love, is connotative of the entities Çré Rädhä-Kåñëa.

Bs 5.5

TEXT 5

TEXT

catur-asraà tat-paritaù

çvetadvépäkhyam adbhutam

catur-asraà catur-mürteç

catur-dhäma catuñ-kåtam

caturbhiù puruñärthaiç ca

caturbhir hetubhir våtam

çülair daçabhir änaddham

ürdhvädho dig-vidikñv api

añöabhir nidhibhir juñöam

añöabhiù siddhibhis tathä

manu-rüpaiç ca daçabhir

dik-pälaiù parito våtam

çyämair gauraiç ca raktaiç ca

çuklaiç ca pärñadarñabhaiù

çobhitaà çaktibhis täbhir

adbhutäbhiù samantataù

SYNONYMS

catuù-asraà—quadrangular place; tat—that (Gokula); paritaù—surrounding; çveta-dvépa—Çvetadvépa (the white island); äkhyam—named; adbhutam—mysterious; catuù-asram—quadrangular; catuù-mürteù—of the four primary expansions (Väsudeva, Saìkarñaëa, Pradyumna and Aniruddha); catuù-dhäma—consisting of four abodes; catuù-kåtam—divided into four parts; caturbhiù—by the four; puruña-arthaiù—human requirements; ca—and; caturbhiù—by the four; hetubhiù—causes, or bases of achievement; våtam—enveloped; çülaiù—with tridents; daçabhiù—ten; änaddham—fixed; ürdhva-adhaù—upwards and downwards (the zenith and nadir); dik—(in) the directions (north, south, east, and west); vidikñu—and in the intermediate directions (northeast, southeast, southwest, and northwest); api—also; añöabhiù—with the eight; nidhibhiù—jewels; juñöam—endowed; añöabhiù—with the eight; siddhibhiù—mystic perfections (aëimä, laghimä, präpti, präkämya, mahimä, éçitva, vaçitva, and kämävasäyitä); tathä—also; manu-rüpaiù—in the form of mantras; ca—and; daçabhiù—by ten; dik-pälaiù—protectors of the directions; paritaù—all around; våtam—surrounded; çyämaiù—blue; gauraiù—yellow; ca—and; raktaiù—red; ca—and; çuklaiù—white; ca—also; pärñada-åñabhaiù—with the topmost associates; çobhitam—shining; çaktibhiù—with potencies; täbhiù—those; adbhutäbhiù—extraordinary; samantataù—on all sides.

TRANSLATION

[The surrounding external plane of Gokula is described in this verse.] There is a mysterious quadrangular place named Çvetadvépa surrounding the outskirts of Gokula. Çvetadvépa is divided into four parts on all sides. The abode of Väsudeva, Saìkarñaëa, Pradyumna and Aniruddha are separately located in each of these four parts. These four divided abodes are enveloped by the fourfold human requirements such as piety, wealth, passion and liberation, as also by the four Vedas, viz., Åg, Säma, Yajur and Atharva, which deal with the mantra and which are the bases of achievements of the fourfold mundane requirements. Ten tridents are fixed in the ten directions, including the zenith and nadir. The eight directions are decorated with the eight jewels of Mahäpadma, Padma, Çaìkha, Makara, Kacchapa, Mukunda, Kunda, and Néla. There are ten protectors [dik-pälas] of the ten directions in the form of mantra. The associates of the hues of blue, yellow, red and white and the extraordinary potencies bearing the names of Vimala, etc., shine on all sides.

PURPORT

Primarily Gokula is the seat of transcendental love and devotion. Hence Yamunä, Çré Govardhana, Çré Rädhä-kuëòa, etc., of the terrestrial Vraja-maëòala lie within Gokula. Again, all the majesties of Vaikuëöha are manifested there extending in all directions. The pastimes of the four propagating manifestations are all there in their proper places. The paravyoma Vaikuëöha has got its extension from the display of the four propagating manifestations. Salvation as of Vaikuëöha, and piety. wealth and passion pertaining to worldly people, are in the proper places in Gokula as their original seed, i.e., primary cause. The Vedas also are engaged in singing the song of the Lord of Gokula. There are ten tridents in ten directions to prevent and disappoint those who are aspirants for having an entrance into Goloka through meditations without the grace of Kåñëa. Self-conceited people who try to reach this region through the paths of yoga (meditation) and jïäna (empiric knowledge) are baffled in their attempts, being pierced by the ten tridents. Self-annihilation has its excellence in Brahma-dhäma which represents the outside covering of Goloka in the shape of tridents. Çüla means a trident; the mundane threefold attributes and the threefold divisions of time represent the trident. Añöäìga-yogis i.e. ascetics who practice the eightfold yoga, are the nondifferentiative liberationists who, trying to approach in the direction of Goloka, fall headlong into the pits of disappointment by being pierced and cut asunder by these tridents placed in ten directions. Those who proceed towards the direction of Goloka through the channel of devotion alloyed with majestic ideas, are fascinated with the charms of Vaikuëöha which is the outer covering plane of Çré Goloka, at the sight of the eight perfections, viz., aëimä, etc., and majesties like mahäpadma, etc. Those who are less forward in their intelligence relapse to the sevenfold world falling under the control of the ten protectors (of the ten directions) in the guise of mantras. In this wise, Goloka has become unknowable and inaccessible. It is only the divine selves of Godhead, the propounders of the divine dispensations for the different ages, who are always forward there to favor the approaching devotees who seek entry into the realm of Goloka through the channel of pure devotional love. These divine forms of Godhead are surrounded there with attendants of their respective natures. Çvetadvépa in Goloka is their place of abode. Hence Çréla Öhäkura Våndävana the manifest Vyäsa of caitanya-lélä, has described the village of Navadvépa as bearing the name of Çvetadvépa. In this Çvetadvépa the concluding portions of the pastimes of Gokula exist eternally as the pastimes of Navadvépa. Hence the region of Navadvépa, Vraja and the realm of Goloka are one and the same indivisible entity; the difference only lies in the manifestations of the infinite variety of sentiments, corresponding to the diverse nature of their devotional love. There is in this a most hidden principle which only the greatest souls who are possessed of the highest transcendental love, are enabled to realize by the direct grace of Kåñëa. The truth is as follows: In this mundane world there are fourteen spheres disposed in the graded order of high and low. Persons living with wives and children hankering for the pleasure-giving effect of their fruitive actions, move up and down within the limits of the three worlds of Bhüù, Bhuvaù and Svaù. Brahmacärés of great austerities, ascetics and persons addicted to hypothetical truth, persons of a neutral disposition adopting nonfruitive works by an aptitude which seeks to be free from all mundane desires, move up and down within the limits of the worlds of Mahaù, Janaù, Tapaù and Satya. Above these worlds lies the abode of four-headed Brahmä, above which lies the unlimited realm of Vaikuëöha of Viñëu, Kñérodakaçäyé, lying in the ocean of milk. Paramahaàsa-sannyäsés and the demons killed by Çré Hari, by crossing the Virajä, i.e., by passing beyond the fourteen worlds, enter into the luminous realm of Brahman and attain to nirväëa in the form of temporary abeyance of the temporal ego. But the devotee actuated by knowledge (jïäna-bhakta), the devotee actuated by the pure devotional aptitude (çuddha-bhakta), the devotee imbued with loving devotion (prema-bhakta), the devotee actuated by pure love (premapara-bhakta), and the devotee impelled by overwhelming love (premätura-bhakta), who serve the majesty of Godhead, have their locations in Vaikuëöha, i.e., the transcendental realm of Çré Näräyaëa.

The devotees who are imbued with all-love and who walk in the footsteps of the spiritual maids of Vraja, alone attain to the realm of Goloka. The different locations of the devotees in Goloka according to the respective differences in the nature of their rasa, i.e., mellow quality. are settled by the inconceivable power of Kåñëa. The pure devotees following the devotees of Vraja and those following the pure devotees of Navadvépa are located in the realm of Kåñëa and Gaura respectively. The identical devotees of Vraja and Navadvépa simultaneously attain to the pleasures of service in the realm of Kåñëa and Gaura. Çré Jéva Gosvämé writes in his work Gopäla-campü that "the supreme transcendental realm is called Goloka being the abode of go, transcendental cows, and gopa, transcendental cowherds. This is the seat of the rasa pastimes of the absolute Çré Kåñëa. Again the realm is called Çvetadvépa owing to the realization of some of the rasas which are the inconceivable manifestation derived from the untouched purity of that supreme realm. The twofold entities of the supreme Goloka and the supreme Çvetadvépa are indivisibly the realm of Goloka." The gist of the whole matter is this—Goloka as Çvetadvépa is eternally manifest because the pleasures of enjoyment of the rasa could not be had in its entirety in the pastimes of Kåñëa in Vraja. He accepts the emotion and effulgence of His predominated moiety. Çré Rädhikä, and makes an eternal pastime for the enjoyment of kåñëa-rasa there. Çré Kåñëacandra coveting to taste the following pleasures, viz., to realize (1) the nature of the greatness of love of Çré Rädhä; (2) the nature of the wonderful sweetness of His love of which Çré Rädhikä has got the taste; (3) the nature of the exquisite joy that accrues to Çré Rädhä by Her realization of the sweetness of His love, took His birth, like the moon, in the ocean of the womb of Çré Çacé-devé. The esoteric desire of Çré Jéva Gosvämé Prabhu is herein made manifest. In the Veda it is also said, "Let me tell you the mystery. In Navadvépa, the identical realm of Goloka, on the bank of the Ganges, Gauracandra who is Govinda, the entity of pure cognition, who has two hands, who is the soul of all souls, who has the supreme great personality as the great meditative sannyäsin and who is beyond the threefold mundane attributes, makes the process of pure unalloyed devotion manifest in this mundane world. He is sole Godhead. He is the source of all forms, the Supreme Soul and is Godhead manifesting Himself in yellow, red, blue and white colors. He is the direct entity of pure cognition full of the spiritual (cit) potency. He is the figure of the devotee. He is the bestower of devotion and cognizable by devotion alone. The selfsame Gauracandra, who is no other than Kåñëa Himself, in order to taste the rasa of the pastimes of Rädhä-Kåñëa in Goloka, is manifest in the eternal realm of Navadvépa identical with Goloka." This is also clear from the Vedic declarations, viz., äsan varëäs trayaù, kåñëa-varëaà tviñäkåñëam, yathä paçyaù paçyati rukma-varëam, mahän prabhur vai and various other statements of the theistic scriptures. Just as Çré Kåñëa had His birth in the mundane Gokula through the agency of Yogamäyä who is the primal energy of the Supreme Lord, so with her help He manifests the lélä of His birth in the womb of Çacé-devé in Navadvépa on this mundane plane. These are the absolute truths of spiritual science and not the outcome of imaginary speculation under the thraldom of the deluding energy of Godhead.

Bs 5.6

TEXT 6

TEXT

evaà jyotir-mayo devaù

sad-änandaù parät paraù

ätmärämasya tasyästi

prakåtyä na samägamaù

SYNONYMS

evam-thus; jyotiù-mayaù—transcendental; devaù—the Lord; sat-änandaù—the own Self of eternal ecstasies; parät paraù—the superior of all superiors; ätma-ärämasya—engaged in the enjoyments of the transcendental realm; tasya—of Him; asti—there is; prakåtyä—with the mundane potency; na—not; samägamaù—association.

TRANSLATION

The Lord of Gokula is the transcendental Supreme Godhead, the own Self of eternal ecstasies. He is the superior of all superiors and is busily engaged in the enjoyments of the transcendental realm and has no association with His mundane potency.

PURPORT

The sole potency of Kåñëa which is spiritual, functioning as Kåñëa's own proper power, has manifested His pastimes of Goloka or Gokula. By her grace individual souls who are constituents of the marginal potency can have admission into even those pastimes. The deluding energy, who is of the nature of the perverted reflection of the spiritual (cit) potency, has got her location on the other side of the river Virajä, which surrounds the Brahma-dhäma forming the boundary of Mahä-Vaikuëöha as the outer envelope of Goloka. The position of Goloka being absolutely unalloyed with the mundane, deluding energy, far from having any association with Kåñëa, feels ashamed to appear before His view.

Bs 5.7

TEXT 7

TEXT

mäyayäramamäëasya

na viyogas tayä saha

ätmanä ramayä reme

tyakta-kälaà sisåkñayä

SYNONYMS

mäyayä—with the illusory energy; aramamäëasya—of Him, who never consorts; na—not; viyogaù—complete separation; tayä—her; saha—from; ätmanä—with His own; ramayä—spiritual potency, Ramä; reme—consorts; tyakta-kälam—by casting His glance in the shape of sending His time energy; sisåkñayä—with the desire to create.

TRANSLATION

Kåñëa never consorts with His illusory energy. Still her connection is not entirely cut off from the Absolute Truth. When He intends to create the material world the amorous pastime, in which He engages by consorting with His own spiritual [cit] potency Ramä by casting His glance at the deluding energy in the shape of sending His time energy, is an auxiliary activity.

PURPORT

The illusory energy has no direct contact with Kåñëa, but has got indirect contact. Viñëu the prime cause, lying in the Causal Ocean, the plenary portion of Mahä-Saìkarñaëa who has His seat in Mahä-Vaikuëöha the sphere of Kåñëa's own extended transcendental pastimes, casts His glance towards the deluding energy. Even in casting His glance He has no contact with the deluding energy because the spiritual (cit) potency Ramä then carries the function of His glance as His unpolluted ever-submissive potency. The deluding energy as the maidservant of the spiritual (cit) potency Ramä, serves the manifested plenary portion of Godhead consorted with Ramä, the time energy representing the force of activity and instrumentality of Ramä; hence there is found the process of masculinity or the creative force.

Bs 5.8

TEXT 8

TEXT

niyatiù sä ramä devi

tat-priyä tad-vaçaà tadä

tal-liìgaà bhagavän çambhur

jyoti-rüpaù sanätanaù

yä yoniù säparä çaktiù

kämo béjaà mahad dhareù

SYNONYMS

niyatiù—the regulator; sä—she; ramä—the spiritual potency; devi—the goddess; tat—of Him; priyä—beloved; tat—of Him; vaçam—under the control; tadä—then (at the time of creation); tat—of Him; liìgam—the masculine symbol, or manifested emblem; bhagavän—possessing opulences; çambhuù—Çambhu; jyotiù-rüpaù—halo; sanätanaù—eternal; yä—which; yoniù—the symbol of mundane feminine productivity; sa—that; aparä—nonabsolute; çaktiù—potency; kämaù—the desire; béjam—the seed; mahat—the faculty of perverted cognition; hareù—of the Supreme Lord.

TRANSLATION

[The secondary process of association with Mäyä is described.] Ramädevé, the spiritual [cit] potency, beloved consort of the Supreme Lord, is the regulatrix of all entities. The divine plenary portion of Kåñëa creates the mundane world. At creation there appears a divine halo of the nature of His own subjective portion [sväàça]. This halo is divine Çambhu, the masculine symbol or manifested emblem of the Supreme Lord. This halo is the dim twilight reflection of the supreme eternal effulgence. This masculine symbol is the subjective portion of divinity who functions as progenitor of the mundane world, subject to the supreme regulatrix [niyati]. The conceiving potency in regard to mundane creation makes her appearance out of the supreme regulatrix. She is Mäyä, the limited, nonabsolute [aparä] potency, the symbol of mundane feminine productivity. The intercourse of these two brings forth the faculty of perverted cognition, the reflection of the seed of the procreative desire of the Supreme Lord.

PURPORT

Saìkarñaëa possessed of creative desire is the subjective portion of Kåñëa taking the initiative in bringing about the birth of the mundane world. Lying in the causal water as the primal puruña-avatära He casts His glance towards Mäyä (the limited potency). Such glance is the efficient cause of the mundane creation. Çambhu the symbol of masculine mundane procreation is the dim halo of this reflected effulgence. It is this symbol which is applied to the organ of generation of Mäyä, the shadow of Ramä or the divine potency. The first phase of the appearance of the mundane desire created by Mahä-Viñëu is called the seminal principle of mahat or the perverted cognitive faculty. It is this which is identical with the mental principle ripe for procreative activity. The conception underlying it is that it is the will of the puruña who creates by using the efficient and material principles. Efficiency is Mäyä or the productive feminine organ. The material principle is Çambhu or the procreative masculine organ. Mahä-Viñëu is puruña or the dominating divine person wielding the will. Pradhäna or the substantive principle in the shape of mundane entities, is the material principle. Nature embodying the accommodating principle (ädhära), is Mäyä. The principle of embodied will bringing about the intercourse of the two, is the dominating divine person (puruña), subjective portion of Kåñëa, the manifestor of the mundane world. All of these three are creators. The seed of amorous creative desire in Goloka, is the embodiment of pure cognition. The seed of sex desire to be found in this mundane world, is that of Kälé, etc., who are the shadows of the divine potency. The former, although it is the prototype of the latter, is located very far from it. The seed of the mundane sex desire is the perverted reflection in this mundane world of the seed of the original creative desire. The process of the appearance of Çambhu is recorded in the tenth and fifteenth çlokas.

Bs 5.9

TEXT 9

TEXT

liìga-yony-ätmikä jätä

imä mäheçvaré-prajäù

SYNONYMS

liìga—of the mundane masculine generative organs; yoni—and of the mundane feminine generative organs; ätmikäù—as the embodiment; jätäù—born; imäù—these; mäheçvaré—of the consort of the great lord of this mundane world; prajäù—the offspring.

TRANSLATION

All offspring of the consort of the great lord [Maheçvara] of this mundane world are of the nature of the embodiment of the mundane masculine and feminine generative organs.

PURPORT

The full quadrantal extension of the Supreme Lord, is His majesty. Of this the triquadrantal extensions of unlamenting, nonperishing and nonapprehending situations constitute the majesties of the realms of Vaikuëöha and Goloka, etc. In this temporal realm of Mäyä devas and men, etc.—all these together with all mundane worlds—are the great majesties of the limited potency. All these entities are embodiments of the masculine and feminine organs of generation by the distinction of efficient and material causal principles; or, in other words, they are produced by the process of sexual intercourse between the male and female organs of generation. All the information that has been accumulated by the agency of the sciences of this world, possesses this nature of sexual co-union. Trees, plants and even all insentient entities are embodiments of the co-union of male and female. The feature that is of special significance is that although such expressions as "the generative organs of male and female" are indecorous yet in scientific literature these words, expressing the above-mentioned principles, are exceedingly wholesome and productive of abiding value. Indecorum is merely an entity pertaining to the external custom of society. But science, and specially the highest science, cannot destroy the true entity by deference to social custom. Wherefore, in order to demonstrate the seed of mundane sex desire, the basic principle of this phenomenal world, the use of those identical words is indispensable. By the use of all these words only the masculine energy or the predominating active potency, and female energy or the predominated active potency. are to be understood.

Bs 5.10

TEXT 10

TEXT

çaktimän puruñaù so 'yaà

liìga-rüpé maheçvaraù

tasminn ävirabhül liìge

mahä-viñëur jagat-patiù

SYNONYMS

çaktimän—joined to his female consort; puruñaù—person; saù—he; ayam—this; liìga-rüpé—in the form of the male generating organ; mahä-éçvaraù—Çambhu, the lord of this mundane world; tasmin—in that; ävirabhüt—manifested; liìge—in the manifested emblem; mahä-viñëuù—Mahä-Viñëu; jagat-patiù—the Lord of the world.

TRANSLATION

The person embodying the material causal principle, viz., the great lord of this mundane world [Maheçvara] Çambhu, in the form of the male generating organ, is joined to his female consort the limited energy [Mäyä] as the efficient causal principle. The Lord of the world Mahä-Viñëu is manifest in him by His subjective portion in the form of His glance.

PURPORT

In the transcendental atmosphere (para-vyoma), where spiritual majesty preponderates, there is present Çré Näräyaëa who is not different from Kåñëa. Mahä-Saìkarñaëa, subjective plenary facsimile of the extended personality of Çré Näräyaëa, is also the divine plenary portion of the propagatory embodiment of Çré Kåñëa. By the power of His spiritual energy a plenary subjective portion of Him, eternally reposing in the neutral stream of Virajä forming the boundary between the spiritual and mundane realms, casts His glance, at creation, unto the limited shadow potency. Mäyä, who is located far away from Himself. Thereupon Çambhu, lord of pradhäna embodying the substantive principle of all material entities, who is the same as Rudra, the dim reflection of the Supreme Lord's own divine glance, consummates his intercourse with Mäyä, the efficient mundane causal principle. But he can do nothing independently of the energy of Mahä-Viñëu representing the direct spiritual power of Kåñëa. Therefore, the principle of mahat, or the perverted cognitive faculty. is produced only when the subjective plenary portion of Kåñëa, viz., the prime divine avatära Mahä-Viñëu who is the subjective portion of Saìkarñaëa, Himself the subjective portion of Kåñëa, is propitious towards the active mutual endeavors of Mäyä, Çiva's consort (çakti), and pradhäna or the principle of substantive mundane causality. Agreeably to the initiative of Mahä-Viñëu the consort of Çiva creates successively the mundane ego (ahaìkära), the five mundane elements (bhütas) viz., space etc., their attributes (tan-mätras) and the limited senses of the conditioned soul (jéva). The constituent particles, in the form of pencils of effulgence of Mahä-Viñëu, are manifest as the individual souls (jévas). This will be elaborated in the sequel.

Bs 5.11

TEXT 11

TEXT

sahasra-çérñä puruñaù

sahasräkñaù sahasra-pät

sahasra-bähur viçvätmä

sahasräàçaù sahasra-süù

SYNONYMS

sahasra-çérñä—possessing thousands of heads; puruñaù—Lord Mahä-Viñëu, the first puruña-avatära; sahasra-akñaù—possessing thousands of eyes; sahasra-pät—possessing thousands of legs; sahasra-bähuù—possessing thousands of arms; viçva-ätmä—the Supersoul of the universe; sahasra-aàçaù—the source of thousands of avatäras; sahasra-süù—the creator of thousands of individual souls.

TRANSLATION

The Lord of the mundane world, Mahä-Viñëu, possesses thousands of thousands of heads, eyes, hands. He is the source of thousands of thousands of avatäras in His thousands of thousands of subjective portions. He is the creator of thousands of thousands of individual souls.

PURPORT

Mahä-Viñëu, the object of worship of the hymns of all the Vedas, is possessed of an infinity of senses and potencies, and He is the prime avatära-puruña, the source of all the avatäras.

Bs 5.12

TEXT 12

TEXT

näräyaëaù sa bhagavän

äpas tasmät sanätanät

äviräsét käraëärëo

nidhiù saìkarñaëätmakaù

yoga-nidräà gatas tasmin

sahasräàçaù svayaà mahän

SYNONYMS

näräyaëaù—named Näräyaëa; saù—that; bhagavän—Supreme Personality of Godhead, Mahä-Viñëu; äpaù—water; tasmät—from that; sanätanät—eternal person; äviräsét—has sprung; käraëa-arëaù—the Causal Ocean; nidhiù—expanse of water; saìkarñaëa-ätmakaù—the subjective portion of Saìkarñaëa; yoga-nidräm gataù—in the state of deep sleep; tasmin—in that (water); sahasra-aàçaù—with thousands of portions; svayam—Himself; mahän—the Supreme Person.

TRANSLATION

The same Mahä-Viñëu is spoken of by the name of "Näräyaëa" in this mundane world. From that eternal person has sprung the vast expanse of water of the spiritual Causal Ocean. The subjective portion of Saìkarñaëa who abides in paravyoma, the above supreme puruña with thousands of subjective portions, reposes in the state of divine sleep [yoga-nidrä] in the waters of the spiritual Causal Ocean.

PURPORT

Yoga-nidrä (divine sleep) is spoken of as ecstatic trance which is of the nature of the bliss of the true subjective personality. The above-mentioned Ramädevé is yoga-nidrä in the form of Yogamäyä.

Bs 5.13

TEXT 13

TEXT

tad-roma-bila jäleñu

béjaà saìkarñaëasya ca

haimäny aëòäni jätäni

mahä-bhütävåtäni tu

SYNONYMS

tat—of Him (Mahä-Viñëu); roma-bila-jäleñu—in the pores of the skin; béjam—the seeds; saìkarñaëasya—of Saìkarñaëa; ca—and; haimäni—golden; aëòäni—eggs or sperms; jäta-ni—born; mahä-bhüta—by the five great elements; ävåtäni—covered; tu—certainly.

TRANSLATION

The spiritual seeds of Saìkarñaëa existing in the pores of skin of Mahä-Viñëu, are born as so many golden sperms. These sperms are covered with five great elements.

PURPORT

The prime divine avatära lying in the spiritual Causal Ocean is such a great affair that in the pores of His divine form spring up myriads of seeds of the universes. Those series of universes are the perverted reflections of the infinite transcendental region. As long as they remain embedded in His divine form they embody the principle of spiritual reflection having the form of golden eggs. Nevertheless by the creative desire of Mahä-Viñëu the minute particles of the great elements, which are constituents of the mundane efficient and material causal principles, envelop them. When those golden sperms, coming out with the exhalation of Mahä-Viñëu, enter into the unlimited accommodating chamber of the limited potency (Mäyä) they become enlarged by the nonconglomerate great elements.

Bs 5.14

TEXT 14

TEXT

praty-aëòam evam ekäàçäd

ekäàçäd viçati svayam

sahasra-mürdhä viçvätmä

mahä-viñëuù sanätanaù

SYNONYMS

prati—each; aëòam—egglike universe; evam—thus; eka-aàçät eka-aàçät—as His own separate subjective portions; viçati—enters; svayam—personally; sahasra-mürdhä—possessing thousands of heads; viçva-ätmä—the Supersoul of the universe; mahä-viñëuù—Mahä-Viñëu; sanätanaù—eternal.

TRANSLATION

The same Mahä-Viñëu entered into each universe as His own separate subjective portions. The divine portions, that entered into each universe are possessed of His majestic extension, i.e., they are the eternal universal soul Mahä-Viñëu, possessing thousands of thousands of heads.

PURPORT

Mahä-Viñëu lying in the spiritual Causal Ocean is the subjective portion of Mahä-Saìkarñaëa. He entered, as His own subjective portions, into those universes. These individual portions all represent the second divine puruña lying in the ocean of conception and is identical with Mahä-Viñëu in every respect. He is also spoken of as the divine guide, from within, of all souls.

Bs 5.15

TEXT 15

TEXT

vämäìgäd asåjad viñëuà

dakñiëäìgät prajäpatim

jyotir-liìga-mayaà çambhuà

kürca-deçäd aväsåjat

SYNONYMS

väma-aìgät—from His left limb; asåjat—He created; viñëum—Lord Viñëu; dakñiëa-aìgät—from His right limb; prajäpatim—Hiraëyagarbha Brahmä; jyotiù-liìga—the divine masculine manifested halo; mayam—comprising; çambhum—Çambhu; kürca-deçät—from the space between His two eyebrows; aväsåjat—He created.

TRANSLATION

The same Mahä-Viñëu created Viñëu from His left limb, Brahmä, the first progenitor of beings, from His right limb and, from the space between His two eyebrows, Çambhu, the divine masculine manifested halo.

PURPORT

The divine puruña, lying in the ocean of milk, the same who is the regulator of all individual souls, is Çré Viñëu; and Hiraëyagarbha, the seminal principle, the portion of the Supreme Lord, is the prime progenitor who is different from the four-faced Brahmä. This same Hiraëyagarbha is the principle of seminal creating energy of every Brahmä belonging to each of the infinity of universes. The divine masculine manifested halo, Çambhu, is the plenary manifestation of his prototype Çambhu, the same as the primary divine masculine generative symbol Çambhu whose nature has already been described. Viñëu is the integral subjective portion of Mahä-Viñëu. Hence He is the great Lord of all the other lords. The progenitor (Brahmä) and Çambhu are the dislocated portions of Mahä-Viñëu. Hence they are gods with delegated functions. His own potency being on the left side of Godhead, Viñëu appears in the left limb of Mahä-Viñëu from the unalloyed essence of His spiritual (cit) potency. Viñëu, who is Godhead Himself, is the inner guiding oversoul of every individual soul. He is the Personality of Godhead described in the Vedas as being of the measure of a thumb. He is the nourisher. The karmés (elevationists) worship Him as Näräyaëa, the Lord of sacrifices, and the yogés desire to merge their identities in Him as Paramätmä, by the process of their meditative trance.

Bs 5.16

TEXT 16

TEXT

ahaìkärätmakaà viçvaà

tasmäd etad vyajäyata

SYNONYMS

ahaìkära—the mundane egotistic principle; ätmakam—enshrining; viçvam—universe; tasmät—from that (Çambhu); etat—this; vyajäyata—has originated.

TRANSLATION

The function of Çambhu in relation to jévas is that this universe enshrining the mundane egotistic principle has originated from Çambhu.

PURPORT

The basic principle is the Supreme Lord Himself who is the embodiment of the principle of existence of all entities devoid of separating egotisms. In this mundane world the appearance of individual entities as separated egotistic symbols, is the limited perverted reflection of the unalloyed spiritual (cit) potency; and, as representing the primal masculine divine generative function Çambhu, it is united to the accommodating principle, viz., the mundane female organ which is the perverted reflection of the spiritual (cit) potency, Ramädevé. At this function Çambhu is nothing but the mere material causal principle embodying the extension in the shape of ingredient as matter. Again when in course of the progressive evolution of mundane creation each universe is manifested, then in the principle of Çambhu, born of the space between the two eyebrows of Viñëu, there appears the manifestation of the personality of Rudra; yet under all circumstances Çambhu fully enshrines the mundane egotistic principle. The innumerable jévas as spiritual particles emanating from the oversoul in the form of pencils of rays of effulgence, have no relation with the mundane world when they come to know themselves to be the eternal servants of the Supreme Lord. They are then incorporated into the realm of Vaikuëöha. But when they desire to lord it over Mäyä, forgetting their real identity. the egotistic principle Çambhu entering into their entities makes them identify themselves as separated enjoyers of mundane entities. Hence Çambhu is the primary principle of the egotistic mundane universe and of perverted egotism in jévas that identifies itself with their limited material bodies.

Bs 5.17

TEXT 17

TEXT

atha tais tri-vidhair veçair

léläm udvahataù kila

yoga-nidrä bhagavaté

tasya çrér iva saìgatä

SYNONYMS

atha—thereupon; taiù—with those; tri-vidhaiù—threefold; veçaiù—forms; léläm—pastimes; udvahataù—carrying on; kila—indeed; yoga-nidrä—Yoganidrä; bhagavaté—full of the ecstatic trance of eternal bliss; tasya—of Him; çréù—the goddess of fortune; iva—like; saìgatä—consorted with.

TRANSLATION

Thereupon the same great personal Godhead, assuming the threefold forms of Viñëu, Prajäpati and Çambhu, entering into the mundane universe, plays the pastimes of preservation, creation and destruction of this world. This pastime is contained in the mundane world. Hence, it being perverted, the Supreme Lord, identical with Mahä-Viñëu, prefers to consort with the goddess Yoganidrä, the constituent of His own spiritual [cit] potency full of the ecstatic trance of eternal bliss appertaining to His own divine personality.

PURPORT

The dislocated portions of the Divinity. viz., Prajäpati and Çambhu, both identifying themselves as entities who are separate from the divine essence, sport with their respective nonspiritual (acit) consorts, viz., Sävitré-devé and Umä-devé, the perverted reflections of the spiritual (cit) potency. The Supreme Lord Viñëu is the only Lord of the spiritual (cit) potency, Ramä or Lakñmé.

Bs 5.18

TEXT 18

TEXT

sisåkñäyäà tato näbhes

tasya padmaà viniryayau

tan-nälaà hema-nalinaà

brahmaëo lokam adbhutam

SYNONYMS

sisåkñäyäm—when there was the will to create; tataù—then; näbheù—from the navel; tasya—of Him; padmam—a lotus; viniryayau—came out; tat-nälam—its stem; hema-nalénam—like a golden lotus; brahmaëaù—of Brahmä; lokam—the abode; adbhutam—wonderful.

TRANSLATION

When Viñëu lying in the ocean of milk wills to create this universe, a golden lotus springs from His navel-pit. The golden lotus with its stem is the abode of Brahmä representing Brahmaloka or Satyaloka.

PURPORT

"Gold" here means the dim reflection of pure cognition.

Bs 5.19

TEXT 19

TEXT

tattväni pürva-rüòhäni

käraëäni parasparam

samaväyäprayogäc ca

vibhinnäni påthak påthak

cic-chaktyä sajjamäno 'tha

bhagavän ädi-püruñaù

yojayan mäyayä devo

yoga-nidräm akalpayat

SYNONYMS

tattväni—elements; pürva-rüòhäni—previously created; käraëäni—causes; parasparam—mutually; samaväya—of the process of conglomeration; aprayogät—from the nonapplication; ca—and; vibhinnäni—separate; påthak påthak—one from another; cit-çaktyä—with His spiritual potency; sajjamänaù—associating; atha—then; bhagavän—the Supreme Personality of Godhead; ädi-püruñaù—the primal Godhead; yojayan—causing to join; mäyayä—with Mäyä; devaù—the Lord; yoga-nidräm—Yoganidrä; akalpayat—He consorted with.

TRANSLATION

Before their conglomeration the primary elements in their nascent state remained originally separate entities. Nonapplication of the conglomerating process is the cause of their separate existence. Divine Mahä-Viñëu, primal Godhead, through association with His own spiritual [cit] potency, moved Mäyä and by the application of the conglomerating principle created those different entities in their state of cooperation. And alter that He Himself consorted with Yoganidrä by way of His eternal dalliance with His spiritual [cit] potency.

PURPORT

Mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram: "The mundane energy prakåti gives birth to this universe of animate and inanimate beings by My direction." The purport of this çloka of the Gétä is that Mäyä, the perverted reflection of spiritual (cit) potency. was at first inactive and her extension of matter constituting the material cause was also in the separately dislocated state. In accordance with the will of Kåñëa this world is manifested as the resultant of the union of the efficient and the material causal principles of Mäyä. In spite of that, the Supreme Lord Himself remains united with His cit potency. Yoganidrä. The word yoganidrä or yogamäyä indicates as follows: The nature of cit potency is manifestive of the Absolute Truth, while the nature of her perverted reflection, Mäyä, is envelopment in the gloom of ignorance. When Kåñëa desires to manifest something in the mundane ignorance-wrapt affairs, He does this by the conjunction of His spiritual potency with His inactive nonspiritual potency. This is known as Yogamäyä. It carries a twofold notion, namely. transcendental notion and mundane inert notion. Kåñëa Himself, His subjective portions and those jévas who are His unalloyed separated particles, realize the transcendental notion in that conjunction, while conditioned souls feel the mundane inert notion. The external coating of transcendental knowledge in the conscious activities of conditioned souls, bears the name of Yoganidrä. This is also an influence of the cit potency of the Divinity. This principle will be more elaborately considered hereafter.

Bs 5.20

TEXT 20

TEXT

yojayitvä tu täny eva

praviveça svayaà guhäm

guhäà praviñöe tasmiàs tu

jévätmä pratibudhyate

SYNONYMS

yojayitvä—after conglomerating; tu—then; täni—them; eva—certainly; praviveça—He entered; svayam—Himself; guhäm—the hidden cavity; guhäm—the hidden cavity; praviñöe—after He entered; tasmin—within that; tu—then; jéva-ätmä—the jévas; pratibudhyate—were awakened.

TRANSLATION

By conglomerating all those separate entities He manifested the innumerable mundane universes and Himself entered into the inmost recess of every extended conglomerate [viraò-vigraha]. At that time those jévas who had lain dormant during the cataclysm were awakened.

PURPORT

The word guhä (hidden cavity) bears various interpretations in the çästras. In some portions the nonmanifestive pastimes of the Lord is called guhä and elsewhere the resting place of the indwelling spirit of all individual souls, is named guhä. In many places the inmost recesses of the heart of each individual is termed guhä. The main point is that the place which is hidden from the view of men in general, is designated guhä. Those jévas that were merged in Hari at the end of the life of Brahmä in the great cataclysm during the preceding great age of the universe, reappeared in this world in accordance with their former fruitive desires.

Bs 5.21

TEXT 21

TEXT

sa nityo nitya-sambandhaù

prakåtiç ca paraiva sä

SYNONYMS

saù—that (jéva); nityaù—eternal; nitya-sambandhaù—possessing an eternal relationship; prakåtiù—potency; ca—and; parä—spiritual; eva—certainly; sä—that.

TRANSLATION

The same jéva is eternal and is for eternity and without a beginning joined to the Supreme Lord by the tie of an eternal kinship. He is transcendental spiritual potency.

PURPORT

Just as the sun is eternally associated with his rays so the transcendental Supreme Lord is eternally joined with the jévas. The jévas are the infinitesimal particles of His spiritual effulgence and are, therefore, not perishable like mundane things. Jévas, being particles of Godhead's effulgent rays, exhibit on a minute scale the qualities of the Divinity. Hence jévas are identical with the principles of knowledge, knower, egoism, enjoyer, meditator and doer. Kåñëa is the all-pervading, all-extending Supreme Lord; while jévas have a different nature from His, being His atomic particles. That eternal relationship consists in this that the Supreme Lord is the eternal master and jévas are His eternal servants. Jévas have also sufficient eligibility in respect of the mellow quality of the Divinity. Apareyam itas tv anyäà prakåtià viddhi me paräm. By this verse of the Gétä it is made known that jévas are His transcendental potency. All the qualities of the unalloyed soul are above the eightfold qualities such as egotism, etc., pertaining to His acit potency. Hence the jéva potency. though very small in magnitude, is still superior to acit potency or Mäyä. This potency has another name, viz., taöasthä or marginal potency. being located on the line demarcating the spheres of the spiritual and mundane potencies. He is susceptible to the influence of the material energy owing to his small magnitude. But so long as he remains submissive to Kåñëa, the Lord of Mäyä, he is not liable to the influence of Mäyä. The worldly afflictions, births and rebirths are the concomitants of the fettered condition of souls fallen into the clutches of the deluding potency from a time that has no beginning.

Bs 5.22

TEXT 22

TEXT

evaà sarvätma-sambandhaà

näbhyäà padmaà harer abhüt

tatra brahmäbhavad bhüyaç

catur-vedi catur-mukhaù

SYNONYMS

evam—thus; sarva-ätma—with all souls; sambandham—related; näbhyäm—from the navel; padmam—a lotus; hareù—of Viñëu; abhüt—sprung up; tatra—there; brahmä—Brahmä; abhavat—was born; bhüyaù—again; catuù-vedé—versed in the four Vedas; catuù-mukhaù—four-faced.

TRANSLATION

The divine lotus which springs from the navel-pit of Viñëu is in every way related by the spiritual tie with all souls and is the origin of four-faced Brahmä versed in the four Vedas.

PURPORT

The same divine lotus originating from the divine person entered into the hidden recess, is the superior plane of aggregation of all individual souls. The four-faced Brahmä, the image of self-enjoyment, derives his origin from the prototype Brahmä or Hiraëyagarbha, the mundane seminal principle, who regards the aggregate of all mundane entities as his own proper body. The delegated godship of Brahmä as well as his being the dislocated portion of Kåñëa, are also established.

Bs 5.23

TEXT 23

TEXT

saïjäto bhagavac-chaktyä

tat-kälaà kila coditaù

sisåkñäyäà matià cakre

pürva-saàskära-saàskåtaù

dadarça kevalaà dhväntaà

nänyat kim api sarvataù

SYNONYMS

saïjätaù—on being born; bhagavat-çaktyä—by the divine potency; tat-kälam—at that time; kila—indeed; coditaù—being guided; sisåkñäyäm—to the act of creation; matim—his mind; cakre—turned; pürva-saàskära-saàskåtaù—under the impulse of previous impressions; dadarça—he saw; kevalam—only; dhväntam—darkness; na—not; anyat—else; kim api—anything; sarvataù—in every direction.

TRANSLATION

On coming out of the lotus, Brahmä, being guided by the divine potency tuned his mind to the act of creation under the impulse of previous impressions. But he could see nothing but darkness in every direction.

PURPORT

Brahmä's impulse for creation arises solely from his previous impressions. All jévas get their nature conformably to their impressions of previous births and accordingly their activity can have a beginning. It is called "the unseen" or the result of one's previous deeds. His natural impulse is formed according to the nature of the deeds done by him in the previous kalpa. Some of the eligible jévas also attain to the office of Brahmä in this way.

Bs 5.24

TEXT 24

TEXT

uväca puratas tasmai

tasya divyä sarasvaté

käma-kåñëäya govinda

he gopé-jana ity api

vallabhäya priyä vahner

mantram te däsyati priyam

SYNONYMS

uväca—said; purataù—in front; tasmai—to him; tasya—of Him (the Supreme Lord); divyä—divine; sarasvaté—the goddess of learning; käma—the käma-béja (kléà); kåñëäya—to Kåñëa; govinda-govindäya, to Govinda; he—O; gopé-jana—of the gopés; iti—thus; api—also; vallabhäya—to the dear one; priyä vahneù—the wife of Agni, Svähä (the word svähä is uttered while offering oblations); mantram-mantra; te—to you; däsyati—will give; priyam—the heart's desire.

TRANSLATION

Then the goddess of learning Sarasvaté, the divine consort of the Supreme Lord, said thus to Brahmä who saw nothing but gloom in all directions, "O Brahmä, this mantra, viz., kléà kåñëäya govindäya gopé-jana-vallabhäya svähä, will assuredly fulfill your heart's desire."

PURPORT

The mantra, consisting of the eighteen divine letters prefixed by the käma-béja, is alone superexcellent. It has a twofold aspect. One aspect is that it tends to make the pure soul run after all-attractive Çré Kåñëa, the Lord of Gokula and the divine milkmaids. This is the acme of the spiritual tendency of jévas. When the devotee is free from all sorts of mundane desires and willing to serve the Lord he attains the fruition of his heart's desire, viz., the love of Kåñëa. But in the case of the devotee who is not of unmixed aptitude this superexcellent mantra fulfills his heart's desire also. The transcendental käma-béja is inherent in the divine logos located in Goloka; and the käma-béja pervertedly reflected in the worldly affairs satisfies all sorts of desires of this mundane world.

Bs 5.25

TEXT 25

TEXT

tapas tvaà tapa etena

tava siddhir bhaviñyati

SYNONYMS

tapaù—spiritual austerity; tvam—you; tapa—practice; etena—by this; tava—your; siddhiù—fulfillment; bhaviñyati—will be.

TRANSLATION

"O Brahmä, do thou practice spiritual association by means of this mantra; then all your desires will be fulfilled."

PURPORT

Its purport is clear.

Bs 5.26

TEXT 26

TEXT

atha tepe sa suciraà

préëan govindam avyayam

çvetadvépa-patià kåñëaà

goloka-sthaà parät param

prakåtyä guëa-rüpiëyä

rüpiëyä paryupäsitam

sahasra-dala-sampanne

koöi-kiïjalka-båàhite

bhümiç cintämaëis tatra

karëikäre mahäsane

samäsénaà cid-änandaà

jyoti-rüpaà sanätanam

çabda-brahma-mayaà veëuà

vädayantaà mukhämbuje

viläsiné-gaëa-våtaà

svaiù svair aàçair abhiñöutam

SYNONYMS

atha—then; tepe—practiced austerity; saù—he (Brahmä); suciram—for a long time; préëan—satisfying; govindam—Govinda; avyayam—imperishable; çvetadvépa-patim—the Lord of Çvetadvépa; kåñëam—Kåñëa; goloka-stham—situated in Goloka; parät param—the greatest of all; prakåtyä—by the external energy; guëa-rüpiëyä—embodying all mundane qualities; rüpiëyä—possessing form; paryupäsitam—worshiped from outside; sahasra-dala-sampanne—on a lotus of a thousand petals; koöi-kiïjalka—by millions of filaments; båàhite—augmented; bhümiù—the land; cintämaëiù—magical touchstone; tatra—there; karëikäre—on the whorl; mahä-äsane—on a great throne; samäsénam—seated; cit-änandam—the form of transcendental bliss; jyotiù-rüpam—the form of effulgence; sanätanam—eternal; çabda-brahma—divine sound; mayam—comprising; veëum—the flute; vädayantam—playing; mukha-ambuje—at His lotus mouth; viläsiné-gaëa—by the gopés; våtam—surrounded; svaiù svaiù—own respective; aàçaiù—by subjective portions; abhiñöutam—worshiped.

TRANSLATION

Brahmä, being desirous of satisfying Govinda, practiced the cultural acts for Kåñëa in Goloka, Lord of Çvetadvépa, for a long time. His meditation ran thus, "There exists a divine lotus of a thousand petals, augmented by millions of filaments, in the transcendental land of Goloka. On its whorl, there exists a great divine throne on which is seated Çré Kåñëa, the form of eternal effulgence of transcendental bliss, playing on His divine flute resonant with the divine sound, with His lotus mouth. He is worshiped by His amorous milkmaids with their respective subjective portions and extensions and also by His external energy [who stays outside] embodying all mundane qualities."

PURPORT

Although the object of meditation is fully transcendental, yet owing to her nature which is permeated with the quality of active mundane hankering, Mäyä, the nonspiritual potency of Kåñëa, embodying the principles of mixed sattva, rajas, and tamas, in the forms of Durgä, and other nonspiritual powers, meditated on the Supreme Lord Kåñëa as the object of their worship. So long as there is any trace of mundane desire in one's heart, it is the object of worship of Mäyädevé (Durgä) who has to be worshiped by such a person; nevertheless the fulfillment of one's heart's desire results from the worship of the object of worship of Mäyädevé, and not from the worship of Mäyädevé herself. This is in accordance with the çloka, akämaù sarva-kämo vä mokña-käma udära-dhiù/ tévreëa bhakti-yogena yajeta puruñaà param. The meaning of this çloka of the Bhägavatam is that though other gods, as distinct manifestations of the Supreme Lord, are bestowers of sundry specific boons, yet a sensible person should worship the all powerful Supreme Lord, giver of all good, with unalloyed devotion, without worshiping those mundane gift-giving deities. Accordingly. Brahmä meditated upon Kåñëa in Goloka, the object of the worship, from a distance, of Mäyädevé. True devotion is unalloyed devotional activity free from all mundane desire. The devotion of Brahmä, etc., is not unmixed devotion. But there is a stage of unmixed predilection even in devotion for the attainment of one's selfish desire. This has been fully described in the concluding five çlokas of this work. That is the easiest method of divine service, prior to the attainment of self-realization, by fallen souls.

Bs 5.27

TEXT 27

TEXT

atha veëu-ninädasya

trayé-mürti-mayé gatiù

sphuranté praviveçäçu

mukhäbjäni svayambhuvaù

gäyatréà gäyatas tasmäd

adhigatya sarojajaù

saàskåtaç cädi-gunuëä

dvijatäm agamat tataù

SYNONYMS

atha—then; veëu-ninädasya—of the sound of the flute; trayé-mürti-mayé—the mother of the three Vedas; gatiù—the means (the Gäyatré mantra); sphuranti—being made manifest; praviveça—entered; äçu—quickly; mukha-abjäni—the lotus faces; svayambhuvaù—of Brahmä; gäyatrém—the Gäyatré; gäyataù—sounding; tasmät—from Him (Çré Kåñëa); adhigatya—having received; saroja-jaù—the lotus-born (Brahmä); saàskåtaù—initiated; ca—and; ädi-guruëä—by the primal preceptor; dvijatäm—the status of the twice-born; agamat—attained; tataù—thereafter.

TRANSLATION

Then Gäyatré, mother of the Vedas, being made manifest, i.e. imparted, by the divine sound of the flute of Çré Kåñëa, entered into the lotus mouth of Brahmä, born from himself, through his eight ear-holes. The lotus-born Brahmä having received the Gäyatré, sprung from the flute-song of Çré Kåñëa, attained the status of the twice-born, having been initiated by the supreme primal preceptor, Godhead Himself.

PURPORT

The sound of Kåñëa's flute is the transcendental blissful sound; hence the archetype of all Veda, is present in it. The Gäyatré is Vedic rhythm. It contains a brief meditation and prayer. Käma-gäyatré is the highest of all the Gäyatrés, because the meditation and prayer contained in it are full of the perfect transcendental sportive activities which are not to be found in any other Gäyatré. The Gäyatré that is attained as the sequel of the eighteen-lettered mantra is käma-gäyatré which runs thus: kléà käma-deväya vidmahe puñpa-bäëäya dhémahi tan no 'naìgaù pracodayät. In this Gäyatré, the realization of the transcendental pastimes of Çré Gopéjana-vallabha after perfect meditation and the prayer for the attainment of the transcendental god of love are indicated. In the spiritual world there is no better mode of endeavor for securing the superexcellent rasa-bedewed love. As soon as that Gäyatré entered into the ear-holes of Brahmä, he became the twice-born and began to chant the Gäyatré. Whoever has received the same Gäyatré in reality, has attained his spiritual rebirth. The status of a twice-born that is obtained in accordance with one's worldly nature and lineage, by the fettered souls in this mundane world, is far inferior to that of the twice-born who obtains admission into the transcendental world; because the initiation or acquisition of transcendental birth as a result of spiritual initiation is the highest of glories in as much as the jéva is thereby enabled to attain to the transcendental realm.

Bs 5.28

TEXT 28

TEXT

trayyä prabuddho 'tha vidhir

véjïäta-tattva-sägaraù

tuñöäva veda-säreëa

stotreëänena keçavam

SYNONYMS

trayyä—by the embodiment of the three Vedas; prabuddhaù—enlightened; atha—then; vidhiù—Brahmä; vijïäta—acquainted with; tattva-sägaraù—the ocean of truth; tuñöäva—worshiped; veda-säreëa—which is the essence of all Vedas; stotreëa—by the hymn; anena—this; keçavam—Çré Kåñëa.

TRANSLATION

Enlightened by the recollection of that Gäyatré, embodying the three Vedas, Brahmä became acquainted with the expanse of the ocean of truth. Then he worshiped Çré Kåñëa, the essence of all Vedas, with this hymn.

PURPORT

Brahmä thought thus within himself, "By the recollection of käma-gäyatré it seems to me that I am the eternal maidservant of Kåñëa." Though the other mysteries in regard to the condition of the maidservant of Kåñëa were not revealed to him, Brahmä, by dint of his searching self-consciousness, became well acquainted with the ocean of truth. All the truths of the Vedas were revealed to him and with the help of those essences of the Vedas he offered this hymn to the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa. Çrémän Mahäprabhu has taught this hymn to His favorite disciples in as much as it fully contains all the transcendental truths regarding the Vaiñëava philosophy. Readers are requested to study and try to enter into the spirit of his hymn with great care and attention, as a regular daily function.

Bs 5.29

TEXT 29

TEXT

cintämaëi-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña-

lakñävåteñu surabhér abhipälayantam

lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänaà

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

cintämaëi—touchstone; prakara—groups made of; sadmasu—in abodes; kalpa-våkña—of desire trees; lakña—by millions; ävåteñu—surrounded; surabhéù—surabhi cows; abhipälayantam—tending; lakñmé—of goddesses of fortune; sahasra—of thousands; çata—by hundreds; sambhrama—with great respect; sevyamänam—being served; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor who is tending the cows, yielding all desire, in abodes built with spiritual gems, surrounded by millions of purpose trees, always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds of thousands of lakñmés or gopés.

PURPORT

By the word cintämaëi is meant "transcendental gem." Just as Mäyä builds this mundane universe with the five material elements, so the spiritual (cit) potency has built the spiritual world of transcendental gems. The cintämaëi which serves as material in the building of the abode of the Supreme Lord of Goloka, is a far rarer and more agreeable entity than the philosopher's stone. The purpose tree yields only the fruits of piety, wealth, fulfillment of desire and liberation; but the purpose trees in the abode of Kåñëa bestow innumerable fruits in the shape of checkered divine love. Käma-dhenus (cows yielding the fulfillment of desire) give milk when they are milked; but the käma-dhenus of Goloka pour forth oceans of milk in the shape of the fountain of love showering transcendental bliss that does away with the hunger and thirst of all pure devotees. The words lakña and sahasra-çata signify endless numbers. The word sambhrama or sädara indicates "being saturated with love." Here lakñmé denotes gopé. Ädi-puruña means, "He who is the primeval Lord."

[Ädi 5.22]

Bs 5.30

TEXT 30

TEXT

veëuà kvaëantam aravinda-daläyatäkñam-

barhävataàsam asitämbuda-sundaräìgam

kandarpa-koöi-kamanéya-viçeña-çobhaà

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

veëum—the flute; kvaëantam—playing; aravinda-dala—(like) lotus petals; äyata—blooming; akñam—whose eyes; barha—a peacock's feather; avataàsam—whose ornament on the head; asita-ambuda—(tinged with the hue of) blue clouds; sundara—beautiful; aìgam—whose figure; kandarpa—of Cupids; koöi—millions; kamanéya—charming; viçeña—unique; çobham—whose loveliness; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is adept in playing on His flute, with blooming eyes like lotus petals with head decked with peacock's feather, with the figure of beauty tinged with the hue of blue clouds, and His unique loveliness charming millions of Cupids.

PURPORT

The matchless beauty of Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord of Goloka, is being described. Kåñëa, the all-pervading cognition, has a spiritual form of His own. The form of Kåñëa is not a fanciful creation of imagination formed after visualizing the beautiful things of the world. What Brahmä saw in his ecstatic trance of pure devotion, is being described. Kåñëa is engaged in playing upon His flute. That flute by his enchanting musical sound attracts the hearts of all living beings. Just as a lotus petal produces a pleasant sight, so the two beautiful eyes of Kåñëa who causes the manifestation of our spiritual vision, display the unlimited splendor and beauty of His moonlike face. The loveliness that adorns His head with peacock feather figures, the corresponding feature of the spiritual beauty of Kåñëa. Just as a mass of blue clouds offers a specifically soothing, pleasant view, the complexion of Kåñëa is analogously tinged with a spiritual dark-blue color. The beauty and loveliness of Kåñëa is far more enchanting that that of Cupid multiplied a millionfold.

Bs 5.31

TEXT 31

TEXT

älola-candraka-lasad-vanamälya-vaàçé-

ratnäìgadaà praëaya-keli-kalä-viläsam

çyämaà tri-bhaìga-lalitaà niyata-prakäçaà

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

älola—swinging; candraka—with a moon-locket; lasat—beautified; vana-mälya—a garland of flowers; vaàçé—flute; ratna-aìgadam—adorned with jeweled ornaments; praëaya—of love; keli-kalä—in pastimes; viläsam—who always revels; çyämam—Çyämasundara; tri-bhaìga—bending in three places; lalitam—graceful; niyata—eternally; prakäçam—manifest; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, round whose neck is swinging a garland of flowers beautified with the moon-locket, whose two hands are adorned with the flute and jeweled ornaments, who always revels in pastimes of love, whose graceful threefold-bending form of Çyämasundara is eternally manifest.

PURPORT

In the çloka beginning with cintämaëi-prakara the transcendental region and the spiritual names of Govinda, in the çloka beginning with veëuà kvaëantam, the eternal beautiful form of Govinda and in this çloka the amorous pastimes of Govinda, the embodiment of His sixty-four excellences, have been described. All the spiritual affairs that come within the scope of description in the narration of the ecstatic mellow quality (rasa) are included in the spiritual amorous sports of Govinda.

Bs 5.32

TEXT 32

TEXT

aìgäni yasya sakalendriya-våtti-manti

paçyanti pänti kalayanti ciraà jaganti

änanda-cinmaya-sad-ujjvala-vigrahasya

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

aìgäni—the limbs; yasya—of whom; sakala-indriya—of all the organs; våtti-manti—possessing the functions; paçyanti—see; pänti—maintain; kalayanti—manifest; ciram—eternally; jaganti—the universes; änanda—bliss; cit—truth; maya—full of; sat—substantiality; ujjvala—full of dazzling splendor; vigrahasya—whose form; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, whose transcendental form is full of bliss, truth, substantiality and is thus full of the most dazzling splendor. Each of the limbs of that transcendental figure possesses in Himself, the full-fledged functions of all the organs, and eternally sees, maintains and manifests the infinite universes, both spiritual and mundane.

PURPORT

For want of a taste of things spiritual, a grave doubt arises in the minds of those who are enchained by worldly knowledge. On hearing a narration of the pastimes of Kåñëa they think that the truth (tattva) regarding Kåñëa is the mental concoction of certain learned scholars, created by their imaginative brains out of material drawn from the mundane principles. With the object of removing this harmful doubt, Brahmä in this and the three following çlokas, after distinguishing between the two things, viz., spirit and matter, in a rational manner, has tried to make one understand the pure lélä of Kåñëa, obtained by his unmixed ecstatic trance. Brahmä wants to say that the form of Kåñëa is all "existence, all-knowledge and all-bliss, whereas all mundane experiences are full of palpable ignorance. Although there is specific difference between the two, the fundamental truth is that spiritual affairs constitute the absolute source. Specification and variegatedness are ever present in it. By them are established the transcendental abode, form, name, quality and sports of Kåñëa. It is only by a person, possessed of pure spiritual knowledge and freedom from any relationship with Mäyä, that those amorous pastimes of Kåñëa can at all be appreciated. The spiritual abode, the seat of pastimes, emanated from the cit potency and formed of cintämaëi (transcendental philosopher's stone), and the figure of Kåñëa, are all spiritual. Just as Mäyä is the perverted reflection of the spiritual potency. the variegatedness created by Mäyä (ignorance) is also a perverted reflection of spiritual variegatedness. So a mere semblance of the spiritual variegatedness is only noticed in this mundane world. Notwithstanding such semblance the two are wholly different from one another. The unwholesomeness of matter is its defect; but in the spirit there is variegatedness which is free from any fault or contamination. The soul and the body of Kåñëa are identical, whereas the body and soul of fallen creatures are not so. In the spiritual sphere there is no such difference as that between the body and soul, between the limbs and their proprietor, between the attributes and the object possessing them, of this world. But such difference really exists in the case of conditioned souls. Limbed though Kåñëa is, His every limb is the whole entity. He performs all varieties of divine spiritual functions with every one of His limbs. Hence He is an indivisible whole and a perfect transcendental entity. Both jéva-soul and Kåñëa are transcendental. So they belong to the same category. But they differ in this that the transcendental attributes exist in the jéva-soul in infinitesimally small degrees, whereas in Kåñëa they are found in their fullest perfection. Those attributes manifest themselves in their proper infinitesimality only when the jéva-soul attains his unadulterated spiritual status. The jéva-soul attains the nearest approach to the absolute identity only when the spiritual force of ecstatic energy appears in him by the grace of Kåñëa. Still Kåñëa remains the object of universal homage by reason of His possession of certain unique attributes. These fourfold unrivaled attributes do not manifest themselves in Näräyaëa, the Lord of Vaikuëöha or in primeval puruña-avatäras, or in the highest deities such as Çiva, not to speak of jévas.

Bs 5.33

TEXT 33

TEXT

advaitam acyutam anädim ananta-rüpam

ädyaà puräëa-puruñaà nava-yauvanaà ca

vedeñu durlabham adurlabham ätma-bhaktau

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

advaitam—without a second; acyutam—without decay; anädim—without a beginning; ananta-rüpam—whose form is endless, or who possesses unlimited forms; ädyam—the beginning; puräëa-puruñam—the most ancient person; nava-yauvanam—a blooming youth; ca—also; vedeñu—through the Vedas; durlabham—inaccessible; adurlabham—not difficult to obtain; ätma-bhaktau—through pure devotion of the soul; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is inaccessible to the Vedas, but obtainable by pure unalloyed devotion of the soul, who is without a second, who is not subject to decay, is without a beginning, whose form is endless, who is the beginning, and the eternal puruña; yet He is a person possessing the beauty of blooming youth.

PURPORT

Advaita means "indivisible truth who is knowledge absolute." Brahman, the infinite, emanates from Him as His effulgence and God-immanent (Paramätmä) as His constituent; but nevertheless He remains one and indivisible. Acyuta means that though myriads of avatäras emanate from Him as subjective portions and millions of jévas as separated spiritual particles, still He remains intact as the undivided whole of fullest perfection. Though He indulges in exhibiting the pastimes of births, etc., still He is without a beginning. Though He disappears after the pastimes of His appearance, still He is eternal. Though without origin, yet He is with an origin in His pastime of appearance; and although eternal in essence, He is still a person in the full bloom of youth. The sum and substance of it is that though He possesses diverse and apparently mutually contradictory qualities, still they are in universal harmonious concordance by dint of His unthinkable potency. This is what is meant by cid-dharma (transcendental nature) as distinguished from the material. His graceful threefold-bending form with flute in hand, possesses eternal blooming youth and is above all unwholesomeness that is to be found in limited time and space. In the transcendental realm there is no past and future but only the unalloyed and immutable present time. In the transcendental sphere there is no distinction between the object and its qualities and no such identity as is found in the limited mundane region. Hence those qualities that seem to be apparently contradictory in the light of mundane conception limited by time and space, exist in agreeable and dainty concordance in the spiritual realm. How can the jéva realize such unprecedented existence? The limited intellectual function of the jéva is always contaminated by the influence of time and space and is, therefore, not in a position to shake off this limitedness. If the potency of cognitive function does not extend to the realization of the transcendental, what else can? In reply. Brahmä says that the transcendental Absolute is beyond the reach of the Vedas. The Vedas originate in sound and sound originates in the mundane ether. So the Vedas cannot present before us a direct view of the transcendental world (Goloka). It is only when the Vedas are imbued with the cit potency that they are enabled to deal with the transcendental. But Goloka reveals itself to every jéva-soul when he is under the influence of the spiritual cognitive potency joined to the essence of ecstatic energy. The ecstatic function of devotion is boundless and is surcharged with unalloyed transcendental knowledge. That knowledge reveals goloka-tattva (the principle of the highest transcendental) in unison with devotion, without asserting itself separately but as a subsidiary to unalloyed devotion.

Bs 5.34

TEXT 34

TEXT

panthäs tu koöi-çata-vatsara-sampragamyo

väyor athäpi manaso muni-puìgavänäm

so 'py asti yat-prapada-sémny avicintya-tattve

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

panthäù—the path; tu—but; koöi-çata—thousands of millions; vatsara—of years; sampragamyaù—extending over; väyoù—of wind; atha api—or; manasaù—of the mind; muni-puìgavänäm—of the foremost jïänés; saù—that (path); api—only; asti—is; yat—of whom; prapada—of the toe; sémni—to the tip; avicintya-tattve—beyond material conception; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, only the tip of the toe of whose lotus feet is approached by the yogés who aspire after the transcendental and betake themselves to präëäyäma by drilling the respiration; or by the jïänés who try to find out the nondifferentiated Brahman by the process of elimination of the mundane, extending over thousands of millions of years.

PURPORT

The attainment of the lotus feet of Govinda consists in the realization of unalloyed devotion. The kaivalya (realized nonalternative state) which is attained by the añöäìga-yogis by practicing trance for thousands of millions of years and the state of merging into the nondifferentiated impersonality of Godhead beyond the range of limitation attained by nondualists after a similar period passed in distinguishing between the spiritual and nonspiritual and eliminating things of the limited sphere one after another by the formula "not this, not that," are simply the outskirts of the lotus feet of Kåñëa and not the lotus feet themselves. The long and short of the matter is this, kaivalya or merging into the Brahman constitutes the line of demarcation between the world of limitation and the transcendental world. For, unless we step beyond them, we can have no taste of the variegatedness of the transcendental sphere. These conditions are the simple absence of misery arising from mundane affinity but are not real happiness or felicity. If the absence of misery be called a bit of pleasure then also that bit is very small and of no consequence. It is not sufficient to destroy the condition of materiality; but the real gain to the jéva is his eternal existence in his self-realized state. This can be attained only by the grace of unalloyed devotion which is essentially cit or transcendental in character. For this end abstract and uninteresting mental speculation is of no avail.

Bs 5.35

TEXT 35

TEXT

eko 'py asau racayituà jagad-aëòa-koöià

yac-chaktir asti jagad-aëòa-cayä yad-antaù

aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-stham-

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

ekaù—one; api—although; asau—He; racayitum—to create; jagat-aëòa—of universes; koöim—millions; yat—whose; çaktiù—potency; asti—there is; jagat-aëòa-cayäù—all the universes; yat-antaù—within whom; aëòa-antara-stha—which are scattered throughout the universe; parama-aëu-caya—the atoms; antara-stham—situated within; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

He is an undifferentiated entity as there is no distinction between potency and the possessor thereof. In His work of creation of millions of worlds, His potency remains inseparable. All the universes exist in Him and He is present in His fullness in every one of the atoms that are scattered throughout the universe, at one and the same time. Such is the primeval Lord whom I adore.

PURPORT

Kåñëa is the highest of all entities. In Him is an entity which is termed cit (spiritual) which is distinct from the principle of limitation. By His inconceivable power, He can at will create numberless universes. All the mundane universes owe their origin to the transformation of His external potency. Again His abode is beyond human conception; since all worlds, limited and spiritual (cit) exist in Him and He resides simultaneously in His fullness and entirety in all the atoms in all the worlds. All-pervasiveness is only a localized aspect of the majesty of Kåñëa, the Lord of all. Though He is all-pervasive yet in His existence everywhere in a medium shape consists His spiritual Lordship beyond human conception. This argument favors the doctrine of simultaneous inconceivable distinction and nondistinction, and knocks down the contaminating Mäyäväda and other allied doctrines.

Bs 5.36

TEXT 36

TEXT

yad-bhäva-bhävita-dhiyo manujäs tathaiva

sampräpya rüpa-mahimäsana-yäna-bhüñäù

süktair yam eva nigama-prathitaiù stuvanti

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

yat—for whom; bhäva—with devotion; bhävita—are imbued; dhiyaù—whose hearts; manujäù—men; tathä eva—similarly; sampräpya—having gained; rüpa—beauty; mahima—greatness; äsana—thrones; yäna—conveyances; bhüñäù—and ornaments; süktaiù—by Vedic hymns; yam—whom; eva—certainly; nigama—by the Vedas; prathitaiù—told; stuvanti—offer praise; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I adore the same Govinda, the primeval Lord, in whose praise men, who are imbued with devotion, sing the mantra-süktas told by the Vedas, by gaining their appropriate beauty, greatness, thrones, conveyances and ornaments.

PURPORT

In discussing rasa we meet with five kinds of devotion or service. Çänta or unattached, däsya or pertaining to reverential willing service, sakhya or friendship, vätsalya or parental love and çåìgära or juvenile love.

The devotees surcharged with the ideas of their respective service, serve Kåñëa eternally and ultimately reach the goal of their respective ideals. They attain the real nature of their self befitting their respective rasas, their glories, conveyances, seats befitting their sacred service, and transcendental qualities of ornaments enhancing the beauty of their real nature. Those who are advocates of çänta-rasa attain the region of Brahma-Paramätmä, the seat of eternal peace; those of däsya-rasa get to Vaikuëöha, the spiritual majestic abode of Çré Näräyaëa; those of sakhya, vätsalya and madhura-rasa (juvenile love) attain Goloka-dhäma, Kåñëa's abode, above Vaikuëöha. They worship Kåñëa by the süktas depicted in the Vedas with the ingredients and objects befitting their respective rasas, in those regions. The Vedas, under the influence of the spiritual potency in certain passages speak of the pastimes of the Supreme Lord. The liberated souls chant the name, qualities and pastimes of the Supreme Lord, under the guidance of the same spiritual potency.

Bs 5.37

TEXT 37

TEXT

änanda-cinmaya-rasa-pratibhävitäbhis

täbhir ya eva nija-rüpatayä kaläbhiù

goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhüto

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

änanda—bliss; cit—and knowledge; maya—consisting of; rasa—mellows; prati—every second; bhävitäbhiù—who are engrossed with; täbhiù—with those; yaù—who; eva—certainly; nija-rüpatayä—with His own form; kaläbhiù—who are parts of portions of His pleasure potency; goloke—in Goloka Våndävana; eva—certainly; nivasati—resides; akhila-ätma—as the soul of all; bhütaù—who exists; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original personality; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, residing in His own realm, Goloka, with Rädhä, resembling His own spiritual figure, the embodiment of the ecstatic potency possessed of the sixty-four artistic activities, in the company of Her confidantes [sakhés], embodiments of the extensions of Her bodily form, permeated and vitalized by His ever-blissful spiritual rasa.

PURPORT

Although the Lord Absolute and His potency are one and the self-same existence, still They exist eternally as separate entities, as Rädhä and Kåñëa. In both the ecstatic energy and the transcendental Lord Kåñëa, there exists çåìgära-rasa (amorous love) whose quality is inconceivable. The vibhäva (extension) of that rasa (mellow quality) is twofold, viz., älambana (prop) and uddépana (stimulation). Of these älambana is twofold, viz., äçraya (supported) and viñaya (supporter). Äçraya signifies Rädhikä Herself and the extensions of Her own form and viñaya means Kåñëa Himself. Kåñëa is Govinda, Lord of Goloka. The gopés are the facsimile äçraya of that rasa. With them Kåñëa indulges in eternal pastimes in Goloka. Nija-rüpatayä means "with the attributes manifested from the ecstatic energy." The sixty-four activities in fine arts and crafts are the following: (1) géta—art of singing. (2) vädya—art of playing on musical instruments. (3) nåtya—art of dancing. (4) näöya—art of theatricals. (5) älekhya—art of painting. (6) viçeñakacchedya—art of painting the face and body with colored unguents and cosmetics. (7) taëòula-kusuma-balé-vikära—art of preparing offerings from rice and flowers. (8) puñpästaraëa—art of making a covering of flowers for a bed. (9) daçana-vasanäìga-räga—art of applying preparations for cleansing the teeth, cloths and painting the body. (10) maëi-bhümikä-karma—art of making the groundwork of jewels. (11) çayyä-racana—art of covering the bed. (12) udaka-vädya—art of playing on music in water. (13) udaka-ghäta—art of splashing with water. (14) citra-yoga—art of practically applying an admixture of colors. (15) mälya-grathana-vikalpa—art of designing a preparation of wreaths. (16) çekharäpéòa-yojana—art of practically setting the coronet on the head. (17) nepathya-yoga—art of practically dressing in the tiring room. (18) karëapätra-bhaìga—art of decorating the tragus of the ear. (19) sugandha-yukti—art of practical application of aromatics. (20) bhüñaëa-yojana—art of applying or setting ornaments. (21) aindra-jäla—art of jugglery. (22) kaucumära—a kind of art. (23) hasta-läghava—art of sleight of hand. (24) citra-çäkäpüpa-bhakñya-vikära-kriyä—art of preparing varieties of salad, bread, cake and delicious food. (25) pänaka-rasa-rägäsava-yojana—art of practically preparing palatable drinks and tinging draughts with red color. (26) sücé-väya-karma—art of needleworks and weaving. (27) sütra-kréòä—art of playing with thread. (28) véëä-òamuraka-vädya—art of playing on lute and small x-shaped drum. (29) prahelikä—art of making and solving riddles. (29-a) pratimälä—art of caping or reciting verse for verse as a trial for memory or skill. (30) durvacaka-yoga—art of practicing language difficult to be answered by others. (31) pustaka-väcana—art of reciting books. (32) näöikäkhyäyikä-darçana—art of enacting short plays and anecdotes. (33) kävya-samasyä-püraëa—art of solving enigmatic verses. (34) paööikä-vetra-bäëa-vikalpa—art of designing preparation of shield, cane and arrows. (35) tarku-karma—art of spinning by spindle. (36) takñaëa—art of carpentry. (37) västu-vidyä—art of engineering. (38) raupya-ratna-parékñä—art of testing silver and jewels. (39) dhätu-väda—art of metallurgy. (40) maëi-räga jïäna—art of tinging jewels. (41) äkara jïäna—art of mineralogy. (42) våkñäyur-veda-yoga—art of practicing medicine or medical treatment, by herbs. (43) meña-kukkuöa-lävaka-yuddha-vidhi—art of knowing the mode of fighting of lambs, cocks and birds. (44) çuka-çärikä-prapälana (praläpana)?—art of maintaining or knowing conversation between male and female cockatoos. (45) utsädana—art of healing or cleaning a person with perfumes. (46) keça-märjana-kauçala—art of combing hair. (47) akñara-muñöikä-kathana—art of talking with letters and fingers. (48) mlecchita-kutarka-vikalpa—art of fabricating barbarous or foreign sophistry. (49) deça-bhäñä-jïäna—art of knowing provincial dialects. (50) puñpa-çakaöikä-nirmiti-jïäna—art of knowing prediction by heavenly voice or knowing preparation of toy carts by flowers. (51) yantra-mätåkä—art of mechanics. (52) dhäraëa-mätåkä—art of the use of amulets. (53) samväcya—art of conversation. (54) mänasé kävya-kriyä—art of composing verse mentally. (55) kriyä-vikalpa—art of designing a literary work or a medical remedy. (56) chalitaka-yoga—art of practicing as a builder of shrines called after him. (57) abhidhäna-koña-cchando-jïäna—art of the use of lexicography and meters. (58) vastra-gopana—art of concealment of cloths. (59) dyüta-viçeña—art of knowing specific gambling. (60) äkarña-kréòä—art of playing with dice or magnet. (61) bälaka-kréòanaka—art of using children's toys. (62) vainäyiké vidyä—art of enforcing discipline. (63) vaijayiké vidyä—art of gaining victory. (64) vaitäliké vidyä—art of awakening master with music at dawn.

All these arts manifesting their own eternal forms are ever visible in the region of Goloka as the ingredients of rasa; and, in the mundane sphere, they have been unstintedly exhibited in the pastimes of Vraja by the spiritual (cit) potency. Yogamäyä. So Çré Rüpa says, sadänantaiù... santi täù, i.e., Kåñëa is ever manifest in His beauty with His infinite pastimes in Goloka. Sometimes the variant manifestation of those pastimes becomes visible on the mundane plane. Çré Hari, the Supreme Lord, also manifests His pastimes of birth, etc., accompanied by all His paraphernalia. The divine sportive potency fills the hearts of His paraphernalia with appropriate spiritual sentiments in conformity with the will of Kåñëa. Those pastimes that manifest themselves on the mundane plane, are His visible pastimes. All those very pastimes exist in their nonvisible form in Goloka beyond the ken of mundane knowledge. In His visible pastimes Kåñëa sojourns in Gokula, Mathurä and Dvärakä. Those pastimes that are nonvisible in those three places, are visible in their spiritual sites of Våndävana.

From the conclusions just stated it is clear that there is no distinction between the visible and nonvisible pastimes. The apostle Jéva Gosvämé in his commentary on this çloka as well as in the gloss of Ujjvala-nélamaëi and in Kåñëa-sandarbha remarks that "the visible pastimes of Kåñëa are the creation of His cit (spiritual) potency. Being in conjunction with the reference to mundane function they exhibit certain features which seem to be true by the influence of the limiting potency (Mäyä); but these cannot exist in the transcendental reality. The destruction of demons, illicit paramourship, birth, etc., are examples of this peculiarity. The gopés are the extensions of the ecstatic energy of Kåñëa, and so are exceptionally His own. How can there be illicit connection in their case? The illicit mistress-ship of the gopés found in His visible pastime, is but the mundane reflection of the transcendental reality." The hidden meaning underlying the words of Çré Jéva Gosvämé, when it is made explicit, will leave no doubt in the minds of the readers. Çré Jéva Gosvämé is our preacher of transcendental truth. So he is always under the influence of Çré Rüpa and Sanätana. Moreover in the pastimes of Kåñëa Çré Jéva is one of the maïjarés. So he is conversant with all transcendental realities.

There are some who, being unable to understand the drift of his statements, give meanings of their own invention and indulge in useless controversies. Çré Rüpa and Sanätana say that there is no real and essential distinction between the léläs visible and nonvisible, the only distinction lies in this that one is manifest in the mundane sphere whereas the other is not so. In the supermundane manifestation there is absolute purity in the seer and the seen. A particularly fortunate person when he is favored by Kåñëa, can shake off worldly shackles and connections, enter the transcendental region after attaining the realized taste of the varieties of rasa that is available during the period of novitiate. Only such a person can have a view and taste of the perfect and absolutely pure lélä of Goloka. Such receptive natures are rarely to be found. He, who exists in the mundane sphere, can also realize the taste of cid-rasa by the grace of Kåñëa by being enabled to attain the realized state of service. Such a person can have a view of the pastimes of Goloka manifested in the mundane lélä of Gokula. There is certainly a difference between these two classes of eligible seekers of the truth. Until one attains the perfectly transcendental stage he must be hampered by his lingering limitations, in his vision of the pastimes of Goloka. Again, the vision of the transcendental reality varies according to the degree of self-realization. The vision of Goloka must also vary accordingly.

It is only those fettered souls who are excessively addicted to worldliness that are devoid of the devotional eye. Of them some are enmeshed by the variegatedness of the deluding energy while others aspire after self-annihilation under the influence of centrifugal knowledge. Though they might have a view of the mundanely manifested pastimes of the Supreme Lord, they can have only a material conception of those visible pastimes, this conception being devoid of transcendental reality. Hence the realization of Goloka appears in proportion to eligibility due to the degree of one's self-realization. The underlying principle is this, that, though Gokula is as holy and free from dross as Goloka, still it is manifested on the mundane plane by the influence of the cit potency. Yogamäyä. In visible and nonvisible matters of transcendental regions there is no impurity, contamination and imperfection inherent in the world of limitation; only there is some difference in the matter of realization in proportion to the self-realization of the seekers after the Absolute. Impurity, unwholesomeness, foreign elements, illusion, nescience, unholiness, utter inadequacy, insignificance, grossness—these appertain to the eye, intellect, mind and ego stultified by the material nature of conditioned souls; they have nothing to do with the essential nature of transcendence. The more one is free from these blots the more is one capable of realizing the unqualified Absolute. The truth who has been revealed by the scriptures, is free from dross. But the realizations of the seekers of the knowledge of these realities, are with or without flaw in accordance with the degree of their individual realization.

Those sixty-four arts that have been enumerated above, do in reality exist unstintedly only in Goloka. Unwholesomeness, insignificance, grossness are found in those arts in accordance with the degree of self-realization on the part of aspirants after the knowledge of the Absolute. According to Çréla Rüpa and Çréla Sanätana all those pastimes, that have been visible in Gokula, exist in all purity and free from all tinge of limitation in Goloka. So transcendental autocratic paramourship also exists in Goloka in inconceivable purity, judged by the same standard and reasoning. All manifestation by the cit potency. Yogamäyä, are pure. So, as the above paramourship is the creation of Yogamäyä, it is necessarily free from all contamination, and appertains to the absolute reality.

Let us pause to consider what the absolute reality is in Himself. Çré Rüpa Gosvämé says, pürvokta-... särataù. In regard to these çlokas Çrépäda Jéva Gosvämé after mature deliberation has established the transcendental paramourship as vibhrama-viläsa, something seemingly different from what it appears to be; such are the pastimes of birth, etc., accomplished by Yogamäyä.

By the explanation tathäpi... vraja-vanitänäm, Çréla Jéva Gosvämé has expressed his profound implication. Joyous pastimes by the medium of seeming error, vibhrama-viläsa, as the contrivance of Yogamäyä, has also been admitted in the concluding statements of Rüpa and Sanätana. Still, since Çrépäda Jéva Gosvämé has established the identity of Goloka with Gokula, it must be admitted that there is transcendental reality underlying all the pastimes of Gokula. A husband is one who binds oneself in wedlock with a girl, while a paramour is one who, in order to win another's wife's love by means of love, crosses the conventions of morality, by the impulse of the sentiment that regards her love as the be-all and end-all of existence. In Goloka there is no such function at all as that of the nuptial relationship. Hence there is no husbandhood characterized by such connection. On the other hand since the gopés, who are self-supported real entities are not tied to anybody else in wedlock, they cannot also have the state of concubinage. There can also be no separate entities in the forms of svakéya (conjugal) and parakéya (adulterous) states. In the visible pastimes on the mundane plane the function in the form of the nuptial relationship is found to exist. Kåñëa is beyond the scope of that function. Hence the said function of the circle of all-love is contrived by Yogamäyä. Kåñëa tastes the transcendental rasa akin to paramourship by overstepping that function. This pastime of going beyond the pale of the apparent moral function manifested by Yogamäyä, is, however, also observable only on the mundane plane by the eye that is enwrapped by the mundane covering; but there is really no such levity in the pastimes of Kåñëa. The rasa of paramourship is certainly the extracted essence of all the rasas. If it be said that it does not exist in Goloka, it would be highly deprecatory to Goloka. It is not the fact that there is no supremely wholesome tasting of rasa in the supremely excellent realm of Goloka. Kåñëa, the fountainhead of all avatäras. tastes the same in a distinct form in Goloka and in another distinct form in Gokula. Therefore, in spite of the seeming appearance, to the mundane eye, of outstepping the bounds of the legitimate function by the form of paramourship, there must be present the truth of it in some form even in Goloka. Ätmärämo 'py aréramat, ätmany avaruddha-saurataù, reme vraja-sundarébhir yathärbhakaù pratibimba-vibhramaù and other texts of the scriptures go to show that self-delightedness is the essential distinctive quality of Kåñëa Himself. Kåñëa in His majestic cit realm causes the manifestation of His own cit potency as Lakñmé and enjoys her as His own wedded consort. As this feeling of wedded consorthood preponderates there, rasa expands in a wholesome form only up to the state of servanthood (däsya-rasa). But in Goloka He divides up His cit potency into thousands of gopés and eternally engages in amorous pastimes with them by forgetting the sentiments of ownership. By the sentiments of ownership there cannot be the extreme inaccessibility of the rasa. So the gopés have naturally, from eternity, the innate sentiment of being others' wedded wives. Kåñëa too in response to that sentiment, by assuming the reciprocal sentiment of paramourship, performs the räsa and the other amorous pastimes with the aid of the flute, His favorite cher ami. Goloka is the transcendental seat of eternally self-realized rasa, beyond limited conception. Hence in Goloka there is realization of the sentimental assumption of the rasa of paramourship.

Again such is the nature of the principle of the majesty that in the realm of Vaikuëöha there is no rasa of parental affection towards the source of all avatäras. But in Goloka, the seat of all superexcellent deliciousness, there is no more than the original sentimental egoistic assumption of the same rasa. There Nanda and Yaçodä are visibly present, but there is no occurrence of birth. For want of the occurrence of birth the assumed egoistic sentiment of parental affection of Nanda and Yaçodä has no foundation in the actual existence of such entities as father and mother, but it is of the nature of sentimental assumption on their parts, cf. jayati jana-niväso devaké-janma-vädaù, etc. For the purpose of the realization of the rasa the assumed egoistic sentiment is, however, eternal. In the rasa of amorous love if the corresponding egoistic sentiments of concubinage and paramourship be mere eternal assumptions there is nothing to blame in them and it also does not go against the scriptures. When those transcendental entities of Goloka becomes manifest in Vraja then those two egoistic sentiments become somewhat more palpable to the mundane view in the phenomenal world and there comes to be this much difference only. In the rasa of parental affection the sentiments of Nanda and Yaçodä that they are parents becomes manifest in the more tangible form in the pastimes of birth etc., and in the amorous rasa the corresponding sentiments of concubinage in the respective gopés become manifest in the forms of their marriages with Abhimanyu, Govardhana, etc. In reality there is no such separate entity as husbandhood of the gopés either in Goloka or in Gokula. Hence the çästras declare that there is no sexual union of the gopés with their husbands. It is also for the same reason that the authorized teacher of the principle of rasa, Çré Rüpa, writes that in the transcendental amorous rasa the hero is of two different types, viz., the wedded husband and the paramour—patiç copapatiç ceti prabhedäv iha viçrutäv iti. Çré Jéva, in his commentary by his words patiù pura-vanitänäà dvitéyo vraja-vanitänäm, acknowledges the eternal paramourship of Kåñëa in Goloka and Gokula and the husbandhood of Kåñëa in Vaikuëöha and Dvärakä etc. In the Lord of Goloka and the Lord of Gokula the character of paramourship is found in its complete form. Kåñëa's deliberate overstepping of His own quality of self-delightedness is caused by the desire of union with another's wedded wife. The state of being another's wedded wife is nothing but the corresponding assumed sentiment on the part of the gopés. In reality they have no husbands with independent and separate existence; still their very egoistic sentiment makes them have the nature of the wedded wives of others. So all the characteristics, viz., that "desire makes the paramour overstep the bounds of duty." etc., are eternally present in the seat of all "deliciousness." In Vraja that very thing reveals itself, to an extent, in a form more tangible to persons with mundane eyes.

So in Goloka there is inconceivable distinction and nondistinction between the rasas analogous to mundane concubineship and wifehood. It may be said with equal truth that there is no distinction in Goloka between the two as also that there is such distinction. The essence of paramourship is the cessation of ownership and the abeyance of ownership is the enjoyment of His own cit potency in the shape of abeyance of paramourship or enjoyment without the sanction of wedlock. The conjunction of the two exists there as one rasa accommodating both varieties. In Gokula it is really the same with the difference that it produces a different impression on observers belonging to the mundane plane. In Govinda, the hero of Goloka, there exist both husbandhood and paramourship above all piety and impiety and free from all grossness. Such is also the case with the hero of Gokula although there is a distinction in realization caused by Yogamäyä. If it be urged that what is manifested by Yogamäyä is the highest truth being the creation of the cit potency and that, therefore, the impression of paramourship is also really true, the reply is that there may exist an impression of analogous sentimental egoism in the tasting of rasa free from any offense because it is not without a basis in truth. But the unwholesome impression that is produced in the mundane judgment is offensive and as such cannot exist in the pure cit realm. In fact Çrépäda Jéva Gosvämé has come to the true conclusion, and at the same time the finding of the opposing party is also inconceivably true. It is the vain empirical wranglings about wedded wifehood and concubinage which is false and full of specious verbosity. He who goes through the commentaries of Çrépäda Jéva Gosvämé and those of the opposing party with an impartial judgment cannot maintain his attitude of protest engendered by any real doubt. What the unalloyed devotee of the Supreme Lord says is all true and is independent of any consideration of unwholesome pros and cons. There is, however, the element of mystery in their verbal controversies. Those, whose judgment is made of mundane stuff, being unable to enter into the spirit of the all-loving controversies among pure devotees, due to their own want of unalloyed devotion, are apt to impute to the devotees their own defects of partisanship and opposing views. Commenting on the çloka of Räsa-païcädhyäyé, gopénäà tat-paténäà ca, etc., what Çrépäda Sanätana Gosvämé has stated conclusively in his Vaiñëava-toñaëé has been accepted with reverence by the true devotee Çrépäda Viçvanätha Cakravarté without any protest.

Whenever any dispute arises regarding the pure cognitive pastimes, such as Goloka, etc., we would do well to remember the precious advice from the holy lips of Çrémän Mahäprabhu and His associates, the Gosvämés, viz., that the Truth Absolute is ever characterized by spiritual variegatedness that transcends the variegatedness of mundane phenomena; but He is never featureless. The divine rasa is lovely with the variegatedness of the fourfold distinction of vibhäva, anubhäva, sättvika and vyabhicäri and the rasa is ever present in Goloka and Vaikuëöha. The rasa of Goloka manifests as vraja-rasa on the mundane plane for the benefit of the devotees by the power of Yogamäyä. Whatever is observable in gokula-rasa should be visible in goloka-rasa, in a clearly explicit form. Hence the distinction of paramourship and concubinage, the variegatedness of the respective rasas of all different persons, the soil, water, river, hill, portico, bower, cows, etc., all the features of Gokula exist in Goloka, disposed in an appropriate manner. There is only this peculiarity that the mundane conceptions of human beings possessed of material judgment, regarding those transcendental entities, do not exist there. The conception of Goloka manifests itself differently in proportion to the degree of realization of the various pastimes of Vraja and it is very difficult to lay down any definite criterion as to which portions are mundane and which are uncontaminated. The more the eye of devotion is tinged with the salve of love, the more will the transcendental concept gradually manifest itself. So there is no need of further hypothetical speculation which does not improve one's spiritual appreciation, as the substantive knowledge of Goloka is an inconceivable entity. To try to pursue the inconceivable by the conceptual process is like pounding the empty husk of grain, which is sure to have a fruitless ending. It is, therefore, one's bounden duty. by refraining from the endeavor to know, to try to gain the experience of the transcendental by the practice of pure devotion. Any course, the adoption of which tends to produce the impression of featurelessness, must be shunned by all means. Unalloyed parakéya-rasa free from all mundane conception is a most rare attainment. It is this which has been described in the narrative of the pastimes of Gokula. Those devotees, who follow the dictate of their pure spontaneous love, should base their devotional endeavors on that narrative. They will attain to the more wholesome fundamental principle on reaching the stage of realization. The devotional activities characterized by illicit amour, as practiced by worldly-minded conditioned souls, are forbidden mundane impiety. The heart of our apostle Çrépäda Jéva Gosvämé was very much moved by such practices and induced him to give us his conclusive statements on the subject. It is the duty of a pure Vaiñëava to accept the real spirit of his statements. It is a great offense to disrespect the äcärya and to seek to establish a different doctrine in opposition to him.

[Ädi 4.72]

Bs 5.38

TEXT 38

TEXT

premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena

santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti

yaà çyämasundaram acintya-guëa-svarüpaà

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

prema—of love; aïjana—with the salve; churita—tinged; bhakti—of devotion; vilocanena—with the eye; santaù—the pure devotees; sadä—always; eva—indeed; hådayeñu—in their hearts; vilokayanti—see; yam—whom; çyäma—dark blue; sundaram—beautiful; acintya—inconceivable; guëa—with attributes; svarüpam—whose nature is endowed; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is Çyämasundara, Kåñëa Himself with inconceivable innumerable attributes, whom the pure devotees see in their heart of hearts with the eye of devotion tinged with the salve of love.

PURPORT

The Çyämasundara form of Kåñëa is His inconceivable simultaneous personal and impersonal self-contradictory form. True devotees see that form in their purified hearts under the influence of devotional trance. The form Çyäma is not the blue color visible in the mundane world but is the transcendental variegated color affording eternal bliss, and is not visible to the mortal eye. On a consideration of the trance of Vyäsadeva as in the çloka, bhakti-yogena manasi etc., it will be clear that the form of Çré Kåñëa is the full Personality of Godhead and can only be visible in the heart of a true devotee, which is the only true seat in the state of trance under the influence of devotion. When Kåñëa manifested Himself in Vraja, both the devotees and nondevotees saw Him with this very eye; but only the devotees cherished Him, eternally present in Vraja, as the priceless jewel of their heart. Nowadays also the devotees see Him in Vraja in their hearts, saturated with devotion although they do not see Him with their eyes. The eye of devotion is nothing but the eye of the pure unalloyed spiritual self of the jéva. The form of Kåñëa is visible to that eye in proportion to its purification by the practice of devotion. When the devotion of the neophyte reaches the stage of bhäva-bhakti the pure eye of that devotee is tinged with the salve of love by the grace of Kåñëa, which enables him to see Kåñëa face to face. The phrase "in their hearts" means Kåñëa is visible in proportion as their hearts are purified by the practice of devotion. The sum and substance of this çloka is that the form of Kåñëa, who is Çyämasundara, Naöavara (Best Dancer), Muralédhara (Holder of the Flute) and Tribhaìga (Triple-bending), is not a mental concoction but is transcendental, and is visible with the eye of the soul of the devotee under trance.

Bs 5.39

TEXT 39

TEXT

rämädi-mürtiñu kalä-niyamena tiñöhan

nänävatäram akarod bhuvaneñu kintu

kåñëaù svayaà samabhavat paramaù pumän yo

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

räma-ädi—the incarnation of Lord Räma, etc.; mürtiñu—in different forms; kalä-niyamena—by the order of plenary portions; tiñöhan—existing; nänä—various; avatäram—incarnations; akarot—executed; bhuvaneñu—within the worlds; kintu—but; kåñëaù—Lord Kåñëa; svayam—personally; samabhavat—appeared; paramaù—the supreme; pumän—person; yaù—who; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who manifested Himself personally as Kåñëa and the different avatäras in the world in the forms of Räma, Nåsiàha, Vämana, etc., as His subjective portions.

PURPORT

His subjective portions as the avatäras, viz., Räma, etc., appear from Vaikuëöha and His own form Kåñëa manifests Himself with Vraja in this world, from Goloka. The underlying sense is that Kåñëa Caitanya, identical with Kåñëa Himself, also brings about by His appearance the direct manifestation of Godhead Himself.

[Ädi 5.155]

Bs 5.40

TEXT 40

TEXT

yasya prabhä prabhavato jagad-aëòa-koöi-

koöiñv açeña-vasudhädi vibhüti-bhinnam

tad brahma niñkalam anantam açeña-bhütaà

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

yasya—of whom; prabhä—the effulgence; prabhavataù—of one who excels in power; jagat-aëòa—of universes; koöi-koöiñu—in millions and millions; açeña—unlimited; vasudhä-ädi—with planets and other manifestations; vibhüti—with opulences; bhinnam—becoming variegated; tat—that; brahma—Brahman; niñkalam—without parts; anantam—unlimited; açeña-bhütam—being complete; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, whose effulgence is the source of the nondifferentiated Brahman mentioned in the Upaniñads, being differentiated from the infinity of glories of the mundane universe appears as the indivisible, infinite, limitless, truth.

PURPORT

The mundane universe created by Mäyä is one of the infinite external manifestations accommodating space, time and gross things. The impersonal aspect of Godhead, the nondifferentiated Brahman, is far above this principle of mundane creation. But even the nondifferentiated Brahman is only the external effulgence emanating from the boundary wall of the transcendental realm of Vaikuëöha displaying the triquadrantal glory of Govinda. The nondifferentiated Brahman is indivisible, hence is also one without a second, and is the infinite, and residual entity.

[Ädi 2.14] [Adi 2.14-1957] [Madhya 20.160]

Bs 5.41

TEXT 41

TEXT

mäyä hi yasya jagad-aëòa-çatäni süte

traiguëya-tad-viñaya-veda-vitäyamänä

sattvävalambi-para-sattvaà viçuddha-sattvam-

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

mäyä—the external potency; hi—indeed; yasya—of whom; jagat-aëòa—of universes; çatäni—hundreds; süte—brings forth; trai-guëya—embodying the threefold mundane qualities; tat—of that; viñaya—the subject matter; veda—the Vedic knowledge; vitäyamänä—diffusing; sattva-avalambi—the support of all existence; para-sattvam—the ultimate entity; viçuddha-sattvam—the absolute substantive principle; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is the absolute substantive principle being the ultimate entity in the form of the support of all existence whose external potency embodies the threefold mundane qualities, viz., sattva, rajas, and tamas and diffuses the Vedic knowledge regarding the mundane world.

PURPORT

The active mundane quality of rajas brings forth or generates all mundane entities. The quality of sattva (mundane manifestive principle) in conjunction with rajas stands for the maintenance of the existence of entities that are so produced, and the quality of tamas represents the principle of destruction. The substantive principle, which is mixed with the threefold mundane qualities, is mundane, while the unmixed substance is transcendental. The quality of eternal existence is the principle of absolute entity. The person whose proper form abides in that essence, is alone unalloyed entity. nonmundane, supermundane and free from all mundane quality. He is cognitive bliss. It is the deluding energy who has elaborated the regulative knowledge (Vedas) bearing on the threefold mundane quality.

Bs 5.42

TEXT 42

TEXT

änanda-cinmaya-rasätmatayä manaùsu

yaù präëinäà pratiphalan smaratäm upetya

léläyitena bhuvanäni jayaty ajasram-

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

änanda—blissful; cit-maya—cognitive; rasa—of rasa; ätmatayä—due to being the entity; manaùsu—in the minds; yaù—He who; präëinäm—of living entities; pratiphalan—being reflected; smaratäm upetya—recollecting; léläyitena—by pastimes; bhuvanäni—the mundane world; jayati—triumphantly dominates; ajasram—ever; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, whose glory ever triumphantly dominates the mundane world by the activity of His own pastimes, being reflected in the mind of recollecting souls as the transcendental entity of ever-blissful cognitive rasa.

PURPORT

Those who constantly recollect in accordance with spiritual instructions the name, figure, attributes and pastimes of the form of Kåñëa appearing in the amorous rasa, whose loveliness vanquishes the god of mundane love, conqueror of all mundane hearts, are alone meditators of Kåñëa. Kåñëa, who is full of pastimes, always manifests Himself with His realm only in the pure receptive cognition of such persons. The pastimes of that manifested divine realm triumphantly dominates in every way all the majesty and beauty of the mundane world.

Bs 5.43

TEXT 43

TEXT

goloka-nämni nija-dhämni tale ca tasya

devi maheça-hari-dhämasu teñu teñu

te te prabhäva-nicayä vihitäç ca yena

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

goloka-nämni—in the planet known as Goloka Våndävana; nija-dhämni—the personal abode of the Supreme Personality of Godhead; tale—in the part underneath; ca—also; tasya—of that; devi—of the Goddess Durgä; maheça—of Lord Çiva; hari—of Näräyaëa; dhämasu—in the planets; teñu teñu—in each of them; te te—those respective; prabhäva-nicayäù—opulences; vihitäù—established; ca—also; yena—by whom; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

Lowest of all is located Devé-dhäma [mundane world], next above it is Maheça-dhäma [abode of Maheça]; above Maheça-dhäma is placed Hari-dhäma [abode of Hari] and above them all is located Kåñëa's own realm named Goloka. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda, who has allotted their respective authorities to the rulers of those graded realms.

PURPORT

The realm of Goloka stands highest above all others. Brahmä looking up to the higher position of Goloka is speaking of the other realms from the point of view of his own realm: the first in order is this mundane world called Devé-dhäma consisting of the fourteen worlds, viz., Satyaloka, etc.; next above Devé-dhäma is located Çiva-dhäma one portion of which, called Mahäkäla-dhäma, is enveloped in darkness; interpenetrating this portion of Çiva-dhäma there shines the Sadäçivaloka, full of great light. Above the same appears Hari-dhäma or the transcendental Vaikuëöhaloka. The potency of Devé-dhäma, in the form of the extension of Mäyä, and that of Çivaloka, consisting of time, space and matter, are the potency of the separated particles pervaded by the penumbral reflection of the subjective portion of the Divinity. But Hari-dhäma is ever resplendent with transcendental majesty and the great splendor of all-sweetness predominates over all other majesties in Goloka. The Supreme Lord Govinda by his own direct and indirect power has constituted those respective potencies of those realms.

[Madhya 21.49]

Bs 5.44

TEXT 44

TEXT

såñöi-sthiti-pralaya-sädhana-çaktir ekä

chäyeva yasya bhuvanäni bibharti durgä

icchänurüpam api yasya ca ceñöate sä

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

såñöi—creation; sthiti—preservation; pralaya—and destruction; sädhana—the agency; çaktiù—potency; ekä—one; chäyä—the shadow; iva—like; yasya—of whom; bhuvanäni—the mundane world; bibharti—maintains; durgä—Durgä; icchä—the will; anurüpam—in accordance with; api—certainly; yasya—of whom; ca—and; ceñöate—conducts herself; sä—she; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

The external potency Mäyä who is of the nature of the shadow of the cit potency, is worshiped by all people as Durgä, the creating, preserving and destroying agency of this mundane world. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda in accordance with whose will Durgä conducts herself.

PURPORT

(The aforesaid presiding deity of Devé-dhäma is being described.) The world, in which Brahmä takes his stand and hymns the Lord of Goloka, is Devé-dhäma consisting of the fourteen worlds and Durgä is its presiding deity. She is ten-armed, representing the tenfold fruitive activities. She rides on the lion, representing her heroic prowess. She tramples down Mahéñäsura, representing the subduer of vices. She is the mother of two sons, Kärttikeya and Gaëeça, representing beauty and success. She is placed between Lakñmé and Sarasvaté, representing mundane opulence and mundane knowledge. She is armed with the twenty weapons, representing the various pious activities enjoined by the Vedas for suppression of vices. She holds the snake, representing the beauty of destructive time. Such is Durgä possessing all these manifold forms. Durgä is possessed of durga, which means a prison house. When jévas begotten of the marginal potency (taöasthä çakti) forget the service of Kåñëa they are confined in the mundane prison house, the citadel of Durgä. The wheel of karma is the instrument of punishment at this place. The work of purifying these penalized jévas is the duty devolved upon Durgä. She is incessantly engaged in discharging the same by the will of Govinda. When, luckily. the forgetfulness of Govinda on the part of imprisoned jévas is remarked by them by coming in contact with self-realized souls and their natural aptitude for the loving service of Kåñëa is aroused, Durgä herself then becomes the agency of their deliverance by the will of Govinda. So it behooves everybody to obtain the guileless grace of Durgä, the mistress of this prison house, by propitiating her with the selfless service of Kåñëa. The boons received from Durgä in the shape of wealth, property, recovery from illness, of wife and sons, should be realized as the deluding kindness of Durgä. The mundane psychical jubilations of daça-mahä-vidyä, the ten goddesses or forms of Durgä, are elaborated for the delusion of the fettered souls of this world. Jéva is a spiritual atomic part of Kåñëa. When he forgets his service of Kåñëa he is at once deflected by the attracting power of Mäyä in this world, who throws him into the whirlpool of mundane fruitive activity (karma) by confining him in a gross body constituted by the five material elements, their five attributes and eleven senses, resembling the garb of a prisoner. In this whirlpool jéva has experience of happiness and miseries, heaven and hell. Besides this, there is a subtle body. consisting of the mind, intelligence and ego, inside the gross body. By means of the subtle body. the jéva forsakes one gross body and takes recourse to another. The jéva cannot get rid of the subtle body. full of nescience and evil desires, unless and until he is liberated. On getting rid of the subtle body he bathes in the Virajä and goes up to Hari-dhäma. Such are the duties performed by Durgä in accordance with the will of Govinda. In the Bhägavata çloka, vilajyamänayä... durdhiyaù—the relationship between Durgä and the conditioned souls has been described.

Durgä, worshiped by the people of this mundane world, is the Durgä described above. But the spiritual Durgä, mentioned in the mantra which is the outer covering of the spiritual realm of the Supreme Lord, is the eternal maidservant of Kåñëa and is, therefore, the transcendental reality whose shadow, the Durgä of this world, functions in this mundane world as her maidservant. (Vide the purport of çloka 3.)

Bs 5.45

TEXT 45

TEXT

kñéraà yathä dadhi vikära-viçeña-yogät

saïjäyate na hi tataù påthag asti hetoù

yaù çambhutäm api tathä samupaiti käryäd

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

kñéram—milk; yathä—as; dadhi—yogurt; vikära-viçeña—of a special transformation; yogät—by the application; saïjäyate—is transformed into; na—not; hi—indeed; tataù—from the milk; påthak—separated; asti—is; hetoù—which is the cause; yaù—who; çambhutäm—the nature of Lord Çiva; api—also; tathä—thus; samupaiti—accepts; käryät—for the matter of some particular business; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

Just as milk is transformed into curd by the action of acids, but yet the effect curd is neither same as, nor different from, its cause, viz., milk, so I adore the primeval Lord Govinda of whom the state of Çambhu is a transformation for the performance of the work of destruction.

PURPORT

(The real nature of Çambhu, the presiding deity of Maheça-dhäma, is described.) Çambhu is not a second Godhead other than Kåñëa. Those, who entertain such discriminating sentiment, commit a great offense against the Supreme Lord. The supremacy of Çambhu is subservient to that of Govinda; hence they are not really different from each other. The nondistinction is established by the fact that just as milk treated with acid turns into curd so Godhead becomes a subservient when He Himself attains a distinct personality by the addition of a particular element of adulteration. This personality has no independent initiative. The said adulterating principle is constituted of a combination of the stupefying quality of the deluding energy, the quality of nonplenitude of the marginal potency and a slight degree of the ecstatic-cum-cognitive principle of the plenary spiritual potency. This specifically adulterated reflection of the principle of the subjective portion of the Divinity is Sadäçiva, in the form of the effulgent masculine-symbol-god Çambhu from whom Rudradeva is manifested. In the work of mundane creation as the material cause, in the work of preservation by the destruction of sundry asuras and in the work of destruction to conduct the whole operation, Govinda manifests Himself as guëa-avatära in the form of Çambhu who is the separated portion of Govinda imbued with the principle of His subjective plenary portion. The personality of the destructive principle in the form of time has been identified with that of Çambhu by scriptural evidences that have been adduced in the commentary. The purport of the Bhägavata çlokas, viz., vaiñëavänäà yathä çambhuù, etc., is that Çambhu, in pursuance of the will of Govinda, works in union with his consort Durgädevé by his own time energy. He teaches pious duties (dharma) as stepping-stones to the attainment of spiritual service in the various tantra-çästras, etc., suitable for jévas in different grades of the conditional existence. In obedience to the will of Govinda, Çambhu maintains and fosters the religion of pure devotion by preaching the cult of illusionism (Mäyäväda) and the speculative ägama-çästras. The fifty attributes of individual souls are manifest in a far vaster measure in Çambhu and five additional attributes not attainable by jévas are also partly found in him. So Çambhu cannot be called a jéva. He is the lord of jéva but yet partakes of the nature of a separated portion of Govinda.

[Madhya 20.310]

Bs 5.46

TEXT 46

TEXT

dépärcir eva hi daçäntaram abhyupetya

dépäyate vivåta-hetu-samäna-dharmä

yas tädåg eva hi ca viñëutayä vibhäti

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

dépa-arciù—the flame of a lamp; eva—as; hi—certainly; daçä-antaram—another lamp; abhyupetya—expanding; dépäyate—illuminates; vivåta-hetu—with its expanded cause; samäna-dharmä—equally powerful; yaù—who; tädåk—similarly; eva—indeed; hi—certainly; ca—also; viñëutayä—by His expansion as Lord Viñëu; vibhäti—illuminates; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

The light of one candle being communicated to other candles, although it burns separately in them, is the same in its quality. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda who exhibits Himself equally in the same mobile manner in His various manifestations.

PURPORT

The presiding Deities of Hari-dhäma, viz., Hari, Näräyaëa, Viñëu, etc., the subjective portions of Kåñëa, are being described. The majestic manifestation of Kåñëa is Näräyaëa, Lord of Vaikuëöha, whose subjective portion is Käraëodakaçäyé Viñëu, the prime cause, whose portion is Garbhodakaçäyé. Kñérodakaçäyé is again the subjective portion of Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu. The word "Viñëu" indicates all-pervading, omnipresent and omniscient personality. In this çloka the activities of the subjective portions of the Divinity are enunciated by the specification of the nature of Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu. The personality of Viñëu, the embodied form of the manifestive quality (sattva-guëa) is quite distinct from that of Çambhu who is adulterated with mundane qualities. Viñëu's subjective personality is on a level with that of Govinda. Both consist of the unadulterated substantive principle. Viñëu in the form of the manifest causal principle is identical with Govinda as regards quality. The manifestive quality (sattva-guëa) that is found to exist in the triple mundane quality, is an adulterated entity. being alloyed with the qualities of mundane activity and inertia. Brahmä is the dislocated portion of the Divinity, manifested in the principle of mundane action, endowed with the functional nature of His subjective portion; and Çambhu is the dislocated portion of the Divinity manifested in the principle of mundane inertia possessing similarly the functional nature of His subjective portion. The reason for their being dislocated portions is that the two principles of mundane action and inertia being altogether wanting in the spiritual essence any entities, that are manifested in them, are located at a great distance from the Divinity Himself or His facsimiles. Although the mundane manifestive quality is of the adulterated kind, Viñëu, the manifestation of the Divinity in the mundane manifestive quality, makes His appearance in the unadulterated manifestive principle which is a constituent of the mundane manifestive quality. Hence Viñëu is the full subjective portion and belongs to the category of the superior éçvaras. He is the Lord of the deluding potency and not alloyed with her. Viñëu is the agent of Govinda's own subjective nature in the form of the prime cause. All the majestic attributes of Govinda, aggregating sixty in number, are fully present in His majestic manifestation, Näräyaëa. Brahmä and Çiva are entities adulterated with mundane qualities. Though Viñëu is also divine appearance in mundane quality (guëa-avatära), still He is not adulterated. The appearance of Näräyaëa in the form of Mahä-Viñëu, the appearance of Mahä-Viñëu in the form of Garbhodakaçäyé and the appearance of Viñëu in the form of Kñérodakaçäyé, are examples of the ubiquitous function of the Divinity. Viñëu is Godhead Himself, and the two other guëa-avatäras and all the other gods are entities possessing authority in subordination to Him. From the subjective majestic manifestation of the supreme self-luminous Govinda emanate Käraëodakaçäyé, Garbhodakaçäyé, Kñérodakaçäyé and all other derivative subjective divine descents (avatäras) such as Räma, etc., analogous to communicated light appearing in different candles, shining by the operation of the spiritual potency of Govinda.

[Madhya 20.316]

Bs 5.47

TEXT 47

TEXT

yaù käraëärëava-jale bhajati sma yoga-

nidräm ananta-jagad-aëòa-sa-roma-küpaù

ädhära-çaktim avalambya paräà sva-mürtià

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

yaù—He who; käraëa-arëava—of the Causal Ocean; jale—in the water; bhajati—enjoys; sma—indeed; yoga-nidräm—creative sleep; ananta—unlimited; jagat-aëòa—universes; sa—with; roma-küpaù—the pores of His hair; ädhära-çaktim—the all-accommodating potency; avalambya—assuming; paräm—great; sva-mürtim—own subjective form; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I adore the primeval Lord Govinda who assuming His own great subjective form, who bears the name of Çeña, replete with the all-accommodating potency, and reposing in the Causal Ocean with the infinity of the world in the pores of His hair, enjoys creative sleep [yoga-nidrä].

PURPORT

(The subjective nature of Ananta who has the form of the couch of Mahä-Viñëu, is described.) Ananta, the same who is the infinite couch on which Mahä-Viñëu reposes, is a distinctive appearance of the Divinity bearing the name of Çeña, having the subjective nature of the servant of Kåñëa.

Bs 5.48

TEXT 48

TEXT

yasyaika-niçvasita-kälam athävalambya

jévanti loma-vilajä jagad-aëòa-näthäù

viñëur mahän sa iha yasya kalä-viçeño

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

yasya—whose; eka—one; niçvasita—of breath; kälam—time; atha—thus; avalambya—taking shelter of; jévanti—live; loma-vila-jäù—grown from the hair holes; jagat-aëòa-näthäù—the masters of the universes (the Brahmäs); viñëuù mahän—the Supreme Lord Mahä-Viñëu; saù—that; iha—here; yasya—whose; kalä-viçeñaù—particular plenary portion or expansion; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

Brahmä and other lords of the mundane worlds, appearing from the pores of hair of Mahä-Viñëu, remain alive as long as the duration of one exhalation of the latter [Mahä-Viñëu]. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda of whose subjective personality Mahä-Viñëu is the portion of portion.

PURPORT

The supreme majesty of the subjective nature of Viñëu is shown here.

[Ädi 5.71] [Madhya 20.281, 21.41]

Bs 5.49

TEXT 49

TEXT

bhäsvän yathäçma-çakaleñu nijeñu tejaù

svéyam kiyat prakaöayaty api tadvad atra

brahmä ya eña jagad-aëòa-vidhäna-kartä

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

bhäsvän—the illuminating sun; yathä—as; açma-çakaleñu—in various types of precious stones; nijeñu—his own; tejaù—brilliance; svéyam—his own; kiyat—to some extent; prakaöayati—manifests; api—also; tadvat—similarly; atra—here; brahmä—Lord Brahmä; yaù—who; eñaù—he; jagat-aëòa-vidhäna-kartä—the chief of the universe; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I adore the primeval Lord Govinda from whom the separated subjective portion Brahmä receives his power for the regulation of the mundane world, just as the sun manifests some portion of his own light in all the effulgent gems that bear the names of süryakänta, etc.

PURPORT

Brahmä is two types: in certain kalpas when the potency of the Supreme Lord infuses Himself in an eligible jéva, the latter acts in the office of Brahmä and creates the universe. In those kalpas when no eligible jéva is available, after the Brahmä of the previous kalpa is liberated, Kåñëa, by the process of allotment of His own potency, creates the Brahmä who has the nature of the avatära (descent) of the Divinity in the active mundane principle (rajo-guëa). By principle Brahmä is superior to ordinary jévas but is not the direct Divinity. The divine nature is present in a greater measure in Çambhu than in Brahmä. The fundamental significance of the above is that the aggregate of fifty attributes, belonging to the jéva, are present in a fuller measure in Brahmä who possesses, in a lesser degree, five more attributes which are not found in jévas. But in Çambhu both the fifty attributes of jévas as also the five additional attributes found in Brahmä are present in even greater measure than in Brahmä.

[Madhya 20.304]

Bs 5.50

TEXT 50

TEXT

yat-päda-pallava-yugaà vinidhäya kumbha-

dvandve praëäma-samaye sa gaëädhiräjaù

vighnän vihantum alam asya jagat-trayasya

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

yat—whose; päda-pallava—lotus feet; yugam—two; vinidhäya—having held; kumbha-dvandve—upon the pair of tumuli; praëäma-samaye—at the time of offering obeisances; saù—he; gaëa-adhiräjaù—Gaëeça; vighnän—obstacles; vihantum—to destroy; alam—capable; asya—of these; jagat-trayasya—three worlds; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I adore the primeval Lord Govinda, whose lotus feet are always held by Gaëeça upon the pair of tumuli protruding from his elephant head in order to obtain power for his function of destroying all the obstacles on the path of progress of the three worlds.

PURPORT

The power of destroying all obstacles to mundane prosperity has been delegated to Gaëeça who is the object of worship to those who are eligible to worship him. He has obtained a rank among the five gods as Brahmä possessing mundane quality. The self-same Gaëeça is a god in possession of delegated power by infusion of the divine power. All his glory rests entirely on the grace of Govinda.

Bs 5.51

TEXT 51

TEXT

agnir mahi gaganam ambu marud diçaç ca

kälas tathätma-manaséti jagat-trayäëi

yasmäd bhavanti vibhavanti viçanti yaà ca

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

agniù—fire; mahi—earth; gaganam—ether; ambu—water; marut—air; diçaù—directions; ca—also; kälaù—time; tathä—as well as; ätma—soul; manasé—and mind; iti—thus; jagat-trayäëi—the three worlds; yasmät—from whom; bhavanti—they originate; vibhavanti—they exist; viçanti—they enter; yam—whom; ca—also; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

The three worlds are composed of the nine elements, viz., fire, earth, ether, water, air, direction, time, soul and mind. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda from whom they originate, in whom they exist and into whom they enter at the time of the universal cataclysm.

PURPORT

There is nothing in the three worlds save the five elements, ten quarters, time, jéva-soul, and the mental principle allied with the subtle body consisting of mind, intelligence and ego of conditioned souls. The elevationists (karmés) make their offerings in sacrifice in the fire. Conditioned souls know nothing beyond this perceptible world of nine elements. The jéva is the self-same soul whose ecstatic delight the joyless liberationists (jïänés) aspire after. Both the principles that are respectively depicted as ätmä and prakåti by the system of Säìkhya are included in the above. In other words all the principles that have been enunciated by all the speculative philosophers (tattva-vädés) are included in these nine elements. Çré Govinda is the source of the appearance, continuance and subsidence of all these principles.

Bs 5.52

TEXT 52

TEXT

yac-cakñur eña savitä sakala-grahäëäà

räjä samasta-sura-mürtir açeña-tejäù

yasyäjïayä bhramati sambhåta-käla-cakro

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

yat—of whom; cakñuù—the eye; eñaù—the; savitä—sun; sakala-grahäëäm—of all the planets; räjä—the king; samasta-sura—of all the demigods; mürtiù—the image; açeña-tejäù—full of infinite effulgence; yasya—of whom; äjïayä—by the order; bhramati—performs his journey; sambhåta—complete; käla-cakraù—the wheel of time; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

The sun who is the king of all the planets, full of infinite effulgence, the image of the good soul, is as the eye of this world. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda in pursuance of whose order the sun performs his journey mounting the wheel of time.

PURPORT

Certain professors of the Vedic religion worship the sun as Brahman. The sun is one of the hierarchy of the five gods. Some people target in heat the source of this world and therefore designate the sun, the only location of heat, as the root cause of this world. Notwithstanding all that may be said to the contrary, the sun is after all only the presiding deity of a sphere of the sum total of all mundane heat and is hence a god exercising delegated authority. The sun performs his specific function of service certainly by the command of Govinda.

Bs 5.53

TEXT 53

TEXT

dharmo 'tha päpa-nicayaù çrutayas tapäàsi

brahmädi-kéöa-patagävadhayaç ca jéväù

yad-datta-mätra-vibhava-prakaöa-prabhävä

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

dharmaù—virtue; atha—also; päpa-nicayaù—all vices; çrutayaù—the Vedas; tapäàsi—penances; brahma-ädi—beginning from Lord Brahmä; kéöa-pataga—insects; avadhayaù—down to; ca—and; jéväù-jévas; yat—by whom; datta—conferred; mätra—exclusively; vibhava—by the power; prakaöa—manifested; prabhäväù—potencies; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I adore the primeval Lord Govinda, by whose conferred power are maintained the manifested potencies, that are found to exist, of all virtues, all vices, the Vedas, the penances and all jévas, from Brahmä to the meanest insect.

PURPORT

By dharma is meant the allotted functions of varëa and äçrama manifested by the twenty dharma-çästras on the authority of the Vedas. Of these two divisions varëa-dharma is that function which is the outcome of the distinctive natures of the four varëas, viz., brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya and çüdra and äçrama-dharma is that function which is appropriate to the respective äçramas or stations of those who belong to the four stages, viz., brahmacarya, gåhastha, vänaprastha and sannyäsa. All customary activities of mankind have been targeted in these twofold divisions. Sins mean nescience, the root of all sins and sinful desire, also the greatest iniquities and sins flowing from them and the ordinary sins, i.e., all sorts of unprincipled conduct. The category of the çrutis means Åg, Säma, Yajur and Atharva and the Upaniñads which form the crest jewels of the Veda. The tapas mean all regular practices that are learnt with the view of the attainment of the proper function of the self. In many cases, e.g., in the form known as païca-tapas these practices are of a difficult character (yoga) with its eight constituents limbs and devotedness to the knowledge of the undifferentiated Brahman are included therein. All these are so many distinctive features within the revolving round of the fruitive activities of conditioned souls. The conditioned souls are embarked on a sojourn of successive births from 84 lakhs of varieties of generating organs. They are differentiated into different orders of beings as devas, dänavas, räkñasas, mänavas, nägas, kinnaras, and gandharvas. These jévas, from Brahmä down to the small insect, are infinite in type. They make up the aggregate of the conditioned souls from the degree of Brahmä to that of the little fly and are the distinctive features within the revolving wheel of karma. Every one of them is endowed with distinctive powers as individuals and is powerful in a particular sphere. But these powers are by their nature not fully developed in them. The degree of power and nature of property vary according to the measure of manifestation of the possessions of the individual conferred upon him by Çré Govinda.

Bs 5.54

TEXT 54

TEXT

yas tv indragopam athavendram aho sva-karma-

bandhänurüpa-phala-bhäjanam ätanoti

karmäëi nirdahati kintu ca bhakti-bhäjäà

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

yaù—He who (Govinda); tu—but; indra-gopam—to the small red insect called indragopa; atha vä—or even; indram—to Indra, king of heaven; aho—oh; sva-karma—of one's own fruitive activities; bandha—bondage; anurüpa—according to; phala—of reactions; bhäjanam—enjoying or suffering; ätanoti—bestows; karmäëi—all fruitive activities and their reactions; nirdahati—destroys; kintu—but; ca—also; bhakti-bhäjäm—of persons engaged in devotional service; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I adore the primeval Lord Govinda, who burns up to their roots all fruitive activities of those who are imbued with devotion and impartially ordains for each the due enjoyment of the fruits of one's activities, of all those who walk in the path of work, in accordance with the chain of their previously performed works, no less in the case of the tiny insect that bears the name of indragopa than in that of Indra, king of the devas.

PURPORT

God impartially induces the fallen souls to act in the way that is consequent on the deeds of their previous births and to enjoy the fruition of their labors but, out of His great mercy to His devotees, He purges out, by the fire of ordeal, the root of all karma, viz., nescience and evil desires. Karma, though without beginning, is still perishable. The karma of those, who work with the hope of enjoying the fruits of their labors, becomes everlasting and endless and is never destroyed. The function of sannyäsa is also a sort of karma befitting an äçrama and is not pleasant to Kåñëa when it aims at liberation, i.e., desire for emancipation. They also receive fruition of their karma and, even if it be disinterested, their karma ends in ätma-mamatä, i.e., self-pleasure; but those who are pure devotees always serve Kåñëa by gratifying His senses forsaking all attempts of karma and jïäna, and being free from all desires save that of serving Kåñëa. Kåñëa has fully destroyed the karma, its desires and nescience of those devotees. It is a great wonder that Kåñëa, being impartial, is fully partial to His devotees.

[Madhya 15.170]

Bs 5.55

TEXT 55

TEXT

yaà krodha-käma-sahaja-praëayädi-bhéti-

vätsalya-moha-guru-gaurava-sevya-bhävaiù

saïcintya tasya sadåçéà tanum äpur ete

govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

SYNONYMS

yam—upon whom; krodha—wrath; käma—amorous passion; sahaja-praëaya—natural friendly love; ädi—and so on; bhéti—fear; vätsalya—parental affection; moha—delusion; guru-gaurava—reverence; sevya-bhävaiù—and with the attitude of willing service; saïcintya—meditating; tasya—of that; sadåçém—befitting; tanum—bodily form; äpuù—attained; ete—these persons; govindam—Govinda; ädi-puruñam—the original person; tam—Him; aham—I; bhajämi—worship.

TRANSLATION

I adore the primeval Lord Govinda, the meditators of whom, by meditating upon Him under the sway of wrath, amorous passion, natural friendly love, fear, parental affection, delusion, reverence and willing service, attain to bodily forms befitting the nature of their contemplation.

PURPORT

Devotion is of two kinds, viz., (1) of the nature of deference to regulation and (2) constituted of natural feeling. Bhakti is roused by following with a tinge of faith in the rule of the çästras and instruction of the preceptors. Such bhakti is of the nature of loyalty to the scriptural regulations. It continues to be operative as long as the corresponding natural feeling is not roused. If a person loves Kåñëa out of natural tendency. there is the principle of räga, which is no other than a strong desire to serve, which turns into bhäva or substantive feeling. When the substantive feeling is aroused the devotee becomes an object of mercy of Kåñëa. It takes much time to attain this stage. Devotion which is of the nature of feeling is superior to that connected with scriptural regulation, soon attains to the realized state and is attractive to Kåñëa. Its various aspects are described in this çloka. Çänta-bhäva, full of reverence to superior, däsya-bhäva, full of service for carrying out the commands of the object of worship, sakhya-bhäva or natural friendly love, vätsalya-bhäva or parental affection and madhura-bhäva or amorous love, are all included in the category of devotion of the nature of instinctive attachment. But anger, fear and delusion, though they are of the nature of instinctive impulse, are not devotion in the strict sense of the term, because they are not friendly but hostile to the object. Anger is found in asuras like Çiçupäla, fear in Kaàsa, and delusion in the paëòitas of the pantheistic school. They have the feelings of anger, fear and instinctive impulse marked by complete self-forgetful identification with the nondifferentiated Brahman. But as there is no friendly feeling towards the object of devotion there is no bhakti. Again among the feelings of çänta, däsya, sakhya, vätsalya and madhura-çänta, though indifferent and dormant in räga, is still reckoned as bhakti on account of its being a little friendly. There is an immense volume of räga in the other four varieties of emotion. By the promise of Gétä, ye yathä mäà prapadyante täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham ("I serve one according to his submission"), those, who allow themselves to be actuated by the sentiments of fear, anger and delusion, attain to säyujya-mukti (merging in the Absolute). The çäntas obtain bodily forms with aptitude for addiction to Brahman and Paramätmä. The däsya and sakhya classes of worshipers attain bodily forms characterized by masculine or feminine disposition according to their respective grades of eligibility. The vätsalya class of worshipers get bodily forms befitting fatherly and motherly sentiments. The amorous lovers of Kåñëa attain the pure forms of gopés (spiritual milkmaids of Vraja).

Bs 5.56

TEXT 56

TEXT

çriyaù käntäù käntaù parama-puruñaù kalpa-taravo

drumä bhümiç cintämaëi-gaëa-mayi toyam amåtam

kathä gänaà näöyaà gamanam api vaàçé priya-sakhi

cid-änandaà jyotiù param api tad äsvädyam api ca

sa yatra kñéräbdhiù sravati surabhébhyaç ca su-mahän

nimeñärdhäkhyo vä vrajati na hi yaträpi samayaù

bhaje çvetadvépaà tam aham iha golokam iti yaà

vidantas te santaù kñiti-virala-cäräù katipaye

SYNONYMS

çriyaù—Lakñmés, goddesses of fortune; käntäù—loving consorts; käntaù—the enjoyer, lover; parama-puruñaù—the Supreme Personality of Godhead; kalpa-taravaù—desire trees; drumäù—all the trees; bhümiù—the land; cintämaëi-gaëa-mayi—made of the transcendental touchstone jewels; toyam—the water; amåtam—nectar; kathä—talking; gänam—song; näöyam—dancing; gamanam—walking; api—also; vaàçé—the flute; priya-sakhé—constant companion; cit-änandam—transcendental bliss; jyotiù—effulgence; param—the supreme; api—also; tat—that; äsvädyam—everywhere perceived; api ca—also; saù—that; yatra—where; kñéra-abdhiù—ocean of milk; sravati—flows; surabhébhyaù—from surabhi cows; ca—and; su-mahän—very great; nimeña-ardha—half a moment; äkhyaù—called; vä—or; vrajati—passes away; na—not; hi—certainly; yatra—where; api—even; samayaù—time; bhaje—I worship; çveta-dvépam—Çvetadvépa; tam—that; aham—I; iha—here; golokam—Goloka; iti—thus; yam—which; vidantaù—know; te—they; santaù—self-realized souls; kñiti—in this world; virala—seldom; cäräù—going; katipaye—few.

TRANSLATION

I worship that transcendental seat, known as Çvetadvépa where as loving consorts the Lakñmés in their unalloyed spiritual essence practice the amorous service of the Supreme Lord Kåñëa as their only lover; where every tree is a transcendental purpose tree; where the soil is the purpose gem, all water is nectar, every word is a song, every gait is a dance, the flute is the favorite attendant, effulgence is full of transcendental bliss and the supreme spiritual entities are all enjoyable and tasty, where numberless milk cows always emit transcendental oceans of milk; where there is eternal existence of transcendental time, who is ever present and without past or future and hence is not subject to the quality of passing away even for the space of half a moment. That realm is known as Goloka only to a very few self-realized souls in this world.

PURPORT

That region which jévas attain by the best performance of their rasa-bhajana, though purely transcendental, is by no means devoid of variegatedness. The nondifferentiated region is attained by indulging in anger, fear and delusion. The devotees attain Goloka, the transcendental region above Vaikuëöha, according to the quality of rasa of the respective services. In reality that region is no other than Çvetadvépa or "the White Island," being exceedingly pure. Those, who attain the highest rasa in the shape of the realization of pure devotion in this world, viewing the reality of Çvetadvépa in Gokula, Våndävana and Navadvépa within this mundane world, designate the same as "Goloka." In that transcendental region of Goloka there are always visible, in their supreme beauty, all the distinctive entities that are incorporated in the pure cognitive principle, viz., the lover and His beloved ones, trees and creepers, mountains, rivers and forests, water, speech, movement, music of the flute, the sun and the moon, tasted and taste (i.e., the unthinkable wonders of the 64 aesthetic arts), milk cows yielding nectarean flow of milk and transcendental ever-existing time.

Descriptions that supply the clue to Goloka are found in various places in the Vedas and the other çästras such as the Puräëas, tantras etc. The Chändogya says: brüyäd yävan vä ayam äkäças tävan eña antar håda äkäçaù ubhe asmin dyävä-påthivé antar eva samähite. ubhäv agniç ca väyuç ca sürya—candramasäv ubhau vidyun nakñaträëi yac cäsyehästi yac ca nästi sarvaà tad asmin samähitam iti.

The sum and substance of it is that all the variegatedness of this mundane world and much more variety over and above the mundane, are to be found in Goloka. The variety in the transcendental world is fully centralized whereas in the mundane world it is not so and hence productive of weal and woe. The centralized variety of Goloka is unalloyed and full of transcendental cognitive joy. The Vedas and sädhus practicing devotion revealed by the Vedas, by availing the support of their individual cognitional aptitude actuated by devotion, may have a sight of divine realm and by the power of the grace of Kåñëa their tiny cognitive faculty attaining the quality of infinitude they are enabled to be on the level of the plane of enjoyments of Kåñëa.

There is a hidden meaning of the proposition "even the Supreme that is also nevertheless the object of enjoyment" (param api tad äsvädyam api ca). The word param api indicates that Çré Kåñëa is the only Truth Absolute in all the transcendental blissful principles and tad äsvädyam api means His object of enjoyment. The glory of Rädhä's love for Kåñëa, tasty quality (rasa) of Kåñëa that is realized by Rädhä and the bliss of which Rädhä is conscious in the process of such realization, all these threefold bhävas (emotional entities) becoming available for enjoyment by Kåñëa He attains His personality of Çré Gaurasundara. It is also this that constitutes the transcendental bliss of the delicious loving (rasa) service manifested by Çré Gaurasundara. This also eternally exists only in the selfsame Çvetadvépa.

[Madhya 14.227]

Bs 5.57

TEXT 57

TEXT

athoväca mahä-viñëur

bhagavantaà prajäpatim

brahman mahattva-vijïäne

prajä-sarge ca cen matiù

païca-çlokém imäà vidyäà

vatsa dattäà nibodha me

SYNONYMS

atha—then; uväca—said; mahä-viñëuù—the Supreme Lord; bhagavantam—unto the glorious; prajäpatim—Lord Brahmä; brahman—O Brahmä; mahattva—of the glory (of Godhead); vijïäne—in real knowledge; prajä-sarge—in creating offspring; ca—and; cet—if; matiù—the inclination; païca-çlokém—five çlokas; imäm—this; vidyäm—science; vatsa—O beloved; dattäm—given; nibodha—hear; me—from Me.

TRANSLATION

On hearing these hymns containing the essence of the truth, the Supreme Lord Kåñëa said to Brahmä, "Brahmä, if you experience the inclination to create offspring by being endowed with the real knowledge of the glory of Godhead, listen, My beloved, from Me to this science set forth in the following five çlokas.

PURPORT

The Supreme Lord became propitious when Brahmä with great eagerness chanted the names, "Kåñëa" and "Govinda" expressive of the form, attribute and pastimes. Brahmä was actuated by the desire for mundane creation. Kåñëa then said to Brahmä how pure unalloyed devotion can be practiced by souls engaged in worldly occupations by combining the same with the desire for carrying out the behest of the Supreme Lord. "The knowledge absolute is knowledge of the glory of Godhead; if you want to procreate offspring being endowed with such knowledge, listen attentively to the science of devotion that is contained in the following five çlokas."

(How bhakti is practiced by performing worldly duties in the form of carrying out the commands of the Supreme Lord, is being described).

Bs 5.58

TEXT 58

TEXT

prabuddhe jïäna-bhaktibhyäm

ätmany änanda-cin-mayé

udety anuttamä bhaktir

bhagavat-prema-lakñaëä

SYNONYMS

prabuddhe—when excited; jïäna—by cognition or knowledge; bhaktibhyäm—and by devotional service; ätmani—in the pure spirit soul; änanda-cit-mayi—full of knowledge and bliss; udeti—is awakened; anuttamä—superexcellent; bhaktiù—devotion; bhagavat—for Kåñëa; prema—by love; lakñaëä—characterized.

TRANSLATION

When the pure spiritual experience is excited by means of cognition and service [bhakti], superexcellent unalloyed devotion characterized by love for Godhead is awakened towards Kåñëa, the beloved of all souls.

PURPORT

Real knowledge is nothing but knowledge of one's relationship to the Absolute. Real knowledge is identical with the knowledge of subjective natures of cit (animate), acit (inanimate) and Kåñëa and of their mutual relationship. Here mental speculation is not alluded to, since that is antagonistic to service (bhakti). The knowledge that embraces only the first seven of the ten basic principles (daça-müla) is the knowledge of relationship. The substantive nature of the spiritual function (abhidheya) inculcated by the science of devotion hearing, chanting, meditation, tending His holy feet, worshiping by rituals, making prostrations, doing menial service, practicing friendship and surrendering oneself are identical with practicing the search for Kåñëa. It is specifically described in Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu. Devotion (bhakti) characterized by love for Godhead makes her appearance by being awakened by such knowledge and practice. Such devotion is superexcellent bhakti and is no other than the final object of attainment of all spiritual endeavor of the individual soul (jéva).

Bs 5.59

TEXT 59

TEXT

pramäëais tat-sad-äcärais

tad-abhyäsair nirantaram

bodhayan ätmanätmänaà

bhaktim apy uttamäà labhet

SYNONYMS

pramäëaiù—by scriptural evidence; tat—of them; sat-äcäraiù—by theistic conduct; tat—of them; abhyäsaiù—by practice; nirantaram—constantly; bodhayan—awakening; ätmanä—by one's own intelligence; ätmänam—the self; bhaktim—devotion; api—certainly; uttamäm—the highest; labhet—one can attain.

TRANSLATION

The highest devotion is attained by slow degrees by the method of constant endeavor for self-realization with the help of scriptural evidence, theistic conduct and perseverance in practice.

PURPORT

Evidence—the devotional scriptures, e.g., Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the Vedas, the Puräëas, the Gétä, etc. Theistic conduct—the conduct of pious persons (sädhus) who are pure devotees and the conduct of those pious persons who practice devotion to Godhead actuated by spontaneous love. Practice—to learn about the ten basic principles (daça-müla) from the çästras and on receiving the name of Hari as laid down in the same, embodying the name, form, quality and activity of the Divinity. To practice the chanting of the name by serving Him night and day. By this are meant study of the çästras and association with the sädhus. The tenfold offense to holy name ceases by serving the name of Hari and simultaneously practicing pious conduct. "Practice" is no other than following the mode of service of the name practiced by the sädhus without offense. By perseverance in such practice and devotion characterized by love which is the fruit of spiritual endeavor makes her appearance in the pure essence of the soul.

Bs 5.60

TEXT 60

TEXT

yasyäù çreyas-karaà nästi

yayä nirvåtim äpnuyät

yä sädhayati mäm eva

bhaktià täm eva sädhayet

SYNONYMS

yasyäù—than which; çreyaù-karam—superior well-being; na—not; asti—there is; yayä—by which; nirvåtim—supreme bliss; äpnuyät—one can attain; yä—who; sädhayati—leads; mäm—to Me; eva—certainly; bhaktim—loving devotion; täm—that; eva—indeed; sädhayet—one should perform.

TRANSLATION

These preliminary practices of devotion [sädhana-bhakti] are conducive to the realization of loving devotion. [Loving devotion]—than whom there is no superior well-being, who goes hand in hand with the attainment of the exclusive state of supreme bliss and who can lead to Myself.

PURPORT

The jéva-soul has no better well-being than loving devotion. In this is realized the final beatitude of jévas. The lotus feet of Kåñëa are attainable only by loving devotion. He who cultivates the preliminary devotional activities anxiously keeping in view that realized state of devotion can alone attain to that object of all endeavor. None else can have the same.

Bs 5.61

TEXT 61

TEXT

dharmän anyän parityajya

mäm ekaà bhaja viçvasan

yädåçé yädåçé çraddhä

siddhir bhavati tädåçé

kurvan nirantaraà karma

loko 'yam anuvartate

tenaiva karmaëä dhyäyan

mäà paräà bhaktim icchati

SYNONYMS

dharmän—meritorious performances; anyän—other; parityajya—abandoning; mäm—Me; ekam—alone; bhaja—serve; viçvasan—having faith; yädåçé yädåçé—just as; çraddhä—faith; siddhiù—realization; bhavati—arises; tädåçé—corresponding; kurvan—performing; nirantaram—ceaselessly; karma—activities; lokaù ayam—the people of this world; anuvartate—pursue; tena—by those; eva—indeed; karmaëä—deeds; dhyäyan—meditating; mäm—upon Me; paräm—supreme; bhaktim—devotion; icchati—one obtains.

TRANSLATION

Abandoning all meritorious performances serve Me with faith. The realization will correspond to the nature of one's faith. The people of the world act ceaselessly in pursuance of some ideal. By meditating on Me by means of those deeds one will obtain devotion characterized by love in the shape of the supreme service.

PURPORT

The function characterized by unalloyed devotion is the real function of all individual souls (jévas). All other varieties of function are activities of the external cases. These exoteric and esoteric dharmas (functions) are manifold, e.g., nondifferential knowledge of the Brahman aiming at extinction of individuality. the añöäìga-yoga-dharma having as its goal attainment of the state of exclusive existence (kaivalya), atheistical fruitive ritualism aiming at material enjoyment, jïäna-yoga-dharma seeking to combine knowledge with fruitive activity and the practice of the function of barren asceticism. Getting rid of all these, serve Me by pure devotion rooted in faith. Exclusive faith in Me is trust. Faith in the form of trust by the process of gradual purification tends to become a constant engagement (niñöhä), an object of liking (ruci), of attachment (äsakti) and a real sentiment (bhäva). The more transparent the faith, the greater the degree of realization. If you ask-How will the preservation and conduct of worldly affairs be feasible if one is continuously engaged in the endeavor for the realization of bhakti? What also will be the nature of the endeavor for the realization of bhakti when the body will perish consequent on the cessation of the function of the body and of society?

In order to strike at the root of this misgiving the Supreme Lord says, "This world subsists by the constant performance of certain activities. Fill all these activities with meditation of Me. This will destroy the quality that makes those activities appear as acts done by you. They will then be of the nature of My service (bhakti).

"Mankind live by the threefold activities of body. mind and society. Eating, seating, walking, resting, sleeping, cleansing the body. covering the body. etc., are the various bodily activities; thinking, recollecting, retaining an impression, becoming aware of an entity. feeling pleasure and pain, etc., are the mental feats; marrying, practicing reciprocal relationship between the king and subject, practicing brotherhood, attending at sacrificial meetings, offering oblations, digging wells, tanks, etc., for the benefit of the people, maintaining one's relations, practicing hospitality. observing proper civic conduct, showing due respect to others are the various social activities. When these acts are performed for one's selfish enjoyment, they are called karma-käëòa; when the desire for attainment of freedom from activity by knowledge underlies these actions, they are termed jïäna-yoga or karma-yoga. And when these activities are managed to be performed in this way that is conducive to our endeavor for attainment of bhakti they are called jïäna-bhakta-yoga, i.e., the subsidiary devotional practices. But only those activities that are characterized by the principle of pure worship are called bhakti proper. My meditation is practiced in every act when bhakti proper is practiced in due time while performing the subsidiary devotional activities in one's intercourse with the ungodly people of this world. In such position, a jéva does not become apathetic to Godhead even by performing those worldly activities. This constitutes the practice of looking inwards, i.e., turning towards one's real self, vide Éçopaniñad—

éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà
yat kiïca jagatyäà jagat
tena tyaktena bhuïjéthä
mä gådhaù kasya svid dhanam
[Éço 1]

The commentator says in regards to this, tena éça-tyaktena visåñöena. The real significance being that if whatever is accepted be received as favor vouchsafed by the Supreme Lord, the worldly activity will cease to be such and will turn into service of Godhead (bhakti). So Éçäväsya says kurvann eveha karmäëi... karma lipyate nare.

If the worldly acts are performed in the above manner one does not get entangled in karma even in hundreds of years of worldly life. The meaning of these two mantras from the jïäna point of view is renouncement of the fruits of one's worldly actions; but from the bhakti point of view they mean the attainment of Kåñëa's favor (prasädam) by their transfer to His account. In this method, which is the path of arcana, you should do your duties of the world by the meditation of worshiping Godhead thereby. Brahmä cherishes the desire for creation in his heart. If that creative desire is practiced by conjoining the same with the meditation of obeying therein the command of the Supreme Lord, then it will be a subsidiary spiritual function (gauëa-dharma) being helpful for the growth of the disposition for the service of the Divinity by reason of its characteristic of seeking the protection of Godhead. It was certainly proper to instruct Brahmä in this manner. There is no occasion for such instruction in the case of a jéva in whom the spontaneous aversion for entities other than Kåñëa manifests itself on his attainment of the substantive entity of spiritual devotion (bhäva).

Bs 5.62

TEXT 62

TEXT

ahaà hi viçvasya caräcarasya

béjaà pradhänaà prakåtiù pumäàç ca

mayähitaà teja idaà bibharñi

vidhe vidhehi tvam atho jaganti

SYNONYMS

aham—I; hi—certainly; viçvasya—of the world; cara-acarasya—of animate and inanimate objects; béjam—the seed; pradhänam—the substance of matter; prakåtiù—the material cause; pumän—the puruña; ca—and; mayä—by Me; ähitam—conferred; tejaù—fiery energy; idam—this; bibharñi—you bear; vidhe—O Brahmä; vidhehi—regulate; tvam—you; atha u—now; jaganti—the worlds.

TRANSLATION

"Listen, O Vidhi, I am the seed, i.e., the fundamental principle, of this world of animate and inanimate objects. I am pradhäna [the substance of matter], I am prakåti [material cause] and I am puruña [efficient cause]. This fiery energy that belongs specially to the Brahman, that inheres in you, has also been conferred by Me. It is by bearing this fiery energy that you regulate this phenomenal world of animate and inanimate objects."

PURPORT

Certain thinkers conclude that the nondifferentiated Brahman is the ultimate entity and by undergoing self-delusion (vivarta) exhibits the consciousness of differentiation; or, the limiting principle itself (Mäyä), when it is limited, is the phenomenal world and is itself the Brahman, in its unlimited position; or, the Brahman is the substance and this phenomenal world is the reflection; or, everything is an illusion of the jéva. Some think that Godhead is evidently a separate entity. Jéva is another different entity. and the phenomenal world, although it is a singular principle, exists separately as an eternally independent entity; or, Godhead, is the substantive entity and all other entities, as cit and a-cit attributes, are one in principle. Some suppose that by the force of inconceivable potency sometimes the monistic and sometimes the dualistic principle is realized as the truth. Some again arrive at the conclusion that the theory of the nondual minus all potency is meaningless; whence the Brahman is the one eternally unalloyed entity vested with the pure potency.

These speculations have originated from Veda relying on the support of the Vedänta-sutra. In these speculations although there is no truth that holds good in all positions, there is yet a certain measure of truth. Not to speak of the anti-Vedic speculations Säìkhya, Pataïjala, Nyäya and Vaiçeñika, nor even of Pürva-mémäàsä which is fond of exclusive fruitive activity in conformity with the teaching of one portion of the Veda, the bodies of opinions detailed above have also come into existence by relying outwardly on the Vedänta itself. By discarding all these speculations, you and your bona fide community should adopt the ultimate principle identical with the doctrine of acintya-bhedäbheda (inconceivable simultaneous distinction and nondifference). This will make you eligible for being a true devotee. The basic principle is that this animate world is made up of jévas and the inanimate world is constituted of matter. Of these all the jévas have been manifested by My supreme (parä) potency and this phenomenal world has been manifested by My secondary (aparä) potency. I am the cause of all causes. In other words, I regulate all of them by the power of My will although I am not a different entity from the marginal and material (taöasthä and acit) potencies. By the transformation of those distinct potencies pradhäna (substantive material principle), prakåti (material cause) and puruña (efficient cause) have been produced. Hence although as regards the subjective nature of all potency I am pradhäna, prakåti and puruña, yet as the possessor of power I am eternally distinct from all those potencies. This simultaneous distinction and nondifference has also sprung from My inconceivable power. So let the attainment of love for Kåñëa by the practice of pure devotion through the knowledge of their mutual true relationship that subsists between the jéva, the jaòa (matter) and Kåñëa based on the principle of inconceivable simultaneous distinction and non-difference, be My instruction for being handed down in the order of spiritual preceptional succession in your community (Çré Brahma-sampradäya).

LIFE COMES FROM LIFE (1979)

Morning walks with His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

FOUNDER-ÄCÄRYA OF THE INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR KRISHNA CONSCIOUSNESS

LCL: Foreword

Foreword

For people who have come to accept every pronouncement of modern scientists as tested and proven truth, this book will be an eye-opener. Life Comes From Life is an impromptu but brilliant critique of some of the dominant policies, theories and presuppositions of modern science and scientists by one of the greatest philosophers and scholars of the century, His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. Çréla Prabhupäda’s vivid analysis uncovers the hidden and blatantly unfounded assumptions that underlie currently fashionable doctrines concerning the origins and purpose of life.

This book is based on taped morning-walk conversations that Çréla Prabhupäda had with some of his disciples during 1973, in the Los Angeles area. On those mornings when he focused on science, Çréla Prabhupäda spoke mainly with his disciple Thoudam D. Singh, Ph.D. An organic chemist, Dr. Singh presently directs the Bhaktivedanta Institute, an international center for advanced study and research in science, philosophy and theology.

Each day, wherever in the world he happened to be, Çréla Prabhupäda would go out for a lengthy stroll in the chill quietude of the early morning, and cloaked in a warm wrap, he would share intimate moments with a small group of students, disciples and special guests. Some mornings found him immersed in contemplation or quiet appreciation of the surroundings, and little dialogue emerged. At other times he spoke at great length, and often with considerable intensity, on various subjects. During these animated discourses he demonstrated that philosophical analysis need not be a dull, abstruse affair, but can be a dynamic cutting edge into every sphere of life. Nothing could escape his keen intellect, deep spiritual insight and uncommon wit. Rejecting superficial and dogmatic thinking, he edified, challenged, cajoled, charmed and enlightened his students, and he carefully guided them to increased insight and understanding.

Çréla Prabhupäda (1896-1977) is an internationally recognize author, scholar and spiritual preceptor, and he is widely esteemed as India’s greatest cultural ambassador to the world. In Life Comes From Life, Çréla Prabhupäda takes the role of philosopher—social critic. With philosophical rigor, profound common sense and disarming frankness, he exposes not only modern science’s methodological shortcomings and unexamined biases but also the unverified (and unverifiable) speculations that scientists present to the trusting public as known fact. Thus Çréla Prabhupäda breaks the spell of the materialistic and nihilistic myths which, masquerading as science, have so bewitched modern civilization.

—The Publishers

LCL: Introduction

Introduction

Science: Truth and Fiction

Science: Truth and Fiction


“How do you know that the incessant progress of science will not compel scientists ... to consider that life has existed during eternity, and not matter? ... How do you know that in 10,000 years one will not consider it more likely that matter has emerged from life?”

—Louis Pasteur


Once upon a time (as in a fairy tale), most of us believed that the food we ate was basically wholesome, nutritious, and free from dangerous chemicals, that advertising was believable, and that product labels truly described the qualities and contents of what we ate. Once upon a time, most of the world believed in the integrity of our heads of state, high-ranking political officials, and local leaders. Once upon a time, we thought our children were getting a solid education in the public schools. Once upon a time, many of us believed atomic energy had “peacetime uses” that were perfectly safe and congruous with a happy and healthy society.

Yet in recent times our illusions have been shattered. Repeated exposes of widespread consumer fraud, grand political scandals, and toxic-waste dumps have all but destroyed our former innocence. We now know that a veil of fantasy and deception can be created with unprecedented expertise through the mass media, making it impossible to distinguish between substance and simulation, reality and illusion.

Scientists as a class have long sat protected in their ivory chambers, exempt from dishonesty. Science, among all other fields, has been regarded as the ultimate meeting ground for seekers and dispensers of truth. The dazzling technological achievements of modern science have given it an aura of infallibility. In Passages About Earth, William Irwin Thompson writes, “Just as once there was no appeal from the power of religion without risking damnation, so now there is no appeal from the power of science without risking a charge of irrationality or insanity.” But scientists in key academic, industrial, and government positions have shown that they are indeed capable of mixing personal beliefs and ambitions with their research, thus altering the results.

When this happens we are no longer dealing with a search for truth but with a pseudoscience and its resultant array of distortions, fabrications, and false information. Unfortunately, this unscientific method has been applied to the most fundamental field of scientific inquiry—the nature and origin of life. Yet when scientists present untested, unprovable speculations about life’s origin, people tend to accept them with blind faith.

Some scientists popularize the notion that a human being is merely a conglomeration of unconscious molecules. But they cannot explain how mere molecules can experience joy upon seeing loved ones, or feel disturbed by the death of one.

A recent exhibit at the Los Angeles Museum of Natural History displayed a number of flasks and beakers. Each contained one of the chemicals found in the human body. The caption explained that although these chemicals represented all the contents of a human body in correct weight and proportion, they could not be considered life, nor could any amount of scientific manipulation bring them to life.

As Michael Polianyi, author of Atomic Reactions, notes,


Current biology is based on the assumption that you can explain the process of life in terms of chemistry and physics; and, of course, physics and chemistry are represented ultimately in term of forces acting between atomic particles. This is the cause of our corruption of the conception of man, reducing him either to an insentient automaton or to a bundle of appetites. This is why science can be invoked so easily in support of totalitarian violence; why science has become the greatest source of dangerous fallacies.


Today many scientists are propagating the doctrine that life originates from matter. Popular works and textbooks posit that life gradually arose from chemicals, a “primordial soup” consisting of amino acids, proteins, and other essential ingredients. However, science cannot provide proof of this, either experimentally or theoretically. In fact these scientists hold their stance essentially on faith even in the face of all sorts of scientific objections. Physicist Hubert Yockey has demonstrated by information theory that even a single informational molecule such as cytochome (what to speak of complex organisms) could not have arisen by chance in the estimated lifetime of the earth: “One must conclude, that, contrary to the established and current wisdom, a scenario describing the genesis of life on earth by chance and natural causes which can be accepted on the basis of fact and not faith has not yet been written.”

Likewise, some scientists promote the widely held belief that the sun, stars, planets, galaxies, and conscious life suddenly sprang from a “big bang.” Dr. Edwin Godwin, a Princeton University biologist, has compared the chances of a planet such as ours arising from a “big bang” to the likelihood of an unabridged dictionary resulting from an explosion in a printing shop.

The noted biologist W. H. Thorpe writes, “We may be faced with a possibility that the origin of life, like the origin of the universe, becomes an impenetrable barrier to science and a block which resists all attempts to reduce biology to chemistry and physics.” And Einstein notes, “Everyone who is seriously involved in the pursuit of science becomes convinced that a spirit is manifest in the laws of the universe—a spirit vastly superior to that of man, and one in the face of which we, with our modest powers, must feel humbled.”

Life Comes From Life demonstrates with simple logic that life cannot be reduced to atoms and molecules, and that matter—without the living force, or spirit—is incapable of generating life in any form. It is also hoped that this book will urge scientists to re-dedicate themselves to a more genuine and intense quest for truth and knowledge and to thereby redirect their valuable intelligence, resources, and work toward the true benefit of the world.

—Thoudam Damodara Singh, Ph.D.


LCL: The First Morning Walk

The First Morning Walk

Recorded on April 18, 1973,
in Cheviot Hills Park, Los Angeles.


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Thoudam Dämodara Singh, Karandhara däsa adhikaré, Brahmänanda Svämé and other students.

Life on Other Planets

Life on Other Planets

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Even on the sun and moon there are living entities. What is the opinion of the scientists?

DR. SINGH. They say there is no life there.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is nonsense. There is life there.

DR. SINGH. They say that there is no life on the moon because they did not find any there.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Why do they believe that? The moon planet is covered with dust, but within that dust the living entities can live. Every atmosphere is suitable for life—any atmosphere. Therefore the Vedas1 describe the living entities as sarva-gataù, which means “existing in all circumstances.” The living entity is not material. Although encaged in a material body, he is not material. But when we speak of different atmospheres, we refer to different material conditions.

KARANDHARA. They say that the moon’s atmosphere is unsuitable for life, but all they can legitimately say is that it is unsuitable for life as they know it.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The Vedas say that the living entity has no connection with material things. He cannot be burned, cut, dried up or moistened. This is discussed in Bhagavad-gétä.2

DR. SINGH. Scientists extend their knowledge about life on this planet, thinking that it must apply to life on other planets also.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. They are thinking foremost of their own selves. They are thinking limitedly, in terms of their own circumstances. This is what we call “Dr. Frog’s philosophy.” [Laughter.] Once there was a frog in a well, and when a friend informed him of the existence of the Atlantic Ocean, he asked the friend, “Oh, what is this Atlantic Ocean?”

“It is a vast body of water,” his friend replied.

“How vast? Is it twice the size of this well?”

“Oh, no—much, much larger,” his friend replied.

“How much larger? Ten times the size?” In this way, the frog went on calculating. But what is the possibility or ever understanding the vastness of the great ocean in this way? Our faculties, our experience, and our powers of speculation are always limited. The speculations of the scientists only give rise to such frog philosophy.

KARANDHARA. The basis of what they call “scientific integrity” is that they talk only about what they can directly experience.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. You may talk about your experience, and I may talk about my experience. But why should I accept your experience? You may be a fool, so why should I also become a fool? You may be a frog, but suppose I am a whale. Why should I take your well as all in all? You have your method of acquiring scientific knowledge, and I have mine.

DR. SINGH. Because the scientists haven’t detected any water on the surface of the moon, they’ve concluded that no life could survive there.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They haven’t seen the whole surface of the moon. Suppose someone were to come here from another planet, drop into the Arabian Desert and then return home. Could he come to a complete conclusion about the nature of the whole earth? His knowledge would not be complete.

KARANDHARA. They have a device that senses water. They say they’ve had it orbit the moon, and they’ve concluded that the moon has no water and therefore no life.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Even if, as on the sun, there is apparently no water, still there are living entities there. How does a cactus grow in the desert, apparently without water?

KARANDHARA. It gets water from the atmosphere.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, because the atmosphere contains all the elements needed to sustain life: earth, water, fire, air and ether. In anything material, all these elements are present. For example, in my body there is water, although you cannot see it. Similarly, you don’t see fire in my body, yet my body is warm. Where does this warmth come from? You don’t see any fire. Do you see any fire burning in my body? Then where does the warmth come from? What is the answer?

The Universe in the Atom

The Universe in the Atom

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. All matter is a combination of five gross elements (earth, water, fire, air and ether) and three subtle elements (mind, intelligence and false ego).

KARANDHARA. According to the Vedic science, material energy begins with the false ego and then develops into the intelligence, then the mind and then the gross elements—ether, air, fire and so on. So the same basic ingredients are present in all matter. Is this right?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. The creation of the material universe is like the growth of a great banyan tree3 from a tiny seed. No one can see the tree within the seed, but all the necessary ingredients for the tree are there, including the required intelligence. Actually, everyone’s body is simply a sample universe. Your body and my body are different universes, small universes. Therefore, all eight material elements are present within our bodies, just as they are within the whole universe. Similarly, an insect’s body is another universe.

KARANDHARA. How about the atom?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The same formula applies: all these constituents are within the atom. Aëor aëéyän mahato mahéyän (Kaöha Upaniñad 1.2.20). This means that whether something is extremely large or infinitesimal, it is still made of the same basic elements. This is true everywhere in the material world. Just as a woman’s small watch has all the requisite machinery for its smooth functioning, so an ant has all the necessary brain substance to manage its affairs nicely. How is this possible? To answer this properly, you must minutely examine the brain tissues in the ant. But this you cannot do. Moreover, there are innumerable insects smaller than the ant. So there must be a mechanical arrangement for all this detailed activity, but scientists cannot discover it.

Relativity and Knowledge

Relativity and Knowledge

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. All living entities possess the required intelligence to execute four principles: eating, sleeping, sexual intercourse and defense. These four principles exist even in the atom. The only difference in the human being is that he has the extra intelligence with which to understand God. This is the difference. Ähära-nidrä-bhaya-maithunaà ca samänam etat paçubhir naräëäm. Eating, sleeping, sex life and defense are to be found everywhere. You have seen trees growing. Wherever there is a knot, the bark does not go this way; it goes that way. [Çréla Prabhupäda gestures to show that a tree’s bark grows not over a knot, but around it.] The tree has intelligence: “If I go this way, I will be blocked, so I will go that way.” But where are its eyes? How can it see? It has intelligence. That intelligence may not be as good as yours, but it is intelligence. Similarly, a child also has intelligence, though not as developed as his father’s. In due course of time, when the child gets a body like that of his father, the child’s intelligence will be fully developed and exhibited.

DR. SINGH. Then intelligence is relative.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Everything is relative. You have your body, your duration of life, and your intelligence, and the ant has his. Both we and the ant live for one hundred years, but the length of our hundred-year life-span is relative to our bodies. Even Brahma, the longest-living entity in this universe, lives for one hundred years. To us the ant’s life-span may seem only a few days. In the same way, on other planets with atmospheres different from the earth’s, there are life-forms suited to those conditions. But the scientists try to view everything according to the relative conditions of planet earth. This is nonsense. Why are they doing that? If the whole cosmic manifestation follows the law of relativity, how can the scientist say that the conditions of this planet must apply to life on other planets?

The Vedas instruct us that knowledge must always be considered in terms of deça-käla-pätra. Deça means “circumstances,” käla means “time,” and pätra means “the object.” We must understand everything by taking these three elements into consideration. For example, a fish is living very comfortably in the water, and we are shivering on the shore of the sea. This is because my deça-käla-pätra and the fish’s deça-käla-pätra are different. But if we conclude that the sea gulls will also shiver in the water, that is nonsense; their deça-käla-pätra is again different. There are 8,400,000 different species of life in the material cosmic manifestation, and each species must adjust to circumstances differently. Even on this planet, you cannot go live comfortably in Alaska, although it is America. Similarly, the living entities enjoying life in Alaska do not come here.

KARANDHARA. Relativity, then, is based upon our individual situation.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Therefore it is said that what is food for one is poison for another.

BRAHMÄNANDA SWAMI. Because scientists cannot survive on the moon, they think no one else can.

The 8.6-Billion-Year Day

The 8.6-Billion-Year Day

DR. SINGH. The problem with the world is that practically everyone is thinking only in terms of his own circumstances—and that is nonsense.

STUDENT. Someone who has never gone out of his village thinks that his village is the whole world.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. The frog is always thinking in terms relative to his well. He has no power to think otherwise. The ocean is great, but he is thinking of the ocean’s greatness in terms relative to his own greatness. Similarly, God is great, but we are thinking of God in terms of relative greatness, greatness relative to our own. There are certain insects that are born at night, and they grow, bear offspring and die—all before day-break. They never see the morning. So if they conclude that there is no morning, that is nonsense. In the same way, as soon as we hear from the çästras [revealed scriptures] that Brahmä’s duration of life is equivalent to millions of our years, we do not believe it. We say, “How can it be?” But Bhagavad-gétä says, sahasra-yuga-paryantam ahar yad brahmaëo viduù: “Four billion three hundred million earth years equal Brahma’s twelve hours.” Even a leading Indian politician who was known as a great scholar of the Gétä could not accept this information. He said it is mental speculation. Such a rascal! Yet he is passing as an important scholar. This is the problem. Rascals and fools are passing as scholars, scientists and philosophers, and therefore the whole world is being misguided.


LCL: The Second Morning Walk

The Second Morning Walk

Darwinism Extinct

Darwinism Extinct

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. This material world is a composition of three qualities—sattva, rajas and tamas (goodness, passion and ignorance)—which are working everywhere. These three qualities are present in various proportions in all species of life. For example, some trees produce nice fruit, while others are simply meant for fuel. This is due to the association of particular qualities of nature. Among animals also, these three qualities are present. The cow is in the quality of goodness, the lion in passion, and the monkey in ignorance. According to Darwin, Darwin’s father is a monkey. [Laughter.] He has theorized foolishly.

DR. SINGH. Darwin has said that some species become extinct in the struggle for survival. Those which are capable of surviving will survive, but those which are not will become extinct. So he says survival and extinction go side by side.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Nothing is extinct. The monkey is not extinct. Darwin’s immediate forefather, the monkey, is still existing.

KARANDHARA. Darwin said there must be a natural selection. But selection means choice. So who is choosing?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That must be a person. Who is allowing someone to survive and someone to be killed? There must be some authority with discretion to give such an order. That is our first proposition. Who that authority is, is explained in Bhagavad-gétä. Kåñëa says, mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù: “Nature is working under My supervision.” (Bg. 9.10)

DR. SINGH. Darwin also says that the different species were not created simultaneously, but evolved gradually.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Then what is his explanation for how the process of evolution began?

KARANDHARA. Modern proponents of Darwinism say that the first living organism was created chemically.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. And I say to them, “If life originated from chemicals, and if your science is so advanced, then why can’t you create life biochemically in your laboratories?”

In the Future

In the Future

KARANDHARA. They say they will create life in the future.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. What future? When this crucial point is raised, they reply, “We shall do it in the future.” Why in the future? That is nonsense. “Trust no future, however pleasant.” If they are so advanced, they must demonstrate now how life can be created from chemicals. Otherwise what is the meaning of their advancement? They are talking nonsense.

KARANDHARA. They say that they are right on the verge of creating life.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That’s only a different way of saying the same thing: “In the future.” The scientists must admit that they still do not know the origin of life. Their claim that they will soon prove a chemical origin of life is something like paying someone with a postdated check. Suppose I give you a postdated check for ten thousand dollars but I actually have no money. What is the value of that check? Scientists are claiming that their science is wonderful, but when a practical example is wanted, they say they will provide it in the future. Suppose I say that I possess millions of dollars, and when you ask me for some money I say, “Yes, I will now give you a big postdated check. Is that all right?” If you are intelligent, you will reply, “At present give me at least five dollars in cash so I can see something tangible.” Similarly, the scientists cannot produce even a single blade of grass in their laboratories, yet they are claiming that life is produced from chemicals. What is this nonsense? Is no one questioning this?

KARANDHARA. They say that life is produced by chemical laws.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. As soon as there is a law, we must take into consideration that someone made the law. Despite all their so-called advancement, the scientists in their laboratories cannot produce even a blade of grass. What kind of scientists are they?

DR. SINGH. They say that in the ultimate analysis, everything came from matter. Living matter came from nonliving matter.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Then where is this living matter coming from now? Do the scientists say that life came from matter in the past but does not at the present? Where is the ant coming from now—from the dirt?

The Missing Link

The Missing Link

DR. SINGH. In fact, there are several theories explaining how life originated from matter, how living matter came from the non-living.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. [casting Dr. Singh in the role of a materialistic scientist]. All right, scientist, why is life not coming from matter now? You rascal. Why isn’t life coming from matter now? Actually such scientists are rascals. They childishly say that life came from matter, although they are not at all able to prove it. Our Kåñëa consciousness movement should expose all these rascals. They are only bluffing. Why don’t they create life immediately? In the past, they say, life arose from matter; and they say that this will happen again in the future. They even say that they will create life from matter. What kind of theory is this? They have already commented that life began from matter. This refers to the past—“began.” Then why do they now speak of the future? Is it not contradictory? They are expecting the past to occur in the future. This is childish nonsense.

KARANDHARA. They say that life arose from matter in the past and that they will create life this way in the future.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. What is this nonsense? If they cannot prove that life arises from matter in the present, how do they know life arose this way in the past?

DR. SINGH. They are assuming...

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Everyone can assume, but this is not science. Everyone can assume something. You can assume something, I can assume something. But there must be proof. We can prove that life arises from life. For example, a father begets a child. The father is living, and the child is living. But where is their proof that a father can be a dead stone? Where is their proof? We can easily prove that life begins from life. And the original life is Kåñëa. That also can be proven. But what evidence exists that a child is born of stone? They cannot actually prove that life comes from matter. They are leaving that aside for the future. [Laughter.]

KARANDHARA. The scientists say that they can now formulate acids, amino acids, that are almost like one-celled living organisms. They say that because these acids so closely resemble living beings, there must be just one missing link needed before they can create life.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Nonsense! Missing link. I’ll challenge them to their face! [Laughter.] They are missing this challenge. The missing link is this challenge to their face.

Nobel Prize for an Ass

Nobel Prize for an Ass

DR. SINGH. Some scientists hope that in the future they will be able to make babies in test tubes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Test tubes?

DR. SINGH. Yes, they intend to combine male and female elements in biological laboratories.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. If they begin with living entities, what is the purpose of the test tube? It is only a place for combination, but so is the womb. Where is the credit for the scientists if this is already being done in nature’s test tube?

KARANDHARA. It is already being done by nature, but when some scientist does it, people will give him the Nobel Prize.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, that is stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam: çva-vid-varähoñöra-kharaiù saàstutaù puruñaù paçuù.4 This verse indicates that those who praise men who are like animals are no better than dogs, hogs, camels and asses. Çva means “dog,” vid-varäha means “stool-eating hog,” uñöra means “camel,” and khara means “ass.” If the Nobel Prize is given to a scientist who is a rascal, the men on the committee who give him that prize are no better than dogs, hogs, camels and asses. We don’t accept them as human beings. One animal is praised by another animal. Where is the credit in that? If the men on the committee are no better than animals, anyone who receives the Nobel Prize in science is fool number one, because animals are praising him, not human beings.

DR. SINGH. For some scientists, the Nobel Prize is the ultimate.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They are rascals. They are speaking nonsense, and because they are juggling words, others are being misled.

BRAHMÄNANDA SWAMI. Nobel is the person who invented dynamite.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. He has created great misfortune, and he has left his money for creating further misfortune. [Laughter.]

BRAHMÄNANDA SWAMI. The Gétä says that demoniac people perform acts meant to destroy the world.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Ugra-karmäëaù kñayäya jagato 'hitaù [Bg. 16.9]. They perform acts meant for inauspiciousness and the destruction of the world.

The Difference Between the Living and the Nonliving

The Difference Between the Living and the Nonliving

[Çréla Prabhupäda points at a dead tree with his cane.]


ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Formerly leaves and twigs were growing from this tree. Now they are not. How would the scientists explain this?

KARANDHARA. They would say the tree’s chemical composition has changed.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. To prove that theory, they must be able to inject the proper chemicals to make branches and leaves grow again. The scientific method includes observation, hypothesis and then demonstration. Then it is perfect. But the scientists cannot actually demonstrate in their laboratories that life comes from matter. They simply observe and then speak nonsense. They are like children. In our childhood, we observed a gramophone box and thought that within the box was a man singing, an electric man. We thought there must have been an electric man or some kind of ghost in it. [Laughter.]

DR. SINGH. One of the popular questions that arises when we start studying biology is “What is the difference between a living organism and that which is not living?” The textbooks say that the chief characteristics that distinguish the two are that a living being can move and reproduce, whereas dead matter can do neither. But the books never talk about the nature of the soul or about the consciousness of the living entity.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But consciousness is the primary indication that life is present. Only because of consciousness can a living being move and reproduce. Because a person is conscious, he thinks of marrying, and begetting children. And the original consciousness is described in the Vedas: tad aikñata bahu syäm (Chändogya Upaniñad 6.2.3). This means that God, the original conscious being, said, “I shall become many.” Without consciousness, there is no possibility of by-products.

The Individual Living Force

The Individual Living Force

DR. SINGH. From experience they know that it will not grow.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Then what is the element that is lacking? Scientists say that chemicals are the cause of life, but all the chemicals that were present when the tree was alive are still there. And these chemicals are still supporting the lives of many living entities such as microbes and insects. So they cannot say that life energy is lacking in the body of the tree. The life energy is there.

DR. SINGH. But what about the life energy of the tree itself?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, that is the difference. The living force is individual, and the particular individual living entity that was the tree has left. This must be the case, since all the chemicals necessary to support life are still there, yet the tree is dead. Here is another example. Suppose I am living in an apartment, and then I leave it. I am gone, but many other living entities remain there—ants, spiders and so forth. So it is not true that simply because I have left the apartment, it can no longer accommodate life. Other living entities are still living there. It is simply that I—an individual living being—have left. The chemicals in the tree are like the apartment: they are simply the environment for the individual force—the soul—to act through. And the soul is an individual. I am an individual, and therefore I may leave the apartment. Similarly, the microbes are also individuals; they have individual consciousness. If they are moving in one direction but are somehow blocked, they think, “Let me go the other way.” They have personality.

KARANDHARA. But in a dead body there is no personality.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. This indicates that the individual soul has left that body. The soul has left, and therefore the tree does not grow.

DR. SINGH. Within the living body, Çréla Prabhupäda, there are innumerable small living entities, but the individual self who owns the body is also living there. Is that correct?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. In my body there are millions of living entities. In my intestines there are many worms. If they become strong, then whatever I eat, they eat, and I derive no benefit from the food. Therefore those who are full of hookworms eat very much but do not grow. They become lean and thin, and they are very hungry, because these small living entities are eating their food. So there are thousands and millions of living entities in my body—they are individuals, and I am an individual—but I am the proprietor of the body, just as I may be the proprietor of a garden in which many millions of living entities reside.

STUDENT. So if I eat kåñëa-prasäda [food offered to Lord Kåñëa], are the living entities in my body also eating prasäda?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. You are very benevolent. [Laughs.] You take kåñëa-prasäda for others.

KARANDHARA. Welfare work.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, but there are so many things within you for them to eat that you do not need to make a separate endeavor to feed them.

Minimum Words, Maximum Solution

Minimum Words, Maximum Solution

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The individual soul is never lost. He does not die, nor is he born. He simply changes from one body to another, just as one changes garments. This is perfect science.

DR. SINGH. But why don’t scientists accept this?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They are not nice men. They are rascals. They are not even gentlemen. Under appropriate circumstances, gentlemen will have some shyness or some shame. But these men are shameless. They cannot properly answer our challenges, yet they shamelessly claim that they are scientists and that they will create life. They are not even gentlemen. At least I regard them like that. A gentleman will be ashamed to speak nonsense.

DR. SINGH. They do not think before they speak.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That means that they are not human beings. A human being thinks twice before saying anything. Kåñëa makes the presence of life within the body so easy to understand. He says:

dehino 'smin yathä dehe

kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä

tathä dehäntara-präptir

dhéras tatra na muhyati

[“As the embodied soul continually passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. The self-realized soul is not bewildered by such a change.” (Bg. 2.13)] In these two lines, Kåñëa solves the whole biological problem. That is knowledge. Minimum words, maximum solution. Volumes of books expounding nonsense have no meaning. Materialistic scientists are like croaking frogs: ka-ka-ka, ka-ka-ka. [Çréla Prabhupäda imitates the sound of a croaking frog, and the others laugh.] The frogs are thinking, “Oh, we are talking very nicely,” but the result is that the snake finds them and says, “Oh, here is a nice frog!” [Çréla Prabhupäda imitates the sound of a snake eating a frog.] Bup! Finished. When death comes, everything is finished. The materialistic scientists are croaking—ka-ka-ka—but when death comes, their scientific industry is finished, and they become dogs, cats or something like that.

LCL: The Third Morning Walk

The Third Morning Walk

Recorded on April 28, 1973,

In Cheviot Hills Park, Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Karandhara däsa adhikaré and other students.

Scientists as Thieves

Scientists as Thieves

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. [holding a rose in his hand]. Can any scientist create a flower like this in the laboratory?

DR. SINGH. That is not possible.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No, it is not. Just see how wonderfully Kåñëa’s energy is working! No scientist can create a flower like this in his laboratory. They cannot create even a few grains of sand, yet they claim to possess the most advanced intellects in the universe. This is foolish.

DR. SINGH. They take matter from Kåñëa, manipulate it, and then claim that they have created something wonderful.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. At least if they would admit that they have taken the matter from Kåñëa, that would be good. We understand that everything comes from Kåñëa.

DR. SINGH. But they will not admit that they are taking anything from Kåñëa. Instead they say that they are the creators.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. How have they created anything? They take the sand and mix it with some chemicals and make glass. They have not created the sand or the chemicals; they have taken them from the earth. How have they created anything?

DR. SINGH. They say, “We have taken the materials from nature.”

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. “From nature” means from a person. They have taken from nature, but they are thieves because everything in nature belongs to Kåñëa. Éçäväsyam idaà sarvam: “Everything is God’s creation.” [Éçopaniñad 1] In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa states that if one does not perform yajïa [sacrifice], he is a thief. Yajïa means acknowledging that things have been taken from Kåñëa. We should think, “Kåñëa, You have given us many, many things for our maintenance.” This much acknowledgement Kåñëa wants; that’s all. Otherwise, what can He expect from you? What are you in His presence? We should acknowledge Kåñëa’s kindness. Therefore, before we eat we offer the food to Kåñëa and say, “Kåñëa, You have given us this nice food, so first You taste it.” Then we eat it.

Kåñëa is not hungry, yet He can eat the whole world and then again produce it exactly as it was. Pürëasya pürëam ädäya pürëam evävaçiñyate. Kåñëa is so perfect that if you take from Kåñëa all of Kåñëa’s energy, all the original energy is still with Him. That is perfect conservation of energy.

The Origin of Nature

The Origin of Nature

DR. SINGH. There is a scientific journal called Nature. It contains articles concerning natural products like plants, flowers and minerals, but it does not mention God.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. We may rightly observe that plants are being produced by nature. But the next question we must ask is, “Who has produced nature?” To ask this is real intelligence.

DR. SINGH. They don’t generally think about this.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Then they are foolish. Where does nature come from? As soon as we speak of nature, the next question should be, “Whose nature?” Is it not so? For instance, I speak of my nature, and you speak of your nature. Therefore, as soon as we speak of nature, the next inquiry should be, “Whose nature?” Nature means energy. And as soon as we speak of energy, we must inquire into the source of that energy. For example, if you speak of electric energy, you must accept its source, the powerhouse. How can you deny it? Electricity does not come to us automatically. Similarly, nature is not working automatically; it is under the control of Kåñëa.

STUDENT. In the Vedas it is said that material energy works under Kåñëa’s direction.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. As soon as you speak of energy, there must be a source.

The Mirage of the Material World

The Mirage of the Material World

KARANDHARA. Geologists study the strata of the earth’s crust to trace out the origin of the earth.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But these strata are being created and destroyed at every moment. Now they are one way, and a half hour from now they will be different. They are jagat, always changing. Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä [8.4], adhibhütaà kñaro bhävaù: “Physical nature is known to be endlessly mutable.” Therefore, one cannot find out the source of all energy simply by observing the energy itself. Now the earth’s strata may be black, later they may be white, and then again black. So the geologists study the black color, then the white color, again the black, and so on. This is called punaù punaç carvita-carvaëänäm, “chewing the chewed.”5 Now it is cold, at midday it will be warm, and at night it will be cold again. In this way, the entire material cosmic manifestation is subject to different types of change. Even our bodies are changing. Everything is changing. But what is the eternity behind this changing? That is the subject of real knowledge. The scientists do not find that eternity, and therefore they are disappointed. They think that the background of everything is void, zero. They think that eternity is zero. And when they are asked where this zero comes from, they say, “It comes from nothing.” So we must ask them, “How have the varieties come about?” The Vedic conclusion is that variety is eternal, although the changing varieties the scientists study in the material world are temporary. These varieties are shadow varieties. Real variety exists eternally in the spiritual world.

DR. SINGH. So the material universe is like a mirage?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Suppose I think I see water in the desert when there is not water. This is an illusion. Water exists, but not in the mirage. Similarly, the material varieties we see—the varieties of enjoyment—are like that mirage. We, the living entities, are meant for enjoyment, but we are seeking enjoyment in a false place—in an illusion. We are like the desert animals who run after water in a mirage and eventually die of thirst.

They cannot relieve their thirst with such illusory water. Similarly, we are trying to manufacture many things to satisfy our thirst for enjoyment, but we are being baffled at every turn because material existence is an illusion. Therefore real intelligence means to inquire, “Where is the reality? Where is the eternal substance behind the illusion?” If we can find that out, we can experience real enjoyment.

LCL: The Fourth Morning Walk

The Fourth Morning Walk

Recorded on April, 29, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Brahmänanda Svämé, Karandhara däsa adhikaré and other students.

The Progress of the Asses

The Progress of the Asses

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Everyone is suffering here in the material world, and scientific improvement means that the scientists are creating a situation of further suffering. That’s all. They are not making improvements. Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura6 confirms this by saying, moha janamiyä, anitya saàsäre, jévake karaye gädhä [Vidyära viläse 3]: “By so-called scientific improvements, the scientist has become an ass.” Moreover, he is becoming a better and better ass, and nothing more. Suppose that by working very hard like an ass, a person builds a skyscraper. He may engage in a lifelong labor for this, but ultimately he must die. He cannot stay; he will be kicked out of his skyscraper, because material life is impermanent. Scientists are constantly doing research, and if you ask them what they are doing, they say, “Oh, it is for the next generation, for the future.” But I say, “What about you? What about your skyscraper? If in your next life you are going to be a tree, what will you do with your next generation then?” But he is an ass. He does not know that he is going to stand before his skyscraper for ten thousand years. And what about the next generation? If there is no petrol, what will the next generation do? And how will the next generation help him if he is going to be a cat, a dog or a tree?

The scientists—and everyone else—should endeavor to achieve freedom from the repetition of birth and death. But instead, everyone is becoming more and more entangled in the cycle of birth and death. Bhave 'smin kliçyamänänäm avidyä-käma-karmabhiù. This is a quotation from Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.8.35]. Here in one line the whole material existence is explained. This is literature. This one line is worth thousands of years of research work. It explains how the living entity is taking birth in this world, where he comes from, where he is going, what his activities should be, and many other essential things. The words bhave 'smin kliçyamänänäm refer to the struggle for existence. Why does this struggle exist? Because of avidya, ignorance. And what is the nature of that ignorance? Käma-karmabhiù, being forced to work simply for the senses, or in other words, entanglement in material sense gratification.

STUDENT. So, is it true that modern scientific research increases the demands of the body because the scientist is ultimately working to gratify his senses?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes.

Word Jugglery and World Crisis

Word Jugglery and World Crisis

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. It is said in the Vedas, yasmin vijïäte sarvam evaà vijïätaà bhavati: “If one knows the Absolute Truth, then all other things become known.” I am not a Ph.D., yet I can challenge the scientists. Why? Because I know Kåñëa, the Absolute Truth. Yasmin sthito na duùkhena guruëäpi vicälyate: “If one is situated in Kåñëa consciousness, then even in the greatest calamities he will not be disturbed.” Çrémad-Bhägavatam [1.5.22] declares, avicyuto 'rthaù kavibhir nirüpito yad uttamaçloka-guëänuvarëanam: “Great personalities have decided that Kåñëa consciousness is the perfection of life.” This kind of knowledge is required. Not that we do some research, come up with a theory, and after fifteen years say, “No, no, it is not right—it is another thing.” That is not science; that is child’s play.

DR. SINGH. That is how they discover things—by research.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. And what is the cost of the research? It is a scientific method for drawing money from others, that’s all. In other words, it is cheating. Scientists juggle words like plutonium, photons, hydrogen and oxygen, but what good will people get from this? When people hear this jugglery of words, what can they say? One scientist explains something to some extent, and then another rascal comes along and explains it again, but differently, with different words. And all the time the phenomenon has remained the same. What advancement has been made? They have simply produced volumes of books. Now there is a petrol problem. Scientists have created it. If the petrol supply dwindles away, what will these rascal scientists do? They are powerless to do anything about it.

The Billion-Dollar Dustheap

The Billion-Dollar Dustheap

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Now there is a scarcity of water in India, but what are the scientists doing about it? There is more than enough water in the world, so why don’t the scientists bring water where it is urgently required? They should employ irrigation immediately. But instead they are going to the moon, the dusty planet, to make it fertile. Why don’t they irrigate this planet? There’s plenty of seawater, so why don’t they irrigate the Sahara or the Arabian or Rajasthani Desert? “Yes,” they say, “in the future. We are trying.” In their pride, they immediately say, “Yes, yes. We are trying.” In Bhagavad-gétä it is said that when one is engaged in the business of satisfying unnecessary desires, he becomes bereft of all intelligence (kämais tais tair håta-jïänäù).

This moon project is childish. Those who aspire to go to the moon are like crying children. A child cries, “Mother, give me the moon,” so the mother gives the child a mirror and says, “Here is the moon, my dear son.” And the child takes the mirror, sees the moon in it and says, “Oh, I have the moon.” Unfortunately, this is not just a story.

KARANDHARA. After spending all that money to go to the moon and bring back just a few rocks, the people on the space project decided that there was nothing more to do there.

BRAHMÄNANDA SWAMI. Now they want to go to another planet, but they are short of money. Going to other planets costs millions and billions of dollars.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. People work very hard while the rascal government takes taxes and spends money unnecessarily. There should be no sympathy when so much hard-earned money comes from the public and is spent so foolishly. Now the leaders are presenting another bluff “Don’t worry, we are going to another planet. Now we shall bring more dust. We shall bring tons of dust. Oh, yes, now we shall have tons of dust.”

DR. SINGH. They believe there may be life on Mars.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They may believe or not believe. What is the difference? Life exists here, but people are fighting. So suppose there is life on Mars. There is life on Mars, undoubtedly. But what will we gain from this?

DR. SINGH. People are curious to know what is going on there.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That means that for their childish curiosity they must spend vast sums of money. Just see the fun. And when they are asked to help one of the many poverty-stricken countries, they say, “No. No money.” Do you see?

Säìkhya Philosophy and Modern Science

Säìkhya Philosophy and Modern Science

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, may we hear a little bit about Säìkhya philosophy?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. There are actually two kinds of Säìkhya philosophy: the ancient Säìkhya philosophy originally taught by Lord Kapiladeva, and the modern Säìkhya philosophy taught more recently by the atheist Kapila. Lord Kapila’s Säìkhya explains how to become detached from matter and search out Lord Viñëu within the heart. This Säìkhya is actually a process of devotional service. But the modern Säìkhya philosophy simply analyzes the material world into its various elements. In that respect, it is just like modern scientific research. Säìkhya means “to count.” We are also Säìkhya philosophers to some extent because we count the material elements: this is land, this is water, this is fire, this is air, this is ether. Furthermore, I can count my mind, my intelligence and my ego. Beyond my ego, however, I cannot count. But Kåñëa says that there is something beyond the ego, and that is the living force. This is what scientists do not know. They think that life is merely a combination of material elements, but Kåñëa denies this in the Bhagavad-gétä [7.5]:

apareyam itas tv anyäà

prakåtià viddhi me paräm

jéva-bhütäà mahä-bäho

yayedaà dhäryate jagat

“Besides this inferior nature [earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and false ego] there is a superior energy of Mine, which consists of all the living entities who are struggling with material nature and sustaining the universe.”

DR. SINGH. Are both the inferior and the superior energies studied in modern Säìkhya philosophy?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No. Modern Säìkhya philosophers do not study the superior energy. They simply analyze the material elements, just as the scientists are doing. The scientists do not know that there is spirit soul, nor do the Säìkhya philosophers.

DR. SINGH. They are analyzing the creative material elements?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The material elements are not creative! Only the soul is creative. Life cannot be created from matter, and matter cannot create itself. You, a living entity, can mix hydrogen and oxygen to create water. But matter itself has no creative potency. If you place a bottle of hydrogen near a bottle of oxygen, will they automatically combine, without your help?

DR. SINGH. No. They must be mixed.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Of course. Oxygen and hydrogen are Kåñëa’s inferior energy, but when you, the superior energy, mix them, then they can become water.

The Remote Cause and the Immediate Cause

The Remote Cause and the Immediate Cause

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Inferior energy has no power unless superior energy is involved. This sea [indicating the Pacific Ocean] is calm and quiet. But when the superior force, air, pushes it, it manifests high waves. The ocean has no power to move without the superior force of the air. Similarly, there is another force superior to the air, and another and another, until ultimately we arrive at Kåñëa. This is real research. Kåñëa controls nature just as an engineer controls a train. The engineer controls the locomotive, which pulls one car, and that car in turn pulls another, which pulls another, and so the whole train is moving. Similarly, with the creation, Kåñëa gives the first push, and then, by means of successive pushes, the entire cosmic manifestation comes into being and is maintained. This is explained in Bhagavad-gétä. Mayädhyakñena prakåtiù süyate sacaräcaram: “This material nature is working under My direction and is producing all moving and unmoving beings.” And in the Fourteenth Chapter [14.4] Kåñëa says:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya

mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù

täsäà brahma mahad yonir

ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

“All species of life are made possible by birth in this material nature, O son of Kunté, and I am the seed-giving father.” For example, if we sow a banyan seed, a huge tree eventually comes up and, along with it, millions of new seeds. Each of these seeds can in turn produce another tree with millions of new seeds, and so on. This is how Kåñëa, the original seed-giving father, is the primary cause of everything we see.

Unfortunately, the scientists observe only the immediate cause; they cannot perceive the remote cause. Kåñëa is described in the Vedas as sarva-käraëa-käraëam, the cause of all causes. If one understands the cause of all causes, then he understands everything. Yasmin vijïäte sarvam evaà vijïätaà bhavati: “If one knows the original cause, the subordinate causes are automatically known.” Although the scientists are searching after the original cause, when the Vedas, perfect knowledge, declare the original cause to be the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the scientists won’t accept it. They keep to their partial, imperfect knowledge. This is their disease.

The Cosmic Machine

The Cosmic Machine

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Scientists do not know that there are two types of energy—inferior and superior—although they are actually working with these two energies every day. Material energy can never work independently; it must first come in contact with spiritual energy. So how can people accept that the entire cosmic manifestation, which is nothing but matter, has come about automatically? A competent machine does not work unless a man who knows how to work it pushes a button. A Cadillac is a nice car, but if it has no driver, what is the use of it? So the material universe is also a machine.

People are amazed at seeing a big machine with many, many parts, but an intelligent person knows that however wonderful a machine may be, it does not work unless an operator comes and pushes the proper button. Therefore, who is more important—the operator or the machine? So we are concerned not with the material machine—this cosmic manifestation—but with its operator, Kåñëa. Now you may say, “Well, how do I know that He is the operator?” Kåñëa says, mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sacaräcaram: “Under My direction the whole cosmic manifestation is working.” If you say, “No, Kåñëa is not the operator behind the cosmos,” then you have to accept another operator, and you must present him. But this you cannot do. Therefore, in the absence of your proof, you should accept mine.

LCL: The Fifth Morning Walk

The Fifth Morning Walk

Recorded on May 3, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh and Brahmänanda Svämé.

The Invisible Pilot

The Invisible Pilot

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Almost everyone in the world is under the false impression that life is born from matter. We cannot allow this nonsensical theory to go unchallenged. Life does not come from matter. Matter is generated from life. This is not theory; it is fact. Science is based on an incorrect theory; therefore all its calculations and conclusions are wrong, and people are suffering because of this. When all these mistaken modern scientific theories are corrected, people will become happy. So we must challenge the scientists and defeat them; otherwise they will mislead the entire society. Matter changes in six phases: birth, growth, maintenance, production of by-products, dwindling and death. But the life within matter, the spirit soul, is eternal; it goes through no such changes. Life appears to be developing and decaying, but actually it is simply passing through each of these six phases until the material body can no longer be maintained. Then the old body dies, and the soul enters a new body. When our clothing is old and worn, we change it. Similarly, one day our bodies become old and useless, and we pass on to a new body.

As Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä, dehino 'smin yathä dehe kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä/ tathä dehäntara-präptiù: “As the embodied soul continually passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death.” And a little later: antavanta ime dehä nityasyoktäù çarériëaù. This means that only the material body of the indestructible and eternal living entity is subject to destruction. The material body is perishable, but the life within the body is nitya, eternal.

Everything works on the basis of this living force. This is the Pacific Ocean, and these high waves are being manipulated by living force. This airplane [Çréla Prabhupäda gestures toward a passing aircraft] is flying, but is it flying undirected?

DR. SINGH. Someone is directing it.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Everything is working under someone’s direction. Why do the rascal scientists deny this? The airplane is a big machine, but it is flying under the direction of a small spiritual spark, the pilot. Scientists cannot prove that this big 747 airplane could fly without the small spiritual spark. So, as the small spiritual spark can direct a large plane, the big spiritual spark directs the whole cosmic manifestation.

Setting the Real Problems Aside

Setting the Real Problems Aside

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad says:

keçägra-çata-bhägasya

çatäàçaù sädåçätmakaù

jévaù sükñma-svarüpo 'yaà

saìkhyätéto hi cit-kaëaù
[Madhya 19.140]

According to this verse, the measurement of the soul, the proprietor of the body, is one ten-thousandth part of the tip of a hair. This is very small—atomic. But because of that atomic spiritual energy, my body is working. That atomic spiritual energy is within the body, and therefore the body works, and the airplane flies. Is it so difficult to understand?

Suppose a man thinks himself very stout and strong. Why is he stout and strong? It is only because within him there exists a spiritual spark. As soon as the small spiritual spark is gone, his strength and vigor disappear, and the vultures come and eat his body. If scientists say that matter is the cause and origin of life, then let us ask them to bring back to life just one dead man, one great man like Professor Einstein. Let them inject some chemicals so that just one dead man may come back to life and work again. But this they cannot do. There are so many things they do not know, but still they are called scientists.

DR. SINGH. Sometimes when a problem is too dreadfully serious, we tend to take it lightly.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. When a monkey confronts a tiger, the monkey closes its eyes, and the tiger immediately attacks. Similarly, if scientists cannot solve a problem, they may think, “All right, let it go on.” This is actually what they are doing, because our real problem is death. No one wants to die, but scientists cannot stop death. They speak superficially about death because they cannot give any relief from it. We do not wish to die, we do not wish to become old, and we do not wish to become diseased. But what help can the scientists offer? They cannot do anything about it. They have set aside the major problems.

President Jackal

President Jackal

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. In Bengal there is a story called jaìgal-ké räjä, concerning a jackal who became king of the forest. Jackals are known for their cunning. One day this jackal came into a village and fell into a tub of blue dye. He fled to the forest, but he had become blue. So all the animals said, “What is this? What is this? Who is this animal?” Even the lion was surprised: “We have never seen you before, sir. So who are you?” The jackal replied, “I have been sent by God.” So they began to worship him as God. But then one night some other jackals began to cry: “Wa, wa, wa!” And since jackals cannot restrain themselves from returning the call of their own kind, this blue jackal also began to cry, “Wa, wa, wa!” And thus he exposed himself before all the other animals as being nothing more than a jackal. Many jackals have been arrested and have resigned from your government.

BRAHMÄNANDA SWAMI. The Watergate affair. It is called the Watergate scandal.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Practically speaking, at the present moment no honest man can become a government official. This is true everywhere. Unless one is a rogue, a dishonest person, one can not maintain his governmental position. Therefore no noble man goes into the government. But what can you do?

DR. SINGH. Politicians are the greatest cheaters.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, they are scoundrels. One philosopher said that politics is the last resort of scoundrels.

Science Should Stop Death

Science Should Stop Death

BRAHMÄNANDA SWAMI. Do scientists know the cause of cancer?

DR. SINGH. They have several theories.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Suppose you know the cause of cancer. What is the benefit? Even if you could stop cancer, you could not make a man live forever. That is not possible. Cancer or no cancer, a man has to die. He cannot stop death. Death may be caused, if not by cancer, simply by an accident. Real scientific research should aim at stopping death. That is real science, and that is Kåñëa consciousness. Simply to discover some medicine to cure disease is not a triumph. The real triumph is to stop all disease. Bhagavad-gétä asserts that the real trouble is birth, death, old age and disease. Äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù punar ävartino 'rjuna: “From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place.” The solution to the problem of repeated birth and death is Kåñëa consciousness, which we are practicing and offering to everyone. The perfect result of this practice is that after the present body becomes useless and dies, one is no longer forced to accept a material body subject to birth, death, disease and old age. This is real science.

LCL: The Sixth Morning Walk

The Sixth Morning Walk

Recorded on May 7, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Brahmänanda Svämé and other students.

Chemicals from Mystic Power

Chemicals from Mystic Power

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The scientists say that life begins from chemicals. But the real question is, “Where have the chemicals come from?” The chemicals come from life, and this means that life has mystic powers. For example, an orange tree contains many oranges, and each orange contains chemicals—citric acid and others. So where have these chemicals come from? Obviously they have come from the life within the tree. The scientists are missing the origin of the chemicals. They have started their investigation from the chemicals, but they cannot identify the origin of the chemicals. Chemicals come from the supreme life—God. Just as the living body of a man produces many chemicals, the supreme life (the Supreme Lord) is producing all the chemicals found in the atmosphere, in the water, in humans, in animals and in the earth. And that is called mystic power. Unless the mystic power of the Lord is accepted, there is no solution to the problem of the origin of life.

DR. SINGH. The scientists will reply that they cannot believe in mystic power.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But they must explain the origin of the chemicals. Anyone can see that an ordinary tree is producing many chemicals. But how does it produce them? Since the scientists cannot answer this, they must accept that the living force has mystic power. I cannot even explain how my fingernail is growing out of my finger; it is beyond the power of my brain. In other words, my fingernail is growing by inconceivable potency, acintya-çakti. So if acintya-çakti exists in an ordinary human being, imagine how much acintya-çakti God possesses. The difference between God and me is that although I have the same potencies as God, I can produce only a small quantity of chemicals, whereas He can produce enormous quantities. I can produce a little water in the form of perspiration, but God can produce the seas. Analysis of one drop of seawater gives you the qualitative analysis of the sea, without any mistake. Similarly, the ordinary living being is part and parcel of God, so by analyzing the living beings we can begin to understand God. In God there is great mystic potency. God’s mystic potency is working swiftly, exactly like an electric machine. Some machines operate by electrical energy, and they are so nicely made that all the work is done simply by pushing a button. Similarly, God said, “Let there be creation,” and there was creation. Considered in this way, the workings of nature are not very difficult to understand. God has such wonderful potencies that the creation, on His order alone, immediately takes place.

BRAHMÄNANDA SWAMI. Some scientists don’t accept God or acintya-çakti.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is their rascaldom. God exists, and His acintya-çakti also exists. Where does a bird’s power to fly come from? Both you and the bird are living entities, but the bird can fly because of its acintya-çakti, and you cannot. To give another example, semen is produced from blood. A man has mystic power in his body so that because he is sexually inclined, blood is transformed into semen. How is this done unless there is some mystic power involved? There are many mystic powers in the living entities. The cow eats grass and produces milk. Everyone knows this, but can you take some grass and produce milk? Can you? Therefore there is mystic power within the cow. As soon as the cow eats grass, she can transform it into milk. Men and women are basically the same, but as a man you cannot eat food and produce milk, although a woman can. These are mystic powers.

DR. SINGH. Scientists would say that there are different enzymes or chemicals inside different types of bodies and that these account for the cow’s producing milk.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, but who produced those enzymes and that arrangement? That was done by mystic power. You cannot make these enzymes or that arrangement. You cannot produce milk from dry grass in your laboratory. Within your body, by mystic power, you can transform food into blood and tissue, but in your laboratory, without mystic power, you cannot even transform grass into milk. Therefore you must accept the existence of mystic power.

The Origin of Mystic power

The Origin of Mystic power

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yogés are mainly concerned with developing different mystic powers. A yogé can walk on the water without drowning. The law of gravity does not operate on him. That is a mystic power called laghimä. Laghimä means that a person can become lighter than cotton and counteract the law of gravity. The yoga system simply develops the inconceivable potency already present in the practitioner. These boys are swimming [gesturing to surf bathers], but I cannot swim. Yet that swimming power is potential within me; I simply have to practice it. So, if yogic power is so potent in the human being, think how much more yogic power God has. Therefore, in the Vedas He is called Yogeçvara, which means “master of all mystic power.” In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says, ahaà sarvasya prabhavo mattaù sarvaà pravartate: “I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me.” Unless we accept this statement from God, there is no conclusive explanation to the origin of material nature. God cannot be understood without accepting the existence of mystic power, but if you understand God scientifically, then you will understand everything.

DR. SINGH. So do you mean to say that science has started from an intermediate point—not from the original point?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, that is it exactly. They are ignorant of the origin. The scientists start from one point—but where does that point come from? That they do not know, in spite of vast research. One has to accept that the original source is God, who is full of all mystic powers and from whom everything emanates. He Himself says in the Bhagavad-gétä, ahaà sarvasya prabhavo mattaù sarvaà pravartate: “I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me.” Our conclusions are not based on blind faith; they are most scientific. Matter comes from life. In life—in the origin—there are unlimited material resources; that is the great mystery of creation.

If you drop a needle, it will fall immediately, but a bird weighing several pounds can float in the air. We must establish the origin of this floating. If we study nature, we find that every living entity has some mystic power. A man cannot live within the water for more than a few hours, yet a fish lives there continuously. is that not mystic power?

DR. SINGH. It is mystic power for me, but not for the fish.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. That is because mystic power is not uniformly distributed. But all the mystic powers exist in God, the origin of everything. I derive some of His mystic power, you derive some, and the birds derive some. But the storehouse of mystic power is God.

There are eight basic types of mystic powers. Some of them are laghimä (by which one can become lighter than a feather), mahimä (by which one can become bigger than a mountain), präpti (which enables one to capture anything he likes) and éçitva (by which one can completely subdue and control another being). Another type of mystic power can be seen in the sun, because from the sunshine innumerable things are inexplicably produced. Unless the scientists accept the existence of mystic power, they cannot explain these phenomena. They are simply beating around the bush.

DR. SINGH. A clever scientist may say anything to prove his point, without actually proving it. A real scientist must reach the ultimate, original cause—the final analysis.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, unless he finds the ultimate source, he is not actually practicing science.

DR. SINGH. Does understanding mysticism mean knowing that every day our bodies are dying?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes.

DR. SINGH. But the average man does not think he is dying.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is due to foolishness. Every moment he is dying, but he is thinking, “I shall live forever.” Actually, death begins from the very moment of birth. Our analysis of the problem is that since people are dying, we should stop their death. But the so-called scientists are not only accelerating the process of death, but also refusing to take constructive advice to correct themselves.

LCL: The Seventh Morning Walk

The Seventh Morning Walk

Recorded on May 8, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh and other students.

The Cheaters and the Cheated

The Cheaters and the Cheated

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Natural phenomena such as the law of gravity or weightlessness are acintya-çakti, inconceivable energies, and real science means to understand this acintya-çakti. To observe a chain of events only from a certain point in time is un-scientific and gives only incomplete knowledge. We must know where things begin. If we carry our investigation far enough, we will find that the origin of nature is acintya-çakti. For example, with brain, brush and color we can paint a flower. But we cannot conceive how vegetation throughout the whole earth is automatically growing and fructifying. We can explain the painted flower, but we cannot explain the real flower. Scientists actually cannot explain biological growth. They simply juggle words like molecule and chromosome, but they cannot actually explain the phenomena.

The essential fault of the so-called scientists is that they have adopted the inductive process to arrive at their conclusions. For example, if a scientist wants to determine by the inductive process whether or not man is mortal, he must study every man to try to discover if some or one of them may be immortal. The scientist says, “I cannot accept the proposition that all men are mortal. There may be some men who are immortal. I have not yet seen every man. Therefore how can I accept that man is mortal?” This is called the inductive process. And the deductive process means that your father, your teacher or your guru says that man is mortal, and you accept it.

DR. SINGH. So there is an ascending process of gaining knowledge and a descending process?7

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. The ascending process will never be successful, because it relies on the information gathered through the senses, and the senses are imperfect. So we accept the descending process.

God cannot be known by the inductive process. Therefore He is called adhokñaja, which means “unknowable by direct perception.” The scientists say there is no God because they are trying to understand Him by direct perception. But He is adhokñaja! Therefore, the scientists are ignorant of God because they are missing the method of knowing Him. In order to understand transcendental science, one must approach a bona fide spiritual master, hear from him submissively and render service to him. Lord Kåñëa explains that in the Bhagavad-gétä: tad viddhi praëipätena paripraçnena sevayä.

My Guru Mahäräja8 once said, “The modern world is a society of the cheaters and the cheated.” Unfortunately, the cheated are eulogizing the cheaters, and the small cheaters are worshiping the great cheaters. Suppose a flock of asses comes and eulogizes me, saying, “Oh, you are Jagad-guru.”9 What is the value of their praise? But if a gentleman or learned man gives praise, his words have some value. Generally, however, the persons who are praising and those who are being praised are both ignorant. As the Vedas put it, saàstutaù puruñaù paçuù: “A big animal is being praised by a small animal.”

Compassion

Compassion

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The law is cheating, medical science is cheating, and the government is cheating. Top government officials are charged with taking bribes. If the governor takes bribes and the constable takes bribes, then where is the good society? People elect the leader who promises them happiness. But since that happiness is mäyä [or illusion], he can never deliver it, and society simply becomes filled with cheaters. Since people are actually after this illusory happiness, however, they continue to elect such unscrupulous leaders time and time again.

The position of a Vaisnava10 is to take compassion on all these ignorant people. The great Vaiñëava Prahläda Mahäräja once prayed to the Lord, “My Lord, as far as I am concerned, I have no problems. My consciousness is always absorbed in Your very powerful transcendental activities, and therefore I have understood things clearly. But I am deeply concerned for these rascals who are engaged in activities for illusory happiness.”

A Vaiñëava thinks only about how people can become happy. He knows that they are vainly searching after something that will never come to be. For fifty or sixty years people search after illusory happiness, but then they must die without completing the work and without knowing what will happen after death. Actually, their position is like that of an animal, because an animal also does not know what happens to him after death. The animal does not know the value of life, nor why he has come here. By the influence of mäyä, he simply eats, sleeps, mates, defends and dies. That’s all. Throughout their lives the ignorant animals—and the animalistic men—greatly endeavor to do these five things only: eat, sleep, mate, defend and die. Therefore the business of a Vaiñëava is to instruct people that God exists, that we are His servants, and that we can enjoy an eternally blissful life serving Him and developing our love for Him.

Beyond the Cage

Beyond the Cage

DR. SINGH. But doesn’t the living entity need matter as long as he is in material nature?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No, the living entity is purely spiritual; therefore, he doesn’t require matter. Because his thinking is diseased, however, he believes he does. The conditioned living entity is like a drunkard who doesn’t require drinking, but who nevertheless thinks, “Without drinking, I shall die.” This is called mäyä, or illusion. Is it true that if a drunkard doesn’t get his drink, he will die?

DR. SINGH. No, but if a man doesn’t eat, he will die.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That’s also not a fact. Last night we were discussing Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé.11 In his later life, he almost completely abstained from eating and sleeping. He would drink only a little buttermilk every three or four days, and he worked twenty-two hours a day, sleeping two or three. And some days he did not sleep at all. So you may ask, “How could he survive?” Actually, he lived for one hundred years. Eating, sleeping, mating and defending were not problems for Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, but still he lived. Because he was a pure devotee of Kåñëa, he was fully aware that the soul is eternal and independent, although it has been put into this bodily cage, which it actually does not require. Suppose a bird is encaged. Is he living simply because he is in the cage? Without the cage he is free. People are thinking that by being encaged within the body they are happy. That is nonsense. Actually, our encagement within this body makes us fearful. But as soon as we purify our existence—we do not even have to come out of our bodies—we will immediately be abhaya, fearless.

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä

na çocati na käìkñati

samaù sarveñu bhüteñu

mad-bhaktià labhate paräm12
[Bg. 18.54]

We can immediately awaken to our original, spiritual existence, in which there is no more fear, no more lamentation, and no more material desire.

DR. SINGH. But the scientist would still want some more explanations as to how the living entity can be independent of matter.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. As long as you are conditioned, you are dependent on matter. For example, a man from Africa is conditioned because he cannot tolerate this cold weather. Therefore he feels discomfort. But there are many people here [gesturing toward children playing on the beach] who are not affected by the cold. The ability to tolerate is simply a question of conditioning.

When you are conditioned, you think in terms of dualities like hot and cold, pain and pleasure. But when you are liberated, you have no such conditioned thoughts. Spiritual life means to become unconditioned—to come to the brahma-bhuta stage. That is the perfection of life. Being conditioned means that although the living entity is eternal, due to his conditioning he thinks that he is born, he is dying, he is diseased and he is old. But an unconditioned person is not even old. Kåñëa is described in the Brahma-saàhitä as advaitam acyutam anädim ananta rüpam ädyaà puräëa-puruñaà nava-yauvanaà ca. This means that He is the oldest person, the first person, but that He has no old age. He always appears just like a young man of twenty because He is fully spiritual.

LCL: The Eighth Morning Walk

The Eighth Morning Walk

Recorded on May 11, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh and other students.

The Evolution of Consciousness

The Evolution of Consciousness

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, I came across a statement in the Bhagavad-gétä to the effect that all 8,400,000 species of living entities are created simultaneously. Is that correct?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes.

DR. SINGH. Does that mean that there are some living entities who come directly to the human species without undergoing the evolutionary process?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Living beings move from one bodily form to another. The forms already exist. The living entity simply transfers himself, just as a man transfers himself from one apartment to another. One apartment is first class, another is second class and another is third class. Suppose a person comes from a lower-class apartment to a first-class apartment. The person is the same, but now, according to his capacity for payment, or karma,13 he is able to occupy a higher-class apartment. Real evolution does not mean physical development, but development of consciousness. Do you follow?

DR. SINGH. I think so. Do you mean that if one falls to one of the lower stages of life, he must evolve step by step up to the higher stages?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. As you get more money you can move to a better apartment. The apartment already exists, however. It is not that the lower-class apartment becomes the higher-class apartment. That is Darwin’s nonsensical theory. He would say that the apartment has become high class. Modern scientists think that life has come from matter. They say that millions and millions of years ago there was simply matter, but no life. We do not accept that. Of the two energies—life and matter—life, or spirit, is the original, superior energy, and matter is the resultant inferior energy.

DR. SINGH. Do they exist simultaneously?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, but spirit is independent, and matter is dependent. For example, I can live even without my hands or legs. If they were amputated, I could survive. Therefore I am not dependent on my hands and legs; my hands and legs are dependent on me, the spirit soul within my body.

Bodies for Eternal Desires

Bodies for Eternal Desires

DR. SINGH. But do life and matter come simultaneously?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No. They do not “come” at all. They already exist. The “coming” idea is in our minds because we are living in this limited world, where we see that there is a beginning to everything. Therefore we think in terms of things “coming.” But actually matter and spirit already exist. When I am born, I think my birth is the beginning of the world. But the world already exists. Another example is a fire. When you light a fire, do the light and heat begin later on? No. Whenever a fire is ignited, immediately there is light and heat. But suppose I think, “Now there is a fire, but I have to wait for the light and heat to come later on.” Isn’t that foolishness?

DR. SINGH. But fire is the source of the heat and light.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, but still the heat and light exist simultaneously with the fire. Similarly, the eternal living entities have many different eternal desires. And all the varieties of species also exist eternally to fit these various eternal desires.

DR. SINGH. And the living entities are made to live in different bodies according to these desires?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. For example, the government constructs a prison house because it knows there will be criminals. So when a criminal is tried and convicted, the prison already exists, even before the judgment period. Similarly, God is described as sarva-jïa, He who knows everything. Thus He knows that some living entities will become criminal and rebel against His service. Furthermore, He knows the various desires the living entities in the material world acquire according to the three modes of material nature. Therefore He creates all the species of life from the very beginning to accommodate all the conditioned souls.

The three modes of material nature are sattva-guëa [goodness], rajo-guëa [passion] and tamo-guëa [ignorance]. With these three qualities, all the different objects of the material world are made, just as one might mix the three primary colors (blue, red and yellow) to make millions of hues. The great expertise required to handle this arrangement exists in nature. According to the Bhagavad-gétä, prakåteù kriyamäëäni guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù: “All activities are performed by the modes of material nature.” And these modes are manifested in the different types of species, which include plants, trees, aquatics, human beings, demigods, cats, dogs and many others, totaling 8,400,000.

The Supreme Lord expands Himself as the Paramätmä, or Supersoul, in everyone’s heart. Although dwelling in the material body, this Supersoul is not material, even though He is the original source of the material body. Because heat and light are the energies of the sun, the sun never feels “too hot.” Similarly, for the Paramätmä there is no distinction between spiritual and material because both the material and the spiritual energies emanate from Him. Sometimes we see that clouds cover the sun; but that is actually our imperfection. We on this planet experience both sunshine and cloudiness, but on the sun, even though it can create clouds, only sunshine is experienced. Similarly, the division of matter and spirit is our experience, not God’s. Whether He comes in a so-called material body or in a spiritual body, He is always spiritual. For Him matter and spirit are the same because He is the energetic. He can turn matter into spirit, and spirit into matter.

H2O Plus Mystic Power

H2O Plus Mystic Power

DR. SINGH. The chemists and the scientists think that certain elements enable the spirit soul to remain in the material world. These elements, they say, are carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen—the main elements that combine to form living units. I think the Vedas teach that in order for a living creature to develop, spirit must first enter within these preexisting chemical elements. Is that correct?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. For example, the earth contains everything necessary for a plant to grow, but you must first put a seed in the earth. Similarly, a mother has within her womb all the necessary ingredients for creating another body, but the father must first inject the semen, or seed, into the womb; then the child will develop. A dog forms a dog’s body, and a human forms a human body. Why? Because all the required ingredients are there, respectively.

We find a certain quantity of chemicals in my body, a smaller quantity in an ant’s body, and a greater quantity in an elephant’s body. So, if I can create so many more chemicals than an ant, and an elephant can create so many more chemicals than I can, then just think how many more chemicals God can create! This is the basis on which scientists should consider how hydrogen and oxygen combine to form water. Otherwise, they cannot identify the source of the vast quantities of hydrogen and oxygen required to make the oceans. But we can. This hydrogen and oxygen exist in the viräö-rüpa, the universal body of the Lord. Why do the scientists fail to understand this plain truth? Hydrogen and oxygen combine to form the water in the seas. We both accept this fact. But the scientists are surprised to hear that the origin of this huge quantity of hydrogen and oxygen is actually acintya-çakti, or the inconceivable mystic power of the Lord.

The Definition of “Life”

The Definition of “Life”

DR. SINGH. I have noticed a disagreement within the scientific community over the definition of living and nonliving. Some say that if a being can reproduce, it is alive. Therefore, they claim to have created life because certain large DNA molecules14 produced in the laboratory can replicate themselves; that is, they can reproduce other chains of molecules by their own power. Some scientists say these DNA molecules are living, and others say they are not.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Because somebody is saying one thing and somebody is saying another, their knowledge must be imperfect.

DR. SINGH. Can we define living as “containing consciousness” and nonliving as “without consciousness”?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, that is the difference. As Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä, avinäçi tu tad viddhi yena sarvam idaà tatam: “That which is spread all over the body is indestructible.” Anyone can understand what is spread all over a living body; it is consciousness. According to our consciousness at the time of death, we are awarded a particular bodily shape. If you have a dog’s consciousness, you will get a dog’s body, and if you have a godly consciousness, you get a demigod’s body.15 Kåñëa gives everyone the freedom to take whatever body he wants:

yänti deva-vratä devän

pitèn yänti pitå-vratäù

bhütäni yänti bhütejyä

yänti mad-yäjino 'pi mäm

“Those who worship the demigods will take birth among the demigods; those who worship ghosts and spirits will take birth among such beings; those who worship ancestors go to the ancestors; and those who worship Me will live with Me.” (Bg. 9.25)

Darwin Condemned

Darwin Condemned

DR. SINGH. If a human being doesn’t attain liberation, does he have to pass through all 8,400,000 species of life before again coming to the human form?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No, only in the lower forms of life does the living entity progress step by step, according to the laws of nature. In the human form of life, he is endowed with developed consciousness—he has discretion. Therefore if he is advanced in consciousness, he is not going to get the body of a dog or cat; he will get another human body.

präpya puëya-kåtäà lokän

uñitvä çäçvatéù samäù

çucénäà çrématäà gehe

yoga-bhrañöo 'bhijäyate16

The word yoga-bhrañöaù refers to someone practicing yoga who somehow or other could not fully succeed. There’s no question of evolution here; he is again awarded a human body. He does not get a cat’s body or a dog’s body. As with the apartments we were discussing, if you can pay more, you get a nicer apartment. You do not have to come to the lower-class apartment first.

DR. SINGH. What you have been saying completely contradicts Darwin’s theory of evolution.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Darwin is a rascal. What is his theory? We kick out Darwin’s philosophy. The more we kick out Darwin’s philosophy, the more we advance in spiritual consciousness.

DR. SINGH. Many scientists doubt Darwin’s theories. But Darwin’s supporters say that life started from matter and evolved from unicellular organisms to multicellular organisms. They believe that higher species like animals and men did not exist at the beginning of creation.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Darwin and his followers are rascals. If originally there were no higher species, why do they exist now? Also, why do the lower species still exist? For example, at the present moment we see both the intellectual person and the foolish ass. Why do both these entities exist simultaneously? Why hasn’t the ass form evolved upward and disappeared? Why do we never see a monkey giving birth to a human? The Darwinists’ theory that human life began in such and such an era is nonsense. Bhagavad-gétä says that you can directly transmigrate to any species of life you like, according to your efforts. Sometimes I travel to America, sometimes to Australia and sometimes to Africa. The countries already exist. I am simply traveling through them. It is not that because I have come to America, I have created or become America. And there are many countries I have not yet seen. Does that mean they do not exist? The scientists who support Darwin are nonsensical. Bhagavad-gétä clearly says that all the species exist simultaneously, and that you can go to whichever species you like. You can even go up to the kingdom of God, if you so desire. All this is declared in Bhagavad-gétä by Lord Kåñëa.

LCL: The Ninth Morning Walk

The Ninth Morning Walk

Recorded on May 13, 1973,

In Cheviot Hills Park, Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Karandhara däsa adhikaré and other students.

Evolution from Human to Dog

Evolution from Human to Dog

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The so-called scientists are putting their faith in a fraudulent theory. Kåñëa says, ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù: “I am the origin of everything.” Kåñëa is life; Kåñëa is not a dead stone.

DR. SINGH. So matter is caused by life?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, and matter grows upon life; my body grows upon me, the spirit soul. For example, I have put on this overcoat, which is made according to the size of my body. But I would be foolish if I thought, “I am this overcoat.” student. Çréla Prabhupäda, mineralogists have proven that mountains are growing by sedimentary activity. Is this growth due to the presence of the spirit soul?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Çrémad-Bhägavatam describes mountains as the bones of God, and the grass as the hair on His body. So, in this sense, God has the biggest body.

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, what is the difference between the transmigration of souls in animal bodies and the transmigration of human souls?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Animals transmigrate in only one direction—upward—but human beings can transmigrate to either a higher or a lower form of life. The body is awarded according to the living entity’s desire. The lower animals have one kind of desire, but the human being has thousands and millions of desires—animal desires as well as human desires. By nature’s law, the lower species are coming up from animal forms to the higher, human forms. But once you come to the human form, if you don’t cultivate Kåñëa consciousness you may return to the body of a cat or dog.

Nirväëa

Nirväëa

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Therefore I say they are rascals. They have no knowledge, yet they still claim to be scientists. Real science is in the Bhagavad-gétä, where Kåñëa says, yänti deva-vratä devän pitèn yänti pitå-vratäù (Bg. 9.25). This means that whatever one worships in this life will determine the type of body he gets in his next life. But if one worships Kåñëa, he ends the process of transmigration entirely. Yaà präpya na nivartante tad dhäma: “When one goes to that supreme abode of Mine, he never returns [to this material world of birth and death].” (Bg. 8.21) Promotion to the spiritual world (saàsiddhià paramäm) is the ultimate perfection of human life. Read Bhagavad-gétä; everything is there. But the scientists have no idea of this perfection; they do not even believe in the existence of the living entity apart from the gross body.

DR. SINGH. They do not speak of the living entity; they speak only of bodies.

STUDENT. Their conception is something akin to Buddhism. The Buddhists say that the body is like a house. Just as a house is put together with wood, the body is put together with chemicals. And when the body dies, it is just like a house that falls apart. Just as the house becomes simply pieces of wood and then there is no more house, so the body becomes simply chemicals, and there is no more body and no more life.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That state is called nirväëa. And then, with the ingredients, you can build another house or another body. That is Buddhism. The Buddhists do not have any information regarding the soul.

Destiny and Karma

Destiny and Karma

STUDENT. Some scientists argue that there are several souls within each body. They use the earthworm as an example. If you cut it in half, both parts will live. They say this proves that two souls occupied the original worm’s body.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No. It is simply that a new soul has come to occupy the other half of the worm’s body.

DR. SINGH. Must the spirit soul necessarily have a body—either spiritual or material?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The soul already has a spiritual body, which the material body covers. My material body grows upon me—my spiritual body—but my material body is unnatural. The real body is spiritual. I am accepting various bodies that are unnatural to my constitution. My real, constitutional position is to be the servant of Kåñëa. As long as I do not come to that position, I remain a servant of matter and get many material bodies according to the laws of material energy. I get one body and then give it up. I desire something else and again get another body. This process is going on under the strict laws of material nature. People think they completely control their destinies, but they are always under nature’s law of karma:

prakåteù kriyamäëäni

guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù

ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä

kartäham iti manyate

“The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities that are in actuality carried out by nature.” [Bg. 3.27] The source of this bewilderment is that the living entity thinks, “I am this body.”

éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà

håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati

bhrämayan sarva-bhütäni

yanträrüòhäni mäyayä17

In this verse the word yantra, or “machine,” means that in any species of life, we are traveling in bodies that are like machines provided by material nature. Sometimes we are moving to higher species, sometimes to lower species. But if, by the mercy of the spiritual master and Kåñëa, one gets the seed of devotional service and cultivates it, he can become free from the cycle of birth and death. Then his life is successful. Otherwise, he has to travel up and down the different species of life, becoming sometimes a blade of grass, sometimes a lion, and so forth.

Advertising Ignorance as knowledge

Advertising Ignorance as knowledge

STUDENT. So it is our desire to enjoy that causes us to take on these material bodies, and our desire to achieve Kåñëa that brings us to our natural position?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes.

DR. SINGH. But there seems to be a constant struggle with our lower nature. We are constantly fighting our desires for sense gratification, even though we want to serve Kåñëa. Does this continue?

STUDENT. The body is almost like a dictator from within.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. That means you are strongly under the control of material energy, or mäyä.

DR. SINGH. Even though we also desire to serve Kåñëa?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. A thief may know that if he steals he will be arrested and put into jail—he may have even seen others being arrested—yet he still steals. Even though he is aware that he is under the authority of the state, he still acts according to his desires. This is called tamas, or ignorance. Therefore, knowledge is the beginning of spiritual life. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa gives Arjuna knowledge. He teaches, “You are not this body.” This is the beginning of knowledge. But where is the university that teaches this knowledge? Dr. Singh, can you tell me where that university is that teaches this knowledge?

DR. SINGH. There is none.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is the position of education: there is no knowledge. They simply advertise ignorance as knowledge.

DR. SINGH. But if the scientists knew that they were not their bodies, their whole outlook would change.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, we want that.

STUDENT. But they don’t want to admit their failure.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Then that is further foolishness. If you are a fool and you pose yourself as intelligent, that is further foolishness. Then you cannot make progress. And if you remain in ignorance and advertise yourself as a man of knowledge, you are a great cheater. You are cheating yourself and cheating others. People are so mad after the material advancement of civilization that they have become exactly like cats and dogs. For instance, they have set up an immigration department, and as soon as you enter a country these dogs go, “Woof, woof, woof! Why have you come? What is your business?” This is a watchdog’s activity. A first-class gentleman is being searched for a revolver. People cannot be trusted, and now there are so many educated rogues and thieves. So what is the meaning of advancement? Can we say that education means advancement? Is this civilization?

Fighting Ignorance With Arguments and Knowledge

Fighting Ignorance With Arguments and Knowledge

STUDENT. Some people say that one reason for the Vietnam war was that the Communists were atheists. It was a dispute between the theists and the atheists. At least that is one excuse given for the war.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. We are also prepared to kill the atheists. But that killing is by preaching. If I kill your ignorance, it can also be called killing. Killing doesn’t necessarily mean that everyone has to take the sword.

DR. SINGH. A new method of warfare?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No, fighting ignorance with arguments and knowledge has always existed. The bodily conception of life is animal life. The animal does not know about matter and spirit. And one who is under the bodily conception of life is no better than an animal. When an animal “talks,” the intelligent man laughs. Such “talk” is nonsense. The animal is not talking knowledge.

STUDENT. At least the animals live by certain codes. They do not kill unnecessarily, and they only eat when necessary, whereas humans kill unnecessarily and eat unnecessarily. So in one sense humans are lower than animals.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Therefore we must suffer more than animals. Kåñëa consciousness is not a bogus, sentimental religious movement. It is a scientific movement designed to alleviate human suffering.

DR. SINGH. Scientists and other people say that everything in the universe is happening by chance.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. So, are they also writing books on the subject by chance?

KARANDHARA. The books are also written by chance, they say.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. So, what is their credit? By chance, anything can be written.

DR. SINGH. The French scientist Dr. J. Monod got the Nobel Prize in 1965. He says that everything started by chance—that by chance certain chemicals combined and formed the basic molecules.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But where did the chemicals come from?

DR. SINGH. According to him, they were created simply by chance, and when the necessity arose, molecules of the chemicals reoriented themselves.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. If everything was happening by chance, how can there be necessity? How can he speak of chance and necessity in the same breath? It is nonsense. If everything is directed by chance, why do people send their children to school? Why not let them grow up by chance? Suppose I break a law. If I say, “Well, it just happened by chance,” will I be excused?

DR. SINGH. So, is crime caused by ignorance?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. That is the cause: my ignorance.

STUDENT. It would certainly be stupid to say that a beautiful instrument like a violin was made by chance.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. It is most regrettable that such a rascal can get recognition. He is talking foolishness and getting recognition.

LCL: The Tenth Morning Walk

The Tenth Morning Walk

Recorded on May 14, 1973,

In Cheviot Hills Park, Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh and other students.

The Scientists’ Mistake

The Scientists’ Mistake

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The scientists’ mistake is that they are ignorant of the two energies—material and spiritual. They say that everything is material and that everything emanates from matter. The defect in their theories is that they begin from matter instead of spirit. Since matter comes from spirit, in a sense everything is spiritual. Spiritual energy is the source and can exist without the material energy. But the material energy has no existence without the spiritual energy. It is correct to say that darkness begins from light, not that light begins from darkness. Scientists think that consciousness comes from matter. Actually, consciousness always exists, but when it is covered or degraded by ignorance, it is a form of unconsciousness.

So “material” means forgetfulness of Kåñëa, and “spiritual” means full consciousness of Kåñëa. Is this clear? Try to understand: darkness comes from light. When no light is visible, then we are in darkness. Clouds are not to be found in the sun; that would be against the nature of the sun. But by the energy of the sun other things are temporarily created, such as mist, clouds or darkness. These creations are temporary, but the sun remains. Similarly, material nature is temporary, but spiritual nature is permanent. Kåñëa consciousness means getting out of this temporary nature and attaining a permanent, spiritual nature. No one actually wants this temporary nature; no one likes this cloudy atmosphere.

DR. SINGH. Is this cloudy consciousness created from spiritual energy?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes.

DR. SINGH. And matter is also created from the superior energy?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Ahaà sarvasya prabhavo mattaù sarvaà pravartate. Kåñëa says, “I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me.” (Bg. 10.8) Kåñëa is the creator of everything, bad or good. Actually, “bad and good” is a material creation. Kåñëa’s creation is good; God is good. What you think is bad is good for God. Therefore, we cannot understand Kåñëa. He is doing something that in our consideration may be bad, but for Him there is no such thing as good or bad. For example, Kåñëa married sixteen thousand wives. Some people may criticize, “Ah, He is so mad after women.” But they do not see the whole picture. Kåñëa’s power is so great that He expanded Himself into sixteen thousand different husbands.

“Everything Is One” Is Nonsense

“Everything Is One” Is Nonsense

DR. SINGH. You said this mist of material nature is temporary. But why should we bother to disentangle ourselves from something transitory?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Why do you put coverings on your body? You may walk naked. The weather will clear in a few hours. Why do you cover yourself?

DR. SINGH. The danger is now.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Whenever it may be, why do you take this step of covering your body?

DR. SINGH. To avoid discomfort.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Otherwise you would be uncomfortable. Not to bother to dress is the Mäyäväda theory: “Everything will come automatically, so why bother? Everything is one.” That is a nonsensical theory. The Mäyäväda philosophy is that God is one and that every thing and every living being is equal to God.

We have no quarrel with the chemists if they begin from life, but unfortunately they say that everything begins from darkness—dead matter. That is what we object to. We say, “Begin from life,” and they say, “No, begin from matter—darkness.” The reason they are in darkness is simple: if one goes from darkness to light, he thinks that darkness is the beginning. Suppose

you have been in darkness all your life, and now you suddenly come into the light. You will think, “Oh, light has come from darkness.” Actually, darkness occurs when light becomes dim. Darkness does not produce light.

DR. SINGH. Then darkness is dependent on light?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Or in other words, in the light there is no darkness. When the light is dim—then we experience darkness. Similarly, when our spiritual consciousness, or Kåñëa consciousness, is dim, our consciousness is material. In the morning we awaken, and at the end of the day we become tired and go to sleep. When life is somehow or other interrupted, we sleep. We sleep at night, and when we get up in the morning we understand that our wakefulness, or “life,” has not come into existence from the sleepy condition. I was alive even while I slept, and on awakening I am still alive. This should be clearly understood. A baby comes from the womb of his mother. He thinks that his life has begun from the day he comes out of the womb. But that is not a fact. Actually, he is eternal. He constructed his material body within the womb of his mother while he was unconscious, and as soon as his bodily features were sufficiently developed, he came out of the womb and again to consciousness.

DR. SINGH. And he again falls asleep at death.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. That is described in Bhagavad-gétä [8.19]:

bhüta-grämaù sa eväyaà

bhütvä bhütvä praléyate

rätry-ägame 'vaçaù pärtha

prabhavaty ahar-ägame

“Again and again the day comes, and this host of beings is active, and again night falls, O Pärtha, and they are helplessly dissolved.”

We Are Not These Bodies

We Are Not These Bodies

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Do you see this flower? It has come back to consciousness, and soon it will dry up and die. This is material life. But spiritual life means to flower only—no dissolution. That is the difference between matter and spirit. I have achieved this body according to my consciousness in my last life. And I will receive my next body according to my consciousness in this life. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä [8.6]:

yaà yaà väpi smaran bhävaà

tyajaty ante kalevaram

taà tam evaiti kaunteya

sadä tad-bhäva-bhävitaù

“Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits his body, that state he will attain without fail.”

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, if our next body is always achieved by our consciousness in this life, how is it that I cannot remember my previous life?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Do you remember everything you did last year, or even yesterday?

DR. SINGH. No, I don’t.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is your nature: you forget.

DR. SINGH. Some things.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. And somebody forgets more than others.

But we all forget.

DR. SINGH. Is that a principle of material nature?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. It is something like stealing. Somebody is a pickpocket and somebody is a bank robber, but both of them are stealing.

DR. SINGH. When we dream, are we being carried away by the subtle elements?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. You are being carried away by nature. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä [3.27]:

prakåteù kriyamäëäni

guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù

ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä

kartäham iti manyate

“The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities that are in actuality carried out by nature.” We forget our real identity because we are under the grip of material nature. The first lesson in spiritual life is that we are not these bodies, but eternal spirit souls. Once you were a child. Now you are a grown man. Where is your childhood body? That body does not exist, but you still exist because you are eternal. The circumstantial body has changed, but you have not changed. This is the proof of eternality. You remember that you did certain things yesterday and certain things today, but you forget other things. Your body of yesterday is not today’s body. Do you admit it or not? You cannot say that today is the thirteenth of May, 1973. You cannot say that today is yesterday. The thirteenth was yesterday. The day has changed. But you remember yesterday; and that remembrance is evidence of your eternality. The body has changed, but you remember it; therefore you are eternal, although the body is temporary. This proof is very simple. Even a child can understand it. Is it difficult to understand?

Changing Bodies

Changing Bodies

DR. SINGH. People want more proof.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. What more is required? The eternality of the soul is a simple fact. I am an eternal soul. My body is changing, but I am not changing. For example, I am now an old man. Sometimes I think, “Oh, I used to jump and play, but now I cannot jump because my body has changed.” I want to jump, but I cannot do it. That jumping propensity is eternal, but because of my old body I cannot do it.

DR. SINGH. Opponents will say that according to their observation, the nature of consciousness is that it lasts for only one body.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is foolishness. In Bhagavad-gétä [2.13] Kåñëa explains:

dehino 'smin yathä dehe

kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä

tathä dehäntara-präptir

dhéras tatra na muhyati

“As the embodied soul continually passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. The self-realized soul is not bewildered by such a change.” Just as this body is always changing (as I can see in my daily experience), there is a similar change at the time of death.

DR. SINGH. But according to the scientists, we cannot actually observe this last change.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Their eyes are so imperfect that they cannot observe many, many things. Their ignorance does not make the Bhagavad-gétä unscientific. Why don’t the scientists admit the imperfection of their senses? They must first admit the imperfection of their senses. Their seeing power does not determine what is and what is not science. Dogs cannot understand the laws of nature. Does that mean the laws of nature don’t exist?

DR. SINGH. Well, the scientists admit that argument, but they say the way to become perfect is through objective information and experience.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No. That is not the way to become perfect. No one can become perfect through imperfect thinking, and our thinking must be imperfect because our senses and minds are imperfect.

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, another question can be raised. Is it not possible that the soul may accept three, four or five bodies and then die?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. You are accepting millions of bodies. I say that your body of yesterday is not your body of today. So, if you live for one hundred years, how many times have you changed bodies? Just calculate.

DR. SINGH. Thirteen.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Why thirteen?

DR. SINGH. Medical science says that all the bodily cells are replaced every seven years.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No, not every seven years—every second. Every second, the blood corpuscles are changing. Is it not so?

DR. SINGH. Yes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. And as soon as the blood corpuscles change, you change your body.

DR. SINGH. In scientific terminology, can the eternality of the soul be compared to conservation of energy?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. There is no question of the conservation of energy, because energy is always existing.

DR. SINGH. But according to scientific terminology, the law of conservation of energy is that energy cannot be created or destroyed, which means, I think, that it is eternal.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Oh, yes, that we admit. Kåñëa is eternal; therefore all His energies are eternal.

DR. SINGH. Is that why the living entity is also eternal?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. If the sun is eternal, its energies—heat and light—are also eternal.

DR. SINGH. Does it follow from this, then, that life cannot be created or destroyed?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Life is eternal. It is not created or destroyed. It is only temporarily covered. I am eternal, but last night I was covered by sleep, so I think in terms of yesterday and today. This is the condition of the material world.

Everything Is Spiritual

Everything Is Spiritual

DR. SINGH. Is material consciousness the absence of Kåñëa consciousness?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes.

DR. SINGH. And when there is Kåñëa consciousness, where is material nature?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. If you continue in Kåñëa consciousness, you will see that nothing is material. When you offer a flower to Kåñëa, it is not material. Kåñëa will not accept anything material. And this does not mean that the flower is material on the bush, and then it becomes spiritual when you offer it to Kåñëa. No. The flower is “material” only as long as you think that it is made for your enjoyment. But as soon as you see that it is for Kåñëa’s enjoyment, you see it as it really is—spiritual.

DR. SINGH. So the entire world is actually spiritual?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Therefore, we want to engage everything in Kåñëa’s service; that is the spiritual world.

DR. SINGH. Can we also appreciate Kåñëa’s creation in that light? For example, can we think, “This tree is very beautiful because it is Kåñëa’s property”?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. That is Kåñëa consciousness.

DR. SINGH. If someone looks at the Deity of Kåñëa in the temple and thinks that it is only stone or wood, what does that mean?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. He is ignorant of the facts. How can the Deity be material? Stone is also Kåñëa’s energy. Just as electric energy is everywhere but only the electricians know how to utilize it, so Kåñëa is everywhere—even in stone—but only His devotees know how to utilize stone to appreciate Kåñëa. The devotees know that stone cannot exist outside of Kåñëa. Therefore, when the devotees see the Deity, they say, “Here is Kåñëa.” They see the real oneness of Kåñëa and His energy.

Simultaneously One and Different

Simultaneously One and Different

DR. SINGH. Is it true that Kåñëa conscious persons perceive Kåñëa in a plain stone as much as in the Deity carved from stone?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes.

DR. SINGH. Just as much?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Why not? In the Bhagavad-gétä [9.4] Kåñëa says:

mayä tatam idaà sarvaà

jagad avyakta-mürtinä

mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni

na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

This means that Kåñëa’s energy—that is, Kåñëa in His partially manifested form—pervades every atom of the universe. But His fully manifested personal form is present in the Deity shaped according to His directions. This is the philosophy of acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva, the simultaneous oneness and difference of God and His energies. For example, when the sunshine is in your room, that does not mean the sun itself is in your room. The sun and its separated energies, like heat and light, are one in quality, but different in quantity.

DR. SINGH. But still, you say that one can see Kåñëa in ordinary stone?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, why not? We see the stone as Kåñëa’s energy.

DR. SINGH. But can we worship Him within the stone?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. We can worship Him through His energy in the stone. But we cannot worship the stone as Kåñëa. We cannot worship this bench as Kåñëa. But we can worship everything because we see everything as Kåñëa’s energy. This tree is worshipable because both Kåñëa and His energy are worshipable, but this does not mean we worship the tree in the same way as we worship the Deity of Kåñëa in the temple.

In my childhood I was taught by my parents never to waste Kåñëa’s energy. They taught me that if even a small grain of rice was stuck between the floorboards, I should pick it up, touch it to my forehead and eat it to save it from being wasted. I was taught how to see everything in relation to Kåñëa. That is Kåñëa consciousness. We therefore do not like to see anything wasted or misused. We are teaching our disciples how to use everything for Kåñëa and how to understand that everything is Kåñëa. As Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä [6.30]:

yo mäà paçyati sarvatra

sarvaà ca mayi paçyati

tasyähaà na praëaçyämi

sa ca me na praëaçyati

“For one who sees Me everywhere and sees everything in Me, I am never lost, nor is he ever lost to Me.”

LCL: The Eleventh Morning Walk

The Eleventh Morning Walk

Recorded on May 15, 1973,

In Cheviot Hills Park, Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh and other students.

Detecting the Spirit Soul

Detecting the Spirit Soul

DR. SINGH. Scientists find it very hard to see the spirit soul. They say its existence is very doubtful.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. How can they see it? It is too small to see. Who has that seeing power?

DR. SINGH. Still, they want to sense it by some means.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. If you inject someone with just one hundredth of a grain of very venomous poison, he dies immediately. No one can see the poison or how it acts, but it is acting nevertheless. So why don’t the scientists see the soul by its action? In such cases we have to see by the effect. The Vedas say that because of the minute particle called the soul, the whole body is working nicely. If I pinch myself, I immediately feel it because I am conscious throughout the whole of my skin. But as soon as the soul is out of my body, which is the case when my body dies, you can take the same skin and cut and chop it, and nobody will protest. Why is this simple thing so hard to understand? Is this not detecting spirit?

DR. SINGH. We may detect the soul in this way, but what about God?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. First of all let us understand the soul. The soul is a sample God. If you can understand the sample, then you can understand the whole.

Modern Science: Help or Harm?

Modern Science: Help or Harm?

DR. SINGH. Scientists are in the process of trying to create life.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. “Process of”! “Trying to”! That we kick out;

that we do not accept. A beggar is saying, “I am trying to be a millionaire.” We say, “When you become a millionaire, then talk. Now you are a poor beggar; that is all.” The scientists say they are trying, but suppose I ask you, “What are you?” Will you say, “I am trying to be...”? What are you now? That is the question. “We are trying” is not a proper answer, what to speak of a scientific proposition.

DR. SINGH. Well, although they haven’t been able to create life so far, they say that soon they should be able to do so.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Any rascal may say that. If you say, “In the future I shall be able to do something extraordinary,” why should I trust or believe you?

DR. SINGH. Well, the scientists say they have done so much in the past and they will accomplish more in the future.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. In the past there was death, and people are dying now. So what have the scientists done?

DR. SINGH. Helped them.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Scientists have helped to minimize the duration of life! Formerly men lived one hundred years; now they seldom live more than sixty or seventy years. And the scientists have discovered atomic energy; now they can kill millions of men. So they have helped only in dying. They have not helped in living, and still they dare to declare that they will create.

DR. SINGH. But now we have airplanes and—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The scientists cannot stop death, they cannot stop birth, they cannot stop disease, and they cannot stop old age. So what have they done? Formerly people used to become old, and nowadays they are becoming old. Formerly people used to become diseased, and now they are becoming diseased. Now there is more medicine—and more disease. So what have they accomplished? Scientists have not helped improve the order of the world. We are going to challenge all the rascal scientists who say that life has grown out of matter. The fact is that matter has grown from life.

The Illusion Of Progress

The Illusion Of Progress

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. How long can science cheat people? One hundred years, two hundred years? They cannot cheat them for all time.

DR. SINGH. Cheating has been going on since time immemorial, so perhaps they think they can continue forever.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Not since time immemorial! Science has been cheating people for only the past two or three hundred years, not before that.

DR. SINGH. Oh, really?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, for the last two hundred years they have been preaching that life comes from matter—not for thousands of years. And the cheating will be finished in another fifty years.

DR. SINGH. Yes, now there is a so-called anti-intellectual movement. People are rebelling against science and modern progress.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. And what is that science? It is not science! It is ignorance. Ignorance is passing for science, and irreligion is passing for religion. But this cheating cannot go on for long, because some people are becoming intelligent.

DR. SINGH. In Newsweek, one of the largest magazines in the United States, there was an article about the degradation of Christianity. The article included a cartoon picturing the devil causing earthquakes. There was recently a very large earthquake in South America that killed many thousands of people. The cartoon attributed such things to the devil, and right next to him it showed Richard Nixon presenting himself as a follower of Christ but bombing Southeast Asia. In this cartoon, the devil turned to Richard Nixon and said, “It’s hell keeping up with Christians.”

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, people will criticize in that way. People are becoming advanced. How long can they be cheated by so-called science and so-called religion? If Mr. Nixon loves his countrymen, why does he not love his country’s cows? They are also born in the same land, and they have the same right to live. Why are they killed? “Thou shalt not kill.” But the animals are being killed. That is imperfection. Kåñëa embraces both the cows and Rädhäräëé.18 That is perfection. Kåñëa even talks with the birds. One day on the bank of the Yamunä River, He was talking with a bird, because He speaks even in the languages of the birds. An old lady saw this and was struck with wonder: “Oh,

He is talking with a bird!”

DR. SINGH. You mean He was actually talking the way the birds talk?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. One of Kåñëa’s qualities described in the Vedas is that He can speak any language. He is the father of all living beings, and the father can understand the language of his children.

Kåñëa is the supreme enjoyer. Actually, except for those who are Kåñëa conscious, no one can have any real knowledge, nor can anyone enjoy. One simply suffers, but he thinks the suffering is enjoyment. This is called mäyä, or illusion. In America people work hard day and night, and they think, “I am enjoying.” This is mäyä. A conditioned soul cannot enjoy anything; he simply suffers, but he thinks he is enjoying.

Therefore, in Çrémad-Bhägavatam the conditioned soul is likened to the camel. The camel is very fond of eating thorny twigs that cut his tongue. While he is eating them, blood issues from his tongue and mixes with the thorny twigs. They become a little tasty, and he is thinking, “Oh, these twigs are very nice.” That is called mäyä. Mäyä means “that which is not.” Mä means “not,” and yä means “this.” So mäyä means “not this.” That is the explanation of mäyä, or illusion. The scientists are in mäyä because they think they are improving things and becoming happy. But this world, along with everything in it, will eventually be finished because it is mäyä; it is not what we think it is. As Çrémad-Bhägavatam explains, the materialists are thinking they are becoming victorious, but they are actually being defeated.

LCL: The Twelfth Morning Walk

The Twelfth Morning Walk

Recorded on May 17, 1973,

A Misty Morning, in Cheviot Hills Park, Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Karandhara däsa adhikaré, Kåñëakänti däsa adhikaré and other students.

Yogic Weapons

Yogic Weapons

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. You have no power to drive away this mist. Scientists merely explain it with some word jugglery, saying that it contains certain chemicals. [He laughs.] But they have no power to drive it away.

DR. SINGH. They do have an explanation as to how the mist is formed.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That they may have, and I may have that also, but that is not a very great credit. If you really know how it is formed, then you should be able to counteract it.

DR. SINGH. We know how it is formed.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Then discover how to counteract it. Formerly, in Vedic warfare, the atomic brahmästra19 was used. And to counteract it, the opposing army would have to use a weapon that would transform it into water. But where is such a science today?

DR. SINGH. Mist is something like milk. Milk looks white, but actually it is a colloidal suspension of certain protein molecules. Similarly, fog is a colloidal suspension of water.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. So if you could create some type of fire, the mist would be immediately driven away; water can be driven away by fire. But that you cannot do. If you were to explode a bomb, it would generate heat, and all the mist would go away.

KARANDHARA. That might damage the whole city.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Everyone knows that fire can counteract water, but you cannot drive away the mist without killing people or destroying property. But by nature’s way, as soon as the sun rises, the mist is vanquished. The power of the sun is greater than your power. Therefore, you have to accept that inconceivable power exists.

Symptoms of God

Symptoms of God

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Without accepting the principle of inconceivable power, no one can understand God. God is not so cheap that any so-called yogé can become God. Such imitation gods are for rascals and fools. Those who are intelligent will test whether or not such a person has inconceivable power. We accept Kåñëa as God because He has demonstrated His inconceivable power. As a child, Kåñëa lifted a big hill. And Lord Räma, an incarnation of Kåñëa, constructed a bridge without pillars by floating stones on water. So one should not accept God cheaply. Nowadays, some rascal comes along and says, “I am an incarnation of God,” and another rascal accepts him. But Lord Räma and Lord Kåñëa actually demonstrated Their inconceivable power. Sometimes people say the descriptions of Their activities are just stories or myths. But these literatures were composed by Välméki,20 Vyäsadeva and other äcäryas, who are all great and vastly learned sages. Why would these great sages simply waste their time writing mythology? They never said it was mythology. They treated the accounts as actual facts. For instance, in the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Vyäsadeva tells of a forest fire in Våndävana. All of Kåñëa’s cowherd boyfriends became disturbed and looked to Kåñëa for help. He simply swallowed up the whole fire. That is inconceivable mystic power. That is God. Because we are tiny samples of God, or Kåñëa, we also possess inconceivable mystic power within our bodies—but only in very minute quantities.

Scientific Knowledge Comes From Kåñëa

Scientific Knowledge Comes From Kåñëa

KÅÑËAKÄNTI. Thedoctors marvelatthecomplexnature of the human brain.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, but it is not the brain that works the body; it is the spirit soul. Does a computer work by itself? No, a man works it. He pushes the button; then something happens. Otherwise, what is the value of the machine? You can keep the machine for thousands of years, but it will not work until a man comes to push the button. But who is working, the machine or the man? Similarly, the human brain is also a machine, and it is working under the direction of Paramätmä, an expansion of God within everyone’s heart.

Scientists should accept God and His mystic power. If they don’t, they should be considered foolish. On the basis of transcendental knowledge, we are directly challenging many big scientists and philosophers. The other day, you brought that chemist, and I told him, “You are foolish.” But he was not angry. He admitted it, and I defeated all his arguments. Perhaps you remember.

DR. SINGH. Yes. In fact, he acknowledged that perhaps Kåñëa didn’t give him all the procedural steps needed to perform his experiments.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. He is against Kåñëa, so why should Kåñëa give him any facilities? If you are against Kåñëa and you want credit without Kåñëa, you will fail. You must first be submissive, and then Kåñëa will give you all facilities. We dare to face any scientist or philosopher and challenge him. How? On the strength of Kåñëa. I know that when I talk with them, Kåñëa will give me the necessary intelligence to defeat them. Otherwise, from the viewpoint of scientific qualification, they are much more qualified than we. We are laymen before them. But we know Kåñëa, and Kåñëa knows everything. Therefore we can challenge any scientists, just as a small child can challenge a very big man because he knows, “My father is here.” He clutches the hand of his father, who makes sure that nobody can harm him.

DR. SINGH. Is the human form of life spoiled for those who do not try to understand Kåñëa consciousness?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. People who do not try to understand their relationship with God simply die like animals—like cats and dogs. They take birth, eat, sleep, beget children and die. This is the sum total of their human lives. These rascals think, “I am this body.” They have no information of ätmä. Ätmä means the self, or the individual soul. Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä give us knowledge about the ätmä, but people are unaware of this.

People are unaware of the knowledge given to human society in the Vedic literature. For example, the Vedas inform us that cow dung is pure. Here in America especially, people bring their dogs onto the street to pass stool. Of course, dog stool is very impure—germs thrive in it. But people are such rascals that they do not consider this; instead, they distribute dog stool everywhere. But there’s no cow dung to be seen, even though the Vedas say that cow dung is pure. Here is a sign: “Littering Illegal.” But dog stool is allowed. Just see how foolish people are. It is illegal to drop a paper on the grass, but your dog is allowed to pass stool. The government authorities will not allow you to bring even one mango from another country; but they will allow your dog to distribute its stool everywhere, although this stool is full of infectious germs.

The Space Program: A Childish Waste of Time and Money

The Space Program: A Childish Waste of Time and Money

DR. SINGH. When the astronauts returned from the moon to the surface of the earth, the scientists in the space program were very careful. They thought the astronauts might have brought some new germs as yet unknown, so they put the astronauts in quarantine for several days to make sure that—

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. First of all, find out whether they have gone to the moon. I am not so sure. Sixteen years ago, when I wrote Easy Journey to Other Planets, I remarked that the scientists were childish in their attempts to explore outer space and would never be successful. Many years later, when I visited San Francisco, a press reporter asked me, “What is your opinion about the moon expedition?” I told him, “It is simply a waste of time and money, that’s all.”

KÅÑËAKÄNTI. The space program recently had another failure.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is always happening. What was it?

KÅÑËAKÄNTI. They sent up a space vehicle to orbit the earth and act as sort of a space outpost, but it failed. It cost two billion dollars.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Why are they wasting time and money in that way?

KÅÑËAKÄNTI. They were criticized in the newspapers.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They are simply childish fools. What have they gained in the last—how many years? For how many years have they been trying to go to the moon?

DR. SINGH. It has been more than ten years. Russia started in 1957 with their sputnik.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But they were trying for many years before that. So let us say that for twenty-five years they have been trying. They have not gained anything except dust, but still they are trying. How obstinate! The space program will never be successful.

DR. SINGH. They say that in the future they want to go to the sub-surface of Mars.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They are all becoming “big men” with their statements about the future.

DR. SINGH. They say that it will happen in about ten years.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. So what if they say one year? They may say ten years or one year, but we do not accept such propositions. We want to see what they are doing now.

DR. SINGH. They are developing their technology by using small scale models.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They are simply childish. In my childhood I used to watch the tramcars go along the rail. Once I thought, “I shall take a stick and touch it to the wire, and I shall also go along the rails.” The scientists, with all their plans, are just as childish. They spend so much time and money, but what is their purpose? Their effort is hopeless because they do not actually know the purpose of life. The scientists are spending large sums of money, and politicians are financing them, but the result is zero. They are like a doctor who doesn’t understand a particular disease, but who still says to his patient, “All right, first try this pill, and if that doesn’t work, then try this pill.” The doctor will never admit that he doesn’t know the remedy for the disease. The scientists are simply bluffing and cheating. They cannot solve the real problems of life—birth, death, old age and disease—and therefore all their programs are taking place on the utopian platform, which in Sanskrit is called äkäça-puñpa. Äkäça-puñpa means “a flower from the sky.” All their efforts to know the truth by exploring outer space are like trying to pluck a flower from the sky.

To give another example, the scientists act like foolish ducks. In India we may sometimes observe a duck following all day behind a bull. The duck is thinking that the testicles of the bull are a fish. In India this is a common sight. The bull is walking, and all day the duck is walking behind, following that big fish and thinking, “It will drop, and I will eat it.”

LCL: The Thirteenth Morning Walk

The Thirteenth Morning Walk

Recorded on December 2, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Hådayänanda Däsa Goswami. Kåñëakäntidäsa adhikaré and other students.

The Devotee Beyond Desires

The Devotee Beyond Desires

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Now, who knows the difference between the karmé, the jïäné, the yogé and the bhakta?

HÅDAYÄNANDA DÄSA GOSWAMI. The karmé wants to enjoy the gross senses, the jïäné wants to enjoy the subtle mind—to mentally speculate—and the yogé wants to manipulate the universe with mystic powers.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. These are all material powers.

HÅDAYÄNANDA DÄSA GOSWAMI. And the bhakta has no material desires.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. And unless one is actually desireless, he cannot be happy. The karmé, the jïäné and the yogé are all full of desires; therefore they are unhappy. Karmés are the most unhappy, the jïäné is a little less unhappy, and the yogé is still more advanced. But the bhakta, the devotee, is perfectly happy. Some yogés have a mystic power that enables them to snatch pomegranates from trees in another country, thousands of miles away. Others can fly without an airplane. And some yogés can hypnotize anyone. Then they point to someone and say, “This is God,” and their victims believe them. I have actually seen such magical nonsense.

KÅÑËAKÄNTI. Is the pure devotee more merciful than Kåñëa?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. A real Vaiñëava, a real devotee, is even more merciful than Kåñëa. Take Lord Jesus Christ, for example. It is said that Lord Jesus took everyone’s sins upon himself, yet he was crucified. We can see how merciful he was. Today, rascals think, “Let us go on committing sinful activities; Christ has taken a contract to suffer for us.” [There is a long, thoughtful silence.]

The Difference Between Matter and Spirit

The Difference Between Matter and Spirit

DR. SINGH. Scientists say that trees also have consciousness.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, that is true, but a tree’s consciousness and my consciousness are different. My consciousness is more developed. If you pinch my body, I will immediately protest. But if you cut a tree, it will not protest. Actually, everything has consciousness in it; it is simply a question of degree. The more covered consciousness is by matter, the more it is considered material. And the more consciousness is developed, the more it is considered spiritual. This is the difference between matter and spirit.

Spirit souls are everywhere. They are trying to come out of the earth. [Points to the grass.] As soon as there is an opportunity, they want to express their consciousness. Those souls who descend from higher planets to this planet sometimes fall down to the ground in raindrops. Then they become grass and gradually evolve to higher forms of life.

DR. SINGH. Oh, that is terrible.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. These are the workings of subtle energy. What do the scientists know about this? Actually, their knowledge is carried away by mäyä, illusion, and they are thinking, “Oh, I am a very learned scholar.”

Soul Transplants?

Soul Transplants?

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, what about heart transplants? We know that the spirit soul is within the heart. But nowadays doctors can replace an old heart with a new one. What happens to the spirit soul in each heart? Does the person who receives a new heart also get a new personality?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No.

DR. SINGH. Why not?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Suppose I get up from one chair and go sit

in another chair. Does my personality change? I may change my seat, but does that mean I have changed?

DR. SINGH. But the heart is changed, and the heart contains the spirit soul.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The Vedas describe the heart as a sitting place for the soul. So when they transplant hearts, they simply change the soul’s seat. The same soul remains. If they could prove that by changing the heart they have increased the patient’s duration of life, then that would prove they’ve caught the spirit soul. But they cannot increase the duration of life, because people have acquired their bodies by a superior arrangement. You have this body, and you must live within it for a certain period. If you simply change one of the parts of your body, that will not help you prolong your life. That is impossible. The doctors think that by changing the heart they will increase the duration of life, but that is not possible.

DR. SINGH. So a heart transplant is a kind of artificial transmigration of the soul from an old heart to a new one?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, it is something like that. Kåñëa explains in the Bhagavad-gétä [2.13]:

dehino 'smin yathä dehe

kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä

tathä dehäntara-präptir

dhéras tatra na muhyati

“As the embodied soul continually passes, in this body, from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. The self-realized soul is not bewildered by such a change.” Changing hearts is just a change of material bodily organs. The heart is not the real source of life, and therefore changing the heart does not prolong the duration of life.

DR. SINGH. Yes, most heart transplant patients live only a very short time after the operation. But is it ever possible to transplant the soul from one body to another?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Sometimes certain yogés can do that. They can find a better body and transfer themselves into it.

DR. SINGH. When the doctors perform a heart transplant, they take a heart from someone who has just died and exchange it for a weak heart in someone else’s body. Does the soul from the dead heart change places with the soul in the weak living heart?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No. The soul has already left the dead heart. There is no question of bringing in another soul.

DR. SINGH. Let me see if I understand you correctly. When the doctors remove the heart of a man who has just died, the soul has already left his heart. Then, when they transplant his dead heart into the body of the patient, the patient’s soul passes into the transplanted heart.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. The soul is destined to live in a particular body for a certain number of years. You may change whatever part of the body you like, but you cannot change the duration of the life of that body.

DR. SINGH. So the heart is just a machine—an instrument?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. It is the sitting place of the soul.

A Mustard Seed in a Bag of Mustard Seeds

A Mustard Seed in a Bag of Mustard Seeds

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, biologists tell us that there are many species of life that can reproduce without sex. Do the Vedas agree with this?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Oh, yes.

DR. SINGH. So we cannot curtail their reproduction?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No. How could we? There are so many living entities that have come into this material world to enjoy life, and therefore reproduction must continue. This material world is like a jail. You cannot put an end to jails. As soon as one man leaves the jail, another is ready to enter it. This same question was discussed by Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu.21 One of His devotees, Väsudeva Datta, said, “Please take all the living entities of this entire universe and release them from material bondage. And if You think they are too sinful to be rectified, then just give all their sins to me.” But Caitanya Mahäprabhu said, “Suppose I were to take this entire universe and all the living entities with it. This is only one of innumerable universes. It is just like a mustard seed in a huge bag of mustard seeds. If you removed one seed from the bag, what would be the difference?” So reproduction cannot actually be stopped. Living entities are unlimited in number, and therefore it must continue.

DR. SINGH. You have said that this material world is like a correction house to teach one to get out of material entanglement and the cycle of repeated birth and death.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Therefore you must practice Kåñëa consciousness.

LCL: The Fourteenth Morning Walk

The Fourteenth Morning Walk

Recorded on December 3, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Dr. W. H. Wolf-Rottkay and other students.

The Origin of the Interplanetary Gases

The Origin of the Interplanetary Gases

DR. SINGH. The scientists say that at one point the earth was composed of dust particles floating in some gaseous material. Then, in due course, this colloidal suspension condensed and formed the earth.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That may be, but where did the gas come from?

DR. SINGH. They say it just existed!

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä [7.4]:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù

khaà mano buddhir eva ca

ahaìkära itéyaà me

bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

“Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and false ego—all together these eight comprise My separated material energies.” Here Kåñëa explains that väyu (gas) came from Him. And finer than väyu is kham (ether), finer than ether is mind, finer than mind is intelligence, finer than intelligence is false ego, and finer than false ego is the soul. But the scientists do not know this. They understand only gross things. They mention gas, but where does the gas come from?

DR. SINGH. That they cannot answer.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But we can answer. From Çrémad-Bhägavatam we know that gas has come from kham, or ether, ether comes from mind, mind comes from intelligence, intelligence comes from false ego, and false ego comes from the soul.

DR. SINGH. The scientists argue that before Darwin’s biophysical type of evolution could take place, there had to be what they call prebiotic chemistry, or chemical evolution.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. And the term “chemical evolution” means that chemicals have an origin, and that origin is spirit, or life. A lemon produces citric acid, and our bodies produce many chemicals in urine, blood, and bodily secretions. This is proof that life produces chemicals, not that chemicals produce life.

DR. SINGH. Scientists say that once the seed of life is present in the cells, then the living entity automatically develops and functions.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, but who gives the seed? In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa answers this question. Béjaà mäà sarva-bhütänäà viddhi pärtha sanätanam: “O son of Påthä, know that I am the original seed of all existences.” And later [14.4]:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya

mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù

täsäà brahma mahad yonir

ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

“It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father.”

Giving Credit to the primal Creator

Giving Credit to the primal Creator

DR. WOLF-ROTTKAY. But in all humility, Çréla Prabhupäda, suppose the scientists actually succeed in artificially creating a living cell. What would you say?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. What would be their credit? They would only be imitating what already exists in nature. People are very fond of imitations. If a man in a nightclub imitates a dog, people will go and pay money to watch him. But when they see a real dog barking, they don’t pay any attention to it.

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, the idea of chemical evolution came from a Russian biologist in 1920. He demonstrated that before biochemical evolution, the earth’s atmosphere was in a state of reduction. In other words, it was mostly full of hydrogen, with very little oxygen. Then, in due course, the sun’s radiation caused these hydrogen molecules to form into different chemicals.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. This is a side study. First of all, where did the hydrogen come from? The scientists simply study the middle of the process; they do not study the origin. We must know the beginning. There is an airplane. [Indicates an airplane appearing on the horizon.] Would you say the origin of that machine is the sea? A foolish person might say that all of a sudden a light appeared in the sea, and that’s how the airplane was created. But is that a scientific explanation? The scientists’ explanations are similar. They say, “This existed, and then all of a sudden, by chance, that occurred.” This is not science. Science means to explain the original cause.

Perhaps the scientists can create imitations of nature, but why should we give them credit? we should give credit to the original creator, God; that is our philosophy.

DR. SINGH. When a scientist discovers some natural law, he usually names it after himself.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, exactly. The law is already there in nature, but the rascal wants to take credit for it.

Gerontology: Prolonging the Suffering

Gerontology: Prolonging the Suffering

DR. SINGH. They are actually fighting against the laws of nature, but often they take pleasure in the struggle.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That pleasure is childish. Suppose a child builds a sand castle on the beach with great effort. He may take pleasure in it, but that is childish pleasure. That is not a grown man’s pleasure. Materialistic men have created a standard of false happiness. They have created a gorgeous arrangement for a comfortable civilization, but it is all false because they cannot create a situation in which they will be able to enjoy it. At any moment, anyone can be kicked out by death, and all his enjoyment will be finished.

DR. SINGH. That is why they say that God hasn’t given us every thing—because we are not able to live here forever.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But God has given them everything necessary to live peacefully, and everything necessary to understand Him. So why will they not inquire about God? Instead, they do things that help them forget God.

DR. SINGH. Now the scientists have organized a whole department in science called gerontology, in which they study how to prolong life.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Their real aim should be to stop the suffering. Suppose an old man is in great pain, suffering from many diseases, and suddenly the doctors increase his life-span. What is the profit?

DR. SINGH. That is what they do with heart transplants.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. It is nonsense! Let them stop death; that would be an achievement. Let them stop all disease; ah, that would be an achievement. They cannot do these things! Therefore, I say that all their research is simply a struggle for existence. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä [15.7]:

mamaiväàço jéva-loke

jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù

manaù-ñañöhänéndriyäëi

prakåti-sthäni karñati

“The living entities in this conditioned world are My eternal, fragmental parts. Due to conditioned life, they are struggling very hard with the six senses, which include the mind.”

STUDENT. Now there is a shortage of oil.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, we have built a civilization that is dependent on oil. This is against nature’s law, and therefore there is now an oil shortage. By nature’s law, winter is now coming. Scientists cannot stop it and turn it into summer. They wrongly think they are in control of nature. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa informs us that the living being thinks himself to be the doer of activities that are in actuality carried out by nature. The sun is now rising. Can they make it dark? And when it is dark, can they command the sun, “Get up!” They do not realize that if they really want to conquer nature, they should try to conquer birth, death, old age and disease. In Bhagavad-gétä [7.14] Kåñëa says:

daivé hy eñä guëa-mayé

mama mäyä duratyayä

mäm eva ye prapadyante

mäyäm etäà taranti te

“This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it.”

DR. SINGH. So, is it very hard to overcome nature’s laws?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. For the materialists, it is impossible. But if one surrenders to Kåñëa, it becomes easy.

The Real Origin of Species

The Real Origin of Species

DR. SINGH. To explain why there are so many varieties of living entities, the scientists say that at a certain time during evolution, the cells’ genes, which normally reproduce themselves perfectly for the next generation, sometimes make a mistake in copying—something like the printing press that sometimes makes mistakes. In some circumstances these mistakes, or mutations, have stood, and different species of living entities have been formed because of the difference in the genes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But that “mistake” has been continuing since time immemorial, for you will find that all varieties of living entities have always existed. Therefore the “mistake” is eternal. But when a “mistake” is permanent, it is not a mistake; it is intelligence!

DR. SINGH. But scientists say that if there were no mutations, then there would be only one kind of living entity in the whole universe.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No. Every living entity has a different mind, and therefore there are so many different species of life to accommodate the different mentalities. For example, we are walking here, but most people are not coming to join us, because they have different mentalities than we do. Why does this difference exist?

DR. SINGH. Maybe it is a mistake.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. It is not a mistake. It is their desire, and at the time of death everyone will get a body exactly according to his desire. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä [8.6]:

yaà yaà väpi smaran bhävaà

tyajaty ante kalevaram

taà tam evaiti kaunteya

sadä tad-bhäva-bhävitaù

“Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits his body, that state he will attain without fail.” What you are thinking of at the time of death exactly determines your next body. Nature will give you the body; the decision is not in your hands, but in nature’s, and she is working under the direction of God.

DR. SINGH. But science seems to have evidence that different species of life do arise by mistakes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is their mistake! In the laws of nature there are no mistakes. In railway cars there are first-class, second-class and third-class sections. If you purchase a third-class ticket but by mistake go to the first-class section, you will not be allowed to stay there. It is not a mistake that there are sections; that is the arrangement. But it is your mistake that you have gone to the wrong section. So, God is so thorough that He knows all the mistakes that will be made. Therefore, according to the mistakes you commit, you enter a particular body: “Here, come here. The body is ready.” There are 8,400,000 species of life, and nature works, assigning different bodies, with mathematical precision. When the government builds a city, it builds a prison even before the city is completed, because the government knows that there will be many criminals who will have to go to prison. This is not the government’s mistake; it is the mistake of the criminals. Because they become criminals, they have to go there. It is their mistake.

In nature there are no mistakes. Kåñëa says:

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù

süyate sacaräcaram

hetunänena kaunteya

jagad viparivartate

“This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and producing all moving and nonmoving beings.” (Bg. 9.10) Nature works under the supervision of God, Kåñëa, so how can nature make mistakes? But we commit mistakes, we are illusioned, our senses are imperfect, and we cheat. That is the difference between God and man. God does not have imperfect senses; His senses are perfect.

Satisfied Animals

Satisfied Animals

DR. WOLF-ROTTKAY.Because our senses are defective, the technological enlargements of our senses must also be defective, of course.

DR. SINGH. The microscopes with which we detect things must also be defective.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Material existence means defective existence. If you construct something with defective knowledge and imperfect senses, whatever you construct must be defective.

DR. SINGH. Even if scientists devised a perfect microscope, they would still have to look through it with defective eyes.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. That is right. Therefore we conclude that whatever the scientists may say is defective.

DR. SINGH. But they seem quite satisfied.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The ass is also satisfied. The ass is satisfied to carry the load of the washerman. Everyone is satisfied, even the worm in the stool. That is nature’s law.

DR. WOLF-ROTTKAY.It is said that even the pauper is proud of his penny.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. In some parts of India one may sometimes see a dog starving to death. But as soon as it gets a female dog, it is satisfied with having sex. Is that satisfaction? The dog is starving, but still it is satisfied with sex.

LCL: The Fifteenth Morning Walk

The Fifteenth Morning Walk

Recorded on December 7, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Dr. W. H. Wolf-Rottkay and another student.

Getting the Eyes to see God

Getting the Eyes to see God

STUDENT. For the last one hundred fifty years, one of the major problems of Western theologians has been the relationship between reason and faith. They have been seeking to understand faith through reason, but they have been unable to find the relationship between the reasoning abilities and faith. Some of them have faith in God, but their reason tells them there is no God. For instance, they would say that when we offer prasäda to the Lord, it is only faith to think that He accepts it, because we cannot see Him.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They cannot see Him, but I can see Him. I see God, and therefore I offer prasäda to Him. Because they cannot see Him, they must come to me so I can open their eyes. They are blind—suffering from cataracts—so I shall operate, and they will see. That is our program.

STUDENT. Scientists say that their common ground of objectivity is what they can perceive with their senses.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, they can perceive things with their senses, but very imperfectly. They perceive the sand with their senses, but can they see who has made the sand? Here is the sand, and here is the sea; they can be seen by direct perception. But how can one directly perceive the origin of the sand and the sea?

STUDENT. The scientists say that if the sand and the sea were made by God, we would be able to see Him, just as we can see the sand and the sea themselves.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, they can see God, but they must get the eyes to see Him. They are blind. Therefore they must first come to me for treatment. The çästras say that one must go to a guru to be treated so that one can understand God. How can they see God with blind eyes?

STUDENT. But seeing God is supramundane. Scientists only consider mundane vision.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Everything is supramundane. For instance, you may think there is nothing in the clear sky—that it is vacant—but your eyes are deficient. In the sky there are innumerable planets you cannot see because your eyes are limited. Therefore, because it is not in your power to perceive, you have to accept my word: “Yes, there are millions of stars out there.” Is space vacant because you cannot see the stars? No. Only the deficiency of your senses leads you to think so.

STUDENT. The scientists will admit their ignorance of some things, but they say they cannot accept what they cannot see.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. If they’re ignorant, they have to accept knowledge from someone who knows the truth.

STUDENT. But they say, “What if what we are told is wrong?”

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Then that is their misfortune. Because their imperfect senses cannot perceive God, they have to hear it from an authority. That is the process. If they don’t approach the authority—if they approach a cheater—that is their misfortune. But the process is that wherever your senses cannot act, you must approach an authority to learn the facts.

The Frustration of the Atheists

The Frustration of the Atheists

DR. SINGH. The difficulty is that in a group of atheists, you can’t prove the existence of God.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. The atheists are rascals. Let us teach the others—those who are reasonable. Everything has been made by someone: the sand has been made by someone, the water has been made by someone, and the sky has been made by someone. Kåñëa consciousness means learning who that someone is.

DR. SINGH. The scientists will say, “Present that someone to me so I can see Him.”

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. And I answer them, “I am presenting that someone to you, but you have to take the training as well.” You have to qualify your eyes to see that someone. If you are blind, but you do not want to go to the physician, how will you be cured of your blindness and see? You have to be treated; that is the injunction.

STUDENT. That step requires faith.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, but not blind faith—practical faith. If you want to learn anything, you must go to an expert. That is not blind faith; it is practical faith. You cannot learn anything by yourself.

STUDENT. If somebody is actually sincere, will he always meet a bona fide guru?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja. Kåñëa is within you, and as soon as He sees that you are sincere, He will send you to the right person.

STUDENT.And if you are not completely sincere, you will get a cheater for a teacher?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. If you want to be cheated, Kåñëa will send you to a cheater. Kåñëa is superintelligent. If you are a cheater, He will cheat you perfectly. But if you are actually sincere, then He will give you the right guidance. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says, sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöo mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca: “I am seated in everyone’s heart, and from Me come remembrance, knowledge and forgetfulness.” Kåñëa speaks of both remembrance and forgetfulness. If you are a cheater, Kåñëa will give you the intelligence to forget Him forever.

STUDENT. But the atheists are in control. They have the dominance.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. One kick of mäyä and all their dominance is finished in one second. That is the nature of mäyä. The atheists are under control, but due to mäyä, or illusion, they think they’re free.

moghäçä mogha-karmäëo

mogha jïänä vicetasaù

räkñasém äsuréà caiva

prakåtià mohinéàçritäù

“Those who are bewildered are attracted by demoniac and atheistic views. In that deluded condition, their hopes for liberation, their fruitive activities and their culture of knowledge are all defeated.” (Bg. 9.12) Because they are bewildered, all their hopes are frustrated. That is stated here in Bhagavad-gétä, and that is actually happening. So many of their big plans, like this moon project, are frustrated, but they still claim that they can dominate nature.

DR. SINGH. They do not want to come to their senses.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Therefore they are rascals.

Scientists Bravely Going to Hell

Scientists Bravely Going to Hell

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. A sensible man will take a good lesson, but a rascal will never take a good lesson. There is a story of a great poet named Kalidasa, who was a great rascal also. Once, Kälidäsa, was sitting on the branch of a tree and simultaneously cutting it. A gentleman asked him, “Why are you cutting this tree limb? You will fall down.”

Kälidäsa replied, “No, no, I will not fall down.” So he kept cutting the limb, and he fell down. The conclusion is that he was a rascal because he would not take good advice. By their so-called scientific advancement, scientists are going to hell. But they do not listen when they are told; therefore they are rascals. Rascals repeatedly make a plan, see it frustrated, and again make another plan. This plan is also frustrated, so they make another plan. Yet when we try to explain to them that all their materialistic plans will be unsuccessful and useless, they refuse to listen. That is rascaldom. The rascals repeatedly chew the chewed. At home, in the street, at the nightclub, at the theater—wherever he is, sex in its different varieties is his only pleasure.

STUDENT. Çréla Prabhupäda, one could say that that is bravery.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, you can say that, but that bravery is their rascaldom. They are bravely going to hell, that’s all. Once, one man was chasing another man, and the man who was chasing asked, “Why are you fleeing? Are you afraid of me?” The other man replied, “I am not afraid of you. Why should I not run? Why should I stop?”

In the same way, the gross materialist is bravely going to hell. “Why should I stop with my sinful activities?” he says. “I will Bravely face any reaction.”

DR. SINGH. They are crazy.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes, crazy. The Vedas say that once a man becomes crazy, or haunted by ghosts, he speaks all kinds of nonsense. Similarly, anyone under the influence of the material energy is crazy. Therefore he talks only nonsense, that’s all. Though scientists are not expert in science, they are expert in bluffing others and juggling words.

Mystic Television

Mystic Television

DR. SINGH. They now have things they did not have before, like telephones, televisions, airplanes, missiles and many other new discoveries.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. But there are better telephones that they do not know about. In Bhagavad-gétä, Saïjaya demonstrated this when he was sitting with his master, Dhåtaräñöra, and relating all the affairs that were taking place far away on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra. Saïjaya’s vision was actually greater than the telephone. It was mystic television. It was television within the heart, for he was sitting in a room far from the battlefield and still seeing everything that was occurring there. In Bhagavad-gétä, Dhåtaräñöra inquired of Saïjaya, “How are my sons and nephews? What are they doing?” Then Saïjaya described how Duryodhana was going to Droëäcärya, what Droëäcärya was speaking, how Duryodhana was replying, and so on. Even though these activities were too far away to be seen by ordinary eyes, Saïjaya could see and describe them through his mystic power. That is real science.

DR. SINGH. Some scientists say that we have improved on nature by making things like plastic and medicine.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. In Vedic times people ate on silver and golden plates, but now the scientists have improved things with plastic plates. [Laughter.]

DR. SINGH. The plastic has become a great problem because they cannot get rid of it. There is no way to dispose of it. It just continues to pile up.

Here is the proof

Here is the proof

DR. WOLF-ROTTKAY.The materialists would be more sincere if they said, “We don’t want to be taken out of our dream. We want to continue trying to enjoy our senses with all our machines.” But they will not admit that their attempts to enjoy always fail.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is their foolishness. Eventually they have to admit it.

DR. WOLF-ROTTKAY. But they say, “Try, try again.”

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. How can they try? Suppose you cannot see because you are suffering from cataracts. If you try to see—you try, try, try, try, try. Is that the cure for cataracts? No. You will never be cured like that. You must go to a physician, who will perform a surgical operation to restore your eyesight. You cannot see by trying and trying.

DR. WOLF-ROTTKAY. That is just what they do not want to accept—that all their efforts to know the truth by materialistic science have failed.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They are foolish. They will not take good advice. If you give a rascal some good advice, he will become angry, just like a serpent. Suppose you bring a serpent into your home and say, “My dear serpent, please live with me. Every day I will give you nice food—milk and bananas.” The snake will be very pleased, but the result will be that its poison will increase, and one day you will say, “Ah!” [imitates a bitten person.]

DR. WOLF-ROTTKAY. But the scientists will never give up hope.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Their plans are being frustrated at every moment, but still they are hoping.

STUDENT. Çréla Prabhupäda, one librarian wanted me to prove that Bhagavad-gétä was five thousand years old. He wanted to see a copy that was written down five thousand years ago.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Suppose I go into a dark room and say to the person inside, “The sun has risen. Come out!” The person in darkness may say, “Where is the proof that there is light? First prove it to me; then I will come out.” I may plead with him, “Please, please, just come out and see.” But if he does not come out to see, he remains ignorant, waiting for proof. So, if you simply read Bhagavad-gétä you will see everything. Come and see. Here is the proof.

LCL: The Sixteenth Morning Walk

The Sixteenth Morning Walk

Recorded on December 10, 1973,

On the shores of the Pacific Ocean near Los Angeles


Çréla Prabhupäda is accompanied by Dr. Singh, Hådayänanda däsa Goswami and other students.

The Meaning of “Supreme”

The Meaning of “Supreme”

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. What is the meaning of supremacy in this material world? Why do you accept President Nixon as the supreme person within your state?

DR. SINGH. Because he has some power.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. And why is he supreme? Because as the government’s number one servant, he gets the highest salary, has all the best facilities, and his order is final.

DR. SINGH. He has the power to convince others.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. No. You may not agree with him, but because he is supreme, you have to accept his order. That is his position. It does not depend on your acceptance or nonacceptance. That is the meaning of supremacy, is it not? The Vedic literature says that one who has the symptoms of supremacy is fortunate. The supremely fortunate person is God. Lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänam: “He is served by hundreds and thousands of lakñmés, or goddesses of fortune.” (Brahma-saàhitä 5.29) Here on this planet we are begging a little favor from the goddess of fortune. But Kåñëa is always worshiped by many thousands of goddesses of fortune.

DR. SINGH. To conceive of anyone so fortunate is beyond our thinking capacity.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. Therefore Kåñëa is acintya, inconceivable. We cannot estimate how great or fortunate He is! Acintya means “that which we cannot estimate.” We can see only a part of God’s opulence—this material nature—which is only a partial exhibition of God’s potencies. The Supreme Personality has many potencies. He has inferior energies and superior energies. In Bhagavad-gétä [7.4] Kåñëa says:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù

khaà mano buddhir eva ca

ahaìkära itéyaà me

bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

“Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and false ego—all together these eight comprise My separated material energies.” In the next verse of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa describes His superior energy (parä prakåti), which is manifested as the spiritual world. So, if in the inferior, material energy there are so many wonderful things, just imagine how much more important and how much more wonderful things are in the spiritual world. This is the meaning of superior.

The Mysteries of Yogic Power

The Mysteries of Yogic Power

HÅDAYÄNANDA DÄSA GOSWAMI. And are all the varieties of life we see on earth contained in the spiritual world?

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Yes. And, moreover, if in this inferior energy there are so many wonderful varieties of life, just think how wonderful are the superior varieties of life in the spiritual world. Even in this material universe, the inhabitants of some planets are far superior to those on other planets. For example, people on earth practice mystic yoga for achieving wonderful powers, but people on the planet called Siddhaloka have these great yogic powers naturally. On earth it is natural that a bird can fly; but we cannot, except with costly machines. However, on such planets as Siddhaloka, the residents can fly even from one planet to another without machines. They can go to other planets simply at will. Even on earth there are some yogés who can take their bath early in the morning in four places at once—Jagannätha Puré, Rämeçvara, Hardwar and Dvärakä.22 One yogé friend used to visit my father in Calcutta. The yogé told him that when he (the yogé) would simply sit down and touch his guru, he would travel from Calcutta to Dvärakä in two minutes. That is yogic power. So what are today’s airplanes? Durvasa Muni traveled all over the universe and up to Vaikuëöha23 within one year. According to modern calculations, certain planets in this universe are more than forty thousand light-years24 distant from the earth. This means it would take forty thousand years to reach these planets if you traveled at the speed of light. Even if they had the means, how could the astronauts live for forty thousand years? So, why are they so proud?

DR. SINGH. The scientists have a theory that they can produce a machine that will travel at the speed of light.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. That is rascaldom. They say that, but they will never be able to do it.

Vedic Cosmology

Vedic Cosmology

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. There are many invisible planets and stars. For example, when the Rähu planet passes before the sun and moon, there is an eclipse. But the scientists describe an eclipse differently. Actually, the Rähu planet causes an eclipse. There are many questionable points regarding the modern scientists’ theory of the eclipse. Their explanation is incorrect according to Vedic information.

DR. SINGH. But the scientists say that they can prove their theories.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They say that science proves everything. But that is nonsense. The scientist has proved everything except what he is. That he does not know. And why does he die? That also he does not know. That is the extent of his knowledge.

DR. SINGH. They can make a model of the universe. They can make a model of the planets and the moon.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. If they can make things, why don’t they make an imitation sun to save electricity? These rascals say everything, but they cannot do anything. That is their position. If they can make a model of the universe, let them make a big model of the sun. Then in the dark night we will not have to spend so much money on electricity. But they cannot do it. Yet they speak big, big words, simply to take money from the taxpayers. They say they know the composition of the moon and the composition of the sun, so why can’t they make them? Why can’t they create an artificial sun so that the people of Iceland and Greenland can be saved from so much cold?

God Is Never Zero

God Is Never Zero

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu once gave the example of the jewel called cintämaëi, which produces many other jewels while remaining as it is.

oà pürëam adaù pürëam idaà

pürëät pürëam udacyate

pürëasya pürëam ädäya

pürëam evävaçiñyate

[Sré Éçopaniñad Invocation]

The meaning of this verse is that although everything emanates from the Personality of Godhead, He never diminishes. Here on earth the petrol is running out, and this is becoming a terrible problem, but the sun is still shining and will continue to shine for an untold number of years. And Kåñëa can create millions of suns; in fact, He has already done so. But He is still fully potent. He has lost nothing. That is God, and that is the supreme energy of God, acintya-çakti.

We have some money to spend, and the next day our account becomes zero. Rascals say that ultimate truth is zero, çünyaväda. They do not know that God is never zero—that He is always positive. So we must have a clear idea of God. Theologians should take these ideas from Vedic descriptions and not be misled by fools and rascals. God and His full energies are explained in the Vedic literatures. Our energy is lost, but God’s is not. That is the difference between God and us. I cannot walk swiftly or do so many other things that a young man can do, because I have lost my youthful energy. But God is always youthful. Advaitam acyutam anädim ananta-rüpam ädyaà puräëa-puruñaà nava-yauvanaà ca: “Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is absolute, infallible and beginningless. Expanded into unlimited forms, He is the original person, the oldest, and always appearing as a fresh youth.” (Brahma-saàhitä 5.33) Kåñëa also says in Bhagavad-gétä, éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati: “The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone’s heart.” He is also within every atom. But still He is one. That is God. And He is advaita, without duality. Not that He is living within your heart and a different personality is living within my heart. No, they are one. God is everywhere by His all-pervasive features, and He is also localized; yet He is still one.

The Absolute Nature of Kåñëa’s Love

The Absolute Nature of Kåñëa’s Love

DR. SINGH. In some Western theological literature, Çréla Prabhupäda, they say that God is love.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. God is everything. Why do they say He is this or that? Anything is God because He is absolute. His love and His enmity are the same. In the material world, we distinguish between love and animosity. But God’s animosity and God’s love are the same thing. Therefore, He is called acintya, or inconceivable. God’s love for the gopés25 and God’s enmity for Kaàsa26 achieved the same result. Both Kaàsa and the gopés went to the spiritual world. Also, Pütanä27 came to poison Kåñëa, and Mother Yaçodä was always anxious to save Kåñëa, the naughty child, lest He be harmed. So Mother Yaçodä and Pütanä are opposite, but they both achieved the same results. Kåñëa thought, “I have sucked Pütanä’s breast, so now she is My mother. She must reach the same destination as Yaçodä.” This is the absolute nature of Kåñëa’s enmity and Kåñëa’s love.

vadanti tat tattva-vidas

tattvaà yaj jïänam advayam

brahmeti paramätmeti

bhagavän iti çabdyate

“Learned transcendentalists who know the Absolute Truth call this nondual substance Brahman, Paramätmä or Bhagavän.” [Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.2.11] God has His impersonal, all-pervasive feature (known as Brahman) and His localized Paramätmä feature. At the same time He is Bhagavän, which is His original, personal, transcendental form. The three are different but the same. This is the nature of God, acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva—simultaneously one and different. One who has reached the personal conception of Bhagavän has automatically reached Brahman and Paramätmä. They are all Kåñëa, but there is a difference between them. They are simultaneously one and different.

Accepting Knowledge From a Learned Person

Accepting Knowledge From a Learned Person

DR. SINGH. Çréla Prabhupäda, many people have difficulty accepting God.

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA. They are diseased, but they do not want to be treated. If they do not agree to be treated, that is their fault. One who is not Kåñëa conscious—God conscious—is a madman. Under the power of the illusory energy—the inferior, material energy—he talks only nonsense, just like someone haunted by a ghost. You must approach a person who is learned. You must find such a person, a guru, and surrender to him. Then question him, and whatever answers you get from him you must accept.

That is the process for understanding God. You must first find the guru; then you must satisfy him by service and by surrendering unto him. The guru will explain everything. Kåñëa explains in Bhagavad-gétä [4.34]:

tad viddhi praëipätena

paripraçnena sevayä

upadekñyanti te jïänaà

jïäninas tattva-darçinaù

“Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth.”

LCL: His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda appeared in this world in 1896 in Calcutta, India. He first met his spiritual master, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé, in Calcutta in 1922. Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, a prominent religious scholar and the founder of sixty-four Gauòéya Maöhas (Vedic institutes), liked this educated young man and convinced him to dedicate his life to teaching Vedic knowledge. Çréla Prabhupäda became his student, and eleven years later (1933) at Allahabad he became his formally initiated disciple.

At their first meeting, in 1922, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura requested Çréla Prabhupäda to broadcast Vedic knowledge through the English language. In the years that followed, Çréla Prabhupäda wrote a commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä, assisted the Gauòéya Maöha in its work and, in 1944, without assistance, started an English fortnightly magazine, edited it, typed the manuscripts and checked the galley proofs. He even distributed the individual copies and struggled to maintain the publication. Once begun, the magazine never stopped; it is now being continued by his disciples in the West and is published in over twenty languages.

Recognizing Çréla Prabhupäda’s philosophical learning and devotion, the Gauòéya Vaiñëava Society honored him in 1947 with the title “Bhaktivedanta.” In 1950, at the age of fifty-four, Çréla Prabhupäda retired from married life, adopting the vänaprastha (retired) order to devote more time to his studies and writing. Çréla Prabhupäda traveled to the holy city of Våndävana, where he lived in very humble circumstances in the historic medieval temple of Rädhä-Dämodara. There he engaged for several years in deep study and writing. He accepted the renounced order of life (sannyäsa) in 1959. At Rädhä-Dämodara, Çréla Prabhupäda began work on his life’s masterpiece: a multivolume translation of and commentary on the eighteen-thousand-verse Çrémad-Bhägavatam (Bhägavata Puräëa). He also wrote Easy Journey to Other Planets.

After publishing three volumes of the Bhägavatam, Çréla Prabhupäda came to the United States, in 1965, to fulfill the mission of his spiritual master. Subsequently, His Divine Grace wrote more than sixty volumes of authoritative translations, commentaries and summary studies of the philosophical and religious classics of India.

In 1965, when he first arrived by freighter in New York City, Çréla Prabhupäda was practically penniless. It was after almost a year of great difficulty that he established the International Society for Krishna Consciousness in July of 1966. Before his passing away on November 14, 1977, he guided the Society and saw it grow to a worldwide confederation of more than one hundred äçramas, schools, temples, institutes and farm communities.

In 1968, Çréla Prabhupäda created New Vrindaban, an experimental Vedic community in the hills of West Virginia. Inspired by the success of New Vrindaban, now a thriving farm community of more than one thousand acres, his students have since founded several similar communities in the United States and abroad.

In 1972, His Divine Grace introduced the Vedic system of primary and secondary education in the West by founding the Gurukula school in Dallas, Texas. Since then, under his supervision, his disciples have established children’s schools throughout the United States and the rest of the world. As of 1978, there are ten Gurukula schools worldwide, with the principal educational center now located in Våndävana, India.

Çréla Prabhupäda also inspired the construction of several large international cultural centers in India. The center at Çrédhäma Mäyäpur in West Bengal is the site for a planned spiritual city, an ambitious project for which construction will extend over the next decade. In Våndävana, India, is the magnificent Kåñëa-Balaräma Temple and International Guesthouse. There is also a major cultural and educational center in Bombay. Other centers are planned in a dozen other important locations on the Indian subcontinent.

Çréla Prabhupäda’s most significant contribution, however, is his books. Highly respected by the academic community for their authoritativeness, depth and clarity, they are used as standard text-books in numerous college courses. His writings have been translated into over thirty languages. The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, established in 1972 exclusively to publish the works of His Divine Grace, has thus become the world’s largest publisher of books in the field of Indian religion and philosophy.

In just twelve years, in spite of his advanced age, Çréla Prabhupäda circled the globe fourteen times on lecture tours that took him to six continents. In spite of such a vigorous schedule, Çréla Prabhupäda continued to write prolifically. His writings constitute a veritable library of Vedic philosophy, religion, literature and culture.

LCL: The Challenge

The Challenge

(note: some exalted titles like Çréla have been removed in the following and 'strikeouts' have been used in outdated titles like Svämé, read Çréla Prabhupäda's comments on this exchange here)


Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor is president of the Sri Lanka branch of the Rationalist Association, an organization especially dedicated to disproving the existence of God and the soul. On August 14, 1977 the Colombo (Sri Lanka) Sunday Times published an article by Dr. Kovoor entitled “Is There Life After Death?” In this article, Dr. Kovoor maintained that life is merely a complex chemical activity and that the soul cannot survive death, since there is actually no such thing as the soul. This article led to a heated debate, both in the Sunday Times and in correspondence, between Dr. Kovoor and members of the Sri Lanka branch of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. The Sunday Times articles and a portion of the correspondence are reproduced here.


Sunday Times
August 21, 1977

It’s Beyond Kovoor’s Power of Observation

It’s Beyond Kovoor’s Power of Observation

[by Haàsadüta Svämé and Mahäkänta]


Although Dr. Kovoor and men of his stamp stand proudly on their platform of knowledge, it should be pointed out for the benefit of members of the public not expert in sophistry that men like Dr. Kovoor, who pose as the guardians of logic, reason and the advancement of science, are sailing on a sinking ship when they meddle in matters that lie beyond the purview of their limited senses. This particularly applies to the question of life after death.

The very first line of Dr. Kovoor’s article is, “I do not hold the view that my life is located in a particular spot in my body.” This statement, as well as a later one—“I do not believe that I have a soul or spirit to survive my death”—betrays the flimsy platform upon which he has chosen to make his stand. Throughout the article Dr. Kovoor gives his views, beliefs and opinions regarding a subject completely beyond his power of observation, and he tries to pass these imaginative speculations off as infallible scientific truths.

With all due respect to Dr. Kovoor, I beg to point out that the process of direct sensory perception, on the strength of which he has made so many statements regarding life after death, is completely limited and imperfect.

Consider, for example, the eyes. They function only under certain conditions: if there is no light, I cannot even see my hand in front of my face. We cannot see the nearest object to the eye—the eyelid—nor can we see that which is farthest away, the outer limits of the universe. Indeed, the eyes are imperfect. Similarly, the senses of touch, taste and smell are limited, and the mind, too, is imperfect. Therefore any conclusions based on imperfect sensory perception must necessarily be imperfect.

Research, experimentation and speculation conducted on the basis of imperfect sensory perception are meaningless when applied to matters that do not come within their purview. Attempting to apply sensory perception to such matters would be like a child’s trying to find who his father is by asking every man in the world—a preposterous idea, to say the least. To understand the identity of one’s father, one must accept the authority of one’s mother—there is no other way. Since no one is able to see his father at the time of conception, one must accept the version of one’s mother. Any sane man must accept this.

Regarding souls and rebirth, Dr. Kovoor writes, “I have not any valid reason or evidence to believe it.” This statement only goes to show that the process of direct sensory perception is limited and imperfect and that it therefore yields no result when applied to matters beyond its jurisdiction. Rather than foolishly declaring, “I do not believe that I have a soul or spirit to survive my death,” Dr. Kovoor would be much safer and more faithful to his professional ethic if he were simply to admit his inability or incompetence to deal with the subject matter in question. There is the soul, there is rebirth of the soul, and there is a Supreme Soul—God. However, we should point out that because the soul is categorically different from matter, the techniques of material science must fail when applied to understanding the soul’s existence and nature.

This does not mean, however, that the subject is open to the random speculation and opinion-making so fashionable today. Just as we have a material science to deal with material phenomena, so also we have a spiritual scientific process which allows its practitioner to penetrate the walls of gross and subtle matter and directly experience the truths of the soul, its rebirth, and its relationship with God, the Supreme Soul.

A true scientist would never prematurely declare, “I do not believe that I have a soul or spirit to survive my death.” Rather, he would enthusiastically embrace a standard technique accepted by respected and recognized men of spiritual science. Such a scientist and sincere seeker of truth would then, in the interests of science, submit himself to that process and make himself the object of experimentation. Only after he had perfectly applied all the practices and techniques to himself, under the guidance of an authorized professor of spiritual science, would he dare make judgmental remarks about the subject in question. Theory, observation and experimentation are the true methods of science, and they apply equally to spiritual science.

Life is not generated from a combination of chemicals, as some scientists would have us believe. Rather, it is life which generates matter. A living man and a living woman combined in sexual intercourse are the cause for generating a living child. A dead man and a dead woman have no power to generate living offspring. A living tree has the power to generate fruit; a dead tree, however, has no such power. The difference between life and death is the soul, which is described in Bhagavad-gétä as superior energy (para prakrti). It is this superior energy which manifests all phenomena within our experience.

If life is a display of chemical combinations only, as some scientists suggest, why can’t science inject a life-giving chemical into a dead body and make a man live forever? If we give a scientist the chemical ingredients of the material body, why can’t he combine the chemicals and bring them to life?

When confronted with these questions, materialistic scientists will answer, “We are trying. We will do it in the future.” But this is not science. This is a bluff.

These scientists proudly declare, “There is no soul. There is no God. Everything has come about by chance.” But when asked to do something substantial to back up their claim, they can offer us only a postdated check: “We are trying. We shall do it in the future.” Dr. Kovoor, being a typical materialistic scientist, resorts to this same bluff when he says, “The time will not be far off when man will be using his advanced knowledge in genetics to improve the quality of his own species.”

Here is my challenge to Dr. Kovoor. Let him inject the appropriate chemicals into a dead body to bring it back to life. Or let him inject the appropriate chemicals into himself to check his own death and restore his old and worn-out body to its youthful luster and beauty.

If he finds this task too difficult, perhaps he could just produce a simple form of life, such as a mosquito or a bedbug. Better still, let him recombine the chemicals of the praying mantis he decapitated (as described in his article) and bring it back to life. Or is the science of Dr. Kovoor only a one-way road to the destruction of life?

It may be that science is not yet ready with a one-step process by which to produce life as a finished product. If this is so, let Dr. Kovoor merely make a plastic egg, inject it with yellow and white chemicals, incubate his artificial egg and thereby produce even one chicken that could go on laying eggs and producing more and more chickens.

Even this task may be a little too difficult for Dr. Kovoor. Perhaps, then, he could simply produce a drop of milk or a grain of rice by chemical combination. Then we could start taking him seriously.

Of course, everyone knows that these are impossible tasks for even the most powerful so-called scientist. Dr. Kovoor, in his next exposition, will undoubtedly give the reader a long-winded barrage of words to cover up his bluff. The sum and substance of it will be “We will do it in the future. We are trying.” In any language, this is merely a bluff.

Haàsadüta Svämé
Mahakanta däsa

International Society for Krishna Consciousness


Sunday Times
August 28, 1977

It’s Not Beyond Kovoor’s Power of Observation

It’s Not Beyond Kovoor’s Power of Observation

[by Dr. Abraham Kovoor]


In the article titled “It’s Beyond Kovoor’s Power of Observation,” in the Sunday Times of August 21, Messrs. Haàsadüta Svämé and Mahakanta däsa of the “Hare Krishna” cult betray their appalling ignorance of modern branches of biological science such as biochemistry, molecular biology, neurobiology, eugenics, genetic engineering, extra-uterine insemination, parthenogenesis, and so on.

It is clear from what they have written that they are equating life with mind and the nonexisting spirit or soul. They do not seem to know that while all organisms have life, only those animals which possess nervous systems have mind, and that mental faculties in animals vary in direct proportion to the development of their nervous systems. Despite the beliefs of millions of religionists for thousands of years, there is absolutely no biological evidence for the existence of souls in organisms. Messrs. Däsa and Svämé say that according to the “professors of spiritual science,” there is the soul, there is rebirth of the soul, and there is the Supreme Soul—God.

I should like to know on what objective evidence these so called professors make this fantastic statement. According to the two writers, life is prior to matter. They say, “Life is not generated from a combination of chemicals, as some scientists would have us believe. Rather, it is life that generates matter.”

The prime source of life on the planet earth is the sun. Solar energy is fixed in green plants when sunlight is converted into chemical energy by the reaction sequence known as photosynthesis. Organisms other than plants obtain their energy by eating green plants or some of the eaters of green plants. These food substances serve as fuel for supplying vital energy to organisms. The energy in the food is liberated as vital energy by slow oxidation during respiration.

Däsa and Svämé say that scientists, with their imperfect sensory powers, are incapable of understanding the reality of things as “spiritual scientists” do. Are the sensory powers of these pseudo scientists more efficient than those of real scientists? Or do the so called spiritual scientists possess any form of perception other than sensory perception?

Knowledge and enlightenment cannot be had through meditation, which is only a form of self-hypnosis.

Däsa and Svämé ask whether scientists can make a chicken come out of a plastic egg.

I do not know whether they are aware that scientists have made over ten elements, such as fermium, plutonium and einsteinium, which God could not create because he did not know the technology involved in making them. Are these two men aware of the success of the Sri Lankan scientist Dr. Cyril Ponnamperuma and the Indian scientist Dr. Bal Gobind Khorana, the Nobel Prize winner, in synthesizing amino acids, the building blocks of living protoplasm, from inert substances, simulating conditions that prevailed in the primitive atmosphere of the earth? Do they know that human egg and sperm cells could be fertilized in test tubes, and the fetus developed in an artificial womb or in the womb of a hired woman?

Among animals that have evolved on this planet, man is the only animal that has progressed in all his activities. This he has achieved through his knowledge and science. While all organisms continue to live even today as their forebears did millions of years ago, man alone has progressed from the caveman state to the present spaceman state by using science and technology, and not by the help of any God or knowledge obtained from any scripture!

Advancements in medical science and social welfare services are helping more and more misfits survive to procreate more and more misfits as future citizens. While the short-term goal is achieved, the long-term goal is jeopardized. Future governments are not going to allow the misfits to procreate misfit children on the ground that “life originates from the Supreme Soul.”

It is the unique ability of man to engage in creative thinking that has made him succeed in his fight against the laws of nature. The highly developed forebrain and the deeply convoluted cortex have helped him to think creatively. Scientists, as a general rule, are objective thinkers, because they base their thoughts on empirical knowledge. Mystics and visionaries, the so-called spiritual scientists of Däsa and Svämé, on the other hand, build up their thoughts on their subjective perceptions. Books on chemistry, physics, mathematics, geography, history, geology, anthropology, paleontology, engineering, medical science, astronomy, etc., are the products of objective thinkers. On the other hand, books like Arabian Nights, Gulliver’s Travels, fairy stories, Mahabharata, Rämäyaëa, the Bible, the Koran, Pilgrim’s Progress, Jataka stories, astrology, palmistry, numerology, theology, demonology, etc., are the products of subjective thinkers. While the former are factual, the latter are fictitious.

Some of the marvelous achievements of mankind in recent years have been the liberation of atomic energy, space flight, landing on the moon, organ transplantation, satellite communication, etc. All these were achieved through science. Mentally deranged intellectuals are capable of expatiating on their hallucinations and often become founders and preachers of diverse types of religious cults.

Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor


Sunday Times

September 4, 1977

The Challenge Still Stands

The Challenge Still Stands

[by Haàsadüta]


First of all, it should be noted that Dr. Kovoor has done exactly what I predicted in my last article he would do—namely, he has swamped the reader with a deluge of word jugglery in order to avoid the main issue, which is this: if life is generated by chance biochemical combinations, as some scientists claim, can the scientist Kovoor, given the proper chemicals, make the chemicals come to life?

Instead of answering this point, he has cleverly written, “Scientists have created over ten elements, such as fermium, plutonium and einsteinium.”

But elements are a far cry from living beings. Dr. Kovoor says that Dr. Cyril Ponnamperuma and Dr. Bal Gobind Khorana, the Nobel Prize winner, have synthesized the building blocks of living protoplasm. If this is a fact, why hasn’t Dr. Kovoor met the challenge by creating life with these building blocks? My challenge still stands.

As for incubating a baby in the test tube, this can be done only if you take the sperm and ovum of a living man and woman. In other words, the seed of life required to produce the baby in the, test tube cannot be created by so-called scientists. What is their credit if they produce a baby in a test tube? God is already producing millions of babies daily in nature’s test tube, the womb. On the other hand, scientists are killing thousands of babies in the womb by abortion and calling it “scientific advancement.”

Dr. Kovoor’s statement that scientists are “objective thinkers, because they base their thoughts on empirical knowledge” only goes to emphasize our point that the soul lies beyond the jurisdiction of the limited senses. Therefore, a completely different process of approach has to be adopted. The definition of empirical is “that which is based on observation and experiment.” Observation and experiment are conducted with limited senses, and therefore the conclusions thus derived are naturally limited and imperfect. Thus, the soul and the existence of God are in fact quite beyond Dr. Kovoor’s power of observation. Why should he be so obstinate? This is a commonsense point that anyone can understand.

Dr. Kovoor says, “It is the unique ability of man to engage in creative thinking that has made him succeed in his fight against the laws of nature.” This is a preposterous claim that only a fool would make. Nature forces everyone to undergo old age, disease, and finally death. Even the world’s most powerful conquerors are helplessly dragged off the stage of life by nature in the shape of all devouring death. Will Dr. Kovoor be the first living being in history who will not die? That remains to be seen.

Finally, Dr. Kovoor says, “Some of the marvelous achievements of mankind in recent years have been the liberation of atomic energy, space flight, landing on the moon,” etc. Everyone knows that the first thing scientists did after discovering atomic energy was to manufacture the atomic bomb and promptly drop it on Japan, thus annihilating tens of thousands of innocent victims in a flash. Marvelous, indeed.

At the expense of untold billions of dollars and years of research and hard labor, scientists have supposedly gone to the moon. Of course, all they have “brought back” is a few blurry photos, a handful of rocks and the revelation that the moon is barren. And now they want more money to go to Mars. What is so marvelous about this? It is complete lunacy. On our own planet earth, millions of people are without food, shelter and basic education. Scientists would be more credible if, instead of spending billions of dollars to bring rocks from the moon, they would spend the tax-payer’s hard-earned money to improve his own lot on earth. Rocks are rocks, whether from China, from the moon or from Mars. Or is it that science can turn the rocks into bread and cheese by applying some chemicals?

Now, to get to the main point, Dr. Kovoor asks on what objective evidence we have made the fantastic statements that life and matter both come from life, that there is a soul, that there is rebirth of the soul and that there is a Supreme Soul, or God. It is said,

“Fight fire with fire.” Therefore, I may simply refer Dr. Kovoor to the authoritative, rational and thoroughly scientific findings of three researchers, all with doctorates, who are members of the Bhaktivedanta Institute. After examining the evidence they have presented,1 one who is truly a rationalist should agree with their conclusion that life never comes from matter, but only from life.

Haàsadüta Svämé

ISKCON Sri Lanka


After the Sunday Times had printed this exchange of articles, the Hare Kåñëa movement publicly challenged Dr. Kovoor to prove his statement that life originates from chance biochemical combinations. ISKCON publicly offered Dr. Kovoor five hundred thousand rupees (sixty thousand dollars) if he could create any form of life—a mouse, a cat, a mosquito or any other plainly visible creature—from inert chemicals. The Sunday Times ran this story:


“The high priest of Sri Lanka rationalists, Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor, who has been challenging people for decades to prove the existence of God, the soul and rebirth, is now on the receiving end.

“ISKCON (The International Society for Krishna Consciousness) has now challenged Dr. Kovoor to prove his contention that life originated from matter.

“We, the members of the Hare Kåñëa movement, are openly challenging him to produce any form of life, even a mosquito, by mixing chemicals together. If he cannot substantiate his theory, he should remain silent forever,” say the ISKCON members.

“They will be waiting for Dr. Kovoor at the Ramakrishna Mission Hall on September 20, at 6:30 P.M. Admission will be free to the public.”


While the issues were thus drawn in the press, Haàsadüta Svämé and Dr. Kovoor crossed swords on their own in a continuing exchange of letters. Part of that exchange is reproduced here.

Haàsadüta Svämé
ISKCON
Sri Lanka
September 6, 1977

September 6, 1977

September 6, 1977


Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor

Sri Lanka Rationalist Association


Dear Dr. Kovoor,

I have further deliberated and have decided to write you a few more words on the existence of God, the soul and the rebirth of the soul. I trust they may be of interest to you.

The greatest disease in the minds of the scientists is that they do not believe that something is a fact unless it is proved by scientific experiments. When a scientist makes a statement and he supports that statement with scientific experiments, everyone is completely convinced, and no questions are asked. When we talk about the spirit soul to these scientists, their usual response is, “How can one detect the presence of the soul?” Because they have been conditioned to working with machines, they wonder whether the soul can be detected by scientific experiments. However, scientists have to agree that even in their own scientific realm there are many facts that cannot be proved by experiments. The fact is that the soul is there, but in order to understand its existence we have to accept knowledge from the right person—Çré Kåñëa (God) or His representative in disciplic succession, the spiritual master.

Everyone in the scientific community knows that mathematicians work with an imaginary number called “i,” which is the square root of minus one (-l=i) . This number does not figure among the natural numbers (1, 2, 3, etc. ). However, important branches of mathematics—for example, the theory of analytical

functions—are based on this imaginary unit. Without the help of this branch of mathematics, various complex theories and problems cannot be solved. Thus the existence of this number cannot be denied; yet there is no experiment to prove it. In a similar manner, scientists in the field of statistical mechanics also utilize various conceptual models—ensembles, for example—to explain their theories and arguments. These are all beyond the realm of experimental science. If scientists are willing to accept these imaginary and conceptual models, what is the difficulty in accepting the perfect knowledge given by Lord Kåñëa, the supreme scientist?

Another scientific theory that is beyond the limit of experimental science is Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. The statement of this principle is that it is impossible to simultaneously determine the position and momentum of any object. In mathematical language, it is stated that the product of the uncertainties in the measured values of the position and momentum (product of mass and velocity) cannot be smaller than Planck’s constant. No existing experimental technique can prove this principle. However, scientists all over the world accept this statement as a fact, knowing that the experimental proof is beyond their ability. Similarly, there is no scientific experiment to prove the Third Law of Thermodynamics. This law, as formulated by Planck, states that the entropy of a perfect crystal at absolute zero degrees is equal to zero. Factually, there is no way to directly measure the absolute entropies. Therefore the proof of this law is beyond the realm of experimental science.

It is also to be noted that so-called scientific theories are changing constantly. For example, at the beginning of the nineteenth century (1808), John Dalton, in developing his atomic theory, stated that atoms could not be further divided. However, toward the end of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth century, it was found that Dalton’s atomic theory could no longer be considered correct. It was observed that atoms could be further divided into fundamental particles like electrons, protons and neutrons. It was also found that some atoms could emit alpha and beta particles, thereby producing new atoms, and so on. As a matter of fact, the so-called nuclear bombs are a result of these findings. In a similar manner, during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries Newton’s mechanics had a tremendous influence on the minds of scientists, since they could be applied to gross material objects. However, at the beginning of the twentieth century, with the discoveries of the fundamental particles, it was realized that Newton’s mechanics failed in describing the motions of these particles. Thus quantum mechanics has been developed to explain the phenomena they exhibit. These theories are filled with speculation, and they are also changing. Just as past and present scientific theories are changing, so we can understand that future scientific theories will also change.

All of this simply shows that the brains of the highly honored scientists are imperfect, and as a result the theories proposed by these brains will always remain imperfect. Actually, perfect knowledge cannot be changed, but in order to get perfect knowledge one has to approach a perfect source. That source is Kåñëa and the Vedic literature. Of course, this may seem like an incredible statement to a scientific brain like yours, which is accustomed to testing everything with scientific instruments and so-called logic, reason, deduction, hypothesis and theory, but it is nonetheless a fact. This can be understood by anyone who is scientific enough to experiment on himself by following the practices recommended in the Vedas, under the guidance of a self-realized soul.

The process is actually very practical. The spiritual master prescribes the process of spiritual discipline, and the student carries it out according to the directions given. If the student experiences the predicted result, then he concludes that the spiritual master was right. If the spiritual master is actually bona fide, the result will be positive. This procedure is quite similar to an honest scientist’s reporting his results along with his experimental method. One who wants to verify the result can perform the same experiment himself. When the same result is reproduced by several scientists, it is accepted as a scientific fact.

In conclusion, I would like to point out that when someone believes that life comes from matter rather than from spirit, his concern for morality diminishes considerably. If all life is merely a complex combination of chance chemical reactions, and if there is no supreme consciousness, no creator and controller, what need is there for moral restraint? This is not a new philosophy. In ancient Greece, Epicurus postulated that everything is simply a combination of atoms and void, nothing more. Today the word “epicure” describes a person whose main activity is to enjoy fine food and drink. The conclusion is that the philosophy that chance biochemical combinations are the origin of life is a philosophy that leads to unrestricted sense gratification, but it is by no means scientific. We can see one vivid example of how demoralizing and vicious this philosophy is in the present worldwide practice of abortion. Because of being taught that the embryo is not actually a living being but only a mass of inanimate chemicals, people have been convinced to kill their unborn children mercilessly within the womb.

I will be very interested in receiving your thoughts on these points and am prepared to discuss the matter further if you have any doubts about them.

I hope this letter meets you well.

Respectfully yours,

Haàsadüta Svämé

September 10, 1977

September 10, 1977


Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor

Sri Lanka Rationalist Association

September 10, 1977

Mr. Haàsadüta Svämé

ISKCON Sri Lanka


Dear Sir:

From [your] letters it is clear that it is futile for me, who base my philosophy on available scientific evidence, and you, who base your faith on dubious scriptures called Vedas, to try to convince each other.

If you insist that I should substantiate, by a demonstration before the public eye, my view that life originated from inert substances by chemical evolution under suitable conditions, I too have an equal right to ask you to substantiate your statement that “whatever we see in existence is the creation of the Lord, and that creation is going on at every moment” by demonstrating it before the public eye. As long as you are not going to get your “Lord” to demonstrate this, you need not expect me to conduct a onesided show.

As far as I am concerned, the universe is only matter and energy in time and space. The question of a creator does not come in, because matter, energy, space and time have neither beginning nor end. The various forms of terrestrial organisms, extinct as well as extant, are the products of millions of years of biological evolution of macromolecules of protein that were formed on earth as a result of chemical evolution under suitable conditions.

Can you tell me who created your “Lord,” and where he was before the universe was created?

Yours in search of truth,

Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor

September 15th, 1977

September 15th, 1977

Haàsadüta Svämé

ISKCON Sri Lanka

September 15, 1977

Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor

Sri Lanka Rationalist Association


Dear Dr. Kovoor,

I am in due receipt of your letter dated September 10, 1977, and have noted the contents carefully.

If it is futile to try to convince each other of our respective points of view, then what is the meaning of your science, rationalism and search for truth? The close of your letter—“Yours in search of truth”—suggests that you have not yet found the truth. That is your defect: you have not yet found truth, yet you pose and speak as if you were in knowledge of truth.

The first aphorism of the Vedänta-sütra is athäto brahma-jijïäsä: “In the human form of life, one should inquire about the Absolute Truth, or God.” You do not know what God is, yet still you have written, “The question of the creator does not come in... The various forms of terrestrial organisms, extinct as well as extant, are products of millions of years of biological evolution of macromolecules of protein that were formed on earth as a result of chemical evolution under suitable circumstances.” In simple English, you mean to say that life is a result of chance biochemical combinations. So if this is a fact—and if by this statement you wish to establish your credibility as a rationalist, scientist and seeker of truth—then why do you repeatedly fail to combine some chemicals and bring them to life, as I have challenged you so many times to do?

You say your philosophy is based on “existing scientific evidence.” So where is the scientific evidence that life comes from chemicals? Mix the chemicals and prove it! You say, “As far as I am concerned, the universe is only matter and energy in time and space.” Where did this matter and energy and time and space come from? Without giving any reason or evidence, you state, “The question of a creator does not come in, because matter, energy, time and space have neither beginning nor end.” Then again you ask me, “Who created your ‘Lord,’ and where was he before the universe was created?” Your statements are inconsistent. First you say that matter, energy, time and space have neither beginning nor end, and then you ask where the Lord was before the creation of the universe. This is clearly contradictory. This shows that you still have a long way to go in your search for truth.

Research reaches its conclusion when one accepts knowledge from the Vedas. Indeed, Vedanta means “the end of knowledge.”

Instead of providing evidence to support your fantastic statements, you try to cloud the real issue by counterchallenging God to create life. This kind of tactic is like that of a penniless beggar who, when brought before the judge to show his means of income, challenges the government to show its source of income first. Such a challenge would hardly be entertained.

According to Roman, Greek, British, American or international law, the burden of proof lies with the plaintiff, he who accuses, not with the defendant. You accuse the Vedas of being dubious, God of being fictitious and those who follow God and the Vedas of being mentally deranged, foolish, gullible, dogmatic fanatics. But the burden of proof is on you. Without giving reason or evidence, you say, “The question of a creator does not come in . . . everything is a matter of chance biochemical combination.’’ Do I have to accept this blindly? The onus is on you. Mix the chemicals and produce life. That is science. But no scientist can create even an insignificant mosquito from chemicals. Therefore, under the circumstances, it appears that it is you, and not we, who may be mentally deranged, foolish, gullible, dogmatic and totally fanatic.

Scientists like to discredit the Vedas by saying that they are the writings of superstitious aborigines. But what kind of aborigines were they who wrote in a language so perfect in grammar, composition, poetry and meter that a scholar needs twelve years to master the grammar alone? What kind of aborigines were they who thousands of years ago formulated divisions of time beginning with one ten-thousandth of a second up to the complete duration of universal time? What kind of aborigines were they who could describe, thousands of years ago, all the planets that modern scientists have only recently discovered? Where is the scientist today who can perfectly describe the process of conception taking place in the womb, as the Vedic so-called aborigines did thousands of years ago? How could these uncivilized aborigines categorize and enumerate in the Vedas all the different species of life, numbering 8,400,000? How is it that the Vedas, which are supposed to be the dubious writings of uncivilized aborigines, contain systematic information on subjects such as music, medicine, art, politics, architecture, warfare and psychology? How could uncivilized aborigines even know the arts of reading and writing, much less describe the atom and atomic energy? How could they give descriptions of the orbits of the planets, their size, their eclipses and the size of the universe, and how could they describe the soul and the Super-soul, God?

If Kåñëa is the Hindu aboriginal God, why did such a scientist as Oppenheimer pay Him heed by studying the Bhagavad-gétä spoken by Him? Why did Einstein, Schopenhauer, Kant, Hegel, Emerson, Thoreau, Schweitzer and scores of scientists more important and brilliant than you read Vedic literature—especially Bhagavad-gétä—if these are books full of superstitions and the deranged ideas of uncivilized aborigines? What is your authority? Are you greater than God? Do you think that these highly learned and honored men were all fools and rascals who had nothing better to do than spend their valuable time reading the writings of uncivilized aborigines? Or could it be that the Vedas are books of knowledge originally given by God at the beginning of the creation, and that they are preserved by being handed down in a Vedic tradition of disciplic succession about which you unfortunately know nothing?

As a scientist, you would do well to take out some time and sincerely examine the Vedas on their own merit, not in terms of preconceived notions resulting from limited, imperfect speculations and experiments.

Whether one speaks for or against the existence of God, the central point is God. You say, “I hope you understand that it is not the way with science to provide proof for things that do not exist.” But we see that the so-called scientist is very busy trying to prove the nonexistence of God. If God has no existence, why bother about Him? According to logic, one cannot conceive of a thing that does not exist. And if a nonexistent entity is inconceivable, where is the question of even discussing it, whether positively or negatively?

It is the peculiar madness of many so-called scientists that they cannot seem to get off the subject of God, who according to them has no existence. We see that the whole aim of their scientific research is to justify their rebellion against the authority of God and the scriptures by trying to find an alternative cause and reason for life and creation. Although these scientists would like to believe that life originated from inert chemicals, no one has ever observed such an event. Therefore, a science based on such beliefs can only be a science of rascals and fools.

My challenge to you, or to any scientist who claims that life originates from chemicals, still stands: mix the chemicals and produce life. Why can’t you do it? You say, “It is like this. It is like that,” so then why can’t you produce life? Sunshine is available, the earth is present, the water, air, fire and all other ingredients are present, and life is being produced by God. If you are greater than God, why can’t you produce something? What is the use of your talk if you cannot produce life? Nor can you stop old age, disease or death. Your talk is simply empty nonsense. You cannot do anything, yet still you are talking, saying that life comes from chemicals. You are a talking scientist, and I am a practical scientist. Take some chemicals and save yourself from old age, disease and death. I asked you to produce an egg—where is it? The chicken is a better scientist than you, because it lays an egg and within a month produces another chicken. Therefore you are less important than a chicken. Chickens are producing life, but you cannot produce anything but empty sounds.

In the service of Kåñëa,

Haàsadüta Svämé



Having been challenged to demonstrate that he could create life at a public meeting, Dr. Kovoor declined to attend, saying that he would not feel obliged to demonstrate that he could create life unless God Himself were to appear in person to demonstrate the same thing. The Times reported this with the headline “Flummoxed Kovoor Passes the Buck.” Then Haàsadüta Svämé sent Dr. Kovoor this final letter.

September 21, 1977

September 21, 1977

Haàsadüta Svämé

ISKCON Sri Lanka

September 21, 1977

Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor

Sri Lanka Rationalist Association


Dear Dr. Kovoor,

You wanted to place yourself above God, but God ‘s devotees defeated you, as the newspaper correctly noted. I’m sure that the readers were also enlightened regarding the theory that life comes from chemicals.

You may be interested to know that you are the first so-called scientist in the world to be officially challenged by ISKCON, and you are also the first to be totally exposed in the public press. Your case is a landmark in history. Because the spiritual life in most religious communities has long ago died out, practically no one has been able to properly put forward the theistic point of view in the modern age. The International Society for Krishna Consciousness, however, is presenting the yuga-dharma, the truly scientific method of religion for this age: it is perfectly teaching and following the Vedic religion. Of course, every religious movement claims to be genuine, but we have to distinguish the genuine from the fraudulent. Your defect is that because you have been repeatedly frustrated by encountering spiritual frauds, you have prematurely concluded that all religions are bogus. You want to brand God and religion fraudulent, but fraud can be understood only in relation to its genuine counterpart. That you fail to know. You do not know what is genuine.

I don’t say that all scientists are frauds, but I do say that you or anyone claiming that life is generated from inert matter is definitely a fool or a fraud. In fact, you are both—because you obstinately cling to the foolish notion that life comes from chemicals. What is the difference between your theory and that of the alchemists, who attempted (and failed) to produce gold from chemicals? A modern scientist scoffs at the alchemists—yet he proposes to create life from chemicals. Isn’t this the height of folly? I’m still open to be convinced that life comes from chemicals, if you can provide evidence by creating life from chemicals.

Now your life is nearly at an end, and at the time of death, when the messengers of death come for your soul, perhaps you will remember all this and understand everything. But then it will be too late, for you will be helplessly dragged off to repeat another life of material struggle in the shape of birth, death, old age and disease. But if one simply chants Hare Kåñëa, he can be saved from this great struggle. I hope you will do that.

Haàsadüta Svämé


(Editor’s note: Dr. Abraham T. Kovoor died on September 18, 1978 in Sri Lanka. Although he was battling with cancer, the cause of death was determined to be heart failure.)

Light of the Bhägawata (1983)


His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Founder-Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness


Special Commemorative Edition

The 497th Appearance Day of Lord Chaitanya Mahaprabhu


March 28th, 1983

Çré Gaura Purnima at Sreedam Mayapur


The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust

Los Angeles, Paris, Zurich, Bombay, Sydney, Hong Kong.


Limited Printing: 1,000 copies

Printed in Hong Kong

LoB: Preface

Preface

We offer our respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, the Founder-Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness who has delivered the Light of the Bhägawata to the whole world. We are pleased to present for his pleasure on the occasion of the 497th anniversary of the appearance of Lord Chaitanya Mahäprabhu, the first publication of his sublime work “Light of the Bhägawata”

Of all His Divine Grace's writings, this work is perhaps the most unique. It was written in Vrindavan in 1961 in response to an invitation to attend a world conference, the Congress for Cultivating the Human Spirit, held in Japan. As most of the participants to the Conference were from the Orient, Çréla Prabhupäda considered deeply how he could best present the timeless teachings of the Çrémad Bhägawatam suitable to the Oriental people. The original Bhägawatam was written over 5,000 years ago as an extremely large book composed of 18,000 verses. Participants to the conference would not have the time to hear it all. He therefore chose one chapter from the original version for presentation.

The chapter he selected is a description of the autumn season in Vrindavan, the place of Lord Krishna’s appearance. Çréla Prabhupäda knew that the Oriental people were very fond of hearing descriptions of nature and that the time of the autumn season is particularly auspicious to them. Presenting spiritual philosophy by examples from nature would be best for their understanding. For each seasonal phenomenon, a parallel teaching could be given. For example, the dark cloudy evening of the rainy autumn season when no stars are visible is compared to the present materialistic, godless civilization when the bright stars of the Bhägawata's wisdom (the devotees and scriptures) are temporarily obscured. Altogether Çréla Prabhupäda composed 48 commentaries to go along with the verses of the chapter.

Çréla Prabhupäda's plan was that the organizers of the conference should find a qualified Oriental artist to illustrate each verse, and he also wrote directions from which the artist could design each painting. He hoped that the paintings and their accompanying explanations would make an impressive display for visitors to the conference. If possible he wished that a book might also be published containing the illustrations and the texts.

Due to unfortunate circumstances, Çréla Prabhupäda was unable to attend the conference and the whole project of “Light of the Bhägawata” was postponed. In fact, at the time of Çréla Prabhupäda's disappearance the "Light of the Bhägawata" still remained unpublished, and the illustrations not yet painted.

The task of completing this great project was therefore left in the hands of the Bhaktivedanta book trust, the publishing house dedicated to keeping all of Çréla Prabhupäda's books in print. Particularly the work was assigned to the Hong Kong branch of the book trust since Çréla Prabhupäda had meant the book especially for the Oriental people. After much searching it was our good fortune to secure the help of the renowned artist Madame Yun-sheng Li, whose mature creative talent and sensitive brushwork alone could properly complement Prabhupäda's beautiful descriptions of the autumn season. Thus the beautifully effulgent “Light of the Bhägawata” may now shine upon the world.

The book has been divided into two sections to accommodate the tastes of different Chinese readers. Those who prefer to gaze with poetic imagination will appreciate the first section which contains the beautiful colour reproductions of Madame Li's work, 48 paintings completed in less than a year's time, meticulous in their detail despite an advanced age and sometimes failing eyesight. Undoubtedly this collection presents the culmination of a long distinguished career as one of the great artists of modern China. Her Gongbi style of painting together which will Prabhupäda's poetic descriptions which appear alongside make for a unique blending of the worlds two oldest cultural traditions — India and China.

Those readers who wish to go more deeply into the philosophy of the “Light of the Bhägawata” may turn to the black and white section of the book. There they will find the complete commentaries written by Çréla Prabhupäda along with small miniature reproductions of the paintings to help identify the painting being described.

This accompanying booklet has been produced especially for our English readers, hoping that it will satisfy them until a proper English edition is brought out. The publishers wish to acknowledge the grateful thanks to Sréman Harivilas das Adhikary and his company's Spiritual Sky of Paris France, for the munificent donation which has made the publication of the Chinese edition and the accompanying booklet possible. Hare Krishna.

Gour Purnima, 1983 Bhaktivedanta Book Trust

Hong Kong

LoB: Acknowledgement

Acknowledgement

The Publishers wish to gratefully acknowledge the help of all those persons who have contributed their services to make this book a great success:

Sriman Harivilas das Adhikary of Spiritual Sky Scented Products, Paris, France for contributing generously to help meet the cost of this publication; Çrémati Jagat-Karana devi dasi for giving artistic inspiration and direction to Madame Li Yuen-Sheng; Miss Maggie Ngai for polishing the Chinese text; Miss Kimmy Chung and Bhakta Peter Fung for layout and design; Bhakta Ho Shui Poon, Bhaktin Helena Chan Kit Yuk, Bhaktin Karen Ho Kee Wun, Bhaktin Cecilia Ip Man Lai, and Mr William Gonzales for proof reading the Chinese text; and Mr Shano Choi for coordinating between the publishers and the artist.

LoB: The Artist

The Artist

Madam Li Yuen Sheng was born in the city of Tientsin in Hopei, China in 1924. Her interest in painting began in early childhood, and she studied under Mr. Chen Shao Mei, an accomplished artist before graduating from Peking's Central Academy of Arts in 1950. Subsequently she worked as a graphic designer, but her reputation as an artist spread quickly, and in 1959 she was elected a member of the Chinese Painting Research Institute.

The paintings in this book bear the most recent witness to her excellence in the traditional Gongbi painting school style. They are the culmination of a remarkable career, during which her paintings were highly acclaimed by the celebrated Chinese artist Xu Bei Hong and extensively exhibited by the Chinese Government both inside and outside of China. When she left China for Hong Kong in 1979, she was unable to take any of her paintings with her, because by that time they were considered part of the Chinese Art Treasury. Since then, the Hong Kong public has enjoyed exhibitions of her paintings at Shatin Municipal Hall and Star House at Tsim Sha Tsui. Her work has also been the topic of several newspaper and magazine articles.

The Gongbi style is very intricate in its finely detailed depiction of Chinese figures and scenery, as can be seen from the meticulous care and labor in Madam Li's work. It is only after a lifetime of practice and experience that she has acquired such a skillful hand. Now she is dedicating much of her time to teaching students who are interested in learning and preserving this fine painting tradition of which she is one of the few remaining masters.

LoB:1

1

The arrival of clouds, accompanied by thunder and flashes of lightning all over the sky, provides a picture of life-giving hope. Covered by deep bluish clouds, the sky appears artificially dressed. The thunder and lightning within the clouds are signs of hope for a new way of life.

The serene sky, limitlessly expansive, is compared to the Absolute Truth. The living entities are truths manifested in relation with the modes of material nature. The deep bluish cloud covers only an insignificant portion of the limitless sky, and this fractional covering is compared to the quality of ignorance, or forgetfulness of the real nature of the living being. A living entity is as pure as the limitless sky. He becomes covered by the cloud of forgetfulness, however, in his tendency for enjoying the material world. Because of this quality, called tamas (ignorance), he considers himself different from the Absolute Whole and forgets his purity, which is like that of the clear sky. This forgetfulness gives rise to separatism in false ego. Thus the forgetful living entities, individually and collectively, make sounds like thundering clouds: “I am this," “It is ours," or “It is mine." This mood of false separatism is called the quality of rajas, and it gives rise to a creative force for separate lordship over the mode of tamas. The flash of lightning is the only beam of hope that can lead one to the path of knowledge, and therefore it is compared to the mode of sattva, or goodness.

The limitless sky, or the all-pervading Absolute Truth (Brahman), is nondifferent from the covered portion of the sky, but simultaneously the whole sky is different from the fractional portion that is liable to be covered by the dark cloud. The cloud, accompanied by thunder and lightning, cannot possibly cover the limitless sky. Therefore the Absolute Truth, which is compared to the whole sky, is simultaneously one with the manifested living being and different from him. The living being is only a sample of the Absolute Truth and is prone to be covered by the circumstantial cloud of ignorance.

There are two parties of philosophers, generally known as the monists and the dualists. The monist believes in the oneness of the Absolute Truth and the living entity, but the dualist believes in the separate identity of the living being and the Absolute Truth. Above these two classes of philosophers is the philosophy of acintya bhedabheda tattva, or the truth of simultaneous oneness and difference. This philosophy was propounded by Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu in His explanation of the Vedänta-sütras. The Vedänta is the medium of philosophical interpretations, and thus the Vedänta cannot be the absolute property of any particular class of philosopher. A sincere seeker of the Absolute Truth is called a Vedantist. Vedä means “knowledge.” Any department of knowledge is called a part of the Vedic knowledge, and Vedänta means the ultimate conclusion of all branches of knowledge. As philosophy is called the science of all sciences, Vedänta is the ultimate philosophy of all philosophical speculations.

LoB:2

2

The scorching heat of the sun evaporates water from the seas, rivers, lakes, and reservoirs, and there is little water anywhere. The people become thirsty and always look overhead for rain, but in despair. Yet just at the right moment, torrents of rain begin to fall everywhere in the land, even on the hard stones, and the land becomes overflooded.

The welfare state imposes upon its citizens scorching taxes in various forms — income tax, sales tax, land tax, terminal tax, excise tax, customs tax, and so many other taxes. But in due course, when the taxes accumulate into a large sum of money, they are utilized for the welfare of the citizens in various ways. Nonetheless, sometimes it happens that the benefits of the taxes fall like rains on stone-hearted men in the state who are unable to utilize the money properly and who squander it for sense gratification.

The common man supposes the unequal distribution of rain to represent nature's wrath for our sinful acts. There is truth in this. Thus to have an equal distribution of state-raised taxes, the citizens need to be scrupulously honest and virtuous. They should be honest in the payment of taxes to the state and should have honest representatives to look over the administration. In the modern setup of democratic states the citizens can have no cause for grievances, because the whole administration is conducted by the people themselves. If the people themselves are dishonest, the administrative machinery must be corrupt. Although a damned government of the people may be given a good or fancy name, if the people are not good they cannot have a good government, regardless of which party governs the administration. Therefore good character in the consciousness of the mass of people is the first principle necessary for a good government and equal distribution of wealth.

In ancient days the kings were taught lessons in political philosophy by ideal teachers, and the citizens from village to village were taught the principles of self-realization according to the Vedic codes for both the material and the spiritual upliftment of society. Therefore the citizens were God conscious and honest in their dealings, and the kings were responsible for the welfare of the state. The same basic principles are accepted in the democratic governments of the present day, for the irresponsible party of the people is always voted out of power and must yield to the responsible party for a better government. In the cosmic administrate n there is only one party, which consists of the servants of God. and the responsible deities of the various planets maintain the cosmic laws in terms of the orders of the Supreme Lord. But the people suffer on account of their own folly.

And what is that folly? In Bhagavad-gétä it is said that people should perform yajïas, or sacrifices for the satisfaction of the Supreme.* The Supreme is all-pervading. Therefore people must learn to perform yajïas to satisfy four different ages, and in the present age of iron industry the yajïa that enlightens the mind of the masses for God consciousness is recommended. This process of yajïa is called the sankértana-yajïa, or mass congregation for invoking man's lost spiritual consciousness. As soon as this movement is taken up through spiritual singing, dancing, and feasting, the people will automatically become obedient and honest.

Obedience is the first law of discipline. The people have become disobedient to the laws of God, and therefore neither rain nor wealth is equally distributed. A man who is ultimately disobedient cannot have any good qualification. When disobedient leaders lead the disobedient people, the whole atmosphere of the administration becomes polluted and full of dangers, as when a blind man leads several other blind men. The state taxes, therefore, should be spent to build the character of the people in general. That will bring happiness to the citizens of the state.

LoB:3

3

Attracted by electricity throughout the sky and driven by forceful winds, clouds gradually cover the surface of the earth to satisfy the needy people by supplying water, which is the substance of their life. The clouds bestow rains upon man as the mercy of the Lord, who is always kind to the needy living being.

We should always know that God is always kind to us. Despite our gross disobedience to the laws of God's nature, the Lord is kind enough to look after our maintenance. Water is one of the most important items for our maintenance, because without water we can neither produce food grains nor quench our thirst. Water is also required very liberally for many other purposes. Thus the Lord has preserved water on three fourths of the globe and has made it salty to preserve it. Salty water does not decompose, and that is the arrangement of Providence. The Lord has engaged the powerful sun to evaporate the water of planets like earth and distill it into clear water in the clouds and then stock it on the peaks of mountains, as we stock water in overhead tanks for later distribution. Part of the stock of water is refrigerated into ice so that it will not flood the earth for no good purpose. The ice melts gradually throughout the year, flows down through the great rivers, and glides down to the sea again for preservation.

Therefore the laws of God’s nature are neither blind nor accidental, as men with a poor fund of knowledge conclude. Behind the laws of nature is the living brain of God, as there is always a lawmaker behind all the laws of the state. It does not matter whether or not we see the lawmaker behind the common laws; we must admit that there is a lawmaker. Matter can never work automatically, without a living hand, and therefore we must admit the existence of God, the supreme living being, behind the laws of nature. The Lord says in Bhagavad-gétä that nature works under His superintendence.* Nature is only a power, and behind the power is a powerhouse and a brain, just as behind electrical power there is an electrical powerhouse, where everything is conducted by the brain of the resident engineer. The material nature works so nicely, and not blindly, because of the superintendence of the supreme powerful God. In the Vedic hymns (Atharva Veda) the same thing is confirmed. It is only under the superintendence of God that all the natural laws are conducted.

The Lord distributes His mercy in the form of rains on the scorched earth at times of dire necessity. He supplies rain when we are practically on the verge of death for want of water. God is merciful undoubtedly, but He bestows His mercy on us when we need it most. This is so because we forget God as soon as we obtain this mercy. We should therefore remember the mercy of God constantly if we want to avoid distress. We are eternally related with Him, despite the state of forgetfulness already described above. The Bhagavad-gétä confirms that the laws of nature are stringent because they are conducted by three different modes. But one who surrenders unto the Lord overcomes the stringency of nature easily.*

LoB:4

4

After heavy rain showers, the fields and forests in all directions appear green and healthy. Thus they resemble a man who has undergone severe austerities for some material gain and has achieved his end, for such a man is strong, hearty, and good-looking.

The greenery of the rainy season is but a temporary show. It looks very pleasant, but we must remember that it will not last. Similarly, there are persons who undergo severe austerities for some material gain, but those who are sane avoid this. Severe austerities for temporary gains are simply a waste of time and energy. Material loss and gain are destined in accordance with the formation of each particular body. There are 8,400,000 species of life, and each type of body is destined to enjoy and suffer in accordance with its particular formation. The bodily enjoyments and sufferings of a wealthy man’s son are different from those of a poor man's son. Although no one undergoes severe austerities to obtain distress, it comes upon us uncalled. Similarly, the happiness we are destined to enjoy will come upon us even without our desires.

Even though we may be able to avoid distress and artificially enjoy some material happiness by temporary achievements, this represents no factual gain in life. Our duty is to achieve permanent happiness and eternal life, and it is for that purpose only—for the ultimate gain—that we should undertake all sorts of penances and austerities.

This ultimate gain is possible to achieve in the human form of life. Permanent happiness is possible when one is free from material sources of happiness, for continuation of material bondage means continuation of the threefold miseries. Human life is meant for ending these miseries.

We should not try to be beautiful like seasonal flowers or greenery that flourish in the rainy season but are weary in the winter. To be enlivened by the clouds of ignorance overhead and to enjoy the sight of temporary greenery is not at all desirable. One should try to live in the unlimited clear sky overflooded with the rays of the sun and moon. That is what we actually desire. A life of freedom in eternity, complete knowledge, and a blissful atmosphere is the heart's desire of an enlightened soul. We should undertake all sorts of penances and austerities to attain that permanent source of happiness.

LoB:5

5

The evening in the rainy season is dark all around. There is no sight of the twinkling stars on the horizon or the pleasing moon. They are covered by clouds. And the insignificant glowworms become prominent in the absence of the luminaries in the open sky.

As there are seasonal changes within a year, so there are changing ages in the duration of the manifest cosmic world. These changing ages are called yugas, or periods. As there are three modes of nature, there are also various ages dominated by these three modes. The period dominated by the mode of goodness is called Satya-yuga, the period of passion is called Tretä-yuga, the period of mixed passion and ignorance is called Dväpara-yuga, and the period of darkness and ignorance (the last period) is called Kali-yuga, or the Age of Quarrel. The word kali means “quarrel." Kali-yuga is compared to the rainy season because many difficulties in life are experienced during this damp season.

In Kali-yuga there is a dearth of proper guidance. One may take guidance in the evening from the stars and moon, but in the rainy season the light of guidance comes from insignificant glowworms. The real light in life is the Vedic knowledge. The Bhagavad-gétä affirms that the purpose of the Vedas is to know the all-powerful Personality of Godhead.* But in this Age of Quarrel there are quarrels even over the point of the existence of Godhead. In the godless civilization of the Age of Quarrel there are numberless societies, religious communities, and religious sects, most of them trying to banish God from religion. Glowworms want to be prominent in the absence of the sun and the stars, and these small groups following various. religious conceptions are like glowworms trying to be prominent before the eyes of the ignorant mass of people. There are now a number of self-made incarnations people follow without authority from the Vedic literatures. There is regular competition between one incarnation's group and another’s.

The Vedic knowledge comes in a tradition from the spiritual master through the chain of disciplic succession, and the knowledge must be acquired through this chain, without deviation. In the present Age of Quarrel the chain has been broken here and there, and thus the Veda is now interpreted by unauthorized men who have no realization. The so-called followers of the Vedas deny the existence of God, as in the darkness of a cloudy evening the glowworms deny the existence of the moon and stars. Saner people should not be waylaid by such unscrupulous men. The Bhagavad-gétä is the summary of all Vedic knowledge because it is spoken by the same Personality of Godhead who imparted the Vedic knowledge into the heart of Brahmä, the first created being in the universe. Çrémad-Bhägavatam was especially spoken for the guidance of the people of this age, which is darkened by the cloud of ignorance.

LoB:6

6

On hearing the sound of the torrential rains, the frogs come out of the mountain caves and begin to chant, like brahmacaris who chant the Vedic hymns by the order of the spiritual master.

In this age of a godless civilization the sages of world-recognized religious sects who believe in God must come out of their secluded places and preach the science of God, the Supreme Will, to the people in general. Hindus, Moslems, Christians, and the members of the other sects that have convincing faith in the authority of God must not sit idly now and silently watch the rapid growth of a godless civilization. There is the supreme will of God, and no nation or society can live in peace and prosperity without acceptance of this vital truth.

The warning is already there, and responsible leaders of religious sects must meet together and form a common platform of a league of devotees of the Lord. There is no need for self-realized souls to live in a secluded place. Perfect self-realized souls, engaged in the service of the Lord, are unafraid of mäyä, just as law-abiding citizens of a state never fear the police. Such fearless devotees of God always speak scientifically about the existence of God, even at the risk of death. Such devotees of God feel compassion for the mass of people, who have completely forgotten the Supreme Lord and who engage in the false pursuit of happiness that ends in the sense pleasures enjoyed by the hogs and dogs.

LoB:7

7

The small rivulets that almost dried up during the months of May and June now begin to overflow their banks, like upstarts that suddenly overflow the limits of expenditure.

One should learn gravity from the sea and the rivulet. The sea is always within its limits, in spite of the many rivers pouring water into it. Similarly, one should properly use the assets of life and not squander them for purposes that have no permanent value. Uncontrolled, sensuous persons play with the assets of the body and accumulate wealth. But the strength of the body should be used for self-realization, not for sense gratification.

Human beings have two kinds of temperament. Some are introspective, and the others are extravagant. Those who are extravagant are enamored of the external features of phenomenal beauty and have no insight into the whole manifestation. They are practically asleep to introspection, and thus they are unable to derive any permanent value from the assets of the human form of body. But one who has developed introspection is as grave as the sea. While those who are extravagant are calm and quiet in sleep, such grave persons use the full advantage of the human form of life.

Although the animal propensities of the body should be minimized, those who are extravagant temporarily overflow in material enjoyment. Nonetheless, as soon as the rainy season of life is over, they become as dry as dry river beds. Life is meant for the right cause, or sat— that which exists for all time. In the material world, nothing is sat, or eternal, but the bad bargain of the material world can be used for the best purpose. The mind dedicated to extravagance is a bad bargain, but one can make the best use of the mind by introspection.

LoB:8

8

The colorful greenery of the newly grown grass, the seasonal flowers, the frog’s umbrellas, the butterflies, and the other variegatedness of the rainy season perfectly represent a well-to-do family absorbed in vanity over their personal assets.

A rich man displays his opulence in various colorful ways. He has a good residential bungalow with sufficient property and a well-trimmed garden. The bungalow is decorated with up-to-date furniture and carpets. There are motor cars with dazzling polish, and a radio set receiving and broadcasting colorful news and melodious songs. All these captivate their proprietor as though he were in a dreamland of his own creation.

When the same man was as dry as fallow land and had none of these opulences, he was plain in behavior, but since obtaining all these material means of enjoyment he has forgotten the principle that everything in the world comes and goes away like the changing seasons. The beautiful Red Fort and the Taj Mahal were built by Shah Jahan, who left the place long ago, and many others have also come and gone in the same place, like seasonal flowers. Material assets are like seasonal flowers only. Either the flowers wither, or the gardener himself leaves. This is the law of nature. Therefore, if we want permanent life, knowledge and bliss, we must seek them somewhere else, not in the changeable, temporary rainy season, which is flooded with so many varieties of pleasing sights that vanish when the season ends.

Material manifestations of things are but shadowy representations of reality. They are compared to mirages in the desert. In the desert there is no water, but the foolish deer runs after illusory water in the desert to quench his thirsty heart. Water is not unreal, but the place where we seek it is misleading. The advancement of materialistic civilization is just like a mirage in the desert. The deer runs after water in the desert with full speed, and the illusion of water moves ahead at the same speed as the foolish deer. Water is not false, but we must not seek it in the desert. A living entity, by his past experience, remembers the real happiness of his original spiritual existence, but since he has forgotten himself he seeks spiritual or permanent happiness in matter, although this is impossible to achieve.

LoB:9

9

A picturesque scene of green paddy fields enlivens the heart of the poor agriculturalist, but it brings gloom to the face of the capitalist who lives by exploiting the poor farmers.

With good rains, the farmer's business in agriculture flourishes. Agriculture is the noblest profession. It makes society happy, wealthy, healthy, honest, and spiritually advanced for a better life after death. The vaiçya community, or the mercantile class of men, take to this profession. In the Bhagavad-gétä the vaiçyas are described as the natural agriculturalists, the protectors of cows, and the general traders. When Lord Çré Kåñëa incarnated Himself at Våndävana, He took pleasure in becoming a beloved son of such a vaiçya family. Nanda Mahäräja was a big protector of cows, and Lord Çré Kåñëa, as the most beloved son of Nanda Mahäräja, used to tend His father's animals in the neighboring forest. By His personal example Lord Kåñëa wanted to teach us the value of protecting cows. Nanda Mahäräja is said to have possessed 900,000 cows, and at the time of Lord Çré Kåñëa (about 5,000 years ago) the tract of land known as Våndävana was flooded with milk and butter. Therefore God’s gifted professions for mankind are agriculture and cow protection.

Trade is meant only for transporting surplus produce to places where the produce is scanty. But when traders become too greedy and materialistic they take to large-scale commerce and industry and allure the poor agriculturalist to unsanitary industrial towns with a false hope of earning more money. The industrialist and the capitalist do not want the farmer to remain at home, satisfied with his agricultural produce. When the farmers are satisfied by a luxuriant growth of food grains, the capitalist becomes gloomy at heart. But the real fact is that humanity must depend on agriculture and subsist on agricultural produce. No one can produce rice and wheat in big iron factories. The industrialist goes to the villagers to purchase the food grains he is unable to produce in his factory. The poor agriculturalist takes advances from the capitalist and sells his produce at a lower price. Hence when food grains are produced abundantly the farmers become financially stronger, and thus the capitalist becomes morose at being unable to exploit them.

LoB:10

10

Just as a living being attains a transcendentally attractive form by rendering service to Lord Hari, similarly, all the inhabitants of the land and the water have assumed beautiful forms by taking advantage of the newly fallen water.

We have practical experience of this with our students in the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. Before becoming students, they were dirty looking, although they had naturally beautiful personal features; but due to having no information of Kåñëa consciousness they appeared very dirty and wretched. Since they have taken to Kåñëa consciousness, their health has improved, and by following the rules and regulations, their bodily luster has increased. When they are dressed with saffron colored cloth, with tilaka on their foreheads and beads in their hands and on their necks, they look exactly as if they come directly from Vaikuëöha.

The residents of the water are the fish, frogs, and so on, and the residents of the land are the cows, deer, and so on. By constantly drinking and taking bath in the fresh rain water of the rainy season, the tired and parched animals are refreshed and their complexion becomes brilliant as their health is invigorated by the arrival of new rain water. The lakes, ponds and rivers are cleansed and invigorated by the down-pour of new rain water and thus become most beautiful. Similarly, a devotee of the Supreme Lord who takes advantage of the beautiful and invigorating downpour of the transcendental descriptions of God found in Vedic literature finds his spiritual consciousness invigorated and refreshed. In this way his spiritualized body becomes very beautiful.

LoB:11

11

In the rainy season, when the rivers swell and rush to the ocean, and as the wind blows the waves about, the ocean appears to be agitated. Similarly, if a person engaged in the mystic yoga process is not very advanced in spiritual life, he can be affected by the modes of nature and thus will be agitated by the sex impulse.

A person fixed in spiritual knowledge will not be attracted by the allurement of material nature in the form of beautiful women and the sex pleasure enjoyed in their association. One however, who is still immature in the cultivation of spiritual knowledge may be attracted at any moment by the illusion of temporary happiness, just as the ocean is agitated by the rushing rivers and blowing wind which occur during the rainy season. It is therefore very important to fix oneself at the lotus feet of a bona fide spiritual master who is a representative of God so that one will not be carried away by sex agitation.

LoB:12

12

The mountains, although being struck by torrents of rain during the rainy season, are not shaken, just as those whose hearts are dedicated to the transcendental Personality of Godhead are never disturbed even when they are harassed by great misfortune.

Because a person who is spiritually advanced accepés any adverse condition of life as the mercy of the Lord, he is completely eligible to enter into the spiritual kingdom. Even though a person takes to the devotional service of the Supreme Lord, he may sometimes become diseased, impoverished or disappointed by life's events. A true devotee of the Lord always considers these sufferings to be due to past sinful activities, and thus he is not disturbed, patiently awaiting the mercy of the Supreme Lord. Such devotees are compared to high mountains which are never agitated in any way even when struck by powerful torrents of rain in the rainy season. Rather, they remain humble in spiritual enlightenment. Free of pride and envy, they easily gain the mercy of the Lord and go back to home, back to Godhead.

LoB:13

13

In the rainy season some of the roads are not frequently used and become covered with long grasses, on account of which it becomes very difficult to see the road. Similarly, in this age the transcendental scriptures are not properly studied by the brähmaëas. Being covered by the effects of time, the scriptures are practically lost, and it becomes very difficult to understand or follow them.

A covered road is exactly like a brähmaëa who is not accustomed to studying and practicing the reformatory practices of Vedic injunctions—he becomes covered with the long grasses of illusion. In that condition, forgetful of his constitutional nature, he forgets his position of eternal servitorship to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. By being deviated by the seasonal overgrowth of long grasses created by mäyä, a person identifies himself with illusory productions of nature and succumbs to illusion, forgetting his spiritual life.

LoB:14

14

The lightning becomes unsteady in its friendship, failing to remain faithfully in any one of the clouds, although they are the friends of the entire world, just as lusty women do not remain steady even in the company of men who possess excellent qualities.

During the rainy season, lightning appears in one group of clouds and then immediately in another group of clouds. This phenomenon is compared to a lusty woman who does not fix her mind on one man. A cloud is compared to a qualified person because it pours rains and gives sustenance to many people; a man who is qualified similarly gives sustenance to many living creatures, such as family members or many workers in business. Unfortunately, his whole life can be disturbed by a wife who divorces him; when the husband is disturbed, the whole family is ruined, the children are dispersed or the business is closed, and everything is affected. It is therefore recommended that a woman desiring to advance in Kåñëa consciousness peacefully live with a husband and that the couple not separate under any condition. The husband and wife should control sex indulgence and concentrate their minds on Kåñëa consciousness so their life may be successful. After all, in the material world a man requires a woman, and a woman requires a man. When they are combined, they should live peacefully in Kåñëa consciousness and should not be restless like the lightning, flashing from one group of clouds to another.

LoB:15

15

In the midst of the thunder in the cloudy sky, there appears a rainbow that has no string. Its appearance is compared to the appearance of the Supreme Personality of Godhead or His servants in the midst of the material atmosphere.

The Sanskrit word guna means "quality" or "mode," as well as "string" or "rope." When a rainbow appears during the rainy season, it is observed to be like a bow and no guna, or string. Similarly, the appearance of the Personality of Godhead or His transcendental servants has nothing to do with the qualitative modes of material nature. The phenomenal appearance of the Transcendence is free from the qualities of material nature, and thus it resembles a bow with no string.

The transcendental Supreme Lord is eternally the form of transcendental existence, knowledge, and bliss. The material energy works under His good will, and therefore He is never affected by the modes of material nature. When He appears before us in the midst of material interactions, He remains always unaffected, like a stringless rainbow.

By His inconceivable energy, the Supreme Lord can appear and disappear like a rainbow, which appears and disappears without being affected by the roaring thunder and the cloudy sky. The Lord is eternally the biggest of the big and the smallest of the small. The living beings, who are His parts and parcels, are the smallest of the small, and He is the biggest of the big as the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

LoB:16

16

At night, by the grace of the moonlight, the clouds in the sky can be seen moving. Yet the moon itself appears to be moving, just as a living being appears to be moving because of false identification with matter.

At night in the rainy season the moving clouds reflecting the moonlight make the moon appear to be moving. This is called illusion. The spirit soul, or the living being, is the root of all the activities of the material body, but because of illusion the spirit soul remains covered by the gross and subtle material bodies. Thus covered, the conditioned soul identifies with the material body and thus becomes subject to the sense of false ego.

This false ego obliges a living being to consider his material body to be his self, the offspring of the body to be his children, and the land of the birth of the body to be an object of worship. Thus the living being's conception of nationalism is another type of ignorance. Because of ignorance a living being identifies himself with the land of his birth and moves with the misconceptions of national ideas. In fact, however, a living being does not belong to any nation or species of life. He has nothing to do with the body, as the moon has nothing to do with the moving clouds.

The moon is far away from the clouds and is fixed in its own orbit, but illusion presents a scene in which the moon appears to be moving. A living being should not float with the misconception of the temporary body; he must always know himself to be transcendental to the bodily identity. This is the path of knowledge, and complete knowledge fixes the living being in the orbit of spiritual activities.

The spiritual living force is always active by nature. By illusion his activities are wrongly directed in relation with the body, but in the liberated condition of complete knowledge his activities are conducted in spiritual devotion. Liberation does not mean stopping activities; it means being purified of illusory activities and becoming transcendental to relations with the gross and subtle bodies.

LoB:17

17

When the clouds appear in the sky the peacock begins to dance in ecstasy, as a sincere soul becomes overwhelmed with joy on the appearance of a saint at his house.

The duty of sages and saints is to go from door to door and thus enlighten the householders in spiritual knowledge. Householder life is compared to a dark well. In a dark well the frog cannot see the free light of the open sky. The dark well of householder life kills the soul. One should therefore get out of it so that he may see the light of spiritual vision. Saints and sages mercifully try to uplift fallen souls from the dark well of householder life. An enlightened householder therefore takes pleasure in the appearance of such saints and sages at his house. The mind of the householder who is a conditioned soul is always disturbed by the threefold miseries of material life. Everyone wants to be happy in his householder life, but the laws of nature do not allow one to become happy in material existence, which is like a spontaneous forest fire.

In the Age of Kali, as described before, people in general no longer take pleasure in the presence of saints and sages, nor are they interested in spiritual enlightenment. The saints and sages, however, take all risks to propagate the message of Godhead. Lord Jesus Christ, Öhäkura Haridäsa, Lord Nityänanda Prabhu, and many such sages risked their life to propagate the message of Godhead. Self-realized saints and sages take such risks for the spiritual enlightenment of the people in general. They do not take vows of silence meant to win cheap glory from the ignorant mass of people. God is satisfied only when His devotees take all sorts of risks to propagate His glories. Such devotees are unafraid of the difficult journey to cross the ocean of nescience. They are always anxious for the welfare of the fallen souls, who are attached to the false enjoyment of materialistic life, in which they forget their eternal relation with God.

It is the duty of the saints and sages to enlighten the fallen souls, and reciprocally it is the duty of the householder to receive the saints and sages cordially, as the peacock dances in ecstasy at the presence of clouds in the sky. The fire of threefold miseries experienced by materialistic men can be extinguished only by the cloud of mercy of the saints and sages who can pour down the water of transcendental messages to put an end to the miseries of the householders.

LoB:18

18

Many plants and creepers that were almost dead during the months of April and May are now visible again in various forms, for they are nourished by their roots in the moist earth. These numberless plants and creepers resemble persons who dry up in severe penances for some material gain but then achieve their objectives and become luxuriously fat, nourished by sense enjoyment.

In Bhagavad-gétä it is said that when the daytime of Brahmä is over the manifested creations of the universe all vanish and after the end of Brahmä's night the creation is manifested again.*Thus the cosmic creation, in its manifestation and nonmanifestation, resembles the creepers and plants that appear during the rainy season and gradually vanish when the season is over.

Even when the plants and creepers are no longer to be seen, their seeds remain, and these dormant seeds fructify in contact with water. Similarly, the seedlike spiritual sparks who are dominated by the desire to lord it over the material nature exist in a dormant state after the cosmic manifestation is annihilated, and when the cosmic manifestation reappears all the silent living beings within the womb of material nature come out and engage in sense enjoyment, thereby growing luxuriously fat.

To attain liberation, one must be completely purified of perverted forms of desire. A living being cannot snuff out desires, and to practice artificially erasing the actions of desire is more dangerous than the active desires themselves. All desires should be reformed and directed towards spiritual activities; otherwise those same desires will repeatedly manifest themselves in different varieties of material enjoyment, thus conditioning the living being perpetually in material bondage.

LoB:19

19

A crane stands on the edge of a pond that is always disturbed by flowing water, mud, and stones. The crane is like a householder who is disturbed in the shelter of his home but who because of too much attachment does not want to change his position.

The forgetful householder life of the conditioned soul is a soul-killing dark well. This is the opinion of Çré Prahläda Mahäräja, the celebrated devotee of the Lord. Too much attachment for hearth and home is never recommended by a self-realized soul. Therefore the span of human life should be methodically divided.

The first stage is called the brahmacaré-äçrama, or the order of life in childhood, when the man-to-be is trained in the ultimate goal of life. The next stage is the gåhastha äçrama, in which the man is trained to enter into the Transcendence. Then comes the vänaprastha äçrama, the preliminary stage of renounced life. The last stage recommended is the sannyäsa order, or the renounced order of life. In this way one accepés a gradual process of spiritual activities for the ultimate goal of liberation.

Unfortunately, for want of sufficient culture of the human spirit, no one wants to give up the householder life, even though it is full of pinpricks and mud. And those who are too attached amidst the pinpricks of muddy householder life are compared to the cranes that stand on the bank of the river for some sense enjoyment despite all the inconveniences there. We should always remember that the society, friendship, and love we are supposed to enjoy in family life are only shadowy representations of the real society, friendship, and love reciprocated in the kingdom of God. There is no reality in the conditioned life of material existence, but because of our ignorance we are attached to the mirage. The idea of society, friendship, and love is not at all false, but the place where we search for it is false. We have to give up this false position and rise to the reality. That should be the aim of life, and that is the result of cultivating the human spirit.

Unfortunately, for want of sufficient culture of this spirit, the materialistic man always sticks to this false place in spite of all its turmoils. It is said that a man should give up the order of householder life at the age of fifty. But in this era of ignorance even an old man wants to rejuvenate his bodily functions, put on artificial teeth, and make a pretense of youthful life, even on the verge of death. Cranelike politicians especially are too much attached to the false prestige of position and rank, and so they always seek reelection, even at the fag end of life. These are some of the symptoms of an uncultured life.

LoB:20

20

Fierce torrents of rain break over the strands and the partition walls of the paddy field. These disturbances resemble those created by the seasonal opponents of the standard principles of the Vedas, who are influenced by the Age of Kali.

Originally the path of self-realization was established by the standard direction of the Vedas. Çréla Vyäsadeva divided the original Veda into four divisions, namely Säma, Atharva, Åk, and Yajur. Then he divided the same Vedas into eighteen Puräëas (supplements) and the Mahäbhärata, and then again the same author summarized them in the Vedänta-sütras. The purpose of all these Vedic literatures is to realize one’s self to be a spiritual being, eternally related with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the all-attractive form (Çré Kåñëa).

But all these different Vedic literatures were systematically distorted by the onslaught of the Age of Kali, as the walls of the paddy field and the strand of the river are distorted by the onslaught of heavy rains. The attacks of distortion are offered by atheistic philosophers who are connected only with eating, drinking, being married, and enjoying.

These atheists are all against the revealed scriptures because such persons are intimately attached to sense pleasures and gross materialism. There are also others who do not believe in the eternity of life. Some of them propose that life is ultimately to be annihilated and that only the material energy is conserved. Others are less concerned with physical laws but do not believe anything beyond their experience. And still others equate spirit and matter and declare the distinction between them to be illusory.

There is no doubt that the Vedas stand as the most recognized books of knowledge, from every angle of vision. But over the course of time the Vedic path has been attacked by philosophers like Charvaka, Buddha, Arhat, Kapila, Pataïjali, Çaìkarä, Vaikaran, Jaimini, the Nyäyakas, the Vaiçeçikas, the Saguëists, the Empiricists, the Päçupata Saivas, the Saguëa Saivas, the Brahmas, the Aryas, and many others (the list of non-Vedic speculators grows daily, without restriction). The path of the Vedas does not accord with any principle devoid of an eternal relation with God, attainment of His devotional service, and culmination in transcendental love for Him.

LoB:21

21

The wind carries the clouds to different parts of the globe, and the clouds distribute rains, to the satisfaction of the people in general, just as rich kings and merchants distribute their accumulated wealth, inspired by religious priests.

As already explained, the four divisions of society—namely the intelligent class of men (the brähmaëas), the ruling class (the kñatriyas), the mercantile class (the vaiçyas), and the laboring class (the çüdras)—are meant to achieve one goal in life: self-realization, or cultivation of the human spirit. The intelligent class of men, the brähmaëas, are to inspire the kñatriyas and vaiçyas in performing sacrifices for spiritual cultivation, and thus the cooperation of the brähmaëas, kñatriyas, and vaiçyas uplifts the people in general, or the ordinary laboring class of men. As soon as this cooperation between the four classes of men in society stops and the basic principles of spiritual culture are neglected, the social structure of humanity becomes a second edition of animal life, based on the propensities of eating, sleeping, fearing, and mating. It is the duty of the intelligent men to influence the members of the richer communities—the kñatriyas and vaiçyas—to sacrifice for spiritual culture. Only in this way can the tension between the capitalists and the laborers be well mitigated.

In this Age of Kali, when a slight difference of opinion leads to quarrel, even to the extent of riots, it is the duty of the intelligent men, the brähmaëas, to selflessly inspire the richer people to sacrifice for this purpose. It is suggested herewith that the men of the intelligent class should not themselves try to become kñatriyas or vaiçyas, nor should they engage themselves in the occupations of the various other classes; rather, the brähmaëas should simply guide them in spiritual cultivation, just as the wind carries the clouds to other places to pour water. The wind itself does not take up the responsibility for pouring water.

The most intelligent men in society are the saints and sages who have sacrificed everything for the service of spiritual culture. Their duty is to travel throughout human society and inspire its members to engage themselves in acts of spiritual culture by sacrificing their words, money, intelligence, and life. That should be the theme of human life in order to make it a complete success. A society with no taste for spiritual culture is a blazing fire, and everyone in that fire perpetually suffers the threefold miseries. As clouds pour water on a blazing fire in the forest and thus extinguish it, the intelligent men who work as the spiritual masters of society pour water on the blazing fire of miseries by disseminating spiritual knowledge and inspiring the richer section of the society to help in the cause. Temples of worship, for example, are constructed by the rich, and these temples are meant to impart spiritual education to people in general. The periodic spiritual ceremonies are held for inspiration, and not for exploitation. If there are flaws now because of the Age of Kali, they should be rectified but the institution must be saved.

LoB:22

22

After the complete rainy season, the forest of Våndävana was full of fruits like dates and blackberries ripening on the trees and bushes. Lord Çré Kåñëa, along with His elder brother Çré Baladeva and other cowherd boys of the vicinity, entered the beautiful forest, accompanied by the cows, to display transcendental pastimes with His eternal friends.

Lord Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, appears with His personal entourage once in 4,320,000,000 years and displays His transcendental paraphernalia, just to attract the conditioned souls of the material world. Although the material world is only a shadow of the spiritual world, the materially encaged living entities seek spiritual happiness here, in a form perverted by materialistic attachment. Emperic philosophers with a poor fund of knowledge imagine a spiritual picture that is impersonal. But the spiritual living being, less attracted by the impersonal form of spiritual emancipation, becomes more attracted by the material form and becomes hopeless of spiritual emancipation.

Therefore the Absolute Personality of Godhead, out of His limitless and causeless mercy, descends from the spiritual kingdom and displays His personal pastimes at Våndävana, the replica of the Kåñëaloka planet in the spiritual sky. Våndävana is the most sacred place within this cosmic universe, and people seeking to achieve spiritual emancipation by entering the kingdom of God may make a home at Våndävana and become serious students of the six Gosvämés who were instructed by Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. The six Gosvämés were headed by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, who was followed by Çréla Sanätana, Bhaööa Raghunätha, Çréla Jéva Gosvämé, Gopäla Bhaööa, and Çréla Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé. They were all seriously engaged in research and excavation of the mystery of Våndävana dhäma.

Lord Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, appeared at Våndävana about five thousand years ago, and the relics of His appearance at Våndävana were lost from view. But Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who is the very same Lord Çré Kåñëa in the form of a great devotee, appeared at Navadvépa, a district in West Bengal, and excavated the holy places of Lord Çré Kåñëa's transcendental pastimes. He instructed the above-mentioned six Gosvämés to compose authorized literature on the cult of Våndävana, and any serious student anxious to know about the Supreme Lord may take advantage of this invaluable literature and the guidance of authorized scholars and thus know about the Lord of Våndävana, Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead.

LoB:23

23

The cows that followed the Lord within the forest moved slowly because of their heavy, milk-laden udders. But when the Lord called them by their specific names they at once became alert, and as they hastened toward Him their milk bags overflowed and poured milk on the ground because of affection for the Lord.

It is understood from scriptures like the Brahma-saàhitä that in the spiritual abode of the Lord the houses are made of touchstone and the trees are all desire trees. There the Lord is accustomed to tending thousands and thousands of kämadhenus (cows able to supply unlimited quantities of milk). And all the houses, trees, and cows are qualitatively nondifferent from the Lord. The Lord and His paraphernalia in the spiritual abode are all one and the same in quality, although there are differences for the pleasure of the Lord. In the material world also we have various paraphernalia for our pleasures in life, but because all this paraphernalia is made of matter it is all destructible at the end. In the spiritual sky there are the very same varieties of pleasure, but they are all meant for the Lord. There the Lord alone is the supreme enjoyer and beneficiary, and all others are enjoyed by the Lord. The Lord is served there by all kinds of servitors, and both the master and the servitors are of the same quality. This spiritual variegatedness is displayed by the Lord when He descends at Våndävana, and we may know that the Lord descends with His personal staff of cows, cowherd boys, and cowherd maidens, all of whom are but spiritual expansions of the Lord Himself for His own pleasures. Thus when called by the Lord the cows were overwhelmed by joyous affection, just as the mother's breast overflows with milk when the child cries for it.

All of us living beings are differentiated expansions of the Lord. But our affection for the Lord is submerged within us, artificially covered by the material quality of ignorance. Spiritual culture is meant to revive this natural affection of the living being for the Lord. The ingredients of fire are already present in safety matches, and only mild friction is needed to ignite a fire. Similarly, our natural affection for the Lord has to be revived by a little culture. Specifically, we have to receive the messages of the Lord with a purified heart.

For spiritual realization one has to purify the heart and know things in their true perspective. As soon as one does this, the flow of one’s natural affection begins to glide towards the Lord, and with the progress of this flow one becomes more and more self-realized in various relations with the Lord. The Lord is the center of all the affection of all living beings, who are all His parts and parcels. When the flow of natural affection for the Lord is clogged by desires to imitate His lordship, one is said to be in mäyä, or illusion. Mäyä has no substantial existence, but as long as its hallucinations go on, their reactions are felt. The Lord, by His causeless mercy, displays the reality of life so that our hallucinations may be completely dissipated.

LoB:24

24

When the Lord entered the forest of Våndävana, all the inhabitants of the forest, both animate and inanimate, were eager to receive Him. He saw that the flowers of the forest, all fully blossoming, were weeping in ecstasy, honey flowing down their petals. The waterfalls on the hilly rocks were gladly flowing, and one could hear sweet sounds from the caves nearby.

The Lord has multifarious energies, and therefore the Lord and His energies are identical. Among His various energies the material energy is one, and it is said in the Bhagavad-gétä that the material energy is inferior in quality to the spiritual energy. Spiritual energy is superior because without contact with the spiritual energy the material energy alone cannot produce anything. But the source of all energies is the all-attractive Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa.

This material world is a combination of matter and spirit, but the spiritual world, which is far, far away from the material sky, is purely spiritual and has no contact with matter. In the spiritual world, everything is spirit. We have already discussed this. The Personality of Godhead, the original source of all energies, is able to convert spirit into matter and matter into spirit. For Him there is no difference between matter and spirit. He is therefore called kaivalya.

In Lord Çré Kåñëa's transcendental pastimes, He reciprocates with spirit, not matter. When He is in the mortal world, the material qualities cannot work upon Him. An electrician knows how to take work from electricity. With the help of electricity he can turn water into cold or heat. Similarly, the Personality of Godhead can turn matter into spirit and spirit into matter by His inconceivable power. Everything is therefore matter and spirit by the grace of the Almighty, although there is a difference between matter and spirit for the ordinary living being.

Flowers, waterfalls, trees, fruits, hills, caves, birds, beasts, and human beings are nothing but combinations of God’s energy. Therefore when the Personality of Godhead appeared before them they all became spiritually inclined, and by natural affection they wanted to serve the Almighty in various capacities.

There are different stages of spiritual development in matter. In the material world the spiritual sparks of the Personality of Godhead are covered by the material energy in different proportions, and gradually they become spiritualized in various species of life. The human form of life represents the complete development of the senses for spiritual realization of one's original affection for the Lord. Therefore, if despite this opportunity for human life we are unable to revive our natural affection for the Lord, we must know that we are wasting our life for nothing. By the grace of the Lord, however, the spiritual consciousness of every species of life can occupy its proper place, and these species can express their spiritual affection for the Lord in the çänta-rasa, as displayed by the land, water, hills, trees, fruits, and flowers of Våndävana during the presence of Lord Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead.

LoB:25

25

The Lord reciprocated the feelings of the inhabitants of the forest of Våndävana. When there was rainfall, the Lord took shelter at the feet of the trees or in the caves and enjoyed the taste of different fruits with His eternal associates the cowherd boys. He played with them, sat with them, and ate fruits with them.

Becoming one with God does not always indicate that a living being merges into the existence of the Lord. To become one with God means to attain one's original spiritual quality. Unless one attains one's spiritual quality one cannot enter into the kingdom of God. The members of the impersonalist school explain their idea of oneness by the example of mixing of river water with the sea water. But we should know that within the water of the sea there are living beings, who do not merge into the existence of water but keep their separate identities and enjoy life within the water. They are one with the water in the sense that they have attained the quality of living within the water. Similarly, the spiritual world is not without its separate paraphernalia. A living being can keep his separate spiritual identity in the spiritual kingdom and enjoy life with the supreme spiritual being, the Personality of Godhead.

In Våndävana all the spiritual entities—the cowboys, the cow maids, the forest, the trees, the hills, the water, the fruits, the cows, and all others—enjoy life spiritually in association with the Lord, Çré Kåñëa. They are simultaneously one with and different from the Lord. But ultimately they are one in different varieties.

LoB:26

26

The Lord enjoyed in the company of Lord Baladeva and the other cowherd boys and sometimes sat with them on the same stone slab. While sitting they ate simple food like rice, dahl, vegetables, bread, and curd, which they had brought from their homes and which they shared in friendly exchanges.

In the Bhagavad-gétä the Lord has expressed His willingness to accept fruits, flowers, leaves, and water from His devotee when they have been offered to Him in devotional affection. The Lord can eat anything and everything, because everything is but a transformation of His own energy. But when there is a question of offering Him something, the offerings must be within the range of the eatables the Lord has ordered. We cannot offer the Lord that which He has not ordered. The Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, cannot be offered anything beyond the range of good foodstuffs like rice, dahl, wheat, vegetables, milk and milk preparations, and sugar. At Jagannäth Puré the Lord is offered such foodstuffs, and in all scriptures the very same foodstuffs are mentioned everywhere.

The Lord is never hungry, nor does He require any food to fill His empty stomach. He is complete in Himself. Yet He always mercifully eats the foods offered by His devotees in sincere affection. The cowherd boys brought simple foodstuffs from home, and the Lord, who is constantly served by hundreds and thousands of goddesses of fortune, is always glad to accept such simple foodstuffs from His devotee friends. All the relatives of the Lord are His devotees only, and they are situated in different transcendental mellows as friends, parents, and lovers. The Lord derives transcendental pleasure by accepting services from His various grades of devotees, who are situated in various grades of rasas. These transcendental rasas are pervertedly reflected in the material atmosphere, and thus the spiritual living being, out of ignorance only, vainly seeks the same bliss in matter.

LoB:27

27

After good rains, the grazing ground for the animals was full of green pasture, and both the bulls and the cows sat down on the grass fully satisfied. The cows, followed by their calves, appeared tired of grazing, because of full milk bags. Calmly and quietly the cows and calves rested and ruminated, chewing their cud.

Protection and grazing ground for the cows are among the essential needs for society and the welfare of people in general. The animal fat required for the human body can be well derived from cow’s milk. Cow’s milk is very important for human energy, and the economic development of society depends on sufficient food grains, sufficient milk, and sufficient transportation and distribution of these products. Lord Çré Kåñëa, by His personal example, taught us the importance of cow protection, which is meant not only for the Indian climate but for all human beings all over the universe.

Less intelligent people underestimate the value of cow’s milk. Cow’s milk is also called gorasa, or the juice from the body of the cow. Milk is the most valuable form of gorasa, and from milk we can prepare many important and valuable foodstuffs for the upkeep of the human body. The killing of cows by human society is one of the grossest suicidal policies, and those who are anxious to cultivate the human spirit must turn their first attention toward the question of cow protection.

If we really want to cultivate the human spirit in society we must have first-class intelligent men to guide the society, and to develop the finer tissues of our brains we must assimilate vitamin values from milk. Devotees worship Lord Çré Kåñëa by addressing Him as the well-wisher of the brähmaëas and the cows. The most intelligent class of men, who have perfectly attained knowledge in spiritual values, are called the brähmaëas. No society can improve in transcendental knowledge without the guidance of such first-class men, and no brain can assimilate the subtle form of knowledge without fine brain tissues. For such important brain tissues we require a sufficient quantity of milk and milk preparations. Ultimately, we need to protect the cow to derive the highest benefit from this important animal. The protection of cows, therefore, is not merely a religious sentiment but a means to secure the highest benefit for human society.

LoB:28

28

The fully beautiful scenery after the rainy season was attractive to the eyes of everyone, including Çré Kåñëa, the cause of all causes.

We should always appreciate the creative energy of the Supreme Lord. Beautiful nature, even though material and therefore temporary, is always full of the glories of the creator. There is a class of philosophers who condemn the material creation as false. They say that Brahman is truth but the creation is false. This is not good.

The temporary creation is also a relative truth. It is in fact the temporary picture of the eternal creation. The forgetful soul has no information of the spiritual creation, known as the sanätana dhäma, but the temporary creation gives an idea of this original creation. The devotees of the Lord, therefore, make the best use of the bad bargain by utilizing the temporary creation in the service of the Lord.

Everything emanates as different energies from the Lord, and thus everything should be engaged for His service only. As soon as even temporary things are engaged in His service, they take on permanent values. The process of such engagement in the service of the Lord is what the sages call cikitsitam, or "well treated”. If we have some kind of trouble in the stomach from drinking milk, the physician prescribes the same milk in the form of curd, which is nothing but treated milk. Similarly, the temporary creation of the material world is undoubtedly full of miseries, but when accepted in terms of its relation with the Supreme Lord the whole thing becomes as well treated as the curd. Everything accepted in full God consciousness has its spiritual value, and by the grace of the Almighty its material effects are diminished in terms of the increasing degree of spiritual consciousness. That is the process for cultivating the human spirit.

LoB:29

29

Thus the rainy season came to an end. The autumn began, and there were no more clouds in the sky. All the reservoirs of water became crystal clear, and the wind was no longer forceful. Lord Kåñëa, along with His elder brother Lord Baladeva, thus lived at Våndävana in this auspicious season.

When the sky is clear of all clouds there is no longer any distinction between the portion of the sky that was covered and that which was never covered. Similarly, when the living entity now covered by the modes of material nature is freed from ignorance, passion, and so-called goodness, he becomes one with the Absolute Truth. Such oneness is called mukti, or freedom from the miseries of material life. There are five different kinds of mukti. Impersonalists prefer to merge into the existence of the Transcendence, but the personalists, or devotees, do not annihilate their individuality, and thus the devotees of the Lord individually enjoy spiritual variegatedness on the planets of the spiritual sky.

The material sky is also the spiritual sky, but it is covered by the modes of material nature. This material nature is also a temporary creation of the Lord, as the cloud is a creation of the sun. When the cloud of the material modes is cleared off, the material nature is said to have been annihilated.

There are two kinds of living entities, namely the conditioned and the pure. It is for the conditioned living entities that the material nature is created, and the conditioned souls are put into it to become pure, unconditioned souls. Those who become unconditioned by devotional service enter into the eternal kingdom of God, and those who lose the chance rot in dormant material conditions, sometimes manifested and sometimes nonmanifested. Lord Çré Kåñëa descends to reclaim the conditioned souls.

LoB:30

30

In autumn all the reservoirs of water become enriched with growing lotuses. The muddy water again becomes normally clear and decorated, as fallen, conditioned souls once more become spiritually enriched in devotional service.

We should not be disappointed in our muddy life of material existence, for as soon as we voluntarily take to the devotional service of the Lord our whole life becomes clear, like water in autumn. Devoid of our relationship with God our life is barren, but as soon as the muddy mind is cleared by spiritual association or cultivation of the human spirit the threefold miseries of material life are at once cleared off. Thus the lotus of knowledge gradually fructifies, and this gradual process of development ushers in transcendental bliss.

The whole spiritual process is technically called yoga, or linking with the Supreme. It is something like a long staircase, and the upward steps are variously designated as regulated work, transcendental knowledge, mystic powers, and ultimately bhakti-yoga, devotional service. Bhakti-yoga is pure and unalloyed, being entirely beyond all the preliminary steps. Such unalloyed devotional service in favor of the Supreme Lord was displayed at Våndävana when the Lord descended there, and thus the yoga exhibited by the gopés of Våndävana is the highest unalloyed love of Godhead, the perfection of bhakti-yoga. To rise to the stage of love shown by the gopés is very difficult, but this stage is attainable for serious conditioned souls.

Unfortunately, cheap neophytes make a show of the transcendental ecstasies of the gopés, bringing them onto the mundane plane for perverted manifestations and thus clearing the way to hell by such unwanted caricatures. Serious students of yoga, however, practice it seriously, and thus they attain the highest perfection in bhakti-yoga, as stated in the Bhagavad-gétä (6.47):


yoginäm api sarveñäm

mad-gatenäntarätmanä

çraddhävän bhajate yo mäà

sa me yuktatamo mataù

LoB:31

31

The four prominent features of autumn are that there is no water in the sky, the weeds that grew here and there in the rainy season all wither away, the muddy roads and fields dry up, and the ponds of water become crystal clear. These four features of the autumn atmosphere are compared to the four orders of life.

In the varëäçrama system the student goes to the äçrama of the master to take lessons from him and serve him, even as a menial servant. These troubles of the student are at once mitigated when he attains transcendental knowledge in terms of his relation with Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead. As the white clouds no longer bear the burden of water in the autumn sky, the student finds that the troubles of drawing water for the master becomes a burdenless job if the student, by the grace of his master, attains to spiritual knowledge.

Householders who beget children without restriction, like weeds in the rainy season, become solitary as soon as they attain to the stage of devotional service. The family planning of a godless civilization cannot check weedlike unwanted population. People should learn to check sex life by voluntary restraint. This voluntary restraint is possible when one is dovetailed with the service of the Lord. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä.*Well situated devotees of the Lord refrain from materialistic sense enjoyment, for they are attracted by the beauty of Transcendence. Forcible restraint by regulative family planning or similar artificial means cannot work very long; one must be attracted by the Transcendence. One can give up the inferior quality of enjoyment as soon as one receives the superior quality of spiritual enjoyment. So family planning is successful when one is engaged in the culture of the human spirit.

The vänaprasthas, who voluntarily avoid cleaning themselves and who allow their beards and nails to grow, no longer feel the discomforts of these burdens when they engage in the service of the Lord. And above all, the mendicants who take a vow to refrain from sex life no longer feel sexual urges when fixed in the transcendental service of the Lord.

Therefore, in all four of the spiritual orders and the four grades of social life, devotional service to the Lord is essential. Without this relationship, all the regulative principles of varëa and äçrama become burdensome duties, as they have in the Age of Kali. When the regulative principles have no aim, the varëas become a caste system, and the äçrama become the business of various shopkeepers. All these anomalies of the present social system can be reformed only by cultivation of the human spirit in the devotional service of the Lord.

LoB:32

32

The beautiful white clouds, freed from all burdens of water distribution, floated in midair, like mendicants freed from all family responsibilities.

As long as one is attached to the so-called responsibilities of family burdens, he is always full of cares and anxieties about meeting his family expenses. The four orders of social life, as designed in the varëäçrama system, are very scientific and cooperative. In student life one is taught the primary principles of the human form of life. One who enters the householder’s life can execute the duties of a family man because he has already been trained for this job in the brahmacaré äçrama. After fifty years of age the householder retires from family life and prepares for the life of sannyäsa.

The householder is dutybound to maintain the members of all three of the other äçramas, namely the brahmacarés, the vänaprasthas, and the sannyasés. Therefore, every member of society was given a chance to retire for a higher order of spiritual culture, and the householders neglected no one. The brahmacarés, vänaprasthas, and sannyasés all curtailed their necessities to the minimum, and therefore no one would begrudge maintaining them in the bare necessities of life.

In Kali-yuga, however, the entire system has gone topsyturvy. The student lives in luxury at the expense of the father or the father-in-law. When the educated, indulgent student becomes a householder by the strength of university degrees, he requires money by all means for all kinds of bodily comfort, and therefore he cannot spare even a penny for the so-called vänaprasthas and sannyasés. The vänaprasthas and sannyasés nowadays are those who were unsuccessful in family life. Thus the so-called sannyasés try to construct another home in the name of the sannyäsa äçrama and glide down into all sorts of luxury at the expense of others. So all these varëas and äçramas have now become so many transcendental frauds.

But that does not mean that there is no reality in them. One should not conclude that there is no good money simply because one has met with counterfeit coins. The sannyäsa äçrama is meant for complete freedom from all anxieties, and it is meant for uplifting the fallen souls, who are merged in materialism. Unless the sannyasé is freed from all cares and anxieties, like a white cloud, it is difficult for him to do anything good for society.

LoB:33

33

There are waterfalls flowing from the hills of the forest, but sometimes water does not flow from them. So the waterfalls are not like ordinary rainfall. They are compared to great reformers, who speak or do not speak, as the time requires.

There are two different kinds of religious preachers. One of them is called the professional preacher, and the other is called the äcärya. The professional preachers are like the rainfall from the sky, but the äcäryas are like waterfalls. The professional traders in Bhägavatam and Ramayana will speak from the portion of the scripture that will appeal to the mundane senses of the audience. For example, the professional Bhägavatam reciter will generally speak on the subject of rasa-lélä, which appears to the layman to be something like the dealings of ordinary men and women. Thus the professional reciters earn money from their so-called admirers. But an äcärya will never speak on rasa-lélä to the general mass of people. The rasa-lélä chapters of the Bhägavatam are the most confidential part of the scripture, and they are meant for advanced students of spiritual realization. In the Bhägavatam there are twelve cantos, and the rasa-lélä is in the tenth. So before one comes to the Tenth Canto, the Bhägavatam tries to convince one of the transcendental nature of the Absolute Truth: Unless one has grasped the spiritual status of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one is sure to accept Him as an ordinary man and thereby commit offenses at His lotus feet by so many unwanted activities.

The äcärya is he who knows the scriptures well and teaches his disciple in terms of the disciple's capacity to understand and advance in spiritual realization. Therefore he sometimes does not speak and sometimes speaks. The holy messages of Godhead have to be received from the realized soul, and not from the professional man. Although rain water and the waterfalls are the same, the water from the waterfalls has a different effect than ordinary rain water. One should not accept messages from the professional men, as one should not accept milk touched by the tongue of a serpent. Milk is good, but as soon as it is touched by the snake it becomes poisonous. The äcärya, therefore, is not a mercenary order-supplier like the professional reciter of scriptures.

LoB:34

34

Small pools of water accumulate during the rainy season, and in the autumn they gradually dry up. The little creatures playing in those small pools do not understand that their days are now numbered and will end very soon. Thus they are like foolish men who do not care for the nearing day of their death but become absorbed in the so-called enjoyment of family life.

Foolish politicians are too attached to family life. A big politician means a big family man. An ordinary family man is attached to his limited family of wife and children, but big politicians extend the same family feeling to a wider circle and thus become encumbered by false prestige, honor, and self-interest. The politician never retires from politics even if he has enjoyed many covetable posts, like that of minister or president. The older he is, the more he is attached to his false prestige. Even at the fag end of his life he thinks that everything will be spoiled without him. He is so foolish that he does not see that many other politicians who thought like him have come and gone, with no gain or loss for want of them. These family men, big and small, are like the small fish in the pools of water that gradually dry up in the autumn. They are foolish because they think that their attachment to their family, even at the end of their lives, will be able to protect them from the cruel hands of death.

As already mentioned, the human life must be divided into four component parts: the student life, the householder life, the preparative life, and the life of dedication to the service of the Lord. One must retire from all sorts of family life, big or small, at the age of fifty, and thus prepare for the next life. That is the process of human culture. The householders are allowed a pension from service so that they can live for a higher cultural life. But foolish men, reluctant even to accept this pension, want to artificially increase the duration of their life. Such foolish men should take lessons from the drying pools of water and should know, in their own interests, that life is eternal, continuing even after death. Only the body changes, whether spiritually or materially. An intelligent man should be careful to know what sort of body is going to be awarded him, and thus he must prepare for a better life in other planets, even if he is reluctant to go back to Godhead.

LoB:35

35

When the small pools of water become too hot because of the scorching heat of the autumn sun, the poor small creatures, with their many family members, suffer terribly, as poor householders with too many family members suffer economic strains and yet go on begetting children because of uncontrolled senses.

Human life is meant for controlling the senses, for uncontrolled senses are the cause of material bondage. But for fools sense enjoyment is the pivot of life's activities. All men undergo hard laborious duties all day and night and in all seasons of the year, only for the sake of sense pleasure with their mates. These foolish creatures have no information of other enjoyment. In a godless civilization especially, sense pleasure, accepted in the name of. culture and philosophy, is all and all. Men who are addicted to this pleasure are called kåpaëas.

When the kåpaëas have too many children, they suffer the scorching heat of family life, and then similar leaders advise them to undertake family planning. The idea of this family planning is that sense pleasure should not be curtailed but birth control should be accomplished by artificial measures. Such methods of birth control are called bhrüëahatyä, or killing the child in embryo. Such killing is a sinful act, and in the revealed scriptures a specific hell is designated for those who commit such sins.

Spiritual culture means pursuing a better engagement in life. When a man engages in such cultural life, the desire for mating automatically abates, and the sufferings of uncontrolled family life are mitigated without artificial means.

The attention of a human being, therefore, should be drawn to the cultivation of the human spirit, for this will gradually protect him from all sorts of discomfiture and elevate him to a higher status of life for real and eternal enjoyment in personal contact with the Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa.

LoB:36

36

With the progress of the autumn season the moist earth and muddy places begin to dry up, and the green vegetation begins to fade. This drying up and fading resembles the gradual disappearance of the false sense of affinity and ego.

Progress in cultivating the human spirit entails the gradual disappearance of the materialistic ego. Covered by ignorance, passion, and so-called goodness, the spirit soul thinks himself all in all and is covered by a false sense of ego. Thus he falsely identifies the soul with the body, and his bodily relations with material things become the objects of his attraction. This false identification and attraction for matter gradually dry up and fade away by success in the cultivation of the human spirit. That is the effect of such higher cultivation. Progress in spiritual culture brings about the disintegration of false ego and material attraction.

The ultimate goal of cultivating the human spirit is God realization and surrender unto God with a full sense of His all-pervasive nature. When a liberated soul thus surrenders unto the lotus feet of the all-pervading Godhead, the ocean of nescience becomes as insignificant to him as the water in the small hoofprint of a calf. He at once becomes eligible to be promoted to the spiritual kingdom, and he has nothing to do with the miserable land of the material world.

Cultivation of the human spirit is not, therefore, mere adjustment of materialistic anomalies. It is the process for preparing oneself to be promoted to the spiritual kingdom. No one can adjust the sufferings of material existence, but by spiritual culture one can elevate himself from the effects of such miserable life. As an example one may cite the condition of a dry coconut. The dry coconut pulp automatically becomes separate from its outer skin. Similarly, the outer skin, or the gross and subtle material coverings of the soul, automatically separates from the spirit soul, and the spirit soul can then exist in spiritual existence, even though apparently within the dry skin. This freedom from the false sense of ego is called the liberation of the soul.

LoB:37

37

With the inauguration of the autumn season the rough sea becomes calm and quiet, just like a philosopher after self-realization, who is no longer troubled by the modes of nature.

The result of self-realization is cessation of the storms of desire and lust, which are products of the modes of ignorance and passion. This cessation of the storm does not mean that the sea becomes inactive. When the storm subsides, the work of navigation can take place smoothly. According to the Indian system of navigation, there is a ceremony on the seashore known as the coconut day. On the coconut day the sea is offered a coconut because she has become peaceful, and from that day on the seagoing vessels sail to foreign countries.

The three modes of nature divide human activities into two different spheres, one external and the other introspective. As long as a man is dominated by the modes of ignorance and passion, he is active externally in desire and lust. Men absorbed in desire and lust are called asuras, and they are always chasing after women and money. For the sake of women and money the asuras exploit every source of economic development. As a result of this asuric civilization, the entire human society becomes like a stormy sea, with no trace of peace and prosperity.

Too much of an external view of the world gives rise to an overly large-scale and difficult type of industry and trade, known as ugrakarma. The word ugra means “hard” or “difficult,” and karma means “task.” The development of hard and difficult industrial undertakings always hinders the progressive cultivation of the human spirit. Asuric leaders of society never retire from such lustful undertakings unless killed by the laws of nature. For them there is no question of retirement or of cultivating the human spirit. But men in the mode of goodness have an introspective mind, and after a regulative struggle for existence they retire at a ripe old age and engage their time to cultivate the human spirit.

According to the varëäçrama principle, it is compulsory that one retire after the age of fifty, without considering other circumstances. Business offices close at a fixed hour no matter what balance of work remains. Similarly, after the age of fifty one must retire from the active, external life and devote oneself to the introspective cultivation of the human spirit. This retirement must be compulsory so that foolish old men will no longer disturb the peaceful progress of spiritual culture. In the modern democratic government, no one should be elected after the age of fifty. Otherwise the storm of the ocean of nescience cannot be stopped to allow the ships and boats to sail back to Godhead. The greatest enemies to progressive spiritual culture in human society are the old fossils of political parties who are blind themselves and who try to lead other blind men. They bring about disaster in a peaceful human society. The members of the younger generation are not as stupid as the old politicians, and therefore by state law the foolish politicians must retire from active life at the age of fifty.

LoB:38

38

After the rainy season, the farmers begin to rebuild the partitioning walls of the paddy fields so that the water will be conserved, just as yogés try to use their conserved energy for self-realization.

The living being is the marginal energy of the absolute Personality of Godhead, and he can spend his conserved energy either externally or internally. When spent internally the energy is identified with the internal energy of the Personality of Godhead, but the same conserved energy, when spent for His external energy, is identified with that external energy. All energies—internal, external, and marginal—are emanations from Him, the Supreme, and they act differently to prove diversity in unity. The unity is the Lord, and the energies represent diversity. The Lord is so powerful that He can do anything and everything merely by His sweet will alone. As mentioned above, everything is done by His energies in a natural way, with full knowledge and complete perfection. That is the information we have from the Vedic literatures.

The internal energy and the marginal energy are of the same superior quality, but the external energy is inferior in quality. That is the information we have from the Bhagavad-gétä. Because the living entity is classified as marginal energy and is of the same quality as the internal energy, it is quite natural for him to cooperate with the internal energy. But when the living entity prefers to cooperate with the external energy, he is put into difficulty. By the process called pratyähära (diversion), yoga diverts our energies from external to the internal.

The energy of our senses is meant to be diverted, not stopped. The senses are to be purified so that they serve the Lord instead of disturbing His settled harmony. The entire cosmic harmony is a settled fact by the will of the Supreme. So we must find the supreme will in every action of the cosmic situation. That is the instruction of the Éçopaniñad. The human life is an opportunity to understand this cosmic harmony, and therefore our conserved energy, which is likened to the conserved water in the paddy field, must be used for this purpose only.

As there is no chance of rain from the sky in autumn, we shall not immediately have a chance to get a human body again if we spend our conserved energy for sense enjoyment. The senses have their utility for the service of the Lord, and if properly engaged they can reach the highest perfection by being directly engaged in the service of the Lord in His personal presence. When the living entity thus goes back home, back to Godhead, and engages in the personal service of the Lord, he is said to have attained saàsiddhi paramä, the highest perfection. This is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä.*

LoB:39

39

In the autumn there is a gulf of difference between the day and the night. During the day the extreme heat of the sun is unbearable, but at night the moonlight is extremely soothing and refreshing. Similarly, Lord Çré Kåñëa is soothing for both the gopés and the mundane man in illusion, who accepts the body as the soul.

As long as the living being, under illusion, accepts the body or the mind as the soul, he will always be unhappy, like a man in the burning heat of autumn. But when the same living being becomes a devotee of Lord Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead, he at once lives a soothing life, as if under the cooling rays of the moon in autumn. Lord Çré Kåñëa is so merciful that He descends to reclaim suffering humanity and preaches the Bhagavad-gétä with the intense desire that all living beings give up all of their engagements and take shelter of His lotus feet. This is the most confidential part of all revealed scripture.

The example of the damsels of Vrajabhümi Våndävana (the gopés) is given here because these eternal consorts of the Lord terribly suffered the separation of Lord Kåñëa when the Lord was absent from their presence for His engagement in tending the cows in the forest. During the absence of Kåñëa the entire day would appear to the gopés to be as unbearable as a hot day in autumn. The Lord so much appreciated this natural feeling of the gopés that He declared His inability to repay their intense love. Lord Caitanya recommended the feeling of the gopés as the highest mode of worship that can be rendered to the Lord. The conclusion is that the regular practice of bhakti-yoga will lead the devotee to the plane of intense love for the Lord, and that is the single qualification by which the conditioned soul is allowed to reenter the eternal life of bliss in the kingdom of God. The threefold miseries of material existence are at once nullified by intense love of God, which is the ultimate goal of cultivating the human spirit.

LoB:40

40

In the clear autumn sky the twinkling stars appear brighter and brighter, just like a transcendentalist with clear vision of the purpose of the Vedas.

It is said that the import of the Vedas becomes clear to one who is not only a sincere devotee ofthe Lord but also a sincere servitor of the spiritual master. The spiritual master knows the purpose of the Vedas, practices it personally, and teaches the disciple of the true light of the Vedas. The supreme spiritual master, Lord Çré Kåñëa, teaches us the import of the Vedas in the following verse of the Bhagavad-gétä (15:16).


dväv imau puruñau loke

kñaraç cäkñara eva ca

kñaraù sarväëi bhütäni

küöa-stho 'kñara ucyate

The Lord says that in the Vedas it is mentioned that there are two kinds of living beings, called the fallible and the infallible. Those living beings who are materially encaged are all fallible, whereas those who are not conditioned and who are eternally situated in the spiritual realm are called akñara, or infallible. The Lord then says:


uttamaù puruñas tv anyaù

paramätmety udähåtaù

yo loka-trayam äviçya

bibharty avyaya éçvaraù

[Bg. 15.17]

yasmät kñaram atéto 'ham

akñaräd api cottamaù

ato 'smi loke vede ca

prathitaù puruñottamaù
[Bg. 15.18]

"Besides these innumerable fallible and infallible living beings there is another, superior personality, known as the Paramätmä. He pervades all the three worlds and exists as the supreme controller. And because I [Lord Çré Kåñëa] am transcendental to all of them, even those who are infallible, I am known in all the Vedas and histories [the Puräëas, Mahäbhärata, Rämäyaëa, etc.] as the absolute Supreme Personality of Godhead."

The import of the Vedas is still more explicitly explained in the Çrémad Bhägavatam. The conclusion of the Vedic literatures is that Lord Çré Kåñëa is the primeval Lord and the cause of all causes. He has His eternal two-armed form as Çyämasundara, with features exactly like those of a most beautiful young man, and that is the sum and substance of the Vedas concerning God. God is one, but the living entities, including both the liberated and the conditioned, are many and have many different grades of positions. The living entities are never equal to God, but as parts and parcels of the Lord they are eternally His servitors. As long as the living entities are situated normally as His servitors they are happy; otherwise they are always unhappy. That is the Vedic conclusion

LoB:41

41

In the clear sky of autumn, the beautiful moon among the beautiful stars becomes the cynosure of all eyes, just as Lord Çré Kåñëa is the central attraction in the Våñëi dynasty or in the family of Yadu.

The Personality of Godhead Çré Kåñëa appeared in the family of Yadu, and since then the Yadu dynasty has been luminous like the moon in autumn. The appearance and disappearance of the Lord are similar to the appearance and disappearance of the sun. The sun is first seen on the eastern horizon, but that does not mean that the sun is the sun of that side. The sun is fixed in its own orbit, and it neither rises nor sets. But because we first see it on the eastern horizon we may say that the sun rises on that side. Similarly, the appearance of Godhead in some particular family does not mean that He is limited by obligations to that family. He is fully independent and may appear and disappear anywhere and everywhere, because He is all-pervading.

Less intelligent persons cannot accommodate the appearance and disappearance of the Lord as an incarnation, but there is no sound reasoning to support such unbelievers. If God is all- pervading, like the power of electricity, He can manifest Himself at any place within His creation. When He is within we cannot see Him, but when He is without He is seen by everyone, although very few know Him as He is. Everyone sees the sun every day, but that does not mean that everyone knows what the sun actually is. Similarly, when Lord Çré Kåñëa was present five thousand years ago, very few could know what He was.

Anyone who comes to know Him as He is becomes liberated at once, and while leaving this present body such a knower goes back to Godhead, never to return to this universe of manifold miseries. In the Bhagavad-gétä (4.9), the Lord confirms this as follows:


janma karma ca me divyam

evaà yo vetti tattvataù

tyaktvä dehaà punar janma

naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna


"My birth and activities are all transcendental. One who knows them in reality will not be conditioned by another material body, but will come back to My abode, where there is no birth and death."

But there are foolish persons who take Him to be an ordinary man, not knowing the essence of His transcendental features. In Bhagavad-gétä (9:11), the Lord affirms this:


avajänanti mäà müòhä

mänuñéà tanum äçritam

paraà bhävam ajänanto

mama bhüta-maheçvaram


"Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and My supreme dominion over all that be."

LoB:42

42

At night in autumn the atmosphere is pleasant because it is neither very hot nor very cold. The mild wind blowing through the gardens of fruits and flowers in Våndävana appeared very much pleasing to all — all but the gopés, who were always overtaken by heartfelt sorrow in the absence of Kåñëa.

There are two kinds of transcendental feelings for those engaged in the worship of the Lord. One is called sambhoga, and the other is called viraha. According to authorities in the disciplic line, viraha worship is more palatable than sambhoga worship. Sambhoga takes place in direct touch, wheras viraha takes place without such direct contact. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu taught us to accept viraha worship. In the present state of affairs we cannot make any direct touch with the Personality of Godhead. But if we practice the viraha mode of worship we can transcendentally realize the presence of the Lord more lovingly than in His presence.

Without love of Godhead there is no meaning even to direct contact. During the presence of the Lord there were thousands and thousands of men, but because they were not in love of Godhead they could hardly realize the Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa. Therefore we must first activate our dormant love of Godhead by following the prescribed rules and by following in the footsteps of the authorities who are actually fixed in love of Godhead. The gopés provide the highest example of such unalloyed love of Godhead, and Lord Caitanya at the ultimate stage of realization displayed the viraha worship in the mood of the gopés.

In the mundane world there is also some shadow of such viraha. A loving wife, husband, or friend may for some time be maddened by the absence of the beloved. Such a state of mind, however, is not permanent. The loving husband or wife takes to another and forgets everything of the past. This is so because there is no reality to such relationships in the material world.

The spiritual situation, however, is completely different. A bona fide lover of God could never forget Him, even in exchange for everything else. The devotee of the Lord cannot be happy in any circumstance without the Lord. In the absence of the Lord the devotee associates with Him by remembering His separation, and because the Lord is absolute the devotee's feeling of separation is transcendentally more relishable than direct contact. This is possible only when we develop genuine love for Him. In that state the devotee is always with the Lord by feelings of separation, which become more acute and intolerable in suitable circumstances. The mild wind reminded the gopés of the association of the Lord, and they felt separation from Him acutely.

LoB:43

43

In the autumn season all the birds, beasts, and men become sexually disposed, and the bull, the stag, the male bird, the man, and the other male creatures forcibly impregnate the fair sex. A similar impregnation takes place as a result of devotional service to the Lord.

Devotional service to the Lord never goes in vain. Just at the right moment, the result of one's particular devotional service will come, even if one has no desire for it. The pure devotees do not wish any return from the Lord in exchange for their service; they do not make business exchanges with the Lord. But the Lord, out of His own accord, fulfills all the desires of the devotees.

It may appear that a devotee of the Lord is becoming poorer and poorer in terms of material prosperity, but factually he is not. The typical example is the Päëòavas. The five brothers, headed by King Yudhiñöhira, underwent all sorts of difficulties because of the conspiracy of their cousins, headed by Duryodhana, but in the long run King Yudhiñöhira was enthroned by Lord Çré Kåñëa, and his enemies were vanquished. King Yudhiñöhira was never disturbed by all the calamities that overcame them even though Lord Kåñëa was ever their companion. The Päëòavas never prayed to the Lord for anything but His devotional service, and in due time everything came out in favor of the devotees.

A devotee, therefore, should execute his devotional services with full energy, endurance, and confidence, he should perform his scheduled duties, he should be pure in heart, and he should serve in association with devotees. All six of these items will lead the devotee to the path of success. One should not be discouraged in the discharge of devotional service. Failures may not be detrimental; they may be the pillars of success. One must have good faith in the regulative principles followed by the self-realized souls, and one should not be doubtful about the ultimate result of such devotional service. Rather, one must go on executing his prescribed duties without hesitation, and one should never be influenced by unwanted association.

We should not consider going back to Godhead a plaything. We must take it seriously, as enjoined in the scriptures. For a strict follower, the result is sure and certain, and when the time is right the result will come of its own force. Dhruva Mahäräja went to worship God to gain something, but when he actually came in contact with God he did not want anything from the Lord. The Lord, however, awarded Dhruva Mahäräja both benefits — that is, the Lord fulfilled his desires and also gave him eternal salvation. Such are the lessons we learn from all the revealed scriptures. The almighty God awards the results we desire, and therefore we should desire that which is eternal, blissful, and full of knowledge. In devotional service we should not endeavor for that which is temporary and useless.

LoB:44

44

In the autumn season all the reservoirs of water are full of lotus flowers. There are also flowers that resemble the lotus but are of a different class. Among them is a flower called kumud. When the sun rises, all the flowers but the kumud blossom beautifully. Similarly, lotus-like men take pleasure in the advent of a responsible king, but men who are like the kumud do not like the existence of a king.

In this Age of Kali the people want their own government, because the kings have become corrupt. Formerly it was not like that. The sons of kings were trained under the guidance of a good brähmaëa äcärya, just as the Päëòavas and the Kauravas were put under the instruction of the qualified brähmaëa professor Çré Droëäcärya. Princes were rigidly trained in politics, economics, the military arts, ethics and morality, the sciences, and, above all, devotional service to the Lord. Only after such good training were the princes allowed to be enthroned. When such a prince became king, then too he was guided by the advice of good brähmaëas. Even in the middle ages, Mahäräja Candra Gupta was guided by the learned brähmaëa Chanakya Pandit.

In a monarchy, one man sufficiently trained was competent enough to conduct alone the business of the state. But in a democracy no one is trained like a prince; instead, politicians are voted to responsible posts of administration by diplomatic arrangements. In place of one king or supreme executive officer, in a democracy there are so many quasi-kings: the president, the ministers, the deputy ministers, the secretaries, the assistant secretaries, the private secretaries, the undersecretaries, the PA's, and the MP's. There are a number of parties — political, social, and communal — and there are party whips, party whims, and so on. But no one is well enough trained to look after the factual interests of the governed. In a so-called democratic government, corruption is even more rampant than in an autocracy or monarchy.

Men who want to flourish in the guise of servants of the people do not want a good king at the head of the state. They are like the kumud flowers, which do not take pleasure in the sunrise. The word ku means “bad” and mud means “pleasure.” Persons who want to exploit the administrative power for their own self-interest do not like the presence of a good king. Although professing democracy, they want themselves to be kings. Thus they compete for votes by bad propaganda and take pleasure in having politics but no king. Thieves and dacoits also take no pleasure in the presence of a good king, but it is the interest of the people to have a well-trained king as the head of the state.

LoB:45

45

After the new grains were cut and brought home from the paddy fields, the people began to observe the navänna ceremony everywhere, in the presence of the Lord as Çré Kåñëa and Baladeva.

According to Vedic culture, learned men consider all natural products, such as food grains, fruits, flowers, and milk, to be God-sent. No one can manufacture these things in manmade factories, however scientifically advanced people may be. People can make preparations of such God-sent foodstuffs, but they cannot manufacture the natural ingredients. Spiritually cultured men, therefore, feel obliged to the Lord when they get sufficient natural foodstuffs by the grace of the Lord.

The navänna präçana ceremony is observed as a way of acknowledging the gifts of God. Newly collected grains would first be offered to the Lord by the villagers, either individually or collectively, and in either case all the members of the village would partake of the prasädam thus offered to the Lord. Such ceremonies make the people happy and prosperous.

We should always acknowledge the mercy of God. We should not think that we can produce ample food grains merely with the help of tractors and fertilizers. These can help us only as instruments for such production; without the sanction of the Lord there is no possibility of having grains, even if there are trucks and fertilizers.

When Lord Kåñëa and Baladeva were present, the good men of Våndävana realized that it was due to the presence of the Lord that their supply of food grains were sufficient. Some of the people of Våndävana, including Lord Kåñëa's father Nanda Mahäräja, used to perform sacrifices to propitiate King Indra, the king of heaven, because he is the controller of rains. Without good rains, grains cannot be produced, and therefore the people would offer sacrifices to Indra. Lord Çré Kåñëa, however, stopped this age-old ceremony and advised His father to offer the same sacrifice to the Supreme Lord. His purpose was to teach that we need not satisfy the various demigods in charge of the various departments of cosmic affairs; instead we must offer sacrifices to the Supreme Lord, for the Lord is the master and all others are His servants. The famous Annaküöa ceremony, performed in Våndävana especially and also in all other parts of India, was thus introduced by the Lord, and people still follow this path by worshipping Govardhana Hill, where the Lord used to take pleasure in tending cows. People also worship Giri-Govardhana as identical with the Lord, because there is no difference between God and His paraphernalia and pastimes.

LoB:46

46

The merchants, preachers, kings, and students who were confined to home during the four months June, July, August, and September began to flow out and attain success in life, just as perfected souls attain the required body as soon as they leave the present one.

The people in general—especially the merchants, preachers, kings, and students—are advised not to leave home during the four months of the rainy season. These four months are known as cäturmäsya, and for everyone there are specific rules for observing this period, partly for the sake of health and partly for spiritual realization. During this period, the merchants cannot do free business, dedicated souls like sannyäsés cannot freely preach the doctrines of the Vedas, kings cannot go out to tour their states, and students cannot go to their schools, which are closed. But after the cäturmäsya period they all get the freedom to go out and perform their respective duties, and by doing so they can achieve the results they desire.

In the same way, one cannot achieve the desired results of one's penances until one attains freedom from the present body. There are various ways to practice the various kinds of yoga to attain various results in various spheres of life. It is not that everything is the same. There are varieties of life, varieties of planets, and varieties of success in spiritual realization. And all these can be achieved only when we have finished the cäturmäsya - like period of life. It is a foolish imagination therefore that we can go to other planets in the present body. If we want to go to Devaloka, the planets of the demigods, we must achieve the required qualifications, and the same is true if we want to go back to the kingdom of God. If we want to remain on this planet in some better condition of life, that also will depend on the required achievements. In any case, those achievements can be fulfilled just after one leaves the body.

The merchants, preachers, kings, and students form the four important sections of human society. The merchants should see that everyone gets his proper share of the food given as a gift by God. The sannyäsé preachers should go from door to door to preach the sense of God consciousness, not to build maöhas and temples but to enlighten the people. The king should go out from his home to see with his own eyes how things are going on. (Mahäräja Parékñit, while on tour, saw a man—Kali —attempting to kill a cow, so the king at once punished him.) And students should gather knowledge wherever it is available. The combined work of these four sections is meant for the general welfare of society.

LoB:47

47

From the Transcendence, which is called Kåñëaloka, there emanates a glowing effulgence that resembles the tail of a comet. This glowing effulgence is unlimited, immeasurable, and unfathomable. Within this effulgence there are innumerable glowing planets, each of them self-luminous. Somewhere, a limited part of that glowing effulgence is covered by material energy, just as a part of the sky is covered by a cloud. Within this material energy there are innumerable universes, in every universe there are innumerable material planets, and the earth is one of these planets. Thus we can understand what an insignificant part of the entire cosmos is this globe on which we live.

Kåñëaloka, as above mentioned, is the residence of the Personality of Godhead, the original Transcendence. The glowing effulgence emanating from Kåñëaloka is the personal glow of the Lord. The almighty Lord, being full of inconceivable energies, expands Himself in various forms and energies. There are forms from His energy as well as forms from His person. He has innumerable energies, and therefore He can do anything and everything as He desires, and these things take place immediately with all perfection. His energies are like the heat and light that expand from a fire. The entire cosmic manifestation is nothing but an expansion of His energies, the energies are emanations from Him, and therefore the emanations are simultaneously one with and different from Him.

The Transcendence is compared to milk, and the emanations are compared to curd. Curd is nothing but milk, but at the same time it is different from milk. Curd is a milk preparation, but it cannot be used in place of milk. The Lord is also sometimes compared to a tree. The root of the tree is the cause of the trunk, branches, twigs, leaves, and fruits, yet the trunk is not the fruit, the fruit is not the leaf, nor is the leaf the root. When water is needed it has to be poured on the root, not on the leaves. Pouring water on the leaves serves no purpose, but pouring water on the root serves all purposes. This is the essence of the philosophy of spiritual culture.

Kåñëaloka is also called Goloka Våndävana. Beneath this Goloka are Haridhäma, Maheçadhäma, and Devédhäma. Hari (Viñëu, Näräyaëa) is the formal expansion of the Lord, Maheça (Çiva) is the formal energetic expansion of the Lord, and Devé is the Lord's energetic expansion. The living entities are also energetic expansions of the Lord. There are two different kinds of living entities, called the liberated souls and the conditioned souls.

The planets within the glowing effulgence are called Haridhäma. On these planets the predominating deity is Hari, and the predominated deities are the liberated souls. The features of the liberated souls and those of Hari are almost the same, yet Hari is predominator and the liberated souls are predominated. The innumerable planets in Haridhäma are predominated by different formal expansions of the Lord, and all of them have different names.

The universes within the material energy are called Devédhäma, and within Devédhäma the predominating Deity is Viñëu, who is assisted by Brahmä and Çiva. Devédhäma is controlled by three modes, namely goodness, passion, and ignorance. Viñëu is the incarnation of goodness, Brahmä of passion, and Çiva of ignorance. Brahmä creates, Viñëu maintains, and Çiva destroys the material creation. The material creation comes into being by the will of the Lord, and it is again annihilated by His will. But although the universes of the material energy are thus created and annihilated, the planets in Haridhäma are ever existent.

The conditioned living entities, who wish to enjoy and not serve, are given a chance within Devédhäma to seek liberation. Some of them enter Haridhäma, some of them enter Maheçadhäma, and some of them remain within Devédhäma. Maheçadhäma is the marginal place between Haridhäma and Devédhäma. The impersonalists who want to merge into the existence of the Transcendence are placed within Maheçadhäma. Those who want to remain within the planetary systems of the material universes do so on various planets, but those who want to go outside the material energy can enter Haridhäma and go either to the various planets there or directly to Kåñëaloka.

The system of bhakti-yoga makes one eligible to enter Haridhäma, the system of jïäna-yoga makes one eligible to enter Maheçadhäma and the system of karma-yoga obliges one to remain in Devédhäma and repeatedly be born and die, changing his material covering according to the standard of karma he performs.

LoB:48

48

The moon, or Candraloka, is one of the four important places of residence for the demigods. Beyond Mänasa Lake is Sumeru Mountain. On the eastern side of this mountain is the planet Devadhäné, where Indra resides. On the southern side is the planet known as Saàyamané, where Yamaräja resides. On the western side is the planet known as Nimlocané, the residence of Väyu, the demigod who controls the wind. And on the northern side of the mountain is the moon, which is also known as Vibhävaré.

All these various planets are within the universe in which our planet is situated. Persons who are too materialistic always engage in sense enjoyment. Such persons worship' the material demigods and goddesses to fulfill their material desires. They are fond of performing many yajïas to propitiate the various demigods and the forefathers in heaven. Such persons are automatically promoted to the moon, where they enjoy soma, a celestial beverage.

The moon is too cold for the inhabitants of this earth, and therefore ordinary persons who want to go there with earthly bodies are attempting to do so in vain. Merely seeing the moon from a distance of eighty thousand miles cannot enable one to understand the real situation of the moon. One has to cross Mänasa Lake and then Sumeru Mountain, and only then can one trace out the orbit of the moon. Besides that, no ordinary man is allowed to enter that planet. Even those admitted there after death must have performed the prescribed duties to satisfy the Pitäs and devas. Yet even they are sent back to earth after a fixed duration of life on the moon.

Men with developed consciousness, therefore, do not waste time making excursions, real or imaginary, to the moon. Such intelligent persons do not endeavor to achieve temporary sense enjoyment. Rather, they apply their conserved energy for the sake of spiritual cultivation. They discharge religious duties for the satisfaction of the Supreme Lord, and not for personal sense enjoyment. The signs of such exceptional devotees of the Lord are that they are unattached to material enjoyment, contented, pure in heart, attached to devotional service, free from affection for temporary things, and devoid of false ego. According Vedic injunctions, such great personalities ultimately attain the place where the Supreme Personality of Godhead predominates and where there is no death, no birth, no old age, and no disease. On the way to these spiritual planets, such personalities pass through the sun-line called arcir-märga. And on the way they can see all the planets between here and the spiritual world.

The Scientific Basis
of Kåñëa Consciousness

by SVARÜPA DÄMODARA DÄSA, Ph.D.

SBKC: Dedication

Dedication

Before making this humble attempt to write a few words about the unlimited and inexhaustible nectarean knowledge of the all-merciful Supreme Personality of Godhead, the supreme scientist, Lord Çré Kåñëa, I offer my most humble obeisances unto the lotus feet of my spiritual master and eternal father, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, and beg from His Divine Grace his kind mercy. Without the mercy of His Divine Grace, it is completely beyond the power of this most unqualified pupil to utter even a fraction of a single word describing the transcendental qualities of the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa. I therefore completely and fully depend on the kind and causeless mercy of my eternal father, Çréla Prabhupäda.

SBKC 1: The Bewildered Spirit Soul

1. The Bewildered Spirit Soul

Modern scientists, especially geneticists, have gone so far that it appears as if the destiny of man lies in their hands. They proclaim that in the future they will make human beings according to demand and necessity.1 This sort of scientific revolution started in 1543 with the publication by Copernicus, the Polish astronomer, of the heliocentric theory (i.e., the premise that planets revolve around the sun). E. E. Snyder, in his book History of the Physical Sciences, writes: "Since an understanding of the natural world was possible through science, it was also possible through science that man should be able to alter the world to his own ends and thereby improve his nature. The burden for man's progress, then, was on man, not God. God created the universe so that it obeyed certain natural laws. These laws were discovered by men (scientists); therefore God was not particularly necessary except in a personal sense."2

My concern is to show that God is still as necessary as ever, and that the further advancement of science itself is necessarily dependent on this understanding. We have reached a point in our technological capability where humanity, whose independence is the cornerstone of the scientific edifice, is threatened by its own achievements. Doomsayers abound, but whether the end comes by bomb, pollution, automated loneliness, or whether it comes at all, there can be no doubt that a fundamental error is being committed in thinking that humanity alone has all the answers.

Science—that is, observation and hypothesis—is a basic fact of the mechanics of thought. What is lacking is a purpose, and a larger intellectual setting within which this empirical exercise can take place.

The word "revolution" is appropriate to describe the history of science. It has been most essentially a chronology of attempts to overthrow the authority, not only of the Church, which burned Bruno at the stake, but also of that kind of thinking called a priori, deductive, submissive, or faithful, and that Person to whom such a thinker pays homage—Kåñëa, God. There is no reason to document here the progress of this intoxicating rebellion. What is important is that once it started, no one could stop it.

This booklet is primarily directed to our scientific friends. Instead of centering one's consciousness around temporary machines, one should transfer his consciousness to Çré Kåñëa, the supreme scientist, knowing that He is the central point for all activities. There can be innumerable concentric circles around a common center. Similarly, all scientists, philosophers, businessmen, politicians, etc., can engage in Kåñëa consciousness, keeping Kåñëa in the center of all their activities.

Kåñëa consciousness is defined as "one's eternal relationship with the Supreme Personality of Godhead; the ultimate goal of life, which is to return home, back to Godhead; and the process of returning to the spiritual world."3 Zero, if it stands alone, has no value. However, when a one is put before it, it becomes ten. Similarly, all activities have no value unless Kåñëa is included within these activities. Thus we can understand that the science of Kåñëa is the only real science which is to be learned and practiced.

SBKC 2: Perceiving the Existence of the Supreme Scientist, Lord Çré Kåñëa

2. Perceiving the Existence of the Supreme Scientist, Lord Çré Kåñëa

When we think calmly and carefully about this wonderful universe, we can see that everything is working under the control of a supreme brain. The arrangements in nature are perfectly ordered. Things would be at random without the careful planning of a scientific and engineering brain. It is a common understanding that there is a cause behind each action. A machine cannot run without an operator. Modern scientists are very proud of automation, but there is a scientific brain behind automation also. Even Albert Einstein agreed that there is a perfect brain behind all the natural physical laws. When we talk about "brain" and "operator," these terms imply a person. They cannot be impersonal. One may inquire who this person is. He is Lord Çré Kåñëa, the supreme scientist and supreme engineer, under whose kind will the whole cosmos is working. Çré Kåñëa says: "The whole cosmic order is under Me. By My will it is manifested again and again, and by My will it is annihilated at the end.'' [Bg. 9.8]

Now let us look into a few samples from the Lord's creation, and upon contemplating these exemplary aspects, one should develop a better understanding and appreciation of the existence of the most powerful brain, Lord Çré Kåñëa. The sun that we see daily is the nearest star. It is one hundred earth diameters across and is ninety-three million miles away from the earth. Every day the sun supplies the solar system with a tremendous amount of heat, light and energy. "The very tiny fraction of the sun's energy that falls on the earth-estimated at about five parts in a hundred million million-is about I 00,000 times greater than all the energy used in the world's industries. The total energy the sun emits in a single second would be sufficient to keep a one kilowatt electric fire burning for 10,000 million million years. Put in a different way, the energy the sun emits in one second is greater than the whole amount of energy the human species has consumed throughout its entire history."2 Yet it is only one of the countless number of stars floating in the sky in every direction. With the material scientific brain, the thermal, electrical and nuclear powerhouses have been made. These can supply heat, light and energy to a small, limited extent, but Lord Kåñëa is supplying the whole planet with an unlimited source of energy just from one sun. Kåñëa says: "The splendor of the sun, which dissipates the darkness of this whole world, comes from Me. And the splendor of the moon and the splendor of fire are also from Me." [Bg. 15.12] The planets are revolving in a systematic path around the sun. Even within the smallest atom, the electrons are orbiting around the nucleus in a perfect manner.

Thus, from the submicroscopic realm of the atom to the expanding reaches of the galactic objects, this material universe is running like intricate, well-oiled clockwork according to great natural physical laws and principles. Scientists have gained great acclaim for making a few spaceships, whereas Kåñëa effortlessly produces gigantic spaceships, such as planets and stars, which are perfectly equipped and maintained. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says, gäm äviçya ca bhütäni dhärayämy aham ojäsa: "I enter into each planet, and by My energy they stay in orbit." [Bg. 15.13] The laws made by the supreme brain always remain perfect; they are never violated. We never see the sun rising in the west and setting in the east. The colorful rainbow that we observe when the sun is shining during a shower is only visible when the sun is behind the observer, due to the laws of refraction. Also, each year the seasons change quite periodically, producing symptoms unique to each season.

Now let us look into some aspects of the Lord's creation at the molecular level. Chemists find that the different colors in flowers are due to chemicals called anthocyanins, and the different aromas are mostly due to chemicals called terpenes and terpenoid compounds. The molecular frameworks for these compounds range from very simple structures to very complex networks. Camphor, for example, is a terpenoid compound, and the characteristic odor of lemons is due to the molecule called limonene, which is one of the simple terpenes. Similarly, the characteristic colors in carrots and tomatoes are due to molecules called carotenoids, which are higher forms of terpenes. The molecular framework for each definite color or aroma is wonderfully unique. A little change in position of a few atoms in the molecule, a little variation in the geometry of the molecule or a slight change in the size of the molecule can cause a color to change from orange to red, a mild, pleasing aroma to become repellent and pungent, and a flavor to change from sweet to bitter. On one extreme we find the smallest molecule, the hydrogen molecule, which contains only two atoms of hydrogen. On the other extreme we find giant molecules such as the proteins and nucleic acids (DNA and RNA), the building blocks of all living material bodies, which contain innumerable atoms made for a definite function. Similarly, the crystalline pattern of each different molecule is unique. The geometrical shape for sodium chloride (common salt), for example, is cubical. Charcoal, graphite and diamonds are all derived from the same element, carbon, and yet the shining and transparent diamond is extremely hard, whereas graphite is soft, black and opaque. This is due to the difference in the crystalline forms of these molecules. In the crystal lattice of the diamond, each carbon atom is tetrahedrally surrounded by four other carbon atoms at a distance of 1.54 angstroms (one angstrom = 10<-8> cm.). In graphite, by contrast, the three bonds of each carbon atom are distorted so as to lie in the same plane, the fourth bond being directed perpendicularly to this plane to link with a carbon atom of the neighboring layer.

In this way we can cite innumerable examples of molecular networks so fantastically and delicately arranged that chemists cannot but wonder about the most expert hand and brain who is making all these wonderful artistic arrangements in His laboratory. Indeed, the intelligence and ability of the supreme scientist, Çré Kåñëa, are inconceivable (acintya). There is no scientist who can deny it. How then can any chemist abstain from appreciating the wonderful works of the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa? In Bhagavad-gétä we find: "One should meditate upon the Supreme Person as the one who knows everything, as He who is the oldest, who is the controller, who is smaller than the smallest, who is the maintainer of everything, who is beyond all material conception, who is inconceivable, and who is always a person. He is luminous like the sun and, being transcendental, is beyond this material nature." [Bg. 8.9]

At best, scientists can only try to imitate the wonderful artistic works of the Supreme Lord. They cannot even do this properly, and most of their attempts lead to failure and disappointment. Even when they are partly successful, it is only with the greatest difficulty. For example, Professor R.B. Woodward of Harvard, a Nobel Prize winner in chemistry (1965) and Professor A. Eschenmoser of Zurich took eleven years to synthesize the vitamin B12 molecule. Altogether, ninety-nine scientists from nineteen different countries were involved just to accomplish this one small task.6 Yet Kåñëa is making all these complex molecules at will.

Interestingly enough, when scientists fail again and again in their attempts to make something, they consciously or unconsciously pray to God for help. Does this not indicate the existence of the supreme scientist, Lord Çré Kåñëa, and the natural subordinate position of all other living entities? A crude example is the explosion that occurred inside the Apollo 13 spacecraft during its attempt to land on the moon on April 11, 1970. The Apollo capsule was made by hundreds of scientific and technological brains and cost millions of dollars. No one could predict that there would be an explosion. When it happened, however, and the lives of the three astronauts were in danger, those involved in the mission requested all the people on earth to pray to God for the safe return of the astronauts. Such is the situation. At times of danger, most people tend to remember God, although at other times they forget Him.

Now, let us look into some very simple and graphic examples of the artistry of the Lord's creation. We see that among the lower forms of living entities, social organization is very smoothly maintained. For example, in a bee colony the queen bee is nicely taken care of by the drones (male bees), while the workers collect nectar from flowers all day long. It is quite amazing to consider how the bees, with their tiny bodies, can collect such a great amount of honey for themselves as well as for other living entities. In this way, the colony is maintained with beautiful order. Similarly, the loving relationship between a mother and her baby is quite clearly visible even in very small forms of living entities. During the monsoon season in tropical countries, when there are torrents of rain, the small ants run to find shelter, carrying their eggs on their heads. The spider makes its wonderful webs with great architectural skill to serve as a shelter as well as to catch its prey for survival. Silkworms spin hundreds of yards of fine threads to form cocoons for their shelter during the pupa stage. Inside a tiny seed, smaller than the size of a mustard seed, the whole potency of a big banyan tree is present. In this way, we can see the wonderful arrangements of the Supreme Lord, who is creating, maintaining and guiding all living entities, small or big. Kåñëa says: "Furthermore, O Arjuna, I am the generating seed of all existences. There is no being-moving or unmoving-that can exist without Me." (Bg. 10.39)

The main trouble with material scientists is that they generally neglect the most important and fundamental aspect of their inquiries. For example, when Newton saw the falling of the apple, he asked why and how the apple fell. However, he did not inquire who caused the falling of the apple. As an answer to his inquiry, he discovered the laws of gravitation. His answer was that the apple fell because of the laws of gravitation. But who made the laws of gravitation? Çréla Prabhupäda kindly explains that the apple did not fall while green but while ripe. Therefore Newton's gravitational theory was not enough to explain the falling of the apple. There is some other cause behind the total scene of the falling and, thereby, behind the law of gravitation. That cause is Lord Çré Kåñëa. In Bhagavad-gétä we find, vasudevaù sarvam iti: "Kåñëa is the cause of all causes." (Bg. 7.19) Furthermore, scientists have to know that the little ability they have is also given by the Lord. Kåñëa says, pauruñaà nåñu. "I am the ability in man." (Bg. 7.8)

By various mechanical means (telescopes, etc.), assumptions, empiric theories and conceptual models, cosmologists and astronomers are trying with tremendous vigor to understand what the universe is, what its size is, and the time scale of its creation. At the present time they are speculating that there may be a tenth planet in the solar system, and they are trying to locate it.10 How far they will be successful in finding a real answer to their attempts only time can tell. But the fact is that they will never be able to fully discover the secrets of nature, which is the product of creation of Kåñëa, the supreme scientist. Any thoughtful person can understand how foolish he is even to dream of measuring the size of this universe, since he does not know completely the nature of the sun, the nearest star. Çréla Prabhupäda cites the example of the philosophy of Dr. Frog, who lives in a well of three feet and has no idea how vast the Pacific Ocean is but who speculates that the Pacific Ocean might be five feet wide, ten feet wide, etc., comparing it to his well. The point is that comprehending the unlimited knowledge beyond by our limited means is simply a waste of time and energy. All the knowledge is already there in the authorized scriptures, the Vedas. One simply has to take the knowledge from the supreme authority, Kåñëa.

The details of the creation of this material universe and the living entities like demigods, men and others have been given in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, First Canto, Chapter Three, verses 1-5. The description of the material and spiritual universes is completely given in the Brahma-saàhitä, Fifth Chapter, and from Bhagavad-gétä we get the clear information that the entire material universe is only one fourth of the creative energy of the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa. The other three fourths of the creative energy of the Lord are manifested in the spiritual sky, called the Vaikuëöhaloka.

Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the golden avatära (incarnation) of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Çré Kåñëa, clearly explained to Sanätana Gosvämé, one of the Lord's intimate disciples, about the nature of these universes. The Lord explained that the material universes have a limited length and breadth, whereas no one can measure the length and breadth of all the Vaikuëöha planets. These Vaikuëöha planets are like the petals of a lotus flower, and the principal part of that flower is the center of all the Vaikuëöhas. This part is called Kåñëaloka, or Goloka Våndävana. The Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa, has His original eternal abode on this planet. The other Vaikuëöhas are also inhabited by residents who are full with six opulences-wealth, strength, knowledge, beauty, fame and renunciation-and in each and every Vaikuëöha planet a different expansion of Kåñëa has His eternal abode.11 Material scientists have no information of this vast knowledge.

Certainly, the secrets of the universe cannot be unfolded by the tiny brains of material scientists. We should agree without a doubt that man's vision in all directions is extremely limited by the inadequacies of his senses, his technology and his intellect. None can deny the existence of the supreme scientist, Çré Kåñëa. He is the proprietor and knower of everything. Kåñëa says: "O son of Påthä, know that I am the original seed of all existences, the intelligence of the intelligent, and the prowess of all powerful men (Bg. 7.10) ... O conqueror of wealth [Arjuna], there is no truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread.'' (Bg. 7.7) Only fools would argue about the existence of the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa. In Bhagavad-gétä, Çré Kåñëa says: "Those miscreants who are grossly foolish, lowest among mankind, whose knowledge is stolen by illusion, and who partake of the atheistic nature of demons do not surrender unto Me." (Bg. 7.15)

Therefore, instead of denying and challenging the existence of the supreme scientist, Lord Çré Kåñëa or God, it should be the prime duty of all our scientist friends to appreciate the inconceivable brain of the Lord and His wonderful manifestations everywhere. One may falsely claim the credit for the discovery of radio, television, computers, penicillin, etc. But the fact is that everything was already there because nothing can come out of nothing. If someone claims that anything belongs to him, he is the greatest thief. He is stealing property from the supreme father, Çré Kåñëa, and claiming it to be his. Nothing belongs to us. Everything belongs to Kåñëa. Çré Éçopaniñad says: "Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one must not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong.15

SBKC 3: What is the Difficulty?

3. What is the Difficulty?

The greatest disease in the minds of the scientists is that they do not believe that something is a fact unless it is proved by scientific experiments. When a scientist makes a statement and he supports that statement with scientific experiments, everyone is completely convinced, and no questions are asked. When we talk about the spirit soul to these scientists, their usual response is, "How can one detect the presence of the soul?" Because they have been conditioned to working with machines, they wonder whether the soul can be detected by scientific experiments. However, scientists have to agree that even in their own scientific realm there are many facts that cannot be proved by experiments. The fact is that the soul is there, but in order to understand its existence we have to accept knowledge from the right person, Çré Kåñëa, or God, and His representative in disciplic succession, the spiritual master.

Everyone in the scientific community knows that mathematicians work with an imaginary number called "i," which is the square root of minus one. This number does not figure among the natural numbers (1,2,3, etc.). However, important branches of mathematics-for example, the theory of analytical functions—are based on this imaginary unit. Without the help of this branch of mathematics, various complex theories and problems cannot be solved. Thus the existence of this number cannot be denied; yet there is no experiment to prove it. In a similar manner, scientists in the field of statistical mechanics also utilize various conceptual models-ensembles, for example—to explain their theories and arguments. These are all beyond the realm of experimental science. If scientists are willing to accept these imaginary and conceptual models, what is the difficulty in accepting the perfect knowledge given by Lord Kåñëa, the supreme scientist?

Another scientific theory that is beyond the limit of experimental science is Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. The statement of this principle is that it is impossible to simultaneously determine the position and momentum of any object. In mathematical language, it is stated that the product of the uncertainties in the measured values of the position and momentum (product of mass and velocity) cannot be smaller than Planck's constant. No existing experimental technique can prove this principle. However, scientists all over the world accept this statement as a fact, knowing that the experimental proof is beyond their ability. Similarly, there is no scientific experiment to prove the Third Law of Thermodynamics. This law, as formulated by Planck, states that the entropy of a perfect crystal at absolute zero degrees is equal to zero. Factually, there is no means available for measuring directly the absolute entropies. Therefore the proof of this law is beyond the realm of experimental science.

It is also to be noted that so-called scientific theories are changing constantly. For example, at the beginning of the Nineteenth Century (1808), John Dalton, in developing his atomic theory, stated that atoms could not be further divided. However, toward the end of the Nineteenth Century and the beginning of the Twentieth Century, it was found that Dalton's atomic theory could no longer be considered correct. It was observed that atoms could be further divided into fundamental particles like electrons, protons and neutrons. It was also found that some atoms could emit alpha and beta particles, thereby producing new atoms, and so on. As a matter of fact, the so-called nuclear bombs are a result of these findings. In a similar manner, during the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries Newton's mechanics had a tremendous influence on the minds of scientists, since they could be applied to gross material objects. However, at the beginning of the Twentieth Century, with the discoveries of the fundamental particles, it was realized that Newton's mechanics failed in describing the motions of these particles. Thus quantum mechanics has been developed to explain the phenomena they exhibit. These theories are filled with speculation, and they are also changing. Just as past and present scientific theories are changing, so we can understand that future scientific theories will also change.

This simply shows that the brains of the highly honored material scientists are imperfect, and, as a result, the theories proposed by these brains will always be imperfect. Actually, perfect knowledge cannot be changed. In order to get perfect knowledge, one has to take knowledge from the perfect scientist, Lord Kåñëa, and His bona fide representative, the spiritual master. Kåñëa says: "I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts.'' (Bg. 10.8) Furthermore: "Of all creations I am the beginning and the end and also the middle, O Arjuna. Of all sciences I am the spiritual science of the Self, and among logicians I am the conclusive truth." (Bg. 10.32)

Scientists have to understand that the knowledge and ability they have is extremely limited and in fact quite insignificant. With this insignificant and limited knowledge, how will it be possible to understand knowledge beyond the material context? Actually there is no question about the existence of the soul. The living entities are fragmental spirit souls, whereas Lord Kåñëa is the supreme soul, supreme person and supreme scientist. Kåñëa says: "The living entities in this conditioned world are My eternal, fragmental parts. Due to conditioned life, they are struggling very hard with the six senses, which include the mind." [Bg. 15.7] Also: "It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father." (Bg. 14.4)

Just as the existence of air can be felt by touch and the existence of certain molecules by fragrance and aroma, similarly consciousness is the clear symptom of the existence of the soul. "O son of Bharata, as the sun alone illuminates all this universe, so does the living entity, one within the body, illuminate the entire body by consciousness." (Bg. 13.34) Biologists also confirm that even the smallest microorganisms, such as bacteria, have consciousness. When consciousness enters into a material body. we call it a living body. However, when there is no consciousness in the body-in other words, when the spirit soul leaves the body-simply a lump of matter is left over. This phenomenon we call death. Therefore the spirit soul never dies and is never born. It is eternal. What we call birth and death are nothing but the changing of different material bodies, the replacement of old bodies with new ones. "The living entity in the material world carries his different conceptions of life from one body to another, as the air carries aromas." (Bg. 15.8) Thus birth, death, old age and disease are the signals of the changing of the material body.

When our scientific friends readily accept Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, the imaginary unit and the various conceptual models of statistical mechanics, which are all beyond experimental science, what is the difficulty in accepting the existence of the spirit soul? The supreme scientist Çré Kåñëa says: "For the soul there is never birth nor death. Nor, having once been, does he ever cease to be. He is unborn, eternal, ever-existing, undying and primeval. He is not slain when the body is slain." (Bg. 2.20) Its size has been described thus: "When the upper point of a hair is divided into one hundred parts and again each of such parts is divided into one hundred parts, each such part is the measurement of the dimension of the spirit soul."8

Scientists are familiar with the law of conservation of energy which states that energy can be neither created nor destroyed. The living entities are the superior energy of the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa. Therefore the soul is eternal. "Know that which pervades the entire body is indestructible. No one is able to destroy the imperishable soul." [Bg. 2.17] The nature of the spirit soul is elaborately described in the Second and Thirteenth Chapters of Bhagavad-gétä. One simply has to take the knowledge from the supreme scientist, Çré Kåñëa, the speaker of Bhagavad-gétä.

SBKC 4: The Incomplete and Speculative Knowledge of Darwin's Theory of Evolution

4. The Incomplete and Speculative Knowledge of Darwin's Theory of Evolution

Before Charles Darwin published his theory of evolution in 1859, he frequently corresponded with A.R. Wallace, one of his contemporary naturalists. In one of his letters to A.R. Wallace (December 22, 1857), Darwin wrote, "... I am a firm believer that without speculation there is no good and original observation....'1 Thus, one does not need to make an extensive study in order to understand his theory. His theory was completely based on his own speculation and mental manipulation, based on some data collected during his "Voyage of the Beagle" (1831-1836). Every sensible person knows that speculative knowledge is quite fallible.

How his theory was developed is given in his own words: "When onboard H.M.S. Beagle as naturalist, I was much struck with certain facts in the distribution of the organic beings inhabiting South America, and in the geological relations of the present to the past inhabitants of that continent. These facts ... seemed to throw some light on the origin of species, that mystery of mysteries. On my return home, it occurred to me, in 1837, that something might perhaps be made out on this question by patiently accumulating and reflecting on all sorts of facts which could possibly have any bearing on it. After five years work I allowed myself to speculate on the subject, and drew up some short notes; these I enlarged in 1844 into a sketch of the conclusions, which seemed to me probable: from that period to the present day I have steadily pursued the same object. In considering the Origin of Species, it is quite conceivable that a naturalist might come to the conclusion that species had not been independently created, but had descended, like varieties from other species."2

Darwin has no knowledge about the nature of the spirit soul. He has no clear information as to how the living entity (spirit soul) is transmigrating from one species to another. He does not know whether there is further evolution from the human platform, and he hasn't the slightest idea as to the total number of species through which the cycle of evolution goes on. He also has no infonnation whether the spirit soul can transmigrate from the human platform to lower species of life.

There has been great confusion regarding Darwin's Theory. His critics are very legitimately asking, "If the theory of natural selection of Darwin is correct, why can't we see the intermediate forms of species, the connecting links?" Darwin himself was completely confused in this respect. He could not provide any logical answer except his speculative argumentation. His own answer was that "extinction and natural selection will ... go hand in hand."3 He did not know that all the species of life have been existing since the dawn of creation. "The different species of life are created immediately along with the universe. Men, animals, beasts, birds-everything is simultaneously created, because whatever desires the living entities had at the last annihilation are again manifested."4 As a crude example, the species portrayed in the ancient Egyptian pyramids were the same as those we meet at the present day. Similarly, since time immemorial the peacock, whose colorful feathers so nicely decorate the transcendental head of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Çri Kåñëa, has been the same as the species we find today. With his poor fund of knowledge, Darwin concluded that some species became extinct in the process of evolution. This is completely wrong.

SBKC 5: Complete and Perfect Knowledge of Evolution

5. Complete and Perfect Knowledge of Evolution

Complete and perfect knowledge of evolution in minute detail is available in the Vedic literatures. His Divine Grace Çréla Prabhupäda has kindly supplied the following Vedic quotations:

açétià caturaç caiva lakñäàs täï jéva-jätiñu
bhramadbhiù puruñaiù präpyaà mänuñyaà janma-paryayät
tad apy abhalatäà jätaù teñäm ätmäbhimäninäà
varäkäëäm anäçritya govinda-caraëa-dvayam

"One attains the human form of life after transmigrating through 8,400,000 species of life by the process of gradual evolution. That human form of life is spoiled for those conceited fools who do not take shelter of the lotus feet of Govinda [Kåñëa].''1

jalajä nava-lakñäëi sthävarä lakña-viàçati
kåmayo rudra-saìkhyakäù pakñiëäà daça-lakñaëam
triàçal-lakñäëi paçavaù catur-lakñäëi mänuñäù

"There are 900,000 species of aquatic life; 2,000,000 species of plants and trees; 1,100,000 species of insects; 1,000,000 species of bird life; 3,000,000 species of beasts, and 400,000 species of human life."2 The meaning of "species" understood by biologists is different from the meaning implied here. The meaning used by biologists applies to the gross physical appearance or the gross morphological feature of the living material bodies. The Vedic meaning, however, which is derived after thorough and careful analysis, is based on the level of consciousness of the living being. For example, biologists say that all human beings belong to one species, whereas the Vedic literatures list 400,000 species. In other words, there are 400,000 grades of human beings on different levels of consciousness.

The process of evolution through these 8,400,000 species of life has been going on since time immemorial. As we noted earlier, the spirit soul never dies and is never born; it is eternal. It transmigrates from one body to another. Lord Çré Kåñëa, the supreme knower of everything, says: "As a person puts on new garments, giving up old ones, similarly, the soul accepts new material bodies, giving up the old and useless ones." (Bg. 2.22) In this way the transmigration of the soul is going on.

As we noted from Brahma-vaivarta Puräëa, the most important species of life is the human being. The Vedänta-sütra instructs, athäto brahma-jijïäsä: "Now, therefore, in this human form of life, it is time to inquire about spiritual realization."4 Who am I? What is the real mission of human life? What is the ultimate purpose of our existence? Every intelligent person must ask these questions and should search for the right answers from the right source. So-called modern educators claim that the purpose of education is to solve the problems of life. But in actuality they are teaching their students how to increase sense gratification more and more, thereby creating more and more paths to degradation. "Thus perplexed by various anxieties and bound by a network of illusions [in terms of increased sense gratification], one becomes too strongly attached to sense enjoyment and falls down into hell." [Bg. 16.16] In modern universities and colleges no one teaches the science by which to answer the question "Who am I?" Çréla Prabhupäda kindly points out, "There are so many departments in a university: technological, medical, engineering, etc. But where is the department to know and understand what this life is, what God is, and what our relationship is?"6 The most important department of education, that which teaches the real mission of human life, is completely left out. Scientists claim that modern science is a product of man's curiosity to know. Why aren't they curious to know who we are and what our relationship is with the Supreme Lord, the supreme scientist, Çré Kåñëa? The Vedas give all the answers perfectly.

Lower forms of life such as animals, birds and plants do not suffer from sinful activities because they never violate the laws of nature. A tiger, for instance, does not commit sinful activity by killing its prey because his body is meant to act in that way; it is properly equipped for that purpose. However, when the spirit soul comes to the level of a human being, the living entity is then subject to the results of his actions (karma-phala). From this human platform the living entity has, therefore, a choice. If the spirit soul wants to leave his material body and attain a spiritual body, he can do so from this human platform; otherwise, at the time of death he can transmigrate to one of the 8,400,000 species according to the desires and consciousness he has developed. Lord Kåñëa says: "Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits his body, that state he will attain without fail." (Bg. 8.6) From the human platform the spirit soul can escape the miserable wheel of birth and death by developing Kåñëa consciousness. "And whoever, at the time of death, quits his body, remembering Me alone, at once attains My nature. Of this there is no doubt." [Bg. 8.5] This is evolution from the material platform to the spiritual platform.

Lower forms of life (animals, birds, plants, etc.) are not favorably situated for taking to Kåñëa consciousness because they are not intelligent enough to understand this great science. On the other hand, it is understood from Vedic literature that there are demigods who are more elevated than human beings, but their position is also not favorable for taking to Kåñëa consciousness because they are too materially opulent. Too much material opulence is also a disqualification for taking up Kåñëa consciousness. "In the minds of those who are too attached to sense enjoyment and material opulence, and who are bewildered by such things, the resolute determination of devotional service to the Supreme Lord does not take place." [Bg. 2.44] That is why it is an absolute necessity for all sane human beings to take up Kåñëa consciousness from this human platform, which is the intermediate birth between the demigods and the lower forms of life. Otherwise, the precious human form of life will simply be wasted.

SBKC 6: Çästric (Authoritative Scriptural) Injunctions Are the Supreme Judgement

6. Çästric (Authoritative Scriptural) Injunctions Are the Supreme Judgement

We understand that our knowledge and intelligence are extremely limited. Our brains are tiny, our senses and scientific equipment are imperfect, and our vision is limited. With all these imperfect means, how will it be possible to comprehend the knowledge (science) beyond? Attempting to understand unlimited knowledge by one's own limited means in the name of doing research is simply a waste of valuable time and energy. Çréla Prabhupäda very kindly explains that by the mature research work of Çréla Vyäsadeva, an avatära (incarnation) of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself, Lord Çré Kåñëa, complete and perfect knowledge (science) is available in the Vedic literatures.

The Vedas were originally spoken by the Supreme Lord Himself to Brahmä, the first living being in the material universe, from within his heart. Vedic knowledge is called çruti, indicating that it is learned by aural reception. Therefore the Vedic knowledge has to be received from higher authorities by hearing (çravaëam). In previous ages people were very intelligent. Their memories were extremely sharp. Just by hearing once from a spiritual master, disciples could remember everything. Therefore, there was no necessity for keeping the Vedas in written form during those ages. However, Çréla Vyäsadeva could see beforehand that people in this present age of Kali, the age of quarrel and misunderstanding, situated amidst the disturbing noise of science and technology, would be much less intelligent, possessing extremely short memories. Therefore about 5,000 years ago he compiled the Vedas in written form for the benefit of all inquisitive souls of this present age.

Veda actually means knowledge, and Vedänta means the end of knowledge, which is to know the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Çré Kåñëa. Bhagavad-gétä is the essence of all Vedic knowledge. It was spoken by the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa Himself, to His intimate friend and disciple Arjuna. Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the ripened fruit of all the Vedic literatures. It is the summum bonum of life, Lord Çré Kåñëa personified. It describes the unlimited transcendental qualities of the Lord. Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu explained to Sanätana Gosvämé, "Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the sound representation of the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. So, as Kåñëa is unlimited, similarly, in each word and each letter of Çrémad-Bhägavatam there are unlimited meanings, and one can understand them by the association of devotees.''1 Lord Çré Kåñëa says: "I am situated in everyone's heart, and from Me come remembrance, knowledge and forgetfulness. By all the Vedas am I to be known; indeed I am the compiler of Vedänta, and I am the knower of the Vedas." (Bg. 15.15) Thus the words of the Vedas are the supreme authority.

One may ask, "How may one accept authority?" The answer is given by Çréla Prabhupäda: "The answer of the genuine mother to the question of who is one's father is authoritative." One cannot argue about or object to this point. Similarly, when a child learns that two times two is equal to four from his father and he tells the same thing to a professor of mathematics, the professor has to agree that the child is speaking perfectly. The child may not be perfect, but the knowledge that he is speaking is perfect because he has taken it from an authority. Similarly, all the Vedic knowledge is infallible. For example, it has been mentioned in the Vedas that cow dung is pure whereas other stool is impure, and modern science has found this to be true. It has been scientifically confirmed by chemical analysis that cow dung indeed contains various antiseptic properties.

There are four principal defects inherent in the conditioned soul, namely, imperfect senses, the propensity to cheat, surety of committing mistakes and surety of being illusioned. Therefore, the conditioned soul is completely unfit to make any rules and regulations. The injunctions laid down in the çästras (authoritative scriptures) are above these four defects. Therefore, all the great saints and äcäryas (holy teachers) accept the scriptural injunctions completely, without adulteration. Our position is simply to accept the supreme authority without question. In this way, one can understand the Supreme Lord and supreme scientist, Lord Çré Kåñëa, through authority. One can perceive or detect Him through authority, one can see Him through authority, and one can associate with Him through authority. Similarly, one can also speak through authority, argue and defend through authority, and prove and demonstrate through authority. The supreme authority is the ultimate judgement, and Çré Kåñëa is that supreme authority.

Men who have a poor fund of understanding further ask, "How does one know that Kåñëa is the supreme authority?" Lord Brahmä, the first living being and the engineer who creates all the living entities in the material universe, sings as follows:

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù
anädir ädir govindaù sarva-käraëa-käraëam

"Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is the very form of eternal being, full of knowledge and bliss. He is the primeval Lord Govinda and the cause of all causes." [Bs. 5.1] Çrémad-Bhägavatam says, kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam: "Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself." (1.3.28) Arjuna, the great devotee of the Lord, also says to Lord Kåñëa: "You are the Supreme Brahman, the ultimate, the supreme abode and purifier, the Absolute Truth and the eternal divine person. You are the primal God, transcendental and original, and You are the unborn and all-pervading beauty. All the great sages such as Närada, Asita, Devala, and Vyäsa proclaim this of You, and now You Yourself are declaring it to me." [Bg. 10.12-13] In the same way, all the mahäjanas (great self-realized personalities) like Prahläda Mahäräja, Çukadeva Gosvämé and Bali Mahäräja, the great äcäryas (holy teachers) like Madhväcärya, Rämänujäcärya and Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, all my predecessor gurus (spiritual masters) in disciplic succession and now my spiritual master and eternal father, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, declare the same thing-that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore there should be no tinge of doubt. Our duty is just to follow the kind footsteps of these greatest of saintly personalities. In this way we can understand the science of Kåñëa.

In spite of this, the project to control nature continues. Rather than researching to find out the plan of the Supreme Being, rather than accepting the laws of nature as laws of God, the scientific mentality seeks to put mankind in the place of God in order to improve on nature. But when we inspect these activities closely, we can see that the two admitted goals, knowledge and pleasure, have not been achieved after so many years of trying. The materialists enjoin us to be patient, saying that very shortly the answer will be known and the pleasure will be available for all. To keep us amused in the meantime, there are technological trinkets galore. If it happens that we die waiting, still the scientist does not admit the tragedy, since for him life is only a molecular peculiarity anyway.

Thus the insensitive fritter away the valuable time of human life, time meant for discovering the answer to the most pressing of all questions—"Why am I suffering?" In fact, they won't even admit that they are suffering. Life thus wasted becomes a painful paradox, in which each minute that passes increases the misery, until finally the body collapses in agonized bewilderment.

In a jeep, in the 1940's, several scientists rode through the New Mexico desert. They were tense, trying to resolve the nerve-wracking conflict of fear and dizzy elation in their minds. The Manhattan Project had come to an end, and they were to witness the first explosion of a nuclear device, which was being considered for use as the "ultimate weapon" to win the war. In their bunker, as they confronted the terrifying, spectacular power of the bomb, Dr. Oppenheimer quoted a verse from the Bhagavad-gétä, "Time I am, the destroyer of the worlds...," no doubt fearing that it would take a person as intelligent as God to be able to use atomic energy properly, and that humanity might not be equal to the task. To know that answer for certain, which evidence will be sufficient for us? The sublime words of the Gétä, or the brute force of history?

SBKC 7: Accepting a Bona Fide Spiritual Master

7. Accepting a Bona Fide Spiritual Master

Any sincere soul who is searching for spiritual science must try to seek out a bona fide spiritual master in disciplic succession (paramparä). Lord Çré Kåñëa is the original spiritual master. The Vedic knowledge, as it is, has been handed down from master to disciple, one after another. Even on the mundane platform, if someone wants to learn chemistry, he has to approach a professor of chemistry; how much greater, then, is the need to approach a bona fide spiritual master to attain the supreme spiritual perfection, Kåñëa consciousness. It is absolutely necessary for a sincere soul to approach a bona fide spiritual master and surrender unto the lotus feet of the spiritual master without reservation. Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu instructed Sanätana Gosvämé thus: "The first and foremost thing is that one should accept a bona fide spiritual master. That is the beginning of spiritual life.''1

The symptoms of a bona fide guru (spiritual master) and devotee are described in the Padma Puräëa. "A person who is a qualified brähmaëa, and at the same time qualified with all the symptoms of a devotee, can become the spiritual master of all classes of men, and such a devotee and spiritual master must be respected as God Himself. But a person, even though he may be born of a very respected brähmaëa family, cannot become a bona fide spiritual master if he is not a devotee of the Lord."2 It is further stated: "Whatever he may be, whatever position he may have, if a person is fully conversant with the science of Kåñëa, Kåñëa consciousness, he can become a bona fide spiritual master, initiator, or teacher of the science. In other words, his capability to become a bona fide spiritual master depends on his sufficient knowledge of the science of Kåñëa, Kåñëa consciousness; it does not depend on birth or a particular position in society."3 The qualifications of a bona fide spiritual master are also described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Eleventh Canto, where the sage Prabuddha tells Mahäräja Nimi: "My dear King, please know for certain that in the material world there is no happiness. It is simply a mistake to think that there is happiness here because this place is full of nothing but miserable conditions. Any person who is seriously desirous of achieving real happiness must seek out a bona fide spiritual master and take shelter of him by initiation. The qualification of a spiritual master is that he must have realized the conclusion of the scriptures by deliberation and arguments and thus be able to convince others of these conclusions. Such great personalities who have taken shelter of the Supreme Godhead, leaving aside all material considerations, are to be understood as bona fide spiritual masters. Everyone should try to find such a bona fide spiritual master in order to furfill his mission of life, which is to transfer himself to the place of spiritual bliss."4 The sage further continued: "My dear King, a disciple has to accept the spiritual master not only as spiritual master, but also as the representative of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the Supersoul. In other words, the disciple should accept the spiritual master as God because he is the external manifestation of Kåñëa."5

Indeed, this material world is a vast ocean of sufferings and miseries, and the waves of mäyä (illusion) are constantly kicking the living entities. Therefore, undoubtedly, all human beings urgently need the kind and able guidance of an expert captain to cross this vast ocean of Kali-yuga. If we are in the hands of an expert captain, our position is quite safe. The bona fide spiritual master in disciplic succession is, unquestionably, an expert captain. Our material bodies are the ships, and the words of Kåñëa are the favorable winds. If one takes shelter of such a spiritual master, there is no difficulty in crossing this vast ocean of Kali-yuga. In Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa instructs Arjuna: "Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him. The self-realized soul can impart knowledge unto you because he has seen the truth." (Bg. 4.34) Also in the Vedic literatures we find:

yasya deve parä bhaktir yathä deve tathä gurau
tasyaite kathitä hy arthäù prakaçänte mahätrnanaù

"Only unto those great souls who have implicit faith in both the Lord and the spiritual master are all the imports of Vedic knowledge automatically revealed."7

Therefore, we simply have to depend on the kind and causeless mercy of the spiritual master and the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Çré Kåñëa. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu says: "By the mercy of Kåñëa one gets a spiritual master, and by the mercy of the spiritual master one gets Kåñëa." In Bhagavad-gétä it is stated: "The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart, O Arjuna, and is directing the wanderings of all living entities, who are seated as on a machine, made of the material energy." (Bg. 18.61) When the Supreme Lord within the heart sees the sincerity of the conditioned soul, He mercifully gives all opportunities for the deliverance of the fallen soul. "Out of compassion for them, I, dwelling in their hearts, destroy with the shining lamp of knowledge the darkness born of ignorance [Bg. 10.11] ... When one is enlightened with the knowledge by which nescience is destroyed, then his knowledge reveals everything, as the sun lights up everything in the daytime.'' [Bg. 5.16]

It is an unquestionable fact that neither doctors, nor social and political leaders, nor philanthropists can solve the basic problems of life, namely, birth, death, old age and disease. At any moment the material body will be finished. Everyone, therefore, should prepare for inevitable death. But without the background of the transcendental science, Kåñëa consciousness, and without the merciful guidance of the expert spiritual master, how can one prepare for impending death? Parékñit Mahäräja, a great king and devotee of the Lord, had seven days' time to prepare for death, but we do not even know for sure whether we have seven minutes to prepare for death. King Parékñit spent those days exclusively hearing the great sage Çukadeva Gosvämé speak the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, which describes the transcendental qualities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Çré Kåñëa. In this way, he perfected his life. Material scientists and philosophers cannot give transcendental knowledge to their students. They have no qualifications to do so. However, a bona fide spiritual master who is one hundred percent Kåñëa conscious can impart complete transcendental knowledge, the science of Kåñëa, to his disciples, and thus he can solve all their problems in life.

Lord Çré Kåñëa is the Supreme Absolute Truth. "The Absolute Truth must descend from the absolute platform. It is not to be understood by the ascending process.''11 One cannot, therefore, approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Çré Kåñëa, directly. In the Ädi Puräëa, Lord Kåñëa addresses Arjuna: "My dear Pärtha, one who claims to be My devotee is not so. Only a person who claims to be the devotee of My devotee is actually My devotee.''12 Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu also says: "I am not a brähmaëa [teacher], I am not a kñatriya [administrator], I am not a gåhastha [householder] and I am not a vänaprastha [retired man]. I do not belong to any of the eight varëäçramas [occupational and spiritual divisions of society]. I am the servant of the servant of the servant of the servant-one hundred times the servant-of the maintainer of the gopés, Kåñëa." This is the perfect example given by the perfect master, Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya Himself.

The spiritual master is, therefore, the transparent via medium through which to approach the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa. Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura, a great äcärya (holy teacher), kindly gives us the following sublime instructions in his famous prayers for the glorification of the spiritual master:

yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädo yasyäprasädän na gatiù kuto 'pi
dhyäyan stuvaàs tasya yaças tri-sandhyaà vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

"If one satisfies the spiritual master, the Supreme Personality of Godhead becomes satisfied. If one does not satisfy the spiritual master, there is no chance of one's being promoted to the plane of Kåñëa consciousness. I should therefore meditate upon him, pray for his mercy three times a day, and offer my respectful obeisances unto him, my spiritual master." [Gurv-añöaka 8]

This is the great Vaiñëava (Kåñëa conscious) tradition. The duty of the disciple is to always think and act to satisfy the spiritual master in all circumstances. Therefore, one should execute the orders of the spiritual master one hundred per cent, without any tinge of personal motivation.

SBKC 8: Conclusion

8. Conclusion

In a transcendental discourse between Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu and Çré Rämänanda Räya, one of the greatest devotees of the Lord, the Lord inquired from Rämänanda Räya: "What is the highest standard of education?" Rämänanda immediately replied that the highest standard of education is to know the science of Kåñëa. Çrémad-Bhägavatam says that Väsudeva (another name of Lord Çré Kåñëa or God) is the ultimate object of knowledge:

väsudeva-parä vedä väsudeva-parä makhäù
väsudeva-parä yogä väsudeva-paräù kriyäù
väsudeva-paraà jïänaà väsudeva-paraà tapaù
väsudeva-paro dharmo väsudeva-parä gatiù

"In the revealed scriptures, the ultimate object of knowledge is Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead. The purpose of performing sacrifice is to please Him. Yoga is for realizing Him. All fruitive activities are ultimately rewarded by Him only. He is supreme knowledge, and all severe austerities are performed to know Him. Religion [dharma] is rendering loving service unto Him. He is the supreme goal of life." [Bhäg. 1.2.28-29]

The process of realizing Him is to render unalloyed devotional service (bhakti) unto the lotus feet of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Çré Kåñëa, and His bona fide representative, the spiritual master in disciplic succession. Lord Çré Kåñëa declared to Arjuna: "My dear Arjuna, only by undivided devotional service can I be understood as I am, standing before you, and can thus be seen directly. Only in this way can you enter into the mysteries of My understanding." [Bg. 11.54]

The conditioned living entities should perform yajïas (sacrifices) for the satisfaction of Viñëu (Kåñëa). Viñëu is also called Yajïeçvara, the Lord of all sacrifices. In Bhagavad-gétä the all-merciful Çré Kåñëa says to Arjuna: "O best of the Kuru dynasty, without sacrifice one can never live happily on this planet or in this life; what then of the next?" [Bg. 4.31] Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the mercy incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead Lord Çré Kåñëa, introduced the saìkértana-yajïa (the chanting and glorification of the names of God) 500 years ago for the deliverance of alI men in this age of Kali. The Lord's incarnation is mentioned in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam as follows:

kåñëa-varëaà tviñäkåñëaà säìgopäìgästra-pärñadam
yajïaiù saìkértana-präyair yajanti hi su-medhasaù

"In this age of Kali, people who are endowed with sufficient intelligence will worship the Lord, who is accompanied by His associates, by performance of saìkértana-yajïa." (Bhäg. 11.5.32) Çréla Prabhupäda states: "Kértana means Hari-kértana, glorification of Hari, Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and no other kértana is recommended."6 It is also stated in the Båhan-näradéya Puräëa:

harer näma harer näma harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva nästy eva gatir anyathä

"In this age of Kali, the only means of deliverance is chanting the holy name of Lord Hari, Kåñna. There is no other way. There is no other way. There is no other way."7 This process of Hari-kértana is to chant the mahä-mantra (the great chanting for deliverance): Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. In the Padma Puräëa it is stated: "There is no difference between the holy name of the Lord and the Lord Himself. As such, the holy name is as perfect as the Lord Himself in fullness, purity and eternity. The holy name is not a material sound vibration, nor has it any material contamination."8 How the holy name of the Lord can be chanted constantly is mercifully described by Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself in His Çikñäñöaka: "One can chant the holy name of the Lord in a humble state of mind, thinking himself lower than the straw in the street; one should be more tolerant than a tree, devoid of all sense of falseprestige, and should be ready to offer all respects to others. In such a state of mind one can chant the holy name of the Lord constantly."9

We therefore humbly request everyone-scientists, philosophers, businessmen, politicians, etc.-to please chant the rnahä-mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. This will cleanse the accumulated dust from the heart and lead to the understanding of Kåñëa consciousness, the supreme absolute science, the ultimate goal of life.

SBKC: About the Author

About the Author

Svarüpa Dämodara däsa Brahmacäré was born in a Vaiñëava (devoted) family in Manipur, India, on February 25, 1941. His father, Jogendra Singh, died when he was a mere child. In 1961 he earned his B.S. degree, with highest honors in Chemistry from Gauhati University, and he earned his master's degree in Chemical Engineering and Chemical Technology with similar honors from Calcutta University in 1964. He was a recipient of a Research Fellowship from the University Grants Commission (1964-1966).

Allured by material advancement, he came to the United States of America and joined the Department of Chemistry, Canisius College, Buffalo, New York, in 1967 and obtained an M.S. degree in Chemistry in 1969. Then he joined the Department of Chemistry, University of California, Irvine, where he is finished his Ph.D. in Physical Organic Chemistry in June of 1974. Now he is working as a Post-Doctoral Research Associate at Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia.

"Early in 1970," he relates, "I got a cablegram from Manipur saying 'Your mother expired, March 24, 1970; saradha April 6, 1970.' From that very moment, my outlook about life became quite changed. I was very much occupied with thoughts of the extremely temporary nature, filled with sufferings and miseries, of this material world. One evening in June, 1970, Dr. Rao, later Rämänanda Prabhu, and I went to Laguna Beach and saw four or five disciples of His Divine Grace Çréla Prabhupäda doing saìkértana [chanting] along the street. I was extremely surprised to see this in the United States. We were watching and following them from a distance, and we wanted to know what they were doing. Soon, one of the devotees stopped by and gave us a card inviting us to come for a Sunday love feast. On that day, I bought a small book entitled Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure, by Çréla Prabhupäda. A few days later, under Dr. Rao's strong influence, I went with him to see Çréla Prabhupäda in Los Angeles. This was toward the end of June 1970, when Dr. Rao was initiated.

"When I saw the devotees in the Los Angeles Temple, I suddenly felt that I should be living like them. I vividly remember the beautiful loving exchange of flowers between His Divine Grace and the disciples early in the morning in front of the temple. I was quite amazed to see the beautiful Çré Çré Rädhä Kåñëa Temple in Los Angeles for the first time. Later on after his initiation ceremony, Rämänanda Prabhu took me upstairs to see Çréla Prabhupäda. When we went upstairs, I received the most affectionate and compassionate glance from Çréla Prabhupäda, and immediately I felt: 'Here is my spiritual father.' Çréla Prabhupäda asked me some kind questions, and I replied with my broken Bengali sentences. I was extremely glad that I had come to see Çréla Prabhupäda. I was formally initiated in the Çré Çré Rädhä Kåñëa Temple, Los Angeles, on June 30, 1971."

SBKC: International Society for Krishna Consciousness

International Society for Krishna Consciousness

In early September of 1965, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda arrived on the shores of America. His mission was to introduce the sublime science of Kåñëa consciousness to the Western world. By translating and explaining the essence of the Vedic literatures, which are vastly elaborate scriptures of advanced spiritual knowledge, he has made available to everyone a clear understanding of true spiritual life.

In 1966, Çréla Prabhupäda founded the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) to spread this culture of Kåñëa consciousness throughout the modern world. With over eighty centers on five continents, ISKCON is practicing and freely distributing the joyful, authorized process most recommended for God-realization in this age-the chanting of the mahä-mantra, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Furthermore, books such as Bhagavad-gétä As It Is and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, printed and distributed in over ten languages, establish this sublime and practical science on a strong intellectual basis.

The following is a sampling of letters ISKCON has received from people around the world who have appreciated the teachings of Kåñëa consciousness.

Dear Sir,

I am a prisoner at the Royal Gaol, Frederick St., Port of Spain, Trinidad. Being in this condition of life, undergoing wrongful prosecution, I had given up all hopes. Reading Bhagavad-gétä As It Is and learning from it that our true identity is spirit soul, a part and parcel of that Supreme Lord Krishna, everyone having equal rights to obtain the Lord's greatest gift, has given me great courage to be most firm and steadfast in my duty towards my Blessed Lord. As a lover of reading God's word, I have never read a doctrine like Bhagavad-gétä As It Is. It is a transparent literature in which every verse is based on spiritual import, which is the main purpose of the scripture. It contains divine words and expression which would hardly be found in other doctrines, and whatever is found in other doctrines will be found in this.

I find great benefit by chanting the Hare Krishna, Hare Räma mantra. In this condition I can experience peace of mind, just by chanting, praying and thinking of the Blessed Lord. There is no one dearer to Him than those who absorb the nectar of His divine teaching and explain it to His devotees. With these words I pray, may the Blessed Lord strengthen you and the Krishna movement in body and soul and protect, guide and lead you all on paths of safety. Best happiness to eternity, and long life and best service in the name of the Blessed Lord Krishna.

Jai Çré Rädhä Kåñëa.

Yours truly,

Kissoon Ramnanan

Hare Kåñëa. All glories to Çré Kåñëa, to His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda and to the devotees of the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

Thank you for the wonderful books, filled with spiritual nectar, which are continually filling me with encouragement and truth.

I am an elementary school teacher, teaching nine-and ten-year-old children in the public schools on St. Thomas. I dedicate each day of teaching to the spiritual Master and Lord Kåñëa. My job is very difficult and tiring. At times I feel discouraged by the fact that I am too weak to remain steady in Kåñëa consciousness while at work (not to speak of at home). Yet I feel that my best service to the Lord is to strive for pure devotion in my teaching duties.

I have found it easy to give up my practice of flesh-eating, marijuana smoking, and use of intoxicants. But my mind often seems uncontrollable. I would like to see His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda and offer my humble obeisances to him, and I would like to be initiated into the Society, although I know I am too unworthy. Please explain to me what is required and involved in initiation into the Society.

The summer is approaching, and I may be returning to the States. Would it be possible to meet with you, other devotees, and the Spiritual Master? How can I serve Lord Kåñëa and His Divine Grace Swami Prabhupäda in the best way? Thank you for your help. My respects to you.

Sincerely,

Gary Dallmann

St. Thomas, Virgin Islands

Dear Friends,

I recently found a book Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, (Complete Edition) by A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, at the public library, and I checked it out. I had formerly read portions of the abridged Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, and I have to admit that it was the pictures that finally urged me to take the Complete Edition.

I have often felt that I must study the Gétä, and Swami Prabhupäda's seems to be, as stated on the jacket, "The definitive English edition."

I love the way it is presented. The Sanskrit is like a beautiful painting to me; the English transliterations are like a holy chant; the word-for-word Sanskrit-English equivalents help me become familiar with the language. The translation, of course, speaks for itself; and the purport builds around it.

And now, at last, I may study it and I have been shown a wonderful, beautiful version to use.

Patricia Langlois

Lombard, Illinois

Dear Sir,

Through an unusual combination of circumstances, there recently came into my possession a copy of the book Bhagavad-gétä As It Is. Although I am so far only up to Chapter 4, the idea of Krishna consciousness has taken possession of my thinking.

I would appreciate it if you would let me know how one can learn further about this matter. Note: I am age 50 and am not looking for anything complicated, but somehow I feel that this is not complicated.

Hoping to hear from you.

Sincerely yours,

Raymond C. Hill

Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada

Sir,

I must admit to feeling a bit uncomfortable in writing this letter.

A couple of weeks ago, devotees of Kåñëa (from Denver, I understand) were here at the University of Arkansas distributing literature. One young man approached me, with a "hard pitch" for my purchasing a copy of the Prabhupäda translation of the Bhagavad-gétä; I was initially quite skeptical (so many people are getting rich from selling their versions of "the answer") and told him not to bother me. He insisted, though, and I finally gave in.

I have been reading the Gétä, having not finished it yet, and have found it quite rewarding; my mind, shaped in logic and empiricism, seems to find itself barely tasting the transcendental material in the book. I discuss it with others; I find myself remembering certain passages which seem to shed some light (almost literally) on coincidental "everyday" occurrences.

It has genuinely stimulated my interest, to say the least, in a way that my readings in Christianity, Zen Buddhism, the "lower" forms of yoga, etc., have never succeeded in doing.

In short, I think I have finally found the beginning.

With best wishes,

Bob Ripley,

Fayetteville, Arkansas

I am 20 years old, living in Stockholm, Sweden, and very much interested in religion. Recently I read Bhagavad-gétä As It Is (the complete edition) by Swami Bhaktivedanta. I personally think it is a most glorious book. The idea about Kåñëa as the Supreme Godhead is invincible.

I am very interested in ISKCON. Is it perhaps possible for me to become a member there? Would you please send me some information about your movement?

Yours very truly,

Anders Franzen

Stockholm, Sweden

Last year in June, I came for the first time in contact with your movement. I provided myself with some of your books because I was interested in your bhakti-yoga system. Especially the book Éçopaniñad struck me very much because of the deep and elaborate devotional purports and the very special translation. I think that the Swami must be a very devoted and educated man, one of the rare true servants of God.

With kindest regards,

V.A. van Bylert

Holland

[Back cover copy]:

A Scientist Should Know His Own Limitations...And Go Beyond Them

This book is the work of a scientist, Svarüpa Dämodara däsa, who is a disciple of the founder and spiritual master of the Hare Kåñëa movement, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. Although the gifts of modern science are not to be denied, Çréla Prabhupäda teaches, a scientist must recognize his won shortcomings, like Newton, who compared himself to a mere boy playing by the shore of a great undiscovered ocean of truth. The Scientific Basis of Kåñëa Consciousness directs scientific inquiry toward the truths that can be known not by the missile or the microscope, but only by the instrument of purified consciousness-the spiritual science of bhakti-yoga.

Teachings of Lord Kapila, the Son of Devahüti

TLK Into

TEACHINGS OF LORD KAPILA

WHEREAS philosophy in the West germinates, most often, in the soil of intellectual curiosity and is highly theoretical, being concerned with "knowledge for its own sake," philosophy in the ancient Vedic tradition of India is very pointedly directed toward the avowedly practical goal of human liberation. The conviction that human life is specifically meant for discovering and applying the proper means for the liberation of the self from matter is the sine qua non of India's traditional spiritual thought and culture.

This book is based on a unique series of lectures on the teachings of Kapila Muni (Kapiladeva), presented in Bombay, India, in the spring of 1974, by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. Kapila Muni, a renowned sage of antiquity, is the author of the Säìkhya philosophical system. Säìkhya, which forms an important part of India's ancient philosophical heritage, is both a system of metaphysics and a system of spiritual knowledge culminating in liberation. Kapila, however, is not an ordinary philosopher or sage. According to Vedic tradition, He is an avatära (incarnation) of the Supreme Absolute Truth, Lord Çré Kåñëa.

Lord Kapila descended as the son of Kardama Muni and his wife, Devahüti, both of whom were great yogis and saints. After Kardama Muni renounced the world and went to the forest to attain spiritual perfection, Devahüti, aware of the divinity of her son, approached Kapila and implored Him to endow her with spiritual enlightenment. Pleased by His mother's sincere desire for transcendental knowledge, Kapila spoke Säìkhya philosophy, the philosophy which leads one to discriminate between matter and spirit and which culminates in the ultimate liberation called bhakti, divine love.

In this book, the author gives a brilliant exposition on the basic teachings of Kapila and thus illuminates a major element in traditional Indian spirituality. Topics discussed include the significance of the guru, the psychology of consciousness, the characteristics of a self realized person, the science of meditation, the nature of transcendental knowledge, and the process of ultimate liberation.

Through his voluminous writings, which constitute a veritable library of Vedic philosophy, religion, literature and culture, Çréla Prabhupäda has distinguished himself as the greatest contemporary teacher of Vedic philosophy and religion. This volume represents another valuable contribution by Çréla Prabhupäda to our increasing understanding of the profound and universal principles of Vedic wisdom.

First Printing, 1977: 50,000 copies

© 1977 Bhaktivedanta Book Trust
All Rights Reserved
Printed in the United States of America

Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data

Puranas. Bhagavatapurana. English. Selections.
Teachings of Lord Kapiladeva.

Bibliography: p.
Includes index.
I. Bhaktivedanta Swami, A. C., 1986-
II. Title.
BLll35.P7A22 1977294.5'925 77-11077
ISBN 0-89213-008-3

TLK Foreword

Foreword

Kapila Muni, a renowned sage of antiquity, is the author of the philosophical system known as Säìkhya, which forms an important part of India's ancient philosophical heritage. Säìkhya is both a system of metaphysics, dealing with the elemental principles of the physical universe, and a system of spiritual knowledge, with its own methodology, culminating in full consciousness of the Supreme Absolute. Kapila, however, is not an ordinary philosopher or sage. According to Vedic tradition, the tradition of India's ancient scriptural literature, He Himself is an avatära (incarnation) of the Supreme Absolute Truth.

Kapila's teachings are originally inscribed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, or Bhägavata Puräëa, one of the most important scriptural documents of Vedic theism. Within the Bhägavatam, Kapila's teachings comprise Chapters Twenty-five through Thirty-three of the Third Canto. This book, Teachings of Lord Kapila, the Son of Devahüti, is based on a unique series of lectures presented in Bombay, India, in the spring of this series, Çréla Prabhupäda spoke from the Twenty-fifth Chapter, which contains the beginning of Lord Kapila's teachings. Çréla Prabhupäda is the author of a celebrated multivolume translation and commentary on the entire text of the Bhägavatam, and at the time of the Kapila lectures he had already completed his written commentary on the section of the Bhägavatam dealing with Kapiladeva's teachings. In these special lectures, however, Çréla Prabhupäda went into significantly greater detail in elucidating the verses and shed an even broader light upon these fascinating teachings.

The text begins with the words of Çaunaka, the foremost of the sages of Naimiñäraëya, the vastly learned sages to whom Çrémad-Bhägavatam was originally spoken some thousands of years ago. The sages have already heard about Lord Kapiladeva from Süta Gosvämé, an exalted spiritual master, and it is clear from Çaunaka's words that they accept Kapila Muni as being an incarnation of the Lord Himself and as therefore being the highest authority on yoga and transcendental knowledge. In recounting the history of Lord Kapila, Süta Gosvämé, in accordance with Vedic principles for presenting spiritual knowledge, refers to discourse by great spiritual masters who have previously discussed this same subject. In this case, Süta Gosvämé refers to a discussion between Vidura and the great sage Maitreya, who was a friend of Vyäsadeva, the original compiler of the Vedic literature.

As Süta Gosvämé has already described, Lord Kapila appeared in this world as the son of Kardama Muni, a master of mystic yoga, and his wife, Devahüti. Both Kardama Muni and Devahüti were aware of the divinity of their son. Indeed, even before Kapila's birth, Lord Brahmä himself, the chief created person in this universe, had appeared before Devahüti and revealed to her that her son was to be an incarnation of the Supreme Lord and that this incarnation would enlighten her with spiritual knowledge.

According to the Vedic social system, a man with a grown son may accept the order of sannyäsa, thus renouncing all connections with his family and worldly life, and entrust his wife to the care of his son. Kardama Muni, of course, knew that his son was an incarnation of the Supreme Lord, yet to honor this Vedic system and emphasize its importance, he too eventually accepted sannyäsa, entrusting his wife, Devahüti, to the care of his divine son, Kapiladeva. Therefore, as Süta Gosvämé begins to answer Çaunaka's request to hear further about Lord Kapiladeva, the sages have already been informed of how Kardama Muni departed for the forest, leaving Kapiladeva behind with Devahüti.

After Kardama Muni's departure, Devahüti, remembering the prophetic words of Lord Brahmä, approaches her divine son and humbly expresses her desire for spiritual enlightenment: "My Lord, I have fallen into the abyss of ignorance. Your Lordship is my only means of getting out of this darkest region of ignorance because You are my transcendental eye, which, by Your mercy only, I have attained after many, many births.... Now be pleased, my Lord, to dispel my great delusion... You are the ax which can cut the tree of material existence. I therefore offer my obeisances to You, who are the greatest of all transcendentalists, and I inquire from You as to the relationship between man and woman and between spirit and matter." (Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.7-11) Pleased by His mother's pure desire for spiritual enlightenment, and feeling great compassion for her, Kapila begins to speak on the Säìkhya philosophy.

Now, what is Säìkhya? Insofar as Säìkhya deals with the elemental categories or principles of the physical universe, Säìkhya is what Western scholars generally refer to as "metaphysics." The term säìkhya literally means "to count." This name is used because Säìkhya philosophy enumerates principles of cosmic evolution by rational analysis. The etymological meaning of the word säìkhya is "that which explains very lucidly by analysis of material elements." Philosophically, this term is used because the Säìkhya system expounds analytical knowledge that enables one to distinguish between matter and spirit. This understanding culminates in bhakti, devotion for and service to the Supreme. It may be said, therefore, that Säìkhya and bhakti form two aspects of the same process, bhakti being the ultimate goal or ultimate aspect of Säìkhya.

It is interesting to note, at this point, that long after Lord Kapila's descent, an imitation Kapila appeared on the Indian subcontinent and propounded a nontheistic Säìkhya. That which is generally studied as Säìkhya in the contemporary academic context is actually this later, nontheistic, materialistic Säìkhya. The Säìkhya philosophy, propounded by the original Kapila, is practically unknown in the West. Teachings of Lord Kapila, the Son of Devahüti (along with Çréla Prabhupäda's complete commentary on Kapila's Säìkhya in his edition of Çrémad-Bhägavatam) is probably the first major exposition in the English language on the original, theistic Säìkhya. It should therefore be of considerable interest to scholars in this field.

Because the basic principle and the ultimate goal of Lord Kapiladeva's Säìkhya philosophy is bhakti, this is the subject with which Lord Kapiladeva begins His instructions to Devahüti. Consequently, because this volume, Teachings of Lord Kapila, the Son of Devahüti, is Çréla Prabhupäda's commentary on the beginning of Lord Kapila's teachings, it is chiefly concerned with the science of bhakti-yoga—the process of linking with God (yoga means "linking") through bhakti (devotion).

As the actual history begins, Devahüti approaches her son, Kapila, and with deep humility expresses her sincere desire for spiritual enlightenment. In response, Lord Kapila delineates "the path of the transcendentalists, who are interested in self-realization." Concisely summarizing the actual process of self-realization, Kapila defines consciousness in both the conditioned and liberated states. He describes the psychology of pure consciousness, delineates the symptoms and characteristics of a sädhu, holy person, and stresses the importance of sädhu-saìga, association with those who are saintly. Kapiladeva then explains that liberation is merely a stage preliminary to the attainment of bhakti and that one who attains bhakti automatically achieves liberation. One who engages in bhakti, devotional yoga, automatically transcends material desires and ultimately crosses beyond birth and death.

According to later descriptions in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Devahüti ultimately attains full enlightenment in transcendental knowledge by hearing and understanding the sublime philosophical teachings of her great son.

—The Publishers

TLK 1: The Purpose of Lord Kapila's Advent

CHAPTER ONE
The Purpose of Lord Kapila's Advent

TLK Vs 1

TEXT 1

çaunaka uväca
kapilas tattva-saìkhyätä
bhagavän ätma-mäyayä
jätaù svayam ajaù säkñäd
ätma-prajïaptaye nåëäm

TRANSLATION

Çré Çaunaka said: Although He is unborn, the Supreme Personality of Godhead took birth as Kapila Muni by His internal potency. He descended to disseminate transcendental knowledge for the benefit of the whole human race.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.1]

PURPORT

The word ätma-prajïaptaye indicates that the Lord descends for the benefit of the human race to give transcendental knowledge. Material necessities are quite sufficiently provided for in the knowledge given in the Vedic literatures, which offer a program for good living and gradual elevation to the platform of sattva-guëa, the mode of goodness. Once one is situated in sattva-guëa, one's knowledge expands. On the platform of passion there is no knowledge, for passion is an impetus to enjoy material benefits. On the platform of ignorance there is neither knowledge nor enjoyment but simply animalistic living.

The Vedas are intended to elevate one from the mode of ignorance to the platform of goodness. When one is situated in the mode of goodness, he is able to understand knowledge of the self, or transcendental knowledge. Such knowledge cannot be appreciated by any ordinary man; therefore a disciplic succession is required. This knowledge is expounded either by the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself or by His bona fide devotee. Çaunaka Muni also states here that Kapila, the incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, took birth or appeared simply to disseminate transcendental knowledge. To understand that one is not matter but spirit soul (ahaà brahmäsmi: "I am by nature Brahman") is not sufficient for understanding the self and his activities. One must be situated in the activities of Brahman. Knowledge of those activities is explained by the Supreme Personality of Godhead Himself. Such transcendental knowledge can be appreciated in human society but not in animal society, as clearly indicated here by the word nåëäm, "for the human beings." Human beings are meant to lead a regulated life. By nature, there is regulation in animal life also, but that is not like the regulative life described in the scriptures or by the Vedic authorities. Only when one's life is regulated according to the Vedas can one understand transcendental knowledge.

For the propagation of this transcendental knowledge, Kapiladeva, the incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, gave instructions in Säìkhya philosophy to His mother, Devahüti. Later, another Kapiladeva appeared who expounded atheistic Säìkhya philosophy, which dealt with the twenty-four elements but gave no information about God. The original Kapila is called the Devahüti-putra Kapila, and the other is called the atheist Kapila. Concerning Kapiladeva, Çaunaka Åñi says, kapilas tattva-saìkhyätä. Kapila is the Supreme Person; therefore He can explain the Absolute Truth. Actually only Bhagavän can know the true position of the ultimate truth. No one else can know it. Bhagavän, Kåñëa or His incarnation, occasionally visits the earth to give humanity information about the aim of life. Thus the Supreme Lord descended as Kapiladeva, tattva-saìkhyätä. The word saìkhyätä means "expounder," and tattva means "the Absolute Truth." The Absolute Truth is Bhagavän Çré Kåñëa Himself. We cannot understand the Absolute Truth or the Supreme Person by mental speculation, especially when we are under the influence of the three modes of material nature (sattva-guëa, rajo-guëa and tamo-guëa). Only those who are situated in sattva-guëa (the mode of goodness) are fit to understand the Absolute Truth. According to Bhagavad-gétä (18.42), those possessing brahminical qualifications are situated in sattva-guëa.

çamo damas tapaù çaucaà
kñäntir ärjavam eva ca
jïänaà vijïänam ästikyaà
brahma-karma svabhäva jam

"Peacefulness, self-control, austerity, purity, tolerance, honesty, wisdom, knowledge and righteousness—these are the qualities by which the brähmaëas work."

According to the Vedic conception, there must be men in society who are factually brähmaëas, capable of expounding the real truth. If everyone becomes a çüdra, the Absolute Truth cannot be understood. It is said that at the present moment in Kali-yuga everyone is a çüdra (kalau çüdra-sambhaväù), and it is very difficult in this age to find qualified brähmaëas, for they are very rare. There is practically not a single qualified brähmaëa in this age.

präyeëälpäyuñaù sabhya
kaläv asmin yuge janäù
mandäù sumanda-matayo
manda-bhägyä hy upadrutäù

"O learned one, in this iron age of Kali men have but short lives. They are quarrelsome, lazy, misguided, unlucky and, above all, always disturbed." (Bhäg. 1.1.10) The people in this age are very short-lived and slow in understanding spiritual life. Actually human life is meant for understanding spiritual values, but because everyone in this age is a çüdra, no one is interested. People have forgotten life's real purpose. The word manda means both slow and bad, and everyone in this age is either bad or slow or a combination of both. People are unfortunate and disturbed by so many things. According to Çrémad-Bhägavatam there will eventually be no rain and consequently a scarcity of food. The governments will also levy very heavy taxes. The characteristics of this age predicted by Çrémad-Bhägavatam are already being experienced to some degree. Since Kali-yuga is a very miserable age, Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who is Çré Kåñëa Himself, advises everyone simply to chant Hare Kåñëa.

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nasty eva gatir anyathä

"In this age of Kali there is no alternative, there is no alternative, there is no alternative for spiritual progress than the holy name, the holy name, the holy name of the Lord." (Båhan-näradéya Puräëa) This process is not Caitanya Mahäprabhu's invention, but is advised by the çästras, the puräëas. The process for this Kali-yuga is very simple. One need only chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. Since everyone in this age is an unintelligent, unfortunate and disturbed çüdra, how can anyone understand the Absolute Truth or the aim of life? As stated by the Lord Himself in Bhagavad-gétä (4.7):

yadä yadä hi dharmasya
glänir bhavati bhärata
abhyutthänam adharmasya
tadätmänaà såjämy aham

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time I descend Myself."

Some hundreds and thousands of years ago Lord Kåñëa appeared as Devahüti-putra Kapiladeva. His father's name was Kardama Muni. After Kapiladeva grew up, His father, according to the Vedic system, retired, took sannyäsa and left home to cultivate spiritual life. It is not that one should rot in this material world throughout one's whole life. Païcäçordhvaà vanaà vrajet. According to the Vedic injunctions, there are four äçramas and four varëas, and these used to be followed very strictly. After his son grew up, Kardama Muni, being a strict follower of the Vedas, left home and put his wife in the charge of his grown son, Kapiladeva.

It is said of Kapiladeva: kapilas tattva-saìkhyätä bhagavän. Lord Kapila is Bhagavän. Nowadays Bhagavän is taken very cheaply because the word is misused, but actually Bhagavän is not an ordinary man. Avajänanti mäà müòhäù: because Bhagavän Çré Kåñëa appeared as a human being, fools and rascals (müòhas) consider Kåñëa an ordinary human. As Kåñëa Himself states in Bhagavad-gétä (7.13):

tribhir guëamayair bhävair
ebhiù sarvam idaà jagat
mohitaà näbhijänäti
mäm ebhyaù param avyayaà

"Deluded by the three modes (goodness, passion and ignorance), the whole world does not know Me, who am above the modes and inexhaustible."

Yet there are mahätmäs, great souls, who can understand Kåñëa. Arjuna could understand that although Kåñëa was playing the part of his friend, He was nonetheless the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Arjuna was in perfect knowledge, yet Kåñëa instructed him for our benefit. Arjuna requested Kåñëa's instructions, which are set forth for all human society. After hearing Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna addressed Kåñëa as paraà brahma paraà dhäma, "the Supreme Brahman and supreme abode."

Every person is actually Brahman, spirit soul. We are not actually the body. Awareness of ahaà brahmäsmi ("I am Brahman") is actual self-realization. According to Vedic culture, one must understand that he is Brahman, not the body. We should not remain in ignorance like cats and dogs, thinking, "I am this body, I am American, I am Indian, I am brähmaëa, I am kñatriya, I am Hindu, I am Muslim," and so on. These are all bodily designations. When one comes to spiritual understanding, he understands ahaà brahmäsmi, "I am Brahman." This is called Brahman realization. It is not that we become Brahman by some practice. Gold is gold, even if it is covered with some dirt, which can certainly be removed. Similarly, we are all Brahman, spirit soul, but somehow or other we have come in contact with these material elements (bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù), and we have acquired bodily coverings. Consequently we think, "I am this body." This is ignorance, and unless one is enlightened by spiritual knowledge, he remains animalistic.

Understanding one's spiritual identity is called dharma. The ultimate goal of dharma is enunciated by Çré Kåñëa Himself in Bhagavad-gétä (18.66). Sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja: "Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me." On this earth we have created so many dharmas—Hindu dharma, Muslim dharma, Christian dharma. These are all manufactured dharmas, but real dharma is attained when we come to the conclusion that Çré Kåñëa is everything. Again, in the words of Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (7.19):

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare."

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant for the propagation of this message. We are not preaching a particular sectarian religious system but a real religion, dharma. Dharmaà tu säkñäd bhagavat-praëétam: no one actually knows what dharma is, and no one can manufacture dharma. Dharma is the order of the Supreme Being. No one can manufacture state laws; they are given by the government. The simplest definition of dharma is that dharma is the order of the Supreme Being. Since the Supreme Being, God, is one, His order must be one. How, then, can there be different dharmas? It is not possible. Different dharmas are created due to ignorance, which causes people to think in terms of Hindu dharma, Muslim dharma, Christian dharma, this dharma or that dharma. No. Gold is gold. If a Christian possesses some gold, does it become Christian gold? Gold is gold whether possessed by a Hindu, a Muslim or a Christian. According to the order of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, dharma means surrendering unto that Supreme Being. This is bhägavata-dharma, and everyone should be taught how to surrender unto God. God is one; there cannot be two Gods. When there is competition, there is no God. Presently there is a different God on every street, but Kåñëa is not that kind of God. He is the Supreme God. As Kåñëa Himself states in Bhagavad-gétä (7.7):

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

"O conqueror of wealth [Arjuna], there is no truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread."

The purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to inform everyone that no one is superior to Kåñëa, God. Because many young Americans and Europeans are fortunate and know nothing of any hodgepodge god, they have taken this bona fide Kåñëa consciousness movement seriously. Kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam: Bhagavän, God, means Çré Kåñëa. We have simply presented this information, saying, "Here is God. Çré Kåñëa." Because they have taken this seriously, many young Americans and Europeans are advancing in Kåñëa consciousness. Consequently many people are surprised to see how Americans and Europeans have become such great devotees and are dancing in ecstasy. How is it they are so advanced? They have taken the information seriously: kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam. Whether one touches fire blindly or knowingly, fire will burn. It is not that because the fire is touched by a child, fire will not burn. These young Westerners have touched fire, and consequently it is acting as fire.

Äcäryopäsanam: this information (kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam) is not concocted, but is accepted by the äcäryas in the disciplic succession. Although an impersonalist, Çaìkaräcärya has accepted Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So have Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Viñëu Svämé, Nimbärka and Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu and His followers. They all accept Kåñëa as the Supreme, just as Arjuna himself did. This is the simplest method. There is no need to speculate, "What is God? Where is God?" Why foolishly go on searching? Here is God—Kåñëa. We may think that Kåñëa cannot be seen, but Kåñëa can appear in the form of His energy. Of course, a stone is not God, but a stone is another one of God's energies. Heat and light are not fire, but without fire there cannot be heat or light. In that sense, heat and light are nondifferent from fire. This material world is like the heat and light of the supreme fire.

eka-deça-sthitasyägner
jyotsnä vistäriëé yathä
parasya brahmaëaù çaktis
tathedam akhilaà jagat

"Just as a fire is situated in one place, but spreads illumination all around, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Parabrahman, spreads His energies throughout this universe." (Viñëu Puräëa 1.22.56)

The sun is situated in one place, and its light and heat expand throughout the entire solar system. As soon as we perceive light and heat, we can understand that the sun is there. Since light and heat can be perceived by everyone, Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (7.8), prabhäsmi çaçi-süryayoù: "I am the light of the sun and the moon." people are saying, "Can you show me God?" while not realizing that they are seeing God daily at every moment. Because people are foolish in this age, they cannot understand that when we perceive the energy of the Lord, we can feel the presence of the Lord.

The young devotees in the Kåñëa consciousness movement are presently worshiping Kåñëa. What are the signs of a devotee? The actual sign of a devotee is that he is no longer interested in material enjoyment: bhaktiù pareçänubhavo viraktir anyatra ca (Bhäg. 11.2.42). The disciples of this Kåñëa consciousness movement do not go to cinemas, restaurants or clubs, and they do not smoke or drink. In European and American countries all these things are available and are very cheap, but these young people are not interested in them. They are simply interested in sitting on the floor and learning about Kåñëa consciousness. Why is this? They have actually rejected the material world. When one comes to detest material enjoyment, one can understand that he has advanced spiritually. Spiritual life does not mean taking sannyäsa and then smoking or drinking tea. One must actually come to detest material life. One comes to lose interest in material activities and becomes interested only in the understanding of God, the Supreme Being, and His service. As enjoined in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (5.5.1):

näyaà deho deha-bhäjäà nåloke
kañöän kämän arhate vid-bhujäà ye

"Of all the living entities who have accepted material bodies in this world, one who has been awarded this human form should not work hard day and night simply for sense gratification, which is available even for the dogs and hogs that eat stool." The word vid-bhujäm means "stooleaters." Hogs work hard day and night simply eating stool, and because stool contains chemicals, hypophosphates, the hog gets strength, becomes very fat and enjoys sex. In any case, human life is meant not for imitating the life of a hog but for tapasya, austerity:

tapo divyaà putrakä yena sattvaà
çuddhyed yasmäd brahma-saukhyaà tv anantam

"Rather, my dear boys, one should engage in penance and austerity to attain the divine position of devotional service. By such activity, one's heart is purified, and when one attains this position, he attains eternal, blissful life, which is transcendental to material happiness and which continues forever." (Bhäg. 5.5.1)

This is the meaning of Vedic civilization. The society of varëäçrama-dharma—composed of brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas, çüdras, gåhasthas, vänaprasthas, brahmacärés and sannyäsés—is meant to elevate people gradually to the perfect stage of understanding God. The whole aim of the different varëas and äçramas is the worship of the Supreme Lord. One can attain this understanding through this social system, which admits of gradations. When one goes to school, he begins with the first grade, then progresses to the second, third and so forth. In this way one makes progress.

When human society accepts varëäçrama-dharma, it can gradually come to the understanding of Brahman. By birth, everyone is a çüdra; therefore everyone has to be educated. The word dvija means "twiceborn." One is first born through the womb of a mother, and one's next birth is given by the spiritual master and Vedic knowledge. Vedic knowledge is the mother, and the spiritual master is the father. When one is twice-born (dvija), he receives a sacred thread from the spiritual master and begins to learn about spiritual life. He is then allowed to read the Vedic literatures. In this way one becomes a son of Vedic literature. Nigama-kalpa-taror galitaà phalam: Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the essence of Vedic culture. It is a wish-fulfilling tree, and we can take whatever we want from it. Vedic knowledge is perfect, and if we want to come to know it, we must take shelter of a bona fide guru (tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet).

Unfortunately, in this age everything is mismanaged. People forget the aim of life, and at such a time the Supreme Lord Himself comes. The Supreme Lord descends out of compassion because He is more anxious to have us return home, back to Godhead, than we are to go. Because we are in ignorance, we do not know anything about the kingdom of God. We know nothing about how to get there or how to become happy. We have forgotten all this. Therefore Kåñëa comes at intervals or sends His representative, the pure devotee. Sometimes He comes personally, and sometimes He sends His incarnation.

Kapiladeva is an incarnation of the Supreme Person, Kåñëa. Therefore it is stated: kapilas tattva-saìkhyätä bhagavän ätma-mäyayä. The word mäyä means not only "illusion," but also "affection" and "energy." When Kåñëa comes, all His energies also come. It is not that He is forced to come. We have to accept a certain type of body because we are forced to do so, but this is not the case with Çré Kåñëa. Presently I may have a human form, but in the future I cannot demand a human form. We receive bodies in the next life according to karma, not will. One cannot demand to be a high-court judge unless one has been educated for the job. First of all, one must become qualified. If one qualifies himself, one may become a devatä, a demigod like Indra or Candra, or one can become a dog or a cat. That depends on one's karma, or activities (karmaëä daiva-netreëa). When Kåñëa or His incarnation come, they do not depend on karma for their bodies. The Supreme Lord is above karma and is fully independent. It is therefore said, ätma-mäyayä. The Supreme Lord comes by His own energy, not by the external energy or by force. When the governor visits the prison, he is not forced to do so. He is not to be considered a condemned person; rather, he goes by his own good will just to see how things are going on, However, it is understood that when an ordinary person is placed in jail, he is sent there by force because he has been proven a criminal. A criminal may think that he and the governor are one, just as rascals and fools think that Kåñëa is one of them. Avajänanti mäà müòhä mänuñéà tanum äçritam. A knowledgeable person knows that when Kåñëa or His incarnation descends upon the material world, the Supreme Lord maintains His transcendental position. He is not an ordinary man, nor is He forced into the material world due to karma. The Supreme Lord comes by His own good will. Paraà bhävam ajänantaù. Rascals cannot understand what Kåñëa is; therefore they think that Kåñëa is a human being. As Kåñëa Himself states in Bhagavad-gétä (7.3):

manuñyäëäà sahasreñu
kaçcid yatati siddhaye
yatatäm api siddhänäà
kaçcin mäà vetti tattvataù

"Out of many thousands among men, one may endeavor for perfection, and of those who have achieved perfection, hardly one knows Me in truth."

Understanding Kåñëa is therefore not so easy. As stated by Kåñëa, out of many thousands one person may become a siddha, a self-realized being. And out of many siddhas, one may be able to understand Kåñëa. It is our great fortune that Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, Kåñëa Himself, has appeared and given us a very easy process by which we can understand Kåñëa. What is that process? We need only hear about Kåñëa. That's all. We have therefore opened all these centers of Kåñëa consciousness throughout the world.

çåëvatäà sva-kathäù kåñëaù
puëya-çravaëa-kértanaù
hådy antaù-stho hy abhadräëi
vidhunoti suhåt satäm

"Çré Kåñëa, the Personality of Godhead, who is the Paramätmä [Supersoul] in everyone's heart and the benefactor of the truthful devotee, cleanses desire for material enjoyment from the heart of the devotee who has developed the urge to hear His messages, which are in themselves virtuous when properly heard and chanted." (Bhäg. 1.2.17)

If we hear about Kåñëa, we become purified. Hearing about Kåñëa means associating with Kåñëa. In this way we may perfect our lives.

TLK 2: The Transcendental Master and Supreme Yogé

CHAPTER TWO
The Transcendental Master and Supreme Yogé

TLK Vs 2

TEXT 2

na hy asya varñmaëaù puàsäà
varimëaù sarva-yoginäm
viçrutau çruta-devasya
bhüri tåpyanti me 'savaù

TRANSLATION

Çaunaka continued: There is no one who knows more than the Lord Himself. No one is more worshipable or more mature a yogé than He. He is therefore the master of the Vedas, and to hear about Him always is the actual pleasure of the senses.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.2]

PURPORT

In Bhagavad-gétä it is stated that no one can be equal to or greater than the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is confirmed in the Vedas also: eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän. He is the supreme living entity and is supplying the necessities of all other living entities. Thus all other living entities, both viñëu-tattva and jéva-tattva, are subordinate to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. The same concept is confirmed here. Na hy asya varñmaëaù puàsäà: among living entities, no one can surpass the Supreme Person because no one is richer, more famous, stronger, more beautiful, wiser or more renounced than He. These qualifications make Him the Supreme Godhead, the cause of all causes. Yogés are very proud of performing wonderful feats, but no one can compare to the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Anyone who is associated with the Supreme Lord is accepted as a first-class yogé. Devotees may not be as powerful as the Supreme Lord, but by constant association with the Lord they become as good as the Lord Himself. Sometimes the devotees act more powerfully than the Lord. Of course, that is the Lord's concession.

Also used here is the word varimëaù, meaning the most worshipful of all yogés. To hear from Kåñëa is the real pleasure of the senses; therefore he is known as Govinda, for by His words, by His teachings, by His instruction—by everything connected with Him—He enlivens the senses. Whatever He instructs is from the transcendental platform, and His instructions, being absolute, are nondifferent from Him. Hearing from Kåñëa or His expansion or plenary expansion like Kapila is very pleasing to the senses. Bhagavad-gétä can be read or heard many times, but because it gives great pleasure, the more one reads Bhagavad-gétä the more he wants to read and understand it, and each time he gets new enlightenment. That is the nature of the transcendental message. Similarly, we find that transcendental happiness in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The more we hear and chant the glories of the Lord, the more we become happy.

In the previous verse, the incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead as Devahüti-putra Kapiladeva has been explained as bhagavän ätma-mäyayä. The word bhaga means "opulence," and vän means "one who possesses." All the opulences of the creation are present in Bhagavän. As stated in the Vedas (Kaöha Upaniñad 2.2.13):

nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm
eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän

Nitya, bhagavän, is the singular, and nityänäà are the plural jévas, or living beings. Nityo nityänäà: we are many, but God is one. There is no limit to the jévas; no one can count them. The word ananta means that they are without limit. All these jévas, living entities, are being maintained by the Supreme One. We cannot conceive how many living entities are being maintained by the Supreme Lord. All the great elephants, all the small ants, all the 8,400,000 species of life are maintained by Bhagavän. Why do we worry that He will not maintain us? Those who are devotees of the Lord and have taken shelter at His lotus feet, leaving everything aside simply to render service unto Him, will certainly be cared for. In our Kåñëa consciousness movement, we have over a hundred centers, and Kåñëa is maintaining them all. None of our devotees are employed for independent incomes, yet they are all being maintained. In Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa never says, "Do this or that, and I will then maintain you." Rather, He states that not only will He maintain us, but He will also protect us from the results of sin, from sinful karma (Bg. 18.66). All of this assurance is there.

Tasyaiva hetoù prayateta kovidaù. The word kovidaù means "intelligent." An intelligent person should try to attain shelter at the lotus feet of Kåñëa. Human life is actually meant for getting in touch with the lotus feet of Kåñëa. That should be our only business. The word upari indicates the higher planetary systems. There are seven higher planetary systems, and we are in the middle system, in Bhürloka. Within this one universe, there are fourteen planetary systems, and the living entities are wandering in different bodily forms on different planets. According to karma, the living entity sometimes goes up and sometimes goes down. He wanders in this way, thinking how he can become materially happy and satisfy his senses. The çästras say that we should not do this, that we should endeavor to understand Kåñëa. We should not worry about eating and sleeping, for the needs of the body are already arranged. We do not have to work independently to maintain the body.

tal labhyate duùkhavad anyataù sukhaà
kälena sarvatra gabhéra-raàhasä
[Bhäg. 1.5.18]

Our actual endeavor should be to attain happiness; that is our real struggle for existence. According to the çästras: tal labhyate duùkhavat. The word duùkhavat indicates that although we do not want misery, misery comes anyway. We don't have to endeavor separately for misery. No one says, "Let there be a fire in my house" or "Let my child die." No one aspires after these things, yet they happen. Everyone is thinking, "May my child live happily" or "May I get so much money." We do not ask or pray for catastrophes, yet they come without invitation. Similarly, whatever happiness is there for our enjoyment will also come without our asking for it. The conclusion is that we should not endeavor for so-called happiness or distress, but should try to attain that position whereby we can understand Kåñëa and get shelter at His lotus feet. This should be the real human endeavor.

It was Caitanya Mahäprabhu who said to Rüpa Gosvämé:

brahmäëòa bhramite kona bhägyavän jéva
guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja

"The living entity is wandering up and down, from one planet to another, and he is very fortunate if by the mercy of the spiritual master and Kåñëa Himself he can get the seed of devotional service to Kåñëa." (Cc. Madhya 19.151) The Kåñëa consciousness movement is an attempt to make people fortunate. In this age, everyone is unfortunate (manda-bhägyäù), but now we are trying to reverse the situation.

Throughout the world there are problems everywhere. One country has one type of problem, and another country has another. There is strife within governments themselves, and even presidents are fraught with problems. Sometimes we may think we are very fortunate, just as President Nixon was thinking, "I am very fortunate. I have become the president of the United States." Then he soon realized that he was most unfortunate. Actually this is the situation for everyone. We should not think that the only apprehended culprit is President Nixon and that we are safe. There is a Bengali proverb: Dry cow dung is used for fuel, and it is said that when the dry cow dung is being burned, the soft cow dung is laughing, saying, "Oh, you are being burned, but I am safe." It does not know that when it dries out, it will be thrown into the fire too. We may laugh because President Nixon is in trouble, and we may think ourselves very safe because we have a big bank balance, but actually no one is safe. Eventually everyone will dry up and be thrown in the fire. That is a fact. We may survive for a few years, but we cannot avoid death. In fact, it is said, "As sure as death." And what is the result of death? One loses everything—all honor, money, position and material life itself. Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä (10.34), måtyuù sarva-haraç cäham: "I am all-devouring death." Kåñëa comes as death and plunders everything—bank balance, skyscrapers, wife, children and whatever. One cannot say, "My dear death, please give me some time to adjust." There is no adjustment; one must immediately get out.

Foolish people are unaware of the miserable conditions of material life. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (13.9), janma-måtyu-jarä-vyädhi-duùkha-doñänudarçanam. Real knowledge means knowing that however great one may be, the four principles of material life are present: birth, old age, disease and death. These exist in the highest planetary system (Brahmaloka) and in the lowest (Pätälaloka).

tasyaiva hetoù prayateta kovido
na labhyate yad bhramatäm upary adhaù
tal labhyate duùkhavad anyataù sukhaà
kälena sarvatra gabhéra-raàhasä

"Persons who are actually intelligent and philosophically inclined should endeavor only for that purposeful end which is not obtainable even by wandering from the topmost planet down to the lowest planet. As far as happiness derived from sense enjoyment is concerned, it can be obtained automatically in course of time, just as in course of time we obtain miseries even though we do not desire them." (Bhäg. 1.5.18)

When Dharmaräja asked Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira what the most wonderful thing in the world was, Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira replied: ahany ahani bhütäni gacchantéha yamälayam. "Every moment people are dying, but those who are living are thinking, 'My friend has died, but I shall live forever.' " (Mahäbhärata, Vana-parva 313.116) Soft cow dung thinks the same way. This is typical of conditioned beings.

Bhagavän, the Supreme Lord, is not in this position. It is therefore said: bhagavän ätma-mäyayä. We come onto this planet to enjoy or suffer life for a few days—fifty or a hundred years—but Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, does not come for that purpose (na mäà karmäëi limpanti). It is further stated, na hy asya varñmaëaù: "No one is greater than Him." No one is greater than Bhagavän or equal to Him. Everyone is inferior. According to Caitanya-caritämåta (Ädi 5.142), ekale éçvara kåñëa, ära saba bhåtya. There is only one master—Kåñëa. All others are subservient, beginning with Lord Brahmä, Viñëu, Maheçvara, Indra, Candra and all the demigods (there are thirty-three million demigods) and the middle and lower species. Everyone is bhåtya, or servant. When Kåñëa orders, "My dear Mr. So-and-So, now please give up your place and leave,', one must go. Therefore everyone is a servant. This is the position of Lord Brahmä and the ant as well. Yas tv indragopam athavendram aho sva-karma [Bs. 5.54]. From Lord Indra to indragopa, an insignificant insect, everyone is reaping the consequences of his karma. We are creating our own karma, our next body, in this life. In this life we enjoy or suffer the results of our past karma, and in the same way we are creating further karma for our next body. Actually we should work in such a way that we will not get another material body, How can this be done? We simply have to try to understand Kåñëa. As Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (4.9):

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna."

This sounds very simple, but actually understanding Kåñëa is very difficult. If we become devotees of Kåñëa, understanding Kåñëa is easy. However, if we try to understand Him by jïäna, karma or yoga, we will be frustrated. There are many types of yogés, but he who is devoted to Kåñëa is the topmost yogé. Çré Kåñëa is far above all yogic processes. In India there are many yogés who can display some magical feats. They can walk on water, make themselves very light or very heavy and so forth. But what is this compared to Kåñëa's yogic mystic powers? By His potencies, great planets are floating in space. Who can manage to float even a small stone in the air? Sometimes a yogé may show a little mystic power by manufacturing some gold, and we are so foolish that we accept him as God. However, we forget that the real yogé, the Supreme Lord Himself, has created millions of gold mines and is floating them in space. Those who are Kåñëa conscious are not befooled by yogés who claim to be Bhagavän. A Kåñëa conscious person wants only to serve the foremost yogé, Yogeçvara (varimëaù sarva-yoginäm). Because we are trying to become His devotees, we accept the Supreme Lord, Yogeçvara, as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Kåñëa Himself states in Bhagavad-gétä (18.55):

bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti
yävän yaç cäsmi tattvataù
tato mäà tattvato jïätvä
viçate tad-anantaram

"One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service. And when one is in full consciousness of the Supreme Lord by such devotion, he can enter into the kingdom of God."

This process is actually very simple. One must first of all realize that the first problem is the conquest of death. Presently we consider death compulsory, but actually it is not. One may be put into prison, but actually prison is not compulsory. It is due to one's work that one becomes a criminal and is therefore put in jail. It is not compulsory for everyone to go to jail. As living entities, we have our proper place in Vaikuëöhaloka.

paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo
'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù
yaù sa sarveñu bhüteñu
naçyatsu na vinaçyati

avyakto 'kñara ity uktas
tam ähuù paramäà gatim
yaà präpya na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"There is another nature, which is eternal and is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is. That supreme abode is called unmanifested and infallible, and it is the supreme destination. When one goes there, he never comes back. That is My supreme abode." (Bg. 8.20-21)

Everything is present in Vaikuëöhaloka. There we can have an eternal, blissful life full of knowledge (sac-cid-änanda). It is not compulsory for us to rot in this material world. The easiest way to go to the Vaikuëöhalokas is: janma karma ca me divyam evaà yo vetti tattvataù. Simply try to understand Kåñëa. Why does He come? What are His activities? Where does He come from? Why does He come in the form of a human being? We only have to try to understand this and study Kåñëa as He explains Himself in Bhagavad-gétä. What is the difficulty? God personally explains Himself as He is, and if we accept Bhagavad-gétä as it is, we shall no longer have to transmigrate. Tyaktvä dehaà punar janma naiti. We shall no longer have to endure birth and death, for we can attain our spiritual bodies (sac-cid-änanda-vigraha) and live happily in Kåñëa's family. Kåñëa is providing for us here, and He will also provide for us there. So we should know that our happiness is in returning home, back to Godhead, where we can eat, drink and be merry in Kåñëa's company.

TLK 3: How to Understand the Lord's Activities

CHAPTER THREE
How to Understand the Lord's Activities

TLK Vs 3

TEXT 3

yad yad vidhatte bhagavän
svacchandätmätma-mäyayä
täni me çraddadhänasya
kértanyäny anukértaya

TRANSLATION

Therefore please precisely describe all the activities and pastimes of the Personality of Godhead, who is full of self-desire and who assumes all these activities by His internal potency.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.3]

PURPORT

The word anukértaya is very significant. Anukértaya means "to follow the description"—not to create a concocted mental description, but to follow. Çaunaka Åñi requested Süta Gosvämé to describe what he had actually heard from his spiritual master, Çukadeva Gosvämé, about the transcendental pastimes that the Lord manifested by His internal energy. Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, has no material body, but He can assume any kind of body by His supreme will. That is made possible by His internal energy.

We can understand the pastimes of the Lord by following one or some of the authorized devotional processes.

çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù
smaraëaà päda-sevanam
arcanaà vandanaà däsyaà
sakhyam ätma-nivedanam

"Hearing, chanting and remembering the holy name, form, pastimes, qualities and entourage of the Lord, offering service according to the time, place and performer, worshiping the Deity, offering prayers, always considering oneself the eternal servant of Kåñëa, making friends with Him and dedicating everything unto Him—these are the nine processes of devotional service." (Bhäg. 7.5.23)

There are nine basic processes of devotional service—hearing and chanting about the Supreme Lord, remembering Him, serving His lotus feet, worshiping Him, offering prayers to the Lord, acting as His servant, becoming His friend, and surrendering everything to Him. The beginning is çravaëaà kértanam, hearing and chanting. One must be very eager to hear and chant. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (9.14):

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate

"Always chanting My glories, endeavoring with great determination, bowing down before Me, the great souls perpetually worship Me with devotion."

We have to speak or chant about the holy activities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but first we have to hear about them. This Çrémad-Bhägavatam was recited by Çukadeva Gosvämé and heard by Parékñit Mahäräja, and we in turn have to hear about Kåñëa and then chant about Him (çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù). When we speak of Viñëu, we mean Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the origin of the viñëu-tattva—that is, Viñëu is an expansion of Kåñëa. When we speak of Viñëu, we understand that the origin of Viñëu is Kåñëa. As Çré Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (10.2), aham ädir hi devänäm: "I am the source of the demigods."

The most important demigods (devas) are Brahmä, Çiva and Viñëu. In the beginning of the creation there is Lord Viñëu, and from Lord Viñëu, Brahmä is born. From Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva is born, and these three gods take charge of the three modes of material nature. Viñëu takes charge of sattva-guëa (the mode of goodness), Lord Brahmä takes charge of rajo-guëa (the mode of passion), and Lord Çiva takes charge of tamo-guëa (the mode of ignorance). However, before the creation there was no Brahmä or Çiva. There was only Kåñëa. Kåñëa therefore says, aham ädir hi devänäm. He is the creator of all demigods and all other living entities. After the cosmic manifestation is created, the living entities are placed in it. Therefore in the Vedas it is stated that in the beginning there was neither Brahmä nor Çiva, but only Näräyaëa (eko näräyaëa äsét). Näräyaëa is also another plenary expansion of Kåñëa.

We have to learn from the scriptures that Kåñëa is the origin of all. Kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam: all the viñëu-tattvas and incarnations are but plenary expansions or expansions of the plenary expansions of Kåñëa. There are millions and millions of incarnations. They are as plentiful as waves in the ocean. There are çaktyäveça-avatäras, guëa-avatäras and svayam-avatäras, and these are all described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. All these avatäras, or incarnations, are svacchandätmä, free from care and anxiety. If we organize a business, we have many anxieties. The managing director or proprietor of the business particularly has many anxieties. Although he sits in his office without disturbance, he is not very happy because he is always thinking about how to do this or that, how to manage this affair or that. This is material nature, and therefore it is said that there is always anxiety in the material world. When Hiraëyakaçipu, the father of prahläda Mahäräja, asked his son, "My dear boy, what is the best thing you have learned from your teachers?" Prahläda Mahäräja immediately replied, tat sädhu manye 'sura-varya dehinäà sadä samudvigna-dhiyäm asad-grahät (Bhäg. 7.5.5). "I have learned that materialists have accepted the asad guëa." Asat means "that which is not." We should not remain on this platform, but should go to the platform of sat (oà tat sat). This is the Vedic injunction. The material world is asad-vastu; it cannot possibly remain. In the material world, everything will ultimately be vanquished. Whatever exists in the material world exists only for some time. It is temporary. The Mäyävädé philosophers say, brahma satyaà jagan mithyä: "The Supreme Truth is real, whereas the world is false"—but Vaiñëavas do not use the word mithyä (false), because God, the Supreme Brahman, is truth, and nothing false can emanate from the truth. If we prepare an earring from gold, the earring is also gold. We cannot say that the earring is false. Yato imäni bhütäni jäyante: the Supreme Absolute Truth is He from whom everything is emanating. If everything is emanating from the Absolute Truth, nothing can actually be false. The Vaiñëava philosophers accept the world as temporary, but not false, as the Mäyävädé philosophers do.

The world (jagat) has emanated from the Supreme; therefore it is not mithyä, but it is temporary. That is also explained in Bhagavad-gétä (8.19): bhütvä bhütvä praléyate. The material world comes into existence, remains for some time, and is then annihilated. It is not false, for it can be utilized to realize the Supreme Truth. This is Vaiñëava philosophy. The world is temporary, but we must use it for spiritual purposes. If something is used for the ultimate truth, the Absolute Truth, it becomes integral with the Absolute Truth. As stated by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé:

anäsaktasya viñayän
yathärham upayuïjataù
nirbandhaù kåñëa-sambandhe
yuktaà vairägyam ucyate

präpaïcikatayä buddhyä
hari-sambandhi-vastunaù
mumukñubhiù parityägo
vairägyaà phalgu kathyate
(Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.2.255-56)

The word mumukñubhiù refers to those who aspire for mukti, liberation. When one becomes disgusted with material engagement, one wants to destroy everything that has anything to do with the material world. However, the Vaiñëava says, präpaïcikatayä buddhyä hari-sambandhi-vastunaù. Everything has some relationship with the Supreme Person, the Absolute Truth. For instance, a microphone is made of metal, but what is metal? It is another form of earth. In Bhagavad-gétä (7.4) Çré Kåñëa says:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

"Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and false ego—all together these comprise My separated material energies." All of these are Kåñëa's energies, and if Kåñëa is the source of them, how can they be untrue? They are not. A Vaiñëava will never say that metal has no connection with Kåñëa. It is a product of one of His energies, just as this material world is a product of the sun. We cannot say that the sunshine is false and that the sun is true. If the sun is true, the sunshine is also true. Similarly, we do not say that the material universe is false. It may be temporary, but it is not false. Therefore the Gosvämés and Kåñëa Himself tell us that since everything belongs to Kåñëa, everything should be utilized for His purpose.

This creation emanates from Bhagavän, the Supreme Lord, who is without anxiety. Kåñëa very pleasantly associates with His consort Çrématé Rädhäräëé and enjoys playing His flute. If God is anxious, what kind of God is He? Even Lord Brahmä and other demigods are anxious. Lord Brahmä is engaged in meditation, Lord Siva dances to annihilate the universe, the goddess Kälé is engaged in killing with her sword, and so forth. The demigods have many activities, but Kåñëa is always peaceful. The Kåñëa who engages in killing demons is Väsudeva Kåñëa, not the original Kåñëa. The original Kåñëa does not go anywhere; He never takes a step away from Våndävana. The other activities performed by Kåñëa are performed in the Väsudeva, Saìkarñaëa, Aniruddha or Pradyumna forms. Kåñëa expands as Saìkarñaëa, Näräyaëa, Viñëu, Mahä-Viñëu, Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu and Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu. God can expand Himself in many, many forms.

advaitam acyutam anädim ananta-rüpam
ädyaà puräëa-puruñaà nava-yauvanaà ca
(Brahma-saàhitä 5.33)

He is the ädi-puruña, the original soul of all. Govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi: Lord Brahmä says that he is not ädi-puruña but that Govinda, Kåñëa, is the ädi-puruña. This Kåñëa has many expansions (advaitam acyutam anädim). He has no beginning, but He is the beginning of everything. He has expanded Himself in many forms. The viñëu-tattva consists of bhagavat-tattva-sväàça, the personal expansions. We are also Kåñëa's forms, but we are vibhinnäàça, separated expansions. We are the expansions of the energies. According to Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (7.5):

apareyam itas tv anyäà
prakåtià viddhi me paräm
jéva-bhütäà mahä-bäho
yayedaà dhäryate jagat

"Besides the inferior nature, O mighty-armed Arjuna, there is a superior energy of Mine, which consists of the living entities who are struggling with material nature and are sustaining the universe."

Thus there are the jéva-prakåti, the parä prakåti expansions, who belong to Kåñëa's superior energy. In any case, Kåñëa is always svacchandätmä—without anxiety. Even if He is killing a demon, He experiences no anxiety. That is also confirmed in the Vedas:

na tasya käryaà karaëaà ca vidyate
na tat-samaç cäbhyadhikaç ca dåçyate
paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate
sväbhäviké jïäna-bala-kriyä ca

"The Supreme Lord has nothing to do, for everything is done automatically by His various potencies. No one is seen to be equal to, or greater than, Him." (Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 6.8)

Çré Kåñëa has nothing to do personally. It is His energy that acts. When an important man wants to get something done, he simply tells his secretary, who does everything. The important man is quite confident that because he has told his secretary, his desires will be carried out. The secretary is a person, energy (çakti). If an ordinary man within this world has many energies in the form of secretaries, then we can hardly imagine the energies possessed by Çré Kåñëa. Çré Kåñëa is jagad-éçvara, the controller of the entire universe, and thus He is managing the entire universe. Foolish people say that there is no brain behind the universe, but this is due to ignorance. By taking information from the çästras, the scriptures, we can understand who that brain is. According to Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (9.10):

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

"This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again." We see His energies working in this material world all the time. There is thunder and rain, and from rain comes the food we enjoy. This process is outlined in Bhagavad-gétä (3.14):

annäd bhavanti bhütäni
parjanyäd anna-sambhavaù
yajïäd bhavati parjanyo
yajïaù karma-samudbhavaù

"All living beings subsist on food grains, which are produced from rains. Rains are produced by performance of yajïa [sacrifice], and yajïa is born of prescribed duties." The origin of everything is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Through yajïa, sacrifice, we have to satisfy the Supreme Person, and yajïas can be executed when human society is regulated according to the varëäçrama-dharma, the system of four social orders (varëas) and four spiritual orders (äçramas). There are four varëas (brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya and çüdra) and four äçramas (brahmacarya, gåhastha, vänaprastha and sannyäsa). These varëas and äçramas have their respective duties, and unless human society is divided according to these eight scientific divisions and everyone acts according to his position, there can be no peace in the world.

varëäçramäcäravatä
puruñeëa paraù pumän
viñëur ärädhyate panthä
nänyat tat-toña-käraëam

"The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Viñëu, is worshiped by the proper execution of prescribed duties in the system of varëa and äçrama. There is no other way to satisfy the Supreme Personality of Godhead." (Viñëu Puräëa 3.8.9)

The ultimate goal of all activity is the satisfaction of the Supreme Lord, Viñëu. Na te viduù svärtha-gatià hi viñëum (Bhäg. 7.5.31). Foolish people do not know that their ultimate interest is the satisfaction of Viñëu. Therefore, when there are dharmasya gläëiù, discrepancies in dharma, Kåñëa or His incarnation personally comes. It is therefore said: yad yad vidhatte bhagavän. Although He comes, He has no anxiety. He comes by His internal potency, and He does not take help from anyone. He possesses a variety of energies, all of which work correctly and perfectly (paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate sväbhäviké jïäna-bala-kriyä ca).

Impersonalists cannot understand how everything is being carried out perfectly because they cannot understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead: mohitaà näbhijänäti mäm ebhyaù param avyayam. As stated by Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (7.14):

daivé hy eñä guëa-mayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

"This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it." Being covered by the three modes of material nature, one cannot understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead. However, the Supreme Lord reveals Himself to His devotees.

It is our business to understand Kåñëa in truth; then our lives will be successful. It is not that we can succeed by understanding Kåñëa superficially. It is therefore stated here: täni me çraddadhänasya kértanyäny anukértaya. The word anukértaya, as we have initially pointed out, means that we should not manufacture anything. The word anu means "to follow." Therefore the bhagavat-tattva, or Bhagavän, can be understood only by the paramparä system, the system of disciplic succession.

evaà paramparä-präptam
imaà räjarñayo viduù
sa käleneha mahatä
yogo nañöaù parantapa

"This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way. But in course of time the succession was broken, and therefore the science as it is appears to be lost." (Bg. 4.2)

Formerly the kings (räjäs) were great saintly persons. They were not ordinary people engaged in drinking and dancing. They were all åñis (sages), up to the time of Mahäräja Parékñit. They were trained in such a way that they were not ordinary men but were called naradeva. Naradeva refers to Bhagavän in the form of a human being. The king was worshiped because he was a räjarñi, both a king and a sage. Çré Kåñëa says that if the king knows the purpose of life, he can rule well. If he does not, he thinks that eating, sleeping, sex and defense are all in all. In this case, his subjects live like animals. Today no one knows the object of human life; therefore although the foolish people of this age are trying to be happy, their hopes will never be fulfilled. Na te viduù svärtha-gatià hi viñëuà duräçayäù. People are trying to be happy in this material world by accepting material objects, but their plans will never be fulfilled. Therefore in world history we see that there have been many leaders who have died working hard. They could not adjust things properly, despite all their hard efforts. There were Napoleon, Hitler, Gandhi, Nehru and many others, but they could not ultimately prevail. This is duräçayä. The ultimate goal of life is to understand Viñëu, yet people are going on blindly trying to satisfy their senses. If one blind man tries to lead another, what is the result? If both the leaders and followers are blind, they will all fall in a ditch, for they are all bound by their nature.

Çravaëaà kértanam, hearing and chanting, are the beginning of bhakti, devotional service. Therefore it is said: täni me çraddadhänasya kértanyäny anukértaya. The word anukértaya means to follow the paramparä system. First of all we must receive the information from authorities; then we can speak the truth. One first has to learn how to describe the Absolute Truth, Bhagavän—His actions, His mercy and His compassion upon all living beings. The Supreme Lord is more anxious to give us education and enlightenment than we are to receive them. He gives us His literature, His devotees and the paramparä system, but it is up to us to take advantage of these. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is intended to give society the proper understanding of the Absolute Truth. We are not presenting a manufactured, bogus philosophy. Why should we unnecessarily waste our time concocting some philosophy? There is so much to be learned that has already been given by the supreme authority. All we have to do is take this Vedic literature, try to learn it and distribute it. That is Caitanya Mahäprabhu's mission.

bhärata-bhümite haila manuñya-janma yära
janma särthaka kari' kara para-upakära
(Cc. Ädi 9.41)

It is the duty of everyone, especially one born in the land of Bhäratavarña, India, to make his life successful by taking advantage of this Vedic literature. Unfortunately, we are simply trying to learn technology, and that is our misfortune. Real education means solving all life's problems.

Transcendental education means learning how to gain relief from the entanglement of material life. This is made possible by learning about the Lord's transcendental activities.

TLK 4: Approaching a Bona Fide Guru

CHAPTER FOUR
Approaching a Bona Fide Guru

TLK Vs 4

TEXT 4

süta uväca
dvaipäyana-sakhas tv evaà
maitreyo bhagaväàs tathä
prähedaà viduraà préta
änvékñikyäà pracoditaù

TRANSLATION

Çré Süta Gosvämé said: The most powerful sage Maitreya was a friend of Vyäsadeva's. Being encouraged and pleased by Vidura's inquiry about transcendental knowledge, Maitreya spoke as follows.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.4]

PURPORT

Questions and answers are very satisfactorily dealt with when the inquirer is bona fide and the speaker is also authorized. Here Maitreya is considered a powerful sage, and therefore he is also described as bhagavän. This word can be used not only for the Supreme Personality of Godhead but for anyone who is almost as powerful as the Supreme Lord. Maitreya is addressed as bhagavän because he was spiritually far advanced. He was a personal friend of Dvaipäyana Vyäsadeva, a literary incarnation of the Lord. Maitreya was very pleased with the inquiries of Vidura because they were the inquiries of a bona fide, advanced devotee. Thus Maitreya was encouraged to answer. When there are discourses on transcendental topics between devotees of equal mentality, the questions and answers are very fruitful and encouraging.

This is the Vedic process for receiving knowledge. One must approach the proper person, the guru, and submissively listen to him expound transcendental knowledge. As Çré Kåñëa advises in Bhagavad-gétä (4.34):

tad viddhi praëipätena
paripraçnena sevayä

"Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him."

Transcendental knowledge is not very difficult, but the process must be known. Sometimes a dictating machine or a typewriter may not work, but if we go to a technician who knows the machine, he can immediately repair it. The process must be known. If one goes to a ditchdigger to repair a dictating machine, he cannot help. He may know how to dig ditches, but not repair a machine. Therefore the çästras enjoin that if one wants transcendental knowledge, one must approach the proper person. The word tad-vijïäna refers to transcendental knowledge, not material knowledge. A medical practitioner may have material knowledge of the body, but he has no knowledge of the spirit soul within. He simply studies the mechanical arrangement of the body, which is a machine (yantra) made by nature. The body is actually stated in Bhagavad-gétä (18.61) to be a machine:

éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà
håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati
bhrämayan sarva-bhütäni
yanträrüòhäni mäyayä

"The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart, O Arjuna, and is directing the wanderings of all living entities, who are seated as on a machine made of the material energy."

For those who are attached to this bodily machine, the yoga system is recommended. One who is overly attached to the bodily conception is taught to concentrate the mind by some physical gymnastics. Thus in haöha-yoga one undergoes various physical disciplines, but the real purpose is to understand Viñëu, the Supreme. The various yoga systems are given for the machine of the body, but the process of bhakti is transcendental to mechanical arrangements. It is therefore called tad-vijïäna, transcendental to material understanding. If one actually wants to understand spiritual life and spiritual knowledge, one has to approach a guru. The word guru means "heavy," heavy with knowledge. And what is that knowledge? Tad-vijïäna. That heaviness is brahma-niñöhä—attachment to Brahman and to Para-brahman, Bhagavän. That is the guru's qualification. Brahmaëy upaçamäçrayam. According to Muëòaka Upaniñad (1.2.12), tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet: "In order to understand that transcendental science, one must approach a bona fide spiritual master." Similarly, as stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (11.3.21):

tasmäd guruà prapadyeta
jijïäsuù çreya uttamam

"Any person who seriously desires to achieve real happiness must seek out a bona fide spiritual master and take shelter of him by initiation."

The Upaniñads inform us that the guru is one who has received knowledge by hearing the Vedas. Çrotriyaà brahma-niñöham. The Vedas are called çruti, and the bona fide guru is in the line of hearing from the disciplic succession. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (4.2), evaà paramparä-präptam. A bona fide guru does not impart some self-styled, concocted knowledge; his knowledge is standard and received from the paramparä system. He is also firmly fixed in the service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead (brahma-niñöham). These are his two qualifications: he must have heard the Vedic knowledge through the disciplic succession, and he must be established in service to the Supreme Lord. He does not have to be a very learned scholar, but he must have heard from the proper authority. God gives us the ears to hear, and simply by hearing we may become great preachers. We don't need Ph.D.'s or academic examinations. One may even remain in his position; no changes are necessary.

For this purpose there is the varëäçrama-dharma, composed of four varëas and four äçramas. Unless society is divided into these eight categories, it is simply an animal civilization. There must be some systematized, regulated arrangement. For instance, there are different divisions for the body: the head, the arms, the belly and the legs. Without the four corresponding divisions, no society can be conducted very well. There will simply be chaos. The words sthäne sthitäù mean "remaining in the varëäçrama-dharma." Even a çüdra can understand what is Brahman, and in that case he becomes a brähmaëa automatically. It is necessary that one hear attentively. That is all.

It is stated that Vidura heard from Maitreya Åñi, and that Maitreya Åñi was very pleased. Unless one satisfies his guru, one cannot receive proper knowledge. That is quite natural. If one receives his guru properly and seats him comfortably, and if the guru is pleased with one's behavior, the guru can speak very frankly and freely, and this will be very beneficial to the student. By going to a spiritual master and asking for his instructions and then not following them, one simply wastes his time. Nor should one approach the spiritual master with a challenging spirit, but should go with the aim of rendering service. The word nipat means "to fall down," and pra means "without reservation." Transcendental knowledge is based on praëipäta. Therefore Kåñëa says: sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja. "Just surrender unto Me." Just as we surrender unto Kåñëa, we have to surrender unto His representative, the spiritual master. The guru is Kåñëa's external representative, and the internal guru is Kåñëa Himself situated in everyone's heart. It is not that Kåñëa is simply in Vaikuëöha or Goloka Våndävana. He is everywhere; He is even within the atom. Goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhütaù (Bs. 5.37). That is the definition of Paramätmä, the Supersoul. I am ätmä, a spiritual soul, and you are ätmä. We are all situated locally, you within your body and I within mine, but the Paramätmä is situated everywhere. That is the difference between ätmä and Paramätmä. Those who are mistaken say that there is no difference between them, but there is a difference. They are one in the sense that both are cognizant and both are living entities (nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm), but they are different quantitatively. Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä (13.3):

kñetra-jïaà cäpi mäà viddhi
sarva-kñetreñu bhärata

"O scion of Bharata, you should understand that I am also the knower in all bodies." The kñetra-jïa is the proprietor of the kñetra (the body). The individual soul is actually not the proprietor but the occupant. In a house, there is a tenant and a landlord. The tenant is the occupant, and the landlord is the proprietor. Similarly, the ätmä is simply the occupant of the body; the proprietor is Paramätmä. When the landlord tells the tenant to leave the house, the tenant must do so. Similarly, when the Paramätmä says that we have to leave the body, we have to do so.

To receive this Vedic knowledge, we must approach the proper guru. The guru's qualification is given in every çästra. In Çrémad-Bhägavatam (11.3.21) it is said:

tasmäd guruà prapadyeta
jijïäsuù çreya uttamam

One should not accept a guru unless one is inquisitive to know the ultimate goal of life. An ordinary man interested in bodily comforts does not need a guru. Unfortunately, at the present moment, the word guru refers to someone who can give bodily medicine. One approaches a Mahätmäjé and says, "I am suffering from this disease. Please help me." And the Mahätmäjé says, "Yes, I have a mantra that will heal you and give you success. Give me a little money and take it." This is not a real guru. One should approach a guru to learn about tattva, the Absolute Truth. One should not search out a guru to cure some material disease; rather, one requires a doctor. Similarly, people think that if a person can make him successful in business, that person is a guru. The çästras do not confirm this either. A guru is one who knows the Vedas and the Vedic conclusion. The Vedic conclusion is the understanding of Kåñëa. Vedaiç ca sarvair aham eva vedyaù: "By all the Vedas, I am to be known." (Bg. 15.15)

It is not that we have to understand Kåñëa fully. That is not possible. We have no capacity to understand the unlimited. Advaitam acyutam anädim ananta-rüpam (Bs. 5.33). With our limited knowledge we cannot understand the unlimited; indeed, even Kåñëa does not understand Himself. His attraction is unlimited, and to understand why He is so attractive, He became Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu and took on the ecstatic emotions of Çrématé Rädhäräëé (rädhä-bhäva-dyuti). If Kåñëa cannot comprehend the limit of His own attraction and bliss, it is certainly not possible for us with our limited knowledge. If we can simply understand Kåñëa in part, that is our perfection. Therefore Kåñëa says: janma karma ca me divyam evaà yo vetti tattvataù. If we misunderstand Kåñëa and take Him to be a human being like us, we become müòhas, fools. Kåñëa's body is not composed of material elements like ours, and if we think this way, we are mistaken. The material nature belongs to Kåñëa, and He is its controller. We are under the control of material nature, and that is the difference.

One who has real knowledge knows that prakåti, material nature, is working under Kåñëa's direction. It is not possible to understand how all this is going on, but we can understand it in summary. Janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç ca: everything emanates from the Supreme Absolute Truth, Kåñëa. This much knowledge is sufficient. We can then increase this knowledge to understand just how material nature is working under Kåñëa's direction. Modern scientists mistakenly think that material nature is working independently and that things evolve by some chemical process only. However, life does not merely come from life or some chemical evolution. As Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä (10.8):

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate

"I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me." The same conclusion is also given in Vedänta-sütra, wherein it is stated, janmädy asya yataù: "Brahman is He from whom everything emanates." "Everything" includes living entities and inert matter. Both matter and the living entities come from Kåñëa. Indeed, the whole world is a combination of matter and spirit, prakåti and the living entity.

Material energy is inferior, and spiritual energy is superior. Why? Superior energy (jéva-bhüta), the living entity, is controlling material nature. Actually he is not controlling, but is trying to utilize it. For instance, human beings are advanced living entities, and they have created modern civilization by utilizing dull, inert matter. This is our superiority. However, we are also prakåti as well as parä prakåti. In this way, we have to understand tattva jïäna.

Çrémad-Bhägavatam is a commentary on Vedänta-sütra. Vedänta-sütra explains that the Supreme is the source of everything, and the nature of that source is explained in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.1.1): janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç cärtheñv abhijïaù svaräö. That source is abhijïa, cognizant. Matter is not cognizant; therefore the theory of modern science that life comes from matter is incorrect. The identity from whom everything emanates is abhijïa, cognizant, which means He can understand. The Bhägavatam (1.1.1) also states, tene brahma hådä ya ädi-kavaye: Kåñëa instructed Lord Brahmä in Vedic knowledge. Unless the ultimate source is a living entity, how can He impart knowledge? Çrémad-Bhägavatam was compiled by Vyäsadeva, who also compiled the Vedänta-sütra. Generally the Mäyävädés emphasize the commentary made on the Vedänta-sütra by Çaìkaräcärya, the Çäréraka-bhäñya, but that is not the original commentary on Vedänta-sütra. The original commentary is given by the author himself, Vyäsadeva, in the form of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. To understand the actual meaning of the Vedänta-sütra, we must refer to the commentary made by the author himself. As stated by Çré Kåñëa Himself in Bhagavad-gétä (13.5):

åñibhir bahudhä gétaà
chandobhir vividhaiù påthak
brahma-sütra-padaiç caiva
hetumadbhir viniçcitaiù

"The knowledge of the field of activities and of the knower of activities is described by various sages in various Vedic writings—especially in the Vedänta-sütra—and is presented with all reasoning as to cause and effect."

Transcendental knowledge is therefore very logical. According to the Vedic system, the äcärya must understand Vedänta-sütra (also called Brahma-sütra) before he can be accepted as an äcärya. Both the Mäyäväda-sampradäya and the Vaiñëava-sampradäya have explained the Vedänta-sütra. Without understanding Vedänta-sütra, one cannot understand Brahman. It is said that Vidura understood transcendental knowledge from Maitreya, and it is stated that Maitreya is a friend of Vyäsadeva's. This means that both Vidura and Maitreya know what Vyäsadeva knows. We have to approach a spiritual master who is in the disciplic succession from Vyäsadeva. Everyone may claim to be following Vyäsadeva, but one must actually follow him. Vyäsadeva accepted Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and Arjuna also accepted Kåñëa as Para-brahman, the Supreme Person. One may say that because Arjuna was a friend of Kåñëa's, he accepted Him in this way, but this is not the case. Arjuna gave evidence that Vyäsadeva also accepted Kåñëa.

paraà brahma paraà dhäma
pavitraà paramaà bhavän
puruñaà çäçvataà divyam
ädi-devam ajaà vibhum

ähus tväm åñayaù sarve
devarñir näradas tathä
asito devalo vyäsaù
svayaà caiva bravéñi me

"Arjuna said: You are the Supreme Brahman, the ultimate, the supreme abode and purifier, the Absolute Truth and the eternal divine person. You are the primal God, transcendental and original, and You are the unborn and all-pervading beauty. All the great sages such as Närada, Asita, Devala and Vyäsa proclaim this of You, and now You Yourself are declaring it to me." (Bg. 10.12-13)

Vyäsadeva accepted Kåñëa as paraà brahma, and Vyäsadeva began his commentary on Vedänta-sütra with the words oà namo bhagavate väsudeväya. If we are actually interested in understanding, we must approach a representative of Vyäsadeva like Maitreya. Maitreya is also addressed as bhagavän, although of course the Supreme Bhagavän is Kåñëa Himself (kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam). But the word bhagavän also refers to other powerful persons like Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, Vyäsadeva or Maitreya. The actual Bhagavän is Kåñëa Himself, but these great personalities have attained as much knowledge of Kåñëa as possible. It is not possible to have cent per cent knowledge of Kåñëa. Not even Näräyaëa Himself is capable of that. Yet those who follow Kåñëa's instructions fully are sometimes called Bhagavän. There are many artificial Bhagavän's, but a real Bhagavän is one who knows what Kåñëa has taught. Vidura was very eager to receive transcendental knowledge, and because of this, Maitreya was very pleased with him. One can please the spiritual master simply by surrendering to him and rendering service, saying, "Sir, I am your most obedient servant. Please accept me and give me instructions." Although Arjuna was a very intimate friend of Kåñëa's, before receiving Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä he surrendered himself, saying, çiñyas te 'haà çädhi mäà tväà prapannam: "Now I am Your disciple and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me." (Bg. 2.7)

This is the proper way to ask for knowledge. One does not approach the spiritual master with a challenging spirit. One should also be inquisitive to understand the spiritual science. It is not that one considers himself superior to the guru. One must first find a guru to whom one can surrender, and if this is not possible, one shouldn't waste his time. By surrendering to the proper person, one can very quickly come to understand transcendental knowledge.

TLK 5: Lord Kapila Takes Charge of His Mother, Devahüti

CHAPTER FIVE
Lord Kapila Takes Charge of His Mother, Devahüti

TLK Vs 5

TEXT 5

maitreya uväca
pitari prasthite 'raëyaà
mätuù priya-cikérñayä
tasmin bindusare 'vätséd
bhagavän kapilaù kila

TRANSLATION

Maitreya said: When Kardama left for the forest, Lord Kapila stayed on the strand of the Bindu-sarovara to please His mother, Devahüti.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.5]

PURPORT

In the absence of the father it is the duty of the grown son to take charge of his mother and serve her to the best of his ability so that she will not feel separation from her husband. It is also the duty of the husband to leave home as soon as there is a grown son to take charge of his wife and family affairs. That is the Vedic system of household life. One should not remain continually implicated in household affairs up to the time of death. He must leave. Family affairs and the wife may be taken charge of by a grown son.

Being a great yogé, Kardama Muni was not very interested in family life. Nonetheless, he decided to marry, and Sväyambhuva Manu brought his daughter Devahüti to him to serve as a wife. Kardama Muni was a yogé living in a cottage, and Devahüti was a princess, a king's daughter. Not being used to work, she became very skinny, and Kardama Muni took compassion upon her, thinking, "This girl has come to me, but now she is not in a very comfortable position." Therefore by his yogic powers, Kardama Muni created a large palace with many servants, gardens and other opulences. Not only that, but he also created a great spaceship as large as a small city. Modern airlines have prepared a 747, and although these are very big, Kardama Muni, by his yogic powers, was able to create a spaceship wherein there were lakes, palaces and gardens. This spaceship could also travel all over the universe. Modern scientists labor very hard to make a small spaceship to go to the moon, but Kardama Muni could create a great spaceship that could travel to all planets. This is possible by yogic powers.

There are different siddhis, or yogic perfections—aëimä, laghimä, präpti, and so on—and whatever yogés choose to do, they can do. That is the real yoga system. It is not that one becomes a yogi simply by pressing his nose and performing some gymnastics. One must actually attain the yogic siddhis. By these siddhis, the yogé can become very small or very large, very heavy or very light. Whatever he wants, he can immediately produce in his hand, and he can travel wherever he desires. Kardama Muni was such a perfected siddhi-yogi. By his wife, Devahüti, he had nine daughters, who were distributed to the prajäpatis like Dakña Mahäräja and many others. The only son of Kardama Muni was Kapiladeva, an incarnation of Kåñëa. This Kapiladeva was one of the mahäjanas. The word mahäjana means "authority," and according to the Vedic çästras there are twelve authorities. These are Svayambhü, Närada, Çambhu, Kumära, Kapila, Manu, Prahläda, Janaka, Bhéñma, Bali, Çukadeva Gosvämé and Yamaräja. Svayambhü is Brahmä, and Çambhu is Lord Çiva. These authorities should be followed if we want to approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead and understand the purpose of religious life. Mahäjano yena gataù sa panthäù. These mahäjanas follow the principles set forth by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, in Bhagavad-gétä.

We cannot very easily understand the actual truth of religious systems, but if we follow these mahäjanas, we can understand. Kapila Muni explained the glories of devotional service to His mother, Devahüti. If we follow Him, we may learn the truth of devotional service. According to the system of varëäçrama-dharma, one who is over fifty years of age must leave home, go to the forest and completely devote his life to spiritual realization. This is the actual varëäçrama-dharma system. It is not a Hindu system, for the word "Hindu" is a name given by the Muslims and does not occur in any Vedic literature. However, the varëäçrama-dharma is mentioned. Civilized human beings should strictly follow the varëäçrama institution. If one is born a brähmaëa, he is trained nicely as a brahmacäré, and then he becomes a gåhastha, a householder. When he gives up his home, he is called a vänaprastha, and after that he may take sannyäsa. Being a yogé, Kardama Muni strictly followed these principles; therefore as soon as Kapiladeva was grown, Devahüti was placed in His charge. Kardama Muni then left home. As stated in this verse: pitari prasthite 'raëyaà mätuù priya-cikérñayä.

According to the Manu-saàhitä, a woman should never be given freedom. When she is not under the protection of her husband, she must be under the protection of her sons. Women cannot properly utilize freedom, and it is better for them to remain dependent. A woman cannot be happy if she is independent. That is a fact. In Western countries we have seen many women very unhappy simply for the sake of independence. That independence is not recommended by the Vedic civilization or by the varëäçrama-dharma. Consequently Devahüti was given to her grown son, Kapiladeva, and Kapiladeva was fully aware that He had to take care of His mother. It is the duty of the father to protect his daughter until she attains puberty and is married to a suitable young man. The husband then takes care of the wife. Generally a man should marry at around twenty-five years of age, and a girl should marry no later than sixteen. If this is the case, when the man is fifty years old, his eldest son should be around twenty-five, old enough to take charge of the mother. According to this calculation, Kapiladeva was about twenty-five years old and was quite able to take charge of His mother, Devahüti. He knew that because His father left His mother in His charge, He should take care of her and always please her. Mätuù priya-cikérñayä. Kapiladeva was not irresponsible, but was always ready to please His mother. Kapiladeva was a brahmacäré, and His mother took lessons from Him. That is the prerogative of the male. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (9.32):

mäà hi pärtha vyapäçritya
ye 'pi syuù päpa-yonayaù
striyo vaiçyäs tathä çüdräs
te 'pi yänti paräà gatim

"O son of Påthä, those who take shelter in Me, though they be of lower birth—women, vaiçyas [merchants] as well as çüdras [workers]—can approach the supreme destination." Women are considered on the same platform with çüdras, and although a woman may be married to a brähmaëa, she is not given the sacred thread. It is also said that the Mahäbhärata was compiled by Vyäsadeva because the direct Vedic knowledge could not be understood by women, çüdras and dvija-bandhus, those who are born in brähmaëa families but are not qualified brähmaëas. Stré-çüdra-dvijabandhünäà trayé na çruti-gocarä (Bhäg. 1.4.25). Consequently Mahäbhärata is called the fifth Veda. The four preceding Vedas are the Säma, Yajur, Åg and Atharva. The essence of Vedic knowledge, Bhagavad-gétä, is given within the Mahäbhärata. Women are inferior to men, and Vedic civilization is so perfect that men are given full charge of the women. It is therefore said: mätuù priya-cikérñayä. The son is always ready to see that the mother is not unhappy. Kapiladeva was anxious that His mother not feel the absence of His father, and He was ready to take the best care of her and give her knowledge. Because women are supposed to be less intelligent, they should be given knowledge, and they should also follow this knowledge. They should follow their father's instructions, their husband's instructions and the instructions of their grown, scholarly sons like Kapiladeva. In this way, their lives can be perfect. In all cases, women should always remain dependent.

Tasmin bindusare 'vätséd bhagavän kapilaù kila. It is noteworthy that in this verse Kapiladeva is referred to as Bhagavän, which indicates that He possesses all wealth, fame, knowledge, beauty, strength and renunciation. These six opulences are fully represented in Kåñëa; therefore Kåñëa is accepted as the Supreme Personality of Godhead (kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam), and others are accepted as His expansions, or incarnations (viñëu-tattva). In Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, Rüpa Gosvämé has analyzed the characteristics of Bhagavän. The first Bhagavän is Çré Kåñëa Himself, but some of His opulences are also bestowed upon Lord Brahmä. Lord Brahmä is a jéva-tattva, a living being like us. If we become spiritually powerful, we can also have the post of Lord Brahmä. Superior to Lord Brahmä is Lord Çiva, and superior to Lord Çiva is Viñëu, or Lord Näräyaëa, and superior to all is Kåñëa. That is the analysis of the Vedic çästras and Brahma-saàhitä. Even Çaìkaräcärya, the Mäyävädé impersonalist philosopher, accepts Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead (sa bhagavän svayaà kåñëaù). All the äcäryas—Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Viñëu Svämé, Nimbärka and Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu—also accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord.

Kapiladeva is an incarnation of Kåñëa, and He gave instructions to His mother, Devahüti. We must distinguish between the two Kapilas. One Kapila is this Bhagavän Kapila, and the other Kapila is the atheist Kapila. Bhagavän Kapila is also known as Devahüti-putra Kapila. Both Kapilas expounded Säìkhya philosophy, but the atheist Kapila expounded it without understanding, perception or realization of God. On the bank of the Bindu-sarovara Lake, Kapiladeva personally expounded Säìkhya philosophy to His mother, Devahüti, just as Kåñëa personally expounded the knowledge of Bhagavad-gétä to His friend Arjuna. Like Arjuna, Devahüti was aware that she was before her spiritual master, as indicated in the following verse. Indeed, Lord Brahmä had informed her that her son was a powerful incarnation.

TLK Vs 6

TEXT 6

tam äsénam akarmäëaà
tattva-märgägra-darçanam
sva-sutaà devahüty äha
dhätuù saàsmaraté vacaù

TRANSLATION

When Kapila, who could show her the ultimate goal of the Absolute Truth, was sitting leisurely before her, Devahüti remembered the words Brahmä had spoken to her, and she therefore began to question Kapila as follows.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.6]

PURPORT

The ultimate goal of the Absolute Truth is Kåñëa consciousness, devotional service. The liberated stage is not final. If we simply understand that we are not the body, that we are spirit soul, our knowledge is insufficient. We must also act as Brahman; then our position will be fixed.

brahmä-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

"One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman and becomes fully joyful. He never laments nor desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state he attains pure devotional service unto Me." (Bg. 18.54) Bhakti is obtainable for a liberated person; it is not for the conditioned soul. How is this possible? In Bhagavad-gétä (14.26) Kåñëa says:

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman."

We must engage in the nine processes of devotional service, the first of which is hearing (çravaëa). Then, under the direction of the spiritual master and the çästras, one can immediately become a liberated person. One doesn't have to endeavor separately to become liberated if he immediately engages in devotional service. One must have a firm conviction that he is engaged in Kåñëa's service and is free from all material contamination. This is imperative. The words tattva-märga-darçanam are elucidated elsewhere in Çrémad-Bhägavatam: brahmeti paramätmeti bhagavän iti çabdyate. The Absolute Truth is understood differently according to the position of the student. Some understand the Absolute Truth as impersonal Brahman, some as localized paramätmä, and others as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, or Viñëu. Brahman, Paramätmä and Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, are not different. They are simply different aspects of the complete Godhead. Looking at a mountain from a distance, we may see a hazy cloud, and if we come nearer, we may see something green. If we actually climb the mountain, we will find many houses, trees and animals. Our vision is of the same mountain, but due to our different positions we see haze, greenery or variegatedness. In the final stage, there are varieties—trees, animals, men, houses, and so on. The Absolute Truth is not without variety. Just as there is material variety, there is spiritual variety. Because the Mäyävädé philosophers are seeing the Absolute Truth from a distance, they think that the Absolute Truth has no variety. They consider variety to be material, but this is a misunderstanding. The Absolute Truth is described as variegated in Brahma-saàhitä (5.29):

cintämaëi-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña-
lakñävåteñu surabhér abhipälayantam
lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor, who is tending the cows, fulfilling all desires, in abodes built with spiritual gems and surrounded by millions of desire trees. He is always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds and thousands of goddesses of fortune."

There are Vaikuëöha planets in the spiritual world, and there are devotees who are all liberated. These devotees are akñara, which means they do not fall down into the material world. They remain in the spiritual world of the Vaikuëöhas. They are also persons like us, but they are eternal persons, complete with full knowledge and bliss. That is the difference between them and us. That is tattva jïäna. Unless we understand the variegatedness of the Absolute Truth, there is a chance that we will fall down. It is not sufficient simply to stick to the indefinite, impersonal feature of the Absolute Truth:

äruhya kåcchreëa paraà padaà tataù
patanty adho 'nädåta-yuñmad-aìghrayaù
(Bhäg. 10.2.32)

Because the impersonalists are not allowed to enter the Vaikuëöha planets, they simply remain in the Brahman effulgence. Thus they fall down again into material variety. We have seen many impersonalist sannyäsés who first of all give up the world as false (brahma satyaà jagan mithyä). They consider themselves Brahman (ahaà brahmäsmi), consider the world false (jagat is mithyä), and, having nothing more to do with the material world, finally say, "I have become Näräyaëa." Then they come to the stage of daridra-näräyaëa (poor Näräyaëa). They become Näräyaëa, but for want of anything better to do, for want of variegatedness, they take up material humanitarian activities. Although they consider their wives mithyä (false), they return. "You have already left. Why do you come back again?" the wives ask. This means that these so-called sannyäsés have nothing to do. They undergo severe penances and austerities to reach the platform of impersonal Brahman, but because there is no pleasure there, they again descend to enjoy material variety.

We may build a nice spaceship and send it off into space, and the astronauts may go up there and fly in the impersonal sky, but eventually they will become tired and pray to God, "Please let us return to land." We have read that the Russian astronauts were simply missing Moscow while they were traveling in space. This impersonal traveling is actually very agitating; similarly, impersonal realization of the Absolute Truth cannot be permanent because one wants variety. A falldown is inevitable. When one gentleman read my book Easy Journey to Other planets, he became very enthusiastic about going to other planets. "Oh, yes," I said, "we can go with this book." "Yes," the gentleman said, "then I shall come back." "Why return? You should remain there." "No, no," he said. "I don't want to remain. I just want to go and come back." This is the "enjoying" mentality. Without variety, we cannot enjoy. Variety is the mother of enjoyment, and Brahman realization or Paramätmä realization does not give us steady änanda, bliss. We want änanda. Änandamayo 'bhyäsät. The living entities are Brahman; Kåñëa is Para-brahman. Kåñëa is enjoying perpetual änanda, and, being part and parcel of Kåñëa, we also want änanda. Änanda cannot be impersonal or void; änanda entails variety. No one is simply interested in drinking milk and eating sugar, but with milk and sugar we can make a variety of foods—perä, barfé, kñéra, rabré, dahé, and so on. There are hundreds of preparations. In any case, variety is required for enjoyment.

The last word of tattva jïäna is to understand Kåñëa, who is full of variety. Kapiladeva is tattva-märgägra-darçanam. He is an incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and He will explain to His mother what tattva is, how one can approach the tattva jïäna, and how one can actually enjoy tattva jïäna. This is not simply dry speculation. This Kåñëa consciousness philosophy includes spiritual variety. People sometimes misunderstand this variety to be material, and they hanker for nirviçeña, niräkära, void. However, our philosophy is not void; it is full of variety and transcendental bliss. This will later be specifically enunciated by Lord Kapiladeva.

TLK 6: Devahüti Desires Transcendental Knowledge

CHAPTER SIX
Devahüti Desires Transcendental Knowledge

TLK Vs 7

TEXT 7

devahütir uväca
nirviëëä nitaräà bhümann
asad-indriya-tarñaëät
yena sambhävyamänena
prapannändhaà tamaù prabho

TRANSLATION

Devahüti said: I am very sick of the disturbance caused by my material senses, for because of this sense disturbance, my Lord, I have fallen into the abyss of ignorance

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.7]

PURPORT

Here, at the beginning of Devahüti's questionings, the word asad-indriya-tarñaëät is significant. Asat means "impermanent," "temporary," indriya means "senses," and tarñaëät refers to agitation. Thus asad-indriya-tarñaëät means "from being agitated by the temporarily manifest senses of the material body." We are evolving through different species of material bodily existence—sometimes in a human body, sometimes in an animal body—and therefore the engagements of our material senses are also changing. Anything which changes is called temporary, or asat. We should know that beyond these temporary senses are our permanent senses, which are now covered by the material body. The permanent senses, being contaminated by matter, are not acting properly. Devotional service, therefore, involves freeing the senses from this contamination. When the contamination is completely removed and the senses act in the purity of unalloyed Kåñëa consciousness, we have then attained sad-indriya, or eternal sense activities. Eternal sensory activities are called devotional service, whereas temporary sensory activities are called sense gratification. Unless one becomes tired of material sense gratification, there is no opportunity to hear transcendental messages from a person like Kapila. Devahüti expressed that she was tired. Now that her husband had left home, she wanted to get relief by hearing the instructions of Lord Kapila.

The Vedic literatures describe this material world as darkness. Actually it is dark, and therefore we require sunlight, moonlight and electricity. If it were not by nature dark, why would we require so many arrangements for artificial light? The Vedas enjoin that we should not remain in darkness: tamasi mä jyotir gama. We are instructed to go to the light, and that light is the spiritual world, which is directly lighted by the effulgence, or bodily rays, of Kåñëa. As stated in Brahma-saàhitä (5.40):

yasya prabhä prabhavato jagad-aëòa-koöi-
koöiñv açeña-vasudhädi-vibhüti-bhinnam
tad brahma niñkalam anantam açeña-bhütaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is endowed with great power. The glowing effulgence of His transcendental form is the impersonal Brahman, which is absolute, complete and unlimited and which displays the varieties of countless planets, with their different opulences, in millions and millions of universes."

Animals have no ability to know that they are in darkness, but human beings can know. Like Devahüti, an intelligent person should become disgusted with the darkness of ignorance. Na hanyate hanyamäne çarére. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (2.20), there is neither birth nor death for the soul. The soul is not destroyed when the body is annihilated. The soul puts bodies on and takes them off like clothes. This simple knowledge is instructed in the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä, yet there are many big scholars and leaders who still cannot understand that the body is different from the person. This is because they do not study Bhagavad-gétä in the proper way. Consequently no one is fully aware or convinced that the real person is not the body. This is called darkness, and when one is disgusted with this darkness, human life begins.

One who has become disgusted with material existence needs the instructions of a guru. Tasmäd guruà prapadyeta jijïäsuù çreya uttamam. Being the wife of a great yogé, Devahüti understood her constitutional position; therefore she is placing her problem before her son, Kapiladeva, an incarnation of God. Although Kapiladeva is her son, Devahüti does not hesitate to take instructions from Him. She does not say, "Oh, He is my son. What can He tell me? I am His mother, and I shall instruct Him." Instruction has to be taken from one who is in knowledge. It doesn't matter what his position is, whether he is a son, a boy, a çüdra, brähmaëa, sannyäsé or gåhastha. One should simply learn from one who knows. That is Caitanya Mahäprabhu's instruction. Although Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself was a brähmaëa and a sannyäsé, He took instructions from Rämänanda Räya, who was a çüdra and gåhastha but nonetheless, very exalted spiritually. When Caitanya Mahäprabhu saw that Rämänanda Räya was hesitant to give instructions, the Lord said, "Why are you hesitating? Although you are a gåhastha and are born in a çüdra family, I am prepared to take lessons from you."

kibä viprä, kibä nyäsé, çüdra kene naya
yei kåñëa-tattva-vettä, sei 'guru' haya
(Cc. Madhya 8.128)

This is Caitanya Mahäprabhu's teaching. Whoever is qualified in Kåñëa consciousness can become a guru. His family or material identity does not matter. He simply must know the science. When we consult an engineer, a doctor or a lawyer, we do not ask whether he is a brähmaëa or a çüdra. If he is qualified, he can help with a particular subject. Similarly, if one knows the science of Kåñëa, he can be a guru. Devahüti was taking lessons from her son because He knew the science of Kåñëa. Even if gold is in a filthy place, we should take it. It is also stated in the Vedas that if a girl is highly qualified or beautiful, she can be accepted in marriage even though born in a lower family. Thus it is not birth that is important, but qualification. Caitanya Mahäprabhu wanted everyone in India to know the science of Kåñëa and preach Kåñëa consciousness. This is very simple. We need only repeat what Kåñëa has said or what has been said about Kåñëa in the Vedic literatures.

Human society cannot be happy without Kåñëa consciousness. Kåñëa is the supreme enjoyer, and we are His servants. The master is enjoying, and the servants are helping the master enjoy. We living entities are eternal servants of God, and our duty is to help our master enjoy. Çrématé Rädhäräëé is the topmost servant of Kåñëa, and Her business is always to keep Kåñëa pleased. Kåñëa is very fond of Rädhäräëé because She renders the best service. Her sixty-four qualifications are mentioned in the Vedic literatures. Unfortunately, in the material world we are busy trying to enjoy our material senses. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (3.42):

indriyäëi paräëy ähur
indriyebhyaù paraà manaù
manasas tu parä buddhir
yo buddheù paratas tu saù

"The working senses are superior to dull matter; mind is higher than the senses; intelligence is still higher than the mind; and he (the soul) is even higher than the intelligence." The soul is on the spiritual platform. this way we become implicated in the laws of nature. As stated in the çästras:

nünaà pramattaù kurute vikarma
yad indriya-prétaya äpåëoti
na sädhu manye yata ätmano 'yam
asann api kleçada äsa dehaù

"When a person considers sense gratification the aim of life, he certainly becomes mad after materialistic living and engages in all kinds of sinful activity. He does not know that due to his past misdeeds he has already received a body which, although temporary, is the cause of his misery. Actually the living entity should not have taken on a material body, but he has been awarded the material body for sense gratification. Therefore I think it not befitting an intelligent man to involve himself again in the activities of sense gratification by which he perpetually gets material bodies one after another." (Bhäg. 5.5.4)

Living entities in this material world are very busy trying to gratify their senses. In the street we see many dogs assembled for sex. This may seem very crude, but human beings are engaged in the same business, perhaps in a more elaborate way. We should know that sense gratification is meant for animals, and that sense control is for human beings. By tapasya, penance, we can purify ourselves and regain our eternal life.

Actually our material senses are not our real senses. They are covered, just as the body is covered by clothes. Our real body is within the material body. Dehino 'smin yathä dehe. The spiritual body is within the material body. The material body is changing, going through childhood, youth, then old age, and then it vanishes. Although this is not our real body, we are engaged in sense gratification with it. However, for our own ultimate happiness, we should try to purify our senses. There is no question of destroying the senses or becoming desireless. Desire is a material activity, and becoming desireless is not possible. The senses must be purified in order for us to act through them transcendentally. Bhakti-yoga does not require us to destroy our senses, but to purify them. When the senses are purified, we can serve Kåñëa:

sarvopädhi-vinirmuktaà
tat-paratvena nirmalam
håñékeëa håñékeça-
sevanaà bhaktir ucyate

"Bhakti, or devotional service, means engaging all our senses in the service of the Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the master of all the senses. When the spirit soul renders service unto the Supreme, there are two side effects. One is freed from all material designations, and, simply by being employed in the service of the Lord, one's senses are purified." (Närada-païcarätra)

We can serve Håñékeça, the master of the senses, through the senses. We are part and parcel of Kåñëa, just as the hand is part and parcel of the body. Similarly, our senses are also part and parcel of the spiritual body of Kåñëa. When we purify our senses, we can act in our original constitutional position and serve Kåñëa. When we forget our position and try to satisfy ourselves, we become conditioned materially. When we forget that our duty is to serve Kåñëa, we fall into the material world and become implicated in personal sense gratification. As long as we continue trying to satisfy our own senses, we have to accept another body. Kåñëa is so kind that if we want to become tigers, He will give us a tiger body. If we want to become devotees, He will give us the body of a devotee. This life is a preparation for the next, and if we want to enjoy our transcendental senses, we have to purify ourselves to return home, back to Godhead. For this purpose, Devahüti is submitting to her son just as a disciple submits to his master.

TLK Vs 8

TEXT 8

tasya tvaà tamaso 'ndhasya
duñpärasyädya päragam
sac-cakñur janmanäm ante
labdhaà me tvad-anugrahät

TRANSLATION

Your Lordship is my only means of getting out of this darkest region of ignorance because You are my transcendental eye, which, by Your mercy only, I have attained after many, many births.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.8]

PURPORT

This verse is very instructive, since it indicates the relationship between the spiritual master and the disciple. The disciple or conditioned soul is put into this darkest region of ignorance and therefore is entangled in the material existence of sense gratification. It is very difficult to get out of this entanglement and attain freedom, but if one is fortunate enough to get the association of a spiritual master like Kapila Muni or His representative, then by his grace one can be delivered from the mire of ignorance. The spiritual master is therefore worshiped as one who delivers the disciple from the mire of ignorance with the light of the torch of knowledge. The word päragam is very significant. päragam refers to one who can take the disciple to the other side. This side is conditioned life; the other side is the life of freedom. The spiritual master takes the disciple to the other side by opening his eyes with knowledge. We are suffering simply because of ignorance. By the instruction of the spiritual master, the darkness of ignorance is removed, and thus the disciple is enabled to go to the side of freedom. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that after many, many births one surrenders to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Similarly, if, after many, many births, one is able to find a bona fide spiritual master and surrender to such a bona fide representative of Kåñëa, he can be taken to the side of light.

The bona fide spiritual master is a true Vedäntist, for he actually knows Vedänta and the Vedas and understands the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. The word veda means "knowledge," and anta means "last phase." There are different types of knowledge. We are interested in ordinary knowledge for economic benefit, but that is not actual knowledge. That is the art of livelihood. One may study to be an electrician and earn his livelihood by repairing electric lines. This kind of knowledge is called çilpa jïäna. Real knowledge, however, is Vedic knowledge, knowing oneself, what one is and what God is and understanding one's relationship with God, and one's duty.

One who is searching after knowledge is called jïänavän. Knowledge begins with the inquiry athäto brahma-jijïäsä: "what is Brahman?" Knowledge also begins by understanding the threefold miseries of the material world—ädhyätmika, ädhibhautika and ädhidaivika. We are suffering from miseries caused by other living entities and acts of nature as well as from miseries arising from the body and mind themselves. The soul is aloof from the body and mind, but he suffers due to material contamination. We have no control over these threefold miseries. They are controlled by Kåñëa's maidservant, Goddess Durgä, who is material nature. She is not independent of Kåñëa. However, she is so powerful that she can create and maintain. Prakåti, nature, can be very unkind. Mother Durgä is often portrayed as chastising demons by piercing them with a trident.

Those who are learned and intelligent look to the mercy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead for relief from the threefold miseries of material existence. Although this material world is nothing but darkness, people are very proud of their eyes. They are always saying, "Can you show me God?" The answer to that is: "Have you the eyes to see God?" Why is the emphasis placed on seeing? Certainly, God can be seen, as stated in Brahma-saàhitä (5.38), premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena: "Govinda [Kåñëa] is always seen by the devotee whose eyes are anointed by the pulp of love."

If we are devotees, lovers of God, the ointment of love will clear our eyes. In order to see God, we have to cleanse our eyes by wiping away the cataracts of material contamination. Although we may be eager to see God, we cannot see Him with these material eyes. Not only can we not see Him, but we cannot understand Him, although His name is there. Understanding God means first of all understanding His name. Therefore from the beginning we should chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. God is not different from His name. Kåñëa's name and Kåñëa's person are the same. "Absolute" means that Kåñëa's name, form, place, dress, pastimes and everything are nondifferent from Him. Kåñëa is present in His name, but because we have no love for Him, we cannot see Him.

Sanätana Gosvämé was a great learned scholar, and he was called a paëòita, which indicates that he was a learned brähmaëa. When Sanätana Gosvämé approached Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, he said, "The people in my neighborhood are calling me a paëòita, and I am very unhappy because of this." Caitanya Mahäprabhu asked, "Why are you dissatisfied?" Sanätana Gosvämé replied, "I am such a poor paëòita that I do not even know the goal of life. I do not even know what is beneficial for me. I am simply being carried away by sense gratification." In this way, Sanätana Gosvämé approached Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. He did not approach Him to get some gold or some medicine. He went to find out his real self-interest. This is the real purpose for approaching a guru.

Devahüti approached Lord Kapiladeva in the same way. She said, "My dear Kapila, You have come as my son, but You are my guru because You can inform me how I can cross the ocean of nescience, which is the material world." Thus one who feels the need to cross the dark ocean of nescience, which is material existence, requires a guru. It is not the guru's task to supply gold and medicine. Now it has become a fashion to keep a guru as if he were a dog or a cat. This is of no use. We must inquire about that portion of God's creation which is beyond this darkness. The Upaniñads and Bhagavad-gétä describe another world, beyond this material nature. According to Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (15.6):

na tad bhäsayate süryo
na çaçäìko na pävakaù
yad gatvä na nivartante
tad dhäma paramaà mama

"That abode of Mine is not illumined by the sun or moon, nor by electricity. One who reaches it never returns to this material world."

It is not possible for us to go to that paravyoma by material means. It is impossible to penetrate the material universe unless one understands Kåñëa. One can be enlightened by the mercy of God because Kåñëa Himself comes to give us information. If He does not come personally, He sends His devotee, or He leaves behind Him Bhagavad-gétä. However, we are so foolish that we do not take advantage of them. We do not take advantage of His devotee, who hankers to give this knowledge, sacrificing everything. Therefore Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu said:

brahmäëòa bhramite kona bhägyavän jéva
guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja

"The fallen, conditioned living entity, trapped by the external energy, loiters in the material world, but if by good fortune he meets a bona fide representative of the Lord, and if he takes advantage of such a guru, he receives the seed of devotional service." (Cc. Madhya 19.151)

The seed of devotional service is received by a most fortunate person. Those who are cultivating bhakti in the International Society for Krishna Consciousness are the most fortunate people in the world. By Kåñëa's mercy one can receive the bhakti-latä-béja, the seed of devotional service. Unless one is free from the reactions of sin, one cannot understand bhakti or Bhagavän. Therefore we must act piously by giving up illicit sex, intoxication, meat-eating and gambling. If we lead a pious life, we can understand God. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is engaged in training people to this end so that their lives will be successful.

TLK Vs 9

TEXT 9

ya ädyo bhagavän puàsäm
éçvaro vai bhavän kila
lokasya tamasändhasya
cakñuù sürya ivoditaù

TRANSLATION

You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the origin and Supreme Lord of all living entities. You have arisen to disseminate the rays of the sun in order to dissipate the darkness of the ignorance of the universe.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.9]

PURPORT

Kapila Muni is accepted as an incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. Here the word ädya means "the origin of all living entities," and puàsäm éçvaraù means "the Lord (éçvara) of the living entities" (éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù). Kapila Muni is the direct expansion of Kåñëa, who is the sun of spiritual knowledge. The sun dissipates the darkness of the universe, and when the light of the Supreme Personality of Godhead comes down, it at once similarly dissipates the darkness of mäyä. We have our eyes, but without the light of the sun, our eyes are of no value. Similarly, without the light of the Supreme Lord, or without the divine grace of the spiritual master, one cannot see things as they are.

In this verse, Devahüti also addresses her son as Bhagavän. Bhagavän is the Supreme Person. If we could just use a little common sense we could understand that an organization requires a leader. Without a leader, we cannot organize anything. Foolish philosophers say that the universe automatically came into being by nature. They say that in the beginning there was a chunk, and this cosmic manifestation came out of that chunk of matter. But where did this chunk come from? The fact is that there must be a brain, a leader, behind anything organized. We have information of this leader from the Vedas: nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm. The Supreme Lord is eternal, and we are also eternal. But the Supreme Lord is one, and we are many. The Supreme Lord is very great, and we are very small. He is all-pervading and infinite, and we are finite and infinitesimal. Even if we analyze the creation, we will find that not everyone is on the same level. One person is more intelligent or opulent than another. If we analyze things in this way, we will come to the demigods, and among them we will find that the most important demigod is Lord Brahmä. He is the original creature within this universe, yet he is not the most intelligent being. It is said that in the beginning, Brahmä received knowledge from the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

Recently newspapers are reporting that faith in a personal God is diminishing. This means that people are becoming more and more foolish. This is natural in Kali-yuga, for as the age of Kali progresses, bodily strength, memory and mercy diminish. We actually see that the present generation is not as strong as the previous. People also have short memories. We also understand that sometimes people are killed while other people pass by, not caring. Thus mercy is also diminishing. Because everything is diminishing, God consciousness is diminishing also; therefore it is natural to receive news that faith in a personal God is diminishing. In Bhagavad-gétä (7.15), one who does not accept a personal God is described as a müòha, a fool.

na mäà duñkåtino müòhäù
prapadyante narädhamäù
mäyayäpahåta jïänä
äsuraà bhävam äçritäù

"Those miscreants who are grossly foolish, lowest among mankind, whose knowledge is stolen by illusion, and who partake of the atheistic nature of demons, do not surrender unto Me."

Actually, people today do not even know the meaning of God, so there is no question of surrender. There are also those who are scholarly and well educated, but their knowledge is taken away by mäyä, illusion. Although they may superficially hold degrees, they have no real knowledge. They are also asuras, demons who simply defy God, saying, "I am God, you are God. Why are you searching for God? There are many Gods loitering in the street. Take care of them." Therefore it is not surprising that newspapers report that faith in a personal God is decreasing. Nonetheless, God is a person. Ya ädyo bhagavän. Lord Brahmä also worships Kåñëa by saying, govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi. He says, "I worship that original person, Govinda." Ädi-puruñam, Kåñëa, has no one preceding Him; therefore He is called original. It is said that Kåñëa was born of Vasudeva, but this simply means that Kåñëa accepted Vasudeva as His father. Çré Kåñëa deals with His devotees in different relationships, or rasas—çänta, däsya, sakhya, vätsalya and mädhurya.

We all have some relationship with Kåñëa, but presently that is covered. Therefore we have to revive it. Simple appreciation of the Supreme is called çänta-rasa. When one appreciates the Supreme fully, he wishes to render some service, and that is called däsya. When one becomes more intimate, he becomes a friend of Kåñëa's, and that is called sakhya. When one is more advanced, he wants to render service to Kåñëa as a father or a mother, and this is vätsalya. Being a father or a mother means serving the son. The Christian conception of God as the Supreme Father is not very perfect because if we conceive of God as a father, our position will be to take things from Him. Everyone wants to take something from the father. One is always saying, "Father, give me this. Father, give me that." However, accepting the Supreme Lord as one's son means rendering service. Yaçodämayé got Kåñëa as her son, and she was always anxious that He not be in danger. Thus she was always protecting Him. Actually Kåñëa protects the entire universe, but Yaçodä was giving protection to Kåñëa. This is Vaiñëava philosophy. Yaçodä became mad when she saw Kåñëa taken away by the Tåëävarta demon. However, Kåñëa became so heavy that the demon could not fly in the sky, and thus the demon fell to the earth and died. Yaçodä immediately said, "God has saved my Kåñëa!" She then began to thank some other God, some devatä. She did not know that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. If she had thought of Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the relationship between mother and son would have been destroyed. Therefore Kåñëa was playing just like an ordinary child, and Mother Yaçodä was treating Him as her son. Kåñëa's friends, the cowherd boys, did not consider Him the Supreme Lord either. The gopés even used to chastise Kåñëa. If a devotee can have such a relationship with Kåñëa, why should he want to become one with God? It is better to be God's father, God's controller. This is bhakti-märga, the path of devotional service. A devotee does not want to be equal to God or one with God. He simply wants to render service.

In order to understand the Absolute Truth, we have to understand the meaning of Bhagavän. Devahüti was not an ordinary woman. She was the wife of Kardama Muni, a great yogé. She had obviously learned something from her husband, for had she not been very exalted, how could Bhagavän Kapiladeva have become her son? Everyone should know what is Bhagavän and take lessons from Bhagavän. Lord Kapila is Bhagavän, and He personally instructed His mother in Säìkhya philosophy. By this knowledge we can develop or awaken our dormant love for God. Then we can see God when our eyes are anointed with love for Him. Indeed, we can see God everywhere and at all times. We will see God and nothing but God. We will see God not only within our hearts. If we go to the ocean, we will see God. If one is a little thoughtful, he will see that the great ocean stays in its place. The ocean has received its orders not to go beyond such and such a limit. Any intelligent man can see God while walking down the beach. However, this requires a little intelligence. People who are asses, müòhas, duñkåtés, cannot see God, but those who are intelligent can see God everywhere because God is omnipresent. He is within the universe and within our heart, and He is even within the atom. Why are we saying that we cannot see Him? God says, "Try to see Me in this way, but if you are too dull, then try to see Me another way."

What is the easy way? Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä, "I am the taste of water." Is there anyone who has not tasted water? He also says, "I am the light of the sun." Is there anyone who has not seen sunshine? Then why are people saying, "I have not seen God"? First of all we have to try to see God. It is as easy as ABCD. When we see God everywhere, we will see the personal God. Then we will understand.

Bhagavän puàsäm éçvaraù. Bhagavän is éçvara, the controller. We are not independent. No one can actually say, "I am independent." We are bound tightly by the modes of material nature, and yet we are thinking that we are independent. This is simply foolishness. Therefore it is said that all the people in the material world are blinded by the darkness of ignorance. When people are blind, out of their ignorance they say, "There is no God. I cannot see God." Then God comes as Kåñëa or Kapiladeva and says, "Here I am. See My features. I am a person. I play the flute and enjoy Myself in Våndävana. Why can't you see Me?" Thus God comes, explains Himself and leaves behind His instruction, Bhagavad-gétä. Still, people are so foolish that they claim not to understand God. If we try to see God through the instructions given to Devahüti by Lord Kapila, our lives will be successful.

TLK Vs 10

TEXT 10

atha me deva sammoham
apäkrañöuà tvam arhasi
yo 'vagraho 'haà mametéty
etasmin yojitas tvayä

TRANSLATION

Now be pleased, my Lord, to dispel my great delusion. Due to my feeling of false ego, I have been engaged by Your mäyä and have identified myself with the body and consequent bodily relations.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.10]

PURPORT

Mäyä is the false ego of identifying one's body with one's self and of claiming things possessed in relationship with the body. In Bhagavad-gétä, Fifteenth Chapter [15.15], the Lord says, "I am sitting in everyone's heart, and from Me comes everyone's remembrance and forgetfulness." Devahüti has stated that false identification of the body with the self and attachment for bodily possessions are also under the direction of the Lord. Does this mean that the Lord discriminates by engaging one in His devotional service and another in sense gratification? If that were true, it would be an incongruity on the part of the Supreme Lord, but that is not the actual fact. As soon as the living entity forgets his real constitutional position of eternal servitorship to the Lord and wants instead to enjoy himself by sense gratification, he is captured by mäyä. This capture leads to the consciousness of false identification with the body and attachment for the possessions of the body. These are the activities of mäyä, and since mäyä is also an agent of the Lord, it is indirectly the action of the Lord. The Lord is merciful; if anyone wants to forget Him and enjoy this material world, He gives him full facility, not directly but through the agency of His material potency. Therefore, since the material potency is the Lord's energy, indirectly it is the Lord who gives the facility to forget Him. Devahüti therefore said, "My engagement in sense gratification was also due to You. Now kindly get me free from this entanglement."

By the grace of the Lord one is allowed to enjoy this material world, but when one is disgusted with material enjoyment and is frustrated, and when one sincerely surrenders unto the lotus feet of the Lord, then the Lord is so kind that He frees one from entanglement. Kåñëa says, therefore, in Bhagavad-gétä, "First of all surrender, and then I will take charge of you and free you from all reactions of sinful activities." Sinful activities are those activities performed in forgetfulness of our relationship with the Lord. In this material world, activities for material enjoyment that are considered pious are also sinful. For example, one sometimes gives money in charity to a needy person with a view to get back the money four times increased. Giving with the purpose of gaining something is called charity in the mode of passion. Everything done here is done in the modes of material nature, and therefore all activities but service to the Lord are sinful. Because of sinful activities we become attracted by the illusion of material attachment, and we think, "I am this body." I think of the body as myself and of bodily possessions as "mine." Devahüti requested Lord Kapila to free her from that entanglement of false identification and false possession.

In asking this, Devahüti is accepting her son, Kapila, as her guru. He consequently tells her how to solve all material problems. Material life is nothing but sex attraction. Puàsaù striyä mithuné-bhävam etam (Çrémad-Bhägavatam 5.5.8). Material life means that men are after women and women are after men. We find this not only in human society but in bird, dog, cat and demigod society. As soon as people join to satisfy their sex desire, the attraction becomes greater and greater. An apartment is needed for privacy, and then one has to earn a livelihood and acquire some land. Without children, married life is frustrated, and of course the children have to be educated. Thus one becomes entangled in material life by creating so many situations, but at the time of death Kåñëa comes and takes away everything—house, land, wife, children, friends, reputation and whatever. Then we have to begin another life. It is not that we simply die and finish everything. We are living eternally; the body is finished, but we have to accept another body out of the 8,400,000 forms. In this way, our life is going on, but we are thinking in terms of wife, children, and so forth. This is all illusion.

In any case, we will not be allowed to stay here, and although we are attached to all this, everything will be taken away at death. Whatever post we are occupying—be it president or Lord Brahmä—we are occupying temporarily. We may be here five years, ten years, one hundred years or five million years. Whatever, our position is limited. Our position in the material world is not eternal, but we are eternal. Why, then, should we be illusioned by the noneternal? By nature we are part and parcel of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha. In order to transcend the darkness of material life and go to the world of light, we need to approach a guru. It is for this reason that Devahüti is approaching Lord Kapiladeva.

In the morning, when the sun arises, the darkness of night immediately goes away. Similarly, when God or His incarnation comes, the darkness of material life is dissipated. When Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, came, Arjuna's illusion was dispelled. He was thinking, "Why should I fight with my relatives?" Actually the whole world is going on under this conception of "my" and "mine." There are fights between nations, societies, communities and families. People are thinking, "Why are you interfering with my business?" Then there is a fight. Because of illusion, we do not consider these situations temporary. On a train, people may argue and fight over a seat, but one who knows that he will only be on the train for two or three hours thinks, "Why should I fight? I shall only be here for a short while." One person thinks in this way, and the other person is ready to fight, thinking that his seat is permanent. No one will be allowed to stay within this material world; everyone will have to change his body and position, and as long as one remains here, he will have to fight and struggle for existence. This is the way of material life. We may temporarily make some compromises, but ultimately the material world is full of misery.

We are very much attached to this material world, but according to the Vedic system, renunciation is compulsory, for when one reaches the age of fifty, he renounces his family life. Nature gives warning, "You are now past fifty. That's all right. You have fought in this material world. Now stop this business." Children play on the beach and make houses out of sand, but after a while the father comes and says, "Now, my dear children, time is up. Stop this business and come home." This is the business of the guru—to teach his disciples detachment. The world is not our place; our place is Vaikuëöhaloka. Kåñëa also comes to remind us of this. The dharma, or order, of the Supreme Person is to become His devotee and always think of Him. Kåñëa says:

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru

"Engage your mind always in thinking of Me, offer obeisances and worship Me." (Bhagavad-gétä 9.34)

In this way, Kåñëa opens the door, but we unfortunately do not accept Him. Kåñëa tells Arjuna, "Because you are My friend, I am revealing to you the most confidential dharma." What is that? "Simply surrender unto Me." This is the dharma taught by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and Kåñëa's incarnation and His devotee will teach the same dharma.

We are all after happiness, but we do not know how to enjoy happiness. We want to enjoy our senses, but it is not possible with these covered false senses. The senses must be opened, and that is the process of purification. We are thinking of ourselves according to so many false material identifications, but we should take Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu's advice: jévera 'svarüpa' haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa.' We must come to understand, "I am the eternal servant of Kåñëa." After all, our senses are employed for the satisfaction of somebody—either for ourselves or for someone else. That is käma, krodha, lobha and matsara—illusion. If we are not serving our own lusty desires (käma), we are serving anger (krodha). If I am the master of anger, I can control my anger, and if I am the master of my desires, I can control my desires. In any case, I am a servant, and my service should be transferred to Kåñëa. That is the perfection of life.

If we are situated in the transcendental position (bhakti), we can understand Kåñëa, Kåñëa cannot be understood by mental speculation; otherwise He would have said that He could be understood by jïäna, karma or yoga. However, He clearly says, bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti: "Only by devotional service can I be understood." If we want to know Kåñëa as He is, we have to accept the process of bhakti. It is this bhakti process that Kapiladeva will reveal to Devahüti.

TLK Vs 11

TEXT 11

taà tvä gatähaà çaraëaà çaraëyaà
sva-bhåtya-saàsära-taroù kuöhäram
jijïäsayähaà prakåteù püruñasya
namämi sad-dharma-vidäà variñöham

TRANSLATION

Devahüti continued: I have taken shelter of Your lotus feet because You are the only person of whom to take shelter. You are the ax which can cut the tree of material existence. I therefore offer my obeisances unto You, who are the greatest of all transcendentalists, and I inquire from You as to the relationship between man and woman and between spirit and matter.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.11]

PURPORT

Säìkhya philosophy, as is well known, deals with prakåti and puruña. Puruña is the Supreme Personality of Godhead or anyone who imitates the Supreme Personality of Godhead as an enjoyer, and prakåti is nature. In this material world, material nature is being exploited by the puruñas, or the living entities. The intricacies in the material world of the relationship of the prakåti and puruña, or the enjoyed and the enjoyer, give rise to saàsära, or material entanglement. Devahüti wanted to cut the tree of material entanglement, and she found the suitable weapon in Kapila Muni. The tree of material existence is explained in the Fifteenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä as an açvattha tree whose root is upward and whose branches are downward. It is recommended there that one has to cut the root of this material existential tree with the ax of detachment. What is the attachment? The attachment involves prakåti and puruña. The living entities are trying to lord it over material nature. Since the conditioned soul takes material nature to be the object of his enjoyment, and he takes the position of the enjoyer, he is therefore called puruña.

Devahüti questioned Kapila Muni, for she knew that only He could cut her attachment to this material world. The living entities, in the guises of men and women, are trying to enjoy the material energy; therefore in one sense everyone is puruña because puruña means "enjoyer," and prakåti means "enjoyed." In this material world both so-called men and women are imitating the real puruña; the Supreme Personality of Godhead is actually the enjoyer in the transcendental sense, whereas all others are prakåti.

In Bhagavad-gétä, matter is analyzed as aparä, or inferior nature, whereas beyond this inferior nature there is another, superior nature—the living entities. Living entities are also prakåti, or enjoyed, but under the spell of mäyä, the living entities are falsely trying to take the position of enjoyers. That is the cause of saàsära-bandha, or conditional life. Devahüti wanted to get out of conditional life and place herself in full surrender. The Lord is çaraëya, which means "the only worthy personality to whom one can fully surrender," because He is full of all opulences. If anyone actually wants relief, the best course is to surrender unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Lord is also described here as sad-dharma-vidäà variñöham. This indicates that of all transcendental occupations, the best is eternal loving service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Dharma is sometimes translated as "religion," but that is not exactly the meaning. Dharma actually means "that which one cannot give up," "that which is inseparable from oneself." The warmth of fire is inseparable from fire; therefore warmth is called the dharma, or nature, of fire. Similarly, sad-dharma means "eternal occupation." That eternal occupation is engagement in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. The purpose of Kapiladeva's Säìkhya philosophy is to propagate pure, uncontaminated devotional service, and therefore He is addressed here as the most important personality among those who know the transcendental occupation of the living entity.

As pointed out before, Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is everyone's real shelter (çaraëaà çaraëyam). Everyone is seeking shelter because we are all constitutionally servants. Originally we are servants of God; therefore it is our nature to take His shelter. Some seek an occupation or the service of a great man; others seek the service of the government or whatever. In any case, the ultimate shelter is Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Being Kåñëa's incarnation, Kapiladeva is also a shelter. Kåñëa has unlimited forms and unlimited incarnations. It is said in Çrémad-Bhägavatam that His incarnations are expanding continuously, like waves in the ocean. Indeed, we cannot even count them. In Brahma-saàhitä it is said: Advaitam acyutam anädim ananta-rüpam. In India there are many thousands of temples, and within these temples there are arcä-vigrahas, Deities. All these Kåñëas are nondifferent; they are one. Kåñëa resides in Vaikuëöha and also in the temple. The Kåñëas are not different, although they are ananta, unlimited. Kåñëa is also the witness within everyone's heart, and He is seeing all of our activities. We cannot hide anything from Him, and we receive the results of our karma because the witness is Kåñëa Himself within the heart. How, then, can we avoid Him? Without Kåñëa's permission, we cannot do anything. Why does Kåñëa give us permission to do something wrong? He does so because we persist. Actually He does not tell us to do anything other than surrender unto Him. We want to do something, and Kåñëa may sanction it, but we go ahead and do it at our own risk. Kåñëa is not responsible. However, we should know that without the sanction of Kåñëa, we cannot do anything. That is a fact. Actually we are constitutionally servants of Kåñëa. Even though we may declare ourselves independent, we are not. Rather, we are servants falsely declaring that we are independent. Self-realization is understanding that we are dependent on the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As Caitanya Mahäprabhu says:

ayi nanda-tanuja kiìkaraà
patitaà mäà viñame bhavämbudhau
kåpayä tava päda-paìkaja-
sthita-dhülé-sadåçaà vicintaya

"My dear Lord Kåñëa, son of Mahäräja Nanda, I am Your eternal servant, but somehow or other I have fallen into this ocean of nescience. Please pick Me up from this ocean of death and place Me as one of the atoms at Your lotus feet." (Çikñäñöaka 5) Because we are under illusion, Devahüti says: sva-bhåtya-saàsära-taroù kuöhäram. In Bhagavad-gétä (15.1-4), material existence is likened unto a banyan tree with its roots upward and its branches below. The roots of this banyan tree are very strong, but they can be cut with an ax (kuöhäram). By taking shelter of Kåñëa's lotus feet, we can cut the strong root of material existence. Because we have given up Kåñëa's service, we have become servants of so many things. We are obliged to serve our parents, wife, children, country and so forth. We are indebted to many people and to the demigods who give heat and light. Although we are not paying the bill, we are taking advantage of the sunlight and the sun's heat. If we take advantage of electricity, we have to pay the bill, but we don't pay the sun bill. This means that we are actually indebted to the sun-god, Vivasvän. Similarly, the King of heaven, Indra, is supplying water in the form of rain. Rascals say that all this comes about by nature, but they do not know that nature is controlled. If we don't pay our debts by performing sacrifices, there will certainly be a scarcity. All of these things are coming from the Supreme Father, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but we are thinking that they are coming from nature, and we are utilizing them without caring whether we pay the bill or not. It is all right to use our father's property, but at the present moment we are not acting as our Father's sons; we are mäyä's sons. We do not care for our Father; however, nature is nonetheless working under His direction. If we do not care for Him, nature will reduce her supply, for nature will not allow demons to flourish. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (16.19):

tän ahaà dviñataù krürän
saàsäreñu narädhamän
kñipämy ajasram açubhän
äsuréñv eva yoniñu

"Those who are envious and mischievous, who are the lowest among men, are cast by Me into the ocean of material existence, into various demoniac species of life."

Demons are always subject to be punished, and great demons like Rävaëa and Hiraëyakaçipu are personally punished by the Lord. Otherwise, ordinary demons are punished by the laws of material nature. Kåñëa does not need to come to punish the petty demons, but when there are great demons like Rävaëa, Hiraëyakaçipu and Kaàsa, the Lord comes as Lord Rämacandra, Lord Nåsiàha-deva or Çré Kåñëa to punish them. If we do not want to be punished, we have to follow the rules and regulations (sad-dharma). Dharma means "the laws given by God." Dharmaà tu säkñäd bhagavat-praëétam. The laws are given by Bhagavän and are written in books like Manu-saàhitä and other Vedic literatures. According to the law, we have to obey the government, and according to dharma, we have to obey Kåñëa, God. We cannot manufacture our laws at home, and we cannot manufacture dharma. If one tries, he is simply cheating the public. Such false dharmas are kicked out of Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.1.2): dharmaù projjhita-. The real dharma is set forth by Çré Kåñëa when He says: sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja (Bhagavad-gétä 18.66). All other dharmas are simply forms of cheating. We must accept the principles of Bhagavad-gétä, which constitute the ABC'S of dharma. Actually, we only have to accept the principle of surrender unto Kåñëa, but this acceptance comes after many, many births. It is not very easy, for only after many births of struggle does one come to his real perfection and surrender unto Kåñëa. At this time he understands perfectly that Väsudeva, Kåñëa, is everything. This is the greatest lesson of Bhagavad-gétä, Everything is Kåñëa's energy, and whatever we see is but an exhibition of two types of energy. Everyone knows that the sun has two types of energy—heat and light. Similarly, Kåñëa has an external energy and an internal energy, and He also has a marginal energy, which is a mixture of the other two. The external energy is this material world, the internal energy is the spiritual world, and the marginal energy is the living entity. The living entity is marginal because he can remain in the material world or the spiritual world. Bhagavad-gétä describes two types of living entities, kñara and akñara, those living in the material world and those in the spiritual world. Those who have fallen into the material world are attracted by the tree of saàsära, the banyan tree of material existence described in Bhagavad-gétä (fifteenth Chapter).

It is essential that we disassociate ourselves from this tree by detachment. Cutting down this tree is very difficult, but it is possible with the weapon of detachment. There is a Bengali proverb that states: "I'll catch the fish, but I will not touch the water." That type of intelligence is required. In America we see many old men on the beach who have retired from their business to waste their time trying to catch fish. They are not very cautious, and they touch the water. However, we have to live in this material world in such a way that we do everything for Kåñëa but do not touch the water of the material world. In this way, we will have no attachment to things of this material world. We may have many great temples, but we should not be attached to them. It is for Kåñëa's sake that we construct temples, but we must understand that the temples are Kåñëa's property. Our mission is to teach people that everything belongs to Kåñëa. Only a thief will occupy something belonging to another and claim it to be his.

The Kåñëa consciousness movement preaches that everything belongs to Kåñëa and that everything should be utilized for Kåñëa's benefit. He is the beneficiary of everything, and it is to our benefit that we come to this knowledge. Éçäväsyam idaà sarvam. If one realizes that everything belongs to Kåñëa, one becomes the greatest mahätmä. Being a mahätmä does not mean that one wears a big beard and a particular type of dress. No, this awareness must be there. Whatever we have should be offered to Kåñëa. If we have first-class food, we should offer it to Him. If we have nothing, we can offer Him a leaf, a flower, a little water or fruit. This can he collected by anyone anywhere without having to pay money. As Çré Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä (9.26):

patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà
yo me bhaktyä prayacchati
tad ahaà bhakty-upahåtam
açnämi prayatätmanaù

"If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit or water, I will accept it."

The point is that we should offer something to Kåñëa with devotion. It is not that Kåñëa is hungry and is asking for food. No, He is feeding everyone, supplying everyone with all the necessities: eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän (Kaöha Upaniñad 2.2.13). What, then, is He requesting? He is asking for bhakti, devotion, because He wants us to love Him. We are suffering in this material world, entangled in the tree of material existence, moving from one branch to another, and because of this we are suffering. Kåñëa does not want us to suffer, jumping like monkeys from branch to branch. We must come to Him and surrender to Him. When we come to this knowledge, we become perfect in knowledge. When we take shelter at the lotus feet of Kåñëa, we are no longer debtors to anyone. Na kiìkaro näyam åëé (Çrémad-Bhägavatam 11.5.41). Kåñëa assures us, ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo mokñayiñyämi: "I'll give you all relief." (Bhagavad-gétä 18.66) This is what we actually want. Therefore Devahüti herein takes shelter of Kapiladeva and tells Him, "You are the ax capable of making me detached." When our attachment to the material world is severed, we become free. Bhakti is the means by which we can develop this detachment. Vairägya-vidyä-nija-bhakti-yoga. Bhakti-yoga is the science of detachment. This verse was composed by Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya when he understood that Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu was the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya was a great logician, and he composed a hundred verses to Caitanya Mahäprabhu, wherein he tells the Lord:

vairägya-vidyä-nija-bhakti-yoga-
çikñärtham ekaù puruñaù puräëaù
çré-kåñëa-caitanya-çaréra-dhari
kåpämbudhir yas tam ahaà prapadye

"Let me take shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, who has descended in the form of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu to teach us real knowledge, His devotional service, and detachment from whatever does not foster Kåñëa consciousness. He has descended because He is an ocean of transcendental mercy. Let me surrender unto His lotus feet." (Cc. Madhya 6.254)

When a person advances in bhakti-yoga, he will automatically become detached from material attractions. There are many American and European boys and girls in this Kåñëa consciousness movement who have been born in countries where they can enjoy a good deal of material affluence, but they consider this material happiness and affluence like garbage in the street. Because they are devotees of Väsudeva, they are no longer attached to these material things. This is the result of bhakti-yoga, which enables one to be detached from material enjoyment. That detachment is the sign that one is advancing in bhakti-yoga. Bhaktiù pareçänubhavo viraktir anyatra ca (Çrémad-Bhägavatam 11.2.42). That is the test of advancing in bhakti. If we are advanced, we are no longer attached to material enjoyment. It is not that we think ourselves great devotees and then go ahead and enjoy material things. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (5.22):

ye hi saàsparça-jä bhogä
duùkha-yonaya eva te
ädy-antavantaù kaunteya
na teñu ramate budhaù

"An intelligent person does not take part in the sources of misery, which are due to contact with the material senses. O son of Kunté, such pleasures have a beginning and an end, and so the wise man does not delight in them." When one sees something superior, he immediately rejects that which is inferior. Actually we cannot bring all this about by our own endeavor; therefore we have to take shelter of Kåñëa, and He will help. Since our only business is to take shelter of Kåñëa, Devahüti says, "I am taking shelter of You so that You can cut my attachment to this material life. Why should You do this? Because I am Your eternal servant."

Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says, anädi karama-phale, paòi 'bhavärëava-jale, taribäre nä dekhi upäya. If we are thrown into the ocean, there is a great struggle, even if we may be very great swimmers. There is no peace in this material world, however expert we may be in dealing with it. There is nothing but struggle. We cannot live here peacefully. It is not possible. Even if we are nonviolent and hurt no one, there will be trouble. However, if somehow or other we manage to reach the shore, we will find peace. There is peace even if we are an inch out of the water. Tava päda-paìkaja-sthita-dhülé sadåçaà vicintaya (Çikñäñöaka 5). If somehow or other we become one of the particles of dust at Kåñëa's lotus feet, we will be liberated.

We may be a Hindu or a Muslim or a Christian for fifty or sixty years, or at the utmost one hundred, but again we have to take birth and be something else. We are thinking in terms of these religious designations, which are called asad-dharma, meaning that they may change at any moment. But what is our real dharma? Real dharma is sad-dharma, that which will not change, and this sad-dharma necessitates surrendering unto Kåñëa. This dharma will continue eternally. There are many propounders of sad-dharma, but actually the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the best propounder because He knows the reality. It is therefore said of the Gosvämés: nänä-çästra-vicäraëaika-nipuëau sad-dharma-saàsthäpakau. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu's direct disciples, the Gosvämés, tried to establish sad-dharma, and we are trying to follow in their footsteps by establishing real dharma throughout the world with this Kåñëa consciousness movement.

TLK 7: Lord Kapila Begins to Explain Self-realization

CHAPTER SEVEN
Lord Kapila Begins to Explain Self-realization

TLK Vs 12

TEXT 12

maitreya uväca
iti sva-mätur niravadyam épsitaà
niçamya puàsäm apavarga-vardhanam
dhiyäbhinandyätmavatäà satäà gatir
babhäña éñat-smita-çobhitänanaù

TRANSLATION

After hearing of His mother's uncontaminated desire for transcendental realization, the Lord thanked her within Himself for her questions, and thus, His face smiling, He explained the path of the transcendentalists, who are interested in self-realization.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.12]

PURPORT

Devahüti has surrendered her confession of material entanglement and her desire to gain release. Her questions to Lord Kapila are very interesting for persons who are actually trying to get liberation from material entanglement and attain perfection. Unless one is interested in understanding his spiritual life, or his constitutional position, and unless he also feels inconvenience in material existence, his human form of life is spoiled. Only a foolish man does not care for the transcendental necessities of life and simply engages like an animal in eating, sleeping, defending and mating. Lord Kapila was very much satisfied by His mother's questions because the answers stimulate one's desire for liberation from the conditional life of material existence. Such questions are called apavarga-vardhanam. Those who are actually spiritually interested are called sat, or devotees. Satäà prasaìgät. Sat means "that which eternally exists," and asat means "that which is not eternal." Unless one is situated on the spiritual platform, he is not sat; he is asat. The asat stands on a platform which will not exist, but anyone who stands on the spiritual platform will exist eternally. As spirit soul, everyone exists eternally, but the asat has accepted the material world as his shelter, and therefore he is full of anxiety. Asad-grahät, the desire to enjoy matter, is the cause of the soul's being asat. Actually, the spirit soul is not asat. As soon as one is conscious of this fact and takes to Kåñëa consciousness, he becomes sat. Satäà gatiù, the path of the eternal, is very interesting to persons who are after liberation, and His Lordship Kapila began to speak about that path.

Those who are sat are thus transcendentalists advanced in spiritual life, and when they hear questions from those who want to understand spiritual life, they become very happy. Transcendentalists are not interested in worldly talks. Indeed, worldly talks are very disgusting to them, and they avoid the company of those who talk about nonsensical worldly affairs. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu advised His disciples: grämya-kathä nä çunibe. The word grämya refers to that pertaining to one's village, society or neighborhood. People are interested in talking about grämya-kathä. Newspapers, for instance, are filled with grämya-kathä. There is no spiritual understanding in them. In the United States there are many newspapers, and simply to publish the New York Times many trees have to be killed. Now there is a paper scarcity. Why are they uselessly killing trees just for grämya-kathä? They are only interested in making a profit.

There is, however, another kind of kathä—kåñëa-kathä. There are literatures which may be nicely presented from the literary point of view, but if there is no glorification of the Supreme Lord, they are useless.

na yad vacaç citra-padaà harer yaço
jagat-pavitraà pragåëéta karhicit
tad väyasaà tértham uçanti mänasä
na yatra haàsä niramanty uçik-kñayäù

"Those words which do not describe the glories of the Lord, who alone can sanctify the atmosphere of the whole universe, are considered by saintly persons to be like unto a pilgrimage for crows. Since the all-perfect persons are inhabitants of the transcendental abode, they do not derive any pleasure there." (Bhäg. 1.5.10)

Worldly literatures are like places where crows take pleasure. In the bird society, there are crows and swans, and crows are interested in places where filthy things are thrown. However, swans prefer nice clear water with lotus flowers, and it is in such places that they take their pleasure. Similarly, there are men who are like crows and men like swans. That is a natural division. According to an old English proverb, Birds of a feather flock together. Crows mix with crows, and swans mix with swans. Since devotees are like swans (haàsas), a most advanced devotee is called paramahaàsa. The paramahaàsas are not interested in subjects fit for crows. A person who is interested in inquiring about transcendental subjects, kåñëa-kathä, makes a paramahaàsa very glad. Therefore Kapiladeva was very glad to hear that His mother was eager to receive information on how to be delivered from material bondage:

atha me deva sammoham
apäkrañöuà tvam arhasi
yo 'vagraho 'haà mametéty
etasmin yojitas tvayä

"Now be pleased, my Lord, to dispel my great delusion. Due to my feeling of false ego, I have been engaged by Your mäyä and have identified myself with the body and consequent bodily relations." (Bhäg. 3.25.10)

Caitanya Mahäprabhu advised His disciples never to eat palatable food, never to talk about village topics and never to read ordinary novels, poems and newspapers. One may ask, "How is it that in the modern age these Europeans and Americans of the Kåñëa consciousness movement do not take interest in newspapers?" Newspapers are very popular in the West. Each day the papers are published in three or four editions, and they are all selling. However, these American boys and girls who have come to Kåñëa consciousness have stopped reading newspapers. They do not know what is happening from day to day, and it does not matter. All of this is a waste of time. It is better that they read literatures like Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä. Why waste one's valuable time?

Kapiladeva was very glad that His mother was interested only in spiritual advancement. This material world is called pavarga, and to nullify it is called apavarga. In this material world, people are laboring very hard simply to earn some money. This creates a hellish situation, and this is the way of material life. People have become so dull that they do not understand the meaning of liberation. They have become just like animals. If an animal is informed that there is such a thing as liberation, how will he understand it? It is not possible. Similarly, at the present moment, human beings have become exactly like animals. They do not know the meaning of apavarga, liberation. Yet there was a time when people understood that human life was meant for apavarga. The questions are raised by Devahüti, and the answers are given by Kapiladeva. That is apavarga-vardhanam. As far as material maintenance is concerned, the çästras never stress it. Rather, they say that one's maintenance will come automatically. God gives food to animals, birds and aquatics. Why should He not give it to one who is interested in apavarga? Unfortunately people have no faith, and therefore good association is required.

People should not waste their time associating with crows; they should associate with swans. When garbage is thrown out, crows and dogs come to see what is there, but no sane man will go. Those who are interested in trying to get pleasure out of this material world are actually chewing the chewed. Punaù punaç carvita-carvaëänäm (Bhäg. 7.5.30). If one picks up a piece of sugarcane which has already been chewed, he is a fool. We must know that the juice has already been taken out of that sugarcane. What will one get by chewing it? However, there are animals who are simply interested in chewing the chewed. Material life means chewing the chewed. A father educates his son to earn a livelihood, get married and settle down, but he himself already knows that by doing this he has not become satisfied. Why, then, is he engaging his son in this same business? A real father is one who does not allow his son to chew the chewed. Pitä na sa syäj janané na sä syät... na mocayed yaù samupeta-måtyum: one should not become a father or a mother unless one is able to save his children from the impending clutches of death. (Bhäg. 5.5.18) That is the duty of the father and mother. How can this be done? A father and mother should educate their son in Kåñëa consciousness. Then he can be saved. They should educate the son in such a way that there is no pavarga. If we do not go forward to liberation, we promote a civilization of cats and dogs. Eating, sleeping, mating, defending, fearing and dying are all experienced by cats and dogs, but human life is meant for another purpose. Of course we have to maintain the body; it is not that we should neglect it. But we should not unnecessarily engage in the maintenance of the body.

yasyätma-buddhiù kuëape tri-dhätuke
sva-dhéù kalaträdiñu bhauma ijya-dhéù
yat tértha-buddhiù salile na karhicij
janeñv abhijïeñu sa eva go-kharaù

"A human being who identifies this body made of three elements as the self, who considers the by-products of the body to be his kinsmen, who considers the land of his birth as worshipable, and who goes to a place of pilgrimage simply to take a bath rather than meet men of transcendental knowledge there, is to be considered like a cow or an ass." (Bhäg. 10.84.13)

From the Vedas we can receive education of all kinds. On a mango tree, there are ripened mangoes and green mangoes. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the ripened mango of the desire tree of Vedic knowledge: nigama-kalpa-taror galitaà phalam. If the mango is tasted by the parrot, it becomes doubly tasty. The word çuka means parrot, and Çukadeva Gosvämé spoke Çrémad-Bhägavatam. It is therefore more relishable from his lips.

nigama-kalpa-taror galitaà phalaà
çuka-mukhäd amåta-drava-saàyutam
pibata bhägavataà rasam älayaà
muhur aho rasikä bhuvi bhävukäù

"O expert and thoughtful men, relish Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the mature fruit of the desire tree of Vedic literatures. It emanated from the lips of Çré Çukadeva Gosvämé. Therefore this fruit has become even more tasteful, although its nectarean juice was already relishable for all, including liberated souls." (Bhäg. 1.1.3) It is regrettable that in India, where these literatures are available, people are not interested. They are interested in Marxist literature but not Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and this is India's misfortune.

When a student hears spiritual subjects attentively, the spiritual master becomes very happy. Kapiladeva was very happy to see His mother eager to understand spiritual subject matters. He therefore thanked His mother for her inquiry.

Generally people are interested in things that give immediate pleasure. We want to taste something tasty to the tongue, regardless of whether it is edible or not. Hogs very readily eat stool, and they do so without discrimination. They have no idea of tapasya, penance. When one engages in spiritual realization, one has to undergo tapasya. However, this has been made very easy by Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Ceto-darpaëa-märjanaà bhava-mahä-dävägni-nirväpaëam. All we have to do is spare a little time and chant Hare Kåñëa, but we are not even ready for this much tapasya. Kåñëa is more interested in leading us down the path of liberation than we are in going. He has given us a very simple method: harer näma harer näma harer nämaiva kevalam. We need only chant Hare Kåñëa. To perfect this chanting of Hare Kåñëa, there is no hard-and-fast rule. Simply by chanting, we will attain perfection. Being contaminated by Kali-yuga, however, we are unfortunate and therefore we have no attraction to the holy names of Kåñëa. Thus when Kapiladeva or His representative sees someone a little interested, he becomes very glad and thanks him. When Kapiladeva saw His mother interested, He thanked her from within, not openly.

Kapiladeva was very glad, and He began to speak. Kapiladeva was an incarnation of God and was a young boy; therefore His face was very beautiful. When He answered this question, He became even more beautiful, and He smiled because He was pleased at His mother's question. Kåñëa is also very beautiful, but when a devotee serves Him and comes to Him, He becomes even more beautiful. When a devotee with all his heart and soul serves Kåñëa, dresses Him in nice garments and gives Him a flower, Kåñëa smiles. If you can get Kåñëa to smile upon you just once, your life's goal is fulfilled.

Thus smiling, Kapiladeva began to enlighten His mother.

TLK Vs 13

TEXT 13

çré-bhagavän uväca
yoga ädhyätmikaù puàsäà
mato niùçreyasäya me
atyantoparatir yatra
duùkhasya ca sukhasya ca

TRANSLATION

The Personality of Godhead answered: That yoga system which relates to the Lord and the individual soul, which is meant for the ultimate benefit of the living entity, and which causes detachment from all happiness and distress in the material world, is the highest yoga system.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.13]

PURPORT

In the material world, everyone is striving for some material happiness, but as soon as we get some material happiness, there is also material distress. In the material world one cannot have unadulterated happiness. Any kind of happiness one has is contaminated by distress also. For example, if we want to drink milk, we have to bother to maintain a cow and keep her fit to supply milk. Drinking milk is very nice; it is also pleasure. But for the sake of drinking milk one has to accept so much trouble. The yoga system, as here stated by the Lord, is meant to end all material happiness and material distress. The best yoga, as taught in Bhagavad-gétä by Kåñëa, is bhakti-yoga. It is also mentioned in the Gétä that one should try to be tolerant and not be disturbed by material happiness or distress. Of course, one may say that he is not disturbed by material happiness, but he does not know that just after one enjoys so-called material happiness, material distress will follow. This is the law of the material world. Lord Kapila states that the yoga system is the science of the spirit. One practices yoga in order to attain perfection on the spiritual platform. There is no question of material happiness or distress. It is transcendental. Lord Kapila will eventually explain how it is transcendental, but the preliminary introduction is given here.

The attempt in this material world to maximize happiness and minimize distress is called the struggle for existence. Generally yoga is practiced to acquire some material profit. There are eight kinds of yogic perfection (siddhis): aëimä, laghimä, präpti, éçitva, vaçitva, mahimä, präkämya and kämävasäyitä. A real yogé can become smaller than the smallest, lighter than the lightest and bigger than the biggest. Whatever he wants he can produce immediately in his hand. He can even create a planet. These are some of the yoga-siddhis, but here it is stated that the supreme yoga system does not aim at material happiness or relief from distresses caused by material inconvenience. Everyone is trying to get out of material distress and gain some happiness. In any case, when something is material, there is only so-called happiness and so-called distress. For instance, there may be fireworks going on, and this may be happiness for someone but distress for us. Some people are thinking that these fireworks are very enjoyable, and we are thinking that they are very inconvenient. That is the material world. On one side there is happiness, and on the other side there is distress. Both happiness and distress are actually illusions. In summer, water is happiness, but in winter it is distress. The water is the same, but at one time it brings happiness and at another time it brings distress. When a son is born, he brings happiness, but when he dies, he brings distress. In either case, the son is the same.

This material world is the world of duality, and we cannot understand happiness without distress or distress without happiness. This is therefore called the relative world. Spiritual happiness is above these dualities, and that spiritual happiness is the perfection of yoga. Yoga ädhyätmikaù. Yoga is the happiness of the soul, and the individual soul can be happy when it is with the Supersoul, the Supreme Soul. Nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm. There is the Supreme Soul, or the supreme living being, and there are many individual souls, individual beings. We are many, but the principal living being is one, Kåñëa. He is the fire, and we are the sparks from that fire. The sparks are illuminated when they are with the original fire, but if the sparks no longer associate with the original fire, they are extinguished. Similarly, our real happiness is in enjoying with the Supreme Being. Happiness is being in His company. Kåñëa is not alone, but is always with His friends, either the gopés or the cowherd boys, or with His mother and father. We never find Kåñëa alone. He may be with Rädhäräëé or with His devotees. He is like a king or president. When one says that the king or president is coming, it is understood that he is not coming alone. He comes with His secretaries, ministers and many others.

The word yoga means "connection," and ätmä means "soul" and sometimes "mind" or "body." The material body has nothing to do with the Supreme Being because the Supreme Being is completely spiritual. He has no material covering. One who thinks that Kåñëa, the Supreme Being, has a material covering is himself covered by mäyä. Kåñëa does not say that He comes as an ordinary living being. Rather, His advent is totally transcendental. Janma karma ca me divyam evaà yo vetti tattvataù. We therefore have to learn how Kåñëa takes His birth, which is not ordinary. If it were ordinary, why should we observe the Janmäñöamé ceremony? His birth is divyam, divine. Everything about Kåñëa is divine, and if we think that Kåñëa is like us, we immediately become müòhas, fools. In the words of Bhagavad-gétä (9.11):

avajänanti mäà müòhä
mänuñéà tanum äçritam
paraà bhävam ajänanto
mama bhüta-maheçvaram

"Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and My supreme dominion over all that be."

Actually Kåñëa is the original Supreme Being, the original spirit soul. We are simply minute parts and parcels of Kåñëa. If we connect with Kåñëa, we are illuminated just as Kåñëa is illuminated. If we fall down from Kåñëa, our spiritual power and illumination are extinguished. The word yoga means connecting or linking with that original source. Yoga is the Sanskrit word meaning "connection," and viyoga means "disconnection."

Kapiladeva is referred to as Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Bhagavän makes no mistakes. Näräyaëaù paro 'vyaktät: even Çaìkaräcärya says that "Bhagavän, Näräyaëa, does not belong to this material world." When we speak of Bhagavän, or when the çästras refer to Bhagavän, we refer to Him who is above material understanding. As stated here, çré-bhagavän uväca. It does not say vyäsadeva uväca or kapiladeva uväca. Similarly, in Bhagavad-gétä, Vyäsadeva says, çré-bhagavän uväca. Bhagavän refers to Him who is above the defects of this material world. Bhagavän is not subject to the four deficiencies of the living entities. Being imperfect, living entities are illusioned and subject to commit mistakes. They also have the tendency to cheat others. When one who has no knowledge tries to become a teacher or preacher, he is actually cheating others. Since we ourselves do not possess perfect knowledge, we simply try to teach what Çré Bhagavän says. We do not manufacture our own teachings. So-called scholars and learned men manufacture their own teachings and give their opinions. In the West especially, we find much philosophical speculation and mental gymnastics, but such philosophy can never be perfect. We have to take our ideas from Bhagavän; then they will be perfect. We read Bhagavad-gétä because it is perfect. There is no mistake in it; there is no illusion in it; there is no cheating in it. Nor is it delivered by one whose senses are imperfect. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (7.26):

vedähaà samatétäni
vartamänäni cärjuna
bhaviñyäëi ca bhütäni
mäà tu veda na kaçcana

"O Arjuna, as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, I know everything that has happened in the past, all that is happening in the present, and all things that are yet to come. I also know all living entities; but Me no one knows."

God knows everything, but we do not know what is God. That is our position. Our position is not knowing. Éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati (Bg. 18.61). Éçvara, God, Kåñëa, is situated in everyone's heart. Sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöaù: "I have entered into everyone's heart." (Bg. 15.15) The Supreme Lord refers not only to the hearts of human beings but to those of animals and everything else.

aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-sthaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi
(Brahma-saàhitä 5.35)

The Supreme Lord is within the atom as Paramätmä, and therefore He is also within the individual soul. Being within everything, He knows everything. Since He knows everything, we have to take lessons from Him. If we take what Bhagavän says as perfect knowledge, we receive perfect knowledge. For receiving this knowledge, there is a disciplic succession (paramparä), which is described in Bhagavad-gétä (4.2):

evaà paramparä-präptam
imaà räjarñayo viduù

"This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way." This Kåñëa consciousness philosophy is very easy because we do not manufacture ideas. We take the ideas and the words delivered by the Supreme Person, Kåñëa, or His incarnation or representative. His representative does not say anything which Kåñëa Himself does not say. It is very easy to be a representative, but one cannot be a representative of Kåñëa if one tries to interpret Kåñëa's words in a whimsical way.

There is no authority superior to Çré Kåñëa, and if we stick to this principle, we can become gurus. We don't need to change our position to become a guru. All we have to do is follow in the disciplic succession stemming from Çré Kåñëa. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has advised: ämära äjïäya guru haïä tära' ei deça (Cc. Madhya 7.128). Caitanya Mahäprabhu instructed people to learn from Him and then go teach people within their own villages. One may think, "I am illiterate and have no education. I was not born in a very high family. How can I become a guru?" Caitanya Mahäprabhu says that it is not very difficult. Yäre dekha, täre kaha 'kåñëa'-upadeça: "Simply speak whatever Kåñëa speaks. Then you become a guru." Whoever speaks what Kåñëa has not spoken is not a guru but a rascal. A guru only speaks what Kåñëa has spoken. This is the çästric injunction.

ñaö-karma-nipuëo vipro
mantra-tantra-viçäradaù
avaiñëavo gurur na syäd
vaiñëavaù çva-paco guruù

"A scholarly brähmaëa expert in all subjects of Vedic knowledge is unfit to become a spiritual master without being a Vaiñëava, but a person born in a family of a lower class can become a spiritual master if he is a Vaiñëava." (Padma Puräëa)

People are in darkness, and they have to be enlightened. We have finally come from the animal kingdom to the human form, and now this human form gives us the opportunity to get out of the cycle of birth and death. The mission of this Kåñëa consciousness society is to awaken people to their original consciousness. Jéva jäga, jéva jäga, gauracända bale. The word gauracända refers to Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who tells the living entity, "Get up! Get up! How long will you continue to sleep?" Kota nidrä yäo mäyä-piçäcéra kole. The same is stated here. It is the prime business of human beings to connect again with the Supreme Soul. The purpose of yoga is to awaken to Kåñëa consciousness and connect oneself again with Kåñëa. That is ädhyätmika-yoga. Yoga does not mean showing some mystic magic. The supreme yogé is described by Çré Kåñëa Himself in Bhagavad-gétä (6.47):

yoginäm api sarveñäà
mad-gatenäntar-ätmanä
çraddhävän bhajate yo mäà
sa me yuktatamo mataù

"And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all."

There are many yogés and many different types of yoga systems, and all of these are discussed in Bhagavad-gétä. There is haöha-yoga, karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga and räja-yoga; however, the real yoga system is meant for reviving our connection with Kåñëa. Here it is said: yoga ädhyätmikaù puàsäm. Ädhyätmikaù: we are living entities, souls. It is not that we are disconnected from Kåñëa, but we have simply forgotten Him. It is not possible to be disconnected, but it is possible to be covered. In the words of Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (7.25):

nähaà prakäçaù sarvasya
yogamäyä-samävåtaù
müòho 'yaà näbhijänäti
loko mäm ajam avyayam

"I am never manifest to the foolish and unintelligent. For them I am covered by My eternal creative potency [yogamäyä]; and so the deluded world knows Me not, who am unborn and infallible."

There is yoga, and there is yogamäyä. Yogamäyä means forgetfulness. First of all we have to understand what is the soul. At the present moment, people are in such darkness that they do not even understand the soul. Therefore Bhagavad-gétä [2.13] first of all teaches what the soul is:

dehino 'smin yathä dehe
kaumäraà yauvanaà jarä
tathä dehäntara-präptir
dhéras tatra na muhyati

"As the embodied soul continually passes in this body from boyhood to youth to old age, the soul similarly passes into another body at death. The self-realized soul is not bewildered by such a change." The word dehé means "the proprietor of the body." We are thinking, "I am this body," but actually this is not so. We are the proprietors of the body, and that is the real understanding of the self. We do not say, "I am this finger" or "I am this hand." Rather, we say, "This is my finger, this is my head, this is my leg, etc." Similarly, the same can be said about the entire body. "This is my body." This means that I am the proprietor of this body. The body has been given by mäyä, the material energy.

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

"The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities that are in actuality carried out by nature." (Bg. 3.27)

The living entity receives different types of bodies according to karma. One living entity may receive a cat body, another a dog body, and so forth. Why are there so many different bodies? Why not one kind of body? The answer to this is also given in Bhagavad-gétä (13.22):

käraëaà guëa-saìgo 'sya
sad-asad-yoni janmasu

"It is due to his association with the modes of material nature. Thus he meets with good and evil among various species."

Because the soul within the body associates with the three modes of material nature (goodness, passion and ignorance), he receives different types of bodies. One doesn't have to aspire for his next body; one need only rest assured that it will be a different body. On the other hand, Kåñëa does not say what kind of body one will be awarded. That depends on qualification. If one associates with the mode of goodness, he is elevated to the higher planetary systems. If he associates with the mode of passion, he remains here. And if one associates with the mode of ignorance and darkness, he goes down to lower life forms—animals, trees and plants. This is the proclamation of Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (14.18):

ürdhvaà gacchanti sattva-sthä
madhye tiñöhanti räjasäù
jaghanya-guëa-våtti-sthä
adho gacchanti tämasäù

"Those situated in the mode of goodness gradually go upward to the higher planets; those in the mode of passion live on the earthly planets; and those in the mode of ignorance go down to the hellish worlds."

There are 8,400,000 species of life, and all of these arise from one's association with the modes of nature (käraëaà guëa-saìgo 'sya). And, according to the body, one undergoes distress and happiness. One cannot expect a dog to enjoy the same happiness that a king or rich man enjoys. Whether one enjoys this or that happiness or suffers this or that distress, both distress and happiness are due to the material body. Yoga means transcending the distress or happiness of the material body. If we connect ourselves with Kåñëa through the supreme yoga, we can get rid of material happiness and distress arising from the body. Reconnecting with Kåñëa is called bhakti-yoga, and Kåñëa comes to instruct us in this supreme yoga. In essence, He says, "Just revive your connection with Me, you rascal. Give up all these manufactured yogas and religions and just surrender unto Me. That is Kåñëa's instruction, and Kåñëa's representative, the incarnation or the guru, says the same thing. Although Kapiladeva is an incarnation of Kåñëa, He acts as the representative of Kåñëa, the guru. If we just accept the principle of surrender unto Kåñëa, we will become actually transcendental to so-called material happiness. We should not be captivated by material happiness or aggrieved by material distress. These are causes for bondage. Material happiness is not actual happiness. It is actually distress. We try to be happy by obtaining money, but money is not very easily obtained, and we have to undergo a great deal of distress to get it. However, we accept this distress with the hope of getting some false happiness. If we purify our senses, on the other hand, we can come to the spiritual platform. Real happiness lies in engaging our senses to satisfy the senses of Kåñëa. In this way our senses are spiritualized, and this is called ädhyätmika-yoga or bhakti-yoga. This is the yoga that Lord Kapiladeva is herein expounding.

TLK 8: Bhakti-yoga: The Supreme Yoga System

CHAPTER EIGHT
Bhakti-yoga: The Supreme Yoga System

TLK Vs 14

TEXT 14

tam imaà te pravakñyämi
yam avocaà puränaghe
åñéëäà çrotu-kämänäà
yogam sarväìga-naipuëam

TRANSLATION

O most pious mother, I shall now explain unto you the ancient yoga system, which I explained formerly to the great sages. It is serviceable and practical in every way.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.14]

PURPORT

The Lord does not manufacture a new system of yoga. Sometimes it is claimed that someone has become an incarnation of God and is expounding a new theological aspect of the Absolute Truth. But here we find that although Kapila Muni is the Lord Himself and is capable of manufacturing a new doctrine for His mother, He nevertheless says, "I shall just explain the ancient system that I once explained to the great sages because they were also anxious to hear about it." When we have a superexcellent process already present in Vedic scriptures, there is no need to concoct a new system, to mislead the innocent public. At present it has become a fashion to reject the standard system and present something bogus in the name of a newly invented process of yoga.

The supreme ancient system of yoga pertains to the soul. Presently, in America especially, haöha-yoga is very popular. It appeals to fat ladies who go to the classes to reduce and keep their digestive systems regular. Many people are interested in this kind of gymnastic yoga, but real yoga is ädhyätmika. Ädhyätmika means to awaken the soul to his proper position. The soul is puruña, spirit, and his business is to reconnect his lost relationship with Kåñëa.

Herein Kapiladeva says that He previously delivered this yoga system to the great åñis, the great sages. This is the process of çravaëa, hearing. One must be very eager to hear, for spiritual life begins with hearing.

ataù çré-kåñëa-nämädi
na bhaved grähyam indriyaiù
sevonmukhe hi jihvädau
svayam eva sphuraty adaù
(Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.2.234)

It is thus stated in the çästras that it is not possible to appreciate or understand Kåñëa with our blunt material senses. Kåñëa's name, form, qualities, pastimes, paraphernalia and abode are all part and parcel of Kåñëa. However, understanding Kåñëa begins with hearing and chanting His name. Then there is His form. Generally, for the neophyte, these items are essential—to hear His name and qualities and see and worship His form. That is Kåñëa's personal instruction:

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru

"Engage your mind always in thinking of Me, offer obeisances and worship Me." (Bg. 9.34)

Bhagavän Çré Kåñëa is present in the temple Deity, and even if a child comes to offer his respects, he is counted as a devotee. A small child may not know anything, but simply by seeing the Deity, chanting and dancing, he is benefited. Temples are meant to give everyone a chance to advance in Kåñëa consciousness one step at a time.

svalpam apy asya dharmasya
träyate mahato bhayät

"A little advancement on this path can protect one from the most dangerous type of fear." (Bg. 2.40) Even if we do a little on the path of bhakti, it goes to our account. For instance, if we deposit only two dollars in a savings bank, it is kept in our account, and it will increase with interest. Similarly, if one performs even a little devotional service, it is not lost. One may come and join this Kåñëa consciousness movement, render some service and after a while fall down. However, whatever service has been rendered is to one's permanent credit. That will never be lost. When one begins again, he begins at the point where he has left off. This is the instruction of Bhagavad-gétä (6.41):

çucénäà çrématäà gehe
yoga-bhrañöo 'bhijäyate

The unsuccessful yogi is born into a family of righteous people or into a family of rich aristocracy." Thus if one fails to perfect his bhakti-yoga, he is given another chance in the next life. According to a Bengali poem:

çuci hayä muci haya yadi kåñëa tyaje
muci hayä çuci haya yadi kåñëa-bhaje

If one takes to Kåñëa consciousness, even if he is born in a family of a cobbler (muci), he becomes greater than a brähmaëa (çuci). However, if one is born in a brähmaëa family and gives up Kåñëa consciousness, he becomes a muci, a cobbler. Thus the door of devotion is open to everyone, whoever he may be. Kåñëa Himself says that regardless of one's position, if one takes shelter of Him, one can approach the supreme destination.

mäà hi pärtha vyapäçritya
ye 'pi syuù päpa-yonayaù
striyo vaiçyäs tathä çüdräs
te 'pi yänti paräà gatià

"O son of Påthä, those who take shelter in Me, though they be of lower birth—women, vaiçyas [merchants], as well as çüdras [workers]—can approach the supreme destination." (Bg. 9.32) And Çukadeva Gosvämé says:

kiräta-hüëändhra-pulinda-pulkaçä
äbhéra-çumbhä yavanäù khasädayaù
ye 'nye ca päpä yad-apäçrayäçrayäù
çudhyanti tasmai prabhaviñëave namaù

"Kiräta, Hüëa, Ändhra, Pulinda, Pulkaça, Äbhéra, Çumbha, Yavana and the Khasa races and even others who are addicted to sinful acts can be purified by taking shelter of the devotees of the Lord, due to His being the supreme power. I beg to offer my respectful obeisances unto Him." (Bhäg. 2.4.18) Kåñëa consciousness is so complete that it is all-embracing. Everyone has an occupational duty as a brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya or çüdra, but one does not have to give up his occupational duty to take to Kåñëa consciousness. And if one takes to Kåñëa consciousness but does not succeed, what has he lost? Even if he falls down, there is no loss. On the other hand, if a man perfectly performs his own duties (sva-dharma) but is not Kåñëa conscious, what does he gain? There is actually no gain. Kapiladeva explains that once one takes to the path of bhakti-yoga, one never actually falls down. Once begun, bhakti-yoga continues, even if one temporarily falls down. One is given another chance by taking birth in a good family, either in a wealthy family, a learned family or a brähmaëa family. If one executes his duties as a brähmaëa, Viñëu will be very pleased, and if one executes his duties perfectly as a kñatriya or çüdra, Viñëu will also be very pleased. One does not have to change one's position. In Bhagavad-gétä (18.46) Çré Kåñëa says that every man can become perfect by following his qualities of work:

yataù pravåttir bhütänäà
yena sarvam idaà tatam
sva-karmaëä tam abhyarcya
siddhià vindati mänavaù

"By worship of the Lord, who is the source of all beings and who is all-pervading, man can, in the performance of his own duty, attain perfection." Thus if one executes his duties as a perfect kñatriya, vaiçya, çüdra or whatever, Viñëu will be pleased. The purpose of work is to please Viñëu. Unfortunately, people have forgotten this. Varëäçrama-dharma, the Vedic system of society, is therefore very important in that it is meant to give human beings a chance to perfect their lives by pleasing Kåñëa. Unfortunately, the varëäçrama-dharma has been lost in this age. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu, just to give relief to the rotting, conditioned souls of this age of Kali-yuga, has given us the mahä-mantra.

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä

"In this age of quarrel and hypocrisy, the only means of deliverance is chanting of the holy name of the Lord. There is no other way. There is no other way. There is no other way." (Båhan-näradéya Puräëa) Although we may try to revive the perfect varëäçrama system, it is not possible in this age. People are fallen, disturbed and unfortunate:

präyeëälpäyuñaù sabhya
kaläv asmin yuge janäù
mandäù sumanda-matayo
manda-bhägyä hy upadrutäù

"O learned one, in this iron age of Kali men have but short lives. They are quarrelsome, lazy, misguided, unlucky and, above all, always disturbed." (Bhäg. 1.1.10) In this age, there will be insufficient rainfall and food, and the government will plunder one's income by heavy taxation. All of these characteristics of Kali-yuga are described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. People will become so disgusted that they will suddenly leave their wife and children and go to the forest. How can the peaceful varëäçrama-dharma be revived when people are so harassed in this age? It is virtually impossible. Therefore the system of bhakti-yoga, the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, should be adopted. The whole aim of bhakti-yoga is to satisfy Viñëu. Yajïaiù saìkértana-präyaiù: Viñëu, Kåñëa, came Himself as Caitanya Mahäprabhu to teach us the way of saìkértana. Presently it has become fashionable to manufacture a new system of religion, but Kapiladeva, like Kåñëa, does not manufacture anything new. This system is not new, but very old (purä). Kåñëa also says the same in Bhagavad-gétä (4.2), evaà paramparä-präptam imaà räjarñayo viduù: "This supreme science was thus received through the chain of disciplic succession, and the saintly kings understood it in that way." Thus Kåñëa and Kapiladeva are not teaching anything new. They are simply repeating the same message because, in the course of time, the knowledge has been lost. Arjuna asks, "Why are you telling me? Why not another?" Çré Kåñëa answers, bhakto 'si me sakhä ceti: "Because you are My devotee as well as My friend." (Bg. 4.3)

Thus without being a bhakta, a devotee of Kåñëa's, one cannot actually understand the science of bhakti-yoga. Understanding Bhagavad-gétä means understanding Kåñëa. All this information is explained only in the bhakti-sampradäya, not in any other school. Therefore Kåñëa says at the conclusion of Bhagavad-gétä (18.55), bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti: if one actually wants to understand Kåñëa and one's relationship with Him, one must take to this process of bhakti-yoga. Bhakti-yoga as explained by Lord Kapiladeva is säìkhya-yoga.

Lord Kapiladeva states here:

tam imaà te pravakñyämi
yam avocaà puränaghe

The word anaghe refers to one without sin. The word agha refers to past sins, and an means "without." Therefore one cannot understand Kåñëa consciousness unless he is free from sin. Yeñäà tv anta-gataà päpam: one can stick to Kåñëa consciousness only when one is completely free from all sinful reactions. One may say, "That will take some time. I cannot get free from sinful reactions overnight." However, Kåñëa says, "No, no. This can be done immediately. Simply surrender unto Me, and I will absolve you from all sin." Thus by simply surrendering unto Kåñëa, our spiritual life begins.

We have to understand that we receive different bodies due to our sinful actions. Now we are given a chance to execute our duty in the human form. Bahünäà janmanäm ante. We have received this body through the evolutionary processes, and this human form is a great opportunity. Narottama däsa Öhäkura sings: hari hari viphale janama goìäinu: "My dear Lord Kåñëa, I have simply wasted my time." Why?

manuñya janama päiyä, rädhä-kåñëa nä bhajiyä,
jäniyä çuniyä viña khäinu

"Because I have received the human form of life, which is meant for understanding Kåñëa, yet I have simply wasted my time by not taking advantage of this opportunity. I have done everything but worship Rädhä-Kåñëa. Therefore I have taken poison knowingly." When one takes poison knowingly, he commits suicide, and not taking advantage of the human form is something like that. If we do not understand Kåñëa in this life, we are knowingly taking poison. This material life is just like a blazing forest fire. Eating, sleeping, enjoying sex and defending are the main material activities. When we are engaged simply in these things, our hearts are always burning as if we had taken poison. How can we be cured?

golokera prema-dhana, hari-näma-saìkértana,
rati nä janmila kene täya

"My dear Lord, You have given us the medicine of hari-näma-saìkértana, the chanting of Hare Kåñëa. Unfortunately, I have no attraction for Your holy names." It is also stated:

vrajendra-nandana yei, çacé-suta haila sei,
balaräma haila nitäi

"Kåñëa has now come as Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the son of mother Çacé. And Balaräma has come as Lord Nityänanda." What is Their business? They are delivering all kinds of sinful men simply by chanting Hare Kåñëa. And what is the evidence of this? The evidence is that Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu and Nityänanda Prabhu delivered the sinful Jagäi and Mädhäi. At the present moment everyone is like Jagäi and Mädhäi, for everyone is intoxicated and mad after sex. Now, by the grace of Caitanya Mahäprabhu, thousands of Jagäis and Mädhäis are being delivered. It is this active medicine, this Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, that is doing it. It is the perfect yoga system. This process is not manufactured, and we have not concocted anything. Our business is simply to accept the words of Kåñëa as they are. Çré Kåñëa Himself characterizes His devotee in this way:

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate

"Always chanting My glories, endeavoring with great determination, bowing down before Me, these great souls perpetually worship Me with devotion." (Bg. 9.14)

We do not need to be very learned. Our only requirement is that we receive the blessings of the Lord. The Lord's blessings will enable us to become learned and follow His instructions. We only need to stick to this Kåñëa consciousness movement on the basis of Bhagavad-gétä. When we are a little further advanced, we can read Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself has opened the way with this saìkértana movement. The entire world is in darkness without Kåñëa consciousness, and in this age people are so dull that they do not even know the difference between mukti (liberation) and bandha (bondage). If a human being does not know this difference, he is no better than an animal.

Presently we are under the sway of the three guëas, the modes of material nature—sattva-guëa, rajo-guëa and tamo-guëa. Out of these three guëas, sattva-guëa, the mode of goodness, is the best. A brähmaëa, characterized by the mode of goodness, is truthful and self-controlled. He controls his mind and senses, and he is very tolerant and simple. He has full knowledge, and he knows how to apply knowledge in life. He has full faith in the authority of the Vedas, a quality called ästikyam. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has explained the difference between nästikyam and ästikyam. According to Vedic understanding, one who does not believe in the Vedas is called nästika. Caitanya Mahäprabhu says: veda nä mäniyä bauddha haya ta 'nästika (Cc. Madhya 6.168). Lord Buddha defied Vedic authority, but His mission was to stop animal killing. In the Vedas there are recommendations for animal sacrifice, and therefore to prevent the killing of animals, Lord Buddha rejected the Vedas. Such sacrifice is not possible in this age because there is no brähmaëa qualified to carry it out. Those who are intelligent know that such a sacrifice cannot be successful in this age because no one knows the proper mantras capable of giving an old animal the body of a new animal. When an animal sacrifice is properly conducted, an old animal is sacrificed, and it emerges from the fire in a new body. This is not possible in this age, but what is possible is saìkértana-yajïa, the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. This is the yajïa, or sacrifice, especially intended for this age. We need only chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. By performing this yajïa, the results will be ceto-darpaëa-märjanam—the mirror of the mind will be cleansed. When the mirror of the mind is cleansed, one is automatically liberated.

Consciousness is the main principle, either for conditional life or for liberated life. We are therefore proposing Kåñëa consciousness, which means liberation from the repetition of birth and death. Unfortunately, people are so dull in this age that they have no idea how birth and death can be stopped. They think that birth and death cannot be stopped; even famous scientists admit this. However, in Bhagavad-gétä Çré Kåñëa says that we should always keep in mind the four miserable conditions. These are birth, old age, disease and death. When we are able to put an end to these, we are liberated. This simply requires that we clear our consciousness by thinking of Kåñëa. The purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to keep our minds constantly on Kåñëa. Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and He is a person. When He was realized by Arjuna, He was addressed as puruñam. God is puruña, male, not female. Puruña means "the enjoyer," and prakåti means "the enjoyed." Everything is enjoyed by the supreme puruña. It is also stated that we are actually prakåti, not puruña. The human dress is simply mäyä, illusion. We are thinking that we are puruña, the enjoyer, but actually we are the enjoyed. A man, thinking of enjoying himself, tries to imitate puruña, but actually he is prakåti. As a consequence, he is cast into this material world. Because the living entity wants to enjoy the material world and is attached to the three guëas, he receives different types of bodies. One who is in the mode of goodness receives the body of a learned brähmaëa. This is somewhat elevated, for he can gradually understand what is God. In the modes of passion and ignorance, no one can understand God. Also, from the material point of view, if one is situated in the mode of goodness, he can be elevated to higher planetary systems. Nonetheless, even if one goes to Brahmaloka, the highest planet in the material atmosphere, one is not actually perfectly situated. There is really no benefit because even on Brahmaloka the four miseries of material existence are found: birth, old age, disease and death. Lord Brahmä also dies and takes birth. From Vedic literatures we understand that Lord Brahmä took birth from the lotus flower generated from the navel of Viñëu. Thus he had his birth, and when Lord Brahmä dies, the entire material cosmic manifestation will be finished. Just as Lord Brahmä undergoes birth, old age, disease and death, so also a small ant or insect undergoes the same process. The point is that the living entity has to be free from this bondage because he is by nature eternal. According to Bhagavad-gétä, the living entity never actually takes birth, and he never actually dies. Na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcit: "For the soul there is never birth nor death." (Bg. 2.20)

It is the body that is destined to die, whether the body be that of Lord Brahmä or of a small ant. One should not think that one is liberated because one can live millions and millions of years. The life of Lord Brahmä covers millions of earth years, yet he is also subjected to birth and death. That is the way of conditional life. We should take advantage of the perfect knowledge given by Vedic literatures, by the great åñis and Bhagavän Kapiladeva, as well as by Bhagavän Çré Kåñëa, in order to attain liberation from the cycle of birth and death.

Receiving Kåñëa consciousness means receiving light. People are exhausted with the materialistic way of life, especially in the West. Now the Kåñëa consciousness movement is giving new life to Western society. By nature, we living entities are liberated. There is actually no question of birth, death, old age and disease. Since we are part and parcel of Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, how can there be a question of these things? Kåñëa is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, and being part and parcel of Kåñëa, we are also of the same nature. We are equal in quality, although not in quantity. Why, then, should we suffer the pangs of death? Therefore in the previous verse Kapiladeva instructed: yoga ädhyätmikaù puàsäà mato niùçreyasäya. The soul is entrapped in the body, and the process of perfect yoga is the process of saving the soul from bodily confinement and the four miseries that plague the body. How can this perfect yoga be attained? That is explained by Lord Kapila in the next verse: rataà vä puàsi muktaye. If our consciousness is simply attached to Kåñëa, we will be liberated.

The great souls are always chanting about Kåñëa. Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. They are also endeavoring with great determination in their devotional service. For instance, in the Kåñëa consciousness temples the devotees rise early in the morning, at 4:00 A.M., and they immediately bathe. Then they go to maìgala-ärati at 4:30, and after maìgala-ärati they study the Vedic literatures. These are the processes by which we can awaken our dormant love for Kåñëa. Because we are part and parcel of Kåñëa—just as a son is part and parcel of his father—there is a natural love between us. However, somehow or other the son leaves home and forgets his father. The father, of course, never forgets his son. He thinks, "Oh, my son has left. If he would only come back!" Kåñëa thinks in this way. We are all sons of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa is more anxious to get us back home, back to Godhead, than we are to go. Therefore Kåñëa comes and says, "You rascal! Give up all this nonsensical material engagement. You have manufactured so many religions and dharmas. Just give them all up and simply surrender unto Me." Kåñëa comes Himself and leaves behind His words. His words are also Himself because His words are absolute. Presently we do not see Kåñëa, but if we actually advance, we will see Him. When we see the Deity in the temple, we think, "Oh, this is an idol. It is not Kåñëa." If we think in this way, we have not seen Kåñëa. Kåñëa is also present in His words, in Bhagavad-gétä. That is kåñëa-väëé, the message of Kåñëa. The stage of awareness of Kåñëa can be attained when one is advanced in Kåñëa consciousness. Then one can understand that Kåñëa is present in the Deity, in Bhagavad-gétä, in the taste of water, in the sunshine, in the moonshine and in all sound. Kåñëa is present everywhere, but one has to acquire knowledge in order to know how to see Kåñëa. That is mukti, liberation. That is Kåñëa consciousness. That is also the process of bhakti-yoga—çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù smaraëam.... Deity worship is arcanam, chanting is vandanam, and däsyam is working for Kåñëa and spreading this Kåñëa consciousness movement.

Generally we experience that people are primarily interested in seeing Kåñëa, but why is the emphasis on seeing? Let us hear about Him. We must come with a little faith, and as we hear, that faith will increase. One should come to the temple, listen to talks about Kåñëa, and then, after some time, officially take initiation into the service of the Lord. That is called bhajana-kriyä. At that time one has to abandon illicit sex, intoxication, meat-eating and gambling. If one is still attached to all these habits, he should know that he is not making progress. When one is actually advanced in bhajana-kriyä, all these anarthas (unwanted things) will be finished. Paraà dåñövä nivartate. When one appreciates something better, he rejects all kinds of nonsense. Once one gets a taste of Kåñëa consciousness, he cannot remain without it. A drunkard cannot remain without a drink, but a devotee is drunk with Kåñëa consciousness. The immunization against all material diseases is this Kåñëa consciousness. To be immuned to the infection of the guëas, we have to engage in bhakti-yoga. Once we attain the perfectional stage, we attain ecstatic love of Godhead. In that state we cannot remain without Kåñëa for a moment. That is called bhäva, and that bhäva may increase to mahä-bhäva. This is not possible for ordinary human beings, but it was possible for the gopés and Rädhäräëé. Indeed, they could not live without Kåñëa. This is the highest stage of liberation.

TLK 9: Purifying the Mind for Self-realization

CHAPTER NINE
Purifying the Mind for Self-realization

TLK Vs 15

TEXT 15

cetaù khalv asya bandhäya
muktaye cätmano matam
guëeñu saktaà bandhäya
rataà vä puàsi muktaye

TRANSLATION

The stage in which the consciousness of the living entity is attracted by the three modes of material nature is called conditional life. But when that same consciousness is attached to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one is situated in the consciousness of liberation.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.15]

PURPORT

There is a distinction here between Kåñëa consciousness and mäyä consciousness. Guëeñu, or mäyä consciousness, involves attachment to the three material modes of nature, under which one works sometimes in goodness and knowledge, sometimes in passion and sometimes in ignorance. These different qualitative activities, with the central attachment for material enjoyment, are the cause of one's conditional life. When the same cetaù, or consciousness, is transferred to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, or when one becomes Kåñëa conscious, he is on the path of liberation.

TLK Vs 16

TEXT 16

ahaà-mamäbhimänotthaiù
käma-lobhädibhir malaiù
vétaà yadä manaù çuddham
aduùkham asukhaà samam

TRANSLATION

When one is completely cleansed of the impurities of lust and greed produced from the false identification of the body as "I" and bodily possessions as "mine," one's mind becomes purified. In that pure state he transcends the stage of material happiness and distress.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.16]

PURPORT

Käma and lobha are the symptoms of material existence. Everyone always desires to possess something. It is said here that desire and greed are the products of false identification of oneself with the body. When one becomes free from this contamination, his mind and consciousness also become freed and attain their original state. Mind, consciousness and the living entity exist. Whenever we speak of the living entity, this includes the mind and consciousness. The difference between conditional life and liberated life occurs when we purify the mind and the consciousness. When they are purified, one becomes transcendental to material happiness and distress.

In the beginning Lord Kapila has said that perfect yoga enables one to transcend the platform of material distress and happiness. How this can be done is explained here: one has to purify his mind and consciousness. This can be done by the bhakti-yoga system. As explained in the Närada-païcarätra, one's mind and senses should be purified (tat-paratvena nirmalam). One's senses must be engaged in devotional service of the Lord. That is the process. The mind must have some engagement. One cannot make the mind vacant. Of course there are some foolish attempts to try to make the mind vacant or void, but that is not possible. The only process that will purify the mind is to engage it in Kåñëa. The mind must be engaged. If we engage our mind in Kåñëa, naturally the consciousness becomes fully purified, and there is no chance that material desire and greed will enter.

Our mind is our friend, and our mind is our enemy. If it is cleansed, it is a friend, and if it is dirty, we contact material diseases. If we keep ourselves clean, pure, we will not be contaminated. According to Vedic civilization, one has to cleanse himself externally three times daily—once in the morning, again at noon, and again in the evening. Those who strictly follow the brahminical rules and regulations follow this process. Cleanliness is next to godliness. Conditional life means that the mind is covered with dirty things, and this is our disease. When we are in the lower modes of tamo-guëa and rajo-guëa, these dirty things are very prominent. One has to raise himself to the mode of sattva (goodness) by the process of saìkértana and çravaëa. One has to hear kåñëa-kathä. Kåñëa is within everyone's heart. The individual soul is part and parcel of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa wants the individual soul to turn to Him. Unfortunately the conditioned soul is attached to material enjoyment, and this is the cause of his bondage to birth, death, old age and disease. He is so foolish that he does not take into consideration that these miseries are repeated. He is like an ass that belongs to a washerman who loads him down with heavy clothes. For a few morsels of grass, the ass has to carry heavy loads all day, although not a single piece of clothing belongs to him. This is the way of the karmés. They may become big multimillionaires, but they are just like asses, working hard day and night. Regardless of how much money they may have, their stomachs can only hold so much. And they require only six feet of space to sleep. Nonetheless, these big karmés are thinking themselves very important. They think, "Without me, all the members of my nation will die. Let me work day and night to the point of death." People are thinking, "I belong to this family, this nation, this community. I have this duty or that duty," and so on. People do not know that these are all false designations.

Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu therefore enjoins, jévera 'svarüpa' haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa': our actual position is that of eternal servants of Kåñëa. We are mistakenly thinking that we are servants of a family or nation, but this is due to ignorance, tamo-guëa. However, we can attain the platform of sattva-guëa by following the instructions given in Bhagavad-gétä. Hearing kåñëa-kathä, topics about Kåñëa, clears all the dirty things from the mind. Also, if we chant and dance, these dirty things will be wiped away. The mind is the cause of bondage, and the mind is the cause of liberation. When it is dirty, it brings about bondage. In conditional life, we take birth, remain for some time, and enjoy or suffer. But really there is no question of enjoyment. There is only suffering. When we die, we have to give up the body and then take on another body. We immediately enter the womb of another mother, stay for nine months or so, and then come out. Then a new chapter of life begins. This is conditioned life, and it goes on again and again and again. In this way we undergo the tribulations of birth, old age, disease and death. The dogs and cats cannot understand this process, but we can understand it in human life through the Vedic literatures. If we don't take advantage of these literatures, all our education is for nothing.

People actually waste their time talking politics, sociology, anthropology, and so on. They read many literatures that do not glorify the Supreme Lord Hari, and thus they waste their time. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is giving everyone a chance to become pious. Puëya-çravaëa-kértanaù [Bhäg. 1.2.17]. It is not necessary to give money or bathe in the Ganges. There are many pious activities and many processes recommended in the çästras for becoming pious. However, in Kali-yuga people have lost all their stamina. They are so sinful that there is no question of becoming pious through all these prescribed methods. The only means is hearing about Kåñëa and chanting His names. Kåñëa has given us ears to hear and a tongue to speak. We can hear from a realized soul and thus perfect our lives. In this way we are given a chance to purify ourselves. Unless we are purified, we cannot become devotees. Human life is meant for purification. Unfortunately in this age people are not interested in Kåñëa, and they suffer through material existence one life after another after another. In one life they may be very opulent. Then they don't care about the next life. They think, "Let me eat, drink and be merry." This is going on all over the world, but the çästras say that people are making mistakes in this way. Nünaà pramattaù kurute vikarmaù (Bhäg. 5.5.4): people have become mad with sense gratification, and therefore they engage in all sorts of forbidden things. Karma means regulated work, and vikarma means just the opposite—unlawful, forbidden activities. The word akarma means that one is not affected by the results of work. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (3.9):

yajïärthät karmaëo 'nyatra
loko 'yaà karma-bandhanaù
tad-arthaà karma kaunteya
mukta-saìgaù samäcara

"Work done as a sacrifice for Viñëu has to be performed, otherwise work binds one to this material world. Therefore, O son of Kunté, perform your prescribed duties for His satisfaction, and in that way you will always remain unattached and free from bondage."

When people are in the modes of passion and ignorance, they perform vikarma. They do not care for their future lives, and they are habituated to eating anything and everything, just like hogs. They do not care for the çastric injunctions, and they are totally irresponsible. They are just like street boys who have no education and do not care for anything. Such urchins do whatever they like, for their fathers and mothers do not care for them. Life in ignorance, tamo-guëa, is such a careless life. People simply act unlawfully, not considering the results of their actions. They act for sense gratification, and actually they take pleasure in committing sins. In Calcutta I have seen people taking pleasure in cutting the throats of chickens and laughing when the chicken jumps and flaps about. Sometimes in Western countries students are taken to slaughterhouses just to see how the cows are butchered. In this age, people take pleasure in committing all kinds of sins. They have no brains to see that this body is temporary and full of suffering. They are completely in the mode of darkness, just like the animals they slaughter. There may be many animals in a pasture, and if one takes an animal aside and cuts its throat, the other animals will simply stand, look, and continue eating grass. They do not realize that the next time they may be slaughtered. The people in Kali-yuga are in the same situation, but the Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying to give these rascals a little sense. We are saying, "Don't remain animals. Become human beings." In the words of Caitanya Mahäprabhu:

kåñëa bhuli' sei jéva anädi-bahirmukha
ataeva mäyä täre deya saàsära-duùkha

"Forgetting Kåñëa, the living entity has been attracted by the external feature from time immemorial. Therefore the illusory energy (mäyä) gives him all kinds of misery in his material existence. (Cc. Madhya 20.117) When one forgets his relationship with Kåñëa, he acts in a very foolish way, and mäyä gives him one misery after another. It is also stated:

mäyä-mugdha jévera nähi svataù kåñëa jïäna
jévere kåpäya kailä kåñëa veda-puräëa

"The conditioned soul cannot revive his Kåñëa consciousness by his own effort. But out of causeless mercy, Lord Kåñëa compiled the Vedic literature and its supplements, the Puräëas." (Cc. Madhya 20.122)

The Vedic literatures—the Vedänta, Upaniñads, Rämäyaëa, Mahäbhärata and many others—should be utilized if we wish to become free from the contamination of tamo-guëa and rajo-guëa. The whole world is revolving due to käma and lobha. Käma means "lusty desire," and lobha means "greed." people cannot have enough sex or money, and because of this, their hearts are filled with contaminations, which have to be cleansed by hearing, repeating and chanting. Human life is meant to get rid of anarthas, unwanted things, but where is the university or college where this science of purification is taught? The only institution is this Kåñëa consciousness society. Kåñëa is within the heart, and the contaminations are also there, but Kåñëa will help us cleanse them. Nañöa-präyeñv abhadreñu nityaà bhägavata-sevayä (Bhäg. 1.2.18). We must regularly hear Çrémad-Bhägavatam and chant Hare Kåñëa; these are the two processes recommended by Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Haridäsa Öhäkura was chanting three hundred thousand holy names a day, but we have fixed the number at sixteen rounds. Nonetheless, we are so unfortunate and fallen that we cannot even perform them. We should not waste our time reading and talking nonsense, but should engage in the study of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Our time is very valuable, and we should not waste it. Cäëakya Paëòita has said: äyuñaù kñaëa eko 'pi na labhyaù svarëa-koöibhiù. We may live for a hundred years, but not one moment of these hundred years can be returned, not even if we are prepared to pay millions of dollars. We cannot add a moment, nor can we get a moment back. If time is money, we should just consider how much money we have lost. However, time is even more precious because it cannot be regained. Therefore not a single moment should be lost. Human life should be utilized only for chanting and reading Vedic literatures. The International Society for Krishna Consciousness is publishing many books so that people can utilize their time properly by reading them and make their lives successful. Not only should we read Çrémad-Bhägavatam, but we should also serve the person bhägavata, one whose life is nothing but Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Nityaà bhägavata-sevayä. By this process we can attain the stage of bhagavad-bhakti, but first we must get rid of all these anarthas, unwanted things. Presently we are wasting our time thinking, "This is my country. This is my nation. This is my body and my family," and so on. Nityaà bhägavata-sevayä. We can vanquish all these false conceptions when we come to the platform of sattva-guëa. Then we will not be disturbed by tamo-guëa or rajo-guëa, nor by käma or lobha (lust and greed). This is the vasudeva platform. Oà namo bhagavate väsudeväya.

Lord Kapiladeva, in the next verse, points out the results that follow the successful completion of this purificatory process.

TLK Vs 17

TEXT 17

tadä puruña ätmänaà
kevalaà prakåteù param
nirantaraà svayaà-jyotir
aëimänam akhaëòitam

TRANSLATION

At that time the soul can see himself to be transcendental to material existence and always self-effulgent, never fragmented, although very minute in size.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.17]

PURPORT

In the state of pure consciousness, or Kåñëa consciousness, one can see himself as a minute particle nondifferent from the Supreme Lord. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä, the jéva, or the individual soul, is eternally part and parcel of the Supreme Lord. Just as the sun's rays are minute particles of the brilliant sun, so a living entity is a minute particle of the Supreme Spirit. The individual soul and the Supreme Lord are not separated as in material differentiation. The individual soul is a particle from the very beginning. One should not think that because the individual soul is a particle, it is fragmented from the whole spirit. Mäyäväda philosophy enunciates that the whole spirit exists, but a part of it, which is called the jéva, is entrapped by illusion. This philosophy, however, is unacceptable because spirit cannot be divided like a fragment of matter. That part, the jéva, is eternally a part. As long as the Supreme Spirit exists, His part and parcel also exists. As long as the sun exists, the molecules of the sun's rays also exist.

The jéva particle is estimated in the Vedic literature to be one ten-thousandth the size of the upper portion of a hair. He is therefore infinitesimal. The Supreme Spirit is infinite, but the living entity, or individual soul, is infinitesimal, although he is not different in quality from the Supreme Spirit.

Two words in this verse are to be particularly noted. One is nirantaram, which means "nondifferent" or "of the same quality." The individual soul is also expressed here as aëimänam. Aëimänam means "infinitesimal." The Supreme Spirit is all-pervading, but the very small spirit is the individual soul. Akhaëòitam means not exactly "fragmented" but "constitutionally always infinitesimal." No one can separate the molecular parts of the sunshine from the sun, but at the same time the molecular part of the sunshine is not as expansive as the sun itself. Similarly, the living entity, by his constitutional position, is qualitatively the same as the Supreme Spirit, but he is infinitesimal.

Self-realization means seeing one's proper identity as the infinitesimal jéva. At the present moment, we are seeing the body, but this is not our proper identity. We have no vision of the real person occupying the body. The first lesson we receive from Bhagavad-gétä (2.13) informs us that the body and the owner of the body are different. When we can understand that we are not the body, that is the beginning of self-realization, and that is called the brahma-bhüta stage. Ahaà brahmäsmi. I am not this material body, but spirit soul. And what are the characteristics of the jéva, the soul? First of all, he is aëimänam, very minute, infinitesimal. We are also jyoti, effulgent, like God, but God is brahma-jyoti, all-pervading and infinite. According to the Mäyäväda theory, we are the same as that brahmajyoti. Mäyävädés give the example of a pot and the sky. Outside the pot there is sky, and within the pot there is sky. The separation is only due to the wall of the pot. When the pot is broken, the inside and outside become one. However, this example does not properly apply to the soul, as it is described in Bhagavad-gétä (2.24):

acchedyo 'yam adähyo 'yam
akledyo 'çoñya eva ca
nityaù sarva-gataù sthäëur
acalo 'yaà sanätanaù

"This individual soul is unbreakable and insoluble, and can be neither burned nor dried. He is everlasting, all-pervading, unchangeable, immovable and eternally the same." The Soul cannot be cut in pieces or segmented. This means that the soul is eternally, perpetually minute. We are the eternal parts and parcels of Çré Kåñëa. As Çré Kåñëa Himself states in Bhagavad-gétä (15.7):

mamaiväàço jéva-loke
jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù

"The living entities in the conditioned world are My eternal, fragmental parts." The word sanätana means "eternal," and the word aàça means "particles." God, Kåñëa, is very great. No one is equal to Him or greater than Him. It is said that God is great, but we do not actually realize how great God is. He is so great that millions of universes are emanating from the pores of His body.

yasyaika-niçvasita-kälam athävalambya
jévanti loma-vilajä jagad-aëòa-näthäù
viñëur mahän sa iha yasya kalä-viçeño
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"The Brahmäs and other lords of the mundane worlds appear from the pores of the Mahä-Viñëu and remain alive for the duration of His one exhalation. I adore the primeval Lord, Govinda, for Mahä-Viñëu is a portion of His plenary portion." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.48)

Millions of universes emanate from the breathing of the Mahä-Viñëu. In the Tenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa gives Arjuna some indication of His infinite glory, and He concludes His descriptions with the following statement (Bg. 10.42):

athavä bahunaitena
kià jïätena tavärjuna
viñöabhyäham idaà kåtsnam
ekäàçena sthito jagat

"But what need is there, Arjuna, for all this detailed knowledge? With a single fragment of Myself I pervade and support this entire universe."

This universe (jagat) is situated on the strength of one part of Kåñëa's yogic powers. In this way we must understand the greatness of God and our own identity as minute particles. It is stated in the puräëas that the individual soul is one ten-thousandth part of the tip of a hair. If we could somehow divide the tip of a hair into ten thousand parts, we might begin to understand how the soul is invisible. Self-realization means knowing our identity as small particles. The small particle of spirit soul is within every one of us, but it is not possible to see with material eyes. There is no instrument existing in the material universe by which one can actually see the soul. Because of our inability to perceive the soul, we say it is niräkära, formless. We cannot even calculate its dimension (äkära). Although we cannot calculate it, it is there nonetheless. The living entity has full form. There are small microbes and insects we can barely see, but they have an anatomy consisting of many working parts. Within a small insect there is also the spirit soul, and that spirit soul also exists within the elephant and other big animals.

When we actually realize our identity as Brahman, our life becomes successful. Presently we are identifying with the body, but as long as we do so, we are no better than cats and dogs, although we may have a considerable amount of scientific knowledge. Conditioned souls consider the body to be the self, and because of this the jévas identify themselves as American, Indian, brähmaëa, kñatriya, man, woman, elephant and so forth. Thinking in these bodily terms, people consider their wives and children to be theirs and the land of their birth to be worshipable. Thinking thus, people are willing to fight and die for their country. Presently everyone is laboring under this delusion, but in order to understand our spiritual identity, we must find the proper guru.

Realizing our identity means realizing that we are Kåñëa's eternal parts and parcels, that we are very minute, infinitesimal, and that we have a perpetual and eternal relationship with Kåñëa, just as a part has its relationship to the whole. At no time can we be as great as Kåñëa, although we are the same qualitatively. No one is equal to God, and no one is greater than Him. If someone claims to be God, he has to prove that no one is equal to him and that no one is greater. If he can do this, he is God. This is a very simple definition. Brahma-saàhitä (5.1) also verifies this statement: éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù. The word éçvara means "controller," and the word parama means "supreme." We small living entities are controllers to a degree. We can control, at times, our family members, wives, children and so forth. Or we can control our office, factory, country or whatever. There are small controllers and larger controllers. If we go to Brahmä, we see that he is controlling the entire universe, but he is not the supreme controller. It is stated in the çästras that Brahmä, the greatest living being within this universe, is also meditating in order to learn how to control. Tene brahma hådä ya ädi-kavaye (Bhäg. 1.1.1).

First of all, Brahmä learned to control the universe; then he became qualified as Brahmä. Although he was born Brahmä, he still had to be educated. If he was the first living being in the universe, who educated him? Kåñëa. Çré Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (10.2), aham ädir hi devänäm: "I am the source of the demigods."

The original demigods are Brahmä, Viñëu and Çiva. Lord Kåñëa is Viñëu, but He is the instructor of Brahmä and Çiva. Therefore it is said that Lord Kåñëa is the source of all the demigods.

We should not foolishly claim that we are as great as the Supreme God. We should understand that we are like sparks of the original fire. The spark is also fire, but if it falls from the original flame, it will go out. One should not think that because he is qualitatively one with God, he is God. the supreme controller. It is very fashionable nowadays to claim to have become Näräyaëa, God. The Mäyävädés address one another as Näräyaëa, and thus everyone supposedly becomes Näräyaëa. In this way we are overcrowded with Näräyaëas here and there. But how can everyone become Näräyaëa? Näräyaëa is one, and the çästras warn:

yas tu näräyaëaà devaà
brahma-rudrädi-daivataiù
samatvenaiva vékñeta
sa päñaëòé bhaved dhruvam
[H.b.v. 1.117]

"Whoever thinks Lord Viñëu and the demigods are on the same level is to be immediately considered a rogue as far as spiritual understanding is concerned." If one compares Näräyaëa to the demigods, he simply reveals his lack of intelligence. It is also fashionable to speak of daridra-näräyaëa, poor Näräyaëa, claiming that the poor man in the street is Näräyaëa. But what is this nonsense? Näräyaëa is the exalted Supreme Personality of Godhead. Even Çaìkaräcärya says: näräyaëaù paro 'vyaktät. Näräyaëa is beyond this universe. Avyaktäd aëòa-sambhavaù: the entire universe is a product of this avyakta. We should not compare Näräyaëa to anyone, what to speak of the poor man in the street (daridra). This is all foolishness. Näräyaëa is Lakñmépati, the husband and controller of the goddess of fortune. How, then, can He be daridra? This is all due to misunderstanding. Therefore the çästras warn that if one thinks that the demigods are equal to Näräyaëa, one is a päñaëòé, an atheist. We should not think that because we have become liberated, we have attained the position of Näräyaëa. By severe austerity and penance one may elevate himself to the position of Brahman, but this is not the position of Para-brahman. Äruhya kåcchreëa paraà padaà tataù (Bhäg. 10.2.32). Although one rises to the platform of Brahman, one again falls down to the material position if he neglects to worship the lotus feet of Kåñëa. One may rise to the Brahma effulgence, but because there is no shelter there one will return to the material atmosphere. One may go to Brahmaloka, the highest planet in the material sky, but one's position there is temporary. However, in the paravyoma, the spiritual sky, there are many spiritual planets, called Vaikuëöhalokas. There are millions of these gigantic planets, and unless we take shelter of one of them, we will fall down again into the material atmosphere.

It is not sufficient to rise to the platform of Brahman. Brahman is sat (being), and a partial realization of the Absolute Truth. We are actually after änanda. Sac-cid-änanda: cit means "knowledge," and that is also partial. We must add änanda (bliss) in order to have complete realization. If we simply fly in the sky, we can't have änanda. We have to descend to an airport at some time or another. If we simply rise to the Brahman effulgence, we do not experience änanda. Änanda is experienced when we enter the spiritual planets, where Näräyaëa, Kåñëa, is present. Paras tasmät tu bhävo 'nyo 'vyakto 'vyaktät sanätanaù (Bhagavad-gétä 8.20). We have to enter the eternal planets and associate with the Supreme Personality of Godhead in order to be happy. If we do not attain this position, we will return to the material world. And how can this position be attained? We simply have to try to understand Kåñëa. Why does He come? What is His business? What is His form?

The purpose of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to teach people how to understand Kåñëa. If one is fortunate in understanding Him, one's life is successful. As long as we have lusty desires and greed, we cannot come to this understanding. The bhakti-yoga process is the process of purification whereby we can become free from käma and lobha, lust and greed, and the influence of the lower guëas, tamo-guëa and rajo-guëa, ignorance and passion. As soon as we engage in devotional service, we immediately become freed from the influence of the guëas. Because we are not expert in approaching the Supreme Lord, we have to follow the principles of bhakti-yoga enunciated by the äcäryas. When a boy goes to school, he has to follow the rules and regulations, but after a while he becomes accustomed to them and does not have to be taught. In other words, he learns automatically to come to school at a certain time, take his seat and study nicely. Similarly, in this Kåñëa consciousness movement, we have certain rules and regulations. We must rise early in the morning for maìgala-ärati, chant sixteen rounds of Hare Kåñëa daily, and execute all the functions of bhakti-yoga. In this way, we become attached to rendering service to Kåñëa, and we become practiced in this science. When we attain this stage, we immediately become self-realized.

TLK 10: Spiritual Attachment and Material Detachment

CHAPTER TEN
Spiritual Attachment and Material Detachment

TLK Vs 18

TEXT 18

jïäna-vairägya-yuktena
bhakti-yuktena cätmanä
paripaçyaty udäsénaà
prakåtià ca hataujasam

TRANSLATION

In that position of self-realization, by practice of knowledge and renunciation in devotional service, one sees everything in the right perspective; he becomes indifferent to material existence, and the material influence acts less powerfully upon him.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.18]

PURPORT

As the contamination of the germs of a particular disease can influence a weaker person, similarly the influence of material nature, or illusory energy, can act on the weaker, or conditioned, soul but not on the liberated soul. Self-realization is the position of the liberated state. One understands his constitutional position by knowledge and vairägya, renunciation. Without knowledge, one cannot have realization. The realization that one is the infinitesimal part and parcel of the Supreme Spirit makes one unattached to material, conditional life. That is the beginning of devotional service. Unless one is liberated from material contamination, one cannot engage in the devotional service of the Lord. In this verse, therefore, it is stated, jïäna-vairägya-yuktena: when one is in full knowledge of one's constitutional position and is in the renounced order of life, detached from material attraction, then, by pure devotional service, bhakti-yuktena, he can engage himself as a loving servant of the Lord. Paripaçyati means that he can see everything in its right perspective. Then the influence of material nature becomes almost nil. This is also confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä. Brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä: when one is self-realized he becomes happy and free from the influence of material nature, and at that time he is freed from lamentation and hankering. The Lord states that position as mad-bhaktià labhate paräm, the real beginning of devotional service. Similarly, it is confirmed in the Närada-païcarätra that when the senses are purified, they can then be engaged in the devotional service of the Lord. One who is attached to material contamination cannot be a devotee.

In the conditional state, we are influenced by material nature. We have already discussed how we are conditioned by the three modes of material nature—ignorance, passion and goodness. Goodness is superior to ignorance and passion because from the platform of goodness we can come to understand Kåñëa and thereby transcend the modes altogether. In this age, people are generally influenced by the lower modes, the modes of ignorance and passion. In these modes, we are not able to serve Kåñëa. It is our constitutional position to serve someone, but when we do not serve Kåñëa, we serve mäyä. In any case, we cannot become master. Who can say that he is a master, that he is not serving anyone? We may serve our family, society, country, business, automobile or whatever. If one cannot find anything to serve, he goes and buys a cat or dog and serves it. Why is this? It is because service is our nature. We are simply lacking the knowledge of where to direct the service. Service is meant to be rendered to Kåñëa. In the material world we are serving our lusty desires, not Kåñëa, and we are deriving no pleasure from this. We are also serving in an office or in some employment in order to get some money. In this case, we are serving money, not the person. Thus in the material world we serve the senses and money. In any case, service is there. We must serve.

Actually the only master is Kåñëa. Ekale éçvara kåñëa, ära saba bhåtya (Cc. Ädi 5.142). All the demigods, human beings, animals, trees and everything else are servants. Self-realization is realizing that one is the eternal servant of Kåñëa and that one's duty is to serve Him. Self-realization is not thinking ahaà brahmäsmi, "I have become Brahman, Bhagavän." How can we become Bhagavän? If we are Bhagavän, we are actually the supreme powerful one. If this is the case, why are we in a miserable condition? Why are we under the influence of mäyä? Does Bhagavän come under the influence of mäyä? No. Kåñëa says specifically in Bhagavad-gétä that prakåti, mäyä, is working under His directions. Mäyä is the maidservant of Kåñëa, and if we are the servants of maya, how can we be Kåñëa, Bhagavän? When we come to our spiritual senses, we can understand that we are erroneously engaged in mäyä's service and that our duty is to engage in Kåñëa's service. That is self-realization. As stated here: jïäna-vairägya-yuktena. Real understanding is knowing oneself to be the servant of Kåñëa, no one else. Because we are under illusion, we are serving käma, lobha, moha, mätsarya—lust and greed—without benefit and without pleasure. Kämädénäà kati na katidhä pälitä durnideçä: "There is no limit to the unwanted orders of lusty desires." (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 3.2.35) When we come to the understanding that our pleasure lies in serving Kåñëa only, we have attained jïäna-vairägya. Therefore in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.2.7) it is stated:

väsudeve bhagavati
bhakti-yogaù prayojitaù
janayaty äçu vairägyaà
jïänaà ca yad ahaitukam

"By rendering devotional service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, one immediately acquires causeless knowledge and detachment from the world." If one engages in the service of Väsudeva, Kåñëa, this knowledge comes, and one becomes a mahätmä. A mahätmä is one who realizes that Kåñëa is everything. He does not defy Kåñëa or try to become Kåñëa. One who does so is not a mahätmä but a durätmä, a rascal. What is the position and knowledge of a mahätmä? Kåñëa states:

mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha
daivéà prakåtim äçritäù
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jïätvä bhütädim avyayam

"O son of Påthä, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible." (Bg. 9.13)

A mahätmä cannot be manufactured. He is under the daivé prakåti, the divine nature. There are two kinds of prakåti—parä prakåti and aparä prakåti. Aparä prakåti is the material world, and daivé prakåti is the spiritual world. As soon as one understands that he is uselessly serving mäyä in the material world in the form of society, friends, country and so forth, one reaches the stage called jïäna, knowledge. As soon as one attains this knowledge, he reaches the brahma-bhüta stage, Brahman realization, and he becomes prasannätmä, happy. One may ask, "Why should I serve Kåñëa?" We have already explained that being a part means serving the whole. The whole is Kåñëa, and the individuals are meant for Kåñëa's satisfaction. Éçäväsyam idaà sarvam.

There are many éçvaras, controllers, but the supreme éçvara is Kåñëa. As soon as one attains this realization, he has attained perfect knowledge, and he renders service in bhakti-yoga. Foolish people say that bhakti is meant for ajïanés, unintelligent people, but this is not the case. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa indicates that after many births, the jïäné, the man in knowledge, surrenders unto Him.

As long as we do not understand Kåñëa, Väsudeva, we should understand that we are still fools. We may advertise ourselves as very great jïänés, learned personalities, but we are actually fools. That is the çästric conclusion. If we are actually jïänés, we should surrender unto Kåñëa.

There are many dharmas, or activities. Some are pious and some impious, but Kåñëa tells us to give up both. Arjuna was thinking that it was impious to fight with his relatives, but Kåñëa was insisting that he fight. How could Arjuna act impiously? He could not, because Kåñëa's service is transcendental to pious and impious activity. At midnight, when the gopés heard the sound of Kåñëa's flute, they ran to the forest to join Him. According to the çästras, it is immoral for young girls to go see a young boy in a forest in the dead of night. But this was not an impious activity because the gopés did this for Kåñëa. Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who was so strict that no woman could even come near Him to offer respects, actually said: ramyä käcid upäsanä vraja-vadhü-vargeëa yä kalpitä. "What could be more wonderful than that worship conceived by the gopés?" Although it actually appeared immoral for the gopés to dance with Kåñëa, Caitanya Mahäprabhu states that their relation with Kåñëa is the highest

form of worship. This is actually transcendental knowledge. One becomes transcendental to all pious and impious activities when one serves Kåñëa. After all, piety and impiety are within the material modes. Kåñëa's service is transcendental to good and bad, pious and impious. Bhakti-yoga begins when jïäna and vairägya are complete. Jïäna is knowledge, and vairägya is detachment from matter and engagement of the mind in spirit. Both of these are automatically attained when we engage in devotional service to Kåñëa.

TLK Vs 19

TEXT 19

na yujyamänayä bhaktyä
bhagavaty akhilätmani
sadåço 'sti çivaù panthä
yoginäà brahma-siddhaye

TRANSLATION

Perfection in self-realization cannot be attained by any kind of yogé unless he engages in devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, for that is the only auspicious path.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.19]

PURPORT

That knowledge and renunciation are never perfect unless joined by devotional service is explicitly explained here. Na yujyamänayä means "without being dovetailed." When there is devotional service, the question arises where to offer that service. Devotional service is to be offered to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is the Supersoul of everything, for that is the only reliable path of self-realization, or Brahman realization. The word brahma-siddhaye means to understand oneself to be different from matter, to understand oneself to be Brahman. The Vedic words are ahaà brahmäsmi. Brahma-siddhi means that one should know that he is not matter; he is pure soul. There are different kinds of yogés, but every yogé is supposed to have attained self-realization, or Brahman realization. It is clearly stated here that unless one is fully engaged in the devotional service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one cannot easily approach the path of brahma-siddhi.

In the beginning of the Second Chapter of Çrémad-Bhägavatam it is stated that when one engages in the devotional service of Väsudeva, spiritual knowledge and renunciation of the material world are automatically manifest. Thus a devotee does not have to strive separately for renunciation or knowledge. Devotional service itself is so powerful that by one's service, everything is revealed. It is stated here, çivaù panthä: this is the only auspicious path for self-realization. The path of devotional service is the most confidential means for attaining Brahman realization. That perfection in Brahman realization is attained through the auspicious path of devotional service indicates that the so-called Brahman realization, or realization of the brahmajyoti effulgence, is not brahma-siddhi. Beyond that brahmajyoti there is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. In the Upaniñads a devotee prays to the Lord to kindly put aside the effulgence, brahmajyoti, so that the devotee may see within the brahmajyoti the actual eternal form of the Lord. Unless one attains realization of the transcendental form of the Lord, there is no question of bhakti. Bhakti necessitates the existence of the recipient of devotional service and the devotee who renders devotional service. Brahma-siddhi through devotional service is realization of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The understanding of the effulgent rays of the body of the Supreme Godhead is not the perfect stage of brahma-siddhi, or Brahman realization. Nor is the realization of the Paramätmä feature of the Supreme Person perfect because Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is akhilätmä—He is the Supersoul. One who realizes the Supreme Personality realizes the other features, namely the Paramätmä feature and the Brahman feature, and that total realization is brahma-siddhi.

As stated before, the word yoga means "to connect." Brahma-siddhaye means "self-realization," and ahaà brahmäsmi means "I am spirit soul." Actually, realizing oneself to be spirit is not sufficient. One has to progress further. One's fever may be cured, but one must also regain his strength and appetite in order to be totally cured. Then one can have a normal, healthy life, free of disease. Similarly, simply realizing that one is spirit soul is not sufficient. One has to engage in spiritual activity, and that spiritual activity is bhakti. Mäyävädé philosophers think that it is sufficient to stop all material activity, and the Buddhist philosophers advocate nirväëa, cessation of material life. Neither give more information. Actually we are suffering due to this material combination, and that is a fact. This body is composed of earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and ego. The Buddhists and Mäyävädés advocate the annihilation of the components. They say, "Let the earth go to earth, let the water go to water, let the fire go to fire and become zero." If we dismantle the house of the material body and become zero, we attain nirväëa. Nirväëa means the cessation of pleasure and pain. The Mäyävädés and Buddhists claim that if we fill an empty pitcher, the water will make some sound as long as the pitcher is not completely filled. When the pitcher is filled, there will no longer be any sound. Thus they claim that all the Vedic mantras and hymns stop when one is completely Brahman-realized. In other words, the Buddhists and Mäyävädés claim that the material world is false, mithyä, and that we should somehow or other make it zero. However, simply realizing Brahman, realizing one's identity as spirit soul, is insufficient. We must realize that Bhagavän is everywhere:

eko 'py asau racayituà jagad-aëòa-koöià
yac-chaktir asti jagad-aëòa-cayä yad-antaù
aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-sthaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship the Personality of Godhead, Govinda, who, by one of His plenary portions, enters the existence of every universe and every atomic particle and thus unlimitedly manifests His infinite energy all over the material creation." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.35)

Çré Bhagavän is not alone. He is not only localized, but is everywhere. Although Kåñëa has a particular place, He is everywhere. It is not that because Kåñëa is in one place, He cannot be in others. Since we are conditioned, when we sit in our office we cannot be at home. Kåñëa is not like this. Goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhütaù. Kåñëa is always in Goloka Våndävana, yet He is aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-stham. He is within every atom of this universe. This universe is existing due to the Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu. There is not only one universe, but there are many millions, and they are all working very nicely because the Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu is present. We should not think that all these planets are floating in space without any arrangement having been made. There is definitely an arrangement.

In order to be completely free of the material modes, one has to come not only to the platform of jïäna and vairägya, but to bhakti also. When we mention bhakti, some people say, "I render bhakti to my wife. I love her very much and take care of her. If I do not see her, I become mad." Thus people have bhakti for their family, country, Goddess Durgä, other demigods and so on. However, that kind of bhakti will not do. Therefore it is said, bhaktir bhagavati. Bhakti must be rendered unto the Supreme. It is not that one should render bhakti unto an imitation Bhagavän. If one says that he is Bhagavän, we should ask, "Are you present in everyone's heart? Can you tell me what I am thinking now?" If one is Bhagavän, he must be akhilätmä. If one is éçvara, he must be present in everyone's heart. Kåñëa is present in everyone's heart (sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöaù). All this should be scrutinizingly studied. It is not that one should accept this rascal or that rascal as Bhagavän. Nor should one render bhakti to this demigod or that demigod, to one's family, country, society, wife, cat, dog or whatever. All this is not really bhakti but imitation bhakti. It is actually lustful desire. If we can develop bhakti for Kåñëa, Kåñëa consciousness, our lives will be successful. Actually there is no alternative. As stated in this verse, sadåço 'sti çivaù panthä. Para-brahman is Kåñëa, and brahma-siddhaye means understanding our relationship with Kåñëa. It is all right for one to understand oneself as Brahman (ahaà brahmäsmi), but what is our relationship with the Para-brahman? There are always two: Brahman and Para-brahman, ätmä and Paramätmä, éçvara and Parameçvara, the individual living being and the supreme living being, nitya and nityänäm, cetanaç and cetanänäm. There are always two present, and two means a relationship. We should therefore understand our relationship with the Supreme, with Para-brahman. Understanding that relationship is brahma-siddhaye.

We are qualitatively one with Para-brahman, but Para-brahman is very great whereas we are very small. Para-brahman is one (kaivalya). There is no alternative and no duplicate. There is no one equal to Him or greater than Him. That is the meaning of kaivalya. Human life is meant for inquiring about Para-brahman and one's relationship with Him. Unfortunately, people are not asking questions about Para-brahman. Everyone is asking about the news and the morning paper, and everyone is concerned with going to the market and purchasing so many goods for cheaper prices. All this is going on in human society and in cat and dog society also.

This world is full of darkness and ignorance, but Kåñëa consciousness is transcendental to this material world. In Kåñëa consciousness, there is no darkness but simply light. If we try to find things at night, it becomes very difficult; however, in the daytime, there is no difficulty. The çästras enjoin that we leave this darkness and come to light. This light is given by the guru.

om ajïäna timirändhasya
jïänäïjana-çaläkayä
cakñur unmélitaà yena
tasmai çré-gurave namaù

"I was born in the darkest ignorance, and my spiritual master opened my eyes with the torch of knowledge. I offer my respectful obeisances unto him." [Gautaméya Tantra]

It is the guru's business to give light by knowledge. The guru has completely assimilated the Vedic essence of life. Çruti, knowledge, is received by hearing. It is not experimental. We cannot understand that which is beyond our sense perception by experiment. We cannot understand who our father is by experimental knowledge. One cannot say, "Let me find out who my father is by experiment." Our father was existing before we were existing, and it is not possible to understand by experimental knowledge that this or that man is my father. The real authority is the mother; therefore Vedic knowledge has been likened to the mother and the puräëas to the sisters. We should understand from the Vedas what ultimate knowledge really is. The ultimate knowable objective is Kåñëa, and simply by understanding Kåñëa, we can understand everything. We do not have to understand things separately. Kåñëa is within our hearts. He is not far away; rather, He is everywhere. If Kåñëa sees that we are attached to Him, He becomes our friend. He is a friend to everyone, but He is especially a friend to His devotees. As Kåñëa Himself says in Bhagavad-gétä (10.11):

teñäm evänukampärtham
aham ajïäna-jaà tamaù
näçayämy ätma-bhäva-stho
jïäna-dépena bhäsvatä

"Out of compassion for them, I, dwelling in their hearts, destroy with the shining lamp of knowledge the darkness born of ignorance."

Jïäna is there, it is simply covered with the curtain of ignorance. Light is there, and darkness is there, but when we are in darkness we cannot see things as they are. Kåñëa says that as one devotes himself to rendering service, He Himself dispels the darkness of ignorance. If we actually want to become perfect in this life, we only need to engage in devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Bhagavän. It is not that Bhagavän is difficult to find. Bhagavän is within the heart. Éçvaraù sarva bhütänäà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati (Bg. 18.61). That is the real Bhagavän, within the hearts of all. That Bhagavän is always active. He instructed Brahmä, the lord of the universe, and Brahmä, having received Kåñëa's instructions, created the entire universe. Kåñëa will also give instructions to us if we simply take to devotional service.

TLK Vs 20

TEXT 20

prasaìgam ajaraà päçam
ätmanaù kavayo viduù
sa eva sädhuñu kåto
mokña-dväram apävåtam

TRANSLATION

Every learned man knows very well that attachment for the material is the greatest entanglement of the spirit soul. But that same attachment, when applied to self-realized devotees, opens the door of liberation.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.20]

PURPORT

Here it is clearly stated that attachment for one thing is the cause of bondage in conditioned life, and the same attachment, when applied to something else, opens the door of liberation. Attachment cannot be killed; it has simply to be transferred. Attachment for material things is called material consciousness, and attachment for Kåñëa or His devotee is called Kåñëa consciousness. Consciousness, therefore, is the platform of attachment. It is clearly stated here that when we simply purify the consciousness from material consciousness to Kåñëa consciousness, we attain liberation. Despite the statement that one should give up attachment, desirelessness is not possible for a living entity. A living entity, by constitution, has the propensity to be attached to something. We see that if someone has no object of attachment, if he has no children, he transfers his attachment to cats and dogs. This indicates that the propensity for attachment cannot be stopped; rather, it must be utilized for the best purpose. Our attachment for material things perpetuates our conditional state, but the same attachment, when transferred to the Supreme Personality of Godhead or His devotee, is the source of liberation.

Here it is recommended that attachment should be transferred to the self-realized devotees, the sädhus. And who is a sädhu? A sädhu is not just an ordinary man with a saffron robe or long beard. A sädhu is described in Bhagavad-gétä as one who unflinchingly engages in devotional service. Even though one is found not to be following the strict rules and regulations of devotional service, if one simply has unflinching faith in Kåñëa, the Supreme Person, he is understood to be a sädhu. Sädhur eva sa mantavyaù. A sädhu is a strict follower of devotional service. It is recommended here that if one at all wants to realize Brahman, or spiritual perfection, his attachment should be transferred to the sädhu, or devotee. Lord Caitanya also confirmed this. Lava-mätra sädhu-saìge sarva-siddhi haya: simply by a moment's association with a sädhu, one can attain perfection.

Mahätmä is a synonym of sädhu. It is said that service to a mahätmä, or elevated devotee of the Lord, is dväram ähur vimukteù, the royal road of liberation. Mahat-seväà dväram ähur vimuktes tamo-dväraà yoñitäà saìgi-saìgam (Bhäg. 5.5.2). Rendering service to the materialists has the opposite effect. If anyone offers service to a gross materialist, or a person engaged only in sense enjoyment, then by association with such a person the door to hell is opened. The same principle is confirmed here. Attachment to a devotee is attachment to the service of the Lord because if one associates with a sädhu, the sädhu will teach one how to become a devotee, a worshiper and a sincere servitor of the Lord. These are the gifts of a sädhu. If we want to associate with a sädhu, we cannot expect him to give us instructions on how to improve our material condition, but he will instruct us how to cut the knot of the contamination of material attraction and how to elevate ourselves in devotional service. That is the result of associating with a sädhu. Kapila Muni first of all instructs that the path of liberation begins with such association.

According to Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu:

'sädhu-saìga', 'sädhu-saìga''sädhu-saìga'—sarvasarva-çästre kaya
lava-mätra sädhu-saìge sarva-siddhi haya

"The verdict of all revealed scriptures is that by even a moment's association with a pure devotee, one can attain all success." (Cc. Madhya 22.54)

It is said that man is a social animal, and, according to our association, we can mold our character. Businessmen associate with one another to develop their business capabilities. There are many different types of association, and association brings about bondage to a particular thing. If one associates with materialistic people, one's bondage to sense gratification tightens. Woman is the symbol of sense gratification; therefore anything dealing with sense gratification is called yoñit-saìga. This material world is filled with yoñit-saìga because everyone is interested in sense gratification. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (2.44):

bhogaiçvarya-prasaktänäà
tayäpahåta-cetasäm
vyavasäyätmikä buddhiù
samädhau na vidhéyate

"In the minds of those who are too attached to sense enjoyment and material opulence, and who are bewildered by such things, the resolute determination of devotional service to the Supreme Lord does not take place." The word bhoga means "sense gratification." Bhogaiçvarya: Those who are overly attached to opulence and sense gratification cannot understand spiritual life, and they are very slow to take to it. At the present moment people are manda, very slow. They do not take this Kåñëa consciousness movement very seriously because they have been taught by modern civilization simply to enjoy life for sense gratification. In the Western countries, especially, there are many implements for sense gratification. There are even machines for shaving, although formerly an ordinary razor would do. Now, thanks to the machine, one does not even have to move his hand. So this is considered progress. However, we learn from the çästras that human life is not meant for sense enjoyment but for tapasya. That is Vedic civilization. First of all, one must be trained in the brahmacäré system and learn how to deny the senses. A brahmacäré should be trained in tapasya, not in enjoyment. Formerly, brahmacärés would have to go from door to door to beg alms for the äçrama, and they were trained from the very beginning to address every woman as mother.

Presently, people are in such a miserable condition that they are saying, "Let us die. Let us die." However, Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä says, "Why should you die?" People want to die in order to put an end to the threefold miseries of material nature, but who is making research on how to stop death? From Bhagavad-gétä we learn that death is not really natural for us. It is artificially imposed upon us, and we have to become deathless again. That is the perfection of human life, but no one cares about it. We have become so dull that we cannot avoid birth, old age, disease and death. We are actually experiencing them because we are not alert. For this reason, when Sanätana Gosvämé approached Caitanya Mahäprabhu, he said, "My dear Lord, somehow or other You have dragged me to Your lotus feet. I am now asking You what my actual position is. Why am I forced to suffer the threefold miseries of material life?" No one is interested in inquiring about this matter. Mokña, liberation, means getting free from the threefold miseries of life as well as birth, old age, disease and death. Sometimes, when people are a little interested, they take to a path that is not even approved, or they invent something. But nothing need be invented. By this Kåñëa consciousness process, everyone can be elevated. Everyone can be delivered, regardless of his situation or culture. We have spread this Kåñëa consciousness movement throughout the world, and people are becoming happy because of it.

According to Bhagavad-gétä (9.32), anyone can take shelter of Kåñëa. Kåñëa never denies anyone, and similarly, Kåñëa's devotee never denies anyone. That is this Kåñëa consciousness movement. We tell everyone, "Yes, you are welcome. Take this education and spiritual life and become a devotee of Kåñëa." Sometimes we are criticized because of this, but Kåñëa specifically says in Bhagavad-gétä that even those who are lowborn can take shelter of Him and become elevated for liberation. What, then, to speak of pious people born in brahminical families? Unfortunately, in this age people born in rich or brahminical families often don't care for spiritual realization. They misuse their chance and exhaust the results of their pious activities. Society needs first-class sädhus in order to improve. If everyone is a çüdra and debauchee, how can society be peaceful? Therefore in order to organize society, Kåñëa recommends the varëäçrama-dharma. There must be ideal brähmaëas, kñatriyas, vaiçyas and çüdras. However, no one cares about this now.

One may ask, "What is a sädhu?" A sädhu is one who serves Kåñëa and engages in Kåñëa consciousness without reservation. In Bhagavad-gétä (9.30), Çré Kåñëa says:

api cet su-duräcäro
bhajate mäm ananya-bhäk
sädhur eva sa mantavyaù
samyag vyavasito hi saù

"Even if one commits the most abominable actions, if he is engaged in devotional service, he is to be considered saintly because he is properly situated."

It is the sädhu's business to be very tolerant. When one becomes a devotee, many people become one's enemy, because in this age people are asuric, demoniac. Even one's father may turn into an enemy like Hiraëyakaçipu, the father of Prahläda Mahäräja. Prahläda was only five years old and was chanting Hare Kåñëa, but his father was prepared to kill him because he was a devotee. Hiraëyakaçipu was saying, "Why are you chanting Hare Kåñëa? Why are you speaking of a separate God? I am God." That is the meaning of asuric, demoniac. Rascals who claim to be God themselves are simply demons. Although Prahläda's father was insisting that he was God, Prahläda Mahäräja could not accept this. He simply accepted his father as an asura, and consequently there was a quarrel between them. When Hiraëyakaçipu asked Prahläda Mahäräja, "What is the best thing you have learned from your teachers?" Prahläda replied, "O best of the asuras, as far as I can understand, because we have accepted this material body, we have to accept death. But this is not the object of human life. Human life is meant for mokña, liberation." Unfortunately, foolish people do not understand this. Kåñëa says, måtyuù sarva-haraç cäham: "I am death, and I will take away everything you possess." (Bg. 10.34) Hiraëyakaçipu was such a powerful demon that even the demigods were afraid of him, but Kåñëa took everything away in a second. Hiraëyakaçipu was looking for security, and he was thinking, "I will not die in this way, and I will not die in that way." But he did not think that he would be killed by the Lord in the form of Nåsiàha. However intelligent we may be, and however much we may try to cheat Kåñëa, Kåñëa is always more intelligent. When Mother Yaçodä tried to bind Kåñëa with a rope, she found that the rope was always two inches too short. Our intelligence is like that. We want to cheat God and surpass Him, but this is not possible. People think themselves very advanced in knowledge, but actually, due to their pride, their knowledge is taken away by mäyä. Kåñëa actually takes the knowledge away from atheistic, demoniac people like Hiraëyakaçipu. Atheists do not know that Kåñëa's intelligence is always at least two inches greater than anyone else's.

In material life, we simply struggle for existence. We want to exist, and we do not want to die. Nor do we want to undergo the pains of birth, catch diseases or grow old. There are so many miseries in material life that we do not want, but they are forced upon us. Unfortunately, we are not intelligent enough to make a solution to all these problems. We should be inquiring like Sanätana Gosvämé about how to put an end to them all. Instead, we are working in such a way that we have to accept another material body. We are experiencing the difficulties arising from this material body, but we are not working in a way to become free. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is giving information on how to become liberated.

Those who are mahätmäs are always engaged in chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. Bhajana is the chanting of Hare Kåñëa. If we serve a mahätmä like Haridäsa Öhäkura, who was always engaged in chanting Hare Kåñëa, our path of liberation is opened. However, if we associate with materialistic people, who are simply mad for sense gratification, we take the way of darkness. Tamo-dväraà yoñitäà saìgi-saìgam. The Vedas enjoin that we not remain in darkness but that we go to the light. We have accepted a body, but we will not be allowed to remain in that body permanently. We will have to give it up and accept another, and then another and another. What is this business? The material world is in such darkness, and people are taking on one body after another. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is therefore here to give enlightenment and liberation, and it is offering not only the simplest process of chanting Hare Kåñëa but also the most sublime philosophy.

TLK 11: The Symptoms of a Sädhu

CHAPTER ELEVEN
The Symptoms of a Sädhu

TLK Vs 21

TEXT 21

titikñavaù käruëikäù
suhådaù sarva-dehinäm
ajäta-çatravaù çäntäù
sädhavaù sädhu-bhüñaëäù

TRANSLATION

The symptoms of a sädhu are that he is tolerant, merciful and friendly to all living entities. He has no enemies, he is peaceful, he abides by the scriptures, and all his characteristics are sublime.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.21]

PURPORT

A sädhu, as described above, is a devotee of the Lord. His concern, therefore, is to enlighten people in devotional service; that is his mercy. He knows that without devotional service, human life is spoiled. A devotee travels all over the country, from door to door, preaching, "Be Kåñëa conscious. Be a devotee of Lord Kåñëa. Don't spoil your life in simply fulfilling your animal propensities. Human life is meant for self-realization, or Kåñëa consciousness." These are the preachings of a sädhu. He is not satisfied with his own liberation. He always thinks about others. He is the most compassionate personality toward all fallen souls. One of his qualifications, therefore, is käruëika, great mercy to the fallen souls. While engaged in preaching work, he has to meet with so many opposing elements, and therefore the sädhu has to be very tolerant. Someone may ill-treat him because the conditioned souls are not prepared to receive the transcendental knowledge of devotional service. They don't like it; that is their disease. The sädhu has the thankless task of impressing upon them the importance of devotional service. Sometimes devotees are personally attacked with violence. Lord Jesus Christ was crucified, Haridäsa Öhäkura was caned in twenty-two marketplaces, and Lord Caitanya's principal assistant, Nityänanda, was violently attacked by Jagäi and Mädhäi. But still they were tolerant because their mission was to deliver fallen souls. A sadhu is merciful because he is the well-wisher of all living entities. He is not only a well-wisher of human society, but a well-wisher of animal society as well. The word sarva-dehinäm refers to all living entities who have accepted material bodies. Not only does the human being have a material body, but other living entities as well. The devotee of the Lord is merciful to everyone—cats, dogs, trees, etc. He treats all living entities in such a way that they can ultimately get salvation from this material entanglement. Çivänanda Sena, one of the disciples of Lord Caitanya, gave liberation to a dog by treating the dog transcendentally. There are many instances where a dog got salvation by association with a sädhu, because a sädhu engages in the highest philanthropic activities for the benediction of all living entities. Yet although a sädhu is not inimical toward anyone, the world is so ungrateful that even a sädhu has many enemies.

What is the difference between an enemy and a friend? It is a difference in behavior. A sädhu behaves with all conditioned souls for their ultimate relief from material entanglement. Therefore, no one can be more friendly than a sädhu in relieving a conditioned soul. A sädhu is calm, and he quietly and peacefully follows the principles of scripture. A sädhu is also one who follows the principles of scripture and at the same time is a devotee of the Lord. One who actually follows the principles of scripture must be a devotee of God because all the çästras instruct us to obey the orders of the Personality of Godhead. A sädhu, therefore, is a follower of the scriptural injunctions and a devotee of the Lord. All good characteristics are prominent in a devotee, and he develops all the good qualities of the demigods, whereas a nondevotee, even though academically qualified, has no good qualifications or good characteristics according to the standard of transcendental realization.

There are 8,400,000 life forms according to the Padma Puräëa, and the ätmä is the same in all of them. The sädhu can understand this, as Bhagavad-gétä (5.18) indicates:

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

"The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog and a dog-eater [outcaste]."

It is not that a brähmaëa is the same as a dog, but that the brähmaëa is a spirit soul, and the dog is also a spirit soul. We are conditioned according to our different bodies, which are given by superior forces. Yamaräja offers the living entity a body according to his karma. Karmaëä daiva-netreëa. We have already discussed the point that bodies are awarded according to one's qualifications. If we acquire the qualities of a brähmaëa and work as a brähmaëa, we become a brähmaëa. If we act as a dog and do the work of a dog, we become a dog. Nor should one think that simply because one is born as a brähmaëa, one is automatically a brähmaëa. There are characteristics mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä by which one can tell to which caste one belongs. Çrédhara Svämé has also noted that birth is not everything. One has to acquire the qualities. Whatever body we may have, our position is temporary. We cannot remain in any position indefinitely. We may think that at present we are Americans and are very happy, and that's all right. We may chalk out our plans for continued happiness, but nature will not allow us to stay indefinitely. As soon as nature calls, we die and give up our post. Then we have to take the post of a dog, a cat, a demigod, a human being or whatever. We are now given a most exalted life form, that of a human being, but if we do not act accordingly, we have to take a lower body. This is karmaëä daiva-netreëa.

We should therefore be very careful in this human form that our aim is to become devotees of Lord Kåñëa. That is the path of liberation. Previously, great personalities in India used to go to the forest in order to meditate to stop the repetition of birth and death. That is the highest occupation for man, and actually every man is meant for that. Unless we conquer repeated birth and death, we simply waste our lives like animals—eating, sleeping, defending and mating. People in this age especially cannot distinguish between animal life and human life. They think the difference is that animals sleep in the street and human beings sleep in nice apartments. However, the çästras do not define civilization in this way. Whether one sleeps in the street or in an apartment, the activity is the same. A dog may eat out of a garbage can, and a human being may eat on a golden plate, but this does not mean that they are engaged in different activities. In either case, both the dog and the man are taking food into their bodies. A dog may have sex in the street, and a human being may have sex in a very nice bed in a secluded place, but that does not change the activity. People are thinking that advancement of civilization means improving eating, sleeping, mating and defending, but actually these activities have nothing to do with civilization. They simply tighten our bondage to material life.

Human life is meant for yajïa, sacrifice for the satisfaction of the Supreme Person. We may perfect our activities, but our success lies in satisfying Kåñëa by our talents. Presently we may be attached to material activity, but we should transfer that attachment to a sädhu. Then our lives will be successful. Presently we are attached to money, women, nice houses, country, society, friends, family and so forth. This attachment is called arjanaà päçu. The word päçu means "rope." When we are bound with a rope, we are helpless, and now we are bound by the guëas, or the three modes of material nature. The word guëa also means "rope." We cannot free ourselves, for we are conditioned. We cannot move freely without the sanction of the supreme authority. It is generally said that not a blade of grass moves without God's sanction. Similarly, we cannot do anything without the supervision of a superior authority.

It is not that God has to take personal supervision of this. Paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate... na tasya käryaà karaëaà ca vidyate: in the Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad (6.8), it is thus stated that the Supreme Lord does not have to act personally. He has many agents to perform everything for Him. We are so controlled that we are not even free to blink our eyes. We may be moving our hands very freely, but at any moment they can be immediately paralyzed. Presently I am claiming, "This is my hand." But what is this? The hand could be paralyzed immediately. This is conditioned life, and how can we improve it? Our business is to become liberated from all this conditioning. How is this possible? Sa eva sädhuñu kåto mokña-dväram apävåtam (Bhäg. 3.25.20). We have to turn our attachment from material things to a sädhu. 'Sädhu-saìga', 'sädhu-saìga'—sarva-çästre kaya: this is the advice of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. All çästras advise us to associate with a sädhu. Even Cäëakya Paëòita, the great politician, recommended: tyaja durjana-saàsargaà bhaja sädhu-samägamam. One Vaiñëava householder asked Caitanya Mahäprabhu what the duty of a householder is, and Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu immediately replied, asat-saìga-tyäga—ei vaiñëava-äcära: "Don't associate with nondevotees, but search out a sädhu." (Cc. Madhya 22.54)

At the present moment it is very difficult to avoid the company of asädhus, those who are not sädhus. It is very difficult to find a sädhu for association. We have therefore started this Kåñëa consciousness movement to create an association of sädhus so that people may take advantage and become liberated. There is no other purpose for this society.

Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä (6.47) that the first-class sädhu is one who is always thinking of Him. This process is not very difficult. We should always think of Kåñëa, but how is this possible? We think of our business, our dog, our family, our lovable object and so many other things. We have to think of something; without thinking, we cannot remain. We simply have to divert our thoughts to Kåñëa. It is the sädhu's business to teach this, and one can learn this in the association of a sädhu. Actually a sädhu will not teach anything else. Ädau çraddhä tataù sädhu-saìgaù (Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu 1.4.15). This is the way to make spiritual advancement. One has to associate with a sädhu. Often the sädhu's task is a thankless one, but he has to be tolerant. Despite all the trouble a sädhu may encounter, he is very merciful upon fallen conditioned souls. He sees that people are suffering due to a lack of Kåñëa consciousness, and because he is always thinking of the welfare of others, he is suhåt. Other people are always envious, but the sädhu is always thinking how to save others from the clutches of mäyä. A sädhu is kind not only to human beings but to cats, dogs, trees, plants and insects; he will hesitate even to kill one mosquito. He does not simply think, "I shall just take care of my brother." He looks on all living beings as his brothers because Kåñëa says that He is the father of all living entities.

Because a sädhu lives in this way, he does not create enemies. If there are enemies, they become enemies out of their own character, not out of any provocation on the part of a sädhu. A sädhu simply teaches, "My dear human being, my dear friend, just surrender to Kåñëa." Enemies arise due to man's envious nature. Cäëakya Paëòita says that there are two envious animals—serpents and men. Although you may be faultless, either may kill you. Of the two, Cäëakya paëòita says that the envious man is more dangerous because a serpent can be subdued by chanting a mantra or by some herbs, but an envious man cannot be so subdued. In Kali-yuga, practically everyone is envious, but we have to tolerate this.

Envious people create many impediments to the Kåñëa consciousness movement, but we have to tolerate them. There is no alternative. One must be peaceful and depend on Kåñëa in all circumstances. These are the ornaments of a sädhu. We should find a sädhu and associate with him. Then our path of liberation will be open.

In the next verse, Lord Kapila further explains the activities of a sädhu.

TLK Vs 22

TEXT 22

mayy ananyena bhävena
bhaktià kurvanti ye dåòhäm
mat-kåte tyakta-karmäëas
tyakta-svajana-bändhaväù

TRANSLATION

Such a sädhu engages in staunch devotional service to the Lord without deviation. For the sake of the Lord he renounces all other connections, such as family relationships and friendly acquaintances within the world.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.22]

PURPORT

A person in the renounced order of life, a sannyäsé, is also called a sädhu because he renounces everything—his home, his comfort, his friends, his relatives and his duties to friends and to family. He renounces everything for the sake of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. A sannyäsé is generally in the renounced order of life, but his renunciation will be successful only when his energy is employed in the service of the Lord with great austerity. It is said here, therefore, bhaktià kurvanti ye dåòhäm. A person who seriously engages in the service of the Lord and is in the renounced order of life is a sädhu. A sädhu is one who has given up all responsibility to society, family and worldly humanitarianism, simply for the service of the Lord. As soon as he takes his birth in the world, a person has many responsibilities and obligations—to the public, demigods, great sages, general living beings, parents, forefathers and many others. When he gives up all these obligations for the service of the Supreme Lord, he is not punished for his renunciation. But if for sense gratification a person renounces these obligations, he is punished by the law of nature.

Kåñëa and all the çästras say that our only obligation is to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. If we take to His service, we are no longer obliged to anyone. We are free. How is this possible? By almighty God's power. A man may be condemned to death, but if a president or a king excuses him, he is saved. Kåñëa's final instruction in Bhagavad-gétä is to surrender everything to Him. We can sacrifice our life, wealth and intelligence, and this is called yajïa. Everyone has some intelligence, and everyone uses his intelligence in one way or another. Generally people use their intelligence in trying to gratify their senses, but even an ant can do this. We should try to gratify not our senses but Kåñëa's senses. Then we become perfect.

We have to learn this purificatory process from a sädhu. Inasmuch as we try to gratify our senses, we become attached to the material world. We may render service to the sädhu or to Kåñëa. The sädhu is the representative of Kåñëa. He will never say, "Serve me," but will say, "Serve Kåñëa." Therefore we have to approach Kåñëa through the sädhu. This is confirmed by the Vaiñëava äcärya Narottama däsa Öhäkura: chädiyä vaiñëava-sevä nistära päyeche kebä. We cannot directly approach Kåñëa; we have to go through the transparent via media, Kåñëa's representative.

Those who are after material concessions go to different demigods. They take something from Çiva, Durgä, Kälé, Gaëeça, Sürya and whomever. However, it was the goddess Pärvaté who asked Lord Çiva, "What is the best type of worship?" Lord Çiva advised, ärädhanänäà sarveñäà viñëor ärädhanaà param (Padma Puräëa). "My dear Pärvaté, of all kinds of worship, worship of Lord Viñëu is the best." Then he added: tasmät parataraà devi tadéyänäà samarcanam. "And even better than the worship of Lord Viñëu is the worship of a Vaiñëava, a devotee."

Spiritual life begins with the association of a devotee, a sädhu. One cannot progress an inch without the mercy of a sädhu. Prahläda Mahäräja has also indicated this:

naiñäà matis tävad urukramäìghrià
spåçaty anarthäpagamo yad-arthaù
mahéyasäà päda-rajo-'bhiñekaà
niñkiïcanänäà na våëéta yävat

"Unless they smear upon their bodies the dust of the lotus feet of a Vaiñëava completely freed from material contamination, persons very much inclined toward materialistic life cannot be attached to the lotus feet of the Lord, who is glorified for His uncommon activities. Only by becoming Kåñëa conscious and taking shelter at the lotus feet of the Lord in this way can one be freed from material contamination." (Bhäg. 7.5.32) Hiraëyakaçipu asked Prahläda Mahäräja, "My dear son Prahläda, how have you become so advanced in Kåñëa consciousness?" Although Hiraëyakaçipu was a demon, he was nonetheless inquisitive. Prahläda Mahäräja replied, "My dear father, O best of the asuras, one can receive Kåñëa consciousness only from the instructions of a guru. One cannot attain it simply by speculating. Ordinary men do not know that their ultimate destination is to return to Viñëu." In the material world, people are always hoping for something. They hope against hope, yet their hopes will never be fulfilled. People are trying to become happy by adjusting the external energy, but they do not know that happiness cannot be achieved without approaching God. People are thinking, "I must first of all see to my own interest." That's all right, but what is that interest? That they do not know. People are thinking that by adjusting the material energy they will be happy, and everyone is trying this individually, collectively or nationally. In any case, it is not possible. People will ultimately be frustrated. Why attempt a process that will ultimately meet with frustration? It is therefore said: adänta-gobhir viçatäà tamisraà punaù punaç carvita-carvaëänäm (Bhäg. 7.5.30). People are being baffled in so many ways because they cannot control their senses. Their only possibility of rescue is Kåñëa. Therefore in this verse it is said: mayy ananyena bhävena bhaktià kurvanti ye dåòhäm.

Prahläda Mahäräja simply thought of Kåñëa. Because of this, he had to undergo a great deal of trouble given by his father. Material nature will not give us freedom very easily. If we become strong enough to try to capture the lotus feet of Kåñëa, mäyä will try to keep us under her clutches. However, if one gives up everything for Kåñëa's sake, mäyä can have no effect. The most excellent example of this is the gopés. They gave up everything—family, prestige and honor—just to follow Kåñëa. That is the highest perfection, but that is not possible for ordinary living entities. We should, however, follow the Gosvämés in their determination to worship Kåñëa.

Sanätana Gosvämé was an important minister in the government of Hussain Shah, but he gave up everything to follow Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. He adopted the life of a mendicant and lived under a different tree every night. One may ask, "After giving up material enjoyment, how can one live?" The Gosvämés lived by dipping into the ocean of the transcendental loving affairs between Kåñëa and the gopés. Since that was their asset, they could live very peacefully. We cannot simply give up everything. We will become mad if we try to give up everything without having staunch faith in Kåñëa. Yet if we find Kåñëa's association, we can easily give up our opulent positions—our family, business and everything. However, that requires sädhu-saìga, association with a sädhu, a devotee. When we associate with a devotee, the day will eventually come when we can give up everything and become liberated persons, fit to return home, back to Godhead.

Presently we are attached to material enjoyment, and Kåñëa even gives us a chance to gratify our senses. He lets us enjoy ourselves to the fullest extent because we have come to this material world to enjoy sense gratification. However, this is called mäyä, illusion. It is not really enjoyment, but simply struggle. When one realizes that he is simply struggling life after life, that there is actually no real enjoyment in the material world, one becomes a devotee of Kåñëa. That realization requires knowledge, and that knowledge can be acquired by association with a sädhu, a devotee.

Freedom from this struggle with material existence is further explained by Lord Kapila in the next verse.

TLK Vs 23

TEXT 23

mad-äçrayäù kathä måñöäù
çåëvanti kathayanti ca
tapanti vividhäs täpä
naitän mad-gata-cetasaù

TRANSLATION

Engaged constantly in chanting and hearing about Me, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the sädhus do not suffer from material miseries because they are always filled with thoughts of My pastimes and activities.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.23]

PURPORT

There are multifarious miseries in material existence—those pertaining to the body and the mind, those imposed by other living entities and those imposed by natural disturbances. But a sädhu is not disturbed by such miserable conditions because his mind is always filled with Kåñëa consciousness, and thus he does not like to talk about anything but the activities of the Lord. Mahäräja Ambaréña did not speak of anything but the pastimes of the Lord. Vacäàsi vaikuëöha-guëänuvarëane. He engaged his words only in glorification of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Ordinary conditioned souls, being forgetful of the activities of the Lord, are always full of anxieties and material tribulations. On the other hand, since the devotees always engage in the topics of the Lord, they are forgetful of the miseries of material existence. Thus they differ from other living entities, who are simply suffering.

There is no one in the world materially engaged who can boldly say, "I am not suffering." I challenge anyone to say this. Everyone in the material world is suffering in some way or another. If not, why are so many drugs being advertised? On the television they are always advertising tranquilizers and pain killers, and in America and in other Western countries they are so advanced that there are dozens of tablets for various pains. Therefore there must be some suffering. Actually, anyone who has a material body has to accept suffering. There are three types of suffering in the material world: ädhyätmika, ädhibhautika and ädhidaivika. Ädhyätmika refers to the body and mind. Today I have a headache or some pain in my back, or my mind is not very quiet. These are sufferings called ädhyätmika. There are other forms of suffering called ädhibhautika, which are sufferings imposed by other living entities. Apart from this, there are sufferings called adhidaivika, over which we have no control whatsoever. These are caused by the demigods or acts of nature, and include famine, pestilence, flood, excessive heat or excessive cold, earthquakes, fire and so on. Nonetheless, we are thinking that we are very happy within this material world, although in addition to these threefold miseries there is also birth, old age, disease and death. So where is our happiness? Because we are under the spell of mäyä, we are thinking that our position is very secure. We are thinking, "Let us enjoy life," but what kind of enjoyment is this?

Obviously we have to tolerate suffering. One of the characteristics of a sädhu is tolerance. Everyone is tolerant to a degree, but a sädhu's tolerance and an ordinary man's tolerance are different. This is because a sädhu knows that he is not the body. According to a Bengali Vaiñëava song: deha-småti nähi yära saàsära-bandhana kähäì tära.

If we properly understand that we are not the body, although we may suffer, we will not feel the suffering as acutely. For instance, if one thinks, "This is my car," and is very attached to it, he suffers more when it is wrecked than a person who thinks, "It can be repaired, or I can leave it." It is a question of mental absorption. Because he is more like an animal, a materialist suffers more. The devotee, on the other hand, takes Kåñëa's advice in Bhagavad-gétä (2.14):

mäträ-sparçäs tu kaunteya
çétoñëa-sukha-duùkha-däù
ägamäpäyino 'nityäs
täàs titikñasva bhärata

"O son of Kunté, the nonpermanent appearance of happiness and distress and their disappearance in due course are like the appearance and disappearance of winter and summer seasons. They arise from sense perception, O scion of Bharata, and one must learn to tolerate them without being disturbed."

In summer we suffer, and in winter we suffer. In the summer, fire brings suffering, and in the winter the same fire is pleasing. Similarly, in the winter, water is suffering, but in the summer it is pleasing. The water and the fire are the same, but sometimes they are pleasing, sometimes they are not. This is due to the touch of the skin. We all have some "skin disease," which is the body, and therefore we are suffering. Because we have become such rascals, we are thinking, "I am this body." According to the Äyur-vedic system, the body is composed of three material elements: kapha-pitta-väyu. The more we are in the bodily conception, the more we suffer.

Presently so many "ism's" are being developed according to the bodily conception—nationalism, communism, socialism, communalism and so on. In Calcutta during the 1947 Hindu-Muslim riots, there was more suffering because everyone was thinking, "I am a Hindu" or "I am a Muslim." But, if one is advanced in Kåñëa consciousness, he will not fight according to such conceptions, A Kåñëa conscious person knows that he is neither Hindu nor Muslim but the eternal servant of Kåñëa. Because people are being educated to become more body conscious, their sufferings are increasing. If we reduce the bodily conception, suffering will also be reduced. Those who are Kåñëa conscious, who are always thinking of Kåñëa within their minds and within their hearts, are not suffering as much because they know that whatever they might suffer is due to Kåñëa's desire. Therefore they welcome suffering. For instance, when Kåñëa was leaving, Queen Kunté said, "My dear Kåñëa, when we were in a dangerous situation, You were always present as our friend and adviser. Now we are well situated with our kingdom, and now You are leaving for Dvärakä. This is not good. It is better that we again suffer so that we can always remember You." Thus the devotee sometimes welcomes suffering as an opportunity to remember Kåñëa constantly. When a devotee suffers, he thinks, "This is due to my past misdeeds. Actually I should be suffering a great deal, but due to Kåñëa's grace I am suffering just a little. After all, suffering and enjoyment are in the mind." In this way, a devotee is not greatly affected by suffering, and this is the difference between a devotee and a nondevotee.

Prahläda Mahäräja, a five-year-old boy, had to undergo a great deal of suffering at the hands of his father, who was torturing him for being a devotee. The boy was trampled by elephants, thrown from a mountain, placed in burning oil and thrown into a snake pit, yet he was silent during this whole ordeal. Similarly, Haridäsa Öhäkura, a Muhammadan by birth, was a very great devotee and was always chanting Hare Kåñëa. That was his only fault. However, the Muslim Kazi called him forth and said, "You are a Muhammadan, born in a great Muhammadan family, yet you are chanting this Hindu Hare Kåñëa mantra. What is this?" Haridäsa Öhäkura mildly replied, "My dear sir, there are many Hindus who have become Muhammadans. Suppose I have become a Hindu? What is wrong with this?" The Kazi became very angry and ordered Haridäsa Öhäkura to be whipped in twenty-two bazaars. This essentially meant that he was to be beaten to death, but because he was such a great devotee he did not actually feel the pain. Although a devotee may sometimes have to suffer, he tolerates the suffering. At the same time, he is very kind to conditioned souls and tries to elevate them to Kåñëa consciousness. This is one of the primary features of a devotee's life. People are always putting a sädhu into difficulties, but he does not give up his job, which is to spread Kåñëa consciousness so that others may become happy. It was Prahläda Mahäräja who said: "My Lord, I am not suffering, for I know the art of being happy." How is this? "Simply by hearing about You and chanting about You I am happy." This is the business of a devotee—hearing and chanting about the Lord. This is çravaëaà kértanam viñëoù smaraëam. Now this çravaëaà kértanam is taking place all over the world through the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

Even in ordinary life it is possible for the mind to be absorbed in such a way that even a surgical operation may not disturb a man. Years ago, when Stalin had to undergo a surgical operation, he refused the use of chloroform. If this is possible even in an ordinary materialistic life, what to speak of spiritual life? One's mind should always be absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness, in thinking of Kåñëa. It is Kåñëa's injunction, "Always think of Me." The European and American youths in the Kåñëa consciousness movement have been accustomed to many bad habits since birth, but now they have given these up. Many people think that it is impossible to live without illicit sex, intoxication, meat-eating and gambling. One famous Marquess told one of my Godbrothers, "Please make me a brähmaëa." My Godbrother said, "Yes, it is not a very difficult thing. Simply give up these bad habits—intoxication, illicit sex, meat-eating and gambling. Then you can become a brähmaëa." The Marquess then said, "Impossible! This is our life." Actually we have seen that in Western countries older men cannot give up these habits, and because of this they are suffering, yet many young boys and girls have given them up, and there is no suffering. This is due to Kåñëa consciousness.

This process is open to everyone. Everyone has heard of the Bhagavad-gétä. We can attain perfection simply by following the instructions given in this book. It is not necessary to abandon our responsibilities. Mahäräja Ambaréña was a great emperor administering to his kingdom, yet at the same time he spoke only of Kåñëa. Caitanya Mahäprabhu requested that His devotees only talk about Kåñëa. If we simply talk about Kåñëa and hear about Him, the stage will come when we will no longer suffer. This is called änandamayo 'bhyäsät in the Vedänta-sütra. The living entity and Kåñëa are both änandamaya, transcendentally blissful. On that platform, there is no possibility of material suffering. It is not a question of displaying some magical feats. The greatest magic is freedom from suffering, and this is the freedom of a devotee. When we feel pleasure from hearing about Kåñëa and talking about Him, we should know that we are making progress on the path of perfection. At that time, material suffering will not be felt at all. This is the practical effect of rendering devotional service, which Lord Kapila is pointing out to His mother.

TLK Vs 24

TEXT 24

ta ete sädhavaù sädhvi
sarva-saìga-vivarjitäù
saìgas teñv atha te prärthyaù
saìga-doña-harä hi te

TRANSLATION

O My mother, O virtuous lady, these are the qualities of great devotees who are free from all attachment. You must seek attachment to such holy men, for this counteracts the pernicious effects of material attachment.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.24]

PURPORT

Kapila Muni herein advises His mother, Devahüti, that if she wants to be free from material attachment, she should increase her attachment for the sädhus, or devotees who are completely freed from all material attachment. In Bhagavad-gétä (15.5) it is stated, nirmäna-mohä jita-saìga-doñäù. This refers to one who is completely freed from the puffed up condition of material possessiveness. A person may be materially very rich or respectable, but if he at all wants to transfer himself to the spiritual kingdom, back home, back to Godhead, he has to be freed from material possessiveness because that is a false position.

The word moha used here means the false understanding that one is rich or poor. In this material world, the conception that one is very rich or very poor—or any such consciousness in connection with material existence—is false, because this body itself is temporary. A pure soul who is prepared to be freed from this material entanglement must first be free from the association of the three modes of nature. Our consciousness at the present moment is polluted because of association with the three modes of nature; therefore in Bhagavad-gétä the same principle is stated. It is advised, jita-saìga-doñäù: one should be freed from the contaminated association of the three modes. Here also, in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, this is confirmed: a pure devotee, who is preparing to transfer himself to the spiritual kingdom, is also freed from the association of the three modes. We have to seek the association of such devotees. For this reason we have begun the International Society for Krishna Consciousness. There are many mercantile and scientific associations in human society established to develop a particular type of education or consciousness, but there is no association which helps one to get free from all material association. If anyone wishes to become free from this material contamination, he has to seek the association of devotees, wherein Kåñëa consciousness is exclusively cultured.

Because a devotee is freed from all contaminated material association, he is not affected by the miseries of material existence, even though he appears to be in the material world. How is it possible? A cat carries her kittens in her mouth, and when she kills a rat, she also carries the booty in her mouth. Thus both are carried in the mouth of the cat, but they are in different conditions. The kitten feels comfort in the mouth of the mother, whereas when the rat is carried in the mouth of the cat, the rat feels the blows of death. Similarly, those who are sädhus, or devotees engaged in the transcendental service of the Lord, do not feel the contamination of material miseries, whereas those who are not devotees in Kåñëa consciousness actually feel the miseries of material existence. One should therefore give up the association of materialistic persons and seek the association of those engaged in Kåñëa consciousness. By such association one will be benefited by spiritual advancement. By their words and instructions, one will be able to cut off his attachment to material existence.

In this Kali-yuga, the present age, the dangerous modes of rajo-guëa and tamo-guëa, passion and ignorance, are especially prominent. Practically everyone in this age is contaminated by lusty desire, greed and ignorance. It is said in the çästras that in this age of Kali, sattva-guëa, the mode of goodness, is practically nonexistent.

The Fourteenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä nicely explains how one can free oneself of contamination by the material modes. Now Kapiladeva advises, "Mother, if you want to get rid of the contamination of material nature, you should associate with a sädhu." Attachment to the material modes brings about our bondage. If we want to be free from this bondage, we have to transfer our attachment to a sädhu.

Actually everyone is attached to something. No one can say that he is free from attachment. The Mäyäväda and Buddhist philosophies tell us to become detached, but this in itself is not possible. A child is attached to playing in so many ways, but gradually his attachments should be transferred to reading and going to school to acquire an education. It is a question not of stopping attachment but of transferring it. If one simply tries to put an end to attachment, he will become mad. Something must be given in the place of attachment. For instance, we tell our disciples to stop eating meat, but how is this meat-eating stopped? In the place of meat, we are supplying kacaurés, rasagullä and many other palatable things. In this way, detachment is possible. First of all, nullify the inferior attachment, and then supply a better attachment. There is no question of forcing a living entity. This must be done gradually. A child may have some attachment, but by the system of replacing attachment, his attachment is overturned. Similarly, our consciousness has somehow or other become contaminated. Now it has to be purified. Then Kåñëa consciousness will automatically arise and awaken.

Kåñëa consciousness is our original consciousness, but somehow or other it has become covered by material attachment. The question is how to give up material attachment and become attached to Kåñëa. The process is sädhu-saìga, association with a sädhu. We have many attachments in this material world, but we cannot make these attachments void. We simply have to purify them. Some say that if the eye is diseased, it should be plucked out, but that is not treatment. Treatment is removing the disease. Somehow or other there is a cataract, and if the cataract is removed, one's eyesight will be revived. We have many desires, but we have to divert these desires to Kåñëa's service. For instance, we may be very attached to making money; therefore Kåñëa says, "Yes, go ahead and conduct your business. There is no harm. Simply give Me the results." As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (9.27):

yat karoñi yad açnäsi
yaj juhoñi dadäsi yat
yat tapasyasi kaunteya
tat kuruñva mad-arpaëam

"O son of Kunté, all that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you may perform, should be done as an offering unto Me."

This is the beginning of bhakti-yoga. If we conduct business and earn money, we should spend it for Kåñëa. This is a form of bhakti. Another vivid example is Arjuna, who was a fighter. By fighting, he became a devotee. He did not become a devotee by chanting Hare Kåñëa but by fighting in the Battle of Kurukñetra. Kåñëa advised him to fight, but because Arjuna was a Vaiñëava, in the beginning he was unwilling. A Vaiñëava does not like to kill anything, but if Kåñëa orders him, he must fight. He does not fight out of his own will, because a Vaiñëava's natural instinct is not to do harm to anyone. However, when a Vaiñëava knows that Kåñëa wants a particular thing done, he does not care for his own considerations. In any case, everyone has some particular type of duty, an occupation. If we perform our occupation in the worship of Kåñëa, our life will be perfect. This is also the instruction given in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.2.13):

ataù pumbhir dvija-çreñöhä
varëäçrama-vibhägaçaù
svanuñöhitasya dharmasya
saàsiddhir hari-toñaëam

"O best of the twice-born, it is therefore concluded that the highest perfection one can achieve by discharging the duties prescribed for one's own occupation according to caste divisions and orders of life is to please the Personality of Godhead."

Formerly, the varëäçrama-dharma was prominent, and everyone had a particular duty according to his position in society. Now the occupational duties have expanded, but it doesn't matter whether one is an engineer, a doctor or whatever. Simply try to serve Kåñëa by the results of work. That is bhakti. It is not the philosophy of this Kåñëa consciousness movement to disengage people from their activities. One should engage in his occupation, but one should never forget Kåñëa. Kåñëa advises us to always become Kåñëa conscious, and we should always think that we are acting for Kåñëa. Of course, we should work by the order of Kåñëa or His representative, not whimsically. If we perform some nonsensical action and think, "I am doing this for Kåñëa," that will not be accepted. The work must be verified by Kåñëa's acceptance or by the acceptance of Kåñëa's representative. Arjuna did not fight without Kåñëa's order; therefore we must receive our orders also. We may say, "I cannot find Kåñëa. How can I follow His order?" It is the role of the sädhu to impart Kåñëa's orders. Since Kåñëa's representative is the sädhu, Kapiladeva advises His mother to associate with sädhus.

We have described the symptoms of a sädhu, and we have stated that a sädhu should be accepted by his characteristics. It is not that we accept anyone who comes along and says, "I am a sädhu." The characteristics of a sädhu have to be present. Similarly, it is not that anyone is accepted who comes along and says, "I am an incarnation of God." There are characteristics of God given in the çästras. Sädhu-saìga, association with a sädhu, is very essential in Kåñëa consciousness. People are suffering due to contamination by tamo-guëa and rajo-guëa. The sädhu teaches one how to remain purely in sattva-guëa by truthfulness, cleanliness, mind control, sense control, simplicity, tolerance, and full faith and knowledge. These are some of the characteristics of sattva-guëa.

Instead of thinking, "Unless I have a drink, I will go mad," one should think, "Unless I associate with a sädhu, I will go mad." When we can think in this way, we will become liberated. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has stated that He wants every village in the entire world to be a center for Kåñëa consciousness so that people can take advantage of sädhus and in turn become sädhus. This is the mission of this Kåñëa consciousness movement. We simply have to voluntarily undergo some penance in the beginning. It may be a little painful in the beginning to refrain from illicit sex, intoxication, meat-eating and gambling, but one has to be tolerant. To be cured of a disease, we may have to agree to undergo some surgical operation. Although the operation may be very painful, we have to tolerate it. This is called titikñavaù. At the same time, we have to be käruëikäù—that is, we have to take compassion upon fallen souls by going from town to town to enlighten others in Kåñëa consciousness. This is a sädhu's duty. Those who are preachers are superior to those who go to the Himalayas to meditate. It is good to go to the Himalayas to meditate for one's personal benefit, but those who undergo many difficulties in order to preach are superior. They are actually fighting for Kåñëa's sake, and they are certainly more compassionate. Those sädhus who leave Våndävana to go fight in the world, to spread Kåñëa consciousness, are superior sädhus. This is the opinion of Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (18.68-69):

ya idaà paramaà guhyaà
mad-bhakteñv abhidhäsyati
bhaktià mayi paräà kåtvä
mäm evaiñyaty asaàçayaù

na ca tasmän manuñyeñu
kaçcin me priya-kåttamaù
bhavitä na ca me tasmäd
anyaù priyataro bhuvi

"For one who explains the supreme secret to the devotees, devotional service is guaranteed, and at the end he will come back to Me. There is no servant in this world more dear to Me than he, nor will there ever be one more dear."

If we want to be quickly recognized by Kåñëa, we should become preachers. This is also the message of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. It is not that one should remain in India; rather, one should travel all over the world to preach Kåñëa consciousness. The sädhu is suhåt; he is the well-wisher of everyone. This does not mean that he is a well-wisher for an Indian nationalist or whatever. No, he is a well-wisher even of cats and dogs. A devotee even wishes to benefit cats and dogs by giving them prasäda. Once, when devotees from Bengal were going to see Caitanya Mahäprabhu, a dog began to follow them, and the leader of the party, Çivänanda Sena, was giving prasäda to the dog. When they had to cross a river, the boatman would not take the dog, but Çivänanda Sena paid him more money and said, "Please take this dog. He is a Vaiñëava, for he has joined our company. How can we leave him behind?" Caitanya Mahäprabhu Himself actually threw some of His food to the dog, and in this way the dog attained Vaikuëöha.

Not only is a sädhu everyone's well-wisher, but he is not an enemy of anyone. He is also çänta, peaceful. These are the preliminary characteristics of a sädhu. He is also attached to no one but Kåñëa. Mayy ananyena bhävena. These are the external and internal symptoms of a devotee. A devotee also respects the demigods because he knows their position in relation to Kåñëa. In Brahma-saàhitä (5.44), the Goddess Durgä is worshiped as the external energy, or potency, of Kåñëa.

såñöi-sthiti-pralaya-sädhana-çaktir ekä
chäyeva yasya bhuvanäni bibharti durgä
icchänurüpam api yasya ca ceñöate sä
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"The external potency, mäyä, who is of the nature of the shadow of the cit, spiritual, potency, is worshiped by all people as Durgä, the creating, preserving and destroying agency of this mundane world. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda, in accordance with whose will Durgä conducts herself."

The Goddess Durgä is so powerful that she can create, maintain and annihilate. However, she cannot act independent of Kåñëa. She is like a shadow of Kåñëa. A sädhu knows that prakåti, nature, is working under Kåñëa's direction. Similarly, a policeman knows that he is not working independently but under government orders. This knowledge is required in order that the policeman, who has some power, will not think that he has become God. No, God is not so cheap. God has multienergies, and one of these energies is Durgä. It is not that she is all and all, for there are many millions of Durgäs, just as there are many millions of Çivas and millions of universes. Although there are millions of demigods, God is one. It is not that there are a million Gods. Of course, God can expand in millions of forms, but that is different. A devotee offers respects to the demigods as the assistants of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, not as the supreme power. One who does not know God as He is considers the demigods to be supreme. Such people are less intelligent. A devotee offers respects to the demigods, but he knows that the Supreme Lord is Kåñëa. Kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam. Actually a sädhu, a Vaiñëava, offers respects to everyone, and he is ready to give up relatives and everything else for Kåñëa's sake. A sädhu simply takes pleasure in hearing about Kåñëa and talking about Him.

There are many pastimes enacted by Kåñëa. He fights and kills demons, and He performs His pastimes with the gopés. He plays as a cowherd boy in Våndävana and as King of Dvärakä. There are many books about Kåñëa, kåñëa-kathä, and this Kåñëa consciousness movement has already published many of them. Apart from Bhagavad-gétä, which is spoken by Kåñëa, we can read these other books. In this way, one can learn the art of becoming a sädhu. Simply by hearing about Kåñëa and speaking about Him, we will be immediately relieved from the suffering of this material condition.

As stated in this verse:

ta ete sädhavaù sädhvi
sarva-saìga-vivarjitäù

These symptoms are visible when one no longer has material attachment. A sädhu does not think himself Hindu, Muslim, Christian, American, Indian or whatever. A sädhu simply thinks, "I am the servant of Kåñëa." Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu has said, "I am not a brähmaëa, kñatriya, vaiçya, çüdra, brahmacäré or whatever. I am simply the servant of the servant of the servant of Kåñëa [Padyävalé 74]." One need only learn this process in order to render the best service to humanity.

TLK 12: Association with the Supreme Lord Through Hearing

CHAPTER TWELVE
Association with the Supreme Lord Through Hearing

TLK Vs 25-26

TEXTS 25-26

satäà prasaìgän mama vérya-saàvido
bhavanti håt-karëa-rasäyanäù kathäù
taj joñaëäd äçv apavarga-vartmani
çraddhä ratir bhaktir anukramiñyati

bhaktyä pumäï jäta-viräga aindriyäd
dåñöa-çrutän mad-racanänucintayä
cittasya yatto grahaëe yoga-yukto
yatiñyate åjubhir yoga-märgaiù

TRANSLATION

In the association of pure devotees, discussion of the pastimes and activities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is very pleasing and satisfying to the ear and the heart. By cultivating such knowledge one gradually becomes advanced on the path of liberation, and thereafter he is freed, and his attraction becomes fixed. Then real devotion and devotional service begin.

Thus consciously engaged in devotional service in the association of devotees, a person gains distaste for sense gratification, both in this world and in the next, by constantly thinking about the activities of the Lord. This process of Kåñëa consciousness is the easiest process of mystic power; when one is actually situated on that path of devotional service, he is able to control the mind.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.25 / 26]

PURPORT

The process of advancing in Kåñëa consciousness and devotional service is described here. The first point is that one must seek the association of persons who are Kåñëa conscious and who engage in devotional service. Without such association one cannot advance. Simply by theoretical knowledge or study one cannot make any appreciable advancement. One must give up the association of materialistic persons and seek the association of devotees because without such association one cannot understand the activities of the Lord. Generally, people are convinced of the impersonal feature of the Absolute Truth. Because they do not associate with devotees, they cannot understand that the Absolute Truth can be a person and have personal activities. This is a very difficult subject matter, and unless one has personal understanding of the Absolute Truth, there is no meaning to devotion. Service or devotion cannot be offered to anything impersonal. Service must be offered to a person. Nondevotees cannot appreciate Kåñëa consciousness by reading the Çrémad-Bhägavatam or any other Vedic literature wherein the activities of the Lord are described; they think that these activities are fictional, because spiritual life is not explained to them in the proper mood. To understand the personal activities of the Lord, one has to seek the association of devotees, and by such association, when one contemplates and tries to understand the transcendental activities of the Lord, the path to liberation is open, and he is freed. One who has firm faith in the Supreme Personality of Godhead becomes fixed, and his attraction for association with the Lord and the devotees increases. Association with devotees means association with the Lord. The devotee who makes this association develops the consciousness for rendering service to the Lord, and then, being situated in the transcendental position of devotional service, he gradually becomes perfect.

In all scriptures people are encouraged to act in a pious way so that they can enjoy sense gratification not only in this life but also in the next. For example, one is promised promotion to the heavenly kingdom of higher planets by pious fruitive activities. But a devotee in the association of devotees prefers to contemplate the activities of the Lord—how He has created this universe, how He is maintaining it, how the creation dissolves, and how in the spiritual kingdom the Lord's pastimes are enacted. There are full literatures describing these activities, especially Bhagavad-gétä, Brahma-saàhitä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam. The sincere devotee who associates with devotees gets the opportunity to hear and contemplate these subjects, and the result is that he feels distaste for so-called happiness in this or that world, in heaven or on other planets. The devotees are simply interested in being transferred to the personal association of the Lord; they are no longer attracted to temporary so-called happiness. That is the position of one who is yoga-yukta. One who is fixed in mystic power is not disturbed by the allurement of this world or that world; he is interested in spiritual understanding. This is very easily attained by the easiest process, bhakti-yoga. Åjubhir yoga-märgaiù [Bhäg. 3.25.26]. A very suitable word used here is åjubhiù, or "very easy." There are different processes of yoga-märga, attaining yoga perfection, but this process, devotional service to the Lord, is the easiest. Not only is it the easiest process, but the result is sublime. Everyone, therefore, should try this process of Kåñëa consciousness and reach the highest perfection.

Sat means "existence," and asat means "that which does not exist," that which is temporary. The material world is asat; therefore the Vedas enjoin: asato mä sad gamaya: "Do not remain within this material world." Those who are interested in materialistic life are also called asat. When asked how a Vaiñëava behaves, Caitanya Mahäprabhu replied, asat-saìga-tyäga—ei vaiñëava-äcära: "A devotee first of all avoids the company of asat, those who are materially interested." (Cc. Madhya 22.87) We have established this Kåñëa consciousness movement in order to avoid asat-saìga, association with those who are interested in material things. Because we are associating with Kåñëa, we do not wish to talk about anything but Kåñëa. Everyone is interested in this business or that, and we are exclusively interested in our Kåñëa consciousness business. Those who are asat are very much attached to sense gratification, and the culmination of sense gratification is sex.

In addition, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé in his Hari-bhakti-viläsa recommends that one should not hear Bhagavad-gétä, the puräëas, the Çrémad-Bhägavatam or any hari-kathä from anyone who is not a Vaiñëava in his actions. That means that we should not hear these Vedic literatures from the Mäyävädés, who actually do not accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. How can one not accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord and yet dare to speak on Bhagavad-gétä? We will never derive any benefit from listening to the commentaries of such people. Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam should be heard from the devotees. We can hear Bhagavad-gétä from Mäyävädés for hundreds of years and yet never understand Kåñëa. It is therefore forbidden for Vaiñëavas to hear talks given by Mäyävädés.

Hari-kathä, talks about Çré Hari, or Kåñëa, are amåta, nectar. If one hears them from the right source, he attains amåta (so 'måtatväya kalpate). Måta means "birth and death," and amåta means "the cessation of birth and death." Spiritual life means putting an end to birth, old age, disease and death. Getting amåta, nectar, means getting relief from birth and death, and that is the real aim of spiritual life. Lord Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (7.16) that spiritual life begins when one is pious:

catur-vidhä bhajante mäà
janäù sukåtino 'rjuna
ärto jijïäsur arthärthé
jïäné ca bharatarñabha

"O best among the Bhäratas [Arjuna], four kinds of pious men render devotional service unto Me—the distressed, the desirer of wealth, the inquisitive, and he who is searching for knowledge of the Absolute."

If we actually want to become pious and develop our devotional life, we have to associate unflinchingly with a sädhu. Then we can acquire some taste for Kåñëa. When we discuss Kåñëa with a sädhu, the discussion becomes very pleasing, and we develop some taste, which is called rasa, or mellow. Rasa is the enjoyment we derive from drinking something very nice when we are thirsty. Kåñëa has instructed us to think of Him when drinking water. This is not very difficult. Kåñëa also tells us to think of Him when we see sunlight in the morning. Why do we say, "Can you show me God?" God is showing us Himself. Why do we close our eyes to try to see Him? He says, "I am this, and I am that." It is not that suddenly we can expect to see God, but we can become qualified to see God through the association of a sädhu. Presently many people are interested in receiving degrees from big universities, but education without God consciousness is simply an expansion of mäyä's influence. Because knowledge is taken away by illusion, the universities are simply presenting impediments on the path of God consciousness. The living entity is already illusioned when he comes into the material world, and so-called advanced education simply increases his illusion. Trying to become happy in this temporary, material life, the living entity has forgotten that he is the eternal servant of Kåñëa. Even if one becomes happy in this temporary life, his happiness is an illusion because no one is allowed to stay and enjoy his happiness. These points have to be understood in the association of devotees. A devotee knows everything because he has seen the Supreme Absolute Truth, Kåñëa.

What is the goal of vedänta-darçana? Veda means "knowledge," and anta means "ultimate." What is that ultimate knowledge? In Bhagavad-gétä (15.15) Çré Kåñëa says:

vedaiç ca sarvair aham eva vedyo
vedänta-kåd veda-vid eva cäham

"By all the Vedas, I am to be known; indeed, I am the compiler of Vedänta, and I am the knower of the Vedas."

If we listen to Kåñëa and understand what and who He is, we can actually understand Vedänta. If we do not understand Kåñëa but advertise ourselves as Vedäntists, we are just being illusioned. Without understanding Kåñëa, one is actually a müòha, a fool. People do not know it, but actually anyone in the material world is more or less a müòha. We are all müòhas, for unless we are müòhas, we do not come into the material world. From Brahmä down to the smallest ant, we are all müòhas of different degrees. In order to become really learned, we have to associate with devotees. Then we can actually relish kåñëa-kathä. When discussed among devotees, kåñëa-kathä is pleasing to the heart and ear. This requires a little training, and this training is given by the devotees. We should follow the devotees in their practical daily life, in their routine work and behavior. Cultivation means practice, and the great äcäryas have given a routine we can cultivate. For instance, The Nectar of Devotion by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé deals with the cultivation of devotional service, and this book, which we have translated, has been very well received in European and American universities. Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, The Nectar of Devotion, is the actual science of bhakti. Bhakti is not sentiment; it is a great science, and we have to learn it scientifically. It is not that we have to wait for another life to cultivate devotional service. We can read The Nectar of Devotion, live with devotees, rise early in the morning to attend maìgala-ärati, study Vedic literature, take prasäda and preach Kåñëa consciousness.

Mäyä is very strong, and to begin devotional service is to declare war against mäyä. Some of the devotees in this Kåñëa consciousness movement may fall down, but whatever is done sincerely is to their permanent credit. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä. If one renders a little devotional service, he does not fall down into the lower species but again attains a human form. There are 8,400,000 species, but the fallen devotee is guaranteed a human life. If one becomes Kåñëa conscious, he is assured of a good birth in the next life. However, if one completes his Kåñëa consciousness in this life, he will not take birth again but will go to Kåñëa. This is what is actually wanted. Why take the chance of being born into a rich family or a brähmaëa family? Actually, such a birth is quite risky because there is really no guarantee. Generally, those who are rich don't care at all for Kåñëa consciousness, and those who are born in brähmaëa families generally become puffed-up, thinking, "I am a brähmaëa. I am born in a very high family." Thinking this brings about their falldown. It is said that pride precedes a fall. A Vaiñëava is by nature very humble.

These are the chances one takes when one becomes a human being. Kåñëa is personally advising us to take up the opportunities offered by the Kåñëa consciousness movement. We should take them and not run the risk of committing spiritual suicide.

This is the process for understanding the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Person, the Supreme Being. In the Absolute, there are no contradictions. Kåñëa's name, form, activities, paraphernalia and attributes are identical with Kåñëa. This is the meaning of absolute. There is no difference between Kåñëa's form and Kåñëa. Kåñëa's hands and Kåñëa's legs are nondifferent. In the material world, there is a difference between our left hand and our right hand, between the nose and the ear, but these dualities do not exist in Kåñëa. This is the meaning of absolute. As stated in Brahma-saàhitä (5.32):

aìgäni yasya sakalendriya-våttimanti
paçyanti pänti kalayanti ciraà jaganti
änanda-cinmaya-sad-ujjvala-vigrahasya
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, whose transcendental form is full of bliss, truth and substantiality, and is thus full of the most dazzling splendor. Each of the limbs of that transcendental figure possesses, in Himself, the full-fledged functions of all the organs, and eternally sees, maintains and manifests the infinite universes, both spiritual and mundane." The different parts of our bodies serve different purposes, but any limb of Kåñëa's body can serve any purpose. Kåñëa can eat through His eyes, or Kåñëa can go somewhere simply by thinking. The Absolute is advaita. There is no duality in the Absolute. Everything is one.

Our material disease lies in wanting to satisfy our senses. We have stated before that advancement of civilization means advancement of sense gratification, but bhakti means just the opposite. As long as we are interested in sense gratification, there is no question of bhakti. We have to reduce our tendency for sense gratification and increase our devotional activities. We have also stated that material bondage means accepting one body and creating another. Kåñëa, through nature, will give us full facility to enjoy our senses. Presently in the Western countries it has become fashionable to run around naked. Therefore nature will give these people an opportunity to stand naked like trees for many years. Why are we receiving different bodies? Because we have different tendencies for sense gratification. We actually have to come to detest sense gratification before our spiritual life begins. This is made possible through bhakti. Although Kåñëa is beyond our vision, He has agreed to be seen by us through the arcä-vigraha, the Deity. We should not think that the Deity is made of stone. Even if it is stone, we should think that Kåñëa has made Himself visible before us like a stone because we cannot see beyond stone. That is Kåñëa's mercy. Because our eyes and other senses are imperfect, we cannot see Kåñëa present everywhere in His original spiritual form. Because we are imperfect, we see the difference between things spiritual and material, but Kåñëa, being absolute, knows no such distinctions. He can become spiritual or material, however He likes, and it does not make any difference to Him. Being almighty and omnipotent, Kåñëa can change matter into spirit and spirit into matter. Therefore we should not think, as the atheists do, that we are worshiping idols. Even if it is an idol, it is still Kåñëa. That is the absolute nature of Kåñëa. Even if we think that the Deity is a stone, or a piece of metal or some wood, He is still Kåñëa. The understanding of this requires bhakti on our part. If we are a little thoughtful and philosophical, and if we are at all inclined toward bhakti, we can understand that Kåñëa is present in stone.

Actually, nothing is different from Kåñëa because everything is Kåñëa's energy. The Mäyävädé philosophers say that since everything is God, the personality of Kåñëa is finished. But actually Kåñëa is Kåñëa, and at the same time He is everything. We can understand this by bhakti, but not by any other process. When a bhakta sees a tree, he sees Kåñëa. As explained in Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 8.274):

sthävara jaìgama dekhe, nä dekhe tära mürti
sarvatra haya nija iñöa-deva-sphürti

The advanced devotee does not see living entities as moving and not moving. He sees Kåñëa. This is also stated in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.38):

premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena
santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti

Because his eyes are always smeared with the ointment of devotion, the devotee always sees Kåñëa and nothing else. He sees Kåñëa and Kåñëa's energy everywhere. For instance, if you love your child, when you see your child's shoe, you immediately see your child. Or if you see your child's toy, you immediately see your child and hear his voice. Similarly, if we have actually developed love of Kåñëa, nothing exists but Kåñëa. When our love for Kåñëa is actually developed, whatever we see, we will see Kåñëa.

Unless one is advanced in kåñëa-premä, love of Kåñëa, he cannot see or understand. By the blunt material senses, we cannot even understand the name of Kåñëa. People are always asking, "Why are these people chanting Hare Kåñëa?" They cannot understand, although Kåñëa realization begins with the name. The name of Kåñëa and Kåñëa are nondifferent, but we cannot realize this intellectually. We have to practice chanting Hare Kåñëa to realize it. When we actually advance in devotional service and chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra offenselessly, we will realize that Kåñëa and His name are nondifferent. Thus kåñëa-bhakti begins with the tongue, for we can utilize the tongue to chant, and to taste kåñëa-prasäda. In this way we can become a Kåñëa bhakta.

When we see the Deity of Kåñëa in the temple, we should think that the Deity is Kåñëa. In this way Kåñëa has agreed to be seen by us and even dressed by us. However, if we think of Kåñëa's viräö-rüpa, His universal form, what can we do? How can we dress the viräö-rüpa? His many heads cover the sky, and we cannot even conceive of Him. Kåñëa can become bigger than the biggest and smaller than the smallest. Therefore this verse states: bhaktyä pumäï jäta-viräga aindriyät. The more we serve Kåñëa, give Him things to eat and dress Him nicely, the less we become interested in our own bodies. In the material world everyone is very busy dressing himself very nicely in order to be sexually attractive, but if we try to dress Kåñëa nicely, we will forget our own material dress. If we feed Kåñëa nice food, we will forget to satisfy our own tongue by going to this or that restaurant.

Kåñëa was teaching Bhagavad-gétä, and Arjuna was seeing Him face to face, but seeing Kåñëa and reading Bhagavad-gétä are the same. Some people say that Arjuna was fortunate to have seen Kåñëa face to face and take instructions from Him, but Kåñëa can be seen immediately, provided one has the eyes to see. There is the example in Caitanya-caritämåta of a brähmaëa in South India who was reading Bhagavad-gétä, although he was illiterate. The people in the neighborhood knew that he was illiterate, and they made jokes, asking him, "Well, how is it you are reading Bhagavad-gétä?" One day Caitanya Mahäprabhu happened to be in a temple nearby, and He could understand that this man was a devotee. He therefore approached him and asked, "My dear brähmaëa, what are you reading?" The brähmaëa replied, "I am reading Bhagavad-gétä, or, rather, I am trying to read Bhagavad-gétä. I happen to be illiterate, but my guru-mahäräja has said that I must read the eighteen chapters of Bhagavad-gétä daily. I am simply trying to carry out his order, and therefore I am opening and closing the pages." Caitanya Mahäprabhu then said, "I see that you are crying sometimes. Why is this?" The brähmaëa replied, "Yes, I am crying because when I take up this book, I see a picture of Kåñëa driving Arjuna's chariot. Çré Kåñëa is so kind that He has accepted the position of a servant to His devotee. Therefore when I see this picture, I weep." Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu then immediately embraced the brähmaëa and said, "You have actually read Bhagavad-gétä."

It is not that a wealth of education is required. One does not even have to understand the language. The only ingredient needed is bhakti, love. If one becomes a pure bhakta, he will forget all material sense enjoyment. Being a bhakta doesn't simply mean wearing tilaka and robes. One is not a bhakta if he has a taste for material sense enjoyment. A true bhakta wants to satisfy not his senses but the senses of Kåñëa. That is the spiritual world. In the spiritual world, Våndävana, everyone—Mother Yaçodä, Nanda Mahäräja, Çrématé Rädhäräëé, the gopés, the cowherd boys, Çrédämä, Sudämä, the land, the water, the trees, the birds—all are trying to satisfy Kåñëa. That is the real meaning of Våndävana. When Kåñëa left Våndävana for Mathurä, everyone in Våndävana fell dead out of separation from Him. Similarly, we can always live in Våndävana, in Vaikuëöha, if we are mad after Kåñëa. This is the teaching of Caitanya Mahäprabhu, and He illustrated this by His very life. When He was in Jagannätha Puré, He was always mad after Kåñëa day and night. The last twelve years of His life were passed in madness. Sometimes He threw Himself into the ocean, and He wandered about like a madman. Of course, this is not possible for ordinary living entities. However, if we become bhaktas, we will find intelligence behind everything in the creation. If we take a flower and see its constitution, how it is made and how its colors are displayed and how it comes into existence, we can see Kåñëa. We can see how Kåñëa has created such a beautiful thing so intelligently. We should not consider like rascals that such a thing has come into being automatically. Fools cannot see, but those who are intelligent can see that the hand of the Supreme Lord is in everything within the creation. Éçäväsyam idaà sarvam.

Actually, nothing comes about automatically. Everything comes about through the intelligence of Kåñëa, through His fine and accurate powers. If we paint a picture of a flower, we have to arrange many facets, and still the picture will not be absolutely perfect. Yet the flower created by Kåñëa has come out perfectly. What rascal can say that there is no brain behind it? Kåñëa specifically says that we should not think that prakåti, nature, is working automatically. He says, "Nature is working under My direction." One simply has to develop the eyes to see how these things are going on. This is possible if we engage the senses in the service of Kåñëa. We first of all must engage the tongue in chanting Hare Kåñëa and in eating bhagavat-prasäda. Nothing else is required. Therefore the Kåñëa consciousness movement is distributing prasäda and engaging people in chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra.

TLK Vs 27

TEXT 27

asevayäyaà prakåter guëänäà
jïänena vairägya-vijåmbhitena
yogena mayy arpitayä ca bhaktyä
mäà pratyag-ätmänam ihävarundhe

TRANSLATION

Thus by not engaging in the service of the modes of material nature but by developing Kåñëa consciousness, knowledge in renunciation, and by practicing yoga, in which the mind is always fixed in devotional service unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one achieves My association in this very life, for I am the Supreme Personality, the Absolute Truth.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.27]

PURPORT

When one engages in the nine different processes of bhakti-yoga enunciated in authoritative scriptures, such as hearing (çravaëam), chanting (kértanam), remembering, worshiping, praying and offering personal service—either in one of them or two or three or all of them—he naturally has no opportunity to engage in the service of the three modes of material nature. Unless one has good engagements in spiritual service, it is not possible to become detached from material service. Those who are not devotees, therefore, are interested in so-called humanitarian or philanthropic work, such as opening a hospital or charitable institution. These are undoubtedly good works in the sense that they are pious activities, and the performer may get some opportunities for sense gratification, either in this life or in the next. Devotional service, however, is beyond the boundary of sense gratification. It is a completely spiritual activity. When one engages in the spiritual activities of devotional service, he does not engage in sense gratificatory activities. Kåñëa conscious activities are performed not blindly but with the perfect understanding of knowledge and renunciation. This kind of yoga practice, in which the mind is always fixed upon the Supreme Personality of Godhead in devotion, results in liberation in this very life. The person who performs such acts gets in touch with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Lord Caitanya, therefore, approved the process of hearing from realized devotees about the pastimes of the Lord. It does not matter to what mundane category the audience belongs. If one meekly and submissively hears about the activities of the Lord from a realized soul, he will be able to conquer the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is unconquerable by any other process. Hearing and associating with devotees are the most important functions for self-realization.

In Goloka Våndävana, the living entities are serving Kåñëa as friends, cowherd boys, gopés, lovers, fathers, mothers and so on. Even the trees, water, flowers, land, calves and cows serve Kåñëa in Goloka Våndävana. This is also our business, but somehow or other we do not like to serve Kåñëa; therefore we have been put into the service of mäyä, in the three modes of material nature. When a criminal does not like to obey the laws of the state, he is placed into prison and forced to abide by the laws. Our constitutional position is to render service to Kåñëa as His part and parcel, and as soon as we refuse to render Him service, mäyä is immediately there to capture us and say, "Serve me." It is not our nature to become master. Even if we become master, we will not be happy, because that is artificial. For instance, if the hand thinks, "Oh, now I have some nice sweets. Now I can eat," the hand will ultimately be frustrated. It is the duty and nature of the hand to place the food in the mouth. In this way the hand is nourished; otherwise everything is spoiled. Similarly, we are part and parcel of Kåñëa, and our business is to satisfy Kåñëa. From the Vedas we understand that God, who is one, has become many. We are the many parts and parcels of Kåñëa. Sväàças are His personal expansions, and we are His differential expansions, vibhinnäàças. In any case, all expansions are meant to serve Kåñëa. This is explained in the Caitanya-caritämåta (Ädi 5.142): ekale éçvara kåñëa, ära saba bhåtya. "Lord Kåñëa alone is the supreme controller, and all others are His servants."

It is our natural propensity to enjoy ourselves with Kåñëa. As stated before, Kåñëa is änanda-maya, and, being part and parcel of Kåñëa, we are also änanda-maya. Now we are seeking änanda (bliss) in different atmospheres. Because we have a little independence, we have decided to go to the prison house of material nature and try to serve our senses instead of Kåñëa. Now we have to learn how to forget to serve this material nature, and that process is bhakti-märga, the path of devotional service. When we come to the understanding that we are actually no one's servant but Kåñëa's, we attain self-realization. We must come to this understanding not by sentiment but by real knowledge. After many births and deaths, when one realizes that väsudevaù sarvam iti—Väsudeva is all—he surrenders unto Kåñëa. This is real knowledge—jïäna and vairägya, knowledge and detachment from material things.

Once one engages fully in Kåñëa's service, he comes to the brahma-bhüta platform. Presently we are on the mäyä-bhüta platform, identifying ourselves with mäyä and working according to the modes of material nature. However, when one comes to the realization that he is spirit (ahaà brahmäsmi), he will immediately become happy.

Under the modes of material nature, we are being carried away by the waves of material nature, and we have no control over where we are going. Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura has stated: mäyära vaçe, yäccha bhese', khäccha häbuòubu, bhäi. We are like straws on the waves of the ocean, and we are fully under the control of the waves. Atheists shudder when they think that there is a next life, because their lives are sinful and they fear punishment in the next. There is a Bengali proverb about a person who thought, "I have committed so many sinful acts that Yamaräja will come and punish me. How can I avoid him?" Thinking about this some time, he decided, "Let me smear my body with stool. Then Yamaräja will not touch me." However, this is simply foolishness. We are under the control of mäyä, material nature, and it is not possible to avoid it. We have become infected by the disease of material nature, and no artificial means will save us. There is no way out other than surrender to Kåñëa. Kåñëa says that He will save us, even though we are very sinful.

If we turn our attention to Kåñëa's service, to bhakti-yoga, we can force ourselves to give up all anarthas, unwanted things. We should get up early in the morning and engage ourselves in the service of Kåñëa; then gradually we will forget the service of mäyä. Bhakti-yoga is so strong that if we engage in it, mäyä's service will automatically be negated. This is called vairägya.

Kåñëa is the original puruña, the original spirit, the original person. Everything has come from Kåñëa, and therefore He is Puräëa, the oldest. No one is older than Kåñëa, but He is always young. That is Bhagavän. He is ädi, the original source, the cause of all causes. Yet we never see Kåñëa as an old man. He is always fresh and youthful. Although Kåñëa was a great-grandfather at the Battle of Kurukñetra, He did not appear any older than a young man of twenty. Kåñëa is always a young boy, and those living entities in the spiritual universe also have spiritual bodies the same as Kåñëa's. In the Sixth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam we read that when the Vaikuëöha-dütas came to take Ajämila, they were four-handed and very beautiful. In the spiritual world, there are four-handed living entities, and they are all nitya-mukta, eternally liberated.

Unfortunately, we are now prisoners in this material world, and we presently have material bodies. These bodies are changing. Sometimes they are young and sometimes old. However, if we become Kåñëa conscious, we will not get another material body after leaving this body. We will go home, back to Godhead, and attain our original, spiritual body, which is the same kind of beautiful body that Kåñëa, Näräyaëa, has. We should take this opportunity to become devotees of Kåñëa by following the processes of bhakti-yoga—çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù smaraëam. päda-sevanaà arcanam. We can take one or all of the nine processes of devotional service and make our lives successful. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has prescribed the most important process—çravaëam. We need only hear, and that will make our lives successful.

TLK 13: Perfect Knowledge Through Surrender

CHAPTER THIRTEEN
Perfect Knowledge Through Surrender

TLK Vs 28

TEXT 28

devahütir uväca
käcit tvayy ucitä bhaktiù
kédåçé mama gocarä
yayä padaà te nirväëam
aïjasänväçnavä aham

TRANSLATION

On hearing this statement of the Lord, Devahüti inquired: What kind of devotional service is worth developing and practicing to help me easily and immediately attain the service of Your lotus feet?

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.28]

PURPORT

It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that no one is barred from rendering service to the Lord. Whether one is a woman or a laborer or a merchant, if he engages himself in the devotional service of the Lord, he is promoted to the highest perfectional state and goes back home, back to Godhead. The devotional service most suitable for different types of devotees is determined and fixed by the mercy of the spiritual master. Therefore in order to become free from the miseries of material nature, one should approach a bona fide spiritual master inquisitively and submissively. When Arjuna submitted to Kåñëa, he said, "My dear Kåñëa, now I no longer care to talk to You as a friend because friendly talks will not benefit me now." Generally we talk to a friend just to spend time, but when we approach a spiritual master, we should be submissive. Friends approach one another on an equal basis, but this is not the way to approach a spiritual master. Unless one is submissive, one cannot accept sublime instructions. Arjuna teaches us submission by giving up his friendly relationship with Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He says, "I have now become Your disciple. Please instruct me."

We can speculate for many births, for many years, and yet not be able to understand the ultimate goal of life. Therefore the çästras all advise that we search out a guru. The word guru means "heavy" or "weighty." One who has much knowledge is heavy with knowledge. One should consider the bona fide guru in this way, and one should not think, "I know everything. Who can teach me?" No one can say such a thing, for everyone needs instruction.

According to the Vedic system, a child is sent to a guru-kula to learn spiritual knowledge from the very beginning. When a child goes to a guru-kula, he becomes a brahmacäré and works like a menial servant. He may be the son of a great brähmaëa or a great king; it doesn't matter. When one goes to a guru-kula, he immediately becomes the menial servant of the guru. If the guru orders him to perform some lowly service, he is prepared to do it. This is the business of a brahmacäré. Even Kåñëa went to a guru-kula to teach us. There was no need for Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, to go to a guru-kula, but He did this simply to set an example. Caitanya Mahäprabhu also accepted a guru.

Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté was a very learned scholar, and he knew that Caitanya Mahäprabhu was also a great scholar, yet he criticized Caitanya Mahäprabhu for chanting and dancing, for Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté felt that a sannyäsé should devote his entire attention to the reading of Vedänta. He therefore considered Caitanya Mahäprabhu a sentimentalist, not a bona fide sannyäsé. Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté inquired, "Why aren't you reading Vedänta-sütra? Why are you chanting and dancing?" Caitanya Mahäprabhu replied:

prabhu kahe—çuna, çrépäda, ihära käraëa
guru more mürkha dekhi 'karila çäsana

"Actually, I am not very learned, and my guru has stated that I am fool number one. He said that because of this I cannot possibly read Vedänta-sütra, for Vedänta-sütra is not meant for an ordinary person. My guru therefore advised me to chant this Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, and now I am doing this and getting the results." (Cc. Ädi 7.71)

At the present moment in Kali-yuga, people are not well educated. They are simply engaged in earning money to fill the belly. Vedänta philosophy is not meant for an ordinary person, nor even for an ordinary learned person. It requires great knowledge of Sanskrit and philosophy. Of course Caitanya Mahäprabhu, being the Supreme Personality of Godhead, knew all things, but at that moment He had assumed the role of an ordinary person in order to instruct an illiterate, ignorant society. In this age people are not even interested in reading Vedänta-sütra. People are so badly infected by the influence of mäyä that they do not even care to understand that there is life after death or that there are 8,400,000 life forms. Sometimes if people hear that by acting in such a way they will become a tree, a dog, a cat, an insect or even a human being, they say that they do not even care to know this. Sometimes they say, "Never mind if I become a dog. What's wrong with that? I will simply forget everything." Many university students in the Western countries speak this way. They have become so ignorant that they are described as manda. Previously, in India, the brähmaëas were interested in understanding Brahman. Athäto brahma-jijïäsä. However, at the present moment everyone is a çüdra, and no one is interested in understanding Brahman. People are simply interested in getting more money and going to the cinemas.

Human life is meant for understanding our situation, and we should take instructions from Bhagavad-gétä. Arjuna is personally teaching us by accepting Kåñëa as his guru. He asks Kåñëa to become his spiritual master and teach him. The lessons given by Çré Kåñëa are not simply meant for Arjuna but for everyone. Kåñëa tells us in Bhagavad-gétä that we should search out a guru. The first guru is Çré Kåñëa Himself, and whoever represents Çré Kåñëa is also a guru. If I am a businessman, and someone goes to canvass for my business and take orders for me, he is my representative. If he simply says that he is my representative and yet takes some orders but uses the money for something else, he is not really my representative.

Kåñëa's representative does not say, "I have become Kåñëa." Such a person is neither a representative nor a guru. He is simply a cheater. Kåñëa's representative is one who canvasses for Kåñëa. Kåñëa says, "Give up everything and surrender unto Me." Kåñëa's representative says, "Give up everything and simply surrender unto Kåñëa." This is certainly not very difficult to understand. Anyone can become Kåñëa's representative. Nonetheless, for the past two hundred years, many yogés and svämés have gone to foreign countries, but no one has spoken about Kåñëa. They have simply presented a hodgepodge of Indian philosophy. No one has actually presented Vedic culture as it is.

We should read Bhagavad-gétä as it is and understand the philosophy as Arjuna understood it. Arjuna was a friend of Kåñëa's. He was sitting with Kåñëa and speaking to Him as a friend speaks to a friend. In the Eleventh Chapter, after having seen the universal form, Arjuna tells Kåñëa: "I have in the past addressed You as 'O Kåñëa,' 'O Yädava,' 'O my friend,' without knowing Your glories. Please forgive whatever I may have done in madness or in love."

Arjuna understood that although Kåñëa was his friend, He was the Supreme Personality of Godhead and therefore the proper person to be his guru. He therefore told Kåñëa at the beginning of Bhagavad-gétä (2.7), çiñyas te 'haà çädhi mäà tväà prapannam: "Now I am Your disciple and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me."

These are the instructions we get from Bhagavad-gétä, and whoever reads Bhagavad-gétä has to accept Kåñëa as the guru. We have to render service to a guru and surrender ourselves. It is not that one should accept just any person as a guru. The guru must be the representative of Kåñëa; then one can surrender oneself. Surrender means that one will accept whatever the guru says. It is not that one thinks, "I do not care for my guru's order. Still I am a disciple." That is not actually accepting a guru. Of course, it has become a fashion to accept a guru in this way, but this will not help anyone. As soon as Kåñëa became Arjuna's guru, Kåñëa immediately chastised him. Çré Kåñëa told him:

açocyän anvaçocas tvaà
prajïä-vädäàç ca bhäñase
gatäsün agatäsüàç ca
nänuçocanti paëòitäù

"While speaking learned words, you are mourning for what is not worthy of grief. Those who are wise lament neither for the living nor the dead." (Bg. 2.11)

In this way Kåñëa essentially told Arjuna that he was fool number one for lamenting for those things for which one should not lament. Arjuna was lamenting for the body, thinking that it was horrible that his relatives would be killed in war. This was not the proper subject matter for him to be contemplating. The real subject matter for a wise man to contemplate is the salvation of the soul. Therefore Çré Kåñëa first explained the distinction between the body and the soul.

This Kåñëa consciousness movement is also concerned with the soul, and therefore we have used the word "consciousness" because consciousness belongs to the soul. Consciousness is the symptom of the soul's presence. Because the soul is in the body, the body feels pleasure and pain. When the soul leaves the body, the body can be hacked to pieces, and yet it will not protest. This is because the consciousness is gone. We feel pleasure and pain because consciousness is present, and Kåñëa advises us that it is this consciousness that is eternal, not the body. We have to purify our consciousness in order to understand that consciousness is eternal. If we can do this, our lives will be successful. At the time of death, our consciousness carries us into another body. There are the mind, the intelligence and the ego, which constitute the subtle body, and there is also the spirit soul, which is even more subtle. We know that we possess a mind, although we cannot see it. Nor can we see the intelligence, the ego or the soul. We can only see the gross material body, and when this gross material body ends, we say that everything is finished. In order to understand these things, we have to approach a guru, just as Arjuna approached Çré Kåñëa.

Çré Kåñëa told Arjuna in very gentlemanly language that he was not a learned man. In essence, He said, "You are not a paëòita. Just try to understand that the real life is the life of the soul." Vedic education means taking care of the soul. Presently the soul is encaged, embodied, entangled in material affairs. The soul is suffering, and it is to our benefit to rescue him from these material clutches. This is real education. To receive this education, one has to approach a proper guru. The guru is there—Kåñëa. The guru is also there as Kapiladeva, the incarnation of Kåñëa. Kåñëa informs us that He is the owner of the body, and He has explained this in many different ways. He has stated that the soul can never be cut to pieces, burned by fire, moistened by water nor withered by the wind. Matter interacts with matter, but the soul does not belong to the material world. This means that the soul is above material action and reaction. In the material world even iron and stone can be melted, but the laws of material nature do not apply to the spirit soul.

To understand these subjects, we should be careful to approach Kåñëa's representative. We should not approach a bogus guru, who is like a blind man trying to lead other blind men. We must go to one who has open eyes, to one who has seen the Absolute Truth. The Absolute Truth is there, just as the sun is there for everyone to see. The sun does not hide, but a person can try to hide from the sun by closing his door. One must open the door in order to see the sun. Similarly, Kåñëa is there, God is there, and we have to come to Kåñëa and take the lessons of Bhagavad-gétä to learn who and what God is. Rascals will not do this, but will simply manufacture some philosophy or other. There is actually no difficulty because Kåñëa's instructions are there, and Kåñëa Himself is there. Kåñëa is so kind that He says, "All right, if you cannot understand Me in this way, just see Me in water. Come on, if you do not understand Me in that way, just see Me in the sunshine." Is this very difficult? There is nothing difficult about it, but we are very obstinate. Mäyä is also very strong, and as soon as we try to accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord, mäyä will whisper in our ear, "No, no. There are many gods. Why are you accepting Kåñëa?" However, the çästras say, kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam.... éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù. "Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead." We should take our lessons from the äcäryas and the çästras. At least in India there are many great äcäryas—Rämänujäcärya, Madhväcärya, Viñëu Svämé, and even Çaìkaräcärya and Guru Nanak. All of these have accepted Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Why, then, should we reject Him? Why should we accept a competitor? We should not simply engage in mental speculation but should accept Kåñëa in full consciousness and be happy. This is made possible by the help of the guru; therefore Devahüti is further questioning her son, Kapiladeva.

TLK Vs 29

TEXT 29

yo yogo bhagavad-bäëo
nirväëätmaàs tvayoditaù
kédåçaù kati cäìgäni
yatas tattvävabodhanam

TRANSLATION

The mystic yoga system, as you have explained, aims at the Supreme Personality of Godhead and is meant for completely ending material existence. Please let me know the nature of that yoga system. How many ways are there by which one can understand in truth that sublime yoga?

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.29]

PURPORT

There are different kinds of mystic yoga systems aiming for different phases of the Absolute Truth. The jïäna-yoga system aims at the impersonal Brahman effulgence, and the haöha-yoga system aims at the localized personal aspect, the Paramätmä feature of the Absolute Truth, whereas bhakti-yoga, or devotional service, which is executed in nine different ways, headed by hearing and chanting, aims at complete realization of the Supreme Lord. There are different methods of self-realization. But here Devahüti especially refers to the bhakti-yoga system, which has already been primarily explained by the Lord. The different processes of the bhakti-yoga system are hearing, chanting, remembering, offering prayers, worshiping the Lord in the temple, accepting service to Him, carrying out His orders, making friends with Him and ultimately surrendering everything for His service.

The word nirväëätman is very significant in this verse. Unless one accepts the process of devotional service, one cannot end the continuation of material existence. As far as jïänés are concerned, they are interested in jïäna-yoga, but even if one elevates oneself, after a great performance of austerity, to the Brahman effulgence, there is a chance of falling down again to the material world. Therefore, jïäna-yoga does not actually end material existence. Similarly, regarding the haöha-yoga system, which aims at the localized aspect of the Lord, Paramätmä, it has been experienced that many yogés, such as Viçvämitra, fall down. But bhakti-yogés, once approaching the Supreme Personality of Godhead, never come back to this material world, as confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä. Yad gatvä na nivartante: upon going, one never comes back. Tyaktvä dehaà punar janma naiti: after giving up this body, he never comes back again to accept a material body. Nirväëa does not finish the existence of the soul. The soul is ever-existing. Therefore nirväëa means to end one's material existence, and to end material existence means to go back home, back to Godhead.

Sometimes it is asked how the living entity falls down from the spiritual world to the material world. Here is the answer. Unless one is elevated to the Vaikuëöha planets and is directly in touch with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, he is prone to fall down, either from the impersonal Brahman realization or from an ecstatic trance of meditation. Another word in this verse, bhagavad-bäëaù, is very significant. Bäëaù means "arrow." The bhakti-yoga system is just like an arrow aiming up to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The bhakti-yoga system never urges one toward the impersonal Brahman effulgence or to the point of Paramätmä realization. This bäëaù, or arrow, is so sharp and swift that it goes directly to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, penetrating the regions of impersonal Brahman and localized Paramätmä.

We must understand the Supreme Person, tattvataù, in truth. Generally people are not interested in knowing about God or their relationship with Him. However, the entire Vedic instruction is for this purpose. First of all we have to know God, then we have to know our relationship with God. The next step is acting on the basis of that relationship. Kåñëa states that out of many millions of people, one may be interested in knowing the purpose of life. Human life is meant for this end, and if one does not come to this understanding, he is no better than an animal. We not only have to understand God and our relationship with Him but also how to act in that relationship. In this way we can perfect our lives. When one is a siddha, one understands himself—that is, one understands, ahaà brahmäsmi: "I am not this body." This is Brahman realization, the brahma-bhüta platform. When one attains this stage, he becomes very happy. However, we must progress beyond this and come to the platform of bhakti-yoga. On that platform, there is variety and änanda, bliss. As stated previously, we are seeking spiritual variety, and if we do not enter the spiritual world, we will again fall down into the material atmosphere.

The varieties of the spiritual world are mentioned in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.29-30):

cintämaëi-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña-
lakñävåteñu surabhér abhipälayantam
lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

veëuà kvaëantam aravinda-daläyatäkñaà
barhävataàsam asitämbuda-sundaräìgam
kandarpa-koöi-kamanéya-viçeña-çobhaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor, who is tending the cows, yielding all desires, in abodes built with spiritual gems and surrounded by millions of purpose trees. He is always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds and thousands of goddesses of fortune.

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is adept in playing on His flute, with blooming eyes like lotus petals, with head decked with peacock's feather, with the figure of beauty tinged with the hue of blue clouds, and His unique loveliness charming millions of Cupids."

We should not consider Kåñëa's form to be imagined by some artist. He is described in the Vedas as veëuà kvaëantam aravinda-daläyatäkñam [Bs 5.30]. He plays a flute, and His eyes are like the petals of a lotus flower. He wears a peacock feather, and His complexion is very beautiful, like a dark cloud. He is so beautiful that He attracts many hundreds of thousands of Cupids (kandarpa-koöi-kamanéya-viçeña-çobham). These are descriptions of Govinda found in the çästras.

In the material world we are simply chewing the chewed, throwing it away, picking it up and then chewing it again. Spiritual variety is not like this. Spiritual variety is änandämbudhi-vardhanam: it is constantly increasing. It is even greater than the ocean, because the ocean does not increase. The shores of the ocean are set; they have certain limits. However, the ocean of bliss is constantly increasing. The more we enter into that spiritual bliss, the more we become joyful.

The young people in the Hare Kåñëa movement chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra all the time. If this mantra were material, how long would they chant it? It is not possible to chant a material name for very long because the chanting would become hackneyed and very tiresome. No one could be satisfied simply by chanting Hare Kåñëa unless Hare Kåñëa itself were spiritual. We may chant, "Mr. John, Mr. John, Mr. John," but after an hour we will be fed up. However, the more we become spiritually advanced, the more bliss we will derive from chanting Hare Kåñëa.

We can experience änanda perfectly in the association of Kåñëa. We can associate with Kåñëa as a servant, a friend, a father, a mother or a conjugal lover. There are five basic rasas—çänta, däsya, sakhya, vätsalya and mädhurya. In this material world, we experience the same rasas, or relationships. We are related to someone as a father, a son, a lover, a beloved, a master, a servant or whatever. These are perverted reflections of the relationship with Kåñëa found in the spiritual world. Today in the material world I may be relishing my love for my son, but tomorrow my son may be my greatest enemy. There is no eternity in this kind of love. Or, if my son does not become my enemy, he may die. Today I may love some man or woman, but tomorrow we may break up. All of this is due to the defects of the material world. However, in the spiritual world these relationships never break up. They simply increase and increase, and this is called perfection.

Kåñëa is very fond of tending surabhi cows, but the Mäyävädés cannot understand this. They say, "What is this Kåñëa?" Even Lord Brahmä was bewildered. He said, "How is it that this Kåñëa, this boy of Våndävana, is being worshiped? He is called the Supreme Personality of Godhead. How is that?" Lord Indra was also bewildered. Therefore if we do not wish to be bewildered we have to understand Kåñëa in truth from Kåñëa Himself or His bona fide representative.

The activities of Kåñëa are not ordinary but divine. If we can understand this, we immediately become liberated. We need only understand the pastimes of Kåñëa with the gopés. These pastimes are not ordinary. In the material world, a young man wants to dance with many young girls, but Kåñëa's dancing with the gopés is different. Because people cannot understand Kåñëa, when they hear about Kåñëa's dancing with the gopés, they take this as some kind of concession, and say, "Now let us dance with young girls." In this way they go to hell. Therefore we have to learn from the proper person about Kåñëa's activities. We should not immediately try to understand Kåñëa's dealings with the gopés, for they are very confidential. These dealings are given in the Tenth Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and this indicates that we have to understand Kåñëa as He is by first reading the preceding nine cantos. When we have understood these nine cantos, we can go on to the tenth. In this way we can understand that Kåñëa's activities are not ordinary but divine, and we can immediately become liberated.

We may either hear about Kåñëa, chant His names, worship Him or offer prayers. In any case, we should work under the directions of our spiritual master or Çré Kåñëa Himself. For instance, Hanumän simply carried out Lord Rämacandra's orders. Hanumän apparently had no education, and he was not capable of teaching Vedänta, but he simply carried out the orders of Lord Rämacandra and attained perfection. Arjuna, on the other hand, took Kåñëa as his most intimate friend. Arjuna was not a Vedäntist but a fighter, a warrior. He had no time to study Vedänta because he had to deal with war and politics, but still he was the greatest devotee. People may say, "Oh, Arjuna was not a Vedäntist, nor even a brähmaëa or a sannyäsé. How could Kåñëa accept him as a devotee?" Nonetheless, in Bhagavad-gétä (4.3), Kåñëa says that Arjuna is His very dear friend and devotee: bhakto 'si me sakhä ceti. If one becomes a devotee, there is no material impediment.

Actually bhakti should be automatic and spontaneous. There should be no motive in serving Kåñëa, but even if there is a motive, service rendered unto Kåñëa is good. Even if one approaches Kåñëa with some ulterior motive, one is considered pious. For instance, Dhruva Mahäräja initially worshiped Kåñëa with a motive, but after attaining perfection in devotional service, his ulterior motive vanished. When he actually saw Kåñëa, he said, "I do not want anything from You. I don't want any benediction other than Your service." After hearing about the many transcendental qualities of Kåñëa, if we somehow or other become attracted to Kåñëa consciousness, our lives will be successful. Tasmät kenäpy upäyena manaù kåñëe niveçayet: "Somehow or other we have to attach our minds to Kåñëa consciousness." (Bhäg. 7.1.32) Then Kåñëa will help us and give us intelligence from within, as He indicates in Bhagavad-gétä (10.10):

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." This is actual buddhi-yoga. Bhakti-yoga means buddhi-yoga, because one who is highly intelligent decides to take to Kåñëa consciousness. In this way, one can perfect his life by engaging in devotional service under the directions of the çästras and the spiritual master. Devahüti understands this and is thus submitting to her son just as Arjuna submitted to Çré Kåñëa on the battlefield.

TLK Vs 30

TEXT 30

tad etan me vijänéhi
yathähaà manda-dhér hare
sukhaà buddhyeya durbodhaà
yoñä bhavad-anugrahät

TRANSLATION

My dear son, Kapila, after all, I am a woman. It is very difficult for me to understand the Absolute Truth because my intelligence is not very great. But if You will kindly explain it to me, even though I am not very intelligent, I can understand it and thereby feel transcendental happiness.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.30]

PURPORT

Knowledge of the Absolute Truth is not very easily understood by ordinary, less intelligent men; but if the spiritual master is kind enough to the disciple, however unintelligent he may be, then by the divine grace of the spiritual master everything is revealed. Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura therefore says, yasya prasädäd, by the mercy of the spiritual master, the mercy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, bhagavat-prasädaù, is revealed. Devahüti requested her great son to be merciful toward her because she was a less intelligent woman and also His mother. By the grace of Kapiladeva it was quite possible for her to understand the Absolute Truth, even though the subject matter is very difficult for ordinary persons, especially women.

In this verse Devahüti shows us the process for understanding transcendental subject matters. It is not by challenge but by submission. The entire bhakti process is a process of submission. That is also Caitanya Mahäprabhu's teaching:

tåëäd api sunécena
taror api sahiñëunä
amäninä mänadena
kértanéyaù sadä hariù
(Çikñäñöaka 3)

If one is interested in advancing in chanting Hare Kåñëa, Caitanya Mahäprabhu advises that one be humbler than the grass and more tolerant than the trees. One should not be very proud of his intelligence but should give all respect to others. In this way, one can chant Hare Kåñëa offenselessly. Although Devahüti was the mother of Kapiladeva, she presented herself as a humble woman. It was not that she considered herself superior because she was His mother.

We have to please the spiritual master by service, and the entire bhakti process depends on the attitude of service. The transcendental nature of Kåñëa is not possible to understand with our blunt material senses. Kåñëa's name, form, qualities and pastimes are all divya, divine. Our present material senses have to be purified by engagement in the Lord's service, and our first engagement begins with the tongue. It is with the tongue that we can chant the transcendental names of the Lord. This is not very difficult, and this path is open to everyone—even women, vaiçyas and çüdras. After describing all the faults of Kali-yuga, Çrémad-Bhägavatam (12.3.51) states:

kaler doña-nidhe räjann
asti hy eko mahän guëaù
kértanäd eva kåñëasya
mukta-saìgaù paraà vrajet

"There is one special advantage about this age of Kali-yuga, and that is that people can attain liberation and return home, back to Godhead, simply by chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra." Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu said:

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä
[Ädi 17.21]

"Chant Hare Kåñëa, chant Hare Kåñëa. There is no other way, no other way at all in Kali-yuga.'

We should try to avoid the ten offenses in chanting the holy name, but anyone who chants Hare Kåñëa sincerely is purified. Ceto-darpaëa-märjanaà bhava-mahä-dävägni-nirväpaëam (Çikñäñöaka 1). This is the easiest process by which the mirror of the mind can be cleansed. If Kåñëa sees that someone is sincerely chanting Hare Kåñëa, He will help. He is within everyone, and He can understand whether one is sincere or not. Kåñëa helps a sincere devotee internally and externally. Internally He helps as paramätmä by giving intelligence from within. Dadämi buddhi-yogaà tam. Externally He helps as His representative, the spiritual master. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu says: guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja. "By the grace of Kåñëa, one gets a bona fide guru, and by the grace of the guru, one gets Kåñëa." (Cc. Madhya 19.151) Thus the çästras have given us a very easy way to appreciate our transcendental life. That is the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

Devahüti has submissively accepted her son as her guru. She wants to understand Kåñëa perfectly, by the grace of Kapiladeva. It is very important to receive the causeless mercy of Kåñëa and the spiritual master. By Kåñëa's mercy, we receive a spiritual master, and by the spiritual master's mercy, we receive Kåñëa.

Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura has greatly stressed the mercy of the guru, and it is an actual fact that if we satisfy the guru by our service, he will give us his blessings. This is a very great opportunity, for the guru is the confidential servant of Kåñëa. The guru never claims that he is Kåñëa, although he is worshiped as Kåñëa: säkñäd dharitvena samasta-çästrair uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù (Gurv-añöaka 7).

All the çästras describe the guru as being on an equal basis with Kåñëa, for he is the representative of Kåñëa. Therefore he is worshiped as Kåñëa. Being the most confidential servant of Kåñëa, the guru is very dear to Kåñëa; therefore if he recommends someone to Kåñëa, Kåñëa accepts the person. The guru is the confidential servant of Kåñëa because he canvasses from door to door, saying, "Please become Kåñëa conscious and surrender unto Kåñëa." Kåñëa tells Arjuna that such a person is very dear to Him. The bona fide guru tells people to surrender not unto him but unto Kåñëa. Thus one has to surrender unto Kåñëa through the via media of the guru, not directly. This is the process. The guru does not accept respect from his disciple for his personal self but conveys this respect to Kåñëa. If we cannot receive the mercy of the guru, Kåñëa is very difficult to approach directly.

It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that knowledge of Kåñëa is received through the paramparä, the disciplic succession. Evaà paramparä-präptam. The guru offers the same respects to his guru, and his guru offers respects to his, and so it goes all the way to Kåñëa. Thus the mercy of Kåñëa comes down through the paramparä system, and the respect offered to Kåñëa is offered up through the paramparä system. One has to learn to approach the Supreme Personality of Godhead in this way. Thus if we want to approach God, we have to take shelter of the guru in the beginning. Devahüti is begging the mercy of Kapiladeva in order to understand the way to approach Kåñëa. She approaches Him very humbly saying, "My dear Kapila, You are the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but I am a woman, and my intelligence is not very sharp. Nonetheless, I want to understand these sublime transcendental subjects from You. It is possible by Your mercy."

The process of approaching and understanding the Supreme Personality of Godhead was also discussed between Rämänanda Räya and Caitanya Mahäprabhu. First, Rämänanda Räya explained the process in terms of varëäçrama-dharma. He said first of all that human life is meant for approaching Lord Viñëu through the rules and regulations governing varëäçrama-dharma. Caitanya Mahäprabhu replied that it is very difficult in this age to execute the rules and regulations of varëäçrama-dharma. It is very difficult to be a brähmaëa in this age, and it is practically impossible to revive the old varëäçrama-dharma culture. Caitanya Mahäprabhu therefore said that this method is not very practical. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has been called by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé "the most munificent avatära" because He distributes love of Kåñëa free of charge. First of all, we cannot even understand Kåñëa; therefore there is no question of loving Him. If we do not understand someone, how can we love him? The love is very far away, but Caitanya Mahäprabhu is so kind that He distributes kåñëa-premä, love of Kåñëa, to whomever will take it. In His life, Caitanya Mahäprabhu cried for Kåñëa and showed how one should be mad after Him.

yugäyitaà nimeñeëa
cakñuñä prävåñäyitam
çünyäyitaà jagat sarvaà
govinda-viraheëa me

"O Govinda! Feeling Your separation, I am considering a moment to be like twelve years or more. Tears are flowing from my eyes like torrents of rain, and I am feeling all vacant in the world in Your absence." (Çikñäñöaka 7)

Without Kåñëa, one should see everything as vacant. This is Rädhäräëé's frame of mind, but this is not possible for an ordinary living being. It was possible for Caitanya Mahäprabhu and a few devotees, His immediate disciples like the Six Gosvämés, who were following in His footsteps. They worshiped Kåñëa in separation and sought Kåñëa everywhere.

he rädhe vraja-devike ca lalite he nanda-süno kutaù
çré-govardhana-kalpa-pädapa-tale kälindé-vane kutaù
ghoñantäv iti sarvato vraja-pure khedair mahä-vihvalau
vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré jéva-gopälakau

"I offer my respectful obeisances to the Six Gosvämés, namely Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who were chanting very loudly everywhere in Våndävana, shouting, 'Queen of Våndävana, Rädhäräëé! O Lalitä! O son of Nanda Mahäräja! Where are you all now? Are you just on the hill of Govardhana, or are you under the trees on the bank of the Yamunä? Where are you?' These were their moods in executing Kåñëa consciousness." (Ñaò-gosvämy-añöaka 8)

The Gosvämés never said, "We have seen Kåñëa." This is the recommended process—worship in separation. We should awaken our lost Kåñëa consciousness in this way and become mad after Kåñëa in our separation from Him. This is called kåñëa-premä, and this love was distributed by Caitanya Mahäprabhu. We should not try to understand Kåñëa by our small knowledge. Since we are imperfect, how can we speculate on Kåñëa? There are many people like jïänés and theosophists who try to understand the Absolute Truth by speculation, but this is not possible.

athäpi te deva padämbuja-dvaya-
prasäda-leçänugåhéta eva hi
jänäti tattvaà bhagavan-mahimno
na cänya eko 'pi ciraà vicinvan

"My Lord, if one is favored by even a slight trace of the mercy of Your lotus feet, he can understand the greatness of Your personality. But those who speculate in order to understand the Supreme Personality of Godhead are unable to know You, even though they continue to study the Vedas for many years." (Bhäg. 10.14.29) Even if one speculates for many years, he cannot understand Kåñëa. One has to receive the mercy of Kåñëa through the spiritual master, and this is the path recommended by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Sthäne-sthitäù çruti-gatäù tanu-väì-manobhiù (Bhäg. 10.14.3). Another name for Kåñëa is Ajita. No one can conquer Kåñëa, but Kåñëa can be conquered by His devotee. One should be submissive and say, "Kåñëa, I am very poor. I have no means to understand You. Please be merciful upon me. Please allow me to understand You and surrender." This is wanted. Kåñëa is very merciful, and when He sees that someone has surrendered, He will help from within.

TLK 14: Bhakti as Ultimate Liberation

CHAPTER FOURTEEN
Bhakti as Ultimate Liberation

TLK Vs 31

TEXT 31

maitreya uväca
viditvärthaà kapilo mätur ittham
jäta-sneho yatra tanväbhijätaù
tattvämnäyaà yat pravadanti säìkhyaà
proväca vai bhakti-vitäna-yogam

TRANSLATION

Çré Maitreya said: After hearing His mother's statement, Kapila could understand her purpose, and He became compassionate toward her because of having been born from her body. He then described the Säìkhya system of philosophy, which is a combination of devotional service and mystic realization, as received by disciplic succession.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.31]

PURPORT

The philosophy propounded by the atheist Kapila is an analysis of the material elements and is very much appreciated by Western philosophers. The säìkhya-yoga explained by Lord Kapiladeva, the son of Devahüti, is practically unknown in the West. The säìkhya-yoga propounded herein is actually bhakti. It is stated here that the proper way to receive this knowledge is by disciplic succession, not by philosophical speculation. Speculation is an improper way to understand the Absolute Truth. Generally Western philosophers try to understand the Absolute Truth by the ascending process of mental speculation. This is the process of inductive logic. The other process is the descending process, and this is the paramparä process. By this method, knowledge descends from a higher source.

In Bhagavad-gétä, many yoga systems are explained, but the bhakti-yoga system is considered highest of all. Ultimately, all yogas end in bhakti-yoga. The ultimate conclusion of jïäna-yoga and haöha-yoga is bhakti-yoga. In the Sixth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, the haöha-yoga system of meditation is explained, and Arjuna, who was highly elevated, said that he could not concentrate his mind in this way. If the haöha-yoga system was so difficult five thousand years ago for a person so elevated that he was Kåñëa's friend, how is it possible today? Arjuna frankly said that this system of yoga was impossible to execute because the mind is as difficult to control as the wind.

The haöha-yoga system is basically meant for those who are overly attached to the body; otherwise, the preferred yoga is säìkhya-yoga or bhakti-yoga. When Arjuna told Çré Kåñëa that the haöha-yoga system was too difficult to execute, the Lord pacified him by saying that the first-class yogé is one "who is always thinking of Me." (Bg. 6.47) Arjuna did not know anything but Kåñëa, and Arjuna requested that Kåñëa be present on his side in the battle. When Duryodhana approached Kåñëa with Arjuna and requested Him to take sides, Kåñëa said, "I have eighteen military divisions. These divisions will take one side, and I personally will take another. However, I will not fight in this battle." At first Arjuna thought it wise to take the eighteen divisions with their many thousands of elephants and horses, but then he considered that if he simply had Kåñëa on his side, that would be sufficient. He would not need ordinary soldiers. Duryodhana, on the other hand, decided to take Kåñëa's soldiers. Thus in order to pacify Arjuna, Kåñëa told him not to worry, although he could not execute the añöäìga-yoga system.

"The first-class yogé is he who always thinks of Me." One should always remember that Kåñëa is within his heart and think of Him. This is the proper system of meditation. If we always chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, we will always remember Kåñëa, and immediately the form of Kåñëa will be awakened within our hearts. The process of always thinking of Kåñëa is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. The first-class yogé is he who is always conscious of Kåñëa. One can be conscious of Kåñëa by hearing about Him submissively.

We have to accept Kåñëa through the disciplic succession. There are four sampradäyas, disciplic successions. One comes from Lord Brahmä (the Brahma-sampradäya), and another comes from Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune, (the Çré-sampradäya). There are also the Kumära-sampradäya and the Rudra-sampradäya. At the present moment, the Brahmä sampradäya is represented by the Madhva-sampradäya, and we belong to the Madhva-Gauòéya-sampradäya. Our original sampradäya stems from Madhväcärya. In that sampradäya there was Mädhavendra Puré, and Mädhavendra Puré's disciple was Çré Éçvara Puré. Çré Éçvara Puré's disciple was Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Thus we are coming in the disciplic succession from Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, and therefore our sampradäya is called the Madhva-Gauòéya-sampradäya. It is not that we have manufactured a sampradäya; rather, our sampradäya stems from Lord Brahmä. There is also the Rämänuja-sampradäya, which comes from the Çré-sampradäya, and there is the Viñëu Svämé-sampradäya, which comes from the Rudra-sampradäya. The Nimbäditya-sampradäya comes from the Kumära-sampradäya. If we do not belong to any sampradäya, our conclusion is fruitless. It is not that one should think, "I am a big scholar, and I can interpret Bhagavad-gétä in my own way. All these sampradäyas are useless." We cannot manufacture our own comments. There are many commentaries made in this way, and they are all useless. They have no effect. We have to accept the philosophy as it was contemplated by Lord Brahmä, Närada, Madhväcärya, Mädhavendra Puré and Éçvara Puré. These great äcäryas are beyond the imperfections of so-called scholars. Mundane scientists and philosophers use the words "perhaps" and "maybe" because they cannot arrive at a proper conclusion. They are simply speculating, and mental speculation cannot be perfect.

Bhakti-yoga is at the top of the stairs of all the yogas. The first step is karma-yoga, and then jïäna-yoga and dhyäna-yoga, but the ultimate is bhakti-yoga. Everyone is trying to reach the ultimate Absolute Truth, but the other yogas end in partial understanding. The understanding derived from bhakti-yoga is complete, and even if partially executed, it has potency. It is also recommended by the great mahäjanas like Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva and Kapiladeva. Since the path of perfection is very difficult to understand, the çästras recommend that we follow the mahäjanas, who are thus described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (6.3.20):

svayambhür näradaù çambhuù
kumäraù kapilo manuù
prahlädo janako bhéñmo
balir vaiyäsakir vayam

Another name for Lord Brahmä is Svayambhü because he was born from a lotus flower emanating from the navel of Lord Viñëu. Since he was not born of a father and mother, he is therefore called Svayambhü. Närada Muni is also a mahäjana, and Çambhu is Lord Çiva. Kumära refers to the four Kumäras—Sanaka, Sanandana, Sanätana and Sanat-kumära. There are twelve authorities following the Säìkhya philosophy, or bhakti-yoga, and these include Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, Kapiladeva, Manu, Bhéñmadeva, Janaka Mahäräja, Çukadeva Gosvämé and prahläda Mahäräja. If we simply accept one of these mahäjanas, we will be successful in understanding the Absolute Truth, but if we try to understand the Absolute Truth by logic and argument, we will ultimately be frustrated. One philosopher may be a better logician than another, and one philosophical argument may counteract another, but this process goes on and on. It is simply a useless waste of time. Even if we approach Vedic scriptures, there are difficulties. There are so many scriptures—Yajur Veda, Åg Veda, Säma Veda, Atharva Veda, the Upaniñads, the puräëas, Brahma-sütra, Rämäyaëa, Mahäbhärata and so forth. Different people read them and arrive at different conclusions. There are also the Bible and the Koran. According to so many different men, there are so many interpretations. One philosopher defeats another philosopher on the basis of scripture. It is even stated that one cannot become a åñi, a philosopher, unless one propounds a different system of philosophy. Näsäv åñir yasya mataà na bhinnam. Thus the truth of spiritual life is very complicated and difficult to understand. The conclusion is that one should follow one of these twelve mahäjanas in order to be successful. Kåñëa is the original mahäjana, and He instructed Lord Brahmä. Lord Brahmä is also a mahäjana. Actually, Kåñëa instructed everyone in Bhagavad-gétä, and thus everyone has learned from Kåñëa.

In Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.1.1) it is also stated: tene brahma hådä ya ädi-kavaye. Thus Kåñëa gives His personal instructions just as Kapiladeva gave His personal instructions. There is no contradiction between Kåñëa's philosophy in Bhagavad-gétä and Kapiladeva's philosophy. We need only receive the transcendental knowledge through the mahäjanas, and the results will be beneficial. Kapiladeva explained this Säìkhya philosophy to His mother, and although He had a natural affection for His mother, we should not think that Devahüti was an ordinary woman. She was very submissive, and when Kapiladeva saw this, He became very compassionate. He saw that she was eager to know about the Absolute Truth, and He considered that, after all, He had received His body from her. Therefore He concluded that He should try to give her the ultimate conclusion of philosophical knowledge, which is this Säìkhya philosophy.

TLK Vs 32

TEXT 32

çré-bhagavän uväca
devänäà guëa-liìgänäm
änuçravika-karmaëäm
sattva evaika-manaso
våttiù sväbhäviké tu yä
animittä bhägavaté
bhaktiù siddher garéyasé

TRANSLATION

Lord Kapila said: The senses are symbolic representations of the demigods, and their natural inclination is to work under the direction of the Vedic injunctions. As the senses are representatives of the demigods, so the mind is the representative of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The mind's natural duty is to serve. When that spirit of service is engaged in devotion to the Personality of Godhead, without any motive, that is far better than salvation.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.32]

PURPORT

The senses of the living entity are always engaged in some occupation, either in activities prescribed in the Vedic injunctions or in material activities. The natural inclination of the senses is to work for something, and the mind is the center of the senses. The mind is actually the leader of the senses; therefore it is called sattva. Similarly, the leader of all the demigods who are engaged in the activities of this material world—in managing the sun, moon, etc.—is the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

It is stated in the Vedic literature that the demigods are different limbs of the universal body of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Our senses are also controlled by different demigods; our senses are representations of various demigods, and the mind is the representation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The senses, led by the mind, act under the influence of the demigods. When the service is ultimately aimed at the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the senses are in their natural position. The Lord is called Håñékeça, for He is actually the proprietor and ultimate master of the senses. The senses and the mind are naturally inclined to work, but when they are materially contaminated, they work for some material benefit or for the service of the demigods, although actually they are meant to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The senses are called håñéka, and the Supreme Personality of Godhead is called Håñékeça. Indirectly, all the senses are naturally inclined to serve the Supreme Lord. That is called bhakti.

Kapiladeva said that in devotional service the senses, without desire for material profit or other selfish motives, are engaged in the service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. That spirit of service is far better than siddhi, salvation. Bhakti, the inclination to serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is in a transcendental position far superior to mukti, or liberation. Thus bhakti is the stage after liberation. Unless one is liberated, one cannot engage the senses in the service of the Lord. When the senses are engaged either in material activities of sense gratification or in the activities of the Vedic injunctions, there is some motive, but when the same senses are engaged in the service of the Lord without ulterior motive, that is called animittä and is the natural inclination of the mind. The conclusion is that when the mind, undeviated either by Vedic injunctions or by material activities, is fully engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, or devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, one is situated far above mere liberation from material entanglement.

Bhakti, devotional service, is transcendental even to mukti, liberation. Generally people are concerned with dharma, artha, käma and mokña. In the beginning, there is dharma (religion), then artha (economic development), käma (sense gratification), then mokña (merging into the Supreme One). However, bhakti is above all these. Mukti is not very important for a bhakta. In the words of Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura: muktiù svayaà mukulitäïjali sevate 'smät. "Mukti herself is standing with folded hands, waiting to serve the devotee." (Kåñëa-karëämåta 107) This is the experience of Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura, who was a very rich South Indian brähmaëa. Due to bad association, Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura became a very staunch prostitute hunter, and he spent all his money on a prostitute named Cintämaëi. One night, during a terrible rainstorm, Bilvamaìgala went to see Cintämaëi, but the prostitute was thinking, "Surely tonight Bilvamaìgala will not come. This is a terrible storm." Nonetheless, Bilvamaìgala came, despite all difficulties. Somehow he managed to cross the raging river, and when he saw the gates of Cintämaëi's house closed, he somehow managed to jump over them. Despite all the dangers, he reached Cintämaëi's house, and the prostitute, being very astonished, said, "How is it you have come tonight? Oh, you are so attracted to this skin! If you just had this much attraction for Kåñëa, it would certainly be to your benefit." Bilvamaìgala then immediately left the prostitute's house and went to Våndävana. The fact was that in his previous life he had executed devotional service up to bhäva-bhakti. Thus the prostitute Cintämaëi actually became his guru. While in Våndävana, Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura wrote a book named Kåñëa-karëämåta, which has been recommended by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu. In that book, Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura writes: "If we have devotion fixed on You, My Lord Bhagavän, then we can easily see Your divine form as kaiçora-mürti, a young boy."

Another name for Kåñëa is Kaiçora. The word kaiçora refers to the age before marriage—that is, it refers to a boy between the ages of eleven and sixteen. Çré Kåñëa is always kaiçora-mürti. By devotional service, one can see the kaiçora-mürti of Kåñëa very easily.

When Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura was going to Våndävana, he was still attracted to women. One night he stayed at the house of a very rich merchant, and the merchant's wife told her husband that Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura was attracted to her. She asked her husband what to do, and the merchant simply said, "Serve him." Finally Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura came to his senses, and he thought, "These eyes are my enemies." When the beautiful woman approached him, Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura said, "Mother, please give me the pins out of your hair. I am very mad after the beauty of women. So let me pluck out my eyes." In this way, he blinded himself. Although he could not see, in Våndävana he was supplied milk by Kåñëa Himself. Thus he personally realized Kåñëa through bhakti and wrote of his personal experience. He wrote, "Mukti is not a very important thing. She is always at my service with folded hands, saying, 'My dear sir, what can I do for you?' " Thus a devotee is not very anxious for mukti because he is already liberated. If a man has a million dollars, why should he hanker after ten rupees?

Bhakti should be animittä, without motive. Actually Kåñëa can fulfill all of our wishes without difficulty because He is almighty and full of all opulences. If we want material happiness from Kåñëa, it is certainly not difficult for Him to grant it. He can also give us mukti, liberation, but it is foolishness to ask anything from Kåñëa except bhakti. Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura used to say that asking God for mukti or anything else other than bhakti is like going to a rich man and asking for ashes. There is another story, about an old woman who was carrying a bundle of dry wood through the forest. Somehow or other the bundle, which was very heavy, fell to the ground. The old woman became very disturbed, and thought, "Who will help put this bundle back on my head?" She then began to call on God, saying, "God help me." Suddenly God appeared and said, "What do you want?" She said, "please help me put this bundle back on my head." So this is our foolishness. When God comes to give us some benediction, we simply ask Him to load us down again with all these material bundles. We ask Him for more material things, for a happy family, for a large amount of money, for a new car or whatever.

Caitanya Mahäprabhu teaches us that we should only beg God for His service life after life. This is the actual meaning of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra. When we are chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma, Räma, Hare Hare, we are actually addressing God and His energy, Harä. Harä is Kåñëa's internal potency, Çrématé Rädhäräëé or Lakñmé. Jaya rädhe! This is daivé prakåti, and the devotees take shelter of the daivé prakåti, Çrématé Rädhäräëé. Thus the Vaiñëavas worship Rädhä-Kåñëa, Lakñmé-Näräyaëa and Sétä-Räma. In the beginning of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra we first address the internal energy of Kåñëa, Hare. Thus we say, "O Rädhäräëé! O Hare! O energy of the Lord!" When we address someone in this way, he usually says, "Yes, what do you want?" The answer is, "Please engage me in Your service." This should be our prayer. We should not say, "O energy of the Lord, O Kåñëa, please give me money. Please give me a beautiful wife. Please give me many followers. Please give me some prestigious position. Please give me the presidency." These are all material hankerings, which should be avoided. Lord Buddha advocated that we give up all material desires. It is not possible to become desireless, but it is possible to give up material desires. It is the nature of the living entity to desire; it is not possible to be desireless. If one is desireless, he is dead. Desirelessness means purifying one's desire, and desire is purified when we only desire the service of Kåñëa.

Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu teaches:

na dhanaà na janaà na sundaréà
kavitäà vä jagad-éça kämaye
mama janmani janmanéçvare
bhavatäd bhaktir ahaituké tvayi

"O almighty Lord, I have no desire to accumulate wealth, nor do I desire beautiful women, nor do I want any number of followers. I only want Your causeless devotional service birth after birth." (Çikñäñöaka 4) He requests Lord Kåñëa's service birth after birth. It is not that He is seeking salvation; rather, He simply wants to serve Kåñëa one life after another. The devotees are not anxious to merge into the existence of the Supreme. The Buddhist philosophy advocates nirväëa, the negation of all material desires. Buddha does not offer more than this. Çaìkaräcärya gives a little more, saying that we should become desireless in this material world and then enter into the Brahman effulgence. This is called brahma-nirväëa. According to the Vaiñëava philosophy, however, we should negate material desires and be situated on the Brahman platform, but in addition we should engage in the devotional service of the Lord. This is called bhakti. Mäyävädé philosophers cannot understand this, but Kåñëa says that this devotional service is on the transcendental platform.

The Säìkhya philosophy of the atheist Kapila, which is a material philosophy, is simply the study of the twenty-four elements. However, the real Säìkhya philosophy, propounded by Kapiladeva, is transcendental to the twenty-four elements and material activity. Thus in this Säìkhya philosophy, which is actually bhakti-yoga, there is no desire for material benefits. On the material platform, a person works for his own personal sense gratification or for some expanded sense gratification. One may work for himself, family, wife, children, society, community, nation or humanity at large. This is simply expanded sense gratification. Whether one steals for himself, family, community or whatever, the fact remains that he is a thief. It is said that when Alexander the Great arrested a common thief, the thief told Alexander, "What is the difference between us? I am a small plunderer, and you are a great plunderer." Being very sensible, Alexander released him, saying, "Yes, there is no difference." Regardless whether the sense gratification is for oneself, one's family, one's nation or whatever, it is, after all, sense gratification. The quality changes only when we work for the sense gratification of Kåñëa.

It is noteworthy that Bhagavad-gétä or Çrémad-Bhägavatam never states that kåñëa uväca ("Kåñëa says") or kapiladeva uväca ("Kapiladeva says"). Rather, it states bhagavän uväca ("the Supreme Personality of Godhead says"). This means that the version is perfect. If we receive knowledge from an ordinary man, there will be many defects. An ordinary person is subject to illusion, and he also has the tendency to cheat. Although an ordinary person may be a very advanced scholar, he does not possess perfect knowledge. Perfection is something totally different from what we find in the material world. Perfection means that there is no mistake, no illusion, no cheating, no imperfection. Therefore it is stated bhagavän uväca, for Bhagavän is all-perfect. We should therefore take knowledge from Bhagavän or from one who speaks according to the version of Bhagavän.

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is based on this principle. We are not presenting anything that we ourselves could manufacture. Whatever we manufacture is sure to be defective or deficient. What is the value of my philosophy? What is the value of my thought? Generally, people say, "In my opinion," thinking that "my opinion" really means something. People do not think, "I am simply a rascal." People value their opinion, thinking it something very big. Everyone in this material world has imperfect senses; therefore whatever knowledge has been gathered through the senses is necessarily imperfect. As we have stressed over and over, we have to receive knowledge from the disciplic succession. Knowledge has to be received from Bhagavän, the perfect one. If we simply follow this system, we can become a guru for the whole world.

The devotee never thinks that he is a great bhakta. Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämé, the author of Caitanya-caritämåta, has stated, puréñera kéöa haite muïi se laghiñöha: "I am lower than the worms in stool." (Ädi 5.205) This is the Vaiñëava conception. A Vaiñëava is by nature very humble. He never says, "I am the Supreme; I have become God." Kåñëa says, "I am God. Worship Me." The Vaiñëava says, "Kåñëa is God. Worship Kåñëa." It is not difficult to become a guru, provided that we repeat what Kåñëa says. Whatever Kåñëa states in Bhagavad-gétä is dharma. Dharma is one. It cannot be different. Dharma means abiding by the orders of God. However, if we do not know God or His orders, we can only set about manufacturing some rubbish and fighting among ourselves. This is not dharma but philosophical speculation. All of this speculation and manufactured dharma has been kicked out of Çrémad-Bhägavatam because it is all cheating. Bhägavata-dharma is not cheating, for it is related to the Supreme Lord. Bhakti can be applied only to Bhagavän, and if there is no Bhagavän, there is no bhakti. If Bhagavän is zero, where is bhakti? Bhakti is the transaction between Bhagavän and the bhakta. Bhagavän is there, and the bhaktas are there, and the bhaktas address Bhagavän, feed Bhagavän, chant Bhagavän's names, invoke people to hear about Bhagavän, publish books about Bhagavän and worship Bhagavän, and in this way they are constantly absorbed in Bhagavän. This is the process of bhakti.

TLK Vs 33

TEXT 33

jarayaty äçu yä koçaà
nigérëam analo yathä

TRANSLATION

Bhakti, devotional service, dissolves the subtle body of the living entity without separate effort, just as fire in the stomach digests all that we eat.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.33]

PURPORT

Bhakti is in a far higher position than mukti because a person's endeavor for liberation from the material encagement is automatically realized in devotional service. If the digestive power is sufficient, then whatever we eat will be digested by the fire in the stomach. Similarly, a devotee doesn't have to try separately to attain liberation. That very service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the process of liberation because to engage in the service of the Lord is to liberate oneself from material entanglement.

For a devotee, liberation is no problem at all. Liberation takes place without separate endeavor. Bhakti, therefore, is far better than mukti or the impersonalist position. The impersonalists undergo severe penances and austerities to attain mukti, but the bhakta, simply by engaging in the bhakti process, especially in chanting Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, immediately develops control over the tongue by chanting, and accepting the remnants of foodstuff offered to the Personality of Godhead. As soon as the tongue is controlled, all other senses are controlled automatically. Sense control is the perfection of the yoga principle, and one's liberation begins immediately as soon as he engages in the service of the Lord. It is confirmed by Kapiladeva that bhakti, or devotional service, is garéyasi, more glorious than siddhi, liberation.

It is stated in this verse that bhakti dissolves the subtle body. The spirit soul has two coverings—subtle and gross. The gross body is composed of earth, water, fire, air and ether. The subtle body is composed of mind, intelligence and ego. Of the eight material elements, five are gross and three are subtle. We cannot see the subtle, and the soul is even more subtle. Anyone with eyes can see the body, but not everyone can perceive the soul, the actual person. When we understand that the soul, or the person, has left the body, we cry, "Oh, my friend has left." We can perceive that the body is there, but something is obviously missing. Thus one's friend is actually different from the body. At the present moment when we say, "This is my friend," we refer to the body, but that is simply the vision of an animal. Animals think, "This is my dog friend, and this is my mother dog." They cannot see beyond the gross body. Similarly, we cannot see the soul, and if we cannot see the minute soul, how can we hope to see God with these blunt eyes? We cannot actually see one another. How, then, can we hope to see God? It is stated: ataù çri-kåñëa-nämädi na bhaved grähyam indriyaiù [Padma Puräëa]. "Material senses cannot appreciate Kåñëa's holy name, form, qualities and pastimes."

Our present senses are incapable of seeing God. Generally, at death we can understand that something has gone. We understand that what we were seeing was not actually our friend but a lump of matter. This is knowledge. However, one who understands before death that the body is simply a lump of matter is called a wise man. He sees the soul through the eyes of knowledge. Those who are on the gross platform, who are like animals, can see neither the soul nor Bhagavän. The karmés, the gross fruitive workers, do not understand the distinction between the body and the soul. Out of many millions of karmés, there may be one jïäné, one wise man who can understand. The jïäné knows that he is not the body, and out of many millions of jïänés, one may be actually liberated. The Mäyävädés think that because they are spirit soul, they are one with the Supreme. Being equal in quality does not mean that one is the Supreme Soul. Because the Mäyävädés think that they have become one with Näräyaëa, they address one another as Näräyaëa. They say, "You are Näräyaëa, I am Näräyaëa, everyone is Näräyaëa." From this misconception, the idea of daridra-näräyaëa (poor Näräyaëa) arises. The devotees fully engaged in the service of the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord do not think in this way. They think, "If I am one with the Supreme, how is it I have fallen into this condition?" They know that a drop of seawater is one in quality with the vast ocean, but they also know that a drop of water is never equal to the ocean itself.

Sometimes the Mäyävädés worship Lord Viñëu, but they do not actually believe in the form of Lord Viñëu. They consider His image to be some imaginary form to utilize as a means for self-realization. Mäyävädés say that the Absolute Truth has no rüpa, no form, but it is stated: éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù. "Kåñëa, who is known as Govinda, is the supreme controller. He has an eternal, blissful, spiritual body."

The word vigraha refers to the supreme form, but the Mäyävädés do not understand this. There are also many so-called Vaiñëavas who worship Lord Viñëu with an aim of becoming one with the Supreme. They sometimes give the example of a drop of water merging into the great ocean itself. This is simply nonsense. The ocean is a combination of countless molecules of water, and it is impossible for one molecule to merge into the totality. The sunshine is a combination of countless trillions of small shining particles, and each particle has its individual identity as an atom. Because we do not have the eyes to see the small atomic divisions, we think that they are one, but actually they are not homogeneous. Similarly, although we are very small particles of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, we all have different identities. In Bhagavad-gétä (2.12) Çré Kåñëa says:

na tv evähaà jätu näsaà
na tvaà neme janädhipäù
na caiva na bhaviñyämaù
sarve vayam ataù param

"Never was there a time when I did not exist, nor you, nor all these kings; nor in the future shall any of us cease to be."

Kåñëa never says that He, Arjuna, and all the soldiers shall eventually become one. Rather, He says that everyone will retain his own individuality.

Those who have complete knowledge never think that in the future they will become one with the Supreme. They simply want to remain in their constitutional position as part and parcel of Kåñëa. Although we are now covered by the material body, the material body can be easily dissolved by the process of bhakti-yoga. If we are strong in bhakti-yoga, we actually no longer have a material body but a spiritual one. We are free.

When we are baffled, we want to become the husband of goddess Lakñmé. The husband of goddess Lakñmé is Näräyaëa, God Himself. In this material world, we are hankering after Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune, but we are frustrated in our attempts. We think, "Now let me become the husband of Lakñmé." Actually, no one can enjoy Lakñmé but Näräyaëa. Even exalted demigods like Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva are inferior to Lord Näräyaëa, but we are so foolish that we are thinking of assuming Näräyaëa's position, or making Näräyaëa into daridra-näräyaëa, the poor man in the street. The çästras never equalize Näräyaëa with anyone, not even Lord Brahmä or Lord Çiva, what to speak of foolish rascals.

One may ask why Näräyaëa has created us, why it is we are part and parcel of Näräyaëa. Eko bahu-syäm. Why has Näräyaëa become many? He has created us for enjoyment. Änandamayo 'bhyäsät (Vedänta-sütra 1.1.12). He has created us in the same way a gentleman accepts a wife. If one takes on a wife, he

will beget children. A man takes on the responsibility of maintaining a wife and children because he thinks that through them he will enjoy life. In the material world we see that during the evening a man tries to enjoy life with his wife, children and friends. Therefore he takes on so many responsibilities. This is supposed to be änanda, bliss, but because it takes place in the material world, the änanda is converted into something distasteful. However, we can enjoy this änanda when we are with our Supreme Father, Kåñëa. We are all children of the Supreme Father, and in Bhagavad-gétä (14.4) Kåñëa claims all species of life as His children:

sarva-yoniñu kaunteya
mürtayaù sambhavanti yäù
täsäà brahma mahad yonir
ahaà béja-pradaù pitä

"It should be understood that all species of life, O son of Kunté, are made possible by birth in this material nature, and that I am the seed-giving father."

The Supreme Father, Çré Kåñëa, has created us for His enjoyment, not to create distress. Although we are Kåñëa's children, we have given up our Supreme Father because we wish to enjoy ourselves independently. Consequently we are suffering. If a rich man's son gives up his home to try to enjoy life independently, he simply suffers. It is to our benefit to return home, back to Godhead, to enjoy ourselves with our original father, Kåñëa. This will give us happiness. Kåñëa is full of all opulence. He possesses in totality wealth, strength, beauty, fame, knowledge and renunciation. He possesses everything in unlimited quantity. If we return to our original father, we can enjoy ourselves with Him unlimitedly. It is not that we can enjoy ourselves independent of Kåñëa. Nor can we say that to enjoy ourselves we have to become one with Kåñëa. In the material world, our father gives us our birth, and we are an entity separate from him. If we are suffering, do we say, "My dear father, I am suffering. Will you please once again make me one with you?" Is this a very good proposal? A father says, "I have begotten you separately to enjoy yourself. You remain separate, and I remain separate, and in this way we will enjoy. Now you are asking to become one with me. What is this nonsense?"

The Mäyävädés want to become one with the Supreme because they are suffering in the material world. Kåñëa has created us to enjoy ourselves in His company, but due to our desire for independent enjoyment, we are not doing that. Consequently we are suffering in this material world, and because we are suffering we are thinking of becoming one with our father. It is mäyä's business to try to build up the living entity, to puff him up, and mäyä's last snare is to make the living entity think that he can become one with God. Mäyävädés think that becoming one with the Supreme is the highest perfection, but this is not perfection because our original constitutional position is to enjoy the company of Kåñëa. Friends sit together in a room and enjoy one another's company. What enjoyment can one have by himself? Variety is the mother of enjoyment, and real enjoyment is being in Kåñëa's company. Therefore devotees never desire to become one with the Supreme. It is Caitanya Mahäprabhu who says:

mama janmani janmanéçvare
bhavatäd bhaktir ahaituké tvayi

"My dear Lord, I do not want to put an end to the process of birth and death. I am not anxious for mukti. Let Me go ahead and take one birth after another. It doesn't matter. Simply let Me engage in Your service birth after birth." (Çikñäñöaka 4) This is real änanda. Unless we are fully qualified devotees, we cannot enter into the Vaikuëöha planets. We have to live outside in the brahmajyoti. If we desire this, Kåñëa will give us the opportunity. After all, Kåñëa is everything. He is brahmajyoti and Paramätmä also. If we want to become one with the Supreme, we will be allowed to live outside the Vaikuëöha planets, in the brahmajyoti. However, that position is not eternal. As we have explained before, we cannot live eternally in the brahmajyoti because we want variety. Without variety, there is no enjoyment.

In all conditions, the pure devotee is liberated. He may engage in some occupation or business, but he is always thinking of how to serve Kåñëa, and in this way he is automatically liberated. It is not that he thinks of becoming one with the Supreme and attaining liberation. Rather, his liberation lies in his personal relationship with the Supreme Lord Himself.

TLK 15: Meditation on the Lord's Transcendental Form

CHAPTER FIFTEEN
Meditation on the Lord's Transcendental Form

TLK Vs 34

TEXT 34

naikätmatäà me spåhayanti kecin
mat-päda-seväbhiratä mad-éhäù
ye 'nyonyato bhägavatäù prasajya
sabhäjayante mama pauruñäëi

TRANSLATION

A pure devotee who is attached to the activities of devotional service and who always engages in the service of My lotus feet never desires to become one with Me. Such a devotee, who is unflinchingly engaged, always glorifies My pastimes and activities.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.34]

PURPORT

There are five kinds of liberation stated in the scriptures. One is to become one with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, or to forsake one's individuality and merge into the Supreme Spirit. This is called ekätmatäm. A devotee never accepts this kind of liberation. The other four liberations are: to be promoted to the same planet as God (Vaikuëöha), to associate personally with the Supreme Lord, to achieve the same opulence as the Lord and to attain His same bodily features. A pure devotee, as Kapila Muni will explain, does not aspire for any of the liberations. He especially despises the attempt to become one with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Çré Prabodhänanda Sarasvaté, a great devotee of Lord Caitanya, said, kaivalyaà narakäyate: "The happiness of becoming one with the Supreme Lord, which is the aspiration of the Mäyävädés, is considered hellish." That oneness is not for pure devotees.

There are many so-called devotees who think that in the conditioned state we may worship the Personality of Godhead but that ultimately there is no personality; they say that since the Absolute Truth is impersonal, one can imagine a personal form of the impersonal Absolute Truth for the time being, but as soon as one becomes liberated, the worship stops. That is the theory put forward by Mäyäväda philosophy. Actually the impersonalists do not merge into the existence of the Supreme person but into His personal bodily luster, which is called brahmajyoti. Although that brahmajyoti is not different from His personal body, that sort of oneness (merging into the bodily luster of the Personality of Godhead) is not accepted by a pure devotee because the devotees engage in greater pleasure than merging into His existence. The greatest pleasure is to serve the Lord. Devotees are always thinking about how to serve Him; they are always designing ways and means to serve the Supreme Lord, even in the midst of the greatest material obstacles.

Mäyävädés accept the description of the pastimes of the Lord as myths, but actually they are not; they are historical facts. pure devotees accept the narrations of the pastimes of the Lord as Absolute Truth. The words mama pauruñäëi (My glorious activities) are significant. Devotees are very much attached to glorifying the activities of the Lord, whereas Mäyävädés cannot even think of these activities. According to them, the Absolute Truth is impersonal, but without personal existence, how can there be activity? Because impersonalists take the activities mentioned in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Bhagavad-gétä and other Vedic literatures as fictitious stories, they interpret them most mischievously. They have no idea of the Personality of Godhead. They unnecessarily poke their noses into the scripture and interpret it in a deceptive way in order to mislead the innocent public. The activities of Mäyäväda philosophy are very dangerous to the public, and therefore Lord Caitanya warned His disciples never to hear from any Mäyävädé about any scripture. Mäyävädés will spoil the entire process, and the person hearing them will never be able to come to the path of devotional service to attain the highest perfection. He only may be able to do so after a very long time.

It is clearly stated by Kapila Muni that bhakti activities are transcendental to mukti. This is called païcama-puruñärtha. Generally, people engage in the activities of religion, economic development and sense gratification, and ultimately they work with an idea that they are going to become one with the Supreme Lord (mukti). But bhakti is transcendental to all these activities. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam, therefore, begins by stating that all kinds of pretentious religiosity is completely eradicated from the Bhägavatam. Ritualistic activities for economic development and sense gratification and, after frustration in sense gratification, the desire to become one with the Supreme Lord, are all completely rejected in the Bhägavatam. The Bhägavatam is especially meant for the pure devotees, who always engage in Kåñëa consciousness, in the activities of the Lord, and always glorify these transcendental activities. Pure devotees worship the transcendental activities of the Lord in Våndävana, Dvärakä and Mathurä as they are narrated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam and other puräëas. The Mäyävädé philosophers completely reject them as myths, but actually they are great and worshipable subjects and thus are relishable only for devotees. That is the difference between a Mäyävädé and a pure devotee as they view scripture.

Actually Vedic scripture is kåñëa-kathä, topics about Kåñëa, and kåñëa-kathä is not a subject matter for a debate club. It is meant for the devotees. Nondevotees simply waste their time reading Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and we have often mentioned that so-called scholars, politicians and philosophers simply give misleading commentaries when they try to interpret Bhagavad-gétä. Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura used to say that they are like people trying to lick at a bottle of honey that is sealed closed. If one does not know how to taste honey, one begins licking at the bottle, but for one to actually taste the honey, the bottle must be opened, and the key to its opening is the devotee. Therefore it is said:

satäà prasaìgän mama vérya-saàvido
bhavanti håt-karëa-rasäyanäù kathäù
taj joñaëäd äçv apavarga-vartmani
çraddhä ratir bhaktir anukramiñyati

"In the association of pure devotees, discussion of the pastimes and activities of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is very pleasing and satisfying to the ear and the heart. By cultivating such knowledge one gradually becomes advanced on the path of liberation, and thereafter he is freed, and his attraction becomes fixed. Then real devotion and devotional service begin." (Bhäg. 3.25.25)

God is eternal, and His instructions and followers are also eternal. In Bhagavad-gétä (4.1) Kåñëa tells Arjuna that millions of years ago He spoke Bhagavad-gétä to the sun-god. Bhagavad-gétä was spoken to Arjuna five thousand years ago, and if we read it today we will still find that it is fresh. Bhagavad-gétä and Kåñëa are never old. Although Kåñëa is the most ancient one, the oldest of all, He always remains like a young boy in His teens. He never appears older than twenty. Kåñëa's words are absolute, as well as His form, qualities and activities. They are always fresh and new. If they were not, how could the devotees glorify them day after day with greater enthusiasm? The more one glorifies Kåñëa, the more enthusiastic one becomes in glorifying, glorifying, glorifying. This is the meaning of spiritual. In the material world, if we repeat something once, twice, thrice or four times, it finally becomes hackneyed and disgusting. However, this Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra can be chanted twenty-four hours daily, and one will still feel fresh and enthusiastic. It is not a material sound like the sounds we hear on the radio. It is a spiritual sound that comes from the spiritual world. Even in the material world we can release a sound from one place, and it can be heard thousands of miles away. A spiritual sound can be released from many trillions of miles away, and it can be heard, provided that one has the machine to capture it. That machine is bhagavat-premä. Those who have developed love of Godhead can hear it.

Arjuna was neither a Vedäntist nor a sannyäsé, nor was he particularly advanced in spiritual understanding. However, he heard Bhagavad-gétä because he was a bhakta. Atheistic scholars and politicians cannot understand the transcendental vibration. They can only lick at the honey bottle. Fools and rascals eat and drink everything without restriction, thinking that they are doing so in the name of religion. There are many so-called svämés and yogés who tell their disciples that they can do anything and still advance spiritually, but this is not possible. One has to become a pure brähmaëa, control the mind and senses and discuss the Supreme Personality of Godhead among sädhus. This may sound very difficult, but one can become a sat, a saintly person, within a second. If one is eager, one can immediately surrender to Kåñëa.

When one approaches Kåñëa, one should say, "My dear Kåñëa, I have forgotten You. Now I am fully surrendered unto You. You may kill me as You like or, if You like, You can give me protection." When Prahläda was asked by the Supreme Lord what benediction he desired, Prahläda Mahäräja replied, "My dear Lord, why should I ask for some benediction simply because I have suffered for You? You are supremely powerful, and whatever I get, I get from You. I was born into a family of demons and was inclined toward material enjoyment. I have seen my powerful father, who was feared even by the demigods, annihilated within a second. Why should I ask for anything? Please engage me in the service of Your servant. This is all I want. I do not want anything else." In this way a devotee never asks for anything material from the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The devotees are simply satisfied in glorifying the Lord. This is the way of bhakti-yoga.

Kåñëa descends to please His devotees and destroy the demons. From the very beginning of Kåñëa's birth, demons were present. Kaàsa advised his constables, "As soon as Kåñëa is born, tell me. I shall immediately kill Him." He was always thinking of Kåñëa in this way, negatively. Similarly, we will find so many so-called religionists whose only purpose is to kill Kåñëa. Somehow or other they try to take Kåñëa out of Bhagavad-gétä. They will comment on Bhagavad-gétä, but in their commentaries there will never be mention of Kåñëa. They will never say that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and that He should be worshiped. This means that they are asuras, demons, although they may present themselves as big scholars. Somehow or other they try to evade kåñëa-bhakti, and their entire propaganda is aimed toward this.

TLK Vs 35

TEXT 35

paçyanti te me ruciräëy amba santaù
prasanna-vakträruëa-locanäni
rüpäëi divyäni vara-pradäni
säkaà väcaà spåhaëéyäà vadanti

TRANSLATION

O My mother, My devotees always see the smiling face of My form, with eyes like the rising morning sun. They like to see My various transcendental forms, which are all benevolent, and they also talk favorably with Me.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.35]

PURPORT

Mäyävädés and atheists accept the forms of the Deities in the temple of the Lord as idols, but devotees do not worship idols. They directly worship the Personality of Godhead in His arcä incarnation. Arcä refers to the form we can worship in our present condition. Actually in our present state it is not possible to see God in His spiritual form because our material eyes and senses cannot conceive of a spiritual form. We cannot even see the spiritual form of the individual soul. When a man dies we cannot see how the spiritual form leaves the body. That is the defect of our material senses. In order to be seen by our material senses, the Supreme Personality of Godhead accepts a favorable form which is called arcä-vigraha. This arcä-vigraha, sometimes called the arcä incarnation, is not different from Him. Just as the Supreme Personality of Godhead accepts various incarnations, He takes on forms made out of matter—clay, wood, metal, jewels, etc.

There are many çästric injunctions which give instructions for carving forms of the Lord. These forms are not material. If God is all-pervading, He is also in the material elements. There is no doubt about it. But the atheists think otherwise. Although they preach that everything is God, when they go to the temple and see the form of the Lord, they deny that He is God. According to their own theory, everything is God. Then why is the Deity not God? Actually, they have no conception of God. The devotees' vision, however, is different; their vision is smeared with love of God. As soon as they see the Lord in His different forms, the devotees become saturated with love, for they do not find any difference between the Lord and His form in the temple, as do the atheists. The smiling face of the Deity in the temple is beheld by the devotees as transcendental and spiritual, and the decorations on the body of the Lord are very much appreciated by the devotees. It is the duty of the spiritual master to teach his devotees how to decorate the Deity in the temple, how to cleanse the temple and how to worship the Deity. There are different procedures, rules and regulations followed in temples of Viñëu, and devotees go there and see the Deity, the vigraha, and spiritually enjoy the form, because all of the Deities are benevolent. The devotees express their minds before the Deity, and in many instances the Deity also gives answers. But one must be a very elevated devotee in order to be able to speak with the Supreme Lord. Sometimes the Lord informs the devotee through dreams. These exchanges between the Deity and the devotee are not understandable by atheists, but actually the devotee enjoys them.

Clearly, those who have the eyes to see Kåñëa will see Him. When Caitanya Mahäprabhu entered the temple of Jagannätha, He immediately fainted upon seeing the Deity. He said, "Oh, here is My Lord! Here is My Lord!" In order to see, one has to become santaù, and one becomes santaù by culture. When we develop love of Kåñëa, we will immediately see Kåñëa and faint, saying, "Oh, here is my Lord!" However, those with no faith, those who are always trying to deny Kåñëa, will simply say, "Oh, this is an idol. This is simply a piece of stone."

We must be eager to see Kåñëa and talk with Him. He is actually waiting to see whether we are interested in talking with Him. In Bhagavad-gétä (10.10) Çré Kåñëa says:

teñäà satata-yuktänäà
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me."

If we want to talk to some important man, we must have some qualification. It is not that we can immediately talk to presidents or even to senators just because we want to talk to them. Somehow or other we must comply with certain rules and regulations. Kåñëa is ready to talk to us, and for this purpose He has descended in the arcä-mürti, the Deity, in order to be seen. We simply have to qualify ourselves to talk with Him. The nondevotees, Mäyävädés, who are interested in denying Kåñëa, say that God has no eyes, no legs, no hands, no ears and so on. This is indirectly saying that God is blind and deaf and that He cannot do this or that. In this way, they are indirectly insulting God. This is blasphemy. God does not want to hear such nonsense. Therefore it is said in this verse: säkaà väcaà spåhaëéyäà vadanti. By saying that Kåñëa is blind, that He has no eyes, no hands, no nothing, we are indirectly saying that Kåñëa does not exist. This is certainly not a favorable way to talk about Kåñëa. If we want to talk about Kåñëa, we must consult the Vedic literatures. Then we can understand how Kåñëa should be worshiped.

In Brahma-saàhitä (5.29) it is stated: "Çré Kåñëa is playing on His flute, and His eyes are as beautiful as the petals of a lotus flower. He wears a peacock feather in His hair, and His form is very beautiful." The Mäyävädés say, "Just imagine some form of God." But God's form cannot be imagined. God's form is not imaginary but factual. This factual information we receive from the Vedas. When Kåñëa was present on this earth, He exhibited His form and activities. All of these are divine, not material. Kåñëa's body is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha. It has nothing to do with anything material. He descends as a favor to His devotees, who are always anxious to see Him. His first business is to give pleasure to His devotees, and His second business is to kill the demons, who are always giving the devotees trouble. It is the nature of demons to give devotees trouble, just as in the West, Lord Jesus Christ was crucified because he was preaching God consciousness. Similarly, Hiraëyakaçipu tried to kill his five-year-old boy Prahläda Mahäräja because his son was talking about Kåñëa. There were many demons who tried to kill Kåñëa Himself, great demons like Pütanä, Aghäsura, Bakäsura and Kaàsa. Nonetheless, Kåñëa destroys them all by His omnipotence.

Actually everyone in the material world is more or less an asura, an atheist. If one preaches, one has to learn to tolerate the asuras and speak in such a way that they can also become devotees. We should always speak of Kåñëa in a pleasing way; then we will be benefited. Another name for Kåñëa is Uttamaçloka, which indicates that He is worshiped by the best selected words. It is not that we should use any words we choose. There are many prayers in the Vedic scriptures and also in the Bible and Koran. Although the Christians and Muhammadans do not worship the Deity, they offer prayers to the Lord, and that is also bhakti. Arcanaà vandanam.

There are nine different processes for worshiping the Lord, and one may accept one or all of them. We should use very selected words and surrender unto Kåñëa, but we should not say things which do not please Him. We should not claim that God is formless and that He has no eyes, no head or whatever. Actually it is stated in the Vedas that Kåñëa has no hand but that He can accept our offering. This means that He has no material hand. If He actually has no hand, how can He extend His hand millions of miles to accept an offering? Goloka Våndävana is many trillions and trillions of miles away, but Kåñëa can accept whatever we offer. When the Vedas say that God has no hands, it is meant that He has no material hands. His hands are sac-cid-änanda-vigraha. If we can understand Kåñëa's activities, form, qualities and pastimes in this way, we become fit to return home, back to Godhead.

TLK Vs 36

TEXT 36

tair darçanéyävayavair udära-
viläsa-häsekñita-väma-süktaiù
håtätmano håta-präëäàç ca bhaktir
anicchato me gatim aëvéà prayuìkte

TRANSLATION

Upon seeing the charming forms of the Lord, smiling and attractive, and hearing His very pleasing words, the pure devotee almost loses all other consciousness. His senses are freed from all other engagements, and he becomes absorbed in devotional service. Thus in spite of his unwillingness, he attains liberation without separate endeavor.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.36]

PURPORT

There are three divisions of devotees—first-class, second-class and third-class. Even the third-class devotees are liberated souls. It is explained in this verse that although they do not have knowledge, simply by seeing the beautiful decoration of the Deity in the temple, they are absorbed in thought of Him and lose all other consciousness. By fixing oneself in Kåñëa consciousness, engaging the senses in the service of the Lord, one is imperceptibly liberated. This is also confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä. Simply by discharging uncontaminated devotional service as prescribed in the scriptures, one becomes equal to Brahman. In Bhagavad-gétä it is said, brahma-bhüyäya kalpate. This means that the living entity in his original state is Brahman because he is part and parcel of the Supreme Brahman. Because of his forgetfulness of his real nature as an eternal servitor of the Lord, he is overwhelmed and captured by mäyä. His forgetfulness of his real constitutional position is mäyä. Otherwise he is eternally Brahman.

When one is trained to become conscious of his position, he understands that he is the servitor of the Lord. "Brahman" refers to a state of self-realization. Even the third-class devotee—who is not advanced in knowledge of the Absolute Truth but who offers obeisances with great devotion, thinks of the Lord, sees the Lord in the temple and brings forth flowers and fruits to offer to the Deity—becomes imperceptibly liberated. Çraddhayänvitäù: with great devotion the devotees offer worshipful respects and paraphernalia to the Deity. The Deities of Rädhä and Kåñëa, Lakñmé and Näräyaëa, and Räma and Sétä, are very attractive to devotees, so much so that when they see the Deity decorated in the temple, they become fully absorbed in thinking of the Lord. That is liberation. In other words, it is confirmed herein that even a third-class devotee is in the transcendental position, above those who are striving for liberation by speculation or other methods. Even great impersonalists like Çukadeva Gosvämé and the four Kumäras were attracted by the beauty of the Deities in the temple, by the decorations and by the aroma of tulasé offered to the Lord, and they became devotees. Even though they were in the liberated state, instead of remaining impersonalists they were attracted by the beauty of the Lord and became devotees.

Here the word viläsa is very important. Viläsa refers to the activities or pastimes of the Lord. It is a prescribed duty in temple worship that not only should one visit the temple to see the Deity nicely decorated, but at the same time he should hear the recitation of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Bhagavad-gétä or some similar literature, which is regularly recited in the temple. In Våndävana, in every temple, there is recitation of the çästras. Even third-class devotees who have no literary knowledge or no time to read Çrémad-Bhägavatam or Bhagavad-gétä have the opportunity to hear about the pastimes of the Lord. In this way their minds may remain always absorbed in the thought of the Lord—His form, His activities and His transcendental nature. This state of Kåñëa consciousness is a liberated stage. Lord Caitanya, therefore, recommended five important processes in the discharge of devotional service: (1) to chant the holy name of the Lord, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, (2) to associate with devotees and serve them as far as possible, (3) to hear Çrémad-Bhägavatam, (4) to see the decorated temple and the Deity and, if possible, (5) to live in a place like Våndävana or Mathurä. These five items alone can help a devotee achieve the highest perfectional stage. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä and in this verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam. That third-class devotees can also imperceptibly achieve liberation is accepted in all Vedic literatures.

As far as meditation on the arcä-vigraha form of the Lord is concerned, we have to look at the Deity beginning with His lotus feet. It is not that we immediately look at His smiling face. We should first try to see the lotus feet of Kåñëa, and when we are practiced in this way, we can look at His thighs, His waist and His chest. Then we can reach His smiling face. In this manner we should meditate on Kåñëa's form, and thus we can associate with Kåñëa by meditating on His smiling face, His flute, His hands, His dress, His consort Çrématé Rädhäräëé and the other gopés surrounding Him. Thus we should practice observing the Supreme Lord, and to this end He has appeared before us as the arcä-vigraha.

There are three kinds of devotee: kaniñöha-adhikäré, madhyama-adhikäré and uttama-adhikäré. The uttama-adhikäré is the most advanced; the madhyama-adhikäré is in the middle stage; and the kaniñöha-adhikäré is the neophyte. It is recommended that the neophyte meditate on the Deity daily. He should begin by meditating on the lotus feet, and then when he is practiced, he should turn his gaze toward Kåñëa's smiling face. The neophyte should also read and hear Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam. If we simply try to see and don't listen, the results will not be permanent. In some temples there are Deities but no discussion about Kåñëa. People attend for some time, but after a while they lose interest. Thus there must be two activities. The Deities must be worshiped, and this is called päïcarätriké-vidhi. There must also be bhägavata-vidhi, reading Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Päïcarätriké-vidhi and bhägavata-vidhi go hand in hand. By participating in these two processes, the neophyte can gradually attain the intermediate stage.

The spiritual master is supposed to be in the most advanced stage, but for preaching purposes he descends to the intermediate stage. The uttama-adhikäré, the most advanced devotee, does not discriminate between devotees and nondevotees. He sees everyone but himself as a devotee. The truly advanced devotee sees that he is not a devotee but that everyone else is a devotee. The kaniñöha-adhikäré, the neophyte, simply concentrates on the Deity, and that is required in the beginning:

arcäyäm eva haraye
püjäà yaù çraddhayehate
na tad-bhakteñu cänyeñu
sa bhaktaù präkåtaù småtaù

"A person who is very faithfully engaged in the worship of the Deity in the temple, but who does not know how to behave toward devotees or people in general is called a präkåta-bhakta, or kaniñöha-adhikäré." (Bhäg. 11.2.47) According to the prescribed duties mentioned in the scriptures, one must care for the Deity, but when one is a little further advanced, he considers his functions with others. When one attains the madhyama-adhikäré stage, his vision is described thus:

éçvare tad-adhéneñu
bäliçeñu dviñatsu ca
prema-maitré-kåpopekñä
yaù karoti sa madhyamaù

"The madhyama-adhikäré is a devotee who worships the Supreme Personality of Godhead as the highest object of love, makes friends with the Lord's devotees, is merciful to the ignorant and avoids those who are envious by nature." (Bhäg. 11.2.46)

The madhyama-adhikäré is not only interested in the Deity, but he can also discern between devotees and nondevotees. He can also understand that this man is innocent and that this man is not. The innocent do not know what is to be done, and they do not know anything about God. They are not actually offenders, but there are others who are offenders. The offenders become immediately envious as soon as they hear about God or His devotees.

The madhyama-adhikäré knows that Kåñëa is God: kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam. He wants to develop his love for Kåñëa. He also wants to see that not a moment is wasted without engagement in Kåñëa consciousness. He is always careful not to spoil life's valuable time. That is the first qualification of a madhyama-adhikäré. We have a very short period to live, and we never know when we are going to die. There is no certainty. Foolish people think that they will go on living forever, but that is simply foolishness. Life is transient; therefore the devotee wants to utilize every moment for the advancement of Kåñëa consciousness.

The madhyama-adhikäré also has a special taste for chanting the Hare Kåñëa mantra. He is also very anxious to live in places like Våndävana, Dvärakä and Mathurä, places where Kåñëa lived. Of course it is a fact that Kåñëa, being God, has His residence everywhere. He even resides within every atom. Aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-stham. Nonetheless, He has special places of residence like Våndävana, Dvärakä and Mathurä; therefore a devotee is anxious to live in those places.

Increasing one's love for God is a gradual process, and the first ingredient is faith. Without faith, there is no question of progress in Kåñëa consciousness. That faith is created after reading Bhagavad-gétä carefully and actually understanding it as it is. Unless one reads Bhagavad-gétä, there is no question of faith in Kåñëa. One must have faith in the words of Kåñëa, particularly when Kåñëa says, "Abandon all dharmas and surrender to Me. I will give you all protection." If we study Bhagavad-gétä as a literary treatise and then throw it away, that is not faith. Faith is explained by Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämé thus:

'çraddhä'-çabde—viçväsa kahe sudåòha niçcaya
kåñëe bhakti kaile sarva-karma kåta haya

"By rendering transcendental loving service to Kåñëa, one automatically performs all subsidiary activities. This confident, firm faith, favorable to the discharge of devotional service, is called çraddhä." (Cc. Madhya 22.62)

In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says that He is not only a person but the Supreme Personality of Godhead as well. He also says that there is no one superior to Him. If one believes these words, then one will have faith. Impersonalists read Bhagavad-gétä, but they do not accept Kåñëa as a person. In the Twelfth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä, Kåñëa says that the impersonalist takes more trouble to come to Him. He will come later, but it will take some time. This is because impersonal understanding of the Supreme Absolute Truth is partial understanding. As Kåñëa states:

kleço 'dhikataras teñäm
avyaktäsakta-cetasäm
avyaktä hi gatir duùkhaà
dehavadbhir aväpyate

"For those whose minds are attached to the unmanifested, impersonal feature of the Supreme, advancement is very troublesome. To make progress in that discipline is always difficult for those who are embodied." (Bg. 12.5)

We have often given the example of impersonal understanding being like the understanding of the sunshine. One may see the sunshine entering through a window into his room, but this does not mean that one knows everything about the sun. Impersonal understanding of the Absolute Truth is like that. The sunshine is impersonal (Brahman), the sun itself is localized (Paramätmä) and the sun-god residing within the sun is a person (Bhagavän). Just as one can understand the three aspects of the sun—the sunshine, the sun itself and the sun-god—one can also understand the three aspects of the Supreme Absolute Truth—Brahman, Paramätmä and Bhagavän.

Impersonalists maintain that the sun is simply a fiery globe and nothing else, but in Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa specifically states that He spoke Bhagavad-gétä to the sun-god Vivasvän. Of course we can hardly imagine how the sun-god can be a person. The sun is a great fiery globe, and we think that it is impossible for anyone to live there, but this thinking is simply shortsighted. It does not follow that no one can live in fire just because we cannot live there. We cannot live in water, yet there are aquatics living there. We live on this planet, which is basically composed of earth, and our bodies are basically composed of earth in order to live here. Bodies are made in such a way that they can live in their environment. Similarly, the sun-god has a body capable of living in fire.

Kåñëa is sac-cid-änanda-vigraha, being, knowledge and bliss, with form. Impersonal understanding is understanding of the sat feature. Understanding Kåñëa in full is understanding all of His features. The änanda feature is realized in Bhagavän. Kåñëa plays on His flute and is accompanied by His pleasure potency, hlädiné çakti, Çrématé Rädhäräëé. Of Kåñëa's many potencies, the hlädiné çakti is His pleasure-giving potency. That is änanda. Although Kåñëa is full in Himself, He expands Himself when He wants to enjoy. That expansion is His pleasure potency, Rädhäräëé. The gopés are the expansions of Rädhäräëé, and the various forms of Kåñëa are manifest just to taste the mellow of transcendental bliss. Änanda-cinmaya-rasa. Thus Brahman realization is realization of the sat portion, Paramätmä realization is realization of the cit portion, and Bhagavän realization is the realization of the änanda portion. In the Vedänta-sütra it is said that the Absolute Truth is änandamayo 'bhyäsät. Kåñëa's lélä is always full of transcendental bliss—especially in Våndävana, His original residence. It is in Våndävana that Kåñëa plays with His cowherd boy friends and dances with the gopés. It is also in Våndävana that Kåñëa steals Mother Yaçodä's butter. All His activities there are filled with transcendental bliss.

We can begin to experience this bliss by following the prescribed methods of devotional service. When we see the Deity, we can gradually realize how Kåñëa is smiling, playing on His flute and enjoying the company of Çrématé Rädhäräëé. Then we also have to hear about Kåñëa. These two processes will increase in such a way that we will automatically become great devotees. Anicchato me gatim aëvéà prayuìkte. This is actually a scientific method. It is not imagination. People think that this is idol worship and imagination, but this method is prescribed in all the çästras for developing God consciousness. It is an actual science.

çré-bhagavän uväca
jïänaà parama-guhyaà me
yad vijïäna-samanvitam
sa-rahasyaà tad-aìgaà ca
gåhäëa gaditaà mayä

"The Personality of Godhead said: Knowledge about Me as described in the scriptures is very confidential, and it has to be realized in conjunction with devotional service. The necessary paraphernalia for that process is being explained by Me. You may take it up carefully." (Bhäg. 2.9.31)

In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa tells Arjuna that He has revealed this most confidential knowledge to him because Arjuna is His very dear friend. That confidential knowledge is, sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja: "Just surrender unto Me." (Bg. 18.66) Brahman realization is certainly confidential, and Paramätmä realization is still more confidential, but understanding Kåñëa as He is, is the most confidential knowledge of all.

If one's mind and senses are completely absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness, one is experiencing bhakti. Bhakti is not a sentiment but a practical science. One may engage in many activities, but in all cases, one's mind must be fully absorbed in Kåñëa. Although a housewife is always busy working around the house, she always takes care that her hair is nicely combed. Regardless of her engagements, she never forgets to arrange her hair in an attractive way. Similarly, a devotee engages in many activities, but he never forgets Kåñëa's transcendental form. This is the meaning of perfection.

TLK 16: The Pure Devotees' Spiritual Opulences

CHAPTER SIXTEEN
The Pure Devotees' Spiritual Opulences

TLK Vs 37

TEXT 37

atho vibhütià mama mäyävinas täm
aiçvaryam añöäìgam anupravåttam
çriyaà bhägavatéà väspåhayanti bhadräà
parasya me te 'çnuvate tu loke

TRANSLATION

Thus because he is completely absorbed in meditation upon Me, the devotee does not desire even the highest benediction obtainable in the upper planetary systems, including Satyaloka. He does not desire the eight material perfections obtained from mystic yoga, nor does he desire to be elevated to the kingdom of God. Yet even without desiring them, the devotee enjoys, even in this life, all the offered benedictions.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.37]

PURPORT

The vibhüti, or opulences, offered by mäyä are of many varieties. We experience different varieties of material enjoyment even on this planet, but if one is able to promote himself to higher planets like Candraloka, the sun or, still higher, Maharloka, Janaloka and Tapoloka, or even ultimately the highest planet, which is inhabited by Brahmä and is called Satyaloka, one will find immense possibilities for material enjoyment. For example, the duration of life on higher planets is far, far greater than on this planet. It is said that on the moon the duration of life is such that our six months are equal to one day. We cannot even imagine the duration of life on the highest planet. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that Brahmä's twelve hours are inconceivable even to our mathematicians. These are all descriptions of the external energy of the Lord, or mäyä. Besides these, there are other opulences which the yogés can achieve by their mystic power. They are also material. A devotee does not aspire for all these material pleasures, although they are available to him simply by wishing. By the grace of the Lord, a devotee can achieve wonderful material success simply by willing, but a real devotee does not do so. Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu has taught that one should not desire material opulence or material reputation, nor should one try to enjoy material beauty; he should only aspire to be absorbed in the devotional service of the Lord, even if he does not get liberation but has to continue the process of birth and death unlimitedly. Actually, however, to one who engages in Kåñëa consciousness, liberation is already guaranteed. Devotees enjoy all the benefits of the higher planets and the Vaikuëöha planets also. It is especially mentioned here, bhägavatéà bhadräm. In the Vaikuëöha planets everything is eternally peaceful, yet a pure devotee does not even aspire to be promoted there. But still he gets that advantage; he enjoys all the facilities of the material and spiritual worlds, even during the present life span.

According to Caitanya Mahäprabhu, Rüpa Gosvämé in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu, Närada Muni in the Närada Païcarätra and Bhagavän Çré Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä, a pure devotee never wants anything from the Lord. He does not even want liberation, to say nothing of material things. Generally, people want dharma, artha, käma and mokña, in that order. First of all, people want to become religious (dharma) in order to attain material opulence (artha). People want material opulence in order to gratify their senses (käma), and when they are frustrated in their attempt to gratify their senses, they want liberation (mokña). In this way, dharma, artha, käma and mokña are going on. However, a devotee is not interested in any of these. In the Christian religion, people pray, "Give us this day our daily bread," but a pure bhakta does not even ask for his daily bread. A pure devotee is kept in the hand of Kåñëa just like a very precious jewel. When you hold something precious in your hand, you are very careful, and similarly, Kåñëa holds the devotee and takes care of him.

One can just imagine his position if a very rich man says, "Don't worry. I will take care of everything for you." Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, is the proprietor of all opulence. There is no one more opulent than Kåñëa; therefore if Kåñëa says that He will take care of His devotee, there is no question of poverty. Most people want material opulence, but they do not know that Kåñëa is the proprietor of all opulence. That is their misfortune. Although the proprietor of all opulence says, "Just surrender unto Me, and I will take care of you," people do not do it. Instead, they say, "I will take care of my own business. I will maintain myself. I will take care of myself, my family, my friends and my country." Arjuna was very intelligent because he simply chose Kåñëa, whereas Duryodhana took Kåñëa's soldiers. It is not possible to conquer Kåñëa, but the devotee can capture Kåñëa with bhakti, love.

It is impossible for people to understand the great opulence of Çré Kåñëa. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu tells us to abandon speculating about God. There is a story of a frog in a well being approached by a friend who says, "My dear frog, I have just seen a huge body of water." "What is that water?" the frog asks. "The Atlantic Ocean," the friend replies. "Oh, the Atlantic Ocean! Is it bigger than this well? Is it four feet? Ten feet?"

Our attempt to speculate about God is very much like this. If we want to understand God, we have to try to understand from God Himself. We may have a neighbor who is very wealthy, influential, wise, strong and beautiful, and we may speculate about his opulence, but if we make friends with him, we can understand his position by listening to him speak about himself. God cannot be subjected to our imagination. Our imagination is limited, and our senses are imperfect. The process of bhakti-märga is the process of submission. There is no question of subjecting God to our imagination. We simply have to become very humble and submissive and pray to Kåñëa sincerely, "Kåñëa, it is not possible for me to know You. Kindly explain how it is I can know You, and then it will be possible." This is the way Arjuna approached Kåñëa in the Eleventh Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä.

We can hardly understand or comprehend the innumerable universes. The word jagat refers to this universe, but there is more than one universe. Although we are seeing only one universe, there are millions of universes, and Kåñëa is supporting all these millions of universes with a single fragment of Himself. This is also confirmed in many other Vedic literatures:

yasyaika-niçvasita-kälam athävalambya
jévanti loma-vilajä jagad-aëòa-näthäù
viñëur mahän sa iha yasya kalä-viçeño
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"Brahmä and other lords of the mundane worlds, appearing from the pores of hair of Mahä-Viñëu, remain alive as long as the duration of His one exhalation. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda, of whose subjective personality Mahä-Viñëu is the portion of a portion." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.48)

This is the information given in Brahma-saàhitä, the prayers offered by Lord Brahmä. This Brahma-saàhitä was accepted by Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, who copied it when He toured South India. Formerly there were no presses to print these literatures, and these important Vedic writings were written by hand. These literatures were not very cheap, and only highly qualified brähmaëas were able to keep them. They were worshiped in the temple as the çästra Deity. It is not that they were available everywhere. Now, of course, the printing press has changed all this, but nonetheless we should always understand that the granthas, the scriptures, should be worshiped as God because they are the sound incarnation of God. One should not consider Bhagavad-gétä or Çrémad-Bhägavatam to be ordinary books, and one should take care of them just as carefully as one takes care of the Deity.

At any rate, when Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu returned from South India with a copy of Brahma-saàhitä, He gave it to His disciples and told them that it was a summary of the Vedänta and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. We therefore accept Brahma-saàhitä as authorized scripture, for it was authorized by the Supreme Person, Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Just as Çré Kåñëa explains in Bhagavad-gétä in so many ways that the entire material creation is resting on one of His portions, Brahma-saàhitä explains the same subject. It is stated that from the skin pores of the Mahä-Viñëu, all the universes are emanating. In each universe there is a Brahmä, a supervisor, who is the supreme creature and manager. These managers live only as long as the Mahä-Viñëu exhales. When He exhales, all the universes are created, and when He inhales, they all return into His body. In this way so many universes and Brahmäs are coming and going. The durations of these breaths, which constitute a life of a Brahmä, are described in Bhagavad-gétä as many trillions of earth years. One may say that this is all fictitious and imaginary, but unless one believes it, one has no right to touch Bhagavad-gétä.

Generally people are interested in going to the higher planetary systems in order to become more opulent. This is the process of karma-käëòéya, and people perform yajïas and pious activities in order to be elevated to higher planets. The idea is that one will be able to enjoy himself more, have a longer life span, more opulence, more beautiful women, nice gardens and so on. Actually this is the case, but a devotee is not at all interested in these things because he accepts Kåñëa. In Bhagavad-gétä (8.16) Çré Kåñëa says, äbrahma-bhuvanäl lokäù punar ävartino 'rjuna: "From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place."

Even if we are promoted to the highest planet, Brahmaloka, the planet where Lord Brahmä lives, our situation there is still not eternal. So why should a devotee be interested in such a place? A devotee is simply interested in the supreme eternal, Çré Kåñëa. The Supreme Lord is the supreme leader of the nityas, the eternal living entities. We are all nityas, eternal, and Kåñëa guides and plays with us. In the spiritual world, Kåñëa and His devotees are friends, and they play together as cowherd boys. They are not interested in Brahmaloka or Candraloka, for these planets will ultimately be annihilated. There are some living entities that live only a few seconds, or, at most, a night. By the morning, they are all dead. Any life in the material world is comparable to that. Brahmä may live millions of years, but he ultimately has to die. Whether we go to the highest planet or the lowest planet, whether we are in the body of a Brahmä or a cat, we ultimately have to die. Kåñëa presents Himself to atheists as death. He appeared in this way before Hiraëyakaçipu, who said, "I am God. All the demigods are afraid of me. I am very powerful." Kåñëa comes before such atheists as death and takes everything away—all power, opulence, money—everything. The theists worship God while they are living, and their only business in this life is serving God. After death, they render the same service; thus there is no difference between Vaikuëöha and a temple, for a devotee. In either case, his business is the same. Why, then, should he aspire to go to Vaikuëöha?

In the Vaikuëöha planets one attains opulence like Kåñëa or Näräyaëa. There are five kinds of mukti, liberation, and one is särñöi. This kind of liberation brings one opulence equal to the Lord. In the Vaikuëöha planets, everyone is four-handed like Näräyaëa, and everyone is equally opulent. In Goloka Våndävana, Kåñëa and the cowherd boys are equally opulent. In Våndävana, the cowherd boys do not know that Kåñëa is God. They look on Kåñëa as an equal. This is the opulence of their devotional position.

Nonetheless, the devotees do not aspire for all this opulence. Their only aspiration is to engage in the service of the Lord. In this way, they get everything. Nor are the devotees interested in attaining the mystic yoga siddhis. They do not need to be able to create a planet, for they can create Vaikuëöha by worshiping Kåñëa in the temple. The temple is nirguëa, transcendental to the guëas. In the çästras it is said that the forest is characterized by sattva-guëa, goodness, and the city is characterized by rajo-guëa, passion, because in the city there is a great deal of illicit sex, intoxication, gambling and meat-eating. Formerly, when people were aspiring for spiritual realization, they left the cities and went to the forests. That was the vänaprastha stage. The word vana means "forest." Before taking sannyäsa, a man would leave his family and go to the forest to begin practicing austerities. Vanaà gato yad dharim äçrayeta [Bhäg. 7.5.5].

Actually, superior to living in the forest is living in the temple because the temple is nirguëa, above all the guëas, even sattva-guëa. The inhabitants of the temple are actually in Vaikuëöha.

Lord Kapiladeva next explains the nature of the special opulences of the devotees.

TLK Vs 38

TEXT 38

na karhicin mat-paräù çänta-rüpe
naìkñyanti no me 'nimiño leòhi hetiù
yeñäm ahaà priya ätmä sutaç ca
sakhä guruù suhådo daivam iñöam

TRANSLATION

The Lord continued: My dear mother, devotees who receive such transcendental opulences are never bereft of them; neither weapons nor the change of time can destroy such opulences. Because the devotees accept Me as their friend, relative, son, preceptor, benefactor and Supreme Deity, they cannot be deprived of their possessions at any time.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.38]

PURPORT

It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that one may elevate himself to the higher planetary systems, even up to Brahmaloka, by dint of pious activities, but when the effects of such pious activities are finished, one again comes back to this earth to begin a new life of activities. Thus even though one is promoted to the higher planetary system for enjoyment and a long duration of life, still that is not a permanent settlement. But as far as the devotees are concerned, their assets—the achievement of devotional service and the consequent opulence of Vaikuëöha, even on this planet—are never destroyed. In this verse Kapiladeva addresses His mother as çänta-rüpa, indicating that the opulences of devotees are fixed because devotees are eternally fixed in the Vaikuëöha atmosphere, which is called çänta-rüpa because it is in the mode of pure goodness, undisturbed by the modes of passion and ignorance. Once one is fixed in the devotional service of the Lord, his position of transcendental service cannot be destroyed, and the pleasure and service simply increase unlimitedly. For the devotees engaged in Kåñëa consciousness, in the Vaikuëöha atmosphere, there is no influence of time. In the material world the influence of time destroys everything, but in the Vaikuëöha atmosphere there is no influence of time or of the demigods because there are no demigods in the Vaikuëöha planets. Here our activities are controlled by different demigods; even if we move our hand and leg, the action is controlled by the demigods. But in the Vaikuëöha atmosphere there is no influence of the demigods or of time; therefore there is no question of destruction. When the time element is present, there is the certainty of destruction, but when there is no time element—past, present or future—then everything is eternal. Therefore this verse uses the words naìkñyanti no, indicating that the transcendental opulences will never be destroyed.

The reason for freedom from destruction is also described. The devotees accept the Supreme Lord as the most dear personality and reciprocate with Him in different relationships. They accept the Supreme Personality of Godhead as a dearmost friend, relative, son, preceptor, well-wisher or Deity. The Lord is eternal; therefore any relationship in which we accept Him is also eternal. It is clearly confirmed herein that the relationships cannot be destroyed, and therefore the opulences of those relationships are never destroyed. Every living entity has the propensity to love someone. We can see that if someone has no object of love, he generally directs his love to a pet animal like a cat or a dog. Thus the eternal propensity for love in all living entities is always searching for a place to reside. From this verse we can learn that we can love the Supreme Personality of Godhead as our dearmost object—as a friend, as a son, as a preceptor or as a well-wisher—and there will be no cheating and no end to such love. We shall eternally enjoy the relationship with the Supreme Lord in different aspects. A special feature of this verse is the acceptance of the Supreme Lord as the supreme preceptor. Bhagavad-gétä is spoken directly by the Supreme Lord, and Arjuna accepted Kåñëa as his guru, or spiritual master. Similarly, we should accept only Kåñëa as the supreme spiritual master.

When we speak of Kåñëa, we include His confidential devotees; Kåñëa is not alone. Kåñëa includes His name, His form, His qualities, His abode, His associates, etc. For example, a king is always associated with his secretary, his commander, his servant and so much paraphernalia. As soon as we accept Kåñëa and His associates as our preceptors, no ill effects can destroy our knowledge. In the material world the knowledge we acquire may change because of the influence of time, but nevertheless the conclusions received from Bhagavad-gétä, directly from the speeches of the Supreme Lord Kåñëa, can never change. There is no use interpreting Bhagavad-gétä; it is eternal.

Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, should be accepted as one's best friend. He will never cheat. He will always give His friendly advice and protection to the devotee. If Kåñëa is accepted as a son, He will never die. Here we may have a very loving son or child, but the father and mother, or those who are affectionate toward him, always hope, "May my son not die." But Kåñëa actually never will die. Therefore those who accept Kåñëa, or the Supreme Lord, as their son will never be bereft of their son. In many instances devotees have accepted the Deity as a son. In Bengal there are many such instances, and even after the death of the devotee, the Deity performs the çräddha ceremony for the father. The relationship is never destroyed. People are accustomed to worship different forms of demigods, but in Bhagavad-gétä such a mentality is condemned; therefore one should be intelligent enough to worship only the Supreme Personality of Godhead in His different forms such as Lakñmé-Näräyaëa, Sétä-Räma and Rädhä-Kåñëa. Thus one will never be cheated. By worshiping the demigods, one may elevate himself to the higher planets, but during the dissolution of the material world, the deity and his abode will be destroyed. But one who worships the Supreme Personality of Godhead is promoted to the Vaikuëöha planet, where there is no time, destruction or annihilation. The conclusion is that time cannot act upon devotees who have accepted the Supreme Personality of Godhead as everything.

Spiritual life is eternal; it cannot be destroyed. Whatever we have here in the material world is subject to destruction. In this material world we aspire for a nice house, good property, children, friends and riches, but ultimately all of these will be destroyed, including ourselves. Nothing here is permanent; therefore everything is called illusory. Actually we do not understand this; we take all this as permanent. The fact is, however, that only Kåñëa is permanent. Kåñëa's material energy is not permanent.

Mäyävädés think that in the spiritual world there are no relationships. However, in the çästras it is stated that in the spiritual world there is real life. Life in this material world is simply a shadow of that life. In the Fifteenth Chapter of Bhagavad-gétä this material world is likened to a banyan tree with its roots above and branches below. This means that it is like a shadow. When we stand beside a reservoir of water, we see the tree reflected upside down. We also have the experience of a mirage in the material world. We think that there is water, but actually there is none. Sometimes sailors at sea think they see land, but actually this is a mirage in the water. This material world is like that. In our lives we think we are enjoying some rasa, some relationship. Our children are calling us father, and we are enjoying our relationship with our wife, but all of these relationships are like shadows, although people have no information of this. The true enjoyment derived from these relationships can be attained in the spiritual world with Kåñëa. Kåñëa therefore comes in person to teach us that we can enjoy the same relationship with Him. We can enjoy Him as our master, our friend, our son, our father or our lover.

The Mäyävädé philosophers say that if Kåñëa has become everything, there is no question of Kåñëa as an entity or a person. This is a materialistic idea. If we tear up a piece of paper into small pieces and throw it away, the paper no longer has an existence. However, Kåñëa is not like that.

advaitam acyutam anädim ananta-rüpam
ädyaà puräëa-puruñaà nava-yauvanaà ca

"I worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Govinda [Kåñëa], who is the original person—absolute, infallible, without beginning, although expanded into unlimited forms, still the same original, the oldest, and the person always appearing as a fresh youth." (Brahma-saàhitä 5.33) Kåñëa has many millions of expansions, and He is also situated in everyone's heart. He is not only within human beings but within animals, trees, plants, aquatics and so forth. It is materialistic to think that Kåñëa has no individual existence if He has entered into so many millions of hearts. Even though Kåñëa has distributed Himself in many millions of parts, He is still present in the same strength. Kåñëa is sarvaiçvarya-pürëa. He is never diminished.

There is an interesting story of a poor boy who was a student in school. During an annual Father's Day ceremony, the teacher requested the students to give some kind of a contribution. Formerly teachers would not earn a salary but would receive whatever the students would bring from their parents' homes or by begging. Generally the brähmaëas were teachers, and they could not charge anything. Thus some students brought the teacher rice, and some students brought other crops. This one student was so poor that he could think of nothing to bring; therefore he told his teacher that he would speak to his mother first. After school, the student told his mother, "My dear mother, all my class contribute?" The mother replied, "My dear son, we are so poor that we cannot give anything. However, Kåñëa is the friend of the poor. If He gives you something, you can promise it to your teacher." "Oh, where is Kåñëa?" the little boy asked. "Well, I understand that He is in the forest," the mother said. Therefore the little boy went to the forest and called for Kåñëa. He then began to cry, and finally Kåñëa came. When a devotee is very eager to see Kåñëa, Kåñëa is so kind that He comes. "So, what are you asking?" Kåñëa said to the little boy. "You are the friend of the poor," the little boy said. "I am very poor, and what can I promise my teacher?" Kåñëa then told him, "You can tell him that you will supply him some yogurt, some dahé." The little boy was very satisfied with this, and the next day he went to his teacher and said, "I will supply you as much yogurt as you need." The teacher felt that this was very nice, and he was pleased with the boy. On the day of the ceremony, the boy again went to the forest and called for Kåñëa. Kåñëa appeared and gave him a quart of yogurt. The little boy took this yogurt to his teacher and said, "This is my contribution, sir." The teacher looked at the quart and said, "What is this? Hundreds of people will be coming, and you have only given this much yogurt?" The teacher became so angry that he spilled the yogurt out of the container. When he bent down to pick it up, he saw that the container was again full. He dropped it again, and it was again full. He could then understand that it was spiritual.

This is the nature of Kåñëa. One can take everything, and yet the same will remain. In the material world, one minus one equals zero, but in the spiritual world, one minus one equals one. That is called advaya jïäna. There is no duality in the spiritual world. One plus one equals one, and one minus one equals one. If we love Kåñëa, that love will not be destroyed as love is in the material world. In the material world, a servant serves the master as long as the servant is pleased and as long as the master is pleased. The servant is pleased as long as the master pays, and the master is pleased as long as the servant renders good service. However, in the spiritual world, if the servant cannot serve under certain conditions, the master is still pleased. And if the master does not pay, the servant is also pleased. That is called oneness, absolute. A guru may have hundreds of disciples, hundreds of servants, but he doesn't have to pay them. They are serving out of spiritual love, and the guru is teaching without receiving a salary. This is a spiritual relationship. There are no cheaters and cheated in such a relationship. If we accept Kåñëa as our son, friend or lover, we will never be cheated. However, we have to give up the false, illusory servant, son, father or lover, for they will surely cheat us. We may love our son with our heart and soul, but that very son may some day be our enemy. We may love our wife very much, but some day that wife may be such an enemy that she will kill us for her own interests. There are many instances of this in history. Mäyävädé philosophers are afraid of having such relationships because they have bitter experience with these relationships in the material world. They therefore want to negate all relationships, and therefore they say no more son, daughter, lover, master or whatever. Being disgusted with these things, they try to make everything void. Yet if we have the same relationship with Kåñëa, we will never be cheated or disappointed. Our enthusiasm will increase more and more. Therefore Kåñëa encourages us to accept Him as our son, as our friend and as our master. Then we will be happy.

TLK Vs 39-40

TEXTS 39-40

imaà lokaà tathaivämum
ätmänam ubhayäyinam
ätmänam anu ye ceha
ye räyaù paçavo gåhäù

visåjya sarvän anyäàç ca
mäm evaà viçvato-mukham
bhajanty ananyayä bhaktyä
tän måtyor atipäraye

TRANSLATION

Thus the devotee who worships Me, the all-pervading Lord of the universe, with unflinching devotional service, gives up all aspirations for promotion to heavenly planets or happiness in this world with wealth, children, cows, home or anything in relationship with the body. I take him to the other side of birth and death.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.39-40]

PURPORT

Unflinching devotional service, as described in these two verses, means engaging oneself in full Kåñëa consciousness, or devotional service, accepting the Supreme Lord as all in all. Since the Supreme Lord is all-inclusive, if anyone worships Him with unflinching faith, one has automatically achieved all other opulences and performed all other duties. The Lord promises herein that He takes His devotee to the other side of birth and death. Lord Caitanya, therefore, recommended that one who aspires to go beyond birth and death should have no material possessions. This means that one should not try to be happy in this world or to be promoted to the heavenly world, nor should he strive for material wealth, children, houses or cows.

How liberation is imperceptibly achieved by a pure devotee and what the symptoms are have been explained. The situation with a conditioned soul is different, however. If he is in the mode of goodness, he may be preparing for promotion to the higher planets; if he is in the mode of passion, he will remain here in a society where activity is very prominent, and if he is in the mode of ignorance, he may be degraded to animal life or a lower grade of human life. But for a devotee there is no concern for this life or the next life because in any life he does not desire material elevation. He prays to the Lord, "My dear Lord, it does not matter where I am born, but let me be born, even as an ant, in the house of a devotee." A pure devotee does not pray to the Lord for liberation from this material bondage. Actually, the pure devotee never thinks that he is fit for liberation. Considering his past life and his mischievous activities, he thinks that he is fit to be sent to the lowest region of hell. If in this life I am trying to become a devotee, this does not mean that in my many past lives I was one hundred percent pious. That is not possible. A devotee, therefore, is always conscious of his real position. Only by his full surrender to the Lord, by the Lord's grace, are his sufferings mitigated. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä, "Surrender unto Me, and I will give you protection from all kinds of sinful reaction." That is His mercy. But this does not mean that one who has surrendered to the lotus feet of the Lord has committed no misdeeds in his past life. A devotee always prays, "For my misdeeds, may I be born again and again, but my only prayer is that I may not forget Your service." The devotee has such mental strength, and he prays to the Lord: "May I be born again and again, but let me be born in the home of Your pure devotee so that I may again get a chance to develop my spiritual life."

A pure devotee is not anxious to elevate himself in his next birth. He has already given up that sort of hope. In any life in which one is born, as a householder, or even as an animal, he must have some children, some resources or some possessions, but a devotee is not anxious to possess anything. He is satisfied with whatever is obtainable by God's grace. He is not at all attached to improving his social status or the education of his children. He is not neglectful—he is dutiful—but he does not spend too much time on the improvement of temporary household or social life. He fully engages in the service of the Lord, and for other affairs he simply spares as much time as absolutely necessary (yathärham upayuïjataù). Such a pure devotee does not care what is going to happen in the next life or in this life; he does not care even for family, children or society. He fully engages in the service of the Lord in Kåñëa consciousness. It is stated in Bhagavad-gétä that without the knowledge of the devotee, the Lord arranges for His devotee to be immediately transferred to His transcendental abode just after leaving his body. After quitting his body he does not go into the womb of another mother. The ordinary common living entity, after death, is transferred to the womb of another mother, according to his karma, or activities, to take another type of body. But as far as the devotee is concerned, he is at once transferred to the spiritual world in the association of the Lord. That is the Lord's special mercy. Because He is all-powerful, the Lord can do anything and everything. He can excuse all sinful reactions. He can immediately transfer a person to Vaikuëöhaloka. That is the inconceivable power of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is favorably disposed to the pure devotees.

In these verses, Kapiladeva is describing the devotee's acceptance of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, as the most dear to us. If we want to love Kåñëa as a son, Kåñëa is prepared to be our son. Arjuna accepted Kåñëa as his friend, and Kåñëa was his best friend. Everyone can accept Kåñëa in so many ways. We can love Kåñëa as Arjuna did, or as Mother Yaçodä did. Similarly, Parékñit Mahäräja simply heard about Kåñëa and developed love. The first-class yogé takes Kåñëa as everything—priya, suta, sakhä, guru, everything. This is real bhakti. If we want a son, Kåñëa is prepared to be our son. If we want a lover, He is prepared to be our lover. If we want a friend, He is prepared to be our friend. Whatever relationship we want in the material world, we can have with Kåñëa. We all have some loving propensity, and Kåñëa is prepared to fulfill this propensity. Kåñëa is not a person like ourselves. We occupy one body, but Kåñëa is the owner of all bodies. The body is a machine given by Kåñëa. In the material world, a father may give his son a car. Similarly, Kåñëa gives the living entities bodies, 8,400,000 different types of bodies. The living entity gets into the body just as a person gets into a car, and he goes this way and that. We can drive this machine called the body for so many years; then it becomes old, and we have to change it for another machine. This is the process of birth and death. We drive one car for a while, and the car is finally broken, or it is smashed. We may have an accident or not, but eventually the car has to go to the junk yard. Then we have to get another car.

Actually our position is that we never take birth and never die, but why have we been put into this position of accepting these machines? This is our real problem. What is the cause of this? We want to enjoy this material world with its wealth and possessions. As long as we are after material possessions, we cannot transcend the cycle of birth and death. However, we have to give up all this and take shelter of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and worship Him. Nor can we worship Him whimsically, but as He desires. If Kåñëa says, "I want a glass of water," we must bring Him water. We cannot say, "Milk is better than water. I think I will bring Him milk." This is not favorable service. Some so-called bhaktas say, "I can worship the Lord in my own way." This is simply imagination. The Mäyävädés say that Brahman has no rüpa, no form, and they suggest that we imagine some form. This is not the case with Kåñëa. Kåñëa is present in His original form, and He is described in Vedic literatures. We have recounted these descriptions before. If we want to attain a body like Brahmä's, we can get it. If we want a body like a worm in stool, we can get it. Or, if we want a body like Kåñëa's, we can get that also. That is our real body of sac-cid-änanda. We can also get a body like a demigod's and go to the heavenly planets. Or we can remain here in the middle planetary system. Our destination is our own choice. We are given full freedom through our activities. By pious activities, we go to the heavenly planets, and by Kåñëa conscious activities, we go to Vaikuëöhaloka.

We are part and parcel of Kåñëa, but somehow or other we have forgotten this. In Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 20.117) it is said:

kåñëa bhuli' sei jéva anädi-bahirmukha
ataeva mäyä täre deya saàsära-duùkha

"Forgetting Kåñëa, the living entity has been attracted by the external feature from time immemorial. Therefore the illusory energy [mäyä] gives him all kinds of misery in his material existence." Because we have forgotten Kåñëa, Kåñëa has given us all these Vedas and puräëas. Kåñëa also comes into this material world in order to remind us of Himself. In this Kali-yuga, people are forgetting Kåñëa more and more. They are not even interested in Him, but Kåñëa is interested because we are His sons. A mad son may no longer be interested in his home, in his father or mother, yet the father never loses interest in his son. He is anxious because his boy has left home and is suffering. Similarly, Kåñëa's son leaves the spiritual sky and takes up one material body after another and in this way travels from one planet to another in different species of life. Therefore Kåñëa comes to rescue him.

TLK 17: Taking Shelter of Kåñëa, the Supreme Controller

CHAPTER SEVENTEEN
Taking Shelter of Kåñëa, the Supreme Controller

TLK Vs 41

TEXT 41

nänyatra mad-bhagavataù
pradhäna-puruñeçvarät
ätmanaù sarva-bhütänäà
bhayaà tévraà nivartate

TRANSLATION

The terrible fear of birth and death can never be forsaken by anyone who resorts to any shelter other than Myself, for I am the almighty Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the original source of all creation, and also the Supreme Soul of all souls.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.41]

PURPORT

It is indicated herein that the cycle of birth and death cannot be stopped unless one is a pure devotee of the Supreme Lord. It is said, harià vinä naiva såtià taranti. One cannot surpass the cycle of birth and death unless one is favored by the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The same concept is confirmed herewith: one may take to the system of understanding the Absolute Truth by one's own imperfect sensory speculation, or one may try to realize the self by the mystic yoga process; but whatever one may do, unless he comes to the point of surrendering to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, no process can give him liberation. One may ask if this means that those who are undergoing so much penance and austerity by strictly following the rules and regulations are endeavoring in vain. The answer is given by Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.2.32): ye 'nye 'ravindäkña vimukta-mäninaù. Lord Brahmä and other demigods prayed to the Lord when Kåñëa was in the womb of Devaké: "My dear lotus-eyed Lord, there are persons who are puffed up with the thought that they have become liberated or one with God or have become God, but they are unintelligent." It is stated that their intelligence, whether high or low, is not even purified. With purified intelligence, a living entity cannot think otherwise than to surrender. Bhagavad-gétä, therefore, confirms that purified intelligence arises in a very wise man. Bahünäà janmanäm ante jïänavän mäà prapadyate. After many, many births, one who is actually advanced in intelligence surrenders unto the Supreme Lord.

Without surrendering, one cannot achieve liberation. The Bhägavatam says, "Those who are simply puffed up, thinking themselves liberated by some nondevotional process, are not intelligent because they have not yet surrendered unto You. In spite of executing all kinds of austerities and penances or even arriving at the brink of Brahman realization, they think that they are in the effulgence of Brahman. But actually, because they have no transcendental activities, they fall down to material activities." One should not be satisfied simply with knowing that he is Brahman. He must engage himself in the service of the Supreme Brahman; that is bhakti. The engagement of Brahman should be the service of Para-brahman. It is said that unless one becomes Brahman, one cannot serve Brahman. The Supreme Brahman is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and the living entity is also Brahman. Without realizing that he is Brahman, spirit soul, an eternal servitor of the Lord, if one simply thinks that he is Brahman, his realization is only theoretical. He has to realize and at the same time engage himself in the devotional service of the Lord; then he can exist in the Brahman status. Otherwise he falls down.

The Bhägavatam says that because nondevotees neglect the transcendental loving service of the lotus feet of the Personality of Godhead, their intelligence is not pure, and therefore they fall down. The living entity must have some activity. If he does not engage in the activity of transcendental service, he must fall down to material activity. As soon as one falls down to material activity, there is no rescue from the cycle of birth and death. It is stated here by Lord Kapila, "Without My mercy" (nänyatra mad-bhagavataù). The Lord is stated here to be Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, indicating that He is full of all opulences and is therefore perfectly competent to deliver one from the cycle of birth and death. He is also called pradhäna because He is the Supreme. He is equal to everyone, but to one who surrenders to Him He is especially favorable. It is also confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä that the Lord is equal to everyone; no one is His enemy and no one is His friend. But to one who surrenders unto Him, He is especially inclined. By the grace of the Lord, simply by surrendering unto Him one can get out of this cycle of birth and death. Otherwise, he may go on in many, many lives and may many times attempt other processes for liberation.

Presently we are so dull and foolish that we do not know what is bhayam and tévram. The word tévram means "very terrible," and bhayam means "very fearsome." We are entangled by a very terrible fear, but we have become so dull due to the spell of mäyä that we do not care. At the time of death there are many troubles, and we become very fearful. Sometimes, when a person is dying, he falls into a coma and lies unconscious. We do not know what kind of fearful test this person is undergoing. He may be dreaming so many things, or he may be crying. He cannot express what is going on. Those who are very sinful especially die in that way. After death, one has to enter into the womb of another mother. That is also a very fearful stage. One becomes packed in a bag, and this bag is filled with stool and urine, and one has to remain packed in this airtight bag for nine months.

This is a horrible situation, but we have forgotten all about it. Therefore Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä that our real trouble is janma-måtyu—birth and death. When the living entity is packed in the womb, unable to move, he prays to God, "Please relieve me from this horrible condition. If You relieve me, I shall worship You." Finally, after nine months, the living entity emerges from the womb, and then he also undergoes so many troubles trying to adjust to the atmosphere of a new planet. As an infant, he cries and cries, and he is totally dependent on his mother's mercy. Sometimes a mother cannot understand what the child wants. Sometimes an ant may be biting the child, but the mother thinks that the child is hungry. There are bugs, worms, mosquitoes, stool, urine and so many things attacking the new body. These are the threefold miseries, yet we think that we have made such progress. We are being attacked moment after moment by one thing after another, yet people close their eyes to birth, old age, disease and death. The atheists want to forget these miseries, and therefore they like to think that there is no life after death. They are like ostriches, who stick their head in the ground when an enemy approaches.

Although the living entity in the womb promises to worship Kåñëa, when he is delivered from the womb he does not fulfill his promise. As soon as he is born and grows up, he begins to acquire a good bank balance, a wife and children and then begins to think that his problems are solved and that he will live very happily. Actually his problems are not solved. He may have some temporary facilities, but the main problem is still there. Every minute, every second, people are dying and going to Yamaräja. Those who are living are thinking that they will not die. They see that their friends are dying, but somehow or other they think that they are eternal. Yudhiñöhira Mahäräja said that this was the most amazing thing in the world. No one thinks that he is going to die, although everyone else is dying.

The living entity thinks that he is very happy in whatever body he gets. He may get the body of a dog or the body of a cat, but he is happy in his body, and he does not want to lose it. This is called illusion. When an ant sees danger, he will run like anything. This is because he values his body and does not want to lose it. Once Lord Indra, the King of the heavenly planets, was cursed by Båhaspati to become a hog. He was going about on earth enjoying his hog body when finally Lord Brahmä came and told him, "My dear Indra, you have suffered enough. Now come with me and return to your heavenly kingdom." Indra in the form of a hog said, "Where shall I go?" "To the heavens," Lord Brahmä replied. It was then that Indra said, "No, I have my family and children. How can I go? I am very happy. Let me remain here." In this way, everyone is thinking that he is very happy, although he is in a horrible and fearsome condition. However, one who is actually intelligent can understand that he is not actually happy, that he is suffering. It is said that ignorance is bliss, but this is the bliss of a hog. When one actually comes to the understanding that he is not actually happy in the material world, he can begin to relieve his suffering.

There is no possibility of being liberated from suffering without taking shelter at Kåñëa's lotus feet. People are thinking that they can relieve suffering through abortion, by killing the child within the womb. In this way they are committing one sin after another and becoming more and more entangled. Consequently the aborted living entity will have to enter into the womb of another mother in order to undergo the birth that he is destined to take. Then, when he enters the womb of another mother, he may again be killed, and for many years he may not be allowed to see the light of the sun. In this Kali-yuga, people are becoming so sinful that there is no possibility of rescue unless one takes to Kåñëa consciousness. The entire human civilization is falling into the illusory fire of mäyä. People fly into the fire just like moths. When there is a beautiful fire, moths come from a long distance, enter it and go pop, pop, pop. In this way one dies, takes birth and suffers and dies again.

Yet Kåñëa and His devotees are so kind and compassionate that they are unhappy to see all the misery of this material world. Kåñëa is the father of all living entities, and He is very unhappy to see His sons suffer. Kåñëa therefore comes and canvasses: "Why are you captivated by this false, so-called happiness? Give up all of this and surrender to Me. Come to Me, and I will relieve you. You will then live happily, eternally and blissfully. You will not have any want, nor will you be troubled by anything." For this reason Kåñëa comes. Actually He has no other business to carry out here because His agent prakåti does everything. Nonetheless, out of compassion Kåñëa comes in His original form or in an incarnation like Kapiladeva. Kåñëa also sends His representative, who says, "You rascal! Simply take shelter of Kåñëa and be happy."

Kåñëa comes once in a day of Brahmä, and His incarnations also come, to educate foolish people who think that they are living happily on this earth. Kapiladeva comes to propound this Säìkhya philosophy, which is unalloyed devotion to the Lord. Herein Kapiladeva says that one is condemned to death unless he takes shelter of the Lord. There is no other way to be saved. We are all in a very fearful situation, but we do not understand this. Under the spell of mäyä, we are thinking we are very happy, but this is not a fact. If we want relief from our dangerous situation, we have to surrender to the Supreme Personality of Godhead and revive our old connection with Him. What is that connection? We are all His eternal servants. We should not foolishly think that we can become one with God or equal to God. This is all the result of rascaldom. The beginning of knowledge is to understand that we are the eternal sons and servants of Kåñëa. There is no difference between a son and a servant. The son serves the father, just as the servant serves the master. There is affection between master and servant and son and father. The father also serves the son in so many ways; therefore the relationship is reciprocal. Caitanya Mahäprabhu has defined our original svarüpa, our original identity, as that of eternal servant. People are artificially thinking, "I am independent. I am no one's servant. I have become God. I have become Bhagavän. I am this, or I am that."

In the material world, it is not very pleasant to be a servant of anyone. We think that being God's servant is like this because we are materially infected. We are thinking that being a servant of God is like being a servant of some man, but in the spiritual world the servant and the served are the same. For instance, the guru is the servant of Kåñëa, but he is accepted as Kåñëa.

säkñäd dharitvena samasta-çästrair
uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù
kintu prabhor yaù priya eva tasya
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

"The spiritual master is to be honored as much as the Supreme Lord because he is the most confidential servitor of the Lord. This is acknowledged in all revealed scriptures and followed by all authorities. Therefore I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master, who is a bona fide representative of Çré Hari [Kåñëa]." (Gurv-añöaka 7) This is the verdict of all çästras. The guru never says, "I am Kåñëa, I am God, I am Bhagavän." Rather, the guru says, "I am the most humble servant of the servant of the servant of God." He does not even say that he is the direct servant. Rather, he is the servant one hundred times removed. Gopé-bhartuù pada-kamalayor däsa-däsänudäsa. We should not try to become direct servants, for that is not possible. First of all we must become the servant of the servant. The guru is the servant of Kåñëa, and if we become his servant, we become an actual bona fide servant. That is our real position. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu prays:

ayi nanda-tanuja kiìkaraà
patitaà mäà viñame bhavämbudhau

"O son of Nanda Mahäräja, I am Your eternal servant, but somehow or other I have fallen into this ocean of birth and death." (Çikñäñöaka 5) Caitanya Mahäprabhu addresses the Supreme Lord Kåñëa as the son of Nanda Mahäräja. Kåñëa is very pleased if one addresses Him as the son of Vasudeva, Yaçodä or Mahäräja Nanda. Kåñëa likes to be named in relation to His pure devotees. Therefore He is called Yaçodä-nandana, Nanda-nandana, Vasudeva-nandana, Rädhikä-ramaëa and so on. Thus Caitanya Mahäprabhu addresses Kåñëa in this way. He says that although He is Kåñëa's eternal servant, somehow He has fallen into the ocean of birth and death, accepting one body after another, dying and being born again, not only in this planet but throughout the whole universe, in many species of life. This is the situation with conditioned living entities, wandering from one life to another and from one planet to another for millions upon millions of years. We do not care about this because we say that we are brave and not afraid. We are very proud in this way, but this is a fool's pride. It is said, Fools rush in where angels fear to tread. In order to save ourselves from this fearful situation, we must take shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. That is the verdict of all the çästras, and Kåñëa comes for this purpose and sends His devotees, who work day and night to propagate this Kåñëa consciousness movement.

TLK Vs 42

TEXT 42

mad-bhayäd väti väto 'yaà
süryas tapati mad-bhayät
varñaténdro dahaty agnir
måtyuç carati mad-bhayät

TRANSLATION

It is because of My supremacy that the wind blows, out of fear of Me; the sun shines out of fear of Me, and the lord of the clouds, Indra, sends forth showers out of fear of Me. Fire burns out of fear of Me, and death goes about taking its toll out of fear of Me.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.42]

PURPORT

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, says in Bhagavad-gétä that the natural laws are perfect because of His superintendence. No one should think that nature is working automatically, without superintendence. The Vedic literature says that the clouds are controlled by the demigod Indra, heat is distributed by the sun-god, the soothing moonlight is distributed by Candra and the air is blowing under the arrangement of the demigod Väyu. But above all these demigods is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the chief living entity. Nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm. The demigods are also ordinary living entities, but due to their faithfulness—their devotional service—they have been promoted to such posts. These different demigods, or directors, such as Candra, Varuëa and Väyu, are called adhikäri-devatä. The demigods are departmental heads. The government of the Supreme Lord consists not only of one planet or two or three; there are millions of planets and millions of universes. The Supreme Personality of Godhead has a huge government, and He requires assistants. The demigods are considered His bodily limbs. These are described in Vedic literature. The sun-god, moon-god, fire-god and air-god are working under the direction of the Supreme Lord. It is confirmed in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.10), mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram. The natural laws are being conducted under His superintendence. Because He is in the background, everything is being performed punctually and regularly.

One who has taken shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is completely protected from all other influences. He no longer serves or is obliged to anyone else. Of course he is not disobedient to anyone, but his full power of thought is absorbed in the service of the Lord. The statements by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kapila, that under His direction the air is blowing, the fire is burning, the sun is giving heat, etc., are not sentimental. The impersonalist may say that the Bhägavatam devotees create and imagine someone as the Supreme Personality of Godhead and assign qualifications to Him; but actually it is neither imagination nor an imposition of artificial power in the name of Godhead. In the Vedas it is said, bhéñäsmäd vätaù pavate/ bhéñodeti süryaù: "Out of fear of the Supreme Lord, the wind-god and the sun-god are acting." Bhéñäsmäd agniç candraç ca/ måtyur dhävati païcamaù: "Agni, Indra and Måtyu are also acting under His direction." These are the statements of the Vedas.

If the demigods are subject to fear, what of ordinary living entities? Material life is not very happy because we are always fearful of something. No one can say, "I am not afraid of anything." Everyone is afraid of something. There is not a bird, beast, human being or living entity alive that is not afraid of something. This is because we are absorbed in the bodily conception, thinking, "I am this body." Since everyone is thinking in this way, everyone fears bodily destruction. When there was an earthquake in Los Angeles, everyone ran out their houses screaming. Everyone was terrified, thinking, "Now death is coming!" This is material nature. There are many events in nature that cause fear. There are great cyclones and tornadoes. There is excessive heat and excessive rain. There is flood and famine and war. Yet people are thinking of being happy on this planet.

Modern scientists say that there are no demigods and that there is no God, that all events are being carried out by nature. It is true that nature is working, but nature, after all, is nothing but matter. Matter cannot work without being directed by a living being. We cannot say that matter works independently. In the ocean we always see that there are great waves moving. Water is dull matter, but the air is pushing these great waves and dashing them onto the earth. Scientists say that nature works in this way and that, but nature is not independent. We receive information from authoritative çästras that nature is moving under the direction of the demigods. So we cannot say that these processes are automatically taking place. Scientists admit that nature is working in a wonderful way, but, after all, nature is not under their control. The scientists may accept or defy Kåñëa, but they cannot defy the activities of nature. Everyone is subordinate to nature. Nature, however, is working under the direction of God; therefore everyone is subordinate to God.

The sun, oceans, land, space and everything else in material creation are but manifestations of Kåñëa's external energy. Nothing is independent of Kåñëa or His energy. In Brahma-saàhitä (5.44) it is said that material nature is so powerful that it can create, maintain and destroy in itself: Såñöi-sthiti-pralaya-sädhana-çaktir ekä. However, material nature is working just like a shadow. If we place our hand before a light, we can see its shadow move on a wall. Similarly, material nature is working due to the touch of spirit soul. It is not possible for an automobile to drive itself. A person, a spirit soul, must be within to push certain buttons. Due to the touch of the spirit soul, the machine is moving. The entire universe is similarly moving due to the touch of God. According to the çästras, the wind is blowing, the water is moving, the sun is shining and the earth is revolving under the direction of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. If the directors of the different material elements do not work properly, they are punished by their master, Kåñëa.

When Kåñëa was present on this earth, He saw that Lord Indra, the lord of the heavens and of rain, was somewhat puffed up. Kåñëa therefore advised His father Nanda Mahäräja not to bother worshiping Indra. He told His father, "There is no need to offer sacrifices to Indra. It is better to worship Govardhana Hill, which is the representative of God. The cows receive their grass and grains from Govardhana Hill; therefore it is better to worship it." At first, Nanda Mahäräja was not willing to do this, but out of affection for Kåñëa, he finally agreed. When Indra saw that Nanda Mahäräja was worshiping Govardhana Hill, he became very angry and sent vicious clouds to inundate all of Våndävana with a flood. Kåñëa then showed Indra that his power was not even competent to deal with the little finger of His left hand. Therefore Kåñëa lifted Govardhana Hill with the small finger of His left hand and used it as an umbrella to save all the people of Våndävana from Indra's torrents. All of this is related in Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

Thus everyone is a servant. No one can actually claim to be master. If we simply take shelter of Kåñëa, we do not have to offer sacrifices to various demigods. If we water the root of a tree, we do not have to water the branches, twigs, flowers or fruits. If we supply food to the stomach, we do not have to feed the eyes, hands and legs separately. Similarly, if we worship Kåñëa, the source of everything, no other worship is necessary.

Large amounts of wealth are necessary to perform sacrifices. In former ages, tons of food were offered in a fire as a sacrifice, but this is not possible in this age. Therefore saìkértana-yajïa, the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, is recommended. Anyone can chant Hare Kåñëa. There is no need for instruments, although Caitanya Mahäprabhu introduced the mådaìga (drum) and karatälas (cymbals). Otherwise, clapping in itself is sufficient. Anyone can sit down with his family, clap hands and chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. This saìkértana is very easy to perform. In the evening people go to restaurants and cinemas and waste time and money at clubs and dances. They are not aware of the fearful situation of birth, old age, disease and death. People are carried away by the waves of material nature, and they have submitted to its laws. We should not waste our time in this valuable human form but should begin to solve our problems.

Eventually everything on this earth will be annihilated. At present, three fourths of this earth is covered with water. In the beginning, the entire earth was covered with water, but gradually the water is drying up, and more land is emerging. Since the land has emerged, we have calculated that this is the Asian continent, this is North America, South America, Africa and so on. Eventually there will be no water but only land, and this means that there will ultimately be destruction. Since there will be no water, the heat will be scorching, and eventually the earth will be burned to ashes. Then again there will be rainfall, and everything will be mixed up again, and again there will be destruction. In this way things come into existence and are dissolved. Similarly, this body comes into existence, takes a nice form, and then is finally finished forever. We will then have to get another body. The body is like a bubble. It is present for one moment, then it bursts and is gone forever.

We simply take on one bubble after another, one body after another, and we think that we will become happy in this way because we are so foolish. Kåñëa comes as a person like us, but we are such rascals that we think He is simply a man, and this is our misfortune. If we just surrender unto Kåñëa, we will no longer be subjected to the karma of different bodies. Even if we attempt to render some devotional service to Him and fall down, we lose nothing and gain everything. A human life is guaranteed in our next birth. It is therefore to our benefit to accept Kåñëa.

TLK 18: Devotional Service: The Final Perfection

CHAPTER EIGHTEEN
Devotional Service: The Final Perfection

TLK Vs 43

TEXT 43

jïäna-vairägya-yuktena
bhakti-yogena yoginaù
kñemäya päda-mülaà me
praviçanty akuto-bhayam

TRANSLATION

The yogés, equipped with transcendental knowledge and renunciation and engaged in devotional service for their eternal benefit, take shelter at My lotus feet, and since I am the Lord, they are thus eligible to enter into the kingdom of Godhead without fear.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.43]

PURPORT

One who wants to be liberated from the entanglement of this material world and go back home, back to Godhead, is actually a mystic yogé. The words explicitly used here are yuktena bhakti-yogena. Those yogés, or mystics, who engage in devotional service are first-class yogés. They are described in Bhagavad-gétä as constantly thinking of the Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. These yogés are not without knowledge and renunciation. To become a bhakti-yogé means to automatically attain knowledge and renunciation. That is the consequent result of bhakti-yoga. In the Bhägavatam, First Canto, Second Chapter, it is also confirmed that one who engages in devotional service of Väsudeva, Kåñëa, has complete transcendental knowledge and renunciation, and there is no further explanation for these attainments. Ahaituké—without reason, they come. Even if a person is completely illiterate, the transcendental knowledge of the scriptures is revealed unto him because of his devotion. To anyone who has full faith in the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the spiritual master, all the import of the Vedic literatures is revealed. One doesn't have to seek separately; the yogés who engage in devotional service are full in knowledge and renunciation. If there is a lack of knowledge and renunciation, it is to be understood that one is not engaged in full devotional service. The conclusion is that one cannot be sure of entrance into the spiritual realm—in either the impersonal brahmajyoti effulgence of the Lord or the Vaikuëöha planets within that Brahman effulgence—unless he is surrendered unto the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord. The surrendered souls are called akuto-bhaya. They are doubtless and fearless, and their entrance into the spiritual kingdom is guaranteed.

Devotional service is most important because there is danger in every step in this material world. At any moment, our life can be finished. We may be walking along very nicely, but at some moment we may slip and break our neck; therefore this planet is called Martyaloka, the planet of death, the place where death is a certainty. Regardless of how strong or healthy one may be, one cannot avoid death. One may exercise on the beach daily, but one may die at any moment. There is no guarantee. Everyone wants health and security, but actually there is no security. There is simply a struggle for existence. People are struggling for security, but in reality this is all foolishness. People are always fearful because they have forgotten or rejected Kåñëa. We have forgotten that we are Kåñëa's eternal servants, His eternal parts and parcels, and that we have a most intimate relationship with Him. In the material world we are situated in asat, a nonpermanent situation. When a child has lost his father and mother, he is always in a fearful condition. He cries in the street, "Where is my father? Where is my mother?" If we no longer want to be in such a fearful condition, we have to take shelter at the lotus feet of Kåñëa. Kåñëa is begging us to come to Him because we are all His sons. He says, "You are rotting here by repeatedly committing sins. You are changing from one body to another, and you are thinking that you are a human being, an American, this or that. The next moment you may become a dog or an insect." People are always thinking that they are secure, and this is called mäyä, illusion.

Knowledge, jïäna, means understanding our relationship with Kåñëa. A wise man asks, "What is my duty to Kåñëa?" Once we understand our relationship with Kåñëa and our duty to Him, we naturally become reluctant to engage in material activities. This is called vairägya, detachment from material activities. Jïäna and vairägya can be awakened by bhakti-yoga. Bhakti means surrender unto Kåñëa. Without surrendering to Kåñëa, we cannot understand our situation. Kåñëa reserves the right of not being exposed to fools and rascals. He is simply meant for the devotees. We cannot understand Kåñëa without becoming devotees.

Material life means sex. People work hard all day in order to have a little sex at night. In the material world everyone is suffering from the sharp arrow of Cupid. Madana, Cupid, shoots his arrow into men and women to make them mad after one another; however, when one actually sees Kåñëa, he sees Madana-mohana, the charmer of Cupid. Then one is no longer pierced by Cupid's arrow. This means that one actually becomes fearless. One can then enter into bhakti-yoga and renounce this material world. According to the çästras, there is çreyas and preyas. Çreyas is the ultimate goal. We should act in such a way that ultimately we will become happy. However, if we want immediate happiness and disregard the future, we want preyas. Preyas is for unintelligent people and children. A child enjoys playing all day; he does not want to be sent to school to be educated. Education is çreyas, the ultimate goal. No one is interested in this. The çästras instruct us to aim for çreyas and not be captivated by preyas. The supreme çreyas is bhakti-yoga.

In the material world we are struggling for existence with the hope that someday in the future we will be happy. Yet we are bewildered. An animal in the desert sees a mirage, a shadow of water, and he runs after this shadow again and again. He runs further and further, and in this way, as he crosses the hot sands, he becomes more and more thirsty and he finally dies. Our struggle for existence is like this. We are thinking, "Let me go a little further. There will be water eventually. There will eventually be happiness." Yet there is no water in the desert. Those who are unintelligent, who are like animals, seek happiness in the desert of the material world. This false attachment has to be given up by the process of bhakti-yoga. This must be taken up very seriously, not artificially. Kåñëa in all seriousness wants to see whether one has finished all his material desires. When Kåñëa sees this, He is very pleased. We are actually busy with dharma, artha, käma and mokña, but when we transcend these, bhakti begins.

If we study the history of the world, we see that it is simply a history of struggle. Mankind attempts to relieve its miserable condition, but it simply brings about another miserable condition. As we try to overcome one problem, another problem arises. Our determination to renounce our association with this material world is called mukti. Mukti means coming to the spiritual platform. Since we belong to the spiritual atmosphere, it is impossible for us to be happy in the material atmosphere. If a land animal is placed in water, he will simply struggle for existence, despite being an expert swimmer. We have come into this material world to gratify our senses, but our attempts will never be successful. If we actually want to attain a state beyond fear, we have to accept this bhakti-yoga process enunciated by Lord Kapiladeva.

TLK Vs 44

TEXT 44

etävän eva loke 'smin
puàsäà niùçreyasodayaù
tévreëa bhakti-yogena
mano mayy arpitaà sthiram

TRANSLATION

Therefore persons whose minds are fixed on the Lord engage in the intensive practice of devotional service. That is the only means to attain the final perfection of life.

[Çrémad-Bhägavatam 3.25.44]

PURPORT

Here the words mano mayy arpitam, which mean "the mind being fixed on Me," are significant. One should fix his mind on the lotus feet of Kåñëa or His incarnation. To be fixed steadily in that freedom is the way of liberation. Ambaréña Mahäräja is an example. He fixed his mind on the lotus feet of the Lord, he spoke only on the pastimes of the Lord, he smelled only the flowers and tulasé offered to the Lord, he walked only to the temple of the Lord, he engaged his hands in cleansing the temple, he engaged his tongue in tasting the foodstuff offered to the Lord, and he engaged his ears in hearing the great pastimes of the Lord. In this way all his senses were engaged. First of all, the mind should be engaged at the lotus feet of the Lord, very steadily and naturally. Because the mind is the master of the senses, when the mind is engaged, all the senses are engaged. That is bhakti-yoga. Yoga means controlling the senses. The senses cannot be controlled in the proper sense of the term; they are always agitated. This is true also with a child—how long can he be forced to sit down silently? It is not possible. Even Arjuna said, caïcalaà hi manaù kåñëa: "The mind is always agitated." The best course is to fix the mind on the lotus feet of the Lord. Mano mayy arpitaà sthiram. If one seriously engages in Kåñëa consciousness, that is the highest perfectional stage. All Kåñëa conscious activities are on the highest perfectional level of human life.

This verse marks the conclusion of bhakti-yoga, as described by Lord Kapiladeva to His mother. Bhakti-yoga is the business of one advanced in jïäna-vairägya, knowledge and renunciation. Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya has explained bhakti-yoga as vairägya-vidyä-nija-bhakti-yoga. Bhakti-yoga begins when we accept Kåñëa's instructions:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja

"Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me." (Bg. 18.66)

We have to renounce all material engagements and accept the lotus feet of Kåñëa. We are making one plan after another to be happy in this material world, but this place is certified by the Supreme Personality of Godhead as duùkhälayam açäçvatam, a place of misery. This material world is actually meant for misery, just as a prison house is meant for punishment. Once we attain our constitutional position of brahma-bhüta, we can enter the kingdom of God, the spiritual world. By karma-yoga we attempt to get out of the gross body, and by jïäna-yoga we attempt to get out of the subtle body, but by bhakti-yoga we can directly transcend both the subtle body (mind, intelligence and ego) and the gross material body. Then we can be situated on the spiritual platform in our original, spiritual body. As long as we are in the subtle and gross bodies, we are suffering under the three modes of material nature. Once we enter into the devotional service of the Lord, we are immediately situated on the platform of brahma-bhüta. Ahaà brahmäsmi ("I am Brahman") is simply theoretical knowledge, but when one actually renders devotional service, one is situated in practical knowledge. Then one is no longer on the material platform but on the Brahman platform.

Prahläda Mahäräja rendered the best service to his father, Hiraëyakaçipu, by having him killed by Lord Nåsiàha-deva. Superficially it appeared that Prahläda Mahäräja did not help his father, but this was not the case. In the çästras it is said that if a person, even though a demon, is killed by God, he is immediately liberated. Prahläda Mahäräja was thinking, "My father is so sinful and so much opposed to God consciousness that he might not be liberated." After Lord Nåsiàha killed Hiraëyakaçipu, Prahläda Mahäräja told the Lord, "My dear Lord, may I ask one thing from You? My father was a great atheist, and he committed many offenses at Your lotus feet. Now You have killed him. I request that he be excused and be given liberation." Actually Hiraëyakaçipu was already liberated, yet his affectionate son was anxious to know whether he was liberated or not. It is confirmed by the Lord that not only does a Vaiñëava's father, but everyone for twenty-one generations before a Vaiñëava receives liberation. Thus by serving the Lord, one renders the best service to his family, because twenty-one generations are liberated if one becomes a pure Vaiñëava.

The yogé's real business is to focus his mind on Kåñëa. That is the real yoga system. There are many gymnastics performed by yogés, but all this is recommended for those who are overly concerned with the body. Rendering service to Kåñëa twenty-four hours daily is called bhakti-yoga, and that is real samädhi. People are working hard day and night to enjoy some results. A person in bhakti-yoga works hard day and night but offers the results to Kåñëa. There is a great difference between a bhakti-yogé and an ordinary karmé. Ordinary karmés cannot understand that the bhaktas are on the transcendental platform.

As we have stated before, there are innumerable forms of God—Räma, Nåsiàha, Varäha, Kåñëa, Kapiladeva, Balaräma and so on. Sometimes foolish people ask, "You are worshiping Kåñëa. Why don't you worship Räma?" Actually there is no difference between Kåñëa and Räma, but everyone has his preference. For instance, Hanumän was particularly devoted to Lord Rämacandra. The gopés are exclusively devoted to Lord Kåñëa. This does not make any real difference. The Lord appears in different forms, but in all cases He is the Lord. Once Kåñëa left the gopés and changed into His four-handed Viñëu form. The gopés went out searching for Kåñëa, and when they saw the four-handed Viñëu form, they did not offer much respect. They simply wanted to see Kåñëa. Actually there is no difference between Kåñëa and Viñëu, but every devotee has a particular inclination. In the Vaiñëava-sampradäya, some devotees worship Rädhä-Kåñëa, and others worship Sétä-Räma and Lakñmé-Näräyaëa. Some also worship Rukmiëé-Kåñëa. All of these are the same, and all of the devotees are Vaiñëavas. Whether one chants Hare Kåñëa or Hare Räma, it is not very important. Worship of the demigods, however, is not recommended. In any case, bhakti-yoga begins with hearing—çravaëaà kértanam. After one has heard from the right source and is convinced, one will automatically perform kértana. Kértana means glorification. Kértana is preaching, glorifying and speaking about the Lord. Parékñit Mahäräja attained perfection simply by listening to Çrémad-Bhägavatam. This is çravaëaà kértanam. Parékñit Mahäräja was listening, and Çukadeva Gosvämé was performing kértana by describing the glories of the Lord. Påthu Mahäräja simply worshiped the Lord, and Lakñmédevé massaged Viñëu's lotus feet. Arjuna made friends with the Lord, and Hanumän carried out the orders of Lord Rämacandra. Bali Mahäräja offered everything he had to the Lord in the form of Vämanadeva, and after he had offered all his possessions, he offered his body. There are many examples, but at the present moment, if we simply hear about Kåñëa, that is sufficient. God has given us ears, and we need only go to a realized soul and hear about Kåñëa from him. This is the process recommended for this age because people are very fallen and are uneducated.

Caitanya Mahäprabhu recommends that we search out a devotee regardless of our position. There is no need to change our position; it is better to remain where we are and simply hear about Kåñëa. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant to give everybody an opportunity to hear about Kåñëa. Kåñëa is within everyone's heart, and as soon as He sees that one is interested in Him, He helps. This is the beginning of bhakti.

Even if we do not understand this philosophy, we will be purified if we hear what Kåñëa says. This is the whole process of hari-saìkértana. One doesn't even have to understand what this Hare Kåñëa is. One only has to hear to be purified. Unless one is purified, one cannot understand God. There are many contaminations within the heart, and the people in this age are engaged in many sinful activities—illicit sex, meat-eating, intoxication and gambling. The whole world is revolving about these things, yet despite this we have to spread this Kåñëa consciousness movement. There may be many obstacles, but they can all be transcended by Kåñëa's mercy. We only have to be determined in our devotion. The rest will follow. This is the essence of Lord Kapila's instructions to His mother.

TLK The Author

The Author

TLK Credits

Credits

“The philosophical and religious works published by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust provide a golden opportunity to Western philosophers, scholars, and people in general to drink deep at the celestial fountain of ancient Indian philosophical and spiritual wisdom.”

Dr. L. S. Varshneya
Chairman, Department of Hindi
Dean, Faculty of Arts
Allahabad University
Allahabad, India

“The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust editions of famous religious classics of India with new translations and commentaries are an important addition to our expanding knowledge of spiritual India."

Dr. John L. Mish
Chief, Oriental Division
New York Public Library

“The books of Srila Prabhupäda are to be treasured. No one of whatever faith or philosophical persuasion who reads these books with an open mind can fail to be both moved and impressed.”

Dr. Garry Gelade
Professor of Psychology
Oxford University

JACKET DESIGNED BY INDRA PRAMADA DASA
ILLUSTRATION BY JAGAT-KARANA DASI

TLK Back Flap

Teachings of Lord Kapila
The Son of Devahüti

LONG AGO, in an age we know about only from the epics of ancient India, the great sage Kapila made His appearance on earth—from the womb of the saintly Devahüti, When her husband left home to seek spiritual perfection in the forest, Devahüti implored her divine son Kapila to lead her to enlightenmentLord Kapila then showed her the way of Säìkhya—the analytical pathway to a higher understanding of the world, the self, and the ultimate source of everything.

Here the world’s most distinguished teacher of Vedic philosophy and religion shows us just how relevant Lord Kapila's ancient teachings are to us today. Through the way ofSäìkhya, as explained in this book, we learn about the qualities of the spiritual master, the science of meditation, the psychology of consciousness, the symptoms of the self-realized person, the secret of transcendental knowledge, and the attainment of supreme liberation.

Teachings of Queen Kunté

TQK Front flap

Front flap

THE TRAGIC and heroic figure of Queen Kunté emerges from an explosive era in the history of ancient India. As the wife of King Päëòu and the mother of five illustrious sons (the Päëòavas), she was a central figure in a complex political drama that fifty centuries ago culminated in the devastating Kurukñetra War.

At the conclusion of the war, Queen Kunté approaches Lord Kåñëa as He prepares to depart from the scene of battle. Although Kunté is Lord Kåñëa's aunt (He incarnated as her brother Vasudeva's son), she perfectly understands His exalted and divine identity as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. She knows full well that He descended from His abode in the spiritual world to rid the earth of demoniac military forces and reestablish peace and righteousness. Thus the prayers she offers Him on this occasion are not the conventional pious solicitations. Rather, they are philosophical reflections, devotional illuminations, even mystical exultations. As such they have been recorded and immortalized in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, India's greatest philosophical and spiritual classic.

Queen Kunté's prayers—the simple and illuminating outpourings of the soul of a great and saintly woman devotee—reveal both the deepest transcendental emotions of the heart and the most profound philosophical and theological penetrations of the intellect. Her words have been recited, chanted, and sung by sages and philosophers in India for thousands of years.

Teachings of Queen Kunté consists of Kunté's celebrated prayers as recorded in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam together with illuminating commentary by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda—Founder-Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, the most renowned Vedic scholar and religious leader of our time and author of more than seventy volumes of translation and commentary on India's ancient Vedic literature.
(continued on back flap)

BOOKS by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda


Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

Srémad Bhägavatam, cantos 1-10 (50 vols.)

Sré Caitanya-caritämrta (17 vols.)

Teachings of Lord Caitanya

The Nectar of Devotion

The Nectar of Instruction

Sré Içopaniñad

Easy Journey to Other Planets

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System

Kåñëa the Supreme Personality of Godhead (3 vols.)

Perfect Questions, Perfect Answers

Dialectical Spiritualism—A Vedic View ofWestern Philosophy

Teachings of Lord Kapila, the Son of Devahüti

Transcendental Teachings of Prahläda Mahäraja

Teachings of Queen Kunté

Kåñëa, the Reservior of Pleasure

The Science of Self-Realization

Life Comes From Life

The Perfection of Yoga

Beyond Birth and Death

On the Way to Kåñëa

Geetär-gan (Bengali)
Vairägya-vidyä (Bengali)
Buddhi-yoga (Bengali)
Bhakti-ratna-bolé (Bengali)

Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge

Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness

Kåñëa Consciousness: The Matchless Gift

Back to Godhead magazine (founder)


A complete catalog is available upon request.


Bhaktivedanta Book Trust
3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90034


THE BHAKTIVEDANTA BOOK TRUST
New York
. Los Angeles . London . Bombay


Readers interested in the subject matter of this book
are invited by the International Society for Krishna Consciousness
to correspond with its Secretary.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness
3764 Watseka Avenue
Los Angeles, California 90034

First Printing, 1978: 57,300 copies

© 1978 Bhaktivedanta Book Trust
All Rights Reserved
Printed in the United States of America

Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data

Bhaktivedanta Swami, A.C., 1896-1977.
Teachings of Queen Kunté.
Bibliography: p.
Includes Index.
BL1132.K8B45 294.5'43 78-20437
ISBN 0-89213-102-0

TQK Introduction

Introduction

The tragic and heroic figure of Queen Kunté emerges from an explosive era in the history of ancient India. As related in the Mahäbhärata, India's grand epic poem of 110,000 couplets, Kunté was the wife of King Päëòu and the mother of five illustrious sons known as the Päëòavas. As such, she was one of the central figures in a complex political drama that culminated fifty centuries ago in the Kurukñetra War, a devastating war of ascendancy that changed the course of world events. The Mahäbhärata describes the prelude to the holocaust as follows:

Päëòu became king because his elder brother Dhåtaräñöra had been born blind, a condition that excluded him from direct succession. Some time after Päëòu ascended to the throne, Dhåtaräñöra married Gändhäré and fathered one hundred sons. This was the ruling family of the Kaurava dynasty, of whom the eldest was the ambitious and cruel Duryodhana.

Meanwhile, Päëòu had taken two wives, Mädré and Kunté. Originally named Påthä, Kunté was the daughter of Çürasena, the chief of the glorious Yadu dynasty. The Mahäbhärata relates that Kunté "was gifted with beauty and character; she rejoiced in the law [dharma] and was great in her vows." She also possessed an unusual benediction. When she was a child, her father Çürasena had given her in adoption to his childless cousin and close friend Kuntibhoja (hence the name "Kunté"). In her stepfather's house, Kunté's duty was to look after the welfare of guests. One day the powerful sage and mystic Durväsä came there and was pleased by Kunté's selfless service. Foreseeing that she would have difficulty conceiving sons, Durväsä gave her the benediction that she could invoke any demigod and by him obtain progeny.

After Kunté married Päëòu, he was placed under a curse that prevented him from begetting children. So he renounced the throne and retired with his wives to the forest. There Kunté's special benediction enabled her to conceive (at her husband's request) three glorious sons. First she invoked Dharma, the demigod of religion. After worshiping him and repeating an invocation Durväsä had taught her, she united with Dharma and, in time, gave birth to a boy. As soon as the child was born, a voice with no visible source said, "This child will be called Yudhiñöhira, and he will be very virtuous. He will be splendid, determined, renounced, and famous throughout the three worlds."

Having been blessed with this virtuous son, Päëòu then asked Kunté for a son of great physical strength. Thus Kunté invoked Väyu, the demigod of the wind, who begot the mighty Bhéma. Upon Bhéma's birth the supernatural voice said, "This child will be the foremost of all strong men."

Thereafter Päëòu consulted with great sages in the forest and then asked Kunté to observe vows of austerity for one full year. At the end of this period Päëòu said to Kunté, "O beautiful one, Indra, the King of heaven, is pleased with you, so invoke him and conceive a son." Kunté then invoked Indra, who came to her and begot Arjuna. As soon as the prince was born, the same celestial voice boomed through the sky: "O Kunté, this child will be as strong as Kärtavérya and Çibi [two powerful kings of Vedic times] and as invincible in battle as Indra himself. He will spread your fame everywhere and acquire many divine weapons." Subsequently, Päëòu's junior wife Mädré bore two sons named Nakula and Sahadeva. These five sons of Päëòu (Yudhiñöhira, Bhéma, Arjuna, Nakula, and Sahadeva) then came to be known as the Päëòavas.

Now, since Päëòu had retired from the throne and gone to the forest, Dhåtaräñöra had temporarily assumed the throne until Päëòu's eldest son Yudhiñöhira came of age. However, long before that time Päëòu died as a result of the curse, and Mädré gave up her life as well by ascending his funeral pyre. That left the five Päëòavas in the care of Queen Kunté.

After Päëòu's death, the sages living in the forest brought the five young princes and Kunté to the Kaurava court at Hastinäpura (near present-day Delhi). In Hastinäpura, the capital city of the kingdom, the five boys were raised in royal style under the guidance of Dhåtaräñöra and the noble Vidura, Päëòu's half brother.

But a smooth transfer of power was not to be. Although Dhåtaräñöra had at first recognized the primogeniture of Yudhiñöhira, he later allowed himself to be used by his eldest son, the power-hungry Duryodhana, who wished to ascend the throne in place of Yudhiñöhira. Driven by uncontrollable jealousy, Duryodhana plotted against the Päëòavas, and with the hesitant approval of the weak Dhåtaräñöra, he inflicted many sufferings upon them. He made several attempts on their lives in Hastinäpura, and then he brought them to a provincial palace and tried to assassinate them by having it set on fire. All the while, the five youthful Päëòavas were accompanied by their courageous mother Kunté, who suffered Duryodhana's atrocities in the company of her beloved sons.

Miraculously, however, Kunté and the Päëòavas repeatedly escaped death, for they were under the loving protection of Lord Kåñëa, who had incarnated to perform His earthly pastimes. Ultimately Duryodhana, a clever politician, cheated the Päëòavas out of their kingdom (and their freedom) in a gambling match. As a result of the match, the Päëòavas, wife Draupadé was abused by the Kauravas, and the Päëòavas themselves were forced to spend thirteen years in exile in the forest—to the great sorrow of Kunté.

When the thirteen-year exile had ended, the Päëòavas returned to Hastinäpura to reclaim their kingdom. But Duryodhana bluntly refused to relinquish it. Then, after some unsuccessful attempts to quell the hostilities, Yudhiñöhira sent Kåñëa Himself to secure the return of the Päëòava kingdom by peaceful means. But even this effort failed—because of Duryodhana's obstinacy—and both sides prepared for battle. To place Yudhiñöhira on the throne—or to oppose him—great warriors from all corners of the earth assembled, setting the scene for what would prove to be a devastating world war.

Fierce fighting raged for eighteen days on the historic plain of Kurukñetra (near Hastinäpura), and in the end all but a handful of the many millions of warriors were dead. Only Lord Kåñëa, the Päëòavas, and a few others survived the massacre. The Kauravas (Duryodhana and his brothers) were devastated. In a desperate gesture of revenge, Açvatthämä, one of the surviving Kauravas, mercilessly murdered the five sons of Draupadé while they were sleeping. Queen Kunté thus suffered a final blow—the loss of her grandchildren.

Arrested and dragged to the Päëòavas' camp like a bound animal, Açvatthämä was let free only by the astounding compassion of Draupadé, the slaughtered boys' mother and Kunté's daughter-in-law, who pleaded for his life. But the shameless Açvatthämä made one more attempt to kill the last heir of the Päëòavas, their unborn grandson in the womb of Uttarä, by hurling the supreme brahmästra weapon. When she saw the missile flying straight at her, Uttarä immediately ran to the shelter of Lord Kåñëa, who was just about to depart for Dvärakä, His majestic capital city. Kåñëa protected the Päëòavas and their mother Kunté from imminent death by stopping the weapon's uncontrollable heat and radiation with His own Sudarçana disc.

Having delivered the Päëòavas from this last calamity, and seeing that all His plans were fulfilled, Lord Kåñëa was again preparing to leave. For years Duryodhana had tormented Queen Kunté's family, but Kåñëa had protected them at every turn—and now He was going away. Kunté was overwhelmed, and she prayed to Kåñëa from the core of her heart.

Kunté was Lord Kåñëa's aunt (He had incarnated as the son of her brother Vasudeva), yet despite this conventional tie with the Lord, she fully understood His exalted and divine identity. She knew full well that He had descended from His abode in the spiritual world to rid the earth of demoniac military powers and reestablish righteousness. Just before the great war, Kåñëa had revealed all this to her son Arjuna in words immortalized in the Bhagavad-gétä (4.7-8):

Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time I incarnate Myself. In order to deliver the pious and annihilate the miscreants, as well as to reestablish the principles of religion, I advent Myself millennium after millennium.

Kåñëa had accomplished His purpose of "annihilating the miscreants" by orchestrating the destruction of the unholy Kauravas. Then He installed Yudhiñöhira on the throne to establish the Päëòava reign, and He consoled the slain warriors' relatives. The scene of the Lord's imminent departure provides the setting for Queen Kunté's exalted prayers.

As Kunté approached the Lord's chariot and began to address Him, her immediate purpose was to persuade Him to remain in Hastinäpura and protect the Päëòava government from reprisals:

O my Lord... are You leaving us today, though we are completely dependent on Your mercy and have no one else to protect us, now when all kings are at enmity with us? (Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.37)

From this supplication we should not mistakenly conclude that Kunté's prayers were self-serving. Although her sufferings were far greater than those any ordinary person could endure, she does not beg relief. On the contrary, she prays to suffer even more, for she reasons that her suffering will increase her devotion to the Lord and bring her ultimate liberation:

My dear Kåñëa, Your Lordship has protected us from the poisoned cake, from a great fire, from cannibals, from the vicious assembly, from sufferings during our exile in the forest, and from the battle where great generals fought.... I wish that all those calamities would happen again and again so that we could see You again and again, for seeing You means that we will no longer see repeated births and deaths. (Bhäg. 1.8.24-25)

Kunté's words—the simple and illuminating outpourings of the soul of a great and saintly woman devotee—reveal both the deepest transcendental emotions of the heart and the most profound philosophical and theological penetrations of the intellect. Her words are words of glorification impelled by a divine love steeped in wisdom:

O Lord of Madhu, as the Ganges forever flows to the sea without hindrance, let my attraction be constantly drawn unto You without being diverted to anyone else. (Bhäg. 1.8.42)

Kunté's spontaneous glorification of Lord Kåñëa and her description of the spiritual path are immortalized in the Mahäbhärata and the Bhägavata Puräëa (Çrémad-Bhägavatam), and they have been recited, chanted, and sung by sages and philosophers for thousands of years.

As they appear in the First Canto of the Bhägavatam, Queen Kunté's celebrated prayers consist of only twenty-six couplets (verses 18 through 43 of the Eighth Chapter), yet they are considered a philosophical, theological, and literary masterpiece. The present book (Teachings of Queen Kunté) includes those inspired verses and illuminating commentary by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, Founder-Äcärya of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness and the most renowned Vedic scholar and spiritual leader of our time. In addition to this commentary (originally written in 1962), Teachings of Queen Kunté contains further explanations that Çréla Prabhupäda gave more recently in an absorbing series of lectures. In those memorable talks, delivered in the spring of 1973 at ISKCON's Western world headquarters in Los Angeles, he analyzed the verses in significantly greater detail and shed even more light upon them.

This new Bhaktivedanta Book Trust publication, complete with eleven color prints of exquisite original oil paintings, will be a prized addition to the libraries of all those who seek a deeper understanding of life's mysteries. Written by a man of profound devotion and erudition, it will provide every reader with firm guidance along the universal path to genuine wisdom and spiritual enlightenment.

—The Publishers

TQK 1: The Original Person

1. The Original Person

kunty uväca
namasye puruñaà tvädyam
éçvaraà prakåteù param
alakñyaà sarva-bhütänäm
antar bahir avasthitam

TRANSLATION

Çrématé Kunté said: O Kåñëa, I offer my obeisances unto You because You are the original personality and are unaffected by the qualities of the material world. You are existing both within and without everything, yet You are invisible to all.

-Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.18

PURPORT

Çrématé Kuntédevé was quite aware that Kåñëa is the original Personality of Godhead, although He was playing the part of her nephew. Such an enlightened lady could not commit a mistake by offering obeisances unto her nephew. Therefore, she addressed Him as the original puruña beyond the material cosmos. Although all living entities are also transcendental, they are neither original nor infallible. The living entities are apt to fall down under the clutches of material nature, but the Lord is never like that. In the Vedas, therefore, He is described as the chief among all living entities (nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm). Then again He is addressed as éçvara, or the controller. The living entities or the demigods like Candra and Sürya are also to some extent éçvara, but none of them is the supreme éçvara, or the ultimate controller. Kåñëa is the parameçvara, or the Supersoul. He is both within and without. Although He was present before Çrématé Kunté as her nephew, He was also within her and everyone else. In the Bhagavad-gétä (15.15) the Lord says, "I am situated in everyone's heart, and only due to Me one remembers, forgets, and is cognizant, etc. Through all the Vedas I am to be known because I am the compiler of the Vedas, and I am the teacher of the Vedänta." Queen Kunté affirms that the Lord, although both within and without all living beings, is still invisible. The Lord is, so to speak, a puzzle for the common man. Queen Kunté experienced personally that Lord Kåñëa was present before her, yet He entered within the womb of Uttarä to save her embryo from the attack of Açvatthämä's brahmästra. Kunté herself was puzzled about whether Çré Kåñëa is all-pervasive or localized. In fact, He is both, but He reserves the right of not being exposed to persons who are not surrendered souls. This checking curtain is called the mäyä energy of the Supreme Lord, and it controls the limited vision of the rebellious soul. It is explained as follows.

TQK 2: Beyond the Senses

2. Beyond the Senses

mäyä-javanikäcchannam
ajïädhokñajam avyayam
na lakñyase müòha-dåçä
nato näöya-dharo yathä

TRANSLATION

Being beyond the range of limited sense perception, You are the eternally irreproachable factor covered by the curtain of deluding energy. You are invisible to the foolish observer, exactly as an actor dressed as a player is not recognized.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.19

PURPORT

In the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Çré Kåñëa affirms that less intelligent persons mistake Him to be an ordinary man like us, and thus they deride Him. The same is confirmed herein by Queen Kunté. The less intelligent persons are those who rebel against the authority of the Lord. Such persons are known as asuras. The asuras cannot recognize the Lord's authority. When the Lord Himself appears among us, as Räma, Nåsiàha, Varäha, or in His original form as Kåñëa, He performs many wonderful acts which are humanly impossible. As we shall find in the Tenth Canto of this great literature, Lord Çré Kåñëa exhibited His humanly impossible activities even from the days of His lying on the lap of His mother. He killed the Pütanä witch, although she smeared her breast with poison just to kill the Lord. The Lord sucked her breast like a natural baby, and He sucked out her very life also. Similarly, He lifted the Govardhana Hill, just as a boy picks up a frog's umbrella, and stood several days continuously just to give protection to the residents of Våndävana. These are some of the superhuman activities of the Lord described in the authoritative Vedic literatures like the Puräëas, Itihäsas (histories), and Upaniñads. He has delivered wonderful instructions in the shape of the Bhagavad-gétä. He has shown marvelous capacities as a hero, as a householder, as a teacher, and as a renouncer. He is accepted as the Supreme Personality of Godhead by such authoritative personalities as Vyäsa, Devala, Asita, Närada, Madhva, Çaìkara, Rämänuja, Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, Jéva Gosvämé, Viçvanätha Cakravarté, Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, and all other authorities of the line. He Himself has declared as much in many places of the authentic literatures. And yet there is a class of men with demoniac mentality who are always reluctant to accept the Lord as the Supreme Absolute Truth. This is partially due to their poor fund of knowledge and partially due to their stubborn obstinacy, which results from various misdeeds in the past and present. Such persons could not recognize Lord Çré Kåñëa even when He was present before them. Another difficulty is that those who depend more on their imperfect senses cannot realize Him as the Supreme Lord. Such persons are like the modern scientist. They want to know everything by their experimental knowledge. But it is not possible to know the Supreme Person by imperfect experimental knowledge. He is described herein as adhokñaja, or beyond the range of experimental knowledge. All our senses are imperfect. We claim to observe everything and anything, but we must admit that we can observe things under certain material conditions only, which are also beyond our control. The Lord is beyond the observation of sense perception. Queen Kunté accepts this deficiency of the conditioned soul, especially of the woman class, who are less intelligent. For the less intelligent there must be such things as temples, mosques, or churches so that they may begin to recognize the authority of the Lord and hear about Him from authorities in such holy places. For the less intelligent, this beginning of spiritual life is essential, and only foolish men decry the establishment of such places of worship, which are required to raise the standard of spiritual attributes for the mass of people. For less intelligent persons, bowing down before the authority of the Lord, as generally done in the temples, mosques, or churches, is as beneficial as it is for the advanced devotees to meditate upon Him by active service.

TQK 3: The Most Intelligent Woman

3. The Most Intelligent Woman

tathä parama-haàsänäà
munénäm amalätmanäm
bhakti-yoga-vidhänärthaà
kathaà paçyema hi striyaù

TRANSLATION

You Yourself descend to propagate the transcendental science of devotional service unto the hearts of the advanced transcendentalists and mental speculators, who are purified by being able to discriminate between matter and spirit. How, then, can we women know You perfectly?

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.20

PURPORT

Even the greatest philosophical speculators cannot have access to the region of the Lord. It is said in the Upaniñads that the Supreme Truth, the Absolute Personality of Godhead, is beyond the range of the thinking power of the greatest philosopher. He is unknowable by great learning or by the greatest brain. He is knowable only by one who has His mercy. Others may go on thinking about Him for years together, yet He is unknowable. This very fact is corroborated by the Queen, who is playing the part of an innocent woman. Women in general are unable to speculate like philosophers, but they are blessed by the Lord because they believe at once in the superiority and almightiness of the Lord, and thus they offer obeisances without reservation. The Lord is so kind that He does not show special favor only to one who is a great philosopher. He knows the sincerity of purpose. For this reason only, women generally assemble in great number in any sort of religious function. In every country and in every sect of religion it appears that the women are more interested than the men. This simplicity of acceptance of the Lord's authority is more effective than showy insincere religious fervor.

Kuntédevé prayed to the Lord very submissively, and this is the symptom of a Vaiñëava. The Lord, Kåñëa, had come to Kuntédevé to offer respect to her by taking the dust of her feet. Because Kåñëa considered Kuntédevé His aunt, He used to touch her feet. But although Kuntédevé, a great devotee, was in such an exalted position, practically on the level of Yaçodämayé, Kåñëa's mother, she was so submissive that she prayed, "Kåñëa, You are meant to be understood by the paramahaàsas, the most advanced transcendentalists, but I am a woman, so how can I see You?"

According to the Vedic system, there are four social divisions (cätur-varëyaà mayä såñöam). The highest members of the social order are the brähmaëas, those who are intelligent, and then come the kñatriyas (military men and administrators), the vaiçyas (farmers and businessmen), and finally the çüdras (ordinary laborers). One's place in this system is determined by one's qualities and work (guëa-karma). The Bhagavad-gétä mentions striyo vaiçyäs tathä çüdräù, and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam speaks of stré-çüdra-dvija-bandhünäm. According to these references women, çüdras, and dvija-bandhus are considered to belong to the same category. The word dvija-bandhu refers to one who is born in an exalted brähmaëa or kñatriya family but who has no qualifications of his own. One's social standing, according to the Vedic system, is determined by one's qualifications. This is very practical. Suppose a man is born the son of a high-court judge. This does not mean that he himself is also a high-court judge. Yet because one happens to take birth in a brähmaëa family, even if he has no qualifications and is rascal number one, he claims to be a brähmaëa, and although his qualifications are less than those of a çüdra, people accept him as a brähmaëa. This has caused the downfall of the Vedic civilization. The brähmaëas in India are sometimes very much against my movement because I train and accept brähmaëas from Europe and America. But we do not care about their arguments, nor will any other reasonable man. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu said [CB Antya 4.126]:

påthivéte äche yata nagarädi gräma
sarvatra pracära haibe mora näma

"In every town, city, and village of the world, the Kåñëa consciousness movement will be preached." How is it, then, that Europeans and Americans will not become brähmaëas? In fact, one who comes to Kåñëa consciousness has already surpassed brähmaëism. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (14.26):

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

"One who takes to bhakti-yoga surpasses the modes of material nature and comes immediately to the transcendental platform [brahma-bhüta]." Not to speak of becoming a brähmaëa, the person who fully engages in bhakti-yoga attains the highest transcendental platform.

The stereotyped, crippled idea that only a person born in a brähmaëa family can become a brähmaëa has killed Vedic civilization, but now we are reviving the correct understanding that the attainment of perfection is meant for everyone. In Bhagavad-gétä (9.32) Lord Kåñëa says:

mäà hi pärtha vyapäçritya
ye 'pi syuù päpa-yonayaù
striyo vaiçyäs tathä çüdräs
te 'pi yänti paräà gatim

"O son of Påthä, those who take shelter in Me—though they be lowborn, women, vaiçyas, or çüdras—can approach the supreme destination." Thus although women, çüdras, and vaiçyas are ordinarily considered to belong to a lower class, when one becomes a devotee he or she goes beyond such designations. Women, çüdras, and vaiçyas are ordinarily regarded as less intelligent, but if one takes to Kåñëa consciousness one is the most intelligent, as stated in the Caitanya-caritämåta (kåñëa yei bhaje sei baòa catura). And Caitanya Mahäprabhu says:

ei rüpe brahmäëòa bhramite kona bhägyavän jéva
guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja

"Among all the living entities wandering throughout the universe, one who is very fortunate receives, by the mercy of the spiritual master and the mercy of Kåñëa, the seed of devotional service." (Cc. Madhya 19.151) The Kåñëa consciousness movement does not consist of wretched, unfortunate men. No. It consists of the most fortunate. One who has taken to Kåñëa consciousness is to be considered the most fortunate because he has found the way to act so that his life will be perfect. One who is Kåñëa conscious and discharging his duties nicely is the most fortunate and the most perfect. This is humbly stated here by Kuntédevé.

Although Kunté had the body of a woman, she was a devotee. Therefore she was not like an ordinary unintelligent woman. Rather, she was the most intelligent, for she recognized Kåñëa to be the Supreme Godhead: "He has come to me to offer me respect, materially appearing to be my nephew, but He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead." Therefore in a previous verse she said, alakñyaà sarva-bhütänäm antar bahir avasthitam: "You are not seen by ordinary men, although You are everywhere, inside and outside." In another verse also she said, na lakñyase müòha-dåçä: [Bhäg. 1.8.19] "Fools and rascals cannot see You." This indicates that Kunté saw Him. Unless she were able to see Kåñëa as He is, how could she say, na lakñyase müòha-dåçä? She also said, prakåteù param: "You are transcendental to this material creation."

Now here also, in this verse, Kunté continues to express herself with humility. This humility is very good in devotional service. Therefore Çré Kåñëa Caitanya Mahäprabhu teaches us, tåëäd api sunécena taror api sahiñëunä: "One should be more tolerant than the tree and humbler than the grass to make progress in spiritual life." This is necessary because for one who is living in this material world there will be so many disturbances, just as if one were traveling on the ocean. One cannot expect a very peaceful situation on the ocean; even a big ship may also be unsteady, and at any moment there may be tumultuous waves. Similarly, in this material world we should always expect danger; one cannot expect a very peaceful life within this material world. The çästra, the Vedic literature, says, padaà padaà yad vipadäm (Bhäg. 10.14.58): at every step there is danger. But if one becomes a devotee, then one can escape (mäyäm etäà taranti te).

If one takes to Kåñëa consciousness, in the beginning there will be many disturbances caused by Mäyä, the material energy of illusion. Mäyä will test us to see how firmly we are fixed in Kåñëa consciousness. Because she is also an agent of Kåñëa, she does not allow anyone the freedom to disturb Kåñëa. Therefore she tests very rigidly to see whether we have taken to Kåñëa consciousness to disturb Kåñëa or are actually serious. That is Mäyä's business. So in the beginning there will be tests by Mäyä, and we shall feel so many disturbances while making progress in Kåñëa consciousness. But if we follow the rules and regulations and chant regularly as prescribed, then we shall remain steady. If we neglect these principles, Mäyä will capture us immediately. Mäyä is always ready. We are in the ocean, and at any moment we may be disturbed. Therefore one who is not disturbed at all is called paramahaàsa.

Kuntédevé therefore says, tathä paramahaàsänäm: [Bhäg. 1.8.20] "You are meant to be understood by the paramahaàsas." The word parama means "ultimate," and haàsa means "swan." So paramahaàsa means "the perfect swan." If we give a swan milk mixed with water, the swan will take the milk and leave aside the water. Similarly, this material world is made of two natures—the inferior nature and the superior nature. The superior nature means spiritual life, and the inferior nature is material life. Thus a person who gives up the material part of this world and takes only the spiritual part is called paramahaàsa.

One should know that the activities of the body are due to the soul within the body. That is the real fact. The body is only the outward covering. Similarly, one should know that Kåñëa is the real center of all activities, and one who knows this is a paramahaàsa. Thus bhakti-yoga is for the paramahaàsa, one who knows that Kåñëa is the central fact. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä, ahaà sarvasya prabhavo mattaù sarvaà pravartate: "I am the source of everything; everything emanates from Me." So one who knows, not only theoretically but practically, that Kåñëa is the cause of all causes—one who is convinced of this—is a paramahaàsa.

Kuntédevé says, "You are meant for the paramahaàsas, not for the rascals and fools. You are meant for the paramahaàsas and munis." The word munénäm refers to those who are thoughtful or to mental speculators, and the word amalätmanäm refers to one who has no dirty things in his heart. The heart of a materialistic person is full of dirty things. What are those dirty things? Lust and greed. All materialistic persons are lusty and greedy, and therefore their hearts are understood to be full of dirty things, but amalätmanäm refers to those who are freed from these two contaminations.

Bhakti-yoga is meant for those whose hearts are cleansed, not for the lusty and greedy. Of course, those who are lusty and greedy may try to advance, and gradually they may do so, but once one is situated in bhakti-yoga there is no more lust or greed. Viraktir anyatra ca (Bhäg. 11.2.42). This is the test—when one is free from lusty desires and greed, then he is situated in bhakti-yoga and is actually a paramahaàsa. Kuntédevé humbly submits, "You are meant for the paramahaàsas and munis, those who are cleansed in heart and are engaged in bhakti-yoga. But what are we? We are simply women. We are in a lower class. How can we understand You?" Although she understands everything, she still takes the position of an ordinary woman and says, "How can I understand You?" This is humility.

TQK 4: Approaching Kåñëa, the All-pervading Truth

4. Approaching Kåñëa, the All-pervading Truth

kåñëäya väsudeväya
devaké-nandanäya ca
nanda-gopa-kumäräya
govindäya namo namaù

TRANSLATION

Let me therefore offer my respectful obeisances unto the Lord, who has become the son of Vasudeva, the pleasure of Devaké, the boy of Nanda and the other cowherd men of Våndävana, and the enlivener of the cows and the senses.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.21

PURPORT

The Lord, being thus unapproachable by any material assets, out of unbounded and causeless mercy descends on the earth as He is in order to show His special mercy upon His unalloyed devotees and to diminish the upsurges of the demoniac persons. Queen Kunté specifically adores the incarnation, or descent, of Lord Kåñëa above all other incarnations because in this particular incarnation He is more approachable. In the Räma incarnation He remained a king's son from His very childhood, but in the incarnation of Kåñëa, although He was the son of a king, He at once left the shelter of His real father and mother (King Vasudeva and Queen Devaké) just after His appearance and went to the lap of Yaçodämayé to play the part of an ordinary cowherd boy in the blessed Vrajabhümi, which is very sanctified because of His childhood pastimes. Therefore Lord Kåñëa is more merciful than Lord Räma. He was undoubtedly very kind to Kunté's brother Vasudeva and the family. Had He not become the son of Vasudeva and Devaké, Queen Kunté could not claim Him to be her nephew and thus address Kåñëa in parental affection. But Nanda and Yaçodä are more fortunate because they could relish the Lord's childhood pastimes, which are more attractive than all other pastimes. There is no parallel to His childhood pastimes as exhibited at Vrajabhümi, which are the replicas of His eternal affairs in the original Kåñëaloka, described as the cintämaëi-dhäma in the Brahma-saàhitä. Lord Çré Kåñëa descended Himself at Vrajabhümi with all His transcendental entourage and paraphernalia. Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu therefore confirmed that no one is as fortunate as the residents of Vrajabhümi, and specifically the cowherd girls, who dedicated their everything for the satisfaction of the Lord. His pastimes with Nanda and Yaçodä and His pastimes with the cowherd men and especially with the cowherd boys and the cows have caused Him to be known as Govinda. Lord Kåñëa as Govinda is more inclined to the brähmaëas and the cows, indicating thereby that human prosperity depends more on these two items, namely brahminical culture and cow protection. Lord Kåñëa is never satisfied where these are lacking.

In the beginning of her prayers, Kuntédevé said, namasye puruñaà tvädyam éçvaraà prakåteù param: [Bhäg. 1.8.18] "I offer my obeisances unto the person, puruña, who is prakåteù param, beyond this material manifestation." Thus in the beginning Kuntédevé gave us the understanding that God is the supreme puruña, the Supreme Person. He is not impersonal. He is a person, but He is not a person of this material world or this material creation, and He does not have a material body. This is to be understood. The poor fund of knowledge held by the impersonalists cannot accommodate how the Supreme Absolute Truth can be a person, because whenever they think of a person they think of a person of this material world. That is their defect. Why should God be a person of this material world? Therefore in the beginning Kuntédevé cleared away this misunderstanding by saying that the Lord is prakåteù param, beyond this material creation. Yet He is a person, and now by the grace of Kunté we can understand that this Supreme Person, although alakñyam, invisible, has now visibly appeared as Kåñëa.

Kuntédevé says, kåñëäya väsudeväya [Bhäg. 1.8.21]. The word väsudeva is sometimes understood to mean "the all-pervading." The impersonalists have this conception of Väsudeva, and therefore Kuntédevé points out, "That Vasudeva, the all-pervading, is Kåñëa." Éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati: Kåñëa, the Supreme Lord, is present in everyone's heart. Thus He is all-pervading.

Kåñëa, the original person, exists in three features: as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, as the all-pervading Paramätmä (the Supersoul), and as the impersonal Brahman effulgence. Those who are interested in bhakti-yoga have no interest in the impersonal Brahman effulgence, which is for common men. If one were an inhabitant of the sun, what interest would he have in the sunshine? That would be most insignificant for him. Similarly, those who are advanced in spiritual life are not interested in the impersonal Brahman effulgence. Rather, they are interested in puruña, the Supreme Person, Väsudeva. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä, this realization of the Supreme Person takes place after many, many births (bahünäà janmanäm ante). The jïänés, the impersonalists, who are attached to the Brahman effulgence, try to understand the Absolute Truth by dint of their knowledge, but they do not know that their knowledge is imperfect and limited whereas Kåñëa, the Absolute Truth, is unlimited. We cannot approach the unlimited by our limited knowledge. That is not possible.

By the grace of devotees like Kuntédevé, we can understand that the all-pervading Absolute Truth, Väsudeva, Paramätmä, is present as Kåñëa (kåñëäya väsudeväya [Bhäg. 1.8.21]). This realization of Väsudeva is not possible for impersonalists very easily. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (7.19):

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

"After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." The word mahätmä means "broadminded." One who cannot understand Kåñëa is not broad-minded but cripple-minded. If one becomes broad-minded, then by the grace of Kåñëa one can understand Kåñëa.

The process of understanding Kåñëa is sevonmukha—by rendering service. Sevonmukhe hi jihvädau. Realization of Väsudeva is possible by rendering service, beginning with the tongue. The tongue has two functions—to vibrate and to taste. So if one repeatedly hears and vibrates the Hare Kåñëa mantra and tastes prasäda, food offered to Kåñëa, by this very simple method one will realize Väsudeva, Kåñëa. Kåñëa will reveal Himself. It is not that by our endeavor alone we can understand Kåñëa, but our endeavor in loving service will make us qualified, and then Kåñëa will reveal Himself (svayam eva sphuraty adaù).

Kåñëa is very much anxious to take us back home, back to Godhead, but we are stubborn and do not wish to go. Therefore He is always looking for the opportunity to take us back home. He is just like an affectionate father. When a son who is a rascal leaves his father and goes loitering in the street, with no food and no shelter, and suffers very much, the father is always anxious to bring the boy back home. Similarly, Kåñëa is the supreme father, and all the living entities within this material world are exactly like misled children of a wealthy man who have left home to loiter in the street. Therefore the greatest benefit one can bestow upon one's fellow human being is to give him Kåñëa consciousness. No kind of material profit will satisfy the living entity, but if he is given Kåñëa consciousness he will actually be satisfied. A bewildered boy loitering in the street may be reminded, "My dear boy, why are you suffering so much? You are the son of a very rich man who has so much property. Why are you loitering in the street?" And if he comes to understand, "Yes, I am the son of this important man. Why shall I loiter in the street?" he may then return home. Therefore the best service is to inform those who have forgotten Kåñëa, "You are part and parcel of Kåñëa. You are the son of Kåñëa, who is full in all opulence. Why are you rotting in this material world?" This is the greatest service. Mäyä, illusion, is very strong, but it is the duty of every devotee of Kåñëa to try to enlighten everyone to Kåñëa consciousness. Kuntédevé, for example, first said that although Kåñëa, the Supreme Person, is within and without, to rascals and fools He is invisible. Therefore she points out, "Here is the Lord—Kåñëa."

Kåñëa is the all-pervading Supreme Personality of Godhead (kåñëäya väsudeväya [Bhäg. 1.8.21]), but He is very much pleased to become the son of Devaké (devaké-nandanäya). Devaké-nandana is also mentioned in the Atharva Veda. Kåñëa comes as Devaké-nandana, and His father is Nanda-gopa, Nanda Mahäräja. Kåñëa likes to be related with His devotees who act as father and mother. Although here in this material world we try to make our relationship with the Supreme by accepting Him as father, Kåñëa wants to become the son. He takes pleasure in becoming the son of a devotee. Ordinary men want God as their father, but that is not very pleasing to Kåñëa because the son always bothers the father: "Give me this, give me this, give me this."

Of course, Kåñëa has immense potencies by which He can supply as much as everyone wants. Eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän. He supplies food to the elephant, and He supplies food to the ant, so why not to the human being? But rascals do not know this. They work like asses day and night to find bread, and if they go to church, there also they pray, "Give me bread." They are concerned only with the bread problem.

Although the living entity is the son of the richest, most opulent person, he has created a bread problem. This is called ignorance. He thinks, "If I do not solve my bread problem, if I do not drive my trucks day and night, how can I live?" This is the nonsense of our modern civilization. Where is there a bread problem? Kåñëa can supply unlimited amounts of bread. There are thousands of elephants in Africa, and Kåñëa supplies food to them. So if He can supply food to the elephants, why not to the human beings? The Bhägavatam therefore says, "Don't waste your time with this bread problem."

tasyaiva hetoù prayateta kovido
na labhyate yad bhramatäm upary adhaù
[Bhäg. 1.5.18]

We should not waste our time with solving economic problems. Economic development is nonsense. Of course, this proposal is very revolutionary, and people may even hate me for it. "What is Swäméjé saying?" they may ask. But actually it is a fact. This economic development is madness. Suppose one has a rich father and enough food. Suppose one knows, "My father is the richest man in the city." Then where is one's economic problem? Actually, that is our position. We have no economic problem. Everything is completely provided. We want water. Just see—there are oceans of water. Of course, we want pure water, and although the ocean has so much water, when water is scarce we shall have to take help from Kåñëa, who will evaporate the water and turn it into clouds, and then when the rain falls down the water will be sweet. Otherwise we cannot drink it.

Everything is under control, and everything—water, light, heat, and so on—is complete.

oà pürëam adaù pürëam idaà
pürëät pürëam udacyate
pürëasya pürëam ädäya
pürëam evävaçiñyate

"The Personality of Godhead is perfect and complete, and because He is completely perfect, all emanations from Him, such as this phenomenal world, are perfectly equipped as complete wholes. Whatever is produced of the complete whole is also complete in itself. Because He is the complete whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance." (Éçopaniñad, Invocation) Kåñëa's stock is never exhausted. We must simply become obedient to Him, and the supply will be there. Therefore a Kåñëa conscious person has no economic problem; everything is sufficiently supplied by Kåñëa. In Los Angeles the neighbors of our temple are sometimes very envious. "You do not work," they say to our Kåñëa conscious devotees. "You have no anxiety. You have four cars. You are eating so nicely. How is that?" Actually, they are right. Somehow or other we are getting everything we need, and we have no problems, for if one simply becomes a sincere servant of Kåñëa, everything is provided. They are envious of us because we do not work but still we have so much. But why don't they come join us? That they will not do. "Come with us," we say. "Chant Hare Kåñëa." "No, no, no. That I cannot do." "All right. Then work with your trucks." By zooming around in their cars and trucks, they have made their own lives dangerous, and they have created danger for others also. At any moment there may be an accident. But they say that this is civilization. Nonsense. This is not civilization. Civilization means calmness, prosperity, and çänti, peace. In peace and prosperity one should be Kåñëa conscious always.

People work so hard, day and night, simply for a little food, not knowing that their food has already been provided. Avidyä-karma-saàjïänyä tåtéyä çaktir iñyate (Viñëu Puräëa 6.7.61). This material world is full of ignorance (avidyä). Therefore our endeavor should be to become free from this ignorance. It is only for this reason that we should work—to come out of ignorance. We are thinking, "I am this material body. I have to work day and night, and then I shall get my food, and I shall live." This is ignorance. We have lived this life of ignorance in forms other than that of a human being. We have lived in bird life, in beast life, and so on, but now, in this life, we should be peaceful, calm, and quiet, and should simply inquire about the Absolute Truth (jévasya tattva-jijïäsä, athäto brahma-jijïäsä). That should be one's occupation.

We are simply sitting down and inquiring about Kåñëa, and this is what one should do. This is life. Why should one work day and night like an ass? What kind of life is this? No. This is not life. Therefore the Bhägavatam says to one who is intelligent (kovida), "Your life should be engaged for this purpose—for understanding the Absolute Truth." Then how will my economic problem be solved? The answer is that happiness one desires from economic development will come automatically in due course of time. Tal labhyate duùkhavad anyataù (Bhäg. 1.5.18). We are looking for happiness. Are you looking for distress? "No, sir." Then why does distress come upon you? If you are not eager for calamities and distress, why do they come upon you? According to our karma, our life holds some portion of happiness and some portion of distress. Therefore, if distress comes without invitation, happiness will also come without invitation.

We are already destined to have a certain amount of happiness and a certain amount of distress, and we cannot change that. The change we should make, therefore, is to get free from this material condition of life. That should be our only business. According to our karma, we are sometimes taking birth in a higher planetary system as demigods and sometimes taking birth as cats and dogs or as germs in stool. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu said:

ei rüpe brahmäëòa bhramite kona bhägyavän jéva
guru-kåñëa-prasäde päya bhakti-latä-béja

"According to their karma, all living entities are wandering throughout the entire universe. Some of them are being elevated to the upper planetary systems, and some are going down into the lower planetary systems. Out of many millions of wandering living entities, one who is very fortunate gets an opportunity to associate with a bona fide spiritual master by the grace of Kåñëa. By the mercy of both Kåñëa and the spiritual master, such a person receives the seed of the creeper of devotional service." (Cc. Madhya 19.151) Only a fortunate living entity gets the opportunity to associate with Kåñëa and Kåñëa's devotee, and in this way he gets the seed of devotional service, the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra, and then his life becomes sublime.

Kuntédevé, therefore, is pointing our attention toward Kåñëa, the Supreme Person, who is alakñya, invisible to all. Who is that invisible person? Here—Kåñëa. "Oh, Kåñëa," one may say. "There are so many Kåñëas." Therefore Kuntédevé says, "I am offering my prayers to Väsudeva, the son of Vasudeva." "There are many Väsudevas." "No. Nanda-gopa-kumäräya: [Bhäg. 1.8.21] I am praying to the foster son of Mahäräja Nanda." In this way, three times she points out, "Here is Kåñëa."

Kåñëa officially takes birth as the son of Devaké and Vasudeva, but in His childhood He enjoys the company of Mother Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja. This is Kåñëa's pastime. A nanda-lélämaya-vigrahäya: Kåñëa's pastimes are all jubilant. Änandamayo 'bhyäsät (Vedänta-sütra 1.1.12): He is by nature full of bliss. We shall never find Kåñëa unhappy. Kåñëa is always happy, and whoever associates with Him is also happy. Therefore He is known as Govinda. The word go means "senses." We are looking for sense gratification, and if we associate with Kåñëa we shall enjoy our senses abundantly, just like the gopés who are dancing with Kåñëa. Thus there is no scarcity of sense gratification, but this sense gratification in association with Kåñëa is not gross sense gratification; rather, it is the spiritual sense gratification enjoyed in the spiritual world. Änanda-cinmaya-sad-ujjvala-vigrahasya. That änanda, or pleasure, is not the third-class änanda we enjoy with our bodily senses. Such bodily enjoyment is not änanda but illusion. We are thinking, "I am enjoying," but that änanda is not factual, because we cannot enjoy this material pleasure of the senses for long. Everyone has experience that this material pleasure comes to an end. Spiritual enjoyment, however, does not end; rather, it increases. That is the difference. Änanda-cinmaya-sad-ujjvala-vigrahasya govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi (Brahma-saàhitä 5.32). Therefore we have to associate with Govinda.

Here also it is said, govindäya namo namaù: "I offer my respectful obeisances to Govinda." The Kåñëa consciousness movement is so sublime that it puts one directly in contact with Govinda. The worship of the Deity of Kåñëa in the temple is also direct contact with Govinda. Çré-vigrahärädhana-nitya-nänä-çåìgära-tan-mandira-märjanädau (Çré-gurv-añöaka 3). The vigraha, the Deity of Kåñëa, appears by Kåñëa's mercy. Because Kåñëa is alakñya, invisible, He becomes visible to give us the facility to see Him. It is not that Kåñëa is stone, wood, or metal. Kåñëa is always Kåñëa, but because we cannot see anything beyond material elements like wood, stone, and metal, He appears in a form made of these elements. But He is neither wood, metal, nor stone. When we associate with the Deity, we associate with Kåñëa personally. Because Kåñëa is invisible, He very kindly takes a form that is visible to us. This is Kåñëa's mercy. Do not think, "Oh, here is a stone Kåñëa." Kåñëa is everything, and therefore Kåñëa is stone also, but He is not the kind of stone that cannot act. Even in the form of stone or metal, Kåñëa can act as Kåñëa, and one who worships the Deity will perceive that. Svayam eva sphuraty adaù. The Deity, although apparently stone, may speak with a devotee. There are many instances in which this has happened.

I am very pleased, therefore, when my disciples nicely dress the Deity, offer the Deity nice foodstuffs, and keep the temple very clean. Çré-mandira-märjanädau. Märjana means "cleansing." Whether one dresses Kåñëa or cleanses the temple, the spiritual benefit one receives is the same. Don't think, "I am only a cleanser, and he is a dresser." No, the person who is dressing the Deity and the person who is cleansing the temple are the same because Kåñëa is absolute. Therefore, one should engage in Kåñëa's service in any way, and one's life will be successful. This is the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

By the grace of Kuntédevé we can understand that Kåñëa, Väsudeva, is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The word väsudeva also indicates that the Lord is understood when one comes to the platform of pure goodness, which is also called vasudeva, or viçuddha-sattva. Sattvaà viçuddhaà vasudeva-çabditam (Bhäg. 4.3.23). To understand the Supreme Lord, we must first come to the platform of sattva, goodness, but goodness here in the material world is sometimes contaminated by the lower qualities ignorance and passion. By hearing about Kåñëa, however, one comes to the platform of pure goodness. Såëvatäà sva-kathäù kåñëaù puëya-çravaëa-kértanaù. We should try to hear and chant about Kåñëa always, twenty-four hours a day, and in this way the dirty things will be cleansed from our hearts. It is not that one should only attend a bhägavata-saptäha, an official reading of Çrémad-Bhägavatam for seven days. That is another form of exploitation. In the Bhägavatam it is said, nañöa-präyesv abhadreñu nityaà bhägavata-sevayä. The word nityam means "daily" or "twenty-four hours a day." One should always read Çrémad-Bhägavatam and carry out the order of one's spiritual master. The word bhägavata may refer either to the spiritual master or to the book Çrémad-Bhägavatam. So one should always serve the person bhägavata or the book Bhägavata. Bhagavaty uttama-çloke bhaktir bhavati naiñöhiké. Then one will be fixed immovably (naiñöhiké) in devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

In this way, one should realize the benefits of the Kåñëa consciousness movement by the prescribed spiritual process and try to distribute these benefits to other people. To awaken the dormant Kåñëa consciousness of others is the greatest welfare activity in the world. We can actually see that devotees who were not Kåñëa conscious four or five years ago have been awakened and are now Kåñëa conscious. Similarly, others can be awakened also. There is no difficulty. The process is the same.

By following in the footsteps of devotees like Kunté, we shall be able to understand Kåñëa's identity. For example, we may ask a person's identity by asking, "What is your father's name?" So Çrémad-Bhägavatam presents God with His father's name, His mother's name, and even His address. We are not impersonalists with a vague idea of God. If one takes advantage of the Kåñëa consciousness movement, one can understand God perfectly and completely.

TQK 5: The Vision of Lotuses

5. The Vision of Lotuses

namaù paìkaja-näbhäya
namaù paìkaja-mäline
namaù paìkaja-neträya
namas te paìkajäìghraye

TRANSLATION

My respectful obeisances are unto You, O Lord, whose abdomen is marked with a depression like a lotus flower, who are always decorated with garlands of lotus flowers, whose glance is as cool as the lotus, and whose feet are engraved with lotuses.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.22

PURPORT

Here are some of the specific symbolical marks on the spiritual body of the Personality of Godhead which distinguishes His body from the bodies of all others. They are all special features of the body of the Lord. The Lord may appear as one of us, but He is always distinct by His specific bodily features. Çrématé Kunté claims herself unfit to see the Lord because of her being a woman. This is claimed because women, çüdras (the laborer class), and the dvija-bandhus, or the wretched descendants of the higher three classes, are unfit by intelligence to understand transcendental subject matter concerning the spiritual name, fame, attributes, forms, etc., of the Supreme Absolute Truth. Such persons, although they are unfit to enter into the spiritual affairs of the Lord, can see Him as the arcä-vigraha, who descends on the material world just to distribute favors to the fallen souls, including the above-mentioned women, çüdras, and dvija-bandhus. Because such fallen souls cannot see anything beyond matter, the Lord condescends to enter into each and every one of the innumerable universes as the Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu, who grows a lotus stem from the lotuslike depression in the center of His transcendental abdomen, and thus Brahmä, the first living being in the universe, is born. Therefore, the Lord is known as the Paìkajanäbhi. The Paìkajanäbhi Lord accepts the arcä-vigraha (His transcendental form) in different elements, namely a form within the mind, a form made of wood, a form made of earth, a form made of metal, a form made of jewels, a form made of paint, a form drawn on sand, etc. All such forms of the Lord are always decorated with garlands of lotus flowers, and there should be a soothing atmosphere in the temple of worship to attract the burning attention of the nondevotees always engaged in material wranglings. The meditators worship a form within the mind. Therefore, the Lord is merciful even to the women, çüdras, and dvija-bandhus, provided they agree to visit the temple and worship the different forms made for them. Such temple visitors are not idolaters, as alleged by some men with a poor fund of knowledge. All the great äcäryas established such temples of worship in all places just to favor the less intelligent, and one should not pose himself as transcending the stage of temple worship while one is actually in the category of the çüdras and the women or less. One should begin to see the Lord from His lotus feet, gradually rising to the thighs, waist, chest, and face. One should not try to look at the face of the Lord without being accustomed to seeing the lotus feet of the Lord. Çrématé Kunté, because of her being the aunt of the Lord, did not begin to see the Lord from the lotus feet because the Lord might feel ashamed, and thus Kuntédevé, just to save a painful situation for the Lord, began to see the Lord just above His lotus feet, i.e., from the waist of the Lord, gradually rising to the face, and then down to the lotus feet. In the round, everything there is in order.

If one sees a lotus flower, one can immediately remember Kåñëa. For example, if one loves one's child and one sees any of the child's garments, or his shoes or a small ship or any of his playthings, one will immediately remember the child: "Oh, these are my child's shoes. These are my child's playthings. This is his garment." This is the nature of love. So if one actually loves God, Kåñëa, one can remember Him always.

It is not difficult to remember Kåñëa. Here Kuntédevé describes Kåñëa with reference to lotus flowers. Similarly, when Kåñëa describes Himself in Bhagavad-gétä, He says, raso 'ham apsu kaunteya: "I am the taste of liquids." So one can remember Kåñëa by tasting water. Even if one is drinking liquor, if he thinks, "The taste of this drink is Kåñëa," he will one day turn out to be a great saintly person. So I can request even drunkards to become Kåñëa conscious, what to speak of others, because Kåñëa says, raso 'ham apsu kaunteya: "I am the taste of liquids." Generally in this context "liquid" is taken to mean water. But liquor is also liquid; it is only sugar and molasses or some other combination fermented and distilled. Of course, it is bad because it creates intoxication. Although in one sense nothing is bad, liquor is bad because it creates bad effects. In America there are many drunkards. There is no scarcity of them. But I may request even the drunkards, "When drinking wine, kindly remember that the taste of this drink is Kåñëa. Just begin in this way, and one day you will become a saintly, Kåñëa conscious person."

So Kåñëa is available under any circumstances, if we want to catch Him. Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (10.10):

teñäà satata-yuktänäm-
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

"To those who are constantly devoted and who worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." If one is actually very serious in searching for Kåñëa, Kåñëa is everywhere. Aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-sthaà govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi (Bs. 5.35). Kåñëa is present within the universe, within our hearts, and even within the atom. So it is not difficult to find Him, but one must know the process by which to do so. This process is very simple, and by the order of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu we are distributing this process to everyone, without charge. The process is to chant Hare Kåñëa. As soon as one chants Hare Kåñëa, one will immediately understand Kåñëa.

Similarly, simply by hearing or chanting the verses of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, one can be purified. Whatever knowledge exists in the world is present in Çrémad-Bhägavatam. It includes literature, poetry, astronomy, philosophy, religion, and love of Godhead. Çrémad-bhägavataà pramäëam amalam. If one simply reads Çrémad-Bhägavatam, he gains the topmost education, for if one studies Çrémad-Bhägavatam he will be well versed in every subject matter. Even if one does not understand a single word of the mantras of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the vibrations themselves have such power that simply by chanting one will be purified. Såëvatäà sva-kathäù kåñëaù puëya-çravaëa-kértanaù. The word puëya means "pious," çravaëa means "hearing," and kértana means "chanting." One who chants or hears the verses of Çrémad-Bhägavatam becomes pious automatically. To become pious one generally has to endeavor a great deal, but if one simply hears the verses of Çrémad-Bhägavatam or Bhagavad-gétä one becomes pious automatically. Therefore it is a rigid principle in every temple of our Kåñëa consciousness movement that there must be a daily class for hearing and chanting. Our movement is meant for training spiritual leaders, but without hearing and chanting it is impossible to become a leader. Of course, in the material world it is possible, but not in the spiritual world.

mälé haïä sei béja kare äropaëa
çravaëa-kértana jale karaye secana
(Cc. Madhya 19.152)

Hearing and chanting waters the seed of devotional service, which develops one's original consciousness.

So here, in these prayers, Kuntédevé, a great devotee, is giving us an opportunity to become Kåñëa conscious simply by concentrating our mind on paìkaja, the lotus flower. Paìka means "mud," and ja means "generate." Although the lotus flower is generated from mud, it is a most important flower, and Kåñëa likes it very much. Kuntédevé therefore describes all the parts of Kåñëa's body with reference to lotus flowers, so that as soon as one sees a lotus flower one will immediately think of Kåñëa: "Oh, Kåñëa's navel is just like a lotus, and from Kåñëa's navel grew the stem of the lotus upon which Brahmä, the creator of this universe, was born. This universe includes so many planets, seas, mountains, and cities with motorcars and other paraphernalia, but the entire universe began from that lotus."

Namaù paìkaja-mäline [Bhäg. 1.8.22]. From Kåñëa comes the wonderful lotus flower that contains the seed of the entire universe. But He is not the source of only one such flower. Kåñëa is not so poor that He simply produces one lotus flower and then is finished. No. Just as there may be a garland with many flowers, Kåñëa is the source of innumerable universes, which may be compared to a big garland of lotuses. This is God. Yasyaika-niçvasita-kälam athävalambya/ jévanti loma-vilajä jagad-aëòa-näthäù (Brahma-saàhitä 5.48). Kåñëa is unlimited. We are very much concerned with this one planet, but Kåñëa's creation contains an unlimited number of planets. We cannot count how many planets there are, any more than one can count how many hairs there are on one's head. This is the nature of Kåñëa's creation. To give another example, on one tree there is an unlimited number of leaves. Similarly, there is an unlimited number of planets, and there are unlimited universes. Therefore, Kåñëa is unlimited.

Kåñëa's navel resembles a lotus, He is garlanded with lotuses, and His eyes are also compared to the petals of a lotus (älola-candraka-lasad-vanamälya-vaàçé, Brahma-saàhitä 5.31). So if we simply think of only this one verse, which describes Kåñëa's body with reference to the lotus, we can meditate our whole life on how beautiful Kåñëa is, how wise Kåñëa is, and how Kåñëa manifests His creation. This is meditation—thinking of Kåñëa. Dhyänävasthita-tad-gatena manasä paçyanti 'yam yoginaù. A yogé is one who always thinks of Kåñëa.

Those who think of something impersonal are not yogés. Their meditation simply involves undergoing more and more labor (kleço 'dhikataras teñäm avyaktäsakta-cetasäm), and they cannot reach anything substantial. Therefore after meditation they say, "Come on, give me a cigarette. Come on, my throat is now dry. Give me a cigarette." That is not meditation. Meditation means thinking of Kåñëa always (satataà cintayanto mäm) and endeavoring to advance in Kåñëa consciousness with a firm vow (yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù).

We have to be purified. Paraà brahma paraà dhäma pavitraà paramaà bhavän. Because Kåñëa is pure, we cannot approach Kåñëa impurely. But if we think of Kåñëa always and meditate upon Kåñëa, then we shall be purified. Puëya-çravaëa-kértanaù [Bhäg. 1.2.17]. That meditation can be possible by hearing and chanting, and then thinking of Kåñëa will automatically come. That is the process of Kåñëa consciousness. Çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù smaraëam [Bhäg. 7.5.23]. The word smaraëam means "remembering." If we chant and hear, then remembrance will automatically come, and then we shall engage in worshiping Kåñëa's lotus feet (sevanam). Then we shall engage in the temple worship (arcanam) and offering prayers (vandanam). We shall engage ourselves as Kåñëa's servants (däsyam), we shall become Kåñëa's friends (sakhyam), and we shall surrender everything to Kåñëa (ätma-nivedanam). This is the process of Kåñëa consciousness.

TQK 6: The Master of the Senses

6. The Master of the Senses

yathä håñékeça khalena devaké
kaàsena ruddhäticiraà çucärpitä
vimocitähaà ca sahätmajä vibho
tvayaiva näthena muhur vipad-gaëät

TRANSLATION

O Håñékeça, master of the senses and Lord of lords, You have released Your mother, Devaké, who was long imprisoned and distressed by the envious King Kaàsa, and me and my children from a series of constant dangers.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.23

PURPORT

Devaké, the mother of Kåñëa and sister of King Kaàsa, was put into prison along with her husband, Vasudeva, because the envious King was afraid of being killed by Devaké's eighth son (Kåñëa). The King killed all the sons of Devaké who were born before Kåñëa, but Kåñëa escaped the danger of child-slaughter because He was transferred to the house of Nanda Mahäräja, Lord Kåñëa's foster father. Kuntédevé, along with her children, was also saved from a series of dangers. But Kuntédevé was shown far more favor because Lord Kåñëa did not save the other children of Devaké, whereas He saved the children of Kuntédevé. This was done because Devaké's husband, Vasudeva, was living, whereas Kuntédevé was a widow and there was none to help her except Kåñëa. The conclusion is that Kåñëa bestows more favor upon a devotee who is in greater dangers. Sometimes He puts His pure devotees in such dangers because in that condition of helplessness the devotee becomes more attached to the Lord. The more the attachment is there for the Lord, the more success is there for the devotee.

Devaké, the devotee who became the mother of Kåñëa, was not an ordinary woman. After all, who can become the mother of the Supreme Personality of Godhead? Kåñëa agrees to become the son only of the most advanced devotee. In their previous lives, Devaké and her husband underwent severe austerities, and when Kåñëa therefore appeared before them, wanting to give them a benediction, they told Him that they wanted a son like God. But where can there be another person equal to God? That is not possible. God is asamordhva; that is, no one can be equal to or greater than Him. There cannot be any competition. One cannot say, "I am God, you are God, he is God, we are all God." No. One who says this is a dog, not God, for God is great, and He has no competitor. No one is equal to Him; everyone is lower. Ekale éçvara kåñëa ära saba bhåtya: the only master is Kåñëa, God, and everyone else is His servant, including even great demigods like Brahmä, Viñëu, and Çiva, not to speak of others. Siva-viriïci-nutam. In the çästra, the Vedic scriptures, it is said that Lord Kåñëa is offered respect even by Lord Çiva and Lord Brahmä, the topmost demigods.

Above the human beings there are demigods. As we human beings are above the lower animals, above us there are demigods, the most important of whom are Lord Brahmä and Lord Çiva. Lord Brahmä is the creator of this universe, Lord Çiva is its destroyer, and Lord Viñëu, who is Kåñëa Himself, is its maintainer. For the maintenance of this material world there are three guëas, or modes of material nature—sattva-guëa (the mode of goodness), rajo-guëa (the mode of passion), and tamo-guëa (the mode of ignorance). Lord Viñëu, Lord Brahmä, and Lord Çiva have each taken charge of one of these modes—Lord Viñëu of sattva-guëa, Lord Brahmä of rajo-guëa, and Lord Siva of tamo-guëa. Yet these three controllers are not under the influence of the guëas. Just as the superintendent of a jail is not a prisoner but the controlling officer, so Lord Çiva, Lord Viñëu, and Lord Brahmä control these three guëas and are not under the control of the guëas.

But above all others, the supreme controller is Kåñëa, who is known as Håñékeça. The word håñéka means "senses." We are enjoying our senses, but ultimately the controller of the senses is Kåñëa. Consider my hand, for example. I claim, "This is my hand. I can fight you with a good fist." I am very much proud. But I am not the controller; the controller is Kåñëa, because if He withdraws my hand's power to act, the hand will be paralyzed. Although I claim, "It is my hand, and I shall use it," when it is paralyzed I cannot do anything. Therefore, I should understand that although I possess this hand by the grace of Kåñëa, I am not its controller. This is Kåñëa consciousness.

A sane man will think, "If this hand is ultimately controlled by Kåñëa, then it is meant for Kåñëa." This is a commonsense understanding. I claim, "This is my hand, this is my leg, this is my ear." Even a child will speak this way. If we ask a child, "What is this?" he will say, "It is my hand." But regardless of what we claim, actually it is not our hand; it is given to us. Because I wanted to use my hand in so many ways, Kåñëa has given it to me: "All right, take this hand and use it." So it is a gift from Kåñëa, and therefore a sane man always consciously thinks, "Whatever I have in my possession, beginning with this body and my senses, is actually not mine. I have been given all these possessions to use, and if everything ultimately belongs to Kåñëa, why not use everything for Kåñëa?" This is intelligence, and this is Kåñëa consciousness.

Everyone is part and parcel of Kåñëa (mamaiväàço jéva-loke jéva-bhütaù), and therefore everyone's senses are also Kåñëa's. When we use the senses for Kåñëa's service, we attain the perfection of life. Therefore, håñékeëa håñékeça-sevanaà bhaktir ucyate: when by our senses (håñékeëa) we serve Håñékeça, the real master of the senses, that service is called bhakti. This is a very simple definition of bhakti. Håñékeça-sevanam, not håñéka-sevanam—service to the supreme master of the senses, not to the senses themselves. When we use our senses for sense gratification, we are in mäyä, illusion, but when we use our senses for the gratification of the master of the senses, that service is called bhakti.

In this material world, everyone is generally using his senses for sense gratification. That is mäyä, illusion, and that is the cause of one's bondage. But when one comes to Kåñëa consciousness, when one becomes purified and understands that these senses are actually meant for satisfying Kåñëa, then he is a liberated person (mukta-puruña).

ihä yasya harer däsye
karmaëä manasä girä
nikhiläsv apy avasthäsu
jévan-muktaù sa ucyate
[Brs. 1.2.187]

"A person who acts in the service of Kåñëa with his body, mind, intelligence, and words is a liberated person, even within the material world." One should come to understand, "My senses are meant to serve the master of the senses, Håñékeça." The master of the senses is sitting within everyone's heart. In the Bhagavad-gétä (15.15) the Lord says, sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöo: "I am seated in everyone's heart." Mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca: "And from Me come remembrance, knowledge, and forgetfulness."

Kåñëa is so merciful that if we want to use our senses in a certain way, He will give us the chance to do so. The senses are not ours; they are Kåñëa's, but Kåñëa gives us the opportunity to use them according to our desires. For example, each of us has a tongue, and suppose we want to eat stool. We may say, "Kåñëa, I want to taste stool," and Kåñëa will say, "Yes, take this body of a hog and eat stool." The master is present—Kåñëa. He will give us an appropriate body and remind us, "My dear living entity, you wanted to eat stool. Now you have the proper body in which to do so." Similarly, if one wants to become a demigod, Kåñëa will give one a chance to do that also. There are 8,400,000 forms of life, and if one wants to engage one's senses in a particular type of body, Kåñëa will give one the chance: "Come on. Here is the body you want. Take it." But eventually one will become exasperated by using one's senses. Ultimately one will become senseless. Therefore Kåñëa says, sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja: "Don't act like this. Your senses are meant for serving Me. You are misusing your senses and are therefore being entrapped in different types of bodies. Therefore, to get relief from this tedious business of accepting one body and then giving it up to accept another and again another in continued material existence, just give up this process of sense gratification and surrender unto Me. Then you will be saved." This is Kåñëa consciousness.

At the present moment, our senses are contaminated. I am thinking, "I am American, so my senses should be used for the service of my country, my society, my nation." Or else I am thinking, "I am Indian, and my senses are Indian senses, and therefore they should be used for India." In ignorance, one does not know that the senses belong to Kåñëa. Instead, one thinks that one has American senses, Indian senses, or African senses. This is called mäyä, illusion. In material life, the senses are covered by designations such as " American," "Indian," and " African," but when our senses are no longer contaminated by all these designations (sarvopädhi-vinirmuktam), bhakti begins.

To think "I am an American. Why shall I take to Kåñëa consciousness and worship a Hindu god?" is foolishness. If one thinks, "I am Muhammadan," "I am Christian," or "I am Hindu," one is in illusion. One must purify the senses so that one can understand, "I am a spirit soul, and the supreme spirit soul is Kåñëa. I am part and parcel of Kåñëa, and therefore it is my duty to serve Kåñëa." When one thinks in this way, one immediately becomes free. At that time, one is no longer American, Indian, African, this, or that. At that time, one is Kåñëa-ized, or Kåñëa conscious. That is what is wanted. Therefore Kuntédevé says, "My dear Kåñëa, Håñékeça, You are the master of the senses."

For sense gratification we have fallen into this material condition and are suffering in different varieties of life. Because this is the material world, even Kåñëa's mother was put into suffering. Devaké was so advanced that she became the mother of Kåñëa, but still she was put into difficulties by her own brother, Kaàsa. That is the nature of this material world. The living entities in this world are so jealous that if one's personal interest is hampered, one will immediately be ready to give trouble to others, even to one's nearest relatives.

The word khala means "jealous." This material world is a world of jealousy and envy. I am envious of you, and you are envious of me. The Kåñëa consciousness movement, however, is meant for one who is no longer jealous or envious. By becoming free from jealousy and envy, one becomes a perfect person. Dharmaù projjhita-kaitavo 'tra paramo nirmatsaräëäà satäm (Bhäg. 1.1.2). Those who are jealous and envious are within this material world, and those who are not are in the spiritual world. Therefore, we can test ourselves. If we are jealous or envious of our friends or other associates, we are in the material world, and if we are not jealous we are in the spiritual world. There need be no doubt of whether we are spiritually advanced or not. We can test ourselves. Bhaktiù pareçänubhavo viraktir anyatra ca (Bhäg. 11.2.42). When we eat, we can understand for ourselves whether our hunger is satisfied; we don't have to take a certificate from others. Similarly, we can test for ourselves whether we are in the material world or the spiritual world. If we are jealous or envious, we are in the material world, and if we are not we are in the spiritual world.

If one is not jealous, one can serve Kåñëa very well, because jealousy and envy begin with being jealous of Kåñëa. For example, some philosophers think, "Why should Kåñëa be God? I am also God." This is the beginning of material life—to be envious of Kåñëa. "Why should Kåñëa be the enjoyer?" they think. "I shall also be the enjoyer. Why should Kåñëa enjoy the gopés? I shall become Kåñëa and make a society of gopés and enjoy." This is mäyä. No one but Kåñëa can be the enjoyer. Kåñëa therefore says in Bhagavad-gétä, bhoktäraà yajïa: "I am the only enjoyer." If we supply ingredients for Kåñëa's enjoyment, we attain the perfection of life. But if we want to imitate Kåñëa, thinking, "I shall become God and enjoy like Him," then we are in mäyä. Our natural position is to provide enjoyment for Kåñëa. In the spiritual world, for example, Kåñëa enjoys, and the gopés, the transcendental cowherd girls, supply the ingredients for Kåñëa's enjoyment. This is bhakti.

Bhakti is a relationship between master and servant. The servant's duty is to serve the master, and the master supplies whatever the servant needs.

nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm
eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän
(Kaöha Upaniñad 2.2.13)

The Vedic literature informs us that Kåñëa can supply all the necessities for one's life. There is no scarcity and no economic problem. We simply have to try to serve Kåñëa, and then everything will be complete.

If Kåñëa desires, there may be ample supplies. In America, for example, there is an ample supply of everything needed, although in other countries this is not so. For instance, when I went to Switzerland I saw that everything there is imported. The only thing supplied locally is snow. This is all under Kåñëa's control. If one becomes a devotee, one will be amply supplied with food, and if one does not become a devotee one will be covered with snow. Everything is under Kåñëa's control, so actually there is no scarcity. The only scarcity is a scarcity of Kåñëa consciousness.

Of course, the world is full of dangers. But Kuntédevé says, "Because Devaké is Your devotee, You saved her from the distresses imposed upon her by her envious brother." As soon as Devaké's brother heard that his sister's eighth son would kill him, he was immediately ready to kill Devaké. But Devaké's husband pacified him. It is the duty of a husband to protect his wife, and therefore Devaké's husband said, "My dear brother-in-law, why are you envious of your sister? After all, your sister will not kill you; it is her son who will kill you. That is the problem. So I shall deliver all the sons to you, and then you may do whatever you like with them. Why should you kill this innocent, newly married girl? She is your younger sister, and you should protect her, just as you would protect your daughter. Why should you kill her?" In this way he placated Kaàsa, who believed Vasudeva's word that he would bring all the sons so that if Kaàsa wanted he could kill them. Vasudeva thought, "Let me save the present situation. After all, if Kaàsa later gets a nephew, he may forget this envy." But Kaàsa never forgot. Instead, he kept Devaké and Vasudeva in prison for a long time (aticiram) and killed all their sons. Finally, Kåñëa appeared and saved Vasudeva and Devaké.

Therefore, we must depend on Kåñëa, like Devaké and Kunté. After Kunté became a widow, the envious Dhåtaräñöra was always planning ways to kill her sons, the five Päëòavas. "Because by chance I was born blind," he thought, "I could not inherit the throne of the kingdom, and instead it went to my younger brother. Now he is dead, so at least my sons should get the throne." This is the materialistic propensity. One thinks, "I shall be happy. My sons will be happy. My community will be happy. My nation will be happy." This is extended selfishness. No one is thinking of Kåñëa and how Kåñëa will be happy. Rather, everyone is thinking in terms of his own happiness: "How shall I be happy? How will my children, my community, my society, and my nation be happy?" Everywhere we shall find this. Everyone is struggling for existence, not thinking of how Kåñëa will be happy. Kåñëa consciousness is very sublime. We should try to understand it from Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä and try to engage our senses for the service of the master of the senses (håñékeëa håñékeça-sevanam). Then we shall actually be happy.

TQK 7: Dangerous Encounters

7. Dangerous Encounters

viñän mahägneù puruñäda-darçanäd
asat-sabhäyä vana-väsa-kåcchrataù
mådhe mådhe 'neka-mahärathästrato
drauëy-astrataç cäsma hare 'bhirakñitäù

TRANSLATION

My dear Kåñëa, Your Lordship has protected us from a poisoned cake, from a great fire, from cannibals, from the vicious assembly, from sufferings during our exile in the forest, and from the battle where great generals fought. And now You have saved us from the weapon of Açvatthämä.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.24

PURPORT

The list of dangerous encounters is submitted herein. Devaké was once put into difficulty by her envious brother, otherwise she was well. But Kuntédevé and her sons were put into one difficulty after another for years and years together. They were put into trouble by Duryodhana and his party due to the kingdom, and each and every time the sons of Kunté were saved by the Lord. Once Bhéma was administered poison in a cake, once they were put into the house made of shellac and set afire, and once Draupadé was dragged out, and attempts were made to insult her by stripping her naked in the vicious assembly of the Kurus. The Lord saved Draupadé by supplying an immeasurable length of cloth, and Duryodhana's party failed to see her naked. Similarly, when they were exiled in the forest, Bhéma had to fight with the man-eater demon Hiòimba Räkñasa, but the Lord saved him. So it was not finished there. After all these tribulations, there was the great Battle of Kurukñetra, and Arjuna had to meet such great generals as Droëa, Bhéñma, and Karëa, all powerful fighters. And at last, even when everything was done away with, there was the brahmästra released by the son of Droëäcärya to kill the child within the womb of Uttarä, and so the Lord saved the only surviving descendant of the Kurus, Mahäräja Parékñit.

Here Kunté remembers all the dangers through which she passed before the Päëòavas regained their kingdom. In Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa says, kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati: "My dear Arjuna, you may declare to the world that My devotee is never vanquished." The Päëòavas, the sons of Päëòu, were great devotees of Lord Kåñëa, but because people in the material world are interested in material things, the Päëòavas were put into many dangers. Their materialistic uncle Dhåtaräñöra was always planning to kill them and usurp the kingdom for his own sons. That was his policy from the very beginning.

Once Dhåtaräñöra constructed a house of lac, which was so inflammable that when touched with a match it would immediately burst into fire. Then he told his nephews and his sister-in-law, Kunté, "I've constructed a very nice house, and you should go live there for some time." But Dhåtaräñöra's brother Vidura informed them of Dhåtaräñöra's policy: "He wants you to go to that house so that you may burn to ashes." When Dhåtaräñöra's son Duryodhana understood that Vidura had thus informed the Päëòavas, he was very angry. Such is the nature of politics. Then, although the Päëòavas knew, "Our uncle's plan is to send us into that house and set it afire," they agreed to go there. After all, Dhåtaräñöra was their guardian, and they did not want to be disobedient to the order of a superior. But they dug a tunnel under that house, and when the house was set on fire they escaped.

Another time, when the Päëòavas were at home, Dhåtaräñöra gave them poison cakes, but they escaped from being poisoned. Then puruñäda-darçanät: they met a man-eating demon named Hiòimba Räkñasa, but Bhéma fought with him and killed him.

On another occasion, the Päëòavas were cheated in a game of chess in the royal assembly of the Kurus. Dhåtaräñöra, Bhéñmadeva, Droëäcärya, and other elderly persons were present, and somehow or other Draupadé, the wife of the Päëòavas, was placed as a bet. "Now if you lose," the Kurus told the Päëòavas, "Draupadé will no longer be your wife." So when the Päëòavas lost the game, Karëa and Duùçäsana immediately captured her. "Now you no longer belong to your husbands," they told her. "You are our property. We can deal with you as we like."

Previously, Karëa had been insulted during Draupadé's svayaàvara. In those days a very qualified princess would select her own husband in a ceremony called a svayaàvara. In modern America, of course, any girl may select a husband as she likes, although for a common girl this is actually not very good. But even in those times an uncommon, highly qualified girl who knew how to select a good husband was given the chance to do so. Even this, however, was limited by very strict conditions. Draupadé's father, for example, placed a fish on the ceiling, and he stipulated that in order to qualify to marry his daughter, a prince had to shoot an arrow and pierce the eye of the fish, without directly seeing the fish but seeing only its reflection in a pot of water on the floor. When these conditions were declared, many princes came to compete, for responding to a challenge is a principle for a kñatriya, a heroic leader.

In the assembly for Draupadé's svayaàvara, Karëa was present. Draupadé's real purpose was to accept Arjuna as her husband, but Karëa was there, and she knew that if he competed, Arjuna would not be able to succeed. At that time it was not known that Karëa was a kñatriya. He was born the son of Kunté before her marriage, but that was a secret. Karëa had been maintained by a carpenter, and therefore he was known as a çüdra, a member of the lowest occupational division of society. Draupadé took advantage of this by saying, "In this assembly, only kñatriyas may compete. I do not want any carpenter to come here and take part in the competition." In this way, Karëa was excluded.

Karëa regarded this as a great insult, and therefore when Draupadé was lost in the game, he was the first to come forward. He was Duryodhana's great friend, and he said, "Now we want to see the naked beauty of Draupadé." Present at that meeting were elderly persons like Dhåtaräñöra, Bhéñma, and Droëäcärya, but they did not protest. They did not say, "What is this? You are going to strip a lady naked in this assembly?" Because they did not protest, they are described as asat-sabhäyäù, an assembly of uncultured men. Only an uncultured man wants to see a woman naked, although nowadays that has become fashionable. According to the Vedic culture, a woman is not supposed to be naked before anyone except her husband. Therefore, because these men wanted to see Draupadé naked in that great assembly, they were all rascals. The word sat means "gentle," and asat means "rude." Therefore Kuntédevé prays to Lord Kåñëa, "You saved Draupadé in that assembly of rude men." When the Kurus were taking away Draupadé's sari to see her naked, Kåñëa supplied more and more cloth for the sari, and therefore they could not come to the end of it. Finally, with heaps of cloth stacked in the room, they became tired and realized she would never be naked. They could understand, "It is impossible."

At first, Draupadé had tried to hold on to her sari. But what could she do? After all, she was a woman, and the Kurus were trying to strip her naked. So she cried and prayed to Kåñëa, "Save my honor," but she also tried to save herself by holding on to her sari. Then she thought, "It is impossible to save my honor in this way," and she let go and simply raised her arms and prayed, "Kåñëa, if You like You can save me." Thus the Lord responded to her prayers.

Therefore, it is not very good to try to save oneself. Rather, one should simply depend on Kåñëa: "Kåñëa, if You save me, that is all right. Otherwise, kill me. You may do as You like." As Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says:

mänasa, deha, geha—yo kichu mora
arpiluì tuya pade, nanda-kiçora
[Mänasa Deha Geha 1]

"My dear Lord, whatever I have in my possession I surrender unto You. And what do I have? I have this body and mind, I have a little home and my wife and children, but whatever I have, I surrender everything unto You." This is full surrender.

A devotee of Kåñëa surrenders unto Kåñëa without reservation, and therefore he is called akiïcana. The word kiïcana refers to something one reserves for oneself, and akiïcana means that one does not keep anything for oneself. Of course, although actually one should surrender in this way, in the material world one should not artificially imitate those who are fully surrendered. According to the example set by Rüpa Gosvämé, whatever possessions one has, one should give fifty percent for Kåñëa and twenty-five percent for one's relatives, who will also expect something, and one should keep twenty-five percent for personal emergencies. Before his retirement, Rüpa Gosvämé divided his money in this way, although later, when his brother Sanätana Gosvämé, another great devotee, was arrested, Rüpa Gosvämé spent everything. This is full surrender. Similarly, Draupadé fully surrendered to Kåñëa without trying to save herself, and then unlimited yards of cloth were supplied, and the Kurus could not see her naked.

But then, in the next game of chess, the bet was that if the Päëòavas lost the game they would go to the forest for twelve years. Thereafter they were to remain incognito for one year, and if detected they would have to live in the forest again for another twelve years. This game also the Päëòavas lost, so for twelve years they lived in the forest and for one year incognito. It was while they were living incognito that Arjuna won Uttarä.

These incidents are all recorded in the book known as the Mahäbhärata. The word mahä means "great" or "greater," and bhärata refers to India. Thus the Mahäbhärata is the history of greater India. Sometimes people regard these accounts as stories or mythology, but that is nonsense. The Mahäbhärata and the Puräëas are histories, although they are not chronological. If the history of such a vast period of time was recorded chronologically, how many pages would it have to be? Therefore, only the most important incidents are selected and described in the Mahäbhärata.

Kunté prays to Kåñëa by describing how He saved the Päëòavas on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra. Mådhe mådhe 'neka-mahärathästrataù [Bhäg. 1.8.24]. On the Battlefield of Kurukñetra there were great, great fighters called mahärathas. Just as military men in modern days are given titles like lieutenant, captain, commander, and commander-in-chief, formerly there were titles like eka-ratha, ati-ratha, and mahä-ratha. The word ratha means "chariot." So if a warrior could fight against one chariot, he was called eka-ratha, and if he could fight against thousands of chariots he was called mahä-ratha. All the commanders on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra were mahä-rathas. Many of them are mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä. Bhéñma, Karëa, and Droëäcärya were especially great commanders. They were such powerful fighters that although Arjuna was also a mahä-ratha, before them he was nothing. But by the grace of Kåñëa he was able to kill Karëa, Bhéñma, Droëäcärya, and the others and come out victorious. While speaking with Çukadeva Gosvämé, Mahäräja Parékñit also referred to this. "The Battlefield of Kurukñetra," he said, "was just like an ocean, and the warriors were like many ferocious aquatic animals. But by the grace of Kåñëa, my grandfather Arjuna crossed over this ocean very easily."

This is very significant. We may have many enemies who may be very powerful fighters, but if we remain under the protection of Kåñëa, no one can do us any harm. Rakhe kåñëa märe ke märe kåñëa rakhe ke. "He whom Kåñëa protects, no one can kill, but if Kåñëa wants to kill someone, no one can give him protection." For example, suppose a very rich man is suffering from disease. He may have a first-class physician, medicine, and hospital available for him, but still he may die. This means that Kåñëa desired, "This man must die." Therefore, the so-called protective methods we have devised will be useless if Kåñëa does not desire us to live. The demon Rävaëa was very powerful, but when Kåñëa in the form of Lord Rämacandra desired to kill him, no one could protect him. Rävaëa was a great devotee of Lord Çiva and was praying to Lord Çiva, "Please come save me from this danger." But Lord Çiva did not come. Then Pärvaté, Lord Siva's wife, asked Lord Çiva, "What is this? He is such a great devotee and has served you so much, and now he is in danger and is asking your help. Why are you not going to help him?" Then Lord Çiva replied, "My dear Pärvaté, what shall I do? I cannot give him protection. It is not possible. Why shall I go?" Therefore, if God wants to kill someone, no one can give him protection, and if God wants to protect someone, no one can kill him. Rakhe kåñëa märe ke märe kåñëa rakhe ke.

Thus Kunté is remembering how Kåñëa saved her and her sons one time after another. This is smaraëam, thinking of Kåñëa. "Kåñëa, You are so kind to us that You saved us from many great dangers. Without You there was no hope."

Then the last danger was drauëy-astra, the weapon of Açvatthämä, the son of Droëa. Açvatthämä performed a most abominable act by killing the five sons of the Päëòavas. Of course, in the Battle of Kurukñetra both sides belonged to the same family, and practically everyone was killed, but the five sons of the Päëòavas survived. So Açvatthämä thought, "If I kill these five sons of the Päëòavas and present their heads to Duryodhana, he will be very much pleased." Therefore, when the five sons were sleeping, he severed their heads, which he then presented to Duryodhana. At that time, Duryodhana was incapacitated. His spine was broken, and he could not move. Açvatthämä said, "I have brought the five heads of the Päëòavas, my dear Duryodhana." At first, Duryodhana was very glad, but he knew how to test the heads to see whether they were in fact the heads of the Päëòavas. When he pressed the heads, the heads collapsed, and Duryodhana said, "Oh, these are not the heads of the Päëòavas. They must be the heads of their sons." When Açvatthämä admitted that this was so, Duryodhana fainted, and when he revived he said, "You have killed all our hopes. I had hoped that in our family at least these five sons would survive, but now you have killed them." Thus in lamentation he died.

Subsequently, Arjuna arrested Açvatthämä and was going to kill him. In fact, Kåñëa ordered, "Kill him. He is not a brähmaëa; he is less than a çüdra." But then Draupadé said, "I am suffering because of the death of my sons, and this rascal is the son of our Guru Mahäräja, Droëäcärya, who has done so much for us. If Açvatthämä dies, then Droëäcärya's wife, our mother guru, will be very much unhappy. So release him and let him go away." Thus Arjuna freed Açvatthämä. But then Açvatthämä, having been insulted, retaliated by unleashing a brahmästra. The brahmästra is something like a nuclear weapon. It can go to the enemy, wherever he is, and kill him. Açvatthämä knew, "The last descendant of the Kuru family is Parékñit, the son of Abhimanyu. He is in the womb of Uttarä, so let me kill him also, and then the entire dynasty will be finished."

When that weapon was unleashed, Parékñit Mahäräja's mother, Uttarä, felt that she was going to have a miscarriage, and therefore she approached Kåñëa, saying, "Please save me." Kåñëa, by His mystic power, therefore entered the womb of Uttarä and saved the child. After the Battle of Kurukñetra, Parékñit Mahäräja, who was still in the womb of his mother, was the last remaining descendant of the Päëòavas, and in mature time, when he was born, only his grandfathers were still alive. Parékñit Mahäräja was the son of Abhimanyu, who was the son of Arjuna and Subhadrä, Kåñëa's sister. When Abhimanyu was sixteen years old, he went to fight, and seven great commanders joined forces to kill him. Subhadrä had only one grandchild, Parékñit Mahäräja. As soon as he grew up, the entire estate of the Päëòavas was entrusted to him, and all the Päëòavas left home and went to the Himalayas. This history is described in the Mahäbhärata. Many great misfortunes befell the Päëòavas, but in all circumstances they simply depended on Kåñëa, who always saved them. Queen Kunté's response to these misfortunes is recorded in the next verse.

TQK 8: Let There Be Calamities

8. Let There Be Calamities

vipadaù santu täù çaçvat
tatra tatra jagad-guro
bhavato darçanaà yat syäd
apunar bhava-darçanam

TRANSLATION

I wish that all those calamities would happen again and again so that we could see You again and again, for seeing You means that we will no longer see repeated births and deaths.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.25

PURPORT

Generally, the distressed, the needy, the intelligent, and the inquisitive who have performed some pious activities worship or begin to worship the Lord. Others, who are thriving on misdeeds only, regardless of status, cannot approach the Supreme due to being misled by the illusory energy. Therefore, for a pious person, if there is some calamity there is no other alternative than to take shelter of the lotus feet of the Lord. Constantly remembering the lotus feet of the Lord means preparing for liberation from birth and death. Therefore, even though there are so-called calamities, they are welcome because they give us an opportunity to remember the Lord, which means liberation.

One who has taken shelter of the lotus feet of the Lord, which are accepted as the most suitable boat for crossing the ocean of nescience, can achieve liberation as easily as one leaps over the holes made by the hooves of a calf. Such persons are meant to reside in the abode of the Lord, and they have nothing to do with a place where there is danger in every step.

This material world is certified by the Lord in the Bhagavad-gétä as a dangerous place full of calamities. Less intelligent persons prepare plans to adjust to those calamities, without knowing that the nature of this place is to be full of calamities. They have no information of the abode of the Lord, which is full of bliss and without trace of calamity. The duty of the sane person, therefore, is to be undisturbed by worldly calamities, which are sure to happen in all circumstances. Suffering all sorts of unavoidable misfortunes, one should make progress in spiritual realization, because that is the mission of human life. The spirit soul is transcendental to all material calamities; therefore, the so-called calamities are called false. A man may see a tiger swallowing him in a dream, and he may cry for this calamity. Actually there is no tiger and there is no suffering; it is simply a case of dreams. In the same way, all calamities of life are said to be dreams. If someone is lucky enough to get in contact with the Lord by devotional service, it is all gain. Contact with the Lord by any one of the nine devotional services is always a forward step on the path going back to Godhead.

In this very interesting verse, it is described that vipadaù—calamities or dangers—are very good if such dangers and calamities remind us of Kåñëa.

tat te 'nukampäà susamékñamäëo
bhuïjäna evätma-kåtaà vipäkam
(Bhäg. 10.14.8)

How does a devotee receive dangers? There must be dangers because this material world is full of dangers. But foolish people who do not know this try to avoid the dangers. Thus they struggle for existence. Everyone is trying to become happy and avoid danger. This is our material business. Everyone is trying for ätyantikaà sukham, ultimate happiness. A working man thinks, "Let me work very hard now and put money in the bank, so that when I get old I shall enjoy life without working." This is the inner intention of everyone. No one wants to work; as soon as one gets some money, he wants to retire from work and become happy. But that is not possible. One cannot become happy in that way.

Here Kuntédevé speaks of apunar bhava-darçanam. The prefix a means "not," and punar bhava means "repetition of birth and death." The real danger is the repetition of birth and death. That must be stopped.

The material world is full of dangers (padaà padaà yad vipadäm). For example, if one is on the ocean one may have a very strong ship, but that ship can never be safe; because one is at sea, at any time there may be dangers. The Titanic was safe, but on its first voyage it sank, and many important men lost their lives. So danger there must be, because we are in a dangerous position. This material world itself is dangerous. Therefore, our business now should be to cross over this sea of danger as soon as possible. As long as we are at sea, we are in a dangerous position, however strong our ship may be. That's a fact. But we should not be disturbed by the sea waves; instead, we should just try to cross over the sea and get to the other side. That should be our business.

As long as we are in this material world, there must be calamities because this is the place of calamity. But even with calamities our business should be to develop our Kåñëa consciousness, so that after giving up this body we may go back home, back to Kåñëa.

On the Battlefield of Kurukñetra, Arjuna said to Kåñëa, "Whatever You are saying is all right. I am not this body. I am a soul, and this is also true of everyone else. So when the body is annihilated, the soul will continue to exist. But when I see that my son is dying or my grandfather is dying and that I am killing, how can I be solaced simply by knowing that they are not dying, but that only their bodies are changing? I am accustomed to thinking of them with affection in terms of the body, and so there must be grief and suffering."

Kåñëa did not deny what Arjuna said. "Yes," He replied. "That's a fact. Because you are in the bodily concept of life, there must be suffering. So you must tolerate it, that's all. There is no other remedy." As mentioned in Bhagavad-gétä (2.14), Lord Kåñëa told Arjuna:

mäträ-sparçäs tu kaunteya
çétoñëa-sukha-duùkha-däù
ägamäpäyino 'nityäs
täàs titikñasva bhärata

"O son of Kunté, the nonpermanent appearance of heat and cold, happiness and distress, and their disappearance in due course, are like the appearance and disappearance of winter and summer seasons. They arise from sense perception, O scion of Bharata, and one must learn to tolerate them without being disturbed."

In America it may sometimes be very chilly in the morning, and that may make taking one's morning bath a little difficult. But does that mean that those who are devotees will stop taking their prescribed morning bath? No. Even if it is chilly, they must take this regular bath. The duty must be done, even if there is a little suffering involved. That is called tapasya, or austerity. Tapasya means that we must proceed with our business of Kåñëa consciousness despite all the dangers and calamities of this world. This is called tapasya, or voluntary acceptance of the difficulties of life.

Sometimes those who have undertaken strict vows of tapasya will ignite a ring of fire all around themselves, and in the scorching heat of the sun in the hot summer they will sit down in the midst of that fire and meditate. Similarly, in the chilly cold of winter they will immerse themselves in water up to the neck and meditate. Such vows are prescribed in strict systems of tapasya. But Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu does not give us such a prescription. Instead, He gives us a very nice program: chant, dance, and take prasäda, food offered first to Lord Kåñëa. But still we are unwilling. We are so fallen that we cannot accept even this tapasya. Although this kind of tapasya is very easy to perform and very pleasant (su-sukhaà kartum avyayam), still we are not agreeable. We may even prefer to rot in the street. Some people prefer to drink and have sex and live in the street. So what can be done?

The Kåñëa consciousness movement is giving all facilities so that people may come here, chant, dance, live very peacefully, take kåñëa-prasäda, and be happy, but people will not accept it. That is called misfortune. Caitanya Mahäprabhu, portraying the people of this age, therefore said, "I am so unfortunate that I have no attachment for chanting Hare Kåñëa." Lord Caitanya prayed (Çikñäñöaka 2):

nämnäm akäri bahudhä nija-sarva-çaktis
taträrpitä niyamitaù smaraëe na kälaù
etädåçé tava kåpä bhagavan mamäpi
durdaivam édåçam ihäjani nänurägaù

Kåñëa, the transcendental holy name of God, has all potencies, Lord Caitanya said. Kåñëa has unlimited potencies, and similarly in the holy name of Kåñëa there are unlimited potencies. Kåñëa has thousands and thousands of names, of which the name Kåñëa is the chief, and there are no hard and fast rules for chanting. It is not that one must chant at a certain time. No. At any time one may chant. Furthermore, Kåñëa's name is identical with Kåñëa Himself. Therefore the holy name of Kåñëa is Kåñëa.

We should not think that Kåñëa is living in His abode, Goloka Våndävana, and that His name is different from Him. In the material world, of course, in the material conception, a name is different from the fact it represents. But in the absolute world there are no such differences. The name is as potent as Kåñëa is. We have a tongue, and if we use this tongue to chant Hare Kåñëa, we shall immediately come directly in touch with Kåñëa, because the name Kåñëa and the person Kåñëa are not different. We may think that Kåñëa is far, far away, but in fact Kåñëa is within us. He is far away, but at the same time He is the nearest. But even if we think that Kåñëa is far, far away, His name is present. We can chant Hare Kåñëa, and Kåñëa will immediately become available. Kåñëa is available in this easy way, for which there are no hard and fast rules. We can chant at any time and immediately get Kåñëa. Just see the mercy of Kåñëa!

Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu says, etädåçé tava kåpä bhagavan mamäpi durdaivam édåçam ihäjani nänurägaù: "My dear Lord, You have given me such generous facilities by which to contact You, but I am so unfortunate that I have no attachment for these things. I have attachment for so many other things, but I have no attachment for chanting Hare Kåñëa. This is my misfortune." Kåñëa is so magnanimous that He is present before us by the transcendental vibration of His name, which has all the potencies of Kåñëa Himself, and if we remain in contact with that name we shall get all the benefits of Kåñëa's benedictions. But still we are not inclined to chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra. This is our misfortune.

A devotee, however, is never disturbed by dangers, reverses, or calamities. Rather, he welcomes them. Because he is a surrendered soul, he knows that both dangers and festivals are but different demonstrations of Kåñëa, who is absolute. In the çästra, the Vedic literature, it is said that religion and irreligion, which are complete opposites, are merely the front portion and the back portion of God. But is there any difference between God's front and God's back? God is absolute, and therefore a devotee, either in opulence or in danger, is undisturbed, knowing that both of these are Kåñëa.

When a devotee is in danger, he thinks, "Now Kåñëa has appeared before me as danger." In His form of Nåsiàha-deva, the Lord was dangerous to the demon Hiraëyakaçipu, but the same Nåsiàha-deva was the supreme friend to the devoted Prahläda Mahäräja. God is never dangerous to the devotee, and the devotee is never afraid of dangers, because he is confident that the danger is but another feature of God. "Why should I be afraid?" the devotee thinks. "I am surrendered to Him."

Therefore Kuntédevé says, vipadaù santu: "Let there be calamities." Vipadaù santu täù çaçvat: "Let all those calamities happen again and again." Because she knows how to remember Kåñëa at times of danger, she is welcoming danger. "My dear Lord," she says, "I welcome dangers, because when dangers come I can remember You." When Prahläda Mahäräja's father was putting him into dangerous predicaments, Prahläda was always thinking of Kåñëa. So if we are put into a dangerous position and that danger gives us an impetus to remember Kåñëa, that is welcome: "Oh, I am getting this opportunity to remember Kåñëa." Why is this welcome? It is welcome because seeing Kåñëa or remembering Kåñëa means advancing in spiritual life so that we will not have to suffer any more of these dangers. Tyaktvä dehaà punar janma naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna (Bg. 4.9). If one becomes advanced in Kåñëa consciousness, the result will be that after giving up the body (tyaktvä deham) one will not have to take birth again in this material world (punar janma naiti). This is to be desired.

Suppose I am very comfortable at the present moment. My body may be comfortable, but there will be death, and then another birth. After giving up my present body, if I get the body of a cat or a dog, what is the meaning of my comfortable position? Death is sure, and after death one must surely accept another body. We may not know what kind of body we shall get, but we can know from the çästra, the Vedic literature. The çästra says that according to our particular mentality, we will get a particular kind of body. Although I may be in a comfortable position, if I keep myself in the mentality of a dog, I shall get my next life as a dog. Therefore, what is the value of this comfortable position? I may be in a comfortable position for twenty years, thirty years, fifty years, or at the utmost one hundred years. Yet if, when I give up this body, my mentality causes me to become a cat, a dog, or a mouse, what is the benefit of this comfortable position? But people do not consider this. They think, especially in the present age, "I am now in a comfortable position. I have enough money and a good estate. I have ample comforts and enough food. When this body is finished, I am not going to take birth again, so as long as I am living, let me enjoy life." This is the modern philosophy of hedonism, but it does not correspond to the facts.

Kunté, however, is aware of birth and death, and she is anxious not to repeat this process. This is indicated by the words apunar bhava-darçanam. If one always sees Kåñëa, one is in Kåñëa consciousness, for Kåñëa consciousness means always thinking of Kåñëa. One's consciousness should be absorbed in Kåñëa thought. Therefore the spiritual master gives different varieties of engagements to devotees in Kåñëa consciousness. For example, under the direction of the spiritual master the devotees may sell books in Kåñëa consciousness. But if the devotees think that the energy invested in selling books should be diverted into selling jewelry, that is not a very good idea. Then they would become nothing more than jewelers. We should be very much careful not to be diverted from Kåñëa consciousness. Even if there is danger or suffering in Kåñëa consciousness, we should tolerate it. We should even welcome such danger, and we should pray in appreciation to Kåñëa.

How should we pray? Tat te 'nukampäà susamékñamäëaù: "My dear Lord, it is Your great mercy that I have been put into this dangerous position." That is the viewpoint of a devotee. He doesn't regard danger as danger. Rather, he thinks, "It is Kåñëa's mercy." What kind of mercy? Bhuïjäna evätma-kåtaà vipäkam: "Because of my past activities, I was meant to suffer very much. But You are mitigating that suffering and giving me only a little." In other words, by the grace of Kåñëa a devotee may receive only token punishment.

In court an important man is sometimes found to be a culprit, and the judge may be able to fine him a hundred thousand dollars and know that the man can pay it. But he may tell the man, "You just give one cent." That is also punishment, but it is greatly minimized. Similarly, we have to suffer for our past deeds. That is a fact, and we cannot avoid it. But karmäëi nirdahati kintu ca bhakti-bhäjäm (Brahma-saàhitä 5.54): the sufferings of those who engage in devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness are minimized. For example, one may have been destined to be killed, but instead of being killed with a knife, he may instead get some little cut on his finger. In this way, for those who engage in devotional service, the reactions of past activities are minimized. Lord Kåñëa assures His devotees, ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo mokñayiñyämi: "I shall give you protection from the reactions of sinful life." So even if a devotee has a history of very grievous criminal activities behind him, instead of being killed he may only get a little cut on his finger. Why then should a devotee fear danger?

We should simply depend on Kåñëa consciousness, because if we live Kåñëa consciously under all circumstances, we shall not return to this material world (apunar bhava-darçanam [Bhäg. 1.8.25]). If we repeatedly think of Kåñëa, see Kåñëa, read of Kåñëa, work for Kåñëa, and somehow or other remain in Kåñëa consciousness, we benefit in such a way that we shall be saved from taking birth again in the material world. That is true benefit. But if we become a little comfortable because of other, materialistic engagements and we forget Kåñëa and have to take birth again, then what is our benefit? We should be very careful about this. We should act in such a way that our Kåñëa consciousness can under no circumstances be disturbed, even if there is heavy suffering. That is the instruction of Kuntédevé.

Before winning the Battle of Kurukñetra, all the Päëòavas were put into many dangers, as already described in the previous verses. They were given poison, they were put into a house of lac that was later set afire, and sometimes they were even confronted with great man-eating demons. They lost their kingdom, they lost their wife, they lost their prestige, and they were exiled to the forest. But throughout all those dangers, Kåñëa was there. When the Kauravas were trying to strip Draupadé naked, Kåñëa was there supplying cloth to protect her honor. Kåñëa was always there.

Therefore, when the Päëòavas went to see their grandfather, Bhéñmadeva, on his deathbed, Bhéñmadeva began to cry. "These boys, my grandsons, are all very pious," he said. "Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira, the oldest of the brothers, is the most pious person. He is even called Dharmaräja, the king of religion. Bhéma and Arjuna are both devotees, and they are such powerful heroes that they can kill thousands of men. Their wife, Draupadé, is directly the goddess of fortune, and it has been enjoined that wherever she is, there will be no scarcity of food. Thus they all form a wonderful combination, and moreover, Lord Kåñëa is always with them. But still they are suffering." Thus he began to cry, saying, "I do not know what is Kåñëa's arrangement, because such pious devotees are also suffering."

Therefore, we should not think, "Because I have become a devotee, there will be no danger or suffering." Prahläda Mahäräja suffered greatly, and so did other devotees like the Päëòavas and Haridäsa Öhäkura. But we should not be disturbed by such sufferings. We must have firm faith, firm conviction, knowing, "Kåñëa is present, and He will give me protection." Don't try to take the benefit of any shelter other than Kåñëa. Always take to Kåñëa.

In Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa says, kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati: "My dear Arjuna, you may declare to the world that My devotee is never vanquished." Now, one may ask, why did Kåñëa advise Arjuna to declare this? Why did He not declare it Himself? The answer is that if Kåñëa Himself made this declaration, it might be suspect, because Kåñëa sometimes violates His own promise. But the promise of a devotee will never be violated. This is Kåñëa's concern. "Oh, My devotee has declared this. I must see that his word is kept." This is Kåñëa's position because of His affection for His devotee. Therefore Lord Kåñëa said, "You declare it. If I declare it, people may not believe it, but if you declare it they will believe you because you are a devotee." Even though Kåñëa may break His own promise, He wants to see that the promises of His devotees are fulfilled.

Therefore, we must take to Kåñëa consciousness and adhere to this consciousness under all circumstances, even in the most dangerous position. We must keep our faith in Kåñëa's lotus feet, and then there will be no danger.

TQK 9: Decreasing the Fever of Illusion

9. Decreasing the Fever of Illusion

janmaiçvarya-çruta-çrébhir
edhamäna-madaù pumän
naivärhaty abhidhätuà vai
tväm akiïcana-gocaram

TRANSLATION

My Lord, Your Lordship can easily be approached, but only by those who are materially exhausted. One who is on the path of [material] progress, trying to improve himself with respectable parentage, great opulence, high education, and bodily beauty, cannot approach You with sincere feeling.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.26

PURPORT

Being materially advanced means taking birth in an aristocratic family and possessing great wealth, an education, and attractive personal beauty. All materialistic men are mad after possessing all these material opulences, and this is known as the advancement of material civilization. But the result is that by possessing all these material assets one becomes artificially puffed up, intoxicated by such temporary possessions. Consequently, such materially puffed up persons are incapable of uttering the holy name of the Lord by addressing Him feelingly, "O Govinda, O Kåñëa." It is said in the çästras that by once uttering the holy name of the Lord, the sinner gets rid of a quantity of sins that he is unable to commit. Such is the power of uttering the holy name of the Lord. There is not the least exaggeration in this statement. Actually the Lord's holy name has such powerful potency. But there is a quality to such utterances also. It depends on the quality of feeling. A helpless man can feelingly utter the holy name of the Lord, whereas a man who utters the same holy name in great material satisfaction cannot be so sincere. A materially puffed up person may utter the holy name of the Lord occasionally, but he is incapable of uttering the name in quality. Therefore, the four principles of material advancement, namely (1) high parentage, (2) good wealth, (3) high education, and (4) attractive beauty, are, so to speak, disqualifications for progress on the path of spiritual advancement. The material covering of the pure spirit soul is an external feature, as much as fever is an external feature of the unhealthy body. The general process is to decrease the degree of the fever and not to aggravate it by maltreatment. Sometimes it is seen that spiritually advanced persons become materially impoverished. This is no discouragement. On the other hand, such impoverishment is a good sign as much as the falling of temperature is a good sign. The principle of life should be to decrease the degree of material intoxication which leads one to be more and more illusioned about the aim of life. Grossly illusioned persons are quite unfit for entrance into the kingdom of God.

In one sense, of course, material opulences are God's grace. To take birth in a very aristocratic family or nation like America, to be very rich, to be advanced in knowledge and education, and to be endowed with beauty are gifts of pious activities. A rich man attracts the attention of others, whereas a poor man does not. An educated man attracts attention, but a fool attracts no attention at all. Materially, therefore, such opulences are very beneficial. But when a person is materially opulent in this way, he becomes intoxicated: "Oh, I am a rich man. I am an educated man. I have money."

One who drinks wine will become intoxicated and may think that he is flying in the sky or that he has gone to heaven. These are effects of intoxication. But an intoxicated person does not know that all these dreams are within the limits of time and will therefore come to an end. Because he is unaware that these dreams will not continue, he is said to be in illusion. Similarly, one is intoxicated by thinking, "I am very rich, I am very educated and beautiful, and I have taken birth in an aristocratic family in a great nation." That's all right, but how long will these advantages exist? Suppose one is an American and is also rich, beautiful, and advanced in knowledge. One may be proud of all this, but how long will this intoxication exist? As soon as the body is finished, it will all be finished, just like the intoxicated dreams of a person who has been drinking.

These dreams are on the mental platform, the egoistic platform, and the bodily platform. But I am not the body. The gross body and subtle body are different from my actual self. The gross body is made of earth, water, fire, air, and ether, and the subtle body is made of mind, intelligence, and false ego. But the living being is transcendental to these eight elements, which are described in the Bhagavad-gétä as the inferior energy of God.

Even if one is mentally very advanced, he does not know that he is under the influence of the inferior energy, just as an intoxicated person does not know what condition he is in. Opulence, therefore, places one in a position of intoxication. We are already intoxicated, and modern civilization aims at increasing our intoxication. In truth we should become free from this intoxication, but modern civilization aims at increasing it so that we may become more and more intoxicated and go to hell.

Kuntédevé says that those who are intoxicated in this way cannot feelingly address the Lord. They cannot feelingly say, jaya rädhä-mädhava: "All glories to Rädhä and Kåñëa!" They have lost their spiritual feeling. They cannot feelingly address the Lord, because they do not have knowledge. "Oh, God is for the poor man," they think. "The poor do not have sufficient food. Let them go to the church and pray, 'O God, give us our daily bread.' But I have enough bread. Why should I go to church?" This is their opinion.

Nowadays, therefore, because we are in a time of economic prosperity, no one is interested in going to the churches or temples. "What is this nonsense?" people think. "Why should I go to the church to ask for bread? We shall develop our economic condition, and then there will be a sufficient supply of bread." In Communist countries this mentality is especially prevalent. The Communists make propaganda in the villages by asking people to go to church and pray for bread. So the innocent people pray as usual, "O God, give us our daily bread." When the people come out of the church, the Communists ask, "Have you gotten bread?"

"No, sir," they reply.

"All right," the Communists say. "Ask us."

Then the people say, "O Communist friends, give us bread."

The Communist friends, of course, have brought a whole truckload of bread, and they say, "Take as much as you like. Now, who is better—the Communists or your God?"

Because the people are not very intelligent, they reply, "Oh, you are better." They don't have the intelligence to inquire, "You rascals, wherefrom have you brought this bread? Have you manufactured it in your factory? Can your factory manufacture grains?" Because they are çüdras (people who have very little intelligence), they don't ask these questions. A brähmaëa, however, one who is advanced in intelligence, will immediately inquire, "You rascals, wherefrom have you brought this bread? You cannot manufacture bread. You have simply taken the wheat given by God and transformed it, but this does not mean that it has become your property."

Simply transforming one thing into something else does not make the final product one's own property. For example, if I give a carpenter some wood, some tools, and a salary and he makes a very beautiful closet, to whom will the closet belong—to the carpenter or to me, the person who has supplied the ingredients? The carpenter cannot say, "Because I have transformed this wood into such a nice closet, it is mine." Similarly, we should say to atheistic men like the Communists, "Who is supplying the ingredients for your bread, you rascal? It is all coming from Kåñëa. In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says, 'The elements of this material creation are all My property.' You have not created the sea, the land, the sky, the fire, or the air. These are not your creations. You may mix and transform these material things. You may take earth from the land and water from the sea, mix them and put them in a fire to make bricks, and then you may pile up all these bricks to make a skyscraper and claim that the skyscraper is yours. But where did you get the ingredients for the skyscraper, you rascal? You have stolen the property of God, and now you are claiming that it is your property. This is knowledge.

Unfortunately, those who are intoxicated cannot understand this. They think, "We have taken this land of America from the Red Indians, and now it is our property." They do not know that they are thieves. The Bhagavad-gétä clearly says that one who takes the property of God and claims it as his own is a thief (stena eva saù).

The devotees of Kåñëa, therefore, have their own form of communism. According to Kåñëa conscious communism, everything belongs to God. Just as the Russian and Chinese Communists think that everything belongs to the state, we think that everything belongs to God. This is merely an extension of the same philosophy, and to understand it one simply needs a little intelligence. Why should one think that his state belongs to only a small number of people? In fact this is all the property of God, and every living entity has a right to use this property because every living being is a child of God, who is the supreme father. In Bhagavad-gétä (14.4), Lord Kåñëa says, sarva-yoniñu kaunteya... ahaà béja-pradaù pitä: "I am the seed-giving father of all living entities. In whatever forms they may live, all living entities are My sons."

We living entities are all sons of God, but we have forgotten this, and therefore we are fighting. In a happy family, all the sons know, "Father is supplying food to us all. We are brothers, so why should we fight?" Similarly, if we become God conscious, Kåñëa conscious, the fighting in the world will come to an end. "I am American," "I am Indian," "I am Russian," "I am Chinese"—all these nonsensical designations will be finished. The Kåñëa consciousness movement is so purifying that as soon as people become Kåñëa conscious their political and national fighting will immediately be over, because they will come to their real consciousness and understand that everything belongs to God. The children in a family all have the right to accept privileges from the father. Similarly, if everyone is part and parcel of God, if everyone is a child of God, then everyone has the right to use the property of the father. That right does not belong only to the human beings; rather, according to Bhagavad-gétä, that right belongs to all living entities, regardless of whether they are in the bodies of human beings, animals, trees, birds, beasts, insects, or whatever. That is Kåñëa consciousness.

In Kåñëa consciousness we do not think, "My brother is good, and I am good, but all others are bad." This is the kind of narrow, crippled consciousness we reject. Rather, in Kåñëa consciousness we look equally toward all living entities. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (5.18):

vidyä-vinaya-sampanne
brähmaëe gavi hastini
çuni caiva çvapäke ca
paëòitäù sama-darçinaù

"The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog, and a dog-eater [outcaste]."

One who is paëòita, one who is learned, sees all living entities to be on an equal level. Therefore, because a Vaiñëava, or devotee, is learned, he is compassionate (lokänäà hita-käriëau), and he can work in such a way as to actually benefit humanity. A Vaiñëava feels and actually sees that all living entities are part and parcel of God and that somehow or other they have fallen into contact with this material world and have assumed different types of bodies according to different karma.

Those who are learned (paëòitäù) do not discriminate. They do not say, "This is an animal, so it should be sent to the slaughterhouse so that a man may eat it." No. Why should the animals be slaughtered? A person who is actually Kåñëa conscious is kind to everyone. Therefore one tenet of our philosophy is "No meat-eating." Of course, people may not accept this. They will say, "Oh, what is this nonsense? Meat is our food. Why should we not eat it?" Because they are intoxicated rascals (edhamäna-madaù [Bhäg. 1.8.26]), they will not hear the real facts. But just consider: if a poor man is lying helpless in the street, can I kill him? Will the state excuse me? I may say, "I have only killed a poor man. There was no need for him in society. Why should such a person live?" But will the state excuse me? Will the authorities say, "You have done very nice work"? No. The poor man is also a citizen of the state, and the state cannot allow him to be killed. Now, why not expand this philosophy? The trees, the birds, and the beasts are also sons of God. If one kills them, one is as guilty as one who kills a poor man on the street. In God's eyes, or even in the vision of a learned man, there is no discrimination between poor and rich, black and white. No. Every living entity is part and parcel of God. And because a Vaiñëava sees this, he is the only true benefactor of all living entities.

A Vaiñëava tries to elevate all living beings to a platform of Kåñëa consciousness. A Vaiñëava does not see, "Here is an Indian, and there is an American." Someone once asked me, "Why have you come to America?" But why should I not come? I am a servant of God, and this is the kingdom of God, so why should I not come? To hinder the movements of a devotee is artificial, and one who does so commits a sinful act. Just as a policeman may enter a house without trespassing, a servant has the right to go anywhere, because everything belongs to God. We have to see things in this way, as they are. That is Kåñëa consciousness.

Now, Kuntédevé says that those who are increasing their own intoxication cannot become Kåñëa conscious. A fully intoxicated person may talk nonsense, and he may be told, "My dear brother, you are talking nonsense. Just see. Here is your father, and here is your mother." But because he is intoxicated, he will not understand, nor will he even care to understand. Similarly, if a devotee tries to show a materially intoxicated rascal, "Here is God," the rascal will not be able to understand it. Therefore Kuntédevé says, tväm akiïcana-gocaram [Bhäg. 1.8.26], indicating that to be free from the intoxication caused by high birth, opulence, education, and beauty is a good qualification.

Nonetheless, when one becomes Kåñëa conscious, these same material assets can be used for the service of Kåñëa. For example, the Americans who have joined the Kåñëa consciousness movement were materially intoxicated before they became devotees, but now that their intoxication is over, their material assets have become spiritual assets that may be helpful in furthering the service of Kåñëa. For example, when these American devotees go to India, the Indian people are surprised to see that Americans have become so mad after God. Many Indians strive to imitate the materialistic life of the West, but when they see Americans dancing in Kåñëa consciousness, then they realize that this is what is actually worthy of being followed.

Everything can be used in the service of Kåñëa. If one remains intoxicated and does not use one's material assets for the service of Kåñëa, they are not very valuable. But if one can use them for the service of Kåñëa, they become extremely valuable. To give an example, zero has no value, but as soon as the digit one is placed before the zero, the zero immediately becomes ten. If there are two zeros, they become one hundred, and three zeros become one thousand. Similarly, we are intoxicated by material assets that are actually no better than zero, but as soon as we add Kåñëa, these tens and hundreds and thousands and millions of zeros become extremely valuable. The Kåñëa consciousness movement therefore offers a great opportunity to the people of the West. They have an overabundance of the zeros of materialistic life, and if they simply add Kåñëa their life will become sublimely valuable.

TQK 10: The Property of the Impoverished

10. The Property of the Impoverished

namo 'kiïcana-vittäya
nivåtta-guëa-våttaye
ätmärämäya çäntäya
kaivalya-pataye namaù

TRANSLATION

My obeisances are unto You, who are the property of the materially impoverished. You have nothing to do with the actions and reactions of the material modes of nature. You are self-satisfied, and therefore You are the most gentle and are master of the monists.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.27

PURPORT

A living being is finished as soon as there is nothing to possess. Therefore a living being cannot be, in the real sense of the term, a renouncer. A living being renounces something for gaining something more valuable. A student sacrifices his childish proclivities to gain better education. A servant gives up his job for a better job. Similarly, a devotee renounces the material world not for nothing but for something tangible in spiritual value. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, Sanätana Gosvämé, and Çréla Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé and others gave up their worldly pomp and prosperity for the sake of the service of the Lord. They were big men in the worldly sense. The Gosvämés were ministers in the government service of Bengal, and Çréla Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé was the son of a big zamindar of his time. But they left everything to gain something superior to what they previously possessed. The devotees are generally without material prosperity, but they have a very secret treasure-house in the lotus feet of the Lord. There is a nice story about Çréla Sanätana Gosvämé. He had a touchstone with him, and this stone was left in a pile of refuse. A needy man took it, but later on wondered why the valuable stone was kept in such a neglected place. He therefore asked Sanätana Gosvämé for the most valuable thing, and then he was given the holy name of the Lord. Akiïcana means "one who has nothing to give materially." A factual devotee, or mahätmä, does not give anything material to anyone, because he has already left all material assets. He can, however, deliver the supreme asset, namely the Personality of Godhead, because He is the only property of a factual devotee. The touchstone of Sanätana Gosvämé, which was thrown in the rubbish, was not the property of the Gosvämé, otherwise it would not have been kept in such a place. This specific example is given for the neophyte devotees just to convince them that material hankerings and spiritual advancement go ill together. Unless one is able to see everything as spiritual in relation with the Supreme Lord, one must always distinguish between spirit and matter. A spiritual master like Çréla Sanätana Gosvämé, although personally able to see everything as spiritual, set this example for us only because we have no such spiritual vision.

Advancement of material vision or material civilization is a great stumbling block for spiritual advancement. Such material advancement entangles the living being in the bondage of a material body followed by all sorts of material miseries. Such material advancement is called anartha, or things not wanted. Actually this is so. In the present context of material advancement one uses lipstick at a cost of fifty cents, and there are so many unwanted things which are all products of the material conception of life. By diverting attention to so many unwanted things, human energy is spoiled without achievement of spiritual realization, the prime necessity of human life. The attempt to reach the moon is another example of spoiling energy because even if the moon is reached, the problems of life will not be solved. The devotees of the Lord are called akiïcanas because they have practically no material assets. Such material assets are all products of the three modes of material nature. They foil spiritual energy, and thus the less we possess such products of material nature, the more we have a good chance for spiritual progress.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead has no direct connection with material activities. All His acts and deeds, which are exhibited even in this material world, are spiritual and unaffected by the modes of material nature. In the Bhagavad-gétä the Lord says that all His acts, even His appearance and disappearance in and out of the material world, are transcendental, and one who knows this perfectly shall not take his birth again in this material world, but will go back to Godhead.

The material disease is due to hankering after and lording it over material nature. This hankering is due to an interaction of the three modes of nature, and neither the Lord nor the devotees have attachment for such false enjoyment. Therefore, the Lord and the devotees are called nivåtta-guëa-våtti. The perfect nivåtta-guëa-våtti is the Supreme Lord because He never becomes attracted by the modes of material nature, whereas the living beings have such a tendency. Some of them are entrapped by the illusory attraction of material nature.

Because the Lord is the property of the devotees, and the devotees are the property of the Lord reciprocally, the devotees are certainly transcendental to the modes of material nature. That is a natural conclusion. Such unalloyed devotees are distinct from the mixed devotees who approach the Lord for mitigation of miseries and poverty or because of inquisitiveness and speculation. The unalloyed devotees and the Lord are transcendentally attached to one another. For others, the Lord has nothing to reciprocate, and therefore He is called ätmäräma, self-satisfied. Self-satisfied as He is, He is the master of all monists who seek to merge into the existence of the Lord. Such monists merge within the personal effulgence of the Lord called the brahmajyoti, but the devotees enter into the transcendental pastimes of the Lord, which are never to be misunderstood as material.

To be materially impoverished is the first qualification of a devotee. One who does not possess anything in this material world but simply possesses Kåñëa is called akiïcana. The word akiïcana means "one who has lost all material possessions." As long as we have even the slightest tinge of an idea of becoming happy materially in some way or other, we shall have to accept a material body. Nature is so kind that according to the way we want to enjoy this material world, she will give us a suitable body, under the direction of the Lord. Because the Lord is situated in everyone's heart, He knows everything. Therefore, knowing that we still want something material, He will give us another material body: "Yes, take it." Kåñëa wants us to have full experience through which to understand that by material gain we shall never be happy. This is Kåñëa's desire.

Because we are part and parcel of Kåñëa, who has full freedom, we too have full freedom, although the quantity of that freedom is quite minute. Although the quantity of salt in a drop of seawater is not comparable to the quantity of salt in the ocean, the chemical composition of both the drop and the ocean is the same. Similarly, whatever we have in a minute quantity is present in its fullness in Kåñëa (janmädy asya yataù). For example, we have a propensity to steal, to take things that belong to others. Why? Because Kåñëa has the same propensity. Unless the propensity to steal is present in the Absolute Truth, how can it be present in us? Kåñëa is known as "the butter thief." But Kåñëa's stealing and our stealing are different. Because we are materially contaminated, our stealing is abominable, whereas on the spiritual, absolute platform the same stealing is so nice that it is enjoyable. Mother Yaçodä therefore enjoys Kåñëa's activities of stealing. This is the difference between material and spiritual.

Any activities that are spiritual are all-good, and any activities that are material are all-bad. This is the difference between spiritual and material. The so-called morality and goodness of this material world is all bad, but in the spiritual world even so-called immorality is good. This we must understand. For example, to dance with the wives of others at the dead of night is immoral, at least according to the Vedic civilization. Even today in India, a young woman will never be allowed to go to a young man at the dead of night to dance with him. But we shall find in Çrémad-Bhägavatam that as soon as all the gopés, the young cowherd girls of Våndävana, heard Kåñëa's flute, they immediately came to dance with Him. Now, according to material conceptions this is immoral, but from the spiritual point of view this is in accord with the greatest morality. Caitanya Mahäprabhu therefore said, ramyä käcid upäsanä vraja-vadhü-vargeëa yä kalpitä: "Oh, there is no better mode of worship than that which was conceived by the vraja-vadhüs, the damsels of Våndävana." After Caitanya Mahäprabhu accepted the renounced order of life, He very strictly avoided association with women. Even in His family life, He never played any jokes with women. He was very humorous, but only with men, not with women. Once He spoke some joking words with His wife, Viñëupriyä. When Çacémätä, Lord Caitanya's mother, was searching for something, He jokingly said, "Maybe your daughter-in-law has taken it." But in His whole life these are the only joking words we find in relation to women. He was very strict. After He accepted sannyäsa, the renounced order, no woman could even come near Him to offer obeisances; rather, they would offer obeisances from a distant place. Nonetheless, Caitanya Mahäprabhu said, ramyä käcid upäsanä vraja-vadhü-vargeëa yä kalpitä: "There is no conception of worship better than that which was conceived by the damsels of Våndävana." What was their conception? They wanted to love Kåñëa, at any risk. And this is never immoral.

That which is in relationship to Kåñëa can never be immoral. To give another example, Lord Kåñëa in His incarnation as Nåsiàha-deva killed Hiraëyakaçipu, the father of Prahläda Mahäräja, while Prahläda Mahäräja stood nearby without protesting. Now, is this moral? Who would like to see his own father being killed? Who would just stand there and not protest? No one would approve of such behavior and say that it is moral. Nonetheless, this actually happened. Not only that, but Prahläda Mahäräja even made a garland to place upon the neck of the killer. "My dear Lord Killer," he said, "please take this garland. You have killed my father, and You are very good." This must be understood spiritually. If one's father is being attacked and one cannot protect him, one must protest and cry for help. But because Prahläda Mahäräja's father was killed by Kåñëa in the form of Lord Nåsiàha-deva, Prahläda Mahäräja prepared a garland for the killer. After his father was killed, Prahläda said to Nåsiàha-deva, "My dear Lord, now that my father has been killed, everyone is happy. Now please withdraw Your angry mood."

A sädhu, a saintly person, never approves of killing, not even the killing of an animal, but Prahläda Mahäräja said, modeta sädhur api våçcika-sarpa-hatyä: [Bhäg. 7.9.14] "Even a saintly person is pleased when a scorpion or a snake is killed." A scorpion or a snake is also a living entity, and a sädhu is never satisfied when he sees another living entity killed, but Prahläda Mahäräja said, "Even a sädhu is pleased when a snake or a scorpion is killed. My father was just like a snake or a scorpion, and therefore now that he has been killed, everyone is happy." Hiraëyakaçipu was a very dangerous demon who gave trouble to devotees, and when such a demon is killed even saintly persons are satisfied, although ordinarily they never want anyone killed. Therefore, although it may appear that Lord Kåñëa or Prahläda Mahäräja acted immorally, in fact they acted in accord with the highest morality.

Kåñëa is akiïcana-vitta, the only solace for one who has lost everything material. In the Caitanya-caritämåta, Lord Kåñëa says, "If someone wants Me but at the same time wants material prosperity, he is a fool." Kåñëa is so kind that if one wants material prosperity but at the same time wants to become a devotee, Kåñëa makes him a failure in material life. Therefore people are very much afraid of coming to Kåñëa consciousness. "Oh," they think, "my material prosperity will be finished."

Generally, people go to a church or temple to pray to God for material prosperity: "O God, give us our daily bread." But although they are approaching God for material prosperity—"Give me this, give me that"—they are also considered pious because they approach God, unlike the atheists, who never approach Him. "Why shall I approach God?" the atheist says. "I shall create my own wealth, and by advancement of science I shall be happy." One who thinks "For my own prosperity I shall depend on my own strength and my own knowledge" is a duñkåté, a most sinful person, but one who thinks "My prosperity depends on the mercy of God" is pious.

It is a fact that without the sanction of God, nothing can be achieved. Tävat tanur idaà tanüpekñitänäm. We have discovered many methods by which to counteract distress, but when freedom from such distress is not sanctioned by God, these methods will fail. For example, a sick man may have very good medicine and a qualified physician, but if we ask the physician, "Can you guarantee the life of this patient?" the doctor will always say, "No, I cannot do so. I try my best. That's all." An intelligent doctor knows, "The ultimate sanction is in the hand of God. I am simply an instrument. If God does not want the patient to live, then all my medicines and all my scientific medical knowledge will fail."

The ultimate sanction, therefore, is Kåñëa. Those who are foolish do not know this, and therefore they are called müòha, rascals. They do not know that although whatever they are doing may be very good, if it is not ultimately sanctioned by God, by Kåñëa, it will all be a failure. On the other hand, a devotee knows, "With whatever intelligence I have I may try to become happy, but without Kåñëa's sanction I shall never be happy." This is the distinction between a devotee and a nondevotee.

As mentioned before, Kåñëa says, "One who tries to approach Me to become Kåñëa conscious but at the same time wants to become materially happy is not very intelligent. He is wasting his time." Our main business is to become Kåñëa conscious. That is the main business of human life. If we waste our time striving for material improvement and forget to chant Hare Kåñëa, that will be a great loss. Therefore Kåñëa says, ämi—vijïa, ei mürkhe 'viñaya' kena diba (Cc. Madhya 22.39): "A rascal may ask some material prosperity from Me in exchange for discharging devotional service. But why shall I give him material prosperity? Rather, whatever he has I shall take away."

When our material assets are taken away, we become very morose. But that is the test. That was stated by Kåñëa Himself to Yudhiñöhira Mahäräja. Yudhiñöhira Mahäräja inquired from Kåñëa, "We are completely dependent on You, but still we are suffering materially so much. Our kingdom has been taken away, our wife has been insulted, and our enemies attempted to burn us in our house. How can this be so?" Kåñëa replied, yasyäham anugåhëämi hariñye tad-dhanaà çanaiù: "Yes, that is My first business. If I especially favor someone, then I take away all his sources of income and place him into great difficulty." In this way, Kåñëa is very dangerous.

I have actual experience in this connection. I do not wish to narrate this whole story, but it is a fact that I received Kåñëa's special favor in this way. When I was twenty-five years old, my Guru Mahäräja, my spiritual master, ordered me to go preach. But I thought, "First of all I shall become a rich man, and then I shall use my money to finance the preaching work." I had good opportunities to become a very rich businessman. An astrologer even told me that I should have become as rich as the wealthiest man in India. There were very good chances. I was the manager of a big chemical factory. I started my own factory, and the business was very successful. But eventually everything collapsed, and in this way I was forced into the position of carrying out the orders of my Guru Mahäräja. When all my material assets were taken away, then I approached Kåñëa, saying, "You are the only shelter." Therefore Kåñëa is akiïcana-vitta, the property of the materially impoverished. When one is bereft of all material opulences, then one turns to Kåñëa. And now I am realizing that I have not lost but gained.

So to lose material opulences for Kåñëa's sake is not a loss. Rather, it is the greatest gain. When one becomes akiïcana, having nothing to possess, Kåñëa becomes one's only riches. Expressing this understanding, Narottama däsa Öhäkura says:

hä hä prabhu nanda-suta, våñabhänu-sutä-yuta
karuëä karaha ei-bära
narottama däsa kaya, nä öheliha räìgä-päya
tomä vine ke äche ämära
[hari hari! vifale 4]

"Kåñëa, but for You I have nothing to claim. I have no possessions. You are my only possession, so please don't neglect me."

This position is very nice. When one does not depend on anything material but simply depends on Kåñëa, one has attained the first-class position of Kåñëa consciousness. Therefore Kåñëa is addressed as akiïcana-vitta. "When one becomes materially impoverished, You are the only wealth." Namo 'kiïcana-vittäya nivåtta-guëa-våttaye [Bhäg. 1.8.27]. "When one takes You as one's only possession, one immediately becomes free from the activities of the material nature." In other words, by accepting Kåñëa in this way, one attains the transcendental position of the Absolute. Ätmärämäya: "At that time, one becomes happy with You. Kåñëa, You are happy with Yourself, and one who surrenders to You becomes happy, as You are." There is no difference between Kåñëa's body and Kåñëa Himself. He is entirely self, entirely spirit. We, on the other hand, have a body that is different from ourselves. I am self, but I possess a material body. But when we actually become dependent on Kåñëa, who is completely self-satisfied, we can also be self-satisfied with Kåñëa.

Kaivalya-pataye namaù. The Mäyävädé philosophers, the monists, want to become one with the Supreme. The Supreme is self-satisfied, and they also want to be self-satisfied by becoming one with the Supreme. Our philosophy of Kåñëa consciousness is the same, but instead of becoming one with Kåñëa, we depend on Kåñëa. That is actual oneness. If we simply agree to abide by the orders of Kåñëa and have no disagreement with Him, we are situated in actual oneness.

The Mäyävädé philosophers think, "Why shall I keep my individual, separate existence? I shall merge into the Supreme." But that is not possible. From the very beginning, we are separated parts of Kåñëa. Kåñëa therefore says in Bhagavad-gétä, "My dear Arjuna, you should know that you, I, and all the persons assembled on this battlefield were individuals in the past, we are individuals at present, and in the future we shall continue to remain individuals."

Nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm. Kåñëa is the supreme nitya, the supreme living force, among the innumerable living forces. We living entities (jéva) are innumerable (ananta); there is no counting how many we are. Similarly, Kåñëa is also a living entity, but He is the chief, the supreme living entity. That is the difference. One leader may have many followers. Similarly, Kåñëa, the supreme living entity, is the supreme leader, and we are subordinate, dependent living entities.

That we are dependent is not very difficult to understand. If Kåñëa does not supply us food, we shall starve, because independently we cannot produce anything. Eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän: Kåñëa is maintaining everything, and we are being maintained. Therefore Kåñëa is the real predominator, and we should be willing to be predominated. That is our natural constitutional position. If we falsely want to become predominators in this material world, we are in illusion. We must give up this illusion and always try to be predominated by Kåñëa. Then our life will be successful.

TQK 11: The Touch of Superior Energy

11. The Touch of Superior Energy

manye tväà kälam éçänam
anädi-nidhanaà vibhum
samaà carantaà sarvatra
bhütänäà yan mithaù kaliù

TRANSLATION

My Lord, I consider Your Lordship to be eternal time, the supreme controller, without beginning and end, the all-pervasive one. In distributing Your mercy, You are equal to everyone. The dissensions between living beings are due to social intercourse.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.28

PURPORT

Kuntédevé knew that Kåñëa was neither her nephew nor an ordinary family member of her paternal house. She knew perfectly well that Kåñëa is the primeval Lord who lives in everyone's heart as the Supersoul, Paramätmä. Another name of the Paramätmä feature of the Lord is käla, or eternal time. Eternal time is the witness of all our actions, good and bad, and thus resultant reactions are destined by Him. It is no use saying that we do not know why we are suffering. We may forget the misdeed for which we may suffer at this present moment, but we must remember that Paramätmä is our constant companion and therefore He knows everything—past, present, and future. And because the Paramätmä feature of Lord Kåñëa destines all actions and reactions, He is the supreme controller also. Without His sanction not a blade of grass can move. The living beings are given as much freedom as they deserve, and misuse of that freedom is the cause of suffering. The devotees of the Lord do not misuse their freedom, and therefore they are the good sons of the Lord. Others, who misuse freedom, are put into miseries destined by the eternal käla. The käla offers the conditioned souls both happiness and miseries. It is all predestined by eternal time. As we have miseries uncalled for, so we may have happiness also without being asked, for they are all predestined by käla. No one is therefore either an enemy or friend of the Lord. Everyone is suffering and enjoying the result of his own destiny. This destiny is made by the living beings in course of social intercourse. Everyone here wants to lord it over the material nature, and thus everyone creates his own destiny under the supervision of the Supreme Lord. He is all-pervading and therefore He can see everyone's activities. And because the Lord has no beginning or end, He is known also as the eternal time, käla.

What is explained herein by the devoted Kunté is exactly confirmed by the Lord Himself in Bhagavad-gétä (9.29). There the Lord says:

samo 'haà sarva-bhüteñu
na me dveñyo 'sti na priyaù
ye bhajanti tu mäà bhaktyä
mayi te teñu cäpy aham

"I envy no one, nor am I partial to anyone. I am equal to all. But one who renders service unto Me in devotion is a friend, is in Me, and I am also a friend to him." God cannot be partial. Everyone is God's son, so how can God favor one son above another? That is not possible. But human beings discriminate. We write, "In God we trust," but one who trusts in God must be equally kind and merciful toward all living entities. That is God consciousness.

Kåñëa says, "I have no enemies, nor have I friends." Na me dveñyo 'sti na priyaù. The word dveñya means "enemy." We are envious of our enemies and friendly toward our friends, but because Kåñëa is absolute, even when He appears to be inimical toward some demon He is actually a friend. When Kåñëa kills a demon, the demon's demoniac activities are killed, and he immediately becomes a saint and merges into the supreme impersonal effulgence, the brahmajyoti.

The brahmajyoti is one of three features of the Absolute Truth.

vadanti tat tattva-vidas
tattvaà yaj jïänam advayam
brahmeti paramätmeti
bhagavän iti çabdyate
(Bhäg. 1.2.11)

The Absolute Truth is one, but is perceived in three features, known as Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagavän. The original, complete feature of the Absolute Truth is Bhagavän, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and His plenary representation is Paramätmä, Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu, who is situated in everyone's heart (éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati). The third feature of the Absolute Truth is Brahman, the all-pervading impersonal effulgence of the Absolute.

The Absolute Truth is equal to everyone, but one will realize the Absolute according to the way one approaches Him (ye yathä mäà prapadyante). According to one's capacity for understanding, the Absolute Truth is revealed either as the impersonal Brahman, as the localized Paramätmä, or ultimately as Bhagavän.

To explain this by an example, we may sometimes see hills from our room, although we may not see them distinctly. In Los Angeles there are many hills, but when we see the hills from a distant place they look like something cloudy. However, if we go further toward a hill, we shall find that there is something distinct—a hill. And if we go all the way to the hill itself, we shall find many people working there, many houses, streets, cars, and so many varied things. Similarly, when one wants to know the Absolute Truth by one's tiny brain and thinks, "I shall conduct research to find the Absolute Truth," one will have a vague, impersonal idea. Then if one goes further and becomes a meditator, one will find that God is situated within one's heart. Dhyänävasthita-tad-gatena manasä paçyanti yaà yoginaù. Yogés—real yogés—see the form of Viñëu within the heart by meditation. The devotees, however, meet the Supreme Person face to face, just as we meet face to face and speak face to face. The Supreme Personality of Godhead orders, "Supply Me this," and the devotee directly serves the Lord by supplying what He wants. Thus there are different realizations of the Absolute Truth, and although He is equal to everyone it is up to us to understand Him according to our advancement. Therefore Kunté says, samaà carantaà sarvatra: [Bhäg. 1.8.28] "In distributing Your mercy, You are equal to everyone."

The word carantam means "moving." The Lord moves everywhere—within and without—and we simply have to make our vision clear so that we may see Him. By devotional service, we can purify our senses so that we may perceive the presence of God. Those who are less intelligent simply try to find God within, but those who are advanced in intelligence can see the Lord both within and without.

The yogic system of meditation is actually meant for those who are less intelligent. One who practices meditation in yoga must control the senses (yoga indriya-saàyamaù). Our senses are very restless, and by practicing the different äsanas, or sitting postures, one must control the mind and senses so that one can concentrate upon the form of Viñëu within the heart. This is the yoga system recommended for those who are too much absorbed in the bodily concept of life. However, because bhaktas, devotees, are more advanced, they do not need to undergo a separate process to control their senses; rather, by engaging in devotional service they are already controlling their senses.

For example, if one is engaged in worshiping the Deity, cleansing the temple, decorating the Deity, cooking for the Deity, and so on, one's senses are already engaged in the service of the Absolute Truth, so where is the chance of their being diverted? Håñékeëa håñékeça-sevanaà bhaktir ucyate: bhakti, devotional service, simply means engaging our senses (håñéka) in the service of the master of the senses (håñékeça). Now our senses are engaged in sense gratification. I am thinking that because I am this body, I must satisfy my senses. In fact, however, this is a contaminated stage of life. When one comes to the understanding that he is not this body but a spiritual soul, part and parcel of God, he knows that his spiritual senses should be engaged in the service of the supreme spiritual being. Thus one attains liberation (mukti).

One attains liberation when one gives up the false idea that the body is the self and when one resumes his actual position of service to the Lord (muktir hitvänyathä-rüpaà svarüpeëa vyavasthitiù, Bhäg. 2.10.6). When we are conditioned, we give up our original constitutional position, which is described by Caitanya Mahäprabhu as being that of eternal service to Kåñëa (jévera svarüpa haya—kåñëera 'nitya-däsa'). But as soon as we employ ourselves in the service of the Lord, we are liberated immediately. There is no need to pass through some preliminary process. This very act of engaging one's senses in the service of the Lord is evidence that one is liberated.

This liberation is open for everyone (samaà carantam [Bhäg. 1.8.28]). In Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa does not say to Arjuna, "Only you may come to Me and become liberated." No, the Lord is available for everyone. When He says, sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja—"Give up all other duties and surrender unto Me"—He is speaking not only to Arjuna but to everyone. Arjuna was the original target, but in fact Bhagavad-gétä was spoken for everyone, for all human beings, and therefore one must take advantage of it.

Kåñëa's impartiality is compared to that of the sun. The sun does not consider, "Here is a poor man, here is a low-class man, and here is a hog. I shall not distribute my sunshine to them." No, the sun is equal toward all, and one simply has to take advantage of it. The sunshine is available, but if we close our doors and want to keep ourselves in darkness, that is our decision. Similarly, Kåñëa is everywhere, Kåñëa is for everyone, and Kåñëa is ready to accept us as soon as we surrender. Samaà carantam. There is no restriction. People may make a distinction between lower class and higher class, but Kåñëa says, mäà hi pärtha vyapäçritya ye 'pi syuù päpa-yonayaù (Bg. 9.32): "Even though one may supposedly be of a lower class, that doesn't matter. If he surrenders to Me he is also eligible to come back home, back to Godhead."

That same Kåñëa is described by Kuntédevé as eternal time. Everything takes place within time, but our time calculations of past, present, and future are relative. A small insect's measurement of past, present, and future is different from our past, present, and future, and similarly the past, present, and future of Brahmä, the chief creative living being within this universe, are different from ours. But Kåñëa has no past, present, or future. Therefore He is eternal. We have a past, present, and future because we change from one body to another. The body we have now is dated. At a certain date I was born of my father and mother, and now this body will stay for some time. It will grow, it will produce some byproducts, then it will become old and dwindle and then vanish, and then I shall have to accept another body. When the past, present, and future of my present body are finished, I shall accept another body, and again my past, present, and future will begin. But Kåñëa has no past, present, or future, because He does not change His body. That is the difference between ourselves and Kåñëa.

The eternal position of Kåñëa is revealed in Bhagavad-gétä. There Kåñëa said to Arjuna, "In the past, millions of years ago, I spoke this philosophy of Bhagavad-gétä to the sun-god." Arjuna appeared not to believe this. Of course, Arjuna knew everything, but for our education he said to Kåñëa, "Kåñëa, we are contemporaries, and since we were born at practically the same time, how can I believe that You spoke this philosophy so long ago to the sun-god?" Then Kåñëa replied, "My dear Arjuna, you were also present then, but you have forgotten, whereas I have not. That is the difference." Past, present, and future pertain to persons who forget, but for one who does not forget, who lives eternally, there is no past, present, or future.

Kunté therefore addresses Kåñëa as eternal (manye tväà kälam). And because He is eternal, He is the full controller (éçänam). By Kåñëa's extraordinary behavior, Kunté could understand that Kåñëa is eternal and that Kåñëa is the supreme controller. He has no beginning and no end (anädi-nidhanam), and therefore He is vibhu, the Supreme, the greatest.

We are aëu, the smallest, and Kåñëa is vibhu, the greatest. We are part and parcel of Kåñëa, and therefore Kåñëa is both the smallest and the greatest, whereas we are only the smallest. Vibhu, the greatest, must be all-inclusive. If one has a large bag one can hold many things, whereas in a small bag one cannot. Because Kåñëa is vibhu, the greatest, He includes everything, even past, present, and future time, and He is all-pervading, present everywhere.

Without Kåñëa, matter cannot develop. Atheistic scientists say that life comes from matter, but that is nonsense. Matter is one energy of Kåñëa, and spirit is another. The spirit is superior energy, and matter is inferior energy. The matter develops when the superior energy is present. For example, two or three hundred years ago the land of America was not developed, but because some superior living entities from Europe came here, America is now very much developed. Therefore the cause of development is the superior energy. In Africa, Australia, and many other places there is still vacant land that is undeveloped. Why is it undeveloped? Because the superior energy of advanced living entities has not touched it. As soon as the superior energy touches it, the same land will develop so many factories, houses, cities, roads, cars, and so on.

The point of this example is that matter cannot develop by itself. That is not possible. Superior energy must touch it, and then it will be active. To give another example, a machine is matter—it is inferior energy—and therefore unless an operator comes to touch the machine, it will not act. One may have a very costly car, but unless a driver comes, in millions of years it will never go anywhere.

Thus it is common sense to understand that matter cannot work independently; it cannot work unless the superior energy, the living entity, touches it. So how can we conclude that life develops from matter? Rascal scientists may say this, but they do not have sufficient knowledge.

All the universes have developed because of Kåñëa's presence, as mentioned in the Brahma-saàhitä (aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-stham). The scientists are now studying atoms, and they are finding that electrons, protons, and other particles act in so many ways. Why are these particles active? Because Kåñëa is present there. This is real scientific understanding.

One should scientifically understand Kåñëa. Kåñëa has no past, present, and future. He is eternal time, with no beginning and no end, and He is equal to everyone. We simply have to prepare ourselves to see Kåñëa and understand Kåñëa. That is the purpose of Kåñëa consciousness.

TQK 12: Bewildering Pastimes

12. Bewildering Pastimes

na veda kaçcid bhagavaàç cikérñitaà
tavehamänasya nåëäà viòambanam
na yasya kaçcid dayito 'sti karhicid
dveñyaç ca yasmin viñamä matir nåëäm

TRANSLATION

O Lord, no one can understand Your transcendental pastimes, which appear to be human and so are misleading. You have no specific object of favor, nor do You have any object of envy. People only imagine that You are partial.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.29

PURPORT

The Lord's mercy upon the fallen souls is equally distributed. He has no one as the specific object of hostility. The very conception of the Personality of Godhead as a human being is misleading. His pastimes appear to be exactly like a human being's, but actually they are transcendental and without any tinge of material contamination. He is undoubtedly known as partial to His pure devotees, but in fact He is never partial, as much as the sun is never partial to anyone. By utilizing the sunrays, sometimes even the stones become valuable, whereas a blind man cannot see the sun, although there are enough sunrays before him. Darkness and light are two opposite conceptions, but this does not mean that the sun is partial in distributing its rays. The sunrays are open to everyone, but the capacities of the receptacles differ. Foolish people think that devotional service is flattering the Lord to get special mercy. Factually the pure devotees who are engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord are not a mercantile community. A mercantile house renders service to someone in exchange for values. The pure devotee does not render service unto the Lord for such exchange, and therefore the full mercy of the Lord is open for him. Suffering and needy men, inquisitive persons, or philosophers make temporary connections with the Lord to serve a particular purpose. When the purpose is served, there is no more relation with the Lord. A suffering man, if he is pious at all, prays to the Lord for his recovery. But as soon as the recovery is over, in most cases the suffering man no longer cares to keep any connection with the Lord. The mercy of the Lord is open for him, but he is reluctant to receive it. That is the difference between a pure devotee and a mixed devotee. Those who are completely against the service of the Lord are considered to be in abject darkness, those who ask for the Lord's favor only at the time of necessity are partial recipients of the mercy of the Lord, and those who are cent-percent engaged in the service of the Lord are full recipients of the mercy of the Lord. Such partiality in receiving the Lord's mercy is relative to the recipient, and it is not due to the partiality of the all-merciful Lord.

When the Lord descends on this material world by His all-merciful energy, He plays like a human being, and therefore it appears that the Lord is partial to His devotees only, but that is not a fact. Despite such an apparent manifestation of partiality, His mercy is equally distributed. In the Battlefield of Kurukñetra all persons who died in the fight before the presence of the Lord got salvation without the necessary qualifications, because death before the presence of the Lord purifies the passing soul from the effects of all sins, and therefore the dying man gets a place somewhere in the transcendental abode. Somehow or other if someone puts himself open in the sun rays, he is sure to get the requisite benefit both by heat and by ultraviolet rays. Therefore, the conclusion is that the Lord is never partial. It is wrong for the people in general to think of Him as partial.

The Lord says in Bhagavad-gétä (4.8):

pariträëäya sädhünäà
vinäçäya ca duñkåtam
dharma-saàsthäpanärthäya
sambhavämi yuge yuge

"In order to deliver the pious and to annihilate the miscreants, as well as to reestablish the principles of religion, I advent Myself millennium after millennium."

When God incarnates, He has two missions—to vanquish the demons and deliver the sädhus, the faithful devotees. The word sädhünäm, which means "saintly persons," refers to devotees. It has nothing to do with worldly honesty or dishonesty, morality or immorality; it has nothing to do with material activities. Sometimes we may think that the word sädhu refers to a person who is materially good or moral, but actually the word sädhu refers to one who is on the transcendental platform. A sädhu, therefore, is a devotee, because one who engages in devotional service is transcendental to material qualities (sa guëän samatétyaitän).

Now, the Lord comes to deliver the devotees (pariträëäya sädhünäà), but it is clearly stated in Bhagavad-gétä (14.26) that a devotee transcends the material qualities (sa guëän samatétyaitän). A devotee is in a transcendental position because he is no longer under the control of the three material modes of nature—goodness, passion, and ignorance. But if a sädhu is already delivered, being on the transcendental platform, then where is the necessity of delivering him? This question may arise. The Lord comes to deliver the devotee, but the devotee is already delivered. Therefore the word viòambanam, meaning "bewildering," is used in this verse because this appears contradictory.

The answer to this contradiction is that a sädhu, a devotee, does not require deliverance, but because he is very much anxious to see the Supreme Lord face to face, Kåñëa comes not to deliver him from the clutches of matter, from which he has already been delivered, but to satisfy his inner desire. Just as a devotee wants to satisfy the Lord in all respects, the Lord even more wants to satisfy the devotee. Such are the exchanges of loving affairs. Even in our ordinary dealings, if we love someone we want to satisfy him or her, and he or she also wants to reciprocate. So if the reciprocation of loving affairs exists in this material world, in what an elevated way must it exist in the spiritual world. There is a verse in which the Lord says, "The sädhu is My heart, and I am also the sädhu's heart." The sädhu is always thinking of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa is always thinking of the sädhu, His devotee.

The appearance and disappearance of the Lord within this material world are called cikérñitam, pastimes. It is Kåñëa's pastime that He comes. Of course, when the Lord comes He has some work to perform—to protect the sädhu and kill those who are against the sädhu—but both of these activities are His pastimes.

The Lord is not envious. The killing of the demons is also a display of His affection. Sometimes we may punish our children by giving them a very strong slap because of love. Similarly, when Kåñëa kills a demon this killing is not on the platform of material jealousy or envy, but on the platform of affection. Therefore it is mentioned in the çästras, the Vedic literatures, that even the demons killed by the Lord attain immediate salvation. Pütanä, for example, was a demoniac witch who wanted to kill Kåñëa. When Kåñëa was performing pastimes as a small child, she coated the nipple of her breast with poison and approached Kåñëa's home to offer the milk of her breast. "When Kåñëa sucks my nipple," she thought, "the child will immediately die." But that was not possible. Who can kill Kåñëa? Instead she herself was killed, for Kåñëa sucked the nipple and also sucked out her life altogether. But what was the result? Kåñëa took the bright side. "This demoniac woman came to kill Me," He thought, "but somehow or other I have sucked her breast milk, so she is My mother." Thus Pütanä attained the position of Kåñëa's mother in the spiritual world. This is explained in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, where Uddhava says to Vidura that Kåñëa is so kind, God is so kind, that even the witch who wanted to kill Him with poison was accepted as His mother. "Since Kåñëa is such a kind God," he said, "whom else shall I worship but Kåñëa?"

Kuntédevé says, na yasya kaçcid dayitaù. The word dayita means "favor." Kåñëa favors no one. Dveñyaç ca: and no one is His enemy. We expect some benediction or profit from a friend and harmful activities from an enemy, but Kåñëa is so perfect that no one can harm Him nor can anyone give Him anything. So who can be His friend or enemy? Na yasya kaçcid dayito 'sti: He doesn't need anyone's favor. He is complete. I may be a very poor man, and therefore I may expect some favor from a friend, but that is because I am imperfect. Because I am not full, because I am deficient in so many ways, I am always needy, and therefore I want to create some friend, and similarly I hate an enemy. But since Kåñëa is the Supreme, no one can harm Kåñëa, nor can anyone give Kåñëa anything.

Why then are we worshiping Kåñëa in the temple by offering Kåñëa so many comforts, dressing Him, decorating Him, and giving Him nice food? We should try to understand that Kåñëa does not need our offerings of nice garments, flowers, or food, but if we give such offerings to Kåñëa, we shall benefit. Thus it is Kåñëa's favor that He accepts such offerings. If one decorates oneself, one's reflection in a mirror will also appear decorated. Similarly, since we are reflections of Kåñëa, if we decorate Kåñëa we also shall be decorated. In the Bible it is said that man was made in the image of God, and this means that we are reflections of God's image. It is not that we invent or imagine some form of God according to our own form. Those who adhere to the Mäyäväda philosophy of anthropomorphism say, "The Absolute Truth is impersonal, but because we are persons we imagine that the Absolute Truth is also a person." This is a mistake, and in fact just the opposite is true. We have two hands, two legs, and a head because God Himself has these same features. We have personal forms because we are reflections of God. Furthermore, we should philosophically understand that if the original person benefits, the reflection also benefits. So if we decorate Kåñëa, we also shall be decorated. If we satisfy Kåñëa, we shall become satisfied. If we offer nice food to Kåñëa, we shall also eat the same food. Those who live outside the temples of Kåñëa consciousness may never have imagined such palatable food as the food we are offering to Kåñëa, but because it is being offered to Kåñëa, we also have the opportunity to eat it. So we should try to satisfy Kåñëa in all respects, and then we shall be satisfied in all respects.

Kåñëa does not need our service, but He kindly accepts it. When Kåñëa asks us to surrender unto Him (sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja), this does not mean that Kåñëa is lacking servants and that if we surrender He will profit. Kåñëa can create millions of servants by His mere desire. So that is not the point. But if we surrender to Kåñëa, we shall be saved, for Kåñëa says, ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo mokñayiñyämi: "I shall free you from all sinful reactions." We are suffering here in this material world without any shelter. We even see many people loitering in the street, with no aim in life. When we go walking by the beach in the early morning, we see many young people sleeping or loitering there, aimless, confused, and not knowing what to do. But if we take shelter of Kåñëa, then we shall know, "Oh, now I have found shelter." Then there will be no more confusion, no more hopelessness. I receive so many letters daily from people expressing how they have found hope in Kåñëa consciousness. Therefore, it is not a fact that Kåñëa descended here merely to collect some servants. Rather, He descended for our benefit.

Unfortunately, however, instead of becoming Kåñëa's servants, we are becoming servants of so many other things. We are servants of our senses and the sensual activities of lust, anger, greed, and illusion. Actually the whole world is serving in this way. But if we engage our senses in the service of Kåñëa, we shall no longer be servants of the senses, but masters of the senses. When we have the strength to refuse to allow our senses to be engaged other than in the service of Kåñëa, then we shall be saved.

Here Kuntédevé says, "Your appearance in this material world is misleading, bewildering." We think, "Kåñëa has some mission, some purpose, and therefore He has appeared." No, it is for His pastimes that He appears. For example, sometimes a governor goes to inspect a prison. He gets reports from the prison superintendent, so he has no business going there, but still he sometimes goes, thinking, "Let me see how they are doing." This may be called a pastime because he is going by his free will. It is not that he has become subject to the laws of the prison. But still a foolish prisoner may think, "Oh, here the governor is also in prison. So we are equal. I am also governor." Rascals think like that. "Because Kåñëa has descended as an avatära," they say, "I am also an avatära." So here it is said, na veda kaçcid bhagavaàç cikérñitam: "No one knows the purpose of Your appearance and disappearance." Tavehamänasya nåëäà viòambanam: the Lord's pastimes are bewildering. No one can understand their real purpose.

The real purpose of the Lord's pastimes is His free will. He thinks, "Let Me go and see." He doesn't need to come to kill the demons. He has so many agents in the material nature that can kill them. For example, in a moment He can kill thousands of demons merely by a strong wind. Nor does He need to come to give protection to the devotees, for He can do everything simply by His will. But He descends to enjoy pleasure pastimes. "Let Me go and see."

Sometimes Kåñëa even wants to enjoy the pleasure pastimes of fighting. The fighting spirit is also in Kåñëa, otherwise wherefrom have we gotten it? Because we are part and parcel of Kåñëa, all the qualities of Kåñëa are present in minute quantity within us. We are samples of Kåñëa. Wherefrom do we get the fighting spirit? It is present in Kåñëa. Therefore, just as a king sometimes engages a wrestler to fight with him, Kåñëa also engages living entities to engage in fighting. The wrestler is paid to fight with the king. He is not the king's enemy; rather, he gives pleasure to the king by mock fighting. But when Kåñëa wants to fight, who will fight with Him? Not anyone ordinary. If a king wants to practice mock fighting, he will engage some very qualified wrestler. Similarly, Kåñëa does not fight with anyone ordinary, but rather with some of His great devotees. Because Kåñëa wants to fight, some of His devotees come down to this material world to become His enemies and fight with Him. For example, the Lord descended to kill Hiraëyakaçipu and Hiraëyäkña. Should we think that these were ordinary living entities? No, they were the great devotees Jaya and Vijaya, who came to this world because Kåñëa wanted to fight. In the Vaikuëöha world, the spiritual world, there is no possibility of fighting, because everyone there engages in Kåñëa's service. With whom will He fight? Therefore He sends some devotee in the garb of an enemy and comes here to this material world to fight with him. At the same time, the Lord teaches us that becoming His enemy is not very profitable and that it is better to become His friend. Kuntédevé therefore says, na veda kaçcid bhagavaàç cikérñitam: "No one knows the purpose of Your appearance and disappearance." Tavehamänasya nåëäà viòambanam: "You are in this world just like an ordinary human being, and this is bewildering."

Because Kåñëa sometimes appears like an ordinary man, people sometimes cannot believe or understand His activities. They wonder, "How can God become an ordinary person like us?" But although Kåñëa sometimes plays like an ordinary person, in fact He is not ordinary, and whenever necessary He displays the powers of God. When sixteen thousand girls were kidnapped by the demon Bhaumäsura, they prayed to Kåñëa, and therefore Kåñëa went to the demon's palace, killed the demon, and delivered all the girls. But according to the strict Vedic system, if an unmarried girl leaves her home even for one night, no one will marry her. Therefore when Kåñëa told the girls, "Now you can safely return to your fathers' homes," they replied, "Sir, if we return to the homes of our fathers, what will be our fate? No one will marry us, because this man kidnapped us."

"Then what do you want?" Kåñëa asked. The girls replied, "We want You to become our husband." And Kåñëa is so kind that He immediately said yes and accepted them.

Now, when Kåñëa brought the girls back home to His capital city, it is not that each of the sixteen thousand wives had to wait sixteen thousand nights to meet Kåñëa. Rather, Kåñëa expanded Himself into sixteen thousand forms, constructed sixteen thousand palaces, and lived in each palace with each wife.

Although this is described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam, rascals cannot understand this. Instead they criticize Kåñëa. "He was very lusty," they say. "He married sixteen thousand wives." But even if He is lusty, He is unlimitedly lusty. God is unlimited. Why sixteen thousand? He could marry sixteen million and still not reach the limits of His perfection. That is Kåñëa. We cannot accuse Kåñëa of being lusty or sensuous. No. There are so many devotees of Kåñëa, and Kåñëa shows favor to all of them. Some ask Kåñëa to become their husband, some ask Kåñëa to become their friend, some ask Kåñëa to become their son, and some ask Kåñëa to become their playmate. In this way, there are millions and trillions of devotees all over the universe, and Kåñëa has to satisfy them all. He does not need any help from these devotees, but because they want to serve Him in a particular way, the Lord reciprocates. These sixteen thousand devotees wanted Kåñëa as their husband, and therefore Kåñëa agreed.

Thus Kåñëa may sometimes act like a common man, but as God He expanded Himself into sixteen thousand forms. Once the great sage Närada went to visit Kåñëa and His wives. "Kåñëa has married sixteen thousand wives," he thought. "Let me see how He is dealing with them." Then he found Kåñëa living differently in each of the sixteen thousand palaces. In one palace He was talking with His wife, in another He was playing with His children, in another He was arranging for the marriage of His sons and daughters, and in this way He was engaged in varied pastimes in all of the sixteen thousand palaces. Similarly, in His childhood Kåñëa played just like an ordinary child, but when His mother, Yaçodä, wanted Him to open His mouth so that she could see whether He had eaten dirt, within His mouth He showed her all the universes. This is Kåñëa. Although He plays just like an ordinary human being, when there is need He shows His nature as God. To give another example, Kåñëa acted as the chariot driver of Arjuna, but when Arjuna wanted to see Kåñëa's universal form, Kåñëa immediately showed him a cosmic form with thousands and millions of heads, legs, arms, and weapons. This is Kåñëa.

Kåñëa is completely independent, and He has no friends or enemies, but He plays for the benefit of both His friends and enemies, and when He acts for the benefit of either, the result is the same. That is Kåñëa's absolute nature.

TQK 13: The Vital Force of the Universe

13. The Vital Force of the Universe

janma karma ca viçvätmann
ajasyäkartur ätmanaù
tiryaì-nèñiñu yädaùsu
tad atyanta-viòambanam

TRANSLATION

Of course it is bewildering, O soul of the universe, that You work, though You are inactive, and that You take birth, though You are the vital force and the unborn. You Yourself descend among animals, men, sages, and aquatics. Verily, this is bewildering.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.30

PURPORT

The transcendental pastimes of the Lord are not only bewildering but also apparently contradictory. In other words, they are all inconceivable to the limited thinking power of the human being. The Lord is the all-prevailing Supersoul of all existence, and yet He appears in the form of a boar among the animals, in the form of a human being as Räma, Kåñëa, etc., in the form of a åñi like Näräyaëa, and in the form of an aquatic like a fish. Yet it is said that He is unborn, and He has nothing to do. In the çruti-mantra it is said that the Supreme Brahman has nothing to do. No one is equal to or greater than Him. He has manifold energies, and everything is performed by Him perfectly by automatic knowledge, strength, and activity. All these statements prove without any question that the Lord's activities, forms, and deeds are all inconceivable to our limited thinking power, and because He is inconceivably powerful, everything is possible in Him. Therefore no one can calculate Him exactly; every action of the Lord is bewildering to the common man. He cannot be understood by the Vedic knowledge, but He can be easily understood by the pure devotees because they are intimately related with Him. The devotees therefore know that although He appears among the animals, He is not an animal or a man or a åñi or a fish. He is eternally the Supreme Lord, in all circumstances.

Kunté addresses Kåñëa as viçvätman, the vital force of the universe. In everyone's body there is a vital force. That vital force is the ätmä—the living being, the living entity, the soul. It is because of the presence of that vital force, the soul, that the whole body works. Similarly, there is a supreme vital force. That supreme vital force is Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Therefore, where is the question of His taking birth? In Bhagavad-gétä (4.9) the Lord says:

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna."

In this verse the word divyam especially indicates that the Lord's appearance and activities are spiritual. And elsewhere in the Bhagavad-gétä it is said, ajo 'pi sann avyayätmä. The word aja means "unborn," and avyayätmä means "not subject to destruction." This is the nature of Kåñëa, whose transcendental nature is further described by Kuntédevé in her prayers to the Lord.

In the beginning of her prayers, Kuntédevé said to the Lord, "You are within, and You are without, but still You are invisible." Kåñëa is within everyone's heart (éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati, sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöaù). Indeed, He is within everything, even within the atom (aëòäntara-stha-paramäëu-cayäntara-stham). Kåñëa is within and He is also without. Thus Kåñëa showed Arjuna His external feature as the viçva-rüpa, the gigantic cosmic manifestation.

This external body of Kåñëa is described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. There the hills and mountains are described as the bones of the Lord. Similarly, the great oceans have been described as different holes in the Lord's universal body, and the planet known as Brahmaloka has been described as the upper portion of His skull. Those who cannot see God have thus been advised to see Him in many ways in terms of the material cosmic manifestation, according to the instructions given in the Vedic literature.

There are those who can simply think of God as being great but do not know how great He is. When they think of greatness, they think of very high mountains, the sky, and other planets. Therefore the Lord has been described in terms of such material manifestations so that while thinking of these different manifestations one can think of the Lord. That is also Kåñëa consciousness. If one thinks, "This mountain is the bone of Kåñëa," or if one thinks of the vast Pacific Ocean as Kåñëa's navel, one is in Kåñëa consciousness. Similarly, one may think of the trees and plants as the hairs on Kåñëa's body, one may think of Brahmaloka as the top of Kåñëa's skull, and one may think of the Pätälaloka planetary system as the soles of Kåñëa's feet. Thus one may think of Kåñëa as greater than the greatest (mahato mahéyän).

Similarly, one may think of Kåñëa as smaller than the smallest. That is also a kind of greatness. Kåñëa can manufacture this gigantic cosmic manifestation, and He can also manufacture a small insect. In a book one may sometimes find a small running insect smaller than a period. This is Kåñëa's craftsmanship. Aëor aëéyän mahato mahéyän (Kaöha Up. 1.2.20): He can create something greater than the greatest and smaller than the smallest. Now human beings have manufactured the 747 airplane, which according to their conception is very big. But can they produce an airplane as small as a flying insect? That is not possible. Actual greatness, however, is not one-sided. One who is actually great can become greater than the greatest and smaller than the smallest.

But even the great things men can manufacture in the modern age are still not the greatest things man has created. We have information from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam that Kardama Muni, the father of the great sage Kapiladeva, manufactured a huge plane that resembled a great city. It included lakes, gardens, streets, and houses, and the whole city was able to fly all over the universe. In that plane, Kardama Muni traveled with his wife and showed her all the planets. He was a great yogé, and his wife, Devahüti, was the daughter of Sväyambhuva Manu, a great king. Kardama Muni had desired to marry, and Devahüti told her father, "My dear father, I want to marry that sage." Thus Sväyambhuva Manu brought his daughter to Kardama Muni and said, "Sir, here is my daughter. Please accept her as your wife." She was a king's daughter and was very opulent, but when she joined her austere husband, she had to serve so much that she became lean and thin. In fact, even with insufficient food she was working day and night. Thus Kardama Muni became compassionate. "This woman who has come to me is a king's daughter," he thought, "but under my protection she is not receiving any comfort. So I shall give her some comfort." Thus he asked his wife, "What will make you comfortable?" A woman's nature, of course, is that she wants a good house, good food, fine garments, good children, and a good husband. These are a woman's ambitions. Thus Kardama Muni proved to her that she had received the best husband. By yogic powers he created for her this great airplane and gave her a big house with maidservants and all opulences. Kardama Muni was merely a human being, but he could perform such wonderful things by yogic powers.

Kåñëa, however, is Yogeçvara, the master of all yogic powers. If we get a little mystic power we become important, but Kåñëa is the master of all mystic powers. In Bhagavad-gétä it is said that wherever there is Yogeçvara, Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the master of all mystic powers, and wherever there is Arjuna, who is also known as Pärtha or Dhanur-dhara, everything is present.

We should always remember that if we can keep ourselves always in company with Kåñëa, we shall attain all perfection. And especially in this age, Kåñëa has incarnated as the holy name (kali-käle näma-rüpe kåñëa-avatära, Ädi 17.22). Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu says:

nämnäm akäri bahudhä nija-sarva-çaktis
taträrpitä niyamitaù smaraëe na kälaù
[Çikñäñöaka 2]

"My dear Lord, You are so kind that You are giving me Your association in the form of Your holy name, and this holy name can be chanted in any situation." There are no hard and fast rules for chanting Hare Kåñëa. One can chant Hare Kåñëa anywhere. Children, for example, also chant and dance. It is not at all difficult. While walking, our students take their beads with them and chant. Where is the loss? But the gain is very great, for by chanting we associate with Kåñëa personally. Suppose we were to associate personally with the President. How proud we would feel. "Oh, I am with the President." So should we not feel very much proud if we were to associate with the supreme president, who is able to create many millions of presidents like those of this world? This chanting is our opportunity to do so. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu says, etädåçé tava kåpä bhagavan mamäpi: "My dear Lord, You are so kind to me that You are always prepared to give me Your association." Durdaivam édåçam ihäjani nänurägaù: "But I am so unfortunate that I do not take advantage of this opportunity."

Our Kåñëa consciousness movement is simply requesting people, "Chant Hare Kåñëa." There was a cartoon in some newspaper that depicted an old lady and her husband sitting face to face. The lady is requesting her husband, "Chant, chant, chant." And the husband is answering, "Can't, can't, can't." So in this same way, we are requesting everyone, "Please chant, chant, chant." But they are replying, "Can't, can't, can't." This is their misfortune.

Still, it is our duty to make all such unfortunate creatures fortunate. That is our mission. Therefore we go into the street and chant. Although they say "Can't," we go on chanting. That is our duty. And if somehow or other we place some literature in someone's hand, he becomes fortunate. He would have squandered his hard-earned money in so many nasty, sinful ways, but if he purchases even one book, regardless of the price, his money is properly utilized. This is the beginning of his Kåñëa consciousness. Because he gives some of his hard-earned money for the Kåñëa consciousness movement, he gets some spiritual profit. He is not losing; rather, he is gaining some spiritual profit. Therefore our business is somehow or other to bring everyone to this Kåñëa consciousness movement so that everyone may spiritually profit.

When Kåñëa appeared on earth, not everyone knew that He was the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Although when there was need He proved Himself the Supreme Godhead, He generally appeared to be just like an ordinary human being. Therefore Çukadeva Gosvämé, while describing how Kåñëa played as one of the cowherd boys, points out Kåñëa's identity. Who is this cowherd boy? Çukadeva Gosvämé says, itthaà satäà brahma-sukhänubhütyä [Bhäg. 10.12.11]. The impersonalists meditate upon the impersonal Brahman and thus feel some transcendental bliss, but Çukadeva Gosvämé points out that the source of that transcendental bliss is here—Kåñëa.

Kåñëa is the source of everything (ahaà sarvasya prabhavaù), and therefore the transcendental bliss that the impersonalists try to experience by meditating on the impersonal Brahman in fact comes from Kåñëa. Çukadeva Gosvämé says, "Here is the person who is the source of brahma-sukha, the transcendental bliss that comes from realization of Brahman."

A devotee is always prepared to render service to the Lord (däsyaà gatänäà para-daivatena), but for those who are under the spell of illusory energy, He is an ordinary boy (mäyäçritänäà nara-därakeëa). Ye yathä mäà prapadyante täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham: Kåñëa deals with different living entities according to their conceptions. For those who regard Kåñëa as an ordinary human being, Kåñëa will deal like an ordinary human being, whereas devotees who accept Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead will enjoy the association of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Of course, the object of the impersonalist is the brahmajyoti, the impersonal effulgence of the Supreme, but Kåñëa is the source of that effulgence. Therefore Kåñëa is everything (brahmeti paramätmeti bhagavän iti çabdyate).

Yet the cowherd boys are able to play with that same Kåñëa, the exalted Personality of Godhead. How have they become so fortunate that they are able to play with Him?

itthaà satäà brahma-sukhänubhütyä
däsyaà gatänäà para-daivatena
mäyäçritänäà nara-därakeëa
säkam vijahruù kåta-puëya-puïjäù
(Bhäg. 10.12.11)

The cowherd boys playing with Kåñëa are also not ordinary, for they have attained the highest perfection of being able to play with the Supreme Personality of Godhead. How did they achieve this position? Kåta-puëya-puïjäù: by many, many lives of pious activities. For many, many lives these boys underwent austerities and penances to achieve the highest perfection of life, and now they have the opportunity to play with Kåñëa personally on an equal level. They do not know that Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, for that is the nature of våndävana-lélä, Kåñëa's pastimes in the village of Våndävana.

Not knowing Kåñëa's identity, the cowherd boys simply love Kåñëa, and their love is unending. This is true of everyone in Våndävana. For example, Yaçodämätä and Nanda Mahäräja, Kåñëa's mother and father, love Kåñëa with parental affection. Similarly Kåñëa's friends love Kåñëa, Kåñëa's girlfriends love Kåñëa, the trees love Kåñëa, the water loves Kåñëa, the flowers, the cows, the calves—everyone loves Kåñëa. That is the nature of Våndävana. So if we simply learn how to love Kåñëa, we can immediately transform this world into Våndävana.

This is the only central point—how to love Kåñëa (premä pum-artho mahän). People are generally pursuing dharma, artha, käma, mokña [Bhäg. 4.8.41, Ädi 1.90]—religiosity, economic development, sense gratification, and liberation. But Caitanya Mahäprabhu disregarded these four things. "These are not what is to be achieved in life," He said. The real goal of life is love of Kåñëa.

Of course, human life does not actually begin until there is some conception of religion (dharma). But in the present age, Kali-yuga, dharma is practically nil—there is no religion or morality, and there are no pious activities—and therefore according to Vedic calculations the present human civilization does not even consist of human beings. Formerly people would care about morality and immorality, religion and irreligion, but with the progress of Kali-yuga this is all being vanquished, and people can do anything, without caring what it is. Çrémad-Bhägavatam says, and we can actually see, that in Kali-yuga about eighty percent of the people are sinful. Illicit sex life, intoxication, meat-eating, and gambling are the four pillars of sinful life, and therefore we request that one first break these four pillars, so that the roof of sinful life will collapse. Then by chanting Hare Kåñëa one can remain established in a transcendental position. It is a very simple method. One cannot realize God if one's life is sinful. Therefore Kåñëa says:

yeñäà tv anta-gataà päpaà
janänäà puëya-karmaëäm
te dvandva-moha-nirmuktä
bhajante mäà dåòha-vratäù

"Persons who have acted piously in previous lives and in this life, whose sinful actions are completely eradicated, and who are freed from the duality of delusion engage themselves in My service with determination." (Bg. 7.28)

The word anta-gatam means "finished." One can engage in devotional service if one has finished with his sinful life. Who can finish with sinful life? Those who engage in pious activities. One must have activities, and if one engages in pious activities one's sinful activities will naturally vanish. On one side, one should voluntarily try to break the pillars of sinful life, and on another side one must engage himself in pious life.

If one has no pious engagement, it is not that one can become free from sinful activities simply by theoretical understanding. For example, the American government is spending millions of dollars to stop the use of LSD and other such intoxicants, but the government has failed. How is it that simply by passing laws or giving lectures one can make people give up these things? It is not possible. One must give people good engagements, and then they will automatically give up the bad ones. For example, we instruct our students, "No intoxication," and they immediately give it up, even though the government has failed to stop them. This is practical.

Paraà dåñövä nivartate. If someone isn't given good engagement, his bad engagements cannot be stopped. That is not possible. Therefore we have two sides—prohibition of sinful activities, and engagement in good activities. We don't simply say, "No illicit sex," "No intoxication," and so on. Mere negativity has no meaning; there must be something positive, because everyone wants engagement. That is because we are living entities, not dead stones. By meditation the impersonalist philosophers try to become dead stones: "Let me think of something void or impersonal." But how can one artificially make oneself void? The heart and mind are full of activities, so these artificial methods will not help human society.

Methods of so-called yoga and meditation are all rascaldom because they provide one no engagement. But in Kåñëa consciousness there is adequate engagement for everyone. Everyone rises early in the morning to offer worship to the Deities. The devotees prepare nice food for Kåñëa, they decorate the temple, make garlands, go out chanting, and sell books. They are fully engaged twenty-four hours a day, and therefore they are able to give up sinful life. If a child has in his hands something that he is eating but we give him something better, he will throw away the inferior thing and take the better thing. So in Kåñëa consciousness we offer better engagement, better life, better philosophy, better consciousness—everything better. Therefore those who engage in devotional service can give up sinful activities and promote themselves to Kåñëa consciousness.

Activities intended to promote all living entities to Kåñëa consciousness are going on not only in human society but even in animal society also. Because all living entities here are part and parcel of Kåñëa but are rotting in this material world, Kåñëa has a plan, a big plan to deliver them. Sometimes He comes to this world personally, and sometimes He sends His very confidential devotees. Sometimes He leaves instructions like those of Bhagavad-gétä. Kåñëa's incarnation appears everywhere, and He appears among animals, men, sages, and even aquatics (tiryaì-narädiñu yädaùsu). For example, Kåñëa even appeared as a fish incarnation.

Thus Kåñëa's birth, appearance, and disappearance are all bewildering (tad atyanta-viòambanam [Bhäg. 1.8.30]). We conditioned living entities transmigrate from one body to another because we are forced to do so by the laws of nature, but Kåñëa does not appear because He is forced. That is the difference. Those who are foolish rascals think, "I have taken my birth in this world, and Kåñëa has taken birth here also. Therefore I am also God." They do not know that they will have to take birth again by the force of the laws of nature.

One may have been given the chance to have a very beautiful body in a country where one can live in opulence and receive a good education. But if one misuses all this, one will get another body according to one's mentality. For example, at the present moment, despite so many arrangements by the government for good schools and universities, the civilized countries of the world are producing hippies, young people who are so frustrated that they even worship hogs. But if one associates with the qualities of the hogs, one will actually become a hog in one's next birth. Prakåteù kriyamäëäni guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù. Nature will give one a full opportunity: "All right, sir, become a hog." Such are nature's arrangements. Prakåti, nature, has three modes, and if one associates with one type of mode, one will receive his next body accordingly.

Kåñëa's appearance and disappearance are meant to put an end to the living entities' transmigration from one body to another, and therefore one should understand the greatness of the plan behind Kåñëa's appearance and disappearance. It is not that Kåñëa comes whimsically. He has a great plan, otherwise why should He come here? He is very much eager to take us back home, back to Godhead. That is Kåñëa's business. Therefore He says:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

"Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reaction. Do not fear." (Bg. 18.66) All of us are children of Kåñëa, God, and since we are unhappy because of taking material bodies for repeated birth, death, old age, and disease, He is more unhappy than we are. Our situation in the material body is not at all comfortable, but we are such foolish rascals that we do not care to do anything about this. We are busy trying to arrange for temporary comforts in this life, but we are neglecting the real discomforts of birth, death, old age, and disease. This is our ignorance and our foolishness, and therefore Kåñëa comes to wake us up from this ignorance and take us back home, back to Godhead.

TQK 14: Lord Kåñëa's Wonderful Activities

14. Lord Kåñëa's Wonderful Activities

gopy ädade tvayi kåtägasi däma tävad
yä te daçäçru-kaliläïjana-sambhramäkñam
vaktraà ninéya bhaya-bhävanayä sthitasya
sä mäà vimohayati bhér api yad bibheti

TRANSLATION

My dear Kåñëa, Yaçodä took up a rope to bind You when You committed an offense, and Your perturbed eyes overflooded with tears, which washed the mascara from Your eyes. And You were afraid, though fear personified is afraid of You. This sight is bewildering to me.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.31

PURPORT

Here is another explanation of the bewilderment created by the pastimes of the Supreme Lord. The Supreme Lord is the Supreme in all circumstances, as already explained. Here is a specific example of the Lord's being the Supreme and at the same time a plaything in the presence of His pure devotee. The Lord's pure devotee renders service unto the Lord out of unalloyed love only, and while discharging such devotional service the pure devotee forgets the position of the Supreme Lord. The Supreme Lord also accepts the loving service of His devotees more relishably when the service is rendered spontaneously out of pure affection, without anything of reverential admiration. Generally the Lord is worshiped by the devotees in a reverential attitude, but the Lord is meticulously pleased when the devotee, out of pure affection and love, considers the Lord to be less important than himself. The Lord's pastimes in the original abode, Goloka Våndävana, are exchanged in that spirit. The friends of Kåñëa consider Him one of them. They do not consider Him to be of reverential importance. The parents of the Lord (who are all pure devotees) consider Him a child only. The Lord accepts the chastisements of the parents more cheerfully than the prayers of the Vedic hymns. Similarly, He accepts the reproaches of His fiancees more palatably than the Vedic hymns. When Lord Kåñëa was present in this material world to manifest His eternal pastimes of the transcendental realm Goloka Våndävana as an attraction for the people in general, He displayed a unique picture of subordination before His foster mother, Yaçodä. The Lord, in His naturally childish playful activities, used to spoil the stocked butter of Mother Yaçodä by breaking the pots and distributing the contents to His friends and playmates, including the celebrated monkeys of Våndävana, who took advantage of the Lord's munificence. Mother Yaçodä saw this, and out of her pure love she wanted to make a show of punishment for her transcendental child. She took a rope and threatened the Lord that she would tie Him up, as is generally done in the ordinary household. Seeing the rope in the hands of Mother Yaçodä, the Lord bowed down His head and began to weep just like a child, and tears rolled down His cheeks, washing off the black ointment smeared about His beautiful eyes. This picture of the Lord is adored by Kuntédevé because she is conscious of the Lord's supreme position. He is feared often by fear personified, yet He is afraid of His mother, who wanted to punish Him just in an ordinary manner. Kunté was conscious of the exalted position of Kåñëa, whereas Yaçodä was not. Therefore Yaçodä's position was more exalted than Kunté's. Mother Yaçodä got the Lord as her child, and the Lord made her forget altogether that her child was the Lord Himself. If Mother Yaçodä had been conscious of the exalted position of the Lord, she would certainly have hesitated to punish the Lord. But she was made to forget this situation because the Lord wanted to make a complete gesture of childishness before the affectionate Yaçodä. This exchange of love between the mother and the son was performed in a natural way, and Kunté, remembering the scene, was bewildered, and she could do nothing but praise the transcendental filial love. Indirectly Mother Yaçodä is praised for her unique position of love, for she could control even the all-powerful Lord as her beloved child.

This pastime presents another opulence of Kåñëa—His opulence of beauty. Kåñëa has six opulences: all wealth, all strength, all influence, all knowledge, all renunciation, and all beauty. The nature of Kåñëa is that He is greater than the greatest and smaller than the smallest (aëor aëéyän mahato mahéyän). We offer obeisances to Kåñëa with awe and veneration, but no one comes to Kåñëa with a rope, saying, "Kåñëa, You have committed an offense, and now I shall bind You." Yet that is the prerogative of the most perfect devotee, and Kåñëa wants to be approached in that way.

Thinking of Kåñëa's opulence, Kuntédevé did not dare take the part of Yaçodä, for although Kuntédevé was Kåñëa's aunt, she did not have the privilege to approach Kåñëa the way He was approached by Yaçodämayé, who was such an advanced devotee that she had the right to chastise the Supreme Personality of Godhead. That was Yaçodämayé's special prerogative. Kuntédevé was simply thinking of how fortunate was Yaçodämayé that she could threaten the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is feared even by fear personified (bhér api yad bibheti [Bhäg. 1.8.31]). Who is not afraid of Kåñëa? No one. But Kåñëa is afraid of Yaçodämayé. This is the superexcellence of Kåñëa.

To give another example of such opulence, Kåñëa is known as Madana-mohana. Madana means Cupid. Cupid enchants everyone, but Kåñëa is known as Madana-mohana because He is so beautiful that He enchants even Cupid. Nonetheless, Kåñëa Himself is enchanted by Çrématé Rädhäräëé, and therefore Çrématé Rädhäräëé is known as Madana-mohana-mohiné, "the enchanter of the enchanter of Cupid." Kåñëa is the enchanter of Cupid, and Rädhäräëé is the enchanter of that enchanter.

These are very exalted spiritual understandings in Kåñëa consciousness. They are not fictional, imaginary, or concocted. They are facts, and every devotee can have the privilege to understand and indeed take part in Kåñëa's pastimes if he is actually advanced. We should not think that the privilege given to Mother Yaçodä is not available to us. Everyone can have a similar privilege. If one loves Kåñëa as one's child, then one will have such a privilege, because the mother has the most love for the child. Even in this material world, there is no comparison to a mother's love, for a mother loves her child without any expectation of return. Of course, although that is generally true, this material world is so polluted that a mother sometimes thinks, "My child will grow up and become a man, and when he earns money, I shall get it." Thus there is still some desire to get something in exchange. But while loving Kåñëa there are no selfish feelings, for that love is unalloyed, free from all material gain (anyäbhiläñitä-çünyam).

We should not love Kåñëa for some material gain. It is not that we should say, "Kåñëa, give us our daily bread, and then I shall love You. Kåñëa, give me this or that, and then I shall love You." There should be no such mercantile exchanges, for Kåñëa wants unalloyed love.

When Kåñëa saw Mother Yaçodä coming with a rope to bind Him, He immediately became very much afraid, thinking, "Oh, Mother is going to bind Me." He began to cry, and the tears washed the mascara from His eyes. Looking at His mother with great respect, He appealed to her with feeling, "Yes, Mother, I have offended you. Kindly excuse Me." Then He immediately bowed His head. Kuntédevé appreciated this scene, for this was another of Kåñëa's perfections. Although He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, He puts Himself under the control of Mother Yaçodä. In Bhagavad-gétä (7.7) the Lord says, mattaù parataraà nänyat kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya: "My dear Arjuna, there is no one superior to Me." Yet that Supreme Personality of Godhead, to whom no one is superior, bows down to Mother Yaçodä, accepting, "My dear Mother, yes, I am an offender."

When Mother Yaçodä saw that Kåñëa had become too much afraid of her, she also became disturbed. She did not actually want Kåñëa to suffer by her punishment. That was not her purpose. But it is a system, still current in India, that when a child creates too much of a disturbance, his mother may bind him up in one place. That is a very common system, so Mother Yaçodä adopted it.

This scene is very much appreciated by pure devotees, for it shows how much greatness there is in the Supreme Person, who plays exactly like a perfect child. When Kåñëa plays like a child, He plays perfectly, when He plays as the husband of sixteen thousand wives He plays perfectly, when He plays as the lover of the gopés He plays perfectly, and as the friend of the cowherd boys He also plays perfectly.

The cowherd boys all depend on Kåñëa. Once they wanted to take fruit from a forest of palm trees, but there was a demon named Gardabhäsura who would not allow anyone to enter that forest. Therefore Kåñëa's cowherd boyfriends said to Kåñëa, "Kåñëa, we want to taste that fruit, if You can arrange for it." Kåñëa immediately said yes, and He and Balaräma went to the forest where that demon was living with other demons, who had all taken the shape of asses. When the ass demons came to kick Kåñëa and Balaräma with their hind legs, Balaräma caught one of them and threw him into the top of a tree, and the demon died. Then Kåñëa and Balaräma killed the other demons the same way. Thus Their cowherd friends were very much obliged to Them.

On another occasion, the cowherd boys were surrounded by fire. Not knowing anyone else but Kåñëa, they immediately called for Him, and Kåñëa was ready: "Yes." Thus Kåñëa immediately swallowed the whole fire. There were many demons that attacked the boys, and every day the boys would return to their mothers and say, "Mother, Kåñëa is so wonderful," and they would explain what had happened that day. And the mothers would say, "Yes, our Kåñëa is wonderful." They did not know that Kåñëa is God, the Supreme Person. They only knew that Kåñëa is wonderful, that's all. And the more they perceived Kåñëa's wonderful activities, the more their love increased. "Perhaps He may be a demigod," they thought. When Nanda Mahäräja, Kåñëa's father, talked among his friends, the friends would talk about Kåñëa and say, "Oh, Nanda Mahäräja, your child Kåñëa is wonderful." And Nanda Mahäräja would respond, "Yes, I see that. Maybe He is some demigod." And even that was not certain—"maybe."

Thus the inhabitants of Våndävana do not care who is God, and who is not. They love Kåñëa, that's all. Those who think of first analyzing Kåñëa to determine whether He is God are not first-class devotees. The first-class devotees are those who have spontaneous love for Kåñëa. How can we analyze Kåñëa? He is unlimited, and therefore it is impossible. We have limited perception, and our senses have limited potency, so how can we study Kåñëa? It is not possible at all. Kåñëa reveals Himself to a certain extent, and that much is sufficient.

We should not be like the Mäyävädé philosophers, who try to find God by speculative deduction. "Neti neti," they say. "God is not this, and God is not that." But what God is they do not know. Materialistic scientists also try to find the ultimate cause, but their process is the same: "Not this, not that." As much as they advance, they will always find "Not this, not that." But what the ultimate cause is, they will never find. That is not possible.

What to speak of finding Kåñëa, materialistic scientists cannot properly understand even material objects. They are trying to go to the moon, but actually they do not know what it is. If they understand what the moon is, why do they come back here? If they knew perfectly what the moon is, they would have resided there by now. They have been trying for the last twenty years to go there and stay, but they are simply seeing, "Not this, not that. There are no living entities, and there is no possibility of our living here." Thus they can report on what is not on the moon, but do they know what is there? No, they do not know. And this is only one planet or one star.

According to the Vedic literature, the moon is regarded as a star. The scientists say that the stars are all suns, but according to Bhagavad-gétä the stars are of the same nature as the moon. In Bhagavad-gétä (10.21) Lord Kåñëa says, nakñaträëäm ahaà çaçé: "Of stars I am the moon." Thus the moon is just like the many stars. What is the nature of the moon? It is bright because it reflects light from the sun. Therefore although the scientists say that the stars are many suns, we do not agree. According to the Vedic calculation, there are innumerable suns, but in every universe there is only one.

What we see in this universe we are seeing imperfectly, and our knowledge is not perfect. We cannot count how many stars or planets there are. We cannot fully understand the material things existing all around us, and therefore how can we understand the Supreme Lord who created this universe? That is not possible. Therefore in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.34) it is said:

panthäs tu koöi-çata-vatsara-sampragamyo
väyor athäpi manaso muni-puìgavänäm
so 'py asti yat-prapada-sémny avicintya-tattve
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

Space is unlimited, and the Brahma-saàhitä suggests: Suppose one travels by spacecraft for millions of years at the velocity of the wind or even the speed of mind. Everyone knows that the mind is so swift that in even one ten-thousandth of a second it can take us millions of miles. If we have seen something millions of miles away, the mind can go there immediately. But even if we can travel at that speed on a spacecraft manufactured by muni-puìgavänäm, the greatest scientists and most thoughtful men, will that be perfection? No. The Brahma-saàhitä says, so 'py asti yat-prapada-sémny avicintya-tattve: still this creation will remain inconceivable to our understanding. And Kåñëa has created all these things, so how can we study Kåñëa? If we cannot understand the things Kåñëa has created, how can we understand Kåñëa? It is not possible at all.

Therefore the mentality of Våndävana is the perfect status of mind for devotees. The inhabitants of Våndävana have no concern with understanding Kåñëa. Rather, they want to love Kåñëa unconditionally. It is not that they think, "Kåñëa is God, and therefore I love Him." In Våndävana Kåñëa does not play as God; He plays there as an ordinary cowherd boy, and although at times He proves that He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the devotees there do not care to know it.

Kuntédevé, however, was not an inhabitant of Våndävana. She was an inhabitant of Hastinäpura, which is outside Våndävana. The devotees outside Våndävana study how great the inhabitants of Våndävana are, but the inhabitants of Våndävana don't care to know how great Kåñëa is. That is the difference between them. So our concern should be simply to love Kåñëa. The more we love Kåñëa, the more we shall become perfect. It is not necessary to understand Kåñëa and how He creates. Kåñëa explains Himself in Bhagavad-gétä, and we should not try to understand much more. We should not bother very much to know Kåñëa. That is not possible. We should simply increase our unalloyed love for Kåñëa. That is the perfection of life.

TQK 15: Beyond Birth and Death

15. Beyond Birth and Death

kecid ähur ajaà jätaà
puëya-çlokasya kértaye
yadoù priyasyänvaväye
malayasyeva candanam

TRANSLATION

Some say that the Unborn is born for the glorification of pious kings, and others say that He is born to please King Yadu, one of Your dearest devotees. You appear in his family as sandalwood appears in the Malaya Hills.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.32

PURPORT

Because the Lord's appearance in this material world is bewildering there are different opinions about the birth of the Unborn. In the Bhagavad-gétä the Lord says that He takes His birth in the material world, although He is the Lord of all creations and He is unborn. So there cannot be any denial of the birth of the Unborn, because He Himself establishes the truth. But still there are different opinions as to why He takes His birth. That is also declared in the Bhagavad-gétä. He appears by His own internal potency to reestablish the principles of religion and to protect the pious and annihilate the impious. That is the mission of the appearance of the Unborn. Still, it is said that the Lord is there to glorify the pious King Yudhiñöhira. Lord Çré Kåñëa certainly wanted to establish the kingdom of the Päëòavas for the good of all in the world. When there is a pious king ruling over the world, the people are happy. When the ruler is impious, the people are unhappy. In the age of Kali in most cases the rulers are impious, and therefore the citizens are also continuously unhappy. But in the case of democracy, the impious citizens themselves elect their representative to rule over them, and therefore they cannot blame anyone for their unhappiness. Mahäräja Nala was also celebrated as a great pious king, but he had no connection with Lord Kåñëa. Therefore Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira is meant here to be glorified by Lord Kåñëa, who had also glorified King Yadu by taking birth in his family. He is known as Yädava, Yaduvéra, Yadunandana, etc., although the Lord is always independent of such obligations. He is just like the sandalwood that grows in the Malaya Hills. Trees can grow anywhere and everywhere, yet because the sandalwood trees grow mostly in the area of the Malaya Hills, the name sandalwood and the Malaya Hills are interrelated. Therefore, the conclusion is that the Lord is ever unborn like the sun, and yet He appears as the sun rises on the eastern horizon. As the sun is never the sun of the eastern horizon, so the Lord is no one's son, but is the father of everything that be.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (4.6) the Lord says:

ajo 'pi sann avyayätmä
bhütänäm éçvaro 'pi san
prakåtià sväm adhiñöhäya
sambhavämy ätma-mäyayä

"Although I am unborn and My transcendental body never deteriorates, and although I am the Lord of all sentient beings, I still appear in every millennium in My original, transcendental form."

Kåñëa is unborn, and we are also unborn, but the difference is that unlike the Lord we have been entangled in a material body. Therefore we cannot keep our position as unborn, but have to take birth and transmigrate from one body to another, with no guarantee of what kind of body we shall receive next. Even in this life, we are obliged to accept one body after another. A child gives up his childhood body and accepts the body of a boy, and the boy gives up his boyhood body to accept a youthful body, which he then gives up for an old body. Therefore it is natural to conclude that when one gives up one's old body, one will have to accept another body; again one will accept the body of a child.

This is a natural cycle of this material world. It is similar to changes of season. After spring comes summer, and after summer comes fall and then winter, and then spring again. Similarly, after day comes night, and after night comes day. And just as these cyclic changes take place one after another, we change from one body to another, and it is natural to conclude that after leaving the present body we shall receive another body (bhütvä bhütvä praléyate).

This conclusion is very logical, it is supported by the çästra, the Vedic literature, and it is also affirmed by the greatest authority, Kåñëa Himself. Therefore why should we not accept it? If one does not accept this—if one thinks that there is no life after death—one is foolish.

There is life after death, and there is also the chance to free oneself from the cycle of repeated birth and death and attain a life of immortality. But because we have been accustomed to accepting one body after another since time immemorial, it is difficult for us to think of a life that is eternal. And the life of material existence is so troublesome that one may think that if there is an eternal life, that life must be troublesome also. For example, a diseased man who is taking very bitter medicine and who is lying down in bed, eating there and passing stool and urine there, unable to move, may find his life so intolerable that he thinks, "Let me commit suicide." Similarly, materialistic life is so miserable that in desperation one sometimes takes to a philosophy of voidism or impersonalism to try to negate his very existence and make everything zero. Actually, however, becoming zero is not possible, nor is it necessary. We are in trouble in our material condition, but when we get out of our material condition we can find real life, eternal life.

Because we are part and parcel of Kåñëa, who is aja, beyond birth and death, we are also aja. How could we be otherwise? If my father is happy and I am the son of my father, why should I be unhappy? I can naturally conclude that I shall enjoy my father's property just as my father is enjoying it. Similarly, God, Kåñëa, is all-powerful, all-beautiful, all-knowledgeable, and complete in everything, and although I may not be complete, I am part and parcel of God, and therefore I have all the qualities of God to a partial extent.

God does not die, so I also shall not die. That is my position. That is explained in Bhagavad-gétä (2.20): na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcit. Describing the soul, Kåñëa says that the soul is never born (na jäyate), and if one is not born how can he die? There is no question of death (mriyate vä). Death is for one who has taken birth, and if one has no birth he can also have no death.

Unfortunately, however, we do not know this. We are conducting scientific research, but we do not know that every living entity is a spiritual soul, with no birth and no death. This is our ignorance. The soul is eternal, everlasting, and primeval (nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëo). The soul does not die with the annihilation of the body (na hanyate hanyamäne çarére). But although the soul does not die, it accepts another body, and this is called bhava-roga, the material disease.

Since Kåñëa is the supreme living entity (nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm), we are exactly like Kåñëa, the difference being that Kåñëa is vibhu, unlimited, whereas we are aëu, limited. Qualitatively, we are as good as Kåñëa. Therefore whatever propensities Kåñëa has, we have also. For example, Kåñëa has the propensity to love someone of the opposite sex, and therefore we have this same propensity. The beginning of love is present in the eternal love between Rädhä and Kåñëa. We are also seeking eternal love, but because we are conditioned by the material laws, our love is interrupted. But if we can transcend this interruption, we can take part in loving affairs similar to those of Kåñëa and Rädhäräëé. Our aim should therefore be to go back home, back to Kåñëa, because since Kåñëa is eternal, we shall there receive an eternal body.

Kunté says, kecid ähur ajaà jätam: the supreme eternal, the supreme unborn, has now taken His birth. But although Kåñëa takes birth, His birth is not like ours. That we should know. The Lord says in Bhagavad-gétä (4.9):

janma karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

"One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna."

It is described in Çrémad-Bhägavatam that when Kåñëa first appeared, He did not take birth from the womb of Devaké; rather, He first appeared in the majestic four-armed form of Viñëu, and then He became a small child on Devaké's lap. Therefore Kåñëa's birth is transcendental, whereas our birth takes place by force, by the laws of nature. Kåñëa is not under the laws of nature; the laws of nature work under Him (mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram). Prakåti, nature, works under the order of Kåñëa, and we work under the order of nature. Kåñëa is the master of nature, and we are servants of nature. Therefore Kuntédevé says, kecid ähuù: "Someone may say that the unborn has taken birth." It may appear that He has taken birth just like us, but in fact He has not. Kuntédevé distinctly says, kecid ähuù: "some foolish persons may say that He has taken birth." Kåñëa Himself also says in Bhagavad-gétä (9.11), avajänanti mäà müòhä mänuñéà tanum äçritam: "Because I have appeared just like a human being, those who are rascals think that I am also just like an ordinary human." Paraà bhävam ajänantaù: "They do not know the mystery behind God's taking birth like a human being."

Kåñëa is everywhere. The Lord is situated in everyone's heart (éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati). And since He is within us and is all-powerful, why should it be difficult for Him to appear before us? When the great devotee Dhruva Mahäräja was engaged in meditation on the four-handed form of Viñëu, all of a sudden his meditation broke, and he immediately saw before him the same form upon which he had been meditating. Was it very difficult for Kåñëa to appear in this way? Of course not. Similarly it was not difficult for Him to appear before Devaké in the same four-handed form. Therefore Kåñëa says, janma karma ca me divyam: "One must understand My transcendental birth and activities." Kuntédevé has this understanding. She knows that although to some fools Kåñëa appears to take birth, in fact He is unborn.

But why should Kåñëa perform the pastime of taking birth? Kuntédevé replies, puëya-çlokasya kértaye: [Bhäg. 1.8.32] to glorify those who are very pious and very much advanced in spiritual understanding. Kåñëa comes as the son of Devaké to glorify His devotee Devaké. Kåñëa becomes the son of Yaçodä to glorify Yaçodä. Similarly, Kåñëa appears in the dynasty of Mahäräja Yadu, His great devotee, just to glorify Mahäräja Yadu. Thus Kåñëa is still known as Yädava, the descendant of Mahäräja Yadu. Kåñëa has no obligation to take His birth in a particular family or country, but He takes birth to glorify a certain person or a certain family because of their devotion. Therefore His birth is called divyam, transcendental.

The Lord is not obliged to take birth, but we are obliged to do so. That is the distinction between our birth and the birth of Kåñëa. If by our karma, or activities, we are fit to take birth in a good family in human society or demigod society, we shall do so, but if our activities are low like those of animals, we shall have to take birth in a family of animals. That is the force of karma. Karmaëä daiva-netreëa jantor dehopapattaye (Bhäg. 3.31.1). We develop a certain type of body according to our karma.

The human form of life is meant for understanding the Supreme, the Absolute Truth (athäto brahma-jijïäsä). But if we do not endeavor for this, if we misuse this opportunity and simply remain like animals, we shall return to an animal form of life. Therefore the Kåñëa consciousness movement is trying to save people from going down to animal life.

The appearance of Lord Kåñëa is compared to the growth of sandalwood trees in the Malaya Hills (malayasyeva candanam [Bhäg. 1.8.32]). There are two Malayas—the Malaya Hills and the part of the world now known as Malaysia. The candana tree, or sandalwood tree, can grow anywhere—there is no rule that it has to grow in Malaysia or the Malaya Hills—but because this sandalwood grows in large quantities in those parts of the world, it is known as malaya-candana. In the Western countries there is scented water known as eau de cologne. It can be manufactured anywhere, but because it was originally manufactured in the city of Cologne, it is known as eau de cologne. Similarly, sandalwood can grow anywhere, but because it was originally very prominent in Malaysia and the Malaya Hills, it is known as Malayan sandalwood. Kunté offered this prayer five thousand years ago, and this indicates that sandalwood was growing five thousand years ago in Malaysia. Malaysia is not a new name; it was known thousands and thousands of years ago to the followers of the Vedic culture. Nowadays, of course, Malaysia is growing rubber trees because there is a good demand for rubber, but formerly Malaysia grew sandalwood on a large scale because there was a great demand for sandalwood, especially in India.

Because India is a tropical country and sandalwood is very cooling people in India use sandalwood pulp as a cosmetic. Even now, during the very warm days of the summer season, those who can afford to do so apply sandalwood pulp to their bodies and feel cool all day. In India it was the system that after bathing and sanctifying the body by applying marks of tilaka, one would offer obeisances to the Deity, take some candana-prasäda from the room of the Deity, and apply it as a cosmetic to the body. This was called prasädhanam. But it is said that in Kali-yuga, the present age, snänam eva prasädhanam (Bhäg. 12.2.5): if one can even bathe nicely, that is prasädhana. In India even the poorest man will take an early morning bath every day, but when I came to America I saw that even taking one's daily bath may be a difficult thing and is often not the practice. In India we are accustomed to see people bathe thrice in a day, but in New York I have seen that one may have to go to a friend's house to bathe because one may not have facilities to do so at home. These are symptoms of Kali-yuga. Snänam eva prasädhanam. In the Kali-yuga it will be very difficult even to take a bath.

Another symptom of Kali-yuga is däkñyaà kuöumba-bharaëam (Bhäg. 12.2.6): one will be famous for his pious activities simply if he can maintain his family. The word däkñyam, meaning "famous for pious activities," comes from dakña, which means "expert." In Kali-yuga one will be considered expert if he can maintain a family consisting of himself, his wife, and one or two children. In India, of course, the traditional family is the joint family, consisting of a man and his wife, their parents and children, their in-laws, and so on. But in Kali-yuga it will be difficult to maintain a simple family of oneself, one's wife, and a few children. When I was living in New York, among the people coming to our classes was an old lady who had a grown son. I asked her, "Why doesn't your son get married?" She replied, "Yes, he can marry when he can maintain a family." I did not know that maintaining a family was such a difficult job here. But this is described in the Bhägavatam: if one can maintain a family, he will be considered a very glorious man, and if a girl has a husband she will be considered very fortunate.

It is not our business to criticize, but the symptoms of Kali-yuga are very severe, and they will grow more severe. The duration of Kali-yuga is 432,000 years, and although only 5,000 years of it have passed, already we find so many difficulties, and the more we grow into this Kali-yuga, the more the times will be difficult. The best course, therefore, is to complete our Kåñëa consciousness and return home, back to Godhead. That will save us. Otherwise, if we come back again for another life in Kali-yuga, we shall find difficult days ahead, and we shall have to suffer more and more.

TQK 16: Returning to Our Natural Consciousness

16. Returning to Our Natural Consciousness

apare vasudevasya
devakyäà yäcito 'bhyagät
ajas tvam asya kñemäya
vadhäya ca sura-dviñäm

TRANSLATION

Others say that since both Vasudeva and Devaké prayed for You, You have taken Your birth as their son. Undoubtedly You are unborn, yet You take Your birth for their welfare and to kill those who are envious of the demigods.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.33

PURPORT

It is also said that Vasudeva and Devaké, in their previous birth as Sutapä and Påçni, underwent a severe type of penance to get the Lord as their son, and as a result of such austerities the Lord appeared as their son. It is already declared in the Bhagavad-gétä that the Lord appears for the welfare of all people in the world and to vanquish the asuras, or the materialistic atheists.

The Lord says:

yadä yadä hi dharmasya
glänir bhavati bhärata
abhyutthänam adharmasya
tadätmänaà såjämy aham

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time I descend Myself." (Bg. 4.7) The words dharmasya gläniù mean "irregularities in religion." When there are irregularities, religion becomes polluted.

In human society there must be a proper balance between spirit and matter. We are actually spirit soul, but somehow or other we have been encaged within material bodies, and as long as we have these bodies we have to accept the bodily necessities of eating, sleeping, mating, and defending, although the soul itself does not need these things. The soul does not need to eat anything; whatever we eat is for the upkeep of the body. But a civilization that simply looks after these bodily necessities and does not care for the necessities of the soul is a foolish, unbalanced civilization. Suppose one merely washes one's coat but does not take care of one's body. Or suppose one has a bird in a cage but merely takes care of the cage, not the bird within it. This is foolishness. The bird is crying, "Ka, ka. Give me food, give me food." If one only takes care of the cage, how can the bird be happy?

So why are we unhappy? In the Western countries there is no scarcity of wealth, no scarcity of food, no scarcity of cars, and no scarcity of sex. Everything is available in full abundance. Then why is there still a section of people who are frustrated and confused, like the hippies? They are not satisfied. Why? Because there is no balance. We are taking care of the necessities of the body, but we have no information of the soul and its necessities. The soul is the real substance, and the body is only a covering. Therefore neglect of the soul is a form of dharmasya gläniù, pollution of duty.

The word dharma means "duty." Although the word dharma is often translated as "religion" and religion is generally defined as a kind of faith, dharma is not in fact a kind of faith. Dharma means one's actual constitutional duty. It is one's duty to know the needs of the soul, but unfortunately we have no information of the soul and are simply busy supplying the necessities for bodily comfort.

Bodily comfort, however, is not enough. Suppose a man is very comfortably situated. Does it mean he will not die? Of course not. We speak of a struggle for existence and survival of the fittest, but bodily comforts alone cannot enable anyone to exist or survive permanently. Therefore, taking care of the body only is called dharmasya gläëiù, or pollution of one's duty.

One must know the necessities of the body and also the necessities of the soul. The real necessity in life is to supply the comforts of the soul, and the soul cannot be comforted by material adjustments. Because the soul is a different identity, the soul must be given spiritual food, and that spiritual food is Kåñëa consciousness. When one is diseased, he must be given the proper diet and the proper medicine. Both are required. If he is simply given medicine but not a proper diet, the treatment will not be very successful. Therefore the Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant to give both the proper medicine and the proper diet for the soul. The diet is kåñëa-prasäda, food that has first been offered to Kåñëa, and the medicine is the Hare Kåñëa mantra.

nivåtta-tarñair upagéyamänäd
bhavauñadhäc chrotra-mano-'bhirämät
ka uttamaçloka-guëänuvädät
pumän virajyeta vinä paçu-ghnät
(Bhäg. 10.1.4)

Parékñit Mahäräja said to the great sage Çukadeva Gosvämé, "The discourses on Çrémad-Bhägavatam that you are giving me are not ordinary. These Bhägavata discourses are relishable for persons who are nivåtta-tåñëa, free from hankering." Everyone in this material world is hankering for enjoyment, but one who is free from this hankering can taste how relishable the Bhägavatam is. The word bhägavata refers to anything in relationship to Bhagavän, the Supreme Lord, and the Hare Kåñëa mantra is also bhägavata. Thus Parékñit Mahäräja said that the taste of the Bhägavata can be relished by one who is free from hankering to satisfy material desires. And why should this Bhägavata be tasted? Bhavauñadhi: it is the medicine for our disease of birth and death.

At the present moment, we are in a diseased condition. Materialists do not know what is disease and what is health. They do not know anything, but still they are posing as great scientists and philosophers. They do not inquire, "I do not want to die. Why is death enforced upon me?" Nor do they have any solution to this problem. But still they call themselves scientists. What kind of scientists are they? Advancement in science should bring about knowledge by which misery can be minimized. Otherwise, what is the meaning of science? Scientists may promise that they can help us in the future, but we may ask them, "What are you giving us right now, sir?" A real scientist will not say, "Just go on suffering as you are suffering now, and in the future we shall find some chemicals to help you." No. Ätyantika-duùkha-nivåttiù. The word ätyantika means "ultimate," and duùkha means "sufferings." The aim of human life should be to put an end to the ultimate sufferings, but people do not even know what these ultimate sufferings are. These sufferings are pointed out in Bhagavad-gétä as janma-måtyu-jarä-vyädhi: birth, death, old age, and disease. What have we done to nullify these sufferings? There is no remedy for them in the material world. The ultimate way to relinquish all kinds of suffering is stated in Bhagavad-gétä (8.15), where the Lord says:

mäm upetya punar janma
duùkhälayam açäçvatam
näpnuvanti mahätmänaù
saàsiddhià paramäà gatäù

"After attaining Me, the great souls, who are yogés in devotion, never return to this temporary world, which is full of miseries, because they have attained the highest perfection."

Thus the Lord says that one should approach Him and go back to Him, back home, back to Godhead. But unfortunately people have no knowledge of what God is, whether one can go back home to Him or not, and whether or not it is practical. Because they have no knowledge, they are simply like animals. They pray, "O God, give us our daily bread." But now suppose we ask them, "What is God?" Can they explain? No. Then whom are they asking? Are they merely praying into the air? If I submit some petition, there must be some person to whom the petition is submitted. But they do not know who that person is or where the petition is to be submitted. They say that God is in the sky. But there are also so many birds in the sky. Are they God? People have imperfect knowledge or no knowledge at all. Nonetheless, they pose as scientists, philosophers, writers, and great thinkers, although their ideas are all rubbish.

The only truly worthwhile books are those like Çrémad-Bhägavatam and Bhagavad-gétä. In the Bhägavatam (1.5.10-11) it is said:

na yad vacaç citra-padaà harer yaço
jagat-pavitraà pragåëéta karhicit
tad väyasaà tértham uçanti mänasä
na yatra haàsä niramanty uçik-kñayäù

"Those words which do not describe the glories of the Lord, who alone can sanctify the atmosphere of the whole universe, are considered by saintly persons to be like unto a place of pilgrimage for crows. Since the all-perfect persons are inhabitants of the transcendental abode, they do not derive any pleasure there."

tad-väg-visargo janatägha-viplavo
yasmin prati-çlokam abaddhavaty api
nämäny anantasya yaço 'ìkitäni yat
çåëvanti gäyanti gåëanti sädhavaù

"On the other hand, that literature which is full of descriptions of the transcendental glories of the name, fame, forms, pastimes, etc., of the unlimited Supreme Lord is a different creation, full of transcendental words directed toward bringing about a revolution in the impious lives of this world's misdirected civilization. Such transcendental literatures, even though imperfectly composed, are heard, sung, and accepted by purified men who are thoroughly honest."

Any literature that has no connection with God is just like a place where crows take enjoyment. Where do crows enjoy? In a filthy place. But white swans take pleasure in nice clear waters surrounded by gardens. So even among animals there are natural divisions. The crows will not go to the swans, and the swans will not go to the crows. Similarly, in human society there are men who are like crows and men who are like swans. The swanlike men will come to centers of Kåñëa consciousness, where everything is clear, where there is good philosophy, good transcendental food, good education, good intelligence—everything good—whereas crowlike men will go to clubs, parties, naked dance shows, and so many other such things.

So the Kåñëa consciousness movement is meant for swanlike men, not for men who are like crows. But we can convert the crows into swans. That is our philosophy. Those who were crows are now swimming like swans. That is the benefit of Kåñëa consciousness.

The material world is the world where swans have become crows. In the material world the living entity is encaged in a material body, and he tries to gratify his senses in one body after another. But the reestablishment of dharma will gradually turn crows into swans. For example, a man may be illiterate and uncultured, but he can be converted into an educated, cultured man by training.

This training is possible in the human form of life. I cannot train a dog to become a devotee. That is difficult. Of course, that also can be done, although I may not be powerful enough to do it. When Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu was traveling through the jungles of Jhärikhaëòa the tigers, the snakes, the deer, and all the other animals became devotees. This was possible for Caitanya Mahäprabhu because He is God Himself and can therefore do anything. But although we cannot do that, we can work in human society. Regardless of how fallen a man is, if he follows the instructions of Kåñëa consciousness he can return to his original position. Of course, there are degrees of understanding, but one's original position is that one is part and parcel of God. Understanding of this position is called Brahman realization, spiritual realization, and it is this realization that Kåñëa Himself comes to this world to reestablish.

Lord Kåñëa came to this world at the request of His devotees Vasudeva and Devaké (vasudevasya devakyäà yäcito 'bhyagät [Bhäg. 1.8.33]). Although in their former lives Vasudeva and Devaké were married, they did not have any children. They engaged themselves in severe austerities, and when Kåñëa came before them and asked them what they wanted, they said, "We want a son like You. That is our desire." But how is it possible for there to be another God? Kåñëa is God, and God is one; He cannot be two. So how could there be another God to become the son of Vasudeva and Devaké? Kåñëa therefore said, "It is not possible to find another God, so I Myself shall become your son." So some people say that it is because Vasudeva and Devaké wanted Kåñëa as their son that He appeared.

Although Kåñëa actually comes to satisfy His devotees like Vasudeva and Devaké, when He comes He performs other activities also. Vadhäya ca sura-dviñäm. The word vadhäya means "killing," and sura-dviñäm refers to the demons, who are always envious of the devotees. Kåñëa comes to kill these demons.

An example of a demon is Hiraëyakaçipu. Because Prahläda Mahäräja was a devotee, his father, Hiraëyakaçipu, was so envious that he was prepared to kill his own son, although the little boy's only fault was that he was chanting Hare Kåñëa. This is the nature of demons. Jesus Christ also was killed by the sura-dviñäm, those who were envious of him. What was his fault? His only fault was that he was preaching about God. Yet he had so many enemies, who cruelly crucified him. Therefore Kåñëa comes to kill such sura-dviñäm.

This killing of the envious, of course, can be done without the presence of Kåñëa. By setting to work the natural forces of war, pestilence, famine, and so on, Kåñëa can kill millions of people. He does not need to come here to kill these rascals, for they can be killed simply by His direction, or nature's law. Såñöi-sthiti-pralaya-sädhana-çaktir ekä (Bs. 5.44). Nature has so much power that it can create, maintain, and annihilate everything. Såñöi means "creation," sthiti means "maintenance," and pralaya means "destruction." Nature can create, maintain, and also destroy. This material cosmic manifestation is being maintained by the mercy of nature, by which we are getting sunlight, air, and rain by which to grow our food so that we can eat and grow nicely. But nature is so powerful that at any time it can destroy everything simply by one strong wind. Nature is working under the direction of Kåñëa (mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram). Therefore, if Kåñëa wants demons killed, He can kill millions of them with merely one strong blast of nature's wind.

So to kill the demons Kåñëa does not need to come. When He comes, He does so because He is requested by His devotees like Vasudeva and Devaké, as Kuntédevé indicates by using the word yäcitaù, meaning "being prayed for." Therefore the real cause of His coming is at the request of His devotees, but when He comes He simultaneously shows that He is prepared to kill anyone who is envious of His devotees. Of course, His killing and maintaining are the same because He is absolute. Those who are killed by Kåñëa immediately attain salvation, which generally takes millions of years to get.

So people may say that Kåñëa has come for this purpose or that purpose, but actually Kåñëa comes for the benefit of His devotees. He always looks after the welfare of the devotees, and so from this instruction of Kunté we should understand that we should always be concerned with how to become devotees. Then all good qualities will come upon us.

yasyästi bhaktir bhagavaty akiïcanä
sarvair guëais tatra samäsate suräù
(Bhäg. 5.18.12)

If one simply develops one's dormant, natural devotion for Kåñëa, one will develop all good qualities.

Our devotion for Kåñëa is natural. Just as a son has natural devotion to his father and mother, we have natural devotion to Kåñëa. When there is danger, even materialistic scientists pray to God. Of course, when they are not in danger they defy God, and therefore danger is required in order to teach these rascals that there is God. Jévera svarüpa haya-kåñëera 'nitya-däsa'. Our natural position is to be dependent on God. Artificially we are trying to banish God, saying, "God is dead," "There is no God," or "I am God." But when we give up this rascaldom, Kåñëa will give us all protection.

TQK 17: Lightening the Burden of the World

17. Lightening the Burden of the World

bhärävatäraëäyänye
bhuvo näva ivodadhau
sédantyä bhüri-bhäreëa
jäto hy ätma-bhuvärthitaù

TRANSLATION

Others say that the world, being overburdened like a boat at sea, is much aggrieved, and that Brahmä, who is Your son, prayed for You, and so You have appeared to diminish the trouble.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.34

PURPORT

Brahmä is directly the son of the Supreme Lord, the supreme father, and was not put into the womb of a mother. Therefore he is known as ätma-bhü. This Brahmä is in charge of further creations in the universe, secondarily reflected by the potency of the Omnipotent. Within the halo of the universe there is a transcendental planet known as Çvetadvépa, which is the abode of the Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu, the Paramätmä feature of the Supreme Lord. Whenever there is trouble in the universe that cannot be solved by the administrative demigods, they approach Brahmäjé for a solution, and if it is not to be solved even by Brahmäjé, then Brahmäjé consults with and prays to the Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu for an incarnation and solution to the problems. Such a problem arose when Kaàsa and others were ruling over the earth and the earth became too much overburdened by the misdeeds of the asuras. Brahmäjé, along with other demigods, prayed at the shore of the Kñérodaka Ocean, and they were advised of the descent of Kåñëa as the son of Vasudeva and Devaké. So some people say that the Lord appeared because of the prayers of Brahmäjé.

Kuntédevé is describing the different statements of different persons about why Kåñëa appears. Some say that He appeared at the request of Vasudeva and Devaké, and some say He appeared at the request of Brahmä. Bhärävatäraëäyänye bhuvo näva ivodadhau: "Some say that He appeared just to reduce the burden of the world, which was overburdened like a boat at sea." When the world is overburdened, there must be war, pestilence, famine, epidemics, and so on. This is nature's law.

The earth floats in space among many millions of other planets, all of them bearing huge mountains and oceans. It floats because Kåñëa enters into it, as stated in Bhagavad-gétä (gäm äviçya), just as He enters the atom. The earth is certainly not weightless; rather, it is very heavy. But it floats because the Supreme Spirit is within it.

Everything is lightened by the presence of spirit. One's body will float in water as long as one is alive, but as soon as the spirit soul leaves, the body immediately sinks. As long as a child is alive we can take it along by one hand, but when the child is dead it is heavy. So now we are heavy, but when we are spiritually advanced we will be free from impediments. Now we cannot fly in the air, but the spirit soul is so light that when freed from the body it can go within a second to Vaikuëöhaloka, the spiritual world (tyaktvä dehaà punar janma naiti mäm eti).

Why then does the world become overloaded? It becomes overloaded due to the presence of demons, those who are against devotional service. When mother earth feels this load to be too heavy, Kåñëa comes just to unburden the earth. If a ship is overloaded, its position is very dangerous, for it may sink at any moment. Therefore when mother earth felt too uncomfortable because of being overloaded with demons (sédantyä bhüri-bhäreëa [Bhäg. 1.8.34]), she approached Brahmä, the chief living being within this universe. When there is a need, the chief personalities in the universe approach Brahmä, who approaches Viñëu to ask that He reduce whatever the burden is. Then Viñëu or Kåñëa appears as an incarnation, as stated in Bhagavad-gétä (4.7):

yadä yadä hi dharmasya
glänir bhavati bhärata
abhyutthänam adharmasya
tadätmänaà såjämy aham

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time I descend Myself."

When there is too much lawlessness and there are too many criminals, the state becomes overburdened and disturbed, and the state administrators are puzzled about what to do. Similarly, when the world is overrun by demons and atheists, they create a burden, and the demigods, the pious administrators of the universe, become perplexed. When the people of a state abide by the laws, administration is easy, but if people are criminals they overburden the state administrators. A similar situation sometimes upsets the balance of the cosmic affairs of this material world. Both the demons and the demigods always exist, but when the demoniac power increases, the world is overburdened. It is then that the demigods approach Lord Brahmä for assistance.

Lord Brahmä is one of the twelve authorities known as dvädaça-mahäjana (svayambhür näradaù çambhuù kaumäraù kapilo manuù/ prahlädo janako bhéñmo balir vaiyäsakir vayam, Bhäg. 6.3.20). We have to follow the mahäjanas, the great authorities, if we want to receive transcendental knowledge. The Vedic injunction is, tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet: if one wants to be in knowledge of everything, one must approach a guru, a bona fide authority, a spiritual master. The original guru is Kåñëa. As Kåñëa taught Arjuna, He also taught Brahmä, as stated in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (tene brahma hådä ya ädi-kavaye).

The Çrémad-Bhägavatam describes the original source of the creation, and this should be the actual subject matter of our research work. What is the original source of creation? Janmädy asya yataù: the original source of everything is the source of janma, sthiti, and pralaya—creation, maintenance, and dissolution. Our body has taken birth at a certain date, it lasts for some years—ten years, twenty years, fifty years, or whatever, according to the body—and then it will be finished. Where did this body come from, and when it is destroyed where will it go? There are scientific laws concerning the conservation of energy. What is the source of that energy? There is a source (yato vä imäni bhütäni jäyante), and that source is identified in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

That source is not blind. Rascals think that everything has come from nothing. But how can something come out of nothing? There is no proof that such a thing happens, but fools claim that it does, and therefore they are blind. What is the nature of the original source from whom everything has come, in whom everything exists, and within whom everything will enter? The Bhägavatam (1.1.1) says, janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç cärtheñv abhijïaù. The word abhijïaù indicates that the source of everything is completely conscious.

The word jïa means "knowledge," and abhi means "specific." We have inadequate knowledge of where we have come from and where we shall go after death, and therefore we are not abhijïa, supremely conscious. But the supreme source is abhijïa. He is not a stone or a void. How could He be? The creation itself is evidence of the consciousness of the Supreme. Everyone can appreciate the cosmic manifestation and how nicely it is working. The sun and moon rise exactly on time, without deviating even one ten-thousandth of a second, and the seasons change in the same way, bringing with them fruits and flowers. In this way the entire cosmic manifestation is going on in a very orderly, systematic way. So unless there is some abhijïa—some very clever intelligence who knows everything—how could all this have been created? Some people say that all this has come from nothing. What is this nonsense? Can such a creation come from nothing? Does this idea show very good reasoning? The Bhägavatam says no.

The Bhägavatam tells us that everything comes from the person who is abhijïa, very intelligent and experienced, and that original intelligent person transmitted knowledge to ädi-kavi, the original created being, Lord Brahmä (tene brahma hådä ya ädi-kavaye). Brahmä, the original created being, has an original source, and he is in contact with that source. We understand that we get knowledge from another person with whom we are face to face. But when Brahmä was created he was alone. Therefore, how did he receive knowledge? That is explained in the Bhägavatam: tene brahma hådä. The word hådä means "through the heart." The Supreme Person, Paramätmä, is within the heart of every living being, including Brahmä. Therefore although Brahmä was alone, he received knowledge dictated by the Supreme. The word brahma means "Vedic knowledge." Thus the Vedic knowledge was given first to Lord Brahmä.

The Vedic knowledge is given to everyone because Kåñëa is within everyone's heart (sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñöaù), but one must be qualified to receive that knowledge. Kåñëa helps us by giving us knowledge both from within as the Supersoul (caitya-guru) and from without as the spiritual master.

Brahmä receives knowledge from Kåñëa and distributes that Vedic knowledge, and therefore he is an authority. There are four sampradäyas, or chains of disciplic succession, through which Vedic knowledge is distributed—one from Brahmä, one from Lakñmé, one from Lord Çiva, and one from the four Kumäras. We have to approach an authoritative representative of Kåñëa appearing in one of these sampradäyas, and then we can receive real knowledge. Thus the earth personified approached Brahmä, who prayed to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, "The world is now overburdened with demons, and therefore I request You to appear." Some say, therefore, that the Lord appeared at the request of Brahmä that He lighten the burden of the world.

When Kåñëa appears, He protects the devotees and kills the demons. Therefore Kåñëa in His Näräyaëa form has four hands. In two hands He holds a disc and club with which to kill the demons, and in the other two hands He holds the conchshell and lotus with which to bless and protect the devotees. The Lord says, kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati. Thus Kåñëa bugles with His conchshell, "My devotees will never be vanquished." And with the lotus flower He extends His blessings. The lotus flower, which sometimes also appears in the hand of Lakñmé, is a symbol of blessings.

Now some may say that Kåñëa appeared for this purpose or that purpose, but the real conclusion is that Kåñëa appears for His own pleasure, not because He is bound by any other cause. We take our birth because we are bound by our karma, but Kåñëa, being fully independent, does not come because of someone else's request or because of karma. Rather, He comes by His own free will (ätma-mäyayä). We are compelled to take birth because of Kåñëa's external, material energy, but Kåñëa is not controlled by the mäyä, or energy, of anyone else, and therefore He does not take birth in such a condition. Mäyä, the illusory energy, is under the control of Kåñëa, so how could mäyä control Him? One who thinks that Kåñëa, like us, is controlled by mäyä is described in Bhagavad-gétä as müòha, a fool (avajänanti mäà müòhä mänuñéà tanum äçritam).

Kåñëa is the original Näräyaëa, the original source of the entire cosmic manifestation. Brahmä, or the first living being born just after the creation, is the direct son of Näräyaëa, who as Garbhodakaçäyé Viñëu first entered the material universe. Without spiritual contact, matter cannot create. Those who are seeking the original cause of the material creation should know that the creation takes place when the spirit soul is present. Matter is activated by the spirit soul; it is not that the soul is created by matter.

According to the Buddhist theory, the living force—the living energy we all have—is created by material conditions. At the present moment, the entire world is influenced by this Buddhist theory. The actual fact, however, is that matter develops because of the presence of the living force. We can understand this very easily. After a child is born, he grows, and his body develops, but if the child is born dead—if the spirit soul is not present—the body will not develop. Therefore the spirit is the basis for the development of matter, and not vice versa. Why does a dead child not grow? Because the spirit is not present. A tree grows as long as there is life in it. If we sow the small seed of a banyan tree in good soil and favor it with water, it will grow because the spirit soul is present. But if we were to fry such a seed in fire and then sow it, it would fail to grow because the spirit soul would not be there.

Matter grows and develops because of the presence of the spirit soul, and this principle has been followed from the very beginning of the creation. At the beginning of creation the Supreme Spirit entered the universe, and the first living being, Brahmä, was born on a lotus flower grown from the transcendental abdomen of Viñëu. Accepting that the lotus on which Brahmä was born is matter, we should understand that it is also grown from spirit. Therefore spirit is the basis of creation.

Because the lotus flower on which Lord Brahmä is born is grown from the navel of Viñëu, Lord Viñëu is known as Padmanäbha. Brahmä is known as ätma-bhü because he was begotten directly from the father, Näräyaëa, or Viñëu, without the contact of mother Lakñméjé. Lakñméjé was present near Näräyaëa, engaged in the service of the Lord, but still, without contact with Lakñméjé, Näräyaëa begot Brahmä. That is the omnipotency of the Lord. When we want to beget a child, we need the help of a wife because we cannot beget a child alone. But Kåñëa, Lord Viñëu, produced Lord Brahmä without the help of His wife, Lakñmé, although she was present, because He is not dependent on anything. One who foolishly considers Näräyaëa to be like other living beings should take a lesson from this.

The Vedic literature forbids one to think that other living beings are on an equal level with Näräyaëa.

yas tu näräyaëaà devaà
brahma-rudrädi-daivataiù
samatvenaiva vékñeta
sa päñaëòé bhaved dhruvam
[H.b.v. 1.117]

Someone has invented the word daridra-näräyaëa, trying to show that Näräyaëa has become poor and that the beggar who comes to my door to beg is also Näräyaëa. This is not authorized in the Vedic literature. Näräyaëa is the master of Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune, and only fools think that He somehow becomes poverty-stricken. Rascals say that Näräyaëa, Brahmä, Çiva, all the demigods, you, I, and everyone else are all on the same level. This is foolishness. Näräyaëa is asamordhva. This means that no one can be equal to or greater than Him. Therefore Kåñëa Himself, the original Näräyaëa, says in Bhagavad-gétä, mattaù parataraà nänyät: "There is no one superior to Me." Nor is anyone equal to Him. The word asama means that no one is equal to Him, and anürdhva means that no one is greater than Him. This is the position of the Lord.

Näräyaëa is not an ordinary living being. He is the Personality of Godhead Himself, and He has all the potencies of all the senses in all parts of His transcendental body. An ordinary living being begets a child by sexual intercourse and has no other means to beget a child than the one designed for him. But Näräyaëa is all-powerful, and therefore He can beget a child from His navel. Every part of His body has full potency, as explained in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.32), aìgäni yasya sakalendriya-våttimanti. For example, I can see with my eyes, but Kåñëa can also eat with His eyes. Foolish rascals will say, "You are offering food to Kåñëa, but what has He eaten? It is still here. He has not eaten anything." Such people do not know that Kåñëa can eat just by seeing, for He can do anything with any part of His transcendental body. When a washerman refused to supply cloth to Kåñëa in Mathurä, Lord Kåñëa displayed His transcendental potency by cutting off the man's head with His hand. How was this possible? It was possible by the Lord's omnipotence.

The Lord is complete and independent to do anything and everything by His various potencies. This is explained in the beginning of Çrémad-Bhägavatam by the words abhijïaù svaräö. The word sva-räö indicates that He is self-sufficient, not dependent on anyone. That is the qualification of God. Nowadays there are so many self-proclaimed incarnations of God, but as soon as they have some toothache they immediately say, "Ooooooh, doctor, help me. Save me." If you are God, save yourself. Why go to a doctor? Such people are rascals, and they make it very difficult to spread Kåñëa consciousness. The whole world is now overburdened by such rascals and demons, and therefore the atom bomb is waiting for them by the will of the Supreme.

TQK 18: Liberation from Ignorance and Suffering

18. Liberation from Ignorance and Suffering

bhave 'smin kliçyamänänäm
a vidyä-käma-karmabhiù
çravaëa-smaraëärhäëi
kariñyann iti kecana

TRANSLATION

And yet others say that You appeared to rejuvenate the devotional service of hearing, remembering, worshiping, and so on, in order that the conditioned souls suffering from material pangs might take advantage and gain liberation.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.35

PURPORT

In the Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä the Lord asserts that He appears in every millennium just to reestablish the way of religion. The way of religion is made by the Supreme Lord. No one can manufacture a new path of religion, as is the fashion for certain ambitious persons. The factual way of religion is to accept the Lord as the supreme authority and thus render service unto Him in spontaneous love. A living being cannot help but render service because he is constitutionally made for that purpose. The only function of the living being is to render service to the Lord. The Lord is great, and living beings are subordinate to Him. Therefore, the duty of the living being is just to serve Him only. Unfortunately the illusioned living beings, out of misunderstanding only, become servants of the senses by material desire. This desire is called avidyä, or nescience. And out of such desire the living being makes different plans for material enjoyment centered about a perverted sex life. He therefore becomes entangled in the chain of birth and death by transmigrating into different bodies on different planets under the direction of the Supreme Lord. Unless, therefore, one is beyond the boundary of this nescience, one cannot get free from the threefold miseries of material life. That is the law of nature.

The Lord, however, out of His causeless mercy, because He is more merciful to the suffering living beings than they can expect, appears before them and renovates the principles of devotional service, comprised of hearing, chanting, remembering, serving, worshiping, praying, cooperating, and surrendering unto Him. Adoption of all the abovementioned items, or any one of them, can help a conditioned soul get out of the tangle of nescience and thus become liberated from all material sufferings created by the living being illusioned by the external energy. This particular type of mercy is bestowed upon the living being by the Lord in the form of Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu.

In this very important verse the words bhave 'smin mean "in this material world." The word bhava also means "grow," and it refers to that which has taken birth. In the material world there are six kinds of changes. First there is birth, then growth, and then that which has been born and has grown stays for some time, produces some by-products, and then dwindles and finally vanishes. These six changes are called sad-vikära. The body, for example, takes birth at a certain date, and then it grows and stays for some time. From the body come so many byproducts in the form of sons and daughters, and then the body becomes old and weak, and finally when it is very old it dies.

But when the body is finished, I am not finished. When the gross body comes to an end, I am still present within the subtle body of mind, intelligence, and false ego, and this subtle body carries me to another gross body. Although everyone has to accept a subtle body, the scientists and medical men cannot see it. I have a mind, and you have a mind, but I cannot see your mind, and you cannot see mine. I have intelligence, and you have intelligence, but you cannot see my intelligence, nor can I see yours, because they are very subtle. Similarly, the spirit soul is still more subtle, so what will the materialistic scientists see of it? They cannot see the mind, intelligence, or false ego, what to speak of the soul. Therefore they say, "The body is everything, and there is nothing more." Actually, however, that is not a fact.

The fact is that the spirit soul is very, very small. Bälägra-çata-bhägasya çatadhä kalpitasya ca (Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 5.9). The soul is one ten-thousandth the size of the tip of a hair. Suppose we were to take a hair and divide it into a hundred parts. Could we do it? No. That is not possible. But if we could do it and then divide it again into another one hundred parts, each part would be the size of the spirit soul.

Of course, this is not possible to understand by experimental knowledge, so how can it be learned? One must learn of this from an authority. Our knowledge is so imperfect that it cannot deal with such subtle affairs, and because rascals cannot deal with such things, they think that matter is the cause of life. Nonetheless, they have not been able to demonstrate that life comes from matter. Let them take chemicals in their laboratory and produce even a small insect with hands, legs, and eyes. Every night we see many of such small insects with legs and eyes with which they approach the light. From such small insects up to Brahmä there are 8,400,000 different forms of life, among which we are traveling from body to body, leaving one body and entering another, as stated by Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (tathä dehäntara-präptiù). Therefore, either we must reject Kåñëa's word or reject all the so-called scientific theories that life comes from matter. But we are pledged to Kåñëa consciousness, and therefore we cannot reject Kåñëa's word. We accept Kåñëa when He says that we have to travel from one body to another.

Every living entity within this material world is under the influence of avidyä, ignorance. Avidyä-karma-saàjïänyä tåtéyä çaktir iñyate. God, Kåñëa, has many millions of potencies (paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate), and they have been summarized into three categories—the external potency, the internal potency, and the marginal potency. The marginal potency and the internal potency are of the same spiritual quality, but the third potency, the external potency, is inferior.

viñëu-çaktir parä proktä
kñetrajïäkhyä tathä parä
avidyä-karma-saàjïänyä
tåtéyä çaktir iñyate
(Viñëu Puräëa 6.7.61)

In this material world, everyone is in ignorance (avidyä). Even Brahmä was ignorant until he was given knowledge by Kåñëa. Therefore no one should be proud of his knowledge. Everyone in this material world is a rascal. A particular living entity desires, "If I can get the opportunity to obtain the post of Brahmä, then I can create a big universe." Thus he receives the body of Brahmä. And the small insect thinks, "If I can create a small hole within this room, then I can live very peacefully and eat." Thus Brahmä desires to create a universe, we desire to create a skyscraper, and an ant desires to create a hole in a room, but the quality of the work is the same. We are all fools, however, because we do not realize that because these things are material they will not last. Because of ignorance we think, "This will be very nice. That will be very nice." Käma-karmabhiù. We create some desire (käma), and then we work accordingly. This results in so many difficulties (kliçyanti). To become Brahmä is not a very easy thing. Brahmä is such a big post, and it is given to a very qualified living entity who is highly advanced in austerities and penance. But he is also a living entity like us. In America there are many citizens, and President Ford is also a citizen, but by dint of his ardent labor and diplomacy he captured the post. Still, he is an ordinary citizen. President Nixon, for example, has now been dragged down and is no longer President. This is because he was an ordinary citizen. Similarly, if we like, we may also become Brahmä. Therefore Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says:

kéöa-janma hao yathä tuyä däsa
bahirmukha brahma janme nähi äçä
[Mänasa Deha Geha 5]

"Let me become an insect in a place where Your devotee is present, because if I fall down in the dust of the feet of a devotee my life will be successful." Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says, bahirmukha brahma-janme nähi äçä: "I would not want to be a Brahmä and not be a devotee of Kåñëa."

Because we are in ignorance, mäyä, at any time we may forget Kåñëa. Therefore we must always engage in Kåñëa consciousness so that we shall not forget Him. That is indicated by Kuntédevé by the words çravaëa-smaraëärhäëi. The word çravaëa means "hearing," smaraëa means "remembering," and arhaëa means "worshiping the Deity of Kåñëa." One should always engage oneself in hearing about, remembering, and worshiping Kåñëa. All the centers of the Kåñëa consciousness movement are opened only for this purpose—to facilitate chanting, dancing, and worshiping so that we shall not forget Kåñëa. Sadä tad-bhäva-bhävitaù: if we always think of Kåñëa, there is a chance that we shall remember Kåñëa at the end of life (ante näräyaëa-småtiù).

Everything takes practice. For example, if one wants to dance on the stage, one has to perform many rehearsals to practice how to dance. Then if one becomes an expert dancer, when one dances on stage one will receive acclaim: "Ah, a very good dancer." But one cannot say, "I shall go immediately to the stage and become a good dancer." That is not possible. One may say, "No, no, no. I shall not attend the rehearsal. Just give me the stage, and I shall perform." But the director will not allow this, for one cannot become a good dancer without practice. The real purpose of life is to remember Kåñëa when one's life comes to an end (ante näräyaëa-småtiù). If at the time of death one can remember Kåñëa, one's life is successful.

In this material world one must suffer from material miseries, but rascals do not care to understand this, for they are absorbed in ignorance. A smuggler may go on with his work, even though he knows that he will be arrested and punished. A thief may know that he will be arrested and punished for criminal acts, and he may even have been punished several times, but still he will commit the same crime again (punaù punaç carvita-carvaëänäm [Bhäg. 7.5.30]). Why? Ignorance. He is so much absorbed in ignorance that he does not think, "I am repeatedly stealing and being repeatedly arrested and sent to jail to be punished. Why am I doing this? The result is not good." A person who is too much sexually inclined may suffer many times from venereal disease and have to undergo treatment, but still he will go to a prostitute again. This is avaidha stré-saìga, illegitimate sex. But even legitimate sex involves so many difficulties. After sex, a woman becomes pregnant and has to suffer for ten months, and at the time of delivery there is also sometimes very great danger. And the father, after the child is born, must take care of the child and work hard to provide for its education. Therefore the Vedic literature says, bahu-duùkha-bhäjaù: after sex, legitimate or illegitimate, there are so many troubles. Tåpyanti neha kåpaëäù: but one who is an ignorant rascal will not be satisfied. Instead, he will do the same things again and again (punaù punaç carvita-carvaëänäm [Bhäg. 7.5.30]). This is called bhava-roga, the disease of material existence.

yan maithunädi-gåhamedhi-sukham hi tuccham
kaëòüyanena karayor iva duùkha-duùkham
(Bhäg. 7.9.45)

In the Vedic civilization, therefore, small boys are trained to remain brahmacäré, celibate, and not involve themselves in the troubles of sex. But if one is unable to remain brahmacäré, he is allowed to marry. After being trained in the beginning as a brahmacäré, he will not stay for many years in family life, but will very soon become vänaprastha (retired) and then accept sannyäsa, the renounced order of life.

In this material world everyone is suffering—the birds, the beasts, the trees, the animals, the plants, and even Brahmä and Indra. Indra is also not safe; he is always in anxiety about competitors who may come.

tat sädhu manye 'sura-varya dehinäà
sadä samudvigna-dhiyäm asad-grahät
(Bhäg. 7.5.5)

Why is everyone in this material world always in anxiety? Avidyä-käma-karmabhiù: because they are rascals. Therefore Kåñëa stresses, "You rascal, give up all your nonsense and surrender unto Me." This is Kåñëa's very good mercy. He is the supreme father. Therefore He directly says, sarva-guhyatamam: "This is the most confidential knowledge." Sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja: "You rascal, give up everything and simply surrender unto Me."

Therefore Kunté says, "You have come to teach rascals like this and engage them in hearing, remembering, and worship." This is bhakti. Çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù: [Bhäg. 7.5.23] one should hear and chant about Viñëu, Kåñëa. But as soon as devotees begin to hear and chant about Viñëu, some rascal svämé will say, "No, hearing or chanting any name will do. Why Viñëu? Why not Kälé?" In Bengal there is a group of people who have invented "kälé-kértana," chanting the name of the demigoddess Kälé. What is this nonsense? In the Vedic literature there is no such thing as "kälé-kértana." Kértana means çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù—hearing and chanting about Viñëu, Kåñëa. The Vedic literature recommends harer näma, chanting of the holy name of Hari, Kåñëa, and no one else.

This çravaëaà kértanam, hearing and chanting, was described very nicely by Çukadeva Gosvämé in the Second Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam (2.4.15). He said:

yat-kértanaà yad-smaraëaà yad-ékñaëaà
yad-vandanaà yat-çravaëaà yad-arhaëam
lokasya sadyo vidhunoti kalmañaà
tasmai subhadra-çravase namo namaù

Before speaking Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Çukadeva Gosvämé offered his obeisances to Kåñëa with this verse. He said, "I offer my obeisances unto Him, for simply hearing of Him is subhadra, auspicious." The entire Bhägavatam is glorification of Kåñëa, and this is glorification by Çukadeva Gosvämé. He says that one can be perfectly purified if one either glorifies Kåñëa, meditates upon Him, or simply sits before the Deity of Kåñëa and sees Him, thinking, "How nicely dressed is Kåñëa. How nicely dressed is Rädhäräëé." If one has no ability to chant or if one's mind is so disturbed that one cannot fix it upon Kåñëa, one is given this chance: "Here is the Deity. Simply see Him." If one is engaged in the service of the Deity, there is a good chance of always seeing Him, twenty-four hours a day. While cleansing the floor of the temple, while dressing the Deity, while bathing the Deity, or while offering Him food, one will always see Him. This is the process of devotional service, but people are such fallen rascals that they do not even go see the Deity. "Oh," they think, "what is this Deity worship? It is idol worship." They may worship the statue of Gandhi or someone else, but when asked to come see the worship of the Deity they will say, "No, this is idol worship."

I have seen that in Calcutta in Chaurangi Square there is a statue of Sir Asutosa Mukherji. Throughout the year the crows pass stool on his face, and the stool becomes caked on. So on one day a year the ordinary sweepers cleanse the statue with their brush in the morning, and in the evening some big men come and garland him with flowers. Then after that evening they go away, and again the next morning the crows come to pass stool on his face. So this kind of worship is accepted—sweeping the face of Sir Asutosa Mukherji with the municipal brush—but if we install the Deity of Kåñëa and worship Him nicely, people will say that this is idol worship.

So people are embarrassed by being entangled in avidyä, ignorance, and the method by which to educate them and rescue them from the clutches of this ignorance is devotional service. As explained by Çukadeva Gosvämé, one may chant the name of Kåñëa or meditate upon Kåñëa, or if one cannot meditate one may simply sit down and see Kåñëa. Even a child can see, "Here is Kåñëa. Here is Rädhäräëé." Even a small child or even an animal can do this and benefit, or if one is more intelligent one may offer prayers, and if one is expert and has been trained by a spiritual master one may perform appropriate worship.

Christians and Muslims are also Vaiñëavas, devotees, because they offer prayers to the Lord. "O God," they say, "give us our daily bread." Those who offer this prayer may not know very much and may be at a lower stage, but this is a beginning, because they have approached God. Going to a church or mosque is also pious (catur-vidhä bhajante mäà janäù sukåtino 'rjuna). Therefore those who begin in this way will one day become pure Vaiñëavas. But the atheistic propaganda that one should not go to a church, temple, or mosque is very dangerous to human society.

One may not be very advanced, but one should try at least to do something to understand God. A child is sent to school, and although he may simply learn ABCD, if he is interested he may one day become a very good scholar. Similarly, one day a pious man may become a pure devotee. Why should one give up religion altogether, become completely secular, and simply open a factory in which to manufacture nuts and bolts and work very hard and drink, and eat meat? What kind of civilization is this? It is because of this so-called civilization that people are suffering.

It is by ignorance that people think that by opening factories they will be happy. Why should they open factories? There is no need. There is so much land, and one can produce one's own food grains and eat sumptuously without any factory. Milk is also available without a factory. The factory cannot produce milk or grains. The present scarcity of food in the world is largely due to such factories. When everyone is working in the city to produce nuts and bolts, who will produce food grains? Simple living and high thinking is the solution to economic problems. Therefore the Kåñëa consciousness movement in engaging devotees in producing their own food and living self-sufficiently so that rascals may see how one can live very peacefully, eat the food grains one has grown oneself, drink milk, and chant Hare Kåñëa.

The process of Kåñëa consciousness should be very vigorously propagated all over the world. Simply by seeing the Deity or simply by joining in chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra, people will derive tremendous benefit. If one performs kértana, chanting, one will be able to think of Kåñëa. One may think, "I danced for two hours and chanted Hare Kåñëa. What is the meaning of this?" This is smaraëa, thinking of Kåñëa. One may even think, "I foolishly chanted 'Kåñëa, Kåñëa' for two hours." But that also is smaraëa. Because the Kåñëa consciousness movement is spreading, people are purchasing our books about Kåñëa. Because they are curious they say, "What is this Kåñëa? Let us see the book." Then they immediately see a picture of Rädhä and Kåñëa, and if they open the book they will see more. In the book there are many prayers glorifying Kåñëa. So some will hear about Kåñëa, and others will read, and if they are fortunate enough they will become Kåñëa conscious and engage in the worship of the Deity. These methods of devotional service—hearing, chanting, remembering Kåñëa, and so on—are so perfect that as soon as one takes to them (either all of them, some of them, or even one of them) one becomes purified. Therefore Çukadeva Gosvämé prays, "I offer my worship to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, for simply by remembering Him, simply by glorifying Him, or simply by seeing Him, so many benefits follow."

Çukadeva Gosvämé is one of twelve important spiritual authorities, and these are the authorities we must follow (mahäjano yena gataù sa panthäù). He affirms that by performing these methods of devotional service one will be cleansed of material contamination. When? Sadyaù: immediately, without waiting. This is the great benefit of the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

TQK 19: Crossing Beyond Illusion's Currents

19. Crossing Beyond Illusion's Currents

çåëvanti gäyanti gåëanty abhékñëaçaù
smaranti nandanti tavehitaà janäù
ta eva paçyanty acireëa tävakaà
bhava-pravähoparamaà padämbujam

TRANSLATION

O Kåñëa, those who continuously hear, chant, and repeat Your transcendental activities, or take pleasure in others' doing so, certainly see Your lotus feet, which alone can stop the repetition of birth and death.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.36

PURPORT

The Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa, cannot be seen by our present conditional vision. In order to see Him, one has to change his present vision by developing a different condition of life, full of spontaneous love of Godhead. When Çré Kåñëa was personally present on the face of the globe, not everyone could see Him as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Materialists like Rävaëa, Hiraëyakaçipu, Kaàsa, Jaräsandha, and Çiçupäla were highly qualified personalities by acquisition of material assets, but they were unable to appreciate the presence of the Lord. Therefore, even though the Lord may be present before our eyes, it is not possible to see Him unless we have the necessary vision. This necessary qualification is developed by the process of devotional service only, beginning with hearing about the Lord from the right sources. The Bhagavad-gétä is one of the popular literatures which are generally heard, chanted, repeated, etc., by the people in general, but in spite of such hearing, etc., sometimes it is experienced that the performer of such devotional service does not see the Lord face to face. The reason is that the first item, çravaëa, is very important. If hearing is from the right sources, it acts very quickly. Generally people hear from unauthorized persons. Such unauthorized persons may be very learned by academic qualifications, but because they do not follow the principles of devotional service, hearing from them becomes a sheer waste of time. Sometimes the texts are interpreted fashionably to suit their own purposes. Therefore, first one should select a competent and bona fide speaker and then hear from him. When the hearing process is perfect and complete, the other processes become automatically perfect in their own way.

There are different transcendental activities of the Lord, and each and every one of them is competent to bestow the desired result, provided the hearing process is perfect. In the Bhägavatam the activities of the Lord begin from His dealings with the Päëòavas. There are many other pastimes of the Lord in connection with His dealings with the asuras and others. And in the Tenth Canto the sublime dealings with His conjugal associates, the gopés, as well as with His married wives at Dvärakä are mentioned. Since the Lord is absolute, there is no difference in the transcendental nature of each and every dealing of the Lord. But sometimes people, in an unauthorized hearing process, take more interest in hearing about His dealings with the gopés. Such an inclination indicates the lusty feelings of the hearer, so a bona fide speaker of the dealings of the Lord never indulges in such hearings. One must hear about the Lord from the very beginning, as in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam or any other scriptures, and that will help the hearer attain perfection by progressive development. One should not, therefore, consider that His dealings with the Päëòavas are less important than His dealings with the gopés. We must always remember that the Lord is always transcendental to all mundane attachment. In all the above-mentioned dealings of the Lord, He is the hero in all circumstances, and hearing about Him or about His devotees or combatants is conducive to spiritual life. It is said that the Vedas and Puräëas, etc., are all made to revive our lost relation with Him. Hearing of all these scriptures is essential.

In the previous verses, Kuntédevé has explained that those who have come to this material world are working very hard like asses and have such a hard burden that they cannot bear it. Because their lusty desires have created heavy work that puts them always in trouble, Kåñëa comes to introduce the system by which one can get relief from this continuously troublesome life.

Religion consists of the laws of God. People who do not know this think that religion means faith. But although you may have faith in something and I may have faith in something, and although I may believe you and you may or may not believe me, that is not religion. There is even a supposedly religious mission that says, "You can manufacture your own way." Yata mata tata patha: "Whatever you think is right, that is right." This is their philosophy. But that is not science. Suppose I am a madman. Is whatever I think all right? How could this be? "Two plus two equals four" is science. If I believe that two plus two equals five or three, does it become true? No. So there are laws of God, and when there is dharmasya gläëiù, deviation from these laws, we suffer. Just as we might suffer by violating the laws of the state, as soon as we violate the laws of God we are subjected to so many tribulations.

Now, how are we to get free from these tribulations? Kåñëa comes to free us from them by giving us bhakti-yoga. Kåñëa recommends, "Do this," and if we do it we shall get relief. Prahläda Mahäräja mentions that this bhakti-yoga consists of nine items:

çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù
smaraëaà päda-sevanam
arcanaà vandanaà däsyaà
sakhyam ätma-nivedanam

iti puàsärpitä viñëau
bhaktiç cen nava-lakñaëä
kriyeta bhagavaty addhä
tan manye 'dhétam uttamam

"Hearing and chanting about the transcendental holy name, form, qualities, paraphernalia, and pastimes of Lord Viñëu, remembering them, serving the lotus feet of the Lord, offering the Lord respectful worship, offering prayers to the Lord, becoming His servant, considering the Lord one's best friend, and surrendering everything unto Him (in other words, serving Him with the body, mind, and words)—these nine processes are accepted as pure devotional service. One who has dedicated his life to the service of Kåñëa through these nine methods should be understood to be the most learned person, for he has acquired complete knowledge." (Bhäg. 7.5.23-24)

"Hearing" means hearing about someone's activities, form, qualities, entourage, and so on. If I want to hear about someone, he must have some activities. We hear about history, and what is history? It is but the record of the activities of different persons in different ages. As soon as there is a question of hearing, we must ask what subject matter we should hear about. Çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù: we should hear about the activities of Lord Viñëu, or Lord Kåñëa, not about the news in the newspaper. Brahma-jijïäsä: we should inquire and hear about Brahman, the Supreme. These are the statements of the Vedas. In our Kåñëa consciousness movement, we also hear and chant, but what is the subject matter? The subject matter is Kåñëa. We are not hearing about market reports and the price of this share or that share. No. We are hearing about Kåñëa.

And when there is hearing, there must also be speaking or chanting. So we speak and chant about Kåñëa (çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù). And as soon as one becomes expert in hearing and chanting, the next stage is smaraëam, thinking or meditation. Whatever we speak or hear we shall later contemplate or meditate upon. First one must begin with çravaëam, hearing, otherwise how can there be meditation? If one does not know the subject matter of meditation, where is the question of meditation? Therefore there must be hearing and chanting about Lord Viñëu (çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù).

Actual meditation in yoga aims at seeing the four-armed Viñëu mürti, which is the form of the Lord within the heart. That is real meditation. Now rascals have manufactured other methods they call meditation, but these are not actually meditation. The senses are very restless, going this way and that way with the mind, but by the añöäìga-yoga system, which regulates one's sitting posture, one's breath, and so on, one can control the senses and concentrate the mind on the form of Viñëu. This concentration is called samädhi, and it is the real goal of yoga. Thus the añöäìga-yoga system aims at coming to the point of smaraëam, or remembering the Supreme Lord.

The next process of devotional service is arcanam, worship of the Deity, the form of Kåñëa in the temple.

çré-vigrahärädhana-nitya-nänä-
çåìgära-tan-mandira-märjanädau
(Çré-gurv-añöaka 3)

It is not that one should worship Kåñëa once a week or once a month. Rather, one should worship Kåñëa twenty-four hours a day (nitya). The Deity should have a new dress every day or twice or four times a day—as many times as possible. This is called çåìgära. Kåñëa is the most opulent enjoyer, and we should supply Him things by which He can enjoy. For instance, if someone gives me new clothing, I say, "Oh, this new clothing is very nice," and this is my enjoyment. Similarly, we should try to satisfy Kåñëa every day with gorgeous clothing. The dress for the Deity should be first class, the food offered to Him must be first class, and the place where He is situated in the temple must be first class or even more than first class. Furthermore, the temple should always be as clean as glass. Everyone remarks that the temples of the Kåñëa consciousness movement are very clean, and they must be very clean. The more one cleanses the temple, the more one's heart becomes cleansed. This is the process of devotional service. The more we dress Kåñëa, the more satisfied we become. At the present moment we are accustomed to seeing and appreciating our own clothing. I think, "What costly clothing I have," and in this way I become satisfied. But when we dress Kåñëa we shall feel spiritual satisfaction.

yuktasya bhaktäàç ca niyuïjato 'pi
vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam
[Gurv-añöaka 7]

It is the duty of the spiritual master to engage his disciples always in worshiping the Deity in this way, and it is to such a guru, or spiritual master, that we offer our obeisances.

By the word çåëvanti Kuntédevé indicates that our first concern should be to hear about Kåñëa. One must be eager to hear. Why do we pay a college fee and go to college? To hear. By sitting down and hearing from the learned professor, we get knowledge. Therefore a devotee always engages in hearing about Kåñëa. For those who are cultivating Kåñëa consciousness, the first business is hearing.

And if one has actually heard about Kåñëa, one's next engagement in bhakti-yoga will be to chant (gäyanti). The preachers of the Kåñëa consciousness movement go from town to town, village to village. Why? What is their purpose? To preach, to chant, so that people may get the opportunity to hear this philosophy and take it seriously (gåëanti). The word abhékñëaçaù indicates that these engagements should go on continuously, twenty-four hours a day without stopping. Caitanya Mahäprabhu therefore recommends, kértanéyaù sadä hariù: one should engage in chanting twenty-four hours a day. That is the business of Kåñëa conscious devotees.

One may perform all the methods of devotional service or may accept only one. Simply hearing is enough. Parékñit Mahäräja did not do anything else but sit down before Çukadeva Gosvämé and hear for the last seven days of his life. If one simply hears, without doing anything else, if one simply sits down in the temple and whenever there is talk of Bhagavad-gétä one goes on hearing, that will be enough. Even if you do not understand, please hear. The vibration, the mantra, will help you. Grammatical or scholarly understanding is not very important. One may not know Sanskrit grammar, but bhakti is apratihatä, unimpedable. Nothing can check the progress of bhakti. Therefore one should simply adopt this process of hearing, as recommended by Caitanya Mahäprabhu.

After Caitanya Mahäprabhu accepted the renounced order of life, he was criticized by Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya, who had been a schoolfriend of Nélämbara Cakravarté, the father-in-law of Caitanya Mahäprabhu's father, Jagannätha Miçra. By this relationship, Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya was on the level of Caitanya Mahäprabhu's grandfather. Thus he said to Caitanya Mahäprabhu, "You are a boy only twenty-four years old, and now You have taken sannyäsa. Sannyäsa is very difficult to keep, because for a young man the world has so many attractions. So You should hear Vedänta-sütra." Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya belonged to the Mäyäväda school, and this indicates that hearing is important even among the Mäyävädés, who stress the importance of hearing Vedänta-sütra. The Vaiñëavas, the devotees of Kåñëa, also hear Vedänta-sütra, but not from the Mäyävädés, who falsely interpret it and spoil the process of hearing. The Vaiñëavas actually hear Vedänta-sütra, because they do not interpret it. When Kåñëa says, "I am the Supreme," the Vaiñëavas accept it, and that is the proper way of hearing. If one speculatively interprets the Vedänta-sütra or Bhagavad-gétä, saying, "The word kåñëa means this, and kurukñetra means that," one is simply wasting one's time. One should hear this literature as it is.

Thus although Caitanya Mahäprabhu agreed to hear Vedänta from Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya, He simply went on hearing it for many days but did not ask any questions. Finally Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya said to Him, " My dear boy, You are hearing, but You do not ask any questions. Why is this? Is it that You can't understand? What is the reason You are silent?" Caitanya Mahäprabhu answered, "Yes, I understand. But I am silent because You are explaining the Vedänta-sütra in a speculative way. Therefore I am simply listening to the verses of Vedänta-sütra but not actually listening to you." Thus He indirectly said, "You are explaining the meaning foolishly." Later He said, "The verses of Vedanta-sutra are just like sunshine, but your explanations are like clouds that cover them."

No one needs a lamp to see the sun. Everyone can see it. But if the sun is covered by a cloud, it is very difficult to see. Similarly, the Vedänta-sütra is like the sun, but the Mäyäväda interpretations cover the real meaning. The Mäyävädés never accept the direct meaning. Even big political leaders who are influenced by the Mäyäväda philosophy cover the meaning of the Vedic literature by speculating, "Kurukñetra means this, and dharma-kñetra means that." Our policy, therefore, should be to hear the original, as it is. Then it will be effective. Çravaëaà kértanaà viñëoù: [Bhäg. 7.5.23] Viñëu should be heard as He is. Then one can meditate upon Viñëu and remember Him (smaranti). In this way one becomes jubilant (nandanti). The word nandana means "pleasing," and one comes in touch with the reservoir of pleasure in this way.

Therefore those who are cultivating Kåñëa consciousness have to hear about Kåñëa, speak about Kåñëa, and deal only in relationship with Kåñëa. "By this process," Kuntédevé tells the Lord, "one will one day come to see You." And when one sees God, Kåñëa, what is the effect? Bhava-pravähoparamam. The word praväha means "current." When there are very forceful currents in the river and some animal is thrown in, it will be washed away. Similarly, we are being washed away by the currents of material nature, which come one after another like big waves in the Pacific Ocean. Because we are under the grip of the three modes of material nature (prakåteù kriyamäëäni guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù), we are being washed away. Therefore Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says, mäyära vaçe yaccha bhese': "You are being washed away, carried away, by the currents of material nature." These are the currents of hunger and thirst, of birth, death, and old age, the currents of illusion. We are spirit souls, but because we have been put into the material ocean, the currents are carrying us away. However, if we engage twenty-four hours a day in hearing, chanting, and seriously serving Kåñëa, the current will stop.

Where will the current stop? Kuntédevé says to the Lord, padämbujam: "It will stop at Your lotus feet." One has to learn how to see Kåñëa's lotus feet and offer a little tulasé and sandalwood pulp at the lotus feet of the Lord, and then this current of material life will stop.

There may be currents in the ocean, but if one gets a good boat, one can cross over these currents very nicely. As mentioned in another verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.14.58), samäçritä ye pada-pallava-plavam. A lotus petal is something like a small boat, and therefore this verse says that if one takes shelter of the petal boat of the lotus feet of Kåñëa, the great ocean of birth and death becomes as insignificant as the water contained in the hoofprint of a calf. In India during the rainy season the roads become muddy, and when the cows and calves walk they create holes in which water collects. But of course one can easily jump over a dozen of such puddles at any time. Similarly, although for others the world of birth and death is like a great ocean, for a devotee it is like such a puddle (bhavämbudhir vatsa-padam), and he can jump over it very easily. In this way the devotee attains paraà padam, the supreme abode. Then what about this material world? Padaà padaà yad vipadäm: this is a place not for devotees but for people who are suffering. Therefore Kuntédevé suggests, "This Kåñëa consciousness is the medicine for your suffering. Take it and be happy."

TQK 20: Full Surrender

20. Full Surrender

apy adya nas tvaà sva-kåtehita prabho
jihäsasi svit suhådo 'nujévinaù
yeñäà na cänyad bhavataù padämbujät
paräyaëaà räjasu yojitäàhasäm

TRANSLATION

O my Lord, You have executed all duties Yourself. Are You leaving us today, though we are completely dependent on Your mercy and have no one else to protect us, now when all kings are at enmity with us?

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.37

PURPORT

The Päëòavas are most fortunate because with all good luck they were entirely dependent on the mercy of the Lord. In the material world, to be dependent on the mercy of someone else is the utmost sign of misfortune, but in the case of our transcendental relation with the Lord, it is the most fortunate case when we can live completely dependent on Him. The material disease is due to thinking of becoming independent of everything. But the cruel material nature does not allow us to become independent. The false attempt to become independent of the stringent laws of nature is known as material advancement of experimental knowledge. The whole material world is moving on this false attempt at becoming independent of the laws of nature. Beginning from Rävaëa, who wanted to prepare a direct staircase to the planets of heaven, down to the present age, they are trying to overcome the laws of nature. They are trying now to approach distant planetary systems by electronic mechanical power. But the highest goal of human civilization is to work hard under the guidance of the Lord and become completely dependent on Him. The highest achievement of perfect civilization is to work with valor but at the same time depend completely on the Lord. The Päëòavas were the ideal executors of this standard of civilization. Undoubtedly they were completely dependent on the good will of Lord Çré Kåñëa, but they were not idle parasites of the Lord. They were all highly qualified both by personal character and by physical activities. Still they always looked for the mercy of the Lord because they knew that every living being is dependent by constitutional position. The perfection of life is, therefore, to become dependent on the will of the Lord, instead of becoming falsely independent in the material world. Those who try to become falsely independent of the Lord are called anätha, or without any guardian, whereas those who are completely dependent on the will of the Lord are called sanätha, or those having someone to protect them. Therefore we must try to be sanätha, so that we can always be protected from the unfavorable condition of material existence. By the deluding power of the external, material nature we forget that the material condition of life is the most undesirable perplexity. The Bhagavad-gétä (7.19) therefore directs us that after many, many births one fortunate person becomes aware of the fact that Väsudeva, Kåñëa, is all in all and that the best way of leading one's life is to surrender unto Him completely. That is the sign of a mahätmä. All the members of the Päëòava family were mahätmäs in household life. Mahäräja Yudhiñöhira was the head of these mahätmäs, and Queen Kuntédevé was the mother. The lessons of the Bhagavad-gétä and all the Puräëas, specifically the Bhägavata Puräëa, are therefore inevitably connected with the history of the Päëòava mahätmäs. For them, separation from the Lord was just like the separation of a fish from water. Çrématé Kuntédevé, therefore, felt such separation like a thunderbolt, and the whole prayer of the Queen is to try to persuade the Lord to stay with them. After the Battle of Kurukñetra, although the inimical kings were killed, their sons and grandsons were still there to deal with the Päëòavas. It is not only the Päëòavas who were put into the condition of enmity; all of us are always in such a condition, and the best way of living is to become completely dependent on the will of the Lord and thereby overcome all difficulties of material existence.

After the Battle of Kurukñetra ended and the Päëòavas were established in their kingdom, Kåñëa, before going back home to Dvärakä, was taking leave of His aunt and bidding her farewell. It was at that time that Kunté offered this prayer. Now she directly asks, "Is it a fact that after finishing Your duty You are going away and leaving us alone?" This is the devotee' s position. Kuntédevé says, yeñäà na cänyad bha vataù padämbujät: "We have no means of protection other than Your lotus feet." This is full surrender.

In the process of surrender (çaraëägati) there are six items. The first is that one should completely depend on Kåñëa, and the next is that one should accept everything favorable for Kåñëa's service (änukülyasya saìkalpaù). Änukülyena kåñëänuçélanaà bhaktir uttamä: a symptom of first-class bhakti, devotional service, is that one accepts everything favorable for that service. Another item of surrender is prätikülyasya-vivarjanam, rejecting everything unfavorable to the procedures of Kåñëa consciousness. Sometimes the spiritual master says, "Don't do this," forbidding something unfavorable, and he also recommends that which is favorable: "Do this. Chant Hare Kåñëa." Full surrender, therefore, entails giving up unfavorable things and accepting that which is favorable (änukülyasya saìkalpaù prätikülyayasya-vivarjanam). Furthermore, one should believe with full faith, "Kåñëa will give me protection," and one should count oneself as one of the servants of Kåñëa. These are some of the items of çaraëägati, full surrender.

Now Kuntédevé says, "My dear Kåñëa, if You think that we are well established now that we have our kingdom back, and if You therefore want to leave us, that is not a very good proposal. We are not free yet. Because we have killed so many kings, all their friends and relatives are planning to come fight with us again. So don't think that we are free from all dangers. We are not. And we have no protection other than Your lotus feet. That is our position." Thus she indirectly says to Kåñëa, "Do not leave us. Don't think that we are now safe. Without Your protection, we are always unsafe."

This should be the position of a devotee. We should know that we are actually in danger in this material world. Mäyä, illusion, may catch us at any time, as soon as we are a little inattentive, thinking, "Now I have done my duty. Let me take a little rest." No, there is no rest. We must be always alert.

There is a verse in which Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé says, avyartha-kälatvam: a devotee should be very much careful to see whether his time is being spent unnecessarily. He should ask himself, "Am I now engaged in mäyä's service or Kåñëa's service?" This is a symptom of an advanced devotee. Näma-gäne sadä ruciù: such a devotee is never tired of chanting, singing, or dancing. The word sadä means "always," and ruci means "taste." A devotee always has a taste for chanting Hare Kåñëa: "Oh, very nice. Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare." This is taste. Of course, this taste takes time to awaken, but when Rüpa Gosvämé was chanting he was thinking, "I have only one tongue and two ears. What can I appreciate of chanting? If I could have millions of tongues and trillions of ears, then I could relish something by chanting and hearing." Of course, we should not imitate him, but the devotees of the Kåñëa consciousness movement must at least be very careful to complete their sixteen rounds, their minimum amount of prescribed chanting. Näma-gäne sadä ruciù: we have to increase our taste for singing and chanting Hare Kåñëa.

Furthermore, we should also increase our inclination to live in a place where Kåñëa lives (prétis tad-vasati-sthale). In the vision of higher devotees, Kåñëa actually lives everywhere, but because we are in a lower condition, we should know that for us Kåñëa lives in the temple. Because we do not see Kåñëa everywhere, we should come to the temple to see Kåñëa, who kindly appears there, by His mercy, in a manner in which we can see Him.

Kåñëa has a completely spiritual body (sac-cid-änanda-vigraha), but we do not have the eyes to see what that spiritual body is. We are accustomed to seeing material, gross things (jaòa). We can see stone, metal, wood, and other elements, and because Kåñëa is everything, to be visible to our imperfect eyes He appears in a form of these elements. It is not that Kåñëa is stone or that we are worshiping stone. We are worshiping Kåñëa, but because we cannot see anything except material elements like stone, Kåñëa kindly appears in a form carved from stone. Therefore one should be very much inclined to live within the circle of a temple environment in which the form of Kåñëa is worshiped.

Moreover, one should always think oneself dependent on Kåñëa. This is Kåñëa consciousness. One should always think, "Without Kåñëa my life is useless, and I am in danger." Therefore, while offering her prayers to Kåñëa, Kunté says, "Kåñëa, You are thinking that now we are safe, but I don't think we are safe. We are always in danger. If You think we are safe, who will give us protection? We have no protection other than Your lotus feet. We are encircled by so many enemies because the sons of those who have died in the fight are now preparing to fight with us."

Now, although Kåñëa had come to Kuntédevé to take the dust of the feet of His superior, His aunt, Kuntédevé addresses Him as Prabhu, the Lord, not as her beloved nephew. She knows, "Although Kåñëa is playing the part of my nephew, my brother's son, He is still the supreme master."

The symptoms of a really Kåñëa conscious person are that he knows that Kåñëa is the supreme master, he always thinks himself in danger without Kåñëa, and by taking shelter of Kåñëa's lotus feet he always feels safe. Kåñëa says, kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati: "You may declare to the world that My devotee is never vanquished." (Bg. 9.31) If one becomes a pure devotee of Kåñëa, there is no question of danger. Of course, Kåñëa gives protection to everyone, for without His protection no one can live even for a single moment. But one should not think, "If Kåñëa is giving protection to everyone, what is the use of becoming a devotee?" A king gives protection to every one of his citizens, for that is his duty, but he especially protects his own circle of men. This is not unnatural. If one directly engages in the service of the President, when one is in some difficulty he is especially protected. Although the President gives protection to all the citizens, those who personally associate with him, giving him service, receive special consideration. That is not actually partiality. That is natural. When a gentleman loves all children but has special love for his own children, no one will say, "Oh, why are you loving your own children more than others?" No, that is natural. Similarly, Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä, samo 'haà sarva-bhüteñu: "I am equal to everyone." Kåñëa, being God, loves everyone because everyone is part of Him. Nonetheless, He takes special care of His devotees. Therefore He says, kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati: "My devotee will never be vanquished."

Kåñëa always sees to the comforts of His devotees, and the devotees are always busy seeing that Kåñëa is satisfied. The devotees dress Kåñëa, supply Him food, and always engage in serving Him, and similarly Kåñëa always sees to the happiness of His devotees. This is the intimate relationship between the devotee and Kåñëa. Every living entity has a relationship with Kåñëa, but when one becomes a devotee the relationship becomes intimate. Therefore Kuntédevé says to Kåñëa, "How can You leave us? We are Your intimate friends. We are simply living by Your care, by Your mercy. Don't think that we are safe and that You can therefore leave us. Our life is always under Your mercy, for we have no shelter other than Your lotus feet. Kindly don't leave us." This is Kunté's prayer. Similarly, Narottama däsa Öhäkura sings:

hä hä prabhu nanda-suta, våñabhänu-sutä-yuta
karuëä karaha ei-bära

"Kåñëa, Nanda-suta, You are present with Rädhäräëé, the daughter of King Våñabhänu. Now I fully surrender unto You. Please show me Your mercy." [hari hari! vifale 4]

Without Kåñëa consciousness one thinks, "I shall protect myself, or my society, community, or state will give me protection. I have so many protectors. Why should I care for God? Why shall I go to Kåñëa? Those rascals who have no protection can go to Kåñëa." But the fact is that unless Kåñëa gives one protection one cannot be protected. This is stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (7.9.19): bälasya neha çaraëaà pitarau nåsiàha. When Prahläda Mahäräja offered prayers to Kåñëa as Nåsiàha-deva, he said, "My dear Lord, one should not think that because a child has a father and mother he has full protection." If Kåñëa did not protect a child, the child could not be protected, even if he were to have thousands of fathers and mothers. Prahläda also says, närtasya cägadam udanvati majjato nauù: "It is not that a good physician or good medicine can protect one from disease." Suppose a rich man is suffering from some disease and he hires a first-class physician and takes first-class medicine. Does it mean that his life is guaranteed? No. If Kåñëa does not give him protection, despite good medical treatment and a good supply of medicine he will die. "Similarly," Prahläda continues, "one may have a good boat, but this does not guarantee that he will not drown in the ocean. If You do not protect him he may drown at any moment." Nature offers so many difficulties, and although scientists may try to invent something to check these difficulties in the struggle for existence, unless Kåñëa gives one protection one's inventions will be of no use.

Kuntédevé knows this, and therefore although she is the mother of the great warriors Arjuna and Bhéma, she still thinks, "Although my sons are great warriors, they are not sufficient to give us protection. Nothing can give us protection but Your lotus feet." This verse illustrates the position of a surrendered soul seeking the protection of Kåñëa. If we remain in this position, knowing that our only protector is Kåñëa and that our only duty is to serve Kåñëa, then our life is successful.

TQK 21: What Is Our Actual Value?

21. What Is Our Actual Value?

ke vayaà näma-rüpäbhyäà
yadubhiù saha päëòaväù
bhavato 'darçanaà yarhi
håñékäëäm iveçituù

TRANSLATION

As the name and fame of a particular body is finished with the disappearance of the living spirit, similarly, if You do not look upon us, all our fame and activities, along with the Päëòavas and Yadus, will end at once.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.38

PURPORT

Kuntédevé is quite aware that the existence of the Päëòavas is due to Çré Kåñëa only. The Päëòavas are undoubtedly well established in name and fame and are guided by the great King Yudhiñöhira, who is morality personified, and the Yadus are undoubtedly great allies, but without the guidance of Lord Kåñëa all of them are nonentities, as much as the senses of the body are useless without the guidance of consciousness. No one should be proud of his prestige, power, and fame without being guided by the favor of the Supreme Lord. The living beings are always dependent, and the ultimate dependable object is the Lord Himself. We may, therefore, invent by our advancement of material knowledge all sorts of counteracting material resources, but without being guided by the Lord all such inventions end in fiasco, however strong and stout the reactionary elements may be.

As soon as an important man dies, his name and form become unimportant, even though he may have been a big scientist, politician, or philosopher. As long as we are alive our name, form, and activities are glorious, but as soon as the life is gone the body is but a lump of matter. When an important man is alive he may have so many guards, and no one can go before him or touch him, but when the same man is dead and lying on the floor, one may kick him in the face, and practically no one will care. After the disappearance of the soul, the body of the important man has no value. And what is that soul? It is the energy of Kåñëa, and therefore it is part and parcel of Kåñëa. So when the energy is withdrawn—that is, when Kåñëa is not there—the body becomes unimportant.

Kåñëa's energy and Kåñëa Himself are not different (çakti-çaktimatayor abhedaù). The sun, for example, is energetic, and the sunshine is energy. As long as the sunshine is present the sun is present, and if the sun were not present the sun's energy would also not be there. The energy and the energetic must both exist. Although the Mäyävädé philosophers do not accept the energetic but only the impersonal energy, we must accept both the energy and the energetic.

While the energy works, the energetic remains aloof, just as the sunshine spreads everywhere while the sun itself remains apart. Similarly, there is energy working throughout the cosmic manifestation. The cosmic manifestation consists of earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego. These eight material elements are separated material energies (me bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä), and we can understand that behind these energies there must be an energetic source. For example, we are using electric power, but behind this power are the powerhouse and the engineer. Rascals do not understand this. They simply see the power of this cosmic manifestation, but they do not understand that behind this power is the powermaker, the source of power. Therefore Kåñëa comes and says, "I am the powermaker. I am behind this power."

Kåñëa Himself personally comes because we do not have the eyes to see Kåñëa and cannot understand Him. When we contemplate the form of God, we think that because God created millions and millions of years ago, He must be a very old man. Therefore God personally comes before us so that we can see what He is. This is His kindness. The Lord says in Bhagavad-gétä (4.7):

yadä yadä hi dharmasya
glänir bhavati bhärata
abhyutthänam adharmasya
tadätmänaà såjämy aham

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time I descend Myself."

God comes to this world in person, He leaves behind His instructions like those of Bhagavad-gétä, and He leaves behind His devotees who can explain who God is, but still we are so stubborn that we do not accept God. This is foolishness. In Bhagavad-gétä those who do not accept God are called müòhäù—rascals and fools.

God exists, and God's energy also exists, so if we cannot see God we can at least see His energy. We may not see the electric powerhouse and the engineer within it generating power, but we use electricity in so many ways. Therefore we should inquire where this electricity comes from. This is intelligence, and if one inquires in this way he will eventually find the powerhouse itself. Similarly, if one studies further to find out who is running the powerhouse, one will find a human being. Although the electricity is impersonal and even the powerhouse is impersonal, the man behind everything is a person. Similarly, God is a person. This is a logical conclusion. How can He be impersonal? That which is impersonal has no intelligence. We have invented so many very wonderful machines, but the machines are not intelligent. The intelligence belongs to the operator. Therefore Kåñëa says, mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram: "You are seeing the energy displayed in the wonderful actions and reactions of this material cosmic manifestation, but don't think that they are working independently. No, I am behind them."

Kåñëa further says:

mayä tatam idaà sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

"By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in them." (Bg. 9.4) That which is avyakta, unmanifested, also has mürti, a form. The sky, for example, is avyakta, unmanifest, but it also has a form—the round form of the universe. If we go to the ocean, there also we shall find a form, like that of a big circle. Without form there is nothing; everything has form, even that which is supposedly impersonal.

Therefore the idea that everything is zero or impersonal is foolish. Behind the impersonal feature and the so-called voidness is the supreme form—Kåñëa. Éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù. The word éçvara means "controller." Nature is not controlling itself; the real controller is Kåñëa. Icchänurüpam api yasya ca ceñöate sä. The Brahma-saàhitä (5.44) says that Prakåti, or Durgä—the deity of material nature—is working under the direction of Govinda, Kåñëa. How is she working? Just like a shadow. Below our hand is its shadow, and as our hand moves, the shadow moves. Behind all manifestations there is motion. I have sometimes given the example of the shunting of the big cars in a railway line. The engine gives the motion and pushes one car, which then pushes another and another, and so on. Similarly, who set up the motion of the cosmic manifestation? That original motion-giver is Kåñëa.

Now Kuntédevé says, "We Päëòavas have become famous, and people say that we are very important. Why? Because You are our friend." Kåñëa was the friend of the Päëòavas and specifically the friend of Arjuna, and therefore Arjuna was a great and valorous warrior. But Kuntédevé knew, "People say, 'Oh, the Päëòavas are such great warriors and heroes,' but what is the value of my sons, the Päëòavas?" Similarly, the Yadu dynasty was famous because Kåñëa took His birth in that family. But Kuntédevé says, ke vayam: "What are we? What is our value?" Ke vayaà näma-rüpäbhyäm: [Bhäg. 1.8.38] "We have our name and form, but without You it is all useless. It has no value."

People do not understand this. They are very proud of having a nice body and a nice name. They think, "I am American," "I am Indian," "I am German," and so on. But what is all this? These are simply bogus names and bogus forms with no value.

If we subtract Kåñëa, everything is zero. This is a fact, but people are such rascals that they do not understand this fact. But who can deny it? The American body or Indian body may have a good name, but if it has no consciousness, what is its value? No value. Therefore it is said:

bhagavad-bhakti-hénasya
jätiù çästraà japas tapaù
apräëasyaiva dehasya
maëòanaà loka-raïjanam

"For a person devoid of devotional service to Kåñëa, his birth in a great family or nation, his knowledge of revealed scripture, his performance of austerities and penance, and his chanting of Vedic mantras are all like ornaments on a dead body. Such ornaments simply serve the concocted pleasures of the general populace." (Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya 3.11)

We all have consciousness, but what is this consciousness? It is Kåñëa consciousness. We have forgotten Kåñëa, and therefore we simply say "consciousness," but really "consciousness" means Kåñëa consciousness, because without Kåñëa we cannot have consciousness. Without the sun, how can there be sunshine? Therefore we say "sunshine," and not just "shine." Similarly, "consciousness" means Kåñëa consciousness. This requires a little intelligence to understand, but devotees like Kunté have this intelligence and understanding. Therefore Kunté says, "The Päëòavas and Yadus are so important, but what is actually our value?

Because Kåñëa is bidding farewell, Kunté laments, "You will go, and we shall not be able to see You. What then will be the value of our name and fame?" Bhavato 'darçanaà yarhi håñékäëäm iveçituù [Bhäg. 1.8.38]. She gives the example that without Kåñëa they would be like the senses without life. In this material world we desire sense enjoyment, but without Kåñëa or without Kåñëa consciousness there is no possibility of sense enjoyment. We may have strong arms and legs, but when there is no consciousness—when there is no Kåñëa consciousness—we cannot even utilize them. An intelligent person, therefore, knows that without Kåñëa his senses have no value, and therefore he becomes a devotee. He rightly concludes that because there is an intimate relationship between the senses and Kåñëa, as long as the senses are active it is one's duty to use the senses in the service of Kåñëa. This is bhakti.

To use an example I have given many times, suppose in an assembly one finds a hundred-dollar note that has fallen from someone's pocket. If one takes that note and puts it in one's own pocket, one is a thief because that note does not belong to him. This is called bhoga, false enjoyment. Then again, someone else may think, "Oh, why shall I touch it? It belongs to someone else. Let it remain there. I have nothing to do with it." This is called tyäga, renunciation. So although the hundred-dollar note is the same, one person is trying to enjoy it while another is trying to give it up. But both of them—the bhogé and the tyägé—are fools.

The bhogés are the karmés, those who are working very hard to exploit the resources of the material nature, like the scientists, for example, who are doing research to further such exploitation. Their intention, actually, is to steal. On the other hand, the tyägés, those who are unable to steal, have a "sour grapes" philosophy: "Oh, these things are useless. There is no need of them." Mostly, of course, people are bhogés; that is, they are trying to use everything to enjoy sense gratification. But still there are those who are baffled in sense gratification and who therefore say, "No, no, we don't need these things."

Continuing the example, however, when a hundred-dollar note is found, the person who acts most properly is the one who takes it and says, "Someone has lost this note. Let me find its owner." Upon returning that note, one renders real service. One who takes the note for himself and one who leaves the note where it is are both useless. Similarly, the bhogé and tyägé are both useless. But the bhakta, the devotee, knows that everything belongs to Kåñëa and should therefore be offered to Kåñëa. This is real service.

Everything belongs to Kåñëa. What is the body? It is a combination of material elements—earth, water, fire, air, and the subtle, psychological elements mind, intelligence, and false ego. Kåñëa claims, "All these eight elements are My separated energy." Then how are the body and mind ours? Although I claim that the body is mine, I do not even know how it is working. A tenant in an apartment may pay rent and somehow or other occupy the apartment and enjoy its utilities, although he may not actually know how the heat and tap water are working. Similarly, although we do not know the details of how the body works, we are using this body, which actually belongs not to us but to Kåñëa. This is the real fact. The body consists of the senses and the mind, and therefore the senses and mind also belong to Kåñëa.

I am a spiritual soul, but I have been given the opportunity to utilize a certain type of material body. Because I wanted it, Kåñëa is so kind that He has given it to me. Ye yathä mäà prapadyante täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham. If one wants the body of a king, Kåñëa will give it; if one follows the prescribed method, one will get the body of a king. And if one wants the body of a hog so that one may eat stool, Kåñëa will give one that kind of body also. But now, in the human form of life, one should understand, "Everything belongs to Kåñëa, so why am I hankering to satisfy this body which is supposedly mine? Rather, now that I have this body, let me serve Kåñëa." This is intelligence, and this is bhakti.

Håñékeëa håñékeça-sevanaà bhaktir ucyate: bhakti means to use håñéka, the senses, in the service of Håñékeça, Kåñëa, the master of the senses (tvayä håñékeçena hådi sthitasya yathä karomi). Because I wanted some sense gratification, forgetting that everything actually belongs to Kåñëa, I have been given this body, which is a facility for sense gratification. But the senses have no value without Kåñëa, and therefore the natural conclusion is that the senses belong to Kåñëa. Therefore, since I have these senses, why not use them for Kåñëa's satisfaction? This is bhakti.

TQK 22: Beauty in Kåñëa's Presence

22. Beauty in Kåñëa's Presence

neyaà çobhiñyate tatra
yathedänéà gadädhara
tvat-padair aìkitä bhäti
sva-lakñaëa-vilakñitaù

TRANSLATION

O Gadädhara [Kåñëa], our kingdom is now being marked by the impressions of Your feet, and therefore it appears beautiful. But when You leave, it will no longer be so.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.39

PURPORT

There are certain particular marks on the feet of the Lord which distinguish the Lord from others. The marks of a flag, thunderbolt, and instrument to drive an elephant, and also an umbrella, lotus, disc, etc., are on the bottom of the Lord's feet. These marks are impressed upon the soft dust of the land where the Lord traverses. The land of Hastinäpura was thus marked while Lord Çré Kåñëa was there with the Päëòavas, and the kingdom of the Päëòavas thus flourished by such auspicious signs. Kuntédevé points out these distinguished features and is afraid of ill luck in the absence of the Lord.

In the Cäëakya-çloka, the instructions of the great moralist Cäëakya Paëòita, there is this very nice verse:

påthivé-bhüñaëaà räjä
närénäà bhüñaëaà patiù
çarvaré-bhüñaëaà candro
vidyä sarvasya bhüñaëam

Everything looks beautiful when one is intimately related with it. The sky, for example, becomes beautiful in relationship with the moon. The sky is always present, but on the full-moon night, when the moon and stars shine brilliantly, it looks very nice. Similarly, the state looks very well if there is a good government, with a good king or president. Then everyone is happy, and everything goes on well. Also, although girls are naturally beautiful, a girl looks especially beautiful when she has a husband. Vidyä sarvasya bhüñaëam: but if a person, however ugly, is a learned scholar, that is his beauty. Similarly, everything will look beautiful when Kåñëa is present.

Therefore Kuntédevé thinks, "As long as Kåñëa is with us, everything in our kingdom and our capital, Hastinäpura, is beautiful. But when Kåñëa is absent our kingdom will not be beautiful." She says, "Kåñëa, You are now walking in our kingdom, and the impressions of Your footprints are making everything beautiful. There is sufficient water and fruit, and everything looks beautiful, but when You leave us it will not look beautiful."

It is not that this applied only when Kåñëa was present and Kunté was speaking. Rather, the truth is always the same. Despite the advancement of our civilization, if we cannot bring Kåñëa and Kåñëa consciousness into the center of everything, our civilization will never become beautiful. Those who have joined the Kåñëa consciousness movement were beautiful before they joined, but now that they have become Kåñëa conscious they look especially beautiful. Therefore the newspapers often describe the devotees as "bright-faced. Their countrymen remark, How joyful and beautiful these boys and girls have become." At the present time in America, many of the younger generation are confused and hopeless, and therefore they appear morose and black-faced. Why? Because they are missing the point; they have no aim in life. But the devotees, the Kåñëaites, look very beautiful because of the presence of Kåñëa.

Therefore, what was a fact five thousand years ago, during the time of the Päëòavas, is still a fact now. With Kåñëa in the center, everything becomes beautiful, and Kåñëa can become the center at any time. Kåñëa is always present, and we simply have to invite Him, "My Lord, please come and be in the center." That's all. To give the same example I have given before, zero has no value, but if we bring the number one and place it by the side of zero, the zero becomes ten. So one need not stop whatever one is doing. We never say, "Stop everything material." One simply has to add Kåñëa.

Of course, we have to give up anything which is against Kåñëa consciousness. It is not that because we do not stop material duties, we should not stop meat-eating. We must stop it, for this is contrary to advancement in Kåñëa consciousness. One cannot commit sinful activities and at the same time advance in Kåñëa consciousness. But Kåñëa says, aham tväà sarva-päpebhyo mokñayiñyämi: "Surrender unto Me, and I shall rescue you by giving you liberation from all kinds of sinful reactions."

Every one of us, life after life, is knowingly or unknowingly committing sinful activities. I may knowingly kill an animal, and that is certainly sinful, but even if I do it unknowingly, it is also sinful. While walking on the street we unknowingly kill so many ants, and in the course of our other ordinary dealings—while cooking, while taking water, while using a mortar and pestle to crush spices—we kill so many living beings. Unless we remain Kåñëa conscious, we are liable to be punished for all these unknowingly committed sinful acts.

If a child unknowingly touches fire, does it mean that the fire will excuse the child and not burn? No. Nature's law is so strict, so stringent, that there is no question of an excuse. Even in ordinary law, ignorance is no excuse. If we go to court and say, "I did not know that this action was criminal," this plea does not mean that we shall be excused. Similarly, ignorance is no excuse for transgressing nature's laws. Therefore, if we actually want to be free from the reactions of sinful life, we must be Kåñëa conscious, for then Kåñëa will free us from all sinful reactions. It is therefore recommended, kértanéyaù sadä hariù—one should always chant Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, so that Kåñëa will save us.

We should always keep Kåñëa within our minds, for Kåñëa is like the sun. This is the motto of our Back to Godhead magazine:

kåñëa—sürya sama, mäyä haya andhakära
yähäì kåñëa, tähäì nähi mäyära adhikära
(Cc. Madhya 22.31)

Kåñëa is just like the brilliant sun, and mäyä, ignorance, is just like darkness. When the sun is present, there cannot be darkness. So if we keep ourselves in Kåñëa consciousness always, we cannot be influenced by the darkness of ignorance; rather, we shall always walk very freely in the bright sunshine of Kåñëa. Kuntédevé therefore prays that Kåñëa continue to be present with her and the Päëòavas.

In fact, however, Kåñëa was not leaving the Päëòavas, just as He never left Våndävana. In the çästra, the Vedic literature, it is said, våndävanaà parityajya padam na gacchati: Kåñëa never goes even one step from Våndävana. He is so much attached to Våndävana. How is it, then, that we see that Kåñëa left Våndävana and went to Mathurä and then far away to Hastinäpura and did not return for many years? Actually, Kåñëa did not leave, for all the inhabitants of Våndävana, after Kåñëa left, were always thinking of Him and crying. The only engagement of Mother Yaçodä, Nanda Mahäräja, Rädhäräëé, and all the gopés, cows, calves, and cowherd boys was to think of Kåñëa and cry, and in this way they felt Kåñëa to be present, because Kåñëa's presence can be felt more strongly in separation from Him. That is Caitanya Mahäprabhu's teaching: to love Kåñëa in separation. Çünyäyitaà jagat sarvaà govinda-viraheëa me. Caitanya Mahäprabhu thought, "Everything is vacant without Govinda, without Kåñëa." Everything was vacant, but Kåñëa consciousness was there.

When we see everything as nothing, but have only Kåñëa consciousness, we shall have attained the highest perfection. Therefore the gopés are so exalted. Having attained this perfection, they could not forget Kåñëa even for a single moment. When Kåñëa went to the forest with His cows and calves, the minds of the gopés at home were disturbed. "Oh, Kåñëa is walking barefoot," they thought. "There are so many stones and nails on the path, and they must be pricking Kåñëa's lotus feet, which are so soft that we think our breasts hard when Kåñëa puts His lotus feet upon them." Thus they would cry, absorbed in these thoughts. The gopés were so anxious to see Kåñëa back home in the evening that they would stand on the path, looking to see Kåñëa returning with His calves and cows. This is Kåñëa consciousness.

Kåñëa cannot be absent from a devotee when the devotee is intensely absorbed in Kåñëa thought. Here Kuntédevé is very much anxious, thinking that Kåñëa will be absent, but the actual effect of Kåñëa's physical absence is that He becomes more intensely present within the mind of the devotee. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu, by the example of His actual life, taught vipralambha-sevä, service of Kåñëa in separation. Tears would come from His eyes like torrents of rain, for He would feel everything to be vacant for want of Kåñëa.

There are two stages of meeting Kåñëa. Being personally present with Kåñëa, personally meeting Him, personally talking with Him, and personally embracing Him is called sambhoga, but there is another way to be with Kåñëa—in separation from Him—and this is called vipralambha. A devotee can benefit from Kåñëa's association in both ways.

Because we are now in the material world, we do not see Kåñëa directly. Nonetheless, we can see Him indirectly. For example, if one sees the Pacific Ocean one can remember Kåñëa immediately, if one is advanced in spiritual life. This is called meditation. One may think, "The Pacific Ocean is such a vast mass of water, with many large waves, but although I am standing only a few yards from it, I am confident that I am safe, however powerful this ocean may be and however fearful its waves. I am sure that it will not go beyond its limits. How is this happening? By the order of Kåñëa. Kåñëa orders, 'My dear Pacific Ocean, you may be very big and powerful, but you cannot come beyond this line.'" In this way one can immediately remember Kåñëa, or God, who is so powerful that even the Pacific Ocean abides by His order. In this way one can think of Kåñëa, and that is Kåñëa consciousness.

Similarly, when one sees the sunrise one can immediately remember Kåñëa, for Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä (7.8), prabhäsmi çaçi-süryayoù: "I am the shining of the sun and the moon." If one has learned how to see Kåñëa, one can see Him in the sunshine. Our scientists have not created the sun, and although they may juggle words, it is beyond their ability to know what the sun actually is. But the Vedänta-sütra (1.1.3) says, çästra-yonitvät: one can know everything through the çästra, the Vedic literature. For example, if one studies the Vedic literature one can know what the sun is, for the sun is described in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.52):

yac-cakñur eña savitä sakala-grahäëäà
räjä samasta-sura-mürtir açeña-tejäù
yasyäjïayä bhramati sambhåta-käla-cakro
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

This verse describes the sun as the eye of all the planets, and if one meditates upon this one can understand that this is a fact, for at night, before the sun rises, one cannot see. The sun is also described as the eye of the Lord. The sun is one of His eyes, and the moon is the other. In the Upaniñads, therefore, it is said that only when Kåñëa sees can we see. The sun is also described as açeña-tejäù, unlimitedly hot. And what is its function? Yasyäjïayä bhramati sambhåta-käla-cakraù. The sun has its orbit. God has ordered the sun, "You just travel within this orbit, and not anywhere else." The scientists say that if the sun were to move a little to one side the whole universe would be ablaze, and if it moved to the other side the whole universe would freeze. But by the order of the Supreme it does not move even one ten-thousandth of an inch from where it should be. It always rises exactly at the correct time. Why? There must be some discipline, some obedience, some order. The Brahma-saàhitä therefore says, yasyäjïayä bhramati sambhåta-käla-cakro govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi: "I worship that original person, by whose order the sun moves in its orbit. It is He who gives direction even to the sun, the ocean, and the moon. Everything takes place under His order."

So where is the difficulty in understanding God? There is no difficulty. If one is actually sane, if one has a brain that is not made of stool, one can understand God at every step. The Lord says:

raso 'ham apsu kaunteya
prabhäsmi çaçi-süryayoù
praëavaù sarva-vedeñu
çabdaù khe pauruñaà nåñu

"O son of Kunté [Arjuna], I am the taste of water, the light of the sun and the moon, the syllable oà in the Vedic mantras; I am the sound in ether and ability in man." (Bg. 7.8) Why then do people say, "I have not seen God"? Why don't they see God as God directs them to see Him? Why do they manufacture their own way? One cannot see God by one's own way. That is not possible. If one tries to do so, one will always remain blind. At the present moment so-called philosophers and scientists are trying to see God in their own way, but that is not possible. One has to see God by God's way. Then one can see Him. If I want to see the President of the United States, can I see him in my own way? If not, then how can I expect to see God in my own way? Is it not rascaldom? I cannot see even an ordinary man in an important position in my own way; I have to make an appointment with his secretary and make the other appropriate arrangements. But although God is so much greater than ordinary men, rascals support the view that one can see God in one's own way. "As many ways as you invent," they say, "they are all bona fide." This is rascaldom. The world is full of rascals and fools, and therefore God consciousness, Kåñëa consciousness, has become a vague idea. Otherwise, if one wants to see God, if one wants Him to be always present, as Kuntédevé is requesting that He be, one can keep God always within one s heart.

We simply have to apply our mind and senses in Kåñëa consciousness, as done by Mahäräja Ambaréña. Sa vai manaù kåñëa-padäravindayor vacäàsi vaikuëöha-guëänuvarëane (Bhäg. 9.4.18). First we must fix our minds on the lotus feet of Kåñëa, for the mind is the center of all sensory activities. If the mind were absent, in spite of having eyes we could not see, and in spite of having ears we could not hear. Therefore the mind is considered the eleventh sense. There are ten senses—five working senses and five knowledge-acquiring senses, and the center of the senses is the mind. The Bhagavad-gétä (3.42) says:

indriyäëi paräëy ähur
indriyebhyaù paraà manaù
manasas tu parä buddhir
yo buddheù paratas tu saù

In this verse Kåñëa explains that although we consider the senses to be very prominent, beyond the senses is something superior—the mind—beyond the mind is the intelligence, and beyond the intelligence is the soul.

How can we appreciate the existence of the soul if we cannot understand even the psychological movements of the mind? Beyond the mind is the intelligence, and by speculation one can at the utmost approach the intellectual platform. But to understand the soul and God, one must go beyond the intellectual platform. It is possible to understand everything, but we must gain understanding through the right channel. Therefore the Vedic injunction is:

tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet
samit-päëiù çrotriyaà brahma-niñöham

If one is actually serious about understanding supernatural, transcendental subject matters, one must approach a bona fide spiritual master." (Muëòaka Upaniñad 1.2.12)

TQK 23: Natural Prosperity

23. Natural Prosperity

ime jana-padäù svåddhäù
supakvauñadhi-vérudhaù
vanädri-nady-udanvanto
hy edhante tava vékñitaiù

TRANSLATION

All these cities and villages are flourishing in all respects because the herbs and grains are in abundance, the trees are full of fruits, the rivers are flowing, the hills are full of minerals, and the oceans full of wealth. And this is all due to Your glancing over them.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.40

PURPORT

Human prosperity flourishes by natural gifts and not by gigantic industrial enterprises. The gigantic industrial enterprises are products of a godless civilization, and they cause the destruction of the noble aims of human life. The more we go on increasing such troublesome industries to squeeze out the vital energy of the human being, the more there will be unrest and dissatisfaction of the people in general, although a few only can live lavishly by exploitation. The natural gifts such as grains and vegetables, fruits, rivers, the hills of jewels and minerals, and the seas full of pearls are supplied by the order of the Supreme, and as He desires, material nature produces them in abundance or restricts them at times. The natural law is that the human being may take advantage of these godly gifts by nature and satisfactorily flourish on them without being captivated by the exploitative motive of lording it over material nature. The more we attempt to exploit material nature according to our whims of enjoyment, the more we shall become entrapped by the reaction of such exploitative attempts. If we have sufficient grains, fruits, vegetables, and herbs, then what is the necessity of running a slaughterhouse and killing poor animals? A man need not kill an animal if he has sufficient grains and vegetables to eat. The flow of river waters fertilizes the fields, and there is more than what we need. Minerals are produced in the hills, and the jewels in the ocean. If the human civilization has sufficient grains, minerals, jewels, water, milk, etc., then why should we hanker after terrible industrial enterprises at the cost of the labor of some unfortunate men? But all these natural gifts are dependent on the mercy of the Lord. What we need, therefore, is to be obedient to the laws of the Lord and achieve the perfection of human life by devotional service. The indications by Kuntédevé are just to the point. She desires that God's mercy be bestowed upon them so that natural prosperity be maintained by His grace.

Kuntédevé mentions that the grains are abundant, the trees full of fruits, the rivers flowing nicely, the hills full of minerals, and the oceans full of wealth, but she never mentions that industry and slaughterhouses are flourishing, for such things are nonsense that men have developed to create problems.

If we depend on God's creation, there will be no scarcity, but simply änanda, bliss. God's creation provides sufficient grains and grass, and while we eat the grains and fruits, the animals like the cows will eat the grass. The bulls will help us produce grains, and they will take only a little, being satisfied with what we throw away. If we take fruit and throw away the skin, the animal will be satisfied with the skin. In this way, with Kåñëa in the center, there can be full cooperation between the trees, animals, human beings, and all living entities. This is Vedic civilization, a civilization of Kåñëa consciousness.

Kuntédevé prays to the Lord, "This prosperity is due to Your glance." When we sit in the temple of Kåñëa, Kåñëa glances over us, and everything is nice. When sincere souls try to become Kåñëa's devotees, Kåñëa very kindly comes before them in His full opulence and glances upon them, and they become happy and beautiful.

Similarly, the whole material creation is due to Kåñëa's glance (sa aikñata). In the Vedas it is said that He glanced over matter, thus agitating it.

A woman in touch with a man becomes agitated and becomes pregnant and then gives birth to children. The whole creation follows a similar process. Simply by Kåñëa's glance, matter becomes agitated and then becomes pregnant and gives birth to the living entities. It is simply by His glance that plants, trees, animals, and all other living beings come forth. How is this possible? None of us can say, "Simply by glancing over my wife, I can make her pregnant." But although this is impossible for us, it is not impossible for Kåñëa. The Brahma-saàhitä (5.32) says, aìgäni yasya sakalendriya-våttimanti: every part of Kåñëa's body has all the capabilities of the other parts. With our eyes we can only see, but Kåñëa, merely by seeing, can make others pregnant. There is no need of sex, for simply by glancing, Kåñëa can create pregnancy.

In Bhagavad-gétä (9.10) Lord Kåñëa says, mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram: "By My supervision, material nature gives birth to all moving and nonmoving beings." The word akña means "eyes," so akñeëa indicates that all living entities take birth because of the Lord's glance. There are two kinds of living entities—the moving beings, like insects, animals, and human beings, and the nonmoving beings, like trees and plants. In Sanskrit these two kinds of living entities are called sthävara jaìgama, and they both come forth from material nature.

Of course, what comes from material nature is not the life, but the body. The living entities accept particular types of bodies from material nature, just as a child takes its body from its mother. For ten months the child's body develops from the blood and nutrients of the mother's body, but the child is a living entity, not matter. It is the living entity that has taken shelter in the womb of the mother, who then supplies the ingredients for that living entity's body. This is nature's way. The mother may not know how from her body another body has been created, but when the body of the child is fit, the child takes birth.

It is not that the living entity takes birth. As stated in Bhagavad-gétä (2.20), na jäyate mriyate vä: the living entity neither takes birth nor dies. That which does not take birth does not die; death is meant for that which has been created, and that which is not created has no death. The Gétä says, na jäyate mriyate vä kadäcit. The word kadäcit means "at any time." At no time does the living entity actually take birth. Although we may see that a child is born, actually it is not born. Nityaù çäçvato 'yaà puräëaù. The living entity is eternal (çäçvata), always existing, and very, very old (Puräëa). Na hanyate hanyamäne çarére: don't think that when the body is destroyed the living entity will be destroyed; no, the living entity will continue to exist.

A scientist friend was asking me, "What is the proof of eternity?" Kåñëa says, na hanyate hanyamäne çarére: The soul is not killed when the body is killed." This statement in itself is proof. This type of proof is called çruti, the proof established by that which is heard through the disciplic succession from the Supreme. One form of proof is proof by logic (nyäya-prasthäna). One can get knowledge by logic, arguments, and philosophical research. But another form of proof is çruti, proof established by hearing from authorities. A third form of proof is småti, proof established by statements derived from the çruti. The Bhagavad-gétä and the Puräëas are småti, the Upaniñads are çruti, and the Vedänta is nyäya. Of these three the çruti-prasthäna, or the evidence from the çruti, is especially important.

Pratyakña, the process of receiving knowledge through direct perception, has no value, because our senses are all imperfect. For example, every day we see the sun to be just like a small disc, perhaps twelve inches in diameter, but in fact it is a hundred times larger than the earth. So what is the value of our direct perception through our eyes? We have so many senses through which we can experience knowledge—the eyes, the ears, the nose, and so on—but because these senses are imperfect, whatever knowledge we get by exercising these senses is also imperfect. Because scientists try to understand things by exercising their imperfect senses, their conclusions are always imperfect. Svarüpa Dämodara, a scientist among our disciples, inquired from a fellow scientist who says that life comes from matter, "If I give you the chemicals with which to produce life, will you be able to produce it?" The scientist replied, "That I do not know." This is imperfect knowledge. If you do not know, then your knowledge is imperfect. Why then have you become a teacher? That is cheating. Our contention is that to become perfect one must take lessons from the perfect.

Kåñëa is perfect, so we take knowledge from Him. Kåñëa says, na hanyate hanyamäne çarére: "The soul does not die when the body dies." Therefore this understanding that the soul is eternal is perfect.

Kuntédevé says, ime jana-padäù svåddhäù supakvauñadhi-vérudhaù: [Bhäg. 1.8.40] "The grains are abundant, the trees full of fruits, the rivers flowing, the hills full of minerals, and the ocean full of wealth." What more should one want? The oyster produces pearls, and formerly people decorated their bodies with pearls, valuable stones, silk, gold, and silver. But where are those things now? Now, with the advancement of civilization, there are so many beautiful girls who have no ornaments of gold, pearls, or jewels, but only plastic bangles. So what is the use of industry and slaughterhouses?

By God's arrangement one can have enough food grains, enough milk, enough fruits and vegetables, and nice clear river water. But now I have seen, while traveling in Europe, that all the rivers there have become nasty. In Germany, in France, and also in Russia and America I have seen that the rivers are nasty. By nature's way the water in the ocean is kept clear like crystal, and the same water is transferred to the rivers, but without salt, so that one may take nice water from the river. This is nature's way, and nature's way means Kåñëa's way. So what is the use of constructing huge waterworks to supply water?

Nature has already given us everything. If we want wealth we may collect pearls and become rich; there is no need to become rich by starting some huge factory to produce auto bodies. By such industrial enterprises we have simply created troubles. Otherwise, we need only depend on Kåñëa and Kåñëa's mercy, because by Kåñëa's glance (tava vékñitaiù), everything is set right. So if we simply plead for Kåñëa's glance, there will be no question of scarcity or need. Everything will be complete. The idea of the Kåñëa consciousness movement, therefore, is to depend on nature's gifts and the grace of Kåñëa.

People say that the population is increasing, and therefore they are checking this by artificial means. Why? The birds and bees are increasing their populations and have no contraceptives, but are they in need of food? Do we ever see birds or animals dying for want of food? Perhaps in the city, although not very often. But if we go to the jungle we shall see that all the elephants, lions, tigers, and other animals are very stout and strong. Who is supplying them food? Some of them are vegetarians, and some of them are nonvegetarians, but none of them are in want of food.

Of course, by nature's way the tiger, being a nonvegetarian, does not get food every day. After all, who will face a tiger to become its food? Who will say to the tiger, "Sir, I am a philanthropist and have come to you to give you food, so take my body"? No one. Therefore the tiger has difficulty finding food. And as soon as the tiger is out, there is an animal that follows it and makes a sound like "fayo, fayo," so that the other animals will know, "Now the tiger is out." So by nature's way the tiger has difficulty, but still Kåñëa supplies it food. After about a week, the tiger will get the chance to catch an animal, and because it does not get fresh food daily, it will keep the carcass in some bush and eat a little at a time. Since the tiger is very powerful, people want to become like a lion or a tiger, but that is not a very good proposition, because if one actually becomes like a tiger one won't get food daily, but will have to search for food with great labor. If one becomes a vegetarian, however, one will get food every day. The food for a vegetarian is available everywhere.

Now in every city there are slaughterhouses, but does this mean that the slaughterhouses can supply enough so that one can live by eating only meat? No, there will not be an adequate supply. Even meat-eaters have to eat grains, fruits, and vegetables along with their slice of meat. Still, for that daily slice of meat they kill so many poor animals. How sinful this is. If people commit such sinful activities, how can they be happy? This killing should not be done, and therefore people are unhappy. But if one becomes Kåñëa conscious and simply depends on Kåñëa's glance (tava vékñitaiù), Kåñëa will supply everything, and there will be no question of scarcity.

Sometimes there appears to be scarcity, and sometimes we find that grains and fruits are produced in such a huge quantity that people cannot finish eating them. So this is a question of Kåñëa's glance. If Kåñëa likes, He can produce a huge quantity of grains, fruits, and vegetables, but if Kåñëa desires to restrict the supply, what good will meat do? You may eat me, or I may eat you, but that will not solve the problem.

For real peace and tranquillity and a sufficient supply of milk, water, and everything else we need, we simply have to depend on Kåñëa. This is what Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura teaches us when he says, märabi räkhabi-yo icchä tohärä: "My dear Lord, I simply surrender unto You and depend on You. Now if You like You may kill me, or else You may give me protection." And Kåñëa says in reply, "Yes. Sarva-dharmän parityajya mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja: simply surrender exclusively unto Me." He does not say, "Yes, depend on Me, and also depend on your slaughterhouses and factories." No. He says, "Depend only on Me. Ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo mokñayiñyämi: I will rescue you from the results of your sinful activities."

Because we have lived so many years without being Kåñëa conscious, we have lived only a sinful life, but Kåñëa assures us that as soon as one surrenders to Him He immediately squares all accounts and puts an end to all one's sinful activities so that one may begin a new life. When we initiate disciples we therefore tell them, "Now the account is squared. Now don't commit sinful activities any more."

One should not think that because the holy name of Kåñëa can nullify sinful activities, one may commit a little sinful activity and chant Hare Kåñëa to nullify it. That is the greatest offense (nämno baläd yasya hi päpa-buddhiù). The members of some religious orders go to church and confess their sins, but then they again commit the same sinful activities. What then is the value of their confession? One may confess, "My Lord, out of my ignorance I committed this sin," but one should not plan, "I shall commit sinful activities and then go to church and confess them, and then the sins will be nullified, and I can begin a new chapter of sinful life." Similarly, one should not knowingly take advantage of the chanting of the Hare Kåñëa mantra to nullify sinful activities so that one may then begin sinful acts again. We should be very careful. Before taking initiation, one promises to have no illicit sex, no intoxicants, no gambling, and no meat-eating, and this vow one should strictly follow. Then one will be clean. If one keeps oneself clean in this way and always engages in devotional service, his life will be a success, and there will be no scarcity of anything he wants.

TQK 24: Cutting Off Ties of Affection

24. Cutting Off Ties of Affection

atha viçveça viçvätman
viçva-mürte svakeñu me
sneha-päçam imaà chindhi
dåòhaà päëòuñu våñëiñu

TRANSLATION

O Lord of the universe, soul of the universe, O personality of the form of the universe, please, therefore, sever my tie of affection for my kinsmen, the Päëòavas and the Våñëis.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.41

PURPORT

A pure devotee of the Lord is ashamed to ask anything in self-interest from the Lord. But the householders are sometimes obliged to ask favors from the Lord, being bound by the tie of family affection. Çrématé Kuntédevé was conscious of this fact, and therefore she prayed to the Lord to cut off the affectionate tie from her own kinsmen, the Päëòavas and the Våñëis. The Päëòavas are her own sons, and the Våñëis are the members of her paternal family. Kåñëa was equally related to both families. Both the families required the Lord's help because both were dependent devotees of the Lord. Çrématé Kuntédevé wished Çré Kåñëa to remain with her sons, the Päëòavas, but by His doing so her paternal house would be bereft of the benefit. All these partialities troubled the mind of Kunté, and therefore she desired to cut off the affectionate tie.

A pure devotee cuts off the limited ties of affection for his family and widens his activities of devotional service for all forgotten souls. The typical example is the band of Six Gosvämés, who followed the path of Lord Caitanya. All of them belonged to the most enlightened and cultured rich families of the higher castes, but for the benefit of the mass of population they left their comfortable homes and became mendicants. To cut off all family affection means to broaden the field of activities. Without doing this, no one can be qualified as a brähmaëa, a king, a public leader, or a devotee of the Lord. The Personality of Godhead, as an ideal king, showed this by example. Çré Rämacandra cut off the tie of affection for His beloved wife to manifest the qualities of an ideal king.

Such personalities as a brähmaëa, a devotee, a king, or a public leader must be very broad-minded in discharging their respective duties. Çrématé Kuntédevé was conscious of this fact, and being weak she prayed to be free from such bondage of family affection. The Lord is addressed as the Lord of the universe, or the Lord of the universal mind, indicating His all-powerful ability to cut the hard knot of family affection. affinity toward a weak devotee, breaks the family affection by force of circumstances arranged by His all-powerful energy. By doing so He causes the devotee to become completely dependent on Him and thus clears the path for his going back to Godhead.

Kunté was the daughter of the Våñëi family and the wife and mother of the Päëòava family. Generally a woman has affection for both her father's family and husband's family, and therefore Kunté prays to Kåñëa, "I am a woman, and women are generally attached to their families, so kindly cut off my attachment so that I may be thoroughly attached to You. Without You, both families are zero. I am falsely attached to these families, but my real purpose in life is to be attached to You." This is bhakti.

Bhakti involves becoming free from the attachments of this material world and becoming attached instead to Kåñëa. One cannot become unattached, for one must be attached to something, but in order to become attached to Kåñëa or enter into the devotional service of the Lord, one has to become detached from material affection.

People ordinarily go to Kåñëa to maintain their attachment to this material world. "O God," they pray, "give us our daily bread." They have attachment to this material world, and to live in this material world they pray for supplies of material things so that they can maintain their status quo. This is called material attachment. Although in one sense, of course, it is good that people go to God to secure their material position, that is not actually desirable. Rather than worship God to increase one's opulence in the material world, one should become free from material attachment. For bhakti-yoga, therefore, we should be detached.

Our suffering is due to our attachment. Because we are materially attached, we desire so many material things, and therefore Kåñëa gives us the opportunity to enjoy whatever material facilities we want. Of course, one must deserve these facilities. First deserve, then desire. Suppose I want to become king. I must have pious activities behind me so that I can become king.

Kåñëa can give us whatever we want, even mukti, liberation, but bhakti is a special consideration because when He gives someone bhakti He becomes purchased by the bhakta and becomes a tool in the hands of the bhakta, even though He is the supreme powerful. Rädhäräëé, the symbol of the topmost bhakti, is so powerful that She has purchased Kåñëa. Therefore Vaiñëavas take shelter of the lotus feet of Rädhäräëé, for if She recommends, "Oh, here is a nice devotee," Kåñëa must accept him.

To become a devotee of the Lord, one must be completely cleansed of all material attachment. This qualification is called vairägya. Upon becoming a student of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya wrote one hundred verses praising Him. Two of those verses are mentioned in the Caitanya-caritämåta, and one of them is this statement:

vairägya-vidyä-nija-bhakti-yoga-
çikñärtham ekaù puruñaù puräëaù
çré-kåñëa-caitanya-çaréra-dhäré
kåpämbudhir yas tam ahaà prapadye

"Let me take shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Çré Kåñëa, who has descended in the form of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu to teach us real knowledge, His devotional service, and detachment from whatever does not foster Kåñëa consciousness. He has descended because He is an ocean of transcendental mercy. Let me surrender unto His lotus feet." (Cc. Madhya 6.254) Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya thus offered his prayer to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who had now assumed the form of Caitanya Mahäprabhu just to teach people how to develop knowledge, become detached, and become pure devotees of Kåñëa.

Although when Caitanya Mahäprabhu was only twenty-four or twenty-five years old He had a lovable, beautiful wife and a devoted, affectionate mother, He gave up everything and took sannyäsa, the renounced order of life. When Caitanya Mahäprabhu was a gåhastha, a householder, He was so much honored that merely by the direction of His finger He was able to enlist thousands of people to join Him in a civil disobedience movement. In Nadia, the city where He lived, His position was very respectable, and physically He was very beautiful. Yet He gave up His young, faithful, beautiful wife, His affectionate mother, His position, and everything else. This is called vairägya, renunciation.

If someone who has nothing to possess says, "I have renounced everything," what is the meaning of his renunciation? But if one has something and then renounces it, his renunciation is meaningful. So Caitanya Mahäprabhu's renunciation is unique. No one else could give up such a happy home, such honor, and such affection from mother, wife, friends, and students. Even Advaita Prabhu, although the age of Caitanya Mahäprabhu's father, honored Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Yet still Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu gave up everything. Why? Just to teach us (äpani äcari, prabhu jévere çikhäya). He personally taught the whole world how one must detach oneself and become a devotee of Kåñëa. Therefore when Rüpa Gosvämé resigned his post as a government minister and met Caitanya Mahäprabhu at Prayäga, he fell flat before Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu and offered obeisances with this prayer:

namo mahä-vadänyäya
kåñëa-prema-pradäya te
kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-
nämne gaura-tviñe namaù
[Madhya 19.53]

"You are most magnanimous," he prayed, "for You are distributing love of Kåñëa."

Love of Kåñëa is not an easy thing to obtain, because by this love one can purchase Kåñëa, but Caitanya Mahäprabhu distributed this love of Kåñëa to anyone and everyone, even to the two drunkards Jagäi and Mädhäi. Narottama däsa Öhäkura has therefore sung:

déna-héna yata chila hari-näme uddhärila,
tä'ra säkñé jagäi-mädhäi
[hari hari! vifale 3]

"Caitanya Mahäprabhu is so magnanimous that He delivered all kinds of sinful men simply by allowing them to chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra. The evidence of this is Jagäi and Mädhäi." At that time, of course, there were two Jagäis and Mädhäis, but at the present moment, by the grace of Caitanya Mahäprabhu and His process of teaching, so many Jagäis and Mädhäis are being delivered. If Caitanya Mahäprabhu is pleased, He can give kåñëa-prema, love of Kåñëa, to anyone, regardless of that person's qualification. If a person is giving charity, he can select anyone to take it.

Without the mercy of Caitanya Mahäprabhu, understanding Kåñëa is very, very difficult. Manuñyäëäà sahasreñu kaçcid yatati siddhaye (Bg. 7.3): out of many millions of people, hardly one tries to make his life spiritually successful. People simply work like animals, not knowing how to make a success of human life. One's human life is successful when one understands Kåñëa; otherwise one remains an animal. Anyone who is not Kåñëa conscious, who does not know who Kåñëa is, is no better than an animal. But Caitanya Mahäprabhu gave this concession to the fallen souls of this age: "Simply chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra and you will be delivered." This is Caitanya Mahäprabhu's special concession (kértanäd eva kåñëasya mukta-saìgaù paraà vrajet, Bhäg. 12.3.51).

Now, Kunté was not an ordinary devotee. She had become one of the relatives of Kåñëa, and therefore Kåñëa had come to offer her respects. But still she said, "Kåñëa, I have become attached to two families, my father's family and my husband's family. Kindly help me become detached from these families." Thus she illustrated that one must become detached from society, friendship, and love, all of which will otherwise entangle us.

As long as I think, "I belong to this family," "I belong to this nation," "I belong to this religion," "I belong to this color," and so on, there is no possibility of becoming Kåñëa conscious. As long as one thinks that one is American, Indian, or African, that one belongs to this family or that family, or that one is the father, mother, husband, or wife of this or that person, one is attached to material designations. I am spirit soul, and all these attachments belong to the body, but I am not this body. This is the essence of understanding. If I am not this body, then whose father or whose mother am I? The supreme father and mother is Kåñëa. We are simply playing the parts of father, mother, sister, or brother, as if on stage. Mäyä, the material nature, is causing us to dance, telling us, "You are a member of this family and a member of this nation." Thus we are dancing like monkeys.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (3.27) it is said:

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

This verse indicates that because the living entity has associated with a certain quality of nature, nature is making him dance according to that quality, and thus one is thinking, "I am this" or "I am that." This information provided in Bhagavad-gétä is the basic principle of understanding, and it will give one freedom.

The most essential education is that which enables one to become free from the bodily concept of life, but unfortunately scientists, philosophers, politicians, and other so-called leaders are misleading people so that they become more attached to the body. It is the human life that offers the opportunity to become Kåñëa conscious, but these rascals are stopping that opportunity by alluring people to bodily designations, and therefore they are the greatest enemies of human civilization.

One attains a human body after evolving through 8,400,000 life-forms, from aquatics to plants, and then to trees, insects, birds, beasts, and so on. Now, people do not know what is the next step in evolution, but that is explained in Bhagavad-gétä (9.25). Yänti deva-vratä devän. As the next step in evolution, one may, if one desires, go to a higher planetary system. Although every night people see so many planets and stars, they do not know what these higher planetary systems are. But from the çästra, the Vedic literature, we can understand that on these higher planetary systems, material comforts are available that are many, many times greater than those on this planet. On this planet we may live for at most one hundred years, but on the higher planetary systems one can live for a lifetime we cannot even calculate. For example, the lifetime of Brahmä, who lives on the highest planet, is stated in Bhagavad-gétä (8.17): sahasra-yuga-paryantam ahar yad brahmaëo viduù. We cannot calculate even twelve hours of Brahmä with our mathematical figures, but even Brahmä has to die. Even though one may have a long duration of life, no one can live permanently in this material world. Nonetheless, if one prepares oneself one may go to the higher planetary systems, or similarly one may go to the Pitålokas. There one may meet one's forefathers, if they have been eligible to go there. Similarly, if one desires, one may also remain here on earth. Or yänti mad-yäjino 'pi mäm: if one becomes a devotee of Kåñëa, one can go to Him.

One may go to hell, one may go to heaven, or one may go back home, back to Godhead, as one likes. Therefore an intelligent person should think, "If I have to prepare for my next life, why not prepare to go back home, back to Godhead?" One's present body will be finished, and then one will have to accept another body. What kind of body one will accept is stated in Bhagavad-gétä (14.18). Ürdhvaà gacchanti sattva-sthäù: those who are in the mode of goodness, avoiding the four principles of sinful life, will live their next life on a higher planetary system. Even if one does not become a pure devotee of the Lord, if one follows the regulative principles for avoiding sinful life one will remain in goodness and get this opportunity. Human life is meant for this purpose. But if we waste our life just living like cats and dogs, eating, sleeping, mating, and defending, then we shall lose this opportunity.

Rascals, however, do not know this. They do not believe that there is a next life. In Russia a professor, Professor Kotovsky, told me, "Swäméjé, after this body is finished, everything is finished." He is a big professor, yet still he said that. Such men may pose as scientists and philosophers, but actually they have no knowledge, and they simply mislead others. This is our greatest source of grief, and therefore I have requested the members of the Kåñëa consciousness movement to challenge and defeat these rascals, who are misleading the entire human society. People should not think that the devotees of Kåñëa are mere sentimentalists. On the contrary, the devotees are the greatest philosophers and the greatest scientists.

Kåñëa has two engagements: pariträëäya sädhünäà vinäçäya ca duñkåtäm—giving protection to the sädhus, the devotees, and killing the demons. Kåñëa gave protection to the Päëòavas and Våñëis because they were devotees, and He also killed demons like Kaàsa, Aghäsura, and Bakäsura. Of the two engagements, His killing of the demons was His major occupation. If we examine how much time He devoted to killing and how much time He devoted to protecting, we shall find that He devoted more time to killing. Similarly, those who are Kåñëa conscious should also kill-not by weapons but by logic, by reasoning, and by education. If one is a demon, we can use logic and arguments to kill his demoniac propensities and turn him into a devotee, a saintly person. Especially in this present age, Kali-yuga, people are already poverty-stricken, and physical killing is too much for them. They should be killed by argument, reasoning, and scientific spiritual understanding.

Kunté addresses Kåñëa as viçveça, the Lord of the universe (viçva means "universe," and éça means "lord" or "controller"). The universal affairs are going on so nicely, with the sun rising just on time, the seasons changing, and the seasonal fruits and flowers making their appearance. Thus there is no mismanagement. But how are these things going on so nicely if there is no controller? If we see any establishment going on very well, we immediately understand that the manager, director, or controller of the institution is expert. Similarly, if we see the universal affairs going on nicely, we must know that behind them is a good controller. And who is that controller? That controller is Kåñëa, as stated in Bhagavad-gétä (mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù süyate sa-caräcaram). Therefore Kunté addresses Him as viçveça, the controller of the universe. People are interested only in pictures of Kåñëa embracing Rädhäräëé that depict the dealings of Rädhä and Kåñëa to be like those of ordinary boys and girls. They don't understand Kåñëa. Such obnoxious pictures should be avoided. Kåñëa is the supreme controller. Let there be a picture showing how Kåñëa is controlling the whole universe. That kind of picture is wanted, not these cheap pictures.

Unless the living force is present within the body, the body cannot move or work nicely, and similarly within the universe, the cosmic manifestation, Kåñëa is present as the living force—Kñérodakaçäyé Viñëu, or Paramätmä. Therefore Kunté addresses Kåñëa as viçvätmä, the soul of the universe. Rascals do not know how this world is moving and how this universe is acting, and therefore they should learn from Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

Kuntédevé also addresses Kåñëa as viçva-mürti, the personality of the form of the universe. When Arjuna wanted to see Kåñëa's universal form, Kåñëa immediately manifested it. This is another of Kåñëa's opulences (vibhüti). The original form of the Lord, however, is Kåñëa with two hands, playing on the flute. Because Arjuna was a devotee and wanted to see the universal form, Kåñëa showed it to him, but that was not His actual form. A person may dress himself as a king, but his real, natural appearance is shown at home. Similarly, Kåñëa's real form is seen at home in Våndävana, and all other forms are expansions of His plenary portions. As stated in the Brahma-saàhitä, advaitam acyutam anädim ananta-rüpam: He can expand Himself in millions and millions of forms (ananta-rüpam), but He is one (advaita), and He is infallible (acyuta). His real form, however, is the dvi-bhuja muralé-dhara—the form with two hands holding a flute. Therefore Kuntédevé says, "You have Your universal form, but the form in which You are standing before me is Your real form."

Kuntédevé prays, "Please sever my tie of affection for my kinsmen." We are thinking, "This is my own, that is my own," but this is moha, illusion (janasya moho 'yam ahaà mameti). How does this illusion come into existence? It begins with the natural attraction between man and woman. A male seeks a female, and a female seeks a male. This is true not only in human society, but also in bird society, beast society, and so on. This is the beginning of material attachment. When a man finds a woman and they unite, this attachment becomes even more firmly established (tayor mitho hådaya-granthim ähuù). Now, after the attachment increases to some degree, the man and woman look for an apartment in which to live together, and then, of course, the man needs to earn money. When they are well settled, they must have children and also some friends to come and praise them: "Oh, you have such a nice apartment and such nice children." In this way one's attachment increases.

A student's education, therefore, should begin with brahmacarya, which means freedom from sexual attachment. If he can, he should try to avoid all this nonsense. If not, he can marry and then after some time enter vänaprastha, retired life. At that time one thinks, "Now that I have enjoyed this attachment so much, let me leave home." Then the man travels all over to various places of pilgrimage to become detached, and the wife goes with him as an assistant. After two or three months he again comes home to see that his children are doing nicely and then again goes away. This is the beginning of detachment. When the detachment is complete, the man tells his wife, "Now go live with your children, and I shall take sannyäsa, the renounced order of life." This is final detachment. The whole Vedic way of life is meant for detachment, and therefore Kunté prays, "Kindly help detach me from this family attraction." This is Kuntédevé's instruction.

TQK 25: Unalloyed Devotion

25. Unalloyed Devotion

tvayi me 'nanya-viñayä
matir madhu-pate 'sakåt
ratim udvahatäd addhä
gaìgevaugham udanvati

TRANSLATION

O Lord of Madhu, as the Ganges forever flows to the sea without hindrance, let my attraction be constantly drawn unto You, without being diverted to anyone else.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.42

PURPORT

Perfection of pure devotional service is attained when all attention is diverted toward the transcendental loving service of the Lord. To cut off the tie of all other affections does not mean complete negation of the finer elements, like affection for someone else. This is not possible. A living being, whoever he may be, must have this feeling of affection for others because this is a symptom of life. The symptoms of life, such as desire, anger, hankerings, and feelings of attraction, cannot be annihilated. Only the objective has to be changed. Desire cannot be negated, but in devotional service the desire is changed only for the service of the Lord in place of desire for sense gratification. The so-called affection for family, society, country, etc., consists of different phases of sense gratification. When this desire is changed for the satisfaction of the Lord, it is called devotional service.

In the Bhagavad-gétä we can see that Arjuna desired not to fight with his brothers and relations just to satisfy his own personal desires. But when he heard the message of the Lord, Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä, he changed his decision and served the Lord. And for his doing so, he became a famous devotee of the Lord, for it is declared in all the scriptures that Arjuna attained spiritual perfection by devotional service to the Lord in friendship. The fighting was there, the friendship was there, Arjuna was there, and Kåñëa was there, but Arjuna became a different person by devotional service. Therefore, the prayers of Kunté also indicate the same categorical changes in activities. Çrématé Kunté wanted to serve the Lord without diversion, and that was her prayer. This unalloyed devotion is the ultimate goal of life. Our attention is usually diverted to the service of something which is nongodly or not in the program of the Lord. When the program is changed into the service of the Lord, that is to say when the senses are purified in relation with the service of the Lord, it is called pure, unalloyed devotional service. Çrématé Kuntédevé wanted that perfection and prayed for it from the Lord.

Her affection for the Päëòavas and the Våñëis is not out of the range of devotional service, because the service of the Lord and the service of the devotees are identical. Sometimes service to the devotee is more valuable than service to the Lord. But here the affection of Kuntédevé for the Päëòavas and the Våñëis was due to family relation. This tie of affection in terms of material relation is the relation of mäyä, because the relations of the body or the mind are due to the influence of the external energy. Relations of the soul, established in relation with the Supreme Soul, are factual relations. When Kuntédevé wanted to cut off the family relation, she meant to cut off the relation of the skin. The skin relation is the cause of material bondage, but the relation of the soul is the cause of freedom. This relation of the soul to the soul can be established by the via medium of the relation with the Supersoul. Seeing in the darkness is not seeing. But seeing by the light of the sun means seeing the sun and everything else which was unseen in the darkness. That is the way of devotional service.

In the previous verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam Queen Kunté prayed that the Lord kindly cut off her attraction for her kinsmen, the Päëòava and Våñëi families. However, giving up one's attraction for material things is not sufficient. The Mäyävädé philosophers say, brahma satyaà jagan mithyä: "This world is false, and Brahman [spirit] is truth." We admit this, but qualify it. As living entities, we want enjoyment. Enjoyment means variety. It is not possible to enjoy anything without variety. Why has God created so many colors and so many forms? In order to create enjoyment out of variety, for variety is the mother of enjoyment.

Mäyävädé philosophers, impersonalists, want to negate this variety, but what is the result? Because they do not engage in devotional service, they simply undertake the hard labor of austerities and penances without achieving any permanent result. This is explained by a prayer in Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.2.32):

ye 'nye 'ravindäkña vimukta-mäninas
tvayy asta-bhäväd aviçuddha-buddhayaù
äruhya kåcchreëa paraà padaà tataù
patanty adho 'nädåta-yuñmad-aìghrayaù

"O lotus-eyed Lord, those who think they are liberated in this life but do not render devotional service to You must be of impure intelligence. Although they accept severe austerities and penances and rise to the spiritual position, to impersonal Brahman realization, they fall down again because they neglect to worship Your lotus feet."

The human form of life is meant for reestablishing our relationship with God and acting according to that relationship. Even in ordinary dealings, one businessman who intends to do business with another must first establish some relationship with him, and then transactions can take place. Similarly, a husband and wife establish a relationship by marriage, and then they live together. In a similar way, human life is meant for reestablishing our relationship with God. The material world means forgetfulness of this relationship. There is no Kåñëa consciousness in this material world, for as soon as there is Kåñëa consciousness, as soon as there is action on the basis of Kåñëa, it is no longer the material world but the spiritual world.

As a woman, Kuntédevé had a relationship with two families. That was her attachment. Therefore she prayed to Kåñëa to cut off these relationships and free her. But after becoming free, what should she do? That is the question. One may be employed in some business and, feeling inconvenience, resign. That resignation may be all right, but if by resigning one becomes unemployed and has no engagement, then what is the value of resigning?

Those who are frustrated and confused want to negate this material world. They know what they don't want, but they do not know what they do want. People are always saying, "I don't want this." But what do they want? That they do not know.

What one should actually want is explained by Kuntédevé. She says, "Let my family relationships cease, but let my relationship with You be confirmed." In other words, she does not want to be attracted to anything but Kåñëa. This is perfection, and this is actually wanted.

The word ananya-viñayä means ananya-bhakti, undeviating devotional service. We must simply be attached to Kåñëa twenty-four hours a day without deviation. In this way our renunciation can be perfect. If we think we can be attached to Kåñëa and material things at the same time, we are mistaken. We cannot ignite a fire and at the same time pour water on it. If we do, the fire will not act.

The Mäyävädé sannyäsés renounce this world (brahma satyaà jagan mithyä). It is very good to preach renunciation of the world, but side by side we must have attraction for something, otherwise our renunciation will not remain. We see many Mäyävädé sannyäsés who say brahma satyaà jagan mithyä, but after they take sannyäsa they return to the material world to open hospitals and do philanthropic work. Why? If they have left this world, considering it mithyä, false, why do they return to take up politics, philanthropy, and sociology? Actually this is bound to happen, for we are living entities and are active. If out of frustration we try to become inactive, we shall fail in our attempt. We must engage in activities.

The supreme activity, the Brahman (spiritual) activity, is devotional service. Unfortunately the Mäyävädés do not know this. They think that the spiritual world is void. However, the spiritual world is exactly like the material world in that it has varieties. In the spiritual world there are also houses, trees, roads, chariots—everything is there, but without the material inebrieties. As described in Brahma-saàhitä (5.29):

cintämaëi-prakara-sadmasu kalpa-våkña-
lakñävåteñu surabhér abhipälayantam
lakñmé-sahasra-çata-sambhrama-sevyamänaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, the first progenitor, who is tending the cows, yielding all desires, in abodes built with spiritual gems, surrounded by millions of purpose trees, and always served with great reverence and affection by hundreds of thousands of goddesses of fortune, or gopés."

In the spiritual world there are kalpa-våkña trees, which yield whatever type of fruit we desire. In the material world a mango tree cannot supply grapes, nor can a grapevine supply mangoes. In the spiritual world, however, if we take a mango from a tree and at the same time desire grapes, the tree will supply them. This is called a "desire tree." These are some of the actualities of the spiritual world.

In this material world we require sunlight and moonlight, but in the spiritual world there is no need of sunlight and moonlight because everything and everyone is effulgent. In kåñëa-lélä, Kåñëa stole butter, and the neighborhood friends of Mother Yaçodä complained. Actually they were not complaining, but were just enjoying the bodily features and the fun of Kåñëa. They told Mother Yaçodä, "Your son comes to our house and steals butter. We try to conceal it in the dark so that He cannot see it, but somehow He still finds it out. You had better take away all His ornaments because we think that the light of His jewels helps Him find the butterpot." Mother Yaçodä replied, "Yes, I will take off all His ornaments." But the neighbors would reply, "No, no. It is useless. Somehow this boy has an effulgence that comes out of Himself. He can find the butter even without the ornaments." Thus the transcendental body is effulgent.

It is because of the effulgence of Kåñëa's transcendental body that there is light. Whatever light we see is simply borrowed light from Kåñëa's effulgence. As stated in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.40):

yasya prabhä prabhavato jagad-aëòa-koöi-
koöiñv açeña-vasudhädi-vibhüti-bhinnam
tad brahma niñkalam anantam açeña-bhütaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

"In the millions and millions of universes there are innumerable planets, and each of them is different from the others by its cosmic constitution. All of these planets are situated within the spiritual effulgence called the brahmajyoti. This brahmajyoti is the bodily effulgence of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, whom I worship."

The bodily effulgence of Kåñëa generates millions of universes. In this solar system the sun produces many planets, and because of sunshine the planets are warm and the seasons change. Because of the sun there are trees, green foliage, fruits, and flowers. Similarly, whatever we see in creation is all due to Kåñëa's bodily effulgence.

The Mäyävädés simply see the effulgence, which is impersonal. They cannot see anything more. We may see an airplane rise in the sky, but after a while it passes out of our sight due to the dazzling sunshine. The airplane is there, but we cannot see it. Similarly, if we simply try to see the effulgent brahmajyoti, we are unable to see within it. One of the mantras in the Éçopaniñad therefore petitions the Lord to wind up His effulgence so that He can be seen properly.

The Mäyävädé philosophers cannot see the personal activities of Kåñëa nor the planet where Kåñëa is personally active. The Bhägavatam says, äruhya kåcchreëa paraà padaà tataù patanty adho 'nädåta-yuñmad-aìghrayaù: (Bhäg. 10.2.32) because they do not see the lotus feet of Kåñëa, they have to return to this material world, despite all their serious penances and austerities. Thus renunciation in itself will not help us. We may artificially renounce, but again we shall become so-called enjoyers. Such renunciation and enjoyment is like a pendulum that goes this way and that. On one side we become false renunciants, and on the other we become false enjoyers. The remedy, however, is here. If we really want to become detached from this material world, we must increase our attachment for Kåñëa consciousness. Renunciation alone will not help us. Therefore Kuntédevé prays, tvayi me 'nanya-viñayä [Bhäg. 1.8.42]. She prays that her attraction be constantly drawn unto Kåñëa without being diverted to anything else. This is bhakti, pure devotional service, for as mentioned by Rüpa Gosvämé, devotional service should be unalloyed (anyäbhiläñitä-çünyaà jïäna-karmädy-anävåtam).

In this material world there are jïänés and karmés. The karmés are fools who unnecessarily work very hard, and the jïänés are those who, when a little elevated, think, "Why work so hard? So many things are not required. Why accumulate so much money and food and so much false prestige?" The jïäné thinks in this way. The bhakta, however, is beyond the karmé and the jïäné. The karmé has many desires, and the jïäné tries to get rid of all desires, but desirelessness can be possible only when we desire to serve Kåñëa. Otherwise it is not possible to get rid of desires. Jïäna-karmädy-anävåtam. As bhaktas, we should have no desires for jïäna and karma. We should be without attachment for material things, but we must have attachment for Kåñëa. In this way our detachment will be fixed.

We must cultivate Kåñëa consciousness favorably (änukülyena kåñëänuçélanam). This means thinking of how Kåñëa will be satisfied. We must always think of Kåñëa, just like the gopés. The Kåñëa consciousness of the gopés was perfect because they had no desire other than to try to please Kåñëa. That is perfection. Therefore Caitanya Mahäprabhu recommends, ramyä käcid upäsanä vraja-vadhü-vargeëa yä kalpitä: there is no better process by which to worship the Supreme Personality of Godhead than that method adopted by the gopés.

The gopés had no desire other than to satisfy Kåñëa. All the gopés tried to satisfy Him, including the elder gopés, Yaçodä and her friends, and so also did the elderly gopas like Nanda Mahäräja and his friends. The boys and girls of Våndävana who were of the same age as Kåñëa also tried to satisfy Him. Everyone tried to satisfy Kåñëa—even the cows, the flowers, the fruits, and the water of Våndävana. This is because everything in Våndävana is spiritual; nothing is material.

We should understand the difference between spiritual and material. That which is material has no living symptoms, and that which is spiritual has all living symptoms. Both the trees in the spiritual world and those in the material world are living entities, but in trees here the living symptoms are absent. A human being is a living entity, and the devotees in the spiritual world are also living entities, but in the human beings who are not Kåñëa conscious the real symptoms of life are absent.

Actually there is no other consciousness but Kåñëa consciousness. And that consciousness is spiritual. Thus even while in this material world, if we simply increase our Kåñëa consciousness we shall live in the spiritual world. If we live in the temple, we live in the spiritual world because in the temple there is no business other than Kåñëa consciousness. There are so many engagements carried out for Kåñëa. Those who strictly follow the regulations of Kåñëa consciousness actually live in the spiritual world, not the material world. We may think we are living in New York, Los Angeles, or elsewhere, but we are actually living in Vaikuëöha.

It is a question of consciousness. A bug may sit on the same seat with the spiritual master, but because the spiritual master has developed consciousness and the bug does not, they are different. They may be sitting in the same place, but the bug remains a bug, and the spiritual master remains the spiritual master. The position in space may remain the same, just as we remain in the material world or the spiritual world, but if our Kåñëa consciousness is strong, we are not in the material world.

Thus renunciation by itself, the simple giving up of worldly things, is not sufficient. Renunciation may be a helpful process, but it will not help absolutely. When we increase our attachment for Kåñëa, our renunciation will be perfect. As we increase attachment for Kåñëa, attachment for this material world will automatically diminish. Attachment for Kåñëa and the material world cannot go hand in hand. If a woman is attached to two men—her husband and her paramour—she cannot maintain her attachment for both. Her attachment will increase for her paramour. Although she may work at her husband's home very nicely, her mind will be attached to her paramour, and she will think, "When shall I meet him tonight?" In the same way, if we increase our attachment for Kåñëa, detachment or renunciation of this material world will automatically come (bhaktiù pareçänubhavo viraktir anyatra ca, Bhäg. 11.2.42).

Thus Kuntédevé prays to Kåñëa that He may grant her His mercy by which she can become attached to Him. We cannot increase our attachment for Kåñëa without Kåñëa's mercy. We cannot become devotees without Kåñëa's mercy; therefore we simply have to serve Kåñëa, for by service Kåñëa is satisfied.

Kåñëa does not require anyone's service, for He is perfect in Himself. However, if we give Him service wholeheartedly and sincerely, then, by His mercy, we shall make advancement. Sevonmukhe hi jihvädau svayam eva sphurat adaù [Padma Puräëa]. God will reveal Himself to us. We cannot see God with our blunt eyes. How then can we see Him? Premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena, santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti (Bs. 5.38). We have to smear our eyes with the ointment of love; then Kåñëa will reveal Himself. Kåñëa will actually come in front of us.

When Dhruva Mahäräja was undergoing penance and meditating upon the form of Viñëu within his heart, the Viñëu form suddenly disappeared, and his meditation broke. Upon opening his eyes, Dhruva Mahäräja immediately saw Viñëu before him. Like Dhruva Mahäräja, we should always think of Kåñëa, and when we attain perfection we shall see Kåñëa before us. This is the process. We should not be too hasty. We should wait for the mature time. Of course, it is good to be eager to see Kåñëa, but we should not become discouraged if we do not see Him immediately. If a woman gets married and wants a child immediately, she will be disappointed. It is not possible to have a child immediately. She must wait. Similarly, we cannot expect that just because we engage ourselves in Kåñëa consciousness we can see Kåñëa immediately. But we must have faith that we will see Him. We must have firm faith that because we are engaged in Kåñëa consciousness we shall be able to see Kåñëa face to face. We should not be disappointed. We should simply go on with our Kåñëa conscious activities, and the time will come when we will see Kåñëa, just as Kuntédevé sees Him face to face. There is no doubt about this.

In the Bhagavad-gétä it is stated that even if one is sometimes found to be somewhat misbehaved, he is to be considered saintly if he engages steadily in the service of Kåñëa. Sometimes American or European devotees may be criticized because they make mistakes and fall short of the system for worshiping the Deity as practiced in India, but still, according to Bhagavad-gétä, they must be considered saintly. We must fix our minds upon serving Kåñëa sincerely and seriously, and then, even if there is some mistake, Kåñëa will excuse it. Rüpa Gosvämé says, tasmät kenäpy upäyena manaù kåñëe niveçayet: we should first fix our minds upon Kåñëa, and then the ability to follow the other rules and regulations will automatically follow. In the beginning we should try our best to fix our minds upon the lotus feet of Kåñëa, and then everything else will automatically become correct.

Kuntédevé addresses Kåñëa as Madhupati. Kåñëa has thousands of names, and the name Madhupati indicates that He killed the demon Madhu. Kåñëa consciousness is likened to a river, but not an ordinary river. It is like the river Ganges, which is very pure and directly connected to Kåñëa. Kuntédevé prays that just as the river Ganges flows toward the sea, her attraction will flow incessantly toward Kåñëa's lotus feet. This is called ananya-bhakti, unalloyed devotion. Thus Kuntédevé prays that her attraction for Kåñëa will flow without hindrance.

TQK 26: Enchantment by Kåñëa's Glories

26. Enchantment by Kåñëa's Glories

çré-kåñëa kåñëa-sakha våñëy-åñabhävani-dhrug-
räjanya-vaàça-dahanänapavarga-vérya
govinda go-dvija-surärti-harävatära
yogeçvaräkhila-guro bhagavan namas te

TRANSLATION

O Kåñëa, O friend of Arjuna, O chief among the descendants of Våñëi, You are the destroyer of those political parties which are disturbing elements on this earth. Your prowess never deteriorates. You are the proprietor of the transcendental abode, and You descend to relieve the distresses of the cows, the brähmaëas, and the devotees, You possess all mystic powers, and You are the preceptor of the entire universe. You are the almighty God, and I offer You my respectful obeisances.

—Çrémad-Bhägavatam 1.8.43

PURPORT

A summary of the Supreme Lord, Çré Kåñëa, is made herein by Çrématé Kuntédevé. The almighty Lord has His eternal, transcendental abode, where He is engaged in keeping surabhi cows. He is served by hundreds and thousands of goddesses of fortune. He descends on the material world to reclaim His devotees and to annihilate the disturbing elements in groups of political parties and kings who are supposed to be in charge of administration work. He creates, maintains, and annihilates by His unlimited energies, and still He is always full with prowess and does not deteriorate in potency. The cows, the brähmaëas, and the devotees of the Lord are all objects of His special attention because they are very important factors for the general welfare of living beings.

Kunté addresses Lord Kåñëa as kåñëa-sakha because she knows that although Arjuna, who is also known as Kåñëa, is her son and therefore subordinate to her, Lord Kåñëa is more intimately related with Arjuna than with her. Kåñëä is also a name of Draupadé, and so the word kåñëa-sakha also indicates Lord Kåñëa's relationship with Draupadé, whom He saved from being insulted when Duryodhana and Karëa attempted to strip her naked. Kunté also addresses Lord Kåñëa as våñëi-åñabha, the child of the dynasty of Våñëi. It was because Kåñëa appeared in the Våñëi dynasty that this dynasty became famous, just as Malaysia and the Malaya Hills became famous because of the sandalwood that grows there.

Kuntédevé also addresses Lord Kåñëa as the destroyer of the political parties or royal dynasties that disturb the earth. In every monarchy, the king is honored very gorgeously. Why? Since he is a human being and the other citizens are also human beings, why is the king so honored? The answer is that the king, like the spiritual master, is meant to be the representative of God. In the Vedic literature it is said, äcäryaà mäà vijänéyän nävamanyeta karhicit (Bhäg. 11.17.27): the spiritual master should not be regarded as an ordinary human being. Similarly, a king or president is also not treated like an ordinary human being.

In the Sanskrit language the king is also called naradeva, which means "God in human form." His duty is like that of Kåñëa. As God is the supreme living being in the universe and is the maintainer of all other living beings, the king is the supreme citizen in the state and is responsible for the welfare of all others.

Just as we are all living beings, Kåñëa, God, is also a living being. Kåñëa is not impersonal. Because we are all individual persons but our knowledge and opulence are limited, the impersonalists cannot adjust to the idea that the Supreme, the original, unlimited cause of everything, can also be a person. Because we are limited and God is unlimited, the Mäyävädés, or impersonalists, with their poor fund of knowledge, think that God must be impersonal. Making a material comparison, they say that just as the sky, which we think of as unlimited, is impersonal, if God is unlimited He must also be impersonal.

But that is not the Vedic instruction. The Vedas instruct that God is a person. Kåñëa is a person, and we are also persons, but the difference is that He is to be worshiped whereas we are to be worshipers. The king or president is a person, and the citizens are also persons, but the difference is that the president or king is an exalted person who should be offered all respect.

Now, why should so many persons worship one person? Because that one person provides for the others. Eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän. God is one, and we are many, but He is worshiped because He provides for everyone. It is God who provides food and all the other necessities of life. We need water, and God has nicely arranged for oceans of water, with salt mixed in to preserve it all nicely. Then, because we need drinking water, by God's arrangement the sunshine evaporates the water from the ocean, takes it high in the sky, and then distributes clear, distilled water. Just see how God is providing everything that everyone needs.

Even in ordinary life the state has a heating department, lighting department, plumbing department, and so on. Why? Because these are amenities we require. But these arrangements are subordinate; the first arrangement is that of God. It is God who originally supplies heat, light, and water. It is God who supplies the rainwater that fills our wells and reservoirs. Therefore the original supplier is God.

God is an intelligent person who knows that we need heat, light, water, and so on. Without water we cannot produce food. Even those who eat animals cannot do so without God's arrangement, for the animal also must be provided with grass before one can take it to the slaughterhouse. Thus it is God who is supplying food, but still we are creating rebellion against Him. The word dhruk means "rebellious." Those rascals who are going against the law of God are rebellious.

The king's duty is to act as the representative of Kåñëa, or God. Otherwise what right does he have to take so much honor from the citizens? Monarchy was formerly present in every country, but because the kings rebelled against God and violated His laws, because they tried to usurp the power of God and did not act as His representatives, the monarchies of the world have nearly all disappeared. The kings thought that their kingdoms were their personal property. "I have so much property, such a big kingdom," they thought. "I am God. I am the lord of all I survey." But that is not actually the fact. That fact is that everything belongs to God (éçäväsyam idaà sarvam). Therefore the representative of God must be very obedient to God, and then his position will be legitimate.

Greedy, self-interested kings are like false spiritual masters who proclaim that they themselves are God. Because such false masters are rebellious, they have no position. A spiritual master is supposed to act not as God but as the most confidential servant of God by spreading God consciousness, Kåñëa consciousness. Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura says, säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästrair uktaù: [Gurv-añöaka 7] all the çästras, the Vedic literatures, state that the spiritual master is to be honored as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Thus the idea that the spiritual master is as good as God is not bogus. It is stated in the çästras, and therefore those who are advanced in spiritual life accept this spiritual injunction (uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù). Then is the spiritual master as good as God? Kintu prabhor yaù priya eva tasya: the spiritual master is not God, but is the confidential representative of God. The distinction is that between sevya-bhagavän (he who is worshiped) and sevaka-bhagavän (he who is the worshiper). The spiritual master is God, and Kåñëa is God, but Kåñëa is the worshipable God whereas the spiritual master is the worshiper God.

The Mäyävädés cannot understand this. They think, "Because the spiritual master has to be accepted as God and because I have become a spiritual master, I have become God." This is rebellious. Those who are given a position by God but who want to usurp His power, which they actually cannot do, are rebellious fools and rascals who require punishment. Therefore Kuntédevé says, a vani-dhrug-räjanya-vaàça-dahana: "You descend to kill all these rascals who rebelliously claim Your position." When various kings or landholders are subordinate to an emperor, they sometimes rebel and refuse to pay taxes. Similarly, there are rebellious persons who deny the supremacy of God and declare themselves God, and Kåñëa's business is to kill them.

The word anapavarga indicates that Kåñëa's prowess is without deterioration. This word is the opposite of the word pavarga, which refers to the path of material tribulation. According to Sanskrit linguistics, the word pa-varga also refers to the Sanskrit letters pa, pha, ba, bha, and ma. Thus when the word pavarga is used to refer to the path of material tribulation, its meaning is understood through words beginning with these five letters.

The letter pa is for pariçrama, which means "labor." In this material world, one must work very hard to maintain oneself. In Bhagavad-gétä (3.8) it is said, çaréra-yäträpi ca te na prasiddhyed akarmaëaù: "one cannot even maintain one's own body without work." Kåñëa never advised Arjuna, "I am your friend, and I shall do everything. You just sit down and smoke gaïjä." Kåñëa was doing everything, but still He told Arjuna, "You must fight." Nor did Arjuna say to Kåñëa, "You are my great friend. Better for You to fight and let me sit down and smoke gaïjä." No, that is not Kåñëa consciousness. A God conscious person does not say, "God, You please do everything for me and let me smoke gaïjä." Rather, a God conscious person must work for God. But even if one does not work for the sake of God, one must work, for without work one cannot even maintain one's body. This material world, therefore, is meant for pariçrama, hard labor.

Even a lion, although king of the beasts, must still look for its own prey in the jungle. It is said, na hi suptasya siàhasya praviçanti mukhe mågäù [Hitopadeça]. A lion cannot think, "Since I am king of the forest, let me sleep, and all the animals will come into my mouth." That is not possible. "No, sir. Although you are a lion, you must go search for your food." Thus even the lion, although so powerful, must endeavor with great difficulty to find another animal to eat, and similarly everyone in this material world must work with great difficulty to continue his life.

Thus pa indicates pariçrama, labor, and pha is for phena, which means "foam." While working very hard a horse foams at the mouth, and similarly human beings must also work hard in this way. Such hard labor, however, is vyartha, futile, and this is what is indicated by the letter ba. And bha indicates bhaya, fear. Despite working so hard, one is always somewhat fearful that things will not be done as he desires. The nature of the body is that it involves eating, sleeping, mating, and fearing (ähära-nidrä-bhaya-maithunaà ca). Although one may eat very nicely, one must consider whether one is overeating, so that he will not fall sick. Thus even eating involves fear. A bird, while eating, looks this way and that way, fearful that some enemy may be coming. And for all living entities, everything finally ends in death, måtyu, and this is what is indicated by the letter ma.

Thus pavarga and its component letters pa, pha, ba, bha, and ma indicate hard labor (pariçrama), foam at the mouth (phena), frustration (vyartha), fear (bhaya), and death (måtyu). This is called pavarga, the path of material tribulation. Apavarga, however, indicates just the opposite—the spiritual world, where there is no labor, no foam, no frustration, no fear, and no death. Thus Kåñëa is known as anapavarga-vérya, for He shows the path to the spiritual world.

Why should one suffer from these five kinds of tribulation? Because one has a material body. As soon as one accepts a material body—whether it is that of a president or a common man, a demigod or a human being, an insect or a Brahmä—one must go through these tribulations. This is called material existence. Kåñëa comes, therefore, to show one the path to apavarga, freedom from these tribulations, and when Kåñëa shows this path, we should accept it. Kåñëa says very clearly, "Surrender unto Me. I shall give you apavarga." Ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo mokñayiñyämi: "I shall give you protection." And Kåñëa has the power with which to fulfill this guarantee.

Kuntédevé addresses Kåñëa as Govinda because He is the giver of pleasure both to the cows and to the senses. Govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi. Govinda, Kåñëa, is the ädi-puruña, the original person. Aham ädir hi devänäm (Bg. 10.2): He is the origin even of demigods like Brahmä, Viñëu, and Çiva. People should not think that Brahmä, Viñëu, and Çiva are the origin of everything. No. Kåñëa says, aham ädir hi devänäm: "I am the origin even of these demigods." Therefore we repeatedly emphasize that we worship no one but the original person (govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi).

When Kunté prays, go-dvija-surärti-harävatära [Bhäg. 1.8.43], she indicates that Govinda, Kåñëa, descends to this world especially to protect the cows, the brähmaëas, and the devotees. The demoniac in this world are the greatest enemies of the cows, for they maintain hundreds and thousands of slaughterhouses. Although the innocent cows give milk, the most important food, and although even after death the cows give their skin for shoes, people are such rascals that they kill the cows, but still they want to be happy in this world. How sinful they are.

Why is cow protection so much advocated? Because the cow is the most important animal. There is no injunction that one should not eat the flesh of tigers or other such animals. In the Vedic culture those who are meat-eaters are recommended to eat the flesh of goats, dogs, hogs, or other lower animals, but never the flesh of cows, the most important animals. While living, the cows give important service by giving milk, and even after death they give service by making available their skin, hooves, and horns, which may be used in many ways. Nonetheless, the present human society is so ungrateful that they needlessly kill these innocent cows. Therefore Kåñëa comes to punish them.

Kåñëa is worshiped with this prayer:

namo brahmaëya-deväya
go-brähmaëa-hitäya ca
jagad-dhitäya kåñëäya
govindäya namo namaù
[Viñëu Puräëa 1.19.65]

"My Lord, You are the well-wisher of the cows and the brähmaëas, and You are the well-wisher of the entire human society and world." For perfect human society there must be protection of go-dvija—the cows and the brähmaëas. The word dvija refers to the brähmaëa, or one who knows Brahman (God). When the demoniac give too much trouble to the brähmaëas and the cows, Kåñëa descends to reestablish religious principles. As the Lord says in Bhagavad-gétä (4.7):

yadä yadä hi dharmasya
glänir bhavati bhärata
abhyutthänam adharmasya
tadätmänaà såjämy aham

"Whenever and wherever there is a decline in religious practice, O descendant of Bharata, and a predominant rise of irreligion—at that time I descend Myself." In the present age, Kali-yuga, people are very much sinful and are consequently suffering greatly. Therefore Kåñëa has incarnated in the form of His name, as found in the mahä-mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

Queen Kunté prayed to the Lord just to enunciate a fragment of His glories. The Lord, upon hearing her prayers, which were composed in choice words for His glorification, responded by smiling, and His smile was as enchanting as His mystic power. The conditioned souls, who are engaged in trying to lord it over the material world, are also enchanted by the Lord's mystic powers, but His devotees are enchanted in a different way by the glories of the Lord. Thus all the devotees worship the Lord by chosen words. No amount of chosen words are sufficient to enumerate the Lord's glory, yet He is satisfied by such prayers, just as a father is satisfied even by the broken linguistic attempts of a growing child. Thus the Lord smiled and accepted the prayers of Queen Kunté.

The Author

Glossary

Guide to Sanskrit Pronunciation

TQK Back flap

Back flap

(continued from front flap)
This new Bhaktivedanta Book Trust publication, complete with eleven color prints of exquisite, original oil paintings, will be a prized addition to the libraries of all those who seek a deeper understanding of life's mysteries. Written by a man of profound devotion and erudition, it will provide every reader with firm guidance along the universal path of genuine wisdom and spiritual enlightenment.

"The philosophical and religious works published by the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust provide a golden opportunity to Western philosophers, scholars, and people in general to drink deep at the celestial fountain of ancient Indian philosophical and spiritual wisdom."

Dr. L. S. Varshneya
Chairman, Department of Hindi
Dean, Faculty of Arts
Allahabad University
Allahabad, India

"The Bhaktivedanta Book Trust editions of famous religious classics of India with new translations and commentaries are an important addition to our expanding knowledge of spiritual India."

Dr. John L. Mish
Chief, Oriental Division
New York Public Library

"The books of Srila Prabhupäda are to be treasured. No one of whatever faith or philosophical persuasion who reads these books with an open mind can fail to be both moved and impressed."

Dr. Garry Gelade
Professor of Psychology
Oxford University

JACKET DESIGNED BY INDRA PRAMADA DÄSA ILLUSTRATION BY JAGAT-KÄRANA DÄSÉ

QUEEN KUNTÉ, a tragic and heroic figure, emerges from an explosive era in the history of ancient India. She was a central figure in a complex political drama that led to a bloody fratricidal war for the Indian throne. Yet through all her sufferings she found an inner wisdom and strength that carried her people through the time of crisis.

Queen Kunté's teachings are the simple and illuminating outpourings of the soul of a great and saintly woman, revealing the deepest transcendental emotions of the heart and the deepest philosophical and theological penetrations of the intellect

Here the world's most distinguished teacher of Vedic culture and philosophy, His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, presents the TEACHINGS OF QUEEN KUNTÉ with startling clarity and power.

Renunciation Through Wisdom

First Printing 1992:50,000

Introduction

Introduction

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) has become well known for its large body of Vedic literature—books on bhakti-yoga that include the Bhagavad-gétä, the Çrémad-Bhagavatam, and the Caitanya-caritämåta. These three works by the movement's founder and spiritual guide, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, are voluminous commented English translations of Sanskrit and Bengali classics. Remarkably, Çréla Prabhupäda wrote these and many other, smaller works in the span of twelve years, from 1966 to 1977, while traveling widely and overseeing the growth of the Kåñëa consciousness movement.

What many people may not know, however, is that during the years before he came to the West Çréla Prabhupäda wrote extensively on Kåñëa consciousness in his native language, Bengali. In 1976, soon after I joined the Hare Kåñëa movement, I discovered some of Çréla Prabhupäda's early Bengali writings. They were serialized essays that had appeared in a monthly magazine he edited called Gauòéya Patrika.

One of these lengthy essays, entitled "Bhagaväner kathä" ("Knowledge of the Supreme") ran in the Gauòéya Patrika in 1948 and 1949, soon after India won its independence. I decided that it would make a wonderful booklet for Çréla Prabhupäda's growing number of followers in his native Bengal. When I presented Çréla Prabhupäda that newly printed booklet in early 1977 in Calcutta, he was extremely pleased. He looked at me with his face shining brilliantly, and with a broad smile he said, "Thank you, thank you very much. Please keep printing my books."

I was so encouraged that I soon collected as many of Çréla Prabhupada's Bengali writings from the Gauòéya Patrika as I could and printed them as booklets under the titles "Bhakti Katha" (The Science of Devotion), "Jïäna Katha" (Topics of Spiritual Science), "Muni-gänera Mati-bhrama" (The Deluded Thinkers) and "Buddhi-yoga" (The Highest Use of Intelligence). Finally, I compiled all the booklets into a hardbound book called Vairagya Vidyä, which has now been translated in English and titled Renunciation through Wisdom.

My close friend and Godbrother Sarvabhävana däsa did the translation, and he has done a very good job. In each of the original Bengali essays Çréla Prabhupäda's profound spiritual wisdom shines through, and Sarvabhävana Prabhu has expertly conveyed this wisdom in his translation.

When Çréla Prabhupäda wrote these essays, he was a family man playing the part of an insignificant devotee in the Gauòéya Maöha, the Kåñëa consciousness society founded by his spiritual master, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura. Yet despite the humble position Çréla Prabhupäda was taking at the time, his writings mark him unmistakably as a pure devotee. Anyone with an open mind and a gracious heart will see from his writings that Çréla Prabhupäda was a self-realized soul all along.

Like his spiritual master, Çréla Prabhupäda strictly followed the teachings of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu in his presentation of Kåñëa consciousness. Those teachings are summarized in the phrase vairägya-vidyä-nija-bhakti-yoga, which means "renunciation through the wisdom that comes from practicing devotional service." This line from a famous verse by Çréla Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya, one of Lord Caitanya's intimate disciples, has inspired the title of the present book, Renunciation Through Wisdom.

What is this wisdom which produces renunciation? It is one of the fruits of devotional service to Kåñëa. When one experiences the nectar of devotional service and becomes steeped in the knowledge of the Vedic literature, one naturally becomes averse to sense gratification and attains freedom from material bondage. Lord Kåñëa spoke the essence of Vedic wisdom in the Bhagavad-gétä. As the Gétä-mähätmya, "the Glory of the Bhagavad-gétä" says in this poetic analogy:

the cowherd boy Kåñëa milked the cow of the Upaniñads [the philosophical essence of the Vedas] for the sake of the calf Arjuna, and the milk that came forth is the Bhagavad-gétä. Saintly persons seriously concerned about their spiritual welfare will drink and relish that wondrous nectarean milk.

In Renunciation Through Wisdom, Çréla Prabhupäda has simplified the teachings of the Bhagavad-gétä for our understanding. If we drink this nectar, very soon the brilliant sunshine of transcendental knowledge will dispel the darkness of ignorance caused by our unwanted material desires, and then love for Kåñëa will dawn in our hearts.

Transcendental knowledge is eternal; it never becomes dated or outmoded but is always relevant, in all times and places. Therefore, Renunciation Through Wisdom though written forty or more years ago in the context of modern Indian history, can enlighten anyone, in any part of the world. Actually, this wisdom is for everyone, for all time.

Bhakti Caru Swami
New York, July 1991

RTW 1: Knowledge of the Supreme

Bhagaväner-kathä
Knowledge of the Supreme

RTW 1.1: This Material Nature Is Full of Suffering

This Material Nature Is Full of Suffering

The editor of the daily Amrita Bazar Patrika, published from Allahabad, began the editorial the other day on a rather sad note:

The nation's week began with memories of 'Jalhianwallah-Bagh,' and political serfdom no longer troubles us. But our troubles are far from being at an end. In the dispensation of providence, mankind cannot have any rest. If one kind of trouble goes, another quickly follows. India, politically free, is faced with difficulties that are no less serious than the troubles under foreign rule.

Now, if one consults the accounts ledger of India's serfdom and freedom, and views the contents from a spiritual perspective, the conclusion will be as follows: The four yugas, or ages, namely Satya, Tretä, Dväpara, and Kali, add up to 4,320,000 years. Kali-yuga, which lasts 432,000 years, began from the time of Mahäräja Parékñit's rule, some five thousand years ago. For approximately one thousand of these five thousand years—i.e., since the invasion of Mohammad Ghori in A.D. 1050—India has been experiencing foreign rule. In other words, when we calculate according to scripture, India has exercised absolute sovereignty over the entire planet Earth for a period of 3,888,000 years, till Mahäräja Parékñit's rule. Hence the meager thousand years of foreign subjugation are not such a lamentable thing. Neither in the past nor at present has India's political serfdom or freedom been the prime concern of India's greatest thinkers and philosophers, who well knew the actual value of such things. The kings of India up to Mahäräja Parékñit were able to rule the entire world, and not for a mere couple of centuries but for hundreds of thousands of years. The reason for their rule was not a political one.

India's wise men of yore easily realized that the threefold miseries we humans are condemned to suffer can never be mitigated by the political condition controlling the country—whether foreign rule or freedom from it. At the dawn of modern history, the Armageddon fought in India over a political question lasted only eighteen days. On that historic battlefield the problem of human suffering and its permanent solution was discussed, and this discussion was compiled in the form of the Bhagavad-gétä.

Thus millennia ago the Bhagavad-gétä comprehensively discussed the same topic the editor of Amrita Bazar Patrika writes about in a despondent mood: "If one kind of trouble goes, another quickly follows." In the Gétä (7.14) Lord Kåñëa says, "This divine energy of mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome." The Sanskrit words daivé mäyä used here can be translated into modern terms as "nature's law." This natural law is so stringent that it is impossible to overcome it, in spite of our prolific articles in the newspapers or our big conferences tabling motions that run into volumes. Our advanced technological and scientific efforts aimed at protecting us from the clutches of nature's law are futile because they are all controlled by the very same nature's law, or daivé mäyä. Therefore trying to utilize mundane science to overpower nature's law is like creating a Frankenstein. Efforts to extirpate human suffering through advanced technology and bring about lasting happiness have brought us to the Atomic Age. Western thinkers have become gravely concerned about the extent of destruction an atomic explosion can cause. Some leaders are trying to calm the alarm with platitudes about how atomic energy is to be used solely for peaceful purposes, but this is another form of deception caused by daivé mäyä, or nature's law.

It is impossible for anyone to surmount the two-pronged attack of daivé mäyä—that is, her covering potency and her throwing potency. The more we try to conquer this divine energy, the more powerfully she defeats us by exciting us through the mode of passion and punishing us with the threefold miseries, culminating in all-devouring death. This struggle between the divine energy and the evil forces is eternal. Our inability to understand this struggle has led us to lament, "In the dispensation of providence, mankind cannot have any rest."

Despite repeatedly tasting defeat at the hands of the divine energy, the evil forces cannot understand why "mankind cannot have any rest." Yet in the Bhagavad-gétä the Supreme Personality of Godhead clearly explains this. At first He sternly warns the evil forces with these words, daivé hy eñä guëa-mayé mama mäyä duratyayä: "This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome"; and then in the next line He tells them how to overcome this divine energy, mäm eva ye prapadyante mäyäm etäà taranti te: "But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it."

[BK 1.1]

RTW 1.2: The Cause of Suffering

The Cause of Suffering

Mahisäsura, the most powerful demon, who was the personification of the forces of evil, was in fact endowed with intelligence, education, wealth, the ability to perform severe penances and attract large followings, and so on. His present-day followers, possessing identical qualifications, are no less enterprising and expert in exploiting the divine energy. They carry out elaborate scientific research, misspending huge amounts of money, time, energy, intelligence, men, and so on. But instead of bringing peace and joy, what they discover through these researches ends up producing untold misery for humanity. This is a perfect example of daivé mäyä's throwing agency in action. All these evil activities bring great losses to human society. As a result of this evil, the mundane scientists incur grievous sin, which destroys their real intelligence. And this loss of intelligence turns them away from God and robs them of their chance to surrender to Him. Thus in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.15) the Supreme Lord says:

na mäà duñkåtino muòhäù
prapadyante narädhamäù
mäyayäpahåta-jïänä
äsuraà bhävam äçritäù

"Those miscreants who are grossly foolish, lowest among mankind, whose knowledge is stolen by illusion, and who partake of the atheistic nature of demons, do not surrender unto Me."

In the Bhagavad-gétä (16.7-20) the Supreme Lord has exhaustively described the nature of such atheistic demons:

Those who are demoniac do not know what is to be done and what is not to be done. Neither cleanliness nor proper behaviour nor truth is found in them. They say that this world is unreal, that there is no foundation and that there is no God in control. It is produced of sex desire, and has no cause other than lust. Following such conclusions, the demoniac, who are lost to themselves and who have no intelligence, engage in unbeneficial, horrible works meant to destroy the world. The demoniac, taking shelter of insatiable lust, pride and false prestige, and being thus illusioned, are always sworn to unclean work, attracted by the impermanent.

They believe that to gratify the senses unto the end of life is the prime necessity of human civilization. Thus there is no end to their anxiety. Being bound by hundreds and thousands of desires, by lust and anger, they secure money by illegal means for sense gratification. The demoniac person thinks: "So much wealth do I have today, and I will gain more according to my schemes. So much is mine now, and it will increase in the future, more and more. He is my enemy, and I have killed him; and my other enemy will also be killed. I am the lord of everything, I am the enjoyer, I am perfect, powerful and happy. I am the richest man, surrounded by aristocratic relatives. There is none so powerful and happy as I am. I shall perform sacrifices, I shall give some charity, and thus I shall rejoice." In this way, such persons are deluded by ignorance. Thus perplexed by various anxieties and bound by a network of illusions, one becomes too strongly attached to sense enjoyment and falls down into hell.

Self-complacent and always impudent, deluded by wealth and false prestige, they sometimes proudly perform sacrifices in name only without following any rules or regulations. Bewildered by false ego, strength, pride, lust and anger, the demon becomes envious of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is situated in his own body and in the bodies of others, and blasphemes against the real religion. Those who are envious and mischievous, who are the lowest among men, are cast by Me into the ocean of material existence, into various demoniac species of life. Attaining repeated birth amongst the species of demoniac life, such persons can never approach Me. Gradually they sink down to the most abominable type of existence.

These verses from the Gétä aptly describe the demoniac nature.

There have always existed two types of men, the devotee and the demon. Long ago there lived a big demon named Rävaëa, who disguised himself as a sannyäsé, a renounced mendicant, and tried to steal the wife of the Supreme Lord, Rämacandra. She was the goddess of fortune, Sétä-devé. In this way the demon brought about his own destruction.

But now, in modern times, Rävaëa's dynasty has multiplied into millions. This has given rise to many different opinions, which have made the demons inimical toward one another. Thus they are all competing tooth and nail, trying to kidnap the goddess of fortune, Sétä-devé. Each one is thinking, "I am the most cunning, and so I will enjoy Sétä-devé all by myself." But like Rävaëa, all these demons, along with their entire families, are being destroyed. So many powerful leaders like Hitler have come, but enamoured by the illusion of enjoying and exploiting the Supreme Lord's energy and consort—Sétä-devé, the goddess of fortune—all of them have been thwarted and crushed in the past, are being thwarted and crushed in the present, and will be thwarted and crushed in the future. The root cause of the aforementioned lament—"In the dispensation of providence, mankind cannot have any rest"—is this demoniac mentality of exploiting and enjoying the Lord's divine energy.

The demons do not know when or where to renounce, nor do they know when or where to accept or receive. When diagnosing a patient, one has to properly judge this accepting and rejecting principle. So, in order to cure the demoniac mentality in human society, which causes the Rävaëa syndrome of trying to steal Sétä-devé, it is essential that the demoniac nature be transformed. For any treatment, two important factors are that the patient be in clean surroundings and that his medicine and food be administered punctually. Similarly, to transform the demoniac mentality, people have to be clean, disciplined, and truthful. This end is not served by advocating the theory of yata mat, tata path—that "there are as many ways to salvation as there are opinions"—for in this way one confuses and deceives the populace. By bringing the clean and the unclean, the disciplined and undisciplined, the truthful and the untruthful onto the same level, one will find it impossible to cure or even treat any patient.

[BK 1.2]

RTW 1.3: The Godless Demons

The Godless Demons

The grossly materialistic demons are so completely bereft of spiritual knowledge that although at every moment they perceive the transience of the material body, all their activities center on the body. They are unable to understand that the soul within the body is the permanent and essential substance and that the body is mutable and temporary. Becoming first enamoured of then deluded by vivartaväda (the theory of evolution), they conclude that the entire cosmic body also lacks a Soul. Since the fallacious theory they apply to their own physical existence leads them to reject any research into the existence of a soul residing within the body, they fail to perceive the presence of the Supersoul within the gigantic body of the cosmic manifestation. They falsely conclude that the body is everything, that there is nothing beyond it; similarly, they think that the material creation, which is the universal body, is factually governed only by the laws of nature. Any discussion on this subject is invariably put to premature death by their insistence that nature is the be—all and end—all. The more intelligent among them carry this discussion a little further and postulate that impersonalism is the quintessence of everything. But far beyond this realm of manifest and unmanifest material nature is the transcendental and eternal state. The atheists, however, are characteristically unable to believe in its existence.

In this way, with their perverted minds bereft of far-sightedness, demoniac men perform activities that bring only misery to the people. And as a result of many such unwanted activities, the atom bomb was discovered. The endless plans these demoniac men chalk out can never bode well for humanity. In the past, Rävaëa attempted to build a stairway to heaven, claiming this was for humanity's benefit. Actually, he was trying to cheat the Supreme Lord, Rämacandra. But he was unsuccessful. History repeats itself, for now we find that Rävaëa's descendants are attempting to cheat the Lord in the name of planning to benefit society. The thing to take note of is that no demon will compliment other demons' plans. Every demon will declare that since his plan is the most wonderful, all others must vote for him. Then an opponent will say that in actuality his plan is the best and hence he should rightfully be given all the votes. In this age of votes, the fighting over who is to actually get the votes has untimely broken all the stairways to heaven. If one calmly considers the facts, one will easily conclude that all these plans manufactured by the perverted brains of the demons, with their myopic vision, can never bring peace in the world. Of course, in one matter all the demons readily agree, and that is to surreptitiously enjoy Lakñmé, the goddess of fortune and eternal consort of the Supreme Lord, without the knowledge of the Lord Himself.

Every demon is vainly proud, thinking no one is more intelligent and esteemed than himself. Therefore the overpowering desires that urge him on to perform various activities are, according to him, ultimately beneficial for human society. In the end, of course, it is inevitably revealed that all his aspirations were illusory and unrealistic. Yet despite this revelation, the demons continue to influence the populace through manipulations and lies.

There are no limits to the imagination of these unclean and deluded demons. They pose as self-styled leaders and endlessly worry about the welfare of society. They worry, for example, about where to lodge the people who come to purchase in the marketplace. What they actually think about is how to make foolproof arrangements to secure their own long-lasting enjoyment, along with their children's, their grandchildren's, and their great-grandchildren's enjoyment, up to the final dissolution of the world. But when they experience suffering instead of pleasure, the demons revert to violence against their fellow men to accumulate wealth. Their material desires are insatiable, and so even billions of dollars cannot appease them. Whoever is expert in illegally amassing huge fortunes becomes the top dog. The demons are full of hate, greed, anger, lust, etc., and they are tireless in their efforts to illicitly amass great wealth merely to gratify their sensual urges. On the other hand, their competitors are no less expert in cheating them of their black wealth. How can such ruthless competition aimed at stealing one another's illegally-earned money bring about peace and prosperity? Hence the demons can never help the person who laments, "In the dispensation of providence, man cannot have any rest."

The demon is always ruminating on how to increase their bank balance: "Today the stocks have gone up, and so also have my profits. Tomorrow, if these other commodities become dearer, my bank balance will further increase. And so my future looks bright and prosperous." The demon continues to think, but now on a slightly different subject: "One of my enemies has already been destroyed, and another one is soon to meet his end. This puts me in a more secure position. So now that I have become adept at eliminating my enemies, I am God Almighty. Why must one look in search of God? Hundreds of 'Gods' are floating right before your eyes." Such thoughts and actions make the demons more and more atheistic, and thus they refuse to hear the transcendental message of God. They proudly declare, "Who is God? Why, I am God! When I can illegally manipulate funds and become so wealthy that I can enjoy everything in this world, then I am indeed Almighty God. I am strong and happy and accomplished. Those who are weaklings, without money and means, must respect me as God. What is the use of crying after any other God?"

The demons are under the impression that no one is more wealthy and popular than themselves. They think that their wealth will somehow be protected by some spirit, and in this way they are deluded. Their final destination is hell.

The few religious deeds that the demons perform are merely a show; they are meant only to flatter their false ego and bring them more recognition and respect. They perform them only for their own sense enjoyment and are invariably acts of violence. The demons engage in these rituals without following the scriptural injunctions, merely to appease their vainglory.

Strutting with false pride, strength, anger, lust, and so on, the demons become totally absorbed in bodily consciousness, thinking "This is my body. I am Indian, Bengali, and so on. He is a Muslim; he is a Hindu; he is a German." In this way they perpetrate acts of violence on others. The Supreme Lord repeatedly puts these most abominable, wretched sinners into the most distressful conditions, constantly punishing them with His stringent laws of nature, or daivé mäyä. Thus taking repeated births as demons, these reprobates can never appreciate the transcendental pastimes, names, beauty, and so on, of the Supreme Lord. Gradually cultivating the impersonal knowledge of the Absolute, they are destined to suffer the worst possible life.

RTW 1.4: The Cause of the Demoniac Mentality

The Cause of the Demoniac Mentality

There are numerous causes of the demoniac mentality, but in this essay we shall broadly delve into only three: lust, anger, and greed. In the Bhagavad-gétä (16.21) Lord Kåñëa describes these three characteristics as destroyers of the self—portals leading to hell.

The Supreme Personality of Godhead is the sole proprietor and enjoyer of everything. When the living entities forget this fact, they develop an intense desire to enjoy this phenomenal world. But they cannot be fully satisfied by such endeavors, and thus anger develops. Anger causes frustration, as in the story of the unsuccessful fox and the "sour grapes." The living entity is then forced to pretend to be a renouncer. But at the bottom of such renunciation burns the great flame of greed and the desire for enjoyment. This is only another stage of material desire. Therefore, unless one transcends this stage of acceptance and rejection of physical pleasures and becomes situated on the platform of the eternal self, one cannot understand the sublime message of the Lord. And without this understanding, one will continue to cultivate the demoniac mentality.

The only method by which one can elevate himself form the depths of demoniac depravity to the path of self-realization is to learn the injunctions of the scriptures and act accordingly. Chaotic and undisciplined activities contrary to scriptural instructions are actions performed out of lust. It is not possible to eradicate anger and greed through such acts of lust; nor is it possible to experience true happiness and divine elevation. Therefore if we wish to find the path to spiritual upliftment and eternal peace—the need for which is expressed in the lament "In the dispensation of providence, mankind cannot have any rest"—revealed scriptures are our only guide. Simply by executing the injunctions of the scriptures, we can become free from acts of lust and chaotic living.

At present we are living in the thick of Kali-yuga. The people of this age are mostly short-lived, misguided, unfortunate and always tormented by disease and distress. Therefore it is not easy for them to appreciate the words of the scriptures. The followers of the world's various religions—Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Buddhists, and so on—are transgressing the scriptural injunctions of their own faiths to varying degrees and living as they like. Many people, far from following scriptural injunctions, ridicule the sacred texts and thus gradually slide down to a demoniac life of unrestricted sense enjoyment. The Supreme Lord and His devotees are very much concerned about the deliverance of these conditioned souls afflicted by the ill influence of Kali-yuga. The devotees, or Vaiñëavas, are the most compassionate, saintly souls, and thus they ardently desire to deliver the fallen living entities. The Supreme Lord always responds to the desires of these Vaiñëavas, and so He answers their prayers for the salvation of these suffering souls of Kali-yuga.

Seeing the miserable condition of the living entities in the Kali-yuga, Lord Caitanya, the savior of the fallen souls, has expounded a method for their salvation. This method is taken from the scriptures and is applicable to everyone. In previous ages, one could study the Vedas and purify oneself by living according to those instructions. But it is impossible for the present population to properly execute scriptural injunctions, which includes strictly following vows of celibacy. One who is extremely degraded and sinful cannot find the accurate path to realization by studying the Vedas. It is a waste of time even to explain the meaning of the Vedas to such persons, who are devoid of proper up-bringing and discipline. Lord Caitanya has indeed showered His mercy upon these Kali-yuga people. So there is no doubt that those who are unable even to receive this mercy from Lord Caitanya are forever bereft of saving grace. As for those fortunate souls who, after realizing the greatness of Lord Caitanya's mercy, have accepted it—they have escaped the punishments of mäyä, or "the dispensation of providence." But for those who have agreed to come under the influence of the cycle of karmic reactions and are being pummeled about by mäyä, the Supreme Lord has arranged the process of karma-yoga, or fruitive activities with the aim of sacrifice to the Supreme Lord.

The learned sages say that the living entities go through 8,400,000 species of life. There are 900,000 aquatic species; 2,000,000 plants, mountains, and other nonmoving species; 1,100,000 insect and worm species; 1,000,000 bird species; 3,000,000 animal species; and 400,000 human species. After passing through all these species, the soul is finally born as a human being in Bhärata-varña, India. He achieves this birth by gradually awakening his consciousness. Many millions of years flash by as the soul goes through each of the above-mentioned species of life. So, even after all this, if the soul, despite being born as a human being in India, continues to be subjugated by mäyä and goes round in the whirlpool of "the dispensation of providence," then there is no limit to his misfortune. Çréla Kåñëadäsa Kaviräj has therefore written,

bhärata-bhümite haila manuñya-janma yära
janma särthaka kari' kara para-upakära
[Ädi 9.41]

One who has take his birth as a human being in the land of India (Bhärata-varña) should make his life successful and work for the benefit of all other people.

Human beings can perfect their lives by following in the footsteps of those great sages of India who have all along shown the proper path. The reason for this is simple: Nowhere else can we find an example of the manner in which the sages of India have endeavored to find absolute cessation of mäyä's attack and to become an eternal dust particle of the Supreme Lord's lotus feet. In other countries, especially in the Occident, tremendous progress has been a made in the various fields of material science—but it is all based on the material mind and body, which are creations of mäyä, the illusory potency. It is for this reason that the Westerners lament, "In the dispensation of providence, man cannot have any rest." At present, the Indians have similarly taken to the path of self-destruction by aping the Western ways. The have discarded and desecrated their own culture and have become beggars at another's door. They are now flying their flag of independence, but this is also a dispensation of mäyä. Factually, they cannot gain anything from it. The Occident has never delved into the three stages in the development of the eternal relationship between the infinitesimal soul and the infinite Supreme Whole. These stages are, first, the initial contact with the Supreme Lord and the re-awakening of one's relationship with him; second, the execution of the means to achieve one's eternal relationship with Him; and finally, the blossoming of that relationship into one of love and total dependence of the soul upon the Lord.

Although Western people have brilliantly developed in mundane matters, they are tossed about in a sea of despair and listlessness. Similarly, the Indians, although trying to feel grateful for their mundane development, are experiencing the same listlessness and dissatisfaction. Strangely enough, now the Western thinkers are looking toward India to find peace and calm. We can safely harbor the firm conviction that soon the message of peace will reach their ears.

RTW 1.5: The Formula for Peace

The Formula for Peace

Lord Krñëa, seeing the distressful condition of the living entities and forseeing their bleak future, spoke the scripture known as Bhagavad-gétä, which contains unequivocal instructions for mankind. These instructions are like the cooling showers of peace on the blazing forest fire of material existence. Ordinary human activities are quite different from the activities recommended in the Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä; understanding this difference is essential for us. In our times we find many fruitive workers who claim to be karma-yogés but in fact are seen to enjoy the fruits of their labor. What is needed is not this false karma-yoga but genuine buddhi-yoga, which Lord Kåñëa several times explains in the Bhagavad-gétä. Buddhi-yoga means "devotion to the Supreme Lord." The Lord says in the Gétä (10.10), "To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me." Elsewhere in the Gétä (18.55) the Lord says, "One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service." Therefore, since buddhi-yoga is the means to attain the Supreme Lord, then buddhi-yoga is nothing other than devotional service. The Supreme Lord is attained through loving devotional service. This fact is well known. Hence the Lord is also known as bhakta-vatsala, "He who is especially inclined toward His devotees."

The course of action one chooses through executing buddhi-yoga is the very means for mankind to attain lasting peace. Such a course of action will enable man to find rest "in the dispensation of providence." We can clearly understand the essence of buddhi-yoga from the Bhagavad-gétä (Chapter 2.39-40):

Thus far I have declared to you the analytical knowledge of säìkhya philosophy. Now listen to the knowledge of yoga whereby one works without fruitive result. O son of Påthä, when you act by such intelligence, you can free yourself from the bondage of works. In this endeavor there is no loss or diminution, and a little advancement on this path can protect one from the most dangerous type of fear.

The attainment of peace through the process of säìkhya-yoga is for the modern man almost impossible. But peace is easily available through the process of buddhi-yoga, or loving devotional service to the Supreme Lord. And this peace is of the highest nature: it far exceeds the happiness experienced through any other process. Activities that are directly connected to devotional service blossom and develop unhindered by anything external. The amount of devotional activity one performs always remains intact; it is a permanent spiritual gain for the performer, never to be rendered futile. Even a little execution of devotional service is enough to save one from the greatest type of fear.

The process of pure devotional service is one. At the same, time the Gétä points out how to execute buddhi-yoga through jïäna, or analytical study, and karma, or fruitive action. When buddhi-yoga is executed in conjunction with fruitive activity, it is known as karma-yoga. Similarly, when it is executed in conjunction with analytical study, then it is called jïäna-yoga. And when buddhi-yoga, or devotional service, transcends both karma-yoga and jïäna-yoga and becomes completely unalloyed, that devotion is called pure bhakti-yoga, or loving devotional service to the Supreme Lord.

The fruitive activities one performs in this world, whether according to social norms or Vedic standards, give different results. Again, by experiencing the fruits of those labors, one creates new sets of activities and their concomitant results, which in turn give rise to newer sets of activities and their results. All these activities and their results cannot automatically be labeled karma-yoga. We can see that the process of performing fruitive actions and experiencing their results is like a mammoth tree sprouting endless branches and twigs. Can the performer of actions who experiences the endless fruits of that mammoth tree ever enjoy peace and benediction? No. Therefore it is said, "In the dispensation of providence, mankind cannot have any rest." Even in this lifetime, one who performs fruitive work is totally entangled in the cycle of karma as he sits on the tree of material existence. As a result, the soul must enter 8,400,000 species and suffer the threefold miseries, never finding any rest or peace.

Yet people find it impossible to renounce fruitive activities. Even the so-called sannyäsés who make a show of renouncing such activities must still perform many activities, at least to relieve their hunger. Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya, seeing the condition of the sannyäsés during his time, commented, "One takes on many different garbs just to fill one's stomach." And trying to give up all activities is no solution. When Çré Arjuna, a warrior, wanted to forsake his duty of fighting a war, the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, advised him, "Perform your prescribed duty, for action is better than inaction. A man cannot even maintain his physical body without work." (Bhagavad-gétä 3.8)

A person should never give up his prescribed duty without scriptural authorization, for this will cause chaos in the world. Since it is impossible to maintain the body without activities, it is impossible to totally renounce activities. On the other hand, the tree of material entanglement, which thrives on fruitive activities and their results, can never bring forth any hope for peace. It is for this reason that the Supreme Lord has explained how one is to perform activities:

Work done as a sacrifice for Viñëu has to be performed, otherwise work binds one to this material world. Therefore, O son of Kunté, perform your prescribed duties for His satisfaction, and in that way you will always remain unattached and free from bondage. (Bhagavad-gétä 3.9)

It is another kind of "dispensation of providence" when the fruits of actions do not bind one. To perform all activities only as a sacrifice for the satisfaction of Lord Viñëu is true freedom from the results of activities, or the real art of karma-yoga. Through this process of karma-yoga one is freed from the shackles of fruitive results and one's inherent eternal loving devotion for the Supreme Lord gradually manifests. This type of karma-yoga is also referred to as desireless actions, or naiñkarmya, or in other words activities performed without expectation of any sense gratification. One who works in this way offers all the results of his actions to the Supreme Lord instead of enjoying them himself.

All of us must try to earn whatever money is required to maintain ourselves and our family. Money buys food, and food maintains our body. Without sufficient food, the body becomes weak and useless, and then it cannot generate further means for its sustenance. Which is the cause and which the effect is very difficult to establish. Such is the cycle of fruitive activities. Our material existence birth after birth consists of going round the great cycle of fruitive activity. If, by the mercy of the Supreme Lord or His pure representative, a fortunate soul caught in the midst of this turning wheel can understand his distressful condition, he begins to perform activities that will free him from this bondage.

RTW 1.6: Life's Only Goal

Life's Only Goal

Our objective is not the temporary peace and happiness available in the material world. As living entities we are eternal, and hence the desire for permanent happiness should be our prime motive. Yet we souls change millions of bodies, going up and down the fourteen material planetary systems, chasing after illusory peace and pleasures, expending huge amounts of blood and energy. The permanent peace and happiness we demonically run after eludes us constantly; we do not know where real peace and happiness are available. As Prahläda Mahäräja says in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (7.9.25),

In this material world, every living entity desires some future happiness, which is exactly like a mirage in the desert. Where is water in the desert, or, in other words, where is happiness in this material world?

In search of truth we become deviated and, taking shelter of the boat of the material body and mind, travel aimlessly in the ocean of material existence, with no land in sight. Mercilessly tossed about, we brood, "In the dispensation of providence, man cannot have any rest." If only we knew that our ultimate destination is Lord Viñëu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead! Then we could end our suffering. To dispel our ignorance about this fact, Lord Krñëä has informed us that we must perform all activities as a sacrifice for Lord Viñëu's satisfaction. The Åg Veda confirms this: "Lord Viñëu is the Supreme shelter of everything. All the demigods are constantly meditating on Him." Thus we see that the demigods also consider Lord Viñëu's lotus feet their supreme destination, and they become liberated simply by performing all activities for His pleasure. One who wants release from the vicious karmic cycle must have Lord Viñëu's lotus feet as his final objective. Otherwise, he will have to become demoniac.

The followers of the varëäçrama way of life, or sanätana-dharma, are now being called Hindus. Their forefathers, especially those who belonged to the upper castes—the brähmaëas, kñatriyas, and vaiçyas—centered their lives on Lord Viñëu. In every stage of life, especially in the householder stage, people worshiped Lord Viñëu in their homes, performing devotional service for His satisfaction. A few very devoted souls continue to do so even today. They collect money only for the Lord's service. The money buys grains and vegetables, which they cook with devotion and then offer to Lord Viñëu. Later the devotees honor this prasädam, the Lord's mercy in the form of food, by eating it. In all these activities Lord Viñëu is the enjoyer, and one seeks to please Him. In the past, the times were conducive to such activities, and even now they are practiced in many places. Actually, such devotional service is applicable to everyone, to all places, and to all times.

Lord Viñëu is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the goal of everything. Performing all works for His satisfaction is the only way to open up the path of liberation from the cycle of fruitive action, or karma. It is recommended that all progressive and beneficial activities be executed for the pleasure of the Supreme Lord, Viñëu. Echoing the words of the scriptures, the learned sages proclaim "the attainment of Lord Viñëu's lotus feet is the same as becoming liberated." The final step in the karma-yoga process is to satisfy Lord Viñëu, at which point one's own desires are automatically fulfilled. While delineating this point, Lord Kåñëa says that if work is not performed for His satisfaction, then all activities are tainted with sin and result in sinful reactions, which created havoc in society. In the Bhagavad-gétä (3.13), Lord Kåñëa says, "The devotees of the Lord are released from all kinds of sins because they eat food which is first offered for sacrifice. Others, who prepare food for personal sense enjoyment, verily eat only sin."

Preparing and eating food in the way just mentioned is service to the Supreme Lord, Viñëu. Sometimes it may appear that some sin is being committed in its execution, but if one takes and honors the remnants of the sacrifice, or offering to Lord Viñëu, then one is automatically exonerated from all binding reactions and becomes liberated. Though we may live very carefully, trying to avoid sins and strictly follow the path of nonviolence, still our lives are controlled by the cycle of karmic reactions. Hence, unwittingly we are forced to commit many kinds of sin. We commit so many sins in business transactions, common human dealings, daily chores, and especially political and administrative activities. It is fine to vociferously support nonviolence, but in actual life one is compelled to commit acts of violence. One may succeed in avoiding many kinds of sin, but it is impossible to escape committing the five great sins called païca-sünä. While walking on the street we may crush many ants to death against our wishes. While cleaning house, we may squash many insects to death. While grinding food grains or lighting a fire, we destroy many tiny lives. In this way, while executing our ordinary, daily chores we are forced to commit violence and take many innocent lives. Willingly or unwillingly, we commit sins. Thus, when a religion fabricated by the human brain prompts one to embrace the path of nonviolence for its own sake, it inevitably gives advantage to one and difficulty to another.

It is impossible to be exempted from the adversities caused by mentally concocted beliefs. According to man-made laws, if one person murders another he is condemned to the gallows, but no action is taken against a man for killing animals. Such is not the law of providence. The law of God is such that it punishes the killers of both man and animals; both acts of murder are penalized. The atheists deny the existence of God because in this way they think they can commit sins unhindered. But all the revealed, authorized scriptures say that by killing innocent creatures, the householders commit many sins willingly or unwillingly while performing their normal daily activities. To get release from these sins, the householders are enjoined to perform certain sacrifices. Foremost of these is to eat and honor the remnants of food offered to Lord Viñëu. As for those selfish householders who cook food only for their own sensual pleasure and not for the service of Lord Viñëu, they have to suffer all the sinful reactions incurred while cooking and eating. This is the law of providence. Therefore, to get rid of these sins, the followers of the Vedic religion dedicate their household activities to Lord Viñëu's service.

The leaders of society are therefore advised to perform devotional service for Lord Viñëu's satisfaction—both for their own benefit and for the benefit of those they lead. As Lord Kåñëa says to Çré Arjuna in the Bhagavad-gétä (3.21), "Whatever action is performed by a great man, common men follow in his footsteps. And whatever standards he sets by exemplary acts, all the world pursues." Because everyone follows their example, the leaders are required to carefully study the process of devotional service to Lord Viñëu. This is their duty. Thus for the benefit of human society, there is a great need to construct universities that will impart knowledge of devotional service.

Alas! The times are such that those who are considered leaders and stalwarts of society are more viciously inimical to God than others. Therefore, what devotional service for Lord Viñëu's satisfaction can they perform? And if they cannot perform devotional service, then how will they gain release from their innumerable sins? If the stalwarts of society are not willing to declare that Lord Viñëu is the omnipresent Absolute Truth, and that He is all-pervasive due to His being both a person as well as formless, then what can the lesser men, the man on the street, understand about this esoteric subject matter? The Supreme Lord is the sole proprietor of everything. We cannot take the position of the enjoyer and proprietor of this material world. Whatever the Supreme Lord mercifully gives us as His remnants, that alone should we accept. We must never desire another's property. As the Éçopaniñad [1] states,

Everything animate or inanimate that is within the universe is controlled and owned by the Lord. One should therefore accept only those things necessary for himself, which are set aside as his quota, and one should not accept other things, knowing well to whom they belong."

Only when the leaders of society center all their activities on the Supreme Lord, Viñëu, will these activities bring good fortune and benediction to the leaders themselves, as well as to their followers. But if the leaders avoid performing their activities for Lord Viñëu and instead pose as Lord Viñëu themselves—taking worship, wealth, and praise from their followers and returning the same to them as remnants—then others might become attracted by their pretentious renunciation and thus follow their path to doom. But nothing further will be achieved. Such leaders uselessly excite their ignorant sycophants, inducing them to perform many sinful activities. In this way such selfish leaders bring about their followers' doom simply to increase their own distinction, adoration, and wealth. Unfortunately, the leaders do not know that these miniscule portions of distinction, adoration, and wealth will be burned to ashes with their death. But the sinful methods used to acquire these temporary material advantages will beget results, which will then very subtly mix with their subtle body, namely mind, intelligence, and false ego. And these results will later become the seeds of further sinful activities, which will entangle the soul in the cycle of karmic reactions birth after birth, forcing him go through many different species of life.

RTW 1.7: How to Cure the Material Disease

How to Cure the Material Disease

The general populace simply follows the dictates and decisions of the leaders, who are bereft of any spiritual realization. Therefore it is advised that the leaders of society should act responsibly. The easy path to prosperity opens up when these leaders intelligently put into practice the precepts of karma-yoga. Without first becoming adept at curing one's own disease, why try to treat many patients? This is unreasonable. First a leader has to adopt the principles of karma-yoga in his own life; then he has to diagnose the disease of the people; then the medicine is to be prescribed and the proper diet given. Simply to offer the suffering people a sense-gratificatory cure that titillates their senses—this is not going to make them healthy. Rather, this will spread the disease further, and at one stage the doctor himself will be infected and finally die from it.

Forgetfulness of the Supreme Lord, Viñëu, is human society's real and original disease. So, if one does not treat this ailment but instead shows insincere and shallow concern for the patients, one might give them some momentary relief and pleasure, but ultimately such a course of action cannot cure them permanently. If the patient goes for proper medicine and diet but is instead administered bad medicine and diet, then he is certainly in the jaws of death.

The remnants of food offered to the Supreme Lord, known as prasädam, is the best diet for all patients. And to discuss and hear topics glorifying the Supreme Lord, to see the Lord's Deity form and offer worship to Him, and to completely surrender oneself to the Lord—these constitute the greatest medicine, the panacea. These activities are the only secure path to prosperity, whereas other activities will wreak disaster. The practices of devotional service to the Lord can never cause harm to society; rather, they can only usher in an age of opportunities and benedictions. Those who are opportunists and financial speculators should calmly consider these facts.

Stalwarts of society like Mahätmä Gandhi are trying in various ways to usher in an age of peace, but because such endeavors are not inspired or blessed by the spiritually evolved saints, they are not turning out successful, nor will they be fruitful in the future. The God of the monists, or Mäyävädés, cannot eat, see, or hear. Such a concocted, formless God can never bring peace to the world. How can a God who has no sensory organs see the miseries of the people or hear their heartfelt prayers? To worship such a formless God in the name of searching for spiritual truth can only produce misfortune in the world, never good fortune. In the Mäyäväda school of philosophy, discussions on pure knowledge can throw some light on the real nature of the Absolute Truth, but they are unable to fully reveal the esoteric and personal aspects of the Supreme Absolute Being. These dry, empirical discussions fall far short of their objective: a complete understanding of the Absolute Truth. Therefore only if leaders like Mahatma Gandhi strive to realize the Supreme Absolute Person—not a formless energy—can they truly benefit human society.

Conditioned human beings are expert at dealing with this material body and mind. These gross materialists, who cannot see beyond materialistic activities, find it impossible to believe that besides our material universe, a spiritual universe exists. Completely identifying with the body, such materialists are like animals, simply eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. They are so captivated by these four animalistic propensities that they lose the power to discriminate between sinful and pious activities. They tirelessly endeavor for a little sense gratification, but all their efforts end in futility. Many modern scientists have taken up the role of priests facilitating such gross activities, which are unbeneficial and fatal. These scientists have made available a variety of products meant simply to titillate the senses, thus creating a deadly competitive mood among the materialists, which has in turn caused an obnoxious atmosphere in society. People think they become free and independent through such sensual activities, but factually they become more tightly bound up in chains. The greater their accumulated wealth, the greater their anxiety and depravity. As much as they try to usurp the Supreme Lord's position of being the only enjoyer, that much and more are they drawn into the jaws of a horrible death. And these activities make a Herculean task out of such a simple and basic activity as sustaining the body, which needs a little nourishment only.

A grade higher than this mean class of gross materialists are those who believe in the transmigration of the soul. These are the fruitive workers who perform pious activities such as giving in charity, but their only motive is to ensure that their next life is one of luxury and sense enjoyment. Neither of these grades of fruitive workers realizes that both pious as well as sinful activities cause bondage. These materialists do not know that karma-yoga, activity performed without fruitive desire, is the best form of activity. Therefore they often think that the karma-yogés are as attached to this material world as the gross materialists. The sole motive of the karma-yogé, however, is to instruct the members of society for their benefit. As Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, says in the Bhagavad-gétä (3.25) "As the ignorant perform their duties with attachment to results, similarly the learned may also act, but without attachment, for the sake of leading people on the right path."

Like others, sages who are in knowledge of the Absolute Truth maintain their bodies, but the difference is that the goal of all their activities is to satisfy Lord Viñëu. Although the general mass of people may wrongly think that the sages' activities are the same as their own, in fact the sages are performing karma-yoga, not fruitive activity.

Present times have seen the widespread expansion of modern science and technology in our world in a variety of forms, which have entangled society more and more in the vicious cycle of karma. Huge factories, universities, hospitals, and so on, are certain to entangle society further in the karmic cycle. Bygone ages never witnessed such huge, complex arrangements for gross materialistic activities. Wrong and simply bad association has tightly bound up the innocent populace in mean activities. But the learned man, the karma-yogé, can show society how to perform all these activities for the satisfaction of the Lord.

Previously, sages arranged for Lord Viñëu's Deity to be worshiped in practically every household, thereby creating the atmosphere for people to become karma-yogés. Similarly, it is now urgent that similar arrangements be made to worship and serve Lord Viñëu in the huge factories, mercantile firms, hospitals, and so on. This can firmly establish true equality among men under a spiritual banner. Lord Näräyaëa is not poor; He is the Supreme Lord of Lords. And hence attempts to say that the poor people are "Näräyaëas" is foolish. Rather, by widely organizing the worship and service of the Lord, one can greatly benefit everyone, including the poor. The Supreme Personality of Godhead manifests Himself in many forms, but the sages have chosen three of His multifarious forms to serve and worship as the Deity. They are Lakñmé-Näräyaëa, Sétä-Räma, and Rädhä-Kåñëa. These three Deity couples are widely worshiped all over the Indian subcontinent. Therefore, we request the owners of large factories and business firms to establish the worship and service of any of these three Deities in their establishments. The owners can then distribute prasädam, offered food, to everyone. This practice will repair any disagreements between worker and owner, because both will become karma-yogés.

Most factory workers and other laborers cannot maintain a good character and thus slide down to depravities. And if such derelicts increase in population, the world has no chance for a prosperous and fortunate future. But if the owners give their laborers and office staff prasädam, then both the givers and the receivers will gradually become purified and more attracted to the Supreme Lord. The whole society will become elevated, civilized, and united in harmony. On the other hand, by trying to achieve only their selfish interests, the owners create a situation in which any harmony or unity is not only fragile but dangerous. And when the owners fire these degraded laborers in pursuit of their crass self-interest, neither the owners themselves nor the laborers are benefited. Soon the workers automatically turn inimical toward their employers.

When laborers and bosses perform activities that are not intended to please Lord Viñëu and are in fact troublesome to the Lord, they end up arguing and fighting with each other, thus creating an awful situation in society. The Communists and Socialists are spending money, intelligence, and even lives propagating their "isms"; the Bolsheviks revolted, disrupting the entire land of Russia and promising to fulfill the people's dream of a prosperous household life on a mass scale; the workers' unions are constantly at odds with the employers. All these complicated problems have one simple solution: everyone should perform karma-yoga, or work meant to please the Supreme Lord.

The endeavors human beings have made to establish a close and harmonious relationship with one another have culminated in the United Nations. This organization is based on the concept of the family unit. The gradual expansion of the family unit to a large community, to a village, to a state, to a country, and finally to a continent has given the clue for the formation of the United Nations. The thing to be noted, however, is its center. What is the central attraction? If the process of expansion were reversed, we would end up with the human body as the basic unit. The senses are of prime importance in the body; more important than the senses is the mind, then intelligence, and finally the false ego. And more important than the false ego is the real self, a pure spiritual being that is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, Viñëu. Therefore the conclusion is that the fountainhead of everything is Lord Viñëu. For this reason Prahläda Mahäräja said,

Persons who are strongly entrapped by the consciousness of enjoying material life, and who have therefore accepted as their leader or guru a similar blind man attached to external sense objects, cannot understand that the goal of life is to return home, back to Godhead, and engage in the service of Lord Viñëu. [Bhäg. 7.5.31]

Those who lose sight of the center and become attracted to the externals are shallow and misguided. These misguided persons are in a sense blind; hence the world cannot expect them to give any guidance toward enlightenment. However much these blind people may pretend to guide and benefit other blind people, factually they are fully controlled by the will of providence. We should make the effort to understand that the cause and source of everything is Lord Viñëu, the Absolute Truth, and that the fullest manifestation of this Absolute Truth is Lord Kåñëa, the source of even Lord Viñëu. As Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.7), "O conqueror of wealth [Arjuna], there is no truth superior to Me."

Thus the ultimate source of everything is indeed Lord Kåñëa Himself, the all-attractive Supreme Personality of Godhead. After considerable deliberation, the sages in the past concluded that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Being, the origin of all expansions and manifestations of the Supreme Absolute Truth. As the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.3.28) declares, "All of the abovementioned incarnations are either plenary portions or portions of the plenary portions of the Lord, but Lord Çré Kåñëa is the original Personality of Godhead..." Later we will discuss more thoroughly the subject of the expansions of Lord Viñëu, but for now let us establish that Lord Kåñëa is the highest aspect of the Supreme. The Brahma-saàhitä (5.1) confirms this: "Kåñëa who is known as Govinda is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal blissful spiritual body. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin and He is the prime cause of all causes."

Thus if we can transcend the material body and its physical relationships and become connected with everyone through the Lord Kåñëa, the original Godhead, we can relate on a platform of truth and reality. Then the actual meaning of fraternity and equality will crystalize.

RTW 1.8: The Living Entities' Real Identity

The Living Entities' Real Identity

A man's relationship with his sister's husband is based on his relationship with his sister. The brother-in-law, prior to his marriage with the sister, was a complete stranger to the man. And when their children become the man's nieces and nephews, his relationship with them is also based on his sister. Similar relationships grow up among races and nationalities, centering on the country of birth. Thus we have Indians, Bengalis, Punjabis, Germans, and so on. We also find relationships centering on religious beliefs. Thus there are Hindus, Muslims, Christians, and so on. But however much we might endeavor to adapt to such partial personalities of the self, and however we try to increase the number of these fractional identities, we will remain infinitesimal and partial. Being part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, if we do not aspire to serve Him, then we forgo our actual identity and fall down into nescience. An appropriate parallel is the functioning of the body: If a limb refuses to execute its usual duty, it becomes useless to the body. Similarly, if our activities are not focused on Lord Kåñëa, they are rendered impotent and valueless. The eternal constitutional position of the self is to serve the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. In fact, all our sufferings start from our refusal to act in our original capacity as Lord Kåñëa's eternal servants. Therefore, the prime duty of all living entities is to become re-instated in their original, constitutional position. The first step toward that goal is to perform karma-yoga. In the Caitanya-caritämåta it is stated, "The living entity is bound around the neck by the chain of mäyä because he has forgotten that he is eternally a servant of Kåñëa."

People in general are ignorant and addicted to fruitive activities. Without disturbing their minds, the karma-yogé can benefit them by explaining the truth about man's eternal position as Lord Kåñëa's servant. Thus in the Bhagavad-gétä (3.26) Lord Kåñëa instructs,

Let not the wise disrupt the minds of the ignorant who are attached to fruitive action. They should not be encouraged to refrain from work, but to engage in work in the spirit of devotion.

It is very difficult to convince those who adhere to fruitive activities that they should render devotional service to Lord Kåñëa. The reason is that most fruitive workers are foolish, fallen and impious. Therefore all their activities are whimsical and motivated by evil. Their intelligence and expertise are thus utilized in defiance of the Supreme Lord. They are totally in the grip of the illusory potency, mäyä, and so they imagine themselves to be the Supreme Lord Himself, or at least His biggest competitor, like the demon Çiñupäla. They simply try to enjoy this material world in various ways. In fact, their hopes for enjoying this world are just make—believe, or mäyä, and this make-believe yearning leaves them hopelessly cheated. Yet they cannot give up the hope to enjoy. And when they realize that fruitive activities are futile and are more or less forced to renounce them, then such renunciation becomes merely another illusory scheme for a greater enjoyment.

Those who hanker after the fruits of their actions undertake many hardships in executing their work, their imagination wanders like an untethered bull, and all the while their mind dictates to them that they are the actual enjoyers. Therefore, without disrupting the minds of these foolish, perverted karmés, the intelligent person should engage them in doing what they are expert in and using the fruits in Lord Kåñëa's service. Such a course of action will automatically uncover the fruitive workers' eternal relationship with Lord Kåñëa. So, to instruct the people for their benefit, the servant of Kåñëa, who is free from the reactions of fruitive activities, will lead a life seemingly like that of the fruitive workers, but actually he is all along performing karma-yoga.

Had not Lord Kåñëa mercifully instructed the process of karma-yoga to His devotee Çré Arjuna, the ignorant souls would have suffered miserably for all time. These wretched karmés have the noose of mäyä constantly wrapped around their necks and are living from one distress to another, but because the Lord's deluding potency covers their intelligence, they cannot understand any of this. However much they might pretend to be the controllers, they are being continuously goaded by mäyä, who leaves them helpless and impotent. Lord Kåñëa has explained this in the Bhagavad-gétä (3.27), "The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities, which are in actuality carried out by nature."

The foolish karmé cannot comprehend that because he has forgotten Lord Kåñëa and is trying to usurp His position, the Lord's external potency, mäyä, has tied a noose around his neck with the rope of the three modes of nature and is making him suffer excruciating pains. Although all of his activities are within the grip of the three modes of material nature and orchestrated by mäyä, still the grossly foolish karmé believes that he is the master of his situation. Thus he busies himself with trying to make better arrangements for living in the world of duality.

Lord Kåñëa instructs us that the living entities are His separated parts. The duty of the part is to serve the whole. A complete body has different parts and limbs, such as hands, legs, eyes, and ears. The hands and legs work the hardest, but they do not refuse to give food to the stomach, although the stomach does very little. On the other hand, if the hands and legs act contrarily and actually refuse to feed the stomach, then an impossible situation is created. There is no question of the hands and legs trying to enjoy in this situation, because the lack of food in the stomach will cause the hands and legs to become weak and useless. The book Hitopadeça explains this point in detail in the story "The Belly and the Senses."

Lord Kåñëa is like the life air and the soul of the massive body of the entire cosmos. In several places in the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa makes this point—that He is the origin and cause of everything. Especially notable are 7.7, "There is no truth superior to Me," and 9.24, "I am the only enjoyer and master of all sacrifices." Therefore, how can there still be any doubt that Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord and that the living beings are His eternal servitors? We have forgotten this simple truth, and thus instead of using our mind and senses in the Supreme Lord's service, we ourselves are posing as little Supreme Lords and utilizing our mind and senses to enjoy this material world. This is mäyä.

Nowadays, different societies are shooting up like mushrooms. One such society that has made its presence felt claims to have started a movement for establishing the ideal kingdom of Lord Rämacandra. But the kingdom of Räma it is propagating seems to be without Lord Räma. Lord Räma's biggest competitor was a demon named Rävaëa, and present-day descendants of Rävaëa are also busy trying to kill Lord Räma. So, where is the question of wanting to usher in the golden age of Lord Räma? If one is sincere about establishing the ideal kingdom of Lord Räma, then everything in the world should be engaged in Lord Räma's service. But the attempt to reduce the position and prestige of Lord Räma is in fact an attempt to establish the tyrannical rule of Rävaëa, the demon king. And if such a mistake is committed, then Hanumän, the valiant and invincible servant of Lord Räma, will have to come and rectify the situation by destroying the entire race of demons. In order to avoid this mistake at the outset, we must follow the path of karma-yoga taught by Lord Kåñëa.

The karmés are foolish and ignorant, whereas the karma-yogés are wise and learned. These wise men know that the nature of the material modes and material activities is exactly opposite to that of the soul. For this reason the karma-yogés never engage in material activities under the modes of material nature, as the karmés do, but rather perform karma-yoga, which is meant to satisfy Lord Viñëu. Such wise men always keep themselves aloof from close association with this phenomenal world, for they aspire to elevate the soul to its original spiritual position. They understand that the soul has come into contact with matter only by a freak arrangement. Therefore, although their ears, eyes, and other senses are involved in this phenomenal world, the sages refrain from material activities. As Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (3.28),

One who is in knowledge of the Absolute Truth, O mighty-armed, does not engage himself in the senses and sense gratification, knowing well the differences between work in devotion and work for fruitive results.

Then in Chapter 3.30-31, Lord Kåñëa describes the means for achieving such a liberated state,

Therefore, O Arjuna, surrendering all your works unto Me, with mind intent on Me, and without desire for gain and free from egoism and lethargy, fight. One who executes his duties according to My injunctions and who follows this teaching faithfully, without envy, becomes free from the bondage of fruitive actions.

Identifying the self with the material body and mind, or thinking that the soul is material, or thinking that everything in relation to the body belongs to oneself—such illusions keep a person ignorant and bereft of self-realization. Therefore Lord Kåñëa advises us to be situated in knowledge of the self. When we become spiritually aware, we can understand that the "I," the self, is not the body or mind; we can realize that we are products of the superior, spiritual energy of the Supreme Lord and hence fully spiritual and eternal. With realization of these transcendental truths comes knowledge of the actual nature of the material energy in its pure form. And when these spiritual realizations gradually mature, one achieves a natural distance from the dualities of material nature. At this stage of spiritual development, the false ego is destroyed, all false identification and titles are removed, and we are liberated from the shackles of the illusory, material energy on the strength of our spiritual association with the Transcendence. No longer does mäyä entangle us in material activities.

There are sufficient scriptural proofs to substantiate that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Absolute Truth. Even scriptures like the Bible or the Koran, declare that the Absolute Truth is the all-powerful, all knowing Supreme Person. Throughout the Vedic literature, that Supreme Person is declared to be Lord Kåñëa. And in the Bhagavad-gétä, Lord Kåñëa Himself says that He is the Absolute Truth. Thus simply by associating somehow with Lord Kåñëa, we can become illuminated about the divine Self. When the sun rises in the morning, everything again becomes visible in the sunlight. Similarly, when the sun of Lord Kåñëa rises on the horizon of the transcendental spiritual sky of our realization, the darkness of illusion is immediately extirpated. Then only does one become purified and radiant with pristine beauty.

These facts may sound exaggerated or mythical to a foolish man, but these are not fairy tales for little boys: they are the reality and the truth. Those who have taken shelter of Lord Kåñëa or His devotee can appreciate and fathom this subject matter. The only ones who will not accept this truth are those who are inimical toward Lord Kåñëa and who want to be the Supreme Lord themselves because of a perverted mind. As Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.11), "Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form." Such men are envious of the Lord. The truth about Lord Kåñëa and His transcendental position can never enter such confused and deluded brains.

RTW 1.9: In Praise of the Supreme Lord's Devotees

In Praise of the Supreme Lord's Devotees

The pious and saintly Vaiñëavas understand the exact meaning of the Bhagavad-gétä. The simple message of the Gétä is self-illuminated like the sun. Its knowledge is not hidden under a gloomy shroud of impersonalism. There is actually no room for extracting some alternative meaning and then giving a so-called esoteric dissertation on it. The devotees of Lord Kåñëa alone can fully take to heart the instructions of the Gétä, and by acting accordingly they are liberated from the awesome and eternal enslavement of the cycle of karma. Such persons are not restricted to a particular country, race, or society. The Lord's devotees belong to a class of their own—they form a spiritual society unhindered by geographical conditions. God is not the monopoly of any particular group. Therefore the message of the Gétä, being universal can be followed by anyone and everyone. After all, it is in the Gétä (9.32) that Lord Kåñëa has unconditionally declared,

O son of Påthä, those who take shelter in Me, though they be of lower birth—women, vaiçyas [merchants], as well as çüdras [workers]—can approach the supreme destination.

The demons misinterpret the words of Lord Kåñëa concerning caste and social division, and they act capriciously on that basis. But this cannot blemish Lord Kåñëa or His words. In the Bhagavad-gétä (4.13) Lord Kåñëa clearly says,

According to the three modes of material nature and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me. And, although I am the creator of this system, you should know that I am yet the non-doer, being unchangeable.

The four divisions of society—namely intellectuals, administrators, merchants, and laborers—should be determined not by birth but by merit, just as one becomes a doctor or a judge not by birthright but by merit alone. In this world of the three modes of material nature, social classes have always existed. Therefore a person's birth should never determine his caste or class in society. The four classes were created according to a person's qualifications.

Doctors are available in every country and society; similarly, the four classes of men are also present in every country and society. A son born to a doctor is not necessarily sure to grow up to be a doctor; similarly, the progeny of the four classes of society do not automatically fix their future career according to that of their parents. The scriptures describe in detail the divisions of society, with their inherent characteristics. Therefore we commit a serious mistake when we regard the different classes of men as belonging to particular countries or races. The Indian culture of today is restricted by the hereditary caste system and kept in the custody of narrow-minded people who are like frogs in a well. If instead India had spread the transcendental message of Bhagavad-gétä in the generous manner befitting a noble brähmaëa, then peace and tranquillity in this world would not be in such acutely short supply. By the propagation of brahminical culture, the world would have greatly prospered. Instead, the Vedic culture has been seriously maimed by the imposition of the hereditary caste system, and this has had grievously adverse effects on the world. The Supreme Lord in His incarnation as Lord Caitanya has opened many avenues to peaceful living by propagating the brahminical culture, which He calls the religion of the soul. Those who are fortunate can emulate His life, follow His divine teachings, and perfect their lives.

Varëäçrama-dharma, the system of four spiritual orders and four social orders of life, is of two kinds: demoniac and transcendental. They have nothing in common. The divisions of society mentioned in the scriptures are present at all times and in all lands. If one with knowledge of the scriptures scrutinizes the different societies, he can easily discern the four classes. Persons possessing brahminical or priestly qualities in varying degrees are seen in practically every society. In modern terms they are called intellectuals. All the other classes are also present. Therefore it is an established fact that the four divisions of society, according to merit, are, were, and will be present everywhere.

Those who think that brähmaëas and the other three castes exist only in Indian society are sadly mistaken. The scriptures have declared that in Kali-yuga everyone is born a çüdra, or a menial laborer, a member of the fourth class. Still, India has many persons endowed with high, brahminical characteristics, and without doubt such persons are also seen in every other country. Every country has these four classes of men, determined according merit. As a matter of a fact, even those who are less than çüdras—the caëòälas or dog-eaters—are eligible to perform devotional service. If a caëòäla becomes an elevated devotee of the Lord, then on the basis of his merit he should be respected by all other classes. There is much scriptural evidence in this regard: The Hari-bhakti-viläsa (10.91) states, "A devotee caëòäla achieves the same spiritual success as the devotee brähmaëa." And in the Bhägavatam (7.9.10), Prahläda Mahäräja says, "A devotee caëòäla is many times more elevated than an ordinary ritualistic brähmaëa." Indeed, such a devotee caëòäla can be the guru of the brähmaëas; this has been shown throughout history by many spiritual preceptors who were born in a low caste but who initiated persons of higher castes. So, the castes are classified according to merit and activity, but a pure devotee of the Lord is beyond all these classifications. He is transcendental to everything material. How can a person who is elevated beyond all castes, a saint, be adequately worshiped if he is worshiped only as a brähmaëa? Therefore one who has taken shelter of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is the recipient of all good fortune in all countries and at all times. The Bhagavad-gétä mentions this in several places.

Whatever part of this world a person belongs to, if he follows the instructions of the Supreme Lord in the Bhagavad-gétä, then he attains the transcendental platform and can become even more elevated than a brähmaëa. As Lord Kåñëa says in the Gétä (4.24),

A person who is fully absorbed in Kåñëa consciousness is sure to attain the spiritual kingdom because of his full contribution to spiritual activities, in which the consummation is absolute and that which is offered is of the same spiritual nature.

This verse explains how one can attain spiritual knowledge by performing activities that please the Supreme Lord.

Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya propounded the impersonal theory, citing phrases like sarvaà khalv idaà brahma: "By nature everything is Brahman, spirit." Çaìkaräcärya's theory has caused great confusion about established scriptural conclusions, but this phrase clearly supports the the Gétä verse quoted above.

At this point it is urgent that we discuss how one can perform devotional service for the Supreme Lord's pleasure. In this regard it is also noteworthy how saintly leaders like King Janaka executed karma-yoga, or devotional service, by performing sacrifice. The aim of all sacrifices should be to please the Supreme Lord, Viñëu or Kåñëa. Contact with matter is unavoidable in our present conditioned state, because while performing activities to sustain the body and to accomplish other purposes, we become intimate with material nature. But if we can spiritualize these activities by performing every one of them as a service to Brahman, the Supreme Absolute Truth, then these activities become yajïa, or sacrifice. When the Vedic phrase sarvaà khalv idaà brahma is interpreted in this way, it is acceptable. In other words, when one invokes the spiritual or transcendental or absolute in everything, then matter loses its mundaneness, and then only can one realize the perfect meaning of the phrase sarvaà khalv idaà brahma. The Vaiñëavas say that anything connected with the Lord in devotional service is transcendental. In other words, it is nondifferent from the Supreme Lord Himself, Mädhava. Just as iron in long and constant touch with fire loses the characteristics of iron and becomes fiery, so everything offered in sacrifice to the Absolute, or the Transcendence, becomes absolute, or transcendental.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (14.27) Lord Kåñëa says, "And I am the basis of the impersonal Brahman, which is the constitutional position of ultimate happiness." This verse unequivocally declares that Brahman is Lord Kåñëa's bodily effulgence. Since Lord Kåñëa is the source of Brahman, devotional service to Lord Kåñëa establishes the true meaning of sarvaà khalv idaà brahma. A sacrifice is properly performed only when all the sacrificial ingredients—the offerings, the fire, the ghee, and so on—become spiritualized, or reach the stage of Brahman, by their contact with Lord Kåñëa. And since the performance of sacrifice culminates in the manifestation of real love for Lord Viñëu, loving devotional service to Lord Viñëu is the very best form of sacrifice. Such a stage can be also described as total absorption in Brahman.

Persons who act in this way become progressively detached from matter and attached to Lord Kåñëa's devotional service. Thus they are able to purify the mirror of their hearts, extinguish the forest fire of material existence, and become situated in their original, spiritual position. They exist at a level of realization far above the impersonal realization of the Absolute, for they are free from the contamination of vainly trying to merge with the Supreme and usurping His Absolute position. They never fall from this stage of consciousness. Fully absorbed in their own transcendental identity, they are the complete masters of their senses. They are the perfect persons to rule this universe, if they so desire, and they alone bring good fortune to everyone. The conditioned souls, however, are unable to benefit the world in any way. The purified, rare souls continuously perform karma-yoga and are always in a liberated state. In the Bhagavad-gétä (5.7) it is stated,

One who works in devotion, who is a pure soul, and who controls his mind and senses, is dear to everyone, and everyone is dear to him. Though always working, such a man is never entangled.

There are those who live and act in a manner exactly opposite to that of the pure souls, who are constantly acting in karma-yoga. Such fruitive workers have no connection with the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. Therefore, they cannot cleanse their heart of material contamination. They are slaves of their sensual urges, spending their time in gratifying their senses according to their whims. Yet they shamelessly say that all their actions are prompted by the Supreme Lord. Being cheaters and atheists, they speak like this so that their impious acts may be acceptable, and thus they inflict untold misfortunes and calamities on the world. By contrast, the pure, self-realized souls are constantly absorbed in serving Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet with their body, mind, and words. They never associate with atheistic people. These saintly persons know that although the spirit soul is infinitesimal, it is nevertheless endowed with minute free will at all times. The Supreme Lord is absolutely independent and can exercise absolute free will over all; because the spirit soul is qualitatively the same as the Supreme Lord, the Lord does not annul his minute free will.

The spirit soul unfortunately misuses this God-given minute free will and falls into the dark well of nescience and illusion. Once the spirit soul takes shelter of mäyä, the illusory material energy, he develops the material qualities of goodness, passion, and ignorance. The spirit soul loses his original characteristics and develops a new nature, which is controlled by the three modes of material nature, and this continues until such time as he transcends them. His actions are prompted accordingly. If it happened in any other way, then material variegatedness would not be visible in this phenomenal world. So if a person fails to inform himself about the very subtle laws and workings of material nature, and at the same time he argues that all activities are sanctioned and inspired by the Supreme Lord, then he is reducing the Supreme Lord's position and making Him out to be partial and unjust. The Lord never favors one and discriminates against another. Factually, He advises everyone to give up all material activities, which are by nature unstable and temporary. Because of forgetfulness of God, a man becomes an eternal victim of ignorance, which then colours all his actions. The Bhagavad-gétä (5.14) says,

The embodied spirit, master of the city of his body, does not create activities, nor does he induce people to act, nor does he create the fruits of action. All this is enacted by the modes of material nature.

Therefore all activities except those performed as a sacrifice to Lord Viñëu are whimsical actions done of one's own volition. They are not performed under the Supreme Lord's direction or sanction. Since such activities stem from the material modes of nature, they are automatically under nature's total control. The Supreme Lord is merely an impartial and silent witness to such activities.

The actions of the karma-yogé, or devotee, are always connected with the Absolute Truth. Hence the devotee remains situated on the transcendental platform, far beyond the mundane sphere. In such a realized position, he does not see this material creation as separate from the Supreme Lord but as a transformation of His energy. Such perceptions are unhindered by the the material modes of nature. Indeed, the karma-yogé's realization of everything's inherent connection with Lord Kåñëa is equipoised and transcendental. The Gétä (5.18) states, "The humble sage, by virtue of true knowledge, sees with equal vision a learned and gentle brähmaëa, a cow, an elephant, a dog and a dog-eater [outcaste] ."

The brähmaëa endowed with such learning is primarily in the material mode of goodness. Among the animals, the cow is also in the mode of goodness; elephants, lions, and so on, are situated primarily in the mode of passion; dogs and some humans (such as the caëòälas and other outcastes) are in the mode of ignorance. The karma-yogés, who are always meditating on the Supreme, never see these outer coverings of the soul, but rather the pure soul proper. This is true equal vision in relation to the Supreme. The karma-yogés perceive that all elements and objects in this world are materials for the Supreme Lord's worship and that all living entities are eternal servitors of Lord Kåñëa. One attains the purest stage of equal vision when one ceases to take into consideration the outer covering of the soul, the body, but rather is established in the soul's innate nature of serving the Lord. In this stage one engages all things in devotional service to the Supreme Lord by using them as ingredients for sacrifice to please Lord Viñëu.

The karma-yogé knows that Lord Kåñëa is the only enjoyer and exploiter of all material objects and that He is the only Lord and master of all living entities. Forgetful of this relationship with Lord Kåñëa, the living entity falls into the clutches of mäyä, or illusion. Under the influence of mäyä, he tries in vain to act the part of an enjoyer or a renouncer—but this is all a mere fantasy. In fact, the real affliction of the living entity is the pretense he is the enjoyer or renouncer. All types of good and pious activities—like yoga, the cultivation of knowledge, austerity, and renunciation—are misapplied labor if they cannot kindle in the heart the flame of loving attraction for topics relating to the Supreme Lord. As Lord Kåñëa declares in the Bhagavad-gétä (5.29),

The sages, knowing Me as the ultimate purpose of all sacrifices and austerities, the Supreme Lord of all planets and demigods and the benefactor and well-wisher of all living entities, attain peace from the pangs of material miseries.

Earlier in this book we discussed the need for performing work as sacrifice, and now from this verse the truth that Lord Kåñëa is the original Supreme Person, the enjoyer of all sacrifices, comes out with clarity. It must be understood that the results of sacrifice performed by the karma-yogés, as well as the austerities of the knowledge-seekers, are all meant to be enjoyed by Lord Kåñëa alone. The object of the yogés' meditation, the Supersoul within the heart, is actually a partial expansion of Lord Kåñëa. We will discuss this subject matter in detail later in this book.

Lord Kåñëa is the well-wisher of the followers of all the different disciplines—karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga, añöänga-yoga (meditation), and bhakti-yoga. And because Lord Kåñëa is the well-wisher of everyone, He sends His close associates to the world to establish proper religious teachings in every millennium. Lord Kåñëa is the supreme master of all the planets, the original Lord, and the cause of all causes. The only path to peace is the path of gradual elevation in karma-yoga, leading to realization of the Absolute Truth, Lord Kåñëa.

Those who are already executing their work for the satisfaction of Lord Kåñëa are not required to separately perform sacrifices, austerities, or meditation, that are not on the platform of pure Kåñëa consciousness. Previously we explained that a pure karma-yogé is automatically a brähmaëa, sannyäsé, and a yogé. Like a karmé, or fruitive worker, he is expert in performing sacrifices and executing his duties; like a jïäné, or seeker of knowledge, he is renounced and austere; and like a yogé, he is also detached from the fruits of his work and has brought his senses under control. One who is completely detached from all fruitive work and has become attracted to the Supreme Lord and His loving devotional service is simultaneously ornamented with all good qualities. As Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (6.1),

One who is unattached to the fruits of his work and who works as he is obligated is in the renounced order of life, and he is the true mystic: not he who lights no fire and performs no duty.

Since the karma-yogé knows that the ultimate enjoyer of the fruits of all his activities is Lord Kåñëa, he does not hanker after those fruits and is fully detached from them. He always thinks of doing everything for Lord Kåñëa. Such an unattached karma-yogé never thinks that action in Kåñëa consciousness is meant for enjoying sense pleasure or avoiding pain. The sannyäsé renounces everything, including activities prescribed by the scriptures, in favor of cultivating knowledge of the Absolute. The yogé retires from active service and, desiring to see the Supersoul within his heart, spends his days in meditation with half-closed eyes. But he whose work is a sacrifice for the satisfaction of the Supreme makes no endeavors for his physical requirements. Since he is engaged in devotional service to the Supreme Lord, he is not required to execute the ritualistic activities recommended in the scriptures. Such a detached karma-yogé is superior to one who is merely unattached to the fruits of his work. The karma-yogé is automatically accomplished in the knowledge of the Absolute that the sannyäsé seeks and the eight mystic perfections that the meditating yogé aspires for.

The real karma-yogés are in fact devotees of the Supreme Lord. Since they have attained perfection, they do not hanker for profit, adoration, or distinction. In their state of perfection, all knowledge and mystic powers automatically embellish them. With everything desirable available to them, why should they need anything else?

Following the eightfold path of Pataïjali, the meditative yogés gradually elevate themselves, mastering the different stages until they reach samädhi, or the state of absorption in the Supersoul. In their desire to reach perfection, they tolerate all sorts of adversities and sufferings and remain fixed on their goal. Ultimately they attain a state of consciousness that cannot be compared to anything in this material world. In this state of mystic perfection, no suffering—not even death—seems formidable. Lord Kåñëa's comment about such yogés has been recorded in the Bhagavad-gétä (6.22),

Established thus, one never departs from the truth, and upon gaining this he thinks there is no greater gain. Being situated in such a position, one is never shaken, even in the midst of greatest difficulty."

In his purport to this verse, Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says that when one detaches himself from the sensual world and becomes situated in samädhi, complete absorption in the Absolute Truth, one perceives the pure spiritual self and is rewarded with intense bliss. Such a yogé never deviates his concentration from the Absolute Truth, the object of his meditation. The eight mystic perfections—aëimä, laghimä, präpti, präkämya, and so on—which the yogé acquires during his discipline, are by-products of his yoga practice. In samädhi the yogé regards all these mystic perfections as insignificant. Many yogés, after mastering a few of these mystic perfections, pretend to have mastered them all, and because of a restless mind they deviate from the goal of permanent samädhi. On the other hand, for the karma-yogé, the devotee of the Lord, there is no such possibility: his heart and concentration remain fixed on his goal because he always works for the pleasure of Lord Kåñëa. He is always in samädhi, the yogé's ultimate destination. In the Lord's devotional service, the devotee experiences ever-fresh emotions, and his perfections become more mature, the transcendental bliss he relishes is inexplicable and inconceivable to mundane mercenaries.

Not to speak of karma-yoga, even in the lesser discipline of eightfold yoga, whatever progress the yogé makes on the path toward the goal of samädhi does not go in vain, although he may not reach the ultimate goal in one lifetime. In his next life he will continue his progress. By contrast, when the fruitive worker dies, whatever wealth and education he has acquired, along with the endeavor that went into acquiring them, all become null and void. As for the pure karma-yogé, or devotee, his devotional activities are all beyond the level of mind and body. They are related to the soul and the Supreme Soul, and hence his activities become the wealth of his pure, eternal soul. Just as the soul is never destroyed with the disintegration of the body, so this wealth of devotional service is never devalued. Thus the Bhagavad-gétä says that the karma-yogé always works for the benefit and elevation of his soul, and that this endeavor and its results remain permanent spiritual assets in this life and the next. These spiritual assets are never liquidated. As Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (6.40),

Son of Påthä, a transcendentalist engaged in auspicious activities does not meet with destruction either in this world or in the spiritual world; one who does good, My friend, is never overcome by evil.

Human beings are divided into two categories: the law-abiders and the law-breakers. Those who care only about satisfying their senses and do not submit to discipline and law are like animals, completely uncontrolled. Whether such an uncontrolled person is cultured or uncultured, educated or uneducated, weak or strong, his actions are always bestial. Their can never benefit anyone.

The law-abiding human beings are further divided into three groups: the karmés, or fruitive workers, the jïänés, or knowledge-seekers, and the bhaktas, or devotees. The karmés are divided into two sections: the sakäma-karmés, or fruitive workers who want to enjoy the results of their labor, and the naiñkäma-karmés, who renounce the fruits of action. The sakäma-karmés are greedy after insignificant, transient happiness. They make progress in their mundane activities and enjoy the heavenly planets in the life hereafter, but all that enjoyment is temporary. Therefore the soul's real benefit evades them.

To attain true, eternal happiness, which comes only after the dissipation of material bondage, is the real benefit for the soul. Thus any path that does not lead the soul to strive for this supreme goal—eternal transcendental bliss—is considered useless. When eternal bliss is the goal of ritualistic activities (karma-käëòa), then they are transformed into karma-yoga. Through the practice of karma-yoga, the heart is purified of material contamination and one gains knowledge of the Absolute. Thereafter one becomes situated in meditation on the Absolute, and finally one attains bhakti, pure devotional service. In the process of karma-käëòa, it is recommended that one renounce physical pleasures for a time; so a karmé may sometimes be called an ascetic. Yet however much penance a karmé may perform, ultimately this penance is another form of sensual enjoyment, since that is its ultimate goal. The demons also perform penance to increase their powers, but it is all simply to enjoy their senses. Once the living entity can transcend the stage of hankering after sensual pleasures, he comes easily to the stage of karma-yoga, which is in all respects good. Only such a person can benefit society.

The spiritual progress the karma-yogé makes in this lifetime remains intact, and he continues in his next life from that point. In the Bhagavad-gétä (6.43), Lord Kåñëa comments, "On taking such a birth, he again revives the divine consciousness of his previous life, and he tries to make further progress in order to achieve complete success, O son of Kuru." In his next life the unsuccessful yogé may be born in the family of a pious brähmaëa or wealthy merchant. When we talk of failure in yoga, we refer karma-yogés, dhyäna-yogés, and jïäna-yogés. Among the followers of these paths, the karma-yogé is closest to becoming a pure devotee, since he has dedicated his activities to the Supreme Lord's service. Gradually, acting in this manner, he becomes a bhakta-yogé. Such a yogé is in the highest order, and he is fit to instruct all other yogés.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (6.47) Lord Kåñëa says,

And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all.

The fruitive workers cannot be counted among the yogés. The actual yogés are the karma-yogés, the jïäna-yogés, the añöäìga-yogés, and the bhakti-yogés. Factually they are the same, although named differently. The yogic process is like a ladder one ascends gradually toward the final goal of the Absolute Truth. Niñkäma-karma, or renunciation of the fruits of one's labor, is the first step on this ladder. When knowledge and austerity are added to it, it becomes jïäna-yoga, the second step in this ladder. And when meditation on the Supreme is added to jïäna-yoga, the third step is reached, namely añöäìga-yoga. Finally, when loving devotional service to the Supreme Lord is practiced along with añöäìga-yoga, it is transformed into bhakti-yoga. This entire successive process is yoga. For an exact and clear delineation of the subject of yoga, all four steps need to be explained separately. Those who desire the best for humanity take to the path of yoga. The process for progressing in yoga requires, first, determination and strict execution of discipline at each stage. When a person is firmly situated at one stage, he then has to relinquish attachment and adherence to the practices of that stage in order to elevate himself to the next higher stage. Those who cannot reach the top for some reason and get stuck at any one of the four stages acquire the designation of that particular stage. Thus there are karma-yogés, jïäna-yogés, añöäìga-yogés, and bhakta-yogés. Lord Kåñëa instructs Arjuna that one who renders loving devotional service to Him, the Supreme Lord, is the highest among all yogés, and that Arjuna should thus strive to become such a bhakti-yogé.

The successive, step-by-step spiritual path is not the same as step-by-step progress in the material world. In the mundane process the rules of progress are strict and cannot be transgressed. If one wants to acquire a doctorate at a university, he has to begin from the elementary school level and gradually work upwards. It is impossible to go directly to the university without prior schooling. In spiritual life, however, although there are strict regulations, by the Supreme Lord's grace one can bypass many intermediary stages and reach the top, or "doctorate" level. One can attain this divine grace by intimate and constant association with the Supreme Lord. And such intimate association with the Lord comes about through confidential exchanges with a pure devotee of the Supreme Lord. Everyone of us is intimately and eternally related to the Supreme Lord, but due to the bad influence of mäyä we have forgotten our relationship with Him.

The living entities are like sons of the Lord, and as such they are rightful heirs to the great wealth of their rich father. But because of the reactions to sins committed in previous lives, they are roaming about without a home, suffering acute poverty. That the living entities are suffering is quite clear to all. But they do not know who their wealthy father is or where they can go to reclaim their valuable inheritance. Without proper knowledge, they are trying in vain to escape from their poverty while aimlessly roaming about like poor beggars. They meet many who promise to help them, but in the end such helpers turn out to be beggars themselves. A few among these strangers seem rich and prosperous, but the directions they give do not lead to the father's house, and so the living entities' poverty knows no end. The wealthy strangers suggest many paths, such as karma, jïäna, or dhyäna, but the problem of poverty remains unsolved. The living entities can escape their poverty only by learning and practicing the science of devotional service to the Supreme Lord. Caitanya Mahäprabhu, the Supreme Personality of Godhead and the source of all incarnations, explained the science of devotional service to Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé at Prayäga (Allahabad). These instructions are the crest jewel of teachings for all humanity. In Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 19.151), the Lord says,

According to their karma, all living entities are wandering throughout the entire universe. Some of them are being elevated to the upper planetary systems, and some are going down to the lower planetary systems. Out of many millions of wandering living entities, one who is very fortunate gets an opportunity to associate with a bona fide spiritual master by the grace of Lord Kåñëa. By the mercy of both Lord Kåñëa and the spiritual master, such a person receives the seed of the creeper of devotional service.

By the mercy of Lord Kåñëa, this seed of devotion is available in the Bhagavad-gétä. Only one who is able to receive this devotional seed can understand the purport of the Bhagavad-gétä. Otherwise, simply repeatedly reading the Bhagavad-gétä and discussing its teachings will not produce any results.

In the Bhagavad-gétä, Lord Kåñëa Himself reveals the truth about Himself. When an ordinary mortal writes an autobiography, he receives many accolades, but when the Supreme Lord writes about Himself, we unfortunately do not fully believe in His words. Furthermore, we overlook the cardinal issues in His writings and quibble over lesser subjects, trying to magnify them by giving them concocted connotations and meanings. This practice is stretched to such absurdity that the original meaning is lost and the lop-sided conclusions attract only ridicule from readers. In the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa unequivocally declares that He is the Supreme Absolute Truth and that it is the duty of everyone to render Him loving devotional service. The Bhagavad-gétä was revealed for the sole purpose of explaining these two principal points. One who understands them is eligible to begin spiritual life as a neophyte devotee. Çraddhä, or faith, is the first prerequisite in spiritual life and is described as synonymous with neophyte devotion. Thus Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.62) says,

By rendering transcendental loving service to Kåñëa, one automatically performs all subsidiary activities. This confident, firm faith, favorable to the discharge of devotional service, is called çraddhä.

RTW 2: The Science of Devotion

Bhakti kathä
The Science of Devotion

RTW 2.1: Everything Is Achieved by Serving Lord Kåñëa.

Everything Is Achieved by Serving Lord Kåñëa

While instructing Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé on the science of devotional service, Lord Caitanya discussed in some detail the material world and the living entities. He pointed out that among the 8,400,000 species of life—900,000 species of aquatics, 2,000,000 kinds of plants, 1,100,000 varieties of insects, 1,000,000 species of birds, 3,000,000 kinds of beasts, and 400,000 species of humans—Homo sapiens are clearly in the minority. Furthermore, humans are subdivided into three categories, namely, the uncivilized, the half-civilized, and the civilized. Also,many who supposedly belong to the civilized group act without restraint and discipline, only for the purpose of enjoyment. In this way they create chaos for the rest. Their sole intention in life being to gratify their senses (their instruments of enjoyment), they always try to keep their senses in fit working condition. They even go to the extent of transplanting monkeys' organs into their bodies once they get too old to enjoy with the vigor of youth.

Such gross sense enjoyers do not understand that the mind is more subtle than the sense organs and superior to them. Superior to the mind is the intelligence, and behind the intelligence is the false ego, which is far superior to the intelligence and which covers the spirit soul. Philosophical inquiry into the existence of the soul will remain a subject beyond the reach of these gross materialists. The gross sense enjoyers are actually to be counted among the animals, because man has more serious matters to attend to than just titillating his senses. Hence he is considered the most advanced among all the living entities. And indeed we do find that some men comprehend the gravity of human life. They carefully reject chaotic living, emulate the exemplary lives of saintly persons, and direct their lives in such a way as to fulfill the purpose of human life.

Followers of various religions—such as the Christians, Hindus, Muslims, and Buddhists—all adhere to the rules of their faith according to the intensity of their belief and the circumstances in their respective countries. Lord Kåñëa speaks of these persons in Bhagavad-gétä (7.3):

manuñyäëäà sahasreñu
kaçcid yatati siddhaye
yatatäm api siddhänäà
kaçcin mäà vetti tattvataù

Out of many thousands among men, one may endeavor for perfection, and of those who have achieved perfection, hardly one knows Me in Truth.

Since time immemorial, living entities have been going through many lower species of life, gradually rising through the evolutionary process and, due to some good fortune, receiving a human birth. In the lower species of life the spirit souls are densely covered by the material modes, and thus carnal appetites dominate their lives. Among the human species, some denounce sensual pleasures and are honored by the world as a saints, yogés, philosophers, scholars, and so on. They experience mental perceptions far superior to gross sensual experiences, and may reach even subtler levels of fine intellect. But even more subtle than the intellect is the spirit soul. So true spirituality, or the real religion of the living entity, means to be situated in self.

Except for the religion of the self, all paths and religions are pseudo-spiritual exercises consisting only of eating, sleeping, mating, and defending oneself from danger. These are the primary activities of the animals. The lower species cannot elevate themselves by executing the religion of the self, or soul. But since human beings are inherently able to practice the religion of the self, some endeavor to reach perfection. Only as a human being can one make such inquiries as "Who am I?" and "Why do the threefold miseries always give me trouble?"

Human life alone affords one the chance to attain unending happiness. In this life one should think, "Although I do not want suffering, it nevertheless comes; although I do not desire death, it forcibly snatches away my life; although I detest old age, when my youth is finished I will surely begin to age; and although I try to be free from disease and disaster, they never leave me alone." Although he sees all this suffering, a fool works hard to make his life comfortable, whereas an intelligent person calmly considers his situation and thinks of the best means to end his distress once and for all. When such thoughts become frequent and sincere, his search leads him to inquire into the Absolute Truth. Such a person takes up the path of self-realization. He may have many duties, but because of his previous pious activities such a wise person will execute these duties and at the same time confront the realities of birth, death, old age, and disease.

The lower stratum of those who strive for perfection are the karmés, or fruitive workers, wholook to gratify their senses. Above them are the jïänés, or seekers of knowledge, who restrain the urges of their senses and become situated on the subtle, mental plane. Superior to them are the yogés who seek mystic perfection. Lord Caitanya has described all these persons as açänta, restless. Among them, those who are free of all material designations and are rid of the false ego, and who are thus liberated beings situated in the self—they alone can understand Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Person, in truth. When they become fully conversant with the science of Kåñëa consciousness, such saintly souls can act as spiritual masters for all humanity, regardless of any external designation. Lord Caitanya confirms this in the Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 8.128):

kibä vipra, kibä nyäsé, çüdra kene naya
yei kåñëa-tattva-vettä, sei 'guru' haya

Whether one is a brähmaëa, a sannyäsé, or a çüdra—regardless of what he is—he can become a spiritual master if he knows the science of Kåñëa.

Therefore we can conclude that neither the karmés nor the jïänés can fathom the depths of the science of devotional service to Kåñëa. Especially the foolish karmés are disqualified, for they generally consider Lord Kåñëa an ordinary mortal, and this disregard for the Lord leads them to misconstrue the meaning of His words in the Bhagavad-gétä.

Humanity, now in the grips of the evil influence of the Age of Kali, has become callous to any spiritual culture. Thus people pass their time in the animalistic activities of eating, sleeping, mating, and defending. What to speak of cultivating spiritual knowledge about the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, they cannot even spare the time for religious rituals or the pursuit of transcendental knowledge. If one strictly follows the scriptural directions for cultivating karma and jïäna, one purifies his consciousness enough to understand the science of Kåñëa to a certain degree. The final conclusion of jïäna is that once one attains the state of oneness with the Absolute, then the doors of an even higher state, that of devotional service to Lord Kåñëa, open up. Since this state of oneness is practically impossible for the people of Kali-yuga to attain, in the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa Himself has taught the science of devotional service to Himself. Then, knowing that the unfortunate human beings of this age would misunderstand evenHis own words, Lord Kåñëa again appeared—this time in the form of Caitanya Mahäprabhu, a pure devotee of the Lord—to teach the world the essence of the Bhagavad-gétä through His personal example.

Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä that He is the source of everything, but envious and cunning people try to refute this fact. Thus He appeared as Lord Caitanya and taught that Lord Kåñëa is the source of everything. There is no difference between the instructions of Lord Kåñëa and those of Lord Caitanya. The object of worship is the same. Still, the unfortunate people of this age refuse to accept these teachings. Trying to give them Kåñëa consciousness is, as the well-known expression goes, like "casting pearls before a herd of swine." The human beings afflicted by Kali-yuga are like a herd of swine. The Lord has shown them boundless mercy by widely teaching the science of devotional service to Kåñëa, which is rarely attained even by Lord Brahmä. Yet because it has been so easy for them to come by this precious and rare commodity, they have abused the mercy shown them. This is another manifestation of their misfortune. By teaching them the science of self-realization, Lord Kåñëa has twice personally tried to save the people of this age from groveling in carnal pleasures, and both times they have converted those divine instructions into a means and an excuse for pursuing sense gratification.

When presented with a colorful glass doll and a diamond, a child will naturally be attracted to the doll and not the priceless jewel. Similarly, the people of Kali-yuga, endowed as they are with limited intelligence, have rejected the priceless diamond of devotional service to Kåñëa and instead chosen the cheap doll of fruitive activity and dry speculation. Just as the child cannot comprehend that the invaluable diamond can purchase many thousands of cheap glass dolls, so the less intelligent people of Kali-yuga cannot understand that kåñëe bhakti kaile sarva-karma-kåta haya: "By rendering transcendental devotional service to Lord Kåñëa, one automatically performs all subsidiary activities."

Those who know the science of Kåñëa consciousness automatically know of subsidiary subjects like fruitive activity, speculative knowledge, yoga, charity, penance, austerity, and chanting mantras. Lord Kåñëa confirms this in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam:

By executing devotional service to Me, My devotees easily acquire everything that can be attained by performing penances, fruitive activity, philosophical speculation, renunciation, yoga, charity, religiosity, and other pious acts.

RTW 2.2: Lord Kåñëa Is the Supreme Absolute Truth

Lord Kåñëa Is the Supreme Absolute Truth

The famous atheist Kapila propagated the Säìkhya philosophy. He concluded that the material world consists of twenty-four material elements, namely, earth, water, fire, air, and ether; form, taste, smell, sound, and touch; eyes, tongue, nose, ears, and skin; mouth, hands, legs, anus, and genitals; mind, intelligence, and false ego; and the unmanifested state of the three modes of nature (pradhäna). When Kapila was unable to perceive the unmanifested soul after analyzing the twenty-four elements, he concluded that God does not exist. Thus the devotee community regards Kapila as an atheist.

Lord Kapila, the son of Devahüti, is a different person altogether from the agnostic Kapila. Lord Kapila is accepted as an empowered incarnation of the Supreme Godhead. In the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa refutes the atheist Kapila's Säìkhya philosophy and its contention that the unmanifested soul is nonexistent. In the Gétä (7.4) Lord Kåñëa alsoestablishes that the material ingredients are all under His control and supervision:

bhümir äpo 'nalo väyuù
khaà mano buddhir eva ca
ahaìkära itéyaà me
bhinnä prakåtir añöadhä

Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence, and false ego—all together these eight comprise My separated material energies.

Who is Lord Kåñëa, and what is His original form? Unless one knows about His opulence, potencies, fame, beauty, knowledge, and renunciation, one can never enter into the realm of pure devotional service. As stated in the Caitanya-caritämåta (Ädi 2.117),

siddhänta baliyä citte nä kara alasa
ihä ha-ite kåñëe läge sudåòha mänasa

A sincere student should not neglect the discussion of such philosophical conclusions, considering them controversial, for such discussions strengthen the mind. Thus one's mind becomes attached to Çré Kåñëa.

One who is situated in knowledge of Kåñëa and acts accordingly is executing devotional service. In pursuing the process initiated by Kapila man failed to fathom the same for hundreds and thousands of years. The Supreme Lord Kåñëa has, in a few words, lifted the shroud of mystery and revealed the truth:

Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and false ego-altogether these eight comprise My separated material energies. Besides this inferior nature, O mighty-armed Arjuna, there is a superior energy of Mine, which are all living entities who are struggling with material nature and are sustaining the universe. Of all that is material and all that is spiritual in this world, know for certain that I am both its origin and dissolution. [Bg. 7.4-6]

Those who cannot understand this truth remain far from the science of devotional service, while those who do understand it are strengthened in their devotional life. Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the supreme male. So, when the supreme male is present, automatically material nature, his female counterpart, is there to serve Him. Those who falsely pose as the Supreme Person claim to have the material nature at their disposal and conclude that nature is no longer at Lord Kåñëa's beck and call. Naturally this is absurd, and only fools will make such a claim.

Similarly, those philosophical schools which propound that the Supreme Person is subservient to prakåti, or nature, are also far from the truth. When one thinks about nature and nothing further, the thought is left incomplete. One has to inquire, "Whose nature is it?" Nature has to belong to someone; she cannot exist on her own. Thus whatmust be established is the identity of the Supreme Person, or puruña—the male factor. Prakåti is the same as çakti, or energy. Through the energy, an intelligent person will seek out the possessor of the energy. The Upaniñads and other Vedic scriptures clearly state that Brahman is the Absolute Truth and the possessor and source of multifarious energies. In the Bhagavad-gétä (14.27) this Brahman is said to be the bodily effulgence of Kåñëa (brahmaëo hi pratiñöhäham). This is confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.40):

yasya prabhä prabhavato jagad-aëòa-koöi-
koöiñv açeña-vasudhädi-vibhüti-bhinnam
tad brahma niñkalam anantam açeña-bhütaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, whose effulgence is the source of the nondifferentiated Brahman mentioned in the Upaniñads, being differentiated from the infinity of glories of the mundane universe appears as the indivisible, infinite, limitless, truth.

Brahman exists as the all-pervading energy in this phenomenal world. Therefore the Vedas have defined Brahman as formless, impersonal, pure, and so on. But the source of Brahman is an eternal personality who has no material form but who has atranscendental form full of spiritual potencies and all divine qualities. He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the embodiment of eternity, knowledge, and bliss. He possesses all six transcendental opulences to an infinite degree, He performs superexcellent divine pastimes, and He alone is to be searched out and known in all the scriptures. The materialistic, fruitive workers make the mistake of thinking that this supreme transcendental personality is mundane, and thus they become degraded into pseudodevotees. And the dry speculators, having been repulsed by the material phenomena in their search for knowledge of the Absolute, think that the transcendental form of the Supreme Personality of Godhead is also repulsive, thus clearly proving that their ascending process of acquiring knowledge is insufficient and inferior. Both these groups are in a pathetic spiritual state. Therefore, to shower His causeless mercy upon them, the Supreme Lord has revealed the truth about Himself and His transcendental potencies in the Bhagavad-gétä.

The above-mentioned eight ingredients make up the material nature, or the Supreme Lord's external potency. These material ingredients—earth, water, fire, air, and so on—are devoid of any free will, and so they are known as the Lord's inferior energy. By contrast, the potency that activates the inferior energy is known as the Lord's superior energy, or spiritual potency. On principle the energy cannot be the enjoyer; nor can one energy enjoy another energy. Energy is the enjoyed, and the energetic is the enjoyer.

The living entities are a product of the Lord's superior, spiritual energy, and so they are superior to earth, water, fire, and so on, which are always devoid of volition. But that does not mean the living entities are on the same platform as the Supreme Lord, who is the absolute controlling principle. It is easy to discern the superiority of spirit over inert matter. The jéva principle is setting into motion and sustaining everything in this material world. And if the jévas did not try to lord it over the material nature, then there would be no variegatedness in this phenomenal world. The material elements would have remained unchanged if the jévas had not been inclined to control and enjoy them. Only through the material energies' connection with the conscious living entity can such substances as earth, wood, stone, and iron be orchestrated so as to give rise to huge, opulent buildings, factories, and cities. Matter cannot organize itself.

From the foregoing one can understand that this massive cosmic creation, with its innumerable planetary systems and heavenly bodies, has come about only through the interference of some superior and powerful consciousness. It is beyond doubt that matter is inert, incapable of voluntary action, and that consciousness has activated the twenty-four material ingredients so as to exhibit variegatedness in material nature. All this goes to prove the inherent insufficiency and imperfections in material nature. Thus transcendental happiness is possible only in spiritual variegatedness. In the Bhagavad-gétä (7.5) Lord Kåñëa confirms that the jévas belong to Hissuperior energy:

apareyam itas tv anyäà
prakåtià viddhi me paräà
jéva-bhütaà mahä-bäho
yayedaà dhäryate jagat

Besides this inferior nature, O mighty-armed Arjuna, there is a superior energy of Mine, which are all living entities who are struggling with material nature and are sustaining the universe.

Because the spirit soul (jéva) is born of the Lord's superior, spiritual energy, it has little in common with the material energy, just as the aquatics have no affinity for the land and the land beasts are out of place in the water. The apparent close connection between the material energy and the spiritual energy is in fact illusory. The jévas, being a product of the spiritual energy, try to exploit the material energy, but ultimately such attempts fail, because it is impossible for one energy to always exploit and lord it over another energy. The jévas can, however,eternally serve the Supreme Energetic, Lord Kåñëa. When the jéva exploits the material energy in his endeavor to serve the Lord, that activity is transcendental—the performance of sacrifice. Any other kind of activity amounts to nothing but materialistic, fruitive work.

In the Viñëu Puräëa (6.7.61) one reads about the three kinds of energy:

viñëu-çaktiù parä proktä
kñetra jïäkhyä tathä parä
avidyä-karma-saàjïänyä
tåtéyä çaktir iñyate

The potency of Lord Viñëu is summarized in three categories—namely, the spiritual potency, the living entities, and ignorance. The spiritual potency is full of knowledge; the living entities, although belonging to the spiritual potency, are subject to bewilderment; and the third energy, which is full of ignorance, is always visible in fruitive activities.

Thus all phenomena in this material world are simply interactions of the Supreme Lord's superior, spiritual energy with His inferior, material energy. The material energy is known as the kñetra, or field of activity, and the spiritual energy is known as the kñetra-jïa, or the knower of the field of activity. All the different species of living entities, with their varied characteristics, are produced by the interaction of the kñetra and the kñetra-jïa. The energetic principle, the controller of both these energies, is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa. He must be recognized as the ultimate cause of the creation, maintenance, and annihilation of this cosmic manifestation. As He says in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.6-7),

etad yonéni bhütäni
sarväëéty upadhäraya
ahaà kåtsnasya jagataù
prabhavaù pralayas tathä

mattaù parataraà nänyat
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

Of all that is material and all that is spiritual in this world, know for certain that I am both its origin and dissolution. O conqueror of wealth [Arjuna], there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread.

The various quotations we hear from the Vedas concerning Brahman—ekam evädvitéyaà brahma: "Brahman is one without a second"; neha nänästi kiïcana: "Besides this, nothing exists"; sarvaà khalv idaà brahma: "Everything and everywhere is Brahman"; ahaà brahmäsmi: "I am by nature Brahman," and so on—find their conclusion in the verses from the Bhagavad-gétä quoted above. The Supreme Lord, endowed with the six transcendental opulences to the absolute degree, is the highest governing principle. Thus no other personality is equal to or greater than He. Lord Kåñëa confirms this point by saying "There is no truth superior to Me," and then explaining how He is present everywhere and intimately connected with everything through His all-pervasive energies.

The material nature is the result of the transformation of the Lord's energies. Both the energies and the energetic are inconceivable, and they are simultaneously one and different. Hence the phrase sarvaà khalv idaà brahma, ("Everything is Brahman") in fact declares that everything consists of transformations of the Supreme Lord's material and spiritual energies. The transformation of His energies neither increases nor decreases the Supreme Absolute Truth; hence Brahman is described as changeless. And the inferior energy, being only the reflection of Brahman, is niräkära, impersonal.

Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu propagated the philosophy of the simultaneous oneness and difference of the Lord and His energies. The highest esoteric truth is that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Absolute Truth and that both the living entities and the material world are His subordinate energies. Those who fail to understand this principle are materialists, while those who do understand it and are trying to reestablish their relationship with Lord Kåñëa are liberated souls, devotees of the Lord. Lord Kåñëa explains this in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.13-14):

tribhir guëa-mayair bhävair
ebhiù sarvam idaà jagat
mohitaà näbhijänäti
mäm ebhyaù param avyayam

daivé hy eñä guëa-mayé
mama mäyä duratyayä
mäm eva ye prapadyante
mäyäm etäà taranti te

Deluded by the three modes [goodness, passion and ignorance], the whole world does not know Me who am above the modes and inexhaustible. This divine energy of Mine, consisting of the three modes of material nature, is difficult to overcome. But those who have surrendered unto Me can easily cross beyond it.

The dualities of like and dislike, good and bad, are all due to the three modes of material nature—goodness, passion, and ignorance. These modes hold all conditioned living entities under their sway. Therefore it is difficult for conditioned souls to understand that the Supreme Lord, being absolutely spiritual, is above the three modes and thus param avyayam, absolutely inexhaustible. The reason the Lord uses these words param avyayam is that although He permeates everything by means of His transcendental energies, He remains eternally unchanged and the complete whole. One should avoid making the mistake of thinking that because Brahman, the Supreme Absolute Truth, pervades the entire cosmic manifestation, therefore He cannot possess a definitive form or personality. The heat radiating from a fire spreads in all directions, yet the fire remains unchanged. Similarly, the sun has been emanating light and heat since time immemorial, yet it has not lost any of its potency. And the sun possesses but a minuscule fraction of the Supreme Lord's inexhaustible potency. So what question is there of the Lord's potency being either transformed or decreased? The Lord's energies, like a fire's heat and light, spread everywhere, yet His energies can never diminish at any time. Thus in the Bhagavad-gétä He describes Himself as param avyayam, inexhaustible, the supreme energetic principle. The Vedas describe Him in the following way:

pürëasya pürëam ädäya
pürëam evävaçiñyate

Whatever is produced of the complete whole is also complete in itself. Because He is the complete whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance. (Éçopaniñad, Invocation)

Like the Supreme Lord Himself, the process for freeing oneself from the mesmerizing grip of the material energy and coming closer to the Lord is also one without a second. As the only way to see the sun is by the help of sunlight, so the only way to see the Supreme Personality, Lord Kåñëa, is by the illumination of sunlike Kåñëa Himself. Only by surrendering to His lotus feet and rendering Him loving devotional service can one approach Him. Neither fruitive activity through physical strain nor speculative knowledge through mental gymnastics can help one attain the highest perfection of God consciousness. Only through bhakti, or devotion, canthe Supreme Lord be achieved. Speculative knowledge and mystic yoga can at best accord one a partial realization of the Absolute Truth—namely, realization of Brahman and Paramätmä (the Supersoul), respectively. It is through the singular means of bhakti that one can perceive face to face the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa, the embodiment of eternity, knowledge, and bliss. When the rising sun chases away the blackness of night, everything becomes clearly visible. Similarly, when the sun of Kåñëa rises above the horizon of one's consciousness, the stygian gloom of mäyä, the illusory energy, is driven away, and the original form of every object comes into distinct focus. Thus full knowledge and realization of the Absolute Truth come exclusively through devotion to the Supreme Lord.

However, the path to this perfect realization is fraught with hindrances caused by mäyä, the insurmountable material energy. In this regard one may ask, "If by serving Lord Kåñëa one can automatically discharge all subsidiary duties, then why doesn't everyone in the world surrender to Lord Kåñëa and worship Him as the supreme absolute being? Almost everyone in the world more or less agrees that there is only one God, not two or more. Yet when that one and only Supreme Personality, Lord Kåñëa, comes personally to declare this truth, why do people still refuse to surrender to Him? Perhaps it is understandable that those who are illiterate and ignorant cannot accept Lord Kåñëa's supremacy and therefore do not surrender to Him. But there are many erudite scholars, philosophers, and leaders of society who extensively discuss the scriptures yet still do not take shelter of Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet. Why?" The Lord Himself answers this question in His Bhagavad-gétä (7.15):

na mäà duñkåtino müòhäù
prapadyante narädhamäù
mäyayäpahåta-jïänä
äsuraà bhävam äçritäù

Those miscreants who are grossly foolish, lowest among mankind, whose knowledge is stolen by illusion, and who partake of the atheistic nature of demons, do not surrender unto Me.

People with demoniac mentalities never surrender to the Supreme Lord. There have always existed two kinds of men: the good, pious men and the impious reprobates. These two types of people are always present in every country and at every period in history. Pious men obey God's laws and are gradually elevated to perfection. The impious, on the other hand, capriciously flaunt God's laws and try to be independent. The racial strife, civil wars, violent revolutions, and world wars so common in the modern age are all caused by the whimsical and selfish nature of impious men.

Pious people can live in any country and adhere to the instructions of their scripture, or they can associate with other pious men from another country and exchange knowledge and realizations. As a result, these seekers of the Absolute Truth can certainly perceive that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. On the other hand, sinful persons have one interest: to satisfy their egoistic cravings. They may make a show of being vanguards of religion, but behind this facade they continue their reprehensible activities. They vilify the sanctity of the religion of their birth and go against their own country's interest. Their self-centered lives preclude their following even the common etiquette of human behavior, what to speak of dedicating their lives to Lord Kåñëa's devotional service. Such demoniac persons are more dangerous than poisonous snakes.

Generally, the gross fools and the ignorant fruitive workers do not surrender to the Supreme Lord. Such people never enquire into the Absolute Truth. They never ask such questions as "Who is God?" "What is the world?" "Who am I?" "Why am I working like an ass my whole life?" or "What is the result of my endeavors?" The ass slaves his whole life carrying the washerman's burden, just for a handful of grass. Similarly, the karmés(fruitive workers) toil tirelessly simply to secure a supply of food and other necessities. The ass is a symbol of foolishness, for he works hard only to fill his belly and copulate with a she-ass. So also do the asinine karmés toil tirelessly out of affection and attachment, struggling to maintain their homes and, beyond that, the land of theirbirth, which they consider worshipable. In the home the karmé's sole source of enjoyment is his wife, who cooks for him and provides pleasure for his misery-ridden senses. The shortsighted karmés do not want to know of any broader issues concerning themselves or their world; they are simply tethered to their home and bodily cares. And those leaders who foster the people's sensual lives are bigger fools and rascals than the ordinary karmés. Therefore they never come in contact with the Bhagavad-gétä or Lord Kåñëa. The word surrender means nothing to them.

People who do not surrender to the Supreme Lord are called narädhama, "the lowest of men." Such men fritter away their human lives, behaving like animals. In other words, when a person does not use this rare human birth to achieve its actual purpose but wastes it in degraded activities, he is called a narädhama. When a beggar suddenly finds a treasure yet continues to live like a beggar, he is surely a miser and a narädhama. Similarly, when someone receives the priceless gift of a human birth yet squanders it by living like an animal—simply eating, sleeping, mating, and defending—then such a person is a narädhama. These fools do not realize that after many millions of births in lower species, the soul finally receives the rare human birth. And it is in this birth that the soul must sincerely endeavor to elevate himself to the transcendental platform, attain the Absolute Truth, and return to his original home in the spiritual world. If in this human life the soul makes no attempt to alleviate his situation, even after learning how horribly he has suffered in millions of previous lifetimes, then such a person is certainly a miserable miser and narädhama. But if one tries to utilize his rare human birth for self-realization by becoming elevated to the brahminical class, then his life is successful. Brähmaëa does not mean brähmaëa by birth. A brähmaëa is one who surrenders to Lord Kåñëa, the Lord of the brähmaëas. A narädhama cannot do so. Therefore another meaning of narädhama is "one who rejects devotional service."

Another class of men who do not surrender to Lord Kåñëa are the demons, those who are staunchly inimical to Him. Famous and powerful demon kings like Rävaëa, Hiraëyakaçipu, Jaräsandha, and Kaàsaacquired many mystic powers through learning and severe austerities. But because they always challenged the various incarnations of the Supreme Lord, such as Lord Räma, Lord Nåsiàha-deva, Lord Viñëu, and Lord Kåñëa, they are known as demons. Often the demons do not lack education or intelligence, but because of their fiendish mentality toward the Supreme Lord, their learning and brain capacity come to naught. Their abilities, being fully in the grip of material nature, are ultimately taken from them. The reason for the demons' failure has been stated earlier: If one does not surrender to Lord Kåñëa, it is impossible to surmount material nature.

Torturing the devotees of Kåñëa is the preoccupation of the demons, who think that Lord Räma and Lord Kåñëa cannot punish them because They are ordinary mortals. Thus the demons conclude that they themselves are as learned and intelligent as Lord Räma and Lord Kåñëa. The atheistic students of Navadvépa thought Lord Caitanya was an ordinary human being, and thus to win their respect the Lord accepted the renounced and austere sannyäsa order of life. In this way the Lord showed Himself to be the personification of divine magnanimity. The demons invariably confuse matters: they worship humans as gods and call God a human being. In the Bhagavad-gétä (9.11) the Lord fittingly describes such grossly foolish persons: avajänanti mäà müòhä mänuñéà tanum äçritam. "Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form." The demons' learning, intelligence, and titles are like the gems that glitter on a poisonous snake's hood. The presence of a priceless gem on a snake's hood does not decrease his venom. Similarly, a demon's erudition, intelligence, and titles do not make him less of a demon, and thus he is as horrendous as a venomous snake.

Decorating a dead body and taking it to the funeral pyre with pomp is certainly nothing but a flagrant display for entertainment only. The public is similarly cheated when accolades and scholarly degrees are piled on a demon who is an arrant competitor of the Supreme Lord. The atheistic, demoniac education imparted to the young in modern universities is simply producing a bunch of demons with titles. Proof of this is the recent incident in which Principal Garg of Aligarh University was murdered by some students. The whole state of Uttar Pradesh is shocked and has opened a probe into this vicious act. The governor has called for a conference of the leaders and teachers, but in the past all such conferences have met with the same frustrating fate: no solution. We think the present conference will also fail. The only means to eradicate the demoniac mentality in society is to teach the science of Kåñëa consciousness. Having taken note of all the disaster and corruption wreaked by the demons, it is the moral responsibility of every citizen in the world to learn and teach the science of Kåñëa consciousness.

RTW 2.3: Dr. Ane's comment on the system of education.

Dr. Ane's comment on the system of education

We were pleased to hear Dr. Ane's address at the Calcutta University convocation on January 12, 1957. Dr. Ane is presently the honorable governor of the state of Bihar. An excerpt from his speech follows:

Our youth are being brought up in a tradition of veiled contempt for religion and everything religious. Spiritualists and religious devotees are the laughing-stock of the educated youth, and as the general masses are religious-minded and have great respect and reverence for such devotees and spiritualists, they feel generally disgusted with the attitude of the educated class and have no regard for them. The educated class has also no affection for the masses, whose way of life is mostly molded by religious ideas. The result is that the educated classes have not been able to produce a sufficient number of servants to work with a real missionary spirit for the amelioration of the suffering of the masses.

Dr. Ane goes on to say that the existing academic courses in schools and colleges exclude classes on religion.

We have included this portion of Dr. Ane's speech, taken from a local newspaper, because we want to impress upon the reader the urgent need for introducing religious studies into the universities. Because in the past strong objections were raised against including religious classes in the schools, they have been excluded, and now severe reactions are being seen in today's youth. I think that excluding spiritual studies from education thwarts all chances for the human mind to awaken and blossom. Because of a lack of spiritual education, today's youth are undisciplined. Students who do not pray or meditate in the early morning, and again in the evening, gradually become agnostics, and their minds float about aimlessly without purpose. They reject religious ideas and ethics and instead embrace logic and argument as supreme. Often they fall into the vicious grip of some unscrupulous politician. The exclusion of religious courses from the universities is the main reason one does not see nowadays a pure and sublime relationship between student and teacher. Many educators feel the need for religious education today.

A few months ago (on January 18, 1957) we had the opportunity of meeting Dr. Ane at the Government House in Patna, and we had some discussions. Being a pious man, he could appreciate our spiritual topics and offered us full support for our missionary activities which are aimed at eradicating the demoniac mentality on a wide scale. His recent speech gives us hope of improvement.

Possessed of perverted intelligence, the demons, rascals, and fools can never surrender to Lord Kåñëa. Similarly, Lord Kåñëa never shows them His mercy. The most munificent incarnation of Godhead, Lord Caitanya, repudiated the sinner Gopäla Cäpala because he was envious of the Lord's devotee. In this regard, the Supreme Lord states His opinion in the Bhagavad-gétä (4.11): ye yathä mäà prapadyante täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham. "All of them—as they surrender unto Me—I reward accordingly." Thus the Lord arranges for the demons to slide lower and lower into degraded species of life and suffer hell for many millions of births. In Chapter 16 (19-20) the Lord says:

tän aham dviñataù krürän
saàsäreñu narädhamän
kñipämy ajasram açubhän
äsuréñv eva yoniñu

äsuréà yonim äpannä
müòhä janmani janmani
mäm apräpyaiva kaunteya
tato yänty adhamäà gatim

Those who are envious and mischievous, who are the lowest among men, are cast by Me into the ocean of material existence, into various demoniac species of life. Attaining repeated birth amongst the species of demoniac life, such persons can never approach Me. Gradually they sink down to the most abominable type of existence.

Yet the Supreme Lord's devotees, being more merciful than the Lord Himself, are compassionate toward even the lowest demons like us.

The Lord's devotees can save even those whom the Lord Himself rejects. This is their unique character. Therefore the devotees of the Lord arrange various means to save the fallen, reprobate souls from perdition. In fact, they live among these spiritual derelicts to encourage them toward spiritual perfection, using any means at hand—even tricks. His Divine Grace Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura Prabhupäda wanted to open a students' hostel in London, the logic being that it was necessary to give sugar-coated pills, in the form of a little sense gratification, to those debauched students in order to attract them to join the path of God-realization.

If they so desire, powerful spiritual masters, or pure devotees of the Lord, can instantly deliver the entire universe and take everyone to the shelter of the Supreme Lord's lotus feet. Çréla Väsudeva Datta declared to Lord Caitanya that he was prepared to take on all the sinful reactions of every living entity in the universe and suffer eternally in hell if the Lord was willing to liberate all the living entities at one time. The pure devotees are so magnanimous that they are always concerned about the spiritual well-being of every soul. The only way to receive the Supreme Lord's mercy is to bathe oneself in the dust of the lotus feet of such unalloyed devotees.

The devotees of the Lord understand that it is mäyä's influence that has spoiled the people and made them demoniac. Thus the inherently noble disposition of the devotees leads them to think only of the demons' benefit, without a tinge of envy. The devotees are therefore known as patita-pävana, "the saviors of the fallen." In fact, the devotees are more compassionate than the Supreme Lord Himself. Of course, it is the Supreme Lord's grace alone that makes them more compassionate than the Lord. And by the mercy of such devotees, the lowest sinful men and women can attain the lotus feet of the Lord.

On the other hand, offending such pure devotees finishes all possibility of salvation. If one offends the Supreme Lord, only His pure devotees can save the offender, but if one offends the pure devotee, then even the Supreme Lord will not save the offender from doom. For this reason alone, pure devotees never feel offended. When Jesus Christ was being crucified, he did not blame anyone for it. Haridäsa Öhäkura was severely lashed in twenty-two marketplaces by the Muslim Kazi's sentries. Still he prayed to the Lord not to punish his tormentors. Lord Nityänanda was wounded by the two rascals Jagäi and Mädhäi, yet the Lord stood His ground, bleeding profusely. He delivered the two notorious brothers and thus brilliantly exemplified the title patita-pävana. Such is the profound compassion of the pure devotees.

Therefore the reprobates' only means of attaining any piety is through the association of devotees. We are looking forward to that time when the stalwart disciples of that illustrious crest jewel of all Vaiñëavas, His Divine Grace Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura Prabhupäda, having received the blessings of their spiritual master, will come together again for the benediction of the whole world and, without wasting any more time, preach the message of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé and Çréla Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé. Çréla Gaurakiçora däsa Bäbäjé always tried to dissuade his disciple, Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura, from going to Calcutta, which he considered a bastion of Kali-yuga. Yet though some might think Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura disobeyed his guru's order, he preached not only in Calcutta but in other capitals of Kali-yuga, such as London, Berlin, Bombay, Madras, and Delhi. He vehemently opposed the idea of constructing a temple in some quiet spot and leading a passive and uneventful life in the monastery. He represented perfectly the ideal of utilizing 100 percent of one's energy in God's service for the spiritual upliftment of humanity. A certain Gujarati friend offered to build him a temple in Ville Parle, a quiet and remote section of Bombay. He immediately refused. We had the greatest good fortune of seeing him act and preach in this way. And now it is our ill fate that after the passing away of Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura, the exemplar of patita-pävana, we have returned to our lowly, fallen ways. Is there a glimmer of hope for our deliverance?

From the ocean of loving compassion, which had been completely dammed up, Lord Nityänanda cut a canal of love of Godhead and flooded the entire world. And then some persons called caste Gosvämés, claiming to be the Lord's descendants, again dammed up that ocean of mercy with their malpractices of fruitive activities and rituals. Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura once more cut open the canal of love of Godhead and brought in the flood waters. And now are we, of all persons, trying once more to dam it up like the caste Gosvämés? By the influence of the good association of the Lord's devotees, even a fool and rascal like me, possessed of a destructive, demoniac mentality, can accumulate enough piety to become inspired to serve the Supreme Lord.

By nature children are restless and playful, so in the kindergarten they are given toys and games to interest them in learning. Similarly, a neophyte is trained to perform activities in the mood of sacrifice, and he is encouraged to worship the Deities according to the scriptural injunctions. The expert Vaiñëava preceptor then gradually draws him toward the platform of pure devotion by narrating the spiritually potent topics of Kåñëa consciousness and giving him the remnants of food offered to the Supreme Lord. These two aspects of devotional life act like medicine on the neophyte, who, like the rest of the world, is affected by the material disease. Devotional service to Lord Kåñëa is the living entity's eternal birthright; it is not a new subject fabricated by the human mind. A base fool thinks that devotion to Lord Kåñëa is merely a mundane psychological state of mind. But in truth devotional service is our eternal spiritual substance—"the essential spiritual reality" (västava-vastu), according to the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.1.2). Devotion to Lord Kåñëa can be invoked naturally in the purified hearts of devotees. When a disease is cured, the patient feels hungry; similarly, when a neophyte accrues sufficient piety by associating with devotees, he feels attraction for devotional service within hisheart.

Four kinds of pious men establish a relationship with the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. As the Lord states in the Bhagavad-gétä (7:16)

catur-vidhä bhajante mäà
janäù sukåtino 'rjuna
ärto jijïäsur arthärthé
jïäné ca bharatarñabha

O best among the Bhäratas [Arjuna], four kinds of pious men render devotional service unto Me—the distressed, the desirer of wealth, the inquisitive, and he who is searching for knowledge of the Absolute.

One obtains another kind of piety by strictly executing his duties under the system of varëäçrama-dharma, a social system containing four spiritual orders and four social orders. Learned sages have long propagated this system. As the Viñëu Puräëa (3.8.9) states,

varëäçramäcäravatä
puruñeëa paraù pumän
viñëur ärädhyate panthä
nänyat tat-toña-käraëam

The Supreme Personality of Godhead, Lord Viñëu, is worshiped by the proper execution of prescribed duties in the system of varëa and äçrama. There is no other way to satisfy the Supreme Personality of Godhead. One must be situated in the institution of the four varëas and äçramas.

The brähmaëas (the intellectual, priestly class), the kñatriyas (kings and administrators), the vaiçyas (the mercantile community), and the çüdras (menial workers) are the four social orders, or varëas. If they live according to the scriptural injunctions pertaining to their particular varëa, then they can accrue piety. Similarly, if the members of the four äçramas—namely, the brahmacärés (celibate students), gåhasthas (householders), vänaprasthas (pilgrims), and sannyäsés (renunciants)—also act in conformity with the scriptural edicts, they too acquire immense piety. But when the ill influence of Kali-yuga corrupts this varëäçrama system, human society is beset by all sorts of degradations. As a result, the living entities are punished by a variety of natural calamities caused by the illusory potency of the Lord. When the citizens abide by the rules of the king, the kingdom runs smoothly and everyone is prosperous and content. But when the demoniac population of thieves, rogues, and criminals steadily increases, the kingdom is filled with chaos and terror.

RTW 2.4: In Search of the Supreme Lord.

In Search of the Supreme Lord

Varëäçrama religion cannot be practised in an atmosphere of such chaos and violence. The system now being called varëäçrama is actually ungodly, demoniac religion in disguise. To wear the holy thread and go through the purificatory process within this demoniac system does not result in piety. Discarding all purificatory processes and religious rites, the men of Kali-yuga vie with each other to become the biggest and the strongest. A person becomes a "brähmaëa" just by slipping a holy thread over his head—indeed, such has been predicted in the scriptures—but this does not earn him any piety. Lord Caitanya rejected this kind of cheating varëäçrama system. Foreseeing the degraded condition of Kali-yuga, Lord Kåñëa hardly discusses varëäçrama religion in the Bhagavad-gétä and instead stresses the performance of work as sacrifice. Hence it is clearly understood that by the performance of sacrifice for Lord Viñëu, the Supreme Person, He becomes satisfied and all ill effects are eradicated.

Persons afflicted by disease or other miseries are known as ärta, "the distressed." Commonly, a sick person depends on a doctor and medicine to cure his disease. But far-sighted scholars say that suffering of any kind is a result of sinful activities performed in the past. Ordinary people do not understand that sinful reactions result from ignorance. This ignorance exists in manifest (prärabdha), unmanifest (aprärabdha) and latent (kuöashta) form.

There is no material means of counteracting these sinful reactions. Administering a pain-killer provides temporary relief but cannot remove the root cause of a disease. Similarly, no materialistic effort aimed at counteracting sinful reactions can provide ultimate relief. One obtains maximum only by surrendering to the Supreme Lord. The Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu [The Nectar of Devotion] supplies us with numerous proofs of how devotional service to the Lord destroys sinful reactions, and ignorance, the root of all sin. Hence we see that pious men depend solely on the Supreme Lord in moments of distress.

It is not the prime duty of human beings to try torelieve their present sufferings. The search in life is for that medicine—that panacea—which will cure the material disease altogether. This disease manifests itself in countless ways, such as birth, old age, disease, and death. The pious person seeks the association of saintly persons and follows the scriptures, and in this way he endeavors for his greatest good. The beginning of devotional service is the development of faith in the scriptures and the words of the saints. This faith destroys all unwanted desires in the heart and increases one's surrender to the Supreme Lord's will.

Innocent enquirers are known as jijïäsu, "those who are inquisitive." These innocent enquirers are society's hope for the future. Most intelligent and innocent young children are inquisitive: they question their parents about many things and remember the answers. When these bright young boys and girls receive proper guidance from parents and teachers who can lucidly answer their queries, they easily understand each point and gradually develop fine brains. From among these intelligent souls, those who are especially pious begin to keenly enquire about God and other spiritual topics. Others, who pursue ignoble material knowledge, cannot become successful in life and end up beating the chaff. Those who are inquisitive about the self and the Absolute Truth, Brahman, quickly surrender to Lord Kåñëa and His devotees. Such surrender proves their good measure of piety brought over from their previous births. Beginning with fundamental enquiries about Brahman, they swiftly become elevated, understand the statement of Lord Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä (14.27) that He is the basis of the impersonal Brahman, and begin to worship Him.

A person with meagre piety, however, can never become a devotee of the Supreme Lord. As the scripture states,

mahä-prasäde govinde
näma-brahmaëi vaiñëave
svalpa-puëyavatäà räjan
viçväso naiva jäyate
[Skanda Puräëa, Utkala-khaëòa]

O king! A person with little piety can never develop faith in Lord Govinda, His mercy, His holy name, or His pure devotees.

Most householders desire material gain. Nowadays especially, everyone is feeling the pinch of poverty. The ordinary man thirsts for money solely to enjoy his senses. Once a person falls into the useless company of sense gratifiers, he spends his wealth on fineries, gold, and women. With more wealth, he seeks adoration and distinction, and along with these he gets mansions, cars, and so on. There is only one interest in this endeavor, and that is to enjoy the senses. Persons whose only goal in life is to gratify the senses were referred to earlier as the less intelligent fruitive workers, or karmés. If any among them happen to have some piety, then this select group will not merely fritter away all their time in titillating their senses, but will spend some time worshiping the Supreme Lord. Although these elite karmés do not associate with the pure devotees of the Lord, they call themselves spiritualists. Actually, theyharbor the desire to gratify their carnal desires. They fail to comprehend that the Supreme Lord is known as Håsékeça, "the supreme master of the senses." Sometimes a jïäné (a seeker of knowledge) or a practitioner of mystic yoga will also worship the Lord, but they also are merely interested ultimately in sensual pleasures. The only way these adulterated devotees can become pure devotees is if they read Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé's Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu. This book is an authority on the science of devotional service.

Genuine jïänés know how everything is connected to Brahman, the Absolute Truth. They are humble, unassuming, clean, brahminical, and reverent toward the guru, and they possess many other good qualities. Most often they take to the renounced order (sannyäsa) and lead a pure and saintly life. Yet frequently these sannyäsés develop one major fault: they consider themselves God. They misinterpret the meaning of the Vedic phrase ahaà brahmäsmi, "I am Brahman," and thus they cannot realize pure knowledge of Brahman. They end up deifying the process of negation, and that finally leads to absolute monism. In this way, many jïänés who want to know the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Brahman, get somehow misled by the illusory potency, mäyä. Mäyä prepares her last fatal trap, liberation, by which she keeps the monists stranded in the ocean of material existence. She deludes them into thinking "I am that," "I am He," as if they were in a drunken daze.

If by some chance the Mäyävädé sannyäsés can earn a little piety and then be graced by a pure Vaiñëava devotee—as the Mäyävädés of Benares were by Lord Caitanya—then they can easily realize that knowledge of the impersonal Brahman or the Supersoul is incomplete. Then they can be enlightened with the transcendental knowledge of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Many sages in the past, like the great Sanaka Åñi, and many self-realized renunciants, like the famous Çukadeva Gosvämé, got a taste for knowledge of the Supreme Personality of Godhead after practicing their impersonal disciplines. Then they relished indescribable bliss by hearing the Supreme Lord'stranscendental pastimes. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (2.1.9), Çukadeva Gosvämé says,

pariniñöhito 'pi nairguëya
uttama-çloka-lélayä
gåhéta-cetä räjarñe
äkhyänaà yad adhétavän

O saintly King [Parékñit], I was certainly situated in transcendence, yet I was still attracted by the delineation of the pastimes of the Lord, who is described by enlightened verses.

One of the stalwarts in the spiritual line of Gauòéya Vaiñëavas, Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura, has given his opinion on the four types of pious men who approach the Lord—namely, the distressed, those desiring material gain, the inquisitive, and those who knows things as they are. He says,

The distressed, those in need of material gain, and the inquisitive—these three are neophyte fruitive devotees. Their devotion is mixed with fruitive desires. All of them want to fulfill their desires according to their specific qualities. Finally, when they become purified, they desire to reach the divine abode of the Supreme Lord—the Vaikuëöha planets. They are not like the karmés, or fruitive workers, who want to attain to the heavenly planets. As Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.25) yänti mad-yäjino 'pi mäm: "One who worships Me attains My supreme abode." The jïäné, or one who knows things as they are, is the fourth type of pious man, and he is superior to the other three kinds. He attains a higher result because his devotion is mixed with knowledge. Like Sanaka Åñi, he attainsthe devotional mellow of neutrality. Moreover,because the Lord and His pure devotees shower their causeless mercy upon him, a jïäné devotee can also achieve pure love of Godhead, as in the case of Çukadeva Gosvämé. When devotion mixed with fruitive desires becomes free from those fruitive desires, it is automatically transformed into devotion mixed with knowledge. The result of practising this devotion mixed with knowledge is mentioned above.

Sometimes, when devotees belonging to the categories of mixed devotion develop a taste for the devotional mellow of servitude and practice it, they attain devotion in servitude mixed with awe and reverence. When their devotion becomes more purified, they attain pure devotion in the mellow of servitude, friendship, and so on, and due to their love for the Lord they become His eternal associates. All this is clearly delineated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Here we have discussed only a few points for reference."

RTW 2.5: Lord Kåñëa Alone Is the Supreme Godhead; Everyone Else Is His Servant.

Lord Kåñëa Alone Is the Supreme Godhead; Everyone Else Is His Servant

Generally the tendency of the jïänés is to veer toward impersonal monistic thought. Their idea of monism is this: having experienced the transience and bitterness of material existence and recognized the futility of fruitive activity, they now realize that they are the Self, Brahman, the Absolute Truth. In fact, when realization of the transcendence is perfectly complete, one perceives the personal aspect of the Absolute Truth in the highest spiritual abode. And when the perception of the personal aspect of the Supreme Godhead deepens, one becomes naturally attracted to the absolute transcendental beauty of Lord Kåñëa. As the Lord says in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.19),

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaà sarvam iti
sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù

After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare.

One who fully understands Lord Kåñëa never experiences any bitterness anywhere in the entire material existence. He thrives on the knowledge of His of eternal relationship with the Lord; indeed, he sees everything in the world, and the world itself, in relation to Kåñëa. In this way he is unlike the impersonalistic salvationists, who regard this world as merely evanescent matter. Such a wise devotee realizes that everything is engaged in Lord Kåñëa's service, that nothing can exist outside this relationship, independent of Lord Kåñëa. In other words, for the devotee this world becomes transformed, surcharged with the existence of Kåñëa in everything. The illusory potency recedes into oblivion, and this world takes on the characteristics of the spiritual world, Vaikuëöha. Such a pure devotee of Kåñëa is not selfish, thinking he alone will enjoy the benefits of surrendering to Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet. Rather, he tries to attract everyone in the world to Lord Kåñëa, and by this effort he becomes known as a mahätmä, a magnanimous soul. Such magnanimous souls are truly rare.

It is seen that many so-called mahätmäs, without first realizing that this entire world is pervaded with Lord's Kåñëa's presence, want to become the Lord and master themselves and be served in that capacity. In this way they become fully imprisoned by His illusory potency. They become hounded and bombarded by endless desires, which finally force them to begin worshiping demigods, who are inferior to the Supreme Lord. As Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.20),

kämais tais tair håta-jïänäù
prapadyante 'nya-devatäù
taà taà niyamam ästhäya
prakåtyä niyatäù svayä

Those whose minds are distorted by material desires surrender unto demigods and follow the particular rules and regulations of worship according to their own natures.

Persons who are thus constantly tormented by unlimited desires suffer much distress, which spoils their intelligence. That is why Kåñëa calls them håta-jïänäù, "men with lost intelligence." They become polytheists and hasten to worship various demigods. Polytheists cannot comprehend that kåñëe bhakti kaile sarva-karma-kåta haya: "By worshipingLord Kåñëa, one automatically takes care of all other, subsidiary duties." Polytheists think that demigods like the sun-god are equal to the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. Such men of distorted intelligence can never take shelter of Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet. On the other hand, lofty-minded persons with incisive intelligence are convinced that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Being. If somehow they harbor some material desires, they immediately approach Lord Kåñëa and pray to Him. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (2.3.10) we find this verse:

akämaù sarva-kämo vä
mokña-käma udära-dhéù
tévreëa bhakti-yogena
yajeta puruñaà param

A person who has broader intelligence, whether he be full of all material desire, without any material desire, or desiring liberation, must by all means worship the supreme whole, the Personality of Godhead.

Whatever desire a person may have, to fulfill it he must serve Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, with intense and unfaltering devotion. (This point was discussed earlier by Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura.) If this injunction is followed, then even those who have an aversion to Lord Kåñëa will eventually decide to surrender to Him.

Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Controller and the Supreme Absolute Being, yet He never forces His will upon the infinitesimal living entities. Rather, it is to the living entity's own benefit to recognize that Lord Kåñëa alone is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and that everyone else is His servitor. The sun-god and other demigods perform their duties according to Lord Kåñëa's wishes; indeed, this is why they are called demigods. And since a devotee of the Supreme Lord also follows His wishes, he is also known as a sura, or demigod. Conversely, those who are oppose the Lord's wishes are known as asuras, demons.

The demigods do not possess any independent powers. In fact, they do not wield enough power even to invoke respect for themselves. That is done by the Supreme Lord. Lord Kåñëa's partial expansion, the Supersoul, resides in everyone's heart, and it is He who instills within one's heart faith and respect for the various demigods. The extraordinary powers seen in the sun-god and other demigods are in fact the Supreme Lord's powers. Once attracted to these extraordinary powers, an intelligent person will gradually be drawn to the source of that power, the Supreme Energetic, Lord Kåñëa. Worship of demigods is indirect,inferior, and unsystematic worship of the Supreme Lord. Those who are too attached to fulfilling their material desires are naturally more attracted to the energy than to the Energetic, the source of that energy. Hence in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.21-22) Lord Kåñëa says,

yo yo yäà yäà tanuà bhaktaù
çraddhayärcitum icchati
tasya tasyäcaläà çraddhäà
täm eva vidadhämy aham

sa tayä çraddhayä yuktas
tasyärädhanam éhate
labhate ca tataù kämän
mayaiva vihitän hi tan

I am in everyone's heart as the Supersoul. As soon as one desires to worship the demigods, I make his faith steady so that he can devote himself to some particular deity. Endowed with such a faith, he seeks favors of a particular demigod and obtains his desires. But in actuality these benefits are bestowed by Me alone.

The demigods' powers are like those of a king's officers. The demigods have no independent powers because they are jévas, minute living entities. An officer of the king can bestow some favors because of the powers invested in him by the king. Similarly, a demigod can shower benefits upon his worshipper because the Supreme Lord has given the demigod some power. If the desire-filled demigod-worshipper becomes a little enlightened about the fact that the demigod he worships is fulfilling his desires by the grace of Lord Kåñëa, then with clear intelligence he will begin worshiping Lord Kåñëa directly.

Different demigods have different powers. The sun-god has the power to cure diseases; the moon-god imbues plants with taste and nutritional or medicinal potency; Goddess Durgä gives strength and courage; Goddess Sarasvaté bestows learning; Goddess Lakñmé grants wealth; Goddess Cäëòé offers one the opportunity to consume meat and intoxicants, and Gaëeça gives success in one's endeavors. But all these powers are invested in the demigods by the Supreme Lord, and thus only He, the complete whole,can bestow every kind of benediction. There is an immeasurable difference between a well and the ocean.

We have already touched on the point that everything in the world has been produced by the interaction of the Lord's kñetra-çakti (His inferior energy, comprising the "field of action") and His kñetrajïa-çakti (His superior energy, which is "the knower of the field").Therefore everything in this world is merely a transformation of Lord Kåñëa's energies. In one sense the energy principle and the energetic principle are nondifferent, just as fire and its burning potency are inseparable and non-different. Unfortunately, the impersonalists, the monistic philosophers, have wreaked havoc in the world with their misguided opinions concerningtransformation of the Lord's energy.

Demigods and all other living entities belong to the energy principle, as does the universe itself. No one but the Lord and His plenary expansions are in the category of the energetic principle. Thus the energy and the energetic are one and different. A person who cannot grasp this subtle principle of simultaneous, inconceivable oneness and difference of the Lord and His energies will surely degenerate into an impersonalist, or Mäyävädé. He will be forced from the path of devotion and become silent. The Supreme Lord, the source of all opulence, is the energetic principle. If we consider Him to be impersonal, then we limit His absoluteness. The words "Supreme Absolute" are applicable to Lord Kåñëa alone. The Lord is the Supreme Absolute Principle, unequalled and unsurpassed. Thus the Vedas say He is "one without a second." The Lord's energies are manifested in various forms, and those who become bewildered by these variegated manifestations end up becoming polytheists. It should be clear to all that whatever variegatedness we see in the universe is but a transformation of the Supreme Lord's diverse energies.

The Mäyävädés reject the theory of transformation of energy and subscribe to the theory of the transformation of Brahman itself. Thus they become fixed in their belief that Brahman is impersonal. The Supreme Lord has described the specific situations in which He manifests Himself in His impersonal form. There are many quotes from the scriptures substantiating this point. The Supreme Lord, by manifesting both His personal andimpersonal features, has firmly established the principle that the Supreme Absolute Person is inconceivably and simultaneously one with and different from His energies. This philosophical conclusion—called acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva—has been explained by Lord Kåñëa Himself in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.12): matta eveti tän viddhi na tv ahaà teñu te mayi. "I am, in one sense, everything, but I am independent. I am not under the modes of material nature, for they, on the contrary, are within Me."

The Supreme Energetic is the source of all energies. Yet although all energies emanate from Him, He remains aloof from the workings of these energies. From this we can conclude that the demigods' extraordinary potencies are an intrinsic part of the Supreme Lord's potencies, but that the demigods are separate from the Lord. Hence the boons granted by demigods benefit the recipient only temporarily. Lord Kåñëa confirms this fact in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.23):

antavat tu phalaà teñäà
tad bhavaty alpa-medhasäm
devän deva-yajo yänti
mad-bhaktä yänti mäm api

Men of small intelligence worship the demigods, and their fruits are limited and temporary. Those who worship the demigods go to the planets of the demigods, but My devotees ultimately reach My supreme planet.

We have already discussed that if fruitive workers filled with fruitive desires approach the Supreme Lord instead of going to the demigods, then the benedictions they receive from the Supreme Lord will be everlasting. They will automatically rise a step higher in the ladder of yoga—from fruitive activities to jïäna-yoga, or the path of absolute knowledge. This means that instead of being elevated to the heavenly planets within this material world, they will attain liberation in the Vaikuëöha planets, the Lord'sspiritual abode beyond this material world. The demigod-worshippers go to the planets of the demigods, the heavenly planets, which are temporary. Once a person's accrued piety is used up, he has to come back to earth. On the other hand, once the devotees of the Supreme Lord attain to Vaikuëöha, His supreme abode in the spiritual sky,they never have to return to this world of mortality.

RTW 2.6: Lord Kåñëa Incarnates in Kali Yuga in the Form of His Holy Name

Lord Kåñëa Incarnates in Kali Yuga in the Form of His Holy Name

Persons with meagre intelligence worship the demigods for fleeting fortunes. So one may ask, "If by worshiping the Supreme Lord one can have all his desires fulfilled, why doesn't everyone worship Him?" Devaåsi Närada once answered a similar question posed by Yudhiñöhira Mahäräja. The sage said,

mahä-prasäde govinde
näma-brahmaëi vaiñëave
svalpa-puëya-vatäà räjan
viçväso naiva jäyate
[Mahäbhärata & Skanda Puräëa]

O king, a person with little piety can never develop faith in the Lord Govinda, His mercy, His holy name, or His pure devotees.

Lord Kåñëa has corroborated this in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.28):

yeñäà tv anta-gataà päpaà
janänäà puëya-karmaëäm
te dvandva-moha-nirmuktä
bhajante mäà dåòha-vratäù

Persons who have acted piously in previous lives and in this life, whose sinful actions are completely eradicated and who are freed from the duality of delusion, engage themselves in My service with determination.

Persons with a demoniac mentality are steeped in sin; hence their understanding of the importance of spiritual knowledge is nil. Those who have been able to eradicate their sins by living according to the dictates of their social and spiritual order, and who have thus acquired sufficient piety, are qualified to practice karma-yoga. Gradually they progress to jïäna-yoga, and finally, in meditation, they realize the transcendental and supreme position of the Lord. Such highly fortunate realized souls can see in their hearts the eternal, transcendental, two-handed form of the Supreme Lord, known as Çyämasundara,playing His flute. The description of the Lord in Çré Brahma-saàhitä (5.30) reads,

veëuà kvaëantam aravinda-daläyatäkñaà
barhävataàsam asitämbuda-sundaräìgam
kandarpa-koöi-kamanéya-viçeña-çobhaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is adept at playing on His flute, with blooming eyes like lotus petals, with head bedecked with peacock's feather, with thefigure of beauty tinged with the hue of blue clouds, and His unique loveliness charming millions of cupids.

Those who are committing sins like illicit sex, fault-finding, and unjustified violence rarely attain spiritual knowledge or realization. Sinful activities deepen the dark gloom of ignorance, while pious activities bring the light of transcendental knowledge into one's life. This knowledge culminates in realization of Kåñëa. However, simply performing pious activities does not make one eligible for God-realization. Only when a person performs pious activities and associates with saintly persons does spiritual knowledge dawn on his consciousness. Then, when he transcends the platform of duality—especially when he no longer takes part in the controversy over the Absolute Truth's monistic or dualistic existence—he sees Lord Kåñëa in his enlightenment and worships Him with determination asone without a second, matchless and supreme. In the perfected stage of pious activities, the mode of goodness dominates the consciousness, dissipating the darkness of nescience and illusion, which are products of the mode of ignorance. As soon as the mode of passion is fully subdued, spiritual realization illuminates the sky of one's consciousness.

The point to consider at this juncture is, does anyone in the present age, Kali-yuga, have the means to properly perform such pious activities as fire sacrifices, giving in charity, penances, or austerities? It is universally accepted that the unfortunate people of Kali-yuga are absolutely unable to undertake such extravagances. For this reason Lord Caitanya, the most munificent incarnation of Godhead and the savior of the Kali-yuga, has declared the truth of the following mantra from the Båhan-näradéya Puräëa:

harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä

In this age of quarrel and hypocrisy, the only means of deliverance is chanting the holy name of the Lord, chanting the holy name of the Lord, chanting the holy name of the Lord. There is no other way. There is no other way. There is no other way.

In the age of Kali the only process for attaining perfection is to hear, chant, and remember the holy name of the Supreme Lord. Numerous quotes from the scriptures substantiate this. All inauspiciousness is destroyed by chanting the all-auspicious name of Lord Kåñëa. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam (12.12.55) confirms this:

avismåtiù kåñëa-padäravindayoù
kñiëoty abhadräëi ca çaà tanoti
sattvasya çuddhià paramätma-bhaktià
jïänaà ca vijïäna-viräga-yuktam

Remembrance of Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet destroys everything inauspicious and awards the greatest good fortune. It purifies the heart and bestows devotion for the Supreme Soul, along with knowledge enriched with realization and renunciation.

Therefore, to remain beyond the reach of delusion and duality, one has to always remember and meditate on the beatific form of Lord Kåñëa, who has a darkish complexion and is playing His flute. One must also remember and chant the holy name of Kåñëa, which is nondifferent from Him, its nature being eternal, perfect, pure, and independent. In the Bhagavad-gétä (8.6-7) Lord Kåñëa explains the importance of remembering Him always:

yaà yaà väpi smaran bhävaà
tyajaty ante kalevaram
taà tam evaiti kaunteya
sadä tad-bhäva-bhävitaù

tasmät sarveñu käleñu
mäm anusmara yudhya ca
mayy arpita-mano-buddhir
mäm evaiñyasy asaàçayaù

Whatever state of being one remembers when he quits his body, that state he will attain without fail. Therefore, Arjuna, you should always think of Me in the form of Kåñëa and at the same time carry out your prescribed duty of fighting. With your activities dedicated to Me and your mind and intelligence fixed on Me, you will attain Me without doubt.

At the time of death, our state of consciousness determines our next birth. Death destroys the body made up of the five gross elements, but the subtle body, consisting of mind, intelligence, and false ego, remains. As the air carries the scent of the place it blows over, so the soul carries a person's subtle body of mind, intelligence, and false ego, along with hisstate of consciousness, on to his next birth, and his body is determined accordingly. When a breeze blows over a garden, it carries the fragrance of flowers with it, but when it blows over a rubbish heap, the breeze is filled with the stench. Similarly, the activities a person performs during his lifetime continuously influence his mentality, and at the time of death the cumulative effect of these activities determines his state of consciousness. Thus the subtle body formed during one's lifetime is carried over to one's next birth and manifests as the soul's next gross body. Naturally, therefore, the gross body reflects one's state of consciousness. As thepopular saying goes, "The face is the index of the mind." And the mind is the product of the activities of one's present and previous lives. In other words, one's mind, intelligence, and false ego, which are influenced by one's habits in this and previous births, form the matrix that determines the type of body and mentality one will have in the next life. Hence the connection between one's previous, present, and future lives is the mind, intelligence, and false ego.

The activities of the day evoke dreams at night and induce emotions appropriate to those activities. Similarly, the activities performed in one's lifetime flash across one's mind at the moment of death and determine one's next life. Therefore, if one's present activities are directed toward chanting, hearing, and remembering the Supreme Lord's transcendental name, along with descriptions of His beauty, qualities, pastimes, associates, and paraphernalia, then one's consciousness at the moment one leaves his body will automatically be attracted to the Lord. Such a spiritual state of consciousness at the moment of death ensures the soul entry into the Supreme Lord's eternal abode in his very next birth. To awaken this spiritual consciousness is man's prime goal in life. We therefore find that Lord Kåñëa, out of compassion for the conditioned souls, instructs Arjuna to fight and at the same time remember Him. This is called karma-yoga. Therefore devotees always remember Him in all their activities—in their endeavors for food and safety and even in the middle of the battlefield while fighting a war. Life being like a battlefield, in which one may die at any time, the devotees remember Him at every moment, and He willingly becomes the charioteer of their chariotlike bodies. The activities of their bodies, minds, and words are thus prompted by the Supreme Lord's will, and at the end, when they leave their gross and subtle bodies, they go directly to the spiritual sky.

The prime symptom of pure devotional service is constant chanting, hearing, and remembrance of the holy name. Mixed devotional service, as we have previously discussed, is devotional service adulterated by karma (fruitive desire) and jïäna (attachment to knowledge). Such devotional service is often impeded by the particular situation or association a person finds himself in. But there is never any impediment to pure devotional service. Perfect realization of the Supreme Lord does not occur until one is firmly situated in unalloyed devotional service. Lord Kåñëa confirms this in the Bhagavad-gétä (18.55): bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti yävän yaç cäsmi tattvataù. "One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service." And in verse 8.14 the Lord mentions the primary characteristic of this pure devotional service:

ananya-cetäù satataà
yo mäà smarati nityaçaù
tasyähaà sulabhaù pärtha
nitya-yuktasya yoginaù

For one who remembers Me without deviation, I am easy to obtain, O son of Påthä, because of his constant engagement in devotional service.

Undeviating concentration on the Supreme Lord is the first sign of pure devotion. In other words, a pure devotee is one who wards off all desires and thoughts not related to unflinching devotional service to the Supreme Lord. Many spiritual stalwarts have commented upon pure devotional service. For example, Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, the foremost of the great spiritual preceptors in the time of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, wrote in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (1.1.11):

anyäbhiläñitä-çünyaà
jïäna-karmädy-anävåtam
änukülyena kåñëänu-
çélanaà bhaktir uttama

One should render transcendental loving service to the Supreme Lord Kåñëa favorably and without desire for material profit or gain through fruitive activities or philosophical speculation. That is called pure devotional service.

People propitiate demigods to satisfy their material desires. Those neophyte devotees of Kåñëa who try to appease demigods like the sun-god in order to escape ill health do so because they succumb to serious doubts about Lord Kåñëa's supreme divinity. In analyzing the word anyäbhiläña ("desires other than those directed toward serving Lord Kåñëa"), we find that one fosters this type of perverted intelligence when one thinks that the sun-god, who is merely a manifestation of the Supreme Lord's potency, can protect one from ill health but that the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, cannot. Once these mind-clouding doubts disperse, one enters the doors of pure devotional service. Karmés and jïänés are also tainted by material desires—the desire to enjoy their senses and the desire for liberation, respectively.Pure devotional service is attained only when these material desires are dissipated and one renders unbroken, favorable devotional service to the Lord Kåñëa. The great sage Närada has said,

sarvopädhi-vinirmuktaà
tat-paratvena nirmalam
håñékeëa håñékeça-
sevanaà bhaktir ucyate

Bhakti, or devotional service, means engaging all our senses in the service of the Lord, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the master of all the senses. When the spirit soul renders service unto Him, there are two side effects-one is freed from all material designations, and, simply by being employed in the service of the Lord, one's senses are purified. (Närada-païcarätra).

The various identities a person adopts in relation to his mind and body are all material designations. The pure soul is unencumbered by such mundane designations, for the only identity he has is that of a servant and inseparable part of the Supreme Lord. Thus, with the shedding of all false designations, one enters a state of transcendence, and when one is firmly situated in transcendence, one becomes pure. Serving the Supreme Lord, the master of all senses, with such purified senses is unalloyed devotional service.

In Bhagavad-gétä (8.14), the two words ananya-cetäù ("without deviation") and nitya-yukta ("regularly") are very significant. One cannot become undeviating in devotional practice without being fixed in undeviating faith. When a person regularly serves the Supreme Lord with this faith, he automatically loses all desires for fruitive activity, speculative knowledge, worship of the demigods, and ritualistic pious activities, and he becomes undeviating in his devotional service. The word satatam ("always") must be understood to imply that devotional service is independent of time, place, circumstance, adversity, and so on. Everyone, regardless of race, caste, sex, or other material designation, can give up mental speculation, fruitive actions, and yoga practice and take complete shelter of Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet without deviation. The word nitya means "daily," "regularly," or "constantly." Those who meditate constantly on Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet can easily attain Him. As Lord Brahmä states in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.33),

advaitam acyutam anädim ananta-rüpam
ädyaà puräëa-puruñaà nava-yauvanaà ca
vedeñu durlabham adurlabham ätma-bhaktau
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

I worship Govinda, the Primeval Lord, who is inaccessible to the Vedas, but who is obtainable by pure unalloyed devotion of the soul, who is without a second, who is not subject to decay, is without a beginning, whose form is endless, who is the beginning, and the eternal puruña, yet He is a person possessing the beauty of blooming youth.

In the process of executing religious duties, performing fruitive activities, cultivating empiric knowledge, and practising mystic yoga, much endeavor, time, and money is spent. One has to accept the sinful reactions along with the pious results of such activities. The only way to nullify these results and reactions is to worship the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. Thus worshiping and serving Lord Kåñëa are the only advantageous activities for the entire world.

The Supreme Lord is the embodiment of eternal bliss and is always engaged in transcendental pastimes. The only thing required to worship Him is undeviating devotion—ostentation will not please Him. Devotional service to Lord Kåñëa does not produce hate or envy; only the agnostic reprobates are strongly opposed to the Lord's devotional service and His devotees. One derives the greatest bliss in devotional service. Indeed, when one finally obtains the Lord, it is like being drowned in an ocean of unlimited ecstasy. Only the devotees of Lord Kåñëa can taste this ecstasy and be always joyful.

RTW 2.7: Under Illusion of Mäyä Man has Forgotten Lord Kåñëa

Under Illusion of Mäyä Man has Forgotten Lord Kåñëa

The karmés, jïänés, and yogés, as well as the common politicians and anyone else who is working hard to make a comfortable and peaceful situation in this material world, must clearly realize that the world is transitory and full of misery. However much one may toil to make a permanent settlement in this world, at the end everyone is forced to leave. As long as one stays here, one must come to grips with the reality of suffering. Since time immemorial the soul has been coming and going. The Lord's devotees, however, not only live happily in this world, but after they leave here they enter the eternal and ever-blissful abode of the Lord. As the Lord says in the Bhagavad-gétä (8.15),

mäm upetya punar janma
duùkhälayam açäçvatam
näpnuvanti mahätmänaù
saàsiddhià paramäà gatäù

After attaining Me, the great souls, who are yogés in devotion, never return to this temporary world, which is full of miseries, because they have attained the highest perfection.

According to the above verse, the devotees attain the highest perfection—that is, they join the elevated corps of the Lord's eternal associates. The mystic yogé's eightfold mystic perfection is not the same as the devotee's para-siddhi, or "highest perfection." While mystic yoga brings perfections that are material and temporary, devotional service to the Supreme Lord brings absolute perfection, which is transcendental and eternal. The Supreme Lord incessantly manifests His ever-fresh transcendental pastimes within this unlimited material universe, which He has created. These pastimes, known as bhauma-lélä, have been going on since time immemorial. The sun remains in one place, yet somewhere on earth people see it rising, while elsewhere people see it setting. This rising and setting has been going on since the dawn of creation. Similarly, although Lord Kåñëa eternally resides in Goloka, His eternal abode, He manifests His transcendental pastimes at every moment in the countless universes of this cosmic creation. As it is a mistake to think the sun rises and sets, it is a gross misconception to think that Lord Kåñëa was born on such-and-such a day and was slain by someone on such-and-such a day. The Lord's birth and activities are all transcendental and miraculous. And those who can comprehend this esoteric truth attain the highest perfection. As the Lord states in the the Bhagavad-gétä (4.9),

janma-karma ca me divyam
evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma
naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

One who knows the transcendental nature of My appearance and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take his birth again in this material world, but attains My eternal abode, O Arjuna.

When Lord Kåñëa desires to manifest His earthly pastimes, He appears through His eternal parents, Çrématé Devaké and Çré Vasudeva, and is later brought up by His foster parents, Mother Yaçodä and Nanda Mahäräja. Saintly souls who perfect their devotional service by following in the footsteps of the Lord's eternal parents are elevated to the highest position as eternal associates of the Supreme Lord. Once having entered into the Lord's eternal transcendental pastimes, these great souls relish superexcellent devotional mellows in ecstatic love of Godhead.

In the innumerable universes, Lord Kåñëa reveals His earthly pastimes with His intimate friend and eternal associate Arjuna. The Lord makes this clear in two Bhagavad-gétä verses (4.5-6):

bahüni me vyatétäni
janmäni tava cärjuna
täny ahaà veda sarväëi
na tvaà vettha parantapa

ajo 'pi sann avyayätmä
bhütänäm éçvaro 'pi san
prakåtià sväm adhiñöhäya
sambhavämy ätma-mäyayä

Many, many births both you and I have passed. I can remember all of them, but you cannot, O subduer of the enemy! Although I am unborn and My transcendental body never deteriorates, and although I am the Lord of all sentient beings, I still appear in every millennium in My original transcendental form.

As for those unfortunate souls who do not strive for the supreme goal of entering the eternal pastimes of the Supreme Lord and instead become attracted to the mundane practices of karma, jïäna, and yoga, which ultimately elevate one to the heavenly planets—such souls must once again take birth in this material world. Although they may reach a high status in this cosmic system, they must come down as if on a ferris wheel. Kåñëa describes this phenomenon in the Bhagavad-gétä (8.16):

ä-brahma-bhuvanäl lokäù
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place. But one who attains to My abode, O son of Kunté, never takes birth again.

The higher planetary systems in this material world are Bhürloka, Bhuvarloka, Svargaloka, Maharloka, Janaloka, Tapoloka, and up to Satyaloka, or Brahmaloka. Whichever of these planets one rises to in his next life, one must finally return to earth. What to speak of the next life, even in this life the high position one attains after considerable hard work—such as king, emperor, minister, governor, or president—is lost after some time, and one is thrown back to a mean and humble status. Only leaders who have experienced this kind of humiliation can know the trepidation that accompanies it. But if at any stage of life the grossly foolish miscreants described in the Gétä decide to render devotional service to Lord Kåñëa, they can escape the ferris wheel of karma. On this wheel, sometimes one goes to heaven and sometimes to hell, sometimes one is born a king and sometimes a slave, sometimes one becomes a brähmaëa and sometimes çüdra, and so it goes on. But once a person enters the spiritual abode of the Supreme Lord, he begins his eternal life in his original, constitutional position.

By the influence of karma, one who is attached to the material body and mind has to change bodies life after life. In this way the soul roams the fourteen planetary systems within this material universe, sometimes going up and sometimes coming down. These planets are transitory—merely theatrical stages upon which the soul enacts his mundane existence. But when the living entity is elevated to spiritual perfection and is situated in his pure, eternal identity, devoid of all mundane designations, he attains the natural habitat of the spirit soul, the supramundane realm transcending this material creation and the intermediary zone of the unmanifested Brahman effulgence.

The material body, made up of material ingredients such as earth, water, fire, and air, is mortal. Similarly, because this material universe is an amalgam of earth, water, fire, air, etc., it is also transitory. But the spirit soul (which, incidently, has never been duplicated in the laboratory despite repeated efforts) is imperishable, as is its natural, eternal home—the kingdom of God. The process that takes the eternal soul to his eternal home is called sanätana-dharma, or "the eternal religion."

Empirical, atheistic philosophers like Kapila spent innumerable tedious hours researching the material phenomena of this cosmic creation. Yet it remained beyond the grasp of their limited intelligence to understand that there exists a realm transcendental and far superior to this manifested material world. Finally, when their probing minds failed to sight land in an ocean of speculation, they concluded that the absolute truth is unmanifest.

Compared to other species, human beings are certainly endowed with good intelligence, yet unless they are devotees of the Lord, all their thinking is limited within mundane boundaries. Therefore it is impossible for the mundane mind to approach the transcendence. But instead of surrendering to the Supreme Lord or His representative, the empirical philosophers try to explain away as "unmanifest" that which is beyond their mundane minds. This is known as the logic of the frog in the well.

No matter how big a thinker a tiny living entity may be, all his activities are limited by mundane boundaries, just as a frog in the well can never comprehend that such a thing as an ocean exists outside his little domain. He refuses to acknowledge that a mass of water infinitely bigger than his tiny puddle can at all be possible. Similarly, we are trapped in the dark well of our body and mind. And although we may try hard through yoga or empirical speculation to overcome our limitations, no matter how erudite we are it is impossible to reach beyond the limitations of our self-made well.

So, who can bring us news of the great ocean? Is there any record of how long we have been struggling in the water to stay afloat in the well of this material world, sometimes going up to the higher planets, sometimes coming down? Only the Supreme Lord Himself or His empowered representative can possibly free us from confinement in this dark well. Under their guidance we can come to know of the limitless ocean of the spiritual sky. This process—hearing from higher authorities—is called the deductive, or descending, process of knowledge. It is the only authorized way to learn transcendental knowledge. By this method alone is eternal truth transmitted.

And what can we learn by this process? Lord Kåñëa describes the spiritual and material worlds as follows in the Bhagavad-gétä (8.17-20):

By human calculation, a thousand ages taken together form the duration of Brahmä's one day. And such also is the duration of his night. When Brahmä's day is manifest, this multitude of living entities comes into being, and at the arrival of Brahmä's night they are all annihilated. Again and again the day comes, and this host of beings is active; and again the night falls, O Pärtha, and they are helplessly dissolved. Yet there is another nature, which is eternal and is transcendental to this manifested and unmanifested matter. It is supreme and is never annihilated. When all in this world is annihilated, that part remains as it is."

People become awestruck when they learn that the life span on Brahmaloka is many millions of years. One has to undergo severe austerities and renunciation, accepting the sannyäsa order of life, in order to reach Brahmaloka. However, we must consider one essential fact: even Lord Brahmä, the presiding deity of that planet, is not immortal. Those who have researched the Vedic scriptures in depth can calculate the lifetime of Brahmä. Human beings count 365 days in their year, and the cycle of four yugas comprises approximately 4,320,000 such years. A thousand cycles of four yugas make up one day-time (twelve hours) of Lord Brahmä's life. In this way his month and year can be calculated, and Brahmä lives for a hundred years of his time. But despite this vast life span—311 trillion 40 billion human years—Lord Brahmä is a mortal being, and this universe created by him is also perishable. Thus it is not strange that human beings, who are also his creation, should perish. As human beings seem immortal to a tiny insect, so Lord Brahmä and the demigods seem immortal to us. In fact, however, no material body of any form is ever eternal.

At the end of Lord Brahmä's day, when night approaches, a partial dissolution inundates the universe up to the Svargaloka, the abode of the demigods. All the living entities of this world are created at the dawn of Lord Brahmä's day and annihilated at dusk, and this creation and annihilation go on in a continuous cycle.

RTW 2.8: The Supreme Lord always resides in the eternal Vaikuëöha planets.

The Supreme Lord always resides in the eternal Vaikuëöha planets

This material creation is manifested and subsequently destroyed during Lord Brahmä's day and night. But beyond this material world is an eternal existence—the spiritual sky—which is untouched by creation and annihilation. That spiritual abode is known as the Vaikuëöha planets. Even when this material creation is destroyed, the Vaikuëöha planets remain unscathed and intact. Once anyone enters these planets, he never again suffers the repetition of birth and death, which is inevitable for earthly beings. While the material world is covered and pervaded by the material sky, the spiritual planets are suspended in the spiritual sky, known as paravyoma. All the planetary systems within the paravyoma are transcendental abodes where the Supreme Lord performs His pastimes eternally.

Earlier we discussed that the Supreme Lord possesses two main energies, the material energy and the spiritual energy. The Vaikuëöha planets are a product of the spiritual energy of the Lord. The living entities belong to this spiritual energy, but because they can reside in either the spiritual world or the material world, even though they are originally spiritual they are designated as taöasthä-çakti, or "marginal potency."

The Vaikuëöha planets are a manifestation of the Lord's internal potency, while the material world is a manifestation of His external potency. Since the Supreme Lord is the master of all energies, it is an irrefutable fact that He is in full control of both the spiritualand material worlds. The perfect analogy is an earthen pot: What is needed to manufacture an earthen pot are clay, a potter's wheel, and a potter. The clay is the material, or ingredient cause of the pot, the wheel is the instrumental or efficient cause, and the potter is the prime cause. Similarly, while the material energy is both the ingredient and efficient cause of this cosmic creation, the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, is the prime cause. Like a shadow, the material energy works strictly in accordance with the Supreme Lord's dictates. As Lord Kåñëa explains in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.10):

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again.

The sad fact is that although Kåñëa reveals the truth about Himself throughout the Bhagavad-gétä and other Vedic literatures, the luckless populace cannot regard Him as the Supreme Lord. In particular, the impersonalistic philosophers, who make tall claims of being bastions of religiosity, reduce the Supreme Lord to the level of a mediocre mortal and thereby accrue heavy sins. Such atheistic offenders can never approach the subject of God on their own merit. The Supreme Lord and His surrendered servitors have in various ways clarified and transmitted the knowledge of the Supreme Absolute, but those who offend the Supreme Lord and His devotees can never comprehend such topics. As Çré Prahläda Mahäräja says in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (7.5.30-31),

matir na kåñëe parataù svato vä
mitho 'bhipadyeta gåha-vratänäm
adänta-gobhir viçatäà tamisraà
punaù punaç carvita-carvaëänäm

na te viduù svärtha-gatià hi viñëuà
duräçayä ye bahir-artha-mäninaù
andhä yathändhair upanéyamänäs
te 'péça-tantryäm uru-dämni baddhäù

Because of their uncontrolled senses, persons too addicted to materialistic life make progress toward hellish conditions and repeatedly chew that which has already been chewed. Their inclinations toward Kåñëa are never aroused, either by the instructions of others, by their own efforts, or by a combination of both. Persons who are strongly entrapped by the consciousness of enjoying material life, and who have therefore accepted as their leader or guru a similar blind man attached to external sense objects, cannot understand that the goal of life is to return home, back to Godhead, and engage in the service of Lord Viñëu. As blind men guided by another blind man miss the right path and fall into a ditch, materially attached men led by another materially attached man are bound by the ropes of fruitive labor, which are made of very strong cords, and they continue again and again in materialistic life, suffering the threefold miseries.

Lord Kåñëa also describes this kind of person in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.11):

avajänanti mäà müòhä
mänuñéà tanum äçritam
paraà bhävam ajänanto
mama bhüta-maheçvaram

Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and My supreme dominion over all that be.

Puny human beings can manufacture only insignificant items like pots, pans, and factories. Therefore, when a personality who was born not so long ago in Mathurä and who looks like a human being is introduced as the Supreme Controller of the entire cosmic manifestation, the Lord of all lords and possessor of all absolute qualities, then, no matter how clearly one explains these truths, ordinary people cannot absorb them, due to their tiny dog's-bent-tail intelligence. Thus they embrace monistic, impersonal philosophy. Denying that Lord Kåñëa alone is God, they insist that they are also "Gods." In this manner they embrace grossly foolish ideas about themselves and God and try to compete with Him, completely disregarding all etiquette and sound philosophical conclusions.

Spiritualists from the West often conclude that such atheistic people are possessed by Satan. In bygone ages many such satanic persons—Rävaëa, Hiraëyakaçipu, Jaräsandha, Kaàsa—challenged the Supreme Lord's authority. In modern times they have steadily multiplied. These demons have dismissed even Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, insulting Him with derogatory name—calling as "son of aunt Çacé."

The point to consider is that no one can really compete with God. The Supreme Lord is unparalleled, second to none. As it is said in the Caitanya-caritämåta, ekale éçvara kåñëa, ära saba bhåtya: "Lord Kåñëa alone is the Supreme Godhead, and all others are His servants." Only those who go through life being kicked about by fate, slaving hard to fill their bellies and maintain a roof overhead, can harbor so preposterous a wish as to compete with the omnipotent Supreme Controller. It is ludicrous.They dare harbor such desires because they are totally ignorant of the supreme, transcendental position of the Lord. Yet the Supreme Lord is so compassionate that by various tricks He tries to teach even these fools the facts of His transcendental and supreme position. And the Lord's confidential servitors, accepting many hazards and pains, also try every possible means to exorcise Satan from these people, who are possessed by the demon of atheism.

Then there are those so-called scholars who claim that they they alone know the scriptures and that all others are illiterate fools. Such "scholars" say that research of the holy texts clearly reveals that Käraëodakaçäyé Viñëu is the cause of this material creation and that Lord Kåñëa, the son of Vasudeva and Devaké, is at best Viñëu's partial expansion. Thus we see that even intelligent men are sometimes bewildered by the illusory potency, mäyä, and subscribe to demoniac ideas. How is it possible for such bewildered souls to accept that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the cause of all causes?

If we consult the çruti and småti scriptures on this topic, we will find many references proving that Lord Govinda, Kåñëa, is the origin of Käraëodakaçäyé Viñëu, and not vice-versa. For example, the Brahma-saàhitä (5.47) states,

yaù käraëärnava-jale bhajati sma yoga-
nidräm ananta-jagad-aëòa-sa-roma-küpaù
ädhära-çaktim avalambya paräà sva-mürtià
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

I adore the primeval Lord Govinda who assuming His own great subjective form, who bears the name Çeña, replete with the all-accommodating potency, and reposing in the Causal Ocean with the infinity of the worlds in the pores of His hair, enjoys creative sleep [yoganidrä].

The Bible says, "God created man after His own image." According to this statement, man possesses two hands because he has a form similar to God's. But this doesn't mean that God is a human being because He has two hands. It is a heinous offence to try to diminish the position of Lord Kåñëa because He appeared in a human form. The truth about His divine potency and supreme position should be learned from the self-realized spiritual master, the saintly souls, and the revealed scriptures.

Demonic persons fail to understand the real purpose of human life. Instead, they are always quick to try to diminish the supreme position of Lord Kåñëa. Such atheists may have very high ambitions and may perform great, noble deeds, but because their ambitions and deeds are cut off from a loving relationship to Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Godhead, they are all useless. The demon Rävaëa wanted to reach heaven by constructing a stairway, but he failed. And all atheists' ambitions are like that. A zero placed next to the number one gives ten, a second zero makes one hundred, and so on. As long as the number one is there, the value keeps rising as the zeroes increase.But without the number one, any number of zeroes are valueless. Similarly, if a person spends his whole life simply increasing the "zeroes" of material wealth, fame, and learning, without any relationship to the "one"—Lord Kåñëa—then his whole life is valueless.As Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.12),

moghäçä mogha-karmäëo
mogha-jïänä vicetasaù
räkñasém äsuréà caiva
prakåtià mohinéà çritäù

Those who are thus bewildered are attracted by demoniac and atheistic views. In that deluded condition, their hopes for liberation, their fruitive activities, and their culture of knowledge are all defeated.

Although a person may call himself a devotee of Lord Kåñëa, if he considers Kåñëa a human being or thinks that He started off as a human being and then evolved into God (as is now in vogue, with so many "incarnations" mushrooming), then such a person is not a devotee but an imposter. One often comes across monists and pseudo-devotees posing as Lord Kåñëa's devotees, but eventually they try to usurp Kåñëa's position. They want to be Lord Kåñëa themselves. Persons with such insidious desires are totally bewildered. If a fruitive worker thinks that Lord Kåñëa is an ordinary mortal, he does not attain the goal of his fruitive work—elevation to the heavenly planets. And if an anthropomorphist happens to be a jïäné, an empirical philosopher, then he also fails to achieve the goal of his pursuit of knowledge—liberation from the material modes.

RTW 2.9: Following in the Footsteps of Self-Realized Saints

Following in the Footsteps of Self-Realized Saints

Atheists gradually develop a demoniac nature and live in the world like beggars chasing after name, fame, wealth, and so on. Constantly deluded by mäyä, they live useless lives. On the other hand, those who are truly dedicated to serving the Supreme Lord are never attacked by such a demoniac mentality. These great souls do not carry the title "Mahätmä" as an appendage. Someone who follows the satanic path and always challenges the Supreme Lord may try to fool the people into thinking he is a mahätmä, but the characteristics of an actual mahätmä are found in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.13):

mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha
daivéà prakåtim äçritäù
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jïätvä bhütädim avyayam

O son of Påthä, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible.

Real mahätmäs do not distract their minds with sense gratification and material desires, but with single-minded resolve they engage in the devotional service of the Supreme Lord. Because they are under the protection of His divine energy, they understand that Lord Kåñëa is the supreme cause of all causes. Such persons alone possess all saintly qualities. Lord Kåñëa's devotees are exceptional personalities, for at all times they are embellished with extraordinary characteristics rarely attained even by the demigods. To usher in the age of peace in this world, the presence such mahätmäs is imperative.

Recently, at a medical convention held in New Delhi, our honorable prime minister made the following observation in his speech:

We go in for public health, sanitation, and all kinds of preventive measures rather than wait for people to fall ill and then treat them. Why not apply that principle in the larger sphere and prevent social diseases that, left untreated, we will have to deal with later in a much more difficult form? So when wise men like you gather together, perhaps you might think of the ills and diseases of humanity as a whole that create so many conflicts and troubles and impede human progress.

Factually, whatever problems crop up in the world are caused by the mind. Paëòitas have researched the scriptures thoroughly and held many discussions on this topic. If we can follow the example set by the subjects of King Ambaréña, who under his guidance concentrated their minds on the lotus feet of Lord Kåñëa, then the mind can be cured of all ills. Any other process will bring upon us the fate described by Prahläda Mahäräja in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (5.18.12): haräv abhaktasya kuto mahad-guëäù manorathenäsati dhävato bahiù.

... a person devoid of devotional service and engaged in material activities has no good qualities. Even if he is adept at the practice of mystic yoga or the honest endeavor of maintaining his family and relatives, he must be driven by his own material speculations and must engage in the service of the Lord's external energy. How can there be any good qualities in such a man?

The only way to cure this mental disease is to wholeheartedly follow Lord Caitanya's instruction to chant the holy names of Kåñëa. This will cleanse the heart of all impurities. Until this esoteric truth is propagated widely, the world will remain deprived of the panacea that cures all mental diseases. Our honorable prime minister should seriously consider this. If the number of Lord Kåñëa's devotees even slightly increases, there will immediately be a resurgence of peace and prosperity in the world. For man to rise to the glorious heights of a demigod, he needs only to revive his latent Kåñëa consciousness. Thus Kåñëa consciousness is the greatest boon to humanity.

The mahätmäs possess other wonderful qualities, some of which Lord Kåñëa describes in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.14):

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate

Always chanting My glories, endeavoring with great determination, bowing down before Me, these great souls perpetually worship Me with great devotion.

This text gives some hints of how to become a devotee of Lord Kåñëa. The word satatam ("always") has been used to indicate that the process of purifying one's consciousness does not depend on fruitive activity, empiric knowledge, yoga, or on time, place, or circumstance.

A living entity becomes free from all suffering as soon as he admits that he is an eternal servant of Lord Kåñëa. Such a servant of the Lord need not perform fruitive activity or cultivate empiric knowledge, nor does he have to undergo any other process of purification. The only essential factor is his intense greed for devotional service to the Lord.

An extreme longing for Lord Kåñëa is the only means for attaining Him. Thus intense, unflinching devotional service is another symptom of a mahätmä. These mahätmäs execute all nine limbs of devotional service, beginning with hearing, chanting, and remembering the name, form, qualities, pastimes, and paraphernalia of Lord Kåñëa. Such devotional service is transcendental to any mundane consideration of time, place, or circumstance. Mahätmäs are always eager to render loving devotional service to the Lord. They tirelessly dedicate their lives, energy, words, intelligence, body, society—everything—in the service of the Lord.

The great endeavor the mahätmä undertakes to execute devotional service is more intense than the ordinary man's voluntary acceptance of excessive pains and troubles to maintain his family and home. The struggle for maintaining family and relatives is illusion, or mäyä. Hence it is truly distressing. By contrast, the difficulties one accepts in serving the Supreme Lord are transcendental, and therefore they are a source of sublime bliss. Moreover, a person who serves the Supreme Lord automatically serves his family. But the opposite is not true: serving the family is not equivalent to serving the Lord. All mahätmäs agree on this point.Not only does the person who serves the Supreme Lord serve his relatives, but he also serves the entire world of moving and nonmoving living beings. Thus service to Lord Kåñëa is the prime cause of world peace and harmony.

The mahätmäs are always ready to render such service to the Lord with great determination. In this regard His Divine Grace Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura once made this comment in a lecture:

The neophyte Vaiñëava devotees' ringing the bell even once during worship of the Deity of the Supreme Lord is a million times more valuable, spiritually and otherwise, than the charitable fruitive workers building many hospitals, feeding thousands of the poor, or building homes, or even the empirical philosophers' Vedic studies, meditation, austerities, and penances.

The mahätmäs have shown the perfect path of charity: devotional service to the Lord. If anyone ignores this path and instead builds hospitals, his effort to help humanity is a mere pretense. Humanity can never reap any permanent advantage from such activities. Indeed, the number of patients only increases along with the number of hospitals. And as for feeding the poor, this will never eradicate poverty, but encourage it. Frankly speaking, we are not against opening hospitals or feeding the poor, or any other such humanitarian service. But what we have learned from our beloved spiritual master is that when devotional service to the Lord is neglected,every other activity is illusory and futile. Without genuine devotional service, even opening hospitals and feeding the poor in the name of Lord Kåñëa is futile. Spiritual groups that do not strictly follow in Lord Caitanya's line cannot comprehend this because they do not wish to abide by the instructions of the mahätmäs. They do not follow Lord Caitanya's injunction to be "more humble than a blade of grass." If they were that humble, they would give up their pride in being the doer of good deeds, the wisest person, the most devoted, and so on.

Those who strive to emulate the mahätmäs never fall prey to passivity and regression. Their eagerness and determination to serve the Lord steadily increase. Such followers observe spiritual occasions like Janmäñöamé and Ekädaçé for the pleasure of the Lord, in the way that the previous äcäryas and mahätmäs have recommended. This is devotional service proper. Because the mahätmäs are more humble than a blade of grass, they worship Lord Kåñëa and everything in relation to Him. Atheists, however, exhibit a different mentality altogether: they want to flaunt their abilities and charitable disposition. They may pretend to serve Lord Kåñëa, but their aim is "to sit on the Lord's head" once they attain perfection. In other words, they want to usurp His position. Therefore they do not really serve Lord Kåñëa, nor is He their real object of worship. The mahätmäs never associate with these demoniac people. They are fixed in their resolve to serve the Lord, and thus they always remain connected to Him through devotional service.

RTW 2.10: The Supreme Lord: Lover of His Devotees

The Supreme Lord: Lover of His Devotees

Members of the so-called educated class ask, "If one is busy all the time rendering devotional service to Lord Kåñëa, how is one to maintain himself and his family?" The so-called educated men think only a fool would be blind to his immediate physical needs and uselessly waste his time in devotional service so he could rise to the platform of a mahätmä. In fact, they think that a real mahätmä is he who strives to improve his material facilities from good to better. They say that it is because of the economists' poor planning that the world is facing a major crisis in food production. Both the economists and their critics should turn to the Bhagavad-gétä (9.22) and hear what Lord Kåñëa has to say on this subject:

ananyäç cintayanto mäà
ye janäù paryupäsate
teñäà nityäbhiyuktänäà
yoga-kñemaà vahämy aham

But those who worship Me with devotion, meditating on My transcendental form—to them I carry what they lack and preserve what they have.

It is relevant to mention here how in the Western world one atheistic government tried to induce the innocent citizens to embrace atheistic views. The government sent their propagandists to proselytize the people in the villages. They asked the innocent villagers, "Why do you all go to church? What do you pray to God for?" The villagers simply answered, "God gives us food." The atheists then led the villagers to the church and asked them to pray to God for food. The villagers, of simple faith, began to pray to God. At the end of their prayers, the officials asked them if they had received food or not. Bewildered, the people shook their heads. The atheists then asked the villagers to pray to them for food, which they did. Immediately, with a look of triumph, the atheists brought out baskets of bread. The villagers became happy and thought that the government representatives were more responsive and productive than God.

Alas! If only a devotee of the Lord had been present there, the villagers' devotion would not have been molested. The neophyte devotees' tender devotion is always susceptible to damage. But bread, after all, does came from God, and not from the atheists. If those villagers had been more conversant with the scriptures, the atheists would never have been successful in their evil plan. The simple villagers were illiterate, and hence they had no idea that the Supreme Lord alone can give them food. If the earth did not produce grain, then the atheists, despite their advanced material science, could never make bread or other foods.

Many may claim that in the modern age material scientists have helped increase agricultural yield. But we fearlessly proclaim that it is precisely such atheistic views that have brought the world to the present acute food crisis. If we are not careful, the day will soon come when fruits will be reduced to just skin and seed, cows' udders will dry up, and paddy fields will grow only grass. The scriptures predict that these things will come to pass in the Kali-yuga.

In reality, the Supreme Lord is always protecting us. The inmates of a prison are being punished by the government, yet the same government feeds them and looks after them. Similarly, sinful, atheistic people, though punished by the Lord's illusory energy (mäyä personified as Durgä-devé), are still fed and cared—for by the Lord Himself. And if the Supreme Lord feeds and maintains even the worst sinners, reprobates, and helpless souls, then what to speak of those who are eternally surrendered to His lotus feet? He is like a king who takes proper care of his subjects, but who especially looks after the needs of his near and dear relatives. Therefore it is not true that a comfortable life can be enjoyed only by those who perform ordinary pious activities, but not by the devotees, who are free from fruitive action and empirical knowledge. The devotees do not always suffer, for the Supreme Lord personally takes care of them. The devotees are the Lord's relatives and family members. Just as ordinary people feel joy and satisfaction when they look after the needs and comforts of their family, the Lord also feels pleasure when he tends to the well-being of His devotees. Thus the Supreme Lord is known as Bhakta-vatsala, "the maintainer of the devotees." But He is never referred to as Karmé-vatsala, "the maintainer of fruitive workers," or Jïäné-vatsala, "the maintainer of empiric philosophers."

The devotees of the Lord fully depend on Him for everything, and so whatever they do to maintain themselves and their family is favorable to devotional surrender. Such pure souls are always fixed in devotion, never wasting a moment in activities outside the Lord's service. They are not assailed by materialistic desires, because everything they do is for the Lord's pleasure. Hence they alone are truly peaceful.

The devotee himself arranges for all expenditures incurred in executing devotional service. To an ordinary eye, earning and spending money in this way may look like sense enjoyment. But when the devotee is devoid of all material desires, the Supreme Lord feels great satisfaction in fulfilling all his needs. Though the obedient son may never express his wants to his father, the loving father spontaneously tries to make his son happy and derives joy from doing so. Therefore the Lord's devotees never lack anything, even materially, and at the end of this life, after leaving the body, they are situated in eternal bliss. This is the transcendental wealth a devotee inherits. Others—the fruitive workers, empiric philosophers, demigod-worshippers, and mystic yogés—cannot attain eternal bliss.

Although Lord Kåñëa is equally disposed toward all, He is nonetheless especially concerned about His devotees' well-being. However, one should not conclude that the Lord is nepotistic. As He declares in the Bhagavad-gétä (4.11), ye yathä mäà prapadyante täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham: "All of them—as they surrender unto Me—I reward accordingly." Though the devotees are desireless and undemanding, the Lord always sees to their requirements. The devotees are ever-joyful upon receiving such grace from the Lord, and there is no offence or sin in accepting His benedictions.

Here one may pose a question: "Why do only the devotees of Lord Kåñëa attain to His transcendental abode? After all, the demigods are simply energies of Lord Kåñëa, and the scriptural conclusion is that the energy and the energetic are nondifferent. Therefore, why can't those who worship the demigods, Kåñëa's energies, attain to the transcendental abode of the Lord?"

In reply, let us first refer to what Lord Kåñëa Himself says on this subject in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.23):

ye 'py anya-devatä bhaktä
yajanti çraddhayänvitäù
te 'pi mäm eva kaunteya
yajanty avidhi-pürvakam

Whatever a man may sacrifice to other gods, O son of Kunté, is really meant for Me alone, but it is offered without true understanding.

People worship demigods to fulfill temporary material desires, and the results they achieve from such worship are equally temporary and material. But if one worships the demigods with the knowledge that they are the Supreme Lord's energies, then this worship is accepted as authorized, and gradually such a worshipper becomes a devotee of Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Godhead. But if one worships the demigods with the idea that they are on an equal level with Lord Kåñëa, then such worship is unauthorized, because Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, unequalled and unsurpassed. Therefore no demigod can exist independent of Lord Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa is just like a king, and the demigods are like his ministers. The minister may sit on a throne and manage state affairs, but he is not independent: his powers come from the king.

By virtue of being the Supreme Absolute Truth, Lord Kåñëa is eternally full of knowledge and bliss, beyond this material world. In the material world we often compare one person with another in terms of their position and power, and so we can rightly say that in comparison with human beings, the demigods are very highly placed. But there is no comparison between the Supreme Lord and the demigods, who are simply living entities belonging to the category as humans. Living entities, or jévas, belong to the Lord's marginal potency, which emanates from His transcendental, internal potency. Therefore anyone who considers the demigods to be independent Supreme Gods is speculating and is totally wrong, because as jévas they are invested only with temporary powers and position.

If a highly placed servant in the king's court is mistakenly honored as the king, that does not mean the king becomes the servant and vice versa. Similarly, Lord Kåñëa is the only Supreme Person, and everyone else is His servant. The Brahma-saàhitä clearly explains the relationship between Lord Kåñëa and the demigods. There are numerous proofs that beings who are in the category of viñëu-tattva—supreme personalities on the level of Lord Viñëu—are the highest absolute beings. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam confirms this truth by proclaiming that of all kinds of worship, worship of Lord Viñëu, or Kåñëa, is the most elevated.

In India, the Hindus worship many gods—the sun-god, the moon-god, and so on. But the rituals of worship always begin with the worship of Lord Viñëu, and in the end everything is offered to Lord Viñëu's lotus feet because He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. A brähmaëa, a member of the priestly class, must start every ritual of worship by invoking Lord Viñëu as the Supreme Being; otherwise all his worship and rituals will be rendered useless. This same Lord Viñëu is, in fact, a partial expansion of Lord Kåñëa, who is the ultimate cause of all causes and the original Supreme Lord. Therefore Lord Kåñëa is the receiver of all oblations and sacrifices and is the ultimate benefactor of all worship. As He says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.24),

ahaà hi sarva-yajïänäà
bhoktä ca prabhur eva ca
na tu mäm abhijänanti
tattvenätaç cyavanti te

I am the only enjoyer and the only object of sacrifice. Those who do not recognize My true transcendental nature fall down.

At the time of worshiping the demigods, the reason for placing Lord Näräyaëa, or Kåñëa, on the throne as the supreme enjoyer of the ritual or sacrifice is that the various demigods also worship Him and offer Him sacrifices. Therefore He is the Lord and master of all sacrifices. The Supreme Lord fulfills the desires of the demigod-worshippers through the agency of the demigods, but because the demigod-worshippers are ignorant of the Supreme Lord's transcendental position, their unauthorized demigod-worship leads them to confusion and illusion.

Demigod-worshippers often try to rationalize their worship of the demigods by thinking, "I am a devotee of this demigod, so he will certainly shower his grace upon me and fulfill all my heart's desires. Hence he is indeed the Supreme Lord." But the authorized scriptures condemn such demigod-worshippers and their worship as unethical and philosophically wrong. Such worshippers cannot understand that Kåñëa is the Supreme Lord, the ultimate source of all energies. The demigods are in fact manifestations of the Lord's energies, though to the illusioned demigod worshippers they appear to be the ultimate object of their worship and devotion. Those who persist in this misunderstanding will never attain the Absolute Truth. On the other hand, those who worship the demigods strictly according to scriptural injunctions quickly realize that their object of worship is subordinate to the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. With this realization, their illusion is destroyed and they take shelter of Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet.

RTW 2.11: Offering a Leaf, a Flower, a Fruit, or a Little Water.

Offering a Leaf, a Flower, a Fruit, or a Little Water

One should always keep in mind that it is unnecessary to worship anyone but Lord Kåñëa. Especially in this Age of Kali it is impossible to perform opulent sacrifices and worship. Of late, it has become a popular practise to publicly worship demigods with great pomp. Such worship is conducted whimsically, without following the scriptural rules. It is an excuse for people in the mode of ignorance to engage in base sense enjoyment and fiendish revelry. No ethics are maintained, no arrangements made for sumptuous public feasting, no authorized mantras chanted, no proper offerings made to the deities. These occasions are simply an excuse for wild singing, dancing, and misbehaving. All such worship is unauthorized.

Therefore intelligent people will follow the process of the congregational chanting of the holy names of God and in this way worship Lord Gauräìga who is Kåñëa Himself with a golden complexion. Worshiping Lord Kåñëa is not an expensive affair, and worshiping Lord Caitanya is even easier and less expensive than worshiping Lord Kåñëa. The reason is that the little effort taken to collect a leaf, a flower, a fruit, or some water for the worship of Lord Kåñëa is not even required in Lord Caitanya's worship. But in any case, both the Supreme Lords can be worshiped easily in any country, in any condition, by anyone—be he foolish or wise, sinful or pious, highborn or lowborn, rich or poor. Thus we find Lord Kåñëa saying in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.26),

patraà puñpaà phalaà toyaà
yo me bhaktyä prayacchati
tad ahaà bhakty-upahåtam
açnämi prayatätmanaù

If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit or water, I will accept it.

Once the Supreme Lord is satisfied, the entire world is automatically satisfied, for by worshiping Him, one worships everyone else. Just as an entire tree—branches, leaves, and so on—receives water once the root of the tree is watered, so when the Lord Kåñëa is worshiped and satisfied, then all the demigods and human beings are worshiped and satisfied.

There is no mention anywhere that worship of Lord Kåñëa has to be conducted with large expenditures and pomp. Nor is there any restriction of time, place, or circumstance. Just as everyone has the right to bathe in the Ganges, so everyone has the right to serve Lord Kåñëa. Flowers, fruit, leaves, and water are available everywhere. Even a pauper can arrange to find these four things with very little effort and at no cost. Thus the process of worshiping Lord Kåñëa is so simple that anyone from anywhere can participate.

Lord Kåñëa is unborn, yet He can accept any form imaginable. And because He is the supreme father of every living being, anyone—whether a high-born brähmaëa or a social outcast—can offer Him a flower, a fruit, a leaf, and water with love and devotion. Then Lord Kåñëa, the cause of all causes, will accept this offering, and by such spiritual activity the worshipper becomes eligible to enter His eternal abode. Who could be more foolish than the person who rejects this easy and joyful process and, becoming captivated by the mirage of material existence and craving for temporary mundane facilities, takes shelter of demigods? Recent times have witnessed a concerted and noble effort on all fronts to bring about unity, peace, and harmony in the world, but these are possible only when people worship Lord Kåñëa and render Him devotional service.

Such a proposal is neither preposterous nor comic. In fact, if someone is a sincere seeker of the Absolute Truth, then whatever his present situation may be, by regularly offering the Supreme Lord flowers, fruit, leaves, and water with love and devotion, he will readily experience that the Supreme Absolute Truth, Lord Kåñëa, is gradually coming nearer to him. We humbly request all our readers to kindly try this excellent method of approaching Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet. This method requires no monetary expenditure, physical exertion, philosophical knowledge, or noble birth.

The differences between a demigod-worshipper and a devotee of Lord Kåñëa are wide and numerous. In general, persons approach demigods only out of temporary material desires, whereas the devotees aim to re-establish their eternal loving relationship with the Supreme Lord. To that end the devotees offer Him worship, gifts, and anything they can collect, together with love and devotion, and the Lord accepts all these with relish. Such devotional offerings are free of any cravings for material benefit.

By contrast, the polytheists' offerings, which are laden with selfish motivations for material gain, are never accepted by the Supreme Lord, even if these offerings are opulent and elaborate. The demigod-worshippers have no real love or devotion for the particular demigod they worship, yet Lord Kåñëa is so merciful that He fulfills the material desires of the foolish demigod worshippers.

Lord Kåñëa never accepts any offering bereft of love and devotion. A person who is not hungry cannot suddenly develop an appetite, even if he is given delectable food. Similarly, the Lord has no attraction for opulent offerings made without love and devotion. We have already discussed that unauthorized worship of the Supreme Lord stems from the absence of devotion and the presence of material desire. One who is full of devotion aims to satisfy the Supreme Lord's senses, while one who is full of material desire aims to gratify his own senses. Those who carry in their hearts the desire to gratify themselves but make a show of serving the Supreme Lord will never experience the joys of being a real devotee. The scriptures have aptly described them as mercenaries. Devotion's prime objective is the attainment of God. Therefore, one must offer the Lord everything in one's possession, including the results of karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga, mystic yoga, austerity, meditation, and so on. This perfect process of surrender will lead to the attainment of God. Thus Lord Kåñëa openly proclaims in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.27),

yat karoñi yad açnäsi
yaj juhoñi dadäsi yat
yat tapasyasi kaunteya
tat kuruñva mad-arpaëam

O son of Kunté, all that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you may perform, should be done as an offering unto Me.

If a person follows this injunction and with love offers the Lord everything he has—wife, house, family, intelligence, learning, business, religiosity, labor, food, water, whatever is required to maintain the body, and even lust, greed, and anger—then the Lord accepts these offerings and completely satisfies the offerer. And at the time of death the Lord takes such a surrendered soul to His Supreme abode.

The demigods are empowered to accept only certain types of offerings, whereas Lord Kåñëa can accept the karma-phala, or fruitive results, of everyone. The Supreme Lord alone is powerful enough to accept conflicting fruitive results and moods of worship. This indicates Kåñëa's supreme lordship and absolute position. It is unlikely that all of humanity will be able to understand the science of pure devotional service, yet everyone always has the ability to attain the Lord's lotus feet, even in the face of striking odds. Therefore the best course is to offer everything to the Supreme Lord.

All the points we have discussed regarding niñkäma-karma are mentioned in detail in the scriptures. Paëòitas define niñkäma-karma as "activities free from the desire for fruitive gain or empirical knowledge." Only such transcendental activities can be offered to Lord Kåñëa. But all activities—whether verbal, physical, or mental—are transcendental if offered to the Lord with love and devotion. And He duly receives these offerings by His causeless mercy.

However, at this juncture we must avoid committing a mistake. Our present discussion does not include the materialistic caste brähmaëas' offering of oblations or fruitive work to Lord Näräyaëa. Because such offerings are not devoid of lust, there is no love or devotion in them. We have earlier established that the main criterion for a proper offering to the Lord is that it be done with love and devotion, for the satisfaction of His senses. Hence we must understand that only those things or services offered solely for the pleasure of the Supreme Lord are actually accepted by Him.

Exerting oneself to satisfy one's own hunger is käma-karma, fruitive activity, but to tirelessly toil to feed the Supreme Lord with delicacies is niñkäma-karma, transcendental work aimed at pleasing Him. Pleasing the Lord should be the sole purpose of commerce and trade, and also of research, science, charity, austerity, and all other activities. Such a practice will inspire one to hear and chant transcendental topics related to Lord Kåñëa, and this hearing and chanting are the foremost of the ninefold devotional activities. In Vedic times, all human activities were strongly affiliated with devotional service to the Supreme Lord. Today the same eternal principle applies: everything must be utilized in the Lord's service.

Lord Kåñëa is the supreme enjoyer of all sacrifices. Thus He accepts the fruits of everyone's labor, and by so doing He crowns all His devotees' endeavors with glowing success. Such is the transcendental potency possessed by the omnipotent Lord. We must pay careful heed, however, never to allow the desire for self-aggrandizement or sense gratification to surreptitiously slip into our consciousness while we are performing devotional service. We should simply follow in the footsteps of the previous spiritual masters. In the Lord's presence, everyone is equal. Therefore, whoever serves the Lord with unwavering single-mindedness is listed among His close associates. They are truly "hari-janas," Lord Hari's own men. To rubber-stamp as a hari-jana a person who does not possess the prerequisite—devotional service—is a farce and an onerous hindrance on the path of devotional surrender.

Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.29),

samo 'haà sarva-bhüteñu
na me dveñyo 'sti na priyaù
ye bhajanti tu mäà bhaktyä
mayi te teñu cäpy aham

I envy no one, nor am I partial to anyone. I am equal to all. But whoever renders service unto Me in devotion is a friend, is in Me, and I am also a friend to him.

One must not misunderstand the meaning of the word samaù, "equal." It does not mean that the Lord is impersonal and that He will bless any whimsical act, even unruly behaviour. The Lord is absolutely personal, the reservoir of divine sentiments, the supreme performer of transcendental pastimes. And He is the well-wishing friend of all living beings. But friendship has different degrees of intimacy. Thus the Lord's equal disposition is not without varieties of personalism. In other words, the Lord reciprocates with us according to our intensity of love for Him. In the Gétä (4.11) He says, ye yathä mäà prapadyante täàs tathaiva bhajämy aham: "As all surrender unto Me, I reward them accordingly." He responds to all the different devotional mellows—servitorship, fraternity, parental affection, and conjugal love. Similarly, he ignores those who disrespect Him by regarding Him as an ordinary mortal. Conversely, He always shelters and protects those who accept Him as the Supreme Lord and serve Him with loving devotion, following in the footsteps of past saintly masters.

RTW 2.12: Give Up all Kinds of Religion and Surrender unto Me."

Give Up all Kinds of Religion and Surrender unto Me."

The so-called progressive modern civilization has produced reprobate human beings, whose sins have been accumulating over many lifetimes. Yet if they surrender to Lord Kåñëa, even they will have all their sins eradicated forever. The process of devotional service and remembrance of Lord Kåñëa will gradually dissipate unwanted, base desires from within their hearts. And those hearts, which previously sheltered immoral yearnings will become fully cleansed and auspicious.

The sinful and the destitute can understand their mistakes and misfortune only by Lord Kåñëa's mercy. Once they begin to repent for their sins and surrender to the Lord, they are saved; they become purified and start manifesting saintly characteristics. And if even after a person takes to the devotional process some vestige of immorality remains in his character, that also will soon be eradicated by the Lord's grace. The single-minded devotee who never offends the Supreme Lord or His devotees is to be considered a saintly soul. Even if it seems that such a saint is not yet rid of all sinful propensities, he will never be destroyed, as are the yogés and karmés in a similar situation. This the Supreme Lord Himself has declared.

The Çrémad-Bhägavatam's account of the deliverance of Ajämila conclusively proves this fact. Once undeviating faith in devotional service to Lord Kåñëa penetrates a person's heart, the process of purification is firmly underway, even though his external activities may show residues of sin. Lord Kåñëa has boldly broadcast in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.31) His promise that His surrendered devotees can never be vanquished: kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati. That Lord Kåñëa will always protect His devotees is proved in this verse, especially since the Lord, instead of declaring the promise Himself, asks the valiant prince Arjuna to do so on His behalf. The Lord may break His own promise, but because He is favorable to His devotees, He will always try to uphold their promises. By breaking His own promise and keeping Bhéñmadeva's on the battlefield of Kurukñetra, the Lord has proved beyond a doubt that He favors His surrendered devotees .

A brähmaëa or someone of noble birth endowed with beauty, wealth, and learning may fallaciously conclude that elimination of degraded habits still visible in a devotee can occur only in the case of a brähmaëa like Ajämila. Ajämila was a brähmaëa by birth, but on account of sinful activities caused by bad reactions from his past life, he began performing abominable activities. At the end of his life, however, his remembrance of the Supreme Lord absolved him of all sins. But deliverance is possible for everyone, not just those of high birth. Even the lowest people, who are naturally given to base activities, can reach the spiritual abode of Lord Kåñëa if they simply surrender at His lotus feet. As He says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.32):

mäà hi pärtha vyapäçritya
ye 'pi syuù päpa-yonayaù
striyo vaiçyäs tathä çüdräs
te 'pi yänti paräà gatim

O son of Påthä, those who take shelter in Me, though they be of lower birth—women, vaiçyas [merchants], as well as çüdras [workers]—can approach the supreme destination.

When the lowest of human beings can attain the supreme destination by surrendering to Lord Kåñëa, then what to speak of high-born brähmaëas? Those who follow the path of devotional service to the Supreme Lord are not hounded by caste and colour discrimination. Monotheism—one religion and one creed—is possible only under the shelter of Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet, and not in any other way.

The illusory potency, mäyä, constantly terrorizes and shackles the people in the present Age of Quarrel, Kali-yuga. Due to forgetting their real identity as spirit souls, they bring disaster to the world. Under such a siege, modern-day thinkers and philosophers are desperately trying to bring purity and unity into society. They are conducting in-depth research into this problem. But Lord Kåñëa long ago gave the solution to our modern problems in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.34):

man-manä bhava mad-bhakto
mad-yäjé mäà namaskuru
mäm evaiñyasi yuktvaivam
ätmänaà mat-paräyaëaù

Engage your mind always in thinking of Me, offer obeisances and worship Me. Being completely absorbed in Me, surely you will come to Me.

O people of the world! Please try to translate the Gétä's message into action and channel your thoughts toward Lord Kåñëa's lotus feet. Serve Him with your mind and body. If you dovetail all your energy in the Lord's service, then not only will you feel intense exhilaration in this lifetime, but you will be immersed in eternal bliss in the spiritual world, perpetually serving Him. The most munificent incarnation of Godhead, Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, recently advented in the Age of Kali to propagate this message. By the great fortune of all Bengalis, He appeared in Bengal and blessed the Bengali race. Thus Bengalis can preach His mission and instructions to the entire human race and deliver the people of the planet and themselves. The presentation of this knowledge in a systematic and scientific manner will bring about universal sublime peace. Yet the shocking fact is that thirteen unauthorized cults have mushroomed into prominence and are fast expanding their illegitimate fold with naive disciples. What one fails to comprehend is how the leaders of these cults, who have never accept discipleship and tutelage from any bona fide spiritual master, can suddenly rise to the position of spiritual master themselves. The subject matter that needs to be promulgated among the people is not some cheap, sentimental concoction meant to deceive them; it is in fact a deeply profound and esoteric theology. The words of Lord Caitanya can never be disseminated by unscrupulous self-styled "gurus" who fake spiritual sentiments to impress the ignorant mass of people. All saintly persons beware!

Our general experience is that impersonalists, given as they are to speculation and sophistry, hesitate to accept Lord Kåñëa as the Supreme Godhead. Thus they will always be frustrated in their endeavors to know the Supreme Absolute Truth by dint of their own intelligence. They cannot perceive this shortcoming in themselves, and even if it is pointed out to them by persons who know the science of Kåñëa consciousness, they cannot grasp it. Such polluted consciousness is a result of not surrendering to Lord Kåñëa. The Lord's name, form, qualities, pastimes, and paraphernalia are all transcendental and extraordinary; hence blunt material senses cannot perceive them. The sun becomes visible only by the help of sunlight; similarly, the Supreme Lord reveals Himself only to those engaged in His devotional service.

The facilities available to us in our material condition are many. One facility in the mode of goodness is intelligence, which gives us the ability to distinguish subtle elements and to discriminate between matter and spirit, and in this way to avoid coming under illusion. Also in the mode of goodness are tolerance, truthfulness, control of the senses, equanimity, and other such qualities. Added to the list are qualities in the mode of passion, such as strong desire, fearlessness, and unwavering determination, as well as qualities in the mode of ignorance, such as fear, madness, and distress over birth, death, old age, and disease. All these facilities are products of the Lord's external, material energy. Since mäyä is under the Supreme Lord's control, all the above-mentioned qualities also emanate from Kåñëa Himself. But Lord Kåñëa is beyond the periphery of our sensual experience, and therefore simply cultivating the nobler qualities—those in the mode of goodness—is not sufficient spiritual practice to elevate us to the Lord's lotus feet. The only way to overcome mäyä is to take complete shelter at the Lord's lotus feet. Kåñëa states in the Gétä (7.14) that those who surrender to Him can easily cross beyond mäyä. Once mäyä is surmounted, one's endeavor is crowned with the realization that Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. As Lord Brahmä says in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.1):

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù
sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù
anädir ädir govindaù
sarva-käraëa-käraëam

Kåñëa who is known as Govinda is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal blissful spiritual body. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin and He is the prime cause of all causes.

Only when one is free from the influences of mäyä can one perceive the transcendental opulence, power, fame, beauty, knowledge, and renunciation of the Supreme Lord. With this transcendental realization one can fathom the Supreme Lord's own words in the Bhagavad-gétä (10. 8-10):

I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts. The thoughts of My pure devotees dwell in Me, their lives are surrendered to Me, and they derive great satisfaction and bliss enlightening one another and conversing about Me. To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me."

RTW 2.13: All Perfections Come from Bhakti-yoga

All Perfections Come from Bhakti-yoga

Whatever exists—manifest or unmanifest, material or spiritual—has one primary source: the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. He is the primeval, supreme controller, the cause of all causes, the Lord of all lords. As the Supersoul within the heart, He inspires all the activities of a transcendentally situated devotee. Those who possess true knowledge of the Absolute can render service to Lord Kåñëa in the mood of a servitor, a friend, and so on. Their hearts are always absorbed in thoughts of Lord Kåñëa, and they yearn to perceive and relish His eternal, transcendental pastimes.

By the grace of the Supreme Lord, these unalloyed devotees can unravel the mysteries of His intimate worship. Then, due to their love for the Lord, they find it difficult to maintain their lives without hearing and chanting the glories of the Lord's name, form, qualities, pastimes, associates, and paraphernalia. They seek the association of like-minded devotees, and with them they dive into the ocean of the nectar of devotion. Situated in their spiritual identity, they relish spiritual exchanges and hear, discuss, and remember the all-auspicious topics of Lord Kåñëa's transcendental pastimes, thus practising the ninefold devotional process.

They execute this ninefold devotional service in the stage of sädhana, or practice, and feel deep satisfaction in the perfected, or siddha, stage. They become saturated with the transcendental spiritual mellows of servitorship, friendship, and so on, from which they derive divine ecstasy. Lord Kåñëa grants genuine transcendental understanding, buddhi-yoga, to those devotees who experience spiritual satisfaction and divine bliss through constant devotional service; gradually their specific devotional attitude increases to the point where they can relish pure love of God.

In the stage of bhäva, or spontaneous devotional service in ecstasy, there is a direct transcendental exchange of mellows between Lord Kåñëa and His pure devotee. The Supreme Lord Himself gives His devotee buddhi-yoga, or spiritual intelligence, and the devotee, acting with that intelligence, serves the Lord until he gradually approaches the Lord's supreme abode. Such a devotee can never be affected by ignorance.

The impersonalists and empiric philosophers consider the unalloyed devotees of the Lord sentimental fools, and thus they deride them. This is a big offense. Such offences cause the impersonalists and pseudo-devotees to slowly become demoniac. Having lost good sense and a stable mind, they gradually develop animosity toward the Supreme Lord and find all their life's endeavors reduced to suffering and futility. If one of these deluded demoniac impersonalists comes in contact with a pure devotee and by his mercy regains his lost insight, then he can begin to understand that the pure devotees he offended are exchanging spiritual mellows with Lord Kåñëa and are thus forever free from ignorance and illusion. The impersonalists must understand that the Supreme Lord, acting from within as the Supersoul, removes all ignorance from the devotee's heart. As Lord Kåñëa states in the Bhagavad-gétä (10.11):

teñäm evänukampärtham
aham ajïäna-jaà tamaù
näçayämy ätma-bhäva-stho
jïäna-dépena bhäsvatä

To show them special mercy, I, dwelling in their hearts, destroy with the shining lamp of knowledge the darkness born of ignorance.

The dry speculative philosophers may kindly note onepoint: By using the word teñäm, Lord Kåñëa openly declares that He is always merciful to His surrendered devotees. The reason that the Lord expands Himself as the Supersoul and enters everyone's heart is not to bless the empiric philosophers and yogés but to bless the devotees from within. If the Supreme Lord Himself wishes to enlighten the devotees with spiritual knowledge and gradually draw them closer to Him, then what question is there of such devotees ever coming under the spell of nescience? Rather, it is out of nescience only that the empiric philosophers try to approach the Supreme Truth on the strength of their own intellect. We know that the Supreme Lord can dissipate the darkness of ignorance with the spiritual effulgence emanating from His body. Can the empiricists do the same? One can never lift the gloom of nescience by one's own efforts. Empiricists such as the atheist Kapila, unable to reach enlightenment by their own efforts, feel great relief in trying to explain away the Absolute Truth as unknowable and unmanifest. But great suffering befalls these dry speculators attached to the theory of the unmanifest Absolute, as Lord Kåñëa confirmsin the Bhagavad-gétä (12.5):

kleço 'dhikataras teñäm
avyaktäsakta-cetasäm
avyaktä hi gatir duùkhaà
dehavadbhir aväpyate

For those whose minds are attached to the unmanifested, impersonal feature of the Supreme, advancement is very troublesome. To make progress in that discipline is always difficult for those who are embodied.

The austerities a monist performs are painful both during the initial stage of practice (sädhana) and when he has supposedly reached perfection. The impersonalists suffer excruciating pains trying to establish the oneness of matter and spirit through speculative theories. Thinking that Brahman is impotent, through sophistry they try to equate the Lord's inferior, material energy with His superior, spiritual energy, thus reaping ridicule from truly learned circles. In attempting to prove that the Absolute Truth cannot be the Supreme Personality of Godhead with unlimited energies, they argue that this would mean immutable Brahman is actually mutable. Thus their logic loses all cohesion and they become a laughingstock. In trying to refute the established theory of pariëäma-väda, or the "transformation of energy," they accuse Çréla Vyäsadeva of being mistaken when he says that the material universe and the living entities are all transformations of the Lord's energy and are therefore real, not false. Thus in their philosophical discussions the monists reject the main purport and essence of all Vedic scriptures and their corollaries and hang on to nonessential injunctions, such as tat tvam asi, "You are that." They like to deliberate on these subpoints, but when confronted with the arguments of a learned Vaiñëava, they turn and run from the battlefront.

Without understanding that the Supreme Lord is a transcendental personality, the monists make futile and grossly mundane attempts at restraining their senses, meditating on the Lord's impersonal aspect as the ultimate and original Absolute Truth. As it is impossible to dam a flooding river, so it is impossible to control the senses by meditating on the impersonal Brahman. As the great sage Sanat Kumära says in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (4.22.39):

yat-päda-paìkaja-paläça-viläsa-bhaktyä
karmäçayaà grathitam udgrathayanti santaù
tadvan na rikta-matayo yatayo 'pi ruddha-
sroto-gaëäs tam araëaà bhaja väsudevam

The devotees, who are always engaged in the service of the toes of the lotus feet of the Lord, can easily overcome hard-knotted desires for fruitive activities. Because this is very difficult, the nondevotees—the jïänés and yogés—although trying to stop the waves of sense gratification, cannot do so. Therefore you are advised to engage in the devotional service of Kåñëa, the son of Vasudeva.

Lord Viñëu's impersonal aspect is known as Brahman. So when the jéva soul, a product of Lord Viñëu's superior, spiritual energy, attains säyujya-mukti, or liberation by merging with Brahman, it is not at all surprising. The energetic principle always enjoys the prerogative of enfolding within itself His own energy, but that does not destroy the energy's eternal individuality. The impersonalists, desiring to merge with Brahman and knowing that it is feasible, still experience intense suffering in their effort to reach brahmänanda, "the bliss of Brahman." The Lord's devotees consider the pleasures of such liberation worse than hell. The impersonalists, in trying to destroy the illusion inherent in material forms, do away with even the eternal spiritual forms. That is indeedvery foolish. Treating a patient to cure his disease is one thing, but ending the patient along with the disease is the work of an idiot. Thus we have this instruction from the great authority Brahmä in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.14.4):

çreya-såtià bhaktim udasya te vibho
kliçyanti ye kevala-bodha-labdhaye
teñäm asau kleçala eva çiñyate
nänyad yathä sthüla-tuñävaghätinäm

My dear Lord, devotional service unto You is the best path for self-realization. If one gives up that path and engages in the cultivation of speculative knowledge, he will simply undergo a troublesome process and will not achieve his desired result.As a person who beats an empty husk of wheat cannot get grain, one who simply speculates cannot achieve self-realization. His only gain is trouble.

Instead of becoming an impersonalist and inviting misfortune and misery, the devotee surrenders to Lord Kåñëa and never suffers in this world. When he leaves his present body, he transcends the material platform and becomes eligible to participate in the Lord's eternal pastimes. As the Supersoul, Lord Kåñëa enlightens the devotee from within the heart and disperses the gloom of ignorance. The Lord gives the devotee the spiritual intelligence to attain Him. The ocean of nescience is very difficult to cross, but when the devotee attempts to cross it, the Lord Himself intervenes to help. Alone the devotee would surely drown, but with the Lord's help he easily crosses over. Thus taking shelter of the Lord is the surest way to surmount the ocean of material existence. As Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (12.6-7)

ye tu sarväëi karmäëi
mayi sannyasya mat-paräù
ananyenaiva yogena
mäà dhyäyanta upäsate

teñäm ahaà samuddhartä
måtyu-saàsära-sägarät
bhavämi na cirät pärtha
mayy äveçita-cetasäm

For one who worships Me, giving up all his activities unto Me and being devoted to Me without deviation, engaged in devotional service and always meditating upon Me, who has fixed his mind upon Me, O son of Påthä, for him I am the swift deliverer from the ocean of birth and death.

Those who surrender to Lord Kåñëa, who repose their unflinching faith in the personal form of the Supreme Lord, offer him their mental and physical activities, along with everything else. With unalloyed, single-minded devotion unencumbered by desires for empirical knowledge, fruitive activity, or severe austerities, they worship and meditate on the eternal, beautiful, two-handed form of Lord Kåñëa playing a flute. Such pure devotees, their hearts saturated with love for Kåñëa, quickly and easily transcend the cycle of material existence, for Lord Kåñëa personally helps them. The merciful Lord promises to reciprocate with each one according to his degree of devotion.

The impersonalists are obsessed with the idea that the Supreme Being is impersonal and that the final goal is to merge into that Brahman existence. Naturally the Lord does not object. If a patient wants to end his disease by ending his life, then who will suffer but him? The more intelligent person will surely want to cure his diseasewithout ending his life, and to that end he will strive to regain his original health. Similarly, the soul infected with the material disease should want to return to his pure, original state without annihilating his individual identity. Lord Kåñëa saves such persons from the jaws of the demoniac conception of trying to become one with God. It is suicidal for the spirit soul to attempt to lose his inherent individuality. The happiness the impersonalist experiences by disentangling himself from the knots of material existence is automatically available to the Lord's devotee as a by-product of devotional service. As the Näradéya Puräëa says,

One should not engage in fruitive activity or cultivate knowledge by mental speculation. One who is devoted to the Supreme Lord, Näräyaëa, can attain all the benefits derived from other processes, such as yoga, mental speculation, rituals, sacrifices, and charity. That is the specific benediction of devotional service.

And in the Kåñëa-karëämåta (107), Bilvamaìgala Öhäkura states:

bhaktis tvayi sthiratarä bhagavän yadi syäd
daivena naù phalati divya-kiçora-mürtiù
muktiù svayaà mukulitäïjali sevate 'sàän
dharmärtha-käma-gatayaù samaya-pratikñäù

O Lord! If our devotion to You is undeviating, then Your ever-youthful form will spontaneously manifest within our heart. At that time liberation personified will serve us like a maidservant, and religiosity, economic development, and sense gratification [the other three goals of the Vedas] will humbly await our bidding.

yä vai sädhana-sam pattiù
puruñärtha-catuñöaye
tayä vinä tad äpnoti
naro näräyaëäçrayaù

Even without the usual requirements for achieving the perfection of life, a person will gain that perfection if he is simply a surrendered devotee of Näräyaëa. (Näradiya Puräëa)

RTW 3: Topics of Spiritual Science

Jïäna-Katha
Topics of Spiritual Science

RTW 3.1: Extinguishing the Flames of Material Existence

Extinguishing the Flames of Material Existence

koöi-janme brahma-jïäne yei 'mukti' naya
ei kahe—"nämäbhäse sei 'mukti' haya"

After many millions upon millions of births, when one is complete in absolute knowledge, one still may not attain liberation, yet this man says that one may attain it simply by the awakening of a glimpse of the holy name.(Caitanya-caritämåta, Antya-lélä 3.194)

Çréla Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé's father and uncle—Hiraëya Majumdara and Govardhana Majumdara, respectively—were big landowners of the ancient village of Cändapura at Saptagräma. One of their employees, a brähmaëa by birth named Gopäla Cakravarté, locked the great Vaiñëava saint Çréla Haridäsa Öhäkura in a debate on the scriptures. The brähmaëa was a sheer empiricist, and the Vaiñëava saint was an absolute authority on the chanting of the holy names of God, Kåñëa. The brähmaëa asked Çréla Haridäsa at what stage of realization liberation is attained. Citing many appropriate verses from the scriptures, Çréla Haridäsa explained that just as fear of nocturnal creatures like thieves, ghosts, and hobgoblins evaporates at dawn's first light, so all sins and offences are erased and liberation is attained in the clearing stage of chanting the holy name, called näma-äbhäsa, which comes long before pure chanting. Only a liberated, highly evolved soul can utter the Lord's name purely and thus achieve the highest realization, untainted love of Godhead. The speculative philosopher brähmaëa, who was very much addicted to sophism, could not fathom the saint's instructions and so ended up offending him. The foolish brähmaëa tried to impose his own interpretations on the excellences of the holy name and concluded that Çréla Haridäsa Öhäkura was a mere sentimentalist. He insolently rebuked the saint in public and tried to ridicule his explanations and character.

Argumentative impersonalists fail to grasp that without first properly understanding the science of the Absolute Truth, one cannot possibly develop firm devotion to the Supreme Lord. Hence when a person is seen to be situated on the platform of pure devotional service, it is to be understood that his ignorance has been destroyed. We have discussed this point in some detail in the previous essay, "The Science of Devotion." The empirical philosophers generally put forward the idea that human life is meant for achieving perfect knowledge. To them, knowledge means the ability to discern reality from illusion. By eradicating illusion and establishing that truth and reality are nondifferent from Brahman, they want to merge into the existence of Brahman. This, then, is their definition of perfect knowledge, which they aspire to attain birth after birth. They declare that the highest stage of knowledge is reached when the knower, the knowledge, and the object of knowledge become one entity, which then finally merges into Brahman, attaining liberation. Lord Caitanya has described this state of liberation as bhava-mahädävägni-nirväpanam, "extinguishing the flames of material existence." He cited many verses from the revealed scriptures proving that a pure devotee easily attains this state of liberation by chanting the holy names of God.

Unfortunately, the stubborn impersonalists cannot comprehend that the final spiritual destination, beyond even the four Vedic goals (religiosity, economic development, sense gratification, and liberation) is absolutely pure and transcendental love of Godhead. They mistake the devotees of the Lord for sentimentalists and consider them their philosophical opponents. Besides these out-and-out impersonalists, there is a certain group of devotees that has deviated from the path of pure devotion and fallen prey to pretension. These cheaters actually end up following the impersonalists' path of trying to merge with the Supreme Lord. Such materialistic sentimentalists are not counted among the devotees of the Lord. Like their impersonalist counterparts, they cannot understand the true position of the Supreme Lord's name, form, qualities, pastimes, associates, or paraphernalia, for they wrongly consider these transcendental subjects illusory. They act capriciously and confuse the mass of people.

These materialistic sentimentalists reject the spiritual conclusions of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé and try and take shelter of impersonalism. Yet they miserably lack the scholarship and discipline of the impersonalists. They divorce themselves from the impersonalists' scriptural studies and philosophical discussions, regarding discussions on the scripture as dry speculation and their ignorant, sentimental outbursts as spontaneous devotional fervour.

Some of these pretenders very closely follow in the impersonalists' footsteps and so may be accepted as a deranged offshoot of the impersonalist line. But they are certainly not part of the Vaiñëava discipline followed by those in the line of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé. These pretenders diligently cultivate and exhibit certain mannerisms of devotees, and so the impersonalists reject them from their fold. Thus ostracized by both impersonalists and Vaiñëavas, they form a cult of demented sentimentalists. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé declares that such pretenders create an outrage in spiritual society. As the Brähma-yamäla says,

çruti-småti-puräëädi-
païcarätra-vidhim vimä
aikäntiké harer bhaktir
utpatpayaiva kalpate
[Brs. 1.2.101]

Devotional service of the Lord that ignores the authorized Vedic literatures like the Upaniñads, Puräëas, and the Närada Païcarätra is simply an unnecessary disturbance in society.

To show mercy to such pretenders, impersonalists, empiricists, and fruitive workers, the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, has in the Bhagavad-gétä discussed jïäna-yoga, or yoga through knowledge. I therefore embark upon the same subject in this essay.

Real knowledge means to discriminate between truth and illusion. Jïäna-yoga is the process by which one becomes eternally fixed on the path of transcendental devotional service to the Supreme Lord, who is the source of the Supersoul and Brahman. Jïäna-yoga should never be interpreted to mean the ascending process of enquiry, the inductive method, through which one aims only at separating reality from illusion by gradually rejecting the unreal. It is impossible to attain perfect knowledge without serving the Supreme Lord, who is full with all opulences and potencies, whose bodily luster is the Brahman effulgence, and whose partial expansion is the Supersoul. The brähmaëa Gopäla Cakravarté believed that jïäna, perfect knowledge, is far superior to devotional service of the Lord. But as recorded in the Caitanya-caritämåta (Antya 3.201):

baläi-purohita täre karilä bhartsana
"ghaöa-paöiyä mürkha tumi bhakti käìhä jäna?"

The priest named Balaräma Äcärya chastised Gopäla Cakravarté. "You are a foolish logician," he said. "What do you know about the devotional service of the Lord?"

If one pretends to be a devotee of the Lord but does not understand the difference between dry speculative knowledge and knowledge of the Supreme Absolute Truth, then such a person's devotion borders on impersonalism and is rank with cheap sentimentalism, which is totally against the spiritual teachings of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé. Therefore jïäna-yoga is not speculation or empirical research; nor is it the sudden emotional outbursts of upstarts pretending to be devotees. By practicing genuine jïäna-yoga, even an empirical philosopher will develop a taste for hearing purely spiritual topics from the scriptures. Eventually he will come to understand the Supreme Lord's transcendental position and potency, and ultimately he will relish the Lord's form, which is eternal and full of knowledge and bliss. He will perceive the Lord as the embodiment of all transcendental mellows. And if the pretentious nondevotee sentimentalists, who like to imitate the empiricists, practice genuine jïäna-yoga, then they too will gain an accurate perspective on the Absolute Truth. They will become firmly established in the understanding that the Supreme Lord's form is spiritual and transcendental, and then they will begin to render unflinching devotional service.

In the Caitanya-caritämåta (Ädi 2.117), Çréla Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja advises,

siddhänta baliyä citte nä kara alasa
ihä ha-ite kåñëe läge sudåòha mänasa

A sincere student should not neglect the discussion of such [scriptural] conclusions, considering them controversial, for such discussions strengthen the mind. Thus one's mind becomes attached to Çré Kåñëa.

Through such discussion and inquiry, we become aware that we are jévas, individual souls, upon which our bodies and minds are temporary and illusory impositions. The scriptures refer to the jéva, a product of the Lord's superior, spiritual energy, as the kñetra-jïa, or "knower of the field," while they refer to the temporary, material body and mind as the kñetra, or "field." Just as the jéva is the kñetra-jïa in relation to his individual body and mind, so the Lord is the kñetra-jïa in relation to His vast universal form. As Lord Kåñëa informs us in the Bhagavad-gétä (13.3), kñetra-jïaà cäpi mäà viddhi sarva-kñetreñu bhärata: "O scion of Bharata, you should understand that I am also the knower in all bodies."

Therefore the jéva and and the Supreme Lord are nondifferent in the sense that both are kñetra-jïa, "knowers of the field." But when we look at which kñetra each of them is knowing, the difference between the jéva and the Supreme Lord is seen to be incalculably wide. The Supreme Lord is infinite, while the jéva is infinitesimal. As consciousness, the jéva pervades his body and mind, which he has acquired due to his karma, or fruitive activities. Similarly, the Supreme Lord pervades the entire creation—His universal body—with His consciousness. Though the jéva permeates his body as impersonal consciousness, he is always a person. Similarly, although in His impersonal, all-pervasive feature the Supreme Lord saturates the cosmic manifestation with His consciousness, in His personal feature He remains eternally in Goloka Våndävana performing pastimes. This point is substantiated by the Brahma-saàhitä (5.37): goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhüto. "Although residing always in His abode called Goloka, the Lord is the all-pervading Brahman and the localized Paramätmä as well." And in the Bhagavad-gétä the Lord Himself explains the functions of the field and the knower of the field, and He says that He is present throughout the creation as the knower.

The dry speculators describe the field and its knower according to their own lopsided logic. They say that the body is like a container and that Brahman enters this container like the all-pervasive sky. Once this container is broken—that is, at the time of liberation—the jéva merges back into Brahman, symbolized by the sky. There are many loopholes in this argument. First of all, the jéva is spiritual energy, while the sky is matter. It is wrong to compare a spiritual subject to a material object. This is a typical example of how the impersonal speculators waste their time trying to equate spiritual substance with mundane things. Such empirical exercises can never be termed jïäna-yoga, the path of perfect knowledge. According to the impersonalists, the infinitesimal jéva merges into the infinite Brahman at the time of liberation. But such merging does not affect the infinite in any way. Unfortunately, the impersonalists are oblivious of the tremendous damage such liberation causes to the infinitesimal living entity.

RTW 3.2: Devotion Resides in Perfect Knowledge of the Supreme

Devotion Resides in Perfect Knowledge of the Supreme

If the infinitesimal soul merges his individuality, or inherent personality, with the infinite being, then that individuality is rendered worthless. Those who want to commit spiritual suicide by sacrificing their individuality are a breed by themselves. Such self-destroyers are known as pure monists. On the other hand, those who desire to maintain their individuality are dualists, or personalists.

Once the jéva manifests his original transcendental nature, he is easily liberated from material conditioning, yet even in such an elevated state he does not lose his individual identity as a spirit soul. In fact, in that pure state he engages in the eternal service of the Supreme Lord and relishes the immortal nectar of sublime bliss.

For eons, all over the world, research on the subject of kñetra and kñetra-jïa has been going on. In India the six philosophical schools have extensively discussed this topic, but this discussion has merely been an exercise in logic and sophistry that has led to many differing opinions among the sages. Hence none of these schools has truly practiced jïäna-yoga, the path of perfect knowledge. Only when discussion of kñetra and kñetra-jïa is applied in the Lord's service does the exercise become jïäna-yoga.

The process of jïäna-yoga has been delineated in the Vedänta-sütra, the philosophical essence of the Vedas. The Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, accepts the authority of the Vedänta-sütra and considers the philosophical presentation proper. Up till the present day, every spiritual line, even in the impersonalist school, has based its philosophical authority on the Vedänta-sütra. And the Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the natural and faultless commentary on the Vedänta-sütra. This is Lord Caitanya's opinion.

Learned circles consider a disciplic line bereft of a commentary on the Vedänta-sütra to be unauthorized and useless. Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya's Vedänta commentary, entitled Çäréraka-bhäñya, is the main commentary of the impersonal, monistic school. Among the Vaiñëavas, besides Çrépäda Rämänujäcärya's commentary, Çréla Baladeva Vidyäbhüñaëa's Govinda-bhäñya is the main commentary in the line of Lord Caitanya, known as the Mädhva-Gauòéya-sampradäya.

Those who are keen to engage in deep discussions on the esoteric conclusions of the scriptures should certainly delve into the philosophy of the Vedänta-sütra. The point to be emphasized is that a well-versed Vedänta philosopher is not a philosopher in the line of Çaìkaräcärya but is actually a Vaiñëava spiritual preceptor, a liberated soul.

According to the Vedas and the sages, the five gross elements are earth, water, fire, air, and ether. Material nature is produced from a combination of false ego (ahaìkära), the ingredients of the material energy (mahat-tattva), and the cause of the mahat-tattva (prakåti). There are five knowledge-gathering senses and five working senses. The mind is the internal sense, the sixth knowledge-gathering sense. Form, taste, smell, touch, and sound are the five sense objects.

We have already enumerated these material ingredients in our description of the Säìkhya philosophy of the atheist Kapila. The kñetra, or "field," is the combination of the twenty-four ingredients mentioned above. When these twenty-four ingredients interact the result is the transformation of material nature, which gives rise to the gross material body composed of five gross elements (païca-mahäbhüta), as a result of material desires, hate, enjoyment, lamentation, and so on. The shadow of consciousness in the form of mind and will are transformations of that field.

What will soon be discussed is that the kñetra-jïa is completely different from the kñetra and its transformations. But to properly understand the knowledge concerning the kñetra and the kñetra-jïa, one must first cultivate at least twenty good qualities listed in the Bhagavad-gétä (13.8-12):

Humility, pridelessness, nonviolence, tolerance, simplicity, approaching a bona fide spiritual master, cleanliness, steadiness and self-control; renunciation of the objects of sense gratification, absence of false ego, the perception of the evil of birth, death, old age and disease; nonattachment to children, wife, home and the rest, and evenmindedness amid pleasant and unpleasant events; constant and unalloyed devotion to Me, resorting to solitary places, detachment from the general mass of people; accepting the importance of self-realization, and philosophical search for the Absolute Truth—all these I thus declare to be knowledge, and what is contrary to these is ignorance.

Persons bereft of these qualities are not eligible to discuss spiritual topics. The false logicians mistake the above-mentioned qualities, which are meant to lead the conditioned soul to liberation, for mundane qualities acquired as a result of transformations of the mind, such as lust, anger, and hate. But factually, the above-mentioned qualities represent spiritual knowledge. Even if one accepts the false logicians' argument that the qualities Lord Kåñëa enumerates in the Gétä as prerequisites for absolute knowledge are mental transformations, still we cannot agree that these transformations are equivalent to such qualities as lust, greed, anger, and illusion, which result from gross ignorance. One kind of mental transformation drags the soul down to depravity, whereas the other redeems the soul from doom. Both disease and medicine are products of material nature, yet one pushes a man toward the jaws of death, while the other saves him from destruction. So one must avoid becoming the laughing-stock of society by accepting the foolish theory of yata mata, tata path—"All ways lead to the Truth"—and on this basis professing that the medicine and the disease are one and the same.

There is one quality among the twenty qualities Kåñëa lists that is especially noteworthy, and that is mayi cänanya-yogena bhaktir avyabhicäriëé: "Constant and unalloyed devotion to Me [Kåñëa]." The other qualities are required to cleanse the consciousness. Once the mirror of the mind is purified and the blazing fire of material existence extinguished, constant and unalloyed devotion to Lord Kåñëa begins to appear on the horizon of the heart. The great saintly spiritual master Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkura has sung, "When will my mind become purified and detached from matter? Oh, when in that purified state will I be able to see the transcendental realm of Våndävana?"

It is interesting to note that once constant and unalloyed devotion to Lord Kåñëa blossoms in the heart of a person, the other nineteen qualities automatically manifest in him. As mentioned in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (5.18.12), yasyästi bhaktir bhagavaty akiïcanä sarvair guëais tatra samäsate suräù:

All the demigods and their exalted qualities, such as religion, knowledge and renunciation, become manifest in the body of one who has developed unalloyed devotion for the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Väsudeva.

By patiently collecting ten, twenty, thirty rupees daily, one will someday have a million rupees. But if one comes upon a million rupees all at once, one does not have to endeavor separately to collect ten, twenty, or thirty rupees and waste valuable time. Similarly, when one develops unalloyed devotion to Lord Kåñëa, all the other above-mentioned qualities automatically adorn that person without extra effort. On the other hand, one who leaves aside unalloyed devotion to Lord Kåñëa and tries to cultivate the other nineteen qualities separately may temporarily receive wealth and honor, but he will become unqualified for achieving the highest goal. In the same verse of Çrémad-Bhägavatam mentioned above (5.8.12), Prahläda Mahäräja says, haräv abhaktasya kuto mahad-guëä manorathenäsati dhävato bahiù:

On the other hand, a person devoid of devotional service and engaged in material activities has no good qualities. Even if he is adept at the practice of mystic yoga or the honest endeavor of maintaining his family and relatives, he must be driven by his own mental speculations and must engage in the service of the lord's external energy. How can there be any good qualities in such a man?

It is futile to make an external show of good qualities like humility and nonviolence while disrespecting the Lord's lotus feet and denouncing the process of devotional service. Such so-called good qualities may be of some material value, but ultimately they are useless and temporary. In fact, the nineteen other qualities combine to make a throne from which unalloyed devotion may rule. These qualities are various limbs of the Absolute Truth, and everything outside this absolute knowledge is nescience.

By cultivating these limbs of knowledge, one attains self-realization. In other words, one is elevated from mundane knowledge of the kñetra to spiritual knowledge of the kñetra-jïa. We have previously established that the word kñetra-jïa implies both the living entity and the Supreme Brahman. Sometimes material nature, or prakåti, is referred to as Brahman, the reason being that Brahman is the cause of the material nature. In one sense a cause and its effect are identical. But Lord Kåñëa is the ultimate source of Brahman. The Lord impregnates Brahman in the form of the material nature with the seed of Brahman known as the jéva. As Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä (14.3),

mama yonir mahad brahma
tasmin garbhaà dadhämy aham
sambhavaù sarva-bhütänäà
tato bhavati bhärata

The total material substance, called Brahman, is the source of birth, and it is that Brahman that I impregnate, making possible the births of all living beings, O scion of Bharata.

This verse explains the famous saying sarvaà khalv idaà brahma from the Upaniñads, meaning "Everything is Brahman." In other words, the Supreme Brahman, Lord Kåñëa, is identical with both the jéva and prakåti in that they are all Brahman. Thus in one sense the Vaiñëavas are pure monists. Previously we deliberated upon another verse from the Bhagavad-gétä (9.10):

mayädhyakñeëa prakåtiù
süyate sa-caräcaram
hetunänena kaunteya
jagad viparivartate

This material nature is working under My direction, O son of Kunté, and it is producing all moving and unmoving beings. By its rule this manifestation is created and annihilated again and again.

The Gétä verse under discussion (14.3) gives a clearer understanding of the other verse (9.10).

RTW 3.3: The Mind Is Purified of Its Attachment to Matter

The Mind Is Purified of Its Attachment to Matter

To shed more light on the meaning of the Upaniñadic aphorism sarvaà khalv idaà brahma, we cite a verse from the Viñëu Puräëa (1.22.56):

eka-deça-sthitasyägner
jyotsnä vistäriné yathä
parasya brahmaëaù çaktis
tathedam akhilaà jagat

A fire radiates light all around although remaining in one spot. Similarly, the Supreme Brahman radiates energy everywhere, which is manifested as this material world.

In their philosophical discussions the Mäyävädés deny the existence of the Supreme Lord's multifarious energies. Such sub-standard debates are indeed on the kindergarten level. According to Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura, the Mäyävädés have a poor fund of knowledge and are thus prevented from understanding that the Supreme Brahman is full with six opulences. To save these poor Mäyävädé impersonalists from philosophical impoverishment, Lord Kåñëa has mercifully instructed them in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.19),

bahünäà janmanäm ante
jïänavän mäà prapadyate
väsudevaù sarvam iti
sa mahätmä su-durlabhaù

After many births and deaths, he who is actually in knowledge surrenders unto Me, knowing Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare.

As the saying goes, "A tethered cow goes as far as the rope." Similarly, one who uses the inductive method to search for ultimate knowledge will fail. His attempt is futile because one cannot know the supramundane with a mundane mind. Complete comprehension of the Absolute Truth is impossible with an unholy, demoniac mind. When one is possessed of a demoniac mentality that tries to reduce the supremely omnipotent Personality of Godhead to impersonal Brahman, all so-called philosophical debates will fail to discover the realm of absolute knowledge or the truth about the nondual substance. Vaiñëavas alone are eligible to cultivate such knowledge.

Of course, not all impersonalists are demoniac. As soon as an impersonalist realizes that the Absolute Truth is a person endowed with all transcendental qualities, he immediately begins to serve Him. This is confirmed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.7.10) which states,

ätmärämäç ca munayo
nirgranthä apy urukrame
kurvanty ahaitukéà bhaktim
ittham-bhüto-guëo hariù

All different varieties of ätmärämas [those who take pleasure in the ätmä, or spirit self], especially those established on the path of self-realization, though freed from all kinds of material bondage, desire to render unalloyed devotional service unto the Personality of Godhead. This means that the Lord possesses transcendental qualities and therefore can attract everyone, including liberated souls.

It is rare to find that great soul who is attracted by the Lord's transcendental qualities and thus surrenders to Him. The only person who can surrender to the Supreme Lord is one who does not attempt to rob Him of His personality but who views the material nature as a transformation of His multifarious energies. Thus the Mäyävädés can never be called mahätmäs, or "great souls." Only when they realize that the nondual Absolute Truth is none other than the Supreme Personality of Godhead, full with six opulences, can they be called mahätmäs.

Vaiñëava mahätmäs have explained the aphorism sarvaà khalv idaà brahma in this manner: The philosophical school known as Viçiñöädvaita propounds the idea that the Supreme Lord eternally exists with His two principal potencies: the cit-çakti, or spiritual potency, and the acit-çakti, or material potency. Though the Lord is one nondual entity, He exists dynamically, manifesting His multifarious energies under the main headings of the cit and acit potencies, which He absolutely controls. Although He is the source of unlimited potencies, He eternally exists in His transcendental, personal form. This form manifests in three aspects, namely, as He sees Himself, as a loving devotee sees Him, and as He is seen by His competitors and enemies. The Çré Vaiñëava disciplic succession, headed by Çré Rämänujäcärya, cites the same text we have cited above to explain the situation of the Lord and His energies:

A fire radiates light all around although remaining in one spot. Similarly, the Supreme Brahman radiates energy everywhere, which is manifested as this material world.

Thus the entire creation is proof of the existence of the Lord. One who is in complete knowledge understands that the Absolute Truth is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who exists eternally as the source and controller of all energies. The mahätmäs fully realize this knowledge, and having taken shelter of the Lord's transcendental energy (cit-çakti), they eternally render loving devotional service to Him. Lord Kåñëa confirms this in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.13-14):

mahätmänas tu mäà pärtha
daivéà prakåtim äçritäù
bhajanty ananya-manaso
jïätvä bhütädim avyayam

satataà kértayanto mäà
yatantaç ca dåòha-vratäù
namasyantaç ca mäà bhaktyä
nitya-yuktä upäsate

O son of Påthä, those who are not deluded, the great souls, are under the protection of the divine nature. They are fully engaged in devotional service because they know Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, original and inexhaustible. Always chanting My glories, endeavoring with great determination, bowing down before Me, these great souls perpetually worship Me with devotion.

The mental speculators and logicians, as well as the Mäyävädés—who are neophytes depending on the empirical, inductive process—should properly understand the position of the pure devotees of the Lord, who have realized the Absolute truth. In the Bhagavad-gétä (4.23) Lord Kåñëa gives this explanation of the activities of the devotees:

gata-saìgasya muktasya
jïänävasthita-cetasaù
yajïäyäcarataù karma
samagraà praviléyate

The work of a man who is unattached to the modes of material nature and who is fully situated in transcendental knowledge merges entirely into transcendence.

The activities of performed as sacrifices are all devotional service. The Sanskrit word yajïa means "sacrifice," but it can also mean Lord Viñëu Himself. To perform one's activities as transcendental devotional service is possible only for those advanced souls who are fully situated in the Absolute Truth. Again, Kåñëa describes His devotees in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.17):

teñäà jïäné nitya-yukta
eka-bhaktir viçiñyate
priyo hi jïänino 'tyartham
ahaà sa ca mama priyaù

Of these, the wise one who is in full knowledge in union with Me through pure devotional service is the best. For I am very dear to him, and he is dear to Me.

If an impersonalist philosopher, due to some piety, engages in devotional service to the Supreme Lord, then only does he become dear to the Lord. But as long as the impersonalists try to rob the Supreme Lord of His divine potencies, they can never be dear to Him, nor can they be called mahätmäs. They will continue to be counted among the demoniac atheists deluded by the Lord's illusory potency. These atheists are not wise men: they are simply ordinary mortals who are offenders against the Lord.

Wherever the word jïäna appears in the Vedic literature, it should be understood to mean sambandha-jïäna, knowledge of the relationship between the Lord and His energies. It does not refer to the impersonalist concept of the Supreme. After a person understands sambandha-jïäna, he comes to the stage of abhidheya-jïäna, knowledge of how to act in his relationship with the Supreme Lord. This is devotional service, practiced by liberated souls. The mature stage of abhidheya-jïäna leads one to love of Godhead, the ultimate goal of all living entities.

It is the general opinion that among modern-day spiritualists who have tried to know the Supreme through their own puny efforts, Çré Aurobindo has attained some degree of realization. The reason for his success, it is claimed, is that the object of his search was not material knowledge. The Mäyävädés attempt to know the oneness of everything, but their search takes them only up to realization of the impersonal, nondual Brahman. They do not know that becoming free from disease is not perfection, that after the diseased material condition comes the healthy state of spiritual existence, wherein a liberated soul is still an individual with personality. This fact is incomprehensible to them.

Çré Aurobindo rose beyond this limited sphere of thinking and talked about "supramental consciousness" in such books as Life Divine. We consider this book a hazy attempt to present the Supreme Lord's transcendental potencies. He accepted that the Supreme Lord is endowed with transcendental potency, and therefore we have some appreciation for him, but we feel that many persons cannot understand Çré Aurobindo's explanation of transcendence in his books. Although he uses fairly simple English, the reader remains puzzled. Those who are unacquainted with such Vaiñëava philosophies as Viçiñöädvaita, Çuddhädvaita, Dvaitädvaita, and finally Lord Caitanya's acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva, cannot understand Çré Aurobindo. And those who are learned only in impersonal philosophy, who are searching for the nondual Brahman, have even less access to Çré Aurobindo's works.

Much of Çré Aurobindo's stream of thinking has been borrowed from Vaiñëava philosophy. In Light on Yoga and in an essay entitled "The Goal," we find the following passages:

In order to get dynamic realization, it is not enough to rescue the Puruña from the subjugation of Prakåti. One must transfer the allegiance of the Puruña from the lower Prakåti, with its play of ignorant forces, to the supreme Divine Çakti—the Mother.

It is a mistake to identify the Mother with the lower Prakåti and its mechanism of forces. Prakåti here is a mechanism only, which has been formed for the evolution of ignorance. As the ignorant mental, vital, or physical being is not itself the Divine, although it comes from the Divine, so the mechanism of Prakåti is not the Divine Mother. No doubt something of her is there in and behind this mechanism, maintaining it for the evolutionary purpose, but she in herself is not the Çakti of Avidya but the Divine consciousness, the Power, Light, and Para-prakåti, to whom we turn for release and divine fulfillment...

If the supermind could not give us a greater and more complete truth than any of the lower planes, it would not be worthwhile trying to reach it. Each plane has its own truth. Some of these truths are no longer needed as we rise to higher planes. For example, desire and ego are truths of the mental, vital, and physical plane, as a man on that plane without ego or desire would be a mere automaton. As we rise higher, ego and desire appear no longer as truths: they are falsehoods disfiguring the true person and the true will. The struggle between the powers of light and the powers of darkness is a truth here, but it becomes less and less of a truth as one rises higher, and in the supermind it has no truth at all. Other truths remain, but change their character, importance, and place in the whole. The contrast between the Personal and the Impersonal is a truth of the overmind; there is no separate truth of them in the supermind: they are inseparably one. But one who has not mastered the lower planes cannot reach the supramental truth. The incompetent pride of man's mind makes a sharp distinction and wants to call all else untruth and leap at once to the highest truth,whatever it may be. But that is an ambitious and arrogant error. One has to climb the stairs and rest ones feet firmly on each step in order to reach the summit.

If one is serious about the real meaning of life, then simple endeavoring to escape the crippling clutches of mäyä is not the only undertaking. The ultimate goal is to liberate ourselves from the enthrallment of the illusory energy and become wholly subservient to the transcendental, spiritual energy.

In the Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 20.108-09, 111, 117-8, 120, and 122), Lord Caitanya gives some illuminating advice to Sanätana Gosvämé:

It is the living entity's constitutional position to be an eternal servant of Kåñëa because he is the marginal energy of Kåñëa and a manifestation simultaneously one with and different from the Lord, like a molecular particle of sunshine or fire.

Lord Kåñëa naturally has three energetic transformations, and these are known as the spiritual potency, the living entity potency, and the illusory potency... Forgetting Kåñëa, the living entity has been attracted by the external feature from time immemorial. Therefore the illusory energy (mäyä) gives him all kinds of misery in his material existence. In the material condition, the living entity is sometimes raised to higher planetary systems and material prosperity and sometimes drowned in a hellish situation. His state is exactly that of a criminal whom a king punishes by submerging him in water and then raising him again from the water.... If the conditioned soul becomes Kåñëa conscious by the mercy of saintly persons who voluntarily preach scriptural injunctions and help him to become Kåñëa conscious, the conditioned soul is liberated from the clutches of mäyä, who gives him up. The conditioned soul cannot revive his Kåñëa consciousness by his own effort. But out of causeless mercy, Lord Kåñëa compiled the Vedic literature and its supplements, the Puräëas.

RTW 3.4: Constitutionally, the Jéva is an Eternal Servant of Kåñëa

Constitutionally, the Jéva is an Eternal Servant of Kåñëa

The profound esoteric conclusions Lord Caitanya revealed in a few aphorisms of instruction to Çré Sanätana Gosvämé are only partially discussed in all the works of Çré Aurobindo. In language full of complex syntax and obscure terms, Çré Aurobindo tries to express the knowledge that is easily available through the practice of vaidhi-bhakti, devotional service rendered according to regulations given by the authorized spiritual master and the scriptures. Because of his high-flown literary style, and for other technical reasons, Çré Aurobindo's writings are not easily understood by the ordinary reading public, and so his literature is, in a sense, ineffectual.

Lord Caitanya discusses in detail the jéva's eternal constitutional position as Lord Kåñëa's servant, and how the jéva is put into illusion, or mäyä, when he tries to be the supreme enjoyer. Lord Caitanya further explains that when the jéva forgets his eternal position as a servant of Lord Kåñëa, he becomes eternally conditioned and illusioned. Thus mäyä inflicts the miseries of material life upon the jéva. If a person artificially tries to be something he is not, then he can expect only misery. In this regard we recall a short story we read as a child in school that tells of a crow who tried to become a peacock. The creator and master of this universe is its rightful owner as well. Thus He is the sole enjoyer of everything. But if one among the creator's many servants tries to usurp His position and play the role of the Lord and enjoyer, how can he expect anything but suffering?

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.87.30), one of the four Kumäras, Sanandana, recites to an assembly of sages in Janaloka the prayers the personified Vedas previously recited to the Supreme Lord. One of the prayers is as follows:

aparimitä dhruväs tanu-bhåto yadi sarva-gatäs
tarhi na çäsyateti niyamo dhruva netarathä
ajani ca yan-mayaà tad avimucya niyantå bhavet
samam anujänatäà yad amataà mata-duñöatayä

If the countless living entities were all-pervading and possessed forms that never changed, You could not possibly be their absolute ruler, O immutable one. But since they are Your localized expansions and their forms are subject to change, You do control them. Indeed, that which supplies the ingredients for the generation of something is necessarily its controller because a product never exists apart from its ingredient cause. It is simply illusion for someone to think that he knows the Supreme Lord, who is equally present in each of His expansions, since whatever knowledge one gains by material means must be imperfect.

The last word in knowledge is certainly not self-realization or Brahman realization. There is more to realize—namely, that the jéva is the eternal servant of Lord Kåñëa. This realization is the awakening of supramental consciousness, and the activities a jéva performs in such consciousness are the beginning of his eternal life. When the jéva performs all his activities under the direction of the Lord's internal, spiritual energy, he enjoys eternal transcendental bliss, which is a billion times greater than the happiness of Brahman realization. The difference in transcendental joy between the two is like the difference between the vast ocean and the water collected in a calf's hoofprint. When Çré Aurobindo wrote of "the Divine Mother," he was likely referring to this internal, spiritual energy, the predominating Deity of eternal transcendental bliss. He also pointed out that the activities of the inferior, material energy should not be mistaken for those of this spiritual potency. Once the famous impersonalist and monist sannyäsé Ramana Maharshi of Madras was asked by a foreign disciple, "What is the difference between God and man?" His cryptic reply was "God plus desire equals man, and man minus desire equals God." We say that man can never be free of desire. In his eternal conditioned existence the jéva is full of the desire to enjoy matter, while in his eternal liberated state he is full of the desire to render devotional service to the Lord. Thus the jéva can never become God. It is sheer insanity to equate man with God, or vice versa. The Mäyävädé's unnatural desire to deny the inherent characteristics of his conscious self is the very same desire that keeps him from attaining liberation. Hence the Mäyävädés' false and arrogant claim of liberation is merely a demonstration of their perverted intelligence.

According to the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, desire can never be nullified. While conditioned, the jéva is a repository of unlimited material desires, summarized as the catur-varga, the four goals of human life enunciated in the Vedic literature (religiosity, economic development, sense gratification, and liberation). However, in the liberated state produced by acting under the direction of the Lord's internal, spiritual energy, the jéva's true, spiritual desires become manifest. Çré Aurobindo has discussed this subject (though not in detail), and for this we appreciate him more than Ramana Maharshi. Ramana Maharshi has more or less tried to completely choke the life out of desire. This forcible elimination of desire is spiritual suicide. There is no credit in finishing off the patient without curing his disease; the doctor is qualified when he can cure the disease and save the patient. Those who pursue the four Vedic goals mentioned above, even up to impersonal liberation, find themselves imprisoned by their senses and enslaved by their desires. On the other hand, one who can teach people how to engage their daily activities in the service of the Supreme Lord is the real benefactor of humanity.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (9.4) Lord Kåñëa says:

mayä tatam idaà sarvaà
jagad avyakta-mürtinä
mat-sthäni sarva-bhütäni
na cähaà teñv avasthitaù

By Me, in My unmanifested form, this entire universe is pervaded. All beings are in Me, but I am not in Them.

In His unmanifested impersonal form Lord Kåñëa pervades this entire universe, which is a transformation of His external energy. Therefore all living entities in the material creation rest on His energies. Energy cannot exist by itself, without an energetic source. Thus the materialenergy and the Supreme Energetic, Lord Kåñëa, are in principle one, though the Energetic is far removed from the workings of His energy. The jéva, being marginal, is moved by desire to serve either the manifestation of the Lord's external energy—this physical world—or the Lord Himself in spiritual world, which is an expansion of His superior, internal potency. In other words, in every situation the jéva maintains his constitutional position as a servant. Thus he cannot relieve the suffering he undergoes as a servant of this material nature by artificially giving up his desire to serve. Inherently a servant, the jéva can never forsake his desire to serve. But if he so desires, he can quit his bad service for a good one. He should abandon his service of the four Vedic goals, including impersonal liberation—which will altogether throttle the life out of his desire to serve—and carefully try to manifest his original spiritual desire to serve the Lord. Çré Aurobindo has discussed this same point in the passage quoted above:

If the supermind could not give us a greater and more complete truth than any of the lower planes, it would not be worthwhile trying to reach it.

If a human being tries to exist without ego, desire, feelings, dislikes, and so on, he will be converted into inert matter. This is not spiritual elevation. When a person gradually progresses from materialistic perception to spiritual perception, he can clearly understand how trivial are his mundane desires, feelings, dislikes, and so on which were so long contaminated by ignorance. As this ignorance dissipates, mundane desires become insignificant. Desires remain, but they are no longer mundane. They become transcendental. In that state, one perceives Brahman, the Supersoul, and the Supreme Lord as one. Such higher perceptions are possible only when one's mind and senses are transcendental, a stage impossible to reach in one leap. Those who try the impossible are irrational and overambitious. Everyone has to proceed gradually, placing each step securely before taking the next one. In this way one will ultimately reach the goal.

In his essay entitled "Yoga," Çré Aurobindo does not recommend destroying desire but rather changing its character. It is a perennial truth that the jéva is by nature an eternal servant of Lord Kåñëa. The jéva has no other identity, whether he is conditioned or liberated. His position is similar to that of a citizen of a country: he is always subject to the government laws, whether he is in or out of jail. When he is inside the jail, all his activities are painful, but as a free citizen he feels content in everything he does. It is merely a matter of changing his character.

Similarly, even when the jéva refuses to serve the Supreme Energetic, Çré Kåñëa, and instead serves His illusory energy, mäyä, he remains a servant of the Lord. But in that condition he is ignorant of the bliss of devotional service to the Lord. Only when the jéva casts away his mundane characteristicscan he experience transcendental joy in devotional service. Still, in no situation does the jéva ever give up his inherent nature as Kåñëa's eternal servant, for he emanates from the Lord's marginal potency.

RTW 3.5: The Means to Liberation

The Means to Liberation

Nowhere do the Vedic scriptures say that one has to annihilate desire in order to comprehend the Upaniñadic statement sarvaà khalv idaà brahma. But there are many statements recommending that the character of desire should be transformed. It is because of the force of desire that all activities in the world are carried out, and in the Bhagavad-gétä (10.4-11) Lord Kåñëa discusses the multifarious ways in which desire influences these activities:

Intelligence, knowledge, freedom from doubt and delusion, forgiveness, truthfulness, self-control and calmness, pleasure and pain, birth, death, fear, fearlessness, nonviolence, equanimity, satisfaction, austerity, charity, fame and infamy are created by Me alone.

The seven great sages and before them the four other great sages and the Manus [progenitors of mankind] are born out of My mind, and all creatures in these planets descend from them.

He who knows in truth this glory and power of Mine engages in unalloyed devotional service; of this there is no doubt.

I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts. The thoughts of My pure devotees dwell in Me, their lives are surrendered to Me, and they derive great satisfaction and bliss enlightening one another and conversing about Me. To those who are constantly devoted to serving Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me. Out of compassion for them, I, dwelling in their hearts, destroy with the shining lamp of knowledge the darkness born of ignorance.

Those who understand that the multifarious human desires are a reflection of the Supreme Brahman's desires are careful not to discard them but to use them in the Lord's service. Long ago, the seven great sages and the Manus all used their God-given desires in the Lord's service, and anyone today who emulates the example of these illustrious ancestors will never see desire as mundane or as an impediment to spiritual progress. IfRamana Mahärñi advises us to negate desire, then we must conclude that he misunderstands the Vedic statement sarvaà khalv idaà brahma. Those who have realized that all desires and feelings are Brahman by nature, and who thus engage them in the Supreme Lord's service, should be considered perfected souls. They are totally free from nescience. The desires of these self-realized, elevated, blissful devotees become purified to such an extent that not an iota of ignorance can influence their consciousness, for the Lord Himself destroys the nescience in their hearts.

The Mäyävädés are hard pressed to understand that there is a wide gulf of difference between their individual efforts to nullify nescience and the Supreme Lord's mercifully enlightening His devotees. The Mäyävädés are always eager to deny the Supreme Energetic His potencies. They are no better than demons like Rävaëa, who tried to usurp the Lord's potency, and Kaàsa, who tried to kill Him outright. This sort of behavior is expected of demons. Aspiring for evil powers, they abandon devotional service to the Lord and take to sinful activities. In this way they forfeit all knowledge.Lord Kåñëa aptly describes them in the Gétä (7.15) as mäyayäpahåta-jïänä, "those whose knowledge is stolen by illusion." Many, many philosophers, scholars, and so-called invincible heroes have tried to make the Supreme Lord impotent, formless, and impersonal, but in the end they always suffered terribly.

Thus in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.14.4) we find this statement by Lord Brahmä:

çreyaù-såtià bhaktim udasya te vibho
kliçyanti ye kevala-bodha-labdhaye
teñäm asau kleçala eva çiñyate
nänyad yathä sthüla-tuñävaghätinäm

My dear Lord, devotional service unto You is the best path for self-realization. If someone gives up that path and engages in the cultivation of speculative knowledge, he will simply undergo a troublesome process and will not achieve his desired result. As a person who beats an empty husk of wheat cannot get grain, one who simply speculates cannot achieve self-realization. His only gain is trouble.

Where can one see qualities such as intelligence, knowledge, freedom from doubt, joy, sorrow, fear, fearlessness, nonviolence, equanimity, contentment, austerity, charity, fame, and infamy? These qualities are indicative of consciousness, so they are present wherever consciousness is present. The Supreme Lord has declared that these qualities are His, that they have sprung from Him. And the Kaöha Upaniñad [2.2.13] states, nityo nityänäà cetanaç cetanänäm eko bahünäà yo vidadhäti kämän: "Among all the eternal, conscious living entities, there is one supreme conscious being who supplies all others with their necessities." Therefore, to deny that these qualities are inherent in all conscious beings, and in this way to equate both the minute living entities and the Supreme Soul with dead matter, results in complete confusion and certainly demonstrates a severe lack of insight. The Mäyävädés are confused as to whether refuting the existence of consciousness or accepting it will give them contentment. The conscious beings always control inert matter. A simple example proves this point: we see how a puny conscious being like a crow defecates fearlessly on the head of a stone statue of some hero, thus demonstrating the conquest of dynamic spirit over dead matter. Only those with stonelike intelligence will try to make the supreme conscious being into an unfeeling, formless object. Such an attempt is utter foolishness.

Çré Aurobindo has accomplished something commendable by presenting today's learned circles with a "new" concept: instead of trying to deny the inherent qualities of consciousness, one should transform one's mundane consciousness into supramental consciousness by engaging in service of the Supreme Lord under the direction of His divine potency. Of course, those who prefer to emulate the modern philosophers rather than the realized souls of bygone ages will find Çré Aurobindo's presentation novel. But those who follow in the footsteps of pure, loving devotees of the Lord linked to an authorized disciplic succession know that Çré Aurobindo's words echo the annals of age—old wisdom. Indeed, they sound close to the essence of the Vedas.

The Six Gosvämés of Våndävana excavated this extraordinary esoteric essence of the Vedas and described the workings of the internal potency of the Lord. Before the advent of Lord Caitanya, subjects of this nature had never been discussed in such detail by any spiritual authority. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, in his play Vidagdha-mädhava [1.2], glorifies Lord Caitanya's unique contribution to mankind:

anarpita-caréà cirät karuëayävatérëaù kalau
samarpayitum unnatojjvala-rasäà sva-bhakti-çréyam
hariù puraöa-sundara-dyuti-kadamba-sandépitaù
sadä hådaya-kandare sphuratu vaù çacé-nandanaù

May that Lord who is known as the son of Çrématé Çacédevé be transcendentally situated in the innermost core of your heart. Resplendent with the radiance of molten gold, He has descended in the Age of Kali by His causeless mercy to bestow what no incarnation has ever offered before: the most elevated mellow of devotional service, the mellow of conjugal love.

In an essay entitled "Surrender and Opening," Çré Aurobindo writes:

The whole principle of this yoga is to give oneself entirely to the Divine alone and to nobody and nothing else, and to bring down to ourselves, by union with the Divine Mother, all transcendent light, power, breadth, place, purity, truth, consciousness, and Ananda of the Supramental Divine.

Rädhä is the personification of absolute love for the Divine, total and integral in all parts of Her being, from the highest spiritual to the physical, bringing the absolute self-going and total consecration of all being and calling down into the body and the most material nature the supreme Ananda.

Although there are disparities in conclusions in the above statements, still on his own Çré Aurobindo has pointed in the right direction. It is impossible to comprehend the conjugal mellow, which is the most elevated and brilliant of spiritual mellows, without the mood of surrender. The Mäyävädés are totally bereft of this attitude of surrender; hence when they try to understand the nondual concept on their own, they end up becoming impersonalists. Let us read what Çré Aurobindo has to say about these Mäyävädés:

To seek after the impersonal is the way of those who want to withdraw from life. Usually such impersonalists try by their own effort and not by opening themselves to the superior power, or by the way of surrender, for the impersonal is not something that guides or helps but something to be attained, and it leaves each man to attain it according to the way and capacity of his nature. On the other hand, by opening and surrendering to the Mother, one can realize the Impersonal and every other aspect of truth also.

The Mäyävädés are never successful in their efforts to attain liberation on their own merit. The only way to conquer illusion and achieve liberation is to surrender to the Supreme Lord, who is complete with six absolute opulences. As Lord Kåñëa clearly states in the Gétä (7.14), mäm eva ye prapadyante mäyäm etän taranti te: "Those who surrender unto Me can easily cross beyond it [the modes of material nature]."

The first step in learning the process of surrendering to the Lord is to surrender to the pure devotee of the Lord. In the Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 20.120 and 122), we find this statement:

sädhu-çästra-kåpäya yadi kåñëonmukha haya
sei jéva nistare, mäyä tähäre chäòaya
mäyä-mugdha jévera nähi svataù kåñëa-jïäna
jévere kåpäya kailä kåñëa veda-puräëa

If the conditioned soul becomes Kåñëa conscious by the mercy of saintly persons who voluntarily preach scriptural injunctions, he is liberated from the clutches of Mäyä, who gives him up. The conditioned soul cannot revive his Kåñëa consciousness by his own effort. But out of causeless mercy, Lord Kåñëa compiled the Vedic literature and its supplements, the Puräëas.

All the Vedas and Puräëas deal with the subject of Lord Kåñëa. In the Lord's own words in the Bhagavad-gétä (15.15), vedaiç ca sarvair aham eva vedyo: "By all the Vedas, I am to be known."

RTW 4: The Deluded Thinkers

Muni-gaëera Matibram
The Deluded Thinkers

RTW 4.1: The Fundamental Question Evades the Erudite Scholar.

The Fundamental Question Evades the Erudite Scholar

In the First Canto of Çrémad-Bhägavatam, in the very first verse of the first chapter, the highest truth has been propounded in these words:

janmädy asya yato 'nvayäd itarataç cärtheñv abhijïaù svaräö
tene brahma hådä ya ädi-kavaye muhyanti yat sürayaù
tejo-väri-mådäà yathä vinimayo yatra tri-sargo 'måñä
[Bhäg. 1.1.1]

I meditate upon Lord Çré Kåñëa because He is the Absolute Truth and the primeval cause of all causes of the creation, sustenance, and destruction of the manifested universes. He is directly and indirectly conscious of all manifestations, and He is independent because there is no other cause beyond Him. It is He only who first imparted the Vedic knowledge unto the heart of Brahmäjé, the original living being. By Him even the great sages and demigods are placed into illusion, as one is bewildered by the illusory representations of water seen in fire, or land seen on water. Only because of Him do the material universes, temporarily manifested by the reactions of the three modes of nature, appear factual, although they are unreal. I therefore meditate upon Him, Lord Çré Kåñëa, who is eternally existent in the transcendental abode, which is forever free from the illusory representations of the material world. I meditate upon Him, for He is the Absolute Truth.

After defining the Absolute Truth and expanding upon it in the Vedas, Puräëas, and vast corollary literatures, Çréla Vyäsadeva still felt discontented. His spiritual master, Devarñi Närada, finding his disciple so dejected, inspired him to go inwards, into in deep meditation. In that state he perceived the highest Absolute Truth, who is free from the slightest illusion. The verse quoted above reflects Çréla Vyäsadeva's spiritual perception. Närada instructed his disciple to reveal the nature of the Supreme Lord's transcendental name, form, qualities, pastimes, paraphernalia, and associates. The result of Çréla Vyäsadeva's efforts is the spotless Puräëa, Çrémad-Bhägavatam.

Çréla Vyäsadeva went to Badarikäçrama, and in the nearby place called Çamyäpräsa, went into samädhi and saw the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He also saw mäyä, the divine potency of the Lord that deludes the conditioned souls. In this realized consciousness Çréla Vyäsadeva described the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, as fully independent and transcendental. This implies that there is no one superior to Him or equal to Him. In the material world Lord Brahmä is accepted as the highest personality among the living entities. But even Lord Brahmä, who is described here as the ädi-kavi, the original intelligent being, is subservient to the fully independent Supreme Lord. Indeed, it was the Supreme Lord who first imparted the Vedic knowledge unto Lord Brahmä.

What to speak of the ordinary mortals, even great sages and powerful demigods become totally bewildered in their efforts to know the Supreme Lord. The purport of the word dhémahi—"I meditate upon"—is that only those who have perfected the chanting of the Gäyatré mantra can understand the supremely independent Lord. Who is eligible to chant the Gäyatré mantra? Those who are controlled by the modes of ignorance and passion can never chant the Gäyatré mantra, what to speak of attaining perfection in chanting it. Only those who possess the qualities of a brähmaëa and are situated in the mode of goodness are eligible to chant the Gäyatré mantra. Gradually, by constant chanting, they come to realize Parabrahman (the Supreme Brahman), or the Absolute Truth. Only then can they perceive the Supreme Personality of Godhead, along with His transcendental name, form, qualities, pastimes, and paraphernalia, as well as the Vaikuëöha planets and the Lord of the Vaikuëöha planets, Näräyaëa. And when one develops a taste for engaging properly in the Lord's transcendental service and realizes thesublime mellows of devotion, one can see Lord Väsudeva, Kåñëa.

Mundane philosophers who try to attain the Supreme through the ascending process of knowledge can never achieve their goal. The only result of such an attempt, which naturally confuses them, is that they become rooted to the misunderstanding that man is God and vice versa, thus clearing their way to hell. A few among them may have a moment's glimpse of transcendence, but end up concluding everything backwards. They fall prey to the erroneous impersonal principle.

To refute this impersonal conception of the Absolute, the previously quoted verse from Çrémad-Bhägavatam unequivocally states that the Absolute Truth is a person. This transcendental personality is so powerful that He could impart the knowledge of the Vedas even to Lord Brahmä, who then went on to create the material universe. Lord Brahmä did not receive this extraordinary Vedic knowledge after creation but before he began the work of creation. The knowledge that existed before the mundane nature came into being is transcendental and is known as saàvit. The Viñëu Puräëa delves into the subjects of sandhiné, saàvit, and hlädiné, the Lord's potencies of existence, knowledge, and pleasure. All together, these are known as the Lord's internal potency, or spiritual potency. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam also discusses the subject of the Lord's internal potency. This superior potency is quite different form the Lord's inferior, external potency, which is qualified by the three material modes. An example of the Lord's superior, spiritual potency is the jévas. One who can understand that the jévas are a product of the Lord's internal potency, not His external potency, can immediately grasp the difference between these two potencies.

Delusion is the perverted image of reality and is the hallmark of mäyä, the Lord's external energy. This delusion is totally absent in His internal, spiritual potency. The jéva is a product of the Lord's superior, transcendental energy, but he becomes deluded into identifying his body as his self. Once this ignorance is dissipated, he can immediately understand the actual nature of the body. Illusion is possible on the mundane plane but never in the spiritual energy.

The variety visible in material nature is due to the influence of the Lord's spiritual energy. In other words, material nature is but a perverted reflection of spiritual energy. For example, sunlight is ever-existing, but when sunlight is reflected on water, there comes into being a new source of light that must accept the cycle of creation, maintenance, and annihilation. The original sun, of course, is not bound by such changes. This practical analogy helps us understand that the spiritual nature is transcendental to creation, maintenance, and annihilation, whereas the perverted reflection of the spiritual energy—the material nature—is bound by these three conditions. The material nature is illusory: sometimes it is there, and at other times it is not. When this illusory, temporary existence of "there and not there" is totally removed and in its place are manifested the name, form, qualities, associates, paraphernalia, and abode of the Lord, one is on the platform of satyaà param, the Absolute Truth, who is described here as nirasta-kuhakam, "forever free from the illusory representation of the material world."

The jéva has been referred to as the Lord's marginal potency. The jéva is unpredictable: sometimes he is under the material energy's control, and at other times under the spiritual energy's shelter. But the supreme, infallible Lord never comes under the sway of any of His energies: He forever remains the absolute autocrat, the master of all energies, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Väsudeva. All energies emanate from Him, and thus He is the supreme energetic principle. When the two words sva-räö ("independent") and param ("supreme") are used to describe an entity, then He must be the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the eternal cause of all causes. That the Supreme Lord never comes under the influence of mäyä is confirmed elsewhere in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.11.38):

etad éçanam éçasya
prakåti-stho 'pi tad-guëaiù
na yujyate sadätma-sthair
yathä buddhis tad-äçrayä

This is the divinity of the Personality of Godhead: He is not affected by the qualities of material nature, even though He is in contact with them. Similarly, the devotees who have taken shelter of the Lord do not become influenced by the material qualities.

It is the Supreme Lord's special prerogative to descend to this material world and remain unaffected by it and detached from it. And like Him, His pure devotees also remain unattracted by the glare of the phenomenal world. As the Supreme Lord is eternal, liberated, and pure, so are His devotees, whatever situation they may be in. This can easily be understood through a simple example: technological advancement has added things like cinemas to the material attractions nature already has to offer, and yet, strangely, these illusory enticements have failed to attract genuine saints and hermits even to this day. And although we do see that some so-called modern saints and mendicants are addicted to cannabis and tobacco, even they are repulsed by many other modern sensual distractions. If the illusory material world holds little or no attraction for the Lord's devotees, how much less must the Lord Himself be attracted to it! Therefore, although out of ignorance one might claim that mere mortals are God, that does not change the reality—that man is always man and God is always God, and never otherwise.

Once one of the brahmacärés of our äçrama met Dr. Sarvapalli Radhakrishnan, who is a spiritualist of sorts and an erudite scholar. Dr. Radhakrishnan is the vice-president of India as I write this essay. On meeting him, our brahmacäré received from him a copy of his Bhagavad-gétä as a gift. Dr. Radhakrishnan had translated this Gétä into English and written a commentary on it, and it sold well in the market for ten rupees in those days [1954].

The brahmacäré read the book and came to us a little dissatisfied, though the book itself was deeply esoteric. The reason for his dissatisfaction was that Dr. Radhakrishnan's writing lacked spiritual insight: in many places he had mishandled and misinterpreted the text, and thus he had made his book unacceptable to spiritualists in the line of pure devotion. This is a perfect example of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam's statement (1.1.1) that "by Him even the great sages and demigods are placed into illusion" (muhyanti yat sürayaù). When the Lord so easily bewilders Lord Brahmä, Lord Çiva, Lord Indra, and other great universal controllers, it is not at all surprising that Dr. Radhakrishnan is placed into illusion.

The brahmacäré was especially shocked and hurt by Dr. Radhakrishnan's misinterpretation of Text 34 of Chapter 9, which appears in his book on page 254. He came to us very depressed, wanting to discuss this passage. The following words were found in the book:

It is not the personal Kåñëa to whom we have to give ourselves up utterly but the Unborn, Beginningless, Eternal who speaks through Kåñëa.

We have not the slightest intention of confronting a world-famous philosopher like Dr. Radhakrishnan with arguments, yet on the brahmacäré's repeated request we have to scrutinize the text and point out the discrepancies. We have great respect for Dr. Radhakrishnan, not only because he is the vice-president of our country but also because of his scholarship and his position as an erudite master of Hindu philosophy. Furthermore, he is faithful to the brahminical tradition he hails from and is a follower of the Mäyäväda school. Going by the oft-quoted dictum that it is better to have a learned enemy than a foolish friend, I feel encouraged in this matter. An intelligent opponent will present reasonable rebuttals, but an ignorant friend may bring about disaster with his floundering. Therefore we feel no compunction about strongly arguing against the points Dr. Radhakrishnan makes in his Bhagavad-gétä commentary.

A well-known Bengali saying goes, "After reading the whole Rämäyaëa, you want to know whose father Sétä is?" This question is ludicrous, since Sétä is Lord Räma's wife, and thus such a query will naturally invite quips and laughter. We find the same absurdity in Dr. Radhakrishnan's English commentary on the Gétä. He writes that we do not have to surrender to the person Kåñëa but to "the Unborn, Beginningless, Eternal" within Kåñëa. This implies that Lord Kåñëa and His "inner self" are two separate identities. According to Dr. Radhakrishnan, since there is a difference between Kåñëa's body and His soul, we must surrender to Kåñëa's soul and not His body. This new discovery in the field of religious philosophy reminds us of the "paëòita" of the Rämäyaëa referred to above. Lord Çré Kåñëa's sole purpose in speaking the Bhagavad-gétä is to convince us to surrender to His lotus feet. Yet right at the outset Dr. Radhakrishnan is unwilling to accept this point. Lord Kåñëa gives the central instruction in the Bhagavad-gétä (18.66):

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reactions. Do not fear.

Lord Kåñëa spoke these words to Arjuna so that he would surrender to Him. The Sanskrit word çaraëam in this Gétä text means "surrender." On page 62 of his "Introductory Essay", Dr. Radhakrishnan has also discussed the idea of surrender in some detail. He writes,

"Prapatti [surrender] has the following accessories—good will to all (änukülyasya saìkalpaù); (ii) absence of ill will (prätikülyasya varjanam); (iii) faith that the Lord will protect (rakñiñyatéti viçväsaù); (iv) resort to Him as savior (gopåtve varanam); (v) a sense of utter helplessness (kärpaëyam); (vi) complete surrender (ätma-nikñepaù)."

These six limbs of surrender should be followed in relation to Kåñëa, or Viñëu, because this instruction on the process of surrender appears in a Vaiñëava scripture. Dr. Radhakrishnan has translated the first limb (änukülyasya saìkalpaù) as "good will to all." Question: Is it possible to surrender to everyone? Surrender should be directed toward the Supreme Lord alone. Dr. Radhakrishnan's proposal is impractical, and indeed impossible. Long before Dr. Radhakrishnan wrote his commentary, many realized spiritual preceptors, including the famous Gosvämés of Våndävana, explained that the words änukülyasya saìkalpaù mean that one should render transcendental loving service to the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, favorably. No genuine scholar would be willing to disregard all other spiritual authorities and accept Dr. Radhakrishnan's version.

When Dr. Radhakrishnan uses the words "faith in the Lord," he definitely refers to the Supreme Personality of Godhead. By what logic does he say "Lord" but mean the impersonal Brahman? Arjuna certainly means the person Kåñëa when he says (Bg. 2.7), çiñyas te 'haà çädhi mäà tväà prapannam: "Now I am Your disciple, and a soul surrendered unto You. Please instruct me." With these words he addresses Kåñëa at the beginning of the Bhagavad-gétä. At this stage of the Gétä the impersonal Brahman is still to be discussed. When the subject of the impersonal Brahman is finally raised, Lord Kåñëa unequivocally declares that He is the source of the impersonal Brahman. Sound logic says that one cannot surrender to something impersonal and formless. Those who are overly attached to the impersonal Brahman will find surrendering to this formless concept very painful and, indeed,impossible, and if they persist along this path they will end up surrendering to their wife, family, and relatives.

RTW 4.2: Transcendental Devotional Service Reveals the Real Form of the Lord.

Transcendental Devotional Service Reveals the Real Form of the Lord

We learn from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam that, due to mäyä, which makes the living entity fall down from spiritual practice, certain obnoxious atheists try hard to create a smokescreen of philosophical jargon around the Supreme Lord to keep Him hidden from the general populace. The result of this effort is also described in the Bhägavatam (12.3.43):

kalau na räjan jagatäà paraà guruà
tri-loka-näthänata-päda-paìkajam
präyeëa martyä bhagavantam acyutaà
yakñyanti päñaëòa-vibhinna-cetasaù

O King! In theAge of Kali people's intelligence will be diverted by atheism, and they will almost never offer sacrifice to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is the supreme spiritual master of the universe. Although the great personalities who control the three worlds all bow down to the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord, the petty and miserable human beings of this age will not do so.

A good example of such philosophical jargon meant to bewilder the public is Dr. Radhakrishnan's translating änukülyasya saìkalpaù as "good will to all" instead of"surrendering to the Supreme Lord," its proper meaning. Such an interpretation is what we can expect from a mundane scholar.

The first word in devotional service is surrender. The only meaning of surrender is to accept that one is a servant of God. Even great scholars and philosophers like Dr. Radhakrishnan will have to perform heaps of austerities and penances before they will yield to the process of surrender. This is the conclusion of Bhagavad-gétä. Dr. Radhakrishnan's explanation of the six limbs of surrender is superficial. Originally defined in a Vaiñëava text, these six limbs of surrender pertain to Lord Viñëu, or Kåñëa. Änukülya means "loving devotion to Lord Kåñëa." The Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu states, änukülyena-kåñëänuçélanaà bhaktir uttamä: "One should render transcendental loving service to Lord Kåñëa favorably. That is called pure devotional service."

Everyone in the world is rendering service to Lord Kåñëa in one way or another. Some are doing it favorably, and others antagonistically. Those who are serving unfavorably are inimical atheists, the foolish nondevotees, while those who do it with pleasure are truly intelligent. In other words, the devotees of Kåñëa are very intelligent, while the mundane scholars are in the same category as the nondevotee atheists led by the demons Kaàsa and Jaräsandha.

The main instruction in the Bhagavad-gétä is to take complete shelter of Lord Kåñëa. Yet this cardinal conclusion, which emanated from Lord Kåñëa's own lotus lips, is reversed by Dr. Radhakrishnan when he writes that one should surrender not to the person Kåñëa but to the "Unborn, Beginningless, Eternal who speaks through Kåñëa." It is an exercise in futility to take up the Gétä for discussion only in order to ostentatiously display one's erudition, and thus to foolishly misinterpret the text so much that one concludes that the speaker of the Bhagavad-gétä, Lord Kåñëa, is a mere mortal. This use of Vedic knowledge to pronounce that God does not exist is a clear example of serving Kåñëa unfavorably.

How does Lord Kåñëa describe sholars like Dr. Radhakrishnan, who have an atheistic understanding of the Vedas? In the Bhagavad-gétä (7.15) we find this statement:

na mäà duñkåtino müòhäù
prapadyante narädhamäù
mäyayäpahåta-jïänä
äsuraà bhävam äçritäù

Those miscreants who are grossly foolish, lowest among mankind, whose knowledge is stolen by illusion, and who partake of the atheistic nature of demons, do not surrender unto Me.

Enemies of the Lord like Kaàsa and Jaräsandha always meditated on Kåñëa, but unfavorably. Similar to these demons are the atheistic scholars who always challenge and misrepresent the real teachings of the Bhagavad-gétä. Though they think about the Lord, they do so with enmity because their intelligence has been covered by mäyä. Kaàsa and Jaräsandha were also erudite scholars, but because they were obsessed with Kåñëa in enmity, they were demons.

We understand from Lord Caitanya's teachings and exemplary actions that it is our duty to follow the instructions of the Bhagavad-gétä favorably. During Lord Caitanya's tour of South India, when He entered the premises of the Çré Raìganätha temple, He came upon a simple brähmaëa engrossed in reading the Bhagavad-gétä. The Lord was overjoyed to see how attentively the brähmaëa was reading, and how tears were streaming down his cheeks. Other brähmaëas sitting nearby knew that he was illiterate, and so they wondered how he could possibly read the Gétä.

Lord Caitanya easily solved this problem. He said that even an uneducated person can understand transcendental words if he is a fully surrendered soul. But without that mood of surrender, Bhagavad-gétä remains incomprehensible.

When Lord Caitanya saw the brähmaëa in tears, He asked him what part of the Gétä moved him to cry. With proper Vaiñëava humility, the brähmaëa answered,

I am merely pretending to read the Gétä; in truth I am illiterate. But my guru instructed me to regularly read the entire Bhagavad-gétä, though I am unlettered. Not wanting to disobey my guru, I try to execute my duty, and so I make a show of reading the Gétä.

The Lord then asked him why he was crying. The brähmaëa replied,

Whenever I sit down to read the Gétä, the form of Lord Kåñëa as Pärtha-särathi [Arjuna's chariot driver] appears in my heart. And as soon as I see this form I immediately remember how the Lord is bhakta-vatsala [especially kind to His devotees]. This thought makes me cry.

The Mäyävädés are always eager to merge with the nondual Supreme Brahman and become God. But their small brains cannot understand how the Supreme Personality of Godhead can become the charioteer of His devotee and carry out his orders. In truth the Supreme Lord and the jévas are eternally related, and because of this relationship many wonderful things are possible. But the Mäyävädés cannot understand this truth, and many who have tried to make them understand have failed miserably. In the çruti (Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 6.23) we find this statement:

yasya deve parä-bhaktir
yathä deve tathä gurau
tasyaite kathitä hy arthäù
prakäçante mahätmanaù

Only unto those great souls who have implicit faith in both the Lord and the spiritual master, all the imports of Vedic knowledge are automatically revealed.

Upon seeing the devotion of the South Indian brähmaëa as he read the Gétä, Lord Caitanya embraced him and then told him that he had perfected the reading of the Gétä. What fool would deny that Lord Caitanya's approval is far superior to millions of university doctorates? This accolade from the Lord proves that the Bhagavad-gétä cannot be studied with material intelligence. The knowledge of the Gétä must be received through the chain of äcäryas, or spiritual masters, coming down indisciplic succession. That is the only method; otherwise studying the Gétä is an exercise in futility. The scriptural conclusion is that since the Supreme Lord is transcendental, His words are also transcendental, and hence the esoteric subject matter of the Bhagavad-gétä can be received only through a disciplic succession that is equally transcendental. As the Padma Puräëa states,

atah çré-kåñëa-nämädi
na bhaved grähyam indriyaiù
sevonmukhe hi jihvädau
svayam eva sphuraty adaù

No one can understand the transcendental nature of the name, form, qualities, and pastimes of Çré Kåñëa through his materially contaminated senses. Only when one becomes spiritually situated by transcendental service to the Lord are the transcendental name, form, qualities, and pastimes of the Lord revealed to him.

This is confirmed in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.38):

premäïjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena
santaù sadaiva hådayeñu vilokayanti
yaà çyämasundaram acintya-guëa-svarüpaà
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who is Çyämasundara, Kåñëa Himself with innumerable inconceivable attributes, whom the pure devotees see in their heart of hearts with the eye of devotion tinged with the salve of love.

Therefore, the scriptural conclusion is that mundane philosophers like Dr. Radhakrishnan arenot qualified to delve into spiritual subjects. The devotees of the Lord alone are eligible to understand Lord Kåñëa; no one else is qualified. As Kåñëa Himself states in the Bhagavad-gétä, bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti yävän yaç cäsmi tattvataù: "One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service. "

Scholars like Dr. Radhakrishnan should understand that within Lord Kåñëa there is only Lord Kåñëa and nothing else. Lord Kåñëa's body and soul are the same. The Gétä's conclusion is that the nondual truth is Kåñëa, the absolute Supreme Being. But Dr. Radhakrishnan has somehow discovered another, second being within Kåñëa. This discovery then converts Dr. Radhakrishnan into a believer in dualism! The manifestation of the Absolute Truth who resiedes in every jéva's heart is ludicly described by Lord Kåñëa in Bhagavad-gétä. In the Bhagavad-gétä (10.8), Lord Kåñëa explains who the being residing in every jéva's heart is:

ahaà sarvasya prabhavo
mattaù sarvaà pravartate
iti matvä bhajante mäà
budhä bhäva-samanvitäù

I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from Me. The wise who know this perfectly engage in My devotional service and worship Me with all their hearts.

And later in the Gétä (15.15) He says,

sarvasya cähaà hådi sanniviñto
mattaù småtir jïänam apohanaà ca
vedaiç ca sarvair aham eva vedyo
vedänta-kåd veda-vid eva cäham

I am seated in everyone's heart, and from Me come remembrance, knowledge and forgetfulness. By all the Vedas am I to be known; indeed I am the compiler of Vedänta, and I am the knower of the Vedas.

The wise men with perfect knowledge—i.e., those who have purified their materialistic intelligence and are thus situated in spiritual knowledge—can understand Lord Kåñëa as the source of everything. Unless the intellect is purified and spiritualized, even the most erudite philosopher and the greatest mystic yogé will become perplexed in trying to understand Lord Kåñëa. As the Lord says in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.3), yatatäm api siddhänäà kaçcin mäà vetti tattvataù: "Of those who have achieved perfection, hardly one knows Me in truth."

The Supreme Lord's name, form, qualities, pastimes, associates, and paraphernalia are all of the same spiritual nature. In fact, anything in relation to Lord Kåñëa is nondifferent from Him. As the Padma Puräëa states,

näma cintämaëiù kåñëaç
caitanya-rasa-vigrahaù
pürëaù çuddho nitya-mukto
'bhinnatvän näma-näminoù

The holy name of Kåñëa is transcendentally blissful. It bestows all spiritual benediction, for it is Kåñëa Himself, the reservoir of all pleasure. Kåñëa's name is complete, and it is the form of all transcendental mellows. It is not a material name under any condition, and it is no less powerful than Kåñëa Himself. Since Kåñëa's name is not contaminated by the material qualities, there is no question of its being involved with mäyä. Kåñëa's name is always liberated and spiritual; it is never conditioned by the laws of material nature. This is because the name of Kåñëa and Kåñëa Himself are identical.

Onlysaintly souls can perceive the truth of these statements; those whose intelligence has been corrupted by Mäyäväda philosophy cannot understand.

In general, the monists cannot grasp the intricate philosophy of nondualism. So Dr. Radhakrishnan has spun out of his imagination a theory by which he tries to establish dualism in nondualism. When Dr. Radhakrishnan writes that we must surrender to "the Unborn, Beginningless, Eternal who speaks through Kåñëa," he implies that it is the impersonal Brahman within Kåñëa who is speaking about surrender. Once it is established that the impersonal Brahman can speak, then He must also possess the instrument of speech, namely the tongue. Thus we see that Dr. Radhakrishnan's whole concept of impersonalism is immediately undermined. There is sufficient evidence in the scriptures to conclude that one who talks can also walk. And a being capable of speaking and walking must indeed be endowed with all the senses. Then He must also be able to perform other activities, such as eating and sleeping. So how can Dr. Radhakrishnan claim that his beginningless, eternal object is impersonal?

In his "Introductory Essay," on page 62, Dr. Radhakrishnan writes,

When we are emptied of our self [?], God takes possession of us. The obstacles to this God-possession are our own virtues, pride, knowledge, our subtle demands, and our unconscious assumptions and prejudices.

From his own arguments we can safely surmise that Dr. Radhakrishnan, due to his carelessness and previous upbringing, is seeing a difference between Lord Kåñëa's body and His soul. He is still not free from false ego, that is, "emptied of self." Therefore his "virtues, pride, knowledge, subtle demands, and unconscious assumptions and prejudices" are all preventing him from understanding the transcendental truth. He must have been brought up in an atmosphere of Mäyäväda thought; for this reason he was unable to grasp the truth.

Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya, the founder and propagator of Mäyäväda philosophy, proved that the material world was an illusion—mithyä—and so he diligently pursued the path of austerity and renunciation, and he stressed it in his teachings. He did not waste valuable time trying to lord it over this illusory material world. But if he were to see the present condition of the philosophy he propounded, perhaps he would be ashamed. We have no doubt that Dr. Radhakrishnan was influenced by him; this is evident from his writings. Yet in his "Introductory Essay," page 25, he writes, "The emphasis of the Gétä is on the Supreme as the personal God who creates the perceptible world by His Nature (prakåti). He resides within the heart of every being; He is the enjoyer and Lord of sacrifices. He stirs our heart to devotion and grants our prayers. He is the source and retainer of values. He enters into personal relations with us in worship and prayer."

After writing this and thus accepting the real purport of the Gétä, how can Dr. Radhakrishnan later state that Lord Kåñëa's body and soul are different? Such an idea must be a result of his materialistic education. What a strange monism he propounds, in which the Absolute Truth, the nondual Supreme Being, is supposedly separate from His inner existence! Can Dr. Radhakrishnan explain these obvious flaws in his philosophy? When the Supreme Lord Himself is present in everyone's heart as the omniscient Supersoul, then who else can sit in His heart? In the Gétä, Lord Kåñëa Himself speaks about His transcendental qualities, making statements that Dr. Radhakrishnan, armed with his material erudition, has made but a feeble attempt to contradict. Through such foolishness Dr. Radhakrishnan has made a show of spreading education, but in fact he has preached untruth.

Brahman, Paramätmä (the Supersoul), and Bhagavän (the Supreme Personality of Godhead)—all three are the same nondual Supreme Absolute. It would be riduculous to say that Dr. Radhakrishnan is ignorant of this subject, yet we fail to see the logic in his claim that when the Supreme Lord incarnates He comes under the sway of mäyä. The Lord unequivocally states in the Gétä that when He appears, He does so in His original transcendental form. Hence there can be no difference between Him and His body. The Lord further states that His appearance, activities, and so on are all transcendental, beyond the realm of matter. He is eternal, supremely pure, the original Supreme Personality and Supreme Brahman. We all agree that the jéva is covered by mäyä, but if the Supreme Brahman, or Parabrahman, is also covered by mäyä, then is mäyä superior to Parabrahman?

RTW 4.3: Lord Kåñëa Is the Supreme Controller Godhead.

Lord Kåñëa Is the Supreme Controller Godhead

Since Dr. Radhakrishnan implies that the impersonal Brahman alone possesses such transcendental qualities as being inexhaustible, imperishable, and unborn, we must turn to the Gétä for a proper reply. In truth, all the divine expansions of the nondual Supreme Being are endowed with these same superexcellent qualities. As Arjuna declares in the Bhagavad-gétä (11.18),

tvam akñaraà paramaà veditavyaà
tvam asya viçvasya paraà nidhänam
tvam avyayaù çäçvata-dharma-goptä
sanätanas tvaà puruño mato me

You are the supreme primal objective; You are the best in all the universes; You are inexhaustible, and You are the oldest; You are the maintainer of religion, the eternal Personality of Godhead.

We should understand that those passages in the Gétä which describe Parabrahman as akñara("indestructible") are references to Lord Kåñëa, the Supreme Controller Godhead. Not once is Lord Kåñëa equated with the kñara, the conditioned jévas. Not only big philosophers like Dr. Radhakrishnan, but even mighty demigods like Lord Brahmä and Lord Indra are in the category of kñara. The Lord maintains the entire cosmic manifestation merely by His separated energy. Just as fire, though situated in one place, spreads its light and heat in all directions, so the unborn Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, while maintaining His full personality, eternality, and imperishability, expands Himself into countless Viñëu forms,jévas, and internal and external potencies. Expanding Himself in this way never diminishes or in any way affects His status as the Absolute Whole. As the Éçopaniñad, Invocation declares, pürëasya pürëam ädäya pürëam evävaçiñyate:

Whatever is produced of the complete whole is also complete in itself. Because He is the complete whole, even though so many complete units emanate from Him, He remains the complete balance.

The Lord is the eternal Supreme Person, and therefore His name, form, qualities, pastimes, and so on are all eternal. The Sanskrit word puruña means "enjoyer." An enjoyer can never be a formless, impersonal, impotent being. Certainly Lord Kåñëa is without material qualities, yet He is the enjoyer and possessor of all spiritual qualities.

In the Bhagavad-gétä, Arjuna glorifies Lord Kåñëa as akñara, Parabrahman, and ädi-deva (the original Personality of Godhead). Dr. Radhakrishnan writes that the term akñara, "inexhaustible," is synonymous with the word avyaya, "without deterioration." Therefore why does he conclude that Lord Kåñëa and His body are different? This we fail to understand. On page 275, Dr. Radhakrishnan admits that Arjuna says Lord Kåñëa is Parabrahman, Bhagavän, the Absolute Truth. In the same book and on the same page he writes something quite incoherent and fictitious and attributes it to Arjuna: "Arjuna states that the Supreme [Çré Kåñëa] is both Brahman and Éçvara, Absolute and God." If Dr. Radhakrishnan possesses such a sketchy and incorrect perception of the Gétä that he thinks Bhagavän is different from Brahman then how can he claim to have read the Gétä? He argues that Bhagavän and Supersoul Kåñëa are products of mäyä, while Brahman is not! Çréla Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämé has severely criticized such speculative philosophy. In the Caitanya-caritämåta he writes, "Not knowing that Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagavän are all features of Kåñëa, foolish scholars speculate in various ways."

We accept both Arjuna and Çréla Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämé as greater authorities than Dr. Radhakrishnan. Arjuna directly heard the Bhagavad-gétä, and the President of India, Dr. Rajendraprasad, has accepted Çré Caitanya-caritämåta as an authentic and authoritative scripture. Those who try to understand the Bhagavad-gétä by receiving it from one in the disciplic succession coming down from Arjuna can actually understand its esoteric knowledge; others fail miserably. It is imperative that one attentively hear what the Bhagavad-gétä and other authorized scriptures have to say about the impersonal Brahman. The scriptures amply prove that the impersonal Brahman is the Supreme Lord's bodily effulgence, just as sunshine is the brilliant emanation from the sun. Furthermore, as the sun's rays are dependent on and subservient to the sun, so the impersonal brahmajyoti effulgence, Lord Kåñëa's bodily luster, is dependent on and subservient to the Lord. In the Gétä (14.27) He says,

brahmano hi pratiñöäham
amåtasyävyayasya ca
çäçvatasya ca dharmasya
sukhasyaikäntikasya ca

And I am the basis of the impersonal Brahman, which is the constitutional position of ultimate happiness, and which is immortal, imperishable and eternal.

The Lord's statements in the Gétä concerning the impersonal Brahman are unequivocal, yet Dr. Radhakrishnan seems unsatisfied with them. He grudgingly translates Text 27 of the Fourteenth Chapter, "For I am the abode of Brahman, the Immortal and the Imperishable, of eternal law and of absolute bliss." Since Lord Kåñëa is the basis of the impersonal, formless Brahman, He is certainly far superior it. The mosquito net is inside the house, not the other way around; the ink-pot is on the table, not vice versa. Even a small boy can grasp this. Then why does Dr. Radhakrishnan hesitate to accept this truth? There are countless proofs in the scripture of Lord Kåñëa's supreme absolute personality, but Dr. Radhakrishnan is like an owl in the daylight of truths. He tries to cover the sun of truth by creating a dark cloud of word jugglery. Thus instead of truth and knowledge, confusion is paraded before the world. We strongly condemn this sort of activity. Whether directly or indirectly, Dr. Radhakrishnan has tried to circumvent the truth—that Lord Kåñëa is the basis of Brahman—and in the process he has been defeated. If Dr. Radhakrishnan really accepts Lord Kåñëa as the absolute God, then what inspired him to see another being within Kåñëa and to write, "It is not the personal Kåñëa to whom we have to give ourselves up..."?

The truth is that only those who have been blessed by the Lord can fathom the spiritual science dealing with God. Dr. Radhakrishnan's book irrefutably proves this. The Mäyävädé philosophers are big offenders to the Supreme Lord, and therefore He never manifests Himself to them. As the Lord Himself declares in the Gétä (7.25), nähaà prakäçaù sarvasya yoga-mäyä samävåtaù muòhaù: "I am never manifest to the foolish and unintelligent. For them I am covered by my internal potency..." All previous spiritual authorities have condemned the Mäyävädés, but Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya Mahäprabhu has directly censured them, calling them the greatest offenders against the Supreme Lord. He said that if a person simply hears philosophy from a Mäyävädé, his spiritual life is in jeopardy. As quoted in the Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 17.129-132 and 134-135), the Lord speaks about the Mäyävädés in this way:

Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu replied, 'Mäyävädé impersonalists are great offenders unto Lord Kåñëa; therefore they simply utter the words brahman, ätmä, and caitanya. The holy name of Kåñëa is not manifest in their mouths because they are offenders unto Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is identical with His holy name. The Lord's holy name, His form, and His personality are all one and the same. There is no difference between them. Since all of them are absolute, they are transcendentally blissful. There is no difference between Kåñëa's body and Himself or between His name and Himself. As far as the conditioned soul is concerned, everything is different. One's name is different from the body, from one's original form and so on. The holy name of Kåñëa, His body, and His pastimes cannot be understood by blunt material senses. They are manifest independently. The holy name of Kåñëa, His transcendental qualities and pastimes, as well as Lord Kåñëa Himself are all equal. They are all spiritual and full of bliss.

The Mäyävädés try to imitate Çrépäd Çaìkaräcärya. Pretending to be orthodox, they reject the truth that the jéva is part and parcel of Parabrahman, the Supreme Lord. They also deny the fact that it is only the part and parcel aspect of Parabrahman (the jéva) and not Parabrahman Himself who falls under the spell of mäyä. And worst of all, they deny that Parabrahman is none other than the Supreme Personality of Godhead. According to their lop-sided argument, when the jéva attains mukti (liberation) he merges into the impersonal Brahman and loses his individual identity. By this logic, when the Supreme Lord, the Parabrahman, incarnates in this material world or appears in the Deity form, He becomes an ordinary jéva. Thus the foolish Mäyävädés draw a distinction between the Lord and His form, and in this way they commit great offences against Him.

So, by knocking a wedge between Lord Kåñëa and His form, Dr. Radhakrishnan has demonstrated his lack of intelligence; indeed, mäyä has robbed him of intelligence, and according to Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu he is the worst offender. In the Bhagavad-gétä the Lord describes such offenders as müòhäs because they ascribe human frailties and faults to the Supreme Lord. Today the world has become a hell because of an excess of atheists, and this is due only to the preaching of Mäyäväda philosophy by enemies of the Supreme Lord. Lord Caitanya's mission is to save the jévas from the clutches of these offenders. Those who are unconcerned about this mission commit offences against Lord Caitanya.

The Mäyävädés try hard to look like spiritualists, but in fact they are gross materialists. They may be able to confuse and mesmerize the public with word jugglery, but in truth their so-called renunciation is as false as the monkeys', for they have become mere beggars looking for distinction, adoration, position, and wealth. They are busy only with worldly progress; forgotten are the spiritual message and spiritual goals and ideals. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.1.2) has defined such showbottle religion as kaitava-dharma, "cheating religion." Those who are attracted to such cheating religious groups are themselves deceitful. Their show of spirituality is abominable; they have no desire for either liberation or devotion and surrender. They are addicted to speculation and can never understand Kåñëa.

When the Mäyävädés pretend to perform kértana or hold discourses on the Bhägavatam for personal name and fame, they may sing and talk about Brahman, Caitanya, and Paramätmä, but they cannot utter Lord Kåñëa's name. Although the words çré bhagavän uväca ("the Supreme Personality of Godhead said") appear throughout the Bhagavad-gétä, the Mäyävädés are prepared to say everything else except the name of Kåñëa. It is a well known scriptural truth that the words Brahman and Paramätmä refer ultimately to Lord Kåñëa and that Kåñëa is the principle name of the Supreme Absolute Person. But even when the Mäyävädés chant such names of God as Kåñëa, Govinda, or Hari, they do so not with the understanding and faith that these names are God's principal names and that they are nondifferent from the Supreme Lord, but rather with the idea that chanting them is a temporary means of sädhana, or spiritual practice. They also do not admit that such chanting of the holy name is an offence. Of course, their biggest offence is to distinguish between Lord Kåñëa and His form. Thus in the Gétä (9.11), Lord Kåñëa Himself condemns these offenders:

avajänanti mäà müòhä
mänuñéà tanum äçritam
paraà bhävam ajänanto
mama bhüta-maheçvaram

Fools deride Me when I descend in the human form. They do not know My transcendental nature and My supreme dominion over all that be.

Let us study how Dr. Radhakrishnan has translated this verse, which appears on page 242 of his book: "The deluded despise Me clad in human body, not knowing My higher nature as Lord of all existences." In other words, when the person who is "Lord of all existences" is "clad in human body," those who see from a materialistic perspective take Him for an ordinary mortal, while those who see from a spiritual perspective understand that He is the Supreme Being, the cause of all causes. So if it is the deluded who despise Lord Kåñëa, then is it not time for Dr. Radhakrishnan himself to admit that he is guilty of this crime? Let him realize how he has abused the "Lord of all existences," equating Him with a mere mortal. When we see how such big scholars are inimical toward Lord Kåñëa, we can conclude, following the Gétä, that their intelligence has been stolen by mäyä.

All the previous spiritual authorities have accepted Lord Kåñëa as the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Even Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya has accepted this truth. Yet Dr. Radhakrishnan is so deluded that he considers Lord Kåñëa an ordinary jéva, or perhaps an extraordinary one.

There is no one who possesses more knowledge than Lord Caitanya. The knowledge of Kåñëa consciousness, which is logical and scientific, must be received from Lord Caitanya. Has Dr. Radhakrishnan anywhere discussed Lord Kåñëa on the basis of the precepts of Çréla Jéva Gosvämé, who is in the direct spiritual line of Lord Caitanya? We request Dr. Radhakrishnan to study the Ñaö-sandarbha of Çréla Jéva Gosvämé. He was especially empowered by his spiritual masters to direct his writings toward the scholars and philosophers and make them understand this esoteric knowledge. Another philosopher of his stature is yet to be born; in fact, no one in the future will be able to surpass him in erudition. We hope that since Dr. Radhakrishnan is a philosopher, he will not reject Çréla Jéva Gosvämé's precepts.

From the writings of Dr. Radhakrishnan one can easily prove how he is perplexed in trying to fathom the science of Kåñëa consciousness. He tries to present Lord Kåñëa as an extraordinary human being and a historical figure of India, but the Bhagavad-gétä makes such a task impossible. In his "Introductory Essay" (page 30) he writes:

In the Gétä Kåñëa is identified with the Supreme Lord, the unity that liesbehind the manifold universes, the changeless truth behind all appearances, transcendent over all and immanent in all. He is the manifested Lord, making it easy for mortals to know, for those who seek the Imperishable Brahman reach Him no doubt but after great toil. He is called Paramätmän.

How can we identify a historical individual with the Supreme God? The representation of an individual as identical with the universal Self is familiar to Hindu thought. In the Upaniñads, we are informed that the fully awakened soul, which apprehends the true relation to the Absolute, sees that it is essentially one with the latter and declares itself to be so.

But the jéva's becoming "essentially one" with the Lord is not the last word in spiritual life. Of course, Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya propagated this idea so that atheists could at least come to this level of realization. But beyond this is the realm of the Supreme Absolute Personality of Godhead. Having entered the sphere of transcendence, if one does not perceive the supreme transcendental personality, one's spiritual practice remains incomplete due to contaminated intelligence, and one has to return to the realm of materialism. Though claiming that the world is an illusion—jagan mithyä—such an unsuccessful transcendentalist then becomes entangled in political, social, and altruistic affairs.

Dr. Radhakrishnan has never directly perceived the supreme transcendental personality, Lord Çré Kåñëa. Although Lord Kåñëa is right in front of him, he cannot see Him, and thus out of delusion he calls Him a historical person. Genuine Indian religious philosophy teaches that there are both oneness with God and difference from Him. This concept of simultaneous oneness and difference has been termed viçiñöädvaita, dvaitädvaita, çuddhädvaita, and acintya-bhedäbheda-tattva. If this esoteric concept were false, then Kåñëa would not be worshiped throughout India, practically in every home. He is worshiped not as a historical figure but as the Supreme Lord. Kåñëa's position as the Supreme Godhead is firmly established by the authoritative text Çrémad-Bhägavatam, which is the natural commentary on and essence of the Vedänta-sütra and the Gäyatré mantra. Many scholarly Mäyävädés far more erudite than Dr. Radhakrishnan have tried to shake the faith of the general populace, but since time immemorial Kåñëa temples have mushroomed by the millions—a slap in the face for the Mäyävädés and atheists, who claim the Lord Kåñëa is an ordinary mortal. In the future also, more Kåñëa temples will be built to frustrate the agnostics and nonbelievers. All Viñëu temples are authorized by the scriptures and äcäryas. It hardly seems likely that, just for the sake of Dr. Radhakrishnan, the entire Indian population is going to strike a compromise with Mäyäväda philosophy.

Indian history is filled with accounts of many brilliant heroes who lit up the heavens with their fame. Why have the many sages and philosophers left aside these brilliant suns and chosen only Çré Kåñëa, Çré Räma, and Their expansions to worship as the Supreme Godhead? The spiritual preceptors who have delved into the scriptures to make an unbiased study of this phenomenon are scholars far more advanced than Dr. Radhakrishnan. Yet it is quite understandable that an ordinary mortal like Dr. Radhakrishnan is illusioned about Lord Kåñëa, since even the residents of the heavenly planets are illusioned about Him. As stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.1.1), muhyanti yat sürayaù: "By Him even the great sages and demigods are placed into illusion." The earth planet is way down in the seventh position among the fourteen planets in this cosmic system, so its residents are endowed only with meagre potency.

Among the countries of this meagre planet earth, Bhärata-varña, or India, is the best because since the dawn of creation Indian sages have exhibited the most exceptional skill in pursuing the esoteric spiritual science. In days of yore, these sages could communicate with the higher planetary systems. But today India is in such a bad condition that we are not willing to follow the instructions of previous sages. We are willing to accept Kåñëa as a historical figure, but by devious means we try distort His instructions with confusing philosophical jargon. This is proof of India's undesirable state. India now has become eager to do away with the real God and replace Him with many fake Gods. This is the greatest misfortune for India.

RTW 4.4: Lord Kåñëa Is the Supreme Personality of Godhead

Lord Kåñëa Is the Supreme Personality of Godhead

It is strange but true that political leaders can never understand that the Absolute Truth cannot be impersonal or formless but must be the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The scriptures are filled with passages that describe incarnations such as the gigantic form of Lord Mahä-Viñëu lying on the Causal Ocean, but Lord Kåñëa is the source of Mahä-Viñëu. Still the demented political leaders cannot comprehend the truth. But if out of His mercy Lord Kåñëa wishes to bless such atheists, then their rocklike hearts will soften and they will see the two-handed form of Kåñëa playing His flute in Våndävana.

Those who try to understand Lord Kåñëa without receiving His mercy, like Dr. Radhakrishnan, will certainly be deluded even if they are scholar—philosophers like him. The Brahma-saàhitä says that Kåñëa is easily manifest to the devotees but is beyond the reach of Vedic scholars. Çréla Särvabhauma Bhaööäcärya has proved this point by participating in a pastime of Lord Caitanya's in which the Bhaööäcärya exhibited his Vedic learning. In recent times, paëòitas such as Çré Bankim Chattopadhyaya and Dr. Bhandarkar became equally deluded trying to approach this subject.

One who really wants to know Kåñëa must follow the path He prescribes in the Bhagavad-gétä (18.55): bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti yävän yaç cäsmi tattvataù. "One can understand the Supreme Personality as He is only by devotional service." Except for devotional service, there is no way to understand Kåñëa. When Lord Kåñëa appeared in the form of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, He gave the same instruction about attaining Kåñëa through devotional service, so it is certain that Kåñëa can be approached only in this manner. Following in the disciplic line of Lord Caitanya, the Six Gosvämés of Våndävana have written extensive literature with detailed explanations of Lord Kåñëa. These confidential revelations are yet to be properly broadcast in the world. The Gosvämés' esoteric logic and profound analytical philosophy have not yet caught the attention of modern thinkers, and the burden of guilt for this discrepancy must indeed fall on us. The Gauòéya Maöha mission was founded to propagate the words of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé and Çréla Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé.

The gigantic universal form that Lord Kåñëa exhibited to Arjuna is certainly not the quintessence of the Lord's divine mood. In fact, the two-handed human form of Kåñëa playing the flute is the superexcellent manifestation of the Lord. But one must not make the mistake of thinking that because Lord Kåñëa appears as a human, He is human. His form is eternal and full of knowledge and bliss, unlike an ordinary mortal's. He is not even an extraordinaryhuman being. The human form may be a facsimile of the Supreme Lord's transcendental form, but that does not make God a man, or vice versa. The Bible and other scriptures state that man was made according to the form of God, but that does not imply that God is a man.

There is substantial proof in the Gétä that those who thoroughly grasp the truth about God will, upon leaving the material body, enter the spiritual realm and be with God. Only those who realize God as the eternal Supreme Personality can become immortal. This realization is the human being's prerogative alone, and one who attains it reaches the highest perfection. Once achieving perfection, the jéva never returns to this temporary world of birth, death, old age, and disease. Only those who discipline their lives so as to attain this objective fulfill the purpose of their human birth; others plunge into oblivion.

Mäyä induces one to make plans so that this temporary life of birth, death, old age, and disease can be permanent. The greatest delusion is to plan a life of nonstop bliss in this material world. Which is the better plan: the one that leads to birth in lower animal species like hogs and dogs, or the one that transports the jéva back to Godhead? The jéva's spiritual existence in the abode of the Lord consists of service to Him in different mellows, such as servitude, friendship, parenthood, and conjugal love. Both Lord Kåñëa and Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu mercifully enacted pastimes to attract the jévas and to teach them the meaning of the following words in the Gétä:

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù
[Bg. 18.66]

Abandon all varieties of religion and just surrender unto Me. I shall deliver you from all sinful reactions. Do not fear.

Who could be more deprived than those conditioned souls who do not try to understand this truth? In the words of Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkura, "One who has not tried to realize his relationship with the Lord has wasted his life; such a person is a miscreant and is worse than an animal."

Wthout proper understanding, Dr. Radhakrishnan has given his opinion about the descent of the Lord's incarnation. He writes, "An avatär is a descent of God into man and not an ascent of a man into God." What he means by "descent of God into man" is that the avatäras, or incarnations, possess physical bodies made up of the five gross elements. Of course, it remains to be clarified what he means by "not an ascent of man into God." Nowadays it is very much in vogue to designate a man as God. And it is not just a few who are said to be avataras: many philosophers go as far as to say that every human being is God. For the present we do not wish to delve into this subject.

We would like to inform Dr. Radhakrishnan, however, that when the Supreme Lord empowers a jéva with His divine potency so that the jéva can carry out some specific work, then that jéva is known as a çaktyäveça avatära. But this is not the only type of incarnation. The scriptures describe innumerable incarnations of the Supreme Lord, such as svayaà-rüpa, svayaà-prakäça, äveça, viläsa, präbhava, vaibhava, yuga-avatära, puruña-avatära, guëa-avatära, and manvantara-avatära. If we calculate the duration of one manvantara-avätara's life, it comes to an incredible number of years—more than three hundred million. And there are other incarnations who live longer. The scriptures give details of the Lord's authorized incarnations—the purposes for their appearance, their forms, the places of appearance, their pastimes, etc. There is no room for the vox populi whimsically choosing an ordinary mortal as an incarnation. And if despite the scriptural injunctions some people still accept a human being as an incarnation, it is easy to surmise the extent of their scriptural knowledge.

The goddess of learning, Sarasvaté, inspired Dr. Radhakrishnan to say "Man cannot become God." We would like to clarify this statement by saying "Even after becoming liberated, a man cannot become God." A liberated person can become a pure devotee of God, but he cannot become God or merge into God and lose his identity. There are innumerable instances in which a liberated soul, failing to become God, also refused to become God's devotee. The only option then open to him is aptly described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.2.32):

ye 'nye 'ravindäkña vimukta-mäninas
tvayy asta-bhäväd aviçuddha-buddhayaù
äruhya kåcchreëa paraà padaà tataù
patanty adho 'nädåta-yuñmad-aìghrayaù

O lotus-eyed Lord, although nondevotees who accept severe austerities and penances to achieve the highest position may think themselves liberated, their intelligence is impure. They fall down from their position of imagined superiority because they have no regard for Your lotus feet.

Attracted by material nature's external glare, such "liberated" souls have to come down to this earth and become wrapped up in some sociopolitical or altruistic work.

Besides the eternally conditioned jévas, there are others, who are eternally liberated (nitya-mukta). They never come to this material world. Among the eternally conditioned jévas (nitya-baddha) are those who make a big show of gaining liberation from this world. An analogy the Mäyävädés often repeat is "All rivers flow into the ocean." This means that all jévas merge into Brahman. But the truth that escapes them is that many large aquatics are permanent residents of the ocean and are never attracted to go and live in the river. The eternally liberated souls need not strive for liberation.

Dr. Radhakrishnan has used the expression "self-conscious man." We do not object to this term if it indicates a state of consciousness of the self in which a person realizes he is an eternal servant of God, Kåñëa. Lord Caitanya came to teach this truth. Once the jéva realizes he is an eternal servant of Lord Kåñëa, he ends his life of misery. He becomes liberated by that realization. And later he understands that liberation personified is standing nearby, waiting to serve him and all other eternal servitors of the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa.

The authorized scriptures have declared that Kåñëa is the original Supreme Lord and the source of all incarnations. In the Bhagavad-gétä (7.7), He says in His own words, mattaù parataraà nänyat: "O conqueror of wealth, there is no Truth superior to Me." Lord Kåñëa came personally to teach that the highest Absolute Truth is not an impotent material concept. He is the full manifestation of absolute spiritual potencies. Those who cannot grasp this profound truth are fools spinning out endless speculations. That person who, although one, desiresto expand and thus becomes many—can such a person be a human being or a formless impersonal entity? When this person decides to expand Himself manyfold, is He doing so in order to destroy Himself? If the Lord were to lose His own identity by expanding Himself into many, that would mean destruction of Himself. Has the Supreme Lord committed such a foolish blunder? Or has the blunder been committed by those who misinterpret the Vedic statements and say that God expanded Himself into many entities and lost His identity? The Supreme Lord can do as He pleases: He can expand Himself as countless incarnations or as multifarious separated energies. And even after expanding Himself in this way, He remains complete and fully Himself, as He is. If this were not so, then how could He be the complete Absolute Whole?

RTW 4.5: Captivated by Mäyä, the Jéva Has Forgotten Lord Kåñëa.

Captivated by Mäyä, the Jéva Has Forgotten Lord Kåñëa

Lord Kåñëa expands Himself into countless Viñëu forms as His sväàça-vaibhava, and He manifests Himself by His vibhinnäàça-prakäça as countless billions of jévas. All the Viñëu expansions are in the category of the Supreme Lord, but the jévas are not: they are the Lord's marginal potency. This marginal potency, comprising the eternal jévas, is a manifestation of the Lord's superior, spiritual energy, or parä-çakti. The conclusion of the Bhagavad-gétä is that the jéva is, was, and always will be eternally a manifestation of the Lord's spiritual energy; he will never enter the category of the Supreme Lord or the Viñëu forms. This separated energy of Kåñëa's, known as vibhinnäàça or jéva, is an infinitesimal part of the Supreme Lord, much like the minute sparks of a large conflagration.

The fraction can never become the whole or equal to the whole. Thus the Mäyävädés' claim that the fraction can become the whole is mischievous, even nefarious. This is the Vedic verdict. After overcoming his conditioned state, the fractional jéva enters the spiritual sky and participates in the Supreme Lord's transcendental, eternally blissful pastimes. The jéva permanently engages in the Lord's service in one of the many spiritual mellows and enjoys divine ecstasy.

The scriptures have clearly indicated that the ecstasy of devotional service to the Supreme Lord is far superior to the bliss of impersonal liberation, brahmänanda. Indeed, the happiness of merging into the Lord's existence (säyujya-mukti) is like a puddle of water in a calf's hoofprint compared with the ocean of bliss derived from devotional service. The devotee never prays for the jïäné's säyujya-mukti, for it is an impossible proposition. By säyujya-mukti the impersonalists mean relinquishing one's identity, or individuality. This is nothing less than spiritual suicide. In this regard, I reproduce Dr. Radhakrishnan's comment on the Bible:

The doctrine of the Incarnation agitated the Christian world a great deal. Arioes maintained that the Son is not the equal of the Father but created by Him. The view that they are not distinct but only different aspects of one Being is the theory of Sabellius. The former emphasized the distinctness of the Father and the Son and the latter their oneness. The view that finally prevailed was that the Father and the Son were equal and of the same substance; they were, however, distinct persons. ("Introductory Essay," p. 35).

These words vaguely describe the philosophy of "simultaneously one and different"; therefore we acknowledge it. Jesus, the son of God, is a jéva, a separated part of the Supreme Godhead. But the jéva is also spiritual, and hence Jesus is qualitatively the same as the Supreme Lord. But the son can never be equal to the Father in all respects; that is to say, the jéva is never on the same platform as the Supreme Lord. Also, all the jévas are separate individuals. And just as each jéva is a unique personality, so God is also a unique personality, but the difference is that He is absolute. By describing the Lord as impersonal and formless, one loses sight of His perfect wholeness. We find the Brahma-saàhitä (5.39) boldly declaring the Lord's Supreme Personality:

rämädi-mürtiñu kalä-niyamena tiñöhan
nänävatäram akarod bhuvaneñu kintu
kåñëaù svayaà samabhavat paramaù pumän yo
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

I worship Govinda the primeval Lord, who manifested Himself personally as Kåñëa and the different avatäras in the world in the forms of Räma, Nåsiàha, Vämana, etc., as His subjective portions.

All these incarnations of the Supreme Lord are full-fledged divinities. They are not influenced by anyone's whims; they do not become impersonal or formless upon someone saying so. They are eternally present. When They deem it necessary, They appear in their original transcendental forms, and then They disappear, just as the sun rises and sets. After Their appearance They perform manifest pastimes, and after Their disappearance They continue with Their unmanifest pastimes. According to the above-mentioned Brahma-saàhitä text, Lord Kåñëa is the original Supreme Personality and all the incarnations are His partial expansions. But the Lord's incarnations are never in the category of the jévas. Çréla Vyäsadeva has also expounded this truth in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.3.28): ete cäàça-kaläù puàsaù kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam. "All the above-mentioned incarnations are either plenary portions or portions of the plenary portions of the Lord, but Lord Çré Kåñëa is the original Personality of Godhead." In other words, not only do the incarnations appear, but Lord Kåñëa, the source of all incarnations, also appears, both as Himself and as an incarnation. These esoteric subjects are understood by the Lord's devotees, not by others, even though they may be erudite sholars.

Therefore, when Dr. Radhakrishnan writes that Lord Kåñëa is an ordinary mortal, or at best an extraordinary one, he is certainly confused. Lord Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the highest Absolute Truth, unsurpassable and perfectly divine. It is impossible to think of Him as impersonal and formless. He is indeed the transcendental, primeval Lord, the embodiment of eternity, absolute knowledge, and bliss. In the Bhagavad-gétä (10.12), Arjuna substantiates this truth about Lord Kåñëa's absolute, supreme divinity. How is Dr. Radhakrishnan to appreciate Lord Kåñëa's transcendental qualities and personality, since even the demigods fail to comprehend them? The word ädi-deva, meaning "the original, primeval Lord," indicates that Lord Kåñëa is the origin of all the Viñëu expansions. The Puruña-sükta prayers in the Vedas glorify Käraëodakaçäyé Viñëu, yet Lord Kåñëa is the ultimate source of even this Viñëu expansion. Indeed, the Brahma-saàhitä expressly declares that Käraëodakaçäyé Viñëu is merely a partial expansion of Lord Kåñëa. Thus the Absolute Truth Dr. Radhakrishnan accepts as eternal and beginningless is, in fact, Lord Kåñëa, but somehow this escapes him.

That Lord Kåñëa is the original Supreme Personality of Godhead is accepted not only by Arjuna but by illustrious saints and sages like Vyäsadeva, Närada, Devala, and Asita. All the previous spiritual preceptors, as well as present-day saints and countless millions of ordinary people, unanimously accept Lord Kåñëa as the Supreme Godhead, but a famous paëòita like Dr. Radhakrishnan hesitates to accept Him as God! Why? Çréla Yämunäcärya aptly explains in his Stotra-ratna [12]:

tväà çéla-rüpa-caritaiù parama-prakåñöaiù
sattvena sättvikatayä prabalaiç ca çästraiù
prakhyäta-daiva-paramärtha-vidäà mataiç ca
naiväsura-prakåtayaù prabhavanti boddhum

O my Lord, those influenced by demoniac principles cannot realize You, although You are clearly the Supreme by dint of Your exalted activities, forms, character, and uncommon power, which are confirmed by all the revealed scriptures in the quality of goodness and the celebrated transcendentalists in the divine nature.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (Chapter 4), Lord Kåñëa speaks about the importance of receiving the transcendental knowledge of the Gétä in the proper disciplic succession. In this way one can avoid making the mistakes described above, which even powerful sages are prone to make. Yet there are those who still try to study the Gétä on their own and draw their own concocted conclusions, rejecting the authority and conclusions of the spiritual disciplic succession. We certainly commiserate with them, but at the same time it is hard not to laugh at them. From the Chapter 4 of the Bhagavad-gétä we learn that after an interval of several million years, Lord Kåñëa re-established the spiritual link with the disciplic succession right in the middle of the Battlefield of Kurukñetra, explaining to Arjuna unequivocally and in detail the science of right action, knowledge, and devotional service. The Bhagavad-gétä is not a novel rendition of a new philosophy. Lord Çré Kåñëa is eternally the original Supreme Personality of Godhead. Similarly, the Bhagavad-gétä is eternally present as His instructions propounding the absolute, undifferentiated truth. The Supreme Lord is eternal, perennially young, and so are His immortal words: they are ever-fresh. Mundane scholars can always discover novel meanings in the Bhagavad-gétä, and in this way they may certainly exhibit their mundane erudition—but this is all just the play of mäyä. The real essence of Bhagavad-gétä cannot be transmitted through such persons. The transcendental knowledge of the Gétä is available only through the transparent medium of the authorized disciplic succession. The devotees and saints are solely concerned with receiving the Lord's message in the Gétä as it is, while the mundane scholars fond of word jugglery look for secondary meanings.

To educate those who are enamored by empirical arguments and who do not receive transcendental knowledge through any bona fide disciplic succession—and who are thus going astray—we have compiled the essential knowledge of the Bhagavad-gétä in a nutshell:

1) Lord Çré Kåñëa is the Supreme Absolute Truth, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the cause of all causes. The definition of God is given in this aphorism from the Vedas: "By Him and from Him is manifest this universe, and He controls its creation, sustenance, and annihilation." He is the mainstay of both this unlimited variegated cosmic manifestation and the immeasurable spiritual sky, the Vaikuëöhas. He is the eternally existing, transcendental Supreme Being with a spiritual form. The impersonal Brahman is but His bodily effulgence; He is the nondual Truth. The Supersoul (Paramätmä) is His plenary expansion who resides in everyone's heart and pervades the entire creation as well.

2) The jévas, the living entities, are Lord Kåñëa's minute parts. Although the jéva is qualitatively nondifferent from the Lord, he is quantitatively different from Him, since the Lord is infinite and jéva is infinitesimal. The jéva is situated in the Lord's marginal potency, which, inconceivably, issimultaneously one with and different from the Lord.

3) The jévas, the marginal energy of the Lord, have the ability to reside eternally either in Vaikuëöha or in this material world. A jéva falls down to material nescience because of countless sinful activities, and in these alien surroundings he goes up and down, traveling through all the planetary systems, from Lord Brahmä's planet down to Pätälaloka. In the material world the jéva experiences birth, disease, old age, and death and is forced to accept three types of suffering, namely: those miseries stemming from his own mind and body, those inflicted by other living entities, and those hurled at him by the demigods.

4) The conditioned living entities are encaged in this many-faceted prison-house called the material world. The nature of this world is creation, sustenance, and destruction. During creation and sustenance this material nature is in a manifest state, and with destruction it again becomes unmanifest. Thus this mundane, illusory realm is the Lord's inferior energy because it is sometimes manifest and at other times unmanifest.

5) Beyond this manifest and unmanifest external energy of the Lord exists another realm, which is transcendental and spiritually variegated. This is the unlimited spiritual sky, known as Vaikuëöha, which is everlasting. This realm is always manifest; it is never unmanifest. Thus it is not subject to creation and annihilation.

6) Those conditioned souls who identify with this illusory material nature and are proud of it, and who do not care to know about the Supreme Lord, are subjugated by the Lord's illusory potency, who is known variously as Mahä Kälé, Cäëòé, and Durgä, and who pierces them with her trident of the threefold miseries. These demoniac jévas are forced into slavery by the illusory potency—Kälé, or Mahämäyä. The Bhagavad-gétä, which is the essence of all the Vedic scriptures, was compiled for the deliverance of the conditioned souls. By studying the Gétä carefully, a jéva takes shelter of the Supreme Lord's lotus feet and attains liberation from the merry-go-round of repeated suffering in the material world.

7) The conditioned jéva suffers from the material disease—the miseries of birth, death, old age and disease. When this suffering becomes unbearable, he looks for help. Those who are less intelligent embrace the path of impersonal liberation and undertake severe austerities to achieve their goal. More elevated than these salvationists are the devotees of the Lord, who realize that their eternal nature is to be His servants. They do not try to extinguish this nature but rather practice and preach the eternal process of devotion so they can enter the Lord's eternal spiritual abode. All living entities have a right to practice this eternal process of devotional service.

8) The mahat-tattva, the material nature, manifests itself in twenty-four ingredients: 1) the unmanifest principle, 2) false ego, 3) intelligence, 4) mind, 5) ether, 6) air, 7) fire, 8) water, 9) earth, 10) sound, 11) touch, 12) form, 13) taste, 14) smell, 15) ears, 16) skin, 17) eyes, 18) tongue, 19) nose, 20) mouth, 21) hands, 22) feet, 23) anus, 24) genitals.

9) The undifferentiated Absolute Truth, the original Supreme Personality, Lord Çré Kåñëa, incarnates in this material world once in every day of Lord Brahmä—that is once every 8,640,000,000 solar years—to shower His mercy upon both His surrendered devotees and the atheistic nondevotees. He protects His devotees and slays the atheistic demons, thus giving the latter troublesome release, so to speak, in impersonal liberation. The Bhagavad-gétä, on the other hand, teaches liberation through devotional service to the Supreme Lord. The only way to obtain this devotional service is to take full shelter of the spiritual authority, the guru, who is coming in the line of a proper disciplic succession. Those who toil without worshiping the spiritual master will find that all their endeavors are futile.

10) Those foolish souls who refuse to take shelter of a bona fide guru are truly shelterless. Without the guidance of a guru, these rascals consider themselves knowledgeable, and on the basis of this misconception they make the mistake of worshiping God as a man and a mere mortal as God.

11) The Supreme Personality of Godhead is full in six opulences and is not the property of any particular sect, group, or country. He is available to everyone. He is the deliverer of all and the Supreme Father of all. He appears in this material world to liberate every living entity, and His message, the Bhagavad-gétä, is therefore applicable to every land and to all people. It is meant to be preached everywhere. Therefore those fortunate souls who are spreading the message of the Lord are most dear to Him.

12) Foolish, demoniac rascals in the grip of the Lord's illusory energy loudly brag about their materialistic plans. The Bhagavad-gétä alone can penetrate their hard shell of ignorance and awaken them to the truth.

13) With concerted, strong preaching, the devotees of the Lord must inform such foolish men that their so-called plans will surely be undermined because the platform they have chosen to build their dream houses on is factually a mirage—a movie only. Reality is elsewhere. The information needed to transport one to that realm of reality and truth is available in the magazine called Back to Godhead.

14) Therefore, the real symptom of a true civilization is that its citizens are inspired by Back to Godhead to take up the process of devotion and go back to Godhead, where they will eternally reside in their actual home. Only in this way can they end all futile labor.

15) Just as the most sinful wretch lives in a ghostly body after death and moves about in the ether, having been denied a gross body, so the impersonalist, although rising to the point of liberation in the transcendental position, falls back down to the material world because of not having developed the mood of loving service to the Supreme Lord. Therefore the severe austerities and penances the impersonalist performs are not equivalent to the eternal religion of devotional service.

16) When monists are so attached to the formless, impersonal aspect of the Lord that they distinguish between Him and His transcendental body, their consciousness becomes contaminated by this blasphemy, and thus they are deprived of a place in the Lord's eternal abode. But if by some good fortune they come in touch with a pure devotee and hear from him with faith about the Lord's transcendental name, qualities, pastimes, and so on, then they will certainly be cleansed of their contamination and become inspired and attracted by the Lord's glorious character, and finally they will surrender to Him fully. Thus the Bhagavad-gétä is such an instructive text that for those who want to enter into the eternal pastimes of the Supreme Lord, its unequivocal message teaches the first stages of surrender, and this surrender is absolutely essential for reaching the ultimate destination. It is to be understood that the pure devotees have successfully passed this test of surrender according to the tenets of Bhagavad-gétä.

RTW 5: The Highest Use of Intelligence

Buddhi-yoga
The Highest Use of Intelligence

RTW 5.1: The Highest Use of Intelligence

The Highest Use of Intelligence

The Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.2.32) states:

ye 'nye 'ravindäkña vimukta-mäninas
tvayy asta-bhäväd aviçuddha-buddhayaù
äruhya kåcchreëa paraà padaà tataù
patanty adho 'nädåta-yuñmad-aìghrayaù

O lotus-eyed Lord, although nondevotees who accept severe austerities and penances to achieve the highest position may think themselves liberated, their intelligence is impure. They fall down from their position of imagined superiority because they have no regard for Your lotus feet."

Thus the yogic process a surrendered servant of the Supreme Lord practices is altogether different form Pataïjali's eightfold yoga system, beginning with sense control, yogic postures, and breath control. These practices are, in a sense, meant to increase physical prowess for better sense enjoyment. The devotee, on the other hand, follows the best yoga system of God-realization, which is enunciated in the Bhagavad-gétä. His activities are not selfishly motivated, aimed at realizing his own cherished dreams, but are directed toward fulfilling the will of God on earth. This yoga is known as buddhi-yoga, wherein lies the entire world's good fortune.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (6.46-47) Lord Kåñëa states,

tapasvibhyo 'dhiko yogé
jïänibhyo 'pi mato 'dhikaù
karmibhyaç cädhiko yogé
tasmäd yogé bhavärjuna

yoginäm api sarveñäà
mad-gatenäntar-ätmanä
çraddhä-vän bhajate yo mäà
sa me yukta-tamo mataù

A yogé is greater than the ascetic, greater than the empiricist, and greater than the fruitive worker. Therefore, O Arjuna, in all circumstances be a yogé. And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all.

The devotee is placed in the highest position because his sole intention is to establish the will of the Supreme Lord in the world. Once everything in the world is conducted according to the Lord's desire, then all activities will become spiritual and the Lord's presence will be felt everywhere and in everything. For the devotee, therefore, the purpose of yoga is not to attain such mean and miserly goals as liberation or sense enjoyment, but to reestablish his loving relationship of devotional service to the Lord and to spread this truth throughout the world. He knows that without being on the platform of Brahman, one cannot render the Lord pure devotional service, the highest stage of transcendence. Yet he also knows that Brahman realization is a concomitant of the highest stage of devotional surrender. Therefore, if through devotional service he can help create an atmosphere of spirituality that will pervade the earth and make everything blissful, then why should he strive for the meager, selfish joys of liberation?

Lord Caitanya declared that the constitutional position of every living entity is to be an eternal servant of Lord Kåñëa. Therefore every jéva is inherently a liberated being. The jéva's present conditioned state is an illusion caused by his forgetting Lord Kåñëa. Lord Kåñëa says in the Bhagavad-gétä that the jéva is His separated part. The conditioned soul is enchained by the mind, senses, and so on, which are agents of mäyä, the illusory energy. The jéva is now in captivity as a result of his previous sinful activities, but why should he remain so eternally? His imprisonment can be easily ended simply by the Lord's mercy. And if the Lord's mercy is not available, then on his own the jéva can never free himself. Conceited persons who think they can obtain liberation without the Lord's mercy, simply by performing strict penances and austerities, are totally mistaken; they fail. Still, although receiving the Lord's mercy is the prime cause for attaining liberation, the Lord does not participate directly in the affairs of the conditioned soul. As the Lord states in the Bhagavad-gétä (5.14), referring both to the jéva and Himself,

na kartåvaà na karmäëi
lokasya såjati prabhuù
na karma-phala-saàyogaà
svabhävas tu pravartate

The embodied spirit, master of the city of his body, does not create activities, nor does he induce people to act, nor does he create the fruits of action. All this is enacted by the modes of material nature.

Although the above statement is true, it is under the Lord's guardianship that the jéva souls in the conditioned state experience the dualities of heat and cold, pleasure and pain, and so on, according to their activities. Since this is all indirectly controlled by the Lord, it is futile to complain about it. One should simply pray for His mercy, and all dualities will be eradicated. Therefore the Lord's devotees are never perturbed by dualities. The pious and intelligent person thinks that the sufferings inflicted upon him due to his previous sinful activities are only slight because of the Lord's mercy, and that by His mercy all suffering can be relieved in moment. As Lord Brahmä states in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.14.8),

tat te 'nukampäà su-samékñamäëo
bhuïjäna evätma-kåtaà vipäkam
håd-väg-vapurbhir vidadhan namas te
jéveta yo mukti-pade sa däya-bhäk

My dear Lord, one who earnestly waits for You to bestow Your causeless mercy upon him, all the while patiently suffering the reactions of his past misdeeds and offering You respectful obeisances with his heart, words, and body, is surely eligible for liberation, for it has become his rightful claim.

Within their hearts, the broad-minded, pure devotees of the Lord are informed of the Lord's orders and of the workings of the material nature.They are also aware that the fully independent Supreme Lord, who is eternally engaged in transcendental activities, chooses a particular land in which to unfold His earthly pastimes, and that this designated country is Bhärata-varña, or India. Therefore all Indians should execute the Supreme Lord's commands. As Çréla Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja Gosvämé says in his Caitanya-caritämåta (Ädi 9.41),

bhärata-bhümite haila manuñya-janma yära
janma särthaka kari' kara para-upakära

One who has taken his birth as a human being in the land of India [Bhärata-varña] should make his life successful and work for the benefit of all other people.

It is indeed true that Indians are especially able to benefit others world-wide. But if the Indians do not meet this responsibility and instead get enticed and bedazzled by the illusory energy as it is manifest in the West in such variegated forms, then they will become known as misers and end their lives in disgrace. The sun is not visible at night because of the rotation of the earth, yet the sun is very much present in the sky, and the entire solar system is working under its influence. Similarly, the light of India's knowledge, contained in the sublime philosophy of the Vedas, the Upaniñads, the Vedänta-sütra, the Puräëas, the Gétä, and their corollaries, is certainly available, but by divine will it is temporarily beyond our view due to the influence of ignorance and passion. Of course, by the Lord's will and by the mercy of His pure devotee, this knowledge will again spread everywhere. Lord Caitanya has made this prediction;

påthivéte äche yata nagarädi-gräma
sarvatra pracära haibe more näma
[CB Antya 4.126]

My holy name will be propagated in every town and village of this globe.

This prediction will very easily come true, for a pure devotee of the Lord can inundate the world with the tidal waves of love of Godhead, the religion preached by Lord Caitanya. Everything is possible if the Lord desires. And thus if the Lord desires, everyone can develop a loving mood of surrender to Him.

Indians must fearlessly preach the glories of the Lord far and wide. One who surrenders to the Supreme Lord, Näräyaëa, can easily face all dangers in the effort to propagate His message. As said in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (6.17.28),

näräyaëa-paraù sarve
na kutaçcana bibhyati
svargäpavarga-narakeñv
api tulyärtha-darçinaù

Devotees solely engaged in the devotional service of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Näräyaëa, never fear any condition of life. For them the heavenly planets, liberation, and the hellish planets are all the same, for such devotees are interested only in the service of the Lord.

When knowledge of the Absolute Truth, which is on the platform of pure goodness, is suppressed by the rampant influence of ignorance and passion, the sages and self-realized souls withdraw to a solitary place of worship and concentrate solely onelevating themselves spiritually. They also greatly benefit the few disciples who stay with them and serve them. But if the Lord desires, then these sages and yogés come forward to benefit the world through missionary activities. For the ultimate good of the world, saintly kings like Janaka, Yudhiñöhira, and Kärtavérya take up the burden of managing world affairs.

All the pastimes of the Supreme Lord in the spiritual world are eternal. His earthly pastimes are similarly transcendental and eternal. As the Caitanya-bhägavata states, "Even at this very moment Lord Gauräìga is enacting His eternal, transcendental pastimes, but only the most fortunate souls can see them." When the sun sets, it goes out of our sight, but it continues to shine somewhere on this globe. Similarly, when the Lord winds up His earthly pastimes, He continues to manifest them in one or more of the uncountable millions of planets in the universe. As Lord Brahmä declares in the Brahma-saàhitä (5.39):

rämädi-mürtiñu kalä-niyamena tiñöhan
nänävatäram akarod bhuvaneñu kintu
kåñëaù svayaà samabhavat paramaù pumän yo
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, who manifested Himself personally as Kåñëa and the different avatäras in the world in the forms of Räma, Nåsiàha, Vämana, etc., as His subjective portions.

The cycle of four yugas, or millenniums—namely, Satya, Tretä, Dväpara, and Kali—goes around a thousand times in one day of Lord Brahmä. The Bhagavad-gétä (8.17) confirms this: sahasra-yuga-paryantam ahar yad brahmaëo viduù. "By human calculation, a thousand ages taken together is the duration of Brahmä's one day." According to the Vedic calculation, one day of Brahmä sees the coming and going of fourteen Manus. Therefore, each Manu lives for seventy-one cycles of the four millenniums. At present we are in the period of Vaivasvata Manu, in the twenty-eighth cycle of the four millenniums, and it is the Kali-yuga. This Kali-yuga is very special, however, because Lord Caitanya appears in this age in His original form and propagates the esoteric science of pure love of Godhead. All this we learn from the scriptures. We have great expectations that this science of pure love of Godhead willbe propagated world-wide in the immediate future.

During the Satya-yuga the mode of goodness is in abundance. Or one can say that when the quality of goodness increases in a person to the extent that he becomes situated in his original constitutional identity as a servant of the Lord, thus making his human life a complete success, at that time he enjoys the bliss and tranquillity of the Satya-yuga. The three modes—goodness, passion, and ignorance—are always present in this material nature. According to the predominance of a particular mode, the yugas change from Satya to Tretä to Dväpara to Kali. The jévas in Kali-yuga are predominantly in the mode of ignorance, and with with the increase of this mode the threefold material miseries expand unlimitedly. Thus people today are afflicted by a short life-span, ill luck, warped intelligence, lethargy, disease, and many other sufferings.

Still, there is no reason to despise this age, for the most munificent incarnation of Godhead, Lord Caitanya, has appeared in Kali-yuga to shower His kindness upon the afflicted souls. The extent of the Supreme Lord's mercy is decidedly more generous in this age than in any other. In his play entitled Vidagdha-mädhava [1.2], Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé has described Lord Caitanya in this way:

anarpita-caréà cirät karuëayävatérëaù kalau
samarpayitum unnatojjvala-rasäà sva-bhakti-çriyam
hariù puraöa-sundara-dyuti-kadamba-sandépitaù
sadä hådaya-kandare sphuratu vaù çacé-nandana

May that Lord who is known as the son of Çrématé Çacédevé be transcendentally situated in the innermost chambers of your heart. Resplendent with the radiance of molten gold, He has descended in the Age of Kali by His causeless mercy to bestow what no incarnation ever offered before: the most sublime and radiant spiritual knowledge of the mellow taste of His service.

The present Kali-yuga is therefore very auspicious, for in this age one can attain the treasure ofdevotional service to the Lord that He Himself propagated. Our hope rests fully with the Lord's surrendered devotees, who are endowed with perfect knowledge of how to disseminate this transcendental science. Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé, after describing the evil aspects of Kali-yuga, sums up this subject toward the very end of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (12.3.51-52):

kaler doña-nidhe räjann
asti hy eko mahän guëaù
kértanäd eva kåñëasya
mukta-saìgaù paraà vrajet

kåte yad dhyäyato viñëuà
tretäyäà yajato makhaiù
dväpare paricaryäyäà
kalau tad dhari-kértanät

My dear king, although Kali-yuga is an ocean of faults, there is still one good quality about this age: Simply by chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra, one can become free from material bondage and be promoted to the transcendental kingdom. Whatever result was obtained in Satya-yuga by meditating on Viñëu, in Tretä-yuga by performing sacrifices, and Dväpara-yuga by serving the Lord's lotus feet can be obtained in the Kali-yuga simply by chanting the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra.

The word hari-kértana used in these verses, which means "singing or chanting the glories of Kåñëa," could very well apply to the Bhagavad-gétä, the song sung by God Himself. The promulgation of the Bhagavad-gétä's knowledge on a world-wide scale will establish a foundation upon which the edifice of the science of love of God will be constructed. This edifice will be the repository of the sublime treasure of devotional service as taught by Lord Caitanya in Kali-yuga, and it will serve as a shining monument to the transcendental endeavors of the Lord's pure devotees.

At present only a small portion of the knowledge contained in the Vedas, Vedänta-sütra, and Upaniñads is available to the general populace. What is noteworthy, however, is that the essence of all Vedic knowledge is available in the Gétopaniñad, popularly known as the Bhagavad-gétä. Lord Kåñëa milked the cow of the Upaniñads, and Arjuna drank the milk thus obtained—the Bhagavad-gétä. If Arjuna found time to hear the Bhagavad-gétä in the middle of a battlefield at Kuruksetra, then what urgent business is stopping us from hearing the Gétä? When knowledge of the Gétä spreads, then everyone will easily be able to attain the platform of yoga. And as the pure devotees of the Lord become successful in their efforts to use their spiritual intelligence in the Lord's service, then the science of love of God taught by Lord Caitanya, the most magnanimous incarnation of Godhead, will be distributed everywhere. Judging from all the symptoms, the time is now ripe. Indians should now take shelter of their saintly preceptors, the pure devotees, and unitedly propagate the glorification of Kåñëa via the medium of the Bhagavad-gétä. In this way the world will become prosperous and perfect. The present age has seen interest in spiritual matters markedly increase. Yoga and meditation societies have mushroomed expressly to transmit the knowledge of the Bhagavad-gétä, but how this will be accomplished is still a question. We are confident that Lord Caitanya's teachings on the process of loving devotional service will easily harmonize all conflicting concepts.

The most effective method for directing humanity toward a positive and favorable consciousness is available in India. Any person, under any circumstances, can reach an elevated state of consciousness by properly hearing the Bhagavad-gétä, and then, by constantly chanting the name of God, he can win God over. The present state of world affairs is full of foreboding, strife, and struggle. These are the effects of Kali-yuga. But our faith in the eternal nature of jéva prompts us to believe that anyone can attain devotional service to Kåñëa simply by hearing and chanting His name and thereby awakening his inherent dormant love for Him. We have full faith in the words of Çréla Çukadeva Gosvämé quoted above from the Çrémad-Bhägavatam—that simply by chanting the name of Kåñëa one can reach His eternal kingdom.

Therefore all signs point toward auspicious changes in the global consciousness. But these changes must be initiated from within every individual's heart; they are impossible to accomplish through political lobbying or social adjustments. The devotional feelings that reach out from within the hearts of men find their culmination in the pure devotees' spiritual perfection. In the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa describes this spiritual perfection as bhakti-yoga, or buddhi-yoga, the yoga of devotional service. At a certain stage, all the systems of yoga become obsolete and have to be discarded—except for buddhi-yoga. The Lord says (Bhagavad-gétä 2.39-40) that a little progress on this path gives immense results:

eñä te 'bhihitä säìkhye
buddhir yoge tv imäà çåëu
buddhyä yukto yayä pärtha
karma-bandhaà prahäsyasi

nehäbhikrama-näço 'sti
pratyaväyo na vidyate
sv-alpam apy asya dharmasya
träyate mahato bhayät

Thus far I have declared to you the analytical knowledge of säìkhya philosophy. Now listen to the knowledge of yoga whereby one works without fruitive result. O son of Påthä, when you act by such intelligence, you can free yourself from the bondage of works. In this endeavor there is no loss or diminution, and a little advancement on this path can protect one from the most dangerous type of fear.

Real yoga is buddhi-yoga, the yoga of devotional service, which brings about direct perception of the Supreme Lord. When the devotee meets the Lord face to face, liberation takes the form of a woman and is at his beck and call, eager to serve him, and she is accompanied by personified material opulence, sense pleasure, and religiosity, all of whom wait upon the devotee like servants. The pure devotees of the Lord are all embodiments of perfection in yoga; thus the four Vedic goals are truly at their beck and call. And beyond these four goals is the supreme destination: superconsciousness, or God consciousness. This is the fifth and paramount Vedic goal. One who has reached the state of unalloyed Kåñëa consciousness isan extremely rare personality—one in a million devotees, according Lord Caitanya.

Such an elevated state of consciousness is the last word in yoga. None of the other yoga processes, such as haöha-yoga or räja-yoga, can bring one to this platform. Buddhi-yoga lies far above these yoga practices, which are mostly physical disciplines. Buddhi-yoga, however, is a spiritual discipline for self-realization. This realization is a full perception of the nondual Absolute Truth, whereby one sees everything resting in the Supreme Lord and the Supreme Lord in everything. As Lord Kåñëa explains in the Bhagavad-gétä (7.7):

mattaù parataraà nänyät
kiïcid asti dhanaïjaya
mayi sarvam idaà protaà
sütre maëi-gaëä iva

O conqueror of wealth [Arjuna], there is no Truth superior to Me. Everything rests upon Me, as pearls are strung on a thread.

This means that every living entity, from demons to demigods to human beings to lower creatures, is fully dependent on the Supreme Lord. One who perceives the Absolute Truth in this way can wholeheartedly surrender to the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

The vision of a pure devotee is described by Lord Kåñëa in the Bhagavad-gétä (15.19-20):

yo mäm evam asammüòho
jänäti puruñottamam
sa sarva-vid bhajati mäà
sarva-bhävena bhärata

iti guhyatamaà çästram
idam uktaà mayänagha
etad buddhvä buddhimän syät
kåta-kåtyaç ca bhärata

Whoever knows Me as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, without doubting, is to be understood as the knower of everything, and he therefore engages himself in full devotional service, O son of Bharata. This is the most confidential part of the Vedic scriptures, O sinless one, and it is disclosed now by Me. Whoever understands this will become wise, and his endeavors will know perfection.

Once a person surrenders fully to the Lord's lotus feet, he sees the Lord's from everywhere, not this world of moving and nonmoving matter. Such surrender has six limbs:

änukülyasya saìkalpaù
prätikülyasya varjanam
rakñiñyatéti viçväso
goptåtve varaëaà tathä
ätma-nikñepa-kärpaëye
ñaò-vidhä çaraëägatiù

The six divisions of surrender are the acceptance of those things favorable to devotional service, the rejection of unfavorable things, the conviction that Kåñëa will give protection, the acceptance of the Lord as one's guardian or master, full surrender, and humility. [H.b.v. 11.676]

The relationship between the Supreme Lord and His surrendered devotee is very intimate. Everything about the devotee is known to the Lord. The devotee has no separate interest that would involve him in speculative knowledge, fruitive activities, sense pleasures, lamentation, meditation, and so on. He simply engages full-time in serving the Supreme Lord. His consciousness becomes purified of all contamination, and the fire of conditioned life is put out. Duality and illusion is eradicated from his heart, his devotion to Lord Kåñëa becomes single-minded, and He throws himself at the Lord's lotus feet, feeling like a sold-out animal. At this stage the Supreme Lord Himself imparts all spiritual knowledge, or buddhi-yoga, to the devotee so that he can attain Him:

teñäà satata-yuktänäm
bhajatäà préti-pürvakam
dadämi buddhi-yogaà taà
yena mäm upayänti te

teñäm evänukampärtham
aham ajïäna-jaà tamaù
näçayämy ätma-bhäva-stho
jïäna-dépena bhäsvatä

To those who are constantly devoted and worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me. Out of compassion for them, I, dwelling in their hearts, destroy with the shining lamp of knowledge the darkness born of ignorance. (Bhagavad-gétä 10.10-11)

When the devotee adopts such a mood of surrender and complete dependence, everything easily happens by the Lord's desire. Even if the process of surrender somehow remains incomplete, the devotee achieves the ends attainable through other yogic practices. As the Lord says, "A little advancement on this path protects one from the most dangerous type of fear." In other words, the Supreme Lord personally intervenes and arranges for His surrendered devotee's success in spiritual life. Is there any doubt that once the Lord's divine energy is active, all our artificial endeavors are most insignificant and futile? The Lord's inconceivable potency that descends to bless us with spiritual perfection shows the magnitude and glory of His potencies. Certainly there are other methods for spiritual advancement, such as räja-yoga, by which one can become equipoised, or difficult präëäyäma exercises, severe austerities, and renunciation, and these practices are very powerful. But when the Lord's divine potency acts, they all seem extremely ineffectual compared to the process of surrender, which invokes that potency. All these other methods, though very potent, are human endeavors. So how can they compare with the Supreme Lord's divine potency? With this divine potency the Lord blesses particular persons in particular circumstances.

The first limb of surrender is to accept that which helps us invoke the Lord's mercy. This means to completely depend on the Lord's will. Such surrender is free from any conditions. It is untinged by the desire for sense pleasure, liberation, or mystic perfections. The devotee, unlike others, is never in anxiety. His only concern is to execute the will of the Lord. In this connection, Çréla Vyäsadeva says,

If a surrendered soul tries to arrange for food and shelter but does not succeed, or if, once having these things, he loses them, then despite such reverses he remains unperturbed and simply remembers the Supreme Lord, Hari.

It is true that when one prays sincerely at the Lord's lotus feet, the Lord generally fulfills one's wishes. But those who have completely surrendered to the Lord, throwing themselves at the His lotus feet, do not pray to the Him for anything material. Yet the Lord automatically provides for all their needs. As Lord Kåñëa assures us in the Gétä (9.22):

ananyäç cintayanto mäà
ye janäù paryupäsate
teñäà nityäbhiyuktänäà
yoga-kñemaà vahämy aham

But those who worship Me with devotion, meditating on My transcendental form—to them I carry what they lack and preserve what they have.

The single-minded devotees are surrendered souls. They can perceive how the Lord's potencies are working. They feel no anxiety if sometimes the Lord's mercy does not manifest, even after long pleading and prayers, for they have unflinching conviction that the Lord will protect them under all circumstances. The mood of the present age is not spiritually conducive, and hence it is difficult to develop a high degree of faith in the Lord. Still, it is certain that faith in the Lord never goes in vain. In the beginning we may be somewhat hesitant to accept this fact, but in time we come to understand that the Supreme Lord is always protecting us.

At times, when doubts and restlessness assail us, we must remain fixed in our resolve. The best remedy for doubts is to seek the association of saintly persons. Saintly souls who are learned in the conclusions of the revealed scriptures and have realized the Supreme Lord can dissipate our doubts and calm our restless mind with unequivocal instructions and exemplary actions. When Kåñëa conscious topics, which are both very potent and nectarean to the ears and heart, are heard and discussed in the association of saints, then faith inthe Supreme Lord gradually increases, along with attraction and devotion to Him. Faith inspires initial surrender, and later, by the powerful influence of saintly association, one's faith deepens and becomes steady. Once faith becomes steady, all mental agitations and doubts clear up due to constant worship of the Lord. One then practices bhajana (chanting meditation) of a very esoteric and elevated nature, and this leads one to the stage of love of Godhead. To attain this state, saintly association is imperative; there is no substitute. Therefore it is said:

'sädhu-saìga', 'sädhu-saìga''sädhu-saìga'—sarvasarva-çästre kaya
lava-mätra sädhu-saìge sarva-siddhi haya

The verdict of all revealed scriptures is that by even a moment's association with a pure devotee, one can attain all success. (Cc. Madhya 22.54)

And how the Lord feels about sädhus is revealed by the Lord Himself in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (9.4.68):

sädhavo hådayaà mahyaà
sädhünäà hådayaà tv aham
mad-anyat te na jänanti
nähaà tebhyo manäg api

The pure devotee is always within the core of My heart, and I am always in the heart of the pure devotee. My devotees do not know anything else but Me, and I do not know anyone else but them.

The Lord always resides in the heart of His pure devotees, and so they have the potency to purify the places of pilgrimage, which become heavily laden with the sins deposited there by all the pilgrims. These are some of the glories of the Lord's pure, surrendered devotees.

Lord Kåñëa says In the Bhagavad-gétä (18.58), mac-cittaù sarva-durgäëi mat-prasädät tariñyasi: "If you become conscious of Me, you will pass over all the obstacles of conditioned life by My grace." Therefore fruitive activity, the search for empirical knowledge, and mystic yoga all culminate in surrender to the Supreme Lord. As Lord Kåñëa says in the Gétä (18.66):

sarva-dharmän parityajya
mäm ekaà çaraëaà vraja
ahaà tväà sarva-päpebhyo
mokñayiñyämi mä çucaù

Abandon all varieties of religion and surrender unto Me. I will deliver you from all sinful reactions. Do not fear.

When the Supreme Lord has agreed to personally take responsibility for our protection, what is there to fear? When He who is omnipotent and the maintainer of the entire cosmic creation is willing to take charge of our life, then what objection can we have to surrendering to Him? If I am guaranteed the protection of the Supreme Personality, who creates, maintains, and destroys this limitless cosmic manifestation simply by His will, then what is left for me to desire? If we try in the proper way to realize the Supreme Lord's potencies, He will certainly reveal them to us as they are. How much can we accomplish with our puny physical and mental abilities? Real success in yoga comes only by fully surrendering to His lotus feet.

However, since it is not possible to attain such a mood of complete surrender in a moment, we should also not expect the Lord's mercy to manifest before us instantaneously. Although the Lord, and sometimes even His devotees, perform miracles, still we must not expect such extraordinary things to happen to us. Of course, it is certain that the degree of mercy the Lord bestows upon us is much greater than our degree of surrender to Him. Another danger is this: If we were to receive all His mercy at once, we would become corrupt and fallen, like many yogés who attain mystic perfection. Better that we continue to perform our duties in a regulated way, with patience and enthusiasm; then undoubtedly we will receive the Lord's full mercy.

Both the Vedas and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam describe the conditioned soul with the same analogy: On the tree-like human body reside two similar birds. One is the Supreme Soul, the Paramätmä feature of the Supreme Lord, and the other is the jéva soul. One bird, the jéva, is enjoying the fruits of material existence, while the other remains aloof, replete with all His transcendental potencies. The jéva soul must surrender to the Supreme Soul and relish the fruits given to him by the Lord.

The Lord says that His external potency—Mahä-mäyä, or Kälé—serves Him in the form of the internal, spiritual potency. The jéva must allow this spiritual potency to influence him freely, without interference from the false ego, which makes the him think he is the doer. Thus surrendering to the Lord is the method prescribed to reach the highest stages of devotional service.

The Çvetäñvatara Upaniçad says, paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate: "The Supreme Lord's potencies are multifarious." These potencies act in different capacities at different levels: On the platform of jëäna, empirical knowledge, they manifest in a particular way, different from any other. On the spiritual, transcendental platform, these potencies produce variegated spiritual manifestations. These potencies can be known if one attains perfection in Kåñëa consciousness. On the platform of material nature, the senses are superior to the body as a whole, mind is superior to the senses, the intelligence is superior to the mind, and the soulis subtler and better than the intelligence. On the spiritual platform, when the pure soul is situated in his original spiritual identity, he renders devotional service to the absolute embodiment of sweet transcendence, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This devotional service is imbued with the partial expansion of hlädiné-çakti, the Lord's pleasure-giving potency.

Great thinkers and philosophers like Çré Aurobindo describe this stage as vijëänänanda, "the pure bliss of realized knowledge." Jesus Christ called it "the kingdom of heaven." By contrast, when one tries to enjoy mundane pleasures on the material plane, spiritual bliss becomes smothered and lies dormant, in a slumbering state. Perfection in yoga, therefore, is marked by the awakening of spiritual bliss. And when one is strongly drawn to this blissful state, one attains to the transcendental abode of the Supreme Lord. Iron in constant touch with fire develops the properties of fire. Similarly, when the jéva in the material nature rises to the state of spiritual bliss by means of devotional service, his spiritual consciousness awakens and he becomes oblivious of this phenomenal world. In the Bhagavad-gétä (12.8-9) Lord Kåñëa tells us how to increase the influence of His spiritual energy upon us:

mayy eva mana ädhatsva
mayi buddhià niveçaya
nivasiñyasi mayy eva
ata ürdhvaà na saàçayaù

atha cittaà samädhätuà
na çaknoñi mayi sthiram
abhyäsa-yogena tato
mäm icchäptuà dhanaïjaya

Just fix your mind upon Me, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and engage all your intelligence in Me. Thus you will live in Me always, without a doubt. My dear Arjuna, O winner of wealth, if you cannot fix your mind upon Me without deviation, then follow the regulative principles of bhakti-yoga. In this way you will develop a desire to attain Me.

When a person fixes his mind on the eternal, exquisite form of Çyämasundara, the blackish, beautiful Lord Kåñëa, all distress and anguish are vanquished. In the initial stages, the attempt to fix the mind on Kåñëa may be unsuccessful, but with regulated practice (abhyäsa-yoga) it becomes possible. Abhyäsa-yoga means sincere engagement in the ninefold process of bhakti, beginning with hearing and chanting the holy name, pastimes, and so on, of Lord Kåñëa. Proper execution of abhyäsa-yoga culminates in the awakening of divine consciousness, or superconsciousness. This is true success.

The modern sage Çré Aurobindo has explained that in the third stage of yoga practice, the yogé sees God everywhere. In the process of jïäna-yoga, or the cultivation of empirical knowledge, whenthe yogé attains impersonal Brahman realization he sees Brahman as all-pervasive and inactive. This realization is bereft of any understanding of the Lord's name, form, qualities, pastimes, or paraphernalia. But if these transcendental topics arrest our attention, one very soon begins following the path of bhakti-yoga—the path enunciated in the Vedas, Upaniñads, and Bhagavad-gétä. A transformation of vision takes place as one advances on this path. The rare soul who perfects this process can see the Supreme Lord in everything and everything in relation to the Supreme Lord. Quotes from various scriptures substantiate this point: In the Bhagavad-gétä the Lord says, väsudevaù sarvam iti sa mahätmä sudurlabhaù: "[The surrendered devotee knows] Me to be the cause of all causes and all that is. Such a great soul is very rare." And the Upaniñads state, sarvaà khalv idaà brahma: "Everything is permeated by Brahman." A person attains the highest stage of this realization when he sees this cosmic creation as a transformation and manifestation of the Supreme Lord's divine energies. Çré Närada instructed Çréla Vyäsadeva with the following words:

idaà hi viçvaà bhagavän ivetaro
yato jagat-sthäna-nirodha-sambhaväù
tad dhi svayaà veda bhaväàs tathäpi te
prädeça-mätraà bhavataù pradarçitam

The Supreme Personality of Godhead is Himself this cosmos, and still He is aloof from it. From Him only has this cosmic manifestation emanated, in Him it rests, and unto Him it enters after annihilation. Your good self knows all about this. I have given only a synopsis. [Bhäg. 1.5.20]

In this stage of realization, the eternal truth is no longer covered by the illusory, mundane pall of impersonal omnipresence, and what shines forth is the absolute spiritual personality. The fullest manifestation of that spiritual personality is Çré Kåñëa, the transcendental form of eternity, knowledge, and bliss, who is beyond the manifested and unmanifested material cosmos. As the Brahma-saàhitä [5.1] explains:

éçvaraù paramaù kåñëaù
sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù
anädir ädir govindaù
sarva-käraëa-käraëam

Kåñëa who is known as Govinda is the Supreme Godhead. He has an eternal blissful spiritual body [sac-cid-änanda-vigrahaù]. He is the origin of all. He has no other origin and He is the prime cause of all causes.

The impersonal Brahman is the transcendental bodily effulgence of the Supreme Lord's sac-cid-änanda form, and the illusory and transitory material nature is a transformation of His separated energy.

Although the sac-cid-änanda Supreme Personality is a permanent resident of His own eternal abode, Goloka Våndävana, He manifests Himself in His all-pervasive universal form and is present throughout this cosmic creation by means of His partial expansion, the Supersoul. As the Brahma-saàhitä (5.37 and 5.43)states,

änanda-cinmaya-rasa-pratibhävitäbhis
täbhir ya eva nija-rüpatayä kaläbhiù
goloka eva nivasaty akhilätma-bhüto
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

goloka-nämni nija-dhämni tale ca tasya
devé-maheça-hari-dhämasu teñu teñu
te te prabhäva-nicayä vihitäç ca yena
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

I worship Govinda, the primeval Lord, residing in His own realm, Goloka, with Rädhä, resembling His own spiritual figure, the embodiment of the ecstatic potency possessed of the sixty-four artistic activities, in the company of Her confidantes [sakhés], embodiments of the extensions of Her bodily form, permeated and vitalized by His ever-blissful spiritual rasa.

Lowest of all is located Devé-dhäma [mundane world], next above it is Maheça-dhäma [abode of Maheça]; above Maheça-dhäma is placed Hari-dhäma [abode of Hari] and above them all is located Kåñëa's own realm named Goloka. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda, who has allotted their respective authorities to the rulers of those graded realms.

Lord Govinda is the Supreme Personality, unsurpassable, the topmost being, the unlimited Godhead. He is known as Kåñëa because He attracts everyone by His extraordinary transcendental pastimes. It is therefore unanimously accepted that all His other names and expansions are partial. As the Çrémad-Bhägavatam declares, ete cäàça-kaläù puàsaù kåñëas tu bhagavän svayam: "All these incarnations of Godhead are either plenary portions or portions of the plenary portions of the Lord, but Lord Çré Kåñëa is the original Personality of Godhead."

Thus Lord Çré Kåñëa is the original, beginningless, and supreme Personality of Godhead, and this material universe is simply part of His unlimited energy. We may now reject this material world as illusory, but one day, with Kåñëa conscious vision, we will see its intimate connection with the Lord. In this stage of spiritual vision we will see material things as objects of neither exploitation nor rejection. Such transcendental vision is attained by the process of buddhi-yoga, or bhakti-yoga. We will then clearly see the truth of the following verse from the Brahma-saàhitä (5.51):

agnir mahé gaganam ambu marud diçaç ca
kälas tathätma-manaséti jagat-trayäëi
yasmäd bhavanti vibhavanti viçanti yaà ca
govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi

The three worlds are composed of the nine elements, viz., fire, earth, ether, water, air, direction, time, soul, and mind. I adore the primeval Lord Govinda from whom they originate, in whom they exist and into whom they enter at the time of the universal cataclysm.

Once one is fixed in transcendental realization, all distress, lamentation, illusion, fear, and so on, are immediately eradicated. The soul is assailed by these miseries as long as he harbors the delusion that something exists outside of Kåñëa. Therefore when one is situated in transcendence, one feels happiness even in this world. The mundane conception of life is a product of the three modes of material nature, which affect the mind and senses. But when one's vision is transformed through buddhi-yoga, one sees everything as having a direct link with Kåñëa. The material elements, such as fire, water, ether, and mind, along with the directions, the soul, and time—everything material and spiritual, personal and impersonal—all reflect Kåñëa, the Supreme Being. When one reaches this state of realization, the dualities and illusion of sin and piety, happiness and distress, are dissolved by the ecstatic harmony of transcendence. In one Upaniñad there is a statement that once a person experiences the happiness derived from Brahman realization, he no longer has anything to fear. A verse from the Éçopaniñad (7) conveys a similar mood:

yasmin sarväëi bhütäny
ätmaiväbhüd vijänataù
tatra ko mohaù kaù çoka
ekatvam anupaçyataù

One who always sees all living entities as spiritual sparks, in quality one with the Lord, becomes a true knower of things. What, then, can be illusion or anxiety for Him?

Self-realization leads to the understanding that everything is situated in the Supreme Lord. At that time there is no more illusion or lamentation, and everything is wonderfully harmonized. One sees the whole material universe as a manifestation of unity in diversity. On this platform everything is full of happiness, knowledge, and eternity. This is the platform of Brahman realization.

In this realized state, we perceive Lord Näräyaëa's presence not only in all living beings but also in all nonliving things. When the darkness of ignorance cloaking our consciousness is dissipated by the merciful light of knowledge emanating from the spiritual master, we gain spiritual vision and can see that every object is directly linked with the Supreme Lord.

There are various stages of elevation the jéva goes through, which are like different shells (koñas) covering him. They are the coverings of food (anna-maya), life air (präëa-maya), mind (mano-maya, or jïäna-maya), and transcendental knowledge (vijïäna-maya). When the final shell is penetrated, the soul attains pure consciousness, enters the state of complete bliss (änanda-maya), and experiences sac-cid-änanda as universal. First the soul has covered consciousness, then he reaches the stage of budding consciousness, then blossoming consciousness, and finally fully blossomed consciousness. And all the while he experiences a gradual expansion of bliss—but only in relation to Lord Kåñëa and His devotional service. At the final stage, flowers, fruits, plants, trees, clay—all objects and elements—become spiritualized by being used in Lord Kåñëa's service. In other words, nothing is seen to be separate from the Lord. As the Éçopaniñad (1) explains, éçäväsyam idaà sarvaà: "Everything animate or inanimate that is within this universe is controlled and owned by the Lord."

To see God everywhere and in every living entity is not the final word in self-realization; one needs to see Him in all events, in every activity, in every thought influencing everyone's life, including one's own. Two things are indispensable for acquiring such a vision: first we must offer the results of all our activities to Lord Kåñëa, and second, every action we perform must be done exclusively as devotional service to Him. We must constantly meditate on the fact that Lord Kåñëa is the only enjoyer and proprietor of every action. As the Lord says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.24, 27),

ahaà hi sarva-yajïänäà
bhoktä ca prabhur eva ca
na tu mäm abhijänanti
tattvenätaç cyavanti te

yat karoñi yad açnäsi
yaj juhoñi dadäsi yat
yat tapasyasi kaunteya
tat kuruñva mad-arpaëam

I am the only enjoyer and the only object of sacrifice. Those who do not recognize My true transcendental nature fall down. O son of Kunté, all that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you may perform, should be done as an offering unto Me.

Considering everything material, some people make a show of renunciation and reject even those things that can be used in the Lord's service. This is futile. All objects in the material world are meant not for our enjoyment or gratification but for the Lord's service. This is the mood of one in transcendental consciousness, or superconsciousness. And all activities performed in this consciousness constitute true renunciation, or yukta-vairägya, as opposed to false renuniciation, or phalgu-vairägya. By instructing Arjuna to act in this way, the Supreme Lord has ordered usto do so as well. It is our duty to execute His instruction. Whatever the result may be, we must be convinced that all such activities are all-auspicious. As the Lord says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.28):

çubhäñubha-phalair evaà
mokñyase karma-bandhanaiù
sannyäsa-yoga-yuktätmä
vimukto mäm upaiñyasi

In this way you will be freed from all reactions to good and evil deeds, and by this principle of renunciation you will be liberated and come to Me.

Real perfection in yoga comes when we forget our personal demands and determine what service the Lord wants from us. Personal interest must be sacrificed, along with our conceptions of good and bad, right and wrong, necessary and unnecessary, ans so on. We must emulate that great warrior Arjuna and try to find out what service the Supreme Lord wants from us. Such Kåñëa conscious activities alone will lead us to the full consummation of all our duties, and the results will be all-auspicious. This degree of fixed faith is indispensable to progress. In the Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.62), Çréla Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja defines this faith:

'çraddhä'-çabde—viçväsa kahe sudådha niçcaya
kåñëe bhakti kaile sarva-karma kåta haya

By rendering transcendental loving service to Kåñëa, one automatically performs all subsidiary activities. This confident, firm faith, favorable to the discharge of devotional service, is called çraddhä.

We need to accept one fact: The energy of the omnipotent Supreme Lord, which carries out the work of creation, maintenance, and annihilation, is in no respect inferior to our puny potency. Therefore God does not have to consult anyone about His or our difficulties or advantages. The question is, What is our duty? In the Bhagavad-gétä (4.16-17) the Lord says,

kià karma kim akarmeti
kavayo 'py atra mohitäù
tat te karma pravakñyämi
yaj jïätvä mokñyase 'çubhät

karmaëo hy api boddhavyaà

boddhavyaà ca vikarmaëaù

akarmaëaç ca boddhavyaà

gahanä karmaëo gatiù

Even the intelligent are bewildered in determining what is action and what is inaction. Now I shall explain to you what action is, knowing which you shall be liberated from all sins. The intricacies of action are very hard to understand. Therefore one should know properly what action is, what forbidden action is, and what inaction is.

The confidential truth about what constitutes good action is almost impenetrable. Some hold that good action consists of executing one's socialresponsibilities. This is what common men generally understand by good action. But a few verses after the ones quoted above, Lord Kåñëa uses the phrase brahma-karma to describe good action, and the word brahma points to Brahman. Therefore some say work done on the platform of Brahman is good action. Others say that good action includes works beneficial for the self, the society, the nation, and humanity at large. When a person acts with such lofty intentions, he is surely known as a good man. Indeed, his actions are certainly noble compared with those of persons with warped mentalities. This kind of action is not buddhi-yoga, however, because such philanthropic works can at best replace one set of people's mundane desires with a new set, but they can never completely root out these unwanted desires from within the heart. Philanthropic activities cannot prepare us for unalloyed devotional service, which is uncontaminated by empirical knowledge and fruitive action.

Individual material cravings are less harmful to the world than mass movements for sense gratification. If the material desires of an individual are unfulfilled, he certainly becomes depressed, but when the mass of people remain dissatisfied, the distress is much greater and gives rise to social conflict. In any case, mundane yearnings bring suffering, both individual or collective. Even if a person starts out not intending enjoy the fruits of his actions, once those fruits come he is forced to enjoy them because he thinks of himself as the doer, influenced as he is by the three modes nature—goodness, passion, and ignorance. These fruits are not without the bitter seeds of anxiety, entanglement, frustration, and disruption. Therefore, neither the execution of social responsibilities nor philanthropic work is ultimately good action. Devotional service to the Supreme Lord, which is beyond the three modes, must be accepted as the only good action.

The noble Arjuna thoroughly analyzed what was good and bad, what was his duty and not his duty, and decided not to take up arms to fight. Then Lord Kåñëa, understanding that Arjuna was motivated by self-gratificatory social sentiments and sheer selfish interests, gave him two kinds of instructions: The first dealt with the process by which the conditioned jéva attains liberation; the second taught Arjuna how the liberated soul can surrender to the Lord and render pure devotional service. Authorized scriptures like Bhagavad-gétä contain the transcendental teachings of the Lord Himself or of self-realized personalities. These scriptures are free from the four human frailties, that is, illusion, mistakes, limited senses, and the cheating propensity. Thus the scriptural injunctions have always remained pristine, despite childish attempts by imperfect men to distort them. Such scriptural instructions not only teach self-control and the elevation of consciousness, but they also help rid us of false ego, bring us to the stage of goodness, and offer us ultimate liberation.

Uncorrupted by any kind of discrepancy or mistake, the Vedas out as the most ancient religious texts in the world. Every human being has a right to follow their edicts, along with the instructions contained in other books of Vedic literature. The Vedic literature consists of the çruti (the Vedas and Upaniñads) and the småti (the Vedänta-sütra, the Puraëas, Itihäsas like the Mahäbhärata and Rämäyaëa, the Païcarätras, and finally the Çrémad-Bhägavatam). The Çrémad-Bhägavatam is the natural commentary on the Vedänta-sütra and offers solid education on how to conduct life perfectly. In recent ages the småti texts have become prominent and influenced human thought and action. All these scriptures fully support the varëäçrama system of four social and four religious orders. But what is today being labeled varëäçrama is an atheistic concept totally unsupported by the scriptures. Real varëäçrama is based not on birth but on people's qualities and activities. One cannot reach the goal of the scriptures by practicing today's demoniac caste system. Only the introduction of daivé-varëäçrama, the transcendental varëäçrama system, will serve the purpose of the scriptures. This will move humanity toward liberation.

It is not at all difficult to compromise the real purport of the magnificent scriptural edicts by selfish motivations and a cheating mentality. When this happens, people aspire for show-bottle religiosity, material gain, sense enjoyment, and impersonal liberation. On the other hand, sincere observance of the scriptural injunctions leads to all-round success in life.

It is not enough to take only the first steps toward liberation. We must strive to reach the final goal within this very life-time. To achieve this end, it is imperative that we approach a spiritual master well-versed in the Vedas and take instruction from him on how to follow the scriptural rules. These rules are meant for the conditioned souls, not the liberated souls who are fully surrendered to the Lord's lotus feet; they have transcended the rules and regulations of the scriptures and can be called paramahaàsas—self-realized pure devotees.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (3.27) Lord Kåñëa says:

prakåteù kriyamäëäni
guëaiù karmäëi sarvaçaù
ahaìkära-vimüòhätmä
kartäham iti manyate

The bewildered spirit soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself to be the doer of activities, which are in actuality carried out by nature.

Success in any activity depends on five essential factors: the place, the doer, the tools or senses, the endeavor, and finally the sanction of the Supreme Lord. Of these, the Supreme Lord's blessing is the most important. This sanction is enacted through the Supreme Lord's favorable supervision of His material energy, for it is by the Lord's will that material nature acts. Material nature acts according to one's consciousness: when the living entity is under the influence of the three modes of nature, his actions are conducted by the Lord's external energy, the material nature. But when he is in transcendental consciousness, the çuddha-sattva state, his actions are conducted by the Lord's internal, spiritual potency. The living entity can choose to have his activities conducted by either the Lord's external energy or His internal energy. This is the extent of the jéva's minute independence.

The moment the spirit soul surrenders completely at the lotus feet of the Supreme Lord and prays to Him for engagement in His loving devotional service, the soul is freed from the bondage of fruitive reactions. In this stage he proves the truth of the scriptural injunction jévera svarüpa haya kåñëera nitya-däsa: "In his original spiritual identity, the spirit soul is an eternal servant of Kåñëa." This position gives the soul immense bliss. It is wrong to equate the position of an eternal servant of Kåñëa with that of a slave of mäyä, the illusory potency of Kåñëa. In other words, the feelings of power and pleasure gained by lording it over matter are insignificant compared to the ecstacy one feels in the Lord's service. Even the eight kinds of mystic perfections are puny compared with the bliss of being an eternal servant of Kåñëa. And surrender is the only means to attain this state; no artificial method can be applied. The awakening of pure Kåñëa consciousness, which is the perfection of the living entity, is obtained only by surrendering to the Lord, the propensity for which is eternally inherent in the jéva. Hence Lord Caitanya says in the Caitanya-caritämåta (Madhya 22.107):

nitya-siddha-kåñëa-prema 'sädhya' kabhu naya
çravaëädi-çuddha-citte karaye udaya

Pure love for Kåñëa is eternally established in the hearts of living entities. It is not something to be gained from another source. When the heart is purified by hearing and chanting, the living entity naturally awakens.

In the Bhagavad-gétä (18.61) Lord Kåñëa states:

éçvaraù sarva-bhütänäà
håd-deçe 'rjuna tiñöhati
bhrämayan sarva-bhütäni
yanträrüòhäni mäyayä

The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone's heart, O Arjuna, and is directing the wanderings of all living entities, who are seated as on a machine, made of the material energy.

The Lord is present in everyone's heart by His inconceivable spiritual potency. He also directs the movements of the jévas by means of His material energy, consisting of the three modes of nature. After placing the jévas in a material body, the Lord controls their wanderings. The intelligence of those jévas who surrender to the Lord is fixed in devotional service, and so they are never again attracted to mundane activities. Transcending the three modes, they dispassionately observe all activities within the realm of the three modes.

In the early stages of devotional service one may be apprehensive because of reactions to sins and pious deeds. All this is due to previous habits. But if one fully surrenders to the Supreme Lord, the Lord Himself burns to ashes all reactions to pious and impious deeds. As stated in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (2.7.42):

yeñäà sa eña bhagavän dayayed anantaù
sarvätmanäçrita-pado yadi nirvyalékam
te dustaräm atitaranti ca deva-mäyäà
naiñäà mamäham iti dhéù çva-çågäla-bhakñye

But anyone who is specifically favored by the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, due to unalloyed surrender unto the service of the Lord, can overcome the insurmountable ocean of illusion and can understand the Lord. But those who are attached to this body, which is meant to be eaten at the end by dogs and jackals, cannot do so.

Lord Kåñëa encourages all living entities with these words in the Gétä (9.31), kaunteya pratijänéhi na me bhaktaù praëaçyati: "O son of Kunté, declare it boldly that My devotee never perishes." Here the Lord clearly intends to relieve all our fears. One can understand the Supreme Lord as He is only by His mercy, which can elevate one from a second-class devotee to a first-class, pure devotee. As said in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.14.29):

athäpi te deva padämbuja-dvaya-
prasäda-leçänugåhéta eva hi
jänäti tattvaà bhagavan-mahimno
na cänya eko 'pi ciraà vicinvan

My Lord, if one is favored by even a slight trace of the mercy of Your lotus feet, he can understand the greatness of Your personality. But those who speculate to understand the Personality of Godhead are unable to know You, even though they continue to study the Vedas for many years.

For the fully surrendered pure devotee, not only is he himself transcendentally situated, but he sees this material nature as untainted by the three material modes. He then employs the material guëas—the qualities of ignorance, passion, and goodness—in the Lord's service. For example, he uses his anger to chastise the enemies of the Lord's devotees.

Lord Kåñëa makes the following statement in the Bhagavad-gétä (14.26):

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicäreëa
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman.

Such a pure devotee sees the material quality of goodness as the Lord's bodily effulgence. For him the quality of ignorance is transformed into peacefulness and equanimity. And he uses lust, a product of the mode of passion, to love and serve the supremely beautiful Lord. He meditates on how to serve the Supreme Lord, and then with enthusiasm and patience he performs all kinds devotional service. In the devotional mellow of çänta, or neutrality, such devotional enthusiasm may be absent, but because such a mood of devotion attracts the Lord's love, it is fully spiritual.

Here is another thought for meditation: The Supreme Personality of Godhead is unlimited, and any service rendered Him is also unlimited because the Lord's unlimited energy is the dynamic force behind such service. When this supernatural energy is reposed in us, all our thoughts and feelings, our physical body, our mind, our knowledge, and so on, are energized by it. Every endeavor then simply merges into this flow of energy, and we become like a lotus growing from the mud—in the world but uncontaminted by it. This is how the nondual principle comes alive: our mind, heart, consciousness, and activities become nondifferent from the Supreme Lord, the Absolute Truth. We consider ourselves the Lord's property, surrendered at His lotus feet, His unalloyed, eternal slaves. Rejecting all mental speculation and mundane desire, with a serene mind we experience incessant spiritual bliss in rendering Him loving service. In the Bhagavad-gétä (3.30) the Lord describes the process of surrender in this way:

mayi sarväëi karmäëi
sannyasyädhyätma-cetasä
niräçér nirmamo bhütvä
yudhyasva vigata-jvaraù

Therefore, O Arjuna, surrendering all your works unto Me, with mind intent on Me, and without desire for gain and free from egoism and lethargy, fight.

To achieve such a state of surrender, one has to be free from selfish desires, unaffected by dualities, and devoid of all false prestige. Dualities are born of false ego, the worst enemy of surrender. One who transcends false ego, and with it the effects of duality, is very easily freed from material desires, and then he vanquishes hate, greed, anger, fear, and so on. In the stage of full surrender to the Lord, even negative qualities like mundane desire and envy, along with dualities like hunger and thirst, heat and cold, joy and sorrow, loss and gain, sin and piety, and honor and dishonor, are converted into spiritual energy by being brought into contact with the Supreme Lord. Saintly, blissful personalities who are devoid of undesirable characteristics like lust and envy are found especially in India. One can conquer duality, illusion, and so on only by spiritual elevation to the state of directly perceiving the Supreme Lord and seeing everything in relation to Him. The only method of achieving this state of consciousness is buddhi-yoga.

For the devotee of the Lord, this kind of vision develops easily. Conversely, the empirical philosophers, fruitive workers, and gross materialists cannot possibly attain this stage. The devotees are inspired by Him to develop spiritual perception, and thus the dualities fade into inconsequence. Such a state is the ultimate result of their devotional surrender and love for the Lord. In the Bhagavad-gétä (18.54) Lord Kåñëa describes the neophyte stage of such divine consciousness:

brahma-bhütaù prasannätmä
na çocati na käìkñati
samaù sarveñu bhüteñu
mad-bhaktià labhate paräm

One who is thus transcendentally situated at once realizes the Supreme Brahman. He never laments nor desires to have anything; he is equally disposed to every living entity. In that state he attains pure devotional service unto Me.

The living entity becomes bound up by the ropes of ignorance, duality, and illusion as soon as he sees this material world through the coloured crystal known as "me and mine." To nullify such false ego and contaminated consciousness, one must follow the process of buddhi-yoga, which is uncontaminated by the three modes of nature (ignorance, passion, and goodness). Otherwise superconsciousness is unattainable.

The state of pure goodness is marked by pure knowledge of the Absolute. But when this knowledge is pervertedly reflected in the material world, it becomes mundane and empirical, and the jéva is thrown into the whirlpool of dualities, which condition him. The mode of passion increases attachment, sense gratification, and material desires, and the jéva becomes entangled in fruitive activities. The mode of ignorance induces illusion, covering the jéva's intelligence; then he slides down to the lowest consciousness, spending time only in sleeping and laziness. And the material mode of goodness also turns the jéva away from the Absolute Truth and makes him conditioned. With an increase of the mode of passion, goodness and ignorance both decrease. When the mode of goodness increases, passion and ignorance decline. In this way the material modes wax and wane in varying degrees. The mode of goodness promotes mundane knowledge and elevated material consciousness, the mode of passion produces untiring energy for work and insatiable desire for results, and the mode of ignorance drags the jéva down to nescience, laziness, sleep, and delusion. The jéva in goodness moves up to more elevated consciousness, one in passion remains suspended in the mediocre state, and one in ignorance descends to the depths of depravity.

Therefore, it is a hazardous path of elevation that depends on personal characteristics within the jurisdiction of the three modes of nature. Without transcending these three material modes, a person will find himself securely in their clutches, and thus deluded, he will think that all his activities are divinely inspired. He will then broadcast this false concept, considering himself an advanced devotee and everyone else inferior. Impressed with his own knowledge, he will try to see God by dint of this knowledge instead of acting in such a way that God will want to see him. Intoxicated by false ego, he will see his activities, which are motivated by passion, as divine. Those who are proud of their knowledge do not surrender to the Lord; instead, they try to attain the Supreme Lord's mercy by the inductive method and thus exhibit an obnoxious mentality. One should constantly remember the Lord and pray to Him for mercy. The Lord, situated in the devotee's heart, responds to such a prayer and illumines his heart with knowledge, which dissipates the darkness of ignorance.

Lord Caitanya has taught:

tånäd api sunécena
taror api sahiñëunä
amäninä mäna-dena
kértanéyaù sadä hariù
[Çikñäñöaka 3]

One should chant the holy name of the Lord in a humble state of mind, thinking oneself lower than the straw in the street. One should be more tolerant than a tree, devoid of all sense of false prestige, and ready to offer all respect to others. In such a state of mind one can chant the holy name of the Lord constantly.

Often people do not understand the transcendental message of this verse. Although they are forced to act by the influence of the three modes, they make an artificial show of humility, pretending to be weak, lowly, and penniless beggars. This sort of cheating mood is most undesirable. Realizing the truth of the Vedic statement ahaà brahmäsmi ("I am Brahman") is one meaning of humility. The essence of this teaching is to understand that matter and spirit are diametrically opposed. When we are inspired by devotional service to the Lord, our original identity begins to manifest in us and ultimately brings us to God-realization. The devotees work hard to induce people from the materialistic masses to take up devotional service, all the while trying to not disturb their minds. Such spiritual efforts are never to be confused with the mundane endeavors of fruitive workers, empirical philosophers, or outright sense gratifiers. As the Supreme Lord says in the Gétä (3.24), utsédeyur ime lokäù na kuryäà karma ced aham: "If I should cease to work, then all these worlds would be put to ruination."

Those who are not enthusiastic to execute the Supreme Lord's transcendental orders will automatically be forced by the mode of passion to perform useless action, which is really the state of inactivity. Arjuna asked Lord Kåñëa about the symptoms and behavior of one who has transcended the material modes. The following verses from the Gétä (14.26-27) summarize the Lord's response to this question:

mäà ca yo 'vyabhicärena
bhakti-yogena sevate
sa guëän samatétyaitän
brahma-bhüyäya kalpate

brahmaëo hi pratiñöhäham
amåtasyävyayasya ca
çäçvatasya ca dharmasya
sukhasyaikäntikasya ca

One who engages in full devotional service, who does not fall down in any circumstance, at once transcends the modes of material nature and thus comes to the level of Brahman. And I am the basis of the impersonal Brahman, which is the constitutional position of ultimate happiness, and which is immortal, imperishable and eternal.

Bhakti-yoga can be divided into three stages: 1) to take the first step toward complete surrender by accepting things favorable to the execution of devotional service; 2) to serve the Supreme Lord after realizing one's true nature; 3) to become situated on the elevated stage, in which one sees the Supreme Lord in everything and everything in the Supreme Lord. In this way, initial faith increases and leads to full surrender to the Lord.

Once a person resolves to accept only those things conducive to devotional service, the Lord's internal potency helps him reach goal. Our sole duty is to constantly remember the Lord and pray for His sanction in everything. The instructions we receive from a spiritual master firmly situated in Kåñëa consciousness help us properly engage in the devotional processes of hearing, chanting, and constant remembrance of the Lord. If we are inspired by our remembrance of the Lord and by His will, then we will never be misdirected. We will not be intimidated by the horrible hallucinations of this illusory material energy. By following the spiritual master's orders with single-minded determination, we will remain undeterred in executing the Lord's service and will make quick progress.

The mood of surrender during the stage of vaidhi-bhakti (devotional service under strict rules and regulations) is different from that in the stage of rägänuga-bhakti (spontaneous devotional service). In the spontaneous stage, the mood of surrender is the natural expression of the self. When the process of surrender is followed step by step, one patiently executes the Lord's orders and gradually becomes enthusiastic. Such a devotee follows the regulative principles of hearing, chanting, remembering, and so on, and emulates previous saintly preceptors. In the association of devotees he becomes more and more proficient in rendering devotional service. Gradually his service becomes easier. Thus constant remembrance ofthe Lord comes simply by developing enthusiasm and patience in devotional activities.

One deviates from the path of yoga because of forgetfulness. In devotional service there is no such apprehension, because the Supreme Lord always protects the bhakti-yogé. Even if the bhakti-yogé falls down, he can regain his former position by receiving strength from the Lord. Because of his remembrance of the Lord, all obstacles on his path are cleared away. Therefore the process of surrender leads to real perfection in yoga; it is the easiest path to follow and is also the most direct.

We learn from the book Sanat Sujätéya that four things are required in attaining perfection in yoga practice: 1) the scriptures; 2) enthusiasm; 3) a bona fide spiritual master; 4) sufficient time. The scriptures recommend the path of surrender described in this book. Enthusiasm means to constantly remember the Lord and to pray for His mercy. The spiritual master in the heart of the surrendered devotee is the Supreme Lord Himself. He manifests as the beloved initiating spiritual master and the instructing spiritual masters. It is the Supreme Lord who, acting as the spiritual master in the heart, enlightens us with buddhi-yoga, or divine consciousness. And this consciousness helps us understand the Supreme Lord as He is.

The sages say that when we surrender to the Lord, we will clearly see how the He personally makes arrangements for us, even in small matters. Then we will easily see how with His omnipotent supreme intelligence He is assisting us out of love. So it is unnecessary to waste time in further speculation. We have to vanquish illusion, develop equanimity and spontaneity, and practice bhakti-yoga. Then a supremely powerful force will gradually transform our material existence into spiritual existence. All our misconceptions, accumulated over millions of lifetimes, will be rectified in a short time. Hence we need not become anxious because of a lack of time. The eightfold yoga practice—yama, niyama, äsana, präëäyäma, and so on—gives quick results, and one feels that he is doing something substantial. However, although such efforts may certainly make one materially proficient, they are nevertheless simply human endeavors. They are totally distinct from the activities carried out by the Lord's potency. The Supreme Lord's energy often works in subtle ways, but where it ultimately takes us is inconceivable to the human mind.

The mundane processes for elevation are, after all, initiated by intelligent human brains. They are like man-made canals: useful for easy transportation from one place to another, but otherwise of limited utility. Human efforts are imperfect, and therefore they keep us in the material world. As the Lord says in the Bhagavad-gétä (8.16),

ä-brahma-bhuvanäl lokäë
punar ävartino 'rjuna
mäm upetya tu kaunteya
punar janma na vidyate

From the highest planet in the material world down to the lowest, all are places of misery wherein repeated birth and death take place. But one who attains to My abode, O son of Kunté, never takes birth again.

The energy of the Lord is like a fathomless ocean that remains undisturbed in all circumstances. It is shoreless, without beginning or end; therefore the process which directly manifests from this energy is omnipotent and can transport one to any heights or levels. The necessities for ocean travel are a ship, a navigator, a rudder, and a favorable wind. One must clearly understand that this human body is the most suitable ship to take us across the ocean of nescience, the spiritual master is the best navigator, the scriptures are the rudder, and the Lord's mercy is the perfect wind. If we do not take advantage of this excellent arrangement and cross over the material ocean of nescience, then we are our own worst enemy. We must always fix our attention on the favorable wind of the Lord's mercy, which incarnates as the spiritual master. Therefore one must approach a spiritual master, take shelter of his lotus feet, and learn from him the science of devotional service. This is what the Upaniñads enjoin—tad-vijïänärthaà sa gurum eväbhigacchet.

The saintly, pure devotees, the guru, and the scriptures all represent the same Absolute Truth. The pure devotees are in fact all gurus because they never swerve from the spiritual principles enunciated in the scriptures: they see only through the lens of the scriptures. Spiritual practices are impossible to execute without the authority of these three ruling principles—the saintly devotees, the guru, and the scriptures. One must vehemently denounce the Western mentality of defying spiritual tradition and the scriptures. Such a mentality reveres mundane philosophies based on speculation and concocted logic, considering these practices signs of superior intelligence. The only weapon the proponents of such philosophies have is mundane argument, but often they exhibit a lack of mastery even of this art. Recent trends show that without probing deeply into a subject, these Westerners uselessly debate direct and indirect meanings ad infinitum. Each of these sophists surely realizes that he must one day accept defeat in the hands of a greater sophist, for there is always someone more intelligent. Therefore the process of debate leads nowhere.

There is a wide gulf between superficial dabbling in philosophy to impress people with a few stock phrases, and a sincere search for knowledge of the Absolute. Through the speculative process it is impossible to fathom the inconceivable topics concerning the Absolute Truth, for they can be understood only through the science of devotion. As Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé writes in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu [2.5.93], quoting from the Mahäbhärata:

acintyäù khalu ye bhävä
na täàs tarkeëa yojayet
prakåtibhyaù paraà yac ca
tad acintyasya lakñaëam

Anything transcendental to material nature is inconceivable and thus cannot be grasped through mundane arguments. Therefore one should not try to understand transcendental subjects in this way.

Without the mercy of the Supreme Lord, such esoteric subjects are incomprehensible, even if one spends many years researching them. Beyond the sensual realm lie indirect, subtle perceptions, which need to be properly understood. But they can be understood properly only if one sees their relationship to the inconceivable, transcendental Absolute Truth. Without seeing this connection, one will find all discussion of these subtle perceptions to be like beating the chaff for grain—a mere exercise in futility that brings only frustration and distress. Such empty sophistry may show off some mundane erudition, but it cannot help one make spiritual progress. In fact, these dry empirical debates often create big hurdles. So it is better to avoid them.

It is strongly recommended that one simply follow in the footsteps of spiritual stalwarts who act according to the scriptural injunctions and the spiritual guidelines given by saintly souls and guru. One should not raise too many doubts and questions. As the Lord states in the Bhagavad-gétä (4.34), tad viddhi praëipätena paripraçnena sevayä: "Just try to learn the truth by approaching a spiritual master. Inquire from him submissively and render service unto him." This process, which strictly follows the Vedas, will bring us to a realization of the inconceivable truth. Once we are on this path, many realizations dawn on us, and it is imperative that we pursue them in order to progress further. The faint illumination of knowledge that appears at first is certain to lead to full enlightenment, but we have to be patient. We must carefully avoid letting pride enter our hearts because of some initial perceptions of the inconceivable Absolute; rather, we must eagerly approach the guru, or the pure devotee, and ask how to proceed. We must reject the narrow and bigoted idea that there is nothing more to know. The most important point is to always fully depend on the mercy of the supreme spiritual master residing in the heart.

In recent times we have heard two words being loudly voiced: Mäyäväda (impersonalist) and Advaita-väda (monist). I deem it proper to write a few words about them. Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya was a brähmaëa who propagated the impersonalist philosophy. But if he were to hear the pathetic version of his theory being espoused today, complete with nonbrahminical Western logic and mundane concepts, he would surely be struck dumb. Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya taught and exhibited ideal brahminical behaviour. He propounded irrefutable arguments that destroyed materialistic views. Furthermore, his erudition, realization, and renunciation were of an extremely high caliber. Yet when his so-called followers dilute and mutilate his philosophy, we are moved simultaneously to tears and laughter.

Through logic and sophistry one can never understand how the Supreme Lord created this unlimited cosmos, but the demoniac atheists will never tire of using these methods. Lord Kåñëa describes their mentality in the Bhagavad-gétä (16.8): asatyam apratiñöhaà te. "They say that this world is unreal, that there is no foundation and that there is no God in control." In fact, the very brain that thinks these childish thoughts is also a most insignificant creation of the Supreme Lord. Hence to expect that such pea-brains can grasp the mysteries behind the Supreme Lord's extraordinary plans is to hope for the impossible. Çrépäda Çaìkaräcärya assessed the prevailing trends of his time and concluded that the monistic view, or the impersonal philosophy, was best suited for his contemporaries. But that was not his final conclusion. He went on to say, bhaja govindaà müòha-mate: "O fools, simply worship Govinda." From his use of the word bhaja, "worship," we understand him to mean that one should worship Lord Govinda's name, form, qualities, pastimes, and do on. The state of transcendence discussed here is far beyond impersonal realization, the ultimate goal of the monists. Indeed, those who worship Govinda enter into Çré Våndävana in Çré Mathurä, the highest spiritual realm, where Çré Çré Rädhä and Kåñëa enact Their quintessential pastimes.

The Supreme Lord is one, yet He has präbhava (fully potent) expansions and vaibhava (partially potent) expansions. The Supreme Lord is endowed with at least six unlimited opulences—absolute wealth, power, beauty, knowledge, fame, and renunciation. With His countless mouths Çré Ananta Çeña is unable to fully describe these opulences.Therefore the Lord is also said to be indescribable, all-pervading, and unmanifest. The Upaniñads describe the Supreme Lord asasamordhva, "one without a second." We have already established this truth. Similarly, Lord Kåñëa Himself says in the Bhagavad-gétä (Chapter 10) that He is the Açvattha tree, fire, Çréla Vyäsadeva, Arjuna, and so on. These facts have also been firmly substantiated. To perfectly comprehend the absolute pastimes of the absolute Supreme Godhead is impossible through any of the "isms," such as empiricism, impersonalism, or sophism. Only by the Lord's mercy can one fathom the Supreme Godhead. That same Supreme Personality benignly reveals the truth about Himself in the Bhagavad-gétä. This text is the essence of all the Vedic scriptures and is the synthesis of all conflicting "isms." Lord Caitanya is the unchallenged spiritual stalwart who propagated the process of surrender to Kåñëa, the conclusion of all the Bhagavad-gétä's teachings. Those who follow in His footsteps are the real yogés and devotees.

All the Supreme Lord's pastimes are eternal. Those who doubt this are impersonalists. When one tries to gauge the omnipotent Supreme Godhead with a limited measuring principle, one is drawn to the impersonal concept. One must carefully avoid this all-devouring philosophy. When Çré Närada Muni saw how Lord Kåñëa had expanded Himself in His original form and was dancing with many gopés simultaneously, he realized that Lord Kåñëa was the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the source of everything. Lord Kåñëa is always being served and worshiped by Çrématé Rädhäräné, yet He expands Himself unlimitedly. Just as a candle can light other candles yet remain unchanged, so the Supreme Lord, though "one without a second," can expand Himself in unlimited forms, and also as the omnipresent, all-pervading, universal soul. This is direct proof of the Supreme Lord's absolute divinity.

The Lord is different from all, yet the same as all. This is His inconceivable potency ofbeing simultaneously one with and different from everything. One has to hear this philosophy from a pure devotee of the Lord; otherwise it is impossible to understand whether the Absolute Truth is a Person or an impersonal substance. If the Supreme is omnipotent, He should be simultaneously personal and impersonal. One who rejects either of these aspects of the Lord tries to limit the absoluteness of the Supreme. Such logic is described as "the logic of half a hen," by which a fool wishes to profit from the egg-laying half of the hen without having to feed the front half. Those who have been blessed by the spiritual master and the Supreme Lord can easily see through this foolish concept and abstain from futile, time-wasting debates. The process of surrender gradually reveals the wonderful glories of the Supreme Lord. Puny human attempts to comprehend such topics will merely end in confusion. The Supreme Lord manifests Himself to the devotee in proportion to the devotee's service attitude and surrender. Arguments and debates are totally inadequate means for understanding the Supreme Absolute Truth.

The objective of life is not simply a subject of debate or speculation. The ultimate aim of life is to realize that supreme object, the Personality of Godhead. Buddhi-yoga, or Kåñëa consciousness, means to become absorbed in serving the Supreme Lord and His name, qualities, form, pastimes, etc. In other words, it means becoming an instrument for His satisfaction. We have to become infused with His spiritual potency; thus strengthened, we then have to make the propagation of His transcendental glories our prime duty in life. By means of such potent missionary activities, innumerable jévas can experience endless spiritual joy.

Neither spiritual retreats, churches, mosques, temples, karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga, dry empirical philosophy, nor imitation devotees can save humanity from the jaws of death. They are inadequate for purifying the consciousness because what they offer as spiritual succor is limited by their sectarian vision, a set of do's and don'ts, and a rigid approach that simply further entangle humanity in the material energy. What is needed are exemplary spiritual actions and the espousal of the genuine path of self-realization, but these have not been properly instituted. Just as Bhagirätha brought down the Gaìgä and liberated his forefathers, similarly, we must bring a deluge of love of Godhead that can extricate the conditioned souls from the clutches of gross materialism. At least for some time, we must create Satya-yuga, the age of reason and piety. We can easily accomplish this Herculean task simply by reintroducing Lord Caitanya's saìkértana movement of the congregational chanting of Lord Kåñëa's name and thus flooding the world with kåñëa-prema. All living entities—the human beings, who are afflicted by Kali-yuga, as well as sub-human beings—must be drowned in the floodwaters of kåñëa-prema.

By studying the Vedas, the Vedänta-sütra, and the Upaniñads, one may find processes for purifying the consciousness and elevating oneself to the transcendental platform. But for the conditioned souls of Kali-yuga, such means are beyond reach. Lord Caitanya alone can liberate the conditioned souls of this age. In His younger days Lord Caitanya was known as Nimäi Paëòita because He was an erudite scholar. Indeed, He became famous as a master of logic. Yet for the sake of the jévas afflicted by the Kali-yuga, He presented Himself as illiterate. Such pastimes are possible only for the Supreme Lord. When the famous Mäyävädé sannyäsé Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté met Lord Caitanya in Benares, he spoke as follows to the Lord: "I see You are a sannyäsé, yet You are in the company of sentimentalists, and like them You are dancing and singing. The real business of sannyäsés is to study the Vedas and meditate on Brahman. But You have rejected these duties and are acting like a sentimentalist. I am impressed with Your effulgent form, which resembles that of Lord Näräyaëa Himself, but why do You act below your status?"

The Mäyävädé sannyäsés study the Vedas simply to gain liberation. Lord Caitanya did not advent merely to teach such an insignificant goal. He propagated the congregational chanting of the holy name and the scientific method of devotional service. His main aim was to establish the authorized religious principle for this age—saìkértana—and thereby liberate all living entities. His reply to Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté was very simple, as if coming from an ordinary mortal. The Lord said,

Respected Swamijé, please listen to the reason why I act as I do. My guru saw that I was ignorant, and so he instructed Me as follows: 'You are foolish and have no proper understanding of Vedänta philosophy. So simply chant this Hare Kåñëa mantra, which is the essence of all mantras. This mantra will deliver You from the entanglement of material existence and award You the shelter of Kåñëa's lotus feet. In the Age of Kali there is no religious principle except chanting Kåñëa's name. It has been ascertained from all the scriptures that Kåñëa's holy name is the essence of all mantras.' He then made Me learn a verse, which I will repeat to you for your consideration:

"harer näma harer näma
harer nämaiva kevalam
kalau nästy eva nästy eva
nästy eva gatir anyathä"
[Ädi 17.21]

"If one wants to make spiritual progress in this Age of Kali, there is no alternative, there is no alternative, there is no alternative to the holy name, the holy name, the holy name of the Lord."

By chanting Kåñëa's holy name, one cleanses all the dust from the mirror of one's consciousness. The blazing fire of material existence is then extinguished. This fire is especially severe in the present materialistic civilization, which is full of conflict, the hallmark of Kali-yuga. But extinguishing the fire of material existence is far from the final result of chanting. Indeed, it is only a preliminary consequence. Gradually, the knowledge that love of Godhead is the absolute necessity of life becomes clearer, the dark veil of ignorance is lifted, and one gets a glimpse of absolute knowledge. As the devotee realizes this transcendental knowledge, he feels ever-increasing spiritual ecstasy overwhelming his heart. This spiritual joy expands at every moment. Let the all-auspicious chanting of the holy name of Kåñëa be ever victorious!

Those who seek the smaller values of life and thus take up yoga for selfish motives are not very noble, and even if they achieve success, they still remain inferior. But those who practice yoga for the benefit of others are truly worthy, for even if they personally do not attain perfection, they are very elevated souls. Devotees of the Lord practice the yoga called buddhi-yoga, or Kåñëa consciousness. This yoga is meant to bless all humanity, as well as bring the practitioner to the perfection of life. The Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.5.17) aptly describes the great value of such yoga:

tyaktvä sva-dharmaà caraëämbujaà harer
bhajann apakvo 'tha patet tato yadi
yatra kva väbhadram abhüd amuñya kià
ko värtha äpto 'bhajatäà sva-dharmataù

One who has forsaken his material occupations to engage in the devotional service of the Lord may sometimes fall down while in an immature stage, yet there is no danger of his being unsuccessful. On the other hand, a nondevotee, though fully engaged in occupational duties, does not gain anything.

Mukunda-mälä-stotra

Translations and purports # 1—6, by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda.

MM Introduction

Introduction

Of the many hundreds of poetic Sanskrit stotras—songs of glorification offered to the Supreme Lord, His devotees, and the holy places of His pastimes—King Kulaçekhara's Mukunda-mälä-stotra is one of the most perennially famous. Some say that its author conceived it as a garland (mälä) of verses offered for Lord Kåñëa's pleasure. It has long been dear to Vaiñëavas of all schools, and our own spiritual master, Çréla A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, frequently enjoyed citing certain favorite stanzas from it.

King Kulaçekhara was part of the Çré-sampradäya, the Vaiñëava school founded by Lord Viñëu's divine consort, Çré. This school's most prominent representative, Rämänuja Äcärya (eleventh century), built on the work of his predecessors Nätha Muni and Yämuna Äcärya and established the systematic philosophy of Çré Vaiñëavism. But these äcäryas came in an already old tradition, that of the ecstatic mystic poets called Älvärs. The twelve Älvärs appeared at various times in South India, in the area roughly corresponding to present-day Tamil Nadu. According to the tradition of the Çré Vaiñëavas, the earliest Älvärs lived more than five thousand years ago, at the start of the present age, Kali-yuga, while the most recent lived in the first millennium A.D.

The Älvärs' Tamil poetry was collected in the Tiruväymoli, revered by Çré Vaiñëavas as their own vernacular Veda. On the strength of the Tiruväymoli's devotional authority, the Çré Vaiñëavas claim to follow Ubhaya-vedänta, the dual Vedänta philosophy founded on both Sanskrit and Tamil scripture. Some Älvärs were atypical renunciants: the third, Äëòäl, was a woman, and three were involved in governing. Among these was the tenth Älvär, Kulaçekhara Perumäl, who was a ruling king in the Cera dynasty of Malainäòu, in what is now Kerala. Modern scholars say he may have lived during the ninth century A.D.

A traditional history of King Kulaçekhara states that once, as he slept in his palace quarters, he had a brilliant and distinct vision of Lord Kåñëa. Upon awaking he fell into a devotional trance and failed to notice dawn breaking. The royal musicians and ministers came as usual to his door to wake him, but after waiting some time without hearing him respond, they reluctantly took the liberty of entering his room. The king came out of his trance and described his vision to them, and from that day on he no longer took much interest in ruling. He delegated most of his responsibilities to his ministers and dedicated himself to rendering devotional service to the Lord. After some years he abdicated the throne and went to Çré Raìgam, where he remained in the association of the Kåñëa Deity of Raìganätha and His many exalted devotees. At Çré Raìgam Kulaçekhara is said to have composed his two great works: the Mukunda-mälä-stotra, in Sanskrit; and 105 Tamil hymns, which were later incorporated into the Tiruväymoli under the title Perumäl-tirumoli.

As the other Älvärs do in their mystic expressions, in his Perumäl-tirumoli King Kulaçekhara emulates the roles of some of Lord Rämacandra's and Lord Kåñëa's intimate devotees: King Daçaratha; two of the Lord's mothers, Kauçalyä and Devaké; and some of the young cowherd women of Våndävana. But Mahäräja Kulaçekhara expresses no pride in realizing such confidential devotional moods. On the contrary, with deep humility he repeatedly begs simply to be allowed to take his next births as a bird, fish, or flower in the place where Lord Kåñëa enacts His pastimes, and in this way to enjoy the association of His devotees.

The Mukunda-mälä-stotra, although composed in elegant Sanskrit, is a simple expression of King Kulaçekhara's devotion to Kåñëa and his eagerness to share his good fortune with everyone else. Being thus a very public work, it does not delve into intimate personal revelations or abstruse philosophical conundrums. Like most other works of the stotra genre, it aims less at presenting a plot than at vividly and honestly expressing the true feelings of a lover of God. With this much we the readers should be completely satisfied, because it is a rare opportunity for us when a devotee of King Kulaçekhara's stature opens his heart so freely—and in a way just appropriate for us, with all our imperfections, to appreciate.

About the Present Edition

Using a Sanskrit edition published by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura in 1895, Çréla Prabhupäda began translating the Mukunda-mälä-stotra in the late 1950's. But after completing six verses with commentary, he suspended it to work on the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. He never resumed it. Yet he clearly intended that the Mukunda-mälä be published, since he included it in the list of his other English books at the beginning of each of the three volumes of the Bhägavatam's First Canto.

In 1989, the Governing Body Commission of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness requested Satsvarüpa däsa Goswami to complete the Mukunda-mälä-stotra. One of Çréla Prabhupäda's earliest disciples, Satsvarüpa Goswami had distinguished himself over the years as one of his most learned and literary followers. He had served as editor of Back to Godhead magazine—the Society's monthly journal—for most of the twenty-three years it had been published in the West, and had written many books already, most notably a six-volume biography of Çréla Prabhupäda.

Satsvarüpa Goswami accepted the assignment and enlisted the help of Gopéparäëadhana däsa, the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust's Sanskrit editor, to translate the remaining forty-seven verses. Then he carefully prepared the purports, often quoting from Çréla Prabhupäda's Bhagavad-gétä, Çrémad-Bhägavatam, and other works. The result is a book that we trust will be informative and enlivening to devotees, scholars, and laymen alike.

—The Publishers

MM mantra 1

TEXT 1

TEXT

çré-vallabheti vara-deti dayä-pareti

bhakta-priyeti bhava-luëöhana-kovideti

nätheti näga-çayaneti jagan-niväsety

äläpinaà prati-dinaà kuru mäà mukunda

SYNONYMS

çré-vallabha—O beloved of Lakñmé (the Supreme Lord's consort); iti—thus; vara-da—O bestower of benedictions; iti—thus; dayä-para—O causelessly merciful one; iti—thus; bhakta-priya—O You who are very dear to Your devotees; iti—thus; bhava—the repetition of birth and death; luëöhana—in plundering; kovida—O You who are expert; iti—thus; nätha—O Lord; iti—thus; näga-çayana—O You who sleep on the serpent bed (of Ananta Çeña); iti—thus; jagat-niväsa—O resort of the cosmos; iti—thus; äläpinam—reciter; prati-dinam—every day; kuru—please make; mäm—me; mukunda—O Mukunda.

TRANSLATION

O Mukunda, my Lord! Please let me become a constant reciter of Your names, addressing You as Çré-vallabha ["He who is very dear to Lakñmé"], Varada ["the bestower of benedictions"], Dayäpara ["He who is causelessly merciful"], Bhakta-priya ["He who is very dear to His devotees"], Bhava-luëöhana-kovida ["He who is expert at plundering the status quo of repeated birth and death"], Nätha ["the Supreme Lord"], Jagan-niväsa ["the resort of the cosmos"], and Näga-çayana ["the Lord who lies down on the serpent bed"].

PURPORT

A devotee of Godhead is he who glorifies the Personality of Godhead under the dictation of transcendental ecstasy. This ecstasy is a by-product of profound love for the Supreme, which is itself attained by the process of glorification. In this age of quarrel and fighting, the process of chanting and glorification recommended here by King Kulaçekhara is the only way to attain perfection.

Persons who are infected with the disease of material attachment and who suffer from the pangs of repeated birth and death cannot relish such recitation of the Lord's glories, just as a person suffering from jaundice cannot relish the taste of sugar candy. By nature sugar candy is as sweet as anything, but to a patient suffering from jaundice it tastes as bitter as anything. Still, sugar candy is the best medicine for jaundice. By regular treatment with doses of sugar candy, one can gradually get relief from the infection of jaundice, and when the patient is perfectly cured, the same sugar candy that tasted bitter to him regains its natural sweetness.

In the same way, glorification of the transcendental name, fame, attributes, pastimes, and entourage of the Personality of Godhead tastes bitter to those who are suffering from the infection of material consciousness, but it is very sweet to those who have recovered from this infection.

All mundane philosophers, religionists, and people in general, who are constantly suffering from the threefold miseries of material existence, can get freedom from all such troubles simply by chanting and glorifying the holy name, fame, and pastimes of the Supreme Lord. The Supreme Lord, the Absolute Truth, is all spirit, and therefore His name, fame, and pastimes are nondifferent from Him. All of them are identical. In other words, the holy name of the Lord is the Lord Himself, and this can be understood by realization. By chanting the holy names of the Lord, which are innumerable, one can actually associate with the Lord personally, and by such constant personal touch with the all-spiritual Lord, one will become spiritually self-realized. This process of self-realization is very suitable for the fallen souls of this age, when life is short and when people are slow in understanding the importance of spiritual realization, prone to be misled by false association and false spiritual masters, unfortunate in every respect, and continuously disturbed by innumerable material problems.

King Kulaçekhara, an ideal pure devotee of the Lord, shows us by his own realization how to offer prayers to the Lord. Since he is a mahä-jana, an authority in the line of devotional service, it is our prime duty to follow in his footsteps in order to achieve the highest devotional platform.

He first addresses the Lord as Çré-vallabha, "He who is very dear to Lakñmé." The Lord is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and His consort, Lakñmé, is a manifestation of His internal potency. By expanding His internal potency, the Lord enjoys His spiritual paraphernalia. In the highest spiritual realization, therefore, the Lord is not impersonal or void, as empiric philosophers conceive Him to be. Although He is not of the material world, He is much more than simply a negation of material variegatedness. He is positively the supreme enjoyer of spiritual variegatedness, of which Lakñmé, the internal potency, is the fountainhead.

King Kulaçekhara next addresses the Lord as Varada, "the bestower of benedictions," because it is He alone who can deliver to us the actual substance—spiritual bliss. When we detach ourselves from His association, we are always in the midst of want and scarcity, but as soon as we get in touch with Him, our gradual endowment with all bliss begins. The first installment of this bliss is the clearance of the layer of dust that has accumulated in our hearts due to millions of years of material association. As soon as the dust of materialism is brushed aside, the clear mirror of the heart reflects the presence of the Lord. And as soon as we see Him we are automatically freed from all kinds of aspirations and frustrations. In that liberated state, everything is blissful in relation with the Lord, and one has no desires to fulfill and nothing to lament over. Thus, following the benediction, full spiritual bliss comes upon us, ushering in full knowledge, full life, and full satisfaction with our whole existence.

King Kulaçekhara next addresses the Lord as Dayäpara, "He who is causelessly merciful," because there is no one but the Lord who can be a causelessly merciful friend to us. He is therefore also called Déna-bandhu, "the friend of the needy." Unfortunately, at times of need we seek our friends in the mundane world, not knowing that one needy man cannot help another. No mundane man is full in every respect; even a man possessing the greatest riches is himself needy if he is devoid of a relationship with the Lord. Everything is zero without the Lord, who is the digit that transforms zero into ten, two zeros into one hundred, three zeros into one thousand, and so on. Thus a "zero man" cannot become happy without the association of the Lord, the supreme "1."

The supreme "1" always wants to make our zero efforts valuable by His association, just as a loving father always wants an unhappy son to be in a prosperous position. A rebellious son, however, stubbornly refuses the cooperation of the loving father and thus suffers all sorts of miseries. The Lord, therefore, sends His bona fide representatives to all parts of the material creation, and sometimes He even comes Himself to reclaim His fallen sons. For this purpose He also exhibits the actual life in the transcendental world, which is characterized by relationships with Him in servitorship, friendship, parenthood, and consorthood. All relationships in the material world are but perverted reflections of these original relationships. In the mundane world we experience only the shadow of the reality, which exists in the spiritual world.

The all-merciful Lord is always mindful of our difficulties in the mundane world, and He is more eager to get us to return home, back to Godhead, than we are eager to go. He is by nature merciful toward us, despite our rebellious attitude. Even in our rebellious condition we get all our necessities from Him, such as food, air, light, water, warmth, and coolness. Yet because we have detached ourselves from Him, we simply mismanage this paternal property. The leaders of society, despite all their materialistic plans, are misleaders, for they have no plan to revive our lost relationship with the Lord. His bona fide devotees, however, try their utmost to broadcast the message of our transcendental relationship with Him. In this way the devotees work to remind the fallen souls of their actual position and to bring them back home, back to Godhead. Such stainless servants of Godhead are very dear to Him. They receive such special favor from the Lord for their compassionate work that they can even go back to Godhead in this very lifetime and not be forced to take another birth.

The Lord is therefore next addressed as Bhakta-priya, meaning "He who is very dear to His devotees" or "He who is very affectionate to His devotees." In the Bhagavad-gétä (9.29) the Lord very nicely describes His sublime and transcendental affection for His devotees. There the Lord declares that although He is undoubtedly equally kind to all living beings—because all of them are part and parcel of Him and are His spiritual sons—those who are especially attached to Him by love and affection, who regard nothing dearer than Him, are particularly dear to Him.

An example of such a pure devotee is Lord Jesus Christ, who agreed to be mercilessly crucified rather than give up preaching on behalf of God. He was never prepared to compromise on the issue of believing in God. Such a son of God cannot be other than dear to the Lord. Similarly, when Öhäkura Haridäsa was told to give up chanting the holy name of God, he refused to do so, with the result that he was flogged in twenty-two marketplaces. And Prahläda Mahäräja persisted in disagreeing with his father, the great atheist Hiraëyakaçipu, and thus voluntarily accepted the cruelties his father inflicted upon him. These are some examples of renowned devotees of the Lord, and we should simply try to understand how dear such devotees are to Him.

The Lord has emphatically declared that no one can vanquish His devotee under any circumstances. A good example is Ambaréña Mahäräja. When the great mystic yogé Durväsä deliberately attempted to take the life of Ambaréña, the Lord suitably punished Durväsä, even though he was a powerful yogé who could approach all the demigods and even the Lord Himself.

Sometimes, even at the risk of having to cross many stumbling blocks, a devotee relinquishes all family connections and homely comforts for the Lord's service. Can the Lord forget all these sacrifices of His bona fide devotee? No, not even for a moment, for the relationship between the Lord and His devotee is reciprocal, as He clearly says in the Bhagavad-gétä (9.29): "But whoever renders service unto Me in devotion is a friend, is in Me, and I am also a friend to him."

A devotee is never as eager to see the Lord as he is to render service to Him. Yet the Lord does appear before His devotee, for He is just like an affectionate father, who is more eager to see his son than the son is to see him. There is no contradiction in such a quantitative difference in affection. Such a disparity exists in the original reality—between the Lord and His devotees—and is reflected here not only in the relations between parents and children in human society but even in the animal kingdom. Parental affection is exhibited even among lower animals because originally such affection in its fullness exists in God, the original father of all species of living beings. When a man kills an animal, God, the affectionate father, is perturbed and is pained at heart. Thus the slaughterer of the animal is suitably punished by the material energy, just as a murderer is punished by the government through police action.

By the mercy of the Lord, a devotee develops all the good qualities of God, for a devotee can never remain in the darkness of ignorance. A father is always anxious to impart knowledge and experience to his son, but the son can choose whether to accept such instructions. A submissive devotee becomes automatically enlightened in all the intricacies of knowledge because the Lord, from within, dissipates his ignorance with the self-illumined lamp of wisdom. If the Lord Himself instructs the devotee, how can he remain foolish like the mundane wranglers?

A father is naturally inclined to act for the good of his son, and when the father chastises his son, that chastisement is also mixed with affection. Similarly, all the living entities who have lost their place in paradise due to disobedience to the Supreme Father are put into the hands of the material energy to undergo a prison life of the threefold miseries. Yet the Supreme Father does not forget His rebellious sons. He creates scriptures for them like the Vedas and Puräëas in order to revive their lost relationship with Him and awaken their divine consciousness. Intelligent persons take advantage of the knowledge contained in these scriptures and thus attain the highest perfection of life.

For His devotees, the Lord personally descends to this world to give them relief and save them from the insane acts of miscreants. It is foolish to try to impose the limits of an ordinary living being upon the unlimited potency of Godhead and obstinately maintain that the Supreme Lord cannot descend. To mitigate His devotees' material pangs, He descends as He is, yet He is not infected by material qualities.

As soon as a person agrees to surrender unto the Lord, the Lord takes complete charge of him. Satisfied with the activities of such a devotee, He gives him instruction from within, and thus the devotee becomes pure and advances on the path back to Godhead. The Lord is expert at guiding such a pure devotee, who is not at all anxious for material superiority. A pure devotee does not wish to possess material wealth, nor does he want to have a great following, nor does he desire a beautiful wife, for by the mercy of the Lord he knows the insignificance of material happiness. What he very sincerely desires at heart is to continue in the loving service of the Lord, even at the risk of taking birth again.

When a neophyte devotee deviates from the path of pure devotion and wants to simultaneously enjoy sense gratification and discharge devotional service, the all-merciful Lord very tactfully corrects the bewildered devotee by exhibiting before him the real nature of this material world. In the material world all relationships are actually mercenary but are covered by an illusory curtain of so-called love and affection. The so-called wives and husbands, parents and children, and masters and servants are all concerned with reciprocal material profit. As soon as the shroud of illusion is removed, the dead body of material so-called love and affection is at once manifest to the naked eye.

The Lord expertly removes the shroud of illusion for the neophyte devotee by depriving him of his material assets, and thus the devotee finds himself alone in the midst of his so-called relatives. In this helpless condition he experiences the awkwardness of his so-called relationships with his so-called wife and children. When a man is financially ruined, no one loves him, not even his wife or children. Such a poverty-stricken devotee more perfectly fixes his faith in the Lord, and the Lord then delivers him from the fate of frustration.

The entire cosmic creation is the Lord's expert arrangement for the delusion of the living beings who try to be false enjoyers. The living being's constitutional position is to be a servant of the Lord, but in the transcendental relationship the servant and the Lord are in one sense identical, for the Lord also serves the servant. The typical example is Çré Kåñëa's becoming the charioteer of His eternal servant Arjuna. Illusioned mundaners cannot understand the transcendental and reciprocal relationship between the Lord and His devotees, and therefore they want to lord it over material nature or cynically merge with the Absolute. Thus a living being forgets his constitutional position and wants to become either a lord or a mendicant, but such illusions are arrangements of Mäyä, the Lord's illusory potency. A false life either as a lord or a mendicant meets with frustration until the living being comes to his senses and surrenders to the Lord as His eternal servant. Then the Lord liberates him and saves him from repeated birth and death. Thus the Lord is also addressed here as Bhava-luëöhana-kovida, "He who is expert at plundering the status quo of repeated birth and death." A sensible man understands his position as the eternal servant of the Lord and molds his life accordingly.

The Lord is also addressed as Nätha, the real Lord. One can attain the perfection of life only by serving the real Lord. The entire material atmosphere is surcharged with the false lordship of the living beings. The illusioned beings are all struggling for false lordship, and thus no one wants to serve. Everyone wants to be the lord, even though such lordship is conditional and temporary. A hardworking man thinks himself the lord of his family and estate, but actually he is a servant of desire and the employee of anger. Such service of the senses is neither pensionable nor terminable, for desire and anger are masters who are never to be satisfied. The more one serves them, the more service they exact, and as such the false overlordship continues until the day of annihilation. As a result, the foolish living being is pushed into degraded life and fails to recognize the Lord as the beneficiary of all activities, the ruler of the universe, and the friend of all entities. One who knows the real Lord is called a brähmaëa, but one who fails to know Him is called a kåpaëa, or number-one miser.

The Lord of the creative energy is called Ananta-çayana. The material energy is impregnated by the glance of this feature of the Lord and is then able to give birth to all organic and inorganic matter. Ananta-çayana sleeps on the bed of Çeña Näga, who has a form like a serpent but is identical with the Lord. Because He sleeps on a serpent bed, the Lord is also known as Näga-çayana. By His spiritual energy Çeña Näga sustains all the planetary globes upon His invisible hoods. Çeña Näga is popularly known as Saìkarñaëa, or "that which keeps balance by the law of magnetism." In the scientific world this feature of the Lord is referred to as the law of gravitation, but factually this law, which keeps all the planets floating in space, is one of the energies of the Lord. All the universes are born with the exhalation of the Lord as He lies on Çeña Näga, and all of them are annihilated with His inhalation. Due to these functions of creation, maintenance, and annihilation, the Lord is celebrated by the name Jagan-niväsa, indicating that He is the supreme resort of all the universes.

There are hundreds of thousands of other names of Lord Viñëu, and each one of them is as powerful as the Lord Himself. One can constantly chant any name of the Lord and thereby constantly associate with Him. There are no hard and fast rules for chanting His names. At any time and any stage of life one can freely chant them, but we are so unfortunate that we are too misled even to adopt this simple process. This is the way of Mäyä, the Lord's misleading energy. However, one can avoid her ways simply by always remembering the lotus feet of the Lord. King Kulaçekhara prays for this facility from Mukunda, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

MM mantra 2

TEXT 2

TEXT

jayatu jayatu devo devaké-nandano 'yaà

jayatu jayatu kåñëo våñëi-vaàça-pradépaù

jayatu jayatu megha-çyämalaù komaläìgo

jayatu jayatu påthvé-bhära-näço mukundaù

SYNONYMS

jayatu jayatu—all glories, all glories; devaù—to the Personality of Godhead; devaké-nandanaù—son of Devaké; ayam—this; jayatu jayatu—all glories, all glories; kåñëaù—to Lord Kåñëa; våñëi—of Våñëi (Lord Kåñëa's forefather); vaàça—of the dynasty; pradépaù—the beacon light; jayatu jayatu—all glories, all glories; megha—like a new cloud; çyämalaù—who is blackish; komala—very soft; aìgaù—whose body; jayatu jayatu—all glories, all glories; påthvé—the earth's; bhära—of the burden; näçaù—to the destroyer; mukundaù—Lord Çré Kåñëa.

TRANSLATION

All glories to this Personality of Godhead known as the son of Çrématé Devaké devé! All glories to Lord Çré Kåñëa, the brilliant light of the Våñëi dynasty! All glories to the Personality of Godhead, the hue of whose soft body resembles the blackish color of a new cloud! All glories to Lord Mukunda, who removes the burdens of the earth!

PURPORT

The theme of this verse is that the Supreme Truth is the Supreme Person. That the Lord's bodily texture and color are described indicates that He is a person, for the impersonal Brahman cannot have a body that is as soft as anything or whose hue is visualized. The Personality of Godhead appeared as the son of Vasudeva and Devaké because for a very long time they performed severe austerities to have the Supreme Lord as their son. Satisfied by their penance and determination, the Lord agreed to become their son.

From the description of the Lord's birth in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, we learn that the Lord appeared before Vasudeva and Devaké as Näräyaëa, with four hands. But when they prayed to Him to conceal His divinity, the Lord became a small baby with two hands. In the Bhagavad-gétä (4.9) the Lord promises that one who simply understands the mysteries of His transcendental birth and deeds will be liberated from the clutches of Mäyä and go back to Godhead. Therefore there is a gulf of difference between the birth of Kåñëa and that of an ordinary child.

One may ask, Since the Supreme Lord is the original father of all living entities, how could a lady known as Devaké give birth to Him as her son? The answer is that Devaké no more gave birth to the Lord than the eastern horizon gives birth to the sun. The sun rises on the eastern horizon and sets below the western horizon, but actually the sun neither rises nor sets. The sun is always in its fixed position in the sky, but the earth is revolving, and due to the different positions of the revolving earth, the sun appears to be rising or setting. In the same way, the Lord always exists, but for His pastimes as a human being He seems to take birth like an ordinary child.

In His impersonal feature (Brahman) the Supreme Lord is everywhere, inside and outside: as the Supersoul (Paramätmä) He is inside everything, from the gigantic universal form down to the atoms and electrons; and as the Supreme Personality of Godhead (Bhagavän) He sustains everything with His energies. (We have already described this feature of the Lord in the purport to the previous verse, in connection with the name Jagan-niväsa.) Therefore in each of His three features—Brahman, Paramätmä, and Bhagavän—the Lord is present everywhere in the material world. Yet He remains aloof, busy with His transcendental pastimes in His supreme abode.

Those with a poor fund of knowledge cannot accept the idea that the Lord appears in person on the face of the earth. Because they are not conversant with the intricacies of the Lord's transcendental position, whenever such people hear about the appearance of the Lord, they take Him to be either a superhuman being born with a material body or a historical personality worshiped as God under the influence of anthropomorphism or zoomorphism. But the Lord is not the plaything of such fools. He is what He is and does not agree to be a subject of their speculations, which perpetually lead them to conclude that His impersonal feature is supreme. The supreme feature of the Absolute Truth is personal—the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The impersonal Brahman is His effulgence, like the light diffused by a powerful fire. The fire burns in one place but diffuses its warmth and light all round, thus exhibiting its different energies. Similarly, by means of His variegated energies the Supreme Lord expands Himself in many ways.

Persons with a poor fund of knowledge are captivated by one part of His energy and therefore fail to penetrate into the original source of the energy. Whatever astounding energies we see manifest in this world, including atomic and nuclear energies, are all part and parcel of His material, or external, energy. Superior to this material energy, however, is the Lord's marginal energy, exhibited as the living being. Besides these energies, the Supreme Lord has another energy, which is known as the internal energy. The marginal energy can take shelter of either the internal energy or the external energy, but factually it belongs to the Lord's internal energy. The living beings are therefore infinitesimal samples of the Supreme Lord. Qualitatively the living being and the Supreme Lord are equal, but quantitatively they are different, for the Lord is unlimitedly potent whereas the living entities, being infinitesimal by nature, have limited potency.

Although the Lord is full with all energies and is thus self-sufficient, He enjoys transcendental pleasure by subordinating Himself to His unalloyed devotees. Some great devotees of the Lord cannot surpass the boundary of awe and veneration. But other devotees are in such an intense compact of love with the Lord that they forget His exalted position and regard themselves as His equals or even His superiors. These eternal associates of the Lord relate with Him in the higher statuses of friendship, parenthood, and consorthood. Devotees in a transcendental parental relationship with the Lord think of Him as their dependent child. They forget His exalted position and think that unless they properly feed Him He will fall victim to undernourishment and His health will deteriorate. Devotees in a conjugal relationship with the Lord rebuke Him to correct His behavior, and the Lord enjoys those rebukes more than the prayers of the Vedas. Ordinary devotees bound up by the formalities of Vedic rites cannot enter deep into such confidential loving service to the Lord, and thus their realization remains imperfect. Sometimes they even fall victim to the calamity of impersonalism.

Vasudeva and Devaké are confidential devotees of the Lord in the mood of parental love. Even greater than them are Nanda and Yaçodä, His foster parents in Våndävana. The Lord takes great pleasure in being addressed as Devaké-nandana ("the son of Devaké"), Nanda-nandana ("the son of Nanda"), Yaçodä-nandana ("the son of Yaçodä"), Daçarathé ("the son of King Daçaratha"), Janaké-nätha ("the husband of Janaké"), and so on. The pleasure one gives the Lord by addressing Him by such names is many, many times greater than the pleasure He enjoys when He is addressed as the Supreme Father, the Greatest of the Great, Parameçvara, or anything of that nature, which indicate volumes of awe and veneration. Therefore the names King Kulaçekhara uses to glorify the Lord in this verse indicate his intimate transcendental relationship with the Lord.

As explained above, all the names of the Lord are as powerful as the Lord Himself, but one can experience different transcendental mellows by chanting His different transcendental names. For example, the çästra (scripture) states that there are one thousand principal names of Lord Viñëu, the Personality of Godhead. But if a person utters the name Räma only once, he gets the result of chanting one thousand names of Viñëu. And if somebody once chants the name Kåñëa, he achieves the results obtained by chanting the name Räma three times. In other words, uttering the name Kåñëa once is equal to uttering three thousand other names of Viñëu.

Therefore King Kulaçekhara, knowing how pleased the Lord is to be addressed by a name indicating His transcendental relationships with His intimate devotees, and knowing also the potency of the name Kåñëa, has chosen to glorify the Lord by addressing Him as Devaké-nandana and Kåñëa. The king also addresses Him as Våñëi-vaàça-pradépa ("the brilliant light in the Våñëi dynasty") because millions of generations of the Våñëi dynasty became sanctified by the Lord's appearance within it. The çästras state that a family in which a pure devotee is born is sanctified for one hundred generations of ancestors and descendants. And the çästras also state that every place within a radius of one hundred miles from where a devotee is born becomes sanctified. If a devotee can sanctify the place and family of his birth so extraordinarily, then what to speak of how completely the Lord can sanctify the place and family in which He chooses to take His birth.

The Lord's birth on the face of the earth is certainly very mysterious, and therefore it is difficult for ordinary men to believe in His birth. How can the all-powerful Lord take birth, seemingly like an ordinary man? The matter is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä (4.6), where the Lord says,

ajo 'pi sann avyayätmä bhütänäm éçvaro 'pi san
prakåtià sväm adhiñöhäya sambhavämy ätma-mäyayä

"Although I am unborn and My transcendental body never deteriorates, and although I am the Lord of all sentient beings, I still appear in every millennium in My original transcendental form." From the çästra we learn that the Lord takes birth not only in the family of human beings but also in the families of demigods, aquatics, animals, and so on. One may argue that an ordinary living being is eternal and unborn like the Lord and also takes birth in different species of life, and so there is no difference between the Lord and an ordinary living being. The difference is, however, that while an ordinary living being changes his body when he transmigrates from one species of life to another, the Lord never changes His body: He appears in His original body, without any change. Also, while there is a vast difference between the ordinary living entity and his body, there is no difference between the Lord and His body because He is pure spirit. In other words, there is no distinction between His body and His soul.

The word avyayätmä in the above verse from the Bhagavad-gétä clearly indicates that the Lord's body is not made of material elements. He is all spirit. Birth and death apply only to the material body. The body of the ordinary living being is made of material elements and is therefore subject to birth and death. But the Lord's body, being all spiritual and thus eternal, neither takes birth nor dies. Nor can the Lord be forced to take birth in some particular family due to His past deeds, as an ordinary living being is.

The Lord is the supreme controller of the material elements, and being endless and beginningless, He exists in all times—past, present, and future. And because He is absolute, He has nothing to do with vice and virtue. In other words, for Him "vices" and "virtues" are one and the same; otherwise the Lord would not be the Absolute Truth.

Since the Lord appears by His internal potency, His incarnations in different species of life are not the creation of the external potency, Mäyä. Therefore those who think that the Supreme Lord appears in different forms by accepting a body made of material elements are wrong; their vision is imperfect because they do not understand how the Lord's internal potency works. The Vedas inquire, Where does the Supreme Lord stand? And the reply is immediately given: He stands on His internal potency. So the conclusion is that although the Lord may seem to assume a material body when He takes birth, like an ordinary being, in fact He does not, for there is no difference between Him and His body. Thus He remains the Absolute Truth in all His appearances in different species of life.

In other words, the living being and the Supreme Lord appear in this material world under different circumstances. One can easily understand these different circumstances if one understands how the Lord's different potencies work. As explained before, the Lord has three kinds of potency, namely, internal, marginal, and external. We have wide experience of the external, or material, potency, but we generally fail to inquire about the actions and reactions of the other two potencies. A simple example will help us understand how the Lord's potencies work. Consider three identities: God, a man, and a doll. The doll consists of material energy, the man is a combination of material and spiritual energy, and God consists wholly of spiritual energy. The doll is all matter, internally and externally. Man is externally matter but internally spirit. And God is all spirit, both internally and externally. As the doll is all matter, so God is all spirit. But the man is half spirit and half matter.

Thus the body of God and the body of a living being are differently constituted. Because the Lord's body is pure spirit, it never deteriorates, and therefore He is called avyayätmä. His body is absolute, beginningless, unborn, and eternal, while the material body of the living being is relative and therefore temporary—it undergoes birth and death. The living being himself, of course, is eternal, and if He so desires he can realize his eternality by merging into the body of the Absolute Truth or being reinstated in his constitutional position as an eternal servant of the Lord. If he does not do so, then his eternality is still maintained, but he remains ignorant of it.

The conclusion is that the Personality of Godhead appears in His original body, without any change, and this is made possible by His inconceivable potency. We should always remember that nothing is impossible for the omnipotent Lord. If He so desires, He can transform material energy into spiritual energy. Indeed, if he so desires He can bring the entire spiritual nature within the material nature, without the spiritual nature being affected by the material modes in any way.

The Lord's different potencies remain tightly under His control. In fact, the Lord actually has only one potency—namely, the internal potency—which He employs for different purposes. The situation is similar to how one uses electricity. The same electricity can be used for both heating and cooling. Such contradictory results are due to the expert handling of a technician. In the same way, by His supreme will the Lord employs His one internal potency to accomplish many different purposes. That is the information we get from the çrutis (Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad 6.8): paräsya çaktir vividhaiva çrüyate.

The present verse of the Mukunda-mälä-stotra states that the color of the Lord's body is blackish, like that of a new cloud. Also, His body is very soft. Softness of the body is a sign of a great personality. The çästras state that the following bodily features indicate a great personality: a reddish luster in seven places—the eyes, the palms, the soles, the palate, the lips, the tongue, and the nails; broadness in three places—the waist, the forehead, and the chest; shortness in three places—the neck, the thighs, and the genitals; deepness in three places—the voice, the intelligence, and the navel; highness in five places—the nose, the arms, the ears, the forehead, and the thighs; and fineness in five places—the skin, the hair on the head, the bodily hair, the teeth, and the fingertips. All these features are present in the body of the Lord.

The Brahma-saàhitä confirms that the color the Lord's body is blackish, like that of a new cloud. But this blackish color is so beautiful that it surpasses the beauty of millions of Cupids. So this blackish color does not correspond to any blackish color in the material world.

Such descriptions of the Lord's body are not imaginary; rather, they are the statements of those who have seen the Lord with their supernatural vision. This supernatural vision is bestowed upon devotees like Brahmä and upon those who follow the footsteps of pure devotees like him. But upstarts and unbelievers cannot have any access to this transcendental vision, for they lack the required submission to the will of the Lord.

MM mantra 3

TEXT 3

TEXT

mukunda mürdhnä praëipatya yäce

bhavantam ekäntam iyantam artham

avismåtis tvac-caraëäravinde

bhave bhave me 'stu bhavat-prasädät

SYNONYMS

mukunda—O Lord Mukunda; mürdhnä—with my head; praëipatya—bowing down; yäce—I respectfully beg; bhavantam—from You; ekäntam—exclusively; iyantam—this much; artham—desire to be fulfilled; avismåtiù—freedom from forgetfulness; tvat—Your; caraëa-aravinde—at the lotus feet; bhave bhave—in each repeated birth; me—my; astu—let there be; bhavat—Your; prasädät—by the mercy.

TRANSLATION

O Lord Mukunda! I bow down my head to Your Lordship and respectfully ask You to fulfill this one desire of mine: that in each of my future births I will, by Your Lordship's mercy, always remember and never forget Your lotus feet.

PURPORT

The world in which we live is a miserable place. It is, so to speak, a prison house for the spirit soul. Just as a prisoner cannot move or enjoy life fully, so the living entities who have been conditioned by the laws of material nature cannot experience their actual ever-joyful nature. They cannot have any freedom, because they must suffer four principal miseries—birth, old age, disease, and death. The laws of material nature impose this punishment upon the living entities who have forgotten the Lord and who are busy making plans for lasting happiness in this desert of distress.

By the mercy of the Lord, the pure devotee knows all this very well. Indeed, his whole philosophy of life is based on this understanding. Advancement of knowledge means to understand the naked truth of this world and to not be deluded by the temporary beauty of this phantasmagoria.

The material nature is not at all beautiful, for it is an "imitation peacock." The real peacock is a different thing, and one must have the sense to understand this. Those who are mad after capturing and enjoying the imitation peacock, as well as those who have a pessimistic view of the imitation peacock but lack any positive information of the real peacock—both are illusioned by the modes of material nature. Those who are after the imitation peacock are the fruitive workers, and those who simply condemn the imitation peacock but are ignorant of the real peacock are the empiric philosophers. Disgusted with the mirage of happiness in the material desert, they seek to merge into voidness.

But a pure devotee does not belong to either of these two bewildered classes. Neither aspiring to enjoy the imitation peacock nor condemning it out of disgust, he seeks the real peacock. Thus he is unlike either the deluded fruitive worker or the baffled empiricist. He is above these servants of material nature because he prefers to serve the Lord, the master of material nature. He seeks the substance and does not wish to give it up. The substance is the lotus feet of Mukunda, and King Kulaçekhara, being a most intelligent devotee, prays to gain that substance and not the shadow.

A pure devotee of Lord Näräyaëa, or Mukunda, is not at all afraid of any circumstance that may befall him. Despite all difficulties, therefore, such a pure devotee asks nothing from the Lord on his own account. He is not at all afraid if by chance he has to visit the hellish worlds, nor is he eager to enter the kingdom of heaven. For him both these kingdoms are like castles in the air. He is not concerned with either of them, and this is very nicely expressed by King Kulaçekhara in Text 6.

A pure devotee of the Lord like King Kulaçekhara does not pray to God for material wealth, followers, a beautiful wife, or any such imitation peacocks, for he knows the real value of such things. And if by circumstance he is placed in a situation where he possesses such things, he does not try to artificially get out of it by condemnation.

Çréla Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, a great associate of Lord Caitanya's, was a very rich man's son who had a beautiful wife and all other opulences. When he first met Lord Caitanya at Päëihäöi, a village about forty miles from Calcutta, Raghunätha däsa asked permission from the Lord to leave his material connections and accompany Him. The Lord refused to accept this proposal and instructed Raghunätha däsa that it is useless to leave worldly connections out of sentimentality or artificial renunciation. One must have the real thing at heart. If one finds himself entangled in worldly connections, one should behave outwardly like a worldly man but remain inwardly faithful for spiritual realization. That will help one on the progressive march of life. Nobody can cross over the big ocean in a sudden jump. What was possible for Hanumän by the grace of Lord Räma is not possible for an ordinary man. So to cross the ocean of illusion one should patiently cultivate devotion to the Lord, and in this way one can gradually reach the other side.

Although a pure devotee does not bother himself about what is going to happen next in his material situation, he is always alert not to forget his ultimate aim. King Kulaçekhara therefore prays that he may not forget the lotus feet of the Lord at any time.

To forget one's relationship with the Lord and thus to remain overwhelmed by material hankerings is the most condemned mode of life. This is exactly the nature of animal life. When the living entity is born in a species of lower animals, he completely forgets his relationship with the Lord and therefore remains always busy in the matter of eating, sleeping, fearing, and mating. Modern civilization promotes such a life of forgetfulness, with an improved economic condition for eating and so on. Various agents of the external energy make explicit propaganda to try to root out the very seed of divine consciousness. But this is impossible to do, because although circumstances may choke up a living being's divine consciousness for the time being, it cannot be killed. In his original identity the living entity is indestructible, and so also are his original spiritual qualities. One can kill neither the spirit soul nor his spiritual qualities. To remember the Lord and desire to serve Him are the spiritual qualities of the spirit soul. One can curb down these spiritual qualities by artificial means, but they will be reflected in a perverted way on the mirror of material existence. The spiritual quality of serving the Lord out of transcendental affinity will be pervertedly reflected as love for wine, women, and wealth in different forms. The so-called love of material things—even love for one's country, community, religion, or family, which is accepted as a superior qualification for civilized human beings—is simply a perverted reflection of the love of Godhead dormant in every soul. The position of King Kulaçekhara is therefore the position of a liberated soul, because he does not want to allow his genuine love of God to become degraded into so-called love for material things.

The words bhave bhave are very significant here. They mean "birth after birth." Unlike the jïänés, who aspire to merge with the impersonal Absolute and thereby stop the process of repeatedly taking birth, a pure devotee is never afraid of this process. In the Bhagavad-gétä (4.9) Lord Kåñëa says that His birth and deeds are all divyam, transcendental. In the same chapter (4.5) the Lord says that both He and Arjuna had had many, many previous births, but that while the Lord could remember all of them, Arjuna could not. For the Lord there is no difference between past, present, and future, but for the living being who has forgotten the Lord there is a difference, on account of his being forgetful of the past and ignorant of the future. But a living entity who always remembers the Lord and is thus His constant companion is as transcendentally situated as the Lord Himself. For such a devotee birth and death are one and the same, because he knows that such occurrences are only ephemeral flashes that do not affect his spiritual existence.

We may use a crude example to illustrate the difference between a devotee's death and an ordinary man's death. In her mouth the cat captures both her offspring and her prey, the rat. Such capturings may appear the same, but there is a vast difference between them. While the rat is being carried in the cat's mouth, his sensation is poles apart from that of the cat's offspring. For the rat the capture is a painful death strike, while for the offspring it is a pleasurable caress.

Similarly, the death of an ordinary man is vastly different from a devotee's passing away from the active scene of material existence. The death of an ordinary man occurs against the background of his past good and evil deeds, which determine his next birth. But for a devotee the case is different. Even if the devotee has failed to perfect his devotional service, he is guaranteed to take birth in a good family—a family of learned and devoted brähmaëas or a family of rich vaiçyas (merchants). A person who takes birth in such a family has a good chance to practice devotional service and improve his spiritual condition.

Unfortunately, in this iron age the members of well-to-do families generally misuse their wealth. Instead of improving their spiritual condition, they are misled by faulty association and fall victim to sensuality. To be saved from this faulty association, King Kulaçekhara prays fervently to the Lord that he may never forget His lotus feet in any future birth. A devotee who perfects his devotional service certainly goes back to Godhead without a doubt, so for him there is no question of birth or death. And, as mentioned above, a devotee who does not achieve complete perfection is guaranteed to take his birth in a learned and well-to-do family. But even if a devotee is not given the advantage of good parentage, if he can attain the benediction of always remembering the lotus feet of the Lord, that is greater than any number of material assets. Constant remembrance of the Lord's name, fame, qualities, and so on automatically nullifies the reactions of all vices and invokes the blessings of the Lord. This constant remembrance of the lotus feet of the Lord is possible only when one engages in His active service.

A pure devotee therefore never asks the Lord for wealth, followers, or even a beautiful wife. He simply prays for uninterrupted engagement in the Lord's service. That should be the motto of life for all prospective students in devotional service.

MM mantra 4

TEXT 4

TEXT

nähaà vande tava caraëayor dvandvam advandva-hetoù

kumbhépäkaà gurum api hare närakaà näpanetum

ramyä-rämä-mådu-tanu-latä nandane näpi rantuà

bhäve bhäve hådaya-bhavane bhävayeyaà bhavantam

SYNONYMS

na—not; aham—I; vande—pray; tava—Your; caraëayoù—of the lotus feet; dvandvam—to the pair; advandva—of release from duality; hetoù—for the reason; kumbhépäkam—the planet of boiling oil; gurum—most severe; api—either; hare—O Hari; närakam—hell; na—not; apanetum—to avoid; ramyä—very beautiful; rämä—of the fair sex; mådu—soft; tanu-latä—of creeperlike bodies; nandane—in the pleasure gardens of heaven; na api—nor; rantum—to enjoy; bhäve bhäve—in various rebirths; hådaya—of my heart; bhavane—within the house; bhävayeyam—may I concentrate; bhavantam—on You.

TRANSLATION

O Lord Hari, it is not to be saved from the dualities of material existence or the grim tribulations of the Kumbhépäka hell that I pray to Your lotus feet. Nor is my purpose to enjoy the soft-skinned beautiful women who reside in the gardens of heaven. I pray to Your lotus feet only so that I may remember You alone in the core of my heart, birth after birth.

PURPORT

There are two classes of men: the atheists and the theists. The atheists have no faith in the Supreme Personality of Godhead, while the theists have various degrees of faith in Him.

The atheists are faithless on account of their many misdeeds in their present and past lives. They fall into four categories: (1) the gross materialists, (2) the immoral sinners, (3) the number-one fools, and (4) those who are bewildered by mäyä despite their mundane erudition. No one among these four classes of atheist ever believes in the Supreme Personality of Godhead, what to speak of offering prayers unto His lotus feet.

The theists, on the other hand, have faith in the Lord and pray to Him with various motives. One attains such a theistic life not by chance but as a result of performing many pious acts in both the present life and the past life. Such pious men also belong to four categories: (1) the needy, (2) those who have fallen into difficulty, (3) those who are inquisitive about the transcendental science, and (4) the genuine philosophers. The philosophers and those who are inquisitive are better than those in categories (1) and (2). But a pure devotee is far above these four classes of pious men, for he is in the transcendental position.

The needy pious man prays to God for a better standard of life, and the pious man who has fallen into material difficulty prays in order to get rid of his trouble. But the inquisitive man and the philosopher do not pray to God for amelioration of mundane problems. They pray for the ability to know Him as He is, and they try to reach Him through science and logic. Such pious men are generally known as theosophists.

Needy pious men pray to God to improve their economic condition because all they know is sense gratification, while those in difficulty ask Him to free them from a hellish life of tribulations. Such ignorant people do not know the value of human life. This life is meant to prepare one to return to the absolute world, the kingdom of God.

A pure devotee is neither a needy man, a man fallen into difficulty, nor an empiric philosopher who tries to approach the Divinity on the strength his own imperfect knowledge. A pure devotee receives knowledge of the Divinity from the right source—the disciplic succession of realized souls who have followed strictly the disciplinary method of devotional service under the guidance of bona fide spiritual masters. It is not possible to know the transcendental nature of the Divinity by dint of one's imperfect sense perception, but the Divinity reveals Himself to a pure devotee in proportion to the transcendental service rendered unto Him.

King Kulaçekhara is a pure devotee, and as such he is not eager to improve himself by the standards of the empiric philosophers, distressed men, or fruitive workers of this world. Pious acts may lead a mundane creature toward the path of spiritual realization, but practical activity in the domain of devotional service to the Lord need not wait for the reactions of pious acts. A pure devotee does not think in terms of his personal gain or loss because he is fully surrendered to the Lord. He is concerned only with the service of the Lord and always engages in that service, and for this reason his heart is the Lord's home. The Lord being absolute, there is no difference between Him and His service. A pure devotee's heart is always filled with ideas about executing the Lord's service, which is bestowed upon the pure devotee through the transparent medium of the spiritual master.

The spiritual master in the authoritative line of disciplic succession is the "son of God," or in other words the Lord's bona fide representative. The proof that he is bona fide is his invincible faith in God, which protects him from the calamity of impersonalism. An impersonalist cannot be a bona fide spiritual master, for such a spiritual master's only purpose in life must be to render service to the Lord. He preaches the message of Godhead as the Lord's appointed agent and has nothing to do with sense gratification or the mundane wrangling of the impersonalists. No one can render devotional service to an impersonal entity because such service implies a reciprocal personal relationship between the servant and the master. In the impersonal school the so-called devotee is supposed to merge with the Lord and lose his separate existence.

Pure devotees like King Kulaçekhara are particularly careful to avoid a process that will end in their becoming one with the existence of the Lord, a state known as advandva, nonduality. This is simply spiritual suicide. Out of the five kinds of salvation, advandva is the most abominable for a devotee. A pure devotee denounces such oneness with the Lord as worse than going to hell.

As His separated expansions, the living beings are part and parcel of the Lord. The Lord expands Himself into plenary parts and separated parts to enjoy transcendental pastimes, and if a living being refuses to engage in these transcendental blissful pastimes, he is at liberty to merge into the Absolute. This is something like a son's committing suicide instead of living with his father according to the rules the father sets down. By committing suicide, the son thus sacrifices the happiness he could have enjoyed by engaging in a filial loving relationship with his father and enjoying his father's estate. A pure devotee persistently avoids such a criminal policy, and King Kulaçekhara is guiding us to avoid this pitfall.

The king also says that the reason he is praying to the Lord is not to be saved from the Kumbhépäka hell. Laborers in gigantic iron and steel mills suffer tribulations similar to those in the Kumbhépäka hell. Kumbhé means "pot," and päka means "boiling." So if a person were put into a pot of oil and the pot were set to boiling, he would have some idea of the suffering in Kumbhépäka hell.

There are innumerable hellish engagements in the modern so-called civilization, and by the grace of the Lord's illusory energy people think these hellish engagements are a great fortune. Modern industrial factories fully equipped with up-to-date machines are so many Kumbhépäka hells, and the organizers of these enterprises regard them as indispensable for the advancement of economic welfare. The mass of laborers exploited by the organizers directly experience the "welfare" conditions in these factories, but what the organizers do not know is that by the law of karma they will in due time become laborers in similar Kumbhépäka hells.

Intelligent persons certainly want to be saved from such Kumbhépäka hells, and they pray to God for this benediction. But a pure devotee does not pray in this way. A pure devotee of Näräyaëa looks equally upon the happiness enjoyed in heaven, the transcendental bliss of becoming one with the Lord, and the tribulations experienced in the Kumbhépäka hell. He is not concerned with any of them because he is always engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. By the grace of the Lord, even in the Kumbhépäka hell a pure devotee can adjust the situation and turn it into Vaikuëöha.

The Bhagavad-gétä and all other revealed scriptures say that the Lord accompanies every living being in His localized aspect of Paramätmä, the Supersoul. Therefore even a living being destined to reside in the Kumbhépäka hell is accompanied by his eternal companion, the Lord. But by His inconceivable power the Lord remains aloof from these hellish circumstances, just as the sky remains separate from the air although seemingly mixed with it.

Similarly, the pure devotee of the Lord does not live anywhere in this material world, although He appears to live among mundane creatures. Actually, the devotee lives in Vaikuëöha. In this way the Supreme Lord bestows upon His pure devotee the inconceivable power that allows him to stay aloof from all mundane circumstances and reside eternally in the spiritual world. The devotee does not want this power consciously or unconsciously, but the Lord is careful about His devotee, just as a mother is always careful about her little child, who is completely dependent on her care.

A pure devotee like King Kulaçekhara refuses to associate with beautiful soft-skinned women. There are different grades of women on different planets in the universe. Even on the earth there are different types of women who are enjoyed by different types of men. But on higher planets there are women many, many millions of times more beautiful than the women on this planet, and there are also many pleasure abodes where they can be enjoyed. The best of all of these is the Nandana Gardens on Svargaloka. In the Nandana Gardens—a "Garden of Eden"—those who are qualified can enjoy varieties of beautiful women called Apsaräs. The demigods generally enjoy the company of the Apsaräs in the same way that the great Mogul kings and nawabs enjoyed their harems. But these kings and nawabs are like straw before the demigods of Svargaloka, which lies in the third stratum of the universe.

The inner tendency to enjoy is in the core of every living being's heart. But in the diseased state of material existence the living being misuses that tendency. The more he increases this diseased, conditioned state, the longer he extends his period of material existence. The çästras advise, therefore, that a living entity should accept only those sense—enjoyable objects necessary for the upkeep of the material body and reject those that are just for sense gratification. In this way he will reduce the tendency for sense enjoyment. This restraint cannot be imposed by force; it must be voluntary.

Such restraint automatically develops in the course of one's executing devotional service. Thus one who is already engaged in devotional service need not restrain his senses artificially. A pure devotee like King Kulaçekhara, therefore, neither desires sense enjoyment nor exerts himself to restrain his senses; rather, he tries only to engage himself in the transcendental loving service of the Lord, without any stop.

MM mantra 5

TEXT 5

TEXT

nästhä dharme na vasu-nicaye naiva kämopabhoge

yad bhävyaà tad bhavatu bhagavan pürva-karmänurüpam

etat prärthyaà mama bahu mataà janma-janmäntare 'pi

tvat-pädämbhoruha-yuga-gatä niçcalä bhaktir astu

SYNONYMS

na—not; ästhä—special regard; dharme—for religiosity; na—nor; vasu—of wealth; nicaye—for the accumulation; na eva—nor even; käma-upabhoge—for sense enjoyment; yat—whatever; bhävyam—inevitable; tat—that; bhavatu—let it happen; bhagavan—O Lord; pürva—previous; karma—my deeds; anurüpam—according to; etat—this; prärthyam—to be requested; mama—by me; bahu matam—most desirable; janma-janma—birth after birth; antare—during; api—even; tvat—Your; päda-ambhoruha—of lotus feet; yuga—in the pair; gatä—resting; niçcalä—unflinching; bhaktiù—devotion; astu—may there be.

TRANSLATION

O my Lord! I have no attachment for religiosity, or for accumulating wealth, or for enjoying sense gratification. Let these come as they inevitably must, in accordance with my past deeds. But I do pray for this most cherished boon: birth after birth, let me render unflinching devotional service unto Your two lotus feet.

PURPORT

Human beings advance toward God consciousness when they go beyond the gross materialistic life of eating, sleeping, fearing, and mating and begin to develop moral and ethical principles. These principles develop further into religious consciousness, leading to an imaginary conception of God without any practical realization of the truth. These stages of God consciousness are called religiosity, which promises material prosperity of various degrees.

People who develop this conception of religiosity perform sacrifices, give in charity, and undergo different types of austerity and penance, all with a view toward being rewarded with material prosperity. The ultimate goal of such so-called religious people is sense gratification of various kinds. For sense gratification, material prosperity is necessary, and therefore they perform religious rituals with a view toward the resultant material name, fame, and gain.

But genuine religion is different. In Sanskrit such genuine religion is called dharma, which means "the essential quality of the living being." The çästras say that this essential quality is to render eternal service, and the proper object of this service is the Supreme Truth, Lord Kåñëa, the Absolute Personality of Godhead. This eternal, transcendental service of the Lord is misdirected under material conditions and takes the shape of (1) the aforementioned religiosity, (2) economic development, (3) sense gratification, and (4) salvation, or the attempt to negate all material variegatedness out of frustration.

Genuine religion, however, does not culminate in either economic development, sense gratification, or salvation. The perfection of religion is to attain complete satisfaction of the spirit soul, and this is accomplished by rendering devotional service to the Lord, who is beyond the perception of the material senses. When the living being directs his eternal service attitude toward the eternal Supreme Being, such service can never be hampered by any sort of material hindrance. Such transcendental service is above even salvation, and therefore it certainly does not aim at any kind of material reward in the shape of name, fame, or gain.

One who engages in the transcendental loving service of the Supreme Being automatically attains detachment from material name, fame, and gain, which are aspired for only by those who do not understand that this name, fame, and gain are merely shadows of the real thing. Material name, fame, and gain are only perverted reflections of the substance—the name, fame, and opulences of the Lord. Therefore the pure devotee of Lord Väsudeva, enlightened by the transcendental service attitude, has no attraction for such false things as religiosity, economic development, sense gratification, or salvation, the last snare of Mäyä.

The purpose of performing real religion is to attain attachment for hearing and chanting the messages of the kingdom of God. Materialistic people are attached to ordinary newspapers on account of their lack of spiritual consciousness. Real religion develops this spiritual consciousness and also attachment for the messages of God, without which all labor in the performance of religious rites is only a waste of energy.

Therefore one should not practice religion with the aim of improving one's economic welfare, nor should one use one's wealth for sense gratification, nor should the frustration of one's plans for sense gratification lead one to aspire for salvation, or liberation from material conditions. Instead of indulging in sense gratification of different grades with the fruits of one's labor, one should work just to maintain the body and soul together, with the aim of inquiring into the ultimate aims and objects of life. In other words, one should inquire into the Absolute Truth.

The Absolute Truth is realized in three phases, namely, the impersonal Brahman, the localized Paramätmä, and the Supreme Personality of Godhead. A person who attains the highest stage of spiritual realization—realization of the Supreme Personality of Godhead—automatically prays as King Kulaçekhara does here.

Only one who renders devotional service to the Lord can attain this stage of indifference to the false and temporary assets of material nature. Such devotional service is not a mental concoction of depraved persons but is an actual process of God realization characterized by full cognizance and detachment and based on the Vedic literature. So-called devotional practices that have no reference to the rules and regulations set down in such books of Vedic literature as the çruti, the småti, the Puräëas, and the Païcarätras are not bona fide. The self-realized souls advise us to reject such pseudodevotional practices, which simply create a disturbance on the path of spiritual realization. Only by sincerely engaging in the service of the Lord according to the injunctions of scripture can one gradually become a qualified devotee of the Lord, and it does not matter whether it takes many repetitions of birth and death, life after life.

MM mantra 6

TEXT 6

TEXT

divi vä bhuvi vä mamästu väso

narake vä narakäntaka prakämam

avadhérita-çäradäravindau

caraëau te maraëe 'pi cintayämi

SYNONYMS

divi—in the abode of the demigods; vä—or; bhuvi—on the earth, the home of human beings; vä—or; mama—my; astu—may be; väsaù—residence; narake—in hell; vä—or; naraka-antaka—O killer of the demon Naraka; prakämam—however You desire; avadhérita—which have defied; çärada—of the fall season; aravindau—the lotus flowers; caraëau—the two feet; te—Your; maraëe—at the time of death; api—even; cintayämi—may I remember.

TRANSLATION

O Lord, killer of the demon Naraka! Let me reside either in the realm of the demigods, in the world of human beings, or in hell, as You please. I pray only that at the point of death I may remember Your two lotus feet, whose beauty defies that of the lotus growing in the Çarat season.

PURPORT

As stated before, a pure devotee of the Lord has nothing to do with mundane religiosity, economic development, sense gratification, or salvation, nor is he concerned whether his standard of material existence is the highest or the lowest. To him, heaven and hell are of equal value. He is not afraid of going to hell for the service of the Lord, nor is he glad to live in heaven without the service of the Lord. In any circumstance his consciousness is fixed on the Lord's lotus feet, whose beauty defies the most beautiful lotus flower of the mundane world.

The defiance is due to the transcendental position of the Lord's form, name, qualities, pastimes, and so on. The çruti mantras declare that although the Lord has no hands He can accept anything we offer Him with devotion, although He has no feet He can travel anywhere, and although He has no mundane eyes He can see anywhere and

everywhere without hindrance. The Brahma-saàhitä describes each of His senses as omnipotent. The mundane eye can see but not hear, but His eyes can see, hear, eat, generate offspring, and so on. The çruti mantras say that He impregnates material nature with the seeds of living beings simply by casting His glance at her. He does not need any other kind of intercourse with mother nature to beget the living beings in her womb and become their father.

Therefore any relationship the Lord has with His many devotees—whether fatherhood, sonhood, or any other—is not at all material. The Lord is pure spirit, and only when the living being is in his pure spiritual state can he have all sorts of relationships with Him. Philosophers with a poor fund of knowledge cannot conceive of these positive spiritual relationships between the Lord and the all-spiritual living beings, and thus they simply think in terms of negating material relationships. In this way such philosophers naturally adopt the concept of impersonalism.

By contrast, a pure devotee like King Kulaçekhara has complete knowledge of both matter and spirit. He does not say that everything material is false, yet he has nothing to do with anything material, from heaven down to hell. He fully understands the statement in the Bhagavad-gétä that from the lowest planets up to Brahmaloka, the highest planet in the universe, there is no spiritual bliss, which the living beings hanker for. Therefore the pure devotee, being in full knowledge of spiritual life, simultaneously rejects material relationships and cultivates his spiritual relationship with the Lord. In other words, the spiritual knowledge a devotee possesses not only allows him to reject material existence, but it also provides him with an understanding of the reality of positive, eternal spiritual existence. This is the understanding King Kulaçekhara expresses in this prayer.


Närada-bhakti-sütra

Translations and purports # 1 - 8, by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda.

NBS Introduction

Introduction

In 1967, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda translated and wrote purports for thirteen of the eighty-four aphorisms (Çréla Prabhupäda called them "codes") of the Närada-bhakti-sütra. In 1989, at their annual meeting, the Governing Body Commission of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) suggested that I complete the book. I was pleased to accept the assignment, especially because of my involvement with Çréla Prabhupäda's initial writing of the Närada-bhakti-sütra.

I was part of the small group of seekers who joined Çréla Prabhupäda in the latter part of 1966 at his storefront temple at 26 Second Avenue, in New York City. At one point we began passing around a Gita Press edition of Närada's Philosophy of Love—Närada-bhakti-sütra. Some of us were attracted to the nectar and simplicity of the aphorisms. In those days it wasn't unusual for us naive followers to pick up all sorts of translations of Sanskrit Indian books. We tended to think that anything Hindu was salutary and within Kåñëa consciousness. It wasn't long before Çréla Prabhupäda made it clear to us that we had to discriminate. Many books, we learned, were the works of Mäyävädés, a brand of atheists in the guise of svämés, gurus, and scholars. It was hard to break our attachments to some of these books, but we always did so once Çréla Prabhupäda explained that a particular book or guru was not bona fide.

But when I showed Çréla Prabhupäda the Närada-bhakti-sütra and told him I liked it, he encouraged me and said he might translate it.

In our edition of the Närada-bhakti-sütra was a beautiful color illustration of Çré Çré Rädhä and Kåñëa. They looked young, about eight years old, and stood gracefully by the edge of the Yamunä River with a cow behind Them. I took the illustration to a photography shop and had a dozen color copies made. With Çréla Prabhupäda's approval, I gave a photo to each of his initiated disciples. It became like an ISKCON membership photo and was used by devotees on their personal altars.

When Çréla Prabhupäda left our New York home early in 1967 and went to San Francisco, I wrote him to ask if he would translate the Närada-bhakti-sütra. Here is Çréla Prabhupäda's reply, dated February 10, 1967:

Yes, please send me immediately one copy of Bhakti Sutra (with original Sanskrit text). I shall immediately begin the commentary.

At first Çréla Prabhupäda's translation of the Närada-bhakti-sütra went quickly. He sent tapes of his dictation in the mail, and I transcribed them along with the tapes he sent for his major work, Teachings of Lord Caitanya. From the beginning it was understood that Närada-bhakti-sütra was a kind of "extra" for Çréla Prabhupäda. But it had its own charm, and Prabhupäda approached it in his own inimitable way. I was surprised, on receiving the translation for the first aphorism, to see how Çréla Prabhupäda translated the word bhakti. The edition he was using translated bhakti as "devotion" or "Divine Love." But Çréla Prabhupäda translated bhakti as "devotional service." Even by this one phrase he indicated that bhakti was active and personal. He would not tolerate any hint that bhakti was a state of impersonal "Love."

It was significant that Çréla Prabhupäda began his first purport with a reference to Bhagavad-gétä, the foremost scripture for teaching bhakti-yoga. The Närada-bhakti-sütra, or any other treatise on devotion to God, should be supported by Lord Kåñëa's direct teachings in Bhagavad-gétä. By their nature, sütras require explanation. As Lord Caitanya explained while discussing the Vedänta-sütra, the aphorisms have a direct meaning, but their brevity allows devious commentators to distort the meaning through misinterpretation. How safe we were when reading the Bhaktivedanta purports to the Närada-bhakti-sütra, and how dangerous it is to read these aphorisms when interpreted by those who lack pure devotion to the Supreme Person!

As with his other works, Çréla Prabhupäda's purports to the Närada-bhakti-sütra were completely in line with the teachings of the param-parä, or disciplic succession, and at the same time full of his own realizations.

One particular statement that attracted me was his reference to enthusiasm in bhakti. Commenting on Sütra 5, Çréla Prabhupäda compared enthusiasm to a powerful engine that has to be used properly. He wrote, "If one, however, becomes disappointed in his enthusiasm for serving the Supreme Lord, that disappointment must also be rejected." As a neophyte devotee, I was well aware of the danger of depression, which we sometimes refer to in ISKCON as being "fried." But just as a serious practitioner restrains his tongue and other senses, so one should not indulge in too much depression or disappointment. It was comforting to hear this from Çréla Prabhupäda and to gain conviction that it is within our control—we are not helpless before unlimited waves of depression.

One simply has to follow the rules and regulations patiently "so that the day will come when he will achieve, all of a sudden, all the perfection of devotional service."

I have to admit that I acquired a personal attachment for Çréla Prabhupäda's Närada-bhakti-sütra as I happily watched its progress. I noticed that some of the same material Çréla Prabhupäda was putting into Teachings of Lord Caitanya also appeared in the Närada-bhakti-sütra, but I didn't think anything was wrong in that. Yet at some point Çréla Prabhupäda began to think that perhaps Närada-bhakti-sütra was a bit redundant, at least while he was also working on Teachings of Lord Caitanya. I might have suspected this when he wrote in his purport to Sütra 12, "There are many authoritative books of spiritual knowledge, but all of them are more or less supplements to the Bhagavad-gétä and Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Even the Närada-bhakti-sütra is a summary of the Bhagavad-gétä and the Çrémad-Bhägavatam. Therefore the beginning of devotional service is to hear these two important transcendental books of knowledge."

Then, in March of 1967, while Çréla Prabhupäda was still residing in San Francisco, he wrote me this letter:

Please accept my blessings. I have seen the typed copies of Narada Bhakti Sutras as well as Teachings of Lord Caitanya. Both of them are nicely made. I think let us finish first Teachings of Lord Caitanya and then we may take again Narada Bhakti Sutras. The subject matter discussed with Narada Sutras is already there in the Teachings of Lord Caitanya.

I have sent you matter for the second part of the Teachings and please go on sending me a copy of your typewritten matter. I shall be glad to hear from you.

And so Çréla Prabhupäda's work on the Närada-bhakti-sütra stopped, and it was never resumed. It was a personal choice by the author, who wanted to concentrate on Teachings of Lord Caitanya. But we should not see it as a rejection of the Närada-bhakti-sütra. Çréla Prabhupäda intended to "take again Narada Bhakti Sutras." And so more than twenty years later we are taking up the work again, on the authority of Çréla Prabhupäda. Whatever we have written to complete the work we have done as Çréla Prabhupäda's student, using his commentated translations of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, the Bhagavad-gétä, and the Caitanya-caritämåta, and his summary studies of the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (The Nectar of Devotion) and the Bhägavatam's Tenth Canto (Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead).

There is a particular charm to the Närada-bhakti-sütra in its brevity, universality, and emphasis on total surrender to Lord Kåñëa. The aphorisms are strong and can be easily remembered and confidently quoted in devotional discussions and preaching. Çréla Prabhupäda refers to the Närada-bhakti-sütra several times in his writings, as in this statement from Teachings of Lord Caitanya (p. 53-4): "In the Närada-bhakti-sütra it is said that one who is very serious about developing Kåñëa consciousness has his desire to understand Kåñëa fulfilled very soon by the grace of the Lord."

The major importance of the present publication is that another of Çréla Prabhupäda's literary works is now available in book form for his growing reading audience. The GBC's request to Gopiparäëadhana Prabhu and me to complete the Närada-bhakti-sütra is their mercy upon us. We pray that we have not deviated from Çréla Prabhupäda's intentions and that this edition of the Närada-bhakti-sütra will bring pleasure and enlightenment to the hearts of everyone who reads it.

Satsvarüpa


NBS: The Value of Devotion

Chapter 1

The Value of Devotion

NBS 1

SÜTRA 1

@TaAtaAe Bai·M( vyaAKyaAsyaAma:

SÜTRA

athäto bhaktià vyäkhyäsyämaù

SYNONYMS

atha—now; ataù—therefore; bhaktim—devotional service; vyäkhyäsyämaù—we shall try to explain.

TRANSLATION

Now, therefore, I will try to explain the process of devotional service.

PURPORT

Devotional service to the Supreme Personality of Godhead is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä, where the Lord says that a self-realized person is always in the transcendental state known as brahma-bhüta, which is characterized by joyfulness. When one is self-realized he becomes joyful. In other words, he is free from the material contamination of lamentation and hankering. As long as we are in material existence, we lament for the losses in our life and hanker for that which we do not have. A self-realized person is joyful because he is free from material lamentation and hankering.

A self-realized person also sees all living entities equally. For him, there is no distinction between the higher and lower species of life. It is also stated that a learned man does not distinguish between a wise brähmaëa and a dog because he sees the soul within the body, not the external bodily features. Such a perfected, self-realized person becomes eligible to understand bhakti, or devotional service to the Lord.

Bhakti is so sublime that only through bhakti can one understand the constitutional position of the Lord. That is clearly stated in the Bhagavad-gétä (18.55): bhaktyä mäm abhijänäti. "One can understand the Supreme Lord through devotional service, and by no other process." There are different processes of understanding the Absolute Truth, but if a person wants to understand the Supreme Lord as He is, he has to take to the process of bhakti-yoga. There are other mystic processes, such as karma-yoga, jïäna-yoga, and dhyäna-yoga, but it is not possible to understand the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, except through His devotional service. This is confirmed in the Fourth Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä (4.3), where we learn that Kåñëa spoke the Bhagavad-gétä to Arjuna simply because he was the Lord's devotee and friend. The Bhagavad-gétä teaches the process of bhakti-yoga, and therefore Lord Kåñëa explained it to Arjuna because he was a great devotee. As far as spiritual life is concerned, becoming a devotee of the Lord is the highest perfection.

People are generally misled by the spell of the illusory energy of material nature. There are innumerable living entities within the material nature, and only some of them are human beings. According to the Vedic literature, there are 8,400,000 species of life. In the Padma Puräëa it is said that there are 900,000 species of life in the water, 2,000,000 species of plants, 1,100,000 species of insects and reptiles, 1,000,000 species of birds, 3,000,000 species of beasts, and only 400,000 species of human beings. So the humans are the least numerous species of all.

All living entities can be divided into two divisions: those that can move and those that are stationary, such as trees. But there are also many further divisions. Some species fly in the air, some live in the water, and some live on the ground. Among the living entities who live on the ground, only 400,000 are human species, and out of these 400,000 human species, many are uncivilized or unclean; they are not up to the standard of proper civilization. From the historical point of view, the Äryans are the most civilized section of human beings, and among the Äryans, the Indians are especially highly cultured. And among the Indians, the brähmaëas are the most expert in knowledge of the Vedas.

The Vedic culture is respected all over the world, and there are people everywhere eager to understand it. The highest perfectional stage of understanding Vedic culture is explained in the Bhagavad-gétä, in the Fifteenth Chapter (15.15), where the Lord says that the purpose of all the Vedas is to understand Him (Lord Kåñëa). Fortunate are those who are attracted to the Vedic cultural life.

The Hindus call themselves followers of the Vedas. Some say they follow the Säma Veda, and some say they follow the Åg Veda. Different people claim to follow different sections of the Vedas, but in fact for the most part they are not followers of the Vedas because they do not follow the rules and regulations of the Vedas. Therefore Lord Caitanya says that since the so-called followers of the Vedas perform all kinds of sinful activities, the number of actual followers of the Vedas is very small; and even among this small, exclusive number, most are addicted to the processes described in the Vedas' karma-käëòa section, by which one can elevate oneself to the perfectional stage of economic development.

The strict followers of the karma-käëòa portions of the Vedas perform various sacrifices for worship of different demigods in order to achieve particular material results. Out of many millions of such worshipers, some may actually engage in the process of understanding the Supreme, the Absolute Truth. They are called jïänés. Perfection for a jïäné lies in attaining the stage of brahma-bhüta, or self-realization. Only after self-realization is attained does the stage of understanding devotional service begin. The conclusion is that one can begin the process of devotional service, or bhakti, when one is actually self-realized. One who is in the bodily concept of existence cannot understand the process of devotional service.

It is for this reason that the Närada-bhakti-sütra begins, "Now, therefore, I shall try to explain the process of devotional service." The word "therefore" indicates that this process of devotional service is for the self-realized soul, one who is already liberated. Similarly, the Vedänta-sütra begins athäto brahma-jijïäsä. The word brahma-jijïäsä refers to inquiry into the Supreme Absolute Truth, and it is recommended for those who have been elevated from the lower stage of addiction to the karma-käëòa portion of the Vedas to the position of interest in the jïäna-käëòa portion. Only when a person is perfectly situated in the realization that he is not the body but a spirit soul can he begin the process of bhakti, or devotional service.

NBS 2

SÜTRA 2

s$aA tvaismana, par"ma‘aemaè&paA

SÜTRA

sä tv asmin parama-prema-rüpä

SYNONYMS

sä—it; tu—and; asmin—for Him (the Supreme Lord); parama—highest; prema—pure love; rüpä—having as its form.

TRANSLATION

Devotional service manifests as the most elevated, pure love for God.

PURPORT

As stated before, after attaining the highest stage of self-realization, one becomes situated in devotional service to the Lord. The perfection of devotional service is to attain love of God. Love of God involves the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the devotee, and the process of devotional service. Self-realization, the brahma-bhüta stage, is the beginning of spiritual life; it is not the perfectional stage. If a person understands that he is not his body and that he has nothing to do with this material world, he becomes free from material entanglement. But that realization is not the perfectional stage. The perfectional stage begins with activity in the self-realized position, and that activity is based on the understanding that a living entity is eternally the subordinate servitor of the Supreme Lord. Otherwise, there is no meaning to self-realization. If one is puffed up with the idea that he is the Supreme Brahman, or that he has become one with Näräyaëa, or that he has merged into the brahmajyoti effulgence, then he has not grasped the perfection of life. As the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.2.32) states,

ye 'nye 'ravindäkña vimukta-mäninas
tvayy asta-bhäväd aviçuddha-buddhayaù
äruhya kåcchreëa paraà padaà tataù
patanty adho 'nädåta-yuñmad-aìghrayaù

Persons who are falsely puffed up, thinking they have become liberated simply by understanding their constitutional position as Brahman, or spirit soul, are factually still contaminated. Their intelligence is impure because they have no understanding of the Personality of Godhead, and ultimately they fall down from their puffed-up position.

According to the Bhägavatam (1.2.11) there are three levels of transcendentalists: the self-realized knowers of the impersonal Brahman feature of the Absolute Truth; the knowers of the Paramätmä, the localized aspect of the Supreme, which is understood by the process of mystic yoga; and the bhaktas, who are in knowledge of the Supreme Personality of Godhead and engage in His devotional service. Those who understand simply that the living being is not matter but spirit soul and who desire to merge into the Supreme Spirit Soul are in the lowest transcendental position. Above them are the mystic yogés, who by meditation see within their hearts the four-handed Viñëu form of the Paramätmä, or Supersoul. But persons who actually associate with the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa, are the highest among all transcendentalists. In the Sixth Chapter of the Bhagavad-gétä (6.47) the Lord confirms this:

yoginäm api sarveñäà mad-gatenäntar-ätmanä
çraddhävän bhajate yo mäà sa me yukta-tamo mataù

"And of all yogés, he who always abides in Me with great faith, worshiping Me in transcendental loving service, is most intimately united with Me in yoga and is the highest of all." This is the highest perfectional stage, known as prema, or love of God.

In the Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (1.4.15-16), Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, a great authority in the devotional line, describes the different stages in coming to the point of love of Godhead:

ädau çraddhä tataù sädhu-saìgo 'tha bhajana-kriyä
tato 'närtha-nivåttiù syät tato niñöhä rucis tataù
athäsaktis tato bhävas tataù premäbhyudaïcati
sädhakänäm ayaà premëaù prädurbhäve bhavet kramaù

The first requirement is that one should have sufficient faith that the only process for attaining love of Godhead is bhakti, devotional service to the Lord. Throughout the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa teaches that one should give up all other processes of self-realization and fully surrender unto Him. That is faith. One who has full faith in Kåñëa (çraddhä) and surrenders unto Him is eligible for being raised to the level of prema, which Lord Caitanya taught as the highest perfectional stage of human life.

Some persons are addicted to materially motivated religion, while others are addicted to economic development, sense gratification, or the idea of salvation from material existence. But prema, love of God, is above all these. This highest stage of love is above mundane religiosity, above economic development, above sense gratification, and above even liberation, or salvation. Thus love of God begins with the firm faith that one who engages in full devotional service has attained perfection in all these processes.

The next stage in the process of elevation to love of God is sädhu-saìga, association with persons already in the highest stage of love of God. One who avoids such association and simply engages in mental speculation or so-called meditation cannot be raised to the perfectional platform. But one who associates with pure devotees or an elevated devotional society goes to the next stage—bhajana-kriyä, or acceptance of the regulative principles of worshiping the Supreme Lord. One who associates with a pure devotee of the Lord naturally accepts that person as his spiritual master, and when the neophyte devotee accepts a pure devotee as his spiritual master, the duty of the spiritual master is to train the neophyte in the principles of regulated devotional service, or vaidhi-bhakti. At this stage the devotee's service is based on his capacity to serve the Lord. The expert spiritual master engages his followers in work that will gradually develop their consciousness of service to the Lord. Therefore the preliminary stage of understanding prema, love of God, is to approach a proper pure devotee, accept him as one's spiritual master, and execute regulated devotional service under his guidance.

The next stage is called anartha-nivåtti, in which all the misgivings of material life are vanquished. A person gradually reaches this stage by regularly performing the primary principles of devotional service under the guidance of the spiritual master. There are many bad habits we acquire in the association of material contamination, chief of which are illicit sexual relationships, eating animal food, indulging in intoxication, and gambling. The first thing the expert spiritual master does when he engages his disciple in regulated devotional service is to instruct him to abstain from these four principles of sinful life.

Since God is supremely pure, one cannot rise to the highest perfectional stage of love of God without being purified. In the Bhagavad-gétä (10.12), when Arjuna accepted Kåñëa as the Supreme Lord, he said, pavitraà paramaà bhavän: "You are the purest of the pure." The Lord is the purest, and thus anyone who wants to serve the Supreme Lord must also be pure. Unless a person is pure, he can neither understand what the Personality of Godhead is nor engage in His service in love, for devotional service, as stated before, begins from the point of self-realization, when all misgivings of materialistic life are vanquished.

After following the regulative principles and purifying the material senses, one attains the stage of niñöhä, firm faith in the Lord. When a person has attained this stage, no one can deviate him from the conception of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. No one can persuade him that God is impersonal, without a form, or that any form created by imagination can be accepted as God. Those who espouse these more or less nonsensical conceptions of the Supreme Lord cannot dissuade him from firm faith in the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Kåñëa.

In the Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa stresses in many verses that He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. But despite Lord Kåñëa's stressing this point, many so-called scholars and commentators still deny the personal conception of the Lord. One famous scholar wrote in his commentary on the Bhagavad-gétä that one does not have to surrender to Lord Kåñëa or even accept Him as the Supreme Personality of Godhead, but that one should rather surrender to "the Supreme within Kåñëa." Such fools do not know what is within and what is without. They comment on the Bhagavad-gétä according to their own whims. Such persons cannot be elevated to the highest stage of love of Godhead. They may be scholarly, and they may be elevated in other departments of knowledge, but they are not even neophytes in the process of attaining the highest stage of perfection, love of Godhead. Niñöhä implies that one should accept the words of Bhagavad-gétä, the words of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, as they are, without any deviation or nonsensical commentary.

If a person is fortunate enough to vanquish all misgivings caused by material existence and rise up to the stage of niñöhä, he can then rise to the stages of ruci (taste) and äsakti (attachment for the Lord). Äsakti is the beginning of love of Godhead. By progressing, one then advances to the stage of relishing a reciprocal exchange with the Lord in ecstasy (bhäva). Every living entity is eternally related to the Supreme Lord, and this relationship may be in any one of many transcendental humors. At the stage called äsakti, attachment, a person can understand his relationship with the Supreme Lord. When he understands his position, he begins reciprocating with the Lord. By constant reciprocation with the Lord, the devotee is elevated to the highest stage of love of Godhead, prema.

NBS 3

SÜTRA 3

@ma{tasvaè&paA ca

SÜTRA

amåta-svarüpä ca

SYNONYMS

amåta—immortality; svarüpä—having as its essence; ca—and.

TRANSLATION

This pure love for God is eternal.

PURPORT

When a person attains to the perfectional stage of love of Godhead, he becomes liberated even in his present body and realizes his constitutional position of immortality. In the Bhagavad-gétä (4.9), the Lord says,

janma karma ca me divyam evaà yo vetti tattvataù
tyaktvä dehaà punar janma naiti mäm eti so 'rjuna

Here the Lord says that any person who simply understands His transcendental activities and His appearance and disappearance in this material world becomes liberated, and that after quitting his present body he at once reaches His abode. Therefore it is to be understood that one who has attained the stage of love of God has perfect knowledge, and even if he may fall short of perfect knowledge, he has the preliminary perfection of life that a living entity can attain.

To conceive of oneself as being one with the Supreme is the greatest misconception of self-realization, and this misconception prevents one from rising to the highest stage of love of God. But a person who understands his subordinate position can attain the highest stage of loving service to the Lord. Although the Lord and the living entities are qualitatively one, the living entities are limited, while the Lord is unlimited. This understanding, called amåta-svarüpa, makes one eligible for being eternally situated.

In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.87.30) the personified Vedas pray to the Lord, "O supreme eternal, if the living entities were equal with You and thus all-pervading and all-powerful like You, there would be no possibility of their being controlled by Your external energy, mäyä." Therefore, the living entities should be accepted as fragmental portions of the Supreme. This is confirmed in Bhagavad-gétä (15.7) when the Lord says, mamaiväàço jéva-loke jéva-bhütaù sanätanaù: "The living entities are My fragmental portions, eternally." As fragmental portions, they are qualitatively one with the Supreme, but they are not unlimited.

One who is convinced that he is eternally a servitor of the Supreme Lord is called immortal because he has realized his constitutional position of immortality. Unless one can understand his position as a living entity and an eternal servitor of the Lord, there is no question of immortality. But one who accepts these facts becomes immortal. In other words, those who are under the misconception that the living entity and the Supreme Lord are equal in all respects, both qualitatively and quantitatively, are mistaken, and they are still bound to remain in the material world. They cannot rise to the position of immortality.

Upon attaining love of God, a person immediately becomes immortal and no longer has to change his material body. But even if a devotee of the Lord has not yet reached the perfectional stage of love of Godhead, his devotional service is considered immortal. Any action in the stage of karma or jïäna will be finished with the change of body, but devotional service, even if not executed perfectly, will continue into the next life, and the living entity will be allowed to make further progress.

The constitutional position of the living entity as a fragment of the Supreme Lord is confirmed in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam and the Upaniñads. The Çvetäçvatara Upaniñad (5.9) states,

bälägra-çata-bhägasya çatadhä kalpitasya ca
bhägo jévaù sa vijïeyaù sa cänantyäya kalpate

"If the tip of a hair were divided into one hundred parts, and if one of those parts were again divided into a hundred parts, that one ten-thousandth part of the tip of the hair would be the dimension of the living entity." As already mentioned, this position of the living entity as a fragment of the Supreme Lord is declared in the Bhagavad-gétä (15.7) to be eternal; it cannot be changed. A person who understands his constitutional position as a fragment of the Supreme Lord and engages himself in devotional service with all seriousness at once becomes immortal.

NBS 4

SÜTRA 4

yaéabDvaA paumaAna, is$aÜ"Ae Bavatyama{taAe Bavaita ta{æaAe Bavaita

SÜTRA

yal labdhvä pumän siddho bhavaty amåto bhavati tåpto bhavati

SYNONYMS

yat—which; labdhvä—having gained; pumän—a person; siddhaù—perfect; bhavati—becomes; amåtaù—immortal; bhavati—becomes; tåptaù—peaceful; bhavati—becomes.

TRANSLATION

Upon achieving that stage of transcendental devotional service in pure love of God, a person becomes perfect, immortal, and peaceful.

PURPORT

The part-and-parcel living entities are entangled in the conditioned life of material existence. Because of their diverse activities they are wandering all over the universe, transmigrating from one body to another and undergoing various miseries. But when a fortunate living entity somehow comes in contact with a pure devotee of the Lord and engages in devotional service, he enters upon the path of perfection. If someone engages in devotional service in all seriousness, the Lord instructs him in two ways—through the pure devotee and from within—so that he can advance in devotional service. By cultivating such devotional service, he becomes perfect.

Lord Kåñëa describes this form of complete perfection in the Bhagavad-gétä (8.15):

mäm upetya punar janma duùkhälayam açäçvatam
näpnuvanti mahätmänaù saàsiddhià paramäà gatäù

"After attaining Me, the great souls, who are yogés in devotion, never return to this temporary world, which is full of miseries, because they have attained the highest perfection." Both while in the material body and after giving it up, a devotee attains the highest perfection in service to the Lord. As long as a devotee is in his material body, his probational activities in devotional service prepare him for being transferred to the Lord's supreme abode. Only those who are one hundred percent engaged in devotional service can achieve this perfection.

In material, conditioned life a person always feels the full miseries caused by the transmigration of the soul from body to body. Before taking birth, he undergoes the miseries of living in the womb of his mother, and when he comes out he lives for a certain period and then again has to die and enter a mother's womb. But one who attains the highest perfection goes back to Godhead after leaving his present body. Once there, he doesn't have to come back to this material world and transmigrate from one body to another. That transfer to the spiritual world is the highest perfection of life. In other words, the devotee achieves his constitutional position of immortality and thus becomes completely peaceful.

Until a person achieves this perfection, he cannot be peaceful. He may artificially think he is one with the Supreme, but actually he is not; therefore, he has no peace. Similarly, someone may aspire for one of the eight yogic perfections in the mystic yoga process, such as to become the smallest, to become the heaviest, or to acquire anything he desires, but these achievements are material; they are not perfection. Perfection means to regain one's original spiritual form and engage in the loving service of the Lord. The living entity is part and parcel of the Supreme Lord, and if he performs the duties of the part and parcel, without proudly thinking he is one in all respects with the Supreme Lord, he attains real perfection and becomes peaceful.

NBS 5

SÜTRA 5

yat‘aApya na ik(iÂaã"AHC$ita na zAAecaita na ãe"ií" na r"matae naAets$aAh"I Bavaita

SÜTRA

yat präpya na kiïcid väïchati na çocati na dveñöi na ramate notsähé bhavati

SYNONYMS

yat—which; präpya—having attained; na kiïcit—nothing; väïchati—hankers for; na çocati—does not lament; na dveñöi—does not hate; na ramate—does not rejoice; na—not; utsähé—materially enthusiastic; bhavati—becomes.

TRANSLATION

A person engaged in such pure devotional service neither desires anything for sense gratification, nor laments for any loss, nor hates anything, nor enjoys anything on his personal account, nor becomes very enthusiastic in material activity.

PURPORT

According to Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, there are six impediments to the discharge of devotional service, and also six activities favorable to progress in devotional service.

The first impediment is atyähära, overeating or accumulating more wealth than we need. When we give free rein to the senses in an effort to enjoy to the highest degree, we become degraded. A devotee should therefore eat only enough to maintain his body and soul together; he should not allow his tongue unrestricted license to eat anything and everything it likes. The Bhagavad-gétä and the great äcäryas, or spiritual masters, have prescribed certain foods for human beings, and one who eats these foods eats in the mode of goodness. These foods include grains, fruits, vegetables, milk products, and sugar—and nothing more. A devotee does not eat extravagantly; he simply eats what he offers to the Supreme Lord, Kåñëa. He is interested in kåñëa-prasädam (food offered to the Lord) and not in satisfying his tongue. Therefore he does not desire anything extraordinary to eat.

Similarly, a devotee does not wish to accumulate a large bank balance: he simply earns as much as he requires. This is called yävad-artha or yuktähära. In the material world everyone is very active in earning more and more money and in increasing eating and sleeping and gratifying the senses; such is the mission of most people's lives. But these activities should be absent from the life of a devotee.

The next impediment Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé mentions is prayäsa, endeavoring very hard for material things. A devotee should not be very enthusiastic about attaining any material goal. He should not be like persons who engage in fruitive activities, who work very hard day and night to attain material rewards. All such persons have some ambition—to become a very big businessman, to become a great industrialist, to become a great poet or philosopher. But they do not know that even if their ambition is fulfilled, the result is temporary. As soon as the body is finished, all material achievements are also finished. No one takes with him anything he has achieved materially in this world. The only thing he can carry with him is his asset of devotional service; that alone is never vanquished.

The next impediment to devotional service is prajalpa, talking of mundane subject matter. Many people unnecessarily talk of the daily happenings in the newspapers and pass the time without any profit. A devotee, however, does not indulge in unnecessary talks of politics or economics. Nor is a devotee very strict in following ritualistic rules and regulations mentioned in the Vedas. Becoming enamored of these rituals is the next impediment, called niyamägraha. Because a devotee fully engages in the supreme service of the Lord, he automatically fulfills all other obligations and doesn't have to execute all the details of Vedic rituals. As the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (11.5.41) says,

devarñi-bhütäpta-nåëäà pitèëäà
na kiìkaro näyam åëé ca räjan
sarvätmanä yaù çaraëaà çaraëyaà
gato mukundaà parihåtya kartam

"Every human being born in this world is immediately indebted to the demigods, the great sages, ordinary living entities, the family, society, and so on. But a person who surrenders unto the lotus feet of the Lord and engages fully in His service is no longer indebted to anyone. In other words, he has no obligations to fulfill except executing devotional service."

Finally, a devotee should not be greedy (laulyam), nor should he mix with ordinary materialistic men (jana-saìga).

These are six negatives, or "do-nots," for the devotee; therefore one who wants to attain the perfectional stage of love of Godhead refrains from these things.

Similarly, there are six positive items for advancing in devotional service. First, while one should not be enthusiastic to attain material achievements, one should be very enthusiastic to attain the perfectional stage of devotional service. This enthusiasm is called utsäha. A living entity cannot stop acting. So when he is forbidden to become enthusiastic about material achievements, he should at once be encouraged to be enthusiastic about spiritual achievements. Enthusiasm is a symptom of the living entity; it cannot be stopped. It is just like a powerful engine: if you utilize it properly, it will give immense production. Therefore enthusiasm should be purified. Instead of employing enthusiasm for attaining material goals, one should be enthusiastic about achieving the perfectional stage of devotional service. Indeed, enthusing His devotees in devotional service is the purpose for which Kåñëa descends to this material world.

The next item favorable for devotional service is niçcaya, confidence. When one becomes disappointed in his service to the Supreme Lord, that disappointment must be rejected and replaced with confidence in attaining the ultimate goal, love of Godhead. The devotee should patiently follow the rules and regulations of devotional service so that the day will come when he will achieve, all of a sudden, all the perfection of devotional service. He should not lament for any loss or any reverse in his advancement in spiritual life. This patience (dhairya) is the third positive item for advancing in devotional service.

Furthermore, a pure devotee is not envious, hateful, or lazy in the discharge of devotional service. Confident of his advancement, he continually performs his prescribed devotional duties. This is called tat-tat-karma-pravartana.

The last two items are saìga-tyäga, giving up the association of nondevotees, and sato-våtti, following in the footsteps of the previous äcäryas. These practices greatly help the devotee remain fixed on the path of devotional service and avoid the tendency to enjoy temporary, material things. Thus the activities of a devotee remain always pure and without any contamination of the material world.

NBS 6

SÜTRA 6

yajÁaAtvaA maÔaAe Bavaita stabDaAe BavatyaAtmaAr"AmaAe Bavaita

SÜTRA

yaj jïätvä matto bhavati stabdho bhavaty ätmärämo bhavati

SYNONYMS

yat—which; jïätvä—having known; mattaù—intoxicated; bhavati—becomes; stabdhaù—stunned (in ecstasy); bhavati—becomes; ätma-ärämaù—self-content (because of being engaged in the service of the Lord); bhavati—becomes.

TRANSLATION

One who understands perfectly the process of devotional service in love of Godhead becomes intoxicated in its discharge. Sometimes he becomes stunned in ecstasy and thus enjoys his whole self, being engaged in the service of the Supreme Self.

PURPORT

The Çrémad-Bhägavatam (1.7.10) states,

ätmärämäç ca munayo nirgranthä apy urukrame
kurvanty ahaitukéà bhaktià itthaà-bhüta-guëo hariù

"Although those who are ätmäräma, self-satisfied, are liberated from all material contamination, they are still attracted by the pastimes of the Supreme Lord, and thus they engage themselves in His transcendental service." When Lord Caitanya explained this ätmäräma verse to Çréla Sanätana Gosvämé, He described sixty-one meanings, and all of them point toward the devotional service of the Lord.

How one becomes intoxicated in devotional service is very nicely described in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (11.2.40):

evaà-vrataù sva-priya-näma-kértyä
jätänurägo druta-citta uccaiù
hasaty atho roditi rauti gäyaty
unmäda-van nåtyati loka-bähyaù

"A person engaged in the devotional service of the Lord in full Kåñëa consciousness automatically becomes carried away by ecstasy when he chants and hears the holy name of Kåñëa. His heart becomes slackened while chanting the holy name, he becomes almost like a madman, and he does not care for any outward social conventions. Thus sometimes he laughs, sometimes he weeps, sometimes he cries out very loudly, sometimes he sings, and sometimes he dances and forgets himself." These are the signs of becoming intoxicated in devotional service. This stage, called the ätmäräma stage, is possible when the Lord bestows His mercy upon a devotee for his advanced devotional activity. It is the highest perfectional stage because one cannot reach it unless one has attained pure love of God.

Neither formal religious rituals, economic development, sense gratification, nor liberation can compare with this sweet stage of perfection of love of Kåñëa, love of the Supreme Lord. The Caitanya-caritämåta (Ädi-lélä 7.97) describes this stage of ecstasy and intoxication as being far above the ecstasy of realizing oneself as Brahman, or the supreme spirit. Lord Caitanya says that the ecstasy of bhakti (love of Godhead) is so vast that it is like an ocean compared to the drop of pleasure derived from understanding oneself as one with Brahman. In all Vedic literature, the highest perfectional stage is said to be the state of intoxication of devotional service. It is not achieved by ordinary persons, the nondevotees.

In the stage of perfection, one's heart becomes slackened and one becomes more and more attached to attaining the lotus feet of the Lord. Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé, a great äcärya in the line of devotional service, has described this stage as follows: "Although appearing just like a madman, a person in the ecstasy of devotional service is not mad in the material conception of the term; this ecstasy is the manifestation of the pleasure potency of the Supreme Lord." The Lord has various potencies, one of which is called ählädiné-çakti, His internal pleasure potency. Only one who becomes a little conversant with this potency can taste such ecstasy. The Vedänta-sütra (1.1.12) states, änanda-mayo 'bhyäsät: "By nature the Lord is always joyful." This joyfulness of the Lord is due to His pleasure potency.

One who becomes affected by the pleasure potency of the Supreme Lord manifests various symptoms of ecstasy, such as slackening of the heart, laughing, crying, shivering, and dancing. These symptoms are not material. However, exhibiting such ecstatic symptoms just to get credit from the public is not approved by pure devotees. Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Prabhupäda says, "Persons without attainment of the highest perfectional stage of loving service cannot achieve any auspiciousness simply by artificially laughing, crying, or dancing without any spiritual understanding. Artificial movement of the body... must always be rejected. One should wait for the natural sequence within devotional service, and at that time, when one cries or dances or sings, it is approved. A person artificially showing symptoms of the pleasure potency creates many disturbances in the ordinary way of life."

One who attains the perfectional stage of devotional service under the guidance of a bona fide spiritual master may preach the science of devotion as Lord Caitanya did. When Lord Caitanya preached, He danced and showed other symptoms of ecstasy. Once, in Benares, a Mäyävädé sannyäsé named Prakäçänanda Sarasvaté objected to these activities. He said that since Lord Caitanya had taken sannyäsa, the renounced order of life, He should not act in such an intoxicated way.

The Lord explained that these symptoms of intoxication had automatically arisen when He had chanted the Hare Kåñëa mantra, and that upon seeing this His spiritual master had ordered Him to preach devotional service all over the world. While speaking with Prakäçänanda, Lord Caitanya quoted an important verse from the Hari-bhakti-sudhodaya (14.36):

tvat-säkñät-karaëähläda-viçuddhäbdhi-sthitasya me
sukhäni goñpadäyante brähmäëy api jagad-guro

"My dear Lord, O master of the universe, since I have directly seen You, my transcendental bliss has taken the shape of a great ocean. Thus I now regard the happiness derived from understanding impersonal Brahman to be like the water contained in a calf's hoofprint."."

In this way, one who reaches the perfectional stage of devotional service becomes so satisfied that he does not want anything more, and thus he always engages in pure devotional service.

NBS 7

SÜTRA 7

s$aA na k(AmayamaAnaA inar"AeDaè&patvaAta,

SÜTRA

sä na kämayamänä nirodha-rüpatvät

SYNONYMS

sä—that devotional service in pure love of God; na—not; kämayamänä—like ordinary lust; nirodha—renunciation; rüpatvät—because of having as its form.

TRANSLATION

There is no question of lust in the execution of pure devotional service, because in it all material activities are renounced.

PURPORT

In pure devotional service there is no question of sense gratification. Some people mistake the loving affairs between Kåñëa and the gopés (cowherd girls) for activities of ordinary sense gratification, but these affairs are not lustful because there is no material contamination. As Rüpa Gosvämé states in his Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu (1.2.285),

premaiva gopa-rämäëäà käma ity agamat prathäm
ity uddhavädayo 'py etaà väïchanti bhagavat-priyäù

"Although the dealings of the gopés with Kåñëa are wrongly celebrated by many as lust, great sages and saintly persons like Uddhava hanker for such loving affairs with Kåñëa." Çréla Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja, the author of Caitanya-caritämåta, has therefore said,

käma, prema,-doìhäkära vibhinna lakñaëa
lauha ära hema yaiche svarüpe vilakñaëa

"As there is a difference between iron and gold, so there is a difference between material lust and Kåñëa's loving affairs with the gopés" (Cc. Ädi 4.164). Although such loving affairs may sometimes resemble material lust, the difference is as follows:

ätmendriya-préti-väïchä-täre bali 'käma'
kåñëendriya-préti-icchä dhare 'prema' näma

"The desire to satisfy one's own senses is called lust, while the desire to satisfy the senses of Kåñëa is called prema, love of God" (Cc. Ädi 4.165).

The impersonalists cannot understand the principle of satisfying Kåñëa's senses because they reject the Personality of Godhead. Thus they think God has no senses and therefore no sense satisfaction. But the devotees simply want to satisfy the senses of the Supreme Lord, and so they take part in the pure activities of love of Godhead. There is no question of lust in that category of pure transcendental love.

Lust leads to fruitive activity for sense gratification. There are different kinds of duties for the human being, such as political obligations, performance of Vedic rituals, obligations for maintaining the body, and social formalities and conventions, but all such activities are directed toward satisfying one's own senses. The gopés, however, simply wanted to satisfy Kåñëa's senses, and thus they completely gave up the conventional path of social restriction, not caring for their relatives or the chastisement of their husbands. They gave up everything for the satisfaction of Kåñëa, showing their strong attachment to Kåñëa to be as spotless as washed white cloth.

It is said that when conjugal affection between a lover and beloved comes to the point of being destroyed and yet is not destroyed, such a relationship is pure love, or prema. In the material world it is not possible to find this kind of love, for it exists only between Kåñëa and His intimate devotees, such as the gopés. The sentiment between the gopés and Kåñëa was so strong that it could not be destroyed under any circumstances. Kåñëa praises the gopés' pure love in the Çrémad-Bhägavatam (10.32.22):

na päraye 'haà niravadya-saàyujäà
sva-sädhu-kåtyaà vibudhäyuñäpi vaù
yä mäbhajan durjaya-geha-çåìkhaläù
saàvåçcya tad vaù pratiyätu sädhunä

"My dear gopés, I am not able to repay My debt for your spotless service, even within a lifetime of Brahmä. Your connection with Me is beyond reproach. You have worshiped Me, cutting off all domestic ties, which are difficult to break. Therefore please let your own glorious deeds be your compensation."

NBS 8

SÜTRA 8

inar"AeDastau laAek(vaed"vyaApaAr"nyaAs$a:

SÜTRA

nirodhas tu loka-veda-vyäpära-nyäsaù

SYNONYMS

nirodhaù—renunciation; tu—moreover; loka—of social custom; veda—and of the revealed scripture; vyäpära—of the engagements; nyäsa—renunciation.

TRANSLATION

Such renunciation in devotional service means to give up all kinds of social customs and religious rituals governed by Vedic injunction.

PURPORT

In a verse in the Lalita-mädhava (5.2), Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé describes renunciation in devotional service:

åddhä siddhi-vraja-vijayitä satya-dharmä samädhir
brahmänando gurur api camatkärayaty eva tävat
yävat premëäà madhu-ripu-vaçékära-siddhauñadhénäà
gandho 'py antaù-karaëa-saraëé-pänthatäà na prayäti

"Activities such as mystic trance, becoming one with the Supreme, and the religious principles of brahminism, such as speaking the truth and tolerance, have their own respective attractions, but when one becomes captivated by love of Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, all attraction for mystic power, monistic pleasure, and mundane religious principles becomes insignificant."

In other words, by discharging pure devotional service one attains the highest stage of love of Godhead and is freed from all other obligations, such as those mentioned in the karma-käëòa, jïäna-käëòa, and yoga-käëòa sections of the Vedas. One who engages in pure devotional service has no desire to improve himself—except in the service of the Lord. In such devotional service there cannot be any worship of the impersonal or localized features of the Supreme Lord. The devotee simply performs activities that satisfy the Supreme Personality of Godhead and thus attains pure love for the Lord.

Only by the combined mercy of the pure devotee—the bona fide spiritual master—and the Supreme Lord Himself can one attain pure devotional service to the Lord. If someone is fortunate enough to find a pure devotee and accept him as his spiritual master, then this spiritual master, out of his causeless mercy, will impart the knowledge of pure devotional service. And it is the Lord, out of His causeless mercy, who sends His most confidential servitor to this world to instruct pure devotional service.

By the divine grace of the spiritual master, the seed of pure devotional service, which is completely different from the seed of fruitive activities and speculative knowledge, is sown in the heart of the devotee. Then, when the devotee satisfies the spiritual master and Kåñëa, this seed of devotional service grows into a plant that gradually reaches up to the spiritual world. An ordinary plant requires shelter for growing. Similarly, the devotional plant grows and grows until it takes shelter in the spiritual world, without taking shelter on any planet in the material world. In other words, those who are captivated by pure devotional service have no desire to elevate themselves to any material planet. The highest planet in the spiritual world is Kåñëa-loka, or Goloka Våndävana, and there the devotional plant takes shelter.

The Närada-païcarätra defines pure devotional service as follows:

sarvopädhi-vinirmuktaà tat-paratvena nirmalam
håñékena håñékeça-sevanaà bhaktir ucyate

"Devotional service to the Supreme Lord means engagement of all the senses in His service. In such service there are two important features: First, one must be purified of all designations, and second, the senses should be engaged only in the service of the Supreme Lord, the master of the senses. That is pure devotional service."

Everyone is now contaminated by various designations in relation to the body. Everyone is thinking, "I belong to such-and-such country; I belong to a certain society; I belong to a certain family." But when a person comes to the stage of pure devotional service, he knows that he does not belong to anything except the service of the Lord.

The symptom of unflinching faith in pure devotional service is that one has overcome the many disruptive desires that impede pure devotional service, such as (1) the desire to worship the demigods, (2) the desire to serve someone other than Kåñëa, (3) the desire to work for sense gratification, without understanding one's relationship with Kåñëa, (4) the desire to cultivate impersonal knowledge and thereby forget the Supreme Lord, and (5) the desire to establish oneself as the Supreme, in which endeavor there is no trace of the bliss of devotional service. One should give up all these desires and engage exclusively in the loving devotional service of the Lord. Except for the service of the Lord, anything done is in the service of illusion, or mäyä.

One should try to get out of illusion and be engaged in the factual service of Kåñëa. Service to Kåñëa utilizes all the senses, and when the senses are engaged in the service of Kåñëa, they become purified. There are ten senses—five active senses and five knowledge-acquiring senses. The active senses are the power of talking, the hands, the legs, the evacuating outlet, and the generating organ. The knowledge-acquiring senses are the eyes, the ears, the nose, the tongue, and the sense of touch. The mind, the center of all the senses, is sometimes considered the eleventh sense.

One cannot engage in the transcendental loving service of the Lord with these senses in their present materially covered state. Therefore one should take up the process of devotional service to purify them. There are sixty-four items of regulative devotional service for purifying the senses, and one should strenuously undergo such regulative service. Then one can enter into the transcendental loving service of the Lord.

Gétär Gän

Bengali Poetic Edition of Bhagavad-gétä As It Is

Introduction

Last year His Master's Voice recording studio in India expressed their willingness to produce a musical presentation of Çréla Prabhupäda's Gétär Gän and market it throughout India. We naturally became quite excited about the project. But we soon realized that it would not be possible, because the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust did not want to give the copyright to any outside organization.

The only way open to us at that time was to produce it ourselves. However, it was a large production and needed a lot of money.

My initial reaction after that was to forget the project. But then it occured to me that it would be a nice gift to offer to Çréla Prabhupäda for his centennial. His Divine Grace was very emphatic about popularizing his Gétär Gän, among the Bengali speaking people. I realized what an impact this musical rendition of Gétär Gän would have on the music-loving Bengalis if it were professionally produced. It will undoubtedly go a long way to turn them on to the message of Bhagavad Gétä.

With the help of His Masters Voice, we got the best musicians and singers in Calcutta. About a dozen artists worked full time for about 2 months to produce these 6 tapes. The music director, an eminent sarod player, Mr Srikumar Banerjee, often stayed up until early in the morning writing the musical scores, and then went to the studio to record throughout the day. This naturally shows what a keen interest he took in composing the music.

For such a large production, one major problem is that it can become monotonous. Especially when the entire book has been written in the same poetic meter. However, Mr. Srikumar Banerjee dealt with that problem very expertly. Perfect application of different ragas with different beats maintained the novelty and excitement.

Finally we offered the tapes to Çréla Prabhupäda on 4th February 1995, through a grand celebration in the most prestigious auditorium in Calcutta. The auditorium was packed with the elite of Calcutta. The first performance was made for Çréla Prabhupäda's pleasure. It seems that His Divine Grace liked it. Now it is being offered to the devotees all over the world. If they like it, I will consider our endeavour has been successful.

Bhakti Charu Swami
Ramnavami
9 April 1995

GG: Chapter 1

Chapter 1
Observing the Armies on the Battlefield of Kurukñetra

dharma-kñetre kuru-kñetre haiyä ekatra
yuddhakämé mamaputra päëòava sarvatra
ki karila tärpar kahata saïjay
dhåtaräñöra jijïäsaye sandigdha håday

Text 1

saïjay kahilen:
räjä çuna mana diyä
päëòaver sainya-sajjä säjäna dekhiyä
räjä duryodhan çéghra droëäcärya päçe
yäiyä våttänta sab kahila sakäçe

Text 2

äcärya cähiyä dekha mahaté senäné
päëòu-putra raciyäche vyüha nänä-sthäné
tava çiñya vuddhimän drupadera putra
säjäila ei sab kari ekasütra

Text 3

eisthäne vartamän vahu yoddhägaë
bhémärjun-sama tä'rä dhanurdhäré han
yuyudhän viräö drupad mahärathé sab
dhåñöaketu cekitän käçéra puàgav

purujit kuntibhoj çaivya-räjä-gaë
yudhämanyu vikränta nahe sädhäraë
véryavän ye ei soubhadra draupadeya
sakalei mahärathé keha nahe heya

Text 4

Text 5

Text 6

ämäder madhye yärä viçiñöa mahän
dvijottama çuna tähä kariyä manan
senäpati ye ye sab mama sainya-päçe
saàjïärthe tomäre kahi açeña viçeñe

Text 7

äpani är pitämaha bhéñmädi-gaë
kåpäcärya raëajayé hay ekatre varëan
açvatthämä vikarëädi soumadatti är
yathä-yathä tathä tathä sainya se apär

Text 8

är ye anek vér ämära lägiyä
äsiyäche hethä sab jévana tyajiyä
nänä-astrapäëi sab yuddhe viçärad
erä sab hay mor yuddhera saàsad

Text 9

aparyäpta mama sainya bhéñma senäpati
paryäpta oder sainya bhém yär gati
yathä-sthäne sthita thäki äpani sakale
rakña bhéñma pitämahe hena yuddha-sthale

Text 10

Text 11

tabe sei pitämaha våddha kurupati
harña utpädane yave kaila sthira-mati
siàha-näde bäjäila çaàkha sei vér
ucca-rav sei sab atéva gambhér

Text 12

çuni sei çatru-rav yata çaàkha bheré
gomukha paëavänaka bäjila satvari
sahasä uöhila sei raëera jhaàkär
tumula haila çavda vahula apär

Text 13

tärpar çveta açva rathete vasiyä
äsila ye mahä-yuddhe niyukta haiyä
mädhava ära päëòava divya saàkha dhari
väjäila pare pare apürva mädhuré

Text 14

håñékeça bhagavän päïcajanya-rave
dhanaïjaya bäjäila devadatta sabe
bhémakarmä bhémasen bäjäila pare
pouëòra-näm saàkha sei ati uccaiù-svare

Text 15

yudhéñöhir dhare çaàkha räjä kuntiputra
ananta-vijay sei ghoñaëä sarvatra
nakula bäjäla çaàkha sughoña tära näm
sahadev bäjäla maëi-puñpaka näm
tärpar eke eke yata mahä-rathé
dhanurdhar käçiräj çikhaëòé särathi
dhåñöadyumna viräöädi vér se sätyaki
mahä-yoddhä päre yärä yujhite ekäké
drupad ära draupadeya påthivépate
soubhadra bäjäla çaàkha yär yär mate

Texts 16-18

se çavda bhäìila buk dhärta-räñöragaëe
äkäça bhedila påthvé kìäpila saghane

Text 19

kapi-dhvaj dekhi dhärta-räñörera gaëere
yuddhera sajjäy sethä milila acire
nija astra dhanurväë yathästhäne dhari
yuddhera lägiyä sethä smarila çréhari

Text 20

mahipate! päëòuputra kahe håñékeçe
ubhaya senär mäjhe rathera praveçe
yävata dekhiba ei yuddha-kämégaëe
tävata räkhibe ratha acyuta ekhäne
dekhibäre cähi kevä äsiyäche hethä
kähära sahita habe yujhibäre sethä

Texts 21-22

yuddhakämégaëe äj nirakhiba ämi
durvuddhi dhärta-räñörer janya yuddhakämé

Text 23

se kathä çuniyä håñékeç bhagavän
ubhaya senär dike haila äguyän
ubhaya senär madhye räkhi rathottam
kahite lägila kåñëa haiyä sambhram

Text 24

dekha pärtha samaveta dhärta-räñöragaë
bhéñma droë pramukhata yata yoddhägaë

Text 25

tärpar dekhe pärtha yoddhå-pitågaë
äcärya mätul ädi pitåsama han
dekhe putra pauträdik yata sakhäjan
är saba vahu lok ätméya-svajan
çvaçurädi kuöumvéya nähi päräpär
ubhaya-pakñéya sainya se hala apär

Text 26

tädera dekhila pärtha saba-i vändhava
kìäpila hådaya tära viñaëëa vaibhava
kåpäte kìäpiche man ati dayävän
viñaëëa haiyä bale çuna bhagavän

Text 27

arjun kahaye kåñëa erä ye svajan
raëäàgane äsiyäche karibäre raë
dekhiyä ämär gätre hayeche romäïca
mukha-madhye ras näi e ye mahävaïca

Text 28

kìäpiche çarér mor sahite nä päri
gäëòév khasiyä yäy ki kariyä dhari
jvaliyä uöhiche tvak mahä-täpa väë
haio nä haio nä vandhu är äguyän

Text 29

asthira hayechi ämi sthir nahe man
sab bhul haye yäya ki kari ekhan
viparéta artha dekhi çunaha keçav
e yuddhe käj nähi hala paëòa sab

Text 30

kona hita nähi hethä svajana-saàhäre
yuddhe mor käj näi phiräo ämäre
he kåñëa! vijaya mor nähi se äkäìkñä
räjya är sukh çänti saba-i äçaìkä

Text 31

yädera lägiyä cähi sukha-bhoga çänti
täräi eseche hethä dite se açänti

dhana präëa saba tyaji marivär tare
sabäi eseche hethä ke jéye ke mare

eseche äcärya püjya pitära samän
saìge äche pétämaha är putragaë

mätula çvaçura pautra kata ye kahiba
çälä är samvandhé sabäi mariba

ämi mari kñati näi erä yadi mare
edera marite çakti nähi dekhibäre

tribhuvana räjya yadi päiba jiniyä
tathäpi nä lai tähä edera märiyä

dhärta-räñöragaëe märi kivä préti habe
janärdana tumi kåñëa äpani kahibe

Text 32-35

edera märile mätra päpa läbha habe
emana vipakña çatru ke dekheche kabe
ei dhärtaräñöra-gaë sa-vändhava hay
ucita nä hay kärya tähädera kñay
svajana märiyä bala kebä kabe sukhé
sukha-leça nähi mätra haba çudhu duùkhé

Text 36

yadyapi erä nähi dekhe lobhéjana
kula-kñaya mitra-droha saba alakñaëa
esab päpera räçi ke vahite päre
bujhibe tumi ta sab bujhäve ämäre
ucit ki nahe ei päpe nivåtti
bujhä ki ucit nahe sei kupravåtti
kulakñaye yei doñ jäna janärdan
ataev ei yuddha kara niväraë

Texts 37-38

kula-kñaye kaluñita sanätana dharma
dharma-nañöe prädurbhäve haibe adharma

Text 39

adharmer prädurbhäve kula-närégaë
patitä haibe sab kara anveñaë

Text 40

duñöä stré haile janme varëa-saìkar dal
varëa-saìkar hale habe naraker phal
yei se käraëa hay varëa-saìkarera
kulakñay kulaghnäni yei aparer

Text 41

narake patana hay lupta piëòa janya
tarivär nähi kona upäy ye anya
kula dharmer nañöa-käré varëa-saìkar phale
ç äçvata jäti dharma utsädita hale

Text 42

narake niyata väsa se manuñyer hay
tumi jäna janärdan se saba viñay
ämi çuniyächi täi sädhu-santa mukhe
naraker pathe cali ke rahibe sukhe

Text 43

häya häya mahäpäp karite udyata
hayechi ämrä çudhu haye kaluñita
räjyera lobhete paòe e duñkärya kari
svajana hanana ei ucita ki hari?

Text 44

yadi dhärta-räñöra-gaë ämäke märiyä
ei raëe räjya lay açastra bujhiyä
se bhälo mane kari yuddha se apekñä
vinä-yuddhe sei ämi kariba pratikñä

Text 45

ekathä baliyä pärtha niçcala basila
rathopastha yuddha madhye astra se tyajila
çokete udvignamanä arjun sadaya
viñäd-yoga näm ei gétära viñay

Text 46

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 2

Chapter 2
Contents of the Gétä Summarized

dekhiyä arjune kåñëa sei açrujale
kåpäy äviñöa haye bhävita vikale
kåpämay madhusüdan kahila tähäre
iti-väkya bandhu-bhäve ati miñöa-svare

Text 1

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
kibhäve arjuna tumi ghor yuddhasthale
anäryer çokänal pradépta karile
akérti asvarga läbh haibe tomär
chi chi bandhu chäòa ei ayogya äcär

Text 2

napuàsak naha pärtha e ki vyavahär
yogya nahe e kärya bandhu ye ämär
håday-daurvalya ei niñcayai jänibe
chäòa ei, kara yuddha yadi çatrüke märibe

Text 3

arjun kahilen:
madhusüdan! ki äjïä kara tumi more
bhéñma droë gurujan täre märibäre?
püjär yogya ye tìärä han nityakäla
tìäder çarére väë sutékñëa dhäräla?

Text 4

çudhu guru nahe tìärä, mahänubhav hay yìärä
hatyä kari tìäder sabäre
tadapekñä bhikñä bhäla, käöiye yäibe käl,
mithyä yuddha karäo ämäre
hatyä ei mahäkäm, vidhi ye haila väm,
ei yuddhe guru hatyä habe
se bhog rudhira mäkhä, kemane kariba sakhä,
se yuddha ke kariyäche kabe

Text 5

bujhite päri nä bhäla, kothäya garimä hala,
kon kärya juyäya ämäy
kivä ämi jay kari, kimbä ämi nije mari
dui noukä ämäre näcäy
yäder märiyä raëe, bìäciba se akäraëe,
tärä sab ämär sammukhe
dhåtaräñöra-putragaë, är yata bandhu-jan,
marile se habe mor duùkha

Text 6

kärpaëya doñete düñé, mohete hayechi vaçé,
sva svabhäv hala apahåta
nija dharma chäòi müòha jijïäsi tomäre dåòha
kåpä kari karaha saàyata
tumi jäna hita mor, hayechi mohete bhor,
bhäla yäte karaha bicäre
hainu tomär çiñya, dekhuk sakal viçva,
çikñä däo ei prapannere

Text 7

dekhi nä ämi ye andha, tähe buddhi ati manda,
ço-känal nibhibe kibhäbe
ye çok jväläya more, indriyädi sab poòe,
bhava-rog kirüpe ghucäbe
yadi päi tribhuvan, räjya-lakñmé sulobhan,
asapatna räjyera vikäça
devaloke ädhipatya, tomäke kahinu satya,
nähi habe e çoka vinäça

Text 8

saïjay kahilen:
se-kathä baliyä guòäkeça paratäpé
håñékeçe nivedila yadio pratäpé
he govinda! mor dvärä yuddha nähi habe
yuddha chäòi sei vér rahila nérabe

Text 9

snigdha häsi manohar håñékeç bale
he bhärat! arjunera çuniyä sakale
yuddha kñetre sainya-madhye häsiyä häsiyä
upadeça karen gétä viñaëëa dekhiyä

Text 10

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
açocya viñaye çok kara tumi vér
prajïäväd bhäñyakär yena kona dhér
paëòita ye jana hay çok nähi tär
måta deha nitya ätmä se jäne vicär

Text 11

tumi ämi yata räjä sammukhe tomär
erä sab cira nitya karaha vicär
pürve erä nähi chila pare nä thäkibe
mürkhera vicära ei niçcayai jänibe

Text 12

deha dehé bhed dui nityänitya sei
kaumär youvan jarä parivartan yei
deher svakärya hay dehé nitya rahe
tathä dehäntar-präpti paëòiterä kahe

Text 13

çét uñëa sukh duùkha indriya vikär
indriyer däsa yärä tähe adhikär
se sab anitya vastu äsi cali yäy
sahiñëutä mätra guë tähära upäya

Text 14

vyathä nähi dyäya yäre anitya eisab
sejan bujhila jäna puruñärtha vaibhav
samaduùkha sukha-dhér anitya vyäpäre
amaratva sei päy jitiyä saàsäre

Text 15

asat çaréra ei sattä nähi tär
nitya-satya jév haya måtyu nähi yär
ubhaya vicär kari karila niçcit
tattvadarçé sei kahe yei hay hit

Text 16

avinäçé sei bujha sarvatra vistär
yähär abhäve haya deha mahäbhär
kñay-vyay nähi yär ke märite päre
amarer mär kivä karaha vicär

Text 17

niùçeña haiyä yäbe ei jaòa deha
nitya ätmä jäna bhäla nä maribe keha
vinäçé prameya nahe ätmä bhäla mate
satya bujhi dåòha-vrata hao ta' yuddhete

Text 18

ye jana bujheche ätmä mare yete päre
athavä ye jana bujhe ätmä anye märe
ubhayei bhramätmak kichu nähi bujhe
mare nä märe nä ätmä jäna yuddha yujhe

Text 19

janama maraëa näi, haya näi, habe näi
hayechila tähä nahe ätmä
aja nitya çäçvata, purätana nitya satya,
çarérer näç nahe måtyu

Text 20

ye jeneche ätmä nitya aja avinäçé
avyay ajar ätmä sarva diväniçi
se kena märibe anye mürkhera matan
se jäne niçcita ätmä mare nä kakhana

Text 21

purätana vastra yathä, bhaìgura çaréra tathä
ek chäòi anya vastra par
purätana vastra chäòe, navéna basana pare
navéna çaréra sei dhare
jérëa çarér chäòi, navéna çaréra dhari
dehénavya haya punarvära
deha dehé ei bhed, tähäte vä kivä khed
chäòa duùkha yuddha karibära

Text 22

asträghäte nähi käöe cinmaya çarér
agni nä jväläya tähä çuna vijïa vér
jal dvärä nähi bhije väyu nä çukäy
ghät pratighät sab jaòete juyäy

Text 23

acchedya je ätmä hay akledya açoñya
cidänanda ätmä nahe jaòera se poñya
sarvatra ätmära gati sthir sanätan
acala aöala ätmä nitya se nütan

Text 24

käöä jvälä bhijä çukä jaòera lakñaë
jaòer dvärä vyakta nahe avyakta kakhan
man dvärä cintya hay jaòera lakñaë
ätmä jaòa vastu nahe acintya kathan
jaòera vikära hay ätmä avikär
jaòa ätmä bibhinnatä çuna bär bär
yathä-yatha ätma-tattva karaha vicär
vicära karile citte päbe camatkär

Text 25

vicära karibe yabe çok nähi rabe
ätmära nityatva jäni nityänanda päbe
yadi täi mäna tumi dehai sarvasva
paricaya nähi kichu ätmära nijasva
nitya janma nitya måtyu deha mätra hay
tabuo tomära duùkha nähi tabu täy

Text 26

jaòa deha upajaya anivärya kñay
kñay haye jaòa dravya punaù upajay
jaòa dravya rüpa chädi anya rüpa hay
nütana rüpera janya anya rüpa kay
ei jaòa vijïa yadi karaye vicär
tathäpi çokera kathä nahe tiladhär

Text 27

jaòera rüpädi nähi pareo thäke nä
madhye mätra rüpa guëa sakali bhävanä
ataeva niräkära yadi niräkär
tähäte tomära duùkha kisera äbär

Text 28

äçcarya ätmär kathä, nä bujhaye yathä tathä
äçcarya tähär dekhä-çunä
äçcarya kehavä bale, äçcarya kehavä chale
äçcarya tähär adhyäpanä
äçcarya haiyä çune, tathäpi vä nähi mäne
äçcarya ye äçcaryera kathä
äçcarya haiyä rahe, äçcarya bujhite nahe
äçcarya ati durlabhatä

Text 29

siddhänta ätmära kathä‚ çuna he bhärat
vedänta ämära kathä çuna sei-mata
dehé nitya mare nähi sakala deher
deher vinäça täi nahe ta' çoker

Text 30

nija dharma dekhi punaù nä hao vikal
kñatriyera yuddha karä dharma ye sakal

Text 31

anäyäse päiyächa svarga-dvär kholä
se yuddha käryete nähi kara abahelä
bhägyavän vér sei hena yuddha päy
yuddha kari yajïa-phal kñatriya labhay

Text 32

ataeva tumi pärtha yadi yuddha chäòa
svadharma svakérti sab ekatre ugära

Text 33

tomära akérti lok niçcayai gähibe
vìäciyä maraëa taba vighoñita habe

Text 34

mahärath yärä sab nindä ye karibe
bhay peye chäòe raë tärä ye balibe
yähäder gaëya-mänya tumi ye ekhan
sakaler cakñe choöa haibe takhan

Text 35

kata gälägäli dibe akathya kathan
bhäbi dekha taba hita ki habe takhan
nija nindä çuni tumi néraba rahibe
bala pärtha sei nindä kemane sahibe

Text 36

mare yadi svarga päo seo bhäla kathä
bìäciyä päibe bhog nahe se anyathä
bìäcä marä dui bhäla yuddhete niçcay
hena yuddha chäda tumi äçcarya viñay
he kaunteya uöha tumi nähi kara helä
yuddha karibäre niçcaya kara ei belä

Text 37

sukha-duùkha samakar häni läbha saba
jayä-jay nähi bhay kartavya baliba
yuddhera lägiyä tumi çudhu yuddha kara
nähi täte päp bhay ei satya baòa

Text 38

jïänera vicäre sab balinu tomäke
ebe çuna buddhi-yoge jïän paripäka
jïanéra yogyatä yadi paripäk hay
bhakti dvärä buddhi-yog tabe se bujhay
bhakti-yukta karma haya karma-yoga näm
yähär sädhane karma bandhana viräm

Text 39

kñay vyay nähi näç se kärya sädhane
yähä pära kare yäo saïcay e dhane
svalpa mätra haya yadi se dharma sädhan
mahä-bhay hate rakñä päibe takhan

Text 40

vyavasäyätmikä buddhi he kuru-nandana
ek-mätra haya tähä bahu nä kakhana
ananta apär se a-vyavasäyé hay
bahu çäkhä bistärita ke kare nirëay

Text 41

puñpera säjane yähä iñöa miñöa kathä
karméra håday tähä kare prafullitä
sei veda bädé sab bhoger käraë
yathä-sarva sei kathä karaye varaë

mürkha sei bhogabädé äpäta madhur
datta-citta haye yäya äsale phatur
kämätmanä loka sab svarga bhog cäy
karma-phal bhoga-lipsä är nä bujhay
äòambare bhule yäya bhogaiçvarya cäy
buddhi-yog ek lakñya tähä nä mänay

Texts 42-43

bhogaiçvarye äsakta ye pägalera mata
nijeke häriyä base äçä çata çata
tärä nähi bujhe vyavasäyätmikä buddhi
äsakti täder çudhu bhukti mukti siddhi

Text 44

triguëera madhye ved sattva rajastama
tähära upare uöha tabe se uttama
takhani dvandva bhäv ghucibe tomär
nitya çuddha sattva bhäv habe äviñkär
ätmaväna hay sadä niryoga nikñem
ye dhane se dhané tähä bhagavad prem

Text 45

sei preme bhäsamän sarva läbha päy
küpa jala nadé jal yathä yathä hay
ek küpe hay ek käryera sädhan
nadéra jalete hay ekatre bhäjan
vedera tätparya sei ek lakñya hay
brähmaëa ye hay sei samasta bujhay

Text 46

nija adhikär mätra karma kare yäo
karma-phal nähi cäo äsakti ghucäo
karma-phal hetu sadä nä haibe tumi
anuküla karma yei sei karma bhümi

Text 47

yogé haye kara karma äsakti rahita
äsakti rahita karma bhagaväne préta
dhanaïjaya! saìga tyaji karma kare yäo
siddhi vä asiddhi sama vaiñamya ghucäo
ei sama bhäv hay yogo siddhi näm
sei siddhi-läbhe pürëa sarva manaskäm

Text 48

buddhi-yoga dvärä chäòä karma avarädi
käm kåñëa karmärpaëe nä hao viñädé
anukñaë sei buddhe çaraëägati yär
kåpaëer phal hetu icchä nahe tär

Text 49

buddhi-yog dvärä karma sukåti ye phal
duñkåti vä phale yähä karaye nirmal
ataev tumi sei yoge yuddha kara
karmera kouçal ei buddhi-yog dhara

Text 50

manéñé yei se karma buddhi yog dvärä
tyägete samartha hay karma phal särä
janma-bandha vinirmukta sei karma-yogé
anämay pada präpta haya sei tyägé

Text 51

yakhana tomära man buddhi yog dvärä
moharüpa kardamäkta haye yäbe pärä
takhana nirved sab haye yäbe käm
çrutira çrotavya taba nähi rabe dhäm

Text 52

çrutira gåhéta jïän yakhana niçcalä
karma jïän yoga ädi takhani saphalä
samädhi takhana hay karma yoge sthiti
sthita-prajïa tär näma yogärüòha gati

Text 53

arjun kahilen:
ki lakñaë sthita-prajïa kivä täìr bhäñä
he keçav! kaha more samädhistha äçä
sthita-dhé ki bale kiàbä uöhä-basä kare
ki bhäbe gaman kare kahata bistäre

Text 54

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
nijera indriya sukhe yata käm äche
baddha jéva mano-dharme dhäya päche päche
se sab kämanä tyaji ätma-bhagaväne
sambandha jäniyä krame hay äguyäne
takhana jänibe tuñöa sthita-prajïa sukhé
e chäòä är ye lok sakalei duùkhé

Text 55

duùkhe anudvigna-manä sukhe nähi spåhä
nija sebä kärye yìär ekamätra éhä
vétaräg çoka bhay krodh nähi yìär
se jana sthita-dhé muni vidita sabär

Text 56

deha småti nähi yìär çubhäçubha kibä täìr
sarvatra anabhi sneha lok vyavahär
abhinanda dveñ näi sarva hite rata
tìähär jänio prajïä sthir pratiñöhita

Text 57

go-däsa indriya sukhe vicalita sadä
gosvämé hayeche dhér ätmäte sarvadä
täi se indriya saba kürma aìga mata
indriya bhogärtha sadä viñaye virata
ataeva jäni tìära prajïä pratiñöhita
se jana upädhi mukta gosvämé vidita

Text 58

vairägya kariyä hay viñaya-nivåtti
tähä nahe sthita-prajïä sväbhävik våtti
paramänanda jäni yebä jaòänanda chäòe
sthita-prajïa sei vér viñaya vihäre

Text 59

ätmära samparka näi vairägyer yatan
paëòita haleo tär prasabhita man
pramäthé indriya täke viñayete phele
çuñka vairägér läge äguna kapäle

Text 60

kåñëa-sevä yukta hay indriya saàyata
indriya ye baç hay prajïä pratiñöhita

Text 61

çuñka vairägya ye är viñayete dhyän
krame krame saìga sei hay äguyän
saìga krame käm haya käme krodha hay
krodhe sammohan pare vibhrama bäòaya
småti bhrañöa hale pare buddhi-näça hay
vairägér sarva-näç sei se paryäy

Texts 62-63

ataeva räg dveñ nähi yìär ati
mukta yevä haiyäche viñayera gati
citta prasäde se hay kåñëärpita man
viñaye thäkiyä tini jévanmukta han

Text 64

paramänanda sukh yei prasäda tär näm
yähära präptite duùkha hay antardhän
se prasäde pratiñöhita ye hay niçcita
ätmaniñöhä buddhi tär jagate vidita

Text 65

jévera svarüpa hay änandete mati
buddhiyoga vinä tära kothäy vä gati
ataeva se bhävanä nähi yär sthiti
kothä çänti tär bala sukhera pragati

Text 66

indriya cälita kari manodharme sthiti
väyura madhyete yathä noukära pragati
se noukä yemana sadä öalamala kare
ayukta vyaktira prajïä seirüpa hare

Text 67

ataeva mahäväho çuna man diyä
nigåhéta man yìära ämäre sìapiyä
tìähära indriya vaç more samarpita
tìähära-i prajïä haya pürëa pratiñöhita

Text 68

viñayé viñaye niñöhä kare se pracur
sarvadä jägrata sei sadä bharapur
saàyaméra sei ceñöä niçära samän
saàyamé jägrata thäke ätma-viñayän
viñayéra sei ätmä rätrira samän
ubhayera kärya haya bahu vyavadhän

Text 69

samudre nadér jala yemana praveç
vicalita nahe sei sadä nirviçeñ
seibhäbe mane yär kämera cälanä
se çänti päibe phal çäntira sädhanä

Text 70

käma chäòi saba yebä nispåha dhémän
sarvatra bhramaëa kare näradiya gän
mamatä-vihéna är ahaìkära näi
tär çänti viniçcita sei ta' gosani

Text 71

sei se småtir näm brähmé-sthiti hay
yìär präpti hay täìr mohana kothäya
sei sthiti yadi haya maraëera käle
brahma-sthiti bhäva nahe kälera kabale

Text 72

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 3

Chapter 3
Karma-yoga

arjun kahilen:
yadi buddhi-yoga çreñöha ohe janärdan
ghor yuddhe niyojita kara ki käraë

Text 1

dvyarthak kathäy buddhi mohit ye hay
niçcit yä hay kaha çreya upajay

Text 2

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
dvibidha loker niñöhä balechi tomäre
säàkhya är jïäna-yog yogya adhikäre

Text 3

vihita karmer niñöhä nä kari ärambha
naiñkarma jïän ye carcä hay eka dambha
vihita karmer tyäge cittaçuddhi nay
keval sannyäse kärya siddhi nähi hay

Text 4

kñaëek samay mätra nä kariyä karma
thäkite päre nä keha sväbhävik dharma
prakåtir guë yathä sabär nirvandha
sei kärya kare yäte karamer vandha

Text 5

karmendriya rodh kari manete smaraëa
ihä nähi cittaçuddhi naiñkarma käraë
ataev sei vyakti vimüòhätmä hay
indriyärtha mithyäcäré çästrete kahay

Text 6

kintu yadi nijendriya saàyata niyame
karmer ärambha kare yathä yathä krame
vätul nä hay markaö vairägya kari
antarniñöhä hale hay sahäy çré-hari
sei hay karma-yog karmendriya dvärä
äsakti-rahit karma viçeñ prakärä

Text 7

niyamita karma bhäla sei akarma apekñä
anadhikäréra karma tyäga, para-mukhäpekñä
çarér nirväha yär nahe karma vinä
karma-tyäg tär pakñe hay viòambanä

Text 8

yajïeçvar bhagaväner santoñ lägiyä
niyamita karma kara äsakti tyajiyä
är yata karma hay bandhera käraëa
ataeva sei kärya kara niväraëa
bhagavada santoñärtha karmera prasaìga
yata kichu äcaraëa saba mukta saëga

Text 9

prajäpati såñöi kari yajïera sädhana
upadeç karechila çune prajägaëa
yajïera sädhana kari sukhé hao sabe
yajïa-dvärä bhog päbe indriya vaibhave

Text 10

adhikäré devagaë yajïera prabhäve
yajïa anuñöhän dekhi sabe préta habe
paraspara préti-bhäv hale sampädana
bhogera sämagré çreya nahe anaöana

Text 11

yajïete santuñöa haye abhéñöa ye bhoga
devatärä dyäya sab pracura prayoga
sei datta anna yähä devatärä dyäya
tìähäder nä diyä khäya cor sei hay

Text 12

yajïera sädhana kari anna yevä khäy
muktira pathete cale päp nähi hay
är yebä anna päk nija svärthe kare
päper bojhä krame bäòe duùkha-bhog tare

Text 13

anna kheye jév bäìce anna ye jévana
sei anna utpädane våñöi ye käraëa
sei våñöi hay yadi yajïa kärye hay
sei yajïa sädhya hay karmera käraëa

Text 14

karma yähä veda-väëé nahe mano-dharma
veda-väëé bhagavadukti akñarera käraëa
ataeva karma hay éçvara-sädhanä
sarva-gata brahma-nitya yajïete sthäpanä

Text 15

sei se brahmera cakra äche pravartita
se cakre ye nähi hay viñeça vartita
päpera jévana tär ati bhayaìkara
indriya prétaye kare päpa paraspara

Text 16

är ye bujhiyäche ätma-tattva-sär
kärya karma kichu näi karibär tär
pürëa-jïäne bhagaväne bhakti kare yei
ätma-tåpta ätma-jïäné tuñöa ätmätei

Text 17

arthänartha vicärädi ätma-tåpta nahe
kartavyä-kartavya yähä veda-çästra kahe
se nahe kähära åëé nijärtha sädhane
sarvasva hayeche pürëa çaraëya çaraëe

Text 18

ataev anäsakta haye kärya kara
yukta vairägya sei täte hao dåòha
anäsakta kärya kare parama padete
yogya hay krame krame se pada labhite

Text 19

janakädi mahäjan karma sädhya kari
siddhi-läbh karechila äpani äcari
tumi-o serüp kara loka-çikñä lägi
läbh näi kichumätra markaöa vairägé

Text 20

çreñöha vyakti yähä kare lokera ädarça
itara janatä yähä kare hay harña
çreñöha vyakti yähä kichu prämäëya svékäre
tähäi svékärya hay prati ghare ghare

Text 21

ämära kartavya näi tribhuvana mäjhe
pärtha tumi jäna kevä samatulya äche
präptavya baliyä kichu kothä nähi mor
tathäpi dekhaha ämi kartavye vibhor

Text 22

ämi yadi karma tyaji atandrita haye
mama vartma sabe anugamana karaye

Text 23

phal ei habe sabäi ucchanna yäbe
ämära darçita path dekhära abhäbe
vidhi är kichu nähi rabe dharätale
vinañöa haibe ei prajärä sakale

Text 24

vidväner ye kartavya avidvän sama
vähyata äsakta haye karma samägama
antare äsakti näi lokera saàgraha
vidväner hay sei karmete ägraha

Text 25

buddhi-bhed nähi kari müòha karméder
ajïäné ye hay tärä täi herpher
täi se säjäte habe sarva karma mäjhe
äpani äcari sab avidyära säje

Text 26

vidväna mürkhete hay ei mätra bhed
prakåtir vaç ek anya se bicched
prakåtir guëe vaç kärya kari yäy
ahaàkäre matta haye nije kartä hay
äpanär paricaya prakåtira mäne
dehe ätma-buddhi kare asatyera dhyäne

Text 27

tattvavit ye vidvän bujhe guëa-karma
guë dvärä kärya hay jäne sär-marma
ataev guëa-kärya nä kare sajjan
prakåtir guëa-kärya äsakta nä han

Text 28

guëa-karme äsakti se guëete saàmüòha
präkåta nijeke mäne sei kärye dåòha
bhava-rogé müòha jane nä kari baïcan
karmera yojanä hate krame jïän val

Text 29

ataev tumi pärtha chäòa abhimän
tomär samasta çakti kara more dän
karma-phal ämä chäòa nirmama haiyä
yuddha kara äçä tyaji müòhatä tyajiyä

Text 30

ämära emata kärya anuñöhän kari
sarva karma kare çüdhu bhajite çré-hari
çraddhävän mor bhakta asüyä-bihén
karma-phal mukta hay bhaktite bilén

Text 31

prakåti-sadåça ceñöä kare guëavän
prakåtir vaçe sarva kärya anuñöhän

Text 32

vahukäl hate yärä prakåtir vaç
nigraha karite näre haiyä vivaç

Text 33

ataev indriyärthe räg dveñ chäòi
viñayete räg dveñ kichu nähi kari
tähär vaçete nije kabhu nä rahibä
anäsakta viñayete mädhavera sevä

Text 34

nija dharma çreya jäna para-dharmäpekñä
bhagavad sevä lägi karma-yoga çikñä
svadharme nidhan bhäla nahe paradharma
bhäla kari bujha tumi ei güòha marma

Text 35

arjun kahilen:
he värñëeya kaha tumi bujhäiyä more
ki lägi hayeche jéva yukta päpa ghore
anicchä-sattveo hay päpe niyojita
avaça haiyä kare päpa se garhita

Text 36

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
käm är krodh hay rajoguë dvärä
abhibhüta baddha-jév tri-jagate särä
jïäné-jév ei dui mahä çatru jäne
kare täi guëätéta kärya sävadhäne

Text 37

tri-jagate käm mätra sarva ävaraë
ägunete dhüm yathä dhüsara darçan
athavä jaräyu yathä garbha ävaraë
alpädhik ei sab kämera käraë

Text 38

ei nitya vairé kare jïäna ävaraë
jév tähe vaddha hay nahe sädhäraë
käm hay duñpüraë agnira samän
ataev käm lägi hao sävadhän

Text 39

sei käm adhiñöhita indriyädi mane
vuddhite vasiyä äìke nikhila bhuvane
vaddha jév se käraë deha abhimäné
svätantryer vyavahär nähi jäne jïäné

Text 40

ataev he bhärat! prathamete käm
niyantrita kari hao sampürëa niñkäm
bhaktira dhäraëa sei käma jaya janya
se jïän vijïan-näçé, nähi patha anya

Text 41

baddha-jév jaòa-buddhi indriya pradhän
indriyädhipati man karmera bidhän
man hate para-buddhi tärpar ätmä
ataev kara sevä sei paramätmä

Text 42

apräkåta buddhi dvärä kara däsya tär
ghucibe sakal moha käma vyavahär
sei se upäy ek çatru jinibär
kämarüpa duräsada keha nähi är

Text 43

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 4

Chapter 4
Transcendental Knowledge

çré bhagavän kahilen:
pürve ämi balechiläm, süryake pratham
ei se niñkäm karm apürva kathan
sürya balechila pare manuke svaputre
ikñväku çunila pare paramparä sütre

Text 1

sei paramparä dvär räjarñigaë
eke eke çune saba gétära vacan
kälakrame paramparä hayeche vinañöa
paramparä vinä jäna saba artha bhrañöa

Text 2

ataeva kahi punaù sei purätan
punarvära paramparä karite sthäpan
bhakti vinä ke bujhibe gétära rahasya
tumi mor priya sakhä karaha vimuñya

Text 3

arjun kahilen:
tumi ta' navéna sakhä sedina janmile
koöi koöi varña pürve sürya janma nile
e kathä ki kare bujhi pürva eta dine
upadeç purätan tumi balechile

Text 4

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
he arjun bahu janma tomära ämär
hayeche pürvakäle se saba apär
bhuli näi ämi sei tumi bhule gecha
ämi bibhu tumi jév ei bhäve ächa

Text 5

sakaler niyämak ajanmä haiyä
avyayätmä paramätmä bhuvana bhariyä
tathäpi sva-çakti säthe janma lai ämi
sei bhagavattä mor bhäla bujha tumi

Text 6

yadä yadä dharma-gläni haila saàsäre
he bhärat! viçva-bhär laghu karibäre
adharmer abhyutthän dharma-gläni hale
ätmära såjan kari dekhaye sakale

Text 7

sädhuder paritraë asädhur vinäç
ye kare adharma tär kari sarva-näç
är dharma sthiti artha karite sädhan
yuge yuge äsi ämi mänase vacan

Text 8

ämära ye janma-karma se ati mahän
ye bujhila sei kathä seo bhägyavän
se chäòiyä deha ei nahe punarjanma
mama dhäme phiri äse chäòe jaòa dharma

Text 9

chäòi räg bhay krodh trividha asär
manmaya madbhakti sädhya kariyä vicär
vahu bhakta jïäné sab tapasyär dväre
vidhauta haiyä päp peyeche ämäre

Text 10

yebhäve ye bhaje more ämi sei bhäve
yathä-yogya phal di-i äpana prabhäve
ämäkei sarva mate cähe sarva öhàäi
ägupichu mätra hay pathe bhed näi

Text 11

karma-käëdé siddhi lägi vahu dev-devé
iha-lok hay sab bahu sevya sevé
çéghra yei karma-phal e manuñya-loke
anitya se phal bhuïje duùkhe är çoke

Text 12

cäri varëa såñöi mora guëa karma bhäge
yär yähä guë hay kahiba se äge
tathäpi se nahi ämi guna karma mäjhe
yadyapi niyantä ämi sakalera käje

Text 13

ämi karma-phale lipta nahi kona käle
spåhä kabhu näi mor kona karma-phale
ämära karmera kathä bujhe bhäla mate
bandhana ghucila tär karmera phalete

Text 14

ei güòha tattva-kathä pürve ye bujhila
anäyäse tärä sab saàsära tarila
tumi pürva mahäjane yathä anusär
yathävat siddhi-läbh haibe vistar

Text 15

kivä karma akarma vä karite vicär
baòa baòa muni åñi hay camatkär
täi se baliba ämi kivä karma hay
jänile se tattva-kathä açubhera kñay

Text 16

karma ye bujhite tumi akarma bujhibe
vikarma bujhite tathä bhäve buddha habe

Text 17

durgama karmera gati nigüòha se tattva
ye bujhila se bujhila tähära mahattva
karmete akarma dekhe akarme ye karma
ye buddhimän manuñya se bujheche marma

Text 18

sakala samärambhe yär saàkalpa varjan
jïänägnite dagdha karma päëòitye grahaë

Text 19

tyakta karmaphaläsaìga äçraya vihén
nitya tåpta nityänanda nija karme léna
se pravåtta nija karme kichu nähi kare
anäsakta karmaphal sacchanda vihare

Text 20

karma-phale spåhä-hén datta citta ätmä
sarva parigraha tyakta yukta se sarvathä
çaréra nirväha mätra karma yei kare
kariyäo sarva karma sarva päpa hare

Text 21

yathä-läbh tathä tuñöa sarva dvandva mukta
nirmatsar samacitta nija karme yukta
siddhäsiddha samadåñöi nähita vidveñ
kariyäo sarva karma karma-phala çeñ

Text 22

asaìga niyukta jïäné citte kñobh näi
jïänävasthita sei sarvadä sab öhìäi
sei se yäjïika sadä äcaraëe dakña
tär karma praviléta ekänta samakña

Text 23

brahma-maya karma tär brahmete arpaë
brahma habi brahma agni hotä brahma-phal
tähära se brahma-gati niçcita nirëaya
brahma karma samädhistha sarvatra vijay

Text 24

daiva yajïa kare pare seo yogé hay
brahma-jïäné seo yogé homädi nilay
naiñöhika brahmacärér yajïa indriya saàyam
çrotädi mänasa tapa agnite arpaë

Text 25

rüpa rasa çabda sparça viñaye saàyam
yajïähuti sei haya indriya haban

Text 26

sarvendriya karma präë saàyam agnite
yatnaçél yata yogé habana karite
ätma-saàyamädi yog jïäna dépite
påthak påthak yogé hay yukta se yogete

Text 27

dravya-yajïa tapo-yajïa yoga-yajïa yata
svädhyäya yogéra jïän çaàsita se vrata

Text 28

präëäpän yogakriyä apäne haban
präëäpän gatiruddha präëäyämé han
ähärädi kharva kari niyata ähär
präëke präëete dyaya homera äkär

Text 29

ei sab tattvavit kñéë päpa hay
krame krame päpahén brahma se präpay
yajïa niñöha bhojé tärä niñpäpa jévan
yogya vyakti hay läbhe brahma sanätan

Text 30: All these performers who know the meaning of sacrifice become cleansed of sinful reactions, and, having tasted the nectar of the results of sacrifices, they advance toward the supreme eternal atmosphere.

ihaloke yajïa vinä kona sukh näi
paralok vinä yajïe kemane se päi

Text 31

he puruñottama! ataù yajïai ye dharma
är sab yähä kichu sakala vikarma
vedädi çästrete tathä bahu yajïa hay
kata çäkhä praçäkhädi ke kare nirëay
se sab yajïädi jäna saba karmajän
muktipatha sei jäna yajïa se sarvän

Text 32

kintu çreya jïäna-yajïa dravya yajïäpekñä
jïänéra nähika är karmaja apekñä
sarva karma çeñ hay jïäne samäpan
karma-çuddha citte hay jïänera sädhan

Text 33

ataeva se vijïän ye jänibäre cäy
upayukta gurupada karaye äçray
praëipät paripraçna sevära sahit
guru-sthäne jäni lao äpanär hit

Text 34

se sab jïänera kathä bujhite pärile
moha är habe nähi härile jitile
takhana se ätmä-dåka dekhe brahma-sama
sampürëa darçana sei samparka se sama

Text 35

päpé hate päpé yadi haye thäka tumi
tathäpi jïänera pote taribe äpani

Text 36

pravala agnite yathä käñöha bhasmasät
jïänägni jvalile päpa sakala nipät
ataev jïänatulya nähi se pavitra
tähä nahe jaòa jïän läbh yatra-tatra

Text 37

yog-siddha sei jïän cinmaya nirmal
se jïän labhile habe änande vihval

Text 38

sraddhävän yei hay labhe sei jïän
saàyata indriya yär tatpara se han
se jïän labhile çänti acirät päya
saàsärera yata kleç sab miöe yäy

Text 39

saàçayätmä ajïa yärä tähe çraddhä näi
vinäça niçcaya tär kahinu niçcaya-i
se sab lokera näi iha-parakäl
saàçayé ätmä se duùkhé se saàsära-jäl

Text 40

ataeva yoga dvärä sandeha vihéna
jïäna-läbha dvärä haya saàçay viléna
ätmavän jïanavän karma hate mukta
he dhanaïjay! tumi sei hao nityamukta

Text 41

ajïäna-sambüta moha jïäna asi dvärä
hådaye udaya sab haiyäche yär
ei sab chinna kari jägiyä uöhibe
he bhärat! yogotiñöha hao e saàsäre

Text 42

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 5

Chapter 5
Karma-yoga-Action in Kåñëa Consciousness

arjun kahilen:
he kåñëa bärek karma tyäga ye kathan
punaräy karma-yog kaha vivaraë
tär madhye yevä niçcita jänibä
saàçaya-bihén kari ämäre kahibä

Text 1

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
sannyäsa är karma-yog dui çreya hay
sakala vedädi çästre täi se kahaya
tär madhye karma-yog sannyäsa apekñä
kriyätmak jana-madhye nä kara upekñä

Text 2

räg-dveña vivarjita yevä karma-yogé
anäsakta viñayete nahe ta' se bhogé
nirdvanda se mahäväho duùkha bandha nahe
tomäre kahinu ämi kariyä niçcay

Text 3

säìkhya-yog karma-yog yevä påthak bale
paëòita se nahe kabhu bälakera chale
ubhaya käryera madhye ye kona se ek
ubhayer phal präpti haibe samyak

Text 4

säìkhya-yog sädhya kari ye pada se päy
yog-siddha hale läbh tähä upajay
ataeva säìkhya kimvä yog ek bal
buddhimän sei hay ye bujhe ek phal

Text 5

sannyäsa kariyä yadi nahe karma yogé
mahä-väho ki baliba våthä sei tyägé
yog-yukta muni yevä brahmapada päy
acirät sei kärya siddhi yoge hay

Text 6

yog-yukta viçuddhätmä jita ñaòa guë
jitendriya hay sei atyanta pravéë
sarva-bhüt lägi yevä karma-yog sädhe
viñayer madhye thäke viñaye nä bädhe

Text 7

se yogé cintaye sadä haye tattvavit
sarva kärya kari kintu kari nä kiïcit
dekhi çuni sparça kari niùçväse praçväse
svapane gamane kimvä bhojane viläse
praläpan kari kimvä bhoge vä se tyäge
unmélan nimélan kimvä nidrä yäya jäge
jaòa-kärye jaòendriya satata se jäne
nija kärya ätma-tattva sarvadä se dhyäne

Texts 8-9

brahmaëi niviñöa kärya niùsaìga ye kare
viñaya prabhäve sei tähäte nä òare
ataeva päp-puëye nähi täre lepe
sei padma-patra jale jäni vä saàkñepe

Text 10

käya mana väkye se ye yogera sädhana
man buddhi indriyädi ekatre bandhana
yogärthe ye kärya hay vairägya se yukta
sakala samaye jïän yogé nitya-yukta

Text 11

karma-phal tyaji yukta vairägya sädhana
naiñöhiké çänti se, nahe saàsära bandhana
phalgu vairägya ye käm käré phal
phal-kärye nivandhana täi se durval

Text 12

bähye sarva-kärya kare antare sannyäs
sarva-kärye suñöhu kari sukhete niväs
nava-dvär yukta deha thäki sei pure
nije kichu nähi kare nä karäy pare

Text 13

anädi karma-phale bhavärëava jvale
äche paòe vä nä hay tìähära såjan
karma-phal yevä yog yähä kare bhog
svabhäva se kärya hay näm bhava-rog

Text 14

éçvarer datta nahe sei päpa puëya
päp puëya yähä kichu nija icchä janya
ajïäna-janita sei bhog icchä kare
päçe thäki mäyä täre jäpaöiyä dhare

Text 15

ataev jïän upajile mäyä näç
ätmära svarüpa tathä svataù-i prakäç
süryera prakäçe yathä andhakär yäy
jïänera prakäse tathä ajïäner kñay

Text 16

sei jïäna anuküle buddhi niñöhä yär
ätma-jïän paräyaë saàsära uddhär

Text 17

samadarçé hay se jïänera prabhäve
vidyä-vinay-sampanna brähmaëe vä gabe
hasté vä kukur vä se néca caëòäl
samadarçé jïäné dekhe sabäi samän

Text 18

jévanmukta sei jïäné sädhäraë nay
sei sämyasthita mane saàsära ye kñaya
samatä nirdeça brahma tähe brahma-sthiti
brahma-jïäné yei tär sei haya réti

Text 19

priya vastu präpya hale uöhe nä näciyä
apriya präptite kabhu mare nä käìdiyä
sthir buddhi brahma-vid asaà-müòha mati
brahmete niyata väs näm brahma-sthiti

Text 20

bähya-sparça sukha yähä näi ye äsakti
ätmänande sevänandé ätmäte vindati
sei brahma-yog yukta ätmä päy
akñara sukhete magna sarvadä se ray

Text 21

sparça sukhe ye änanda tähä duùkhamaya
bhog nahe bhogé sei jäniha niçcay
sei sukhe ädi ante çudhu duùkha hay
buddhimän vyakti yei nä täte ramay

Text 22

çaréra chäòite pürve ye abhyäsa kare
tähära sulabha sei anye kìädi mare
ñaòaveg jay kari gosvämé ye hay
sukhé sei nara-näré kare dig-vijay

Text 23

bähirer sukh chäòi yevä antarmukh
antare ramaë kare antarjyoti-rüp
brahma-bhüta hay sei brahmate nirväë
bahirangä mäyä chäòe päy bhagavän

Text 24

niñpäpa haiyä åñé brahmete nirväë
sarva-bhüta hite rata chinna dvidhä-jïän

Text 25

käm krodha vinirmukta yata citta dhér
ätma-tattva jïäné yati atéva gambér
sadasad vicära kari brahmete nirväë
prakåti atéta tär brahme avasthän

Text 26

e chäòä añöäìga yog tähä bali çuna
abhyäsa yähär hay atéva triguëa
çavda sparça rüpa ras är yähä gandha
bahirbähya kari räkhi nä räkhi samvandha
cakñu sei bhrumadhye räkhiyä niçcal
präëäpän väyu dhari näsä abhyantar
näsikär agrabhäg kevala darçan
uttama prakriyä sei yogera sädhan
indriya saàyam sei yog prakaraë
man buddhi dvärä muni mokña paräyaë
se bhäve ye vét icchä bhay är krodh
yukta hay se puruñ saàyata nirodh

Texts 27-28

yogeçvara ämi hai ämi sei lakñya
se kathä ye bujhe bhäla sei yogé dakña
sakala yajïa tapasyär ämi bhoktä hai
samasta loker svämé keha nahe sei
samasta jéver bandhu ämi ekmätra
jagater çänti hay jänile sarvatra

Text 30

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 6

Chapter 6
Dhyäna-yoga

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
anäçrita karma-phal sei mukhya hay
tähä vinä sannyäsé ki yogé kichu nay
karma-tyäg nahe mukhya karma-phal tyäg
daihik ceñöä se tyäg nahe ta' samyak
täi se sannyäsé yogé samän ye kram
karma-phal tyäg vinä dui sei bhram

Text 1: The Supreme Personality of Godhead said: One who is unattached to the fruits of his work and who works as he is obligated is in the renounced order of life, and he is the true mystic, not he who lights no fire and performs no duty.

asànyasta saìkalpa vinä nahe yogé
vähye mätra kriyähén antare se bhogé

Text 2

sab yog hay siddha karma se käraë
ärurukña muni sei çuna vivaraë
yogete ärüòha sei çamatä käraë
sädhaker krama panthä yogänusaraë

Text 3

indriyärtha yadä karma äcarita nay
sarva saìkalpa-çünya sannyäsé se hay
yogärüòha se avasthä çästrera nirëay
se avasthä mukta path karaha äçray

Text 4

anäsakta viñayete yathä karma dåòha
saàsära se küp hate nija ätmä käòa
ätmäke uddhär karä ätmära ucit
ätmäke nähi kabhu kara abasäd
ätmäi ätmär bandhu ätmäi se ripu
ätmära çatru ye hay hiraëyakaçipu

Text 5

ye jan jinila nija man ätmajita
se man ye bandhu tähä çästrete kathita
ajita ye man sei man nija çatru
apakäré hay sadä viruddha vipakña

Text 6

praçänta ye man sei sarvadäi jita
ätmajita man paramätmä samähita
gréñma çét yata duùkha män apamän
jita man yär tär sakali samän

Text 7

nija tåpta sei man jïän vijïänete
küöastha vijitendriya nijera käryete
sama loñöra svarëa yär yukta hay yogé
sakala avasthäte ye sarvadäi tyägé

Text 8

suhåd mitra niñpakña bandhu kimbä ari
sakaler prati yini sama bhuddhi kari
madhyastha kimbä sädhu ye päpéyasé hay
sakaler prati sämya çreñöhatä präpay

Text 9

ye yogé satata thäki ekäké nirjane
niräçé aparigraha cittera yatane
samädhistha haye thäke adhika samay
vairägé tähär man vaçébhüta hay

Text 10

pavitra sthänete basi nijäsan upare
celäjin vastra äsanädi paropare
ati ucce nähi base ati néce nahe
sthir man haye evä yogäbhyäse rahe
ekägrataù man kari yata cittendriya
yogäbhyäs kare muni viçuddha håday

Texts 11-12

deha çir grévä tin samäna kariyä
acala avasthä dhér bhävete basiyä
näsikär agra-bhäg satata dekhiyä
anya yata dåçya-vastu kichu nä dekhiyä
praçäntätmä bhay näi brahmacäré vrata
saàyamita man yevä ämätei rata

Texts 13-14

se bhäve ye yoga sädhe niyata mänas
sadätma sei yogé amåta paraç
nirväë parama çänti hay adhikäré
phire yäy mama dhäme yathä lélähari

Text 15

ati-bhojé anähäré yoge siddha nay
ati-nidrä ati-jägé çuna dhanaïjay

Text 16

yukta-bhojé vihära se yukta karma ceñöä
yukta nidrä yukta jägi yoga paräsåñtä

Text 17

yatätmä viniyata citta ätma-tuñöa
nispåha ye sarvakäme sei yoga-puñöa

Text 18

yathä dép vinä väyu sthir bhäve thäke
uttama upamä sei yogéra niñöhäke

Text 19

yogéra se ätma-sthir yoga sädhanete
yogätmana tär näm yog abhyäsete
viñay bhoger uparati yogéra pramäë
niruddha se yog-sevä siddhira nidhän
ätmäräm yadä tuñöa ätmär darçane
siddha sei yogé hay yogera sädhane
satya ye sukh tähä indriyatéta
yev sei nähi jäne asthira tattvataù
ye sukh haile läbh sarva-läbh hay
anya sab yata läbh kichu kämya nay
yähäte haile sthita guru duùkhe ati
asthira nä hay thäke aöala vicyuti
yog sädhi se avasthä yadi labhya hay
añöäìga yoger siddhi tähäre kahay

Texts 20-23

utsäha dhairya är nilaya ätmikä
yog-siddhi lägi chäòi nirveda präpikä
saìkalpa samasta dvärä nä haye kiïcit
man dvärä indriyake kariyä vijit

Text 24

krame krame uparäm viñaya bhogete
ätmasthita man kari viräma cintäte

Text 25

asthira caïcal man yathä yathä dhäy
ceñöä kari sei man vaçete räkhay
ätmära vaçete man sadäi räkhibe
caïcal svabhäva tär çodhana karibe

Text 26

praçänta haile man sukh uttam yogér
çänta hay rajoguë niñpäp çarér
niñpäpa haile sei sattva guëe sthita
brahma-bhüta näm tär çuddha samähita

Text 27

vidhauta samasta päp yogé akalmaña
sukhe brahma saàsparça se kramaça kramaça
brahma sukhe magna hay se yogé takhana
präkåta guëädi tyaji brahma anubhava
brahma sparça kivä hay kemane tä jäni
sarva-bhüta brahme darçan sarva brahma jäni

Text 28

sarvatra samän dåñöi yog-yukta ätmä
samädhistha sei yogé dekhe paramätmä

Text 29

se dekhe ämäre sab stävara jaìgame
anya dåñöi nähi tär nirguëa saìgame
se hay ämär premé ämi hai tär
nérasa çuknä tarka nahe vyavahär

Text 30

sarva-bhüta-sthita dekhe sarvatra ämäre
bhajane ästhita haye sevaye se more
se yogé nikhila bhave sarvatra thäkiyä
ämäte vasaye nitya ämäre bhajiyä

Text 31

vasudhä kuöumba tär keha nahe par
präkåta vicära näi svpar apar
nija sukha nija duùkha anyete vyavahär
sei se samänadarçé sarvatra pracär

Text 32

arjun kahilen:
äpani ye yoga värta kahilen ämäre
he madhusüdan! tähä nä sambhave more
mor mana caïcala se asthira se mati
ataeva bujhi ämi asambhava gati

Text 33

he kåñëa jäna nä kivä pramäthé manere
ati balaväna sei saba paëòa kare
tähära nigraha mäni ati suduñkara
väyu rodha yathä hay atyanta prakhara

Text 34

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
asaàçaya sei kathä tumi yä kahile
atyanta kaöhina sei manera caïcale
kintu yadi kare ceñöä çunaha kaunteya
vairägya sädhane tabe hay kärya çreya

Text 35

asaàyata mana yär yog se duñkar
sei se ämära mat bujaha bistar
ätma-vaçi ceñöä kari ye kare upäy
tähära se kärya siddhi jänaha niçcay

Text 36

arjun kahilen:
ceñöä kariyäo yadi siddha nähi hay
he kåñëa! bala tär ki äche upäy
sädhyamata ceñöä kari vicalita hay
apräpya se yoga-siddhi tähära niçcay

Text 37

ubhaya bhrañöa chinnäbhra mato sarvanäç
vimüòha brahmera pathe kivä tär äç
mahäväho! e saàçaya karaha chedan
ghucäo äpani sei manera vedan

Text 38

tumi kåñëa se svayaà sab kichu jäna
tumi vinä chettä kivä äche är äna

Text 39

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
he pärtha! çunaha tumi se rüp tähär
ek-janme nahe siddha vipatti apär
tähär-o nähi näs iha vä amutra
kalyäëa kärya ye sei vijaya sarvatra

Text 40

yadivä haila bhrañöa yogera sädhane
tathäpi se päy sei yähä puëyaväne
uttama brähmaëa dhané vaëikera ghare
yogabhrañöa janma lay vidhira vicäre

Text 41

athavä yogéra kule tär janma hay
durlabha se saba janma kivä tär bhay
se sab durlabha janma yadi keha päy
tärpar saìga doñe yadi nä bhramay

Text 42

buddhira saàyoge pürva dehe ye sädhila
he kurunandana jäna sei niçcay-i bujhila
tabe buddhimän kare puëah yoger sädhan
dåòha ceñöa kari yogé punaù siddha han

Text 43

sväbhävik bhäve sei icchära udyam
äkåñöa haiyä kare se kärye udyam
jijïäsu yadi vä hay yogera viñay
tathäpi se karmakäëòa atéta taray

Text 44

yatna-mätra kari yogé kärya siddhi kare
janma-janmäntare siddha bhavärëava tare

Text 45

tapasvé se yata äche, saba-nimna yogé käche,
jïäné nahe tär samatulya
karméra ki kathä är, kothäy tulanä tär,
he arjun! yogé hao yogya

Text 46

yata yogé prakära se çästrete nirëay
tär madhye mad-gata-präë yevä keha hay
sabära se çreñöha yogé jäniha niçcay
çraddhävän yadi sei ämäre bhajay

Text 47

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 7

Chapter 7
Knowledge of the Absolute

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
ämäte äsakta haye yogera sädhan
tomäre kahinu pärtha sab etakñaë
se yog äçray kari samagra ye ämi
asaàçay bujhibe ye anivärya tumi
çuna pärtha sei kathä tomäke ye kahi
bhakti-yog çuddha sattva yäte tuñöa rahi

Text 1: The Supreme Personality of Godhead said: Now hear, O son of Påthä, how by practising yoga in full consciousness of Me, with mind attached to Me, you can know Me in full, free from doubt.

ämär viñaye ye hay jïän-vijïän
se viñaye açeñata çuna diyä man
jänile se tattva-jïän jïätavya viñay
sahaje-i sab tattva samädhän hay

Text 2

sahasra manuñya madhye kona ekjan
siddhi-läbh karibäre karaye yatan
yatnaçél sei käry kona ekjan
siddhiläbh karibäre upayukta han
tär madhye keha keha ämäke tattvata
bujhite samartha han vivekavaçata

Text 3

bhümi jal agni väyu buddhi ye äkäç
är ahaìkär man buddhira prakäç
ei sab añöa prkärera hay ye prakåti
bhinnä sei ämä hate bähira bibhüti

Text 4

anutkåñöä tärä saha utkåñöä tä hate
prakåti är ek ye ächaye ämäte
jév-bhütä se prakåti çuna mahäbäho
jév dvära dhärya jaòä jäna aharaha

Text 5

ei dui prakåti se näm paräparä
sarva-bhüta yoni tärä jäna paramparä
yehetu prakåti dui ämä hate hay
jagatera utpatti lay ämi se niçcaya

Text 6

ämäpekñä paratattva çuna dhanaïjay
parätpar ye tattva anya keha nay
ämäte samasta jagat äche pratiñöhita
sütre yena gìäöhä thäke maëigaë yata

Text 7

jalera ye sarasatä ämi se kounteya
candra-sürya prabhä yei ämä hate jïeya
sarva-vede ye praëab hay mukhya tattva
äkäsera çavda sei ämi hai satya

Text 8

påthivéra puëya gandha süryera prabhäv
jévana sarva-bhüter tapasvéra täp

Text 9

utpattira véj-rüp sabära se ämi
sanätana tattva pärtha sakalera svämé
buddhi-män yevä hay tär buddhi ämi
tejasvéra teja hay yähä antaryämé

Text 10

valavän yata äche tär val ämi
käm-räga vivarjita yata agragämé
dharma aviruddha käma he bharatarñabha
se saba bujhaha tumi ämära baibhava

Text 11

ye sab sättvika bhäv rajasa tamasa
ämä hate hay sab ämi nahi vaç

Text 12

ei tin guë dvärämohita jagata
nä bujhite päre more parama çäçvata

Text 13

ataev guëamayé ämära ye mäyä
bahiraìgä çakti sei ati duratyayä
se mäyära hät hate yadi mukti cäy
ämära caraëe sei prapatti karaya

Text 14

kintu yärä duräcär narädham müòha,
sarvadäi guëa-kärye ati-mäträ dåòha
mäyära dväräte järä apahåta jïän
prapatti kare nä tärä yata asurän

Text 15

sukåti kareche yärä sei cärijan
ärta arthärthi jijïäsu kimbä jïäné han
prapatti sahita tärä karaye bhajan
asurädi mäyä-yuddhe häräy jévan

Text 16

ei cärijana madhye jïäné se viçiñöa
priya hay jïäné mor ati se valiñöha

Text 17

ukta cärijan bhakta sakale udär
çuddha bhakti präpta han kramaça vistär
tär madhye jïäné bhakta ati se ätméya
se käraëe uttam gati hay varaëéya

Text 18

krame krame jïänéjan bahu janma pare
ämära caraëe çuddha prapatti se kare
väsudevamaya tadä jagat darçan
durlabha mahätmä sei çästrera varëan

Text 19

ye paryanta kämanär dvärä thäke vaçébhüta
prapatti ämäte tadä-nahe ta sambhüta
sei käm dvärä tärä håta-jïän hay
ämäke chäòiyä anya devatä püjay

Text 20

ämi antaryämé tär thäkiyä antare
sei sei devapüjä karäi satvare
sei sei çraddhä di-i kariyä acal
ataev anya dev karaye püjan

Text 21

se takhan çraddhäyukta dev ärädhan
kariyä se phal päy ämära käraë
kintu sei sei phal anitya sakal
svalpa medhä cähe täi sädhana viphal

Text 22

tärä devaloke jäy anitya se dhäm
mor bhakta mor dhäme nitya pürëa käm
svalpa-buddhi yär hay se bale niräkär
jäne nä tähärä cid vigraha ämär

Text 23

sarvottama çreñöha hay ämära çarér
avyaya saccidänanda yähä jäne sab dhér
ämi sürya sama nitya sanätana dhäm
sabära nikaöe nahi dåçya ätmäräm

Text 24

uparokta müòha lok nähi dekhe more
ämi ye avyaya ätmä ajara amare

Text 25

ämära änanda rüp nitya avasthiti
se käraëe he arjun trikäla vidhiti
vartamän bhaviñyat athavä atét
samasta käler gati ämäte vidit
kintu müòha lok yärä nähi jäne more
éçvara parama kåñëa vidita saàsäre

Text 26

durbhägä ye lok sei dvandve-te mohita
icchä dveñ dvärä tärä saàsäre cälita
ataev he bhärat tärä janma käle
pürväpürva saàskärera sarvadä kavale

Text 27

niñpäpa hayeche yärä puëya karma dvärä
dvandva moha hate mukta hayeche yähärä
tärä hay dåòha-vrata bhajane ämär
nirbhay tähärä sab jinite saàsär

Text 28

ämäke äçray kari ye jana saàsäre
jarä maraë mokñer märga sadä yatna kare
se yogé jäne tattva brahma paramätmä
kimbä karmagati yäha jäne se dharmätmä

Text 29

adhibhüta adhidaiva kimbä adhi-yajïa
sei sab tattvajïäne yärä haya vijïa
tähäräo prayäëa samaye bujhe more
paramätmär sälokya läbh sei kare

Text 30

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 8

Chapter 8
Attaining the Supreme

arjun kahilen:
brahma kimbä adhyätma ki karma puruñottama
adhibhüta adhidaiva kaha tära krama

Text 1: Arjuna inquired: O my Lord, O Supreme Person, what is Brahman? What is the self? What are fruitive activities? What is this material manifestation? And what are the demigods? Please explain this to me.

adhiyajïa kivä sei he madhusüdan
kibhäve tomäke päy prayäëa yakhan

Text 2

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
akñay vinäç näi ataev brahma
ämi bhagavän sejanya parama-brahma
paramätmä är ye bhagavän
sei ye parama-tattva sei brahma-jïän
karma se käraë jaòa çaréra visarga
bhütombhava yär näm çuna tär varga

Text 3

padärtha ye adhibhüta kñara bhäva näm
viräöa puruña sei adhidaiva näm
antaryämé ämi sei adhiyajïa näm
yata dehé äche tär håde mor dhäm

Text 4

ataev antakäle ämäre smariyä
yebä cali yäy ei çaréra chäòiyä
se päy ämära bhäv amara se hay
niçcaya-i kahinu ei nähita saàçay

Text 5

ye yei smaraëa kare jéva anta käle
ye-bhäve se tyäje nija jaòa kalevare
sei sei bhäva yukta tatta läbha kare
he kounteya! thäki sadä sei bhäva ghare

Text 6

ataeva tumi sadä ämäke smaribe
käyamana buddhi sab ämäke arpibe
sebhäbe thäkile more päibe niçcay
ämäte arpita man yadi asaàçay

Text 7

kaöhina nahe ta' ei abhyäsa karile
manke anyatra sadä nähi yete dile
he pärtha se-bhäve cinti parama puruñe
niçcaya-i päibe tumi deha avaçeñe

Text 8

parama puruña dhyän çunaha tähära jïän,
sarvajïa tini se sanätana
niyantä se ati sükñma, vidhätä se antarékña,
agocara jaòa buddhi mana
ye jan smaraëa kare, nitya sei puruñere
ädityera nyäy svaprakäça
prakåtir parapäre, ye jäne se vidhätäre
svaräö tini cid viläsa

Text 9

acal manete yevä, prayäëa-kälete kivä,
bhakti-yukta haye yoga-vale
bhrur madhye räkhi präë, yadi hay se smaraë
divya puruña tähäre mile

Text 10

veda-jïäné ye akñar, läbhe hay tatpar
yähäte praviñöa hay yatigaë
vétaräg brahmacäré, sadä äcaraëa kari,
se tathya bali çuna vivaraë

Text 11

samasta indriya dvär, ruddha hayeche yär,
viñayete anäsakti näm
manke nirodh kari, hådayete sthir kari,
yei jan hayeche niñkäm
präëke bhrur mäjhe, yogya sei yogé-säje,
samartha yog dhäraëe sei

Text 12

oàkära akñara brahma, uccäraëe yei brahma,
ämäke smaraëa kare yei
se yäy çaréra chäòi, vaikuëöha vihäré hari,
samän lokete hay väs
sei se paramä gati, çréhari caraëe rati,
dhanya tär paramärtha äç

Text 13

ye yogé ananya citta, ämäke smaraye nitya,
dåòhatär saha aviräm
tähära sulabha ämi, he pärtha jänaha tumi,
nitya yoge tähära viçräm

Text 14

ämäke läbh kare se mahätmä hay
nahe tär punarjanma yethä duùkhälay
açäçvata saàsärete nahe tära sthiti
paramä gatite tär siddha avasthiti

Text 15

caturdaça bhuvanete yata lok hay
brahmalok paryanta se nitya keha nay
se sab lokete sthän gamanä-gaman
sakala lokete äche janama-maraë
bhaktira äçray yevä ämäke ye päy
kevala tähära mätra punarjanma nay

Text 16

manuñer sahasra ye caturyug yäy
brahmära se ekadin kariyä gaëay
seirüp ekarätri brahmära gaëana
rätri-dina brahmära ye karaha manana

Text 17

sei rätri abasäne avyakta haite
vyakta hay e trilok brahmära dinete
äbära se rätri-käle haibe pralay
avyakta haite janma avyakte miläy

Text 18

caräcara yähä kichu sei udbhav pralay
punaù punaù janma är punaù punaù kñay

Text 19

tähära upare yei bhävera nirëay
sanätan sei dhäm akñaya avyay
sakala såñöira näñ e jagate hay
sanätana dhäm nahe haibe pralay

Text 20

sei se avyakta näm 'akñara' tähär
jévera se gati näm paramä yähär
se gati haile läbh nä äse phiriyä
ämära se nitya dhäm saàsära jiniyä

Text 21

parama-puruña sei nitya dhäme väs
he pärtha! ananya bhakti tähära prayäsa
tìähär-i antarete hay samasta jagata
antaryämé se puruña sarvatra viståta

Text 22

ye kälete anävåtti yogéra sambhav
balitechi çuna tähä bharata åñabh

Text 23

brahmavit puruña ye jyoti çubhadine
uttaräyaëa kälete karile prayäëe
brahma-läbh haya tär anävåtti gati
karméra jïänéra sei sädhäraëa mati

Text 24

tärä iñöäpürti karme rätri kåñëa-pakñe
dhüm vä dakñiëäyana candra jyoti lakñe
märga sei äçrayete punarägaman
karma-yogé nähi kare brahma-nirüpaë

Text 25

ataev dui märga çukla kåñëa näm
çäçvata ye dui path hai vartamän
çukla-märge yär gati tär anävåtti
kåñëa-märge yär gati se ävåtti

Text 26

kintu pärtha bhakta mor dui märga jäni
mohapräpta nähi hay bhakti-yog mäni
ataev he arjun! more nitya smara
bhakti-yog-yukta hao kabhu nä päsara

Text 27

vedädi çästrete yähä, yajïa tapa dän tähä,
puëya-phal yähä se pradiñöa
se yog ye avalambe, päy tähä avilambe,
samyaka bujhiyä nija iñöa

Text 28

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 9

Chapter 9
The Most Confidential Knowledge

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
evära he arjun çuna asüyä rahita
ei ek guhyatama kahi tava hita
ihä hay jïän är vijïäna-sammata
jänile se mukta hay sarb açubhata

Text 1: The Supreme Personality of Godhead said: My dear Arjuna, because you are never envious of Me, I shall impart to you this most confidential knowledge and realization, knowing which you shall be relieved of the miseries of material existence.

räj-vidyä ei jïän räj guhya kahe
pavitra uttam tähä sädhäraë nahe
yähära sädhane hay pratyakñänubhav
susukha se dharma hay avyay baibhav

Text 2

yähära se çraddhä näi ohe parantap
ei dharma vijïänete våthä japatap
se ämäke nähi päy jäniha niçcay
måtyu saàsärera pathe nirantar ray

Text 3

avyakta ye nirviçeñ ämär-i rüp
jagata vyäpiyä thäki anirdiñöa rüp
ämäte jagat sab nä ämi tähäte
pariëäm hay tähä ämära çaktite

Text 4

ämära çaktite thäke bhinna ämä hate
yogaiçvarya sei mor bujha bhäla mate
bhartä sakala bhüter nahi se bhütastha
bhüta-bhåt näm mor bhütädi taöastha

Text 5

äkäça är ye väyu serüpa tulanä
äkäça påthaka hate väyura cälanä
äkäça sarvatra vyäpta väyu yathä thäke
tathä sarvabhüta sthita thäke ye ämäte

Text 6

prakåtir lay hale viçräma ämäte
kalpärambhe hay såñöi punaù ämä hate
pralayer pare thäki ämi ye éçvar
såñöä-ñåñta yähä kichu ämära kiìkar

Text 7

ämära prakåti dvärä såji punaù punaù
prakåtira vaçe hay yata bhüta gräm

Text 8

kintu dhanaïjay tumi bujhibe niçcay
prakåtira kärye kabhu ämi lipta nay
udäsén ämi sei prakåtira kärye
äsakti nahe ta' mor prakåti vidhärye

Text 9

iìgita-mätra se mor jaòä-kärya kare
caräcar yata kichu prasabe sabäre
jagat parivartana hay sei se käraë
punaù punaù hay yata janama maraë

Text 10

ämära manuñyäkär vigraha dekhiyä
müòha lok nähi bujhe avajïä kariyä
ämi maheçvara ei jagata saàsäre
ämära parama bhäv ke bujhite päre

Text 11

ämäke avajïä täi vyartha sab äçä
biphala karama tär jïänera jijïäsä
yähära äsuré bhäv räkñasa svabhäv
chäòe more mäne çudhu prakåti baibhav
prakåti mohiné mürti täre järi märe
mäyämay mürti bale tähärä ämäre

Text 12

kintu yevä mahätmä se ärädhya-prakåti
äçraya laiyä kare bhajana saìgati
ananya manete kare viçuddha bhajan
samasta bhütera ädi ämäke takhan

Text 13

lakñaëa se mahätmär hay vilakñaë
mahimä ämär kare satata kértan
ämära mahimä janya sarva karme rata
sakala viñaye yata hao dåòha-vrata

Text 14

bhaktira yäjana är praëäma vijïapti
nitya-sevä upäsanä ämäkei präpti
yärä çuddha bhakta nahe kintu more bhaje
jïän yajïa kari tärä tin-bhäve maje
ahaàgraha upäsan ekatva se näm
påthakatve upäsanä pratékopäsan
viçva-rüpa upäsanä anirdiñöa-rüp
niräkär-bhäv kimbä bhäve bahu-rüp

Text 15

ämi-i sei smärta-yajïe çrouta vaiçyadev
ämi-i se svadhä mantra ouñadha vibhed
ämi-i se agni homa ghåtädi sämagré
ämi pitä ämi mätä athavä vidhätå

Text 16

ämi pitämaha vedya pavitra oàkär
ämi åk ämi säm yaju kiàbä är

Text 17

ämi gati ämi bhartä more säkñé kara
ämi se çaraëya-dhäm prabhava pralaya

Text 18

ämi se utpatti sthiti véja avyay
ämi våñöi ämi megh ämi måtyumay
ämi se amåta tattva çuna he arjun
sadasad yähä kichu ämi viçvarüp

Text 19

karma-käëòa veda tray, sädhane ye pürëa hay,
soma-ras päne päpa kñay
yajïa mor upäsanä, yevä kare se sädhanä,
svarga-sukh prärthanä se kare
puëyera phalete sei, surendra lokete yäy,
divya-sukh bhog sethä kare
viçäla se svarga-sukh, bhule yäy jaòa duùkha,
krame krame tära puëya hare
trayé dharma karma-käëòa payo-mukha viña-bhäëòa
amåta bhäviyä yevä khäy
gatägati käma-läbh, janme janme mahätäp,
tär janma adhaùpäte yäy

Text 20

Text 21

kintu ye ananya-bhäve more cintä kare
ekänta haiyä çudhu ämäke ye smare
sei nitya-yukta bhakta ämära se priya
ye sukha cähaye sei hay mor deya
ämi tär yogakñem bahi lai yäi
ämä vinä anya tär kona cintä näi

Text 22

itara devatä yevä püje çraddhä kari
çeo ämäke püje vidhi dharma chäòi

Text 23

sarva yajïeçvara ämi prabhu ära bhoktä
se kathä bujhe nä yärä nahe tattva-vettä
ataev tattva-jïän haite vicyuta
pratékopäsanä sei tättvika vismåta

Text 24

itara devatä yäjé yäy devaloke
pitålok upäsak yäy pitåloke
bhüt-pret upäsak bhütaloke yäy
ämäke bhajana kare ämäkei päy
ämära püjana hay sakale sambhav
daridra hale-o nahe apekñä vaibhav

Text 25

patra puñpa phal jal bhakta more dyay
bhaktira käraëa sei grahaëéya hay
yatna kari mor bhakta yähä kichu dyay
santuñöa haiyä lai bhaktira prabhäy
nirapekña bhakta tumi e mora niçcaya
tomära ye käryakram saba bhakti haya

Text 26

ataev kara yähä bhog yajïa tap
arpaëa karaha tumi ämäke sesab

Text 27

çubhäçubha phal yähä hay tähä dvärä
tähära bandhana hate mukt tumi särä
sei se sannyäsa-yog karite yuyäy
yähära phalete lok more präpta haya

Text 28

ämi ta' sakala bhüte dekhi samabhäv
nahe keha priya mor dveñya vä prabhäv
kintu sei bhaje more bhakti-yukta hai
se ämäte ämi täte äsakta ye rai

Text 29

ananya ye bhakta yadi kabhu duräcär
bhajana karaye more ekaniñöhatär
se sädhu mantavya hay samyag vyavasita
doña tär kichu nay se ye dåòha-vrata

Text 30

ati-çéghra yäbe sei bhäva duräcär
dharma-bhäv habe tär bhaktite ämär
he kaunteya! pratijïä e çunaha ämär
ämära ye bhakta hay näç nähi tär

Text 31

ämäke äçray kari yevä päp-yoni
mlecchädi yavan kimbä beçyä madhye gaëi
kimbä vaiçya çüdra yadi ämära äçray
päibe vaikuëöha gati jäniha niçcay

Text 32

bräùmaëa kñatriya yärä tädera ki kathä
puëyaväna hay tärä jänibe sarvathä
ataev e anitya saàsäre äsiyä
bhajana karaha mor niçcinte basiyä

Text 33

manmanä madbhakta mor bhajana püjan
ämäke praëäm tumi kara sarvakñaë
matpara haye tumi nija kärya kara
avaçya päibe more jäna ihä kara

Text 34

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 10

Chapter 10
The Opulence of the Absolute

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
äbära bali ye çuna parama vacana
tomära maìgala hetu kahi vivaraëa

Text 1: The Supreme Personality of Godhead said: Listen again, O mighty-armed Arjuna. Because you are My dear friend, for your benefit I shall speak to you further, giving knowledge that is better than what I have already explained.

ämära prabhäva yei keha nähi jäne
suragaë åñigaë kata jane jane
sakaler ädi ämi dev åñi yata
bhaviyä cintiyä tärä ki bujhibe kata

Text 2

ye more anädi jäne loka maheçvara
saccida änanda çreñöha avyaya ajara
marta-loke asaàmüòha yei vyakti hay
ei mätra jäni tär sarva päpa kñay

Text 3

sükñmärtha nirëaya yogya buddhi yähä hay
ätma ye anätma tähä jïänera viñay
satya, dama, çama, kñamä, sukha, duùkha, bhay
abhaya, bhabäbhaba är ahiàsä yä hay
samatädi-tuñöi-yaça a-yaça vä däna
sakala bhütera bhäv yähä kichu äna
ämi tär såñöi-kartä påthaka påthak
buddhimän yevä hay bujhaye nichak

Texts 4-5

marécyädi sapta-åñi cäri sanakädi
caturdaç manu pürva hiraëya-garbhädi
tädera e prajä sab yata loke äche
ämä hate janma sab mänasädi päche

Text 6

ämära svarüpa-jïän çakti va bibhüti
samasta kriyädi yog çreñöha se bhakati
ei sab tattva yärä niçcita jänila
bhakti-yog sädhibäre yogya se haila

Text 7

präkåtäpräkåt sab ämä hate hay
buddhimän vyakti jäni ämäke bhajay
ämär ye bhäv tähä bhaktira lakñaë
apaëòit nähi jäne jäne paëòitagaë

Text 8

ämär ananya-bhakta maccitta mat-präë
paraspara bujhe paòe änande magan
ämära se-kathä nitya baliyä çuniyä
toñaë ramaë kare bhaktite majiyä

Text 9

sei nitya-yukta yärä bhajane kuçal
prétira sahit tärä dhare bhakti-bal
ämi di-i bhakti-yog tädera antare
ämära parama dhäm tärä läbh kare

Text 10

sei se ananya-bhakta nahe ta ajïäné
ämi tär hådayete jïän-dvép äni
andhakära tamonäça kari se açani
jïäna-dvép jväläiyä kari täre jïäné

Text 11

arjun kahilen:
parama brahma parama dhäma pavitra param
tumi kåñëa hao nitya ei mora jïän
çäçvata puruñ tumi aja, ädi bibhu
apräkåta deha taba sakalera prabhu
devarñi närada är jata åñi äche
asita-devala vyäs sei gähiyäche
tomära ei çré-mürti ohe bhagavän
nä jäne devatä kimbä yärä dänavän

Texts 12-13

he keçava tomära e géta väëé yata
sarva satya mäni ämi se veda-sammata
tomära mahimä tumi jäna bhäla mate
ananta päre nä gähite ananta jihväte

Text 14

he puruñottama, tumi jäna tomära tomäke
bhüta-bhävana bhüteça deva-deva jagat-pate
tomära bibhüti yog divya se açeñ
yadi kåpä kari bala bistäri viçeñ

Text 15

ye ye bihüti bale bhuvana caturdaç
vyäpiyä rayecha tumi sarvatra se yaç
kibhäve kariyä cintä tomära mahimä
he yogé tomäke jäni tähä se kahibä

Text 16

kibhäve bujhiva ämi tomära se baibhav
kåpä kari tumi more kaha se bhäv

Text 17

he janärdan tomära yoga vä bibhüti
bistära çunite mana hayeche se ati
punaù punaù bala yadi tabu tåpta nay
amåta tomära kathä måtattva nä kñay

Text 18

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
he arjun bali çuna bibhüti ämär
yähära nähika anta ananta apär
pradhänata bali kichu çuna man diyä
kuru-çreñöha nija sreñöha bujha se çuniyä

Text 19

sarva-bhüta äçraya se ämi guòäkeç
ämi ädi ämi madhya ämi se-i çeñ

Text 20

aditya-gaëera viñëu jyotiñe se sürya
maréci marut-gaëe çaçé täräcarya

Text 21

ved-madhye säm-ved devgaëe indra
indriya-gaëera man cetanär kendra

Text 22

rudradera madhye çiv yakñera kuver
pävaka se vasu-madhye parvate sumer

Text 23

purohita-gaëa madhye hai båhañpati
senänéra madhye skanda sägara jaleti

Text 24

maharçi-gaëera madhye bhågu ämi hai
oàkära praëava ämi ekäkñara sei
yajïa yata hay tära madhye ämi jap
acalete himälaya sthävara ye sab

Text 25

sarva våkña madhye hai açvattha viçäl
devarñira madhye näm närada ämär
gandharvera citra-rath siddhera kapil
muni-gaìer madhye se sarvata jaöil

Text 26

açvadera madhye hai uccaiùçravä näm
samudra manthane se hay mor dhäm
gajendra-gaëera madhye airävata hai
samräöa-gaëera madhye manuñyete sei

Text 27

astrera madhyete vajra dhenu kämadhenu
utpattira kandarpa hai kämtanu
sarpa-gaëer madhyete ämi se väsuki
ananta se näga-gaëe varuëa yädasi
pitådeva madhye ämi hai se aryamä
yamaraja ämi sei madhyete saàyamä

Texts 28-29

daityadera prahläda se bhaktira pipäsé
vaçédera madhye ämi käl mahä-vaçé
mågadera madhye siàha ämi haye thäki
pakñédera madhye ämi garuòa se pakñe

Text 30

vegaväna madhye ämé hai se pavan
çastradhäré madhye se ämi paraçuräm
jalacara madhye ämi hayechi makar
jahnavé ämära näm madhye nadévar

Text 31

yata såñöa vastu tär ädi madhya anta
he arjun dekha mor aiçvarya ananta
yata vidyä hay tär madhye ätma-jïän
ämi se siddhänta madhye yata bädégaë

Text 32

akñarera madhye ämi 'a'-kära se hai
samäsera dvandva ämi kintu dvandva nai
srañöä-gaëe ämi brahma dhvaàse mahäkäla
rudra näma dhari ämi saàhäri viçäla

Text 33

haraëera madhye ämi måtyu sarva-hara
bhaviñya ye haya ämi udbhava äkara
näréder madhye ämi çré väëé småti
kérti, medhä, kñamä mürti athavä se dhåti

Text 34

säm ved madhye ämi båhata se säm
chanda yata tär madhye gäyatré se näm
mäs-gaëe ämi hai se agrahäyaë
vasanta näma mora madhye åtugaë

Text 35

vaïcanär madhye ämi hai dyüta kréòa
tejasvé-gaëera madhye ämi tejavérä
udyamera madhye hai ämi se vijay
tära madhye çreñöha ämi hai vyavasäya
balavän madhye ämi haye thäki bal
ämära bibhüti ei bujhaha sakal

Text 36

våñëider madhye ämi väsudev hai
päëòaver madhye ämi jäna dhanaïjay
munidera madhye vyäsa kavi çukräcärya
sakalera madhye çreñöha ämi sei ärya

Text 37

çäsana-kartära sei ämi hai daëòa
nyäyädhéçgaëa madhye ämi se nyäyya
gupta ye viñaya haya tära madhye mouna
jïäné-der ämi jïän är sab gauëa

Text 38

çarva-bhüta praväha véja ämi se arjun
ämi vinä caräcar sakala aguë

Text 39

ämära bibhüti divya nähi tär anta
saàkñepe balinu sab çuna he tapanta

Text 40

yekhäne bibhüti sattä aiçvaryädi bal
se saba ämära kåpä jänibe sakal
ämära tejäàsa dvärä hay se sambhav
sekhäne ämära sattä kara anubhava

Text 41

adhika ki bali arjun saàkñepe çuna
ämi se praviñöa hai sarvaçakti guëa
jagate sarvatra thäki ämära ekäàçe
satyavat jaòa mäyä täi se prakäçe

Text 42

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 11

Chapter 11
The Universal Form

arjun kahilen:
anugraha kari more çunäile yähä
moha nañöa haiyäche çuni tattva tähä
sei se adhyätma tattva ati guhyatama
bigata sandeha hala yata chila mama

Text 1

dui tattva çuniläm kamala paträkña
såñöi, sthiti, lay är nitya tattva
ei såñöi madhye yathä tumi he parameçvar
nija rüpa prakaöiyä prakäça bistar

Text 2

puruñottama se yadi dekhäo ämäke
icchä mor dekhibär yadi çakti thäke

Text 3

ataev tumi yadi yogya mane kara
dekhibäre viçvarüp tomära bistara
yogeçvara tähä tümi dekhäo ämäre
nivedan ei mor kahinu tomäre

Text 4

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
he pärtha ämära rüp sahasra se çata
ei dekha nänä-vidha divya bhäla mata
aneka äkåti varëa karaha pratyakña
sakala ämära sei hay yogaiçvärya

Text 5

adityädi vasu rudra açviné maruta
adåñöa apürba sab äçcarya bhärata

Text 6

caräcara viçvarüpa ämära bhitar
dekha äj ekasthäne sab paräpar
guòäkeç ämi kåñëa parätpara tattva
dekha tumi bhäla kari ämära mahattva

Text 7

tumi çuddha bhakta mor nahe präkåta darçan
ataev divya cakñu kari tomäre arpaë
divya cakñu sopädhik kintu sthüla nahe
aparokña anubhüti sakale se kahe

Text 8

saïjay kahilen:
ataùpar çuna räjä yogeçvara hari
pärthake aiçvarya-rüp dekhäla çré-hari

Text 9

aneka nayana vajra adbhuta darçana
aneka se astra är divya ävaraëa
divya mälä gandha är candana lepana
sab-iäçcarya rüp viçvera såjana

Texts 10-11

yadi sürya dine uöhe sahasra sahasra
ekatre kiraëa bujha ananta ajasra
tähä hale kichu tär aàça anumän
anyathä se divya tej naheta pramäë

Text 12

arjun dekhila tabe kåñëera çarére
ekatre se abasthän ananta viçver
ek ek se bibhakta yathä-sthän
sei tej jyoti madhye bidhira bidhän

Text 13

dhanaïjay håñöaräm dekhiyä vismita
çirasä praëäm kare kåtaïjalipuöe
kahite lägila sei sambhrama-sahita
devatär käche yathä yäce nija hita

Text 14

arjun kahilen:
he dev çarére taba, dekhitechi ye vaibhava,
nahe väkya manera gocara
sakala bhütera saàgda, se ek viçäl raìga,
ekatrita saba caräcara
brahma ye kamaläsana sakala uraga-gaëa
antaryämé-bhagaväna éça
yata åñi-gaë hay, keha sethä bäké nay,
divi dev yata jagadéça

Text 15

aneka vähu udar, aneka nayana vaktra,
dekhitechi ananta se rüpa
ädi anta nähi tär, viçveçvara ye apär,
adbhüta ye dekhi viçvarüpa

Text 16

kiréöa ye cakra gadä, räçi räçi tejaprada,
déptamän dekhitechi saba
dekhite durüha sei, pradépta ujjvala yei,
dépta agni sürya dyuti sama

Text 17

tumi ye akñara tattva, bujhibär yogya tathya,
e viçvera parama äçraya
sanätana dharmarakña, sanätana puruñäkhya,
tumi hao ananta avyaya

Text 18

tava ädi anta näi, madhyera ki kathä täi,
tumi hao se ananta vérya
tomära vähu mahän, candra-sürya netravän,
tomära hutäça dépta vaktra
nija teja räçi dvärä, tapta kara viçva särä,
vyäpta tomära sarvatra teja
påthivé vä antarékñe, vähire bhitare madhye,
yata dig-digantera deça
dekhiyä tomär rüp, mahäna ye viçvarüp,
yähä hay adbhuta darçana
hayeche dekhiyä bhéta, tribhuvane ye vyathita,
sab loka çuna mahätmana

Text 19

Text 20

ai ye yata deva-gaë, laiteche ye çaraë,
keha vä hayeche bhéta mane
stav kare joò häte, maharñira se santati,
svasti-väd sakale bäkhäne

Text 21

rudra är ye äditya, vasu är yata sädhya,
açviné kumära viçvadeva
maruta vä pitålok, gandharva vä siddhalok,
dekhite äsiyäche se saba

Text 22

tomära mahäna rüpa, bahu netra bahu mukha,
bahu päda üru mahäväho
bahu udara danta, karäla nähika anta,
dekhiyä manete bhayäbaha

Text 23

äkäçe öhekeche mäthä, jhule yena agni-mäkhä,
vahu varëa hayeche vistära
vyäptänana dépta netra, jhalasiyä se sarvatra,
dhairyacyuti kareche ämära

Text 24

karäla dìätera päöi, mukhe tava äöisäöi,
kälänala jveleche yemana
dika-bhrama saba karma, bujhi nä ämära çarma,
rakñä kara ohe bhagavän

Text 25

dhåtaräsöra putra yata, tärä saba avirata,
saìge laye yata dik-päl
bhéñma droëa är karëa, ämädera yata sainya,
piñöa tava dantete karäl
sabäi praveça kare, bhayänaka danta stare,
cürëa haye thäke se lägiyä
bhävi se dekhiyä mane, nadé srota dhävamäne,
gela bujhi samudre miçiyä
yata nara lokavér, jvale gela hala sthir,
tomära mukhera ye gahvare
yemana pataìga jvale, agnite praveça käle,
dhvaàsa hay nijera vegete
tumi'ta karicha gräs, yata loka itihäs,
jvalita tomära ei mukhe
se tejete bhäsamän, jagatera nähi träë,
he viñëu sabäi mare duùkhe

Texts 26-27

Text 28

Text 29

Text 30

kåpä kari bala more, kevä tumi ugra-ghore
praëami prasäda tumi prabhu
ki käraëa e adbhuta, dhariyächa viçvarüpa,
dekhi näi bujhi näi kabhu
kivä se pravåtti taba, jijïäsi tomäre saba
icchä haya jänibär tare
yadi kåpä taba hay, vivaraëa se niçcay,
kåpä kari kaha prabhu more

Text 30

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
mahäkäl ämi sei, pravåddha icchäy hai,
yata lok gräs karibäre
pravåtta hayechi ämi, ämi sei antaryämé,
loka-kñay antare antare

Text 31

ataev yära hethä, yuddha lägi samavetä,
tumi vinä sakale maribe
yata yoddhä äsiyäche, sammukhe dìäòäiyäche,
keha nähi jévita se rabe
ataev kara yuddha, yaça-läbh habe çuddha,
çatru jini sukhe räjya kara
ämi sei prathamete, märiyä rekhechi ete
nimittamätra se tumi yuddha kara

Text 32

droë är bhéñma karëa, jayadratha tathä anya,
yata yoddhä vér äsiyäche
mariyäche jäna tära, ämära icchära dvärä
kivä duùkha karibära äche

Text 33

saïjay kahilen:
arjun çuniyä tähä, kåtäïjalipuöe ihä,
kampita çarér punaù punaù
namaskär kare bhüme, bhaya-bhéta sasambhrame,
ye kahila bali tähä çuna

Text 34

arjun kahilen:
taba kérti håñikeça, çuniyäche ye açeña,
jagatera yevä yethä äche
änandita haye tärä, anugata hay yärä,
pägala haiyä dhäya päche
räkñasädi bhaye bhéta, yadi cähe nija hita,
paläya se dig-digantare
yärä haya siddhajana, sadä praëamita mana,
yukta hay se kärya tädere

Text 35-36

kena nä he mahätmana, nähi labe se çaraëa,
tumi hao sarva garéyasé
brahmära ädi kartä, tumi hao tär bhartä,
taba kérti ati mahéyasé
he ananta deva éça, tumi hao jagadéça,
sadasad pare ye akñara
tumi hao sei tattva, ke bujhibe se mahattva,
naha tumi bhoutika vä jaòa

Text 37

tumi ädi deva hao sakalera sädhya nao
puräëa puruña sabä hate
jagatera yähä kichu sambhava hayeche pichu
sthira ei jagata tomäte
tumi jäna sab prabhu sanätana tumi bibhu
tumi hao parama nidhäna
e viçva tomära dvärä vyäpta hayeche särä
ananta se tomära bidhäna

Text 38

väyu yama bahni candra sakalera tumi kendra
varuëa ye tumi hao saba
tumi hao prajäpati prapitämaha se ati
yähä hay tomära baibhava
sahasra se namaskär kari prabhu bär bär
tomära caraëe ämi dhari
punaù punaù namaskär bhüya bhüya bär bär
kåpä dåñöi kara he çré-hari

Text 39

sammukhe paçcäte taba sarvato praëäme raba
namaskära taba pädapadme
antaryämé urukrama tumi vinä saba bhrama
prakäçita tumi nija chande

Text 40

mäniyä tomäke sakhä pragalabha karechi våthä
he kåñëa he yädav kata balechi
nä jäni ei mahimä äçcarya se nähi sémä
sämänyata tomäke bhebechi
parihäs kari sakhä asatkära yathä-tathä
se pramäda yä kichu balechi
vihära çayyä äsane parokña bä sämne
kñama aparädh yä karechi

Texts 41-42

yata loka caräcar tumi péta se sabär
tumi pujya guru se pradhäna
samäna adhik taba anya keha asambhaba
apratima tomära prabhäba

Text 43

daëòavata namaskär kari ämi bär bär
he éça, he püjya jagate sabär
kåpä taba bhikñä cäi anyathä se gati näi
pitä putre yathä vyavahära
athavä sakhär säthe priya är ye priyäte
doñ kñamä hay se sarvadä
he deveça jagannäth se samåddha mor säth
tuñöa hao tathä he bhürédä

Text 44

Text 45

caturbhuja ye svarüp dekhibäre ye icchuk
saìkha cakra gadä padma-dhäré
ye viñëu svarüp hate viçvarüpa e viçvete
hao se sahasra vähudhäré

Text 46

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
tomära prasanna lägi he arjun ämi yogé
ei jaòa viçvarüpa dekha
ämära yoga prabhäve tähä sei sasambhave
asambhav nähi yär lekha
sei tejomaya vapu nä dekhila keha kabhu
tomära sei prathama darçan
veda yajïa kimbä dän ati paöu adhyayan
asamartha sesaba varëan
kimbä ugra tapobal kriya-käëòa ye sakal
sädhya näi erüpa darçane
he kuru pravér çuna nä dekhibe tumi bhinna
ämära ye rüpa tribhuvane

Text 47

Text 48

diba nä tomäke vyathä bibhrama hayeche yathä
dekhi mor ei ghora rüp
chäòa bhaya préta hao punaù çänti präpta hao
dekha mor ye nitya svarüp

Text 49

saïjay kahilen:
se kathä baliyä hari arjunke lakñya kari
väsudev bhagavän punaù
nija caturbhuja rüp dekhäicha aparüp
pürëa brahma apräkåta guëa
tärpar nityarüp çré-kåñëera yei rüp
dvibhuja mürati ävirbhäva
punarvära hala souma svarüper ye mähätmya
äçväsane phirila svabhäva

Text 50

arjun kahilen:
dekhiyä tomär ei manuñya svarüp
he janärdan peyechi phiri mor rüp
saàvåtta hayechi ämi sacetä prakåti
idanéà se citta sthira sväbhäbika gati

Text 51

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
ämära dvibhuja rüp durlabha darçan
tumi yä hericha äj haye ekman
brahmä çiv ädi dev se äkäìkñä kare
çuddha bhakta hay yärä bujhibäre päre

Text 52

ved niñöhä jap tap kimbä dän puëya
püjä-päöh yata kichu dharma-patha anya
konaöäi nahe yogya e rüpa dekhite
yadyapi se avatérëa ämi påthivéte

Text 53

ananya-bhakti ye hay ekmätra käm
he arjun dekhibäre yogya mor dhäm
sei se bujhite päre tattve dekhibäre
nitya léläte mor se praveç kare

Text 54

ämära santoña lägi kara saba karma
nitya yukta mor bhakta se parama dharma
tär kona çatru näi sarva-bhüta mäjhe
sei mor çuddha bhakta thäke mor käche

Text 55

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 12

Chapter 12
Devotional Service

arjun kahilen:
ye çüddha bhakta ye kåñëa tomäte satata
ananya bhaktira dvärä haye thäke yukta
är ye avyaktavädé avyakta akñare
niñkäma karam kari sadä cintä kare
tär madhye kevä uttam yogavit haya
jänibär icchä mor karaha niçcay

Text 1

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
ämära çvarüpa ei yära mana sadä
äviñöa haiyä thäke upäsanä hådä
çraddhär sahit kare präëa bhaktimay
uttama yogéra çreñöha kahinu niçcay

Text 2

akñara avyakta-sakta nirdiñöa-bhäv
indriya saàyam kari hitaiñé svabhäv
sarva-vyäpé acintya ye küöastha acal
dhruva nirviçeñ sattve thäkiyä aöal
samabuddhi haye sab kare upäsanä
se ämäke präpta hay kariyä sädhanä

Texts 3-4

kintu ei-mätra bhed jäna ubhayera madhye
bhakta päy ati çighra är kañöe siddhe
avyakta äsakta sei vahu kleç tär
avyakta ye gati duùkha dehéra apär

Text 5

ye ämär sambandhete sab karma kare
ämära svarüpa ei nitya dhyäna kare
jévana ye more sìapi ämäte äsakta
ananya ye bhäv bhakti tähe anurakta
se bhaktake måtyu-rüp e saàsära hate
uddhär kariba çéghra jäna bhäla mate

Texts 6-7

ataev tumi ei dvibhuja svarüpe
eman buddhi sthira kara bhagavat svarüpe
ämära e nityarüpe nitya-yukta hale
avaçya päibe prem sarva-çreñöha phale
ürdhva-gati sei jäna nä kara saàçay
sarvocca phal tähä kahinu niçcay

Text 8

yadi se sahaj bhäve hao asamartha
abhyäsa yogete kara läbh paramärtha
vidhi-märge räg-märge yevä more cäy
acirät se abhyäse loka more päy

Text 9

abhyäseo asamartha yadi tumi hao
ämära lägiyä karme sadäyukta rao
ämära santoña janya yevä kärya hay
jänio sesab more präptira upäy

Text 10

tähäteo yadi taba çaktira abhäv
bhakti-yog äçrayete viruddha svabhäv
tabe se vaidika karma tyaji karmaphal
avaçya sädhive tumi yatnete prabal

Text 11

bhakti-yoge asamartha yevä abhyäs-ibhäla
tähäte ye asamartha jïänete suphala
tähäteo asamartha ätma-cintä çreya
tähäteo asamartha karma-yoga çreya
kämya karme sukh näi tyäg-iuttam
tyäg-içäntira mül täte nähi bhram

Text 12

ämära ye bhakta sarva-guëera ädhär
sakalera mitra hay hiàsä nähi tär
bhakta nahe hiàsär pätra bhakta se karuë
jévera durdaçä heri sadä duùkhé man
dehe ätma-buddhi bhram bhaktera se näi
nirmamonirahaìkära duùkhera bäläi
sarvata santuñöa yogé se dåòha niçcay
yatnaçél nija kärye ämäte vilay
tär kärya man präë ämäte niyukta
ämära se priya bhakta sarbadäi mukta

Texts 13-14

tär dvärä kona lok duùkha nähi päy
kähäkeo mane präëe duùkha nähi dyäy
harñämarña-bhayodveg e-sabe se mukta
ataev mora bhakta ati priya-yukta

Text 15

lok vyavahäre bhakta sadä nirapekña
udäsén gata-vyatha çuci är dakña
çuci hay mor bhakta brahma se svabhäve
jäti buddhi nähi kara bhakta se vaiñëave

Text 16

jaòa kärye haåña duùkha ye janera näi
tyajiyäche ye äkäìkhä cintä yär näi
çubhä-çubha parityägé yevä bhaktimän
ämära se priya bhakta tähäke sammän

Text 17

çatru mitra apamän kiàbä nija män
jaòamukta mor bhakta mänaye samän
çét, gréñma, sukh, duùkha ek yevä mäne
saìgamukta sei bhakta sthita ätma-jïäne
tulya nindä stuti är santuñöa gambhér
niketana tär näi mati tär sthir
sei mor priya bhakta sei bhaktimän
bhaktera lakñaëa yata karinu vyäkhyän

Texts 18-19

ei süddha bhakti yevä karibe sädhanä
amåta se dharma jäna jaòa vilakñaëä
tähäte ye çraddhä-yukta anuküla präë
atyanta se priya bhakta ämära samän

Text 20

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 13

Chapter 13
Nature, the Enjoyer, and Consciousness

arjun kahilen:
prakåtir är puruña kñetra ye ksetrajïa
jänibär icchä mor ämi nahi vijïa
seirüp jïän är vijïäna ki hay
keçava ämäke kaha kariyä niçcay

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
he kaunteya! e çaréra kñetra näm tär
ihära ye jïätä sei kñetrajïa vicär

Texts 1-2

ämio kñetrajïa bujha sakala çarére
he bhärata, antaryämé kahe se ämäre
sei kñetra är kñetrajïer yevä jïän
ämära vicäre hay sei çuddha jïän

Text 3

sei kñetra är kñetrajïera vicär
ki tär svarüp kimbä ki tär vicär
ki tär prabhäva kimbä kothä hate hay
çuna tumi kahi ämi kariyä niçcay

Text 4

därçanik åñi kata kareche vicär
småti chande kata vale nähi tär pär
kintu vedänta väkye yuktira sahita
ye vicär kariyäche lägi lokahita
sei se vicär jäna susiddhänta mat
sakalera grahaëéya chäòi anya path

Text 5

kñiti, ap, tej, väyu, vyom mahäbhüta
ahaìkär, buddhi är man avyakta sambhüta
cakñu, karëa, näsikä, jihvä, tvak yähä jäni
päyu, päd, peö, liìga är yähä päëi
sei daç vähya-är man se antare
ekädaç indriya se çästrera vicäre
rüp, ras, gandha, çavda, sparça ye viñay
cavviça se tattva bujha kñetra paricay
ihädera ye vicär kare viçleñaëe
kñetra-tattva sei vijïa bhäla-rüpa jäne
icchä, dveñ, sukh, duùkha är ye saìghät
sthül deha parimäë païca mahä-bhüta
cetanä çakti ye hay jévera ädhär
tär saìge dhåti jäna kñetrera vikär
ataev ei sab ekatre se kñetra
sthüla sükñma jaòa vidyä sei ye sarvatra

Texts 6-7

amänitva, adämbhitva, ahiàsä ye kñänti
saralatä, guru-sevä, çouca, dhairya, çänti
äömära nigraha yähä indriya viñaye
vairägya nirahaàkär sakala äçaye
janma, måtyu, jarä, vyädhi duùkhera darçan
anäsakti stré putrete gåhera präëgaë
udäsén pariväre sukhete duùkhete
nitya samacitta iñöa aniñöa madhyete
ämäte ananya-bhakti avyabhicäriëé
nirjana sthänete väs grämya niväraëé
adhyätma jïänera kare nityatva svékär
tattva-jïän lägi kare darçana vicär
sei se jïänera carcä vikäre näç
ajïänatamera näm anyathä prakäç

Texts 8-12

jïänera jïätavya yähä tähä bali çuna
jänile se tattva habe amåtera pän
sei brahma-tattva-jïän ämära äçrita
anädi se sat är asat atéta

Text 13

sarva-sthäne hasta-pada nahe niräkär
sarva-sthäne cakñu çir kata mukh tär
sarvatra çravaëa sarva ävaraëa sthän
tini chäòä tribhuvane nähi kichu äna

Text 14

tìähä hate indriyädi hayeche prakäç
jaòendriya nähi tär sarva-guëäbhäs
anäsakta sarva-bhüt tini se nirguë
sakala guëera bhoktä tini cirantan

Text 15

sakala bhütera tini antare vähire
tìähä hate hay sab cara vä acar
ati sükñma tattva täi avijïeya
yugapat bahu düre nikaöeteo hay

Text 16

avibhakta hai-yäo vibhaktera mata
akhaëòa samañöi tini vyañöi-rüpe sthita
sarva-bhüta bhartä tini saba janmadätä
tini-i sabär punaù saàhärera kartä

Text 17

samasta jyotira tini parama ädhär
cinmaya tìähär jyoti jaòa para är
jïänamaya rüpa täìr jïänagamya jïeya
sakalera hådi-mäjhe tini adhiñöheya

Text 18

ei kahinu tattva kñetra jïän jïeya
vijïäna tähära näm paëòitera priya
e vijïän bujhiyä se mor bhakta hay
tattva çuddhi jïäna hay bhaktira äçray

Text 19

prakåta puruña hay anädi se siddha
anädi käla hate ubhaya saàvåddha
vikärädi guëa yata präkåta sambhava
präkåta puruña yei tär anubhava

Text 20

kärya vä käraëa hay prakåtira dän
bhogera käraëa sei puruñei han

Text 21

präkåta haiyä jév bhuïje sei guë
prakåtira guëa sab prakåtira dän
präkåta guëera saìga ucca-néca yoni
sadasad janma hay anya nähi gaëi

Text 22

se jévera baddha rüpe paramätmä saìge
upadeñöä anumantä han tini raìge
maheçvara tini bhoktä puruñe parama
jévera uddhära lägi tini saìge han

Text 23

sei se jïänera dvärä puruña prakåti
puruñera ye präkåta guëera svékåti
ye bujhila vartamän haiyä sarvathä
punarjanma nähi tär nahe se anyathä

Text 24

bhakta-gaë cidäçraye sadä dhyäne rata
prema-cakñe paramätmäke darñana satata
säàkhya-yogé jïäna dvärä älocanä kare
karma-yogé bhagaväne karmärpaëa kare

Text 25

anya sädhäraë lok bujhe nä se kichu
çravaëäntar upäsanä tärä kare kichu
täräo tvariyä yäy e saàsär hate
yadi çruti-paräyaëa sädhura saìgete

Text 26

sthävara jaìgama yata janmeche janmäbe
kñetra kñetrajïera saàyoga prabhäve

Text 27

se saba bhütete samasthita bhagavän
darñana karite päre kona bhägyavän
bhagavän avinaçyat vastu tähära bhitare
vinaçyat dharma tini svékära nä kare

Text 28

sakaler madhye sama thakena éçvar
dekhite samartha hay yei tatpar
ye ätmäke adhaùpät kabhu nähi kare
kupathagämé se duñöa mana dväre

Text 29

prakåti-pradatta deha indriyädi dvärä
prakåti-i sädhe karma jévera se särä
kintu ätma-tattva jév kichu nähi kare
jìähära darçana sei se dekhite päre

Text 30

präkåtik vaicitrye yevä ekatva darçane
sarva-bhütera påthak bhäv samartha se mane
såñöi sthiti vistär sei yevä jäne
samartha se jan dåñöi brahma sampädane

Text 31

brahma-jïäné jév nitya parama avyay
nirguëa anädi tattva nirlipta se ray

Text 32

yemana sarvagata vyom, sukñma tattva anupam,
sarvatra sambhav vicaraë
tathäpi se lipta nahe, nijera svatantra rahe,
sei-rüp ätma vicaraë
sarvatra vyäpiyä dehe, küöastha påthaka rahe,
mahäbhüte nahe se milan
tathä brahma-bhüta jév, ätma-tattva haye çiv,
deha-dharme lipta nähi han

Text 33

surya yathä prakäçaye akhila jagat
ek deçe ekä thäki samräöa mahat
he bhärat sei-rüp kñetré prakäçay
ekä eksthäne thäki kñetra deha-may

Text 34

kñetra är kñetrajïer tattva-jïän cakñe
dekhibär çakti hay se yähär pakñe
ek kñetrajïa se jév anya paramätmä
ubhayer kñetre väs kñetra viçeñätmä
tär mokña jaòa-niñöha pravåtti haite
sukhe väs para-vyome jaòa deha ante

Text 35

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 14

Chapter 14
The Three Modes of Material Nature

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
äbära parama jïäna baliba tomäre
jïäna-carcä yata äche uttama sabäre
ye jïänete muni jïäné haiyä sarvata
pürva itihäs chila siddhi päraìgata

Text 1

ei jïäna läbha kari nirguëa jïänete
avasthita hay loka nirguëa ämäte
tähär nä hay janma punaù såñöira samay
kimbä duùkha näi tär yakhana pralay

Text 2

jagater mätå-yoni jaòä mahat-tattva
sei brahme garbhädhän kari se mahattva
he bhärat täi janme sarva-bhüta yata
jagater bhüta såñöi hay sei mata

Text 3

ataev sarva-yoni yata mürti dhare
he kounteya jäna tähä ämära ädhäre
brahma mahat-tattva hay sabära janané
ämi véja-prada pitä jagata saraëé

Text 4

sattva, raj, tama guë prakåti-sambhava
triguëete vaddha jév haye yäy saba
ei deha se vandhana niguòha äkär
jéva avyaya se vaddha ye prakär

Text 5

tär madhye sattva-guë nirmala ädhä
päpa-çunya prakäçaka tattva se ätmär
jïäna-carcä kari sattve bandhana tähär
sei çuddha saìga mäne çreñöha camatkär

Text 6

rajo-guë tåñëä-may çudhu bhog cäy
äjévan karma kari kare häy häy
karma kare yata päre baddha tähe hay
asambhava karma ceñöä sukhe duùkhe ray

Text 7

tamo se ajïäna-rüpa nigüòha bandhan
påamäda älasya nidrä tähära mohan

Text 8

sattva-guëa sukhe bìädhe rajo-guëa käje
tamo-guëa pramädete bandhane viräje

Text 9

rajo-guëa paräjaye sattvera prädhänya
sattva-tama paräjaye raja hay gaëya
raj sattva paräjaye tamera prädhänya
sei se paryäya hay guëera sämäëya

Text 10

jïänera prabhäve yadä çarére prakäç
sakal indriya-dväre sattva-guëera vikäç

Text 11

lok-püjä pratiñöhädi karmera äkäìkñä
rajo-guëe våddhi hay nähi anyäpekñä

Text 12

aprakäç apravåtti moha tamor lakñaë
vividha guëera kärya he kuru-nandan

Text 13

pravåddha ye sattva-guëe dehera pralay
niñpäpa uttama lok täìr präpti hay

Text 14

pravåtta se rajo-guëe dehera nirväë
karméra saìgete hay tär anuñöhän
pravåddha ye tamo-guëe çaréra chäòay
müòha paçu-yoni madhye tär janma hay

Text 15

sukåta sättvika karma phala se nirmal
räjasika karme hay duùkhai praval
tämasika karma yata hay acetan
ajïänatä phal sei paçute gaëan

Text 16

sattva-guëe jïäna-läbha rajo-guëe lobh
tamo-guëe moha läbh pramäda vikñobh

Text 17

satyalokävadhi lok yäy sattva-guëe
rajo-guë dvärä naraloke avasthän
tamo-guëe adhaùpät narake gaman
vividha guëera sei phal nirüpaë

Text 18

guë bhinna anya kartä nähi tribhuvane
sükñma darçana yär guëa nirüpaëe
guëätéta mor bhakti ämära se bhäv
svarüpete çuddha jév präpta se svabhäv

Text 19

guëätéta hate dehé guëadeha chäòe
janma-måtyu jarä-duùkha bìädhe nä tìähäre

Text 20

arjun kahilen:
ki lakñaë kaha prabho gunätéta hale
äcaraë kivä hay triguëa jitile

Text 21

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
prakäça pravrtti är mohana ye tin
guëera prabhäv sei hay bhinna bhin
tähäte ye dveñäkäìkñä chäòila jévane
guëätét hay sei bujha tribhuvane
guëa-kärye udäsén mato ye äsén
bicalita nahe tähe pravåddha pravéë
anäsakta guëa kärye yevä hay dhér
sama duùkha sukha svasthaù loñöra svarëa sthir
tulya priyä-priya tär tulya nindästuti
tulya män apamän çatru mitra ati
bhog tyägädite nahe se äsakta
guëätét hay sei nirguëete yukta

Texts 22-25

triguëer atikrame ye kärya karay
sei se ämära bhakti jänaha niçcay
ye avyabhicäré bhakti ämäte karay
jaòa guë atikrame brahma-bhüta hay

Text 26

brahmera pratiñöhä ämi amåta çäçvata
änanda ye sanätana ämäte nihita
ämär äçraye sei sakala sulabha
ataev-mor bhakti hay sudurlabha

Text 27

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 15

Chapter 15
The Yoga of the Supreme Person

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
vedaväëé karmakäëòé saàsära äçraye
nänä yoni präpta hay kabhu mukta nay
saàsära ye våkña sei açvattha avyay
ürdhvamüla adhaù-çäkhä nähi tär kñay
puñpita vedera chanda se brahmera patra
mohita se veda-väkya jagata sarvatra

Text 1

våkñera se çäkhäli ürdhva adhaù-gati
guëera vaçete yär yathä vidhi-mati
se våkñera çäkhä yata viñayera bhog
nija karma anusäre yata bhava-rog
baddha-jéva ghure sei våkña òäle òäle
manuñya-loka se bhuïje nija karmaphale

Text 2

kñudra-buddhi manuñya se sémä nähi päy
ananta äkäçe tär ädi anta nay
kivä rüpa se våkñera tähä nähi bujhe
ananta kälera madhye jév yuddha yujhe
se açvattha våkña hay sudåòha ye mül
se mül käöite hay çata çata bhul
anäsakti ek astra se mül käöite
sei se ye dåòha astra saàsära jinite
käöiyä se våkña-mül satyera sandhän
bhägya-krame yär hay täte avasthän
se yäy vaikuëöha-loke phire nähi äse
e våkñera mül yathä se puruña päçe
se ädi puruñe adya kara ye prapatti
janmädi se yähä hate prakåti pravåtti

Texts 3-4

nirabhimän nirmoha saìgadoñe mukta
nityänitya buddhi yär kämanä nivåtta
sukha duùkha dvandva mukta jaòa müòha nay
vidhijïa puruña päy se pada avyay

Text 5

se äkäçe jyotirmaye sürya vä çaçäìka
ävaçyak nähi tathä kimbä se pävaka
sekhäne praveç hale phire nähi äse
nitya-käl mor dhäme se jana niväse

Text 6

yata jév mor aàça nahe se apar
sanätan tär sattä jévaloke ghor
ekhäne se man är indriya-vandhane
karñaëa karaye kata prakåtir sthäne

Text 7

bär bär kata deha se ye präpta hay
ek deha chäòe är anye praveçay
väyu gandha yathä yäy sthän sthänäntare
karma-phal sükñma sei deha dehäntare

Text 8

çarérera anusär çravaëa darçan
sparçana, rasana är ghräë vä manan
se çarére jéva kare viñay sevan
baddha-jéva kare sei saàsära bhramaë

Text 9

müòhaloka nä vicäre ki bhäve ki hay
utkränti sthiti bhog kär vä kothäy
yär jïäna-cakñu äche gurura kåpäy
bhägyavän sei jan dekhiväre päy

Text 10

kata yogé vaijïänik ceñöä vahu kare
ätmajïän abhävete våthä ghuri mare
kintu yevä ätmajïäné ätmävasthita
dekhite samartha hay çuddha avahita

Text 11

ei ye süryera tej akhila jagate
candrera kiraëa kimbä äche bhäla-mate
ämära prabhäva sei äbhäsa se hay
ämi yäke älo di-i se älo päy

Text 12

ei ye påthivé yathä väyu-madhye bhäse
ämära se çakti dhare savete praveçe
ämi se ouñadhi yata poñaëa karite
candra-rüpe raçmi-dän kari se tähäte

Text 13

ämi vaiçvänara hai dehamätra vasi
präëäpän väyuyoge bhakñya dravya kañi

Text 14

sabära hådaye ämi, sanniviñöa antaryämé,
ämä hate småti jïän man
ämi se jägäi käre, ämi se bhuläi täre,
ämä hate hay apohan
yata veda påthivéte, ämära se talläsete,
ämi hai saba vedavedya
ämi se vedänta-vit, ämi ye vedänta-kåt,
vedäntera kathä çuna adya

Text 15

vaddha mukta puruña se hay dvi-prakär
dui näme paricita se kñara akñar
vaddha jév yata hay tär kñara näm
akñara küöastha jév nitya mukta-dhäm

Text 16

tähä hate ye uttam puruña pradhän
éçvara se paramätmä thäke sarvasthän

Text 17

kñara vä akñara hate ämi se uttam
ataev ghoñita näm puruñottam

Text 18

ye more bujhila çreñöha se puruñottama
sakala sandeha chäòi haila uttama
se jänila sarva veda nirmala håday
he bhärat! sarvabhäve se more bhajay

Text 19

ei se çästrera güòha marma kathä çuna
tumi se niñpäpa hao çuddha tava man
ihä ye bujhila bhägye hala buddhimän
he bhärat! kåta-kåtya se hala mahän

Text 20

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 16

Chapter 16
The Divine and Demoniac Natures

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
abhaya sattva saàsiddhi jïäne avasthän
dän dam yajïa är svädhyäy tapän
saralatä satya är ahiàsä akrodh
tyäg çänti dayä är paranindä rodh
alolupatä mådutä tej acapal
kñamä, dhåti, çouca, vä hré adroha sakal
abhimän çünyatä se chävviça ye guë
sampad se hay tär yär daivéte janam

Texts 1-3

dambha, darpa, abhimän, krodh, niñöhuratä
sampada äsuré hay yathä ajïänatä

Text 4

daivé sampada ye tär muktira käraë
äsuré sampada hay saàsära vandhan
tomära cintära kathä nähi he päëòava
daivé sampade tomär hayechhe janam

Text 5

he bhärat, e jagate dui bhüt såñöi
ek daivé dvitéya se äsuré vä dåñöi
daivé yärä tär kathä anek hayeche
çuna ebe kathä yärä asura janmeche

Text 6

pravåtti nivåtti yähä asura nä jäne
çoucäcär satya mithyä nähi tärä mäne

Text 7

asura ye lok tärä nä mäne éçvar
jagater vidhätä yini asvékära tär
såñöira käraë sei anéçvaravädé
jaòa kärya-käraëa se kämuka vivädé

Text 8

ei kñudra dåñöi laye asurera gaë
ätma-tattva-jïänahén alpa-buddhi han
ugra-karme utsäha tär jagata ahita
kñaya-kärye paöu tärä hay prabhävita

Text 9

duñpüra äçraya käma dambha madänvita
mohagrasta asadagräha açuci-vrata

Text 10

apareya cintä tär yatadina bäìce
käma-mätra upabhog hådayete äche
çata çata äçä-päç çudhu käm krodha
käma-bhoga lägi artha anya se virodha
anyäya se kare nitya saïcayete
citta tär nitya viddha asata käryete

Texts 11-12

adya ei artha-läbh mano-ratha siddhi
punarbär bhaviñyate habe artha våddhi
se çatru marila anya niçcaya märiba
ämi se éçvara dhané se kärya sädhiva
ämi bhogé siddha är balabäna sukhé
mama sama keha nahe är saba duùkhé
ämi abhijanavän ämi dhana-ädhya
ämära samäna habe kär kivä sädhya
ämi se kariba yajïa ämi dän diba
stré-saìga kariyä ämi änanda päiba
ajïäna mohita haye kata kathä bale
mohajäla samävåta kälera kavale
äsalete kämäsakta narakera yätré
açuci narake bäs naraka vidhätå

Texts 13-16

ätma sambhävita män dhanete anamra
madänvita asura se sarvadä vinamra
näma-mätra yajïa kare çästre vidhi näi
dambha-mätra äche sär kevala baòäi

Text 17

ahaàkär, vala, darpa, käm, krodhäçray
ämära samparke dehe dveñ se karay
asüyär vaçe cintä svapara apare
sädhura guëete doñ kimbä nindä kare

Text 18

sei se vidveñé krür narädhama gaëe
nitya se kñepaëa kari saàsära gahane

Text 19

asura yonite hay janama maraë
ajasra açubha tär jévana yäpan
asurera ghare müòha janame janame
ämäke bhuliyä duùkhé marame marame
krame krame päya sei adhamä ye gati
akñama ämäke pete yehetu kumati

Text 20

sei käma, krodh, lobh, narakera dvär
tyaja tähä nay tin sädhu vyavahär

Text 21

ei tine mukta yärä çuna he kaunteya
tamoguëera dvär sei atiçay heya
tabe se äcari dharma nija çreyaskar
parägata läbh kare mama bhakti par

Text 22

çästra vidhi parityäge käma äcaraë
siddhipräpti nahe tähe sukha gatipar

Text 23

ataeva çästra-vidhi käryera pramäë
jäni çästra-vidhi kara kärya samädhäna

Text 24

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 17

Chapter 17
The Divisions of Faith

arjun kahilen:
çästra-vidhi nähi jäne kintu çraddhänvita
yajana karaye yärä kivä tär hita
kivä niñöhä tär kåñëa sattva, rajotam
vistära kaha'ta sei çuni icchä mama

Text 1

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
svabhävaja tin niñöhä çraddhä se dehéra
sättviké, räjasé är tämasé gabhéra
vivaraë kahi tär çuna diyä man
yär yebä çraddhä hay guëera käraë

Text 2

nija sattvä anurüpä çraddhä se bhärata
çraddhämay puruña ye çraddhä ye temata

Text 3

sättviké ye çraddhä sei püje devatäre
räjasé ye çraddhä püje yakña räkñasere
tämasé ye çraddhä tähe bhüt pret püje
yär sei çraddhä hay sei tathä bhaje

Text 4

çästra-bidhi tyäg kari ye tapasyä kare
dambha darpa käm räg yukta ahaìkäre
våthä upaväsa kare kleç sahiväre
çarérete bhütgaëe mürkha karçiväre
ämäkeo antaryämé çaréra bhitare
äsurik jäna sei tär vyavahäre

Texts 5-6

ähära-o trividha se yathäyatha priya
sättviké, räjasé är tämasé ye heya
yajïa, jap, tap, dän se-o se trividha
yär yevä bhed guë bhinna vahuvidha

Text 7

äyu sattva valärogya sukha préti bäòe
rasya snigdha sthir hådya sättvika ähäre
kaöu amla lavaëäkta ati uñëa yei
jvälä poòä ämayé räjasika sei
väsé çaitya gataras pacä vä durgandha
ucchiñöa amedhya yei khädya tamasändha

Text 8-10

aphaläkäìkñé ye yajïa vidhi-mata hay
kartavya ye mane kare sättviké se kay

Text 11

müle abhisandhi yär äkäìkñä phalete
räjasik yajïa hay dambhera sahite

Text 12

vidhi annahéna näi mantra vä dakñiëä
çraddhä-hén yajïa sei tamasä äcchannä

Text 13

dev dvija guru präjïa ye saba püjan
çouca saralatä brahmacaryera pälan
sei sab siddha hay çaréra tapasyä
anudveg-kara väkya kiàbä priya poñya

Text 14

svädhyäya abhyäs yata ved uccäraë
väìmaya tapasyä se çästrera vacan

Text 15

cittera prasannatä ye är saralatä
ätma-nigrahädi mouna bhäva pravaëatä
sei saba mänasika tapa näme khyäta
uparokta saba tapa triguëa prakhyäta

Text 16

trividha tapasyä yadi parä-çraddhä-yukta
phaläkäìkñä yadi nahe sättviké se ukta

Text 17

läbh püjä sammänera janya dambhera sahit
ye tapasyä sädhe loka tähä räjasik
se tapasyära ye phal tähä aniçcit
antavat tära phal haya çästrete vidita

Text 18

müòha-buddhi yärä tape ätma-péòä dey
aparera vinäçärtha ye tapasyä karay
tämasé se saba yata tapasyä vahula
aléka tähära näm nahe çästra anukül

Text 19

kartavya jäniyä yei dänakriy hay
deçakäl pätra bujhi dätavya karay
anupakäréke dän se sättvika hay

Text 20

pratyupakärera janya phalänusandhän
kimbä dän kari hay anutäpavän
räjasik dän sei çästrera vicär
tämasika dän yähä çuna ei vär
adeçakäle ye dän apätrete hay
asatkär avaktä yei tämasika kay

Text 21

Text 22

yajïa dän tapasyädi yähä çästrera nirëay
oà tat sat se uddeçye anya kichu naya
se uddeçye pürva-käle brähmanädigaë
yajïa dän tapa ädi karila pälan

Text 23

sejanya brähmaëagaë 'om' uccäraëe
yajïädi vidhän kare brahma äcaraëe

Text 24

ataeva yajïa dän tapasyära phal
anyäbhiläñ nahe bhaktira käraë
mokñä-käìkñé sejanya yajïa däna kare
sei se yajïädi phal vidita saàsäre

Text 25

sat se çavdera artha brahma brahma-par
se uddeçye yata karma saba brahma-par
yajïa dän tap kärya se uddeçye kare
loukika vaidika karma brahma näm dhare

Texts 26-27

se çraddhä vinä yähä karmakåta hay
asat karma tär näm çästrete nirëay
asat karma çuddha nahe iha parakäle
çästra-vidhi parityäge sei phal phale

Text 28

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.

GG: Chapter 18

Chapter 18
Conclusion—The Perfection of Renunciation

arjun kahilen:
sannyäser tattva kivä icchä se çunite
håñékeç kaha täi more bujhäite
keçi nisüdan kaha tyägera mahimä
çunite änanda hay nähi parsémä

Text 1

çré-bhagavän kahilen:
kämäkarma parityäg sannyäs se hay
sarva karma phala-tyäg tyäg paricay
vicakñaë kari yata karila nirëay
sei se sannyäsa är tyäg näma hay

Text 2

manéñégaë sarva karma tyäg kare
yajïa dän tapa-kriyä nahe, kahaye apare

Text 3

tär madhye ye siddhänta kahi tähä çuna
trividha se tyäg hay bharata-sattama

Text 4

svarüpata yajïa-dän kabhu tyäjya nay
sakala samaye tähä kärya yogya hay
baddha jév äche yata tädera kartavya
manéñé pävana sei yajïa däna kärya

Text 5

se käryer anuñöhän phala-saëga tyäg
kartavyera anurodhe çudhu tähe räg

Text 6

nirdiñöa karmera tyäg nahe se vidhän
mohete se tyäg hay tämasika jïän

Text 7

duùkha hay tär janya karma-tyäga kare
kimbä karma-tyäg kare käya-kleça òare
räjasika tyäg sei phal nähi päy
sei ye kahinu yata çästrera nirëay

Text 8

kartavya jäniyä yevä sarva karma kare
phala-tyäg karibäre sättvika näm dhare

Text 9

karytavera anurodhe akuçala-o kare
äsakti nähi se kuçal karmera tare
medhävé ye tyägé sattva samäviñöa hay
chinna tär haye yäy sakala saàçay

Text 10

dehadhäré jéva karma-tyäg nähi kare
karma-phala tyäg kari tyägé näma dhare

Text 11

aniñöa iñöa vä miçra karmaphala hay
kintu sannyäséra sei kichu bhog nay

Text 12

païca se käraëa hay sakala käryera
mahäväho çuna sei kahi se tomäre
vedänta siddhänta sei çästrera nirëay
bhäla-manda yähä kichu sei se paryäy

Text 13

adhiñöhäna kartä är karaëa påthak
vividha se ceñöä daiva e paìca-çérñak

Text 14

çaréra vacan man karma tat dvärä
nyäyya vä a-nyäyya yata karma särä
sabära käraëa hay sei païca vidha
sakala käryera hay sei se hetava

Text 15

mürkha yärä kartä säje nija man gaòä
nä bujhiyä käraëa se çudhu kartä chäòä

Text 16

ataev ye nä haya ahaìkäre matta
buddhi yär ahaà-bhäve nähi hay lipta
kartavyera anurodhe yadi viçva märe
kähäke-o märe nä se kimbä karma kare

Text 17

karmera preraëä hay jïän, jïeya, jïätä
karmera saàgraha se karaë karma-kartä

Text 18

jïän är kartä hay trividha guë bhede
kahiba se trividha bhed tomäke saàkñepe

Text 19

ek jév ätmä nänä karmaphal bhede
manuñyädi sarva-dehe se vartamän kñede
avyaya se jév hay ek-tattva jïän
bibhinnate ek dekhe sei sättvik jïän

Text 20

vibhinna jévera sei påthakatva dekhe
räjasik tär jïän nänäbhäve thäke

Text 21

dehake sarvasva bujhi ye jïän udbhav
a-tattvajïa alpa-buddhi tämasika sab

Text 22

räg dveñ saìga vinä ye niyata karma
se jänibe sab sättvikera dharma

Text 23

phalera kämanä karma ahaìkär saha
kañöasädhya yata räjasa samüha

Text 24

nä bujhiyä mohavaçe anubandha karma
hiàsä paratäp ädi tämasika dharma

Text 25

mukta-saëga anahaëkär dhåti utsähapürëa
nirvikär siddhäsiddhi sättvika se dhanya

Text 26

karmäsakta phale lobh hiàsuka açuci
räjasik kartä sei harña-çoke ruci

Text 27

ayukta präkåta stabdha naiñkåti alas
dérghasütré viñädé vä kartä se tämas

Text 28

buddhira ye tin bhed dhåti är guë
dhanaïjay açeña vicär tär çuna

Text 29

pravåtti nivåtti kärya akärya vicär
bhayäbhay bandha mürti sattva-buddhi tär

Text 30

dharmädharma käryäkärya ayathävat jäne
räjasik sei buddhi çästrera pramäëe

Text 31

dharmake adharma mäne adharmake dharma
viparéta se tämasa buddhi är karma

Text 32

ye dhåtir dvärä dhare präëendriya kriyä
avyabhicäriëé bhakti sättviké se dhiyä

Text 33

ye dhåtir dvära dhare dharma, artha, käm
phaläkäìkñé räjasik hay tär näm

Text 34

ye dhåti dvärä nahe svapna bhaya tyäg
tämasé se dhåti durmedhä ära mada

Text 35

trividha se sukha çuna bhärata åñabha
jaòa sukhe maje jéva kintu duùkha saba
se sukha se uparati duùkha anta hay
saàsärera mäyäsukha tabe hay kñay

Text 36

agrete viñera sama paçcäte amåta
ye sukhera paricaya se haya sättvika
se sukhera läbh hay ätma-pramädete
ätma-buddhi bhägyavän yogya ye tähäte

Text 37

indriyer saàyogete viñayera bhog
amåtera mata ante kintu bhava rog
pariëäme viñayera viña hay läbh
räjasika sei sukh jévera svabhäv

Text 38

yähä agre anuvandhe sukhera mohan
nidrälasya pramädottha tämasika jan

Text 39

brahmäëòera madhye yata nara devaloke
keha nahe mukta sei triguëa triloke

Text 40

brähmaëa kñatriya vaiçya çüdra parantap
svabhäva prabhäve guë hay karma sab

Text 41

çama dama tapa çouca kñänti se ärjava
jïän vijïän ästikya brahma karma-bhäva

Text 42

çourya teja dhåti däkñya yuddhe nä päläy
dän éça bhäva yata kñatriye yuyäye

Text 43

kåñi go-rakñä väëijya vaiçya karma hay
çüdra ye svabhäva tär paricaryä karäy

Text 44

ucca néca yata karma sabe siddhi hay
svakarma kariyä guëa saàsära taray

Text 45

yini vyañöi samañöi vä jagata käraë
yìähä hate bhütagaëer väsanä jévan
svakarma kariyä yadi sei prabhu bhaje
siddhi-läbha hay tär saàsäre nä maje

Text 46

asamyak anuñöhita nija dharma çreya
suñöhu äcaraëa kare paradharme bhaya
nija svabhäva niyata yei karma anuñöhän
niñpäpa haibe tähe çästrera vidhän

Text 47

sadoña sahaja karma kabhu nahe äja
tähätei siddhi läbh hådi sadä bhaja
jagatera saba käj doñ vinä nay
agrete yathä kadä dhüm dekhä yäy

Text 48

doñäàça tyägete yathä guëäàña grahaë
nija sattä çuddha kari svadharma sädhan
anäsakta buddhi jit ätmä spåhähén
naiñkarma siddhi se hay sannyäsa pravéë

Text 49

siddhi-läbh kari yathä brahma präpti hay
saàkñepete kahi çuna tär paricay

Text 50

viçuddha se buddhi yukta dhåti niyamita
çavdädi viñaya tyäg räg dveñ-jita
vivikta ye laghubhojé yata väk man
dhyäna yoga parä nitya vairägya sädhan
ahaìkär val darpa käma parigraha
krodh är yata äche asata ägraha
nirmama ye çänta yei brahma anubhave
niçcita samartha hay tähäte sambhave

Texts 51-53

brahma anubhav hale prasannätm hay
çok är äkäìkñä se nirmala niçcay
sarva-bhüta sama-buddhi tär paricay
nirguëa ämära bhakti tabe läbh hay

Text 54

nirguëa bhaktite jäne ämära svarüp
saviçeñ nirviçeñ tattvata ye rüp
se tattva-jïäna läbhe praveçe ämäte
ämi brahma paramätmtä bhagavän yäte

Text 55

bhaktite präpti se hay bhagavad svarüpa
premäpümärtha mahän näm yär rüpa
sei premäçraye yei sarva karma kare
ämära prasäde para-vyom läbh tare

Text 56

se premäçraye hao maccitta satata
ämära lägiyä sarva kärye hao rata
sei buddhi-yoga näm ämära äçraya
yähära prabhäve kärya sarva-siddhi haya

Text 57

maccita yei se tare ämära prasäde
sarva-duùkha saàsäre duùkha vä viñäde
ämära se upadeç yevä nähi mäne
ahaìkäre matta haye vinäçe äpane

Text 58

ahaëkär kari bal yuddha nä karibe
mithyä se pratijïä tumi karibe svabhäve

Text 59

svabhävaja karma taba avaçya sädhive
kaunteya nirvandha sab nija karma-bhäve
ataev mohavaçe icchä nähi kara
avaçe karibe sei tumi ataùpara

Text 60

éçvara äche se sarva-bhütera hådaye
karma karma-phala sab niyantra karaye
mäyära yantrete tini sabäre ghuräy
bhukti väïchä kare jév jei yathä cäy

Text 61

tìähära caraëe lao sarvato çaraë
prasäde haibe sarva vaïchita püraëa
parä çänti päbe är çäçvata ye sthän
sarva-läbh se prasäde duùkha niväraë

Text 62

guhya guhyatara jïän kahiläm ämi
bhäla-manda vicära ye se karibe tumi
vicära kariyä tumi yähä icchä kara
upadeç ämära se nitya tumi smara

Text 63

tadapekñä guhyatama är tumi çuna
atyanta se priya tumi täi se vacana

Text 64

manmanä mad-bhakta hao more namaskär
ämäke päibe tumi pratijïä ämär

Text 65

sarva dharma tyägi lao ämära çaraë
rakñiva tomäke ämi sadä sarvakñaë
kona cintä nä karibe päp nähi habe
ämära çaraëe tumi parä çänti päbe

Text 66

abhakta vä atapaska paricaryä héna
ämära svarüpe ei yära çraddhä kñéëa
upadeça nä karibe gétära vacan
uparokta loka sab adhikäré nan

Text 67

ämära bhaktake yevä upadeç kare
paräbhakti läbh kari päibe ämäre

Text 68

tadapekñä naraloke priya nähi mor
hay näi habe näi änande bibhor

Text 69

ämära e upadeç yevä vicär karibe
tär jïäna-yajïe mor upäsanä habe

Text 70

çraddhävän haye yärä çravaëa karibe
puëyavän tär çubha loka-präpti habe

Text 71

dhanaïjay, kaha eve kivä çaìkä hala dür
ekägrete upadeç çuniyä pracur
he pärtha, kivä tava ajïäna andhakär
pranañöa haiyä gela tava duùkha bhär

Text 72

arjun kahilen:
nañöa moha småti läbha tomära prasäde
acyuta, sandeha gela nähi se viñäde
sthita ämi nija kärye tomära vacana
niçcayai kariba ämi ghucila vandhana

Text 73

saïjay kahilen:
sei se çunechi ämi kåñëärjuna kathä
adbhuta saàväda romaharñaëa sarvathä

Text 74

vyäsera prasäde ämi çuniläm sei
parama se guhyatama tulanä ye nei
ei yog yogeçvara kåñëa se kahila
säkñät tìähär mukhe ämi se çunila

Text 75

smaraëa kariyä räjä punaù punaù sei
adbhuta saàväda smari håñöa ämi hai
keçava ära arjun kathä puëya gétä
muhürhmuhu çune nitya sarvahite ratä

Text 76

smaraëa kariyä sei adbhuta svarüpa
punaù punaù håñöa man hay aparüpa

Text 77

yathä yogeçvar kåñëa pärtha dhanurdhar
tathä çré vijaya bhüti dhruva nirantar
yei näm sei kåñëa nähi se antara
çuddha näm yär hay sei dhurandhara

Text 78

bhaktivedänta kahe çré-gétära gän
çune yadi çuddha bhakta kåñëagata-präë

Thus Bhaktivedänta sings the song of Çré Gétä, with the hope that hearing this, Kåñëa conscious pure devotees will be pleased.




Songs of the Vaiñëava Äcäryas (1972)

BOOKS by
His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Bhagavad-gétä As It Is
Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Cantos 1-4 (11 Vols.)
Çré Caitanya-caritämåta (2 Vols.)
Teachings of Lord Caitanya
The Nectar of Devotion
Çré Éçopaniñad
Easy Journey to Other Planets
Kåñëa Consciousness: The Topmost Yoga System
Kåñëa, The Supreme Personality of Godhead (2 Vols.)
Transcendental Teachings of Prahläd Mahäräja
Transcendental Teachings of Caitanya Mahaprabhu
Kåñëa, the Reservoir of Pleasure
The Perfection of Yoga
Beyond Birth and Death
On the Way to Kåñëa
Räja-vidyä: The King of Knowledge
Elevation to Kåñëa Consciousness
Lord Caitanya in Five Features
Back to Godhead Magazine (Founder)

A complete catalogue is available upon request.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness
3959 Landmark Street
Culver City, California 90230

SVA: Foreword

FOREWARD

The International Society for Krishna Consciousness was established in New York in the year 1966. After my arrival in the United States in September of 1965, I personally underwent a difficult struggle, and in 1966 I rented a storefront and apartment at 26 Second Avenue. When ISKCON was incorporated, a boy named Chuck Barnett joined me, along with a few others, to form the nucleus for the institution's future development. At this time I used to chant the Hare Kåñëa mahä-mantra underneath a tree in Tompkin's Square Park in New York. Çrémän Barnett and another boy, Bruce, were the first to begin dancing in front of me, and others in the audience joined them. The New York Times published a report of this, with our picture and a headline declaring that I was attracting the younger generation to the Hare Kåñëa movement.

Later both Chuck and Bruce, along with others, became my initiated disciples, and still later, in 1970, both took sannyäsa, receiving the names Acyutänanda Svämé and Brahmänanda Svämé. Now Brahmänanda is preaching in Africa, and Acyutänanda is preaching in India.

When I became sick in 1967, I left the United States and returned to India. Çrémän Acyutänanda could not remain separated from me, and therefore he joined me in Våndävana when I was staying there. Since then, Acyutänanda Svämé has worked very hard in India. He has preached extensively in Calcutta and other parts of Bengal, he has learned how to sing in Bengali and play mådaìga like an expert professional, and now he has compiled this book of Bengali songs with English explanations.

I am greatly pleased to see this collection of songs composed by Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda, Narottama däsa, and other great äcäryas of the Gauòéya Vaiñëava community (sampradäya). Songs composed by the äcäryas are not ordinary songs. When chanted by pure Vaiñëavas who follow the rules and regulations of Vaiñëava character, they are actually effective in awakening the Kåñëa consciousness dormant in every living entity. I have advised Srémän Acyutänanda Svämé to sing more songs of the Vaiñëava padävalé and record them in books so that my disciples and others in the Western countries may take advantage of this chanting and thus advance in Krsëa consciousness more and more.

I confer all my blessings upon Acyutänanda Svämé for his genuine attempt to advance in Krsëa consciousness. I hope he will thus advance more and more and never be hampered by mäyä. We should always remember the danger of mäyä's influence and endeavor to save ourselves from her great power. We must therefore always merge in the transcendental mellow of kértana-rasa, for kértana-rasa is the safest situation within this material world. Hare Kåñëa.

A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami

SVA: Introduction

INTRODUCTION

It was my good fortune to be in the service of Çréla Prabhupäda at Çré Mäyäpur, the birthplace of Lord Caitanya, in setting up the groundwork of our Society’s international center there. That year (1971), there was a terrible flood, but although for many days the water was rising, it was diverted from flooding the Society’s property solely due to the embankment created by a road constructed by Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, our Parama Guru Mahäräja. I wrote a letter to His Divine Grace explaining the situation, and I mentioned, “The water has not entered our property. Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta’s road has saved us.” Çréla Prabhupäda, however, wrote back in answer in a different tone: “Yes, we are always saved by Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta’s road, so go on glorifying the disciplic succession, and your life will be a great success.” Later on, when I suggested writing down the songs of Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura and Narottama Däsa Öhäkura in English translations, His Divine Grace said, “Yes, we must push on this mission of Bhaktivinoda.” So here in this book, which is the first of a series of translations of the complete works of the Vaiñëava äcäryas in the line of succession coming after Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu, I have also included a short life sketch of Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda. In the following volumes, the lives of Çréla Narottama Däsa Öhäkura, Çréniväsa Äcärya, and other Vaiñëava äcäryas will appear.

The songs in this book are mostly by Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda and Narottama Däsa Öhäkura. While they may sometimes make awkward English poetry, the translations are accurate renderings of the originals. All these songs have exquisite melodies, and we are hopeful that a record may be cut to accompany the book. It should be noted that these songs and verses are all explanations of pure devotional service and that devotional service to Çré Kåñëa is obtained only by the mercy of the spiritual master, which can be obtained by serving his desires perfectly. These songs are not substitutes for the main and prime benediction of the age of Kali, the congregational chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare, which is of the utmost importance. They are verses which have expanded from the mahä-mantra and they are explanations of the mantra. Thus, because they are expansions of the mahä-mantra, they are nondifferent from it.

The songs of Çréla Narottama Däsa and Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura are nondifferent from the Vedic mantras. But, as stated by Çréla Prabhupäda in The Nectar of Devotion, even if someone does not have initiation into the Gäyatré mantra, the chanting of Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare is sufficient to enable one to attain the highest perfection of spiritual life.

The verses of these songs are wonderful sources of knowledge for preachers of Kåñëa consciousness. In each and every line there is so much philosophy that one can preach from one line for hours. They are all so pregnant with meaning and they lead to such succinct spiritual conclusions that a preacher need only recall the simple lines of songs like "Bhaja Huì re Mana," "Çré Rüpa-maïjaré-pada," "Ohe Vaiñëava Öhäkura," or the "Çré Manaù Çikña," and every point of Kåñëa consciousness will be covered in detail. Çréla Prabhupäda is constantly quoting from these lines in his lectures and books, and here also in this book his commentaries are given. Wherever Çréla Prabhupäda has translated a song, I have not given any of my own translations, for his are complete in themselves.

This is the first time that these transcendental vibrations have appeared in the English language, and to introduce them I am including herewith a life sketch of Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura.

SVA: A Glimpse into the Life of Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda

A GLIMPSE INTO THE LIFE OF ÖHÄKURA BHAKTIVINODA

Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda led a life of incessant labor and activity for Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He produced such immense good to the world that his work is only to be compared with the unbounded works of Çré Caitanya Himself and the Gosvämés. It was the spiritual attempts and divine writings of this individual that turned the scale and led the intelligent and educated community to believe in the noble precepts and teachings of Lord Caitanya.

If we look back one century, we cannot but be astonished to find how degraded was the condition of the Vaiñëava faith which had its pure origin in the deep and majestic spiritual philosophy of Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Even vastly learned paëòitas could not fathom the superexcellent precepts of Lord Caitanya's philosophy, yet due to incredulity born of the ignorance of uncultured men, the Vaisëava faith had been degraded and was considered a beggar's excuse for living at the expense of society. It was by sheer love for the Godhead that Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda expounded the deep philosophy which had remained concealed in the pages of the Vedas, the Upaniñads, the Puräëas, and the Bhägavatam. By his action toward divine service and also by his words, set in simple language to be easily understood by readers in general, he has given this philosophy to the world. It is his writings and his divine, unparalleled character that have helped to produce a class of educated and enlightened men who are now proud of their Vaiñëava faith and of their acquisition of the spiritual knowledge of the pure and sublime philosophy of Kåñëa on which the stern teachings of Çré Caitanya are based.

Though born in opulent circumstances (on 2nd of September, 1838), Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda, who was given the name Kedäranätha Datta, had to meet many difficulties in his early life. His childhood was spent at his maternal grandfather's house at Birnagar (Ulagram), from where he came to Calcutta at the age of thirteen, after the death of his father. After he completed his education, he was requested to be present at the time of his paternal grandfather's death. His grandfather, Räjavallabha Datta, had been a famous personality of Calcutta and had retired to a lonely place in Orissa to spend his last days as an ascetic. He could predict the future and knew when he would die, since he could commune with supernatural beings. Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda was present at the eventful time when that great soul passed away, and after receiving his grandfather's instructions, he visited all of the major temples and äçramas of the state of Orissa.

Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura then entered the educational service and introduced English education into the state of Orissa for the first time. He wrote a small book about all the äçramas of the state and mentioned an äçrama which was on his ancestors' property. "I have a small village Chotimangalpur in the country of Orissa of which I am the proprietor," he wrote. "In that village is a religious house which was granted by my predecessors to the holy men as a holding of rent-free land. The head of the institution entirely gave up entertaining such men as chanced to seek shelter on a rainy night. This came to my notice, and I administered a severe threat that his lands would be cruelly resumed if in the future complaints of inhospitality were brought to my knowledge." Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura later took to the government service and was transferred to Bengal. In one town he gave a historic speech on the Çrémad-Bhägavatam which attracted the attention of thousands. He made the world know what hidden treasures pervade every page of the Bhägavatam, which should be read by all persons having a philosophical turn of mind. He was transferred some years later to a town called Champaran. In this town there was a brahma-daitya living in a great banyan tree, and he was being worshiped by many degraded people. (A brahma-daitya is a type of ghost.) One day the father of a famous girl scholar came to Bhaktivinoda for alms, and Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura at once employed him in reading the Bhägavatam under the shade of the banyan tree which was the abode of the ghost. After one month, the Bhägavatam was completed, and then and there the tree crashed to the ground, and the ghost was gone for good. Everyone was thankful for this act except the few dishonest persons who were worshiping the ghost.

Bhaktivinoda's next move was to Puré. The government commissioner was much pleased to get him in his division, and he asked him to watch the affairs of the temple of Jagannätha on behalf of the government. It was through Bhaktivinoda's exertions that many malpractices were checked and the time for the offering of foods before the Deity was regulated to its extreme punctuality. Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda was especially entrusted to quell the rise against the government of one Biñikiñeëa, who declared himself to be an incarnation of Mahä-Viñëu. During the course of his investigation, Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda found him to be a hoax and a culprit and charged him with transgressing government injunctions. After his trial the fellow was sentenced to imprisonment for a year and a half, but he died shortly after in jail. This man was really possessed of unnatural powers, but as they were the outcome of nonspiritual practices, he had to submit to the Öhäkura when the latter wanted him to do so. Biñikiñeëa was held in dread by the common people, and everyone warned Çréla Bhaktivinoda not to admonish him, even for the sake of justice, in view of the serious consequences that the yogé would inflict. But although the Öhäkura was not a man of ostentation and did not allow people to know his true qualities and spiritual strength, he easily cut down the demoniac power of the impostor. With the fall of Biñikiñeëa there rose an impostor Balaräma at another village, and there were also other so-called incarnations of God, but their plans were similarly frustrated.

During his stay at Jagannätha Puré, Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda devoted much of his time to the discussion of spiritual works and prepared notes on the Vedänta-sütras which were published with the commentaries of Baladeva Vidyäbhuñaëa. He also composed the Kalyäëa-kalpataru (from which Vibhävaré Çeña, one selection, appears in this book). This may very truly be termed an immortal work, and it stands on the same level as the divine writings of Narottama däsa Öhäkura. In 1857 he left Puré on government service and started a well-known spiritual journal called the Sajjana-toñaëé ("The Satisfaction of Pure Devotees"). He also published the Çré Kåñëa-saàhitä, which revealed to the world the underlying philosophy explaining the spiritual existence of Kåñëa. This book opened the eyes of educated people to teach them their true relationship with God. It also attracted the admiration of many German scholars, for although the public regarded Kåñëa as a poetic creation of erotic nature, Çréla Bhaktivinoda revealed Kåñëa as Parabrahman, the Supreme Transcendental Person, the Absolute Being, on the basis of Vedic evidence.

At the close of his stay at the village of Narail, he visited Våndävana. There he had to encounter a band of dacoits known as Kanjharas. These powerful bandits spread all over the roads surrounding the holy place and used to attack innocent pilgrims. Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura brought this news to the government and after many months of struggle extirpated the bandits from Våndävana forever. From this time on, Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda preached extensively in large gatherings, explaining all of the precepts of the saìkértana of the holy names, Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare.

While staying at Barasat, Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda met the famous Bengali writer Baìkimacandra. This novelist and playwright had just finished writing a book on Kåñëa, and knowing Çréla Bhaktivinoda to be an authority on topics of Kåñëa, he gave the manuscript to Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura to see. It was full of mundane Western-stylized speculations and ideas, but after four days of discussion, Bhaktivinoda had the whole text revised by Baìkimacandra to accommodate the pure supramundane precepts of Lord Caitanya. During his last year at Barasat, Bhaktivinoda was requested by a noted high court judge to publish an authoritative edition of the Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä with the commentaries of Çré Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura as well as his own (Bhaktivinoda's) translation. The preface, written by Baìkimacandra, expressed his gratitude to the Öhäkura for his endeavor, and when it was published, the copies were soon exhausted. Then Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda published a unique work entitled Çré Caitanya-çikñämåta (The Nectarean Teachings of Lord Caitanya) which dealt with Lord Caitanya's theistic philosophy and the philosophies of the Western speculators. This book defeats every other philosophy point for point and establishes the philosophy of Lord Caitanya as supreme. In 1885 he started a society named Çré Viçva-Vaiñëava-Sabhä for the propagation of pure hari-bhakti. Many eminent citizens of Calcutta joined the society, and several committees were organized with assigned duties.

Bhaktivinoda Thäkura was so anxious to see the land of Lord Caitanya that he applied many times for a transfer to any town nearby. Upon not receiving the desired transfer, he formally submitted a resignation from public service, but it was refused. Then, to his great rejoicing, he obtained a transfer to Kåñëa-nägar, twenty-five miles from Navadvépa, Mäyäpur. Once stationed at a place near Navadvépa, he did not let a single free moment pass without visiting the land of Navadvépa. He at once made inquiries about the exact whereabouts of the different places of Lord Caitanya's pastimes. He soon discovered that the then city of Navadvépa was only a town of 100 years' standing, so he was curious to locate the actual birthplace of Lord Caitanya. He was convinced that the town of Navadvépa was not the authentic location, and he at once commenced a vigorous inquiry to find the truth of the matter, but he could not easily escape from the people who tried to make him believe that the birthplace of Caitanya was at that town. Then, after careful inquiry, he was told that the site was lost under the shifting course of the Ganges. Not satisfied with this explanation, he himself set out to discover the yoga-péöha (birthplace). After great difficulties, he came to know of a place which was being adored by many realized souls as the true birthplace of Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu and which was then in the possession of the Muhammadans. Local inquiry and corroborative evidence from ancient maps of the latter part of the 18th century which showed the name "Çré Mäyäpur" at last helped him to discover the real site of the birthplace. The discovery led to the publishing of a valuable work called Navadvépa-dhäma-mähätmya. (Chapter Five of this book has appeared in ISKCON's Bengali Back to Godhead magazine.)

The year 1887 was the most eventful year in the history of the Vaiñëava world, and Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura was the prime mover of the events. It was in this year that he discovered the actual place of Lord Caitanya's birth, which was given up for lost. Thousands of visitors were present at a function held at the spot. Just after retirement from government service, Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda himself, in a spirit of perfect humility and with a view to giving a firm standing to the discovery, went from door to door to raise funds for a temple. In the Amrita Bazar Patrika newspaper, on 6th of December, 1894, the following article appeared: "Bäbu Kedäranätha Datta, the distinguished Deputy Magistrate who has just retired from the service, is one of the most active members. Indeed, Bäbu Kedäranätha Datta has been deputed by his committee to raise subscriptions in Calcutta and elsewhere and is determined to go from house to house if necessary and beg a rupee from each Hindu gentleman for the noble purpose. If Bäbu Kedäranätha Datta sticks to his resolution of going around with a bag in hand, we hope that no Hindu gentleman whose house may be honored by the presence of such a devout bhakta as Bäbu Kedäranätha will send him away without contributing his mite, however humble it may be, to the Gaura-Viñëupriyä Temple fund." Truly, Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda honored the houses of many persons for the fulfillment of the noble object he had undertaken. He went to persons to whom he would not have gone for any purpose but for this mission of Lord Caitanya, and his efforts were not fruitless, since the sum collected contributed to the construction of a building on the holy site of Lord Caitanya's appearance.

The work of preaching the holy name was also in full swing, and it spread fast into the distant corners of the globe. The Gauräìga-smaraëa-maìgala-stotra, with a preface in English containing the life and precepts of Çré Caitanya, came out from Bhaktivinoda's pen soon after the discovery of Lord Caitanya's birthplace and found its place in all the learned institutions of both hemispheres.

The more the names of Lord Caitanya and Lord Kåñëa were preached, the merrier was Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda. He thereafter made annotations of Çré Brahmä-saàhitä and Çré Kåñëa-karëämåta and gave to the world his immortal and precious works Çré Harinäma-cintämaëi and Bhajana-rahasya. He also edited, with commentary, Çrémad-bhägavatärka-maréci-mälä, which contains all the most prominent çlokas of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam pertaining to the Vaiñëava philosophy. His pen never tired, and it produced many other Vaiñëava philosophical works. He would begin his writings very late at night, after completing his government work, and stay up until one or two o'clock in the morning composing songs and literatures. Most of his works appeared in the Sajjana-toñaëé magazine (which will be translated shortly). He was equally engaged in writing and in preaching the holy name in many districts of Bengal. His personal appearances at villages had marvelous effects on the people. To maintain the center at Nadia he built a house at Çré Godruma-dvépa which is called Çré Svänanda-Sukhada-Kuïja. Here in this abode the preaching of hari-näma continued in full swing.

It was at the beginning of the 20th Century that he chose to live at Puré and build a house on the beachfront there. Many honest souls sought his blessings and readily obtained them when he retired to the fourth order of life by taking sannyäsa from Çré Jagannätha däsa Bäbäjé in 1908. Though he was leading the life of a renounced soul, he could not avoid the men of all description who constantly visited him. All of them received oceans of spiritual training, instructions and blessings. In 1910 he shut himself up and remained in a perfect state of samädhi, or full concentration on the eternal pastimes of the Lord. In 1914 he passed on to the blissful realm of Goloka on the day which is observed as the disappearance day of Çré Gadädhara. Here we quote a stanza written about the samädhi of Haridäsa Öhäkura which Çréla Bhaktivinoda wrote sometime in 1871 to explain what influence a Vaiñëava carries in this world even after his departure:

He reasons ill who tells that Vaiñëavas die
When thou art living still in sound!
The Vaiñëavas die to live, and living try
To spread the holy name around!

Çréla Bhaktivinoda predicted, "Soon there will appear a personality who will preach the holy name of Hari all over the world." It is clearly understood that His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda is that personality. I offer my prostrated obeisances first unto all the devotees that have surrendered unto his divine lotus feet and next unto the devotees who will in the future take shelter of his lotus feet, and I then offer my humble obeisances unto his lotus feet again and again. May he bless this first translation attempt so that it may be accepted by the Lord Çré Kåñëa, and may he engage me in the service of the six Gosvämés of Våndävana, Lord Caitanya, and Rädhäräëé.

Acyutänanda Svämé

August 20, 1972
Disappearance Day of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé
Rädhä-Dämodara Temple
Seva Kuïj, Våndävana


THE DISCIPLIC SUCCESSION

[pictures omitted]

His Divine Grace
A.C. Bhaktivedanta
Swami Prabhupäda—the
Founder-Äcärya of
ISKCON and greatest exponent of Kåñëa consciousness in the western world.

Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta
Sarasvaté Gosvämé Mahäräja—the spiritual master of His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda and foremost scholar and devotee in the recent age.

Çréla Gaurakiçora däsa
Bäbäjé Mahäräja—the
spiritual master of Srila Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé and intimate student of Çréla Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda.

Çréla Öhäkura Bhaktivinoda—the
pioneer of the program to benedict the entire world with Kåñëa consciousness.


SVA 1: Çré Guru Praëäma

ÇRÉ GURU PRAËÄMA (obeisances)

oà ajïäna-timirändhasya jïänäïjana-çaläkayä

cakñur unmélitaà yena tasmai çré-gurave namaù

om—address; ajïäna—of ignorance; timira—by the darkness; andhasya—of one who was blinded; jïäna-aïjana—by the ointment of knowledge; çaläkayä—by a surgical instrument; cakñuù—eyes; unmélitam—opened; yena—by whom; tasmai—unto him; çré-gurave—unto my spiritual master; namaù—obeisances.

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto my spiritual master, who has opened my eyes, which were blinded by the darkness of ignorance, with the torchlight of knowledge." [Gautaméya Tantra] [purport]

çré-caitanya-mano 'bhéñöaà sthäpitaà yena bhü-tale

svayaà rüpaù kadä mahyaà dadäti sva-padäntikam

çré-caitanya—of Lord Caitanya; manaù—mind; abhéñöam—and desire (mission); sthäpitam—established; yena—by whom; bhü-tale—on the surface of the globe; svayam—himself; rüpaù—Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé; kadä—when; mahyam—unto me; dadäti—will give; sva—his own; pada—lotus feet; antikam—proximity to.

"When will Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé Prabhupäda, who has established within this material world the mission to fulfill the desire of Lord Caitanya, give me shelter under his lotus feet?" [Narottama däsa Öhäkura, Prema Bhakti-candrikä, Mangaläcaraëa 2] [purport]

SVA 1: Maìgaläcaraëa

MAÌGALÄCARAËA

vande 'haà çré-guroù çré-yuta-pada-kamalaà çré-gurun vaiñëaväàç ca

çré-rüpaà sägrajätaà saha-gaëa-raghunäthänvitaà taà sa jévam

sädvaitaà sävadhütaà parijana-sahitaà kåñëa-caitanya-devaà

çré-rädhä-kåñëa-pädän saha-gaëa-lalitä-çré-viçäkhänvitäàç ca

vande—offer obeisances; aham—I; çré-guroù—of my spiritual master; çré-yuta—auspicious; pada-kamalam—unto the lotus feet; çré-gurün—unto the spiritual masters; vaiñëavän—unto all the Vaiñëavas; ca—and; çré-rüpam—unto Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé; sa-agrajätam—with his elder brother (Sanätana Gosvämé); saha-gaëa—with associates; raghunätha—Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé; anvitam—accompanied by; tam—unto him; sa-jévam—with Çréla Jéva Gosvämé; sa-advaitam—along with Advaita Äcärya; sa-avadhütam—along with Lord Nityänanda; parijana—and other associates; sahitam—with; kåñëa-caitanya-devam—unto Lord Çré Caitanya Mahäprabhu; çré-rädhä-kåñëa-pädän—unto the lotus feet of Rädhä and Kåñëa; saha-gaëa—along with associates; lalitä—Çré Lalitä; çré-viçäkhä—Çré Viçäkhä; anvitän—accompanied by; ca—also.

"I am offering my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of my spiritual master and unto the feet of all Vaiñëavas. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé along with his elder brother Sanätana Gosvämé, as well as Raghunätha däsa, and Raghunätha Bhaööa, Gopäla Bhaööa and Çréla Jéva Gosvämé. I offer my respectful obeisances to Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya Mahäprabhu and Lord Nityänanda Prabhu, along with Advaita Äcärya, Gadädhara, Çréväsa, and other associates. I offer my respectful obeisances to Çrématé Rädhäräné and Çré Kåñëa along with Their associates Çré Lalitä and Viçäkhä."

[purport]

SVA 1: Çréla Prabhupäda Praëati

ÇRÉLA PRABHUPÄDA PRAËATI

nama oà viñëu-pädäya kåñëa-preñöhäya bhü-tale

çrémate bhaktivedänta-svämin iti nämine

namaù—obeisances; om—address; viñëu-pädäya—unto him who is at the feet of Lord Viñëu; kåñëa-preñöhäya—who is very dear to Lord Kåñëa; bhu-tale—on the earth; çrémate—all-beautiful; bhaktivedanta-svämin—A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami; iti—thus; nämine—who is named.

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, who is very dear to Lord Kåñëa, having taken shelter at His lotus feet."


namas te särasvate devaà gaura-väëé-pracäriëe

nirviçeña-çünyavädi-päçcätya-deça-täriëe

namaù—obeisances; te—unto you; särasvate—servant of Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Gosvämé; devam—spiritual master; gaura-väëé—the message of Lord Caitanya; pracäriëe—who are preaching, nirviçeña—from impersonalism; çünya-vädi—from voidism; päçcätya—western; deça—countries; täriëe—who are delivering.

"Our respectful obeisances are unto you, O spiritual master, servant of Sarasvaté Gosvämé. You are kindly preaching the message of Lord Caitanya-deva and delivering the Western countries, which are filled with impersonalism and voidism."

[purport]

SVA 1: Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Praëati

ÇRÉLA BHAKTISIDDHÄNTA SARASVATÉ PRAËATI

nama oà viñëu-pädäya kåñëa-preñöhäya bhü-tale

çrémate bhaktisiddhänta-sarasvatéti nämine


"I offer my respectful obeisances unto His Divine Grace Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté, who is very dear to Lord Kåñëa, having taken shelter at His lotus feet."


çré-värñabhänavé-devé-dayitäya kåpäbdhaye

kåñëa-sambandha-vijïäna-däyine prabhave namaù

çré-värñabhänavé-devé-dayitäya—unto Çré Värñabhänavé-devé-dayita däsa, the servant of the husband of Çrématé Rädhäräné; kåpä-abdhaye—who is an ocean of mercy; kåñëa-sambandha—of the relationship with Kåñëa; vijïäna—of the science; däyine—who is the deliverer; prabhave—unto the master; namaù—obeisances.

"I offer my respectful obeisances to Çré Värñabhänavé-devé-dayita däsa [another name of Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté], who is favored by Çrématé Rädhäräëé and who is the ocean of transcendental mercy and the deliverer of the science of Kåñëa."


mädhuryojjvala-premäòhya-çré-rüpänuga-bhaktida-

çré-gaura-karuëä-çakti-vigrahäya namo 'stu te

mädhurya—conjugal; ujjvala—glorious; prema—love; äòhya—enriched with; çré-rüpa-anuga—following Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé; bhakti-da—delivering devotional service; çré-gaura—of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu; karuëä—of the mercy; çakti—energy; vigrahäya—unto the personified; namaù—obeisances; astu—let there be; te—unto you.

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto you, who delivers devotional service which is enriched with conjugal love of Rädhä and Kåñëa, coming exactly in the line of revelation of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé."


namas te gaura-väëé-çré-mürtaye déna-täriëe

rüpänuga-viruddhäpasiddhänta-dhvänta-häriëe

namaù—obeisances; te—unto you; gaura-väëé—teachings of Lord Caitanya; çré-mürtaye—unto the personified; déna—of the fallen; täriëe—unto the deliverer; rüpa-anuga—the principles of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé; viruddha—against; apasiddhänta—of unauthorized statements; dhvänta—the darkness; häriëe—unto you who are removing.

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto you, who are the personified teachings of Lord Caitanya. You are the deliverer of the fallen souls. You do not tolerate any statement which is against the teachings of devotional service enunciated by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé."

SVA 1: Çréla Gaurakiçora Praëati

ÇRÉLA GAURAKIÇORA PRAËATI

namo gaura-kiçoräya säkñäd-vairägya-mürtaye

vipralambha-rasämbhode pädämbujäya te namaù

namah—obeisances; gaura-kiçoräya—unto Gaurakiçora; säkñät—exactly; vairägya—renunciation; mürtaye—unto the personified; vipralambha—of separation; rasa—of the mellow; ambhodhe—O ocean; päda-ambujäya—unto the lotus feet; te—unto you; namaù—obeisances.

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto Gaurakiçora däsa Bäbäjé Mahäräja [the spiritual master of Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté], who is renunciation personified. He is always merged in a feeling of separation and intense love of Kåñëa."

SVA 1: Çréla Bhaktivinoda Praëati

ÇRÉLA BHAKTIVINODA PRAËATI

namo bhaktivinodäya sac-cid-änanda-nämine

gaura-çakti-svarüpäya rüpänuga-varäya te

namaù—obeisances; bhaktivinodäya—unto Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura; sat-cit-änanda-nämine—known as Saccidänanda; gaura—of Lord Caitanya; çakti—energy; sva-rüpäya—whose own nature; rüpa-anuga-varäya—who is the foremost follower of Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé; te—unto you.

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto Saccidänanda Bhaktivinoda, who is transcendental energy of Caitanya Mahäprabhu. He is a strict follower of the Gosvämés, headed by Çréla Rüpa."

SVA 1: Çréla Jagannätha Praëati

ÇRÉLA JAGANNÄTHA PRAËATI

gaurävirbhäva-bhümes tvaà nirdeñöä saj-jana-priyaù

vaiñëava-särvabhaumaù ñré-jagannäthäya te namaù

gaura—of Lord Caitanya; ävirbhäva—of the appearance; bhümeù—of the place; tvam—you; nirdeñöä—the indicator; sat-jana—to all respectable persons; priyaù—respectful; vaiñëava—of the Vaiñëavas; särvabhaumaù—chief; çré-jagannäthäya—unto Jagannätha däsa Bäbäjé; te—unto you; namaù—obeisances.

"I offer my respectful obeisances to Jagannätha däsa Bäbäjé, who is respected by the entire Vaiñëava community and who discovered the place where Lord Caitanya appeared."

SVA 1: Çré Vaiñëava Praëäma

ÇRÉ VAIÑËAVA PRAËÄMA

väïchä-kalpa-tarubhyaç ca kåpä-sindhubhya eva ca

patitänäà pävanebhyo vaiñëavebhyo namo namaù

väïchä-kalpa-tarubhyaù—who are desire trees; ca—and; kåpä—of mercy; sindhubhyaù—who are oceans; eva—certainly; ca—and; patitänäm—of the fallen souls; pävanebhyaù—who are the purifiers; vaiñëave-bhyaù—unto the Vaiñëavas; namaù namaù—repeated obeisances.

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto all the Vaiñëava devotees of the Lord. They are just like desire trees who can fulfill the desires of everyone, and they are full of compassion for the fallen conditioned souls."

[purport]

SVA 1: Çré Gauräìga Praëäma

ÇRÉ GAURÄÌGA PRAËÄMA

namo mahä-vadänyäya kåñëa-prema-pradäya te

kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-nämne gaura-tviñe namaù

namaù—obeisances; mahä-vadänyäya—who are the most magnanimous; kåñëa-prema—of love of Kåñëa; pradäya—who are the bestower; te—unto You; kåñëäya—Lord Kåñëa; kåñëa-caitanya—Çré Kåñëa Caitanya Mahäprabhu; nämne—who are named; gaura-tviñe—whose color is golden; namaù—obeisances.

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya, who is more magnanimous than any other avatära, even Kåñëa Himself, because He is bestowing freely what no one else has ever given—pure love of Kåñëa."

SVA 1: Çré Païca-tattva Praëäma

ÇRÉ PAÏCA-TATTVA PRAËÄMA

païca-tattvätmakaà kåñëaà bhakta-rüpa-svarüpakam

bhaktävatäraà bhaktäkhyaà namämi bhakta-çaktikam

païca-tattva—five features; ätmakam—consisting of; kåñëam—unto Lord Kåñëa; bhakta-rüpa—form as a devotee; sva-rüpakam—personal form; bhakta-avatäram—the form of incarnation; bhakta-äkhyam—celebrated as a devotee; namämi—I bow down; bhakta-çaktikam—the giver of the energy of a devotee.

"I bow down to Lord Kåñëa, who appears as a devotee [Lord Caitanya Himself], as His personal expansion [Çré Nityänanda], His incarnation [Çré Advaita], His devotee [Çré Çréväsa] and His energy [Çré Gadädhara], and who is the source of all strength for the devotees." [Ädi 1.14]

SVA 1: Çré Kåñëa Praëäma

ÇRÉ KÅÑËA-PRAËÄMA

he kåñëa karuëä-sindho déna-bandho jagat-pate

gopeça gopikä-känta rädhä-känta namo 'stu te

he—O; kåñëa—Kåñëa; karuëä-sindho—O ocean of mercy; déna—of the distressed; bandho—friend; jagat—of the universe; pate—the Lord; gopa-éça—master of the cowherdsmen, gopikä-känta—very dear to the gopés; rädhä-känta—lover of Radhäräëé; namaù—obeisances; astu—let there be; te—unto You.

"O my dear Kåñëa, You are the friend of the distressed and the source of creation. You are the master of the cowherdsmen and the lover of the gopés, especially Rädhäräëé. I offer my respectful obeisances unto You."

SVA 1: Sambandhädhideva Praëäma

SAMBANDHA-ADHIDEVA PRAËÄMA

jayatäà suratau paìgor mama manda-mater gaté

mat-sarvasva-padämbhojau rädhä-madana-mohanau

jayatäm—all glories; suratau—who are engaged in amorous pastimes; paìgoù—who am lame; mama—of myself; manda-mateù—having depraved intelligence; gaté—the shelter; mat—my; sarva-sva—be all and end all; pada-ambhojau—whose lotus feet; rädhä-madana-mohanau—to Çré Rädha and Madana-mohana.

"Glory to the all-merciful Çré Rädhä and Madana-mohana, who are always engaged in amorous pastimes. They are the only shelter of my depraved and crippled self. Their lotus feet are the be-all and end-all of my life." [Sambandhädhideva Praëäma]

SVA 1: Abhidheyädhideva Praëäma

ABHIDHEYA-ADHIDEVA-PRAËÄMA

dévyad-våndäraëya-kalpa-drumädhaù

çrémad-ratnägära-siàhäsana-sthau

çré-çré-rädhä-çréla-govinda-devau

preñöhälébhiù sevyamänau smarämi

dévyat—shining; våndäraëya—in Våndävana; kalpa-druma—the desire tree; adhaù—under; çrémat—opulent; ratna—bedecked with gems; ägära—in a mansion; siàha-äsana—on a throne; sthau—who are seated; çré-çré-rädhä—Çré Rädhä; çréla-govinda-devau—and Govinda; preñöha—most loving; älébhiù—by female attendants; sevyamänau—being served; smarämi—I meditate upon.

"I meditate on Çré Rädhä and Govinda They are seated on a throne in a mansion bedecked with gems under the desire trees in Våndävana, being served by Their loving female attendants." [Abhidheyädhideva Praëäma]

SVA 1: Prayojanädhideva Praëäma

PRAYOJANA-ADHIDEVA-PRAËÄMA

çrémän räsa-rasärambhé vaàçévaöa-taöa-sthitaù

karñan veëu-svanair gopér gopénäthaù çriye 'stu naù

çrémän—worshipable Lord; räsa-rasa—of the räsa-lélä; ärambhé—the inaugurator; vaàçévaöa—of the vaàçévaöa tree; taöa—at the base; sthitaù—seated; karñan—attracting; veëu—of the flute; svanaiù—with the sounds; gopéù—the gopés; gopé-näthaù—Master of the gopés; çriye astu—may He be auspicious; naù—unto us.

"May Lord Gopénätha confer on us His grace. He inaugurated the räsa-lélä by attracting the spiritual milkmaids of Vraja with the enchanting tune of His flute, and He is seated at the base of the vaàçévaöa tree." [Prayojanädhideva Praëäma]

SVA 1: Çré Rädhä Praëäma

ÇRÉ RÄDHÄ PRAËÄMA

tapta-käïcana-gauräìgi rädhe våndävaneçvari

våñabhänu-sute devé praëamämi hari-priye

tapta—molten; käïcana—like gold; gaura—fair complexion; aìgi—whose body; rädhe—O Rädhäräné; våndävana-éçvari—the Queen of Våndävana; våñabhänu-sute—the daughter of King Våñabhänu; devi—O goddess; praëamämi—I offer my respects; hari-priye—very dear to Lord Kåñëa.

"I offer my respects to Rädhäräëé, whose bodily complexion is like molten gold and who is the Queen of Våndävana. You are the daughter of King Våñabhänu, and You are very dear to Lord Kåñëa."

SVA 1: Païca-tattva Mahä-mantra

PAÏCA-TATTVA MAHÄ-MANTRA

(bhaja) çré-kåñëa-caitanya prabhu nityänanda

çré-advaita gadädhara çréväsädi-gaura-bhakta-vånda
[purport]

SVA 1: Hare Kåñëa Mahä-mantra

THE HARE KRSNA MAHA-MANTRA

HARE KÅÑËA
HARE KÅÑËA
KRSNA KÅÑËA
HARE HARE
HARE RÄMA
HARE RÄMA
RÄMA RÄMA
HARE HARE

[purport 1, 2]

SVA 1: Çré Çré Gurv-añöaka (saàsära-dävänala-léòha-loka)

ÇRÉ ÇRÉ GURV-AÑÖAKA
(Eight Prayers Glorifying the Spiritual Master)
by Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura

Çréla Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura, who appeared in the latter half of the 17th Century, is a great spiritual master in the Kåñëa conscious chain of gurus and disciples. He says that one should loudly chant the following eight prayers, with care and attention, during brähma-muhürta, the auspicious time an hour and a half before sunrise when devotional practices are especially potent. Anyone who thus chants these eight beautiful prayers glorifying the spiritual master will certainly get a chance to render direct service to Kåñëa, the Lord of Våndävana, after the demise of his body.


1) saàsära-dävänala-léòha-loka-

träëäya käruëya-ghanäghanatvam

präptasya kalyäëa-guëärëavasya

vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

saàsära—of material existence; dävä-anala—by the forest fire; léòha—afflicted; loka—the people; träëäya—to deliver; käruëya—of mercy; ghanäghana-tvam—the quality of a cloud; präptasya—who is the receiver of; kalyäëa—auspicious; guëa—of qualities; arëavasya—who is an ocean; vande—I offer obeisances; guroù—of my spiritual master; çré—auspicious; caraëa-aravindam—unto the lotus feet.

"The spiritual master is receiving benediction from the ocean of mercy. Just as a cloud pours water on a forest fire to extinguish it, so the spiritual master delivers the materially afflicted world by extinguishing the blazing fire of material existence. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master, who is an ocean of auspicious qualities."


2) mahäprabhoù kértana-nåtya-géta-

väditra-mädyan-manaso rasena

romäïca-kampäçru-taraìga-bhäjo

vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

mahäprabhoù—of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu; kértana—by chanting; nåtya—dancing; géta—singing; väditra—playing musical instruments; mädyat—gladdened; manasaù—whose mind; rasena—by the mellow; roma-aïca—standing of the hair; kampa—quivering of the body, açru-taraìga—torrents of tears; bhäjaù—who feels; vande—I offer obeisances; guroù—of my spiritual master; çré-caraëa-aravindam—unto the lotus feet.

"Chanting the Holy Name, dancing in ecstasy, singing, and playing musical instruments, the spiritual master is always gladdened by the saìkértana movement of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu. Because he is relishing the mellows of pure devotion within his mind, sometimes his hair stands on end, he feels quivering in his body, and tears flow from his eyes like waves. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master."


3) çré-vigrahärädhana-nitya-nänä-

çåìgära-tan-mandira-märjanädau

yuktasya bhaktäàç ca niyuïjato 'pi

vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

çré-vigraha—the arcä-vigraha, (Deities); ärädhana—worshiping; nitya—always; nänä—with various; çåìgära—clothing and ornaments; tat—Their; mandira—temple; märjana—cleaning; ädau—beginning with; yuktasya—who is engaged; bhaktän—his disciples; ca—and; niyuïjataù—who engages; api—also; vande—I offer my obeisances; guroù—of my spiritual master; çré-caraëa-aravindam—unto the lotus feet.

"The spiritual master is always engaged in the temple worship of Çré Çré Rädhä and Kåñëa. He also engages his disciples in such worship. They dress the Deities in beautiful clothes and ornaments, clean Their temple, and perform other similar worship of the Lord. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master."


4) catur-vidha-çré-bhagavat-prasäda-

svädv-anna-tåptän hari-bhakta-saìghän

kåtvaiva tåptià bhajataù sadaiva

vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

catuù—four; vidha—kinds; çré—holy, bhagavat-prasäda—which have been offered to Kåñëa; svädu—palatable; anna—by foods; tåptän—spiritually satisfied; hari—of Kåñëa; bhakta-saìghän—the association of devotees; kåtvä—having made; eva—thus; tåptim—satisfaction; bhajataù—who feels; sadä—always; eva—certainly; vande—I offer obeisances; guroù—of my spiritual master; çré-caraëa-aravindam—unto the lotus feet.

"The spiritual master is always offering Kåñëa four kinds of delicious food [analyzed as that which is licked, chewed, drunk, and sucked]. When the spiritual master sees that the devotees are satisfied by eating bhagavat-prasäda, he is satisfied. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master."


5) çré-rädhikä-mädhavayor apära-

mädhurya-lélä guëa-rüpa-nämnäm

pratikñaëäsvädana-lolupasya

vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

çré-rädhikä—of Çrématé Rädhäräëé; mädhavayoù—of Lord Mädhava (Kåñëa); apära—unlimited; mädhurya—conjugal; lélä—pastimes; guëa—qualities; rüpa—forms; nämnäm—of Their holy names; pratikñaëa—at every moment; äsvädana—relishing; lolupasya—who aspires after; vande—I offer obeisances; guroù—of my spiritual master; çré-caraëa-aravindam—unto the lotus feet.

"The spiritual master is always eager to hear and chant about the unlimited conjugal pastimes of Rädhikä and Mädhava, and Their qualities, names, and forms. The spiritual master aspires to relish these at every moment. I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master."


6) nikuïja-yüno rati-keli-siddhyai

yä yälibhir yuktir apekñaëéyä

taträti-däkñyäd ati-vallabhasya

vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

nikuïja-yünaù—of Rädhä and Kåñëa; rati—of conjugal love; keli—of pastimes; siddhyai—for the perfection; yä yä—whatever; älibhiù—by the gopés; yuktiù—arrangements; apekñaëéyä—desirable; tatra—in that connection; ati-däkñyät—because of being very expert; ati-vallabhasya—who is very dear; vande—I offer obeisances; guroù—of my spiritual master; çré-caraëa-aravindam—unto the lotus feet.

"The spiritual master is very dear, because he is expert in assisting the gopés, who at different times make different tasteful arrangements for the perfection of Rädhä and Kåñëa's conjugal loving affairs within the groves of Våndävana. I offer my most humble obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master."


7) säkñäd-dharitvena samasta-çästrair

uktas tathä bhävyata eva sadbhiù

kintu prabhor yaù priya eva tasya

vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

säkñät—directly; hari-tvena—with the quality of Hari; samasta—all; çästraiù—by scriptures; uktaù—acknowledged; tathä—thus; bhävyate—is considered; eva—also; sadbhiù—by great saintly persons; kintu—however; prabhoù—of the Lord; yaù—who; priyaù—dear friend; eva—certainly; tasya—of him (the guru); vande—I offer obeisances; guroù—of my spiritual master; çré-caraëa-aravindam—unto the lotus feet.

"The spiritual master is to be honored as much as the Supreme Lord because he is the most confidential servitor of the Lord. This is acknowledged in all revealed scriptures and followed by all authorities. Therefore I offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of such a spiritual master, who is a bona fide representative of Çré Hari [Kåñëa]."


8) yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädo

yasyäprasädän na gatiù kuto 'pi

dhyäyan stuvaàs tasya yaças tri-sandhyaà

vande guroù çré-caraëäravindam

yasya—of whom (the spiritual master); prasädät—by the grace; bhagavat—of Kåñëa; prasädaù—the mercy; yasya—of whom; aprasädät—without the grace; na—not; gatiù—means of advancement; kutaù api—anywhere; dhyäyan—meditating upon; stuvan—glorifying; tasya—of him (the spiritual master); yaçaù—the glory; tri-sandhyam—three times a day; vande—I offer obeisances; guroù—of my spiritual master; çré-caraëa-aravindam—unto the lotus feet.

"By the mercy of the spiritual master one receives the benediction of Kåñëa. Without the grace of the spiritual master, one cannot make any advancement. Therefore, I should always remember and praise the spiritual master. At least three times a day I should offer my respectful obeisances unto the lotus feet of my spiritual master."

[purport]

SVA 1: Çré Çré Ñaò-gosvämy-añöaka (kåñëotkértana-gäna-nartana-parau)

ÇRÉ-ÇRÉ-ÑAÒ-GOSVÄMY-AÑÖAKA
by Çréniväsa Äcärya

1)

kåñëotkértana-gäna-nartana-parau premämåtämbho-nidhé

dhérädhéra-jana-priyau priyakarau nirmatsarau püjitau

çré-caitanya-kåpä-bharau bhuvi bhuvo bhärävahantärakau

vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who are always engaged in chanting the holy name of Kåñëa and dancing. They are just like the ocean of love of God, and they are popular both with the gentle and with the ruffians because they are not envious of anyone. Whatever they do, they are all-pleasing to everyone, and they are fully blessed by Lord Caitanya. Thus they are engaged in missionary activities meant to deliver all the conditioned souls in the material universe. [680815IN.MON] [681226PS.LA] [710628LE.SF] [740317SB.VRN]

2)

nänä-çästra-vicäraëaika-nipuëau sad-dharma-saàsthäpakau

lokänäà hita-käriëau tri-bhuvane mänyau çaraëyäkarau

rädhä-kåñëa-padäravinda-bhajanänandena mattälikau

vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who are very expert in scrutinizingly studying all the revealed scriptures with the aim of establishing eternal religious principles for the benefit of all human beings. Thus they are honored all over the three worlds, and they are worth taking shelter of because they are absorbed in the mood of the gopés and are engaged in the transcendental loving service of Rädhä and Kåñëa.

3)

çré-gauräìga-guëänuvarëana-vidhau çraddhä-samåddhy-anvitau

päpottäpa-nikåntanau tanu-bhåtäà govinda-gänämåtaiù

änandämbudhi-vardhanaika-nipuëau kaivalya-nistärakau

vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who are very much enriched in understanding of Lord Caitanya and who are thus expert in narrating His transcendental qualities. They can purify all conditioned souls from the reactions of their sinful activities by pouring upon them transcendental songs about Govinda. As such, they are very expert in increasing the limits of the ocean of transcendental bliss, and they are the saviors of the living entities from the devouring mouth of liberation.

4)

tyaktvä türëam açeña-maëòala-pati-çreëéà sadä tucchavat

bhütvä déna-gaëeçakau karuëayä kaupéna-kanthäçritau

gopé-bhäva-rasämåtäbdhi-laharé-kallola-magnau muhur

vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who kicked off all association of aristocracy as insignificant. In order to deliver the poor conditioned souls, they accepted loincloths, treating themselves as mendicants, but they are always merged in the ecstatic ocean of the gopés' love for Kåñëa and bathe always and repeatedly in the waves of that ocean.

5)

küjat-kokila-haàsa-särasa-gaëäkérëe mayürä-kule

nänä-ratna-nibaddha-müla-viöapa-çré-yukta-våndävane

rädhä-kåñëam ahar-niçaà prabhajatau jévärthadau yau mudä

vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who were always engaged in worshiping Rädhä-Kåñëa in the transcendental land of Våndävana, where there are beautiful trees full of fruits and flowers which have under their roots all valuable jewels. The Gosvämés are perfectly competent to bestow upon the living entities the greatest boon of the goal of life.

6)

saìkhyä-pürvaka-näma-gäna-natibhiù kälävasänékåtau

nidrähära-vihärakädi-vijitau cätyanta-dénau ca yau

rädhä-kåñëa-guëa-småter madhurimänandena sammohitau

vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who were engaged in chanting the holy names of the Lord and bowing down in a scheduled measurement. In this way they utilized their valuable lives, and in executing these devotional activities they conquered over eating and sleeping and were always meek and humble, enchanted by remembering the transcendental qualities of the Lord.

7)

rädhä-kuëòa-taöe kalinda-tanayä-tére ca vaàçévaöe

premonmäda-vaçäd açeña-daçayä grastau pramattau sadä

gäyantau ca kadä harer guëa-varaà bhäväbhibhütau mudä

vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who were sometimes on the bank of the Rädhä-kunda lake or the shores of the Yamunä and sometimes in Vaàçévaöa. There they appeared just like madmen in the full ecstasy of love for Kåñëa, exhibiting different transcendental symptoms in their bodies, and they were merged in the ecstasy of Kåñëa consciousness.

8)

he rädhe! vraja-devike! ca lalite! he nanda-süno! kutaù

çré-govardhana-kalpa-pädapa-tale kälindé-vanye kutaù

ghoñantäv iti sarvato vraja-pure khedair mahä-vihvalau

vande rüpa-sanätanau raghu-yugau çré-jéva-gopälakau

I offer my respectful obeisances unto the six Gosvämés, namely, Çré Rüpa Gosvämé, Çré Sanätana Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, who were chanting very loudly everywhere in Våndävana, shouting, "Queen of Våndävana, Rädhäräëé! O Lalita! O son of Nanda Mahäräja! Where are you all now? Are you just on the hill of Govardhana, or are you under the trees on the bank of the Yamunä? Where are you?" These were their moods in executing Kåñëa consciousness.

SVA 1: Çré Çré Çikñäñöaka (ceto-darpaëa-märjanaà)

LORD CAITANYA'S MISSION

Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu instructed His disciples to write books on the science of Kåñëa, a task which His followers have continued to carry out down to the present day. The elaborations and expositions on the philosophy taught by Lord Caitanya are, in fact, the most voluminous, exacting, and consistent, due to the system of disciplic succession. Although Lord Caitanya was widely renowned as a scholar in His youth, He left only eight verses, called, Çikñäñöaka. These eight verses clearly reveal His mission and precepts. These supremely valuable prayers are translated herein.

ÇRÉ ÇRÉ ÇIKÑÄÑÖAKA

1) ceto-darpaëa-märjanaà bhava-mahä-dävägni-nirväpaëaà

çreyaù-kairava-candrikä-vitaraëaà vidyä-vadhü-jévanam

änandämbudhi-vardhanaà pratipadaà pürëämåtäsvädanaà

sarvätma-snapanaà paraà vijayate çré-kåñëa-saëkértanam

Glory to the Çré Kåñëa saìkértana, which cleanses the heart of all the dust accumulated for years and extinguishes the fire of conditional life, of repeated birth and death. This saìkértana movement is the prime benediction for humanity at large because it spreads the rays of the benediction moon. It is the life of all transcendental knowledge. It increases the ocean of transcendental bliss, and it enables us to fully taste the nectar for which we are always anxious.


2) nämnäm akäri bahu-dhä nija-sarva-çaktis

taträrpitä niyamitaù smaraëe na kälaù

etädåçé tava kåpä bhagavan mamäpi

durdaivam édåçam ihäjani nänurägaù

O my Lord, Your holy name alone can render all benediction to living beings, and thus You have hundreds and millions of names like Kåñëa and Govinda. In these transcendental names You have invested all Your transcendental energies. There are not even hard and fast rules for chanting these names. O my Lord, out of kindness You enable us to easily approach You by Your holy names, but I am so unfortunate that I have no attraction for them.


3) tåëäd api sunécena

taror api sahiñëunä

amäninä mänadena

kértanéyaù sadä hariù

One should chant the holy name of the Lord in a humble state of mind, thinking oneself lower than the straw in the street; one should be more tolerant than a tree, devoid of all sense of false prestige, and should be ready to offer all respect to others. In such a state of mind one can chant the holy name of the Lord constantly.


4) na dhanaà na janaà na sundaréà

kavitäà vä jagad-éça kämaye

mama janmani janmanéçvare

bhavatäd bhaktir ahaituké tvayi

O almighty Lord, I have no desire to accumulate wealth, nor do I desire beautiful women, nor do I want any number of followers. I only want Your causeless devotional service, birth after birth.


5) ayi nanda-tanuja kiìkaraà

patitaà mäà viñame bhavämbudhau

kåpayä tava päda-paìkaja-

sthita-dhülé-sadåçaà vicintaya

O son of Mahäräja Nanda (Kåñëa), I am Your eternal servitor, yet somehow or other I have fallen into the ocean of birth and death. Please pick me up from this ocean of death and place me as one of the atoms at Your lotus feet.


6) nayanaà galad-açru-dhärayä

vadanaà gadgada-ruddhayä girä

pulakair nicitaà vapuù kadä

tava näma-grahaëe bhaviñyati

O my Lord, when will my eyes be decorated with tears of love flowing constantly when I chant Your holy name? When will my voice choke up, and when will the hairs of my body stand on end at the recitation of Your name?


7) yugäyitaà nimeñeëa

cakñuñä prävåñäyitam

çünyäyitaà jagat sarvaà

govinda-viraheëa me

O Govinda! Feeling Your separation, I am considering a moment to be like twelve years or more. Tears are flowing from my eyes like torrents of rain, and I am feeling all vacant in the world in Your absence.


8) äçliñya vä päda-ratäà pinañöu mäm

adarçanän marma-hatäà karotu vä

yathä tathä vä vidadhätu lampaöo

mat-präëa-näthas tu sa eva näparaù

I know no one but Kåñëa as my Lord, and He shall remain so even if He handles me roughly by His embrace or makes me brokenhearted by not being present before me. He is completely free to do anything and everything, for He is always my worshipful Lord, unconditionally.

[681228PU.LA] [660525BG.NY]

SVA 2: Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

SVA 2: Aruëodaya-kértana (udilo aruëa)

ARUËODAYA-KÉRTANA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1)

udilo aruëa püraba bhäge,

dvija-maëi gorä amani jäge,

bhakata-samüha loiyä säthe,

gelä nagara vräje

When the rising sun appeared in the East, the jewel of the twice-born, Lord Gaurasundara, awakened, and, taking His devotees with Him, He went all over the countryside towns and villages.

2)

'täthaé täthaé' bäjalo khol,

ghana ghana tähe jhäjera rol,

preme òhala òhala soëära aìga,

caraëe nüpura bäje

and played the mådaìga, and the cymbals chimed in time. Lord Gauräìga's shimmering golden features danced, and His footbells jingled.

3)

mukunda mädhava yädava hari,

bolena bolo re vadana bhori',

miche nida-vaçe gelore räti,

divasa çaréra-säje

All the devotees chanted the names Mukunda, Mädhava, Yädava and Hari, their mouths being filled with the vibrations. They would announce to the still sleeping people, "You spend your nights uselessly sleeping and your days decorating your bodies!

4)

emana durlabha mänava-deha,

päiyä ki koro bhäva nä keha,

ebe nä bhajile yaçodä-suta,

carame poribe läje

You have achieved such a rare human body, but you do not care for this gift. You remain not serving the darling of Yaçodä and slowly fall through your last moments to death.

5)

udita tapana hoile asta,

dina gelo boli' hoibe byasta,

tabe keno ebe alasa hoy,

nä bhaja hådoya-räje

With every rising and setting of the sun, a day passes and is lost. Then, why do you remain idle and not serve the Lord of the heart?

6)

jévana anitya jänaha sär,

tähe nänävidha vipada-bhär,

nämäçraya kori' yatane tumi,

thäkaha äpana käje

This temporary life is full of various miseries. Take shelter of the holy name as your only business.

7)

jévera kalyäna-sädhana-käm,

jagate äsi' e madhura näm,

avidyä-timira-tapana-rüpe,

hådgagane viräje

To penetrate the darkness of ignorance and bless everyone's heart, the holy name has risen like the shining sun.

8)

kåñëa-näma-sudhä koriyä pän,

judäo bhakativinoda-präë,

näma vinä kichu nähiko ära,

caudda-bhuvana-mäjhe

Drink the pure nectar of the holy name." There is nothing but the name to be had in the fourteen worlds. It has filled the soul of Çré Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura.

SVA 2: Aruëodaya-kértana (part 2) (Jév Jägo)

ARUËODAYA-KÉRTANA (part 2)

1)

jév jägo, jév jägo, gauracända bole

kota nidrä yäo mäyä-piçäcéra kole

2)

bhajibo boliyä ese saàsära-bhitore

bhuliyä rohile tumi avidyära bhore

3)

tomäre loite ämi hoinu avatära

ämi vinä bandhu ära ke äche tomära

4)

enechi auñadhi mäyä näçibäro lägi'

hari-näma mahä-mantra lao tumi mägi'

5)

bhakativinoda prabhu-caraëe poòiyä

sei hari-näma-mantra loilo mägiyä


1) Lord Gauräìga is calling, "Wake up, sleeping souls! Wake up, sleeping souls! How long will you sleep in the lap of the witch called Mäyä?

2) You have forgotten the way of devotional service and are lost in the world of birth and death.

3) I have descended just to save you; other than Myself you have no friend in this world.

4) I have brought the medicine that will wipe out the disease of illusion from which you are suffering. Take this mahä-mantra—hare kåñëa, hare kåñëa, kåñëa kåñëa, hare hare/ hare räma, hare räma räma räma, hare hare."

5) Çré Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says: "I fall at the Lord's feet, having taken this mahä-mantra."

[purport]

SVA 2: Gäy Gorä Madhur Svare

GÄY GORÄ MADHUR SVARE
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

gäy gorä madhur svare

hare kåñëa hare kåñëa kåñëa kåñëa hare hare

hare räma hare räma räma räma hare hare
gäy gorä madhur svare

refrain:
Sing the nectarean names of Gauräìga! O my Lord, please engage me in Your loving service. Sing the nectarean names of Gauräìga!

gåhe thäko, vane thäko, sadä 'hari' bole òäko,

sukhe duùkhe bhulo näko
vadane hari-näm koro re

Whether you are a householder or a sannyäsé, constantly chant, Hari, Hari! Forget about happiness and sorrow and fill your lips with hari-näma.

mäyäjäle baddha ho'ye ächa miche käj lo'ye,

ekhona cetana peye,
'rädhä-mädhav' näm bolo re

You are bound up in the ocean of mäyä and are forced to toil fruitlessly. But as soon as you come to your senses, immediately shout out the names of Rädhä-Mädhava.

jévana hoilo çeñ, nä bhajile håñékeç

bhaktivinodopadeç,
ekbär näm-rase mäta re

Without serving the Lord of the senses [Håñékeça] you are as good as a dead man. Take the advice of Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura: just once relish the nectar of the holy name.

Purport to Gäy Gaura Madhur Svare

SVA 2: Gopénätha

GOPÉNÄTHA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

part 1

gopénäth, mama nivedana çuno

viñayé durjana, sadä käma-rata,

kichu nähi mora guëa

O Gopénätha, Lord of the gopés, please hear my prayer. I am a materialistic rascal, always full of lust. I have no good qualifications.

gopénäth, ämära bharasä tumi

tomära caraëe, loinu çaraëa,

tomära kiìkora ämi

O Gopénätha! You are my only resort. As Your eternal servant, I take shelter of Your lotus feet.

gopénäth, kemone çodhibe more

nä jäni bhakati, karme jaòamati,

poòechi soàsära-ghore

O Gopénätha! How can I uplift myself? I don't know anything regarding devotional service. I am weakminded and have fallen into a pit of illusion.

gopénäth, sakali tomära mäyä

nähi mama bolo, jïäna sunirmalo,

svädéna nahe e käyä

O Gopénätha! Everything here is Your illusory energy. I have no power or pure knowledge, and I am bound by a material body.

gopénäth, niyata caraëe sthäna

mäge e pämara, kändiyä kändiyä,

korohe karuëä däna

O Gopénätha! I desire to remain always at Your lotus feet. Please take this sinner, weeping and weeping, and show me Your mercy.

gopénäth, tumi to' sakali päro

durjane tärite, tomära çakati,

ke äche päpéra ära

O Gopénätha! You can do anything. You have purified the most wicked by Your power, but who is more wicked than me?

gopénäth, tumi kåpä päräbära

jévera käraëe, äsiyä prapaïce,

lélä koile suvistära

O Gopénätha! You are the vessel of kindness. You enter into this mundane world and display Your sublime pastimes for the sake of the fallen souls.

gopénäth, ämi ki doñe doñé

asura sakala, päilo caraëa,

vinoda thäkilo bosi'

O Gopénätha! I am the sinner of sinners. Yet I sit waiting for You to take me, for many demons have attained Your lotus feet.


part 2


gopinäth, ghucäo saàsära-jvälä

avidyä-yätanä, äro nähi sohe,

janama-maraëa-mälä

O Gopénätha! Destroy the miseries of this world! I am strung on a necklace of births and deaths and cannot bear the kicking of mäyä.

gopénäth, ämi to' kämera däsa

viñaya-väsanä, jägiche hådoye,

phändiche karama phäìsa

O Gopénätha! I am a servant of lust, entangled in the net of material desire which has sprung up in my heart.

gopinäth, kabe vä jägibo ämi

käma-rüpa ari, düre teyagibo,

hådoye sphuribe tumi

O Gopénätha! When will I wake up and cast this enemy of lust far from me? Then only will You be revealed to me in my heart.

gopénäth, ämi to' tomära jana

tomäre chäòiyä, soàsära bhajinu,

bhuliyä äpana-dhana

O Gopénätha! I am Your own. By leaving Your lotus feet, forgetting Your treasures, I have served only mäyä.

gopinäth, tumi to' sakali jäna

äpanära jane, daëòiyä ekhona,

çré-caraëe deho sthäna

O Gopénätha! You know everything. Take me to Your lotus feet and punish Your servant.

gopénäth, ei ki vicära tava

vimukha dekhiyä, chäòa nija-jane,

na koro' karuëä-lava

O Gopénätha! Is it to Your liking to reject me and not show me Your kindness?

gopénäth, ämi to' murakha ati

kise bhälo hoy, kabhu nä bujhinu,

täi heno mama gati

O Gopénätha! I am the greatest fool. I don't at all know what is good for me. I cannot understand anything. This is my fate.

gopénäth, tumi to' paëòita-boro

müòhera maìgala, tumi anveñibe,

e däse nä bhäva' paro

O Gopénätha! You are the greatest intellect. Not considering that I am Your servant, judge me without bias.


part 3


gopénäth, ämära upäya näi

tumi kåpä kori' ämäre loile,

saàsäre uddhära päi

O Gopénätha! I have no means of benefiting myself. By Your mercy and kindness, please pick me up from this miserable world and take me to You.

gopénäth, porechi mäyära phere

dhana dära suta, ghireche ämäre,

kämete rekheche jere

O Gopénätha! I have fallen into this dark world. Bound by wealth, wife and sons, I am feeling the pain of lust.

gopénäth, mana ye pägala mor

nä mäne çäsana, sadä acetana,

viñaye ro yeche ghora

O Gopénätha! I am going mad! Never caring for spiritual practices, I am always unconscious and deeply sunk in the muck of sense gratification.

gopinäth, hära ye menechi ämi

aneka yatana, hoilo biphala,

ekhona bharasä tumi

O Gopénätha! I surrender unto You. All my endeavors are a useless waste of time. Now I surrender unto You.

gopénäth, kemone hoibe gati

prabala indriya, vaçébhüta mana,

nä chäòe viñaya-rati

O Gopénätha! How shall I reach the goal? My mind is overwhelmed by the powerful senses. I cannot shake off attachment to worldly pleasures.

gopénäth, hådoye bosiyä mora

manake çamiyä, loha nija päne,

ghucibe vipada ghora

O Gopénätha! Please reside in my heart. Destroy these dangerous obstacles, correct my mind and guide me to Your own true path.

gopénäth, anätha dekhiyä more

tumi håñékeça, håñéka damiyä,

tär'he saàsåti-ghore

O Gopénätha! Please let Your glance fall on me. I am helpless, but You are Håñékeça, the Lord of the senses. Please control my senses and pull me out of this world of dangers.

gopénäth, goläya legeche phäìsa

kåpä-asi dhori', bandhana chediyä,

vinode koroha däsa

Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura prays:

O Gopénätha! My voice is faltering. I must throw off these shackles and catch hold of Your mercy.

Gopénätha!

SVA 2: Gurudeva (kåpä-bindu diyä)

GURUDEVA KÅPÄ-BINDU DIYÄ
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

gurudev!

kåpä-bindu diyä, koro' ei däse,

tåëäpekhä ati héna

sakala-sahane, bolo diyä koro',

nija-mäne spåhähéna

Gurudeva, give to this servant just one drop of mercy. I am lower than a blade of grass. Give me all help. Give me strength. Let me be as you are, without desires or aspirations.

sakale sammän, korite çakati,

deho' nätha! yathä yatha

tabe to' gäibo, hari-näma-sukhe,

aparädha ha'be hata

I offer you all respects, for thus I may have the energy to know you correctly. Then, by chanting the holy name in great ecstasy, all my offenses will cease

kabe heno kåpä, lobhiyä e jana,

kåtärtha hoibe, nätha!

çakti-buddhi-hén, ämi ati dén,

koro' more ätma-sätha

When will such mercy fall to this one who is weak and devoid of intelligence? Allow me to be with you.

yogyatä-vicäre, kichu nähi päi,

tomära karuëä-sära

karuëä nä hoile, kändiyä kändiyä,

präëa nä räkhibo ära

If you examine me, you will find no qualities. Your mercy is all that I am made of. If you are not merciful unto me, I can only weep, and I will not be able to maintain my life.


SVA 2: Mänasa Deha Geha

MÄNASA DEHA GEHA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1)

mänasa, deho, geho, yo kichu mora

arpilüì tuyä pade, nanda-kiçora

My mind, my body, my home, or whatever I have in my possession I surrender unto Your lotus feet, O my dear Lord, son of Nanda Mahäräja.

2)

sampade-vipade, jévane-maraëe

däya mama gelä, tuyä o-pada varaëe

In good or bad fortune, in life or at death, there is no other duty than taking shelter of Your lotus feet.

3)

märobi räkhobi—yo icchä tohärä

nitya-däsa-prati tuyä adhikärä

Now if You like You can kill me, or if You like You can give me protection. Whatever You like You can do. I am Your eternal servitor. You have every right to deal with me in any way You please.

4)

janmäobi moy icchä yadi tor

bhakta-gåhe jani janma hao mor

If I must be reborn, let that birth, by Your desire, be in the home of a devotee. Let that birth be mine.

5)

kéöa-janma hao yathä tuyä däsa

bahir-mukha brahma-janme nähi äça

Even a worm's life I'll live as Your servant, but a nondevotee Brahma's lifetime I'll never accept.

6)

bhukti-mukti-spåhä vihéna ye bhakta

lobhoite täìko saìga anurakta

If one has no aspiration for enjoyment or liberation, I simply hanker for his association.

7)

janaka, janané, dayita, tanaya

prabhu, guru, pati-tuhüì sarva-moya

Fathers, mothers, daughters, sons—all there may be—master, preceptor, husband, You are all in all to me.

8)

bhakativinod kohe, çuno käna!

rädhänätha! tuhüì hämära paräëa

Çréla Bhaktivinoda says: "O Kåñëa, do hear. Lord of Çrématé Rädhäräëé, You are my life dear."

[purport]

SVA 2: Prasäda-seväya

PRASÄDA-SEVÄYA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

part 1

çaréra avidyä-jäl, joòendriya tähe käl,

jéve phele viñaya-sägore

tär madhye jihvä ati, lobhamoy sudurmati,

tä'ke jetä koöhina soàsäre


kåñëa boòa doyämoy, kori bäre jihvä joy,

svaprasäd-anna dilä bhäi

sei annämåta khäo, rädhä-kåñëa-guëa gäo,

preme òäko caitanya-nitäi

O Lord, this material body is a place of ignorance, and the senses are a network of paths to death. Somehow, we have fallen into this ocean of material sense enjoyment, and of all the senses the tongue is most voracious and uncontrollable; it is very difficult to conquer the tongue in this world. But You, dear Kåñëa, are very kind to us and have given us such nice prasäda, just to control the tongue. Now we take this prasäda to our full satisfaction and glorify You Lord—Rädhä and Kåñëa—and in love call for the help of Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda. [purport]

part 2

ek-dina çäntipure, prabhu advaitera ghare,

dui prabhu bhojane bosilo

çäk kori' äsvädana, prabhu bole bhaktagaëa,

ei çäk kåñëa äsvädilo


haeno çäk äsvädane, kåñëa-prema äise mane,

sei preme koro äsvädana

jaòa-buddhi pari-hari', prasäda bhojana kori',

'hari hari' bolo sarva jan

One day at Çäntipura in Çré Advaita's house, Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda were seated at prasäda. When Lord Caitanya tasted the green vegetables, He said, "My devotees, this çäk is so delicious! Lord Kåñëa has definitely tasted it. Such çäk as this, when tasted, will give you a taste of kåñëa-prema." The devotees forgot their materialistic conceptions and took prasäda shouting, "Hari bol! Hari bol! Hari bol!"

SVA 2: Rädhä-Kåñëa Bol

RÄDHÄ-KÅÑËA BOL
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

'rädhä-kåñëa' bol bol bolo re sobäi

1) (ei) çikhä diyä, sab nadéyä,

phirche nece gaur-nitäi

hari-bol bolo re ei çikhä diyä

'rädhä-kåñëa' bol bol bolo re sobäi

Chant, chant "Rädhä-Kåñëa!" Everyone chant!
When Lord Caitanya and Lord Nityänanda came dancing through Nadia, They gave these teachings: Chant, chant "Rädhä-Kåñëa!" Everyone chant!


2) (miche) mäyär boçe, jäccho bhese',

khäccha häbuòubu, bhäi

hari-bol bolo re bhäi mäyär boçe

'rädhä-kåñëa' bol bol bolo re sobäi

You are caught up in a whirlpool of senseless action and are sinking lower and lower. Chant, chant "Rädhä-Kåñëa!" Everyone chant!


3) (jév) kåñëa-däs, e viçväs,

korle to' är duùkha näi

hari-bol bolo re jév kåñëa däs

'rädhä-kåñëa' bol bol bolo re sobäi

If you just understand that the spirit soul is the eternal servant of Kåñëa, you will never have any more sorrows. Chant, chant "Rädhä-Kåñëa!" Everyone chant!


4) (kåñëa) bolbe yabe, pulak ha 'be,
jhorbe äìkhi, boli täi

hari-bol bolo kåñëa bolbe jabe

'rädhä-kåñëa' bol bol bolo re sobäi

Chant Hare Kåñëa and your eyes will fill with tears and your body will feel transcendental shivering. Chant, chant "Rädhä-Kåñëa!" Everyone chant!


5) ('rädhä) kåñëa' bolo, saìge calo,

ei-mätra bhikhä cäi

hari-bol bolo rädhä kåñëa bolo

'rädhä-kåñëa' bol bol bolo re sobäi

Simply chant "Rädhä-Kåñëa" and join with us. Those are the only alms we beg. Chant, chant "Rädhä-Kåñëa!" Everyone chant!


6) (yäy) sakal vipod, bhaktivinod,

bolen, yakhon o-näm gäi

hari-bol bolo re yäy sakal vipod

'rädhä-kåñëa' bol bol bolo re sobäi

"All dangers will be gone when that Name is chanted," says Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura. Chant, chant "Rädhä-Kåñëa!" Everyone chant!

[purport]

SVA 2: Rädhä-Mädhava

RÄDHÄ-MÄDHAVA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

rädhä-mädhava kuïja-bihäré

gopé-jana-vallabha giri-vara-dhäré

yaçodä-nandana braja-jana-raïjana

yämuna-téra-vana-cäré

[synonyms]

Çré Rädhä-Mädhava have their loving pastimes in the groves (kuïja) of Våndävana. Gopé-jana-vallabha means "one who attracts and reciprocates loving pastimes with the gopés. Giri-vara-dhäré is Kåñëa's name in the pastime of lifting Govardhana Hill. Yaçodä-nandana is the son of Yaçodä ("nanda" means son and is also the name of Kåñëa's father, so Kåñëa is also Nanda-nandana). Braja-jana-raïjana means the attractive darling of the inhabitants of Våndävana. He is always playing in the groves (vana) of the bank (téra) of the Yamunä River. Therefore Kåñëa is also known as Yämuna-téra-vana-cäré.

(Çréla Prabhupäda is very fond of this song and sings it just before his lectures. In Allahabad and Gorakhpur Çréla Prabhupäda fell into a trance after singing the first two lines, and after some time he came back into external consciousness and said, "Now just chant Hare Kåñëa." Çréla Prabhupäda said that this song is "a picture of Våndävana. Everything is there—Çrématé Rädhäräëé, Våndävana, Govardhana, Yaçodä, and all the cowherd boys.")

[purport 1, 2]

SVA 2: Siddhi Lalasa (kabe gaura-bane)

SIDDHI LÄLASÄ
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

(Note—These next two songs of Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura are written under the heading of Siddhi-lälasä. Lälasä means "to hanker in great expectation," and siddhi means "perfection." Hankering in great expectation to achieve a perfectional stage is called Siddhi-lälasä. A devotee never has any desire for material enjoyment, heavenly birth, mystical powers, liberation or even the four superior stages of liberation such as attaining equal opulence to the Lord, having the same form as Lord Viñëu, always being in the presence of the Lord, or living on the same planet as the Lord in the spiritual sky. The hankering of the pure devotee is simply that he will become the servant of the Lord unconditionally. That perfectional stage is the stage to be desired).

[1]

kabe gauravane, suradhuné-taöe,

'hä rädhe hä kåñëa' bole'

käìdiyä veòäbo, deha-sukha chäòi,

nänä latä-taru-tale

[2]

çvapaca-gåhete, mägiyä khäibo,

pibo sarasvaté-jalo

puline-puline, gaòägaòi dibo,

kori' kåñëa kolähala

[3]

dhäma-väsé-jane, pranati koriyä,

mägibo kåpära leça

vaiñëava-caraëa-reëu gäya mäkhi',

dhari' avadhüta-veça

[4]

gauòa-vraja-vane, bheda nä dekhibo,

hoibo varaja-väsé

dhämera svarüpa, sphuribe nayane,

hoibo rädhära däsé

When, oh when, will I chant on the bank of the Ganges in the land of Navadvépa? O Rädhä, O Kåñëa, when will I wander among the creepers and trees with tears in my eyes and forget my bodily comforts?

When will I be satisfied by taking some food from the untouchable men who live here and there and by drinking the water of the Sarasvati? When will I roll to and fro on the banks of the river, raising an uproar of "Kåñëa! Kåñëa!"

When will I bow down to the inhabitants of the holy place of Navadvépa and obtain a bit of their mercy? When will I wear the dress of the paramahaàsas and wear the dust of the feet of the Vaiñëavas on my body?

When will I see the inhabitants of Navadvépa as nondifferent from the inhabitants of Våndävana, and when shall I become a Vrajaväsé, too? When will I see the true form of the transcendental realm opening before my eyes, and when will I attain the service of Çré Rädhäräëé?

SVA 2: Kabe Ha'be Bolo

KABE HA'BE BOLO
(Invocation of the Holy Name)
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1)

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

(ämär) aparädha ghuci', çuddha näme ruci,

kåpä-bole ha'be hådoye saïcär

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

When, oh when will that day be mine? When my offenses ceasing, taste for the name increasing, when in my heart will your mercy shine, when, oh when will that day be mine?

2)

tåëädhika hén, kabe nije mäni',

sahiñëutä-guëa hådoyete äni'

sakale mänada, äpani amäné,

ho'ye äsvädibo näma-rasa-sär

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

Lower than a blade of grass, more tolerant than a tree. When will my mind attain this quality? Respectful to all, not expecting their honour, then shall I taste the name's nectar sublime. When, oh when will that day be mine?

3)

dhana jano är, kavitä sundaré,

bolibo nä cähi deho sukhakoré

janme-janme däo, ohe gaurahari!

ahaituké bhakti caraëe tomär

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

Great wealth or followers, feminine beauty, I won't care for them or the comforts of my body. Birth after birth give me, Oh Lord Caitanya, causeless devotion to Your feet divine I when, oh when will that day be mine?

4)

(kabe) korite çré-kåñëa-näma uccäraëa,

pulakito deho gadgada vacana

vaivarëya-vepathu, ha'be saàghaöana,

nirantara netre va'be açru-dhär

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

When will I utter Kåñëa, Kåñëa, Kåñëa, with words choked up and shivering body? When will I be trembling all over, lose bodily color, tears pouring from my eyes, When, oh when will that day be mine?

5)

kabe navadvépe, suradhuné-taöe,

gaura-nityänanda boli' niñkapaöe

näciyä gäiyä, veòäibo chuöe,

bätulera präy chäòiyä vicär

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

When in Navadvépa along with Ganges bank, shouting 'Gaura-Nityänanda' as a surrendered soul, dancing, chanting, running everywhere, when will I become half mad of mind? When, oh when will that day be mine?

6)

kabe nityänanda, more kori 'doyä,

chäòäibe mora viñayera mäyä

diyä more nija-, caraëera chäyä,

nämera häöete dibe adhikär

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

When will Lord Nityänanda show mercy upon me, when will I reject the world of mäyä? Bestow unto me the shade of Your lotus feet, let the right to preach the name be mine. When, oh when will that day be mine?

7)

kinibo, luöibo, hari-näma-rasa,

näma-rase mäti' hoibo vivaça

rasera rasika-, caraëa paraça,

koriyä mojibo rase anibär

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

I will beg, borrow, or steal the nectar of the name. By the name's effect I will feel paralyzed. Oh! Enjoyer of the nectar of the name, When will I touch your lotus feet till the end of time? When, oh when will that day be mine?

8)

kabe jébe doyä, hoibe udoya,

nija-sukha bhuli' sudéna-hådoya

bhakativinod, koriyä vinoya,

çré-äjïä-öahala koribe pracär

kabe ha'be bolo se-din ämär

When kindness to all beings will be appearing, with free heart forget myself comforting, Bhaktivinoda in all humility prays, "Now I will set out to preach Your order sublime." When, oh when will that day be mine?

SVA 2: Çuddha-bhakata

ÇUDDHA-BHAKATA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1)

çuddha-bhakata-caraëa-reëu,

bhajana-anuküla

bhakata-sevä, parama-siddhi,

prema-lati-kära müla

The dust of the lotus feet of pure devotees, enthusiastic devotional service, and service to the pure devotees of the highest order are the roots of the creeper of devotion.

2)

mädhava-tithi, bhakti-janané,

yatane pälana kori

kåñëa-bosati, bosati boli',

parama ädare bori

The holy days like Ekädaçé and Janmäñöamé are the mother of devotion for those devotees who respect them. Let the holy places of Kåñëa's pastimes be my places of worship, and bless me.

3)

gaur ämära, ye-saba sthäne,

koralo bhramaëa raìge

se-saba sthäna, heribo ämi,

praëayi-bhakata-saìge

May I always visit all the holy places associated with the lélä of Lord Caitanya and His devotees.

4)

mådaìga-vädya, çunite mana,

avasara sadä yäce

gaura-vihita, kértana çuni',

änande hådoy näce

When I hear the sound of the mådaìga in my heart I always desire to join in kértana; and when I hear the bonafide songs describing Lord Caitanya's pastimes, my heart dances in ecstasy.

5)

jugala-mürti, dekhiyä mora,

parama-änanda hoya

prasäda-sevä, korite hoya,

sakala prapaïca joya

Whenever I see the transcendental çré-vigrahas of Rädhä-Kåñëa I am in bliss, for by taking Their Lordships' prasäda we can conquer over the material elements.

6)

je-dina gåhe, bhajana dekhi,

gåhete goloka bhäya

caraëa-sédhu, dekhiyä gaìgä,

sukha nä sémä päya

One day while performing devotional practices, I saw my house transformed into Goloka Våndävana. When I take the caraëämåta of the Deity, I see the holy Ganges waters that come from the feet of Lord Viñëu, and my bliss knows no bounds.

7)

tulasé dekhi', juòäya präëa,

mädhava-toñaëé jäni'

gaura-priya, çäka-sevane,

jévana särthaka mäni

By seeing the tulasé tree my heart feels joy, and Lord Mädhava (Kåñëa) is also satisfied. When I eat the prasäda favored by Lord Caitanya it is a new life's experience. (Lord Caitanya was very fond of a green vegetable preparation called çäk, and there is another song in this book that tells of the amazing effects of this type of prasäda.)

8)

bhakativinoda, kåñëa-bhajane,

anaküla päya yähä

prati-divase, parama-sukhe,

svékära koroye tähä

Bhaktivinoda concludes by saying: "Whosoever attains the stage of enthusiasm for these devotional practices will be supremely blissful wherever he may be."

[purport]

SVA 2: Bhoga-ärati (bhaja bhakata-vatsala)

ÇRÉ-BHOGA-ÄRATI
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1)

bhaja bhakata-vatsala çré gaurahari

çré gaurahari sohi goñöha-bihäré

nanda-yaçomaté-citta-hari

Worship Çré Gaurahari, who is always very affectionate to His devotees. Lord Caitanya, who is always having pastimes with many devotees, is Kåñëa Himself, the same personality who has stolen the heart of Yaçodä-Nanda.

2)

belä ho'lo, dämodara, äisa ekhona

bhoga-mandire bosi' koroha bhojana

Mother Yaçodä calls Kåñëa: "Come on, the time has come for Your meal. Now come down to the hall."

3)

nandera nideçe boise giri-vara-dhäré

baladeva-saha sakhä boise säri säri

The holder of Govardhana Hill sits down next to Çré Baladeva and all His friends,

4)

çuktä-çäkädi bhäji nälitä kuñmäëòa

òäli òälnä dugdhatumbé dadhi mocä-khaëòa

and they are served with a feast of çuktä (a bitter tasting wet vegetable which increases the appetite), then nice fried things, then squash and white squash with òäla (dahl) and thick yogurt, and vegetables made from the flower of the banana tree.

5)

mudga-boòä mäña-boòä roöikä ghåtänna

çañkulé piñöaka khér puli päyasänna

Then there are fried squares of mung òäla paddy and urad òäla paddies (baòä), capatis and rice with ghee. Then there are sweets, cakes, thick creams, cakes floating in milk, sweet rice,

6)

karpüra amåta-keli rambhä khéra-sära

amåta rasälä, amla dvädaça prakära

bananas, cheese and cream boiled together, twelve different kinds of chutneys,

7)

luci cini sarpuré läòòu rasäbalé

bhojana korena kåñëa ho'ye kutüholé

purés made with white flour and sugar, thick cream (skin of milk) laòòus, and òäla paddies boiled in sugar rice.

8)

rädhikära pakka anna vividha byaïjana

parama änande kåñëa korena bhojana

Eating these nice foodstuffs, Kåñëa feels great joy and ecstasy. Rädhäräëé Herself cooks various kinds of vegetables.

9)

chole-bole läòòu khäy çré-madhu-maìgalo

bagala bäjäy, ära deya hari-bolo

Kåñëa's brähmaëa friend Madhumaìgala is very fond of laòòus, and when he eats them he shouts, "Hari bol! Hari bol!" and makes a funny sound by slapping his sides under his armpits with his hands.

10)

rädhikädi gaëe heri' nayanera koëe

tåpta ho'ye khäy kåñëa yaçodä-bhavane

Rädhäräëé and Her gopé friends greatly delight at how Kåñëa takes prasäda at Yasoda's house.

11)

bhojanänte piye kåñëa subäsita bäri

sabe mukha prakhäloy ho'ye säri säri

12)

hasta-mukha prakhäliyä yata sakhä-gaëe

änande viçräma kore baladeva sane

13)

jambula rasäla äne tämbüla mosälä

tähä kheye kåñëa-candra sukhe nidrä gelä

14)

viçäläkha, çikhi-puccha cämara òhuläya

apürba çayyäya kåñëa sukhe nidrä jäya.

11-14) After taking sweets, Kåñëa is served with sweet drinks scented with rose water. Then all the friends of Kåñëa line up to wash their hands and mouths, and Kåñëa and Balaräma go to take rest. They take pan with fancy spices and catechu and very happily take Their rest and are fanned with a tail fan by His servant Viçäläkña.

15)

yaçomaté-äjïä peye dhaniñöhä-änéto

çré-kåñëa-prasäda rädhä bhuïje ho'ye préto

Çré Dhaniñöhä is one of Kåñëa's servants, and by Mother Yaçodä's orders he brings the prasäda that is left on Kåñëa's plate, and Rädhäräëé eats it.

16)

lalitädi sakhé-gaëa avaçeña päya

mane mane sukhe rädhä-kåñëa-guëa gäya

Lalitä-sakhé and all the other gopés also receive His prasäda and in their hearts also sing the glories of Rädhä-Kåñëa.

17)

hari-lélä ekmätra yähära pramoda

bhogärati gäy öhäkur bhakati-vinoda

Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says: "There is no other happiness than that which is found in the pastimes of Çré Hari."

bhaja govinda govinda gopäla
giri-dhäré gopé-nätha nanda-duläla
nanda-dulälal yäy gaur gopäla
bhaja bhakata vatsala çré gaurahari

SVA 2: Gaura-ärati (kiba jaya jaya goräcänder äratiko çobhä)

ÇRÉ-GAURA-ÄRATI
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1)

kiba jaya jaya goräcänder ärotiko çobhä

jähnavé-taöavane jaga-mano-lobhä

All glories, all glories to the beautiful ärati ceremony of Lord Caitanya. Lord Caitanya's beautiful form on the bank of the Jahnavé (Ganges) attracts all the living entities of the universe.

2)

dakhiëe nitäi-cänd, bäme gadädhara

nikaöe advaita, çré-niväsa chatra-dhara

On His right side is Lord Nityänanda, and on His left side is Çré Gadädhara. On either side stand Lord Çré Advaita and Çréniväsa who holds an umbrella over Lord Caitanya's head.

3)

vasiyäche gorä-cänd ratna-siàhäsane

ärati koren brahmä-ädi deva-gaëe

Lord Caitanya is seated on a golden throne. The ärati ceremony is performed by Lord Brahmä, and all the other demigods are present.

4)

narahari-ädi kori' cämara dhuläya

saïjaya-mukunda-väsughoñ-ädi gäya

Lord Caitanya's associates like Narahari and others fan Him with a whisk, and Mukunda and Väsu Ghosh are the expert singers that lead everyone in kértana.

5)

çaìkha bäje, ghaëöä bäje, bäje karatäla

madhura mådaìga bäje parama rasäla

The sounds of the conchshell, cymbals, and sweet mådaìga are very relishable to hear.

6)

bahu-koöi candra jini' vadana ujjvala

gala-deçe vana-mälä kore jhalamala

Lord Caitanya's face shines like many, many millions of moons, and His garland of forest flowers also shines.

7)

çiva-çuka-närada preme gada-gada

bhakativinoda dekhe gorära sampada

Lord Çiva, Çukadeva Gosvämé, and Närada Muni are there, and their voices are choked with transcendental loving symptoms. Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says: "Just see the opulence of Lord Caitanya!"

[681231PU.LA]

SVA 2: Çré Näma-kértana (yaçomaté-nandana)

ÇRÉ NÄMA-KÉRTANA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

(Kåñëa is very pleased when we call on Him by His Names which are associated with His devotees, qualities and pastimes. This song by Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura is composed of the Names of Kåñëa in different aspects.)


1) yaçomaté-nandana, 2) braja-baro-nägara,

3) gokulo-raïjana käna

4) gopé-paräëa-dhana, 5) madana-manohara,

6) käliya-damana-vidhäna

7) amala harinäm amiya-viläsä

8) vipina-purandara, 9) navéna nägara-bora,

10) vaàçé-vadana 11) suväsä


12) braja-jana-pälana, 13) asura-kula-näçana

14) nanda-godhana-räkhaoyälä

15) govinda mädhava, 16) navanéta-taskara,

17) sundara nanda-gopälä


18) yämuna-taöa-cara, 19) gopé-vasana-hara,

20) räsa-rasika, 21) kåpämoya

22) çré-rädhä-vallabha, 23) våndävana-naöabara,

24) bhakativinod-äçraya

1) The son of Mother Yaçodä, 2) The greatest of all the inhabitants of Vraja, 3) The attractor of the people of Gokula, 4) The heart of the gopés, 5) The One Who can even attract the mind of Cupid, 6) The destroyer of the Käliya serpent demon, 7) Chanting the Lord's Name is my pastime. 8) He Who plays in the garden groves, 9) The ever new beauty of Våndävana, 10) He Who is always seen with His flute, 11) He Who lives in beautiful artistic craftsmanship, 12) The protector of the inhabitants of Vraja, 13) The destroyer of the descendants of the asuras, 14) He Who keeps and tends Mahäräja Nanda's cows, 15) Govinda Mädhava, 16) The butter thief, 17) The beautiful cowherd boy of Nanda Mahäräja, 18) He Who on the banks of the Yamunä 19) Stole the garments of the gopés, 20) He Who relishes the loving exchange of mellows, 21) He Who is full of mercy, 22) The attractor of Rädhäraëé, 23) The best dancer of Våndävana, 24) The shelter of Bhaktivinoda.

SVA 2: Tumi Sarveçvareçvara

TUMI SARVEÇVAREÇVARA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1) tumi sarveçvareçvara, brajendra-kumära!
tomära icchäya viçve såjana saàhära

O youthful prince of Vraja, You are the controller of all controllers. By Your whims the universe is created and destroyed.

2) tava icchämata brahmä korena såjana
tava icchämata viñnu korena pälana

By Your wish Lord Brahmä creates, by Your whims Lord Viñëu maintains,

3) tava icchämate çiva korena saàhära
tava icchämate mäyä såje kärägära

by Your wish Lord Çiva destroys, and by Your wish mäyä creates the prison of the world.

4) tava icchämate jéver janama-maraëa
samåddhi-nipäte dukha sukha-saìghaöana

By Your wish the living entities are born and are killed.

5) miche mäyä-baddha jéva äçä-päçe phire'
tava icchä vinä kichu korite nä päre

They develop and they are degraded in different stages of happiness and pain all by Your sanction.

6) tumi to' räkhaka är pälaka ämära
tomära caraëa vinä äçä nähi ära

You are my protector and maintainer. I have no other wish but to attain Your feet.

7) nija-bolo-ceñöä-prati bharasä chäòiyä
tomära icchäya ächi nirbhara koriyä

By my own endeavor I have no hope. I am completely dependent, on Your desires.

8) bhakativinoda ati déna akiïcana
tomära icchäya tä'r jévana maraëa

8) Çréla Bhaktivinoda says: "I am a very small devotee with only You to depend on. By Your wish I have my life or death."

SVA 2: Ohe! Vaiñëava Öhäkura

OHE! VAIÑËAVA ÖHÄKURA
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1)

ohe! vaiñëava öhäkura, doyära sägara,

e däse koruëä kori'

diyä pada-chäyä, çodho he ämäya,

tomära caraëa dhori

O venerable Vaiñëava, O ocean of mercy, be merciful unto your servant. Give me the shade of your lotus feet and purify me. I hold on to your lotus feet.

2)

chaya bega dami', chaya doña çodhi',

chaya guëa deho' däse

chaya sat-saìga, deha' he ämäre

boshechi saìgera äçe

Teach me to control my six passions; rectify my six faults, bestow upon me the six qualities, and offer unto me the six kinds of holy association.*

3)

ekäké ämära, nähi päy bolo,

harinäma-saìkértane

tumi kåpä kori', çraddhä-bindu diyä,

deha' kåñëa-näma-dhane

I do not find the strength to carry on alone the saìkértana of the holy name of Hari. Please bless me by giving me just one drop of faith with which to obtain the great treasure of the holy name of Kåñëa.

4)

kåñëa se tomära, kåñëa dite pära,

tomära çakati äche

ämi to' käìgala, 'kåñëa' 'kåñëa' boli',

dhäi tava päche päche

Kåñëa is yours; you have the power to give Him to me. I am simply running behind you shouting, "Kåñëa! Kåñëa!"

SVA 2: Vibhävaré Çeña

Vibhävaré Çeña
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

[1]

vibhävaré çeña, äloka-proveça,

nidrä chäòi' uöha jéva

bolo' hari hari, 1)mukunda 2)muräri,

3)räma 4)kåñëa 5)hayagréva

Now night is over. The light of dawn is entering. Wake up, sleeping souls! Chant the names of Kåñëa. He is 1) the bestower of liberation, 2) the killer of the Mura demon, 3) Lord Rämacandra, 4) all-attractive, 5) the horse incarnation whose breathing created the Vedas,

[2]

6)nåsiàha 7)vämana, 8)çré-madhusüdana,

9)brajendra-nandana 10)çyäma

11)pütanä-ghätana, 12)koiöabha-çätana,

13)jaya däçarathi-räma

6) the half-man, half-lion incarnation, 7) the one who appeared as the dwarf, 8) the killer of the Madhu demon, 9, 10) the blackish prince of Våndävana, 11, 12) the destroyer of the Pütanä and Kaiöabha witches, 13) the son of Daçaratha,

[3]

14)yaçodä duläla, 15)govinda-gopäla,

16)våndävana purandara

17)gopé-priya-jana, 18)rädhikä-ramaëa,

19)bhuvana-sundara-bora

14) the darling of Mother Yaçodä, 15) the attractor of the senses, the cows and the land, 16) the cowherd boy of Våndävana, 17) the dearmost beloved of the gopés, 18) the consort of Rädhäräëé, 19) the most beautiful personality in the universe,

[4]

20)rävaëäntakora, 21)mäkhana-taskora,

22)gopéjana-vastrahäré

23)brajera räkhälo, 24)gopa-vånda-pälo,

25)cittahäré vaàçé-dhäré

20) the bringer of the end to Rävaëa, 21) the butter thief, 22) the thief of the garments of the gopés, 23) the tender of the calves of Vraja, 24) the friend of the cowherd boys 25) He who can steal one's mind with His flute playing.

[5]

26)yogéndra-vandana, 27)çré-nanda-nandana,

28)brajajana-bhayahäré

29)navéna nérada, 30)rüpa manohara,

31)mohana-vaàçé-vihäré

26) the Lord and master of mystical perfections, 27) the son of Mahäräja Nanda, 28) He who removes all fear of the inhabitants of Vraja, 29) He who is the color of a new monsoon cloud, 30) He whose form is all enchanting, 31) the enchanting flutist,

[6]

32)yaçodä-nandana, 33)kaàsa-nisüdana,

34)nikuïja-räsa-viläsé

35)kadamba-känana, 36)räsa-paräyaëa,

37)vånda-vipina-niväsé

32) the son of Yaçodä, 33) the killer of Kaàsa, 34) He who enjoys the räsa-lélä in the groves of Våndävana, 35) and plays in the grove where the kadamba flowers grow, 36) who is controlled by loving mellows, 37) who lives in the groves of Våndävana,

[7]

38)änanda-vardhana, 39)prema-niketana,

40)phula-çara-yojaka käma

41)gopäìga-nägaëa, 42)citta-vinodana,

43)samasta-guëagaëa-dhäma

38) who is always increasing in ecstasy, 39) the reservoir of love, 40) who is decorated with flowers, 41) who jokes with the cowherd boys, 42) who is the pleasure of our consciousness, 43) the abode of all qualities,

[8]

44)yämuna-jévana, 45)keli-paräyaëa,

46)mänasa-candra-cakora

näma-sudhärasa, gäo kåñëa-yaça

räkho vacana mana mora

44) the life of the Yamunä, 45) who is always playful, 46) and is the moonlight of our mind, which is like the cakora bird that exists upon moonlight.

Chant these pure vibrations of the Lord's glories. Take these words of mine (Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura) and keep them with you always.

[purport]

SVA 2: Vidyära viläse

VIDYÄRA VILÄSE
by Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura

1)

vidyära viläse, käöäinu käla,

parama sähase ämi

tomära caraëa, nä bhajinu kabhu,

ekhona çaraëa tumi

Once I spent long, long hours in the pastimes of scholarship. I never took to service of Your lotus feet as I do now.

2)

paòite paòite, bharasä bäòilo,

jïäne gati habe mäni'

se äçä viphala, se jïäna durbalo,

se jïäna ajïäna jäni

Reading on and on, never finding satiation, I felt that knowledge would be the highest goal. That hope was false and fruitless—that knowledge was ignorance.

3)

jaòavidyä yata, mäyära vaibhava,

tomära bhajane bädhä

moha janamiyä, anitya soàsäre,

jévake koroye gädhä

Materialistic studies are the glare of mäyä only, for they are an obstacle to spiritual progress. The infatuated person is trapped in the nonpermanent world and falsely trying to enjoy it, and such studies make him as foolish as an ass.

4)

sei gädhä ho'ye, soàsärera bojhä,

bahinu aneka kälo

värdhakye ekhona, çaktira abhäve,

kichu nähi läge bhälo

When they stretch out over a long period of time, one loses all energy and is sapped of all power to enjoy. By the time old age comes, nothing in the world is tasteful for such an ass.

5)

jévana yätanä, hoilo ekhona,

se vidyä avidyä bhelo

avidyära jvälä, ghaöilo viñama,

se vidyä hoilo çelo

Now at the end of life I realize that all my academic study is ignorance. Realization of this fact is burning like a piercing dart.

6)

tomära caraëa, vinä kichu dhana,

soàsäre nä äche ära

bhakativinod, jaòavidyä chäòi,'

tuyä pada kore sära

Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura says: "Without Your lotus feet there is no value in the world. Reflecting upon my material studies, I take to Your lotus feet and superexcellence."


SVA 3: Songs of Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkura

Songs of Çréla Narottama däsa Öhäkura

SVA 3: Ei-bära karuëä

EI-BÄRA KARUËÄ
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

1)

ei-bäro koruëä koro vaiñëava gosäi

patita-pävana tomä vine keho näi

O Vaiñëava Gosvämé, please be merciful to me this one time. You are the savior of the fallen; without you there is no one.

2)

yähära nikaöe gele päpo düre yäy

emana dayäla prabhu kebä kothä päya

Just by being in your presence, sins go far away. Where can anyone find such kindness?

3)

gaìgara paraça hoile paçcäte pävan

darçane pavitra koro-ei tomära guë

Merely by the touch of the waters of the sacred Ganges one becomes liberated, even if he is the lowest of mankind; but just by seeing you, the same effect is achieved. Such is your quality.

4)

hari-sthäne aparädhe täre harinäm

tomä-sthäne aparädhe nähi pariträë

If one commits an offense at the feet of Lord Hari, he can be forgiven if he chants the holy name. But if one offends you, there is no salvation for him.

5)

hari-sthäne aparädhe täre harinäm

tomä-sthäne aparädhe nähi pariträë

In your heart Lord Govinda is always resting. Çré Govinda Himself says, "I am the living force of My devotees."

6)

prati-janme kari äçä caraëera dhüli

narottame koro doyä äpnära boli'

I hope that in every birth I will obtain the dust of your lotus feet. Çré Narottama prays, "Please, O Vaiñëava Gosvämé, be kind unto me."

SVA 3: Hari Hari! vifale

HARI HARI! VIPHALE
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

[1]

hari hari! vifale janama goìäinu

manuñya-janama päiyä, rädhä-kåñëa nä bhajiyä,

jäniyä çuniyä viña khäinu

[2]

golokero prema-dhana, hari-näma-saìkértana,

rati nä janmilo kene täya

soàsära-biñänale, dibäniçi hiyä jvale,

juòäite nä kainu upäya

[3]

vrajendra-nandana yei, çacé-suta hoilo 'sei,

balaräma hoilo nitäi

déna-héna yata chilo, hari-näme uddhärilo,

tä'ra çäkñé jagäi-mädhäi

[4]

hä hä prabhu nanda-suta, våñabhänu-sutä-yuta,

karuëä koroho ei-bäro

narottama-däsa koy, nä öheliho räìgä päy,

tomä vine ke äche ämära


O Lord Hari, my life I've simply spoiled. Although I've taken this rare human birth, like a miser, I've not served my Lord. I've no love for You, Rädhä and Kåñëa, and so quite purposefully I've drunk poison.

From Goloka Våndävana comes the chant of Hare Kåñëa—such spiritual sounds vibrate only from the planets of God. How unlucky that I've no taste for nectar such as this, no love for transcendental bliss.

All matter is on blazing fire, and it is always burning my heart. Though ablaze, I've no desire to escape. Though my mind and body burn, I remain bound, trying to enjoy this holocaust.

Lord Caitanya, son of Mother Çacé, formerly son of Nanda Mahäräja, has now appeared with Lord Nityänanda, formerly Balaräma. They come chanting the holy names—Hari, Räma, Kåñëa.

Chanting Kåñëa's names, They extricate all kinds of fallen, sinful entities from the blaze of this dark age of iron. Even two drunkards, Jagäi and Mädhäi, are delivered, purified by Their songs.

My Lord Kåñëa, son of Nanda Mahäräja, now You are before me with Rädhäraëé, daughter of King Våñabhänu. O Lord! Please cast your glance of mercy upon me. I Narottama däsa, now plead to You, Lord.

Now I surrender to You fully. Please don't kick Narottama däsa away, for he has no shelter but Your lotus feet. Glance mercifully, O Lord, glance mercifully on Narottama dasa, who is pleading at Your feet.

[681113LE.LA, 681226PU.LA, 690910PU.HAM]

SVA 3: Hari he dayäla

HARI HE DAYÄLA
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

1)

hari he dayälo mora jaya rädhä-nätha

bäro bäro ei-bäro laho nija-sätha

O Çré Hari! O Lord of Rädha! Be kind unto me again and again. Please, this time, take me to Your lotus feet.

2)

bahu yoni bhrami' nätha! loinu çaraëa

nija-guëe kåpä koro' adhama-täraëa

Through many wombs have I traveled before surrendering to You. Please pick me up—I, who am unqualified.

3)

jagata-käraëa tumi jagata-jévana

tomä chäòä kara nahi he rädhä-ramaëa

You are the cause and divine force of the universe, and there is no other controller than You. O Supreme Lord, O bliss of Rädha,

4)

bhubana-maìgala tumi bhuvanera pati

tumi upekhile nätha ki hoibe gati

You are the only source of good fortune in this world, and You are its master. Please instruct me as to my true goal and resting place.

5)

bhäviyä dekhinu ei jagata mäjhäre

tomä vinä keho nähi e däse uddhäre

I have seen and considered this whole world, and without You, Kåñëa, there is nothing that can save me.

SVA 3: Lälasä-mayé ('gauräìga' bolite habe)

LÄLASÄMAYÉ [from Prärthanä]
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

[1]

'gauräìga' bolite ha'be pulaka çaréra

'hari hari' bolite nayane ba' be néra

[2]

ära kabe nitäi-cäìdera koruëä hoibe

soàsära-väsanä mora kabe tuccha ha'be

[3]

viñaya chäòiyä kabe çuddha ha 'be mana

kabe häma herabo çré-våndävana

[4]

rüpa-raghunätha-pade hoibe äkuti

kabe häma bujhabo se yugala-périti

[5]

rüpa-raghunätha-pade rahu mora äça

prärthanä koroye sadä narottamo-däsa

[681229PU.LA]

SVA 3: Purport to Lälasä-mayé Prärthanä

Purport
by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

This song was sung by Narottama däsa Öhäkura, a great devotee and äcärya in the Gauòéya Vaiñëava-sampradäya, the disciplic succession coming down from Lord Caitanya. Narottama däsa Öhäkura has written many songs which are recognized as authority by all Vaiñëavas. He has sung these songs in simple Bengali language, but the purport—the deep meaning of his songs—is very significant.

In this song he says, 'gauräìga' bolite ha'be pulaka çaréra. One has attained the perfection of chanting when as soon as he chants the name of Lord Gauräìga, who initiated this saìkértana movement, at once there is shivering in his body. This is not to be imitated, but Narottama däsa Öhäkura is asking, "When will that opportune moment come to us when there will be shivering of the body as soon as we chant Lord Gauräìga's name?" And after the shivering: 'hari hari' bolite nayane ba 'be néra: "while chanting Hare Kåñëa, there will be tears in the eyes."

Then he says, ära kabe nitäi-cäìdera koruëä hoibe. We are all asking about the mercy of Lord Nityänanda. Nityänanda is supposed to be the original spiritual master, so we have to approach Gauräìga, Lord Caitanya, through the mercy of Lord Nityänanda. What is the symptom of a person who has achieved the causeless mercy of Lord Nityänanda? Narottama däsa Öhäkura says that the symptom of one who has actually received the causeless mercy of Lord Nityänanda is that he has no more material desire. Ära kabe nitäi-cändera koruëä hoibe soàsära-väsanä mora kabe tuccha ha'be. Soàsära-väsanä means desire for material enjoyment, and Narottama däsa wonders when it will become very insignificant. Of course, as long as we have bodies we have to accept so many material things, but not in the spirit of enjoyment, but only to keep body and soul together.

Narottama däsa says further, rüpa-raghunätha-pade hoibe äkuti: "When shall I be very much eager to study the books left by the six Gosvämés?" Äkuti means eagerness. Because Rüpa Gosvämé is the father of devotional service, he has written a book called Bhakti-rasämåta-sindhu in which there are nice directions on devotional service. These topics are also dealt with in Caitanya-caritämåta and other books, and we have given the summary of those directions in our book, Teachings of Lord Caitanya. One has to learn of the conjugal loving affairs of Rädhä-Kåñëa through the teachings of these six Gosvämés. Narottama däsa Öhäkura directs us not to try to understand the conjugal love of Rädhä-Kåñëa by our own endeavor. We should try to understand this yugala-périti, conjugal love, under the direction of the Gosvämés.

As long as the mind is too much absorbed in the materialistic thought, one cannot enter into the kingdom of Våndävana. But Narottama däsa Öhäkura says, viñaya chäòiyä kabe çuddha habe mana kabe häma herabo çré-våndäbana: "When the mind is completely purified, being freed from material anxieties and desires, then I shall be able to understand Våndävana and the conjugal love of Rädhä and Kåñëa, and then my spiritual life will be successful."

[purport 1, 2, 3]

SVA 3: Näma-saìkértana (hari haraye namaù kåñëa)

HARI HARAYE NAMAÙ

[1]

(hari) haraye namaù, kåñëa yädaväya namaù

yädaväya mädhaväya keçaväya namaù
[Ädi 17.122]

[2]

gopäla govinda räma çré-madhusüdan

giri-dhäré gopé-nätha madana-mohan

[3]

çré-caitanya nityänanda çré-advaita sétä

hari, guru, vaiñëava, bhägavata, gétä

[4]

çré-rüpa, çré-sanätana, bhaööa-raghunäth

çré-jéva gopäla-bhaööa däsa-raghunäth

[5]

ei chay gosäi kori caraëa-vandan

yähä hoite vighnanäç abhéñöa-püraë

[6]

ei chay gosäi yär, mui täro däs

täì'sabära pada-reëu mora païca-gräs

[7]

tädera caraëa sevi bhakta-sane väs

janame janame hoy ei abhiläñ

[8]

ei chay gosäi yabe braje koilä väs

rädhä-kåñëa-nitya-lélä korilä prokäç

[9]

änande bolo hari, bhaja våndävan

çré-guru-vaiñëava-pade majäiyä man

[10]

çré-guru-vaiñëava-päd-padma kori äç

näma-saìkértana kohe narottama däs

SVA 3: Purport to Näma-saìkértana

Purport
by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

This song of Çréla Narottama Däsa Öhäkura is very famous among devotees in Bengal and Orissa. When Lord Caitanya returned from Gayä, where He was initiated by Çré Éçvara Puré, He was completely transformed into a God-intoxicated personality whom His students of grammar had never known before. Instead of teaching ordinary grammar studies, Lord Caitanya explained every sentence in such a way that every Sanskrit word and every letter was understood to indicate Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This form of grammar was later on developed by Çréla Jéva Gosvämé in a book called Hari-nämämåta-vyäkaraëa, The Grammar of the Nectar and Name of Çré Hari. But Lord Caitanya's students thought that their teacher had become mad, and they rubbed His head with Viñëu oil, an oil that cools the brain. Finally they asked Him, "You say that everything means Kåñëa and we should ultimately always be chanting the names of Kåñëa. Just how should we do this?" Then Lord Caitanya began to sing the names of Kåñëa and clap His hands, and He began His näma-saìkértana movement. The names He sang are the first two lines of this song, and Narottama Däsa Öhäkura and others have placed these names in the beginning of their writings to immortalize these events in the memory of everyone.

Narottama Däsa Öhäkura chants the names of Lord Caitanya, Nityänanda, Çré Advaita and Sétä (Lord Advaita's consort). Since Lord Hari, the spiritual master, and the Çrémad Bhagavad-gétä are all on the transcendental platform, they are given the same respect. Then Çréla Narottama Däsa chants the names of the six Gosvämés. "I offer my obeisances at their feet," he sings, "which destroy sufferings accumulated over many long years. I am the servant of these six Gosvämés, and the dust of their lotus feet is my five kinds of foodstuffs. To serve their lotus feet and keep the association of devotees is my only business, birth after birth." When the six Gosvämés were staying at Våndävana, they revealed the eternal transcendental pastimes of Çré Çré Rädhä-Kåñëa. Before Lord Caitanya the exact location of the places of Lord Kåñëa's pastimes were not known, and therefore Lord Caitanya instructed the Gosvämés to uncover the holy places and construct temples. The temple of Çré Rädhä Dämodara is situated near the location of the räsa dance, and Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé and the other Gosvämés used to gather there and discuss the topics of their literatures, which scientifically explained the super-excellent pastimes of Çré Çré Rädhä-Kåñëa. By revelation of the places of Rädhä-Kåñëa's pastimes, by excavation and by authoritative books, they revealed the pastimes of Çré Çré Rädhä-Kåñëa. Narottama Däsa Öhäkura says, "In great ecstasy shout the name of Hari and serve the real transcendental master and devotees." He concludes by saying, "With all hopes in the lotus feet of my guru and the holy Vaiñëavas, Narottama Däsa sings the saìkértana of Lord Hari—Hare Kåñëa Hare Kåñëa Kåñëa Kåñëa Hare Hare/Hare Räma Hare Räma Räma Räma Hare Hare."

SVA 3: Sakhé-vånde Vijïapti (rädhä-kåñëa präëa mora)

SAKHÉVÅNDE VIJÏAPTI
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

1) rädhä-kåñëa präëa mora, yugala-kiçora

jévane maraëe gati, ära nähi mora

O Radha-Krsna, Rädhä-Kåñëa! Rädhä-Kåñëa, my living force! O youthful couple, in life or death I have nothing more than You.

2) kälindéra küle keli,-kadambera vana

ratana-vedéra uparo, bosäbo dujana

On the banks of the Yamunä in a grove of flowering kadamba trees, I will prepare a golden throne and seat You there.

3) çyäma-gauré aìge dibo, candanera gandha

cämara òhuläbo kabe, heribo mukha-candra

I will anoint Your dark and fair forms with sandalwood pulp scented with aguru. I will fan You with a peacock tail fan and see Your two moonlike faces.

4) gänthiyä mälatéra mälä, dibo dohära gale

adhare tuliyä dibo, karpüra-tämbüle

I will string garlands of mälaté flowers and place them around Your Lordships' necks, and for Your lotus lips I will offer betel leaves scented with camphor.

5) lalitä viçäkhä-ädi, yata sakhévånda

äjïäya karibo sevä, caraëäravinda

By the side of Lalitä and Viçäkhä I will stand, ready to fulfill any order of service at their lotus feet.

6) çré-kåñëa-caitanya-prabhura, däsera anudäsa

sevä abhiläña kore, narottama-däsa

Narottama däsa, the servant of the servant of the servant of Lord Caitanya, says: "Allow me to engage in these pastimes of devotional service."


SVA 3: Sapärñada-gaura-viraha-viläpa (je änilo prema-dhana)

SAPÄRÑADA-GAURA-VIRAHA-VILÄPA
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

1) ye änilo prema-dhana karuëä pracur

heno prabhu kothä gelä äcärya öhäkur

That personality who delivered the treasure of prema-bhakti, who was so intense with compassion—where is such a personality to be found as Çré Äcärya Öhäkura (Çréniväsa Äcärya)?

2) kähä mora svarüpa-rüpa kähä sonätan

kähä däsa-raghunätha patita-pävan

Where are the saviors of the fallen souls? Where is my Svarüpa Dämodara, and where are Rüpa Gosvämé and Sanätana Gosvämé? Where is Raghunätha däsa to be found?

3) kähä mora bhaööa-yuga kähä kaviräj

eka-käle kothä gelä gaurä naöa-räj

Where are my Raghunätha Bhaööa and Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämés? Where am I to find Çré Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja now? All at once they have gone to join Lord Gauräìga, the great dancer.

4) päñäëe kuöibo mäthä, anale paçibo

gauräìga guëera nidhi kothä gele päbo

To reach such a perfect personality as Lord Caitanya, I can only break my head against the stone in the anguish of separation.

5) se saba saìgéra saìge ye koilo viläs

se saìga nä päiyä kände narottamo däs

They have all gone off together in their own lélä (pastimes). Narottama däsa Öhäkura says: "Unable to obtain their association, I must simply weep."


SVA 3: Sävaraëa-gaura-mahimä (gauräìgera duöi pada)

SÄVARAËA-GAURA-MAHIMÄ
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

[1]

gauräìgera duöi pada, yära dhana-sampada,

se jäne bhakati-rasa-sära

gauräìgera madhura-lélä, yära karëe praveçilä,

hådoy nirmala bhelo tära

[2]

ye gauräìgera näma loya, tära hoy premodoya,

täre muïi yäi balihäri

gauräìga-guëete jhure, nitya-lélä täre sphure,

se jana bhakati-adhikäré

[3]

gauräìgera saìgi-gaëe, nitya-siddha kori mäne,

se yäya vrajendra-suta-päça

çré-gauòa-maëòala-bhümi, yebä jäne cintämaëi,

tära hoy vrajabhüme väsa

[4]

gaura-prema-rasärëave, çe taraìge yebä òube,

se rädhä-mädhava-antaraìga

gåhe vä vanete thäke, 'hä gauräìga' bole òäke,

narottama mäge tära saìga

SVA 3: Purport to Sävaraëa-gaura-mahimä

Purport
by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

This is a song by Narottama däsa Öhäkura in praise of the glories of Lord Caitanya. Gauräìga refers to Lord Caitanya, who has a fair complexion. One who has a fair complexion is called gaura, and since Lord Caitanya was very fair, just like molten gold, He was also named Gaurasundara. Narottama däsa Öhäkura says, gauräìgera duöi pada, yära dhana-sampada, se jäne bhakati-rasa-sära. Anyone who has accepted the two lotus feet of Lord Caitanya can understand the true essence of devotional service. Devotional service is very difficult. It cannot be understood by any ordinary man. As it is stated in the Bhagavad-gétä, out of many thousands of persons who are trying to achieve the perfection of human life, only some actually become perfect and realize the self. And out of many thousands of such self-realized persons, only one can understand Kåñëa. Without understanding Kåñëa, how can one engage himself in the service of Kåñëa? Therefore, the devotional service of Kåñëa is not an ordinary thing. But, fortunately, if one follows in the footsteps of Lord Caitanya (gauräìgera duöi pada) by following the path shown by Lord Caitanya—the process of simply chanting Hare Kåñëa—he can very easily understand what devotional service is. Therefore, Narottama däsa Öhäkura prays that one take shelter of Lord Caitanya and follow in His footsteps, for then one can understand the essence of devotional service.

Lord Caitanya's pastimes are very pleasing because the basic principles of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu's movement are chanting, dancing, and eating Kåñëa prasäda. He made His headquarters in Jagannätha Puré and would dance, chant, and then immediately call for prasäda to be distributed to the devotees. They were so pleased that every day hundreds of men would come to chant and dance with Lord Caitanya. The temple proprietor, the King of Orissa, Mahäräja Pratäparudra, had an open order to the workers in the temple to supply as much prasäda to Lord Caitanya's devotees as they wanted. Therefore, His pastimes are very pleasant: chant, dance, and take prasäda. If one is captivated by the pastimes of Lord Caitanya, simply by chanting and dancing and eating prasäda the dirty things in his heart will all become cleansed. The heart of anyone who takes to this movement of chanting, dancing, and eating Kåñëa prasäda will surely be cleansed of all dirty material contamination. Narottama däsa Öhäkura says very rightly, gauräìgera madhura-lélä, yära karëe praveçilä, hådoy nirmala bhelo tära: if one wants to cleanse his heart, he must take to the movement of Lord Caitanya, Kåñëa consciousness.

Lord Caitanya is so nice that one who simply takes the holy name of Gaurasundara, Çré Kåñëa Caitanya, will immediately develop love of God. Generally, devotees first chant çré-kåñëa-caitanya prabhu nityänanda, for the preliminary process of cleansing the heart is to invoke the mercy of Lord Caitanya, Lord Nityänanda, and Their associates. Lélä means "pastimes." Without associates there cannot be pastimes, so Caitanya Mahäprabhu is always accompanied by associates—Nityänanda, Advaita, Gadädhara, Çréväsa, and many other devotees. Tära means "his," hoy means "it is effected," and premodoy refers to development of love of God. Simply by chanting çré-kåñëa-caitanya prabhu nityänanda one immediately develops love of God. To such a person Narottama däsa Öhäkura says, "Bravo!" to encourage him in chanting Lord Caitanya's name and dancing: just as we clap and say, "Bravo!" similarly he says, yäi bolihäri: "Very nice. Excellent!"

Then he says, gauräìga-guëete jhure, nitya-lélä täre sphure: if one appreciates the merciful pastimes of Lord Caitanya and feels ecstasy and sometimes cries, this process will immediately help him to understand the pastimes of Rädhä-Kåñëa, which are called nitya-lélä. The loving affairs between Rädhä-Kåñëa are not a temporary thing. Here in this material world we can see loving affairs between boys and girls, but that is temporary. That is simply for a few months, a few years, or maybe a little more. But then all that so-called love will go to hell. They are not permanent affairs. But if one really wants permanent love affairs, he must enter into the pastimes of Rädhä-Kåñëa. Simply by appreciating Lord Caitanya's movement one can immediately enter into or understand Rädhä-Kåñëa's eternal pastimes. One who can understand the transcendental eternal pastimes of Rädhä-Kåñëa reaches the highest perfectional stage of devotional service.

The next line is, gauräìgera saìgi-gaëe. Saìgi-gaëe means "associates." Lord Caitanya is always associated: He is not alone. We never see a picture of Lord Caitanya alone. At least there must be Lord Nityänanda or Gadädhara Paëòita. Actually, wherever Lord Caitanya was present, many thousands of devotees would assemble. Such devotees, especially those who were His nearest intimate associates, were nitya-siddha. In the devotional line there are three kinds of perfect devotees. One is called sädhana-siddha. This refers to a person who has very rigidly performed the regulative prescriptions and thereby reached the perfectional stage. Reaching the perfectional stage by executing the regulative principles is called sädhana-siddha. There is another devotee who is called kåpä-siddha. He may not have executed the regulative principles very rigidly, but by his service mood he is specifically blessed by the spiritual master or Kåñëa. He is immediately promoted to the perfectional stage. This is called kåpä-siddha. Nitya-siddha is one who was never contaminated by the material nature. The sädhana-siddhas and the kåpä-siddhas were supposed to have once been in the contamination of material nature, but nitya-siddhas never came into contact with the material nature. All the associates of Caitanya Mahäprabhu are nitya-siddhas, or eternally perfect. Nityänanda Prabhu is Balaräma, the immediate expansion of Kåñëa; Advaita Prabhu is Mahä-Viñëu. He is also viñëu-tattva. Gadädhara Prabhu is an expansion of Rädhäräëé, and Çréväsa is an incarnation of Närada. They are nitya-siddha, or eternally perfect. They were never imperfect. They were never in contact with material contamination. We should understand that as Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu, Kåñëa Himself, is transcendental, similarly, His personal associates are also nitya-siddha, or eternally transcendental. Se yäya vrajendra-suta-päça. Vrajendra-suta means Kåñëa. Simply by accepting that the associates of Lord Caitanya are eternally free, one can immediately be promoted to the transcendental abode of Lord Kåñëa.

Çré-gauòa-maëòala-bhümi. Gauòa means West Bengal. Lord Caitanya appeared in West Bengal, Navadvépa, and He especially flooded that part of the country with the saìkértana movement. That part of the country has special significance, for it is non-different from Våndävana. It is as good as Våndävana. Living in Våndävana and living in Navadvépa are the same. Narottama däsa Öhäkura says, çré-gauòa-maëòala-bhümi, yebä jäne cintämaëi. Cintämaëi means the transcendental abode. Tära hoy vrajabhüme väsa. If one simply understands that this land of Navadvépa is not different from Våndävana, then he actually lives in Våndävana. One should not think that he is living in Bengal or any material country; the places where Lord Caitanya had His pastimes are as good as Våndävana.

Lord Caitanya's distribution of this love of God is compared with an ocean (rasa-arëava). What kind of ocean? Not this salty ocean that one cannot taste. The water of this ocean is so nice that if one drinks even one drop, he will like it more and more. It is not ordinary ocean water, of which one cannot taste even a drop. Therefore it is called rasärëava. In that ocean there are different waves; an ocean does not stand still, for it is not impersonal or void. And as the ocean is always dancing with waves, similarly the ocean of transcendental love of Kåñëa as introduced by Lord Caitanya has constant waves, constant sound. One has to dive deep into that ocean. If one knows the secret and says, "Let me dive deep into the ocean of the transcendental loving movement introduced by Lord Caitanya," he immediately becomes one of the confidential devotees of Rädhä and Kåñëa.

Therefore Narottama däsa Öhäkura concludes this song by saying, gåhe vä vanete thäke, 'hä gauräìga' bole òäke. It is not necessary that one become a mendicant or give up his family life and society. One can remain wherever he finds it suitable, whether as a householder, as a brahmacäré, as a vänaprastha, or as a sannyäsé. Vänaprasthas and sannyäsés are supposed to live outside of the city. Vanete means forest. Formerly, those who were in spiritual consciousness used to live in the forest to become free of the turmoil of city life. But that is not possible now. In this age, no one can go into the forest. That requires practice, and no one is practiced to that line. Therefore generally one is recommended to live with his friends, wife and children; that doesn't matter. But he must take to the process of Kåñëa consciousness as introduced by Lord Caitanya. It is not difficult. The real thing is that one has to accept the movement of Lord Caitanya: chanting, dancing and eating Kåñëa-prasäda. Even if one is in family life, there is no difficulty. He can just sit down, chant Hare Kåñëa, dance nicely, and then take Kåñëa-prasäda. Everyone can do this. Those who have renounced this world, sannyäsés, also can do it; there is no difficulty. Therefore Narottama däsa Öhäkura says that it doesn't matter whether one is a brahmacäré, gåhastha, or sannyäsé. He says, "If you have taken to these principles of life, I desire your company, because you are a devotee of Lord Caitanya." In this way, Narottama däsa Öhäkura finishes the song.

[purport 2]

SVA 3: Çré Guru-vandanä (çré-guru-caraëa-padma)

ÇRÉ-GURU-CARAËA-PADMA
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

1)

çré-guru-caraëa-padma, kevala-bhakati-sadma,

bando mui sävadhäna mate

yähära prasäde bhäi, e bhava toriyä yäi,

kåñëa-präpti hoy yähä hoite

The lotus feet of our spiritual master are the only way by which we can attain pure devotional service. I bow to his lotus feet with great awe and reverence. By his grace one can cross the ocean of material suffering and obtain the mercy of Kåñëa.

2)

guru-mukha-padma-väkya, cittete koriyä aikya

är nä koriho mane äçä

çré-guru-caraëe rati, ei sei uttama-gati,

ye prasäde püre sarva äçä

My only wish is to have my consciousness purified by the words emanating from his lotus mouth. Attachment to his lotus feet is the perfection that fulfills all desires.


3)

cakhudäna dilo yei, janme janme prabhu sei,

dibya-jïän håde prokäçito

prema-bhakti yähä hoite, avidyä vinäça yäte,

vede gäy yähära carito

He opens my darkened eyes and fills my heart with transcendental knowledge. He is my Lord birth after birth. From him ecstatic prema emanates; by him ignorance is destroyed. The Vedic scriptures sing of his character.


4)

çré-guru karuëä-sindhu, adhama janära bandhu,

lokanäth lokera jévana

hä hä prabhu koro doyä, deho more pada-chäyä,

ebe yaça ghuñuk tribhuvana

Our spiritual master is the ocean of mercy, the friend of the poor, and the lord and master of the devotees. O master! Be merciful unto me. Give me the shade of your lotus feet. Your fame is spread all over the three worlds.

SVA 3: Çré-Kåñëa-caitanya prabhu

ÇRÉ KÅÑËA CAITANYA PRABHU
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

[1]

çré-kåñëa-caitanya prabhu dayä koro more

tomä vinä ke dayälu jagat saàsäre

[2]

patita-pävana-hetu tava avatära

mo-samo patita prabhu nä päibe ära

[3]

hä hä prabhu nityänanda premänanda-sukhé

kåpäbalokana koro ämi boro duùkhé

[4]

doyä koro sétä-pati advaita gosäi

tava kåpäbole päi caitanya-nitäi

[5]

hä hä svarüpa, sanätana, rüpa, raghunäth

bhaööa-yuga, çré-jéva, hä prabhu lokanäth

[6]

dayä koro çré-äcärya prabhu çréniväs

rämacandra-saìga mäge narottamo däs

[680717PU.MON]

SVA 3: Purport to Çré-Kåñëa-caitanya prabhu

Purport
by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

This is a song composed by Narottama däsa Öhäkura. He prays to Lord Caitanya, "My dear Lord, please be merciful to me, because who can be more merciful than Your Lordship within these three worlds?" Actually, this is a fact. Not only Narottama däsa Öhäkura, but Rüpa Gosvämé also prayed to Lord Caitanya in this way. At the time of the first meeting of Lord Caitanya and Rüpa Gosvämé at Prayäg (Allahabad), Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé said, "My dear Lord, You are the most munificent of all incarnations because You are distributing love of Kåñëa, Kåñëa consciousness." When Kåñëa was personally present He simply asked us to surrender, but He did not distribute Himself so easily. He made conditions—"First of all you surrender." But this incarnation, Lord Caitanya, although Kåñëa Himself, makes no such condition. He simply distributes: "Take love of Kåñëa." Therefore Lord Caitanya is approved as the most munificent incarnation. Narottama däsa Öhäkura says, "Please be merciful to me. You are so magnanimous because You have seen the fallen souls of this age, and You are very much compassionate to them, but You should know also that I am the most fallen. No one is more greatly fallen than me." Patita-pävana-hetu tava avatära: "Your incarnation is just to reclaim the conditioned, fallen souls, but I assure You that You will not find a greater fallen soul than me. Therefore, my claim is first."

Then he prays to Lord Nityänanda. He says, hä hä prabhu nityänanda premänanda-sukhé. "My dear Lord Nityänanda, You are always joyful in spiritual bliss. Since You always appear very happy, I have come to You because I am most unhappy. If You kindly put Your glance over me, I may also become happy." Then he prays to Advaita Prabhu. Dayä koro sétä-pati advaita gosäi. Advaita Prabhu's wife's name was Sétä. Therefore He is sometimes addressed as sétä-pati. Thus Narottama däsa Öhäkura prays, "My dear Advaita Prabhu, husband of Sétä, You are so kind. Please be kind to me. If You are kind to me, naturally Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda will also be kind to me." Actually, Advaita Prabhu invited Lord Caitanya to come down. When Advaita Prabhu saw that the fallen souls were all engaged simply in sense gratificatory processes, not understanding Kåñëa consciousness, he felt very much compassionate toward the fallen souls, and he also felt himself incapable of claiming them all. He therefore prayed to Lord Kåñëa, "Please come Yourself. Without Your personal presence it is not possible to deliver these fallen souls." Thus by His invitation Lord Caitanya appeared. Naturally, Narottama däsa Öhäkura prays to Advaita Prabhu, "If You will be kind to me, naturally Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda also will be kind to me."

Then he prays to the Gosvämés. Hä hä svarüpa, sanätana, rüpa, raghunätha. Svarüpa refers to Svarüpa Dämodara, the personal secretary of Lord Caitanya. He was always with Caitanya Mahäprabhu, and immediately arranged for whatever He wanted. Two personal attendants, Svarüpa Dämodara and Govinda, were always constantly with Lord Caitanya. Therefore Narottama däsa Öhäkura also prays to Svarüpa Dämodara and then to the six Gosvämés, the next disciples of Lord Caitanya—Çré Rüpa, Çré Sanätana, Çré Bhaööa Raghunätha, Çré Gopäla Bhaööa Gosvämé, Çré Jéva Gosvämé, and Raghunätha däsa Gosvämé. These six Gosvämés were directly instructed by Lord Caitanya to spread this movement of Kåñëa consciousness. Narottama däsa Thäkura also prays for their mercy.

After the six Gosvämés, the next äcärya was Çréniväsa Äcärya. Actually, Narottama däsa Öhäkura was in the disciplic succession after Çréniväsa Äcärya and was almost his contemporary, and his personal friend was Rämacandra Cakravarté. Therefore he prays, "I always desire the company of Rämacandra." He desires a devotee's company. The whole process is that we should always pray for the mercy of the superior äcäryas and keep company with pure devotees. Then it will be easier for us to advance in Kåñëa consciousness and receive the mercy of Lord Caitanya and Lord Kåñëa. This is the sum and substance of this song sung by Narottama däsa Öhäkura.

[purport 2]

SVA 3: Çré-Nityänanda-Niñöhä (nitäi-pada-kamala)

ÇRÉ-NITYÄNANDA-NIÑÖHÄ
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

[1]

nitäi-pada-kamala, koöi-candra-suçétala,

je chäyäya jagat juòäya

hena nitäi vine bhäi, rädhä-kåñëa päite näi,

dåòha kori dharo nitäi päy

[2]

se sambandha nähi yära, båthä janma gelo tära,

sei paçu baòo duräcära

nitäi nä bolilo mukhe, majilo soàsära-sukhe

vidyä-kule ki koribe tära

[3]

ahaìkäre matta hoiìä, nitäi-pada päsariyä,

asatyere satya kori mäni

nitäira koruëä habe, braje rädhä-kåñëa päbe,

dharo nitäi-caraëa du'khäni

[4]

nitäi-caraëa satya, tähära sevaka nitya,

nitäi-pada sadä koro äça

narottama baòo dukhé, nitäi more koro sukhé,

räkha räìgä-caraëera päça

[681221PU.LA]

SVA 3: Purport to Çré-Nityänanda-Niñöhä

Purport
by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

This is a very nice song sung by Narottama däsa Öhäkura. He advises that nitäi-pada, the lotus feet of Lord Nityänanda (kamala means lotus, and pada means feet), are a shelter where one will get the soothing moonlight not only of one but of millions of moons. We can just imagine the aggregate total value of the soothing shine of millions of moons. In this material world (jagat), which is progressing toward hell, there is always a blazing fire, and everyone is struggling hard without finding peace; therefore, if the world wants to have real peace, it should take shelter under the lotus feet of Lord Nityänanda, which are cooling like the shining of a million moons. Juòäya means relief. If one actually wants relief from the struggle of existence and actually wants to extinguish the blazing fire of material pangs, Narottama däsa Öhäkura advises, "Please take shelter of Lord Nityänanda."

What will be the result of accepting the shelter of the lotus feet of Lord Nityänanda? He says, hena nitäi vine bhäi: unless one takes shelter under the shade of the lotus feet of Lord Nityänanda, rädhä-kåñëa päite näi—it will be very difficult for him to approach Rädhä-Kåñëa. The aim of this Kåñëa consciousness movement is to enable us to approach Rädhä-Kåñëa and associate with the Supreme Lord in His sublime pleasure dance. Narottama däsa Öhäkura advises that if one actually wants to enter into the dancing party of Rädhä-Kåñëa, he must accept the shelter of the lotus feet of Lord Nityänanda.

Then he says, se sambandha nähi. Sambandha means "connection" or "contact." Anyone who has not contacted a relationship with Nityänanda is understood to have spoiled his human birth. In another song also Narottama däsa says, hari hari viphale janama goìäinu: anyone who does not approach Rädhä-Kåñëa through a relationship with Nityänanda has uselessly spoiled his life. Båthä means "useless." Janma means "life." Tära means "his," and sambandha means "relationship." Anyone who does not make a relationship with Nityänanda is simply spoiling the boon of his human form of life. Why is he spoiling it? Sei paçu boòo duräcära. Sei means "that," paçu means "animal," and duräcära means "misbehaved" or "the most misbehaved." Without elevation to Kåñëa consciousness through the mercy of Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda, life is simply spoiled in the animal propensities of sense gratification. Narottama däsa says that ordinary animals can be tamed, but when a human being is animalistic, having only animal propensities, he is most horrible, for he cannot be tamed. Ordinary cats and dogs or even a tiger can be tamed, but when a human being goes out of his way and neglects to take to the human activity of Kåñëa consciousness, his higher intelligence will simply be misused for animal propensities, and it is very difficult to tame him. The enactment of state laws cannot make a thief an honest man; because his heart is polluted, he cannot be tamed. Every man sees that a person who commits criminal offenses is punished by the government, and also in scriptural injunctions punishment in hell is mentioned. But despite hearing from scripture and seeing the action of the state laws, the demoniac cannot be tamed.

What are they doing? Nitäi nä bolilo mukhe. Since they do not know who Nityänanda is, they never say the names of Lord Nityänanda and Lord Caitanya. Majilo soàsära-sukhe. Majilo means "becomes absorbed."

They become absorbed in so-called material enjoyment. They don't care who Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda are, and therefore they go deep down into material existence. Vidyä-kule ki koribe tära: if one has no connection with Nityänanda, and if he does not come to Kåñëa consciousness, his vidyä, or his so-called academic education, and kule, birth in a high family or great nation, will not protect him. Regardless of whether one is born in a very big family or nation or has a very advanced academic education, at the time of death nature's law will act, his work will be finished, and he will get another body according to that work.

Why are these human animals acting in this way? Ahaìkäre matta hoiïä, nitäi-pada päsariyä. They have become maddened by a false concept of bodily life, and thus they have forgotten their eternal relationship with Nityänanda. Asatyere satya kori mäni: such forgetful persons accept the illusory energy as factual. Asatyere refers to that which is not a fact, or, in other words, mäyä. Mäyä means that which has no existence but is a temporary illusion only. Persons who have no contact with Nityänanda accept this illusory body as factual.

Narottama däsa Öhäkura then says, nitäira karuëä habe, braje rädhä-kåñëa päbe: "If you actually want to approach the association of Rädha-Kåñëa, you must achieve the mercy of Lord Nityänanda first. When He is merciful toward you, then you will be able to approach Rädhä-Kåñëa." Dharo nitäi-caraëa du'khäni. Narottama däsa advises that one firmly catch the lotus feet of Lord Nityänanda.

Then again he says, nitäi-caraëa satya. One should not misunderstand and think that as he has caught hold of mäyä, similarly the lotus feet of Nityänanda may also be something like that mäyä or illusion. Therefore Narottama däsa confirms, nitäi-caraëa satya: The lotus feet of Nityänanda are not illusion; they are a fact. Tähära sevaka nitya: and one who engages in the transcendental loving service of Nityänanda is also transcendental. If one engages in the transcendental loving service of Nityänanda in Kåñëa consciousness, he immediately achieves his transcendental position on the spiritual platform, which is eternal and blissful. Therefore he advises, nitäi-pada sadä koro äça: always try to catch the lotus feet of Lord Nityänanda.

Narottama baòo dukhé. Narottama däsa Öhäkura, the äcärya, is taking the position that he is very unhappy. Actually, he is representing ourselves. He says, "My dear Lord, I am very unhappy." Nitäi more koro sukhé: "Therefore I am praying to Lord Nityänanda to make me happy." Räkha räìgä-caraëera päça: "Please keep me in a corner of Your lotus feet."

[purport 2, 3, BTG]

SVA 3: Çré Rüpa Maïjaré Pada

ÇRÉ-RÜPA-MAÏJARÉ-PADA
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

1) çré-rüpa-maïjaré-pada, sei mora sampada,

sei mor bhajana-püjana

The lotus feet of Çré Rüpa Maïjaré are my treasure, my devotional service, and my object of worship.

2) sei mora präëa-dhana, sei mor äbharaëa,

sei mor jévanera jévana

They give my life meaning, and they are the life of my life.

3) sei mora rasa-nidhi, sei mora väïchä-siddhi,

sei mor vedera dharama

They are the perfection of rasa, and they are perfection worthy of attainment. They are the very law of the Vedic scriptures for me.

4) sei vrata, sei tapaù, sei mora mantra-japa,

sei mor dharama-karama

They are the meaning of all my fasts and penances and my silent utterings of my mantras. They are the basis of religion and activities.

5) anuküla ha'be vidhi, se pade hoibe siddhi,

nirakhibo e-dui nayane

By the purifying process of favorable devotional service one will attain perfection and with these two eyes be able to see.

6) se rüpa-mädhuré-räçi, präëa-kuvalaya çaçi,

praphullita habe niçi-dine

His transcendental form is shining like moonlight in my heart, and my heart therefore shines and reciprocates. In other words, the ordinary moon lights up the night, and its shine illuminates other objects; but the moon of the effulgence of the form of Çré Rüpa Maïjaré shines into the heart and makes the heart also shine back to the spiritual sky. This moon shines not only in the nighttime, but day and night.

7) tuyä adarçana ahi, garale järala dehé,

cirodin täpita jévana

Your absence from my vision is like a dose of strong poison, and I will suffer till the end of my life.

8) hä hä rüpa koro doyä, deho more pada-chäyä,

narottama loilo çaraëa

Narottama däsa Thakura says: "Please give me your mercy and the shade of your lotus feet."


SVA 3: Våndävana

VÅNDÄVANA
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

våndävana ramyasthäna, divya ciìtämaëi-dhäma

ratana-mandira manohara

ävåta kälindé-nére, räjahaàsa keli kore,

tähe çobhe kanaka-kamala


tära madhye hema-péöha, añöa-dale veñöita

añöa-dale pradhänä näyikä

tära madhye ratnäsane, bosi ächen dui-jane

çyäma-saìge sundaré rädhikä


rüpa-läbaëyaräçi, amiya paòiche khasi

häsya-parihäsa-sambhäñaëe

narottama-däsa koya, nitya-lélä sukha-moya

sadäi sphuruka mora mane

[synonyms]

Våndävana is a transcendental beautiful place. It is in the spiritual sky, where everything is made of touchstone, which fulfills all desires. All the temples there are bedecked with costly jewels. In that far distant place is the River Yamunä, which is full of lotus flowers. In the midst of that throng of lotus flowers there is a golden boat, appearing like another big lotus flower, with eight petals, who are none but the eight chief gopés who always surround Rädhä and Kåñëa. In the surrounding petals there is a golden throne where the two transcendental lovers, namely Rädhä and Kåñëa, are seated, but of all of them the governing Deity is Çrématé Rädhäraëé. There is no comparison to Rädhäraëé's beauty and the luster of Her transcendental body. The so-called beauty of the moon has fallen on the ground in the presence of Rädhäraëé's beauty. In that assembly of Rädhä-Kåñëa and Their principal associates there is a flood of laughing and joking as they address one another. Narottama däsa says that the eternal pastimes of Rädhä-Kåñëa from day to day are full of transcendental pleasure. Let us all remember them now and then and thus become happy even in this material world.

SVA 4: Songs by other Äcäryas

Songs by other Äcäryas

SVA 4: The Holy Places Of Våndävana (jaya rädhe, jaya kåñëa, jaya våndävan)

THE HOLY PLACES OF VÅNDÄVANA
by Kåñëadasa Kaviräja Gosväm
é

1)

jaya rädhe jaya kåñëa jaya våndävana

çré-govinda, gopénätha, madana-mohana

All glories to Rädhä and Kåñëa, and to the transcendental realm of Våndävana! All glories to the three presiding Deities of Våndävana—Govinda, Gopénätha and Madana-mohana.

2)

çyama-kunòa, rädhä-kuëòa, giri-govardhan

kälindé yamunä jaya, jaya mahävana

All glories to Çyäma-kuëòa and Rädhä-kuëòa, which are beautiful garden pools belonging to Rädhä and Kåñëa and are the places of the pinnacle of Their léläs. Glories to Govardhana Hill and to the Yamunä, or Kälindé, and to the great forest.

3)

keçé-ghäöa, vaàçi-vaöa, dvädaça-känana

yähä saba lélä koilo, çré-nanda-nandana

Glories to Keçé-ghäöa, where Kåñëa killed the horse demon, and to the vaàçé-vata tree, where Kåñëa used to sit and call the gopés with His flute. Glories to the twelve groves of Våndävana. These places set the background for the son of Nanda Mahäräja to play His pastimes.

4)

çré-nanda-yaçodä jaya, jaya gopa-gaëa

çrédämädi jaya, jaya dhenu-vatsa-gaëa

Glories to Kåñëa's divine mother and father, Nanda-Yaçodä, and to the cowherd men. Glories to Kåñëa's friends the cowherd boys headed by Çrédämä. All glories to the cows and calves of Våndävana.

5)

jaya våñabhänu, jaya kértidä-sundaré

jaya paurëamäsé, jaya äbhéra-nägaré

All glories to Rädhä's mother and father, Kértidä and Våñabhänu, and to Her grandmother, who is the personality of Yogamäyä.

6)

jaya jaya gopéçvara våndävana-mäjha

jaya jaya kåñëa-sakhä baöu dvijaräja

All glories to the Lord of the gopés of Våndävana and to Kåñëa's brahmaëa friends Sudämä and Madhumaìgala.

7)

jaya räma-ghäta, jaya rohiëé-nandana

jaya jaya våndävana-väsé yata jana

Glories to Räma-ghäöa. Glories to the son of Rohiëé (Balaräma), and glories to all the inhabitants of Våndävana.

8)

jaya dvija-patné, jaya nägakanyä-gaëa

bhaktite yähärä päilo govinda-caraëa

All glories to the Nägapatnés. All glories to the wives of the Vedic brahmaëas who left their husbands and surrendered at the lotus feet of Kåñëa, Govinda, and were bestowed with pure bhakti.

9)

çré-rasa-maëòala jaya, jaya rädhä-çyäma

jaya jaya rasa-lélä sarva-manorama

Glories to the arena of the räsa dance and Rädhä and Çyäma. Glories to the räsa-lélä which captures the minds of all.

10)

jaya jayojjvala-rasa sarva-rasa-sära

parakéyä-bhäve yähä, brajete pracära

All glories to the ever-shining mellow of parakéyä-bhäva, the supreme platform of the unalloyed "lawless love" of the gopés.

11)

çré-jähnavä-päda-padma koriyä smaraëa

déna kåñëadäsa kohe näma-saìkértana

With memory of the lotus feet of Lord Nityänanda's çakti, Çré Jähnavä-devé (Yogamäyä), Kåñëadäsa, who describes himself here as very fallen and lowly, sings the names of the Lord.

SVA 4: Jaya Rädhä-Govinda

JAYA RÄDHÄ-GOVINDA

jaya rädhä-govinda rädhä-govinda rädhe*

rüpa-gosvämér präëa-dhana he

[TRANSLATION]

jaya rädhä-madanamohana rädhä-madanamohana rädhe*

sanätaner präëa-dhana he

[TRANSLATION]

jaya rädhä-dämodara rädhä-dämodara rädhe*

jéva-gosvämér präëa-dhana he

[TRANSLATION]

jaya rädhä-ramaëa rädhä-ramaëa rädhe*

gopäla-bhaööer präëa-dhana he

[TRANSLATION]

jaya rädhä-gokulänanda rädhä-gokulänanda rädhe*

lokanäther präëa-dhana he

[TRANSLATION]

jaya rädhä-gopénätha rädhä-gopénätha rädhe*

madhupaëòiter präëa-dhana he

[TRANSLATION]

jaya rädhä-çyämasundara rädhä-çyämasundara rädhe*

çyämänander präëa-dhana he

[TRANSLATION]

jaya rädhä-giridhäré rädhä-giridhäré rädhe*

däsa-gosvämér präëa-dhana he

[TRANSLATION]

These are the names of the famous seven temples of Våndävana and the äcäryas who founded them. Çré Lokanätha, Çré Maòhupaëòita and Çyämänanda Gosvämé were associates of Çréniväsa Äcärya, and their history is in a book called the Bhakti-rätnakara. Präëa-dhana means "the lord of one's life." The Deities of Rädhä-Govinda, Gopénätha, etc., are the Lords of Their äcäryas' lives. The Gosvämés and äcäryas were all perfectly realized souls, and as such their vision of the Deity was not obstructed by any material conception. Thus they could hear the Deity speaking to them and see the Deity's pastimes.

SVA 4: Çré Dämodarañöaka (namäméçvaraà sac-cid-änanda-rüpaà)

ÇRÉ DÄMODARÄÑÖAKA

This eight çloka prayer is sung morning and evening during the month of Dämodara.


namäméçvaraà sac-cid-änanda-rüpaà

lasat-kuëòalaà gokule bhräjamänam

yaçodä-bhiyolükhaläd dhävamänaà

parämåñöam atyantato drutya gopyä

1) To the supreme controller who possesses an eternal form of blissful knowledge, whose glistening earrings swing to and fro, who manifested Himself in Gokula, who stole the butter that the gopés kept hanging from the rafters of their storerooms and who then quickly jumped up and ran in retreat in fear of Mother Yaçodä but was ultimately caught—to that Supreme Lord, Çré Dämodara, I offer my humble obeisances.


rudantaà muhur netra-yugmaà måjantam

karämbhoja-yugmena sätaìka-netram

muhuù çväsa-kampa-trirekhäìka-kaëöha-

sthita-graiva dämodaraà bhakti-baddham

2) Upon seeing His mother's whipping stick, He cried and rubbed His eyes again and again with His two lotus hands. His eyes were fearful and His breathing quick, and as Mother Yaçodä bound His belly with ropes, He shivered in fright and His pearl necklace shook. To this Supreme Lord, Çré Dämodara, who is bound with His devotee's love, I offer my humble obeisances.


itédåk sva-léläbhir änanda-kuëòe

sva-ghoñaà nimajjantam äkhyäpayantam

tadéyeñita-jïeñu bhaktair jitatvaà

punaù prematas taà çatävåtti vande

3) Those superexcellent pastimes of Lord Kåñëa's babyhood drowned the inhabitants of Gokula in pools of ecstasy. To the devotees who are attracted only to His majestic aspect of Näräyaëa in Vaikuëöha, the Lord herein reveals: "I am conquered and overwhelmed by pure loving devotion." To the Supreme Lord, Dämodara, my obeisances hundreds and hundreds of times.


varaà deva mokñaà na mokñävadhià vä

na canyaà våëe 'haà vareñäd apéha

idaà te vapur nätha gopäla-bälaà

sadä me manasy ävirästäà kim anyaiù

4) O Lord, although You are able to give all kinds of benedictions, I do not pray to You for liberation, nor eternal life in Vaikuëöha, nor any other boon. My only prayer is that Your childhood pastimes may constantly appear in my mind. O Lord, I do not even want to know Your feature of Paramätmä. I simply wish that Your childhood pastimes may ever be enacted in my heart.


idaà te mukhämbhojam atyanta-nélair

våtaà kuntalaiù snigdha-raktaiç ca gopyä

muhuç cumbitaà bimba-raktä-dharaà me

manasy ävirästäm alaà lakña-läbhaiù

5) O Lord, the cheeks of Your blackish lotus face, which is encircled by locks of curling hair, have become reddened like bimba fruit due to Mother Yaçodä's kisses. What more can I describe than this? Millions of opulences are of no use to me, but may this vision constantly remain in my mind.


namo deva dämodaränanta viñëo

praséda prabho duùkha-jäläbdhi-magnam

kåpä-dåñöi-våñöyätidénaà batänu

gåhäëeça mäm ajïam edhy akñi-dåçyaù

6) O unlimited Viñëu! O master! O Lord! Be pleased upon me! I am drowning in an ocean of sorrow and am almost like a dead man. Please shower the rain of mercy on me; uplift me and protect me with Your nectarean vision.


kuverätmajau baddha-mürtyaiva yadvat

tvayä mocitau bhakti-bhäjau kåtau ca

tathä prema-bhaktià svakäà me prayaccha

na mokñe graho me 'sti dämodareha

7) O Lord Dämodara, in Your form as a baby Mother Yaçodä bound You to a grinding stone with a rope for tying cows. You then freed the sons of Kuvera, Maëigréva, and Nalakuvera, who were cursed to stand as trees, and You gave them the chance to become Your devotees. Please bless me in this same way. I have no desire for liberation into Your effulgence.


namas te 'stu dämne sphurad-dépti-dhämne

tvadéyodaräyätha viçvasya dhämne

namo rädhikäyai tvadéya-priyäyai

namo 'nanta-léläya deväya tubhyam

8) O Lord, the entire universe was created by Lord Brahmä, who was born from Your abdomen, which was bound with a rope by Mother Yaçodä. To this rope I offer my humble obeisances. I offer my obeisances to Your most beloved Çrématé Rädhäräëé and to Your unlimited pastimes.

SVA 4: Çré Guru-paramparä (kåñëa hoite catur-mukha)

ÇRÉ GURU-PARAMPARÄ

[1]

kåñëa hoite catur-mukha, hoy kåñëa-sevonmukha,

brahmä hoite näradera mati

närada hoite vyäsa, madhva kohe vyäsa däsa,

pürëa-prajïa padmanäbha gati

[2]

nåhari-mädhava-vaàçe, akñobhya-paramahaàse,

çiñya boli' aìgékära kore

akñobhyera çiñya joy—tértha näme paricoy,

tära däsye jïänasindhu tore

[3]

tähä hoite doyänidhi, tära däsa vidyänidhi,

räjendra hoilo tähä ho'te

tähära kiìkora joy—dharma näme paricoy,

paramparä jäno bhälo mate

[4]

jayadharma-däsye khyäti, çré puruñottama-yati,

tä ho'te brahmaëya-tértha süri

vyäsatértha tära däsa, lakñmépati vyäsadäsa,

tähä ho'te mädhavendra puré

[5]

mädhavendra puré-boro, çiñya-boro çré-éçvaro,

nityänanda, çré-advaita vibhu

éçvara-puréke dhanya, korilena çré-caitanya,

jagad-guru gaura-mahäprabhu

[6]

mahäprabhu çré-caitanya, rädhä-kåñëa nahe anya,

rüpänuga-janera jévana

viçvambhara-priyaìkoro, çré-svarüpa-dämodaro,

çré gosvämé rüpa sonätan

[7]

rüpa-priya mahäjana, jéva-raghunätha hana,

tära priya kavi kåñëadäsa

kåñëadäsa-priya-boro, narottama sevä-para,

yära pada viçvanätha-äça

[8]

viçvanätha-bhakta-säth, baladev jagannäth,

tära priya çré-bhaktivinoda

mahäbhägavata-boro, çré-gaurakiçora-boro,

hari-bhajanete yära moda

[9]

çré-värñabhänavé-borä, sadä sevya-sevä parä,

tähära doyita-däsa-näm

tära pradhän pracärako, çré-bhaktivedänta nämako,

påthivéte gaura-väné bhitore

[10]

ei saba hari-jana, gauräìgera nija-jana,
tä' der ucchiñöe mor käma


Lord Kåñëa enlightened the four-faced Brahmä with the devotional science, which Brahmä then passed on to Närada Muni. In the Çrémad-Bhägavatam, Second Canto, Ninth Chapter, the history of how Lord Brahmä received initiation directly from Kåñëa is explained. Brahmä found himself in the midst of darkness. He tried to explore the dark universe by traveling down the stem of the lotus planet of his birth, but, being only a jéva with limited senses, intellect, and power, he failed to find more than darkness. Brahmä then heard the syllables ta and pa from outside the covering of the universe, and following this instruction, he performed tapasya, or penance, by which the spiritual realm was revealed to him. The four seed verses of the Bhägavatam were transmitted by the Lord Himself to Brahmä. The conclusion is that Brahmä could not understand anything by his own attempt; only by Lord Kåñëa's revelation could Brahmä get absolute knowledge.

Lord Brahmä took to the disciplic succession naturally. He initiated Närada Muni, who in turn initiated Vyäsadeva, the compiler of all Vedic literatures. It is recorded in the Bhägavatam, First Canto, Fifth Chapter, that Vyäsadeva compiled the Vedas in four divisions and then wrote the Mahäbhärata, Puräëas, and Upaniñads, and revealed the conclusion of knowledge in the Vedänta-sütras. Yet as he meditated he did not feel satisfied, and Närada Muni explained to him that this was because he had not described the léläs, forms, qualities, etc., of Lord Kåñëa. Then Vyäsadeva expanded the four seed verses of the Çrémad-Bhägavatam into 18,000 verses, and then initiated Madhväcärya. Vyäsadeva is still living in the Himalayas at Badarikäçrama, and, therefore, there is no gap of time between Vyäsa and Madhva; they are contemporaries, just as we are contemporaries of Vyäsa, who is presently in this world. The äcäryas coming from Madhva are Padmanäbha, Nåhari, Mädhava, Akñobhya, Jayatértha, Jïänasindhu, Dayänidhi, Vidyänidhi, Räjendra, Jayadharma, Puruñottama, Brahmaëya-tértha, Vyäsatértha, Lakñmépati, and Mädhavendra Puré. (Baladeva Vidyäbhüñana, the great äcärya who wrote the commentary on Vedänta-sütra after hearing it directly from the Deity Govindajé, has confirmed Mädhavendra Puré's connection with the Madhva-sampradäya.)

Mädhavendra Puré had several disciples who were highly transcendental personalities. Lord Nityänanda, the incarnation of Lord Balaräma, and Çré Advaita, the incarnation of Maha-Viñëu, accepted initiation from him. However, Çré Éçvara Puré possessed a very high standard of devotion and would even clean the toilet place for his spiritual master. Thus Éçvara Puré was given the seat of äcärya. He in turn initiated Lord Caitanya, Who is none other than Rädhä-Kåñëa Himself and Who is the living force of the followers of Rüpa Gosvämé. Lord Caitanya is succeeded by Rüpa Gosvämé along with Svarüpa Dämodara and Sanätana Gosvämé, then Raghunätha däsa and Jéva Gosvämé, Kåñëadäsa Kaviräja, Narottama däsa Öhäkura, and Viçvanätha Cakravarté Öhäkura. Viçvanätha Cakravarté was the spiritual master of Baladeva Vidyäbhüñaëa and Jagannätha däsa Bäbäjé. Jagannätha däsa's most beloved disciple is Çréla Sac-cid-änanda Bhaktivinoda, who empowered Çréla Gaurakiçora däsa Bäbäjé, an uttama-adhikäré mahä-bhägavata (great devotee of the highest order), to initiate Çréla Bhaktisiddhänta Sarasvaté Öhäkura, who is also spiritually named Çré Värñabhänavé-dayita däsa. I have added one more line to this song: "His foremost disciple-preacher is Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, who has spread the message of Lord Caitanya throughout the entire world."

SVA 4: Çré-Rädhikä-Stavaù (rädhe jaya jaya mädhava-dayite)

ÇRÉ-RÄDHIKÄ-STAVAÙ
by Çréla Rüpa Gosvämé

[1]

rädhe jaya jaya mädhava-dayite

gokula-taruëé-maëòala-mahite

[2]

dämodara-rati-vardhana-veçe

hari-niñkuta-våndä-vipineçe

[3]

våñabhänudadhi-nava-çaçi-lekhe

lalitä-sakhé guëa-ramita-viçäkhe

[4]

karuëäà kuru mayi karuëä-bharite

sanaka-sanätana-varëita-carite

Glories, glories to Çré Rädhäräëé, the beloved of Mädhava and most worshipable of the cowherd girls of Gokula Maëòala!

Decorated by the dress of Lord Dämodara's increasing ecstasy, You are the lady of the house of Lord Hari and the groves of Våndävana.

From the ocean of Våñabhänu has arisen a new moon which is overwhelming the qualities of Lalitä and Viçäkhä.

O Goddess, Your qualities are described by Sanaka and Sanätana Åñis and by Sanätana Gosvämé. Please bestow Your mercy upon me.

[purport]

SVA 4: Çrita Kamala

ÇRITA KAMALA
Çré Jayadeva Gosvämé

1)

çrita-kamaläkuca-maëòala (he)

dhåta-kuëòala (e)

kalita-lalita-vanamälä

jaya jaya deva hare

Glories, glories to Lord Hari, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is bedecked with jeweled earrings and a garland of forest flowers and whose feet are marked with a lotus!

2)

dinamaëi-maëòala-maëòana (he)

bhava-khaëòana (e)

munijana-mänasa-haàsa

jaya jaya deva hare

The Lord's face shines like the whorl of the sun. He removes the miseries of His devotees and is the resting place of the minds of the swanlike sages. Glories! Glories to Lord Çré Hari!

3)

käliya-viñadhara-gaïjana (he)

jana-raïjana (e)

yadu-kula-nalina-dineça

jaya jaya deva hare

O Supreme Personality of Godhead who destroyed the demoniac Käliya serpent! O Lord, You are the beloved of all living entities and the sun in the galaxy of the Yadu dynasty. Glories! Glories to Lord Çré Hari!

4)

madhu-mura-naraka-vinäçana (he)
garuòäsana (e)
sura-kula-keli-nidäna
jaya jaya deva hare

O Lord, destroyer of the demons Madhu, Mura and Naraka! Seated on Garuòa, You are the source of joy for the demigods. All glories to Hari!

5)

amala-kamala-dala-locana (he)

bhava-mocana (e)

tribhuvana-bhuvana-nidhäna

jaya jaya deva hare

O Lord, Your clear eyes are like lotus petals, and You destroy the bondage of the material world. You are the maintainer of the three worlds. Glories to Lord Hari!

6)

janaka-sutä-kåta-bhüñaëa (he)

jita-düñaëa (e)

samara-çamita-daçakaëöha

jaya jaya deva hare

O Lord, as the gem of the sons of Janaka, You were victorious over all the asuras, and You smashed the greatest asura, the ten-headed Rävaëa. Glories to Lord Hari!

7)

abhinava-jaladhara-sundara (he)
dhåta-mandara (e)
çré-mukhacandra-cakora
jaya jaya deva hare

O Supreme Personality of Godhead who held the Govardhana Hill! Your complexion is like a fresh monsoon cloud, and Sri Rädhäräëé is like a cakora bird who is nourished by drinking the light of Your moonlike face. Glories! Glories to Lord Sri Hari!

8)

tava caraëaà praëata vayam (he)

iti bhävaya (e)

kuru kuçalaà praëateñu

jaya jaya deva hare

O Lord, I offer my humble obeisances at Your lotus feet. Please bless me by Your limitless mercy. Glories! Glories to Lord Sri Hari!

9)

çré-jayadeva-kaver idaà (he)

kurute mudam (e)

maìgalam ujjvala-gétaà

jaya jaya deva hare

The poet Çré Jayadeva offers this song of devotion and shining good fortune to Thee. All glories! All glories to Lord Çré Hari!

SVA 4: Çré-Çré-Gaura-Nityänandera Dayä

ÇRÉ-ÇRÉ-GAURA-NITYÄNANDERA DAYÄ
by Locana däsa Öhäkura

[1]

parama karuëa, pahuì dui jana,

nitäi-gauracandra

saba avatära—, sära çiromaëi,

kevala-änanda-kanda

[2]

bhaja bhaja bhäi, caitanya-nitäi,

sudåòha viçväsa kori

viñaya chäòiyä se rase majiyä,

mukhe bolo hari hari

[3]

dekha ore bhäi, tri-bhuvane näi,

emona dayäla dätä

paçu-päkhé jhure, päñäëa vidare

çuni yära guëa-gäthä

[4]

soàsäre majiyä, rohili paòiyä,

se pade nahilo äça

äpana koroma, bhuïjäye çamana,

kohoye locana-däsa

Purport
by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

This is a song by Locana däsa Öhäkura. Pahuì means "Lord," and dui jana means "two." Locana däsa Öhäkura declares that the two Lords Nitäi-Gauracandra–Lord Nitäi and Lord Caitanya–are very merciful (parama karuëa). Saba avatära–, sära-çiromaëi. Avatära means "incarnation," and saba means "all." They are the essence of all incarnations. The specific significance of these incarnations is that prosecuting Their way of self-realization is simply joyful (kevala-änanda-kanda), for They introduced chanting and dancing. There are many incarnations like Lord Räma and even Kåñëa, who taught Bhagavad-gétä–which requires knowledge and understanding. But Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda introduced a process that is simply joyful–which is simply to chant and dance. Therefore, Locana däsa requests everyone: bhaja bhaja bhäi, caitanya-nitäi. "My dear brother, I request that you just worship Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda with firm conviction and faith." Don't think that this chanting and dancing will not lead to the desired goal. It will. It is the assurance of Lord Caitanya Mahäprabhu that one will get all perfection by this process. Therefore one must chant with firm faith and conviction (viçväsa kori).

But what is the process? The process is viñaya chäòiyä, se rase majiyä. If one wants to be Kåñëa conscious by this process, one has to give up his engagement in sense gratification. That is the only restriction. If one gives up sense gratification, it is sure that he will reach the desired goal. Mukhe bolo hari hari: one simply has to chant Hare Kåñëa, Hari Hari, without any motive of sense gratification.

Dekha ore bhäi, tri-bhuvane näi. Locana däsa Öhäkura says, "My dear brother, you just try and examine this. Within the three worlds there is no one like Lord Caitanya or Lord Nityänanda because Their merciful qualities are so great that They make even birds and beasts cry, not to speak of human beings." Actually, when Lord Caitanya passed through the forest known as Jharikhaëòa, the tigers, elephants, snakes, deer, and all other animals joined Him in chanting Hare Kåñëa. It is so nice that anyone can join. Even the animals can join, not to speak of human beings. Of course, it is not possible for ordinary men to induce animals to chant, but if Caitanya Mahäprabhu could inspire animals to chant, at least we can encourage human beings to adopt this path of Hare Kåñëa mantra chanting. It is so nice that even the most stonehearted man will be melted. Päñäëa means "stone." It is so nice that even stone will melt.

But Locana däsa Öhäkura regrets that he is entrapped by sense gratification. He addresses himself, "My dear mind, you are entrapped in this sense gratification process, and you have no attraction for chanting Hare Kåñëa. Since you have no attraction for the lotus feet of Lord Caitanya and Lord Nityänanda, what can I say? I can simply think of my misfortune. Yamaräja, the superintendent of death, is punishing me by not allowing me to be attracted by Lord Caitanya's movement."

[purport 2, 3, 4]

SVA 4: Çré Tulasé-kértana (namo namaù tulasé kåñëa-preyasi)

ÇRÉ-TULASÉ-KÉRTANA
by Narottama däsa Öhäkura

[1]

namo namaù tulasé kåñëa-preyasi namo namaù

rädhä-kåñëa-sevä pävo ei abiläñé

[2]

ye tomära çaraëa loy, tara väïchä pürëa hoy

kåpä kori' koro täre våndävana-väsi

[3]

mora ei abhiläña, viläsa kuïje dio väsa

nayana heribo sadä yugala-rüpa-räçi

[4]

ei nivedana dhara, sakhéra anugata koro

sevä-adhikära diye koro néja däsé

[5]

déna kåñëa-däse koy, ei yena mora hoy

çré-rädhä-govinda-preme sadä yena bhäsi


O Tulasé, beloved of Kåñëa, I bow before you again and again. The only desire left in me is to serve Rädhä and Kåñëa. O dweller of Våndävana, the wishes of all those who seek your favor are fulfilled. Bestow your kindness upon me. I wish you to live in my small garden and remain green forever. O storehouse of beauty, I am your follower and sakhé. Pray that by making me your maidservant, as a servant of Kåñëa, this body will be His—not mine. Bless me, that in this body may dwell only love for Rädhä and Kåñëa.

SVA 4: Çré Tulasé Praëäma (våndäyai tulasé-devyai)

ÇRÉ-TULASÉ-PRAËÄMA

våndäyai tulasé-devyai priyäyai keçavasya ca

kåñëa-bhakti-prade devé satyavatyai namo namaù

våndäyai—unto Våndä; tulasé-devyai—unto Tulasé-devé; priyäyai—who is dear; keçavasya—to Lord Keçava; ca—and; kåñëa-bhakti—devotional service to Lord Kåñëa; prade—who bestows; devi—O goddess; satya-vatyai—unto Satyavaté; namaù namaù—repeated obeisances.

"I offer my repeated obeisances unto Våndä, Çrématé Tulasé-devé, who is very dear to Lord Keçava.

O goddess, you bestow devotional service to Kåñëa, and you possess the highest truth."

SVA 4: Tulasé Prayer (yäni käni ca päpäni)

TULASÉ PRAYER

yäni käni ca päpäni brahma-hatyädikäni ca

täni täni praëaçyanti pradakñiëaù pade pade

yäni käni—whatever; ca—and; päpäni—sins; brahma-hatya—killing of a brähmaëa; ädikäni—and so on; ca—also; täni täni—all of them; praëaçyanti—are destroyed; pradakñiëaù—circumambulating; pade pade—step by step.

"Those who circumambulate Çrématé Tulasé-devé step by step destroy whatever sins they have committed, even the killing of a brähmaëa."

SVA 4: Çré Tulasé Ärati (våndäyai tulasé-devyai)

ÇRÉ-TULASÉ-ÄRATI
by Candraçekhara Äcärya

[1]

namo namaù tulasi mahäräëé,

vånde mahäräëé namo namaù

namo re namo re meiyä namo näräyaëi

namo namaù

[2]

yäìko daraçe, paraçe agha-näçai

mahimä veda-puräëe väkhäni

namo namaù

[3]

yäìko patra, maïjaré komala

çré-pati-caraëa-kamale lapaöäni

namo namaù

[4]

dhüpa, dépa, naivedya, äroti

phulanä kiye varakhä varakhäni

namo namaù

[5]

dhanya tulasi meiyä, puräëa tapa kiye

çré-çälagräma-mahä-päöaräëé

namo namaù

[6]

chäpänna bhoga, chatriça byaïjana,

vinä tulasé prabhu eka nähi mäni

namo namaù

[7]

çiva-çuka-närada, äur brahmädiko

òhürata phirata mahämuni jïäné

namo namaù

[8]

candra-sekhara meiyä, terä yaço gäoye

bhakati-däna déjiye mahäräëé

namo namaù

Worshipable Tulasé Devé, O Våndä Devé, obeisances unto thee again and again. All praises, O mother of bhakti. O Näräyaëi [energy of Näräyaëa], my humble obeisances to thee again and again. Simply by touching or by even seeing Çré Tulasé-devé, all sins are destroyed. My obeisances to thee again and again, whose magnificence is described in the Vedas and Puräëas. Your ärati is performed with offerings of incense and lamps, flowers and praises. My obeisances to thee again and again. You have performed long austerities and have become the offering to the Lord's çälagräma expansion. My obeisances to thee again and again. The Lord does not care for a single one of fifty-six offerings or thirty-six curries offered without a tulasé leaf. Lord Çiva, Çukadeva, Närada Muni, Brahmä and all others are paying their respects unto thee. Candraçekhara (the author), who is singing your glories, prays, "Please bestow prema-bhakti unto me. My humble obeisances unto thee again and again."

SVA 4: Çré Nåsiàha Praëäma (namas te narasiàhäya)

Çré Nåsiàha Praëäma

namas te nara-siàhäya prahlädähläda-däyine

hiraëyakaçipor vakñaù-çilä-öaìka-nakhälaye

ito nåsiàhaù parato nåsiàho yato yato yämi tato nåsiàhaù

bahir nåsiàho hådaye nåsiàho nåsiàham ädià çaraëaà prapadye
[Nåsiàha Puräëa]

namaù—obeisances; te—unto You; nara-siàhäya—unto Lord Narasiàha; prahläda—to Prahläda Mahäräja; ähläda—of pleasure; däyine—the giver; hiraëyakaçipoù—of Hiraëyakaçipu; vakñaù—chest; çilä—on the stone-like; öaìka—chisels; nakha-älaye—whose nails; itaù—here; nåsiàhaù—Lord Nåsiàha; parataù—there; nåsiàhaù—Lord Nåsiàha; yataù yataù—wherever; yämi—I go; tataù—there; nåsiàhaù—Lord Nåsiàha; bahiù—externally; nåsiàhaù—Lord Nåsiàha; hådaye—internally; nåsiàhaù—Lord Nåsiàha; nåsiàham—Lord Nåsiàha; ädim—the origin; çaraëam—to the shelter; prapadye—I surrender.

"I offer my obeisances to Lord Nåsiàha-deva, who is always giving bliss to His devotees like Prahläda Mahäräja and chiseling at the hearts of demons like Hiraëyakaçipu. The devotee always sees Lord Nåsiàha everywhere. Lord Nåsiàha is within and without. Therefore let us all take shelter of Lord Nåsiàha."

[purport]

SVA 4: Prayer to Lord Nåsiàha (tava kara-kamala-vare nakham)

PRAYER TO LORD NÅSIÀHA
FROM
DAÇÄVATÄRA
by Jayadeva Gosvämé

tava kara-kamala-vare nakham adbhuta-çåìgaà

dalita-hiraëyakaçipu-tanu-bhåìgam

keçava dhåta-nara-hari-rüpa jaya jagadéça hare

tava—Your; kara—hands; kamala—lotus-like; vare—on the beautiful; nakham—nails; adbhuta—wonderful; çåìgam—pointed; dalita—ripped apart; hiraëyakaçipu—of Hiraëyakaçipu; tanu—the body; bhåìgam—wasp-like; keçava—O Lord Keçava; dhåta—who assumed; nara—half man; hari—and half lion; rüpa—form; jaya—all glories; jagat-éça—O Lord of the universe; hare—O Lord Hari.

"O my Lord Nåsiàha, Your hands are very beautiful, like the lotus flower, but with Your long nails You have ripped apart the wasp Hiraëyakaçipu. Unto You, Lord of the universe, I offer my humble obeisances." [Daçävatära-stotra 4]

SVA 4: Sri Dasavatara-stotra

Sri Dasavatara-stotra
(from Gita-govinda)
by Jayadeva Gosvami

(1)

pralaya-payodhi-jale dhrtavan asi vedam

vihita-vahitra-caritram akhedam

kesava dhrta-mina-sarira jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of a fish! All glories to You! You easily acted as a boat in the form of a giant fish just to give protection to the Vedas, which had become immersed in the turbulent sea of devastation.

(2)

ksitir iha vipulatare tisthati tava prsthe

dharani-dharana-kina-cakra-garisthe

kesava dhrta-kurma-sarira jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of a tortoise! All glories to You! In this incarnation as a divine tortoise the great Mandara Mountain rests upon Your gigantic back as a pivot for churning the ocean of milk. From holding up the huge mountain a large scar like depression is put in Your back, which has become most glorious.

(3)

vasati dasana-sikhare dharani tava lagna

sasini kalanka-kaleva nimagna

kesava dhrta-sukara-rupa jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of a boar! All glories to You! The earth, which had become immersed in the Garbhodaka Ocean at the bottom of the universe, sits fixed upon the tip of Your tusk like a spot upon the moon.

(4)

tava kara-kamala-vare nakham adbhuta-srngam

dalita-hiranyakasipu-tanu-bhrngam

kesava dhrta-narahari-rupa jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of half-man, half-lion! All glories to You! Just as one can easily crush a wasp between one's fingernails, so in the same way the body of the wasplike demon Hiranyakasipu has been ripped apart by the wonderful pointed nails on Your beautiful lotus hands.

(5)

chalayasi vikramane balim adbhuta-vamana

pada-nakha-nira-janita-jana-pavana

kesava dhrta-vamana-rupa jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of a dwarf-brahmana! All glories to You! O wonderful dwarf, by Your massive steps You deceive King Bali, and by the Ganges water that has emanated from the nails of Your lotus feet, You deliver all living beings within this world.

(6)

ksatriya-rudhira-maye jagad-apagata-papam

snapayasi payasi samita-bhava-tapam

kesava dhrta-bhrgupati-rupa jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of Bhrgupati [Parasurama]! All glories to You! At Kurukshetra You bathe the earth in the rivers of blood from the bodies of the demoniac ksatriyas that You slain. The sins of the world are washed away by You, and because of You people are relieved from the blazing fire of material existence.

(7)

vitarasi diksu rane dik-pati-kamaniyam

dasa-mukha-mauli-balim ramaniyam

kesava dhrta-rama-sarira jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of Ramacandra! All glories to You! In the battle of Lanka You destroy the ten-headed demon Ravana and distribute his heads as a delightful offering to the presiding deities of the ten directions, headed by Indra. This action was long desired by all of them, who were much harassed by this monster.

(8)

vahasi vapusi visade vasanam jaladabham

hala-hati-bhiti-milita-yamunabham

kesava dhrta-haladhara-rupa jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of Balarama, the wielder of the plow! All glories to You! On Your brilliant white body You wear garments the color of a fresh blue rain cloud. These garments are colored like the beautiful dark hue of the River Yamuna, who feels great fear due to the striking of Your plowshare.

(9)

nindasi yajna-vidher ahaha sruti-jatam

sadaya-hrdaya darsita-pasu-ghatam

kesava dhrta-buddha-sarira jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of Buddha! All glories to You! O Buddha of compassionate heart, you decry the slaughtering of poor animals performed according to the rules of Vedic sacrifice.

[purport]

(10)

mleccha-nivaha-nidhane kalayasi karavalam

dhumaketum iva kim api karalam

kesava dhrta-kalki-sarira jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed the form of Kalki! All glories to You! You appear like a comet and carry a terrifying sword for bringing about the annihilation of the wicked barbarian men at the end of the Kali-yuga.

(11)

sri-jayadeva-kaver idam uditam udaram

srnu-sukha-dam subha-dam bhava-saram

kesava dhrta-dasa-vidha-rupa jaya jagadisa hare

O Kesava! O Lord of the universe! O Lord Hari, who have assumed these ten different forms of incarnation! All glories to You! O readers, please hear this hymn of the poet Jayadeva, which is most excellent, an awarder of happiness, a bestower of auspiciousness, and is the best thing in this dark world.

(12)

vedan uddharate jaganti vahate bhu-golam udbibhrate

daityam darayate balim chalayate ksatra-ksayam kurvate

paulastyam jayate halam kalayate karunyam atanvate

mlecchan murchayate dasakrti-krte krsnaya tubhyam namah

O Lord Krsna, I offer my obeisances unto You, who appear in the forms of these ten incarnations. In the form of Matsya You rescue the Vedas, and as Kurma You bear the Mandara Mountain on Your back. As Varaha You lift the earth with Your tusk, and in the form of Narasimha You tear open the chest of the daitya Hiranyakasipu. In the form of Vamana You trick the daitya king Bali by asking him for only three steps of land, and then You take away the whole universe from him by expanding Your steps. As Parasurama You slay all of the wicked ksatriyas, and as Ramacandra You conquer the raksasa king Ravana. In the form of Balarama You carry a plow with which You subdue the wicked and draw toward You the River Yamuna. As Lord Buddha You show compassion toward all the living beings suffering in this world, and at the end of the Kali-yuga You appear as Kalki to bewilder the mlecchas [degraded low-class men].

[purport]

SVA 4: Bhajahu Re Mana Sri Nanda-nandana

Bhajahu Re Mana Sri Nanda-nandana
by Govinda dasa Kaviraja

(1)

bhajahu re mana sri-nanda-nandana-

abhaya-caranaravinda re

durlabha manava-janama sat-sange

taroho e bhava-sindhu re

O mind, just worship the lotus of the son of Nanda, which make one fearless. Having obtained this rare human birth, cross over this ocean of worldly existence through the association of saintly persons.

(2)

sita atapa bata barisana

e dina jamini jagi re

biphale sevinu krpana durajana

capala sukha-laba lagi' re

Both in the day and at night I remain sleepless, suffering the pains of the heat and cold, the wind and the rain. For a fraction of flickering happiness I have uselessly served wicked and miserly men.

(3)

e dhana, yaubana, putra, parijana

ithe ki ache paratiti re

kamala-dala-jala, jivana talamala

bhajahu hari-pada niti re

What assurance of real happiness is there in all of one's wealth, youthfulness, sons, and family members? This life is tottering like a drop of water on a lotus petal; therefore you should always serve and worship the divine feet of Lord Hari.

(4)

sravana, kirtana, smarana, vandana,

pada-sevana, dasya re

pujana, sakhi-jana, atma-nivedan

govinda-dasa-abhilsa re

It is the desire and great longing of Govinda dasa to engage himself in the nine processes of bhakti, namely hearing the glories of Lord Hari and chanting those glories, constantly remembering Him and offering prayers to Him, serving the Lord's lotus feet, serving the Supreme Lord as a servant, worshiping Him with flowers and incense and so forth, serving Him as a friend, and completely offering the Lord one's very self.

[purport 1, 2, 3, 4]

The Hare Kåñëa Cook Book

$1.95

Readers interested in the subject matter of this book are invited by the International Society for Krishna Consciousness to correspond with its Secretary.

International Society for Krishna Consciousness
3959 Landmark Street
Culver City, California 90230

© 1973 the Bhaktivedanta Book Trust.
All rights reserved

Fourth Printing, 1973

International Standard Book Number: 0-912776-42-4

Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 73-83769

Printed in the United States of America

ALL GLORY TO ÇRÉ GURU AND GOURÄÌGA

The Hare Kåñëa Cook Book

RECIPIES FOR THE SATISFACTION
OF THE SUPREME PERSONALITY OF GODHEAD

compiled by
KÅÑËA DEVÉ DÄSÉ and ÇAMA DEVÉ DÄSÉ

with an introduction by
His Holiness KÉRTANÄNANDA SVÄMÉ

THE BHAKTIVEDANTA BOOK TRUST

New York • Los Angeles • London • Bombay

Cover illustration: Lord Çré Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, enjoying lunch among His cowherd friends in the transcendental land of Våndävana. This is an illustration from Teachings of Lord Caitanya by His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada.

HKC: Dedication

DEDICATION

Prasädam means mercy, and this Prasädam Cookbook is dedicated to the fountainhead of all mercy, the spiritual master, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda. He is by nature kind to every living entity, but that ocean of mercy becomes fully visible in his devotees.

Çréla Prabhupäda has not given us some dry, canned philosophy to chew; he has given us the nectar for which we have sought so long: he has taught us how to render transcendental loving service to the Lord in all our daily activities. This book illustrates one of them.

The process of Kåñëa consciousness is usually described as one of singing, dancing and feasting. We have already demonstrated to the world how anyone can sing and dance to the holy names of God, Hare Kåñëa, and now, with the publication of this Prasädam Cookbook, we hope that the whole world will feast in honor of the Supreme Lord. That will make this world like Våndävana, the transcendental abode of Kåñëa, where Krñëa, Balaräma and the monkeys visit every kitchen with thieving intent and bless the devotees with pure love of God.

HKC: Foreword

FOREWORD

Almost six years ago, I published the first article on Kåñëa cookery, entitled "Kåñëa Prasadam: Food for the Body, Food for the Soul, and Food for God." Since I had just begun my life as a devotee, the article revealed my intrigue with the idea of cooking for God. Perhaps I was still rebelling against my puritan background, in which God had been depicted as a stuffy old man who certainly needed nothing like food. Actually, I still wonder at the idea of His eating—but a little differently. Today I think of how great God must be. On the one hand, He is sustaining all the planetary systems, men, animals and whatever might be, and on the other, He becomes "hungry" for the loving offering of a pure devotee: "If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit or water, I will accept it." (Bhagavad-gétä, 9.26) Within this simple promise to His friend Arjuna, Kåñëa has given the rarest gem in all three worlds—loving reciprocation with Godhead. Were I not an individual, were God not an individual, and were there not the possibility of loving exchange, what would be the possibility of Absolute Pleasure? Pleasure cannot exist in a void or vacuum, for it is a product of activity; and the supreme activity is the exchange of love between persons. Everyone hankers for a lover. Then why should we settle for anyone less than the Supreme Lover, Kåñëa?

Çréla Prabhupäda has given us the formula of how to attract Kåñëa. Kåñëa, being God, is not in need of anything. He is ätmäräma, or self-contained. But He is also the highest Pleasure Absolute, and for the purpose of pleasure He expands Himself by His pleasure potency into millions and billions of living beings who are all meant for His enjoyment. In the spiritual world such spiritual sparks of the Lord are eternally enjoying with the Lord, and their existence is called sac-cid-änanda—eternal, full of knowledge, and blissful. The living beings in this material world are also part of that pleasure potency, but due to forgetfulness of their relationship with Kåñëa, they are living independently, trying to lord it over the resources of material nature for their own pleasure. Such pleasure is only illusory, but the eternal pleasure resulting from loving communion with Kåñëa can at once be revived by the simple Kåñëa conscious process of dedicating all one's activities to the enjoyment of the Lord.

This transcendental cookbook is designed to help you transform one of the most important daily chores into a spiritual reservoir of bliss. You may follow it in all or in part. The idea is to completely engage you in service to Kåñna, and it is promised that if you agree to be thus engaged, you will also enjoy unlimitedly. If you cannot follow all the rules and regulations, follow what you can. At least one can prepare pure vegetarian foods with all care for cleanliness and then offer them simply with love and devotion. Even offering such foods with only the repetition of Hare Kåsna, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Rama, Hare Rama, Räma Rama, Hare Hare is sufficient to render the highest benefit. The main point is to begin. Offer something nice to Kåñna with love and devotion and see for yourself what happens. That is the miracle of prasädam!

HKC: FOREWORD: THE YOGA DIET

THE YOGA DIET

Lord Kåñëa says in Bhagavad-gétä that yoga is not for him who eats too much or for him who eats too little. Rather, one who is actually practicing yoga sees the body as a valuable boat which has to be maintained very nicely in order to get across this ocean of material existence which is full of birth, old age, disease and death. Therefore, the yoga diet is designed to supply the body with all necessary nutrients, without pandering to the whims of our changing senses. The principle of regulation is strictly adhered to, and the daily fare is almost unchanging. This is very important for a brahmacäré, or celibate student, for if the tongue is agitated for sense enjoyment, all the other senses follow. We do not suggest that you have to follow this diet, but it is included for those who desire to know it. The Sunday feast is an opportunity for everyone to participate in the opulence of Kåñëa. Again, the principle is regulation, and the particular feast menu included here is chosen for its authentic quality, all of the preparations being great favorites of our beloved spiritual master, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda.

Morning prasädam:
raw chick-peas, ginger, fruit, cereal and milk.
Noon prasädam:
dahl, rice, chapatis and curried vegetabIe.
Bedtime prasädam:
milk.
The Sunday Love Feast:
rice and peas, wet cauliflower and potatoes, puris, samosa, halavah, sweet rice, sweet balls, pineapple chutney (sweet and hot), rhubarb chutney (salty and hot) and dahi.

Kértanänanda Svämé

HKC: Introduction

INTRODUCTION

Prasädam:
Food for the Body,
Food for the Soul,
and Food for God

by Kirtanänanda Svämé

Prasädam means food for the body, food for the soul and food for God. More specifically, it is food which has been sanctified by special selection and preparation and then offered to Kåñëa, God, in love and devotion. Cooking for God? How absurd that sounds to the sophisticates of this modern age! How anthropomorphic! Even most transcendentalists will smile a smile of condescension at the suggestion: cooking for God! But why not? We cook for every conceivable nonsensical purpose. Why not cook instead for the Lord? Why shouldn't this most important and central activity of life be dedicated to the Supreme? Why not cook transcendentally?

We are not so naive as to suggest that God needs our food, but we are suggesting that we need God to bless the energy of our hands and thus to sustain us by means of daily bread. He does this by accepting and eating the food which we prepare and offer to Him, and then giving it back to us in the form of prasädam.

In the Bhagavad-gétä Kåñëa says: "If one offers Me with love and devotion a leaf, a flower, fruit or water, I will accept it. O son of Kunté, all that you do, all that you eat, all that you offer and give away, as well as all austerities that you may perform, should be done as an offering unto Me." (Bg. 9.26-27) Of course, He doesn't need food; He is supreme, absolute. He is full of all opulences, namely, wealth, fame, beauty, strength, knowledge and renunciation. He is never in need or want of anything. Still, He asks His devotee to offer Him these simple fruits of the earth. The key word is devotion. Twice it is used: "If in full devotion a pure devotee offers a little leaf, a little flower, a little fruit with a little water, because he offers it with great devotion, the Supreme Personality of Godhead accepts them and eats them." So it is not as if the Lord were in need of something; He is fully satisfied in Himself. Indeed, He is everything. So whatever we are offering Him, be it a grain or a fruit, is already His; it is not, and never was, "ours." But out of His causeless mercy, He is so kind to His devotees that any small offering given in devotion He accepts and eats. The Lord is not hungry for our food but for our hearts; He is not wanting for our substance but for our consciousness, our love, our union.

This is why prasädam is "mercy." In shopping, in preparation, in eating, we are given a chance to remain conscious of Him, to be engaged in His transcendental loving service. This is why the word bhakti, or devotion, is so stressed—it is this bhakti which makes the Supreme Lord "transcendentally hungry." Even the greatest banquet cooked by the most renowned chef has no appeal to one who is not hungry; so, too, Kåñëa's acceptance of our gifts is dependent upon His being "hungry," and only our love and devotion can do that. His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda writes: "The devotee is so humble and submissive to the Supreme Lord that whenever he prepares something for the Lord, he takes all care to finish the preparation nicely. And for such offering a devotee asks nothing. It is the exchange of love. That love is accepted by the Supreme Lord, and He eats... Therefore, devotional service is the only way to offer anything to the Supreme Lord, to understand the Supreme Lord, to be in the confidence of the Supreme Lord, and to go back to the supreme abode of the Supreme Lord." Devotional service begins with the chanting of the Lord's holy names, as in the mahä-mantra: Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare/ Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare. That is the first great activity of transcendental service, and the next is to prepare and offer food to the Lord. There are a number of reasons for doing so. First of all, Kåñëa commands it: "The devotees of the Lord are released from all sins because they eat food which is offered first for sacrifice. Others, who prepare food for personal sense enjoyment, verily eat only sin. All living bodies subsist on food grains, which are produced from rains. Rains come from performance of yajïa [sacrifice], and sacrifice is born of man's work." (Bg. 3.13-14) Here, then, the Lord asserts that everything belongs to and comes from Him alone. It is already His, but He invites us to take it and offer it to Him first and then eat the remnants for our bodily demands.

Similarly, because everything belongs to Him, we have no right to take anything we please, but only what He allots us; and our allotment, according to the Gétä and the Vedas, is what can be offered to Him: a leaf, a fruit, etc. At no point does He ask us to offer meat, or fish, or eggs; but, on the contrary, the prohibition against animal slaughter is so strong that even if one has only an indirect dealing with animal slaughter, such as selling or transporting meat, he is guilty of murder and must pay a murderer's price. (Çrémad-Bhägavatam, 1.7.37) Therefore, we cannot offer Lord Kåñëa animal flesh, and to do so is an offense.

If I am preparing a dinner for my friend and I know he does not like spinach, I do not fix spinach. I go to all pains to prepare only those things which he likes. That is the meaning of friendship. If one has no regard for Kåñëa's wishes, how can he claim to be the Lord's friend? If we want to cook nicely for Kåñëa, we must dovetail our desires with His desires; and that is clearly expressed in the above-quoted verses.

There is another reason why we must offer our food to Kåñëa if we wish to make spiritual progress. Not only are we thieves if we do not, but we become further implicated in the wheel of saàsära by sinful reactions. That every action has a reaction is as true in regard to our personal behavior as in the laboratory test tube. The slaying of life automatically provokes a like result upon the slayer, and if I sustain myself on another's life, at some point my life will be demanded in return. That is nature's law.

This applies equally to those who take animal life and to those who take plant life. Life is life, and the slayer will be slain. Then what is the difference? The difference is that Kåñëa says that we may offer the leaves and flowers to Him, and by accepting them He also accepts all the sinful reactions, leaving the purified remnants, free from all reactions, for our consumption. But those who eat that which is not offered to Kåñëa, or that which Kåñëa will not accept, are left with all the reactions on their own heads. That is why the Lord says: "The devotees of the Lord are released from all sins because they eat food which is offered first for sacrifice. Others, who prepare food for personal sense enjoyment, verily eat only sin."

Of course, the devotee's primary concern is not for himself, nor even for liberation, but always for Kåñëa. Therefore suitable foodstuffs—suitable, that is, for Kåñëa—are the concern of the pure devotee: vegetables should be fresh and appealing to the eye, grains should be wholesome, fruits large and sweet, and milk fresh and pure. Obviously, living under the conditions of the modern metropolis, these are often impossible to procure—at least on our budgets; but we must do the best we can. That is Kåñëa consciousness.

No canned foods—please!

Having selected the items for preparation, our next concern is cleanliness. Since it is the Supreme for whom we are engaging our energy, we want to be super-hygienic—not for ourselves, but for Him. Wash your hands thoroughly as soon as you come into the kitchen; wash the food as you prepare it; use nothing that touches the floor or other contaminated areas, such as the sink and garbage pail, unless it can be cleansed. In all preparations, use only fresh things; no leftovers should be mixed in (they should not even be in the kitchen, but rather kept in a specific area of the dining room). Remember, we are cooking for the Supreme, and that which has been offered once should not be offered a second time. And, as good Vaiñëavas (devotees), we refrain from using garlic, onion, mushroom, and from mixing salt with fresh milk (although there is no restriction with any other kind of milk culture).

Finally, and probably hardest for American cooks, don't taste the food during preparation—not even to see if it is seasoned properly. I know that it is difficult, but it is worthwhile; we are cooking for Kåñëa, and He must be the first to relish it.

When the food is nicely prepared we offer it back to the Source from which everything emanates. If we remember that His "hunger" is proportional to our love, the offering is sure to be successful. Simply place love, and a generous portion of each item to be offered, on a plate or metal tray, along with a glass of fresh water, and set it before the Deity or picture of Kåñëa. Then prostrate yourself and pray to Lord Kåñëa to accept your humble offering. Acknowledging that it is through the mercy of the spiritual master and the golden incarnation Lord Caitanya that Kåñëa accepts our offering, the devotees of the Kåñëa consciousness movement offer food to the Lord with these prayers:

1) nama oà viñëu-pädäya kåñëa-preñöhäya bhütale
çrémate bhaktivedänta-svämin iti nämine

namas te särasvate devam gaura-väëé-pracäriëe
nirviçeña-çünyavädi-päçcätya-deça-täriëe

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, who is very dear to Lord Kåñëa, having taken shelter at His lotus feet.

"Our respectful obeisances unto you, O spiritual master, servant of Sarasvaté Gosvämé. You are kindly preaching the message of Lord Caitanyadeva and delivering the Western countries, which are filled with impersonalism and voidism." [Çréla Prabhupäda Praëati]

2) namo mahä-vadänyäya kåñëa-prema-pradäya te
kåñëäya kåñëa-caitanya-nämne gaura-tviñe namaù

"I offer my respectful obeisances unto the Supreme Lord Çré Kåñëa Caitanya, who is more magnanimous than any other incarnation, even Kåñëa Himself, because He is bestowing freely what no one else has ever given—pure love of Kåñëa." [Madhya 19.53]

3) namo brahmaëya-deväya go brähmaëa hitäya ca
jagadd-hitäya kåñëäya govindäya namo namaù
[Viñëu Puräëa 1.19.65]

"I offer my respectful obeisances to the Supreme Absolute Truth, Kåñëa, who is the well-wisher of the cows and the brähmaëas as well as the living entities in general. I offer my repeated obeisances to Govinda, who is the pleasure reservoir for all the senses. "

After offering the food to the Lord, you may distribute the prasädam to all who are present. Çréla Bhaktivinoda Öhäkura, a great spiritual master in the disciplic succession, has written a nice prayer which you may recite before eating:

çaréra avidyä-jäl, joåaendriya tähe käl, jéve fele viñaya-sägore,
tär madhye jihväti, lobhamoy sudurmati, thäke jetä kathina saàsäre,

kåñëa boåa doyämoy, koribäre jihvä joy, saprasäd anna dilo bhäi,
sei annämåta päo, rädhä-kåñëa-guëa gäo, preme òäko caitanya-nitäi

"O Lord, this material body is a place of ignorance, and the senses are a network of paths leading to death. Somehow, we have fallen into this ocean of material sense enjoyment, and of all the senses the tongue is most voracious and uncontrollable; it is very difficult to conquer the tongue in this world. But You, dear Kåñëa, are very kind to us and have given us such nice prasädam just to control the tongue. So now we take that prasädam to our full satisfaction and glorify You, Lord—Rädhä and Kåñëa—and in love call for the help of Lord Caitanya and Nityänanda. [Prasäda-seväya 1]

HKC 1: Basic Cooking Ingredients

CHAPTER I

BASIC COOKING INGREDIENTS

In the Vedic scriptures it is stated that the Supreme Lord has provided ample varieties of foodstuffs for all living creatures and that one should take only that which is allotted to him by the Lord, not more. For humanity the Lord has set aside simple foods such as grains, vegetables, fruit and milk products, and he has requested that we offer Him such pure and nourishing foods. In this way, there are hundreds and thousands of palatable dishes that may be prepared and then offered to Lord Kåñëa.

Listed below are some of the ingredients most commonly used in preparing Kåñëa prasädam.

white flour (unbleached if available)
whole mung beans
*
chick-pea flour, sometimes called besan or gram flour *
whole chick-peas
yellow split peas
split, cleaned urad dahl
*
split, cleaned mung dahl *
farina (cream of wheat)
powdered milk
almonds (raw and shelled)
walnuts (raw and shelled)
peanuts (raw and shelled)
sugar
white rice flour
*

*Most of these ingredients are readily available from regular grocery stores. The items marked with asterisks would more likely be found at Chinese food stores or Indian specialty stores.

HKC 1.1: SPICES

SPICES

Spices determine the taste of a preparation, and they are the jewels of cooking for Kåñëa. Foodstuffs are spiced in three different ways.

Massala is prepared by heating ghee in a pan, adding spices, and cooking them until they become fragrant; then the vegetable is added to the ghee and spices. Most of the vegetable recipes are cooked in massala. Chaunche is prepared by heating a small amount of ghee in a small pot. Spices are added and cooked until fragrant, and the contents of the pot are added to an already cooked preparation, such as dahl or chutney. The third process is to add certain uncooked spices to a preparation. This is usually done in savories such as samosa or kachori filling because they will be deep-fried. Using uncooked spices keeps the taste fresher after the deep-frying. Adding or omitting a spice varies the taste quite a bit. Crushed or whole chilis or ground cayenne pepper have no taste; they provide the heat sensation. After preparing certain dishes several times, you will become familiar with the spices and be able to make up your own massala or chaunche.

Hot and spicy preparations should not be mixed with unspiced preparations. Salt should never be put into milk or butter. Salt may be added to yoghurt, however. Some spices are sweet, and some are pungent. For instance, luglu would never be made with asafoetida. In preparing prasädam it is a good policy to stick to paramparä (disciplic succession) and not experiment too much on one's own.

The spices that are mentioned here also have a role other than taste. They serve certain functions for maintaining good health. Turmeric is a blood purifier, chili peppers aid digestion, asafoetida is an anti-convulsant, ginger controls the intestines, etc. If possible, spices should be bought whole and ground at home in small quantities. The taste of freshly ground spices is incomparable.

Some of the common spices used in prasädam preparations are listed below:

ground allspicecoriander

ground cumin seeds

whole anise seedcumin seedsblack pepper

fresh ginger

whole caraway seedsgingercardamom pods

dried mango powder

cayennenutmeghed chilis

whole peppercorn

ground cinnamonwatercinnamon sticks

saffron

ground cloves

whole sesame seedscloves

ground turmeric

Most of these spices are available at supermarkets and spice shops, but some will have to be purchased at Indian specialty stores. If there are none in your area, you can probably have these spices shipped to you. Asafoetida and mango powder will have to be purchased from a specialty store, and ginger root may only be available in a Chinese food store.

HKC 1.2: SPECIALLY PREPARED INGREDIENTS

SPECIALLY PREPARED INGREDIENTS

There are a few basic recipes which are used over and over again in preparing food for Kåñëa's pleasure. Yoghurt, curd, bean sprouts and such rare and costly ingredients as ghee may be simply and inexpensively prepared from the recipes given here. Generally we do not use commercially prepared cheeses, buttermilk or sour cream because many commercial products contain a nonvegetarian stabilizer called rennet which is an extremely impure ingredient. Generally, sour cream and yoghurt marked "kosher" or "pareve" do not contain this, but it is always best to check carefully. Even if rennet is not listed on the label, it is a good idea to call the dairy company that makes the particular product and ask if rennet has been used. In any case, it is not difficult to make cottage cheese, cream cheese, yoghurt and other such preparations, and this is a good opportunity to render service to Kåñëa by cooking for Him with devotion.

BEAN SPROUTS

1 cup mung beans

Soak whole mung beans overnight in a sufficient of amount of water to allow for expansion. Take a large 2 gallon glass jar and punch holes in the tin cover. Place beans in the jar and fill the jar with lukewarm water. Turn upside down and allow the water to escape by itself through the holes in the lid. When the beans have been "irrigated," shake out excess water and place the jar in a dark warm place. Every four hours, irrigate them in the same way, each time returning them to a warm dark place. Leaving them overnight without irrigation will not harm them if you have tended them regularly all day long. In two or three days they will be nice bean sprouts, like the ones sold in the store, but more flavorful and much cheaper. They can be stored in a plastic bag in the refrigerator for about a week and still retain their freshness.

COCONUT MILK

Coconut milk is prepared by adding 1/2 to 1 cup milk to 1/2 freshly grated coconut or 1/4 cup commercially grated coconut. Then heat to the boiling point and let sit for 20 minutes. Strain milk through cheesecloth to remove coconut pulp.

COTTAGE CHEESE (Panir)

Heat 1 pint milk in a saucepan. When it boils, add 1/2 teacupful of yoghurt which has been made a day or two in advance. Bring to the boiling point again. When solid lumps are formed, strain through a fine cloth. The whey (excess liquid) can be used in soups and breads. Press the cloth bag containing the panir with a heavy weight so as to squeeze out all whey.

CREAM CHEESE

Allow fresh cream to sour at room temperature. This will take about 2 days. Pour the soured cream into a clean cheesecloth bag and let the liquid drain. Remove solid cream cheese from the bag.

CULTURED BUTTERMILK

3 1/2 cups fresh or skim milk
1/2 cup buttermilk

Shake the whole milk and the buttermilk together in a quart jar or milk bottle. Cover the jar or bottle and set it in a warm place (perhaps near a hot water heater) overnight or for 10-12 hours. The temperature should be about 80-850 F. When milk has coagulated, shake or stir well and refrigerate.

CURD (A light natural cheese)

1/2 gallon whole milk
2 lemons
large square muslin (18" x 18")

Bring milk to a boil, being careful not to burn it. Meanwhile, squeeze the juice from the lemons and strain it. When the milk boils, add the lemon juice. The milk will curdle. Remove it from the heat and cool it. Then again bring it to a boil. This will nicely separate the curds and the whey. Use the muslin square to line a colander, and pour curds and whey through it. Allow it to drain a few minutes, then tie up the curds in the muslin. Hang this bag up to drip, using a good heavy string. Different preparations using curd call for different amounts of dripping time. Curd is the basis of many different delicious preparations. It has no substitute.

GHEE

3 lbs. sweet butter, as fresh as possible

Used for deep-frying and regular cooking, ghee is the best cooking medium; it has the most delicate flavor and has no substitute.

Place the butter in a heavy pot. It is easiest if the liquid fills between 1/2—3/4 of the pot when the butter has melted. Let the butter melt on a medium flame until it begins to foam up. Take a large spoon and a bowl and skim the foam off into the bowl. Lower the heat and keep cooking Gradually the butter will clarify and the solids will keep rising to the top. The solids will begin to be crusty rather than foamy. Be very careful not to burn the ghee. Keep skimming every 10 minutes or so until the ghee is an amber color and no more solids rise to the top. (Preparation time is from 11/2 to 21/2 hours). The few impurities which remain at the bottom can be strained by pouring the ghee into a container through muslin Ghee can be stored indefinitely without refrigeration. The solids can be used in making bread, biscuits, steamed vegetables and cereals.

BASIC MASSALA

Heat 1 T. ghee
Add 1 t. whole cumin seed
Brown cumin seed and 1 t. crushed chilis.
Cook until brown.

GRAM MASSALA

1 T. cloves,
2 T.
cinnamon
1 T. ground coriander
1 T. ginger
1 T. nutmeg
2 T. ground cumin

Mix together all spices.

There are many different mixtures of spices, and they are all called gram massala. You can purchase Indian spices at specialty stores. When you are familiar with the different spices, you can prepare your own.

KHOYA

Boil milk fairly quickly in a pan for 1 hour, stirring continuously as it thickens. When cool, the residue is khoya, which becomes stiff and is used in pastry and sweetmeats. 1 pint milk makes about 3 oz. khoya. The cooking and stirring process takes patience and time.

SOUR MILK COTTAGE CHEESE

1 qt. raw milk
(sour or clabbered whole milk)

Heat milk over hot water until lukewarm. It should curdle and thicken. Remove it from the heat and stand it in a warm place for curd to collect. Pour cheese into cloth-lined strainer. Drain whey. (If milk was very sour, rinse with cold water and drain again). Hang until all whey is drained off. Moisten with cream or sour milk.

TAMARIND WATER

lump of tamarind about the size of a walnut
5 oz. hot water
sugar or molasses for sweet and sour sauce (optional)

Soak the tamarind in hot water. When the water is cool, squeeze and strain into a cup. This amount is equal in sourness to the juice of 2 lemons. To increase sour taste, increase amount of tamarind used. Tamarind can be bought at an Indian specialty store.

picture caption: Kåñëa is notorious as a transcendental butter thief because He used to break the butter pots of His mother and distribute the contents to His friends and playmates.

YOGHURT

one gallon whole fresh milk
1 pint prepared yoghurt (plain)

Bring milk to a full boil, stirring occasionally with a wooden spoon. Be careful not to burn it. Remove from fire and place in refrigerator or sink with cold water to cool. When milk has cooled to a little warmer than normal body temperature, stir yoghurt until very smooth—no lumps—and add to the milk. Stir and mix thoroughly. The yoghurt tends to stay on the bottom of the pot, so carefully stir the bottom. On your stove, pile 4 burner rings one on top of another and make sure they are very steady. Turn on the pilot light to medium, or use the smallest flame in the ring, and place the covered pot of milk and yoghurt on the burners. Leave covered and maintain the temperature at approximately 110O (use a cooking thermometer), only until the yoghurt thickens. Place the yoghurt in a convenient container in the refrigerator until thoroughly cool. Do not put it in the freezer. When it is cold, it is yoghurt.

Take out 1 pint and set it aside for use in starting the next batch. You should make yoghurt about twice a week to be sure the culture doesn't weaken. If one gallon is too much, then make 1/2 gallon and use 1/2 pint yoghurt for starter. Yoghurt should be stirred very well before it is offered, and sugar should be added to sweeten it. There are many prasädam recipes requiring yoghurt. Every month or so, or if the yoghurt starts turning out thin and watery, you should purchase fresh yoghurt at the store to use for starter.

picture caption: Here a transcendental feast is offered to the Lord in ISKCON's Hawaii temple on the Appearance Day of Lord Caitanya Mahaprabhu.

HKC 2: Rice

CHAPTER II

RICE

It is explained in the Upaniñads that in order to live a life of peace and happiness and make progress in self-realization, one should live in a very simple and pure manner. One should know that because he is an eternal part and parcel of Kåñëa, Kåñëa will surely provide whatever he needs for his maintenance and sustenance. Therefore one should be contented with the simple food which Lord Kåñëa has provided for human society, and he should not take more than that. Knowing that everything actually belongs to Kåñëa, the devotee first offers all his food to Kåñëa, and then he joyfully accepts the prasadam remnants as Kåñëa's mercy.

In order to be accepted by Kåñëa, food need not be very opulent, but it should be offered to the Lord with love and devotion. In the Kåñëa Book Çréla Prabhupäda relates the story of a poor devotee who had nothing to offer the Lord but a few grains of the lowest grade of rice. But because of his sincere devotion, the Lord was so pleased by this offering that he turned the devotee's small hut into a palace and granted him unlimited opulence. Çréla Prabhupäda comments, "What the devotee actually offers to the Lord is not needed by the Lord. He is self-sufficient. If the devotee offers something to the Lord, it acts for his own interest because whatever a devotee offers comes back in a quantity a million times greater. One does not become a loser by giving to the Lord, but he becomes a gainer by millions of times."

Even plain steamed rice will be accepted by the Lord as a very opulent offering if it is offered with love and devotion. Rice is a very simple preparation, but to cook it nicely for Kåñëa requires practice. Each grain should be separate; it should be neither mushy nor hard. To cook plain rice, use two parts water for one part rice, bring it to a boil, cover it, lower the flame, and let it summer for 15-20 minutes. Rice should first be washed and rinsed several times, until the water becomes clear. The pot should be deep and the cover tight-fitting. Just before removing it from the fire, "flake" the rice gently with a fork.

Plain steamed rice and be made fancier by adding some peas in the last five minutes of cooking, and of course plain steamed rice can be offered with curry. Rice also combines with vegetables, nuts and curd in a very pleasing way. The most important consideration, however, is not the elaborateness of the preparation but the devotee's sincere desire to please the senses of Lord Çré Kåñëa.

HKC 2.1: COPRA CANA

COPRA CANA

2 cups extra long grain rice
1 qt. thick coconut milk
10 whole cardamoms
10 whole cloves
2 cinnamon sticks
1/2 cup butter
1/2 t. turmeric
1/2 t. allspice

Fry the spices in ghee for a few minutes. Then fry rice in this mixture for about 3 minutes. Add boiling coconut milk to the depth of 2" above the rice. Cover and let simmer. Do not stir this dish. It must be carefully folded with a fork about twice during cooking.

HKC 2.2: LEMON RICE

LEMON RICE

2 cups rice
1/4 cup butter
1/2 t. cumin seeds
1 t. turmeric
1/2 t. salt
4 cups water
2 lemons
1/2 t. coriander seeds

Fry rice, cumin seeds, coriander seeds, turmeric and salt in butter. Add water. When done, after about 20 minutes, add the juice of a lemon to each cup of rice.

HKC 2.3: LIME RICE

LIME RICE

1 1/2 cups chick-peas
2 cups rice
1 T. turmeric
1 fresh lime
1/4 cup ghee
1/2 cup fresh lime juice
1/2 t. salt
1 T. ginger
1/2 t. cayenne

Cook rice as usual with 1/2 t. salt. Soak 1 1/2 cups chick-peas for 3 hours and drain. Fry the beans in 1/4 cup ghee until crisp. Then mix them with turmeric. Toss spices, lime juice and salt into cooked rice. Garnish with thin rounds of lime.

HKC 2.4: POTATO RICE

POTATO RICE

1 cup rice
1 cup cubed potatoes
1/4 cup butter
1/2 t. cumin seeds
1/2 t. coriander seeds
1 t. turmeric
1/2 t. salt
1/4 t. cayenne pepper
2 cups water
1/2 lemon

Fry rice and potato chunks in butter and spices. Add water to cover and cook until tender. Add the juice of 1/2 lemon for each cup of rice.

HKC 2.5: PULAO

PULAO

2 cups rice
10 oz. peas
1
1/2 cups butter
4 cups water
1 t. salt
1 t. gram massala
1 t. ground cumin seed
1/8 t. cayenne
1/8 t. ginger
1/8 t. black pepper
1/8 t. tumeric

Sauté rice in 1 cup butter. Set 1/2 cup butter and peas aside. Add all other ingredients to rice and cook until done. Cook peas in butter separately and add when done.

HKC 2.6: PUSHPANA WITH CASEIN

PUSHPANA WITH CASEIN

2 cups rice
2 or 3 lemons
1 qt. fresh milk
ghee for frying
massala
3 T. butter
1 t. turmeric
4 cups water
1
1/2 t. cinnamon
1/2 t. ginger
1/2 t. nutmeg
pinch black pepper
pinch cloves
1/4 cup sugar
1/4 t. asafoetida
a little corn starch for hands

Casein:

Prepare curd (see recipe for Curd). Let hang 6-8 hours. Remove from muslin and knead on a smooth surface until curd is smooth and oily. Pinch off bits of curd and roll into little balls. Use corn starch on hands to prevent sticking. Deep-fry balls in ghee using medium-low heat until golden. Stir for even frying. Remove and drain.

Rice:

Make massala. Add rice, turmeric, asafoetida and water. Cook until done. Then add cheese balls, butter, spices and sugar.

HKC 2.7: RAINBOW RICE

RAINBOW RICE

2 cups rice
1 t. salt
slivered green peppers
2 zucchinis
4 cups water
ghee
2 t. turmeric
1 tomato
1/4 cup sweet butter
1 t. gram massala

Steam rice, adding salt. Saute one green pepper in ghee and massala. Fry zucchinis in ghee and flavor with turmeric. In serving bowl, place a layer of rice, a layer of peppers, a layer of zucchini and one tomato cut into chunks. Sprinkle with paprika and toss to marble the colors. Finish all ingredients in this manner. Top with melted sweet butter.

HKC 2.8: RED RICE

RED RICE

2 cups rice
1 t. gram massala
1/4 cup sweet butter
1 sliced green pepper
1 cup stewed tomatoes water

Wash rice. Heat 1t. massala in butter. Add a sliced green pepper and saute until tender. Add rice and cook until it begins to color or stick to the pan. Add tomatoes and enough water to rise 1" above the rice. Bring to the boiling point. Simmer until quiet and liquid is absorbed.

HKC 2.9: RICE WITH PEAS

RICE WITH PEAS

4 T. ghee
1/2 T. cumin seed
1
1/2 t. crushed chilis
1/2 t. ground black pepper
1 cup white rice
1/2 T. turmeric
1 T. salt
1/2 lb. peas
1
3/4 cups water

Heat ghee and add cumin seed. When it browns add crushed chilis and black pepper. Add washed, drained white rice and stir. Add salt and turmeric. When rice sticks a little to the side of the pan, add peas. Add the water and bring to a boil. Cover and lower flame. Wait 15-20 minutes and check to see if rice is done. Do not stir until after rice is cooked. Casein may be added to rice about 5 minutes before it is done. A very nice rice dish—colorful for feasts and very tasty.

HKC 2.10: RICE WITH PEAS AND PEANUTS

RICE WITH PEAS AND PEANUTS

1 1/2 T. ghee
1
1/4 cups washed long grain rice
1/2 T. crushed chilis
1/2 t. ground black pepper
1/2 t. salt
1/3 lb. peas
1/4 cup raw peanuts
2
1/8 cups water

Put the ghee in a saucepan and heat it on a medium or low flame. Add crushed chilis. When they turn black, add black pepper. Add peanuts and stir until peanuts are golden brown. Add washed, drained rice and continue to stir until rice sticks a little to the bottom and sides of the pot. Add salt and peas. Stir a little more and then add water. Bring to a boil on medium-high flame, cover and turn heat very low. Cook 15-20 minutes covered—do not stir. After 15-20 minutes check the rice by sticking a spoon down into it. Do not stir. If it is still wet, cover and continue cooking. It is done when dry. Fluff a little with a fork.

HKC 2.11: RICE WITH SPINACH

RICE WITH SPINACH

1 1/2 T. ghee
1/4 T. crushed chilis
1/2 t. ground black pepper
1
1/4 cups washed long grain rice
1/2 t. salt
2
1/8 cups water
1/2 lb. spinach (fresh)
1 t. ground coriander
1/2 cup fried peanuts (drained)

Put the ghee in a saucepan and heat it on a medium flame. Add crushed chilis. When they turn black, add black pepper and rice. Stir until rice begins to stick to pan. Add salt and water. Bring to a boil on a high flame, cover and turn heat very low. Cook about 12 minutes. Meanwhile, wash spinach very carefully and drain. After rice has cooked 12 minutes, add spinach and coriander. Do not stir. Cook another 5 minutes and test by sticking fork into rice to see if it is done. Uncover and cook another 2 minutes to dry out rice. Fluff with a fork, distributing spinach throughout. Add peanuts and stir lightly again.

HKC 2.12: SPICY RICE

SPICY RICE

Basic Massala
2 cups rice
4 cups water
1/2 of a cardamom pod
pinch of cloves
1/3 cup butter
pinch thyme
1/2 t. nutmeg
1 t. cinnamon
1 t. ginger
1 T. ghee

Prepare basic massala in 1 T. ghee. Add rice and stir until rice is brown. Add water, bring to a boil, then cover rice and cook until done (about 20 minutes). Add all the spices and butter. Stir gently.

HKC 2.13: YELLOW RICE

YELLOW RICE

2 cups white rice
4 cups water
1 t. salt
1 t. turmeric
sweet butter

Wash rice and drain. Measure water into a pot along with the salt, turmeric and rice. Stir nicely and cover tightly. Cook over a low flame for 20 minutes. Garnish with sweet butter to taste.

HKC 3: Dahl

CHAPTER III

DAHL

Bhagavad-gétä explains that in order to achieve self-realization and God realization, one should be temperate in his activities of eating, sleeping, working and recreation. "There is no possibility of one's becoming a yogé," Lord Kåñëa says, "if one eats too much or eats too little, sleeps too much or does not sleep enough." (Bg. 6.16) It is not that one should artificially try to eat less than one needs, but eating should be regulated for the purpose of spiritual progress.

Modern so-called civilized men are addicted to eating meat, which they accompany with liquor to help aid their digestion. This meat and liquor agitates them, and they cannot control their senses. Thus they become trapped in nature's modes of passion and ignorance and behave more like animals than civilized men.

Therefore, one should not eat anything and everything but should eat only food which is offered to the Lord. As explained in Bhagavad-gétä, when offered to the Lord one's eatables are sanctified, and by eating sanctified foodstuffs, one's very existence becomes purified; by the purification of existence, finer tissues in the memory become sanctified, and when memory is sanctified, one can think of the path of liberation, and all these combined together lead to Kåñëa consciousness, the great necessity of present-day society.

There is no need for human beings to resort to eating meat, fish or eggs to get protein because there is ample protein available through split peas, nuts, dahl, whole wheat, etc. The main source of protein in the daily Kåñëa consciousness yoga diet is dahl, which is made from different types of dried beans. Most varieties are easily available in Indian specialty stores, the most delicious being split mung dahl and split urad dahl. Ordinary split peas or whole mung beans may also be used. Dahl can be a very plain but wholesome soup, or it can be used to make the most delicate and unusual pancakes. It is also used in kachoris, which are the best of all savories and a favorite of Çrématé Rädhäräëé, Kåñëa's eternal consort.

Chick peas (garbanzo beans) are usually offered in the morning and may be prepared as follows. Soak the chick-peas overnight (1/2 cup is sufficient for a family of four). In the morning, drain them well and sprinkle over them the juice of 1/2 lemon. Add 1/2 t. salt, a light sprinkling of black pepper and a pinch of asafoetida. Offered with small pieces of ginger, they are a wonderful source of energy.

HKC 3.1: BASIC SPLIT PEA DAHL

BASIC SPLIT PEA DAHL

1 cup split peas
1 red pepper
1 cup variety cut vegetables
2 T. ghee
5 cups water
1 t. salt
2 t. turmeric
1/2 t. cumin seeds

Wash peas and place in a saucepan with water, turmeric and salt. Bring to a boil. Add vegetables. Reduce treat end simmer until dahl is a smooth soup (about 1 hour). In a small pan heat ghee until smoking. Add cumin seeds and cook until black. Add the broken red pepper and cook until black. Pour contents in a fell swoop into the dahl and cover quickly to avoid splashing.

HKC 3.2: CHICK-PEAS (Garbanzo Beans)

CHICK-PEAS (Garbanzo Beans)

2 cups chick-peas
8 cups water
1 red pepper
1/2 cup freshly grated coconut
juice of 1 lemon
1/4 cup ghee
1 T. salt
1 t. turmeric
1 t. cumin

Soak peas overnight. Bring peas and water to a boil. Add salt and turmeric. Simmer gently until tender. Add lemon juice and coconut. Prepare chaunche as with BASIC SPLIT PEA DAHL. Serve with CUDDY SAUCE.

HKC 3.3: CHICK-PEAS & PEANUTS

CHICK-PEAS & PEANUTS

1 cup chick-peas
1
1/2 cups raw peanuts
2 t. salt
juice from 1 lemon
1/2 t. turmeric
ghee for deep frying
1/4 t. cayenne

Soak chick-peas overnight. Drain very well. Fry peanuts and chick-peas until golden brown (separately). Combine all spices with lemon juice and pour over fried chick-peas and peanuts. Mix well.

HKC 3.4: CHICK-PEAS & YOGHURT

CHICK-PEAS & YOGHURT

1 1/2 cups chick-peas
2 cups yoghurt
1/4 t. ground red pepper
1 T. salt
1/2 t. ground black pepper

Wash chick-peas thoroughly. Soak 8 hours or overnight in 4 to 5 cups water. When ready to prepare, use same water and bring to a boil. Cover chick-peas and simmer until they are tender and can be easily mashed. Test by mashing one between the fingers. Drain off water and mash well; then add yoghurt, salt and pepper. Mix well.

HKC 3.5: DOSA PANCAKES

DOSA PANCAKES

1 cup raw white rice
1/2 cup urad or mung dahl (split)
1/2 cup yoghurt
water
2 t. salt
1/4 t. cayenne

Soak the dahl and rice overnight. Drain. Blend in an electric blender, adding salt and cayenne with just enough water to help blending process. Pour into a bowl and add the yoghurt. Mix well. The batter should be like any pancake batter. Lightly grease a skillet. Pour batter into nice circles. The bottom is done while the top is still bubbling. Turn over and brown other side. This may be served plain, or best, with tender potatoes fried in spices with a little water. It can be served with potatoes and cabbages.

HKC 3.6: FRIED DAHL

FRIED DAHL

1 1/2 cups split peas
1 crushed red pepper
1/4 cup ghee
1/2 t. gram massala
1 t. cumin seeds
1/4 t. ginger

Wash and soak peas in water overnight. Drain. Heat ghee and make massala. Add peas and fry slowly for 20-25 minutes or until tender and spices have been absorbed. These are not crispy. Spice now with gram massala and ginger.

HKC 3.7: HARD DAHL

HARD DAHL

1 lb. yellow split peas (or any other dahl)
1 t. red pepper
3 cups ghee
1/2 t. salt
1/4 t. black pepper
1 t. cumin
1 t. cinnamon
1 t. ginger
1/2 t. nutmeg
1/4 t. ground cloves

Soak peas overnight and drain. Heat ghee and slowly pour in peas and fry slowy until hard Drain off excess ghee. Then add remaining spices. Stir well and serve.

HKC 3.8: KITRI

KITRI

1 cup rice
1 cup urad or mung dahl or split peas
1 T. salt
1 t. tumeric
2 crushed red peppers
1/2 cauÿiflower or cabbage
1" piece of fresh ginger
2 cups string beans
1 t. anise seed
1 small potato
1/2 t. asafoetida
1/4 cup butter
2 t. ground cumin
5 cups water

Wash rice and dahl very thoroughly. Place in large-sized pot with tight cover and add water. Bring to a boil. Add salt and spices. Cut cauliflower in large flowerettes, or cut cabbage in large pieces. Cut potato in 11/2" chunks; remove strings from string beans and snap into 2" pieces. Add vegetables immediately or after kitri has been simmering on a medium flame, covered for 1/2 hour, for more crisp vegetables. Stir once or twice, but not too often. Frequent stirring makes the kitri too mushy. Cook on low-medium flame until it is well cooked and the vegetables are very tender. Add butter and stir lightly. Offer to Kåñëa.

HKC 3.9: MUNG BEAN DAHL

MUNG BEAN DAHL

1 cup mung beans
6 cups water
1/2 t. finely chopped fresh ginger
1 large fresh sliced tomato
3 T. ghee
1 t. salt
1 t. turmeric
1/2 t. cumin seed
1 t. red pepper

Wash beans and put into a saucepan with water. Add tomato, ginger, turmeric and salt. Bring to a boil. Turn to a low boil and cook until the beans are soft and broken up. Spice as with basic split dahl.

HKC 3.10: SPLIT PEA BARA

SPLIT PEA BARA

2 cups yellow split peas (green if not available)
2 cups yoghurt
ghee for frying
1
1/2 cups water
1/4 -1/2 cup salt
1/4 t. cinnamon
1 T. ground coriander
2 T. sage
1 T. ground cumin
1 T. tumeric
1/2 t. cayenne
1
1/2 t. salt
1/4 t. allspice
1/2 t. asafoetida

Wash split peas well. Soak 2 hours and then drain. Grind in a food grinder into a pan. Place another pan under grinder to catch excess water. Grind a second time. Discard excess water. Add spices to ground peas and mix until well-blended. Heat ghee in a deep fryer (about 1/3 full).

In another pot make a solution of salt and water—2 handfuls of salt to 6 cups of water. Shape ground peas into flat cakes the size of a half dollar. It is helpful to put a little salt water in the palm of the hand while patting the split peas into baras. Place a layer of baras in the frying basket and deep fry until hard, but not brown. Put the fried baras in the salt water solution and soak until they are slightly soft. Remove them and mix the baras in with the yoghurt. Before offering, place baras and yoghurt in oven for 10 minutes under low heat. Yoghurt will separate and the nice flavor is increased.

HKC 3.11: URAD DAHL

URAD DAHL

1 cup urad dahl
1/2 sliced tomato
6 cups water
1 t. salt

optional chaunche

1/4 t. anise seed
1 t. turmeric
1/4 t. asafoetida
1" piece fresh ginger

Wash dahl and put dahl, tomato and water into saucepan. Bring to a boil and add all other ingredients. Cook on a high flame for five minutes; then cover and simmer until beans are soft and expanded.

HKC 3.12: URAD DAHL BARA

URAD DAHL BARA

1 cup urad dahl (split)
2 cups yoghurt
ghee for deep frying
1/4 cup water
1/2 t. cinnamon
1
1/2 t. salt
1 t. cumin
1/2 t. allspice
1 t. cayenne

Soak dahl overnight. Drain, then grind in a blender, adding a little water (no more than 1/4 cup) to a paste. Beat the paste a little. Heat the ghee. Make a mixture of salt and water—a handful of salt to 3 cups water. Wet your palms with the salt water mixture and pat the paste into little cakes no bigger than half dollars. Fry the baras in the ghee on a medium flame until golden brown. Drain. Soak the baras in the salt water mixture about five minutes and then remove them and squeeze them so that the water is removed. Beat the yoghurt and spices together with salt. Pour the yoghurt over the baras. These are more delicate than split pea baras.

HKC 4: Breads

CHAPTER IV

BREADS

Although it is very good to pray to the Lord to supply our daily bread and in this way acknowledge our dependence on the Lord, to ask the Lord for bread is actually unnecessary, since He is already supplying food for all living entities, without our needing to pray for it. Knowing this, pure devotees, not concerned with their own self-interest, prepare to bake bread for the Lord's enjoyment and offer it to Him in love. This is just like the love of a child for his father. A father may have many sons and give them all a weekly allowance of money to spend in their own ways for their pleasure, but if one son uses the money to buy something for his father, the father is very much appreciative. Actually the money already belongs to the father, who is not in need of anything from the child, but nevertheless he cannot help being pleased when the son expresses his affection in this way. The son knows: "It is not the money which is wonderful but my father—he is wonderful." Similarly, the pure devotee is not very much concerned with making the Lord his order supplier for daily bread, but he wants to serve Kåñëa in love and devotion. This is Kåñëa consciousness.

The breads described here are very delicious as well as wholesome, and they are easy to prepare with a little practice. None of them are cooked in an oven, although regular baked bread (without yeast) is very nice to offer. All the breads described here (except bread sticks) are round and require a little skill in rolling, but it soon becomes easy to do. Chapatis, which are made from whole wheat, are the daily bread of the classical Vedic diet. Puris and chapatis are especially exciting to make because they blow up almost to bursting during the cooking. The perfect chapati should have no trace of burns on it, and the perfect puri should be white, with no brown areas. Both, however, must be fully cooked.

HKC 4.1: BREAD STICKS

BREAD STICKS

2 cups whole wheat flour
1
1/2 T. sesame seeds or caraway seeds
1/2 cup white flour
1 t. salt
ghee for deep-frying

Mix together flours, salt and seeds. Add ghee solids and mix with hands until flour is the consistency of coarse corn meal. Add enough warm water to make a soft and damp dough (but not wet). Add water gradually to avoid using too much. Knead the dough until done for 5 to 10 minutes. Divide it into 12 parts. Roll the bits of dough into long shapes, no longer than 5" long and 1"-1 1/2" in diameter. Deep fry the bread sticks, several at a time. They should be covered as much as possible by the ghee. Deep fry on a medium flame until they are golden brown and sound hollow when tapped. Remove with tongs and drain. Delicious buttered or plain, they are very good for traveling and will keep nicely for 2 to 3 days. They also make elegant rolls.

HKC 4.2: CHAPATIS

CHAPATIS

1 cup whole wheat flour
1/4 cup melted butter
warm water

Mix together flour and water. Add water gradually until dough is soft but not wet and can be kneaded. Knead the dough until fairly soft (about 10 minutes). Cover and let stand 1 hour. Sprinkle flour on the rolling area and pinch off balls of dough about 1 1/2" in diameter. Flatten balls and roll out to about 4-5" in diameter. Heat a skillet (you should have one just for this purpose; always keep it clean and free from oil or ghee—cast iron is best) and place the chapati on it. Watch carefully. When bubbles appear, turn chapati quickly and watch for bubbles again. Using tongs, hold the chapati over a direct flame from the stove. You can rest the chapati on the burner, but be very quick to turn it. Place the chapati down on the first side that it was cooked on in the skillet. Within a few seconds the chapati will puff up. Quickly turn it over, put on the burner a few seconds, and then remove. Butter both sides with the melted butter, using a pastry brush. Cover the chapatis with a clean cloth to keep in the heat.

HKC 4.3: CHEPURIS

CHEPURIS

1 cup whole wheat flour (or 1/2 cup whole wheat flour water 1/2 cup white flour)
1/2 t. salt
water
ghee for deep-frying
2 T. ghee solids, ghee or butter

Prepare dough as for PURIS, and then fry in the same way. Chepuris are very delicious and tasty because they combine the wholesome taste of chapatis with the delicacy of puris.

HKC 4.4: CHIPS

CHIPS

2 cups white flour
1/2 t. baking powder
2 T. caraway or sesame seeds
scant
3/4 cup cold water
1/2 T. coarse salt
3
1/2 T. ghee solids
ghee for deep-frying

Mix together flour, seeds, salt and baking powder. Add ghee solids, mixing with hands until flour is corn meal consistency. Slowly add cold water, mixing constantly. Knead dough, then roll out to 1/4" thickness. Cut into diamond shapes and deep-fry until golden brown.

HKC 4.5: COCONUT BREAD

COCONUT BREAD

1/2 cup whole wheat flour
1 cup grated coconut
3 T. sugar
1 t. salt
pinch coriander
few drops rose water

Mix ingredients with enough cold water to make a soft dough. Pat into dollar-size patties and fry in ghee until crisp and light brown.

HKC 4.6: PARATHA

PARATHA

1 1/2 cups whole wheat flour
1/4 cup ghee or melted butter
1/2 cup white flour
water

Work butter or ghee into flour with fingertips. Add enough water to make a medium-soft consistency. Cover and let stand for one-half hour. Knead for about 10 minutes. Make large balls, 2" in diameter, using 1/2 cup flour for each paratha, and roll out about 8" round so it's nice and thick. Spread top with melted butter and fold in half. Smear with butter and fold into quarters (/\ shape). Roll out. Place in a medium hot skillet, turning frequently. With each turn, add a spoonful of ghee on the surface and rub lightly with the spoon. Press the edges occasionally to insure doneness. Cook until it turns reddish and is crispy.

HKC 4.7: STUFFED PARATHA

STUFFED PARATHA

Prepare regular paratha, but before folding, add 1 T. grated radish, cauliflower, or green pepper with a sprinkle of salt and ground coriander. These are very delicious and can be offered in an assortment to Kåñëa.

HKC 4.8: PARATHA II

PARATHA II

1 cup whole wheat flour
water
a few tablespoons of butter or ghee

Mix water into the flour, stir a little, and then press or knead lightly again. Make a 2" ball from the dough and then roll out a round paratha about 1/3-1/2" thick. Place a little ghee in a heavy round-bottom pan (or Indian tala). Put the paratha down on one side into the pan; in a short while it will puff up. Turn it over and cook the paratha in a small amount of butter or ghee until both sides are a light brown. A few turnings on each side should be sufficient.

HKC 4.9: STUFFED PARATHA II

STUFFED PARATHA II

Roll out paratha in the same way. On one paratha place a few teaspoonsful of vegetables (raw spinach, grated white radish, grated cauliflower, grated carrot, mashed potatoes, etc.) and sprinkle vegetables with a little gram massala and salt. Place another paratha on top, and then roll them together to seal. Roll very carefully. Cook them the same as regular parathas. Offer hot.

HKC 4.10: PURIS

PURIS

2 cups white flour
2
1/2 T. ghee or ghee solids
little over
1/2 cup water
ghee for deep-frying

Add ghee solids to flour and mix with hands until flour is consistency of coarse corn meal. Add water a little at a time; keep mixing. Knead dough about 10 to 15 minutes. Cover with a dampened cloth and let sit about 1/2 hour. For rolling, rub a little ghee on a table top and onto rolling pin. Pinch off bits of dough into balls 1 1/2" in diameter. Roll into round, flat, thin puris. It takes a little practice to get them perfectly round.

Place puri in hot ghee. Push it to the bottom and bathe it in ghee. It will rise up and puff up, like a balloon. Turn over quickly; remove with tongs. To drain them nicely, prepare in advance a cardboard box lined with paper toweling. Stand puris up in long lines to drain. Puris are traditionally served plain, but they may be sprinkled with confectioner's sugar or spread with chopped walnuts, raisins and honey. They are delicious served with fruit chutneys or with WET POTATOES AND CAULIFLOWER.

HKC 4.11: SOPAI PILLAS

SOPAI PILLAS

4 cups white flour
2 T. ghee
2 t. black pepper
milk
3 T. sugar
ghee for frying

Work ghee into sifted dry ingredients with fingertips. Add enough milk to make a firm dough. Cover and let dough stand for 30 to 40 minutes. Then roll out to a 1/4" thickness. Cut into diamonds and deep fry in ghee.

HKC 4.12: WHOLE WHEAT DIAMONDS

WHOLE WHEAT DIAMONDS

2 cups whole wheat flour
1 T. coriander
1/4 cup ghee
water
1 cup powdered sugar
ghee for deep-frying

Mix coriander into the wheat flour. Rub in ghee with fingertips. Add the powdered sugar and enough water to make a stiff dough. Roll out 1/4" thick and cut into diamonds. Fry in ghee.

HKC 5: Vegetables

CHAPTER V

VEGETABLES

In Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa declares, "I enter into each planet, and by My energy they stay in orbit. I become the moon and thereby supply the juice of life to all vegetables." (Bg. 15.13) Çréla Prabhupäda further explains: "It is due to the Supreme Personality of Godhead that the moon nourishes all vegetables. Due to the moon's influence, the vegetables become delicious. Without the moonshine, the vegetables can neither grow nor taste succulent. Human society is working, living comfortably and enjoying food due to the supply from the Supreme Lord. Otherwise, mankind could not survive. Everything becomes palatable by the agency of the supreme Lord, through the influence of the moon."

Most vegetables in season can be offered to Kåñëa. From the recipes in this section you will see how you can transform simple vegetables into classic, flavorful dishes. The potato is called the "king" of vegetables because it can be prepared in many delicious ways. Eggplant and cauliflower, being great favorites, are also an integral part of the Vedic diet, as are okra, string beans and peas. Onions, garlic and mushrooms are considered unclean vegetables and are therefore never offered to Kåñëa. Vegetables can be prepared with spices or steamed in a small amount of water with butter added at the end. Fresh lemon squeezed on plain vegetables prepared by steaming is very delicious, and the correct amount of salt brings out the wonderful natural flavor of any vegetable. Each recipe calls for fresh vegetables. One should not offer Lord Kåñëa canned vegetables and fruits. However, frozen vegetables may be used, since they retain their freshness.

HKC 5.1: BEAN SPROUTS

BEAN SPROUTS

6 cups bean sprouts (fresh)
1/2 t. ground ginger
2 T. ghee
1/4 t. asafoetida
3/4 t. salt
1/4 t. ground coriander

Heat the ghee and add all spices except salt. Fry spices 2 minutes and then add well-drained bean sprouts. Fry bean sprouts, constantly turning, for 5 to 7 minutes, or until sprouts become translucent and slightly soft. Add salt; fry and mix for 2 minutes more. This is nice as an accompaniment to a green vegetable and TOMATO RICE.*

HKC 5.2: CABBAGE

CABBAGE

2 medium heads cabbage
1 t. cayenne
8 T. ghee
1 t. turmeric
1 T. salt

Core cabbages. Chop into tiny pieces. In a large frying pan heat the ghee, adding the cayenne and turmeric. Stir, then add the cabbage. Fry on medium flame until cabbage becomes clear. Add salt. Stir and cook another few minutes. The cabbage should be neither browned nor watery; it should be slightly crisp.

HKC 5.3: CAULIFLOWER

CAULIFLOWER

3 medium cauliflowers, grated or chopped very small
7 T. ghee
1
1/2 T. salt

Heat ghee on a medium flame. Add the cauliflower, stirring until vegetable becomes clear and slightly tender. Add salt. Stir a few minutes more, being careful not to brown the cauliflower. Do not overcook or the vegetable will become watery. This is very simple, but very delicious and unusual.

HKC 5.4: CHINESE PEA PODS

CHINESE PEA PODS
(sometimes called snow peas or sugar peas)

1/2 lb. pea pods
2 T. ghee
1/4 t. ginger
1/4 t. asafoetida
1/2 t. salt

Heat ghee. Add spices except salt. Fry spices 2 minutes and add pea pods. (The stems of the pods should be removed as you would for string beans). Fry the pods 5 minutes and then add salt. Fry another 5 minutes until pods are just tender. This green vegetable is very delicious and delicate. Be very careful not to burn.

HKC 5.5: CHINESE PEA PODS AND GREEN PEAS

CHINESE PEA PODS AND GREEN PEAS

1/2 lb. pea pods
1 lb. green peas
1/4 cup fried peanuts (opt.)
1/2 cup diced pineapple
4 T. ghee
1/4 t. asafoetida
1/4 t. ginger
1/2 t. coriander
1/2 t. salt
1/2 t. ground black pepper

Remove the stems of the pea pods, and wash and drain well. Heat the ghee and add all the spices except the salt and coriander. Add the pods, and fry for 5 minutes stirring constantly, but gently. Add the salt. Fry another 5 minutes. Add the peas, and stir all together. Cover the pan and let the peas gently steam until they are almost tender. Add pineapple, peanuts, and coriander; stir and cover. When peas are just tender, uncover and cook one minute more.

HKC 5.6: DRY CAULIFLOWER AND POTATOES

DRY CAULIFLOWER AND POTATOES

1 cauliflower
4 potatoes
massala
1 t. turmeric
1 t. salt

Wash and cube potatoes. Wash cauliflower and break into small flowerettes. Make massala. Add vegetables, salt and turmeric. Cover with water and cook over medium heat covered until dry.

HKC 5.7: CUCUMBERS

CUCUMBERS

2 cucumbers
1 small piece fresh ginger
1/4 t. salt
1/2 t. black pepper
pulp from 2 lemons or limes

Cut cucumber into tiny pieces. Grind ginger and citrus pulp. Add salt and pepper. Serve cold. Very cooling in summer.

HKC 5.8: EGGPLANT BHARATA

EGGPLANT BHARATA

1 eggplant
2 small green chilis, saute'ed
small piece fresh ginger
2 T. butter
1/4 cup shredded coconut
1/4 cup golden raisins
1/2 t. ground coriander
1/2 t. salt

Boil eggplant with stalk. Remove from water when tender. Peel, remove the stalk, and mash the pulp. Heat butter, add the pulp, raisins, chilis, salt, finely chopped ginger. Keep frying for 5 minutes. Add shredded coconut and coriander and remove from fire.

HKC 5.9: EGGPLANT FAVORITE

EGGPLANT FAVORITE

1 eggplant, cubed
massala
ghee
1 cup chopped green beans
2 sliced tomatoes

Heat ghee in a pan and make massala. Add eggplant and green beans with a little ghee and cook until soft in covered pan. Add tomatoes. On a high flame, cook and stir until wetness has evaporated.

HKC 5.10: EGGPLANT PUKI

EGGPLANT PUKI

1 medium eggplant
3 T. salt
3 T. turmeric
1/2 cup ghee

Cut the eggplant in quarters. (It is best to use an eggplant that doesn't have a long neck. A short, squat eggplant works best.) After the eggplant is quartered, cut in thick slices. You should have 12 to 14 thick slices. Mix the salt and turmeric together and place in a flat plate. Heat the ghee in a frying pan. The ghee should cover about 1/2" of the pan. Dip each slice of eggplant in salt-turmeric mixture (the slices should be thoroughly dry) and rub the mixture on the slice as a coating. Fry the pieces in the pan of ghee on a medium-high flame, turning as necessary. Hold a small sharp knife over a piece of eggplant puki and let it drop. If it falls straight through, hitting the bottom of the pan, and the eggplant is as soft as butter, it's ready to offer. If there is excess ghee, strain it through a piece of muslin and pour it on plain rice. The muslin will remove the salt and turmeric.

picture caption: Although Kåñëa is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He appeared in this world as a cowherd boy to enjoy transcendental pastimes as the son of Nanda Mahäräja and his wife Yaçodä in the land of Våndävana.

HKC 5.11: EGGPLANT AND TOMATOES

EGGPLANT AND TOMATOES

1 eggplant
ghee for frying
3 cubed tomatoes
2 t. turmeric
1 t. salt
1 green pepper
1/4 cup golden raisins
1/8 t. asafoetida
1/2 t. cumin powder
1/4 t. cayenne

Wash and chop the green pepper, then saute in ghee until tender. Drain and set aside. Cube eggplant and fry in ghee until done. Drain and set aside. Put a little ghee in a pan. Cook tomatoes, spices, green peppers and raisins for 5 minutes, then add eggplant and cook an additional 5 minutes, uncovered.

HKC 5.12: EGGPLANT, TOMATOES AND CHICK-PEAS

EGGPLANT, TOMATOES AND CHICK-PEAS

1 1/2 lb. tomatoes
4 medium eggplants
1/2 cup chick-peas
1/2 cup ghee
1 t. turmeric
1/2 t. crushed chilis
pinch asafoetida

Soak chick-peas overnight. Boil until tender, drain and set aside. They may be mashed. Cut tomatoes into quarters and cook until they are almost all liquid. As they cook, cut eggplant into thin wedges. Heat the ghee and add chilis. When chilis are brown, stir in asafoetida and turmeric. Add eggplant and fry, stirring constantly. When eggplant is soft and coated with spices, add chick-peas and tomatoes. Cook covered, stirring occasionally until vegetables are tender and mixture thickens. This is delicious with rice and lemon.

HKC 5.13: EGGPLANT AND ZUCCHINI

EGGPLANT AND ZUCCHINI

1 eggplant
2 lb. zucchini
1 t. cumin seed
1/2 t. crushed chilis
1/4 cup ghee solids
1 t. salt
1/2 t. turmeric

Wash and cut vegetables into 1" chunks. Make basic massala. Add vegetables and spices and stir. Cook covered on medium heat, stirring occasionally. After 20 minutes, lower heat and continue cooking until vegetables are done. Then remove cover and let excess water steam off.

HKC 5.14: GREEN PEPPERS

GREEN PEPPERS

2 T. ghee
1/2 t. coriander
6 chopped green peppers
1/2 t. turmeric
1/4 cup chick-pea flour
salt
1/2 cup grated coconut

Simmer peppers in ghee until tender. Drain. Mix in other ingredients and fry for 5 minutes.

HKC 5.15: GREEN VEGETABLES BHAJI

GREEN VEGETABLES BHAJI

2 bunches spinach
1 bunch turnip leaves
1 bunch white radish leaves
2 T. ghee
1
1/2 t. salt
1 T. coriander
1/4 t. cayenne
1 small piece ginger

Wash vegetables. Remove the hard stems and cut roughly. Heat 2 T. ghee. Add spices and vegetables and stir well. Cook, uncovered, on low flame until all water is evaporated. Stir again. Add butter.

HKC 5.16: KOFTA (for 6)

KOFTA Balls (for 6)

Balls

2 med. heads cauliflower
2 potatoes
1
1/2 t. tumeric
1
1/2 t. salt
about
1/2 cup chick-pea flour
pinch asafoetida
ghee for deep frying

Sauce

10 tomatoes
1/2 t. whole cumin seed
1/2 t. crushed chilis
1/2 t. whole coriander seed
1/4 t. asafoetida
1/4 t. ground ginger
1 t. salt
2 bay leaves
1/2 t. oregano
2 T. ghee

Grate the cauliflower and potatoes together. Drain excess water. Add all the spices and enough chickpea flour to hold ingredients together in 1" balls. Deep-fry the kofta balls in medium hot ghee. Drain on paper towels and set aside.

Sauce: dry roast the cumin seeds and add chilis. Brown chilis and add asafoetida and ginger. Chop 3 tomatoes and add. Simmer 10 minutes on a low heat. Meanwhile, blend 7 tomatoes and add to sauce with bay leaves and oregano. Cook slowly for 1/2 hour to one hour. Tomato sauce can be begun first and balls can be fried during the simmering time. When tomato sauce is ready to offer, add the kofta balls. Serve with melted butter and LEMON RICE and CHEPURIS.

HKC 5.17: OKRA AND COCONUT

OKRA AND COCONUT

1 T. ghee
1/4 lb. okra (halved long way)
1/2 t. salt
1/2 t. ground turmeric
1/4 cup coconut
1/2 t. ginger
1
1/2 cups yoghurt
1/4 t. cayenne
1/2 t. coriander

Heat ghee. Add halved okra. Fry 5 minutes, then add salt, turmeric and ginger. Fry until done. Combine yoghurt, cayenne, coriander and coconut. Toss with okra.

HKC 5.18: PEAS AND TOMATOES WITH CASEIN

PEAS AND TOMATOES WITH CASEIN
(serves 4-6)

curd from 1/2 gallon of milk
1 t. cayenne
1/2 lb. tomatoes
1 lb. peas
6 T. ghee
1
1/2 t. salt
1 t. turmeric
1 cup whey (save from curd)
1 t. ginger
2 t. ground coriander
ghee for deep frying

Let curd hang 3-4 hours and reserve 1 cup whey. Make casein balls. Set aside. In a frying pan heat ghee and add all the spices except salt. Heat for a minute or two, then add the tomatoes. When the tomatoes cook down a little, add the peas and whey and salt. Lower flame and cook until peas are tender. Add the fried casein balls and simmer about 15 minutes. This is a very rich and tangy vegetable, especially good for festive celebrations.

HKC 5.19: PEAS AND PEANUTS

PEAS AND PEANUTS

2 lb. peas
1/2 cup raw peanuts
4 T. ghee
pinch asafoetida
1 t. salt
1/4 t. turmeric
1/2 t. cayenne
1/2 t. ground black pepper
1 T. ground coriander
1/2 t. cinnamon
1/2 t. allspice

Heat the ghee in a frying pan. Add a pinch of asafoetida. Add peanuts and cook until light golden brown, add peas and stir lightly. Add salt and spices one at a time and stir until all are well mixed. Cook until peas are tender.

HKC 5.20: POTATOES AND PEPPERS

POTATOES AND PEPPERS

2 lb. potatoes, diced
1 green pepper
1/4 cup ghee
1 t. turmeric
1 t. basic massala
1 t. salt

Make basic massala and add green pepper. Add potatoes. Stir. Add turmeric and salt. Cover with water and cook uncovered until done.

HKC 5.21: MASHED POTATOES AND CABBAGE

MASHED POTATOES AND CABBAGE

4 potatoes
1 t. turmeric
1 large cabbage
1/2 t. anise seeds
juice of 1 lemon
1/4 cup brown sugar
1 cup yoghurt
1/2 cup ghee
basic massala

Wash vegetables. Boil peeled potatoes in turmeric water. Mash. Make basic massala. Fry shredded cabbage in ghee with anise. Sprinkle with lemon juice and sugar. Add to potatoes. Add yoghurt and mix.

HKC 5.22: POTATOES, CAULIFLOWER AND PEAS

POTATOES, CAULIFLOWER AND PEAS

4 potatoes
ghee
1 t. turmeric
2 t. salt
1 cup green peas
1/4 t. cayenne
1 cauliflower
1/2 t. cumin powder

Boil all vegetables. Mash into a paste. Add spices and make into patties. Fry in pan until crust is formed. Turn often and add more ghee as necessary.

HKC 5.23: POTATOES, CAULIFLOWER IN YOGHURT

POTATOES, CAULIFLOWER IN YOGHURT

1 small cauliflower
4 potatoes
1 T. turmeric
1/2 t. ginger
1
1/2 t. salt
ghee
1 cup yoghurt

Break washed cauliflower into flowerettes. Wash and slice potatoes. Deep-fry both in ghee until golden. Drain. Toss into spiced yoghurt.

HKC 5.24: DEEP-FRIED POTATOES

DEEP-FRIED POTATOES
(serves 6)

5 lb. potatoes, cut in one inch cubes
2 T. ghee
ghee
1 cup chopped green pepper (opt.)
1 t. cumin seed
1 t. crushed chilis
pinch asafoetida
salt

Using frying basket, deep-fry potatoes in ghee until potatoes are light golden color and are easily pierced with a sharp knife. Do not brown. When they are all done, heat 2 T. ghee in a small pot. Add cumin seed and heat until brown. Then add asafoetida and chilis. When chilis are brown, add ghee and spices to potatoes and salt well. Add green peppers and mix.

HKC 5.25: POTATOES AND YOGHURT

POTATOES AND YOGHURT

2 lb. potatoes
2 cups yoghurt
1 t. salt
1 t. turmeric
1 t. ground cumin

Wash and cut potatoes in half. Boil in a pot with water. When done, drain, mash and add spices. Add yoghurt and mix well.

HKC 5.26: SPINACH IN COCONUT MILK

SPINACH IN COCONUT MILK

1 cup dried grated coconut
1 cup milk
2 lb. spinach
1 t. lemon juice
1/2 t. pepper

Combine coconut and milk in a saucepan. When it boils, remove from heat and discard pulp. Wash spinach and drain well. Chop. Combine spinach, lemon juice, pepper and coconut milk in a saucepan. Cook covered over low heat for 20 minutes.

HKC 5.27: SPINACH, EGGPLANT AND CHICK-PEAS

SPINACH, EGGPLANT AND CHICK-PEAS

massala
2 bunches spinach
5 large tomatoes
1 eggplant
1/2 cup chick-peas
1 T. turmeric
1 T. salt
1/2 cup melted butter

Soak chick-peas overnight. Drain and set aside. Stew tomatoes in simmering water until soft. Drain off excess water and mash. Set aside. Wash and chop spinach and eggplant. Make massala. Add eggplant, tomatoes, chick-peas, spinach and spices. Cook over medium heat until done. Add butter.

HKC 5.28: STRING BEANS (serves 4-6)

STRING BEANS (serves 4-6)

2 lb. string beans
1/4 cup ghee solids
juice of 1
1/2 lemons (strained)
1
1/2 t. salt
1/2 t. black pepper
1 T. ground coriander
1/2 cup fried peanuts (optional)

Wash string beans well. Break off both ends and remove strings. Put them in a saucepan and put one inch of water in the bottom of the pan. Place on medium flame. When water begins to boil, cover and lower flame slightly. Steam string beans until they are tender. Check frequently to see that water does not evaporate. Add a little more water if necessary. When string beans are done, drain them. Keep the water, as it is very nutritious and flavorful, to use in rice or dahl. Add the ghee solids. When they melt, add salt and spices and lemon. Mix very well. Add peanuts.

HKC 5.29: STRING BEANS AND EGGPLANT

STRING BEANS AND EGGPLANT

1 eggplant, chopped
1/2 lb. string beans
1/4 cup ghee
1 t. cumin
1/4 chili, crushed
1/2 t. salt
1/2 t. turmeric
1/3 cup water
massala

Boil string beans in water until soft. Drain and set aside. Put ghee in a pan and make massala. Add chopped eggplant and stir. Add water and other spices. Cover and cook, stirring occasionally until the eggplant is soft as butter. Mix in the string beans. Cook five minutes uncovered.

HKC 5.30: SWEET POTATOES (serves 6)

SWEET POTATOES (serves 6)

2 1/2 lb. sweet potatoes (or yams)
1/2 t. cinnamon
1 t. ground cumin
1 cup grated coconut
1/2 T. salt
1/2 stick butter (2 oz.)
1 t. ground black pepper
1/2 t. allspice
1/4 t. cayenne

Cut yams in halves or quarters if large. Boil until soft. Peel and mash. Toast coconut. Add butter, coconut, salt and spices to yams. Mix well.

HKC 5.31: TOMATOES AND PLANTAINS (serves 6)

TOMATOES AND PLANTAINS (serves 6)

8 plantains, peeled and cut in 1 inch chunks
2 t. salt
ghee for deep frying
8 large tomatoes
1 T. amchur (mango powder)
6 T. ghee
1 t. cumin seed
1/2 t. crushed chilis
1
1/2 T. ground coriander

Cut tomatoes in quarters or eighths. Boil plantains in water until they are bright yellow and slightly tender. Test by piercing with a sharp knife. Drain plantains. Heat ghee for deep frying and deep fry plantains until they are golden brown. Remove. Heat 6 Tablespoon ghee and add cumin seeds. When cumin browns, add crushed chili peppers. When chilis are brown, add tomatoes. Cook until soft and semi-liquid. Add plantains, salt and spices and keep cooking until tomatoes form a nice sauce and plantains are tender. Cover and cook on a low flame, stirring occasionally to prevent sticking or burning.

HKC 5.32: UPMA

UPMA

1 1/2 cups farina (cream of wheat)
1
1/2 cups diced string beans, peas and cabbage
2 t. salt
1/2 t. cumin powder
1 broken chili
2 cups water
1/4 cup butter

Put farina into a dry skillet and stir briskly and continuously over medium flame until browned. When nicely browned, remove from fire and pour into a bowl. Heat butter. Make massala. Add vegetable. Let cook for a few minutes. Then add 2 cups water. Let it come to a boil and cook until the vegetable is done. Add 2 t. salt. Add farina, stirring as you put it in. It will soak up water quickly and is done in no time. It has the consistency of dry halavah.

HKC 5.33: UPMA II

UPMA II (serves 4)

4 T. ghee
1/2 cup peas
1 cup farina (cream of wheat)
2 med. green peppers (cut in small pieces)
strained juice of lemon
1 small cauliflower or cabbage (cut in small pieces)
2 T. butter
1/2 t. turmeric
2 t. salt
1/2 t. cayenne pepper
pinch asafoetida

Put the ghee in a deep pot and heat it well. Add the chopped cauliflower or cabbage until it becomes clear and slightly soft. Add green pepper and saute about 5 minutes, stirring continuously. Add water, peas and spices and bring to a fast boil; then turn the heat slightly down and cook several minutes until vegetables are tender. Add farina by pouring it slowly with one hand and stirring with the other to avoid lumps. (The farina should be dry roasted beforehand.) Add the lemon juice and butter. Stir very firmly until upma is perfectly blended and not mushy—about 5 minutes. This is very tasty and easy to prepare.

HKC 5.34: WET CAULIFLOWER

WET CAULIFLOWER

4 med. cauliflowers
7 T. ghee
2 t. turmeric
1
1/2 T. salt
2 T. butter or ghee solids
1 t. crushed chilis
water to cover

Cut cauliflower in flowerettes. In large frying pan heat ghee and add crushed chilis. When chilis brown, add turmeric, stir, and add cauliflower. Saute cauliflower 5 or 10 minutes and add enough water to cook the cauliflower. Cover and salt. Cook covered, stirring occasionally until tender. Add butter. The juice is delicious poured over plain rice.

picture caption: When Kåñëa's cowherd friends came to beg food from some brähmaëas who were performing Vedic rituals, the brähmaëas refused them, but the wives of the brähmaëas, out of spontaneous affection, immediately went out into the forest to offer a nice feast to Kåñëa and His brother Balarama.

HKC 5.35: WET CAULIFLOWER AND POTATOES

WET CAULIFLOWER AND POTATOES (serves 6-8)

3 lb. potatoes, cut in 1 inch cubes
1 T. turmeric
3 T. ghee
2 small-med. cauliflowers, cut in small flowerettes
1 t. cumin seed
1 t. crushed chilis
1 T. salt
1/4 cup yoghurt
pinch asafoetida

Deep fry potatoes and cauliflower in deep fryer until tender, but still white. Keep putting fried vegetables in a separate large pot until all vegetables are done. In a separate pot, make massala (asafoetida, cumin seed, chilis and ghee). Fill the pot with water sufficient to cover the vegetables. Bring to a boil on a high flame, then add salt, turmeric and yoghurt. Add vegetables, bring to a boil and turn off flame.

Note: Split pea baras may be added to this vegetable preparation. The fried baras should be first soaked in salt water, then added to the cooked vegetables to soak up the juice. The baras do not have to soak in yoghurt for this preparation.

HKC 5.36: ZUCCHINI AND PEPPERS

ZUCCHINI AND PEPPERS

2 lb. zucchini
2 green peppers
massala
1/4 cup ghee
1/2 t. turmeric
1/4 t. salt

Fry washed and sliced zucchini and peppers in massala and ghee. Add salt and turmeric.

HKC 6: Savories

CHAPTER VI

SAVORIES

The preparation of savories shows the sophistication of prasädam cooking. The great spiritual masters in Kåñëa consciousness recommend that one should not be attached to material sense enjoyment, but one should accept everything enjoyable which is in relationship to Kåñëa. For example, eating is necessary, and we want some palatable dishes to satisfy our sense of taste. Therefore, for the satisfaction of Kåñëa rather than for the satisfaction of the tongue, some palatable dishes may be prepared and offered to Kåñëa. This is renunciation. Let the palatable dishes be prepared! However, unless they are offered to Kåñëa one should not eat them. This vow of rejecting anything which is not offered to Kåñëa is actually renunciation, but it is not dry and artificial renunciation, for by such Kåñëa conscious renunciation one is fully able to satisfy the demands of the senses.

For an impersonalist, the Lord, or the Absolute, being impersonal, cannot eat. Therefore an impersonalist artificially tries to avoid good eatables. But a devotee, knowing that Kåñëa is the supreme enjoyer and that He eats all that is offered to Him in devotion, offers good eatables to the Lord and then enjoys the prasädam remnants. The devotee takes prasädam in Kåñëa consciousness, whereas the nondevotee rejects it as material. The impersonalist, therefore, cannot enjoy life due to his artificial renunciation, whereas the devotee enjoys full bliss in relationship with Kåñëa.

HKC 6.1: CHUDY NOODLES

CHUDY NOODLES

1 cup chick-pea flour
1 t. cayenne pepper
1 t. turmeric
ghee for deep frying
1 t. salt

Mix together flour, spices and a few tablespoons hot water to make a firm dough. This should not be like a batter, but it should be wet enough to squeeze through a ricer. Knead the dough for 5 minutes, and meanwhile heat the ghee in a deep pot. When the ghee is almost smoking, place a nice amount of dough in the ricer, and squeeze it through into the ghee. In a minute the noodles will be done; they will have a brown color. Do not fry too long because they keep cooking when removed from the ghee. These are very crunchy and spicy and delicious. They are very nice with puffed rice, fried peanuts and golden raisins, all combined, or they can be mixed with hard dahl.

HKC 6.2: MUNG BEAN KACHORIS

MUNG BEAN KACHORIS

2 cups white flour
1 cup chick-pea flour
1 t. salt
2 cups chudy noodles
tamarind sauce
gram massala
1 t. cayenne pepper
1 cup yoghurt
peanut oil for deep frying
1/4 cup mung beans
4 medium potatoes

Make a soft dough with sufficient water using the white flour. Do not put any butter or ghee in the dough. Mix the chick-pea flour with the salt and cayenne, and dry roast the chick-pea flour in a pan until nicely browned. Mix the chick-pea flour with water to make a soft dough. Prepare chudy noodles using enough flour to yield 2 cups. If possible, use a ricer with small holes to make long, thin noodles. Set aside.

Now, with the white flour dough, make a ball about one inch in diameter. Push your finger into the ball to make a depression about 3/8 inch deep. Make a ball from the chick-pea flour dough a bit bigger than a pea. Place the chick-pea ball inside the depression in the white flour dough, and then pinch the white dough together, completely enclosing the chick-pea ball. Again roll the ball lightly in your hands so that it is evenly round. Now, very carefully roll a nice-sized puri from the ball. (Be very careful that nothing is stuck on the rolling pin or on the rolling surface to break the puri.)

Heat the peanut oil (oil is used for this preparation so that the puri will be very hard and crisp rather than tender) and fry the puris. Fry until they puff up. Then continue to fry until the puris are very hard and crispy.

Before you begin the frying process, boil the potatoes, peel them, and dice them in 1 inch cubes. Boil the mung beans until they are soft, but not mushy or broken. Set both aside. Prepare tamarind sauce and add 2 T. salt. Set aside. Begin frying the puris. When they are all done, in the center break a hole about 2" in diameter in the crispy, puffed-up puri, and drop a few pieces of boiled potato inside. On top of the potatoes, put some mung beans, then a big spoonful of yoghurt, on top of the yoghurt put some chudy noodles, and then sprinkle gram massala. Finally, put a generous amount of tamarind sauce on top of all the layers. Prepare all the kachoris in this way, and offer. This preparation is described as being so delicious that it appears that kachoris are from the upper planetary systems.

HKC 6.3: PAKORA

PAKORA

batter:

1 cup chick-pea flour
1 t. ground cumin seed
1 t. turmeric
1
1/2 t. ground coriander
1/2 t. each—allspice & cinnamon
3/4 t. salt
1/2 t. crushed chilis
3/4 t. baking powder
little less than 1 cup water
ghee for deep frying

Sift chick-pea flour. Add all spices, salt and baking powder. Mix with hands until blended. Add water a little at a time to avoid lumps. Heat ghee for deep frying.

plain pakora:

Pour a small amount (about 1 T.) into hot ghee. It will puff up and become similar to a ball. Turn over and brown. Tap with a spoon—if it sounds hollow it's done. Remove with a skimmer and drain on paper toweling. Fry several at a time.

filled pakora:

Filling: thin-sliced eggplant wedges or strips, small cauliflower flowerettes, green pepper strips, asparagus tips, parsley sprigs, thin rounds of zucchini or cucumber, carrot rounds or strips. Pieces should be no bigger than 2" long and they should be thin. Dip vegetables into batter and deep fry until golden. Remove and drain. The little fried batter drips can be removed and saved for salad or peas and peanuts.

HKC 6.4: POPPERS

POPPERS

Poppers are not prepared, but they are bought at Indian specialty stores. They are round, incredibly thin and crisp crackers. They come in a variety of brands and spice mixtures. The two best brands are Ambi's or Bedekar's. The three main flavors are: red chili (hot), black pepper (tasty but not hot), and plain.

The poppers should not be offered uncooked. They are fried in this way: heat ghee in a large frying pan. It isn't necessary to fill the pan; 1/3 full is plenty. When ghee is very hot, place a popper in the pan. In a matter of seconds it will expand sideways and become light in color. Immediately remove with tongs and stand sideways in a pot lined with paper toweling. Drain very well. These fry very quickly, so don't allow the popper to curl up. These are very delicious and delicate and go very well with rice and peas, or potato preparations. Before offering them, be sure that they are placed so as not to absorb any juices and become soggy. The poppers are prepared from different flours made from beans.

HKC 6.5: POTATO KACHORIS

POTATO KACHORIS

Filling 1:

2 medium potatoes
1/2 cup peas
1/2 t. turmeric
1 t. whole cumin seeds
1/2 t. crushed chilis
1" piece ginger root, cut in small pieces
pinch asafoetida
1/2 t. salt
1/4 t. each of cinnamon, cloves & nutmeg
1 t. ground coriander
5 T. ghee

Filling 11:

All ingredients the same but omit the peas, add 1/4 of one medium cauliflower cut in tiny pieces.

Dough:

1 1/4 cups white flour
ghee for frying
3/4 cup whole wheat flour
water
ghee solids or butter

Prepare dough as for puris, soft but not wet. Knead well, cover with dampened cloth and set aside. Cut potatoes in large chunks and boil until cooked but not very soft. Drain, peel and set aside.

Filling I: Heat ghee and add ginger. Fry until ginger browns, then remove ginger and add cumin seed. Brown and add asafoetida and chilis. Brown chilis and add all spices except salt. Heat spices thoroughly and add potatoes. Fry potatoes, mashing slightly as they cook, and then add peas and salt. Fry five minutes more and then mash thoroughly.

Filling II: Heat ghee and add ginger. When brown, remove and add cumin seed. When cumin seed is brown, add asafoetida and chilis. Brown and add cauliflower. Fry cauliflower until it is as soft as butter. Mash, then add potatoes. Fry as for 1, mashing and adding spices. Mix thoroughly and mash well when done.

To stuff: Pinch off 1" balls of dough and roll out to 21/2" circles. Place 1 t. or more of filling on one side and fold in half, making a half-circle shape. Using a tiny bit of water, seal very well. Fry in medium hot ghee until done. Kachoris fry about the same as samosa. Test by noting the golden brown color and a hollow sound when tapped.

HKC 6.6: PUFFED RICE (for 4-6)

PUFFED RICE (for 4-6)

8 cups puffed rice
1 cucumber peeled, cut in very thin slices
salt
black pepper
3/8 cup butter

Heat butter until melted. Soak cucumber in salted water for ten minutes. Then drain very well. When the butter is cool, pour over puffed rice and mix in well. Sprinkle salt and pepper and mix in with dry cucumbers. If it is too dry, add a little more melted butter.

HKC 6.7: RÄDHÄBALLABHA KACHORIS

RÄDHÄBALLABHA KACHORIS

ghee for deep frying
cayenne pepper
1 cup of cleaned, split urad dahl
asafoetida
2 cups white flour
salt
2 T. freshly ground anise seed
butter or ghee solids

Wash urad dahl thoroughly. Soak in water overnight. Drain, leaving a tiny bit of water. In a blender, grind urad dahl until it is a smooth paste, adding a little more water if necessary. The paste should be very thick. Set aside. Add anise seed to paste. Using white flour, butter or ghee solids and water, make a soft dough, like puri dough. (Not wet.) Let the dough sit for one hour under a dampened cloth. Meanwhile prepare three very small bowls in the following manner:

1. Put in a mixture of 1 T. water and 1/2 t. asafoetida.

2. Put plain salt in the second.

3. Put cayenne pepper in the third.

Pinch off balls of dough one inch in diameter. Roll them out into circles of 2 1/2" in diameter. Pinch off a ball of kachoré paste about one inch in diameter; dip into each of bowls in succession, and place in the center of the circle of kachoré dough. Gather up the dough around the paste as you would gather a paper bag. Make sure all the urad dahl is covered, and seal the top edge very well using a little water. Flatten the sealed kachoré with a rolling pin, and then roll gently as you would a puri or chapati.

Be very careful not to break the surfaces. If necessary, pat them out by hand. Deep-fry the kachoré in fairly hot ghee as you would a puri. Stand up kachoris on paper toweling to drain. Before offering them, refry very quickly, but do not brown.

This preparation is one of Çrémati Rädhäräëé's favorites and is always prepared for Her appearance day. There is nothing in the material world to compare with the flavor of Rädhäballabha Kachoris.

HKC 6.8: SAMOSA-30 flaky, delicious samosas

SAMOSA—30 flaky, delicious samosas

Filling:

1 small cauliflower
1/2 lb. peas
1/8 cup ghee
1/2 T. cumin seed
1/4 t. asafoetida
1/2 t. ground ginger
1/2 T. salt
1 t. cayenne pepper
1/4 t. allspice
1/4 t. cinnamon
1/4 T. ground cumin seed
1/2 T. ground coriander

Dough:

2 cups white flour
little over
1/2 cup warm water
4 T. ghee solids or ghee
ghee for deep-frying

Cut cauliflower in tiny pieces. Heat ghee and add cumin seed. When they brown, add asafoetida. Fry cauliflower in ghee and spices on medium flame until cauliflower is tender but not browned. Add peas and cook until peas are tender. Add salt and all other spices. Cook until vegetable is very soft and can be mashed easily and then continue until the paste is quite dry and a little dark in color.

Dough:

Cut ghee solids or butter into the white flour. Mix together with hands until it is the consistency of coarse corn meal. Slowly add warm water. Mix very well and then knead until dough is completely soft—about 10 minutes. Pinch off balls about an inch in diameter. Roll out in circles 3 1/2-4" in diameter. Cut in half. Place half circles across the left hand with rounded edge towards fingers. On straight edge put a thin line of water with finger. Pull top corner down, twisting over slightly until you have a cone. Press firmly on the seam to seal. Fill 2/3 of the cone with filling and then seal the top edge, first moistening the two sides with a little water. Pinch, twist and fold the sealed edge in successive folds to form a fluted top. Each samosa should have 10-12 little pressed-down folds. The final objective is to have a uniform triangular or fanshaped samosa. They must be well sealed so that they will not break open during the deep frying. Heat ghee for deep-frying. Fry samosas till golden and flaky. Test for doneness by tapping lightly with tongs or spoon. If it sounds hollow, it is done. This is the most delicious pastry ever made.

HKC 6.9: URAD DAHL KACHORIS

URAD DAHL KACHORIS

1/2 cup urad dahl
1
1/2 cups white flour or 1 cup white flour and 1/2 cup wheat flour
5-6 T. ghee solids or butter
water
1/2 t. salt
1 t. cayenne
1/4 t. asafoetida
ghee for deep-frying

Soak urad dahl for 5-6 hours. Drain, and crush the beans. Heat 2 T. ghee in a frying pan, and fry the urad dahl with salt, cayenne and asafoetida. Fry for 10 minutes, then add a little more ghee to make the filling smoother. Prepare a very soft dough from the flour and ghee solids or butter. Add a little water and when the dough is well-kneaded, make small balls, 1/2" in diameter, and stuff in the same way as potato kachoris. Roll out the kachoris like puris, using a rolling pin rubbed with ghee, and the rolling surface rubbed with ghee. The puri should be carefully rolled so as not to break, and should only be 11/2-21/2" in diameter. Heat the ghee for deep frying. Fry until they puff up, remove from the ghee and drain, and when they cool off, deep fry in ghee a second time. If you like you can wait until a few minutes before offering to re-fry. These are very similar to Rädhäballabha Kachoris.

HKC 7: Chutneys, Raitas & Curries

CHAPTER VII

CHUTNEYS, RAITAS & CURRIES

Chutneys and raitas are accompaniments or side dishes served with rice, vegetables, bread and savories. Generally, chutneys are made with fruits and are hot and sweet. Raitas usually consist of a vegetable prepared with yoghurt and salt; they are similar to salads and are simple to prepare.

With a little experience, it is easy to determine which chutney or raita will be most palatable with each offering. For instance, peach chutney is very tasty with cauliflower pakora, and cucumber raita goes well with steamed rice, plain cuddy and plain pakora. Tomato chutney is excellent with potato kachoris, Rädhäballabha kachoris, samosas, baras and so on. Raitas and chutneys should also be chosen for their colors and arranged very nicely on the offering plate.

As it is said, "Variety is the spice of life." The Supreme Personality of Godhead, being the reservoir of all bliss, cannot be impersonal. The idea of impersonal oneness is monotonous and dull, whereas the unlimited spiritual varieties which are present within Kåñëa are an eternal source of transcendental pleasure for His devotees.

Lord Caitanya Mahaprabhu has prescribed a very simple program by which anyone can easily make progress in the spiritual life of Kåñëa consciousness even in the present age of quarrel and hypocrisy. It is simply to hear about Kåñëa's philosophy and activities from authorized scriptures like Bhagavad-gétä As it Is and Çrémad-Bhägavatam, to chant the Hare Kåñëa mantra and dance in ecstasy, and, when one feels tired after chanting and dancing, to rest and enjoy sumptuous Kåñëa prasädam. When Lord Caitanya was propagating this saìkértana movement in the holy city of Jagannätha Puré, there were standing orders to the managers of the Jagannätha temple that Lord Caitanya's devotees should have as much prasädam as they wanted. Every evening there would be chanting and dancing with thousands of devotees, and then there would be profuse distribution of Kåñëa prasädam. Therefore this saìkértana movement of Lord Caitanya is simply transcendentally pleasing, and every living entity can take part in it and relish the essence of all bliss.

HKC 7.1: CHUTNEYS

CHUTNEYS

Apple Chutney

5 lbs. apples
1/2 cup water
1/4 cup butter
2 T. crushed chilis
1 t. nutmeg
1/4 t. cloves
1 t. turmeric
1 t. ginger
1 t. cinnamon
6 cups sugar

Wash, core and peel apples. Measure spices. Steam apples in water until done. Remove lid and cook off excess water. In a deep skillet heat butter and make massala. Add all other spices immediately. Stir; add apples and let cook on a high heat, cooking away excess liquid. Add the sugar until mixture becomes jam-like. Remove from heat. Serve cold to Kåñëa.

AVOCADO CHUTNEY

Mash 3 avocados to a pulp. Spice with lemon, chili powder, ginger, honey and salt.

BANANA CHUTNEY

12 bananas
1" piece tamarind
1/4 t. nutmeg
1/4 t. cinnamon
3/4 cup sugar
1/4 t. ground cumin
1/4 t. ground red pepper
1/4 t. ginger
1/4 t. black pepper

Soak tamarind overnight in a small amount of water. Push through a strainer into a large bowl and add all other ingredients. Mash, mix and serve cold.

BANANA SAMBAL

4 bananas
1 t. nutmeg
1/4 cup sugar
1/2 cup butter
juice of 2 limes

Sprinkle bananas with sugar, lime juice and nutmeg. Saute in butter until light brown. Serve as a side dish.

FIG AND DATE CHUTNEY

1 1/2 lbs. figs
3/4 lb. dates
1 T. turmeric
1
1/2 cups sugar
2 T. cumin seeds
6 T. ghee
5 crushed chili peppers
water

Grind or chop dates and figs very fine. Put ghee in a pan. Make massala and add other spices. Add fruit and stir. Add water to cover and boil for one hour. When cooked, add sugar. When mixture resembles a hot jam, remove from fire and cool. This can also be made with figs or dates alone.

GREEN TOMATO CHUTNEY

2 qts. green tomatoes
2 T. turmeric
1 cup green pepper, chopped
1 cup golden raisins
1 t. cumin seed
1/3 cup ghee
1 t. salt

Chop tomatoes into quarters. Fry green pepper in ghee with cumin seed. Add tomatoes. Cook on a medium heat. Then add turmeric and raisins. Do not overcook.

LEMON PICKLE

1 lb. fresh lemons, cleaned properly and dried very well
2 oz. gram massala
sugar (optional)
2 oz. salt

Prepare a jar large enough to hold the lemons. Wash it thoroughly and then dry it until there is no moisture left. With your hands and the knife perfectly dry, quarter the lemons, without cutting all the way through. Put a few teaspoonsful of massala, sugar, and salt mixture in the bottom of the jar, and also put the spice mixture inside the cut of the lemons. Place 2 layers of lemons in the jar, and then a layer of salt and spice mixture, alternating in this way until all the lemons are in the jar. Place a square of clean cloth on top of the jar, and then put a tight-fitting cover on. It will be ready in 3 months. After one week check and see if mold has formed on any of the lemons; if it has, remove the lemon with the mold and place the remaining lemons in the sun. Cover the lemons in the jar with salt and sugar completely. After a day in the sun, covered by salt and sugar, they will be all right. Re-cover the jar with a new cloth and seal tightly. When ready, small pieces may be offered with rice, vegetables and dahl preparations.

PINEAPPLE CHUTNEY

2 fresh pineapples, chopped small
1 t. cinnamon
1/4 t. cloves
1/2 cup butter, melted
1 T. nutmeg
cumin seed
1/2 t. ginger
red pepper
1 t. coriander
1/2 t. turmeric
2
1/2 cups brown sugar
1 cup golden raisins

Chop two fresh pineapples into small pieces. Melt butter, adding cumin seed and red pepper. Cook until brown. Toss in pineapple. Cook until pineapple reaches liquid consistency. Add remaining ingredients. Bring to a boil, then simmer for two hours, stirring occasionally until liquid cooks down to a mush.

PLUM CHUTNEY

2 qts. plums
3 cardamom pods
1 grated coconut
1
1/2 cups milk
2 t. coriander
2 cups sugar

Pit plums and cut into chunks. Put into a deep pan over medium heat. Add remaining ingredients and cook to a chunky puree. Cool and serve cold.

RAISIN CHUTNEY

3/4 lb. raisins
1 t. cumin seeds
2 chili peppers
sugar
ghee
water

Heat ghee. Make massala. Add raisins, stir, and add water. Cover and cook on high heat. When water is evaporated, add enough sugar to make jam-like consistency. Serve cold.

RHUBARB CHUTNEY

3 lbs. fresh rhubarb
water
1 T. salt
1 T. turmeric
basic massala

Trim rhubarb and cut into cubes. Make massala. Add rhubarb, stir, add salt, turmeric and stir. Cover with water and cook until water is evaporated. Serve cold.

ROSE PETAL PRESERVES

3 cups fresh rose petals
2 cups water
8 cups sugar
1 T. lemon juice

Wash rose petals in cold water. Drain, place in a pot and cover with 2 cups cold water; bring to a boil. Strain liquid into a second pot, setting aside petals for later use. Add sugar to liquid and boil into a thick syrup. Add lemon juice. Return petals to the syrup and cook for 20 minutes on a low flame. Pour into jars, seal tightly, but do not store in the refrigerator. Offer with PURIS or use in HALF MOONS.

TOMATO CHUTNEY

2 lbs. tomatoes
1/2 t. cumin seed
2 t. salt
2 T. ghee
1 t. crushed chilis
1 t. coriander

Cut tomatoes in eighths. Cook covered until tomatoes are liquid. Add salt and coriander while cooking. In a small pot heat ghee and add cumin seed. When it browns, add crushed chilis. Add ghee and spices to cooked tomatoes.

HKC 7.2: RAITAS

RAITAS

CUCUMBER RAITA I

1 large cucumber
1/2 t. salt
2 cups yoghurt
pinch of cayenne
1/2 t. cumin powder

Peel and thinly slice cucumber. Add yoghurt and spices. Gently toss. Chill.

CUCUMBER RAITA II

5 cucumbers
1 T. salt
1/2 t. black pepper
1/4 t. cayenne pepper
1
1/3 cups yoghurt

Cut off an inch slice from each end of the cucurnbers. On each end make ten tiny cuts in each direction. This is done by flipping the knife quickly. The cuts should be no more than 1/8" deep. Fit the cut ends back on to the cucumber and rub together vigorously. Do one end at a time. This process will completely remove the bitterness from the cucumber. Peel cucumbers. Cut in half lengthwise, and cut each half into quarters. Then slice strips crosswise. Mix the yoghurt, salt and spices together and add to cucumber bits. Very tangy and refreshing.

POTATO RAITA I

1 lb. potatoes
2 cups yoghurt
3/4 t. salt
1/2 t. gram massala
1/2 t. cayenne

Boil potatoes, peel and dice into 1" cubes. Beat the yoghurt and add the potatoes. Add salt. Sprinkle with gram massala and cayenne.

POTATO RAITA II

1/2 lb. potatoes
2 cups yoghurt
1
1/2 t. cumin seed, crushed, dry roasted
3/4 t. salt
cayenne (optional)

Prepare potatoes as in Raita 1, but blend the cumin seed with yoghurt. Add cayenne if you like.

picture caption: When Kåñëa ate lunch with His friends in the forest, Kåñëa appeared like the whorl of a lotus flower, and the boys surrounding Him appeared to be its different petals. These transcendental activities of the Lord are described by Çréla Prabhupäda in his book Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.

HKC 7.3: CURRIES

CURRIES

CUDDY (serves 6-8)

1 cup yoghurt
1/2 cup chick-pea flour
4 cups water
3/4 T. salt
1 t. turmeric
3 T. ghee
2 t. cumin seed
1 t. chili peppers

Mix yoghurt and chick-pea flour together in a deep pot. Add water, salt and turmeric. Bring to a boil, stirring occasionally, and boil until cuddy foams up to the top of the pot. Remove from the heat. In a small pot heat ghee and add cumin seeds. When they brown, add chili peppers. Add to the cuddy. The sauce can be served plain over white rice or, best of all, it can have plain PAKORAS added to it and be served over rice. Very quick and delicious.

MIXED VEGETABLE CURRY

1 cup green peas
1/4 t. asafoetida
1 cup diced carrots
2 t. whole cumin seed
1 cup diced potatoes
1 t. salt
2 cups fresh string beans cut in 1" pieces
2 t. turmeric
4 T. ghee
2 whole chilis or
1/2 t. crushed chili

Put all vegetables and salt in a pot with barely enough water to cover. Bring to a boil and simmer gently until vegetables are barely tender. Set aside after draining. In a large skillet heat the ghee and add the cumin seeds. Brown the seeds until they begin to smoke. Add chilis, then, after a few seconds add spices. Add vegetables and fry until dry.

POTATO CURRY

6 medium potatoes
3 T. ghee
1 t. whole cumin seed
1 t. turmeric
1 t. salt
2 cups water
1 t. ground coriander
1 t. cayenne pepper
1/2 cup yoghurt
1 small cucumber, peeled and chopped (optional)

Chop potatoes fairly small. Heat the ghee and add cumin seeds. When the seeds brown, add turmeric and cayenne. Cook spices 2 to 3 minutes and then add potatoes. Fry potatoes, stirring constantly for 10 minutes, then add the water and salt. Simmer slowly for 1/2 hour. Add the yoghurt and coriander. Cook another 10 minutes. Sprinkle with cucumber after it is on the serving dish. This is very nice to serve with plain steamed rice and CHEPURIS.

POTATO AND TOMATO CURRY

6 potatoes
1 t. whole cumin seed
3 tomatoes
1 t. salt
3 T. ghee
1 t. cayenne pepper
1 t. turmeric
1/2 cup yoghurt

Chop potatoes and tomatoes and keep separate. Heat ghee and add cumin seeds. Fry until brown, add turmeric and cayenne, heat spices 2 to 3 minutes. Add the vegetables and salt and fry on high flame for 5 minutes. Stir constantly. Barely cover vegetables with water and simmer about 20 minutes to 1/2 hour. Add yoghurt and cook 5 minutes more. Offer with plain steamed rice.

HKC 8: Sweets & Milk Sweets

CHAPTER VIII

SWEETS & MILK SWEETS

It is important that one should not only offer nice palatable food to Kåñëa and then accept the remnants of such an offering as Kåñëa's mercy or prasädam, but one should also distribute such prasädam to others. This is Kåñëa consciousness. Even if one does not accept all the principles of Kåñëa consciousness, if he simply eats Kåñëa prasädam he can gradually become fully qualified to become a devotee of Kåñëa. In this way even the most ignorant people—or even an ignorant animal—can get the benefit of Kåñëa consciousness. Sivananda Sen, a devotee of Lord Caitanya, once gave a little prasädam to a dog; thus the dog later met Lord Caitanya Himself and attained liberation.

Once, after a lecture, a disciple asked Çréla Prabhupäda what happens if a devotee gives someone a little morsel of prasädam, such as the "simply wonderfuls" described later in this section. Çréla Prabhupäda replied, "Then that is wonderful. Simply wonderful! He has not tasted such a wonderful sweet in his life. Therefore, you give him a simply wonderful, and because he is eating that wonderful sweet, one day he will come to your temple and become wonderful. Therefore it is simply wonderful. So go on distributing these simply wonderfuls." He thought for a moment, and then said, "Your philosophy is simply wonderful, the prasädam is simply wonderful, you are simply wonderful, and your Kåñëa is simply wonderful. The whole process is simply wonderful." The devotees responded, "Çréla Prabhupäda is simply wonderful!" It is said, yasya prasädäd bhagavat-prasädaù: "It is only by the mercy of the spiritual master that one can receive the mercy of Kåñëa."

HKC 8.1: BRAHMIN SPAGHETTI

BRAHMIN SPAGHETTI

1 lb. rice flour
water
sugar
ghee

Mix rice flour with water to make a stiff dough. Let dough stand long enough to sour (usually one day). Then squeeze dough through a potato ricer into smoking hot ghee. Deep fry until golden brown and drain off excess ghee. Soak in sweet nectar made of 4 cups sugar and 2 cups water.

HKC 8.2: BURFI

BURFI

3/4 cup butter
1
1/4 cups sugar
1 cup whole milk
3
1/2 cups powdered milk
1 cup chopped walnuts or almonds

Melt the butter. Add sugar and mix together. Add the whole milk, stir and bring to a boil on medium flame. Lower flame and add powdered milk, a little at a time. Keep stirring and add coconut and nuts. When all powdered milk is added, stir to get out all lumps. Use an electric beater if you have one. Lightly butter a rectangular or square cookie sheet. Pour burfi mixture onto the sheet and refrigerate. When it is cold and hard, remove it from sheet and cut into small diamonds. Place the diamonds on a plate. You can sprinkle finely chopped pistachios on top. For an added nice touch, mash a ripe banana and add it during the cooking.

HKC 8.3: COCONUT BURFI

COCONUT BURFI

1 cup ground fresh coconut
1
1/2 cups sugar
6 cups milk
1/2 t. ground nutmeg
ground seeds from 6 cardamoms

Grind the coconut with a special coconut grinder, or you can use a food grinder. Put the coconut and sugar in a pot, or deep frying pan, and cook for about 10 minutes, being careful not to let it burn. Then add the milk and cook it down for 1/2 hour or 45 minutes, until it is fairly thick. Add the nutmeg and cardamom seeds and roll into balls, or pour it onto a flat sheet and cut squares or diamonds when it is cool.

HKC 8.4: CELESTIAL BANANAS

CELESTIAL BANANAS

8 bananas
1/2 lb. homemade cream cheese
2 T. butter
4 T. brown sugar
cinnamon to taste
1 cup yoghurt
ghee for frying

Halve the peeled bananas lengthwise and brown lightly in ghee. Butter a pie plate and place 8 halves on the bottom. After creaming the sugar and cream cheese with cinnamon, spread half of the mixture on the 8 halves. Place remaining bananas on top and spread with butter and cheese mixture. Place yoghurt on top. Bake at 375 [F] degrees for 20 minutes.

HKC 8.5: PERA (Makes 6 pera)

PERA (Makes 6 pera)

10 oz. milk
4 t. powdered milk
4 t. granulated sugar
2 black cardamoms ground coarsely (green if black not available)
6 grated pistachios

Put whole milk in a small wok and place on a high flame. Prepare khoya (see basic preparations chapter). Let the khoya dry for a few minutes; then add the powdered milk and mix well. Thoroughly mix in sugar. Add the cardamom and mix again. Form balls by rolling between the palms. Do not make smooth round balls—make rough ones. Place pera in the palm of the left hand; with thumb of the right, pick up grated pistachios and press into the middle of the pera, making a depression. Do not offer the same day, but keep aside a day or two to harden. The cracks in the pera increase the wonderful flavor.

HKC 8.6: COCONUT SWEET BALLS

COCONUT SWEET BALLS

1 finely shredded coconut
3 cups sugar
pat of butter
pepper
pinch of ground camphor
salt

Add 3 cups sugar to coconut and fry in a heavy pan until the mixture thickens and sticks together. Add butter, camphor, salt and pepper. Cool slightly and shape into balls.

HKC 8.7: HALF MOONS

HALF MOONS

puri dough made from one cup of flour

for orange filling:

the juice of 4 oranges
2-3 T. corn starch
sugar

Cook orange juice in a pan, and when it cooks down a bit, add corn starch. When the orange filling is thickened to a jelly, add twice as much sugar to the filling. Cook 5 minutes. Cool.

for banana filling:

2 mashed bananas
1/2 cup dates, walnuts, or coconut

Add twice as much sugar to the mashed bananas and mix well.

for strawberry filling:

one pint box fresh strawberries (or any berry)
3 t. corn starch
sugar

Cook strawberries on a medium flame. When they are liquid, add corn starch and cook until they thicken. Add twice as much sugar to the filling. Cook 5 minutes, and then cool. ROSE PETAL JAM also makes a very nice filling.

Make 10-12 balls one inch in diameter. Roll them out to 4 inch diameter and very thin. Add approximately a teaspoon of filling (not too much or the pastry will break open during cooking) and then fold circle in half, pressing ends tightly together; moisten with water if necessary. With the tines of a fork, press all around the sealed ends on both sides.

On one side prick with fork to let steam escape while baking. Place on a greased baking sheet and bake 1/2 hour in a preheated 400 degree oven. Check every 10 minutes to see the progress. When one side is golden, turn all the half-moons over very gently, and bake another 10-15 minutes. When both sides are golden, remove from oven and sprinkle with confectioner's sugar. It is nice to offer these warm.

HKC 8.8: JALLEBI

JALLEBI

4 cups white flour
2 T. baking powder
2 cups sugar
1 t. rose water
pinch saffron
ghee for frying (deep)
1/4 cup yoghurt

Sift flour and baking powder together. Dissolve saffron in 2 t. warm water. Beat yoghurt until smooth. Add saffron and water, yoghurt, and enough water to make a thick batter of the flour. Leave for 1 hour. Make a thick syrup with sugar and 2 1/4 cups water. Boil until thick and add rose water. Keep sugar water warm. Heat the ghee in a frying pan and put some batter in a forcing bag. Pipe round swirls of batter into the ghee and fry on both sides until crisp. Drain the jallebis and put them in sugar water for about 3 minutes. Remove and put on serving plate.

HKC 8.9: JEEBE GAJA

JEEBE GAJA

1/2 cup flour
1/2 cup sugar
1/8 t. baking powder
1/4 cup water
ghee for deep frying
1 T. ghee

Make a soft dough from flour, baking powder, water and ghee. Make 16 balls. Roll thin and oblong. Prick with fork. Deep fry in ghee. Soak in sugar water solution.

HKC 8.10: LADDU

LADDU

1 cup unsalted butter
2 cups sifted chick-pea flour
2 cups sifted confectioner's sugar
1
1/3 cups dry shredded coconut
1/2 cup chopped walnuts or almonds (unsalted)

Melt butter in frying pan. Slowly add sifted chick-pea flour. Stir continually until chick-pea flour is roasted and turns a bit darker. Add coconut and stir a bit longer, then add sifted confectioner's sugar gradually and mix in thoroughly, crushing lumps with a spoon. Remove from heat and cool until it can be handled comfortably. Squeeze into round balls about 1" in diameter. A 1/4 t. cinnamon or nutmeg can be added for variation.

HKC 8.11: LUGLU

LUGLU

1 1/2 cups chick-pea flour
ghee for frying
water
1 t. cinnamon
1/4 t. nutmeg
1/4 t. ginger
dash cloves
2 cups sugar
1 cup water
3/4 cup chopped nuts (walnuts, almonds or pistachios)
1/2 cup golden raisins
1/4 cup chopped dates or figs

Make thin batter of chick-pea flour and water. Drop, shaking from a colander over hot ghee so small pearls of batter are fried until golden color. These form little crispy balls. Make a thick syrup of sugar and water and cook down until it begins to crystallize on sides of pan. Slightly cool. Add drained pearls, nuts & fruits and cover evenly in sugar syrup. Mix well. Cool until you can form into balls. Make walnut-sized balls. When cool they will stick together.

HKC 8.12: MALPOURI

MALPOURI

1 cup powdered sugar
1 cup white flour
water
ghee for frying
3 cups yoghurt (plain)
1 cup strawberries (opt.)

Make fairly thick batter from sugar and flour and enough water. Drop by tablespoonfuls into hot ghee. Remove when golden brown. Drain. Cover with yoghurt and strawberries. Serve immediately.

HKC 8.13: MANGO CREAM

MANGO CREAM

4 -5 ripe but firm mangoes
1/4 cup powdered sugar
1
1/2 cups whipped cream

Wash the mangoes and cut up into small pieces, but do not peel. Simmer in a small amount of water for 25 minutes or until tender. Press through a very fine sieve. Cool the pulp, fold into the whipped cream. Add the powdered sugar and gradually blend all together. Place into cups and chill.

HKC 8.14: MYSORE PAK

MYSORE PAK

1 cup chick-pea flour
2 cups butter
1
1/2 cups sugar
5 oz. water
chopped raw pistachio nuts

Sift chick-pea flour. Make sugar water with sugar and water, and boil about five minutes until sticky. Melt 1/2 cup of butter and add chick-pea flour, fry on medium flame and stir constantly. After 10 minutes, add the sugar water and keep stirring. Put remainder of butter into a small pot and bring to a simmer. Pour dribbles of butter into the chick-pea flour and continue stirring. Fry 10 minutes more and then pour onto a flat greased pan to harden. It hardens quickly, so cut into nice diamond shapes as soon as it is a little cool.

HKC 8.15: NAKALDANA

NAKALDANA

2 cups sugar
1
1/2 cups raw peanuts
1 cup water
ghee for frying

Boil sugar and water until sticky. Test with fingers, taking a small bit off stirring spoon. It will feel a little hard. Then roll together in a small, slightly, hard ball. Remove sugar solution from heat. Fry some peanuts in ghee slowly for about 15 minutes until done. Then put them in a large flat pan. Add sugar solution spoon by spoon and stir into peanuts. Peanuts turn whitish and are like candy-coated peanuts.

HKC 8.16: COCONUT NAKALDANA

COCONUT NAKALDANA

2 cups coconut or 1 grated fresh coconut
1
1/2 T. ghee
1/2 cup water
1 cup sugar

In a frying pan heat the ghee. Add coconut and fry over a medium flame stirring constantly until coconut turns a light golden brown. Remove from heat. In a small heavy pot, mix together sugar and water. Keep boiling until a thick syrup is formed. Test by putting a drop of syrup in cold water—it should form a semi-hard ball. Pour the syrup over the coconut and stir very rapidly. The sugar will crystallize and you will have a dusty, sandy, sweet coconut.

HKC 8.17: PEANUTS AND RAISINS

PEANUTS AND RAISINS

Grind peanuts which have been cooked in ghee as usual. Also grind raisins (an equal amount). Add sugar syrup (2 sugar/1 water) and cook all together until thick and can be rolled. Roll into nice balls. Raw cashews or almonds may be substituted.

HKC 8.18: SIMPLY WONDERFULS

SIMPLY WONDERFULS (a great favorite) (Makes 3 dozen)

2 cups powdered milk
1 cup unsalted butter
1
3/4 cups confectioner's sugar
1/2 cup chopped unsalted nuts, or coconut or raisins

Melt butter in a saucepan. Remove from heat and cool slightly. Add confectioner's sugar and stir until it becomes a creamy consistency. Add powdered milk gradually and mix continually. Try squeezing a small amount into a 1" ball. If it is too wet, add a little more powdered milk. If it is too dry, add a little more melted butter. Roll into balls 1" in diameter.

HKC 8.19: SWEET POTATO BALLS

SWEET POTATO BALLS

4 med. sweet potatoes
2 cups sugar
a little flour
1 cup water
1/2 t. nutmeg
ghee for frying

Wash and peel potatoes. Boil in water until tender. Mash, add spices and flour. Knead. Make a syrup of sugar and water and let boil for 5 minutes. Pinch off olive-sized balls and fry in medium hot ghee until brown and firm. Remove and drain. Soak in hot syrup.

Variation: Roll dough into cylinders and proceed as above.

HKC 8.20: SWEET POTATO CRISP

SWEET POTATO CRISP

12 sweet potatoes
3/4 cup butter
1/4 cup flour
1/2 cup brown sugar
1
1/2 t. ground black pepper
1/2 cup heavy cream
1/4 cup finely ground nuts

Cook potatoes. Peel and slice 1/2" thick. Spread on buttered large, shallow baking dish. Sprinkle with butter, flour and all other ingredients. Broil until bubbly and caramelized.

HKC 8.21: WATERMELON SHERBERT

WATERMELON SHERBERT

6 cups pitted watermelon pulp
2
1/2 cups sugar
juice of
1/2 lemon
2 cups whipping cream

Mash watermelon well and add lemon juice and sugar. Pour into a large bowl and place in freezer. Let it thaw about 1/2 hour before offering. Pour cream over sherbert and let it be nicely absorbed. Very cooling and refreshing for Kåñëa on hot days.

HKC 8.22: ALMOND HALAVAH

ALMOND HALAVAH

8 oz. almonds, blanched
1
1/2 cups sugar
1 cup water
1/2 cup butter
2 T. flour

Pound or blend almonds to a powder. Melt butter and mix in almonds and flour. Cook well. Make a thick sugar-water syrup, adding it to the almond mixture. Stir and cook until it thickens and leaves the sides of the pan. Pour into buttered dish and cut into squares when cold.

HKC 8.23: CARROT HALAVAH

CARROT HALAVAH

2 bunches of carrots
1 cup sweet butter
3-4 cups sugar
crushed seeds of 5 cardamom pods

Wash and grate carrots. Put 1/2 cup butter in frying pan and add carrots. Cook slowly until soft (takes about 40 minutes). When soft, add remaining butter and sugar. Cook for 10-15 minutes until thick, jamlike consistency is obtained. Sprinkle with cardamom.

HKC 8.24: FARINA HALAVAH

FARINA HALAVAH

1 cup farina
1/2 cup butter
1
1/2 cups water
1 cup sugar
handful golden raisins

Mix water and sugar and bring to a boil. Melt butter in a pan. Toss in grain and raisins, stirring constantly at a low heat for 20-25 minutes until golden in color. Then add grain by single spoonfuls to water and sugar, which should be simmering. When all grain is added, keep on fire for 2 or 3 minutes, stirring continuously. Remove and serve hot.

HKC 8.25: BANANA HALAVAH (Kela Halavah)

BANANA HALAVAH
(Kela Halavah)

6 bananas (ripe)
4 T. butter
1
1/2 cups water
1 t. rose water
1
1/4 t. cardamom seeds (peeled)
2 T. blanched almonds
saffron

Melt butter in a heavy skillet. Peel and cut bananas into 1" pieces. Fry in butter 5-7 minutes on medium heat. Stir often and mash after they have fried for 5 minutes. Add 1/2 cup water. Simmer with care on low heat for 3 minutes, stirring constantly. Stir the sugar into the remaining 1 cup water and add to the bananas. Boil gently 15 minutes. Stir often to prevent scorching, and also to thicken mixture. Add rose water, remove, and pour into a shallow dish. Bruise the cardamom seeds and sprinkle on halavah. Sliver the almonds, and sprinkle enough saffron to color the halavah golden. Offer hot or cold.

HKC 8.26: CARAMEL

CARAMEL

1 can sweetened condensed milk

In a deep pot, bring enough water to boil as will completely cover the can of condensed milk. When the water is at a rolling boil, place the unopened can in the water. Boil constantly for 2 to 2 1/2 hours. Remove the can from the water and refrigerate. When the can is cold it can be opened and the caramel offered to the Deities. Any chopped unsalted nuts or coconut can be added.

HKC 8.27: CARROTS IN MILK

CARROTS IN MILK (Gajja Kheer)

1/2—3/4 lb. carrots
1/8 lb. ground almonds
5 cups rich milk
1/2 t. ground cardamom seeds
3/4 cup sugar
pinch of saffron threads

Wash and grate the carrots finely. Bring the milk to a boil and add the grated carrots. Cook until the carrots are soft and the mixture has thickened (35-40 min.). Stir occasionally with wooden spoon. Add sugar, almonds, cardamom and saffron. When sugar is completely dissolved and mixed in, remove from fire. It may be offered warm or cold.

HKC 8.28: CHANDRA MURTI

CHANDRA MURTI

1 qt. milk
3 cups sugar
1 cup water

Make PANIR (curd). Make sweet nectar very thick. Roll balls smaller than marbles and cook in nectar until crunchy.

HKC 8.29: FIRNI

FIRNI

2 oz. rice flour
2
1/4 cups rich milk
1/2 cup sugar
1 t. rosewater or ground cardamon seeds from 2 cardamoms
10 chopped blanched almonds
10 shelled, chopped pistachio nuts, unsalted

Mix the rice flour in a little cold milk and water to avoid lumping during cooking. Bring the milk to a boil, then remove it from the heat and mix in the flour mixture. Cook over low heat until thick, then add the sugar and cook until a little thicker. Add the rose water or cardamom and pour it into a bowl. Sprinkle the nuts over top. Refrigerate and offer cold.

HKC 8.30: HASPIA

HASPIA

2 cups fresh milk
2 t. cornstarch
4 cups grated coconut
2 T. sugar

Heat milk until scalding. Pour over coconut and let steep for 1/2 hour. Pour through cloth and squeeze all possible liquid from coconut into a bowl of liquid. Mix cornstarch with liquid. Add sugar. Heat again to just under boiling point. Stir constantly until smooth. Pour into a shallow pan. Let set until firm. Slice in 2" squares. Serve cold.

HKC 8.31: KHEER

KHEER (Serves 4-6)

1/4 cup long grain white rice
1/2 cup water
2 cups half milk and half cream
1 cup milk
almost
1/2 cup sugar
10 whole cardamom pods

Soak rice in water for 4-5 hours. When ready to prepare, bring milk and cream to a boil. Be very careful not to burn. (For this preparation a wooden spoon is necessary.) While milk is boiling, add rice and water and cardamom pods. Bring to a boil again and then lower heat. Stir constantly after about 15 minutes of cooking. It will thicken and rice will dissolve into milk. The color will be pale peach. At this point, add sugar and mix until it melts into pudding. Put the kheer in refrigerator and chill. Remove cardamom before it becomes cold.

HKC 8.32: KHOYA BOATS

KHOYA BOATS

2 cups rich milk
3 rounded handfuls sugar
shelled unsalted pistachio nuts

Cook milk over high flame with wooden spoon. Stir vigorously so that it doesn't stick. Remove from heat when milk dries up and becomes one slightly hardened lump. Continue stirring until sizzling stops. It takes about 25 minutes to prepare one pint of milk in this way. (One pint of milk produces about 3 oz. of khoya). Then add the sugar and mix well. Take small lumps of khoya and press in your palm, closing your hand. With the thumb of the other hand, make a depression in the center. Press a pistachio nut into depression. The finished shape and size is like a small boat.

HKC 8.33: KULFI

KULFI

2 qts. rich milk or 2 gts. regular milk with half pt. of cream
3/4 cup sugar
1 t. rosewater
1 cup frozen raspberries, blackberries or strawberries, thawed

Cook milk until it is the consistency of thick cream, stirring almost constantly with wooden spoon, (about 25 min.). When milk is like thick cream or thin yoghurt, add sugar, rose water and berries. Mix well and place in freezer. Remove from freezer ten minutes before offering.

HKC 8.34: RASAGULLA

RASAGULLA

curd from 1/2 gal. of milk
3 cups water
2
1/4 cups sugar

Let curd hang 4-5 hours. Remove from muslin and knead on smooth surface until curd is smooth and oily. Pinch off bits of curd and roll into balls about 1/4" in diameter. Bring water and sugar to a boil and then simmer. Remove 1/3 of this sugar syrup and put it in another pot off the heat. Place several balls in the simmering syrup and cook about 20 minutes until they are slightly cracked and swollen. Remove carefully with slotted spoon and place in cooled syrup. Continue until all rasagulla are done. Serve cool. These are very subtle and delicate sweets.

HKC 8.35: BENGALI RASAGULLA

BENGALI RASAGULLA

curd from 1 gallon of milk
1/8 cup farina
1 small pkg. rock candy (white)
sweet nectar (1 part sugar
—4 parts water)

Knead the curd with the farina. The farina will prevent the curd from falling apart. Roll balls of curd 1" in diameter. In the same way that cardamoms are inserted in rasaballi, insert a piece of rock candy about 1/4" long in the rasagulla. Reshape the ball firmly, to prevent falling apart. Prepare the sweet nectar, and bring to a boil. Add the rasagullas and cook on a fairly rapid simmer for about 20 minutes. If you cook them in batches, then remove some sweet nectar to soak the cooked ones in. As you cook the rasagullas, the rock candy will melt from the heat and cause the sweet juice to rush into the ball to fill up the empty space, thus causing the rasagulla to rise up. After all the rasagullas are cooked, soak them in the sweet juice 5 hours before offering.

HKC 8.36: RASABALLI

RASABALLI

curd
seeds from cardamom pods
sugar water in the following proportion: 3 sugar to 4 water (use a suffcient mixture of water both to boil and then to soak)

Knead the curd until creamy, and then roll rasaballis into balls of one inch diameter. With the small finger, make a depression in the balls 1/3 of the thickness of the rasaballi. Put in one seed from a cardamom pod and 1/4 t. sugar. Pinch together and re-roll the ball. When all are filled and rolled in this way, put them in simmering sugar water and simmer on medium heat for 1/2 hour. The balls should be stirred and the sugar water should be almost boiling. These may be done in batches like rasagulla, with some sugar-water taken out for soaking. After boiling, the rasaballis should be left to soak in the sugar water for 3 days, and stirred once or twice a day.

HKC 8.37: SANDESH

SANDESH

curd from 1/2 gallon of milk
1 t. rose water (opt.)
1/4 cups sugar (not more than 1 part sugar to 4 parts curd)

Let curd hang 4-5 hours. Remove curd from muslin and knead on a smooth surface until curd is smooth and oily. Mix curd and sugar and rosewater together in a small pot and place on a very low heat. Be very careful not to burn it. Stir constantly until curd begins to pull away from the pan and is not so sticky. Remove and knead again. Roll into balls.

HKC 8.38: SOMETHING ELSE

SOMETHING ELSE

1 cup rice
4 cups milk
2 T. butter
1 cup sugar
grated lemon rind
nuts
1/4 t. cinnamon
dash nutmeg

Soak rice in 2 cups milk for 2 hours. Add other 2 cups milk. Cook on low heat in thick pot until rice is tender. Set aside to cool. Preheat oven to 350 [F]. Butter a 2 quart casserole. Work butter with sugar. Add to rice with rind, spices, nuts, etc. Pour into casserole. Bake for 45 minutes. Serve warm or cold, plain or with chilled whipped cream.

HKC 8.39: SWEETBALLS

SWEETBALLS

fresh ghee for deep frying
2 cups water
1/2 cup whole milk
2 cups sugar
4 cups powdered milk

Make sweet nectar by mixing sugar and water until it is clear. In a mixing bowl put whole milk and add powdered milk a little at a time. Beat with a fork until all milk is added and you have a stiff dough. Rub a little ghee onto a smooth surfaced table and on your hands. Knead the dough for a few minutes, quickly, and then pinch off bits and roll into balls 1/2" in diameter. Make the balls very quickly because the dough tends to dry up. (It will be easiest if you do this in 2 or 3 batches by dividing the milk measurements in half or thirds.) Heat the ghee in a large frying pan that keeps its heat well—cast iron is very good for this preparation. Deep fry the sweetballs very slowly on low heat until they are golden brown. Keep stirring gently. They will swell up during the cooking. When they are done, remove them with a slotted spoon and place them in the sweet nectar. Soak them for 1-2 days, stirring gently 3 or 4 times a day. This is the devotees' most favorite sweet.

HKC 8.40: SWEET RICE I

SWEET RICE I

4 cups fresh milk
1/4 cup rice
pinch camphor
3/4 cup sugar
pinch of black pepper

Cook rice in milk, stirring constantly until the mixture is thick like pudding. This will take about 1 hour. Add sugar, and two grains of camphor and a pinch of black pepper.

HKC 8.41: SWEET RICE II

SWEET RICE II

2 cups rice
4 cups milk
2 bananas, ripe or
1/2 fresh chopped pineapple
2 cups whipped cream
sugar to taste (
1/2 cup)

Cook the rice as usual. Let stand to cool for 3-4 hours. Then add whipped cream, finely chopped bananas or pineapple, and sugar. Stir well and serve cold.

HKC 8.42: SWEET RICE III

SWEET RICE III

1/4 cup white or Basmati rice
1
1/2 cup sugar
1/2 gallon milk
15 whole cardamom pods (opt)

Cook all the rice with 1 cup of milk for about 20 minutes until soft. Then add the cardamom pods. Gradually, over a period of 2 hours, add the remaining amount of milk, stirring occasionally with a wooden spoon. The sweet rice should be thin, and the consistency like fresh cream: the color should be whitish. Before you remove the sweet rice from the fire, add the sugar and stir until the sugar is completely absorbed. If cardamom is used, remove them before the sweet rice cools. Place the sweet rice in the refrigerator and offer when very cold. If you have the time, you can cook the sweet rice all day, adding more and more milk. Do not cook the sweet rice in an aluminum pot.

HKC 9: Beverages

CHAPTER IX

BEVERAGES

There are many nice beverages to offer to Kåñëa, including fruit and vegetable juices of all varieties, and in the summer, combinations of different fruit juices can be frozen. The most simple beverage, however, which is available everywhere in the world, is water. In Bhagavad-gétä Lord Kåñëa requests that water be offered to Him in love, and elsewhere in the Gétä He declares, "I am the taste in water." Water is universally appreciated for its pure taste, and that taste is Lord Kåñëa Himself. Without water we cannot live, and so a Kåñëa conscious devotee glorifies Lord Kåñëa for kindly supplying water to quench man's thirst.

Milk, praised both by modern nutritionists and the eternal Vedas as the "miracle food," is the single most important item in the Vedic diet, for it contains all the vitamins necessary to sustain the human body in good health. Even more importantly, the proteins, fats and vitamins found in milk are perfectly balanced for the development of the finer tissues of the brain, and thus milk is the perfect food for one who is seeking advancement in spiritual life. By Kåñëa's arrangement, the cow eats ordinary grass and transforms it into a delicious drink which is rich in all the food values necessary for good health and spiritual progress. When Lord Kåñëa appeared on earth He displayed His childhood pastimes as a cowherd boy, and He is worshiped for His childhood activities as a naughty butter thief. Thus He emphasized in many ways the importance of cows and milk products for human society. Lord Kåñëa is also celebrated as "Govinda" because He appeared as the reservoir of pleasure for the cows as well as all living beings. Devotees of Lord Kåñëa therefore acknowledge the kindness of the Lord by offering Him milk, and they feel great satisfaction in drinking milk prasädam and thinking about the transcendental pastimes of the Lord.

HKC 9.1: MILK

MILK

1 qt. milk (for 4 people)
1/4 -1/3 cup sugar

Bring milk to a boil three times (as it foams up, turn down, then turn flame up, then down, and then up). Add sugar. Simmer milk about 3 minutes, and stir sugar in well using a wooden spoon. A whole cardamom or a drop of rosewater may be placed in the milk and cardamom removed when milk is done. Honey may be substituted for sugar, using about 1/3 cup per quart. Milk can be offered with a ripe banana or some figs, or dates. Milk should be poured from one cup to another. This cools the milk and also makes it more flavorful.

HKC 9.2: BANANA NECTAR

BANANA NECTAR

1 qt. milk
1 large ripe banana
1/3 cup sugar
2 T. butter
1 whole cardamom
pinch cinnamon
pinch nutmeg
pinch ground coriander

Bring the milk and all the spices to a boil, and crush the banana with your hands. Add the crushed banana and the sugar. Let the milk boil three times and turn flame down to a simmer. Add the butter and allow it to melt. Cool by pouring the milk back and forth from one cup to another.

HKC 9.3: MASSALA MILK

MASSALA MILK

2 cups milk
2 T. sugar
10-12 ground pistachios (peeled)
6 ground almonds (blanched)
pinch crumbled saffron
crushed seeds of two cardamom pods
1/4 t. ground nutmeg

Bring milk to a boil three times and then lower heat and add all spices, nuts and sugar. Stir and cook for five minutes.

HKC 9.4: DAHI

DAHI

equal parts yoghurt and fruit juice
sugar

Mix the yoghurt and the fruit juice and add sugar in this proportion—1/3 cup sugar to 2 cups dahi. This is a wonderful chilled drink during the summertime for Their Lordships Çré Çré Rädhä-Kåñëa.

HKC 9.5: LASSI

LASSI

3 parts yoghurt to 1 part water
dry roasted cumin seed or sugar
black pepper
salt

Mix the yoghurt and water. For each 4 cups of yoghurt and water add 1/2 t. salt, 1/4 t. black pepper and 1 t. roasted cumin seed. Mix well. Lassi can also be prepared by mixing yoghurt and water and adding 1/3 cup sugar for each 2 cups lassi. This is another delicious summer beverage.

Kåñëa prasadam is but one aspect of the most authorized, scientific and joyful movement of spiritual culture in the world—Kåñëa consciousness. By chanting Hare Kåñëa, dancing in ecstacy, eating Kåñëa prasädam and reading books of transcendental knowledge such as Bhagavad-gétä As It Is, one can easily revive his dormant loving relationship with Kåñëa, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and thus attain the perfection of life in eternity, knowledge, and bliss. His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, the spiritual master of the Hare Kåñëa movement, has given us many important books and established temples all over the world to help us understand this science. This Kåñëa consciousness movement is the greatest benediction for all living beings. It is yours for the taking.

Hare Kåñëa, Hare Kåñëa, Kåñëa Kåñëa, Hare Hare
Hare Räma, Hare Räma, Räma Räma, Hare Hare

HKC: Invitation

INVITATION

On behalf of our spiritual master, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda, we invite you to partake of a sumptuous feast of Kåñëa prasadam every Sunday at any of the Hare Kåñëa temples listed on the opposite page. The Sunday festival and love feast usually begins around four p.m. Please come and enjoy a whole feast of transcendental food and advance wonderfully in spiritual life. The devotees will be more than pleased to show you how to offer all your food to Kåñëa, so that your eating may always be simply wonderful and your advancement on the path back home, back to Godhead, will be sure.

Hare Kåñëa.

....................................................................

BOOKS

by His Divine Grace A.C. BHAKTIVEDANTA SWAMI PRABHUPÄDA

BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS
ÇRÉMAD-BHÄGAVATAM, CANTOS 1-3 (6 VOLS.)
TEACHINGS OF LORD CHAITANYA
THE NECTAR OF DEVOTION
EASY JOURNEY TO OTHER PLANETS
KÅÑËA CONSCIOUSNESS: The Topmost Yoga System
KÅÑËA, THE SUPREME PERSONALITY OF GODHEAD (2 Vols.)
TRANSCENDENTAL TEACHINGS OF PRAHLÄD MAHÄRÄJ
TRANSCENDENTAL TEACHINGS OF CAITANYA MAHÄPRABHU
KÅÑËA THE RESERVOIR OF PLEASURE
THE PERFECTION OF YOGA
BEYOND BIRTH AND DEATH
ON THE WAY TO KÅÑËA
ELEVATION TO KÅÑËA CONSCIOUSNESS
RÄJA-VIDYÄ: The King Of Knowledge
BACK TO GODHEAD MAGAZINE (Founder)

A complete catalogue of books and cassette tape recordings by His Divine Grace is available from

ISKCON BOOKS, 3959 Landmark Street, Culver City, California 90230

....................................................................

"This knowledge is the king of education, the most secret of all secrets. It is the purest knowledge, and because it gives direct perception of the self by realization, it is the perfection of religion. It is everlasting, and it is joyfully performed."

Bhagavad-gétä 9.2


BHAGAVAD-GÉTÄ AS IT IS
His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupäda

Available from

ISKCON BOOKS 3959 Landmark Street, Culver City, California 90230

Softcover $4.95 Hardcover $10.95